Westminster Hall

28 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:10 - 00:15
Speaker 1
Order.  Mr Alex Barros-Curtis to move the motion. 
00:15 - 04:04
Speaker 4
I beg to move that this House has considered sentencing in cases of careless and dangerous driving involving death.  And it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Loll.  I'm grateful for the opportunity to open this debate, although I cannot honestly say that it is a pleasure to do so.  We are here because people have lost their lives on our roads.  Families have lost children, parents, partners and friends, and too many are left feeling that the justice system has not reflected the enormity of their loss. 

This debate is about accountability, public confidence and whether the law does enough to punish those responsible and deter others from making the same devastating choices.  I want to begin, Ms Loll, with the tragic case of my constituent, Keely Morgan, a 15-year-old girl whose life was cut short while crossing the road in Cardiff.  She was a much-loved daughter and a cherished granddaughter, sister and friend, with so much to look forward to.  On the 1st of May 2023, Keely was struck by a car while crossing at a pedestrian crossing in Caerau in my constituency, and she died at the scene.  The court heard that the driver was travelling above the speed limit, had been driving erratically and showing off, and had removed the vehicle's black box to invalidate his insurance. 

The judge described him as, quote, an irresponsible show-off.  He received 16 months imprisonment for causing death by careless driving and 11 months for causing death by driving while uninsured, to be served concurrently.  He was also disqualified from driving for two years and eight months.  Yet, he was released after serving only around six and a half months.  Keely's family must live with their loss for the rest of their lives, and her mother, Sian Morgan, has channeled her grief into campaigning for change. 

Her petition has attracted nearly 12,000 signatures, and I'm pleased that Sian is here with us today.  And I pay tribute to her determination to ensure that other families do not have to endure the same tragedy.  Her campaign deserves to be heard, Ms Loll, and as her Member of Parliament, I will ensure it is heard.  This House must take seriously the questions that it raises.  I recognise that courts, of course, must consider the individual circumstances of every case. 

The distinction between careless and dangerous driving is, of course, important, and not every offence should result in the same sentence.  However, where a driver's actions demonstrate a serious disregard for the safety of others and a life is lost, we must ask whether our sentencing framework adequately reflects such conduct.  And sadly, these concerns are not new in my constituency of Cardiff West.  Almost a decade ago, my predecessor raised very similar concerns following the death of another constituent in a case involving dangerous driving in Adamstown in Cardiff.  The constituent was killed after two drivers deliberately pursued her and drove her off the road. 

Both were convicted of dangerous of causing death by dangerous driving and sentenced to just six and a half and seven and a half years in prison respectively.  The outcome then left the victim's family members feeling that justice had not fully reflected the gravity of what had happened.  And so how can I find myself, Ms. Low or Ms. T, ten years later representing the same constituency, arguing the same point and in the same hall we're in today?  Why and how can history continue to repeat itself in this way?  Now I know these concerns... 
04:04 - 04:06
Speaker 2
Will he give way on this point? 
04:06 - 04:07
Of course. 
04:07 - 04:31
Speaker 5
Thank you, Mr. Low.  And I do thank him for shedding light on these cases and it can't be easy and it can't be easy for families hearing what's happened again.  But the reason we're back here, I expect, is because firstly the sentences aren't a deterrent.  And also the term death by dangerous driving, it completely underplays what happens, particularly in the cases you've explained.  I mean, this is manslaughter. 

04:31 - 04:39

Scott Arthur

So do you think we should, sorry, do you agree that we should think both about sentencing and also about how we present these cases to the courts?

04:39 - 07:35

Alex Barros

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and I entirely agree and surely I will come on to some actions that I'm calling on the government to take forwards and I think he will be pleased and will agree with some of those when I get to that moment. In 2024, a collision in Carmarthenshire, Carmarthenshire claimed the lives of two young people. In sentencing the driver at Swansea Crown Court on the 2nd of April of this year, Judge Hugh Rees observed that although the driver had not exceeded the speed limit, his driving was "simply not appropriate for the prevailing road conditions." Visibility was limited, conditions were extremely poor, yet the driver accelerated when greater caution was required. That driver received 16 months imprisonment, suspended for 12 months on both counts of causing death by careless driving with the sentences again running concurrently.

He was disqualified from driving for 18 months and ordered to complete 200 hours of unpaid work. Two young lives in that case were lost. Yet the driver did not receive an immediate custodial sentence. The outcome and that outcome and others that I've talked about including my constituents inevitably raises questions about whether the seriousness of the conduct and its consequences are adequately reflected in sentencing. Because road safety cannot be measured solely by whether someone exceeds the speed limit.

Drivers must exercise judgment, adapt to conditions, and put the safety of others first. When two lives are lost, the public must have confidence that the sentences reflect the seriousness of that failure. Sentencing of course is not solely about punishment, it must also be a deterrent. If we want drivers to think twice before speeding, before they're showing off, before using their phones when at the wheel, before taking risks in poor weather or disregarding other road users, the consequences must be clear and meaningful. When families repeatedly see outcomes they perceive as inadequate, public confidence suffers.

Justice must not only be done, it must be seen to be done. We must also consider what happens after an offender has been sentenced. Driving is of course a privilege, not a right. Where a driver has demonstrated a serious failure to meet their responsibilities, we must ensure that their return to the road is subject to appropriate safeguardings. So I urge the government to take action in four areas.

First, driving disqualifications must be reviewed. Where a driver has demonstrated that they cannot be trusted to drive safely, there should be a robust process for assessing their fitness to return to the road. The government should consider Shaan's proposal for automatic license revocation following serious traffic incidents, notably before an appearance at court or before conviction by a court. Such steps should be considered alongside mandatory reassessment before driving privileges are ever restored.

07:35 - 07:36

Will he give way?

07:35 - 07:59

Kim Leadbeater

I thank him for giving way and I thank him for securing this very important debate today. Road safety is a key issue in my Spen Valley constituency. He's absolutely right to say that the sentences should reflect these hideous crimes. Would he also agree with me that we have to look at prevention? And would he as part of that encourage the government to look at the introduction of graduated driving licenses, which is a way of preventing these horrendous incidents taking place in the first place?

07:59 - 08:03

Kim Leadbeater

And there's huge international evidence now that shows that it saves lives.

08:03 - 08:59

Alex Barros

I completely agree with my honorable friend, she makes the point excellently and I totally endorse what she said. And I'm sure the minister was listening carefully and I look forward to hearing what he has to say about that when he winds up. I am aware that the suspension of driving licenses was consulted on as part of the Department for Transport's motoring offenses consultation. This was not just in circumstances of death by dangerous driving or careless driving offenses, but also for both drink and drug related offenses. So I would ask the minister does everything he can to ensure that the Department for Transport carefully considers this question and that of my honorable friend for Spen Valley as it analyzes those consultation responses.

Secondly, sentencing guidelines must be reviewed. The government should examine guidelines for careless and dangerous driving resulting in death, ensuring that excessive speed, deliberate risk taking, previous offending and disregard for safety receive appropriate weight.

08:59 - 09:00

Will my friend give way?

09:01 - 09:50

Speaker 8

Thank you, I thank my friend for giving way on this important issue. Having spoken quite vociferously on this issue previously, one thing has to happen is that tougher sentences have to happen with the revocation of licenses for a very, very long period. In my own constituency, two lives were lost, one two months ago, a 60-year-old man. On the same stretch last year, we lost a 56-year-old. Right, we have to look at the causes as well.

And if that's people taking balloons, we've got to restrict them taking the gases in the balloons when they're high on things, but also implementing safety measures that would prevent cars doing 89 miles an hour in a 20-mile zone.

09:50 - 11:34

Alex Barros

I thank him for sharing those stories and I extend my greatest sympathies to the affected constituents that he so admirably represents. And I entirely agree with what he said. Because consistency is important, Ms. Lewell, but it must not come at the expense of properly reflecting the circumstances of each crime. Relatedly, the minister will know that the unduly lenient scheme allows anyone to ask for certain Crown Court sentences to be reviewed by the Attorney General's Office if they think the sentence is too lenient. The review is ultimately conducted by the law officers, the Attorney General or the Solicitor General, and if they consider the sentence appears unduly lenient, they can ask the Court of Appeal to review the sentence.

But only sentences passed in the Crown Court in respect of offenses triable only on indictment, i.e. in the Crown Court, or those offenses added to the scheme by subsequent order may be referred to the Court of Appeal. Now the offense of causing death by careless driving is not triable only on indictment, and although there is a long list of offenses which have been added to the ULS scheme by various subsequent orders, this, the offense of causing death by careless driving, has not been. Following the sentence of Keeley's killer, Sharne was mistakenly told by the prosecuting barrister and the CPS lawyer dealing with the case that the sentence imposed may have been too lenient and that they would consider whether the matter should be referred under the ULS scheme. For the reasons I've mentioned, regrettably, this was a mistake. I wonder then if the minister might reflect on this disconnect and whether he would seek to inquire whether the offense of causing death by careless driving should itself be added to the ULS scheme.

Thirdly, the government should consider whether legislative changes are needed to strengthen custodial sentences.

11:34 - 11:35

Will my honorable friend give way?

11:36 - 11:51

Speaker 6

I thank my honorable friend for bringing this important debate to the House and for giving way. And I want to raise the really sad case of Sophie Brimble, which was brought to me by her sister. She was killed as a passenger in the car with her boyfriend who was going three times the speed limit.

11:51 - 12:07

Speaker 7

The driver was found unfit to plead and therefore he walked out of court without having to face justice. This unfit to plead law dates back to 1836, so would my honourable friend agree with me that this is really well overdue for this law to be reformed?

12:07 - 13:11

Alex Barros

I thank my honourable friend for sharing yet another tragic story and again extend my sincere condolences to her constituents and I entirely agree and I hope the minister can address that when he stands to speak. Now of course a prison sentence can never bring back a loved one, but it must provide meaningful accountability and act as a genuine deterrent as we've been saying. We must examine whether the sentences available and imposed in these most serious of cases adequately reflect the harm caused, including whether suspended sentences are even appropriate in such cases. Now fourthly, we must address repeat offending and prevention and deal with and prevention. Now the government should, in my opinion, Miss Loll, review whether current penalties sufficiently address patterns of irresponsible driving before they lead to further tragedy.

Stronger sentences alone will not solve every road safety problem, enforcement, education and safer infrastructure must remain central.

13:11 - 13:12

I'll give way.

13:12 - 13:44

Speaker 18

I thank the honourable friend for giving way. Government figures show that rural roads account for 60% of road deaths, but only 45% of traffic. And speed related factors recorded over half of fatal conditions in the last year. In my constituency in Gravesham, we lost two people in Solstreet who were cyclists on the road. Does my honourable friend agree with me that rural villages where roads are narrower without pavement, shared by walkers, cyclists and horse riders need particular attention and intervention?

13:44 - 14:15

Alex Barros

I thank my honourable friend and I entirely agree and again extend my condolences to affected constituents in her constituency and I agree, part of my constituency is indeed rural as well, so this affects many constituencies across our four home nations and I am sure the minister has been listening carefully to that. This debate, Miss Loll, is not about revenge, it is about justice, accountability and prevention. We cannot change what happened to the victims of these offences, but we can decide what lessons we learn from their deaths.

14:16 - 14:48

Monica Harding

My constituent Darren, who is the father of Aiden Venison, who was 19 years old when he was killed by a driver under the influence of drink and drugs and he was not a first time offender, he'd already been banned from driving before, also while uninsured. The parents clearly don't understand the leniency that may have been afforded to a driver like that and why they are still allowed to be on the roads. Would the honourable member agree that sometimes what is perceived as lenient sentences actually adds to the heartbreak of parents?

14:48 - 15:06

Alex Barros

I completely agree with the honourable lady and again extend my condolences to the constituent she's so admirably representing and I entirely agree, it is about accountability, it is also about justice and it's about the message it sends to the victims and their families who have to live with that loss for the rest of their life.

15:06 - 15:07

I'll give way.

15:07 - 15:54

Tessa Munt

I thank the honourable gentleman very much for giving way and I'm so glad he's called this debate. I just wanted to include in the feeling of injustice that there is for those who suffer the loss of a family member, one of my constituents in particular, where the person who killed his wife with a car actually chose to give a no comment interview throughout.

And there were only two vehicles involved, a bike with his wife and a car. She didn't, she didn't deny that she'd done that, but she gave a no-comment interview throughout the proceedings, and that is just adding to the grief and injustice that that family feels.

15:54 - 18:11

Alex Barros

I thank the gentleman for that tragic story again, extend my condolences to those affected, and I entirely agree we have to think of this holistically because the impact is forever with the families and the friends of the victims. If, Ms. Lewell, two different families, two different MPs from the same constituency have been raising the same concerns now for almost a decade, Parliament has a responsibility to listen. We must ask whether our laws provide sufficient punishment, sufficient deterrence, and sufficient protection for the public. And if they do not, we must have the courage to change them. Every day, residents cross the zebra crossing in Cairo to visit the park.

For the community there, it's a daily reminder of Keeley and the life lost. The community support I know for the family has been tremendous, but no amount of flowers, murals, or kind words are going to bring Keeley back to Sharn and her lovely family. I am grateful and thank Sharn and her family and everyone who's supported her campaign for their courage, channeling their grief in an attempt to get a productive outcome that we're talking about here today. Keeley should have been able to cross that road safely and return home. She was so much more than the circumstances of her death: a daughter, a sister, and a young girl with her whole life ahead of her.

Her family should be able to remember her for who she was, rather than having to fight to ensure that no other family has to suffer the same indignity. Ultimately, this is about ensuring that our sentencing framework reflects the seriousness of these offenses, gives families confidence that justice has been served, and acts as a meaningful deterrent to prevent further tragedies. We must ensure that the consequences are serious enough to reflect the harm caused, hold offenders accountable, and deter others from taking the same risk. I urge the government to review the legislation and sentencing framework and to take meaningful action. I look forward to hearing the minister's response and the further contributions of colleagues.

18:11 - 18:14

Speaker 9

Thank you, Ms. Lewell.

18:14 - 25:48

Tessa Munt

I remind members they should not speak regarding any live or ongoing court cases or inquests throughout the debate. The question is that this House has considered the matter of sentencing for causing death by dangerous or careless driving. Tessa Munt.

Thank you, Madam Chair. And as I said before, I thank the honorable member for bringing this debate forward. I want to just to pick up on something the honorable gentleman had said, and that is driving is a privilege. And to be able to return to the road immediately as somebody who may have, well, has killed another person or caused somebody serious injury seems particularly injurious. And his call for automatic license revocation, I hope that the minister may be able to address that point, and the fact that that feels so incredibly lenient, especially when it is the case that court cases take a long time to come around and people have to wait a very, very long time before, and they can, the person who's the perpetrator can carry on with the rest of their life while the family is suspended in utter grief.

So my sense is that suspended sentences also are not appropriate.

And particularly in the case I'm thinking of, there's one where somebody's given a no-comment interview to the police and chooses not to speak at all. It just seems so desperately unfair. I wondered also if we might address the fact that it's already been mentioned that there are people who are driving without insurance, people who drive without tax, people who drive without a valid MOT, and yet the police are so stretched that they are not able to deal with this sort of issue when it comes along. And those minor infringements, as the people who do that would consider them, only just increase the likelihood of somebody carrying on to behave more and more irresponsibly. So I would ask the Minister perhaps to consider what he might have done to look at what's happening in France and in Ireland, which are our nearest neighbors, and they seem to have slightly different view and different action that take place.

And I'm very happy to send the Minister some information about that, and I'll do that, sir. Thank you. Right, so I would like to just talk about one other aspect, and that is how we prevent dangerous behavior before it results in another death, even one. And I want to concentrate on at this point on speeding and racing, which is a serious concern in my constituency of Wells and Mendip Hills. So between 2019 and 2024, 204 people were either killed or seriously injured.

It was actually 29 who lost their lives and another 175 suffered serious injuries. And I know that just when I was sitting here, I'm thinking about an accident that happened near Dinder just outside Wells, an accident that happened at Blackford, an accident that happened very recently in the village of Ston Easton. These things are catastrophic, not just for the people who live nearby, not just for the family, but for everyone who's involved. It's really desperate stuff. So those people who are killed or seriously injured, they're not just statistics.

They represent the individuals, the families, and the communities whose lives are very often changed forever. And whilst I wouldn't suggest that all those collisions involved speeding, we do know that nationally excessive speed is a contributory factor in around one in five fatal collisions in 2024. And that surely underlines why tackling excessive speeding must be central to any serious strategy to reduce road deaths. And I'm aware that the Transport Department has published the first road safety strategy in over a decade, and I think that's great. But we have a Justice Minister here, so I shall just ask him if he would actually please work with his colleagues in the Transport Department.

And I have a really straightforward question, and that is there's an ambition to reduce deaths and serious injuries by 65% by 2035. And that's very welcome, but I'm not entirely sure, and I'll ask the Minister to ask the Transport Minister, where that 65% reduction is going to come from. Many in the road safety community are questioning whether the measures currently proposed are sufficient to achieve that ambition. And the strategy is relatively light on specific measures to tackle serious and persistent speeding, despite recognizing speeding as one of the fatal four causes of death or serious injury on our roads. So since that strategy has been published, and it was published all the way back in January, there must be an urgent need to finalize the government's response to the consultations, set out a clear delivery plan, and to begin implementing the measures that will actually save lives.

One possibility, I know that I went to an event here in the Houses of Parliament, and I was really interested in the intervening Intelligent Speed Assistance or ISA. And that is there is technology that is fitted to new cars, I recognize that, but this can be fitted to cars that are already on the road.

I've asked for some, only because I drive, you know, 25,000 miles a year, and I'm in and out of 30 and 40 and 20 limits, um, regularly, and I don't wish to get any points. So, um, but so I should declare an interest, I suppose. But, um, unlike the intelligent speed assistance technology, which is fitted to new cars, new cars, this can warn driver, that warns drivers when they exceed the speed limit, but that can be overridden or switched off, and it shouldn't be. Intervening technology can actively prevent a vehicle from accelerating beyond the legal limit. Um, and it's not a theoretical idea.

It's already happening in Virginia in the United States, and there's a program that was introduced this year which allows the courts to require certain speeding offenders to use vehicles that are fitted with speed limiting technology. And I think that has to be an advance. So, I think Transport for London's also demonstrated very high levels of speed limit compliance using intervening technology in its bus fleet. So can the minister reassure his, or can I ask the minister to get transport ministers to reassure, um, us that his officials, her officials, beg your pardon, have examined the progress being made in other jurisdictions using ISA as part of the offender management? Um, and I wonder whether the minister might sort of pose a slightly different angle on this and just ask why would we not do that, rather than why would we do it?

It just seems that it's, it's demonstrated to be effective and practical and potentially, it has potential to save lives. So I just think it's something we should be trialing, at least. Um, so Chair, I return to the families, um, whose experiences lie at the heart of today's debate. They deserve justice. They also deserve to know that we're doing everything that is reasonably possible to prevent other families suffering as they have.

I'll give way. Surely.

25:48 - 26:26

Speaker 8

Thank you for giving way. I agree with you that we welcome the 65% target by 2035. But by 2035, we could have at least two general elections, if not more. And that is not fair on the families that have lost their loved one. We need to be reducing quicker, more, um, urgently than 2035 to be the target.

If that target is set, then perhaps it needs to be brought forward into this Parliament and make a significant start, um, in achieving that by 2035.

26:26 - 27:12

Tessa Munt

I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention. I would say to the minister, all the optimism in the world in that you might get another two lots of elections, I still think doesn't give you reason to, this, this timetable really does need to be contracted when there's such simple wins that can be taking place. And we should do things as quickly as we possibly can. 2035 does seem like an awfully long way away. So, um, there is an ambitious target, I understand that, but we do need the measures and the timetable and the determination.

And as I said, I'm going to ask him to answer those questions that are relevant to him, and I will ask him very kindly to pass those that he's not going to be able to answer onto the Department for Transport, the Secretary of State in particular. Thank you. Thank you, honorable Chair.

27:12 - 27:13

Siobhain McDonagh.

27:13 - 28:38

Siobhain McDonagh

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms. Lowell. I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Cardiff West, on securing this debate on an issue that is particularly close to my heart, having seen two young women from my constituency lose their lives as a result of dangerous driving.

I know that too many colleagues in this room will have supported families who have experienced similar tragedies. I want to begin with the story of Lily Clack and the extraordinary work her family have undertaken in her memory. On Christmas Day 2021, Lily was a passenger in a car driven by a man who had been drinking. The driver, Charlie Hilton, was fleeing the police at speeds of more than 100 miles an hour when he lost control of the vehicle and crashed into a tree. Lily suffered catastrophic injuries and died three days later.

She was just 22 years old. In February 2023, Hilton was sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison for causing death by dangerous driving and other offences. But no prison sentence can bring back Lily or undo the devastation caused to her family. And Lily's death is far from an isolated incident.

28:38 - 29:32

Steve Yemm

I thank the honorable member for giving way. And this week marks a year since the death of Abigail Eggleston, the girlfriend of one of my constituents, in similar circumstances, killed by Liam Bowes in a hit and run incident. And I'm sure all of our thoughts will be with the family and her former partner, William Payne. Bowes was sentenced to 12 years in prison for causing death by dangerous driving. And I wonder if my honorable friend will agree that justice has to be delivered for victims of crimes like this, and if she would welcome the government's commitment that those convicted of this crime and this offence will not be eligible for early release, which would otherwise have effectively halved the time that Bowes would have served in prison.

29:32 - 34:27

Siobhain McDonagh

I absolutely agree with my honorable friend, and can I extend my own condolences, and I'm sure of all members, to Abigail Eggleston's family, that she died in such tragic circumstances. According to the Stop Excessive Speeders campaign, between 2020 and 2025, 282 people were killed or seriously injured in road collisions in Mitcham and Morden, including five who'd lost their lives. Those figures seem extraordinary, Madam Chair. Another young woman from my constituency who lost her life as a result of dangerous driving was Alia Mohammed. Alia was just 20 years old and studying at King's College London.

In March last year, she was sitting on a bench outside her university when a van mounted the pavement and struck her. She died at the scene. The driver, Christopher Jackson, subsequently pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving and was sentenced to eight years in prison. Alia had her whole life ahead of her, and her family have been left to come to terms with a loss that no sentence can undo. Her death is a reminder that dangerous driving threatens not only those travelling on our roads, but also pedestrians going about their everyday lives.

And it's tragedies like these that have led families to campaign for change. Since Lily's death, her mum Debbie, alongside her auntie Donna, has worked tirelessly to ensure that something positive comes from the unimaginable tragedy. And I want to take a moment to recognise what Debbie has achieved.

On what would have been Lily's 25th birthday, Debbie opened Lily's in the Garden, a beautiful tea room at Merton and Sutton Joint Cemetery. I had the pleasure of attending its opening and I cannot speak highly enough of the wonderful space Debbie has created. It is somewhere for people visiting loved ones at the cemetery to find comfort and equally somewhere for anyone passing by to enjoy a cup of tea, a slice of cake and a very friendly conversation. I would encourage any honorable members who find themselves on Garth Road in Lower Morden to pay a visit. Through her charity, Eyes Wet Now, Debbie is also working to support other bereaved families.

It is a remarkable achievement and a wonderful tribute to Lily. Debbie and Donna have also been campaigning for the introduction of Lily's Law, with more than 43,000 people signing their petition. Their campaign has two demands. First, that a driver's license should be immediately suspended following a fatal road collision pending investigation. And second, that anyone convicted of causing death by dangerous driving should be permanently disqualified from driving, whether alcohol was involved or not.

These proposals seek justice for those who have lost their lives and they are also about preventing further tragedy. I also want to recognize the extraordinary determination of Claire Corkery, who has been campaigning for justice following the deaths of both her parents. In January 2024, Tom and Sue Corkery were walking their dog in Bearsted, Kent, when they were struck and killed by a speeding driver. In a single moment, Claire lost both her mum and her dad. The driver, Scott Gunn, was subsequently convicted of causing death by dangerous driving and sentenced to 16 years in prison.

But it took over a year for Gunn to be brought before the courts. Throughout that time, he was legally permitted to drive and he admitted in court that he had continued to drive. Even after his conviction, Gunn received a driving ban of just eight years. Claire is understandably concerned that he could return to the roads once he has served his sentence and his disqualification has expired. Claire has also campaigned against the early release of dangerous drivers, determined to ensure that sentences reflect the seriousness of the lives lost.

Her experience demonstrates precisely why the two demands of Lily's Law are so important.

34:27 - 34:52

Peter Dowd

I'd like to thank my friend for bringing this debate as well. There are 4,154 people still on the roads who have 12 plus points on their license on the grounds that it would cause disproportionate suffering to a third party. But what about the disproportionate suffering to families? Would my honorable friend agree with me that that get-out needs review as well?

34:52 - 37:30

Siobhain McDonagh

I would agree with my honorable friend on that point. Lily's Law is so important because it wants the power to suspend licenses immediately following fatal collisions and permanent disqualification for those convicted of causing death by dangerous driving. Her determination, like Debbie's, deserves recognition. And I want to recognize the important progress the government has already made. In August, the government confirmed that those convicted of causing death by dangerous driving would be excluded from the new early release arrangements.

Debbie Clark wrote to the Prime Minister personally to thank him for that decision. For a family who has endured so much, it meant a great deal to know that the seriousness of what happened to Lily has been recognized. And I welcome the government's road safety strategy published in January, which as we've already heard, sets out an ambitious target to reduce the number of people killed or seriously injured by 65% by 2035. This is a strategy that recognizes the need for stronger action against dangerous drivers. It considers new powers to suspend the licenses of those under investigation for the most serious motoring offenses resulting in death or serious injury.

This is a significant step forward towards addressing one of the central concerns by Lily's Law. I would be grateful if the Minister could update on the progress of those proposals and when we might expect to see them brought forward. I also want to raise the question of permanent driving disqualification. I recognize the courts already have the power to impose lifetime driving bans. Could the Minister also explain what consideration the government has given to mandatory permanent disqualification and whether further measures could be considered to strengthen the protection of the public?

The government's own road safety strategy makes an important point as other honorable members have argued, holding a driving license is not an automatic right. And I think that principle should guide us as we consider how to protect people from the most dangerous drivers. I hope that the Minister will continue to listen to Debbie and families like hers and work with them to ensure that we do everything possible to prevent another tragedy like Lily's, Arlia's, and Tom and Sue Corkery's.

37:30 - 37:31

Jim Shannon.

37:31 - 43:14

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Chair. As always, a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and to be called. And can I thank the honorable gentleman for Cardiff West for raising what is an incredibly sensitive debate and for all the contributions because the contributions will always by the very nature of life include circumstances in your own constituency where someone has passed away or been killed as a result of a road accident or died afterwards. I have to say this, I don't believe that anyone sets out in their car intending to take a life, yet tragically this does happen for whatever those reasons may be, from using a phone behind the wheel to driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. I'm old enough in this world to remember when it was always alcohol under the influence was the reasons and then it was alcohol and drugs or just drugs on their own.

And this last few years, I think the presence of motorists using drugs and how it affects their driving and aspects of their driving and the threat that they hold behind the wheel to others has become a massive issue. And whilst the maximum penalty for causing death by dangerous driving is now life imprisonment in England and Wales, in many cases, as the honorable lady before me said, this is not applied. And the honorable lady referred to having mandatory sentence, life sentence for it, I think is what I would probably be seeking for as well, not the discretion that the magistrate or the judge will have when it comes to handing out the sentence. Critics say of course or judges retain a large amount of discretion allowing them to assess individual culpability, which I'm not quite sure how that is done. It's not me here to tell a judge they're doing things wrong because that's not my way of doing things nor is it my knowledge when it comes to legal matters.

However, I do believe that justice in these cases is best served by allowing judges to consider the unique circumstances of each case. But it is clear the system is largely effective as 95% of those convicted of death by dangerous driving are indeed sent to prison. So there is stats which I think indicate that it does happen. But the things that always come to our attention are the cases where it happens and there is no life sentence, there is no sending them to prison. I should have welcomed the minister to his place, my apologies for not doing so earlier.

I wish him well in the role that he does and hopefully we can get the answers that we seek from the honorable gentleman. Nonetheless, we must continue to listen to the victims' families' concerns, because that's really what motivates us all as elected representatives, is the victims' families. As some highlighted, offenders can continue driving until conviction after causing a fatality, or resume driving very soon after leaving prison. So when it comes to getting the sentence and going to prison, I think it would be appropriate, Madam Chair, that the driving license should be removed from them and that they aren't able just to resume driving as soon as they would exit prison after, probably in many cases, a small sentence. These gaps must be addressed both to protect the public and to provide greater reassurance to families.

In Northern Ireland, Madam Chair, the maximum sentence remains 14 years for causing death by dangerous driving, and this I believe should be brought into line with England and Wales, giving our courts greater powers to impose even harsher sentences where they see fit. My own constituency of Strangford unfortunately has not, has also seen the blight of dangerous driving and those, I have to say, who have lost their lives as a result. Just last year, Madam Deputy Speaker, or Deputy Chair, on the same night, two young people were killed in separate incidents: Lucas Strainer, aged 12, and Jaden Rice, aged 16. Two lovely young people and hadn't even got into the prime of life and they were both lost their lives due to accidents. My thoughts continue to be with both families whose lives have been changed forever.

And when you hear the family stories, as others have explained and told very eloquently here in the chamber today, Madam Chair, the impact upon the families left behind is something that they resonate with every day of their life. I remember one of my good friends, a son was killed in different circumstances, but he always told me, Jim, he says, when I go to bed at night I think of Stuart, and when I wake up in the morning I think of Stuart. And that's what the families do, the families, that vacant chair, that anxiety and angst and pain that they have in their heart is something that's very, very real to them. So I conclude with this, Madam Chair. I call on government to retain the discretion of judges when sentencing, but always to have the mandatory sentence of to jail.

These cases are immensely complex. They cause profound distress to drivers, victims, and their families. And while no sentence can ever reflect the loss suffered, the court must be allowed to assign a sentence which is truly reflective of blameworthiness. And again to the honorable gentleman for giving us a chance to speak today, I thank him very much and I look forward to the minister's response. Thank you.

43:14 - 43:15

Josh Dean.

43:15 - 47:39

Josh Dean

Thank you very much, Chair, and it's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair this afternoon. And I thank my honorable friend for securing this really important debate, because behind every road death is a family, a group of friends, loved ones that have been changed forever.

Today I want to speak about one such family from my constituency, the parents of Jess Waterman who join us in the gallery this afternoon and whom Minister you kindly met with earlier this year. On the evening of the 19th of February 2022, Jess's partner, someone she knew and trusted, picked her up from the Watermans' home in Bishop's Stortford. He had never passed a theory or practical driving test. He took to the roads in full knowledge that he was not qualified to drive. He showed brazen disregard for Jess's safety and the safety of other road users.

He crashed that evening and when he fled the scene to avoid arrest, he left Jess behind, seriously injured. Tragically, Jess died the following day. She was three days short of her 21st birthday. The police acted to apprehend the driver, but the outcome of this case raises serious questions about whether the law properly reflects the choices people make before getting behind the wheel and the devastation that can follow when it goes wrong. The driver responsible for Jess's death was convicted of causing death by careless driving rather than causing death by dangerous driving and that distinction matters.

Dangerous driving will generally involve driving that falls far below the standard of expected, expected of a competent driver. Careless driving can cover errors of judgment or lapses in attention. Driving without a license is not simply careless. This was not a split second mistake. It was a conscious decision taken before the journey ever began.

It required premeditation. The driver knew he was unqualified, knew he should not be behind the wheel, but he chose to get behind the wheel anyway with Jess in the car. Jess's death was treated in law as careless driving, in the same category as offenses like forgetting to get an MOT. As a result, the man responsible for Jess's death was in 2023 sentenced to just four years in prison. Not only was he out of prison by early 2026, but stunningly, he was caught driving again.

He showed no remorse for the tragedy he'd brought upon the Watermans or regard for that he might bring upon another family despite being handed a 10 year ban. He was rightly returned to prison. Chair, no parent expects to outlive their child. No parent expects to receive a phone call or visit from the police to tell them that their child is never coming home. But that is the reality that one driver's actions has left the Waterman family living with every day.

Out of their loss, the Watermans have campaigned for change, calling for death caused while driving without a license to be treated as dangerous automatically and calling for stronger deterrence. They have worked tirelessly to ensure that no other family has to experience what they have endured and I promised them that I would do all I can to support their campaign and ensure their voices are heard in this house. As we consider these issues today, I ask colleagues to think about this. How can it be just that taking to the roads in full knowledge that you are not qualified is not considered dangerous? How can we claim that there is sufficient deterrent when Jess's killer spent so little time in prison and immediately took to the roads again upon his release?

We owe it to the Watermans, to the victims and their families to ask in cases such as this whether sentencing powers properly reflect the profound harm that has been caused. I stand with the Watermans as they call for change in the law. I thank the Minister for meeting with us earlier this year. I'd be grateful if he could update us on what action he has taken and if he would commit in this debate to working with colleagues in the Ministry of Justice and across government to review whether causing a death while knowingly driving without a license should automatically be treated as dangerous driving. The law should better reflect the poor choices made before a tragedy occurs and the consequences that families must live with forever.

Out of grief, they have sought to make change and to protect others. I can honestly say that I can't imagine showing the strength, determination, and courage that they have shown were I in their shoes. I'm humbled by their commitment and their work, but they deserve more than just our admiration. They deserve our support. We must not fail to meet their call, for Sue, for Dell, for their younger son, Jess's brother, and most importantly, for Jess.

Chair, I want to conclude by paying tribute to the Watermans.

48:02 - 48:05

Speaker 23

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Ben Maguire.

48:05 - 53:24

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I congratulate the honorable member for Cardiff West for securing this really important debate today. I also commend him for his campaigning efforts on behalf of his own constituents, especially the family of Keeley Morgan, whom he referenced so powerfully in his speech today. He was absolutely right that proper deterrents should be in place for offenders. I cannot even begin to imagine the pain that her family have been through following Keeley's tragic death and the subsequent pain of navigating the justice system to address such serious failures of accountability and justice.

Yet sadly, this is the same story for so many of our constituents up and down the country, including one tragic case in my own North Cornwall constituency, which I'll touch on later in this debate. I'd also like to take the opportunity to commend all members across this House who spoke so powerfully about their constituents' tragic cases, sadly far too many similar experiences. And on behalf of too many grieving families and the victims themselves, we Liberal Democrats are fighting for changes in sentencing in relation to causing death or serious injury by dangerous or careless driving. We believe sentences handed to those who kill someone by dangerous driving should properly reflect the seriousness of their crimes. We supported much tougher maximum sentencing and longer disqualification periods in the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act back in 2022, and we've been long calling for an updated road safety strategy to be delivered as quickly as possible following years of neglect of Britain's roads by successive governments.

One shocking case relating to road safety that happened in my own constituency of North Cornwall involved the hit-and-run of a young man named Ryan Saltern. In 2019, Ryan was hit and killed by a drunk driver late at night who then sped away from the scene, leaving Ryan alone in the middle of the road to die. Yet despite killing Ryan, fleeing from the scene, and then hiding from police for 36 hours, Ryan's killer was spared prison entirely and was handed a four-month suspended sentence. He received a 12-month driving ban, all in a magistrates' court. Because the CPS couldn't prove he'd been driving dangerously, he was charged only with failing to stop and reporting a road accident, which is essentially the same charge as if he hit clipped someone's wing mirror and then driven off without reporting it.

Like my honorable friend for Wells and Mendip Hills, witnesses at the scene gave a no-comment interview and experienced no consequences whatsoever. Imagine the heartbreak that added to Ryan's family. In response to Ryan's tragic death, his parents Mark and Helen, as well as his sister Leanne, launched their Ryan's Law campaign. Their aim is to widen the causing death by dangerous driving offense to include failure to stop, call 999, and render aid at the scene until emergency services arrive, including that as aggregating factors.

Their online petition garnered 167,000 signatures and support for this change is extremely strong both locally in Cornwall, but also across our country. Sadly, there are hundreds of families who don't currently see justice served. During my first two years in this place as North Cornwall's MP, I've been really taken aback by the sheer dedication and perseverance of the Sultan family in their campaign on this vital issue. They've committed to make sure no more families in Britain are left feeling so badly let down and lost in the justice system after a road traffic collision like this, and are doing some incredible work as well with Rise Haven, which provides a safe, dedicated space for any families grieving a loved one from a road accident where they can escape and process what happened. I've joined the Sultan family in meetings with various road ministers at the Department for Transport, the most recent of these taking place last month.

I've also raised their case with the previous Solicitor General and I've tried to champion their cause in a number of debates in this House to demand that change that the Sultan family and as we've heard today, so many families are calling for. It's why I've been so pleased to see the announcement of this government's new road safety strategy at the start of this year, noting that previous road safety strategies have successfully delivered good improvements in road safety. But now we're almost one year on and we're still seeking clarity on when that strategy will be implemented and how the several consultations that have already taken place will feed into it. And while I appreciate the Minister... Yes, I'll give way.

53:24 - 54:02

Monica Harding

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. As part of the road safety strategy, would my honorable friend agree that we should give some consideration to graduated driving licenses, which has actually been introduced in Northern Ireland? The honorable member talked about the risks for dangerous driving and mentioned drink and drugs, but youth is also a danger because kids get into a car and start to speed very, very quickly and then we end up in a tragic situation. So does my honorable friend agree that England and Wales should maybe have and Scotland should have the same rights as Northern Ireland?

54:02 - 56:52

Ben Maguire

I thank my honorable friend for that excellent contribution and I do agree that there is a strong case to be made for graduated licenses. And I think it was the honorable member from Batley and Spen that referred to international research showing the success of that scheme and my honorable friend mentioned the success of that in Northern Ireland. So hopefully the Minister is listening to that. But I appreciate the Minister in his place and I welcome him to his place by the way as well. I know he's a very diligent Minister having served with him on the Home Affairs Select Committee.

I hope the Minister will be able to at least go away and speak to his colleagues in the Department for Transport to get an update on the timing of that road safety strategy, which all of us in this House are still waiting to hear about. At the heart of submissions to each consultation in that strategy was the actual impact of road traffic collisions on victims and their families. The human cost of inaction is staggering, with each of the one and a half thousand fatalities on Britain's roads last year having left a grieving family wanting justice to be properly carried out on behalf of the loved one that they had lost. In August this year, the Victims' Commissioner set out six very clear recommendations in relation to road safety in their report on barriers to justice.

To quote the Victims' Commissioner Claire Waxman directly, behind every road death or serious injury is a victim, a grieving family whose lives are changed forever. Yet too many victims told me they felt road crime was not treated with the seriousness it deserved. Her recommendation set out four areas of improvement, which included stronger national standards for investigating road collisions, implementing trauma-informed training for police officers and staff, and sustainable funding for specialist traffic collision victim support services. So just to conclude, Madam Chair, I would ask the Minister in his wind-ups to confirm if he's read the Victims' Commissioner's report from August in full, and if his department is working cross-departmentally to implement its six recommendations. Will the Minister please provide clarity around the timeline of the road safety strategy, including when the government will respond to the consultations held earlier this year?

And will the Minister look into adopting a much more victim-centered approach in the new road safety strategy, so that families like the Sultans and like the parents of Keely Morgan and the countless families we've heard about so powerfully from members today can finally feel their voice is being properly heard? Thank you.

56:52 - 56:55

Speaker 27

Opposition spokesperson Kieran Mullan.

56:55 - 01:01:42

John Kieran Mullan

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I'd like to begin by thanking the honorable member for Cardiff West for securing this debate and for the way in which he spoke about his constituent Sian and her daughter Keely. He made their case very powerfully. And preparing for this debate has given me the opportunity to read more about Sian and her campaign and her daughter Keely.

And as the member described, Keely was just 15 years old when she was killed in May 2023, struck by a car while crossing the road. The driver was convicted of causing her death by careless driving and of causing death while uninsured, and he was sentenced to 16 months in prison. In my work with victims and campaigners, I've got to know that until you speak to a person individually, you don't always know the ins and outs of every case, and I wouldn't want to say anything that was incorrect. But what I can say confidently is that a 15-year-old girl died, a family has been changed forever, and the sentence was measured in months, not years. And I know how I would feel if my similarly aged niece was killed in the same circumstances with the criminal background of the individual concerned, and I would want to speak out for Sian in the way in which she's campaigned in response to that.

More than 11,800 people have signed her petition calling for tougher sentences and for changes in how those cases are handled. As other members have said, under the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 introduced by the last government, the maximum penalty for causing death by dangerous driving and for causing death by careless driving while under the influence of drink and drugs was raised from 14 years to life imprisonment. I know those weren't the exact same charges that were involved in this case, but that I think demonstrates an attempt to recognize these sorts of offenses and the impact that they make. But as the member for Strangford described, maximum sentences are one thing, what judges give are another. If you don't mind, I'll talk about a family that I have worked directly with and can speak more confidently about, that's Glenn and Rebecca Ewens, who lost their daughter Violet-Grace in March 2017 when she was four years old.

She was walking with her grandmother in St Helens when a stolen car driven at 83 miles per hour in 30 mile an hour zone hit them. Violet-Grace died and her grandmother was left with life-changing injuries. The driver fled the scene. He was later sentenced to nine years and four months, but because he pleaded guilty, he received a reduction and he was released after around four and a half years. And as Glenn powerfully describes, he spent less time in prison than his daughter was alive.

I've been proud to support Glenn and his family and they're part of a group called Justice for Victims. And in what I hope can be an inspiration to Sian, they also launched a petition and campaigned vociferously in their daughter's memory, and they were a big part of why that maximum sentence for causing death by dangerous driving was increased.

And I mention them as well because, like so many of the cases mentioned today, these are the people that really understand what it is to not get justice, to care deeply and love someone deeply and live in a country where you expect that if you do the right thing and someone does the wrong thing to you, the system will deliver justice to you. You can't bring somebody back and you don't want revenge, you want justice. And I think the concerns in these cases, but actually across very many other cases, demonstrate that again and again for many decades, so this isn't a one government or another government, for many decades, I don't think the justice system in this country delivers justice anywhere near as often as it should do, particularly when it comes to serious offences and serious offenders who commit crimes again and again. During our time in government, we did take some steps to try to address this. We did this in a major way by rolling back the automatic halfway release of offenders to two-thirds for some offences.

We've talked today about sentences, but we have to always remember that whatever sentence is passed in the court, the amount of time someone spends in prison can be very different to that, and prior to that change, essentially everybody outside of a life sentence only served half of their sentence anyway. That was an important step. But what's happened under this government, I'm afraid, since then? They've taken a sledgehammer to the ability of victims to get justice by introducing even earlier one-third release for most offenders sent to prison for most crimes. So in this case, for example, prior to later changes that we managed to help secure, offenders just like the person that killed Shaan's daughter would have only been asked to spend a third of their time in prison.

I think that was disgraceful. And what did they actually want to do? What was the actual aim of the government? They wanted to make it even earlier for those responsible for causing offences not just like this, but causing death by dangerous driving, rape, a whole series of very serious crimes, this government attempted to let them out of prison earlier too. The member who sponsored the debate talked about whether or not Parliament listens enough.

Actually, very many MPs from across different parties did listen to what people said about that and attempted to stop the government from doing that. We put forward an amendment.

01:01:42 - 01:02:04

Siobhain McDonagh

Would the honourable member be prepared to give credit to my constituent, Miss Corkery, who campaigned tirelessly to ask for death by dangerous driving to be excluded from the early release, and that she and other people campaigning in that way were successful?

01:02:04 - 01:05:52

John Kieran Mullan

I want to speak about that in detail, absolutely. And so but I think it's important for people watching and listening to know when the minister gets up and gives lots of warm words about this, this was the minister that specifically argued to let people just like this gentleman involved in this case get out of prison after serving just a third of their sentence. It was only as a result of campaigners like Shaan in other areas and campaigners such as the one that the member mentioned fought the government and had to tell their stories again and again in public, in what I'm sure the petitioner knows is a deeply traumatic thing to have to do, that the government was forced into U-turning. And all of this was based on a set of plans for an independent review that did absolutely nothing to engage with what the victims actually want from sentencing policy when it comes to justice. So as I said, this is an issue that has gone on for decades.

There was an opportunity to grapple with it properly, to seek to understand why is there such a big gap, why do we see these campaigns again and again, not just in relation to driving offences, but a whole series of offences where victims feel so badly let down. Nothing was done to engage with what victims actually want to see from sentencing. And even today, those early releases are described by this government as earned releases, when in fact they're automatic. So these people automatically walk away from prison even earlier. Thank goodness because of campaigners it hasn't applied to those more serious offences, and I welcome that.

But it isn't only on this issue that Parliament sought to improve the situation.

During the passage of that bill, there was actually an amendment that was put forward to provide automatic disqualification of those convicted of causing death by careless or dangerous driving. And again, hundreds of MPs clubbed together to defeat that amendment, including, I'm afraid, some of the many MPs who've spoken in the debate today in support of those people who've been affected by those sorts of cases. I think I understand the sponsor member didn't actually oppose these measures and saw the sense in what many other MPs were seeing, and I congratulate him for not having supported some of these measures and certainly not sought to stand against them. Madam Chair, I think that does lead the Minister having to ask us some basic questions, answer some basic questions. Does the government believe that the current sentencing framework and the way in which it's being applied does properly reflect the seriousness of causing somebody's death through dangerous or careless driving?

If the answer is yes, the Minister must explain why so many families and members of the public believe otherwise. If the answer is no, they need to tell us what they intend to do about it. And as other members have described, there are other things in the short term that the government could do and that we support. Absolutely, the ULS should be extended to those that cause death by careless driving. Surely, if a case is so serious that it's led to the death of a person, it should be eligible for that.

We continue to want to see automatic disqualification for those that are convicted of offences of careless or causing the death of through careless or dangerous driving. And I think there's absolutely merit in providing the police, for example, an opportunity to ensure that someone's license is temporarily revoked if they consider the facts on the ground. We know the police seek bail conditions all the time to restrict what people can do in relation to them being suspects prior to conviction. I have no reason to see why it shouldn't also be applied. But there's a broader question that this government and previous governments have failed to grip and seek to sort, which is that we have a massive yawning gap between what the public and victims and families just like Sharn want to see when it comes to serious offences and what they actually get when it comes to justice in the court.

I think that gap is too huge. We're committed to seeking to address that if we're back in government. But whoever gets back in government, we have to finally grip this, even if it's difficult, even if it's expensive, so that we don't see again and again victims deeply let down by a system they expect to be there for them when they're sadly the victim of a serious crime.

01:05:52 - 01:05:54

Speaker 30

Minister.

01:05:54 - 01:06:29

Speaker 32

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I thank my honourable friend, the member for Cardiff West, for securing this incredibly important debate and raising these incredibly important issues, both in the chamber but also outside the chamber with me and others in the preceding weeks. But I want to start, as many have, and pay tribute to his constituent Sharn, who is here today. She's shown extraordinary courage in fighting to make sure her daughter Keely's death wasn't in vain and to try and make changes to improve the country for others. And that is something that we should applaud.

01:06:29 - 01:06:50

Speaker 31

It's not easy, and it's something that is hugely admirable. I want to apologize to her as well, because she wrote to me through her Member of Parliament and hasn't received a response in prompt time. There has been an error in my office. It's not acceptable, and I'm getting to the bottom of it. And I look forward to meeting her later today, hopefully to talk about the substantive issue, but also to apologize to her personally as well.

01:06:50 - 01:07:56

Speaker 32

And I want to thank my honourable friend, the member for Hertford and Stortford. I've of course met with him and the Watermans, and it's good to see Derek and Sue here again today. After that meeting, I committed, Madam Chair, to raise the specific issues of their campaign and the tragic death of Jess with the then Roads Minister, which I did both in writing and then met with her and her officials and indeed her special advisers, who are political appointees in the Department for Transport, to make sure those issues are really high on the agenda as the government's strategy on road safety comes into force. There is more that we can do. It is a work in progress.

The Roads Minister has changed since then, but I've also met with him. And indeed, because of the debate today, I've written to him again this morning to make sure that both the campaigns and the issues we're talking about today are right at the top of his agenda.

It's not me trying to duck away from many of the issues that have been raised in this debate, but some of them are for the Department for Transport. I will try and address as many of them as possible, but if not, I will make sure that members who raise those issues will get a written response from the roads minister who deals with some of the road safety issues, but of course the sentencing aspects I'll try and deal with. Yes, of course.

01:07:56 - 01:08:29

Jim Shannon

I'm grateful to his response to the questions I've asked. My honorable friend and colleague to my left-hand side referred to the graduated driving license changes in Northern Ireland. I want to ask that question because we have done it after long consultation, after deliberations with all the bodies concerned, and it seems to be a very, very strategic way forward. Certainly it was, it's been received quite well by all sections of the general public in Northern Ireland. Is that something, Minister, that the government here and your department would consider?

01:08:29 - 01:09:18

Speaker 32

Well, critically it's not my department to consider, but the DfT, the Department for Transport, sorry, is certainly looking at and is alive to the evidence that have been raised I think by a number of members from internationally. I can't get ahead of what the roads minister will set out, but I will make sure that he's heard the contributions from today's debate as well. And I think I want to thank all members from across the chamber on raising very difficult cases. Perhaps in particular if I may, my honorable friend the member for Mitcham and Morden, I wasn't aware of the work that Debbie has done around Lily's tragic death, and it was very moving to hear about that and in particular the cafe that so many people will enjoy in her memory. I'm very happy to meet with Debbie if that would be helpful to her, or indeed I will get the roads minister to meet her if that would be more beneficial.

Yes.

01:09:18 - 01:09:43

Siobhain McDonagh

Debbie and Donna have both met with the previous road safety minister to discuss their case and their reasons for asking for license to be suspended after an accident and then for there to be a lifetime ban. But I thank him for his offer to meet them. I'm sure Debbie will be marching her way towards him as she hears him speak.

01:09:43 - 01:15:45

Speaker 32

I look forward to Debbie marching into my office. And look, victims do not want to meet with a conveyor belt of ministers from all different departments. It is important that we do have those meetings because it's important that they are heard. It's important for us to understand that behind every statistic, every paper we get reading in our box, it is a human life and a human tragedy. And so it's critical that we do meet with her and I look forward to meeting with her in due course.

But what they want is action. And I hope that what as I develop my speech, that she'll be reassured that we are taking these issues seriously and that we are taking action. But I look forward to meeting with her and many other members who may be perhaps intervened and no longer here have raised important cases. And it struck me actually as a member of parliament only for two years, just over two years now, that you get exposed as an MP to different parts of our country that perhaps you don't as a normal citizen. And one of them is just the prevalence and tragedy of road deaths because you as an MP often get notified if there has been an accident or if there has been a criminal offense committed on our roads that has led to an injury, a serious injury or a death.

And it is far too regular in our country. And when you meet with the families as I have done in my constituency in Ribble Valley, it stays with you. So I'm determined to play my role to try and bring about safer roads. I just want to turn to the sentencing framework as it is today because there has been some conflation between death by careless and death by dangerous. I'm certainly not trying to educate members at all, but it's my responsibility to on record set out the regime as it is today.

And honorable members know that sentencing within the framework that's set out in legislation is rightly a matter for the independent courts. Judges consider the facts on each case, weigh up any aggravating and mitigating factors, and follow relevant sentencing council guidelines before arriving at a sentence that is just and proportionate. And just part if I may just touch on this, some of the issues that I think have emerged in this debate are perhaps less about sentencing, although some times certainly, but are about the charging decision. And this was an issue that I discussed with my honorable friend and the Watermans about the CPS charging decision, what offense a defendant is charged with is obviously and should be independent of any government any government effect, but clearly they they need to involve the victims in that decision. Not do what they say, but involve them, communicate and engage with them.

And too often I meet with victims in this area of road traffic road traffic offenses, but also others where they simply haven't been engaged at all. So I am talking to the victims minister to ensure that the CPS where they can, where it's appropriate, they should be communicating with victims to make sure that charging decision is the right one. The law must reflect both the harm caused, but also how responsible the offender was for causing it. Because whilst two drivers can cause the same terrible outcome, they may have done so through very different actions. That doesn't of course make one's family's loss any less than another's, but it does mean that the law has to distinguish between these different levels of blame.

So I'll turn to the offenses themselves. The most serious driving offense is causing death by dangerous driving. This is where someone's driving falls far below the standard expected of a competent and careful driver and where the danger should have been obvious. We are talking here about things like excessive speed, racing, dangerous overtaking. For offenses committed since June 2022 as mentioned by the the official opposition spokesperson, the maximum sentence for causing death by dangerous driving is now life imprisonment.

There is also a minimum five year driving disqualification and compulsory extended driving test before an offender can return to the road. These are tough penalties and rightly so. They give judges the power to impose the most serious punishment in the very worst cases. There is also the offense of causing death by careless or inconsiderate driving. This covers driving that falls below the expected standard but doesn't reach the higher threshold for dangerous driving.

The maximum sentence is a five year imprisonment alongside a minimum 12 month driving ban. And I raise the issue of the CPS because of course what the defendant is charged with is what the judge and the court can deal with. And so that charging decision is often just as important to get right for victims and families and wider society than the final sentencing which then may not seem fair or sufficient to victims. The distinction therefore between dangerous and careless driving is a really important in our law, although I of course recognize as I've said before that it's it's difficult for grieving families to accept when clearly their loss they have suffered is exactly the same. I want to deal with some of the specifics that have been raised in the debate in particular by my honorable friend the member for Cardiff West, driving disqualification and looking at whether there should be automated disqualification.

I think the honorable member also raised this. This is part of live discussions that I've had with the Department for Transport. It strikes me, and I'm very happy to put this on record, that I have come across too many cases where driving disqualification is seen as is not taken as seriously as part of the punishment. And often it runs concurrently with a prison sentence, so you have this absurd situation where you can't obviously drive in prison, you get out and you've never had any disqualification of driving at all. I raised this in a meeting I had with the chair of the Sentencing Council, perhaps it was after the meeting with the Watermans that I raised it personally with her.

I think it's I'm not breaching any state secret, she wasn't persuaded of that. I've asked them to look again. The DFT are also doing work looking at the evidence to try and make sure that we have evidence based policy. And I'm going to continue pushing how we can ensure that driving disqualification is is used in a more muscular fashion by the judiciary.

They have the power. So Parliament in this case, there's an issue about automating, but they have the power to implement lifelong driving bans, but too often they don't seem to be considered. Now I'm not criticizing independent judges, I never would do that, but we do need to have a look at what we need to do as a government, as a parliament, but also Sentencing Council's role in trying to push that forward.

01:15:45 - 01:16:04

John Kieran Mullan

Yes. Just so I'm clear and understand, absolutely there's a sentencing framework and Parliament has some of the judges have a role in applying that, but it would be totally within Parliament's remit to make it mandatory, to make it automatic, and we could seek to do that and a number of MPs did vote for that last year and were blocked from doing that by his government.

01:16:04 - 01:16:57

Speaker 32

No, he's absolutely right to say that Parliament could pass the law to have an automatic driving ban. Now it does get it does get more complex as to automating upon before conviction. I think he was referring to post-conviction of dangerous driving. There is a general principle we try as a government, previous governments before us as well, to give judicial discretion. Every case is somewhat different.

But I accept the points. I'm not trying to hide away from the the argument. The judges have the power. We need to get the evidence to see how often they're using it and why they're not using it and understand that. And sometimes legislating to force judges' hands can actually lead to further absurdities and injustices in very different ways.

So we do try and offer judicial discretion because every case is different, but I accept the point he's made.

01:16:57 - 01:17:42

Tessa Munt

Yes, of course. Thank you very much. I regard this as really, really serious. I hope he's going to address the matter of potential suspension immediately after an accident so that people are not driving around for a year, two years, three years, four years while they're waiting for a court case. But I wonder whether in the same way as somebody who has been the perpetrator of sexual abuse, domestic abuse, or whatever, they have to report in to their local they have to say where they're living and then the local police are aware of where that person is living, whether in fact one could then make sure that the local police are aware that X person is not permitted to drive for a period of five years, ten years, or forever, because they are going to be the people that pick that up.

Thank you.

01:17:42 - 01:19:35

Speaker 32

She's right to raise this point about the period before trial or conviction. We know too often that can be far too long. It isn't as straightforward as immediately after the event because no doubt she will be aware that in often there is very complex investigations that have to take place. Of course it can be a bail condition. And again I'm trying trying to assess why in too many cases it's not used.

And I remember actually comes to mind the case that's raised by me by the honorable member for West Bromwich where some a gent well, not a gentleman, someone had been bailed for death by dangerous driving I think, and immediately got in a car and got convicted of drunk driving just a few hours later. Now that is an absurdity and I think we have to start taking driving offenses more generally, whether low-level or high-level, more seriously. Now the road safety strategy does I think show that and want to seek to do that. We want to get on with that and I'm pushing the roads minister to work with me to do that and have that reflected in sentencing guidelines as much as possible. Graduated driving license was raised by my honorable friend the member for Cardiff West as well as sentence I hope I've dealt with that.

It is on the agenda, it's very much a DfT issue so I don't want to comment too much. Sentencing guidelines as well, I'm in a constitutional dialogue with the Sentencing Council on lots of issues and this is one of them. I'll be careful with what how what else I say on it, but it's very I'm very much alive to it. And in terms of the ULS, I'm very alive to this as well. The Law Commission are doing work on the ULS as I think my honorable friend will no doubt know from his time working with the law officers.

And we need to assess whether death by careless driving should be added to that list. And I can commit to I can commit to doing that today.

01:19:35 - 01:19:39

John Kieran Mullan

And will you write to them and ask them to ensure that they do actually consider that as part of their review?

01:19:39 - 01:20:49

Speaker 32

Well, I'm happy to write to Law Commission to ask them whether to consider that specific issue. I'm going to consider it anyway. So I don't really mind whether the Law Commission, I want the Law Commission to do it, evidence would be helpful, but we will do that nonetheless, working with the Attorney General's office, of course. There will be no doubt some effects to that, but let's look into it and see what we can do. And he talked, I think, finally about prevention.

And ultimately, again, the road safety strategy at its heart tries to reach its target of 65% reduction by prevention. And there is a serious amount of investment. This is the first road safety strategy in a decade. It's backed with, I think, 18 million pounds in prevention work. Not an insignificant amount of money.

We'd like to do more, no doubt. But I know the roads minister will be working hard. In terms of other questions from members about the road safety strategy more generally, I can't really, it's not my strategy. So it's difficult for me to comment on timings and when that will be. But I can, I will ask the roads minister to write to members who've raised specific points on that.

And I'll make sure my office gets in touch with him on that. Yes, of course, one last time.

01:20:49 - 01:21:34

Tessa Munt

So I know everybody has the right not to comment, but it is simply outrageous when that has no weight. I mean, it would be different if someone had had some sort of medical episode which meant that they were not able to remember what had happened. But where that is clearly not the case and someone is advised by the solicitor not to comment throughout the whole of all of this, it's really very, very tough on the families. And I wonder if he might consider that point and seeing if there's a way in which one can put some weight behind that and also speak to the victims' minister about that, because it is something that happens repeatedly.

01:21:34 - 01:22:04

Speaker 32

She raises a wider point about defendant conduct as part of the criminal investigation, how that should be taken into account in the sentencing. I mean, there are mechanisms by which it is already, because the judge will consider a large degree of factors, including if the defendant has taken responsibility for their actions. If they have undertaken a no-comment interview consistently and simply not engaged with the criminal investigation process, that should be taken into account by sentencing. Yes, this is the final time.

01:22:04 - 01:22:24

Tessa Munt

I don't want to wang on, but I know that his department has looked just recently at what happens to people who refuse to come to hear their sentence. And so clearly there is the ability to intervene in the process that's involved. And I'll just entreat him to do something more.

01:22:24 - 01:23:03

Speaker 32

The Lord Chancellor, I think, announced last week further action on trying to, as much as is possible, get defendants to face up to their actions, frankly. That's what we're talking about. In terms, I don't think you can force a defendant to give answers if they don't want to give answers, but you can certainly reflect that in the sentencing regime, and it is reflected in the sentencing regime. But if there's any other suggestions about how we can go further, be more than happy to hear from her as a member of the Justice Select Committee. She always does the, she'll write to me signal, and I look forward to responding to her in due course.

Madam Chair, in conclusion, I want again to thank all members who've raised this issue. I think there's just, okay, yes.

01:23:03 - 01:23:14

John Kieran Mullan

Just that central question that I put to him. At the moment, as a justice minister, does he think that the justice system is consistently delivering justice for victims of these offenses and other serious offenses?

01:23:14 - 01:24:46

Speaker 32

No. Too often, there are families who feel let down by the justice system in lots of different ways, whether that is the final sentence, whether that is the way they were treated.

The case that the honorable friend from Cardiff West raises about misinformation being given about options at the end can cause huge damage. And I'm not criticizing the individuals in that case because they're hard-working individuals and it's a complex area of law, but we just need to get some of these basics right to make the system as amenable as humanly possible for victims when they're navigating the most traumatic time in their lives. And too often it doesn't. And I accept also sentences as well. Now, we are in a complex constitutional relationship where I'm not going to criticize independent judges and sentences given in any individual case.

It would be wrong for me to do so, but of course I accept that too often victims feel that justice hasn't been done. And I do just finally, Madam Chair, in conclusion, I think there is a real disconnect between when I knock on doors in my constituency, you know, road safety is really top of their priority list in so many, especially rural villages, which was raised by the honorable member, and how often we talk about it in this place. And I think that if we can do all of us do our bit to raise these issues with myself, but also across government, we will be doing a service to the country and of course to victims more. So I just want to thank everyone, in particular those in the public gallery, and I look forward to continuing this discussion and taking action in the coming weeks and months. Mr. Alex Barros-Curtis to briefly wind up.

01:24:46 - 01:26:49

Alex Barros

Thank you, Chair, for your, for chairing this so excellently and to everybody who's contributed today. I think it's been incredibly humbling to hear the stories of loss and of tragedy and the prevalence of it, as the Minister said, across the piece. And I'm particularly touched, of course, to have Shaan and her family here and of course Sue and Dell Waterman as well to hear of these inspiring examples of individuals, and of course Lily's Law, as my honorable friend for Mitcham and Morden said, channeling grief and tragedy into ensuring that people don't have to go through this again, so that we can learn lessons from their deaths is inspiring. But it's something that has been, we've been talking about for too long and too often in this place. So I'm very grateful to what the Minister has said about some of the calls for action that I and others have called for, about some of the actions that he is going to take forwards.

I think anything he can do with the new Roads Minister to impress upon him the urgency of this situation for myself and no doubt Shaan to meet with him again for my calls for action, for those of the Watermans, from Lily's Law and others who've been speaking here, I think anything that he can do to drive this change across government will be central in order to ensure this pernicious, the severity of this is just dealt with because it is something that has just gone on for too long. I will also ask that when he is continuing his discussions on the constitutional pull that he talks to, if he could perhaps speak to the Chief Prosecutor of Wales for some of the challenges they found in why sentencing was pegged in this, in this specific case in my constituent, why they had to go at the lesser offense, because I think there could be some invaluable lessons that he could learn as part of the wider framework that he's putting together. But I'll just finish, Madam Chair, by thanking everyone for contributing, but first and foremost to thank all the victims, my condolences to all the constituents that have been referenced and particularly to Shaan and her family for inspiring me and allowing me to work with them in order to drive change through.

01:26:49 - 01:30:35

Emma Lewell

The question is that this House has considered the matter of sentencing for causing death by dangerous or careless driving. As many are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. Order, order.

Sitting is briefly suspended till 4:00 p.m.

Order. I will call Sarah Gibson to move the motion and I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as is the convention for 30-minute debates. Order, order.

Sarah Gibson to move the motion.

01:30:35 - 01:32:45

Sarah Gibson

Thank you. And it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Madam Chair. And I'm grateful for the opportunity to secure this debate on the performance of HCRG in the South West and in Wiltshire in particular. Over recent months, a growing number of constituents, carers, and healthcare professionals have contacted me. And I want to open this debate by thanking some of the staff who have stuck their heads above the parapet and asked us, their elected representatives, to put HCRG's performance on the Minister's radar.

Some of those members of staff who are sitting in the gallery today in this debate, and I thank them again for coming. The community served by HCRG contracts are diverse: Bath and North East Somerset, Swindon, and Wiltshire. Each have their own challenges, demographics, and patterns of service use. The issue is not whether one area matters more than another. It's whether local circumstances are properly understood.

District nurses covering rural Wiltshire face very different challenges from those working in more urban areas. Yet many of the staff who contacted me feel that those differences have not been properly recognized. Wiltshire is a large rural county.

Patients can live miles from healthcare facilities. Community nursing teams often spend significant amounts of their days travelling between appointments. And aggregate figures for a large contract area tell part of the story, but they can also obscure local pressures and local problems. A successful service model is one that understands those differences and responds to them. And I'm afraid I have concluded that HCRG does not understand those differences.

When responsibility for community health services was awarded to HCRG in October 2024, patients were promised more joined-up care, easier access to services and simpler overall experiences.

01:32:45 - 01:33:11

Speaker 40

I absolutely will. I thank my honourable friend for giving way and I think she's going to get onto the point in the first in a second, but I will also say thank you to the members of staff that have taken the time to come here and put themselves forward. Does she agree with me that HCRG's promise of improving services through single access point has been a historic failure, and if they do not manage to get back on track, we should be looking at re-evaluating their contracts?

01:33:11 - 01:33:47

Sarah Gibson

Thank you, and I thank the member for his intervention. He's absolutely right. There are serious concerns about what was promised and what has been delivered. And I think that central part of that vision and that delivery was this single point of access. And as the member has highlighted, on paper, that's an attractive idea, but the reality seems to be completely different.

And constituents repeatedly tell me about the long waits for phones, missed call-backs, referrals that are difficult to track and urgent cases not reaching the right team quickly enough.

01:33:47 - 01:34:21

Speaker 41

I will absolutely give way. I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Would she agree with me that one of the most disruptive changes for frontline staff and patients has been the loss of dedicated admin support in favour of the so-called single point of access or SPA that simply does not work? If HCRG is serious about improving services, restoring adequate admin support for clinical teams must surely be part of the solution. Time spent on admin by clinical staff is time spent away from patients.

Thank you.

01:34:21 - 01:35:57

Sarah Gibson

I absolutely agree with my honourable friend and I was, I will come onto that point exactly. But the biggest concern for staff is the patient safety and they have highlighted that very clearly to all of us, I believe. A Chippenham resident told me that they waited an hour to get through to the single point of access, only to be told to expect a call-back that didn't arrive until the following day. A constituent from Calne described spending a week making calls, leaving messages, sending emails, simply to secure a podiatry appointment. In the end, I understand that he was so desperate he just went into the offices.

Not everyone can do that. And I appreciate that the ICB, the commissioners, have the single point of access under surveillance. But as I will return to later, being under surveillance is just not enough for our residents. Many of the concerns raised with me have come not only from patients but also from staff. And I've heard concerns about growing caseloads, vacancies, the loss of experienced staff and as my honourable friend mentioned, the reduction of administrative support.

One nurse reported what had previously been 10 visits per day had increased to approximately 15.

Another described seeing 14 patients during a shift that overran by 90 minutes. Staff speak of chronic understaffing, excessive workloads, and concerns about the impact that these pressures are having both on patients and on the workforce.

01:35:57 - 01:35:58

Will the honourable lady give way?

01:35:58 - 01:35:59

I absolutely will.

01:35:59 - 01:36:38

Jim Shannon

Can I commend the honourable lady for bringing this forward? And the HCRG group that the honourable lady refers to took over the substantial NHS contract to run the community health service in the South West of England. I share the honourable lady's concerns about the long delays faced by patients because similar issues have come up in my constituency as well across Northern Ireland, where they struggle to provide services due to worker shortages and lack of funding. Does the honourable lady agree that the ability of private care providers to deliver NHS contracted services effectively and reliably has to and must be more thoroughly assessed before the contracts are handed out?

01:36:38 - 01:44:51

Sarah Gibson

I thank the honourable member for his intervention, and he's quite right. We are seeing promises not being delivered. Now, whether that is because they are a private service or because of the management of the system is not for me to say, and that's something I'm hoping that the minister will be able to look into. And I have to say, I personally spend a lot of time in the NHS, not out of choice, but as a patient and also as a carer for my husband. And the frontline staff are fabulous.

They go above and beyond to support the patient, regardless of whether that patient happens to be their MP or not. But as their MP, I do find that the staff tend to approach me in confidence to say that they fear using the formal channels for feedback. Patients and staff working across the community-based healthcare system are raising the same issues with me: delays, difficulty navigating the referral pathway, and concerns about whether requests always reach the right clinical team. And I think ministers have a responsibility to take those concerns as seriously as the members sitting next to me. Patient safety is my chief concern since HCRG took over.

One community nurse described families contacting nursing teams because a loved one approaching the end of life was experiencing severe pain despite being told that help would be available. The nurse reported incidents where no referral appeared to have reached the community nursing team at all. Visits were eventually arranged, but the patient spent several hours without adequate pain relief. And a former community nurse separately described obtaining additional medication for palliative patients and not being able to get it. Nobody approaching the end of their life should spend hours in avoidable pain because the system is inadequate.

I have also heard concerns about delayed wound care, time-critical medication, and urgent catheter issues. One district nurse described attending a patient whose leg wounds had leaked through his dressings. His daughter had contacted the service twice over the weekend without receiving assistance. By the time the nurse arrived, the patient had resorted to wrapping plastic bags around his legs. And I understand that the same problem occurred the following weekend.

The concerns I have received are not limited to community nursing. A physiotherapist working in Chippenham Hospital described concerns about the introduction of the new referral system. According to the information, staff noticed that referrals were dropping dramatically with the new system.

But when those delayed referrals were eventually identified and processed, clinicians faced a sudden influx of cases, including urgent post-operative patients. We're talking about knee replacements that are not being seen in a timely manner, in which case they will end up being redone. This is cost for nothing. Clinicians describe patients waiting around eight weeks after these knee replacement surgeries, despite the treatment being expected much sooner. And the concerns raised are not simply about waiting times, but about the possibility of avoidable deterioration and long-term impacts to recovery.

These are not simply administrative inconveniences. They are potential patient safety. I also want to touch briefly on the wheelchair services. I understand Wiltshire currently has one wheelchair technician, where it had originally been intended to have four. And one constituent from Calne told me she was supplied with an unsuitable wheelchair without being properly measured.

She raised the concerns about the difficulty and the safety and the fact that she couldn't get onto the bus. But despite repeated attempts over months to resolve the matter, she's getting nowhere. Other constituent reported from Chippenham that the replacement battery didn't arrive, the updated seating didn't arrive, which meant that they were unable to get to college. When repair and maintenance services are not functioning as they should, the consequences for the patient are immediate and profound. One observation that particularly troubled me was a comment made to me by some patients no longer bothering to complain because they have become accustomed to the delays and the difficulty.

And sometimes the absence of formal complaints reflects a loss of confidence rather than anything else. And this is particularly concerning when we think about older patients, disabled patients, and those who are already struggling to navigate a complex health system. People who find it the hardest to access the services are often the same people least likely to make their voices heard. That's why scrutiny and transparency matters. When constituents raise concerns about the HCRG services, they expect clear, simple answers.

Who is responsible? We have an ICBC contract oversight group reporting to the ICBC collaborative oversight forum. We have the BSW community delivery group overseeing transformation across the system. We have joint contract oversight groups, quality boards, and safeguarding groups, all scrutinizing performance. But many of the same organizations sit across multiple levels of this oversight.

The integrated care board, the local authority commissioners, and the HCRG itself are involved throughout this governance structure. The organizations commissioning the contract, managing the contract, are also scrutinizing the contract. All seem to be on the same table. Frankly, even as elected representatives, I have to say, to a certain extent, we struggle to work out who is accountable. When everyone involved in the oversight, it can be remarkably difficult to identify who is responsible for acting when the problems emerge.

There is a risk that organizations end up marking their own homework. And with concerns passing between governance groups rather than being subjected to genuinely independent challenge, patients deserve a system where responsibility is visible, understandable, and transparent from the outset. Where persistent concerns are being raised about the access to care, referral pathways, and patient safety, it's entirely reasonable to ask whether the Care Quality Commission should take a closer look. An independent scrutiny should not be something we worry about, it should be something we welcome because it will lead to improvement.

And finally, Madam Chair, I'd be grateful if the Minister could address two specific points. Firstly, will she ask BSW's ICB and the HCRG to publish some comparable pre- and post-transformation performance data, including call waiting times, call back performance, referral processing times, complaints and patient outcome, broken down where possible to a local level, so that both the patients and us as parliamentarians can actually see whether those promised improvements have actually been delivered a year and a half into the contract, despite the fact they also had six months before the contract started in order to to provide the transition. And secondly, will she engage with the Care Quality Commission about a case for further independent scrutiny of HCRG's Wiltshire services and clarify what further regulatory action may be available if these persistent concerns about access, referrals and patient safety continue as was referenced by my honorable colleague. Patients don't really care how many committees or meetings are called. What they really want is the answers, and their concern is whether they are getting the care they need when they need it.

01:44:51 - 01:44:53

Speaker 42

Thank you, Madam Chair.

01:44:53 - 01:45:00

Emma Lewell

The question is that this House has considered the performance of HCRG Care Group in the South West. Minister.

01:45:00 - 01:49:16

Karin Smyth

Thank you, Ms. Lewell-Buck, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Can I thank the honorable lady for Chippenham bringing forward this debate and a really well-informed and well-considered set of proposals about a contract about which I'm aware. I it has been on my radar, obviously this was on my radar before the general election and is one that was signed just after the election as a partly as a local MP. And I'm conscious, as I think she said, there are staff here today that this remains a concern of staff and some of the trade unions, not least kept on my radar by my honorable friend the member for Swindon North. So absolutely aware of some of the genesis of of the sort of process of this contracting coming forward.

We won't rehearse that where we are, we are where we are now. But I do want to make sure that people are aware of that. And I mean, I think as she said, what we need to make sure now really is what was promised is delivered. And I and I commit that that's what we all want to see for the people of her community and across the wider ICB. So to be clear on our general expectation around community services, they are really vital and particularly vital to to the left shift.

And this particularly is true, I think, in rural areas, actually. A wide range of services delivered under this umbrella, from district nursing to services provided by allied health professionals such as physiotherapy or OT, services for adults and children where they live in local communities and also really good local jobs. And these are services are vital to support in our ambitions for neighborhood health. And and that is why we set out clear ambitions for them in our medium-term planning framework. And for the first time, we have set a target for systems to reduce long waits for community health services.

By 28-29, at least 80% of activity delivered by community health services should take place within 18 weeks, bringing community health services in line with targets for elective care. We've also published guidance outlining the core components of community health services for children, young people and adults that ICBs should provide. And this is hugely important for many of the issues that she has raised here today. We know there is variation between services available across the country, and we know that people are waiting too long to access community health services. And that's why this government is taking action to reduce unwarranted variation, cut waits and improve access to high-quality community services.

Now, in terms of the performance about HCRG Group, as we know, they have taken on the contract to bring together more than 130 community health and care services across the ICB area. It is a large-scale what is called transformation programme. And since they have been awarded the contract, the ICB obviously has to work very closely with them. And I have met the ICB in advance of this debate to hear from them as well. They are responsible for managing the contract, as I understand it.

That's where we want to get to.

They do, and as she has alluded to these many arrangements, they do have arrangements in place to oversee the quality, the safety, the performance across all those commissioned services, and performance is regularly monitored. I do recognise the concerns about delays, call-backs, and referrals across the teams and getting people across the single point of access. I do say that single points of access are things that have been worked on for many years under many different contracts because generally they should do what they say on the tin and actually help people go forward. So, it, they do need to make it work. And I understand they are increasing that oversight as a result of some of the issues that have been raised, bringing together the provider and systems to support improvement.

And that is really important to bring together patients, carers, local community staff, and stakeholders as they develop that work. And the ICB assures me they remain committed to engaging openly with those communities, with MPs, with Healthwatch, and other stakeholders throughout delivery and community, throughout the delivery and the development of those community services. I'm happy to...

01:49:16 - 01:49:37

Sarah Gibson

Would the Minister agree with me, though, that the level of complexity of the oversight system and the fact that the same people are on every single one of those groups does not help either the staff or the patients feel that there is genuine independent scrutiny of what is actually happening? We are getting the same answers from the same people.

01:49:37 - 01:55:56

Karin Smyth

I will come on, I will come on to some of that overall because it's also tied up with the Health Bill and things that we are proposing to do for the future. And she touched on some of my favourite subjects, which is accountability of local health systems in the time I have available, Ms Lewell-Buck. Can I just talk about the hospital-at-home services, though, because they are also really important, supporting, you know, supporting people, as it says on the tin, to keep people out of hospital where they don't need to be and support early discharge. They do remain a really important part of the community services offering across Bath and North East Somerset, Swindon, and Wiltshire ICB. There have been changes to the service provision.

I am assured by the ICB, and I'm sure she will correct me if that is wrong, that there are no plans to reduce capacity or withdraw the hospital-at-home service. The ICB is currently undertaking a review of the services following concerns raised and will continue to monitor the impact of these changes to ensure safe and effective care is maintained. Again, this is absolutely in the direction of travel that we want to see these services change and improve. We are, we are, I'm going to finish, I'm going to finish the comments if I may in the debate. It is also important, industrial relations, you know, we cannot run a health and care service without good staff, well-supported, and maintaining good industrial relations at a local level.

That is a matter primarily for the group, its employers, and recognised trade unions. And the ICB needs to continue to monitor that and, you know, go through those established processes for doing that. They do need to keep working with them, and we certainly support that at a national level. On the wider issues about supporting ICB performance, and I mean I do sympathise and I've spoken many times in opposition, Ms Lewell-Buck, and in government about the frustrations of local Members of Parliament to understand what was a very fragmented system left under the Lansley reforms. And I do appreciate what she is saying from her position in Chippenham may be different to other positions.

It is a large geographic area, and that is one of the issues that we need to get right and are working very closely on in terms of the Health Bill where we are devolving responsibility and accountability for the commissioning and then the providing of services at a local level.

That is the right thing to do. But we also need to get right in that the link to neighborhoods and place through local authorities and particularly strengthening health and wellbeing boards. That is the direction of travel in the bill and what we are currently trying to make happen. ICBs are held to account nationally for delivering for patients though. The oversight framework provides a transparent approach for assessing performance.

And from 26-27, every ICB, this is something else that we have changed since coming into power, every ICB will be placed in a delivery segment based on national performance measures, helping to identify where greater support, scrutiny, or intervention is needed at that national level. That will be complemented by an annual assessment of how effectively each ICB is discharging its statutory functions. Where performance is falling short, oversight can be increased and support can be targeted to the areas of challenge. And where necessary, formal intervention powers are available, bringing ICBs into line with other providers. So at the same time, we are also, and this is partly through the Health Bill, strengthening ICBs' commissioning capability.

We have the strategic commissioning framework setting out what effective strategic commissioning looks like, and the commissioning development program provides targeted support to strengthen those capabilities in local systems. We recognize that there is variability across the country. So to be clear, ICBs are responsible for assuring the quality, effectiveness, and value of the services they commission, while NHS England oversees the performance of ICBs through the oversight framework, including consideration of how effectively they discharge those commissioning responsibilities. Finally, we have heard issues raised around palliative and end-of-life care. Patients approaching the end of life and those important to them, their closest friends and family, absolutely should receive compassionate, dignified, and personalized care in an appropriate environment.

And that is why the government is committed to improving access to high-quality palliative care and end-of-life care and shifting more care from hospitals into the community and into home where appropriate. NHS England requires ICBs to commission appropriate palliative care and end-of-life care to meet the needs of their local populations. And to support the ICBs in this duty, NHS England has again published statutory guidance and service specifications. In addition to this, we're developing a modern service framework for palliative care and end-of-life care. This will be a clinically-led, evidence-based framework to support sustained improvement in outcomes for patients and carers, including identifying, measuring, and reducing health inequalities and reducing unwarranted variation in access, experience, and outcomes.

So in conclusion, Miss Lewell, we do continue to work hard to strengthen community health services and shift care closer to home. As she said, what was promised to her population and the wider ICB area must be delivered. All too often, community health services do not get the attention that they deserve and the recognition, actually, that staff on the ground deserve too. And I think this debate has raised some important questions about how we are holding organizations to account that are commissioning and delivering services. She asked two specific points about comparable data.

As I think I've outlined, I am committed to, and if anybody hasn't read the transformation packs and opportunity packs I got to all MPs last year about your local systems, I recommend that. I continue to get information on your local systems to all MPs. I think she asks, and I think she probably knows this, she probably can't compare like for like, but she should have that information. We are getting that on stream. I'm happy to write to her with any details of what is available or what might be made more available.

She also asked questions about the CQC. She knows that's an independent regulator, but there's a specific question there. I will make sure that we write to her about that too. And I thank her and other members who've contributed to this debate.

01:55:56 - 02:01:08

Emma Lewell

The question is that this House has considered the performance of HCRG Care Group in the South West. As many are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. Order, order.

The sitting is suspended until 4:30.

Order. Wendy Morton to move the motion.

02:01:08 - 02:03:14

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Ms. Luell. I beg to move that this House has considered the national scheme of delegation of planning functions. And it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. From Saturday, councillors across England will lose powers, powers to bring planning applications before elected committees. For communities like mine in Aldridge-Brownhills that are already facing huge speculative development, this is a serious loss of accountability.

My residents have faced an onslaught of applications on greenbelt sites, including Yorks Bridge for 330 houses, Queslett Road East for 850, Barns Lane for 77, Longwood Lane for 78, and Bosty Lane for 550 houses. This is just some of them. These applications have brought the debate about the future of our countryside very close to people's doors. These green spaces help give our communities their identity. Residents want to know what development will mean for their already busy roads, school places, and access to a GP.

They are right to expect those questions to be properly considered before ministers introduce sweeping changes. Yet here we are, just days, Ms. Luell, before the new rules take effect, still looking for answers. Of the outstanding applications for 2,350 homes across my constituency, it would seem that 80% will be determined on the new rules and behind closed doors. Residents and councillors won't be able to easily ask questions of the developers or raise issues in open committee. Of course, we agree on the need for homes that local people can afford.

I want brownfield sites brought back into use with supporting infrastructure. And as I've said time and time again in this place, and I'll probably still be saying this, once agricultural land is built on, it's gone and it's gone forever. I want to see planning consents built, not banked. So that brings me to the current consultation on the Walsall Borough Local Plan. Of course I will.

02:03:14 - 02:03:54

Jim Shannon

Can I commend the honourable lady, I spoke to her beforehand, and always looking to be helpful, Madam Chair, in what we do back home in Northern Ireland under section 31 of our own Planning Act, each of our 11 district councils is legally mandated to operate its own bespoke scheme of delegation. Whilst this gives local authorities excellent democratic autonomy over local developments, it has at times led to the exact regional inconsistency and application processing times that this new English model explicitly seeks to correct.

So does the honorable lady agree that the information within the Northern Ireland process should be shared to achieve best practice in planning and hopefully address some of the very issues that the honorable lady is highlighting in this debate today?

02:03:54 - 02:05:11

Wendy Morton

Thank you. I'm always grateful to my honorable friend because he always brings useful contributions into Westminster Hall and contributions that we can reflect on and often share on those those different experiences. And I think the fundamental thing here to me is about making sure that our our communities feel that their councillors have a voice rather than what we're faced with is a democratic deficit. So thank you for that. So our local plan consultation closes on Monday and over the last six weeks I've been encouraging residents to respond, holding public meetings, helping with objections, making it clear to them that their views, whatever their views are, matter, including when the plan goes before an independent inspector.

What but what message are these new regulations sending? Residents take the time to go through the documents, attend the meetings and help shape their area's future while the government restricts their councillors' ability to secure full and public scrutiny when an application arrives. This is not democracy in action. It's not scrutiny nor is it accountability. So what is the point of asking communities to invest their time in a local plan if contentious decisions about its application are then to be taken behind closed doors?

02:05:11 - 02:05:13

Speaker 52

Yes, of course I will.

02:05:13 - 02:05:47

Chris Hinchliff

Thank the right honorable lady for giving way. I suspect I'm doing neither myself nor her any favors by saying I absolutely agree with what she's saying. And I think it's our duty as MPs to robustly defend local democracy. So I wonder whether the right honorable lady agrees with me that when the communities we represent and their directly elected councillors oppose speculative development, the answer is not to try and silence their voices but to try and secure genuine public consent with a higher standard of development that meets local needs and hopes for the future.

02:05:47 - 02:06:24

Wendy Morton

I can assure the honorable gentleman that he's certainly not upsetting me by those comments, far from it, because the point that he makes is exactly the one that I'm making, that local democracy and local accountability matters. And it's so important that we include the local voices because it's the local voice that has the local knowledge and to shape the community. And if we want communities that are truly cohesive and that work together, then we need to make sure that their voices are heard, not having targets and housing imposed upon them. I'm spoilt for choice so I'll go that way then I'll go that way.

02:06:24 - 02:07:18

Helen Whately

I thank my right honorable friend very much indeed for letting me intervene on her and for the really important speech that she is making. Recently in my constituency, a development for eight and a half thousand homes which was due to go to the local planning committee was suddenly taken away from them, called in by the neighboring MP for Sittingbourne and the decision now is sitting with the Secretary of State, totally taking that important decision which would make a huge impact on the area out of local hands. This is clearly denying local democracy when we have locally elected councillors who know the kind of impact this development will have on my constituency. So does she agree with me it is completely wrong to take those powers to influence local planning decisions away from local councillors and absurd that a government which talks about increasing devolution is the one that is doing this taking those powers away from local councillors?

02:07:18 - 02:07:26

Wendy Morton

I will simply say spot on to my right honorable friend. She is absolutely right on that point. So I'll give way to my other colleague.

02:07:26 - 02:07:59

Paul Holmes

I thank my right honorable friend for giving way and can I congratulate her on securing this debate. She mentioned accountability and democracy and as she will know the government are currently putting through the representation of the people act which is trying to encourage quite rightly increased participation and accountability within our electoral system. Does she share a concern like I have which is that the role of councillors are undermined by this measure and that people locally actually will lose confidence in the democratic checks and balances of local government and that therefore we may see turnouts and participation actually go down.

02:07:59 - 02:17:55

Wendy Morton

My honorable friend is really right on this point. For a long time it's concerned me that turnout at elections particularly local elections has been falling. And I personally do not believe that the simple answer is just to lower the voting age. What we should be doing cross-party is actually seeking to engage with people and with communities. And actually what we're seeing here is a government that imposes top-down targets, says it's all about devolution, goes through the mayors, but when it actually comes to accountability and scrutiny, I can't scrutinize the mayor of the West Midlands.

He doesn't even reply to my to my letters yet he's getting more powers. And on the local council, the powers come to the through these measures down to local councils and once again local councillors they're losing their voice. Our communities are losing their voices. So how can we say we want to engage with communities? How do we really want to shape the future of our of our country and our communities if we are taking away transparency and accountability, the things which to me are the very foundations of good strong democracy.

Now, delegation is a familiar concept. In fact, the government's own white paper said officers made 96% of planning decisions in the second quarter of 2024, but it cannot become how every application is determined. Where is the evidence about delays as a result of planning committee call-ins? How much arises from waiting for the committee and how much from staffing shortages, outstanding technical advice or the complexity of the process? Under the new rules, ordinary applications for up to nine houses on sites smaller than half a hectare must be decided by officers.

Larger applications are not guaranteed a hearing either. Referral requires the nominated officer and the chair of the planning committee to agree and a test of significance to be met. If they disagree, the decision stays with officers. Even reserved matters for a purely residential scheme of several hundred homes can be subject to mandatory delegation. So why exclude councillors from details that materially change the makeup of their own community?

A ward councillor will know exactly why a proposal matters locally, but under these new rules, cannot make sure it's heard at committee. So it would be helpful if the minister could outline how they will ensure the significance test is applied consistently. What can a councillor do when a well-founded referral request is rejected? How can it be the case that an application concerning a protected tree can still be eligible for committee consideration while an application for nine houses can be excluded? What principle explains that distinction?

Why should councils be able to future to consider the future of a single tree, I'm not saying trees aren't important, but but not the circumstances of a housing development? And then we come to the issue of transparency. Will reasons for refusing to refer an application to committee be published before the application is decided, allowing time to raise an error? Reporting afterwards will give no comfort to concerned residents if permission has already been granted. As the minister will undoubtedly be aware and I do appreciate it's not entirely her her brief today, but some councils are seeking to preserve democratic oversight through informal councillor panels advising on planning applications.

So what assessment has the department made of the risk of developers alleging predetermination where councillors express a view through those panels and subsequently participate in the gateway decision or determine the application at committee?

Could the resulting legal challenges and delays undermine the very housebuilding targets these regulations are intended to support? So I would be really grateful if she or her department would publish clear guidance so councils can retain meaningful elected involvement without creating further uncertainty. There is also the question of neighbourhood plans. One council leader tells me their council has called for applications conflicting with an adopted neighbourhood plan policy to be eligible for committee consideration. Communities spend years and years and thousands of pounds preparing these plans before residents endorse them in a referendum.

They deserve a route to elected scrutiny when an application conflicts with those policies. So will the minister provide that safeguard, including for applications otherwise subject to mandatory delegation? There's a similar concern about houses of multiple occupation, all too often used to house those decanted from asylum hotels. Councils introduced Article 4 directions because they have identified a need for greater control over conversions in particular neighbourhoods, yet applications brought into the planning system by those directions can fall within Schedule 1, preventing elected members from determining them. So will the minister clarify which HMO applications exactly must be delegated and explain why an Article 4 direction provides no exception?

Where an application raises significant concerns about the concentration of HMOs, about parking or the loss of family housing, will they allow councillors to secure a committee hearing? And of course planning officers, let's not forget those, because planning officers also deserve protection. They undertake difficult professional work, often with very limited resources. Moving contentious decisions away from committees has a real risk of leaving them personally exposed. And councils are rightly asking what safeguards will protect officers from undue influence or pressure from developers, from applicants and other interested parties.

Will there be requirements to record substantive discussions, declare conflicts of interest and obtain a second opinion in contentious cases? What independent route will officers have to report improper pressure? Officers must act impartially. So how will the minister prevent them becoming the lightning rod for political criticism when elected members have lost their decision-making role? The Royal Town Planning Institute has warned about the risk of increased abuse and public pressure.

So what support will be funded to protect staff and to help councils retain those important experienced planners? Transparency protects officers and residents alike. People should be able to follow the evidence and understand who decided and why. Accessibility matters too. Developers often have a planning consultant and legal team, whereas residents concerned about an application only have the option to open the planning portal for the very first time.

They shouldn't need professional help to find out whether an application will reach committee, how to ask for scrutiny or whether their concerns have been considered. So will ministers engage in a publicity campaign to update people on those changes and ensure that each authority has an easily understandable explanation of the new process on their website, including how residents can put their case where there is no committee meeting? The Planning Inspectorate also has an important role. An inspector will examine whether the proposed local plan in my constituency meets legal requirements and is sound. Separately, inspectors determine many planning appeals.

But how will local evidence about infrastructure and cumulative green belt loss be considered through these processes? On another point of fairness, or rather the lack of it, applicants can appeal refusals, but residents objecting have no equivalent appeal on planning merits.

So given that imbalance, why weaken scrutiny before the decision? What affordable option will residents realistically have if an application is wrongly kept away from the committee? And a separate part of this new scheme requires councils to consult the Secretary of State before refusing applications for 150 or more homes. How will that operate transparently? How can residents make representations?

Ministers are creating an additional opportunity for Whitehall interference and involvement while restricting elected local councillors. And this, Ms Lewell, undoubtedly creates a democratic deficit. How does that really sit with the Prime Minister's promises on devolution and community empowerment? I don't see how it does. The LGA Conservative Group has organized a letter with more than 1500 Conservative councillors calling for this scheme of delegation to be repealed, and I'd like to put on record my thanks to them for that.

Let's hope the Prime Minister gives it his urgent attention when it's delivered to him at Number 10 tomorrow. Ms Lewell, to conclude, we all know councils must comply with the law, but we must remember that agreeing to update their constitutions does not mean they consent to these regulations or believe that they serve their communities. A government that talks about devolution should trust local representatives and trust communities. So I hope the minister will reconsider these regulations, and at the very least, they should restore an effective route to committee for contentious applications, to protect neighborhood plans and Article 4s and provide clear safeguards for officers. So before the scheme takes effect on Saturday, this Saturday, will the minister commit to those changes and an early published assessment of its impact ahead of the statutory review in 2028?

My constituents are being asked to engage with their local plan by Monday. I want to be able to tell them that doing so will make a difference and that their elected councillors will still have a meaningful role when decisions are taken. That is the assurance that I'm seeking today. Thank you.

02:17:55 - 02:18:01

Emma Lewell

The question is that this House has considered the national scheme of delegation of planning functions. Olly Glover.

02:18:01 - 02:22:24

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Ms Lewell. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and can I thank the honorable member for Aldridge-Brownhills for setting out her case so well. I think the starting point here has to be that government needs to be clear what problem and the causes of that problem they are trying to solve. I think the vast majority of people in this House would agree that we need more housebuilding, ideally affordable and social, with a particular focus on that. But the causes as to why we're not hitting the government's housing targets are many, and they certainly should not be lazily reduced to blaming it on the planning system or indeed planning committees.

And that's why the solutions that the government seeks to deal with that housebuilding shortage in terms of targets should be based on evidence and not ideology. And I fear, Ms Lewell, that sometimes ideology is more of what dominates. Removing local scrutiny in the way that has been described will not address the underlying causes of delay, including capacity constraints in planning departments and the wider construction supply chain. We need a planning system that is simpler, more effective, and capable of delivering the homes that are well-built, warm, and cheap to heat, but also is accountable to local people and their representatives. Looking at the two district councils that cover my Oxfordshire constituency, South Oxfordshire and Vale of White Horse District Councils, the planning committee works well and there is no evidence it is slowing development down.

95% of planning applications are decided by officers already. The majority of those debated by the planning committees are also passed, but having more complex and more contentious planning decisions made in public aids transparency and scrutiny over how planning policies are being applied. On Vale of White Horse, it has an excellent record on planning appeals. Only 4.3% of appeals were allowed over the past two years, demonstrating that the decisions being made under the existing system is working well and is of high quality. In Didcot and Wantage, my constituency, we've seen huge rates of housing growth over the past 15 years, and the key frustration for local people is that the infrastructure has not kept pace.

And a lot of the time, the local councils, they are not the ones who are able to dictate what we need in terms of housing or new railway stations and in terms of health and significant infrastructure like that is not something they have direct control over. Reducing the input of local communities and removing the ability for local ward councillors to call planning decisions to a committee could reduce the opportunity for those who understand our communities best to influence the infrastructure that developers provide alongside new homes. And over the past few years, there have been signs that house building is slowing down. The build rate of homes on some of the larger developments in my part of Oxfordshire has slowed. But the government has misdiagnosed the cause for slower build rates.

Planning committees are not the cause of build rates slowing. There are wider economic causes and wider system causes. Developers will only build the homes they're confident of selling. More expensive mortgages and potential buyers not feeling confident about investing in buying a home are significant factors. On the Planning and Infrastructure Bill, which I had the pleasure of serving on alongside the honourable member for Hamble Valley who is in this chamber, I'm sure we all have very, we both have very fond memories of it and a very rewarding and fulfilling experience it was.

And indeed the Conservative spokesperson also served on that committee. It was on topics such as the one we're debating today where there were common amendments between Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, and Green Party honourable members. Now how often does that happen? And were I the government, I would be very wary about uniting such three very different parties. Now in conclusion, in conclusion, the wider philosophical problem that we fail to address as a parliament, as a country, is this tension between national need versus local concern.

And I think we need to start approaching that question intelligently. And yet it becomes yet another of these debates that becomes polarized with two tribes shouting at each other and not really engaging in dialogue. Maybe we need more of ministers coming to areas affected by significant planning issues. I'm not talking about a little cul-de-sac of new houses, maybe very significant infrastructure projects. If ministers were more willing to come to our constituencies, they themselves can make the case and directly debate and challenge local opponents.

I'll give way to the honourable lady.

02:22:24 - 02:22:43

Wendy Morton

I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman and just on that point, I would actually be delighted if the minister came to Aldridge-Brownhills and they could see the impact that 20,000 homes will have across the borough where we have no, well a lack of infrastructure and I'm still waiting for the funding for Aldridge railway station.

02:22:43 - 02:23:35

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I thank the right honourable lady for her intervention and I was amazed that she didn't mention that station campaign in her opening speech, but she's now rectified that omission. And ministers coming and engaging directly in that way could be part of a campaign of national persuasion to really tackle the causes as to why people resent development in a given area. But too often it is left to large corporate interests to do so, which fuels mistrust. And indeed in my constituency, the main advocate of what would be the second biggest reservoir in the country is Thames Water. And of course that really does not help to persuade people of the case and is one of the major reasons why there's significant local opposition.

I do agree with the right honorable lady in her speech and indeed the honorable member for Hamble Valley that these changes that are being made by the government do run the risk of further eroding trust in local politics and local democracy and that is in none of our interests.

02:23:35 - 02:27:19

Paul Holmes

Thank you very much, Ms. Low, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And can I congratulate my right honorable friend the member for Aldridge-Brownhills on securing this debate and welcome the minister to her position since the government reshuffle. Ms. Low, I have serious concerns about this policy and agenda and specifically regarding the future of the ability of residents to have a meaningful say in the development of their own communities. I'm happy now that I'm no longer shadow housing minister that I can speak about these things in much more of a free way in which I possibly could at the dispatch box, although I know that my honorable friend the member for Broxbourne will be absolutely excellent in his winding up today. And like the member for honorable member for my honorable friend actually for Didcot and Wantage, I have very fond memories of the bill committee where I often found myself going home in the evening and thinking how could I have agreed with the Liberal Democrats so much.

But I looked in myself in the mirror, had a wash and got over that the next morning. But Ms. Low, planning decisions as we know shape our towns and villages for generations to come and they determine where new homes are built, how much pressure is placed on roads, schools and healthcare services and whether the character of our neighborhoods is preserved. These decisions have real consequences for the people who live with them every day and it is therefore essential that local residents have a meaningful opportunity to influence them. And I say to the minister my big concern that we warned about in the planning committee in the Planning and Infrastructure Bill Committee was that this government seems ardent on taking those decisions and influence away from local people. Because the government's proposed approach risks weakening the democratic safeguards that allow communities to have their voices heard.

This policy represents a significant shift in the balance between professional planning officers and elected local representatives. And one of the most concerning aspects of these reforms is the removal of existing arrangements that allowed ward councillors to request committee consideration or enabled an application to be referred automatically when a specified number of objections had been received. Under the new scheme, the volume of objections cannot in itself justify referral to committee. Instead, applications must meet the national criteria and the nominated officer and nominated councillor must agree that they should be referred. Consider what that means for residents who have legitimate concerns about a development in their neighborhood.

They may organize a petition, write detailed objections and encourage their neighbors to participate in the consultation process, yet the strength of that opposition will not in itself guarantee that elected councillors will debate the application in public. Residents retain the right to submit representations, but their ability to secure committee scrutiny is restricted. And that raises the question, what is the point of encouraging people to participate in local planning consultations if the system provides fewer opportunities for their elected representatives to consider their concerns publicly? And why, if we allow this to go ahead on Saturday as I suspect it will, why many people will be asking in my parish councils or in my borough council or on my county council, why would people bother voting for their councillor? Planning decisions are one of the most public-facing decisions that a councillor makes.

They live in their communities, they know that if a housing development is being built round the corner or a pub is being closed to be converted into something else, they know what should be referred to their planning committee. This is being taken away for a faceless officer to make that decision instead and that is not accountable.

02:27:19 - 02:27:34

Sarah Green

I thank the honorable member for giving way. In Buckinghamshire we don't yet have a local plan and right now we're seeing speculative application after speculative application going in. Does he agree with me that removing the right for ward councillors to call those applications in not only undermines accountability, it makes our green belt even more vulnerable?

02:27:34 - 02:31:13

Paul Holmes

I entirely agree with the honorable lady because the councils are going through a process to develop a local plan.

They will know alongside officers which applications should be able to be called in if a local plan is ratified. If there is no local plan and you have small speculative developments happening across a whole constituency, that soon adds up. And if the honourable lady's constituents won't be able to play a massive part in being able to shape those developments and craft those developments, it begs the question what do they serve for? And I think that will be the question that is resoundingly going across local government this afternoon. A national framework cannot be expected to capture every local nuance.

While the government argues that the scheme will create greater consistency and allow committees to focus on significant applications, there is a risk that standardisation, if I said that correctly, will come at the expense of local discretion. Consistency should not be preventing councils from responding to the particular needs and concerns of their residents. And I say, Ms Lewell, minor delegations do not mean that planning decisions are any less important. And I'll give her an example in my constituency. There is a pub called the Pear Tree Inn in Boarley Green that is owned by a brewery who wanted to sell off a huge amount of the local play area and car park for six houses.

Local councillors were dead against it. It was the only local pub in the area. It's a very valued asset to the local community. Under this scheme, that would not be able to be referred by a ward councillor. It would not be able to be debated by ward councillors who represent the community.

I as the Member of Parliament could make a written representation but wouldn't be able to go to a planning committee led by councillors to make that decision. And that is fundamentally wrong. Which is why now a parish council is being able to submit that pub under current legislation, submit that pub to be an asset of community value. If an officer was making that decision without the importance of a referral by a ward member, then that decision would not be the same as the one that has happened, an excellent decision by Eastleigh Borough Council to refuse that planning permission by its ward councillors who were elected by the people that live there. Now, I'm not against building new homes and nor am I arguing against the expertise of planning officers.

It's an argument for ensuring that development takes place alongside transparency, public participation, and democratic accountability. If the government wants communities to support development, it must recognise that people are more likely to have confidence in the decisions when they feel their voices have genuinely been heard. Finally, Ms Lewell, this government has spoken hugely, today in the budget has spoken hugely about devolution and empowering local people. And she will not get, the minister will not get any argument against that from me. I hope that she brings the mayoral elections for Hampshire forward to 2027, her department.

But she can't have it both ways. She can't devolve to local people while taking away some of the most retail decisions that councillors and locally elected people make on behalf of those people with one hand and give with the other. That is a topsy-turvy world. It will cause the government huge issues with resentment from local people about the public participation processes that they're expected to undertake, particularly with mayoral elections. And I ask her seriously to go back to the department, I appreciate it's not all within her brief, but she goes back to the department and gives the strength of feeling that this government is making and doing against locally elected councillors.

They are not happy, neither are we, and more importantly, neither are the people in which we serve.

02:31:13 - 02:31:21

Emma Lewell

For our final two backbench contributions, if possible if you could keep them to five minutes each so we can hear from the front bench. Victoria Collins.

02:31:21 - 02:34:54

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Ms Lewell-Buck, it's a pleasure to chair under your chairmanship and I congratulate the right honourable member for Aldridge-Brownhills on securing this important debate.

Moira from Tring asked me, "How can we take back our democracy, which is being eroded at a shocking rate?" And yes, she's talking about planning. She's talking about this change. She'd read about these planning decisions that were being taken from the councillors that she has elected. And she is absolutely right.

First, the Conservative government with their top-down targets, and now this Labour government, who just keep taking power away from local councils and therefore communities. There have been continuous changes to the National Planning Policy Framework with over 3,000 drafting changes, all taking power away. The introduction of grey belt has effectively opened our green belt to developers. Even higher top-down targets mean that, for example, this week, after St Albans have adopted a housing plan, the government are adding 9,000 more. And for Dacorum, the other side of my constituency, another 6,000 more, again after a local plan has just been secured.

And all while we are facing Luton Airport expansion and Bedford Universal Studios, which are impacting infrastructure on local people. And now from this Saturday, this latest regulation means officers must decide householder applications and schemes of up to nine homes. And ward councillors and town and parish councillors lose the right to call them in, as has been reiterated by members across the chamber today. And what has also been eloquently highlighted by the honorable member previously, the scale and nature of planning applications doesn't necessarily imply they're not controversial or important. These are even small things have a massive impact on our community.

And it doesn't mean that just because they're under this scope that they don't deserve to be looked at more closely by a committee of democratically elected councillors. And so Lib Dem councillors from Dacorum and St Albans are horrified and share Moira's concerns. But their hands will be tied by this regulation and legal challenge thanks to this government. And in light of this, Liberal Democrat Dacorum Borough Council have voted to hold an extra meeting of its development management committee so as many called-in applications as possible can be heard before the new changes take effect. But this is no way to run our country or local councils.

And what they really need are long-term changes to planning law that support local communities' voices, like whether it's from Tring, Redbourn, Berkhamsted, Sandridge. And all they want to do is get planning right for the place where they live and raise legitimate concerns about their everyday lives. They know that we need to build. They want a say in the homes, the buildings, and infrastructure that will impact their lives. And ministers have said, and as the member for Didcot and Wantage highlighted, there has been an excuse about this will speed up house building.

But actually, and the member for Aldridge-Brownhills I think also raised it, but actually in terms of planning permission, a survey showed of 62 councils found that over 200,000 homes with planning permission still haven't started. And so committees are not the bottleneck. And so if this government truly believes in power in every postcode, if they're going to walk the walk instead of just talk the talk, people will feel it in their planning. It is so vital. So will the minister and the government stop taking powers away from local communities and actually give them the powers back about their homes, the infrastructure to get it right?

02:34:54 - 02:40:03

Vikki Slade

Will they restore call-in for ward councillors and town and parish councillors and tackle the real problem, unbuilt homes with use-it-or-lose-it planning permission? And will they also look at wider reforms to bring our communities with us? Thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Snelgrove. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. And I want to thank the right honorable member for Aldridge-Brownhills for securing this important debate, which I know will be so important to those people in my constituency of Mid Dorset and North Poole.

And new homes as well as sitting empty as well as unbuilt homes. And I hope the minister can pass a message back to the Secretary of State that I am still waiting for the promised meeting that she said I could have in the chamber. But today I want to focus specifically on the schedule one in the scheme of delegations. And I accept that the vast majority of planning applications are rightly determined by professional officers. But when applications are controversial, where communities have legitimate concerns or residents simply need confidence that their voices have been heard, these committees play a really vital role.

They are not there to frustrate development, they're there to improve it. They bring together the three important sides: professional advice, local knowledge and public scrutiny, allowing elected representatives to listen to applicants, officers and residents and identify solutions to make development more acceptable to everyone. They are often the best of democracy and they can be the closest many of our constituents get to influencing the places where they live. Recent examples from my area shared by Lib Dem councillors today demonstrate that value. In one application considered and refused today, the councillors refused an application based on height, density and design, but were able to debate how the proposal could better fit with the character of an area.

In a case last month, members considered the impact of neighbors of three bungalows being squeezed onto a plot for one and discussed the conditions that might make a future application more acceptable. Both were rejected today, but they expect them to come back, but better. That ability to shape development rather than just approve or reject it is a crucial part of the process. Now supporters of the changes argue that community engagement should take place through local plans, and I do understand that, but local plans and planning committees serve very different purposes and different timelines. As has already been explained by my colleague from Chesham and Amersham, local plans are often out of date and when they're rewritten, they create a bird's eye view of a community.

They don't see inside the window of a poorly placed neighbor's extension. They can allocate land but they can't tell you if a particular design respects the character of a street or whether a historic feature like the the wall in my ward which was built by Italian prisoners of war should be retained. That's only something local councillors and local residents know. And with the funding slashed for neighborhood plans which the honorable member for Ribble Valley and I were discussing when we were on the devolution bill together, now communities don't even have the opportunities to create those new neighborhood plans to get that much closer position. I want to give you another example that was also shared with me today in Poole where a recommendation for a HMO was going to be approved and had there not been local concern, it would not have gone to committee where a mistake was discovered.

A mistake that meant that the planning officer thought that meant that nine additional properties were going to be created and therefore the housing capacity would be affected when in fact a HMO does not create nine additional properties. If it had not gone to planning committee, that mistake would have not been able to be fixed because the decision would have been published too late, community wouldn't have had their say. These people are not blockers, they are trying to make their communities better. They recognize that planning officers make the recommendations on law and policy, but they contextualize it. Another issue that hasn't been covered is that many planning applications are now determined from afar.

Since COVID, we've had planning officers working from Northern Ireland and only seeing the sites on Google Maps. It's the councillors are the ones that can tell you the context of whether a site is overhanging another, not somebody who's been shipped in on a contract from afar. The government frequently speaks about devolution and empowering communities, but devolution should mean trusting local people and their elected representatives, not reducing their involvement in decisions that affect the places where they live.

And one Dorset resident who put it to me today put it far better than I. They said, if a community is going to feel it's been completely shafted by a decision, there should at least be a meaningful opportunity to secure measures that address its concerns and help rebuild trust in the process. That ultimately is what planning committees provide: trust, transparency, and democratic legitimacy. By removing that layer of local decision-making, we may make some decisions faster, but we risk weakening public confidence in the planning system itself.

02:40:03 - 02:42:16

John Milne

Thank you, Mr. Ullah, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I congratulate the honorable member for Aldridge-Brownhills on securing this debate. The Liberal Democrats are deeply concerned by the introduction of a national scheme of delegation, which gives the Secretary of State sweeping powers and allows planning decisions to bypass local planning committees. We opposed this approach throughout the passage of the Planning and Infrastructure Act, including by seeking to protect the existing powers of committees. Faster planning decisions should come from properly resourced planning departments and by giving the councils the freedom to set planning fees that truly reflect the cost of their job, not by shutting communities out of decisions about their local area.

On Saturday, a national scheme of delegation will come into force. Every council in England must rewrite its constitution to match it, and none has been given a say on whether to do so. Planning is where most people first meet local democracy, as many members have said. It's one of the most important reasons why they vote for a councillor in the first place. Household applications, minor commercial applications, schemes of up to nine homes, and a range of technical decisions must now go to officers.

For other applications, a committee can step in only where it raises a significant issue and an officer and nominated member both agree. A councillor cannot refer an application alone. The ward member's call-in has gone, and so has the route by which enough objections would bring an application to committee. Nine homes next to your own is not a minor matter if that's your home. And councillors, of course, will still be blamed for this.

When something is built that nobody wanted, residents will ask their councillor why, and the honest answer will be that they had no control over it whatsoever. The government's case is that committees slow things down, but the reality is that this country does not have a permissions problem in the first place. Councils already approve nine in ten applications. The, sorry, I've lost my place.

02:42:16 - 02:42:53

Paul Holmes

I will, yes, thank you. I thank the Lib Dem spokesman for giving way. He will know that both the Liberal, in fact, as the honorable member for Didcot and Wantage said, that the Liberal Democrats, Conservatives, Greens, and a cross-party delegation on the bill committee came up with sensible amendments to try and make sure that there was a balance between efficiency in the planning system and the criteria to which officers might be able to have decisions, more decisions, but still involving local councillors. I wonder if he could elaborate on what some of his thoughts are on where the balance is between councillors and planning officers.

02:42:53 - 02:44:34

John Milne

I thank the member for his intervention and I very much agree, and I'll come on to that. Removing local scrutiny, as this scheme does, touches none of these problems. Where delay is real, it lies in planning departments running at about 80% of the staff that they actually need, and with one in five major applications decided on time, and in fees that the government accepts do not cover the cost of the work. The Liberal Democrats said so throughout the passage of the Planning and Infrastructure Act, and my honorable friend the member for Taunton and Wellington tabled 78 amendments in committee and more than 50 on report, part of which was to protect planning committees. Unfortunately, the government did not accept any of these amendments.

The government has decided that residents are just a nuisance to be overcome. By these measures, which come on top of years of reduced neighbor control, they have killed one bird with a thousand stones. It's not as if local people had much say over things even beforehand.

The Liberal Democrats regret the lack of any attempt to build consensus, and this is just storing up problems and resentment for the future, as members have said. So I ask the minister, will the government let a ward member bring an application to committee on behalf of residents as the locally elected official? Will it look again at the standard method, which is the flawed formula that sets local targets? Will it commit to telling us in plain terms whether this change is doing what it's supposed to by 2028 at the latest? And finally, national fees are planned at an estimated 90% cost recovery, so will the government commit to full cost recovery so that planning departments are properly resourced?

02:44:34 - 02:44:44

Speaker 64

Basically, we need to rediscover the principle of consent.

02:44:44 - 02:47:17

Lewis Cocking

Thank you, Mr. Howell, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and take part in this debate about the national scheme of delegation. I want to start by thanking the right honorable, my right honorable friend, the member for Aldridge-Brownhills, for securing this important debate, and I know the right honorable lady always fights to protect the green belt in her constituency. And I was sitting here reflecting on what members had said, and I don't think there's much I disagreed with, and it took me back, and I know a number of members across this chamber were on the bill committee, and it took me back to some of the arguments we thrashed out on that debate. When I speak to constituents right across Broxbourne, planning is one of the biggest issues that comes up door after door, election after election. And we know from hearing the accounts from members from across the house today that this is also the case elsewhere across the United Kingdom, right from Aldridge-Brownhills to Hamble Valley, to name a few.

The government would love for everyone to think that local councillors are the main barrier to housebuilding. They want to move to a system where new applications all over the green belt are rubber-stamped by officials instead. The truth of the matter, as who, as already has been said, the vast majority of planning decisions are already made by officers, as many as 96% according to the government's own figures. The national scheme of delegation won't magically fix the Secretary of State's failure to build the 1.5 million new homes that she promised. What these measures will do is undermine local government and expand the state even more.

Unfortunately, we see it time and time again. The same developer comes along with a plan entirely inappropriate for the local area. Perhaps there are vague promises for a school or a park that we know that will never get built, and the local community make their views very clear that they do not want to see these plans. Even when the council's planning committee vote against them, they get overruled by the planning inspector as they decide a sum of the land is grey belt rather than green belt, often, as has already been said, without even visiting the site. That, Madam Chair, is just not right.

The Labour government are forcing massive new housing developments on areas like Goffs Oak in my constituency, whilst reducing targets in London to cover up Sadiq Khan's failings. And this is at the same time that we've got a Prime Minister that is going on and on about devolution, how local leaders are the ones best placed to make local decisions. This is so inconsistent. I will give way.

02:47:17 - 02:47:50

Wendy Morton

Just on that, on that point about local leaders making decisions and showing leadership, does he agree with me that it's important that we actually see that? Because in areas like Walsall, what we're not seeing from the new leadership there from the reform council is really strong leadership on this. And one of the areas that I really think needs some more pushback on is looking at duty to cooperate with other areas, because in our area, Birmingham's housing target has gone down, ours has gone up. There are some towns and cities in neighboring counties that actually want more housing and have more brownfield.

02:47:49 - 02:49:46

Lewis Cocking

She's right to mention the duty to cooperate, and local leaders must step up to the plate. That is what they're elected to do, and that is what their residents expect. Residents, as I said, expect their local councillors to represent them, not hide behind the duty to cooperate. They must cooperate across borders. They don't need powers taken away from them and given to unaccountable bureaucrats in distant council headquarters.

I thank the honorable lady for that intervention, and I completely agree with her.

Under the national scheme of delegation, proposals for under ten properties will only be looked at by planning officers. This means that only in very limited circumstances there will be no way for councillors, local councillors, to bring those decisions before a planning committee. Planning officers are not elected, and they are not accountable to voters. Everyone knows that sometimes planning officers get this wrong, and the decisions need to be overturned. I've seen it, I've served on a planning committee, and the trouble is, once a planning application gets approval, once it gets built, it's there for a very long time.

It's very difficult to rectify it once it goes wrong. Does the government really think that unelected officials are better placed to make decisions on local issues than elected councillors? People vote for their councillors to represent them on planning issues and can hold their councillors accountable at the ballot box. But here, it's just not what is at stake. Planning is at stake, but trust in politics as a whole is also at stake.

Removing powers from elected representatives is an attack on British democracy, and the British people can see right through it. Local action groups like Goscote Community Association are already fighting tooth and nail to stop their towns and villages being wrecked by inappropriate developments, which are often proposed without any sort of adequate infrastructure. The government clearly does not care about their views, otherwise they wouldn't be bringing in this national scheme of delegation. These changes also ignore the fact that planning committees are not just there to approve or deny applications. Councillors talk with local people and can address their concerns by putting conditions on development, which has already been... I will give way.

02:49:46 - 02:50:16

Paul Holmes

He raises a good point, and there's another concern that I have is that if you're looking at infrastructure such as healthcare facilities or more importantly larger scale road networks, quite often locally elected councillors and MPs work together to secure the funding from central government but also maybe a county council. My concern, and I wonder if he shares it, that in some of these larger schemes that are going to be decided by planning officers, the ability to get that multi-layered approach to funding actually will not be there because there will not be the political will to do so.

02:50:16 - 02:50:51

Lewis Cocking

My honorable friend is absolutely right. If we don't have local people having a say over planning applications, that includes local councillors with the input from the local community and MPs, we will not have development that comes forward with the appropriate infrastructure. And that is what our constituents from right across the country expect. I'm pleased to say that my party has firmly stood against these proposals from the start. And if the minister really wants to deliver on the government's promise to devolve power to every postcode across the United Kingdom, then she will stop this attack on local democracy and bin this scheme once and for all.

02:50:51 - 02:52:44

Speaker 67

Thank you, Mr. Llwyd, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. As honorable members have identified, I am not the minister for housing. The minister for housing is in another committee as we speak, but I am pleased to respond on behalf of the government, and I will make sure the strength of feeling and further questions that have been raised today are fed back. I will not persistently intervene, I can assure you, but just with that on that specific point, can the minister reassure me that where questions are asked today and if she is unable to answer, and I appreciate it's not her portfolio, could she ensure that the minister responds to those of us on this committee and publicly in writing before these regulations come into force on Saturday? Because it's absolutely critical that members here and councillors across the country fully understand the implications.

I will ensure that that request is fed back to the Minister for Housing and the strength of feeling is on it as well. I would like to thank the right honorable member for Aldridge and Brownhills for securing today's important debate, and I'd also like to thank all the honorable members for their contributions on the subject. The modernization of planning committees, as many will know, is a big part of the housing and infrastructure delivery that the government intends on. Our reforms here are about creating a level playing field across the country to give certainty to both communities and developers about the process their applications will follow. We recognize the vital role that planning committees play in providing local democratic oversight for important development decisions in their area.

Our reforms were a key measure in the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, and they're intended to support them in this crucial role so that they can be as effective as possible. In doing so...

02:52:44 - 02:53:11

Paul Holmes

I thank the minister for giving way, and I won't intervene on her any further. She talks about giving people certainty, but the certainty that could have been created by this government is putting the planning system, standardized the planning system in favor of councillors making the decisions that they were sent to local councils to make. The reason that the government hasn't is because they have made a political decision to take that power away. Does she agree with that?

02:53:11 - 02:54:39

Speaker 67

I don't agree with that, and there was extensive consultation done around this policy before it was brought in. I believe there was three rounds of consultation in fact done. The national scheme of delegation, which will come into force this Sunday, will allow committees to focus on the larger and more complex development proposals which really require member input. These are the applications which matter most to communities and those which will deliver the kind of development that local people desperately want to see. We also want to ensure that skilled planning officers in councils are trusted and empowered to make decisions on more applications and more quickly to ensure development is brought forward in the right place at the right time.

The national scheme of delegation will mean that officers will spend less time and resource prepping for committee meetings on for smaller applications, speed up decision-making processes more broadly, and freeing up time to focus on larger and more complex applications. It will also provide greater clarity and consistency across the country about who in a local planning authority will determine applications. And irrespective of whether a decision is made by an officer or a planning committee, the important thing is that both are working to serve the interests of their community. I want to thank the member for Didcot and Wantage who praised his council's record in relation to planning, and I hear the concerns he's raised and as I've said will make sure that is fed back. The government...

02:54:39 - 02:54:51

Speaker 68

I thank the minister for giving way, and I didn't want to interrupt her flow, but she said that planning officers are there to serve their community as well. Could she explain what the community can do if they're not happy with those decisions that the planning officer makes?

02:54:51 - 02:59:44

Speaker 67

I will come to that later in my speech, but I will just canter through because I'm just very conscious of time. The government has been very clear during the many consultations and parliamentary debates on these planning committee reforms that they are not in any way intended to be an attack on local democracy. We recognize that councillors and communities are central to deciding what development is right for their area, and that the government believes the best way for them to do that is at the beginning of the process when the local plan is being developed. The national scheme of delegation will support the plan-led system. It will allow planning committees to operate as effectively as possible.

For example, they will not need to revisit the same decisions that have already been considered through the local plan process. Instead, they will be able to focus on those applications which really require member input. I must also stress that decision-makers, whether they are members or officers, must determine applications in accordance with the local plan, unless other material considerations indicate otherwise.

And having an up-to-date local plan will have the biggest bearing on the outcome of a robust decision. Importantly, we are not changing the consultation rules on planning applications. Local residents and elected councillors will still be able to make their views known on individual applications. And regardless of who the decision maker is, where those representations relate to the planning merits of the development, they will continue to be taken into account in reaching decisions. On transparency and reporting, it's clearly important local communities know about the decisions that are being made on their behalf.

This includes decisions on the referral of schedule two applications to the committee. We've set out requirements for this in the statutory guidance to which local authorities must have regard. And as a minimum, we would expect local authorities to keep a record of cases the nominated officer and the nominated member have considered for referral to the committee, the outcome of their consideration and the reasons for their decision. And this should be reported to the planning committee on a regular basis and made available on the authority's website. In relation to a couple of points raised around HMOs, a strong local plan, particularly featuring HMOs, should be able to guide planning officers.

But I will ask the minister to write to honourable members who raised that and provide further information on it. And I will also feedback in relation to websites and the council advertising campaign as well. In relation to devolution and powers of strategic authorities, I am, as it happens, the minister for the devolution strategy and the rewiring the state plan. And we will be setting that out later this year as part of the government's ten-year plan. And I think that honourable members will see that this government is serious about putting power back in communities.

And part of that is having a strengthened local government. And I can give an example in my own strategic authority. We announced this week that we will be reopening Doncaster Sheffield Airport, which is going to have a massive impact on the local community in terms of jobs and growth. And this is a prime example of how rewiring the state can bring the power and prosperity that has been referenced today. In relation to mandatory training for members, the government's priority has been getting the national scheme of delegation in place.

Now that is complete, there'll be resuming work on member training. Further stakeholder engagement is needed as to how we'll make that credible and cost-effective system. And I know the minister will work with local government and honourable members to ensure that that is robust. On the approach to the size of the committees, planning committees need to be the right size for informed decision-makings. There's been examples of sprawling committees having unruly debates and not getting anywhere.

The intention behind introducing the cap was to ensure that they're more focused and better quality. I think initially the planning committees were going to have eleven members, but that's been increased to thirteen, representing that some because some councils are represented by a number of political parties. And that is as a direct feedback from consultation. On the national scheme of delegation, it's something new. We recognise the need to ensure that it works on the ground as intended.

And that's why following the consultation on the draft regulations earlier this year, we inserted further provision into the regulations to require that they are reviewed within two years of coming into force. This will give opportunity to monitor the implementation of the regulations. I take the request that this is looked at before the two-year mark. And I will feed that back to the minister and ask him to come back, even if it's some kind of interim or informal assessment of how that has been going. Once again, I'm grateful to the right honourable member for Aldridge and Brownhills for securing this debate and for the contributions from other colleagues on this important issue.

I recognise that not all the questions raised may have been answered, but I'll ensure the minister comes back to honourable members where I haven't had the time to do so. And I would like to close by reiterating that the reforms to planning committees, including the national scheme of delegation, are intended to support, not undermine committees. We want them to be as effective as they possibly can so they serve the best interests of our communities.

02:59:44 - 02:59:48

Emma Lewell

Wendy Morton to sum up, if you can do it in a few seconds.

02:59:48 - 03:00:11

Wendy Morton

I'd like to thank all those across the House for their contributions today. It's clear that there is a lot of cross-party support, but it is noticeable that some of those who protesteth about saving the green belt, namely our Reform colleagues across in the House, are nowhere to be seen in this Westminster Hall. So I know who's fighting for residents and who's standing up to protect the green belt.

03:00:11 - 03:00:11

Order, the sittings stands adjourned.