Westminster Hall

3 November 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:03 - 00:09
Speaker 2
Order.  Order. Josh Newbury to move the motion. 
00:09 - 01:55
Speaker 1
Thank you very much, Ms. Jardine.  It's a pleasure to open this afternoon's debate with you in the chair.  As we all know, the great British weather is something that we love to talk about, but it isn't particularly predictable, and it's becoming more and more extreme as a result of climate change.  Although I was motivated to apply for this debate by the impact of this summer's heatwave on train services in my constituency, I suspect that honourable members will have come to this debate with a huge range of weathers in mind, and I'm sure will be hearing something akin to the 10 Plagues of Egypt this afternoon, reflecting the diversity of our great nation.  And I suspect that for many passengers on the Chase Line, the turning of the seasons into the warmer months now brings a familiar question: will the train make it to Rugeley? 

That's not quite the seasonal tradition people have in mind.  We might have hoped for a little sunshine, a trip away, or an afternoon in the garden, but we now will probably have to check whether or not we can get a train home.  Passengers along the Chase Line know the problem well.  As temperatures rise, delays and cancellations become more frequent.  Services are canceled at short notice, journeys are cut short, and the trains that do run are often overcrowded. 

And when they do run, services are often halted at Hednesford, with the dreaded rail replacement bus completing the journey to Rugeley Town and Rugeley Trent Valley stations.  My constituent, Allan, who heads the Chase Line Rail Promotion Group, rightly asked me to tell the House that for many months this year, trains were not reaching Rugeley for much of the day.  At best, services were cut from half-hourly to hourly, and passengers often didn't even know where to catch the bus.  As honourable members will have heard from their constituents, missing a train is not just an inconvenience, as the Tannoy often says.  It can mean missing an appointment, arriving late for work, or having even to lean on friends and family just to get home after a long day. 

I wanted to make sure—  Yes, I will give way. 
01:55 - 01:56
Jonathan Towler. 
01:56 - 02:19
Speaker 4
many ways for starting this debate. So helpful.  Does the honourable member agree with me that during July heat wave the service between East Midland railway service between Leicester and Nottingham ran directly and didn't stop in between because the on the turn out it said it was simply too hot.  Therefore, the people, students, businesses can not revolve around the service that work that way. 
02:19 - 03:49
Speaker 1
Well, I thank the honourable gentleman for raising that point.  Having grown up myself in Leicestershire, I'm familiar with the line that he's talked about, and I think there we have another example of how hot weather can affect train journeys.  I'll describe in extraneous detail how it affects my constituency, but he is very right to raise how it's affecting his constituents, and for those who need to stop off on that line, perhaps somewhere like Loughborough, they're massively impacted by that, and that can really impact people's lives in a way that only they know, but I think we should raise in this House, so he's right to do so.  And I wanted to make sure, Ms. Jardine, that my constituents' experiences were heard directly in this debate, so my office ran a survey of people who use the Chase Line regularly.  And the responses covered all sorts of journeys: people going to work, students getting to college, and families trying to get their children where they need to be. 

I wanted to share a few of them today.  Rosie told us that her regular 8:00 a.m. journey from Hednesford to Walsall for college.  She said that delays and cancellations have meant arriving late and missing lessons.  Replacement buses make any journey much longer, and on some occasions, she's had to spend around £22 on an Uber just to get there on time. 

She told us that she sometimes only found out about cancellations after buying her ticket and then struggled to get a refund.  Another respondent told us about their son travelling to college in Stafford.  There's no direct bus from where they live, so the train is the only practical way for him to get there.  Both parents work, so they can't drop everything to drive him in when the train is cancelled.  Emma also raised the importance of the Hednesford to Rugeley Trent Valley connection for children who travel on to Stafford. 

03:49 - 06:20

Josh Newbury

There's no direct bus alternative for that journey either. Without the train, how are those students supposed to get to college? Where What do those aborted journeys mean for their futures? The impact on people travelling to work is just as clear. Jack commutes from Cannock or Hednesford to Birmingham New Street.

He described repeated delays and serious overcrowding, particularly at peak times. During hot weather, he told me two loads of passengers or two trainloads of passengers were often squeezed onto one service. He wants to see more frequent services during the morning and evening peaks, a fair request, I think. Angela told us about travelling from Rugeley to work at Birmingham's Queen Elizabeth Hospital. She uses the train to avoid the difficulty of parking, but reliability has meant train journeys are increasingly difficult.

On one occasion, her outward journey was cancelled, so she had to drive to another station. On her return, she found that she couldn't get back to Rugeley, where her car was parked. Lewis, who commutes from Rugeley to Birmingham, too, has recently secured a major career opportunity after years of study and hard work, but constant delays and cancellation make it difficult to know whether he will get to work, and just as importantly, get home. His commute costs him around £100 a month. We know how difficult it is at the moment for young people to get a foothold in their chosen career.

Lewis should be able to concentrate on making the most of his opportunities rather than worrying about whether the train will get him there. His role is hybrid, which helps, but not everybody has got that flexibility. Chris told us that after repeatedly being stranded at work, they stopped going to the station altogether. On some occasions, they had to travel via Wolverhampton and arrange a lift or find another bus because no replacement transport was even provided. Susan described a similar problem on her journey from Rugeley towards Birmingham.

Her return service terminated at Hednesford, and with no replacement bus, she had to pay herself for a separate bus outside Tesco just to get her home. Lee described repeated summer cancellations and the explanations that he's been given about infrastructure and signalling. He said that the stretch between Hednesford and Rugeley must have a world-unique microclimate, it's so consistently affected. I'm not sure we can significantly or scientifically back that one up, but as a Chase Line passenger myself, I'm very much with him in that frustration. The survey we ran also shows how much this uncertainty can affect people's working lives.

I've heard from constituents who've suffered migraines from the stress of their commute, and others who've had to take annual leave because of cancellations. I don't think anybody expects a railway to run completely without disruptions. There will always be incidents and occasions when services have got to change. Safety must come first, after all. But passengers are entitled to ask why hot weather keeps causing such serious problems and what's being done to address them.

06:20 - 06:21

Will the honourable member give way?

06:21 - 06:23

Speaker 3

Absolutely happy to give way.

06:23 - 06:53

Speaker 13

I want to thank the honourable member for introducing this debate and giving way. Like him, I've surveyed my commuting constituents and, as a result of that, I regularly complain about the unreliability of South Western Railway. They're particularly unreliable whenever there is hot and cold weather. Does he agree with me that the Government, and hopefully we'll hear from the Minister later today, an investment plan to improve our railway network so it can adapt to climate change, including introducing air conditioning on all train services?

06:53 - 08:13

Josh Newbury

Well, my shoddy he is he's absolutely right to raise this issue, particularly of how extremes of temperature are increasingly affecting our railway. We know in many cases our lines were not designed to run at temperatures, you know, well into the high 30s or even below -10, but, increasingly, those are the conditions that they're having to endure. And we know those conditions are not going to get any easier. We're not going to have milder winters suddenly coming back. So, we absolutely, as he says, need to make sure that the services in and out of the train are resilient to that reality.

And he leads me perfectly onto my point that we know that high temperatures affect the railway. Rails expand in the heat, signalling equipment can overheat and overhead lines can also be affected.

Network Rail already takes steps to manage those risks, including track inspections, painting rails white to reduce heat absorption and monitoring infrastructure during hot weather. And I recognize the hard work that railway staff do to keep services safe in difficult conditions, and I sincerely thank all of the staff that do that. But I want to know what more can be done to make the Chase Line more resilient. We shouldn't be having to have the same conversations every summer. We all know that hotter and hotter weather will be coming.

Passengers need to know that lessons are being learned and that the work is happening before the next heat wave. Absolutely happy to give way.

08:13 - 08:53

Charles Edward Robin Morello

I thank the honourable member for giving way, and we share a lot of the problems in the South West. The Salisbury to Exeter line runs a reduced service over the summer as a result of soil moisture deficit, a catchy term that means the ground is too dry and too hard, and the trains can't run over it. This is not a new problem. We had a reduced service last year. We had a reduced service the year before.

Proper planning for what is now our everyday experience of climate change is vital, and I wonder whether or not he agrees with me that the Railway Bill, currently in the other place, is an opportunity to ensure that our infrastructure is resilient for the future and is also taking account of our climate targets?

08:53 - 09:27

Josh Newbury

Well, again, we're hearing, you know, a different impact from a different part of the country, and it's great to get that perspective from the West Country. I completely agree with him that we need to look at how a changing climate can affect different parts of the country in different ways as well. We all know we've got different realities, different weather patterns, different topographies, that all needs to be factored in. And I agree with him that the Railways Bill, which I'll come to come onto a little bit later in my speech, is provides us with an opportunity to think about the resilience for the future of the railway for decades to come, because that's absolutely where our thinking needs to be in the long term as well as the short term. Yeah, happy to.

09:27 - 09:46

Shockat Patel

I thank you for giving way and being very generous. As the honourable member has mentioned, Network Rail themselves have admitted there was an extremely challenging summer, and that it has work to do, but does the honourable member agree with me that apology is not a strategy, and that every route, including the Midland Main Line, needs a published heat resilience plan before next summer?

09:46 - 11:28

Josh Newbury

I think he makes a very interesting point again around what we need from Network Rail to ensure that the kind of local particularities of each area are taken into account. I think he's right that kind of work around resilience in the face of climate change needs to be done. I think he raises a really interesting point and I hope that Network Rail will take that on board. I recently had a meeting, including Network Rail, with some of the passengers that are affected in my constituency, and this kind of question of long-term planning in the face of what we know is going to get worse and worse was part of that, and I hope that he will have the same opportunity to do that in his constituency. There's also, Ms. Jardine, the question of communication, because people can make other arrangements if they know that a cancellation is happening in good time.

It's much harder when they've bought a ticket, travelled to the station, only then to discover that the train isn't running. And when a service is cancelled or terminated early, replacement transport needs to get people to where they actually need to go. Now, thankfully, we already have the diagnosis and the prescription for the Chase Line, we just need the fee to dispense the cure. Back when the line was electrified around a decade ago now, the project run over budget, and the previous government refused to allocate additional resource, so, therefore, corners were cut. Track circuits, which tell the signalers where trains are on the line, were bought on the cheap.

A model designed for underground railways was used and, unsurprisingly, they don't fare too well outdoors, particularly in the warmer weather. In fact, they typically trip at any point above 24 degrees, and it goes without saying that we had many days this summer where, at night time, temperatures were higher than that, let alone during the day. This is what has led to the misery that my constituents have faced on the Chase Line for successive summers, and Network Rail tell us that a full replacement is what's needed. However -

11:28 - 11:30

Speaker 5

yes, happy to give way.

11:30 - 12:01

Alex Easton

I thank the honourable member for giving way and for securing this debate. In my North Down constituency, passengers on the Bangor to Belfast line know about disruption to do with severe weather, particularly where trees grow close to railways. Would he agree that the UK government should work to support all relevant transport agencies and where relevant the devolved institutions to audit routes at risk from falling trees and support prevention measures and actions before the next storms?

12:01 - 18:14

Josh Newbury

Well, I'm really glad that we've had falling trees and leaves raised as an issue. We all we've all heard the dreaded leaves on the line being the reason for service disruption, and he's absolutely right to raise that. In all four corners of the UK, we know that is an issue, particularly as budgets have been cut back and some of that maintenance work hasn't always been done to the standard that it would have been done previously. He's absolutely right that we do need to look line by line at where the risks are and try and address the most severe risks, particularly where trees, as he said, are at risk of falling before the next season. We know we've got stormy autumn and winter ahead, so that's particularly a poignant point, but I think he's right that we need to look at that in the longer term as well.

This is what has led to the misery that my constituents have faced on the Chase Line for successive summers, and Network Rail tell us that a full replacement is what we need. However, I'm told that will cost in the region of £3 million, and with budgets being tight, we need the department to support us with this essential infrastructure correction. The alternative being looked at the moment is a coating for the circuits, which might raise their operational temperatures to around 30°. And that buys us a bit more time, but it will still leave us vulnerable to major disruption next summer. I hope the minister will pass on to the noble Lord Hendy that my constituency neighbour and I would heartily welcome him to Rugeley to discuss the challenges on the Chase Line, and perhaps while he's there, also the urgent need for an accessible footbridge at Rugeley Trent Valley station as well.

The lack of a lift is a total barrier for wheelchair users and people with limited mobility. It can also make journeys difficult for older passengers, people carrying luggage, and parents with young children. I've heard from an older constituent who found the stairs at Rugeley Trent Valley a barrier to visiting his family. I've also heard from a passenger with severely impaired knees who had to crawl up and down the steep footbridge just to change platforms. Nobody should have to face that just to catch a train.

I also want to recognise the wider challenges taking place on our railways. London North Western Railway and West Midlands Railway have now returned to public ownership, a really important step in the government's plans for Great British Railways. I welcome that move. Bringing railways closer together, with track and train working closely together, should make it easier to plan services, deal with problems, and give passengers clearer accountability. The government's also invested in new trains and stations right across the West Midlands and in the Midlands rail hub, which is all really welcome progress, and I want people in Cannock Chase to benefit from that, too.

But there's a wider issue here about the condition of our railway infrastructure and its ability to cope with more extreme weather. Network Rail's current five-year funding period, known as control period seven, runs from 2024 to 2029, and its total funding envelope is £45.4 billion in cash terms. But inflation has put that settlement under considerable pressure. The Office of Rail and Road reports that Network Rail now expects to deliver so- just 83% of its original renewals programme in England and Wales by the end of that period. It's also warned that an increasingly aging asset base has implications for reliability, performance, and safety, and that could lead to more asset failures over time, and we've been hearing some of that in the chamber today.

I recognise the financial pressures facing the railway and that difficult choices have got to be made, but with hotter summers and wetter winters, as we've heard, placing greater demands on our network, it's important that we keep the renewals programme under review and make sure essential work to protect the railway's resilience isn't lost.

And as well, the Rail Freight Group has been in touch with me to raise a concern about the Railways Bill currently before Parliament. At present, Network Rail pays compensation to passenger and freight operators when services are disrupted by bad weather and other incidents. That gives Network Rail a financial reason to keep services running where possible, and to get them back up quickly when things go wrong. Clause 65 would remove the requirement to pay compensation for events outside of Network Rail's control. It's not yet clear whether that would include seasonal weather, and we understand that weather-related exclusions are being considered by Network Rail.

I'd be grateful if the Minister could clarify perhaps, if not this afternoon, in writing, what will count as being outside Network Rail's control, and when we can expect that to be defined. Because if weather-related disruption is included, there's a risk that Network Rail has less financial incentive to keep services running or restore them, which could impact the government's ambitious target to grow rail freight by at least 75% by 2050. And I welcome the government's wider ambition to build a railway that people can rely on. This includes, as we've heard, the Railways Bill, which will create a strengthened passenger watchdog to set minimum standards on many things, such as delay compensation and accessible travel. This is a really welcome step forward towards ensuring that operators are held more accountable for when things go wrong, and that passengers are put at the heart of every journey, which is exactly what people on the Chase line are looking for.

That line is such an important connection for Cannock Chase and southern Staffordshire, linking people to jobs, education and services in Birmingham and beyond. Making it reliable is absolutely part of delivering that ambition. So, there are a few practical things I would like to put forward to end today's debate. Firstly, the need for a review of the parts of the Chase line that are most vulnerable to hot weather, particularly between Hednesford and Rugeley, as you've heard me say many times, with a clear plan and timetable for the work needed. Secondly, a proper hot-weather plan for passengers: good information, replacement transport that gets people to their destinations, and clear arrangements when services are cancelled or cut short.

Thirdly, a serious look at the frequency and capacity of services, especially at peak times. An hourly service is difficult enough when everything is running normally, let alone when services are disrupted. And fourthly, an update on step-free access at Rugeley Trent Valley, including the work that is needed and how it can be funded. The people who responded to my survey are asking for very simple things: Rosie wants to get to college, Jack wants to get to work without being packed on an overcrowded train, Angela wants to get to and from hospital where she works, Susan wants to be able to complete her journey home. We can reasonably expect a little bit of sunshine in the summer.

We might even look forward to it. But the people using the Chase line should not have to spend the warmer months wondering whether the train will run, whether it will get them to their destination, or how they will get home if it doesn't. I hope the Minister will take these experiences seriously and set out what can be done to make lines like the Chase line more resilient before next summer. And I very much look forward to hearing the contributions of other honourable members. Thank you.

18:14 - 18:27

Christine Jardine

Can I remind members that they should bob if they wish to be called in the debate? The question is that this House has considered the impact of extreme weather on train services. Charlotte Cane.

18:27 - 23:06

Charlotte Cane

Thank you, Ms Bardell. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. I congratulate the member for Cannock Chase for bringing this debate. Many decades ago, I actually did an excavation in Rugeley, a Mesolithic cave site. Moving forward a little to the Bronze Age, we know from the excavations at Flag Fen that our forebears back then knew how difficult it was to travel across the fenland and how to build and maintain good routes and keep an investment in them.

So, moving forward to the 21st century, it's extremely disappointing that we don't seem willing to put the same level of investment into our transport systems as they did back in the Bronze Age. Looking back at over June and August this year, the train line between King's Lynn and King's Cross, 1/3 of those trains didn't run at all. Of the 2/3 that did run, 80% were delayed.

So that is extremely unreliable for commuters, students, or people just trying to go about their daily lives, go to the theatre, go to sports events. You cannot rely on a train that may or may not come, may or may not arrive on time, and, indeed, the other insult is that it quite often terminates partway through the journey. So you're trying to get back from London, and you get as far as Cambridge, and you're told that's as far as the train is going to take you, and you have to work out how you're going to finish your journey from there. I myself have been impacted by this, obviously quite often, with going back and forth, but particularly when I had a surgery in Littleport, I left in plenty of time, but the train I was trying to catch was cancelled. The next train terminated at Cambridge, so I arrived an hour later than I'd intended, and therefore late for my surgery, which is extremely rude, and I really hate being rude to my constituents.

But worse than that, I've got constituents writing to me, one in particular who's written to say that because their train has been so unreliable for getting to their job in London, that their employer is now putting them under pressure because they are becoming an unreliable member of staff. Their employer doesn't know when they're going to turn up to work, and they're also having to make up the time at the end of the day, which means they're getting home very late, often later than they expected, because not only have they left late, but the train has then been delayed, and so it makes it a complete nightmare for them, because they have to be up early the next morning to come in. So, the reasons are many and various, but one of the main ones is the overhead power lines.

They don't like very hot weather. I think they don't like very cold weather either, but in the summer, it was the very hot weather. But the really big problem is that the tracks are buckling because the soil underneath is moving. We have the same problem with our roads. And this is a major problem, and with climate change, it is going to happen year in, year out.

So we really need to put the investment into sorting that out. I will say I've talked to Great Northern, and they are, in fairness, doing a lot to try and make it less unreliable, but really, they're going to need proper funding from government to help them address this. And my constituents really rely on this. As I say, it's getting to work. Many of my students, because the sixth form colleges are in Cambridge, so they need to get to college.

Our main hospital is in Cambridge, so people need to get to the hospital. These train services are really vital to people, so I do call on the government to look hard at what the particular issues are of the extreme weather and the impact it has on fen soils, and how we can make our rail lines more resilient so that my constituents can rely on a good train service.

23:06 - 23:14

Christine Jardine

I'm about to call Jayne Kirkham, but after I do, I'll be calling Steve Darling. Jayne Kirkham.

23:14 - 29:28

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Ms Jardine. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I congratulate and thank the honourable member for Cannock Chase for securing this debate on extreme weather and rail services, something that he knew I would probably turn up to talk about, because it's an issue that's felt so acutely in my coastal and rural constituency of Truro and Falmouth.

Coastal and rural areas like mine need a railway that's reliable, resilient, and speedy, so our communities and economy can thrive. Cornwall in fact has the fastest-growing branch lines in the country, and demand has soared for rail since COVID. Yet in the Duchy, there is just one rail line going in and one going out for the million residents of Cornwall and Plymouth. That is all. Anyone living or working across Cornwall and Devon knows the fragility of this vital link.

The line through Devon into Cornwall sits right on the sea wall at Dawlish and Teignmouth, exposed and exceptionally vulnerable to heavy seas. When the bad weather hits, this section frequently breaks down, leaving us 1 million people effectively cut off from the rest of the country. In February 2014, the railway line was basically swept away and cut off for eight weeks. The track was hanging into the waves. GWR shared with me in August that last winter cancellations exceeded 10% of services, and punctuality dropped to 75%.

And obviously, as others have said, it's not just storms and wintry weather. The heat we experienced this summer meant there were four separate line-side fires on the Falmouth branch in July, resulting in full cancellations. And alternate branch line services were cancelled because the rails were too hot. On Saturday, the train I was on, the lines in Cornwall were too slippery. This isn't just a story of severe named storms.

Our line is now so precarious that train services get knocked out by standard non-extreme weather: high tides, leaves on the track, routine heavy rain, are all sometimes enough to trigger speed restrictions, single-line working or total cancellations. When major storms do hit, the crisis deepens. Storm Gerrit closed the route entirely. It was over a day in the end, because we couldn't get home. And just a week later, during Storm Íngrid, I was on the 6:00 a.m. train home from Westminster when we were halted at Dawlish as massive waves crashed over the track.

With one line swallowed by the sea, we joined a queue of trains crawling forward on the single operational track. And soon after this, Storm Chandra cut the line off yet again. The human cost of this persistent disruption is immediate. I have constituents contacting me regularly, sharing their frustrations and the impact of the disruption on their lives. The last one was a constituent who contacted me about an overfilled train from Reading to Truro, impacted by Storm Austin, leaving her husband, who is coming back from abroad, heavily delayed.

It's unacceptable that passengers travelling thousands of miles across the globe face the greatest hardship on the final leg home through our region. Network Rail teams do work heroically round the clock, clearing fallen trees, repairing track faults, and executing a 2.6 billion national investment in climate resilience, but our local infrastructure is simply failing to cope. Long-range forecasts warn of increasingly challenging weather this coming winter. It's already started with Storm Austin. With climate change, obviously, these disruptions will become more frequent and severe, unless we take decisive action.

In 2014, after the storms, the Department for Transport started a South West Resilience Programme. Phase 1 to 4 have been completed, but phase 5 at the Teignmouth cliffs has been delayed and is currently unfunded. Phase 5 is dewatering and stabilising the cliff face.

Testing is occurring, but funds are simply not there. There's obviously a very real risk that the cliff could fall on a train. Much of the capital funding has gone to the Northern Powerhouse Rail. We have one vulnerable line in and out for our million people. There is no way of flying from Newquay to London most days because we've lost our PSO for our airport.

And there is an acceptance, it appears, with Network Rail that we will get cut off for a day or two when there's inclement weather, which I don't think would be accepted in many other parts of the country, to be honest. There are options. Brunel obviously didn't think ahead when he designed where the line was going to go. You can't really blame him, I suppose, but now we look back, it maybe wasn't the best place to put it. The Okehampton line has been reopened, and there is we've always talked about as a kind of a distant dream, a second line that could go across along by the A30.

The rail bill will mean that regional transport plans can be considered by GBR. We would hope that would apply to our Cornish transport plan as well. And GWR will be nationalised in December of this year. Cornwall has extraordinary economic potential. We have immense value to offer the country, partly through the critical minerals that we have under our feet, but we need to remain connected.

I'm trying very hard at the moment to reopen the freight line, that 150 yd between Falmouth Docks and the Falmouth branch line, that could bring some of those critical minerals in and out of Cornwall. But up the line, we do need a more resilient line to connect to. The Royal Albert Bridge is hard for freight to get across, and those cliffs are very difficult to get past. Better rail links aren't a luxury; they're a real necessity, particularly when you're out on a limb, as we are. We will keep pushing until the far South West gets that resilient railway network that our constituents need.

29:28 - 29:29

Steve Darling.

29:29 - 34:36

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you. May I say it is a pleasure to chair to serve under your chairmanship. May I congratulate the member for Cannock Chase for landing this really important debate. And we've had heard conversations around climate change, and that really is the enemy that we're facing, whether it's extreme heat or storms. And it's already been alluded to so far in the debate about the storm 12 years ago at Dawlish that ripped away the sea wall, leaving it almost as if it looked as if it was a railway line some somewhere in South America after a big storm had hit it.

But it resulted in eight weeks of a closure down to the South West of England, eight weeks that massively impact. One estimate suggested that the economic impact was around £1.2 billion. I can remember getting on trains in Paddington, which are usually busy places, and the train felt more like the Mary Celeste. It was absolutely incredible. Now we know that there were five parts to the puzzle of sorting this rail line out as part the South West Resilience Programme.

And the last part of this jigsaw puzzle, the fifth one, remains outstanding, and that is extremely worrying. We all know that we've you most of us enjoyed or some of us endured the really good summer that we've just had, but we know that the other side of that coin is much wetter winters. And the fact of the matter is that those wetter winters could massively impact on the cliffs at Dawlish, cuz that is the enemy now, rather than the sea. And that those cliffs could potentially collapse. And the that is unfunded, and so we desperately need the funding, and so I hope the Minister will be able to reflect on that in their comments at the end.

Further up the line from Dawlish is Powderham, often a place for events and, but again, there's a challenge there.

We're perfectly aware that the Environment Agency are choosing to do a managed retreat away from Dawlish Warren. That means the Warren will break, that acts as a protector to the estuary there, and that opens up the railway line at Powderham to attack by storms and the sea. So, again, we need investment there to protect the rail line, which is the next line that we need to protect after we've achieved the Dawlish success that we were hoping for from the Minister. And then, I'd like to reflect on where we are with the heat that a number of colleagues have spoken around, and those you know, particularly in Devon and Cornwall, we have really poor quality local rolling stock that is almost you know, life expired.

And the perverse thing is they're not new to us. Well, they are new to us, but they're third or fourth hand-me-down ones from elsewhere in the country, the 175s that they haven't you know, they were handed down from South Wales, and yet they haven't quite got them running. So, even the hand-me-downs don't work. So, we've seen this happen up in the north of England where there's been investment in the TransPennine railways for quality rail solutions, part partly electrification, part battery, so that we can have a futuristic rail service for Devon and Cornwall that will not only be a lot more sustainable in our changing world, but also making sure that we take the carbon out of the process of travelling on our rail system.

So, we're truly tackling those challenges. And then, I'd like to We'd already heard of some of the challenges across South West Trains and the lack of moisture in the soil, which means that trains are having to travel particularly slowly. So, again, that is another impact that we need to be alive to, as well as buckling rails. And I'd like to just, you know, we get I speak to hoteliers, such as one the owner of the Bur- Burgh Island Hotel, which is quite close to Torquay railway station, and she shares with me how she often gets international visitors, and it's very sad, because often their experience on the continent is a much better quality rail service.

So, after decades of underinvestment, we really need that investment to be happening. So, in conclusion, Chair, I look forward to the Minister reflecting on the final piece, the fifth piece of Dawlish rail, and what will be happening there, Powderham and how we can be protecting that in light of the threat that I've highlighted earlier on, and then, finally, investing in quality rail stock for Devon and Cornwall, so we can face the future with confidence. Thank you, Chair.

34:36 - 34:37

Joe Morris.

34:37 - 36:43

Joseph Ronald Morris

It's a pleasure, as always, to serve under your chairship, and I commend my honourable friend for securing such an important and, given the weather on Sunday, timely debate. Thank you, Mr Gray. When the weather turns, the Tyne Valley does find out very quickly how well-looked-after its railway has been over the years. And last Tuesday, for example, 20 services were cancelled across the Northern network because of Storm Bert, and the whole of the Carlisle to Newcastle line was disrupted. Now, I grew up in my constituency, and I know what the morning looks like after a particularly rough bit of weather.

You get a message on your app saying "cancelled", or you see that message at the train station, you make an apologetic phone call to your boss or a client, people wait for news, either at home, in the station coffee shop, or just hanging around under the shelter.

But this is about far more than just one storm. Extreme weather is no longer the exception. Heavy rain, flooding, landslips, high winds and extreme heat are all hitting the safe and reliable running of services, and climate change is very much, as has been said here, the driving cause. The problem is, of course, that our railway wasn't built for this.

Most of our infrastructure is Victorian in origin, and around 90% of Network Rail's assets in my constituency were installed before the year 2000. Our rails are stressed for that standard operating limit of around 30 degrees, and in 2022 we exceeded that. Track has been recorded at 51 degrees.

The July 22 heatwave alone cut performance by 40 to 50% and cost £30 million in lost revenue in just a single week. We've seen that replicated in the years since, and the result is buckled track, sagging wires and failing embankments. Those are, of course, the headlines. Behind each disruption is a personal story.

In Haltwhistle, that closed line turns hospital appointments into an ordeal. In Haydon Bridge or Bardon Mill, it's someone who potentially loses out on a day's work. In Corbridge, Riding Mill or Stocksfield, it's a commuter forced onto roads that could be flooded or blocked. And in Prudhoe or Wylam, that's being forced onto a bus that carries a fraction of what a train can. Now, rural lines, like those in my constituency, feel it first,

36:43 - 36:59

Speaker 17

and we feel it worst. Cities have other routes. In the Tyne Valley, when the railway goes, it's the A69 that's all left. And that road then immediately becomes congested. And I just want to add to the weather problem the trains problem.

36:59 - 37:26

Joseph Ronald Morris

I recently wrote to Northern about lack of capacity between Hexham and Newcastle and across the west of my constituency, including the absence of extra trains when Newcastle United are playing at home. Now, it's hard to square the aspiration of a modern, passenger-focused railway with these predictable surges in demand being managed by existing timetables. Northern have been candid with me. Too much of the fleet is approaching the end of operational life and needs ever more repair.

37:26 - 38:08

Speaker 18

Those units become unexpectedly unavailable. And that's because they run many different types of train, not all being compatible with all routes, which limits the ability to move around units to strengthen their services. Now, I'm grateful for that honesty. But thinking through it again,

when a storm hits and units fail, there's no spare train and no flexibility. An old fleet and an old network are asked to cope with a climate that neither was designed for. That's what 14 years of putting off tough decisions looks like to rural communities in my constituency. And I touch on the rural communities in my constituency that face extensive difficulties even getting to the central train line. If you're in Bellingham, if you're in Slaggyford, if you're in Nenthead, Allendale, if you are up in Stamfordham,

38:08 - 38:27

Speaker 19

a unreliable local bus that's been cut by the Morpeth Conservatives is often not arriving on time, or it's not arriving at all. And I welcome the government bringing the railway back into public hands, and I welcome the new trains programme, which I know the Minister's aware of my enthusiasm of my enthusiasm for. But structures aren't resilient. So, I do want to put a few challenges to the Minister.

38:27 - 39:16

Speaker 18

First of all, sustained investment in resilience rather than simply repair. We can't add we can't answer extreme weather with more cancellations and permanent resilient reliance on precautionary speed restrictions. So, could the Minister look at longer-term funding for renewals and maintenance so that the embankments, drainage and track are built for the climate that we have now and the one that's coming over the hill? Secondly, safety and reliability together. The choice is not between accepting disruption and taking risks.

Train drivers themselves see and tell me of the of aging infrastructure and extreme weather firsthand, and their experience must be part of how we plan for the decades ahead. So can the Minister make sure that it is? Thirdly, spare capacity. Can the Minister press Northern on how the new train on how the new trains programme will give the Tyne Valley the flexibility to respond when something goes wrong and when something goes right,

39:16 - 40:10

Speaker 15

like when there's a full stadium on a match day, when the Mags or when the Newcastle Red Bulls are playing? Fourthly, a plan for the day if it goes wrong.

proper replacement services, early and honest information and a recovery plan in place for rural lines before the storm, rather than my constituency feeling like it's consistently improvised after the fact. There is a bigger argument, too. If we wish to hit our climate goals, we need more people and more freight onto rail. Domestic transport is 30% of our territorial greenhouse gas emissions, and road vehicles represent around 90% of that figure. Rail is a fraction of that.

A single freight train could replace up to 129 lorry movements. We can't ask people to switch to rail and give them a railway that falls over at the first sign of trouble. The people of the Tyne Valley, and my constituency more broadly, aren't asking for luxury. They're simply asking for a railway that works when the weather doesn't.

40:10 - 40:11

Jim Shannon.

40:11 - 43:16

Jim Shannon

Madam Chair, as always, an absolute pleasure to serve under your chairship, and a big thank-you to the honourable gentleman for Cannock Chase for this debate. He continues to bring an assiduous delivery for his constituents, and today's another example of doing just that, and well done to him. The events of the past year have given us a very brutal wake-up call. We have seen record-breaking heatwaves causing rail bucklings, severe autumn storms bringing down overhead lines, torrential downpours flooding key transport arteries right across the United Kingdom. This is no longer a temporary seasonal inconvenience.

It's a permanent disruption to the daily lives of our constituents. And it does require an urgent systematic response. I want to give a Northern Ireland perspective, which the minister would be very glad to hear is no responsibility for. And I wish him well. And the minister always gives us a helpful responses when it comes to the questions that we ask.

Now, over here, of course, whenever, as you do if you're an Northern Ireland MP, how do you get here? Well, you fly over, you get the Heathrow Express, or it depends where you fly to, maybe the Gatwick Express, and then you get the DLR or the Tubes on the way down. And there's occasions whenever there's delays on the real duty, obstructions. Sometimes there's people on the Heathrow Express, and occasionally, as it was last summer, or a summer past there, whenever I was coming over and I'd taken the Gatwick Express, a bus had hit a bridge, and the Gatwick Express was not able to progress any further until they'd cleared the obstacle of what took place. So, there's always problems.

And that's one of the reasons, Madam Chair, why travelling is certainly one of those things that I enjoy, because there's always hassle, and there's always delays. While much of the national debate naturally focuses on major inner-city networks, I want to bring attention to the specific harsh realities facing my people in Northern Ireland, particularly within my own constituency of Strangford. I want to talk, if I can, the delays that happen, and how that affects daily life, and social engagement, and people having normality. We must look at how these infrastructure failures are directly impacting two crucial groups: first of all, our children trying to access education, and our hard-working citizens trying to travel to work. Madam Chair, let us look first at the at our young people and children, who are simply trying to better themselves through education.

We have students from across the Ards Peninsula and the wider Strangford area, who travel every single day to universities and colleges in Belfast, and right across the province to Londonderry. And the only way of getting there, if you haven't got a car, and road be too expensive, is the railway, and that's how it works. When extreme weather hits Northern Ireland, as we've seen with increasingly violent storms and localized flooding, Madam Chair, on many occasions now when the rain comes, it's a it's a biblical downpour, and the impact right away upon roads and gullies is incredible. I'm quite happy to give way.

43:16 - 43:43

Gregory Campbell

Thank the honourable member for giving way. Would he agree with me that the issue now isn't just confined to the South and the South-East of the United Kingdom, whereas it may have been 20 or 30 years ago, but, given the increasing warming of our climate, it is imperative that all our devolved institutions, both North and South, need to ensure that they take steps to try and mitigate against the problem that we see everyone encountering?

43:43 - 47:18

Jim Shannon

Yeah, they I think my noble friend and colleague for that intervention, and again very wise words, and he underlines the very issue. Yeah.

When extreme weather hits Northern Ireland, as we've seen with increasingly violent storms and localised flooding, our transport network instantly buckles. So, for a student, Madam Chair, heading from our area to the Magee campus in Coleraine or Londonderry, a single weather-related rail restriction, a flooded track Excuse me. or a single weather-related rail restriction or a missed connection means missing vital lectures, labs and exams. They are fighting against a system where a simple weather warning can completely derail their academic work.

We cannot expect our young people to fulfill their educational potential when the physical infrastructure to get them to the lecture hall is entirely unreliable or continuously breaks down. The situation is even more acute for further education college students travelling south down to campuses in Downpatrick, again from my constituency as an example. Many of these young people depend entirely on the Strangford Lough ferry service to bridge the gap between Portaferry and Strangford village. That ferry is supposed to be the lifeline, a one-mile crossing that replaces what would otherwise be a grueling 46-mile journey by road. Yet, what have we seen?

We have seen repeated sudden suspensions of the ferry service due to severe storm conditions, high tides, and subsequent mechanical strains caused by operating in extreme weather. When the ferry stops, the education of these teenagers stops. Bus substitutions are hastily put in place, but they cannot make up for the hours that are lost, and these students are arriving at college exhausted, late or worse, unable to get there at all, and facing attendance penalties through absolutely no fault of their own. Now, the Minister might say, and he probably will say to me, might look at a map and say, "Well, Strangford doesn't have a railway line." Well, no, it doesn't.

No, sir, we don't, but our workers and our commuters are resourceful. Thousands of my constituents utilize the Belfast to Bangor rail line, which the honorable member for North Down referred to, located just 10 minutes away from the edge of my constituency. So, it's a good opportunity to get a main train line into Belfast and not too far away and not have to park their car in Belfast, and so, our workers, our job seekers and the commuters drive, get lifts or catch connecting buses to Bangor station every morning to access the wider employment market in greater Belfast where the employment and the jobs are. But what happens when extreme weather strikes the Bangor line, as the honorable member for North Down refers to? Trees fall, leaves on the line, and there's always problems.

The Bangor line suffers from immediate cancellations, terminates early or skips vital stops like the City Hospital and Grand Central. So, when the Bangor line fails due to weather-stressed infrastructure, the knock-on effect on Strangford's workforce is immediate and devastating. It is the low-wage shift workers, the apprentices, the people who don't have the luxury of working from home who suffer the most. They're left stranded on cold platforms. They lose vital day wages, and on occasion, they face disciplinary action for employers for being late.

It's not every time you can say the plane's late again today, or that's right, the train's late again today and expect it to be the normal excuse when it is the right reason, but the repetition of that as an excuse doesn't always work out.

47:18 - 47:19

Will the honorable gentleman give way?

47:19 - 47:21

Speaker 23

Very happy to, yes.

47:21 - 48:15

Jess Brown-Fuller

I thank the honourable gentleman and it's interesting listening to his speech and the commonalities that we have so far apart with my constituency on the south coast and a lot of my constituents travel outside of the city of Chichester for work and similarly a lot of people living in Bognor Regis and Portsmouth come into the city for work and they are encouraged to use public transport, but when extreme weather is rapidly becoming weather, does he agree with me that it's incredibly frustrating for people who are constantly told, we're sorry for the disruptions, but we're experiencing extreme weather, but with 40 days this year where temperatures reached over 30 degrees, where leaves on the line can stop the trains from running, where the other day swans on the line stopped the trains from running on our arterial railway route, that we need to get a grip with making sure the trains can run so people can continue to work?

48:15 - 50:17

Jim Shannon

The honourable lady has given a incredibly accurate explanation of what happens in her constituency. And when you look across the world and you see where Canada has extreme weathers, snow and real warmth in the summer, they seem to be able to cope with it all right. And really sometimes I think we must ask ourself this very question, why come we can't adjust or learn perhaps from what they do? I would suggest, Madam Chair, that the social contract is being broken. We are asking people to slog their guts out and go to work every day, yet the state, my honourable lady is right, is failing to provide the basic resilient infrastructure to let them do safely and reliably.

The national funding allocated for weather resilience must not, and I say this respectfully, must not be hoarded by the Treasury or spent exclusively on major English intercity routes. We need to see that investment deployed with absolute urgency into regional infrastructure. We need it spent on securing the resilience of the Translink services, stabilizing the vessels on the Strangford ferry and ensuring that vital regional feeder lines, like the Bangor rail track, for instance, are fully weatherproofed against extreme temperatures and flooding. I conclude with this, Madam Chair. I urge the Minister today, and the Minister probably does this already, but just to have it on the record, can I ask the Minister to engage with the Minister at the Northern Ireland Assembly, to hold the discussions, to exchange thoughts and ideas on how we can better learn how to deal with extreme weather, whether it be warm in the summer, 35 to 40 degrees, or whether it be the winter time when whenever the the the the the very bad weather means that we're not able to travel the same.

And while exchanging those ideas with the Northern Ireland Assembly Minister, that resilience funding is released. Let us fix these lines, protect our commuters and ensure that extreme weather stops putting the lives, the education and the careers of our people on hold. Thanks very much.

50:17 - 50:21

Christine Jardine

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Richard Foord.

50:21 - 54:54

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Mr. Jardine, and it's good to see you in the chair today. And I congratulate the honourable member for Cannock Chase on securing this debate. It's one that I've tried to secure myself on a number of occasions, and that's because I have the West of England line running through the Honiton and Sidmouth constituency, passing through the towns of Axminster and Honiton as well as the village of Feniton. I was struck a moment ago by the honourable member for Chichester describing how extreme weather has become simply weather. And I think that it's really very well put.

And moreover, we could talk in this debate not about extreme weather, but about the impact of climate change on our transport infrastructure. I think that it's also really good to see the Minister for Local Transport in his place because he has been fantastic at securing for Mid Devon and for Somerset new railway stations at Cullompton and Wellington respectively.

So I know that he does an excellent job in his role, and that's why I'm pleased to have this opportunity today to talk about Liberal Democrat policy, but also to talk about the West of England Line. The West of England Line connects Exeter with London Waterloo, and goes via Salisbury. And for much of that line, certainly west of Salisbury, it is a single-track line, so that when there is a disruption or a delay, it means that the whole timetable gets thrown. And so you can understand that a lot of residents from East Devon have contacted me about it in the dry, hot summers that we have had last year and this. South Western Railway describes the main consequences of this dry weather as "soil moisture deficit", which is a euphemism for embankments that are dry.

And this is due to the route largely sitting on clay. When prolonged heat and drought remove moisture from the soil, the clay shrinks, the embankments move and the track moves, too. And of course, in these conditions, it would be dangerous to carry on as normal. Speed restrictions have to be imposed, and we saw the consequences of extreme weather on a railway line that doesn't have any sort of disruption to the schedule. We saw that in Lewes earlier this year, I think, where Southern railway experienced a derailment.

The euphemism in that case was "track geometry irregularity", which I think is a euphemism for rails that have bent. But no, in seriousness, I accept that safety has to come first. We've got to acknowledge the um that while safety is a priority, it's having severe consequences on the people who we represent. First of all, I'd like to just consider young people trying to build their future. One person who is from Awliscombe wrote to me that her sorry, his 17-year-old daughter could no longer get to her apprenticeship for 8 o'clock in the morning because the only train reaching Exeter at that time had been cancelled.

And without any replacement bus service, he and his wife are having to make a 40-mile round trip by car to get their daughter to work. That's not an isolated incident; roughly 550 college students travel on the West of England line to Exeter College. A father from Offwell told me his daughter, who's just started, is subject to train cancellations, delays, and often spends two to three hours every day waiting for a train home from Exeter. A mother from Honiton explained how, since both the 7:30 and the 7:30 train and the 7:45 bus have been cancelled, there's no way for students to arrive on time for their 9:45 lectures. So students are relying on this service to access further education, but it's also disrupting working people.

Shelby Gittins is a dental hygienist from All Saints, near Axminster. And she is being prevented from reaching Exeter reliably before the start of her working day. Due to the delays, her office has had to reschedule her 9 o'clock patients indefinitely until the matter is resolved. And given that Devon is one of the UK's foremost dental deserts, this is quite a serious consequence for people trying to get dental work in Devon. I will.

54:54 - 55:44

Caroline Jane Voaden

I thank the honourable friend for giving way. Forgive me, Chair, for being late, but the railway did not want me to be here for the start of this debate, so here I am. My honourable friend talks about the impact on working people of delays on the line, and we in the West of England are going to be impacted for a year, two years, possibly more by the works at Old Oak Common. So, I wonder if my honourable friend would agree with me that, for the tiny sum of 12 million pounds, which is only just over half of what's being spent every single day on HS2, for 12 million pounds, high-speed Wi-Fi could be put on every single one of the 94 trains on the Great Western Railway network. And if it was, all those working people, like myself, who get stuck on delayed trains and slow trains going down to the West of England, we actually wouldn't mind an extra 10 or 15 minutes on the journey time because it would be productive time.

So would he agree with me that the government needs to fund this project?

55:44 - 01:00:01

John Richard Foord

Hear. The honourable member for South Devon makes a very good point, of course. Time is not wasted in on a delayed train if there is good Wi-Fi connection for the workers on board the train who can work. So of course I would recommend that investment in the mainline. But on the poor relation, that is the West of England Line, I've heard from constituents who have been trying to get to college, to school, to businesses.

I've heard from patients and families, and the effect that it's having on the local economy. Most importantly, these disruptions often hit the most vulnerable in our society the hardest. Catherine Wilkerson from Sidmouth told me that, over the course of six journeys to London for work she made in the summer heat, only one featured working air conditioning. And when she was in packed trains, she explained that on multiple occasions, she had to pause her journey and get off the train due to dizziness and to avoid fainting from heat exhaustion. Catherine pointed out this means that train travel in the heat can be dangerous, and the rolling stock needs to be updated to accommodate and to adapt to the climate change we all see.

So, these three groups tell the same story. It affects the students, the workers, and the vulnerable. And people I represent are right to ask, why a line of such importance for the network as a whole remains so vulnerable? They accept that soil moisture deficit, as a temporary measure, is required, but this is no longer a temporary measure. This is the second year in a row where this the schedule has been introduced for months and months at a time, meaning that trains are only running once every two hours.

Weather-related delays across the country have cost around 370 million pounds over 3 years, from 2023 to '24, but that is just the narrow economic consequence on the railways, not the wider consequences for all of these people who I've described and with their anecdotes earlier today. The Liberal Democrats believe passengers deserve railways that withstand the climate conditions we are set to face. Too much of our infrastructure, particularly in the West Country, still relies on Victorian earthworks, drainage systems and assets that were never designed for today's climate, and of course, they've been subject also to the Beeching cuts. And instead of bringing these facilities back into the 21st century, the last Conservative government left behind a legacy of underinvestment and crumbling infrastructure. Now I have corresponded with the Department for Transport and with ministers, not least with Lord Hendy in the other place, about the West of England Line.

And the specific things that I have been seeking from ministers is investment into passing loops on the West of England Line. If you make an analogy with the road, this is like pulling over to allow an oncoming vehicle to come the other way. And I understand from Lord Hendy that, if we were to make the case for investment for in passing loops in Control Period 8, the period 2029 to 20 2034, that potentially we could see those passing loops developed at Tisbury, Feniton, Whimple, and other places on the West of England Line to enable trains to pull over and to enable trains to run on a much more frequent basis, even when experiencing soil moisture deficit.

So I ask the Minister, what further can he recommend we do to secure these passing loops in control period 8? And more generally for the Government, how will they accelerate investment in climate resilience so that we can get ahead of the changes we know are coming down the track at us with a changing climate to make sure that our students, our workers and our most vulnerable members of society get the transport links that they deserve? Thank you.

01:00:01 - 01:00:05

Christine Jardine

Thank you. Opposition spokesperson, Richard Holden.

01:00:05 - 01:09:38

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed, Ms Jardine, and it's a it's a pleasure to serve under your chairwomanship yet again. And I'd like to congratulate, first of all, the honourable member for Cannock Chase for bringing forwards this debate today. The challenges posed by extreme weather on our railways are not a new problem. After all, in the early days of British railway innovation, plans could be repeatedly derailed for bad weather. For instance, one of the many challenges with Brunel's infamous attempts to introduce an atmospheric railway at South Devon was it repeatedly falling foul of the weather, a part of the country that is still acutely impacted by these extremes today, and as we've heard from many members across the House.

Unfortunately, the problems posed by these extremes are not a thing of the past. After a spring and summer in which the performance of our railways has worsened, I would commend the member for proposing this debate. And as we've repeatedly said, our approach on this side of the House to railways must be evidence-based, and I hope that goes for all sides of the House. Our railways should not be run according to a dogmatic ideology, but according to what serves the travelling public best. Now, although Britain has one of the safest railways in the world, we cannot remain complacent, and as we recently saw in Spain, rail accidents can have the most tragic of consequences, and we've got to do everything possible we can to avoid them.

One of the approaches we need to take is improving the resilience of our railways, making them much more effective in coping with whatever weather conditions we experience. Given the railways are performing worse now under almost every metric, this is all the more important, and the data for the first six ORR periods of the 2026-2027 financial year showed a deterioration in performance across the vast majority of operators. This included delays on services such as South Western, LNER, Southeastern, c2c and Greater Anglia, many of which were previously performing much better under previous operators. This is reflected in costs to the taxpayer. According to the DfT's own numbers, South Western Railway spent 8.25 million pounds on payouts to rail users under its Delay Repay scheme, despite the fact that fewer than half of eligible passengers actually claim this compensation, so it should be at least twice as high.

Possibly most worryingly, given the terms of this debate and the importance of addressing extreme weather, Network Rail attributable delay minutes increased across every region of the UK, except Scotland. This means more delays for passengers, directly attributable to the organizations organization that manages infrastructure, and which is likely to play a leading role within GBR once it is fully established. And as the honourable member who proposed this debate mentioned, the impact this can have on freight sectors as well is incredibly important, and we need to understand fully some of the clauses in the Railway Bill, and the impact that could have on what we want to see, which is greater numbers of freight taking some of those lorries off the roads where it's appropriate to do so. And we need But they need to have the certainty that it's going to happen and that they will get properly compensated if there are issues with the network.

These are not small changes that we've seen, but significant ones. In the southern region, for example, on a per thousand train mile basis, Network Rail was responsible for over 50% more delays in minutes than during the first few months of 2024 over those last few time periods. I think it is worth noting this, considering Network Rail's comments about the challenges it faced this summer. If the government manager of our rail infrastructure is facing severe problems with the weather, how can we have confidence that it's going to be a really core part of GBR and managing that process of full nationalisation effectively? I recognise that a number of these concerns have been raised previously and reiterated today.

For example, I understand that the, some of the Lib Dem members who spoke today have raised the need to consider the current rail stress temperatures need to be looked at again given the much wider range of temperatures we are now experiencing across increasingly hot summers. Furthermore, more modern railway electrification infrastructure in the country is much needed and to be more resilient than the older and sometimes, as honourable members pointed out, sometimes inappropriate equipment installed over the decades. Given this government's cancellation of projects like the Midland Main Line electrification, it is unclear how the government will effectively upgrade that older, less resilient infrastructure. Now, we all recognise the costs that there would be involved in this if there were to be significant changes to increase those stress temperatures. Therefore, the government must explain how we can maintain our railway in a cost-effective and targeted way.

I say that on the basis of the previous reviews of extreme weather highlighted a clear need to better establish where there are problems and the need to target root causes. However, to achieve this, Network Rail must embed cost control into its overall approach, so that its resources are as use as effectively as possible across what is a large network. Ultimately, while I absolutely share our love, obviously, of our environment and the need to protect it, and to obviously ensure that money is allocated to our railways properly, it's got to be used as effectively as possible. The question is whether the projects Network Rail are currently conducting are the best use of such funds. As ministers have unfortunately given less than clear answers to some of my written parliamentary questions about biodiversity projects, it's hard to understand sometimes precisely how money is allocated to biodiversity is currently being directed, and whether it's being used in the best way in the, in order to protect the infrastructure that so many of our constituents rely on across the country.

We've heard from Network Rail about its innovative use of technology to achieve its aims of managing some of these projects. However, does the minister think that this technology and investment would be better directed towards ensuring that our infrastructure continues to operate successfully during periods of extreme weather? We know that Network Rail, for example, uses technology such as thermal imaging to examine issues around earthworks with East Midlands reporting savings of around £100,000 in doing so. However, ensuring these tools are directed always towards improving resilience must surely be the priority when facing weather conditions as we've seen this summer. Furthermore, in adapting to the changing causes of weather-related delays, we must consider how we can build and maintain our infrastructure more cost-effectively.

That means removing unnecessary regulations wherever possible, which make it more difficult to carry out enhancements needed to make our railways more resilient. For example, we cannot allow unnecessary bureaucratic regulations to stand in way of measures designed to improve the railway's resilience to these extreme weather conditions we're now increasingly facing. And all of this could only be achieved with funding. The government's responses to written parliamentary questions on this matter have referred to £2.6 billion as recently as September. However, given the official Control Period 7 Delivery Plan, published in the spring of 2024, set out what it described as a step change in our approach to mitigating the impact of extreme weather with and including a targeted £2.8 billion in investment to protect our most susceptible assets, in particular earthworks and drainage to support reliability, could the minister perhaps explain the discrepancy between these numbers, and if he can't today could he write to me about it?

For example, the summary of regional plans for 2024-2029 set out clear spending commitments across all regions amounting to £2.79 billion. Is this discrepancy due to different classifications of maintenance spending, or is it the result of cuts which have been made to these resilience budgets leading to a reduction in the allocated spending? Given that 2.6 is obviously less than 2.8 billion, and we've seen significant inflation within the rail sector as well, and the majority of the spending was earmarked for earthworks and drainage, is the minister confident that all the money necessarily is being delivered towards these projects specifically, because that's what people here today have been asking about on behalf of their constituents? And when we consider the government's decision to indefinitely pause phase five of the South West Rail Resilience Programme, this is directly linked to funding and the priorities that this government has chosen to pursue. While we obviously recognise that there are tough decisions to be made on spending, it would be helpful if the minister could clarify precisely how much the government is spending and whether it expects other significant projects in this space to be halted as well.

Overall, Ms Jardine, I reiterate the points that we made at the start of the debate. When dealing with extreme weather, the government must focus and focus all of its efforts to works which are most cost-effective and delivering for our constituents. Having wasted money on GBR signage, obscure bureaucratic projects, and other ideology-driven activities, the government really needs to demonstrate that it's prioritising things that matter to our constituents. Our railways are experiencing an increasingly different set of challenges on the extreme weather conditions. We do understand that, but that means that the government needs to adapt accordingly to those to the challenges we face today.

The end result otherwise would be a failure to deliver on the targets that are really there to support our constituents.

01:09:38 - 01:09:41

Christine Jardine

Government minister Simon Lightwood, please.

01:09:41 - 01:11:50

Simon Lightwood

Thank you very much, and always a pleasure to see you in the chair, Ms Jardine. I'd like to begin by expressing my sincere condolences to the families and loved ones of those who lost their lives in the tragic train crash in Toledo, Spain, on the 28th of October, and to all those affected. I know that the UK Rail Accident Investigation Branch was quick to offer its expertise and its support to its counterparts in Spain in the aftermath of this tragedy. I also want to acknowledge the recent derailments at Lewes and Wickford and the collision at Bedford over the summer. My thoughts are with everyone affected by these incidents.

And I'd like to pay tribute, I'm sure members across the House will join me in this, tribute to the emergency services and all those that were involved in the response. These incidents are a reminder of the responsibility that we carry to remain vigilant, learn from what's happened, and maintain an unwavering focus on safety. As the relevant independent authorities continue their investigations, Ms Jardine, it's important of course, we avoid speculation and allow their work to conclude before drawing any conclusions about those causes. I'm pleased to speak in Westminster Hall today about the impact of extreme weather on train services. And I congratulate my honourable friend the member for Cannock Chase for securing this debate and for all the other contributions today.

If I don't manage to address your specific points, I reassure you, assure you, even, that the rail minister would have heard your points today and can always follow that up in writing as well. The effects of extreme weather on the railway are felt not as abstract statistics, as my the honourable gentleman, my by-election twin for Honiton and Sidmouth, said, this is not just about statistics.

It's about miss connections, it's about disrupted working days and uncertainty for passengers and freight. It's about impacts on local economies, on customers. Communities need a railway that is safe and reliable, and able to recover quickly when conditions deteriorate.

01:11:50 - 01:11:51

On that point, will the Minister give way?

01:11:52 - 01:11:53

Markus Campbell-Savours.

01:11:53 - 01:12:23

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Madam Chair. In Cumbria we fully appreciate how disruptive bad weather can be and we've got quite a lot of experience of it, but we don't appreciate why bad weather in Scotland can mean trains heading north on the West Coast Main Line terminate in Preston, nearly an hour away from Penrith and even further to Carlisle. Would the minister commit to writing to Avanti and Network Rail to understand why and consider solutions that might get my constituents home a bit quicker?

01:12:23 - 01:17:58

Simon Lightwood

My honourable friend raises a really interesting question, I don't know personally, but I will make sure I speak to the rail minister and see what answers we can get from my honourable friend on that particular issue. Look, this summer brought those challenges into sharp focus, I think. The UK experienced five widespread heat waves between May and August, and in June, the Met Office issued a rare red extreme heat warning. During the most severe conditions, on the 24th and 25th of June, passengers were advised to make only essential journeys in affected areas, including the West Midlands. Services continued to run, but safety required reduced speeds and amended timetables.

That meant longer journeys and a greater risk of delays, cancellations, and late changes. My honourable friend is right to highlight the experience of Cannock Chase. This summer, heat reduced Chase line services, while intense rainfall flooded the railway between Hednesford and Rugeley and forced trains to terminate at Hednesford. Further storms disrupted services in October. These events reinforce, I think, the need for better preparations, including drainage, targeted resilience investment, and strong local partnership working.

Network Rail have produced a weather resilience and climate change adaptation plan for each of our regions, and they indicate where investment may be needed during hot weather and how they can be addressed. The first duty, of course, of the railway is of course to keep passengers and staff safe. Speed restrictions, targeted inspections, and temporary closures can be really frustrating, but they are needed to ensure a safe railway. The task is to make those decisions earlier and more precisely, communicate them clearly, and restore the services quickly as possible as conditions allow. The industry has drawn practical lessons from summer 2026, preparing earlier, focusing on the greatest risks, planning for prolonged heat, and making decisions sooner.

Operationally, that means acting as one railway, using restrictions in a targeted way, building recovery into the response, and adapting quickly as evidence changes. The Railways Bill will establish Great British Railways, which will integrate operations and infrastructure in regional routes acting as one railway. In the meantime, the rail industry has established a climate change programme, co-chaired by Network Rail and DfTO, to provide strategic direction, align the industry, and monitor delivery. Preparation is not confined to summer, and climate risks are not confined to heat and the consequential soil moisture deficit in many areas. The developing El Niño is expected to increase the chances of wetter, stormier conditions across the UK this autumn and in early winter, with stronger winds and increased risks of heavy rainfall and flooding.

But in addition, colder spells are also possible.

The railway is therefore preparing for a range of conditions, using drones and specialist treatment trains and forecasts in autumn, while managing vulnerable trees, planning contingency timetables, monitoring conditions in real time, and deploying winter equipment to keep passengers moving safely. But as well as operational preparedness, we need to look to the future. Summers like these, like this last one we experienced this year will become increasingly common. As you said, the extreme weather has become the weather. The changing climate means that resilience cannot simply be something we consider after extreme weather strikes.

It needs to be built into the everyday decisions we make about how we transport, how the transport system is maintained, operated, and of course funded. That's why the Department for Transport launched its climate adaptation strategy for transport in December 2025, that's setting out our vision for a transport system that is safe, reliable, and resilient to a changing climate. Importantly, the strategy is about turning that ambition into practical change, supporting the transport system to prepare for the impacts of climate change by setting the strategic direction, strengthening the evidence base, and embedding adaptation into planning and decision-making. That approach is already being put into practice on the railway. Network Rail is pioneering work on adaptation planning through its adaptation pathways so that investment can be prioritized and staged as risks change.

Publicly owned train operators have also developed weather resilience and climate adaptation plans for the first time to look at climate risks across the railway, not just infrastructure. Staff and customer welfare, for example, working air con are equally important. Just yesterday, the Department for Transport published the first Transport Resilience Strategy to provide strategic direction to improve the resilience of the transport sector and ensure that resilience principles are embedded within decision-making and planning. And the members for Strangford and East Londonderry will be pleased to know that we're setting up a Four Nations transport resilience group as part of this. Looking ahead, Great British Railways will address resilience across track and train as one system, while the long-term rail strategy will highlight climate resilience and adaptation as a clear priority, building on the £2.9 billion invested in 2024 to 2029, and this has been invested in activity, yes, but also technology to improve the resilience in extreme weather and climate change.

Well indeed, yes.

01:17:58 - 01:17:59

Steve Darling.

01:17:59 - 01:18:17

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. A few months ago, Network Rail met with myself and other Southwest MPs who were here today, and told us that it's acceptable occasionally to close the Dawlish rail line. Do you believe that it's acceptable? Oh sorry, does the Minister believe it's acceptable? Apologies, Chair.

01:18:17 - 01:18:18

That's all right, Steve.

01:18:18 - 01:21:09

Simon Lightwood

I'll come on to talk specifically about the issues you raised. I think all endeavours are being made, and a great deal of funding has gone in to try and make that track as resilient as possible. I don't think anybody really wants to suspend services through that area, but unfortunately, there will be instances where that may have to take place. But I think the investment that has taken place has made it more resilient. We saw that in the latest storms, whereby it was reopened the very next day after its closure.

So, the member for Truro and Falmouth, and the member for Torbay talked about the Southwest rail resilience, I think more than £165 million has been invested through the Southwest Rail Resilience Programme, including a new seawall, a rockfall shelter at Parsons Tunnel, and major cliff stabilization work. And as I've just said, the value of that investment has already been demonstrated at the start of this year during those storms, and also so actually, Cornwall's worst-ever rainfall totals. But the new seawall performed as designed, helping to protect the infrastructure from major damage, and allowed it to reopen the very next day. In terms of phase 5 of the resilience programme, indeed it was not funded as part of the 2025 Spending Review, we're continuing to fund investigative work on that section of the route.

Network Rail is currently undertaking a drainage trial to remove water from the cliffs, as well as further ground investigation that will help Network Rail with more detailed data that it needs for longer-term solutions. I know that monitoring equipment is also installed in those areas of the cliff between Parson's Tunnel and Teignmouth, which will help provide a quick response when triggered. And my honorable friend, the member for Hexham, also mentioned about Northern. I think Northern are procuring I think 450 new trains, they're due in 2031. Now I appreciate that feels like a long time away, but they're also looking at shorter-term options to improve capacity.

To conclude, Ms Jardine, that I would like to assure the honorable member, and the honorable members throughout the House, that this Government recognizes both the immediate disruption experienced by passengers, and the longer-term challenge facing our railway. Cannock Chase has seen the effect of heat, intense rainfall and storms within a single season. We'll continue to work with Network Rail, train operators and local partners to learn from those events, improve drainage and operational preparedness, target investment where risk is greatest and give passengers clearer information. Extreme weather cannot be prevented. But its consequences can be better anticipated, managed and reduced, and that is how we will secure a safer, more reliable and more resilient railway for Cannock Chase and for communities across the country.

01:21:09 - 01:21:11

Speaker 38

Thank you.

01:21:11 - 01:21:13

Christine Jardine

Josh Newbury to wind up.

01:21:13 - 01:25:00

Josh Newbury

Well, thank you very much, Ms Jardine. And I would like to start by thanking all honorable members who've contributed to this debate this afternoon, either through interventions or through making their speeches. I found it very enjoyable, not because of the litany of examples of disruption we've heard from across the country, but because of the richness with which honorable members have come here today to speak up for their constituents who are affected by these issues. And we had many interventions where members highlighted particular constituency concerns, including for the members for Leicester South, Woking, West Dorset, Chichester and South Devon. I was really interested to hear about the archaeological endeavors in Rugeley of the honorable member for Ely and East Cambridgeshire.

We'll have to find her site and have her back to repeat that again. She's right to raise issues for her constituents traveling in and out of London as well as within Cambridgeshire, and I support her calls for investment in her line, even if it's like just after the my line. And I my honorable friend, the member for Truro and Falmouth, really highlighted the human consequences of disruption, particularly in Cornwall. And she rightly highlighted the fact that big pots of money have gone to elsewhere in the country, but in Cornwall where they just have the one line, they've often missed out. She's right to raise that, as well as the lack of alternatives like flights, which I know in many cases are being cut back, too.

And also she highlighted the issues at Dawlish, which the minister referred to, which are also referred to by the member for Torbay. He's right to say that climate change is the real enemy that we are facing in this battle. And he also raised the risks further up the line at Powderham, and I think he was right to highlight that too. He mentioned ageing rolling stock, as did my honorable friend, the member for Hexham, who drew on his personal experience having grown up in his constituency. And also the fact that so much of the infrastructure in his part of the world is getting very old now.

And he was right to highlight, as well, the disruption around major events, which I think underlined the fact that these disruptions could affect our sporting, hospitality and leisure industries, as well as individually us as passengers. And my honorable friend, the member for Strangford, as always, present in these debates and making an excellent contribution, despite the lack of his train line in his constituency boundaries, he was right to highlight the experiences of his constituents who used the Bangor line and the importance for resilient services going in to Belfast, which the honorable member for North Down also mentioned. I really thank him for highlighting the issues for our young people who often find their opportunities limited by travel disruption.

He's right to highlight that. And the member for East Londonderry also reminded us that transport worries are spreading right across Northern Ireland and the need for that cross-border collaboration, which I think is true right across the British Isles. And just briefly, Mr. Jardine, out of the interventions, I would just like to pick up the honorable member for South Devon, who made a really important point around train Wi-Fi. She's absolutely right. We face a lot of productivity issues in this country.

If people were able to work whilst they're stuck on trains, that would go some way to addressing that. But I would also like to commend her for the campaigning that she is doing, although it's a road issue rather than rail, around the A379 at Slapton Sands. Her constituency is one that my family and I visit every year to go on holiday. And when we were down there this year, I was struck by the explanation on hoardings of businesses that have been affected by the washing away of the road and the immense storm they had at Torcross and the explanation of the work that she is doing as an assiduous constituency MP to try and get that those issues resolved, and I really wish her all the best with that campaign. So, with that, Mr. Jardine, I'd like to finish the debate once again by thanking all honorable members, and I'm sure we will all continue to talk about this disruption, hopefully which will be re- resolved soon.

But I thank everybody for bringing their stories to the debate today.

01:25:00 - 01:30:27

Christine Jardine

The question is that this House has considered the impact of extreme weather on train services. As many as are of that opinion, say, aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. Order.

Sorry? Yeah. We'll suspend now until 4:00 p.m.

Order. I will call Esther McVey to move the motion and I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up, as is convention for a 30-minute debate. Order.

Esther McVey to move the motion.

01:30:27 - 01:31:20

Esther McVey

I beg to move that this House has considered the use of agricultural land for solar panels, and Mrs Jardine, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Currently, planning is being sought for a large solar panel development in my constituency on 150 acres of grade 1 and 2 agricultural land, some of the best and most versatile agricultural land there is, and including 70 acres of grade 1 farmland, and which forms part of an historic rural landscape too. The local residents of Tabley and Knutsford are both distraught and mystified that a time when food security is increasingly recognized as a national priority that we should be allowing our highest-quality agricultural land to come out of production.

01:31:21 - 01:31:22

I will indeed.

01:31:22 - 01:31:57

Jim Shannon

The honourable lady and I share many things and this is one of things we share the same concern over. And increasingly in my constituency of Strangford and across Northern Ireland, there are great many solar applications coming through which will take away prime agricultural land. In Northern Ireland, the agriculture is an important the most important backbone of our regional economy. Does the honourable lady agree that where the consideration must always be given to brownfield sites and rooftops as to ensure that the valuable land that everybody wishes and talks about is retained for the purpose that it should be, and that's for the production of foods?

01:31:57 - 01:31:58

Esther McVey.

01:31:58 - 01:32:19

Esther McVey

My honourable friend makes absolute correct sort of point there. I'll be coming to that, and I know other members here will be pointing that out as well. For once development of this kind is approved, this land is no longer available for its primary purpose, producing food.

01:32:19 - 01:32:20

Will my right honourable friend give way?

01:32:20 - 01:32:22

Esther McVey

I will indeed.

01:32:22 - 01:32:57

Graham Stuart

I'm extremely grateful to my right honourable friend. Clean Air solar farm proposal near Beverley, again, is on some excellent BMV, best and most versatile, agricultural land. Does she like me consider the fact that given this fantastic high quality land only constitutes about 40% of farm land, does she agree with me that it's insane to allow solar to go on that best land when 60% of the land that's widely available could have solar on it, and the minister would be well-advised to tighten up the rules, because then his solar strategy is far more likely to retain public support?

01:32:57 - 01:32:58

Esther McVey.

01:32:58 - 01:34:07

Esther McVey

"Insanity" is the right word and that what was expressed by many of my constituents. At the last public meeting, arranged by Raynor Jackson and the newly formed community group Knutsford Solar Action, hundreds of local residents gathered hoping to get some answers from the developer and the local council as to why that site had been chosen. Sadly, neither a courer, the developer, nor Cheshire East Council bothered to attend. And so, even the most basic questions, such as why an environment environmental impact assessment had not been done for this site, could be answered. The whole process has shown absolutely no regard for the local rural community.

The truth is, this government's colossal rush to achieve its net zero targets is coming at the expense of our nation's food security and destroying the UK's farming land. But then again, we know what this government thinks of our farmers and farming: not a lot. I will indeed give way.

01:34:08 - 01:34:29

Rose Savage

I thank the right honourable lady for giving way. Would she agree with me that it cannot be right that farmers in the South Cotswolds who have had no say in this are now facing the compulsory acquisition of rights over their land, purely because the developer has chosen to locate a solar farm 13 miles away from the nearest grid connection?

01:34:29 - 01:34:30

Esther McVey.

01:34:30 - 01:35:15

Esther McVey

I agree with the honourable lady, and I do hope the minister today is listening to what all honourable and right honourable members are saying about this issue. According to the Commons Library, between August 2025 and July 2026, 733 solar photovoltaic projects received planning permission across the United Kingdom. This shows the pace at which solar developments are reshaping our countryside, with around 188,000 acres approved for grid-scale solar projects across the UK. I will indeed give way. There were two members wishing to speak on the same point, so I'll go from one to the other.

01:35:15 - 01:35:49

Helen Whately

My right honourable friend has been very generous with the interventions that she is allowing. She's just talking about the scale and pace that we're seeing of solar development on agricultural land.

In my constituency we have a huge development over 700 acres already and then another one of 160 acres just being given permission near Rodmersham. So this is a huge quantity of important agricultural land now being destroyed by these solar developments. Does she agree with me that the government needs to be taking this into account on their guidance on planning decisions so we don't jeopardize our food security?

01:35:49 - 01:36:02

Esther McVey

I do indeed agree with my right honourable friend, and that's precisely why we're having this debate today to impress upon the government what actions they need to take. And I will indeed give way to my neighbour.

01:36:02 - 01:36:39

Speaker 46

I thank my right honourable friend and constituency neighbour for giving way. She's making an excellent and really important speech. Energy security of course is important, but as she has pointed out, we cannot lose sight of the vital importance of food security. And does she agree with me that actually we need action, not words? There has been a lot of people saying that we should prioritize brownfield sites.

It's not enough to say it. We need to make sure that these solar panels are going on brownfield sites, on rooftops before and not building over our prime agricultural land.

01:36:39 - 01:37:04

Esther McVey

I don't know how many thousands of people, tens of thousands of people this government needs to hear saying precisely that before action is taken. Ministers repeatedly state that lower-quality land should be used, but in reality that is not the case, and a growing gap is occurring between policy and practice. I will indeed give way.

01:37:04 - 01:37:28

Speaker 49

I thank the right honourable friend for giving way. The Green Hill Solar Farm in my constituency has just been approved by the Secretary of State. That is going to use 60% of best and most versatile land, it means that arable land will be lost for 60 years in our area. Now local groups are considering trying to do a judicial review because does the honourable lady agree with me it doesn't make sense if the policy says you shouldn't be using this land and then they're going ahead and approving them nonetheless?

01:37:28 - 01:38:06

Esther McVey

Well, I think like most things, this government doesn't actually know what's going on. It talks the talk, but actually doesn't put what it says into practice. In 2025, the Campaign to Protect Rural England found that 59% of England's largest solar farms are located on productive farmland, with almost a third occupying the very best agricultural land. The proposed Tabley Hill solar farm in my constituency is another instance of a large-scale solar development being directed towards some of the country's best agricultural land. I will indeed give way.

01:38:06 - 01:38:42

Sammy Wilson

I thank the member for being very generous. Would she agree with me that apart from rolling over the wishes of local communities, that the ideology driving these solar farms is economically disastrous because we're losing good agricultural land and also environmentally disastrous, because much of this land, which is good prime land, is being destroyed by machinery, by pipelines, by concrete bases, etc., and it's being lost for a generation because this isn't a short-term thing, it's at least 60 years?

01:38:42 - 01:39:06

Esther McVey

I agree with my right honourable, and I will say friend. And I think this government has been blinded by its net-zero zealotry, and it needs to open up its eyes and listen to what the public are saying and us here as the public's representatives. I will indeed give way to my right honourable friend.

01:39:06 - 01:40:03

Speaker 45

I'm grateful to my right honourable friend for giving way, and also applaud her a speech and getting the speech today, the debate today. I do want to say one other thing about this, which is quite vital. We managed reasonably to, finally under against government pressure, get an amendment into the Great British Energy Bill to stop the government buying solar arrays that have been made in Xinjiang, in China, where slave labour is practiced.

Now we know that they simply do not check enough. We have clear evidence now that there are still solar arrays, cheaper, made using slave labour. It's all very well to talk about 300 years ago, but right now we are allowing slave labour to take place, and the minister needs to get to his feet and give us a pledge he'll put in proper checks to stop that filthy trade being part of this disaster that my right honourable friend is eloquently making.

01:40:03 - 01:40:41

Esther McVey

I want to thank my right honourable friend for raising this issue too. I know it's something he spends a lot of time and energy investigating and pursuing this and I'm glad that he's brought his expertise to this debate today. The government has made clear that solar energy will be central to its clean power mission, with solar capacity expected to increase from 17 GW to between 45 and 47 by the end of the decade. However, meeting that target should not come at the expense of the country's agricultural land. I will indeed give way.

01:40:41 - 01:41:28

Adrian Philip Ramsay

Thank you very much to the right honourable lady for giving way. Solar energy must continue to make a huge and growing contribution towards our clean energy future, and this must include far more solar on rooftops and car parks, and a considered approach to the use of land for energy generation. There are competing demands for food production, renewable energy generation, nature and rural livelihoods, and I'm concerned about the lack of an integrated land use framework and strategic spatial energy plan to guide solar expansion, which is resulting in lots of speculative applications. So, does the right honourable lady agree that we must move towards a coordinated spatial strategy that balances energy security, food security and nature recovery, and seeks to enhance all three?

01:41:28 - 01:46:22

Esther McVey

I do indeed agree that the government does need to have oversight of what is going on. At the moment, it seems our farming land and our food security is being put at a lower priority than a sort of a net zero mission and vision. And as we've all agreed, solar panels should be put on appropriate brownfield land, on top of roofs, on industrial land, not on agricultural land. So, does the minister know how much prime agricultural land this government is prepared to sacrifice to meet its green targets? Supposedly, Tabley Solar Farm is a temporary development, yet a scheme expected to remain in place for 40 years is not temporary, and other members have talked about 60 years.

It will determine how this land is used for a generation. Now, I recognise the financial pressures many farmers face, particularly under the government's savage policies, and why the certainty of a long-term income from solar development may be attractive. The fault does not lie with individual farmers, it lies with the system that can make generating electricity more profitable than producing food on some of the country's highest quality agricultural land. There are impacts on tenant farmers threatened with eviction, and further pressure on land values, which makes it harder for new entrants to join the sector and begin farming. Okera, Tabley Hill's developer, points to a community fund that is established, I think it's derisory, £10,000 a year, and that's evidence that it is bringing benefits to the local area.

However, local residents are entitled to ask whether £10,000 a year is proportionate compensation for a development covering 150 acres, occupying green belt agricultural land, and altering the character of the area for decades.

I say, it is not. Community benefit funds have their place, but they should not be treated as a substitute for meaningful community consent or as a suitable replacement for our food security. The burden of this development will not be confined to the site as well. Construction traffic is expected for around two years, with every construction vehicle accessing the site via Chester Road, HGV movements are expected to increase by 60% for up to a year, placing additional pressures on local roads and nearby residents. This is a rural community, and local people are understandably concerned about increased traffic, noise, disruption and the danger of that on these rural roads.

Tabley Hill is about more than one planning application in our constituency. It raises broader questions about how we meet our energy needs without undermining food production, eroding green belt protections and placing unnecessary pressure on rural communities. There are also questions about whether land use for solar farms will or ever could be returned to agricultural use. Many people are questioning that. Many people don't have the answers on that.

I support a balanced energy mix, and I recognize that solar panel has a role to play in future energy, but I do not support the unnecessary loss of some of our highest quality agricultural land when brownfield sites, commercial rooftops, warehouses and industrial land remain available alternatives, as other members have said today. Productive farmland should be protected wherever possible, and these alternatives should be exhausted before land of this quality is taken out of use for a generation, but in my mind, it should never be used. The minister presumably agrees with me about this issue. Solar planning guidance says the planning authority should encourage development of solar farms on non-agricultural land, but that is clearly not strong enough as it is not working. What does the minister propose to do to save our vital agricultural land?

Stopping his government's assault on farmers would be a good start, so will he toughen up official planning policy to protect more agricultural land from solar farm developments? If not, how much agricultural land is he prepared to see lost from our nation's ability to provide food for its people?

01:46:22 - 01:46:24

Christine Jardine

Minister Shanks.

01:46:24 - 01:48:08

Michael Shanks

Thank you very much, Mr. Jardine. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, as always. Can I thank all honourable members for coming to this debate? I will just say at the outset, obviously, many colleagues across the House have come here to raise concerns about projects in their own constituencies. I understand entirely why, but given these are subject to planning processes, I want to say right at the outset, I can't comment on the positives or negatives or decisions that will be raised through the NSIP process for any of those particular applications.

They are rightly for the Secretary of State to make decisions on in due course. I do want to touch on the general points the honourable lady makes in her speech. And first of all, I think just to recognize an area where I think we do have common agreement here, on the fact that infrastructure across our country is necessary, but that it should be built in sensible locations and take account of local impacts. I've said throughout that I find much of the NIMBY debate that has come about in a lot of this a bit redundant in actually trying to bring communities with us. But I've also said very clearly that we need to build infrastructure as a country, and it's not possible to just build all of it somewhere else.

And inevitably in these debates, what we often get back to is this argument that people are in favour of the technology, but just not anywhere near my constituency. And there has to be some common ground somewhere in the middle of that, which recognizes we do need to build infrastructure somewhere.

Solar in particular, and I'll give way to the honourable gentleman in a moment, solar in particular is important because it tackles our energy security, but it's also by far the cheapest to deploy electricity generation in the country at the moment. With affordability as right at the forefront of all of our constituents' minds, it's right and proper that we try to deploy as much as of solar as we possibly can. I'll give way to the honourable gentleman.

01:48:08 - 01:49:08

Graham Stuart

I'm grateful to the minister for giving way, and of course I had his role just two and a half years ago. I think I agree with pretty much everything he's said so far. There is a backlash because we're seeing so much high quality land loss, we're seeing cumulative impact, which again notionally, and I know the government says should be looked at, but it never seems to stop a project, and we're seeing the slave labour supply chains issue. So, I would invite the minister, given that 60% of the land isn't best and most versatile, to tighten up the rules on best and most versatile land, tighten up the rules so that there's the real protection around cumulative, and tighten up the rules on slave labour supply chains. And I think he can still fulfil his ambition to see that infrastructure built, but make sure that we've got a system which is sufficiently rigorous that the communities are quieted.

It won't stop every Nimby in anywhere, but at least it will show reassurance, it will show there are real rules to provide real protection, because right now the absence of it is causing scepticism right across this House and across the country.

01:49:08 - 01:51:32

Michael Shanks

Well, I will come to several of those points. He has always, I think, I hope this doesn't do him a disservice, been more pragmatic than his party on a lot of these issues, and I've always appreciated that. And he's right to see we what we want to try and do is find a place where we build the infrastructure we need, but that we bring communities with us and that we don't turn them away from the energy transition. I think that's really important. I do want to just put some statistics here, because I think individual applications often paint a picture of a much greater use of land across the country than is actually the case.

The land devoted to solar farms at the end of September 2024, which is the latest set of figures I have at this point, is that it covered an estimated 21,000 hectares, which is around 0.1% of total land in the UK. Even in our most ambitious deployment scenarios in the clean power action plan, we expect to get to 0.4% of deployment and 0.6% of agricultural land in the country. So while I recognise there are local impacts of all of these projects, and I speak as a Member of Parliament very close to some of the biggest onshore wind farms that were built under the previous government, I recognise land use is a challenge across communities, but it is nevertheless across the country a very small proportion of land overall. The second point the honourable gentleman raises, which the right honourable gentleman from Chingford I think made earlier on, and he rightly challenges us on this around supply chains. I'd say two things on this.

First of all, it was right that we accepted the amendment, but also set up Great British Energy to be a leader in how we build supply chains that can try to get a supply chain on solar panels here in the UK again, and to do due diligence on supply chains coming in from China. There is much more work to do on that, and I don't pretend that the work is complete yet. Some of the initiatives, like the Solar Stewardship Initiative, I think need to go further to make sure we're really getting into the detail of supply chains. But equally, I would just say, when we left government in 2010, there were three companies building in the solar supply chains in the UK, and when we came back, there were none. And this comes back to a really important part, I think, about re-industrialisation, which is if we want to have supply chain security, if we want to have line of sight on things like human rights, but actually, if we want to create good jobs across the country, we need to invest in the manufacturing capability in this country and nurture it, and not let it go to the wall, which is where we get to particular risks at the moment.

I'll give way to both honourable gentlemen, briefly.

01:51:32 - 01:51:57

Sammy Wilson

Would he accept that one of the reasons why so many UK firms disappear is because they can't compete against firms especially in China who have got cheap labour or labour at no cost at all?

And that's why it's so important that we the government tighten down on where the supplies of these this equipment comes from.

01:51:57 - 01:52:44

Speaker 45

The main point I wanted to make to the right honorable gentleman is that China thwarts all the rules around commerce. They subsidize all their industries. They subsidize the solar array industry. They use slave labor, which we've mentioned already. The thing about the slave labor is America does it in a much cleaner way.

What they do is they force the companies and they assume that those companies are in fact using slave-made solar arrays. They leave it to the company to prove to them with serious checks from places like all these various companies who do it using forensic science that they are not using slave-made solar arrays. Now, the government should look at that and adopt that process. That would kill the supply of slave-made solar arrays tomorrow.

01:52:44 - 01:55:27

Michael Shanks

Yeah, look, I think the right honorable gentleman and he made similar points during the passage of the Great British Energy Bill, and we continue to look at that across government in procurement that we're reviewing right across government investment in these projects, and we do want to incentivize as much as possible supply chains to be here in the UK. I don't accept the point the honorable gentleman makes that cost alone is the reason why we don't have supply chains here in the UK. We have to use the mechanisms we have to encourage that manufacturing to be in the UK, which is why things like the clean industry bonus is about saying alongside Contracts for Difference to build renewable energy in the UK, you can also get investment to make sure the manufacturing is here in the UK as well and the jobs that go with it, but also security at a time where supply chains are absolutely critical. So I think there is more we can do. No doubt it's a challenge.

I absolutely accept that point, but there's more we can do. I want to just come back to two points. The honorable lady the right honorable lady talked about net zero zealotry. I think there is quite a lot of anti-net zero zealotry in this debate as well. And I hope there is, I think at the end of her speech, she said something that I completely agree with.

I hope there is a recognition that solar is part of an energy mix. It's not the entirety of it. We need a mix of technologies. But that the quicker we can get off fossil fuels, the better it is for our energy security in a very uncertain world, as we're all experiencing at the moment, but also to bring down bills. Solar is a crucial part of that.

And although we absolutely want to see solar panels on as many rooftops as possible, and we want to support innovative projects like floating solar, we also recognize ground-mounted solar plays an absolutely critical role in this as well. The honorable, right honorable lady made a number of points about food security, and of course, I absolutely agree with her. Food security is national security. We do need to back British farmers, and agriculture is really important in this country, and it is important that we work to preserve the beauty and the character of rural areas. I understand all of those points, but that is precisely what the planning system exists to do, to weigh up different impacts with opportunities, to look through specific projects, to take account of local views, which are all considered in these processes, and on cumulative impact, to be really clear that a number of projects in a particular area does impact on the at on the nationally significant infrastructure prog project pipeline, and they are taken into account in those processes.

So visual amenity, protected landscapes, natural environment, all of these things are taken into account. And as she rightly says, the planning system already steers developers to use brownfield sites wherever possible, and the development of agricultural land has to only be where absolutely necessary, and even then, it should be lower-grade land used first. I'm Very briefly to the right honorable lady, then I'll have to close.

01:55:27 - 01:55:46

Esther McVey

The minister has heard here today, though, that is not the case, and therefore, I was asking what specific steps he would be taking to tighten up the planning process or have oversight so that what he thinks is happening.

01:55:46 - 01:57:34

Michael Shanks

Well, it's not for me to litigate individual planning applications. That is what the planning system exists for. We've given very clear guidance on this. Of course, we keep these things under review, but we do, at the moment, already have a planning system that takes those things into consideration. I'm not going to open up the debate on individual projects.

And indeed the National Farmers' Union themselves has said that there's no threat to food security as a result of solar. I'd also just point to the most glaring point on all of this, which is clean energy is about us trying to get off fossil fuels. But the reason we're doing that is partly to reduce the exposure to all of our constituents to the bills impact we're seeing. But the summer we've just lived through is also a perfect example of climate change in action, and the impact to food security of not tackling the climate crisis is very clear and present for us as well. And I think to exclude that from the debate is missing the absolutely crucial point here, which is climate change is far more likely to impact our food security in Britain than any infrastructure that we're building.

I've already said to her that I agree on rooftop solar. We should be building much more of that. That's why the Future Homes Standard encourages new houses to be built with solar installed. That's why I'm working to see if we can get even more solar on to warehouses and supermarkets and car parks and everywhere else we possibly can. I'm entirely open to that.

But nevertheless, ground-mount solar will remain important. I also want us to look at much more innovation in how we do farming alongside solar farms. I've visited a number of solar farms where two, the two do go alongside one another, where livestock grazing can go alongside solar deployment. A lot of emerging, I'll just, I don't think I can, I'm sorry. A lot of emerging science in agrivoltaics to develop new ways to make sure we've got arable farming alongside solar.

I'll give way very briefly.

01:57:34 - 01:57:45

Speaker 49

One of the arguments was made that you could have sheep farming, and in the Secretary of State's decision, it actually said it's irrelevant, it wouldn't be considered because they couldn't guarantee it. So, actually, the promise of them sitting side by side is not a guarantee.

01:57:45 - 01:59:20

Michael Shanks

Well, I'm not making any guarantees here. I haven't pretended that I have. I'm saying there is much more opportunity to do these things side by side, and I've visited and seen some of that where it is working, and indeed, actually, a net gain in biodiversity from the deployment of solar panels. I, look, we are clearly in this focus group on solar not going to have supporters from everyone who's spoken in the debate today, and I entirely understand that. But I recognise, as I've said in a number of debates, and I hope fairly, that we do want to try and make sure we bring communities with us on this as much as possible.

The planning system is important. The right honourable lady also rightly talked about community benefits. It is really important that those are meaningful to communities. We'll say more on this very soon about our expectations on developers on community benefits. We want those to genuinely invest in the future of communities, to not be tokenistic.

But it's important to say they are not compensation regimes. They are about saying, you're hosting infrastructure on behalf of the country, we thank you for that, and here is a community benefit. There is much, contrary to what it might seem from my speech, that actually I think we agree on. We do want to preserve the character of the countryside across the country, but I also genuinely believe that we have to rapidly increase the amount of electricity we can generate from clean sources. We do have to make sure that renewables are there alongside nuclear and other technologies, but the balance of doing that alongside continued food production, alongside protecting communities is what the planning system exists to do, and I'm very open to the idea we should continue to look at any further reforms that are necessary.

But I think, at the moment, that balance is absolutely understood, and I hope we can continue this conversation in the manner in which we have today, and I'll give way. Thank you.

01:59:20 - 01:59:33

Christine Jardine

The question is that this House has considered the use of agricultural land for solar panels. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. Order.

01:59:33 - 02:00:13

Speaker 59

Now suspended until 16:30. Order. Tulip Siddiq. Tulip Siddiq to move the motion.

02:00:13 - 02:02:18

Speaker 57

Thank you, Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under you. Gynaecological health should never cost you your livelihood. However, almost a third of women with endometriosis are forced to leave work because of their symptoms. Behind the statistics are heartbreaking stories of women struggling everyday to get the support that they need in the workplace. A defining mission of my time in Parliament, which is coming up to 12 years now, is about making the workplace fairer and safer for women up and down the country.

One of my proudest achievements in Parliament has been leading the campaign for mandatory flexible working rights. And this has enabled parents, particularly women, to thrive at work while balancing their commitments, especially their family commitments. Some people in the House may remember that in 2019, I delayed the birth of my son to vote against Brexit because there was no other option. I had to come into Parliament because there was no way to register the views of my constituents in Hampstead and Kilburn. Now, I was very pleased to say after that proxy voting was brought in,

which means that MPs can now come in and ask someone to vote for them when it's parental absence. But it shouldn't have taken something like that for proxy voting to come in, and it showed the world how inaccessible even Parliament is for women nowadays. I'm pleased to say that the rules have changed, but we still have a long way to go before we can make workplaces more accessible for men, women. So when one of my very brave constituents told me how they were unfairly dismissed from work after many years of loyal service, while suffering from crippling endometriosis, and then had to fight years simply to establish that the law had protected them at all, I was absolutely astounded by her story.

And that's because not a single gynaecological condition is included in the disability guidance of the Equality Act. And I'm, yes.

02:02:18 - 02:02:52

Helen Maguire

I thank the honourable member for giving way. I, too, have a constituent who suffered with endometriosis and has been unable to work as a result, and hasn't received the support that she requires. And whilst the Equality Act protects pregnancy, does my honourable friend agree that it should also protect gynaecological conditions such as endometriosis? And there are other conditions as well, because we know at the moment that 1 in 6 people leave the workplace due to endometriosis, because they just experience apathy, lack of understanding, etc. And it's really important that we empower women to work with conditions like endometriosis.

02:02:52 - 02:04:13

Speaker 57

I thank my honourable member for her intervention. I think it's very important what she says about people not quite understanding what endometriosis is actually about. And I have to say, when my constituent came to me and started talking to me about her situation and her case at work, I have to say, I had to look it up as well, because if you haven't personally suffered from it yourself, it can be very easy to just dismiss as something that isn't crippling your life. But it does cripple your life, and I will go on to a few points that the honourable member makes as well in my speech.

And the reason I'm standing here today is because of my constituent who is in the gallery today and who led the petition that received over 110,000 signatures calling for this to be changed, a formidable campaigner who I'm proud to say lives in our constituency. The statutory guidance on the definition of disability does name Ménière's disease, epilepsy, schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder and certain types of depression as examples of conditions where effects are fluctuating or recurring, but it is silent on endometriosis. It is silent on fibroids. It's silent on PMOS, PMDD, conditions that affect millions of women and whose effects are by their very nature cyclical and recurring. And in response,

02:04:13 - 02:04:59

Jim Shannon

Can I commend the honorable lady for bringing this forward and the merits of having a debilitating gynaecological conditions like endometriosis to the quality list are clear. But it would legally guarantee woman the reasonable workplace adjustments they need to stay in employment. But does the honourable lady not agree that this means very little if the underlying healthcare system is failing? For us back home, and it's not the minister's responsibility, but back home, we were finding ourselves where the care is so severely limited, women in my constituency are trapped in agonizing waiting lists, or forced to pay thousands to travel across the water here for surgery simply because the care does not exist at home. So, does the honourable lady agree that protecting women at work is only half the battle, there's still a lot to do in the healthcare system?

02:04:59 - 02:18:24

Speaker 57

I thank my honourable friend for his intervention. I'm pleased to see him at every debate in the chamber, and he hasn't stopped doing that, and he's always fighting for the rights of women in any of the debates that we have, and he's absolutely right to say that we do need to settle what's happening in the workplace, but we've got to look at the health care system as well, and make sure that it doesn't become a postcode lottery so that women have to travel in order to get treatment, because it should be available for everyone. So, in response to my constituent's petition, the Government acknowledged that these conditions can affect women's performance at work, but it said it had no plans to amend the guidance. And that's why I'm standing here today, urging my colleagues in Government to reconsider this decision, because when a women's condition is missing from the guidance, she starts every conversation with her employer and also her HR department and every claim that she has on the back foot. And that's because courts and tribunals must take the guidance into account.

HR departments and managers will use it as their checklist. It opens the door to legal protection, to fairer workplace adjustments, and a fairer system for millions of women across the country. Last month, members of this House may have seen that the APPG on Endometriosis published its Endometriosis Not in the Workplace Report. And if everyone looks at the results, they are sobering. They're gathering evidence from more than 6,000 employers with confirmed or suspected endometriosis and 250 employers, and the inquiry provides one of the most detailed pictures yet of the condition's impact on working life.

These are some of the facts. 97% of employees worked with severe pain. 94% believed employers lacked understanding of the condition. 62% were worried about losing their job. 47% had lost income, and 39% were experiencing financial hardship.

49% had difficulties progressing in their career after the condition. 28% had been forced to leave their job altogether. 49% had received no workplace adjustments at all. And 72% of employers said they had no training and no guidance on women's health conditions, such as endometriosis. So, it's I think it's fair to say that women with endometriosis have been failed by employment rights system.

And it's damaging their lives, damaging their families, damaging the economy with only 11% of employers in the UK having a menstrual health policy. Employers are not making the reasonable adjustments to accommodate people with endometriosis who are then forced to suffer in silence.

And this is a shocking statistic that highlights why there is such widespread discrimination of women with endometriosis. And that's why I think we need to have gynaecological conditions, which must be included as impairments with fluctuating or recurring effects in the Equality Act 2010 guidance on the actual definition of disability, because I believe, by doing so, we strengthen workplace protections for women with disabling gynaecological conditions, including endometriosis, including fibroids, including PMOS, PMDD, severe menopausal symptoms and other menstrual disorders. One of the biggest challenges we have, and this is a lot that I've learned from my constituent as well who suffers from this, is the unpredictable nature of these conditions. So, women can experience severe pelvic pain. They can have debilitating fatigue.

They can have heavy bleeding leading to anaemia. They have bowel and bladder symptoms. They have bloating. They have nausea. They have loss of appetite and other complications that can fluctuate in severity.

A woman with endometriosis, for example, one day may be able to function absolutely fine, but the next day cannot get up from her bed. And this is something that employers should be taking into account. This is overwhelmingly evidenced in medical statistics, which my constituents tell me is being ignored by employers because these conditions are not listed in the guidance, which is what we're trying to fight for. I would therefore ask the minister, who I know is passionate about this topic and has been in touch with me about it, to consider four practical steps. Firstly, updating the Equality Act 2010 guidance.

It is issued by a minister under section 6 of the Equality Act, so no primary legislation is needed. Gynaecological conditions should be named among the existing examples of conditions which are recurring of fluctuating effects with worked examples of what a flare could look like in a working day: pain that stops a woman travelling, pain that stops a woman standing up or concentrating, heavy bleeding, fatigue or anaemia or recovery from surgery. Secondly, I would ask the minister to look at the EHRC guidance to set out in its employment code examples of reasonable adjustments for these conditions, such as flexible and hybrid working, adjusted hours on bad days, access to facilities and rest breaks, time off for medical conditions and a phased return from surgery. As I'm listing these, it seems incredulous that women aren't allowed this and are having to fight for this. Of course you should have a phased return after surgery.

But the fact is, lots of women don't have that option in the workplace. A lot of these things would cost little or nothing, but would make the lives of those who are suffering so much easier. Thirdly, I would ask the minister to give employees something tangible to take back to their managers or to HR. A simple standard workplace adjustments passport backed by Acas guidance would record what has been agreed, so that a woman does not have to explain her condition over and over again, which is exhausting in itself, every time her manager changes, and so that managers know exactly what is expected of them.

Fourthly, I would build on the Employment Rights 2025. Large employers will soon have to publish equality action plans that includes support for employees who are going through the menopause. The Those plans which are going to be published should extend to menstrual and gynecological health and the government's Keep Britain Working agenda and workplace health system should expressly include the women with these long-term fluctuating conditions. And of course, these changes would not only help women with these conditions, but everyone living with a non-visible chronic condition whose effects come and go. This basic change could save jobs and so much money, and especially, save so much anxiety for countless women across the country who are being disabled by endometriosis and not given reasonable adjustments in the workplace.

And by doing so, we can be a government that ensures women have workplace protections and the right to reasonable adjustments for their condition. The Minister will know, I was a part of the Treasury, so the economy is always on my mind. So, this is not just a question of fairness. For me, this is actually about a strong economy and sound business. Endometriosis alone is estimated to cost the UK economy 8.2 billion pounds a year in treatment, in lost work, and healthcare costs.

The ONS found that women with endometriosis earned about 4,500 pounds less over the five years after receiving a diagnosis. The Fawcett Society found that one in ten women who work during the menopause has left a job because of their symptoms, and many others worked on reduced hours. The PMDD Project found that nine in ten reported that PMDD significantly or extremely affected their everyday life, particularly employment. They can be perceived as unreliable, inconsistent, or unable to manage their workload, when in reality they are living with a recognised, and most often, severely disabling condition. I'm sure the Minister will agree that women are a vital part of our workforce and our economy, and it's right that the law and guidance explains it, and it reflects the reality of their everyday lives.

Employment lawyers who act in these cases describe the same pattern again and again. Very senior women in whom businesses have invested, year after year, training, client development, are managed out after surgery or a period of sickness absence, when a phased return, a flexible pattern of working, a modest change to their duties could have retained them and helped our economy at the same time. The business lose their skills, their client relationships, and everything that has been invested in them. It then pays to recruit and train a replacement, and very often, pays again to defend a claim. And those claims can take years.

So, at the end of June this year, there were 70,000 single claims waiting in employment tribunals, the highest number on record. The average claim takes well over a year to resolve, with some final hearings being listed for 2028 and 2029. With appeals if a case could run three years or more, think about the damage to the economy, to the business, and particularly to the morale of all our women who we need back in the economy, working for our country. It's three years of legal cost for both the employer and former employee, three years of uncertainty, anxiety for all the women, and three years in neither the business nor the woman can move, crippling the economy, crippling the business, and often crippling the woman's life.

The cases that do reach the courts show what is at stake. In South Gloucestershire Council v Handle decided by the employment appeal tribunal in 2024, a social worker with endometriosis who the tribunal found was managing complex cases well, despite her disability, had her placement ended because of the absences caused by her medical condition. Her manager had suggested adjustments, working from home and spreading her four-day week over five days. Neither was tried and an occupational health referral was not even considered. The tribunal found that ending her engagement could not be justified and that the appeal tribunal agreed.

In another case, sorry, the tribunal accepted that a woman with endometriosis could not walk, stand, or drive when her symptoms flared, and the condition left her anaemic, exhausted and unable to sleep. It found she was disabled, observing that nothing in the Equality Act requires a disability to be constant. This is exactly the point that guidance should be made plain so that women do not have to waste time, effort and mental energy going to a tribunal to establish it. Reasonable adjustments are the most effective way to avoid all of this. They keep women in work.

They protect the employer's investment. They stop claims arising in the first place and prevention is far cheaper than cure. So for a for as long as our employment rights ignore the gynaecological conditions of millions of women in Britain, the injustice will continue. Making reasonable adjustments is simply the fairest thing to do. It is also economically the most sensible thing to do.

Naming these conditions in the guidance would give every woman something concrete to point to and every employer a clear basis on which to act. It would save money. It would save time and most importantly it would spare women, their families and their employers so much avoidable pain. The benefits of doing so spreads beyond the workplace for all of us in society. It will improve mental health and the wellbeing of women by being seen, heard, protected and able to advocate for themselves.

The guidance will also help DWP assessors who are rejecting claims from women with endometriosis and other gynaecological conditions. So for me, this is a win-win because it will protect women in the economy, in education, in healthcare, the workplace and beyond. So, I'm urging colleagues in government to recognize what women experience every single day, and I believe it's time to end this discrimination once and for all.

02:18:24 - 02:18:39

Christine Jardine

Can I remind members that they should bob if they wish to be called in the debate. The question is that this House has considered the potential merits of adding gynaecological conditions to Equality Act 2010 guidance. Alec Shelbrooke.

02:18:39 - 02:23:30

Alec Edward Shelbrooke

Thank you Mrs Jardine and a pleasure to serve under your chairship today. May I congratulate the honourable member on an excellent opening speech, which has covered off so many of the aspects that we've spoken about for so many years. I think I've started to raise the issues of endometriosis about a decade ago in this very room. And again, just like the honourable lady, this came to my attention by someone coming to see me in a constituency surgery. But actually then realized I had a close friend whose wife had suffered from this from her teen years.

And of course what strikes you straightaway is just that comment that so many people don't know about this condition. And I think therein lies one of the great problems.

I remember when I first started doing this getting lots of comments about why are you bringing this up as a man, which I always found a particularly strange comment because surely we're elected to represent all of our constituents, and certainly well over 50% of my constituents are women. But I think it spoke to a greater problem that people don't understand women's health needs. And women's health needs are exceptionally different to men's. The reality is, men cannot empathise. They can sympathise, but they cannot empathise because they're unlikely through their lives to suffer with chronic diseases from teenage years right the way through to adult.

I mean you can have endometriosis way after the menopause. This is not something to do with being of a fertile age. This is And also, the endometrium growing is not necessarily just linked to having a uterus, et cetera. It can spread to other parts of the body. The honourable lady outlined some of the problems, but I just want to get, if I can, just a little bit more graphic.

And I'm sorry for this Mrs Jardine, but I want to try and paint that picture of what some of these conditions might mean. Now, when you're getting into stage 3, stage 4 endometriosis, there is probably a real chance that it's invaded your digestive system. And it can indeed be some of the times that it actually starts to really become apparent that you've got those problems. And by this time it's a long way down the line. Now, I'm sure everybody in this room has suffered from a food poisoning or an upset stomach, and I don't want to be too graphic, but you cannot get off the toilet.

We all know what it's like and it's horrific thing. We stay at home. We take our salts and our fluids, and we work our way through it for 24 hours, and we feel a bit rotten for a couple of days, and then we go back to work. That's what happens. But this happens all the time when someone has reached that level of the disease that they don't know if they're sitting at work that they suddenly have to rush to the bathroom.

It's one thing, I think, people recognise that people may get heavy bleeding, and how embarrassing that can be as a teenage girl through having endometriosis. But the very fact that you may just soil yourself without realising is a great problem. And it needs sympathetic employers to be able to arrange an office space so that if someone's working with them, they can actually position things that there is that ability to go to the toilet quickly. There is an understanding from fellow employees. And But also to make sure that employers recognise this.

Now, I don't want to dwell on this too long because I know there's so many other people want to speak. Education does play an important point. That's how I didn't know, but it shocked me to be working with some girls who were born in the 21st century who didn't know about this. And if this is taught in schools to all sexes, then that understanding will come through. And because it's easy if people don't know what a disease is, to try and dismiss it and say, "This person just takes time off work.

Women get heavy periods. Let's just, you know, they're just a malingerer, they're not doing anything." It does need to be a protected part of the Disability Bill, spoken about this for so long. Because, and I'm very proud to be the chairman of the board of the Endometriosis Foundation, and our brilliant CEO Carla Cressy, who's got stage 4 endometriosis, has done so much to support people. But the research we showed, you know, 90% of people have a mental health impact.

50% of women think about taking their lives. And, unfortunately, maybe about 30 women a year do take their lives. This is how serious this subject is. And if I can just leave one message today, is that just think about it. Think about it if you're an employer, think about a man, that if you had to go to work every day, and whilst you were sat at your desk, you don't know if just suddenly, you may soil yourself.

Just think about that, and think about how you should be dealing with people who suffer from this terrible disease.

02:23:30 - 02:23:37

Christine Jardine

If I could ask members to stick to an informal limit of three minutes please, where possible. Imogen Walker.

02:23:37 - 02:26:17

Imogen Walker

Thank you, Mrs. Jardine. It's a pleasure to serve under you. And I'm very grateful to my honorable friend for securing this debate. The question she raises is an excellent one, because we can see very clearly that there is a troubling difference in the care delivered for women's conditions and those of the general population, and I have raised this with my local NHS board. Health is, as you know, devolved in Scotland, but equalities is not, and I'm open to any solution that will help the women and girls in my constituency get the health care that they need when they need it.

When I met NHS Lanarkshire in November 25, we discussed waiting lists. I was told that the board aimed to eliminate two-year waits by spring. That's progress, I thought, relatively speaking, but there was a catch. The exception was gynaecology. So, I wrote to them to ask what the plan was, and I was told that it was difficult and challenging, but they weren't able to share a plan, and nor did they confirm that ensuring women received the same levels of healthcare as men was a priority.

They are operating in very difficult circumstances, it is true, and the SNP-led Scottish Government must take their share of responsibility, but this exception is not the answer. For endometriosis, the average wait in England is 9 years and 4 months, and in Scotland, it is 10 years and 2 months. That is more than a decade of pain and more, as my honorable friend has described so well, and the dreams that young women so rightly have for themselves can be lost in this process, which is devastating. Many of us have heard somebody say, "Well, if men suffered from this, they would have found a cure." But there is an even more modest question that we also need to ask, which is: what do we need to do to make sure that women get the treatment that already exists?

Women are not born to endure. They are not born to accept pain or incapacitation as part of the feminine experience. When they are ill, they shouldn't be dismissed, they shouldn't be told, and this happens at every stage of life, quite frankly, that it's their age, or if it's really bad, they can take a paracetamol. And these examples are and have been far too familiar to too many women for far too long. So we all know that these problems run deep, and my honorable friend has cut to the heart of the issue.

02:26:17 - 02:26:28

Speaker 67

Much more needs to be done. It shouldn't take a rewriting of the Equalities Act to make it happen, but she is right to ask the question, and I thank her for it.

02:26:28 - 02:26:30

Christine Jardine

Hannah Spencer.

02:26:30 - 02:29:54

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

Thank you, Chair. So, a few weeks ago, I posted a video sharing some of what I'm learning about endometriosis, and the response was absolutely heartbreaking. My comments were full of people sharing their experiences: years of pain of being dismissed by doctors, struggling to get a diagnosis, and then, on top of that, trying to hold down a job, to get their employers to understand. I heard about lives turned upside-down by a condition that they have no control over and very little support with, and I hear the same stories from people in Gorton as well. And what gets me the most is that it does not have to be this way.

All that is needed is for women's pain and the pain of those who were assigned female at birth to be taken seriously by the doctors that serve them, by the employers that they work for, and by the government that represents them. And yet, instead, as is so often the case throughout history, it ends up being down to the people most affected who are left to fight for the change that they deserve.

Despite the pain and debilitating symptoms of endometriosis, they're the ones coming up with the ideas, solutions and plans. They are the experts, and we all should be listening. One in six women with endometriosis leave the workplace due to their condition. Almost half say that they've struggled to progress in their careers because of endometriosis, and almost half hadn't received workplace adjustments. Almost half had lost income.

And despite endometriosis affecting one in 10 women, it's rarely effectively taught at medical schools as part of the curriculum, leaving future healthcare practitioners without the necessary knowledge. Those with endometriosis in Gorton and Denton, and in every constituency across the country, are losing money, missing out on opportunities and struggling to stay in employment, not because they don't want to work, but because the support simply isn't there. And we're talking about basic, practical help that could help make the difference between someone staying in work and having to give it up completely. And good employers want guidance, they want advice on flexible working, on time off for medical appointments, extra breaks or a phased return after surgery. Good employers want to help their staff so that their businesses can perform to their highest potential.

We need a government that will finally listen to and act on lived experience by adding gynaecological conditions, such as endometriosis, to the Equality Act 2010 guidance on the definition of disability. These conditions are long term, often lifelong, and by definition, they fluctuate and reoccur, meeting the criteria for disability. And there must be specificity in the guidance to ensure employees disabled by debilitating chronic conditions such as this are supported with reasonable adjustments and legally protected against workplace discrimination. And to Shanjida Paul, who has campaigned for so long and so hard on this, as well as the tireless work of countless other organisations, and to everyone for sharing their experiences and who are out there fighting for change, thank you. This debate is titled The Potential Merits of Adding Gynaecological Conditions to Equality Act 2010 Guidance, but I think the people living with these conditions would find it pretty shocking that we even have to debate the merits.

The debate should be how much longer we can afford not to. Thank you.

02:29:54 - 02:29:56

Christine Jardine

Gill Furniss.

02:29:56 - 02:32:37

Gill Furniss

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairpersonship, and I thank my honourable friend for the Member for Hampstead and Highgate for bringing forward this very important debate. Seven years ago, I was sat in this very room for a debate on endometriosis workplace support, in which the much-missed David Amess announced that the endometriosis APG, APPG, would be launching an inquiry into the state of care. And I also would like at this point to thank the MP for Wetherby and Easingwold for all the work that he has put in over these years. I wish I could say that I cannot believe we are having that same debate again. And yet I know from the countless emails I have received from women across the country about their experiences that many of the issues identified by the APPG all those years ago still persist.

One constituent recently reached out to me, having been repeatedly bedridden as a result of her pain. She spoke about a fruitless struggle to access healthcare that had left her untreated and worried about keeping her job down. Some changes have been made in the right direction, but we cannot ignore the evidence telling us that support is not reaching far enough. A recent Endometriosis APPG call for evidence found that less than half of respondents with the condition had received any workplace adjustments, yet 80% of employers giving evidence supported changes to guidance that explicitly recognise the condition as meeting the definition of the disability.

Our workplaces are clearly willing to make adjustments, but the guidance is failing them, as well as the people it is supposed to safeguard. The Government and the Equality and Human Rights Commission must review the guidance so that it clearly reflects chronic and fluctuating conditions like endometriosis, so I will ask the Minister to look carefully at the APPG's findings and consider whether the guidance for employers should now be reviewed. I have two further questions. Will the Minister work with the Equality and Human Rights Commission and Acas on practical guidance that covers support before a diagnosis and the fair handling of short recurring absences? Secondly, as the Government develop the workplace health system, will the Minister ensure that endometriosis and other fluctuating menstrual health conditions are part of that work?

Women have waited long enough to be believed by their doctors; they should not have to wait any longer to be supported by their employers.

02:32:37 - 02:32:38

Sureena Brackenridge.

02:32:38 - 02:36:57

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Mrs Jardine. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I'm truly grateful to my honourable friend for securing this important debate and everybody else who's worked and championed this who join us in the gallery. We all know that for far too long women's conditions have been often dismissed, not a priority, in some cases misunderstood. Some might say it's down to misogyny that's baked in within the system. But these conditions truly impact every lever of a woman's life, right from very early girls, teenage years, all the way to when you're supposed to be wise and full of wisdom, not necessarily so in some cases.

But the conditions are fluctuating, and I think that's part of the reason why employers out there take the opportunity to not have to address reasonable adjustments. In fact, reasonable adjustments are often faced by unreasonable expectations from employees. The scale of the challenge remains significant. So I welcome in Wolverhampton's NHS Trust waiting lists are coming down, and over 5,800 people in Wolverhampton were waiting for treatment this summer, which is an improvement from 6,462 the year before, but you can see the scale that we are still facing. I do welcome the Government's action on the renewed women's health strategy, but I do call for levers across government departments to push faster.

Today's debate is more about it's more than just healthcare; it's also about employment and workplace protections, as we've heard. Too often the support depends on whether an employer understands and has the resources to support what an individual is going through. That's really inconsistent and actually can lead to further harm for the individual. The Equality Act already provides important protections where a condition meets the legal definition of disability, however many women find themselves in a grey area where their condition significantly affects everyday life, but the support remains inconsistent. And that is why I believe there is a strong case for explicitly referencing gynaecological conditions within the Equality Act guidance.

Clearer guidance would support employers to be better employers, to better understand conditions such as endometriosis, fibroids, PCOS, and menopause. It would encourage those earlier conversations. It will reduce stigma, and it will support reasonable adjustments that are needed. And in many cases, those adjustments are straightforward, whether that is flexible working, time off for specialist appointments, temporary changes to working patterns, or maybe some flexibility with home working. So I ask the Minister, will she work with the Equality and Human Rights Commission, employers, and women's health organisations to consider how Equality Act guidance can better reflect the realities faced by women living within with these conditions?

Women have waited long enough to have these conditions recognised. We are making progress in health care, and that progress should be welcomed, but now we have an opportunity to ensure that the support extends beyond hospitals and GP surgeries and into workplaces too.

02:36:57 - 02:36:58

Michelle Welsh.

02:36:58 - 02:40:32

Michelle Welsh

Thank you, Chair. I congratulate the member for Hampstead and Highgate on securing this debate. I speak as the chair of the PCOS APPG, and as a woman living with PCOS and endometriosis, I feel like I somehow won the cup when I got both of those somehow. One in eight women suffer from PCOS in the UK. Yet, despite how common it is, it remains poorly understood, underdiagnosed, and too often overlooked.

The World Health Organization estimates up to 70% of women affected globally remain undiagnosed. And both those figures are women waiting for answers. For me, diagnosis took over 18 years. During those years, I developed an eating disorder, I became bulimic, I experienced depression, I lost confidence. I passed out in sixth form on so many occasions.

I lost the feelings in my leg and my legs, and when I went to the GP, he told me over and over again it's all part and parcel of being a woman, take some paracetamols. And I share that because we must understand what delayed diagnosis actually costs. It reaches into your relationship with food, your mental health, your working life, and your sense of self. Failing to diagnose does not make the condition disappear. It leaves women managing its consequences without the explanation, treatment, or support they deserve.

PCOS affects more than fertility. It can affect metabolism, periods, mental health. It increases the risk of conditions including type 2 diabetes. Earlier diagnosis provides an opportunity to manage those risks and offer support sooner. Instead, women can spend years questioning themselves when the system should be asking the right questions.

Those failures do not fall equally either. This condition disproportionately affects women from South Asian and Black backgrounds, and those on lower incomes, yet access to diagnosis and support remains inconsistent. Without greater awareness, existing inequalities in health can translate into inequalities in employment, career progression, and economic opportunity. I can't tell you the amount of times I would have a sleepless night before an exam, or a driving test, or anything important, worried that day I would be too ill to stand up and do it.

A woman's income, ethnicity or postcode should never determine whether she is heard or helped. We must tackle racism, language barriers and unequal access to care. For someone on an insecure contract, attending an appointment could mean losing wages. Asking for flexibility can feel like risking a job. Advice to seek support means little if that support is beyond her reach.

And I ask the minister for early diagnosis, access to psychological support, targeted action on inequalities and clear workplace guidance. Changing the name of PCOS to PMOS must be matched by changing women's experience. I cannot get those 18 years back, but we can stop another generation enduring the same weight, the same pain and the same anguish. Greater awareness of PMOS and endometriosis in the workplace can help ensure that women are supported, valued and able to thrive at work, rather than being forced to choose between managing their health and progressing in their careers. No woman should have to lose her health, her confidence or her future before the system finally decides to believe her and act.

02:40:32 - 02:40:34

Christine Jardine

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Marie Goldman.

02:40:34 - 02:45:02

Marie Goldman

Thank you, Mrs Jardine. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. I'd also like to congratulate the honourable member for Hampstead and Highgate on securing this really important debate. And I'd also like to join other members from across the House in congratulating and commending the campaigners, some of whom are in the gallery, for the incredible work that they do of this on behalf not just of themselves, but all women, I would say, across the country, indeed internationally. Millions of women face the difficulty and pain of managing gynaecological conditions such as endometriosis, adenomyosis, fibroids and PMDD, and the list could go on and on.

It's obvious that more must be done to rapidly speed up diagnosis times and provide effective care and accommodations to those with these often incredibly debilitating conditions. The impacts of these conditions on women's everyday lives extend, as we've heard, to education, to employment and to fertility, with some women leaving work altogether because they can't obtain the support that they need. We can't, indeed we mustn't, accept this as normal. My Liberal Democrat colleagues and I believe there's merit in treating these conditions in the same way as cancer, as HIV and multiple sclerosis, which are deemed to be disabilities under the Equality Act 2010 from the point of diagnosis, without the need to meet the functional test. I therefore urge the government to examine this further.

But as we've heard, even diagnosis is appallingly slow, and women's symptoms are too often normalised or dismissed across all health conditions. I've heard outrageous stories of women's persistent health concerns being dismissed with sometimes incredibly sexist comments attached. One young woman described to me fairly recently a particularly awful example where she was explaining to a consultant how she felt physically sick because of her persistent stomach pain. In the instance that she was describing, it was a case whilst she was out shopping with friends, only to be dismissed by the doctor who replied, and I quote, "Oh yes, I often feel sick when out shopping with my wife." With groan, indeed, the groans from the audience, that actually happened.

With grossly outdated and misplaced attitudes like this, it's hardly surprising that it takes an average of almost 10 years to receive an endometriosis diagnosis in the UK. Recent research by Endometriosis UK has shone a light on the extent of the impact of this particular condition. In a recent report, the charity found that 97% of those surveyed worked while experiencing severe pain. It's no wonder that almost half of all those with endometriosis said it had made it difficult to progress in their career, whilst 28% had to leave their job altogether because of it. That same survey found that employers overwhelmingly want to help, but with little guidance and facing the everyday pressures of running a business, the support for these women often just isn't there.

This is costing women in pain, in missed career opportunities and ultimately in dignity.

My Liberal Democrat colleagues and I have written to the Minister for Women's Health on several occasions to raise the urgent need to improve care for women with gynaecological conditions. The Government knows that health-related economic inactivity costs the UK 212 billion pounds every year. Even if we only think about this in such crude economic terms, the action needed here pays for itself. Indeed, one NHS Confederation report that found that for every one pound spent on obstetrics and gynaecology, the estimated return on investment was 11 pounds. It must surely follow that tackling NHS waiting times for gynaecological services should be a top priority.

That's why it was so disappointing that the Women's Health Strategy contained no specific measurable time-bound target to reduce the backlogs in endometriosis care, whilst the NHS 10-year health plan did not include endometriosis, adenomyosis, PCOS or fibroids in its prevention agenda. Without clear direction from Government, we risk consigning more women to even longer waits and prolonged, unnecessary pain. That's why I was proud Liberal Democrats introduced an amendment to the health bill that would have ensured that the average wait time for endometriosis and other women-specific conditions is no longer than the average wait time for other elective conditions in the NHS. This would be a meaningful step towards equality in women's healthcare. And finally, we know what gets measured gets done in the NHS.

I hope the Minister takes this away and conducts a serious examination of adding gynaecological conditions to the Equality Act 2010 guidance. We owe it to these women to do all we can to tackle this injustice. Thank you.

02:45:02 - 02:45:05

Christine Jardine

Opposition spokesperson, Joy Morrissey.

02:45:05 - 02:50:25

Joy Morrissey

Thank you, Mrs. Georgiou, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I am grateful for all those here today who have, and I welcome this opportunity to discuss this very important issue, and I thank all members for their contributions today. And I'd like to thank the campaigners that are here today for raising this, and also the ladies in the gallery studying from UCL for public health. That's wonderful, we need more women bringing these issues to the forefront of our public health agenda, so thank you for that. And this is something that is very close to my heart, Madam Chairman.

It's something that I've suffered from, and I suffered in silence for a very long time, and often times you're told that it's just a lady's problem and you can just sort of continue on, and nothing, you know, as take it, take a paracetamol, you'll be fine. And it is not the case, and it is debilitating, and one often needs surgery, multiple surgeries, and it is a difficult one to explain to one's employers, one's even spouse, or, you know, whoever you're with. It's a very difficult thing because you can carry on as a normal human being, and it is there, some days, completely debilitating your every day existence. So I am I'm very sympathetic to this debate and the need for women's gynaecological issues to be brought to the fore- forefront of public health. And I think that it's a particularly warm and welcome development that the NHS is recognising biological sex, because I think it is important for biological females with these particular endometriosis, ovarian issues, cystic, but all the things that women, specifically biological females are suffering from, have been neglected over the years.

And I feel that, and I don't know, Madam Chairman, if this is just my experience, but it was very difficult in the NHS. It was a very long waitlist or just told that perhaps I didn't have endometriosis, and needed to go back to just taking some paracetamol to get over what I was what was wrong with me. And indeed I did have endometriosis, and it was not found out until I had surgery. And I know that there are so many women who are suffering from the exact same thing who are being told just wait, you'll be fine, it's just your own personal issue, you're just, you know, take a paracetamol, you'll feel better soon, and it actually just gets worse and worse over time.

And I want to make sure that women have access to the same public health needs that everyone has. And those things have fallen through the cracks, Madam Chairman, over the years, and that is why I wanted to raise them today in this debate. And the reality is that women have to endure debilitating pain, uncertainty or discrimination simply because of a condition that too often is misunderstood or dismissed, a reality where overall waiting times for appointments for a gynaecological specialist is higher than they were the month before, the year before, since the last general election. And women are waiting a very long time just to see a gynaecologist, just to see just for those basic things to be checked, and then the referral process just takes years and years. And it's debilitating, and many women just give up.

And the reality that so many women face this level of waiting within the NHS is something that I know many across this House have tried to change. And I'd like to pay tribute to David Amess for starting the APPG on Endometriosis, and really raising this for across the House, this important issue. And conditions not just of endometriosis, but of polycystic ovary syndrome and heavy menstrual bleeding can have a profound impact on women's lives. They can affect their ability to work, their education, their relationships, and their mental well-being. And just recently, I heard a powerful story from a brave young woman called Sofia.

Sofia shared with me that she is suffering from extreme pain that can affect her ability to attend school. She's in secondary school. This took a lot of courage for her to talk to me about this. But she faces the refrain again and again of "It's just period pain, you'll be fine, it's just period pain." A phrase that too many young women hear for conditions like endometriosis.

That is because our NHS has been too distracted by other realities to not put women's health at the forefront of care and prioritisations. And for women with endometriosis, the average wait for this diagnosis is around nine years. And this nine years of uncertainty, pain, and in many cases being told that their symptoms are simply part of being a woman. I hope that we can work together today to bring forward a solution that will help put women's health at the forefront of care moving forward. Thank you.

02:50:25 - 02:50:27

Christine Jardine

Minister.

02:50:27 - 02:51:20

Speaker 80

It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs Jardine. I will endeavor to talk at pace so I can cover everyone's point and respond accordingly. Can I start by thanking my honourable friend, the member for Hampstead and Highgate, for bringing forward this important debate on a serious issue faced by so many women and girls. I'm sure we can all agree you spoke extremely passionately, and I want to personally thank you for your ongoing efforts in this campaign and to extend my thanks to campaigners here and acknowledge the challenges her constituent, Sanju Pal, has faced leading to her to bring forward the petition to urge gynaecological conditions, apologies, to the Equalities Act 2010 guidance.

02:51:20 - 02:52:11

Speaker 79

Thank you for sharing your stories and everybody's contributions. It's something that I'm personally very passionate about, and the stats speak for themselves and I'm not going to repeat them. But we all know that behind every statistic is a woman potentially suffering in silence, is a woman that is getting dismissed, is a woman that needs support. And this government recognizes the difficulties and pain that women and girls face in managing symptoms related to gynaecological conditions. As highlighted in this debate today, we know that menstrual and reproductive health issues can have a significant impact on the physical and mental well-being of women and girls, including participation in the workplace.

02:52:11 - 02:54:21

Speaker 80

The struggle is real, and I have felt it myself so I can relate to the opposition spokesperson and to the sponsor member, just a personal thank you for your efforts inside this House as well, cuz I've definitely personally reaped the benefits from the campaigns that have happened internally so I can vote by proxy, for example, when I've been struggling with my health. As a government, we don't believe that anyone in this country should have to choose between managing their health and pursuing their career. This government is committed to protecting the rights of women against unlawful discrimination in the workplace and ensuring they have access to redress. As members will know, depending on the circumstances, the Equality Act already provides protection from discrimination on the grounds of sex, age or disability. The Equalities Act definition of disability focuses on, the most part, on how a condition affects a person's day-to-day life rather than listing specific conditions or impairments.

This flexibility is important to allow the law to cover a vast range of conditions as well as avoiding the risk of excluding changing, fluctuating, or progressive conditions that impact individuals differently. In to In response to specific requests on guidance, she and members may be aware that government intends to produce guidance explaining how the law protects against combined discriminations, and we can, of course, consider how gynaecological conditions can form part of this. And I will ensure that is considered effectively. However, alongside this, and I know she made noises to this effect, she will agree, and others will, that this issue can be addressed more effectively and quickly through ongoing efforts to help employers themselves take more effective steps to support health and well-being of their female employees, strengthening rights related to sick leave and flexible working and improving how the health system addresses these conditions as well. Of course.

02:54:21 - 02:54:22

Alec Shelbrooke.

02:54:22 - 02:55:00

Alec Edward Shelbrooke

Backing to a Minister, Mrs. Jardine. And I'm listening very carefully to what the Minister is saying, and I don't doubt for one second her belief in the policy moving forward. But where I have my concern, and it's just concern, is that by putting it into the Act, then employers recognize it's specifically there, whereas saying that the Act can deal with it is still a bit opaque, and I think that's been one of the problems that's taken place. The specificity of what we want to bring in, or the honourable lady said, is to try and make employers recognize just how serious this situation is.

02:55:00 - 03:00:05

Speaker 80

I thank you for that intervention and accept that making it clearer will absolutely help. I think it should be considered as part of the combined discrimination guidance which is going to be considered to reassure members. And I do think it's important to stress what else the government is doing to address these important issues, because this debate has been quite healthy in reflecting, actually, this being a wider issue and it not just being on legislation despite that being important.

We want to encourage employers to implement workplace adjustments, which has been raised by several members in the debate, to help women remain in work and thrive in their careers, something which this government is committed to, not just because it's the right thing to do, because equality, as so many have already pointed out, is a precondition to our economic success. By creating more supportive and informed workplaces, we can help ensure that women with endometriosis and women experiencing other health conditions can remain in work, progress in their careers and reach their full potential. That is why there is a great deal of action being taken by this government to improve the support and protections available to women experiencing symptoms relating to gynecological conditions. In April earlier this year, Mrs. Frost-Trupp was, apologies if I've got that wrong, was appointed as the government's Women's Employment Ambassador. In this role, she will campaign on women's health throughout their life course, working with employees across the country to strengthen workplace support, raise awareness of key health issues and wider challenges affecting women in work and highlight the vital economic contribution women make.

The ambassador intended to launch the Endometriosis: Not in the Workplace report, and in her remarks, she emphasized that supporting women's health in the workplace is not only the right thing to do, but also vital in retaining talent, reducing inequalities and strengthening the economy. This work will also include engaging with Keep Britain Working. Sir Charlie Mayfield's independent Keep Britain Working review highlighted the scale of the economic inactivity due to ill health and disability, and the important role employers can play in helping people stay in work. During the vanguard phase, we have worked with employers, providers, unions and people with health conditions to develop and refine approaches that will help people thrive in work, including promoting early conversation about health needs and supporting reasonable workplace adjustments for women's health conditions. We, as we develop the workplace health systems, we are considering how health and work interact across different stages of life, including the impact of endometriosis and other long-term, fluctuating menstrual health conditions on people's ability to remain and thrive in work.

We welcome the involvement of the Endometriosis UK in the Vanguard, which provides valuable insight into the experiences of people living with these conditions and helps inform our approach. As well as taking steps to create more supportive and informed workplaces, the renewed Women's Health Strategy, which has been mentioned, published in April, represents a decisive shift towards addressing long-standing failures in women's health outcomes, experiences, and access to care. Some of the stories shared during this debate are absolutely heartbreaking, and all of them have led to this important shift. As part of this Women's Health Strategy, it does identify endometriosis as a priority condition and states our commitment to improve the treatment and ongoing care for every woman affected. Through the plan,

Okay. God, I've got 2 minutes. Through the plan to Make Work Pay, we are strengthening support for people managing health conditions alongside their work by inquiring by requiring employers to accept flexible working requests where it is reasonable for them to do so. We want to ensure all employers are supporting their employees' health and well-being to benefit both them and their organization.

That's why the Government is getting large employers to publish action plans, as the member mentioned, setting out how they will make meaningful changes to tackle the barriers women face throughout their working lives, including the steps they are taking to improve menopause support, including endometriosis, and addressing gender pay gap. Very importantly, the EHRC was mentioned. As members will know, this is an independent, this is independent arm of the Government and will make its own operational decisions. Thank you very much for everybody's contribution, sorry if I didn't get to your points.

03:00:05 - 03:00:18

Christine Jardine

The question is that this House has considered the potential merits of adding gynaecological conditions to the Equality Act 2010 guidance. As many are of that opinion, say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. Order.

The sitting stands adjourned.