Defence Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Defence Committee House of Commons
Follow its sittingsJulian David
Last time we were here, Chair, we did report on our survey of members and they were saying, you know, the market, 73% of them said the market's declined since the report. That was in May. Funding delays, reductions at 87% of the respondents. And 93% of them are now reassessing investment or recruitment of people to focus in this sector.
97%.
Julian David
Yeah, 93%. So, you know, this is causing us the problem, particularly from an SME point of view, is they live off the cash flow and if there is no cash flow or no predictable path to cash, then, you know, they're going to either try and find markets elsewhere or they're going to cut back and wait and see. We've checked again with them since that survey and I have to say there haven't really seen a lot of progress. And I would highlight the fact that in terms of delivery, the MOD are still not properly staffed in order to deal with procurement and particularly procurement of new things and from smaller companies.
You know, so and sometimes that's disguised. So, you know, one commercial team's headcount is 70%, let's say, so a gap of 30%. But 40% of the team is filled by contractors who cannot actually fulfill the whole process to sign off authority. So this is a real challenge, and it's being reported by members that way. I would echo Kevin's point about the clarity of when is spend, you know, how much is actual spend, is it committed, when is it going to come.
Again, we see that the spread of it does depend on a few things. Even if that spread is even, it's we're still waiting for the budget to say whether or not, hopefully the fact that the previous Defence Secretary is now the Chancellor will help with that. There's a dependency on capital cuts elsewhere, which, you know, may or may not happen, and there's a gap still. So yes, we all want efficiencies and we do want a shift to new types of procurement, faster procurement, but that's a problem. And one of the other things I need to highlight is the change in security clearances, which is having a real effect because of the change of the way it's done on the sponsoring.
Julian David
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's affecting small businesses, but also affecting large businesses, I'm sure colleagues can talk about that as well. You know, with people losing 1,600 clearances, SMEs having to reapply because their sponsor route has gone. This is a cross-government issue, but clearly very important in defence. And I think you mentioned the international context and the shift from a transatlantic to an Atlantic and a channel across.
And if you think about tech and dual use, which is really close to defence tech, things like the European Cloud AI Development Act, which builds on the safe exclusion to actually say non-EU companies cannot supply dual-use technology, cloud technology, AI technology in the EU. That obviously affects the exporting capability of our industry, which is a big blow to the economy, but also affects the capacity and the resilience of the industry that's based here and will encourage them to look elsewhere as well.
Lincoln Jopp
So the figures that you were quoting in terms of your survey, were they very much asking the question about their relations with MOD? Because we see a lot of we go around, you know, particularly in the High North where we've just been, you know, focusing. And we've got countries out there spending like drunken sailors on shore leave. Are they spending that with your members? And notwithstanding what you just said about the AI bit at the end.
Julian David
Yes, that's happening, but equally we have international members who came here to invest and they are not seeing the resulting pathway to growth and business. And so they are also saying, well, maybe I made the wrong decision to come and expand in the UK and perhaps I should retrench and go elsewhere.
And I think that's... you know, we're not in favor of a buy British approach because we think that just reinforces all the challenges that our industry, which is very international, would have. But we are very much in favor of looking at capability in the UK and and encouraging new capability to flourish here with support for exports, which are essential.
Arnab Dutt
Thank you. And it's good to have the opportunity to talk about the the wider environment of SMEs, not just those who are already on defense pipelines. So speaking directly, our view of the DIP, the publication of the Defense Investment Plan, was a really welcome step towards transparency. But it's very high level. The long-term equipment plans don't really provide viable commercial signals to small businesses outside of the defense perimeter.
Okay, so we're really concerned about how MOD looks beyond that horizon and looks ahead at the environment because again, we are very concerned, we echo my two colleagues here, Julian and Kevin, we're concerned about capacity and capability building. So the fixed pipeline documents fail to drive SME engagement effectively. So I'll give you a little a few figures from our own research. Only 13% of small businesses use pipeline documentation to find public opportunities, compared to 28% use active procurement platforms. That means the vast majority aren't even looking.
So there's a question about pre-engagement and engagement with the external SME supply chain. Three-fifths, that's 62% of small businesses, are looking for public sector contracts but report that finding suitable opportunities is incredibly difficult. And so demonstrating a that a passive publication of equipment will do anything to improve that situation is is rather fanciful in our opinion. Contracts stemming to stemming from DIPs certainly will continue to flow exclusively to SMEs already on those supply chains and to the prime contractors. And so far, I have to say as an organization, we've had minimal consultation on the DIP with MOD, which has been really disappointing because it doesn't give us the opportunity to to help MOD and give them advice and support.
Speaker 10
So that has been our our main bugbear with this process and with the with the public since the publication of the DIP.
Lincoln Jopp
I can't remember, it was about when you last came here that MOD were talking about the launch of their SME hub or something like that. Has that... is that real or is that just another all hat and no cattle?
Arnab Dutt
I mean, it may have happened, but we certainly don't know much about it because the engagement has been incredibly sparse and really, you know, we've had no cadence, we've been given no notification. All of those all of those things were promised by MOD that we'd be able to engage in a timely manner. That hasn't happened.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Just to say we will be coming back into detail on this, gents, just towards the end of the meeting, we will be having a specific section just on the Defense Office for Small Business Growth. So yeah, just hold your thoughts there. Carry on please, Arnab.
Arnab Dutt
Sorry, yeah, Arnab. And I was about to say another awful piece of I suppose research is that companies that have already engaged with MOD, 19% of them said they won't be doing so again because of the systemic barriers and just the level of hard work and engagement, which could be 19% of them, they could be some brilliant businesses there.
So that's another issue.
Stephen Phipson
I suppose the answer is patchy. So we see a slightly different perspective on that. DIP has, I mean, welcome in many respects, particularly around the autonomy brief and what's happening with bringing in SMEs into the innovation part of it. We see a number of actions that are happening, which we see different behaviors coming from MOD at the moment. I mean, I would cite things like the energetics program, the low-cost one-way effectors, what we're doing with drones, where we've actually brought in not only defense suppliers, but also because we've got a very wide brief in Make UK around the whole of manufacturing, non-traditional defense suppliers coming into those sorts of development activities with the MOD.
So that is a change of behavior and that's something worth noting to give them some credit. But it's a very small part of what's outlined in the DIP. And you know, the point we get from many of the companies is you can't invest in press releases. We need detail and we need funding and we need to make that work. But in the number of those projects where they have focused, we definitely have seen a change in behavior there and bringing in lots of new SMEs into the supply chain.
The point I would make is that a lot of the SMEs are doing very well on the export market. To your point about everyone spending like drunken sailors, I think you said, but we're seeing a lot of that. So a lot of them are doing really well with lots of innovative technologies going out and exporting to European defense authorities and seeing it very slow from the UK perspective. The other point I would say is that we've had a lot of manufacturing companies who are not normally defense companies wanting to enter the market. And we have a big service helping them to make that transition and they, I mean, it's very difficult.
Once there's a lot of enthusiasm, but then there's no direct funding, there's no orders, there's no requirement. So we do have the enthusiasm to do it in terms of supplying and fulfilling the DIP, but we do need to see some certainty to get it delivered. But there is some pockets there, I would just push back a little bit and say there are some pockets where the MOD has changed behavior.
Lincoln Jopp
So one thing which I don't think will be covered later to the chair's point is, you know, the MOD, we know, puts massive barriers to entry to SMEs to do business. Have we seen any change in the behaviors of the primes towards their SMEs to the good or the bad? Because in my view, our model needs totally reworking. Having 18 primes doesn't work for me. But have we seen any tangible change in, and it won't be by all primes, it might be by one or two primes, about the way in which they are investing in or not their relationship with their SMEs who are crucial to their business?
Kevin Craven
Broadly, you have seen some incremental improvements. Some of the primes are stepping up, so improved payment terms, direct account management for smaller primes, easier routes to entry. But feel free to name the ones who are doing well. So I mean, I'd probably call out Lockheed Martin, for example, as someone who's had a prompt payment code for a long time. But there are others such as BAE and Babcock who are building better routes for SMEs as we speak.
But it's patchy, in fairness. But some of that does relate back to the lack of longer-term certainty from the MOD in terms of 10-year programs that then they are unable to pass that certainty onto the supply chain. And the capacity of both the primes and the MOD to respond to those small businesses remains low, is my view.
Julian David
I think I would add to that, it's not that primes don't want to work with SMEs. I'm sure Stephen and Arnab can give examples of that. But the procurement environment and the way things are happening does sort of push towards going through the prime rather than getting directly to the SMEs. And of course that potentially excludes a lot of innovation. You know, it's even in the numbers of the, you know, seven and a half billion SME spend by May 2028, of which only two billion is direct and five point five is going to be indirect.
And the procedure to actually check on this is sort of tracking rather than committing and delivering. We have said many times what's needed here are targets for the people actually doing the procurement and KPIs and then measuring progress against that, as opposed to waiting until the end of 2028 and then say, did it happen or not?
Well, yes.
Julian David
And the other thing I would just point out is MOD has also chosen to use a different definition of SME than is generally the...
It's 250 employees, isn't it?
Yes, but different from the Procurement Act and Fair Payment Code. So SMEs who are used to reporting that way have now got to report another way. And it doesn't seem to make any sense.
Emma Lewell
Thank you, Chair. Morning all. I was just wondering, we're coming up to, I think, about a year since the National Armaments Director was appointed and he assured me in this committee that things would improve and procurement would get better within the first year. How do you feel it has?
Julian David
If I go first. I think the plan is good. The intentions are good. We submitted to the Defense Investment Joint Council a significant, there's a 30-point series of things that we thought would make a big difference here. And the National Armaments Director agreed to adopt pretty much all of them.
What I would come back to, though, is if we don't actually have granularity behind the DIP, so what is it they're actually going to do and when are they going to do it at a granular level of procurement? And if we don't actually track performance, then I think we're probably not going to see that. And then the second thing is the difficulty of addressing the gaps in capability within MOD procurement, they seem to be very challenged.
Emma Lewell
Just on the back of your answer there, that's come in. Have you heard rumors about the DIP implementation plan? Have you seen it? Do you know what it is? Because we don't.
October, is it?
Kevin Craven
Yes, I mean, so we're engaging with each of the frontline commands in terms of a program of consultation about unpacking the DIP and the implementation thereof. So to be fair to the frontline commands, they too have some of the lack of certainty that is required around that implementation plan and the pace at which it's going to go. You know, so the NAT group is, which is the total aggregation of departments that now report into Rupert Pearce, is some 25,000 people. And in parallel with the announcement of the DIP and implementation of SDR is defense reform going on. So the challenge of transforming your department whilst implementing a gigantic strategic shift is causing large amounts of pain within that department.
So I think there is still some way to go in terms of the implementation being granular, transparent, and obvious to industry.
Stephen Phipson
I think I would say that it's all too slow is the problem. I mean we're being told in the media and on constantly that we're under threat and 2030 is a key date. And and the way things are going at the moment is if there's another delay in the spending review to finding the money for the DIP. I mean we're not talking factories are not built overnight. People have to do investment plans and we have to build capability.
Some of the changes in behaviour have been good but they're minimal. They're mainly on the new capability. If we see what's happening on autonomous and we mentioned things like you know cheap one-way effectors, that sort of stuff. That's good. That's a different way of doing things with non-traditional defence suppliers.
But it's tiny compared to what we need to do. So I think the overriding sense is one of speed and pace and delivery and moving forwards quickly. I think that would be one message to take from this.
Speaker 29
I mean have you since since the publication of the DIP have you seen any significant contracts being awarded?
Julian David
A few, a few is the answer. We've seen a few.
Yeah and and some of them are as Stephen said in in the new areas but and and techUK's very keen to support that and we have had engagement and hosted members with MOD officials now. But we are talking you know relatively small amounts of of money and relatively small programs.
Emma Lewell
And do you think when when contracts are awarded do you think they're too concentrated in the South East and the South West? I mean the government wants good growth in every postcode and wants defence to be an engine for growth in every region but it seems to all just get concentrated in the same regions time and time again is my view. You might disagree.
Stephen Phipson
Well we obviously we have national coverage and we've got thousands of companies all around the UK. So so we do see clusters of technology. At the moment the North East is doing very well with technology, cyber in defence for example in the North East is very strong. And it depends where the existing pockets of capability are. But I wouldn't say there's a particular concentration in that in that respect.
We are seeing some good effects. We're also seeing some very interesting new stuff happening with the automotive sector around the West Midlands in defence where there's a lot of interest in using their capability. But it's early days yet. I mean in terms of large contracts we haven't seen that.
Okay.
Kevin Craven
I was just going to say the spend per head figures per region that the MOD used to publish but have either slowed down or not published those remain broadly the same. So you know the South West and the South East still significant areas, regions like Northern Ireland particularly and Scotland less so.
Julian David
I would say again if you know if you have the traditional spending relationships then you will risk reinforcing that. The tech industry does have a bias to certain parts of the country. There's a lot in in the London and South East area but there's also a lot in in Cambridge, Manchester, a lot up in in Newcastle and obviously in Scotland as well. So it's entirely possible to spread it but if the relationships stay with the current players then you know that will leave the concentrations where they are.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Right thank you very much.
Right, let's now go on to the level of detail within and the funding of the 2026 Defence Investment Plan and let's kickstart things with Ian Room.
Speaker 30
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, a long, long, long way, the SDR was published in June 25 and then the DIP was going to come that autumn. And we waited. And we waited. And we waited even blooming longer, didn't we, until June 26.
Ian Roome
So how useful, you alluded to it, Kevin, earlier on, how does for industry the DIP compare to the equipment plans and does it provide enough detail and confidence to you or do you prefer, would you have preferred something similar to keep the equipment plan?
Kevin Craven
There are things in the DIP that are welcome and the focus on the industrial context and capacity is useful and helpful in terms of building the resilience that we need. But the focus of the DIP is very much on the first four-year period to 2029, whereas the Defence Equipment Plan used to focus on a granular acquisition pipeline over 10 years. So we can see the rough shape of the DIP is around 50-55% of the total spend over the 10-year period, so some spend has been brought forward to improve the readiness of what we are doing, but there is not enough granularity to provide certainty to industry. So intent is not the same as a commitment that is suitable for investors in defence.
Stephen Phipson
Well, I mean, having done this a long time, to say the least, and there's not, as Kevin said, there is not sufficient detail. It's nothing like an equipment plan. There is, this is not investable as it stands at the moment. It gives you a thematic direction of travel in many areas, a lot of which is welcome, which is great news, attracts a lot of new companies into the market. But then the question is where's the contracts, where's the program, where's the procurement, and we haven't got that yet, and that's the problem.
Julian David
I would say a good thing about the DIP is as the point Kevin made, which is it is a more comprehensive view of what's needed, which came from the SDR as you say, and that's very welcome. We would like to see that extended actually to a shift towards software-defined procurement. We really think that equipment purchases, standalone equipment purchases, do not work very well in the modern defence environment. But we'd also like to see within the plan now the granularity and specificity and also responsibility. You know, we see the DIP delivery plan, I think awareness is low, and the National Armaments Director has confirmed they are converting it into a more granular plan coming in October, I believe.
But, you know, does that then have the program-level funding, the dates, route to market, and also I come back to my point, if you read through the SME action plan, it's a cautionary tale. It says "we" throughout, no owners, no KPIs, and just the one target date, then we'll all wait until after 2028 to find out whether it worked.
Arnab Dutt
So, I mean, can I add to that? You know, to send out demand signals to the broader supply chain, we need far more information and then following on from that, a plan around actual engagement, regional and countrywide engagement. And that will be probably the process that begins to open up opportunities for SMEs as they get ready. That's the real demand signal if they actually see that coming down the line, and that isn't in there.
Julian David
I'd also like to point out this costs the country money because delay in an inflationary context, and particularly in tech and availability crisis of certain components, just means that what you are going to do costs more when you get round to doing it.
Ian Roome
So, the MOD Director General for Commercial and Industry says that he has had a really positive response from industry to the DIP and the demand signal it sets out. Is that the feedback that you're getting from your members?
Julian David
A really positive response to the DIP. It's a good plan, but what we now need to see is the detail and the commitments.
Kevin Craven
It's a strategic plan. It's not a detailed granular plan as we were used to with the acquisition pipeline that was represented by the 10-year equipment plan.
Kevin Craven
No is the short answer, I think, in that there's a clear shift in strategic direction, and we've talked about autonomy and other changes in terms of that, particularly I would call out frontier AI and other things. Thank you very much. But the lack of certainty over that 10-year period is a real problem. So headlines don't make for good investment.
Ian Roome
And just your views, how damaging would it be if the next spending review failed to provide a firm funded pathway towards 3% of GDP on defence? Would industry still invest on the strength of the current DIP?
Stephen Phipson
Well, the answer is no. They won't. They're only going to invest when there's certainty in what the program looks like, and we've seen this for decades in defence. It's got to be around a certain program. So the thematics we've got are all good and welcome, and so to your earlier point about industry welcome, of course they welcome the new technologies and the new innovation.
But until we see certainty, no one's going to invest a penny. You need to see where those contracts are going to come from, and we will play with all the innovation work that's happening with the MOD. That's good. But what we do need to do is start building factories and capability. It's what we need to do.
Julian David
I also think the fact we've had certain deadlines that have either not been met or when they've arrived have been met in a very summary level is a learned behavior, and contrast that with other geographies that are spending, then you do have that open question why invest here.
Arnab Dutt
Can I echo Julian as well? We have some brilliant firms, especially in some of our tech clusters, and they are finding opportunities abroad and in Europe because those countries around the Baltics, Northern Europe, are getting on with it because they see the threat as imminent. And if their capacity is taken up, even though they'd love to be working here, we're going to lose out. So the risk to us in terms of capability over the next few years by not addressing this, getting that granularity and actually funding it properly, is potentially very, very dangerous in my opinion.
Kevin Craven
It is low numbers. There are companies that are leaving, and both the US and Europe are representing more attractive defence markets at the moment.
Ian Roome
So if I could just leave my question, Mr. Chair, on one question to each to each. If you could sort out one thing from the MOD today regarding this particular area of the DIP, what would you say they need to do urgently that your members require?
Kevin Craven
I'm going to take two things if I may, but rapid procurement. We have a number of rapid procurement routes that work and Commercial X has done some good work in this space, but also resource the Office for Small Business Growth. There are four people in that office versus the 29 that is suggested as being appropriate.
Julian David
So I would echo that, you know, the contracting backlog really does need to be sorted out, otherwise how can we contract new stuff as well? And it really to encourage investment, we've got to have, you know, the plan is multi-year, we've got to have a delivery plan which is multi-year, which is granular, and which signals the, you know, the implementation of the SDR.
Arnab Dutt
I think the granularity is really, really important, but I want to echo what Kevin said. We do have fantastic exemplars of super practice of speedy procurement where, you know, barriers have been removed and Commercial X is one of them, it's been running since 2022. Now, if MOD was able to use that as an exemplar across the, you know, the wider field of MOD procurement, that would be a great start. It's not like reinventing the wheel. We're doing it really well.
Speaker 36
That project is incredibly successful in giving SMEs contracts. So use it. Use the exemplar.
Stephen Phipson
So two things from my perspective. One is to echo the points about funding certainty. That's going to drive investment, people being clear about when things are required and what they're going to cost. But there is a wider point I'd just like to make about manufacturing in this country, which is something we've been talking to the Chancellor about. In fact, Julian and I were with the Chancellor this morning on this very subject, is that we are losing a lot of companies now because it's uncompetitive to be here to manufacture goods.
And that's because of the energy cost in the UK. So this year we've had an enormous flight of businesses out of the UK. In particular, larger companies are finding it hard to allocate capital to UK capability because it's much better, the maths works better if you do it in France and Germany than it does in the UK. So it's very difficult to just isolate that to the MOD, but there is a wider issue about competitiveness of manufacturing in this country, which to be fair to the Chancellor, I think he recognized this morning as a key issue for growth.
Julian David
And I would sort of just also echo the number of companies that are actually saying, okay, we're not going to be here anymore, we're going to be somewhere else is low, but what they are doing is shifting emphasis and investment money elsewhere. And again, back to the sovereignty point, if we do get into a buy British, buy European, buy US, then that is going to mean, given the relative spends of those markets, that there'd be more emphasis on companies shifting their entire locus to one of those geographic entities.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Thank you very much. Well, let's move on to the funding profile. That's been set out in the Defence Investment Plan, but it sees that majority of that investment appear after 2030. So backloading, that's something that we as a committee raised with the Secretary of State and the Permanent Secretary just last week during our session. My question to yourself is, is there sufficient capacity within the UK defence industry to bring any of that planned investment forward if required?
Kevin Craven
Um, there is, we have great underlying capacity in the UK and as has already been mentioned, you know, other sectors interested like automotive as well as we're seeing in other international comparators like Germany. So, but you cannot switch on industrial capacity and production lines overnight. You need a strong demand signal over a long number of years to be able to do so. So a ramp up towards the back end of a period is not actually helpful. What it does is creates a future bottleneck where firms will compete for the necessary skills, moneys and other industrial requirements at the same time.
So it's not a helpful profile in any way.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
But basically what you're saying is there is sufficient capacity to bring some of that investment forward or not?
Kevin Craven
With advanced warning there's sufficient capability to build the capacity we need. But, you know, to build a brand new production line from scratch will take between two and four years depending on what we're talking about. At the moment we're not seeing sufficient certainty to enable that investment to take place.
Julian David
The UK has a, you know, really large and capable tech industry, both indigenous and also people from other countries that have invested here. And so in one sense there's no capacity issue, it could respond. I think the challenge has been that they do need a plan and they set those plans and they know what they're going to invest in, particularly smaller companies. And if you don't have sight, as Kevin has said, of when that capacity is actually going to be potentially productive, that's quite hard to do. So, yes, I mean, I think we could do an awful lot more on some of the newer technology areas.
The other thing to watch out for is the bottlenecks that are going to happen to components. They're already happening to components such as memory and processors and there will be other bottlenecks. So again, having a plan where people can procure ahead of time is incredibly helpful to them.
Arnab Dutt
You know, we believe there is. I think adopting the dual capacity that they've done in Northern Europe and the Baltics states is a really good exemplar of how you can do it. But again, you need time, access to finance and the right type of investment. What we worry about is the problem we have already in the economy, which is the ability to source skilled labour. And we think again that's where the bottleneck's going to occur and it's something we really have to address, especially if we want to act quickly, because it's already a real problem for many small companies, manufacturing, engineering and tech companies.
Stephen Phipson
So I would say that we don't lack capacity at all. We certainly have it there. We have thousands of SMEs which are exporting defence technology at the moment to other nations. Would much rather be doing that with their own MOD, I can tell you from first-hand experience. And we have some large sectors under pressure at the moment as well, Chairman, like automotive, where we have 600,000 people employed and we have capacity.
And every single one of those is members of MakeUK and all of them would love to be doing much more in defence to fill some of that capacity. So it's there. It's a matter of bringing it together, sending clear demand signals about where the investment's needed and funding it properly.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Good, so the message is clear from industry is that rather than backloading, let's have a clear demand signal right here and now and let's get on with actually producing. Right, let me come on to another part of the second part of my question, which is around the additional 15 billion pound which has been provided to defence.
Do you think that it's sufficient and does it concern you that it's reliant on efficiency savings? We've had this out in the Public Accounts Committee as well when I guest-ed on there. But, you know, are you concerned about that, that money may or may not materialize given it's based on efficiency savings and, you know, that's going to be have to be found in this month's budget? Should we start off with yourself, Mr. Craven?
Kevin Craven
We are concerned. The MOD has a long history of baking in efficiency savings to its plans and then not necessarily being able to deliver them. So the commitment to deliver those is not the same thing as doing so. One of the interesting things about the DIP was the central contingencies held by the MOD was increased from one point two percent up to two percent over the spending period, which is indicative of perhaps some of their own cynicism around the ability to deliver those efficiencies and savings. Again, just the complexity of delivering defence reform at the same time as implementing a huge shift in capability towards new warfare areas is a very complex thing to do.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Good. Basically we've seen this movie before and it doesn't quite end as well as some would wish. Anybody else want to come in on this particular point?
Julian David
Yes, I would. You know, obviously we're waiting to see. We think nearly five billion is dependent on the budget. And obviously there was some potential confusion about is the budget actually going to do that or will they wait to the spending review? In our view that would be a very big mistake and compound the delays we've already highlighted.
I echo the point about efficiency savings. Will they arrive? And actually does that mean it's new money? Depends where the savings are made from. If they cut some other parts of capital, is that really saving or is that just shifting money around?
And still some we don't see clarity on it being funded.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Yeah. I mean, when Lord Robertson appeared before us, he said that out of the fifteen billion, according to him, only around eleven billion of that was actually new money. So there's a considerable concern. But let's see what the Chancellor is going to enlighten us with. Mr. Phipson, you wanted to come in on that?
Stephen Phipson
The other point I would make is around the previous spending review, the difference between CDEL and RDEL and what's happening there. The CDEL number increased by seventy-five percent in the ten years, but RDEL only by point seven percent. And of course that means cutting things like training and all the other support services, which is very concerning if you look at that mix. I don't know if the committee's had a chance to look at that in some detail, but something else we just wanted to point you in that direction of.
Arnab Dutt
Yeah, we've discussed that as well in terms of RDEL versus CDEL. Mr. Dutt, do you want to come in before I move on?
Speaker 43
I mean, we love the ambition, but the proof of the pudding will be in the eating. And I think everyone's said more or less the same thing. So let's see what happens.
Speaker 45
Right, we're all singing from the same hymn sheet. Right, brilliant. On to Emma Lewell-Buck.
Emma Lewell
Welcome. In your dealings with government and different departments, what do you currently think the status of the relationship is between the MOD and the Treasury?
Julian David
Well, it should be a lot better now that we've got the ex-Defence Secretary as the Chancellor. So we definitely got the impression from the Chancellor this morning that he understands the need for a transition in defence spending.
So that was encouraging for the tech industry to hear.
I guess we're going to see in the budget, aren't we?
Kevin Craven
Yes. Look, I think nobody would welcome the shift on certainty in defence spending towards the CSR and then question marks about whether the CSR or the defence spending element of that being delivered in spring next year or autumn next year. If that rumour is correct, that is very unwelcome. So...
Kevin Craven
No. So I think the relationship has actually improved given the Chancellor's direct knowledge of the problems that defence has faced. The ability for him to then fund the resources necessary to fix those problems is actually the question rather than just the relationship, which has been unhelpful in the past.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Thank you. Well, look, the Defence Committee has very, very forthrightly for a considerable amount of time now put out a statement to say we need to reach 3% of GDP spent on defence by the end of this Parliament. I've forthrightly made that point on the floor of the House as well recently as well as before. Unfortunately, we're in a situation where we're now having to wait until next year's spending review, which we're led to believe may actually come now in the autumn of next year, to get that clear pathway to 3%. In your perspective, is that too late for industry to respond to the demand signal?
Stephen Phipson
Absolutely too late. I think we're, you know, again, we're all working to this idea that we've got some a severe threat in front of us by 2030, I think is the current number. And, you know, the investment cycles in building capability are quite lengthy. You know, if we decide now, it is, as we said before, two to four years, perhaps even five years, depending on the capability, to get that up and running to put it into FOC. So I would say that you need to start now.
We need to see that now. We need to bring that forward and not another, that would effectively be another two-year delay in the process.
Mr David?
Julian David
It's really is having a material and deleterious effect. And that, you know, as I say, you get learned behaviour from delays. And if you yet again delay what has been publicly stated by the government, including the Prime Minister, is an absolute national priority, it sends a message.
Kevin Craven
Yes. Um, if I may. I mean, look, I think that, firstly, there are probably three sets of stakeholders that are affected by the lack of certainty around this. So we've talked a lot about industry, but there's also the defence planners inside the MOD who also need that certainty. The third group is our international allies, and we particularly could mention NATO.
But the one that I would mention and that is probably should be of most importance to the Chancellor is that our figures indicate that if we did get to 3%, there would be 50,000 additional jobs in the UK. And if we went to 3.5% by 2035, that would be a further 85,000 jobs.
This is on an industry which currently has around 190,000 jobs in the UK and adds roughly 16 billion of value add to the UK economy. And we could, one of the challenges we have is that most of the attractive markets in defence are not here in the UK. Our export figures are about 11 billion out of a total of 36, 37 billion of revenue, so less than 30%. We could double that. Some of the SMEs we've talked about this morning are at 65, 70% of their revenues on exports.
So there is a market outside the UK which, you know, is where people are turning because of that lack of certainty here.
Arnab Dutt
I was about to say that market is incredibly competitive as well. And if our high-skilled SMEs are getting that level of business from abroad, that's where they're going to build out their capability, long-term contracts, which means the opportunity when that money is released is, it's just going to be harder, more difficult. And if you, and the opportunity cost of not getting to that target quickly, 50,000 jobs, that's a huge amount and it's, it's something which is part of the government's target and is really important for our own SMEs in this country in terms of skills, employment, growth. So, very much so, you know, the sooner it happens, the better. I'm again echoing what everyone's saying, it's not rocket science.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
That is something that has been forthrightly put forward as a case, not just because of the significantly raised threat level, we've got the issues that we're missing out on defence as an engine for growth, also the British global leadership on defence. Many of our European allies are looking to us for that leadership, whether it's in JEF, whether it's in European security with respect to Ukraine and so on. And we've seen the likes of Germany, which has decided that they are now going to be investing huge amounts to make the Bundeswehr the largest conventional army in Europe, not to mention that within four years they will be spending as much on defence as the UK and France. So that's why I think we need that clarity to, you know, to have that 3.5%. But in your opinion, at the same time in the spending review, do we need to have a clear pathway to reach 3.5% or do you think that that can be done at a later date?
Kevin Craven
Yes, we need a clear pathway to 3.5%. It's critical for our allies, critical for the UK that we have that certainty.
Julian David
I absolutely agree and, and take it away from the annual test every year that's, is, are we still going to do it or not? So, so the pathway thing as much forward as possible, I agree with you there, Chair, and, and show that we're not going to deviate from it.
Arnab Dutt
Absolutely critical. Absolutely critical in terms of capacity and growth and a huge demand signal as well for the broader economy. So, incredibly important.
Stephen Phipson
I, I do agree and we get involved in lots of long-term discussions about investments with big manufacturing groups and they're talking about 10-year plans here. So of course you need to have it now.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Brilliant. Well, that, that's exactly what we've been making the case for, that we don't want the British taxpayer to be stung by defence inflation, that we need a well-managed process, a strategic plan for the next decade in order that we can have that increased gradual profile of spending on defence. Right, let me move on to my colleague Jesse Norman.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Just a follow-up point on that, thank you and welcome everyone and apologies for arriving late.
Speaker 63
Obviously in relation to monetary policy, the Bank of England takes particular steps and has done in the past to articulate forward guidance about where it expects interest rates to be precisely in order to allow industry to organise itself and plan on a more secure monetary basis. One of the reasons why they do that is because it reduces not just the uncertainty cost to the businesses, but the wider cost to the country of the additional insecurity. Does the same argument apply to you to defence, do you think in your judgement, that you get a lack of not just a lack of planning, but a wider lack of uncertainty and therefore in some sense almost encouragement to our to our opponents that comes out of that lack of guidance?
Stephen Phipson
I would absolutely agree, we do that is exactly the case. And the problem is the capital goes somewhere else. So this investment capital which is, you know, looked at by the manufacturing businesses to invest in the sector, if they haven't got clarity, it goes where there is clarity. That's the problem. So we are seeing lots of the groups investing overseas, we're seeing other, you know, other investment activities happening, some of it due to cost, but some of it due to they can only invest in something that's real, that's actually got an attached commitment to it.
Alexander Jesse Norman
And so we need to see that, otherwise it's the same guidance, it'll capital flow somewhere else.
Stephen Phipson
Actually movement from a budget to a spending review and then delay in a spending review just racks up uncertainty.
Speaker 56
Which was always the beauty of having a long-term equipment plan so that you could see what what people needed to invest in.
Kevin Craven
Yes, yes, well quite. Any other comments from you first?
There's probably two effects that are relevant. One is that lack of certainty, the other is the actual costs of doing business in the UK are increasing as we speak. So things like national insurance, well debated, but also the steel measures introduced 50% tariffs on out of quota orders is an unhelpful development for the defence industry.
Kevin Craven
So there were new steel measures which placed a tariff of some 50% on out of quota supplies of specialist steels. That has particularly impacted on defence and aerospace industries in terms of a cost of doing business and is likely to make UK steel businesses less competitive in this marketplace. So all of these things add up to a point where overseas marketplaces are becoming more attractive, particularly if you are a large global company who has perhaps a big business in the UK but also has choices about where it can place its.
Alexander Jesse Norman
The anchoring effects of capital investment are not being felt as well. Do you just a very quick question while we're exploring maybe ask you Mr David, Mr Dutt, are you seeing foreign companies come to this country because they're worried about uncertainty elsewhere? Is there a countervailing effect or is it really only going away from us and towards other countries in your experience?
Julian David
So in tech there is a huge amount of inward investment still happening. And and that obviously, you know, the broader context of defence tech is is tech.
Julian David
Yes, well it it is all of those things and you and you would have seen the the imprints that better growth than UK was expected during this year has been driven by AI adoption. And I would like to make the point that actually we need to understand the environment, the broader business environment. So AI infra tech infrastructure is really important to people's adoption of these technologies which are now fundamental to modern defence production.
And that is becoming difficult in the UK. So, quite high-profile, you know, people stopping investment in data centers, in other parts of the tech infrastructure because of planning problems and because of the cost of doing anything here. So the delays, it's not just the price of energy, Stephen, is it? It's the ability to get connections, which are now running at sort of eight to ten years versus about four years average anywhere else. And you can see that also in skills, and you can see that also in the supply of weaponry.
So, you know, we have to have a broader economic focus in order to secure our defense tech and defense broader.
Speaker 61
Thank you, Mr. Thank you, thank you very much. Right, let's move on to Michelle's Grogam.
Arnab Dutt
I was just about to add, there is another context, and that is the lack of visibility on this spend is having a huge impact in confidence for businesses. And we saw in the last quarter that small business confidence is at minus 57%. So, that certainty of spend would do a long way, it would go a long way in actually shoring up business confidence, and that's really important. And going back to what Julian said about costs, from our reports and our own research, 30% of our members that reported were experiencing annual cost increases greater than 10% on their businesses. That's massive.
Speaker 60
Yes, thank you very much, Chairman. Thank you very much, on to Michelle's Grogam.
Michelle Scrogham
Thank you, Chair, and good morning. We're seeing inflation in defense much higher than standard inflation, and the Minister for Defense Readiness has said that this is down to workforce, supply chain uncertainty, and the investment environment. Do you recognize these as the drivers, and if so, what extent, sorry, to what extent can government levers be used to remedy that? I'm going to probably come to Kevin first.
Kevin Craven
So certainly we do recognize that defense inflation does run higher than the norm and is unhelpful in the current environment where, you know, defense is expected to find efficiencies alongside building capacity and capability. In terms of ameliorating that, government can do that, can help with that by supporting in areas of enablement, like skills, for example, is a possibility, and also thinking about that general business context. So I mentioned the steel measures, there's also the carbon border adjustments coming down the track as well. There are a number of other general business measures that are making it expensive to do business in the UK.
Michelle Scrogham
When you say they can help out with the skills, whose responsibility do you see it as being to ensure that we have all of those skills in the UK, given we've got a global shortage in an awful lot of these sectors? They don't appear out of nowhere in, you know, putting them through schools. If you need them, where's industry's role in training?
Kevin Craven
So, look, so one of the huge industrial advantages that the UK has is in its creative engineering and innovation ability. That's why tech firms come here, it's why defense firms come here, it's why there are a lot of sectors that operate in the UK.
The thing that supports that skill base is orders. So back to the old refrain I'm afraid, certainty over the next 10 years would be enormously helpful in enabling industry to invest both in production lines but also in things like skills. And there are some exemplars as you well know in terms of your own constituency where we're seeing great progress made in developing the community and the surrounding environment supporting a major industry.
Michelle Scrogham
I understand. I think my question is, when we know that we have a global shortage in these skills, why is industry waiting for an order rather than getting ahead of the game and understanding that they need those people to deliver any contract? If we've got a global shortage, why is industry not training more? I'll go to Mr Phipson.
Stephen Phipson
Okay, so let me try and explain the situation, this is a subject we constantly talk to the MoD about. So the UK manufacturing, all manufacturing is 800 large companies and 130,000 SMEs. And that includes defence. If you look at the 800, most of them are investing really heavily in skills because at the moment the workforce in the UK is 2.6 million people in manufacturing and we've got 50,000 vacancies. And those vacancies are vocational skills, they're welders, toolmakers, robot technicians, service techs, all the things that normally come from an apprenticeship.
What we have got is BAE Systems, Leonardo, they've all got great training facilities. They've been investing themselves recognising that the system is not pumping out enough of these skilled people. But the big gap is the SME community. And the challenge there is they rely on FE. So in FE, so nowadays if you go because we haven't revised the apprentice levy system since 2016, a lot of FE colleges have dropped out doing engineering courses because you have to buy capital to do it.
So if you're a little machine shop doing defence work in East Anglia, whereas once you used to take on one apprentice a year, now you've got nowhere to send them because the local college isn't doing it anymore. So what we need to do is redo the apprentice, and I think it's well understood by certainly the government ministers that we engage with, that we need to have another look at how we are using that apprentice funding to make sure that we can encourage FE to get back into it. There are some pockets of great, great work going on. I would point you towards Yeovil College for example and what's happening with the Defence Technical Colleges, excellent work there with that additional money that's gone in to do that in that particular area. But we need to do it across the country because a lot of those SMEs can't send their apprentices anywhere so they just don't take them on.
Michelle Scrogham
Can I ask what your thoughts are if anybody has a comment on over-training of apprentices in some industry where they do have that capacity?
Julian David
Used to have a program, exactly. So I think we've called for more flexibility and more focus in the skills and growth levy as it's now called. And we haven't really seen it. And there are as you say exemplars of concentrations, I was reading about your constituency's efforts there Mr Norman and that's obviously really encouraging. The tech industry is trying to address the supply of skilled people.
We've recently put together a platform funded entirely by the industry with eight career paths to show people how they can get into the tech industry. And it's really aimed at NEETs and returners, so it starts from a point that says what sort of person are you, what are you interested in, and shows them pathways to do this, all of which are supported by industry connections and engagement.
But so far we're not really seeing Skills England really step up to this. We're not really seeing the MOD publish a real skills plan of what sort of skills it thinks the Defence Investment Plan's going to be calling for. So there's, you know, there's other people that could help here. And the final point is the bulk of industry are SMEs. SMEs just do not have the capacity to take people on who are not productive.
And they map them against where business is. And these very tech skills are very well sought after, as are welders, strangely enough. So, you know, there's a high price on these people. And if you haven't got a contract, you're not going to take them on.
Michelle Scrogham
No. And I would suggest the high price is down to the fact that they are like hen's teeth when it comes to welders. So maybe, maybe overtraining a few of them wouldn't be a bad thing. In Germany, we're seeing automotive facilities being repurposed. And quite a few of the industries in the UK are saying that they have capacity for this.
Do you see that being a solution here in the UK?
Stephen Phipson
Yes, absolutely. So we have all the automotive companies in membership and they are all very interested to see. We have quite a lot of available capacity at the moment and they're all very interested. They come along to all of the meetings we do with the MOD and they're very interested in providing help and capability. Again, they want to know where to invest really and which programs they need to be involved in.
I mean, we've got JLR involved in the light and the light, the new light vehicle program. But we can do much more than that. So yes, it's available. It's about being clear about what the priorities are and what the investment is going to look like going forwards.
Kevin Craven
It's not actually a straightforward conversion process though. So the compliance, certification, security arrangements, specialist engineering. So we are working very closely with the SMMT, the trade association for automotive, in terms of bringing forward some of the how you might do that. But it has not yet happened because again, back to the certainty of future demand.
Julian David
And I would refer back to the point about security clearances because the automotive supply chain is made up of SMEs. And they are not typically people who have had security clearance. And now that's become more difficult to obtain if you're an SME.
Michelle Scrogham
Moving on to a different topic altogether. On Saturday, The Times have reported that police are investigating incidents where defence executives have been targeted by activists. What impact do you think this has on the wider industry? And do you think government's recognized the security issues?
Kevin Craven
So certainly this is not a new problem. What is new is the escalation from premises to individuals. That is most unwelcome and resembles very closely what happened with Huntington Life Sciences some ten years ago. And these are individuals working at their day jobs who are now being punished and their families are being punished for involvement in the defence industry, which is a major part of the UK's industrial base. So it is a very unwelcome escalation and one that we would strongly hope the government would pay attention to.
Prior to this latest escalation, we have worked very closely with the Home Office on the policing of protests and this type of activity. And there has been some improvement, but as with everything, the threat morphs and has now moved to something which I think is going to have an impact on morale and the desirability of working in the defence industry if you can come home and find your house has been painted red, for example.
Julian David
I think we, you know, this is something that is very, very unwelcome and has to be addressed because again, if you think about the fact that all these companies can operate in different geographies and a lot of the executives do come on assignment and come from elsewhere, they're going to start to think, well, perhaps this is not a good idea. And it does seem to be a particular political angle which is driving this because the generality of the acceptance of defence companies seems to have become much better. You see a change in the attitude of people wanting to join defence companies and you see a change in the financing now, that there is money from institutions that they want to put to defence. Tech companies are all switching to dual use and defence as well. So this kind of politically oriented targeted attack is really very unwelcome.
Michelle Scrogham
Do you think the public have a wide enough understanding of some of these particular groups like Palestine Action and what their activists are doing? Do you think that's publicised enough in the media or through government structures?
Stephen Phipson
Well, I would say I think, I mean, having been around this issue for a number of years, there is a really important story to tell about this industry is defending our way of life. It's defending the rights of those protesters to protest. And without it, we would be in a very, very different sort of country. And we haven't really, what we need to do is keep reinforcing that point, I think, to the public. It's a point that we all reinforced very much with the financial community about banking the defence industry.
You are defending the way of life in this country. It's absolutely a vital mission which is done by these companies. And we need the government to constantly reinforce that message, I think. Sometimes there's too much airtime on the other counter-narrative and not on what we are actually doing here, which is defending our way of life.
Julian David
And I think the broader question of, you know, the whole country defence posture, the whole society defence posture, really does need some focus. And you're seeing in other parts of Europe, they're really getting to that message and they're really picking it up. And I think until that kind of messaging gets through to the general public, they won't understand, you know, why these things matter.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Thank you very much. Thank you, Chair. I couldn't agree more that I think it's deplorable that people are being attacked at their homes at a time when we are trying to encourage more people to get involved in the national endeavour of actually defending our country. But Mr David, I just wanted to come back on something that you said around security clearances. Can you just explain in greater detail the issues around security clearances, what has changed, why is it more difficult, because we've been advised that when we raised this issue around security clearances, that things are much better now and it's all sorted.
Julian David
So I suppose in summary, to sponsor someone's security clearance, a company now requires a contract-specific sponsor access letter.
And government departments at the moment don't seem to be able to agree who pays to process it. Right. So the impact is real. One provider has estimated thousands of people are affected. One SME that we know of lost 163 clearances in a single single date, costing it £68,000 and 12 months, including 14 redrafts of the access letter to put right.
So, you know, this change is really affecting small companies, but it's now beginning to affect large companies as well. And effectively what happened was the way it used to be being done has been changed, but they haven't actually put in place the capability to process it in the new the new way. We have raised that through the Defence Industry Joint Council. It is being looked at by Jim Carter's team, but so far no answer.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Just so that we can pursue this further as a committee, can anybody else give me any other examples around security clearances and the messy situation that you're faced with?
Kevin Craven
I can help a little bit, Chair. So there are two problems. One is MOD is currently providing security clearances that can be used by other departments who don't necessarily have their own security clearing apparatus. And that appears to be a source of concern. That's one issue.
Separate issue is that the MOD are looking at organisations that provide third-party sponsorship for those security clearances. That including my own organisation, we are currently sponsoring some 14,000 security clearances for 700 SMEs and other organisations in the supply chain. So if that authorisation was removed, the burden for supplying those clearances would shift in some instances to the primes who already are struggling with security clearances for their own staff, but also there are large numbers of SMEs who want direct access to the MOD and are using these third-party clearing houses to obtain that security clearances. So it would be a major problem and looks like being a major problem at the moment.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Well, just to reassure you that we have been on the case on on security clearances. In fact, it featured prominently within our AUKUS report as well because that was another area where we thought that we needed to, you know, get matters resolved before it actually impedes progress on delivery. But let me move on now with Jesse Norman.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Thank you very much indeed, Chair. If I may just draw attention to my role not just as MP for Hereford but also as Chair of NMITE, our new technology university, and which is, I should say, a member of Make UK. Thank you all very much indeed. I think you're absolutely right about the point about public conversation. I made this I had this conversation you may have seen with the Defence Secretary the other day.
Speaker 63
Previous Prime Minister promised a proper public debate about these things. We had a lamentable shortfall, as I would say. I think members across this this this committee were worried about it regardless of party. I think the this Secretary of State has said he's going to lead a conversation on this. And the paradox is that many of our younger people are not the snowflakes they're depicted as.
Speaker 69
They are actually thoroughly engaged. Could you just comment on any of that and say what you'd like to see, perhaps?
Julian David
So I think the the government taking a lead in actually explaining what is going on, the the fact that we are already under attack in a hybrid way, the fact that we are being scoped for future attack, the fact that interference through social media is influencing people's attitudes to things in a way that is really naive and bizarre and not being counteracted.
So that's my view. This really does need a whole government campaign approach of the whole government. And there needs to be, you know, a change to this idea that defense companies who have relationships in the US and other parts of the world are necessarily bad people.
Speaker 72
It's an information campaign. It's led from the top of government. It covers the whole of government. Is that what you're saying?
Julian David
I think MPs have a really clear responsibility here because you are, you know, responsible for your constituents and keeping them safe. So posturing which some MPs have done about ideological positions on defense are really unhelpful.
Kevin Craven
Look, the national conversation on defense as a priority is a desperately important one and this committee has played a major part in raising the profile of that, which we welcome very strongly. It is clear though that the two major regional conflicts around the world at the moment are impacting on Britain in a number of different ways, not the least of which we see in the fuel price at the moment. But the gray zone, the hybrid warfare impacts on Britain are already happening where we are seeing attacks on major retailers, we are seeing the social media influence campaigns, etc. So it is really important that the government leads this conversation and we move on from this characterization of defense spending as being something where it's contrasted with welfare spending. That's a very simplistic approach that doesn't begin to approach the right conversation around the place of national security of the UK.
Speaker 74
Thank you. Stephen. We don't need to go around everyone but just get a consensus quickly and then we can move on.
Stephen Phipson
Just some of the characterizations in the press about youngsters are very unfortunate, I think. I mean, we run an apprentice training center with 2,000 young apprentices in it. I'm also the chair of an educational trust with 21,000 school-leaver age type students in it. And when you talk to them about defense, it's not that they don't want to be involved in it, they're not sure how to get involved in it. There is no route, there's no program, there's no national conversation that says this is great, I mean, how do we get involved in the reservist movement or something else?
Unless there's those pockets, Hereford's a good example of a good pocket for doing that, but the rest of the country isn't like it. So I don't think there's an appetite to say we don't want to be involved as youngsters. It's a matter of us explaining how they can become involved in it.
Arnab Dutt
And I'd like to, you know, echo what Stephen says. You know, I meet a lot of young people, luckily enough to mentor some, and the ones I meet are absolutely fabulous. I compare them to my generation going back 40 years and I'm absolutely sure that we have fabulous people out there. And of course the opportunities within defense now are far more and greater and varied than they've ever been before. You know, as Julian said, software development, you know, it's not just hardware.
You know, the adaptability and change is happening in software on the front line. And so the opportunities across a whole bunch of tech areas and manufacturing are just phenomenal. But as Stephen says, explaining that, explain it to them.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Great. So national conversation led from the top, covering the whole of government with specific opportunities and articulating specific ways you can get involved. Very helpful. Thank you. Real worry about what a UK company is at the moment.
MOD is committed to spending with UK companies, but doesn't seem able to define it. How do you think of it? What's the right definition of a UK company, acknowledging that it's, you know, fuzzy and difficult?
Julian David
We've published a document on this, talking, we call it confident sovereignty. And it talks about looking through the lens of capability, control, and choice. And that reflects the fact that the tech industry particularly, but I also think it's true of the broader defence industry, is an international industry. And therefore what countries need to do is to understand what capability they need, understand what they have the capacity and the ability to provide for themselves and invest in that, focus on that, analyze what capability gaps they have, and then work out which trusted partners they're going to get that from, and then look at how do they control that when they have it. How do you make sure it can't be switched off?
How do you make sure you've got then choices in the event that you need to have a, you know, an alternative approach? And we think that is much more helpful in the context of our international defence industry and our broader international tech industry than saying buy British. Because if you say buy British, you really give a license to, and the EU is the one that's currently doing this mostly, to say, well, you should buy EU then. And they've shown their capability of doing that, and if we give them a justification...
Speaker 73
It feels like safe is a kind of internal racket which doesn't want to buy some of the best technologies in the market because they come from this country.
Julian David
Well, yes. And we should challenge that, and we've got to challenge the Cloud AI Development Act because that really affects dual use and technology infrastructure.
That's a further interesting point. Yeah. Thank you.
And we've said to the government repeatedly, again this morning to the Chancellor, this is not just a business department issue, it's not just Minister Falconer's responsibility. This must be a central plank of the EU discussions. And we have plenty of value to add. I won't call it leverage because you get into strange diplomatic places there. The UK has a lot of value in both of these conversations and I don't think we push that enough.
Alexander Jesse Norman
And do you guys all broadly agree around those three Cs or would you like a more, as it were, postcode-based approach to national?
Kevin Craven
Look, we welcome the desire to drive up UK industrial capability and capacity. But the definition of sovereignty, and we've been working with the MOD, I think we've run now four or five workshops on how to derive an appropriate definition of sovereignty, but that's got to be focused on the substantive economic and national security value to the UK rather than just a registered address. You know, so we really have to be clear it's at that capability level rather than at a pure sort of brass plate on the door type of level. Because we're a very open economy already. We have a large number of heritage British firms that have been acquired by foreign headquarters and they have treated those firms and the workers with respect and they still have a significant part to play in this conversation.
The the geopolitical point in terms of competition with Europe is an important one which needs to be addressed at the sort of UK EU security pact level rather than a made in Europe or buy British level which is sort of punch and Judy.
Alexander Jesse Norman
You think we'll get a kind of shared view of what constitutes adequate definition of British for purposes of sovereignty from your organisations or is the argument going to be much more specific about capability? Obviously some of our most important capabilities as you've pointed out are owned by foreign companies.
Stephen Phipson
Just I would say I mean when I was the head of defense exports for the government we were very clear about where sovereign capability was and there are a number of it's well controlled within the MOD about how we protect the IP how we have Chinese walls and how we make sure that none of that leaks out because that's obviously critical to the defense of the country. So they're quite good at defining that. I think the frustration around and we've all had the workshops we've all done the gold silver bronze and everything else what different flavors of and actually it happens in other sectors as well just to say it's not limited only to defense. I think Julian's point is not to be underestimated here about made in Europe. We're in a very difficult place with industrial accelerator act at the moment and the more we go out on the TV saying buy British the more we're not going to be part of the European system which accounts for more nearly half the exports of the country.
So really serious place we're in at the moment and there I've just spent two days with my counterparts across Europe doing made in Europe in actually we did it in Madrid for two days which sounds lovely but it was commission work brutal work. And we are not in a good place and the and the French government is very much against the UK being part of this which will substantially affect all of us not just in defense but in the other sectors as well. So so we have to be there's a balance here but I I would just reassure the committee that my experience without going into too much detail because we can't is that this is very well controlled about making sure we protect. The frustration often is about buying purely American platforms without any noble UK work happening here. That sort of thing is what we try to get to in terms of doing more in the UK.
Alexander Jesse Norman
I suppose the other question arises is is look when when the guano starts flying the whole sector is going to go Europe is going to go into some kind of lockdown right at that point we've got to know that we've got the things we need on hand right we can't it'll be like the global financial crisis everyone thought they could sell it turns out no one could sell because the market had fallen so fast. So how does that going to how do we build that into the picture?
Julian David
So I think it's about a couple of things. The first is that analysis that says what do we need and where are you know and where are we getting it from?
Julian David
Yeah and you know an understanding if we're getting it from somewhere else do we control it? And and and then it's much also a case of you know grow the British industry base here including foreign investment as as Kevin and and Stephen have pointed out which is very willing generally to actually invest and to give us that that kind of security. And you can do a lot by really getting on by investing and encouraging SMEs directly. You can do a lot by using the procurement act social value all of those things are available to be used which don't say this is a nationalistic exclusion it just says these are things where we're trying to to make a difference.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Thank you very much. Right let's move on now to post DIP developments starting off with Fred Thomas.
Frederick Thomas
Thank you, Chair. Yes, so post-DIP, which we are living in now, we are expecting of course this defence finance investment strategy to come forward and we have this investment summit which we're all looking forward to pretty soon. So I want to ask you some questions around that and also around the currency of the DIP, particularly as regards AI and emerging technologies, which maybe I can come to yourself, Julian, around the emerging technologies in a second. But Kevin, can I ask you, this DFIS coming forward, what do you think are the key things that it needs to clarify so that people are kind of clear, clearer of what to produce and what to invest in?
Kevin Craven
Yes. So, I mean, private finance and capital follows viable markets and at the moment, you know, defence does not necessarily here in the UK represent a very attractive market for defence investment. So that longer-term certainty which we've discussed at length this morning is a key component of that, but equally the attractiveness of the MOD as a customer. So those investors don't want to pay for the poor performance of the MOD as a procurer, for example, is something that is unhelpful. Risk sharing is probably one of those things that is important to understand again.
You know, investors are not attracted to high-risk ventures, which by definition defence feels like in some instances, but there is defence infrastructure which is much less low-risk and the recent announcement on the mobile docks for the Clyde was a really good example of something which could be funded perhaps by private finance as an example. So there's a number of things, but I'd maybe just also draw attention to SME financing and we've talked about the difficulties they face in procurement, but they equally face a challenge in terms of funding for working capital, bonding, insurance, that type of thing. And again, in the same way as the MOD has challenge in terms of the capacity to address seven or eight thousand suppliers, the finance industry and the capital investment industry in the UK is also wrestling with finding viable SME pathways for investment.
Frederick Thomas
Do you find that you have SMEs who are accessing financing from high street banks in a slightly more risky way? And the context of that question is I'm briefed by a number of high street banks that they have what they would call venture debt teams where they're very keen to, apparently, support growing British startups such that they wouldn't have to sell equity to venture capital funds but could borrow money from high street banks. Do your members doing that or how does what does that look from an industry point of view?
Kevin Craven
So we're working with a number of the high street banks, not all of them by any stretch of imagination, who are better at supporting SMEs in that difficult journey. Some of it is a second-tier problem, so for example using a contract award as a surety for mezzanine-type finance or debt finance in terms of that's hard to come by in the current climate. But they are, as is any, as is many sectors, are attracted into defence and the possibilities of participating because globally defence spending is up sort of 25%, 30%. It simply hasn't manifested here in the UK at the same speed.
Speaker 78
Okay, thank you. Sure. I'm going to come to Stephen and then come back to yourself, Julian, to ask about that, that tech comment.
Stephen Phipson
Just a few comments on the financing part because we do this not only in defence but across the rest of the manufacturing sector. We have got some, we can get start-up financing and the high street banks have got a role to play in that. We've seen still some de-banking in the defence sector which is another subject we might want to get onto separately even though the larger banks have done a much better job recently than we saw but some of the smaller banks are still very challenged with it. But what is a real problem and actually the government's done quite well with the British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund about financing those SMEs. What is a big problem in this country is series B funding.
Stephen, do you want to respond?
This is a big problem. So series A, getting that start-up getting it going, fine. Once they get going and then they want to build a factory, they want to do the next round of financing, the last five deals in the manufacturing sector this year all went to the Americans. All of them. And no financial institution in the UK wants to pick them up.
We've got a serious problem, something we talk to Treasury about every week at the moment about why is it that this patient capital is not available to on the series B in particular. And why is it National Wealth Fund are in that series A and then won't go on to series B and help the next stage of the development of those companies. So there's a whole area there that needs exploring but we are an outlier and the American companies are taking advantage of it. So some of our high-tech businesses, not specifically in defence recently, have gone to American investors because they will take the risk at series B and we won't. So there's something around there and there's still something around de-banking which we need to address on the defence sector as well I would say.
Speaker 80
Just to reassure you, you know, this committee's heard evidence around that funding journey, series B onwards, growth stage capital. And we are aware of that. And I think what we're tracking.
Frederick Thomas
Let me come back to my question Julian. We're talking about the DIP and I'm moved us on to talk about the Defence Investment Strategy and the summit that's coming up. There's an element where, you know, the SDR was written in 2024-25, DIP was written in sort of 25-26. We're now sort of in 26 moving to 27. Some of the movement with AI is so recent, it's unreasonable to expect that it would be accommodated and acknowledged in a document written two years ago.
How current is the DIP from a tech point of view, how urgently do you think we need to review procurement decisions based around shifts in technology?
Julian David
So I think the point about the DIP and the SDR is they did talk a lot more about outcomes. And one of the things that's bedevilled government contracting in the past is they actually try and specify inputs. And they try and actually say we want this, not this capacity, not this meet this requirement. They actually say we need this kind of technology and this kind of approach. So that was welcome.
We would like them to go even further and actually shift, you know, to software being the core of everything and equipment being brought in to work around the software core and the secure compute and the secure comms infrastructure to go with it. So the DIP in itself doesn't need to keep pace with which is the best AI model and they never will. What needs to happen is they need to have this idea of a software-enabled approach so things can be modified and changed so we don't get into the situation where we've got to cut holes in the side of ships that were even built because the computers that are in there need to be changed and they can't actually be taken out. You know, so we need to shift to everything being designed around the idea that it will be upgraded, it will be changed, components will be swapped in and out in an architecture.
And if we do that, that's fine. I would like to pick up on the procurement point because what we find all the time, both in defence tech but also in dual-use tech, is that there is not an appetite for the long term in investment in the UK. So companies in all parts of emerging tech find a much better conversation when they talk to US particularly investors that... Talk about private capital. Yeah.
And that's why they are so prominent in our funding landscape, and that's why there are so many trade acquisitions as well, because these people all have a longer-term view of what's going on and they're prepared to offer much higher valuations. They think they're getting bargains, our investment community seems to think it's something they don't want to pay for.
Frederick Thomas
Can I ask you very quickly, since the DIP came out, the government has stood up Sovereign AI as a fund run technically out of DSIT. So there's different bits of government procuring AI, which is perfectly reasonable. You could say every government department should be procuring AI. What does that look like from an industry point of view, and who is kind of seen as the most progressive bit of government that's moving forward with AI?
Julian David
Look, there are two elements to AI, I would say simplistically. One is the development of the frontier, the new type of AI, which is actually becoming quite an interesting and varied environment now with various options. So Sovereign AI is a very welcome and useful development. And then there's applied AI, which is what can you do now with it. I think, and I'll ask colleagues their perspective as well, I don't see a lot of connection between the activities of Sovereign AI and the necessity for national security and defence.
There doesn't seem to be any connection. I would also highlight the fact that we have a futuristic investment vehicle and discovery vehicle called ARIA, supposedly modelled on DARPA. Again, I don't see any connection between that and defence and security requirements. So we do seem to have a lot of initiatives that don't fit to a national purpose, and particularly one around resilience and defence.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Thank you very much indeed, Chair. Interesting comment earlier on about the Defence Office for Small Business Growth and how it was four people rather than 29 in it at the moment. Can we just focus on that for a second and just talk a bit about whether it's been effective, took a while to get set up, what it's doing, what your read is on it?
Kevin Craven
Happy to start. So look, we are very supportive of the concept. I think as with many things in the DIP, the funding of the resources required to deliver it to full implementation is a challenge. And at the moment, it is more of a signposting function and information function than it is an actual helping individual SMEs to work within the defence sector. So great concept and some good ideas, but still limited in its effectiveness in terms of changing the landscape for our SMEs.
Speaker 84
And you'd like it to be more than a signpost, you'd like it to be actually fighting for the voice of SMEs within MOD, is that kind of...?
Kevin Craven
Yes, and publishing best practice. So for example, I mentioned the Commercial X neutral vendor framework and there are some other rapid procurement pathways that do work and can work, and those could be shared around as best practice within the MOD or promulgated.
Speaker 86
But that's not happening at the moment. They're basically pretty quiescent, they're not advocating within the organisation.
Stephen Phipson
Um, we just... we understand that they reach full operational capability by the end of the year is the plan for the... for the...?
Speaker 92
The end of this year? And not this financial year, this actual calendar year?
Stephen Phipson
This calendar year, we're told. So we're two weeks away. 4 to 29 is an interesting... Yeah, absolutely. Great.
I agree. But so, yes, we're in that first phase at the moment of setup. I think having a single front door as Kevin said for SMEs is a great idea, very good idea. We haven't had that before and should act as a champion. We want to see them being more front-footed when they get to FOC.
Absolutely critical they do that. So we're giving them a little bit of the benefit of the doubt at the moment until they now declare that they're fully operational and off and running. But we are engaged with them and I think that's a good thing.
Speaker 88
So kind of three or four out of ten so far, but hoping to get... yeah. Okay, Arnab?
Arnab Dutt
Uh, we've had very little formal engagement and communication. What we hope for is a sort of regular meetings, structured meetings, at least on a quarterly basis where we can support them. And, but as I said, we love the ambition. We wait for it to perform and we want to support them as much as we can.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Right, so what about some internal transparency as well? You know, these are the 50 small businesses we've supported over the last quarter, here's the 100 we're working on, here's the 200 we've done so far. Is that the kind of thing you'd be thinking about as well?
Arnab Dutt
That would be incredibly useful for us, especially, you know, especially engaging and showing where the hurdles are, where the real challenges lie.
Speaker 93
I mean, it would get you guys off their back apart from anything else. I mean, that would be quite a good... that's a...?
Arnab Dutt
It would be because we feel that often times with MOD, we feel like we're complaining a lot and we don't want to be... we want to be critical friends.
Julian David
I would go further though, which is actually have targets which are allocated to people responsible for delivering them and the KPIs. We're very concerned about the fact we still don't have clarity over the 24-25 spend with SMEs.
Julian David
Yeah, and the proposal is that after 2028, there will be a report produced saying whether or not they made the targets that they've set for this. And we don't know what they are anyway. There's no KPIs on the way. And if you look at what they, you know, everything that they say, they talk about "we" are going to do this, not, you know, Billy Smith or Sally Scott. It's, you know, we really think if you in business, if you want to change something, you put somebody responsible for it and you give them targets and you have a periodic reporting on how it's going.
And we don't see that.
Alexander Jesse Norman
So internal advocacy, metrics, but also KPIs and named individuals.
Julian David
Responsibility. Doesn't have to be an individual, could be just the... that particular branch of the MOD.
Speaker 96
We've been saying they should be publishing a sort of impact report that says each year what they've actually... well, like we see in other departments.
Julian David
Impact report as well. Great, that's a little progress. That's good to say.
And the danger I'm afraid of allowing them just to publish the examples of what they're doing really well is that's what it becomes.
Speaker 91
It becomes a kind of show and tell rather than a proper view of how the whole thing's actually...?
Speaker 94
Well, it becomes a "look, this one's all right". Ignore the ten that failed. What about the overall?
Alexander Jesse Norman
And that's not the way to grow a British capability. No, quite. So, so, so in terms of looking at it from the point of view of a defense small business, you'll be aware that this kind of links to other conversations we're having. To some extent, where you end up as a company is often being driven not as it were head first but tail first because the lack of defense orders, the slowness in creating defense demand then causes companies to go into a kind of stasis where they're trying to build capability but they don't have the revenue to do that. They might have foreign revenue, might have quite a lot of foreign revenue, you know, Norway, Scandinavia, the US, the Gulf, places like that.
But no UK revenue. So they're running out of credibility locally, possibly with their financial institutions. Then of course a VC comes up to them and says, okay, take some money. And then once you're on that treadmill, you know, you're having to feed the demand for growth possibly faster than you think the market actually or the product actually needs. Do you see that in your own businesses?
Stephen Phipson
Definitely, we see that all the time. I think, I mean we've got thousands of SMEs in the community and the focus is on either they are dual use, i.e. they've got another market they're servicing. So they're in automotive for example and in defense or aerospace to be more accurate. Or they're in exports. But there's very few doing just MOD work.
Who can take the risk?
Exactly, yeah.
Alexander Jesse Norman
And because obviously if both sides could talk to each other or at least signal to each other that they were moving forward, you could get quite a rapid overall acceleration in capacity and capability.
Arnab Dutt
We find that there are other government departments that are doing some brilliant work on market pre-engagement and signaling where the pipelines are coming from, how much will be spent, which are the regions that they want to engage with and going out there and getting those SMEs ready and informed about what's ahead. Now that in itself is a huge move and it makes all the difference in the world. So when someone has to make a decision, do I go abroad, but if I'm being engaged with by MOD saying look this is coming down the tracks, those businesses can then prepare rather than being caught by surprise. So this is a really important part of what we want MOD to do as far as FSB is concerned.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Okay, great. Gents, any further comments on that? Do you see this interplay between lack of orders and getting your money from elsewhere and then how they could felicitously work together if we had a bit more rapid defense procurement?
Kevin Craven
Yes, simplistically, I mean if you think about a small company, the sales resource generally is the principal, the owner, and perhaps one other, but if they are turning their attention to exports they're not able to service the domestic market as well.
Julian David
The other thing I would add to that is a reference of British defense use of a new company's solutions is incredibly powerful in the match of being able to get orders outside of the UK.
Could you speak up a little bit Julian?
Julian David
It's incredibly powerful to have a reference that says this is used by UK armed forces, this is used by UK security agencies. That's a hugely powerful reference.
Speaker 98
Well if you don't have it, then how come your own defense establishment isn't using it?
Alexander Jesse Norman
I mean your product may be the best in the market, but if the MOD aren't buying it for whatever reason, it's got lost in Abbey Wood or something, then you're not selling to anyone else.
Stephen Phipson
As a former head of defense exports for the government, I can tell you when you're out there talking to other governments, the first question is, is it in service with your military? And if it's not, don't talk to me about it.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Like drones in Ukraine, right? Is it being sold in Ukraine? Absolutely, yeah. Okay.
Thank you very much. Just wanted to come onto a couple of issues that the committee's raised previously. Firstly, around MDM and DSRB. So we know that the government has made a commitment of about 400 million pounds to the multilateral defence mechanism with the UK, Netherlands, Poland, and also Finland contributing to that joint procurement. But at the same time, we don't have any clarity around the Defence Security and Resilience Bank.
What are your views on the DSRB? Should we be in or out? And are you expecting a decision on that within the defence finance and investment strategy? Short, clear answers would be good because we've had a lot of williness around some of this. So it'd just be good, are you in favour or not, and are you expecting this to be announced within the DFIS?
Mr. Craven.
Kevin Craven
We are very supportive of the concept of the DSRB. We think it complements the MDM, which is all about aggregation of demand across those nations. But the DSRB will be about how do we build the capacity here in the UK to support that aggregated demand.
Kevin Craven
We're expecting some news on that, whether it's the actual decision, I don't know. It's encouraging that the UK has observers in the DSRB. We've not heard any specific decision.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Right, that was very clear, concise as to where you stand on the issue. Mr. David.
Julian David
So I think, you know, we don't we don't really know because we don't know whether our technologies are going to be included in in the Defence Security and Resilience Bank provisioning. If it is, that would be a good thing. I think on the MDM, again, more significant to us is the NATO Communications and Information Agency role in this space. Again, if it gets expanded to include more dual-use and more tech, that that will make a difference. And I refer you back again to if we get locked out of CARD-A, that will make all these other things less.
We estimate it's going to be a 30 to 60 billion pound hit to the UK economy if we don't have CARD-A trusted status over five years.
Mr. Dutt.
Arnab Dutt
Yes, we're, you know, very supportive of DSRB, what it looks like. But what we're really interested in is how we get more SMEs registered on the NATO Support and Procurement Agency, which we think is a must.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
I'll I'll be coming onto that, but right, your answer is clear on DSRB. Mr. Phipson.
Stephen Phipson
Absolutely. So DSRB, good, positive, merge it with MDM, excellent. MDM needs to be deliverable. We don't need another procurement agency because we've already got one with NATO and you're going to come onto that in a second, Chair.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Brilliant. Right, that brings me onto the last point before we wrap up for today. We couldn't get a clear answer from either the Defence Secretary or the Perm Secretary or anybody else regarding why the UK is not making better use of the NATO Support and Procurement Agency. So Mr. Dutt, you mentioned it. Why do you think that is?
Arnab Dutt
I mean, I I really don't know. It seems like the obvious thing to do. It's something that will facilitate sort of more SMEs working with counterparts in Europe. It just it seems like low-hanging fruit for the government.
Stephen Phipson
No, no, not at all. We should be using it more. And what we don't need to do is create another one with the MDM. So we need to be focusing on what we've got already and trying to utilize it.
Speaker 102
Mr. Craven, Mr. David, given your background with ADS members or techUK, do you know why the UK is not using it?
Kevin Craven
Yes. In actual fact, the problem is getting worse. So in 19- in 2022, we were the fifth largest user of the NSPA. We're now the eighth largest. And during that time, the size of the NSPA's budget has trebled.
So it's a significant problem and we strongly recommend that we should be better engaged and making more use of it.
Julian David
I'm assuming the nodding is you're in concurrence. Echo those comments as well. And it does seem to in a sense highlight that we don't have such an expansive view of international opportunities as we once had. And that may bleed back to the fact we're not proceeding with our own activities as fast as we should be.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Very sobering thought on which to end. Thank you so much, gents, for your time that you have taken. As was mentioned, you're all very, very busy individuals with respect to your trade associations, but I think that has really helped to inform not just the committee in terms of future deliberations, but also the wider public as to the importance of taking full advantage of what the DIP has to offer and the implications that have been on your sectors. Thank you very much. And with that, I call to order today's House of Commons Defence Committee evidence session.
Order. Order.