House of Commons

12 October 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:17 - 00:45
Speaker 13
Order, order.  Will the Member wishing to take their seat please come to the table. 
00:45 - 02:06
Speaker 5
I swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors according to the law, so help me God. 
02:06 - 02:11
Lindsay Hoyle
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Right, we now come to questions to the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions.  Andrew Pakes. 
02:11 - 02:12
Number one, Mr. Speaker. 
02:12 - 02:13
Secretary of State. 
02:13 - 03:23
Lab Member of Parliament | Leicester West
Member of Parliament | Leicester West
Elizabeth Louise Kendall
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  It's been some time since we had one of these sessions and there have been some political developments.  We have a new Prime Minister in place.  The Shadow Secretary of State has survived a reshuffle.  I know what that feels like, so I welcome her back to her place. 

And of course, we've just welcomed the new MP for Holborn and St Pancras.  I should say if her opponent needs any help with employment security, we have a number of work experience and training programs that I'm happy to make available to him if he ever needs it.  Now, turning to the question, youth trailblazers are a flexible, locally delivered way to help more young people into work.  The early evidence is encouraging, showing more participation and getting young people work-ready.  There'll be a full evaluation next year. 

And I should also say that delivering employment support more locally through mayors and local authorities is the direction of travel, and we will do more of this in the future. 
03:23 - 04:06
Lab Member of Parliament | Peterborough
Member of Parliament | Peterborough
Andrew Elliot Pakes
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  Too many young people in Peterborough are starting off adult life without the skills, support, or training to get on.  So I'm incredibly proud that Peterborough was chosen as one of the first pilots for the Youth Guarantee trailblazer.  But we don't just have high levels of NEETs.  According to our Chambers of Commerce yet again, we have a high level of businesses unable to recruit the staff they need because of skills shortages. 

This highlights one of the big mismatches between young people who don't have the skills and between employers who can't find the people they can train and give support for those skills.  So can my right honourable friend tell me what more DWP and his department can do to ensure young people and businesses can find each other when it comes to investing in apprenticeships? 

04:06 - 04:46

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I should congratulate my honourable friend for his tireless and constant campaigning on the issue of youth opportunity. He asks specifically about skills. From the 1st of August this year, we're fully funding apprenticeship training for all eligible under-25s. We've also brought the National Careers Service into the DWP, meaning around 500 qualified careers advisers are now helping people of all ages to access career support, regardless of benefit status, and do that skills matching that he spoke so eloquently about.

04:46 - 04:47

Suella Braverman.

04:47 - 05:19

Suella Braverman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We've got over a million young people who are not in education, employment, or training. This is simply a crisis. And one of the reasons for it is because businesses, particularly small and medium-sized businesses, are not taking on apprentices. So will the Secretary of State take this chance to support Reform UK's apprenticeship wage credit?

Let's see what he says. Which will provide direct support to small and medium-sized businesses when they take on a young apprentice.

05:19 - 05:52

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable lady for her question. And where I can agree with her is that more youth apprenticeship starts is desirable. She may not know, but we are actually introducing a hiring incentive of 2,000 pounds for a small business that takes on a young apprentice. And if that young person has been out of work and on Universal Credit for six months or more, that incentive goes up from 2,000 pounds to 5,000 pounds. So we are helping small businesses do exactly what she called for.

05:52 - 05:57

Lindsay Hoyle

Brent Lishman. Question two please, Mr. Speaker.

Minister.

05:57 - 06:18

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We want all pensioners, including women born in the 1950s, to have the comfortable retirements they deserve. And that is why we're delivering on our twin priorities for pensioners: raising the state pension and rescuing the NHS. We are also delivering the largest ever pension credit take-up campaign, which is in particular important for low-income pensioners who are disproportionately women.

06:18 - 06:19

Brent Lishman.

06:19 - 06:57

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. There are over three and a half million WASPI women affected by the change to state pension age. Now, time is really of the essence because another WASPI woman dies on average every 13 minutes without receiving fairness or justice. The Prime Minister personally assured the WASPI campaign during the Makerfield by-election that he would meet with them to discuss potential routes to redress. Can the Minister confirm what actions the department are taking to support the Prime Minister for these discussions and, crucially, when will the meeting happen?

06:57 - 07:31

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Look, I and the Prime Minister opposed the Liberal Democrats and the coalition government's 2011 acceleration of the state pension age, in particular because it gave some women as little as five years' notice of changes to their state pension age. Those same women face disadvantage in the workplace and very uneven burdens of caring responsibilities. I have recently written to WASPI representatives to set out the government's position. With legal proceedings ongoing, further comment isn't appropriate, but I continue to hear from and to speak to women affected by the accelerated increases in the state pension age.

07:31 - 07:32

Sir Roger Gale.

07:32 - 07:59

Roger Gale

Mr. Speaker. It is several years now since the ombudsman reported on this matter. As I recall the last government agreed to accept the recommendations of the ombudsman. To take the point made by the honorable gentleman who asked the lead question many of these ladies will be dead before they see any money at all. When is the government going to stop messing around and do something?

07:59 - 08:21

Torsten Bell

Well I thank the honorable member for his his question I just don't agree with the tone with which he's asked it. This government has considered the case set out by the ombudsman we provided a detailed response to that. I'm afraid the previous government did nothing of the sort of saying that they would proceed with a compensation scheme. In fact in fact the reason the ombudsman laid their report before Parliament rather than to the government is because it was very clear where the last government was going with this.

08:21 - 08:22

Sarah Russell.

08:22 - 08:25

Speaker 11

Question number three please Mr. Speaker.

08:25 - 08:45

Stephen Timms

Mr. Speaker parents should be able without undue financial pressure to spend time off work in their child's vital early months. Our review of parental leave and pay due to report early in the new year is considering how working families can best be supported including through statutory paternity pay.

08:45 - 09:14

Sarah Russell

Mr. Speaker my constituent got in touch with me after she had had an emergency cesarean section with twins it was a traumatic experience. Her husband had to go back to work when she had only been out of hospital for a week. Does the minister agree with me that this is not the way that we should be looking after parents in a civilized society and that both the mother and the father in that situation would have been better served with longer periods of paid leave?

09:14 - 09:50

Stephen Timms

Well I'm concerned to hear about my honorable friend's experience. The government does recognize the vital role of fathers in supporting mothers and newborn children particularly after difficult births like the one my honorable friend has referred to. Our parental leave and pay system is complicated. The review that's underway is looking at how paternity leave and pay and all the current entitlements are supporting working families and across government families' experiences like the one my honorable friend has brought to the house are informing our future policy.

09:50 - 09:51

Tim Farron.

09:51 - 10:26

Timothy James Farron

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Statutory paternity pay and paternity leave are very important things for the government to be looking at and I want to support them in what they are seeking to achieve. In the investigation that the minister is undertaking would he look carefully at the status of those people who are self-employed? One in four people in my constituency in the workforce works themselves including of course the 1600 people who farm in Westmorland and Lonsdale. It's so important that those families are protected too isn't it?

So how will the brief be extended to ensure that those people who work for themselves or indeed work for small employers are protected too?

10:26 - 10:38

Stephen Timms

Well the honorable gentleman is absolutely right and I'm pleased to be able to confirm to him that self-employed parents are explicitly covered in the terms of reference of the the current review.

10:38 - 10:39

Dan Aldridge.

10:39 - 10:42

Colin Daniel Aldridge

Thank you Mr. Speaker question number four.

10:42 - 11:05

Stephen Timms

Mr. Speaker. In March the Office for Budget Responsibility published its official forecast that UK welfare spending at the end of this Parliament in 2029-30 would be around 390 billion pounds. The OBR will update that forecast at the budget two weeks on Wednesday.

11:05 - 11:21

John Lamont

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Now the minister's just confirmed that the benefits bill will continue to grow. Now the minister also seems to have confirmed the Prime Minister's position that national security cannot come at the at the expense of social security. Is that correct?

11:22 - 11:55

Stephen Timms

Well, Mr. Speaker, the honorable member will be relieved to know that spending on working age and children welfare is forecast to be 4.9% of GDP at the end of this Parliament, as it is now. Overall welfare spending is forecast to rise by less than half as much in this Parliament as in the last, by just over 0.3 percentage points by 2030-31, compared with 0.7 in the last Parliament. This government is putting right the problems it inherited.

11:55 - 12:24

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A recent report from the Good Growth Foundation found that half of disability claimants would swap up to £1,000 of benefits for help such as employment support, therapy, and physical aids. Does the Secretary of State agree that providing tailored support to disabled people could both reduce the welfare bill and stop disabled people who want to work being written off by the system?

12:24 - 12:53

Stephen Timms

I do agree with my honorable friend, and we did inherit a system which wrote people off exactly as she's said. We're very pleased with the early results coming out of our Connect to Work programme, which are providing exactly that sort of tailored support to disabled people and others with complex barriers to work. We've recently published the second set of quarterly outcome stats, and the news is very encouraging.

12:53 - 13:34

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The number of children between the ages of 6 and 11 with ADHD has grown sixfold, meaning that in the years ahead there'll be a surge in those applying for PIP as children become adults. Even the Secretary of State accepts that the growing number of children on DLA will transfer, most of them, onto PIP. Does the Minister agree with me it's time to end a cash payments benefit system for people with more minor conditions and ensure that those with genuine need receive the therapeutic support to learn, work, and contribute to the economy?

13:34 - 14:08

Stephen Timms

Well, the honorable gentleman will have seen Professor Peter Fonagy's recent report about the incidence of ADHD and autism and other conditions. He'll also know that I'm co-chairing a review of Personal Independence Payment, which is looking at how we can make sure that system does meet the very real need that many disabled people have, and that the benefit is also on a sustainable financial footing for the future. And the report of my review will be published before the end of the year.

14:08 - 14:12

Torcuil Crichton

Question number five, Mr. Speaker.

14:12 - 14:30

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is supporting employment in rural areas through local Get Britain Working plans, a reformed jobs and careers service with expanded digital, phone, and in-person support, and increased outreach through the flexible delivery network.

14:30 - 15:11

Torcuil Crichton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Minister for that answer. He's been in Uist himself, so he knows about the challenges of administering and delivering benefits in the constituency of the Western Isles, Na h-Eileanan an Iar. But that process could be made simpler if the verification of identification could be done virtually in some cases instead of requiring a home visit, which for DWP staff could involve travelling to other islands, and he knows about the challenges of weather and the inheritance of a failed ferry system that we've been given by the SNP. Can the Minister consider changing this one-size-fits-all system of verifying claims and identities to take into account the rurality and the insularity of constituencies like Na h-Eileanan an Iar?

15:11 - 15:44

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I hope I can give my honorable friend some welcome news, in that the DWP does have several different ways to carry out identity verification for customers accessing our services in rural locations. And that does include, for customers who are unable to access a job centre, offering verification through our digital service, telephone, or postal delivery. If that is not happening in his locality, as he says there is an excellent team working out of the job centre in Stornoway who I have met, if they or he want to let me know, I will be very happy to look into that for him.

15:44 - 16:12

Priti Patel

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Rural areas could create and support more jobs if they have the right transport infrastructure. So now that the government has now cancelled the A12 widening scheme, paused the dualling of the A120 and now scrapped the A127 economic corridor in Essex, what will the minister do to lobby his colleagues across government to help support more rural job creation in Essex?

16:12 - 16:43

Alison McGovern

The right honourable lady will be aware that this government is delivering an additional 120 billion pounds of public spending to support improved infrastructure across the country. But what I would say to her specifically on the question of jobs in rural locations, this government is taking the steps needed to support people into work. Just take the agricultural sector as one such example where there are over 22,000 more jobs than there were when her party left office.

16:43 - 16:44

Pauleen Moon.

16:44 - 17:13

Perran Moon

Moras, Mr Speaker. The number of young people claiming unemployment benefit in my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency has risen 26% in the last year alone, far higher than the national average. Can the minister outline what employment action the government is taking particularly in areas, remote coastal areas like mine that have seen such a dramatic increase to deal with the issue of young people claiming unemployment benefit?

17:13 - 17:46

Alison McGovern

My honourable friend raises a very important issue not just in his constituency but across the country, recognising the specific concerns that he has about his locality but also that these challenges are faced more broadly. I'm delighted that this government has brought forward the youth jobs grant, has introduced the new 2,000 pound incentive for small and medium-sized enterprises that are hiring apprentices under the age of 25 and rolling out youth hubs across our country. But if there is more that he feels that we could be doing in his area, I'd be very happy to discuss that with him.

17:46 - 17:48

Lindsay Hoyle

Ann Davies.

17:48 - 17:50

Ann Celia Davies

Sorry, question six, I'm sorry.

17:50 - 17:55

Speaker 19

I'm sorry, Danny. Jamie Stone, come on, welcome back.

17:55 - 18:30

Speaker 41

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I would just like to thank honourable, right honourable members for the very kind sentiments I've received recently. I'm sure that the minister recognises that the lack of available or affordable housing is critical when it comes to rural employment. Indeed, the west coast of my constituency, opposite the honourable member's constituency, we have almost none at all. It is, of course, housing is devolved to Scottish government, but could I ask the minister, could he share the best practice within England and Wales with the north of the border to see if we can do something about this problem?

18:30 - 19:01

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and can I also welcome the honourable gentleman back to his place. I would be very happy to ask colleagues in MHCLG to share any such best practice with Scottish counterparts. This government is investing 39 billion pounds in the delivery of social and affordable homes. That is because we recognise the issues that he sets out. The fundamental starting point for any good life is access to a good quality, safe and secure home.

That is something we are committed to delivering.

19:01 - 19:02

Danny Beales.

19:02 - 19:03

Mr Speaker.

19:03 - 19:04

Secretary of State.

19:04 - 19:51

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Thank you, Mr Speaker. With your permission, I'd like to answer questions 6, 14, 18 and 21 together. We've announced an additional two and a half billion pounds as part of the youth guarantee to create up to 500,000 opportunities to earn and learn over the next few years.

This has begun rolling out across Great Britain. The gateway to it is available in job centres. We're expanding youth hubs. We've launched the three thousand pounds youth jobs grant, and we're rolling out the jobs guarantee for the long-term young unemployed. And I should end by saying I recently met the first beneficiaries of the jobs guarantee at Boots headquarters in Nottingham and saw the huge difference that having a job made to the young people taking part.

19:51 - 20:26

Danny Beales

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Minister for joining me to mark the opening of the Uxbridge job hub a few weeks ago. And I'm sure he'll join me in thanking the college, the job centre, the Chamber of Commerce and many others who made this a reality. One group who still experience the biggest employment gap are young people with special educational needs. So I'd like to ask the Minister, the Secretary of State, what steps the government is taking to ensure that the job hubs and the youth guarantee offer more broadly are inclusive of young people with SEND and that they also see those benefits.

20:26 - 21:10

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, can I thank my honourable friend for the campaigning he's done on this issue, and my honourable friend the Minister for Employment, who enjoyed cutting the ribbon at the Future Start youth hub a few weeks ago. He's absolutely right what he says. We need to end the culture of signed off and written off, and we want all young people, including those with special educational needs, to benefit from the youth guarantee. That's why youth hubs work closely with our work coaches and disability employment advisers, as well as local partners, because the idea for this is that whatever condition people have, we try to give them the opportunities that are available and help them to live the fullest life.

21:10 - 21:54

Liz Twist

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just last week, I had the privilege of visiting Derwentside College in my constituency to see the amazing work that they do linking to employers across the region in a range of sectors, ensuring that every qualification offered can lead to real employment opportunities across Durham and the region. From care to construction, there are real opportunities that can tackle the issues for young people not currently in education, employment or training. So will the Minister join me in congratulating them on the work they do, and will he join me in visiting them to see their incredible work in practice?

21:54 - 22:13

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, let me thank the honourable member for her question. I'm very happy to echo her congratulations to Derwentside College for all the work that they are doing. In terms of a visit, I will do the best I can with that. I know she's a passionate advocate for the college, and if I get an opportunity to visit, I most certainly will.

22:13 - 23:17

Maureen Burke

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister hit the nail on the head when he said that too many young people have been failed by a school system that focused too much on the university route and not enough on technical education. It is not surprising that a number of young people on benefits has grown so significantly when the education system has failed to equip them with the skills they need for today's job market. When I speak to unemployed young people in my constituency, they tell me that they are desperate to find work, not just for the pay, but for a sense of purpose and the independence to shape their own future. The choice before us is clear: invest in young people's success or create a lifetime of dependency carrying a huge price for the taxpayer.

Does the Minister agree with me that we need to invest in young people's success rather than leave them to languish on benefits?

23:17 - 24:08

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Yes, I do agree with my honourable friend. She's absolutely right to say that we need to invest in opportunity and success, and she's spoken admirably about her own life experiences in this House. As I've said, we are putting forward an additional two and a half billion pounds investment into the youth guarantee and the growth and skills levy, recently announced, that we're expanding the jobs guarantee to help eligible young people receiving health-related benefits.

They should not be signed off and written off. And there's another point in the question she raised. Too often in these debates, we have young people attacked with a negative narrative describing them as snowflakes and shirkers. What she's saying is right, is that given the chance, young people want to work, want to have a full life, and don't want to spend it on benefits.

24:08 - 24:42

Luke Murphy

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Youth hubs like that based in Inclusion Education in Basingstoke provide fantastic opportunities for young people to learn and to work, including those with special educational needs and disabilities. But could the Secretary of State say a bit more about how youth hubs are helping deliver the Youth Guarantee to help young people realize their potential? And having heard that the Minister opened the youth hub in Uxbridge, would the Secretary of State or Minister consider a visit to Basingstoke's youth hub to discuss the challenges and opportunities that young people face?

24:42 - 25:32

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, when I get back from Derwentside, I'll see if a visit to Basingstoke is popular. Youth hubs are a crucial part of the Youth Guarantee. They bring together employment skills, employment and skills and wider support, often involving housing and health advice. They are an important feature of the Dutch system, where the NEET rate is one third of ours. We're expanding the network to over 360 locations across Great Britain.

And the whole idea is to get the help that a Jobcentre can provide out of the Jobcentre and into the community. But there are other important parts of the Youth Guarantee too: hiring bonuses, an extra 300,000 work experience places, and a Jobs Guarantee for the long-term young unemployed.

25:32 - 26:21

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently visited Portugal to observe a NATO exercise using maritime uncrewed systems. Now, the young man who drove our safety boat had done his apprenticeship at Searegs in Plymouth. It came to light over the recess, though, that Skills England is consulting to axe the Small Commercial Vessel Crewmember Level 3 apprenticeship, which this young 18-year-old did for Plymouth Cattewater Harbour Authority. He wouldn't have been able to qualify if it is scrapped, though.

The small enrollment numbers for this course reflect the specialist nature of the industry, not a lack of value. The apprenticeship gives young people in coastal communities like mine a direct route into skilled jobs that support our national defense. So will the Secretary of State step in and stop this apprenticeship and others like it that are also being consulted on from being scrapped?

26:21 - 26:52

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to the honorable lady for her question. Skills England play an important role in accrediting approved apprenticeships. They look at demand, they look at quality. I'm sure they've heard the representations that she has made. The overall direction of travel that we have given to Skills England is to make sure that we have more youth apprenticeship starts in the future, because that is where the need is greatest and that is where the public expect us to be investing the Growth and Skills Levy to create the most opportunity that can change the most lives.

26:52 - 27:30

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, I visited several successful marine businesses at Noss on Dart who are struggling to find the crew needed for workboats which support the wider maritime sector, following on from my neighbor's question. With the funding for the commercial vessel apprenticeships now threatened, the route for young people to enter this sector and find well-paid, year-round, permanent employment in coastal communities will potentially be closed off. So will the Minister commit to continuing this funding, because these specialized apprenticeships may not have the same take-up as nationwide apprenticeships, but they are absolutely vital to economic growth in coastal communities like South Devon?

27:30 - 27:47

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, I'm grateful to her for her question, and as I said to the honorable lady who asked a question a moment ago, Skills England will always look at the range of courses available, will always consider accreditation, and I'm sure that they will have heard the representations that she's made.

27:47 - 28:29

Mark Pritchard

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State talks about jobs hubs. Can I just gently say to him the best jobs hub of all is a business that is expanding. The best youth hub of all is businesses taking on apprentices. Now, he's mentioned a range of very wide-ranging schemes to try and get young people back into work.

In the Wrekin, unemployment, youth unemployment has risen by 27.8% in the last 12 months alone. A lot of the schemes are in urban areas. So what is he going to do for my constituents, young constituents, who live in rural and semi-rural counties like Shropshire?

28:29 - 29:01

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, Mr. Speaker, he's right to emphasize the importance of jobs, and that's why he will be pleased to know that there are 243,000 more people in work than at this time last year. He'll also be pleased to know that the employment rate in the UK is higher today than in all but one of the 14 years when his party were in power. And he'll be pleased a third time to know that economic inactivity is down by 367,000 since the last election.

29:01 - 29:27

Ann Celia Davies

If we want to support young people into employment, we must address the barriers that they face long before they enter the workplace, and one of those is child poverty, which is why the Plaid Cymru government will pilot the Cynnal payment. So will the Secretary of State confirm that the £10 a week payment for children in households receiving Universal Credit will be disregarded for benefit purposes?

29:27 - 30:05

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, Mr. Speaker, we made a major change on this front last year when we abolished the two-child limit. That, together with other elements in the child poverty strategy, is estimated to bring down child poverty by about half a million over the course of this Parliament. And that is an important step towards children being able to live the fullest life possible, because those children who are poor can often suffer from worse education results, worse mental health later in life too. So this is not just an anti-poverty measure, it's a pro-opportunity measure too.

30:05 - 30:57

Helen Whately

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Every DWP questions, Labour members dutifully line up to give the Welfare Secretary a chance to make it look like he's doing something about the youth unemployment crisis, a crisis of their own making. Their jobs tax and their Unemployment Act have killed 300,000 jobs, hitting young people hardest. We've had enough talk about hubs and schemes. Young people tell me they want real jobs.

That's why we will halve National Insurance for 21 to 24-year-olds so it's cheaper for businesses to hire them. Under us, there will be thousands more jobs for young people. Will the Secretary of State get the Chancellor to use his budget to do the same?

30:57 - 31:47

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, I have to remind the right honourable lady that under her government, NEETs, the number of young people not in employment, education, or training, went up by a quarter of a million in the three years before the last election. And since the last election, as I said to her honourable friend, there are 243,000 more people in work this time than last. The employment rate today in the UK is higher than in every one but one year of her 14 years in power.

The UK has the fastest growing economy in the G7 in the first half of this year. And I'll tell you what could threaten it. A bunch of unfunded tax cuts from the party opposite. We know where that ends up. We saw the movie a few years ago, and I would advise her not to repeat it again.

31:47 - 31:51

Lindsay Hoyle

Labour spokesperson Steve Dolly.

31:51 - 32:19

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government recently announced funding for apprenticeships through areas where there are elected mayors. However, almost half England does not have an elected mayor, and so will the Secretary of State acknowledge that young people in communities such as mine in Torbay and across Devon and Cornwall will feel the government has turned their back on them?

32:19 - 33:33

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, Mr. Speaker, the honorable member is right to say that the devolution map in England is uneven. I ought him to wait for the white paper later this year where we'll have more to say about this. But it is our belief that locally delivered services in employment support can break down the departmental barriers that have too often dogged getting the right help to people at the right time. People are human beings. They're not departmental clients, and it's time we treated them as such, and delivering more services locally can help us do that.

Question number seven, please, Mr. Speaker. Forgive me, Mr. Speaker. Alan Milburn delivered his interim report a few months ago and will deliver his final report in a few weeks' time. I'd like to take the opportunity to thank Alan Milburn for the work he's done. He's done tremendous work in highlighting the issue of youth inactivity, and I look forward to his final report.

33:33 - 34:19

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ahead of Alan Milburn's report, in Gloucester there are over two and a half thousand young people not in employment, education, or training. And I've spoken with many of them across the last two years who want an opportunity but have been let down by the system. Something needs to change. At the end of November, I'm hosting the Gloucestershire Futures Summit with Gloucestershire County Council, and we've invited schools and colleges, local employers, healthcare providers, local government, and the third sector to get everyone in the room to discuss how we can solve this together.

I know the Secretary of State has a long list of constituencies to visit after today's questions, but he also shares my determination to give every young person the opportunity to fulfill their potential. And I wonder whether he or one of his team might be able to join us for the summit at the end of November.

34:19 - 34:54

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, I will add it to the list of places to go, and I would dearly love to visit his constituency. And if I can't, I'll try and make sure one of my colleagues does. But on the point of substance that he raises, it is clear that the problem of youth inactivity in the country has built up over many years. Not enough has been done about it in the past. We now have a youth guarantee that's investing in it.

We know there is more that we have to do, and that's why we are looking forward to the final report from Alan Milburn in a few weeks' time.

34:54 - 35:52

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Can I just say to the Secretary of State, it sounds like when it comes to youth unemployment, he has his head very firmly in the sand. Has he not heard, as member after member from across this House has stood up and quoted the number of people, number of young people who are not in education, employment, or training that has gone up under this government? He quotes back to us the national figures for people overall that are employed, but that's because the population has gone up. What are the NEET figures?

Let me tell him. In Gosport, the number of young people not in education, employment, or training has gone up 23% under this government. And it's all because of the number of taxes that are being put on businesses that are there to employ them, particularly the small businesses that do the Saturday jobs, the apprenticeships, hair and beauty, adult social care, care. What is he actually going to do, and what will Alan Milburn's report say that's actually going to do something about this?

35:52 - 36:35

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, Mr. Speaker, the truth is it has been a problem for a long time. I repeat what I said to the Shadow Secretary. Under the government that she supported, the number of NEETs went up by a quarter million between 2021 and 2024. She asked me what we'll do. In addition to the programs that I've announced, we recently announced a partnership with the British Retail Consortium to hire 100,000 young people not in education, employment or training over the next few years.

And she'll be pleased to know that the latest Recruitment and Employment Confederation survey showed the strongest hiring sentiment in four years.

36:35 - 36:39

Lindsay Hoyle

Ah, can we welcome the new Shadow Minister, Andrew Snowden.

36:39 - 37:31

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Labour have been talking up the Milburn report for months, and the Treasury are so pleased with it, Mr. Speaker, that they've delayed it until after the budget, which means it's not going to be good news for taxpayers or the bond markets. So whilst the government dithers and delays, we have published our plan on this side of the House for tough love on youth unemployment. Support from day one to get back into work, and after six months, those who can work but won't work will have their benefits cut. I'm sure the Chancellor of the Exchequer would welcome our cost-cutting plan in the budget.

So can the Secretary of State explain why the Treasury do not want his plan in the budget?

37:31 - 38:02

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Well, Mr. Speaker, I refer him to the Chancellor's speech that he made at our party conference a couple of weeks ago, where he was quite clear that we owe young people not just an income, but a future too. And that's why the government is behind the agenda I am setting out. I look forward to the final report from Alan Milburn in a few weeks' time. And I remind him and everyone on the benches opposite that he was clear in his interim report that the problems we're talking about are deep-seated, long-term, and have existed in this country for a great many years.

38:02 - 38:04

Lindsay Hoyle

Dan Aldridge.

38:04 - 38:06

Colin Daniel Aldridge

Question number eight, Mr. Speaker.

38:06 - 38:07

Minister.

38:07 - 38:36

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is determined to help more young people to build careers in sectors such as hair and beauty, investing an additional 2.5 billion pounds through the Youth Guarantee and the Growth and Skills Levy. Whether a young person chooses hair and beauty or another sector, we want them to have the skills, training and support they need to succeed, including through the funding of apprenticeship training costs for eligible under-25s who started their apprenticeships from August this year.

38:36 - 39:12

Colin Daniel Aldridge

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This week is British Beauty Week, a great opportunity to celebrate the fantastic and fast-growing beauty and wellness businesses that we have in this country, especially in towns like Weston-super-Mare, where businesses like Sacred Willow, founded by Kerry and Simon Lemmerton, and Luceo Lounge, founded by Lisa De Laune, keep our high streets alive, our economies going, and generally make people feel much better about themselves. Will the Minister give some more information about the support his Department is providing, especially for young people through the Youth Guarantee, making sure small businesses in areas like mine get the benefits as much as possible?

39:12 - 39:43

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I welcome my honourable friend's support for British Beauty Week and join him in celebrating local beauty and wellness businesses helping to drive growth and create opportunities for young people, particularly the two he has highlighted in his own constituency. I'd encourage his local businesses to look at the incentives offered by not just the jobs component of the Youth Guarantee, but the Youth Jobs Grant and the 2,000 pound payment to SMEs hiring a young apprentice, all of which can support them in giving opportunities to young people in Weston-super-Mare and beyond.

39:43 - 39:44

Lindsay Hoyle

Vicky Slade.

39:44 - 40:26

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's been a thirty percent reduction in the number of apprenticeships in the hair and beauty sector over the last five years. One reason being the number of people actually employed has plummeted with many people being forced into false self-employment due to increasing costs. But in addition, the number of providers working in the sector is at a critical level. My constituent Mike, who owns Mike Taylor Education with his wife Emily, told me of a young man travelling from Kent to Dorset every week in order to follow his level two barbering course because there are no courses anywhere else.

Will the Minister meet with me and sector representatives to talk about how we can reverse this decline?

40:26 - 40:43

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Clearly, I would be very happy to meet with the honourable lady. That sort of distance is unfortunate and I'm sorry if that is the experience that her constituent or indeed their apprentice is having. As I say, very happy to meet with her to discuss further.

40:43 - 40:44

Tom Jones.

40:44 - 40:50

Clive Jones

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Can I ask the Minister... oh, sorry, question nine.

40:50 - 40:52

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

40:52 - 41:19

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and it's always a pleasure to discuss with the very keen honourable member. This government's reforms provide greater flexibility for well-funded defined benefit pension schemes to share surplus with employers and to benefit members. Scheme trustees who must act in the interest of scheme beneficiaries are best placed to determine the appropriate use of any surplus for their individual scheme. And trustees will agree how members can benefit, working with sponsoring employers.

41:19 - 41:20

Tom Jones.

41:20 - 41:42

Clive Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I ask the Minister, is it not the case that nothing in law stops the government requiring pre-97 pensions to be restored before surplus goes back to employers, and that the only reason that it is not happening is that the Minister has decided it should not?

41:42 - 42:38

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the honourable member for his question here. And I have met and discussed this issue on a wide number of occasions. Around three quarters of schemes already provide some pre-1997 indexation, but the honourable member is right to point out the strength of feeling on this. I have met with many both MPs and scheme members, including those in South Wales who have been affected by a lack of pre-97 indexation on their defined benefit schemes. This is separate from the changes we've already introduced for the PPF, the Pension Protection Fund's indexation.

Look, trustees do need to be in the driving seat on this. Employers will have no access, no direct access to a scheme's surplus. And I'm already seeing the flexibilities we've put in place through the Pension Scheme Act and the guidance that the Pensions Regulator is providing changing the nature of the discussion between trustees and employers. And I think it will lead to a step change in this area.

42:38 - 43:18

Peter Bedford

Peter Bedford, Shadow Minister.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It didn't sound as though the Minister could commit to improving outcomes for pensioners. And this is no surprise given this government's record. They cut the winter fuel payments, they undermined incentives for saving into pensions through the salary sacrifice scheme and dragging pensions into the scope of inheritance tax. And at the Labour Party conference, the Prime Minister's announcement created yet more uncertainty for those in or approaching retirement.

So will the Minister give the House a commitment today that there'll be no further policies like these undermining the prospects of pensioners and damaging their retirement?

43:18 - 44:01

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I obviously listened closely, not quite to every but to lots of the opposition party's conferences.

It's still not absolutely clear to me what their policy position is on the triple lock, or indeed on many other things when it comes to the pension space. I've been paying a lot of attention, and what I've learned when I pay attention is that I've got the shadow foreign secretary calling the triple lock a Ponzi scheme. I've got the previous shadow chancellor calling the triple lock completely unsustainable. The shadow secretary of state absolutely knows that she's got a ridiculous position when it comes to reform of the state pension. What this government is going to do is put the state pension on a sustainable basis and make sure we address the other big challenge in the pension system, which is to make sure that we have an adequate private pension system, and that is what the Pensions Commission will do.

44:01 - 44:04

Lindsay Hoyle

Euan Stainbank.

44:04 - 44:36

Alison McGovern

Thank you, and with your permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions 10 and 19 together. We are making strong progress expanding youth hubs across Great Britain, with delivery ahead of schedule, bringing the total number of youth hubs to 160. These hubs provide a single, community-based front door to joined-up employment, skills, and wider support for young people. We continue to work closely with local authorities and partners to maintain momentum and support further expansion.

44:36 - 45:05

Euan Stainbank

Euan Stainbank.

Mr. Speaker, in August, Falkirk became one of the first towns in Scotland to have a youth hub opened at the Falkirk campus of Forth Valley College, visible evidence of a Labour government's investment in young people's futures, based at our primary local further education institute. Will the minister join me in visiting the youth hub and Forth Valley College, and will the department also re-engage with the Falkirk-based local training provider Powering Futures, whose model could deliver a preventative solution to youth unemployment, but who are currently falling between the cracks of reserved and devolved competency?

45:05 - 45:27

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank my honorable friend for his invitation and for highlighting the work of the Falkirk youth hub and its partners. I know that my right honorable friend the Secretary of State has already met with Powering Futures and is aware of the issues that he raises. I know he has been relentless in seeking support for this organization, and I hope the Scottish government will think again and consider supporting their good work with funding.

45:27 - 45:31

Lindsay Hoyle

Andrew Ranger.

45:31 - 45:51

Andrew Steven Ranger

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For many of our young people, the hardest step towards work is that first one, walking into a jobcentre or a youth hub and asking for support. Does the minister agree with me that youth hubs, including the new hub in Wrexham, must include an approach of reaching those young people where they are, rather than wait for them to come through the door?

45:51 - 46:29

Alison McGovern

My honorable friend is absolutely right, Mr. Speaker. The whole purpose of youth hubs is to take support out of traditional settings and into communities, meeting young people where they are, rather than expecting them to come to us. Through partnerships with local authorities, charities, colleges, and other organizations, youth hubs such as the upcoming Wrexham youth hub will help us reach young people in their local communities who might otherwise miss out on support. We will continue to encourage all youth hubs to undertake proactive outreach and work with local partners to reach young people, and I have seen excellent examples of this in the hubs that I have visited thus far.

46:29 - 46:33

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Ashley Fox.

46:33 - 47:05

Ashley Peter Fox

Mr. Speaker, over the last two years, the government has increased the cost of employing young people, with higher national insurance charges on employers and imposing 350 pages of additional regulation contained in their Employment Rights Act. So would the minister agree with me that the best way of reducing youth unemployment is to cut the cost of employing young people, rather than an endless array of hubs, grants, schemes, and guarantees?

47:05 - 48:01

Alison McGovern

Well, I would agree with the honorable gentleman, Mr. Speaker, but then we would both be wrong. I attended a recent parliamentary event hosted by the Resolution Foundation, chaired by Lord Willetts, the former Tory minister, and the research that they had undertaken was very clear that cutting taxes was not as effective in delivering opportunities to get young people into work.

We're very, very clear that the targeting of employment support was much more effective than the approach he is suggesting. The Shadow Secretary of State was there, she saw that. She may not have agreed with it, maybe because she didn't stay until the end of the event, but nonetheless, it was very, very clear the best way to support young people into work is through employment support schemes, youth hubs, and the routes that we are taking.

48:01 - 48:13

Speaker 76

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Every local area should have a youth hub, and the benefits are so very clear. The Minister is promising an expansion of youth hubs, when can we see one in Bath?

48:13 - 48:38

Alison McGovern

Well, I'd be very happy to write to the honorable lady to confirm specific timings in individual localities. We are ahead of projected delivery at the moment, having already hit more than 160 youth hubs, but we have a target of reaching more than 300 in the coming months and years, and I will set out plans for the youth hub that will serve her local area to her in writing.

48:38 - 48:40

Lindsay Hoyle

Topical questions, Gregory Stafford.

48:40 - 48:42

Gregory James Stafford

Topical question one, sir.

48:42 - 49:25

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Since we last had a session of these oral questions, we have announced an agreement with the British Retail Consortium to hire 100,000 young people not in education, employment, or training over the next few years. We've announced an extension of disability bus pass usage to cover peak hours. We have rolled out more of the Youth Guarantee, and as has been referred to, we've announced our intention to adjust the triple lock, ensuring rising and sustainable pensions for the future, and also releasing funds for a new National Care Service, a matter of huge importance to pensioners and their families.

49:25 - 49:52

Gregory James Stafford

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Times newspaper this morning has reported that over two-thirds of those on sickness benefits are awaiting their reassessment, and they remain unchecked with average waits being over two years. So what is his Department doing to meet its moral duty to help those who can work back into employment and its economic duty to save the taxpayer billions of pounds so that only those who genuinely need help receive it?

49:52 - 50:23

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, I'm glad that he's given me the opportunity to point out what we inherited, which is exactly what's set out in the Times this morning, which was a backlog of two million people waiting reassessment. As he knows, the Tories left a system with almost no face-to-face assessments. Since then, we have announced at the budget of last year a plan to tackle the backlog in work capability assessments and reassessments. The OBR have costed this activity at saving over... Secretary of State, come on. Secretary of State, please.

50:23 - 50:29

Lindsay Hoyle

I'm trying to get your backbenchers in. Obviously you don't want to get the questions, even if I do. Alex Baker.

50:29 - 50:53

Alex Baker

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Parents of neurodivergent young people in my community regularly tell me about the barriers their children face in accessing work opportunities. I'm delighted that a youth hub is opening in Aldershot on Farnborough this year, but how will the Government ensure that every young person in my community receives all the support they need as this hub opens?

50:53 - 51:19

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I welcome plans for a youth hub in her constituency and thank her for the work that she has done to campaign for that. The core blueprint for youth hubs ensures that every hub provides access to employment support alongside mental health, housing, skills, and employer engagement, and aims to support all young people in a locality to address their barriers to work on an individual basis, including those with neurodivergent conditions.

51:19 - 51:47

Helen Whately

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The working-age welfare bill is set to reach 170 billion pounds by the end of this Parliament, up 45 billion on the welfare party's watch.

All around the country, the residents of Benefit Street are doing better under Labour. The Welfare Secretary is always across his brief, so can he tell me the benefits bill for his constituency?

51:47 - 51:49

Lindsay Hoyle

Secretary of State.

51:49 - 52:11

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, the welfare budget rose twice as fast during her party's last Parliament in power than it is during this party's Parliament in power. We are reforming the system through changes to Universal Credit, more personalized employment support, and the youth guarantee that we've referred to a number of times during this session.

52:11 - 52:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Hannah Buckley.

52:13 - 52:53

Helen Whately

Well, I'm surprised the right honorable gentleman didn't know. I can help him. It's 400 million pounds a year. That's why he's dragging his heels on welfare reform. The number of PIP claimants in his constituency exceeds his majority, and the same can be said for 203 of his fellow Labour MPs.

No wonder all his colleagues ask him, who can they tax in order to spend more on benefits? So, will this month's budget just be more of the same, hiking taxes on working families to pay for Benefit Street?

52:53 - 52:55

Lindsay Hoyle

Secretary of State.

52:55 - 53:26

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Mr. Speaker, I remind her that the system that she criticizes is the one designed, created, and legislated for by her government and her party. We are changing the system through the changes in Universal Credit that were announced in April this year, through more personalized support for people with long-term health conditions who were signed off and written off by her party, and through more intervention for youth opportunity for young people who were neglected while the NEET numbers went through the roof on their watch.

53:26 - 53:28

Lindsay Hoyle

Paul Davis.

53:28 - 54:02

Paul Davies

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this year, I met with Benenden Health, a healthcare provider that offers support to women going through the menopause. Research by them shows 17% of women in Yorkshire who experience menopause symptoms have reduced their working hours, and 7% have left their jobs due to these symptoms and lack of support. In light of this, will the Minister commit to assessing whether menopause aspects of employer action plans are improving retention and reducing workforce exits among women experiencing menopause?

54:02 - 54:25

Alison McGovern

Minister.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We recognize the significant impact menopause symptoms can have on retaining women in the workforce. That is why we launched evidence-informed action plans to help employers provide effective menopause support. We have published guidance to help employers monitor their progress, and we are committed to evaluating the impact of action plans, including through a post-implementation review.

54:25 - 54:28

Lindsay Hoyle

Democrat spokesperson Steve Darling.

54:28 - 54:49

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Whether it's processing access to work claims or reassessing sickness benefits, the Department for Work and Pensions have a culture of dither and delay with processing such matters. Can the Secretary of State advise when they will get a grip on this and by when?

54:49 - 54:51

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

54:51 - 55:12

Stephen Timms

Well, Mr. Speaker, we are getting a grip. The honorable gentleman will be very pleased to know that we are recruiting 500 extra staff to process access to work applications. Those staff are being recruited at the moment, they're being trained, and as a result of that, we will eliminate the backlog on access to work which we inherited from the previous government, and we'll eliminate it by September next year.

55:12 - 55:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Joe Powell.

55:14 - 55:38

Edward Joseph Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm delighted North Kensington will soon be opening a youth hub to support young people back into work.

One challenge people tell me we have locally is hidden NEETs, those who might be enrolled in college and not attending or not claiming Universal Credit. So could the Secretary of State or the Minister explain what expectation there will be for the youth hubs to reach this hard-to-reach cohort of young people?

55:38 - 56:11

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is absolutely right to highlight the challenge of hidden NEETs. Youth hubs are open to all young people aged 16 to 24 regardless of benefit status, and we expect them to work closely with local authorities, schools, colleges, and community organizations to identify and engage young people who may be missing out on support. There is a particular challenge with hidden NEETs, and it is my expectation that it is through this place-based intelligence sharing that we will be able to bear down on that problem.

56:11 - 56:48

Peter Smarth

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In answer to a question from my honorable friend the Member for Westmorland and Lonsdale earlier, the Minister confirmed that his ongoing review into parental leave and pay explicitly includes self-employed people. He'll be aware of the gap that exists whereby self-employed adopters are not eligible for the support either birth parents or employed adopters are eligible for. Could he confirm that his review is looking at closing this gap so that potential future adopters aren't stopped from growing their family and giving some of our most vulnerable young people the families they deserve?

56:48 - 56:54

Speaker 78

Well, Mr. Speaker, I'll be happy to check that point with the team that's doing the work, and I'll drop her a line to confirm.

56:54 - 57:15

Jessica Morden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government's recent investment in Connect to Work in the youth hub in Newport is really welcome. Can the Minister assure my constituent who raised with me the struggle her son who is neurodiverse has had finding support into and in work that these initiatives will be long-term meaningful commitments?

57:15 - 57:44

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I can give my honorable friend that reassurance. The government is investing an additional 2.5 billion pounds in the Youth Guarantee, which includes funding for youth hubs and the growth in skills levy by 2029, supporting almost 1 million young people and creating up to 500,000 opportunities to earn and learn. Connect to Work, which will support around 300,000 people, is intended to run until March 2030 with multi-year grant agreements in place to support long-term local planning and delivery.

57:44 - 58:12

Speaker 89

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently met with Leslie and her adult daughter Alice, who has profound disabilities and requires two carers around the clock. Leslie loves caring for her daughter, but she is finding that recruiting skilled carers is increasingly difficult, leaving her filling exhausting gaps and unable to earn a living. So can I ask the Minister what he is doing to support families like Leslie's to receive the support they desperately need?

58:12 - 58:43

Stephen Timms

Well, Mr. Speaker, we owe an enormous debt to carers who carry the kind of burden that she's describing, and we owe that debt right across the country. We're doing some important work at the moment on Carer's Allowance, which is the benefit that provides support in these circumstances. We've consulted on some ideas for change, and we particularly want to make it easier for people to combine work and caring, and that may well help in the situation she's described.

58:43 - 59:09

Speaker 91

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Young workers are facing real challenges in their living standards, particularly due to their housing costs dwarfing those faced by the generations that came before them. This is leading many to reduce the contribution they make to their workplace pensions or even to forgo them entirely, risk having inadequate pensions when they come to retirement. Will the Pensions Commission make recommendations on how to address these challenges?

59:09 - 59:39

Torsten Bell

I thank my honorable friend. He's absolutely right to raise the challenges facing younger workers. They face exactly the same cost of living challenges as the rest of society, but often with added pressure when it comes to housing.

The good news is that between 2012 and 2025, participation amongst employees aged 22 to 25 who are eligible for automatic enrollment increased from 28% to 85%. But he's completely right, there is much more to do and I can confirm the Pensions Commission is exploring exactly these long-term questions.

59:39 - 01:00:16

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Madam Speaker. Constituents in my constituency are facing extremely large delays in their response rates from the DWP. One of my constituents has been waiting now for two months for a response from DWP with regards to his dispute with the Child Maintenance Services, despite receiving a final letter before closure before action. Another constituent has been waiting for four months for a response to his PIP review claim. Can the Minister explain why we're receiving such long delays and what he is doing to resolve this and why my constituents haven't had a response in months?

01:00:16 - 01:00:40

Stephen Timms

Well, I thank the honorable member for his question. We know that increased volumes and more complex cases have led to increased response times and we are working hard to bring those down by deploying additional resources, strengthening oversight and improving case management. I agree, it's not acceptable, we're working to improve the situation.

01:00:40 - 01:01:03

Speaker 84

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It took the DWP hotline 29 working days to respond to me about a serious constituent's regarding PIP arrears and it took them 39 working days to reply to me about an email regarding a reduction in state pension for one of my constituents. Can the Minister help me with this please?

01:01:03 - 01:01:22

Stephen Timms

Well, I thank my honorable friend for her question. As I've said, we recognize that response times are not good enough. I'm acting with putting extra resources in to improve them and of course if she wants to raise the particular case with me, I'll look into it and make sure she gets a speedy outcome.

01:01:22 - 01:01:43

John Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In Scotland, benefit crime has effectively been decriminalized and the Scottish Conservatives have raised the case of people being coached in how to fiddle the system. When I've asked the DWP about this, the reply is basically nothing to do with us, gov. Is there not a moral imperative here that we do something about this?

01:01:43 - 01:02:05

Stephen Timms

Mr. Speaker, yes, I think there is. We are looking at some of the developments that we're seeing in social media and kinds of coaching and including cases where people are being charged for advice which they could obtain free of charge without difficulty. So we are looking at all of that at the moment.

01:02:05 - 01:02:27

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Birmingham has piloted a job guarantee scheme now since April and employment table that I ran in Selly Oak saw lots of young people lack confidence and communication skills to get back into work whilst after being on Universal Credit for 18 months. So will the Secretary of State commit to publishing how many pilot participants are still in work once the six months is over?

01:02:27 - 01:02:46

Elizabeth Louise Kendall

Grateful to my honorable friend. I enjoyed the visit to his constituency to support young disabled people a few weeks ago. On the matter of long-term youth unemployment, he's right in what he says. That's why we've got the jobs guarantee and we will publish a full evaluation of its effects.

01:02:46 - 01:03:24

Speaker 92

Mr. Speaker, it's always very obvious to tell when there's a Labour government in place because the first thing a Labour Prime Minister will do is take a swing at pensioners. So it's not at all surprising that the Prime Minister is already abandoning his promises to WASPI women. So I want to ask the department how pensioners, how WASPI women, how the public in general can trust this department when the Prime Minister seems to find it so easy to say yes and make grand promises when there are no consequences, but those promises seem to have absolutely no meaning in practice.

01:03:24 - 01:03:38

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. What this government promised in our 2024 manifesto is to make sure that the state pension to pensioners in Scotland, England and Wales would rise every single year. And that is exactly what this government is getting on with doing.

01:03:38 - 01:03:54

Speaker 85

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I established the Get Heynburn Working Group, and together we're looking at how we can bring our youth hub into a town center location that also bringing health, training, and education services all under one roof. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss how the government can support us to bring that into a reality?

01:03:54 - 01:04:44

Speaker 97

Mr. Speaker, we should all be behind Get Heynburn Working. I am certainly behind it and I'm very happy to meet my honorable friend.

01:04:44 - 01:04:51

Speaker 94

We now come to statement from the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham.

01:04:51 - 01:06:52

Andy Burnham

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I wish to make a statement on the United Nations General Assembly and related international events since the House last met. Before I do, let me first welcome the new member for Holborn and St Pancras to her place. What a journey from child refugee to Parliament. And what a country, Mr. Speaker, that this story of hope could happen here. I know my honorable friend will enhance this House in so many ways, and I look forward to working with her.

Mr. Speaker, I took a clear message to the UN that after a decade of turbulence, Britain is back and can be relied upon as a consistent and stable partner in an uncertain world, always upholding the shared values set out in the UN Charter, rejecting aggression wherever we see it, and always steadfast in our support for Ukraine, as I assured President Zelenskyy at our meeting in New York. In the three weeks since that meeting, Russian strikes have intensified even further, with more attacks on civilian, on apartment blocks housing innocent families, on buses carrying innocent children. When I spoke to President Zelenskyy on Saturday, he described the step change from Russia, including daylight attacks intended to break their will and ours. I can tell you, Mr. Speaker, that will never happen. In recent days, we have announced new funding to help them get through their fifth winter under Russian bombardment, and a new sanctions package so that over 90% of Russia's oil producing capacity is now covered by UK sanctions.

01:06:52 - 01:09:02

Speaker 96

On diesel, the quickest way to get it back onto world markets without rewarding the aggressor is an energy ceasefire with both sides stopping their attacks. I raised this with President Trump in New York. It is what Ukraine wants to see, and so I welcome President Trump's announcement yesterday of a reciprocal energy ceasefire. President Zelenskyy has assured me Ukraine would immediately implement it when a start date is confirmed, and I will be discussing this further with him in the coming days.

Mr. Speaker, NATO is a defensive alliance. We do not seek confrontation, but our resolve to defend our allies and ourselves is absolute. And I was clear in all of my meetings, including with the NATO Secretary General in Oxfordshire, that we will meet our NATO commitments in full. We know Russia is conducting a campaign of hybrid attacks and sabotage across Europe. In Berlin last week, Chancellor Scholz and I agreed a new partnership to tackle these hybrid threats.

We must be clear-eyed about attempts to destabilize our democracies. It is why in my speech to the UN General Assembly, I confirmed our commitment to establish a new center for information defense as recommended by the Foreign Affairs Select Committee. More broadly, this is a moment to deepen collaboration with our partners, and it is why in Berlin, I indicated Britain's openness to Germany joining the Global Combat Air Programme alongside Italy and Japan. In my meeting with President Trump, we discussed the situation in the Middle East. I confirmed Britain's decision to send air defense and a Voyager aircraft to Saudi Arabia to provide air-to-air refueling support.

01:09:02 - 01:09:28

Andy Burnham

I can confirm today it has already completed 14 operational missions. This support is needed to protect civilians. I condemn the appalling attacks on the King Khalid International Airport. We will continue to stand with Saudi Arabia against the Houthis. Since UNGA, Mr. Speaker, we have been in close contact with US about protective security at our shared bases.

01:09:28 - 01:16:09

Speaker 96

I want to thank our police and military personnel for their swift response to the incidents at RAF Fairford and RAF Molesworth. My right honorable friend the Home Secretary will update the House regarding the incident at RAF Fairford, but I can confirm our assessment that it is highly likely to have been coordinated in Iran, almost certainly directed by Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard. We will not tolerate these threats on our soil. We will crack down on Iran's use of criminal networks using our full range of powers to target them and their funding streams. And we will bring further sanctions to restrict the capacity of Iran and the IRGC to do us harm.

In my meeting with the President, I also raised the Falkland Islands and the clear and declared will of the islanders to remain British. I emphasized this point in my speech to the General Assembly and that we will also always do whatever it takes to uphold their will. Mr. Speaker, in New York, I also had a positive meeting with the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, about the forthcoming UK-EU summit. I can confirm to the House today that it will take place in Brussels on the 20th of November. This summit presents an opportunity to make progress on two crucial issues: boosting UK growth and controlling illegal immigration.

On the table is a trade deal on food and drink products, a deal on emissions trading, progress towards linking our energy systems, a new youth experience scheme, and deeper cooperation on immigration. The summit will also be an opportunity to raise our concerns about Made in Europe, and it is clear to me that there is an opportunity to make progress in all of these areas.

Together, these deals will add the equivalent of over 10 billion pounds per year to the UK economy by 2040, with the potential to add significantly more. We should not turn our backs on this opportunity, Mr. Speaker. And I hope all sides of this House will get behind the government's efforts to land a positive outcome. It is a chance to cut costs and bureaucracy for sectors like farming. At present, entire truckloads of plants or fresh produce can be destroyed because of a single missing stamp or a minor paperwork delay.

Fresh meat and fish spoil while waiting in trucks, and tons of exports have to be written off. Our largest food export, Scottish salmon, faces a 100% rate of document checks at the border, costing us around 100 million pounds in lost exports. British burgers and other fresh meat products cannot be sold in the EU; seed potatoes from Scotland and shellfish from Wales are banned. This is having a real impact on businesses, and the agreement on the table could reverse some of that damage. For farmers and food producers, it will lift the burden that can reach 1,400 pounds on a single shipment.

For our small businesses, it means no more export health certificates, which can cost up to 200 pounds each time; for households, it will ease the pressure on prices in the supermarket. It could help lower energy costs for households and businesses alike. In Northern Ireland, the proposed energy deal could cut wholesale energy costs by 20%. On immigration, we could link up our law enforcement efforts once again, sharing more data and criminal records of foreign nationals, as well as faster electronic evidence from the phones of those behind the gangs. Mr. Speaker, it is in Britain's interest to secure a deal along these lines, and I will work hard over the next five weeks to achieve it.

I believe our chances of doing so will be enhanced by being open to a discussion about our relationship with the EU in the longer term. If we are serious, if we are serious about promoting growth, controlling immigration, upholding our values and security, it is a conversation we must have. Sticking with the status quo is not good enough for Britain. Worse, it would be a major dereliction of duty to turn away. We need to take a calm, clear-eyed, rational look at the world as it is today to consider what is best for our country.

Our immediate priority is securing a successful outcome at the summit, and I believe we should then set up a serious dialogue about the different options for our relationship in the long term. At every stage, the British public will be the boss, and I am clear that public opinion currently supports a pragmatic approach like the one I am suggesting. But if we go into this further phase, we will proceed with care and complete transparency. Mr. Speaker, this is the leadership we need to draw a decade, to draw a line on a decade of drift and division and take the country forward.

Beyond Europe, a confident Britain is ready to play our part on the global stage as we take up the presidency of the G20 in 2027. I confirmed in New York that we will place AI center stage in our presidency, capturing the incredible opportunities it presents while guarding against the risks. Leading voices like the president of Microsoft are saying Britain is the world leader in AI safety, so we are well placed to take on this role and work towards agreeing a single set of global principles and standards on AI as part of our G20 presidency year. Mr. Speaker, the message to the world is clear: Britain is back. On so many fronts, we are playing our part and looking confidently to the future.

01:16:09 - 01:16:23

Andy Burnham

We are leading again, so our country can hope again, and I commend this statement to the House.

01:16:23 - 01:21:57

Kemi Badenoch

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Prime Minister for advance sight of his statement. Since we last met, Iran has sponsored an attempted terror attack on a British military base. President Trump has withdrawn support from President Zelenskyy. Saudi Arabia is being bombarded with Houthi missiles and has asked Britain to come to her aid. UK household energy bills are set to rise by nearly 300 pounds in January, and diesel prices have hit 2 pounds a liter for the first time ever.

Against this backdrop, the Chancellor will deliver a budget in two weeks. The IFS has said that there is a 35 billion pound black hole in the public finances. More borrowing or more taxes are on the way because we know the Prime Minister will not cut spending. This is at a time when families and businesses are already suffering under the weight of 70 billion pounds in Labour's tax rises. So what has the Prime Minister chosen to focus on today?

Brexit. His exact words earlier this year were, "The last thing we should do right now is rerun those arguments." And yet here he is, unpicking the deal this country signed with the EU a decade after the referendum. He is not going to get a better deal. The EU are tough negotiators.

And Mr. Speaker, it's not just that the EU are tough negotiators, he has already revealed his entire negotiating hand. He has just blurted out everything he wants in this statement. And I will tell you, tell him now, Mr. Speaker, as a former trade secretary, this is not how you conduct negotiations. Over the weekend, over the weekend, he's told them everything and they haven't even started. Unbelievable.

Over the weekend, on the Rest is Politics podcast, he implied that the referendum result was illegitimate because of Russian interference. Where has this come from? We all remember in 2018, the head of MI5 said that there was no evidence that Russia had influenced the EU referendum result. Even this morning, his own Foreign Minister could not say if the evidence existed. So will he confirm, here and now, whether he believes the referendum result was legitimate?

And if not, will he publish the evidence that Russia swung the result of the 2016 referendum? From my perspective, Mr. Speaker, this is just another example of him trying to distract the country rather than solve the immediate challenges we face. And just like some people thought all of Britain's problems would be solved by leaving the EU, some now think all our problems will be solved by rejoining. Neither of these are serious positions. This is lazy thinking from people who don't have solutions to the real problems we face, like on defense.

The Prime Minister told us he would set out a target date for spending 3% of GDP on defense at the spending review in the spring. That spending review has now been delayed until next autumn. He has delayed procurement decisions, well, Labour delayed procurement decisions by a year to hold the Strategic Defense Review. Then the Defense Investment Plan took another 18 months. Now the armed forces have to wait another 12 months at least to find out what they're getting.

Defense of the realm is the first duty of any government. Kicking it into the long grass is a dereliction of duty. I welcome the support that he has set out for our allies in, for our allies in Saudi Arabia and Ukraine, but they will require money and there are still serious questions on defense that need to be answered. The United States have withdrawn their bombers from RAF Fairford. Can the Prime Minister tell us why?

And what does that mean for the safety of our British aircraft and more importantly British personnel at that base? He said in his statement that we will not tolerate threats from Iran on our soil. So were he and his Foreign Secretary aware of those threats before the Foreign Secretary met and shook hands with the Iranian Foreign Minister at the UN? And does the Prime Minister now think the Foreign Secretary was wrong to do that? On the 18th of July, we were told that the Prime Minister would grant licenses for the Jackdaw gas field and Rosebank oil field.

We are still waiting for a decision nearly three months later as a global energy crisis is looming. Can he now confirm exactly when he will approve these licenses? Britain cannot afford to wait until the end of the decade for him to act. He is the Prime Minister for today. Rather than promising things on the never-never, here are some things that he could do right now.

Cut welfare, fund our defense, drill in the North Sea, bring down people's taxes, get young people into work, build new prison places and put more police on our streets. He could do all those things today if he cut spending. That's what I would do. Instead he is trying to reopen yesterday's arguments to avoid today's decisions. So, Mr. Speaker, what this statement shows is the difference between that side of the house and this side of the house.

01:21:57 - 01:22:05

Speaker 104

We have answers to today's problems, they are living in the past.

01:22:05 - 01:23:11

Andy Burnham

Uh, can I thank the right honorable lady, Mr. Speaker. She started on the right point, which is the situation in the Middle East and the extent to which it is affecting cost of living pressures here at home, the cost of filling up at the pump, cost more, more broadly people are feeling. So she's absolutely right to say that that's where our focus should be, it's where my focus was when I had all of my meetings in New York and it's why I have taken action to remove VAT off electricity bills this month. So we are acting quickly on the cost of living and we will continue to do that. Mr. Speaker, I was listening carefully what she said about the European Union and one could only conclude from what she said about unpicking the deal, the deal that is supposedly so good for Britain, that she will be defending the status quo.

01:23:11 - 01:26:24

Speaker 96

I'm sure I heard her say at her conference that increasing growth would be the operating principle of any government that she leads. So how can she justify turning her back on a deal that is potentially on the table now to add billions to the UK economy?

How can they justify, how can they justify turning their back on farmers and the food industry who are finding it hard to export into Europe? I think they need to, I think they need to reflect on that, Mr. Speaker. And she says that, oh, I've revealed what I want to do and this isn't any way to negotiate. Because the Tories were so good, weren't they, Mr. Speaker, at negotiating deals with our, with our partners? She, can I just address the point that she said?

I implied no such thing in my comments on the Rest is Politics podcast. I think she should go back and, and look again. It is a matter of record, Mr. Speaker, that Russian actors sought to interfere in the 2019 general election and we think it is inconceivable that this was the first time. I have a question for the right honorable lady. I listened, I listened carefully to what she said at her conference last week when she was asked directly about Brexit twice, whether she thought Brexit had been good for London.

Twice she could not answer. She could not address the question even. And this is not going to be good enough for a party that once again wishes to lead this country. That is not leadership, Mr. Speaker, to turn your back on growth, to turn your back on building the British economy. On defense, Mr. Speaker, this government is already spending 14 billion pounds more every year than their last year in government.

We will continue to work with our US counterparts on RAF Fairford, Mr. Speaker. And can I say to her, every single foreign secretary, including David Cameron as the last Conservative foreign secretary, met representatives of the Iranian government. And she should look back at that as well as she should look back at her own record in government. She stands there today and says she will build new prison places. Why is there a crisis in our prisons?

Because they didn't when they were in office. We are dealing with the issues that she left behind. We are the ones that are providing leadership in difficult times and it is about time that the honorable lady faced up to some of those realities about the mess they left behind.

01:26:24 - 01:26:26

Lindsay Hoyle

Dame Emily Thornberry.

01:26:26 - 01:27:13

Anne Emily Thornberry

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I'm very grateful to the Prime Minister for treating concerted attempts to undermine our democracy with the seriousness that it deserves. Because whilst it is always difficult to measure the success of such campaigns, it is also difficult to believe that Russia would bother if there wasn't at least a chance that it might succeed. And one thing is for sure, that over the last 10 years Russia has certainly got better at it, whilst at the same time elements of the British state have been far too complacent about it. So to hear the Prime Minister announce a new center for information defense was very encouraging indeed.

Can the Prime Minister assure the House that this center will be publicly accountable, scrutinized by Parliament, and scrutinized in particular by the Foreign Affairs Committee?

01:27:13 - 01:28:05

Andy Burnham

I can indeed give those assurances to my right honorable friend, the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank her for the work she has done in making that recommendation. She is right to say that the wrong approach was taken in the past. The Intelligence and Security Committee report in 2020 said that the last government failed to seek evidence of any potential interference in our democratic processes.

We will not make those mistakes in the next decade as were made in the last, Mr. Speaker. The new National Centre for Information Defence is about putting Britain in a strong place to face the challenges in a difficult world, and that is what we will do.

01:28:05 - 01:28:58

Edward Leigh

Will the Prime Minister forgive him, forgive me, if I put some words in his mouth? Does he think this is a reasonable statement? Look, I've been elected by my MPs to serve a full term of government. I'm going to get on with bread and butter issues such as the care system, pensions, asylum, and of course, you know, we'd like a good close relationship with our partners on security in Europe. But I say this to the people, this is the Prime Minister speaking.

I am very wary about reopening the whole Brexit wars, years of harrowing negotiations, an even worse deal, and I give this absolute commitment that I would not seek to join the EU unless there was a general election first and I offered the British people a full referendum.

01:28:58 - 01:29:34

Andy Burnham

Can I say to the Father of the House that I stand by every single one of those words. I am not reopening the referendum. I respect the referendum result as I have just said a moment ago. But what I will do is take a pragmatic approach when I can boost growth in the British economy, when I can increase cooperation to get a grip on the boat crossings across the channel. I will do those things where I believe they can be in the country's best interests.

01:29:34 - 01:30:07

Speaker 96

And the deal that I've inherited coming into office represents an opportunity to secure progress on both of those things. And the case I'm putting to the House this afternoon is that it is a dereliction of duty from any member of this House to turn away from that possibility when we can support the food industry, we can support farmers, we can get Britain growing more strongly again. That is our responsibility in this House to serve this country's best interests, and that is what I will do.

01:30:07 - 01:31:32

Tanmanjeet Dhesi

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's statement and in particular his efforts to assist our allies and to forge closer ties as well as helping to de-escalate the situation in the Middle East. Mr. Speaker, it's clear that President Trump's efforts to lift sanctions on Russian diesel and then buy it is a real kick in the teeth for our Ukrainian friends and will allow Vladimir Putin to further fuel his deadly war machine. And no doubt nations like India, which was slapped with tariffs for buying Russian fuel, will decry and be left bemused through these haphazard hypocritical policies which actually stop our long-term strategic aims from being achieved. However, there have also been reports that US officials have been contacting European counterparts to stop Ukrainian attacks on Russian refineries and also limiting the supply of weapons and intelligence.

Can the Prime Minister confirm whether he has had any such discussions with our US or European allies and why we need to continue supporting our Ukrainian friends?

01:31:32 - 01:32:24

Andy Burnham

Well, I will always support our Ukrainian friends, Mr. Speaker.

And I can say to my honourable friend that I called President Zelenskyy on Saturday afternoon precisely because I recognised that he was in the middle of a very, very difficult 24 hours. I can also say to the House that the Chancellor of the Exchequer spoke to the US Treasury Secretary around the same time and talked about the importance of an energy ceasefire. It was good to see that proposal emerge from the President yesterday. That is the best possible outcome in the circumstances that we are in. It will get fuel flowing into the market as well as protect Ukraine throughout the winter ahead of us, and we will continue to make the case for that.

01:32:24 - 01:32:29

Lindsay Hoyle

Leader of the Liberal Democrats, Sir Ed Davey.

01:32:29 - 01:35:18

Edward Jonathon Davey

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And following the loss of his father, Roy, can I start by offering the Prime Minister and his family my deepest sympathies? I'm sure all of us were moved by the Prime Minister's words about his dad and his determination to fix social care and tackle the devastating impact of dementia on sufferers and their families. I hope we can work across the House to make that happen. Turning to the Prime Minister's words on Europe, Mr. Speaker, his predecessors turned a blind eye to the disastrous consequences of the Conservatives' Brexit deal.

So it is welcome to hear him recognise that damage today. We on these benches have consistently argued that their Brexit deal has made us all poorer, weaker, and less safe. So I'm glad the Prime Minister has arrived at the same conclusion as we have. But now it's time to do something about it. So the test of the Prime Minister's ambition is straightforward: if he wants growth and if he wants to cut the cost of living, will he drop Labour's red lines now and open negotiations on joining the single market and a customs union?

Because, Mr. Speaker, it would be a real dereliction of duty to refuse now to fix a deal we know isn't working. Every day, every week, every month of delay means more unnecessary costs for British businesses, more pointless red tape, more pain for British families. Being outside negotiations on AI safety, Made in Europe regulations, and migration agreements does this country real harm. Fixing our relationship with Europe is more important now than ever, especially at a time when President Trump is waging a trade war with Canada while signing a new trade deal with Putin. Never before have we seen a US President so hostile to the UK and our allies and so friendly to our adversaries.

We cannot afford to fudge or dodge on this issue, especially on Ukraine. So will the Prime Minister bring together a coalition of the willing behind a joint statement condemning Trump's diesel deal with Russia and calling on him to cancel it? Finally, Mr. Speaker, on the Prime Minister's comments about Russian interference in the Brexit referendum, that took courage after the Conservatives spent so long suppressing the evidence. So will he now present it to the House in full, alongside any evidence of interference in other UK votes, so we can understand the threat and make it a national security priority to protect our democracy from attacks like that?

01:35:18 - 01:37:16

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank the right honourable gentleman for his kind words about my about my dad? They are much appreciated, Mr. Speaker.

And can I agree with him in the way he presented the harm done to food and farming and other industries by the Brexit deal? It would seem that the party opposite is in denial about and not open to seeing how we can move forward to a better position for the country. And indeed, it's clear that British public opinion has moved, and I believe the public would now favour that we are not ideological but pragmatic in taking steps to support growth and improve our approach to tackling irregular migration. So I hope I can count on his and his colleagues' support if we can secure a good deal when this comes before the House. What I can't do, as much as I want to improve growth in the UK, I also want to maintain trust in politics, and I'm afraid I'm not prepared to revisit the red lines in our manifesto.

On Ukraine, I have had discussions with Chancellor Merz about bringing forward a meeting of the coalition of the willing, and I can update the House further as that proceeds. And finally, on the Brexit referendum, Mr. Speaker, I think it's really important in this moment to be open with people about everything that we've lived through in the last decade. I have been open, but I am also making sure that Britain is in a position where we do not face the same again. And I hope he too and his colleagues will support the new National Centre for Information Defence so that Britain never again faces the risk of interference in our democratic process.

01:37:16 - 01:38:13

Tanmanjeet Dhesi

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, can I commend the Prime Minister on what's been a flying start on the world stage? And can I commend news of a better, stronger deal with Europe that will cut costs and cut bills this winter? But it's very clear to us on the evidence that we've received that the deal we inherited has left red tape strangling our businesses in general and strangling small businesses in particular. But the EU's Made in Europe proposals risk destroying any ambitions to reindustrialise our country.

To avoid that peril, we are going to have to get serious with the EU in tackling unfair competition from China. So will the Prime Minister reserve the right to introduce new tariffs on unfairly subsidised imports from China so that British and European businesses have got a fair level playing field on which to compete?

01:38:13 - 01:38:40

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my right honourable friend? My apologies, I'm still getting used to being back, Mr. Speaker. And can I agree with him about the red tape that our businesses are facing? I read out examples in this House this afternoon. They used to be the party that would be the first to stand up and say, oh yes, let's remove red tape from our businesses.

01:38:40 - 01:39:10

Speaker 96

It sounds mightily like they were defending that red tape to me this afternoon. What's happened to them? They were meant to be the champions of free enterprise. Well, it falls to us to remove that red tape, and I will work hard, Mr. Speaker, to get that deal. I agree with him, though, that Made in Europe does present risks to British manufacturing, and I know he will have concerns about the automotive industry in the West Midlands.

01:39:10 - 01:39:39

Andy Burnham

I am raising those concerns with European partners. It is important that we get to an arrangement here that works for both the UK and the EU. After all, we are both trying to deal with the same issue, which is Chinese exports and the damaging effect that's having on our industry. So the way to approach this is to do it together, and that's the case that we're making to the EU.

01:39:39 - 01:40:19

Andrew Mitchell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the Prime Minister's international agenda, should he not also focus on the appalling humanitarian situation in Darfur, Sudan? On avoiding making policy on Israel, whose timing enhances Netanyahu's prospects of reelection? And on Yemen, as well as defending Saudi from these outrageous Houthi attacks, using Britain's deep historical links and connections in Yemen to support constitutional negotiations and prevent the situation from getting any worse?

01:40:19 - 01:41:21

Andy Burnham

Can I assure the right honorable gentleman that ending suffering in Sudan is very high on the Foreign Secretary's list of priorities, and also tackling the aggression from the Houthis is something that we are taking extremely seriously. Of course, providing support to Saudi Arabia as I've mentioned this afternoon, and we will be prepared to consider further requests as and when they come in. But I cannot accept what he said about Israel and Palestine. In this House, we have long supported a two-state solution. If we do nothing when a tender process is moving forward to build on the West Bank, we will allow that two-state solution to die in front of our eyes.

01:41:21 - 01:41:27

Speaker 111

The Foreign Secretary is not prepared to allow that, I am not prepared to allow that, and we strongly defend the stance we've taken.

01:41:27 - 01:42:01

Speaker 112

Mr. Speaker, in my negotiations with Commissioner Šefčovič, I agreed not only the reaccession of the United Kingdom to Erasmus+, but also that at this year's summit we'd deliver that food and drink agreement to bear down on costs in the supermarket, an emissions trading system linkage which means hundreds of millions of pounds in carbon taxes don't need to be paid by UK businesses, but also opportunities for young people to work, travel, and study in the UK. So can I say to the Prime Minister, anyone who sets their face against the deal that I hope he now pushes over the line on the 20th of November is in favor of adding costs to businesses and to households.

01:42:01 - 01:42:37

Andy Burnham

My right honorable friend is exactly right, Mr. Speaker, and can I commend him on the excellent work that he did to lay the groundwork for this deal. He is right, in these circumstances, at this moment in time, it is incumbent on every member of this House to do whatever we can to relieve pressure on British business. And that is what we will do, and it's interesting this afternoon that the country will be able to see that we're prepared to do it, but the other side is not.

01:42:37 - 01:43:15

Esther McVey

The Prime Minister opened today's statement with the words that he took a clear message to the UN that Britain is back and can be relied upon as a consistent and stable partner. Can the same be true and said of the Prime Minister? If so, can he tell me, does he plan to honor the Brexit referendum outcome as he said in May 2026 when courting the Brexit voters of Makerfield, or is he planning to overturn it either partially or fully?

01:43:15 - 01:44:05

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the right honorable lady that I am always a stable and consistent partner.

And indeed I will honor the results of the referendum as I always have for the last 10 years. And that is a clear commitment as is the commitment to our manifesto as I explained just a moment ago. But I am also going to lead and be prepared to set out options that I think are options that Britain should consider. If she is saying she is happy with the status quo she is in a minority in this in this country. People know Britain can do better than this.

I am determined to secure better for Britain. I'm just surprised that the other side is setting their ambitions for our country so low.

01:44:05 - 01:44:07

Lindsay Hoyle

Stella Creasy.

01:44:07 - 01:45:06

Judith Stella Creasy

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker I for one am really relieved that the Prime Minister isn't going to take any lessons from any member of the previous Conservative government when it comes to negotiating with Europe given what a mess they made of it. Their irrational hatred of anything to do with Europe meant they took us out of the bio-food security alert which means that British farmers don't get told when there's foot and mouth and took us out of the Eurodac system. He took us out... I'm watching the the member opposite say what she might want to look at some of the details that she helped negotiate. But they also took us out of the Eurodac system which means that we don't get the asylum data which makes protecting our borders harder.

So will the Prime Minister assure me and my constituents that he won't let Tory mistakes make border control and British farming harder to do and he will put the national interest first seek that data and ensure we have a future working with Europe not hating it.

01:45:06 - 01:45:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Just to remind members please address through the chair so we don't get into this attack on each other. Prime Minister.

01:45:13 - 01:46:08

Andy Burnham

Well can I say to my to my honorable friend she is right to raise the issue of the loss of immigration control that has come with the inability now to access data across the European Union. And it's something that the the people who promoted this this idea need to take on board and be held account for because the reality is we are in a weaker position when it comes to controlling immigration than we were just over 10 years ago Mr. Speaker. And it is really important as we go into this next phase that all sides of the house support the British position when we go towards this negotiation. Is any member of this house truly saying to me this afternoon that they do not want to have access again to that European immigration information? If they are saying that they need to be honest about it.

01:46:08 - 01:46:10

Lindsay Hoyle

Monica Harding.

01:46:10 - 01:46:56

Monica Harding

Thank you Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Foreign Secretary's speech on Sudan at UNGA. And the Prime Minister recently said that he would be really concerned to lose Sheikh Mansour Vice President of the UAE and owner of Man City from Manchester. But does he also recognize that the same individual is also reported by outlets including the New York Times as having a central role not only in Man City's contested success but also of the genocide famine and forced displacements happening across Sudan by the RSF. So when will the Prime Minister stand up to Sheikh Mansour and the UAE and call out their dishonest roles in Manchester and fanning the flames of conflict leading to the biggest humanitarian disaster in the world in Sudan.

01:46:56 - 01:47:21

Andy Burnham

Prime Minister.

My right honorable friend is clear that we want a humanitarian solution in Sudan without fear or favor and we will make that case very clearly to the to the UAE. And in relation to the wider issue I can confirm Mr. Speaker that all of my dealings will be published this afternoon in relation to any meetings with the owners of Manchester City.

01:47:21 - 01:47:23

Lindsay Hoyle

Joanna Baxter.

01:47:23 - 01:48:29

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome my right honorable friend's statement this afternoon, and he may be aware that the Ukraine Solidarity Campaign is today protesting outside the US embassy in London against President Trump's diesel deal, which will directly fund Putin's war machine. A war machine that broke its promise to stop targeting Ukraine's energy infrastructure less than 24 hours after it was committed to. A war machine that continues to bombard Oleshky, a city in the grip of a humanitarian crisis where people are being starved to death. And a war machine that is complicit in the forcible deportation and abduction of at least 20,651 Ukrainian children.

So will the Prime Minister impress upon the President of the United States that his diesel deal will cost his own voters, my constituents, and the people of Ukraine their safety?

01:48:29 - 01:48:57

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my honorable friend for the powerful way in which she puts her question. Can I assure her that Britain will always take the strongest possible approach towards sanctions on Russia, Mr. Speaker. The Foreign Secretary has recently announced new sanctions on the shadow fleet, on crypto, on oil companies in Russia, and we will continue to take that action, and we hope set a lead that others will follow.

01:48:57 - 01:48:59

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Julian Lewis.

01:48:59 - 01:49:27

Julian Lewis

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As the chairman who oversaw the publication of the Russia report as soon as the Intelligence and Security Committee was reconstituted, may I just ask the Prime Minister to explain to the House exactly how he thinks Russia was able to alter the result of the referendum?

01:49:27 - 01:49:51

Andy Burnham

Mr. Speaker, I've got great respect for the right honorable gentleman, but I didn't say that. I didn't at any point say that it altered the result. I simply come back to what I said earlier. It is a matter of record that Russia has sought to interfere in elections, the 2019 general election, and we think it is inconceivable that this was the first time.

01:49:51 - 01:49:53

Lindsay Hoyle

Bill Esterson.

01:49:53 - 01:50:55

Speaker 126

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister quite rightly mentioned in his statement the fact that 90% of Russian oil production is covered by UK sanctions. I very much welcome what he had to say about calling, joining calls internationally for a ceasefire on attacks on energy installations as well. But when he is discussing this with President Trump, will he remind the President that the biggest reason for our high diesel prices here and in the United States isn't the war between Russia and Ukraine, it is what is going on in the Strait of Hormuz and in Iran, and will he, when he's discussing it with the President, remind him that it won't cut the diesel price, the action he is taking, all it will do is fuel the Russian war machine?

01:50:55 - 01:51:36

Andy Burnham

Well, can I assure my honorable friend that we are using our good offices on every front to make sure that we get a solution with regard to the cost of energy in Ukraine. As I said before, an energy ceasefire is the best way to get fuel flowing into the market, and that has to be a reciprocal ceasefire. But also we are doing whatever we can to support the bringing forward of a solution in the Middle East. I discussed both of these matters with President Trump in New York. Britain stands ready to play its part on both fronts.

01:51:36 - 01:51:38

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Oliver Dowden.

01:51:37 - 01:51:38

James Oliver Dowden

Iran clearly views this country as its enemy, and I fear that they smell weakness. They have attacked or attempted to attack Diego, Akrotiri, and now Fairford. Does the Prime Minister agree that this demands a robust response, and will he confirm that if they are successful in attacking one of our bases, we will use direct action against Iran in legitimate self-defense, and will he provide enhanced support and assistance to our friends and allies who are under constant attack from Iran and its proxies, not just Saudi Arabia, but also the United Arab Emirates and indeed Israel?

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:52:23 - 01:52:50

Andy Burnham

Mr. Speaker, can I assure the right honorable gentleman that we are providing the most robust response to this situation. We've introduced a tough sanctions regime. We are taking every step that needs to be taken in close consultation with our United States counterparts. There is no suggestion at all that Britain is not playing its part.

01:52:50 - 01:52:52

Lindsay Hoyle

Baggy Shanker.

01:52:52 - 01:53:23

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

Mr. Speaker, Derby has the manufacturing talent and capabilities that will help Britain succeed on the international stage. And with a brilliant one billion pound order for 29 new battery electric trains at Alstom in Litchurch Lane, we're on a roll in our city. Does the Prime Minister agree with me that championing British manufacturing on the international stage, we can secure more of this work and secure jobs that our communities desperately need?

01:53:23 - 01:54:06

Andy Burnham

Well, can I pay tribute to my honorable friend for the work he has done with his colleagues in Derby to secure this investment and these new jobs. Mr. Speaker, Derby, the great city of Derby, will be a big beneficiary of this government's drive to reindustrialize this country. I was at Alstom myself with him. I saw what is being done, the apprenticeships that are there. We're proud of what is going on in the city.

And I will ask my right honorable friend the Chancellor, the First Secretary of State, to do everything they can to drive the maximum value for British jobs from every pound of public procurement in this country.

01:54:06 - 01:54:08

Lindsay Hoyle

Victoria Collins.

01:54:08 - 01:54:46

Victoria Collins

Mr. Speaker, as Liberal Democrats, we've long been calling for global leadership on AI from the UK. And so I'm pleased to hear the Prime Minister talk of that because we cannot get the best out of AI if we can't protect people from the worst, and the UK should be leading on that. But we also need to learn from online safety, and it needs to be government who take the charge and not big tech. So will the Prime Minister also listen to Lib Dem calls to call for an AI safety institute based on the International Atomic Energy Agency, based here in the UK, an international organization?

01:54:46 - 01:55:37

Andy Burnham

Can I say to the honorable lady that we do indeed already have an AI safety institute. And to be fair, I want to pay tribute to the previous Conservative Prime Minister who was instrumental in the establishment of that institute. And it's because of that that we have the president of Microsoft on the radio this morning saying Britain now is regarded as the world leader in AI safety. What we mustn't be, though, is complacent. It is why I am putting AI at the top of the agenda for Britain's presidency of the G20.

And I look forward to working with her, indeed members across this house, to make sure Britain brings together a global code of standards and principles that can capture the benefits of AI while guarding against the risks it poses.

01:55:37 - 01:56:38

Alex Sobel

Alex Sobel.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I first of all want to thank my right honourable friend for his speech at UNGA and the fact that he has committed or recommitted the United Kingdom to be a consistent and stable partner and to uphold the shared values in the UN Charter, which will be increasingly important as we enter the G20 presidency. Last week, I spent the week with the chairs of the British group in the Ukrainian Parliament, Deputy Speaker Korniyenko and Lesia Vasylenko, and they talked to me about how this winter, the El Niño winter, is going to be the hardest ever winter in Ukraine. Just this week, due to electricity outages because of Russian attacks, their sewage system broke in Kyiv. Can I ask the Prime Minister what additional support we can give, particularly to Kyiv, in terms of generators, in terms of solar panels, thermal batteries, and other humanitarian support to ensure that they can get through this exceedingly hard and difficult winter that is coming to Ukraine?

01:56:38 - 01:57:26

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say, Mr. Speaker, to my honourable friend, I don't think any member of this House has done more than him to support Ukraine through its darkest hour. And on the issue of energy infrastructure and protection for it, as well as helping Ukraine with renewable and sustainable energy systems, my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary was in Ukraine last week and was talking about these very issues, as well as visiting the site where one of the bomb attacks that killed children took place, and people may have seen the photos of that. So we are as engaged as he is. We won't waver in any way, shape, or form. We'll be there till the end, as I know will he.

01:57:26 - 01:57:28

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Roger Gale.

01:57:28 - 01:58:38

Roger Gale

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, I'm quite sure that the whole House will applaud the Prime Minister's reaffirmation of this country's support for Ukraine and will support the additional sanctions that we are seeking to impose. President Trump has effectively driven a coach and horses through those sanctions, has torn up the bill that he himself signed in the White House, and for the sake of his domestic audience is seeking to blame President Zelenskyy and Ukraine for the oil shortages that the United States is now facing, rather than placing that blame where it truly lies: his disastrous expedition in Iran. He didn't answer the question from the leader of the Liberal Democrats. Will he answer it now?

Will he join with my right honourable friend the Leader of the Opposition in unequivocally condemning this act of treachery by the President of the United States?

01:58:38 - 01:59:21

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr. Speaker, I did make it clear in my statement that when I heard news, I was immediately on the phone to President Zelenskyy offering any help that I could provide. And I think where Britain can best provide help is in trying to bring people back together to get a solution that works for Ukraine. And you have to think about that more than anything in these circumstances: what will be most helpful? And of course, it's critical to get the US, as we discussed in New York with President Trump, back to the concept of an energy ceasefire, and that is what he announced yesterday.

01:59:21 - 01:59:22

Lindsay Hoyle

Jonathan Hinder.

01:59:22 - 01:59:40

James Jonathan Hinder

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents in Pendle and Clitheroe want immigration to be controlled and managed in the best interests of the country. And I know the Prime Minister's constituents in Wigan feel the same. So can he confirm that as long as he's the Prime Minister, there'll be no return to freedom of movement?

01:59:40 - 02:00:18

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to my honourable friend, I take my responsibilities very seriously to my to my constituents. And that is why I've said consistently that the manifesto upon which members on this side were elected will be will be fully respected. What we have to look at are the options that are available for the long-term relationship. This country in the next decade needs to know where it's going. There is no assumptions here, and as I said in my in my comments, the British public will be the boss of whatever whatever is decided.

02:00:18 - 02:00:19

Kirsty Blackman.

02:00:19 - 02:00:55

Ann Kirsty Blackman

Prime Minister says when it comes to the relationship with the EU, the British public will be the boss. Given that Scotland last had a vote about whether or not to stay in broken Brexit Britain before Brexit was even on the cards, does he not think it's a wee bit cheeky to give the UK public a choice and the driving seat and the reins on whether or not to have a different future with the EU, but to refuse that same choice to Scotland on its future with the UK?

02:00:55 - 02:01:11

Andy Burnham

Well, I'm sure that like me, she will look at opinion polls in all parts of the country, including including Scotland. And can I just say, Mr. Speaker, no one is in this house today proposing a referendum.

02:01:11 - 02:01:13

Colin Daniel Aldridge

Dan Aldridge.

02:01:13 - 02:01:41

Speaker 144

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I also was pleased to hear what the Prime Minister had to say about AI, both in New York and again this afternoon in the chamber. Can I ask him to confirm that it remains his view that decisions about global principles and standards for AI should be taken by democratically elected governments representing working people and not by industry alone?

02:01:41 - 02:02:31

Andy Burnham

Well, I agree with her very forcefully. And that is why I am setting up a process under the banner of the G20 presidency that mirrors what this country did in 2008 when international agreement was needed about how to handle the financial crisis. So the Canadian Prime Minister, who was very much involved at that time, was in discussions with me about how we could create a process to mirror that for AI so that individual countries could then go back and embed those principles in their own in their own laws and statutes. So that is what we're trying to achieve. And I would be really pleased if the whole house would get behind this this endeavour as the UK is in the global spotlight.

02:02:31 - 02:02:32

Chuka Umunna.

02:02:32 - 02:03:01

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The so-called energy ceasefire is a farce. All but one of Ukraine's oil refineries has already been destroyed. This is about protecting Russia's oil refineries while Russia bombs Ukraine's power grid into obliteration and results in a health disaster. So will the Prime Minister commit to sending large-scale generators to Ukraine now?

And will he stand by our Saudi allies at UN Security Council and under Chapter 7 designate the Houthis as a terrorist organisation, yes or no?

02:03:01 - 02:03:31

Andy Burnham

Well, on the first part of what she said, Mr. Speaker, I heard her strong view on the energy ceasefire. But I was hearing from the President on Saturday afternoon asking me and the UK government to press for such a ceasefire. And I think that is right that we hear him and that we do everything within our power. And indeed, as I've said, there's been some progress on that front in the last 24 hours. On the second matter that she raises, I will reflect on what she said and come back to her.

02:03:32 - 02:04:04

Melanie Onn

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And traders at Grimsby Seafood Village will be welcome, will welcome any action to reduce the Brexit red tape and bring down energy bills for them. But I think that they would also want to know and want to hear him say explicitly, because he danced around in his response to my honorable friend earlier, that there will not be a return to freedom of movement and that in these negotiations we will not have to capitulate and join the Euro.

02:04:04 - 02:04:41

Andy Burnham

As I've said many times this afternoon, Mr. Speaker, we will honor the manifesto in full and the red lines are in place and they will remain in place. On the seafood purveyors of Grimsby, can I say that they will probably have noticed when I was talking about their plight and some of the difficulties they face, the lack of support that was coming from the benches opposite for them. I think they need to have a period of reflection on their approach on this whole matter and do some, do something to help British businesses that are struggling right now.

02:04:41 - 02:04:43

Speaker 136

Richard Tice.

02:04:43 - 02:05:01

Richard Tice

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister confirmed that the incident at RAF Fairford is likely coordinated in Iran. Can he comment on serious suggestions that some of those who have been arrested and then bailed had Iranian diplomatic immunity?

02:05:01 - 02:05:16

Andy Burnham

Well, I hope the honorable gentleman will understand that I am not going to get into those matters on the floor of this house. The Home Secretary will make a statement later today and will provide more detail.

02:05:16 - 02:05:52

Rupa Huq

Rupert Huq, Dr. Rupert Huq.

From clutching pride at the National Theatre to jamming Smiths with Ukrainian troops, we know that this PM gets culture. So can he revisit pragmatically the Tory mess that's left the really useful theatre group touring a production of Phantom of the Opera into Europe with Chinese, with a Chinese cast because of all the red tape, and also musicians crippled with no cabotage agreements by the costs, because it's killing gigs and venues.

02:05:52 - 02:06:20

Andy Burnham

Well, can I, can I say to my honorable friend, these are precisely the issues that we believe need a second look and we need to take a more pragmatic approach. And my honorable friend the Minister for Europe is having these discussions with Europe. I think we do want to see better arrangements for our British creative industries because they deserve it, because they are the best in the world and Europe wants to see and hear more from them.

02:06:20 - 02:06:22

Chris Stephens

Chris Stephens.

02:06:22 - 02:07:08

Simon Hoare

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, irrespective of how we voted in the referendum, I hope the Prime Minister will agree if one wants to be called a democrat, we have to abide by that decision and make it work. But the Windsor Framework illustrates that no deal is ever cast into tablets of stone and that things are capable of sensible evolution. But will the Prime Minister accept that at this time, as with always, businesses large and small, urban and rural, need certainty. They need to know the regulatory regime in which they are trading, the opportunities which exist, the barriers which they may need to overcome.

02:07:08 - 02:07:18

Speaker 137

So will he commit to whatever evolution he is envisaging, that that will be delivered speedily to be able to give confidence, certainty and clarity to North Dorset businesses and those across the country.

02:07:18 - 02:08:02

Andy Burnham

Well, can I commend the honorable gentleman on the pragmatic tone that he has taken and he's absolutely right to approach it in that way.

When I visit Northern Ireland, as I do, I hear a call for things to be changed and improved, evolved as he said, and that is exactly right. I did say in my statement, Mr. Speaker, the energy cost benefit for Northern Ireland could be significant. There could be up to a 20% reduction in wholesale energy costs. Now, why wouldn't I do everything I could to deliver that for the people of Northern Ireland? And he mentions the speed.

Well, if this whole House gets behind this drive to improve the deal, then we will get it through more quickly.

02:08:02 - 02:08:35

Torcuil Crichton

Mr. Speaker, I thank the Prime Minister for his statement and for highlighting the effect of Brexit on the salmon farming industry. Salmon farming is worth 189 million to the Western Isles, 34 million direct, over 200 jobs. Similarly, fishing, 16 million, most of that prawn exports to Spain and France. We are physically furthest from that EU market, but we need that deal. We need to get our fish in, we need to get our produce in, and while we're at it, let's get a deal for our young people to get them in studying and working in Europe.

02:08:35 - 02:08:53

Andy Burnham

My honorable friend puts it so well because he knows these issues so well, Mr. Speaker, because of the travel times to market. So if only people on the other side of the House had the level of understanding that he has just demonstrated, we would be in a better place.

02:08:53 - 02:09:38

Peter Smarth

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I note the Prime Minister's remarks concerning Russian interference in some recent and not so recent elections, and they raise serious questions for all of us who worry about the integrity of our democracy. Will the Prime Minister commit to reviewing whether campaign finance rules, both the ones that are in place at the moment and those being the welcome but limited steps being introduced in the Representation of the People Bill, whether they sufficiently guard against foreign interference through political donations? In particular, could I encourage him to look at a cap on donations, political donations, to limit the influence of ultra-wealthy individuals and potential foreign interests?

02:09:38 - 02:09:53

Andy Burnham

Can I say to the honorable lady, my right honorable friend the First Secretary is leading a task and finish group on cleaning up politics, and I'm sure she'd be very pleased to hear from her on the proposals that she's got.

02:09:53 - 02:10:31

Catherine Jane Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the 26th of October 2021, the then Conservative government's Elections Bill was going through the public bill stage. I was a shadow minister and I tabled a new clause related to foreign interference in politics. The then minister responsible for keeping our democracy safe replied to me in bill committee that she had not read the Russia report and asked me to explain it to her. Does the Prime Minister share my concern that the now Leader of the Opposition may not be fully across the detail?

02:10:31 - 02:11:05

Andy Burnham

Well, I wasn't aware of that, Mr. Speaker, but I am aware of what it says in the Russia report, quote, "written evidence provided to us appeared to suggest that Her Majesty's Government at the time had not seen or sought evidence of successful interference in UK democratic processes." That is indefensible, Mr. Speaker. This government will not make that mistake. We will ensure that we defend British democracy in the next decade in the way that it wasn't defended in the last.

02:11:05 - 02:11:58

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. When it comes to illegal immigration, the Prime Minister will be aware that in the last month, three boats have left Normandy bound for the Solent and South Coast. The government is giving France 662 million pounds, and yet the smugglers have simply moved down the coast. And on the 4th of October, nearly 150 people landed in Gosport against the will of local people, against the will of the local council, and against the safety advice of the Police and Crime Commissioner. It just sends a message to these evil people smuggling gangs that this is now a viable new route.

Does the Prime Minister agree with me, and on the basis that no one from the Home Office had the courtesy to either contact me before, during or after 150 people were landed on the shores of my constituency, would he perhaps be able to let me know what conversations are happening with France to try and shut down these routes from Normandy?

02:11:58 - 02:12:51

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady, I will look into what she just said about not being informed, because that, if I'm sure it is true, isn't good enough, and we will seek to ensure that the Home Office improve that, because these are difficult issues, and I know they were difficult issues as they presented in her constituency. But the answer is almost in what she said. We are working closely with the French, and it's precisely because of the success of that cooperation that the gangs are changing their tactics, and obviously she's seen the effect of that. But we will be relentless in changing ours to make sure that they don't, they don't succeed. So we will look at the issues that she mentioned, and, you know, we will endeavor to make sure there's no, no repeat.

02:12:51 - 02:12:59

Speaker 146

But it's precisely because we are succeeding in reducing the number of boat crossings that they are having to try different routes.

02:12:59 - 02:13:37

Helena Dollimore

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to strengthening relations with our European neighbors, and can I give him one example of how he can boost economic growth by doing just that on the south coast, where thousands of the people I represent have called for international trains to come back to Ashford International? It would boost our economy by 2.7 billion pounds, bring half a million more visitors to Sussex and Kent every year, and we have an international terminal sitting there ready to be used. It's a no-brainer. So will the Prime Minister give me his commitment that he will support this like the Transport Secretary?

02:13:37 - 02:13:46

Andy Burnham

She makes an excellent case, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend and I will ask the Transport Secretary to look into it and get back to her.

02:13:46 - 02:14:22

Speaker 148

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to the new National Center for Information Defense. It's a critical fact in preserving the integrity of our democracy. But the Prime Minister will be aware that the US State Department intends to spend tens of millions of pounds promoting ideological propaganda and supporting far-right parties in Western Europe, potentially including the UK. So will he give the House the assurance that the new National Center will be free to go where it needs to go without fear or favor in investigating misinformation and disinformation, and that that where necessary will include the activities of the United States?

02:14:22 - 02:15:10

Andy Burnham

Indeed, I will give him that assurance here and now. That's exactly the point, Mr. Speaker, that it should be free to do that and with independent oversight as my right honorable friend the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee said. Let's remember, the Russian government spend over a billion pounds every year on misinformation and disinformation, and we've got to be open-eyed about that and start to respond accordingly. It's not about a ministry of truth or whatever people wanted to say. It's about making sure that people are aware what is being done where there is interference in our democratic process, and it'll be more successful if it carries the full support of all sides of the House with the requisite independence and oversight.

02:15:10 - 02:15:46

Speaker 151

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Prime Minister for his statement. It is an absolute no-brainer that we move closer to our closest trading partner, the EU, and I know thousands of businesses in my constituency of Monmouthshire will welcome the reduction in costs.

And I'm sure Monmouthshire farmers too will be delighted that they were at the center of your statement today and the prospect of less red tape and lower costs when dealing with the EU. They were sold a lie by the party opposite about Brexit. So can the PM confirm with me that both Welsh lamb and Welsh beef exports will increase as a result of this statement today and the renegotiation with the EU?

02:15:46 - 02:16:23

Andy Burnham

Not as a result of this statement, Mr. Speaker, if only I had that power. But yes, if we can secure the deal that the statement is talking about. It is a really important moment, I think, for British farming. They've had a very difficult year. It's incumbent on me to do everything that I can.

And I can assure them, and she can assure them because she heard it from me, I will do everything I possibly can to get this deal over the line in the next five weeks.

02:16:23 - 02:17:03

Nigel Huddleston

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister has adopted a fascinating negotiating strategy by revealing his hand and his goals in advance of any discussions with the EU. Is he aware that the price of any deal therefore went up with every word that he said? And as a former trade minister, can I also advise the Prime Minister, because his officials and ministers clearly haven't, that actually it may not be as easy after all because of clauses in some of the 70-plus-something other trade deals that we did with other countries to unwind all the things he would like to do. It may not be as simple as he may think.

02:17:03 - 02:17:27

Andy Burnham

Well, can I again, Mr. Speaker, just reflect on the negotiating geniuses on the other side of the House, whose main strategy, as far as I recall, was insulting every member of the European Commission, every member state. That went well, didn't it?

02:17:27 - 02:18:13

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I congratulate the Prime Minister on his strong leadership at the UN and in preparing to host the G20 as well. And I welcome the National Center for Information Defense as a member of the Foreign Affairs Committee. But on the EU, it's about boosting the opportunities for our hospitality sector, our accommodation sector, and our tech sector. And they are the ones who talk about the great opportunities for young people to study, work, and live both here and being able to travel for people in my constituency to Europe as well.

So I welcome the talk of the work experience scheme in the EU summit. Could the Prime Minister say more about that scheme and whether it will lead to a youth mobility scheme which will really boost our growth in this country?

02:18:13 - 02:18:46

Andy Burnham

Well, that very much is part of the discussion at the summit, Mr. Speaker. And I believe that too is in our interest. If young people come here to study, they develop an attachment to the country that often bodes well for us for the rest of their lives. And also British students going the other way. These are the things that worked in the past.

There is no reason why this generation should not be able to take advantage of them. And I welcome her generous support for what we are trying to do.

02:18:46 - 02:19:53

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I'd first like to congratulate the new honorable member for Holborn and St Pancras who was with us here earlier and warmly welcome her to her place in this House with us. And I'd like to welcome much of what the Prime Minister's international statement contained, particularly his recognition of the disastrous effects of Brexit on our country. As far as I'm concerned, the faster we move to rejoin, the better.

But in his international update, there was no mention of the climate crisis. Does he not recognise that the climate crisis is one of the biggest international challenges facing us, that it requires keeping fossil fuels in the ground, and that therefore, given that COP31 is coming up next month, the government must rule out Jackdaw and Rosebank and move with all speed, move with all speed to the future of clean, green, renewable energy on which this country's future prosperity depends.

02:19:53 - 02:20:34

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank the honourable lady for her welcome for what I had to say today. On climate crisis, I can assure her that I wasn't silent in my speech to the UN General Assembly, and indeed the Foreign Secretary convened climate crisis-related events in New York. As I've said before, we will be pragmatic on oil and gas given that the country will continue to need to use it in the future, but where we agree is it's essential that this country builds the strongest possible bridge to a renewable future.

02:20:34 - 02:21:19

Katrina Murray

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Last week, one of the food production companies in my constituency contacted my office regarding an import of fish from the European Union, which has been held at Suffolk Coastal Port Health Authority because of a labelling discrepancy. The delay and potential refusal of entry has significant financial implications for the business, with storage and associated costs continuing to accrue while the container remains at port, with the increasing likelihood that this stock will have to be destroyed as time goes on. Can I ask for the Prime Minister's assurance that closer ties with Europe will make it easier for local businesses to import and export to the European Union.

02:21:19 - 02:22:05

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr Speaker, one can only imagine the frustration of the businesses who are trying to get that produce released. And the Minister for Europe just said, you know, we get calls like this all of the time. Why was there such indifference on the other side of the House to this situation? Why are we not working towards a pragmatic solution to get British goods flowing to market? I don't think the position that they're in is sustainable, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the example my honourable friend has just given, speaking up for businesses in her constituency, is one that the vast majority of people would say, well, right, get that fixed, and we will.

02:22:05 - 02:22:41

Lincoln Jopp

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Prime Minister for his statement, to which I listened very carefully, and in it he said, our resolve to defend ourselves is absolute. However, at that dispatch box on another occasion, he said that national security can't come at the expense of social security. Bearing in mind that our allies and our enemies are listening to our proceedings today, could he make it crystal clear to the world that he has no higher priority than the national security of the United Kingdom.

02:22:41 - 02:23:21

Andy Burnham

I can make it abundantly clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, that national security is my highest priority and the government's highest priority, and we will set out how we will meet our NATO commitments in due course. But resilience builds from the community level up, and we also have to have an eye to the resilience of our communities as well in a very changing world. So I was talking about social security in the broadest sense, Madam Deputy Speaker. They go together. I want a resilient and strong Britain in the 21st century.

02:23:21 - 02:23:52

Christopher Paul Webb

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The Prime Minister knows from our discussion cost of living is the number one issue my constituents raise with me and are struggling with right now in Blackpool South. So with the UK-EU summit now confirmed, does the Prime Minister believe this is the perfect opportunity to deliver real benefits for Blackpool businesses and families, including lowering food prices, more opportunities for young people, stronger defense, but more importantly for many of my constituents, further immigration controls we lost under the previous government?

02:23:52 - 02:24:38

Andy Burnham

So one of the most positive aspects of my meeting with President von der Leyen in New York was her openness to the conversation about restoring data sharing on immigration across the UK, across Europe. And that is something that Britain has long sought in the decade since Brexit. It is the control that we lost actually at the time of the, at the time of the referendum. It's one of the issues that doesn't get enough attention and it should get more. And I can say to him, I will work hard to see if we can get a practical arrangement on that very issue at the summit in November.

02:24:38 - 02:25:25

Robbie Moore

Madam Deputy Speaker, there's only just over five weeks to go to the European summit that the Prime Minister has announced. And the Prime Minister makes reference to our farmers, but the agricultural sector are putting out huge warnings at the moment. So I wonder if the Prime Minister could specifically reference and refer to CropLife UK's detailed report, which outlines that aligning the UK's crop protection rules with the EU is set to slash farming income by up to 810 million pounds in the first year alone, trigger steep falls in UK crop protection, and will significantly impact negatively the progress that was made through the Precision Breeding Act. Can the Prime Minister comment on those concerns that are being made right now?

02:25:25 - 02:26:01

Andy Burnham

Where I can comment, Madam Deputy Speaker, is in saying to him that the National Farming Union is very strongly in support of this, of this proposed, proposed deal. And we will, obviously we need to get the details on the table and I will listen, I will listen to what he's got to say and if he was to send me the report that he referenced, I will, I will take a look at it. But there is strong support for what we are trying to do to support British food and farming.

02:26:01 - 02:27:01

James Mark Sewards

Members will want to know that I want to get as many people as possible into this statement, so please if we can quicken the pace. Mark Sewards.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. In August, I had the privilege of visiting the Falkland Islands, an amazing place. And there I spoke with their government's representatives and they told me all about the opportunities presented by the Sea Lion oil development fund. Now, whatever one's opinion of the Sea Lion oil development, it's quite clear that the Argentine government, the government of Argentina, cannot threaten those that choose to get involved in this project and cannot choose to try and scupper it with external actions that do not match our ambitions. So I ask the Prime Minister today, will he set out his view on this and will he also say unambiguously that it is the Falkland Islanders' right to determine where their resources go?

02:27:01 - 02:27:24

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have consistently demonstrated our unwavering support for the Falkland Islanders and indeed for the Sea Lion project. I made that very clear in New York. I know the Foreign Office, Foreign Commonwealth Development Office are working hard on this very issue and we will say more in due course.

02:27:24 - 02:27:50

Robin Swann

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I fully recognize the need not to prejudice an ongoing investigation, but can the Prime Minister distinguish between the criminal investigation into the recent incidents at RAF bases and what measures the government is taking to establish whether other military bases face similar vulnerabilities, both at home and abroad, to protect our armed forces?

02:27:50 - 02:28:43

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I just assure the House that British police and security services have done everything that they should have done and have conducted the investigation with the utmost rigor in relation to RAF Fairford. It needs just to be said and put on the record. But he is right to press on base security more broadly. And I can assure him that I'm working with the Defense Secretary to ensure that we are doing everything that we can. We are confident in the way that we are managing the security of our bases, but we are not complacent and we will do everything necessary to secure them.

I pay tribute to those, though, who apprehended the trespassers at RAF Molesworth recently. That shows that we are being very vigilant when it comes to the security of our bases.

02:28:43 - 02:29:19

Alex Baker

Alex Baker.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's statement. To deter our adversaries, we're not only going to have to increase defense spending, but we're also going to have to mobilize our financial markets. I welcome that there are lots of good conversations going on between the UK and Canada at the moment, but the founding of the Defense Security Resilience Bank is going to take political leadership. So will the Prime Minister take that step, stand with Prime Minister Carney, and ensure Britain is at the forefront of building the financial power needed to deter our adversaries?

02:29:19 - 02:29:42

Andy Burnham

Well, I have had discussions with the Canadian Prime Minister at a certain football ground on this very subject, so I can assure her of that. But we are also looking at how we can pursue procurement cooperation more broadly. So we will say more in due course, Madam Deputy Speaker.

02:29:42 - 02:29:57

David Reed

David Reed.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. For the avoidance of doubt, can the Prime Minister confirm which country was responsible for the JLR hack, and more importantly, have there been any repercussions?

02:29:57 - 02:30:00

Andy Burnham

I will write to the honorable gentleman.

02:30:00 - 02:30:47

Patricia Ferguson

Patricia Ferguson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is estimated that Scotland is some thirty billion pounds a year worse off as a result of Brexit. We've already heard this afternoon the problems faced by the fishing and agriculture sectors, but in addition to those sectors, the creative industries, the financial services, architectural firms, engineering companies, tourism, and the creative sector have all identified problems arising for them and the people who work in those areas because of Brexit. In the EU summit to come, will the Prime Minister consider the opportunities there may be to advance the cause of those industries, particularly as they're so important to my home city of Glasgow?

02:30:47 - 02:31:31

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm looking forward to visiting Scotland later this week, and I hope to have those discussions. We can't accept the status quo. It's not good enough for Scotland. It's not good enough for Britain. And I was encouraged by the pragmatic approach by the honorable member for Dorset, one of the Dorset seats.

North Dorset, thank you. And I just hope once people... North Dorset or Dorset North, no. I hope we can encourage that same spirit of pragmatism onto the rest of the opposition benches in the weeks to come.

02:31:31 - 02:32:11

Mark Pritchard

Mark Richard.

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I thank the Prime Minister for his steadfast support for Ukraine and his early visit? But next year there may be a potential problem for Europe, and we have the Europe Minister here and the Defense Secretary, with the rise of National Rally in France and the AfD in Germany.

We might start to see support in NATO and some European nations fragment. So can I ask the Prime Minister if he'll work with the Defence Secretary, work with the Chancellor on defence planning and a defence budget should the United Kingdom need to do more for Ukraine in those circumstances?

02:32:11 - 02:33:00

Andy Burnham

Well, he is right to point to a very changing picture in Europe, and obviously we will have to be mindful of how the picture might change. I was pleased to welcome the NATO Secretary General to Oxfordshire, Madam Deputy Speaker, and we had an excellent discussion. Britain will remain at the heart of NATO and we will continue to do whatever we need to do. It's really important, it's right that members opposite challenge us about our commitments to defence from the other side of the House, but we are the third biggest contributor still to NATO and sometimes that point is missed. We are spending billions more as a government as we were and will continue to spend more as we go forward.

02:33:00 - 02:33:32

Sarah Russell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Younger generations in this country sacrificed a great deal during COVID to protect older generations and we all owe them our thanks for this. With the youth job grant and the Your First Home scheme, the government is taking concrete steps to try and improve opportunities for young people. Of course the Prime Minister must prioritise economic growth in his discussions with the EU, but can he please confirm that long-term commitment to Erasmus and a youth mobility scheme will be prioritised as well so that younger generations can have the same opportunities as my generation benefited from?

02:33:32 - 02:33:44

Andy Burnham

I can give my honourable friend that assurance, Madam Deputy Speaker. The youth mobility component of this matters as much to me as the other parts.

02:33:44 - 02:34:39

Bernard Jeremy Corbyn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Prime Minister for his statement and I hope that it's going to be a regular feature that he makes an international statement in the House. He's just come from the UN. What discussions took place about the future of the UN, the proper funding of the UN, the funding of the agencies of the UN and reform of the Security Council and the General Assembly so that it can play a real role in trying to bring about an end to the conflicts that are going on around the world? The world spent 2.7 trillion last year on arms, it's going to be more this year.

Surely there's a role for international peace institutions to try to bring about ceasefires where possible and peace wherever it can be achieved. Surely that needs to be the agenda. The last point I'd make is this. In reply to the member for North Herefordshire, he said there was going to be concerns about the environment.

02:34:39 - 02:34:44

James Mark Sewards

Order, order, order. I think the Prime Minister's got the gist. Prime Minister.

02:34:44 - 02:35:09

Andy Burnham

To meet the Secretary General of the United Nations in New York, and of course Britain will play its part in the support that the UN needs, making sure that its standing rises in these times in which we live because we need it more now than we have in recent times. And we will always be open to reform of the UN too, I can assure my right honourable friend of that.

02:35:09 - 02:35:42

Speaker 170

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Putin tax, the cost of Russian attacks on the UK, both cyber and physical attacks, is costing the British taxpayer around about 2.5 billion pounds each year.

Over the research my office conducted in the summer, however, we were unable to find a great deal of information about what the true cost of Russian hostile activity might be due to government not collecting that information. Can I ask the Prime Minister if he will commit the government to collecting more of that information and to publishing it to the UK public on a regular basis so they know the true cost to the UK taxpayer of Vladimir Putin's aggression?

02:35:42 - 02:36:12

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to my honourable friend that this was a topic of conversation with Chancellor Merz on our in our meeting in Berlin last week, and the cyberattacks that both Germany and the UK face are multiple and they pose serious risks for British business. It's why we have launched a new partnership on hybrid attacks. I agree with him about the importance of monitoring the data, and I will see what more we can do on that front.

02:36:12 - 02:36:42

Graham Stuart

Graham Stuart.

Madam Deputy Speaker, you're not looking at me. Can I thank the can I thank the Prime Minister for his statement and his commitment to being more straightforward with the House than perhaps has always been the case over the last couple of years? And in that light, could he give the House his unequivocal assurance that he believes that the Brexit referendum was legitimate and he will say so on the record?

02:36:42 - 02:37:04

Andy Burnham

I will very much say so on the record, Madam Deputy Speaker. It was legitimate. I have always respected the result. I have never questioned its legitimacy, but I am within my rights to point out where foreign actors are looking to interfere in British democracy.

02:37:04 - 02:37:30

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The last ten years of poor Brexit deals have taken a toll on our business and economy, including a lot of SMEs in my Calder Valley constituency who are looking to grow. We all want less red tape for business and frictionless trade with our largest trading partners. So can the Prime Minister seek a deal that opens up possibilities for my breweries, farmers, and manufacturers to help them grow?

02:37:30 - 02:37:56

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, if if we get to a deal and it doesn't do all of the things he just mentioned, then it won't be the right deal. I I know I'll be in a stronger position the more that people on all sides of the House get behind what I'm what I'm saying. That will put Britain in the strongest place to negotiate a deal. That would be a good negotiating strategy, and maybe the opposition might consider it.

02:37:56 - 02:38:11

Saqib Bhatti

Saqib Bhatti.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The whole House will have noted when the Prime Minister was asked about freedom of movement, he evaded the question. So can I ask him directly, it's a simple yes or no. If there is any negotiation, future negotiation about rejoining the EU in the future, freedom of movement will not be on the table.

02:38:11 - 02:38:39

Andy Burnham

The honourable gentleman's getting way ahead of himself. There's no proposal for a a referendum. There's no deal on the table. All I have said is as we go towards this negotiation, it makes sense to consider also our longer-term options because it helps our European partners if they know where Britain wants to go in the future. That is all that is being said at this moment in time.

02:38:39 - 02:38:41

Laura Marie McEvoy

Lola McEvoy.

02:38:41 - 02:39:07

Speaker 186

Thank you very much. Britain has enormous strengths in AI. We attracted almost as much private investment as the EU 27 combined last year, but in an industry dominated by the United States and China, it's only by cooperating with our friends in Europe that we can achieve the scale necessary to keep ourselves safe and to thrive. So does the Prime Minister agree that a technology partnership is one of the ways in which we can rebuild our relationship with the EU?

02:39:07 - 02:39:44

Andy Burnham

I think it's an excellent thought and it's exactly what we may be able to strengthen as part of our G20 presidency year. But can I just point him towards the actions of the AI minister, who has secured access for the AI Safety Institute, regained access to AI from US AI frontier models. So this shows that we are in a good position to broker new new standards on AI across across the world and make partners with all of and make arrangements with all of our partners.

02:39:44 - 02:39:46

Ben Morgan Lake

Ben Lake.

02:39:46 - 02:40:11

Speaker 180

Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend the Prime Minister on his statement and specifically his acknowledgement of the significant harm that Brexit has wrought on our communities.

I also welcome his desire for a serious conversation about the long-term relationship with the European Union. Would he agree that for any dialogue to be serious, it has to include the whole range of options, including membership of the Customs Union, the Single Market, and possibly the European Union?

02:40:11 - 02:40:50

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm pleased that he has taken an open-minded approach. At this stage, it is right, I think, as we look to move beyond a decade that wasn't the best for Britain, let's be honest about it. We've got to have a discussion in here about where do we want to go, where do we want to take this country in the next decade, and let's be clearer about our direction in the next decade than we were in the last. That is what I'm going to try and bring as Prime Minister for this country. And I'm not going to turn away from questions just because they might be awkward or difficult.

02:40:50 - 02:41:11

Speaker 189

That is what's got us into a position that we are in where we've turned away from things that we should have dealt with. I'm not going to do that, and I appreciate the spirit he's showing today. I think that's what the country needs to have as we go forward from here.

02:41:11 - 02:41:54

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I congratulate the Prime Minister on the work he's doing with allies to promote resolution to conflict around the world, particularly in the Middle East and in Ukraine. Nevertheless, my constituents in Dartford remain extremely anxious about the effect of the situation in the Strait of Hormuz upon their fuel bills going into what will probably be a difficult winter. So can the Prime Minister provide reassurance that he will be trying to protect the most vulnerable from increases in energy bills going forward, but also that he will continue our acceleration away from dependence on fossil fuel and much more towards renewables so that we're less open to energy price shocks in the future?

02:41:54 - 02:42:16

Andy Burnham

I can assure my honourable friend that reducing the cost of energy is a core priority of this government, as I said at the conference in Liverpool just over a week ago. I've already removed VAT from electricity bills. There is more to come, and we will set that out soon.

02:42:16 - 02:42:32

Speaker 179

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If the Prime Minister is so keen to support our farmers, there's one step that he could take which is entirely within his control, and that is to scrap the family farm tax. So will he do that and show a genuine commitment to our farmers?

02:42:32 - 02:42:43

Andy Burnham

As she knows, changes have been made, Madam Deputy Speaker, but it's not the only issue affecting British farming, and that's why I'm making the statement that I've made today.

02:42:43 - 02:43:12

James William Naish

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This Minister loves his music, as does Rob, a member of my constituency who's a member of the Musicians' Union, and he welcomed the government's plan for music, Turn It Up, and its support for local venues, but it is quiet about what the future relationship will look like with Europe when it comes to touring. So with 59% of musicians saying that EU touring is no longer viable, will he commit to putting visa waivers on the table for this specific purpose on the 20th of November?

02:43:12 - 02:43:23

Andy Burnham

Let me be plain, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to see the return of visa-free access to Europe for British musicians and performers.

02:43:23 - 02:44:09

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the 20th of September, Javier Milei initiated Annex 7 arbitration proceedings against the United Kingdom in relation to halting activities at the Sea Lion oil field. That deadline expired yesterday, and so I assume that we haven't complied. The Government's already said that they would robustly defend the Falkland Islands against this, which means that Javier Milei will now initiate the proceedings under ITLOS. That's great, and I agree that we should be pushing against that.

But last year, last May, the former Defence Secretary stood at the dispatch box and said that the most proximate and potentially most serious legal challenge facing us about the Chagos Islands was the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea. So why are we prepared to defend the Falkland Islands against ITLOS but not the Chagos Islands?

02:44:09 - 02:44:38

Andy Burnham

Well, I've been very clear this afternoon, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we will defend the Falkland Islands, and I reiterated that to the Falkland Islands Government at our recent conference. And I did discuss the matter of the Chagos Islands in New York, and particularly the crucial need to secure the future of our base at Diego Garcia, and I can assure him that's what we will do.

02:44:39 - 02:45:04

Speaker 91

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of my younger constituents feel that their horizons have been shortened and their opportunities limited by the restrictions on their ability to travel, study, and work in Europe post-Brexit. They simply want the same opportunities that were available to the generations before them. Does the Prime Minister agree with me that through a new youth experience scheme, they should get those opportunities?

02:45:04 - 02:45:27

Andy Burnham

Well, I believe this generation now, which has so much potential, so much promise, deserves the same that so many of us took for granted, which is the ability to travel and study in Europe with ease. And that is why, as I said a moment ago, the youth mobility component of the proposed deal matters greatly to me.

02:45:27 - 02:45:28

Robert Jenrick.

02:45:28 - 02:46:09

Edward Robert Jenrick

We now know that Iran has targeted bases on our soil. We already knew that Iranian agents who had been charged with terrorism offences entered the United Kingdom on small boats. So will he do what we would, which is declare a national security emergency? Because we have a gaping hole in our borders right now. Send the Royal Navy into the Channel and shut down the entire asylum farce once and for all to truly fulfil his duty as Prime Minister, which is to keep the British people safe.

02:46:09 - 02:46:34

Andy Burnham

I can remember a time when the right honourable gentleman stood up in this House and made serious proposals. Sadly, not today. If he'd checked the facts recently, he will see that small boat crossings are coming down under this Government. When he was Immigration Minister, what did they do? They went up and up and up.

Those are the facts. He should engage with them.

02:46:35 - 02:47:18

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, you'll be aware that I absolutely love my town of Harlow. Somebody who loved it even more than me, and apparently the Member for Bracknell, was the late great Jean Clark, a former Harlow councillor who sadly passed away during recess. She will be dearly missed, and I would love the Prime Minister to pay tribute to a real Harlow legend. He will also be aware that many small and medium-sized businesses in Harlow depend on trade with the EU.

They've been really pressured by the increased red tape that we've seen since Brexit. Would he confirm to those businesses that what he's talking about is not a rerun of the Brexit referendum or a rerun of those negotiations, but actually ensuring that we get the best deal for businesses in Harlow?

02:47:18 - 02:47:45

Andy Burnham

Well, he's paid a very touching tribute to Jean there, and absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm very pleased to reiterate that too from the dispatch box. I know she'll be much missed in Harlow.

And he's exactly right. It's not about re-running anything. It's about getting a pragmatic arrangement that improves the position from where we are now. I think most of the common sense people of Harlow will fully understand what I'm trying to do.

02:47:45 - 02:47:46

Patrick Spencer.

02:47:46 - 02:48:32

Speaker 181

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I just clarify? The Prime Minister said he wanted to increase defense spending, but then he backtracked. He then said he was going to prioritize welfare before, sorry, he promised to cut welfare before prioritizing it over defense. Now, despite a commitment not to reopen the Brexit debate, that's exactly what he's done.

So, he said here in the chamber, no referendum. Does that mean he would consider taking Britain back into Europe unilaterally?

02:48:32 - 02:48:41

Speaker 191

I was trying to follow that question, Madam Deputy Speaker, but it was going in all so many. And the answer to that is no. Full stop.

02:48:41 - 02:49:18

Peter Swallow

Peter Swallow.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister is right to be honest with the British public. Brexit has made us economically and socially poorer. It has made it harder to tackle illegal immigration and it is driving a cost of living crisis for my constituents. That's why the Prime Minister is also right to say the status quo cannot hold.

Can I urge him to take a position of maximum pragmatism ahead of the EU summit in November so we can make sure we get a closer relationship with Europe and a better deal for the British public?

02:49:18 - 02:49:30

Andy Burnham

I will absolutely do that, Madam Deputy Speaker, and already the quality of the conversations is improving and I'm confident that we can steer this to a successful conclusion.

02:49:30 - 02:49:32

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Wera Hobhouse.

02:49:32 - 02:50:09

Speaker 76

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Bath we led the rebellion against Brexit and I have raised time and again here in Parliament how the Conservatives' botched Brexit deal has harmed hundreds of small businesses in my constituency in Bath. And we have already heard this afternoon that it is not just in the food and drink industry, but endless paperwork and red tape harms all business sectors and particularly small businesses. And as well I recognize that he is focusing on the next six weeks, could he perhaps outline his ambition of how to negotiate cutting red tape and endless paperwork for businesses across the board and support small businesses like mine in Bath?

02:50:09 - 02:50:36

Andy Burnham

Well, that is the deal that's on the table, Madam Deputy Speaker, not for the whole of the economy, but for those sectors that I've mentioned today. And if we can land that, then I think it points to going further in the future. So I appreciate that she's been a consistent voice on this matter, if only her pragmatism was mirrored on the benches in front of me.

02:50:36 - 02:50:37

Ewan Stanbank.

02:50:37 - 02:51:05

Euan Stainbank

Speaker, the Prime Minister will be aware of the concerns of our vehicle manufacturers about the consequences if the UK does not secure exemptions from made in Europe as drafted, and I welcome his assurances that the government are prepared to act to harmonize our approach on Chinese imports in order to achieve this. Does the Prime Minister also agree that if there are any changes to tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles, there is no reason why there would be a different approach as compared to Chinese electric bus imports?

02:51:05 - 02:51:34

Andy Burnham

Well, my honorable friend will remember when we visited Alexander Dennis in his constituency when Greater Manchester was buying buses from there. I've got the strongest of commitment to Scottish manufacturing and indeed manufacturing across the UK. It's why we need to make common cause with Europe on the whole question of tackling Chinese exports and the damaging effect that they can have on undercutting British industry.

02:51:34 - 02:51:36

Luke Brandreth

Luke Brandreth.

02:51:36 - 02:52:12

Speaker 89

In recent weeks, we've seen once again that Iran poses a grave threat to British people and our allies. Our intelligence relationships are our first line of defense and Israel is among our most valued partners in countering that threat. Given the fallout from his decision to sanction Israeli settlements and the deteriorating relationship that has followed, will the Prime Minister give the House a clear assurance today that intelligence cooperation with Israel is continuing in full, or is he putting at risk the safety and security of the British people?

02:52:12 - 02:52:44

Andy Burnham

Madam Deputy Speaker, it's possible to have differences on one issue but then cooperate on others. And of course we cooperate on intelligence and security with many international partners, including Israel. And can I say to her as well, we also have been in discussions about the British presence in East Jerusalem and we work to secure British interests all of the time.

02:52:44 - 02:53:40

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now as part of his international update, I'm very interested to hear what the Prime Minister has to say about yet again foreign ownership closing vital Scottish industry. This time it is Syngenta's Chinese owners in Grangemouth who are going to make 377 people redundant on site and we all know that that really means thousands in the wider supply chain. Now the Prime Minister is right when he talks about the pressing need to reindustrialize vast parts of the country. Will he come to Grangemouth and listen to local people who have had the heart ripped out of their community and will he commit to spending the 200 million pounds from the National Wealth Fund to save jobs and build the industrial future that Grangemouth and Scotland needs?

02:53:40 - 02:54:00

Andy Burnham

Can I say to my honorable friend that I do want to visit Grangemouth as soon as my diary allows because I recognize some of the very difficult issues that he is dealing with and we have to secure a good transition for industry in his constituency. Can't give him a date today, but I'd give him a commitment that I will as soon as I can.

02:54:00 - 02:54:29

Speaker 197

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Northern Ireland voted to remain and believe me, nowhere part of the UK has suffered more through Brexit than Northern Ireland. If there's now a chance to make sure that my constituents in Lagan Valley have cheaper electricity, we're there. What communication can the Prime Minister give to me today that he is in live discussions with my colleagues in the Northern Ireland Executive to make sure that Northern Ireland gets the best out of any possible deal?

02:54:29 - 02:54:45

Andy Burnham

Well, that's my stated intent from this dispatch box, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I hope we can work together with her and her colleagues to deliver what could be a very real change that is felt by her constituents and many more.

02:54:45 - 02:54:57

Speaker 193

Madam Deputy Speaker, now for the fourth time of asking, in any negotiations with the EU, will the Prime Minister rule out a return to freedom of movement?

02:54:57 - 02:55:25

Andy Burnham

Simple. It's not on the table, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's not up for discussion. So I'm sorry that it doesn't suit his political purpose. And can I just clarify, Mr. Speaker, the National Farmers' Union are waiting to see the terms of any deal, so they are neutral at this moment in time.

I just thought I'd better correct the record before the end of this session.

02:55:25 - 02:56:04

Jim Allister

Does the Prime Minister view himself as the Prime Minister of Britain or the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom? I ask because the SPS deal that he seeks to negotiate with the EU is exclusively a GB-EU SPS deal, meaning that Northern Ireland remains under the colonial rule of the EU on all SPS matters, whereas if it was a UK-EU deal, the UK could take back control in Northern Ireland of EU laws which presently we have no say whatsoever over.

02:56:04 - 02:56:28

Andy Burnham

Well, I can say to the honorable gentleman that this will also have the effect of reducing checks in the Irish Sea, which will bring a benefit for his constituents, and also of course the bigger benefits for Northern Ireland are in relation to energy, and you know I think that's something that his constituents would want me to pursue.

02:56:28 - 02:56:44

John Kieran Mullan

Kieran Mullen.

The Prime Minister likes to present himself as a straight-talking kind of guy, but again and again he's been asked a straight question and not given a straight answer. Can he rule out, yes or no, taking Britain back into freedom of movement while he's Prime Minister?

02:56:44 - 02:57:09

Andy Burnham

I mean, I don't know how many times, Madam Deputy Speaker, I need to remind the honorable gentleman of the commitment I made to the red lines in the manifesto, which include freedom of movement. And I don't know if he has just not been listening even though he's been sat there all afternoon. It's simply not on the table in these discussions.

02:57:09 - 02:57:56

Luke Taylor

Luke Taylor.

The Prime Minister spoke encouragingly about closer ties with the EU, and between this and renewed appetite for electoral reform, I welcome the Labour Party's recent adoption of Liberal Democrat policy priorities. The leader of the Conservatives was right to say the opposition has won the argument, it just wasn't her. On international relations, Britain has always straddled two global alliances: European neighbors and our global Commonwealth brothers and sisters. So with that in mind, to build a more comprehensive global security network and to unlock future growth, to add to the closer links with the EU he's committed to, could he inform the House what the government's position is on strengthening integration with Canada, New Zealand, and Australia, and will he also meet with the newly formed CANZUK APPG to discuss this important issue further?

02:57:56 - 02:58:27

Andy Burnham

Can I say that I will at some point, but I will come back to him as to precisely when. But I had an excellent conversation with the Prime Minister of Canada, as I referenced a moment ago, and I think there is huge importance in the English-speaking world uniting in this moment, working together, navigating a difficult climate, but also forging new partnerships to do so.

02:58:27 - 02:58:52

Luke Morgan Evans

Dr. Luke Evans.

The Falklands have to get explicit permission to have new oil and gas licenses from this country. So would he consent to them? If yes, then why is it okay to drill in the South Pacific but not in the North Sea? And if no, how does that figure with self-determination of the Falkland Islands?

02:58:52 - 02:59:17

Andy Burnham

Well, he's jumping to a conclusion that he's made that I've made decisions on the matters in relation to the North Sea. But I've been very clear that we support the Falkland Islanders' right to self-determination. We will defend it resolutely in the face of hostility from Argentina, and the Foreign Secretary will say more on that in due course.

02:59:18 - 03:00:03

Alexander Christopher Murray Law

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister will be acutely aware as a proud unionist that despite Scotland voting overwhelmingly to remain in the EU, it was dragged out against its will because it's part of the United Kingdom.

Since then, support for Scottish independence has only risen. Two-thirds of the last 22 independence polls show support for independence. The Scottish Parliament has the highest majority ever of pro-independence MSPs, and it voted 72 to 55 in favour of a Section 30 agreement for a referendum on Scotland's future. In the Prime Minister's own words to me last month, Madam Deputy Speaker, a clear consensus has now been met. So I ask the Prime Minister a simple question: what steps is he now undertaking with the Scottish Government to secure a legal pathway so that Scotland can decide its own future and rejoin the EU?

03:00:03 - 03:00:20

Andy Burnham

The discussions I'm having with the Scottish Government and will have later this month are on a model of deeper devolution for Scotland that can get growth going in all parts of the country. That's where my priority lies and that's what I will do.

03:00:20 - 03:00:54

John Richard Foord

Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the clarification that the Prime Minister made that he believes that the EU referendum was legitimate. The Intelligence and Security Committee recommended six years ago that the UK intelligence community should produce an assessment of Russian interference in the EU referendum and an unclassified summary be published. That didn't happen. Why does the Prime Minister think that his predecessors have been so reluctant to speak about Russian attempts to interfere in the referendum?

03:00:54 - 03:01:16

Andy Burnham

Well, he might ask the honourable gentleman to his left there because, as I say, the Russia committee, the Russia report from the ISC, said, found that Her Majesty's Government had not sought evidence. So that, those are the facts as found by the, by the committee, and those are matters and questions for that government rather than this one.

03:01:16 - 03:01:40

Ayoub Khan

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister has told this House repeatedly about the involvement of Russian authorities in our democratic process and the fact that they're willing to spend millions and millions of pounds to interfere in our democratic process. Given that, does the Prime Minister concur with me that photo identification at polling stations during elections is not just important but an absolute necessity?

03:01:40 - 03:01:59

Andy Burnham

I would say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we do want to uphold the highest standards of security in our voting system, but the bill before the House does that as well as allowing more people the ability to vote.

03:01:59 - 03:02:37

Vikki Slade

Today was a very sad day for my residents in Mid Dorset and North Poole with the very last sailing of the Barfleur from Poole to her twin town of Cherbourg in France after 34 years of continuous trade. And it was blaming Brexit red tape, food export restrictions, travel limitations on people who only can travel 90 in 180. Will the Prime Minister please ask his officials to do all they can to keep the window of opportunity open to keep this going and make sure that in the UK-EU summit, the issue of UK ports and their role is included?

03:02:37 - 03:03:03

Andy Burnham

Well, the honourable lady raises a really important point, and the Minister for Europe has just said that he's willing to meet with the honourable lady to discuss that because it is a shame, a real shame with that level of history. But again, I come back to it, that's why we're trying to negotiate a better arrangement, and we will do exactly as she says and look at how what we're trying to achieve could benefit British ports.

03:03:03 - 03:03:29

Claire Louise Young

Madam Deputy Speaker, talk of an energy ceasefire shows once again how central energy security is to national security. So will the Prime Minister reassure the House that the rumoured cuts to the DESNZ budget will not undermine his government's ability to protect our critical energy infrastructure or indeed to protect our constituents from the sort of high energy bills that undermine society's cohesion?

03:03:29 - 03:03:58

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady that protecting our critical national infrastructure and our energy infrastructure is a crucial part of national security. It's at the essence, it's the essence of the deal, the partnership we struck with Germany last week. And we will ensure that there is sufficient funding to achieve that via the Ministry of Defence and indeed DESNZ too.

03:03:58 - 03:04:19

Max Wilkinson

The EU asylum and migration pact ticks all of the Prime Minister's boxes in terms of bringing control and safety to the asylum system and it's cheaper than the bilateral agreement that his government is making with France and Belgium. So why isn't it on the agenda for his government?

03:04:19 - 03:04:29

Andy Burnham

Well, I'm happy to look at what the honorable gentleman has to say if he writes to me in detail on that very matter.

03:04:29 - 03:04:58

Kit Malthouse

During the last couple of hours, I've heard the Prime Minister talk about three of the four pillars of our national defense: our military, our resilience, and our alliances. But he's yet to mention the fourth crucial pillar, which is the importance of the international rules-based order and the institutions that underpin it. So can I ask, is he going to take any active steps to defend the International Criminal Court and the UK citizens who work there against the American sanctions that have been placed upon it?

03:04:58 - 03:05:11

Andy Burnham

Obviously, we are looking at the decisions that have been reached in relation to that very issue and we will of course defend any British citizens who've been unfairly treated.

03:05:11 - 03:05:28

Peter Richard Prinsley

I've listened carefully to what the Prime Minister had to say and I'm very grateful to him. Would he agree with me that in our international affairs we must do all we can to support the BBC World Service, which is the voice of this country to the world, the voice of truth and facts?

03:05:28 - 03:05:38

Andy Burnham

Indeed, I'm a very big supporter of the World Service, indeed of the BBC as a whole.

03:05:38 - 03:05:48

Michael Peter Martin

Will the Prime Minister state categorically that he's in no way considering a May 2027 general election?

03:05:48 - 03:05:53

Speaker 208

Yes.

03:05:53 - 03:06:20

Ben Maguire

The US President's disastrous war in the Middle East has massively driven up LPG and heating oil in my rural North Cornwall constituency. Pensioners and struggling families will be forced to leave their heating off, risking their health. As reducing bills is the Prime Minister's stated priority, will the Prime Minister please consider removing VAT on heating oil and LPG and include them within the energy price cap?

03:06:20 - 03:06:48

Andy Burnham

Well, I understand the point that the honorable gentleman is making. Obviously there are different parts of the UK that are more dependent on heating oil and that issue has really come to the fore throughout the course of this year. So I will consider what he's got to say and just to clarify in relation to the last question: yes, in no way am I considering a May 2027 general election.

03:06:48 - 03:07:18

Andrew Rosindell

I know that the people of the Falkland Islands will be reassured by the Prime Minister telling President Trump and the UN General Assembly that the clear and declared will of the islanders is to remain British. But will he please afford the same rights to the people of the Chagos Islands? Surely all citizens of overseas territories should have the right of self-determination and the right to stay British.

03:07:18 - 03:07:39

Andy Burnham

Well, we will certainly uphold our obligations in respect to the Falkland Islands, Madam Deputy Speaker.

And as he knows, the issues related to the Chagos Islands are are different, they are not strictly comparable, but we will always take the right and fair approach.

03:07:39 - 03:08:13

Speaker 211

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister is confident that closer ties with the EU will deliver growth. But what evidence can he provide to this House that this will translate into tangible improvements for the communities that felt left behind by globalization and then voted Brexit? Does he accept that we have a duty to respect that democratic decision and that reopening this deeply divisive debate must be justified by clear, measurable benefits that could not be achieved otherwise outside the European Union?

03:08:13 - 03:08:57

Andy Burnham

The clear, measurable benefits are containers and lorries full of fresh produce not sitting at ports and and going off. That is a clear and measurable benefit to a business, as is an extra several billion pounds size growth in the UK UK economy. I would not be pursuing this were there not tangible differences for British business at the end end of it. The figures are from the Treasury, they quantify at least 2% increase 0.2% increase in UK GDP if we get the right deal, possibly more, and that is worth pursuing at this moment in time.

03:08:57 - 03:09:00

Speaker 216

And the final question, Jim Shannon.

03:09:00 - 03:09:39

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, my legs are the strongest legs in this chamber without a doubt. Closer alignment with Brussels has caused great alarm with my constituents in Strangford and indeed across parts of Northern Ireland as well. If this is government's idea of a reset with Europe involving further alignment, will the Prime Minister explicitly state today whether he intends to permanently lock Northern Ireland under foreign laws in an unelected European court, or will the Prime Minister finally take a hard line to fully restore the Acts of Union and the internal market of the United Kingdom as it should have been from the start? All together or not at all must be the message. Thank you.

03:09:39 - 03:10:18

Andy Burnham

Well, I understand what what the honorable gentleman is is saying, but I didn't negotiate the arrangement that that is currently in place. What I am trying to do is make things better for the people of Northern Ireland. And I'm confident in saying to him, if we get the right deal around energy connection, that could make an appreciable difference for his constituents, as could the paperwork on Irish Sea crossings as as well. So there are real benefits that I can achieve here that will improve things for Northern Ireland, possibly not to his complete satisfaction, but they are steps forward.

03:10:18 - 03:11:58

Lindsay Hoyle

Right, that completes the statement, the front benches change over. Order. Before we come to the Home Secretary's statement, I should note that Joshua Curry has been charged with a number of offenses, including the murder of Amwidicum and engaging in conduct in preparation of acts of terrorism, including against honorable members for Clacton. These cases are therefore sub judice. I am granting a limited waiver so that members can refer to the fact that those charges have been brought and the way in which related matters have been handled by the police.

However, members should not discuss the details of those cases or speculate on the guilt or innocence of the individual while this is rightly being dealt with in the courts. I'd also like to say to the House, I have not been told which members were on the list, I've had no information, the only time I know is when members personally contact me, which I find very difficult to help and support. I think this has not been handled well, and I wonder what we're going to do in the future.

And obviously, without a list, it makes it very hard to know. Okay, let us come to the statement. Home Secretary.

03:11:58 - 03:25:52

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With permission, I will make a statement on national security. Since the House last sat, we have received a reminder of the threats ranged against this country. This has included the danger posed by extremists and terrorists, but it has also comprised threats posed by foreign powers seeking to undermine our nation's security. These threats have targeted people, businesses, and critical infrastructure.

But above all else, they are attacks on our values and our way of life. The first duty of government is the security of the nation. So today, I will update the House on our response to these threats and how we are acting to keep our country and our citizens safe. I start with the threat posed by terrorists and extremists. And I know one case in particular will be on the minds of many in this House today.

It is now three months since the murder of Anne Widdecombe at her home in Devon. We continue to mourn her loss. On the 2nd of October, the suspect was charged with a terrorism offence, including preparing an act of terror against the leader of Reform UK, the honourable member for Clacton. I know that news that that news will have been deeply distressing for the honourable member, so may I say to him and to his family, they have my profoundest sympathies at what must be an awful time. As I have said before, an attack on any one of us is an attack on us all.

I know other members, as well as people outside of this House, have recently been contacted by the police in connection with this case. To all of those affected, may I offer the same sympathies and solidarity as I do to the honourable member for Clacton. Mr. Speaker, at times like these, we must stand together as one House. For those who serve, politics is a calling. Robust debate and criticism are part of this job.

Threats, abuse, and violence are not. Today, as on so many other days, we remember Anne Widdecombe, Sir David Amess, and Jo Cox, three beloved colleagues and three champions of our democracy. We owe it to them and to everyone who believes in a fair and open country to ensure those who serve at all levels receive the protection they deserve. We must first ensure that every opportunity was taken in this particular case to stop this attacker. The Independent Office of Police Conduct is investigating the response to an attempted break-in at the honourable member's home last year.

I have asked them to conduct this investigation both thoroughly and swiftly, and we expect it to conclude early next year. I would caution everyone not to preempt that investigation. Regardless of the outcome of that investigation, it is clear there is insufficient protection for those who serve. I can therefore announce today that I will expand with immediate effect police support to political figures who are not currently members of Parliament. This will include former members of Parliament, peers, and party spokespeople, giving them access to a named police officer as well as help with wider security measures.

...ty provided by the state to those in public life. This review will be led by Sir Stephen Lovegrove, the former National Security Adviser, and it will examine protective security from every angle, including physical threats, online risks, and the dangers posed within our more polarized society. It will hear directly from ministers, Members of Parliament, and other high-profile people in public life, and it will report within six months. It will complement Sir Robert Buckland's ongoing review into the killing of Sir David Amess. Mr. Speaker, this is rightly an independent review, but my commitment is that its findings must and will lead to tangible change, and that the state's resources will be rebalanced to protect those people and places that need it most.

But we must go further, Mr. Speaker.

Mr. Speaker, the terrorist threat is not ranged only at those who serve in public life. In recent days, we marked the first anniversary of the terror attack at the Heaton Park synagogue. On that awful day in October of last year, as our Jewish community celebrated Yom Kippur, two brave men, Melvin Kravitz and Adrian Doby, lost their lives, and three others were seriously injured. What happened that day must be fully understood. So, as requested by the coroner, I can today announce a public inquiry into the deaths of Mr. Kravitz and Mr. Doby.

This will ensure that all evidence can be heard, including any sensitive national security material that could not otherwise be fully heard in the coroner's court. Tragically, Heaton Park was just one of a series of attacks on our Jewish community. In the year since, they have included the stabbing of two Jewish men in Golders Green, North London, with a trial now set for March 2027; a failed attack on the Israeli embassy, for which the attacker was last week jailed for 20 years; a spate of arson attacks across North London; and last month, just hours before Yom Kippur began, a foiled but potentially lethal plot on the Jewish community in Manchester. In this case, two men, both Iranian nationals, have now been charged with terrorism offenses. I pay tribute to the police and the security services for what was a long-running investigation, conducted with their customary professionalism and skill.

Faced with the threat posed to our Jewish community, we have increased funding to the police by an additional 250 million pounds to boost police presence in key Jewish areas and to tackle antisemitism on our streets. But I know we cannot simply build higher walls around our Jewish community and expect them to live in fear. So we must root out the evil of antisemitism wherever it lurks in society. And this government is committed to that effort, tackling antisemitism wherever it is found, be it online, in our schools and universities, in our public services, or on our streets. The threat posed to our Jewish community shows us how the lines are increasingly blurring between extremism and state threats.

We know the Iranian state is targeting our Jewish community. Earlier this year, the Islamic Movement of Companions of the Right, or the IMCR, claimed responsibility for the arson attacks in North London. We know that members of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the IRGC, were behind that group, and most certainly directed its other attacks across Europe. This speaks to a wider trend. States like Iran are using proxies to conduct hostile activity here in Britain.

They pay criminals or exploit naive volunteers, attacking our country and its citizens while maintaining an air of plausible deniability. It is a brazen threat, but it is one that we are alert to and will not tolerate. And that is why this summer we fast-tracked the National Security State Threats Act through Parliament. This created stronger powers and tougher punishment to deal with state-backed threats to domestic security.

And under these new powers, we have designated both the IMCR and the IRGC. This brings us to the recent events at RAF, RAF Fairford. As the Prime Minister has said, our assessment is that it is highly likely to have been coordinated by a known individual based in Iran and almost certainly directed by Iran's IRGC. The Foreign Secretary has today summoned the Iranian Ambassador. He will condemn Iran's continued attempts to undermine our safety.

We are also sanctioning two individuals involved in conducting espionage and attacks on behalf of the government of Iran in Europe and the US. And we will not hesitate to take further action to restrict Iran's capacity to threaten international security. The threat is not confined to Iran, of course. As the invasion of Ukraine enters its fifth winter, the Kremlin continues to lash out at European countries. Together with the EU, we attributed an attack on Poland's energy grid last December to Russia, which could have caused half a million citizens to lose electricity.

Similarly, we are acting against the threat on our shores. Last month, a British man was charged under the National Security Act over alleged contact with Russia's military intelligence agency. And in recent days, a Royal Navy sailor accused of spying on behalf of Russia has been charged under the same act. We remain vigilant to the threats posed by China too. MI5 recently warned universities and academics to cut ties with the China General Technology Research Institute.

This group had been funding research in the UK with the primary purpose of improving China's espionage operations. Those who continue to work with this group will face criminal charges for aiding a foreign state and lengthy prison sentences as a result. Mr. Speaker, the threats we face today are complex and often interconnected. They target communities and citizens, the critical infrastructure that we depend on, and the institutions and individuals that make up our democracy. Our response to this growing threat is, rightly, multifaceted.

We are tackling extremism in our communities and in the online world. In Protecting What Matters, our social cohesion plan, we set out a range of measures to tackle this threat, including banning those who seek to come to this country and spread hatred, and committing to publishing an annual State of Extremism report which will identify the threats we face and, crucially, equip frontline professionals to counter it. We are also adapting to the changing nature of the violent threat that we face. Following the horrors of Southport, we have taken action to curb the threat posed by individuals fixated on violence. This has included strengthening the handling of repeat Prevent referrals and making it clear that referrals can be made to Prevent without a clearly identifiable ideology.

The Online Safety Act has also ensured thousands of services now have stronger age checks and safety measures. In addressing the threat posed by states, make no mistake, our police and security services are on permanent watch. Since 2023, more than 23 people have been charged under the National Security Act, leading to five convictions and totaling more than 48 years in prison so far, including 18 years for two men convicted of spying for China. We have imposed more than 4,000 sanctions linked to Russia and Iran. And we have placed both on the enhanced tier of the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme, which means anyone conducting activity on their behalf must register it or face the prospect of prison.

But more is required. As I have noted already, the National Security State Threats Act has given us powerful new tools to tackle state threats. We are also building a specialist mission in counter-terror policing to disrupt state threats and tightening security around military bases.

Of course, resilience is about more than our physical defenses. We are also establishing a National Center for Information Defense to tackle disinformation from states. Our Cyber Security and Resilience Bill will protect everyday services by strengthening national defenses against cyberattacks, and we will go further with our upcoming National Security Bill and give intelligence agencies and police stronger powers to bear down on cybercriminals. Let me also say, Mr. Speaker, to the public: if you are ever worried about someone you know, tell a teacher, a doctor, or someone you trust. Institutions like Prevent exist to stop people from following a dark path from which there may be no return.

If ever you see something suspicious, report it immediately to the police or a relevant authority. And to businesses, in an increasingly online world, consider the cyber threat that you face and strengthen your defenses. Finally, Mr. Speaker, to those responsible for some part of our critical infrastructure, let me say we will work with you. The National Protective Security Authority and the National Cyber Security Centre stand ready to help. We can defeat those who mean us harm, but we are strongest when we act together.

Mr. Speaker, in a more dangerous world, we are faced by threats from without and within that target our democracy and our way of life. In response, we are adapting and strengthening our defenses. As ever, I commend the work of the police and our security services, who labor in silence to keep us safe. And I'm sure the whole House joins me in offering thanks to them for that vital, life-saving work. This Government is taking action in support of that effort, but I know there is more that we must do, as I have set out in this statement, to protect this country, to protect our citizens, and to protect our democracy.

I hope the whole House can join together in that vital work, which is so much greater than any of our differences. Because I know that those of us who choose to serve all share a belief: we will never be defeated by those who mean us harm. And Mr. Speaker, with my thanks to you for allowing me to run a little longer than would usually be the case, I commend this statement to the House.

03:25:52 - 03:25:55

Lindsay Hoyle

Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp.

03:25:55 - 03:29:19

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Home Secretary for advance sight of her statement. The whole House supports the security services and the police for their work. I pay tribute to the brave men and women who serve our country in that way. On RAF Fairford firstly, seven suspects were arrested, one a dual UK-Iranian national. These men were all released quickly on bail, and senior US officials have expressed surprise about this.

Can the Home Secretary tell the House if she thinks it was reasonable to release these men so quickly and if she believes they pose any risk? Will the Home Secretary also tell the House if the Government was aware in advance of any threat to RAF Fairford and if so, what action they took? As the Prime Minister and just now the Home Secretary have both said, it is highly likely the Iranian state directed this. It is not acceptable for a state like Iran to organize hostile activity on our soil. After the Salisbury attacks by Russia, then Prime Minister Theresa May expelled 23 Russian diplomats.

So will the Government now take similar action and expel Iranian diplomats, especially those thought to be involved in hostile activity or in espionage?

And does she agree in these circumstances it was unwise of the Foreign Secretary to publicly shake hands with the Iranian Foreign Minister on September 24th in contravention of long-standing Foreign Office policy? I note Mr. Speaker that on the 4th of October the US withdrew all of its B-1 bombers from RAF Fairford and both the US President and Vice President ascribed this to security concerns. Will the Home Secretary confirm that is indeed why the B-1s left and does the Home Secretary have any concerns about the safety of US military assets here? Because shortly after the RAF incident, two Latvian men were arrested inside RAF Molesworth which also hosts US forces. Can the Home Secretary comment on whether any foreign state may also have been involved in that incident too?

Mr. Speaker, I thank the Home Secretary for her update on the police response to the terrible murder of Anne Wickham. The whole House mourns her and those who know Anne of course will miss her. And this comes on the heels of the tragic murders of our dear colleagues Jo Cox and David Amess not that long ago. The threat against current and former members of Parliament is clearly a very real one. Joshua Kerry, the man accused of murdering Anne is said by prosecutors to have an extreme left-wing mindset suggesting this was a politically motivated murder.

He is also accused of conducting online reconnaissance on over a hundred public figures and trying to break into the home of the honorable member for Clacton last year. It has been reported that despite recovering substantial amounts of CCTV, that case was closed. It was then reopened in October.

03:29:19 - 03:29:35

Lindsay Hoyle

Sorry, just very careful about how we're going, motivation we're creeping into what a court might decide and we're not the court. Please if we can just steer a little bit away because we all want a prosecution. I want nothing to risk this case because she was a friend to all.

03:29:35 - 03:32:44

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

Thank you Mr. Speaker, I was quoting what the prosecutor said but of course I'll take your advice as always. I was just going to go on to ask whether the Home Secretary shares my concern which she alluded to in her statement that the cancellation of the earlier investigation may have meant opportunities to prevent the later tragedy might have been missed. I understand a number of current and former MPs have very recently been contacted to be told that they appeared on a list made by Kerry. Kerry was arrested on the 11th of July but it was not until last week nearly three months later that some of those on that list, colleagues of ours here and other former MPs were notified. Can the Home Secretary tell the House when she knew about that list and does she agree it would be wrong if those listed on it had had the information withheld from them for a period of time potentially as long as three months?

Threats to democratically elected representatives are threats to democracy itself. And so I do welcome the Home Secretary's announcements just a few minutes ago on protective security including for those outside Parliament, recognizing of course that it is Mr. Speaker who plays the leading role in protecting members of Parliament. I would also like to mark the anniversary of the terrible deaths of Melvin Kravitz and Adrian Dolby at Heaton Park Synagogue in an anti-Semitic attack perpetrated by an Islamist extremist. In the year since, I have twice visited Golders Green in the aftermath of anti-Semitic attacks and as the Home Secretary said in just the last ten days, two Iranian small boat illegal immigrants have been charged with plotting a further anti-Semitic terror attack in Manchester. So it is more important than ever that we redouble our efforts to fight anti-Semitism and Islamist extremism with all our might.

And on that topic, I wrote to the Home Secretary on September 27th just a few weeks ago asking her to deny an entry visa to Randa Abdel-Fattah.

This is someone who praised the appalling terrorist massacre on October the 7th as, and I quote, "exhilarating". But the Home Secretary allowed Fattah into our country anyway. So can I ask, why did the Home Secretary do that, given the obvious risk that Fattah might radicalise others with her antisemitic and pro-terror views? I do think that really does demand a specific answer. Mr Speaker, there are clearly a wide range of serious threats to the safety of our country, the safety of political leaders across the political spectrum, and to our Jewish community.

The whole House will be united, I know, in wanting to fight those threats. And I would like to conclude, Mr Speaker, by thanking again those serving in the security services and the police who work tirelessly to keep us safe. The whole House supports them in their vital work.

03:32:44 - 03:38:15

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and let me thank the Shadow Home Secretary for his comments and questions. Though let me say to him, much of what he has asked, as I do believe he knows full well, relates to ongoing investigations, and there are limits to what I can share with the House today. And also, let me just also observe, there are limits to what is appropriate to be said publicly whilst there are investigations ongoing. That isn't just a restriction we impose on ourselves for the sake of it. It is an important part of ensuring the integrity of our criminal justice system and the independence of police investigations.

So he will therefore understand, I hope, even if his questions don't suggest so, that in relation to his questions on RAF Fairford and the decision to bail suspects, that is entirely an operational decision for the police who are solely responsible for that investigation. But let me tell him, I have full confidence in the police as they carry out that investigation. And because it's ongoing, more facts will be established, and I am sure that the police will take appropriate action when they come to light. They are bailed, those suspects, under strict conditions, and no one, certainly no one in our legal jurisdiction, should be commenting on the rightness or wrongness of that, because it is in our legal jurisdiction and we have a responsibility to make sure that the investigations have full integrity and also that if there are criminal proceedings that will follow, that those proceedings are not prejudiced by commentary beforehand. So he will, I hope, understand why I won't go further than what I have said in my statement on that point today.

And I do think that a more responsible approach from all members of this House on this matter is required. Let me also say to him, I wouldn't comment on intelligence briefings, nor do other Home Secretaries either. And I, as I say already, I'm not going to compromise an ongoing investigation as more facts are established. They will, of course, be public when it is appropriate for them to be so. Let me also say to him, he raised the point about action taken by the previous government post the Salisbury attack and his suggestions about actions against the Iranians at this stage.

Let me just simply say to him, of course I've set out in my statement the actions that the Foreign Secretary is already taking. But we wouldn't take anything off the table as more facts are established, as the investigation matures and we know more of the detail as to exactly what happened. The government will always keep under review all of the methods that we have at our disposal for responding to any hostile state carrying out any activity in our country.

Let me also say on Molesworth, again, I suspect he does know this, but the police have said that their investigation is at a very early stage. At the moment there is nothing to suggest that this incident is connected to the events at RAF Fairford. But as I say, the police are continuing to investigate. Again, it wouldn't be appropriate to provide a wider running commentary on that investigation whilst it's still in its early stages. Let me say to him then, he moved on to the circumstances relating to the murder of Anne Widdecombe and the recent charging decisions against Joshua Kerry on terror charges.

Again, I'm not, and it wouldn't be appropriate for me to comment on conversations between myself and counter-terrorism policing, but let me say that I don't believe at any point that information has been withheld from anybody in an inappropriate manner. This is an investigation, it's a thorough investigation whereby the police have been checking devices and other material at the property of this individual in order to establish a fuller picture. And as that fuller picture has emerged, the police have been sharing information. They've sought to do so, in my view, appropriately. And I know that people have been contacted by the police.

That is of course a matter for the police to pursue. But I don't believe any, I think the implication of the questions that the Shadow Home Secretary was putting to me was suggesting potentially that there was a withholding or it took too long for the information to be shared with individuals, both Members of Parliament and former Members of Parliament. I don't believe that anything has happened in this investigation that is inappropriate, is how I would respond to the Shadow Home Secretary, Mr. Speaker. He went on to ask questions relating to attacks on our Jewish community. And let me say to him just in relation to the powers that the Home Secretary has for excluding individuals from entering our country.

I, we have had these exchanges on a number of occasions across this dispatch box. I will always use my powers appropriately by looking at both threat, risk, and also the wider impact on communities. I have used those powers in some instances where that threshold has been met. I haven't used them in every single one. It wouldn't be appropriate to do so.

But let me tell him, I take a robust approach to the exercise of my powers and will always use them in an appropriate way to limit threat to our communities here at home. With that, Mr. Speaker, I think I've covered everything he said to me. I'll make sure, I'll make sure I respond to his letter as soon as I finish this statement.

03:38:15 - 03:38:37

Lindsay Hoyle

Just to gently say to the Home Secretary, it's much harder when you read it in a newspaper of which MPs have been targeted named and me having no knowledge. I think it puts us all at a disadvantage, especially as we give the support of health and well-being and the security as well. So I think there is a gap that's not been closed. Gareth Snell.

03:38:37 - 03:39:44

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Home Secretary for her statement and recognize that she, being a woman of color, has been at the receiving end of quite a lot of this stuff herself over many years and the dignified way with which she now carries out her duties in trying to help and support all of us. And I say that, Mr. Speaker, because in the two years that I've been back here, I have lost count of how many times we've stood here now to discuss the activities and antics of people in this country who want to come after MPs, who want to come after peers, who want to come after minority communities and do so seemingly because they fear very little. Whether it's the so-called patriots that do their patrols around the streets targeting migrant communities or whether it be the virulent anti-Semites who go after the Jewish community. I agree with the Home Secretary, we can put walls up to protect those communities, but at some point the state is going to have to say, right, enough of this, we're coming after them. So can I ask the Home Secretary, as well as all the welcome protections she's putting in place for the victims, what more can we all do collectively to bring the perpetrators to the place that they deserve, which is probably in front of a judge and then in jail?

03:39:44 - 03:41:56

Yvette Cooper

Thank you. Mr. Speaker, may I just say before I answer the question from my honorable friend on the issue of the sharing of information. You will know, Mr. Speaker, this is a matter for counter-terror policing.

They are in charge of this investigation. They've got to make sure that all of their actions can survive contact with a court of law in the future, and nobody wants to do anything that might be prejudicial in any way. I do hear the case that is being made by you, Mr Speaker, and by other members of this House, and let me just assure you I will pick up those conversations with counter-terror policing and wider criminal justice system partners to make sure that we have stress-tested the robustness of our arrangements in such cases as this one. And let me say I'll come back to you directly, Mr Speaker, as well as updating the House in the future as well. And the Lord Speaker too.

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I will make sure I do so. Let me say to my honourable friend, look, he will know that this government has announced substantial new additional funding for the protection of our Jewish community. Around 250 million pounds of additional money has been committed over a three-year period to ensure there is an enhanced policing posture in areas with, in key Jewish community sites. And I think that's an important step forward.

It's a recognition of the ongoing nature of the threat that our community faces. He is right on this issue of putting up ever higher walls. We've got to make sure that the security system is robust and can respond effectively. And let me say again to him, as we can see from the sheer number of cases that are now appearing before the courts, the police, our security services are working around the clock to bring people to justice, to foil plots. They have done so on many occasions, and they will continue to do so.

But we do have to have a wider national conversation about the cultural changes that we have seen, whereby we do need a wider societal response against antisemitism, because we can't simply put security guards everywhere. We need our citizens to be able to live together in harmony and respect for the betterment of everyone.

03:41:56 - 03:45:02

Max Wilkinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I will start by sharing my support for the police and security services, and as the MP for GCHQ, that means a particularly great deal to me, given so many of my constituents work there. The murder of Anne Widdecombe, if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker, start with that, shocked us all, and the revelations about the suspect's plans to apparently attack other MPs are deeply concerning to all of us here. Those of us who want protection for all politicians must demand it for all, no matter what the political persuasion of those politicians might be, and that needs to be said on the record today. In return, we also must hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, that all politicians on all sides moderate their language when necessary to lower the temperature of debate and reduce the threat against us all, and that is an important part of this debate which must not be lost.

Those who target politicians must not be allowed to impose their intended chilling effect on our democracy, and my thoughts remain with Anne's family, including my constituent, the Reverend Roger Widdecombe, who leads the congregation at St Paul's in Cheltenham. Sadly, the public discourse aimed at politicians has coarsened in the last decade, and this has resulted in increased levels of hatred, abuse, offences against politicians and retired politicians at all levels, and politically motivated killings. We must never forget what happened to Sir David Amess and Jo Cox. It is important that we can all do our jobs without intimidation, without fear or worse, and I know that the chair takes this very seriously.

We welcome the review therefore into the protective security provided to those in public life and it is right that it will be done swiftly. On the other of the on one of the other elements of this statement, Madam Deputy Speaker, we must be clearly ever more mindful of the threat to this country from our enemies on the global stage and those at home too. We must do all that we can to prevent these threats, especially as we have seen in recent months those which have wickedly targeted the Jewish community in this country. And it is right that today we remember Melvin Kravitz and Adrian Dolby and we welcome the Home Secretary's comments on the inquiry for the on an inquiry for the Heaton Park attacks. Let us all remain vigilant to antisemitism and supportive of our Jewish communities and that goes for all political parties.

In April, I wrote to ministers seeking additional support for police to account for the added strain on their resources in areas around military bases. Ministers told me that the police should work within their existing budgets without extra support, but given what has recently happened, will ministers not look again at how they can support the police forces responsible for the areas around RAF Fylingdales and other bases? And will the Home Secretary push ministers to accelerate the previously announced security review and to set out what she will do to strengthen the security of all bases in general? The Prime Minister earlier stated that Iran and the IRGC was highly likely to have been behind the incident at RAF Fylingdales. So finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, what action is being taken against Iranian operatives involved in this activity?

03:45:02 - 03:45:06

Speaker 228

Is the expulsion of diplomats being considered?

03:45:06 - 03:47:19

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me thank the honorable member for his comments and his questions. Let me say to him just on the issues relating to the murder of Ann Widdecombe, he he made a point about our responsibility to lower the temperature. I'll just observe, I believe it is possible to have very robust debate, a thorough contest of ideas, and without having to cross a line and call into question our collective security. I think it's possible to do that and I would all urge all members as ever to reflect on their own behavior just to make sure that we are modeling the right behavior that we expect our citizens to see as well.

We we lead the national discourse and we should seek to do it in an appropriate way without losing all of the political contestation that is a hallmark of a thriving democracy. Let me say to him on let me welcome his comments on remaining vigilant on antisemitism as as a collective as as a whole of society response. I think all political parties have a responsibility to make sure that they are active partners in the fight against antisemitism which is a pernicious form of hatred and we know that it has increased substantially in recent years and we all have a responsibility there. On the issue of military bases specifically, he will know of course this is primarily a matter for the Ministry of Defence, but of course they work closely with the police as with us here at the Home Office. Let me assure him I am in good discussions with the Defence Secretary to make sure all appropriate measures are being taken at our military bases, that we are aware of all of the risks and that there are good security measures.

It is my belief that there are, but of course we are never going to be complacent on that matter and will always review and make sure that our response is appropriate. I'd be happy to discuss this with him as well if if needed and if he writes to me again I can make sure that he gets an updated response that reflects the current and recent events as well.

03:47:19 - 03:47:59

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So British Jews like me find the vote by the Greens to declare Zionism racism deeply disturbing.

Now, perhaps some Greens were misled, for Zionism is simply the belief that Jewish people have a right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. So, so I am a Zionist, and who here is not a Zionist? British Jews, some of whom now live in areas controlled by Green councils, are worried. How can they be reassured that they will not be the subject of political prejudice?

03:47:59 - 03:49:12

Yvette Cooper

Well, I thank my honorable friend for his question. Let me say, the policies of another political party are a matter primarily for that political party. I would expect them to have to explain the impact of their motion on the safety and security of Jews in their own party. In the Green Party, I believe there are questions there for the Green Party leadership to look at and to be to answer for. And on the issue of Green councils, every council, regardless of who is the political party running that council, has to follow the law.

And the law will not allow any prejudicial treatment of any of our citizens based on their protected characteristics, whether that's their race or their religion. And that applies with as much fervor to the Jewish community as it does to any other community in this country. And I would expect all councils to make sure that they comply with the law. Nobody has the right to freelance on equality policy. It is set by the government.

There is clear legal there is a clear legal framework and every council has to follow it.

03:49:12 - 03:50:05

Karen Bradley

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, you I can't be alone in having had many colleagues over the years report to me instances where they've received threats and the police have simply not taken it seriously. It's only when those threats have been escalated up and and further action's been taken that the police finally intervene. And that's simply not good enough. We've also seen in this case the police communications are not appropriate and that the Mr. Speaker and Mr. Lord Speaker are not able to offer the support they need to to those members that have been victimized have been victims.

So, can I ask the Home Secretary what conversations she's having with the police about their attitude to threats to members of Parliament, because these threats need to be taken seriously. We do not want to see another plaque put up in here for another murdered colleague.

03:50:05 - 03:51:39

Yvette Cooper

Let me say I I absolutely agree with the chair of the select committee in the final part of her remarks. None of us want to be here mourning another one of our colleagues, both current or former. And that is why I do believe change is needed. For the protective security system as it stands today, she will know that the responsibilities are shared across multiple departments: the Parliamentary Security Department, individual local police forces, the Home Office, RAVEC. It's a fragmented system.

And I am acknowledging today that whilst everybody works hard within that system to have a good security response for individuals in public life, it does need to be looked at again because of the range of threats that we now see, the complexity, the changing environment. When this system was first set up, nobody had in mind that you'd have very high-profile political leaders who are not in Parliament. It just wasn't how our political culture used to work. And things have changed, but the system hasn't been able to keep up in the way that it needs to. That's why I've announced the expansion to Operation Ford to cover more people, so at least they have some contact with police, can access advice and where necessary have a an assessment of their risk with other security measures attached to it.

But the system needs an overhaul, and that is why I think the review is an important step forward. And I will be finalizing terms official terms of reference with Stephen Lovegrove, who is the independent reviewer. I will obviously make sure the House is updated. And as I say, I want it done within six months because I recognize the urgency of the situation that we are in.

03:51:39 - 03:52:41

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Faith matters in this country and nothing strikes British, our shared British values more than attacks on places of worship. It is absolutely right that this government calls out the attacks on synagogues and other Jewish communal organizations and it is right that members of this House push the government to do more to tackle antisemitism and make available the resources. There is also a wider hatred going on against other faiths in this country as well and I'm aware that in my gurdwaras and mosques and other religious faiths, people are worried about the attacks on their communal spaces and their sacred ability to worship freely as part of being part of modern Britain. Can my right honorable friend tell us what more she can do to focus on not just antisemitism, which it is right to do, but what support and funding is available to other places of worship to ensure that modern Britain is a place where all of our faiths have a place and are represented and protected.

03:52:41 - 03:54:08

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me thank my honorable friend. He's absolutely right, it is a sacred ability of all of our citizens who have a faith to be able to practice their faith freely in their places of worship, a freedom that I have availed myself of on many, many occasions, but I do understand the fear that people have whenever they hear of an attack either on a synagogue, a mosque, a gurdwara or indeed any other place of worship too. Let me say to him, he might be aware the government has already allocated record funding of over 75 million pounds, which is for the protective security schemes for faith communities. That includes all faith communities. Of that money, 40 million is for the protective security for mosques scheme.

I've already updated members on the money made available to the Jewish community given the particular range of threats to our Jewish community, but within the funding that we have made available, there is funding for other faith groups as well who can apply for assistance with security measures. At the Home Office, we are obviously very downstream of many of these issues. We are involved when things are about to go wrong or have gone wrong and of course what we can offer in terms of policy are things like security measures. He is right, we need a wider societal conversation on how we change our culture so that we can stop the descent into a more polarized society that we have seen in recent years and do more to build a cohesive society that is confident and whose citizens can live freely alongside one another.

03:54:08 - 03:54:09

Richard Tice.

03:54:09 - 03:54:58

Richard Tice

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Home Secretary for her statement and my colleagues will ask questions with regard to MP security. I want to touch on RAF Fairford. The government's own terrorism czar Jonathan Hall KC said that in incidents of serious terrorism that actually more information should be put out faster and sooner and in more detail to prevent misinformation. So I asked the Prime Minister earlier as to whether or not there was any truth in the suggestion that some of those arrested and then bailed were, had Iranian diplomatic immunity.

He gave the hospital pass to the Home Secretary. So I therefore repeat the question, Home Secretary, as to whether any more could be said about that and whether actually not only are they British nationals, but could they be dual Iranian-British nationals.

03:54:58 - 03:56:05

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me say to the honorable member, no one had or has diplomatic immunity, so I can put that on the record immediately. Let me also say to him, he is absolutely right about the Jonathan Hall recommendations that followed the horrific attacks in Southport and we would always seek to work with partners in the criminal justice system to make sure that information is shared as quickly as possible in order to prevent disinformation from spreading and for people to succeed in sowing fear in our communities.

He will also I hope understand that it is a live investigation and how an investigation starts is not always how it ultimately ends. There are many developments along the way and it is important that if we think as the police should always do, have an open mind about an investigation but also want to protect the integrity of future court proceedings, that proceeding with care is also required. And let me assure him that I will always make sure that we put out accurate information into the public domain as soon as we are able to do so and in a way that doesn't compromise an investigation. This investigation is still at an early stage.

03:56:05 - 03:56:06

Lee Anderson.

03:56:06 - 03:56:44

Lee Anderson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for her statement. Recently constituents have been contacting me concerned about self-appointed uniformed groups, sometimes masked, patrolling our local area, but I know this is becoming a nationwide phenomenon. They tell me it's frightening and it's also stopping them going about their daily lives. So with this in mind, would she tell me whether she feels the current national guidance around these self-appointed patrol groups and existing legislation is sufficient, given this behavior falls outside normal protests?

03:56:44 - 03:57:49

Yvette Cooper

Well, firstly, my honorable friend is absolutely right. The behavior of some of these groups, particularly masked individuals, is causing fear across communities. It is designed to do that. Let me say to her that we do expect the police to use all of their powers at their disposal, including on the removal, requiring the removal of face coverings where that is appropriate. And as as as groups develop their approach on protest-like activity, let me also assure her that I will always keep those matters under review.

It is important that we respect the right to freedom of protest, freedom of political dissent, and taking an active approach to allowing people to show their political dissent, that is a key hallmark of our democracy. But it is important that that doesn't happen in a fear that has a chilling effect on the freedoms of others. And getting that balance right is something that I'm obviously absolutely committed to making sure that this government does. And I will, I'm happy to discuss with her the experiences in her constituency and in her region to make sure that our response is appropriate.

03:57:49 - 03:57:51

Vikki Slade

Dr. Roz Savage.

03:57:51 - 03:58:38

Rose Savage

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. RAF Fairford is in my constituency, and on the night of the incident, the residents of Whelford, a nearby village, were woken in the wee small hours by police hammering at the door and were given just a few minutes to leave their homes, in many cases leaving behind pets and medication. Obviously, this was a very unsettling experience, and many of them still feel quite deep anxiety. So I'd like to ask the Home Secretary what assessment has been made of the ongoing risks, and will she meet me and local parish councils to discuss lessons learned and to ensure that residents' concerns are addressed before US bombers return to RAF Fairford?

03:58:38 - 03:59:18

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me say to the honorable lady, of course, I recognize the deep anxiety that will have been felt by the residents of Whelford. It must have been a terrifying experience for them. She will, of course, understand that the police have to act quickly in order to safeguard life and they have to take every risk seriously, and that is, I'm sure, what they sought to do in this case. But there is no getting away from the fact that by doing their jobs, that would also still be unsettling for residents. I'd be very happy to make sure that their concerns are listened to, and I will arrange a meeting for her with the Security Minister in the first instance to go through those concerns, but I will make sure that I am also kept updated.

03:59:18 - 03:59:20

Vikki Slade

Marcus Campbell-Savours.

03:59:20 - 03:59:58

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Home Secretary for her statement.

Adults in the UK seeking to access pornographic material online are now required to upload identification to pass age verification checks. Yet those choosing to share extremist material and incite hate and terrorism on social media can enjoy anonymity. Can I ask what considerations the Home Office has given to ensuring social media users can be identified? My constituents, some of whom have been victims of online harassment, simply don't understand why anonymity is allowed.

03:59:58 - 04:00:58

Yvette Cooper

Well look, I do understand the concern raised by my honourable friend. He'll know that this is a matter of policy for colleagues in the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Department. But you know, the Secretary of State has made very clear that she believes that there is further work to do on ensuring online safety for everyone. Let me just observe more generally, however, age verification has had a good impact in relation to the viewing of pornographic material. He will know that when it comes to material that is in the more contested space of cultural issues in this country, that is contested.

And so you would still have the issue of where you draw the line between content that is lawful, might be horrible, but it's still lawful, lawful but harmful, and then also content that then slips into illegality. Those questions remain regardless of whether you have age verification or not.

04:00:58 - 04:02:02

Mark Pritchard

Can I put on record my thanks to Counter Terrorism Policing West Midlands and Special Branch West Mercia Police for all they're doing for all members across parties in their region and area? In an earlier reply to the Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee, no longer in her place, the Home Secretary mentioned that the system was quote, fragmented. So I'd be interested, given that in her statement, page four, quote, we are also building a specialist mission in counter-terror policing to disrupt state threats. She will know the security service play a major part, and she knows what branch, on counter-espionage and counter-terrorism. We also have counter-terror police, we have the National Crime Agency, and given that more proxy attacks are happening through criminal gangs, which she referenced earlier, deniable attacks.

Isn't this creating another silo when actually we need to break down the silos and have all these agencies and forces working together?

04:02:02 - 04:03:39

Yvette Cooper

I thank the honourable gentleman. Firstly, let me say for his comments on supporting the work of counter-terror police. So much of that work is not public, but it is absolutely crucial to the safety and security of our nation. It's right that we place on the record our thanks to them. Let me say he makes a good point on silos.

That is exactly one of the reasons why I am setting up the National Police Service, which will bring together the National Crime Agency and counter-terror policing into one National Police Service. And I'm doing so because I recognise that placing those two agencies together means that we are in the best possible place to face the growing nature of the threats that we face, the complex nature of them. They are of course changing all of the time. Let me place on record though, at the moment I do believe that the National Crime Agency, counter-terror policing work very effectively together. And they have built up good arrangements over the years in order to make sure that when criminal or alleged criminal activity strays across the boundaries of what their organisations look at, they do work very closely together.

I meet all of them alongside other partners on a weekly basis, as does the Security Minister. So we work very hard at the moment to make sure that there aren't those same silos. The reason for setting up the new State Threats Mission is because the nature of state threats has changed so significantly. We are seeing this, other Five Eyes partner countries are seeing the same trend. It's important we make sure we're absolutely at the cutting edge of understanding how our enemies want to do us harm so that we can make sure that we can meet that challenge as well.

04:03:39 - 04:03:43

Speaker 234

But let me commit to him, I won't allow any silos to exist. And I do believe in the future the National Police Service will be a key part of making sure that never happens.

04:03:43 - 04:04:30

Stephen Race

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I put on record my sympathies and join the House in expressing my sympathies to the family of Ann Widdecombe also as a fellow Devon resident. We know that antisemitism and other hate crimes have risen in recent years and when I talk to young Jewish people in my constituency they're fearful and unable to live their full Jewish lives freely. I'm particularly worried about new self-appointed groups who are door-knocking in Jewish communities under the guise of anti-apartheid for example. It strikes me as that being a bit closer to harassment than otherwise.

Is the Home Secretary satisfied that she and the security service and police have the right tools to combat this new activity that's rising across the country? Thank you.

04:04:30 - 04:05:37

Yvette Cooper

I thank my honorable friend. He of course raises a similar point to that of my honorable friend earlier on self-appointed groups who are showing a new form of protest type activity, not quite the same as the traditional protests that we have seen. But whether they come from either the far right or the far left, they do what no one is allowed to do is break the law of our land, harass people, threaten, intimidate. And wherever a crime is has taken place I would expect the police to respond robustly and make sure that communities or individuals are not living in fear. Let me assure him that I am discussing the emerging picture of this type of activity with all of the appropriate partners.

I'm happy to discuss with him also the experience that he has seen in his area and to work with honorable members to make sure that we do have the right balance between legitimate freedoms and expression of freedoms of protest, of conscience, of political speech and so on, but not in a way that chills the freedom or indeed the safety of anyone else.

04:05:37 - 04:05:38

Kirsty Blackman.

04:05:38 - 04:06:25

Ann Kirsty Blackman

We know that it's not always the most high profile or the most senior politicians who are targeted and we know that to our cost in this House. The Speaker's Conference on Security looked at the views of members and candidates from across all parts of these islands, including specifically seeking evidence from Northern Irish candidates and MPs, Scottish and Welsh ones who maybe don't have the same jurisdictional or geographical issues that English MPs perhaps do. Can I ask the Home Secretary for reassurance that a range of voices will be listened to by Sir Stephen Lovegrove and a range of experiences, particularly where we've got different jurisdictions or different geographies so that appropriate recommendations can be made?

04:06:25 - 04:07:11

Yvette Cooper

Let me give that assurance immediately to the honorable lady. The government already recognizes that there is a different picture for devolved administrations. Operation Fort is extended to all devolved administrations and I know the review will make sure that they're able to take into account the many different ways in which our democracy is expressed in our country, whether that's metro mayoralties, the devolved administrations, current and former members of those administrations as well as local councillors of which there are many thousands across the country. So I can give her that reassurance. The review will be a full look and end-to-end look at the whole picture of protective security for all for those in public life.

04:07:12 - 04:08:17

Christopher Paul Webb

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And following on from questions of my honorable friends before, we're seeing more masked gangs and those seeking to intimidate our communities. But what often follows them is the new self-proclaimed auditors that are there to film them and often fund these gangs.

Unfortunately, we've seen this trend dramatically grow in Blackpool, including recently intimidating Blackpool councillors of all parties enter the council chamber for a full council meeting, screaming and demanding they identify what political party they are. And during the recent by-election in Claremont, harass and intimidate local activists, again of all party, as they were going about during that campaign. So can I ask the Home Secretary what measures are now looking in place to allow councils to ban these auditors in certain areas of their town, especially in town centres? We see this as well growing on the nighttime economy, often preying on vulnerable individuals. But we know this is becoming a real problem.

It's been highlighted by the leader of Blackpool Council as well. But what more can we do, or what new powers need to be implemented to stop this wave of auditors?

04:08:17 - 04:09:14

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me say to the honourable friend, very sorry to hear of the experiences of people in his local community. And let me restate that we expect the police to use the full range of all of their powers. People have the right to show their political dissent in this country. That is an important freedom that everybody has. But nobody has the right to break the law.

Nobody has the right to threaten or harass individuals or otherwise engage in any criminal act. What I would encourage is for his local council leaders to be working with their local police. But I will also ensure that I meet with all colleagues who have raised similar concerns in order to talk through the current policy environment and to make sure, as I've said in response to previous questions, that we get the balance right between maintaining the freedoms which make our country the great country that it is, but without chilling the freedoms of others in our society as well.

04:09:14 - 04:10:13

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Madam Speaker. RAF Molesworth is in my constituency and the break-in last week has caused something of a concern locally, being located next to a very small village. People are rightly concerned that the base is vulnerable. And whether this is criminal activity or whether this is a foreign actor intervening, it does show that the base itself has vulnerabilities. Within my constituency, we've got three bases, two of which are US visiting forces, one of which is UK.

Two of them are some of the most strategically sensitive sites in Western Europe. And we have a very small and quite underfunded police force. And I appreciate that it's complicated because it mixes Cambridgeshire Constabulary, Ministry of Defence Police, counter-terrorism policing now, and also US visiting forces. I went out with Ministry of Defence Police the other day on an Operation Project Servator to deter people locally. But it's not something that I'd heard of, and it certainly isn't something that people are aware of locally.

04:10:13 - 04:10:54

Yvette Cooper

Could I suggest that there's a real opportunity for areas like mine to get some sort of briefing or encouragement locally for people to be more vigilant about this type of activity and the vulnerability of those military bases?

Well, let me thank the honourable member. And let me say to him, if he's amenable, I'd be happy to make sure that he's able to meet the Security Minister. And I will also personally pick up those issues with the Defence Secretary as well. He is right when the honourable member notes that there are many different organisations involved in the security of bases across the country and in his own constituency. And I will make sure that I follow up to ensure that everything is happening as it should in his own constituency, but also that there is better sharing of information where that's appropriate.

04:10:54 - 04:11:37

Michael Peter Martin

Thank you, Madam Speaker. We've had the government reporting that there's 20 active terror plots. Just recently, two Iranians have been arrested. And now the Prime Minister's telling us that there are Iranian links to the Fairford incident. I think it's safe to say that there's a systematic Iranian campaign on British soil.

The measures that the Home Secretary's announced today and recently as well are really welcome. But they're largely defensive in nature. So sometimes offence is the best form of defence. And I wonder whether the Home Secretary's considered that perhaps we need to increase the costs on the Iranians for their actions, and whether she has considered that. And also, has she considered signalling that fact to the Iranians to deter them from future activity?

04:11:37 - 04:12:11

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me simply say to the honourable member, we work very closely with all of our allies.

These are threats that are shared and felt by many of our allies and colleagues in other countries. And we will always make sure that we take both collective action to deal with the threats that we all face, but also make sure that we are always protecting the British national interest. I won't give a running commentary on wider discussions, but let me say this government will always take every appropriate measure to keep our people safe.

04:12:11 - 04:12:12

Lee Anderson.

04:12:12 - 04:12:40

Speaker 238

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week I got a telephone call from Nottinghamshire Police to tell me that I was on a kill list of 100 MPs and former MPs and VIPs. Now I think I strongly believe that it took a leak to the press before the police actually contacted me and my colleagues sat here. So can the Home Secretary tell me when she first became aware of this list?

04:12:40 - 04:13:33

Yvette Cooper

Well let me say to the honorable gentleman, I don't believe that as I said in answer to previous questions, that anything has inappropriate has happened in relation to the list. I'm not going to give him or the allegations of the list, I'm not going to give a running commentary on intelligence discussions, but nothing has happened that is inappropriate in my view. I will make sure that I am able to share more information with the House as I as I referenced in my answer to Mr. Speaker earlier and the concerns that have been raised about who has knowledge of who those names are. But this is an investigation that is led by the police. I don't get a running commentary or an update myself.

It would be inappropriate for that to happen. They are operationally independent. They must go where the evidence takes them and no politician should ever have a directive hand in those proceedings.

04:13:33 - 04:13:34

Peter Smarth.

04:13:34 - 04:14:20

Peter Smarth

Much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really welcome the Home Secretary's announcement of the independent review of protective security provided by the state to those in public life. A statement mentions former MPs and party spokespeople and I'm really glad that she said from the dispatch box it will also include elected councillors. Because it cannot be the case that really good people are being put off from standing to represent their community because of fear of violence, intimidation and abuse. The reality for too many councillors though is that Operation Ford is inconsistent and is not rising to the moment.

So I welcome her widening the scope of Operation Ford, but could she explain how she plans to strengthen the operation itself so that elected councillors and candidates get the support and protection they deserve.

04:14:20 - 04:15:43

Yvette Cooper

Well let me say to the honorable lady, I'm very happy to pick up any concerns that she has specifically or with councillors that she has been discussing problems with Operation Ford to make sure that those are are dealt with. What I would observe is actually when Operation Bridger first started and I say this as a Member of Parliament rather than as the Home Secretary, it maybe wasn't as effective as you know each time it has done anything members have been able to shape how it works based on their own lived experience. And that engagement between members, the parliamentary authorities and then the police itself I think has been crucial in improving Operation Bridger. It's been an iterative process because the the nature of these threats is very complex. It varies from place to place, from person to person and so it's right that it adapts as circumstances change and is responsive.

I would expect Operation Ford to also respond in the same way to the threats faced by other elected officials. And let me tell her I will ensure that that is the case and that there is good learning across all of the Operation Ford network to make sure that there is a consistent standard. It is not unusual for MPs to still say that Operation Bridger can be inconsistent so it is a work in progress. But I do believe the wider review gives us the best opportunity to have a single system with a with a clear approach based on threat and risk management that I think is crucial for everyone.

04:15:43 - 04:16:04

Robin Swann

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The National Protective Security Authority, the National Centre for Information Defence... Can I seek reassurance from the Home Secretary that infrastructure in Northern Ireland and also the misinformation that is portrayed into Northern Ireland politics is also focused, a focus of this government in regards to the work that it's doing?

04:16:04 - 04:16:32

Yvette Cooper

Let me absolutely assure him infrastructure in Northern Ireland is just as important as infrastructure in any other part of the United Kingdom. And whether the work that we do is through the new National Centre or indeed our current arrangements, there will be no discrepancy between the way that the government approaches the safety and security of the people of Northern Ireland or indeed the critical national infrastructure in Northern Ireland as compared to any other part of the United Kingdom.

04:16:32 - 04:17:01

Robin Swann

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of the greatest strengths of British democracy is that constituents can meet their Member of Parliament face to face. Does the Secretary of State agree with me that while we must keep elected representatives safe from violence, the basic right of people to speak to their Member of Parliament must always be championed?

04:17:01 - 04:17:46

Yvette Cooper

Let me say to the honourable gentleman, I agree it's a really important way in which this country functions and how our democracy functions. I don't think of it as a right so much, but it's more, it's part of our political culture. It's always been the case that people can turn up quite freely to this, the nation's house themselves, that they can meet with their local Members of Parliament, also their councillors. It's very normal in our country for people to do advice surgeries and also be outdoor knocking. And those are important, important parts of our political culture that I don't wish to see changed.

But we do also have to be mindful of the new risks that are posed to those elected officials. And as one of the honourable members noted earlier, we don't want people to be put off from entering public life as well. So it's important that our arrangements adapt in a way that protects our political culture.

04:17:46 - 04:18:18

Speaker 241

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Secretary asks rightly that the public play their part in national security, but we have no serious national framework for civilian resilience. Countries such as Finland have demonstrated the value of preparing the civilian population before a crisis. So will the government seriously consider the Liberal Democrat proposal to establish a dedicated civil defence office and civil volunteer reserve, which would bring together volunteers trained in cybersecurity, emergency response, and protection of critical national infrastructure?

04:18:18 - 04:18:49

Yvette Cooper

Well, the government takes very seriously the need to be prepared for all of the threats that we face across a whole range of public policy concerns, whether those are national security matters or related to the environment and other issues as well. Let me say to him, I'm sure myself and colleagues across government will always look at all proposals designed to help us be more resilient as a nation. I know the Prime Minister will have more to say on this in due course.

04:18:49 - 04:19:25

Edward Robert Jenrick

It's abundantly clear to me that if the attack on the home of the member for Clacton had been properly investigated instead of brushed aside in some combination of incompetence and political bias, Ann Widdecombe would still be alive today. Instead, she was brutally murdered because of two-tier Britain. Let that sink in to everyone in this place. Why did it take the death of Ann Widdecombe for people to begin at least to wake up to what is happening in this country?

04:19:25 - 04:20:43

Yvette Cooper

Look, I appreciate that the circumstances of Ann Widdecombe's murder, but also the additional information that has come to light, are very distressing. And, you know, I have offered sympathy and support from this dispatch box before, I do so again.

But I don't think that the distressing nature of these events justifies the charge that the honourable member makes. And I do reject the charge that he makes. He will know, and he's been a former minister himself, so he does know how these things work. The Independent Office for Police Conduct is investigating. They are independent of government, they're independent of police.

They will go where the facts take them on the additional incident that is being investigated in relation to the honourable member for Clacton's property. And it is important that they are able to get on with their job. It is also important we don't preempt what the findings of that IOPC investigation will be. They are working swiftly, they will advance this quickly. And I know those answers will be debated in this chamber, but it is important we don't make findings of fact before the facts are known.

04:20:43 - 04:21:07

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The RAF Fairford plot was reported in the press as having been foiled by a local resident. She described parked vans as having strange signage on them. She said, I looked at it and thought, that is not real. Will the Home Secretary credit this sort of alertness from a member of the public?

And will the government be doing more to encourage this whole-of-society approach to security?

04:21:07 - 04:21:53

Yvette Cooper

Let me say, as I said in my statement to all members of the public, if you see anything suspicious, if they see anything suspicious, they should contact the police as residents did in relation to the incident at RAF Fairford. He will know, as the Defence Secretary has said, that there is more to the investigation and how the incident unfolded than is known or said publicly at the moment. That's because the investigation has to be able to continue in the normal way. So there is more about those circumstances. But let me commend the resident in question and all others for doing their civic duty, spotting something suspicious and making sure they called the police.

And I would urge everybody else if the same ever happens again to do the same.

04:21:53 - 04:22:46

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Home Secretary for her statement? My constituents in Strangford are deeply proud of Northern Ireland's unmatched cybersecurity and resilience, but they're also deeply worried about the modern multi-layered threats confronting our nation. We are seeing unprecedented foreign interference, state-sponsored cyber warfare, transnational repression from hostile states like China, Iran and Russia, targeting democratic institutions and communities on our own soil. At a time when global instability is worsening, how will the Minister reassure the House that this government will stand firmly behind our intelligence-sharing networks with key democratic allies such as Israel, rather than risking them through short-sighted, one-sided trade or diplomatic restrictions such as those against Israel?

04:22:46 - 04:23:26

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me thank the honourable member. Let me assure him again, as I did to the other honourable member from Northern Ireland earlier, the approach that the government takes in relation to our people and our places in Northern Ireland is no different to anywhere else in the United Kingdom. Let me also say to him, we as a government value our defence and security and intelligence relationships with all of our allies and our partners. And those relationships are important, they are strong, they continue. That is also the case in relation to Israel.

And we will continue working with our allies and partners to make sure that we are collectively doing everything we can to keep our people safe.

04:23:26 - 04:23:51

Speaker 240

I thank the Home Secretary for her statement. I will allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over. Brings us to a statement on Drumcree, Secretary of State for Northern Ireland.

04:23:51 - 04:32:25

Chris Bryant

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With your permission, I'd like to make a statement on Drumcree. I should first of all alert members to the fact that the decision that I will lay out in this statement is subject to legal challenge. I respect the court's role and will not anticipate its conclusions. I wanted to update the House as soon as possible, but I hope honorable members will understand that this may limit some of what I can say.

I also note that this afternoon the Court of Appeal sitting in Belfast refused leave to appeal to the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition. The court therefore confirmed the Parades Commission determination as it was made at the time on the 25th of September, as did I. My exercise of powers under section 11 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act, however, considered the situation as it stood on Friday the 9th of October. The repeated standoffs at Drumcree in the 1990s saw disorder, violence, and horrific deaths and represent a particularly painful chapter in Northern Ireland's history. At the heart of the matter is the return route of the Orange Order Portadown District's parade from Drumcree Church.

Members of the Orange Order attach great importance to completing their route down the mainly nationalist Garvaghy Road, while residents of the road have long opposed its passage through their community. For 28 years, the independent Parades Commission had determined that the route should not pass down the Garvaghy Road, but on the 25th of September, a Parades Commission determination allowed for 35 members of Portadown Lodge to walk along the Garvaghy Road without the accompaniment of music on Sunday the 27th of September. To some, this was a legal victory that recognized the religious, cultural, and personal significance of this procession. To others, it was a profound shock and a reopening of wounds they long thought closed. On Saturday the 26th of September, following a challenge brought on behalf of the residents, a temporary injunction was granted, then appealed and overturned, before permission to seek judicial review was refused in the early hours of Sunday the 27th.

The parade, lawfully determined, was due to take place at 8:00 AM that same morning. However, the Orange Order were unable to complete that route due to an unlawful, unnotified protest by residents of the Garvaghy Road and their supporters who blocked the road. For much of the two weeks since, Drumcree has once again been the scene of a standoff. This is a deeply emotive and hurtful issue for many of those who've been involved in this dispute, either now or in the past. I have spent the last fortnight in extensive conversations with all affected parties trying to get a mutually acceptable agreement between the two sides.

I hosted several rounds of negotiations at Hillsborough Castle over five days and maintained frequent contact with those involved, including members of this House. During those discussions, we explored multiple options for ending the impasse. These included options such as the Portadown Lodge completing one final march along the Garvaghy Road on the condition that it would not apply to march that route again, and an option that would have seen Portadown Lodge accept that it had won the right to march but agree not to exercise that right. Other options included the residents accepting that the Lodge had established the legal right and would not challenge other parts of the route. Unfortunately, we could not secure agreement.

I want to thank the Portadown Lodge for their time and their constructive engagement. Their commitment to upholding the law and their cooperation with the police has been absolutely vital in maintaining calm and order. I recognize that having received a determination permitting them to march after 28 years, they will feel bitter disappointment at its prohibition. I also want to thank the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition for their engagement.

They made clear to me the profound anxiety this dispute has brought, relighting painful memories. I deeply regret that we were not able to reach a compromise on a way forward. Although I was still keen to establish a local agreement, I did not want to see the standoff continue into another weekend, with the consequent risk of protests spreading to other parts of Northern Ireland and the further deterioration of community relations. I therefore intensively considered all options for bringing this dispute to an end. On Friday the 9th of October, the Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland made an application to me under section 9 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act.

As required by law, I reviewed the initial determination made by the Parades Commission relating to the application made by the Portadown District for the 27th of September 2026. I consulted the Chief Constable and the Parades Commission. The Chief Constable advised me that it would not be possible to enable the procession to happen without a major intervention which would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder, and a wider contagion effect across Northern Ireland. The Parades Commission also advised me that while ultimately a matter for the courts to determine, the Commission was of the view that, in the light of this current assessment by the Chief Constable, the original determination does not now have enduring legal effect. As a result, given that the circumstances under which that decision was made have now changed considerably and in the interests of wider public interest and safety, I came to the conclusion that the procession should not go ahead as it was originally determined.

I did not take this decision lightly. I had tried to get a locally agreed solution, and as the Court of Appeal has held today, the Portadown District had a lawful determination from the Parades Commission allowing the procession. I have also not criticized the original determination made by the Parades Commission in good faith and based on the information it had at the time. Indeed, as part of my decision on Friday, I confirmed that original determination, which has also been upheld as lawful by the court, as anybody who criticizes the Parades Commission should bear in mind. But I must acknowledge that the situation has changed considerably, which is why I used my powers under section 11 of the Act to prohibit the procession.

Madam Deputy Speaker, respect for the rule of law is fundamental to our society. And I am grateful to those who have behaved peacefully and legally and sought to ease tensions in their respective communities. It is right to say that the Orange Order obtained a legal right to parade, but I agree with the Chief Constable who has said upholding of the Parades Commission determination does not come at any cost. Upholding the law also entails judiciously preventing serious disorder, which is why I am glad that despite the manifest tension, events have passed peacefully in Portadown. That is in itself a significant achievement.

I want to thank the PSNI officers who have carried the burden of policing this difficult situation. However, nobody is able to grant themselves immunity from the law. And those who have acted unlawfully must face the consequences of their actions. It is not for me to determine how the police exercise their duties, but I am glad that the PSNI operation in relation to unlawful protesting on the Garvaghy Road is underway. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am grateful to all those who have engaged with me in good faith and to those within this House who have worked diligently to reduce tensions.

I particularly thank those who have sought to moderate their language. It is easy to stir up a grievance; it is much harder to calm it down.

I appeal now to everyone to help reduce tensions and for all political and community leaders to consider carefully the effect of their words. I urge people to let the courts do their work and to cooperate fully with the police and the Parades Commission. The community in Portadown has been on the sharp end of intense attention for a number of weeks. It will take time to rebuild relationships. Sometimes leadership is extremely difficult.

But it is vital that at this time the political parties in Northern Ireland offer stability. That can be a challenge when loud voices dominate. But in my conversations with both sides and with political leaders from different parties and traditions, I have met many extraordinary people of good faith who do want to rebuild trust and cooperation based on mutual respect. I hope all members will want to share in that ambition. I commend this statement to the House.

04:32:25 - 04:35:20

Alex Burghart

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of his statement and for the call that he made to me over the weekend. I do not envy him the position he's been placed in these past few weeks. The scenes that we have witnessed on the streets of Drumcree are all too reminiscent of previous times. Times that we had all hoped were past, times that we must still hope are past.

The willingness of communities nearly 30 years ago to submit to independent adjudication processes was one of the pillars of the peace. It is consequently at best irresponsible and at worst dangerous for people to ignore those processes when they do not go their way. Further, it is inexcusable for anyone, but particularly politicians, to decide that they will only obey the law when it suits them. This is the road, Madam Deputy Speaker, to a very dark place. As the Secretary of State has set out, the planned march was legal, subject to the detailed restrictions placed upon it by the Commission.

It follows that under section 14 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, those who prevented this lawful march would seem to have broken the law. The standoff that they caused ultimately led to Chief Constable Boucher asking the Secretary of State to review the Commission's determination and stop the march. The Chief Constable said that facilitating it would have required a substantial public order intervention that was not assessed to be proportionate and which would have carried an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder, and a wider contagion effect across Northern Ireland. I hope the Secretary of State can be clear with the House about what is behind this statement and what the nature of that risk was. Was the Secretary of State at any stage made aware of a possibility of terrorism?

Was he at any stage made aware that firearms or explosives were likely to be deployed? I very much hope he was not, but I do think the House should know. I know that the Secretary of State was placed in a desperately invidious position, but the consequence of the march not going ahead is that those who have broken the law have won. The consequence is that those who threatened the serious injury, disorder, and wider contagion of which the Chief Constable warned have won. Unless remedy is made, the message being sent to Northern Ireland is that people can pick and choose which laws they obey and that those who threaten violence and disorder will get their way.

I know that this is not what the Secretary of State wants. But I do think that he needs to tell the House what he intends to do to prevent that terrible message being the legacy of these past few weeks. And I know that it is not for him to determine how the police exercise their duties following this incident. But I hope he can tell the House how the government now intends to prevent the law from being openly flouted again and again and again.

04:35:20 - 04:37:36

Chris Bryant

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm very grateful for the tone in which the my shadow has entered into this conversation and I was grateful for him taking the call over the weekend and I very much hope that we can work cooperatively together. We've not actually faced each other as Secretary of State and Shadow Secretary of State until now. Two things I want to say. First of all, I say this to those who flouted the law and to those who are considering doing so again, nobody is above the law and you will face the consequences of your actions. To those who have cooperated with the police, thank you, thank you enormously and to those who are considering ending cooperation with the police, please, please, please think again.

He asked me specifically about the advice I'd I received and he quoted in precise words the terms that I had been given by the Chief Constable. I've publicly set out that advice and I the advice I received that facilitating the procession would require a major police intervention carrying unacceptable risks as he said. I think he will understand that I'm not going to comment on specific intelligence that I did or did not receive for obvious reasons. But in the end, I'm accountable for the decision that I made. It was my responsibility to weigh the police advice and the consequences of proceeding, which is precisely what I did.

He asks about how we're going to make sure that we build respect for the rule of law. I think that that is a matter for all communities to do into the future. I would also point out that he makes the point about politicians. We politicians have a particular responsibility to abide by not just the letter of the law but the spirit of the law. And indeed the Northern Ireland Act requires ministers in schedule 4 to pledge to uphold the rule of law based as it is on the fundamental principles of fairness, impartiality and democratic accountability, including support for policing and the courts.

These should not just be words that are spoken one moment, they should be things that we embody in everything we do.

04:37:37 - 04:38:16

Hilary James Benn

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. My right honourable friend was clearly faced with a very difficult decision, but in the light of the advice he had been given by the Chief Constable, which he's reported to the House, I think he took the right decision and I thank him for it. Given the enormous progress that Northern Ireland has made since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, who would want to go back? What does my right honourable friend think is now required to restore confidence in an independent process for determining parades?

04:38:16 - 04:39:35

Chris Bryant

I'm very grateful to my predecessor to whom I pay tribute and am grateful for his kind words. I think there are several things we need to do. The first thing we need to do, I think what this moment has shown is that the veneer of peace is sometimes remarkably thin. And we need to strengthen the relationship between different communities. One of the things I found most moving was when people said to me how cross-community organisations in Portadown had been completely discombobulated and thrown up into confusion over these last two weeks and it's one of the reasons why I did want us to be able to get to a successful conclusion that worked for everybody.

He's right about the parades position. I note that some people who a few weeks ago were passionately opposed to the Parades Commission are now passionately in support of the Parades Commission and vice versa. The truth is we one of the we had problems earlier on this year and that's why I've set up an inquiry led by Justice O'Hara, who I think has been warmly supported by everybody in that process. We need to make sure that the Parades Commission works for the future and and I and I would hope that everybody in this House at least would want to urge people to be working closely with the police rather than undermining them.

04:39:35 - 04:41:21

Paul Kohler

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Paul Keiller.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of his statement. This is a complicated and sensitive issue and my party supports all those from every community who are focused on de-escalation and working together on a shared future. The Secretary of State's decision was based on unambiguous police advice and I do not think he had any real alternative available to him. I know how hard he and others sought to achieve compromise and I share his deep regret that was not possible.

As he recognized in his statement, respect for the rule of law is fundamental to any democratic society. It is consequently imperative the legitimate concerns of many in regard to what message this decision conveys must be recognized and taken into account as we seek to move forward. The impact events like this have on local people in Portadown must be our first concern. People living side by side and getting on with their lives suffer by this replaying of the worst chapters of the past. Our task on all sides of the House is to support those who want to move forward, to protect the institutions, respect the rule of law and ensure this dispute does not undermine the hard-won progress of the last 30 years.

I have three questions for the Secretary of State. Firstly, what discussions has he had with the Executive and political leaders in Northern Ireland about ensuring the institutions remain stable throughout this period? What more does he think can be done to ensure the rule of law is upheld and respected by all political leaders across Northern Ireland? And finally, what support is being provided to the communities in Portadown, particularly young people who have lived through three weeks of escalating tension?

04:41:21 - 04:43:04

Chris Bryant

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful again for the way in which he's approached this. Number one, on the discussions with the Executive. I mean, part of my attempt to have discussions with the Executive has focused on trying to get a budget for the Executive as well. We're six months in and we still haven't got a settled budget and that is going to provide very significant problems in the very near future for the whole of the operation of the Executive if we're not very careful.

And I'm very keen to work with the Executive to get to a good outcome there. We have made an offer of 1.5 billion pounds and more over three years. I think that is a good settlement considering the difficult situation we've got. I would say that everybody has been predicting the collapse of the Executive for some time and it seems to be much more resilient than people would suggest. And that is a good thing.

In terms of the rule of law, it's not for me to tell the police who and whom they should be speaking to about unlawful actions or for me to determine what the punishment should be. But I would merely point out that an offence under the Act carries up to a six months imprisonment and a level five fine. And of course that is for the prosecuting authorities to consider. In relation to the young people in Portadown, I'm very keen when a little bit of the dust has settled. I think that one of the phrases that was frequently used on both sides was that people wanted a breathing space.

We've got that breathing space now. I think once the dust has settled a little bit then it will be important for us to consider and I want to do this with obvious local representatives to work out how we can strengthen the cross-community relationships which have undoubtedly, as he says, been tested over the last couple of weeks.

04:43:04 - 04:43:28

Speaker 249

Madam Deputy Speaker, sometimes you'd be forgiven for forgetting that in the late 90s, 21 Catholics were murdered as a result of this dispute. Three of them were children, the Quinn boys who were burned to death in their homes. Why anybody thought it was a good idea to try to force this parade down that street is frankly beyond me. And it's beyond any right-thinking person.

04:43:28 - 04:43:55

Speaker 248

This wound should never ever have been opened up again. The Garvaghy Road residents have had this done to them. They've had it done on them. This chaos has been visited to their door. Will the Secretary of State work with the Irish government to ensure the proper investment is now put into Portadown to rebuild relationships that took a long long time to build back up?

04:43:55 - 04:45:16

Chris Bryant

Well, I'm grateful for my right honourable colleague's comments. In fact, we were only here a few weeks ago listening, having had the Robert Hamill report, which of course happened and his murder occurred against the background of the problems in Portadown back in the day as well. So I think it is still very live and very raw for a large number of people in the community. I do have to push back to him though. The Parades Commission decision has been upheld by the courts on repeated occasions now and I have not, I did not revoke the decision, the decision.

However, given the situation when the Section 9 letter came to me from the police the other day, it became, it was absolutely apparent that this was a matter that I had to deal with. The final point is he asks me to get the Irish government to be engaged. Of course I always want to work as cooperatively as I possibly can with the Irish government and I've spoken to them several times. But in the end, security in Northern Ireland is the responsibility of the UK government and we need to make sure that community relations in Northern Ireland are enhanced.

04:45:16 - 04:46:47

Gavin Robinson

The Secretary of State is right to indicate that the Parades Commission considered and approved the parade. But how sad is it that on Friday evening or indeed in the statement this evening he doesn't conclude by saying he is determined to uphold the rule of law that will include the completion of a parade, would welcome a fresh application to be considered on its own merits and whether now or in the future will ensure that no lawful application will succumb to the threats of violence. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the last 28 years the police, the RUC and the PSNI have always maintained the position that they will police whatever determination is. They can't say that anymore. For the last 28 years no Secretary of State has ever used Section 11 powers even when there was actually violence, actual disorder and guns on the street.

People in Northern Ireland know that this is more about obstruction on a road, Madam Deputy Speaker. They know that it is a threat of violence from terrorists and they know that this British government has bent the knee to them. We need to see the rule of law upheld but we also need to see political accountability. The Secretary of State mentions Schedule 4 of the Northern Ireland Act. He knows that there is no consequence for breach of the pledge of office.

Will he meet with my colleagues and I to ensure that there is?

04:46:47 - 04:48:12

Chris Bryant

Madam Deputy Speaker, the honourable gentleman knows that he and I have had many discussions about this issue over the last fortnight and I'm grateful to the way in which he has conducted those conversations with me. I do however utterly reject the charge that I have in any way succumbed to mob rule. The truth is things have actually passed remarkably peacefully. There has been no major disorder. Now lots of people lobbied me or provided advice over the airwaves on how to deal with the situation but I don't think anybody seriously proposed that the police should drag people off the street.

And I would just say to him gently that the rule of law is not just a single headline. It's equality before the law, transparent laws, the separation of powers, an independent judiciary, and access to justice. All of these things are actually in remarkably fine fettle in Northern Ireland. There are, as I've said previously, some abnormalities about the way the executive and power-sharing works in Northern Ireland. I'm very happy to sit down with him and to work through ways in which we can make this function better.

That may need, as I've said to him before, some reform of the institutions at Stormont.

04:48:12 - 04:49:03

John Martin McDonnell

2010, Tom Bingham, who was Lord Justice then, published his book, The Rule of Law, which often we cite in this House. And he said about ministers' decisions, ministers and public officers at all levels must exercise the powers conferred on them in good faith, fairly, and for the purpose for which the powers were conferred, without exceeding the limits of such powers, and not unreasonably. Can I say to him, I believe that he upheld that principle set out by Tom Bingham all those years ago excellently in making this decision, which was a difficult decision, I know. But he'll know in this summer at the Belfast Fleadh, all traditions of music came together, including many unionist bands and singers, and they were welcomed and enjoyed together. Isn't that the spirit in which we want to go forward in building unity?

04:49:03 - 04:50:12

Chris Bryant

Well, I'm grateful for my honorable friend's comments. This was undoubtedly, this was certainly a difficult decision, but a decision I was in law required to make, having been written to by the Chief Constable under Section 9 of the Act. And I chose to make the eventual decision based on the advice that he had given. But I want to say this more generally, which is mutual respect between different communities is often hard-won, and moments like this can rapidly descend into greater disorder and into problems, which is why I was very keen not to let this run on at great length, and that's why I responded in the way I did. But we do have a job of work in Northern Ireland to do still to enhance mutual respect between people.

Some of the language that has been used from one community to the other and back again has been utterly vile. And I think it's incumbent on all of us, in particular as Members of Parliament, to moderate our language.

04:50:12 - 04:51:14

Speaker 197

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, I never thought in my lifetime that I would see again Land Rovers lined up outside Drumcree Church. The people of Northern Ireland did not clamor for this, and that includes people that are unionist, nationalist, and other. They did not want to revisit this incredibly dark chapter in our history. Whilst the cost of living bites, this operation at the time of conclusion cost around five million pounds.

What we have now is picking up the pieces. Secretary of State, you have referred to the language that we use. In the last week, members of this House have referred to people of the Garvaghy Road as rabble. They have referred to the fact that the Garvaghy Road needed, quote-unquote, sanitization. Would you agree with me that in the mouth of this crisis, it is incumbent on all members of this House, but everybody across Northern Ireland, to engage respectfully across all communities, all communities of which have suffered in the last few weeks?

Would you agree with me?

04:51:14 - 04:52:00

Chris Bryant

I think one of the biggest problems, and I found this when we were trying to reach some kind of consensus between the two sides when we gathered everybody in Hillsborough, when I have to say both sides were immensely respectful.

One of the difficulties was that sometimes the moment they spoke to somebody outside the room, louder voices prevailed and dragged them away from compromise. That, I think, is a problem that we have regularly, and I think social media amplifies some of this as well, which makes it more difficult. I should also say that I know that there are members of this House who have been vilified, absolutely vilified, just for standing up for their constituents, and that's not appropriate either.

04:52:00 - 04:52:42

David William Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for his statement and for the tone that he's taken. He's in an invidious position, as we can see in the debate here. And I wonder if he'd agree with me that ultimately, if we take one step back from these events, that really what we're talking about here is the lack of societal reconciliation in Northern Ireland over 30 years now since the Good Friday Agreement. And that we in this House and those politicians in Northern Ireland have a role to try and foster that reconciliation wherever we can, whether it's in the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill or in another way in the way we resource it, fund it, and take a lead on that.

04:52:42 - 04:53:13

Chris Bryant

I think the most important thing that we have to realize is that the job of work of the Good Friday Agreement is not complete. There are so many different elements of it which were sort of parked at the time, and we need to complete. It's one of the reasons why I think it's very important that we get the Troubles Bill right, because I've met so many people who still bear not just bruises but deep, deep scars from the Troubles, and they want to get answers, and that's precisely what we're trying to legislate for at the moment.

04:53:13 - 04:53:53

Robin Swann

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The parade was lawful. The protest was unlawful. What we're actually hearing in response in Northern Ireland to that protest is in stark contrast to what we heard from the Home Secretary in the statement prior to the Secretary of State's. He said in his statement, let the courts do their work.

Can I ask the Secretary of State, when he knew that the court was to rule today, why did he move from section 9 to making a section 11 decision on Friday night rather than waiting on the court today?

04:53:53 - 04:54:18

Chris Bryant

Well, when I received the section 9 letter on the morning of Friday, I had no idea when the court was going to come to its conclusions, and obviously I'd been asked and I'm required by law to consult, as I did with the Parades Commission and with the Chief Constable, and that's the process that I followed. I don't want to stray further into that process simply because all of this is subject to legal challenge.

04:54:18 - 04:55:09

Gregory Campbell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State has outlined the issues in terms of the Drumcree parade, and in his statement he says, and those who have acted unlawfully must face the consequences of their actions. If that process is allowed to proceed, and hopefully it will be, police must do their job and the prosecution service their job. But beyond that, people in Northern Ireland need to know that if political leaders and others break the law, there are consequences beyond the court proceedings, consequences that will preclude them from holding office. Is he prepared to issue and to declare and to discuss what can be done in terms of sanctions to prevent a lawbreaker holding public office if they break the criminal law?

04:55:09 - 04:55:47

Chris Bryant

Well, I think the honorable member is asking me to introduce primary legislation to change the Northern Ireland Act. That isn't my intention at the moment because I'm not sure what other process there would be that he's considering, but I'm very happy to consider it with him. I noted one of the things he said earlier, I think, or was it maybe it was yesterday on the television. He said that the last thing we want is Chris Bryant running Northern Ireland. And he's nodding to that, so I got that right.

And so maybe we can agree with each other that I want the Northern Ireland Executive to continue in operation, and I certainly don't want to be in a position where I'm running all of Northern Ireland.

04:55:47 - 04:57:13

Jim Allister

Could I begin by paying tribute to Portadown District, who abided by the law to the letter, and yet had the response of being kicked in the teeth by those who broke the law being rewarded. And could I also commend the honorable member for the district of Portadown, the honorable member for Upper Bann, for for her stand, for her leadership, for her courage, and utterly condemn the shocking demonization and abuse to which she has been subjected. As for the Secretary of State, it is so sad, sad for me to say it, that the Secretary of State's shameful surrender to the mob rule and to the threat of violence has trampled the rule of law into the gutter in Northern Ireland. Not only tonight do we still have a First Minister of lawlessness because of the inaction of the DUP, but now we have a Secretary of State, now we have a Secretary of State who chose to back the lawbreakers. What a travesty.

My question is this: how can the rule of law recover when the Secretary of State undermines it so spectacularly?

04:57:13 - 04:58:09

Chris Bryant

Well, I am fond of the honorable gentleman, though he does remind me of the John Lewis advert, never knowingly undersold, because his arguments are never knowingly undersold. He called me pathetic yesterday, I think, on the television, and he keeps on referring to mob rule. I would just say that every time people use this term "mob" about people on the other side of the argument, I think it actually makes it more difficult. And I would also say that the use of the word "sanitizing" was particularly inappropriate, particularly inappropriate. I just think that it behooves us all to moderate our language because people look to us to provide leadership.

And in a situation where compromise is normally the best outcome for everybody, for all communities, it's best if we manage to come to a if we double down on compromise ourselves.

04:58:09 - 05:00:02

Carla Lockhart

Carla Lockhart.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the honorable member and all those honorable members who have reached out with regards to the level of abuse that has been received. I find it absolutely incredible that I am standing in this House where we make the law, confronting a Secretary of State who has wilted before those who have defied the law. Twenty-eight years Portadown District obeyed the determinations they opposed. When they secured a legal determination to return, this government and the PSNI bowed to those IRA commanders, dissidents, and a First Minister who broke the law on the Garvaghy Road. Mob rule won, whether the Secretary of State likes to admit it or not.

At Hillsborough Castle, he treated law-abiding citizens as equals with Brendan McKenna, whose record is very clear. He held a family at hostage and was involved in the blowing up of Portadown Royal British Legion. He has impeded the police doing their job over the last two weeks and thinks we're all effers.

Yet lawbreaking has been rewarded by this sovereign Parliament. A shameful surrender and one that has very serious consequences for the rule of law in Northern Ireland. The Secretary of State has, like Michelle O'Neill and the Chief Constable, thumbed their noses at law-abiding citizens and laughed and smirked whilst doing it. And their positions are becoming more untenable with every passing moment. Does the rule of law only apply to law-abiding citizens in Northern Ireland whilst the self-titled First Minister for all seems to be immune?

05:00:02 - 05:01:50

Chris Bryant

Madam Deputy Speaker, when I referred earlier to those who've been vilified, I was actually going to refer to her because I've seen some of the foul comments that have been made about her online and elsewhere. And I completely abhor that. And as she knows, I've spoken to her regularly throughout this whole process so that we've tried to maintain a very civil conversation between us. I just want to clear up one other thing that she asked. She didn't ask about this today, but she said I would have to answer this question this evening.

She said this earlier in the day. She said that I had to clear up whether I became aware of what today's judgment was before or after I made my ruling. I think she's suggesting that in some way or other I knew what the court was going to decide today before anybody else. I want to make it absolutely clear that I did not. At the time I started my determination, I didn't even know when the court was going to come up with its ruling.

So I very much hope that she will withdraw that semi-allegation. I, and more importantly, I had to respond to the Section 9 request from the court, from the Chief Constable. She, I'm afraid sometimes she resorts to extravagant and erring language as well. And I'm not sure that that really helps secure an outcome for the Orange Lodge. The final point I'd make to her is she is absolutely right that everybody needs to uphold the law.

I very much hope that she would urge everybody that she knows who is now saying that they should not cooperate with the police to cooperate with the police. Because otherwise, I'm afraid it is a question of what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

05:01:50 - 05:03:21

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. First of all, can I pay tribute to the honorable lady for Upper Bann for her determination, for her courage, and her leadership in and to stand strong against the threats that have been made, physical threats, verbal threats, all sorts of threats to her and her family. And I think we in this House should stand strong with the previous statement, Madam Deputy Speaker, referred to security for individuals. That's one individual member of this House who deserves and everyone in this House should back the honorable lady as she makes her stand. My constituents are asking me this question.

Why did the Secretary of State take the extraordinary step of intervening before the Court of Appeal had delivered its scheduled legal ruling today? As by preempting the highest courts in the land, what message does this catastrophic surrender send to extremist factions active across the entire United Kingdom? If they descend upon a community in great numbers, refuse to obey the law, and threaten violence, the government will grant them their aims. If I'd have blocked the roads in Francis Street in Newtownards on Saturday along with my constituents, we'd have been in Bangor custody within 30 minutes. So will the Secretary of State admit that this sets a devastating national precedent?

This is a policy of short-sighted appeasement that buys peace for the day at the expense of our future. So why should law-abiding citizens continue to trust the democratic process when government signals to extremists of every stripe that street-level intimidation trumps the rule of law and the British ideology of upholding law and justice as a foundation has now crumbled? Thank you.

05:03:21 - 05:05:13

Chris Bryant

First of all, just to be clear, the court decision today, the court was looking, the appeal court was looking at a completely different matter from the matter that was before me. The appeal court was looking at the decision that was made by the Parades Commission on the 25th of September. I was looking at the situation on the 9th of October. These are two different matters and that's why it was not material to me whether the court was going to be ruling today. As a matter of fact, I didn't know at the time when the letter came in from the Chief Constable when the court was going to be ruling.

More importantly, under the Act, I am required by law to respond to the Chief Constable's request under section 9, and that's what I did. I decided, as the courts did, to uphold the original decision, the original determination of the Parades Commission, but also to consider the situation as it pertains now and the advice that had been given to me by the Parades Commission and by the Chief Constable. Just on the final point, I know there are people who are arguing that this is the end of the rule of law in Northern Ireland in some way. I just want to say to people, actually what has happened in the last few weeks is, yes, people have said very cross things to one another. Yes, people have shouted at one another.

They have mostly done so in the Assembly or here in Parliament today or on the airwaves. They have not been throwing things at each other. It has been peaceful in Portadown. And I just want to say that that is an achievement, not the opposite of an achievement, because in the end policing is not just about ensuring a determination can be upheld, it's also about judiciously preserving the peace.

05:05:13 - 05:05:32

Speaker 260

Can I thank the Secretary of State for his statement this afternoon, and I will allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over. Point of order, Ian Roome.

05:05:32 - 05:06:12

Robin Swann

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've now written to the Health Secretary four times between 27th of July and the 7th of October to request an urgent meeting about the maternity crisis at North Devon District Hospital, and I've yet to even receive a response. The Prime Minister also promised to write to the hon. Member for Kingston and Surbiton an update on the crisis on 2nd of September, and that the Health Secretary would respond. This is an urgent health emergency for expectant moms across Devon and Cornwall. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, what remedy is available to members of this House?

05:06:12 - 05:06:47

Speaker 259

Can I thank the hon. Member for his point of order. He will know, as indeed the whole House will, of the importance that Ministers provide timely responses to correspondence from members. The Treasury front bench will have heard his concerns, and I note it is the Leader of the House who is listening to this. The Leader takes these matters very seriously, and I'm sure will report back to the relevant Health Minister to make sure that the hon. Member's concerns are addressed. Motion number one on business of the House today.

Minister to move.

05:06:47 - 05:06:48

Move formally.

05:06:48 - 05:07:26

Speaker 259

The question is as on the order paper. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.

We now come to the Select Committee statement on behalf of the Procedure Committee. Cat Smith will speak for up to ten minutes, during which no interventions may be taken. At the conclusion of her statement, members may ask questions on the subject of the statement, which must be brief questions, not full speeches. I call Cat Smith.

05:07:26 - 05:16:58

Catherine Jane Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Procedure Committee has now concluded our in-depth review of the written parliamentary questions system, and we were pleased to publish our report just before the conference recess. I'd like to thank the Backbench Business Committee for granting time for this statement today. I'd also like to put on record my thanks to current and former members of the Procedure Committee for their thoughtful consideration throughout the inquiry. My committee regularly reviews the performance of departments in answering written parliamentary questions, but there was a sense that a wider review was needed.

And for the benefit of the House, the context of that was that the written parliamentary questions system really wasn't working for MPs. The numbers of questions had risen drastically, and the responses weren't keeping pace or, frankly, meeting our expectations when it came to terms of quality. Equally, we knew that the Government and the House administration were under pressure to deliver in a system that was at risk of being overwhelmed. So we launched our inquiry in November 2023, and we ran a survey of MPs and received written evidence and heard in person from opposition frontbenchers and groups of backbenchers. I'd like to thank the many colleagues from across the House who gave evidence to the committee.

We know that colleagues are not always satisfied with government responses to WPQs. We know that this feeling has increased in the context of the number of WPQs also increasing sharply. The theme that we heard was that there were frustrations amongst colleagues that a small number of MPs submitting a disproportionate number of questions, which could be construed as an abuse of the system. Members who make restrained and focused use of the WPQ system for their parliamentary work are being effectively adversely affected by this. The system overall needs to be based on a lower volume of input but a higher quality of output when it comes to responses from the Government.

So the flip side of our efforts is to alleviate some of the pressures on the system is that we think that MPs should expect better responses from the Government. We heard concerns that some WPQs are being tabled with limited member involvement. We are clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, that WPQs are a proceeding in Parliament and therefore should always be initiated by elected members. Indeed, we can't send our staff to come and speak in oral questions for us, nor should we expect our staff to be tabling WPQs without us seeing them. At present, this is reflected by the hard copy WPQs needing our wet signature on if we're to table them that way at the Table Office.

And we believe that this should be reflected by the modern-day modern e-tabling system, so that we recommend that members should be required to personally approve in MemberHub questions submitted by their staff. The fundamental e-tabling limit should remain at 20 per member per sitting day, but a limit should be introduced for recesses. It is, in our view, an anomaly that this limit applies in sitting times but not in recess. Members will understandably wish to scrutinize developing events during a recess, but as WPQs submitted during recess can't be answered until the House returns, there is often a better way of doing this, such as corresponding directly with ministers. So our recommendation is that a limit be set of 20 WPQs per member for recess for one calendar week in length, and a further 10 WPQs for each additional full calendar week.

I.e., you get more questions the longer the recess. We remind colleagues that these are very much maximums and not targets to be hit, and that when we increase quantity, we may see a decline in quality. And indeed, that it's not necessarily looking busy by tabling more WPQs than your neighboring MP is not an indication of how well you're working as an MP.

We listened to colleagues' concerns about carding as well, and we found that the process generally works well, but the terminology could be modernized. A card isn't a red card, a card isn't a block, it is merely a query that can generally be resolved very quickly by nipping into the table office. So we recommended that carding should be renamed querying to reflect this. But also, where a member accumulates a large number of unresolved queries, the old money carding, at any one time, it creates a blockage in the system and reduces the table office's ability to advise other members. When members receive 20 live unaddressed queries at any one time, they should be required to address those before submitting further WPQs.

At the moment, there is a cutoff time for the same-day e-tabling of WPQs, but it's different on different days of the week. It falls outside of the normal working day, and the committee believe that a uniform time of 4:00 PM should be set on Mondays to Thursdays. That's more straightforward for members, but it also means that the focus of table office staff in the evenings, when there are far fewer staff available, is rightly on advising members on matters such as motions and amendments for the following day, rather than marshalling WPQs. It allows for questions to be considered over more time, supporting our goal of improving the consistency of colleagues' experiences. Given that Friday sitting hours, we recommend that we remain the 2:30 cutoff on Fridays.

We know that having an exceptional route to an urgent answer is very useful to colleagues, but we found that named day was a very confusing term for some. And we thought that in terms of modernization, we could replace that with priority questions, which better reflect the core purpose of a named day question. Priority questions should be a more simple term for colleagues to understand, but we recommend that the deadline for answer for priority questions should be set automatically at three working days after tabling, which is the earliest that you can get an answer for a named day question. The limits for priority questions should remain unchanged at five per member per sitting day, and colleagues should consider using an ordinary question to get a detailed response and use the priority questions where speed is more of the essence. Turning to government responses, we heard a range of concerns with government responses to WPQs from colleagues across the house, and the government should address these, particularly ensuring that questions are grouped sparingly, but always individually addressed within a combined response.

We recommend that references to information published elsewhere should be used sparingly, with relevant extracts and not just hyperlinks. And that the government communicate with members and the table office where there is a block over questions on a particular topic. There should also be more transparency and accountability about the government's performance in answering WPQs. And to that end, we have recommended a public-facing dashboard be introduced on the parliamentary website to be updated monthly, showing the performance of each department in answering WPQs on time. That will empower members, the public, and even the press to pursue inadequate performance, and we hope that it will also help the government to drive forward improvements.

We recommend that members consider how we use WPQs. We are best placed to decide as individual elected representatives when we need to ask a particular question, but we should also consider the cost to the public purse. There are many alternatives, including other parliamentary proceedings, ministerial correspondence, and the excellent services provided by the House of Commons Library. And sometimes we might actually get a better outcome from these.

Lastly, AI was an emerging theme in our inquiry and we appreciate concerns raised by members. We are a forward-thinking committee and we do see the benefit to it in improving the processes, but we are more cautious about its use for content. The most important thing is that MPs check and remain responsible for their questions and that ministers check and remain responsible for their answers. Ultimately, as we set out in the report, given the importance of WPQs to members across the house, we recognize the importance of bringing the house with us. And for that reason, we have recommended that the government bring forward a motion to endorse this report as a whole to enable the house to endorse its findings, recommendations and statements of principle and to allow the house administration, the government and all of us to get on with implementing it.

We hope that colleagues will support this motion when it comes before the house. And we have overhauled the WPQ system in a very much modernizing direction, but we haven't been able to take up every suggestion that was made to us, but we have sought to give colleagues a better experience of WPQs and to make them a more valuable tool, including for our important function of scrutinizing government. The committee will review our findings and their implementation as we continue our regular work monitoring departmental performance in answering WPQs and on that basis, Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this report to the house.

05:16:58 - 05:17:24

Speaker 259

Well, the honorable lady's got off very lightly if nobody wishes to ask her a question on that. So we now come to the second select committee statement on behalf of the International Development Committee. Sarah Champion will speak for up to 10 minutes during which there will be no interventions and at the conclusion of her statement, members may ask questions on the subject of the statement. I call Sarah Champion.

05:17:24 - 05:24:37

Sarah Champion

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, I appreciate it. Climate change is not a distant threat. It's already reshaping lives and livelihoods around the world. The earth is warming and with it, rainfall patterns are becoming increasingly unpredictable. Sea levels are rising and extreme weather events are now more frequent and more severe.

The impacts of climate change are being felt more than ever, both at home in the UK and even more acutely in the world's poorest and most climate-vulnerable countries. Climate change is often discussed in terms of emission targets, financial commitments and international agreements. But behind these debates, there is a humanitarian crisis unfolding. A crisis of homes destroyed, crops failing, livelihoods lost and communities struggling to rebuild in the wake of disasters they did little to cause. We witnessed such a reality most recently in Nepal.

In a matter of hours, devastating floods washed away entire cities, leaving thousands of people dead or missing, forcing many more to face an uncertain future in a country where a quarter of the population already lives in poverty. But Nepal is not an isolated case. And with the prospect of a super El Niño, if countries are unable to mitigate and adapt to climate change, such disasters are set to become the norm. It is against this backdrop that the International Development Select Committee has published its report examining the UK's international climate finance commitments. Our inquiries focused on three overarching themes.

First, the government's successive reductions to ODA have made it difficult to deliver on its climate finance commitments to lower and middle-income countries in a transparent, meaningful and credible way. Frustratingly, rather than striving to deliver genuine climate and nature outcomes, the government has been cutting corners to maintain headline spending commitments. This is impacting on our international credibility.

Our report highlights that the government has also substantially reduced the ODA proportion of the UK's climate finance commitment for the next three years. This comes at a time when climate finance needs are growing and when sustained international leadership is more important than ever. To that end, I welcome the new Foreign Secretary, who I would argue is uniquely qualified to meet this challenge. But let me be clear, it is an enormous challenge. Recent policy shifts in the US, alongside signaling from major multilateral institutions that they may scale back or abandon climate finance targets, have created an increasingly uncertain landscape for climate action.

In that context, the case for strong and consistent UK leadership has never been clearer. Second, the UK's climate finance is not simply about how much money is spent. It's about who can access it, who benefits from it, and who has a voice in how it is used. In a period of constrained public finances, the quality, accessibility, and effectiveness of the UK's climate finance is vital. Throughout our inquiry, we repeatedly heard that climate finance is most effective when local organizations, communities, and subnational governments can access high-quality funding directly and play a meaningful role in designing and delivering climate solutions themselves.

We also heard compelling evidence about the importance of inclusion. Women and girls, for example, disproportionately bear the brunt of climate impacts, yet receive less than 1% of climate finance globally. However, women and girls are often agents of change within their communities, capable of driving long-lasting climate outcomes. It's clear that, too often, those most affected by climate challenges face the greatest barriers to accessing the UK's climate finance. That is why the committee's report argues that the UK's climate finance, regardless of whether it's delivered through its own programs, multilateral institutions, or partners, must be more accessible, inclusive, and responsive to the needs and priorities of the most climate-vulnerable countries.

Third, we consider the government's evolving approach to mobilizing private finance for climate adaptation and mitigation. We recognize that, in a resource-constrained environment, the government is increasingly seeking to mobilize private capital to help it meet its climate finance obligations. We acknowledge that the pathway to addressing climate change is one that must include the private sector. However, our government has a critical role in creating an enabling environment that allows private finance to flow where it is needed most. That means using the UK's development finance institutions, guarantees, partnerships, and diplomatic influence strategically to reduce risk, strengthen local capacity, support investable projects, and direct investments towards climate and nature outcomes.

But the shift from donor to investor must not come at the expense of poverty reduction. Public climate finance has a unique role to play in supporting the poorest and the most climate-vulnerable countries, particularly where private finance investment is least likely to go. The government must therefore ensure that its efforts to mobilize private finance complement rather than replace grant-based solutions to support those communities that need it most. But, Chamber, let me be blunt. Climate change threatens to reverse decades of hard-won progress towards sustainable development goals.

It not only risks perpetuating a vicious cycle of poverty, instability, and humanitarian need in the most climate-vulnerable countries, but will have downstream implications for the UK's own prosperity and security.

The question now facing the government is not simply how much climate finance can be provided. The real test is whether the UK can demonstrate that every pound spent delivers genuine climate and nature outcomes. That means being more transparent, focusing on evidence, targeting its limited ODA climate finance where it's needed the most and ensuring it strengthens rather than undermines broader development objectives. The committee's report should serve as a reminder that climate finance should not be treated as an optional extra to ODA, that it should not be reprioritised or repurposed in the face of competing priorities, but rather it should be treated as an essential part of how the UK meets its global responsibilities under the Paris Agreement and meaningfully contributes to tackling the defining challenge of our times.

05:24:37 - 05:24:38

Monica Harding.

05:24:38 - 05:25:34

Monica Harding

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable lady and chair of the select committee gave a very powerful speech. Yesterday she pointed out Nepal was hit by another flood after 1,400 people were killed by those earlier in the year. These extreme weather events are having a huge impact on biodiversity and I would urge every member to read the government's national security assessment of global biodiversity loss and ecosystem collapse and the threat to our own national security here. And those challenges can only be met if public money is available and that means a return to ODA at 0.7%.

So will the minister layout how that will be, with the chair of the select committee layout, does she think that's important and how does public funding marry with the private investment that she talks of?

05:25:34 - 05:25:59

Sarah Champion

I thank my honourable friend and committee member and she well knows that when we go and visit some of these places, farmers haven't been able to plant crops for years. And these are also in areas where when we go into our own supermarkets, we're expecting the food to come from. So unless we recognise this as an international catastrophe that we're all interconnected with, we will never get to the resolution that we need.

05:25:59 - 05:26:01

Speaker 265

Sam Rushworth.

05:26:01 - 05:26:38

Sam Rushworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's true and we know that those bearing the brunt of climate disasters are those the least responsible for causing them. And the reality is that the cuts that are being implemented not just by this government but all governments risk global food security, increased poverty, increased conflict and refugee and migration flows. I've previously called for the government to properly assess the impact of this and to publish it so that we as British taxpayers can understand what those impacts are going to be. Would she join me in that call?

05:26:38 - 05:26:59

Sarah Champion

I thank my honourable friend and committee member and he has consistently made this argument. The government needs to give us the transparency so that we can see what works, what doesn't work and then replicate that on a global scale. Without that clear information presented to this House, it becomes impossible to see the impact that we're having.

05:26:59 - 05:27:01

Speaker 263

Jim Shannon.

05:27:01 - 05:27:54

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. First of all, can I thank the chair of the committee for her contribution today and indeed for all the committee for what they've done. I don't care what anybody says, none of us can ignore the fact that the ice caps are melting, that the rainforests are being decimated, that bird life and animal life across the world is being reduced quite dramatically and fires, floods and pestilence, to use a biblical term, seems to be an everyday occurrence.

But the honourable lady mentioned in particular, and I wish to focus and ask her a question on that, is for women and girls. I think it's really important that they have the chance to thrive, they have the chance to be educated, they have the chance to have the health that they should have, and then also to have the opportunity to find a job. What more can this government and our government do to ensure that women and girls across the world have a chance to thrive?

05:27:54 - 05:28:22

Sarah Champion

So, Chairman, my honourable friend makes a powerful point and it's one I've heard him for decades make to try and support women and girls to flourish wherever they find themselves. And what I would say is that the most straightforward thing that the government could do right now is publish the data about who the money goes to and how it impacts positively on their lives. It's something the committee has been calling for for as long as I've chaired it, and I think it's something the government really needs to act on.

05:28:22 - 05:28:34

Speaker 259

Can I thank both select committee chairs for their statements this evening. That brings us to the backbench business debate on Baby Loss Awareness Week. Andy McDonald to move.

05:28:34 - 05:29:40

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a privilege to open this debate again during Baby Loss Awareness Week. And I want to start by recognising the bereaved parents participating in the debate today, whether by watching at home, having shared your story with your MP, or even by speaking in this chamber today. To lose your child is one of the most painful things a parent can experience. I know today will bring back difficult and deeply upsetting memories for many, but we're here today in our children's memory.

Since our debate last October, the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Baby Loss has heard from countless families, charities and support groups. They've trusted us with heartbreaking stories of babies who died, of concerns that were dismissed, of parents left without answers, and of families having to fight the very systems that should have supported them. We've also heard from dedicated healthcare professionals, representative of tens of thousands across the country working incredibly hard to deliver great care despite the system, not because of it. Last year I shared my experience of losing my daughter, Mallory. This year I've been spurred on by the stories others have entrusted with us.

05:29:40 - 05:29:59

Speaker 268

Each is different, but the message running through them is the same. We know more than enough about the failures and the problems. We know what good should look like. Families and professionals now need us to urgently deliver change. To everyone who has spoken at the APPG, often at great personal cost, I say thank you.

05:29:59 - 05:30:23

Speaker 267

Your testimony must not simply become part of another report. It must shape what happens next. When I opened last year's debate, I focused on the national investigation into maternity and neonatal services. Since then, Baroness Amos has published her findings and a national maternity and neonatal taskforce has begun developing a national action plan. That is progress, but it is not yet delivery.

05:30:23 - 05:31:33

Andy McDonald

Time and time again, families have seen inquiries established, reports published, recommendations accepted, only for the same failures to reoccur again and again. We must break this cycle and make this national action plan a watershed moment. The test will not be the quality of the plan when it's published, it'll be whether care improves, whether families are listened to, whether staff are supported to provide care, and ultimately whether fewer babies die. Today I want to focus on some key areas in which action is urgently needed. And first, to underpin the action plan, we need new national targets to reduce baby deaths and eliminate inequalities.

Black and Asian babies continue to experience substantially higher rates of stillbirth and neonatal death, while babies born to the most deprived communities also face worse outcomes. We do not need another decade of evidence to know this demands action. The previous national maternity safety ambitions expired last year and have not yet been replaced. So Sands and Tommy's joint policy unit are calling for new targets to take us to 2035. These targets must be ambitious, transparent and measurable.

05:31:31 - 05:31:32

Will my honourable friend give way?

05:31:33 - 05:31:33

Jim Dickson

Can I thank my honourable friend for giving way and for the eloquent, moving speech he's making with lots of practical proposals as well. On the subject of maternity service failures, in April 2021 my constituents Phoebe and Jim Brooks tragically lost their much-wanted and loved son Jasper at Darent Valley Hospital a few hours after he was born. The coroner's report found there'd been serious failures in his care including a lack of resuscitation expertise on hand during the birth and premature withdrawal of neonatal care from Jasper. The family were sent to a bereavement room while Jasper was still alive. Does my honourable friend agree with me that tragedies such as this indicate strongly that we need as a matter of urgency to implement the recommendations of the Amos review and then look at the need for a full statutory public inquiry into UK maternity safety?

The policy unit's recommendations include national targets for stillbirth, neonatal mortality and preterm birth, alongside an explicit commitment to eliminating the inequalities in these outcomes based on ethnicity and deprivation.

05:32:31 - 05:32:58

Andy McDonald

I thank my honourable friend and the tragic case he describes is unfortunately just too common and reflected in so many accounts I've heard from families in our all-party group. And yet again it just adds to that weight of evidence that says we need that urgent and immediate action. We cannot wait, we cannot let those families down. I will.

05:32:58 - 05:33:38

Peter Swallow

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. He has brought forward an incredibly important debate tonight that will allow many such stories as we've just heard be shared. I wanted to just share the story of my constituents whose son Jesse died in their arms just six days after he was born. And his parents are now bravely campaigning for placental cord insertion to be routinely assessed as part of a 20-week scan to reduce preventable stillbirths and neonatal deaths. I wonder whether he'll take this opportunity to pay tribute as I do to Jesse's parents' bravery in launching this campaign.

05:33:38 - 05:34:43

Andy McDonald

I pay tribute to those parents and the tribute to so many parents that have actually launched campaigns in their children's names. I would hope and believe that particular measure will be considered alongside many other methods, many other actions that could prevent the tragedies that we see all too often. So I thank him for bringing that to our attention. So to go back to national maternity targets, these are vital because without these clear targets it's harder to maintain focus, measure progress or hold the system to account. The government should adopt this call, progress must be published regularly and the data must show not only the national picture but which communities are being failed and where.

We must understand where babies are dying, which families are experiencing the poorest outcomes, where learning is taking place and ultimately where changes in policy are actually making a difference. And this must include better data on miscarriage. At present we do not routinely collect the information needed to understand fully how many families experience miscarriage, how those experiences differ between communities and whether outcomes are improving. I will.

05:34:43 - 05:35:25

Helen Maguire

I thank the honourable member for giving way. As he has rightly alluded to, the system is currently failing so many mothers, babies and families and often there's a lack of care, support and compassion. A constituent of mine, Rachel, recently last year suffered two devastating miscarriages. And she mentioned the insensitivity towards her from both the doctor who asked why are you crying, the midwife who told her to calm down and have a glass of wine. So does the honourable member agree with me that things like guarantees for bereavement and perinatal mental health specialists in every maternity service are really important and would he agree that that's something that perhaps we could strive for?

05:35:25 - 05:37:31

Andy McDonald

I thank her and actually I agree wholeheartedly and as she will see later in my speech I'll be focusing on that to a significant extent.

So on miscarriage data Scotland's expecting to begin routine data collection on miscarriage from this year and England should match that ambition. And linked to this we also need to address anomalies in how stillbirth is defined and recorded. But fundamentally targets and data however are only meaningful if someone is responsible for monitoring progress and challenging failure. That brings to my second point. The maternity and neonatal commissioner as recommended by Baroness Amos must be independent empowered and properly resourced.

The commissioner could provide a strong national voice for women babies and families monitoring whether recommendations are implemented holding the system to account and ultimately helping to rebuild trust. The commissioner should report regularly to Parliament on progress against national targets identify where improvement has stalled and require public bodies to explain what corrective action they will take. And this must include being able to challenge the regulators. Long-term issues with the CQC NMC and GMC are well recognized but effective trusted and fit-for-purpose regulators are a crucial element of any maternity safety system and a maternity commissioner should be able to demand better of them. But the commissioner's potential will be realized only if they can act independently of the system being scrutinized.

The system cannot be allowed to mark its own homework. The commissioner should have a statutory basis independent publication rights the power to obtain information and make formal recommendations and a duty to monitor implementation. The office will also need protected funding and a dedicated team. The government must explain how the commissioner will work alongside the task force and other bodies and what powers the office will possess and how its independence will be protected. And this will be particularly important if the role is to be based within the Department of Health.

If this is the case the government should present a clear rationale as to why this is the best option and provide specific reassurances around independence. Ultimately families will judge the maternity commissioner role by whether it can ask difficult questions publish uncomfortable findings and demand proof that change has occurred.

05:37:31 - 05:38:01

Jim Shannon

I was hoping that perhaps maybe the honorable gentleman might have mentioned when there is a tragedy there is a loss whenever there's a heartbreaking whenever a family grieve the child that they have lost and that really hurts. Does he feel does the honorable gentleman feel and does government feel ultimately that there should be some access to a faith person of faith perhaps a chaplain perhaps a man or a woman of the cloth that could come forward and give some succor and support whenever they need it.

05:38:01 - 05:38:22

Andy McDonald

I thank the honorable gentleman and I think this kind of connects into the issue of individualized care because when it comes to bereavement support it's the care and support that works for that individual. And what I'll talk later about personalized care plans and personalized support plans during bereavement but it's reflective of what the individual needs not what the system says someone needs.

05:38:22 - 05:38:55

Peter Richard Prinsley

The honorable member's making a very powerful speech. I wonder whether he'd agree with me that charitable organizations such as Sands. We have Suffolk Sands in my constituency. Today the red pillar boxes throughout Bury St Edmunds are covered in crocheted hats which have come from Sands and the peer group support that these organizations are able to make available is absolutely crucial to support families who have lost babies. There can be few families in the land not affected by this.

05:38:55 - 05:39:50

Andy McDonald

I'll join my honorable friend in paying tribute to Sands indeed we're joined by staff from Sands in the gallery today but also so many other charities like Tommy's and others that are absolutely vital. And it is in some ways it is a fact that so many parents rely on voluntary services and voluntary support to get through what is the most difficult times in their lives. Those charities are indispensable but at the same time they're often plugging gaps that exist within the system that maybe should be providing that support. So the third point I wanted to focus on was that question about personalized family-centered care. Every pregnancy and every family is different.

Good care depends upon seeing the person in front of you listening carefully and understanding the history circumstances concerns and individual risks.

Too many families have been described as being dismissed or treated as a category rather than as a person. A safe service cannot be one in which parents are not heard, nor can it be called safe if assumptions about ethnicity or background influence the care that somebody receives.

05:39:50 - 05:40:41

Tessa Munt

I will. Thank the honorable gentleman very much indeed. I'm here to really represent the views of my constituents, John and Holly Osman. And Holly and John lost two babies and they they had a catastrophic history. But that's driven Holly to work in this area.

And she's asked me to point out that the NHS maternity survey says that 18% of parents reported that their concerns during labor and birth were not taken seriously. He's already referred to Sands and Tommy's. I just wondered whether he'd got some ideas about whether in fact it would be right really for staff to ensure that parents are their concerns are listened to and are acted upon. Would he agree?

05:40:41 - 05:42:03

Andy McDonald

I thank the honorable lady and and I thank John and Holly for raising that that question. And and absolute of course I would fundamentally agree that that listening to parents, listening to families, listening to to to mothers is is is just so fundamental and crucial to a good service. To me it's the thing that defines a good service, that personalization and individualization of care. And and building on that, your families must be genuinely involved in decisions. Information must be clear and accessible.

Risks must be assessed individually. When a mother or parent says that something is wrong, that concern must be taken seriously. The national action plan should establish what every family is entitled to expect through the maternity and neonatal pathway. That is physical and psychological safety, dignity, informed choice and compassionate care and communication. And in designing this change we should recognize that there are midwives, doctors, nurses, support workers and bereavement specialists throughout the country delivering extraordinary care every day, often under immense pressure.

We must learn from this and build on it. To give just one local example, we have the Women Lancashire Women and Newborn Centre in Burnley. Speaking with staff and patients there, we can see what good practice looks like. It's a high-quality environment with a triage unit to catch early issues. There's a mutual respect amongst staff, personalized care for patients.

05:42:03 - 05:43:00

Speaker 267

They take time to listen and to provide compassionate bereavement support where needed. This same high standard of care is replicated in many units throughout the country. So reform must not simply identify what has gone wrong. We must recognize, celebrate and share what actually works. We must have structures that identify best practice and effectively propagate this throughout maternity services.

And this brings me to my fourth point. Supporting and empowering staff must be central to reform. Throughout the APPG's work, we've heard from healthcare professionals who care deeply about families and take great pride in their work. But goodwill cannot compensate for a lack of time, training, capacity or appropriate facilities. Safe care requires the right staff with the right mix of skills, the right resources and the facilities to deliver it.

Staff need time to listen properly to families, undertake training, reflect on difficult cases and learn from colleagues.

05:43:00 - 05:43:34

Speaker 273

I will. I very much thank my honorable friend for leading this debate so ably. One of the things that we heard at the APPG patient safety is the need for staff to feel confident to speak out if they do see things going wrong and that importance of a safe culture. And yet in the NHS staff survey, four in ten midwives, only four in ten, say that their organization would address concerns if they were raised. Does my honorable friend agree that we need to do more to build a safe staff culture within the NHS and within maternity units?

05:43:34 - 05:45:42

Andy McDonald

I I totally agree. I'm so glad she's raised it because she has wonderfully set up the next passage of my of my speech. Exactly, staff must be able to raise concerns without fear of damaging their careers. The figure I believe in the NHS staff survey is 43.5% of midwifery staff feel confident that their concerns will be addressed.

Staff are often first to recognize when a system is becoming unsafe. If they believe speaking up will make no difference, an opportunity to prevent harm may be lost. Improving culture must therefore mean more than asking staff to attend another program or complete another exercise. It must mean creating an environment with time to listen and time to care. Speaking up should be welcomed, concerns taken seriously, and those who raise them protected.

Boards and senior leaders must hear what staff are telling them. They must be able to trace concerns from the ward to the boardroom, demonstrate what action was taken, and report back to those who spoke up. Whistleblowers must be protected from retaliation and isolation. No healthcare professional should be forced to choose between remaining silent about unsafe care and risking their livelihood by raising it. If staff are trusted, supported, and heard, they are far better placed to listen to families in turn.

Fundamentally, we should empower staff to provide the standard of care they entered the NHS to deliver. And finally, we must deliver compassionate and equitable bereavement care. Our daughter Mallory died at five days old. Nothing could have been done to prevent that and we received exceptional care throughout our time in hospital. We also received good emotional support in the immediate aftermath from hospital staff.

But trauma can take time to kick in. The impact of losing a child does not end after a week or a month or a year. They stay with us. My wife Vanessa suffered depression and PTSD in the years following Mallory's death. For 11 years now, she's had consistent difficulties accessing specialist and sustained mental health support.

Instead, she's been bounced between short-term interventions and generalists, often reliant on limited voluntary services. At no point was she able to get support from a mental health professional who actually specialized in birth trauma. She was never able to return to her role as a senior health visitor. She's now had her NHS career terminated on ill-health grounds and she's back on another waiting list for therapy. And Vanessa's experience is far from unique.

Time and time again, I've heard from mothers and fathers as to how the system was incapable of responding to their individual circumstance and the timing and depth of trauma.

05:45:42 - 05:46:09

Monica Harding

I will. I thank the honorable member for giving way. I want to refer to a case in my constituency who came into my surgery, but I've heard it again that individuals or mothers that suffer from bipolar, the actual birth process is very, very triggering and there is very rarely any support available at that point. It's a critical point in their life. And what does the honorable member think about what needs to be provided for those patients?

05:46:09 - 05:46:24

Andy McDonald

I thank the honorable lady and I'll come on to the full sort of package of support I think is needed. But again, that's just indicative of how the care is not available when people need it most. And we hear that time and time again.

05:46:24 - 05:46:53

Saqib Bhatti

I will. I thank him for giving way. He's incredibly generous. I think he's giving an excellent speech. When there is a gap as he said in terms of therapy care and therapeutic care, there are charities like Lily Mae Foundation in my constituency who do fill that gap.

And I know we talked about Sands and Tommy's etcetera, but there's lots of charities out there who do need that support to make sure they are, as they do that important work. Does he agree that we should consider a bit more support for them as well?

05:46:53 - 05:49:51

Andy McDonald

Support of charities is vital in this. They do so much incredible and brilliant work and of course I'd encourage any support that could be given. And I will now attempt to move towards wrapping up and not take any more interventions if that's okay. The eye has been caught. So the care received after losing a baby stays with the family forever.

Kindness, dignity, and privacy cannot remove grief, but poor and absent care after loss will deepen trauma and cause long-term harm. And to be clear, good bereavement support must include fathers.

Only 29% of services offered basic assessments to fathers in 2024. That is simply not good enough. Services must recognize what fathers that fathers and partners will also grieve. We need to do better and we can. We know what needs to be done.

The National Bereavement Care Pathway already exists and covers miscarriage, termination of pregnancy for fetal anomaly, stillbirth, neonatal death, sudden unexpected death in infancy. Every NHS trust in England has voluntarily adopted it. But implementation remains inconsistent because services have not always received the resources and prioritization needed to deliver it. We must address this and require that all bereavement pathways are considered within NHS planning and resourcing. Effective bereavement support should be integral to all maternity services with identified bereavement leads.

All staff who may care for bereaved families should have access to appropriate bereavement training during working hours and they must receive the support themselves they need in dealing with the losses that they have seen. When losses occur, every family should have a private space to spend time with their baby, make memories and begin the process of what has happened. Specialist bereavement support services should be there to support them through personalized support plans and in the longer term, they need to see specialist mental health support available to respond as trauma manifests, even if this is years later. So Madam Deputy Speaker, to sum up, the question is no longer whether maternity and neonatal services require fundamental change. Report after report has answered that.

The question is whether we have the determination to deliver it. We need targets to reduce baby deaths and eliminate inequalities by 2035, supported by good data to show policy is working. We need a commissioner with the independence and authority to hold the system to account. We need care that sees and listens to every family as individuals. We need to give staff the training, time, capacity and protection they need to provide safe care and speak up when someone is wrong, something is wrong.

And when a baby dies, we need compassionate, high-quality bereavement care for every family. Last year I said we had the opportunity and the obligation to act. That obligation is now greater because the actions we must take have been laid before us. Families have heard promises before. They've watched recommendations accepted and have been assured that lessons would be learned, only to see another family experience the same failures.

We owe them something different now, not another expression of good intent, but evidence that care is changing and lives are being saved. Bereaved families have given us their testimony, their time and their trust. They should not be asked to return in another year or another decade to tell us the same failures continue. We cannot bring back the babies who have died, but we can honor their short lives through what we do next. Thank you.

05:49:51 - 05:50:06

Speaker 259

The question is as on the order paper. Members will know that there is protected time, so we have until 11:02 this evening, but it would be very helpful if members could keep their remarks to maybe seven or eight minutes. Sir Jeremy Hunt.

05:50:06 - 05:52:58

Jeremy Hunt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to thank the honorable member for Rossendale and Darwen for that excellent opening speech. And I want to thank him and the honorable member for Sherwood Forest for co-sponsoring this debate with me. But most of all, I want to thank the parents who've lost children that took me on a journey on this issue when I was Health Secretary. I'm thinking of James Titcombe, who lost his son Joshua at Morecambe Bay, of Carl Hendrickson, who lost his wife Nitya and his son Chester at Morecambe Bay, of Richard Stanton and Rhiannon Davies, who lost their daughter Kate at Shrewsbury and Telford, of Derek Richford, who lost his grandson Harry at East Kent.

And them and many, many others are watching this debate tonight. And they can see that the Health Secretary is here. And I want to thank her for being here for this backbench debate. That means an awful lot and I know that she really does care about this issue. And I want to start my brief comments by recognizing there has been some progress made.

Since I first stood at that dispatch box in 2014 with the Morecambe Bay inquiry, which was the first of many maternity safety inquiries, the neonatal death rate has fallen by 21%, which is about 700 fewer deaths a year.

But it's not good enough. And the fall in death rates plateaued in 2020 and hasn't been getting much better since then, but since then we've had a very worrying rise in maternal deaths. And the 2025 target that I set back in 2017 to halve neonatal deaths was missed. And I think there are really three problems that are behind our lack of progress. Firstly, and this is something for which I am partially responsible, there are just too many recommendations.

I mean, Baroness Amos earlier this year counted 748 maternity safety recommendations, mainly since 2015. The NHS is a world champion at doing reports into maternity safety, but sadly not a world champion at implementing the recommendations made. And I think it's a really encouraging thing that the Health Secretary says she's going to have a recommendations hub. But could I ask that she gives it real teeth, so that there is a timescale within which the NHS will decide whether it's going to adopt a recommendation? And if it is going to adopt it, there is a person responsible within the vast labyrinth that is the NHS for implementing it, and a timescale so that we and our constituents all know that something really is going to happen.

05:52:58 - 05:53:00

Speaker 276

I'm happy to give way to my honourable friend.

05:53:00 - 05:53:24

Jim Shannon

I thank the honourable gentleman, and indeed I know the honourable gentleman will be very much aware of the research that suggests that giving women access to specialised care after their first miscarriage could help prevent baby loss. Current specialist care is only offered after three miscarriages. It's estimated that supporting the early intervention could prevent around 10,000 baby losses per year. There's one thing that could be done right now.

05:53:24 - 05:54:17

Jeremy Hunt

Well, I absolutely agree with the honourable gentleman. And it actually links very closely to the second of my three reasons, which is that we have still not, after all this time, implemented proper continuity of care, which should mean that every mother from the moment that she is told she is pregnant is assigned one team of doctors and midwives to be with her throughout pregnancy, throughout birth, and even after birth. Because clinical teams who know their patients are much more likely to identify risk when it happens and to avoid tragedies happening. And it is that lack of continuity of care that sits behind the feeling that we were hearing about just in the speech before mine, of which parents say time after time they feel forgotten in the system. Yes, I give way to my honourable friend.

05:54:17 - 05:55:05

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

I thank my right honourable friend for giving way. And I think there's a real issue in this that quite often we hear that when women have high-risk pregnancies, don't worry, contingency of care is there. But even in my own experience where I had placenta accreta last year, which is one of two conditions that still kills women in birth, I remember turning up for scans knowing, having been told there was an 11% chance that I might die on the day I gave birth, turning up for scans at the high-risk team and them saying, so it's just a normal pregnancy, right? Everything's going really great, like we'll just get this done really quickly, find out how things are. And the lack of care taken with women who are carrying everything that matters in that time.

And so I just want to press the point because I think so many people say, but don't worry, high risk is fine, it's dealt with really well, it's only standard pregnancies, that actually we still have a comprehensive issue across all of it.

05:55:05 - 05:57:25

Jeremy Hunt

Well, I thank my honourable friend for that very powerful personal experience. And I actually am concerned about this idea of women being moved from sort of no team to a high-risk team, because I don't think you can always know in advance if someone is high risk.

It is constantly knowing every woman's situation that actually enables a team to understand whether she is deteriorating and whether therefore she's in need of specialist help. But the third reason why I think we still have this problem after all this time is the one I want to really focus on today, and that is the ideological obsession that still exists in some parts of the NHS with so-called natural or normal birth. And this is something which leads to the promotion of vaginal birth over and above C-sections in a way that means that all too often interventions come too late, escalations happen too late, and mothers and babies die. And I don't ask the House to take my word for it, but I would just like to mention in some of those reports comments on this issue. So Bill Kirkup, who did the Morecambe Bay report, said that maternity services at Furness General Hospital became strongly influenced by a small number of dominant individuals whose overzealous pursuit of the natural childbirth approach led at times to inappropriate and unsafe care.

Donna Ockenden told the Select Committee about Shrewsbury and Telford, "We've spoken to hundreds of women who said to us they felt pressurized to have a normal birth." "My clinical team said they've seen examples even in situations where a normal birth in their own hospital would be contraindicated of women being pressured, a multi-professional focus on normal birth at pretty much any cost." Again, at the launch of the Nottingham inquiry, Donna Ockenden said there were hundreds of cases where the quest for normal birth continued and the avoidance of intervention persisted. And I will come to the honorable member. And finally in Leeds, where Fiona Winzar-Ram told the Times she was convinced that normal birth ideology played a part in the death of her daughter Aliona.

And I give way to the honorable member.

05:57:25 - 05:58:12

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, honorable member for Dewsbury. And I have to first of all say I am very impressed to see both a former Health Secretary and the present Health Secretary here late in the evening for this debate, which is a sign, I think, of the absolute importance of this. But I wanted to ask the honorable member whether he felt that fundamental to the problem, the third problem that he describes, is the breakdown in relationships between the profession of midwifery and the profession of obstetrics, and that there is in some instances what appears to be a competition between these two crucial professions. And one of the answers to this may be some way of getting these two professions closer together.

05:58:12 - 05:59:03

Jeremy Hunt

Well, I absolutely, I first of all I defer to the honorable gentleman's own clinical experience, but I absolutely agree with him. I think he's put the nail on the head with the issue. And before I come on to my solutions, I just want to say why I think this is still a problem. There are still very senior voices who are promoting normal birth ideology, including a former president of the Royal College of Midwives who told LBC in June, "Doctors have taken over maternity and they're not doing it very well." And it really is time to stop denying the problem and start solving it.

Never again should the promotion of an ideology about a so-called preferable type of birth lead to a mother or baby being put at risk. Will my honorable friend give way again? Yes, I'll give way.

05:59:03 - 05:59:56

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

I wanted to unite together the point that you gentlemen, I am going to draw again on personal experience because it brings home this point. My son reacted badly to being induced and his heart rate stopped. We were rushed to the emergency room, he's got to get him out, got to get him out. Just before they cut, somebody screams, "Stop!" "His heart rate's gone back to normal, he's fine, you don't need a C-section."

And stood at the end of the bed was an obstetrician and a midwife. And the midwife said, "Great, you don't need the C-section anymore, don't do the C-section." And the surgeon said, "Yes she does, she needs to have it now, she needs to have it."

And they said to me, "You need to decide." And they refused to come to agreement between them about what was safer for my baby, and they said that I had to make that decision. This is exactly the problem, and I think my honourable friend is so brave to make this point, because he will come under criticism for saying that there is such a thing, there is no such thing as this obsession with natural birth. A safe birth is the best birth, and I'm thankful to him for his bravery in making these points tonight.

05:59:56 - 06:01:53

Jeremy Hunt

Well, I want to thank my honourable friend for her courage in talking about her personal experience, but that really does say it better than I ever could. And that leads me to conclude with what I think the solutions are. And the first one, it brings together the points made by both honourable members in their interventions, that we need a total overhaul of midwifery education to make it clear that there has to be teamwork around every birth. It is not midwives versus doctors, it is midwives and doctors working together for the safe delivery of every single child. Secondly, we need a shared agreement about what risk is and when escalation is required across both professions, total agreement about when that moment for intervention comes, so that something such as my honourable friend describes never ever happens.

And finally, we need to rehumanise the whole process through which the NHS takes care of pregnant mothers and newly born babies, so that for every mother, from the moment of pregnancy, they are assigned one team of doctors and midwives responsible for that mother and that child right the way through and after their birth, so that no one is ever turned into a number or an episode of care or a type of care, but everyone is a human being and is always treated that way by the NHS. This week, we are here to remember the babies and mothers who should be here and are not here. And we recognise the progress that has been made in their name. But we also have a duty to the families to be humble about the failures as well.

06:01:53 - 06:13:49

Michelle Welsh

Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to thank, start by thanking the Secretary of State for making maternity and neonatal safety a priority, for publicly stating that maternity is the Secretary of State's priority from the offset. Personally, it felt like a relief, especially after the uncertainty, and I wish to personally thank her for that. Baby Loss Awareness Week is a time to remember the babies we have lost, stand alongside bereaved families, and recognise that pregnancy and baby loss can change a life forever. Behind every case discussed in this House is a baby who is loved, a family who imagined a future, a life that will always be part of theirs. And when preparing for this debate, I watched last year's debate again, and what saddened me was how much of what we raised then remains painfully familiar today.

Families still fighting for answers, women still describing concerns that were dismissed, and staff still frightened to speak up. Last year, I said, "Let grief be the engine for change." Today, I want to go further. Families have carried the grief. It is time the system carried the responsibility.

There has been an important change over the past year, baby loss, maternity safety, and neonatal care being discussed openly and treated as priorities of the government. The work of Donna Ockenden, Baroness Amos, and Lady Justice Thirlwall has put devastating failings into sharp focus.

I thank them, their teams, and above all the families whose courage made that work possible. For the last six and a half years I've fought for change, listening to over 1,000 families and organisations. My own experience of miscarriages and birth leaving me with both physical and mental scars. I'm so proud to serve as the government's national maternity and neonatal advisor and contribute to the national taskforce. The taskforce brings together families, clinicians and others with the experience and expertise to shape reform.

Bringing those voices together in this way is a significant step forward and I welcome the determination to work together. I also wish to thank the civil servants working behind the scenes, often to demanding deadlines, to turn that determination into action. But the measure of our success will be what changes for women arriving at hospital frightened, the midwife trying to keep her safe, and the families who sadly leave without their baby. Our goal must be clear: safe care, informed choice and compassionate births, with support that continues when things go wrong. That must be the standard every family can expect.

Madam Deputy Speaker, that includes families experiencing early pregnancy loss. We must never confuse an early loss with a small loss. A woman may have known she was pregnant for only a short time. She may have already imagined a name, a face, a future. She may be grieving privately before she's told anyone she is pregnant.

Whatever her circumstances, she deserves compassion. And we must think about where that care takes place. A woman who has just been told her pregnancy ended should not have to sit beside someone celebrating a reassuring scan. A woman losing her baby should not be placed on a ward where she must listen to other babies crying and families celebrating their arrival. We should not ask people to endure avoidable distress because the service has failed to consider their needs.

We need appropriate private spaces, timely assessment and scans, sensitive explanations and clear information about what happens next. And women need to understand their treatment choices. They need pain relief, follow-up and someone to contact when they are frightened or unsure. Partners need support too. And a woman should never be left feeling that because miscarriage happens relatively often, her own loss somehow matters less.

The care we provide cannot remove that grief, but it can make the difference between being supported through it and being traumatised further. And that brings me to something very simple: time to care. Now, in Nottinghamshire, when someone is struggling, we often say, "Come on, let's have a cuppa." We put the kettle on, we make a brew. But what we really mean is: stop for a moment, take a breath, sit down, I'm here and I'm listening.

In maternity care, time matters. Time to hear a woman say something feels wrong, time to explain a scan result, time to answer a father's question, time to sit with parents after devastating news. A hurried conversation can leave someone frightened and confused. A compassionate conversation can help them understand, feel heard and know what support is available. We cannot ask staff to provide that care while giving them neither the time nor the staffing to do it.

Time to care must be built into the service. That means a properly funded, ring-fenced perinatal workforce plan: enough midwives, obstetricians, neonatal staff, sonographers and bereavement specialists with the training and support they need. It means continuity whenever possible, so that when women are supported by professionals who understand their history, their fears and their circumstances. Compassion must be supported by the way we organise and resource care, and listening must also lead to the right action. We need timely access to the right scans, skilled interpretation of the results and prompt referral when concerns are identified.

Safe, informed choice depends on having that information and the opportunity to discuss it. We must also confront the inequalities in whose concerns are heard. Black, Asian and ethnic minority mothers continue to face an unacceptable disparity in maternal outcomes. Racism, assumptions about pain and failures to listen must be addressed directly. We need services that take women's symptoms seriously, provide appropriate interpretation and examine outcomes honestly.

A national improvement in safety cannot be judged a success while some women remain much less safe than others. Where you live, the colour of your skin or your ability to make yourself heard must never determine whether you receive compassionate safe care. Madam Deputy Speaker, it would be an omission on my part if I did not speak about responsibility and accountability because I know how deeply this hurts in Nottinghamshire. Women were left traumatised. Families described fathers sleeping on windowsills only hours after their precious baby had died because there wasn't even a chair available.

And some of those who held senior responsibility during those years did not engage with Donna Ockenden's review. For families who have revisited the worst moments of their lives to help establish the truth, the refusal hurts. It runs deep. It stings. Families have answered the difficult questions.

They have shared intimate details. They have found the strength to speak when speaking has cost them so much and they deserve answers from those who held responsibility. For far too long we've had a system in which excellent midwives are fighting to speak up. Families must fight for answers and some explanations that they have been given have been clearly untrue. Women have been made to feel that what happened was their fault.

We have to address that. A culture that supports honest learning must protect staff who raise concern and distinguish between human error and reckless or dishonest conduct. It must also ensure that failures of leadership have consequences. Protecting staff who speak the truth and holding people accountable for concealing it are both essential to safer care. And that is why the maternity and neonatal commissioner must have teeth.

The commissioner must have their independence, authority and resources to listen to families and staff, identify patterns, obtain information and challenge failures. There must be clear routes to require a response and escalate concerns when organisations fail to act. Families should not have to wait for another major inquiry before someone in authority listens. But national oversight must be matched by accountability in every trust. Every trust board should be able to say who is responsible for maternity safety, what concerns have been raised, what action has been taken and how progress will be demonstrated.

Improvement plans should have named owners, deadlines and evidence that care has changed and improved.

We also need consistent national data that helps us identify warning signs early, and accountability must reach the ward, the boardroom, and the organisations overseeing them. We therefore must review our regulatory bodies and how they are fulfilling their purpose. The GMC, the NMC, and the CQC have different responsibilities, but all have a role in protecting patients. We need to examine how they respond to concerns, share information, and act when warning signs emerge. We have these three regulators, yet families still need large-scale investigations to establish what happened and secure change.

The question is simple. How could serious concerns at Nottingham University Hospital Trust persist for over 20 years, while bereaved families had to stand up, organise, and fight before meaningful change began? That is a broken system. A system that leaves grieving parents to expose its failures is unfit for purpose. And when it forces those parents to fight for the truth while carrying the loss of their baby, it is cruel.

And we should call that cruelty out. We should reject it, and we should change it. Bereaved parents should never have to become the safety net for a system that failed their children. Now I know there are exceptional midwives and obstetricians working every day across this country. They listen, they care, they save lives, and many have themselves fought to raise concerns.

They deserve a system too that supports them, protects them when they speak up, and acts on what they say. It is for those staff, for the future of our services, and above all, the babies, mothers, and families that we must make change happen. And I welcome the Health Bill's proposal to extend the time limit for bringing relevant prosecutions from three years to five, but we must go further. Families facing bereavement may spend months simply trying to survive. Understanding a complex regulatory system should not fall entirely on them.

They need clear information about where to raise concerns, what each organisation can do, and how to access support.

06:13:49 - 06:14:32

Anna Dixon

I thank my honourable friend for giving way and for her amazing work on this issue over many years campaigning for families who've been harmed in her area. Families often face long and lonely legal battles after the grieving and damage that's been done during their child's care. Clinicians and organisations can often become defensive and risk-averse, particularly in an environment. Does she agree with me that as part of these changes that she's calling for, we also need to look at NHS Resolution, the clinical negligence scheme, and stop making it a fight for parents to get answers to the questions that they have?

06:14:32 - 06:14:45

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Order. This is a very powerful debate, but it is limited to three hours, and I won't be able to get all the members in if speeches are long, but I appreciate how sensitive it is. Michelle Welsh.

06:14:45 - 06:17:57

Michelle Welsh

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I do agree. Bereavement care also needs proper scrutiny. A poster on a wall cannot demonstrate that a family is receiving passionate care. Families need appropriate spaces, trained staff, sensitive communication, and support after they leave hospital.

Where families wish, equipment such as cuddle cots can allow precious times with their baby. Parents should be supported to make their own choices about holding their baby, creating memories, and saying goodbye. Nobody should be rushed, nobody should be made to feel there is a correct way to grieve. The quality of that care should never depend on which hospital door a family walks through.

I also want to raise the no breath required campaign. In England and Wales, coroners generally cannot investigate a stillbirth. Their jurisdiction depends on whether a baby was born showing signs of life. That distinction can leave families in very similar circumstances with different routes to independent scrutiny. The need for answers does not disappear because a baby was stillborn.

I believe we should give coroners the power to investigate stillbirths with appropriate safeguards, expertise, and resources. We have seen the harm caused when inadequate reviews fail to identify what went wrong or prevent it happening again. An extension of coroners' powers must sit within wider reform. It needs sufficient capacity, specialist understanding, and compassionate support for families. We must also recognize that some losses occur despite good care.

Every family deserves an honest explanation, support, and the opportunity to ask questions, and that support must continue beyond discharge. Grief does not end when a hospital episode closes. It follows people home, into work, into relationships, and sometimes into subsequent pregnancy. Families need access to bereavement and mental health support for as long as they need it. They should not have to prove that they are struggling badly enough to deserve help.

Madam Deputy Speaker, bereaved and harmed families have already given us so much. Their testimony has exposed failures. Their persistence has driven reviews. Their determination has brought us to this point. They should never have needed to become campaigners to make the system listen.

As the government and the task force move forward, their voices must remain central and our promises must be tested against their experience. We need time to care, power to act, and responsibility to answer. Last year I said, let grief be the engine of change. This year we must show families where that change is happening. Families have carried the grief.

It is time the system carried the responsibility. Baby Winter, baby Harriet, baby Sebastian, baby Cooper, baby Teddy, baby Quinn, baby Aubrey, baby Grace, baby Poppy, baby Dexter, baby Luna, and baby Luna Ladybird. We must remember every baby, support every family, and do everything in our power to prevent avoidable loss. Thank you.

06:17:57 - 06:23:15

Alison Bennett

We now on a speaking limit of seven minutes, Alison Bennett.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank the honorable members for Rossendale and Darwen and Sherwood Forest and the right honorable member for Godalming and Ash for their advocacy for better maternity care and for their opening speeches this evening. I want to begin by talking about an extraordinary woman, my constituent Jane Plumb from Haywards Heath, and her son Oliver, and the work that they've done along with their colleagues running a charity called Group B Strep Support. They visited Parliament in the summer and some honorable members came along to learn more about their campaign calling for all expectant mothers to be offered GBS-specific tests late in pregnancy as part of their antenatal care. If that test was offered, that would mean that more babies could be protected from a life-threatening infection.

I spent some time this afternoon looking at the Group B Strep Support website and I found the history of the charity. I knew that Jane set up the charity after her baby Theo died from the infection, and I know that she had been working on it for decades since then. The first time I saw a photograph of her in Parliament was outside this building with David Cameron. And then a few years later she met my predecessor Sir Nicholas Soames and Theresa May, again campaigning. It gives you a sense of the decades that she's put in to trying to fight for babies in future not to have the same outcome that baby Theo had.

The second set of constituents I want to reflect on are the families in Mid Sussex who are part of the Truth for our Babies campaign.

Since last year's debate to mark Baby Loss Awareness Week, progress has been made for the families in Sussex who lost their babies, whose babies were harmed, or for the mums who were harmed themselves. Last October in this debate, I called for the then Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, the right hon. Member for Ilford North, to listen to the calls from those families in the Truth for our Babies campaign. Their ask was quite clear. They wanted there to be an independent review into maternity services at the University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust and, critically, they wanted Donna Ockenden to lead that review. It was not until April, six months later, that their requests were met.

In the intervening months, the meetings that those families convened with the right hon. Member for Ilford North were raw, emotional, and stark. They are meetings I will not forget. I wish that the bereaved parents from Truth for our Babies had not been put in the position where they felt that they had no choice but to lay out their babies' stories again and again in order to be heard. As so many hon. Members can attest, the distress, pain, and exhaustion felt by parents and families tragically stretches on beyond the loss of the baby. It is right and proper that these families receive reviews to better understand what went wrong and to stop things going wrong in the future.

I am of course glad the Sussex maternity review is now underway. But, when I receive extremely concerning correspondence from my constituents, such as that which I will briefly quote below, I have serious doubts about the way in which reviews are being conducted. My constituent tells me, and I quote, that there is currently no funding available to cover families' travel expenses to review meetings and that no remuneration arrangements are in place for our time, expertise, and emotional labour. My constituent rightly notes that this is a particularly concerning factor given the review's commitment to being inclusive and non-discriminatory. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is despite the fact that NIHR guidance is clear about the importance of properly resourcing public involvement.

It recommends payment for public contributors' time, skills, and expertise, alongside reimbursement of reasonable expenses such as travel. The guidance recognises that financial barriers can prevent people from participating and that appropriate payment and expenses are important to ensuring that involvement is accessible and inclusive. If families who cannot afford the cost of travel or to take time away from work or caring responsibilities, and if they repeatedly revisit traumatic experiences without appropriate recognition and support, the evidence gathered will inevitably be incomplete and potentially fuel the inequalities already in place. I hope Department of Health and Social Care's officials and the Secretary of State will reflect on this. I'd be very happy to engage with them further as a matter of urgency.

And I'd also like to ask the Secretary of State whether she will meet Group B Strep Support's calls for screening to be put in place for all expectant women. Thank you.

06:23:15 - 06:26:54

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Every single baby loss is a tragedy of almost incomprehensible magnitude.

But I welcome the Amos report, commissioned by this government, which I believe will prove to be a watershed moment for those families. The report highlights that Black, Asian and economically deprived families face significantly higher risks of death and complications in maternity and neonatal care. Babies of Black and Asian ethnicity face higher rates of dying shortly after birth compared to white babies, and Black mothers face up to 40% higher risk of miscarriage than white mothers. For many of my constituents in Ealing Southall, which is one of the most ethnically diverse in the country, this brings an added level of risk when using maternity services. I recently met with a family from Southall who lost their newborn shortly after birth.

Mum and dad did not have good English, so their 13-year-old daughter had to translate for her parents and explain to them that they were being asked to agree to turn their new baby's life support machine off. This 13-year-old girl then ended up standing in front of a judge arguing on behalf of her family. She showed me the heartbreaking letter the judge sent her explaining the decision to end life support, a decision which she and her parents still cannot accept or even understand. We rightly focus on the parents when a child dies, but brothers and sisters are too often overlooked when it comes to support after a family bereavement. My 13-year-old constituent felt that some of the medical professionals struggled to communicate with her about what had happened to her newborn baby sister.

She told me she felt there wasn't enough help available for her, both as a child experiencing the loss of a sibling and as a child carrying all of the burden of communicating with officialdom on behalf of her family. No 13-year-old child should have to go through what my constituent has, so I welcome the government's commitment to more compassionate and individualized care for every bereaved family. But I hope the Secretary of State will work to ensure that in the design of this, there are measures in place to support families where English is a second or even third language, including support for siblings who act as the family translator. Madam Deputy Speaker, every woman should feel safe and looked after in the NHS, but it is important that all women are listened to, including Black and Asian women. I welcome the new task and finish group on miscarriage and baby loss care, but I urge it to look closely at how Black and Asian women often face indeed double jeopardy when accessing maternity and neonatal services, and to find ways of removing this inequality once and for all.

Thank you.

06:26:54 - 06:26:55

Alicia Kearns.

06:26:55 - 06:28:28

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the honorable members who secured this debate and all the families who have in their darkest moments raised their voices so that we may support them and hopefully prevent future tragedy. I welcome that the Health Secretary has promised to publish a national action plan, and so I want to focus on a few issues that I hope are reflected in it. The first follows on my right honorable friend on this question of a normal birth and how we must stop pushing towards it. It is the one time when my friends tell me they're pregnant that I say to them, you need to have the confidence to challenge the NHS. We are taught to say thank you, of course, whatever you say.

It is the one time in your life when you say why, stop, what are the other options, I want a different opinion, I need some time.

And we must teach women to listen to their bodies and be able to trust that. And we cannot say there is not an obsession with more births, because I remember with my second, being forced by the hospital to go onto a one-hour online course so they could convince me to have a vaginal birth, having had to have an emergency C-section. And I remember at the end of the course they said to all of us on it, so which of you are now, you know, ready to accept the fact that you should go for a vaginal birth? And all the women said yes, apart from me. And they said, well why won't you say yes?

And I said, well on slide whatever it was, twenty-something, you said that I was X percent safer, me and my baby, to have a second C-section, so that's what I want. They went, oh no, no, no, it does say that, but let's go for a natural birth, you can do it. This is an obsession and we have to challenge it. I will happily give way.

06:28:28 - 06:29:01

Jonathan Luke Charters

I thank her for giving way. It just reminded me of our family's own experience, traumatic first birth, second birth, it was an elective C-section that was the only game in town, that's for sure. And we said this to the registrar, and I'll never forget it, do you give the clinical risks to women of a vaginal birth, the same clinical risks that you've talked to us for half an hour about? Do you give the same data to give women and families informed choice? The registrar said no one's asked me that in my entire career.

06:29:01 - 06:34:20

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

So that's the point she's exactly making, and I thank her for that.

Not at all, I'm afraid I will be drawing on a lot of personal experiences, though I scrapped at least nine further examples of things, but absolutely that. The next thing I want to impress on the Health Secretary is my view that CPR should be mandatory before the discharge of babies, particularly if they've been in NICU. Now most pregnancies we all study what to do, you know, if your baby needs CPR, but the reality is we all know that even if you've had one before, the difference between the pregnancy course and once you've held that baby in your arms is so different. And I want to praise Addenbrooke's Hospital because they forced my husband to do a CPR course before our discharge because my daughter had had to go into NICU for a brief period. And when we'd come home, only about two weeks after she'd given birth when she'd finally reached her due date, she stopped breathing out of nowhere.

We were sat in bed and she just stopped breathing and I remember screaming for my husband and the poor person on the phone on 999, I'm normally quite good in an emergency and I was not and I lost the plot and I was screaming down the phone at this person on 999, my baby's dying, my baby's dying, you have to get here, you have to save her. But because my husband had done that CPR course, he was able to take this tiny, tiny baby and save her life because it took them too long to get an ambulance to us. Her temperature had fallen below 34 degrees by the time the ambulance had got there. He saved her life at a time that I could not do it, I was not in a place where I could save my baby. And yet we let people go home from hospital without knowing what it is to hold a baby and then be re-taught what CPR is.

And I genuinely believe that it would save so many lives if we did what Addenbrooke's did and force people to spend 20 minutes doing a CPR course before they go home. The next issue I want to touch on is maternal deaths because as my right honourable friend said, they are rising. The leading direct cause of maternal death in this country is blood clots. But if you ask any friend who is pregnant or who has gone through a pregnancy, they will not say blood clots. They'll talk about diabetes, they'll talk about bleeding out when you're giving birth, they'll talk about all sorts of things, but blood clots are the number one cause of death.

And when you open your books, and I've gone back and looked at all three of my NHS trust books that you get given that you're not meant to keep after you give birth because the NHS doesn't like you having all that evidence that you could use if there was ever an issue, but I kept mine, nothing about blood clots. NHS trusts do not educate you about them when you are pregnant. And yet that is the number one cause of death.

Royal cultural obstetrics and gynecologists are responsible for the guidance that is meant to be published, republished every three years on how to prevent, diagnose and treat blood clots. They haven't updated it since 2015. That means midwives and obstetricians have had no updated guidance on how to handle the most common cause of death in women in pregnancy and postnatal. Reviews in 18, 21, 24 were all missed. Even now, when I have started to fight them to do something about this, they say they will not get any guidance out until at least 2027.

How many more women will die in that time? Because the reality is, and I've met with Thrombosis UK, that every single woman who is pregnant, if you gave them anticoagulants for the whole of their pregnancy, there is no negative outcome. There's no risk to them from giving the anticoagulants. Now fortunately last year I was again, I've had a real few years of it, one of those people. And I went to the doctor and I said there is something wrong with me, my only symptom is a slight catch in my chest as I walk up, I'm not grabbing my chest and screaming like everyone else does.

And I was dismissed and sent home and told there was nothing wrong with me. A lady wrote to me and said that she went to the doctors three times worried about blood clots because she knew there was something not right in her leg. And each time she was told she just needed to do some yoga and get moving. The fourth time they finally diagnosed the blood clots. For me I went back to my doctor and said there is something really wrong and luckily she did a D-dimer and then she rang me the next day and said you need to go to Addenbrooke's immediately.

And they found five clots had passed through my heart into my lungs and I was lucky to be alive. And Addenbrooke's said that I clearly had an exceptional doctor and I am so grateful to Dr. Laura Stevens for saving my life. But the reality is we are in a position now where the average woman has no idea that blood clots are the number one killer. 25% of those deaths happen before 12 weeks. The first 12 weeks of pregnancy where you probably don't go to a doctor anymore because you've done a pregnancy test and you know you're pregnant.

We need a mass awareness campaign from the Department of Health. We need GPs to be aware of the risk. We need obstetrics and midwives to be taught not just about normal births, but all births. And tomorrow is World Thrombosis Day, so I am calling for maternal blood clot prevention to be a priority for the new national strategy because we can prevent them and almost all deaths from women with blood clots could have been prevented. Very briefly I want to talk about an issue that may seem slightly odd, but it's a real cruelty that was inflicted upon mothers.

The former Prime Minister apologized for the horrendous forced adoption scandal that took place in this country. But in some of those mother and baby homes, the babies never left. And ITV found that 200 infants from eight homes were buried in mass plots in 10 cemeteries across the UK. I ask the Health Secretary as part of this work to make sure that the government forces local authorities, churches and charities to open up their records because there are mums who were forced into these cruel places, these mother and baby centers, who lost their babies or who had stillbirths and to this day do not know where their babies were buried, the graves are unmarked. I will very happily give way.

06:34:20 - 06:35:11

Christopher John Vince

I thank the hon. lady for giving way and for what she's said throughout her speech. I would just say without giving too much away as my wife wouldn't forgive me, but some of the experiences that she spoke about earlier certainly resonate with me and the birth of my son a year ago. But on the point about the historic forced adoption, I was actually on the select committee when we reopened this and very proud that the previous Prime Minister did give that apology. What I found quite shocking was that those mothers, when they were trying to get the records for their children, were treated appallingly. I mean one of them as she will be aware was a PPS for a former Prime Minister and she was treated like she herself was a child asking for her own information.

So would she agree with me that that is not acceptable and should not have been allowed to happen and there needs to be apology on that?

06:35:11 - 06:37:04

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

I thank the hon. gentleman and our little ones must be very close in age, so I hope that they are doing very, very well. But the Prime Minister's apology said that we are sorry. Opening up the records means we meant it and we will release you from the shame that was forced upon you and we will give you a way to bury your babies and to finally have them to be able to name them, find them and lay them to rest. Often in this place we talk about what should be done or what we could do, so I want to end very briefly on a positive note because we can't undo a family's heartache and the loss they'll carry for all their lives.

But what drives most of us to come here is a determination to stop it happening to someone else. I made that promise to my best friend in 2022 when she lost her baby Sienna at nine months. And I took my promise and I secured 1.8 million pounds in funding from the then Conservative Health Secretary to roll out a new technology designed to reduce stillbirths and premature births. The Tommy's app or Sienna app is a clinical decision support tool and it accurately assesses women's chance of having a premature birth or developing complications with the placenta that can lead to stillbirth. And they have proven that it is saving lives.

Now the trial began in 2024 and it's running in 26 NHS maternity units involving 39,000 women a year. So my request to the Health Secretary is to roll this app out across every single hospital. We've proved it works. We've proved that it essentially gives midwives an AI equivalent giving them all the information they may not know or understand about someone because they come from a different heritage, they have a different background, or they have a complicated medical history. This tool can save lives and save more families the heartache that too many suffer.

So in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, we must do better. We are failing women on too many accounts. Almost all of us in this room can probably stand up and share a trauma or a time where something went wrong in the NHS because we weren't listened to. We must do more. And I thank everyone for their frankness and sharing their stories this evening.

And I thank the Health Secretary for having agreed to meet with me in a few days. I'm really grateful.

06:37:04 - 06:41:23

Catherine Jane Smith

Cat Smith.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've never spoken in a Baby Loss Awareness Week debate before. But that doesn't mean to say I don't care. I watched last year's on the television and I see many of the faces that were there last year this year. And I just want to say that just because for the benefit of those watching, if your MP's not here and you've asked them to be here, I think often it can be quite difficult to talk about issues where you feel you've got skin in the game.

And that's certainly the case to the extent whereby my local hospital, the Royal Lancaster Infirmary, invited me to the opening of the new bereavement suite in the maternity unit earlier this year. And I actually, I found a reason not to go. And it wasn't that I wasn't glad that that room was there, but it was because I'd never wanted to see the inside of it. Unfortunately, in June this year, I did get to see the inside of it. But not as a MP there with the ribbon being cut.

It was as a grieving parent. And the thing about miscarriages is that when you leave hospital, you don't have anything apart from maybe some leaflets from the Miscarriage Association. And the one thing I want to talk about today, and I'm going to keep this quite tight, is around baby loss certificates. Because that's one thing you can have and you can hold when you've got nothing else of your babies. But there are some some real issues with baby loss certificates that I want to set out and I believe that we can make policy changes that could make this better for parents.

Because the eligibility criteria for the certificates in England is far stricter than the eligibility criteria in Scotland and Northern Ireland. So in England, you are required to have experienced the loss in England and be living in England when you apply. Whereas in Scotland and Northern Ireland, you can apply if you live there or lived there at the time of the loss. And this variation does create an inconsistency in what's available to parents across the UK. There is another issue with cross-border access to certificates because since the English scheme was launched, I've been made aware by Sands of families where bereaved parents who live in Wales but experienced their loss in an English hospital are finding they're not eligible for the certificates.

Now the charity's concern is that once the Welsh certificate scheme finally launches, if the verification criteria is the same as the English criteria that would require the parents to both live in Wales and have experienced the loss in Wales, those parents would fall between the cracks and never be eligible for a baby loss certificate under either scheme.

But there's also an inconsistency where parents don't live in the same part of the UK, which was an issue raised in the Scottish Parliament's debate on baby loss last week. And the issue was raised by my partner, David Linden MSP, because the issue stems from the verification process which uses NHS numbers and postcodes to confirm eligibility, but it results in the problem whereby the baby loss certificates that I have just have my name on as the mother and are left blank where the father's name should be, not because he doesn't want to be on that certificate, but because the system says no, because his postcode is wrong. So you can't have both parents' names on a baby loss certificate when you live in different parts of the United Kingdom. David did raise this last week in the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Health Minister Maree Todd said she would take it forward to the department. And my only ask today is that the Secretary of State receives that warmly and perhaps even reaches out to ministers in all the nations of the United Kingdom to ensure that whilst it's not the typical way a family is, living across different nations of the United Kingdom, that where families are, that they are eligible for baby loss certificates because when you're walking out of a hospital and the only thing you wanted was your baby, but all you've got is loss, having that certificate is something tangible to hold on to and does offer a huge amount of comfort.

And I think this is a computer says no administrative error that would offer a lot of comfort to many families. Thank you.

06:41:23 - 06:47:33

Speaker 197

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's moments like this that you realize across this House that these are the incredible moments where people come together to share their testimony. And I really want to thank the honorable member for Rossendale and Darwen for bringing the debate today and for the member for Lancaster and Wyre, you absolutely broke my heart, but the strength you have shared is incredible and I know so many people watching this would be absolutely moved and just feel the power and strength of your testimony there. Obviously I'm from Northern Ireland, we introduced the baby loss certificates, it's a devolved matter for us, but I know so many of my constituents were really, really just seen by that. And I would encourage the Health Minister for England to do what we've done in Northern Ireland because it really has made such a difference.

I want to just talk briefly about a number of charities in my constituency of Lagan Valley, Zach's Wish and the Little Forget Me Nots Trust. In Northern Ireland we are one of those parts of the world where some things we do really well, other things we don't do very well. And it's actually the member for Rutland and Stamford talking about the issue of forced adoption and mother and baby homes. And across the island of Ireland we have a long and shameful heritage of a number of mass graves. And that has really impacted women and families throughout the centuries because they haven't actually been able to ever get closure.

Now the Northern Ireland Assembly at the minute is doing a big public health piece of work on actually trying to trace some of those babies to their mothers or maybe their brother or their sister or another family member. And I want to pay tribute to my colleague in the Northern Ireland Assembly, Nuala McAllister MLA for North Belfast, who has been incredible in trying to bring churches to deal with their shame for not allowing families to have a burial or even just an acknowledgment of their loved one.

Another huge issue that I have felt that is yet to be named in this debate is the issue of maternal mental health. And whenever you experience baby loss, no one can name that for you and tell you how to feel and what to do. But I do know that for women who have already experienced that incredible and crushing hollow in the center of their stomach, that sometimes the one thing that they need is somebody to be there. And I think other members have touched on the fact tonight that there needs to be that continuity of care throughout a pregnancy, and that includes whenever that journey comes to an end and the person doesn't have a baby in their arms. And I want to pay tribute to one of my constituents, Lynette Glenn from Lagan Valley and the MAAS project in the Atlas Women's Centre.

I don't want to betray any confidences, but I do know that one of the women involved in another project with Women's Aid lost her daughter after she gave birth. And within Northern Ireland, shamefully, we still do not have a proper program for women who are experiencing postnatal and issues around during the pregnancy as well, and issues around postnatal depression and anxiety. And that is deeply, deeply troubling. I can't even begin to imagine how much that compounds the loss of a child whenever you were already potentially in deep distress. Another issue that we have really come across in Northern Ireland and other parts of the United Kingdom is the lack of the pediatric pathology services.

We now have a situation where babies are being taken from Northern Ireland to other parts of the UK. And earlier this year, having met actually with some of the pathology department in the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast, I can say that that team are absolutely second to none. But that doesn't mean that that's going to hurt moms and dads and other people who have lost their baby whenever their baby is taken away from them. That's really difficult, but we have a staff shortage across that workforce of pathologists, and that's really incredibly difficult. And I think we still need to give thought to how we're actually going to help families who are undergoing that loss as we really think our way through this.

Earlier this year, we experienced the passage of the Hillsborough Law, and so many people have already made reference to the Ockenden report. And I think that's really key in terms of the culture sometimes of secrecy and cover-up. And I think that is absolutely key whenever we're discussing baby loss. I am so heartened by the number of MPs that are already doing incredible work in this space, and I think we need to do so much more there. Northern Ireland currently has the highest infant mortality rate in the UK, and that is something that I'm sure many people will find as troubling as I do.

I also want to pay tribute to a charity called Mummy's Star, founded by a lovely man called Pete, who actually lost his wife whenever she had cancer and she was pregnant. There are so many other women that go through cancer when pregnant, and sometimes they are left with no other option than to terminate their pregnancy, a much-loved pregnancy, a much-wanted pregnancy. And we need to do so much more to support those women. There are incredible clinicians who are doing work already in this space to support those women and their babies, but I think there is so much more to be done. Lastly, I just want to, if you'd spare me an indulgence, talk about IVF.

Whenever you go through IVF, sometimes you are left with, as you say, nothing in your arms. And I know for many women in Northern Ireland, at the minute we only have one funded cycle of IVF. And for those women who do not have many eggs during the egg collection, you only have one shot at a fresh egg transfer. If that isn't successful, you walk away with nothing. Your one shot's been done.

I would just really call on members across this House to help our campaign to ensure that Northern Ireland gets the three fully funded cycles of IVF or ICSI, because those women experience that loss and may potentially never gain that baby in their arms.

So I would just ask members to be mindful and to help me in that cause for women in Northern Ireland. And lastly, just thank you to everyone who shared their experiences tonight. You're incredible. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:47:33 - 06:47:45

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

The speaking limit has been dropped to six minutes. And before I call Luke Charters, because I don't want to interrupt anyone's speech, "you and yours" is not good form. You're speaking through the chair. Remember that. Thank you.

Luke Charters.

06:47:45 - 06:52:24

Jonathan Luke Charters

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm very grateful for the opportunity to contribute to the debate. And I'm reminded of the words of Jo Cox, "more in common". That sharing of experiences tonight, I hope the public and my constituents will see there is more in common between us in this house. We all recognize that baby loss brings an unimaginable grief.

No family should have to face that loss in isolation. And this is the 24th Baby Loss Awareness Week. And I pay tribute to Tommy's, Sands, and the many charities, NHS staff, and volunteers in York who are supporting families through their darkest moments. Through their compassion, they help ensure that bereaved families know they're never alone. But Madam Deputy Speaker, for too many families, baby loss could have been preventable.

Too often families have said they were not listened to when they raised concerns. Although my own family's experience is different from that of families who experienced a loss, this debate is personal. And when my wife and I welcomed our first child, we experienced a traumatic birth. Fortunate, blessed, and lucky to have him, but traumatic nonetheless. It left a profound mark on our family and particularly on my own mental health witnessing it all.

And actually, I want to pay tribute to the Sky journalist Sarah-Jane Mee, who with her empathy gave me the confidence to share my story. The findings of Baroness Amos's independent review into maternity neonatal services are important. But in the short time I have, I would say insufficient in there for non-birthing partners. And I warmly welcome the new Health Secretary to her place. And I am very appreciative of her predecessors who met with me and showed me empathy in sharing my experiences.

And I know many other members feel the same. And in her shared view, I think that there is a national crisis around the standards of maternity care in this country. I wanted to touch on the member for Sherwood Forest. One of her particular remarks, just given time, was around GMC and the professional and holding people to account. Because I think being one of those families that, frankly, too few professionals just seem to have been struck off, too few seem to have been held to account.

And I think this is echoed through some of the work in the Ockenden review and the other investigations at Nottingham. And I'm now working with her as a family in her review of maternity services at LTHT, Leeds Trust, where we were one of the families involved. And Donna, I would just say on record, she's been respectful and kind and empathetic. And I want to thank her for that. But at the heart of every recommendation must be one simple principle: that families must be listened to.

And no non-birthing partner should feel helpless as their warnings go unheard. And no bereaved family should be left wondering whether a different response could have changed the outcome for their baby. But I want to pay tribute to Hayley Patrick-Copeland and her two daughters that she lost, Aliyah and Aleah. She is a powerhouse of a northern mum. And through her Knits and Natter groups, which I visited in my constituency, they've been knitting hats and gowns for stillborn children.

And she texts me to say that awareness is so important so that people feel less alone, that they can more openly share their wonderful baby stories. And Hayley's channeled her grief into helping others, creating ribbons displays across York that offer remembrance, comfort, and solidarity to families affected by baby loss. I pay tribute to Hayley and to the local organizations supporting her. Thank you to Huntington Working Men's Club. Thank you to the Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust.

Hayley, you're amazing.

You really are. I want to close with some candour, try and let other members in, but really just to say that the test of every review, recommendation and action plan is whether families' experiences actually improve, not only in the immediate aftermath of the loss, but in the months and years that follow. And I was immensely grateful to the team at York District that were there for us during the second birth. On Thursday evening this week, the global wave of light will bring people together to remember those who have been lost too soon. But I must say that the overwhelming message I get from families in York is that sympathy is never enough.

So I hope that tonight is a clamouring call for action, that we owe them the action they deserve, and we owe it to the babies we remember this week to learn every possible lesson from their loss.

06:52:24 - 06:57:10

Robin Swann

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to thank the members from both sides of the House for bringing this debate forward this evening on Baby Loss Awareness Week. This comes at a very important moment for many of my constituents in North Devon. Due to a serious staffing crisis, all births at North Devon District Hospital have now been suspended for more than eight weeks. That has forced more than 180 expectant mothers to travel over two hours or more to Exeter to give birth since the 11th of August.

Many fear that the journey is not safe and have experienced weeks of stress and anxiety, picturing unexpected complications, the trauma of a difficult birth or the loss of a little one. This is a fear that cuts through the whole community, down every street, across every class and background. I know I am not the only member who receives private emails from constituents with heartfelt or even heartbreaking stories shared only in complete confidence. There are estimated to be 120,000 miscarriages in the UK each year, although the NHS does not know the true figure, with some estimates far higher. Losing a child is something nobody should ever have to suffer, and many families are left grieving what might have been.

Reading their accounts, you are struck by how much small acts of kindness matter. How trusts go about investigating a tragedy, whether overworked NHS staff took time to listen to parents, whether or not public bodies use their child's name. In North Devon, we're blessed with the hard work of a wonderful local charity called Families in Grief, who gave me a simple glimpse into how complex bereavement support can be. The loss of a child is something that impacts not only parents, but siblings and extended family for a long time. People experience grief very differently, and a death is something that can shatter whole families.

Speaking as a father and now a grandfather, the National Health Service is a modern miracle to some families. According to the Office of National Statistics, the infant mortality rate has fallen by more than 90% since 1900. In fact, more than 35% in just the past 25 years. And yet in some ways we seem to have gone backwards. According to the pregnancy baby loss charity Sands, the proportion of parents waiting six months or more for post-mortem results has trebled to more than one in five.

That is especially painful where it stops parents planning for another child. Bereavement support is still only offered to parents after experiencing a third miscarriage. I know that the Liberal Democrats have argued for bereavement care after every miscarriage, something also proposed by the national pregnancy charity Tommy's. They advocate for basic counselling and advice after the first miscarriage, then blood tests and more advanced scans after each successive miscarriage.

Those are important for bereavement but also for the underlying health risks that need to be identified for a future pregnancy. In North Devon, our local hospital is desperately trying to fill and find the two consultant spaces for the rota so that births can resume locally. But hundreds of families in our community also deserve a full independent review into what has happened. We need accountability so that it never happens again. No parent should have this major milestone in life ruined by inadequate access to services, poor quality care or insensitive treatment.

In December, the government's neonatal and maternity task force is due to put together a new national action plan to strengthen maternity units in the hospitals across the country. The desperate case of North Devon District Hospital and the peril of young parents in my constituency should be front and center in their thinking. I have met with many families who are struggling to even get to Exeter because of lack of transport because of a rural constituency, yes I will give way.

06:57:10 - 06:57:55

Peter Richard Prinsley

Grateful to the honorable member for taking an intervention and I'm aware of the problem in his hospital. I just like to say something quite shocking. We're talking tonight of baby loss, but we must also consider those babies who are born but damaged by obstetric catastrophes. Just a simple fact. The cost of the NHS obstetric service about one, about three billion pounds per year.

We spend 1.3 billion pounds per year on negligence compensation with a total liability of 37 billion. The average claim for a damaged baby is 11 million pounds. So although we're talking about baby loss and the problems of the obstetric service, we must also consider those babies who are born but are damaged because of obstetric disasters.

06:57:55 - 06:58:27

Robin Swann

I thank the honorable gentleman and his clinician experience in bringing that awareness to the house and I totally agree with him. So basically to conclude, after writing to the Secretary of State four times since July and not receiving one reply, I would welcome an urgent meeting with the Secretary of State to discuss the issues around maternity at North Devon District Hospital and how the closure is affecting my constituents in North Devon. Thank you.

06:58:27 - 07:04:33

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I can thank so many colleagues for their powerful contributions to this debate. I want to talk briefly about three things. The first is this point about awareness, which is such an essential first step. The second is about the significant uplift and support that we need to see for bereaved parents. And my third point is specifically about mental health support, which should always be there when people are trying for a baby or when they lose that baby during pregnancy or during or after birth.

I speak with a bit of relevant personal experience. I now have three beautiful children, but before I got pregnant with my eldest, I had three miscarriages. Three times my husband and I went through that surge of hope and excitement and nerves, that early planning for life with a baby, sharing the news with a few close friends and family, only for it to end in disappointment. I was really knocked by each time, really unsettled as there was no explanation for why it had happened. Really frustrated by all the people who just said don't worry, you'll be fine, because I didn't believe that I would be fine.

I didn't understand what had happened and I didn't know whether I'd be able to have a baby or not. But I was I suppose lucky because the NHS did get to the bottom of it and I was then able to have my children. So more importantly I am here today on behalf of all my constituents in Aylesbury and the villages an estimated half of whom will have been affected by some form of pregnancy or baby loss either directly or through someone they know. And I can bet that many of them won't have shared those experiences or won't have felt supported if they did. So my first point is about awareness because until I looked into it I had no idea that half of adults living in the UK are affected by baby loss.

And before I had my own miscarriages I had no idea that one in five pregnancies ends that way. I want to thank the organisations that are working nationally to change that like Sands and Tommy's and I want to thank the groups in my constituency who are doing the same. And I want to give a special shout out to Aylesbury Yarn Bombing who have covered post boxes across Aylesbury with these incredibly beautiful and moving post box toppers this month with hand stitched sleeping babies and candles and teddy bears and hearts and little notes asking passers by just to take a moment to show support and remember those babies we've lost and the families who have been affected. That's so important because it's on all of us to educate ourselves to speak more openly about baby loss and to reach out and rally around people who are struggling as a result of it. So that takes me to my second point which is about improving that support.

I'd like to make one specific point about miscarriage because when I when I had mine it turned out to be quite a common and treatable issue but it wasn't until the third miscarriage that I was eligible for the tests to discover this. And if that miscarriage support had kicked in sooner I could have avoided the trauma of multiple miscarriages. And so I really support this graded model of miscarriage care developed by Tommy's which would allow at least those limited tests to start sooner and I would ask that the Secretary of State looks into that. More broadly we have to end this lottery of care that exists for baby loss. I do hear from people who receive compassionate support that midwife or bereavement counsellor who makes all the difference but there's far too much of the opposite.

I'll just quote from one lady from my constituency who got in touch before this debate and said I'm a mother of a stillborn baby. I was full term 41 weeks and six days overdue with my firstborn she was born sleeping. I received very little support afterwards I was given a leaflet and just told don't worry you're healthy you'll have a baby soon and that was that. And that's not good enough and she is one of too many people being dismissed in this way. So as we've heard we need that national framework to set out what high quality support for baby loss should look like.

We need better data behind it we need clear ambitions and accountability for maternity safety more broadly. And as always when it comes to maternity care we need that sustained focus on reducing the pervasive inequalities in access and outcomes. We need that dedicated space in hospitals too I had another constituent tell me about going through surgery for ectopic pregnancy and being put straight back into a public waiting area and then being told there was no bed to stay overnight. That has to change and I know we are making good strides towards this but there is so much more to do. I'll move to the third point which is specifically the mental health support that should surround baby loss.

Because of course it's not only a physical experience or a bereavement it can have a profound and lasting effect on mental health. Research published by Miscarriage UK in March this year found that more than two thirds 68% of respondents reported mental health problems following pregnancy loss including anxiety depression and post-traumatic stress. Research supported by the National Institute for Health and Care Research has broken that down for early pregnancy loss finding that one month afterwards 29% of women experienced post-traumatic stress symptoms 24 experienced anxiety and 11% experienced depression severely.

And this continues for many months and years and of course includes people with no history of mental illness. And then according to the baby loss charity Sands, only one in six bereaved parents were actually able are actually able to access any mental health care through the NHS. Mental health support must be an integral part of the support after baby loss. And I would love to see national standards for mental health services for bereaved parents, as well as national guidance for the local commissioning of these services to help end the postcode lottery that I've spoken about. We of course also need the staff and the training and the resources to be able to deliver these services, something that we struggle with across the NHS but particularly for mental health.

This is the only way to ensure that every parent experiencing baby loss will have access not just to compassionate clinical care and bereavement support, but also to that appropriate mental health support, including a clear pathway for referral into specialist services where that's needed. Ultimately, for every parent and family experiencing baby loss, the response from the NHS and from society has to be one of dignity and compassion, and it has to result in the right support. And I hope today's debate will be a step in that direction.

07:04:33 - 07:10:54

Saqib Bhatti

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I just start by paying tribute to all the excellent speakers who shared their story with utmost bravery. This debate is one that I've attended since I was first elected and it's the only debate I know where doorkeepers distribute tissues and quite rightly. I'm the vice chair on the APPG for baby loss and I do pay tribute to everyone who's contributed to this debate and to the inquiry as the APPG has carried it out. I'm going to start with a slightly more positive story, which is a personal one, but it while the outcome was positive, there is relevance to some of the experiences that we had. And we've just we've just welcomed our third baby, he's about seven months old now.

And we we had the good fortune to attend the midwifery unit in at Warwick Hospital, which is not in my constituency, but I would still encourage the Secretary of State to go and visit it. I'm sure the member for Warwick and Leamington would welcome that. But we had a we had a very positive experience in the sense of the midwives were really, really good in terms of their communication. When and I'm going to protect my baby's identity, so he's got crazy hair, so I'm going to call him Baby Elvis. But Baby Elvis when he came out, he wasn't breathing.

And I remember the moment because in that moment the midwife had pressed the panic alarm and he came out and he was grey. And you know, and I just I remember that kind of moment where my I suppose I speak about it today because my wife's been trying to get me to talk about it for about seven months and I haven't and now I'll do it in front of the TV cameras I suppose. And she's a very patient woman. But what I remember in those two moments, those takeaways I suppose, because my honourable friend for Rutland and Melton talked about CPR and the midwife just got straight into action. And I hadn't realized that the room had filled up with health professionals from across the hospital.

It was it was quite a sight to see when I turned around once everything had kind of settled down. And in that moment I suppose I thought, oh my God, we're about to become another statistic. And those midwives did turn did work their magic. But I you know, the the talk of non-birthing partners and the support that they need has come up in this debate. And while I don't want to take away anything from mothers and what they go through and clearly they go through everything as we've heard, I think there is there is a call for any support that does come takes into account what partners and parents go through.

Because I I would probably have to admit that I probably have thought about that moment many, many times in the last seven months. And I still do and those kind of images they don't really leave you. So anything the Secretary of State can do and will do, I hope that is also taken into account.

In the limited time I've got, I'm just going to make a few calls and just recognize some of the charities that I've worked with in my locality. And I know there is work going on to do a national framework to make sure there are standards put in place. Of course, any standards that are put in place need to have KPIs and accountability along with those. And so I'm sure the Secretary of State is looking at that, and I do welcome her being in her seat today. One of the things that really did help us as a family was to do, I know families go through the NCT parents go through the NCT training, but we actually went through a private provider called Bump to Baby.

And what one of the key things that came out was actually the training that I suppose we got to be able to challenge what was given to us. And my hon. Friend for Rutland and Melton spoke about this and being able to say actually no, or why, and those things and being given the confidence to do so. And that really did help us. And actually in that moment, the midwives when I talk about our baby, they did spend a lot of time answering our questions afterwards and making sure we had, you know, taking really going over and above to recognize that there were questions that needed to be answered. And so I think the training on the way on pregnancies is really, really important to give parents the power in their arsenal to be able to ask those questions.

There's been the point about data and miscarriages has been made, and that's been also made to me from my constituents as well. So I hope the Secretary of State can clarify what thought process she's going through around collecting data on miscarriages. And I mentioned in my intervention to the hon. Member earlier the Lily Mae Foundation. I've met with Amy and Ryan who set up the Lily Mae Foundation over a decade ago. They've recently received the British Empire Medal.

They are a smallish charity. They punch way above their weight. They're incredibly strong in what they do. They've trained over a thousand parents, grieving parents of baby loss. They've supported professionals, given them training as well.

But they pointed out the postcode lottery that does occur. And actually if you're a smaller charity, you don't always get the support. And they're just being asked to do more with less. And I think that's really, really important. That was a point I just wanted to stress in this time because of course they are seeing first-hand the kind of increased load that they're seeing.

And one of the things I just wanted to finalize, just pay tribute to a couple of friends of mine because of course baby loss does touch everybody. And they've only just gone through it in the last couple of months. They had baby loss and they experienced it at Musgrove Park. And they were really keen for me to stress how great the labour team were. But they did see grieving parents and bereaved parents next to families who were celebrating birth.

And clearly there is a that disparity still continues. It's one I've seen in other hospitals. So perhaps the Secretary of State could reflect on that and pay tribute to the staff at Musgrove Park and recognize baby Merlin who they sadly lost as well. And just to finish on, on Thursday in St Philip's Church in Dorridge, I know many of my constituents will be gathering for the Wave of Light service that is being put up by the Teddy Rose Foundation through their windmill dedication. Thank you.

07:10:54 - 07:16:47

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

You were leaning, so I wasn't quite sure if you were still speaking. But Lizzi Collinge.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, I represent a large chunk of Morecambe Bay, and I will never forget the 2015 Kirkup report into maternity safety, published just one year after the birth of my first child. And I'm here today because too many babies are still dying. I have met too many bereaved families, whether that's baby Ida's parents, or the constituents who had a medical termination due to a fatal fetal abnormality, or the twins who lost their mum in childbirth, or indeed the women I speak to regularly who've lost pregnancies at all stages.

Now others have spoken about the Amos review, the Ockenden reports, and the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce, and I would like to support my colleagues' comments on these. And I would really like to hear from the Secretary of State in her closing remarks about how she'll drive the changes needed as outlined in those reports. And I would first direct her to the submission from the Patient Safety APPG to the Amos review, and I would particularly direct the Secretary of State to the Japanese system of no-fault compensation for cerebral palsy. This gives automatic compensation to parents whose baby gets a brain injury, but doesn't prevent them taking further legal action. This has reduced costs, but more importantly, it's actually reduced the number of cases of profound cerebral palsy because it has standardized reporting and standardized learning processes.

I also just want to briefly flag that health is much wider than healthcare that you receive, and the truth is right now that racism and poverty is killing babies and it's killing mums, and we need to do something about it. And those of us who are interested in patient safety talk a lot about culture. And this is quite a simple thing actually, culture is simply the way we do things around here, but it can have a really profound impact on safety, particularly the psychological safety of staff to raise concerns, which in turn of course affects the safety of services. And senior leaders and ward managers need to be able to welcome concerns and act swiftly upon them, but unfortunately, we still see too many times a culture which makes life difficult for staff when they speak out, and managers and leaders who don't take responsibility. Which is one of the reasons I welcome the Hillsborough Law, because I think it changes the legal risk from one where honesty is seen as legally risky to one where honesty in the event of a tragedy is now legally enforceable.

And further on culture, I'd like to highlight in the chamber my worries that midwifery education and culture in some instances still promotes normal birth ideology. I have seen this too often, in no other area do we expect bodies to work perfectly, and yet there is still some sections that think you can think your way to a natural birth, and I have seen the harm of this just too often. I want to speak Madam Deputy Speaker now about miscarriages, and I've left this till the end because to be honest, even after nine years, a pregnancy loss can still sting. Miscarriage is the most common complication of early pregnancy, about a quarter of a million miscarriages every year, but even this isn't exactly clear. We don't know the true prevalence of miscarriage, and I think this means we're missing opportunities for data-led service planning and of course vital research.

Miscarriage is really common, and I hope that the openness that we're developing as a nation can help women to recover, whilst also recognizing that it can have a really severe impact on your mental health. Tommy's data shows us that many months after a loss, many women have symptoms of anxiety, depression, even PTSD. And women who have experienced a miscarriage are 3.8 times more likely to die by suicide. Now I'm not saying this is a direct causal link, but there is an association, needs to be looked at. And I'm really proud of what we've done as a government for recognizing baby loss, and recognizing the toll that a miscarriage can take.

We have heard some of the problems with baby loss certificates, and I hope those problems are addressed. But finally I just wanted to say, it's wrong that women still have to go through three miscarriages most of the time before they get any care and support. So I would really urge the Secretary of State to fully roll out the Tommy's graded model of miscarriage care. It is absolutely essential that women get an appropriate level of support, information, and treatment when that happens to them.

But I do want to give people some hope as well. I know there's some very recent experiences in the chamber today. And last week I was reading a novel by Catherine Shellman and she had a line in it, it was about the loss of a spouse, but it really reflects perfectly, I think, my feelings about a decade, about a decade after pregnancy loss. It just reads, it was still there, but quieter. A sad memory instead of a broken heart.

And I just want to reassure colleagues that you can go some way to mending that broken heart. And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to offer my thanks to the people supporting families who lose babies. I want to especially thank Matilda's Mission, a baby loss charity that works in my constituency of Morecambe and Lunesdale and who every year remembers Baby Collins. They support so many families at the absolute worst time. They give them a community that understands them and supports them, and that's what we should have for every family.

07:16:47 - 07:16:50

Jim Shannon

Thank you.

07:16:51 - 07:19:46

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a real pleasure to follow the honorable lady for Morecambe and Lunesdale and thank her for sharing her personal story as many others have in this chamber as well. And those personal stories remind us all of the grief and the loss and the pain that comes from that. So I think thank you, Madam Deputy, for allowing this important debate to be brought forward. Baby Loss Awareness Week provides an important opportunity to raise awareness and to reflect on loss. And I think probably everyone who has spoken tonight has reflected on loss, whether it be directly or through friends and family.

However, we must also recognize that the impact of baby loss extends beyond this week. It's not just this week. It's many other weeks of the year, with families continuing to carry their grief long after this campaign ends. Excuse me, losing a baby both before and after term is devastating. Parents speak of the potential of what could have been, the hope and the dreams that they had for their child and the milestones that they believed that they would celebrate, but that wasn't to be.

And with this loss comes immense grief and anxiety. And the impact of this not only on the mother but on the wider family circles cannot be underestimated. And sometimes I know that the moms and the dads and the siblings will feel the pain probably more, but the grandparents and the aunties and the uncles and the sisters and the brothers, they all feel it as well because they're all living for through that family member hoping that that new life will indeed be part of something that they can enjoy as well. For many families, this affects these effects continue to future pregnancies. Parents report feeling constant fear and anxiety, waiting with grim anticipation for this tragic event to happen again.

And sadly for some families, it does. For my mother, she lost, she had four miscarriages. She had four children, but she also missed four. My speechwriter Naomi, who's a very busy girl, she lost her first baby as well. So many of my constituents tell me of their loss.

So this debate tonight is for me through this debate to express on their behalf their sorrow and the fact that it means so much to them. Supporting women through and after this loss should be a priority. We must advocate for open communication amongst friends and families, as many women have shared that talking about their loss has helped them in their own healing and made them realize they're not alone in this experience. And you're not alone in this experience. You have your family about you, but you have many others who have gone through the same pain.

Of course, supporting women in this loss is essential, but we must also do everything we can to prevent loss where possible. And in an earlier intervention, I drew attention to the research suggesting that giving women access to specialized care after their first miscarriage could help prevent baby loss.

07:19:46 - 07:19:50

Speaker 293

Others have referred to that and I'm very happy to excuse me.

07:19:50 - 07:20:30

Speaker 296

I thank him for giving way. I my my daughter is a rainbow baby. And I feel so it's amazing that we managed to that we managed to have her but the hurt and the pain that you get in getting to that position where you've lost children in between is absolutely unbelievable. So I wonder if he agrees with me based on what he's just said that it is so important that after that first loss as Tommy's have suggested that intervention and professional support is given immediately both in terms of investigations and understanding what the cause is but also in terms of that mental health support.

07:20:30 - 07:23:11

Jim Shannon

I thank the honorable gentleman for that intervention. Yes I totally agree with that. I think everybody else in this chamber also agrees with it as well. The current specialist care is only offered after three miscarriages but if it was offered after one then estimates suggest that supporting an early intervention could potentially prevent around 10,000 losses each year in the UK. That's that's a magnitude of just one step one step in the right direction.

So I'm looking forward to the minister's response and I hope that the minister can give us some encouragement. I know the honorable lady is a compassionate minister and she understands how we all feel in this chamber in relation to this this issue and I hope we can get that that reassurance. I want to speak about Northern Ireland. I know the honorable lady for Lagan Valley spoke about made some comments about Northern Ireland and I want to do something similar if I can as well. I sincerely welcome the recent changes made in Northern Ireland as it has become the first region in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to provide paid leave to both parents affected by miscarriage.

Really important that our minister took that step in the right direction at that time. Maybe that's something the minister would consider for here as well because in the mainland it was something that would help many many people. It's estimated some around 10 9,000 people per year in Northern Ireland are affected by miscarriage. And this leaves me in no doubt that this will have a real impact on families in Northern Ireland. Further efforts have also been made in Northern Ireland through the baby loss certificate scheme.

Again another perhaps a small way but a big way in the effect that it has. Certificates are now available to anyone who has experienced a pregnancy loss before the end of the 24th week of pregnancy. And the formal recognition of these losses offer families who previously went unrecognized I believe a degree of comfort and closure. And an intervention earlier on the gentleman who set the debate had spoken the importance of having a chaplain or a minister available to give the succor and the care and the support that sometimes needs that spiritual dimension of loss. As a Christian obviously that would mean a whole lot to me but I think it would mean a whole lot to others as well if they had that opportunity.

So perhaps maybe minister on that we could have some reassurance as well. We must ensure that the impact of these schemes are properly evaluated so that we can understand how effective they are in supporting bereaved families. If the evidence shows that these measures are making a meaningful difference then this house I believe must consider how similar support can be implemented UK wide. I conclude with this Madam Chair. It is clear that baby loss has a lasting impact.

07:23:11 - 07:23:25

Speaker 295

Every baby loss represents a life that could have been lived and a future that might have been. We must show compassion and understanding to those affected not only during baby awareness week but indeed every day of the year. Thank you.

07:23:25 - 07:28:03

Katrina Murray

With colleagues withdrawing we have a few more minutes on the clock so backbenchers are on an eight minute speaking limit and I call Katrina Murray.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to begin by telling the House about Rita Grace Gazzala, the daughter of my constituents, Fadi and Liz. I consider myself very privileged that Fadi and Liz have asked me to share Rita's story today. And not just sharing her story with me, but allowing me to share her story with the House. During pregnancy, Fadi and Liz learned that Rita had Edwards' syndrome, a life-limiting condition.

They knew that the time that they might have with their daughter could be desperately short. Rita was born in December 2024 and spent nine days with her mum and dad at the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow. Fadi and Liz describe those nine days as simply the best nine days of their lives. Nine days is a heartbreakingly short life, but Rita's life was a life filled with love and one that has already left an extraordinary legacy. In the months since Rita's death, Fadi and Liz have channeled their grief into making things better for other babies with expected short lives and for their families.

Through Rita's legacy of hope, thousands of people have supported their fundraising. They have funded Rita's room at Crossbasket House, providing a dedicated space for bereaved families so no other family has to go through counseling sessions in an office. Providing two portable incubators, allowing parents to keep their babies close and make the most of their precious time together. And a cuddle cot and blanket system for Scotland's tertiary pediatric palliative care service. It's an extraordinary legacy for one little girl.

But through that work, Fadi and Liz also identified something that they believe needs to change. Fadi and Liz knew long before Rita was born that she had a life-limiting condition. So that pregnancy was full of months of hospital appointments, treatment, worry, and uncertainty. They have been very clear to me that they were fortunate. They were financially able to take time away from work and had employers who would support them.

But they also know that many families receiving the same devastating news will not be in that position. No parent who learns that the time they may have with their child could be measured in hours or days should also have to worry about whether they can afford to take time away from work. Fadi and Liz believe that families whose baby has been diagnosed with a life-limiting condition should have a statutory right to paid leave during pregnancy. They call that proposal Rita's Law. The government has already taken important steps to strengthen the rights of parents, including through the Employment Rights Act, and I particularly welcome the review of parental leave and pay system that's now underway.

But Fadi and Liz's experience highlights a gap. The support available following the birth or death of a baby does not address the particular circumstances of parents who during pregnancy are told that their baby is expected to have a very short life. So I'm asking the Minister to work with the Department of Business, Innovation, Science and Technology to ensure that the needs of those families are explicitly considered as part of the parental leave and pay review and to take a look seriously at Fadi and Liz's proposal for Rita's Law.

Rita's life was heartbreakingly short, but it mattered enormously. And Fadi and Liz have ensured that Rita's name will be associated with compassion, dignity and giving families precious time together. And I hope that by listening to their call for change, we can help that legacy reach even further.

07:28:03 - 07:33:54

Josh Newbury

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is an honour to speak in this debate, which is always so powerful, and I pay tribute to my honourable friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen for leading it so sensitively. There are very few things that compare to the joy of knowing that you're about to become a parent, considering names, imagining a future and those little things in life that suddenly take on a whole new meaning. But for some families, there's a moment where all of that changes, when the future that was so full of possibility is filled with uncertainty and grief. My constituents Phil and Emma were brave and generous in sharing their experiences with me and my team.

Emma's story is one of repeated pregnancy loss, difficult childbirth experiences and not receiving the care and support that she needed. I will share Emma's story in her own words and to warn honourable members, Emma describes in harrowing detail her experience of miscarriage. Emma told me this. Our story of pregnancy loss started back in March 2019. I booked a GP appointment after continually bleeding for three weeks.

No pregnancy test was offered and I was told to just monitor the bleeding. After fainting at work from persistent blood loss, I visited the Samuel Johnson Walk-in Centre and I was given a routine pregnancy test, which came back positive. Emma's first miscarriage was followed by another pregnancy in February 2020 during the pandemic. She describes the anxiety of attending appointments alone without her husband after her previous experience of loss. She went on to give birth to her daughter Alice, but difficulties did not end there.

Following her discharge, Emma developed an infection and was passed between three hospitals. She describes being physically weak, emotionally struggling and without the support she needed. After experiencing birth trauma, Emma and Phil were understandably nervous about having another child. But in March of this year, they discovered they were expecting again, excited about the possibility of a positive experience. Emma wrote, I had an in-person eight-week midwife check on the 19th of March and was advised I needed birth trauma counselling, which I welcomed as I felt it finally felt as though somebody was listening and caring about my past experiences.

But at 11 weeks, Emma began spotting and knew she needed help quickly. She called the early pregnancy unit at New Cross Hospital eight times before her call was answered. Despite her concerns, she was offered an appointment several days later. A private scan confirmed that the pregnancy was no longer viable, but the hospital couldn't bring her appointment forward. Emma describes what happened next.

When we attended the New Cross EPU on the 14th of April, we had to sit in the same room as pregnant women and ironically were taken into the same room where my first pregnancy was confirmed as a miscarriage. Despite the findings, Emma was told she needed another scan in 10 days. She was sent home without pain relief, follow-up appointments or even a number to call for help. Just three days later, Emma experienced a devastating medical emergency at home. She said, I went to the toilet and found I'd haemorrhaged completely through my clothing.

I was scared and alone. Emma passed out and was found in a pool of blood by her mother, who called 999. After waiting 45 minutes, the ambulance service called back to say that Emma would have to make her own way to hospital. Her husband struggled to get her into the car and drive her to New Cross. When they arrived, staff hadn't been informed of her situation.

Emma described that experience.

My husband at this point pleaded with the staff for me to be seen. He had to explain multiple times what had happened all whilst I was bleeding heavily. Eventually Emma was taken into a treatment room where her blood pressure dropped dramatically low and she lost consciousness. She was taken to intensive care where she heard staff discuss blood transfusions and emergency treatment. Emma's clear that the staff who cared for her that day were wonderful, but her experience leading up to that point raises questions about the support available to women experiencing pregnancy loss and medical emergencies.

Emma was discharged with blood thinning injections, but no emotional support or follow-up appointments. She sought help for her mental health, only to be told that miscarriage was just something that happens and given an NHS talking therapies leaflet. She eventually contacted Tommys where she finally felt listened to and supported. Emma also raises a wider concern about how pregnancy loss is counted and recognized. She said, despite the fact that I've had two miscarriages, because I had a healthy pregnancy in the middle of those, my count will be reset to one, almost rendering my first miscarriage as forgotten and pointless.

Madam Deputy Speaker, Emma's story highlights the physical and emotional impact of pregnancy loss, the importance of timely and compassionate care, and the need to consider the experiences of partners and families alongside those women themselves. I want to finish by returning to Emma's words. Emotionally, it's an incredibly difficult time, but physically, the pain women go through is totally underestimated. We want change for women's health, change for partner support, and change for all the families that have had to experience any maternity issues or baby loss. It was so encouraging to see the government introduce two weeks of unpaid leave for those who experience pregnancy loss in any form and at any stage, and I'm proud of the ambition set out in the women's health strategy.

But we now need to move as quickly as we can to ensure every woman has access to high quality miscarriage care and bereavement support irrelevant of if she lives in Cannock Chase, rural Northumberland, or central London. No family should have to find out that the support available to them depends on their postcode. We've made important progress, now we need to make sure that progress is felt by every woman and every family that experiences the heartbreak of losing their baby. Thank you.

07:33:54 - 07:38:16

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Jane Gakum.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent, little Brown Tony Cliff, was born on the 11th of December 2024. He suffered a severe head injury during his birth and died on the 17th of December 2024. On 7th of February he had his funeral. He was born at Royal Cornwall Hospital in Cornwall and he was transferred to Southmead after that.

I'm here to make some of the points that his parents have made to me about the care that he had and make some other points actually that haven't been made yet about the system of post-mortems and coroners and the inquests. Firstly, the mental health support was a struggle after what happened for Brown's parents, for his mom, and there was very little support for the other parent. And this is a point that's been raised across the house, that the other parent often is left to feel that they are just there and what they think and feel isn't taken into consideration and often doesn't really matter. But I was asked to say that the team at Treliske, the bereavement team, have been very good throughout Helen and Phil's experience.

They also wanted me to say that the recommendations in some of the reports and investigations are made, as the honorable member for Godalming and Ash mentioned, many, many times, many many recommendations, but whether these are actually acted upon and how parents can make sure that some of those, that the care improves after those recommendations are made is very difficult. Last year I spoke about Bram and the previous health secretary met his parents, Helen and Phil, and they fed into the government's review. Some of the points that were made were also relevant to the Ministry of Justice, so one of the ministers from the MOJ was there too. There was a very long wait for a pathologist's report in Bram's case. This is a common issue, the lack of pathologists, and it's something that the minister did take away.

Also, Bram's inquest has been delayed, in fact it's still being delayed and is scheduled to take place in the new year, so that's over two years since Bram died, which is an extremely long time. They also made the point that they have had a number of dealings with the coroner's court and they thought that maybe improved training for the coroner's court when dealing with parents who've undergone this kind of thing would be helpful because they found the whole process extremely difficult. I wanted to raise some charities who really helped Bram's family, who are local to us in Cornwall: Luna's Fund, who support parents in Devon and Cornwall; To Wish, which is a child bereavement charity; and Helen and Phil set up their own charity for Bram, Bram's Library, which gifts picture books to parents in similar situations. I wanted also to mention my predecessor actually in this place, Cherilyn Mackrory, who spoke very movingly when she was in this house about her experiences and her daughter Lily, and she was the co-chair of the Baby Loss APPG, again I believe with the member for Godalming and Ash. So many families are affected by baby loss, my own is no exception, and anything that we can do to learn from the experiences of our constituents, our own families, so the health secretary, that it's so fantastic that she's been here throughout this debate, can take away these stories and can make improvements for the future.

07:38:16 - 07:41:38

Speaker 302

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's an honor to follow the member for Truro and Falmouth. I'd like to pay tribute to all of the members who have made such emotional, moving and powerful contributions this evening. Madam Deputy Speaker, a number of honorable members have mentioned continuity of care, and I must confess to something of a thrill upon being elected to this place in July 2024 to quite soon afterwards finding myself in a committee room in Portcullis House next to Professor Chris Whitty discussing continuity of care, and it may not surprise you, Madam Deputy Speaker, that he thinks it's a good idea as well, as many people in this room do. The right honorable member for Godalming and Ash also mentioned the importance of a good functioning team in the NHS to ensure decent outcomes, and I saw this quite recently last week when I visited my local hospital to see a team of surgeons and other staff operating a robot in order to remove a gallbladder from a patient, delivering really good outcomes, and that importance of having a really well-integrated team together is absolutely vital.

This obviously is a really important debate and those experiencing baby loss have an especially tragic bereavement. The loss of a loved one or friend is always tragic, something to be sympathised with in solidarity. But those experiencing the loss of a baby are particularly deserving of our kindness, sympathy and support. The life cut short, the potential of what has disappeared, the joy of growing and living together, of shared love, laughter in life, relegated to the imagination and the hopes of what might have been. The intention of the Secretary of State is clear, to support women and families let down by maternity services.

And personally, I'm very glad to see that the early loss is being recognised with the baby loss certificate scheme, which covers pregnancy loss before 24 weeks. The government is investing in services to support families dealing with the tragedy of baby loss. Every ICB is funded specialist bereavement midwives and bereavement services, for example. In Hertfordshire, in which my constituency of Watford is located, there are many organisations doing amazing work to support those grieving the loss of a baby or miscarriage, with those offering support including Alternatives Watford, West Herts Hospitals Charity, Petals, Chums, Sands and Tommys, as well as GP practices and the County Council, which also has a network for staff who have experienced baby loss and providing much needed support. In a former career, I worked in health and social care, including for the Hertfordshire Safeguarding Children's Board.

And in my experience of supporting serious case reviews into the death of a child or the child death overview panel, it is important to recognise the engagement of health staff in being determined to find out what has gone wrong, and we should acknowledge that. I welcome the efforts of the government and those supporting this work to minimise the incidence of baby loss and to ensure that nobody goes unsupported when experiencing it. Thank you.

07:41:38 - 07:48:32

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Fainted a little bit sooner than expected. I call the front benches and I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson Helen Morgan.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'll start by declaring my interest as a member and former co-chair of both the baby loss and maternity APPGs and a member of the birth trauma APPG, and by thanking the honourable and right honourable members for Sherwood Forest, Rossendale and Darwin and Godalming and Ash for securing this important debate to mark Baby Loss Awareness Week. And it has been an emotional evening listening to the contributions of members across the House in this debate who've either bravely shared their own stories or those of their constituents, or who have worked incredibly hard to bring about improvements in both maternity and neonatal care and bereavement care for those families who face the loss of their baby, and in some cases both of those things. Since I was elected in December 2021, there have been far too many reports which have come to Parliament which detail the unimaginable pain of families who've lost or injured babies or mums. From Shrewsbury and Telford, which impacted families in my community, some of whom were my close friends and which I've spoken about on a number of occasions in this place, through East Kent, Nottingham and the many hospitals included in the Amos review, and now new inquiries into Leeds and Sussex, there have been many, many reports and far too little action.

The silent scandal of the maternity crisis in this country has unfolded in plain sight. Maternal deaths are higher than at any point in the last decade. 65% of maternity units are not rated as adequately safe by the CQC, who've warned that there's a risk of normalising serious harm in maternity care. The latest MBRACE-UK report shows that women from black ethnic backgrounds are nearly three times as likely to die during or up to six weeks after pregnancy compared to women from white ethnic backgrounds, and with women from Asian ethnic backgrounds also facing a slightly increased risk.

Stillbirth rates for babies born to mothers living in the most deprived areas remain significantly higher than those in the least deprived areas. Women in the most deprived areas are also twice as likely to die during or shortly after pregnancy compared to those in the least deprived areas. The 2015 national maternity safety ambition aimed to halve the 2010 rates of stillbirth, neonatal and maternal deaths and brain injuries occurring during or soon after birth by 2025. We've missed the target on this, and targets for the future haven't been set, and they must be. 1.3 billion pounds is spent every year on medical negligence payments.

We're spending the equivalent of a third of the whole maternity budget on the price of failure rather than keeping mums and babies safe in the first place. And we know that many experienced clinicians are leaving the profession, burnt out by exhaustion, the crumbling units they work in, and the lack of time for training for the increasingly complex pregnancies and births that they must deal with. Now, I welcome the fact that the government, despite there having been three Secretaries of State this year, has shown commitment to improving maternity services. Their agreement to create the statutory role of a maternity commissioner and to legislate for that in the Health Bill as it makes its way through the other place is undoubtedly a good step forward. And I thank both the Secretary of State and the Minister, the honorable member for Bristol South, for their constructive and collaborative approach to making that happen.

The government's also established a maternity task force and commissioned Baroness Amos's review, all welcome acknowledgments that improvement in maternity services should be of the highest priority. But there have unfortunately been missteps too. Removing the ringfence from service development funding, the very fund designed to support enhanced care for complex pregnancies, multiple births, and bereavement care and support, is incomprehensible in the light of concerns that have been so widely raised, and I call on the Secretary of State to reinstate it. Liberal Democrats have put improvement in maternity at the heart of our work in this parliament, and we've proposed a package to tackle the crisis, starting with safe staffing on every ward. Now, often when things go wrong, that happens at night or at a weekend when the on-call consultant is at home, because I think we've all, we all know that babies famously haven't grasped the importance of respecting normal working hours.

We would ensure that there's a consultant obstetrician present 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and that one-to-one midwifery care for every woman in labor is available so that the early signs of complication in labor are recognized quickly. Now, we know that many pregnancies and births are more complex now. Training teams to deal with that is essential, and we call on the government to introduce mandatory, regularly updated, salaried training for all staff. And for those in leadership roles, we'd work on a culture of openness, learning from mistakes, and speaking up when it's obvious that things are going wrong. Lots of members this evening have talked about better support throughout pregnancy, ensuring that high-risk mums have the right team around them from the start, and that crucially, women are listened to throughout their pregnancy.

We'd tackle the huge disparities in outcomes for Black, Asian and disabled women and from those, and those from deprived backgrounds through better training to understand risk, alongside investment in the public health measures that are so critical to tackle some of the drivers of these disparities. And finally, we urge the government to recognize that tragically, not every pregnancy goes to plan. We urge the government to record all miscarriages so that the issue is no longer hidden, support every woman who has had a miscarriage, not make them wait for their third one, and invest in ensuring that there is bereavement care for every family who needs it.

Now there is undoubtedly a cost to all this, of course there is, but it is less than half of that eye-watering medical negligence bill. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Thirlwall Inquiry highlights the failure of the NHS to learn from mistakes and implement recommendations from detailed investigations that are undertaken when things go wrong. It's highlighted how constant top-down reorganisations of the NHS have prevented progress and obscured the monitoring of improvement. And it says that a lack of political will has failed to overcome the barriers to change for the better. I've heard colleagues from all sides, all parties, both sides of the House agree on the urgent need to improve maternity services this evening, and I'm encouraged by the steps that the government has taken so far.

But now it's time for action. I'm ready to work with colleagues from all parties to tackle this crisis and to ensure that no other family has to endure the pain of the avoidable loss of their beloved baby. I look forward to hearing from the Secretary of State that the government has the political will to do the same. Thank you.

07:48:32 - 07:57:28

Caroline Johnson

Shadow Minister Dr Caroline Johnson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and before I start I must declare an interest as a consultant NHS paediatrician, a member of the British Medical Association, a member of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, and also that I've worked in neonatal intensive care in a number of different hospitals, including Nottingham University Hospitals where I worked as a junior doctor in part and very partly overlapped the initial period of the Ockenden Review. I'd like to congratulate the honourable members for Rossendale and Darwen and Sherwood Forest and my right honourable friend the member for Godalming and Ash for bringing this really important debate today, and also the charities such as Bliss, Tommy's, Sands and others for the important work that they do. This House, as others have said, become a somewhat annual debate. And reflecting on it, it has a sort of a pattern. We hear many stories and we've heard many emotional stories this evening from very brave individuals who've put forward their words or the words of their constituents.

We reflect on the babies that have been lost, their first words, when they would have had their first steps, who they would have grown up to become. We talk in sorrow and in memory. But there is also, Madam Deputy Speaker, some frustration because 13 babies every day will die shortly before, during or after their birth. So it's important, Madam Deputy Speaker, to reflect, but I firmly believe that families would like us also to focus on prevention and service improvements. So I'm going to use the rest of my remarks to talk about whether the government is doing all it can to tackle baby loss and as quickly as it can.

As a children's doctor, I've been privileged to attend hundreds of births. Politics offers the opportunity to save more lives than doctors across the whole country because it has the power to make impactful change and save lives and the government must use this. Just over a decade ago, my right honourable friend the member for Godalming and Ash, then the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, set a target to halve the rate of stillbirths, neonatal and maternal deaths by 2030. And he didn't succeed completely, but he made very encouraging progress. Stillbirths fell by 20%.

Neonatal deaths fell by 20%. And maternal deaths fell by a third. And as he said himself earlier, that means that 700 additional babies a year are waking up today and tomorrow and loving their parents and being loved by their parents and bringing great joy. The new Health Secretary came into post last month and I welcome her to her place. And she said herself, it's time to put maternal, neonatal care and safety at the top of the NHS agenda where they belong.

She's right, and I know it is important to the Secretary of State.

I want to acknowledge the government has made progress in some areas. It built on conservative work by expanding the baby loss certificates, and we've heard from the honorable member for Lancaster and Wyre this evening just how important and vital those certificates can be. They've implemented Martha's rule so that people can have a second opinion. I appreciate the Secretary of State is newest in post, but also her predecessors this year have acted too slowly. They came to power in July 2024, saying that they had a plan for the NHS.

It took them a year until July 2025 to bring forward their 10-year plan. It said that they'll bring forward a neonatal task force, but they took seven months to decide who was going to be on it. And a maternity and neonatal plan was going to need to be produced. There was going to be a rapid review that was going to produce a plan by December 25, but it came June 2026, almost two years after their election. That national maternity investigation brought forward two key recommendations.

The first one is to appoint a maternity and neonatal commissioner, and the government have promised to do so. That promise was announced over three months ago. Can the Secretary of State tell us when that appointment will be made, or will it be delayed by putting it on a statutory footing, or will she be able to make it anyway? The second recommendation is to develop a modern, safer framework to establish minimum standards for maternity care. And the government announced that they'll be developing a national action plan on this, but it won't be ready until December 2026.

So can the Secretary of State guarantee that it will be ready by 2026 December, because that's coming very soon now? In the meantime, the government has promised 41 million pounds for maternity and neonatal buildings. Can the Secretary of State tell us how and where this money will be spent and which hospitals will benefit? My honorable friend the member for Meriden and Solihull East spoke of people experiencing baby loss or babies on the neonatal unit being on a ward next to those celebrating the births of healthy children that were beside them. Can the Secretary of State tell us how she is going to manage that so that doesn't happen anymore?

The government has spoken about the Black and Asian maternal mortality gap, and it committed in its manifesto to a target to close this gap. Can the Secretary of State tell us when this target will be published and how she will close that gap? I also want to talk about workforce, because workforce is key to delivering these outcomes. The last conservative government created a long-term workforce plan for the NHS, but this government decided they wanted to create their own workforce plan, which is absolutely their right to do so. But we were promised it by the end of 2025, and we're now deep into autumn 2026.

And we're being told they'll provide an update on the workforce plan in due course, which, having been told it was imminent previously, is somewhat disappointing. But they need to know and say how many midwives they're going to need, how many obstetricians, how many gynecologists, how many pediatricians. How will all of these people be trained? How many more medical school places may be required? The government promised time and time again it would double the number of medical school places, yet it has rowed back on that promise like it never existed.

So can the Secretary of State tell us once and for all if the government will be doubling the number of medical school places, or if it was just a 2024 general election promise? Can she tell us what date the workforce plan will be ready and published? The manifesto also promised to train thousands of additional midwives. So can the Secretary of State tell us how many have been trained so far? My right honorable friend for Godalming and Ash and my right honorable friend for Rutland and Stamford, as it is now, spoke about the importance of listening to women and also not having an ideological fixation on a normal birth or a particular type of delivery, but instead looking for a good outcome.

And looking at training I wonder if the Secretary of State could elaborate on how she intends to encourage the midwives and obstetricians to see themselves as one team. I know in some places they do and in other places tragically they do not. But how they can work together as a team with the wider team, anaesthetists, paediatricians and other professionals to work for the best outcomes of women rather than a particular ideological outcome. Some have talked this evening about complexity of pregnancies in modern times and I wonder if the Secretary of State could talk about whether she feels nursing skills are required of midwifery and to what extent and how she intends to ensure that they're delivered. And also I know the government's got its three shifts, one of which is prevention.

And I wonder if she could talk about vaccination and chronic disease optimisation before pregnancy and how they could help to reduce the amount of baby loss. Madam Deputy Speaker, on a wider level the NHS is being reorganised and I appreciate from the Secretary of State's point of view this was announced before she became Secretary of State. But the abolition of NHS England and the shaking up of ICBs is causing disruption to health services. And the abolition of Healthwatch, which she still has time to do something about, is removing the independent voice, that listening to women that we have heard about so much this evening. Now I want to conclude Madam Deputy Speaker by saying there are many, many, many fantastic NHS staff.

Many women, most women in fact, get great care. But some don't and the findings of recent investigations and indeed investigations over many years have been hugely disturbing. I know that the Secretary of State cares very deeply about this topic. So I would like her assurance please that these plans will be published, the staff will be trained, the taskforce and commissioner will be effective and that she will deliver on the maternity safety that everybody right across the house wants to see.

07:57:28 - 08:03:19

Karin Smyth

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I just say a huge thanks to everybody who has spoken in this debate this evening for the personal stories that they have told and also for the tributes that they have given to their constituents and the personal stories that they have told from constituents as well. I think it is a moment for the whole house to come together to reflect on the babies lost and also on our responsibility to do everything that we can to support families who do go through the unimaginable and lose a baby and lose a child and also to do everything that we possibly can to prevent it happening for more families in the future as well. Can I thank the honourable members who have called the debate today, my honourable friend the member for Rossendale and Darwen and to thank him for the work that I know he has done on the APPG but also his courage in talking about his own experiences and his determined focus on the action that is needed. Thank you to him.

Can I thank too the right honourable member for Godalming and Ash, one of my predecessors as Health Secretary, who I know championed patient safety and in particular maternity safety and it is hugely welcome that he is still speaking out so strongly and has sat here throughout the entire debate this evening again. I say thank you. And thank you particularly to my honourable friend the member for Sherwood Forest who is doing such an incredible and invaluable job as our national maternity and neonatal advisor.

Thank you to her for the work that she is doing and the incredible job she is doing making sure that parents' voices are heard and making sure that babies are remembered and making sure that change is driven forward for families in the future. And her work has been hugely powerful and I've seen the work that she has been doing with parents across the country and also with the maternity task force as well. But particularly thank you to everyone because no one should underestimate the courage that it takes to talk about personal experiences and some of the most devastating personal experiences in such a public forum but also in a way that is all about helping others, about giving comfort to others and bringing that empathy and humanity that if we are honest we do not always show in this place but we have come together to show this evening. And can I particularly say that this debate is about Mallory and Jasper and Jesse and Joshua and Nitaya and Chester and Kate and Harry and Alia and Aliyah and Theo and Ida and Bran and Winter and Harriet and Sebastian and Cooper and Teddy and Quinn and Aubrey and Grace and Poppy and Dexter and Luna and Theo and Sienna and Rita and Baby Ladybird and Baby Collinger. And we remember all of those babies as well.

As my honourable friend the member for York Outer said earlier, we will see on this Thursday evening at seven o'clock hundreds of parents in every one of our constituencies will light candles at home to remember babies that they have lost and it's something which spreads across the world from one time zone to the next as a global wave of light to unite parents from every continent in an act of collective grief. And you'll go on social media and see the pictures of burning candles posted by mums and dads and the sense for those of loss for those families does not go away and it doesn't grow lighter or less painful. But on that day of October 15th there is at least the knowledge that it is shared and we hold together a candle up to an issue that has for too long been hidden or ignored or dismissed which is saying to every family which has faced the pain of losing a baby that you are not alone and you deserve support. And an issue that was raised by the honourable member for Rutland and Stamford and the member for Lagan Valley and Stamford. I want to just refer to, I had a conversation earlier this evening with Gina Jacobs.

And Gina 57 years ago lost her stillborn son Robert and at the hospital he was taken away and she never saw his face. And only years later did she discover that he had been buried in a mass grave without her knowledge. And you can just imagine the heartbreak of losing the child but followed by the pain of realising that something so important and personal had been kept from her. Because across the decades many bereaved parents have lost babies in NHS hospitals and been denied any say and denied any information about what would happen to their remains. On behalf of the government I want to issue a profound apology to them.

08:03:19 - 08:03:49

Speaker 307

I've issued that apology to Gina today but to so many more like Gina who have sought answers over many years and I'm sorry for the unthinkable pain caused by those historic practices because what happened to those parents should never have happened and we need to ensure it can never happen again. I also want where I have the time to do so to also recognise the parents of baby Dexter from my constituency because Dexter's mum Sophie is in the gallery this evening.

08:03:49 - 08:09:56

Karin Smyth

And I spoke to Sophie and Dale some months ago before I became Health Secretary. Their story and Dexter's story had a profound impact on me and is one of the reasons why I'm so determined to make maternity and neonatal care a priority for the NHS and for the government. Because Dexter died in 2018, less than 24 hours after his birth, following hospital failures that were admitted years later. And I've listened to Sophie talk about the concerns they had not being listened to about failures on diagnosis, early intervention, or treatment. And to go through the unimaginable and then not be able to get answers, and still eight years later, they are still navigating NHS complaints, regulators, legal processes, the coronial system, the Parliamentary Ombudsman, trying to get answers and accountability.

And I want to acknowledge Sophie's determination and the courage it takes to be here today and the commitment for so many parents who have been through the unimaginable and that trauma to keep campaigning for others. And all of us in this chamber have a responsibility to Dexter's family and to every family represented in this debate to listen, to learn, and to act. Because as Sophie said to me earlier, trust begins with truth. And if you can't get answers as to what's happened, it makes it compounds the anguish and the distress. So it's why I have made this a priority.

It's also why I want to recognize the very wonderful care that so many midwives, consultants, support staff, health visitors provide when families need it most in our NHS right across the country. But we also know that the devastating stories where things have gone wrong, where things families didn't get answers, and where we know so much more needs to be done. Where we need as part of a new maternity and neonatal task force to ensure that we have a new national action plan drawn up, but also the work done to establish a new modern services framework of proper standards across maternity and neonatal care. And I think this is crucially important because 25 years ago when I was a junior health minister, I had responsibility for maternity services. Yes, a full quarter of a century ago.

I was pregnant at the time of being responsible for maternity services, so you can imagine I had a particular interest in maternity services at the time. But one of the things that I'd announced then at that time was that there should be a new set of standards, a national services framework for maternity and child health. And so when I arrived in the department to say, well, what do we need to do in order to address the Amos report and the Ockenden reviews, the Morecambe Bay reviews, the many different reviews that we have had. And one of the things that the responses I got was that well, we need a national services, we need a modern services framework. And when I asked, well, how different is it, because obviously we need to modernize the standards from the existing one.

And one of the things they said is the existing one doesn't exist because it had just been allowed to lapse. And so we didn't have a set of national standards in place. We have to put that right. And I think there is collective determination. I think the honorable member for Meriden referred to the importance of national standards, and that's one of the things that needs to be done as part of the work of the task force alongside the action plan.

But right at its heart has to be the listening to parents and listening particularly to mothers. The honourable member for Rutland's powerful personal experiences of feeling that she was left having to make choices or feeling she had to fight to be listened to. Nobody should be in that situation and no parent, no mother should be in that situation. And one of the reasons I think it is so important that we legislate for and will appoint a new independent maternity and neonatal commissioner is because this issue cannot simply be a something where a spotlight is shone on the issue at a time when we have a debate in this house or at a time when we have a new review that comes out or at a time when particular health secretaries say this is a priority. It has to be something that is always a priority for our health service because this is about the very start of a family's life.

This is about the some of the most important things that our National Health Service does. Many members have talked about miscarriage and I pay tribute to my honourable friends including my honourable friend for Aylesbury and for Morecambe and others who have talked about the importance of miscarriage care. And we are working with Tommy's to assess the findings around their miscarriage study which I do think is hugely important. And I will say that it's important that miscarriage care is also included as part of the modern services framework that we are drawing up and will be as part of and member for Cannock Chase I'm sorry who also importantly talked about the impact for his constituent around maternity about miscarriage care. That needs to be a central part of those standards and and the way in which we provide support for families in those circumstances.

08:09:56 - 08:10:58

Speaker 307

And we should never underestimate the impact that miscarriage can have at different stages in a pregnancy and the deep distress from miscarriage through to stillbirth through to the loss in neonatal care as well. That at every stage the impact that that can have on the family and also the trauma that can be caused as well and the long-lasting impact that this can have on a family. And that's why I particularly wanted to highlight the response and I many members referred to the importance of bereavement care and services as well. And we are already putting additional investment, nine million invested in bereavement suites and also seven day a week bereavement services do now need to be the standard across maternity and neonatal settings. All report trusts are reporting compliance with these services but we need to make sure that this is happening in practice.

08:10:58 - 08:18:45

Karin Smyth

And they have been funded to to provide specialist bereavement midwives but again it is crucial that those services are in place because every family needs time to grieve after losing a baby and needs that immediate support and care in place. It's why too my honourable friend for Cumbernauld referred to the importance of the employment law reforms and the bereavement leave being allowed now for pregnancy loss before twenty-four weeks because we know too the impact that that can have on families and the importance of being able to refer to provide the support at that time. And to make sure that as part of the work that we're doing now to draw up a new mental health strategy that we include as part of that the issues around postnatal depression but also the issues around bereavement and the distress and trauma that can be experienced.

My honourable friend for Ealing Southall referred particularly to the issues around inequalities. The fact that black women have an increased risk of miscarriage, stillbirth and maternal mortality. It is really just shocking and deeply distressing that in the 2020s we can face those kinds of inequalities and also that we can have seen periods in which maternal mortality for some groups and in some areas has increased. And it is crucial, this is a central issue for the maternity and neonatal taskforce and we will be setting out the targets, the progress and the action that we need to take in order to address those inequalities. The inequalities particularly around ethnicity, challenging racism, but also inequalities around deprivation as well again must be a central part of the work that we do.

Member for Godalming, the member for Morecambe also referred to some of the issues around normal birth ideology. Let me just be really clear, there is no place for any ideology anywhere in childbirth. Childbirth has to be about the mums and babies and safety and it has to be about what is right for the family. It has to be as my honourable friend has set out, it has to be about safety, it has to be about informed choice and it has to be about compassion. No mother should ever feel the pressure to have a particular kind of ideal birth to live up to because as we know all of us are different and services need to reflect that and to support that as well.

The honourable member for North Devon raised particularly the areas, the real challenges that he has been facing and that mothers have been facing, families have been facing in his constituency. And I know that he is meeting my honourable friend the national maternity and neonatal advisor later this week. Let me be clear, I've spoken several times to the NHS chief executive exactly about what is happening in North Devon, about ensuring I know that they are taking action because theirs is a workforce challenge. They are taking action to increase their recruitment but it is crucial they do so. It is completely unfair on families to be worrying at a point that they should be really looking forward to the birth of a new baby that they should be worrying about having to travel the two hours in this way because the services are not open locally.

We are looking not just at making sure that there is appropriate support in North Devon to get those services open but also at the what the workforce issues are for other rural areas where there are more remote services that are crucial and need to be sustained and provided and we will continue to look at that as part of the workforce issues around the maternity issues as well. I know there were other issues, I'm looking through my list of the points that members have made, the B-strep. We are, we have a trial underway at the moment that will report back I think within the next 12 months and the information and the evidence will go to the national screening committee to look at exactly this issue around testing.

It's a really important one that she raises, and I would thank her constituent for campaigning, who I understand has been campaigning for a very long time on this. Can I also say to my honourable friend for Lancaster and Wyre, I can give her a personal undertaking, I will absolutely follow this up directly on the baby loss certificate with the Scottish government, because it's just unthinkable that she could be left in such a distressing situation, and that other people will be in a similar distressing situation for lack of coordination between governments that frankly we should be able to do as well. But let me just, and others have made other points and forgive me if I have not covered, I recognize the important points that were, I'm keen to follow up around CPR and CPR training, also around maternity triage and around regulation and a series of important things. But some of this I want to just come back to a broader issue about my concern about the fact that it feels to me as though maternity services and neonatal services have not been taken seriously enough in the NHS and in government for too long, and have too often been treated as really a sidecar. As for many hospitals, acute trusts, they have a lot of things happening, but the maternity unit, my sense has been, has been often treated as a bit of a sidecar to the main hospital.

And that although there may be some brilliant work and support being done within that maternity unit, it's not always seen by the rest of the hospital, by the rest of the trust. And so therefore, when things go wrong, then too often too little is done. And so when mums are not listened to, when parents are not listened to, when something goes awry with the support and the care and the compassion that's needed, then there often hasn't been a strong enough action taken to make sure that something is done. And to me, that has meant in those cases, that's meant that we have mothers and babies treated as second-class patients. And mothers and babies should never be treated as second-class patients, because this is one of the most important things that our NHS does, be there at the very start of a new family's life and get this right for a new family, and it supports the family for the rest of their lives.

And so I do recognize the remarkable and wonderful care provided in many places, but I still have this strong sense that overall, our NHS has not been giving the start of life and maternity and neonatal services the priority that they really need to be given.

08:18:45 - 08:19:26

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

When she meets officials and has this discussion, I would urge her to cite what happened during the pandemic, where despite the fact that it was medically illogical, what did middle managers do in NHS hospitals? They said that women when they were coming to give birth on their own or to miscarry on their own, had to do so without their partners. And that is the very best example when people told me this is a nonsense, Alicia, stop saying that women are being treated badly in the NHS. They said, well, women have given birth for thousands of years, and women were mistreated during the pandemic and we were shown that exactly that, the maternity is a sidecar. So I say to anyone who stands in her way on this, she is absolutely right and we have the evidence in the last few years and I urge her to use it.

08:19:26 - 08:19:35

Speaker 307

I take very seriously the points the honourable member makes and I look forward to talking to her in more detail very soon as well.

08:19:35 - 08:21:28

Karin Smyth

And I think and that I think is I suppose is the wider point that I want to make. Look, there are many changes that we're trying to make, many different things we're looking at, different rules, different services. We're expanding Martha's rule to all maternity and neonatal services so there is a clear way not just for women in labor and their families but actually also for staff in maternity services and neonatal services also to be able to raise concerns, to ask for a second opinion and to make sure that we are building in that need to listen to parents, to listen to families as well. But all of this only works if it is part of that wider recognition that we have to give much greater priority to maternal and neonatal care. The final thought that I would leave people with is we obviously tonight's debate has been about baby loss and the most distressing of circumstances.

But we know that the support around childbirth, the support around loss, the support around the through maternity journey and through and into the early years, if it is really to be about giving every family that best start in life, every child that best start in life, I think those maternity services can't just be about childbirth. It's about what happens throughout maternity and it's what happens beyond in those first few years as well. And that's why I think one of the other most important things we're doing is going to be restoring the Sure Start health services to the family hubs right across the country and to start going back to that coordinated support of every all every service coming together to support families, to support babies at the very start of their life. And I thank you again to everyone who spoke in this debate.

08:21:28 - 08:21:31

Speaker 308

Andy MacNae to wind up.

08:21:31 - 08:22:50

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And and thank you, thank you to everyone that's spoken today and shared your experience. It it is not easy. And in that regard actually just reflect on a comment made by my honorable friend from Lancaster and Wyre. There are colleagues who couldn't be here today because their losses are too recent and too painful.

And so and as many others reflected, baby loss is is something that affects I think far far more of us than we actually realize. So so thank you all. And thank you to the Secretary of State for being here, for being here throughout. It does mean a lot. It really really does matter and your commitment and passion does shine through to get this right.

But we we've heard a consensus, a clear consensus across the House today about what needs to be done. I think we all need to be very clear that in a year's time, when we'll be back here in a year's time, we need to be talking about what has been done. Real, tangible, concrete actions. And to deliver that we need the resource, the institutional capacity, the leadership to actually drive that change through with the urgency and the practicality that we need. So next year, let's be celebrating what we've done, not what needs to be done.

Thank you.

08:22:50 - 08:23:21

Speaker 309

The question is as on the order papers. Many that are in favor say aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Before I go to the next set of business I'll allow the front benchers a moment to shuffle over.

08:23:21 - 08:23:32

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Walk a little bit faster. Fantastic, fantastic. Front benches are we ready? Petition Jane Kirkham.

08:23:32 - 08:24:33

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm not the first to talk about the issue of Cubert crossroads, which has defeated many people. Over a thousand people in two small villages have signed this petition. The problem is becoming worse because in the summer months, traffic volumes have increased significantly and we have far more seasonal visitors and far more new houses around the area. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urge the Government to support the campaign to ensure that Cubert crossroads has appropriate highway safety measures in place, recognizing the importance of having a safe crossroads that doesn't put road users at risk.

08:24:33 - 08:24:55

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Petition highway safety measures at Cubert crossroads. I beg to move that this House do now adjourn. The question is that this House do now adjourn. And I call Linsey Farnsworth on Government support for high streets in Amber Valley constituency. Linsey Farnsworth.

08:24:55 - 08:37:38

Linsey Farnsworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are few occasions in this place where members universally agree, but recognizing the importance of town centers to our communities is one such occasion. Which is why I'm pleased to be bringing this debate and why I'm glad that the Government is prioritizing high street regeneration. Because Madam Deputy Speaker, the sad truth is that successive governments have overseen the managed decline of high streets in former industrial and mining towns like mine. My constituents are fed up of it, and so am I.

I recently conducted a high street survey across my three towns of Alfreton, Heanor, and Ripley. The results echoed what I hear time and time again on the doorstep. Residents are frustrated by high streets they describe as run down, untidy, drab, and unloved. Many respondents felt there were too many gambling shops, barbers, and vape shops, and not enough of the businesses that help create vibrant town centers, such as clothes shops, restaurants, chemists, greengrocers, children's activity centers, farms, and especially independent local businesses. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Minister will be pleased to know that my constituents also proposed solutions to these issues.

Stronger measures to take over empty or derelict buildings, equipping small businesses to compete on a level playing field against big multinationals, reducing business rates, cracking down on unlawful businesses, encouraging variety and competition, increasing pedestrianized areas, requiring shopfronts to be cleaned up, repainted, and repaired, and of course, the famous one, free parking in town centers. From my side, I'm partnering with local business leaders to set up an Alfreton Town Centre Taskforce, and I'm meeting with Ripley Traders Association and Heanor Vision to discuss how we can address these concerns and implement some of my constituents' ideas. I'd be grateful if the Minister could address those ideas in his remarks and outline the very welcome steps that I know he is taking in this area to tackle some of these persistent issues.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the government's commitment to giving communities the power and resources that they need to drive this change forward is welcome. It builds on the excellent work of my town and parish councils, including the beautiful flower displays that bring pride and colour to our high streets in Amber Valley. But civic pride alone cannot undo years of neglect. Successive governments have overlooked former industrial towns and left the East Midlands facing an estimated 11.4 billion pound investment gap. Now Amber Valley needs meaningful investment to modernize our high streets and ensure they're not just attractive, but sustainable for the future.

Last night, my youngest son and I went to the cinema to see The Uprising, a film, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I would highly recommend. But in Amber Valley, the real uprising took place in 1817, when men left Pentrich village in what became the last armed uprising in England, driven by a feeling of being overlooked and taken for granted. Nearly a century later, fed-up miners at Alfreton Colliery led the national coal strike of 1912, helping secure the first minimum wage for coal miners. Those defining moments are still commemorated on information boards and in our town centers, at Ripley's fish and chip shop and Alfreton's Moot Bar. Now why, Madam Deputy Speaker, do I recount those events this evening?

Well, because the people of Amber Valley still feel that our communities are overlooked. Not for lack of ambition, not for lack of effort or ideas, but because investment has too often gone elsewhere. Yet the determination to turn things around is clear. Our borough council, town and parish councils, businesses and community groups have devised projects that can create jobs, strengthen our town centers and grow the local economy. I'll champion them every step of the way, but they need investment to become a reality.

So let me turn to some of these now. First, as the minister will be well aware, I've been pressing the government for government funding to support the borough in delivering an ambitious regeneration of Alfreton town center. The vision is of a revamped pedestrianized area around Institute Lane, outside seating in Severn Square, and a lively daytime and nighttime offering. The potential of this was brought home to me recently when I was lucky enough to be invited to Alfreton Town Football Club to meet some of the brilliant volunteers who keep the club running. Madam Deputy Speaker, if my club Everton is the people's club, then Alfreton Town FC should certainly be known as the community's club.

The atmosphere, players, volunteers, staff and fans were phenomenal, and I came away in awe of them and their sense of togetherness. As I traveled home, I reflected on how a revitalized town center could become an integral part of the matchday experience. Breakfast at Naughty but Nice cafe before kickoff, celebrating a victory in Severn Square, or warming up over a coffee with Dominique at the Hive Lounge after a cold winter's match. I hope the minister will outline today what support and investment the government can provide to bring this project to life. It would make a tangible difference to my constituents and show that Amber Valley's future is worth investing in.

A second project I'm supporting is the regeneration of the Premier Electric Theatre in Somercotes.

Built in 1912, it has served as a theatre, cinema, and bingo hall. But today, after many years, it stands empty and is decaying. Yet its potential remains enormous. With the right support, it could once again provide a home for local theatre, live music, cinema screenings, arts activities, and become a hub for community life and a catalyst for regeneration. Somercotes Parish Council and Save the Premier community group deserve great credit for developing that vision.

However, with a planning application which includes permission to demolish the building due to be considered in the coming months, time is short. The immediate priority is securing £21,000 for a feasibility study to assess the building's future and unlock access to larger funding streams. So I say gently to the Minister, if there's £21,000 to be found down the back of these green benches this evening, it could make all the difference. For Whitehall, it's a modest sum. For Somercotes, it could determine whether a valued part of our community's heritage is preserved or lost forever.

Now, in a similar vein, there's a project in Heanor which I've discussed with the Minister previously. Amber Valley Borough Council brought forward an ambitious vision for the regeneration of Heanor town centre, but that vision had to be scaled back when funding from the previous government fell significantly short of what was required. Rather than abandon the project altogether, the borough adapted, contributed £1 million of council resources, and ensured that regeneration could still proceed. The result is a transformed marketplace and the beautiful restoration of the historic grammar school building. Yet the overall project remains unfinished.

The Borough Council still owns the adjacent science block, which was originally intended to be transformed into a cinema. Crucially, that cinema would have generated the revenue needed to cover the running costs and long-term maintenance of the grammar. Instead, the science block remains vacant and derelict, standing as an ugly reminder of the gap between what the community expected and what was ultimately able to be delivered. I know that some people in Heanor are angry, and I understand why. They were presented with a bold vision for their town, including extensive community use of the grammar.

But when the funding was reduced and the science block regeneration couldn't proceed, the income stream that would have sustained the grammar was lost. As a result, difficult decisions had to be made. To secure the future of the building, a substantial proportion of the grammar is now to be occupied by a long-term tenant whose rental income will safeguard this important heritage asset for generations to come. Now, that is a sensible and responsible solution, but it's not the outcome that residents were initially led to expect, and it means the level of community usage is more limited than originally envisaged. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm angry too.

Not at Amber Valley Borough Council, which did everything possible to save the project. Nor at those who have made the difficult but necessary decisions to secure the building's future. I'm angry that a community with ambition, a credible plan, and strong local support was forced to accept a diminished version of its vision because the funding required to deliver it was cut by the last government. I'm angry that local people were left with a restored building but without a fully realised community asset that they expected.

And I'm angry that the council was forced to choose between scrapping part of their vision or risking losing it altogether. But now we have an opportunity to put that right. And that's why I believe that Heanor is exactly the sort of place the newly announced Derelict Buildings Fund was created to help. The borough council owns the building. The plans exist.

The local support is there. The need is clear. Like my son and I, families have to travel outside of Amber Valley to see films because there isn't a single cinema in any of the three towns in the constituency. What is required now is the investment to bring the science block back into use, complete regeneration of the site, and finally deliver the full potential that the people of Heanor deserve. So I ask the Minister, how can communities access the Derelict Buildings Fund or similar support?

And what will he do to ensure that places which have too often been overlooked, like Amber Valley, are prioritized for investment? As the Minister is aware, the recent closure of Denby Pottery, which had operated in my constituency for over 200 years, has caused a significant economic shock, with 350 jobs lost in the constituency and the loss of around 250,000 visitors to the pottery village per year. Its closure has been deeply felt by my constituents. Investment in our high streets would go a long way. It would support Amber Valley communities and businesses and help us rebuild from this social and economic scarring.

So, Madam Deputy Speaker, now is the time for the government to step in and show my constituents that Amber Valley matters. I know that the Prime Minister understands areas like mine and wants to put them at the heart of his agenda. And so, with the high streets strategy imminent, I hope that Amber Valley will finally receive the long-overdue investment that it deserves. Thank you.

08:37:38 - 08:43:28

Jim McMahon

Minister, Minister Jim McMahon.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to my honorable friend, the member for Amber Valley, for securing this important debate and for the passionate way that she continues to champion the community that she represents in Amber Valley. I really believe that she was a fantastic champion on the Denby issue. And I think all of us who care about our heritage, care about those good skilled working-class jobs, really mourned its loss. And I think the way that she continues to fight to say that isn't the end of the community that is there and actually we need to see investment in the future, I think is really important.

So I welcome this opportunity to set out the government's approach to supporting high streets, both in Amber Valley and across the country. High streets matter because they are far more than just places to shop. They are where people meet friends, visit local businesses, access services, and spend time together. When a high street succeeds, it can lift confidence in a place and support local economic growth. But when it struggles, the impact is felt across the whole community.

And that is why the government has made this a priority. I know that Amber Valley's towns and communities have felt many of the same pressures seen across the country. Changes in shopping habits, vacant premises, crime and anti-social behavior, the increasing challenge of attracting investment have all had an impact on our town centers. Yet there are also real strengths to build on, including proud local businesses, active communities, and a strong sense of local identity. Amber Valley has been a recipient of regeneration funding, including the Heanor area that received 8.59 million through the Future High Streets Fund, supporting improvements that she referenced in her speech to the marketplace for the restoration of the former grammar school and plan for a new town center housing.

Those investments demonstrate the role regeneration can play in preserving heritage, improving places, and encouraging future growth. But it's quite clear that her ambition goes even further into Alfreton and beyond, and I thought the Somercotes Theatre that she made reference to is a fantastic example and hopefully I'll give her some hope to potentially that she might be able to apply to. Because the government is making high streets a priority. On the 27th of September, we announced 210 million pound to bring derelict buildings back into use, to tackle vacancy and support community ownership and control. We're introducing reforms that will benefit high streets across the country and we're tackling long-term vacancy through the high street rental auctions.

These powers enable councils to bring persistently vacant properties back into use and make town center premises more accessible to businesses and the community. More than 40 authorities are already using these new powers and have brought over 80 properties back into use. And to accelerate delivery, we've announced a further 10 million pound to support councils and a review of New Burdens funding payments to ensure that councils have the resources that they need to implement these powers quickly. We're also empowering communities to take greater role in shaping their local high streets. Through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, we've introduced a new community right to buy, helping local people take ownership of valued community assets such as pubs, shops, and community buildings when they're at risk of being lost.

We also are acting to tackle the issues that too often undermine confidence in our town centers, for instance, through a 13 million pound crackdown on high street organized crime, stronger closure powers, and the creation of a dedicated high streets organized crime unit, we're supporting legitimate businesses and helping communities take back control of their high streets. Because we know that retail crime remains a significant concern for local businesses. And that's why in addition to the other measures, we through the Crime and Policing Act, we introduced a new offense of assaulting a retail worker and we've removed the 200 pound threshold for shop theft, making it clear that all shop theft is unacceptable and will be treated seriously. We're also supporting business directly and have introduced permanently lower business rate multipliers for eligible businesses, hospitality and leisure properties. Alongside additional support for pubs and live music venues.

We have also legislated a ban to ban upward-only rent reviews in commercial leases, helping to create a fairer and more flexible commercial property market that supports investment and reduces the risk of long-term empty properties. Alongside this, the Business Growth Service is helping small and medium-sized businesses access finance, advice, support to start, grow and invest, ensuring that local businesses can continue to play their vital role at the heart of our town centers. We recognize that communities want attractive high streets that reflect local character. And that is why we're giving councils stronger powers to address the clustering of vape shops and gambling premises and supporting better standards for shopfronts and for public open spaces. However, we know there is more to do.

Later this year we'll publish a new high street strategy, setting out our longer-term plan for supporting businesses, bringing back life into our town centers and helping communities to shape the future of their high streets. The strategy is being developed in partnership with businesses, civic leaders and local communities because we know that thriving high streets cannot be delivered by central government alone. Our ambition is clear: high streets that are safe, that are vibrant, that are economically successful, places where people want to invest, and importantly, places that local people can be proud of. I know my honorable friend will continue to make the case for Amber Valley as that work progresses, and I welcome her contribution to this conversation and all her hard work, and I hope that we can meet soon to share the future success of the projects that she's mentioned.

08:43:28 - 08:43:38

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as that opinion say aye. Aye. As many as that opinion say aye. Aye.

The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.