House of Lords

8 September 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
05:16 - 07:26
Speaker 10
Charles the Third, by the grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of our other realms and territories King, head of the Commonwealth, defender of the faith.  To all lords spiritual and temporal, and all other our subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we of our especial grace, certain knowledge and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create and prefer our trusty and well-beloved Swaranpreet Singh to the state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Singh of Solihull, of Solihull in our county of West Midlands.  And for us, our heirs and successors, do appoint, give and grant unto him the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Singh of Solihull, to have and to hold unto him for his life.  Willing and by these presents granting, for us, our heirs and successors, that he may have, hold and possess a seat, place and voice in the parliaments and public assemblies and councils of us, our heirs and successors within our United Kingdom amongst the barons. 

And also that he may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities and advantages to the degree of a baron duly and of right belonging, which barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed or as they do at present use and enjoy.  In witness whereof, we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourself at Westminster in the afternoon of the nineteenth day of August in the fourth year of our reign. 
07:26 - 07:36
Speaker 2
By warrant under the King's sign manual. 
07:36 - 11:31
XB Member of the House of Lords
Member of the House of Lords | Lords
The Lord Singh of Wimbledon CBE
I, Swaranpreet, Lord Singh of Solihull, do swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.  So help me God. 
11:31 - 13:56
Speaker 10
Charles the Third, by the Grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of Our other Realms and Territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith.  To all Lords Spiritual and Temporal and all other Our Subjects whatsoever to whom these Presents shall come, Greeting.  Know Ye that We of Our especial grace, certain knowledge, and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf Us enabling, do by these Presents advance, create, and prefer, Our trusty and well-beloved Nicholas Charles Stace, Officer of Our Most Excellent Order of the British Empire, to the state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baron Stace, of Brighton in Our County of East Sussex.  And for Us, Our Heirs and Successors, do appoint, give, and grant unto him the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baron Stace; to have and to hold unto him for his life.  Willing, and by these Presents granting, for Us, Our Heirs and Successors, that he may have, hold, and possess a seat, place, and voice in the Parliaments and Public Assemblies and Councils of Us, Our Heirs and Successors, within Our United Kingdom amongst the Barons. 
13:56 - 13:56
I, Nicholas Lord Stace, do swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors according to law, so help me God. 
16:03 - 16:05
Speaker 1
First oral question, Lord Morris. 
16:05 - 16:13
Lord Morris
Member of the Committee
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper. 
16:13 - 16:46
Speaker 3
The DCMS Secretary of State is required to monitor all jurisdictions with UK adequacy decisions, including the US, to ensure that all UK personal data transferred abroad continues to be protected to the UK's high standards.  DCMS works closely with our international counterparts and with UK departments to understand the implications of developments relating to adequacy decisions for UK data subjects. 
16:46 - 17:26
Lord Morris
Member of the Committee
Thank you to my noble friend the Minister for that answer.  She will be aware that the House expressed concerns about UK digital sovereignty before the recess, that is the way non-UK entities own much of our digital infrastructure, invest in data centers, process the data of UK citizens in key public services, and of course transfer the data within adequacy agreements as she has just addressed.  So could I ask the Minister if she can reassure the House that the government will pay close attention to the vulnerabilities for this country of having some limitations to our tech sovereignty. 

17:26 - 18:00

Speaker 3

I note my noble friend's point about the safety, security, and sovereignty of UK citizens' data, and this government will continue to pay close attention to how UK citizens' data is transferred overseas and processed by non-UK data controllers. For our adequacy decisions, DCMS undertakes active ongoing monitoring processes, including the tracking of changes to relevant legislative frameworks and case law within third countries.

18:00 - 18:36

Timothy Clement-Jones

We welcome the return of data protection to DCMS, my Lords. The government's own Data Use and Access Act replaced the essentially equivalent test for adequacy for international data transfers with a lower threshold of not materially lower. Does the Minister accept that this weaker standard leaves UK citizens' data more exposed to the gaps in foreign countries' protections, and what monitoring of that effect is the government carrying out to safeguard real UK sovereignty over our data?

18:36 - 19:16

Speaker 3

Our priority is the protection of UK citizens' personal data, and we will monitor our adequacy decisions with this in mind. The DCMS has a statutory duty to monitor all of our data adequacy decisions and has the duty to amend or revoke them if she, the Secretary of State, becomes aware the standard has fallen below that of the UK GDPR. Officials are monitoring all existing adequacy decisions on an ongoing basis, and the DCMS Secretary of State must be satisfied that the levels of data protection afforded to UK data subjects in a given country or territory is not materially lower than that of the UK GDPR.

19:16 - 19:42

Francis Nicholas Markham

My Lords, given that the UK-US data bridge is estimated to be worth almost a billion pounds to the UK economy, and that twice before transatlantic data arrangements have collapsed following successful legal challenges, what is the government doing to proactively with the US administration strengthen the bridge now, rather than waiting for weaknesses to be exposed by a third legal challenge?

19:43 - 20:13

Speaker 3

The United States is our close ally and tech partner and we are committed to ensuring that this delivers real benefits and protections for people on both sides of the Atlantic. And those companies who have signed haven't signed up to US systems and so are not covered by adequacy are will be British companies who contract with those companies will be obliged to ensure that there are contractual obligations for compliance with GDPR.

20:13 - 20:51

Speaker 13

My Lords, according to an answer to a written question that I received last week, the government currently doesn't centrally record how much of government's critical digital infrastructure relies on cloud or computing services that are headquartered overseas or under the jurisdiction of a foreign government. Will the government take steps now to assess that exposure and will ministers commit to developing a digital sovereignty strategy to ensure that our national security, resilience and the protection of citizens' data are not undermined by reliance on foreign hosted systems?

20:51 - 21:12

Speaker 3

The government approach is to ensure that the UK has the right balance between access to the benefits of international data flows and carefully protecting both personal and non-personal data. This is underpinned by data protection law, UK security standards and established commercial rules.

21:12 - 21:42

Speaker 18

My Lords, given the evolving legal landscapes surrounding the transatlantic data flows and potential future changes to US surveillance laws, what contingency plans does the government have in place should the current adequacy regulation be challenged in court and under what specific conditions would the UK suspend the agreement to protect citizens' privacy?

21:42 - 22:24

Speaker 3

The government takes a balanced approach to this, ensuring public sector systems are secure, resilient and effective while benefiting global innovation. And the overarching point is that this government remains committed to protecting UK citizens' personal data and continuing to keep other countries' obligations around personal data under careful review with the Secretary of State's DCMS being satisfied at all times that the levels of data protection afforded to the UK data subjects in a given country or territory is not materially lower than that of GDPR.

22:24 - 22:38

Speaker 6

My Lords, what assessments has the government made of the amount, type and usage of data that is transmitted to China by Chinese manufactured cars?

22:38 - 22:56

Speaker 3

That is a very specialist question which on my first outing on data at this particular dispatch box, I think I would like to say to the noble Lord, I'd be more than happy to write to him with details.

22:56 - 23:16

Speaker 14

My Lords, can I ask my noble friend what assessment has been made of the security risks associated with the use of US tech and digital suppliers, particularly given that the current US regime is focusing on protecting their technology from external regulation?

23:16 - 23:47

Speaker 3

Risks linked to technology suppliers are managed through established security and resilience processes.

Decisions in these areas are informed by evidence on security, reliability and long-term resilience. The government seeks to balance the benefits of secure international data flows with our high standards of personal data protection. We continue to monitor developments relevant to the US adequacy decision and to engage with international partners to ensure our standards continue to be met.

23:47 - 24:27

Speaker 12

My Lords. I've long been concerned about the internet of things, especially the internet of things that we tend to buy on eBay or Temu or one of these predominantly Chinese importation agents. How can we be sure that there are not data flows going on, particularly on firmware updates that are regular with many internet of things items? Does the government have any strategy to look at this, because I can only imagine it is down to sort of local councils to manage importation of goods at source and I hazard a guess it's perhaps beyond them.

24:27 - 24:53

Speaker 3

DCMS aims to facilitate the flow of data to places that have high data protection standards and will continue to monitor the threats to UK personal data. On the matter of other jurisdictions, therefore including China, in determining whether UK data can flow, we consider the risk to UK data subjects rather than jurisdiction.

24:53 - 25:04

Speaker 17

Second oral question, Lord Gascoyne.

25:04 - 25:33

Baroness Smith

My Lords, Number 10 North is central to the Prime Minister's commitment to get good growth in every postcode, drive devolution and bring government closer to the communities it serves. It will put senior decision makers in the same room as mayors, employers, councils and public services so that decisions about this country's economic future are no longer only taken in Westminster. The cost of establishing Number 10 North is covered by existing departmental budgets.

25:33 - 26:24

Robert Gascoyne-Cecil

I'm grateful to the Minister and having known the Minister for a number of years, can I congratulate her on not just rejoining the government but also on the additional responsibilities at Cabinet Office as well. As a proud Northerner from God's own county of Lancashire, I'm genuinely delighted by the government's emphasis upon the North. But I hazard a guess that most people do care more about fixing the issues that matter to them rather than the postcode from where it's being done. So could I ask the Minister two questions. The first is what specific and material issue will Number 10 North fix that Whitehall has been unable to do?

And am I right to assume, based on the answer I just got, am I right to assume though that the overall cost of the size and the cost and the size of government will increase as a result of this addition?

26:24 - 27:39

Baroness Smith

On the second point, I don't think that's necessarily the case that it will increase, but where what we will do is make sure that invoices and costs will be reported in the normal way. In relation to the noble Lord's first point, I've actually got written down that you're from Pendle just in case you went in for an anti-Manchester perspective. But I think from my perspective, I think I went to Number 10 North and I've spoken to the people working there, absolutely passionate about rewiring and the state and making sure that it works for people in every part of the country. I'm absolutely clear that having the same conversations with the same people in Whitehall in the same way isn't necessarily going to deliver anything other than the same results. And actually what we've got with Number 10 North is you've got it carrying the authority of the Prime Minister to drive forward on his objectives in terms of making decision making long held by ministers in Whitehall closer to the communities we all serve.

27:39 - 28:13

Speaker 11

Will be aware that 14 of the 15 cities with a higher productivity than the average are all, all in the south. The only exception is Edinburgh. No cities in the north, no cities in the Midlands, not even Birmingham or the famed Manchester. Will the minister ensure to get value for money he reports annually, or she reports annually, my apologies, how the Downing Street of the North has made a difference to our cities in the north and the Midlands?

28:13 - 28:52

Baroness Smith

So we're intending for Downing's, Downing Street in the North to Number 10 North to make a difference for every part of the country. The noble lord rightly identifies that not every part of the country has benefited equally from economic success over the past. I think you won't be able to stop us shouting about the success of Downing Street Number 10 North in terms of the delivery once we get going, but I'm very happy to come back to your lordship's house and talk about it in more depth over coming months.

28:52 - 29:13

Speaker 15

My lords, my lords, it's an interesting question from the noble lord, and of course every government should be mindful of costs of doing business and return on investment. With that in mind, I would, I wonder if my noble friend the minister could inform us of the benefits that will accrue to the country of establishing Number 10 North.

29:13 - 29:48

Baroness Smith

So my noble friend is right and actually as the question identifies, there clearly have been some costs associated with establishing Number 10 North. However, it's important to recognize that this office is going to sit at the center of this government's agenda to deliver economic growth across all of our regions. And as the First Secretary of State informed the other place last week, it is vital that in order to do this we rewire the state, which is a phrase I can't say, to deliver the change people up and down the country voted for. Try that with a lisp.

29:48 - 30:16

Speaker 16

My lords, Number 10 North is approximately 200 miles north of where we are. Perthshire from where I'm from is more than 200 miles further north than that, and the north of Scotland is a further more than 200 miles north of that. And I wondered if there were any plans to rethink the name of Number 10 North, which doesn't feel right if you live 200 miles north of it.

30:16 - 31:12

Baroness Smith

I think the noble lord makes, I mean, it's a valid point. I think that it is the north of England, so it's Number 10 the north of England. I think, however, it is in the north for the purposes of general geographic designations in this country. What I would say in relation to the points around Scotland is that where we're looking at making sure that we recalibrate how the state works, including to devolved administrations such as Scotland, Wales obviously and Northern Ireland, we will be taking into account the needs of all those areas. So this is, we feel, a project and a way forward and a way of working that should benefit every, every part of the country, even those for whom Number 10 North is in the south.

31:12 - 31:23

John Redwood

Ministers and senior officials will be mainly working from Number 10 North, and why does Number 10 South lack the prime ministerial authority to make good decisions?

31:23 - 32:02

Baroness Smith

I think it's quite clear that Number 10 just across the road does have the authority to make those decisions. But I think as I said to noble lords earlier, if you have the same conversations in the same place in the same rooms, you're not necessarily going to get a different outcome. So a number of ministers have spent considerable time in Number 10 North. The Prime Minister himself is committed to work there on a regular basis and so far during his premiership he's been at least once a week.

32:02 - 32:33

Speaker 26

I welcome the establishment of Number 10 the North of England. But if the government agrees that centralization in London is a problem, should the answer not be to strengthen devolution across these islands, giving the governments of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland the powers and resources to act in the best interests of their people, rather than simply relocating functions within England?

32:33 - 33:18

Baroness Smith

I'm not sure how it would have gone down with governments in devolved administrations if we'd suddenly popped up with a new central government office. But what is clear is that there is no way this will succeed in terms of the rewiring of the state if we do not take into account devolved nations and their needs. And this will require collaboration with devolved governments to make sure that the benefits of regional empowerment and of doing things differently so that people feel that growth in every area, we need to make sure we work very closely and ministers are looking forward to close collaboration with devolved administrations to succeed in this.

33:18 - 34:03

The Baroness Finn

My lords, I too welcome the noble baroness the minister to her place again. Having worked in Number 10 and had the enjoyable task of managing a Prime Minister's diary, I know that time is the most precious commodity and that there are certain unexpected events and logistical pressures. So can the noble baroness the minister explain how the practical implications, such as the convening of a high security meeting at short notice, will be managed when the center of government is effectively split between two centers, Number 10 and Number 10 North? Will there need to be a duplication of resources so both centers are equally well equipped?

34:03 - 34:33

Baroness Smith

I think both centers will be equally well equipped. I'm very glad and thank you to the noble lady for her kind words. I'm very glad I've never had to manage a Prime Minister's diary, but I would like to think that those people who do and those people who organize these meetings and as the noble lady rightly says, these are often at very short notice, are better equipped than I would be to make sure everything's absolutely in the right place at the right time, including the Prime Minister.

34:33 - 34:57

Speaker 24

My lords, does the minister agree with me that whatever the cost of Number 10 North is, it pales into complete insignificance compared to the billion pound in fraud that the party opposite gave for those people and friends of theirs with the PPE contracts?

34:57 - 35:05

Baroness Smith

I think my noble friend's words speak for themselves. I'm not sure I've got anything further to add.

35:05 - 35:08

Speaker 21

Third oral question, Baroness Pitchely.

35:08 - 35:13

Baroness Pitchely

I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

35:13 - 36:03

Gillian Merron

My lords, access to primary care is improving. June 25 to June 26 saw nearly 14 million more GP appointments compared with the same period in the previous year. And satisfaction when contacting a GP increased by over 14% compared to July 2024.

We have introduced for the first time now a waiting time standard for community health services and 37.6 million NHS dental treatment courses were delivered in 25-26 which is a figure some 6.2% higher than in 24-25.

36:03 - 36:29

Caroline Pidgeon

My Lords, more than 600,000 people are waiting for hospital eye appointments and yet on our high streets there are optometrists who can provide urgent and minor eye care services ensuring faster, more convenient access for patients. So will the government require all ICBs to commission these basic community health services?

36:29 - 37:11

Gillian Merron

Well the requirement on ICBs now is to focus on the strategic commissioning of health services and to be responsible for all but the most specialized. If I look particularly in terms of improvement of access to eye care which is extremely important, the government for example recently announced some 20 million to improve digital connectivity between primary care, optometrist and secondary eye care. In all these ways people will be far better served in their eye care.

37:11 - 37:52

Speaker 27

My Lords, do we think that the ICBs are going to have a problem? We know that they have a fragmented IT service as well as terrific work overload. And I believe they're going to go down from 46 boards to 26 boards. Surely this is going to cause a problem for them being able to get the access they need. It is a real worry for them and I thought even more of a worry for the patients and their families who are trying to access primary and community services.

37:52 - 38:40

Gillian Merron

I do understand why change creates worry and I would like to give a reassurance to the noble lady that actually the 10-year health plan did set out the role of ICBs and as I just mentioned for the strategic commissioning of health services and also commissioning neighborhood providers. I actually think that it will help to move towards fewer integrated care boards. There are currently 36. That will mean pooling of shared budgets, it will mean greater efficiency, reduction in running costs and more resources going to the front line. And in all of these ways I hope that the change and intend that the change will deliver a better service locally.

38:40 - 39:07

Ilora Finlay

What other criteria that the ICB plan to use to monitor 24/7 access to services in the community? Because at the moment the pressures are on emergency departments where ever more patients arrive because that's where the lights are on and we've heard about the governance problems of clinical errors occurring where staff are under extreme pressure and patients are in corridors.

39:07 - 39:56

Gillian Merron

Well the whole intention of one of the major shifts as we look to the future and also look currently for the NHS is about moving services from hospitals to communities and we had a question on this just yesterday.

I do think it's important to say that the fundamentals of oversight which we are improving will be through the NHS oversight framework. And that means it will be clear about delivery and approach. And I should also add NHS England will be able to focus on helping the most challenged organizations in terms of their performance and their capabilities. So if there are problems as the noble lady says, they will be identified.

39:56 - 40:42

Speaker 31

My lords, access to women's health services varies significantly across the country, with women from deprived areas and some ethnic minority communities facing particular barriers. Therefore, can I ask my noble friend the minister what steps are the government taking to ensure that the ICBs not only commission but also deliver equitable women's health services in all regions so that a woman's ability to access timely diagnosis and treatment is not determined by her postcode, ethnicity, or social deprivation?

40:42 - 41:12

Gillian Merron

Well, my noble friend makes an important set of observations and I can reassure your lordship's house that reducing inequalities is absolutely hardwired throughout our renewed women's health strategy. To just make one point to my noble friend as an example, we are redesigning clinical pathways for the most common women's health conditions and that will standardize and improve care across the country.

41:12 - 41:58

Speaker 32

My lords, when speaking to primary and community health providers, they often speak of two hierarchies that they face. At the ICB level, they say that large trusts dominate, whereas at the primary care level, they say it's GPs who often dominate, often at the cost of the voice of pharmacists, dentists, and optometrists who can take on more work as the noble baroness Pigeon said. But underneath all these clinical hierarchies sit patients who in some ICBs struggle to be heard. So given the government's plans to rewire the state, including abolishing local Healthwatch organizations, how will it ensure that independent patient voices, and I mean independent, not part of the DHSC or not from local authorities, how do you make sure they're listened to and acted upon at all levels?

41:58 - 42:33

Gillian Merron

Well, the patient's voice is absolutely key and that's why the health bill which is currently in the Commons and will be introduced tomorrow in your lordship's house is very focused on that. There will be much discussion in here, but I can assure the noble lord that I certainly believe that patient safety, patient voice, patient experience is absolutely key and that will be the case as we move forward to develop and further improve the NHS.

42:33 - 43:03

Speaker 30

My lords, there is increasing evidence that access to senior nursing staff in care homes and in the community keeps people out of A&E and therefore reduces many of the problems there. What responsibility will ICBs have to ensure that they purchase district nursing and community mental health training so that we have sufficient district nurses and admiral nurses to support the elderly population?

43:03 - 43:57

Gillian Merron

Well, getting the right staffing mix is absolutely key and the noble lord Lord Kumar just spoke about what was described as a hierarchy. I am more interested as I know noble lords here are in the team.

And the noble lady raises a very correct point about the role of nursing staff. These are decisions to be made locally. However, the requirement is on ICBs and what they will be measured on, and as will be contained in the national guidance, will be getting the right staffing mix, the right people in place to meet the move to community health services and reduce unnecessary attendance and bed occupancy within hospitals.

43:57 - 44:31

Speaker 36

My Lords, in some places, community nurses and their relationship with acute hospitals is good and patients receive what they think is a care pathway. In other places, the relationship between district nurses and GPs is incredibly problematic and instead of it being a clear care pathway, it becomes a blockage. What are ICBs going to do to make sure that everybody gets the best distribution of services, not the worst as we have in some places?

44:31 - 45:16

Gillian Merron

Well, that is indeed the intention, as the noble lady rightly points out. I think in all this, and in all of the discussion today, which is very legitimate, that transparency is important. And we have committed in our 10-year health plan and already launched a new set of league tables so that every NHS trust is ranked against clear and consistent standards so we can see what progress is or is not being made. That will raise standards, but it'll also tackle variation in care and allow a focus where extra focus needs to happen to make changes. Previously, it was far too generic, this will allow us to focus.

45:16 - 45:19

Speaker 34

Fourth oral question, Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick.

45:19 - 45:25

Margaret Ritchie

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the questions standing in my name on the order paper.

45:25 - 45:59

Lord Khan

My Lords, the Met Office is continually updating forecasts for the ongoing El Niño event. Work is underway across government to assess any potential direct and indirect impacts. El Niño is expected to increase the likelihood of wetter and stormier conditions this autumn and winter. Government is therefore monitoring potential implications for flooding, international food supply chains, energy resilience, and food security. El Niño highlights the importance of climate adaptation and resilience planning work that is underway across government.

45:59 - 46:52

Margaret Ritchie

My Lords, could I thank my noble friend the minister for the detailed answer. Only last week, the Secretary General of the United Nations indicated that the El Niño effect will be more pronounced in the next few months and will have direct implications for food security. I know and I welcome the fact that our Labour government has been working on that multi-departmental approach to dealing with the impact of climate change. And therefore, could my noble friend the minister indicate when the government is unveiling the strategy in 2026 to bring the UK closer into line with the EU in terms of emergency preparedness, and what is it likely to recommend to protect food security and to ensure that our rural communities are more resilient to the impact of El Niño?

46:52 - 47:54

Lord Khan

My noble friend is right to highlight the attention that's being paid to the impact of El Niño. And indeed, the Government Office for Science is undertaking work to assess the potential impacts on the UK, including implications, as I've said, for the food system. Defra is working with the Met Office and other government departments to understand this and the wider risks to our national resilience. There is no current evidence that this event will lead to food security issues for the UK, though of course we continue to assess emerging evidence and forecasts as well as industry intelligence.

The government published its annual statement on national resilience on the 14th of July this year, in which we announced a multi-year campaign to direct the public to updated guidance on simple steps they can take to make sure they're prepared for risks like power cuts or storms. This campaign, which builds on existing guidance which we already publish on gov.uk/prepare, will launch later in the year and will indeed bring the UK into line with European peers, most of which already run similar awareness activity.

47:54 - 48:14

Anne McIntosh

Executive droughts followed by a flood, with the consequences for the UK was severe. The government has tools in its toolbox like the Cunliffe report and the forthcoming Clean Water Bill. For what reason has the Clean Water Bill been delayed until next year, if that is the case?

48:14 - 48:44

Lord Khan

Well, the noble lady is right to point out the importance of the Cunliffe report and the general and the need to reform reform the the water industry. This is a very complex a very complex matter. The as as she as she noted, or at least as she implied, the there is we are due to have a water bill and as was announced in the King's Speech, it is coming and I and and we will unveil further reforms as part of that process.

48:44 - 49:18

Speaker 41

Does the minister agree that it is faintly ironic for the Secretary of State to be advising households to stockpile food while the UK has fallen to 65% self-sufficiency in what we eat? Given the UN's warning that 50 million people worldwide face acute hunger from this super El Niño, what assessment has the government made specifically of risk to British food security?

49:18 - 50:04

Lord Khan

Well, I think the the comments from my my colleague the Secretary of State were simply those of calling for awareness and preparedness, and that's a that's a a rightly precautionary route to take. As I as as I said in answer to my noble friend, as we currently stand, the intelligence that we have is that there's no there are no impact on evidence that the El Niño event will lead to food security issues for the UK. But of course we work with organisations and work with the UK Agriculture Marketing Monitoring Group, which monitors UK agriculture markets around issues of price, supply, inputs, trade, and other recent developments to keep this keep this under under review. But as I said, as it stands, there's no evidence that this event will cause food security problems for our country.

50:04 - 50:38

Speaker 44

Increasingly challenging impact of climate change on on households, on public services and businesses. Has the minister and his department given any consideration to ensuring that the UK's national adaptation plan is a dynamic document which is regularly updated rather than something just static which is updated every five years? And could he also update the House on any representations that he and his department have made to the new Chancellor to protect long-term funding, for instance for flooding, at future fiscal events?

50:38 - 51:20

Lord Khan

Well, we are very clear that whilst there's no clear evidence that climate change is making El Niño events more frequent, it's certainly the case they're taking against taking place against a backdrop of rising global temperatures and extreme and increasing extreme weather, so it can indeed intensify existing risks. So on his point of the liaison with the Treasury, we are of course committed to investing in in in improving water infrastructure and and resilience. And indeed, I believe I'm right in saying there's about a we're expecting over more than a hundred billion pounds of investment to come in to improve the water infrastructure system, which should go some way to help improve the country's resilience.

51:20 - 52:23

Speaker 43

My Lords, I refer to my interests in the register as chair of the National Preparedness Commission, and I recall that I asked a very similar question to my noble friend a couple of months ago. I have to say I am slightly disconcerted by the assumption that somehow this will not have an impact on food supplies, because I think directly and indirectly it will. But my question is, the most likely outcome of the enhanced El Niño, the event in a millennium that we're now being told it may be, is that we will have far more extreme storms which will affect us. So whilst the my noble friend the minister has responded very much on behalf of Defra, I do wonder what other departments are doing to prepare the sectors that they are concerned about as to how they are going to withstand and respond to what may be extremely severe weather conditions.

52:23 - 53:27

Lord Khan

Well, I thank my noble friend for that and indeed for all his work in terms of national preparedness. And indeed, to be clear, there may well be, not saying there won't be any impact on supply chains, but in terms of wider food security, I think we can have a, at the moment, a greater certainty around the evidence there'll be an impact. He raises a very important point around cross-government preparedness for if the consequence of wetter weather in terms of flooding. Activities are currently underway. There is the National Flood Response Centre will be stood up for a testing exercise very shortly.

And indeed the Flood Resilience Taskforce, which is a cross-departmental, cross-government, cross-local, regional, devolved national governments as well, taskforce is preparing an assessment of flooding risk and preparedness, and it's going to meet in October to discuss those plans. I should also note that Flood Action Week begins next month on the 12th of October and it coincides with National Resilience Week, which will help combine the importance of these messages.

53:27 - 53:55

Jock Stirrup

Given that we are going to see some effects from these weather patterns and that they're going to be devastating in parts of the country, can the noble lord the minister assure the house that in preparing for this, proper consideration is being given to planning and training of reserve forces in response to local flooding and other severe weather conditions, given the fact that the military are almost certainly going to be called upon to support the other emergency services?

53:55 - 54:09

Lord Khan

Well, the noble and gallant lord makes an important point, and of course that the use of both normal and reserve forces in these situations are important. That's exactly the sort of issue that the Flood Resilience Taskforce will be looking at in its preparedness.

54:09 - 54:44

Speaker 45

When will the government accept, my Lords, my Lords, when will the government accept that it is our own brilliant British farmers who can provide food security, but they are being punished for their efforts by the family farms tax? Why is the government refusing to listen to the NFU and its 43,000 farming members who remain opposed to the policy as the wrong approach, or major accountancy firms who confirm the policy will introduce considerable challenges for those affected?

54:44 - 55:24

Lord Khan

Well, I feel I'm going to, this is rather going to be a repeat of the question that my noble friend Baroness Hayman gave to the front bench yesterday. But it is absolutely the case that we recognise the importance of our farming sector. We are working, providing policies that actually work for rural areas, which include support through rural rate relief, small business rates relief, a high VAT registration threshold, and small profit corporation tax, as well as things like reduced red diesel rate. So we are working to support the farming sector.

55:24 - 55:54

Speaker 37

The worsening, the worsening and more erratic behaviour of El Niño is simply because of climate change. We've got a climate crisis and the fact is, fossil fuel burning, keep quiet Archie, fossil fuel burning is a direct cause of our climate crisis. And given that, why has the government even got the opening of Jackdaw and Rosebank oil fields on the menu?

Why not just say it's wrong?

55:54 - 56:28

Lord Khan

Well, it's lovely we've had the opportunity to hear from the noble baroness and a little bird thought made me think that we might actually be getting onto Jackdaw and Rosebank. I want to be very, very clear. They are both those fields are subject to a live regulatory process. Those public notice periods were open, they've closed on the 10th and 17th of August respectively. We're part of that regulatory process.

My colleague Secretary of State Van-Bulle will consider representations received and will make separate decisions on each project in due course. And I'm afraid you'll not hear anything further from me on that subject.

56:28 - 56:36

Speaker 40

My Lords, that concludes oral questions for today. Parliamentary Works Estimates Commission appointment motion, the Lord Privy Seal.

56:36 - 56:40

Lord Privy Seal

My Lords, I beg leave to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

56:40 - 57:06

Speaker 40

The question is that the motion in the name of the Lord Privy Seal be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, we now come to an instrument previously debated in Grand Committee, Licensing Act 2003, Mandatory Licensing Conditions Amendment Order 2026, Lord Hanson of Flint.

57:06 - 57:09

David Hanson

My Lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

57:09 - 58:07

Speaker 40

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Questions on a statement made in the House of Commons on Tuesday the 1st of September on criminal justice reform.

58:07 - 01:05:14

David Wolfson

My Lords, I think the exodus we've just seen has been about as chaotic as the government's plans that we're about to debate. But I thank the noble Lord the Minister for providing us the opportunity to ask questions. This latest statement represents the fifth early release scheme that has been announced since the Prime Minister took office less than two months ago. At every new announcement, victims have been left in doubt as to which criminals will in fact be released early. I hope the government recognizes the impact their lack of direction will have caused.

Now the Minister in the other place set out that the amended early release scheme will operate for the foreseeable future as the Sentencing Act 2026 is the basis on which standard determinate sentences will be governed. But given that the Act as passed by Parliament did not exclude any of the exemptions announced last week, I hope the noble Lord the Minister will understand why questions remain. Now of course it is right that those convicted of the crimes set out by the Justice Secretary are exempt from the early release scheme.

And in fact, if noble Lords cast their minds back to January this year, when the House was debating report stage of this very Act, they may remember an amendment proposed by my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie, which would have achieved a very similar outcome. That amendment would have excluded a number of dangerous criminals from early release, those serving time for some of the most serious offences. But the government resisted our conservative amendment and prevented it going into the Act. And the government was warned that the Act would reduce the time spent in prison for over 60% of rapists and more than 80% of child sex offenders. Now nine months later, the government has belatedly accepted the problems with their early release scheme.

So I do ask the noble Lord the Minister, why has it taken the government so long to acknowledge the warnings from my noble and learned friend? And what has changed their assessment of available prison spaces between January and September that they can now include these exemptions when they resisted them just earlier this year? There is a further important point which I would ask the noble Lord the Minister to consider very carefully. The statutory instrument that establishes the early exemptions says, "The provisions listed in regulation 2 do not come into force in relation to a sentence for an offence listed in the schedule to the regulations." In other words, it's a commencement issue.

It stops it coming into force. Now, the Sentencing Act 2026 does have a commencement provision. The Secretary of State has the power to commence the early release scheme on different days for different purposes. So you can have a postponed commencement for offences that are subject to the early release scheme under the 2026 Act. But you can only have a postponed commencement.

You can't have no commencement. And as the noble Lord the Minister knows, there is case law to the effect that a permanent failure to commence the early release scheme in full would be beyond the powers of the Secretary of State because it would frustrate the will of Parliament in passing the legislation in the first place. And so, my Lords, there is a real conflict here between government comms and government policy. Government comms is telling the media that the exempted serious offenders will remain behind bars full stop. The mechanism ministers are using appears only to be temporary.

So can the noble Lord the Minister resolve that conflict by confirming to us today that the carve-out in these regulations is only in fact a temporary carve-out? Will the government therefore be bringing forward substantive amendments to the 2026 Act, and if so, when? And if he cannot confirm that today, will the noble Lord the Minister recognise that he's and confirm that he's at least taken into account the real risk that this statutory instrument will be successfully overturned following judicial review? My Lords, I now turn to IPP sentences, and I acknowledge that 99% of IPP prisoners have served longer than their original tariff. Equally, of course, these prisoners were given those sentences due to the risk they posed, so we have to consider public safety.

The Minister in the other place outlined the government would be introducing legislation on this matter. Would the noble Lord the Minister be able to help us on whether that is primary or secondary legislation, and is there a more specific date for its introduction than soon, which is one of those rather elastic words when used by government ministers for legislation? I do ask the Minister to outline, if he can, what safeguards will remain in place to ensure that prisoners still considered too dangerous to release are not released, and that any risk to victims, of course, is taken properly into consideration.

My Lords, in the other place, the Minister did not share a particular target or timeline by which the government expects to deport foreign national prisoners, or to answer the question of how the government intends to overcome the barriers posed in particular by Articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention of Human Rights. So would the noble Lord the Minister set out the government's plans on how they will address those barriers and provide a date by which they expect to remove all foreign national prisoners, or a target number which they intend to remove by the end of this year. These are pressing issues, I hope the Minister will be able to address them. My Lords, one final short point arising from the statement, the government have pledged a prison building programme that will create 14,000 new prison places, we're told, by 2031, but the problem is now. There are currently 4,000 operational prison places not in use for reasons ranging from regulations to officer shortages, and what steps is the government taking to utilize those spaces?

These matters are all of serious concern to victims. The government, as I say, has now made five different announcements on the early release scheme, so I hope for clarity's sake, and perhaps indeed for the Minister's sake as well, this is going to be the last one. And I look forward to the noble Lord the Minister's responses to my questions.

01:05:14 - 01:10:32

Jonathan Marks

My Lords, we agree with the statement that the government clearly inherited a crisis of prison spaces, and that was a crisis in our criminal justice system as a whole. And frankly, the crisis was clearly attributable to many years of neglect, principally under the last government. The Sentencing Act was a response, a timely response to that crisis of available prison space, and it is unsurprising that as events have developed, the implementation of the Sentencing Act has changed and the response of the government is acceptable in that regard. My Lords, we're content to see that a great deal is being done for victims and victim support, but concerned to know that the public confidence in tagging and the other measures that are proposed to increase confidence and security among the public are matched by an increase in concern for the welfare of the victims generally and the availability of services to those victims. My Lords, the provision of probation services plays a considerable part in this statement, and the concern that we have is that the resources available from the welcome allocation of 700 million pounds by the end of this parliament for probation services will be insufficient given the increased demands of more prisoners released into the community, more tagging, more restrictions and more exclusions which are designed to increase confidence and security in the public.

What is the government, what are the government's plans in the event that the resources for probation prove insufficient? How far are they able to say that there will be an increase in the 700 million pound allocation?

My Lords, I turn now to prison building. There is in the statement a pride taken in the fact that more prison spaces are to be made available. However, prison building is not the whole answer. We need to move to a more humane system that prioritizes the reduction in reoffending and reform and rehabilitation over simply providing more space. And we have old, overcrowded and unhealthy prisons, many of which need replacement.

But new prisons take a great deal of time to build. There are delays in planning, in getting planning permission, in design, in building new prisons. Can the noble Lord the Minister give us details of those delays in the prisons that have been recently opened? The statement also talks about building more cells within existing prisons. That is well and good, but the problem may be that those new cells in existing prisons will put more pressure and more spaces on the rest of the facilities in those prisons.

How far has the government considered ways of mitigating that? My Lords, finally, on a more positive note, we very much welcome the commitment to legislate to ending the complete scandal of IPP sentences before the end of this Parliament. My Lords, it is monstrous that a sentence that was abolished in 2012 should still be keeping prisoners behind bars when those prisoners would have been released years ago had they been given sentences that fitted their crime. My Lords, I hear the concerns about security, but nevertheless, prisoners on determinate sentences are released into the community and it's welcome to see, to hear that the same is going to happen for IPP prisoners. We welcome the invitation and accept the invitation to work cross-party with the government to work out how this can be achieved.

But it would be interesting to hear from the Minister today the detail of how this is going to be achieved within the timescale and what measures that are not currently in place will be taken to that end.

01:10:32 - 01:19:32

James Timpson

My Lords, I should begin by declaring my interest. I was the lead non-executive director and I chaired the agency board of His Majesty's Prison and Probation Service until March 2024. My Lords, last week the Chancellor set out in the other place changes to the implementation of the Sentencing Act to strike a better balance between protecting prison capacity and protecting the public from dangerous offenders. And I want to begin by saying the government does recognize, as the noble Lord Lord Wolfson indicated, the uncertainty that victims have faced over the summer when they're told that an offender may be released earlier than they expected. I have no doubt at all it can be extremely distressing.

And I'll say a bit more about how we propose to support victims and are already supporting victims in a moment.

I can tell noble Lords that victim liaison officers will be engaging directly with victims opted into the victim contact scheme, which this government has expanded in recent legislation, so that they understand how their individual cases are affected. We are also attempting to trace victims who are not in the scheme, and this is backed by 18.9 million pounds for victim support, including a dedicated helpline and specialist support for victims of violence against women and girls. My Lords, the government does of course recognize that victims' concerns are increased by uncertainty. But I would say, my Lords, that the whole purpose of making these changes to the exemptions is because we have listened to victims. That's the basis on which we are proposing to make these changes.

So that was why the government was determined to look again at these changes, which never applied to some of the most serious violent and sexual offenses or life sentences. And of course I remember, I should say to the noble Lord Lord Wolfson, the debates about the Sentencing Act. I was here throughout. I suppose I won't be the first or the last minister to say that we're doing something differently to the things I objected to in the past. We have now rightly also excluded rape, serious child sex and grooming offenses, manslaughter, other unlawful killing offenses, and indecent assault, which had been used to prosecute historic child sex abuse.

My Lords, we acknowledge the public concern. That is why the Prime Minister and the Lord Chancellor have initiated these changes, and that's why we have made the announcement we have. And we have listened to victims. That's why we're doing these things, and we do want to continue to do that. On the point that the noble Lord Lord Wolfson made about commencement, the Act has already been commenced, and primary legislation is not needed in the short term, but we will pursue it when parliamentary time allows.

But we must be, however, continue to be honest about why these reforms were introduced. When we took office in 2024, prisons were regularly in 99% of their capacity, running out of places, risk paralyzing the criminal justice system, and we acted to avert that crisis. But prisons continue to operate near their limits. My Lords, I want to say, because I've been involved with this subject for many, many years now, this problem is not a new problem. This goes back to 2022.

I have discussed it... well, goes back beyond that. But the intensity has not gone away. And the answer cannot be a succession of emergency measures. Lord Wolfson said to me we... said the government's introduced various emergency measures. Well, we needed to because the previous government refused to act.

Parliament legislated through the Sentencing Act for a sustainable model in which some offenders spend less of their sentence in custody, depending on their behavior, before continuing to serve their sentence under intensive supervision in the community. My Lords, much of the debate about this... these changes that we're making in the Sentencing Act has simply not taken account of the changes we're making in the supervision arrangements. I'm happy to say more if noble Lords want to ask me, but it is a different proposition that is now being proposed for the second third of the earn progression model by probation staff.

My lords, probation staff do an extraordinarily difficult job protecting the public, and I want to pay tribute to them. It's easy to be critical of both prison and probation staff. They, I regard them as heroic and doing jobs that many of us would find almost unconscionable. Working closely with the police, we have given them a much more robust range of measures to manage offenders outside prison, and we are building a very different probation service. These measures can include curfews and exclusion zones, and for the most serious sex and violent offenders, new restriction zones, which will tightly constrain their movements, with serious breaches of these conditions potentially resulting in recall to prison.

The purpose of probation as we are now conceiving and structuring it is about controlling people's movement, is about knowing where people are, and it's about being able to take action. One of the things we're doing is making it possible for probation officers to know where offenders who are tagged are in real time. That has not been possible before. So this is a really big change. We recognize, in response to the noble lord Lord Marks's question, the pressure probation already faces, and now we're asking it to do more.

And that's why, as he noted, we've invested an additional 700 million pounds in probation and community services by the end of the sentencing review period. We have also hired 2,300 more trainee probation officers, and that's gone well, recruitment of new probation officers, and we plan to bring on board 1,300 more by March 2027. We've made substantial progress on productivity in probation through the introduction of Justice Transcribe, and we've reduced probation officer caseloads by 25%. And I pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Timpson for his work in this area. He was relentless in his focus on improving probation, and I think he's still there, yeah, he is, and I'm delighted to have him as my guardian angel on my shoulder.

My lords, I said earlier that we cannot allow our prisons to return to the cliff edge we faced in 2024. Changes to the implementation of the Sentencing Act inevitably have an effect on prison capacity, and we have a duty to ensure there is enough space in prisons to meet demand. The Lord Chancellor has therefore brought forward 110 million pounds to convert existing prison spaces into cells. We are also accelerating current builds and securing sites for future prisons. This will help us to reach our ambitious target of creating 14,000 additional prison places by 2021, of which 3,200 have already been delivered.

The noble lord Lord Marks asked me about planning difficulties and so on. I would just say that we have made progress on acquiring land, happy to give him more detail later, but we've made a good deal of progress on acquiring land and have speeded up the planning process. We're also freeing up capacity by accelerating the removal of foreign national offenders, I'm sure I'll come back to that, Lord Wolfson. We'll shortly commence a power under the Sentencing Act allowing eligible offenders to be removed immediately after sentencing. This will not include dangerous offenders.

My lords, my time is up, but I do want to address the points that were made about IPPs. This is a very significant change. We can talk at greater length about the questions that noble lords asked about how we're going to go about this, but my lords, taking these sentences off the statute book is an absolute priority, regardless of even if the prisons were half empty.

01:19:32 - 01:20:19

Speaker 55

My Lords, with regard to excluding those convicted of manslaughter from early release, should we not keep in mind that manslaughter involves varying degrees of culpability, from the very serious to those which are less serious, for those involving, for example, a high degree of provocation or diminished responsibility, or for example, a common assault where a single blow fells the victim who falls, hits his head on a table and dies? These are offences which vary in culpability to a high degree and they should not be classed, may I suggest, in one single spectrum.

01:20:19 - 01:20:34

James Timpson

I entirely agree with those comments from the noble Lord. That is absolutely right. But we obviously have to be consistent in the way that we've applied these exemptions. But the variation he points to is exactly right.

01:20:34 - 01:21:16

Speaker 24

My Lords, I very warmly welcome this statement. The government's commitment to end the IPP scandal, as has been mentioned, is long, long overdue. A transition with public protection at its heart is the right way forward. But may I suggest that we start straight away with what I call the low-hanging fruit? That is the IPP prisoners who have already been found safe for release but recalled to custody for no further offence.

That's about 80% of those recalled. Around a thousand IPP prisoners could be released safely under supervision like this. So will the government consider this option as a matter of urgency?

01:21:16 - 01:22:45

James Timpson

Well, I thank the noble Lord and I pay tribute to him for the work that he's done along with many other noble Lords on all sides of the House to move us forward on this question of IPPs and how we regularise the situation. I should reinforce, of course it goes without saying, that we are not going to release people that the government or the Parole Board thinks are dangerous and we will put in place arrangements to make sure that we don't. On recall specifically, we are planning to consider if we can make more use of the risk-assessed recall. I'm happy to discuss this with my noble friend and others to address some of the concerns he's raised. But the recall powers are there for a reason and we're not proposing to get rid of them.

We are proposing to make sure that they are used in a way that keeps the public safe but doesn't keep people in unnecessarily. I'm sorry, I know you want to get up, Lord Ghani, but just very quickly to respond to Lord Marks's questions about implementation. It's obviously very early days. The Prime Minister has made a commitment to legislating in this Parliament and I think that's a major step forward. And I absolutely undertake to keep the House and the noble Lords who are interested in this up to date as our thinking develops.

But I'm sure he understands I can't precisely explain how we're going to do it now.

01:22:45 - 01:23:23

Sally Hamwee

Liberal Democrats. My Lords, also on IPPs, we've failed so many people. There are so many of those prisoners who were not able to access the courses that they were supposed to undertake to qualify them to apply for parole and so on. And they must have been damaged by what has happened and the length of time they've had to spend in prison, which they should not have done. What are we going to do to support that cohort of people?

01:23:23 - 01:24:06

James Timpson

Well, I thank the noble lady. That is exactly what we're thinking about now.

As we go forward with these plans on IPPs, we're very actively considering how we support them before release and afterwards. It is absolutely shocking that 80% of the unreleased IPP prisoners, I think the noble Lord Wolfson mentioned this statistic, have served more than 10 years over their tariff. Of course that's had an effect on them, and we must make sure that we understand and mitigate that effect, not just from the view of, from the point of view of public protection, but from the welfare and dignity of those people. I still believe in the welfare and dignity of prisoners, I know it's old-fashioned.

01:24:06 - 01:25:08

Speaker 53

My Lords, I'm grateful to the Minister for this statement, particularly the highlight on IPP prisoners. However, the approach still feels piecemeal, driven too much by ill-informed public narrative and wrongly focusing the problem on prison capacity. Does the Minister agree with me that the focus needs to be on reducing offending and reoffending, with the solutions being evidence-led to benefit victims, offenders, families and communities together? So, will the Minister say what progress has been made in response to 5.1 of the independent review of sentencing, namely to launch a public awareness campaign on sentencing, because in recent weeks we've seen the consequences of this huge void?

01:25:08 - 01:25:43

James Timpson

I thank the right reverend prelate for those observations. The only thing I would disagree with is the comment about ill-informed public narrative. I do think there is a need for us to explain better to the public what we're doing and why we're doing it, particularly in relation, as I've said, to the intensive community supervision that we're talking about in the second phase of the progression model. The government is still committed to the progression model, it is what is in the legislation, and we will take it forward. And I absolutely accept the challenge that we need to do better at communicating with the public.

01:25:43 - 01:27:38

Kenneth Clarke

My Lords, I was Justice Secretary when we abolished IPPs in 2012, and nobody in Parliament then would have believed that 14 years later we would have 2,000 people still indefinitely being held in prison without release. It's not the case they'd all been sentenced because they were dangerous, it was beginning to be used by many courts as a routine sentence for comparatively minor criminal offences. And if they'd been given the normal determinate sentences that we now have, I think every one of those 2,000 would have been released without further process some time ago. Now, it's quite certain that when the 2,000 are released, one or several of them will commit quite serious offences and come back before the court, and then of course there will be outrage led by campaigners and understandably by victims and so on. There is a danger that to guard against that, the government's now going to legislate with all kinds of constraints on the release of the IPP prisoners.

And I fear that in a few years' time we'll find that a thousand or so are still in prison on indeterminate times. So, of course the government's got to look at legislation, but will the Minister try to ensure that the legislation is not based on ultra-caution trying to avoid some future turmoil, but is mainly based on the belief that all these people should be free, and only in exceptional circumstances could those that are an obvious danger to the public be kept in custody?

01:27:38 - 01:28:21

James Timpson

Well, I pay tribute to the work that the noble Lord Lord Clarke did as Justice Secretary, particularly in relation, if I may say so, to young offenders. But on the specific point about IPP, I do take his warning very seriously. And this will be a very heated debate and I shall appreciate the support of all noble Lords in taking this forward in the way that Lord Clarke suggests. The government doesn't want to be risk-averse, nor guided by ill-informed public opinion, but we do want to take into account victims, as I'm sure he understands. But as this goes forward, those warnings will be ringing in my ears.

01:28:21 - 01:28:23

Speaker 50

Crossbench.

01:28:23 - 01:29:24

Speaker 51

My Lords, might I turn to the cause of the prison problem? In my time in the law, I've seen sentences steadily increasing, so that today they are more than twice as long as they were when I started at the bar, and far longer than sentences imposed in most European countries. The cause of this has generally been a knee-jerk reaction to perceived demand from the public for greater punishment for particularly unpleasant instances of a crime, so that sentences have been increased by the legislature. Does the noble Lord the Minister not consider that this trend, which shows no signs of abating, is one which ought to be examined very carefully, so that sentences are not increased without having due regard to the consequences that this is going to have?

01:29:24 - 01:30:32

James Timpson

That observation about sentences having doubled at the hands of legislators over a few decades is at the heart of the way that we are progressing with the Sentencing Act and creating a different structure for these things. I would say, you know, if the intention, and I don't know what the intention was, but if the intention was to win public confidence in reducing crime by doubling these sentences, it has palpably failed. And of course there are competing objectives, but there are several objectives that we need to take into account here: seeing justice is done, taking the views of victims into account, and making sure the public understand why the sentences that are imposed are the ones that are imposed. But we must proceed with all those objectives in a considered and holistic way. That is what seems to me to have been missing.

01:30:32 - 01:31:07

Don Foster

My Lords, can I gently remind... ...appears to be plucking figures out of the air. We're told that between 200 and 900 new cells are going to be created by conversion of laundries, office spaces, and storage areas. Can the noble Lord the Minister at least assure us that every one of those new cells will be fitted with automatic fire detection equipment? And secondly, can he tell us where the staff are going to come from to supervise the prisoners in those cells?

01:31:07 - 01:31:59

James Timpson

Well, of course we will take all the standard precautions about fire safety and all the others in the provision of these new cells. They're not cheap, I don't think that's a secret. And the numbers, I think, will be in the middle of the range that the noble Lord suggests. On staffing, I agree with the noble Lord. I think we do need to make sure that these places are properly staffed.

But I would say, in relation to increases in capacity, as noble Lords know, I'm not generally one for blaming the previous government, but the last government created net 500 new places in 14 years.

We've created 374 in two years.

01:31:59 - 01:34:14

Lord Garnier

May I remind the noble Lord, who I believe is actually interested in this subject, that this is not a zero-sum game and year zero is not 2024. I pointed out to the then Justice Secretary Jack Straw in July 2007 in the other place that thanks to the Blair-Brown regime creating 3,000 new criminal offences through 65 new acts of Parliament which affected the criminal law, the prison population increased. But the thing they forgot about was the need to create prison capacity to put all these new prisoners in. When my noble friend Lord Hurd of Westwell was Home Secretary in 1990, the prison population was 40,000. It's now just short of 88,000.

I'm not making a party political point, I promise. But I do find it a bit boring when ministers in this government say it was all the fault of the 2010 to 2024 government and has got nothing whatever to do with what happened before. Let me give the noble Lord the minister a gentle suggestion. His noble friend Lord Woodley, the noble lady Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb and I put forward an amendment, I think it's amendment 96 to the Sentencing Bill as it then was earlier this year, which would allow a panel of judges to reconsider the imprisonment of those prisoners on IPP sentences. Could he have a look at it and see if he can bring it back?

It would take a one-clause bill which we could get through this house in 20 minutes, through the other house in God only knows how long. But we could pass that law to improve the condition of these people that my noble and learned friend Lord Clarke has mentioned and to some small extent reduce the overcrowding of our prisons, which cannot function if they are overcrowded. We just churn people round and round and round. It's an expensive waste of human life.

01:34:14 - 01:35:40

James Timpson

I thank the noble and learned Lord. I am interested. I hope I sound interested. I've been interested for a very long time in all this. In fact, I'm starting to even bore myself, not just the noble and learned Lord.

But I do take seriously what he said. Yes, of course, I generally am not, as I say, one for blaming the previous government. I do take, I absolutely recognise that this has been going on a long time now and we haven't managed to expand the prison estate. There have been successive announcements, but I do think we are making some progress in that regard. And we're not going to get down to the sort of numbers that the noble and learned Lord is talking about.

He knows that. But we do have to make those commitments to prison building. On IPPs, I absolutely will have a look at the amendment that the noble and learned Lord proposed. But obviously at this stage we are working our way through exactly how we do this. And I'm sure I'll be back before your Lordships at the dispatch box before long to set that out.

And just one other thing which I should have mentioned when Lord Clarke was speaking.

Lord Blunkett, who can't be in his place today, said to me these sentences have not worked in the way they're intended. And he and that's a kind of confirmation of what Lord Clark has said.

01:35:40 - 01:35:42

Speaker 57

Crossbench.

01:35:42 - 01:36:36

Edward Faulks

My Lords, the the Minister referred to the removal of foreign national offenders and how that was to be a priority. And I'm sure the House welcomes that. But I didn't hear an answer to the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson's question about the changes in the application of the relevant provisions in the European Convention on Human Rights, which would potentially make it much easier to remove foreign national offenders. Can he tell us when we can expect these changes? And also in terms of changes, one of the problems that we heard a great deal about from his predecessor was the backlog of cases.

And of course that meant that people were in prison for longer than necessary, often awaiting trial. Can he tell the House whether the proposed changes to trial by jury are still part of the government's plans or not?

01:36:36 - 01:37:11

James Timpson

So on foreign national offenders, foreign national offenders have the right to appeal their removal, but this government is already already tightening how the right to family life in the ECHR is applied to our immigration rules. Are are no longer abused as part of our immigration white paper. We do not have to withdraw from the ECHR to deliver meaningful change. That is the government's view. On the question of trial by jury, we'll be discussing the the Courts and Tribunals Bill before long, I'm sure.

01:37:11 - 01:37:33

Speaker 59

The most other countries do in prison of our population. Is that situation not going to continue and get even worse and promote even more crises until the government explains to the public that an enormous amount of resources are spent building and staffing prisons and that those resources are not being used in the way most likely to reduce reoffending?

01:37:33 - 01:38:44

James Timpson

I I need to be straightforward with the noble Lord that the prison numbers are are not going to come down quickly. In fact, in fact, they're going to rise. But and that's why we're we're building new prisons. But a number of noble Lords have asked me about reducing reoffending. Can I say this, the government has has done a great deal about reducing reoffending and indeed HMPPS had a great deal of support from the previous government financially to build up our capacity for housing, our capacity for drug treatment.

And my noble friend Lord Timpson did a great deal on the employment front. But I should say this, my Lords, the what will not reduce reoffending in any circumstances is overcrowded prisons with overstretched staff operating in an environment which is extremely disruptive. If we want people not to reoffend, the the way to achieve it is to have highly motivated staff working in a reasonable way with the support and the facilities that are available in the way that my noble friend Lord Timpson sought to achieve.

01:38:44 - 01:39:13

Speaker 62

My Lords, and the government's early release scheme has clearly created quite a lot of concern amongst the wider public. So could the Minister provide any data on how many of those offenders who have been released under this scheme have since been returned to prison? And can he also commit to providing regular updates on data of any prisoners who have to be returned to prison after being early released?

01:39:13 - 01:39:32

James Timpson

Well, the these arrangements are not coming in until the beginning of October. So there have been prisoners released at the end of their sentences for a long time. We do publish data on on prisoner releases and we'll continue to do so.

01:39:32 - 01:40:48

Eirlys Morgan

My Lords, can I think thank you. I have the privilege of serving on the Domestic Abuse Post-Legislative Scrutiny Committee.

And I can, I'm reassured by the noble Lord the Minister's focus on victims. But I can assure him, because we're obviously liaising very closely with both the Domestic Abuse and the Victims Commissioner, that there continues to be a very, very high level of concern amongst victims, not least because of the failures in communication in making clear to them and their children quite often what degree of harm they may be in the way of. I would ask one specific question in response to breaches of either exclusion zones or restriction zones. They will only be as effective as the monitoring of and responses to any breaches. And if an offender wants to breach, they will breach.

What processes are in place to ensure that probation receives timely notification of any breach and that the police can react swiftly? And will responses to breaches actually keep the victims safe in the moment, or will they simply be identified and acted upon retrospectively?

01:40:48 - 01:43:07

James Timpson

Well, I pay tribute to the noble Lord for the work he's done on this and we've discussed it many times. On the specific question, I think I already indicated that under the way that we are managing probation data going forward, probation officers will know the whereabouts of offenders on tags in as close to as possible real time. At the moment, that is not the case. I think the key thing in relation to domestic abuse victims is, as I've said, that the way in which the victims feel safe and are safe is if the system, the probation service, knows where people are, what they're up to, and can keep them, keep the victims safe from accessing those people. And the noble Lord knows that the, the what we've rolled out on DAPLs, domestic abuse on license, has actually been very successful.

We've introduced 2,000 of these and we're rolling it out across the country by the end of the year. But in relation to domestic abuse, my Lords, there's one thing about ensuring justice is done and getting a trial and so on, but the primary thing in my experience in talking to domestic abuse victims is they want to feel safe and they want their families and their children to feel safe. And the way in which we can achieve that is partly through, in large measure actually in the short term, through the intensive community supervision provisions that we're making. Can I make one, I'm out of time and I find it difficult to shut up on this subject, but can I make one final offer to your Lordships? Because we've had a number of questions about probation, I will arrange for an all-peers presentation to the changes we're making, particularly to the intensive supervision model, including in relation to domestic abuse for all peers.

I do want the House to really feel they've understood those things and then I'm very happy to take any further questions.

01:43:07 - 01:43:50

The Baroness

My Lords, before I move to next business, those noble Lords who wish to leave, please do so quickly.

01:43:50 - 01:44:01

The Lord Krebs

House again in committee on the Armed Forces Bill, Lord Coker.

01:44:01 - 01:44:06

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, I beg to move that the House do now sit in committee.

01:44:06 - 01:44:35

The Lord Krebs

The question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many of that opinion say content. Contrary, not content. The contents have it. After clause 36, amendment 38, Lord Coker.

01:44:35 - 01:46:08

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, these government amendments under my name, amendments 38 and 39, are needed to make improvements to the bill. Amendment 38 makes a simple but important modernising change. It will allow formal call-out and recall notices for reservists to be sent electronically in addition to the existing postal route, ensuring that our legislation reflects the way people communicate today. The existing postal system will remain available where needed. When time matters most, electronic communication can provide faster delivery, greater assurance that notices have been received, and a more responsive process for communicating with reservists.

This is not simply an administrative improvement. The Strategic Defence Review emphasised the importance of national resilience, preparedness, and the role of our strategic reserves. If we are to strengthen readiness across defence, we must also ensure that the systems underpinning mobilisation are agile and fit for purpose. In a crisis or national emergency, speed of communication can be critical. This amendment helps ensure that we can reach reservists more effectively, supporting a force that is ready to respond when the nation requires it.

It is a practical and proportionate measure that forms part of our wider effort to update our reserves legislation. It retains existing safeguards, modernises an outdated process, and demonstrates the government's commitment to building a more resilient, prepared, and responsive reserve force for the future. Finally, amendment 39 is needed to make a drafting correction. I beg to move.

01:46:08 - 01:46:16

The Lord Krebs

Amendment proposed, after clause 36, insert the new clauses printed on the marshalled list.

01:46:16 - 01:46:46

Stephen Benn

My Lords, can I just say briefly, this is a very sensible amendment and I support it. Can I ask, in the world in which we now live and the way in which we communicate with one another, are there people in our armed forces already thinking ahead to different, more urgent ways of being in contact, for example via WhatsApp, so that email may not be the only way we can use modern technology to achieve the ends set out in clause 38?

01:46:46 - 01:47:21

Julie Smith

My Lords, like the noble Lord Viscount Stansgate, I would agree that these government amendments are limited and make perfect sense. I think sending notices by email does make sense. I would be concerned about formal communications being sent necessarily by forms of social media, but equally, I think it would be sensible for His Majesty's government to keep open the opportunities of using whatever modes of communication are relevant at the time.

01:47:21 - 01:50:15

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, I do not have too much to say on this group of two government amendments, so I will keep it brief. I understand entirely why the government wishes to allow call-out notices to be sent by email. The noble Lord the Minister has given us an excellent explanation of their rationale and we on these benches concur. There are, however, two points on which I'd be grateful for the noble Lord the Minister to clarify. The drafting of the amendment says a notice under this section may also be served.

This could be taken to mean instead of or as well as. My point is that it must mean as well as. I would not be comfortable with call-out notices only being sent out by email. What if the email ends up in a junk or spam folder, or the recipient misses the email, or perhaps they don't even check their email, as probably some here that don't do that? If the call-out notice is only sent by email, then there exists a relatively high possibility that it might be missed.

This would of course have some quite or could have some quite serious ramifications. So I hope the Minister can confirm that call-out notices will continue to be sent by post as well as by email. If that is the case, then I have no issue. The second point relates to the first. New subsection 6A specifies which email will be used to send a call-out notice, that being the last known email address used by that person as a means for communicating with them, or an email address by means of which there are reasonable grounds to believe that an email sent to that address will come to the attention of that person.

What precisely does used mean in this context? Does it mean an address to which the individual has provided the MOD? Does it mean an address to which the MOD has previously sent communications? Does the department need evidence that the person has actually received or responded to communications at that address? And who makes the judgment that an email address is the last known one?

Further, what are those reasonable grounds? Does this imply trying to send the email to a friend or relative, and if so, how will the third party be chosen? If this policy is to have the desired effect, then information collection and record keeping must be paramount. I understand that the Reserve Forces Provision of Information by Persons Liable to be Recalled Regulations 1997 expressly state that there is a legal obligation for those who are subject to recall to keep the MOD up to date with their residential or postal address. This seems essential.

However, those regulations do not currently require those liable to recall to keep the MOD updated about any changes to their email address. Obviously that is because the legislation doesn't yet enable email addresses to be used for call-out. Can the noble Lord the Minister confirm that with this change to the process, the government will update the 1997 regulations and any other relevant policies?

01:50:15 - 01:53:14

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, can I thank the Earl Minto, Baroness Smith, and also Viscount Stansgate for their questions around this this particular simple change. Let me let me just say, of course, as with everything as we go through this bill, I will look into all the various points that that have been made. My understanding, however, with respect to the email is the amendment provides legal certainty by establishing when a notice is deemed to have been delivered, mirroring, and this is the the the wording, mirroring the existing approach used for the postal service. So many of the questions that the noble Lord has asked, quite rightly, the noble Earl has asked quite rightly, about what about the email, what happens in these circumstances, they are exactly the same sorts of questions that can be asked about the postal service, and there are established procedures and practice in place to actually deal with that. So as again, I think it's a really important point the noble Earl has asked, it mirrors the existing approach used for the postal service, it simply gives an alternative alternative and and modern way of doing it.

Can I say to the the noble Lord, Lord Viscount Stansgate, it is the sort of legal certainty that we're looking for, again mirroring the postal service, that isn't available were we to use some of the other methods of communication, channels of communication, that that might be mooted.

We need to communicate through a reliable and auditable channel, again going back to the Earl of Minto's point, it's the auditable, auditable, auditable, a reliable channel that we need to, so you can follow it through and make sure it's been delivered to who it's been delivered to. Again, with respect to the postal service, many of us know with respect to letters that are sent, are we certain that's the address that the person that we think lives there, is there? Are we certain that they've got it? But there is a trail by which we can follow that through. And that's exactly the same process that will be followed by, by email.

But it does provide us with the opportunity to modernize the current process and improve the speed and effectiveness of delivery. I think it provides us with a measured and proportionate approach. It introduces a well-established form of electronic communication whilst retaining the existing, and this is a point for the Earl of Minto, while retaining the existing postal option where necessary. As technology and communication methods continue to evolve, future Armed Forces Bills will provide opportunities to consider whether further changes are appropriate. For now, as far as the government is concerned, email strikes the right balance between modernization, legal clarity, and ensuring that reservists can be reached quickly in support of defense readiness, mobilization, and national resilience.

But again, can I thank noble lords for their contributions.

01:53:14 - 01:53:22

Speaker 70

Before the noble lord the minister sits down, can I just confirm that we're talking about in addition to rather than instead of, whichever is the most appropriate to use?

01:53:22 - 01:53:35

The Lord Krebs

The question is that amendment 38 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. Amendment 39, Lord Coaker, move formally?

01:53:36 - 01:54:07

The Lord Krebs

The question is that amendment 39 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that schedule 5 as amended be the fifth schedule to the bill. As many of that opinion say content.

Contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that clause 37 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that clause 38 stand part of the bill, the Earl of Minto.

01:54:07 - 02:01:13

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My lords, I rise to oppose the question that clause 38 and schedule 6 stand part of the bill. These provisions would abolish the 13 Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations and the Council of Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations and replace them with a single new national non-departmental public body. I should say at the outset, I recognize that the Sullivan review identified genuine weaknesses in the governance of the RFCAs, but the vast majority of those recommendations have already been rectified by the previous government, and what is proposed here is not a solution. Rather, I would suggest, it is more likely than not to exacerbate the remaining problems. Furthermore, I'm quite aware that this reorganization has been in the works in the Ministry of Defence for quite some time, and my noble friend Baroness Goldie was made aware of these plans surfacing in 2020 during her tenure in the department, and she was always skeptical of the idea.

She was particularly concerned about the voluntary ethos of the associations being usurped by the bureaucracy of a quango. Interestingly, the proposal did not feature in the Armed Forces Bill of 2021, and so there was nothing at that time to object to.

I'm also of the view that this reorganization would destroy the voluntary character of the associations. The RFCAs are not and never have been ordinary arms-length bodies of Whitehall. They were established in their modern form under the Reserve Forces Act 1996, but their lineage runs back to the Territorial and Reserve Forces Act in 1907 and further still to the county associations that Haldane created to bind the volunteer soldier to his own community. Their governance has always rested on people who give their time freely: reservists, cadet force adult volunteers, employers, local authority representatives and members of the regular services and importantly, the Lord Lieutenancy. Voluntarism is at the very epicenter of the RFCAs.

It is why local businesses release employees for an annual camp, why head teachers make school halls available for cadet units and why ex-regulars sacrifice their evenings and weekends up and down the country for the benefit of the nation. Turn that structure into a single national quango directed by central government dictat and staffed by salaried employees and the incentive to and the enjoyment of volunteering withers. Volunteers give their time to an institution they recognize and trust, rooted in their own county. They absolutely do not give it in the same way to a branch office of a national quango. The minister may say that the new body will retain the strength of the membership.

I would gently observe that such stated intentions are not guarantees written into statute and that once this bill abolishes the associations as they are presently constituted, the retention of any volunteer ethos becomes increasingly and progressively less likely. Second, this proposal will sever the historic and constitutional links between the Lord Lieutenant and the cadet and the reserve forces in each county. Currently, each RFCA is bound county by county across the whole nation to the office of the Lord Lieutenant, who by long custom provides over or patronizes the association in his or her area. The Lord Lieutenant is the sovereign's representative in the county, the office having been created by King Henry VIII, and through that office the cadet forces and reserve forces of these islands are connected directly to the crown itself. A cadet parading at a county event, a reservist inspected by the Lord Lieutenant, a cap badge being presented at a passing out parade with a lieutenancy in attendance, this is the living thread that ties a 15-year-old cadet in Kent or the borders for that matter to centuries of continuous military tradition and to the crown under which that tradition sits.

Strip out the county associations and replace them with a single national body headquartered inevitably in London or maybe Manchester and you cut the geographic and ceremonial link between the lieutenancy and the cadet and the reserve forces that has in various forms existed for almost 500 years. Once that link is gone, my Lords, we will not get it back. And if that happens, it will be yet another example of something good, traditional and historic being destroyed for no other reason than the administrative convenience of the civil service. Third, and I put this to the House as a matter of principle rather than only as it applies to this bill, non-departmental public bodies bring with them a well-documented set of accountability problems. Such bodies are close enough to government to be tasked and funded by a sponsoring department, yet distant enough that direct ministerial accountability to this House and the other place is diminished.

The Public Accounts Committee and the National Audit Office have repeatedly reported on the difficulties of holding NDPBs to account for the money they spend and the decisions that they take. A single national RFCA successor body will inherit precisely these familiar problems, which makes the government's decision all the more perplexing given that these problems do not currently exist. So, may I ask the minister directly: why are the government doing this? What specific measurable improvement will this restructuring make to the delivery of the cadet forces on the ground? What of the impact to the number of adult volunteers, to the condition of the facilities and to recruitment into the reserve?

The government's own explanatory notes speak of addressing financial, legal, safeguarding and estate management risks and placing responsibilities on a clearer statutory footing. Those are understandable aims, but none of them require the abolition of the county-rooted voluntary associations and the severance of the link to the lieutenancy. My Lords, I'll be candid about what I suspect is the real motive, although I invite the minister to correct me if I'm wrong. Is this not at its heart about cadets and reservists? I would suggest it is more about the administrative convenience of the civil service who institutionally do not like anything that seems irrationally messy, historic or not quite uniform.

This may make life easier for officials in Whitehall, but it will make life much harder for the volunteers who have for well over a century made the reserve and cadet forces of this country work so well. It will also inevitably cost a lot more than currently expended.

02:01:13 - 02:01:20

Speaker 71

My Lords, I would like to support... Sorry, after you.

02:01:20 - 02:03:57

Jock Stirrup

Thank you very much. My Lords, I strongly support the purpose of this amendment. The PAC 43rd report of 2024-25 heavily criticised MOD for inadequacies in their financial oversight of the RFCAs. To quote from their report, I quote: "The department's arrangements for monitoring and reporting on the RFCAs' financial performance are inadequate." And again, another quote: "They fall below the standard we expect."

My Lords, I've studied this report, it's quite a shocker. The PAC even said that there was uncertainty over who is responsible when problems arise. I could go on, but I will spare officials their blushes. I hope they are preparing the progress reports the PAC demanded covering these shortfalls and failings. The PAC specifically acknowledged that the reserve forces and cadets are increasingly important to UK defence, as is stressed in the SDR.

But to take these shortcomings as specific reasons for changes, not just to financial control, but to the management structure and leadership of the RFCAs is simply overreaction. The drafters of this aspect of the bill seem to ignore history or have little feel for the long tradition of the armed forces' loyalty and direct connection with the crown, a tradition going back centuries as mentioned to Henry VIII and beyond. Such history is binding for the armed forces; it should never, even inadvertently, be disparaged or discarded. My Lords, let's recall what Dr Sullivan's review recommended. He sought to retain the regional volunteer networks, employer engagement and community links that make RFCAs so valuable, while strengthening the strategic direction, financial resilience and oversight.

His broader message was to ensure RFCAs remain a modern, effective and trusted partner for defence, while expanding their contribution to reserves, cadets, employers, veterans and the volunteer estate.

02:03:57 - 02:07:34

Speaker 73

What then is their particular strength? Let me just pick briefly on two. First, their unique voluntary nature. This, apart from their nil personnel cost, is the essence of the regional and collective support that they bring to the reserves and cadets. Their local intimate knowledge of employers and of the attractions and enthusiasms of their locality are such a foundation of success of the cadet concept that inspires young of different ages, sex and background to join up and get involved.

Their national coverage is a key defense requirement. All this, my Lords, should be valued and sustained, not badly revamped, even discarded. There does not appear to be strong evidence of widespread problems recruiting RFCA volunteers themselves, particularly cadet force adult volunteers, where some regions have reported growth. The direct relationship between Lords Lieutenant, personally chosen and appointed by the sovereign, and the cadets in their counties symbolize the expectation of the reserves and cadets' loyalty to their monarch, their commander-in-chief. Why discard this without even consulting the Lords Lieutenant, or even His Majesty the King?

I subscribe to that old-fashioned notion: if it ain't broke, why fix it? Are the identified MOD failures in financial supervision entirely to be laid at the feet of the RFCA structure? The National Audit Office, commenting on the financial weaknesses, suggested that arrangements other than a full-blown NDPB one would be acceptable. MOD's own internal record following consideration of Dr. Sullivan's report seemed to indicate that the NDPB approach had been overtaken by the SDR and the key efforts to enhance the reserves and cadets' contribution to overall defense needs. I strongly recommend that the noble Lord the Minister takes this back to his department, checks that the present financial oversight has been improved following the PAC criticisms, and gives credit where credit is due to the volunteer strengths of the present structures and the important of the symbolic relationship with the Lords Lieutenant and the reserves and cadets' loyalty to the Crown.

The bill is mistaken to degrade or throw away such key elements of a long-established and volunteer structure. To throw it away in hasty pursuit of progress, modernization, accountability and transparency, or of any other overworked nostrum of management speak is pure madness. Of course, MOD should heed the PAC criticism of their lack of proper financial management and ensure that the MOD's accounting officer has regained the financial oversight expected by the PAC.

02:07:34 - 02:07:55

Jock Stirrup

But MOD's financial failings are no reason to discard the tried and tested experience that makes the reserves and cadets with their supporting volunteer associations of increasing value both to defense and society at large. Hear, hear.

02:07:55 - 02:12:41

Annabel Goldie

My Lords, it is an honor to follow the noble and gallant Lord, and I rise to support my noble friends and speak to the amendment that clause 38 stand part of the bill. I am always keen to champion improvements in governance, and in the case of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations, there is a perfectly reasonable case highlighted by the National Audit Office for bringing greater consistency, accountability, and financial assurance to these organizations. But my concern is that in achieving that objective, clause 38 risks losing something which is particularly valuable in Scotland, which is the strong regional relationship between defense and the communities it serves. My Lords, Scotland currently has two RFCAs, Highland and Lowland. And as the noble Earl Minto said in his opening, they are not simply administrative offices of the Ministry of Defence.

They are embedded in the communities in which they operate. They work with reservists, cadets, employers, schools, local authorities, and civic organizations. Lowland RFCA alone maintains more than 130 reserve and cadet centers across Scotland and supports engagement with employers and communities across a very large and diverse geographical area. This local knowledge and connection was highlighted by Dr. Sullivan's report itself. And he identified, as the noble and gallant Lord referred to, he identified, I quote, the wide breadth of expertise and community links as key strengths of the RFCAs.

So the government's proposal replaces these existing 13 regional associations with a single UK-wide statutory body. And regional councils will be created, but they will be subordinate to the national body. And many of the important questions about their membership, functions, geographical responsibilities will be left to regulations of the new board. So my concern is not simply structural, it is actually about accountability and voice. As I have often said in this house, my Lords, Scotland is not just another region of England.

Defense may well be reserved, but many of the institutions and relationships through which the reserve and cadet forces operate are not. Education, local government, skills, employers, and communities, for example, are all part of a devolved and distinctly Scottish eco-structure. And with the changes as currently proposed, how can we have any confidence that a UK-wide NDPB will not inadvertently become a London-centered organization in which Scottish interests are represented only through administrative delegation? The bill does not, as I understand it, guarantee Scottish representation on the national board. Nor does it guarantee the continuing role, powers, or membership of Scottish regional councils in primary legislation.

The strength of the RFCAs lies precisely in their ability to connect defense with civil society, something that is a very current issue in these uncertain times, and as we seek to deliver the recommendations of the SDSR and meet our NATO commitments. The historic reason for having regional associations was not bureaucracy, it was fostering that local connection. And this remains just as important today. Indeed, the Commons Committee recognized the importance of retaining regional representation and local connections. And so I would therefore urge the government to think carefully about whether the measures in clause 38 of this bill protects these.

Does the proposed NDPB deliver a properly governed national body which retains genuinely empowered regional structures? In Scotland, that should mean meaningful and guaranteed representation, a clear role for both Highland and Lowland, proper engagement with Scottish civic and public institutions, and sufficient delegated authority to ensure that decisions affecting Scottish reservists, cadets, employers, and the reserve estate are informed by the people who understand Scotland. Until the noble lord the minister can demonstrate this is the case, there remain important questions, I believe, unanswered, and therefore I support opposing the question that clause 38 stand part of the bill.

02:12:41 - 02:13:56

Jock Stirrup

Let me start by saying that I agree with everything that's been said so far. I have put my name to some amendments later on in subsequent groupings that seek to ameliorate some of the worst aspects of schedule 6 where I think the government has got it badly wrong, and I'll seek to develop further the arguments when we come to those amendments. But let me just pose a question to the noble lord the minister. My understanding, like the noble lord the Earl of Minto, is that this move is largely driven by a desire to centralize much stronger financial control. If such central financial control is necessary for financial efficiency and propriety, may I ask the noble lord the minister how on earth the government is going to carry out its agenda of decentralization more widely across the country?

Since this is a government which seeks to promote devolution, which seeks to promote decentralization, a much greater local control, how on earth can this particular part of the Armed Forces Bill be consonant with that government policy? It simply can't have it both ways, and I wonder if the noble lord the minister, when he responds, could address that particular point.

02:13:56 - 02:17:41

Charles Moore

My lords, it's a pleasure, honored to follow several noble lords, two of them gallant, who have spoken already, and of course they have tremendous expertise. And I also wanted to thank the noble lady Fraser because she made a point which I think is very important, I think, for the more general argument, not just about Scotland, that the question of the reserves is not a reserved matter, and that shows something about how it all operates, about how local it is. I have the honor, my lords, to be a member, as a Sussex man, of a club called the Sussex Club, and at our annual dinners, twice a year actually, we propose a toast, as well as of course the loyal toast, we have an absolute rule that we have no speeches ever, but we have two toasts, and one says prosperity to the county of Sussex and the other is to the forces of the crown. And I think the link between those two toasts says it all, actually, and that's partly why we don't have speeches. This is what we're talking about here.

This is why it matters and why it's rooted. And we must remember that the origins of all our armed forces, unlike the origins of the Royal Navy, all our armies are not a standing army, but regiments raised, armies raised from, and that's the way that the loyalty of the people has always been bound in. So it's actually quite a serious historical and emotional and cultural matter. But of course, we shouldn't only rest our argument on that point, central though it is, because it could be argued that for some reason these arrangements are out of date.

But I think then what we need to do is to think about two things. One is, will they be more efficiently arranged if they are in fact centralized? It was raised, I think, by the noble Earl of Minto that the centralized non-departmental body is actually a major difficult feature of modern British government, and it's all to do with the problem about answerability. And I notice one thing that comes into rhetoric a great deal in modern government is that we need an independent body to do something or other. And that sounds lovely because we all want independence, but what does that independence mean?

It actually means that a person with a bureaucratic background being appointed by bureaucrats, and there's almost no answerability to the public more widely or even to Parliament. So I would be suspicious of that. And then I would just like to take up, follow what the noble and gallant Lord Stirrup said. The reason, the particular reason it's relevant now with this government, I think, is that I feel this government has inherited this measure from its officials and that it's actually not consonant with its own policies. Because what we're getting from so-called Manchesterism from the Prime Minister is in a way a modern and more urban version of the thing we're all praising in relation to the reserves in counties.

It's the idea that local loyalty matters and that local people understand these questions better and that power should be devolved. And that is going in, this measure is going absolutely in the wrong direction. And this matters particularly in our time because this government is trying to shift all of that, and also because, my Lords, we mustn't forget the wider picture. We live in a dramatically more dangerous world than we have done for a very long time. The loyalty we're talking about needs to be constantly cultivated.

People need to understand why their service matters, and this will make it harder for them to understand at a time when we want them to volunteer.

02:17:41 - 02:22:21

Hugo Swire

My noble friend Lord Moore thinks there is some intellectual coherence about the government's approach to regionalization, given the fact it's just abandoned large swathes of it in the last 24 hours, including in my part of the world, but I understand and take on board what he says. I don't want to make a political point, having just made a political point, but I strongly agree with Lord Moore as well. I suspect this has the hands of officials all over it, and knowing the noble Lord the Minister as I do, I wouldn't be wholly convinced that this has his support. Of course he'll have to support it, it's part of government, as a government proposal, but I think he will get the arguments against it as well as anyone else. I only rise to speak because I'm nervous, always nervous about any form of military reorganization when it comes to recruitment.

I bow to more distinguished military figures in this chamber than I was myself, and it's very dangerous to speak about one's own military experience given how long ago in my case it was. But I have witnessed over the years, and indeed in the other place was a critic of the move to change the way we recruit our armed forces, not least through the use of Capita, which I always thought had disaster written all over it in capitals. And indeed that was a view shared at one point by both, I think, the Public Accounts Committee and the National Audit Office. And I'm pleased that the government is transitioning to the Armed Forces Recruitment Programme, which is, I think, going to come into force next year, and we can only hope and pray that that is going to do us better service than did the Capita project. But of course what we lost during all that was the whole issue of recruiting regiments from their localities, something which has been enormously important over the years, not least as it engenders comradeship amongst those who join together from different parts of the world when they serve abroad.

We've seen that throughout history. I agree, I thought this goes against the government's idea of localism to try and centralize everything. I can quite understand sitting in the MOD on a quiet Friday afternoon, some officials thinking, oh my goodness, we must bring all this together. We can't have all these independent organizations. It's much easier to have one.

But I think it would be a great mistake. And I would just say this. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Armed Forces, Louise Sandler-Jones, in an article, I think today, I think it was in today's Telegraph, I think, has been talking about the mobilization of some of the 95,000 retired people who have served in the armed forces for an exercise next year. Now, I know they've raised the age of veterans that can be mobilized from 55 to 65, so unfortunately that will exclude me by a year or two, but I hope that I might have some use somewhere along the line if they're going to do that. But my point is other.

My point is this, that if we are talking about a mass mobilization, it rather goes back to the debate we were having on the earlier clause about how to contact these people. We are talking about contacting people who have not been in contact for many, many years, for decades. But also they live all over the country. And what better way of connecting with those people and engendering and fostering some sense of purpose and community by doing it through the existing structure? So I think the whole way we do our military, to use rather bad English, is going through a transition with much more concentration on our reserve forces and mobilizing those forces in the case of an emergency.

And I would therefore urge extreme caution to the government to stop tinkering with this at the present time. Of course, these organizations, the RFCAs, are not above criticism. I understand a lot of improvements have already been made, but I just think it is senseless and the timing is wrong to follow what the government is proposing to place in their wake.

02:22:21 - 02:23:41

Stephen Benn

I would like to begin by apologizing to my noble friend, the Minister, for whom I have the highest regard, because I fear that what I'm about to say may not be the most welcome contribution to make to this debate. And I don't know half as much about this as many noble and gallant lords and other members in the chamber. But I do want to say this. Last week, I went to an RAF base, and I declare an interest because my son-in-law is the station commander. But I went for this event, and I was very struck by the extent to which it celebrated the local connection between the base and the community.

They had representatives of local organizations and schools and others there, in addition, incidentally, to the Lord Lieutenant, with whom I had a friendly word. And I got a sense, I believe, of what lies behind the debate we're having today. And all I would say to my noble friend is that it is possible that we might lose something valuable by proceeding with this clause. But I would be very grateful and interested to hear what my noble friend has to say in reply to this debate, because I have an open mind, but I think some valid points have been made.

02:23:41 - 02:32:09

Rupert Ponsonby

I'm chairman of the current Council of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations and I'm extremely grateful to my noble friends for putting down these clause stand part amendments. Since the Haldane reforms of the early 20th century, most recently renewed in the 1996 Reserve Forces Act, to which my noble friend the Earl of Minto referred, many of the functions supporting the reserves and cadets have until now been provided by autonomous regional organisations known as the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations, 13 in number, with a wide membership across the UK. They are made up of former reservists, regulars and cadets, employers, politicians and representatives of universities and of local government, all of whom wish actively to support the reserves and cadets from the communities in the regions. These 13 regional RFCAs are being abolished in the bill. Each of these RFCAs is run by an executive overseen by a board which is elected by the members and, as the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig of Radley said, wholly unremunerated.

Each board holds the executive to account for delivering against service level agreements covering estate management, support to cadet units and carrying out employer and community engagement on behalf of the reserves, cadets and indeed defence generally, including running the employer recognition scheme. The unremunerated board is to be done away with in the bill. The county Lord Lieutenants are appointed as the RFCAs' presidents and vice presidents. The bill removes the involvement of the Lord Lieutenants. According to the Defence Council's own RFCA regulations, appointments of members of boards are already made in accordance with the Office of the Commissioner for Public Appointments guidance.

Procedures for this are specified in regulations and incorporated in each RFCA's scheme of association with senior appointments such as regional chairs approved by the Defence Council. The 13 boards are each represented on a regulated national board which has financial authority delegated from MOD through its chief executive to deliver five principal service level agreements with the MOD, the Royal Navy, the Army, the Royal Air Force and the Defence Infrastructure Organisation. This is scrutinised by a sponsor board comprising the MOD's Reserve Forces and Cadets branch, the service level agreements holders, the chair of the RFCA board, MOD financial teams and others as required. The RFCAs' national board consists of the chairs of the 13 regional RFCAs with a paid national chief executive and other non-executive members plus representatives from the services. The body is responsible for a budget of about 120 million pounds, mostly spent in small sums across several thousand reserve centres and cadet huts.

This estate is spread from the remotest location in the Scottish islands and islands to the cities across the UK. It is the membership and association boards that have the expertise and connections in these vastly differing locations, which is vital to effective allocation of funds, cadet development and reserve support all around the UK. This professionally led but volunteer-based federated structure is familiar to anyone who has volunteered in a local political party, a parish, a sporting association or a charity. The membership is to be abolished by the bill. My Lords, recognising the RFCAs' local roots, the Strategic Defence Review commented in relation to the critical importance of the need for defence to reconnect with society, and I quote: "The RFCAs will be a valuable organisation in delivering this engagement."

My Lords, an exemplar of course of what the Prime Minister is trying to achieve in as indeed the noble and gallant Lord Lord Stirrup said.

In 2019, the MOD instituted a review into the RFCAs, known as the Sullivan Review, to which a number of noble Lords have referred. The vast majority, the vast majority of the recommendations in the Sullivan report have been implemented. But the last government did not implement the one to convert the RFCAs into a NDPB. This is now revived in section 38 and schedule 6 of the Armed Forces Bill, which is intended to convert the 13 RFCAs into a single national RFCA NDPB. It would make sweeping changes to the status quo, centralizing decision making and removing from statute the entire nationwide volunteer membership and the involvement of the Lord Lieutenant.

As the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig said, in a March 2025 report, the National Audit Office specifically contemplated a structure other than that being pursued. In its report on its investigation into the MOD's oversight of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations, the NAO concluded, and I quote, the MOD must mitigate the remaining legal and financial risks identified in the Sullivan review, whether that is by creating a new NDPB or further strengthening the current model to support the evolving role of the Reserve Forces. In doing this, the MOD will need to consider how best to retain the benefits of the RFCA's local identities and connections, while ensuring the RFCAs provide cost-effective, high-quality infrastructure and support services. So the NAO specifically acknowledged that creating a new NDPB was not the only way of doing this, but that further strengthening of the current model was indeed an option. This has been completely ignored in the drafting of the bill.

Furthermore, the NAO said that the MOD would need to consider how best to retain the benefits of the RFCA's local identities and connections. The route the MOD have opted to follow will in fact remove the benefits of the RFCA's local identities and connections, rather than building a bespoke organization that retains the strength, local and national identity of the current structure and one which addresses the risks identified. My Lords, a Cabinet Office memo dated the 4th of October 2007, when the Labour Party was of course in office, specifically stated, and I quote, the Cabinet Office view is that the RFCAs occupy a unique position within the central government sector and do not fall into any of the existing administrative classifications. In particular, they are not NDPBs. Not is underlined in that memo.

Crown status implies a closer relationship with central government than is typical for NDPBs. Some of the NDPB controls, such as those on appointments, would not be appropriate for RFCAs, end of quote. Furthermore, my Lords, after a meeting with the MOD's permanent secretary in September 2025, his post-meeting note stated, and I quote, Sullivan should now be regarded as overtaken by events by SDR/NAO report. And concerns were raised about the NDPB approach risking national linkages, as is currently the case through the 13 associations, end of quote. My Lords, in removing all involvement of the voluntary membership, the changes proposed in respect of the RFCAs in the Armed Forces Bill, by amending the Reserve Forces Act of 1996, fly in the face of Prime Minister Starmer's stated aim to push power down to the regions of the UK.

The permanent secretary's position as accounting officer requires him to have oversight of the funds allocated to the RFCAs. This accountability and financial authority is indeed already in place and vested through a letter of delegation through the RFCA's chief executive. None of the things being done through the Armed Forces Bill, replacing the current board with unelected so-called independent people selected by ministers on advice through the OCPA process with no special commitment to the reserve forces and cadets, will do anything at all to improve the permanent secretary's oversight of the funds, but they will do considerable damage to a large body of people who can advocate for defense in the regions and nations of the UK. So my Lords, I support my noble friend's amendment.

02:32:09 - 02:35:03

Edward Faulks

I too support this amendment. I took part in the debate initiated by the noble Lord, Lord De Mauley, in January 2020, when it appeared that the then government was leaning towards adopting the recommendation that now appears from the Sullivan report. All the backbench speakers on that occasion were against that course of action, with the possible exception of the Labour front bench who did not commit themselves one way or another. The only speaker who was very cautiously in favor was the noble lady, Baroness Goldie, who is normally, as we know, a formidable advocate for the government or any other cause. On this occasion, she acknowledged all the points that were made as it were against the government's suggestion, but nevertheless advanced some arguments in its favor.

I wonder if her heart was really in it. Anyway, I look forward to hearing from the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, whom we much respect, about the real advantages that will follow from this organization, reorganization, advantages which are supposed to compensate for the undoubted loss of the various links which have been so eloquently described around the House. In particular, I ask him to clarify whether there is any legal requirement to make this change. I suspect his notes will contain a number of words like governance, accountability, assurance, transparency, and public confidence. But stripping away the language, I need to be convinced that there is any actual legal requirement for a change of this sort.

Turning to the budget, I think it was mentioned in the debate in 2020, this was said to be 112 million pounds. Now this is a trivial sum when it's compared with 333 odd billion we spend on welfare and social security, it is of course. But is it felt that there's been some financial failure generally on the part of the organizations apart from the changes which have been implemented from the Sullivan report? Is it considered better to have paid rather than volunteer participants in the organization? How much will this increase expenditure?

And of course, as has been said a number of times, how does this fit in with the devolution agenda? At the moment, whilst I don't in any way challenge the sincerity of the civil servants who've no doubt advised the government that the change is for the better, I think the House needs persuading that the unique characteristics that the RFCAs have are worth sacrificing on some of the altar of tidying up or centralization.

02:35:03 - 02:36:11

Richard Dannatt

My Lords, I intend to speak to further amendments in this general area later on today, but I don't wish to repeat the very sensible arguments the noble Lords and noble and gallant Lords have already made as far as this matter is concerned. But it seems to me that we are taking with this fundamental series of changes a pretty large sledgehammer to crack a nut.

That nut is the Sullivan report of 2019, which itself has been largely attended to and many of the changes already made. So I think the sledgehammer is being applied to the wrong nut. But my greatest concerns are that if these measures were to be implemented, the local character of our reserve and cadet forces would be changed beyond recognition and the volunteering ethos on which they currently depend would itself go. Many noble Lords will know that since COVID, so many of our volunteering organisations have struggled to recruit further volunteers, and I believe we would be putting a stake through the heart of our reserve forces and cadets associations and the local character and volunteering ethos of them if these measures were to go through.

02:36:11 - 02:41:20

Mark Lancaster

My Lords, I, this is one of those moments when it would be very easy to remain firmly in my seat. I declare my interest as the Assistant Chief of Defence Staff, Reserves and Cadets, and therefore find myself something as a piggy in the middle of this debate, working as I do for the government in that role. I have sought advice about speaking in this debate, and I do so strictly in a personal capacity. And I'm worried slightly about the very binary nature of this debate. And I sense that there are things that could be done perhaps to reassure this House.

I should also specifically declare that if this non-departmental public body is created, then I would be the Ministry of Defence representative on that body, albeit ex-officio and unpaid and with no voting rights. But nonetheless, this is not a competition for who can be the greatest advocate of the RFCAs. I am certainly in amongst them, and they have done tremendous work for many years. And we must, as both the Sullivan report, the PAC report, and the NAO report says, do everything we can to maintain this goodness. It cannot be an attack on them.

And in many ways, I am frustrated that we are focusing down in on its organisation rather than right now, at the most crucial time as Article 3 becomes ever more important than homeland defence, rather than focusing on what future role the RFCAs can play in the defence of our realm and through their local links and generating wider awareness in society as to how much more could be done and their absolutely vital role that they must do. And instead, we are getting ourselves wrapped around our handles slightly through what is a technical change in their approach. But I do not see it that we are simply wiping away the regional nature of the RFCAs. There are absolutely technical matters that need to be resolved over representation. I understand the calls for voting rights, which will be discussed later, and indeed whether or not members should be paid or not.

That can all be discussed in detail. But I do recognise that on the face of the bill, there are elements which perhaps pose questions which have yet to be answered. And as sort of piggy in the middle and hopefully somebody who can draw the House together, I fully recognise the need now to implement the SDR recommendations to increase the size of the reserve by 20% when financial conditions allow, or indeed when it comes to cadets, a key element that RFCAs deliver but nonetheless hasn't really been mentioned much in this debate, the vital role that we must do to continue to expand the cadets. These are all things which I see in the future RFCAs doing and continuing at a very regional level to be able to do that. But we have to recognise that in successive reports, there have been criticisms over governance, there have been recommendations for legal change, and there have been challenges about the relationship, as much criticisms of the Ministry of Defence as of the RFCAs, and let's be clear about that, about the relationship between them, particularly when it comes to financial matters.

And I do think that there is a strong argument. I mean, what I haven't heard in this debate is if we don't go down that NDPB route, what are the proposed suggestions about strengthening that financial relationship? It is public money at the end of the day. What are the suggestions about changing the legal relationship between the MOD and RFCAs? I've not heard alternative suggestions, but perhaps we can explore that in the future.

But if I may as a bridge, looking to, you know, the Minister and indeed other members of the House, perhaps one sensible way forward as we move forward, and perhaps the Minister can respond to this, is that there are things potentially that can be done in secondary legislation, and I understand that there has been some consultation with RFCAs, that may put some of these fears to one side and address them. So perhaps a sensible way forward is rather than this very binary approach of trying to find a way where perhaps your Lordships' House can come together with a pragmatic sensible way where we address the issues of governance, and I do for one feel, and I'm sorry if it's not a unified view of this of your Lordships' House, I do feel that NDPB is one way of doing it, but maybe not, you know, in a purist sense where we can accommodate the specific needs of the regional nature of the RFCAs within that NDPA, but by using secondary legislation to reassure your Lordships' House as to some of the things, as to some of these issues can be addressed.

02:41:20 - 02:47:34

Julie Smith

My Lords, I thought I was going to rise from these benches and be able to say I agree with all the noble and noble and gallant Lords who have spoken so far in this debate because there appeared to be uniformity from across the House. And we are very often used to that on defence matters. We last week at committee first day of committee stage, the were discussions outside the chamber, some of the doorkeepers were saying, well, we might have to get taxis this evening. And I said, are you sure we're not going to finish by 10 o'clock? And they looked at me and said, really, do you think so?

But of course with something like military precision, we finished at five to 10, we finished all our groups, and people kept saying afterwards, well, of course, it was military precision, what else did you expect? But my Lords, it wasn't military precision that meant we dealt with the business expeditiously on day one of committee stage. It was that by and large, the proposals that we were debating and the amendments that we were discussing were areas where we were probing, broadly we were supportive of what His Majesty's Government was proposing, and as so often on defence matters, His Majesty's official opposition and the Liberal Democrat benches and the cross benches were supportive of what the government was trying to do. But this evening we have amendments clause 38 stand part and schedule 6 stand part or not stand part, where the House is virtually united to suggest that the government really does need to think again. If I was speaking merely from the back benches, I would simply ask the government why, why clause 38?

But as I'm speaking from the front bench, I feel that it's appropriate just to outline the fact that from these benches, we share very much the concerns that have been raised, particularly about the losing the local connection. I had mutterings from behind me saying, "I agree with Lord De Mauley." And certainly the concerns that have been raised from across the chamber, but particularly the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley, earlier on in the debate, very rightly pointed out the issues of the importance of the reserves, but also the local connection and the fact that the RFCA had acknowledged that reserves and cadets are increasingly important for the defense of our realm and that this was something also highlighted in the SDR. The noble Lord, Lord Lancaster, who was the only dissenting voice really, and even he said he wanted to be a bridge, speaking I think as a non-affiliated peer, but apparently from the Conservative benches, so I'm not quite sure. But he is the only noble Lord who so far has suggested that maybe clause 38 is the right way forward.

Is it needed?

But my Lords, he reminded the House that the SDR talked about wanting to increase the number of reserves by 20%, when resources allow, in brackets. My Lords, surely we shouldn't be waiting till resources allow. What we should be doing is working with the structures that we have through the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations, strengthening those local connections, thinking of ways to ensure that we enhance the local connection and also the local resilience, because what we haven't yet done as a country is engage with the national conversation that the SDR said we needed. And how better to do it than work with local people, local reserve forces, but in particular also the cadets. And the noble Lord, Lord Lancaster, rightly pointed out we hadn't said much about the cadets, but surely that is an area where we need to be thinking about strengthening the cadet forces, again strengthening the local connection, but really looking at ways in which we can ensure that we have perhaps a pipeline to recruitment, resilience, and a sense that really we are beginning the national conversation.

And I'm going to conclude with a statement from Portsmouth City Council, not my local area, haven't done what the noble Lady Baroness Fraser did and talked about my area, partly because as a Liverpudlian, I do feel that perhaps the North West is now getting quite a lot of coverage thanks to the new Prime Minister. But Portsmouth City Council, in line with its geographical position and the extent of its naval commitments, has a very strong commitment to the Armed Forces Covenant, but also to the South East Reserve Forces and Cadets Association. And they made an official contribution to the committee stage call for evidence in the other place. And in particular, what they remind us of, as some noble Lords have already done this evening, is the fact that this isn't just about the individual RFCAs, but it's also about working with local employers. And if we accept clause 38, there is a very real danger not just that we lose the history, which is important, but also that we lose very significant aspects of current practice that work well and could be enhanced and should be enhanced.

02:47:35 - 02:54:37

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, it's a great privilege and pleasure to stand up in your Lordships' House and make the case for clause 38. Can I just return, if your Lordships' House will allow me, just to clarify something to the Earl of Minto. The service of notice for call-out will be both by post and email. I actually meant that by the remark I made and I realize I didn't, so I apologize to the Earl of Minto and to the House for that. So it'll be both by post and by email for that call-out notice.

I thought I'd said that and meant that, but clearly I didn't. I found out through a variety of means that I hadn't said what I meant to say. Anyway, there we go. So that's that. Can I just start, however, by also saying something else.

Lots of people have made a lot of really important points. And as everybody knows in this House, I will consider those and how we take those forward. I can't walk on water on these things and persuade everybody that I can do everything. But I hope your Lordships will know that I will try to do as much as I can to take account of the various points and important points that have been made. But I wanted to start by one thing.

Lord Fawkes, it's not a legal requirement. It's the recommendations of various reports that the government seeks to implement. But let me just say this for clarity's sake before I make the formal remarks that I make, because as your Lordships' House will know, I like to make some informal remarks before I make the formal ones. Nobody in this House doubts the importance of the reserves that take place, the cadets, the organization, the work of the Lord Lieutenants, the charities that are involved. Many of your Lordships do far more than I do, even as a minister, to support those local organizations.

And Lord de Mauley is one of the best examples of that. Nobody seeks to undermine that. Nobody seeks to do anything that would in some way not ensure that that can carry on. I was with Lord Elliott, he was there a moment ago in this place, in Enniskillen just on Saturday, where the reserves, the Lord Lieutenants, the cadets at the RAF show there, which I went to to support, was phenomenal. Absolutely phenomenal to see that work that's going on there.

Nobody seeks to undermine that. Nobody seeks to do anything that would in any way hinder that or not help that. On Saturday, this Saturday coming, I'm going to Grantham for the reserves' pass-out, rather, that's taking place there, because of the significance and importance of that. So it doesn't matter whether it's the reserves, doesn't matter whether it's the cadets. Ministerially, the Baroness Goldie, Earl Minto, Baroness Smith no doubt, the Lord Stirrup through his long and distinguished career, the Lord Craig through his long and distinguished career, Lord Dannatt through his and many others, all of us are committing ourselves to pursue that purpose, which is crucial to our nation.

Whether it's Scotland, whether it's Wales, whether it's Northern Ireland or whether it's the regions of England. It's crucial and fundamental to us that we do that. Each of the three reports which I'll mention in my remarks, each of those three reports emphasized that. What they said, however, alongside that, and Lord de Mauley is right and in my remarks I'll reference that, it did say either/or to make sure that with respect to the PAC report I think it was.

But each of those reports said the current framework needed to be revised and looked at. And in answer, my view of this is that what the national body does, it creates a strategic oversight for the new structure, for a structure which would allow the regional councils to be stronger and more purposeful in what they are doing with the financial oversight and clarity that a strategic body would give them. That's how devolution works. You don't just let the mayors of the country do exactly what they want. There is a national strategic framework policy which is set, which allows those local bodies, those local government or whatever to function and to function effectively.

And that's what this seeks to do. I just reference to again before I make these formal remarks, what is on the face of the bill, yes, is the establishment of the new body, the new RFCA, but also on page 136, I'll have to put my glasses on. Slows the rhetoric, but there we go. 136, I don't often wear glasses, as you've noticed, I don't often wear glasses, but on page 136, it lays out on 136 and then indeed onto 137, it puts on the face of the bill in primary legislation, regional councils. How those are actually set up.

The RFCA, and I just say this to Baroness Fraser, the RFCA must establish a committee for each area of the United Kingdom as may be specified in regulations. Now, that would include Scotland, that would include Wales and all of those things. Now, I just say that that is laid out there and then it goes on about the various regulations that can be made. The only point I will in a moment, the only point I would then make is that what it then goes on to specify with each of the other things that come for it. And we'll deal with all the various range of amendments about membership and all of those things about whether people are paid or unpaid.

All of those things will be dealt with in regulations. Now, I realize that the debate then becomes whether it should be primary or secondary, but it's on the face of the bill that they will be dealt with by regulations. And as I'll make in the formal remarks that I make, those draft regulations are in draft form at the moment. I will share those draft regulations with members of the committee before report stage, where they can look at those regulations and decide whether they answer some of the points that they would make or not. So that we don't just have a situation which sometimes happens with government where draft regulations are just presented and you either vote for it or not without any sort of proper ability for people to properly scrutinize what's in those draft regulations and whether they agree with them or not, of course.

02:54:37 - 02:54:46

Annabel Fraser

Thank you. It was just whether the devolved nations were assured of a seat on the national board.

02:54:46 - 03:02:46

Vernon Coaker

Again, those are the sorts of things that will be sorted out in the regulations which I referred to. What I'm saying to the noble, laid out in primary legislation is the fact that we will be able to ensure that the regions and nations of the country are represented and have the various functions that the noble Baroness would want. Now, I can't satisfy everybody with those remarks and all I'm saying is I'm laying out the alternative. Lord de Mauley will disagree, I'm sure, with what I've just said and I fundamentally respect, there's nothing I can do about it, I respect the point that Lord de Mauley will make about that. It may be the Earl of Minto and others within the room will say the minister's totally wrong, he's destroying and undermining the regional bodies.

What I'm saying is the alternative view is to say we will set up a strong coordinated body at a national level which will take on board certain functions and then within that the regional framework, which is absolutely fundamental for both the reserves and cadets, will be established to deliver in a in what we regard, the government regards as a more powerful and effective way. Now that's the debate that goes to the crux of what we're arguing about. I, as I say, many people have spent more years than I have developing the reserves and cadet associations and have spent their lives to it and no one wishes to detract from that. So I just think it's important to to say that because I, you know, as I say, the people represented in here, your lordships represented here, have made speech after speech saying what the government is proposing is wrong and I just think it's important that I from a government point of view articulate a point of view which is different but not trying to be disrespectful to the positions that the people have. My lords, clause 38 creates a new public body to deliver vital support to the reserves forces and cadets association.

The government fully recognises, as I've said, the valuable contribution RFCAs have made over many decades through their support to the reserve forces, the cadet movement, employers and local communities. They provide an important link between defence and society. In an increasingly uncertain security environment, the RFCA will have an important role in supporting defence's contribution to national resilience. Through the links with reservists, employers, local authorities and communities across the United Kingdom, they help strengthen the relationships and structures that underpin defence's ability to respond to crises and support the protection of our critical national infrastructure. In these dangerous times, these functions are more important than ever, as the noble Lord Earl Minto will recognise.

My lords, the RFCAs not only play a vital role for our reserves forces, but also for our cadets, who are at the heart of defence's engagement with young people. The government believes that clause 38 is necessary to ensure that these important functions can continue within a governance framework that meets modern public sector expectations. The case for reform has been identified in a series of independent reviews. The 2019 Sullivan review concluded that the existing structure should be regularised and streamlined by bringing the Council of Reserve Forces and Cadets Association associations and the 13 RFCAs together in a single executive non-departmental public body. That review envisaged implementation through primary legislation and identified a stronger governance framework as the best means of securing the long-term future of the organisation.

More recently, as the noble Lord Lord De Mauley mentioned, the National Audit Office investigation into the MOD oversight of the RFCAs found that legal and financial risks remained within the current arrangements and concluded that the department must address those risks, but as the noble Lord pointed out, whether through creating a new NDPB or by further strengthening the current arrangements. And I accept that point that the noble Lord quite rightly made. He won't agree, but the government have made a decision to do that through the creation of an NDPB. But he's quite right and I hope he recognises that I've recognised that he was factually correct in what he was saying. The Public Accounts Committee, however, went further, noting weaknesses in the current arrangements and recommending that the department report on progress towards establishing an NDPB.

The committee recognised the department would need to manage the limitations of the present structure until an NDPB is established. Therefore, clause 38 establishes a single national reserve forces and cadets association as an NDPB.

The reform is concerned with governance and accountability. It will provide a clear line of accountability, strengthening governance and financial oversight and ensure consistency in the administration of public funds and assets. Importantly, the government is not seeking to remove the local knowledge, regional expertise, or volunteer contributions that have long been central to the success of the RFCAs. Regional engagement and delivery will remain at the heart of the organization's work and mechanisms are included to preserve that strong regional representation within the new structure. Clause 38 also enables the orderly transfer of staff, property, rights, and liabilities, ensuring continuity of service and support to reservists, cadets, and defense more broadly.

The government's view is that removing clause 38 would prevent these reforms from being implemented and would leave in place arrangements that successive independent reviews, Parliament's Public Accounts Committee, and the National Audit Office have all concluded require significant reform or mitigation. It would also delay the creation of a governance structure better suited to supporting defense resilience and national preparedness in an increasingly challenging security environment. If I could just refer, a number of amendments have been related which we'll discuss in other groups in relation to this part of the bill. These amendments seek to set out on the face of the bill detail that would be set out in secondary legislation. And again, to repeat what I said earlier, in that spirit, I wanted to make clear at the outset that I am happy to share a copy with your lordship's house of the draft regulations ahead of report stage.

The Ministry of Defense has already shared these draft regulations with a number of bodies, such as some of the RFCAs, and I hope this will assist noble lords in scrutinizing the practical effect of these measures and provide further reassurance on how the provisions are intended to operate in practice. With that, can I thank noble lords for the contributions that have been made. I will reflect on the points that have been made and how, although I think consensus might be difficult, certainly through the draft regulations we may address some of the different points that people have made in this debate around staying clause part, but also in the further groups that we'll discuss as we move forward our consideration.

03:02:46 - 03:06:31

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My lords, I am most grateful to the noble lord the minister, who as we all know has huge respect across this house for his reply with his customary passion and belief in the position that he takes, and to all noble lords from all sides of the house, even the non-affiliated ones, who have so strongly contributed with great consideration to what is clearly a very strongly held views and very contained within a lot of understanding, whether it's the noble and gallant or people with direct relationships with the forces and the cadets and the reservists, either directly or through family ties. It just goes to show how important this is and how it is absolute right and proper that we have a clear understanding of exactly what is being proposed here.

I fear I remain unpersuaded. I'm sure the noble lord the minister won't be surprised. The noble lord the minister has told us in effect that the new body will be designed to preserve the spirit of the membership and the voluntary ethos, and I don't deny that, but it's a question of how that will be carried out. I don't doubt the sincerity of the government's intention. What I do doubt is that spirit can survive the destruction of the structure that has for over a century created the conditions in which that spirit has been developed and flourished.

There's no doubt it flourished, as anybody who's been to a county show, anybody who's seen recruiters or whatever it is out and about will know. The minister has not told us how that ethos is to be guaranteed rather than merely hoped for, nor with respect has the government yet told this house what specific operational improvements the cadet and reserve forces this reorganization will deliver. The government seems more concerned with consistency and ensuring a clearer statutory footing. This is all bureaucratic language emanating from Whitehall and do not really reflect the wishes of those who are actually involved in these organizations. I remain of the view, and I think the tone in the house will probably support that view in the main, that I set out at the beginning of the group.

This change serves the convenience of the center rather more than it serves the volunteers, the cadets, or the communities that the RFCAs have bound to our armed forces since before the first county associations were formed. I don't think that it is sufficient reason to abolish 13 historic voluntary county-based bodies and the links to the lieutenancy which they carry. And my lords, that is why along with my noble friend Lord De Mauley, I oppose this reform. It is a solution in search of a problem. It's an attempt to fix something that isn't actually broken and it destroys the very features, the voluntary spirit, the county identity, and the link to the lieutenancy and the crown that makes the reserve and the cadet forces the valuable and universally respected organizations that they are.

However, my lords, this is committee and I've made my point. I will reflect very carefully on what the minister has said and I give notice that absent a considerably fuller response from the government on the questions I've put, I intend to return to the matter on report and if necessary to test the opinion of the house. For now, my lords, however, I beg leave to withdraw my opposition to the question that clause 38 stand part of the bill.

03:06:31 - 03:06:46

Speaker 82

The question is that clause 38 stand part of the bill. As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. After clause 38, amendment 40, Lord Harlech.

03:06:46 - 03:17:50

Jasset David Cody Harlech

My lords, it's a new day of committee and so I declare my interest as a serving officer in the army reserve once again. In moving amendment 40, I shall also speak to amendments 41, 45, 69, and 70, and I'm grateful to my noble friends Lady Penn and Lord De Mauley for adding their names in support to my amendments. And let me also preface my amendments by reiterating my intent behind all of the amendments which I did so on the first day of committee. They are all aimed at improving the lived experience of reservists in order to boost recruiting and retention and therefore enhance the operational effectiveness of the armed forces.

So I begin by welcoming the government's amendment 38, which allows call-out notices to be served by email. It's sensible, I support it, but it also illustrates the point behind this group. We're getting steadily better at calling reservists up, but we have said almost nothing about the civilian conditions which determine whether they're still serving and able to be a serving reservist when we call. I think there's common ground across your Lordship's House on that objective, and the noble Baroness Lady Smith of Newnham has amendments later today which approach the same problem from a different direction. The select committee on this bill in the other place put the point plainly.

It welcomed the changes to recall liability and then noted that the measures focus on the strategic reserve and do not in themselves achieve the strategic defence review's ambition, which in my humble opinion is too modest anyway, of an increase of 20% larger active reserve. That growth will be produced by the conditions in which people serve, and those conditions are set at the reservist's desk on a Monday morning rather than in the drill hall. So, amendment 40 would require employers with 50 or more employees to publish and maintain a policy of employment of reservists. There is no sanction, there is no civil liability, the Secretary of State supplies a model policy, and under amendment 69 it does not commence for 12 months. This is already the required standard of silver and gold employers under the defence employer recognition scheme.

The difficulty with a voluntary scheme is that it reaches the converted. The employers who need a policy have never heard of it. There are roughly 38,000 medium-sized businesses in this country, and that is where a great many reservists work and where there is no human resources function to absorb the question when it arises. A reservist in a firm with no policy negotiates from nothing. Every request for time away is a personal favour rather than an entitlement, granted or refused according to the temperament of whoever is in the chair.

And when that person moves on, the answer changes; a written policy would end the line manager lottery. Subsection 2B requires the policy to address what happens to pay, pension, seniority and continuity of employment during mobilisation. Most reservists have no idea what happens to any of those things because nobody has ever written it down, and that is a remarkable thing to discover at the point of deployment. I turn now to my main effort, which is amendment 41, which is at the heart of this group. Most reservists fund their own training out of their annual leave.

They spend their holiday entitlement on annual camp and have to spread the remainder amongst family commitments, personal holiday and the incidentals that real life throws in their path. That is the position we're in today and I don't think it is defensible. So this amendment would give 10 working days of unpaid leave, unpaid leave a year for annual continuous training or for promotion courses. It becomes applicable only after the employee has completed 26 weeks with the civilian employer.

It requires 28 days written notice and a certificate from the commanding officer. It excludes employers with fewer than 10 employees, it confers no right to be paid, and it counts against any contractual entitlement the employer already offers. Section 50 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 already gives unpaid time off for public duties to magistrates, to local councillors, to school governors, and to members of health bodies. So Parliament has decided that sitting on a planning committee merits protected time off, it has not yet decided that training for the defence of the realm does. My Lords, I think that is a very difficult proposition to explain to a reserve soldier.

10 days is already the gold standard under the Defence Employer Recognition Scheme, and the Civil Service has offered paid leave of this kind for well over a decade. It is a fair question why what the government expects of itself as an employer is too much to expect of anybody else. Looking at our Five Eyes counterparts, Australia's Defence Reserve Service Protection Act 2001 requires employers to release reservists for training, not just mobilisation, for training. Our own Act of 1985 protects mobilisation only, so the current gap is legislative, not cultural. Let me anticipate the objections, including of those on my own front bench.

First, that this is a burden on employers. It is unpaid, it is capped at 10 days, it requires four weeks' notice, excludes the smallest firms, and under Amendment 70 does not commence for a year. If that is an unacceptable burden, then we should be honest that we're not really serious about a whole force. Second, that an absolute right is too rigid and employers must be able to refuse. A refusable right is precisely the position reservists have now, and it is exactly why they use annual leave instead.

The notice period and the annual cap are what protect the employer, and they are real protections. Third, that this is a day-one right. It's not, it arises only after the reservist has committed 26 weeks of employment with the civilian employer, the same qualifying period this House insisted upon for unfair dismissal. So I turn to something which has happened since these amendments were tabled. Last Friday, the BBC and the Times reported that the Army has been instructed to halt non-essential training exercises, and that collective training for United Kingdom-based units is suspended for most of this year on budgetary grounds.

The Army has not denied it, it says it is prioritising the activity which contributes most directly to readiness, and I understand why it would say that. But this bears directly on the amendments before your Lordships' House. A reservist books their annual continuous training months ahead, clears it with their employer, and very often pays for it out of their own annual leave. If the exercise is then cancelled, they don't get that leave back, and the employer who has released them draws their own conclusions about how seriously the department takes its own training. Every cancellation of that kind spends employer goodwill that took years to accumulate.

I would therefore ask the noble Lord the Minister three things. Firstly, whether reserve collective training and the annual continuous training period fall within the scope of the current pause. Second, what has been cancelled or curtailed for the reserve so far this financial year. Third, 4.7 billion pounds of the 15 billion in the defence investment plan remains to be confirmed at the budget on the 28th of October, and I would be grateful if he could say whether reserve pay and training are protected within that settlement and undertake to write to members of the committee once the position is known.

I put that in support of these amendments rather than against the government. If money is tight, the measures which cost the exchequer nothing become more important and not less, and everything in this group is of that kind. Amendment 45 is the mechanism which makes amendment 40 matter. It would require the national procurement policy statement to address how contracting authorities take account of a supplier's arrangements for employing reservists. These authorities must already have regard to that statement under the Procurement Act 2023, so this creates no new machinery and no new liability.

There is one fact here the committee ought to have. The current statement disapplies the social value priority for the Ministry of Defence in relation to defense and security contracts. So the one department whose suppliers most obviously employ reservists is therefore the department least required to weight it. And I would be grateful if the noble lord the minister could explain how that came about. Amendment 69 and 70 are consequential, they provide the 12-month commencement for the two duties, and I move them formally.

My lords, this bill asks reservists to be available later in life, at shorter notice, and on lower thresholds. Attendance at annual continuous training is the single biggest determinant of a reserve unit's readiness, and promotion courses generate the non-commissioned officers without whom mobilization at scale is not possible, whatever powers this bill confers. My lords, these are modest amendments and they cost the exchequer nothing. I beg to move.

03:17:50 - 03:17:56

Speaker 84

Amendment proposed, after clause 38, insert the new clause printed on the marshalled list.

03:17:56 - 03:21:58

Hugo Swire

My lords, before we move on, because I suspect this is not going to detain us too long, I'd just like to tease from the government front bench a couple of questions. As I said in earlier remarks, I think we are going through something of a sea change, rather too late in the day, in the way we look at our reserves and our responsiveness and our state of alert in this country. And I would just ask in that respect, we understand it's easier for larger companies to let people go for training because they have more people. But it's really the smaller companies, I think, which we should spend a little bit more time thinking how we can better assist them. So with that in mind, in both cases of the large and smaller companies, what are we actually doing to promote the idea that it is a good thing for them to release their employees to act, to take part in some activities involving the military?

Are we actually actively doing that? The second thing is, which suddenly struck me in terms of people being released from other duties, it seems to me rather ridiculous that people on the reserves are not exempt from jury service. Because that means, particularly if you're a small employer, you might have to let somebody go not only for their reserve training and time, but also for jury service. And that takes a huge whack out of somebody's time.

And however we monitor these things, it's almost impossible to ensure that people ultimately aren't being penalized in their careers for taking time off. And I would like to know what the government is actually doing to monitor this on an ongoing basis to make sure that people who are actively involved in the reserves are not being penalized further down the line. My Lords, there does seem to be something of a disconnect here in our thinking. On the one hand, as I said earlier, the talk about mobilizing many more veterans, something like 69,000 in an exercise next year, just at the same time when we're telling our reserve forces that they cannot have money for training and equipment. So again, I would ask the minister, what is the government's thinking about that?

If we are going to mobilize these people, is it going to be a paper exercise or are we actually going to invite them to turn up? Are they going to be given equipment? What is the current thinking about this or is it just a catchy headline? My Lords, we've debated the whole issue of preparedness in this country and will continue to do so for obvious reasons going forward. Of that I'm absolutely sure.

The noble Lord, Lord Harlech, mentioned a number of issues with which I concur and I'm broadly supportive of many of the amendments, some of which I think are probing, that he's tabled this afternoon, or we are discussing, debating this afternoon. But and he talked about Australia and the difference in their approach to these matters than ours. And I think we have lessons to learn from Australia. But why don't we also take into account what they've been doing so successfully in Switzerland for really decades now, whereby almost anyone of a working age and beyond is required to do service in the reserves and they do that at weekends. It's a very bonding exercise.

You can be somebody's boss in the week and that person can be your radio operator at the weekend. And it does engender in a country a sense of purpose, of unity and, my Lords, preparedness, which is what this must all be about.

03:21:58 - 03:23:03

Reg Empey

Just a brief point. Lord Harlech mentioned the training issues and I have raised this with the minister and will come back to it in another issue. But dealing with the employment issues, we have discussed the issue of people being released. But having had responsibility for fair employment matters, what about somebody being employed if an employer happens to know that that person is a reservist? Because that means that they could say, well, I don't want to have that man or woman employed because they'll be a nuisance to me and I will have to let them go on release.

So that is one step before you get to the actual point of being an employee. So the question is, is a person to be discriminated against on the basis of being a reservist by a future employer who happens to know that that person is a reservist, whether their picture appears in the local paper or it's word of mouth or whatever? So I think there is an issue there to be addressed.

03:23:03 - 03:27:15

Annabel Goldie

My Lords, if I could just address the noble Lord Empey's point, I think we're going to come to the issue of protections for employees in the next group. And I'm just rising at the moment to support my noble friend Lord Harlech about the need to have certainty for employers. And I declare my interest as an employer of in a small charity at Cerebral Palsy Scotland and as the mother of a serving reservist. No, she's about to go on her captain's course tomorrow, I think. So she has been negotiating with her employer time off.

No, she's about to go on her captain's course tomorrow, I think. So she has been negotiating with her employer time off. And I think to me this group of amendments comes to the heart of something that bothers me every time we talk about reservists and employers in that the MOD, it seems to me, always seems to look at this from their point of view. And we get the things like the Defence Employer Recognition Scheme demonstrating to us that look at all these wonderful companies that have signed up. And that's fine if you are a silver or a gold large company.

But there aren't enough of them. And the point that my noble friend Lord Swire raised about what are we doing to highlight the benefits of employing reservists to employers, I think is one well made and something that I don't think we do well enough. And these amendments take the existing requirements of the silver and gold employers and offer it to a wider group of people. Now, the example of public duties is a really good one. At Cerebral Palsy Scotland, we were finding ourselves being completely hammered by jury call-up.

So our clinicians who make appointments six weeks in advance were being called up for jury service, which in Scotland is even more likely to happen because you have 15 people on the jury rather than 12. And so we decided we needed a public duties policy. And it was because of my daughter and because of the need for that that we had to consider as a small employer how would we treat reservists. And we have a policy, I'm glad to say, that enables us to lay out what we would do in terms of time off and all the rest of it. But I think these amendments lay it down and are really important to give that certainty for employees to the vast range of employers.

And not just as I am seeing, and this is anecdotal, but I see that the current active reserves are disproportionately made up of people from organisations, public sector, civil servants, teachers, who have, yeah, self-employed. And therefore that's because they don't have to ask for time or negotiate with their bosses for training days. So, and I would argue that I think not only does this put people off being in and remaining in the reserves, this uncertainty, but it also leads to the number of service days that active reserves can commit to if there is this uncertainty. And I was just trying to look up, but I think I'm right in saying that the number of service days that active reserves have served has decreased year on year. And I think measures like this would improve that.

And anything we can do to support employers to support our reservists would get my vote.

03:27:15 - 03:31:02

Rupert Ponsonby

My Lords, I support my noble friend Lord Horlock's amendments 40, 41 and 45 and I put my name to them.

In an era when the NATO Secretary General tells us we could be at war within three to five years, while I hesitate to make life more difficult for them, I think we have little option but to require those things which the amendments demand of employers. But, and this goes to my noble friend Lord Soames' and my noble friend Baroness Fraser's point, we need to do better by employers too. So as a quid pro quo, we should be arranging matters so that reservists' training adds more value in the civilian workplace, and so that the time employers allow reservists for military training is used more efficiently. Defence qualifications which produce skills which are significantly useful in the civilian workplace often have limited civilian recognition because no thought has been given to matching acquired skills to recognised civilian standards. Similarly, relevant civilian qualifications frequently don't transfer into the defence system purely because no thought has been given to it, and so time is wasted teaching people material they already know.

Too often, the army assumes a baseline level of zero knowledge rather than assessing existing competence. Qualified civilian paramedics who become reservists with the intention of becoming combat medical technicians are required to complete entry-level military medical technician training, which they've already done in their civilian workplaces, rather than focusing on the military application of the skills they already possess. A more intelligent approach that is pragmatic and less risk-averse is required. Employers also need to know that reservists' time is used well. Yet, my Lords, the brutal truth is that a lot of training is done in a way that wastes time.

Mandatory annual training consumes a disproportionate amount of the limited time available. For example, fire safety, manual handling, data protection and similar packages are repeated every year regardless of experience or previous completion. Rather than asking how reservists can fit into systems designed for the regular army, we should be asking how those systems can be redesigned to maximise the value generated within the limited time reservists and their employers are able to give. Courses across the board are often shaped to fill a fortnight rather than be designed pragmatically around the time actually required to achieve competence, wasting significant amounts of the time reservists commit and creating an impression of pointless bureaucracy. This approach values conformity over efficiency.

It's not helped by the fact that the system seems reluctant to open some training facilities out of hours and to ask regular training staff to work late and at weekends, which is time reservists really need to be used to be more efficient. Reserve training doctrine usually mirrors that of the regular army with an expectation that trade training should encompass every single thing required to operate a capability before an individual is considered employable. One has to ask oneself if this is the right approach for the reserve. In many professions, individuals are taught the minimum required to operate safely before building competence and experience on the job. My Lords, I'm convinced that if employers considered that the time reservists gave up for military training was well used and that much of the training and military experience was valuable in the workplace, they'd be more comfortable employing reservists.

At the same time, it would make being a reservist vastly more satisfying.

03:31:02 - 03:33:53

Julie Smith

My Lords, the amendments in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Horlock, and noble Lord, Lord de Mauley and Baroness Penn, bring together a range of issues that I think are important. Clearly, we need to think about the impact of the reservists going on their training for employers. But at second reading, the noble lady Baroness Dacres of Lewisham, who sadly I believe cannot participate at committee stage because she's now a government whip, but she came and spoke very compellingly about the importance of the reservists' contribution back in local government, that she'd seen the benefits of working with reservists and how that could contribute back into the workplace.

And picking up on Lord De Mauley's points, I think there is, there are ways in which we ought to be able to find synergies where the armed forces should be looking much more closely at what are the skills that reserves are bringing to the armed forces, not simply have we ticked off ten days of repeat training, but actually maybe a day of repeat training and then actually working with the skills. But equally, explaining to employers the value of the training, because small and medium-sized enterprises might not be aware of the benefits that can accrue to employing reservists. As the noble lady Baroness Fraser said, Lord MP's point will be raised I think in the next group. But these amendments would appear to be desirable, certainly from the perspective of those in the reserves, hopefully in terms of both recruitment and retention, but also potentially beneficial to employers for exactly the reasons that Baroness Fraser raised. That it's not simply a question of saying please give us your time, but actually giving clarity about the expectations and almost we need a template of, well this is what's required, so that if you're a small employer, you would actually be able very quickly to work out what was needed and individual reserves wouldn't be having to reinvent the wheel every time.

So from these benches, we support the amendments and hope that His Majesty's government might at least be able to listen and find ways, if not accepting the amendments as drafted, of finding a way of perhaps bringing amendments in lieu that would deal with some of these questions.

03:33:53 - 03:36:50

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, I also rise to speak to amendments 40, 41 and 45 tabled in the name of my noble friend Lord Harlech, along with my noble friends Baroness Penn and Lord De Mauley. My noble friend Lord Harlech has long been a doughty and most effective champion of our reserve forces, and these benches share his conviction that the reserves are indispensable to our national defence and deserve every reasonable support we can muster. However, my Lords, I'm afraid I must express some reservations about the amendments in this group and the next. This is a genuine and very difficult balancing act. On the one side sits our duty to reservists and to employers who already at times go beyond the call in supporting them.

And on the other sits our duty to the small and medium-sized businesses that make up the overwhelming majority of Britain's employers and who are right now facing a cumulative weight of obligation that these amendments risk compounding rather than ameliorating. Some five and a half million businesses operate in this country, and over 99% of them are small or medium-sized enterprises. Firms of the kind caught by the 50 employee threshold or the 10 employee threshold in amendment 41 are frequently the very smallest operations. They might be a family firm, a local manufacturer, a handful of tradesmen incorporated together. For a business of 10 employees, losing one member of staff for 10 working days a year for training could produce real strain on their workforce, potentially pushing back deadlines and damaging their ability to compete for contracts against larger rivals who can afford such absences more easily.

It could also, and this is quite dangerous I think, influence the willingness of employees and fellow workers to be generous with their attitude towards service. And that is very important.

And my Lords, this cannot be considered in isolation from the wider climate in which small businesses are currently operating. Businesses have had to suffer two years of this government that have made their lives considerably harder, what with the increase in employer national insurance contributions and the increase in national living wage and the Employment Rights Act. That is the context in which we must judge these amendments. We're not saying reservists do not deserve support, indeed quite the opposite, but we believe the existing Defence Employer Recognition Scheme, built on voluntary best practice amongst gold and silver employers, achieves much of what these clauses seek without imposing statutory duties that might deter smaller firms from hiring reservists at all, the very outcome we wish to avoid. I hope my noble friend will reflect on these concerns in the spirit in which they are offered, and I look forward to continuing this conversation as the bill progresses.

03:36:50 - 03:45:39

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, again can I thank everyone who's contributed to the debate. I think I should have declared an interest at the beginning, so I apologize again for my son-in-law who's currently mobilized and an active reservist, so I apologize I should have made that statement before. Can I also, again, the noble Lord Lord Harlech and myself have a number of conversations both within this chamber and without, and I often say so, can thank him for bringing forward the amendments. I will write to him on the particular three questions that he asked, and for the clarity for the rest of the committee I will copy that to everyone who is in the chamber at the current time, and also place a copy in the library, so I hope that's satisfactory to the noble Lord with respect to the three specific questions that he asked me. On the issue of the jury service, you will know the armed forces are not exempt from jury service.

If a reservist is mobilized, they can apply for a deferral in the normal way. We can all agree that reserve forces are critical to defence, and every day reservists balance civilian careers, family commitments and military service, giving their time to train and remain ready to serve when called upon. In answer to the noble Baroness Smith's point, of course I'll consider all of the various points. I'll always do that. I can't answer them to the satisfaction that everybody would wish, but of course I'll consider them.

I also think to be fair that the Earl Minto made an important thing, this is all the way through it's a balancing act between trying to recognize the important demands that employers of all sizes have on their businesses, but at the same time doing all we can to promote reserves and reservists and to ensure that we meet both of those, not competing demands, but both of those demands and to try to find a way that balances all of that. And I agree with the noble Earl, it's not in opposition to what the noble Lord Lord Harlech's done in his amendments 40 and 41, rather it seeks how do we address what's the correct balance between all of that. Defence relies on the commitment of our reservists, their skills, experience and willingness to step forward in service of the nation make them indispensable part of our armed forces, and we're deeply grateful for their dedication and support of their employers. And again Lord Sway mentioned that, and the noble Lord Lord Sway recognized that in the comments that he made.

And of course we need to try and encourage more people to become reservists and and we will do. I'm not sure the Swiss example, I'm not an expert on Switzerland, but it it gets near to requiring people to do certain things and he will know that this government and previous governments have always taken the view that ours is the voluntary through the reservists ours is the voluntary route and we seek to encourage people to to participate and and to act in the service of their of their nation and I think that's the right approach for us to to continue with. I want to be clear that the government supports the objectives however underlined in the amendments put forward. Defence already works closely with employers through our defence relationship management team, the Armed Forces Covenant and indeed as the Earl Minto pointed out the defence employer recognition scheme which seeks to recognize employers of all various sizes and I think is an important way forward. These arrangements encourage employers to adopt reserve-friendly policies and provide appropriate time off for training.

Many employers do this voluntarily. The amendments would represent a significant move away from the current partnership-based approach. Amendment 40 would impose new policy publication and review requirement on employers while also requiring the government to establish supporting guidance and compliance reporting arrangements. Although the amendment does not provide for sanctions or civil liability, it would nevertheless create administrative burdens for employers. There is also a risk that moving from a voluntary framework to a statutory one could discourage some employers from engaging with defence and employing veterans, undermining the collaborative approach that has helped secure employer support for reservists to date.

I think that was a point well made by Lord de Mauley about the collaboration and working together between businesses and veterans of all sizes and I think that was an important point that was made. Amendment 41 would go further by creating a new statutory employment right requiring employers to accommodate up to 10 days of additional absence for qualifying reserve training irrespective of their existing policies or particular operational circumstances. Both amendments again could therefore create additional workforce administrative and operational pressure for employers and those impacts may be particularly significant where employers rely on specialist skills, shift patterns or need to maintain business continuity. Reservists already benefit from a range of statutory protections under the Reserve Forces Act 1996 and the Reserve Forces Safeguard of Employment Act 1985. For example, the Reserve Forces Call-out and Recall Financial Assistance Regulations 2005 made under the Reserve Forces Act 1996 help ensure that reservists are not financially disadvantaged when mobilized.

Alongside that statutory framework, our voluntary arrangements allow defence to recognize and build upon good practice while sustaining the positive relationship with employers on which reserve service depends. Defence will continue, continue to encourage employers to adopt supportive policies and provide time off for reserve training. However, we consider that this is best achieved through engagement, recognition and partnership and again I think that was a point Lord de Mauley made well. We keep the legislation that governs our reserve forces however, in answer again to Baroness Smith, we keep it under regular review review and if we believe that further change or legislation is required to improve the readiness of the reserve forces we will look to do so and include that in future legislation.

Amendment 45 while we are clear that employers who support our reserves deserve recognition and encouragement the amendment risks turning public procurement into an indirect test of an employer's internal HR policies even where these policies have no connection to the goods and services being procured. And that would be a significant and ineffective extension of procurement policy. The Procurement Act 2023 is designed to deliver a simple transparent and effective procurement system and we believe that the amendment would cut across that objective by adding another mandatory policy for consideration for contracting authorities to interpret and apply. It would also risk penalising otherwise capable suppliers particularly smaller businesses that may strongly support the armed forces community but do not yet have formal written policies enhanced leave arrangements or defence recognition status. That would not necessarily help reservists and it could deter suppliers from bidding for public contracts or further administrative burdens.

The government already has tools for this purpose. Reservists are supported through employment protections defence's relationship management team the Armed Forces Covenant and employer recognition schemes. These routes are designed to promote genuine practical and voluntary support from employers rather than imposing a procurement requirement that may be remote from the contract being let. So we understand the purpose and intent of the amendments that have been put forward. Lord Empey's points will be raised we can deal with in the next group.

But I with that would ask the noble Lord to withdraw his amendments but for him to be assured that of course I will consider the various points that have been raised.

03:45:39 - 03:46:43

Jasset David Cody Harlech

Well my Lord let me start with the good. I am grateful for support of my noble friends. I think Lord Swire Baroness Fraser Lord De Mauley all made very strong points. I'm a bit disappointed by the rather gloomy view of what reserve service offers to an employer by my front bench. I'll have to pick this discussion up outside the chamber and try and persuade them otherwise.

And I cannot understand why the government isn't going for it. I'm trying to generate mass for the reserve and giving them to this. What I would leave the the committee with then is this. How can of course I'll definitely give way to my noble friend who's a bit gloomy.

03:46:43 - 03:47:17

Mark Lancaster

I'd quite like to cheer him up slightly because what does reserve service give to employers? Well actually quite a lot. And to answer the Lord De Mauley's question earlier one of the things that defence absolutely is doing in a common skills framework is trying to ensure that the skills we learn in defence both civilian qualifications will be recognised but also the skills that you get in defence can then be transferred to civilian qualifications. So rather than having two parallel systems there's an equal recognition so there's mutual benefit to both employers and defence when it comes to training.

03:47:17 - 03:48:14

Jasset David Cody Harlech

I'm very very grateful to my noble friend for that intervention and for setting out this equivalence of skills defence skills passport which is which is much needed long overdue and will be incredibly helpful. We must get better at explaining to employers the value of employing reservists and why it's good that they go train they'll maybe go and do a course in leadership and management they'll come back upskilled happy motivated and you know spread that goodwill and new skills throughout you know throughout the rest of the civilian employer.

But I would just leave the committee with this on this one. How can it be that the rest of the Five Eyes counterparts do what I'm suggesting and more, much more in some cases, and we don't? Do we think that is the right way around or the wrong way around? To be continued. And with that, I beg leave to withdraw for now.

03:48:14 - 03:48:29

Eirlys Morgan

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 41 not moved, Lord Harlech. After clause 38, amendment 42, Lord Harlech.

03:48:29 - 03:54:51

Jasset David Cody Harlech

So, my Lords, I think we've already started to discuss some of the themes here. The noble Lord, Lord Empey, definitely raised some of these. This is amendment 42 and amendment 43, 44, and I'm again grateful to my noble friends Lady Penn and Lord de Mauley for their support. And this group addresses what I believe to be the largest single gap in the law protecting reservists. We protect the reservist who is already in the job and almost nobody else.

So section 17 of the Reserve Forces (Safeguard of Employment) Act 1985 makes it a criminal offence to dismiss a reservist because of call-out liability, and section 48 of the Defence Reform Act 2014 removes the qualifying period for unfair dismissal where the reason is connected with reserve membership. Both are about dismissal. Neither touches a candidate sitting an interview. I would add that where an employer is convicted under section 17, compensation is capped by section 18 at five weeks' pay. That is the entire financial consequence of criminally dismissing a reservist.

So, my Lords, amendment 42 would make it unlawful to refuse a person employment because they have been or may become a reservist, with a remedy in the employment tribunal. Our closest ally covers this expressly. American law protects applicants as well as employees and reaches past, current and future military obligations. And this House has already accepted the principle at home: part three of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 makes it unlawful to refuse a person employment on grounds of trade union membership. My Lords, it is very difficult to explain to a reservist why union membership merits statutory protection at the point of hiring and service to the Crown does not.

My Lords, this matters because of what it causes. The reason reservists conceal their service from employers is the belief, frequently a correct belief, that declaring it will cost them the job. That belief is entirely rational because there is no remedy if they are right. The consequence is that the whole architecture of employer support rests on people hiding the very thing it exists to support. That is not a stable foundation for the whole force, and it is not a recruiting proposition either.

I expect to be told that there is no evidence of a problem. The absence of evidence is a function of the absence of a remedy: nobody records a refusal they have no means of challenging.

I expect also to be told that subsection 6, the shifting burden of proof, is too onerous. Well, my Lords, it is the standard provision used throughout discrimination law and well understood by tribunals, and it is narrower than the American test. Without it, the clause would be decorative because no employer writes down that they declined a candidate over their reserve service. Amendment 43 deals with what happens afterwards. Between the 1985 Act and unfair dismissal lies everything which actually occurs in practice: being passed over for promotion, taken off the client list, given the shift pattern which clashes with drill nights, moved quietly sideways after a mobilization.

The employer who does not want reservists does not dismiss them. Dismissal is legally risky and commercially untidy. They simply make staying unattractive, and at present that is entirely lawful. American protection reaches promotion, retention, and any benefit of employment. Ours reaches nothing until the individual is sacked.

My Lords, this is settled machinery, mirrors the detriment provisions already in part 5 of the Employment Rights Act, which protects whistleblowers, health and safety representatives, and pension trustees. It falls hardest on those the reserve can least replace: the medical, legal, cyber, and engineering specialists the regular forces cannot recruit and could not afford to grow. Amendment 44 concerns the reservist nobody has legislated for at all. A substantial proportion are self-employed, run small businesses, or are partners in professional firms, and not one of the protections in this bill or in existing law reaches them. For that person, the cost of annual camp is not leave, it is a fortnight of lost revenue with the overheads still running.

Australia's protections expressly reach partnerships, and its employer support payment scheme covers the self-employed. Canada operates something comparable. We pay the reservist a daily rate and give the employer a certificate. So again, you know, to my own front bench, I would suggest that this is very pro self-employed businesses and business owners. Subsection 3 is deliberately a duty to review and not a spending power, so it creates no charge on public funds.

I am asking the government to examine the question and report, not yet to fund a scheme. If the answer is that we cannot afford what Australia and Canada do, then this House is entitled to be told the figure. My Lords, I recognize that these are not government amendments and that the noble Lord the Minister may have concerns about the drafting. If the principle is accepted, I am entirely content for the drafting to be the government's, and I would welcome a conversation with him and with colleagues in all parts of the House before report. I beg to move.

03:54:51 - 03:54:57

Speaker 86

Post after clause 38, insert the new clauses printed on the marshalled list.

03:54:57 - 03:56:38

Joanna Penn

My Lords, I'll rise briefly to support my noble friend Lord Harlech in amendments 42 and 43. I think he's again brought before the committee sensible, pragmatic amendments that seem to me must surely be addressed if we want reservists to continue to play a growing role in our armed forces. Refusal of employment or denial of promotion or withdrawal on the grounds of reserve service must be unacceptable.

We're relying on reservists to balance the demands of their military service and their employment, and we must be able to say to them that they will be properly protected if their service unfairly threatens their livelihoods. The noble Lord the Minister said in response to the previous group that reservists already benefit from employment protections. These amendments identify two gaps in those protections that I cannot see a reason not to fill. As my noble friend anticipated, the Minister may find objections in the drafting or other areas, but it would be really interesting to hear whether the government accept the principle that these are gaps in the employment protection for reservists. I also expect we might hear the challenge about providing employment protection on or prior to appointment, but I think my noble friend's found a very good precedent in law with the Trade Union Act, where this has been solved in other cases.

So I look forward to hearing the noble Lord the Minister's response on these issues.

03:56:38 - 03:59:20

Julie Smith

My Lords, on this occasion, I'm going to split my remarks into slightly separate comments on amendments 42 and 43, where the principle, I think, has been very clearly outlined by the noble Lord, Lord Harlech. And the fact, as Baroness Penn has pointed out, he's found a precedent in the Trade Union Act, I think is very helpful. And the idea that somehow people should face detriment or possibly something that could lead to something like constructive dismissal, but not directly dismissal because of serving as a reservist, is clearly something that as a society, a parliament, and a government, we should try to avoid because if anything, we need to be finding ways of making it easier for people to be reservists and easier for companies to understand the benefits of reserve occupation, of people being reservists. But I have some questions about amendment 44, and it's simply the practicality of it. And I know the noble Lord, Lord Harlech, has said, well, our friends and colleagues in Canada and Australia do something similar.

But if your self-employed reservist is a plumber, and somebody says, I really need your services, I have an urgent problem, there's a flood, and the reserve is either deployed or is doing training, they can't precisely say, well, I'll come back in a few months' time and deal with your overflowing drains. So I'm slightly puzzled by what it means to say it is unlawful to subject a member of the reserve forces to a detriment on a ground of falling within section refusal of employment on grounds of membership of the service. I'm just not quite sure how that would work in practice. So although I can see that it would be desirable to find ways of making it easier for self-employed people to serve in the reserves, equally there needs to be a way of ensuring that they could be replaced in the function that they're doing, or ensure that they have replaced themselves, because it's not the same as somebody working for an employer where the employer would be expected to find a temporary stopgap, and that's what we'd be looking for.

03:59:20 - 04:01:21

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, again, I'm most grateful to my noble friends Lord Harlech, Baroness Penn, and Lord de Mauley for these amendments.

Like my response to the last group, I completely share my noble friends' desire to support the reserves wherever possible. I am absolutely not gloomy about the reserves at all, rather the opposite. I know that reserve training adds depth to any participant and indeed to any organisation that they might be part of. But unfortunately, I also have some concerns with these amendments. Between them, these amendments would create new tribunal-enforceable duties on refusal of employment, extend protection against detriment short of dismissal, and place fresh obligations on businesses dealing with the self-employed and with partnerships.

Taken together, that is a substantial new compliance burden to place on employers, many of them small businesses, at a time when they are already absorbing a great deal of regulatory change, as I have already established. I think it's right to pause before adding further to that already pretty hefty burden. Amendment 42 raises a further difficulty. It would make it unlawful to refuse employment to somebody who merely proposes to become a reservist. In practice, how is an employer to know that at the point of the hiring?

Unless a candidate volunteers information, there's no reliable way for an employer to be aware of an intention that exists only in someone's future plans, which makes the obligation very hard to comply with and harder still to enforce fairly. My Lords, it is fundamentally my view that the commercial requirements of businesses, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, must be our primary consideration. And that's it really. I hope my noble friends will reflect on these practical concerns and I look forward to the Minister's response.

04:01:21 - 04:08:36

Vernon Coaker

Can I again thank everyone who's participated in the debate? Let me start again by Lord Harlech asked if we could have a conversation before report, specifically asked me that, of course we can have that conversation because we understand the intention behind the amendments to further build on the protections offered to our reservists within current primary legislation. However, we don't believe, the government don't believe that the new clauses are proportionate and risk creating unintended consequences for employers, reservists and the wider labour market. As mentioned earlier, reservists already benefit from a range of statutory protections. They allow a reservist to claim compensation where their military pay is lower than civilian earnings, subject to a cap, and provide support for reasonable additional costs arising from mobilisation, such as childcare or other domestic expenses.

This recognises the significant commitment reservists make in serving our armed forces. The Armed Forces Covenant further ensures that service personnel are not disadvantaged by virtue of their military service. The government's approach is to foster a positive partnership between defence and employers rather than to create new categories of employment litigation. Membership of the reserve forces is a voluntary commitment that may involve specific and foreseeable periods of absence from employment due to training or mobilisation. The amendments could introduce broad new causes of action in employment tribunals.

The provisions are drafted, as Earl Minto pointed out, are drafted in particularly wide terms, extending not only to actual reservists but also to persons who propose to become a reservist or who may become liable for future service. That would inevitably create significant evidential difficulties for employers, in particular recruitment decisions often involve a range of legitimate factors and it may be challenging to later demonstrate conclusively that reserve service played no part in a decision.

These amendments may therefore have the unintended consequence of discouraging employers from discussing reserve commitments openly with applicants and employees. The government's objective is to encourage transparent and constructive dialogue between employers and reservists. A statutory requirement may undermine that objective and weaken the collaborative relationship that currently exists between defense and employers through, as I say, the Armed Forces Covenant and the Defense Relationship Management program. We remain committed to supporting reservists and promoting reserve services among employers. However, the amendments would create a disproportionate and potentially burdensome, as I say, new legal requirement and introduce unnecessary uncertainty into recruitment and employment without compelling evidence of necessity.

Turning to amendment 44, the government recognizes that reservists who run their own businesses, work as contractors or practice in partnership can face particular challenges in balancing civilian livelihoods with military service, again, the point that the noble Lord, Lord Harlech, made. Their commitment is highly valued and defense will continue to support them through a combination of legislation, financial assistance, employer engagement and practical guidance. While government fully supports the objective of ensuring that reservists are not treated unfairly because of their service, we do not believe that the amendment is necessary or proportionate. The amendment would extend protections into a wide range of commercial contracts and partnership arrangements. Decisions about contracting, allocation of work on business partnerships are often based on legitimate commercial factors.

The amendment could make such routine decisions vulnerable to legal challenge where current or potential reserve service is alleged to have played a role. That would represent a significant and far-reaching change to the law in this area, and the government is not persuaded that a case for such a change has been made in the context of this bill. As I say, there are already existing protection support mechanisms in place through various pieces of legislation. Financial assistance may also be available under part eight of the Reserve Forces Act 1996 when a reservist is mobilized or undertakes relevant reserve force activities. Support is available to reservists and employers, including self-employed employers and business partnerships.

This can include provision for loss of earnings, replacement costs and additional business costs arising from mobilization. The government's approach is therefore to maintain a balanced framework, and I think that starts to try and answer Baroness Penn's points about trying to have a balanced framework and a balanced approach to some of the competing demands that there are. A statutory protection where it's required, financial assistance where service creates identifiable costs, strong engagement with employers and business through defense relationship management. I agree with Lord Lancaster's points earlier on about ensuring that everyone is aware of the skills that reservists can bring back to industry. I think that's an important point.

The Armed Forces Covenant and the employer recognition scheme. That partnership-based approach has built substantial and growing employer support for reservists without placing legal burdens on businesses. In 2016, there were under 1,000 organizations, business organizations or organizations signed to the Armed Forces Covenant. Today, we now have over 15,200 organizations signed up. I think that's a significant thing of which we can all, all of us across this house, be proud of, although still much more to be done.

The review requirement in the amendment is unnecessary. Defense already keeps reservists and employer support under regular consideration, including financial assistance arrangements for mobilization and wider measures to improve reserve utilization, readiness and support.

And again, let me reassure Lord Harlech in what he said. The government will continue to consider whether existing schemes remain appropriate, but does not believe that a statutory review tied to overseas comparators is the right mechanism. International models can help, but arrangements in Australia and Canada operate within different reserve structures, employment markets, legal frameworks, and funding systems. For these reasons, although we understand the intent and I'm willing and perfectly happy as always to have a conversation with Lord Harlech, we remain, we don't believe that these amendments are necessary, and with that, I would ask the noble Lord to withdraw his amendment.

04:08:36 - 04:09:28

Jasset David Cody Harlech

My Lords, I'm, I'm grateful to all noble Lords who participated in this, I think it's been a balanced but brief debate. I'm grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for setting out the government's position. Sort of like with the last group, I would say, are the numbers of reserves, are they going up? Not really. We've sort of stopped the bleed, so we've stabilized it, but the numbers are going down.

So if we keep doing the same thing, we will get the same results. That's why what I'm suggesting is a big change, it is dramatic, because I think it's time to start doing things dramatically differently to, to get our reserve forces where they need to be. But for now, I will withdraw my amendment.

04:09:28 - 04:09:47

Eirlys Morgan

Is it your Lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 43 not moved, Lord Harlech. 44 not moved. Amendment 45 not moved.

In schedule 6, amendment 46, Lord de Mauley.

04:09:47 - 04:17:41

Rupert Ponsonby

My Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 46, 47, and 49, which are in my name. To understand the importance of these amendments, one needs to appreciate the significance of the nationwide membership of the RFCAs. The 2019 Sullivan report on the RFCAs, which recommended conversion to an NDPB, itself provides an explanation at paragraph 2.2.2, where it says, and I quote, "A key strength of the RFCAs is their extensive volunteer membership, numbering around 8,000, bringing with it a wide breadth of expertise and community links, without which the RFCAs would unlikely have access to the information and knowledge needed to discharge the duties. Their position as the link between defence and the wider public, continuity of staff and expertise, and tri-service drive enables the RFCAs to deliver across all functions, particularly community and employer engagement, the latter proven by the success on the Armed Forces Covenant and employer recognition scheme work strands. This is particularly valuable in cases where local knowledge and understanding may be limited in MOD customers."

End of quote. What is proposed, my Lords, in the Armed Forces Bill, is the removal of all the regional chairs from the central board, the new decision-making arm of the RFCA. So if the Armed Forces Bill proceeds as drafted, the members who currently elect those chairs will be completely disenfranchised, with a consequence of a loss of defence's connection with society and the advocates and supporters of the reserves and cadets across the UK.

The members have made it very clear that this will be sufficiently significant that it will lead to a reduction in the membership to a negligible number. My Lords, is that really what the government wants when it states in the strategic defense review its ambitions to increase the size of the reserves, to increase the number of cadets, to create a completely new homeland and critical national infrastructure defense force, and that a whole of society approach to defense is essential? In discussions with the MOD over the last 12 months, matters had developed to a point at which the MOD had agreed in writing, confirmed by a government minister at the RFCA's annual conference, that regional chairs would indeed sit as full members on the national board in order to protect the societal links and work done by the engaged and experienced membership. Stepping back from that commitment, as the bill does, is already being taken very badly indeed by the membership. My Lords, I don't blame the minister.

I don't believe the implications of what is proposed have been explained to him. They can't have been because if they had, he would not be proceeding with this. This is about something more important even than the permanent secretary's perception of how he will improve his oversight of what in the context of the MOD's overall budget is a relatively small amount of funding the RFCAs receive and use on maintenance of the volunteer estate. It's about the country's ability to defend itself in time of war because the effects of section 38 and schedule 6 will do irreparable damage to the government's ability to defend the country through the use and expansion of the reserve forces of which the RFCAs are a demonstrable key enabler. It'll also have a damaging effect on the government's aim of growing the cadet forces in which again local RFCAs are pivotal enablers.

The Denny report entitled 'The Impact and Value of School-Based Cadet Forces in the UK' identified that those with cadet service were statistically unlikely to be not in education, employment, or training, something rather topical these days. My Lords, turning now to amendment 49, I mentioned earlier what the Sullivan report says itself about a key strength of the RFCAs being their extensive volunteer membership. Let me give a couple of examples of how the membership helps defense. My first one is that in the first decade of this century, the country was mobilizing reservists in large numbers to go to Iraq and Afghanistan to bolster the regular army. In the case of the regular forces, they live on the patch.

There are welfare officers, commanding officers' and RSMs' wives, and a whole machine which is wheeled into action to look after the welfare of the families left behind. For the reservists, who are scattered over the area from which their unit recruits, which can be several counties or several cities, there's no such welfare machine. That is when the RFCA's membership comes into action, visiting and offering help and advice. And my Lords, reservists have the added complication of a civilian employer. An RFCA member who is him or herself an employer can visit them, explain what's happening and the legal position.

I commanded a reserve regiment during the mobilization of large numbers of reservists for Op TELIC between 2003 and 2005, and without the support and influence of the RFCA, particularly with employers, the reserve would have responded less effectively. It allowed me to command and lead whilst employment matters could be successfully dealt with by the RFCAs, and I know, my Lords, that other commanding officers had similar experiences.

It was the RFCA that led on the work relating to employment, which subsequently was woven into the Future Reserves 2020 White Paper. My second example is that, being apolitical, the RFCAs have been extremely helpful to defense, especially in the devolved administrations. In Scotland, when the government announced the expansion of the cadet forces in schools, one of the nationalist papers printed a story suggesting that this was about training child soldiers. Its apolitical position allowed the RFCA, through its members and connections, to persuade the government in Scotland that this was not a fair representation, with which they agreed and the story died. The SDR having proposed increases in the size of the reserves and of the cadets, the creation of a new homeland defense force, that defense should become a whole-of-nation responsibility, and that resilience in the civilian community needs to be improved, it seems quite extraordinary that the RFCA's membership, which could do so much to enable these things, should be abolished, and for no good reason.

Furthermore, as was said earlier, this is directly against the new Prime Minister's drive on devolution outwards of power and influence. Whereas the Reserve Forces Act of 1996 specifically includes in Schedule 4 the details of the grassroots membership, this is completely and deliberately removed by paragraph 2B of Part 3 of Schedule 6 of the Armed Forces Bill, so there would be henceforth no reference at all to membership in primary legislation, I think for the first time since 1908. Thousands of volunteers across the UK would be immediately disenfranchised and lost. My Lords, it has been suggested that the membership, and the noble Lord the Minister, I think, referred to this earlier, might be reinvented through secondary legislation. But we all know that is a poor way of doing it.

It relegates the voluntary concept to a secondary level of importance, and it also makes it much easier to amend, change, and indeed delete it. My Lords, I beg to move.

04:17:41 - 04:17:50

Eirlys Morgan

Amendment proposed, Schedule 6, page 133, line 17, at end insert the chairs of the regional councils.

04:17:50 - 04:23:08

Jock Stirrup

My Lords, I've added my name to these amendments for the reasons that the noble Lord Lord de Mauley has set out so clearly and so cogently, and I don't intend to repeat them all. I agree with everything that he said, but let me try and make a couple of wider points. And they're wider points centered on the requirement for a regional approach to our reserves and cadets. Now, there's been wide acknowledgment of the benefits that such an approach brings. A couple of things that haven't been mentioned perhaps to the extent that they should be are, first of all, the matter of footprint.

Reserve forces and cadets allow us a military footprint across the country, across the United Kingdom, that is no longer possible with our sadly depleted regular forces. And this matters. It means that defense and defense issues can be represented locally by people who are local, and the noble Lord Lord de Mauley has already pointed out one example where this has been of inestimable benefit in Scotland. So, one very important point there. Another one, though, is a matter of identity.

Within military organizations, identity matters. Identity of the group. In the regulars, it's perhaps the identification with your ship, with your regiment, with your squadron. But as far as regulars are concerned, it's identity with your locality. That is fundamental to it, and it's and that identity is fundamental to the effectiveness of any military organization.

Now, the noble Lord, the noble Lord Lord Lancaster of Kimbolton said that the bill does not seek to destroy the regional aspect of reserve forces. Well, to an extent. But of course he knows, as well as anyone here, that the regional nature of reserve forces is not just about the wiring diagram. It's about the authority that those regional forces have.

That's absolutely fundamental. Now, the noble Lord the Minister, in response to an earlier amendment, said that, well, you know, devolution is achieved through overarching strategic direction. Mayors can't do what they like. Well, actually, that's the whole point. Within certain limits, they can.

That's the point of devolution: giving them authority along with responsibility. Yes, of course, there is overarching strategic direction, although I just say as an aside that that won't necessarily work in the case of mayors, because you could quite well have a Conservative mayor and a Labour national government, and I'm not quite sure how far the Conservative mayor would follow the national government's overarching strategic objectives. But we're not discussing that matter here today. So I accept, yes, overarching strategic directive, but it is strategic. It's not operational, it's not tactical.

And therefore, the local authorities will have a great deal of freedom to decide things, but they will need the authority to carry through on those decisions. And authority, of course, goes along in many instances with funding, but with other things besides. And this is one of the reasons why I think schedule 6 is potentially so damaging for the reserve forces. Now, of course, this speaks to what in military parlance we would term mission command. You give overall direction on the broad objectives you want to see achieved, but you leave a great deal of freedom open to your subordinate organisation, in this case the regional forces, to decide how it is to be done.

But they must have authority along with that responsibility. Now, if mission command is to operate effectively, you also at a superior level need to listen to your subordinates and to their concerns, and when they're telling you that something simply won't work and that you have to come up with a different plan. And at the moment, the way that the legislation is framed, the link between the subordinate and the superior formations is going to be at best neutered, at worst cut off completely. The amendments that are proposed here, 46 and 47, seek to ensure that the RFCAs are properly represented at a senior level and that their voice can be heard. But that plays both ways, of course, because if their voice isn't heard, then they lack authority at the local level.

And if they lack authority at the local level, it's going to impact on recruiting and retention, it's going to lower morale, and it's going to lower effectiveness. And that's something I know nobody in this chamber wants to see. Equally with amendment 49, this seeks to ensure that the RFCAs' wider membership is enshrined in primary legislation, that its breadth and its diversity is retained, again so that the wider community links, the wider regional links are retained and have credibility across that regional community. So, my Lords, as I said in an earlier part of this committee, I have concerns about schedule 6 overall. If we are to retain it, I plead with the Minister to take these issues away and correct those bits of it which will restore the authority and the voice of the local reserve forces and cadets through the RFCAs in particular.

04:23:08 - 04:28:23

Frederick Curzon

My Lords, I intervene in this debate very briefly in support of my noble friend Lord de Mauley, and in doing so declare my interest as a former defence minister and as the minister responsible for piloting the 1996 Reserve Forces Act through your Lordships' House. I suspect that the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig, is the only person present who might remember that from having directly witnessed it.

I must also declare a further interest in that my wife, who is Lord Lieutenant of Buckinghamshire, is president of SERFCA, the South East Reserve Forces and Cadets Association. In mentioning my part in giving birth to the 1996 Act, I don't wish the committee to suppose that I'm opposed to changing it. I'm not an old reactionary, at least not in this regard. As I'm the first to recognize that the world as it was in 1996 is not the world that we are confronted with today. And when it comes to the government's stated aim of placing greater emphasis on our reserve forces in creating a more lethal integrated force model for defense, I am wholly in favor.

What I do think, though, is that in acknowledging the deficiencies of the 1996 Act against that policy backdrop, we should not at the same time downplay its strengths. And one of its major strengths, as other noble lords have emphasized and the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, has so well described, is to acknowledge the importance of ensuring the buy-in of the civil community in the delivery of well-supported, well-motivated, and administratively efficient reserves and cadet units. That civil buy-in is achieved because local people know that their efforts and their knowledge really matter, that through the structure of the RFCA, their voice is heard at a higher level, and that their knowledge and their concerns and indeed their achievements are being fed through to national decision-making. What the RFCAs do is to enable a sense of local ownership. And that sense of local ownership matters because what follows from it is a feeling of local empowerment.

My Lords, it is that that many of us fear will be put at risk by centralizing governance and decision-making through a new NDPB. If the government agree that the contribution made by the volunteer membership is important, and the minister says he does, we have to keep those volunteers enthused and motivated. Volunteers are not paid employees. They can choose to walk away. Once people start feeling disempowered or put upon or taken for granted, or that their voice is not being properly represented, there is a danger that they will start viewing the local association or local council as a mere talking shop.

And that way lies disaster. My Lords, with my own eyes, I have seen this very thing play out in a completely different context, that of a once successful national charity whose volunteer membership deliver valued services in their local areas based on a county structure. For many years, the county bodies enjoyed a degree of operational autonomy as well as support from leading members of the community, whilst remaining, of course, accountable to the center. But then, following a review, the governance and finances of the charity were centralized, thereby relieving the counties of much of their autonomy and sense of ownership, all in the name of efficiency. The inevitable happened.

The volunteers rapidly felt disempowered, poorly understood and poorly supported, and recruitment plummeted. A belated attempt by the center to put the policy into reverse a few years later has as yet failed to undo the damage caused. For me, the experience of that charity is a cautionary tale. And it's for these reasons that I'm very supportive of the amendments in this group and I hope that the minister will listen sympathetically to what has been said in their favor.

04:28:23 - 04:31:51

Tom Elliott

My Lords, just a few brief comments on this group of amendments. But firstly, before I do, I want to pay tribute and thank the noble Lord, the Minister, Minister Coaker, for his attendance at the most westerly constituency of the United Kingdom last weekend in County Fermanagh when he visited the RAF recruitment event, which was a two-day event in just outside Enniskillen and was very successful. We had a huge number of interested organizations and not only that, but we had a number of interested young people who clearly want to be part of the defense forces in the years to come, and on that occasion particularly the RAF. So I do thank the Minister for that. Getting that out of the way, I do think there are some reasons to support these amendments.

And one is which we're very recognizable of in Northern Ireland, just the same as Scotland and Wales, and that is localism, regionalism and localism. If you don't have your local support, if you don't have those who represent you, then you don't feel part of it. And I think that is a huge issue around the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations. Because these are people who may join or at least may have sympathy for our forces in the years to come, in the generations to come. So it's about encouragement.

It's about ensuring that they have representation. And it is important that that regionalization and localization is there for them, because that's what it is. It's there for them. It's not just there for us. Because if they don't feel part of it, then they're not going to be fully participating within that process.

It comes down to a number of issues. The Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations are hugely important, not just around the future of the services, but it's around discipline, around commitment, around loyalty and colleague support. Those are excellent values to put into young people that they can promote then to their peers, to their friends and to their colleagues. So not only is this about the amendments, but this goes much wider and I think offers a huge organizational support for the community, but also for individuals. I witness so many people who don't have that discipline, who don't have that commitment to either their families or indeed their community.

But that is something that's instilled within them within the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations. So I plead to the Minister and to the government, please have a look at this. Maybe there are some tweaks. Maybe there are some options to make this better. But please allow those people who are serving either in the Cadets Associations or the reservists to feel a part of it by that local support.

04:31:51 - 04:31:54

Speaker 90

Thank you.

04:31:54 - 04:34:35

Annabel Goldie

My Lords, I don't propose to repeat what we said in an earlier debate in committee, but I do rise to thank my noble friend Lord De Mauley for these amendments, and I want to focus on amendment 48 and the importance of volunteering. So in the Sullivan report, they identified that a key strength of the RFCAs was their extensive volunteer membership. And in every other part of our communities, we are doing everything we can to support volunteers and volunteering, and in times of tight financial straits especially, we seek to appreciate the knowledge of volunteers. And I'm afraid my heart sinks when I think of replacing volunteers who represent the voice of our local regions, nations, communities. They bring experience, they bring institutional memory, and they do it, they do it because they want to.

And we're going to replace that with board appointments made on ministerial advice. Now, I'm sure many colleagues in this house have experience of public appointments. I currently sit on two public bodies as a board member and therefore am appointed by one Scottish minister and one Westminster minister to that board. And we are subject to the whims of that department. In one case, DCMS has decided apparently that public appointments should only serve for one term.

Now, I leave that with you as how that supports institutional memory and succession planning in our public bodies. And in Creative Scotland, where I sit on the board, we are currently four or five board members short, and the public appointment process is so slow that we're not able to get to the front of the queue to organize to fill these appointments. So the idea that these wonderful volunteers that we currently have supporting our reserve forces cadet associations are going to be replaced by some sort of NDPB board appointments slightly fills me with horror, and that we will end up with the usual suspects rather than these experienced and committed volunteers that allow them to speak impartially, freely, and frankly.

04:34:35 - 04:36:31

Julie Smith

My Lords, I rise to support these amendments to which I have added my name. As the noble Lord Lord De Mauley and the noble and gallant Lord Lord Stirrup have pointed out, in many ways these amendments serve, if we can't remove clause 38 and schedule 6, then at least amending clause 38 might ameliorate some of the issues and very much enable us to retain the local connections and in particular, as the noble and gallant Lord pointed out, the importance of a wide footprint. We've heard from Lord Elliott of the situation of Northern Ireland, we've heard from Baroness Fraser about the situation in Scotland.

My Lords, surely we should be looking for ways of ensuring that the voices of the nations and regions are all heard, not that we should have a single centralized body that doesn't represent anybody. And these amendments very much serve to ensure that the voices that we currently hear in the regional RFCAs actually can continue to play a role, but in particular amendment 49 outlines key people who should be involved. My Lords, could the noble lord the minister explain to the house whether he feels that clause 38 as currently envisaged and the idea of an NDBP really does deal with the questions of representation? And if not, and if he doesn't feel able to support the amendments as drafted, might he consider bringing back government amendments on these issues?

04:36:31 - 04:39:31

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, I've already argued at some length that I do not believe the government's proposed alterations to the characters of the reserve forces and cadets associations is sound policy. Much like my noble friend Lord De Mauley and that of Baroness Smith of Newnham, my preference therefore would be for those particular provisions to be removed from the bill entirely. However, if that is not to happen, then the second best outcome would be for the various amendments suggested by my noble friend to be adopted as a minimum. Amendments 46 and 47, which my noble friend Lady Goldie has signed, would require the chairs of the currently constituted regional councils to sit as members of the new RFCA body. Amendment 49 ensures that the wider membership of the RFCAs is not overlooked in the creation of the new body by requiring the regional councils to appoint members who are representatives of all the various organizations that work through the RFCAs.

Currently, the 13 chairs are entitled to a seat on the national board and those chairs are in turn elected by their membership. This structure ensures that the members of each RFCA are represented at the national level. However, as drafted, the bill will remove that representation. This does not seem sound. And my noble friend's salutary story of decline where local accountability is removed, I thought was poignantly salient.

Particularly since the bill also provides for the establishment of regional councils. So the government believes that there should be regional committees to help oversee and run the new body, but does not believe that those regional councils should have any representation at the national level. My Lords, this is surely a contradictory and indefensible position. The drafting of the bill also fails to recognize the vital contribution of the voluntary membership of the RFCAs. As my noble friend Lord De Mauley has pointed out, the Sullivan report itself highlighted the vitality of the voluntary membership to the organization as a whole, but this does not feature in the government's proposals.

And it is not as if the government is blind to this. The strategic defense review proposed increasing the size of the reserves and the cadets and the creation of a new homeland defense force. Let us not forget the proposed move to a whole of society approach to defense readiness. At a time when the government is claiming that it recognizes the value of expanding the reserves and the cadets, it seems extraordinary that the RFCA's membership, which could do so much to assist the government in its stated aims, should be abolished without replacement.

I hope the noble lord the minister will seriously consider at least accepting these amendments before report.

04:39:31 - 04:47:56

Vernon Coaker

Well, my lords, we don't actually accept many of the amendments that are before us in terms of the drafting of them. Am I going to speak to Lord De Mauley and the rest of the committee about what we may do to take on board some of the comments that have been made around clause 38? Of course we'll have discussions about it. Of course we'll see whether there are changes which could be made or improvements which could be made which are acceptable to the government but seek to address some of the problems that Lord De Mauley and others have laid down. That's the commitment I've always made with respect to that.

I can't promise what the outcome of that will be. This is committee stage, it's not a full-on report stage, it's not second reading or third reading. Committee stage is about challenge to the government about what it's doing and the government responding to that by saying it will consider how it may take things forward. This doesn't alter the fact, just to set the framework, that the government believes that there should be a national strategic body and the regional councils, which I'll say a little bit more about as I carry on with my remarks. But do I believe that points are being made which are important for the government to consider?

Yes, I do. And so that, I think, is the important... I can't satisfy everybody's demands around this is what we think and we think clause 38 should not stand part of the bill, which has been referred to with respect to these 46, 47 and 49 amendments before us, but that's been referred to. And so of course we will and we'll address all of that. Can I just say something to Earl Howe? I think it's a really important comment for me to make and for this house to recognise.

I do not see this as a debate between people who are young and thrusting and understand today's society and, I think what did Earl Howe say, I shouldn't be seen as an old-fashioned reactionary. Of course you're not. You and your... I think you said your wife was the Lord Lieutenant in Buckinghamshire, are doing great service and are important contributors to the fabric of our country. And so this is not a debate between those who are modern and those who are old-fashioned. This is a discussion between people who have at their heart the understanding that Lord Lieutenants, reserves, cadets, all of those play a massively important... make a massively important contribution to our country.

The discussion between us all is what is the most effective way of doing that. The government's view is that the establishment, and I go back to the point I made before, the establishment of a body that allows a strategic framework to be set that deals with some of the criticisms that were made by the various reviews that I referred to earlier, that in responding to that we can establish an overall framework within which those regional councils can operate. And those regional councils, whether established... will be a matter of discussion about what they should be, but of course they'll retain the local knowledge, the local experience, the local expertise, the local connection, the reserves, the cadets, all of those things that Lord... thank you for the remarks you made, Lord Elliott, but the points that Lord Elliott made, that the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup made, and earlier the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig made. Of course they're vital to our country. Nobody's seeking to abolish them.

The debate between us is how we make it more effective, and the government's view is you have the overall strategic framework within which that localism operates. I think, and again there's disagreement here, I think that is perfectly compatible with the overall and overarching way in which the government is seeking to devolve power within an overall strategic framework. That allows people to make their own decisions and to take their own steps forward. I go back to: that is why on the face of the bill, the primary legislation requires that regional councils are not abolished, but regional councils are actually maintained and protected. What those regional councils should be, and how they should be set up, and on what area they should be based, will be a matter of discussion, will be a matter for us to try and reach a consensus.

It then goes on on the further page on 137 to list all of the various regulations which I referred earlier. Now, the view of some on the committee is that those regulations, membership of the national body, all of the other things to which I've referred, should be in primary legislation. The government's view is that it should be done in secondary legislation. But the commitment I've made to the committee is that those draft regulations that are already drafted, and they are draft, can be shared with people so that people can look at those and then seek to understand whether some of the concerns, not all of the concerns, but whether some of the concerns that they have about membership, etc., are addressed by those regulations. Now, it may be that they're not, and people think that the draft regulations are not.

But the government is not going to go back to... The draft regulations will not say we accept that clause 38 should be abolished, but they may say we think the area should be this, we think the membership should be that, we think that this is the way forward for us. And giving draft regulations in good time to your Lordships' House will enable a discussion to be had at report which can take that forward and people will make their own mind up or not as to whether that's appropriate. And so that, without specifically therefore, from the government's perspective, means that amendments 46, 47 and 49 are not necessary because the government is seeking to deliver some of what those amendments are asking for in a different way. And Lord de Mauley, you know, in a very interesting and logical and emotional way, quite rightly, put forward the case for the regional chairs and for many of the established ways of working to continue, supported by Lord Stirrup and Baroness Smith and Lord Empey and many others.

And the debate between us will not be a debate about how we reach consensus in that sense because there is a disagreement. But what I have been asked is if clause 38 and schedule 6 are to remain part of the bill, is there something we can do which may satisfy some of the concerns that your Lordships have expressed in a way which means that some of the old-fashioned reactionaries amongst us, as Earl Howe mentioned, whether we can at least address some of the very important points which are not old-fashioned, are not reactionary, but are important considerations which any government should make when it seeks to make the change which is significant to ensure that we don't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

And with that I would ask that Lord De Mauley would withdraw his amendments.

04:47:56 - 04:48:35

Rupert Ponsonby

My lords, I thank all noble lords who have spoken supporting these amendments. I thank the noble lord the minister for his response and for offering to meet and discuss these matters, to which of course I am open. I'd say to him that the way the bill is drafted is that there are to be regional councils, but there are no members beneath them supporting them and they have no representation at national board level, so they're suspended in mid-air and it seems to me rather pointlessly. My lords, we're in committee, so I reserve the right to return to this matter on report, but for this evening I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.

04:48:35 - 04:48:43

Eirlys Morgan

Lordships, pleasure this amendment be withdrawn. Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 47, Lord De Mauley, not moved? Not moved.

04:48:43 - 04:48:56

Alicia Kennedy

My lords, I beg to move that the house be resumed. We will then move to dinner break business. We will therefore not return to the bill before 20:23.

04:48:56 - 04:49:38

Eirlys Morgan

The question is that the house be resumed. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Order.

Thank you. My lords, plant health, seeds, seed potatoes and plant propagating material amendment Northern Ireland regulations 2026, motion of regret, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, but before Lord Dodds speaks, the government whip wishes to say a few words.

04:49:38 - 04:50:00

Maggie Jones

We've just to say that for backbench contributions that the limit is three minutes. There is no gap. We're very tight for time, so if people stick within the three minutes, everybody will be grateful and we'll be able to hear from the minister later on.

04:50:00 - 04:50:26

Nigel Dodds

My lords, I rise, I notice just looking at the speakers' list has the minister down to speak, but I'm happy to to start. So my lords, I rise to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

04:50:26 - 04:56:35

Sue Hayman

Yes, thank you. I thought that was probably the case. Thank you. My lords, I beg to move that the house approves the plant health, seeds, seed potatoes and plant propagating material amendment Northern Ireland regulations 2026, which were laid before this house on the 22nd of June. This instrument extends to Northern Ireland only and has been brought through Westminster working closely with the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, DAERA.

The government notes the regret motion tabled by Lord Dodds of Duncairn, which raises concerns about the implementation of EU-derived plant health and seed legislation in Northern Ireland without public consultation and about the broader implications of the Windsor Framework. This is a necessary measure to update Northern Ireland's domestic legislation and plant health enforcement provisions, ensuring the continued protection of Northern Ireland's biosecurity and fulfillment of our Windsor Framework obligations. As noble lords will be aware, under the terms of the Windsor Framework, limited parts of European Union law falling under Annex 2 to the framework continue to apply in Northern Ireland.

These include the movement of goods, agri-food standards, and animal and plant health. It is important to note that this instrument makes no changes to the Windsor Framework. This instrument will amend existing Northern Ireland plant health legislation, introducing changes to six Northern Ireland statutory rules. The instrument will also update Northern Ireland legislation in line with EU legislative changes which are directly applicable in Northern Ireland. The majority of these changes update obsolete and outdated references in respect of Northern Ireland, Great Britain, and EU member states following the UK's exit from the EU.

I will now outline the changes being made by this instrument. Three of the pieces of marketing legislation being amended are, first, the Marketing of Vegetable Plant Material Regulations NI 1995, second, the Marketing of Ornamental Plant Propagating Material Regulations Northern Ireland 1999, and thirdly, the Marketing of Fruit Plant and Propagating Material Regulations Northern Ireland of 2017. These set out conditions relating to plant varieties, documentation requirements, and plant health quality for an array of fruit, vegetables, and propagating materials. They protect buyers and growers by outlining compulsory standards for products. Also being amended is the Forest Reproductive Material Regulations Northern Ireland 2002, which implements rules for marketing forest seeds, plants, and cuttings, ensuring that material is from approved sustainable sources and is identifiable from seed to the final user, protecting Northern Ireland's biosecurity, traders, and growers.

The fifth piece of legislation being amended is the Seed Potatoes Regulations Northern Ireland 2016. As you will possibly be aware, seed potatoes are one of the notable good news stories resulting from the introduction of the Windsor Framework. The Windsor Framework permitted the movement of seed potatoes from Great Britain to Northern Ireland and their growing on, which had been prohibited during EU exit. The final piece of domestic legislation for Northern Ireland that this instrument will amend is the Plant Health Official Controls and Miscellaneous Provisions Regulations Northern Ireland 2020. This is a central piece in setting out the overarching rules and requirements for plant health.

These amendments are primarily technical in nature to update references and terms that are related to Northern Ireland, the UK, and the EU. The amendments will also update domestic legislation to include EU biosecurity legislative changes which are already applicable and implemented, including some relating to disease control. A number of the pests and diseases covered in these technical updates pose similar risks to us here in Great Britain and controls have already been introduced in legislation here. This instrument ensures similar control measures to protect against these pests and diseases already in place in Northern Ireland will be fully enforceable. This instrument moves beyond the existing ability of rejecting consignments and provides for full enforcement of non-compliance, including pursuing penalties and prosecution where necessary.

And whilst no formal public consultation was undertaken for this instrument, we have worked closely with stakeholders through webinars, publication of guidance, roundtables, the Horticulture Working Group, as well as one-to-one meetings, particularly on the implementation of the Windsor Framework.

From these ongoing stakeholder engagement mechanisms and the technical nature of this instrument, we determined that a consultation was not required. In conclusion, let me emphasize that it is essential that the amendments in this instrument update the Northern Ireland statute book and enable effective compliance with plant health requirements to uphold our commitment to full and faithful implementation of the Windsor Framework. This instrument does not impede upon Northern Ireland's constitutional position or grant any additional powers to the European Union, nor does it introduce any additional impositions to stakeholders. So by approving it, we reaffirm our solid commitment to protect our agri-food, forestry, and horticultural sectors and deliver on our international obligations. I beg to move.

04:56:35 - 05:03:01

Nigel Dodds

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing the regulations and I move the motion standing in my name on the order paper. Once again, we are debating regulations which may appear on the surface to be technical and limited in scope, but as we know, such regulations raise issues of real constitutional and democratic significance and importance. No one, my Lords, here tonight is going to argue against high standards of plant health or biosecurity. Of course, we need effective protection against pests and disease, and Northern Ireland farmers and growers deserve robust safeguards. The question is not whether we should have these high standards, the question is who decides those standards and what should they be?

In a democracy, the answer should be straightforward. The laws applied to citizens of the United Kingdom should be made by legislators the people elect and can remove. Yet here we are passing regulations because, as the explanatory memorandum says, they're necessary to implement obligations arising under the Windsor Framework and to reflect EU legislation which continues to apply to Northern Ireland. Such legislation isn't made here at Westminster and it's not made at Stormont by the Northern Ireland Assembly. Yet businesses and citizens, UK businesses and UK citizens in Northern Ireland are required to obey it.

Parliament is being asked to amend domestic law as a consequence of a regulatory regime imposed on part of the United Kingdom by the European Union. These regulations permit the authorities to enforce laws. That's what these regulations do, the power of enforcement. They don't actually set the laws that people are having to abide by in Northern Ireland. That has already been decided.

It's been decided by the European Union and imposed on Northern Ireland. So tonight, whatever your views are on the merits of the particular issues that are before us tonight in these regulations, we can't actually debate those. That's already been decided. We're debating the enforcement mechanisms. That's the constitutional reality which ministers and others continually try to avoid with words such as technical, pragmatic, necessary.

I mean, and when you look at some of the wording of the regulations, you can see that these are not mere technical tidying up of wording, updating the statute book in some small way.

B, any reference to the Union or Union territory, that's European Union territory, is to be read so as to include Northern Ireland. Now these are hardly technical changes. These are not small matters. Instead of removing the regulatory border within our country, government policy amounts to managing that border by accommodating the EU rules which created the need for it in the first place. It's an acceptance and entrenchment of the problem.

It's not a solution to the problem. We hear much about protecting the Northern Ireland internal market. We've heard it again tonight. In a genuine internal market, goods move freely from one part of the country to another without an international customs border, without special schemes which we have in Northern Ireland with their crushing bureaucracy and enormous costs, compliance requirements which are having a chilling effect on companies doing business with Northern Ireland consumers and in some cases banning it altogether. My problem, my Lords, the problem with the way in which the Windsor Framework is discussed by the government and others who support it is that each individual regulation is presented as some small technical measure.

Each individual change is said to be limited in scope and not burdensome, but taken together as part of the Windsor Framework in their totality, they amount to something constitutionally enormous: the subjection of Northern Ireland to laws made by an authority outside the United Kingdom and the creation of barriers to trade between one part of our country and another. And as the minister has just tried to explain, they're not even bothering about public consultation anymore. They say it's unnecessary. If legislation affecting England, Scotland or Wales were being amended because laws made by a foreign legislature continued automatically to apply in certain respects, would ministers really regard consultation as an unnecessary formality? The absence of consultation is particularly striking because these regulations concern enforcement.

The government aren't simply tidying up references in legislation. They are ensuring that the requirements flowing from the EU regime can be effectively enforced in part of the United Kingdom. Surely that deserves the proper scrutiny and engagement with those who will actually be affected in Northern Ireland. And the absence of a full impact assessment is similarly concerning. A key assessment should be what the cumulative impact is of all of these arrangements on trade within the United Kingdom.

My Lords, the reality is that the Windsor Framework of which this is part fundamentally alters Northern Ireland's constitutional position without the cross-community consent which has been at the foundation of political stability in Northern Ireland for decades. It's simply nonsense to say that the only choices are the present arrangements or some kind of hard border on the island of Ireland. That's been comprehensively debunked and shown to be false. The government needs to be working towards fundamental solutions to the problem rather than continuing to legislate to administer the consequences of the protocol and to entrench it even further. For those reasons, I beg to move.

05:03:01 - 05:03:05

Speaker 97

The question is that this motion be agreed to.

05:03:05 - 05:06:31

Peter Lilley

My Lords, I entirely, I'm grateful to the noble Lord Dodds for securing this debate and ensuring we actually have three whole minutes to discuss the dismemberment of the United Kingdom. If we, well, I began by trying to find out what it was about by reading the explanatory memorandum. Can I make a complaint to those, if any of them are listening, who write these things, that it is completely opaque?

It gives no indication of what the actual consequences of what we're doing have on real people and real lives or on the constitution of this country. And in the future they must write them I hope more informatively. Following from that, if we were to reject this statutory instrument, what would happen? Would it mean that the European laws did no longer apply in Northern Ireland? No, they'd still apply.

They'd probably not be enforced by the British government. I don't know what would happen. Perhaps the European Union would send in officials to do the enforcement for us. But we should find out what the actual consequences of passing or not passing this legislation is before we decide whether it should go ahead. The next, does do these this regulation does this regulation actually fulfill the promises of the Windsor Framework as it's so called?

I looked up what the promises were and it says re plant health and so on that where's it gone? Ah yes, it says instead of full EU certification all plants and seeds will move under the existing UK wide plant passport scheme in line with traders throughout the UK. Previously banned seed potatoes will once again be available from other parts of the UK while remaining prohibited in Ireland. Now is that the case? Is it exactly the same as in the rest of the UK or not?

The honourable member for well Sammy Wilson in the other place said that he finds it difficult to get seed potatoes in Northern Ireland. That consignments about two kilograms have to go through complex procedures and lots of producers and suppliers no longer get them from GB. Is that or is that not the case? Will this regulation alter that in any way? Now I share the disgust which the noble lord has mentioned at the inclusion in this document of statements that Northern Ireland is to be treated as part of the EU.

What it's effectively saying is that the constitutional relationship between Northern Ireland and the rest of the United Kingdom is to be the same as between Donbas and Luhansk and the rest of Ukraine. Legally they're part of Ukraine but the laws are made by Russia. Here legally Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom.

05:06:31 - 05:06:35

Speaker 99

I could just ask the noble lord to to bring his comments to an end.

05:06:35 - 05:08:57

Paul Bew

And not that somewhat.

My lords, it's already apparent that this particular SI is connected to a wider ideological political debate. Particular SI we learn from the text, we'll come back to the text later for the statutory instrument, that it has virtually no impact, is already operative in Northern Ireland and so on. The noble baroness the minister said that the Windsor Framework seed potatoes was one area of great success for the Windsor Framework. I actually wish ministers would make more of those areas of success for the Windsor Framework because the most important thing it does for all its many defects is it returns to the fundamental negotiating point which led to the Good Friday Agreement. The negotiating point being that commitment the British government was not committed in any way to developing an all-island economy which it is committed to by some of the documents before the Windsor Framework agreed with the European Union.

That is the most important thing. And the current expansion and growth of Northern Ireland, I've seen figures recently which suggest that the Greater Belfast region is actually doing better than the Greater Manchester region, heaven forfend. But it is linked into because of the fact that the UK as an economy still operates fundamentally as a viable internal single market. Now, having made that point, I just want to say one thing because I do think Lord Dodds has a point. No consultation on this document.

Some of the looking at our own statutory our secondary legislation statutory committee, looking at the correspondence in and around that, it's very difficult to get a handle on it. It and you leave with the feeling that because this is small beer, because it really does not affect very many people in a significant way, officials don't put the work into it. Now, I actually think we do not we should not be coming towards this House and saying no consultation. We should be coming to this House with explaining what the consultation said. I think Lord Dodds has a point there.

05:08:57 - 05:12:28

Margaret Ritchie

My Lords, another week and yet again we have another regret motion in respect of the Windsor Framework regarding plant health seeds, seed potatoes and plant propagating material. I ask the simple question: what does this achieve? And like the noble Lord Bew, I agree that this is more about the constitutional debate in Northern Ireland. Who benefits from these repetitive debates in the House of Lords? And as someone who supports the Windsor Framework and does not support the regret motion, I would say that we should be looking at areas of collaboration and cooperation with the wider business community about the benefits to be availed and to be obtained from the Windsor Framework and also from the dual access to the UK internal market and access to the EU single market, because that is what many of the businesses are saying to me and that is where the benefits lie.

We must not forget that the Windsor Framework is a direct result of Brexit, which many of those who are opposed to the special arrangements for Northern Ireland are opposed. The bottom line is that we would have been better to remain within the EU and for my personal hope is that that comes about over the next few years. Obviously this SI, my Lords, is to ensure that EU legislation governing plant health, seeds, seed potatoes and plant propagating materials continues to operate effectively in Northern Ireland. It also includes full enforcement powers to ensure compliance with plant health requirements and biosecurity in Northern Ireland. It also states there is an ongoing programme of work to ensure that all regulations covered by the Windsor Framework are fully operable and enforceable in Northern Ireland.

Obviously this information should have been in the explanatory document as the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee states, and maybe my noble friend the Minister could indicate why this did not happen, and maybe she doesn't have that information to hand this evening, maybe she could possibly write to me. Undoubtedly the potato industry is significant to the agri-food industry in Northern Ireland, and I have family involved in it, and they do not talk about the inability to get seed potatoes or the regulations which they face.

Their main concern centers on the weather conditions as a result of climate change because they face wet springs and autumns which make planting and harvesting extremely difficult. Undoubtedly the Windsor Framework has presented a number of challenges, and I'd like to ask my noble friend the minister in conclusion if she could provide us either tonight or in writing with a copy in the library of the full implementation of Lord Murphy's report recommendations were accepted by government and the ones from our committee as well, and also in relation to further details in relation to the SPS agreement. Thank you.

05:12:28 - 05:15:41

John Redwood

This is no way to legislate for Northern Ireland. It is not right to annex part of our country to the European Union. I and some colleagues in the Commons at the time of the Windsor Framework opposed it and pointed out that there were much easier ways of organizing the trade and border arrangements between Great Britain, Northern Ireland, and the Republic of Ireland. And I think the government should go back to that work and understand that we do not have here a system of handling Northern Ireland law and trade which meets the requirements of the loyalist community and maybe others in Northern Ireland as well. The government should be ashamed of how undemocratic this process is, as Lord Dodds has rightly identified.

There is no point in consulting all the people who are going to be affected by regulations in these areas in Northern Ireland because the government can't change them. And the government can't be bothered to work out the impact costs or even the impact benefits of a regulation because it rightly understands it is a spectator, it is not in charge of any of these things. And then we're told in the documents that there's going to be no review of how this works out. Well, all the other examples that come to the Commons and the Lords' consideration from government go through a proper process. There is consultation with the people they're going to affect.

Both Houses do expect a proper assessment of costs and benefits. We do expect a proper debate, and if the government's got it wrong, we expect the government to go away and change it or amend it. And we certainly expect there to be a review after the process so that we can see whether it's worked out in the way the government wanted. The fact that none of these things can happen on any of these SIs means that we are going to spend a lot of time on SI after SI complaining about the process. So I have this suggestion for the government.

They have embarked on negotiations for something they call the EU reset. And so far all I've seen is a list of things that the EU wants and the government indicating it would like to give those away in order to purchase some greater friendship or influence. It's always very odd that they think you get influence by giving in to what the other party wants. It's not the way most people negotiate. But wouldn't it be a good idea then if the government put to the EU that this is doing damage in Northern Ireland to relations between communities and to the way they're governed and that it is undemocratic and so surely we need a new settlement over how Northern Ireland legislation is conducted and over how trade is conducted.

And so I would recommend very much the mutual enforcement model where we say that we won't send anything from Northern Ireland which is non-compliant to the EU and we won't want to impose any new barriers on the Republic of Ireland-Northern Ireland border, but we would dismantle all barriers between GB and Northern Ireland.

05:15:41 - 05:18:55

Speaker 101

My Lords, it's a real pleasure to be here to support my noble friend the Minister and to oppose the amendment in the name of Lord Dodds. I do respect, and have heard them many times, as has I think everybody else present, the constitutional concerns that have been raised. But I think it is right that we focus on the practical reality facing farmers, growers, businesses in Northern Ireland on these occasions. It is probably worth reminding the House that under the Northern Ireland Protocol, the movement of seed potatoes into Northern Ireland, there were difficulties, and that the Windsor Framework was negotiated by the previous government in order to attempt to resolve some of these. Nobody, I think, would argue that we're in a perfect situation.

There are issues, there are constitutional concerns, there is a problem with concerns from the unionist community. That is absolutely understood. It is legitimate. What you do about that is an open question and something that I don't think anybody has a simple, whatever they might try and imply in these sorts of debates, a simple solution to. But for today, this is about allowing the movement of high-quality seed potatoes into a market.

It is necessary. The measure means that the appropriate agencies will have the powers that they need to protect biosecurity. That's it. That is what this does, and that is why my noble friend is right to propose it to the House. On the issue of consultation, it is my observation that Defra in particular needs no encouragement to consult on any issue at any given time.

But this instrument doesn't introduce a new policy or introduce new burdens. I did hear what Lord Bew said about this, and I think sometimes there are sometimes a need for other reasons to engage the community in a very visible way. Perhaps that is a point worth reflecting on for future. But in the narrow sense, the thing that would trigger a consultation ordinarily, this would not meet that threshold. And it's a decision not to consult, it's not forced not to consult.

But by rejecting these regulations, we wouldn't solve the concerns of noble Lord, Lord Dodds, or anybody else. You know, this is an imperfect situation. We recognise that. But for tonight, and for the benefit of business and growers in Northern Ireland, it is important that we pass these regulations to give the legal certainty and clarity that that important industry needs. And I would just finally say that at a time when free trade faces growing threats from protectionism and geopolitical instability in many areas of the world, that for me, I think that if we can secure a stable, frictionless internal market here, that is more important now than ever.

05:18:55 - 05:22:04

David Frost

My Lords, we are in the second of what will be three discussions of statutory instruments before we go to recess on the Windsor Framework. And one of the advantages of this rapid sequence of debates is that we can check the consistency of what is said in one debate compared to another. And with that in mind, I note that the noble Baroness the Minister said when winding up last week, and I quote: "The noble Lord, Lord Frost, implied that the UK has ceded biosecurity responsibilities for Northern Ireland to the EU."

She went on to say, we retain complete autonomy to make our own regulatory decisions, end quote. Now, I gently ask the Minister whether she entirely stands by that statement in the light of the discussion we're having today for a few reasons. First, as we've heard, the explanatory memorandum says that the EU amendments, as they're called, are already, I quote, operational in Northern Ireland. Not only that, Defra told the secondary legislation committee in discussion on this that, and again I quote, if necessary, DAERA, the Northern Ireland equivalent, could in practice have relied on the EU regulations as a basis for enforcement action. So one wonders quite what the point of this SI is, given what the powers that are already in place, and it certainly feels rather irrelevant.

Second point, in case it's not obvious enough, the government is clear, and we've heard, that these amendments are required of us by the Windsor Framework. The explanatory memorandum again says, the purpose of this SI is to ensure that relevant domestic legislation operates in accordance with the Windsor Framework. In other words, that's the justification, not the substantive purpose. And third, again as we've heard already, if that was not enough, para 7.1 of the explanatory memorandum washes its hands of it and says, if you've got concerns about any of this, go to Brussels and talk to them about it. I wonder when this great reset and the new SPS rules are in place and impose this regime on the whole of the UK, whether that will also be the government's position and whether farmers will be told to go to Brussels and beg if they don't like the new SPS reset arrangement.

Seems like that's the logical consequence of the position that's taken here. My Lords, it couldn't be clearer, I think, that the British government has no say in these matters at all, and today's legislation makes that abundantly clear. So I ask the noble lady the Minister, in what sense does she think the government does have autonomy in these areas? And I suggest to her that today's discussion is really disconnected from the real power relationships in Northern Ireland and is entirely performative, and therefore Lord Dodds' regret motion is entirely justified.

05:22:04 - 05:24:41

Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor

My Lords, this is another statutory instrument to update EU law enforcement on plant health, seeds, seed potatoes and plant propagating material so it operates effectively in Northern Ireland. It aligns, therefore, the operation of Northern Ireland's agri-food sector with EU laws. The measures do not take account of the geographical climate, agricultural conditions of Northern Ireland, different from those of mainland Europe. The House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee concluded in its assessment of SPS for GB that full adoption of EU rules in this area risks embedding regulatory decisions inappropriate for GB production systems. So I'd like to ask the noble Baroness the Minister, is it right that we should be having statutory instruments to enforce regulatory decisions that may not suit the conditions, of very different conditions, in Northern Ireland?

Worse, the regulations violate the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom, rupturing our internal market. They mean divergent laws to govern the agri-food sectors under the Windsor Framework. That framework, as we know, accepted as permanent the EU's power to regulate goods in Northern Ireland, including this aggregate sector. Whereas the settlement under the Northern Ireland Protocol of the withdrawal agreement was recognized by the parties at the time as temporary, pending, and to quote, best endeavors to find a more lasting solution. Northern Ireland, as long as we have the current arrangements, will thus be an economic vassal of Brussels, governed autocratically with laws made for the people but not by the people.

05:24:41 - 05:27:47

Speaker 104

My Lords, I'm not going to reiterate some of the wider constitutional issues which have already been raised, but I would first of all question why is this SI even needed? By Defra's own admission, the current regulations are fully complied with by everybody in the industry. And indeed, it is something, that admission, is one which has been highlighted, I think, by the Subordinate Legislation Committee, does not even get a mention in the explanatory memorandum, no matter how opaque it is, and indeed was criticized by the committee for its omission. But I want to particularly concentrate on the issue of consultation, or lack thereof, and it seems to be part of a wider pattern on these SIs in which there is no consultation taking place. And there are two conclusions one can draw in relation to that.

First of all, it is an approach which is both arrogant and ignorant. Indeed, one of the rationales being given by the government in the SI for a lack of consultation is that, quote, stakeholders, impacted stakeholders and businesses have had many opportunities to feed into the development of the EU regulations through various formal EU consultations. So the expectation is that if you're a small business, you're supposed to be both aware of what is coming down the pipeline from the EU and actually feed in and make your representations directly to the EU. The government appears to be completely washing their hands of that. And in terms of the issue of ignorance, we've seen previous occasions whenever, for example, legislation was put through on seed potatoes, where the impact of that, and I know from one particular example in which a business would have actually completely gone out of business because they were not able to source even from another source, and it took a considerable amount of work with the then agriculture minister in Northern Ireland to find a technical solution to enable them to remain in business.

And that was because it was simply imposed with an ignorance to the direct impact on the individual. But it is also the case, the second reason why consultation clearly has not taken place, is because effectively this is a fait accompli. It doesn't matter in many ways whether this is on the substance of this, that stakeholders would say, fair enough, we think this is perfectly fine, or whether they would be utterly up in arms, because in either case, the government is in the position where simply it is allowing it to be imposed. So why go through a consultation in the first place?

That, I would suggest, is no way to do laws in this country, to impose it upon people. And it suggests to me, in conclusion, that whether it's with this government with the reset or a future government with a very different reset, simply banking the current status quo and building upon that is not something which is acceptable. And that is the wider lesson that we need to draw from this SI.

05:27:47 - 05:30:35

Bryn Davies

I welcome the opportunity to take part in this interesting debate. This is the second time I've intervened in what appears to be a series of debates on this issue. The last time I was guilty of a degree of naivety. It turned out that it wasn't a debate about tumble dryers. It was really a debate about Brexit and the Windsor Framework.

Just as today's debate, although quite a few references have been made to plant health, seeds, and potatoes, this is really at heart a debate about where we are with Brexit and the associated Windsor Framework. Why are we here? Given the time available, I just want to make three points about Brexit. First, it was sold on a false prospectus, of which 'take back control' was one of the most egregious. It was, to put it no finer, a lie.

We do not have control in an interconnected world to the extent we were told. Secondly, the terms upon which exit was negotiated were negotiated, in my view, incompetently, not least of which the failure to appreciate until too late the implications of a land border between Northern Ireland, between the UK and the European Union. And thirdly, it's worth making the point that now a majority of people in the United Kingdom regard Brexit as a mistake. These are all thoughts that need to be borne in mind when undertaking this debate. I just want to make one final point, that given the nature of this debate and why it's happening, it's relevant to point out that in the Brexit referendum, a clear majority of the people of Northern Ireland were against leaving the European Union.

In fact, the majority in favour of staying in Europe was somewhat greater than the majority across the UK as a whole who wished to leave.

05:30:35 - 05:33:41

Kate Hoey

Noble Lords should be clear that these regulations, which allow the law in Northern Ireland to diverge from that of Great Britain, actually violates Article 1(2) of the Windsor Framework, which clearly states, and I quote, that the purpose of the Windsor Framework is to protect the essential state functions of the United Kingdom. Now, surely, my Lords, the most basic function of a state has to ensure the nation's security, and a critical component of that is, of course, biosecurity. And what the government has not admitted is that this legislation applies different biosecurity standards to Northern Ireland and Great Britain because of the EU dictat and is set in the context of an SPS border dividing one part of the UK from another, and that these regulations step beyond the bounds of the Windsor Framework.

Now the noble lady last week sought to dismiss concerns of this kind by arguing that the island of Ireland has long been treated as a single area for epidemiology. But this argument does not work because there is a distinct difference between being treated as a single area for epidemiology in a context where we set our own common UK biosecurity standards and what happens now. And today we are being divided in two by international SPS border control posts at Belfast, Larne, Warrenpoint and Foyle, supposedly to protect Northern Ireland from the threat from our own country. What a ridiculous thing to say. Control posts which have cost 152 million pounds so far of taxpayers' money to construct.

The truth is that while we have ceased being members of the EU, we have still not left the EU. While the Windsor Framework is in existence, the United Kingdom will never really experience a true departure from the European Union. And this point is so eloquently demonstrated by the regulations mentioned by many noble peers. A reference to a member state is to be read as if Northern Ireland were a member state of the European Union. How dare his Majesty's government just write out Northern Ireland from its own country and into the EU's regulatory territory.

And we also refer to GB as a third country, which is also really outrageous. And even worse, any future changes which Brussels wants to bring in will simply be nodded through and business will have to comply or be sanctioned. Changes to all sorts of things, passports, farm machinery, etc. No public consultation, not a single farmer or garden centre or grower asked for their view. How dare the government again say that these are just technical changes.

And if I could say to the noble Baroness Ritchie, we will keep having these SI regret motions because that is the only way in this chamber that we get the chance to discuss the constitutional outrage of what is happening and the drip-by-drip approach, the drip-by-drip moving away Northern Ireland from the rest of the United Kingdom. And this is not something that is going to go away. And I very much support the noble Lord Dodds if he in fact decides to vote this to show as a matter of principle that we object to this kind of treatment.

05:33:41 - 05:36:24

Susy De Martini

My Lords, I thank the minister for introducing these regulations as well as Lord Dodds for allowing us to have this short debate this evening through his regret motion. As I said in last week's debate, the concerns about these regulations are much less about the substance of the regulations themselves and more about the democratic oversight, parliamentary scrutiny and very legitimate fears that Northern Ireland feels that it is being treated differently to the rest of the UK. Regarding the regulations themselves, can the minister say what is the government's assessment of the impact, if any, on the sector of the eight-year gap between the introduction of the EU regulations in 2018 and these enforcement regulations that we're debating this evening? Can she also say a little more about how business and stakeholders were able to feed into the development of the regulations through various EU consultations as it states in the explanatory memorandum and how the government ensured that this happened in practice? In last week's debate as well as this evening, Baroness Chapman talked about the need to be pragmatic and practical.

In general terms, I would agree. The agricultural sector is looking for stability, biosecurity and mechanisms to protect our ecosystems from invasive pests and crop diseases. On these benches, we recognise that aligning with the EU reduces barriers to trade. The reality of dynamic alignment, however, my Lords, is that we are usually dealing with very small technical changes which are probably only truly understood by a small group of experts, including I would hope the noble lady the minister who follows these matters very closely. But in the absence of formal representation in the European Union institutions, it is vital, I believe, that this parliament plays a full and proper scrutiny role.

And I still firmly hope that the government will set out a strategy in this regard.

Finally, it is deeply to be regretted, I believe, that the House of Commons no longer has a European scrutiny committee. It previously played a vital role in carrying out necessary scrutiny of these regulations. And this function is increasingly only being carried out by the European Affairs Committee of your Lordships' House. And through regret motions such as this one, I believe this is something that the government really does need to bring forward proposals to improve.

05:36:24 - 05:39:21

David Simpson

My Lords, I thank the noble lady the Baroness, the minister, for bringing this secondary legislation before your Lordships' House tonight. Once again, noble lords and ladies from Northern Ireland and some of my noble friends have, in my opinion, made a very powerful and unanswerable case about the undemocratic way these regulations have been imposed in Northern Ireland without any input from Northern Ireland politicians or the United Kingdom government. Now, of course, these regulations already take effect across the EU, and these regulations are operational and enforcement measures. However, I do have questions and concerns about the process, as other noble lords have said. And I do share the concerns of the noble lord, Lord Dodds, whose motion formally regrets that these regulations were made without public consultation.

Now, the explanatory memorandum states that the government has engaged with key stakeholders to notify them of the main changes, but that is not the same as consultation. So can the noble lady the minister provide more detail on how the department and the Northern Ireland Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, DAERA, how they select stakeholders to engage with and ensure that those impacted are aware of the changes? What exactly was the scope and scale of this engagement? Furthermore, whilst the government have said that businesses and stakeholders can participate in formal EU consultations, how does the government ensure businesses and stakeholders are aware of these EU consultations? What assessment has the government made of current participation levels, and does the government think the EU consultations are adequate in acting on concerns raised?

My Lords, we should not be complacent, but proactive in ensuring the needs and concerns of businesses and key stakeholders in Northern Ireland are heard and acted upon. Now, on the Windsor Framework itself, despite its inherent flaws, this is a great improvement on the awful Northern Ireland Protocol negotiated in October 2019. But that is not to say this is perfect, nor was it ever the view that the Windsor Framework is beyond improvement. As the official opposition, we remain open to constructive discussions with all interested parties on how we can best protect the economic and constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom. And so I thank the noble lord, Lord Dodds, for his motion and his valuable insights tonight.

As noble lords have said, whilst individually these SIs are small and technical and not significant, but collectively, slowly and surely, they give the impression that Northern Ireland is being leveraged out of the United Kingdom. That situation is not sustainable, and sooner rather than later, it needs to be addressed by this Parliament. I look forward to the noble lady the Baroness's response.

05:39:21 - 05:47:23

Sue Hayman

My Lords, first of all, can I thank noble lords from all sides of the House for their contribution and comments to the debate today and for the valuable points made in respect of the instrument. I will rattle through, I don't have very long, I'm afraid. Because there's been a broad range of issues that have been covered during the debate, some clearly beyond the scope of the instrument, but important nonetheless.

So I'll do my best to cover the issues raised in the time I have. The noble Lord Lord Dodds talked about Northern Ireland's status as have other noble Lords. This is a technical amendment. I get the point that the noble Lord Brinkath has just made, but this is not about making Northern Ireland a member state or changing Northern Ireland's status. It's about protecting the unique opportunity that we've secured for Northern Ireland.

And what we have done is we're ensuring that Northern Ireland's operators maintain seamless access to the EU single market while at the same time firmly remaining within the UK's internal market. A number of noble Lords did raise the issue of constitution and the Windsor Framework. And as I said at the beginning, this does not change the Windsor Framework. And I do appreciate the strength of feeling around constitutional issues, but I want to assure noble Lords that this instrument respects Northern Ireland's position and integral place within the United Kingdom. It is UK-made, UK-scrutinised and operates within the scope of the UK's international commitments.

And introducing and applying domestic legislation to Northern Ireland upholds the UK government's commitment to implementing the Windsor Framework. And as we've heard is a clear improvement on the Northern Ireland Protocol and is the best workable solution that we have. And some Lords have, noble Lords suggested the United Kingdom is being governed by the European Union, or at least given that implication. This is not the case. Northern Ireland, as I said, is fully part of the UK internal market.

It has unfettered access for Northern Ireland goods moving to GB. And EU law applies only in limited defined areas necessary to preserve island of Ireland biosecurity and Northern Ireland's access to the EU single market. The framework enables Northern Ireland's unique dual market access supporting its agri-food sector and its rural economy. There are no constitutional changes made by this instrument. It simply provides for full enforcement of biosecurity controls at domestic level.

Noble Lords, the noble Lord Lily for example talked about enforcement. Defra and GB competent authorities work closely to achieve compliance with biosecurity controls and minimise any disruption or delay on trade. However, Defra must also be able to ensure it has adequate means of taking appropriate action on the small number of operators that may not comply with plant health requirements in order to ensure a level playing field for those following the rules. The amendments included in this instrument will ensure that Defra will have the powers to maintain a legal regime that can be effectively enforced so that penalties can be imposed for non-compliance that put Northern Ireland biosecurity at risk. However, it is the intention of Defra to maintain a proportionate approach.

The noble Lord Bew mentioned the positive impacts of the Windsor Framework. I mentioned seed potatoes in my speech, but I'd just like to give another example. Goods moved under the Northern Ireland plant health label scheme, which was introduced as part of the Windsor Framework, increased from 1,708 in 2024 to 4,090 in 2025. This is extremely positive and clearly demonstrates that goods are moving across the United Kingdom and that the flow of trade is good. I was asked about why there wasn't an impact assessment.

A full impact assessment was not prepared as it isn't required under the better regulation framework and it will not impact on businesses and stakeholders. And in fact provides Defra with more effective enforcement against non-compliant operators.

I did talk about the engagement with stakeholders leading to the development of the instrument and I mentioned the UK Horticultural Working Group. The noble lady Baroness Hoey said that we haven't spoken to any farmers, but that group includes the UFU, the Ulster Farmers' Union and the Horticultural Trades Association. I'd also like to assure the noble Lord Lord Redesdale that we talked to the EU during our discussions about Northern Ireland and the concerns that are raised in the particular ways that we have to manage Northern Ireland trade. And Lord Frost may be interested to know that I met a number of farmers today who are very supportive of our SPS negotiations because they see the benefits to trade. Lord Frost and the noble lady Baroness Chapman talked about the necessity of the SI on opposite ends of the scales.

The legislation gives Deara the necessary powers. You know, this is why we need it. We need to protect Northern Ireland's biosecurity and high plant health status. My noble friend Baroness Ritchie asked about the Murphy report. The government accepted all of the recommendations made by Lord Murphy in his independent review of the Windsor Framework.

And amongst other measures, we will sharpen and improve our engagement with a range of stakeholders across different sectors and businesses that implement the Windsor Framework. And we will also continue our work to smooth the flow of goods moving from GB to Northern Ireland, including the future SPS agreement. The noble lady Baroness Hoey mentioned divergence and I completely appreciate her points in respect of regulatory divergence and concerns that this could complicate trade. However, the government's view is that the Windsor Framework promotes a careful and pragmatic balance between maintaining Northern Ireland's access to the EU single market and safeguarding its place within the UK internal market. It reduces unnecessary checks on goods, which is why many businesses support this approach.

The noble lady Baroness Lawlor may be interested to know that Deara officials in Northern Ireland actually drafted the legislation and have worked to ensure that the instrument is drafted with what is necessary and proportionate for Northern Ireland at its core. And that approach reflects the fact that the Windsor Framework obligations arise from an agreement reached by the UK government and which ultimately fall to the UK government to uphold. It's not appropriate to leave them solely to the Northern Ireland Executive discharge, which is why we work on direction and control with Deara. Turning back to the specifics of the statutory instrument at hand today, this instrument serves only to update Northern Ireland's plant health legislation, ensuring it's clear, operable and accurate. This not only gives Deara clarity in the vital roles it delivers in protecting Northern Ireland's biosecurity, but clarity and stability to Northern Ireland stakeholders, ensuring all parties play their part in doing what's necessary to maintain plant health in Northern Ireland.

By ensuring the requirements are clear and correct in this instrument, it will ensure there are no legislative gaps, no room for confusion in dealing with complex plant health environment and thus contributes to safeguarding Northern Ireland's trade and economic success in the agri-food, horticulture, forestry and woodland sectors. And it also, as I've said, ensures that the United Kingdom meets its international obligations under the Windsor Framework, serving to ensure high biosecurity standards that Northern Ireland is privileged to observe are continued. I want to give the noble Lord Lord Dodds time, so I will finish there on the details of the consultation raised by the noble Lord Lord Blencathra and the noble lady Baroness Suttie. I will write with the detail because there's quite a lot there.

05:47:23 - 05:47:25

Speaker 111

I beg to move.

05:47:25 - 05:49:02

Nigel Dodds

I'm grateful for all those that have taken part in this debate, especially those who have indicated support for my regret motion. One noble baroness said, well, what's achieved by these debates, who benefits? Well, I suppose when the government doesn't bother about consultation, they don't impact assessment, the next logical step is to forget about parliamentary debate as well. Why bother having any of this? The purpose of these debates is actually to bring scrutiny to legislation which would otherwise pass without any examination made by a foreign political body for the citizens of the UK.

That's why it's important. That's why they're significant. And when people say why aren't we dealing with the practicalities instead of the constitutionalities, the fact is the practicalities are decided not here but elsewhere. We can't debate tumble dryers as the noble lord mentioned or these other issues because the policy, the legislation is not decided here. We're debating enforcement and other peripheral matters, the substance has been decided elsewhere.

The noble baroness, the minister, said that this respects Northern Ireland's place in the United Kingdom. How does a regulation which states in terms that any reference to the European Union or Union territory is to be read so as to include Northern Ireland? That's in black and white in these regulations. That is a scandalous proposition for any government to put in legislation in this house. And for that reason, I wish to test the opinion of the house and to seek where people stand on issues of such importance.

05:49:02 - 05:49:21

Ilora Finlay

Question is that this amendment be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. I think the not contents have it. The question will be decided by a division and I will inform the house when voting is open.

My lords, voting is now open, clear the bar.

05:52:22 - 05:52:30

Speaker 112

The question is that this amendment be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne and the not contents to the left by the bar.

05:57:21 - 05:59:31

Speaker 114

The question is that the amendment in the name of Lord Dodds be agreed to. My Lords, they have voted. Contents 26, not contents 63, so the not contents have it.

05:59:31 - 05:59:55

Ilora Finlay

The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

The contrary not content. The contents have it.

05:59:55 - 05:59:59

Speaker 115

My lords, I beg to move the house again resumes itself into committee.

05:59:59 - 06:00:26

Ilora Finlay

The question is that the house do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Schedule six, amendment 48, Lord De Mauley.

06:00:26 - 06:07:50

Rupert Ponsonby

My lords, I rise to speak to amendments 48, 50, 51 and 52 which are in my name. Let me start with amendment 48 which is about payment to the new non-executive board members. The members of the RFCAs and those of all their forebear organisations commencing with the county territorial associations in 1908, whether acting locally or at national level, have never been paid. The volunteer ethos is of very considerable significance, especially in the world of reserves and cadets. My lords, imagine how it will look to the reservists who volunteer and put their lives on the line and to the cadet forces if the non-executives, the non-executives, are to be paid.

It's a really bad look and unlikely to attract the best of society who are absolutely committed to the reserves and cadets. Furthermore, we are living in a time of scarce resources, especially in the field of defence. Yet here is the MOD deliberately adding cost when they know there is a ready supply of volunteers who will do and indeed are currently doing this work for no financial reward. One can guess the reaction of those who've shown over many years their dedicated and unpaid commitment to the reserves and cadets to the appointment of paid non-executives with no apparent commitment to reserves or cadets. My lords, it's a mistake to offer money to entice people to apply for these roles.

Turning now to amendment 50 to reinstate Lord Lieutenants. Lord Lieutenants are the sovereign's representatives in their respective lieutenancies or counties. It is their foremost duty to uphold the dignity of the crown. Historically, each Lord Lieutenant was responsible for organising the county's militia. The Territorial and Reserve Forces Act of 1907 established county territorial associations with the Lord Lieutenant as the president of the county association.

The relationship of Lord Lieutenants with the military today is maintained via their presidency of their county RFCAs and all Lord Lieutenants are affiliated to one of the 13 regional RFCAs, one of them is president and they rotate it amongst them. This is constituted in primary legislation, most recently schedule four to the Reserve Forces Act of 1996. To remove that would remove the final vestiges of a military role and an important part of the Lord Lieutenant's symbolic relationship to the crown. Service personnel hold the sovereign in the highest regard. To cut off this link between reservists and the crown seems to say the least inappropriate.

Lord Lieutenants have evidenced considerable concern over the review's proposals and the consequences of breaking this important link. Under the Armed Forces Bill, the involvement of the Lord Lieutenants which was established under schedule four paras two, three and four of the Reserve Forces Act of 1996 is to be abolished. That's in the schedule six part three para 42B where it says omit section 111 and schedule four (provisions of schemes for the constitution of associations).

My Lords, it's been suggested as an afterthought that the continued involvement of the Lord Lieutenants might be achieved through secondary legislation or regulation. The involvement of the Lord Lieutenants is currently in primary legislation, and to relegate it to regulations is nothing short of insulting. It also makes it much easier to amend, change and delete it. If it is proposed to amend the law in a way that affects a class of persons, it is, my Lords, customary to consult them. Even if there's no statutory duty to do so, there have been cases where the courts have held that failure to consult is a reason for upholding judicial review of the government.

My Lords, I understand that the Association of Lord Lieutenants has not been consulted. I urge the noble Lord the Minister to consider the amendment carefully. And my Lords, now turning to amendment 51 to establish a National Council. The strength of the RFCAs lies in their embeddedness across the regions. This wasn't accidental.

It reflects the original Haldane model from 1908, a decentralized, citizen-based structure designed to mirror national diversity and ensure societal ownership of the Territorial Reserve Force. And it has endured and worked for over a century. What is today described as "connecting defence with the nation" is rooted in this model. So it's right that the Bill establishes regional councils in paragraph 14 of Part 1 of Schedule 6. What is extremely odd, though, is that the drafters haven't understood that the regional councils are irrelevant if their views are not brought together and debated centrally so that a single, considered, professional message can be delivered to ministers.

Abolishment of the membership discussed in the debate on the last group also presents a conundrum as to where the regional council members will be elected from. When we questioned this, we were told, "don't worry, it'll be dealt with in secondary legislation". Well, I suggest this is a quite extraordinary response. Without a National Council, the regional councils are completely irrelevant, and without a membership, they will be ineffective. This seems to be an attempt to pay lip service to devolution while in fact cutting it off at the roots.

A National Council is fundamental to the functioning of the new structure, and the amendment would establish one. My Lords, turning now to amendment 52 about the External Scrutiny Team. The UK Reserve Forces and Cadets Association's External Scrutiny Team provides an independent annual assessment to Parliament on the state, capabilities and health of the United Kingdom's Reserve Forces. Identified as fundamental to advising ministers and the single services on the effectiveness of training, fighting efficiency and leadership of the Reserve, thus meeting the FR2020 proposition to reservists. It was established following the Future Reserves 2020 review and operates with statutory duties mandated by the Reserve Forces Act 1996.

The Armed Forces Bill at paragraph 5b introduces the concept that the Defence Council can remove responsibility for producing the annual assessment or report and award it to someone else at the stroke of a pen. This is not the case in the current legislation. Will the noble Lord the Minister therefore explain what lies behind this change? To whom might the responsibility for producing the independent assessment be transferred? What would be considered appropriate grounds for transferring it?

When might this happen?

How will ministers ensure the assessment continues in future to be conducted properly and truly independently of the MOD? My Lords, I beg to move.

06:07:50 - 06:07:58

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed, schedule 6, page 134, line 22, leave out paragraph 4.

06:07:58 - 06:13:39

Jock Stirrup

My Lords, I added my name to these amendments and I agree with the points that have been so well made by the noble Lord, Lord De Mauley. Let me start my brief remarks by making just a couple of general points. The first is that while there have been some criticisms of the arrangements of reserve and cadet forces, particularly in fairly recent reviews, most of these have been attended to subsequently, and the general opinion was that in the round the reserve forces and cadets operated extremely well, were extremely valuable, and the arrangements that had been set in place had served this country extremely well for a very long time. There's therefore a burden of proof on anyone seeking to change the current arrangements to show why any proposed alterations will be better than the arrangements that are already in place. And I fear, my Lords, that the government fails on this count in many instances within this particular part of the Armed Forces Bill.

My second point is that the noble Lord the Minister has previously indicated in committee that some of the shortcomings might be attended to in secondary legislation, and the noble Lord, Lord De Mauley, has just referred to this. Well, that's all very well, but as everybody in this chamber knows, we can't amend secondary legislation. We take it or leave it, and usually we have to take it. Now, of course we have to have secondary legislation for the detailed implementation of an act and the measures within that act. But issues of principle should be settled in primary legislation, not in secondary legislation, again for some of the reasons that the noble Lord, Lord De Mauley, has just pointed out.

And quite a number of the issues covered by the amendments this evening are issues of principle and therefore belong in primary legislation, not in secondary legislation. Now, as regards the burden of proof, I think that applies particularly to what is proposed in terms of having paid non-executive members. We have unpaid members at the moment. It works extremely well. They're volunteers, as the noble Lord, Lord De Mauley, says, it fits in very well with the volunteer ethos.

Why do we want to change it? I simply fail to see the rationale. Perhaps the noble Lord the Minister can explain this in some detail when he replies. With regard to amendment 50 and the issue of the Lords Lieutenant, my Lords, one point which we haven't touched on very much to date with regard to the reserves, which was referred to fleetingly by the noble Lord, Lord Lancaster of Kimbolton, who's no longer in his place, was we need to think about the future employment of the reserves, not just about the past. I agree entirely, and it seems clear to me, and I think it was made pretty clear in the government's own strategic defence review, that a very important role for reserves in the future will be to deal with issues of national resilience.

National resilience in the face of natural disasters, and indeed we had a question on that earlier today with regard to the flooding we're likely to see in this country as a result of the recent and current El Niño event, but also of course if we come under attack from an enemy.

The overall coordination of national resilience and the resources required to ensure it will of course be conducted at the national level. But the tactical dealing with national resilience will be conducted at the local level. The emergency services will all be dealing at the local level. And it seems to me incomprehensible to suppose that the reserve forces will not have a major role to play, particularly when we see severe challenges to our national resilience. That needs to be conducted at the local level.

It also seems to me implausible to suggest that the sovereign's representative in the locality will not be intimately involved in any responses to severe challenges to national resilience. The Lord Lieutenant will have a role to play in all of this. So the Lord Lieutenant's association with the reserve forces, it seems to me, is not just an issue of representation and history as referred to by the noble Lord, Lord de Mauley, but is a very practical issue in terms of the future role of the reserves. With regard to the national board for the regional associations, I have been an advocate for regionalism, for allowing authority to local bodies and to reserve forces within their regions. But clearly there will be an important role to be played in terms of spreading best practice, in terms of coordinating the various messages of those regional bodies, as the noble Lord, Lord de Mauley, has pointed out, and representing those at the national level.

And there does seem to me to be a requirement for some sort of mechanism that enables to do that, that acts as a bridge between the two. Finally, my Lords, if we're going to have a report on the reserve and cadet forces, for heaven's sake, let's have a report that we can rely upon, that is produced by an independent body that has no axe to grind one way or the other, except to see that this nation is served as it deserves to be, as it needs to be, by the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association.

06:13:39 - 06:17:42

Frederick Curzon

My Lords, again I should like to say a few words in support of my noble friend Lord de Mauley, and in particular to reinforce everything he said in relation to amendments 50 and 51. On amendment 51, I'll say no more than it plays into the issues that I was trying to highlight in the previous group and which the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, has referred to just now, as regards the need to retain a representative and coherent voice for the individual RFCA memberships. My noble friend argued the case for a national voluntary body very well and I don't intend to repeat the arguments he put forward. I would, however, like to make a couple of points on amendment 50. I mentioned earlier that my wife has the honour of being His Majesty's Lord Lieutenant of Buckinghamshire, and in that role she is ex-officio president of SERFCA.

We can easily talk about tradition in the context of supporting the work of the reserve forces and cadets. However, whilst I'm a great one for wanting to preserve such traditions, I don't regard tradition on its own as the most important reason for maintaining a statutorily based role for Lord Lieutenants in the regional councils. The main argument to my mind is that the involvement of Lord Lieutenants as honorary presidents or vice-presidents is highly valued by the RFCAs and by the reservists and cadets themselves.

Every year, my wife presents meritorious service awards to reservists in Buckinghamshire who've displayed outstanding achievement and commitment to the volunteer ethos. And the significance of these awards to the recipients is without question enhanced by the fact that they're presented by the King's representative. And I would go further in saying that the Lord Lieutenant's role in these presentations plays no small part in maintaining the motivation of our reservists and cadets. Exactly the same point can be made in relation to employer recognition scheme awards and how they are perceived by those in receipt of them. The appointment of Lord Lieutenants' cadets is another example.

It's an honor that cadets aspire to. Now the Minister may well say, indeed I think he has, that there will be nothing to prevent Lord Lieutenants from fulfilling the same kind of honorary function once the bill has been enacted. However, I for one don't feel that a loose arrangement of that kind would do justice to the well-defined function that Lord Lieutenants fulfill in upholding the dignity of the Crown. It's a function that of course is born of tradition over many centuries, but much more importantly, it is one that reflects the direct relationship between the armed forces and the Crown. Every time the King's representative meets a reservist on a public stage to recognize his or her outstanding service, it is a reminder that servicemen and women across the country owe their loyalty first and foremost to the Sovereign.

It isn't satisfactory in my judgment for a statute of this kind to remain silent on that key constitutional point.

06:17:42 - 06:20:35

Richard Dannatt

I speak in support of amendment 50 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord de Mauley, and other noble and gallant Lords in regard to ensuring that Lord Lieutenants' involvement as presidents of regional RFCA councils remain enshrined in primary legislation. And I totally support the comments just made by the noble Earl, Earl Howe. I should declare two interests: first, that I was a Deputy Lieutenant for Greater London and for Norfolk for over 10 years, supporting the Lord Lieutenants in those counties; and second, that my wife is the current Lord Lieutenant of Norfolk and the current president of the Eastern region of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association. I don't wish to repeat the arguments already made in support of amendment 50, nor dwell on the historic links, as important as they are, between the Crown and the reserve forces and cadets in each county through the role of the Lord Lieutenant, but to emphasize the leadership role that the Lord Lieutenant plays in their respective counties. The noble Earl, Earl Howe, has just referred to that.

In Norfolk recently, as in many other parts of the country, we've had a lot of fires during the drought period. Norfolk was particularly affected by that. My wife required a number of her Deputy Lieutenants to go to visit all the volunteer fire stations with letters of thanks from the county on behalf of His Majesty for their service. So it's not just reserve forces and cadets, it's actually the emergency services in the round. This role is currently enshrined in primary legislation, and my Lords, that is where it should remain.

Reducing it to secondary legislation seems unnecessary and, as Lord de Mauley has said, even insulting perhaps to both the Crown and Lord Lieutenants.

I understand that perhaps not surprisingly neither Buckingham Palace but more worryingly nor the Association of Lord Lieutenants have been formally consulted on this proposed change. Perhaps the noble Lord the Minister in answering this debate could comment on that. My Lords, at a time of increased threats to our national security, every effort should be made to promote our reserve forces and those such as Lord Lieutenants that support them. That support is of course freely given and at no cost to the nation. Moreover, our cadet forces are the largest youth movement in the country and provide great character training and personal development for those involved.

That many cadets go on to join our regular or reserve forces is a most welcome byproduct. And as already been mentioned, initiatives such as the annual appointment of Lord Lieutenants' cadets is a much cherished accolade in most counties and an incentive to excellence. My Lords, the bill as it stands serves to weaken the hugely important links between the crown through His Majesty's Lord Lieutenants and communities throughout the nation at a time of great insecurity. I strongly urge His Majesty's government to think again and I firmly support amendment 50.

06:20:35 - 06:23:54

Jasset David Cody Harlech

My Lords, I rise to support these amendments too in the name of my noble friend Lord de Mauley. And let me say from the outset that I do not oppose reform in principle and I did not put my name to the notices to oppose clause 38 or schedule 6 which the committee discussed earlier. However, there are two further things in this reorganization which we must not lose, which other noble Lords have already outlined. And I'm not persuaded that the bill protects either as it is currently drafted. The first is the independent reporting which is the subject of amendment 52.

The associations provide annual advice to defense by two formal means. And one of them is the external scrutiny team report on the state of the reserve forces. That report is at present the only genuinely independent annual assessment of the reserves which this house receives. If responsibility for it passes to a body sponsored by, funded by and accountable to the Ministry of Defence, we do not merely change who writes it, we lose the thing which made it worth reading. And we would be losing it in the very bill which increases our reliance on the reserves.

A department expanding its call on a force which it also grades is not a comfortable arrangement. And Parliament will need that independent view more in the coming decade, not less. The second is the standing of the regional structure which amendments 50 and 51 concern. These associations were established in 1908 precisely to root the reserve in the county. And as other noble Lords have said, the Lord Lieutenants have presided over them ever since.

Amendment 51 would provide a national council of the regional chairs so that the volunteer structure has a collective voice rather than 13 separate ones. This is not just sentiment and ceremony, important though they are. The office of Lord Lieutenant is what gives the reserve unit in a market town its standing within the county. And it costs the public purse nothing at all. My concern is that efficiency reforms have a habit of removing precisely the parts which look inefficient on a spreadsheet because they are voluntary and unpaid.

That is also the point behind amendment 48. Non-executive members who serve without payment serve because they care about the reserves and cadets. And I would be sorry to see that ethos priced. I recognize the governance case the Ministry of Defence has made.

And everything in this group and the last is offered as an attempt to improve the new body rather than obstruct it. I would ask the noble lord the minister to tell the committee specifically what safeguards will preserve the independence of the external scrutiny team report and how the role of the Lord Lieutenant will be maintained under the new body. If those assurances can be given from the dispatch box, then I think a good deal of the anxiety across these two groups would fall away.

06:23:54 - 06:30:37

Reg Empey

So I'm pleased to add my name to the suite of amendments. It covers a broad area. If we could start with 48. I'm sure any of us who have served as ministers or council leaders will have appointed loads of people to different bodies over the years. And one thing I did notice in more recent times is that a cohort of people have emerged who apply for a lot of different bodies whether or not they have qualifications or experience in any of them.

And while I understand that people aren't necessarily expected to do things for nothing or to be paying out money, I'd be more than content for people to get perfectly fair and reasonable expenses, whether that is travel or whatever it would be required. So I've no issue with that. But once you move the thing from that level to somebody who perhaps almost has a career in representing public on being sitting on public bodies, I think that changes the entire ethos and atmosphere around the establishment of these boards. So I have to say I have not been convinced by what is in the draft bill at the present moment and I would sincerely hope that we could retain. I mean, if unless there's a complete absence of people applying or unless there's an obvious shortage of people who are willing to sit on these boards, then I cannot understand why we would want to engage in expense in order to do it.

And given the fact that the whole apparatus and noble and gallant lords are far more expert than I am, but if you have an organization that is working and staff, what incentive are you giving those who do the grunt work on the ground if executives board members are being paid? I just think it upsets the balance. Now, the noble and gallant lord Lord Stirrup mentioned national resilience. And of course the reserve forces inevitably, whether it's a weather catastrophe or something else, are going to be part of that. And I have to say to the noble lord the minister, who we all know could sell snow to the Eskimos if he was put to it, the fact is that we have a situation in the press even yesterday where our training budgets for our soldiers apparently are being reduced for public expenditure reasons.

Now, if you were sitting in the Kremlin looking at that and, you know, it sounds so preposterous. And his right honorable colleague in the other place, the environment secretary, is urging us all to stock up on baked beans because and candles and be prepared for the emergency. And in the same breath, we're reducing apparently basic training. Now, if you're preparing the country for emergency and you're urging people to stock up on basics, what's the connection between those two things? I just can't make it out.

It seems completely counterintuitive. And the minister knows I tried to get a PMQ yesterday on that subject, but the Falklands won out quite properly.

But look, it is a serious question. And I think the government, the rhetoric coming from the government, the rhetoric coming from successive Prime Ministers is that defense of the nation is the number one priority of government. And I don't necessarily want to bring this into it, but might I gently remind him that if we're trying to save 30 million pounds on training, we're not trying to save any of the billions we're spending on the asylum industry, which is just making a mockery of our country. So I think we have to get serious here about what our priorities as a nation really are. And I think this is sending out the wrong message.

With regard to the Lord Lieutenants, I remember back home seeing our Lord Lieutenant with a cadet, and the cadet, she was as proud as punch, and this was a wonderful opportunity for a young person to take that role. And you could see the enthusiasm, and that person was committed as a young person to serving as the cadet, and it gave that person a wonderful opportunity of a career path as a young person to move forward. And, you know, to potentially take that away, for what? I don't know. So I would seriously ask the Minister to consider that.

And I hope he would speak between now and report to Lord de Mauley and colleagues and talk about these things, because I'm sure his door will be open. And I think that would be most helpful to the House if that was to happen, because I doubt if there's a huge amount of difference between all of us. We all want to see the same thing. And I accept that you can't go forever without looking at change, and so on, it's part of life. But I have to say also that the issue of the report, we all know how government works, we all know how local government works.

If you are doing an in-house report, people will say to you in the corridor, "Well, now, I think maybe you should be a wee bit careful about that or go a bit easy." We want an accurate, independent report without any strings attached, without any ability to be pressured financially or in any other way. I would have thought that's fairly basic. I mean, we're not asking for anything that's not sensible or reasonable. So I think this suite of amendments, I think, goes a long way to correcting what some of the flaws might be.

Fair enough, the drafting may need to be changed and so on, and I hope in the discussions between now and report, some of these anomalies can be resolved.

06:30:37 - 06:33:16

Julie Smith

My Lords, I rise to speak to the amendments to which I've also attached my name. And as the noble Lord, Lord MP, has pointed out, they're a reasonable set of amendments. They are again amendments that speak to issues of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association and in many ways could have been part perhaps of a previous group, because again they are trying to deal with issues associated with Clause 38. But, my Lords, we've already heard very articulately this evening that at the moment we have reserve and cadet forces that are not paid and councils which are not paid. Why has His Majesty's Government thought it necessary or appropriate to bring forward the suggestion of non-executive directors being paid and even potentially having pensionable incomes?

Is there a reason for it that is eluding the chamber because at the moment it doesn't seem to be clear why that would be necessary or desirable? In terms of the role of the Lord Lieutenant, as other noble Lords have pointed out, it seems wholly inappropriate that that should be consigned to secondary legislation and in particular if it is indeed the case that the Palace and the Lord Lieutenants' Association have not been consulted, what does the noble Lord the Minister propose to do to rectify that and pending any consultation would it not be appropriate to consider removing those parts of the bill? In terms of the final amendment again, so amendment 52, as the noble Lord Lord Empey has just pointed out, surely if you want an independent report it really does we do need to have clarity that it is going to be produced by people independent of the MOD so that they cannot be subject to any sort of informal pressure to produce a report that might be what the MOD or ministers might want to hear. So my Lords, a suite of reasonable amendments, can the noble Lord the Minister perhaps give us some suggestion of areas in which the government might be willing to move?

06:33:16 - 06:35:29

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, much has been said by noble Lords, noble and gallant Lords, myself and my noble friend Lord de Mauley about the importance of the continuation of the voluntary nature of the RFCAs. This isn't because I wish to sound like a stuck record but out of a genuine desire to preserve all that has made the reserves and cadets so successful. And of those factors, the voluntary ethos is paramount as the noble Lord Empey has so clearly expressed. These are organisations that despite being established by statute do not operate as traditional government bodies. They are more akin to civil society organisations.

That's their brilliance. The voluntary nature of the membership brings together such a wide array of people from ex-regulars who don't want to give up on their military life to those who want to give back to society to those who simply want to help young people get a step up, get on in life. They're not forced into this. It's not their career. They do it because they want to.

This is how we attract the best and most dedicated people. The new structure envisaged by the government, however, would create a professional board of independent people, potentially with no relevant experience as several noble Lords have mentioned, or links to either the cadets or the reserves. This is why I support amendments 48 and 51 from my noble friend to prevent non-executive board members from being paid and enshrining a national voluntary body in statute. Only then can we ensure that those involved with the RFCAs remain genuinely committed to and passionate about the cadets and reserves they put themselves forward to serve. My Lords, I have also spoken already about my desire to conserve the traditional link to the Crown through the involvement of the Lord Lieutenancy in the associations.

It's for that reason that I also strongly support amendment 50, which would in essence preserve an element of the status quo by ensuring the Lord Lieutenants are appointed as presidents of the regional councils. My Lords, this wouldn't cost the Ministry of Defence a penny. It wouldn't interfere with their bureaucratic restructuring, but it would help preserve those traditions that have kept our nation going for so long and which might just make our lives a little bit more enjoyable.

The severance of that link would be a deeply regrettable consequence of this policy and one that is entirely unnecessary.

06:35:51 - 06:37:14

Vernon Coaker

Can I thank Lord de Mauley for the amendments that he's led on in presenting to us and just to say to Lord de Mauley, I've said on a number of occasions, both to Lord de Mauley and the committee as a whole, that of course I'll continue to have the conversations between now and report about what we may or may not do with some of the amendments before us. So that commitment has already been made. And I think for the points he made about spending, that I'm perfectly willing to answer another private notice question if he's successful or whatever at another time, but perhaps not this evening. As I say, can I thank Lord de Mauley and the Earl of Minto and Baroness Goldie for their view that non-executive members of the new RFCA board should be unpaid. That view assumes that unpaid service better demonstrates commitment.

I actually don't accept that. Commitment is not determined by whether a member is remunerated and there is no evidence in my view that remuneration reduces dedication to the reserve forces or cadet organisations. I take the point that people make about voluntary ethos, but in terms of the board membership and others... I'm sorry.

06:37:14 - 06:37:29

Rupert Ponsonby

I suggest in answer to that point from the noble Lord the Minister, what it does do though, is it calls into question their independence from their MOD masters.

06:37:29 - 06:46:42

Vernon Coaker

Well, that may be a matter that we consider in the conversation that we have. I have to say, just I don't want to go on too long. It is one of the few, much of the comment that different people have made this evening, I actually understand, some of it I agree with to a larger or lesser extent. I have never ever thought, generally speaking, that in some circumstances unpaid work is the way forward in certain situations and this is one with respect to the board. I don't think it undermines the voluntary ethos as a whole because in this it's particularly related to the board membership.

And I think in that circumstance it's perfectly reasonable, given the new board that we wish to set up, that that position should be remunerated, whilst accepting the point that in the broader establishment of Lord Lieutenants and others across the wider... I'm sorry, I'm surprised to interrupt. The noble Lord the Minister has said he does not believe that having paid non-executive directors will lessen their commitment. That's not the question though, surely. The question is, does having unpaid representatives lessen their commitment?

It doesn't. So why do we want to change it? Because I believe when it comes to, this is the difference. I understand the whole point about the voluntary ethos generally across the Reserve and Cadet Association. I understand and accept that absolutely.

What I'm saying is that with respect to the board members, where you're creating a national board that wants to take on certain statutory functions, that that position should be remunerated. And that's the difference between us. And in the end, that is something that personally I think is not inconsistent with the belief that you can have a voluntary ethos whilst you say... I mean, look, we have voluntary organisations all over the country that display a voluntary ethos that we are all proud of. At the top of that organisation are people who are remunerated, are board members that are remunerated.

And we would not expect them to be able to do that job of work without that remuneration. And that's the principle, the point that I'm making.

We're committed to equality of opportunity to breaking down barriers that prevent people from contributing to public life. So we want public appointments to be open to all those with the skills, experience and commitment, not only those with the financial means to do so without compensation. The government objective is to attract the best candidates from the widest possible range of backgrounds and retaining the option to remunerate supports that aim. I hope that that explains the government's position whilst accepting again that many noble lords will disagree with that. But that is my point about the payment on the statutory on the on the strategic oversight board whilst respecting the voluntary ethos more widely within the reserves and cadets organizations and associations.

And I thank the noble lord, Lord de Mauley and Lord Stirrup for their views and highlighting the important role that lord lieutenants have long played within the reserve forces and cadets association. Again, I absolutely respect that. I understand now I think the noble noble lord's wife is the lord lieutenant I think in Norfolk. So we've got Norfolk and Buckinghamshire represented here today and I think again that's something that we can all be proud of and and and respect. So we value that and the vital link between His Majesty the King and the communities they serve, championing reserves and cadets, strengthening links.

And I would remind all of us that if we need reminding, which we don't really, that of course the lord lieutenants are the appointments of His Majesty, which is I think also important and maintains Earl Howe's point about the I think it was Earl Howe, it may have been the noble and gallant lord, Lord Stirrup, the link between the crown and the and the lord lieutenants across the whole of the UK I think is important. We remain committed to the involvement of lord lieutenants in the regional council structure and as I say detailed government arrangements including links with lord lieutenants within the regional council structure are more appropriately set out in secondary legislation. Can I just make the point that the noble and gallant lord, Lord Stirrup has to understand, well let me just say defensively, I'm not often defensive, let me just say defensively, I take the point that you cannot amend secondary legislation. That is why I said it is really important that this committee has the draft regulations because you can amend and adapt draft regulations. And that was now people will say it should be primary legislation but at least I'm trying to provide the committee with another step by which they can try to influence what the regulations should be before they are set in stone.

Again, won't satisfy everyone but is actually a way in which I've recognized the fact that you can't amend secondary legislation but having the draft gives people the opportunity to comment. And those of members of the committee who've dealt with me in many ways know that their involvement and influence they've had on various reports, one of which is to be published next week where directly their comments have been taken on board, I think shows the commitment that I have to ensuring that it's not just a talking shop and that we make we make changes. So the amendment in our view is not required to achieve its stated objective. The bill is intended to establish the statutory framework for the new body and we don't believe it's necessary to prescribe these arrangements in statute. On amendment 51, I agree the government agrees with the objective of ensuring a strong collective voice for the regional councils and we intend to establish a national council and will set out its roles within the government's framework for the new body.

The question is therefore whether the detailed arrangements for a National Council should be set in primary legislation or provided for through the government's framework. The government believes the latter approach is the more appropriate one. The bill establishes the statutory framework for the new body. Detailed government arrangements including the composition and functions of a National Council are better set through secondary legislation and the wider government's framework so as a new body it has a greater freedom to evolve and adapt. But let me just say this to Lord de Mauley again.

However, while I'm not convinced that this is a matter that needs to be settled in primary legislation, I've heard the wide range of views and opinions that have been expressed that don't agree with where the government currently is. And I will take this point away and consider them carefully with respect to that. As I say, for the, I share the noble lord's desire to ensure the regional councils have a strong collective voice. And I hope that that, certainly at committee stage, would give some reassurance to the noble lord and he'll withdraw that particular amendment as well as the others. I'm also grateful to Lord de Mauley and to the noble and gallant lord, Lord Stirrup, for amendment 52 and the attention it gives to the important issue of reporting on the state of the Volunteer Reserve Force.

We agree that Parliament should continue to receive robust and independent reporting. The noble lord, Lord Harlech, asked me what was the accountability. The point I'd make to him, I personally do not believe there is any greater accountability than an annual report to this house and to the other place. That gives all of us the opportunity to read what has or hasn't happened and to raise questions or even call ministers to account. And he asked me and frankly challenged me to say how all of this would be reported and what accountability there would be.

I'd say there's parliamentary accountability. I think that's a pretty powerful thing to say of a particular organisation. I know there is a difference because under the bill responsibility for producing the report rests with the RFCA or such other person or body as the Defence Council may determine. The responsibility for delivering the report will be given to the new RFCA, but the bill also gives the Defence Council the ability, if it sees fit, to commission the report from another suitable person or body outside of defence. It doesn't require it, it just says if it sees fit.

It's right that primary legislation should secure the requirement, as I've said to the noble lord, Lord Harlech, and indeed others who've asked about accountability, the requirement for annual reporting rather than fix a particular organisational model in statute. In that way we protect the outcome, rigorous reporting to Parliament, without unnecessarily fixing the means of delivery in primary legislation. I hope with those remarks that the noble lord, certainly for committee stage, would see fit to be able to withdraw his amendment.

06:46:42 - 06:47:32

Rupert Ponsonby

My lords, I once again thank those noble lords who have spoken in support of the amendments. I also thank the noble lord, the minister. He says voluntary bodies all over the country have paid people at their heads. Well, of course they do. I'm a trustee or president of I think seven charities.

Universally, outside government, those paid are the executives, not the non-executives. And my lords, my concerns on the point about amendability of regulations is different to the one that he addressed actually. My concern is that the government can amend them, not that we can't. It's that the government can amend them much more easily than primary legislation.

06:47:32 - 06:47:41

Speaker 116

My Lords, I'm sure we'll return to these issues on report, but for this evening, if I may, my Lords, I beg leave to withdraw these amendments.

06:47:41 - 06:48:32

Ilora Finlay

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 49, Lord De Mauley, not moved. Amendment 50, Lord De Mauley, not moved. Amendment 51, Lord De Mauley, not moved.

Amendment 52, Lord De Mauley, not moved. The question is that schedule 6 be the sixth schedule to the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.

The question is that clauses 39 to 42 stand part of the bill en bloc. As many as that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 53, Baroness Brinton.

06:48:32 - 06:59:48

Sal Sarah Brinton

My Lords, Lord Thomas of Gresford cannot be in his place today as he is recovering at home after an operation. We hope he'll be back with us by report stage. My Lords, I have signed Lord Thomas's amendment and I will speak to and move it. I also have amendments 54 and 68, and I've also signed Lady Bennett's amendment 55. The victims' names that I will use are not their own to protect their identities.

My Lords, I'm sure you will recall the disgraceful case of US spy Anne Sacoolas, who was driving on the wrong side of the road in Northamptonshire in 2019 when she hit and killed Harry Dunn, aged 19, and the US authorities managed to spirit her out of the country to evade justice. We became aware then that the US authorities did not respect our policing and justice systems. She was eventually brought to justice, but only because of Harry's family's campaign and then public and governmental pressure. In recent months, following the brave disclosures made by a victim of rape and sexual assault by a US serviceman on UK soil, not on his USAFE base, many more shocking cases have emerged. And my Lords, at second reading, both Lord Thomas and I spoke of this case, Jacob Wolfston, a US Air Force pilot, who in 2023 sexually attacked a Cambridge resident in his own Cambridge property, so not at the Lakenheath base where he worked.

His victim, who I have talked to, was very clear that she was alleging rape and sexual assault. Now under the terms of the Visiting Forces Act 1952, it is clear that where an offence by an off-duty American serviceman against a British civilian takes place off the American base, the investigation and any subsequent court case should usually be in the UK Crown Court, and the rest of the bill goes on to talk about exceptions to that. What happened in this case was that the Cambridgeshire Police waived jurisdiction, and I understand it was not at a senior level, and the trial took place by a court martial before a US military judge and panel in the Lakenheath base. All the UK protections that are offered to victims of alleged rape and serious sexual attacks disappeared at that moment, and worse, because the victim isn't American, she wasn't entitled to the minimal victim support available to US citizens in US courts compared to the victims' rights here in the UK. And worse, since the victim was brave enough to talk to the Guardian newspaper, many more similar cases have been reported.

So this is now, we understand, not a rare occurrence. And I can see why our beleaguered police forces would welcome the removal of cases from their very heavy workload, but these decisions are not being made at the right level, and it is not clear at all that the CPS are involved.

I was astonished to discover that many of the specific agreements with countries on such justice systems with us are made as secret and confidential between the UK and the country, so we in Parliament, the press, or even the victims cannot find out the details. The Guardian exposed another case in July. Rebecca fled the house of an American airman in Suffolk, going to the police to report he had raped and violently attacked her. She saw specialist health and police staff, they looked after her, she was given an ISVA, that's an independent sexual violence advisor, to support her in the legal UK process. And then, my Lords, the USAF at RAF Lakenheath did exactly the same as the previous case I've described and persuaded Suffolk police to transfer the case to them because justice would be quicker.

Then Emily, the wife of the accused, Tyrion Davis, also came forward to say that she had also been raped and sexually assaulted by him on a number of occasions. At the subsequent Lakenheath trial, he was convicted of sexually assaulting both Rebecca and Emily. On discovering that the jury panel at Lakenheath would be composed of Davis's military peers from a small base, by our jury pool for civil court case standards, Rebecca said, "It's like if I did something wrong outside of work, having all my nursing colleagues being on the jury, it just doesn't make sense." And in another case, Hannes Marszalek boasted to his friends that he had exposed himself from his house in his small town of Littleport near RAF Lakenheath to a 16-year-old girl and four young women as they went past. When asked why US Air Force authorities had taken over the case, a spokesperson said, "We negotiated over this case with the local police using all the available facts at the time."

So the accused was able to negotiate a plea bargain in his case and was convicted on a much lesser charge. He later won an appeal in a US military court this year that quashed his conviction on technical grounds, even though the court papers showed that he had texted two friends to say he had, quote, "definitely flashed a couple of ladies walking from the train, lol," and later he texted, "I took all of my clothes off when I walked in, I went to go open a window and I was standing right in front of it when they walked by," end quote. He also admitted in court that he had done this twice before. The US military court sentenced him to two months. If it had been in a UK court, he would probably have received two years.

Then, my Lords, astonishingly, a US military appeal court dismissed the guilty verdict against him, ruling that prosecutors had made an error by charging him under the wrong offense. I suspect they realized it should have been a more serious one. Since these cases were publicized, more and more women are coming forward with their own experience of the US military court system taking over their cases in the UK, and we're seeing injustice after injustice like these. So amendment 53 asserts, as a matter of principle, the UK victim is of a criminal offense perpetrated within the jurisdiction of the UK by a member of or a person attached to a visiting force has a right for their complaint to be investigated and tried under UK law.

And it goes on to say that any attempt by treaty, agreement or memorandum of understanding to create exceptions to such a principle should be open and transparent, and that where an exception exists, its exercise should be subject to safeguards. In particular, reasons must be formulated and committed to writing, communicated to the victim and justiciable. My Lords, this is particularly important in sexual offences cases because the protections given to victims in court proceedings differ between the UK and the USA. So, for example, under section 41 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, only the accused or someone acting on the accused's behalf may apply to introduce the sexual history of the victim. Under the US military rule of evidence 412, the prosecution as well as the defence may make such an application.

In the US system, a ground for admitting such evidence is that it would violate the constitutional rights of the accused to rule it out, whereas our UK system is more restrictive. On the other hand, the US system permits the victim to have their own counsel to argue admissibility, to make representations on the victim's behalf and to protect the victim's rights. But I have also heard that if the victim isn't prepared to give evidence, then sometimes, quite often in American court, the case does not proceed even if there is other evidence. So can I ask the Minister, where US courts-martial involving a British victim have taken place, have these victims been advised of their rights under US law to have a special victim's counsel? And if so, how are they informed and who pays for it?

Or is it true, as I have been told by one of these victims, that special victim's counsel is only available in the US court to US citizens? What is clear is that the present arrangement cannot continue. That is why I laid amendment 54, which adds the United States of America specifically to the list of countries bound by the Visiting Forces Act in 1952. At present, the USA is only bound by the slightly less formal arrangements of troops from other countries who are here under the banner of NATO forces, which is an even less transparent mechanism than in the Visiting Forces Act sections. This is particularly extraordinary because no country other than the USA now has its own bases in the United Kingdom, and it has the largest numbers of visiting forces of any foreign country.

So it makes sense for them to be added to the list of countries with whom we have specific agreements under this Act. And my amendment 68 is a consequential amendment 54, bringing it within the commencement provision in clause 55 of the bill. Lady Bennett's amendment 55, which I've signed, makes specific the element of the agreement between the UK and the countries whose visiting forces come here. And it's very helpful in echoing Lord Thomas of Gresford's amendment 53 in being explicit about a restriction on the relinquishing of jurisdiction without the explicit decision of a relevant prosecutor and the issues that the relevant prosecutor must take into account. So under this scheme, most of the cases that have come to light that were taken over by Lakenheath airbase would most probably not have transferred from the relevant UK police force.

Most importantly, this is a transparent process under these amendments, including notifying the victim. My Lords, all the amendments in this group are trying to solve a problem that this country should be ashamed of. Once again, the USA has been shown to ride roughshod over our judicial system relating to offences on British soil against British citizens, and our own processes have failed as our police forces allowed these cases to be removed to a US military judicial system that has clearly failed the many victims of rape and sexual assault.

My Lords, I beg to move amendment 53.

06:59:48 - 06:59:56

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed, after clause 42, insert the new clause the words as printed on the Marshall list.

06:59:56 - 07:09:58

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the noble lady Baroness Brinton and to thank the noble lady for supporting my amendment 55, which I'm going to concentrate on because this is a carefully worked attempt to deal with an issue that the noble lady Baroness Brinton has already very clearly outlined: criminal behavior by US service people in the UK that is not being appropriately dealt with. Now there are more than 12,000 US military personnel stationed in the United Kingdom, operating from at least 15 bases and facilities. These are people living, working, and socializing in communities across the UK. They will and do commit offences. And my amendment is focused particularly on sexual offences, but of course the noble lady Baroness Brinton referred to the disgraceful, awful death of Harry Dunn and the fact that his family had to campaign against the entire US government to try to achieve some kind of justice.

But that's not the focus of this particular my particular amendment. I also note that given the current state of the US today, these bases are coming under increasing public attention. However, that's not the subject of this amendment. As I spoke at second reading and said that I was going to bring this amendment forward, and in doing so, I have to both thank the Guardian journalists who've put and indeed editors who've put a great deal of resources into uncovering this situation. And I should perhaps declare my former position as editor of the Guardian Weekly, but I'm not influenced by that.

And I also want to thank the Center for Military Justice for its advice and assistance in developing the amendment that I put before your Lordship's committee today. Now the noble lady Baroness Brinton chose not to name any of the people concerned, but given that she bravely chose to waive her own anonymity and speak to the Guardian, I am going to put forward the name of Sarah Steel because she wanted to speak publicly about what she went through. Now what happened was she went through an ordeal that is a result of the failure of UK processes. This was an incident, an attack that took place on UK soil away from a US military base and while the service member was off duty. Yet the military police, the US military police quickly took over the investigation and the whole proceeding subsequently took place through the US military justice system, as Baroness Brinton said.

Indeed, it was held at RAF Lakenheath, the largest US military base in the UK. Ms. Steel described this as confronting, frustrating, and distressing. The procedures she found were archaic and bizarre. And if you think about what she experienced happening, being held before a military courtroom. At points during her testimony, fighter jets were taking off just a few hundred meters from where she was speaking.

She described the experience as feeling like she was in an alternative world. Now in Ms. Steel's case, the US court martial ultimately convicted the defender of strangling an intimate partner, but acquitted him of the sexual assault charge.

He received a sentence of six months in a correction facility and the conviction is subject to automatic appeal. Now you might have views about that, I certainly do, but that is not directly what this amendment is about. And as the noble lady Baroness Brinton said, this is one case of which we have a great deal of detail and I won't go through the others that the noble lady has already outlined, but I will just mention one other case where the victim recounted that the Court Martial process took two years. She was forced to drop out of a midwifery degree as a result and she had to give evidence in the same room as the man she accused, without the protections that victims would normally have in a UK court. Now, what is the current legal position here?

How have we got to this point? My understanding is that the NATO Status of Forces Agreement provides a framework for determining which country has the primary right to exercise jurisdiction. Where the offence is punishable under laws of both countries, the sending state has the primary right in certain specified circumstances. These include where the offence is solely against the security or property of the sending state, where it's solely against another member of the force or their civilian component or dependent, or where it arises out of an act done in performance of official duty. But where an alleged sexual offence is committed against a civilian who has no connection with the visiting force and the alleged offence does not arise out of an act done in the performance of official duty, the receiving state, i.e. the UK, has the primary right.

The UK has jurisdiction. So the question is not about that, it's who decides that the UK does not use that jurisdiction, which is where this amendment comes in. Now, we've got in the UK no process of how the decision should be made, what criteria should apply or what role the victim should have. Nor, according to the Centre for Military Justice, is there an equivalent statutory framework governing the transfer of jurisdiction to a foreign military justice system. Now we have recognised, I want to highlight, within our own justice arrangements that decisions about serious sexual offences require appropriate safeguards.

Where there's a question whether a serious offence should be dealt with by civilian or service justice within the UK, there is now a protocol between the DPP and the Director of Service Prosecutions. It provides for senior level consideration of jurisdiction in rape and sexual assault cases, ordinarily treats offences against civilians as matters for the civilian courts and provides for the victim's views to be sought. But there is no equivalent safeguard where a foreign military person is involved. So what this amendment does is fixes that situation. It adds a new section 3A to the Visiting Forces Act of 1952.

It would create a clear presumption that where a member of the visiting force is accused of a qualifying sexual offence against someone with no connection to that force, the case should be investigated by UK police and heard in a UK court. Now it does provide for exceptions. I find it hard to imagine where there would be exceptions, but that's the way the law works. And it also provides what specific matters the prosecutor should consider. They would have to consider the gravity of the alleged offence, the connection of the alleged victim and the offence with the UK, the capacity of the sending country's arrangements, particularly important given what we've heard about all of this, including the treatment of victims, and the matters relied upon in the support for a request for a waiver, and any representations made by the alleged victim.

And the decisions and reasons would have to be recorded in writing and so far as practicable notified to the victim. It would make a huge difference to all of the cases that we've been talking about tonight. And it would mean that a person who has already taken the difficult step of reporting an alleged sexual offence would not have to adjust to a justice system they never expected to encounter. Now I also think there's a point here I want to put a direct question to the noble lord the minister because there is currently in the current arrangements an exception to question of duty offences. Now I hope the noble lord the minister would agree with me that a qualifying sexual offence would never be capable of being characterised as arising in out of and in the course of official military duty.

This government, previous governments have had a very good record of addressing issues of sexual violence in conflict and I think it's important that that is made clear, perhaps in writing if not now. Now my other question to be put to the noble lord the minister is as a starting point, surely I think the argument has been made but does the government accept there is currently a gap in the process for deciding whether the United Kingdom should relinquish its primary jurisdiction in serious sexual offence cases involving visiting forces? This amendment is ultimately about the confidence in our justice system, about the trust of the public in having visiting military forces on our soil. And I finally in closing I just want to stress that this is not an issue that I am going to allow to slip lightly. I think we owe it to all of the victims that we've already heard from and others who we almost certainly don't know about but exist that this is dealt with in this bill.

This is clearly the bill to deal with this situation now that it's come to light. And in saying that obviously we will discuss the details and discuss ways in which we might perhaps combine the amendments in this group or look at how they fit in detail but something has to be done about this utterly unacceptable current situation.

07:09:58 - 07:10:07

Julie Smith

My lords, I don't think I need to wind from these benches. I think my noble friend Baroness Brinton has said everything that needs to be said.

07:10:07 - 07:15:18

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My lords, I am grateful to the noble lord Lord Thomas of Gresford and the noble baronesses Lady Brinton and Lady Bennett of Manor Castle for tabling this group of amendments because it gives us an opportunity to discuss a complex but very important area of the law. I'm also grateful to the noble baroness Lady Brinton for standing in for the noble lord Lord Thomas of Gresford and wish him a very speedy recovery. He's a nice guy. The Visiting Forces Act 1952 establishes the legal framework that governs the relationship between the United Kingdom and those states that send members of their armed forces to our territory. The issue sits at the very intersection of national sovereignty, the rights of victims and this country's long-standing alliance relationships and it's right that this house probes how this balance is struck.

Turning first to amendment 54 tabled by the noble lord Lord Thomas of Gresford and the noble baroness Lady Brinton, which would require publication in unredacted form of any part of a visiting forces agreement touching on jurisdiction together with the reasoning behind it, I merely observe that a statutory duty to publish in unredacted form is a very blunt instrument to apply to what are in many cases live diplomatic and security arrangements with partner nations. But it may be useful if the noble lord the minister can explain what mechanisms already exist for parliament to scrutinise these matters without compelling wholesale publication.

What I would say, and what I hope the minister will take away from this debate regardless of the amendment's fate, is this. Whatever one's view on publication, it must be beyond doubt in any case where a jurisdictional dispute arises between the United Kingdom and a sending state exactly how that dispute is to be resolved, who takes the decision, and on what criteria. Ambiguity at that point serves no one. On amendment 56 in the name of the noble baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, the noble baroness is right to press the government on how such cases are handled. Where I part company with her is on the question of necessity, because the outcome she is seeking already exists in law.

The Visiting Forces Act 1952 does not hand jurisdiction wholesale to sending states. Section 3 of the act states that the sending states' military authorities have the primary right of jurisdiction only where the offense arises out of official duty, is against another member of the visiting force or corresponding civilian component, or is against property belonging to the force or its members or dependents. In any case where a member of a visiting force commits a criminal offense against a dependent British citizen, the jurisdiction lies with British authorities. Thus, such an offense would be investigated by the territorial police force for the area, prosecuted by the Crown Prosecution Service, and the case heard in a British court. This is the case for all offenses, however serious, including sexual offenses.

This position is unambiguously clarified in the Crown Prosecution Service's own published guidance. Furthermore, where the NATO Status of Forces Agreement is also engaged, the position is, if anything, even stronger. The CPS guidance notes that, taken together with the 1951 NATO agreement, this produces dual jurisdiction in any case where the victim is a dependent who is either a UK national or habitually resident here. That is precisely the category of victim, a dependent rather than a fellow service member, that I believe the noble baroness's amendment is designed to protect. Where cases have an international dimension going wider than the visiting forces framework itself, as for example in dealing with the United States, the mechanism for resolving concurrent jurisdiction is also already in place.

The guidance governing such cases between our two countries commits prosecutors to weighing each case on its individual merits, guided throughout by a commitment to fairness and objectivity. I won't detain the committee further on the remaining amendment in this group concerning the list of countries in section 1(1)(a) of the 1952 act, save to say that I believe the United States is counted as a visiting force. The Visiting Forces (Designation) Order 1954 exercises the power in section 1(2) of the 1952 act to designate Belgium, France, the Netherlands, Norway, and the United States of America as visiting forces. The US is also covered under the NATO SOFA agreement. I would be very grateful if the noble lord the minister could confirm whether this interpretation is correct.

07:15:18 - 07:22:22

Vernon Coaker

My lords, can I first of all thank Baroness Brinton, Baroness Bennett, and indeed the Earl of Minto for their important contributions to what is an incredibly important area of law, of which we've seen a number of matters raised recently and not so recently which cause us all concern.

I would just say for legal reasons, I'm going to read verbatim the information I have because I think it's important and it's such an important area, I don't want to be misquoted if anything's used, which would not help the various people that we would wish to see being helped. Noble Lords will notice, particularly when I get towards the end of my remarks, however, there are one or two quite important comments that I make, which I hope offer some reassurance, if not total reassurance, to your Lordships' House, but also to those who read our proceedings in the way in which we are trying to move forward. The legal framework governing the allocation of jurisdiction between the UK and a visiting force are set out in UK domestic law through Section 3 of the Visiting Forces Act 1952, with further reference to Section 12. This framework applies both to states that are party to the NATO Status of Forces Agreement and to non-NATO states that have bilateral arrangements with the UK and are designated under Section 1 of the Visiting Forces Act 1952. In all such cases, visiting forces remain subject to the provisions of the Act.

Any other agreements or arrangements are modelled on the provisions of the NATO Status of Forces Agreement and reflect the provisions of the Visiting Forces Act 1952. The Visiting Forces Act is already publicly available and the principles within it are applied by UK prosecuting authorities on a case-by-case basis when questions of jurisdiction occur. I hope that provides some reassurance to Baroness Brinton, but also to the noble Lord, Lord Thomas. Can I thank the noble Baroness Brinton for her views on the Bill and acknowledge her concerns and that of others about the Visiting Forces Act 1952 and why the United States is not explicitly referenced as being subject to the legislation. Can I reassure her and others that the United States is already included as subject to the Visiting Forces Act by virtue of Section 1(1)(b).

This specifically explains that along with the countries individually named at Section 1(1)(a), a country will be subject to the Act's provisions if it is designated by Order in Council. The United States, along with Belgium, France, the Netherlands, and Norway, were included in the Visiting Forces Designation Order 1954, Statutory Instrument 634/1954, and so fall under the Visiting Forces Act 1952. On Amendment 55, can I thank the noble Baroness, Baroness Bennett and Baroness Brinton for their views on the Bill and acknowledge their interest in the Visiting Forces Act 52 and the proposal to restrict and regulate how requests for transferring jurisdiction are determined in cases involving qualifying sexual offences. Can I begin by reassuring them that the government is fully committed to ensuring that alleged sexual offences perpetrated by visiting forces are treated with the utmost seriousness and that jurisdiction for such cases is decided in accordance with the extant legislation. I am aware of recent cases highlighted in the media, most notably the case concerning US airman Jacob Alston, which raised concerns regarding the extent to which the right decisions regarding jurisdiction for prosecution had been made.

Section 3 of the Visiting Forces Act 1952 already sets out the limited circumstances in which jurisdiction should be transferred from the UK to a visiting force. The decisions on whether or not to do so are made independently by the relevant police force or the Crown Prosecution Service in response to any request from a visiting force. The government is committed to identifying and applying the lessons arising from the issues raised in these cases. This includes the application and operation of jurisdictional arrangements under the Visiting Forces Act 1952 and how these are implemented across the criminal justice system. In particular, I welcome the action taken by the chair of the National Police Chiefs' Council, who has written to all chief constables in England and Wales to remind forces of their responsibilities under the Visiting Forces Act 1952.

I understand the National Police Chiefs' Council is also considering whether further formal guidance for police forces is required to reinforce the principles of the existing legislation. I was, as I say, deeply concerned by the reports of how jurisdiction was handled in the Wolfson case. Victims of such serious offences need to be supported and their cases treated with the seriousness, dignity and compassion they deserve. This includes ensuring that jurisdiction for alleged offences is only ceded to a visiting force where absolutely appropriate under UK law and Crown Prosecution guidance. I have directed my officials to work with the Home Office, the National Police Chiefs' Council and any other government departments as required to ensure the Ministry of Defence is assisting in that outcome.

I hope that provides some assurance to Baroness Brinton and to Baroness Bennett and indeed to Earl Minto. No doubt these discussions will continue, but we understand the seriousness of the topics that have been raised and the need for us to consider how we can deal with it.

07:22:22 - 07:22:54

Sal Sarah Brinton

Brief question because then my response to his longer contribution will be relevant. Is there currently an agreement between the UK and the USA as is described in the Visiting Forces Act and referred to elsewhere, other countries have it? Is there currently such an agreement already about protocols on this sort of case and other details which aren't relevant, but the sort of case we've been discussing this evening? And I'll leave my question at that.

07:22:54 - 07:23:11

Vernon Coaker

I am concerned about misinforming your Lordships on legal matters. I will write when I've taken legal advice as to the correct answer for that, copy it to other members of your Lordships' House and place a copy in the library.

07:23:11 - 07:23:36

Natalie Bennett

I understand if the noble Lord will want to write in answer to this question as well, but he referred to the National Police Chiefs' Council considering further formal guidance writing to forces. What will that be based on? What's the legal basis of this? Where's it coming from? Surely this is something that's a matter for Parliament, not just for the police chiefs to work out the way forward.

07:23:36 - 07:23:42

Speaker 119

Where's the framework coming from?

07:23:42 - 07:25:03

Vernon Coaker

I'm not sure if I totally understand what the noble Baroness means. I mean, I thought it was a pretty important step that the National Police Chiefs' Council were taking in order to look at whether current guidance was appropriate or further guidance was needed to ensure some of the issues that have arisen and some of the concerns that have been quite rightly expressed were avoided in the future. That is the normal practice within which the National Police Chiefs' Council operate around a whole range of very, very difficult issues. They reflect on the law, they reflect on the guidance that operates with respect to the law and as to whether any of the guidance that they have needs to be changed or adapted. And that would be my assumption about what this means with respect to the guidance to be issued to all the various police forces to ensure that questions of jurisdiction are properly made within the context of the law as it stands.

07:25:03 - 07:28:11

Sal Sarah Brinton

I'm grateful to everyone who's spoken in this debate and I should also earlier have thanked the Centre for Military Justice, the Guardian and the women who I've spoken to. I'm glad to hear Lady Bennett's speech and unsurprisingly we agree almost entirely on the problems and I also agree with her that we won't let this go whether it goes beyond the passage of this bill or not. And I'm grateful too to Earl Minto for his comments. I'm particularly pleased that he agreed with Lady Bennett and myself that it's absolutely clear that sexual attacks on UK soil are not part of the clause section three of the Visiting Forces Act where the exceptions might be. That's extremely helpful and I'm very grateful to him.

I particularly want to thank the Minister for his extremely well-constructed and considered speech and I understand for all the right legal reasons why he, I'm very sorry, I'm trying to catch the Minister's eye. Thank you very much indeed. It, and I'm going to be doing this for a few minutes, so I'm really sorry. Because I think what's really important is that we find a solution. I agree with the Minister that there is provision in the Visiting Forces Act, so his exposition of that was really important.

Our problem is as a Parliament that we need to resolve the problem that the victims faced. And that's why I'm very grateful for his comments about the Police Chief Council and the guidance that they're looking at offering. But the one organisation that hasn't seemed to have a role in any of this at the moment is the CPS. And they clearly do because there are issues that are not just about taking the statement of the victim, making sure they seek medical help, all of the issues that I outlined in that one specific case. There are also issues about charging levels which would then affect what happens and whether there might be a reason for whatever that it should be considered to go elsewhere.

So I think in concluding this evening, because these were only probing amendments on my behalf and indeed Lord Thomas's behalf as well, I wonder if it would be helpful to have a meeting between committee and report with yourself, Minister, somebody from the Home Office who can talk about the policing side and possibly the Police Chief Council and somebody from the CPS.

Of course. Thank you very much. And I think on that basis, my Lords, and given the hour and the number of groups we still have to go through, I will withdraw my amendment.

07:28:11 - 07:29:00

Ilora Finlay

Is it your Lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 54, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 55, Baroness Bennett, not moved. The question is that clauses 43 to 46 stand part en bloc, as many as of that opinion will say content.

Content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that schedule 7 be the seventh schedule to the bill, as many as of that opinion will say content. Content. The contrary not content, the contents have it.

The question is that clause 47 stand part of the bill, as many as of that opinion will say content. Content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. Amendment 55A, Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay.

07:29:00 - 07:36:36

Stephen Parkinson

My Lords, amendment 55A stands in my name. It is a rather late amendment and this is the first time I've spoken on the bill. I must apologize in particular to the noble Lord, Lord Dannatt, for inadvertently gazumping his amendment that clause 48 stand part of the bill and look forward to hear his contribution on that in a moment, but I read with interest his comments on that issue at second reading and I'm glad to have the chance to take part in this debate on that issue as well since I do believe that clause 48 should be in this bill. At second reading, the noble Lord, Lord Dannatt, mentioned the Gloucester, not the HMS Gloucester, for she was built and launched in that dark period of our history when we temporarily cast aside the monarchy, but the Gloucester was lost off the Norfolk coast on the 6th of May 1682. On board and thankfully not lost with her were James, Duke of York, who went on to become King James II, and John Churchill, who went on to become the first Duke of Marlborough.

As the noble Lord rightly said, had they been lost, the course not just of British but of global history would have been changed. Such is the power of our maritime heritage. I had a solemn and more recent reminder of this over the summer recess when I had the privilege of visiting the Falkland Islands with the Armed Forces Parliamentary Scheme. I found it profoundly moving to see the buoy in San Carlos water which marks the resting place of HMS Antelope, one of the Royal Navy warships lost in that conflict along with HMS Ardent, HMS Coventry, and HMS Sheffield, as well as the RFA Sir Galahad, the Merchant Navy's Atlantic Conveyor and landing craft Foxtrot 4. The Falklands War and those who gave their lives in waging it were among the spurs for the Protection of Military Remains Act of 1986, which is what clause 48 of this bill seeks to amend.

And I do support the ways it proposes to do so. While the 1986 Act gave immediate and automatic protection to wrecked aircraft, it requires wrecked ships to be individually designated in order to be protected. This means that shipwrecks remain vulnerable to disturbance, souvenir hunting, salvage activity, or archaeological interference before formal designation has occurred.

That process requires secondary legislation and noble Lords across the committee will know how long it can take to obtain legislative slots. Indeed, it took 16 years until 2002 for the first designations under the 1986 Act to come into force. Those who've been lost at sea in the service of our nation should not have to wait for secondary legislation to deliver the protection they deserve. Clause 48 also seeks to remove the restrictive time constraints which apply to protected places and controlled sites, broadly since the First World War for the former or within 200 years for the latter, to ensure that historic military shipwrecks from before these rather arbitrary cutoff points can also be protected. There should, my Lords, be no temporal limit to our gratitude to those who've died to preserve the freedoms we enjoy today.

Clause 48 of this bill will not change the system which has been well understood by responsible divers for many years. Diving in protected places will continue to be permitted on a look but don't touch basis and diving in a controlled site will continue to require a license. But the changes in Clause 48 will help to deter unauthorized salvage, damage to our shared underwater heritage and the desecration of the final resting places of brave service personnel. So, I do hope that it will remain part of the bill. I hope so too because I seek to amend it.

My own amendment 55A seeks to add to Clause 48 and in doing so clarify a worrying confusion in the law which pertains to military shipwrecks. The UK has long asserted that sunken state vessels enjoy protection through the principle of sovereign immunity. This means they cannot be subject to the jurisdiction of another state. Crucially, the ships cannot have salvage services conferred on them without the permission of His Majesty's government. As a proud seafaring nation with a history as long as ours, the UK has a considerable number of sunken state vessels, currently estimated to be over 5,000, lying at the bottom of seas and oceans across the globe.

The principle of sovereign immunity is used to protect these vessels, their heritage significance and the last known resting place of the sailors who went down with them. Without the principle of sovereign immunity, our underwater cultural heritage would be extremely vulnerable to salvage since consent to salvage sunken vessels is not required in law except in very limited circumstances. It ought to be, my Lords, as simple as that. But it may not be. The Crown Proceedings Act first muddied the waters in 1947, modifying the application of sovereign immunity to His Majesty's vessels by stating that the civil law of salvage would apply to them.

In effect, this removed the protection of sovereign immunity from sunken state vessels. This provision was subsequently restated in section 230, subsection 1 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995, which brought the 1989 International Convention on Salvage into force in the United Kingdom. In the decades since, the Ministry of Defence has taken the view that section 230(1) of the Merchant Shipping Act only applies in UK territorial waters, that is out to 12 nautical miles, and that sunken state wrecks beyond our territorial waters remain protected under the principle of sovereign immunity from unauthorized salvage. That is certainly the interpretation reflected in the most recent guidance published in 2014 by the MOD and by DCMS. Though it predated my time as heritage minister, this was the guidance in place when I served at DCMS in the last parliament.

Since then, I've been alerted by the Joint Nautical Archaeology Policy Committee to legal research conducted by academics at Plymouth University Law School, which suggests that this interpretation may not be correct. Their finding is that the effect of section 230, subsection 1 of the 95 Act is to remove the protection of sovereign immunity from all state vessels wherever they are located, leaving sunken ships from the Royal Navy and other state vessels vulnerable to salvage without the permission of the United Kingdom.

The academics who conducted that research are naturally concerned to have reached this conclusion, but they are convinced of it and are very keen that action should be taken to remedy it. Even if their conclusions are debatable, as points of law often are, I hope the noble lord the minister would agree that this is not the sort of matter where there ought to be any doubt or any scope for unseemly legal dispute. The remedy I have suggested in amendment 55A is not the perfect one, I'm limited somewhat by the scope of this bill, but might I ask the noble lord the minister if he would look into this matter carefully, to consider the legal research that's been conducted, and to see if there's the possibility of using this bill to put the matter entirely beyond doubt. I'd certainly be very glad to discuss it further with him and to do so in concert with the legal experts who've looked at this in greater detail. I beg to move.

07:36:36 - 07:36:47

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed, clause 48, page 68, line 15, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.

07:36:47 - 07:41:21

Richard Dannatt

My lords, I beg to move that clause 48 does not stand part of the bill. There are two issues here, my lords. One relates to the wrecks themselves that contain military remains, the other relates to diving activities related to those wrecks which the bill would now make protected, or would describe as protected places. My contention is that insufficient detail has been provided in relation to the nature and definition of the wrecks themselves, and that there's been a lack of consultation with the diving community, whose hitherto legitimate activities could be constrained or rendered illegal by clause 48 as it stands. With regard to the wrecks themselves, and Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay has spoken at length about them, there can be no issue with the principle that warships that contain the human remains of servicemen and women who lost their lives carrying out their naval duties should remain undisturbed, as it is the case with aircraft or with bodies recovered from battlefields.

However, there is an issue about which wrecks qualify to be covered by clause 48 of the bill. The noble lord the minister will be aware from correspondence that he has received and that I've seen, that many believe there is considerable ambiguity on what is proposed to be covered under clause 48 and what is not. The definition of military service many believe is too vague. Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay has proposed one alternative, there are many other alternatives, one such being, quote, a commissioned military vessel or vessel under direct admiralty command at the time of loss. My point is that there are several definitions that could apply and that this military service definition is too vague.

Now time fortunately precludes a detailed scrutiny of the concerns raised, but my request on this aspect is that further consideration is given to the ships to be covered by this clause, and clarification is provided ideally by the report stage, or indeed that this clause does not stand part of the bill, pending further consideration and fresh legislation proposed on another occasion. With regard to diving activities in and around designated wrecks, I declare an interest as chair of the Gloucester 1682 Charitable Trust, although I am not a diver myself. The noble lord the minister knows, as do the noble baroness Goldie and the noble earl Minto, as former ministers, that I've been raising the issue of the wreck of the Gloucester, lost off Norfolk on the 6th of May 1682, for several years.

The history of that is now a matter of public record, but it's an interesting public record. But it has drawn me into an understanding of diving and the problems that clause 48 as drafted creates for the hobby diving community, which has tens of thousands of participants in this country. And I touched on some of those issues at second reading, and I'll try and be brief. The diving community has a number of concerns. Among the issues are that the prohibition on the use of grapnels, anchors or shots should be removed as their use is essential on health and safety grounds to protect scuba divers, particularly in the uncertain waters of the North Sea.

The grounds for rejection of this objection pose a situation which in practice does not really exist. The damage that could be caused by such grapnels and anchors is absolutely minimum and not going to be of a major nature as the bill rather suggests. Another issue is around the entering of a wreck. There needs to be a sensible definition of what access is legal and what is not. Over-prescription will not stop diving, but it will make illegal diving of some nature, which would render the divers' insurance useless and therefore place divers at further risk.

And the third thing is with regard to artifacts. A complete prohibition on removing anything will undermine the current system of reporting finds to the receiver of wreck and probably not stop removals as this cannot be policed. It's better that fixtures are left intact, but loose items can be recovered rather than them being lost to the currents and sea. My Lords, I submit that clause 48 raises many issues on which there has been insufficient consultation. The implications for the diving community are significant.

I believe it should be withdrawn pending further consultation with the communities concerned. I beg to move.

07:41:21 - 07:42:01

Julie Smith

My Lords, I think we've heard two fascinating speeches from noble Lords who have considerable expertise and interests in the questions of military remains. I would be interested in the noble Lord the Minister's responses, particularly to the noble Lord Lord Dannatt's suggestion that further work be done on this clause. And again, as with the previous group of amendments, it would be helpful to know what consultation His Majesty's Government has undertaken about the implications of this clause for divers.

07:42:01 - 07:45:47

Annabel Goldie

Well, my Lords, I'm probably about to provide a less fascinating speech. Can I endorse everything said by my noble friend Lord Parkinson, and as such, I'm pleased to support his amendment. Clause 48 will automatically expand the protection provided by the Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 to every vessel lost in military service, rather than requiring each one to go through a separate designation order. And I think that's a welcome and overdue reform. However, the issue that my noble friend has raised, whilst related, pertains to a slightly different problem.

The Merchant Shipping Act of 1995 currently applies the ordinary civil law of salvage to His Majesty's ships in much the same way as it would to a vessel in private ownership, subject only to a narrow procedural safeguard on how any claim may be brought. Now, my Lords, in practice, that treats the wreck of a Royal Navy vessel, which very often will be the final resting place of Royal Navy sailors, as well as the property of the Crown, as though it were, to be honest, fair game for private salvage. And I think amendment 55 is an attempt to rectify that situation by restoring the principle of sovereign immunity and aligning the law on salvage with the spirit of what I think clause 48 is trying to achieve.

Now, in setting out the case for his amendments, my noble friend has referenced a group of academics who have highlighted this issue with the application of civil salvage law in terms of section 230, subsection 1 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995. And I would also be grateful to the noble lord the minister if he could confirm the Ministry of Defence's interpretation of that position. Now, the government may very well believe there to be no problem, and the noble lord the minister may not agree with the interpretation of the law by the academics mentioned by my noble friend. But whether the government agree or not, is the key issue not that the law can even be questioned in the first place? The fact that there exists sufficient legal ambiguity to allow academics to come to this view means that there is a risk of people attempting to salvage and recover military wrecks believing that they are allowed to do so.

Now, I do hope the government agrees to meet my noble friend and those others who are concerned so that the legal position can be clarified. On the amendment from the noble lord, Lord Dannatt, to remove the clause entirely, and I do remember with pleasure our extensive exchanges on HMS Gloucester, I most respectfully do not entirely agree with that proposal to remove the clause entirely. It is my interpretation that divers will remain free to visit sites on the same look but don't touch basis that already applies to protected places, and I remember numerous letters as a minister in that context. What becomes unlawful is the disturbance, damage, or entry into enclosed parts of a wreck without Ministry of Defence authorisation. And I believe the intention is to prevent poor behaviour by the minority who treat these sites as a source of souvenirs, which is not the ordinary conduct of responsible divers.

My lords, I do think we have a duty to prevent the desecration of the final resting places of all our war dead. They gave their lives in service to our nation; that is the least they deserve. And if these measures can prevent such desecration by unlicensed diving, then I suggest they deserve our support.

07:45:47 - 07:52:58

Vernon Coaker

My lords, first of all, can I thank everyone who's contributed to the debate. Can I start with Lord Parkinson's amendment 55A and thank him for bringing that forward in relation to salvage claims against military and Royal Fleet Auxiliary vessels via section 1 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995, which is a principal piece of primary legislation, as he knows, in the UK that governs maritime law, ship registration, and safety standards. Can I reassure your lordships that we will investigate the noble lord's concerns and comments about section 230(1) of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995 before report stage and come back with appropriate comments with respect to that. And I hope that's a reassurance to him about all of the various comments that he helpfully made for your lordships' house. Can I also, in moving to clause 48 and the debate on that, thank the noble and gallant lord, Lord Dannatt, for his views on the bill and acknowledge his concerns about clause 48 and the Protection of Military Remains Act 1986.

Clause 48 of the bill addresses the existing disparity between the protection of military aircraft and vessels under the Protection of Military Remains Act 1986. The 1986 act secures the protection from unauthorised interference of the remains of military aircraft and vessels that have crashed, sunk, or been stranded, and of associated human remains, making it an offence to enter or interfere with a military wreck site without an authorised licence.

The Act provides for two types of protection: protected places and controlled sites, as designated through a statutory instrument in tranches. To date, a total of 129 wrecked vessels have been designated in eight tranches, the last coming into force on the 30th of March 2026. However, the Act does not currently allow designation of a vessel which was sunk or stranded on or before the 4th of August 1914 as a protected place, or to designate a site as a controlled site if over 200 years has elapsed since the crash, sinking, or stranding of the vessel or aircraft. As a result of these time limits, older military shipwrecks lack protection. For example, the Gloucester, which I know from our discussions and correspondence is of particular interest to the noble and gallant Lord, which sank in 1682 carrying the future James II and with a loss of around 200 lives, is currently unprotected.

Clause 48 amends section 1 of the 1986 Act so that all military shipwrecks which are the last resting places of serving personnel are automatically protected as protected places. This ensures alignment with the protection already afforded to military aircraft. The clause also removes the restrictive time constraints that apply to both protected places and controlled sites, ensuring the nation's historic military shipwrecks, which are currently excluded from inclusion by virtue of the time limits specified, can be protected. By providing automatic protection to all military shipwrecks, the MOD will enable a significant improvement in the way our maritime military graves and underwater cultural heritage are protected. Significant advances in underwater technology and technical diving are leading to more of our military wrecks being discovered.

This of course is good news, but it also requires that we do all that we can to protect them. I think the noble Baroness was alluding to why one of the reasons why we were doing it, and it's that those advances in technology is one of the reasons. So we need to do all we can to protect them once they've been discovered and identified, to prevent them from being disturbed or damaged and prevent interference with military remains. The recent discovery of HMS Tiger off the Isle of Wight is a prime example of why the amendments are being sought, again to Baroness Goldie's point. HMS Tiger was discovered 118 years after she collided with HMS Berwick during a training exercise and was cut clean in two.

Currently, she can only be designated as a controlled site simply due to sinking in 1908, effectively restricting access to divers. Though through the changes in the Bill, HMS Tiger will become a protected place, permitting non-intrusive activities such as diving without a licence. It is important that we protect UK military shipwrecks in UK territorial waters and international waters, and I hope that there is no doubt that our intention is to do all we can to offer better protection to prevent unauthorised desecration of these historically important sites, which are often the last resting place of our serving personnel. Can I also say to your Lordships' House, the fact and draw attention to the fact that many of the provisions already contained within the current Act will remain.

Clause 48 simply seeks to strengthen it. Diving on protected places will continue to be permitted, again to the noble baroness, Baroness Goldie's point. Diving on protected places will continue to be permitted on a look but don't touch basis, whilst a license to dive on a controlled site will still be required. Giving all military wrecks protected place status will help to deter unauthorized salvage and the desecration of the wrecks and military remains of service personnel and where appropriate enable the MOD to prosecute those who flout the law in this respect. Can I reassure the house that already provisions within the act to permit diving on UK military shipwrecks in UK territorial and international waters, but to assist divers in navigating their way around the changes proposed, MOD will be updating and publishing their policies on underwater cultural heritage should the bill be passed.

Can I also reassure the house that the MOD in consultation, again I, it might have been Baroness Smith asked, in consultation with the British Sub-Aqua Club, the UK governing body for sub-aqua diving, has produced a set of questions and answers designed to inform their members and the diving community of the proposed changes which were published on the 2nd of September 2026. With those necessary reassurances, I hope the house would see the need for clause 48 and the amendment would be withdrawn.

07:52:58 - 07:54:19

Stephen Parkinson

My lords, I'm very grateful to the noble lord the minister for his replies. As he rightly says, the technology and the increased availability of it to many more people is the reason why the broad changes the government is seeking to make through this bill are so timely and so needed. On my amendment 55A, I'm grateful to him for undertaking to investigate the position in detail before we move to report. I understand why before that investigation takes place he doesn't want to say any more about it now, but reiterate my offer to speak to him further if I can be of assistance or to put him in touch with those who've conducted the research that has led me to table this amendment. If as he mentioned at the end his department and DCMS are going to be updating their guidance documents in light of it, that will be necessary to do so that there can be absolute legal certainty for those who wish to dive and enjoy the investigations and sport that they do, but also for those, including divers, who care so deeply about the sanctity of these sites and their heritage significance.

So with gratitude for now, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

07:54:19 - 07:54:51

Ilora Finlay

Is it your lordship's pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question is that clause 48 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.

The contents have it. The question is that clauses 49 and 50 stand part of the bill en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.

After clause 50, amendment 56, Lord Craig of Radley.

07:54:51 - 07:59:56

Jock Stirrup

My lords, I rise to speak to amendment 56 and I thank the noble lord, Lord Horlock, for adding his name in support. I also thank the Royal British Legion for their guidance in drafting this amendment. This amendment proposes amending the national fees regulations of 2018 to waive fees for certain armed forces veterans granted indefinite leave to remain in the United Kingdom.

Noble Lords may be interested to learn that the terms of my amendment featured in all three major party manifestos for the 2024 election. Let me just quote briefly. Labour: we will scrap the visa fees for non-UK veterans who have served for four or more years and their dependents. Conservatives: we will extend the visa fee waiver introduced to cover Commonwealth personnel to include their direct dependents. And the Liberal Democrats: will secure a fair deal for the Armed Forces community by waiving application fees for indefinite leave to remain for members of the Armed Forces on discharge and their families.

Well, Lords, nothing has happened since, except in response to follow-up questions, written questions last year. A Home Office minister said on the 13th of March: we continue to keep this policy under review in the context of our wider considerations of various aspects of the immigration system. And the Ministry of Defence responded a week later that they were, quote, working actively with the Home Office to take this forward. In short, my Lords, prevarications apart, nothing has happened. And to have a reply, quote, we continue to keep this policy under review in our wider considerations of various aspects of the immigration system, is surely classic Sir Humphrey speak.

I think the Home Office should be ashamed of itself. The immigration system must be under constant study, not a one-off difficulty. What wider considerations are implied? The government has recently prided itself on over 40% reductions in illegal arrivals and an increase in repatriations. There seems no crisis or wider aspect so great that the government cannot immediately introduce this universally and manifesto-promised arrangement.

Families of service personnel who have qualified for indefinite leave to remain are faced with visa fees which were 155 in 2003, but have risen to no less than 3,226 pounds per person as of the 8th of April. A staggering increase. So a spouse, a partner, and two children applying for ILR would now have to find almost 13,000 on top of their fares and relocation costs to move to the UK. This is no way to be treating veterans and their families. This prevarication and inertia does not seem to be even related to the present government.

For over 10 years, I and others pressed the Home Office to grant ILR for members of the Armed Forces who had been recruited and served in Hong Kong, all of members of the Hong Kong Military Service Corps. Repeated Home Office answers were varied ways of saying it's under active consideration or that a decision will be made as soon as possible. I once christened this Home Office foot-dragging as repetitive inactivity syndrome. The Hong Kong Military Service Corps veterans had to wait over a decade for their approval.

Of course, my Lords, the Home Office faces pressures over immigration arrangements. But it flies in the face of the government's commitment to the Armed Forces Covenant and treating veterans fairly to have not yet honored their manifesto pledge. As this has cross-party support, will the noble Lord the Minister take this back and quickly resolve it with the Home Office? I beg to move.

07:59:56 - 08:00:09

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed after clause 50, insert the following new clause: waived fees for indefinite leave to remain for spouses of children of serving or discharged members of the armed forces, as printed on the marshal list.

08:00:09 - 08:07:08

Joanna Penn

My Lords, I support the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig of Radley's amendment 56, which would waive fees for applicants for indefinite leave to remain for spouses and immediate family members of serving personnel and veterans. I also have amendment 66 in this group, which seeks to achieve the same outcome through a slightly different route by requiring the government to bring forward secondary legislation within a specified timeframe designed to address some of the concerns raised by ministers in the other place around specific approaches and wording. But frankly, I don't mind what legislative approach is taken, provided the issue is resolved. And I don't think I need to add to the noble and gallant Lord's exposition of the issue. But I would say to the noble Lord the Minister that typically immigration rules are changed twice yearly, with the next set expected in October.

And so I'd ask the noble Lord the Minister whether he could provide greater clarity on the government's timetable for action and whether he could reassure military families that this commitment by all three major parties indeed will finally be delivered in the forthcoming changes this autumn. My Lords, turning to amendment 57 in this group, standing in my name and the name of the noble Baronesses Lady Newnham and Lady Bennett and the noble my noble friend Lord Harlech, for whom I'm grateful for their support. At the heart of this is about how we support military families, but it's also about military capability. The Strategic Defence Review identified a workforce crisis. And when our armed forces depend so heavily on experience and invest so much in their personnel, retention matters as much as recruitment.

And that's why I welcome the many provisions in this bill designed to strengthen service life. Amendment 57 proposes a relatively small change, but one that could make a meaningful difference to both military families and to retention. The recently published Tri-Service Families Continuous Attitude Survey underlines the reality for families. 78% of service families have children, and one in five have children who are under two years old. Yet a quarter of service families live apart during the working week, rising to almost 40% in the Royal Navy and the Royal Marines.

Nearly three in ten families experienced separation of three months or more during the past year. At present, serving fathers receive two weeks of paternity leave at full pay. But for military families, returning to work after two weeks is not a return to a normal commute. It means returning to a posting many hours away or to months of separation. And that's why this issue matters so deeply to those who serve.

One serving soldier told the Dadshift: being posted four hours away from my child when she was born was tough.

collapse of my relationship with her mother too. These challenges are reflected further in the tri-services family survey. 52% of spouses disagree that they feel valued by the service. 34% say they would feel happier if their partner left the military, while 44% have at some time in the past year encouraged their partner to leave. The factors driving dissatisfaction are revealing.

The impact on their careers, the amount of separation from their spouses, and the effect on their children are the top three reasons. Improving paternity leave is not a silver bullet, but the evidence consistently shows that it supports maternal employment, strengthens family relationships, and improves outcomes for children. At a time when retention is a strategic issue, we should take seriously reforms that strengthen family life of those who serve. And the experiences of serving personnel themselves will illustrate why. One RAF officer recalled: "Both children saw us remain in hospital with our newborn for three to four days due to challenges with feeding and jaundice.

With only two weeks available, time spent dealing with complications or hospital stays can consume a significant proportion of the leave itself." Now the noble lord the minister may point to shared parental leave or the possibility of additional compassionate leave as options to resolve this. However, service families often describe those options as difficult to access and inconsistently applied. One army officer reported: "I pushed and took shared parental leave, but I had to threaten a service complaint to do so with my work at the time." He added that if the process was difficult for a senior officer, it would likely be much harder for more junior personnel.

Likewise, an RAF corporal told the Dadshift: "I have had my paternity leave handled three different ways for my three different children. It comes down to that recurring line manager lottery issue, unfortunately." That inconsistency in itself is part of the problem. Families should not have to rely on confidence, rank, or managerial discretion to receive adequate support at such a significant moment in their lives. Soldiers, sailors, and aviators should not have to worry about explaining to their commanding officer that their wife and baby are struggling with breastfeeding and need more support, or that their wife's stitches are infected, or that he's worried that she might be suffering from postnatal depression but can't even be sure because he's not home enough to tell.

Of course, the impact of leave on operational readiness must be taken into account. Unlike maternity leave, paternity leave is not exempt from the provision in JSP 760 that the granting and timing of all forms of absence is to be at the discretion of the service and is subject to operational requirements and the general exigencies of the service. Nothing in my amendment changes this. The sacrifices made by those serving in our armed forces are shared by their families. And when a child is born, those pressures are felt even more acutely.

Two weeks of paternity leave is increasingly out of step with the realities of modern family life, with the practices of leading employers, and with the approach taken by many of our closest allies, with Australia offering eight weeks of paid paternity leave and the United States offering 12 to its military personnel. When Congress extended that entitlement, bipartisan supporters from both houses described it as a matter of military readiness and national security. I hope, therefore, that in responding to this group, the minister will recognize not only the family case for reform, but also the strategic one. Supporting military families at the moment they need it most is the right thing to do, but it would also be an investment in retention, morale, and the long-term strength of our armed forces.

08:07:08 - 08:11:54

Natalie Bennett

My lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble lady Baroness Penn and to attach my name to amendment 57, which provides for six weeks of fully paid paternity leave for service people.

Noble Lords, the committee will see that this is perhaps not the broadest alliance across the political spectrum that you might find, but it's certainly up there in the spread that you will typically see in your Lordship's House. But as the noble lady Baroness Pinnock has powerfully outlined, and I won't repeat, the arguments for this are twofold. First of all, it's about the welfare of children. It's about children being able to establish a proper relationship, a proper foundation for family life, something that's going to be going through them, with them through their lives. It is also, of course, an issue in terms of retention of service people, which is a big issue.

It's an issue in recruitment of service people. So it is an issue for the effectiveness of our armed forces. Now, at second reading, I addressed this issue and quoted a number of quotes from the survey. I think there's one I'll just add here. If we think about what two weeks is like, and this is an RAF officer from the Dad Shift survey: "Both children saw us remain in hospital with our newborn for three to four days due to challenges with feeding and jaundice."

"Even low-level complications might result in the first week of paternity leave being spent in hospital." Those are not circumstances in which for one week you're really going to be establishing a stable relationship, extremely stressful, extremely difficult, extremely unnatural circumstances. And then maybe you have one week or maybe you have no weeks after that. So I really, I know that at second reading the Minister said that, well, there is a broader government review of paternity leave, but I don't think, given we have the Armed Forces Bill before us, there is any need or any argument for waiting. Action can clearly and clearly needs to be taken now.

I come now to amendment 67, which is also in this group, which appears in my name, which is a fairly simple amendment, which puts on the face of the bill a specification that the government must establish a concessionary travel scheme for bus travel for veterans. Now, it doesn't specify, the amendment doesn't specify exactly the detail of which that concessionary bus travel might be provided, how it might be set out, what levels it might be set out. That's clearly the sort of thing that's appropriately put to statutory instrument. But I think if we think about the situation of a veteran, some may qualify for concessionary travel because they're older or because they have a qualifying disability. But what about the veteran at the age of 30 or 40 or 50 who has no qualifying disability, but perhaps after many years of service returns to the UK not having a stable base here in the UK?

And we know that there's a significant number of veterans who have real difficulty establishing themselves within civilian life, finding a stable place within civilian life. Being able to afford the bus travel might mean being able to get to work, attend training, access services, get an appointment, visit family, or just remain connected in the community. This would be potentially a meaningful part of the support we could provide for veterans making a transition back into civilian life. Now, some people might say, "Oh, well, is this too difficult or complicated?" Well, we have concessionary bus travel schemes operating right across the UK at very significant scale.

In England alone, there were 8.9 million older and disabled concessionary travel passes in the year to March 2025. Those pass holders made 624 million concessionary bus journeys in the year. The government reimbursed bus operators 795 million for those journeys. Of course, the scale that we're talking here would be a tiny fraction of that, but these systems already exist. There would not be a need to create new systems.

And of course we know that these schemes work in other parts of the UK as well. I have previously noted in your Lordships' House with great pride the fact of free bus travel for the under-22s in Scotland, something that's been a hugely popular and successful scheme. So the question is not whether the government can administer a concessionary travel scheme, but who should be entitled to benefit from one. And I think this is a small, modest measure that could really help our veterans and help our communities.

08:11:54 - 08:13:49

Jasset David Cody Harlech

My Lords, I rise very briefly just to speak in support of the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley's amendment and my noble friend Baroness Penn's. I think there's a lot of shared aims with these amendments of improving morale amongst our armed forces community and as we've heard, improving recruitment but also crucially retention, which is something that's really suffered over a long period of time. And I think it's important to recognize that service personnel understand that operational need will come first. They accept, when they sign up, when they swear that oath, they accept that there will be times where they will be away through a deployment. They will miss birthdays, christenings, weddings.

It comes with the territory. They might not always like it, but they accept it. I think what this gets at is not having that parental time in that crucial early stages of a new life when you're at home, when you're on base. So I think that's the difference and I think we should be doing something to bring ourselves in line with, again, I remember saying this earlier on today, with our Five Eyes counterparts. I think there's a trend here, yes, across the different groups, across the different amendments, that we are way behind what the rest of our allies are doing in these categories.

Yeah, so with that, I'll pass it on.

08:13:49 - 08:15:27

Julie Smith

My Lords, the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley, has over the years held His Majesty's Government of whichever complexion to account, in particular as he mentioned earlier over the rights of the Hong Kong military. He rightly reminds us that all of the main parties made commitments over waiving fees for the families of service personnel, veterans who served with our armed forces. Could the noble Lord the Minister undertake to give us some commitment to looking into this, because my suspicion is that when he was on the opposition benches, he would have been speaking quite loudly in favor of reducing the fees, and that is clearly something which we should be doing. The noble lady Baroness Penn very eloquently explained the importance of extending paternity leave and the reasons for that. I won't go any further, there's no need to rehearse that at this time of night, other than to express the views of these benches to support the proposals and to ask His Majesty's Government to think very carefully about the importance of extending paternity leave, in particular for reasons of retention.

08:15:27 - 08:17:48

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, I turn first to amendment 56 tabled by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley, and supported by my noble friend Lord Harlech.

I'm pleased to be able to say that we on these benches do support this amendment. We have already waived the fees for indefinite leave to remain for Commonwealth citizens who have served in our armed forces in recognition of the sacrifice to our nation that that service represents. It is difficult to see any principled basis for stopping short of extending that same waiver to their spouses and children. These are, after all, the families who have supported that service, often at real personal cost to themselves. My Lords, as has already been said, extending fee waivers of this kind to service families was a manifesto commitment at the last election made by both my party and the Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats.

Given that shared commitment, I hope the Minister will explain today why it has not yet been implemented and when government intends to act. I now turn to amendments 57 and 58 in the name of my noble friend Baroness Penn, amongst others. I hope she will understand why, unfortunately, I'm not able to support this. The current scheme already provides two weeks of paid paternity leave with the ability to agree further paid leave on a unit-by-unit basis where circumstances allow. We believe that flexibility matters.

Operational necessity varies enormously from unit to unit and deployment to deployment, and decisions about what additional leave is achievable are, in our view, best worked out between the individual serviceman and his commanding officer. It is that commanding officer who understands the operational picture on the ground best. I am aware of the obvious drawback to this policy of flexibility, that is to say it will create unequal and disparate outcomes. Some units may be more generous than others. However, my Lords, I think that it is an unfortunate fact of life and is eminently preferable to a centrally set period fixed in statute at six weeks, regardless of circumstance and operational necessity.

I look forward to hearing the Minister's response to both amendments.

08:17:48 - 08:23:06

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, let me, given the hour, let me deal with these head-on. First of all, can I start with the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig's amendment 56. The government, the opposition, all of us, it seems to me, are committed to scrapping visa fees for non-UK veterans who have served for four years or more and their dependents, building on the existing fee waiver in place. Home Office and Ministry of Defence ministers are working closely together to deliver this commitment in a way that is fair, comprehensive, and achievable. I understand that the noble and gallant Lord will have heard that language before.

He asked me to have conversation urgently with the Home Office to see what progress has been made, and I will certainly do that. And I think that is the important commitment to make. Indeed, in terms of the Earl of Minto, he was asking for that as well. So let me, I will follow that up and I will certainly talk to the Home Office. But they will also have heard the very well-constructed speech that the noble and gallant Lord made to ask when is this going to happen and it's about time it did.

So I hope with that reassurance he can see the importance of putting amendments at committee stage. Can I also turn to the, I thought again, powerful speech made by Baroness Penn with respect to her amendment 57 and the various points that she made about childcare, about family life, about parental leave, all of those various topics and points that she made very eloquently.

She will know that there is a government review which is going on around parental leave and pay and many of these other issues. The review is considering costs, benefits and potential reforms across the whole system as a whole. And the review principally covers civilian parental leave and pay entitlements. MOD will consider the outcome of that review and its applicability to the armed forces. It would be premature to prescribe now a specific, for example, six-week model for the armed forces before the wider review concludes.

But I think this may be of interest to the noble baroness, the review is expected to conclude in early 2027. So that might start to give us some reassurance about where we go to with the various points that she's raised. But can I just say to her, I think these are extremely important points. I think they are points that need to be heard, but as well as being heard, they need to be acted upon. And all I can say to her is that the continued putting of these amendments, the continued challenges to the system to say what more are you going to do to ensure that we get the entitlements that are needed, I think is important.

She will know within the armed forces when it comes to paternity leave that for all eligible personnel there are the concerns about its impact upon operational effectiveness. But surely as we move forward there ought to be a way of matching the desire for better family arrangements with maintaining the operational effectiveness and particular needs of the armed forces. And we have to find a way of better balancing all of those demands that she quite rightly made through her amendment. And I'll certainly do that within the department as well. Can I say also with respect to the noble baroness, Baroness Bennett, she raises an important point that's continually made through her amendment 67 about the need for travel, for subsidized travel, for veterans having travel in excess.

And again, all of this, we started, if she remembers a number of years ago, like me, there were very few concessions. Gradually concession after concession was made quite rightly with respect to children, with respect to family tickets, all of those sorts of things. And I think certainly we need to see what more we can do with respect to our armed forces and see whether there are additional concessions that can be made which will be of benefit to them to reflect the service that they hold. An example is in London, we already know there's a veteran's Oyster photocard which entitles people to free travel on a range of transport services including buses. That demonstrates to us that progress can be made.

So whether it's with respect to transport, whether it's with respect to various family entitlements or whether it's with respect to the leave to remain point that the noble and gallant lord was making with respect to the fee waiver. I think it demonstrates sometimes even to my own government, I sometimes say, can we get a move on.

08:23:06 - 08:23:40

Jock Stirrup

My lords, just very briefly, I think the way the noble lord has answered my question in such a positive way is very encouraging. And it's certainly made my day, or perhaps I should say it's made my night. But I also thank the noble baronesses and the two noble lords who spoke in favor of my amendment, which I thoroughly accept as very supportive. Thank you.

08:23:40 - 08:23:54

Ilora Finlay

Is it your lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 57, Baroness Penn, not moved.

Amendment 58, Baroness Goldie.

08:23:54 - 08:32:23

Annabel Goldie

My lords, there may be some amongst your lordships who looked at this amendment in my name and had a flash of déjà vu. And that is because, of course, we have in some manner been here before, except that I was the one facing a grilling from noble lords rather than the noble lord the minister. During the passage of the Overseas Operations (Service Personnel and Veterans) Act of 2021, this house voiced strong opposition to what was clause 12 of the bill. And that clause stated that where the Secretary of State considers an overseas operation to be significant, they must keep under consideration the appropriateness of making a derogation under Article 15(1) of the European Convention on Human Rights. Now, my lords, there were many prescient points and much legal analysis made in our committee stage deliberations on that clause.

And after those debates, I informed the house that the government had agreed to accept the amendment to remove the clause. The amendment I bring today bears some resemblance to the clause the government at that time agreed to remove that I've just referred to, but it goes much further. And in that regard, I believe I've taken the sting out of one of the more damning lines of criticism which troubled the last attempt. And that was the argument that the clause was simply unnecessary because Article 15 already permits member states to derogate from certain convention rights in time of war or public emergency threatening the life of the nation. But that, my lords, is on the basis of could or may.

The difference with my amendment today is that it places a duty on the Secretary of State to derogate from the ECHR when our armed forces are engaged in a significant overseas operation. In other words, my lords, we have moved from a may to a must. This, of course, does not alter the fact that the United Kingdom could make a derogation under Article 15 regardless, but I submit that for the sake of our armed forces, we have to move from could to must. My lords, as a former lawyer, I have always had sympathy for law which protects individuals in the pursuit of their legitimate activities, particularly when confronted with the might of the state. And I'm in no doubt that the architects of the ECHR were driven by honorable and noble motives because these rights and freedoms are very important.

What I think was not anticipated was that increasingly the ECHR would attain a status which challenged the right of sovereign states to conduct their affairs as democratically elected governments might determine, and that vital national activity such as the operation of our military forces in a conflict situation would come within the reach of the ECHR, hence the emergence of the term lawfare. My lords, I've concluded, particularly as a former defense minister, that this evolution of the ECHR in this manner is undesirable, unworkable, and for our national security, unsafe. Whatever the former merits of the ECHR, even its most ardent advocates accept the need for reform. Indeed, I understand the new Attorney General has reportedly in the updated legal risk guidance to government softened the approach counseled by her predecessor. And if the noble lord the minister is able to share more information with us about that, I think the chamber would be very interested to hear his comments.

Now the second aspect of my amendment inserts a new section 7A into the Human Rights Act 1998 to prevent proceedings from being brought under that act in respect of any overseas operations by His Majesty's forces. Subsection 4 of that new section would also exempt members of the armed forces from the convention for the period of their deployment. I should be clear that my amendment is something of a compromise because as I said, the preferred position on these benches would be to leave the ECHR altogether. But that is not a debate for tonight and it's not, it's clearly not in scope of this bill and it's not going to happen until we have a change of government. So given that, I believe my amendment is the only solution to prevent a potentially calamitous wrong that demands to be put right.

And I am of course talking about the appalling vexatious legal claims based largely on creative interpretations of human rights law made against our veterans and serving soldiers. Such claims have led to brave members of our armed forces being sued by lawyers, hounded by journalists, hauled through the courts and in many cases a torment lasting for years. Now all this despite the fact that the Human Rights Act and the convention were not originally intended to apply to operations outside a state's own territory. And during our debates on clause 12 in 2021, the noble lord Lord Faulks, and I'm very pleased to see him in his place, gave a detailed history of how we got to a position where the convention was held to apply extraterritorially as a result of the Al-Skeini ruling in 2011. My lords, that was in my view a decision which has warped the application of the convention to such a degree that it has permitted deployment of the convention to launch wholly unjustified attacks on our troops serving in conflict.

And the reason this is so serious is twofold. Firstly, the lawfare that has been directed at our armed forces over the past decade has had a serious impact on morale, recruitment and retention. We know that the SAS raised concerns about recruitment as a result of this government's, I'm sorry, shameful decision to restart prosecutions of the Troubles veterans. Further high-profile prosecutions and civil proceedings relating to more recent conflicts have exacerbated the problems. And secondly, my lords, we live in a world where the Secretary General of NATO is warning that we face the prospect of a major conflict with Russia by 2030, 2030.

Now if that does indeed happen, we cannot go into such a conflict with our hands tied behind our backs. Russia is not a party to the ECHR and we have seen how ruthlessly they prosecute their wars. Now to be clear, my lords, I am absolutely not arguing that we should match Russian brutality, particularly given the appalling reports of widespread use of sexual violence as a weapon of war and the barbaric treatment of civilians. But my lords, this is not a binary situation with clearly delineated and neatly drawn lines of what constitutes right and what constitutes wrong. Those who argue it is black and white would have us believe that either you're in the ECHR and abide by it even during times of war, or you act like the Russians have in Ukraine.

But I reject that binary classification entirely, for between these two positions there exists a huge grey area.

What I am arguing is that if we have any hope of fighting on a level footing in any future war, we cannot have the possibility of lawfare hanging over the heads of our soldiers. Now, my Lords, I appreciate we will not reach a point of agreement on this issue tonight. But could the noble Lord the Minister at least tell me how the government plans to prevent human rights law from being weaponized against British troops in any potential future conflict? How will the government give them the certainty that they will be able to do their jobs in an environment of conflict requiring immediate decisions of often potential lethality without fear of years of ensuing harassment and investigation? The present situation is unsatisfactory.

The ECHR is jeopardizing our war-fighting capability and our security, and I beg to move.

08:32:23 - 08:32:33

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed: after clause 50, insert the following new clause: overseas operations and the European Convention on Human Rights, as printed on the marshalled list.

08:32:33 - 08:37:10

Edward Faulks

It will be generally agreed that our country needs our armed forces, including the reserves and the cadets, more than ever. We need to encourage people to join, and we need to look after them when they do. And we ask them to risk their lives on our behalf. If we do that, we should ensure that they have the appropriate legal protection. There used to be a common law principle of so-called combat immunity.

What that meant was that the courts did not get involved in measuring the responsibility for what occurs in the heat of battle. Aggression that may, with the benefit of hindsight, be seen to be excessive, should not be analyzed many years later in the studied calm of a courtroom with lawyers employing slippery words like proportionality. Now, this is to say nothing of so-called blue-on-blue or friendly fire incidents, which are inevitable from time to time. I would not want to give our armed forces a free pass legally. They would not want one.

The law of armed conflict is necessary and well-established. The Geneva Convention and the accumulation of international conventions and treaties are generally described as international humanitarian law, and it's generally respected. But what worries me, as it does the noble lady Baroness Goldie, is the ECHR and its incorporation into our law by the Human Rights Act 1998. It has brought the law into places where it has no business. The Strasbourg jurisdiction in this area has become exorbitant.

It has held, for example, as the noble lady said, that the European, yes, the European Convention on Human Rights applies to theaters of war in Afghanistan and Iraq. Reference was made to Al-Skeini, there's also a case called Al-Jedda. These cases brought about, among other things, the persecution of our troops by lawyers like Phil Shiner, a lawyer who was eventually imprisoned for his deeds. But not without causing immense damage and immense expense before doing so. And the causation, I fear, is quite clearly established by the decisions of human rights lawyers to rely on the convention in inappropriate ways.

Now, the rights embodied in the convention are in themselves wholly unexceptionable. But the living instrument approach has meant that judges have approached its application in what might be described as an open-textured way, resulting in real uncertainty as to what our troops are entitled to do legally. Article 2, the right to life, has, for example, been held to justify a claim against the Ministry of Defence in connection with the supply of Land Rovers. It's the case of Smith and Ministry of Defence.

For some time now, the think tank Policy Exchange has focused on the so-called problems of lawfare. Tom Tugendhat MP, now Shadow Foreign Secretary, wrote a paper some time ago entitled The Fog of Law. It remarked on all these facets which are causing such a difficulty for our troops. We have now reached a position where our troops are embarrassed in front of allies, and we are accused by our allies of legal freeloading when lawyers try and explain our position, our legal position. Now lawyers are conservative in the advice that they give, if not in their politics.

The result is that our troops are vulnerable to legal attack, and their leaders may well become inappropriately circumspect in their approach in the light of the legal advice that they receive. These amendments attempt to give our reserves and all our troops proper protection from the incursions of the ECHR. And I ask the Minister, for whom we all have great respect, to explain whether he considers, whether the government considers the current state of the law is justifiable, and whether it is truly in the interests of our servicemen and women, or indeed in the public interest.

08:37:10 - 08:40:02

Sal Sarah Brinton

My Lords, I'm sorry because I don't rise. I'm very grateful to both Lady Goldie and to Lord Fookes for their introduction to the amendment and for explaining them in detail. And I am not a lawyer, so forgive me for not being able to respond to some of the cases that Lord Fookes has certainly raised. And from these benches, we have complete sympathy with the principles of sorting out this lawfare issue, because it is clearly a problem. But from our perspective, our concerns are, having particularly listened to Lady Goldie, is whether under the terms of Article 15 of ECHR, even this level of derogation is permissible.

She quoted from section 1 of Article 15, but not from section 2, which says no derogation from Article 2, the right for life, except in respect of deaths resulting from lawful acts of war, from Articles 3 and 4, torture and slavery, and 7, retrospective criminal penalty, shall be made under this provision. And I think that section means that it is not possible for the UK to derogate. Has, I just wondered, when the noble lady was minister, were there any discussions with the Council of Europe on this particular issue, rather than a particular court case, because we cannot be the only country affected by this. I mean, it may be it's particularly bad in the UK, but I am concerned that as I understand it, from not just the ECHR Article 15 itself, but also the government's independent review of the Human Rights Act in I think 2023, which referred to the progress of the bill of Overseas Operations and Service Personnel and Veterans Bill 2019 to 2021, which Lady Goldie referred to. It is explained that the amendment was withdrawn partly because of the very strong feelings in your Lordships' House, but it referred specifically to this point in Article 15 in ECHR, and the government then decided it could not continue with the amendment.

So I would, having asked Lady Goldie the question, which is perhaps slightly unfair because she's no longer a minister, ask the minister at the moment whether or not any further discussions have been had with the Council of Europe on this particular problem. Because as we know, the ECHR is a living document and if there are issues, it is quite probable that the members would agree to some changes, perhaps expanding the level of articles that can be covered by a derogation.

08:40:02 - 08:42:48

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, can I thank the noble Baroness Goldie for introducing her amendments and acknowledge the points she has made. Can I also thank Lord Faulks for his contribution to the debate and just say to him that clearly, not only within the context of this bill, but certainly within the whole range of other bills, debates and topics, many of the cases that he raises will be raised and I think there'll be a more extensive debate on a whole range of those issues that he raises and we need those to be discussed. On terms of Baroness Brinton and the Council of Europe, the debate about the ECHR goes on continuously. Whether anybody's raised the specifics around this amendment with them, I am simply unaware. The ECHR provides for legally enforceable rights within the jurisdiction of the state and in some circumstances that jurisdiction can extend beyond the territory of the state, namely extraterritorial jurisdiction.

Extraterritorial jurisdiction does not apply uniformly in relation to the various ECHR obligations and the position has evolved over time through the case law of the UK courts and the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. I understand the concerns about how extraterritorial jurisdiction of the ECHR has been interpreted, but I want to make this important point which gets to the heart of why I don't think this amendment should be made. And that is amending the Human Rights Act directly does not change the UK's international law obligations under the ECHR to which the government wishes to adhere. For instance, new section 7A seeks to restrict the territorial extent of the Human Rights Act in relation to overseas operations. However, Article 13 of the ECHR requires the UK to provide an effective domestic remedy for anyone with an arguable claim that their convention rights have been violated.

In other words, if the extraterritorial application of the Human Rights Act is removed, the UK will still need to ensure that there is domestic remedy in respect of arguable ECHR breaches occurring in an overseas operation. Additionally, the existence of a domestic remedy separate from that provided for by the Human Rights Act would not prevent the European Court of Human Rights from hearing a case where an applicant had exhausted that domestic remedy. A similar issue arises...

08:42:48 - 08:43:43

Edward Faulks

Sorry, excuse me, noble Lord, for allowing me to intervene. He's right up to a point, in the sense that it is true that provided we remain a member of the European Convention, then there is potentially a remedy if there is considered to be a breach of the convention right at Strasbourg. But we chose in 1996 to incorporate the convention in our domestic law. And what this amendment is doing, and Baroness Goldie correct me if I'm wrong, is to amend our domestic law to restrict the remedy. Now, of course, ultimately it might be possible to go to Strasbourg to pursue a remedy.

But what this is concerned to do is to limit the possibility of anybody relying on a statute passed by this government, that's the Human Rights Act, and seek a remedy in our courts relying on that.

08:43:43 - 08:44:12

Vernon Coaker

Well, that's the debate, isn't it? And I understand the point very well made by the noble Lord, Lord Faulks.

But that's the debate we're having. The debate the government, the argument the government puts forward is the disapplication of the Human Rights Act does not prevent somebody taking, does not prevent the application of the ECHR. And that's the point that's being, that's being made. And that's the point of difference between us.

08:44:12 - 08:45:00

Edward Faulks

Can I just simply say this one thing. Until we had the Human Rights Act in 1996 we were a member of the European Convention. We didn't initially even have the right to go to Strasbourg. We then allowed those who wanted to bring an action to go to the Strasbourg court. But it was completely unnecessary, it was thought by the then government, the Labour government in fact, to actually incorporate the convention.

So this is considerably diluting the rights. It's an important difference. The government may say well we need this, this right incorporated in our law in the United Kingdom and that's a different point. But if he's simply saying yes we're a member of the convention, there is always a right to go to Strasbourg, I agree with that, but that's not quite what the amendment is focusing on.

08:45:00 - 08:46:35

Vernon Coaker

The government would make both points. I'm just speaking to the amendment. If the, if the, if I was simply, if I was not responding to the amendment but I was putting the whole point around the Human Rights Act and the ECHR, I would say the government is proud to have the Human Rights Act which it passed and also the consequent ability to go to the ECHR as well. But what I'm doing in this amendment, in this, in these remarks, is speak to the actual amendment that's before us now that the Baroness Goldie has put before us. And as we do that, as I say, we see that the disapplication of the Human Rights Act does not work in the way that the noble Baroness wants because you can still go to the ECHR and that's the point that I'm making.

For example, before derogating an assessment must be made as to whether the circumstances amount to a war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation, whether derogation is necessary, which convention obligations require limitation, noting that some rights are absolute and cannot be departed from, and whether any measures adopted are strictly required by the exigencies of the situation. These assessments are inherently context-specific. By making derogation mandatory whenever an overseas operation is deemed significant, the amendment risks replacing the individualized assessment required by Article 15 with a blanket statutory presumption of derogation. And on the basis of this I would ask the noble Baroness to withdraw her amendment.

08:46:35 - 08:47:18

Edward Faulks

I apologize to the noble Lord, I promise him this is the last intervention I'll make. I think it's really to deal with the point made by the noble lady Baroness Barker, who I think was saying that her view or her understanding was the position that the government cannot, sorry, Brinton, forgive me, forgive me. Her point was that the government cannot derogate. I understand the answer to Baroness Goldie which is to say well we want to consider the position whether it is appropriate. But I understand from the Minister that it is accepted that the government has the right to derogate but doesn't want it mandatory for it to exercise it in overseas operations because it will be context-specific.

Is that the position?

08:47:18 - 08:47:29

Vernon Coaker

That's the first time in all the time I've been in this House that I don't actually understand what the noble Lord means. I've said what I've said and I think I'll leave it there.

08:47:29 - 08:47:56

Edward Faulks

I'll give it one more go, it's probably my lack of clarity. Because the question is whether the government has the right to derogate at all. And I think that was the issue that was being raised, maybe I've misunderstood it.

But his answer, quite understandable answer, is that it has, I think, it has the right to derogate, but it does not feel that it ought to be automatic because it needs to consider the particular circumstances as to whether it is appropriate to derogate.

08:47:56 - 08:48:25

Vernon Coaker

Of course the government can make the laws for itself and can choose to derogate should it wish to do so. What I've done in my remarks is to point out the inconsistency of the amendment put before us by Baroness Goldie, which requires us to derogate from the Human Rights Act, but doesn't achieve the objective she wants because it still leaves us liable to the ECHR, which would allow people to go to that and pursue it in that way.

08:48:25 - 08:50:45

Annabel Goldie

Well, my Lords, I think the minister understands fully what it's like to be grilled at the dispatch box in relation to the European Convention of Human Rights and the Human Rights Act. May I first of all thank the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, and of course the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, for their contributions. And I'm particularly grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, for his elucidation of the legal aspects of this. It is complex, there are interwoven components, and I was following his interrogation of the minister with a rather selfish interest as the minister nobly endeavoured to respond. What I think is emerging, and I'm really intrigued by this, I just glean from the contributions that actually there's a subject here meriting debate.

And the conundrum is this, that the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, has articulated what the problem is particularly for our troops in conflict. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, said I think there is a problem, there is a problem. And indeed the minister himself conceded this whole issue is needing a more, and I think his phrase was, extensive debate. But herein lies the conundrum, my Lords. I think we all now recognize that there is a problem.

I think we all now acknowledge that however we have arrived at this situation, the combined effect of ECHR and the Human Rights Act is creating a challenge for our troops in conflict, which in 2026 is a much more foreseeable prospect than perhaps it was even five years ago. And I am encouraged that there seems a willingness to engage in this debate. This is a serious matter, and I do suggest to the minister that it is not one about which either his department or his colleagues can remain passive or inert. I'm very grateful to all who have contributed. I appreciate the minister's response.

In the circumstances, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.

08:50:45 - 08:50:56

Ilora Finlay

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 59, the Lord Bishop of Norwich.

08:50:56 - 08:55:28

Graham Usher

My Lords, in moving amendment 59, I will speak also to amendment 60 in my name. And I thank noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham, and the noble Earl, Lord Minto, for their support. I declare also an interest as the father of a soldier. The amendments I'm proposing aim to give the same protection to service police in the conduct of their duties as to their civilian counterparts.

Amendment 59 would include service police within the offence of impersonating a police officer in the Police Act 1996. Amendment 60 would give service police the status of emergency worker within the meaning of the Assaults on Emergency Workers Act 2018. Both amendments are structured to amend the existing civilian criminal legislation rather than to create additional service offences. The purpose of this is to ensure these protections apply both to military and civilian offenders. Service police operate both behind the wire and on the streets of Britain where they respond to incidents involving both the military and civilians.

They police high-profile events such as significant military funerals, large-scale ceremonial occasions and, for example, the Edinburgh Tattoo, as well as Friday nights in garrison towns when things can get quite lively. They do not have a choice as to what incidents they come across on their patrol and must be prepared to act, including using lawful force, to prevent crime and harm to others no matter who is involved. This inevitably puts service police at risk of being assaulted when on duty. Few service police officers do not know colleagues, if not themselves, who have been assaulted whilst on duty. Currently, if a member of the service police is assaulted on duty, there are none of the enhanced sentencing powers afforded through the Assaults on Emergency Workers Act 2018, which would be used if a civilian police officer had a similar assault.

Service police are asked to face similar risks as civilian police and other emergency workers, yet they're not protected in the same way. My Lords, this strikes me as unjust. Amendment 60 will add service police within the definition of emergency worker. Adoption of this amendment will act as a deterrent against assaulting service police and, where assaults do occur, give the enhanced sentencing powers to deal with offenders to the same standard as if the assault was against a civilian police officer. Similarly, my Lords, amendment 59 aims to give service police protection against impersonation both by military personnel and civilians.

At present, it is not a specific offence to impersonate a service police officer. Service personnel who do so are currently prosecuted under the military offence of conduct prejudicial to good order and discipline, whilst there is no equivalent legislation to deal with civilians who impersonate service police officers. For both military and civilian offenders, this is a gap in legislation which could allow, does allow, for the abuse of service police powers by impersonation without appropriate consequences. In recent years, offenders have been, have avoided prosecution due to this gap in legislation which I believe needs to be closed through amendment to the civilian criminal legislation in the Police Act 1996 rather than additional service offences.

08:55:28 - 08:55:31

Speaker 122

My Lords, I beg to move.

08:55:31 - 08:55:42

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed after clause 50, insert the new clause, the words as printed on the marshalled list.

08:55:42 - 08:56:25

Julie Smith

My Lords, I rise to support the amendments in the name of the Right Reverend Prelate, to which I have appended my name. The reason being for, um, that as the Right Reverend Prelate has rightly pointed out, there are disparities in the provisions for service police versus civilian police, and that seems to be wholly wrong. So, um, in for reasons of expediting business this evening, I don't propose to speak any longer other than to say we wholly support the amendments from these benches.

08:56:25 - 08:59:54

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, I too have signed both these amendments tabled by the Right Reverend Prelate, the Bishop of Norwich, which I believe because I believe they identified two important gaps in the law. Section 90 of the Police Act 1996 creates the offence of impersonating a member of a police force or special constable. The Act is concerned with civilian police forces in England and Wales established under the Police Act of 1996 and related legislation. The definition of special constable is limited to one appoint- one appointed for a police area. Members of the service police forces are not members of a territorial police force and are not special constables.

They are members of the- of the service police under the Armed Forces Act 2006. As a result, a person pretending to be a service police officer would not obviously fall within the wording members of a police force or special constable in section 90. I believe this is clearly an omission and that it needs to be rectified. With regard to section- to amendment 60, I believe I'm correct in saying that the definition in section 3 of the Assaults on Emergency Workers Act 2018 could include service police officers. Subsection 1b states that a person other than a constable who has the powers of a constable or is otherwise employed for police purposes or is engaged to provide services for police purposes is included within that definition.

Service police officers are clearly engaged to provide services for police purposes. It might be useful for the noble lord the minister to confirm whether that is the government's position. However, more importantly, that Act only applies to England and Wales, not to Scotland and Northern Ireland. Scotland does have a corresponding law, the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Act 2005, which creates specific offences of assaulting, obstructing or hindering emergency workers and those assisting them. The protected categories include constables, fire and ambulance personnel and in circumstances prison officers, coastguard personnel, RNLI crews, social workers executing child protection orders and mental health officers.

My Lords, like the English and Welsh equivalent, the Scottish Act does not expressly mention service police officers. However, service police can sometimes be treated as constables when exercising powers concern- conferred by service law or civilian legislation. Whether the 2005 Act applies to a particular service police officer would depend on the precise capacity in which were- they were acting at the time. Thus the position regarding police- service police isn't clear. Northern Ireland does not have a direct equivalent of the Assaults on Emergency Workers Offences Act 2018 that creates a single overarching emergency workers assault offence.

Instead it has a mixture of general assault offences and occupation-specific offences.

I think this requires some thought from the government and I would welcome an opinion on these matters from the noble lord the minister.

08:59:54 - 09:01:11

Vernon Coaker

Well first of all can I thank the Earl of Minto but can I particularly thank the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Norwich. As he knows I've spoken to him outside of the chamber and had a number of conversations with him about this. I have asked my officials to look at both his amendment 59 with respect to the impersonation of a member of the service police. I've also asked for us to look at amendment 60 which is adding service police to the list of emergency workers regarding assault. And I will take those forward.

I just to be clear I cannot absolutely promise the outcome but I do personally think there is a problem with respect to these two issues. And I look forward to continuing the discussion with him to see whether we can come forward with something at report to plug what do appear on the face of it to be two gaps within the legislation within our country and other parts of it as well.

09:01:11 - 09:02:23

Graham Usher

My lords I'm very grateful for speakers to Baroness Smith for her brevity at this late hour where many of us want to be tucked up in bed. But it was worth staying up to hear the noble Earl Lord Minto's analysis and that was particularly helpful around the different jurisdictions around these islands and particularly the potential for amending the laws in Scotland and Northern Ireland. But I'm immensely grateful to the minister for all his hard work on this bill but also for giving the commitment that he has to your lordship's house to look at this in further detail. My understanding is that the service protection authority have given legal advice that they do not believe that service police fall under the definition of emergency workers. So I think that's all part of the conversation to go on as this bill progresses towards report stage.

So I am most grateful. I therefore beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

09:02:23 - 09:06:51

Julie Smith

Amendment be withdrawn. The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 60 the Lord Bishop of Norwich not moved. Amendment 61 Baroness Smith.

My lords I rise to move the first three amendments in my name which are in group 12 amendments 61, 62 and 63. I am not going to do them justice at this time of night because the first amendment is calling for an independent review of armed forces recruitment and retention. And in order to do that justice I really would need to rehearse the difficulties that we've seen in armed forces recruitment. Capita was mentioned earlier on in proceedings today. Issues of retention have also been raised.

Given the lateness of the hour and the hope that noble lords and indeed Hansard, doorkeepers and everybody else will have and officials in the box actually to get home at some point in the wee small hours. What I would like to do is express the view that it is important for his majesty's government to have an independent review of recruitment and retention in particular because we hear at each time there is an SDR that we need to look at the size of our armed forces. We need to look at the size of the reserves. And yet there is very little clarity on the recruitment process and on retention.

We've heard proposals this evening from the noble lady Baroness Penn about increasing paternity leave entitlement precisely as a way of enhancing retention. But my Lords, we need clarity, the country needs clarity on recruitment and retention, and as Parliament we need to be able to scrutinize the current provisions and perhaps give suggestions to His Majesty's Government about ways in which we could be improving the system. So my Lords, I would like to raise that issue. I'm not going to go into any further detail this evening. Amendment 62 is one that I hope will be seen as uncontroversial, even by somebody sitting where the noble Lord the Minister is.

Obviously it's an amendment, but it's suggesting a duty to provide medical records on discharge. My Lords, that is simply to ensure that anyone leaving the services is able to go straight away, register with their GP, and in particular if there are issues that they have perhaps retired, there's a medical discharge, but even not a medical discharge, somebody might be at risk of PTSD undiagnosed. Having those medical records is going to be crucial for the individuals, and it seems to be only right that their record should be provided as soon as is practicable. And finally my Lords, an amendment that ought to be self-evident, but I realize it may be that the noble Lord the Minister feels that it's not one purely for the MOD, it's perhaps more a DWP matter. But the amendment 63 suggests the insertion of a clause, personal independence payment assessment exemption for amputees.

And the logic behind that is that it seems very odd to keep requiring PIP assessments and reassessments when if somebody has had a limb amputated, that's not going to change between assessments. It may be that robotics or other medical innovations change somebody's capacity to work, but given that we're talking about somebody who may have been, have had a limb amputated as a result of their service, then relieving them of PIP reassessments would appear to be an appropriate way of acknowledging the reasons why they've lost the limb and ensuring that we don't put them through unnecessary repeat medical or assessments.

09:06:51 - 09:07:01

Ilora Finlay

Amendment proposed, after clause 50, insert the following new clause, independent review of armed forces recruitment and retention as printed on the marshalled list.

09:07:01 - 09:07:32

Rupert Ponsonby

My Lords, I want to support the noble lady Baroness Smith's amendment 61 requiring there to be an independent review of armed forces recruitment and retention. At this late hour, let me just say that at a time when there are nearly a million young people not in any of education, employment or training, we can't even recruit 10,000 a year, and our armed forces are well below the relatively tiny strength at which they're funded to be.

This suggests that something is seriously wrong with their recruiting process, and this report needs to be done.

09:07:32 - 09:08:33

Sal Sarah Brinton

I'll speak to amendment 62 very, very briefly and just say my noble friend raised the point about it being important for veterans to be able to have their details in their hands. The NHS guidance for veterans specifically notes that it takes several months for the full records to follow the veterans. And if veterans have complex health issues without the information, then the GPs that they see are in deep trouble. And on the point about the amputees, there's a really important point in that unlike many amputees in the civilian world, most people in the military world who have amputations have also got a significant amount of other injuries as well. And it's already an issue about amputees in the civilian world having to have repeat PIP tests, but it seems to me that it would be sensible to look at this particular area.

09:08:33 - 09:09:45

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

Very briefly, my Lords. The noble Baroness Lady Smith of Newnham has raised some very important issues in these amendments. Between 1999 and 2025, there were only seven years in which more people joined the regular forces than left them. And the Strategic Defence Review was blunt enough to call the result a workforce crisis. I might add one further point on retention.

Retention in the armed forces will not be improved by prosecuting veterans who served in Northern Ireland fighting the IRA. My noble friend Lady Goldie has already mentioned the adverse impact that government policy is having. Retention will also surely be improved in delivering the investment in the forces' housing that the government has promised. Two actions the government could take immediately to improve retention and recruitment: drop this widely despised Troubles Bill and deliver the housing investment now, rather than pushing the funding further back as they've done in the Defence Investment Plan. I completely concur with Baroness Brinton about what she said about the medical records, and I think that that also needs tidying up really pretty quickly and would definitely help.

And I look forward to hearing the noble Lord's responses.

09:09:45 - 09:10:49

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, let me just say this. None of us are going to do justice to the amendments that the noble Baroness has brought forward. She made a couple of important points, as did Baroness Brinton, as did Lord de Mauley, and some of what the Earl of Minto has said was something to which I would need to respond in a positive way, others perhaps not. But let me just say this. I think the important thing is that to do it justice, I think I need to write a letter which looks at retention, looks at some of the issues that have been raised, looks at the transfer of health records and the PIP point that was made.

They are important points, and for me just to say two sentences on this and two sentences on that is inadequate. So with the Committee's permission, I'll write a letter, copy it to members of the Committee, and place a copy in the library. And I hope if with that reassurance that the Committee will see fit to withdraw the amendment.

09:10:49 - 09:11:08

Julie Smith

I'm grateful to all noble Lords who've contributed, and particularly to the noble Lord de Mauley for co-signing amendment 61 and to my noble friend Baroness Brinton. We look forward to the letter from the noble Lord the Minister, and with that, I beg leave to withdraw.

09:11:08 - 09:11:25

Ilora Finlay

Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 62, Baroness Smith of Newnham, not moved, and 63, not moved.

Amendment 64, Baroness Smith of Newnham.

09:11:25 - 09:14:42

Julie Smith

My Lords, this very small group, unfortunately numbered group 13, is about the defense investment plan. And in particular, it felt appropriate to bring forward amendments that had been laid in the other place by my honorable friends. I think it was James McLeary who tabled them. Essentially to suggest that Parliament has an interest in ensuring that we hold His Majesty's government accountable on the defense investment plan. And in particular, I noted in his response to the noble lady Baroness Penn earlier on, the noble lord the minister said continued challenges are important.

So I would like to suggest that amendment 64 is by way of a continued challenge, that it would be beneficial to His Majesty's armed forces and to the country to have a report on the defense investment plan. And clearly, it's not something where one needs the noble lord the minister to respond in any detail today because we're calling for it six months after this act has been implemented or passed. So the key thing is that the defense investment plan took a long time. It is still unclear whether the funding is going to be forthcoming and so accountability and scrutiny seem to be appropriate. And the final amendment, 65, a report on the impact of the defense investment plan delays.

My Lords, the suggestion here is, or the request is, that we have a report within six months of the act being passed. And again, this is very much about accountability. My Lords, the defense investment plan was hugely important. It was also significantly delayed. And even for the primes, the delays have been significant.

But for the smaller defense companies, particularly dual-use companies, there are significant questions of the impact about the impact of the delays. And therefore we've specified quite clearly what we would want to see in a report. I don't think I need to go into any more detail other than to ask the noble lord the minister if the government might indeed provide the reports, particularly the annual reports requested in amendment 64 because earlier on the noble lord Lord Coaker did point out in another part of the bill there is no greater accountability than an annual report to Parliament. Please may we have one? I beg to move.

09:14:42 - 09:14:53

Ilora Finlay

Clause 50, insert the following new clause, reporting on the defense investment plan as printed on the marshaled list.

09:14:53 - 09:15:41

Gilbert Elliot-Murray-Kynynmound

My Lords, the noble Baroness Lady Smith of Newnham once again is highlighting issues that we've spent a significant amount of time debating in your Lordships' House. The glaring hole in the in the funding of the DIP just has to be addressed. The funding issues have not yet been resolved. Can the noble lord the minister please confirm that his former boss, now the Chancellor, will find the necessary funds to fill that that in the budgetary budgetary hole in the upcoming budget? Furthermore, we've also recently heard that the government will not set out the plan to 2.5% of the GDP on defense spending until the spending review next year.

So another six months of preparation lost, another six months of of stasis. It's not acceptable, my Lords, and I hope that the government rethinks.

09:15:41 - 09:18:36

Vernon Coaker

Well, let me just finish with an upbeat message of the fact that I have never felt that I have been lacking scrutiny on the defense investment plan or lacking scrutiny on accountability with respect to defense spending.

I've answered numerous questions from Baroness Smith, from Baroness Goldie, from the Earl of Minto. I have not felt in any way that there's been a lack of scrutiny at all. And that's as it should be. So I'm perfectly happy to stand here and that. The amendments are completely unnecessary in terms of holding me to account, of holding the government to account.

Baroness Smith, Baroness Goldie, Earl Minto and most members of this House find it extraordinarily easy to bring me to this dispatch box to tell me how bad the government is and me to say how much I am working hard to ensure that we deliver the defense this country needs. So completely unnecessary these amendments, absolutely no need for them at all. So that's my answer to at this late hour to that particular amendment. On the couple of serious points to make, the annual report, we have committed in the DIP to an annual update to Parliament before summer recess each year on progress against the DIP and any changes in financial investments. So the first one that the noble Baroness Baroness Smith asked will be audited by the National Audit Office.

The first will be published by July 2027. Can I just say to the noble Earl Minto, because I've got a fresh burst of energy now, that if the if unlike when we were talking about the establishment of the National Reserves and Reserves Forces and Cadet Association and we didn't the noble Earl didn't take too much notice of what the National Audit Office says because it didn't fit his argument. I bet if the National Audit Office come forward and say that the government's defense investment plan is not going according to plan and it's an outrage what the government I bet the noble Lord quotes at length the National Audit Office report. But there we go, that's the nature of politics, I understand that and so on. But the first, going to Baroness Smith, July 27 will be the first the first annual reports.

And on the final point to make, the Chancellor will lay out how the 4.7 billion will be found with in the autumn budget around the DIP. He'll have heard the Chancellor also say that the further plans will be set out in the spending review of 2027. Can I also just finish with this? I don't know why it's a surprise to everyone in this House that that was said because I've stood at this dispatch box and said exactly the same thing, if you check Hansard, on a number of different occasions in answer to the noble Baroness Baroness Goldie. So with that, can I say I hope the noble Baroness sees fit to withdraw her amendments.

If not, bring them forward at report and let's have another debate on defense spending.

09:18:36 - 09:19:16

Julie Smith

My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Earl Lord Minto for his support really for challenging His Majesty's government. And I'm grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for his ever-ready presence to respond at the dispatch box. We may well come back to questions of the impact of DIP delays, particularly in terms of supply chains, because there are some very significant issues. But whether they are appropriate for an amendment to this particular bill, I think is another question. But with that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

09:19:16 - 09:20:49

Ilora Finlay

Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn.

Amendment 65, Baroness Smith of Newnham, not moved. Amendment 66, Baroness Penn, not moved. Amendment 67, Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, not moved. The question is that clauses 51 to 54 stand part of the bill en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

The contrary not content. The contents have it. In clause 55, amendment 68, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 69 and 70, Lord Harlech, not moved. The question is that clause 55 stand part of the bill.

As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. The question is that clause 56 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

The contrary not content. The contents have it. The question is that this be the title of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.

The contents have it. My Lords, that concludes the committee's proceedings of the bill. The house will now resume. My Lords, the committee of the whole house to which the Armed Forces Bill was committed has gone through the same and has directed me to report it to your Lordships with amendment. My Lords, I beg to move that the house do now adjourn.

That the house do now adjourn.