House of Commons

7 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:17 - 00:24
Speaker 2
Order, order.  Anneliese Midgley. 
00:24 - 01:10
Speaker 9
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  I beg to move that Mr. Speaker do issue his warrant to the Clerk of the Crown to make out a new writ for the electing of a member to serve in this present Parliament for the borough constituency of Holborn and St Pancras in the room of the Right Honourable Sir Keir Rodney Starmer, who since his election for the said borough constituency has been appointed to the office of Steward and Bailiff of His Majesty's Three Chiltern Hundreds of Stoke, Desborough and Burnham in the county of Buckingham. 
01:10 - 02:00
Speaker 6
The question is that I do issue my warrant to the Clerk of the Crown to make out a new writ for electing of a member to serve in the present Parliament for the borough constituency of Holborn and St Pancras in the room of Right Honourable Sir Keir Rodney Starmer, who since his election to the said borough constituency has been appointed to the office of Steward and Bailiff of His Majesty's Three Chiltern Hundreds of Stoke, Desborough and Burnham in the county of Buckingham.  As many of that opinion say aye.  I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.  Right, we now come to questions to Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, Josh Newbury. 
02:00 - 02:02
Speaker 1
Number one please, Mr. Speaker. 
02:02 - 02:42
Speaker 5
Welcome back.  Thank you, Mr. Speaker, I'm delighted to have been appointed Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government and it's great to be back answering questions from this dispatch box, in fact I like it so much I thought we'd do a statement straight afterwards as well.  I'd like to pay tribute to my predecessor, the right my right honourable friend the member for Streatham and Croydon North and his team for their hard work, Mr. Speaker.  Our new National Planning Policy Framework strengthens support for green spaces by requiring local plans to set standards for green infrastructure and increasing support for new and improved community facilities and public service infrastructure. 
02:42 - 03:14
Speaker 3
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to warmly welcome the Secretary of State and her team to their places, it is fantastic to see my right honourable friend back at the heart of government.  This summer's relentless wildfires have brought home the vital importance of green spaces and woodlands to us in Cannock Chase.  But I've heard from residents of new estates like Norton Hall Meadow in Norton Canes that their woodlands have been badly neglected by private management companies.  So will the Secretary of State ensure that as we build new homes across the country, that the planning system makes sure green spaces are available to all and maintained properly for decades to come. 
03:14 - 03:53
Speaker 4
Well, Mr. Speaker, he's right to raise the subject of private management companies, I recognise the situation he's describing and how unacceptable it is. 

It is clear that the current system is not delivering for ordinary people and the government is committed to reducing the prevalence of private estate management arrangements and ending the injustice of fleecehold.  We've consulted on the proposals, Mr. Speaker, I think that was in March, to increase adoption of amenities in new estates and will respond in due course.  It is the Wild West, Mr. Speaker, at the moment and my honourable friend the Housing Secretary is undertaking important work to tackle it. 
03:53 - 04:26
Speaker 30
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  The Secretary of State has doubled housing targets for Maldon District, causing them to fall behind on their five-year supply and it's putting green spaces at risk and villages such as Tollesbury.  Now these villages are building more homes, but importantly it's affecting their ability to plan strategic infrastructure and their community growth going forward.  Will the Secretary of State meet with myself and the Member of Parliament for Maldon to discuss these targets and the impact this is having on the community and on green spaces? 
04:26 - 05:01
Speaker 5
Well, I thank the right honourable member for her question and we've set out our targets within the National Planning Policy Framework and local plans and I encourage them to make sure their local plans are up to date.  Natural England standard on accessible green space stipulates that everyone has access to good quality green and blue spaces across to home for health and wellbeing and contact with nature.  So hopefully the honourable right honourable member will be able to see that we're putting things in place to ensure that we have the housing and the green spaces people want. 

05:01 - 05:51

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the right honourable lady to her place alongside her team. Guildford Borough Council's latest Green Belt assessment found 92% of its Green Belt now meets the government's grey belt definition, while its assessed housing need has been doubled by the government from 562 to 1,168 homes a year. This has left many of my residents very worried about the loss of green space, unsustainable development without appropriate infrastructure and loss of distinctive historic character of their villages. What assessment has the Secretary of State made of the potential impact of planning policy on Green Belt land in my constituency, which falls within the Guildford Borough area, and can she outline what steps her government will take to protect green spaces for communities by ensuring that developers are directed towards genuinely brownfield sites first, rather than development being concentrated on land around Guildford that was previously protected by the Green Belt?

05:51 - 06:18

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, what we've been doing is making sure we're strengthening and clarifying the rules around the release of what is grey belt, but that brownfield has to be first and also strengthening policy provisions to support local authorities to plan for green space at a strategic level, so making sure that green space is available, we have the housing and infrastructure people need, but that brownfield is used first and I encourage her to work with her local authority to look at their local plans.

06:18 - 06:52

Matthew Pennycook

Question number two, Mr. Speaker.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government does not collect data on how much land within Green Belts has been formally identified as grey belt by individual local authorities. It is for local authorities themselves to determine if land in their areas constitutes grey belt, either through plan-making or through looking at specific applications that come forward. On the 27th of February 2025, the government updated Green Belt planning practice guidance to support a consistent approach to assessing Green Belt to identify grey belt land.

06:52 - 07:30

Mark Pritchard

Is the Minister aware that speculative developers want to build 800 new houses in Albrighton in my constituency, inside the Green Belt and outside the local plan? Let me be clear, my constituents who I met in a public meeting on Friday are not against housing, they're just against housing at the wrong scale in the wrong location. So it's not about NIMBYism, it is about protecting nature, it is about protecting open spaces and it is about protecting the Green Belt. And nearly 4,000 on consultation have signed a local petition against these flawed proposals.

So would the Minister accept that Shropshire's Green Belt needs to be protected from this destruction?

07:30 - 08:01

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. I am aware of the case. My understanding is that Shropshire Council refused planning permission for the development on the basis that the land was not grey belt, and therefore building on it would constitute inappropriate development in the Green Belt. In general terms, when it comes to determining whether a site is classified as grey belt at appeal, the relevant inspector will consider relevant legislation, national planning policy including the NPPF, planning policy guidance, and any other relevant local development plan policies and material considerations.

08:01 - 08:02

Bradley Thomas.

08:02 - 08:04

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Number three, sir.

08:04 - 08:06

Speaker 17

Minister.

08:06 - 08:23

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The new National Planning Policy Framework that was published on the 17th of August includes a number of new policies designed to increase densification inside settlements, including by encouraging the upward expansion of existing homes and the creation of new dwellings within existing plots.

08:23 - 08:58

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Bradley Thomas. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, I've just heard the Secretary of State say that there should be a brownfield-first approach, but what's going on in Bromsgrove and in many other constituencies is contradictory. An 85% increase in the housing target in a constituency that's 90% Green Belt. So I challenge the Secretary of State to think again, to prioritise urban densification.

This is fundamental to the redevelopment of towns, cities, urban centres that are in desperate need of renewal. Why doesn't she just admit that she's got this wrong and change tack?

08:58 - 09:34

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I have to say to the honourable gentleman, we haven't got it wrong. The new NPPF does prioritise urban development and densification. As I've made clear to him a number of times previously, local authorities are able to justify a lower housing requirement than the figure set by the standard method on the basis of local constraints such as land availability. It's for local planning authorities themselves to determine whether exceptional circumstances exist that justify the release of Green Belt, and we fully expect them to first demonstrate that they've examined fully all other reasonable options for meeting identified need for development, including making as much use as possible of suitable brownfield sites and underutilised land.

09:34 - 09:35

Alex McIntyre.

09:35 - 09:54

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The gate streets in Gloucester city centre are in urgent need of regeneration. Does the Minister agree with me that one way to breathe more life into our city centre is to convert the empty upper floors of shops into good quality housing, and what steps are the government taking to unlock those opportunities?

09:54 - 10:12

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honourable friend for that question. The government is undertaking a number of pieces of work to look at what we can do more to revitalise our high streets, and I am specifically, along with the Secretary of State, looking at what more we can do in terms of arming local authorities with the powers they need to bring empty homes back into use.

10:12 - 10:14

Speaker 8

Sir Minister Davidson.

10:14 - 10:41

Paul Waugh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Planning permissions, of which there are around 1.5 million for new homes, are already one thing, but getting those units built is another. With Savills reporting that two-thirds of London boroughs have seen net zero new housing starts under this Mayor of London, what proposals does the government have to ensure that units with permission actually get built rather than concreting over our Green Belt?

10:41 - 11:03

Matthew Pennycook

Well, the shadow minister is absolutely right that housebuilders across the country are facing challenges with viability, not least, Mr. Speaker, to the implications of the ongoing conflict in the Middle East. London has a number of challenges particular to itself that the rest of the country is not facing. That is precisely why we brought forward an emergency package with the Mayor of London specifically to get those stalled sites in the capital moving.

11:03 - 11:05

Speaker 11

Ben Maguire.

11:05 - 11:07

Ben Maguire

Question four, Mr. Speaker.

11:07 - 11:08

Minister.

11:08 - 11:32

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Local planning authorities are expected to plan effectively for infrastructure provision through local development plans and infrastructure funding statements. To support them, the government has strengthened national planning policy in respect of community facilities and public service infrastructure, and we provide direct financial support for essential infrastructure in areas of greatest housing demand through land and infrastructure funding programmes.

11:32 - 12:09

Ben Maguire

Ben Maguire. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. To protect their profits, Wain Homes are now backing out of 350,000 pounds of promised infrastructure funding in my town of Bodmin. But with more than 3,000 homes to be built by 2030, Bodmin now faces an infrastructure emergency.

Just last week, the Prime Minister said Cornwall lacks a basic level of infrastructure, which in turn harms growth and holds back life chances. So as part of Cornwall's bespoke devolution package, will the Minister please consider greater control over infrastructure levies, like those enjoyed by other local authorities?

12:09 - 12:43

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honorable gentleman for his question, and my colleagues on the front bench will have heard his request in terms of the devolution offer that is to be made to Cornwall. Specifically on developer contributions, because he cited the case where the developers backed out of their commitments, communities rightly expect necessary infrastructure to be provided and any commitments made met. Section 106 planning obligations help obviously to mitigate the impacts of a development proposal. They are legally binding and enforceable. If he wants to write me with the particular circumstances in the case, he's more than welcome to do so.

12:43 - 13:19

Melanie Onn

Melanie Onn. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. There is a development proposed near Weelsby Woods, which is a designated nature corridor in my constituency, of 1,500 properties. Within that, there are no designations of social housing, there's no suggestions of doctor's surgeries, there's no consideration for the potential road congestion that's taking place. All the while, 1,500 homes are promised, but 2,000 sit empty in the town center.

Is there any action being planned for empty town center homes?

13:19 - 13:47

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honorable friend for that question. As I've just said in respect of a previous question, we are looking at what more we can do in terms of giving local authorities the powers they need to bring empty homes back into use. She will understand I won't be able to comment on specific applications being made, but councils can, through section 106 agreements, seek to negotiate with developers to bring forward the necessary infrastructure and amenities and affordable housing on particular sites.

13:47 - 14:16

Lewis Cocking

Shadow Minister Lewis Cocking. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents and people across this country are fed up with more and more housing being built without the proper infrastructure in place first. There is nothing in the Planning and Infrastructure Act about forcing developers to put schools and GP surgeries in place at the same time as new development. So will the Minister look again and commit to listening to existing residents about bringing changes in legislation to make sure infrastructure first?

14:16 - 14:51

Matthew Pennycook

I welcome the Shadow Minister to the front bench and on a well-deserved promotion. What I would say to him is the previous government had 14 years to resolve this problem. It didn't do so. I've got to say to him honestly, and he knows this full well, he's a former local councilor, there is no single simple answer to the problem of getting the necessary infrastructure in place. As I said, we strengthened national planning policy to ensure that community facilities, public service infrastructure is brought forward.

Developer contributions again we're strengthening. We directly finance land and infrastructure. There is more to be done and we are going to do that.

14:51 - 15:18

Lewis Cocking

Mr. Speaker, well they've had two years and that won't wash with my constituents that have seen thousands of new homes built with no new infrastructure. Healthcare services are of particular concern, and it makes it much harder when there's new housing for everyone to see their GP. This government is taking on more political control of the NHS, so can the Minister tell me what discussions he's had with the Department of Health and Social Care on ensuring new healthcare facilities are built in place when there is new housing?

15:18 - 15:45

Matthew Pennycook

Well the Shadow Minister does raise a very justified point in that when it comes to bringing forward the necessary public service infrastructure, in some cases it's ensuring that the buildings are brought forward through the relevant developer contributions, other infrastructure funding streams. In some cases it's other issues like workforce challenges in particular areas. So we do regularly speak to colleagues in other government departments, including the Department of Health and Social Care, to ensure that we get that infrastructure upfront and alongside development.

15:45 - 16:17

Florence Eshalomi

Question 5, Mr. Speaker.

Minister, welcome. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With your permission, I will take question 5 and 6 together.

Young people must be seen and heard. We are giving 16 and 17-year-olds right across the UK a vote in elections, working across government and with our partners to prepare them for to exercise that right, including through the Democratic Education Fund, our 2.5 million Democratic Engagement Fund.

16:17 - 16:18

Julie Minns.

16:18 - 16:53

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I very much welcome the government's plans to extend the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds. However, blind and visually impaired young voters will still be disenfranchised as long as there is not legislation that requires that they be able to vote in secret and independently like their peers. Will the minister please take the opportunity to reiterate her commitment, given last week, that the government will bring an amendment to the Representation of the People Bill to provide fully accessible voting to all voters of all ages.

16:53 - 17:20

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for her question and just to thank her again for the work that she's done in highlighting this really important issue. I'm happy to reiterate my commitment during report stage and to thank her for all her work. As she noted during the debate, the government has indicated its readiness to act on the bill and move through its passage so that visually impaired voters can vote independently and in secret and will continue to work with her and other honorable members to deliver that outcome.

17:20 - 18:01

Alex Baker

Alex Baker.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer I had some great conversations with the latest cohort of work experience students from Farnborough Sixth Form who came to spend time in my office, who all agreed that their citizenship education from the various local secondary schools they'd attended was a bit hit and miss in in terms of how it taught about democracy, how it actually works and how they can participate. Does the minister agree that if you want more young people to engage in our democracy, we need to give them the knowledge and confidence to do so, and what more can the government do to ensure that young people leave school understanding how they can make their voices heard.

18:01 - 18:43

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for the work that she's highlighted and it's really important when we are going out speaking to our young people across schools and sixth forms that they are equipped. We want them to engage in the democratic process and making sure that when they start including in that, they can continue that into adulthood. And that means equipping them and empowering them with the knowledge and understanding that they need. The Secretary of State for Education is considering recommendations of the curriculum and assessment review alongside the government's ambition to transform technical education from 14 through to 16. We expect there to be a full public consultations on the proposals for the curriculum and the assessment in due course.

18:43 - 18:44

Rishi Sunak.

18:44 - 19:15

Rishi Sunak

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My local schools also do an excellent job engaging young people in democracy and pupils at Brompton Primary School deserve particular praise for taking action. They gathered evidence, took local views, came to speak to me and the council about implementing a 20-mile-an-hour speed limit outside their school, something that is now being actively worked on. Will the minister join me in praising their efforts, but also agree that they are an inspiring example of what young people can do when they get involved in the democratic process.

19:15 - 19:46

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the right honorable gentleman for the work that he's doing and really good to see that he continues to be an active constituency MP.

one of the best parts about this role for all of us is going out to visit our primary schools and secondary schools, meeting with the young people because you never know what questions you are going to get. So I just want to use this opportunity to praise the campaigning efforts of the young people from Brompton Primary Community School and to encourage all other young people in other schools to carry out similar community engagements.

19:46 - 19:47

Tom Gordon.

19:47 - 20:32

Thomas Gordon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to put on record some of the fantastic youth organisations like the likes of Harrogate Youth Council in my constituency that do their bit to engage young people in democracy. My office manager will attest that I too do my bit by having an endless stream of work experience students through the office door, much to her frustration managing the number of cohort of people who are interested. One of them recently, Benji, mentioned to me that he's really excited about going forward young people will be able to vote, but he did say that there was an unequal opportunity coming to education when it comes to accessing social media for young people. One of the ways in which young people will get that information to vote would be through social media.

So what steps is she taking with the other government departments to ensure that young people can find information online?

20:32 - 21:13

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honourable gentleman for that really important point, and it is important that when we are looking at the ways young people receive information about voting, it's through all different means, including social media. There are some challenges which I know that DCMS colleagues are looking at in terms of misinformation and fake news circulating online, so it's really important that we look at the place where young people spend the majority of their time: schools, educational settings, making sure that our teachers and trainers and carers are equipped to give young people that right engagement. So I think the Democratic Process Engagement Fund will be a key way to help that, and I know that this is an area that the Electoral Commission are also looking at in terms of the engagement online.

21:13 - 21:14

Monica Harding.

21:14 - 21:16

Monica Harding

Question number seven, please, Mr. Speaker.

21:16 - 21:35

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The National Planning Policy Framework contains strong protections for the Green Belt, making clear that inappropriate development in it should not be approved unless justified by very special circumstances. It is for local planning authorities themselves to set and review Green Belt boundaries in accordance with national policy in the NPPF.

21:35 - 22:13

Monica Harding

Mr. Speaker, the government's changes to planning rules are of considerable concern to my constituents, leading to speculative applications everywhere, and theoretically could mean the whole of my constituency, which is 50% Green Belt and has seven stations, being concreted over. So my constituents are certainly not opposed to growth or housebuilding, but they do not want to be ignored, and the long-standing right of councils to call in applications has been removed, and it runs counter to the new Prime Minister's values on devolution. Which is why I wrote to the Secretary of State on the 28th of July, and I've not had a reply to my questions. So will she meet with me so that she can answer these questions directly?

22:13 - 22:45

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honourable lady for her question, and I appreciate fully her concerns about inappropriate development around stations such as Hersham, Claygate in her constituency. It is right that we seek to promote good development around well-connected stations outside of settlements or on Green Belt land as these are some of the most sustainable locations for new homes in the country. However, the new NPPF does make clear that development proposals around such stations should not prejudice any proposals for long-term comprehensive development in the same location and must also be of a scale which can be accommodated, taking into account existing or proposed availability of infrastructure.

22:45 - 22:46

Navendu Mishra.

22:46 - 22:48

Navendu Mishra

Question number eight, Mr. Speaker.

22:48 - 23:19

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We're building the homes this country needs through our 39 billion pounds of social and affordable homes, the 16 billion pounds in the National Housing Bank, and the most ambitious planning reforms in a generation. The Greater Manchester Combined Authority and their fantastic new mayor have received 258 million from the National Housing Delivery Fund, and ministers have intervened to ensure that Stockport's local plan is consulted on so that we can provide the homes that Stockport needs.

23:19 - 24:09

Navendu Mishra

Mr. Speaker, can I congratulate my good friend the Secretary of State and the ministers on their appointment? She knows Stockport well as a fellow Stockportian.

Mr. Speaker, in Stockport nearly 10,000 households are on the waiting list for housing and the council has spent, Stockport Council has spent more than 2 million pounds on temporary accommodation, hotel accommodation for people with nowhere else to go. Stockport also has one of the highest levels of residential tower blocks in Greater Manchester and many residents are living in aging high-rise homes, including those in Lancashire Hill in my constituency, and they're raising serious concerns with me about the condition of their housing, their flats. Will the Secretary of State set out how her department will support councils not only to build new social homes in our communities, but also to invest and protect existing housing stock so that everyone has a safe, decent home to go to?

24:09 - 24:41

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I thank my honorable friend for his question. He's a great advocate for his constituency, the town of my home birth, and I have fond memories of Lancashire Hill as a child where my nan lived. And we announced initial allocations to the social and affordable homes program, which will support the delivery of tens of thousands of new council and social homes. And we're supporting councils, Mr. Speaker, to invest in existing homes with a 10-year rent settlement alongside the warm homes funding.

24:41 - 24:44

Speaker 38

Question number nine, Mr. Speaker.

24:44 - 25:05

Speaker 32

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We will be giving mayors greater flexibility to deploy funding within integrated settlements and mayors will also retain a share of business rates in place of government grant from April 27, and we will replace further grants from central government with a share of local income tax from 2028.

25:05 - 25:31

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Bakerloo extension line is a project that would help to revitalize Catford, which is a town in my constituency of Lewisham East. In fact, it would unlock thousands of new homes in the area. Would changes to the regional funding allow the Mayor of London and the GLA to make decisions themselves to back the Bakerloo line and progress the project?

25:31 - 26:01

Speaker 32

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I know the honorable member has been campaigning on this issue. She will be pleased to know that we are committed to empowering mayors, giving them further levers to invest in their communities and their areas, including through retaining a share of income tax. Further details will be set out as part of the fiscal devolution roadmap at the budget. The Bakerloo extension line itself will be a decision for the GLA and TfL, and I will continue to work with them to support their work on future projects.

26:01 - 26:57

Mark Francois

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Labour have also said they want to devolve NHS funding. To give a practical example, the NHS uses a standard metric of 2.4 additional patients per every new dwelling constructed. So in South Essex, for the 63,000 homes envisaged in Basildon and Thurrock, that would mean 151,000 extra patients for Basildon Hospital, which unfortunately is rated inadequate by the CQC and is part of a trust which is also one of five in the country in intensive special measures because of its poor management. So in short, how on earth can Basildon Hospital cope with 151,000 additional patients because of Labour's housing targets when it can barely cope with the patients that it's got at the moment?

26:57 - 27:16

Speaker 32

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I think that's probably a question best directed for health orals, but what I will say is the government is committing to working with all areas as part of our devolution roadmap to make sure that authorities and health providers can deal with the devolution that we've got planned and I'd be happy to meet with him outside of this to discuss it further.

27:16 - 27:28

Lindsay Hoyle

Just a point, I'll let it go on the basis that it is actually about funding that follows housing growth.

That's why I allowed it, so I think it was fair in fairness. Shadow Minister David Simmons.

27:28 - 27:58

Paul Waugh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With the government having earlier today briefed the media that much of its devolution program is being paused, with only Surrey looking like it's going to get its way, I'm sure the subject of relentless lobbying by Labour backbenchers. Can the Minister tell us how many of the new mayors that were promised by this government after its election will be in place by the next general election?

27:58 - 28:08

Speaker 32

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Following questions today, the Secretary of State will be making a statement on this very issue, setting out what we'll be doing going further with local government reform and with mayors.

28:08 - 28:12

Speaker 31

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Zoe Franklin.

28:12 - 29:01

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I do welcome the Prime Minister's indication that newly formed local authorities won't be forced to have a strategic mayor in order to benefit devolution. However, the key to success is going to be ensuring real fiscal devolution to support and deliver services and economic growth for residents. So, can I ask the Minister to set out how the department will ensure non-mayoral strategic authorities, including the emerging foundation strategic authority in Surrey, where my own constituency is based of Guildford, how will the Minister ensure that our area receives the financial resources to make meaningful funding decisions at a regional level, including access to funding streams currently only available to mayoral strategic authorities?

29:01 - 29:32

Speaker 32

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So our ambition is to ensure that everywhere in England has or is in the process of establishing a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028. It is right that we won't impose mayors on areas that don't want one, but we do consider that directly accountable mayors represent the strongest form of governance, which is why there is a different set of available powers and money for them. But I'm happy to discuss that with her further, we'll be setting out more information around our plans for devolution in the coming months.

29:32 - 29:33

Fleur Anderson.

29:33 - 29:44

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Question number 10, please, Mr. Speaker.

29:44 - 29:58

Jim McMahon

To help restore high streets across the country, we have announced measures to tackle organized crime, to cut business rates for pubs, and to stop the spread of vape shops and gambling outlets. Later this year, we'll publish a high street strategy setting out a longer-term plan for bringing life back into our town centers.

29:58 - 30:36

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the whole of the front bench to their places and the Secretary of State back. And I thank the Minister for meeting with me to talk about Putney High Street. We love our high street in Putney and we want to see it thrive even more, especially to open up those empty shops. Will the Minister give hope to every high street by reviewing and reducing business rates and by making the high street rental auction policy work more effectively by cutting the unnecessary red tape and providing councils with the financial support that they need to bring vacant properties up to a lettable standard?

30:36 - 31:20

Jim McMahon

Thank you. And first of all, can I congratulate my honorable friend on the championing that she does for Putney and her high street, and also for attending the round table. Councils need both the tools and the support to bring vacant properties back into use, and that's exactly why we introduced the high street rental auctions. To make powers as straightforward as possible, we have published guidance and templates and established a dedicated support mechanism for local authorities. We're reviewing new burdens funding to ensure that councils are properly resourced and have announced 10 million pound to fund tackle long-term vacancies and bring empty units back into productive use.

And on business rates, this government is committed to reforming the system to create a fairer approach that fully supports investments and high streets like her own.

31:20 - 31:22

Speaker 23

Jen Kirkm.

31:22 - 31:26

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number 11.

31:26 - 31:52

Matthew Pennycook

With your permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll take questions 11 and 13 together.

We recognize that many councils are facing significant financial pressure on their HRAs. The government has already taken a number of steps to rebuild the capacity of councils to borrow and invest in new and existing homes, including fundamental reform of the Right to Buy scheme, a 10-year social housing rent settlement, and social rent convergence. We will continue to explore further ways we might support councils to expand their stock of social homes, including low-cost borrowing options.

31:52 - 31:53

Jane Kirkham.

31:53 - 32:36

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And this government has of course committed to and taken steps to boost council housing, which is fantastic. Cornwall's Housing Revenue Account has struggled to build because they've had to invest in repairs, meaning they've had to reduce the annual amount of funds available for new homes. Another of the barriers, of course, to delivering new council homes is the debt, with over 90 million as a result of the self-financing arrangements dating back to 2012. If that debt was reduced, councils could do more, Cornwall and others.

Will the government consider options to write off HRA debt, or at least provide that lower-cost finance, such as that made available to registered providers through the National Housing Bank?

32:36 - 33:02

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honorable friend for her question. As I made clear, we have already acted to build capacity in the sector and we'll continue to explore further ways we might increase the headroom available to councils and housing associations, not least in terms of low-cost borrowing options. With regard to the HRA, we remain of the view that the principle of self-financing is the right foundation, but we're fully aware, as I said, of the impact of HRA debt on the ability of many councils to build more, and we will continue to explore ways we might further support them.

33:02 - 33:03

Dan McCurley.

33:03 - 33:38

Margaret Olivia Hillier

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is aware of the challenges of housing in my constituency and across London. And every home that is built that provides a foundation for people's lives saves the state money as well, in terms of temporary accommodation costs, people being able to get that foundation in life. So will he undertake to talk to Treasury colleagues about how to look at that maths to make sure that we understand that tackling issues around debt could actually save money in the long term? I recognize it might be a long haul, but could he promise to start?

33:38 - 34:15

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I thank my right honorable friend for that question. She's absolutely right about the importance of building more homes in London. I'm acutely aware of the housing delivery challenges the capital is facing. It's really important that those homes are, a big proportion of them are social rented homes and council-delivered social rented homes. I'm really pleased that in the early years of the Social and Affordable Homes Programme, 30% of the funding will go to London.

That will allow London to deliver at least 6 billion pounds of initial allocations, over half of which will be for council housing. But there is more we need to do in this area, and more than happy to have a discussion with her outside the chamber about what.

34:15 - 34:43

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Councils like Dorset sold their housing stock many years ago and their social housing is entirely operated by housing associations. Therefore, they have no HRA, making it more expensive and complex to influence the social housing network in their areas and support constituents living in poor quality, overcrowded social homes. So what additional measures are being considered to make sure we don't end up with a two-tier system between those with an HRA and those without?

34:43 - 35:11

Matthew Pennycook

We have made changes to help more councils access an HRA, raising the threshold from 200 to 1,000 homes to provide support in that area. Over time, we want to see a deeper partnership and more working between councils and local authorities. But we are giving consideration to what more we can do in terms of ensuring there is sufficient public control of private registered providers in an area to meet housing need. And we may discuss this issue further, Mr. Speaker, on the second reading of the Social Housing Bill on Thursday.

35:11 - 35:12

Tim Farron.

35:12 - 35:52

Timothy James Farron

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The average house price in my constituency is 12 times average household incomes, and so the desperate need for more social housing is clear and plain for everyone to see.

Westmorland and Furness Council does now have a housing revenue account inherited from the previous Barrow Borough Council, but it's unlikely to spend any of that money, it's unlikely to build council houses whilst the right to buy remains unfettered. If you build council houses in the Lakes and the Dales, they'll be sold and they'll be Airbnbs and second homes before the year is out. So what will the government do to encourage the likes of my local authority to build with confidence so people can have affordable homes that they can guarantee will remain so?

35:52 - 36:12

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. As he is hopefully aware, we've already taken action to reduce maximum right to buy cash discounts through the Social Housing Bill that I mentioned second reading on Thursday. We are taking further action to increase eligibility and banning the right to buy on new build social homes for 35 years. I hope he can get behind that bill on Thursday and support it.

36:12 - 36:17

Martin Wrigley

Question number 12, please.

36:17 - 36:53

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've asked the Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth to undertake a rapid review of local government reorganisation program. I have withdrawn the decisions made in March this year for four areas, namely Essex, Southend-on-Sea and Thurrock, Hampshire, Isle of Wight, Portsmouth and Southampton, Norfolk and Suffolk. The review will look at the program as a whole, including the decision that was taken for Devon, Plymouth and Torbay.

36:53 - 37:29

Martin Wrigley

May I congratulate the Secretary of State back to her place on this MHCLG and welcome her team as well. May I thank her for her upcoming statement and the review that she has just started that addresses my question and that of my colleague, the MP for South Devon, on the local Devon local government reorganisation that had been described as bonkers. May I ask the next time round the government includes the local MPs in the process and whether the local councils will be refunded the costs incurred in this time round?

37:29 - 37:59

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I hope that local MPs will be engaged and councils. I've made the commitment which I'll go into further in the statement after orals, but this is about making sure that we make the right choices that are right for their local areas. And where there has been funding incurred, there will be conversations with my department, which was allocated money to support local government reorganisation. And we are still committed, Mr. Speaker, to local government reorganisation, but with people.

37:59 - 38:05

Steve Yemm

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number 14.

38:05 - 38:27

Florence Eshalomi

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister has set a clear ambition to end rough sleeping at the earliest opportunity, backed by the full support of central government. The government will convene an inter-ministerial group working to drive progress against the PM's ambition and ongoing work towards the commitment made in the national plan to end homelessness.

38:27 - 39:02

Steve Yemm

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently wrote praising the Prime Minister and Secretary of State's determination to make rough sleeping a priority and highlighted how the Old Eight Bells in Mansfield turned a derelict building into a lifeline for adults who needed supported housing and brought new activity into our town centre. If this approach was backed in our fight to end rough sleeping, does the minister agree to me that it would give a really significant helping hand in our drive to tackle rough sleeping?

39:02 - 39:30

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for raising that example of really good local initiatives to look at how we can end the scourge of rough sleeping. We have to be honest that central government alone cannot achieve this task. We have to work with local voluntary groups, councils, community groups, charities who are doing fantastic work across the country. I'd be pleased to look at the example that my honourable friend set out to look at how we can learn lessons from what they've done there.

39:30 - 39:52

Ayoub Khan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

In my constituency of Birmingham Perry Barr, which has amongst the highest levels of deprivation, unfortunately subways and bus shelters are homes to the most vulnerable. Will the minister meet with me? I know that 440 million pound has been allocated. I don't know how much has been given to Birmingham City Council. But will the minister meet with me to see how we can address this issue?

39:52 - 40:18

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honorable member for raising this and it is truly shocking that we are still seeing people having to sleep in really poor and worrying conditions on the streets. I'm happy to look at did to see how much funding his local authority has received from the new funding. The government have committed 442 million new funding in the Prime Minister's ambition to end homelessness and I'm happy to give him additional detail on what impact that will have for his constituency.

40:18 - 40:22

Speaker 63

Abena Oppong-Asare.

40:22 - 40:26

Abena Asare

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Question 15.

40:26 - 40:27

Minister.

40:27 - 41:05

Florence Eshalomi

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Encouraging progress has been made against national homelessness and rough sleeping targets within Erith and Thamesmead constituency. In particular, the number of families in B&B over six weeks in Greenwich has decreased by 96% year-on-year from 100 households to four. Congratulations. Over 168 million new funding for the rough sleeping program was announced for London last month.

This funding will be used across key areas to tackle rough sleeping in the winter and beyond, including within the Erith and Thamesmead constituency.

41:05 - 41:07

Speaker 60

Abena Oppong-Asare.

41:07 - 41:28

Speaker 72

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Women experiencing rough sleeping are often hidden from official figures. Will the minister ensure that this is a specific focus in the forthcoming homelessness summit? And can she make sure that new guidance is backed by resources councils need to provide safe trauma-informed support?

41:28 - 41:29

Minister.

41:29 - 42:06

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for raising that really important point and we've made clear that all areas should be looking at providing accessible support for women, including specialist provision where needed. Our ending rough sleeping program will require a whole of society approach. This autumn, the Prime Minister will bring together a diverse range of leaders from businesses, finance, charities, faith, health communities and much more to consider a range of options to support people, including the needs of different people and most importantly the needs of women.

42:06 - 42:13

Brian Patrick Hurley

Patrick Hurley. 16 please Mr. Speaker. Minister.

42:13 - 42:49

Florence Eshalomi

Mr. Speaker, the number of families in temporary accommodation has decreased in Southport year-on-year and in June 2026 there were zero people sleeping rough across the month in West Lancashire Council area. Funding for the national rough sleeping program was announced last month with 340,000 allocated to Sefton, 6.7 million for the Liverpool City Region and 189,000 for West Lancashire Council, ensuring that people sleeping rough in Southport can be offered a roof off the streets by Christmas.

42:49 - 42:51

Speaker 59

Patrick Hurley.

42:51 - 43:28

Speaker 69

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Light for Life, the homelessness charity in Southport, tell me that some of the people sleeping rough with the most complex needs are precisely the same people least able to navigate the bureaucracy associated with finding themselves a roof over their heads. So will the minister look at creating a distinct pathway for entrenched rough sleepers, allowing trusted local bodies to triage people directly and get them into emergency accommodation, rather than expecting people with addiction issues, poor mental health and chaotic lives to navigate the bureaucracy before they can get help?

43:28 - 44:14

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for raising that. It's really important that we highlight the complexity and challenges many people sleeping rough are facing. And it's important that we recognize complex needs can be the least available to navigate traditional services. Our new 442 million rough sleeping program will fund routes off the streets alongside settled accommodation, intensive support, bringing together the multi-agency support response that's often needed to move people off the streets for good. Local areas will have the flexibility to work with trusted voluntary organizations that can reach people furthest from the services.

And I'd be happy to look at the experience that my honorable friend has raised and the experience of Light for Life in Southport.

44:14 - 44:15

Saqib Bhatti.

44:15 - 44:18

Saqib Bhatti

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question 17, please.

44:18 - 44:20

Speaker 61

Minister.

44:20 - 44:42

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The definition of reasonable walking distance is set out in the glossary of the NPPF for the purposes of policies relating to land around well-connected stations. It makes clear it should be considered to be around 800 meters or around 10 minutes walk time if topography, route availability and quality of physical barriers would prevent or discourage walking from up to 800 meters away.

44:42 - 45:18

Saqib Bhatti

I thank the minister for that response. This policy has created a huge amount of consternation in my constituency. It puts huge amounts of Green Belt at risk, especially in villages like Hampton-in-Arden, historic, beautiful villages because there's one way in, one way out, a small GP practice surgery, a school with one form entry. My constituents are very, very concerned about how they will be overwhelmed by their Green Belt being overwhelmed. Isn't it better for the minister to focus on growing housing in places like Birmingham, which needs more housing, and making sure there's a brownfield first, infrastructure first approach?

45:18 - 46:03

Matthew Pennycook

Well, we need more housing in all parts of the country. We do have a brownfield first approach. We do want to see infrastructure delivered in a timely manner alongside housing developments. But it's absolutely right, Mr. Speaker, that we focus development within reasonable walking distances of train stations, within settlements or well-connected stations outside of settlements, including in the Green Belt. As I've said, these are some of the most sustainable locations for new housing in the country.

We've defined well-connected stations by the 80 travel-to-work area areas of the country. And we've also linked minimum density requirements to service frequency. So there is a link to the amount of trains a station receives per hour and the amount of development we want to see come forward. But I'm more than happy to speak to the honorable gentleman about the particular issues in his constituency.

46:03 - 46:06

Speaker 62

Robert Luffa, please.

46:06 - 46:34

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last Thursday marked the two-year anniversary of the publication of the Grenfell Tower Inquiry Phase 2 report. We remain committed to ensuring that the Grenfell tragedy is not forgotten and never happens again. And we will continue to work closely with the community and the building industry as we deliver lasting change.

46:34 - 47:01

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Mr. Speaker, some constituents are facing exorbitant service charges from retirement properties inherited from a family member and which are proving impossible to sell. One of my constituents is paying 770 pounds a month for an empty one-bedroom flat just in service charges after inheriting the home from their late mother. What steps will the government take to regulate this sector and stop these companies ripping people off?

47:01 - 47:18

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I have great sympathy with what the honorable member is saying. And the housing minister has just indicated he would be happy to meet with him. But that is something that we do want to tackle. We've been very clear on service charges as well as leasehold and making sure that we're bringing legislation forward that protects people from unfair charges.

47:18 - 47:21

Speaker 65

Olivia Bailey.

47:21 - 47:47

Speaker 77

My constituency is packed full of beautiful rural villages, but house prices are through the roof and social housing stock is being sold off by housing associations like SNG, forcing my constituents out of the places that they grew up. I welcome the government's measures to protect rural social housing stock in the Social Housing Bill, but will my right honourable friend consider strengthening rules to protect against the sell-off of properties that could be housing local families in my community?

47:47 - 48:11

Matthew Pennycook

Mr. Speaker, can I say I recognise the strength of feeling in the House regarding this matter. I want to ensure every opportunity is taken to retain homes within the social housing sector. While housing associations remain independent organisations responsible for their own asset management decisions, I can assure my honourable friend that we are exploring what further steps could be taken to protect much-needed social housing stock.

48:11 - 48:27

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I would like to take this opportunity to congratulate the Secretary of State on her return to her position and to welcome her to her place. What steps is she taking to proactively protect the Green Belt?

48:27 - 48:56

Matthew Pennycook

As I've said, Mr. Speaker, there are strong protections in the National Planning Policy Framework. It is for local authorities to decide whether in plan-making exceptional circumstances exist for its release, or in decision-making whether very special circumstances exist that would outweigh the harms involved when it comes to inappropriate development. Those safeguards remain. We're committed to preserving England's Green Belts, which have served our towns and cities very well over many decades.

48:56 - 49:38

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I agree with the last point, but I don't, I'm not too sure I believe the preceding point. If the government are serious about protecting the Green Belt and generating new housing, one of the best ways of doing both would surely be to ensure that planning permissions are actually built. But according to the Local Government Association, there are currently up to 1.4 million housing units that were granted planning consent over the past decade and have not been completed. Now, the government may claim that they are serious about solving this problem and point to their planning reform working paper entitled Speeding Up Build-Out. But that paper was published in May last year, requires primary legislation for it to have any effect at all.

If the government are serious about protecting the Green Belt and getting the homes built, where is the legislation?

49:38 - 50:09

Matthew Pennycook

Well, the shadow minister, who I have a lot of time for, I must say, knows full well that development can stall on particular sites for a variety of reasons, not least those viability pressures that we discussed earlier. But we are taking action to get sites moving. The NPPF strengthens expectations in this area. And on the specific matter he raised, primary legislation isn't needed. Primary legislation was taken through by the previous government, and we do have a plan to switch on the necessary secondary legislation to ensure that we have transparency over build-out rates.

He doesn't have long to wait for this to come forward.

50:09 - 50:38

Speaker 85

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government's new commitment to devolution is much welcomed in Bletchley and Milton Keynes, where we are eager to deepen our partnership with neighbouring local authorities in Luton and Bedfordshire, with whom we share a strong labour market and a broader economic geography. And so in that vein, will the minister meet with me and parliamentary colleagues about how we can create a combined authority with a directly elected mayor at the very heart of the Oxford-Cambridge growth corridor?

50:38 - 50:49

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I'm always happy to meet with my honourable friend. I think the specific matters in question will fall to another minister, thankfully, but I'm more than happy to join that meeting if there are housing issues involved.

50:49 - 51:12

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've received over 70 complaints in my constituency from tenants who are resident in Places for People properties about a failure to maintain their obligation to fix the property, to conduct basic maintenance. Is this something that the government's aware of in terms of being a widespread problem? Is there anything the government can do to encourage Places for People to fulfil their obligations?

51:12 - 51:36

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. Places for People will, I'm sure, no doubt have heard the concerns he's raised today. Social housing providers are regulated on the basis of consumer standards. They're inspected on that basis.

We have obviously introduced Awaab's Law to provide for landlords having to fix hazards within specified time limits. If he wants to write to me with further information about the specific development in question, I'm happy to look into it.

51:36 - 52:02

Christopher David Ward

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Rough sleeping is a huge challenge in Brighton, Kemptown and Peacehaven, so I'm delighted that the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State are making this such a big priority. But can she tell me, will any of the very welcome additional funding go to existing schemes like the Ending Homelessness in Communities Fund, which is a brilliant scheme but heavily oversubscribed, including from charities in my constituency?

52:02 - 52:39

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for his question. I think it is important, again as I mentioned earlier, looking at local initiatives. I repeat, the government's new 442 million Rough Sleeping Programme and Ending Homelessness Fund will be looking at that. Brighton and Hove has received an allocated 1.35 million pounds through the Rough Sleeping Programme allocation, while Brighton Women's Centre has been allocated 371 and 380,000 through the Ending Homelessness Community Fund, subject to grant agreement completion.

52:39 - 53:05

Alexandra Katherine Brewer

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, police and trading standards carried out coordinated visits to retail premises on Fleet Road over suspected criminality, something of increasing concern to me and my constituents. This was led by our local police officer, but how is the Minister working cross-departmentally with the Home Office to keep our high streets safe and lawful?

53:05 - 53:24

Jim McMahon

Well, the honourable member really highlights an issue that's affecting actually many town centres and many high streets, which is for far too long, organised criminal gangs have been acting in plain sight and getting away with it. Well, now they've got a government that's ready to take them on.

53:24 - 53:53

Sonia Kumar

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've met with residents of Goodrich Mews in Dudley. They confirmed that the installation of the retaining wall by Keir-FE Group, I quote, will not have met their criteria to enable the state service life and needs emergency repair. FE Group and Vella have absolved themselves of any responsibility, leaving residents with a dangerously collapsing wall. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss how we can put these companies and hold them to account?

53:53 - 54:18

Matthew Pennycook

Mr. Speaker, homeowners should not be expected to shoulder the financial consequences of defective work. However, the case of Goodrich Mews is a challenging one in that the legal liability appears to now lie with the resident management company. My honourable friend knows that I've been looking into the matter for her. I'm more than happy to meet again. I believe my office has been seeking further information from hers, which we'd be grateful to receive.

54:18 - 54:44

James Cleverly

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Increased energy costs, increased material costs, the increased cost of employing people, particularly young people, the increased cost of bureaucracy, business taxes, all these things are pushing up the cost of building and squeezing the viability of projects. Does the right honourable lady not realise it's her government policies making it harder for young people to get on the housing ladder, or does she simply not care?

54:44 - 55:00

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the right honourable gentleman for that question. Is he saying that he doesn't agree with minimum energy efficiency standards? Is he saying he doesn't agree with a modernised decent home standard? These measures are driving up the quality and the safety of the homes. We can do that while increasing supply.

55:00 - 55:23

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As somebody that worked previously for a homeless charity, Streets to Homes in Harlow, I welcome the Housing First approach that this government is taking to tackle rough sleeping. But would the Secretary of State or Minister, whoever's answering the question, agree with me that along with that housing, we must provide that support, that long-term support to ensure those people can keep those tenancies securely?

55:23 - 55:52

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for raising that really important initiative in Harlow. Housing First is an important intervention which evidence has shown can transform the lives of people with complex needs. We are funding Housing First and other forms of housing-led accommodation through our 2.7 billion pound homelessness, rough sleeping, domestic abuse grant, which goes to areas including, as I mentioned, the 442 million across rough sleeping programmes, including for areas like Harlow.

55:52 - 56:11

Speaker 66

Mistley is a tiny village with a hundred residents, no school, no high street, no major employer.

But it has a train station and a planning application that will double the size of that village. If the Secretary of State's not going to reconsider this blanket policy, will she at least intervene on this specific application?

56:11 - 56:18

Matthew Pennycook

It's not a blanket policy, Mr. Speaker. It relates to well-connected stations. I've set out the definition with appropriate minimum densities to go with them.

56:18 - 56:43

Adam Thompson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Empty, run-down shops from absentee landlords are a blight on our town centers. But Labour-run Erewash Borough Council are fixing the problem through clean-up orders, such as the one served to the Burton's building in Long Eaton. As soon as it was renovated, new businesses moved right in. But clean-up orders can be very time-consuming, so what more can the government do to tackle these absentee landlords and bring these shops back into use?

56:43 - 57:03

Jim McMahon

Can I thank my honorable friend for the work that he's doing to champion his high street? And also that the government, of course, have allocated 24.8 million pound to the Long Eaton town deal, which is funding high street redevelopment projects like public realm improvements. And I'm very happy to meet to talk about what we can do more of.

57:03 - 57:38

Richard Tice

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week at the successful Reform conference, I launched a series, I launched a series of, I launched a series of bold planning proposals which will make it easier to regenerate our town centers, easier to build on brownfield sites by making it cheaper and faster to get planning consents. Therefore, will the Secretary of State consider these proposals? They've been well-received by the industry and I urge her to consult and meet with me.

57:38 - 57:47

Matthew Pennycook

I'd say to the honorable gentleman, we take his planning policies about as seriously as the country took his conference.

57:47 - 58:12

Tracy Gilbert

The Local Growth Fund funding released this month presents great opportunities for young people in my Edinburgh North and Leith constituency. This money will train them in jobs for construction and net zero sectors. Does my honorable friend agree with me that this approach the government is taking on empowering and funding local stakeholders to grow local economies is an approach that should be adopted by the SNP Scottish government?

58:12 - 58:39

Jim McMahon

Can I thank her for the question? Since summer '25, this department has been working in partnership with the offices for the nations and partners in each nation to deliver the Local Growth Fund in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. And we're committed to ensuring that fund is spent on projects that really matter to local people. And it is really important that every arm of government, regardless of where it is in the UK, really drive down that investment so local people feel empowered in the places where they live.

58:39 - 59:11

Paul Holmes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Liberal Democrat-controlled Eastleigh Borough Council's debt, listen, now sits at 620.1 million pound, up from 585 million pound last year. And 36,000 pound a day are paid in interest. The last government put a best value notice in to make sure that their debt was reduced. This government scrapped that.

Why is this government so unwilling to take to task the Liberal Democrat council that are ripping off my constituents?

59:11 - 59:31

Jim McMahon

Well, I think he'll find that we do not shy away from intervention when it's required. But we also think that government ought to be working in partnership with local government. And where councils need support, they find a partner in central government.

But he can be absolutely sure when it comes to value for taxpayers' money and holding the sector to account that the right checks and balances are finally in place.

59:31 - 59:42

Daniel Zeichner

Mr Speaker, I welcome the government's plans to deepen devolution. Can the minister reassure me that that will have no alteration to the commitment to a Cambridge Development Corporation?

59:42 - 59:57

Matthew Pennycook

Mr Speaker, the government remains fully committed to delivering nationally significant growth in Greater Cambridge. And as my honourable friend is well aware, we've established a centrally-led urban development corporation to take it forward in partnership with local leaders.

59:57 - 01:00:29

Speaker 89

Thank you, Mr Speaker. When the Prime Minister was campaigning to be the MP for Wakefield, he said that all of the thirty-nine billion pounds of affordable housing fund should be dedicated to building council homes. Can the Secretary of State explain to the three thousand one hundred and eighty families in temporary accommodation across Manchester and Tameside, many of them in Gorton and Denton, why the government has now backtracked and is instead continuing with the lack of ambition that we had under Keir Starmer, rather than building so many secure, truly affordable homes as possible?

01:00:29 - 01:00:54

Matthew Pennycook

There's no lack of ambition, Mr Speaker, when it comes to social and affordable housing from this government. At least sixty percent of that historic thirty-nine billion pounds will go to social rented homes. We've delivered the highest number of council homes since records began in 1991-92. We're taking a pragmatic approach. There are social homes ready to be built by housing associations, but we're going to make sure that more of that funding goes to councils for direct delivery.

01:00:54 - 01:01:17

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Community-led housing plays a vital role in meeting our housing targets. In my constituency of Birmingham Selly Oak, the Stirchley Cooperative Development has built thirty-nine social and affordable homes, but delays and cost overruns by the housing association has pretty much dropped everyone into despair. Will the minister meet with me to put a resolution to this issue?

01:01:17 - 01:01:21

Matthew Pennycook

I'm more than happy to meet with my honourable friend about the issue.

01:01:21 - 01:01:44

Alec Edward Shelbrooke

Mr Speaker, the Home Secretary will potentially be asking the Secretary of State soon to use a Crown Development Order to approve planning on Linton-on-Ouse as an asylum centre. So can I ask the Secretary of State to reject that as undemocratic and make sure that it goes through the locally elected North Yorkshire planning authority?

01:01:44 - 01:02:02

Matthew Pennycook

I'd say to the right honourable gentleman, it will be whether the application in question meets the criteria set out as to whether it's an application that should proceed and can proceed down the Crown Development route. Obviously the applicant is separate to our department. We are the stewards of the process and we'll make the determination on the basis of that criteria.

01:02:02 - 01:02:26

Anna Gelderd

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I welcome the government's focus on social and affordable homes. In South East Cornwall, we really need first homes, not just second homes, as local people face an affordability crisis, particularly acute amongst younger people. So Cornwall is well placed and eager for a strategic place partnership with Homes England. And will the minister meet with me and other Cornish MPs to discuss that as part of future devolution deals?

01:02:26 - 01:02:30

Matthew Pennycook

I'm more than happy to meet with my honourable friend and other colleagues.

01:02:30 - 01:02:56

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I recently met a homeless man at homeless charity Matthew 25, who in his words said that he was dumped by Brighton and Hove City Council in temporary accommodation in Eastbourne without the support that he needed. The last minister promised that she would review the out-of-area placement guidance for local authorities in this matter. Will the minister meet with me to discuss the progress of that review?

01:02:56 - 01:03:05

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honourable gentleman for raising that point. And Matthew should not have gone through that. I am very happy to meet with him to discuss this case.

01:03:05 - 01:03:22

Damien James Egan

Thank you, Mr Speaker. With the Kingswood area of my Bristol constituency currently being targeted by HMO landlords, can the minister set out the government's current thinking on how powers to restrict HMOs can be made more effective?

01:03:22 - 01:03:38

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honourable friend for that question. There's a variety of practice in the country and we want to understand a bit better whether local authorities are making the full use of existing powers. But I can reassure him we keep the matter under review. We have to make sure that we are regulating HMOs properly.

01:03:38 - 01:04:02

Mary Victoria Boswell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government wants Buckinghamshire Council to develop 91,000 homes, but 2,890 of those are going to basically be adjacent to Northamptonshire and it's going to be my residents in Brackley who are going to be affected by that. Now they're going to have none of the help in terms of developer contributions or a proper say in this. So will the Minister meet with me to discuss this concerning issue for my constituents?

01:04:02 - 01:04:19

Matthew Pennycook

I'd say to the honorable lady that is precisely why we have introduced strategic cross-boundary planning through spatial development. It's not in place yet, she says it's not working, it's not in place yet. We took the Planning Infrastructure Act through last year. It will be in place in fairly short order and more than happy to have a conversation with her about it.

01:04:19 - 01:04:45

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday I visited Shri Guru Ravidass Sikh Gurdwara in my constituency of Ealing Southall, where they told me about the weekly drop-in they run to help and advise rough sleepers without the right to stay in this country to reconnect with family and go home with dignity. Would the Secretary of State congratulate the work of the Gurdwara and can she tell us how we can further help these kind of organizations?

01:04:45 - 01:05:22

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for raising that and sharing that example of the fantastic work carried out by the Gurdwara. It's important I mention that we will work with all organizations, including charitable organizations and faith communities playing an important role because for a number of people sleeping rough they do seek sanctuary in faith communities. I'm happy to look at the examples she's raised and what further work we can do.

01:05:22 - 01:05:49

James Stuart Andrew

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite what we've heard from the Minister, there are colleagues who've been talking about the train railway station issue on developments. That has a practical consequence on the rural village of Long Buckby in my constituency. Land that is currently in open countryside beyond the village boundary will now be designated a priority area. It does give no consideration to the distinction between a rural village and an urban area.

So will he meet with me to discuss this in detail?

01:05:49 - 01:05:55

Matthew Pennycook

I'll happily meet with the honorable gentleman.

01:05:55 - 01:06:13

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Minister meet with myself and the leader of City of York Council? The fair funding formula isn't working for our city because it doesn't use the lower tier data with regards to the indices of deprivation, meaning we're the worst funded local authority. So can we have that meeting?

01:06:13 - 01:06:16

Jim McMahon

Very happy to do so.

01:06:16 - 01:06:37

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite swift action from Dacorum Council to tackle a six-acre unauthorized development in Chiltern landscape, they had to choose between occupation or restoration because tackling both would have potentially dragged this out for years. So what are the government doing to help with powers and councils to ensure that these can be tackled sooner?

01:06:37 - 01:07:03

Matthew Pennycook

I think the honorable lady was referring to unauthorized development. We have strengthened national planning policy in respect of intentional unauthorized development, making it harder to grant permission after the fact where there's evidence that development was carried out intentionally without permission. However, it's become evident, we had a meeting on this subject, that we are seeing the prevalence of a more structured pattern of unauthorized development, Mr. Speaker, and we are working across government to see what more action might be taken to bear down on it.

01:07:03 - 01:07:25

Cameron Thomas

Thank you. New towns should be an opportunity to better manage development pressures, not add to them. So can I thank the Housing Minister for hearing our campaign to ensure that any Tewkesbury new town counts towards my local authority's housing targets, not in addition to it. How can we now ensure it's considered at pace so if approved it can count towards our local housing plan and the local planning process as quickly as possible?

01:07:25 - 01:07:48

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honorable friend for his question, the support he's given to the new towns program. We will bring forward, Mr. Speaker, final decisions in short order responding to that consultation that we undertook earlier this year and those proposed seven new town sites.

01:07:46 - 01:08:45

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This government is committed to delivering good growth across the country and power in every postcode, with places able to set their own ambitions and integrate services to meet people's needs. Achieving that requires a fundamental rewiring of the state, giving power held by Westminster and Whitehall back to people and places where they live and work. As we set out in the cabinet statement on rewiring the state, effective and sustainable local government is the vital foundation of our devolution ambitions. As we are now determined more than ever to devolve power across closer to the people we represent, it's only right that as the new Secretary of State, I make sure that everything we do is working towards that plan to change Britain.

01:08:45 - 01:08:56

Lindsay Hoyle

I think we've had this before, haven't we? Please, I want to hear this myself. It does affect my constituency and others, so the last thing I need is you heckling.

01:08:56 - 01:14:05

Angela Rayner

They'll get the chance, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister told the House last week he was prepared to look at local government reorganisation, and he asked me as his Communities Secretary to do that. Throughout this process, the government has listened to representations from members of this House, councils, and the public. And I want to be clear, Mr. Speaker, on how critical this is to me, given how important they are to our democracy and the services they provide for local people. But Mr. Speaker, there will always be a wide range of divergent views, which means achieving perfect consensus will never be possible.

I understand that feelings run high and people naturally have strong views, but in different directions. In that context, in light of legal advice, I want to satisfy myself first that the right process is in place that is robust and of course complies with the law. And secondly, I want to fully test whether our proposals for local government reorganisation meet the priorities of the new administration and the new Prime Minister and any additional considerations. With those two considerations in mind, I've decided to withdraw the decisions made in March this year for Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk, and Suffolk, and where relevant, Mr. Speaker, their neighbouring unitary authorities. The government's legal representatives have notified the court of this step.

I have also decided, Mr. Speaker, to conduct a full review of the local government reorganisation program, including the decisions that were announced in July of this year for a further 14 areas and those two areas where decisions have not yet been taken, and ask that reorganisation activity be paused. These 14 areas, Mr. Speaker, are Derbyshire, Devon, East Sussex, Gloucestershire, Hertfordshire, Kent, Lancashire, Leicestershire, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire, Oxfordshire, Staffordshire, Warwickshire, and Worcester, and where relevant, their neighbouring unitaries.

Mr Speaker, I do not take this lightly. I recognise the huge amount of work that has already gone into progressing reorganisation in each of these areas and I am very grateful for it. I know that many members of the House and many council leaders outside the House will have lots of questions about what this means for them and their communities and I will try to address these as best I can today. Firstly, we are working across government on rewiring the state following the cabinet statement. We recognise the effective and sustainable local government is fundamental to our ambitions for a devolved country which works better for and with communities and we will consider this issue as part of our wider approach.

And secondly, as an immediate step, I have asked the Minister for Local Government Devolution and Regional Growth to undertake a rapid review of the current local government reorganisation programme, including the position of the four areas where we've withdrawn and the further 14 areas that we are reviewing and pausing alongside the two remaining areas. New councils, Mr Speaker, for East and West Surrey will be unaffected because they are already established in law and have had their first elections and are on track to go live in April 2027. And thirdly, I want to be clear in terms of what this means for elections scheduled next May. Elections will go ahead in May 2027 on existing council boundaries. Finally, Mr Speaker, my department will provide support to council leaders, officers and members representing impacted areas and the Minister for Local Government has written to leaders and copied members of this House.

I want to assure that all those of you who represent these areas feel fully included in considering their future and I will update the House at the earliest opportunity. My ministerial team and civil servants from the department are ready, Mr Speaker, to discuss and work with you. My team will proactively reach out to discuss the implications locally in detail and my department remains committed to working in partnership with local government, both in this immediate period and in the longer term and I commend this statement to the House.

01:14:05 - 01:14:16

Lindsay Hoyle

Can I just say it's refreshing to actually hear it first in this chamber rather than TV. Shadow Minister David Simmons.

01:14:16 - 01:17:45

Paul Waugh

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to welcome the Secretary of State back to the dispatch box and to thank her for the early sight of her statement. I'm not sure this was the triumphal return to the subject of devolution that she had in mind because our councillors and the communities they represent are looking aghast at yet another shambolic U-turn from this government. Ministers have repeatedly given assurances to this House at that dispatch box that have not been honoured and it speaks volumes for that sense of priority that this far into this administration only Surrey has proceeded with its reorganisation despite all those assurances. Mr Speaker, the Secretary of State has already told the House that she is not satisfied that the process that was followed by her predecessor was lawful.

Can she tell the House from the dispatch box why she is not satisfied that it was lawful? And will she place all the non-privileged documentation and correspondence relating to this debacle in the public domain and in the library?

What assessment can she tell the House she has made, given that the government has agreed to pay the legal costs of councils that have challenged them on this matter? What assessment has she made of the legal costs that will be borne by taxpayers of the consequences of this U-turn? Given that this government has been banking on millions of pounds in savings, savings that we have challenged repeatedly across these dispatch boxes, to mitigate the costs, including the massive rise in national insurance, which has driven many councils to the verge of bankruptcy. What assessment have Treasury colleagues made, and what advice have they given her about how they will need to mitigate this further delay in any of those savings, should they ever materialize, being achieved? She's told the House from the dispatch box that elections will go ahead.

Now, Mr. Speaker, we've all heard that promise being made at that dispatch box before, and indeed in some cases reversed literally the following day. So given the promises that have been made, given that all of our political parties have selected candidates who've been campaigning for mayoral elections, for new unitary authorities, which this government promised were coming into being with elections to take place next May. Will she give a categorical assurance that those new authorities will be in place, or promise the House clearly that they won't? And will she tell us what the timetable is, if there is one at all, for bringing those new mayoral combined authorities into existence, particularly given the store by which the government has set those as their path for devolution? And finally, Mr. Speaker, let me ask her.

I appreciate she's returned to this role after others have been stewarding it. But will she apologize to all of those councillors, all of those local government officials, all of those political candidates and activists, all of those businesses that have engaged in good faith with this government's process, all of whom have been shamefully let down by this betrayal of local democracy?

01:17:45 - 01:19:38

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I welcome the honorable gentleman to his place and thank him for his constructive comments. Look, it is disappointing that I've come to the House and made this statement, and I recognize the work that local authorities, that members of this House, that others have put into getting us to this point. But Mr. Speaker, when I took over this role recently and the Prime Minister asked me to look at this again, and upon receiving legal advice, I wanted to satisfy myself as the Secretary of State that the process was robust and legally sound. And therefore, that is why I've made the decision today, and I understand why honorable members will be disappointed in that, but that is why I made that decision. In terms of legal costs, which was asked of me, legal costs will be determined in the usual way.

The government, you know, local government reform is often contested in courts, and it's right and part of our democratic system that important issues can be challenged, and the government engages legal advisers to defend decisions whenever challenges are brought, and that does bring costs. He asked me about the savings that are made. I'd just like to say that the government has made savings in the past on local government reorganization. But for me, Mr. Speaker, it's got to be about not savings, but about the outcomes for people in their local area. And that's what's driven reorganization from my point of view.

And in terms of the new mayoral authorities and what will happen, I'm really clear, Mr. Speaker, that it has to be done correct and right.

And I as Secretary of State have to in good conscience believe that I have dotted every i and crossed every t, and that's why I'm making the decision I've made today.

01:19:38 - 01:20:13

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. This has been a long process for Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, and we sort of ducked and dived as best we can with the announcements that have come over the last two years. But the thing that we really care about is devolution, because where the line is drawn on councils is is important, but the real powers that are unleashed for devolution are what makes a real difference to my constituents. So is the Secretary of State able to give some inclination as to the impact on the timetable for moving towards mayoral combined authorities for places like Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, where currently the opportunity does not meet our aspiration?

01:20:13 - 01:20:46

Angela Rayner

Well, my honorable friend's absolutely right to raise the opportunities with devolution. And the Prime Minister is really clear that that's what the government ambition is, to ensure that every area in England has or is in the process of establishing a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028. This process that I have put in place today is about making sure that we have a rapid review and we make the right and correct decisions on our reorganization.

01:20:46 - 01:22:23

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of her statement. I have almost lost track of the number of times I have stood in this chamber and warned the government about problems with its local government reorganization plans, and yet here I am again. It appears the government has finally listened, but it has done so too late and the damage has already been done. Thousands of residents have been denied their right to vote over the course of this process because of plans that many of us in this chamber warned were on very uncertain legal footing. Councils have poured enormous amounts of time, effort and money into proposals that they repeatedly assured were legally sound, only to discover they are now being abandoned.

The abortive costs are likely to be substantial. And worse still, a number of authorities were relying on reorganization as part of a strategy to address serious financial concerns. Those councils are now being left in limbo. In my own area of Surrey, councils were forced down a reorganization route that now appears to be effectively abandoned by the government and questionable on a legal basis. Will the Secretary of State commit to meeting with Surrey MPs and the new authority leaders to discuss how our county can avoid the risks and uncertainty the government says have prompted this decision elsewhere?

The government needs to acknowledge the significant democratic harm caused by this episode and take responsibility for it, including an apology. So will the Secretary of State set out clearly what happens next for communities and local authorities left in limbo by today's announcement, and will she publish the legal advice so Parliament and affected communities can understand what went wrong with the original process?

01:22:23 - 01:23:15

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've set out already, Mr. Speaker, I want to be able to review these decisions to ensure myself decisions are the right ones. And I think that is the correct course of action. Respecting the court process means the way to do this is to withdraw and consider afresh. And it's a long-standing principle, Mr. Speaker, that the government does not publish or comment on legal advice.

The review will consider implications for the timetable, as the honorable lady mentioned. Local elections scheduled to take place to existing councils in May 2027 will go ahead unless we are in a position to hold elections to new unitary councils at that point. And in Surrey, Mr. Speaker, the review does not include reorganization of Surrey. Councillors have been elected and new councils go live from the 1st of April.

01:23:15 - 01:23:48

Ashley Dalton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's a real appetite for change in my constituency of West Lancashire. We're not scared of it. We are eager for it. Only today we've actually seen former Reform Lancashire County Councillor for Skelmersdale East defecting to the Labour Party because he knows that Labour will deliver for Skem.

But can the Secretary of State assure me that the government will meet the ambition of my constituents and keep pushing for change and a better system for Lancashire?

01:23:48 - 01:24:18

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Mr. Speaker, and I commend the work of local representatives in Lancashire and commend them for the work that they've done. I've been really clear that I've paused to have a review of those places to make sure that I am confident as the Secretary of State going forward that I have dotted every I and crossed every T and worked with local people to ensure that we give them the best possible local government reform and devolution package.

01:24:18 - 01:24:53

Edward Leigh

I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for looking again at Lincolnshire. I put this point to a predecessor. The proposal for a Greater Lincolnshire was in the eyes of many people just a gerrymander. Will she look again at it and stop dividing West Lindsey and North Kesteven in half? You know, I represent Gainsborough South West Ward, the most deprived ward in the entire country.

I'm on the Pride of Place board. What was the point of dividing Gainsborough, letting it out on a limb for the rest of the county? So I'm grateful to her and will she look at our viewpoint in a positive way?

01:24:53 - 01:25:26

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I thank the Father of the House and I can feel his frustration but also acknowledge the plug he gave for the Pride of Place funding, which I think is making a real difference to some of the most deprived areas. But I want to reassure him that this review of the decision is about me making sure that it's the right decision to give me the time to listen to what honourable members and leaders are saying to ensure that I have got the correct advice. And as Secretary of State, I take that responsibility very seriously and I will make sure that that's done as quickly as possible.

01:25:26 - 01:26:07

Linsey Farnsworth

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for her statement today. I support local government reorganisation and the two unitary option for Derbyshire. But Chris Emmas-Williams, the leader of Amber Valley Borough Council and myself have repeatedly made representations against the decision to split Amber Valley into two. My constituents don't want it and I have concerns about the capacity to deliver that divide whilst maintaining the high standards of service that my constituents deserve. So will the right honourable friend, will my right honourable friend commit to meeting me to discuss this further?

01:26:07 - 01:26:34

Angela Rayner

I thank my right honourable friend for that question and pay tribute for the work that she's doing to represent her constituents in Amber Valley. As I've said, there is a pause whilst we review this program. I'm sure the Minister, as I've outlined, will arrange a meeting with herself and the local leaders there to ensure that we have got a full understanding of the challenges and the opportunities that Amber Valley have so that we can take it forward.

01:26:34 - 01:27:01

Bernard Jenkin

Can I thank the Secretary of State for her announcement, which however she dresses it up, is in fact a decision about common sense and listening. Can I put it to her that in Essex most of the district councils, the county council and most of the MPs want to stay with two-tier local government? Is that an option? Will she acknowledge that and listen?

01:27:01 - 01:27:41

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm glad that the honourable member says, used the term common sense and listening because I am trying to listen and use my common sense and be pragmatic about taking forward. As I said previously when I embarked on local government reform, this has to be about services to local people. And that on the two-tiered approach with local authorities, we've always been really clear about making sure that the split is absolutely right so you get the scale so that things like education and other areas can be delivered. And that's why we always said we'd consider those proposals on how best to deliver unitary councils in this Parliament.

01:27:40 - 01:28:12

Amanda Martin

Thank you Mr. Speaker. As Secretary of State and her ministers can attest throughout this reorganization process I've been fighting to protect my city's proud identity and its important but often neglected position in Hampshire. And Mr. Speaker I am sorry for all of the confusion and politicking residents have had to face it's simply not good enough. So as she reviews local reorganization in Portsmouth can she reassure my residents that any decision will maintain Portsmouth's strong identity and will she confirm that today's announcements will not delay the government's plan for devolution and putting power close to the people that we represent.

01:28:12 - 01:28:42

Angela Rayner

Well Mr. Speaker my honorable friend has been an absolute champion since being elected into Parliament for the people of Portsmouth and I don't think any of us will try and take the identity away from the people of Portsmouth and I'm sure that she will be pushing that. And she's absolutely right to talk about devolution and that we need to grasp the nettle on local government reform so that we can put areas in a strong place for devolution and we'll be working with her in the next coming weeks to ensure that that happens.

01:28:42 - 01:28:44

Speaker 109

Steve Darling.

01:28:44 - 01:29:07

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you Mr. Speaker. These current proposals for Devon were the brainchild of Exeter and Plymouth and endorsed by the Conservative leader of Torbay Council. They resulted in a rural rump for Devon. Can the Secretary of State give us assurances that the rural rump of Devon will not rear its ugly head again.

01:29:07 - 01:29:21

Angela Rayner

Well like I said Mr. Speaker I have paused that decision today and that we will be reviewing that and I'm sure the minister will be happy to meet with members for Devon to discuss the challenges that they faced in particular.

01:29:21 - 01:29:23

Lindsay Hoyle

Jonathan Hinder.

01:29:23 - 01:30:06

James Jonathan Hinder

Thank you Mr. Speaker. This decision is to put it mildly frustrating for everyone in Lancashire who has been involved in this process and I feel for councillors council workers and all the service users for having to deal with this frustration. My question to her today is what are the legal reasons that I can go back to my constituents and explain because at the moment listening to this statement I've got nothing to go back to my constituents with to explain why this has happened. When is the next step going to be? Are the boundaries which were just announced in July going to change?

Just give us something to go back to people with please.

01:30:06 - 01:30:44

Angela Rayner

Well Mr. Speaker I considered the legal advice provided as part of the JR process and the decision to withdraw the decision reflected updated legal clarity and it's a long-standing principle that the government does not publish or comment on legal advice. I have been really clear that I want to be able to review these decisions to ensure myself as the new Secretary of State that the decisions are the right ones. We'll consider the program in the round in light of the government's priorities set out in the re-running of the state and ministers will meet with members of this House and will set out decisions at our earliest opportunity.

01:30:44 - 01:30:46

Lindsay Hoyle

Dame Caroline Dinenage.

01:30:46 - 01:31:26

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much Mr. Speaker. I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for her statement but I have to confess to being a little bit more confused now than I was when I walked into the room because when it comes to Hampshire is this a pause or is this a cancellation? When will we know if this titanic waste of council taxpayers' money is actually going to re-emerge? The government's top-down reorganization plans have cost councils across Hampshire so much time so much money at a point where finances are already stretched to breaking point. Has she calculated the cost of this?

Will local authorities be reimbursed for the time and money already spent and when are we going to know what's in the plan.

01:31:26 - 01:31:55

Angela Rayner

Again Mr. Speaker I said that we would work at pace but I want to be able to review these decisions to ensure myself that the decisions are the right ones and respecting the court process that means that the way to do this is to withdraw and to consider afresh. And in terms of the issue around costs so far I recognize that a lot of work has gone into the financial commitments that have been made and this work is not wasted I'd say to the honorable member and the government has committed to providing transitional funding.

01:31:56 - 01:32:46

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There have been lots of different views about reorganization in my constituency of Dartford, but one thing everybody is fully agreed on is that Kent County Council is a failing organization. It is too big to be effective and it consistently lets residents right across the county down. So it's critical we get this right, and because it's residents who live with the results. While this pause is underway, how can we ensure that momentum is not lost in improving local services and ensuring that Kent and the different communities in Kent start to receive decent services?

And for instance, in my case, I'm disappointed we've lost the Thames Estuary Growth Board, but how can we ensure, Secretary of State, that we'll get the structures and powers we need to succeed and thrive?

01:32:46 - 01:33:16

Angela Rayner

Well, my honorable friend's absolutely right to recognize the work that has been done already and that we want to work at pace to review the program. And we will report back to Parliament at the earliest opportunity, Mr. Speaker. And hopefully that work that has been underway is already paying dividends to those areas. But I do understand the frustration, but I ask members who have worked really well in bringing these proposals forward to bear with me as I review this and take us forward at pace.

01:33:16 - 01:33:18

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir James Cleverly.

01:33:18 - 01:34:02

James Cleverly

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the 26th of March of this year, I said that people will ask whether these reforms are an act of gross gerrymandering and political opportunism or gross incompetence and stupidity. I think today we recognize that it's both. Now, the right honorable lady has only just returned to the dispatch box, so it can't really be her fault. So who screwed up?

Who is it that has wasted the time, effort, and money of people in Essex and in other parts of the country? She has the opportunity now to tell us where this went wrong, how it went wrong, and why, and I encourage her to do so.

01:34:02 - 01:34:40

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, I've made it really clear that I want to be able to review the decisions. I've made it clear that I was given legal advice that was provided to me as part of the JR process, and I have made a decision to withdraw because of where we're up to and to review the decision. And I want to also say a great number of dedicated and professional public servants have worked on this in both central and local government, and I want to thank them on record. But I want to be sure, Mr. Speaker, that as Secretary of State now, I'm making the correct decision with all information available.

01:34:40 - 01:34:42

Lindsay Hoyle

Alex McIntyre.

01:34:42 - 01:35:05

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Most Gloucester residents aren't interested in the details of who's running what services. They want to know what's important to them. Are their services going to improve? Are we going to feel the benefits of devolution?

And are we going to reverse the years of cuts under the previous government? Can the Secretary of State confirm that taking time to get this decision right will achieve those three aims?

01:35:05 - 01:35:43

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Mr. Speaker, and I commend my honorable friend for the work that he's been undertaking as well. I was really clear after 14 years of the Conservatives who took money out of local government and in fact boasted about taking money out of the most deprived areas, that I would work in a way that was to rebuild the foundations and the resilience of local government. And local government reorganization for me was about making sure that local areas feel the benefits and also can take forward devolution. And I want to make sure, Mr. Speaker, that I get that right as Secretary of State, and that's why I've made the decision today.

01:35:42 - 01:36:12

Jess Brown-Fuller

Mr. Speaker, I want to press upon the Secretary of State the anger that my local councillors across all parties are feeling at yet another pause because pauses create more uncertainty for local authorities when they should be planning for the future so that our residents get better services in the long term. So can the Secretary of State lay out if she believes a single resident in West Sussex is better off because of these reforms that were announced two years ago?

01:35:43 - 01:35:44

Jasper Ffoulkes.

01:35:44 - 01:35:45

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:36:12 - 01:36:51

Angela Rayner

Well again Mr. Speaker, I think that if we get this right this can really unlock benefits through local government reform. I absolutely believe in that whether that's in education, in transport, in local services, in social care, I believe it can unlock. I am a big champion of local government, I'm a creature of it, I spent a long time there and represented members who work in local authorities. So I want to get this right and I say to the honorable member, she's absolutely correct to pull me up on it and say that people are frustrated. I understand that, but I want in good conscience make sure that I've got all the information available, I'm working with local areas to get this right.

01:36:51 - 01:37:34

Lindsay Hoyle

Michael Payne. Thank you Mr. Speaker, back in July in this place I called for a review of the decision in Nottingham and Nottinghamshire so I hugely welcome the announcement of the pause and review by the Secretary of State into the decision in Nottingham and Nottinghamshire. And let me say this to the Secretary of State, she's a long-standing friend of mine, whatever the noise she receives today, she should know that listening and pausing is a sign of strength, not a sign of weakness. Will the Secretary of State therefore assure me that during this review, the views of local residents of mine in Gedling, local councillors and myself as the Member of Parliament in Gedling will be properly heard, taken seriously and genuinely reflected on whatever the decision is ultimately made?

01:37:34 - 01:38:08

Angela Rayner

Absolutely Mr. Speaker, and I again commend my honorable friend for his years of service to local government. And I think it's absolutely right, I've had the privilege and honor to be reappointed as the Secretary of State in this job and it is my number one priority to get it right for honorable members here and those from all different political parties that have invested so much into local government reform because they believe that this will unlock potential and support for their constituents and I want to make sure I've done the time to get it right and that's why I've made this decision.

01:38:08 - 01:38:44

Leo Brown

Leo Brown. In the government's own consultation on whether to expand Leicester, nine out of ten people said no. Tens of thousands of people have signed petitions against it and yet ministers until they hit this legal snag tried to press on anyway. When I wrote to them, ministers said that they wouldn't publish any of the advice or guidance they'd been given ahead of making this decision, leaving local people wondering what have they got to hide. So can they answer at least this question: why do ministers sat here in London believe that they know better than local people in Leicestershire what local people in Leicestershire want?

01:38:44 - 01:39:21

Angela Rayner

Well, I'd gently say to the honorable member is what we're trying to achieve is working with local members to get better outcomes for local people and that's why I've made the decision to pause and to review it and I'm happy for the honorable member to meet with the minister who will be taking this forward and to make sure that his views and the views of his local members are fully part, fully engaged and fully part of this process. I do believe as a principle Mr. Speaker, that local government reform can unlock great potential for local areas and I remain committed to that but I'm going to do it properly and right.

01:39:21 - 01:39:51

Amanda Hack

Amanda High. Thank you Mr. Speaker, I thank the Secretary of State for her statement. When the announcement for Leicester, Leicestershire, Rutland came forward in July, I wanted reassurance from the then Secretary of State about the barriers to growth which for Leicestershire is not having a mayor and without a devolution settlement.

So what reassurance can the Secretary of State give in light of this announcement that my constituents of North West Leicestershire will no longer feel the delay of not having a devolution settlement?

01:39:51 - 01:40:18

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, I've said really clear that the government's ambition to ensure that every area in England has or is in the process of establishing a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028. I agree with my honourable friend that achieving good growth requires a fundamental rewiring of the way our country works, and I want to work with her and her local leaders to make sure that they reach their full potential.

01:40:18 - 01:40:19

Stephen Barclay.

01:40:19 - 01:40:53

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Her predecessor rushed to the House on the last day before recess, less than two months ago, to say how essential these were, and these benches warned that it was gerrymandering. And it's not that the Secretary of State has listened, she's been told by her lawyers that it is gerrymandering. And the warning signs were there two months ago when Cambridgeshire itself was paused. So in announcing a pause again for Cambridgeshire, can she tell my residents how long this pause will be for and how much it will cost?

01:40:53 - 01:41:31

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, I said that I want to do this at pace, the review at pace, and I'll be working on that. But I also, I also want to place on record that there is no suggestion of wrongdoing by my honourable friends, the members for Croydon North and Birkenhead. They are quite correct that we must review processes and learn lessons, and I'm pleased that we will today announce our new permanent secretary in my department with an impeccable track record, Mr. Speaker, in public service, including local government. And I will make sure that we continue at pace to ensure we get the best of local government reform for his area.

01:41:31 - 01:41:32

Rachel Taylor.

01:41:32 - 01:42:07

Margaret Rachel Taylor

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement. In North Warwickshire and Bedworth, our councils, businesses, voluntary organisations were all preparing for new unitary councils. They'll be disappointed with this news, but we must get reorganisation right. Can she assure the councils who are struggling to recruit and retain high-quality officers, the businesses who want to invest, and the voluntary organisations that are preparing to restructure, that this pause will not be an undue delay and the towns and villages in my constituency will not be left behind without the investment devolution will bring?

01:42:07 - 01:42:37

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Mr. Speaker, and my honourable friend is absolutely right to highlight the challenges but also the opportunities that can be unlocked as part of this process. I appreciate the specific work that has been done that needs to be paused, but I would say to the honourable member that they can continue with cross-cutting things like data sharing, and my officials will be in touch to make sure we're giving the right support to her local area so that we can get back on track and make sure that we deliver for her constituents.

01:42:37 - 01:42:38

Robert Jenrick.

01:42:38 - 01:43:19

Edward Robert Jenrick

Earlier in the year, her predecessor's decision to cancel elections for five million people was overturned on the eve of it going to the courts, amidst allegations of gerrymandering. Now, her predecessor's decision to reorganise local councils has been overturned on the eve of it going to the courts, amidst allegations of gerrymandering. What is going wrong in the Secretary of State's department, and how is she going to reassure people that this government takes decisions fairly, in accordance with the law, and actually respects local democracy?

01:43:19 - 01:44:09

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, let me be really clear.

It hasn't been overturned. I as Secretary of State have made a decision to withdraw so that I could have a look and have a clear sight of what's going on and the and review those decisions. I've made that in good conscience because I want to make sure that we absolutely get this right. And and I dispute the gerrymandering allegation, Mr. Speaker. I don't believe that that is the case, but I am really clear that local government reform can unlock potential in his area, in areas across England, and that's what I want to do with local people.

I understand that we won't get consensus and it is probably going to be a highly litigated area, but I do want to work hard to get this right as quickly as possible so we can deliver for his constituents.

01:44:09 - 01:44:41

Alan Andrew Lewin

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Welcome Secretary of State back to her position. I've been an advocate of local government reorganization, but my thoughts today are for the local council officers and councillors who have been working so hard for so long, including in some instances people who have been employed specifically to manage the transition. So would my right honorable friend give them some reassurance today? What they need above all else is certainty.

And can she tell the House that in Hertfordshire, where she's promised a full review, that she will come forward as soon as possible with clear clarity on the timelines and what comes next?

01:44:41 - 01:45:18

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Mr. Speaker. And and I also agree with my honorable friend the amount of work that has gone in from local officers and from representatives within councils as part of this process. And I recognize that a lot of work has gone into the financial commitments that have been made as well. And I want to say to the House this work is not wasted. We are reviewing at pace so that I can come to the House at the earliest opportunity.

And the government has committed to providing transitional funding and I and I would urge him and his local leaders to contact my department.

01:45:18 - 01:45:41

Rachel Maclean

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And in Worcestershire, this has thrown everything into disarray. And I wonder if the Secretary of State can clarify, now that we're asking people to stand as district councillors next May, if that will be for a four-year term?

01:45:41 - 01:46:05

Angela Rayner

Well well again, what I've said, Mr. Speaker, is that the elections next year will be on the old boundaries. And we will continue and we will continue at pace with local government reorganization and working with the area to make sure we get it right. So I would urge her and her local leaders to make contact with my department and the minister so we can take that forward.

01:46:05 - 01:46:26

Madeleine Sarah Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome Secretary of State's statement. Before the summer, I raised the concerns of my constituents in Hyndburn around the proposals for a Pennine Lancs authority, which could become the most deprived in the country. So as her ministers undertake the review here, will they look at that very, very closely and consider the perspectives of my constituents on this issue?

01:46:26 - 01:46:41

Angela Rayner

Well again, Mr. Speaker, absolutely right to raise these issues. And we want to make sure we get it right working with local leaders. And I'm sure the honorable member will have the opportunity to speak with ministers and my officials going forward as we look at this review.

01:46:41 - 01:47:12

Steffan Aquarone

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. North Norfolk has more than 2,000 people waiting for housing, a coastline which we're trying to defend from falling into the North Sea, endless challenges from being an underfunded rural authority, and now they have been made to waste 600,000 pounds on a local government reorganization program that the Secretary of State demanded and has now gone back on. One question will be about the future of devolution for Norfolk, but what people in North Norfolk will be thinking first is we want our money back. Will she give it to us?

01:47:12 - 01:47:43

Angela Rayner

Well again, Mr. Speaker, I push back a little bit on that because I don't think that this is wasted. I've said I want a review and I've put a pause in place to carry out that review to make sure as Secretary of State I get it absolutely right.

So I don't think that that money is wasted. I've been really clear that the government has committed to providing transitional funding and I want to continue to work with his local leaders so that we can get local government reform on track. But I want to be confident that I'm making the correct decisions for his local area, with his local area and delivering what they want.

01:47:43 - 01:48:24

Christopher David Ward

Thank you Mr. Speaker and can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement. A pause and a review is clearly the right step here. But what my constituents in particularly those in East Saltdean, Peacehaven and Telscombe will want to know now is what comes next. So can she just answer two things for me specifically? Firstly, the review she's announced, will it look again at the boundaries that were announced, the precise boundaries in May as well as the legal process that got to it?

And secondly, how will my constituents have a chance to shape that decision? Will it be through MPs or will there be another consultation and how can they feed in so we can get this right and make LGR the success we both know it can be?

01:48:24 - 01:48:46

Angela Rayner

Well I thank my honourable friend for that and the review will look at those issues and then I'll be able to give a more detailed with the minister response to to how that happens. But I want to make sure that local members feel that this review takes into account the issues and concerns that people raises, that it's done in a prompt way, but it's done in an inclusive way so that we can make the right decisions for his local area.

01:48:46 - 01:49:21

David Reed

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Building 1.5 million new homes and doing LGR at the same time was clearly bonkers. Now from freedom of information requests that I've submitted, local councils in my area have already spent over a million pounds trying to do LGR. And that's much needed money that could have been spent on SEND and other critical things within my county. So can the Secretary of State, before any more money is wasted, please be very explicit what is happening in Devon, will elections be happening next May and can she give an indication when a decision will be reached?

01:49:21 - 01:49:52

Angela Rayner

Well again I've said Mr. Speaker that we'll look at the review happening as speedily as possible. The government committed 63 million pound for transition costs to support councils including 900,000 per unitary. And again Mr. Speaker I say that I don't think this is wasted. I do believe that certainly from my perspective as the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister's local government reform is about delivering for people in their local area better services and I want to work with him and his local leaders to make sure that that happens.

01:49:52 - 01:50:40

Patrick Spencer

Thank you Mr. Speaker and I thank the Secretary of State for her statement today. I know it's an incredibly difficult one to make but I also know how disappointed and concerned local residents, businesses, organisations and of course councils will be. They put in a huge amount of work into this and not least in the last six months when the original decision was made. But this isn't just about looking to the past, it's also about looking forward to the future. And that's why so many people including myself are championing Greater Ipswich and South Suffolk, East Suffolk Council and a West Suffolk Council.

But just on the verge of when we thought a new future was possible, this has changed everything. So can the Secretary of State offer some reassurance to all my local residents, businesses, organisations and councils that we aren't going to go right back to the start of the drawing board here?

01:50:40 - 01:51:22

Angela Rayner

Well I thank my honourable friend and recognise the amount of work that local leaders, himself and others have put into this. And effective and sustainable local government is key to our ambitions on devolution and as part of that we are looking at the overall program timings but we're not moving back from local government reform. I absolutely believe in that. What I am doing as Secretary of State is making sure that I have reviewed those decisions and I'm taking them forward in a way that satisfies myself and my obligations to this house that I have delivered what is expected of me. And I would rather come to this house and say I've had to put a delay to satisfy myself of that than to make in haste and then regret at leisure.

01:51:21 - 01:51:56

Adnan Hussain

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Having consistently raised concerns about the proposed East Lancashire Authority, which would group together some of the most deprived communities, I welcome the Secretary of State's decision today to pause these plans. Can I ask the Secretary of State to assure me that this review will look at deprivation, economic stability, and together with an assurance that this will deliver for Blackburn and the surrounding areas? And will she meet with me and other Lancashire MPs before any new proposals are made?

01:51:56 - 01:52:27

Angela Rayner

Well, I give the honorable member assurances that the Minister is here in this place and he will be meeting with you, with the members of Lancashire. And we do want to make sure that we unlock the potential for that area. And that means the Prime Minister talked about growth in every postcode, making sure that devolution and local government reorganization delivers for everybody across the whole of Lancashire. And that's what we want to do when we put this review forward, and that's at the forefront of my mind.

01:52:27 - 01:53:03

Calum Miller

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have to say I'm really disappointed by this. Councils have had months working on proposals and resources and precious time has been spent on it, or I would say wasted on it. Now, growth is meant to be a priority for this government and Oxfordshire is a high growth delivery area, yet we have no devolution, no local government reorganization, and no timescale for either. Will the Secretary of State or one of her ministers meet with myself and my honorable friend the member for Oxford East to discuss the shortcomings in this high value growth area?

01:53:03 - 01:53:38

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, absolutely happily meet with the honorable member and the Minister as part of this program. And the new Prime Minister's made absolutely clear that we want to see growth in every postcode and that actually in order for the UK and England in particular to raise its growth agenda, it needs to be that every area feels that. And we've had the Chancellor make a statement earlier today about how he sees that as a priority for his areas and that devolution is part of that program. So we will be in touch with him to support his area.

01:53:38 - 01:53:56

Desmond Swayne

Delighted, Mr. Speaker, delighted at the reprieve. The New Forest was to be split and part of it swallowed by Southampton. Will she accept my representation that while she wants the New Forest to remain, its integrity to remain, the last thing we want is it all swallowed by Southampton?

01:53:56 - 01:54:12

Angela Rayner

Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm glad I've pleased the honorable member. I don't think I've ever done that before, but I'm really pleased that I've done that. And of course, happy to work with him going forward. And you never know, I might even visit the New Forest without the split.

01:54:12 - 01:54:43

Paul Stuart Anderson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Back to Lancashire again. The residents of Lancashire, and in particular the two authorities that represent my constituency of Chorley and South Ribble, are rightly really disappointed with this news, Secretary of State. However, can you please just reiterate and commit that local government reorganization in Lancashire is still a commitment of this government and that this is a pause and that you'll be reporting back and hopefully will go to the four unitary model? Thank you.

01:54:43 - 01:55:25

Angela Rayner

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I absolutely am committed to making sure that areas like Chorley and Lancashire do get local government reform and we take it forward. This is a pause and I haven't taken that decision lightly, but I do want to review the decisions and make sure for my peace of mind as Secretary of State that I've got this absolutely right. And I've taken on board the legal advice that has been given to me recently and making sure that the Prime Minister who tasked me last week with reviewing this, that I can go to the Prime Minister and say I have reviewed it and we are making the right decisions. I accept I won't get everybody's consent around the House, but I want to make sure that I've at least heard everybody's views.

01:55:26 - 01:56:07

Adrian Philip Ramsay

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Councillors and council officers have put a huge amount of time at the government's request into preparing for these proposals. Time that could have been put into improving council services. And yet if there's going to be another extended period of instability it will worsen that situation further. Does the Secretary of State accept that local government funding is extremely stretched especially for councils that run services such as SEND and social care and that they have very little money for anything else?

And does she agree that if local government reorganisation is going to go ahead and devolution is to be meaningful it needs to put the hands money into the hands of local people and there needs to be proper funding for local government?

01:56:07 - 01:56:08

Secretary of State.

01:56:08 - 01:56:49

Angela Rayner

Well again Madam Deputy Speaker I say that this government has recognised that after 14 years of failure by the Conservatives that local government had faced the brunt of austerity and we did put additional funding in. But we also recognise and and I want to say that the most important thing as part of local government reorganisation is about delivering for local people better services. And the Prime Minister has said and recognised that in terms of devolution. We recognise the investment that's gone in. That's why we've put transitional funding in place to support councils.

But I want to work to get this right because I absolutely believe that this will be the best for his local constituents.

01:56:49 - 01:56:51

Judith Cummins

Kevin McKenna.

01:56:51 - 01:57:31

Kevin McKenna

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I very much want to welcome what the Secretary of State has said from the dispatch box today in two forms. One there is no question that the two-tier system is very very bad for the people of Sittingbourne and Sheppey and across Kent. So I welcome her commitment to go on and press ahead with local government reorganisation. At the same time the geographies that were announced by her predecessor just before the summer recess were absolutely terrible for the people of Sittingbourne and Sheppey.

So I'd really like to hear from the Secretary of State how myself local councillors local residents businesses and other organisations locally can feed into this review which which again I am really grateful is going to happen.

01:57:31 - 01:57:32

Secretary of State.

01:57:32 - 01:58:03

Angela Rayner

Well I thank my honourable friend for his contribution and my department will be reaching out to to local authorities to the areas affected to make sure that we are taking into account all of the information that we have at hand. And the minister is willing to meet with represent representatives of of the local areas as well to make sure we get this right. I don't want this review to go on for a considerable length of time. I want to do it rapid but I want to be reassured that the decisions we're making are the right decisions.

01:58:03 - 01:58:05

Judith Cummins

Dr Caroline Johnson.

01:58:05 - 01:58:29

Caroline Johnson

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker the Labour leader of City of Lincoln Council has put forward suggestions that votes should be weighted on the basis of deprivation leading to proposed wards with an electorate of 2,100 electors per councillor and others with 4,700 electorate per councillor. Does the Secretary of State agree with me that all our votes should be created equal?

01:58:29 - 01:58:30

Secretary of State.

01:58:30 - 01:58:33

Angela Rayner

None of that is progressing Madam Deputy Speaker.

01:58:33 - 01:58:35

Judith Cummins

Daniel Zeichner.

01:58:35 - 01:59:13

Daniel Zeichner

Oh thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Devolution and local government reorganisation in my view are very different things and to be honest should probably be considered separately but they've become so interlinked and intertwined in this debate that it is impossible to do so. But if we're going to have a stronger devolution settlement it seems to me it's right to spend more time getting it right. But I wonder if the Secretary of State would agree with me that in any new structures that emerge they should be based on economic growth and dynamism rather than having to be built on existing districts the building blocks which quite frankly were established in a very different economic era.

01:59:13 - 01:59:14

Secretary of State.

01:59:14 - 01:59:45

Angela Rayner

Absolutely and I I do agree with my honourable friend and and again in our past lives we've both worked in local government and on local government policy for some time.

I do believe that we have to take time to get this right and he's absolutely right to make the distinction between local government reform and devolution but how the two can intertwine to help us on our way. I do believe that this doesn't impact on the timetable for devolution. Unitary local government can help with smoothing functions of strategic authorities but is not a prerequisite to it.

01:59:45 - 02:00:13

John Richard Foord

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Devon is one of 14 areas where local government reorganization is being reviewed and paused. And I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for having listened to Liberal Democrats in Devon and perhaps also to her legal advisors. When the rapid review takes place, please will the Secretary of State consider that there are greater costs associated with delivering services in the countryside such as in rural Devon.

02:00:13 - 02:00:48

Angela Rayner

Well again, I think some of the challenges that rural areas face like for example transport and one of the reasons that the Prime Minister has been so eager to make sure that devolution happens is that those that are closest to what's going on in their local area know what the challenges are faced and how we can unlock some of the potential for their local areas. And I believe that that is something that Devon could really take positive from and we want to work with Devon to make sure that they get the right local devolution for them and that local government reform is absolutely the right for them and that's why I paused the decision.

02:00:48 - 02:01:24

Sojan Joseph

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituency Ashford and people in Kent cannot wait any longer to see an improvement in their roads, local bus services, social care and SEND provision. They were let down by decades of Tory administration and now reform. Can the Secretary of State reassure that this pause is not going to create more uncertainty and will decline in further in these public services.

02:01:24 - 02:02:04

Angela Rayner

Well Madam Deputy Speaker, he's absolutely right my honorable friend to raise the issue of what happened under the Conservatives and that is why this Labour government took steps to ensure that we recognized what local government had been through and build the resilience back up and recognize the funding pressures. But local government reform to me is about making sure that people get the right services at the right level and that we can deliver the best for their local area and that's what hopefully we'll be able to deliver. I still believe and am committed to local government reform Madam Deputy Speaker, I just want to make sure that we get this right.

02:02:04 - 02:02:41

Priti Patel

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Since the Secretary of State first announced these plans when she last held this role, the Labour government has played fast and loose with our local democracy council elections and creating chaos and uncertainty in our councils as they struggle to deliver key frontline services. So as she goes to work on this review going forward, will she publish alongside the legal advice she has received the financial costs that councils in Essex have faced from this massive U-turn. And has she assessed the adverse impact on local services caused by the time and resources spent on these changes.

02:02:41 - 02:03:04

Angela Rayner

Well again Madam Deputy Speaker, I gently say this is not a U-turn, this is me as Secretary of State reviewing and making sure we get this right. I still believe that local government reform especially in particular in her area can deliver for her local constituents and I want them to engage with us. We've got transitional funding in place, we put that in place to support and her local authorities and local areas can get in touch with my department regarding that.

02:03:04 - 02:03:38

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I warmly welcome the Secretary of State back to her place and I especially welcome her statement today as will many people back home in Newcastle-under-Lyme who only wanted to be listened to. Back in July in the strongest terms I asked her predecessor to think again and pause, today she has done that and I'm grateful.

I hope she'll listen to the many representations I've made to her department. Can I go one step further, Madam Deputy Speaker, and ask the Secretary to focus on establishing the new mayoral authorities where there is comprehensive cross-party, cross-community support that we need for the changes of that scale?

02:03:38 - 02:04:04

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister's been really clear about what he wants to see in terms of our devolution agenda and we will be taking that forward. As I've said, this will be a rapid review. I want to make sure that that is done and that the decisions are the right decisions, but we are moving forward with devolution and we will be engaging his local area so they can unlock their full potential.

02:04:04 - 02:04:38

John Whittingdale

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I say to the Secretary of State that my constituents in Maldon never asked for local government reorganisation? They do not support local government reorganisation, which they see as leading to decisions being taken by more remote, more expensive and less accountable authority. So will she confirm that maintaining the status quo is at least an option as a part of her review? And can she also say, is it still intended to go ahead with a mayoral election in Essex in 2028?

02:04:38 - 02:05:10

Angela Rayner

Well, again, as I said, and I gently say to the honourable member that I actually think that local government reform can unlock potential for their areas. What we want to do it with areas and to look at how we're able to deliver for his area. I think there are opportunities and sometimes there is duplication and therefore how we're able to improve on services for his local constituents, I welcome that discussion. And again, on in terms of taking forward the devolution agenda, I don't envisage that being interrupted by this process.

02:05:10 - 02:06:03

Alex Baker

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's never too late to make sure a decision is the right one, but I'm pleased to hear the Secretary of State recognising the challenge this is for local councils such as my district council, Rushmoor Council, who've worked so hard to deliver LGR in our community. But this also impacts businesses, schools and community organisations across Aldershot and Farnborough who have spent months committing time and energy to preparing for local government reorganisation on the basis of the government's decision. Does the Minister recognise how frustrating it is for them now to have that certainty pulled away? And has the department considered the cost and disruption this decision will cause beyond local councils themselves?

02:06:03 - 02:06:43

Angela Rayner

Well, again, I thank my honourable friend and members of her local community who have really engaged in local government reform. And again, I reiterate at this dispatch box my commitment to that, but to make sure that we get it right. And I think the example that I can give especially to the young people in her area is that if you feel that you haven't got all the information, then it's okay to say that and then to take it forward in the correct way. And that is the right and correct way forward. And there are, we are committed to providing transitional funding and I would urge her and her local leaders to be in touch with my department and we can take a look at that.

02:06:43 - 02:07:18

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Madam Deputy Chairman. In Lincolnshire, as we heard from the Father of the House a short while ago, there is a welcome for the review in the county council area, but in the north of the county where the two unitaries are, I and my two neighbouring colleagues, her Labour colleagues, favour the status quo, as do the council leaders. Could I urge the Secretary of State to make an early decision to say that at least in respect of the two unitaries that the status quo will continue?

02:07:18 - 02:07:28

Angela Rayner

Well, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to give clarity to the honourable gentleman and to his local leaders and I will review it at pace to make sure that we're able to do that.

02:07:28 - 02:07:57

Speaker 155

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituents in Gillingham and Rainham want a local government that works for them and delivers the services that they need. Could the Secretary of State provide some reassurance that while this review is taking place that the that she will continue to look at local government funding and finances and particularly at how councils like mine which are Medway Council in a non-mayoral area actually able to access investment and growth opportunities in a way that other devolved authorities are able to do so.

02:07:57 - 02:07:58

Secretary of State.

02:07:58 - 02:08:24

Angela Rayner

Absolutely Madam Deputy Speaker. It's really important as the Prime Minister set out that every area every postcode feels the benefits of growth and that we can unlock the potential through devolution and local government reform is part of that process but not the only bit of that process. And I do believe that this will put areas in a strong position through devolution and that we can be able to deliver better services to her local area and start to repair some of the damage that was done with the cuts to local government under the previous government.

02:08:25 - 02:09:15

Timothy James Farron

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I wonder if the Secretary of State would clarify that the mayoral election in Cumbria will go ahead as planned and the planned introduction of the combined authority would also come in without further hindrance or disruption or uncertainty. And would she also take this opportunity to review the other mistake this government has made when it comes to devolution of the last couple of years and that is the errors when it comes to what's referred to wrongly as fairer funding. Westmorland and Furness is the most rural unitary authority in England and for that crime it's borne a penalty of a 31% cut in its funding from the government meaning devolution normally no longer looks like devolution of power more like delegation of cuts for the people of Cumbria.

02:09:15 - 02:09:16

Secretary of State.

02:09:16 - 02:09:53

Angela Rayner

Well again Madam Deputy Speaker we you know I recognise that what local government have been through after 14 years of the Conservatives and actually I think you were there your party was there at the time. But look in the spirit of trying to you know recognise the challenges that areas face I do believe that the local government reorganisation and what I'm saying today doesn't impact it doesn't impact on the timetable for devolution. So I do believe that that will go ahead and unitary local government can help with the smooth functioning of strategic authorities.

02:09:53 - 02:10:46

Toby Perkins

Toby Perkins.

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. In Chesterfield there will be unmitigated despair at the statement we've heard today from my right honourable friend and that for those authorities that she is doing a review into the 14 that thought they'd got their decision in July can she clarify what the basis of that review is. Is she still attempting to achieve what we were attempting to achieve previously in terms of the number the size and the authority or is she relooking at the basis of what that should achieve. And we were told in February 2026 that when the previous 2026 elections were cancelled and then the cancellation was cancelled that this definitely would not be happening in 2027. Can we find out what has actually gone wrong because there is a real lack of confidence that what we're being told one day is the same thing we're going to be told the next.

02:10:46 - 02:10:47

Secretary of State.

02:10:47 - 02:11:26

Angela Rayner

Well I appreciate my honourable friend and his comments and I appreciate the frustration but again I have considered the legal advice that was provided as part of the JR process and also the Prime Minister asked me to review this process and therefore I took the decision that I needed more time. And I really appreciate how that has left people and the frustration on that. This is not the end of local government reform Madam Deputy Speaker. We remain committed to unitary councils and the review will again consider proposals and how best to deliver unitary councils in this parliament including ensuring alignment with the priorities of the new administration.

02:11:26 - 02:11:28

Speaker 148

Liz Jarvis.

02:11:28 - 02:11:49

Liz Jarvis

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Communities like mine in Eastleigh are being denied funding opportunities because they do not yet have an elected mayor. With the timeline for local government reorganisation and elections now thrown into doubt, will the Secretary of State ensure that funding opportunities are offered to all local authorities whether or not they have an elected mayor?

02:11:49 - 02:12:23

Angela Rayner

Well again devolution Madam Deputy Speaker can unlock funding and potential. It doesn't necessarily need to have a mayor and I think the Prime Minister outlined that in his statement that he made I think over three hours of questions that he did. I say to the honourable member to have a look back at that but this was about making sure that devolution can be unlocked for areas at their pace at what which they wish. And as I've said in this statement that I don't believe that this particular pause will have an impact in terms of people's ability to continue that devolution agenda.

02:12:23 - 02:12:56

Christopher Paul Webb

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I understand the limits on what my right honourable friend will be able to say today but it seems that there's been real failures in official process for now she's being accountable and that many in our constituencies now are put on hold because of even though she's not actually responsible. So can my right honourable friend assure me that she will investigate any failures of process that have occurred and led us to this situation and so we can learn the lessons so it doesn't happen again?

02:12:56 - 02:13:37

Angela Rayner

Well my honourable friend is absolutely right that we do have to review process and learn lessons. And as I said to an honourable member not so long ago that we have announced our new permanent secretary and I'm sure that he will be listening to this debate and will want to take that forward as well. But I want to place on record my thanks to the dedicated professional public servants that have worked on this from both central and local government and also place on record my thanks to my predecessor. And I want to reassure the House that this is a decision I've made as Secretary of State to ensure that I've got all the facts in order to make the decision.

02:13:37 - 02:14:17

Kit Malthouse

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I have to confess to the Secretary to the Secretary of State that I'm even more confused now than the honourable lady for Gosport was 40 minutes ago. So could I just be clear, could she just be clear with my residents? The combined authority elections that were due next May are off and the borough council elections are on. But the combined authority elections might be on if she gets her skates on and the borough council elections might be off.

And if the combined authority elections are off, when will they be on? And is the mayoral election in 2028 on or off? And if it's off, what's going to happen to police governance?

02:14:17 - 02:14:34

Angela Rayner

Well Madam Deputy Speaker I've said that the review is on. The elections are on. I'm ready to get on with it and I'm sure the member will work with me to make sure we get it sorted and it's on.

02:14:34 - 02:15:11

Stephen Race

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. One of the policy goals of LGR is to encourage economically important cities like Exeter to better play their role in generating jobs, growth, housing and better place-based services. In our case devolution does not work without Exeter being on that strategic authority. It's one of the two big economic drivers of the region. Can the Secretary of State confirm that this remains the case and that this rapid review, should it be have a positive outcome, we can move forward with both LGR and devolution in Devon in the future?

02:15:11 - 02:15:32

Angela Rayner

Well I want to reassure my honourable friend that I've said this review should be rapid and we should get on with it as as quickly as possible with that engagement. But also that devolution should the timetable for devolution shouldn't be affected. That we need to make sure that we make the right decisions on local government reform but we want to take forward devolution at pace.

02:15:32 - 02:16:03

Speaker 153

Thank you. To paraphrase everyone this local government reform is a shambolic incompetent mess now.

I just want to put on record how much time as well as money has been spent by councillors and by council officials right across Norfolk. It's been a massive monumental distraction, not for months, but for years. The Independent Local Government Association say this, and I quote, "There is no excuse for the government's mishandling of this process." Does she agree?

02:16:03 - 02:16:56

Angela Rayner

No, Madam Deputy Speaker. What I have said is that I have reviewed the decisions. I have said on record that the work that people across Norfolk, the people, representatives across the whole conurbation have put in a great amount of work. I want to, I want to respect that work as the new Secretary of State and make sure that I am listening, that I have reviewed the decisions and that I have made sure that I am making the right and the correct decision. I don't believe that that's a waste of the time and the resources that have been put into this.

I do believe local government reform is an opportunity for Norfolk and I will work with local leaders to at pace give them that certainty. But I wanted to, out of respect for their work, make sure that I take that into consideration as the Secretary of State.

02:16:56 - 02:16:58

Andy McDonald

Andy McDonald.

02:16:58 - 02:17:48

Speaker 164

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I do echo comments made by Lancashire colleagues, particularly in this being an opportunity to review the boundary decisions. But I do also think that all those councillors and officers who worked so hard on reorganisation and made so much progress in Lancashire do deserve an apology here. But more fundamentally, more fundamentally, every week that goes past, every day, Lancashire falls further behind our neighbours in Manchester and Liverpool, simply through a lack of an effective structure along with the capacity and capability to deliver our growth potential. I was pleased to hear the Secretary of State's recommitment to growth in every postcode.

So will she meet with me along with Lancashire colleagues to agree how we can properly resource Lancashire's growth potential? We can't wait, we need to do it now, we need to properly resource it and we need to deliver on potential through this period of uncertainty.

02:17:48 - 02:18:16

Angela Rayner

Well, again, I say to my honourable friend that I recognise the work that has gone in, Madam Deputy Speaker, and that work is not wasted. That this pause will be about working with local areas at pace to get this right. But it doesn't mean that we can't take advantage of unlocking growth in every postcode. And the ministers here will be happy to work with the honourable member and other honourable members from that area to ensure that we get the devolution and the package that works right for them.

02:18:16 - 02:18:17

Gagan Mohindra.

02:18:17 - 02:19:07

Gagan Mohindra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm going to try a different tack rather than the hokey-cokey of this process. The more serious point is that local government reorganisation was always a significant risk to the voluntary and community sector. Many charitable funders are reluctant to fund organisations with annual incomes exceeding one million pounds, leaving these organisations reliant on commission contracts from local government, NHS bodies and other public sector departments. The proposed transition to unitary authorities was already disrupting the existing funding streams.

Today's announcement leaves this even more so. What reassurance can the Secretary of State give those important community organisations to ensure that they have the funding in place, but also the certainty and direction of travel to have the confidence to actually start and continue to do the services they do for my community?

02:19:07 - 02:19:34

Speaker 162

Well, again, I want to reassure the honourable member that this is about getting the process right. And I want him and those local organisations to get in contact with my officials to make sure that we're doing everything possible to support that process. I've said that unitary local government can help with the smooth functioning of strategic authorities. And I've also recognised that the government is committed to providing transition funding, so please come ahead and get in touch with my department.

02:19:35 - 02:19:55

Luke Murphy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for her statement. It will be met with some disappointment and frustration locally, not least because many businesses, community groups, charities, councillors and council officers have put an enormous amount of effort into the proposal for a Northampton authority.

I do believe that is still the right course to set up a Northampton authority. So can she reassure them that their effort hasn't been in vain and that she will provide the certainty and take a decision on the new proposals as soon as possible?

02:19:55 - 02:20:25

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Absolutely provide that reassurance. I needed that time and on the advice that I received as part of the JR process and the Prime Minister asking me to look again, I think it was only right that I did that in a timely way. But as I've reiterated, I am absolutely clear that I want to take this forward. Local government reform is a priority and I want to do that at pace with members across the House, including the honourable member and his local leaders.

02:20:25 - 02:21:16

Nigel Huddleston

Nigel Huddleston.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There's a video circulating online that claims the three most difficult things to say in life are "I'm sorry", "I love you" and "Worcestershire". It's fascinating to see that the right honourable lady struggles with at least two of those three things. But I am glad that she has now abandoned her decision, or at least paused her decision, to destroy the well-run, low-tax, Conservative-controlled Wychavon District Council. But is she aware of the chaos and cost she has caused to councils in Worcestershire and across the country?

She is giving very strong vibes that she does not know what she's doing. Is that because she does not know what she's doing?

02:21:16 - 02:21:55

Angela Rayner

Oh, Madam Deputy Speaker, I am sorry. I'm not sure I love you, but I love something and Worcestershire. I do know what I'm doing. I apologize, I do know what I'm doing. And I know that this has been a disappointment for some areas and I don't come to this House and make this statement lightly, but I do it in all sincerity to get it right.

And I hope honourable members appreciate that across Worcester and across every other area that we are looking at local government reorganization and hopefully, even if I can't say I love you, hopefully you'll be able to say you love me at the end of this process.

02:21:55 - 02:22:42

Jacob Collier

Jacob Collier.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I firstly thank the councillors and council officers from ESBC and Staffordshire County Council for the hard work that they've put into this process. And that rapid review is essential to give residents and council workers that certainty that they need. As my honourable friend for Stoke Central said, this should be seen aside from the mayoral devolution, which I think is the real prize for our communities to bring power out of this place into Staffordshire. So with that in mind, will she commit to a meeting in Number 10 North with Stoke and Staffordshire MPs so that we can talk about getting this deal into place?

02:22:42 - 02:22:53

Angela Rayner

My honourable friend is absolutely right to raise that devolution can happen at pace and it will unlock potential. And I'm sure the Minister will be happy to meet with him and my colleagues from Number 10 North to make sure that we can unlock the potential for his area.

02:22:53 - 02:22:55

Zoe Franklin

Zoe Collins.

02:22:55 - 02:23:35

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I absolutely share the shock and anger of councillors and council officers at this announcement. And what at the heart of this are councillors who are working so hard to deliver frontline services, whether it's education, housing, social care, and it is those who are battling this change. And I have been left still uncertain about what's going to happen in May. So will the Secretary of State please assure the people of Hertfordshire who they will be voting for in May?

And also look at the cost and time, will they be reimbursed that that would be able to go to the services that are desperately needed?

02:23:35 - 02:24:33

Angela Rayner

Well, again, I gently say to the honourable member that words like shock and anger, I appreciate the honourable member is using that language, but for me, what was important as Secretary of State is to make the right decision and therefore to come to this House to speak to honourable members to ensure we do that.

I still believe that local government reform will unlock potential for her area. I want to make sure that I'm doing it with local people's consent. I know that you can't get everyone's consent but I do absolutely believe that we can design services that are going to improve the local services in her area and we have committed to providing transition funding and hopefully with local government reform we can really transform some of these thorny issues that have been around for a long time like the Prime Minister said like adult social care and building that resilience at a local level.

02:24:33 - 02:25:00

Charles Noah Law

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister and the Cabinet Office last week set out their plans to rewire the state and effective local government of course remains fundamental to that. So will the Secretary of State double down on her commitment to listening as she did so well to us in Cornwall to members of this house to local councils to members of the public as part of that process?

02:25:00 - 02:25:40

Angela Rayner

I thank my honorable friend for that Madam Deputy Speaker and absolutely. I think I said it last I think I can't remember what day we're on now but last week I think I said very clearly that I recognize that members in local government the work that they do and how difficult it's been for our local government colleagues through the changes that have happened in our communities the demands on local government the pressures that are on them. But I absolutely believe that they are critical to making sure we get this right with the devolution agenda and that we build the resilience back at a local level so that they can carry on delivering excellent services to their to their residents.

02:25:40 - 02:26:25

Mark Francois

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Secretary of State local government reform in Essex has been a farce from the outset because the people never wanted it. The council taxpayers themselves never had any desire for this process. So I welcome the fact that Labour's jerrymandered five unitary authorities are clearly now stone dead. But could I honestly give her some advice?

Drop it. Walk away including the mayoralty. We've got by in Essex for a thousand years without a mayor and the last thing we want in our county is another Sadiq Khan. Just get rid.

02:26:25 - 02:26:54

Angela Rayner

Well I won't drop it Madam Deputy Speaker because I believe that the people of Essex and all over England deserve good local services and anything that I believe is worth exploring with local leaders whether that's Essex or anywhere else that will improve local services then I'm up for that challenge. I'm not ready to drop it. I think we can work together to improve local services and I'm happy to meet with him or any of his local leaders to progress it.

02:26:54 - 02:27:24

Michelle Welsh

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the review which gives a real opportunity to get local government reorganization right for my constituents and I do hope that they now will be really heard. Infrastructure in my constituency is cracking at the seams due to years of neglect from the previous government. Will the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss the real concerns in my constituency of Sherwood Forest about planning local infrastructure local government reorganization and an exciting opportunity to create a local country park?

02:27:24 - 02:27:57

Angela Rayner

Well Madam Deputy Speaker Sherwood Forest and a local country park I'm really up for that although I was in the Lake District on bank holiday weekend and managed to fall halfway down the mountain and that's why my legs are a little bit not used to bouncing up and down at the moment because my knees aren't so good so I'm hoping that it's a bit flatter and the gradient is a little bit more for me.

But she asks if we'll meet, and the minister, I'm sure, will be happy to meet with her on how she can, how we can progress making sure that her area, including Sherwood Forest, benefits from devolution and from local government.

02:27:57 - 02:27:58

James McClary.

02:27:58 - 02:28:25

Speaker 176

Madam Deputy Speaker, large numbers of my constituents took part in good faith in the government's consultation on the proposed boundaries for the unitary East Sussex. They're appalled by Brighton and Hove City Council's attempted land grab in our area, and together we resisted it. So can the Secretary of State be crystal clear for my constituents about whether this, as part of this review, she intends to reopen the discussion over East Sussex's local government boundaries?

02:28:25 - 02:28:54

Angela Rayner

Well, again, at the moment, I give the honorable member assurances that I am looking at the areas and I am going to look to make sure that all of the consultation and all of the information and the advice is correct and that we're making decisions that are robust. And I want to make sure that I do that, and I'm happy for him to be in contact with the minister or myself to make sure that we hear what he's saying in terms of that process, but I have heard him today.

02:28:54 - 02:28:55

Jonathan Davies.

02:28:55 - 02:29:46

Jonathan Peter Tom Davies

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I appreciate that the Secretary of State is new in post, so the issues which she's outlined today are not necessarily of her making, but I must tell her it is extremely frustrating for people in Derbyshire. It will undermine service delivery and also business confidence whilst this pause goes ahead. And I'm at a loss as to how it's proceeded so far without it being totally legally watertight. So I'd appreciate some assurances that she can give me that it won't be torpedoed in the courts again.

And crucially, we're going to be asking people to stand for the existing local authorities in Derbyshire in May next year. People of all parties, civic-minded, community-spirited people. How long will they serve for? I think we owe it to them to tell them how long their term will be because they make professional sacrifices and sacrifices of their families as well. So if she can offer me that information, I think that would be very helpful.

02:29:46 - 02:30:23

Angela Rayner

Well, again, I do recognize the frustration that the honorable member has expressed as part of this process, and I want to make sure that we take it forward and it is robust. And that is part of the confidence of why I've come to this House to say I wanted to review the decision based upon the legal advice provided as part of the JR process. I want to make sure that those that go forward, including the 14 other areas, that the rationale for that is absolutely watertight. And I say to the honorable member, meet with the ministers as part of this process and we can iron out some of those concerns.

02:30:23 - 02:30:55

Joe Robertson

Joe Robertson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When the Secretary of State embarked on local government review for Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, her department accepted the principle that the Isle of Wight Council should remain a standalone unitary authority. Now she is reviewing local government reorganization, will she reconfirm that the Isle of Wight Council will remain a standalone unitary authority and it will not be and is not at risk of merging with a part of the mainland?

02:30:55 - 02:31:08

Angela Rayner

I think it's fair to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that there is a very strong argument for it and a rationale for it. I will make sure that the review happens speedily and that we can give those reassurances as part of that process after the review.

02:31:09 - 02:31:49

James William Naish

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've repeatedly argued with colleagues that LGR is extremely complex but extremely important. But it therefore didn't need to be a term one priority for this government, and I do remain of that view because for me, our councils should be building council houses, tackling homelessness, strengthening trade standards, and regenerating high streets, not focusing on administrative structures. But assuming LGR does still go ahead in some form, and I would advise the Secretary of State to think really deeply about that, would she please explain how the views of Rushcliffe and Nottinghamshire residents, many of whom felt ignored through the last process, will be fully considered in this new approach?

02:31:49 - 02:32:38

Angela Rayner

Well again, Madam Deputy Speaker, we will be making sure that we cover that within the review that people are engaged in that process. And I say to the honorable member that I do believe that local government reform is challenging and complex, but the sort of the searchlight for me in that and the aim is that we do deliver better services for local people. And that is about building the homes that we desperately need. That is about our high street renewal which this government are taking forward. We can deliver better services, we can reorganize and we can do better.

And I believe that working with local leaders is the way forward to deliver for the people of this country. And that's why I'm committed to local government reform. I want to make sure we get it right and that's why I've made the decision to have the review today.

02:32:38 - 02:33:41

Mims Davies

Mims Davies.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am grateful. As the only MP in the House to represent constituents in both East and West Sussex and three district councils including Lewes, which is going to potentially be split previously, and of course the potential splitting up of West Sussex, the confusion around devolution, LGR in West Sussex is a terrible mess because we have different speeds, different approaches and an unclear mayoral timetable. And I say that to the Secretary of State as the two previous East and West Sussex leaders, she will acknowledge spent huge amounts of time with positive energy to bring to this process. So when the honorable lady, right honorable lady rightly talks about outcomes, what does she think she could tell me to tell my constituents when it comes to their services on education, social care, roads, infrastructure and how they will be delivered in the future?

02:33:41 - 02:34:10

Angela Rayner

Well again, I pay tribute to her local leaders and the work that they're doing in local government. I recognize the challenges and I've outlined them in terms of what has happened to local government over I would say the decade and a half that her government was in power. And what I've tried to do is build that resilience up for them. Previous ministers chose to take more time to consider the proposals as she outlines from the two places and we will consider these alongside the wider review of the program.

02:34:10 - 02:34:49

David Williams

David Williams.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I'm out on the doorsteps of Stoke-on-Trent North and Kidsgrove, residents tell me that too often they feel distant from decisions taken that affect their lives. What I want for residents is for them to feel that decision making is brought closer to home, that locally we're taking better decisions about improving our buses, our housing and giving young people the skills that meet their potential. Therefore, can the Secretary of State please confirm that devolved powers are still coming to Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire and at speed because we cannot be left behind?

02:34:49 - 02:34:58

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker, devolution is at the heart of our plans to rewire the state and ensuring that happens is exactly why I'm making this statement today.

02:34:58 - 02:35:54

Alison Louise Griffiths

Alison Griffiths.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Twenty-six months in and the real costs that the Secretary of State has already admitted the government hasn't assessed are the costs of the lost programs, projects and services which haven't been delivered in West Sussex and Arun because the bandwidth, head space and resources have been devoted to LGR. So can she instead tell me what has been the financial cost nationally, in West Sussex and in Arun to our so far failed experiment with LGR?

And secondly, how many months can the district councillors elected in 2027 expect to serve?

02:35:54 - 02:36:38

Angela Rayner

Well, again, I don't see local government reorganisation as a wasted endeavour. I've been really clear on the pause. I've been really clear on the pause and the decision and the reasons to do that to get the decision right. We've committed to providing transitional funding. We've seen where local government reform has happened in the past, there has been savings.

But my motivation, Madam Deputy Speaker, is to work with local authorities to improve their services. And local authorities recognise that we were, that we could do that. And I say to the honourable member that I am absolutely committed to continuing that and we will work at pace to deliver for her area.

02:36:38 - 02:37:25

Speaker 185

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome my right honourable friend back to her role and thank her for her statement today? I'm also sorry the right honourable gentleman from the New Forest is no longer here. I did want to assure him that far from being swallowed up, his constituents would have had a warm welcome and excellent local public services as part of Southampton. But I do understand the difficult decision that she's had to make, but must express disappointment that after all the hard work across councils and across parties, the five unitaries for Hampshire and the Isle of Wight will not be going ahead.

Will the Secretary of State confirm that after her rapid review, Southampton and the surrounding councils will still have the opportunity to reorganise if they wish, or is today the last we're going to hear of LGR?

02:37:25 - 02:38:00

Angela Rayner

I absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker, want to reassure honourable members that this is not the end of local government reorganisation. I am absolutely committed to it. And I commend the work of his local partners, his work and others from across the House who recognise what local government reorganisation could do for their area. And I want to work at pace to ensure that I'm able to put us on the firm footing as Secretary of State, that I am clear-eyed about the decision I'm making and that we can go ahead with their consent or not.

02:38:00 - 02:38:52

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. From the LGR options that were on the table for Devon, the government opted for a Labour-led proposal that created three urban growth areas and then all the rural bits that were left behind were just dumped in together into one huge unworkable authority that divided communities, had no economic hub and had little chance of being sustainable. So I welcome the Secretary of State's announcement today that she's going to review this decision, although it's not clear how this review is going to happen, who's going to do it, how long it's going to take. What I'd like to ask the Secretary of State is will she commit to meeting with all the members on this side of the House who represent rural Devon so that we can discuss the best proposal for the biggest number of people across Devon, because the one we had was going to leave rural Devon behind and we want to make sure that that doesn't happen again.

02:38:52 - 02:39:17

Angela Rayner

Well, I want to reassure the honourable member that we don't want to leave rural Devon behind either. And as the Minister's just had to nip out for another meeting, I will volunteer him for the commitment to meet with the members. And it is a serious concern to me to make sure that people are heard in this process. And that's why I've taken the decision that I've taken today to review it.

02:39:17 - 02:39:44

Speaker 190

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know this pause will be frustrating for people in Adur and Worthing who want to see the back of West Sussex County Council and have power and money brought closer to them. But I do accept that it's important that we take the time to get this right. Can the Secretary of State assure me that this review will not diminish the government's plans to devolve power closer to my constituents?

02:39:44 - 02:40:04

Angela Rayner

Absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are absolutely committed to devolution and devolving of power.

The Prime Minister has made that really clear as one of his priorities. And we want to make sure we do this right with local people so that the power is there and that we give the resources and the support that areas need to flourish.

02:40:04 - 02:40:36

Speaker 193

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Local councils across South Cambridgeshire in good faith spent time and money preparing for local government reorganisation according to the government's criteria and timelines. And businesses in one of the fastest growing areas of the country welcome the prospect of certainty with a final decision. Yet further delay leaves them all in limbo. So does the Secretary of State agree that chaos is not good for local democracy, it's not good for investment, and will she meet with me and local council leaders to understand the implications for Cambridgeshire of this decision?

02:40:36 - 02:41:17

Angela Rayner

Well, I totally recognise that Cambridgeshire has a huge amount of potential and will absolutely ensure that a meeting is set up with myself or the minister so that we can take that forward. And I gently say as well, I do understand the implications of me coming to the House today and as Secretary of State reviewing these decisions. I've said I want to do it at pace, but I've also made it really clear that I felt as Secretary of State I needed to put that review in place so that I could satisfy myself that we're doing it correctly. These are some really big reforms, as she's aware. I want to make sure we get it right so that her area can reach its full potential, and I'm sure it will.

02:41:17 - 02:41:57

Luke Morgan Evans

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And when she came to the House last year to announce her consultation, I called it a mess. Fast forward 18 months and it is chaos now in the outcome and decisions. And make no mistake, it's because of the threat of the courts the reason why we are here. Now, my concern comes because in Leicestershire we had three applications go forward and the government chose its own fourth application.

So when she's doing her review, will she ensure that it's not just the process, it's the boundaries as well? Because in Leicestershire the biggest contention is the massive land grab coming from the city, and nine out of 10 people in her own consultation said this was not acceptable.

02:41:57 - 02:42:24

Angela Rayner

Well, I want to reassure the member that I am going to review and make sure that I look at those issues and make sure that I'm confident in the decision that is made, including within the boundaries, to make sure that any decisions that are made are the correct and the right ones. And I will update him and work with him and other members to ensure they have that clarity. We might not agree, but I will make sure that I have listened and I at least know where I'm going with that and make the decision confidently.

02:42:24 - 02:43:14

Max Wilkinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was not in favour of the decision announced by the predecessor before the summer break for a single unitary Gloucestershire. I would have preferred something more Cheltenham-centric. However, that decision does seem to reflect the political consensus across party in Gloucestershire. So I've got to ask the Secretary of State, is she in the business of overturning the consensus politically across party locally in Gloucestershire?

And if not, will she just let us get on with it so the councils can get on with doing the things that my residents want, making sure there are not unwanted cuts to fire services because of cuts from Westminster to our budgets, making sure that the town centre in Cheltenham is fixed up, and making sure that we get a tip reopened for Cheltenham? Because that's the things my residents want. They're not so bothered about boundaries, even if they are concerned about Cheltenham losing its historic voice.

02:43:14 - 02:43:44

Angela Rayner

Well, I thank the honourable member for his contribution. And this is not about overturning or overpowering local decisions.

This is about me reviewing and making sure that there is a robust system that says, this is where we want to go and we can take it forward. And I hope to do that within a matter of weeks, not too long a process, but that I get it right. And that is fundamentally the first and foremost. I want to get it right for his constituents so they can get on and get the things that they absolutely want and deserve.

02:43:44 - 02:43:45

Peter Bedford.

02:43:45 - 02:44:07

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Given that the right honourable lady mentioned or she emphasised listening to local people, empowering local communities and decisions being made with their consent, does she agree with me that local communities such as in Leicestershire should have local referendums before such decisions are imposed upon them, such as being dragged into an enlarged Leicester City Council area?

02:44:07 - 02:44:32

Angela Rayner

I've got to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not a big fan of referendums if I'm really honest, but that's my personal opinion. But you know, I am open to having discussions about how we can make sure that his local residents feel like they're engaged and see the benefits of local government reform, which is what my ultimate aim is as part of this process, and I look forward to working with him to that endeavour.

02:44:32 - 02:44:33

Charlotte Cane.

02:44:33 - 02:45:29

Charlotte Cane

Madam Deputy Speaker, the residents of Ely and East Cambridgeshire will be... oh sorry, I should have drawn members' attention to my register of interest. I'm a district councillor on East Cambs District Council. The residents of Ely and East Cambridgeshire will be relieved they're not going to have the wrong unitary imposed on them, but also worried about the chaos that we've heard about and uncertainty and what happens next and when. So, what is the remit of the review? How is it going to be run to ensure that local people get their voices heard?

And what is the real timetable? Quickly as possible, at pace, all great, but what is the actual timetable? And also, the Secretary of State appeared to say that the May's elections would be on the existing district council boundaries unless the unitaries were in place by then. What did you mean by that?

02:45:29 - 02:46:06

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've asked the Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth to undertake a rapid review of local government reorganisation programme. That is the review regarding the decisions that were announced in March and July. I've said that and the two remaining areas of West Sussex and Cambridgeshire and Peterborough. I've said that the review will cover 18 decisions already taken and the two areas where decisions have not yet been made.

I want that review to work at pace to review the programme and we'll report back to Parliament at the earliest opportunity.

02:46:06 - 02:46:07

Bradley Thomas.

02:46:07 - 02:47:05

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This process has been a complete shambles from start to finish and has failed to have Worcestershire's best interests at its heart. Will the Secretary of State confirm to the House whether this is actually being paused or if the reality is the can being kicked down the road to delay this under the veil of it being delayed rather than the government admitting embarrassment? If it has been paused and she's going to revisit the decision, will the evidence base be revisited and will there be a new consultation with stakeholders including residents? If that is the case, will the Secretary of State meet with me as Member of Parliament for Bromsgrove before she takes a decision?

And I think she said earlier on that the government had allocated 63 million pounds across the country to support councils in this process. Can she confirm to the House how much of that 63 million pounds has been spent so far?

02:47:05 - 02:47:49

Angela Rayner

Well, again I say to the honourable member that this is a pause, it is a review, and I've made that absolutely crystal clear for me to consider the legal advice that was provided as part of the JR process and also for me to be able to do what the Prime Minister asked of last week was to look at the local government reform programme and that is what I am doing. I did talk about the 63 million pound. That money is earmarked. There is opportunity for those areas to come forward if they have got financial concerns in regards to the money they spent on local government reorganisation, they can contact my department.

02:47:49 - 02:47:51

Speaker 181

Manuela Perteghella.

02:47:51 - 02:48:41

Manuela Perteghella

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This sudden U-turn is greatly disappointing for my constituency of Stratford-on-Avon after so much work by council officials, residents, councillors and other partners, and after so much money wasted on LGR costs. Given that the two unitary model in Warwickshire, South Warwickshire and North Warwickshire, were championed by my constituents, by the majority of local council leaders and by the majority of Warwickshire MPs, will the Secretary of State reassure us all what a timescale will be for this review, but above all, that the decision will respect the democratic input of the people of Warwickshire who contributed to the previous LGR process.

02:48:41 - 02:49:18

Angela Rayner

Yes, absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to reassure the honorable member that this is about me reviewing and making sure that the decisions are absolutely correct and and I want to do that. I recognize the work that has gone in from her local area and those representatives and I pay tribute to the work that they're doing. I've indicated that I want this to be weeks rather than months. I don't want to kick the can down the road.

I just want to be making sure that the decisions that we made are robust and take us forward in the spirit of cooperation with local areas.

02:49:18 - 02:50:00

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Well, when I led the debates on in my Westminster Hall debate last week on the impact of local government reorganization in Cambridgeshire, I couldn't possibly have anticipated it would have been powerful enough to stop it dead in its tracks. But I do welcome the pause to tranche three. But in order to get a little bit of clarity for the councillors in my constituency, obviously this is going to be reviewed. If it does come back, are we potentially going to see local elections in May 2028 that will for a new shadow unitary? And with that in mind, would the Shadow Secretary of State meet with me and Huntingdonshire District Council in order to discuss some of the topics that are still outstanding and the reason why Cambridgeshire and Peterborough was delayed in the first instance.

02:50:00 - 02:50:28

Angela Rayner

Well, I thank my honorable member for his comments and I believe that he enjoyed the Westminster Hall debate with the minister. I'm sure that the minister would like to continue that conversation to ensure that we get the best deal over the line. And I don't want to preempt that review, but I want to make sure that we've heard from him and his local representatives about the challenges, and I'm sure that the minister will will set that meeting up in his diary as soon as possible to make sure that we we expedite that process quickly.

02:50:28 - 02:51:08

Monica Harding

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituents in Esher and Walton in Surrey are left wondering whether they've been thrown under the bus by a government who failed to be secure in the legal advice and the costs from the very beginning. It is incompetence. So will the government release the legal advice? What are the legal implications for Surrey and what extra support will she be giving to Surrey, particularly in the cost implications, given the grossed underestimation of how much LGR would cost, the significant debt that Conservative Surrey has amassed in the last two years while this has been going on under the unfair funding formula.

02:51:08 - 02:51:19

Angela Rayner

Well, I say again, Madam Deputy Speaker, the review does not include reorganization of Surrey. Councillors have been elected and new councils go live from the 1st of April.

02:51:19 - 02:52:14

Al Pinkerton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. You wait a while and two Surrey questions come along at once because one of the potentially unintended consequences of today's announcement is to leave Surrey in the slightly discomforting position of being in an experimental cohort with a sample size of one, one county that is being reorganized under this legislation.

And we all know why, and it's because the Conservative-run Surrey County Council begged the government to put them on this rollercoaster with no known destination and, as it turns out today, with legally slightly shonky rails. So can I ask the Secretary of State, does the, do the legal concerns that she has expressed today relate also to Surrey? And if Surrey is affected by those legal concerns, what faith should my residents have that this experiment isn't going to come fully off the rails before 1st of April 2027?

02:52:14 - 02:52:53

Angela Rayner

I gently say that for me this is not an experiment. This is about working with local areas to deliver local services and to improve on that. And the review does not include reorganisation of Surrey. As I said, Madam Deputy Speaker, councillors have been elected already and the new council goes live on the 1st of April 2027. And I hope that Surrey with the new two unitary councils will be able to deliver for across their area on the vital services like adult social care, like transport, like those good services that people want to see across their areas and I'll work with them to deliver that.

02:52:53 - 02:52:57

James MacMurdock

And the final question on this statement, James MacMurdock.

02:52:57 - 02:53:32

Speaker 199

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for sharing her, I have lost it now. Forgive me, I've had a two-hour wait and I've completely lost my train of thought. Over the last two years of people, the people of Essex have faced, over the last two years, the people of Essex have faced a dizzying array of changes from cancelled council elections from off and on, hospitals that are oversubscribed, 30,000 new homes to be built, many of which will be on greenfields. The question is, how can we trust this government to deliver on anything when it says one thing and then does another?

02:53:32 - 02:53:44

Angela Rayner

Well, I appreciate the honourable member's frustration, but...

02:53:44 - 02:53:59

Speaker 196

Order. Secretary of State. The honourable member may wish out of courtesy to this House and certainly the Secretary of State and his constituents and my constituents to stay in his seat to listen to the response by the Secretary of State. Secretary of State.

02:53:59 - 02:54:44

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable member for Essex and the place raised these issues before and I do appreciate the frustration in Essex. But in response to the honourable member who was here a while ago and was raising these issues, I made it really clear that local government reorganisation is about delivering, I know you're still here, local government reorganisation is delivering for people across Essex. And I do understand the pressures on local services, but Essex do have a need for more housing, it has a need for more infrastructure and it has a need for local government reform and this government is there to work with the local people of Essex to deliver it.

02:54:44 - 02:55:26

Speaker 200

And that concludes the statement. I'll now let the front benches swap over before we start the next statement. We'll now begin the next statement. Minister.

02:55:26 - 03:02:38

Sarah Jones

With your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will make a statement on public order following the protest activity seen on the south coast this weekend. I know many in this House and outside will have been concerned by the events of the past two days, and I welcome the opportunity to set out what happened, as well as updating members on the action this government is taking to address the issues at the heart of these protests. It is right to begin with the facts. At around 7:30 AM on Saturday morning, around 150 individuals descended on the Port of Dover, many of them wearing face coverings. Kent Police deployed rapidly to the scene of what the force has described as a no-notice protest.

No arrests were made and the crowd eventually dispersed some hours later, at which point full access to the port was restored. Nevertheless, the impact was felt by local residents and workers for whom the scenes will have been unnerving, as well as ferry passengers and motorists who faced delays as a result. Turning to the second incident in Portsmouth, in the early afternoon on Sunday, a boat carrying approximately 120 people reached British waters near the Isle of Wight, considerably further west than the majority of small boat crossings. The RNLI, under the direction of HM Coastguard, met the boat and directed it towards Eastney Marina in the wider Portsmouth area. At around 8:00 PM, a group of more than 200 protesters arrived at the harbour, intending to block three coaches which were due to take the arrivals for processing.

Many of these protesters were dressed in all black and wearing face masks. Hampshire and Isle of Wight Constabulary, with the support of other neighbouring forces, used a dispersal notice to ensure public safety, and officers were forced to use batons and PAVA spray to maintain order in the face of some aggression. Officers worked through the evening and into the early hours of the morning, and at around 4:00 AM, protesters began to disperse and the coaches eventually set off. Again, no arrests were made on the night. However, investigations are ongoing and where criminality is identified, those responsible should expect to face the consequences.

Mr Speaker, these types, Madam Deputy Speaker, these types of incidents require careful handling by the police, and I place on record my thanks to all those who were part of the operational responses in Dover and Portsmouth. I am especially grateful to those on the front line whose efforts were essential to bringing the demonstrations to a conclusion. I have today spoken to key policing partners. As the House would expect in the wake of such incidents, work is ongoing to establish any lessons and ensure that relevant intelligence is shared at pace across our law enforcement system. Peaceful protest is a fundamental part of our democracy and it must be defended.

But so too is the right of other citizens to go about their lives without undue interference, and there can be no excuse for threatening behaviour or serious disruption. Let me therefore make clear to the House and to the country that disorder of any kind will never be tolerated, and those who cross the line from peaceful protest into illegality will face the full force of the law. This government condemns the intimidating and thuggish behaviour shown by some of the protesters this weekend.

We are working closely with the police in Kent and Hampshire alongside the National Police Coordination Centre, all of whom have our full backing in taking any necessary step to uphold public safety and maintain the peace. Madam Deputy Speaker, none of this is to in any way minimize the very valid concerns that law-abiding people have when they see vile criminal gangs exploiting our nation's generosity and people making illegal and unnecessary journeys to reach this country. Let us never forget that the frustration we see in our communities today is a product of chaos and crisis in the years that preceded the general election of 2024. Since then, this government has taken action to fix the broken system we inherited and bear down on the people smugglers. We have doubled the number of National Crime Agency officers tasked with dismantling organized immigration crime.

System-wide arrests are up 70%. More than 1,100 boats and engines have been seized, and in partnership with French law enforcement, we have prevented over 48,000 attempted crossings. We are now taking that partnership further with a landmark new deal signed in April, securing a 40% increase in French boots on the ground, taking the total to over 1,000, as well as enhanced surveillance technology and new specialist units. At the same time, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are removing the incentives that draw people here illegally in the first place. Since the election, we have made over 6,000 small boat returns, a 64% increase in the last two years of the previous government, and we have removed more than 80,000 illegal migrants and foreign criminals from these shores.

As a result of the action this government has taken, this summer saw the lowest number of small boat arrivals since 2020, and so far this year, the number of crossings is down by over 43% on last year. Progress is being made, but we are not complacent. We must and we will be unrelenting, not least in response to any shift in tactics by the gangs. The use of larger boats with over 100 people crammed on board is a clear cause for concern, and we remain alert to the potential for crossings on less frequently targeted stretches of water off our coastline. The gangs are never going to go quietly, Madam Deputy Speaker.

They are responding to the impact our work is having, and we will adapt in turn, both in terms of our enforcement, in partnership with France, and in terms of our response here. Madam Deputy Speaker, our priority will always be the safety of the British people. As such, we will continue bearing down on small boat crossings and the criminal gangs behind them, as we deliver the strong, secure borders the people of this country expect and deserve. At the same time, we will keep working closely with police forces to maintain order on our streets. While we must protect our ancient right to free speech, what we will never tolerate is the disruption of people's daily lives or the intimidation of our communities.

And I commend this statement to the House.

03:02:38 - 03:07:54

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my constituency neighbor, the Minister for Policing, for advance sight of her statement. Now, I'm sure we all agree that the right to protest is a fundamental part of our democracy. But the right to protest should never be violently exercised, and it should never cause serious disruption to other people. And I'm sure all of us would equally condemn any form of protest where those guidelines are abused. I'm sure we all equally support the police in making sure protest where it occurs is lawful and peaceful.

But this should also be a wake-up call for the government.

Because it's not just those protesters in Dover and Portsmouth who feel so angry about large-scale illegal immigration. It is millions and millions of people up and down this country who feel angry as well. Since the general election, over 80,000 illegal immigrants have crossed the channel, all illegally and all unnecessarily because France is a safe country. Nobody is fleeing persecution in France. Almost 20,000 have crossed this year alone and 625 crossed yesterday with more coming in the early hours.

Every day when the sea is calm, hundreds of illegal immigrants cross the channel and the numbers this year would have been higher were it not for rough seas in the last few months. The government should not be complacent at all. This problem is not solved and I don't think the plan is working, if indeed there even is a plan. I was on the beaches of Northern France just a few weeks ago, waist-deep in water as one of these dinghies embarked with about a hundred illegal immigrants on it. And the French Gendarme National, who we pay for, who the Home Secretary pays for with 660 million pounds of our money, almost all of it unconditional, stood by, ten of them, stood by and did nothing while this dinghy embarked in basically knee-deep water.

They could easily have stopped it and when I asked one of those Gendarmes after it happened why they did nothing, he said they were under orders not to intervene. Almost all of these French officers are prohibited from preventing embarkations in the water. They don't prevent the migrants getting to the water's edge either. And so long as that continues to happen, these crossings will continue as well. She mentions return numbers.

What she didn't mention is those returns of small boat migrants, 6,000 in the last two and a bit years, amount to only 8%. 8% of illegal immigrants crossing the channel. That is to say 92% of illegal immigrants crossing get to stay. There is no deterrent whatsoever in that. And of course these people who cross illegally are costing billions and billions of pounds to accommodate in hotels and apartments and then even more once they get asylum and start claiming welfare.

The people are angry, not just because of the numbers, not just because of the expense, but because of the crime being committed as well. I met with Siobhan White a few weeks ago, the mother of Rhiannon White, brutally murdered by a Sudanese illegal small boat migrant called Den Majek, stabbed 23 times including in the neck. There have been numerous rapes committed by small boat illegal immigrants as well, including a girl just 12 years old in Nuneaton. And the government is using a sleight of hand. It's moving illegal immigrants from hotels into apartments and then it's granting them asylum on an industrial scale.

Just this afternoon, the UNHCR, hardly, hardly a bastion of right-wing extremism, I'm sure she will agree, said that Home Office asylum decision-making only meets its own standards in half of cases. And the UNHCR no less said that many illegal immigrants being given asylum do not deserve to be granted that status under the government's own rules. And a whistleblower in the Times today said that only 1% of asylum claims are really genuine, citing amongst many examples, I can't give them all in the interest of time, but there was apparently hundreds of Pakistani men claiming to be gay based on a letter from the same individual claiming to be the sexual partner of all of them, hundreds. That is quite clearly fabricated with the assistance of immigration lawyers. So when the system is being abused on this scale, it is no wonder people get angry.

This government repealed the most of the Illegal Immigration Act, which prohibited illegal immigrants from ever getting citizenship. If she wants to create a deterrent, I strongly suggest she reinstitutes that measure. They cancelled the Rwanda scheme before it even started that would have seen illegal immigrants getting deported. If they're serious about fixing this and ending public anger, they need to get serious about the measures, leave the ECHR and deport illegal immigrants as soon as they arrive, then people won't be so angry.

03:07:54 - 03:11:57

Sarah Jones

Can I thank the shadow Home Secretary for the start of his remarks. I think we all would agree that the right to protest should never be violently exercised. And of course we all agree that it's not just protesters who feel angry about the current system. And of course we are doing all we can to bear down on it and change what we inherited. I know that the shadow Home Secretary was in France, we all saw the videos over the summer and enjoyed those.

The weather, he claims that the weather accounts for the improved situation we find ourselves in. The 43% cut in small boat crossings in people that we've had come across this year compared to last year cannot be accounted for by the weather. That is just a fact and I would hope that the shadow Home Secretary would accept that. And I know that he spoke to some land officers who weren't maritime officers, who are the officers who can enter the water. And we have footage, and I'm hopefully he's seen the footage, of those maritime officers going into the waters and doing exactly what he wants them to be doing.

So I just hope he can learn a bit more about what our deal is and what responsibilities we are paying for. He said that we are not paying, we are just giving the French the money without results. He knows that the new deal that we have done with the French for the first time introduces payment by results. Under his government, there was nothing, we were throwing money with no payment by results. So 110 million pounds of what we give to the French is dependent on them delivering results, which is why we are seeing an improvement.

We are also now funding over a thousand French police. That is historic levels of funding, but also we are working in partnership with them so to make sure we are doing the things that we need to do to stop the small boats from coming and to strip the criminal gangs of their armoury. Germany, for example, has just passed a law so that it is an offence in Germany, which is where a lot of these boats were being warehoused, to sell boats outside for the use of this kind of smuggling activity in another country. We are doing every single thing we can, pulling every single lever, and the results speak for themselves. I think, I think sadly that the shadow Home Secretary is the only person in this place who thinks that the Rwanda scheme would have worked.

I think the rest of us have come to the conclusion, including I suspect people on his own side, that it was a gimmick and that it will never have worked. And that the numbers that we are seeing in terms of the results that we have seen over the last two years speak for themselves. In partnership with French law enforcement, we have prevented over 48,000 attempted crossings. That is substantial. Now, have we got a lot further to go?

Of course we have. And he's right to have met the family of Rhiannon White and it is horrific what happened to her. Nobody would claim anything else. And it is in memory of her and it is the right thing to do for every single constituent that we all have across our country that we take control of our borders and make sure we have a fair migration system.

The government is doing the hard work restoring control at our borders. We are seeing progress. We are not complacent. We will continue to work. But I'll end where I began, which is that I agree with the shadow home secretary that we must allow the police to exercise the powers that they need to stop thuggish and violent protest behavior.

And that is what we are looking at and what happened over the weekend. We will learn the lessons if we need to from what happened. I am talking closely with the police as he would expect me to, and we will make sure that they have the resources they need to do their job.

03:11:57 - 03:12:46

Adrian Michael Tapp

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the minister for her extremely important statement. On Saturday, as we know, hundreds of masked men, dressed uniformly in black, traveled from around the country to Dover, blocked key roads around Britain's busiest port, intimidated my constituents and caused disruption. This has been described as a dummy run by the group. It was not spontaneous. It was well organized.

Will the minister please ensure that the intelligence picture is strong enough so that the police can respond accordingly to future incidents? And will the government look again at whether the law on face coverings at protest goes far enough?

03:12:46 - 03:14:24

Sarah Jones

Can I thank my honorable friend? And I was pleased to be able to talk to him earlier today, and of course we were in touch over the weekend as the House would expect. And as the Member of Parliament for that area, it's absolutely right and proper that he should lead the way in terms of asking for the right lessons to be learned from what happened. Having spoken to Deputy Chief Constable Peter Ayling and Assistant Chief Constable Nicola Faulconbridge today, they took me through the order of what happened and how it happened. It was a no-notice protest in the sense that a lot of protests that we see in this country, the police are told in advance, they're allowed to then think about whether they want to impose conditions and what those conditions should be.

This was a no-notice protest in terms of the police weren't told about it. Clearly it was planned. And clearly it was people from outside the area coming in and causing chaos. Of course we need to learn whatever lessons we need to learn in terms of intelligence. We have since the riots of 2024, we've set up a new structure or beefed up the structures that we have around the national coordination of sort of protests and intelligence sharing, looking online, having a stronger capability to look across the internet and see what we can find out there as well.

So there is more coordination. And, you know, the offer of mutual aid worked very well this weekend as it always does. But of course, I will listen to any intelligence he has and we will make sure we learn the lessons.

03:14:24 - 03:16:34

Max Wilkinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. How is it that far-right thugs in balaclavas were able to close Britain's busiest port without the police receiving any prior intelligence? And how is it that then an apparently separate group with some commonalities were then able to blockade another site the next evening? Will the minister tell the House whether she will review why the police were caught off guard? More shockingly still, perhaps just as shockingly, no arrests have been reported.

Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, people have drawn comparisons this weekend with the arrests of hundreds of sign-holding protesters who have been arrested since July 2025 on other protests. Can the minister understand why people are confused by the difference in approach? Can she also answer questions from Portsmouth Liberal Democrat council leader Steve Pitt about the lack of local consultation for identifying appropriate landing sites?

This is a key question that needs answering, because it clearly caused problems in Portsmouth. Now Britain's transport infrastructure cannot be left vulnerable to far-right mobs. It is a disgrace, Madam Deputy Speaker, that this weekend Reform MPs took to social media to fan the flames alongside people like Musk and Robinson. It is a disgrace that members of this House support such vigilante action. Now it was the decision to leave the European Union championed by those Reform members and their allies in the Conservative Party which created the small boats crisis in the first place.

We will, we will only get, Madam Deputy Speaker, a safe and controlled asylum system in line with British values if we join the EU migration and asylum pact. It will save taxpayers money too. The government is paying at least 500 million pounds for a three-year agreement with France. More money will follow when the agreement with Belgium is struck. The UK's contribution to join that pact, which would bring order and safety to the asylum system, would cost significantly less than we are currently pledging to pay.

Joining the pact must be top of the agenda when the Prime Minister meets with EU leaders later this year.

03:16:34 - 03:18:29

Sarah Jones

Can I thank him for his comments? He asks about the lack of intelligence. It wouldn't be appropriate for government to comment on specific intelligence matters on these cases, but of course we are looking at all decisions that were taken and we will learn any lessons. The two events happened on consecutive days, of course, and of course there was a crossover in terms of the online activity. They were, they were very different in that one was clearly organised by a group of, a group of called the Southeast Patriots, I think it's part of Patriot Platform, which is a kind of far-right racist platform.

That was, that was clearly organised, whereas in Portsmouth there was a response to a series of events that led to this boat having to dock Eastney Marina. And I think there will have been a mix of local people who were very concerned as well as, you know, bad actors who were whipping up activity online and responding in kind. So they were two separate events, but we will of course learn any lessons that we need to. Similarly, he asks the question about the landing site and why that site was picked. And we are of course making sure we understand what exactly happened in that circumstance, but also stepping back, you know, members will have seen a bit of a trend towards people leaving France more to the western end and what does that mean and are we making sure we're responding in the right way and that there's enough resource going into that?

And we have pushed some of that resource from the French police down the coastline, but of course we will be monitoring those things.

03:18:29 - 03:19:35

Amanda Martin

Amanda Martin. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a sad day for Portsmouth. My city saw peaceful protests turn into disorder last night with people coming from outside the city, some wearing face coverings to intimidate those working on land and sea and damaging police vehicles. This morning I spoke with residents and one elderly resident who attended the protest because she felt so strongly.

She and so many others are angry and worried about small boat crossings in the UK and now on our doorstep, and she has every right to protest peacefully. But she and I both agree that that cannot extend to criminal behaviour. I've heard the Minister's statement today and I welcome the government's progress, but there is more that must be done and the emergence of these new routes and larger boats is deeply worrying for my city. So can I ask what more the government is doing to stop the boats and tackle the vile criminal gangs behind them? And will she come to Portsmouth to listen to residents and stand firmly against those who come to our city to cause trouble, intimidate communities and stir up hatred and put our emergency services at risk and further pressure on our borders?

03:19:35 - 03:21:16

Sarah Jones

Can I thank my honourable friend for that question and for the work that she's doing? And I should also pay tribute to my honourable friend the member for Portsmouth South, who is in his place here today but cannot speak as he is a minister.

But I know and I've spoken to him, obviously I've been in touch with him about the conversations he's been having with local businesses, local individuals and the local police. And I think my honourable friend is absolutely right. There were clearly people there who were there because they were concerned about what they were seeing. That is very different from the kind of racist far-right thugs that we also see as part of what has happened over the weekend. And it's very important that we distinguish between the two.

She also wants more. We are doing, I listed the improvements that we're making in terms of the National Crime Agency, the intelligence that we're gathering and our ability to go after the criminal gangs. We also need to do more to reduce the incentives for people to come into the country. The asylum grant rate, which is a statistic that I haven't mentioned yet, has fallen from 77% in 2022 to 38% this year. So that's another mark of progress.

And of course, where we are reforming the asylum system more widely, last November, of course, the Home Secretary set out reforms that we are working through. We've had a consultation on the standard qualifying period for most migrants. All of these things are all part of trying to create a fair system that doesn't incentivize people to come here from France.

03:21:16 - 03:21:56

Edward Leigh

Father of the House, Sir Edward Leigh.

If the center doesn't take action, nasty extremes will take over. The fact is we're in acute danger. These people can now launch from anywhere on the North French coast and are escorted to our shores. We're frankly being invaded and the public are completely fed up. There's only one solution and that was put to her by the Shadow Home Secretary.

There is no deterrent. They know they're not going to be deported. We have to get out of these outdated conventions, detain immediately and deport immediately. Will the government take action?

03:21:56 - 03:23:16

Sarah Jones

So with the greatest respect, I don't know if he was saying that we are frankly being invaded when his government was in charge and when the numbers of people coming into this country was at an all-time high. Net migration when my neighbor from Croydon was in the Home Office was at an all-time high. The boats are down by 43% this year to last year. The honourable member shakes his head, but that is just a fact. They are still coming, but they're coming at a 43% lower rate than they were.

And the action that we are taking is ensuring that we will keep going and we will keep building on the success that we have had. The increased police resource in France, the changes to the asylum system, the way we are getting through the case backlog so that we can remove people from this country who have no right to be here or are foreign national offenders. All of these things add up so that when the criminal gangs are looking at where they can make the most money, they think, no, actually, the UK is not somewhere where we can easily make money. We will not do this crime and we will move on to something else somewhere else. So we are pushing every single lever we can and with the greatest respect, I would say we're having a lot more success than his government did.

03:23:16 - 03:23:53

Richard Quigley

Richard Quigley.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm sure the Prime Minister will be glad to hear that the good weather is now attributable to a Labour government. Can I pay tribute to the brave men and women of the RNLI that put themselves out to the sea to save lives without fear or favour. The Isle of Wight salutes you all, unlike the masked bullies in Portsmouth. Lots of misinformation has happened over this weekend regarding the Isle of Wight.

And as we don't have the infrastructure and cross-Solent transport is an issue for us, can the Minister confirm that there are no plans for an asylum center on the Isle of Wight?

03:23:53 - 03:24:45

Sarah Jones

I am very grateful to my honourable friend for his question. And of course the RNLI do an incredibly difficult job in dangerous circumstances and we are very grateful for the work that they do and I'm grateful to him for making that point in this House. As to any of the plans going forward, of course we are reducing the numbers, we are reducing the hotels, they are massively down. We are reducing the incentives for people to come here and we are making sure we are removing people as quickly as possible. So I'm sure that the Minister responsible would be very happy to have a conversation with him, but our direction of travel is to reduce the numbers to a much more manageable level so that we do not, so that we do have control of our borders.

03:24:45 - 03:25:46

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yesterday afternoon MPs across the Solent region were scrambling for reliable information with complete radio silence from the Home Office. As a result, we weren't in a position to calm fear and tension. We still know very little about this extraordinary mega-dinghy turning up on our shores. This is not just west a little bit from Dover, this is halfway down the south coast.

Will criminal gangs launch more small boats in the direction of Hampshire? Will she share that intelligence with coastal MPs? Where was the intelligence on this? And can she also answer claims that the police were not properly resourced to do this? Over 140 were dragged away from our communities, in fact communities as far as London, to police this and to deal with this.

Can she please assure us that this will be dealt with better in the future and that she'll be doing everything to make sure it doesn't happen again in the future?

03:25:46 - 03:27:50

Sarah Jones

Firstly, can I just thank the honourable lady for the question. I know she will have been concerned over the weekend as a local Member of Parliament and I appreciate that. Very happy to always be there if she wants to contact me, if she's struggling to get through to anybody, very happy to give her my number and have another chat about that. Obviously it was a moving picture as well in terms of what was happening, so it isn't always possible for the police who are dealing with the incident to be able to respond in a way that one might want with that. Aware of what she's saying about is this going to be an emerging problem with people trying to land further down.

We are aware and it is in part because we are making it harder for people to launch from their sort of traditional places that people are starting to launch further west along the French coast. There's no evidence to suggest that they want to particularly land anywhere other than to get to Manston and to go where they would normally go, but of course we will keep these things totally under review. In terms of the mutual aid that was given, I think I'd say two things. I think the force was given the mutual aid that they asked for, there were several forces around and that actually in the end the problem was dispersed. But the mutual aid, that's not uncommon for forces to offer mutual aid.

When we saw the problems that we had in Cleveland in recent weeks, there were 600 officers who went in in mutual aid.

I think it does, just to make a slightly wider point, make the case for reform of policing. If you have a national police service, if you have a national police service, which we are introducing, not that reform, you would have these agencies working much more closely together because they'd be part of the same organisation. So rather than relying on sort of mutual aid from other forces, everyone would be joined up and sharing intelligence, and I think that would be a better system. Sorry.

03:27:50 - 03:27:58

Speaker 196

Minister, if I can just ask, we've got such a tight schedule tonight, if you could just shorten your answers a bit. Apsana Begum.

03:27:58 - 03:28:38

Apsana Begum

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Pogroms in Belfast, riots in Southampton, and then of course the chilling incidents over this weekend in Dover and Portsmouth. What's difficult to contend with is that this appears to be becoming more frequent and normalised. But we cannot normalise the activities of the organised far-right gangs. Will the Minister condemn the racism at the core of the activities and actions this weekend?

And what can she say to those who cover their face for religious, health or work reasons, who will be feeling particularly vulnerable at this time about the government and police response?

03:28:38 - 03:29:32

Sarah Jones

Can I thank her for her question? She's right, we cannot normalise this kind of behaviour, nor will we, and nor would that be right for any government to do. What we saw in Dover with Patriot Platform, who are a group, a far-right group with a lot of racism and thuggery as part of that group, cannot be tolerated, disrupting our people's daily lives. Of course, we will always make sure the police have the resources that they need. I think she speaks to the point of face coverings.

We introduced in the last piece of legislation new powers for the police to insist on people removing their face coverings when they are at protests. Of course, when they are going about their daily business for religious reasons, absolutely fine to have face coverings, and that would continue.

03:29:33 - 03:30:05

Alan Mak

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. No small boat arrivals landed on Hayling Island or any other part of the Havant constituency yesterday, but nevertheless residents are concerned, and they agree with me that anybody who enters the UK illegally should be deported within a week and banned from claiming asylum. Does the Minister agree with me, and will she and the Home Secretary meet me and other members from across the House to explain the police response, the Home Office response, and explain why Labour has lost control of our borders?

03:30:05 - 03:30:43

Sarah Jones

Labour is doing the hard work, as I said, restoring control at our borders that was lost under the previous government. We have made progress, as I've already explained, and we will continue to do everything we can to make sure we are having that control, having a fair system, making sure those who are claiming asylum genuinely are given safe haven on our shores, as we have done for many, many, many years and will continue to do so, but that we will reduce the incentives and reduce the incentives for people to come here and claim asylum rather than other places, and we will make sure we get back that control.

03:30:43 - 03:30:45

John Hayes

Sir John Hayes.

03:30:45 - 03:31:27

Sojan Joseph

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The protest on Saturday caused widespread disruption across East Kent, affecting not just local residents in Dover and people travelling to the port, but also in communities further along A20 and M20, including those in my constituency. While some members opposite have failed to condemn the mob mentality, does my honourable friend agree that with me we should always uphold the right to lawful and peaceful protest, but the intimidating and unacceptable behaviour we witnessed over the weekend was completely un-British and should be condemned by everyone who genuinely values freedom of expression and the value of law?

03:31:27 - 03:32:24

Sarah Jones

Can I thank my honourable friend?

Of course it did cause disruption way beyond the immediate, the immediate protest because of the nature of the roads and the protest on the A20 and on those surrounding roundabouts and the impact that that had of course was great. Lots of people wanting to go about their business not being able to. I would say I do think the police response was a good one. 7:30 the protest started and before well before 12 o'clock they had been dispersed with the police establishing a gold command structure as they do, declaring a major incident and making sure the system was, making sure the protest was stopped. But of course it's very disruptive.

Wearing the masks is clearly intimidatory and you know we will do everything to make sure the police have the powers they need to stop them.

03:32:24 - 03:33:38

Suella Braverman

I was in Portsmouth Harbour this morning near Eastney Marina speaking to local people in Fareham and Waterlooville and this is the message that they wanted me to send the government. They are terrified. They are furious and they are desperate. They are not far-right racists. Only last week a migrant man was arrested on the suspicion of raping a 14-year-old boy in the area.

And what is the government doing? It's handing out leaflets to illegal migrants asking them not to rape British girls and women. The government's response has been frankly pathetic. Now given these are unlikely to be the last illegal migrants in Portsmouth, my question to the minister is this. Will she guarantee the House today that under no circumstances no migrant processing center temporary or permanent will be put up or established in Portsmouth.

And what assurance can she give me that the national security of the naval dockyard in Portsmouth is maintained given that the invasion has now reached Hampshire.

03:33:38 - 03:35:28

Sarah Jones

First I would say to the right honorable lady that of course people are scared and angry and see that the borders as they see it are not secure. And of course she will know from her time in the Home Office that we have come some way since she was there and improved the system very significantly with more than a thousand boats and engines being seized, system-wide arrests up 70%, 48,000 prevented crossings, 40% increase in the French boats and the French boots sorry on the ground, increased surveillance technology, huge drop 42% drop in the number of boats coming over and we have removed more than 80,000 illegal migrants and foreign criminals. So people are right to express a view and it is disingenuous of her I think to suggest that I was calling those people racist when I quite clearly was very clear all the way through that there were people in Portsmouth who were concerned local residents who were coming out because they are angry and we've heard that and that is very different from the racist thugs that we see in other places and who were also there and the whipping up online of that kind of hatred that we saw. We will continue to bear down on illegal boat crossings. And I would also just finally pay tribute to the Kent and Hampshire police.

Kent police dealt with 1,300 999 calls on Saturday and Hampshire dealt with a thousand. So whilst these incidents were going on there was also a lot of work being done keeping us safe across the counties.

03:35:28 - 03:36:19

Luke Pollard

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We should be opposed to gangs wherever we find them. Whether they are gangs of smugglers or whether they are masked gangs in Southampton and in Dover. And I wish this House today was a little bit more united and a little bit more resolved in opposing both types of gangs. Peaceful protest strengthens our democracy.

What weakens our democracy is intimidation and the abuse that we have seen. This government passed the 2026 Crime and Policing Act because we wanted to tackle concealment which is linked to criminality. Now that is in respect of police designated areas where protest is happening under certain conditions. Where we clearly have concealment linked to criminality in non-police designated areas, as we have seen in Southampton and Dover, will the government now consider extending the parameters of that 2026 Act to tackle those?

03:36:19 - 03:36:38

Sarah Jones

Of course we keep all legislation under review when it comes to public order and there is a big piece of work that Ken Macdonald, Lord Macdonald has done for us which we are considering. There are some other powers about face coverings from the Public Order Act of 1994 as well, but we will always look at these things.

03:36:38 - 03:36:39

Joe Robertson.

03:36:39 - 03:37:31

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I pay tribute to the brave lifeboat volunteers from Bembridge on the Isle of Wight who responded to the migrant crossing yesterday. Now the Isle of Wight is more than just a little bit west of Kent. This is a really concerning development about a potential failure to contain the geography of small boat crossings. Now the Minister likes to talk about the reduction in numbers, but what assessment has she made about this potential new development from where people smugglers are willing to operate, in this case over 80 miles of open water?

What is she doing not only to ensure resources are targeted properly in France, but here on the south coast so that local communities like those on the Isle of Wight and in Hampshire can respond to something that they have not seen at scale before?

03:37:31 - 03:38:13

Sarah Jones

And can I thank him for his question and say of course we will keep and we are keeping all these things under review at the moment. There is not the intelligence to suggest that where people are leaving France further west that they are doing anything other than wanting to go where they and land where they normally would. But of course we keep all these things under control. I have spoken today to multiple people within the National Police Coordination Centre, Border Force and the police more widely. And of course these things are kept under review.

I would say there's no evidence of what he suggests. But of course if the criminals are being disrupted over here, we know that they, you know, they try and change tactics. But there is no evidence of that at the moment in terms of where they're trying to land.

03:38:14 - 03:39:12

Kim Marie Johnson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The far right and the British fascists reared their ugly heads on the streets of Dover and Portsmouth this weekend. Allegedly these protests were spontaneous, but hundreds of people were mobilised, dressed as fascists of the past, hiding their identity. So let me tell you, their behaviour wasn't just thuggish and intimidatory, it went far beyond that. Their protests were about hate, division and racism.

And even though the police had powers, they went largely unchecked. So can the Minister tell us why there appears to be a two-tier system because if you sit quietly with a banner you get arrested, but if you're masked up and attack the police no arrests are made. Thank you.

03:39:12 - 03:40:16

Sarah Jones

Can I thank my honourable friend but say very strongly that there was no two-tier policing in this situation. When people are arrested holding a banner supporting a proscribed terrorist organisation, they will get arrested. She's right. But in this case, and she is right, there was some, this wasn't spontaneous.

The Dover incident was obviously planned and was obviously a tactic from a nasty organisation called Patriot Platform or Southeast Patriots, I think they call themselves various different things. There was no notice given to the police that it was happening. That was the, that's the differentiation between that word spontaneous, but it was clearly planned and clearly intended to be intimidatory. Where there is criminal activity, the police will be and they'll be reviewing now, I know they are reviewing because I've talked to them today, all of the CCTV, the ANPR, all the evidence to see where criminality has occurred and they will take action where it has occurred.

03:40:16 - 03:41:02

Peter Wishart

Madam Deputy Speaker, the sight of masked far-right thugs causing mayhem and disruption on the English south coast was as nauseating as it was frightening and so reminiscent of a dark period in our history that we thought was long behind us. Does she agree that the growth of the far-right is the most dangerous development that we currently have in our politics? And if so, when are they going to start to take it seriously? There was no arrests at all over the weekend. There's no real challenge about the disinformation that the far-right put out to all our communities to cause this disruption and division.

And when will this government stop pandering to this right-wing agenda?

03:41:02 - 03:41:29

Sarah Jones

Can I thank him for his question to say we're not pandering to the right-wing agenda at all. Where there is criminality, the police will come down hard on that criminality as we would expect them to. On Saturday in Kent, no one was arrested and in Dover, sorry Portsmouth, but the police will be, as I just said, reviewing all of the evidence over the weekend and where there have been crimes that have been occurred, they will make the appropriate arrests.

03:41:29 - 03:42:16

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, at the weekend we saw masked men dressed all in black block roads, block a port, intimidate people in Dover and in Portsmouth. We know that at other disorderly anti-migrant protests, a large proportion of the people arrested had already been reported for domestic abuse. In fact, the leader of this weekend's protest, Danny Thomas, spent two years in prison for trying to kidnap someone at knifepoint. So does the Minister agree with me that this is not about a legitimate policy debate?

The men who decide to come out in balaclavas are not driven to thuggery by political passion, but simply they like violence, they like intimidation and should not be given the fig leaf of political legitimacy that some people in this place wish to.

03:42:16 - 03:43:11

Sarah Jones

I agree with my honourable friend we shouldn't give them political legitimacy. And of course there's well-known connections between violent men and the types of violence that they inflict. And it isn't always in one area, it can be across lots of different behaviours, sexual violence, domestic abuse and the rest. And of course we have no truck with these awful groups and the gentleman that she refers to does seem particularly awful. But of course the police will do what they need to do.

They need to disrupt and remove the protesters so that people can go about their business and in both cases that's what they did. We will make sure we learn lessons and arrests are made where they need to be. The conversations that I had with the police today about their response was that they were proportionate and managed to get the result that we wanted, which was the removal of the protesters and enabling people to go about their business.

03:43:11 - 03:44:18

Alec Edward Shelbrooke

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful that it's the Policing Minister doing this debate. I've spoken with North Yorkshire Police and obviously RAF Linton-on-Ouse is a site that is being suggested to be an asylum centre. But the trouble is, asylum centre at military site does not paint what it is. It's relatively just a mass hotel because people are free to come and go and these are just going to be men.

Now, the Home Secretary made the statement that she wouldn't allow a hotel anywhere which is near a primary school or a nursery. Well, within 300 meters of the entrance to that base is a primary school and a nursery. North Yorkshire Police have made clear that they would find it exceptionally difficult to constantly be policing protests, and these protests are coming from far and wide. So with the fact that with the change in way protests are happening, the fact that North Yorkshire Police would find it very difficult to police, and the fact that there is a primary school and a nursery within what will effectively be a mass hotel for 1500 people, can she confirm that it is still the policy of the Home Secretary that she would not open these hotels near schools and nurseries?

03:44:18 - 03:44:53

Sarah Jones

And can I thank him for his question and I suspect he's already had conversations with the immigration ministers about this particular case. I suspect he's making these arguments to them and I wouldn't want to get in the way of those conversations and I'm sure the minister would be happy to have those conversations. Of course we need to bear down on the numbers overall, which is what we are trying to do. So we haven't, so we're not just closing the hotels, but we're also reducing that number coming in and reducing the incentives for people to come in, which is why we're doing the raft of policy interventions that I spoke about earlier.

03:44:53 - 03:46:24

Kevin McKenna

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to commend the minister on the way that she's managing to handle two really difficult challenges that are facing the country at the moment. Obviously there's the small boats crossings. Obviously these are very, very concerning to people in Sittingbourne and Sheppey, as many people of Kent. It hasn't escaped my notice that this protest in Dover at the weekend happened at a point that those boat crossings are falling. And the second challenge, this challenge of increasing far-right activity, uniformed thugs on our streets who've been organizing relentlessly behind the scenes and publicly on Facebook is something that we have to come down hard on now.

I'd like to ask the minister two things actually. One is in the 1930s, I mean we've seen this before, this isn't the first time the country and other countries have faced this. In the 1930s we banned uniformed political parties and uniformed political activists. Obviously we wear slightly different clothing now than we did in the 1930s. Has the minister looked at how we can update that law to address these thugs and make sure it's actually fit for purpose in the modern world?

And secondly, local news outlet in Kent, independent news outlet Kent Current, reports that the night before the incident in Dover, these thugs were on mustering in nearby villages. Local people picked this up and had been reporting it, but that seemed to be missed. So can the minister look at that further and make sure that this intelligence from the ground by concerned people in Kent is also factored in?

03:46:24 - 03:47:06

Sarah Jones

And can I thank him for his question. As I said earlier, I can't comment on the kind of intelligence situation in terms of what happened with these two incidents, but of course we will learn those lessons and what we knew in advance and what was or wasn't done about that is an important part, very important part of the lessons that we will learn. We are, as well as local police and the intelligence that they are able to gather, we also have now the national coordination of NPOT where we've got extra resources for things like internet intelligence investigations and we can reach and coordinate better than we could before. But of course there'll be lessons to learn, I'm sure, and I will take away his question about the uniformed political parties.

03:47:06 - 03:47:45

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the last year or so, Poole has seen planned protests by groups calling themselves patriots traveling to the town and targeting the RNLI headquarters specifically because they, like firefighters and other emergency crews, rescue those at sea without fear or favor.

And concerns have been raised with me that no arrests were made this weekend despite serious intimidation, injuries to the police and criminal damage, in sharp contrast to elderly people holding placards. So can I ask, what message does it send to our brave RNLI rescue crews if police stand aside during these events while they put their lives at risk day and night?

03:47:45 - 03:48:58

Sarah Jones

Of course, as I said, any lessons that we need to learn from these cases will be learned. But from the conversations that I had, the police were dealing with an emerging problem in quite a difficult geographical area, particularly in terms of Portsmouth with one road going in and out. They had a lot of vulnerable people, and I am speculating as to their physical health because I haven't had a full briefing on this, but I suspect there was hypothermia, I suspect there were all kinds of issues that they were having to deal with. The police were having to deal with an increasing number, about 200 people protesting, and definitely, you know, they had to use batons, they had to use interventions. That point may not have been the right point to arrest those people, but there will be investigation, CCTV.

So I just ask her really genuinely not to draw a conclusion from the fact that there were no arrests made at that point because it may well be that there will be. It's just you have to do the right things in the right time in the right order, and in that emerging difficult situation, it might be that they took a decision to do those things for the safety of everyone there and then they can turn to investigations afterwards.

03:48:58 - 03:49:33

Brian William Leishman

Madam Deputy Speaker, when there is a Reform UK councillor who says that Nigerians should be melted down to fill potholes, and an ex-Reform councillor who had to resign because they used racial slurs against a black family, then I am disgusted at their overt racism. Does the Minister agree with me that the racist Reform UK and the ethno-nationalist Restore Britain are contributing to the scenes that we have seen in Dover and Portsmouth?

03:49:33 - 03:49:58

Sarah Jones

So anyone who's whipping up this kind of activity and breeding racism is to be condemned, of course. I notice that there are other Reform MPs who are bobbing to ask their question. Perhaps they can address the issue of the Reform member who wants to see Nigerians melted down. I'm sorry, I hate to even say the words in repeating, but perhaps one of the honourable members would respond.

03:49:58 - 03:50:32

Lee Anderson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the Minister said there was a lack of intelligence in Dover, and I'm sure she wasn't referring to the local MP for Dover and Deal. But is she aware that since this illegal invasion started, that hundreds of young girls have been raped in our country? We've had an 80-year-old man raped. We've had a young girl in Ashford raped.

A 14-year-old boy raped. So does she understand why people in this country are so furious and take to the streets? Does she understand?

03:50:32 - 03:51:35

Sarah Jones

First, just to clarify, I don't think I said there was a lack of intelligence. I said I didn't want to comment on the intelligence, and there is a difference. And in the case of Dover, the police hadn't been informed of the protest. That isn't to say there wasn't intelligence that I can't comment on or I wouldn't know about. So I just want to be clear about that, it's a different thing.

Now, of course, all crimes need to be punished. We need to make sure that those people who are committing vile sexual violent offences go to prison, or if they are not from this country, are deported and sent home. And that is what we are doing. The number of foreign national offenders who are going home and being sent home and the number of people who've been turned down for asylum and are being sent home is significantly up on his previous party when the Conservative party was in power.

We will continue to do that, but that is not to say that we are not, of course, intensely sympathetic and sorry for people who have been victims of awful crimes.

03:51:35 - 03:52:35

Bernard Jeremy Corbyn

Jeremy Corbyn.

Thank you, thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Minister give us an assurance that the Home Office will turn its attention to the growth of far-right organisations across the country, the racist activities they undertake, those people that arrived in Dover and Portsmouth and behaved in a violent, disgraceful, racist manner, including abusing volunteers in the RNLI? And will she also recognise that the plight of refugees all across Europe is a serious human rights disaster and we do need cooperation between all governments across Europe to ensure that we deal with this in a decent and humane way and not allow people like these sitting in front of me to just routinely abuse anyone who's trying to seek a place of safety.

03:52:35 - 03:53:24

Sarah Jones

Um, can I thank him for his question and of course there are there are very difficult issues here of people who are fleeing war, who are fleeing conflict, who are fleeing and and and we in this country, but we in this country and I would say to the shadow Home Secretary and everyone else here have a honourable tradition of of being a place of safety and that must continue. The issue that we have seen over recent years is that when the last party were in power, anybody who came in wasn't dealt with, wasn't turned around, wasn't returned. So people, you know, the criminal gangs understand that if you come to this country nothing is going to happen, you're going to get to stay here forever regardless. They make money from that vulnerability, so we are trying to improve the system. Improving the system is not lack of compassion, it is exactly the opposite.

03:53:24 - 03:54:08

Edward Robert Jenrick

Robert Jenrick.

The sight of the government escorting illegal migrants into Portsmouth Harbour, the home of the Royal Navy, was a national humiliation. Sometimes I wonder if members of this House have no appreciation of the level of anger there is in the country at the rapes, the murders, the billions that are being wasted that should be being spent on the British people. Will the Minister put the Royal Navy in the channel today, escort those illegals to France? As Reform proved on Saturday, it is operationally, it is legally and it is now diplomatically possible. It's a matter of political will.

03:54:08 - 03:54:15

Speaker 219

Minister, can you please keep your answer short and backbenchers please make sure your questions are short as well.

03:54:15 - 03:54:51

Sarah Jones

Um, there is absolutely nothing that the government has said at all that would suggest that we don't understand the level of anger that the honourable gentleman, the state of the country that the honourable gentleman left us and that the we have a big job to do and of course we understand the level of anger. This government is doing the hard work, restoring control at our border and fairness to our migration system and any rhetoric from the right honourable member who has not one leg to stand on given his own personal involvement in the situation we find ourselves in is going to stop us.

03:54:51 - 03:55:26

Zarah Sultana

Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank the honourable members who shared my disgust at the sight of intimidating, fascistic gangs and squads of men in black on our streets in Dover and Portsmouth. But the roots of organised violence are political, it needs a political response. So will the Secretary, the Minister agree with me, it's time to start naming hard-right and fascist politics when we see it, recognise how frightening this is for people in our communities and stand up to the racists on our streets and here in the chamber, rather than pandering to and repeating and accepting anti-migrant propaganda and lies.

03:55:26 - 03:56:05

Sarah Jones

And I can thank the honourable lady for the question and I and I just disagree with her analysis.

I think I have been very clear in calling out the racism that we've seen. I've been very clear in being very straightforward that where criminal activity has occurred, the police should use the full force of the law. We have named far-right actors in this place today. And if for others not to do that, that is for them. Thank goodness they are not in government currently.

We will do everything we can. We can we can we can call out racism, we can call out the thuggery that we have seen whilst also accepting the anger that individuals feel about our borders. And the two are not incompatible.

03:56:05 - 03:56:30

Speaker 224

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Whilst we condemn any violence against the police, we cannot ignore the deep public anger, frustration, and outrage over the illegal migration now seen across Britain. No one voted for this, yet the boats keep coming and they are no longer small. Will the government finally declare a state of emergency in the English Channel?

03:56:30 - 03:56:51

Sarah Jones

No one voted for it multiple times when they elected a Conservative government promising to cut and stop the boats, which didn't happen. We have reduced the boat, the numbers of people coming over is down 43% this year on last year so far. That is real progress. Is it enough? No.

Will we go further? Yes.

03:56:51 - 03:57:34

Sammy Wilson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a sad state of affairs when ordinary people feel compelled to take direct action against illegal immigration into our country as a result of successive governments failing to stop the invasion of our country by illegal immigrants aided by criminal gangs. But does the minister not recognize the part that her government continues to play in perpetuating this problem by housing those who come, by providing them with better health services than some people in our country can access, and by setting such a low standard for asylum criteria that 92% of them stay? Would it not be better to put the people back on the boats rather than put them in hotels?

03:57:34 - 03:57:52

Sarah Jones

The proportion of people being granted asylum has massively shrunk in the last few years. And we have removed more than 80,000 illegal migrants and foreign criminals from this country. We are improving the system, making the changes we need to do, and we will continue to do so.

03:57:52 - 03:58:41

Adnan Hussain

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Does the minister acknowledge the seriousness of what we are now witnessing? Organized militia-like groups of masked men take to the streets, stopping cars, confronting members of the public, and leaving ethnic minority communities terrified in their own towns. So I ask, will the minister plainly say what action, if indeed any, will be taken against these vigilante groups? And what responsibility does she believe politicians in this house bear when inflammatory claims of an invasion translate into terror on our streets, into racial fear, intimidation, and street vigilantism?

03:58:41 - 03:59:08

Sarah Jones

I would say to the honorable gentleman, it's not appropriate for me to comment on the sort of intelligence and the the situation and who's going to be charged and who's not going to be charged with these two incidents. We don't know enough at this point and the police are operationally independent for a good reason. And politicians shouldn't be involved in that in that day-to-day process. Are we looking, of course, at the threats that we we face in this country, of which there are many? Is the Home Secretary alive to all of those threats and doing everything she can with all the levers at her disposal?

Absolutely.

03:59:08 - 03:59:57

Ayoub Khan

Final question. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One image in 2015 changed the public opinion, and that was of a toddler, Alan Kurdi, a two-year-old whose frail body washed up onto the shores, face buried in sand.

That changed public opinion. That's because as humans and as this nation, we are compassionate. 250,000 Ukrainians came into this country. We allowed them to utilize our services. But there seems to be selective outrage.

When it's selective outrage in this house. Does the minister agree that we need to have proper safe routes that can prevent this exploitation by criminals and allow those which are desperate and fleeing war-torn areas sanctuary in this nation?

03:59:57 - 04:00:31

Sarah Jones

I think on the one hand, there is selective outrage and whataboutery and let this sink in and all this nonsense that people put on social media all the time. At the same time, there is a significant problem that we have to deal with. The two are true. We have to deal with the control at our borders and we will bear down on that control to make sure we have what we need. But at the same time, where there are malicious actors stirring up hatred and division, we have to, and I would hope this house would, come together to promote unity and solidarity and the compassion with which you speak.

04:00:31 - 04:00:54

Speaker 229

That is the end of the statement on Dover and Portsmouth protests. If the front bench wish to shuffle over. Members are ready. We'll move on to the statement: Economic Growth. Chief Secretary to the Treasury.

04:00:54 - 04:07:49

Darren Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With permission, I will make a statement about the government's plan to deliver good growth in every postcode. At the G20 in North Carolina last week, the Chancellor and I met with finance ministers from leading economies to discuss our shared economic challenges. Global instability, conflict, and trade frictions are continuing to drive up inflation and interest rates around the world. While these shocks are international in nature, their impact is also being felt here in the UK, from the cost of the weekly family shop to the cost of government borrowing.

Britain has shown resilience in the face of these pressures and the economy is now turning a corner. Our growth was the fastest in the G7 in the first half of this year. Government borrowing fell to its lowest level in six years last year and interest rates have been cut six times since the general election. We are building on our strengths: our world-class universities and our world-leading sectors such as life sciences, defense, technology, creative industries, and financial services. And because of the choices that this Labour government has already taken, we are in a stronger position today to capitalize on the opportunities for growth across our economy.

But in the context of a more uncertain world, we must continue to make responsible choices. And fiscal discipline will underwrite every promise this government makes. Both the Prime Minister and Chancellor have made clear their commitment to meeting the fiscal rules with a buffer against uncertainty. And we will address the long-term pressures on our public finances to put debt on a sustainable downward path. And as the Chancellor said earlier today, there is nothing progressive about spending one pound in every ten pounds on debt interest.

In his statement to this house last week, the Prime Minister laid out a clear diagnosis of what has gone wrong in our economy. Political power was centralized, the economic fundamentals were privatized or outsourced, and our country was deindustrialized. The solution is a fundamental shift in the way our country works. Number 10 North and the Treasury are working together to build a stronger, more strategic center of government and a more active state. Together we will support the ambitions of local leaders and exert political public influence on and direction over the essentials, including transport and housing.

We will devolve power and resources to local leaders. London is, of course, an economic powerhouse. But if our city regions could emulate the success of second cities in France and Germany, growth in our country could be transformed.

The Chancellor has instructed public investment institutions to focus on regional growth. To build on our high growth areas, the Oxford-Cambridge corridor and the Northern Growth Corridor, he has today announced a new 150 million pounds Northern Scale-up Fund, delivered by the British Business Bank, to back the most innovative and fast-growing firms from Liverpool to Newcastle. A new Northern 500 will also bring together 500 of the North's most ambitious mid-sized businesses into a single growth community, focused on scaling, investment and productivity. The National Wealth Fund will establish new strategic partnerships with South Yorkshire, the Liverpool City Region, the North East and Cardiff, giving these areas support to build their investment pipelines. And at the budget next month, the government will go further, with a roadmap for fiscal devolution, a permanent transfer of power and resources from Whitehall to our regions.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this plan will drive economic growth and productivity in three key areas: supporting investment, boosting innovation and getting more people into good jobs. First, investment. Business investment has increased by nearly 5% since the general election. But in a highly competitive world, we must do more to reduce the barriers that firms face. The government will tackle the thicket of consultation, litigation and administration that is holding up private investment, including by extending our reforms of judicial review from energy to all major infrastructure.

We will bring an end to the consultation culture across government, supported by new guidance from the Attorney General on legal risk to give ministers confidence to make decisions. And as the Chancellor has set out, we will make further changes to the Treasury's Green Book, reducing the discount rate from 3.5% to 3% to ensure that the Treasury rulebook doesn't go against key regional infrastructure projects and to make sure places across the country get a fairer hearing in spending decisions. Work is already underway to progress place-based business cases in Plymouth, Birmingham, Liverpool and Port Talbot, and at the budget we will publish guidance to allow more areas to do the same. Second, innovation. The UK has a fantastic record on innovation.

We are world leaders in frontier technologies, quantum computing, nuclear fusion, space technology and AI. But too often ideas born here have to go elsewhere to find the capital they need to scale. So today we are setting out a new ambition to double the number of unicorns in this country. The government will identify and back these high-potential firms, providing with the necessary capital to scale. New cross-economy sandboxing powers will also enable firms to test frontier technologies safely.

And building on the important work already taking place in defence and in sovereign AI, the Chancellor will work with government departments to earmark new dedicated funds to back British innovation. The third vital driver of growth is jobs. Our objective is to get more people into good, highly skilled jobs and to make the most of the untapped talent that exists across the country. That is why, two weeks into office, the Prime Minister set out a bold new plan to transform technical education. And this autumn, Alan Milburn will set out his full recommendations to government on how to address the blight of youth unemployment.

This is our moral duty, not only our fiscal duty, because it cannot be right that so many young people are stuck on benefits. Madam Deputy Speaker, this plan for growth is underpinned by fiscal discipline.

04:07:49 - 04:08:20

Speaker 227

It will hand power to local leaders and unlock the potential of our regions. It will build a strong strategic center of government and enable greater public direction and influence over the essentials. And it will back British business, British goods and British exports, creating wealth and prosperity in all parts of the country. This is a plan to build hope and optimism across our economy and to drive good growth in every postcode. Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this statement to the house.

04:08:20 - 04:08:23

Speaker 226

I call the Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Richard Fuller.

04:08:23 - 04:12:51

Richard Fuller

Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you very much, and may I thank the minister for her statement and for early sight of it. On a day when the country was listening for a message of change, it was the same old, same old: a continuity Chancellor with continuity policies and a continuity team of ministers in the Treasury. Does the minister recognize the harsh irony of a government that could find plenty of money to hire 14,000 more civil servants in SW1, that the Chancellor chose to go to the West Midlands just a few miles away from Jaguar Land Rover, but had nothing at all to say about it? The minister talked about government borrowing falling to its lowest levels. But I wonder, can she talk also about the cost of government borrowing?

Can the minister confirm that the cost of government borrowing for 30 years is now at its highest rate for 28 years? The minister talks about there being nothing progressive about spending one pound in every ten on debt interest. Well, amen to that. But then why, minister, did this government choose to increase borrowing by 500 billion pounds over the course of this Parliament? The minister talked about the Northern Scaleup Fund, an interesting initiative.

But can the minister advise who will be making the investment decisions, and can she assure the house that they will not be subject to political direction? The minister talks about a National Wealth Fund with new strategic partnerships, a permanent transfer of power from resources from Whitehall to the regions. Did she listen to the Secretary of State for Housing saying that local government reform is on hold? Does she confirm, can she confirm to the house what proportion of the country will qualify under that measure to be part of Labour's largesse? My fear is that many parts of the country will not qualify.

The minister did talk smartly about removing the thicket of consultation, looking at judicial review and the consultation culture, and we will be supportive of measures that she comes forward with that. But then, after a brief moment of common sense, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor then talked about reducing the discount rate from 3.5% to 3%. Now, can the minister confirm that the cost at which the government is borrowing is going up and up, 5.9% for 30 years? And she has chosen this moment to reduce the rate at which the government expects to get money back from 3.5 to 3%. Can she explain how those numbers add up?

And then, of course, the final cherry on the parfait: that the government will identify, quote, "the government will identify and back," unquote, unicorns in this country. So how will the government identify these unicorns?

And can the minister explain how that is different from the discredited policy of governments picking winners? Then the minister returned to common sense and the about the announcement that Mr. Milburn will set out his recommendations to the government. Could the minister please advise the house, because I think many will be concerned about this, on what date will Mr. Milburn make his recommendations? Madam Deputy Speaker, we had an opportunity today from the government, from the minister and the chancellor, where they could at least, at least have mentioned the high cost of energy that's crippling British manufacturing. We could have had the chancellor or the minister rule out tax increases and therefore provide some more certainty for business that they can invest.

We could have had the government say they will take up the offer from the conservative leader of the opposition to work together on meaningful reform and reductions in welfare so that we make work pay. But we didn't hear any of that. Instead, we are heading to a budget where a Labour government has again run out of money, where a Labour government once again increase taxes to cover their fiscal incompetence. Same old continuity Labour.

04:12:51 - 04:17:32

Darren Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a great pleasure to be stood opposite the honourable gentleman again. We've done so earlier on in this parliament. I say kindly to him that I would rather be continuity Labour than continuity Liz Truss. And he mentions, I will address the the the points that he mentioned.

He mentions Jaguar Land Rover, and he's right to do so. It is a very concerning time for the workforce, and the business secretary is working closely with the chief executive and indeed the trade union leader of Unite and bringing those two together tomorrow to discuss the situation. Jaguar Land Rover has made clear that they face very competitive global headwinds, but we have done a lot to support the automotive industry and indeed Jaguar Land Rover itself, given the loan guarantee that we provided last year when in the wake of their cyberattack, but also the help that the business secretary and the government is providing to the automotive sector to bear down on the cost of energy. I think in some cases he said that he agreed with me, which is always, it's always good to hear. I think we can agree that there is nothing progressive about spending so much money on servicing our debt.

And that's why as a government, we are committed to fiscal discipline, we are committed to the fiscal rules, because we want to bring down the cost of government borrowing. But we are not immune to the global instability that is that means that the cost of borrowing is also increasing for every other G7 country. But we have got the fastest growth in the G7, we are cutting our deficit faster than any other G7 country, business confidence is up, investment, business investment is up, productivity is up, interest rates have been cut six times since the election, and consumer confidence is up. So while he talks down our economy, the chancellor and I and the whole ministerial team will be talking up the British economy. He asks about the Northern Scaleup Fund, and he asked a serious question about that, which I will respond.

The British Business Bank will make those decisions independently as in of government, as always should be the case, and he's right to ask for reassurance about that, and I provide that reassurance.

On devolution, we are a government that is very serious about devolving power to every part of the country. We'll have more to say about that at the budget and we will set out a fiscal devolution roadmap as well. He accused me nicely of talking smartly about the thicket of consultation and saying that I had some common sense. I thank him for that. I think we can agree, and he's been in government too, in the Treasury.

I remember it fondly when we had meetings together back then. And it's good that we have an agreement across the dispatch box that we need to make sure that those sorts of things don't gum up the system, that ministers are able to take decisions and that we're able to get infrastructure built in this country. I do respectfully disagree with him about the green book discount rate. We proudly say that we are reducing the discount rate to 3% because there have been times in the past when the Treasury has stood in the way of good regional infrastructure projects that have a long-term benefit. And I'm proud that we are making sure that those projects get a fairer hearing.

On unicorns, he will know that we've already made some changes to tax in last year's budget to support unicorns and we're opening up opportunities to public procurement. I think he mentioned pudding at the end, parfait I think it was, but I won't respond to that. I'm a big, big fan of pudding myself. On the serious question, turning to the serious question of the Alan Milburn review, I cannot give him a timeline, but I will repeat what I said in my statement, that it is absolutely our moral duty as a government to ensure that we have more young people back in the labour market. That's why we've already introduced the youth guarantee so that young people who've been out of work for longer than 18 months will get a paid placement by the government.

And we've also introduced a grant for businesses that take on unemployed young people. I think it is a very serious issue and one that we will address.

04:17:32 - 04:18:36

Margaret Olivia Hillier

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Chief Secretary's statement and her commitment she's just made that the British Business Bank's new fund will not be interfered with politically. Because when the Treasury Select Committee looked at the National Wealth Fund, we were very clear that it needed in that case to be able to get on and do its job, crowd in that private investment, and it shouldn't be a chop and change approach to the policy or a delivery vehicle for different government policies as governments can change. On the point of devolution, which is something that I've run up in my career backing devolution, but there is a challenge, isn't there? When she's the Chief Secretary, she has to make sure that the money that taxpayers give to government to be spent is spent well.

And there is a gap with our region the elected mayors of oversight and scrutiny of that public spending. So whilst devolution is a good thing, what is she going to make sure is in place to ensure that those devolved mayors, the mayors and devolved authorities can report back about how well they are spending taxpayers' money and if they're not, what will be the consequences?

04:18:36 - 04:19:23

Darren Jones

I thank the chair of the Treasury Select Committee for her question. And I agree with her that public financial institutions must make independent decisions about the businesses that they support. But it's also the case that the Chancellor today talked about new strategic priorities for the NWF and that is also the right thing to do. That goes in parallel with what she was saying. On oversight of mayoral strategic authorities, she is right to say that if we are going to devolve more power and critically more resources, there should be more oversight.

The First Secretary of State has talked about the role of others, including members of this House, in holding mayoral strategic authorities to account when they receive those new powers.

04:19:23 - 04:21:26

Charlie Maynard

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Chancellor and the Minister for their speech and their statement. We know that the Conservatives' Brexit deal has hit national GDP by as much as 8%, costing the country up to 90 billion a year in lost tax revenues. Will the government now pull the largest zero-cost growth lever available to it by negotiating a growth and defense partnership with the EU, including joining the single market and a new customs union, rather than clinging to the same failed red lines that are costing businesses billions every year? Being outside the single market and the customs union directly links to the 13% fall in the UK's export of goods since 2022. This has hit traditional manufacturing regions the worst.

These are the same places that the government's reindustrialize the North agenda claims to prioritize. I would like to understand whether she acknowledges the reality of that linkage or not. I welcome the Chancellor's emphasis on the importance of fiscal credibility and linked to that meeting the fiscal rules. However, the reality of these fiscal rules have been easily gamed by successive governments, with our budgetary process being summarized as speculation without scrutiny, short-term headroom chasing, and gaming the system through a jam, i.e. spending today, pay, i.e. tax tomorrow, with tomorrow never arriving. The result is that it has been more than 25 years since we had a balanced budget and our national debt is now six times larger than 20 years ago.

So I want to ask the Chief Secretary if she will demonstrate that she is serious about tackling our debt, whether she agrees that a key way to do that is to grow our economy, and whether she is interested to consider what we can learn from how other countries such as Switzerland, Sweden, and New Zealand have addressed and solved their budget process problems.

04:21:27 - 04:22:49

Darren Jones

I thank the honorable gentleman for his questions. I'll try and do justice to them in the short time available. On Brexit, the Chancellor said this morning that Brexit has hammered British exports. I do agree with him that there is a link between the fall in exports that he talks about and the barriers that the previous Conservative government put up with our nearest and biggest trading partner. So I agree with him on that, and that's exactly why this government is renegotiating a reset with our European partners.

We promised in our manifesto we will not join the single market, but we will bring down those barriers at the border, particularly with our SPS agreement that we're currently negotiating with the EU, and there'll be further announcements on that in due course. And that will benefit our agri-food industry by making it easier to export to the European Union. He asked about the fiscal rules. I don't agree with his analysis on that. We have brought forward the fiscal rules to apply to three years to get round some of the gaming that he talks about.

We are serious about tackling our debt, and as I said in my statement, we are reducing our deficit at the fastest rate in the G7. I'm always interested to learn from other countries. I think we should always be open to that, and I'd be interested to hear more about what he had in mind.

04:22:49 - 04:22:57

Speaker 219

We have the health debate later on today, so we are pressured for time. I ask colleagues to keep their questions short and for the Minister to be on point. Nesil Caliskan.

04:22:57 - 04:23:23

Nesil Caliskan

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Minister for her statement and indeed agree that London is a powerhouse for growth. But as a Member of Parliament for an outer London borough, she will recognize, I'm sure, that that wealth is not felt by every Londoner. Can I ask the Minister to give us reassurance that as industrialization and job creation is a priority for the government, that priority reaches the postcodes of my constituency of Barking?

04:23:23 - 04:23:50

Darren Jones

Yes, I can absolutely agree with her. As the Chancellor stressed this morning and as the Prime Minister has repeatedly said, this government is going to drive good growth in every postcode. And she's right to say that the situation in London is not a simple one. It is an economic powerhouse, but there are high levels of poverty in many different parts of London. And I can reassure her that we will focus on Barking and other parts of London too.

04:23:50 - 04:24:06

Desmond Swayne

Last week, the Prime Minister in the same breath boasted that we had the fastest growth in the G7 and that the decade of slow growth was caused by Brexit. Well, if we're ahead of the pack, it can't be caused by Brexit, can it?

04:24:06 - 04:24:12

Speaker 235

We could be even further ahead of the pack.

04:24:12 - 04:24:53

Graham Stringer

Madam Deputy Speaker, I strongly agree with the government's policy on devolution and better technical and scientific education. But all that will be for naught if we don't do something about the cost of energy. We cannot as an economy grow and compete when we have higher energy costs than our major industrial competitors. We have closed more than half our oil refineries in the last 20 years, which means we're now importing a majority of our energy. Will my right honourable friend do something about those destructive policies?

04:24:53 - 04:25:17

Darren Jones

He's right to raise this. The cost of energy for UK business is higher than elsewhere. That's why the Business Secretary, working hand in hand with the Treasury, is bearing down on that cost through the Business Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, for our IA, our industrial strategy, eight sectors. We've done that for automotive, aerospace and other sectors that are key to driving economic growth.

04:25:17 - 04:25:45

Mark Pritchard

Is it not the case that the bond markets are losing faith in the government's economic policies and the cost of borrowing, as we've heard from our front bench, is at an 18-year high? And that means, of course, that mortgage rates will increase, putting even more financial pain on many of our constituents. So what does the Minister say to my constituents who are likely to see three or four rate increases in mortgages over the next 12 months?

04:25:45 - 04:26:11

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question. I think in terms of what he is observing, it underlines the need for this government to stick to our fiscal rules. The Chancellor is right to say that fiscal discipline is the bedrock of our economic security and our national security. And that's why we have committed to meeting those fiscal rules, and in fact we're meeting one of them early.

04:26:11 - 04:26:34

Speaker 239

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chief Secretary's comments in relation to regional growth and indeed the active state is music to my ears. But rather than simply picking winners or de-risking private investment, how will she ensure that we see detailed local industrial strategies that builds our domestic productive capacity and supply chains?

04:26:34 - 04:26:58

Darren Jones

I thank her for her question. I'm glad to know that some of what I say is music to her ears. And I reassure her that that will be for mayoral strategic authorities to take forward. She's in a part of the country that has had great success in taking forward devolution, using those powers to drive economic growth, and I'm sure that her area will thrive under this government too.

04:26:58 - 04:27:20

Bobby Dean

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister said in her opening remarks about global instability, and there's no doubt that energy costs are having an impact on the cost of doing business. But local businesses this summer also said to me that it was the domestic government that raised the cost of them doing business too through national insurance and business rates rises. Will the Chancellor be doing something about that in the next budget?

04:27:20 - 04:27:23

Speaker 234

He invites me to write the next budget. I'm not going to do that.

04:27:23 - 04:27:57

Speaker 85

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chief Secretary is absolutely right that the UK has a vibrant ecosystem of innovative companies, but too many are looking overseas to realise their scale-up potential and become globally consequential companies. So I very much welcome the focus of using the state as a strategic partner to help them do that. That's exactly the message that CEOs and founders of companies that I met in the summer told me. So I very much welcome that.

So can she say, can the Chief Secretary say how the Treasury will be working across Whitehall and the wider public sector to help drive that cultural mindset change?

04:27:57 - 04:28:22

Darren Jones

I can, I thank him for his question, but also his work on this agenda. And can I reassure him that as the Chancellor set out this morning in his growth speech, we will be working across departments to ensure that we are opening up public procurement to the smaller and start-up businesses to ensure that they stay here rather than going elsewhere when they scale up.

04:28:22 - 04:28:35

Esther McVey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Does the Minister believe that putting up taxes is good for economic growth or bad for economic growth?

04:28:35 - 04:28:46

Darren Jones

Well, sometimes it is necessary in order to fund improvements in our National Health Service and also to fill the 22 billion fiscal black hole that we inherited.

04:28:46 - 04:29:26

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I make a pitch to the Minister for a part of the country called the Midlands, which I know she knows well. Not everything is about the south or everything about the north. There are a vast swathe of counties that form a band of engineering and manufacturing prowess in this country from Shropshire through to Lincolnshire that don't have the powerful mayors of the north and don't have the economic growth that the south has had. So when I talk to businesses in my own constituency in Stoke-on-Trent, the chemical industry talks to me about UK REACH double regulation, steel manufacturers talk about the tariffs, and ceramics talk about access to BICS and the supercharger.

So if she wants good growth in every part of the country, including the Midlands, how are we going to overcome those immediate challenges?

04:29:26 - 04:29:44

Darren Jones

Well, can I just agree with him that the Midlands is a very important part of the country, being from Wolverhampton myself. But can I also say to him, working alongside him, and he's a really powerful advocate for his area, he will know that we have put forward a ceramics support package to ensure his area thrives and others in the area.

04:29:44 - 04:30:17

Speaker 242

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the references in the Chief Secretary's remarks to the Oxford growth corridor and to localising power and resources. But I wonder if she could help my constituents who are deeply concerned to be sure that infrastructure will come before the many developments that the government has in mind. So can she confirm that along the Oxford-Cambridge growth corridor there will be an infrastructure-first approach, and can she let me and my constituents know which Minister now has responsibility for that corridor?

04:30:17 - 04:30:41

Darren Jones

Well, as the Chancellor set out this morning, we are determined to speed up infrastructure. Frankly, compared to other countries, we are just too slow at building high-speed rail or other types of rail. And we're determined to press ahead and ensure that we speed up infrastructure to make sure that we can then develop other areas. I have an interest also in the Cambridge-Oxford growth corridor because my constituency isn't very far away.

04:30:41 - 04:31:34

Chris Curtis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And on that point, we are now on the fourth round of consultation on East West Rail, the latter rounds of consultation consulting on the outcomes of the earlier rounds of consultation. At the same time, we are in the middle of building the most expensive nuclear power station in the history of the human race because of the four rounds of consultation required for Sizewell C. And when we try to build the Lower Thames Crossing, the total consultation at the DCO process was 359,000 pages. That is 250 times the length of War and Peace.

This is right to go to war on these consultations, but can the Minister tell us how she will stop at nothing to ensure that we get these infrastructure projects built more efficiently so that we can be saving taxpayers far more money and ensuring that they can be driving economic growth?

04:31:34 - 04:31:50

Speaker 227

I say to my honourable friend, I share his impatience. I want to get things done, and so does the Chancellor. That's why the Attorney General is going to provide that guidance to Ministers so that we can make quicker decisions, and she will advise about the need for consultation, where we don't need consultation. He's absolutely right to be impatient for change, and I am too.

04:31:45 - 04:32:22

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Isn't it quite bizarre just a few hours after the Secretary of State for Local Government came to the House to pause local government reorganisation on the basis of legal risk so that she can have more consultation, for then the Chief Secretary from the same government to come a few hours later and say we will bring an end to consultation culture and with guidance from the Attorney General on legal risk the ministers are confident to make decisions? So is it that they're going to have a high legal risk appetite or is it that they're going to pause in order to have more consultations? The two ministers are saying opposite things.

04:32:22 - 04:32:41

Darren Jones

We've got to get local government reorganisation right, so I make no apology for the Secretary of State coming to the House to update colleagues for a couple of hours actually, it was a very long statement. I know lots of people, lots of members across this House have strong views, but it's important that the government gets this right.

04:32:41 - 04:33:05

Chris Hinchliff

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm going to ask a slightly different question than I originally intended to. Every time we come to this chamber to discuss the economy, we spend a lot of time debating public spending, but we never seem to discuss our trade deficit. We haven't been in surplus since 1998. So what is the government going to do so that we can actually start paying our way in the world again?

04:33:05 - 04:33:19

Darren Jones

He's right to talk about the trade deficit and actually when I was at the G20 in North Carolina last week, there was a discussion at the G20 about global trade imbalances and indeed that is something that we're considering putting on the agenda for our G20 presidency.

04:33:19 - 04:33:43

Ann Kirsty Blackman

Labour promised 200 million pounds for Grangemouth, none of which has materialised. Labour promised a thousand jobs for GB Energy, turns out a third of the 130 delivered so far are not actually in Scotland. If the Prime Minister's localism project isn't just for Manchester, what extra powers will be devolved to Scotland as a result of the decisions being made?

04:33:43 - 04:33:54

Darren Jones

Well, can I say gently to the honourable lady, Scotland has rightly had plenty of devolution, but that doesn't mean that the two decades of SNP government has been successful.

04:33:54 - 04:34:23

Brian William Leishman

Madam Deputy Speaker, on that note, after two decades of failed SNP governance, 29% of children in Clackmannanshire are living in poverty. Now, the Labour government have lifted the two-child cap, which will reduce that figure and help life chances. And I say to the Chief Secretary, improving economic growth is of course laudable, but could we also look at taxing multi-millionaires and billionaires and go for some classic Labour redistribution of wealth?

04:34:23 - 04:34:43

Darren Jones

Well, can I agree with the honourable gentleman that it is simply not acceptable that we live in a country where the last government plunged 900,000 children into child poverty. We are a Labour government that is proud to lift the two-child limit and lift 450,000 children out of poverty.

04:34:43 - 04:34:54

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, on a day that Jaguar Land Rover have announced 4,000 job losses, how many more jobs have to be lost before the government changes course?

04:34:54 - 04:35:32

Darren Jones

Well, as I said in response to the honourable gentleman, the Business Secretary is working closely with the Chief Executive and the leadership of this company. Jaguar Land Rover employ 30,000 people in different parts of the country. We have supported them last year in the wake of their cyberattack. We are supporting automotive with a 4 billion pound capital and R&D funding to manufacture zero-emission vehicles. My thoughts are with the workforce.

This is a very difficult time, but as I understand it, the company has said that by and large this will be done via voluntary redundancy as much as possible and over a two-year period.

04:35:32 - 04:35:59

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, since 2020, government, Prime Ministers, ministers, UKRI and businesses have all supported the BioYorkshire project, which will address the issues within the environment and climate crisis as well as provide good quality jobs and provide a return for the Treasury. However, the government has not been able to get money out of the door.

So can the Minister say more about how she's actually going to invest and spend that money?

04:35:59 - 04:36:17

Darren Jones

I thank her for her question. And I really profoundly believe that we've got to drive a win-win here, that we can deliver good infrastructure and good jobs and limit the number of consultations, but we obviously have to have an eye to the impact on the environment. On her specific question, I will come back to her.

04:36:17 - 04:36:18

Robert Jenrick.

04:36:18 - 04:36:53

Edward Robert Jenrick

Imagine you're a worker at JLR, worried about your future, and you have the misfortune of watching the Chancellor's speech, containing searing economic insights like, "I want to see businesses make a profit." Nothing about scrapping EV mandates, bringing down energy costs by getting rid of net zero targets, or bringing down the cost of employing people by getting rid of the increase in employers' national insurance. Isn't the truth that it is the government that is killing the British car industry and needs to wake up and take action?

04:36:53 - 04:36:54

No, it's not the truth.

04:36:55 - 04:37:23

Chris Kane

Like many parents all over the country this month, my wife and I will be dropping our child at university for the first time, in our case to begin an engineering degree. What assessment has she made of the economic benefits of helping more young people into secure work? And what assurances can she give all of our young people starting in education or training this month that this Labour government is alive to their fears over rising costs, technological changes and global uncertainty and working hard to make sure the economic conditions exist so that they have a job when they enter the jobs market?

04:37:23 - 04:37:45

Darren Jones

Well, this government is on the side of young people, of young graduates, but also those who pursue technical education. As the Prime Minister set out in his first two weeks in power, we want to make sure that there is parity between technical education and university education and also drive good growth in every postcode, including in his own constituency.

04:37:45 - 04:37:46

Gavin Williamson.

04:37:46 - 04:38:14

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the Chief Secretary will know, there are so many of those Jaguar Land Rover employees who live in my constituency as across the whole Midlands. The government committed to consult on the zero emission vehicle mandate in August. Will the Chief Secretary undertake to make sure that consultation is as quick as possible so we give our car manufacturing firms the best chance to compete globally?

04:38:14 - 04:38:32

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question. We were once parliamentary neighbours. I understand the concern that he is expressing. I spoke with the Business Secretary over the weekend about this issue, and we will, we are doing a consultation. It will be a quick consultation.

I recognise the concerns that he's laid out.

04:38:32 - 04:38:33

Andrew Pakes.

04:38:33 - 04:39:19

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I heartily welcome my right honourable friend to the dispatch box in her new role. Madam Deputy Speaker, in 1954, the Co-operative Permanent Building Society opened its office in Peterborough. In the 70 years since then, now as Nationwide, it has provided advice and support for lenders and people buying a house. There are few examples in this country of a commitment to our high streets and to growth in every postcode than building societies and the mutual movement. We have a manifesto commitment to double the size of the co-operative and mutual economy.

Can my right honourable friend reassure me that when we talk about growth in every postcode, this government will do everything it can to ensure the building society movement can play its part in rebuilding our country?

04:39:19 - 04:39:37

Darren Jones

I can absolutely do that. And can I just thank my honourable friend for the work that he does to further the cause of co-operatives and indeed mutuals. And I very much enjoyed when I was Economic Secretary working with the sector because the building societies often offer more innovative products to first-time buyers in particular and they do sterling work.

04:39:37 - 04:39:38

Dr. Luke Evans.

04:39:38 - 04:40:07

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The rhetoric might have changed under the new Prime Minister a bit, but it seems to be continuity Chancellor on the policy front. Now the Minister talks about the failures of privatization, but where's the action to bring water back into public hands? She talks about the need for an active state, but where's the action to tax wealth fairly so we can invest in the services that we need? Fundamentally, we can't get good growth unless it's both green and fair.

We won't build sustainable prosperity by trashing nature and the climate.

04:40:07 - 04:40:24

Darren Jones

I I don't believe in trashing nature and the climate either. But if we want to tackle climate change, we cannot stop every renewable project going ahead, which the Greens would have us do, and indeed the building of nuclear power.

04:40:24 - 04:40:53

James William Naish

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend talked about good growth in every postcode, which of course I welcome, as well as the 150 million pound scheme with the British Business Bank. But there was nothing for the Midlands, which was ironic given where the Chancellor delivered his speech earlier today. The truth is the Midlands is being squeezed from the north and from the south. So will she help me to revisit this limit, to resurrect the scheme on the A46, which was canned previously, and also meet with me to discuss investment coming into our region?

04:40:53 - 04:41:03

Darren Jones

One I can I just reassure him, one of our trailblazer projects on the place-based business cases is with Birmingham, which is obviously the beating heart of the West Midlands.

04:41:04 - 04:41:28

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chancellor has promised good growth in every postcode, and that must include rural communities like Glastonbury and Somerton, not just our cities and towns. Yet rural England's productivity sits at just 69% of the non-rural rate, costing our economy billions in lost revenue every year. Now that's not just a rural problem, it's a national one. So what is the Chief Secretary doing to create opportunity in the countryside and unleash the full potential of rural Britain?

04:41:28 - 04:42:01

Darren Jones

Um, can I thank her for her question? And she'll know that rural communities are also something that's close to my heart in my previous role, but also the fact that I have a semi-rural constituency. There is huge potential in rural communities. The Prime Minister visited rural Cornwall in the first few weeks in the job. And we will do more and we are doing more to improve local transport, the cap on the two pound cap on bus fares, to improve rural connectivity, because she's right to say there's great potential there which we must realize.

04:42:01 - 04:42:02

Amanda Martin.

04:42:02 - 04:42:25

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Too often decisions have been made in Westminster with an assumption that investment opportunity and growth flows naturally to the south, while in reality Portsmouth has been ignored and faces real pressure on housing, transport and education. So will she will the Minister work with me to make sure that my city and the people of Portsmouth are no longer an afterthought but at the heart of government's plan for growth and opportunity?

04:42:25 - 04:42:37

Darren Jones

Absolutely, I can give her that reassurance. And this government is intent on driving good growth and job creation opportunities across the country, in the north and the south and the Midlands and every other part too.

04:42:37 - 04:42:38

Guy Opperman.

04:42:38 - 04:43:11

Andrew Murrison

The government insisted on applying the social time preference rate to the disastrous Chagos deal in order to make an appalling deal look slightly better. Will the Minister confirm that the changes that she has announced today as part of her Green Book revision will increase the cost of that deal by 288 million, which is 10 times the amount that she proposes to cut from the army training budget this year?

04:43:11 - 04:43:18

Darren Jones

The Green Book discount rate is a tool of economic analysis and it doesn't change the cost of the deal.

04:43:18 - 04:43:19

Mark Tufnell.

04:43:19 - 04:43:38

James Mark Sewards

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can the Minister confirm that the reviews to judicial review of infrastructure, the reforms, sorry, are going to apply to the West Yorkshire mass transit project?

And does she consider that project to be nationally significant infrastructure?

04:43:38 - 04:43:48

Darren Jones

Can I just state to my honourable friend that we are working with the mayor on that issue, and I would have our colleagues get back to you on that.

04:43:48 - 04:43:53

Speaker 219

Hopefully not get back to me, Minister, but get back to the member. That's okay. Llinos Medi.

04:43:53 - 04:44:18

Llinos Medi

Diolch, Dirprwy Lefarydd. The Sea Shanty Cafe on Ynys Môn is desperate for hope. Paying 20% VAT is simply unsustainable. Hospitality is a major employer on the island, but our businesses are being squeezed by rising costs. Cutting VAT to 10% would be a quick win, driving growth by giving businesses some breathing space and protecting jobs.

Will the Chief Secretary consider this?

04:44:18 - 04:44:42

Darren Jones

I thank her for her question, and the Prime Minister is very clear that the hospitality sector is one that is close to his heart and a sector that he's worked very closely with when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester. We've already announced earlier this summer the business rate reductions for pubs, social clubs, and live music venues, and we will go further in the budget.

04:44:42 - 04:45:03

David Mundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will know from her previous role that the cost of fuel is the most single most important business cost for rural businesses. So, not asking her to write the budget today, will she convey to the Chancellor the importance of continuing the fuel duty freeze from the end of December for rural businesses?

04:45:03 - 04:45:20

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question, and as I outlined to the honourable lady from the Liberal Democrats, it's absolutely right that we focus on rural communities and urban areas and city regions. I will convey that message to the Chancellor, but I won't be writing the budget right now.

04:45:20 - 04:45:44

Steffan Aquarone

Madam Deputy Speaker, the government talks quite a lot about how they're going to create economic growth, but there is no way just to legislate your way to growth. There are, however, plenty of ways to legislate against it, something small rural businesses in North Norfolk know only too well. Can the Minister tell these rural businesses what she's doing to help them grow and, more importantly, what things that get in their way will she stop doing?

04:45:44 - 04:46:06

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question. As I said to his honourable friend, we do take the economic success of rural communities really seriously, and we are improving connectivity, whether that's digital connectivity or local transport connectivity, to ensure that the areas are more successful. There's obviously more to be done.

04:46:06 - 04:46:33

Julian Lewis

For some years, I've known the proprietor of a small-to-medium aviation company that has come up with revolutionary aircraft designs with both civilian and military applications. But every time, the government ends up, the government of the day, supporting the big operators in this field. How will her new policy towards unicorns benefit somebody like that?

04:46:33 - 04:46:52

Darren Jones

Well, I thank him for his question, and he's right to raise this issue. We, as I said, we've given strategic steers to the public financial institutions to make sure that they are focusing on regional growth. That is also about opening up opportunities for the kinds of businesses that he mentions.

04:46:52 - 04:47:21

Sammy Wilson

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor has rightly identified trade frictions as a major impediment to economic growth. As a result of the Windsor Framework, the internal market in the UK has been severely disrupted by EU-imposed restrictions on trade, which mean customs unions, mountains of paperwork, and physical barriers. What steps does she intend to take to remove this barrier to economic growth in Northern Ireland?

04:47:21 - 04:47:38

Darren Jones

I thank him for that question and can I reassure him that when I was environment secretary I visited the port of Belfast and I saw the kind of checks that were going on there and the SPS agreement that we are negotiating with the EU will help to reduce that friction.

04:47:38 - 04:47:55

Thomas Gordon

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chief Secretary talks about 150 million pounds for investment in the North. How much of that funding is actually new capital expenditure from this government or is it simply the case it's a repackaged reannounced sum of money for the North?

04:47:55 - 04:48:12

Darren Jones

Well it's money that already sits with the British Business Bank but the change is the focus on the North on scale-up businesses to ensure that we unleash their growth potential. We're not announcing new funding. We never said we were.

04:48:12 - 04:48:37

Iqbal Mohamed

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker Dewsbury and Batley is a capital of furniture bed and upholstery manufacturing in the UK. After Brexit it lost a lot of its export business. So what is the government going to do to support furniture upholstery and supply chain manufacturers in Dewsbury and Batley as part of its investment in the North?

04:48:37 - 04:48:51

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question and the trade deals that we're doing but also the reset of the relationship that we are taking forward with the EU will bring down barriers with our biggest and closest market.

04:48:51 - 04:49:18

Ian Sollom

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister cites our world-class universities and an ambition to double the number of UK unicorns built on frontier technologies like quantum and AI. But does the Minister recognise that those breakthroughs often come from curiosity-driven frontier physics research and that's in our universities and a research base now faces that research base now faces a 700 million pound funding gap?

04:49:18 - 04:49:26

Darren Jones

I thank him for his question. UKRI invests in that sort of research and you know the government will continue to do so through UKRI.

04:49:26 - 04:50:02

Shockat Patel

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I too am a bit concerned the Minister is missing a page of her statement because there's no mention of the East Midlands because the Prime Minister was right when he blamed Margaret Thatcher for picking winners and abandoning whole regions and it appears that East Midlands happens to be the case this time. In my constituency Leicester Leicestershire and Rutland receives a grand total of zero pounds in infrastructure investment. On skills funding Leicester gets 11 pounds 30 per head against 52 pounds 10 in Greater Manchester and 66 90 in the West Midlands which is six times more. So can she reassure me the people of East Midlands and my constituents of Leicester South that we will not be left behind?

04:50:02 - 04:50:24

Darren Jones

I can reassure him and the East Midlands and the West Midlands are really important. The changes that the Chancellor outlined to the discount rate today will benefit places such as his because it will make sure that we value the longer-term benefit of regional investment projects more fairly. And as we've said we will drive growth in every postcode and that includes in his own constituency.

04:50:24 - 04:50:48

Ayoub Khan

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The concept of devolution and localisation is to empower local communities by bringing the decision-making process closer to them. In Birmingham Birmingham City Council is being forced to relinquish its planning powers to the regional mayor. That is anti-devolution. Does the Minister agree and what will she do to ensure that the council does not lose its powers on planning?

04:50:48 - 04:51:08

Darren Jones

I would disagree because obviously the mayoral strategic authorities are about local authorities coming together in a combined authority and working together across the borders of the West Midlands an area that I know extremely well and that's about driving growth driving good decisions across that region.

04:51:08 - 04:51:38

Adnan Hussain

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chief Secretary has promised good growth in every postcode. Blackburn has the talent the institutions and major employers such as EG on the Move that are willing to invest in local people.

But we need government investment to match that ambition. So I ask, will the Chief Secretary make Blackburn a test case for this plan and back an employer-led jobs and skills partnership to create good local jobs?

04:51:38 - 04:52:12

Darren Jones

We are working in close partnership with business, and he's right to say that we've got to unleash talent in his own constituency and elsewhere and unleash business investment. But as I said to my honourable friend, the chair of the Treasury Select Committee, the way that the public financial institutions work is that they assess independently the potential of firms and then back them, and that's what the Chancellor was talking about today. We set the strategic priorities and those independent economic organisations assess projects for their potential.

04:52:12 - 04:52:43

Speaker 229

That is the end of the statement on economic growth. As front bench wish to shuffle over, we will in a moment move on to presentation of bills. Presentation of bill, David Davis.

04:52:43 - 04:52:46

David Michael Davis

Military Operations Bill.

04:52:46 - 04:52:47

Second reading what day?

04:52:47 - 04:52:49

David Michael Davis

Friday 12th March.

04:52:49 - 04:52:59

Speaker 262

Friday the 12th of March. Program motion, Minister to move.

04:52:59 - 04:53:16

Speaker 229

The question is that the House Bill Program Number 2 motion as on the order paper, as many that opinion say aye. As many that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. The clerk will now proceed to be the orders of the day.

04:53:16 - 04:53:24

Speaker 260

Health Bill, as amended in the Public Bill Committee, to be considered.

04:53:24 - 04:56:22

Karin Smyth

I beg to move. We will begin with new clause 96, with which it will be convenient to consider other new clauses and amendments as listed on the selection paper. I call the Minister to move new clause 96, Minister.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And before I formally move, I do want to just take a moment to really thank the members of this House on all sides who served on the Bill Committee during what was a very hot end of June and July, if one can remember back that far. But as part of that process, the committee scrutinized every clause of the bill and debated over 195 amendments. And we on the government benches are grateful for their diligence. The implementation of the bill is better for all that hard work.

And I also welcome the spirit of collaboration that has greeted this bill on the main provisions from all sides of this House, most notably at second reading, but also during committee. And I hope that we can continue in that spirit at this stage. For our part, we remain committed to working with MPs and peers across the House and other stakeholders to ensure that the end result is a bill that strengthens the NHS. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I know we've got a large number of amendments on a variety of topics, so I will keep the remarks on these amendments very short. So I beg to move new clause 96 and 97 regarding visiting rights.

And these amendments strengthen the role of integrated care boards and local authorities in promoting visiting, supporting people to have someone with them, and ensuring the involvement of family, friends, and carers in decisions. They complement the existing legal requirements and the work already underway to drive a change in culture and practice by embedding visiting at the heart of the responsibilities of commissioners. An amendment new clause 96 explicitly places duties on integrated care boards to promote opportunities for visiting and accompaniment, while 97, new clause 97, builds on local authorities' existing wellbeing duties by emphasizing the importance of involving other people in decision-making, receiving visitors, and maintaining opportunities to take trips outside the care home. And maintaining meaningful contact and connection with family, friends, and carers is critical to the health and wellbeing of so many people in our health and care settings.

I know the question of who is required to sit on ICB boards has raised comments from all across this House, and I'm grateful to all those members who have raised the importance of local government having a voice in ICBs, including my friend the honourable member for Birmingham Erdington and wider, the honourable members across all sides of the Health and Social Care Select Committee who've continually advocated on this issue. And we agree, it was never the intention to weaken the voice of local government in the NHS. We recognise that local authority board members is an important voice for commissioning on the ICB, and often providing helpful challenge and a very different perspective on those commissioning decisions. This is especially significant in... I will give way.

04:56:22 - 04:57:02

Layla Moran

I'm grateful to her for giving way and also to thank her for taking our amendment on this issue. We pressed her over and over and over again and her colleagues, to the extent where we got a letter back that honestly at one point we thought was generated by AI, because the logic in it had absolutely no follow-through at all. So I'm delighted that she's listened. But I would also ask her, what else is she intending to listen to us to, in particular, and these are for tomorrow, but the HSIB amendments, the Healthwatch amendments, we've got the health inequalities amendment and most importantly, the special needs amendment today. What else is she going to listen to us on?

04:57:02 - 04:59:45

Karin Smyth

Well, I thank the chair of the Health Select Committee and I can assure her that I'm Karin, not Claude, and those amendments were absolutely generated... and, you know, she tempts me to go further on the rest of this bill. But can I say I genuinely thank her and the committee and I hope she would agree that I did spend a lot of time over the past months before report stage and committee stage meeting with her and members of the committee and many honourable members across this House. We have some what we might call some simple provisions in this bill to democratise the NHS accountability and particularly enforcing single patient record and improve the landscape around patient experience and patient safety. But we absolutely recognise that within those simple propositions there's a lot of complexity and we'll continue to listen to honourable members. We want to make sure that the NHS is strengthened as I said from this.

But in relation to the ICBs and local authority voice, it was particularly significant over the summer period in light of those comments, but also my right honourable friend the Prime Minister's commitment to rewiring the state and our ongoing reform to social care. And with that in mind, I am pleased to table these amendments which re-establish a requirement on ICBs to have at least one board member jointly nominated by local authorities in that area, which sits alongside the existing duty to have a member nominated by the mayor of each mayoral strategic authority as well as duties on ICBs and local government to work together, including on health and wellbeing boards. And in committee we had a very useful discussion on health and wellbeing boards along with neighbourhoods and that accountability at local level. I would also note that ICBs are able to appoint other people to their boards if they would benefit from their expertise, and that is a decision to be taken locally. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to briefly preempt the honourable member for North Shropshire and make a few comments about new clause 1.

And I would like to thank the honourable member for North Shropshire and the way that she has worked with me and the committee in committee and through this issue around maternity commissioner, an issue which I think unites the House on maternity. And as the honourable member knows, we have accepted Baroness Amos's recommendation from her national investigation into maternity neonatal care. And to deliver on this commitment, I can announce today that we will be bringing forward an amendment to this bill in the other place to establish a statutory maternity and neonatal commissioner.

04:59:45 - 04:59:51

Speaker 266

And Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move these government amendments.

04:59:51 - 05:00:12

Speaker 229

Integrated care boards duty as to visiting etc. The question is that new clause 96 be read a second time. And before I call the shadow minister, Dr Caroline Johnson, this debate is heavily oversubscribed. Backbenchers will be on an immediate speaking limit and not everybody will get in. I call the shadow minister, Dr Caroline Johnson.

05:00:12 - 05:11:53

Caroline Johnson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'll try and keep my remarks as short as I can. But first, I'd like to thank my right honourable friend, the member for Daventry, for all the hard work he's done over the last year holding the government to account on health and social care. To thank the whole of the conservative health team for their support and every member of the committee who, as the minister said, scrutinised this bill in detail in such a hot and sticky room before the summer. And I'd like to thank my parliamentary team for their support with it as well. And finally, to congratulate the minister on her reappointment and thank her for the time that she has taken to engage with opposition on this legislation.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I also must declare an interest as an NHS consultant paediatrician, a member of the British Medical Association and a member of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. So, after that, turning to the bill. It's not a small bill, Madam Deputy Speaker. It runs to over 200 pages and there are almost as many pages of amendments as there is in the bill, with around 180 different MPs signing or supporting different amendments. Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't agree with every amendment proposed, but I do welcome thoughts and ideas coming from right across the house, well from most way across the house, we didn't see much from Reform.

Now, this bill does have scale, but does it have direction? Does it have clarity of purpose? Leadership sets direction, a destination. Follow that, from that follows a path as smooth as possible from A to B with appropriate milestones. But this bill, like so many of this Labour government's, came as an announcement without enough thought.

Let's go back. The government started with the Darzi report. I won't restate the arguments about why it was done or the weakness of their claims that it is independent, but suffice to say it is their report published by a Labour peer and former Labour minister for a Labour government. And it says a few things about reorganisation. Lord Darzi wrote that a top-down reorganisation of NHS England and integrated care boards is neither necessary nor desirable.

Yet the government decided to abolish NHS England and restructure the ICBs and half the ICBs' budgets, all at once, without properly planning what would come next. So that's the first clause of the bill, abolishing NHS England. One of the main arguments provided was the unnecessary bureaucracy and duplication of staff. And as a conservative, I accept that that is a strong case for efficiency. Government must use taxpayers' money wisely.

In a letter to the permanent secretary sent to the Public Accounts Committee, officials estimated savings of a billion pounds a year by abolishing NHS England and redundancy cost payments of approximately 1 to 1.3 billion pounds. But we haven't seen the calculations behind those. Madam Deputy Speaker, it was announced in March 25 that the restructure would be completed in two years. Yet we're now 18 months in and ministers don't seem to be on track. From March 25 to July 26, a year and three quarters of the time they've given themselves, a total headcount across NHS England and the minister's department decreased by 12.9%.

Nowhere near what the government need to deliver the cost it's promised savings. So we've tabled amendment 102 requiring the government to publish a full workforce transition plan and new clause 153 requiring the government to publish precisely how many people it makes redundant.

I'd like to raise a contradiction, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government's talked a lot about devolution and local decision making, but this bill does the opposite. It removes the council of governors from foundation trusts. It gives ministers the power to hire and fire health leaders. It puts an end to local Healthwatch.

It gives the Secretary of State the power to set and adjust annual funding allocations for ICBs and direct them to ringfence funding for service integration. It takes away local decision making. It's also inconsistent with what the Prime Minister said the other day. In response to a question about this bill, the Prime Minister said he does not like the idea of a postcode lottery in the National Health Service. But if decisions are taken locally, decisions taken will be different and in different areas, which will lead to a postcode lottery.

So can ministers shed some light on what they actually believe? Does this government want decisions made locally and accept that they will be different, or do they want decisions made centrally? And back to Lord Darzi. Lord Darzi said something else in his report. He said, and I quote, "Constant reorganisations are costly and distracting."

They stop NHS structures from focusing on their primary responsibility to raise the quality and efficiency of care in providers. Indeed. In fact, it's not too dissimilar to what the Minister of Secondary Care previously concluded herself in opposition, when she said, "The reorganisation of health services always distracts from people's jobs, destroys morale, and wastes money." So how is the NHS performing? Let's take a look.

Well, the total number waiting for appointment has gone down a bit, as they've said. But in trauma and orthopaedics, ophthalmology, cardiothoracic surgery, elderly medicine, and gynaecology, it's gone up, in some cases higher than it was before the election. But for those waiting for an admission who need a procedure or an operation, it's not only going up month on month, year on year, it's higher than it was at the time of the general election. And what about accident and emergency? The number of people waiting for more than 12 hours after a decision to admit was 29% higher in July '26 than July '24.

And that's despite the fact that, Madam Deputy Speaker, there were fewer such admissions in July '26 than July '24. And how has the government performed in other health areas? Childhood vaccination rates are in decline. The workforce plan has not been published, despite the minister herself saying it was imminent months ago. Fracture liaison clinics haven't been delivered, despite allegedly being one of this government's planned first acts.

I could go on, Madam Deputy Speaker, but we don't have much time, and I think I've demonstrated the point. NHS reorganisation is distracting from delivery. And one of the things I want to talk about that it is not delivering is the response to the Hughes report. And I'd like to thank Dr. Henrietta Hughes, the Patient Safety Commissioner, for her hard work on this report. When it became apparent the trauma and suffering that some people, particularly women, have experienced from mesh repairs, and the harm that children have suffered because of exposure to valproate in the womb, we were all horrified.

The previous government changed the way valproate was prescribed and commissioned regional surgical centres of excellence to provide care for women who suffer from the effects of a mesh repair. The Conservative government also commissioned this Hughes report, published in February '24, that investigated compensation schemes for those affected. But the general election was called just three months later, so delivering compensation, delivering on this report, became the Labour government's job. But sadly, ministers have dithered and delayed for more than two years now. We've had written question after written question, several debates, and a lot of warm words, but still no response to the Hughes report.

Madam Deputy Speaker, it is simply not good enough. Those suffering should not have to wait any longer. And that is why we have tabled clause 14, new clause 145. This new clause would provide a legal backstop ensuring the government publishes its response to the Hughes report within 30 days of this bill becoming law at the latest. That's still not soon enough for those affected, but it's the only way of putting in an effective backstop so the government can stop fobbing off victims and start delivering justice.

When the bill came, ministers chose to change the composition of ICBs too, removing the voice of hospitals and primary care from boards, as well as the voice of local authorities, severing that link with social care. Integrated care partnerships will also be abolished. There'll instead be a focus on mayoral representation, even for mayors where there is little role if any in delivering social care. So in Lincolnshire, Madam Deputy Speaker, for example, instead of a local authority and an ICB on the same geographical footprint working together over the same area to cover health and social care, we now have a government conspiring to give us an ICB covering three counties and no voice for the local authorities who aren't sure after today's announcement whether they're going to be split up or not. We discussed at some length in committee the importance of health and social care working together, so I welcome the government's U-turn on day one of this term to reinstate local authority representation.

But I urge the minister to consider, as the opposition parties have proposed, to reinstate primary care and secondary care representatives too. Um, there were three amendments on workforce, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I'll speak of them briefly because I'm aware of the time. The first, new clause 154, would require the Secretary of State to increase the number of medical school training places to 15,000 by 2031-32. And why? And to put it simply, because they promised they would do and they haven't.

Yeah. And then, secondly, merit-based applications, new clause 152. The current system for allocating doctors their first jobs used to be done on performance, it was when I was a junior doctor. Now it's done by a computer algorithm prioritising choice. This is unfair, demoralising, and destroys incentive to study hard.

We believe in meritocracy and I urge the government to accept new clause 152. And then also new clause 144, I urge the government to support this too. This addresses the plight of a small but significant group of people, a group of medical students subject to a great injustice. These are students who are British students, British citizens, studying at a British university, predominantly Queen Mary's University in London, who were told four and a half years into their degree that they would not be able to have places on the foundation programme but be at the back of the queue. The medical training prioritisation act has meant that non-prioritised doctors got only 1.8% of the jobs and they were the last 1.8% that were left.

Now that was the point of the bill, but this particular group of British citizens the government should put into the priority group. In terms of our other amendments, Madam Deputy Speaker, which we'll talk about no doubt in the Lords, we have an amendment on self-care, new clause 155, to give people more autonomy over their own care. We have new clause 101 which talks about the national commissioning of services, which are the low-volume high-complexity services, to make sure that government can't just move them into ICBs without a proper consultation and a proper plan. We have the patient choice duty amendment 95, ensuring that patients have the choice over the care that they receive in neighbourhood services as well as hospital services. We have amendment 88, the single patient record.

The single patient record, Madam Deputy Speaker, has the potential to be truly transformative, bringing the NHS in line with other modern healthcare systems. They can also prevent people having to repeat themselves. But the government has lots of unanswered questions. It's another example of making an announcement without thinking it through. How will existing health records be linked?

How will patient carers and clinicians have access? Who will control the data? How will it be kept safe? Yeah. So we've tabled amendment 88 requiring the Secretary of State to publish a full plan before making changes.

Madam Deputy Speaker, there are some parts of this bill that the opposition can support. But the government in its hurry to make announcements often doesn't seem to think things through properly. And this is the story of local government reform that we heard in this house earlier today as well. It's a story of the much delayed workforce plan. And it risks becoming the story of this NHS reorganization.

In health, Madam Deputy Speaker, there are life and death situations. So we cannot afford for the government to get it wrong. The opposition have made a series of sensible amendments and we'll be grateful for the minister's support.

05:11:53 - 05:11:57

Speaker 229

Backbench speeches are on a five-minute speaking limit. Clive Efford.

05:11:57 - 05:15:04

Clive Efford

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to support the motion number 97, amendment number 97 in my name, which is to remove clause 10 from the bill. Clause 10 would give powers to the Secretary of State to vary the proportion of public-private provision of health services if they consider that to do so is in the interests of the health service. In evidence to the Health and Social Care Select Committee, the Chief Executive of the Nuffield Trust said of clause 10, of clause 10, that it seems to make it more possible for the Secretary of State to explicitly set out to increase private or public provision. My question is why does she need this power?

Introducing an extra level of nuance now, as clause 10 would do, has the potential to raise fears within the NHS that it could be abused in future. The clause has the potential to create unintended consequences. The explanatory notes on the bill say that this new flexibility is necessary where there may otherwise be a breakdown in provision of health service. Can we imagine a situation where the Secretary of State has concerns about a health service that an approach to assist a local provider would be rebuffed? It's hardly likely to happen.

The explanatory notes suggest that in such circumstances, the Secretary of State needs the power to direct local decisions rather than to work with local health service providers to resolve any difficulties. How does the power to influence the proportion between public and private provision help resolve a breakdown in service? Labour's 2024 plan to make work pay set out a very welcome desire to bring more essential services back into public control, something which is welcomed by health workers across the country because so far the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation, as was promised, has felt more like a trickle when it comes to the NHS. The health bill is something which the new Prime Minister and the new Secretary of State have inherited from their predecessors. So hopefully they will be able to stamp their own mark on it before it becomes law and remove clause 10, and that would be one way of making their mark.

The concern here is that those that work for the NHS and those that support it is that the clause has the potential to be exploited in future by those who would seek to move away from the public provision of healthcare. There are ample powers to enable the Secretary of State to intervene and resolve breakdowns in provision of health service. We must balance clause 10 against what it adds in those situations against its potential misuse by an ideologically driven government that is determined to privatize our NHS. To remove any ambiguity and to protect the NHS from the possibility of this clause being abused by a future Secretary of State, I would urge that it be dropped from the bill.

05:15:04 - 05:15:06

Speaker 268

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Helen Morgan.

05:15:06 - 05:17:01

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I've tabled a number of amendments to this bill, but I'll hopefully keep my remarks focused so that there is a good opportunity for other members to make their speeches. This bill should be about fixing the front door and the back door of the NHS. It's obviously an opportunity to bring in tangible changes for patients, to address pressing problems and introduce desperately needed improvements to patient safety and experience. The primary care and social care crisis in particular are millstones around the neck of the NHS.

But instead of these, the bill has focused on a top-down reorganization, which risks diverting time and money away from pressing issues and giving sweeping powers to the Secretary of State, which is not in itself without risk. The Liberal Democrats would instead put social care and general practice at the heart of this bill, a move which would represent real reform of the health service. In particular, new clause 54 and 56 put down by the honourable member for Mid Sussex would together transform the rights of family carers through guaranteed respite care and reform of the carers allowance. These would put free personal care and an end to catastrophic care costs at the heart of social care reform. The member for Epsom and Ewell's new clause 53 would ensure everyone can see a GP within seven days or 24 hours if urgent, while amendment 17 would introduce a primary care investment standard.

Although general practice is the core of the patient's relationship with the NHS, it has seen its funding decline as a share of NHS spending. Less than 10% of the NHS budget is spent on primary care, although this is estimated to constitute 90% of a patient's direct experience with the NHS. A primary care investment standard would help to reverse that trend. Dentistry is another area of primary care which has been neglected, leading to dental deserts and dangerous DIY dentistry. New clause 18 would introduce a scheme to end dental deserts and guarantee appointments for children and those in most need.

Now, it's... I will give way.

05:17:01 - 05:17:23

Jim Shannon

And does the honourable lady agree with me when it comes to the family mental health pathway? It refers to new clause 82, but the point I'm making is the diagnosis right through treatment and charging for some bereavement, mental health support for families can't be an afterthought, it must be a statutory proactive duty. Does the honourable lady agree that when it comes to that issue in particular, perhaps government and the minister in particular should take that on board?

05:17:23 - 05:19:33

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Well, I thank him for his intervention, and I broadly do agree with him, and I'm about to come on actually to mental health in a moment. It's right to modernize the NHS and to end some of the duplication that we see between NHSE and the Department for Health and Social Care, but the way it has been handled has been chaotic. It's been combined with 50% cuts to ICB budgets, unfunded redundancy payments and chaos through the system. And I was alarmed to read the report in the Times at the weekend about advice to the Secretary of State that the changes envisaged in the bill are impossible to implement, given that the staff of NHS England are on different pay scales to those of the department. So given these significant hurdles, I hope the secretary, sorry, the minister can give us some reassurance in her closing remarks that abolishing NHS in the way that the bill envisages is actually achievable.

We're also particularly concerned that the functions of the Secretary of State under these reforms open the door to political capture, a huge risk to take given the unstable political climate we live in. That's why we've tabled amendment 16 to create a firewall between the Secretary of State and operational decisions. These new powers are particularly concerning in the context of the patient safety issues which we are going to discuss in more detail tomorrow. Beyond the department itself, the bill is complacent on taking seriously the vulnerability of our NHS from foreign interference and its implications for national security. That's why we've put forward amendments new clauses 2 to 5, which recognize and address the NHS's role as part of our sovereignty and the sensitivity of patient data.

My new clause 17 would require scrutiny in this house of the arrangement between the United States of America and the United Kingdom on pharmaceutical pricing. This deal, forced on us by Donald Trump with no say in the British people, will hike prices of medicines in the coming years by billions of pounds and deserves parliamentary scrutiny. What all of these shortcomings of the bill attest to is that the NHS already spends far too much time and money responding to failure, rather than improving the safety and quality of services in the first place. Our amendment 10, I will give way, and that will be the last one.

05:19:33 - 05:19:53

Gideon Amos

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way. On the points about safety, would she agree with me on the gravity of the national maternity review and the fact that it found that Musgrove Park Hospital was the, and I quote, most challenging estate in the country? And if it is the most challenging estate in the country, would she agree with me it needs to be addressed sooner than 2033 so that mums get better treatment sooner than the 2040s?

That is unacceptable if it's the most challenging estate in the country.

05:19:53 - 05:23:40

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Well, I thank him for his intervention. Crumbling estates are a big part of the problem across the whole NHS and in maternity, and he's right to highlight the state of his own local hospital and advocate for its quick remedy. Now, our amendment 10, which the member for Winchester I'm sure will outline in more detail, reintroduces the mental health investment standard. This is a crucial investment to avoid failures further down the line if interventions aren't made for patients early on. But nowhere is the cost of failure more obvious than in maternity, a devastating scandal which despite the many recent reviews still deserves far more attention.

Our amendments to finally make our maternity services safe for mothers and babies will therefore be the main focus of my remarks today. But I would first like to thank the minister for her constructive engagement with me on new clause 1 and the commitment that she's made at the dispatch box today to table relevant amendments when the bill reaches the other place to put that maternity commissioner in place. And I'm very grateful to her for the discussions that we've had and the constructive approach that she has taken both with me and the large numbers of campaigners on this issue beyond this place. So in the light of that, I won't be pushing new clause 1 to a vote, I will be withdrawing it. But I've seen up close the human costs of the failures in our maternity system.

Four years ago, the Ockenden review found that over 200 babies and nine mothers in my community had died needlessly in Shrewsbury and Telford due to failures in maternity care. This has been devastating for my community, and since then we've heard that it wasn't isolated. There have been terrible stories from families around the country, most recently following the review into services in Nottingham. I've therefore tabled new clause 6, which would introduce a scheme to ensure that every maternity unit in the country is rated good or outstanding by the CQC. This new clause is essential if we are to meaningfully address the crisis in our maternity services and show families that lessons have been learned not just locally but nationally.

The Liberal Democrat maternity rescue package behind this would require an estimated 600 million pounds a year to bring safety in maternity units up to standard, investing in safe staffing and listening to mothers. But the government already spends 1.3 billion pounds a year, more than double the cost of this package, on maternity negligence payments. Introducing this reset is a no-brainer, Madam Deputy Speaker. Rather than spending a fortune compensating for failure and heartbreak, the NHS should be getting it right in the first place. Recently we've seen the consequences of safety failures with lack of staffing causing North Devon's maternity unit to close, forcing women to take a 50-mile trip if they go into labor.

The honorable member for North Devon, whose constituency has been hard hit by this news, has tabled new clause 66 to guarantee safe staffing levels and access to a maternity unit within 45 minutes. And while on the subject of women's health, I also want to highlight new clause 11 and new clause 12. Earlier this year, I wrote to the EHRC to highlight the stark inequality in research and investment in women's health, with a huge gap in investment, governance, and reporting mechanisms between the women's and men's health strategies. These new clauses would set up an inquiry into women's health outcomes and ensure that average waiting times for women's health conditions do not exceed the average waiting times for wider elective treatment. The crisis in our maternity care is a national shame and reveals a systemic neglect of the safety of women and their babies over many, many years.

However, this is indicative of even wider concerns for patient safety, which I urge the Secretary of State to address in this bill and will discuss in more detail tomorrow. If the government is serious about using this bill to improve our NHS, it must invest time and money in the front and back doors of the NHS rather than structural reorganizations.

05:23:49 - 05:26:31

Daniel Francis

I declare my interest as chair of both the APPGs for disability equipment and wheelchair users, and as the parent of a wheelchair user. I know just how important getting these services right is for disabled people and their families, and the consequences and long-term impacts when it goes wrong. The evidence gathered by the APPG for access to disability equipment report last year found that one in three equipment users who responded are waiting significant times for equipment, with one in five waiting over two months, and 55% stating they don't have the equipment they need for their long-term needs. At a time when we're rightly focused on reducing waitlists and improving patient flow, it makes little sense for somebody to remain in a hospital bed simply because the equipment they need to return home has not arrived. And 74% of professionals and equipment providers report awareness of patients experienced delayed hospital discharge because essential equipment was not available at home, increasing pressure on hospital beds and placing further strain on services.

And the system is fragmented, inconsistent, and lacks sufficient accountability and national oversight. My amendments would introduce two things that the system lacks: a clear expectation about how long people would wait, with clear set timelines and accountability when things go wrong, and they'd also ensure that patients have a clear pathway for hospital discharge. Within amendment 32 would require ICBs to provide community equipment and wheelchair services within 18 weeks of the date that a person's assessed. And I know from my own experience that in my daughter's case, when she was eight, on two occasions that 18-week deadline was missed, and she was without an adequate wheelchair for 21 months. It's the case that these issues simply shunt costs to elsewhere in the NHS.

The all-party group for wheelchair users has heard evidence from consultants within the NHS about the quality of assessment, interventions, and aftercare. We've heard how delays lead to children receiving a wheelchair that is no longer fit for purpose by the time they receive it. And the following are quotes we heard. There is the additional care to consider as well: poor equipment provision leads to pressure sores, increase in scoliosis, all of which have a wider impact on the sector. In terms of inequity of care, when asked for information, it's always the same eight or 10 ICBs who respond.

The ones who don't are probably the ones we should worry about. And there's a level of bureaucracy in NHS that stops things happening. Disability is not considered as important as other things in health parameters. And we know the data that is available shows that within ICBs, that wheelchair deadline is being missed by many ICBs: 29% of ICBs aren't meeting the deadline for over 25% of wheelchairs within that 18 weeks.

05:26:31 - 05:26:33

Danny Beales

Will he give way on that point?

05:26:34 - 05:27:07

Danny Beales

I thank my right honourable friend for my honourable friend for giving way and for the work he's done on the APPG. He is a real champion for this issue. AJM, who are the contractor in my constituency, have similar levels of failure that he is raising today: people left for months, sometimes six months, without a wheelchair, bedbound, unable to get out the house as a result. Does he agree with me that ICBs seem completely at sea with managing this issue, totally unaccountable, and don't we need much tougher measures such as those he suggests to hold them to account?

05:27:07 - 05:29:18

Daniel Francis

Thank you, and I completely agree with my honourable friend from Uxbridge. There is, as I'll come to in a moment, an inconsistent set of data from across the country, not just between ICBs, but in the case from my constituency and my honourable friend over there from Eltham, within those neighbouring London boroughs, for instance, the same ICB, there is a different framework within each borough. I'm working with support of the Children's Commissioner for my amendment, who said across the country, children wait far too long for the right equipment that's essential for daily life.

In recent research on children experiencing delayed discharge from hospital, the office was told that delays in getting equipment and having equipment serviced had led to children being stuck in hospital away from family, friends and school. And as I say, the postcode lottery doesn't just exist across the country, I know a number of ICBs elsewhere in the country where there are significant issues, but that ICB, that postcode lottery exists within ICBs. So in my part of South East London, it can mean that one patient can be discharged while a patient in the same hospital with the same condition living on the opposite side of the road can't because a borough boundary runs through the road and there are different contractual arrangements between different London boroughs within the same ICB. And again, I know first-hand that two children in the same school class can have completely different service standards for their wheelchair because one lives in one London borough while the other lives in a neighbouring borough, still within the ICB. I'd also like to briefly speak to amendment from my honourable friend from Thurrock, New Clause 85.

Like myself, she is the parent of a disabled child and we have fought these issues for many years, both as parents but also on behalf of our constituents. I know in my case in London Borough of Bexley, when we had that outcome of systemic failings from Ofsted in our SEND provision, we could hold our local authority to account but we could not properly hold our ICB to account. The judgment was issued against the council, not the ICB, and there is more we need to do in those areas.

05:29:18 - 05:29:20

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Will my honourable friend give way?

05:29:21 - 05:29:33

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

I thank my honourable friend for the powerful speech he's giving and bringing his personal experience. The EHCP, I'm sure he'll agree with me, has the letter H in which stands for health and we need to see the health service doing its part, does he agree with me?

05:29:33 - 05:30:37

Daniel Francis

I absolutely do agree. And I've had to sit there unfortunately as a Labour councillor back then, as leader of the Labour opposition, married to a SENCO employed by the local authority, employing my own professionals to get through this process to ensure that that health aspect was upheld. It's absolutely abhorrent and for many parents who don't have that opportunity and that insight that my wife and I had, they are left in a place where they cannot ensure that accountability is there for their child. And as I say, when my borough went through that judgment of systemic failings, that really what did come to the fore. So I would be grateful later on if the Minister or Secretary of State could outline on my amendments and on my honourable friend's amendments how it intends to address those with my amendments, how it intends to ensure we deliver those basic objectives, clear expectations for how long disabled people should wait for consistent standards and meaningful accountability for ICBs when services fall short.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:30:37 - 05:33:17

Jeremy Hunt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to start by thanking the Minister for the emphasis the Bill places on a single patient record, which is something where, despite many problems in NHS care, this is actually an area where the NHS is a world leader. But putting a single patient record on the right legal footing, making it possible to share data with proper governance, actually gives the NHS an opportunity to become a world leader in AI and also the opportunity to transform care for patients. So that has my full support. I speak in support of New Clause 25 because I am worried that the biggest structural reform in this Bill is the abolition of NHS England, but there are other structural reforms that are not in the Bill that would have a much bigger impact on patient care.

And New Clause 25 is about continuity of care, particularly in general practice and maternity. It is now very clear to many people that the abolition of the old GP list system in the 2004 contract changes was a huge mistake.

In fact, restoring the system where GPs have their own patients was part of the Labour manifesto. So I think it's something that the government understands, but it isn't in this bill. A study in Norway, published in the British Journal of General Practice in 2022, over 4 million patients showed that patients who have their own doctor for more than 15 years are 30% less likely to need out-of-hours care, 28% less likely to need hospital care, and 25% less likely to die. Why is that? Because patients who know their GP, GPs who know their patients, are less likely to make mistakes, they're more likely to give an accurate diagnosis, and they are going to better calibrate risk because they will have situational awareness of a patient and their families.

And the experience of patients, of course, is infinitely better when they're dealing with a GP who they know. Instead of which, we have moved to a system in which many GP surgeries effectively operate like call centres, and you will contact a GP and you may never see that GP again. It's exactly the same when you call 111 if you get put through to a clinician. And contacting a GP in the NHS should never be like calling an Uber driver who you never see again. I'm happy to give way.

05:33:17 - 05:33:51

Speaker 280

I'm grateful to my right honourable friend and for colleagues opposite who did have that in their manifesto, they might want to reflect how much commitment, more, much more commitment do we have to constituents because they are our constituents rather than if we were sharing constituents on a day-to-day basis. We often go out of our way, we hope to, to look after our constituents because of that sense of ownership, that sense of obligation. And it's only because we're allocated those people and they are our responsibility that we go to that extra extent. Why would doctors not be the same and can colleagues not see the sense of what my right honourable friend is saying?

05:33:51 - 05:36:52

Jeremy Hunt

My honourable friend is speaking wise and of course this is actually not just about massively improving care for patients, it's also about improving motivation for doctors. And GPs are amongst the most demoralised groups within the NHS. There's a GP surgery in Horfield in the Bristol area which kept the old GP list system, as in fact 10% of surgeries have done. And when I was chairing the Health and Social Care Select Committee, I interviewed this doctor, Dr Lee. And he said that because 60%, around 60% of the patients they see every day are their own patients, because they've kept this system, they don't have any problem with GP retention.

The GPs who go to work there are happy because they're seeing people that they know. So this would also be transformative for morale inside general practice. Now, people might very reasonably say, well, you were in that job rather a long time, why didn't you do it? To which I want to share with the House a little secret, which is that I did actually try to do this. I changed the GP contract in 2015 so that every NHS patient in England has a named accountable clinician.

Unfortunately, I was outfoxed by the system because as a result of that change, on every electronic patient record, every one of us here will have a named accountable GP on the record, but absolutely nothing else changed. And the NHS continued with the system as it had done before.

Now this is a real opportunity to transform care, transform life for GPs, transform life for patients. And the same principle applies to maternity care, where we know with inquiry after inquiry that despite reams of recommendations, things have not been getting better. If every mum, the moment she knew she was pregnant, was told this is the team who are going to be responsible for the safe delivery of your baby, antenatal, birthing and postnatal, we would restore that personal connection to maternity care, which is the one of the biggest issues that comes from so many mothers who say they feel anonymous and not listened to in the system. The NHS at its best delivers absolutely incredible care. And I have three wonderful children who exist because of amazing NHS care.

But at its worst, it turns patients into numbers. It turns human suffering into box ticking. Now lots of things are necessary to turn that around, but one of the biggest things is restoring continuity of care so that every patient always knows who the doctor is who's responsible for their care. And that's why I urge the government, if it's not going to be in this bill, to consider how to restore continuity of care in both general practice and maternity.

05:36:52 - 05:41:34

Navendu Mishra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I say there is lots in this bill that is very positive, but couple of local issues that I want to raise include my local hospital of Stepping Hill. I want to thank the minister for meeting with me and my neighbor from Hazel Grove constituency to discuss Stepping Hill Hospital, because Stepping Hill is at the heart of healthcare provision in my town of Stockport. It serves around half a million patients a year and is one of the four specialist hub centers for emergency and high-risk general surgery in Greater Manchester. Now I appreciate that after 14 years of austerity imposed by the coalition government of Liberal Democrats and Conservatives and subsequent Conservative governments, it has taken its toll on the NHS and the Labour government is trying to fix things over the last two years, but Stepping Hill is a huge issue locally.

I have previously raised the condition of the hospital a number of times in this chamber, and a number of constituents frequently get in touch with me about the state of Stepping Hill. At one point, Stepping Hill was reported to be delivering only 51% of its usual outpatient services, which is simply not good enough. The staff do an amazing job, it has an amazing set of volunteers that support the hospital Stepping Hill, but so much more needs to be done. Now the hospital is, the backlog for repairs at the hospital is estimated at around 138 million pounds. The government has allocated 2.5 million pounds for targeted essential repairs for fire safety and other works, and the foundation trust has also been allocated 75 million pounds by this government over the next four years.

This is a positive step, but can I urge the minister to go a bit further in terms of Stepping Hill Hospital in Stockport, Greater Manchester. The second issue I want to raise is IVF funded treatment, NHS IVF funded treatment. And the reason I raise this, I have also raised this issue previously, is we have a situation where we live in a country where we have a postcode lottery in terms of NHS funding for your IVF treatment, and it shouldn't be the case. Now I did sign NC104 tabled by the right honorable member for Stone, which was about NHS funded IVF in line with NICE guidelines. And once again, sadly, a number of parents in my constituency have been in touch with me about this issue.

Sadly, NHS Greater Manchester ICB has taken a step to reduce the provision, and they did conduct a consultation a few months ago, and 74% of respondents either disagreed or completely disagreed with the proposed one-plus cycle offer.

I have tabled a Freedom of Information request to Greater Manchester ICB in terms of the cost and resources that went into this consultation, because they did the consultation and then they just proceeded to reduce the provision. And this disproportionately impacts low-income women, people who live in poorer backgrounds, and it's simply not good enough. Greater Manchester has a population of almost 3 million people, and this is a regressive step. So I think the government needs to do a lot better in terms of mandating legal access to NHS-funded IVF. Now, current data from fertility units in the North East shows us that only two areas where ICB funds three full rounds of IVF treatment show that the chance of having a baby for a woman under the age of 40 after three cycles of treatment is 70%, whereas people who get access to one cycle is just 46%.

In England, we need standardization of IVF treatment. Can I also add my support to NC108, which has been tabled by my good friend from Liverpool West Derby? I won't say much on this because I have spoken on three separate occasions in Westminster Hall and this chamber about data hygiene and safety, and I have had a very large volume of correspondence from constituents on this issue. Many people in Stockport are worried about foreign tech firms having access to their sensitive personal medical records, and I think people need to have confidence that the NHS, the personal details, the data they provide the NHS won't be misused. So I'm supporting that NC108 from the honorable member from West Derby.

Now, can I just finish on the point that as I said earlier, in the last two years this government has achieved a lot, but we need to recognize that there is so much more to be done. I mean, Labour governments of course always fix things in the long run, but can I just ask the minister specifically in terms of Stepping Hill Hospital and IVF to go a bit further? Thank you.

05:41:35 - 05:45:15

Layla Moran

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to start by talking, taking up that theme of maternity, which has already been mentioned by a number of members, and to welcome the government's commitment to instating a maternity commissioner. I sit on the expert reference group, as what we're called, that feeds into the maternity and neonatal task force, and so I'm seeing how the government is trying to pull all of these different issues together. The committee has repeatedly heard across a number of inquiries how important this issue is, and we do need someone who is independent of government who is going to be able to knit it all together. Our Black Maternal Health report heard how workforce shortages are undermining efforts to improve maternity care.

Data is lacking and there's a culture where women, particularly Black women, are not listened to. Investment and training are needed to tackle this. The First 1000 Days report found that the UK has some of the worst early years health outcomes in Europe, including in infant mortality, and we've called for proper targets for early years professionals in the long-lost workforce plan. As an aside, where is the workforce plan? I'd love to see it.

Locally, however, Oxford University Hospitals that provides maternity care for my residents and indeed my own family, baby took first steps this weekend, it was a momentous occasion, finally. But I also reflect, and very genuinely, there are people in my NCT class who did not have as good experience as we did, and have been proactively contacted by the hospital to have an apology given and an explanation for their awful traumatic birth.

They didn't even complain. And this is as a result of in part the CQC inspections but I think more importantly the Amos inspection or inclusion of OUH and the John Radcliffe in her report. So I toured it this summer again and heard specifically from trust leaders and also the midwives. They are doing everything that they can to respond to all the criticisms that are being levelled at them by families. But they did tell me that there is only so much that they can do without a new building.

Amos's own report said the maternity and neonatal units sit across multiple floors. We saw delivery suites that don't have windows, that were cold, small and cramped and had pillars in the middle of them affecting where equipment could be placed. A large number of them don't have en suites. Can you imagine what that must be like to be giving birth in those rooms? So as the government knits together its action plan, can I please beg them to not forget investment and in particular capital investment when they are empowering the commissioner to do their good work.

Now I want to move to a few of the other amendments. I support the work to tackle health inequalities in amendments new clause 90 and 91. Over and over again we hear as a committee how if we want to unlock productivity in the NHS, that is where we need to focus. And I also support the campaign from my honourable friend the member for Newton Abbot and his cross-party amendment new clause 34 which echoes the finding of my committee that the government really needs to think again when it comes to Palantir and instead supercharge the capability of UK-based companies instead.

05:45:15 - 05:45:36

Martin Wrigley

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. On that very point, does she agree with me that the recent NHS cost-benefit analysis showing the Palantir project will cost 1.1 billion pounds and deliver benefits of 800 million pounds, a net loss of 300 million pounds for the NHS, underlines the fact it needs to be got rid of now?

05:45:36 - 05:47:27

Layla Moran

I thank him for his intervention. He's been a doughty campaigner on this and as has other members on the committee including the member for Chelsea and Fulham. We also know the data is based on much of the data being taken from Chelsea and Westminster Hospital and not much else across the country. We have a lot of questions about that particular contract and hence why we came to that very same conclusion. But I would primarily urge the government to please consider the new clause 85 in the name of the honourable member for Thurrock's name, which is about imposing duties on ICBs in delivering the EHCPs.

We did a round table in my constituency to give evidence for our own hearing on this. This was based by the way on a recommendation that came out of the Education Select Committee's work on EHCPs. And so we decided to take up the H bit. In that round table I heard movingly from families who kept saying things like everything is a battle. One child, Stefan, suffers from multiple epiphyseal dysplasia which affects his hips.

He needs support to get around. He's very, very bright. He desperately wants to learn. His mother was there and told me how against school policy he is allowed exceptionally to keep a phone on him. Why?

Because there is no one that the school can employ to make sure that he can be wheeled from class to class. So instead what happens, and you know mother and school have done everything they possibly can, is he keeps a phone in his pocket and he rings up mum so that she can come from home and deliver him to his next class. This is the kind of thing that ridiculously goes to tribunal and then those tribunals cannot hold the ICBs to the same level of accountability as local authorities. The whole thing is nonsensical. So the title I will of course give way.

05:47:27 - 05:47:48

Peter Swallow

I thank her for giving way.

I just wanted to agree with the point that she is making around this and just add the voice of a member of the Education Select Committee and the findings of the Education Select Committee's report, which equally found that we have to have a system where ICBs can be held to account for delivering on EHCP plans.

05:47:48 - 05:48:33

Layla Moran

Grateful to him and the work of that committee. We're doing work together right now on children's mental health, and so this theme I'm sure we will continue to pursue. But the point around this was also that the impact wasn't just on that child. It was on the mother who couldn't work. It was on the distress that they had to battle the system.

The mental health of both parents was being affected. This doesn't need to be this way, and I genuinely believe that accountability is part of the answer. So my plea to the government in ending is simply to say it is past time that the H part of EHCPs came into a statutory footing, and I urge the House to support new clause 85.

05:48:33 - 05:48:36

Speaker 282

Danny Beales.

05:48:36 - 05:50:43

Danny Beales

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's much to support as part of this bill, and I support its ambition to enable many of the provisions of the Welcome Ten Year Plan for the NHS. The plan is the right one, the three shifts are correct, and we do have to fundamentally reform the health system if we're to meet the modern health and care challenges we all see in our constituencies. To some extent, these challenges are not new, these ambitions are not new. We've seen similar initiatives before, but the systems, the structures, the bureaucracy, the siloed budgets push against change in the health sector.

They've hindered and reinforced these silos and made the same investment choices. They prevent digitalization, they've kept care in acute, and they've stopped joined-up working. So this bill could and should be a key lever to overcome them if we are to achieve those ambitions. I very much support the digital single patient record, a key ambition as part of the shift from analog to digital health. We've all heard from patients who have to tell their same story over and over and over again at every single health appointment, between care and health, between community and secondary care.

So the potential for a genuine single patient record could be transformational. We have, however, heard from pharmacy, from community mental health services, that for this to work, they have to have a seat at the table when designing that single patient record. So I do hope, whilst this bill enables the architecture, the delivery will fundamentally ensure that all of the health and care system are crucially part of the decision-making process about the design of the single patient record. Regarding the abolition of NHS England, again, I think the idea of streamlining bureaucracy at the center is a good one, delivering power and budgets and resources and decision-making power locally, again, is admirable. The success, however, of that will be that the right decisions are taken at the right scale, and I very much give way.

05:50:43 - 05:51:09

Ben Coleman

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. One of the concerns I have about the changes and the abolition of NHS England is that at the moment, highly specialized services, which are there's only 79 of them in the country that treat the rarest and most complex conditions, currently sit directly with NHS England. And it isn't clear exactly whether or not these will continue to be commissioned centrally, and does he think it would be helpful if we had clarification from the minister on that?

05:51:09 - 05:52:35

Danny Beales

I thank him for that contribution. And having worked in neonatal care services and the NHS for 10 years in areas of specialized services, one of the benefits of NHS England was bringing together highly specialized services and ensuring consistent service specifications and uplifting the quality and availability of care across the country.

So I do hope that when we make decisions about which specialized services will be devolved to ICBs, consideration will be very much given to that point. Equally we've heard from national population health programs like the diabetes prevention program, it's been a huge success. We can't lose the benefits of of scale of public health initiatives like vaccinations and prevention programs as we make those final decisions about the levels of decision and I would welcome the minister's thoughts and reflections on on that. The importance as well of integrated working, we do have to as I say blend budgets, bring together decision makers across current silo divides. And in that spirit I very much welcome the change through government amendment 60 to give local authorities a seat back at the table.

We need a bigger voice for public health and for social care in health decision makings, not less. So I very much thank the minister and the government for moving on that and listening to the health committee. The NHS Alliance's view is that this is not enough, they would like to see a reciprocal duty to collaborate, which I think is an interesting one, but I do think this is an important start. Very much happy to do so.

05:52:35 - 05:53:02

Anna Dixon

Thank my honorable friend for giving way and congratulate him and others in the select committee who did the work around strengthening local authority representation on the integrated care board. But would he agree with me and the sentiments of my new clause amendment which are really saying that we need to do a stronger duty to cooperate both within the NHS and between the NHS and local authorities.

05:53:02 - 05:56:18

Danny Beales

Thank you very much for the contribution. She might have actually read my speech, I was about to turn to her to my honorable friend for Shipley's amendments and and the the the suggestion around reporting on on integrating health and social care. I think they're interesting ideas, I think they have a great deal of merit. I hope the minister will outline in her response the government's approach, particularly with the ongoing Casey review to enabling more progress on integration of health and social care. Turning specifically to inequalities, we've had it mentioned already in the debate and one of the government's key ambitions obviously is growth in every postcode, also good health in every postcode.

And time after time again we see disproportionality, inequalities unfortunately seemingly hardwired into our health system. Well to change that we are going to have to do something differently and and I do welcome my honorable friend from Stoke-on-Trent's amendments N90 and N91 which haven't been unfortunately selected. But I think they do definitely reinforce the government's 10-year plan commitment to halve the gap in healthy life expectancy between the richest and poorest regions and to raise the healthiest generation of children ever. Unfortunately we have moved against those in the last 10 years and we will have to do something differently to bridge that gap. In my own constituency from north to south there is a huge divide in the quality of health and of outcomes based on postcode and that must change.

And whilst the government is not minded to to accept these amendments, I would very much note that the minister is passionate about inequalities and the bill does require neighborhood health plans to be developed, which I think is an important new measure when responding to neighborhood health needs. And preparing those plans, the responsible local authority and partner ICB must have regard for guidance issued by the Secretary of State. So I hope the minister may explore using this guidance to ensure that neighborhood health plans when they are developed specifically must address inequalities between neighborhoods. And finally turning to another major challenge the government is rightly grappling with, the SEND system. I'd just like to thank my honorable friend and fellow member of the Health and Social Care Select Committee, the member for Thurrock and her amendment NC85 which does seek to address this chasm between the education and the health system.

And while this is fundamentally a health bill, I think it's right to ask the question what more the health system could and should be doing. We do know as the chair of the committee's rightly said already when we looked at EHCPs, the H is far far from present. The decision makers are not required to come round the table, the specialists are not provided. In my own constituency I've been to specialist schools where nursing provision isn't there so people miss school days, the specialist transport isn't there so people can't even get school transport because it doesn't have the proper health knowledge of of the bus drivers.

Quite clearly, we do have to have an education and health response. So I hope the minister will in her closing remarks address how if this bill isn't the right mechanism, how the future SEND reforms may pick this up and how the Department of Health will contribute to that. Madam Deputy Speaker, to conclude, there is a great deal to support in this health bill. It is a major step forward, particularly around digital healthcare, giving people control of their records and joined-up care. And I hope the government will continue to drive forward reform of our health system.

05:56:18 - 05:56:20

Speaker 285

Sir Gavin Williamson.

05:56:20 - 06:01:14

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If we all think about a memory, we often have quite a common memory that is so incredibly important, and that is holding our child for the very first time, and how important and how special that is. But sadly, there are so many people up and down this country that aren't able to have that memory because they're having difficulty in having children. In 2004, the National Institute of Clinical Excellence recommended a way forward on IVF, and that was to give all a minimum three cycles of IVF treatment. This was something that they set out 22 years ago.

It's something that you would hope that actually over time all ICBs would have moved towards delivering. Sadly, it's something that people have actually moved away from. And it's not because it's an issue that has got easier or better or is impacting less people. The reality is it's an issue that has got more difficult, impacting more people, meaning that more people are not going to have that amazing joy of holding their own child. I would ask the minister to look at new clause 104 that has been tabled in my name along with the support of 16 others from across this house.

The issue of people not being able to have children is growing. Male fertility has been collapsing over the last few decades. As people deal with greater pressures in order to buy their own home, they're having children later in life as against earlier in life. But we have a postcode lottery. There are only two ICBs across the country that offer the NICE recommendation of three cycles.

And in fact, as we've already heard in Manchester, that has actually been what was offered has been decreased. That has also been the case in Cheshire and Merseyside as well. In Staffordshire, where I represent, you're not even entitled to one full cycle of IVF, meaning that unless you're incredibly rich, you are condemned to probably never being able to have children.

This, Madam Deputy Speaker, is just not right. And I urge the Minister to be proactive in looking at how this can be addressed. We face a demographic issue in this country, with a falling birth rate, with less than 600,000 babies born in this country last year, and that is only going to get worse. It is sad that the NHS isn't prioritising this, and I understand the pressures that ICBs operate under. And it's maybe always seen that actually it's an easy no-cost option to deprive people of the ability to have a child.

But for those people who desperately spend their whole life doing everything they can, remortgaging their homes, begging for money from family and friends in order to have a cycle of IVF, it is destroying them. There is no humanity in this system, and I urge the Minister to look at clause 104 to give the opportunity to have families have the opportunity, the most greatest blessing that they can have, to hold their own child. And I would urge the Minister to take action as against just ignoring something that is so important to so many.

06:01:14 - 06:02:00

Jennifer Craft

Madam Deputy Speaker, I strongly welcome this landmark bill, which will protect and strengthen our health service for decades to come. But for children with special educational needs and disabilities, who are disproportionately impacted by not getting the healthcare they need, I believe that this bill should go further. That is why I have tabled new clause 85, which seeks to address a fundamental imbalance in the provision of health services for disabled children and young people. Currently, the statutory duty to deliver education, health and care plans, the legal mechanism by which children with special educational needs and disabilities can receive support, sits entirely with local authorities.

06:02:00 - 06:02:22

Jim Shannon

Could I commend the honourable lady for all her endeavours in this particular subject matter, and does she share my concern that when a child is diagnosed with cancer, parents are instantly overwhelmed by medical jargon, by appointments and by sheer panic? And does the honourable lady agree the government and the Minister should accept the common sense duty to ensure no family faces those critical first two weeks completely alone?

06:02:22 - 06:04:12

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, and I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention, and he raises a very good point about the impact of a childhood illness not only on the child but on the family themselves. And I very much do agree that support for families is absolutely crucial. They are part of the care team, in fact, for children when they are unwell, and that acknowledgement is something that very much needs to be strengthened and taken forward. As I was saying, the statutory duty to deliver EHCPs sits solely in with local authorities. And in practice, this means that councils are the only body that can be held legally responsible for providing the service a disabled child needs to access education.

And this includes, for example, health services like occupational or speech and language therapy. Health bodies are not subject to that same requirement. And through my work as a member of the Health and Social Care Committee, as a constituency MP, and as a parent of a disabled child, I know that this too often means that health are just not at the table when it comes to delivering services for children with special educational needs and disability.

There is a fundamental lack of accountability in this system. And in practice this can lead local authorities or families to have to procure privately, which can drive shortages in the NHS workforce, or it means that provision is substandard or non-existent. My constituent's son Haider, for example, has an EHCP which outlines his need for speech and language therapy to fully access education. And despite his mother's mother Kyla's relentless efforts, this support was not delivered for months. Kyla tells me she has been forced to watch while Haider has become withdrawn, anxious, and isolated.

And my constituent Elizabeth has a similar story. She's been fighting to get occupational and physical therapy for her son William, but significant delays securing assessments from healthcare professionals have resulted in inaccurate, unhelpful support arrangements.

06:04:12 - 06:04:13

Will my honourable friend give way?

06:04:14 - 06:04:43

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

I thank my honourable friend for a powerful speech and for all the work that she does on this. It is particularly difficult with children when there's these long waiting times because a child's life is is so is so attenuated. So if you're waiting 18 months, that's one and a half, two school years. And I sorry, if if the parent is waiting. Does my honourable friend agree with me that actually as key to prevention is getting these things dealt with as quickly as possible?

06:04:43 - 06:05:26

Jennifer Craft

I completely agree with my honourable friend and I thank him for his intervention. And the example I was just giving about my constituent Elizabeth and her son William, his lack of early intervention has meant that he has missed countless hours and days and weeks of schooling at a really, really critical point in his development. And I met another woman last week at a drop-in that I hosted called Annika. Her daughter Winnie has cerebral palsy and an EHCP that clearly states she requires a physiotherapist. But the family have been forced to arrange this for themselves.

But there are countless other families in this situation. I think every single member in this house has cases from their own constituency. And and it's just not good enough. And evidence suggests...

06:05:26 - 06:05:59

Speaker 280

I thank the honourable lady, she is giving a most powerful speech and we will all have experienced the frustration of parents with child with an EHCP not at the health element. Does she share my concern that the abolition of Healthwatch might further remove one of the few elements that actually externally and independently marks the homework of the NHS and that we're moving to a situation where it'll be the NHS itself and ministers who collect the data and mark their own homework and we'll lose yet another of the very few tools that a parent has who's frustrated to hold the system to account.

06:05:59 - 06:09:09

Jennifer Craft

I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention and look I do agree that there needs to be better accountability in the health service. It currently doesn't work and the mechanisms by which we can hold healthcare bodies to account are few and far between. And it is most acutely felt, I believe, in paediatric care and in the special educational needs and disability system where a mechanism for holding public bodies already exists by EHCPs. I I believe that it falls entirely, the fact it falls entirely on local authorities is misguided because roughly about 50% of what a child needs in order to access education if they have an EHCP is rightly healthcare and that should be provided by a healthcare service. And there must be better accountability and transparency when that doesn't happen for parents and for their children.

And I know that parents themselves often have to go out of their way to spend on average 8 and a half thousand pound a year on their child's healthcare so that they can access education. I will not because I am going to run out of time but I do thank him. Roughly 40% of people have paid privately for therapies and that many are forced to fundraise for vital medical equipment their child is legally entitled to. And it's worth noting that beyond the direct costs, many parents are also forced to miss work because the right support is not available for their child to attend school. Around 40% report cutting back their hours and 35% have left the job market completely.

And before I became a Member of Parliament, I stopped work to become a full-time carer for my daughter. And I don't regret that choice for a second, but it was a difficult and sometimes lonely period. And like many parents, I hadn't anticipated just how hard it would be to secure basic support for my child, and to continue to this day to secure the basic healthcare support that she needs to support her education and her place at school. And I'm wearing this dragon today for her, and she will know why that is, and I won't share it with the House, but if she watches this, she'll see the dragon and it'll make her smile. But new clause 85 is intended to fix this inequality.

It will place a statutory duty on ICBs to deliver the health part of EHCPs. It matches the existing duty on local authorities. The fundamental concept that there must be a meaningful legal requirement on health services to deliver the support set out in EHCPs is critical. If we do not act, if we do not rightly demand that health services pull their weight, the status quo of young people missing out on education will continue. Plan SEND reforms, I'm afraid, will be doomed to failure.

Disabled children are no less worthy of a decent education than their peers, and no less capable of thriving in school, but we are denying them access to the tools they need to succeed. I'm grateful to the Health and Social Care and the Education Select Committees for their support, as well as the nearly 100 members across this House who put their name to this clause. I want to express my thanks to the charities involved in the centre for their continued campaigning efforts, and for the parents, the many, many parents who have contacted me. I sincerely hope the government will give this clause the attention it deserves, and if they can't bring it forward in total, will give a commitment for proper accountability.

06:09:09 - 06:11:06

Thomas Gordon

From after the next speaker, there'll be a four-minute time limit, but I will not reduce it further than that. Tom Gordon.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to start by welcoming the commitment from the Minister at the dispatch box about bringing forward a maternity commissioner, and thank my honourable friend, the member for North Shropshire, for her tireless campaigning on this issue. It's something that when I worked for her many years ago, the scandal at SaTH was something that I was all too aware of from sitting in on surgeries with her. And indeed, in my own constituency of Harrogate and Knaresborough today, I've ended up with tireless campaigners bringing those same issues to me when they've faced maternity issues at Leeds Hospital too. Turning to the amendments tabled in my name, first one is new clause 36, which would require the government to bring forward a formal transition strategy and report back to Parliament on what happens when NHS England is abolished.

This is a reason, the reason for this amendment is one of concern from families who've lost loved ones at the hands of TEWV, the mental health trust. They've said time and again that they're concerned that the delayed appointment of a chair to that inquiry is something they're really worried about as we see the largest changes to the health service in a generation, and they don't want that to be lost. So I press the Minister on whether that is something that she might be able to push forward or get her colleagues to do so. Turning to new clause 43, this would reduce inequalities when it comes to access to clinical research funding and trials. I've been working closely with Yorkshire Cancer Research based in my constituency in Harrogate on Hornbeam Park, and we know that across Yorkshire, clinical research trials and funding gets about a quarter of that received in London.

The logic follows that if those areas outside of London and the South East are getting less research funding, then inequalities will be struggled to be closed in those areas too. We know that cancer, I will give way.

06:11:06 - 06:11:33

Speaker 289

I'm grateful for the honourable member giving way, and he's touching on a point of health inequalities that I think is really, really important. Cancer cases are expected to rise by about 30% by 2040, and England already has fewer radiotherapy machines per head than comparable European countries. Weston-super-Mare doesn't even have one, despite being the size of the city of Bath.

Would he agree with me that that needs to come in conjunction with the rest of the investment that he's talking about?

06:11:33 - 06:13:02

Thomas Gordon

I thank the gentleman for his point and I completely agree with him. And as well, my colleague, the honorable member for Westmorland and Lonsdale, who's not here, but tirelessly is campaigning on radiotherapy and radiography as well. The point I was making around those health inequalities is that if we look at regions like Yorkshire, we have a high incidence of cancer and also poorer outcomes. So we need to close that funding gap to close those inequalities. New clause 61 and new clause 93, both in my name, pertain to NHS dentistry.

There were many other clauses that I also added my name to and support. New clause 61 would make sure that there was adequate provision of dental appointments in Harrogate and Knaresborough. In my constituency, we know over the last two years and across North Yorkshire as a whole, that the number of people who are having access to an NHS dentist appointment is down from 50% to just 37%. The issue when it arises at casework and surgeries is often precipitated through people who work in A&E telling me about the traumatic stories of people reaching A&E as a result of emergency dental care or lack of. And in particular, some harrowing stories that we've heard from local children about their inability to focus in school.

New clause 93 would require the Secretary of State to publish before Parliament a regular report on the state of NHS dentistry, including that unmet need, and also pay particular attention to workforce capacity and distribution.

06:13:02 - 06:13:26

Vikki Slade

I will give way.

I'm really grateful to the honorable member for giving way. In Dorset, we have lost 44 dentists in the last five years and there hasn't been a single new contract given for 10 years. Would he suggest that his new plan would reverse that to allow us to be able to see exactly where the gaps are in the system?

06:13:26 - 06:14:48

Thomas Gordon

I thank my honorable friend for her intervention and I agree that that is something that we do need to see and we do need to do, which is why I tabled this amendment to get the answer to some of those questions that not just constituents in my patch, but those in hers as well are asking us as members of Parliament. It's particularly frustrating that we're now into the second year of this Labour government and at the outset, the talk of dental contract reform was one that kept cropping up and we've seen little progress on that. So I press the minister on what more can be done to make sure that we get those gaps filled. Turning to new clause 121, I sit in Parliament as the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Diabetes. As was mentioned earlier by the honorable member for Uxbridge, there have been some fantastic care when it comes to diabetes and really world-leading practice.

This new clause would maintain existing national diabetes prevention, treatment, and audit programs, and we would want to see an explanation being brought forth from government about how we can see those continued with regular reports in Parliament. Overall, there have been a fantastic number of amendments tabled by colleagues from across the House. I hope the minister will pay attention to them and can provide us with some answers on them this evening and going forward.

06:14:48 - 06:18:30

Anna Dixon

Madam Deputy Speaker, I worked as a civil servant for the coalition government and saw firsthand some of the duplication and confusion that was caused when NHS England was set up. So I welcome this bill, the decision to abolish NHS England. But reversing the fragmentation caused by the Tories' failed reforms of the NHS will not on its own create a more integrated and joined-up service for patients and carers. And that's why, Madam Deputy Speaker, I've tabled new clause 106.

The Secretary of State to report to Parliament within six months of the Act passing on how well NHS bodies and local authorities are working together to integrate health and social care in England. Having worked in the health and care sector, I know how vital it is to have integrated services, and I know as an MP, and I'm sure others do and from personal experience, how devastating uncoordinated care can be for patients, for their families and for our NHS. One of my constituents, Ellery Carroll, was diagnosed with diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma, an inoperable brain tumour in September 2024. Very sadly, she died in May this year, just aged nine. Ellery and her parents, Fran and Christian, suffered in ways that are unimaginable, but it was a lack of cooperation between services that added to their suffering.

Just one example, for example, after going for an MRI scan at Great Ormond Street, Ellery had to endure a repeated scan at LGI in Leeds due to an inability to share results between hospitals, and I hope the single patient record that this bill also creates will help join up systems and reduce such problems. We see this disjointed care both within the NHS, between hospital and community services, but also between health and social care. Another constituent, Roger, in his 90s, had a fall and serious head injury last year. Again, after the acute hospital treatment in Leeds, there was a failure of the NHS to join up his care with Bradford social services, resulting in delays to his discharge. He developed infections in hospital and delirium, and after nine months of being moved from one hospital to another, despite his wife fighting to get him home with support, he died in hospital.

These, Madam Deputy Speaker, are the consequences when our health and care systems aren't integrated. It's also expensive. Around one in ten hospital beds in England are occupied by someone who doesn't need to be there, often again because community or social care are not available. We know that any reform of the NHS will ultimately fail unless we also reform adult social care, and that's why I welcome the priority given to this by the Prime Minister and the commitment he's made to bring forward the conclusion of the Casey Commission. But even if we build a National Care Service, which we must, there is a risk that if it doesn't work in sync with our National Health Service.

So it's essential we place very clear obligations on all parts of the NHS to cooperate and integrate with social care. So I would ask the Minister in her closing remarks to set out how she and the Secretary of State will monitor the impact of the Health Bill on integration and how they will ensure cooperation remains a critical priority for the NHS, not just on paper, not just in law, but in the way that we all experience health and care in a joined-up way. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:18:30 - 06:18:31

Steve Barclay.

06:18:31 - 06:21:19

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I rise to speak to clause one on the abolition of NHS England and clause six on promoting innovation. And what has characterised the first of those has been an announcement without any clear plan, and that is what has driven the cost and confusion that a number of members across the House have spoken of. And for those in any doubt about that, they can just look at NHS England's own accounts. The 25-26 annual accounts show the costs have already gone up by more than a hundred million pounds above what was forecast and now sit at above half a billion pounds.

I don't recall seeing that on election leaflets. And indeed, just six directors at NHS England have been paid over eight hundred thousand pounds. So that points to the costs. And sometimes these big figures are hard for constituents to get their heads around. So just to localise it for my own constituency, in terms of the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough ICB alone has paid out fourteen million pounds in redundancy last year and has merged with a number of other ICBs to form the Eastern Central ICB.

And yet we now hear from government that they should align with metro mayors, which means going back to exactly what they were before, the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough ICB.

And that's just one of many confusions around this announcement. The member for North Shropshire spoke about confusion over the timetable, what was described to the media as now an impossible timetable. We have also reports this weekend in the media in terms of the destination of staff in NHS England. Can they actually go into the department or will another body be set up because of some of the pay disparity between the two? And this is more than, well, around 18 months on from the actual announcement.

And indeed this confusion seems to extend to government itself because they seem unable to answer pretty straightforward written parliamentary questions. Indeed, just to give, given the time limit, just to give a few examples, I asked how many people have been hired to NHS England since the announcement of its abolition. Not least given the huge cost, over half a billion pounds in voluntary redundancy. Despite the deadline being passed, the minister hasn't answered the question. Yet we know from another written parliamentary question more than a thousand jobs have been advertised.

So it's relevant to know in an organization that's paying people to leave, how many people they are then hiring. I also asked how many people have accepted voluntary redundancy. Again, a written parliamentary question that's passed its deadline and not being answered. So this process is characterized by a lack of transparency. Of course I give way.

06:21:19 - 06:21:56

Speaker 280

Grateful to my right honorable friend who's giving a typically punchy speech. Does he agree with me that every signal is that this has not been thought through? The very fact they've conceded on the fact, oh we're going to have local government coming back on board. How could you conceive of health and social care without local government being engaged? But on every front it looks as if they haven't thought it through and they are abolishing everything from the safety inspectorate to Healthwatch.

And we have a government which is out of control, spending tens of billions if not hundreds of millions on redundancies with no clear end destination in view and wasting a huge opportunity.

06:21:56 - 06:24:12

Paul Stephen Barclay

Well my right friend is absolutely right. They're spending millions of pounds. There isn't a plan. It was announced without working that out. It came as a surprise to many within the system.

It's had a chilling effect on many decisions. And you can just see that this isn't isolated. Just today we had the complete shambles of local government reorganization where on the last day before summer recess the Secretary of State rushed to the House to push through an announcement that the new Secretary of State today is then reversing on, whilst the Chief Secretary is then contradicting her by saying actually they want to have a higher legal appetite in terms of risk and they want to have fewer consultations. So there's just this confusion across departments. And actually the issues around clause one, which a number of members have spoken to, give an illustration of that.

But given the time limit, let me also just turn to clause six. And you know, I don't doubt for a minute that the health minister, the Secretary of State, anyone in the department doesn't want to promote innovation. I know the right honorable friend, my right honorable friend the member for Godalming and Ash spoke a lot about this in his book about capital to revenue switches and the pressure that takes away from innovation. And I used to have a wry smile when I was health secretary at the battles I had with him when I was being pushed by the Treasury to do exactly the same thing. The issue is not the lack of will.

The issue is the alignment between procurement, regulation and also the clinical leadership particularly in the colleges and the ability to scale innovation. It's not about having more ministerial pilots.

And finally, just because I'm almost out of time, can I just pick up on the chair of the Health Select Committee's very good points around data. My frustration when I was in the department was often I had to go on dashboards that were open source to get information that should have been available to me as a minister, and I suspect the same is still the case in the department. We should make data dashboards a common theme. If you look at the CSV files that the department publish, they're extremely difficult to access. Make data more transparent.

It will help the debate in this Parliament, and I dare say it'll help ministers get more support.

06:24:12 - 06:26:24

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Minister for this bill, and I want to put on record that I'm the chair of the Sickle Cell and Thalassaemia APPG, and I'm speaking to new clause 162. It is well known that the NHS commissions specialised services unevenly across England, and I'm confident that this government's ambition is to end the postcode lottery of specialised services, and I would like to hear more about this. New clause 162 is designed to do something very simple. It is designed to ensure that Parliament can identify where inequalities exist, measure where they are improving, and hold the Secretary of State to account when they are not.

Let me make the case through the experience of people who live with sickle cell. Sickle cell disorder is the fastest growing serious genetic condition in England. It causes episodes of serious chronic pain, spasms, and a crisis that will continue if left untreated. It can damage organs and frequently requires hospital care. When a crisis strikes, patients have to attend A&E, wait for hours, often only to be seen by medical staff who may have little or no familiarity with their condition.

Due to past experiences, many sufferers do not trust the NHS to meet their needs, and stories of sufferers who have died in hospital due to complications, such as Evan Nathan Smith, are well known. In 2021, the No One Listens report demonstrated that people with sickle cell need to be listened to. That report prompted NHS England to act. It initiated the Sickle Cell and Thalassaemia Quality Improvement Programme, and from that programme came seven pilot emergency department bypass units. They are dedicated facilities that allow sickle cell patients to avoid A&E and receive immediate care to bring that crisis under control.

This service works. But here is the problem that brings me to this new clause. When the APPG met last week, we heard from stakeholders that this progress is indeed fragile. There are only seven bypass units across the country, and with the transfer of commissioning responsibilities under this bill, there is a real and legitimate fear that what has been built and just begun will not be protected to continue.

06:26:24 - 06:26:58

Ben Coleman

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way. I was also a member of the APPG and was also at that meeting, and in the Health Select Committee we raised this very point that you have these short-term pilots and we managed to get an extra year's funding. I have to say, and I will say this as the person I am, I feel that if this was a problem which affected white people predominantly, not black people, it would be taken a lot more seriously. And I think that the government needs to reflect on that when it comes to deciding whether or not it wishes to accept this amendment and whether or not it wishes to give sickle cell sufferers the full support that they need and are not sufficiently getting.

06:26:58 - 06:28:45

Janet Jessica Daby

I absolutely thank my honourable friend. He couldn't have said that more clearly. It is absolutely about inequalities within the health service, and he has explained that and expressed that extremely well. And I know, like myself, he will continue to advocate on behalf of ethnic minority and diverse people. This new clause calls for the Secretary of State to do two things.

First, to produce an annual report laid before Parliament on the performance of specialised services against national standards. And second, to ensure the regular publication of data on quality and outcomes, the kind of information currently captured in the specialised services quality dashboard, which NHS England has maintained on a non-statutory basis.

Without legislation, those dashboards could quietly disappear when NHS England does, and this indeed must not happen. The new clause would make their continuation or something equivalent a legal requirement. I want to be clear about the modesty of this ask. We're not asking the government to build new services. We're not asking the government to ringfence budgets.

We're not asking the government to second-guess local commissioning decisions. We're asking them to measure, to publish, and to report. We're asking for the basic accountability for patients with rare conditions. We're asking for geographically dispersed people, predominantly from black and minority ethnic backgrounds, to have services that work. Madam Deputy Speaker, the patients who rely on specialised services are often marginalised twice over, once by their condition and again by a system that does not always see them clearly.

The new clause would require the Secretary of State to identify and to report back to this House what they find. I urge the government to take seriously the new clause and to respond appropriately.

06:28:45 - 06:29:38

Steffan Aquarone

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Amendment 19 closes a dangerous gap in this bill and commands support of members on both sides of the House. It's right that clause 4 calls for the Health Secretary to reduce inequality of access to health services, but the bill must explicitly cover rural and coastal health inequalities or else less densely populated communities will always lose. At face value, it makes sense to measure success by the greatest number helped, but in the long run, it's a false economy. Delayed diagnosis and treatment ultimately cost the NHS more.

It's a little bit like access to high-speed broadband, Madam Deputy Speaker. We rolled out the first phase to places where the most people could be connected, and that rewarded the government and providers with some impressive-sounding numbers while disguising failure in the margins. Rural and coastal communities are literally and politically at the end of the line and are therefore reached last.

06:29:38 - 06:30:13

Joanne Sarah Dyke

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. As you'll know, the Chief Medical Officer, the rural health report is due later this year. Rural health can't be seen as an afterthought. This is why I tabled new clause 120, which would create a farmer-friendly general practice scheme, similar to that to the veteran-friendly accreditation scheme. It would recognise GPs who proactively reach isolated farming communities.

So does my honourable friend agree that the government must treat the rural health report's recommendations as a genuine test of action, not just warm words?

06:30:13 - 06:33:12

Steffan Aquarone

I thank her for the intervention and I absolutely agree. And to that end, in order to achieve genuine equality of access, the government must go outside-in, Madam Deputy Speaker. That is to design provision around the hardest places to serve. She gives a great example, then work inwards from there. If Australia can effectively serve communities living in remote outback, we can meet the needs of people living in rural and coastal England.

These are the words of the right honourable member for Ilford North when he was the Health Secretary. Not only do I agree with him, but I challenge the current Health Secretary to turn his government, her government's own words into law. We got it wrong with broadband, we cannot afford to get it wrong with people's health. In my North Norfolk constituency, I see the struggles for health access and outcomes firsthand. When you're on the coast, you're starting with literally half the access that inland areas have.

Conventional service models assume you can approach access from any direction, but on the edge, where our coastal communities sit, half our access is in the sea. The sea may be beautiful, but it does not run a bus service or staff a clinic or provide a patient catchment. Combined with sparse populations and poor transport, that means coastal communities need more local points of care, not fewer.

On top of that, the services we do have are burdened by exceptionally long waits. We're not unique in this, as some of the poorest healthcare access and outcomes can be found in communities like mine. We know the challenges of health and wellbeing in these areas from the excellent work of Professor Sir Chris Whitty. He spelled out how we suffer shorter life expectancy and higher rates of major chronic illness, higher rates of alcohol and drug-related harm, and more cardiovascular and chronic lung conditions. These are very serious problems, and they can't remain an afterthought in national health policy.

National systems must not mistake population density for severity of need. Besides, problems caught earlier and treated faster lead to better outcomes. It's one of the reasons I was so frustrated to be told by the government before recess that they have no plans to provide an urgent treatment centre at Cromer Hospital in my constituency, which would transform access to urgent care across North Norfolk. Now, I'm putting the department on notice today: my constituents and I will continue pressing the case until ministers reconsider. Let me tell the House what these inequalities mean in human terms.

It means constituents like Kelly, who's been waiting more than 70 weeks for a hip replacement, living every day in pain. Another constituent, Samantha, told me she waited 30 weeks to see a gynecologist; the NHS standard is 18 weeks. Appallingly, our wait times made a young woman so unwell that she was forced to sacrifice her education; during the wait, her symptoms worsened to the point that she had to step back from the degree she was studying for. I heard from Ian, who has metastatic prostate cancer and requires treatment at the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital. It's a half-day trip for him by car to get the essential treatment he needs.

He also told me that he considered using a local bus service, but that would be an hour journey just to get there. Living with a damaged bladder condition, he told me it makes life very unpleasant. I'd go further and say it's undignified and dehumanising.

06:33:12 - 06:33:13

Will the honourable gentleman give way?

06:33:14 - 06:33:47

Speaker 280

I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for giving way, and he's giving a powerful speech on behalf of rural and coastal areas. One word he hasn't used yet is the word age, because age is the clearest proxy for health need that there is. It's not deprivation, it's not other things, it's age. And yet the distribution of health funding in this country has, under successive administrations, failed to recognise that and has failed to allocate the funding. And that is why his constituents and mine find themselves with chronically less spent on them per cancer patient than compared to those in areas where there are many fewer.

06:33:47 - 06:34:40

Steffan Aquarone

I thank the intervention; I couldn't agree more. It's one of the many aspects in which rural and coastal communities, particularly coastal communities, have so much more in common around the country than they do even with their inland neighbours just a few miles away. Again, theoretically available treatment becomes practically inaccessible if it requires a journey to be made without, in this case, reliable toilet access, but in the cases he raised, where access to private transport is all that more limited. Kelly, Samantha, Ian, and so many more are entitled to the same access to good treatment and the same chance of good health as people living in urban and inland communities. It's absolutely right for the government to pursue this bill, and I support the aim wholeheartedly, but I challenge them to assess it based on who's left behind, not just who can be helped.

Accept this amendment or explain why rural and coastal inequalities do not merit explicit protection.

06:34:40 - 06:38:11

Speaker 291

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My remarks will focus mainly on new clause 69, which is in my name. I would say getting rid of NHS England is one of the best things I think this government's done, and as a working clinician, at least we now get away from so much admin and management. So this, my amendment, though, is a quite simple one about self-care and health literacy. Now, demand for healthcare has increased enormously.

Well, since 2019, for example, GP consultations in Stroud, my area, have gone up 30%. When I started work as a GP, patients saw me three times a year on average; it's now about eight times a year.

And indeed, A&E attendance has gone up about 20% over the last decade. And yet, the health of the nation remains the same. So this is the demand side of the NHS that we very rarely discuss. And this is what I'm asking from the Secretary of State. So what are the causes of this?

So there's a concept in medicine of something called the symptom iceberg. Now, most of us get symptoms every day, but we don't go to the doctor. We only go to the doctor with a very small amount of them. But that's increased over the last 20 years. And all the roles of something we call lay referrals, which is like your mum, who used to live next door, is often much further away.

We're a socially isolated and atomised society. And we also have a much higher expectation of our health, which you can't fault, but that means that you go to the doctor with very minor things, for example. So there's also factors like AI. I don't know, in my surgery we use AI, but that also creates its own demand, I believe. And also there's good old Dr. Google.

Now, Dr. Google is consulted over 50 million times in this country every year. So if you try and do that, go to Dr. Google, you usually end up with cancer or needing an emergency ambulance. So that is clearly driving demand. There are also doctor factors. If we carry on treating sore throats with antibiotics, people will carry on coming back in.

Earaches generally get better, headaches don't usually need to see a doctor. And so we're over-diagnosing and over-medicalising everything. And in terms of NHS factors, there are things like the algorithms for 111 and litigation. So what I'd also like to talk about is health literacy. What does that mean?

That means about knowing about your health, but it also means understanding that we're not always in totally good health. And just because we're feeling a little bit low or a little bit tired, we don't have to consult the health service. One of my colleagues in Stroud, Dr. Hugh van't Hoff, has started something called Facts for Life, which is a school-based education service going into schools. In the last 10 years, he's worked with over 200 primary schools. And if you teach young children about health and how it's normal to sometimes feel tired, have a sore throat and stuff, you can actually reduce the consultations in the NHS.

And you can also teach children how to understand the internet. So when they look at something with statistics, they know actually what it means instead of saying, "Oh, my risk of cancer has been doubled by doing this." They actually understand what that might mean. So that's really important. Very briefly, we are also over-medicalising patients.

9 million patients in this country are on antidepressants. All right, that is a scandal. That's one in 20. That's in England alone, one in five, certainly arguably.

06:38:11 - 06:38:36

Martin Wrigley

Thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. In terms of interpreting statistics, does the honourable gentleman agree with me that the idea of GP confidentiality in terms of dealing with data, such as from the Palantir FDP, is absolutely critical, certainly when we come to the single patient record, and that this bill should not be reducing confidentiality or data privacy to achieve the single patient record?

06:38:36 - 06:40:01

Speaker 291

Can I thank my honourable friend for that comment? And I think he's absolutely right. What I would also say, though, is that NHS data and GP data is an a massive resource for our scientists in this country. And I agree with him, it should be owned by the UK and it should be a sovereign wealth issue. And I'd like to make sure that that happens over time.

So I'd just like to talk a little bit about over-medicalisation, if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker. So what often happens, I'd like to try and actually divert patients with mild to moderate mental health symptoms into social prescribing, such as access to nature, arts and culture, exercise, or indeed comedy. And let's try and reduce those 9 million antidepressants so people don't have to come back for review. They're less harms, like suicide in the first couple of weeks of taking them. And let's also look again at neurodivergence and try and look at a way of not medicalising so many children with this condition.

So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, if we are serious about reducing waiting lists and making NHS sustainable for the future, we cannot focus only on supply. We must address rising demand too. So giving people the knowledge and confidence to look after their own health will empower them, free up clinicians to care for those who need them most, and ultimately build a healthier population.

That is what new clause 69 seeks to achieve, and I urge the government to accept it.

06:40:02 - 06:43:20

Charles Edward Robin Morello

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Only half of children in my constituency of West Dorset have seen a dentist in two years. There has been a 20% decrease in NHS dental practices, and some of my constituents have written to me recently to say that they have been quoted in excess of £7,000 for the most basic of treatments. Amendment 47 would require the government to establish training hubs in Dorset. It ensures dental hubs will train dentists for the future and mandate final year trainees to provide supervised treatment to NHS patients straight away.

Trainees are already providing treatment for free, paid for by the taxpayer as part of their training. Those appointments should be for the NHS and not for private patients. Amendment 48 would ensure that the dental funding underspend is redirected towards additional NHS appointments, shorter waiting times, outreach, home and school-based services. Amendment 49 would require the dental funding formula to account for rurality and an ageing population, disability, transport costs, and recruitment difficulties. We should also do more to support GPs.

Amendment 51 on rural and coastal GP funding would recognise the additional recruitment and travel costs faced by practices serving dispersed populations with worse economies of scale. Amendment 52 on primary care estate investment would establish a dedicated capital investment programme for practices whose premises are outdated, unsafe, or restricting the delivery of care. Amendment 54 would expand the electronic prescribing and mandate greater interoperable records, which would reduce paperwork, avoid delays, and give clinicians the information they need when they need it. The collapse of Jhoots pharmacy showed us the limits of the current regulatory framework, which was largely designed around independent pharmacies, not large companies controlling extensive pharmacy networks. During my urgent question on Jhoots, there was cross-party support for legislative action, which has not come from the government.

Amendment 55 would give the Secretary of State powers to require an ICB to intervene where there is a serious risk to patient safety or medicine supply, something we did not have to tackle Jhoots' crisis. Amendment 56 would give the ICBs their own stronger powers to require remedial action, suspend arrangements, or secure an alternative provider acting immediately where patient safety is at risk. These are exactly the powers that the minister told me they needed a year ago to act, and the government has not accepted these amendments. New clause 74 would ensure that employees are not forgotten when a provider fails. It would protect wages and essential employment rights and help staff transfer to a replacement provider where possible.

Amendment 58 would require government and ICBs to support new independent pharmacies to open after a large-scale closure and help them secure medicines and supplies quickly. Amendment 59 would mean funding allocations reflect rurality, population age, travel costs, recruitment difficulties, economies of scale, and unmet need. All of these clauses would be designed to improve this bill, they will all be rejected, and that is a shame. In West Dorset, we need a joined-up NHS, accessible NHS dentistry, sustainable GP practices, resilient pharmacies, modern infrastructure, and funding systems that recognise the realities of rural Britain and coastal healthcare, and I hope the government will listen.

06:43:20 - 06:45:44

Ian Robert Byrne

Ian Byrne.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to speak to my amendment, new clause 108, because the public rightly expect any company entrusted to operate within our National Health Service to meet basic standards of ethical conduct, both inside and outside the NHS. Madam Deputy Speaker, in my experience as parliamentary lead in Hillsborough Law, I regularly meet members of the public who are shocked that a duty of candour, which would compel public officials to tell the truth to the people they serve, does not already exist. I believe many of my constituents would be equally shocked that the basic principles of ethical accountability are not already enshrined in government procurement policy, but they are not. New clause 108 is not radical.

It's a straightforward safeguard requiring the Secretary of State to review the NHS procurement framework and ensure that companies with proven involvement in violations of international law or breaches of internationally accepted standards of business conduct cannot be offered public contracts. Those standards include the UN guiding principles on business and human rights and the OECD guidelines on multinational enterprises. What exactly is there to disagree with? The absolute bare minimum of businesses is that they do not contribute to harm, that they carry out human rights, proper human rights due diligence, and they are transparent about how they handle the data of the people they serve. Yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, we currently have a company operating at the heart of our NHS infrastructure through the federated data platform which fails to meet that basic standard.

I'm talking about the US tech firm Palantir. Palantir has consistently refused to publish a formal human rights impact assessment for its software used in Israel's assault on Gaza, violence ICE detentions in America, and its use of NHS staff and patient data. Such lack of transparency is not a technicality, but a serious failure to meet the standards under the UN and OECD guidelines. I first raised concerns about Palantir's NHS contract in a letter to the then Health Secretary in August 2023. These concerns have been echoed by many, many others.

I'm pleased that Parliament has started to push back with calls for Palantir to be dropped by numerous committees. I also fully support new clause 34 tabled by the honourable member for Newton Abbot. Madam Deputy Speaker, patients trust the NHS with the most sensitive... I'll give way.

06:45:44 - 06:46:07

Martin Wrigley

I thank the honourable member for giving way. Does the honourable member agree with me that it is a fundamental principle of anything like the SPR that it must have privacy by design at the center of it? And as such, a firm like Palantir that has a US slightly cavalier, somewhat casual attitude to how data privacy should be controlled should not be allowed anywhere near it.

06:46:07 - 06:48:23

Ian Robert Byrne

I thank the honourable member for that intervention. I fully agree. I've signed his amendments and we've been in many committees together on this. New clause 108 provides a proportionate evidence-based mechanism to address this. The new clause does not name or target any individual company.

It establishes a clear and principled test rooted in international law and internationally accepted standards which every contractor must meet. If a company such as Palantir cannot meet that test, it should never hold contracts with our NHS or other government departments. I've repeatedly urged the government to trigger the 2027 break clause in Palantir's contract to operate the federated data platform. I make that call again tonight. But it's only through a measure like new clause 108 that we can ensure companies like Palantir cannot operate within our public services again.

It should be adopted through this bill, but the principle behind it should not end with the NHS. It should be applied across every government department led by the Cabinet Office. The Cabinet Office report on social value in procurement published last month was really welcome, but contained a glaring omission: a clear ethical foundation. My clause would provide that crucial and much-needed safeguard, ensuring a legislative framework preventing companies with records like Palantir from securing public contracts in the future. Madam Deputy Speaker, last week I visited the Vatican and spoke with officials about how the United Kingdom could lead the world in the ethical use of artificial intelligence and advanced technologies.

Tonight, my government has a real opportunity to put a marker down and demonstrate that Britain intends to be at the forefront of that global movement.

I look forward to helping them achieve that if they adopt my amendment. Let's make it clear that scrutiny, transparency, and respect for human rights are not optional extras in public procurement, but conditions of entry for any company seeking to serve NHS workers and patients. That's what clause 108 calls for, and that is the change that would be welcomed in Liverpool West Derby, across our country, and indeed in the halls of the Vatican. I look forward to the government response tonight.

06:48:23 - 06:51:34

David Chadwick

Madam Deputy Speaker, today I'm speaking in favour of new clauses 133 and 134, which stand in my name. These new clauses would require the UK Secretary of State for Health to work with Welsh ministers to update the England and Wales cross-border healthcare statement of values and principles, and to bring forward proposals to place those principles on a formal legal footing. For many people living along the border, cross-border healthcare is simply a fact of life. In Powys, at least 40% of people depend on hospitals across the border in England. Yet the framework governing how our two healthcare systems work together remains based on a voluntary statement of values and principles dating back to 2018.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, we do not need to look far to see why the current arrangements need reform. Since last July, Powys Teaching Health Board has asked English hospitals treating Powys residents to treat them more slowly than patients from England as part of cost-cutting measures. This is despite the fact that they had always previously been treated as equals. The impact of that decision has been devastating. Many patients have now had their waiting times increased to up to two years, forced to wait longer in pain, all the while deteriorating in their condition.

And it's not just myself and the Liberal Democrats who have been sounding the alarms. English providers on the English side of the border have themselves resisted these arrangements because of concerns about the impact on patients. Yet there seems to be little will from either the Welsh government or the health boards responsible to resolve this issue. Meanwhile, patients are falling through the cracks. My constituents should not have to navigate the administrative boundaries between the NHS in England and NHS Wales simply to get the arrangements, the treatment that they need.

Eight years after the statement of values and principles was introduced, the limitations of relying on a voluntary statement with no formal legal footing are clear. New clause 134 would require the Secretary of State to work with Welsh ministers to update that statement, reflecting the problems cross-border patients face today. Crucially, it would also require the government within two years to bring forward proposals to place those principles on a statutory footing. The border should never be a barrier to receiving healthcare. It is time to update these principles, strengthen them, and give cross-border patients the statutory protections they deserve.

Because Madam Deputy Speaker, I fear that cross-border healthcare is going to continue deteriorating over the next couple of years. Over the summer recess, I held a series of public meetings in response to plans by Powys Teaching Health Board to cut the number of community beds, which will just mean that more people will end up stuck in community beds on the English side of the border. Thank you.

06:51:34 - 06:55:22

Speaker 297

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This government aims to shift focus from treatment to prevention, and it is in the spirit of this I have tabled new clauses 90 and 91 in my name.

There is an up to an 18-year gap in life expectancy between different parts of the UK and indeed between nearby neighborhoods. Health Equals shows that within my constituency of Stoke-on-Trent South, just a golf course separates two areas with an average life expectancy gap of eight years and 11 months. Reaching old age is somewhat of an aspiration in more of my deprived areas. Indeed, in most deprived communities, people spend an average just 52 years in good health. The stark inequalities are driven not only by healthcare, but by the wider determinants of health, including poverty, housing, education, employment, and the environment.

Within Stoke-on-Trent, healthy life expectancy at birth has fallen by 6.6% for men in the last decade. And for women, the picture is even worse, falling by 9.6% in healthy life expectancy in the last 10 years to just 53.5 years. The Health Bill represents a real opportunity to enshrine in law a statutory duty for the Secretary of State to go beyond reducing inequalities in NHS access and outcomes to reflect wider cross-government goals for health improvement. Our health is shaped by the world around us: the food we eat, the money in our pockets, the air we breathe, and the home we live in. In other words, every part of government has an opportunity to influence people's health.

The purpose of new clause 90 is to ensure that government takes greater responsibility for improving the nation's health. This includes mitigating any increase in health inequalities just such as seen in my constituency. This clause would make improving health a duty, placing prevention on the same footing as treatment. But a stronger duty alone is not enough. That is why new clause 91 would require the government to publish a new health improvement and inequalities strategy within six months.

The strategy would include long-term targets for adults and children, public reporting on progress, a duty on ministers across government to have regard to the strategy, and independent accountability arrangements. Now, the minister, who has worked very hard on this bill with her engagement, and I commend her for that, has alluded to the fact that pre-existing guidance and processes are in place, and these are designed to tackle health inequalities, and she is right. However, I argue that they are clearly not working as health inequality has increased. So I ask again, what is the harm of embedding this duty in this bill to tackle the most fundamental issue in health across England: health inequalities? These amendments have cross-party support, and I note that they are also supported by the Health and Social Care Select Committee.

And I thank Health Equals for their work on these amendments. And again, I thank the minister for her engagement, and I urge the government to consider accepting these clauses. I will briefly just mention new clause 019, also placed in my name. This clause was written by myself and Harris Shuaib, with whom I work on the standard BS 30440, a validation framework for the use of AI within healthcare. And I previously worked with the AI and Digital Regulation Service for NHS England, working with NICE, MHRA, CQC, and HRA.

And in the interests of time, I'll say that in that duty, I identified a number of accountability and regulatory gaps that certainly needs further addressing. And I would ask that the Minister for Health would meet with me so we could discuss these further. And they do partner quite well with a new clause 108 as well, which I didn't spot, and I apologize for not signing your amendment. Thank you.

06:55:22 - 06:59:10

Charlotte Cane

Charlotte Cane.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In the constituency of Ely and East Cambridgeshire, only 40% of adults have seen a dentist in the past two years. And for children, it's only 54% seen in the last year. And the impact on that is that 12 and a half percent of children in East Cambridgeshire have tooth decay by the age of five. We are in a dental desert and it's incredibly difficult to get an NHS dentist appointment.

But the most frustrating thing when I talk to the dentists is that it is the contract that is preventing them from doing this, not their own intentions. The contract, because it's based on units of treatment, they tell me, for example, if they do one filling, they just about cover their costs from the unit they get paid for. But that unit covers up to three fillings, and at three fillings, they're making a loss. But even more frustrating, they get allocated their units at the beginning of the year. And once they've used them all, they can get no more.

And yet they're aware that there are other dentists locally who have not used all their units by the end of the year and they hand them back. Why isn't there a mechanism whereby those units can be given to the dentists who have the capacity to do more work so that at least more people get treated? It is really frustrating to me to know that my constituents are struggling without a dentist and I have dentists in my constituency willing to treat them, but they can't get the funding from the NHS to do that. Utterly shocking. So that's why I support new clause 18 and the other clauses that seek to make dentistry more available to people.

I'd also like to pick up on what people have said about NHS in rural areas. It's really important to understand the size of rural areas, the lack of public transport. My constituents in one village nearly lost their GP surgery a few years ago. The ICB wasn't particularly worried because there were other GPs within the general area that they could apparently get to. Well, they couldn't because there wasn't public transport.

They kicked up enough of a stink that fortunately the ICB changed its view and has made sure that they do indeed have a local surgery. Because you've got to understand that it is a much, much bigger area. It's not like in a town or a city where you probably can get a bus to another GP. You, if you can't get to your GP, you've got a real problem because your GP can't get to you either. And I would also like to pick up on what's been said about Palantir.

I've had a lot of people contact me about that, lay constituents as it were, patients and GPs who are very, very worried about how that contract works and how Palantir operates. Medical data is hugely, hugely sensitive. People have to be confident that that is being managed by a company that they can trust. And Palantir doesn't meet those criteria. It's an incredibly expensive contract as we've heard.

It doesn't deliver the value for money that we need. But more importantly, people don't trust it. And it's their medical records, so it has to be with a company they trust.

06:59:10 - 06:59:11

Will my honorable friend give way?

06:59:12 - 06:59:30

Martin Wrigley

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. May I, does she agree with me that this element of trust is even more important when we get the single patient record and absolutely critical to enabling GPs to use it, medical professionals everywhere and patients to trust it.

06:59:30 - 07:00:17

Charlotte Cane

I absolutely agree. The single patient record is so important to making the NHS work efficiently, effectively, to help it treat patients better. To achieve that, we as patients have to trust that that data is being well protected. And I'm afraid a lot of the people I talk to, including GPs, who are obviously critical in convincing the patients that Palantir is safe, do not trust it. We have to pull out of the contract with Palantir.

So will the Minister please consider that? Please make sure you consider the aspects of rural areas and also please, please, please get us some NHS dentists in Ely and East Cambridgeshire.

07:00:17 - 07:00:18

Apsana Begum.

07:00:18 - 07:04:18

Apsana Begum

Madam Deputy Speaker, I rise to speak firstly to new clause 108 tabled by my honourable friend the member for Liverpool West Derby, along with new clause 34 tabled by the honourable member for Newton Abbot. Madam Deputy Speaker, countless constituents, countless numbers of constituents have contacted me about Palantir Technologies, telling me their concerns about the company's involvement with Israel's military and Trump's ICE. And over 35 members on a cross-party basis have signed my early day motion calling on the government to activate the break clause in the NHS Federated Data Platform contract. The objection is not just about Palantir's ethics, but also about its operations under that contract. And I share the concerns of many, including the National Data Guardian, about whether data identifiable to individual patients may be accessible to Palantir.

The potential success of the proposals on the single patient record and whether it manages to gain the confidence of the British public depends on the government listening to these concerns and making sure that issues around data access and limits, patient opt-outs and the data controller are resolved. I know that the honourable member for Newton Abbot has tabled a number of other amendments related to data safety, which I support. I also wish to speak in support of amendment 10 in the name of the honourable member for North Shropshire. On ICB financing, I am deeply concerned by the introduction of a duty under clause 48 for each of the constituent bodies of the ICB to achieve financial balance. Madam Deputy Speaker, in East London we are currently fighting against a massive eight-figure cuts in the East London NHS Foundation Trust, where workers have been on strike amid cuts to jobs in much-needed mental health services, all of which are being justified by reference to new requirements for financial balance across the trust.

Under the provisions of clause 48 in this bill, matters will be made much worse and the ability to shift and adapt capacity across the system will be rendered impossible. One of the reasons why this is so regrettable, particularly in an area like East London where the need for mental health services is acute and rising, is that the cuts to these services will simply lead to greater costs to arise elsewhere. For that reason, I also support amendment 10 tabled by the honourable member for North Shropshire to place ICB spending on mental health services on a statutory footing. I also support amendment 45 tabled by my honourable friend the member for York Central as I am concerned, as others are, about provisions in the bill for the reorganisation of ICBs. These are among many aspects of this bill which regrettably point towards a revival of prior decades' marketisation policies, policies which have by now been largely discredited.

To tackle the biggest health challenges that we face, we require partnership working, joined-up decision-making between the NHS, local authorities and expert voices, a dialogue between providers and commissioners. Removing the potential for this type of dialogue appears to be a significant misstep, particularly for integrated care.

And turning ICBs into purchasers alone appears to be being done for the benefit of reinforcing a purchaser-provider split, a split which experts have said time and time again does not work, does not deliver improved performance and outcomes, or even value for money. So while I am relieved that the government is tabling its own amendment 60 to reverse the scrapping of local authority ICB membership, I remain in support of amendment 45 in order to ensure that NHS trusts and foundation trusts too retain their voice in commissioning and public health decisions. To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, the fundamental problem in this bill lies in its adherence to a logic of marketization. It's deeply regrettable that the government is returning to the harmful public-private partnership model for capital investment and rehashing of the PFI disaster, the negative effects of which are still being felt across my East London constituency.

07:04:19 - 07:07:22

Shockat Patel

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I refer the members to my register of interest as a practicing optometrist and also as an officer for the APPG for eye health and visual impairment. Sight is precious, Madam Deputy Speaker, and none of us would like to lose it. But sadly, two million people in this country are living with some form of sight loss today, which on the department's own projection will rise to 2.7 million by 2030. Every day, 250 people in the UK start to lose their sight.

That's one person every six minutes. And left unaddressed, that number is set to more than double to over 4 million by 2050. We are witnessing a growing problem, and this bill sadly does not treat it with, I feel, the urgency it deserves. So tonight I urge the government to strengthen this legislation in these specific ways. On governance, clause 21 rightly ensures ICB boards reflect local political accountability, but it says absolutely nothing about clinical accountability.

Optometrists have no guaranteed voice in the rooms where commissioning decisions affecting their patients are made. I think it would be unthinkable to build a localized healthcare without GPs at the table. It would be equally unthinkable to do so without pharmacists. So I ask the government plainly: optometrists have an expertise, the infrastructure, and the systems already in place to relieve pressures on our hospital, yet this bill says nothing about it. Concerning commissioning, I want to see eye care, glaucoma monitoring in particular, along with the management of minor eye conditions, commissioned consistently by every ICB in England and not left to a postcode lottery.

Optometry already has what I call the TAC effect: it is trusted, it is accessible, and it is capable. Commissioning it properly would reduce unnecessary demand on emergency departments, freeing them to focus on the genuinely specialist cases while improving patients' access to specialist eye care where they need it. Because right now, according to a recent report by the Association of Optometrists, they have found that 780,000 people, the equivalent of the entire population of Greater Nottingham, attend A&E with eye problems annually. At an average cost of 145 pounds to the NHS per A&E presentation, that is 113 million pounds a year. But at least seven out of ten of these people with an eye problem would be successfully managed in a community optometrist setting with the right service commissioning.

These stats reflect a lived reality for many across our country. And if the new government wants to make smarter decisions with public money, they must consider this. And finally, on the single patient record, schedule 1 clause 47 should be amended so that subsection explicitly includes optometry within the single patient record framework, ensuring optometrists have appropriate access to relevant patient information. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill takes real and welcoming steps in many areas, but more than 2 million people have already lost their sight, a number none of us want to see double to over 4 million by 2050. Fundamentally, to see should be a right and not a privilege, so I ask the government to look again.

07:07:22 - 07:10:26

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I rise as chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Spinal Cord Injury to speak to amendments 103, 104, new clause 160 and amendment 105 in my name. And I thank the Minister for meeting me during the passage of the bill and for her subsequent letter. And I also thank the Spinal Injuries Association for its support to the APPG and crucially to people living with spinal cord injury. These amendments are not about preventing reform.

They're about ensuring that when responsibility for highly specialised services changes, patients continue to receive safe, equitable and nationally consistent care. Spinal cord injury is a relatively low volume but complex lifelong condition requiring specialist expertise, rehabilitation and long-term follow-up. National commissioning exists to prevent fragmented services and postcode variation. If commissioning moves to Integrated Care Boards, we need confidence that specialist workforce capacity, national standards and the sustainability of specialist centres will be protected. I therefore ask the Minister to clarify how those safeguards will work in practice, particularly around workforce, rehabilitation and geographical variation.

I also seek clarity on whether spinal cord injury services will transfer to ICBs and what criteria will determine that decision. Amendment 104 and new clause 160 would provide national assurance and parliamentary accountability for outcome, access, workforce and geographical variation. Amendment 105 addresses the single patient record. Specialist charities provide vital practical and peer support after life-changing injury, even where they are not part of the clinical care. And that's why this appeal is so resonant.

If we can engage with those providers at that early stage, the outcomes are undoubtedly going to be improved. So this amendment would allow referral with patient consent to approved condition-specific organisations sharing only necessary information. Madam Deputy Speaker, I will not press these amendments to a vote today, of course. I hope the Minister will consider further safeguards and clarification during the Lords stage. For patients dependent on specialist services, their care and access to support should not depend on where they live.

Thank you.

07:10:26 - 07:23:37

Karin Smyth

Which brings us to the Minister, Karin Smyth.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I do want to thank members across the House for these contributions. It has been, as we'd expect on a bill of this size, a wide-ranging and I won't be able to address every single amendment, but I do commit to try to cover them all in the time that I've got and if necessary get back to people afterwards. Because as a government, we do know what we've set out to do through this bill is ambitious. We're not, we don't resign from that.

We want to be ambitious. We want, we are determined to make a real and positive change for people who use the NHS up and down the country. And throughout the bill, we have remained focused on the key objectives, which are to strengthen democratic accountability, strip back bureaucracy and empower patients. So on integration, this bill and our wider programme of reform does support the further integration of health and care and beyond.

I know this is a matter of considerable interest to members across the house, including who I've met with, my honorable friend the member for Shipley and as highlighted by my friend the member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip. And I can assure them and all members of this house that we are committed to supporting joint working between local authorities and the NHS, and this bill upholds the existing duties to cooperate on NHS bodies and local authorities. Making it happen is the task on the ground, not additional legislative requirements, but as I told the honorable member for Shipley when I met her, we're very happy to continue working and using her expertise to help make that happen. With regard to on SEND and new clause 85, let me pay tribute to the work of my honorable friend the member for Thurrock and new clause 85. I agree with her that we need a much more joined up approach across education and health.

It's one of the reasons the new Secretary of State for Health and Social Care has made clear to the department and the NHS that we must give greater priority to maternity and child health. If children have to wait a long time for the treatment or support they need, the problems can last a lifetime as we've heard. So I can tell my honorable friend that we will set strengthen the SEND expectations on ICBs in the new NHS planning framework, including joint commissioning, implementing local SEND reform plans and the new experts at hand offer. We're also determined to strengthen accountability as has been raised here today. The Department of Health and Social Care will join NHS England and the Department of Education in reviewing this summer's local SEND reform plans to ensure proper ICB engagement, and the bill gives the Secretary of State the power to intervene to ensure these ICBs are meeting their duties.

The framework of requirements on the NHS to provide care across local populations works very differently to the duties on local authorities to support individuals, and therefore this kind of amendment would not be workable for the NHS, but we share its sentiment and we want to work with the honorable member to ensure that ICBs are accountable for their responsibilities on SEND. Can I also add, I'm going to move on, I'm going to move on because there's a lot to get through. I would also add to my friend the member for Bexleyheath and Crayford, a powerful on his own experience and the terrible experience of his constituents, I will commit to write to him about what we want to do with ICBs to make that situation better. Can I also refer to as was referred to new clause 56 and member for Mid Sussex, and can I also thank my honorable friend the member for Blaydon and Consett for the ongoing work and interest on carers throughout this bill. I can assure the house that the government fully recognizes the importance of supporting carers' health and wellbeing.

This includes ensuring that they can take breaks from their caring responsibilities where needed. The Care Act already includes duties to assess and address carers' current and future needs, and of course we want to ensure carers get the full benefit of the single patient record, and we intend to use our regulation powers already in the bill to achieve this. On inequalities, which was highlighted a lot today, we are committed to ensuring that local areas are empowered to make decisions to tackle the specific health challenges they face and make real progress in health inequalities. And I want to reassure the house that reducing health inequalities remains a priority for this government, and I know that the chair of the Health and Care Select Committee and the committee indeed takes great interest in this and we are committed to working with them. Can I thank my honorable friends the member for Stoke-on-Trent South and the member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip for their championing of this important issue and our meeting last week.

I'm not, however, convinced about new clause 91. Our focus is and must remain on delivering improvements in health outcomes, support and prevention and tackling the causes of ill health rather than creating additional statutory red tape. We already have a wide range of duties from the 2006 acts, we've got a new duty on combined authorities, the purpose in the 22 act of ICBs was indeed in this space as a duty on foundation trusts, we have the equality and the public sector equality duty as well as our commitment in the 10-year health plan. Again, the issue is making it work and empowering local leaders to do just that. To my friend the member for Lewisham East, I commend her work on the APPG and I will write to her specifically on the issues she raises, additionally on including she talked about specialized commissioning, also raised by my friend the honorable member for Middlesbrough.

We know that this is an ongoing area of concern across many areas and I commit to keeping in touch with them and others. On maternity and women's health, mental health and maternity services, again I can assure the House this is a priority for the Secretary of State. That's why we've published the action-focused renewed women's health strategy. It's why we're undertaking a single national action plan on maternal health overseen by the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce to drive improvements where it matters to families, clinicians and other experts. Now I know many members of this House are committed to improving mental health but I do want to take this opportunity to thank my honorable friend the member for Sherwood Forest for all of her work on this as the National Maternity Advisor.

The party opposite raised the Hughes report. I can assure the House that the government we recognize the importance of providing a response to the Hughes report. Work is ongoing in this area. I don't have time to go into all of that work at the moment and we will do so and commit to do so at the earliest possible opportunity. They had a long time.

The honorable member opposite said it was about to before the election. Well that's not what we found when we came into power. There's a lot of work to do on this and many other areas that they left us to do but we are committed to it. On fertility services, reducing inequalities in fertility services I know has been raised by the honorable my friend from Stockport and the honorable for Stone, Great Riley and Penkridge and he's been a tireless advocate on this area as have many others. I have recently written to him.

NICE guidance inform how ICBs should commission this but I know it's not uniformly implemented and we will continue to work with ICBs to evaluate the next steps. On primary care, a lot of discussion on primary care particularly including dental access across the country. We are committed to rebuilding dentistry in England but actions speak louder than words and we are making great strides to improve access ensuring an urgent care safety net across the country, reforming the dental contract and developing a 10-year workforce plan. And more broadly we think it's right that under this bill primary medical services become the responsibility of ICBs. They have the right knowledge of their areas to make commissioning decisions.

This includes on eye care. That is their responsibility for all primary medical services. But rightly they will be accountable to the Secretary of State for their performance. And in response to the issues raised by the right honorable member for Godalming and Ash, I mean he is right that we will always say that he could have done it while he was in power but you know we don't always say that. But he's right, absolutely right about continuity care.

I've also visited the practice he talks about in Horfield in Bristol. That's not just because I was on the PCT board when the 2004 changes happened but broadly Bristol does have different standards on some of these issues. But I think it highlights our point. We don't need to make some of these provisions in legislation. Through the neighborhood care plans and neighborhood work and work in primary care networks this is exactly the sort of good practice that can be shared in local systems.

On the single patient record, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is fundamental to the government's mission to create a modern joined-up NHS which puts patients at the center of their care. And on amendments 26, 42 and 43 I want to assure members that the overarching purpose of making regulations to create and operate the single patient record is limited to the direct care of patients and the clause is already explicit about this. Crucially the clause does not create any new data sharing gateways for secondary purposes such as planning and commissioning and these amendments are therefore not necessary. On data safeguards, the security and privacy of people's health and social care data are paramount. And as you would expect we will build in the strongest safeguards into the record.

On new clause 32 I can assure honorable members the SPR will be designed to protect personal data by default with the highest standards of cybersecurity and information governance ensuring that only the right people can access the right information at the right time and only for the right reasons. Finally I have heard how important it is that the single patient record is accessible and inclusive.

We're also committed to tackling digital exclusion. We've considered this as part of the single patient record equality impact assessment and work is already underway to help address barriers around connectivity, skills and confidence. And again I have heard my friend the honourable member for Mid-Missouri and Thornby about the need to engage him and others in the single patient record as we go forward. On the federated data platform, decision about public contracts must be made through fair, open and non-discriminatory processes. This is governed by UK procurement law which recognises certain international treaty obligations.

NHS England is reviewing the federated data platform contract to determine if it should continue with standard contract management processes. This will look at the evidence of delivery and impact of the platform and that should be the basis on which a contract's continuation is decided. I won't give way, we've heard a lot from the honourable gentleman. I do want to make some clear points for the house this evening. We've heard a lot of discussion about commercial processes in the house.

And honourable members including the honourable gentleman have raised important points around data security, governance and ethical standards of contracts, support for domestic suppliers and for voluntary community and social enterprise organisations. Contracts involving NHS data and digital services must be subject to proper scrutiny. The government's approach is to assess risk based on the nature of the data, service and supplier access and crucially we already have the tools we need to carry out appropriate due diligence through legal powers and robust contractual provisions. On new clause 108 in the name of my friend the honourable member for Liverpool West Derby. And I agree with the spirit of this amendment and fully recognise the importance of ensuring that the NHS does not inadvertently support exploitation or rights abuses.

UK legislation already incorporates some international laws, for example the Human Rights Act of 1998 incorporates the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law. Similarly we can use existing legislation and guidance to exclude suppliers from NHS procurements. Both the Procurement Act and the Provider Selection Regime allows us to exclude providers where there has been serious misconduct or illegality. For example we could exclude a supplier under the Procurement Act for breaches of modern slavery and or human trafficking laws. We have very high standards and expect all suppliers to meet them including whichever companies go on to provide the single patient record.

On a related note the Chancellor has already written to the Secretary of State to ask that the NHS procurement better supports British industry. In light of this the Secretary of State has commissioned within the health family a review of strategic procurement pipelines to find opportunities for the new social value model to support more British jobs, skills and innovation. The First Secretary of State who is leading work on procurement across government would be happy to meet with my honourable friend the member for Liverpool West Derby as part of this important work as it progresses. And I can assure him that the actions we take will be fully in line with the principle of international law as he has set out in the amendment. In closing Madam Deputy Speaker I want to thank my honourable friend the member for Stroud for his help in driving down access to healthcare with that sore throat.

But I would like to end this debate by thanking all sides of the house for their contributions to an interesting and helpful discussion. The expertise that we've heard and the scrutiny of members has and will continue to strengthen this bill. And as a consequence I will give way to my honourable friend for who spoke earlier, yes that's fine, that's fine, that's fine.

07:23:37 - 07:24:03

Rachael Maskell

I'm really grateful to the Minister giving way. I've listened carefully to the debate and referred to my new clause 57. The challenge of the NHS is there is so much significant unaccountable power being held that we as MPs can't even deliver for our constituents. Will she look at her my amendment and work with me to ensure that we get the bill in the right place with regard to accountability before the bill goes to the Lords?

07:24:03 - 07:25:12

Karin Smyth

Well, I thank my honorable friend for York Central for that because, and as she knows, over many years I have spoken from the opposition benches about the lack of accountability of our local systems to local members of the Parliament. I think it was a great loss in the Lansley bill. It's one of the things that drove me to becoming a member of Parliament. And I think in my role as the Minister of State I have endeavored to make sure that local members of Parliament have... I won't...

The right honorable member was Secretary of State for Health twice, so he had his chance to put all the right things on all the bill. The honorable gentleman's not helping my sore throat. But the point being exactly as she mentions in this bill is about putting back that democratic accountability direct to the Secretary of State. We've had a lot of pushback in different places around the provisions to do that. That is what this bill does.

It puts accountability back to the Secretary of State. It devolves that responsibility for delivery to the ground to NHS organizations and crucially it empowers patients. It strengthens this bill and I commend it to the House.

07:25:12 - 07:25:51

Speaker 304

The question is that new clause 96 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that new clause 96 be added to the bill.

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We come to government new clause 97. I call the Minister to move new clause 97 formally.

07:25:51 - 07:25:55

Speaker 302

Can support involvement of others and visitors.

07:25:55 - 07:26:47

Speaker 304

The question is that new clause 97 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that new clause 97 be added to the bill.

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Order, order. Under the order of the House today I must now put the questions necessary to bring proceedings to a conclusion.

New clause 6 has been selected for separate decision. I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson to move new clause 6 formally.

07:26:48 - 07:27:51

Speaker 303

Question is that new clause 6 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. Division, clear the lobby. The question is that new clause 6 be added to the bill.

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. The tellers for the Ayes are Bobby Dean and Will Forster, the tellers for the Noes, Shaun Davies and Jade Botterill.

07:39:05 - 07:39:57

Speaker 304

Order, order. The Ayes to the right 77, the Noes to the left 317. The Ayes to the right were 77, the Noes to the left 317, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. New clause 85 has been selected for separate decision.

I call Jen Craft to move new clause 85 formally.

07:39:58 - 07:40:12

Speaker 304

Not moved. New clause 108 has been selected for separate decision. I call Ian Byrne to move new clause 108 formally.

07:40:13 - 07:40:28

Speaker 304

Not moved. New clause 145 has been selected for separate decision. I call the Shadow Minister to move new clause 145 formally.

07:40:28 - 07:40:29

Move formally.

07:40:29 - 07:40:37

Speaker 304

The question is that new clause 145 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:40:37 - 07:40:39

Speaker 306

Aye.

07:40:39 - 07:40:40

Of the contrary no.

07:40:41 - 07:41:22

Speaker 308

Division, clear the lobby. The question is that new clause 145 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:41:22 - 07:41:24

Speaker 307

Aye.

07:41:24 - 07:41:25

Of the contrary no.

07:41:25 - 07:41:28

Speaker 305

No.

07:41:28 - 07:41:28

The tellers for the ayes are Sir Ashley Fox and Jerome Mayhew, the tellers for the noes, Jade Botterill and Shaun Davies.

07:52:08 - 07:52:13

Speaker 309

Order, order.

07:52:13 - 07:52:27

Speaker 311

The ayes to the right 170, the noes to the left 316.

07:52:27 - 07:52:51

Speaker 304

The ayes to the right were 170, the noes to the left 316, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. I call the minister to move government amendments 60 to 64 and 70 and 71 formally.

07:52:52 - 07:53:11

Speaker 304

The question is that government amendments 60 to 64, 70 and 71 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Bill to be further considered what day?

07:53:12 - 07:53:27

Speaker 304

Tomorrow. Motion number three on environmental protection. Minister to move.

07:53:27 - 07:53:28

I beg to move.

07:53:28 - 07:53:41

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number four on plant health.

Minister to move.

07:53:41 - 07:53:42

I beg to move.

07:53:42 - 07:54:05

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The division is deferred until Wednesday. Motion number five on trade unions.

Minister to move.

07:54:05 - 07:54:06

I beg to move.

07:54:06 - 07:54:20

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number six on business of the house.

Minister to move.

07:54:20 - 07:54:21

I beg to move.

07:54:21 - 07:54:38

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to motion number seven relating to the environment, food and rural affairs committee.

Jessica Morden.

07:54:38 - 07:54:39

I beg to move.

07:54:39 - 07:54:54

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to motion number eight on the joint committee on the national security strategy.

Jessica Morden.

07:54:54 - 07:54:55

I beg to move.

07:54:55 - 07:55:09

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to motion number nine relating to the procedure committee.

Jessica Morden.

07:55:09 - 07:55:10

I beg to move.

07:55:10 - 07:55:43

Speaker 304

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Petition, Caroline Voaden.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government recently backed a proposal to replace Devon's councils with four unitary authorities. This decision would expand the councils of Exeter, Plymouth and Torbay while leaving an unworkable rural Devon council spanning a 100-mile drive from Lynton to Salcombe.

07:55:44 - 07:56:51

Caroline Jane Voaden

This decision would expand the councils of Exeter Plymouth and Torbay while leaving an unworkable rural Devon council spanning a 100 mile drive from Lynton to Salcombe. 1,783 people signed an online petition about this issue and I have been contacted by hundreds of constituents who are deeply concerned about the risk posed to vital local services. Devolution should be built from the ground up not imposed by Whitehall. This plan made a mockery of that and it's not what rural Devon wants. I appreciate a review is now underway and I welcome it.

The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urge the government to reverse its decision on local government reorganisation in Devon and to reconsider alternative options. And the petitioners remain etc.

07:56:51 - 07:56:55

Speaker 310

I beg to move that this house do now adjourn.

07:56:55 - 07:56:58

Speaker 312

The question is that this house do now adjourn. Danny Beales.

07:56:58 - 07:58:44

Danny Beales

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to begin by welcoming the government's decision at the start of the summer to pause the application of VAT on medicines donated for free to patients through compassionate access early access and related schemes. The health charities patients and industry bodies I've worked with are grateful to ministers for recognising this issue needs to be addressed and particularly for the ministerial statement previously setting out the government's intention to introduce a new approach to VAT on free of charge donations of medicines. I know my right honourable friend the financial secretary and previously the member for Chipping Barnet have both worked a great deal on this issue and I thank them both for their commitment to find a resolution. Without a permanent solution however pharmaceutical companies do not have the legal certainty to fully re-engage with early access programs.

And whilst today only Bayer has withdrawn from these schemes outright I've heard from a number of other companies who tell me the uncertainty is causing them to reconsider drug by drug whether they can afford to continue offering free access for fear of creating open-ended VAT liabilities. And tragically the people who are paying the price for this delay are patients. I know the government recognises the consequences for patient outcomes which is why it has committed to bringing forward a new approach either through changes to VAT rules or through a reimbursement scheme. I also welcome the fact that the new approach will apply once introduced to donations made on or after the 23rd of June 2026. However a pause is simply not good enough to resolve this issue fully and I have called for this debate today to ask the government to reconfirm its commitment to find a permanent solution and to ask the government to move forward as quickly as possible in determining that comprehensive solution.

I would gladly give way and then I'll continue.

07:58:44 - 07:59:13

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Joseph was diagnosed with a brain tumour at just 28 years old. He was fortunate to receive early access to Vorasidenib through compassionate access schemes but Vorasidenib is only the second new NHS approved brain cancer drug in 20 years. So does my honourable friend agree that given the painfully slow progress we've seen in developing treatment for brain tumours we should be removing every possible avoidable barrier to patients receiving these promising new medicines.

07:59:13 - 07:59:24

Danny Beales

Thank my honourable friend for that and as the chair of the APPG for access to medicines those are stories I've heard far too often and I completely agree we should be removing every single barrier. I very happily give way.

07:59:24 - 08:00:06

Jim Shannon

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. First of all can I commend the honourable member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip for bringing this forward.

He has hit the nail on the head on an issue that's quite frankly a matter of life and death for families right across this United Kingdom. Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs sweeping in and penalizing that relief is a disgrace. So does the honorable member not agree that a temporary pause, while welcome, from the Treasury is simply not a solution when the clock is ticking for cancer patients and those with rare diseases? And that government should commit to working with the Treasury and devolved health executives, including my own constituency of Strangford, to secure a permanent VAT exemption and ensure that tax bureaucracy never stands in the way of human empathy. Thank you.

08:00:06 - 08:11:17

Danny Beales

Danny Beales. Thank you for that contribution. And I agree we do need to find a permanent and comprehensive solution. I think hopefully there is issues that we can air fully today. And, you know, fundamentally I think the principle underlying this issue, which is very straightforward, is if a pharmaceutical company is willing to provide a life-saving medicine to a patient free of charge because the patient has a serious or life-threatening condition and has exhausted the available standard treatment options, we shouldn't have a tax system that makes access to those life-saving drugs more difficult, which reflects those members' points so far.

Pharmaceutical companies already operate these schemes at a loss. For example, over the last four years AstraZeneca alone has given more than 2,500 patients access to innovative life-saving medicines free of charge, costing millions of pounds. This is clearly not a commercial transaction. It is a moral, compassionately motivated decision and program. And in my view this means it should be supported, championed and facilitated by government, not blocked or disincentivized or made administratively more burdensome.

But this is exactly unfortunately what had happened since the HMRC started charging VAT on those donations. This isn't just a line on a tax return or impacting the bottom line. The impact is also having real-world consequences on patient groups. The consequences of this delay are gut-wrenching and deeply frustrating for clinicians, patients and their families. Every day, every week, every month that we wait for a permanent solution to move forward, more severely ill patients are denied access to drugs that could save their lives and extend them at no cost to the NHS.

It is also important to note that patients with rarer cancers are disproportionately affected by this issue as they generally already have fewer treatment options. In August I was contacted by Emma and her husband Ian. Ian and Emma are currently watching this debate online from Ian's hospital room at UCLH and couldn't be here in person. Ian has an advanced rare and aggressive bile duct cancer. Following his latest chemotherapy, his consultant Professor Bridgewater recommended Regorafenib as Ian's next treatment.

This was previously supplied free of charge by Bayer through the compassionate use program. However, since Bayer's liability for VAT on the medicines it was donating, it withdrew from the program, meaning that Ian lost free access to the potentially life-extending treatment. Ian and Emma are now urgently trying to find the money to pay privately for Ian's treatment, and the cost is thousands of pounds per month. It goes without saying that many families cannot afford to pay thousands of pounds a month each and every month for treatment. Working with Sarcoma UK, I have also heard from Dr. Robin Young, a consultant medical oncologist at Weston Park Cancer Centre, who reported that a 62-year-old patient with metastatic leiomyosarcoma, whose disease had progressed through all standard chemotherapy options, was also denied this drug in January 2026 because of Bayer's withdrawal.

The patient subsequently self-funded an alternative treatment at a cost of 3,500 pounds for one month before deciding he could not afford to continue with that treatment. These are heartbreaking decisions for patients and their families. I've also heard from Dr. Alex Lee, a consultant medical oncologist at the Christie NHS Foundation Trust, who has reported that two patients with advanced osteosarcoma were refused access to this drug earlier this year with Bayer citing the VAT position. Tragically, one of those patients has since died. She was just 20 years old.

I hope these stories make clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, the urgency of resolving this issue as soon as possible, which will enable not only Bayer to re-engage, but ensure those existing participants continue to be able to access drugs through the program, and potentially new drugs can also enter early and compassionate access schemes in future.

On paper, it may be a niche and complex part of tax policy, but in real life, it is a desperately ill patient, it is a family, and it is a clinician having to explain why a medicine which had previously been made available can no longer be provided. Turning to the position of the pharmaceutical industry, patients, clinicians and the Minister will be pleased to hear that the pharma companies are keen and willing to re-engage with the compassionate, early access and other schemes once a suitable solution can be finalised with government. But I have heard some concerns from the industry about the pace and the scope of current negotiations since the government announced its pause. The first issue is about the breadth of the definition of the products that will be exempted from liabilities. The definition used to determine a VAT exemption going forward should include the full range of schemes that pharma companies engage in to provide these medicines free of charge.

This includes compassionate use where a clinician requests a specific medicine as a last resort once other options have been exhausted, usually off-license, early use for new patients immediately after a trial, post-trial provision for patients who responded well in a trial and need to continue, and also bridging prescriptions for patients where a drug has been approved but is not yet funded in the NHS. However, I have been told that the definition initially suggested by the HMRC during negotiations has been too narrow and does not cover all of these uses. I would encourage the Minister to look again at this, given the compassionate use of off-license drugs accounts for a substantial proportion of patients who currently benefit from donations to the program. I understand the government may now be willing to move to a better position at this point, and I would welcome confirmation from that from the Minister. The second issue is that I've heard is that the HMRC is considering attaching two conditions to any VAT exemption.

First, the patient must be treated on the NHS rather than by a private clinician, and second, the medicines must be supplied directly by the company to the NHS. I'm skeptical of the merits of both of these points. First, I do not think that patients should potentially lose access to a life-saving free treatment at the cost of industry just because the clinician recommending the treatment is a private doctor. On the second, I would be grateful for the Minister to explain on a practical level how such an arrangement would actually work. We all know that the NHS themselves can refer to private clinics, that clinicians can, particularly for specialist issues, work regularly between practices in NHS and private clinics.

The fundamental question must surely be: is it clinically needed, is it free at the point of use for the patient as a medicine that is being provided? The third issue related, raised by pharma, pertains to the question of historic liabilities. My understanding is that many pharma companies have already paid VAT for historic liabilities, and it is important to say that we do not expect that they will be able to recover that in full. However, given the upcoming changes, it would be helpful for the government to provide some clarity on the legal position with regards to historic liabilities before the pause, and I would encourage settlements to be negotiated constructively with the understanding based on the nature of these liabilities. Closely related to this issue of historical liabilities is that of coordination between government departments on this issue.

AstraZeneca has told me that despite ongoing negotiations with HMRC and the pause announced in July, they are currently being pursued by HMT for accounts by the end of September, which has been indicated should include VAT liability on compassionate access, a position AstraZeneca are not confident is consistent with what they are hearing from the HMRC. Business needs certainty to prepare their accounts, and I would encourage the Minister to ensure HMRC and the Treasury are working from the same hymn sheet. I would like also to raise the point of the method and pace of resolution.

My understanding is that the government is currently looking at creating an exemption for compassionate donation of medicines through a legislative change to the VAT Act. However, I'd like to ask whether the government has considered issuing a business brief from HMRC to clarify the new position, given that this could be a faster and more effective route. So I'd be grateful for the Minister's perspective on that. As well as the patient benefits, there are also clearly more broadly a key strategic opportunity here for us as a country to be a global industry leader for life sciences research. Many other countries do have complex schemes in place and sometimes charging of VAT or equivalent on such issues.

However, I understand the Netherlands, whilst liabilities exist technically, they are not enforced in practice. If the UK were to fully resolve this issue clearly and put it beyond doubt, it would be a genuine point of competitive advantage for attracting life sciences investment, research and clinical trials to this country at a time where our overall competitiveness in the sector is under pressure from other directions and policy. I would also encourage more participation of innovative new drugs and potential wider patient applications of them, driving forward future potential research opportunities and improving healthcare practice. To sum up, my questions to the Minister are as follows. First, can the Minister confirm that a permanent solution will define eligibility products broadly and as widely as possible to include the full range of such schemes that are presently used?

And will the Minister reconsider the proposed restrictions on eligibility to NHS-treated patients only? Secondly, on timescales, the government has said it will act as soon as possible, but for a patient with a life-threatening disease, the phrase can feel like a very long time. Can Ministers set out a clearer timetable today about actions and next steps and when the consultation with industry is likely to conclude? And will the government decide to bring forward a change or a reimbursement mechanism? Can the Minister explain why a business brief route has not been preferred to date, or if so, if it can be explored, and when detailed guidance is likely to be published and operational?

Finally, what is being done to repair the relationships with industry that have been damaged as a result of this policy? Where a company such as Bayer has withdrawn, I hope that they will be encouraged strongly to re-engage as soon as possible so the patients we've heard about today can gain access quickly. And can the Treasury work with Department of Health and Social Care to both engage industry and also be in direct communication soon with clinicians to help identify which patient groups that have been most affected could be notified as soon as possible that these treatments may become available again? To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is on paper a narrow technical issue of tax policy, not always the thing that might make the front pages of newspapers or the most engaging social media video. But in practice, a clear and quick resolution to this issue is a life and death issue for many thousands of people.

It is the difference between a patient like Ian fighting to save thousands of pounds a month or not, and just to be able to focus on his health and his loved ones. It is the difference between a clinician having to explain why a medicine that was available last year is now not available, or instead being able to provide this innovative and life-saving drug to them and many more patients besides. It is the difference between a pharmaceutical company that wants to do the right thing, providing drugs to patients for free at low costs, or withdrawing their drugs completely because the costs become significant. Once again, I strongly welcome the ministerial statement and the pause from June. I thank the Minister and his predecessor significantly for their work to date, which has made a difference.

And I know that he is committed to engagement on this issue and finding a way forward. Thank you very much.

08:11:17 - 08:11:19

Speaker 313

Minister James Murray.

08:11:19 - 08:17:07

James Stewart Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to respond in this debate.

And I'd like to begin by thanking my honourable friend, the member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip, for securing this debate and for all his engagement and campaigning on this very important issue. I know from my conversations with my honourable friend that he cares very deeply, as do I, about ensuring patients can access innovative medicines, particularly when there is unmet clinical need. Free of charge arrangements play an important role in giving patients early access to medicines, as my honourable friend so powerfully illustrated when he spoke about the patients and families who have shared their stories with him. I was moved to hear the experiences of those patients, and I'm grateful to my honourable friend for sharing them this evening. My thoughts are, as I'm sure every member's thoughts will be, with those patients and families, including the family of the young woman whom my honourable friend told us had tragically passed away.

I'm sure that everyone in this House agrees that we must find a solution which means those patients and others like them can continue to access life-saving medicines. Madam Deputy Speaker, before responding to the points made, I will first set out some of the context to the existing VAT treatment of donated medicines. This evening's debate concerns the application of long-standing VAT rules to some medicines supplied free of charge. Under UK VAT law, some transactions where no money changes hands are treated as though a supply had been made, and these are known as deemed supplies. These rules help to keep the VAT system fair when a business has reclaimed VAT on its costs.

These are not new rules introduced by this government. These are long-standing features of the VAT system dating back to the early days of VAT before the VAT Act 1994. HMRC wrote to the sector in 2023 as part of the process of ensuring that businesses pay the correct tax. However, the government recognizes concerns raised by pharmaceutical companies and patient groups about the potential impact of this treatment on free of charge access and ultimately on patients. And that is why, as my honourable friend mentioned, on June the 23rd, my predecessor announced that the government would bring forward a new approach as soon as possible.

As set out in the written ministerial statement on the 2nd of July, the government is considering either changes to the VAT rules or a reimbursement scheme. The new approach will be effective for donations made on or after the 23rd of June 2026. Officials in the Treasury, HMRC, and the Department for Health and Social Care have been working closely together and engaging constructively with the pharmaceutical sector to develop the details of both options. That work must ensure that any approach supports patients whilst also being legally robust, operationally workable, and sustainable. We recognize that free of charge medicines are supplied through a variety of arrangements.

These include both early and expanded access, including post-trial access and arrangements which operate after MHRA authorization. Now, my honourable friend raised the question of which medicines would be in scope of the new approach, and the government is considering this question carefully in collaboration with the sector. The solution must capture genuine patient access arrangements without creating unintended consequences elsewhere in the VAT or supply systems. It's important that we complete that work quickly so that patients across the UK can benefit from innovative medicines as quickly and as safely as possible. It is equally important that we get this right to avoid inadvertently omitting important avenues by which medicines are donated or open the door to abuse.

And that is why we're working closely with the industry to craft the scope appropriately. My honourable friend also asked about which forms of donations would be in scope and whether it would apply only to donations to the NHS. He would appreciate that I am not in a position to announce any final decisions today whilst work remains ongoing with the firms.

However, I can reassure him that I have no desire to artificially circumscribe the scope of the new approach, unduly leaving out genuine donation practices. My honorable friend asked about timelines. I regret that as it is a potential tax change, I cannot give further detail beyond reassuring him that I have reiterated the urgency that we both feel of the need to reach a swift resolution, and I have imparted this urgency to my officials. On the question of historic liabilities, the new approach will apply to donations made on or after the 23rd of June 2026, but I am happy to hear input from firms on that point as we go through the process. On the question of coordination in the case of AstraZeneca, it would not be appropriate for me to comment on the tax affairs of an individual taxpayer, but I would certainly encourage firms in the round to share the detail of any specific concerns they have with my officials.

On the question of whether HMRC could publish a business brief to fix this issue, as a matter of existing law, firms must account for VAT on donated medicines. An HMRC brief can only communicate a change in policy when the law itself has changed or following a judicial decision requiring a change in law. A revenue and customs brief cannot make the change in law itself. And lastly, I share my honorable friend's desire to see Bayer return to the early access scheme so that patients can regain access to innovative medicines. We have committed to apply the new approach retrospectively to donations made on or after the 23rd of June 2026, and I hope that Bayer takes confidence from that and rejoins the early access scheme as soon as possible.

08:17:07 - 08:17:38

Danny Beales

I thank the minister for giving way. He's being very generous as ever. I appreciate his response about the limitations of the business brief process. On amending the VAT Act specifically, if that is the right route, does the minister know how roughly long that would take to find a resolution if that is the route for resolution, how generally long that would take? And I fully support his point about Bayer re-engaging and, you know, in good faith the government has moved, I hope Bayer will also.

08:17:38 - 08:19:08

James Stewart Murray

I thank my honorable friend for his question. As the changes we're discussing today concern a potential tax change, I'm afraid I can't give him further detail about any timelines, but I would again reiterate the fact that I've imparted to my officials in Treasury and HMRC the urgency that I feel about this and that I know he and others will share. And I'm glad that he joins me in calling on Bayer to take confidence from what we've announced and rejoin the early access scheme as soon as possible. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to again thank my honorable friend for securing this debate and for the constructive way in which he has raised this issue this evening and at times in the past. In concluding this debate, I would like to pause to reflect on the impact of continued access to medicines for patients.

Individual members have raised with me the importance that early access medicines can have, especially for those in the most tragic of circumstances who sadly have few other options. I have been moved in hearing these cases, and it is vital that we keep those medicines accessible. I'm grateful to members across the House for bringing this issue the attention it deserves. I'm also grateful for the constructive engagement that my officials have had with the pharmaceutical sector, and I know that we have a common goal in resolving this issue swiftly. I look forward to setting out further detail once that work has concluded and when final decisions have been taken.

08:19:08 - 08:19:18

Speaker 304

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.