House of Commons

9 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:24 - 00:51
Speaker 11
Again, I note that a greater than unusual number of questions to the Minister for Women and Equalities have been transferred to other departments.  Transfers are of course a matter for the Minister, but I would gently urge the Minister to clarify any changes in cross-departmental responsibilities and to always ensure that members affected by any transfers are properly notified.  Order.  We start with questions, Minister for Women and Equalities, Dame Meg Hillier. 
00:51 - 00:54
Speaker 3
Number one, Mr. Speaker. 
00:54 - 01:19
Speaker 7
Mr. Speaker, covert filming using smart glasses can raise serious privacy concerns, and it's important that we spread awareness that criminal offences such as voyeurism already cover their most harmful uses.  Platforms which host images or videos captured by smart glasses may also have duties to remove them under online safety or data protection legislation, and they should take those responsibilities extremely seriously. 
01:19 - 01:48
Speaker 18
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  I'm pleased at my right honourable friend's answer, but she is in a unique position across government to make sure that not only are we protecting women, but also those people with visual impairments and who are blind who really value this technology.  So can she make sure that across government, when if regulation is being talked about, it's about the person using, misusing it, rather than the adaptive technology itself, which can be so much use to so many people. 
01:48 - 02:07
Speaker 6
My right honourable friend is right to raise the issue of the potential benefits in this area as well as the risks and potential misuse that we sadly have seen.  And I'd be more than happy to make sure that she has a meeting with the Minister at DCMS to discuss this further, but I would of course be happy to discuss it with her myself as well. 
02:07 - 02:34
Speaker 12
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  The privacy of a woman is a non-negotiable topic, and I would hope the Minister would agree with me that we need to carefully monitor technological advancements to ensure that there are appropriate safeguards in place.  In particular, with regard to AI tools being used to undress women and children without consent.  What steps is the Minister taking to ensure that, ensure the continued protection of women and children? 
02:34 - 03:01
Speaker 6
Mr. Speaker, I do agree with the honourable lady, and she will know that we have already taken action in this area to make sure that the law is strong and firm.  But of course there is always a question of enforcement running alongside that, and as technology adapts and changes very rapidly, it is of course the responsibility of this government to make sure that the law keeps pace with that change, and of course that women are protected from the potential misuse of technology that can be an amazing force for good, but in the wrong hands can cause serious harm. 
03:01 - 03:04
Speaker 1
Number two, Mr. Speaker. 
03:04 - 03:25
Speaker 6
Mr. Speaker, this government will ensure that we protect and promote our values, build more confident, cohesive and resilient communities.  And I'm working with colleagues across government to deliver our initial plan, protecting what matters, to uphold the UK's social fabric and to give communities the tools that they need to shape their own future. 
03:25 - 03:36
Speaker 5
This government will always seek to bring people together, not to divide our communities. 

03:36 - 04:05

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank my right honorable friend for her answer. Will my right honorable friend join me in welcoming Lancashire County Councillor Nigel Swales from my constituency to the Labour Party? Councillor Swales has defected to Labour from Reform because he knows they won't deliver. And we saw at their party conference last week men literally beating young women on conference floor and spokespeople stirring up hatred.

Does the Minister agree that Reform can't be trusted to protect social cohesion?

04:05 - 04:50

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, I do welcome the growing number of people who are recognizing that Reform simply don't have the answers to the challenges our country faces and are inspired by this Labour government's message of hope and optimism. Mr. Speaker, there can be no place for violence or intimidation of women, whether that's on the Reform conference floor or anywhere else. And I would say to this House, Mr. Speaker, this is not a laughing matter. And those in Reform in recent days who have sought to make light of such serious scenes should reflect very seriously on why they think it is appropriate at one level to say that violence against women is acceptable, I agree, but then at another allow it to take place at their own conference.

04:50 - 05:32

Christine Jardine

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In June of this year, an individual went on an anti-Muslim rampage at sites in Edinburgh. And since then, we've seen a surge in incidents, individuals using Nazi salutes at protests. When I spoke to the representatives of one of the mosques involved in the incidents, they said that they fear there's been a catastrophic collapse in community cohesion in parts of the country. So can the Minister tell me what the government is doing?

And does she agree with me that this is not a local problem just for local authorities or regional authorities to deal with? We have to deal with it on a national scale.

05:32 - 06:18

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, the honorable lady is right. We must tackle prejudice, racism, and intolerance in all its forms. And I know that many of our Muslim communities have experienced unacceptable hatred and intimidation simply because they wish to go about their lives, practicing their religion and belief as is at the cornerstone of everything that we as a nation should believe in, the ability to worship, to practice your religion, and to express those views peacefully. And whatever form that racism takes, we will challenge it. It is why we as a government have been very clear that tackling anti-Muslim hostility is essential alongside tackling the appalling antisemitism we have also seen, alongside making sure that all of our communities are vibrant, cohesive places in keeping with the best of our traditions.

06:18 - 06:44

Stephen Timms

Mr. Speaker, the Equality Act places a duty on public bodies to make reasonable adjustments so that disabled people are not put at a disadvantage by accessibility challenges. Public service providers have to test provision regularly against the service standards, and departments have to publish accessibility standards and provide feedback routes for users.

06:44 - 07:06

Clive Jones

Speaker, I have constituents whose agreed adjustments have been removed, appointments arranged by telephone despite hearing impediments, and assessment sites lacking disabled parking. Does the Minister agree adjustments must be applied consistently by government departments and contractors, and what action will they take when they are not?

07:06 - 07:54

Stephen Timms

Well, Mr. Speaker, I do agree with him. And if he'd like to send me details of that particular case, I'll happily look into that. For people with a hearing impairment, my right honorable friend and I will be meeting the British Sign Language Advisory Board this afternoon. But the broader accessibility challenges, it's very important that we meet and deliver on the communications needs, deliver on the reasonable adjustments that people have. If people are applying to the DWP, they can be notified at any stage, those adjustments can be notified at any stage of their claim, they'll be noted on the claimant's record, so they should then be consistently addressed when that individual is in touch.

07:54 - 08:18

Anneliese Dodds

Good morning Mr. Speaker on the 25th of June the government published its draft conversion practices bill for pre-legislative scrutiny parliament is in the process of appointing the joint committee which will review the draft provisions. I understand that the committee aims to report by the 22nd of January and I look forward to working with all members of the committee on this important legislation to ensure a ban is effective in targeting these abusive and harmful practices.

08:18 - 08:19

Tom Gordon.

08:19 - 08:56

Thomas Gordon

Thank you Mr. Speaker I welcome the steps the minister has outlined there under the conservative government we saw multiple attempts at bringing forward a bill but one never made it through over successive government cycles. So I hope that the minister will learn learn from their lessons and bring one forward that is properly trans-inclusive too. The bill talks about abusive conversion practices which risks implying non-abusive forms exist leading to a potential loophole. I wonder if the minister might be able to outline what steps and conversations are we having to make sure that people can't be pushed through these other alternative loopholes.

08:56 - 09:10

Anneliese Dodds

So let me be clear this government is committed to protecting the dignity and safety of trans people. That is why we're introducing a full trans-inclusive ban on conversion practices as per our manifesto and I would be delighted to meet with the honorable gentleman to discuss his his further queries in person.

09:10 - 09:11

Christopher Vince.

09:11 - 09:13

Christopher John Vince

Thank you Mr. Speaker number five.

09:13 - 09:14

Secretary of State.

09:14 - 09:35

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker I'm continuing to work with cabinet colleagues to drive forward ambitious action to tackle child poverty. I'm proud that decisions that this Labour government has taken will see over half a million children lifted out of poverty the biggest reduction in any parliament. We know however that our work is not done and we'll continue to drive action to cut the cost of living and raise families' incomes.

09:35 - 09:36

Chris Vince.

09:36 - 10:12

Christopher John Vince

Thank you Mr. Speaker across my constituency of Harlow 18% of children live in poverty which rises to 30% in areas such as Mark Hall and Netteswell. Around 12% of children in Harlow will benefit from the Labour's lifting of the two-child cap something that parents and myself really welcome. But children child poverty still remains deeply uneven across Harlow and also across the UK and too often children's chance in life are shaped by where they grow up. What further steps is the minister taking to to tackle these regional and local disparities to ensure that children growing up in our most deprived communities benefit from the government's drive to reduce poverty.

10:12 - 10:39

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker I know my honorable friend will always stand up for children and families across Harlow and he's right to say that we must go further to bed down on many of the drivers of child poverty such as housing costs parental employment which require long-term structural change right across society and government. I am proud that we have delivered alongside the two-child limit a huge expansion in free school meals and new breakfast clubs opening from this term.

10:39 - 10:40

Alex Easton.

10:40 - 11:00

Alex Easton

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Isn't it a critical step for government to guarantee access in every region of the UK to affordable high-quality childcare by expanding funded childcare provision and reducing costs for younger children so that parents can work more hours without losing most of their additional income to childcare fees.

11:00 - 11:16

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker access to childcare right across our communities is absolutely essential it's why this Labour government in England has massively expanded access to childcare whilst recognising the differences that exist in Northern Ireland I'm sure ministers would be happy to discuss further any ideas he has.

11:16 - 11:17

Lee Dillon.

11:17 - 11:18

Mr. Speaker question six please.

11:18 - 11:19

Minister.

11:19 - 11:47

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Thank you Mr. Speaker with your permission I will answer questions six seven nine and ten together.

We are driving action across government to deliver our landmark commitment to halve violence against women and girls in a decade. This includes the national rollout of our life-changing domestic abuse protection orders across England and Wales, setting up pilots in schools to tackle harmful behaviors, and delivering a flagship GP referral program in England to better support victims.

11:47 - 12:12

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given the well-established links between domestic abuse, coercive control and suicide, and tomorrow being World Suicide Day, does the Minister agree that organizations like Project Salama in my constituency that provides joined-up support to victims of DA are important? And can the Minister explain how the government is going to ensure domestic abuse services, mental health services and the suicide prevention strategy work together?

12:12 - 12:39

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Can I thank the honorable gentleman for raising this vitally important point? And my thoughts are with everyone tomorrow recognizing the day. He is right to raise this. It's why the Law Commissioner are also looking at this regarding the links between suicide and domestic abuse. We are working with the Chief Coroner's Office as well to formally establish that pathway there, and brilliant organizations like the one he mentions in his own constituency who are supporting families and individuals bereaved as a result of this.

12:39 - 13:22

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the government's accelerated rollout of specialist police rape and sexual offense teams. Will the Minister consider what more help can be done upstream through relationships and sex education so young people know where to seek help after sexual assault? Willow Tree Sexual Assault Referral Centre, which is in my right honorable friend's constituency of Wolverhampton South East, provides specialist support and enables young people in Wolverhampton and Willenhall to self-refer. Will she work with police, schools and sexual assault referral centers to ensure young people know that this support is available?

13:22 - 13:54

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Absolutely, and I thank my honorable friend for raising this. Prevention is at the heart of our flagship strategy to tackle violence against women and girls. It's why we are working on healthy relationship guidance so that all children can understand where to get help and what is a healthy and important relationship in their lives. Secondary pupils will be given that information on where to report abuse, where to seek medical attention when required. And just yesterday, I got to witness this in person at CARA in Colchester, a fantastic organization helping young people rebuild their lives following sexual violence.

13:54 - 14:14

Speaker 35

Mr. Speaker, more than a hundred organizations have warned the government that their early release scheme is going to put women and girls at increased risk. So perhaps the Minister could explain to the House and those organizations how that scheme is going to help her halve violence against women and girls.

14:14 - 15:01

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

The honorable gentleman welcomes the, mentions the early release scheme. This is something that we have had to put in place in order to ensure that our criminal justice system is able to function to help all victims, regardless of the crime type. I regularly meet with all the organizations that are mentioned in this letter to discuss what best protections we can put in place. He will know that we have increased funding to support victim support services. There will be a presumption on tagging on release, and we are introducing world-first restriction zones to ensure that victims no longer have to constantly look over their shoulders wondering where their perpetrator is.

We're also working on timely communication to ensure that we keep victims and survivors informed as to the information and they can feed in directly to licensing conditions. But I will happily discuss this with him further if he wishes.

15:01 - 15:34

Steve Witherden

Number 10, please, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the 30th of June this year, the then Secretary of State for Justice made a very welcome and vital commitment in this chamber to close the 10-year sentencing gap, ensuring that domestic homicides are treated with the same severity as other murders.

Does the Minister agree that we must hear the same commitment from the current Secretary of State and see a clear timetable for implementation so that we can achieve our goal of halving violence against women and girls?

15:34 - 16:02

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

I am happy to reiterate that commitment at the dispatch box today, Mr Speaker. I pay tribute to the Killed Women campaign who have long hard fought to secure this change. We will introduce a new 25-year starting point for domestic murders to apply to anyone who murders their current or former intimate partner, and we will bring forward this change as soon as parliamentary time allows.

16:02 - 16:19

Kemi Badenoch

To tackle violence against women and girls, does the right honourable lady agree with me that men entering this country illegally from countries such as Eritrea, Afghanistan and Sudan pose a direct threat to the safety of British women and girls?

16:19 - 16:48

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Mr Speaker, can I welcome the right honourable lady to her place and I look forward to working with her on tackling violence against women and girls, which should not be party political, it not should have any borders. The issue includes us all to tackle, which is the answer here. This our strategy, our flagship strategy on tackling violence against women and girls is to tackle all forms of violence against women and girls wherever it occurs by whoever it does it.

16:48 - 17:07

Kemi Badenoch

Thank you. And I know that my honourable friend is a wonderful champion for women, but does the right but does the Minister agree with me that men who enter Britain illegally and need a leaflet to ask them not to rape women and girls should instead be deported immediately?

17:07 - 17:36

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Under this government, foreign deportations of those who commit crimes in this country are up. They are up significantly because it is this government that is taking that action directly. What I would say to the honourable lady is that anyone who commits crimes against women and girls should seek the full force of the law and would will be facing the full force of the law, and we are seeking to educate everyone on what is acceptable in our country regard because that is our British values.

17:36 - 18:14

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker, last month BBC News reported on a woman who only discovered that the man she was in a relationship with was a registered sex offender by fluke after he was summoned to court over an assault charge under a different name. While the law allows police to block a sex offender's request to change their name, it does not require them to. Women, campaigners and safeguarding groups all say this is not good enough. Will the Minister work with Home Office colleagues to close this loophole so that sex offenders are prevented from changing their name by default and police are required to individually approve each request?

18:14 - 18:38

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Well, I thank the Liberal Democrat spokesperson for raising this. She will know that great strides have been made including by my good friend the honourable member for Rotherham regarding this campaign. I will happily meet with her to discuss this further to see what more we need to do to protect women and girls and all children from these heinous crimes.

18:38 - 19:07

Stephen Timms

Mr Speaker, autistic people, people with ADHD have been struggling to get the right support at the right time. Recommendations from Professor Karen Goldberg's neurodivergence task and finish group directly informed the SEND reforms published earlier this year. We want schools and others supporting young people to understand neurodivergent behaviours clearly, including how they differ for boys and for girls so that needs can be identified early and properly met.

19:07 - 19:44

Kim Leadbeater

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank the Minister for his reply. However, people in Broxtowe and across the country widely are concerned that dyslexia in women and girls is identified later than in boys. Too often a lack of understanding of how dyslexia presents in girls means that they are three times more likely to miss out on diagnosis, and this creates barriers to support in education and later life.

So what action has the Minister taken across government to close the gap of diagnosis and improve the outcomes for dyslexic women and girls in education, health, employment, and the criminal justice system?

19:44 - 20:19

Stephen Timms

Well, Mr. Speaker, better outcomes do require early identification and support for girls and young women with special educational needs, including dyslexia. That is the aim of the SEND reforms, the development of national inclusion standards. We're going to be supporting education providers to identify and respond to needs earlier and more consistently, drawing on a broader range of evidence and expertise so that girls and young women can receive the support they need in good time to achieve and to thrive.

20:19 - 20:22

Lindsay Hoyle

Harriett Baldwin, topical.

20:22 - 20:24

Harriett Mary Morison Baldwin

Number one.

20:24 - 21:05

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, I'm proud to be standing here as the first ever standalone Cabinet Minister for Women and Equalities. And at the heart of this government's ambition is to bring hope back to communities. It is the promise that whatever your background, wherever you're from, ours is a country where you will be able to get on, to follow your dreams, and to succeed in life. Today I'm therefore announcing a new class unit in government to deliver on that promise. We've been squeamish about class for too long, yet we know it is a deep barrier to opportunity.

The work of the Social Mobility Commission will be brought into the heart of government as we get Britain believing once again.

21:05 - 21:06

Harriett Baldwin.

21:06 - 21:26

Perran Moon

Moras Hamit-Darma, Mr. Speaker, conversion practices are a form of abuse and this government was elected on a manifesto commitment to ban them. So whilst I welcome the draft, the publication of the draft bill in June and the Minister's commitment to the committee by the end of January, can the Secretary of State appreciate the frustration of many that the process to ban this abuse is taking so long?

21:26 - 21:55

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, as my honorable friend the Minister set out just earlier, this government has published its draft conversion practices ban for pre-legislative scrutiny. We did so in June. We'll shortly confirm the joint members of that committee. It is an incredibly important piece of legislation and a safeguard for LGBT people. I look forward to working with all members of this House on this important legislation to ensure that a ban is effective in targeting what are abusive and harmful practices and have no place in modern Britain.

21:55 - 21:58

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir James Morris.

21:58 - 22:17

Kemi Badenoch

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Following last night's vote on puberty blockers, will the right honorable lady set out exactly what her red lines are when it comes to experimenting on children and what age she thinks children are able to make life-changing decisions about their gender?

22:17 - 23:08

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, can I begin by welcoming the honorable lady to her place and say that I wish her predecessor, the right honorable member for East Surrey, all of our best wishes as she heads off to welcome her new baby into the world. I wish her all the very best, I'm sure we all do. Mr. Speaker, on this important issue, it is essential that healthcare available to children and young people is safe, evidence-based, and clinically appropriate. It is why Dr. Hilary Cass has looked seriously and in detail at this issue. She concluded that not enough was known about the safety and efficacy of puberty-suppressing hormones.

It's why therefore a trial is taking place. It's why, Mr. Speaker, we accepted the recommendations of Dr. Cass. We will always put the safety and wellbeing of children first in line with her recommendations.

23:08 - 23:10

Lindsay Hoyle

Ashley Dalton.

23:10 - 23:45

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. People from ethnic minority backgrounds, disabled people, and old people are more at risk of being coerced into an assisted death, a feeling of burden or feeling pressured to end their lives. This is the findings of the government's own equality impact assessment on the Terminally Ill Adults End of Life Bill that comes to this House on Friday.

In the event of the bill being passed, what steps will the minister take to ensure that these risks to people with protected characteristics will be mitigated?

23:45 - 24:16

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend will know that the government is neutral on the matter of assisted dying and the passage of the bill. We've therefore not developed a detailed implementation bill and if the bill were to pass, we would engage with all relevant people and all partners to ensure safe and effective implementation. She references the equality impact assessment, members are able to read that for themselves. I'm sure my honorable friend will seek to make the points that she has made today as we discuss these matters further on Friday.

24:16 - 24:17

Ollie Glover.

24:17 - 24:46

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the minister for her earlier answer about Meta smart glasses? She's right to acknowledge that this technology can provide benefits to people with disabilities, but also is being used for covert recording of women. So can I push her a bit further, what further discussions with other departments can she commit to to ensure that tech company products advance rather than undermine equalities and human rights?

24:46 - 25:12

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, there are potential benefits that come of the use of this kind of technology, but we know that there are also significant risks. It's why we will continue to keep the law under review in this area to make sure that it's effective and fit for use. But alongside that, tech companies also have a responsibility to make sure that they are taking down inappropriate material and that prosecutions follow in cases such as voyeurism, where we are clear glasses should not be used.

25:12 - 25:44

Alison Louise Hume

Mr. Speaker, ahead of World Suicide Prevention Day, it's important we recognize the heightened risk of suicide amongst autistic women and girls who are too often overlooked and diagnosed too late. Autistic people are three times more likely to attempt or die by suicide than non-autistic people. Will the Secretary of State set out what action the government is taking to reduce suicide amongst women and girls with autism?

25:44 - 26:14

Bridget Phillipson

Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend raises an extremely important point ahead of World Suicide Prevention Day. One life lost to suicide is one life too many and all of us across this house have a responsibility to make sure that people know there is always support available, there is always someone to talk to, there is always help that is there. My honorable friend raises the question around neurodiversity and autism, I'd be happy to discuss that further with her as we bring forward an updated anti-suicide prevention plan.

26:14 - 26:34

Lindsay Hoyle

Bill Trough. Can I welcome the President and Secretary General of the Inter-Parliamentary Union who are in the gallery today? We now come to questions to the Prime Minister, which start with Lillian Jones.

26:34 - 26:36

Lillian Jones

Question number one, Mr. Speaker.

26:36 - 27:54

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, on Friday, we will mark the 25th anniversary of 9/11, a moment to remember the nearly 3,000 people who died, including 67 British citizens. There will be a ceremonial changing of the guard and events across the country. Our thoughts will remain on Friday with the loved ones of all we lost. Mr. Speaker, I also want to send our sympathies to the hundreds of people who will gather today at the funeral of PC Matthew Blades, including many serving police officers, and we send our thanks to them all for their service and their work to keep our communities safe. And on Back British Farming Day, as we can see, Mr. Speaker, I know the whole house will join me in paying tribute to everyone working around the clock to feed our country.

Food security is national security and we will continue to back British farming as a government. Mr. Speaker, this morning, I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others.

In addition to my duties in this House, I shall have further such meetings later today.

27:54 - 28:48

Lillian Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I associate myself with the comments on 9/11 and our brave policeman, the police officer that lost his life. Mr. Speaker, my hometown of Kilmarnock was once the industrial powerhouse of Ayrshire, but after decades of decline and deindustrialization, it's never fully recovered. So I welcome the Prime Minister's determination and focus to revive our high streets, and I extend a warm invitation to the Prime Minister anytime. Mr. Speaker, hope has been rekindled in Kilmarnock thanks to this government's 20 million pound pride in place investment.

The first Kilmarnock town center master plan created in over 50 years, led by the community, setting an achievable vision for a successful future, and we want to build on that momentum. Will the Prime Minister champion a new partnership between Kilmarnock, my hometown, Manchester, and London?

28:48 - 28:53

Lindsay Hoyle

Order. I think the Prime Minister's got a grip of the first three questions. Prime Minister.

28:53 - 29:22

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, well, it does my heart good to hear my honorable friend talk about rising hope in Kilmarnock and the master plan for the town that she mentioned, backed by the government with the pride in place funding. And yes, I can assure her, Number 10 North is as much at the service of her constituents as it is at the service of any constituent in this House, and we will turn what's happening in Kilmarnock into real momentum for the town.

29:22 - 29:27

Lindsay Hoyle

Come to Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch.

29:27 - 30:06

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, after last week's session, the country was thrown into confusion over whether the Prime Minister was or was not going to fund 3% for defense by 2030. After today, he'll have another five weeks off PMQs, but there are some serious threats to national security that cannot wait. His Chancellor resigned as Defense Secretary because the Labour government would not increase defense spending to 3% by 2030. Does the Prime Minister think he was right to quit?

30:06 - 31:05

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, as I said last week, I appointed this Chancellor because of his strong commitment to the defense of this nation. That was the reason why. And we will honor our NATO commitment, 3.5% by 2035, and a target date for 3, and that will all be set out in the spending review, Mr. Speaker. I don't feel, though, that you get the right to come to this House and claim the moral high ground and point fingers wherever you can when defense spending was 2.3% of GDP and fell during 14 years of a Conservative government. On this issue, I think we should do more problem-solving than point-scoring, and I say to the right honorable lady, we would do our armed forces well if we could agree on this crucial issue more across the floor of this House.

31:05 - 32:24

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister wants to talk about the past on defense spending, so let me refresh his memory and the House. I remember when he was Shadow Home Secretary, when the Labour leader wanted us to leave NATO, disarm our nuclear deterrent, and defund the army, so I will not be taking any lectures from him. He says, he says the target is 2030, is 2035.

2035 is a decade away. If he can't get to 3% by 2030, why should we believe he'll get to 3.5% by 2035? The spending review is next year. Last week I set out how we would get to 3% by 2030. The threats are now.

Argentina is threatening the Falklands now. Russia is threatening us in the North Sea now. And Mr. Speaker, he didn't answer my question. He didn't answer my question. The Chancellor was right to quit.

I asked him if he was right to quit, the Chancellor was right to quit, which is why it's so wrong that he's not sticking to his principles. The Chancellor used to say not hitting 3% by 2030 would put our troops at risk. He also said Keir Starmer was unable and the Treasury unwilling to provide that funding. So is the Prime Minister unable or is he just unwilling to get that money by 2030?

32:24 - 34:01

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, this Chancellor of all Chancellors will be willing to provide that funding to our armed forces, back our defense investment plan. This government's commitment, Mr. Speaker, to the defense of this country is absolute. We've taken the strongest possible stance in supporting President Zelenskyy and Ukraine. We are playing our role around the world and we will continue to do so. Mr. Speaker, she mentions the plan that she has set out.

And this is why I say we should have an honest conversation across this dispatch box, because I looked at it and I don't think myself that taking 4 billion pounds out of housing benefit is going to get the right consensus around this issue because that would, that would create levels of homelessness in this country, Mr. Speaker, that we wouldn't have seen before, hundreds of thousands of children in temporary accommodation. Can I say to the right honorable lady, yes, we do everything to support our national security, but it can't come at the expense of social security. Having strong national security also, also depends upon having resilience in our communities. This side of the house will not be forced to choose between the two and we will set out a plan to get to 3.5% by 2035 at the spending review.

34:01 - 35:08

Kemi Badenoch

Unbelievable, Mr. Speaker, that the Prime Minister would say that. He is clearly unwilling. We need to fund our defense, not spend all of our money on welfare. I cannot believe that he would actually say that. He is clearly unwilling, but Mr. Speaker, there are ways to do this, he's not unable.

There are ways to do this. On Monday, Chris Rokos, Britain's third biggest taxpayer, announced he was leaving the country. That's 330 million pounds of taxes walking out the door because of this Labour government. Every year, Mr. Speaker, 330 million. His taxes could be going on defense.

The Prime Minister is talking about spending more on welfare. The benefits bill is set to rise by 32 billion pounds under him. The benefits bill is set to rise by 32 billion. That's not all of it, that's the rise. That money could be going on defense.

The Prime Minister won't approve the Rosebank oil field. 1.4 billion pounds of tax revenue that could be going on defense. So will the Prime Minister tell the country, where is he going to find the money to fund our defense?

35:08 - 36:49

Keir Starmer

So, Mr. Speaker, I can't comment today on decisions that are quasi-judicial decisions, but we will take a pragmatic approach to oil and gas as I've said before at this dispatch box. And let's get to the heart of this question, Mr. Speaker, as she invites me to do.

And what is the right way to fund defense and, yes, bring the welfare budget down? So, she would make crude cuts to housing benefit. And as I've said, if you take four billion pounds out in the next few years, you will make families homeless. You will increase rough sleeping on our streets. So here's the Labour way, the way that we do it on this side of the House.

We have set out plans for the biggest council house building program this country has seen in a generation. And if you look at research from the National Housing Federation, you will see that is the route to save billions from housing benefit. We will shortly respond to the final report of Alan Milburn, who is looking at the issue of young people not in education, employment, or training. Again, something left behind by the last government. We will take the Labour way: change education, support our young people, more mental health support.

That's the Labour way to get the welfare bill down. And I say to the honorable lady, that is the right way to fund defense.

36:49 - 37:37

Kemi Badenoch

No, it is not, Mr. Speaker. The truth is he doesn't know where he's going to find the money from. That's what it is. He doesn't know where he's going to find the money from. He's talking about anything except defense: council housing.

He won't fund the military. I'll tell you what he is funding though, Mr. Speaker. I'll tell you what he is funding: Keir Starmer's thirty-five billion pounds surrender of the Chagos Islands and its crucial military base. That is British sovereign territory. This is a weak decision, and it is no wonder that Argentina is now threatening the Falklands.

We need to project strength. We need to show that British sovereign territory is non-negotiable. So why, just like Keir Starmer, is he planning to surrender the Chagos Islands?

37:37 - 38:16

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, I have to say to the right honorable lady, she does have to do better than that. I mean, they are the worst kind of points to be scoring when the country is watching. We will not surrender our base at Diego Garcia. We are in discussions with the United States about that. And we will always respect the rights of the Falkland Islanders to choose to be British.

That will never change under this government, and we will be relentless in defending that.

38:16 - 38:54

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, we are talking about paying thirty-five billion pounds to give away British territory. And all of that is happening while his government is canceling thirty million pounds of vital training for British soldiers. The Prime Minister may be new to the job, so let me tell him what may not be in his briefing paper. Last year, defense funding fell in real terms. That is on them.

To govern is to choose. So why is he choosing to send thirty-five billion pounds to Mauritius when they cut the money to train our troops?

38:54 - 40:06

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, I don't think she's on strong ground when it comes to defense spending. It was two point five percent of GDP when the last Labour government left office. It was two point three percent of GDP when the government she was in left office. It's now set to be two point seven percent in the next year. So that is the reality of the situation, Mr. Speaker: a government that is strong on the defense of this country.

That is what we are doing.

It's why we've set out a defense investment plan that will be fully funded. I say to her again, it would be better to work across the floor of this House to get a fully and securely funded path to 3.5% of GDP by 2035 that won't change under any government. That would send the strongest possible message to our armed forces. This is an area for problem solving rather than point scoring. I invite her, I invite her to work with us on that so that we can set out that clear path.

40:06 - 40:59

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister seems to think that the last government was a Conservative government. The last government was a Labour government and it failed, which is why Keir Starmer resigned. He keeps talking about their record as if it was fantastic. If it was, then why is Keir Starmer not sitting there? Where Britain needs leadership, what we have at the moment is just vibes.

He said he appointed the Chancellor because he cares about defense, but he won't fund it. Other countries are making claims over our sovereign territory. They smell weakness. He's pretending that he's the change candidate, but the fact is he's still failing to cut welfare, he's still paying to hand over a sovereign territory, he is still not funding defense. So on the issues that really matter, isn't he just continuity care?

40:59 - 42:33

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, she mentions leadership. Let me tell her and the whole House where Britain is showing leadership. There have been Conservative politicians at this dispatch box, Labour politicians too, for decades who've talked about the importance of the two-state solution between Israel and Palestine. Words from any politician about a two-state solution will be only words if it's not backed with action. And leadership is about taking action where there is injustice, where we need to correct unfairness, people being driven out of their homes, losing their homes, being intimidated in their daily lives.

I credit the Father of the House who yesterday applauded the action that this government is taking. In this difficult and dangerous world, Britain has to stand for something. Britain has to show leadership. Britain has to stand for fairness against injustice where people are being bullied out of their homes, intimidated. We will always stand with the underdog and take what action we can to support them.

That, Mr. Speaker, is leadership on the world stage. Britain being true to what it's always been about. That is what the British government, British people expect of us, and that is what this government will do.

42:33 - 42:46

Lindsay Hoyle

Mr. Baker, I don't need advice from you. I am not responsible for the answers. The Prime Minister answers the questions. Don't look to me, please. Right, Sarah Hall.

42:46 - 43:19

Sarah Hall

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister grew up in Warrington, so he will know our town has changed enormously, but too much of the infrastructure people depend on has not changed with it. Much of Warrington Hospital was built in a different century for a much smaller population, while Broomfields Leisure Centre is at the end of its life, its pool now closed on safety grounds. Will the Prime Minister come home to Warrington, meet me, and set out how the government will deliver the infrastructure my constituents deserve?

43:19 - 44:08

Keir Starmer

And I can say to my honourable friend, I'm a more regular visitor to her constituency than she might realize, constantly nipping in and out for various reasons.

So I know Warrington well. I believe it is a success story, actually, something of a jewel in the North West crown, a growing town. You could almost say a city it should be, given how successful it's been in recent times. But it does need new infrastructure. I would like to see a remodeled Warrington Bank Quay with high-quality east-west, north-south connectivity running through it.

And when it comes to leisure, Mr. Speaker, you know this as much as anyone in the House, perhaps more than anyone, this is a Prime Minister that will back grassroots sport to the hilt. And I can assure her I'm happy to talk to her about the leisure center that she mentioned.

44:08 - 44:13

Lindsay Hoyle

I'm watching Warrington Wolves, I hope. Sir Ed Davey, leader of the Liberal Democrats.

44:13 - 45:32

Edward Jonathon Davey

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I associate myself with the Prime Minister's opening remarks, not least on the 25th anniversary of the horrific terror attacks of 9/11? And can I welcome the government finally banning imports from illegal Israeli settlements, something Keir Starmer should have done a long time ago? And on Back British Farming Day, can I also celebrate British farmers? But I hope the Prime Minister will do more than that, and I hope he will end the family farm tax.

Mr. Speaker, last week I asked about North Devon's maternity unit, which is still closed. This week I have to raise Musgrove Park Hospital, where his Labour colleague Baroness Amos found the most challenging maternity estate in the whole country. She described leaking roofs, a ceiling propped up by poles, and room temperatures that put newborn babies at risk. Mr. Speaker, no mother should have to give birth in such circumstances. So does the Prime Minister agree that Musgrove Park can't wait until 2033 for work to start on a new maternity unit?

Will he offer a meeting to local MPs so we can move it forward? And will he make fixing the maternity scandal across our country a top priority of his government?

45:32 - 46:55

Keir Starmer

A fair question, Mr. Speaker. Let me first thank him for his support for my right honorable friend's statement yesterday. I think it is important that there is support across this House for what was announced. We've all stood together for the two-state solution. The reason why my right honorable friend decided to announce what he did yesterday when he did is obviously the E1 settlement tender concludes before the Israeli general election.

It was important to make a clear statement of where Britain stands, for Britain to show leadership, and that is what we've done. But we appreciate the cross-party support. On British farming, I hear what he says. I will set out more measures later. I did look into the issues with North Devon, Mr. Speaker, and he will soon receive an update from me.

He mentions Musgrove Park, the hospital in Taunton, a hospital I know, Mr. Speaker. It points to a systemic challenge facing maternity services across the country, as various reviews have said. It is why my right honorable friend the Health Secretary will next week be chairing a meeting of the maternity task force in the Department of Health, and we will make sure all of the issues being raised, including at the hospitals mentioned, are looked at in detail.

46:55 - 46:57

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Ed Davey.

46:57 - 47:46

Edward Jonathon Davey

Can I thank the Prime Minister for that answer? Britain should be the safest country in the world to have a baby, and we will keep raising this issue until it is. Mr. Speaker, the best legacy of the last Conservative Prime Minister is our world-leading AI Safety Institute. It is now essential to our national security and global security in the age of artificial intelligence.

But today, the Financial Times is reporting that Anthropic did not submit its latest model to the institute for testing, apparently due to pressure from the Trump administration. Does the Prime Minister think that it's acceptable for President Trump to undermine Britain's efforts to keep the world safe from dangerous AI?

47:46 - 48:44

Keir Starmer

Well, on the specific issue, Mr. Speaker, can I say that the institute that he mentioned is indeed a world leader and is in daily conversation with industry partners including Anthropic, and those conversations will continue. On the broader issue, he is absolutely right that AI poses risks to our national security, but it also could be the source of solutions to keeping us safer, and that was a discussion that we had yesterday. Mr. Speaker, it's why I appointed a Minister for Artificial Intelligence to the Cabinet. We have lifted the level of the conversation about artificial intelligence within government, and the offer is open to colleagues on all sides of the House who want to be a part of that crucial discussion.

48:44 - 49:43

Connor James Naismith

Mr. Speaker, it is clear to me and many across this House that despite the hard work and dedication of our postal workers, Royal Mail's management is failing in its obligation to provide a basic and reliable postal service. And the people of Crewe and Nantwich are paying the price through missed appointments, through late fees, and in some cases even county court judgments. I have full confidence in this Prime Minister to deliver for our country. Will he join me in calling upon Royal Mail's management to do the same, including by working with the Communication Workers Union and through the implementation of the recommendations of the Select Committee report published earlier this year?

49:43 - 50:31

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, it is good for me to be able to credit the Communication Workers Union because I know they've done a huge amount of work over the years raising some of the issues within Royal Mail. And it's because of that work that there has now been a commitment from the business to invest five hundred million pounds in frontline resourcing. But I think everyone in this House will know standards have not been good enough. People have been facing an unreliable service. We are committed as a government to a comprehensive universal service obligation.

That is what will safeguard Royal Mail's future, but the company now needs to listen to what my honourable friend is saying, get on and deliver.

50:31 - 51:24

Stephen Flynn

In the coming weeks, energy bills will rise again for households across the United Kingdom. Within the last few days, five major mortgage lenders have pushed up mortgage prices for households across the United Kingdom, and within the last few hours, the cost of a barrel of oil has gone over a hundred dollars, pushing prices at the pumps up for motorists across the United Kingdom. But despite this, Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister still seems fairly well-liked, and I'll let you into a wee secret: I quite like the new Prime Minister. But popularity will not pay the bills during this winter's looming cost of living emergency. So will he stand up now and tell people what is he going to do to help?

51:24 - 51:53

Keir Starmer

I will, Mr. Speaker, and I will remove VAT from electricity bills next month. It's not going to solve everything for people, Mr. Speaker, but it will take a little bit of pressure off, and he should look out for further measures as we go through the year.

And we do this because it's a cost of living government. We want to give people hope that actually some help is coming. And can I say to him, Mr. Speaker, can I thank him for his faint praise and say it will get him everywhere.

51:53 - 52:55

Dawn Butler

Mr. Speaker, in a capital city still scarred by the loss of 72 lives in the Grenfell fire, we have a second equally flammable and deadly risk. In bedrooms and corridors across London, low-paid deliverers for Deliveroo, Just Eat and Uber Eats are charging the tools of their trade: lethal lithium e-bike batteries. Every other day the London Fire Brigade are called out to an e-bike battery fire, with a record 206 in 2025 alone. Will the Prime Minister commit the government to ban the import of substandard e-bikes and converter kits, and will his ministers attend my round table in October with regulators, delivery companies and insurers to find a way forward?

52:55 - 53:24

Keir Starmer

Can I say to my honourable friend that we recently consulted on the conversion kits that she mentioned. We will set out a response shortly, but as somebody who had former responsibility for Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, can I say I fully understand the issue that she's raised, and she can expect a robust response on all of the issues raised. I'm not sure that I will be able to attend the round table, but I will make sure a minister does.

53:24 - 54:06

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Mr. Speaker, community energy is a fantastic way of empowering communities, help with the energy security and the cost of living. The Energy Security and Net Zero Select Committee recently published a report and they identified that people living around a community energy project still cannot buy that electricity because of complex market regulations. Beechen Cliff School in Bath has solar panels on its roof, produced lots of excess electricity during the summer month, but the many households living around couldn't buy it and use it. Will the Prime Minister support the acceleration of change to market reform to make sure we unleash the full potential of community energy?

54:06 - 54:39

Keir Starmer

We absolutely can give the honourable lady that assurance, Mr. Speaker. Our local power plan backed by one billion pounds from Great British Energy is making sure that every community in the country, including her constituents in Bath, can benefit from clean, affordable, locally generated energy. And I will ensure if she wishes to, I will facilitate a meeting for her with Great British Energy so she can see how the plan can benefit her constituency more.

54:39 - 55:11

Lauren Edwards

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister will remember his first visit as Labour leader to Gravesend, proving he loves the south as much as the north. Mr. Speaker, on that day I spoke to him about mine and my honourable friend the member for Thurrock's long campaign to get the return and the sustainable funding of the Gravesend-Tilbury ferry. Will the Prime Minister give his support again and help us unlock barriers to back this very route, as connectivity to supporting high streets matter?

55:11 - 56:03

Keir Starmer

Well, I'm glad to correct something of a myth at this dispatch box, Mr. Speaker. Like you, I do love the south of England, so thank you for my honourable friend giving me that opportunity.

Okay, I love the South of England. I, on this issue, I won't speak for you, Mr. Speaker. On the day I became leader, I visited and I saw where the ferry link used to go across the head of the river. And of course, critical connectivity for her constituents. I do not think it's acceptable that a link that used to be there just gets abandoned and it goes.

I will work with her to find ways of bringing that service back, supported by Number 10 North. She's got my word on that.

56:03 - 56:05

Lindsay Hoyle

Alberto Costa.

56:05 - 57:07

Alberto Costa

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I hope the Prime Minister likes South Leicestershire as much as he likes the Southern parts of England. Mr. Speaker, against the wishes of the villagers of Blaby, Enderby, Huncote, Cosby, Countesthorpe, to name but a few, these are rural or semi-rural villages which have little in common with the urban area of the city of Leicester. They have responded to the government's consultation and said they do not want to be part of the city of Leicester. Now, this is nothing to do with devolution.

It's local government reform, changing the boundaries. So I've got a very easy ask of the Prime Minister. He said he's in listening mode. Will he therefore agree to meet me, the villagers of these areas I've mentioned, and other stakeholders to discuss the issue of local government reform?

57:07 - 57:29

Keir Starmer

On this issue, Mr. Speaker, I will agree to his request and I will meet. As announcements this week have shown, I do believe when it comes to political reform, it will always benefit from the highest degree of consensus. So I will give him that assurance here and now.

57:29 - 57:31

Lindsay Hoyle

Kim Johnson.

57:31 - 58:11

Kim Marie Johnson

Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker. No, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, I apologize. BT Openreach identified Liverpool as one of their 30 national hubs. However, in July of this year, they decided to pull out of Liverpool with the loss of 600 well-paid and skilled jobs.

So will the Prime Minister join me in calling on BT Openreach to reverse their decision? And will he join me, the CWU, and the political leadership in Liverpool to do everything that this government can do to ensure these jobs stay in Liverpool and BT stays in Liverpool?

58:11 - 59:25

Keir Starmer

Can I start by saying to my honorable friend, I think there are many people watching Prime Minister's Questions across the South of England who would now like the Mr. Speaker to be demoted in the way that she suggested. Very thin ice this for a Lee-Leopard supporter to be on. But on the crucial issue, Mr. Speaker, I am aware of the potential office closure by British Telecom in Liverpool and the level of job losses, I believe up to 600. I do believe that Steve Rotheram, the Mayor of the Liverpool City Region, and MPs have been in meetings, including with Number 10 North yesterday, discussing this and other issues. So we will continue to work to support those jobs.

And can I just congratulate the Mayor of the Liverpool City Region for bringing buses across his city region back under public control at the weekend after 40 years of deregulation? That is change in action, protecting services for local communities.

59:25 - 59:26

Lindsay Hoyle

Liz Saville Roberts.

59:26 - 01:00:23

Liz Roberts

Diolch yn fawr iawn, Llywydd. Yr Heliwr. Yr Heliwr in Nefyn is a community-owned pub and it's buzzing with events, fueled by local beers and foods, and I have to declare an interest. I have shares in Yr Heliwr and it makes my husband very happy indeed. Now, supporting businesses like Yr Heliwr is of course key for economic growth in coastal areas.

But they're held back by 20% VAT, while hospitality of course in France and Spain and Italy pays just 10%. So will he have a word please with the Chancellor before the autumn budget and cut VAT for hospitality to prove that postcodes furthest from London and from Manchester won't be forgotten in his drive for growth?

01:00:23 - 01:00:58

Keir Starmer

Well, Mr. Speaker, as the honorable lady might know, I am something of a pub person myself. In my first week in office, made the decision to cut business rates for pubs. I think we need to go further to support hospitality. I can't commit to what she is saying today at this dispatch box, but I would say that she should wait for the budget. We are keen to support high streets and hospitality up and down the country, England, Scotland, Northern Ireland, and indeed Wales too.

01:00:58 - 01:01:57

Ian Lavery

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With tech billionaires driving the deployment of AI, many of my constituents are concerned about job losses, they're concerned about misinformation and the infrastructure needed to support this technology. In Slough, Burnham and Taplow, three vast, and I mean vast, data centers are proposed on scarce industrial land that could be used for other industries that create far more local jobs. Communities are being asked to give up valuable land and suffer local disruption. Will the Prime Minister support a moratorium on future data centers until regulation catches up and introduce critical national infrastructure levies so host communities can share in the rewards?

And will he visit my constituency to hear the local people's concerns for himself?

01:01:57 - 01:02:37

Keir Starmer

Mr. Speaker, I understand the concern that he's raising about data centers, but I have to say to him at this point I won't go as far as a moratorium. But I will agree that it is important that communities see the benefits of AI and data center investment. And I can speak to him from experience that the data center itself can be the magnet that clusters in other investment over time, and that needs to be remembered. From this government's point of view, we have a policy that AI growth zones will allow local authorities to retain 100% of business rate growth so that it can benefit communities.

01:02:37 - 01:03:18

Speaker 56

Mr. Speaker, in response to my question last week, the Prime Minister stated that he is, and I quote, very aware of every word in the Good Friday Agreement and will stick to it 100% as Prime Minister. So he will therefore know that the Northern Ireland Act contains a provision for a referendum on leaving the United Kingdom, but no equivalent provision exists within the law for Scotland. Does the Prime Minister recognize the people of Scotland have the same right, the equal right, to choose their own future, and that the conditions for a second independence referendum should be set out in law?

01:03:18 - 01:03:58

Keir Starmer

So, Mr. Speaker, he mentions the Good Friday Agreement and I will stick to it 100%. And I would also remind him on that question of a border poll, it is to be considered by the Northern Ireland Secretary when there is a clear consensus in the country, when public opinion has changed to the point where the call has to be, has to be considered.

I would say exactly the same situation in Scotland. I am not aware that there is a majority of public support for another referendum and until that changes, Mr. Speaker, there won't be one.

01:03:58 - 01:04:42

Speaker 62

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the Prime Minister for his commitment to mental health and to building a country which acts sooner when people need help. Five years ago I lost one of my best friends Sophie to suicide after the birth of her third child. Her little girl was just 10 weeks old at the time. Having a new baby can be a time of great excitement and joy but for one in four women it's a time of mental health challenges from anxiety and depression to OCD and serious conditions like postpartum psychosis.

I have introduced a bill, Sophie's Law, to ensure that every pregnant woman gets a mental health check-in. Will the Prime Minister work with me to ensure that no one else struggles in the way that Sophie did?

01:04:42 - 01:05:19

Keir Starmer

Well, can I pay tribute to my honourable friend for the incredible work she's doing in memory of her friend and I know her dad Nigel has also campaigned so strongly on this. I've always believed, Mr. Speaker, in whole person care, physical, mental and social care delivered together. We are investing more in perinatal mental health and parent-infant relationships so more funding is going in but I would accept what she's saying that more needs to be done. I will look at her bill. I understand the call for Sophie's Law and I will make sure a health minister meets her to discuss it.

01:05:19 - 01:05:58

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hertfordshire has one of the lowest numbers of mental health inpatient beds per head in England. When patients are in crisis, including some young people, they can be sent hundreds of miles away undermining their recovery and costing millions of pounds in paying for private beds. So will the Prime Minister commit personally to look at my three-year campaign to fund a mental health facility in Hertfordshire, a facility which is shovel-ready, which would improve health outcomes for patients and which would pay for itself within just a few years?

01:05:58 - 01:06:29

Keir Starmer

Well, I thank the honourable lady for that question. It's a very direct question and a good one. I think she is right to point to wasted spending in the mental health system when people are being sent hundreds of miles in search of a bed and those placements can be very costly indeed. We need to move to a more preventative mental health service and I will look at the specifics in her constituency. It will all be considered as part of a mental health strategy that will come before this House before Christmas.

01:06:29 - 01:07:06

Catherine Eccles

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Prime Minister for visiting my constituency during the recent wildfires in Stourbridge and meeting with affected residents, emergency workers, volunteers and council staff and would he join me in thanking the brave firefighters for giving their all in the most challenging conditions on the hottest day of the year? The fire spread over 600 acres destroying 19 homes and damaging many more and with extreme heat becoming the norm in a changing climate, what is the government doing to ensure our fire services are properly resourced for future wildfires?

01:07:06 - 01:07:57

Keir Starmer

Well, I remember the visit well I did to Stourbridge and it won't leave me actually because the devastation and the loss of everything within a moment that happened to so many families and her support for them was really visible on the day and the community clearly is very strong and that was evident.

Can I say to her, I am going to be chairing a wildfire summit and she is welcome to be part of that if she wishes. Our fire services are not set up for the future. I mentioned resilience before, community resilience. We need a fire service that has a statutory responsibility to deal with flooding, that is equipped to deal with wildfires, with backup national aerial support to see better support next time we see those issues. And I give her my word that we will learn every possible lesson from what she and her community went through.

01:07:57 - 01:08:00

Speaker 61

Final question, Sir Ben Jennings.

01:08:00 - 01:08:41

Bernard Jenkin

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite long and historic disagreements between successive UK governments and Israel, they have remained a steadfast ally in the counter-terrorist effort to keep our people safe in this country. And we are now embarked, it seems, on a full diplomatic dispute with Israel and tit-for-tat expulsions of diplomats. What advice was the Foreign Office itself giving ministers on this matter and what advice were the security services giving about our national security interest before this decision was taken?

01:08:41 - 01:09:51

Keir Starmer

Can I say to the right honourable gentleman, we gave the most careful consideration to all of the issues involved, indeed all of the risks. As we took, myself and the Foreign Secretary, we took close advice from the security services and of course officials in the Foreign Office and in our embassies. The risk of the collapse of the two-state solution is a risk that should concern us all in terms of the effect that that would have on the Middle East. The risk is that it is dying before our eyes and that requires us to have the courage to act. In the world that we're in, if Britain loses the confidence to lead on the world stage, then where will we be, where will this country be?

It's right that we have taken the action that we have. And can I say again, the Leader of the House who said yesterday he absolutely and fully supports what my right honourable friend is doing, standing up for freedom, for morality, for justice, for all people in this world. Those were his words and we take great heart from them.

01:09:51 - 01:11:05

Lindsay Hoyle

Hopefully when we do come back after conference recess, we might be able to speed questions and answers up in order to get more people in. Let the front bench change over. We now come to the statement, Secretary of State, Yvette Cooper.

01:11:05 - 01:20:08

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With permission, I would like to provide the House with a brief update on the additional pressures on health this summer as a result of the heat, the action our NHS has taken in response, and some of the next steps the department is now taking on investment and reform to help our NHS improve its resilience and performance in the face of new health challenges.

Before I do, let me say as I did last night what a pleasure and honor it is to be back at this dispatch box as Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, 27 years after I first became a health minister under the last Labour government. And whilst there have been many changes in health and healthcare in the last quarter century, the values that underpin our NHS, care and compassion for all of us based on need and not the ability to pay, are the best of British values and they have endured through generations. And what has also endured is the incredible dedication of NHS and social care staff. As a result of their work and with the support of this government, despite record health demand, we have seen millions of additional appointments, record numbers of patients receiving treatment, waiting lists down by 350,000 in two years, ambulance and A&E waiting times down in the winter, thousands of extra doctors, nurses and mental health workers in place, and patient satisfaction with access to GP services up to 75% from 61% two years ago. But alongside recognizing the dedication of NHS staff, I also want to recognize the impact that COVID had on staff across our NHS and social care, the pressures they faced, and to recognize that they were there for us then and we should not forget that now.

And that is also what makes me incredibly angry about the figures that show one in seven NHS workers have faced violence and abuse while doing their job, and much higher in emergency care. That is a disgrace and I hope I speak for the whole House when I say to those staff: we are on your side and we will always stand up for you. Mr. Speaker, let me also pay tribute to my immediate predecessors in this role, my right honorable friend the member for Ilford North, my right honorable friend the member for Ealing North, and also to the work of other health ministers over the last two years, who together have commissioned the Darzi report, drawn up the NHS 10-year plan, the cancer plan, for which I particularly pay tribute to my honorable friend the member for West Lancashire, and who have driven the additional investment, reforms and improvements in performance we've seen in the last two years. But I want to focus on the immediate pressures on health that our NHS has faced, exacerbated by the summer heat. We've experienced what's officially been registered as the hottest summer on record: five heatwaves, 40 days of temperatures above 30 degrees, extremes that we now expect to be the new normal because of the impact of climate change.

During May and June of this year, it's estimated that there were more than 2,800 excess deaths. To put that in perspective, it's almost twice as many as the 1,500 heat-related deaths during the entire summer of last year. And once the analysis of July and August is complete, it will be clear: the extreme heat we've seen this year has had an unprecedented impact on the health of the nation and represents a new, significant threat to the very oldest, the very youngest and the most vulnerable in our society. Extreme temperatures also pose additional challenges to the normal functioning of the NHS. So this July saw the highest number of attendances at A&E of any month in any year in the history of the NHS.

Ambulance teams handled over 800,000 incidents that month, the second highest month outside winter. And this is against a backdrop of continued pressure in A&E, where today's NAO report recognizes the NHS is beginning to see improvements in A&E performance, but not yet at a scale that we need to see. The heat has also highlighted some of the weaknesses in the NHS estate: overheated wards and operating theatres, which comes against a backdrop of the damaging underinvestment in NHS estates that we inherited and that was highlighted in the Darzi report, which said the NHS was starved of capital after 2009, impacting on productivity and performance as well as letting patients and staff down.

So let me set out the action we are now taking to boost the resilience and performance of our NHS in the face of these new summer and other pressures. First, in the spending review, we allocated for the first time a multi-year 6.75 billion estate safety fund. I can announce the first wave of investment from this fund today, covering 950 hospital projects across England, which will receive a share of a 1.5 billion investment to fix urgent problems with aging buildings and facilities. Schemes tackling issues including failing fire safety systems, outdated ventilation, aging electrical equipment that could put patients and staff at risk. More than 32 million will be spent specifically on projects that include improving cooling and ventilation, helping hospitals cope with extreme heat as well as winter pressures.

As part of this funding, I can announce 10 major schemes worth 200 million pounds for Wycombe Hospital in High Wycombe, the Royal Free Hospital in North London, the Linden Centre in Essex, the John Howard Centre in London, Lister Hospital in Hertfordshire, Southend Hospital in Essex, the Stepping Hill Hospital in Stockport, St George's Hospital in Stafford, the Bristol Royal Infirmary and the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Gateshead. I have also asked the NHS to look particularly at extreme weather resilience as part of future waves of capital plans. Second, on resilience and planning. For many years the NHS has run a detailed planning process to ensure it's prepared for the pressures of winter months. This summer shows us seasonal resilience is just as important at other times of year.

So we have established a new heat taskforce including the Chief Medical Officer, NHS England leaders and several NHS chief executives from services that have been most affected. I have requested the taskforce examines the impact particularly on vulnerable groups, including those who are frail, expectant mothers, those with mental health conditions, and I will chair its first meeting in the coming weeks. It will help to ensure our summer planning is on the same footing as winter planning, looking at staffing, expert teams, patient flow, corridor care, links to social care and also crucially prevention and public health as well. And this comes against a backdrop where we're investing 450 million to improve urgent and emergency care, expanding urgent care centres, mental health in A&Es and shifting more care into the community. And that takes me to the third area, on social care.

Because many of those most vulnerable to extreme heat are in social care, so the work our care system does is vital for people's health. But we also know the persistent lack of join-up between health and social care continues to be a problem, with frail elderly people sent to hospital who would be better cared for at home, patients held in hospital for far too long because care support is not in place. And this feels like Groundhog Day. We're having the same discussions about coordination between health and social care when last I was a health minister 25 years ago. So the government is taking action, including through the Better Care Fund, neighbourhood health and an additional 4 billion investment into adult social care by 2028-29 as well as through the planning process to improve coordination.

But we know that the problems are structural and will need much more substantial reform. And that is why the Prime Minister announced this summer we are bringing forward Baroness Casey's commission to report next year and alongside it taking forward cross-party talks to see what consensus can be built.

Mr. Speaker, the legislation to create our NHS went through this House 80 years ago this autumn. And at its heart was what Nye Bevan called at second reading, lifting the shadow from millions of homes, ensuring a healthcare service to care for all of us when we need it and improving the health of our nation. So ensuring that shadow stays from our doors for the next 80 years means not just the modernization of NHS, the 10-year plan, the improvements we will debate many times in this House, it also means building that level of resilience, be it to changing weather and climate or a changing world that impacts on our health and healthcare too. We will only do that working together and with the dedicated staff, patients and communities across the country, so I commend this statement to the House.

01:20:08 - 01:20:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Can I welcome the new Shadow Secretary of State, Damian Hinds.

01:20:13 - 01:23:06

Damian George Patrick Hinds

I'm grateful, Mr. Speaker, thank you. And thank you to the Secretary of State for her statement and for advanced sight of it. Preparedness statements to date have tended to focus on winter, as she said, and it is correct that now we need such a statement, such an approach also for summer. So I welcome her statement today. But we must also ask, Mr. Speaker, what about this year, the summer just gone?

Yes, the intensity and length of high temperatures was new with the spikes that it brought in emergency admissions and all the cancelled appointments, but it was also predictable, high temperatures were forecast. So what lessons had the department learned from the UK Health Security Agency reports on adverse weather and health? What preparations had they made in advance of this summer? What guidance was given? Were trusts left to develop protocols themselves?

Specifically, what guidance was given to care and nursing homes? And of course, these high temperatures were not unique this summer to the United Kingdom, nor indeed is the UK the hottest country in Europe by quite some way. So what conversations has she been having, her ministers been having with counterparts in other countries and making sure each learned from the other? Mr. Speaker, right now the NHS is amidst a massive top-down reorganization. What assessment has she made of the effect of that, the uncertainty and the upheaval that always comes with a major reorganization on the NHS's ability to put in place changes at short notice?

For the future, with the extreme heat that staff were enduring, what steps is she taking not only on building temperature, ambient temperature, but also to ensure the design of PPE, for example, reflects these changed needs? What specific consideration is being given to the ambulance service? And there is a connected issue, Mr. Speaker, of the cost of energy for summer as well as winter. So what is she doing across government to make heating and cooling more affordable also for households, for individuals, which will bring down admissions? And will the government now adopt the cheap power plan that we have set out?

And finally, we are talking about the summer, but already it is September and I think it is reasonable and timely to ask also about winter. And we do understand that supply of the RSV vaccine is in place, but what guarantees can she give on wider preparedness and when she'll come to the House to set these plans out? The number of people waiting, Mr. Speaker, in A&E for more than 12 hours for admission is up significantly since the change of government. What is she doing to grip this well ahead of those coming winter pressures?

01:23:06 - 01:26:03

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank the right honorable member for his response, honorable member for East Hampshire, because I did not reply to him yesterday, obviously did not get yesterday to welcome him to his post and to his appointment. He referred to my personal links to East Hampshire.

I can say I do remember going to see the GP at the health center on Anstey Road in Alton for an earache, I think it was. Not that I am associating him with health and earache, I promise, as well, future. He raised the point about this summer. What I can say to him is that as a result of the huge amount of planning and work that had been done on performance, particularly around A&E, particularly around emergency care and around electives, despite the huge and record demand on the health service in July, we actually saw improvements in the performance around waiting lists, around waiting times and also on emergency care as well. That is tribute to the work across the National Health Service and also all of the planning work that had been done nationally, including to improve performance as well.

He also raised the issue about preparedness for next winter, again, for the coming winter, again, rightly so. I can tell him that the health ministers have meetings about the winter in the summer. And I think we are now going to increasingly have winters about the summer in the winter as well, but that planning is already well underway right across the NHS and across NHS England as well, and we will continue to provide updates for the House in due course. And then he raised some of the particular issues around heat. So the approach the NHS I think needs to have is to have a seasonal resilience, to be ready for what might be extremes of flooding, which might be extremes of hot weather, might be different kinds of conditions that will impact on the country and also to be able to respond to changing patterns of health need.

And that's why things like the capital investment is so important in terms of building that greater resilience, which we don't have at the moment because of what we have inherited. And also it's why we have specifically the heat task force now to look at through the journey on both prevention and also how we modernize and how we ensure that the right response is in place right across the NHS, and very happy to discuss those details with him further as that work progresses. I hope that he will recognize actually a lot of the investment that has gone in over the last two years in contrast to what we inherited and also the improvements in the reforms that are taking place as a result of the changes that we have made, and I look forward to discussing this with him further.

01:26:03 - 01:26:57

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I very much welcome this statement looking at our preparedness for future extreme heat events. As the Secretary of State mentioned, there were record attendances at A&E, and in my constituency as well as many other areas, this led to ambulance queues outside of A&E. In my area it was upwards of eight hours. I have called on my local hospital trust, Mid and South Essex, to make a room available for paramedics and ambulance crews to actually rest and recuperate when this happens.

Otherwise they're sat in their ambulance with often a very sick person for upwards of eight hours plus, and they can't even find somewhere to go and have a cup of tea and a sandwich. I have not been successful thus far. So will she back my call that hospital trusts, and particularly Mid and South Essex, make space available for ambulance crews to rest, to take a break when they are set outside of A&Es for prolonged periods of time?

01:26:57 - 01:27:40

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank my honorable friend for raising this issue and for recognizing the important role that ambulance staff, that paramedics, that all of the ambulance staff provide and the crucial role they play as part of our emergency care, but also the importance of the NHS supporting its staff and recognizing that our NHS is the staff and is the people that makes up the service. I obviously don't know the details of her individual case. I'll make sure that it is passed on to NHS England as well, but I do certainly agree with her we need to make sure that staff have the support they need.

01:27:42 - 01:29:53

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State to her place and the Shadow Secretary of State to his place. And I have to say I wasn't expecting to be the continuity figure in the health portfolio. But we need to be honest, the NHS is now in perma-crisis, as outlined by the National Audit Office report. The hallmarks of peak winter pressure in the past, overcrowded A&Es, queuing ambulances, and soaring 999 calls are now a feature all year round.

This summer was particularly difficult due to record temperatures across the UK, with over 33 NHS trusts reporting temperatures well above the 28-degree limit set by NHS England. And I think we can all agree that that's not acceptable. It's inhumane not just for patients, but for staff. 42 degrees is unbearable. A constituent of mine suffered in his final days in a desperately hot setting in Royal Shrewsbury Hospital until managers worked with my team to ensure that he was made more comfortable.

And we don't want to be dealing with cases like that every year. We need hospitals that can withstand the heat. And Lib Dems have been calling for a new NHS rapid adaptation unit to urgently heat-proof the most heat-affected hospitals and care homes. Now turning to corridor care, the percentage of people waiting 12 or more hours in A&E has tripled since before the COVID-19 pandemic. Analysis suggests that people waiting this long are twice as likely to die within 30 days of leaving A&E compared with those who wait just two hours.

It's abundantly clear that the policies to deal with A&E aren't working. Spend is increasing, as outlined in the report, while outcomes are decreasing. We are pumping money into emergency departments with no proportionate improvement. Now the Lib Dems have outlined our plan to end 12-hour waits in a year by investing more into step-down care and support for people to leave hospital in social care. Now the health bill reduces cooperation between local authorities and ICBs, risking those improvements in social care.

So while we welcome the cross-party talks on social care, I hope that the Secretary of State will look at this issue as the health bill makes its way through the Lords. So will she listen to our plans, change her approach, and commit to ending the ongoing A&E scandal? Thank you.

01:29:53 - 01:32:14

Yvette Cooper

And can I again thank the honorable member for her questions on this and also for her drawing on her expertise and interest in this area as well. Can I start with the issue about the capital fund? It's exactly why we are allocating 32 million as part of the emergency, as part of the additional capital fund that we have set out specifically to deal with repairs, specifically to deal with safety issues that are, have become acute across the NHS estate as a result of really more than a decade of underfunding of the capital underfunding of the National Health Service. Something that Ardarzi in his report made clear had a huge impact on patients, on staff, but also on the productivity of the NHS because we have facilities that cannot be used because of the underfunding of that capital investment. 32 million is particularly going to be targeted at measures that will improve on cooling systems.

But I have asked the NHS to look further as part of the second wave of funding to look at other areas across the country where there will be particular needs as a result of buildings needing to deal with extreme heat that they were never designed for. There's 1.5 billion going in now as a result of the announcements I've made today into improvements to existing facilities to upgrade them and make sure they reach the right quality and standards.

On the corridor care point she made, nobody should have to be treated in a corridor or to be seen in the corridor or have to wait for a long time at one of the most distressing times of all when you need emergency care and support. I've seen some phenomenal examples discussed with hospitals such as in Watford in the work that they have done in order to eliminate the corridor care challenges they had. We've introduced reporting and publication of those statistics for the first time exactly in order to ensure we have that priority, but I would pay tribute to the work that was done by A&E teams in order to actually improve performance even despite the huge increase in demand that they saw in July. They are working to do a really important job.

01:32:14 - 01:32:15

Danny Beales.

01:32:15 - 01:33:16

Danny Beales

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Minister to her place, very much looking forward to working with her. Over the summer I met with a number of GP practices and they reported frequent instances of racism, abuse and even violence against staff in the practice. And this summer we also saw a horrific stabbing of a doctor at Hillingdon Hospital. So I welcome the Secretary of State's comments about the unacceptable levels of abuse we are seeing in our health system.

Meeting with them, they do think more could be done around panic alarms, around cameras, around increased security staff and speeding up some of the regulatory processes. NHS Property Services can sometimes take a long time to improve even the simplest thing like a security door or additional CCTV. So will the Secretary of State join me in condemning in no uncertain terms the abuse faced by NHS staff in Hillingdon and across the country and outline what more action could be taken on this issue?

01:33:16 - 01:34:10

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank my honourable friend for raising this? And he is right to stand up for the staff at Hillingdon but also right across the country. These are people who are doing the most important jobs in the country, caring for all of us at the time when we need them most, at the time when things go wrong in our lives, when we are sick, when we need support and help. And it is a total disgrace that in doing that job they should end up facing abuse or violence or discrimination or the kind of racism. It is totally appalling and unacceptable.

I am very keen to work with staff groups, with trade unions, with NHS organisations right across the country to uphold strong standards in standing up for our staff and making sure that they have the support they need. And I look forward to working with him on this.

01:34:10 - 01:34:11

Deidre Costigan.

01:34:11 - 01:34:45

Luke Morgan Evans

We're talking about resilience. One of the things that's made resilience worse is Labour's policy on mandatory advice and guidance in single point of access. We know secondary care doctors are struggling, we know that GPs are struggling, but more importantly it's causing actual harm to patients. Not my words, that's HSIB, the health watchdog, who've asked for a report to be commissioned to look into this specifically. So has the Secretary of State read that report?

Will she be commissioning that review? And if so, who's going to do it and when will it be done by?

01:34:45 - 01:35:25

Yvette Cooper

Well, I can tell the honourable member that my honourable friend the Health Minister has been looking in detail at that report. We obviously take all reports entirely seriously. The advice and guidance has been in place for some time and rightly provides huge amounts of support and advice and actually improvements in healthcare right across the country. Where there are cases where things may go wrong or where there are cases that are raised with us, we will always investigate them and take them immensely seriously. We will also always ensure that the whole regulatory framework is there to ensure that the highest of standards are upheld.

01:35:25 - 01:35:27

Lindsay Hoyle

Deidre Costigan.

01:35:27 - 01:35:57

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I thank the Secretary of State for her statement. Ealing Hospital in in my constituency of Ealing Southall has already had 5.9 5.9 million pounds in investment from this Labour government to install 22 solar panels and a new heating system that stops patients and staff getting too hot or too cold. Does she agree that her announcement today won't just help the NHS to beat the heat, but it will also help us to save money that we can spend on patient care?

01:35:57 - 01:36:30

Yvette Cooper

My honorable friend is exactly right and this is a hugely important example in Ealing of the way in which modernizing our basic estates and facilities can ensure that they are fit for different kinds of conditions and circumstances in the future, but also that we reduce the energy bills that of course provide other pressure on our NHS and that means we can get the money back into frontline care and can I pay tribute to the work being done by the NHS in her constituency.

01:36:30 - 01:36:32

Lindsay Hoyle

Lisa Smart.

01:36:32 - 01:37:03

Lisa Smart

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I must confess I'm a little frustrated. I think this is the third time the ventilation system at Stepping Hill Hospital has been announced by a minister and it's not new money. There's 138 million pound repairs backlog and I wonder if I could invite the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to come and join me on a tour to both see some of the remarkable work that's done by some of the remarkable people working at Stepping Hill, but also the state of repairs in buildings in many cases older than the NHS itself.

01:37:03 - 01:37:38

Yvette Cooper

Well I hope the honorable member talked about Stepping Hill Hospital in Stockport. I hope she will welcome that they are one of the 10 major schemes that is worth 200 million pounds that is part of the 1.5 billion pounds investment that we are putting into the improving our NHS estates today. And I would also just as well gently remind her that obviously some of the problems in the capital estate do go back to austerity and what happened in the reduction in capital funding after 2010.

01:37:38 - 01:37:40

Lindsay Hoyle

Rachael Maskell.

01:37:40 - 01:38:19

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome today's statement and also the Secretary of State to her place. York Hospital was heralded as a cheap build, but we're paying a heavy price today. We know that heat in that hospital will impact on clinical outcomes, but also on staffing. So will she look at York's desire to have a new hospital co-located with the university to ensure that it is fit for modern healthcare, but also recognize the work that is being done in York to stop frail and elderly people entering the hospital through the incredible work of primary care leading the way there?

01:38:19 - 01:39:02

Yvette Cooper

Well my honorable friend is exactly right to talk about the need both to prevent people going into hospital who don't need to be there and frankly would be better treated and supported either in their own homes or in care homes in the first place and that the overall approach to improving our health and the service and care that is supported needs to include primary care, needs to also include acute care and social care and also that the the ICB as well needs to work with York on the improvements to facilities that are needed. I look forward to hearing more from her about what the health system wants to see in York to ensure that they have the facilities they need.

01:39:02 - 01:39:58

Layla Moran

Layla Moran, chair of the select committee.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. May I welcome the Secretary of State to her place. I look forward to working with her as I had her predecessors. And may I draw her attention to the work of the committee on corridor care in particular and the correspondence between us and the Minister of State who's in her place. It was a very constructive session, I thought.

But in the correspondence from the department, we raised the issue of staff fatigue. Staff will understandably have questions about, well, if summer is the new winter, what now happens to the leave that they were planning to take, the training that they must attend, that they often can't during the winter? Can she be clear with staff about that? And in the letter back, the department said that there are new NHS staff standards, there are new occupational health and wellbeing support, all fine. But then it says, and a continued focus on workforce sustainability will come through the NHS workforce plan.

Where is the workforce plan?

01:39:58 - 01:41:32

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank the honorable lady for the work that she does and also the work that her committee does. And I know that her committee has actually highlighted many of the issues that in fact the government has then responded to and needed then to look at and as a result of the extensive work that they have done. So I welcome the work they do and look forward to obviously coming to give evidence, but also responding to the inquiries and to the reports that they have underway. One of the issues I have asked the task force to look at that's looking around the summer pressures is particularly around the staffing resilience. Because I think whilst in a lot of areas there were all sorts of extremely good preparations in place for this summer that responded well, including in July, I think she is absolutely right to raise this issue about staff resilience, the pattern simply of staff holidays, of all of our holidays as well, and the impact that that has then needs to therefore have on planning.

And I take immensely seriously that. She's right to raise the workforce plan. We are continuing to do the work to complete the workforce plan. It is needed. We are looking as well at how do we also ensure we have a proper workforce plan around social care and what the links there should be.

One of the key areas we want to prioritize in response to Baroness Casey's work is actually developing a proper workforce strategy for social care as well alongside the work being done for the NHS.

01:41:32 - 01:42:07

Lewis Atkinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State to her place and I look forward to engaging with her regularly along with her ministerial team. There's increasingly clear international evidence of the link between extreme heat and poorer population mental health. And the Office for National Statistics estimates that one of every 32 suicides in recent years in the UK has been attributable to extreme heat. So can I ask the Secretary of State for her assessment of the impact of extreme heat on mental health?

And as she goes about her role, will she ensure that she takes as much attention on NHS mental health waiting lists as she does on physical health waiting lists?

01:42:07 - 01:43:01

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank my honorable friend for not only for raising this question, but also for the considerable work that I know he has been doing in this field both before he came to this place, but also the issues he's been raising here as well on this. On the mental health, our intention is to bring forward a new mental health strategy before Christmas. And I completely agree with him, we need to look at waiting times and also where we can do early intervention around mental health. And we have announced new mental health A and E provision as well earlier this summer. But we have also asked as part of the work led by the Chief Medical Officer for work to be done around looking at the impact of extreme heat, including on mental health and also on the most vulnerable populations.

He's right to raise health inequalities here.

01:43:01 - 01:43:34

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Secretary of State to her place and thank her for her statement. The government's reorganization of the NHS will see Healthwatch England and all the other local watchdogs, including Healthwatch Somerset, being abolished. Now, at a time when NHS services in Somerset are in great need of improvement, how confident is the Secretary of State that without Healthwatch Somerset, she will be aware of the views of patients?

01:43:34 - 01:44:27

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank the honorable member for his question and say to him that I take very seriously the importance of patient voice in local health services and making sure that that local patient voice can be heard. And that is why I have said we will look further at the provisions around Healthwatch and also around what happens in local areas to make sure that there is proper accountability and also strong patient voice. And we will do that before those issues are discussed in the House of Lords as well, because I do take that seriously. But what I would say to him in terms of the overall reforms here is we know that the current system hasn't been working. We know that there's been too much duplication.

We know that there is a legacy from those 2012 reforms that were very damaging. But what we want to see now is a much more streamlined, effective system that gets support to the frontline.

01:44:27 - 01:44:57

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I put on record my thanks to NHS and care staff across Harlow for what they have done in a very difficult summer, particularly those that work at Princess Alexandra Hospital. She will know, talking to our honorable friend from Ilford North, how much I lobby on behalf of Princess Alexandra Hospital. I'm delighted that it is in wave two of the new hospital program, but can I emphasize the aging estate that we do have in that hospital and the need for emergency funding moving forward before we complete that new hospital project.

01:44:57 - 01:45:47

Yvette Cooper

Can I welcome my honorable friend's determination and enthusiasm. And whilst he managed to refer to the hospital I think twice, he only managed to refer to Harlow twice in that question as well, I think he may be slipping. I am delighted that he is included now in the wave two. Obviously there is considerable work to ensure is underway to make sure that that project stays on track and that the planning is in place. But look, this is part of our commitment to upgrade, to increase the capital investment in our NHS and to make sure that there are facilities for the staff who work in the NHS, but most of all for patients in Harlow.

And can I thank through him the NHS staff who work in his constituency.

01:45:47 - 01:46:54

Andrew George

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State mentioned the ten-year plan and of course central in that is the shift from hospital to community. One of the things she will no doubt have noticed in the last quarter of century since she was last a minister in the department is the dramatic cut in acute hospital beds over that period and the resultant pressure that that is putting on frontline services. Indeed, as winter pressures have become summer pressures and indeed in Cornwall at least they're all-year-round pressures, with 98% bed occupancy most of the time, that results in dysfunctionality and crisis on the frontline. So would the Secretary of State please look again at this and make sure that the hospitals are stabilized before this shift, because otherwise further dysfunctionality and crisis is going to occur.

And I would recommend that she comes to Cornwall and sees what it's like on the frontline in order to understand what I'm talking about.

01:46:54 - 01:47:54

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank the honorable member. I too take very seriously the pressures that there are on acute hospitals across the country, including around the pressures around beds, pressures around services as well. It's really important we have the right kinds of facilities. And I do also believe that actually the work to prevent people who don't need to be in hospital, prevent people who actually would be better cared for in the community, that has to start straight away because that is the right thing to do. There are further measures that we want to take around neighborhood health where we're building plans right across the country that we want to see more of.

None of this is an alternative to having good acute care and strong hospitals that perform well, because we all need those to be there whenever we need them. But we also need to make sure we are not serving patients in the best possible way, as well as communities in the best possible way, if we're not also doing more to prevent people needing to go into hospitals, certainly for long stays in the first place.

01:47:54 - 01:49:12

John Slinger

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I warmly welcome the Secretary of State to her place. She rightly said that the NHS is its staff, so I want to pay tribute, Mr. Speaker, to the NHS staff in my constituency of Rugby, obviously the doctors and the nurses, but also some of the people that don't always get mentioned, the allied health professionals, the caterers, the cleaners, the administrators and the managers, and may I say the porters, since I was one in my 20s. They all do a fantastic job and we owe them a debt of gratitude. And I use those services in my constituency and they are improving thanks to the work of this government since July 2024. But there is obviously much further to go and in particular in urgent care services.

And in my constituency of Rugby, like many towns, there are urgent treatment centers that do a very good job. And I'm very grateful for the government for its investment in those urgent care centers. So may I make a plea for some of that 450 million pounds that she mentioned in her statement and also for her to take a look at the urgent care center in Rugby where my constituents feel more provision could be provided. And I fully agree with them and I hope she can at least take a look at that. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:49:12 - 01:49:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Thank you. Secretary of State.

01:49:14 - 01:50:03

Yvette Cooper

Can I also join him in thanking the NHS and social care staff in Rugby? And he is also absolutely right to refer not just to the allied health professionals, to support staff, catering staff, and crucially to the porters as well. He has raised this point with me before. And actually, you know, as some of the staff who spend the most time in direct contact with patients, it's hugely important we must never underestimate the importance of every role within our health service. And I welcome his point.

Obviously, we have provided 450 million to transform urgent and emergency care. We are seeing improvements taking place already despite the very strong pressures on our emergency care. And I pay tribute to all those involved.

01:50:03 - 01:50:05

Lindsay Hoyle

Adam Dance.

01:50:05 - 01:50:33

Adam Dance

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've been contacted by families in Yeovil who have disabled relatives unable to leave their flat who rely on carers. During the recent heatwaves, the family reported indoor temperatures over 49 percent with no air con. Public transports and lots of other public spaces do not have air con either. So what steps is the Secretary of State going to take to protect housebound individuals and their carers from the public health risks that heatwaves?

01:50:33 - 01:50:34

Secretary of State.

01:50:34 - 01:50:58

Yvette Cooper

I thank the honorable member for raising this. This is exactly one of the issues that I have asked the Chief Medical Officer to look at is if we are going to face more of these extreme heat conditions, what is the impact on those who are the most vulnerable? That obviously includes those who are housebound, those who are the most disabled. And obviously these are issues for local authorities to look at in local areas as well, but I have asked the Chief Medical Officer to look at this nationally.

01:50:59 - 01:51:36

Alison Louise Hume

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I welcome the Secretary of State for a statement and to her place. Last year a wildfire raged across the North York Moors near Whitby, releasing 25,000 tons of carbon into the atmosphere. Wildfire smoke is a health risk and it really does exacerbate symptoms for those with pre-existing health conditions.

With the frequency and severity of wildfires increasing, can I ask what assessment my right honorable friend has made of the health risks posed by wildfire smoke and how her department is preparing for these growing public health challenges?

01:51:36 - 01:52:25

Yvette Cooper

I thank my honorable friend for raising this and also for the work I know that she has been doing in her constituency and recognizing the impact that this issue has. I can tell her that the Chief Medical Officer attended the meeting chaired by the Prime Minister looking at the wildfire issues over the summer. We are already looking at both how we ensure that there is rapid advice to people who might suffer from asthma or other conditions that might be exacerbated by wildfire smoke so that those messages can be reached and public health messages can go out in those areas and we can do that prevention work, but also this becomes part of ensuring that our NHS is resilient enough to respond to whatever the healthcare issues are that are raised by different extreme events.

01:52:25 - 01:52:53

Adrian Philip Ramsay

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. During one of the summer heatwaves, one of the hospitals serving my constituency of Waveney Valley, the Norfolk and Norwich, had to switch off its MRI scanners resulting in hundreds of people losing their appointments. Does the Secretary of State agree that this shows the range of challenges facing the NHS and will the government's investment plans look at how to keep equipment working as well as how to keep patients and NHS staff safe in extreme heat?

01:52:53 - 01:53:56

Yvette Cooper

I think the honorable member makes an important point. I think look there's two issues here. The first is that I do think there is a legacy of lack of capital investment in the resilience of our NHS estates and that includes the capital investment around equipment as well that goes back over many years and was highlighted in the Darzi report. That is why we are turning that round with the safety fund that can start to respond and start to put money into looking at exactly these kinds of issues including the 32 million that's dedicated around some of the heating issues as part of this wave of funding. But I think also the second issue if we're honest with ourselves is because many of our NHS buildings were not designed with climate change in mind, they weren't designed to anticipate the kinds of weathers that we now expect to see in this country and therefore that means we have to all of us start to rethink the ways of working to ensure we respond.

01:53:56 - 01:54:25

James William Naish

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State is right to highlight how the NHS has been starved of capital over many years so I welcome the government's approach. This is no more obvious in my constituency than in East Leake Health Centre which is a 1960s glass building, it's poorly ventilated and there are currently holes in one of the treatment room's roofs. Would she commit today to making sure that older rural areas are prioritized as well as her team looking at East Leake Health Centre?

01:54:25 - 01:54:53

Yvette Cooper

I welcome my honorable friend raising this and standing up for the healthcare in his constituency. Obviously we are asking ICBs to look at what the priority needs are and different locations are in each area. It is vital that they also look at pressures around rural areas and pressures for every different community in each area in making sure that all areas have the services they need.

01:54:53 - 01:55:12

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On social care, the Secretary of State pointed to the Better Care Fund in her statement. I'm glad she recognizes the importance of this, but I must ask why is she weakening the provisions for the pooled budgets including the Better Care Fund in the Health Bill, will she reconsider?

01:55:12 - 01:56:13

Yvette Cooper

Well what I'd say to him to her the honorable member is that the Better Care Fund is hugely important, I think it's 9 billion pounds that's jointly being allocated and for NHS and local authorities to work together on ensuring that we both help prevent people entering hospital when they don't need to but also ensure that we have the proper services and that coordination in place.

We're also looking at the neighborhood health program as well, as that is another area to look place by place at better coordination and better ways of working. We these are really important, they will continue, but we also want to look as part of the response to Louise Casey's review, really how we better bring together all of these different approaches because at the core, it's the same fundamental issue, which is we're not really still, still, whatever we've tried in different times, effectively coordinating health and social care, and we have to.

01:56:13 - 01:56:16

Lindsay Hoyle

Rosie Wright.

01:56:16 - 01:57:06

Rosie Wrighting

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to welcome the Secretary of State to her place and thank all the staff across the NHS, but particularly at Kettering General Hospital, who worked throughout the summer in very tough conditions. With this government, we have seen investment in Kettering General Hospital, new solar panels, construction starting on the new energy center, but we still await construction on the main building, particularly the maternity ward. One local midwife told me, the building is deteriorating badly. We are worried about the safety of everyone who relies on this service. As midwives, we come to work every day to provide safe, compassionate care, but it is becoming difficult to do so in a building falling into disrepair.

So I ask the Secretary of State, will she meet with me and my constituent to discuss the building's urgent challenges?

01:57:06 - 01:57:51

Yvette Cooper

I'm very happy to talk to my honorable friend further on this, and I know that the Health Minister will be as well. She is rightly standing up for her patients, particularly for new moms in her constituency, as well as for the staff who are affected by facilities. It's hugely welcome, obviously, that the we have managed in the wave two of the new hospitals program to include Kettering Hospital and the new facilities it needs. Obviously, there is a lot of work to be done and there'll need to be discussions about prioritization locally about what can be done and when, but can I also personally welcome her prioritizing the issues around maternity? This is an important personal priority for me.

I think we have not taken it seriously enough across the health service for too long.

01:57:51 - 01:57:53

Lindsay Hoyle

Abdur Hussein.

01:57:53 - 01:58:37

Abdur Hussein

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. When I bumped into the Secretary of State yesterday, I made clear the urgent need for investment in Royal Blackburn Hospital. The scenes I have seen throughout this year in the corridors are shocking and undignified. Having spoken to the hospital's executive team, it is abundantly clear that the hospital is serving a population that is far, far beyond the capacity it was originally built for. I welcome the building of new homes across East Lancashire, but does the Secretary of State accept that unless we extend the hospital's estate and its workforce, this crisis will get worse?

Health inequalities across Blackburn are already amongst the worst in England.

01:58:37 - 01:58:41

Lindsay Hoyle

I'm sure the Secretary of State has got the gist of the honorable gentleman's question. Secretary of State.

01:58:41 - 01:59:20

Yvette Cooper

Can I thank the honorable member for raising this? We have invested an additional 29 billion in the National Health Service this year and have also recruited thousands more doctors, nurses, midwives, and mental health workers as well. It's important that investment goes in. We also have now the major new the hospitals program alongside, in addition to that, the 1.5 billion I announced today is part of a 6.75 billion pound fund in order to improve existing facilities where there are safety issues to make sure the NHS has the facilities it needs.

01:59:20 - 01:59:22

Judith Cummins

Dr. Lauren Sullivan.

01:59:22 - 01:59:56

Lauren Edwards

Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the Secretary of State to her place. I know the Secretary of State will share my concern about the ongoing water supply issues at Darent Valley Hospital. An internal heating system fault was identified in 28th of April leading to contamination of hot and cold network water, which resulted in bottled water being used for many parts of the wards in the hospital. Will she outline capital funding support that are available to help modernize the hospital in North Kent, but also the renewal of outdated buildings such as the Gravesend Hospital and M Block, so that local patients and staff have a good, fit place to work?

01:59:56 - 02:00:30

Yvette Cooper

Well, my honorable friend is exactly right to raise this issue because it is an example of the way in which I think the underinvestment over more than a decade since 2009 actually has had impact on safety and also on performance as well, because it means that facilities can't be effectively used. It's why we've got the Estate Safety Fund in place, but it's also why we encourage local areas as well to prioritize what other further capital improvements and other improvements that they can make, and I look forward to discussing that with her further.

02:00:30 - 02:01:16

Max Wilkinson

Max Wilkinson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State's mention of prevention was welcome. That means keeping people cool in their own homes. If you live in a conservation area or a listed building, however, that is extremely difficult, and so many people in my constituency of Cheltenham and many other places like it have experienced temperatures of way in excess of 35 degrees in their upper floors this summer, which is a particular problem for older people and for parents with young babies. So isn't it time for the Secretary of State to get involved with Historic England and with MHCLG and lead a big conversation about how we can have reform, sensible reform of conservation and listing rules so the planning system doesn't stop people cooling their own homes?

02:01:16 - 02:02:06

Yvette Cooper

Well, I can assure the honorable member that the Chief Medical Officer looks very seriously at all of the broader issues around prevention, because particularly in dealing with health inequalities as well, we know issues around housing, issues around buildings, issues around communities have a big impact on health. The other thing I should I would highlight to him is some areas have traditionally done a sort of community centers for cold weather to so there is somewhere for people to go and stay warm and see other people in the community when the weather gets cold if they're worried about heating their homes. Some areas have now started to do the same thing to ensure there are places that people can go that are cooler as well, but that is communities coming together in order to be able to respond together to challenges because actually it's local communities we need to empower.

02:02:06 - 02:02:39

Shockat Patel

Shockat Adam.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Analysis from the Ordnance Survey has highlighted how my great city of Leicester is now projected to show the biggest rise in Britain's heat vulnerability ranking, climbing from 10th to 4th. This is deeply concerning considering the record-setting heatwave that we've just had. So can I ask the Secretary of State, in the absence of a full and speedy green transition, what reassurance can she give to my constituents of Leicester South that their health facilities will be able to cope with the inevitable increase in the heat?

02:02:39 - 02:03:12

Yvette Cooper

Well, I would again draw the honorable member's attention to the work that we have set out now, which is new planning processes around summer pressures, where we are setting the framework as part of the work of the Heat Taskforce for local areas to then do their resilience planning, because local NHS managers need to ensure that their systems are resilient to extreme heat just as they do for winter pressures as well. Our NHS needs to be resilient for all times of year, and it's really important that that happens for Leicester as well.

02:03:12 - 02:03:54

Danny Chambers

Dr. Danny Chambers.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State to her place. I heard from many patients and staff that Winchester Hospital was horrendously hot this summer, and pay tribute to all the staff who are delivering care in those conditions.

And when we're looking at how we can address the repair backlog and ensure that the entire NHS estate is fit for these hotter summers we're expecting, can we ensure that clinical staff and infection control experts are also consulted? Because for example, you know, installing air conditioning, that is also a way of improving ventilation, air filtration, infection control and reducing antimicrobial resistance in hospital-acquired infections.

02:03:54 - 02:04:28

Yvette Cooper

Well, welcome the honourable member's point. The 1.5 billion that I have announced today covers 950 projects right across the NHS across England exactly to deal with some of these safety issues, to improve facilities, and each area does need to ensure that they have looked at issues around infection control as well as building repairs so that they are making the best use of the funding they will get. After the next questioner, I will come to Steve Darling. Richard Foord.

02:04:28 - 02:05:02

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the announcement of 32 million pounds for cooling and ventilation in hospitals. I've received letters from seven children over the summer about the closure of Littletown Primary for two days in June because it acted like a greenhouse and was deemed unsafe. And likewise, Ottery St Mary Primary is fundraising for air conditioning. Will the Secretary of State talk to counterparts at the Department for Education about adapting the school estate to climate change so that children don't end up with heatstroke?

02:05:02 - 02:05:31

Yvette Cooper

Well, I know that this is an issue that my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State for Education, already takes very seriously. And she recognises the importance of keeping children in school. And just as we are ensuring that the NHS is sufficiently resilient, this is something that public buildings across the country need to take seriously as we deal with the changing weather and climate that we face. Steve Darling.

02:05:31 - 02:06:03

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The tower block at Torbay Hospital was like an oven this summer. It is no longer fit for purpose and is even seen to be a fire risk for staff and patients alike. On the 5th of February, myself, the member for South Devon, Newton Abbot, wrote to the government backing the Foundation Hospital's bid for funding for a new ward tower block. Secretary of State, is the cheque in the post?

02:06:03 - 02:07:10

Yvette Cooper

Well, I know that the honourable member will know both the New Hospital Programme that we have and the different waves of the work as part of the New Hospital Programme, which depends on prioritisation being done within ICBs and within regions as well. And also the fact that for the first time, this government has set up a dedicated fund for safety improvements, the Estate Safety Fund of 6.75 billion in order to do that and in order to deal with the 950 projects that I have announced as part of this first wave of 1.5 billion pounds of funding. So we are turning around the substantial underinvestment that we inherited from the previous government. But I would again gently point out to him that Ardagh's report identified that the big drop in capital investment in our National Health Service that has led to many of these problems started after 2009 and started as part of austerity under the coalition government. Afzal Khan.

02:07:10 - 02:07:46

Ayoub Khan

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement and certainly welcome the additional funding which will help infrastructure of our hospitals up and down the country. Can I also thank our NHS staff for their valiant efforts throughout challenging times. My question is around numerous complaints that I receive because patients that were treated which pass away unfortunately in hospital, their bodies are not being released in order for burial to be effective, rapid release of body. So will the Secretary of State meet with me or get a relevant minister to meet with me to see how we can improve the release of bodies from hospitals?

02:07:46 - 02:08:27

Yvette Cooper

I do take the point that the honourable member has made very seriously.

I will ensure that one of the health ministers is able to talk to him further about the details of this. I think for families who have lost a loved one, it is immensely important that they have the respect and support that they need to be able to bid farewell to their loved ones. And it's also immensely important that we treat those who are deceased with the utmost of respect. That has not always happened in other areas and that is why we are proposing regulation of services in this area, but it's also why we need to make sure existing facilities work properly.

02:08:27 - 02:09:00

Claire Louise Young

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State mentioned social care. There have been a number of distressing reports in the media about care home deaths from heatstroke and I have written to her about a case where a resident was left in direct sun for a period. I would just like to ask, has the Secretary of State got plans to improve the knowledge and understanding of heatstroke in the care home workforce and how the CQC assess whether they are taking appropriate steps?

02:09:00 - 02:09:47

Yvette Cooper

So I can tell the honorable member because she's absolutely right to raise this. This is one of the first issues that I raised with the Department of Health team, social care teams, during some of the first meetings that I had after being appointed. And we were looking in the height of some of the heatwaves at what could be done to ensure the right advice, the right requirements were going out to social care across the country. I know that many care homes did a phenomenal job, sometimes in difficult circumstances because of old buildings, but she is also absolutely right to point out areas where actually things didn't happen in the way that they need to and we are continuing to look further at this as part of the heat taskforce.

02:09:47 - 02:10:24

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State very much for her statement and welcome the commitment that quite clearly there is in that. Strangford's aging population rely heavily on robust community care and swift access to their GPs. So can the Secretary of State outline what specific discussions the Secretary of State is having with her counterparts in the devolved administrations, particularly Northern Ireland, to ensure a UK-wide coordinated approach to summer resilience and what targeted support has been made for community pharmacy networks which so often act as the front line of defense when GP surgeries are stretched to capacity as we prepare for the cold and flu season?

02:10:24 - 02:11:02

Yvette Cooper

Can I reassure my the honorable member that there are regular meetings, not just in terms of discussions involving ministers, but also chief medical officers across the devolved administrations as well to ensure that there is coordination, especially some of these issues where there are areas where we can learn from each other, but there are also areas where you need proper coordination, particularly around some of the public health issues, some of the information issues, and as he rightly says, some of the issues that link in to some of our economic supply chains including around community pharmacies as well.

02:11:02 - 02:11:45

Judith Cummins

Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement this afternoon. I'll allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over.

Before I call the Secretary of State, can I remind members that statements are an opportunity for the Secretary of State to make a statement and members should ask questions, not make statements of their own. Statement on education and skills reform, Secretary of State for Education.

02:11:45 - 02:21:44

Bridget Phillipson

With permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will now make a statement to update the House on the Government's education and skills reform. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a real privilege to address members for the first time as Education Secretary, without question the best job in Government. I got a reminder of why this is such a special job when I went to GCSE results day in Harper Green School in Bolton. While I was with Mika as he opened his exceptional results, his mum beamed and gave him a massive hug. She then gave me one too because she was thanking me for his success.

Madam Deputy Speaker, that is the power of education. A source of pride and hope, a sense of achievement and confidence. I was a proud mum myself on GCSE results day this year and I know how much hard work goes into it and how committed our teachers and staff are. But results day isn't like that for every child. There are too many locked out of opportunity and left behind.

That's why we are leading an education revolution. We have real strengths to build on. As yesterday's PISA results showed, a 30-year consensus begun by the last Labour Government and continued by successive Governments, particularly focusing on literacy and numeracy, has raised standards and performance. Generations of children have benefited from world-leading practice in fundamentals like phonics introduced by Labour, built on by the Conservatives. And today, more pupils are getting the top grades in GCSE maths and are going on to do A-level.

As someone who loves maths and did an A-level in maths myself, that brings me huge joy. So I think the whole House should celebrate and thank our fantastic teaching workforce for the latest PISA data out yesterday, which shows strong international rankings in maths, reading and science. I will always keep pushing for ever higher standards. But continued improvement is about challenging ourselves about what's going wrong, not just what is going right. And an honest appraisal of the evidence is that our current system works well for some but is leaving just too many behind.

A disadvantage gap that remains stubbornly wide. A gap between regions that is widening. A SEND crisis that is growing. One and a half million children persistently absent from school at the last general election. A doubling of those educated at home since 2019.

And now, a million young people, all educated during the last 16 years, not in education, employment or training. Anyone who cares about the futures of these young people can see the need for change. Alan Milburn has warned of a lost generation, labelling education as the faltering foundation. The co-chairs of the White Working Class Inquiry said that, and I quote, "doing more of the same is unlikely to solve the problem". And even Andreas Schleicher, who oversees PISA, commenting on our results said, "a big share of young people think school is a waste of time, that's really not good news".

This is the other side of the same coin of a one-size-fits-all system. Nothing symbolises how we've lost perspective more than the treadmill of failure young people are on with the endless cycle of maths and English resits. Of those retaking their maths GCSE this summer, under 14% got the standard pass they needed. That's nearly nine in 10 experiencing failure again and again.

Maths and English are essential, Madam Deputy Speaker, but everything we know about how to build confidence in young people tells us this approach doesn't work. Yet we carry on. Researchers from UCL called it a wellbeing penalty. I call it wrong. And that's why I'm changing it.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we're in the middle of a huge technological revolution. The world is changing faster than anyone can keep up. My children, all our children, will be doing jobs that my generation couldn't have conceived of. In this world of change, we have a duty to change too. But a way that builds rather than abandons what we know to be true about learning.

Because let's be clear: in the AI social media age, the human ability to understand and interpret the world around us becomes more important, not less. Literacy and numeracy become more important, not less. We must equip our young people to master technology, not be mastered by it. And there's value in human endeavour that AI, AI can never replace. Whilst pen and paper exams have their place, we need to rebalance toward the applied skills of the modern world and include practical learning in practical subjects like computing, drama and PE, as well as ensure human skills like speaking and presenting are developed.

Knowledge and skills, not one or the other. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, a broader, more inclusive education built on strong foundations with pathways for all facing the future. Education as a passport for work, for life, to success. No matter your needs, your ambitions or your postcode. Supporting every child every step of the way, from their first days of life to their first days of work and beyond.

Early intervention, smoothing transitions, boosting enrichment, creating clear pathways, raising standards, keeping young people engaged and closing the gap between classroom and the workplace. Excellence for all, not just for some. Less an exam factory and more a talent factory. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I can confirm that we will see through the vital SEND reforms, built in partnership with parents and professionals. We are investing now in a new system of early intervention and the right support close to home, so families can get the help they need first.

And we will introduce legislation and set out our response to the consultation in due course. Our commitment to opportunity doesn't stop there. We'll make this country a technical education superpower, creating new pathways of equal esteem and equal ambition. We'll connect our young people to the careers not of some dusty past, but of an exciting future. That's why the Prime Minister and I announced over the summer our plans to transform technical education and work experience from the age of 14, building on the revolution already happening post-16.

Combining with high-level academic subjects, we'll develop top-quality technical qualifications that give a clearer pathways into T-levels, A-levels and the new V-levels, as well as apprenticeships, university and beyond. A clear line of sight into work, tailored to local opportunities by working with mayors and local leaders. Madam Deputy Speaker, some claim that improving technical education is somehow anti-academic. But those lazy falsehoods are stuck in the past. Technical education can also give new purpose to academic subjects.

Countries that boast low levels of NEETs combine the two. Our curriculum and assessment reform will go hand in hand with that ambition, and we'll publish proposals building on the Becky Francis review soon. We'll have fewer barriers to progression and new emphasis on the skills to succeed, including critical literacy as well as more foundation and stepping stone qualifications. More space available, including for creative subjects, PE, and to develop deeper understanding. But not a system of separation, instead choices, options, chances.

A curriculum broad enough for long enough to capture the imagination of every child. That means changing how schools are measured to incentivise a broader offer and reward inclusion, underpinned now and always by progress in English and maths. I will set out these proposals in due course. I know many worry about change, even though they agree that change is needed. Let me reassure education leaders, teachers, and the workforce that you will be part of this process every step of the way.

Perhaps even more important than these new reforms is a new way of working. We'll design change in partnership with the people who deliver it, based on the very best evidence and practice, not reform beamed into the classroom direct from Whitehall. Mayoral and strategic authorities, for example, helping to deliver real work experience opportunities. For the first time, mayors will have control of the 16 to 19 education budget. And in the early years and early intervention, I know we can transform outcomes through the power of place.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this is just the beginning. Big reform is on the way. We're moving quickly because this can't wait. Those young people locked out of opportunity, who don't see education working for them, their eyes are on us, and it's our duty to show them that we get it. Some have called this bringing back stupid.

Not a bit of it, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the Prime Minister said last week, we're bringing back hope, and I commend the statement to the House.

02:21:44 - 02:26:54

Speaker 111

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I begin by welcoming the new Secretary of State to her place. Madam Deputy Speaker, just yesterday, the new PISA statistics showed that English pupils are now in the top 10 in the world for reading, for maths, and for science. This is a huge achievement and a real English success story. We are punching well above our weight, while other countries are falling behind. And Madam Deputy Speaker, this did not happen by accident.

It happened because of hard-won, evidence-led reforms and brilliant teachers. We raised expectations. We strengthened the curriculum. We learned from the highest performing education systems in the world. My noble friend Lord Gove and Nick Gibb built on Labour reforms to create an evidence-led school system which has catapulted us up international league tables.

So why, when the Education Secretary herself said that we should celebrate the PISA results, when the rest of the world are trying to learn from England, has the Government decided that now is the moment to change course? The Secretary of State says that everyone can see the need for change. I think the opposite is true. The Secretary of State has argued that there has been an overfocus on academic outcomes. I profoundly disagree.

High academic standards do not hold children back, they lift them up. Instead of acknowledging that our schools are the one part of the state that is not just working well, they're world-leading, the Government seems determined to point the finger at schools for problems it has failed to solve elsewhere.

Over the summer recess, while schools were closed and teachers were on holiday, our new Prime Minister used his so-called grand tour of the country to announce fundamental changes to our education system. Extraordinarily, this government now seems to be blaming the NEETs crisis on schools. Not those on the benches opposite who in government failed to get a grip on the spiralling welfare bill, nor the government's genius plan to impose red tape on businesses and make it harder to hire young people, nor critically, the government's huge rise in business taxes, which have made employing young people way more expensive. It is basic economics, Madam Deputy Speaker, if you make it more expensive for businesses to hire young people, fewer young people will be hired. But instead of addressing these problems they have created, the government is laying the NEETs crisis at the door of schools.

And in response, and confirmed today, they're tearing up the education system once again and returning to a policy that has failed before, introducing a vocational pathway at 14. Now Madam Deputy Speaker, this is not about being against technical qualifications, quite the opposite. We on this side of the house have championed technical education and apprenticeships. But 14 is far too young, start closing down academic options. And we've tried this before, it failed.

Labour's reforms to GCSEs in 2005 were intended to strengthen vocational education options. But what happened was that children from poorer backgrounds were channelled away from the rigorous academic subjects. Instead of raising aspirations, the system lowered expectations. So therefore the danger in what the government is proposing is obvious. History is going to repeat itself.

Highly academic schools will continue to push their pupils towards academic qualifications. And schools serving more disadvantaged communities will come under pressure to steer children towards technical routes far earlier because that is what happened before. So can the Secretary of State tell the house what evidence she has that her reforms will produce a different result? And can she guarantee that choosing a technical pathway at 14 will not close down a young person's opportunity to go on to complete academic GCSEs? And can the Secretary of State explain just how this is different from the failed approach in Scotland and in Wales, because from where I'm sitting it sounds very similar.

There are also serious practical questions about how any of this is going to work. The government says these new pathways will begin in 2028, but what qualifications will schools actually be expected to offer? What standards will those qualifications have to meet? And do schools have the specialist teachers, facilities and employer partnerships required to meet them? And what assessment has the department made of the additional burden this will place on schools?

What funding is going to be provided? Because this is not happening in isolation, schools are already being asked to implement major SEND reforms.

02:26:54 - 02:27:06

Judith Cummins

The honourable lady has had over five minutes now. If I'm going to be tough on members for long questions, I should also be tough on the front bench. Secretary of State.

02:27:06 - 02:30:35

Bridget Phillipson

Well I also look forward to having many of these exchanges across the dispatch box. I would have hoped though that the right honourable lady might have been a little bit more generous in also building on the sense that there has been consensus around these issues for over 30 years, which began with a Labour Prime Minister talking about education, education, education, introducing the literacy numeracy hour, introducing phonics, bringing in Sure Start for that early intervention and an evidence-based cycle of continued improvement which was built on by her government, there's no question about that.

And there actually used to be a consensus around technical education as well. It was her government that they should be proud of, actually, of introducing T-levels, which are now really coming on stream in a way. They also introduced UTCs, which offered a completely separate pathway, actually, in separate institutions for young people at 14. So she might want to look at her own record there before she starts having a go. I'm absolutely clear that this is not about creating a two-tier system.

This is about creating multiple pathways. For some, it will be to the same destination. It might be to a career in engineering. They take a different pathway. Some might go A-levels, university, others might go a different route and arrive at the same destination.

But we have got to address the underlying problems in our current system and the outcomes that they are giving to people, because you can't just take credit for all the good without also taking responsibility for what's not worked either. And I will just take this opportunity, there's a few people that she once lauded who agree with us on this, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sir Hamid Patel has said our education system is not working for every child. The Education Endowment Foundation said inequality of outcomes has blighted our education system for far too long. And Lord Agnew, I remember Lord Agnew, the well-known Conservative education minister, said that our reforms are a laudable ambition and a good signal.

So yes, I would agree with her, these things will be challenging, of course, and there'll be lots that we have to get right. But in Harper Green, where I was on results day, they've brought in a new construction centre. They are massively oversubscribed for those courses at 14 to 16. And a couple of the young lads that I met said to me, I don't really get on with English and maths, but I come to school every day because I get a great sense of achievement out of building a brick wall. And I'm afraid it's those kind of kids that I'm really thinking about.

And just to leave it there, I will just say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I agree with a previous Education Secretary who said, for many years, our education system has failed properly to value practical education, choosing to give far greater emphasis to purely academic achievements. Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I agree with Michael Gove. Think it's the first time I've said that.

02:30:35 - 02:31:41

Elizabeth Helen Hayes

Chair of the Education Select Committee, Helen Hayes.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And thank you, Secretary of State, for her statement and welcome her to her place. I also warmly welcome the government's focus on boosting technical and vocational education and achieving parity of esteem with academic routes. The Children's Commissioner has today highlighted the unacceptably high numbers of young people who are registered at college but who attend less than 50% of the time. Colleges need the resources to address this problem by monitoring attendance more effectively and by intervening to provide targeted support to students who need it.

But despite being part of our state education system, colleges are on an uneven financial playing field because, unlike schools, they are unable to claim back VAT.

They have told my committee again and again that they would be able to do far more if this unfair and unjustifiable tax anomaly was corrected. So can I therefore ask the Secretary of State to make representations to the Chancellor ahead of the budget that colleges should be allowed to claim back VAT in the same way that schools can?

02:31:41 - 02:32:37

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank her and just put on record my huge respect for her as the chair of the Education Select Committee. I look forward to working with her closely and with her committee closely over the coming months. And I know she's done fantastic work in this space. She's absolutely right. Further education really is transformative, especially when we're talking about some of those children who have been left behind by our broader education system.

We have got a number of reforms coming in which will help. We've got additional funding going in. I am particularly alive to the issue of transition from school to college and attendance at further education college. And that and funding are key focuses of the Alan Milburn review, which I am following closely, and I hope to update the House more on that once that report is published.

02:32:37 - 02:34:59

Munira Wilson

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Munira Wilson.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I start by welcoming the Secretary of State to her new role, and it's good to finally have the chance to question her on this announcement. Now, despite some of the rhetoric, academic and vocational education are not enemies. A successful economy needs both. However, in the past, creating technical pathways without parity of esteem and funding has led to children from more disadvantaged backgrounds being disproportionately funnelled into technical pathways earlier on and their options narrowed too soon.

Successive governments have rightly moved us away from that. Academic excellence matters and remains a powerful engine for social mobility. We should never apologize for wanting children, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds, to have access to the same intellectual opportunities as the most privileged. Yesterday's PISA scores show that here in England we have some of the best results in the world. And that's testament to the dedication of brilliant teachers and the work of all parties to drive up standards across our schools in recent years.

And yes, I am proud that the Liberal Democrats have played our part too through introducing the pupil premium and Progress 8 scores. Whilst the Prime Minister has put a heavy emphasis on parity of esteem, how will the Secretary of State ensure that technical qualifications will be as rigorous as academic qualifications? Will a child be able to move between technical and academic pathways easily after the age of 14? Crucially, parity of esteem needs parity of funding. On top of the upcoming SEND reforms, unfunded enrichment activities, underfunded pay rises and school meals, budgets are already cut to the bone.

So will there be new funding attached to these reforms? And despite Labour's promises, teacher numbers are down. Where will schools find new specialist teachers? Will she be reversing the mandatory qualified teacher status?

02:34:59 - 02:36:11

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank her for her response, and I know from many exchanges we've had when I was Leader of the House, you know, what a doughty campaigner she is. And I'm really looking forward to working with her in this role too. She's absolutely right that we need to get parity of esteem between technical and academic subjects. And I actually want there to not be such a delineation between the two, because actually technical subjects can give new life to academic standards as well, and vice versa. And my vision, actually, is for us, which is what we're now embarking on, is to have high-quality new technical and vocational qualifications available at 16, which students would maybe look at a suite of those.

So you're not actually choosing entirely academic or entirely technical. Everyone will obviously have to do English, maths and science alongside that. But you know, my own highly academic son who's about to choose his options, you know, he would really like to do some applied qualifications as well. And that's what I want for all of our children, that they can have these options and these suites and options open to them and pathways that lead to similar destinations but just via a different route.

02:36:11 - 02:36:12

Serena Brackenridge.

02:36:12 - 02:37:00

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State's commitment to address the "what's the point" question that's felt by so many disengaged young people who are struggling in a one-size-fits-all school system. But all of this must be underpinned by good careers advice and guidance that's delivered not just at the end of Key Stage 4 but much earlier on in their school life. So I ask the Minister, will she champion properly funded good careers advice and guidance which also includes place-based employer partnerships so young people know what's available on their doorstep in places like Wolverhampton North East?

02:37:00 - 02:37:34

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank her for that question? She's absolutely right. The jump between the classroom and the workplace is just a too bigger jump at the moment. And it's what employers say to us time and time again. I've got a summit tomorrow, Madam Deputy Speaker, in Number 10 North, bringing together all our mayors, including the Mayor of the West Midlands, with business leaders, with school and college leaders, so that we can come together to design these real experiences of work and better careers advice and close that gap between schools and the workplace.

02:37:35 - 02:38:17

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In her statement, the Secretary of State referred to the Government's SEND reforms as having been built in partnership with parents. Now, I can assure the Secretary of State that there are many parents of SEND children in Mid Buckinghamshire who are deeply concerned about the shape of those reforms, the one-size-fits-all nature of them. So before she brings forward any legislation or response to the consultation, can I urge her to look very carefully at what all campaigners on this subject are saying? And as she is new in post, look again at the Government's axing of a new SEND school for Buckinghamshire and build it.

02:38:17 - 02:38:18

Secretary of State.

02:38:18 - 02:39:14

Bridget Phillipson

Well, look, I really hope that with something as sensitive and as important as reform of special educational needs, we can actually come together across this House and recognize that reforms are necessary, that they have been ducked, I would like to say, for too long. We have increasing levels of money going in with outcomes not good at all, with a very adversarial system that doesn't really work for anybody. That's why we are proceeding very carefully in full consultation with parents. My good friend the Schools Minister has and others have been right round the country doing hundreds of events. We are going through with a fine-tooth comb all the responses to the consultation.

And I will assure him that the proposals that we come forward will take account of all of those responses we've received.

02:39:15 - 02:39:40

James Mark Sewards

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Education Select Committee's report into further education and skills published last year found that technical and vocational pathways were not presented with the same prominence as academic routes in schools and colleges.

In fact, we had evidence from eight different Yorkshire colleges that highlighted extremely limited opportunities for under-16s to pursue any creative subjects. So how will the reforms correct this and give parity of esteem to both academic and technical routes?

02:39:40 - 02:40:33

Bridget Phillipson

Well, as a former teacher, I know he understands these issues well. I mean, look, I think there's a range of things we need to do here. One is that we are going to be introducing new high-quality, rigorous vocational and technical qualifications that I think will be attractive to young people and their parents. We are looking at the incentives for schools, so the changes to Progress 8 measures to encourage schools to offer a broad curriculum, not an increasingly narrow one, which is what they get judged on. And it's about supporting teachers and working with teachers so that they're excited about delivering these new options and courses.

And as we've seen, where they are embedded in school, people vote with their feet and really take them up in high numbers.

02:40:33 - 02:41:04

Caroline Jane Voaden

Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the announcement about technical education. I think it's really valuable, but approximately 40% of colleges have had to cancel or scale back trade and vocational courses because of a lack of staff, and around three-quarters of colleges in England are unable to recruit the necessary staff to teach technical subjects. So could the Education Secretary tell the House where the workforce is going to come from to teach technical subjects in every school in the country?

02:41:04 - 02:42:12

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I just say that I admire greatly our teaching profession. You know, teaching is not a job, it is a calling, and we should all thank every day the amazing work that our teachers do. I want teachers to feel respected and valued and to be attracted to the workforce, and that I feel is my first priority. So yes, we will look at making sure that we've got the teaching staff, but also the preparation that teachers need and the training that they will need to adapt to these new courses, and we'll bring them in in a way that we take the workforce with us. But I think there are real opportunities here for teachers that are already teaching certain subjects to be able to transfer those skills and combine that with technical education as well.

And it's also giving more practical skills alongside some of the current qualifications that we have, whether that be drama or music or PE, or even computing, where at the moment there is very little actual practical assessment involved in those qualifications.

02:42:12 - 02:43:09

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If I can beg your indulgence and start with a couple of thank-yous. Firstly, to the Secretary of State and the Government for a massive investment in South Staffordshire College right across the southern part of Staffordshire to really make sure that we're turbocharging opportunities for young people. And secondly, a massive thank-you to every teacher, teaching assistant, every member of school support staff who delivered great results across my constituency and further afield. My question today, though, is as important as it is to have these comments and discussions about PISA data that's come out today, and those international comparisons are important, I know if I go out on a doorstep in Lichfield constituency, in Burntwood or elsewhere this weekend and talk to them about PISA statistics, I'm going to get short shrift.

Because what people really want is opportunities for young people, and I hear time and time again from young people who want to work with their hands. They want to be chippies, they want to be brickies, they want to be sparkies. Can she confirm that the reforms today will make it easier for those people and those kids to be able to get the future that they deserve?

02:43:09 - 02:43:58

Bridget Phillipson

He's absolutely right. PISA measures are important, but they're not the whole picture. This is about improving outcomes, about improving opportunities. And our announcements on technical pathways and qualifications are incredibly popular with students and parents.

There's huge evidence about that. And I would just say that in a world of AI, which is transforming jobs and careers across the world, those jobs that AI can't replace, like building a brick wall or building a house, frankly, cutting my hair or looking after our parents or grandparents in a care home or providing high-quality childcare support to our kids, those jobs will never be taken over by AI, and that's why we need to support young people into accessing them.

02:43:58 - 02:43:59

Sir Ashley Fox.

02:43:59 - 02:44:38

Ashley Peter Fox

Can I welcome the Secretary of State to her new role and agree that we need to reform education for children with SEND? Somerset Council is failing children across our county. While neighboring North Somerset Council manages to assess 85% of children for their EHCPs within 20 weeks, Somerset Council assesses fewer than 2% within that time limit. So how confident is she that the incompetent Liberal Democrats who run Somerset Council will be capable of improving outcomes for our children?

02:44:38 - 02:45:07

Bridget Phillipson

Well, look, there are discrepancies. You know, these things can be very postcode-specific, which is something that we will be addressing. He will know that we're going through quite a robust process with local authorities at the moment about their special educational need plans and about their budgets and their deficits. And he can be assured that we're taking a very rigorous approach to that to make sure that local authorities really are delivering what people expect.

02:45:07 - 02:45:09

Speaker 121

Chris Vince.

02:45:09 - 02:46:00

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When you've worked 12-hour days and come home and turned on the television and been told by the then Education Secretary that you're lazy, that you're letting down the children that you teach, and that you are not aspirational enough, it's pretty easy to become quite angry and quite despondent very, very quickly. So I'm glad that the new Education Secretary has a very different approach to things. And I'm absolutely delighted she's talking about the need for a broader curriculum, which will benefit young people in my constituency of Harlow. On the point about Harlow, I wonder if the Education Secretary agrees with the former MP for Harlow, Robert Halfon, who said there is a false hierarchy that undermines vocational and technical skills compared to academic education?

It's a shame the current Tories don't seem to think the same thing.

02:46:00 - 02:46:47

Bridget Phillipson

Well, I do want to pay tribute to teachers and school leaders right across the country. Almost my entire family are teachers and headteachers. So if I ever said anything like that, I would never be able to go home again. So rest assured, I won't be doing that. But he's absolutely right.

I served on the Education Select Committee when Robert Halfon was the fantastic chair of that committee. And actually, it was him that really taught me something about the value of technical education. He pioneered that. He pushed that through. He also was very determined to make sure we addressed the gap for white working-class boys that exists in our education system as well.

And I know if he were here today, he would be supporting what I'm announcing.

02:46:47 - 02:46:49

Suella Braverman

Suella Braverman.

02:46:49 - 02:47:33

Speaker 124

There are some aspects of the Secretary of State's statement that I welcome. And I was going to say no one has yet mentioned white working-class boys, but just a minute ago, she has mentioned it because she will know that the data is compelling. White working-class children, in particular boys, have one of the lowest participation rates in GCSEs, are more likely to be persistently absent from schools, and have the worst educational outcomes. So does the Secretary of State agree that this failure reflects profound challenges with curriculum, with teacher training, with discipline in the classroom, with parental engagement, and indeed vocational training, and that actually we need some targeted measures rather than generic approaches?

02:47:33 - 02:48:22

Bridget Phillipson

Well, I, I actually really agree with her. And I didn't just mention it then, I mentioned in my opening statement the White Working Class Commission, which I think has done some really valuable work. And one of their findings was that for white working class boys in particular, they just couldn't see the purpose of school. It didn't relate to their lives. They didn't understand where it was going to take them.

And that's why offering technical and vocational pathways or qualifications for those young people is part of that answer. But she's absolutely right. This is also about how we engage, how we have a more interesting curriculum from right from when children start school to when they leave school. And we give them those opportunities to express themselves in a different way to perhaps other students.

02:48:22 - 02:48:24

Oliver Ryan

Oliver Ryan.

02:48:24 - 02:48:47

Speaker 127

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for her statement and welcome her to her role. She's such a powerful advocate and thought leader when it comes to our students and brilliant teachers in Burnley, Padiham and Brierfield. Does she agree with me that we shouldn't be complacent with the PISA results and robustly act to address England's weaknesses, particularly in reading and maths and too many children who don't see school as valuable?

02:48:47 - 02:49:32

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank him for those very kind words. I'm sure I'll get up to Burnley very soon to visit a school with, with him. I'd be happy to do that. But look, he's absolutely right. There is a huge amount to celebrate and in those PISA results, as I say, as I think of a real consensus over a long period of time about what works, what needs to be done.

But we do have to address where outcomes are very poor for some and recognize that our current education system, which is a bit of a one-size-fits-all, has left too many behind. And that's why I am taking the steps that I need to. I know some people don't, don't agree with me, but I think it's got to be done and that's why we're going to get on with it.

02:49:32 - 02:50:04

Adam Dance

Adam Dance.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to welcome what I hope is the end to post-16 resits. It's something I've been calling for because it punishes neurodiverse people. I'd also like the Secretary of State to explain on what early identification means. Does that mean universal screening of neurodiversity?

And will she commit to ensuring that access to assistive technology through lending libraries is expanded to Somerset? I'm really keen that Somerset does not miss out on anything because we do not have a mayor.

02:50:04 - 02:51:02

Bridget Phillipson

Um, well, first of all, can I thank for what he said about the approach we're taking to that endless cycle of resits. Just to be absolutely clear, every child has the right to resit an exam should they want to do it. But, but putting them on this treadmill of repeated resits that just brand them a failure and knocks their confidence for life is actually no way to help a child to give that sense of achievement. And actually the former Prime Minister Rishi Sunak welcomed my remarks on that. So it's not everybody who disagrees with me on it.

But we will be developing, we are developing those national inclusion standards. That will be something that we publish alongside our, any legislation or any further steps that we're taking on SEND. And of course, devolution doesn't just stop with mayors. We've got great local authorities, great local leaders and in fact they're at the front line of delivering a lot of our SEND support.

02:51:02 - 02:51:20

Speaker 125

I'm sure the Secretary of State meant to say the right honourable member for Richmond and Northallerton. He's still here, yes. Dame Chi Onwurah.

02:51:20 - 02:52:13

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome my right honorable friend to her exciting new role and her emphasis on the importance of technical and technological education. I'm always struck by the energy, the intelligence, and the ambition of the young people I meet across Newcastle Central and West. But after 14 years of Tory neglect, they have been let down, with the attainment gap between young people in the Northeast and in London at the highest it has been since records began. Can I ask to meet with my right honorable friend to see how we can address this and ensure that young people in the Northeast have the opportunities and the education they deserve?

02:52:13 - 02:52:54

Bridget Phillipson

Well, my friend is absolutely right. I was really concerned when I saw some of those growing gaps in regions in this year's results, particularly with the Northeast, that gap with London growing wider and wider this year. That's why we've got the Mission Northeast program working alongside our RISE program in the Northeast. That's bringing together school leaders with the local authorities, with all of those involved to get that real focus, sharing best practice, working together to really drive up standards. But I'm really happy to meet with her and other colleagues from the region to discuss this further.

02:52:54 - 02:53:22

Ayoub Khan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In my constituent Birmingham Perry Barr, I have many families that are being moved from pillar to post in temporary accommodation, which is often many miles away from the school where the children attend. Families are unable to take their children to that school because they can't afford the transport cost. Will the Secretary of State see what can be done to support Birmingham City Council with additional resources so those children can get to school?

02:53:22 - 02:53:54

Bridget Phillipson

Well, he's absolutely right. And that's why the Prime Minister, some groan every time he mentions it, but I've seen the transformation that has come from giving young people free bus passes in Greater Manchester, not just so that they can attend school and college, but actually gain that independence, that confidence to go out and about and tackle some of those mental health issues as well. So we have announced some of those measures. Expect to see more in terms of bus passes for young people, I'm sure.

02:53:54 - 02:54:31

Adam Thompson

Madam Deputy Speaker, in my previous career teaching first secondary physics and later degree level apprentice engineering, I saw over and over and over how powerful apprenticeships are in particular in enabling both excellence in our brilliant engineering sector as well as personal social mobility for the apprentices themselves. Can I thank therefore the Secretary of State for her statement today and her also renewed commitment to technical education generally? And then also ask her if she might elaborate on the role of degree level apprenticeships specifically in her ongoing vision of our world-class education system.

02:54:31 - 02:55:11

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank him for all that teaching he did in his former career as well? And he's absolutely right. I mean, degree apprenticeships and apprenticeships are becoming increasingly popular. We're now, as with T-levels as well, when we have good vocational and technical qualifications that combine those things, they become really in demand as people can see the value of them. So I do want to see an expansion of degree apprenticeship across higher education.

I also want to see more level four, five apprenticeships being offered too, so that we've got these clear pathways and lines of sight that really help young people get that confidence and get into the world of work.

02:55:11 - 02:55:49

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Secretary of State commend the staff at specialist schools like Summerwood in Dorset, where my son George goes, who pick these children up after they've been failed by mainstream, give them the confidence to sit exams like their GCSEs that they never believed they would do, and when they don't actually make it, give them the resilience to have another go, because it's so important to give these children hope? But can the Secretary of State explain how parents, young people, and the teaching staff themselves can influence which qualifications children will take, because so often it's based on the funding says no and the children then can't take the qualifications that suit them best?

02:55:49 - 02:56:32

Bridget Phillipson

Well, she raises a really good point and I'm happy to join her in praising the staff of Summerwood School where her son attends. And you know, this is about ensuring that the kind of mainstream offer is also more inclusive and has more... If I had a pound for every parent or child that said to me that school just hadn't worked for them and they'd had to leave the school system because school wasn't designed for them, I would be very rich indeed. So sitting alongside our important SEND reforms are these curriculum and inclusion reforms that we'll be bringing in. And of course, people will be able to design that and she shouldn't hopefully worry too much about some of the issues.

02:56:32 - 02:56:34

Lauren Sullivan

Dr. Lauren Sullivan.

02:56:34 - 02:57:09

Lauren Edwards

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I absolutely welcome your statement today, her statement, apologies, apologies, Madam Speaker, her statement today. Welcome her to her place. This is exactly what needs to be done. It's about knowledge and skills, it's about a love of learning, it's about choice.

When I was a science teacher, it was about the practical skills and it was the practical experience that really just brought science to life and it was the application. So will she visit Gravesham so that we can have a discussion about how we can actually make sure that no young person is left behind without opportunities?

02:57:09 - 02:57:41

Bridget Phillipson

Well, especially after her excellent Prime Minister's question today about Gravesham, you know, I'd be really keen to come and visit and see that. But again, thank her for her previous teaching as a science teacher. And as somebody who's got a science degree myself, I love science. And as she's absolutely right that at the core of science is about experimenting, about getting things wrong, about working out how things work in a practical way, not just in a theoretical way. So I look forward to discussing that further with her.

02:57:42 - 02:58:10

Ian Sollom

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The department previously had to delay the plans for defunding BTECs and although there's been progress on T-levels, there are still shortages of placements and teachers. Can she guarantee that the transition to V-levels won't have the same uncertainty? Because that transition previously, or delayed transition, has been really damaging to and not provided certainty to young people.

02:58:10 - 02:58:51

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank him for asking me about this? It was one of the first things I asked in taking office because I'm well aware, representing a number of further education colleges and sixth form colleges in Manchester, of some of the issues. Can I assure him that there will be no gaps in that sort of transition? And I've asked the department to bring forward some of that work around the specification of qualifications, the teacher training that's needed, so that when we've got the open days coming up just next month for many colleges, teachers feel confident about offering V-levels as well. But I will let him know further in due course.

02:58:51 - 02:58:52

Sam Rushworth.

02:58:52 - 02:59:38

Sam Rushworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And about 14 months ago, I stood here and led a debate on working-class boys and the North East and called for many of the things that are in this statement. So I absolutely welcome it. And I'm surprised that the benches opposite don't, because it creates the pathways to take the T-levels that they created and they should be proud for doing so. And it broadens access to the sort of UTC-type education that they have advocated for.

It's a great intervention, but it does require work placements and that can be a challenge. And I'm working with Bishop Auckland College to try to increase the number of work placements. I don't expect her to have all the answers to that today, but would she work with me on that to make sure that as we roll this out, we have the adequate work placements available?

02:59:37 - 03:00:12

Bridget Phillipson

Well, he's absolutely right. I mean, obviously the the work placement requirement in the T levels has been challenging, but that is now really coming on stream and many more students taking T levels. And that valuable work experience or experience of work whilst you're at school, we know the value of it, yet it is something that can be very challenging to deliver. So that's why we do want employers and as alongside mayors to work with us to really give these experiences of work and work placements for our young people.

03:00:12 - 03:00:52

Shockat Patel

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome much of the Secretary of State's statement, especially acknowledging the fact that one size does not fit all and highlighting that one million of our young people are not in education, employment or training. One way out of that is obviously our apprenticeship schemes, but apprenticeship providers are really struggling, Madam Deputy Speaker, especially my constituent Amanda, who runs an independent hairdressing business, who is now paying 204,000 pounds a year in employment taxes and VAT before even she before she even pays her wages. We need entrepreneurs like her, but current policies mean that she cannot afford to take them. What steps is the Minister taking to address that issue?

03:00:52 - 03:01:44

Bridget Phillipson

Well, look, I I really hear what he's saying and look, I I know my own hairdresser and her team really well. They do a great job on my hair. Thank you. And indeed, the hairdressers here in the Commons who do a great job on my hair and the Deputy Speaker's at times as well. But actually, you know, hairdressing is a job that AI is never going to do.

AI's not going to be coloring or cutting my hair anytime soon. And these are actually good careers for young people. So we do need to look at the barriers of entry. It once used to be a really clear pathway into work and apprenticeship in a hair salon, but for many reasons, those numbers are really falling and it's something I think we need to look at.

03:01:44 - 03:02:24

Clive Efford

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thank you for letting me take part in this question, apart from the fact that I had to be away for to carry out my duties around the House. Can I welcome my right honorable friend's statement and and also ask her what she's likely to do in my part of Southeast London for technical and vocational places? And can I just remind her that there is a former education college site that is in the ownership of the Education Department in my constituency, which could be ready-made for creating such places and would she take the opportunity to meet with me to discuss the future of that site?

03:02:24 - 03:02:52

Bridget Phillipson

Well, the Minister for School Estates sitting next to me and he's very happy to meet with the honorable gentleman to discuss that. Look, part of this is we are going to need to look at the school estate as the pupil roll in the early years is is diminished, yet requirements on further education and apprenticeships and technical education is expanding. These are some of the issues that we will have to address, but the Minister will meet with him soon.

03:02:52 - 03:03:25

Claire Louise Young

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State mentioned persistent absence. Parents of children with unmet SEND needs continue to be unfairly prosecuted for their children's absence. Before recess, I met the Minister of State for School Standards with a number of charities including Square Peg and Define Fine. We're working together to try to end this injustice and as a first step to ensure that this issue is properly recorded as it is not at the moment.

So will the Secretary of State commit to a review of this ahead of the Education for All Bill with the aim of ending this scandal?

03:03:25 - 03:04:02

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I pay tribute to her and all engagement and the leadership and the work that she's done on these issues? And I know they're much appreciated by the schools minister who's been leading many of those conversations. I I absolutely agree with her that issues around absenteeism, exclusion, off-rolling, the homeschooling which is often not actually what the parents in those circumstances want, but they just feel that the mainstream system isn't working for their children, are of paramount importance and part of what we will be tackling in the reforms that we'll be making.

03:04:02 - 03:04:03

Rosie Wrighting.

03:04:03 - 03:04:37

Rosie Wrighting

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was at my old school Montsaye Academy at GCSE results day and it was really heartwarming to see the students receive their results after going through a journey of improvement at the school. I received my results there not that long ago and then went on to study creative subjects. Now the students studying creative arts are down 47% since 2010. Could the Secretary of State say what more her department can do to develop the next skill, the skills of the UK's next generation of creatives?

03:04:37 - 03:05:18

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I thank her for all the championing she's done on these issues in the time that she's been here? Yeah, I'm sure her results day was not as long ago as mine was, I would like to add. But she's absolutely right, the creative subjects, the creative industries, fashion, which I know she's a particular champion on, textiles, you know, there are huge job opportunities in these sectors. And frankly, our curriculum and our system as it's been designed recently hasn't allowed them to flourish as much as they could. And she can rest assured that that's top of my mind when looking at the reforms we're going to be making.

03:05:18 - 03:05:19

Connor Naismith.

03:05:19 - 03:05:49

Connor James Naismith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know that the Secretary of State is already well aware of the excellent work being undertaken by providers like Crewe Engineering and Design UTC and Cheshire College South and West in equipping young people with the technical skills that local employers need. But what steps is she taking to build on successful examples of colleges and UTCs with proven industry partnerships and will she visit Crewe and Nantwich to see that work in action?

03:05:49 - 03:06:31

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I just say that I actually met a student recently at Alstom and had a made a video with him who had attended Crewe UTC? And UTCs have provided a pathway for some children, some young people to then go into apprenticeships or to go on to do other study or great opportunities like he had at Alstom. But it has not really been on the scale I think we need to have it. And that's why we need to have more technical and vocational pathways and qualifications available to all children, not just those that can get into one of the UTCs.

03:06:32 - 03:07:01

Alison Louise Hume

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the Education Secretary's statement and to her place as well? Scarborough is one of the pilot areas for Mission Coastal, which aims to improve educational outcomes in our coastal communities. And I'd like my right honourable friend if she was able to provide an update on the progress of Mission Coastal and the steps the government is taking to tackle regional inequalities in GCSE attainments.

03:07:01 - 03:07:34

Bridget Phillipson

Well, she's absolutely right that the challenges faced in many of our coastal communities is is particular and is deep. And that's why Mission Coastal is such an important initiative. The schools minister is working tirelessly with school leaders, with local leaders on this and I'm sure she'd be happy to meet with her and other coastal MPs to give an update. But we we really do need to press on with this kind of support so that we can see real improvements in opportunity and outcomes for young people in our coastal communities.

03:07:35 - 03:08:14

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I very much strongly welcome the Secretary of State's statement that she's just set out. Setting out how children regardless of their skill set and passion can achieve and how we will support them to do so. Currently far too many children are traumatized by a system that basically tells them that they're not good enough and they are good for nothing. And this must change.

My plea to her today is that any upcoming changes, particularly through the SEND reform, take account of what disabled children are able to do. And if she will meet with the charity Teach Me Too, who campaign for all children regardless of their disability to have access to literacy from an early age and throughout their school career.

03:08:14 - 03:09:02

Bridget Phillipson

Well, can I first of all thank her for all her leadership and her contribution to this very important debate, which I know means a lot to her personally. And I look forward to meeting with her and discussing it all further. And rest assured that as we develop our plans, we will do that absolutely in concert with members of this House, including the honorable member. And I'm happy to meet in one of those meetings with Teach Me Too so that we can really focus on supporting all of our young people, no matter what their needs are, on developing their passions, developing the core skills that they do, and do that in a way that gives them a sense of achievement and progress in their lives.

03:09:02 - 03:09:42

Judith Cummins

Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement this afternoon. And whilst I allow a few moments for the front benches to swap over, can I just remind them that the Minister has 10 minutes, the Shadow Minister has 5, and the Liberal Democrat spokesperson 2 minutes. And statements must not be an opportunity for members to make statements of their own, but to question the Minister. We come now to a statement on Jaguar Land Rover redundancies from the Department of Business, Innovation, Science and Trade. Minister, Flem McDougall.

03:09:42 - 03:18:11

Blair McDougall

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With your permission, I wish to make a statement on the Government's support for Jaguar Land Rover and our wider automotive sector, and to offer my apologies on behalf of the Secretary of State, who is on his way to France to talk to our trading partners there. As the House will be aware, Jaguar Land Rover recently announced approximately 4,000 redundancies as part of a 1.7 billion pounds cost-saving effort. The company now intends to consult on those job losses that are planned over the next two years. Although Jaguar Land Rover has stated that these losses will not impact production staff, the news will undoubtedly come as a terrible shock, a shock to all of the company's employees.

My right honorable friend the Secretary of State and I have been in regular contact with the company and the relevant unions since the Government became aware. We've made clear that we want to see the company reducing the impact on workers through the consultation period. All employees deserve maximum clarity on the extent and focus of its plans for non-production workers, and the Business Secretary and I encouraged the company to do this when we met with them and the Unite General Secretary earlier today. We recognize too the impact these redundancies will have on local skills. There is a deep advanced manufacturing skill base in the West Midlands, and this Government is working together with employers and the combined authority to retain that skills base within the regional economy.

This includes backing Mayor Richard Parker's 500,000 pounds support package for JLR workers taking voluntary redundancy.

The Department for Work and Pensions also stands ready to support anyone affected through its rapid response service. It provides support and advice to employers and employees facing redundancy, including help with finding new work and training. Now, honourable members will know that Jaguar Land Rover has been forced to confront a series of challenges over recent years, many of them shared by vehicle producers all over the world, and I'll say more about that shortly. One of the unique challenges the company faced last year, however, was a significant cyberattack. That temporarily halted production for several weeks, but with support from this government, including a 1.5 billion pound loan guarantee, we helped its operations to resume and its assembly lines to reopen.

So make no mistake, when British industry is attacked, we will step in to defend it and defend it strongly in our national interest. In this case, however, Jaguar Land Rover has cited global market conditions as one of the principal reasons why job reductions are needed. Indeed, similar announcements from manufacturers like Volkswagen and BMW underscore the challenging global headwinds which nearly all automotive manufacturers are facing right now: tariffs, high energy costs, the transition to electric vehicles, and stiff competition from overseas producers. We recognise these challenges and we are using our modern industrial strategy to help our car industry to rise to them. Through our Drive 35 programme, we are ploughing more than 4 billion pounds into our automotive sector.

That funding is supporting the electrification of vehicle plants alongside batteries, electric motors, hydrogen fuel cells, and power electronics. It is the biggest investment in our car industry of the post-war era. Jaguar Land Rover has benefited from this funding with 40 million pounds of public and private investment going into advanced software-defined vehicles, supply chain resilience, and lightweighting. Alongside that funding for innovation and next-generation technologies, honourable members will know the government has made a considerable grant investment into Agratas's gigafactory in Somerset. This is strengthening the UK's battery production capability, but it's also strengthening the automotive industry and companies like Jaguar Land Rover because they will benefit from a secure domestic supply.

When it comes to energy costs, our British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme will save over 10,000 manufacturers up to 25% of their electricity bills. This will almost certainly include some of the biggest companies in the automotive sector, including Jaguar Land Rover; the successful applicants for that scheme will be announced soon. On global market conditions and tariffs, this government has acted decisively to secure trade agreements which support our nation's car manufacturers. Our Economic Prosperity Deal, for example, includes a preferential rate of 10% on the first 100,000 UK-made cars exported to the USA each year. The US is obviously a major export market for Jaguar Land Rover, the biggest in fact, and it is for so many other high-value manufacturers in the UK.

That's why we worked so hard to secure that deal, and we remain the only country in the world subject to a 10% tariff for automotive exports; other nations face a much higher rate. We place just as much importance on vehicle exports in the other trade deals we have negotiated since taking office. That includes the landmark agreement we secured with India, an agreement which reduces tariffs on British-made vehicles from roughly 110% to 10%. This is a significant win for Jaguar Land Rover and other manufacturers as India is already a huge market, with consumers only set to grow by millions in the coming decades as the country's economy fast expands.

One other area I should touch on is the zero emissions vehicle mandate, which provides a clear pathway to phase out new petrol and diesel cars and vans. We always said we would keep it under review. We always said that we needed a pragmatic and balanced approach here. That is the right thing to do because discouraging the production of electric vehicles doesn't make good business sense for anyone. The fact is that consumers want them.

Recent stats show that for the first time in the UK, more electric vehicles have outsold petrol cars over a 12-month window. Europe reached a similar milestone recently. Electric is the future. And as part of our ambition to reindustrialise our country, we absolutely want those electric vehicles designed and built in Britain. So, a mandate to steer the industry into that electric future is needed.

But equally, if we accept that zero emissions is the destination, then we have to partner with industry to get there. And I know Jaguar Land Rover is of that view too. We are consulting with them and other manufacturers to ensure that the ZEV mandate works for our automotive industry. That it strikes the right balance with targets that are ambitious but realistic. The consultation on the ZEV mandate review closes on the 23rd of next month.

Madam Deputy Speaker, Jaguar Land Rover remains our largest car manufacturer. It is a lynchpin of the UK automotive sector, a company with a long and proud history. Over many decades it has become synonymous with the best of British design and engineering. That's true for past models like the E-Type, the XJS, the F-Type. And it's true for the firm's modern lineup including the Land Rover Defender and the Discovery.

These vehicles endure years after production ended. I note that the Jaguar I-PACE is still a vehicle of choice for companies operating driverless cars in the US and indeed those testing them here in the UK. And with last week's launch of the new fully electric Range Rover, I'm confident that Jaguar Land Rover will get past this difficult period. It will emerge from it stronger and more competitive, holding its own in the global car market against the best of them from Germany, the United States and China. And for our part, we will use our industrial strategy and Drive 35 to support them and the British automotive sector in this journey.

And in doing so, we will guarantee Britain's status as a proud, successful car-making nation for many years to come. I commend this statement to the House.

03:18:11 - 03:23:30

Julia Dockerill

Shadow Secretary of State Julia Lopez.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank the Minister for his statement. In his final Prime Minister's Questions, Keir Starmer spoke emotionally about how he saved jobs at Jaguar Land Rover. Two months later comes news of 4,000 job losses at Britain's biggest car manufacturer. The new Minister for Reindustrialisation is forced to make his first statement to us on deindustrialisation.

And JLR workers will have spent another weekend contemplating their future, wondering about the impact on their careers, their families, their communities, questioning the sustainability of the British car industry and the countless businesses in JLR's nationwide supply chain, firms whose vital industrial capability once lost will be hard to replace. JLR is still recovering from a crippling cyberattack, of course, and the Minister has talked about the headwinds facing all car manufacturers. That includes massive barriers erected by China to sell into its domestic market while Chinese cars are aggressively sold into our own. Tech is changing the car industry from an engineering business to a component assembler and software installer. These shifts are huge, they are undisputed.

The Business Secretary has said that JLR must become more competitive. But the question remains: what are he, the Chancellor and this new Prime Minister doing to make our country more competitive and fast?

Let's take the ZEV mandate, which dictates that the manufacture of petrol and diesel cars will be banned in this country in just over three years' time. It sees to our firms' fine right now for customers not buying electric vehicles that they do not want. Having been maneuvered into joint ventures and had their designs copied by Chinese competitors, British manufacturers are now being forced to subsidize the Temu Range Rovers' gobbling market share. It is crazy economic self-harm. Conservatives would abolish the ZEV mandate.

That's what unions want too. So can the Minister tell us, will government act? Our industrial base is crippled by ruinous energy costs. We are being asked to applaud the government's industrial energy scheme that does not start until next year, it fails to address the underlying problem, and it will not bring down prices for the whole economy. And how will it position us against the competition?

BIX will bring down energy costs by 25%, but given our industrial electricity costs are four times that of the US, twice as high as France, and 46% higher than the global average, our competitive disadvantage remains. Conservatives have a cheap power plan to slash energy costs for the entire economy. It involves hard-nosed choices: repealing the Climate Change Act, axing the emissions trading scheme, scrapping wind and solar subsidies, investing in nuclear, and getting the North Sea drilling again. Will this government be similarly tough, or will it continue to pretend that British industry is not having its legs cut off by net zero? The Chancellor this week talked ploddingly about reducing the burdens on business.

But the truth is that through regulation and tax, the Unemployment Act and the National Insurance hike, Labour have made it riskier and more expensive to employ people. That is bad for business because it adds another cost pressure, and it is bad for sales. 20% of JLR's vehicles are for the domestic market, and right now too many Brits are too worried about tax bills, inflation, and jobs to buy premium cars. How does this new iteration of Labour intend to untangle the mess of these past two years? JLR sells nearly a third of its cars into America.

US tariffs on them are four times higher than when Labour came in. But it was our being outside the EU, because we are outside the EU, that we at least got a better tariff deal than member states. And it's the same with this India deal. As this new Prime Minister ingratiates himself with Brussels, can we be assured that he will not negotiate away our competitive advantages? We know too that tariff and quota deals can change.

The Foreign Secretary's performative pronouncements on Israel and the Prime Minister's ongoing failure to set out a defense plan risk antagonizing the Americans and throwing us into another round of tariff negotiations that could cripple our car and our life science industries. What will the Minister do to make sure his colleagues are not jeopardizing JLR jobs with dubious diplomacy? And are there any trade measures being considered when it comes to China? Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain is de-industrializing before our eyes, and in the West Midlands and beyond there will be pain in every postcode. More Whitehall schemes and an army of mayors are not going to stop the rot.

Government cannot solve all of JLR's problems, but it is the job of ministers to create conditions in which it and countless other businesses can manufacture competitively in Britain. Are ministers going to accept that this involves tough choices and then act with the urgency that this crisis demands?

03:23:31 - 03:26:24

Blair McDougall

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Look, this is a day to talk about the workers who are deeply worried, who are being communicated to by Jaguar Land Rover at the moment in terms of the future of their employment.

She talks about the supply chain. She talks about the supply chain. JLR have been very, very clear publicly and in private to us and to unions that the production staff are not going to be impacted by this. This is not Jaguar Land Rover retreating from investment, lowering its ambition, withdrawing from markets. They are as ambitious as they have been, they have as good a product, a world-beating product as they ever had.

She asks what we're doing to tackle those headwinds which Jaguar Land Rover have cited when they talked about this decision. And there is a little bit of a habit I think now developing in this house of the party opposite standing up to ask why we are not fixing the damage they did quickly enough. The British industrial competitiveness scheme that's coming in never existed under the previous government. It will save an enormous amount for automotive manufacturers and their supply chain. She rightly mentions trade deals.

We have, and she's right to recognize that, a trade deal with the United States that no other country enjoys. I notice, and we can all understand why, she didn't mention the relationship with Europe and the impact of trade deals that we inherited there, which ministers across the government are working incredibly hard to deal with at the moment in terms of made in Europe and rules of origin. And finally, we inherited the ZEV mandate from her party. We have already, we already, we already, the honorable gentleman says from a sedentary position, well change it. We did change it.

We changed it, we changed it last year. We changed it last year in part to help plug-in hybrids, which was of enormous importance to Jaguar Land Rover. And again I say, as I said in the statement a moment ago, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have recognized the scale of the challenges that the automotive sector faces worldwide. All of the criticism she makes, I would say Volkswagen, who are letting a hundred thousand staff go, are not governed by a Labour government. But we have recognized those global headwinds and it's exactly why we're putting in the biggest investment into the automotive sector of the post-war period.

Rather than criticizing the industrial strategy, she should get in the car and travel that journey with us.

03:26:24 - 03:26:27

Speaker 137

Chair of the Business and Trade Select Committee, Liam Byrne.

03:26:27 - 03:27:24

Dominic Liam Byrne

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Four thousand jobs lost at Jaguar Land Rover is a body blow for workers, families and communities across the West Midlands. So I commend Richard Parker, the Mayor of the West Midlands, for moving quickly to put half a million pounds on the table on Monday to help make sure everybody gets back to work. But will the Minister pledge that if more is needed, he will act to back the Mayor in getting everybody back into work? But more broadly, will he reiterate the pledges that he made in front of the Select Committee yesterday to bring down costs, especially energy costs, and leave his mind open to the necessity of implementing tariffs on China, which is importing cars that are frankly over-subsidized?

At the end of the day, everybody in this house believes in competition, but it needs to be competition that is fair.

03:27:24 - 03:29:00

Blair McDougall

I thank the Select Committee Chair for that series of questions. I know this is not just a committee interest for him, but a local interest as well. Taking his points in reverse order, on the issue of Chinese imports into the UK, this is, as I said to him in the Select Committee yesterday, something we have to be very careful about. Our automotive industry is very export-focused, and the industry themselves want us to be very, very careful not to do anything which, in protecting our domestic manufacturers, might also hurt them by closing down markets elsewhere. So, as I said to him yesterday, we are looking very carefully at this, but we have to be very careful.

On energy, look, we would love to go further than BICS. It's worth noting that when we introduced the proposal for the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme initially, it was for fewer businesses than will be eligible and will start to apply for in a matter of days now. And we'll continue to see how far we can go in that, because we're aware of how much of a problem for so many parts of industry it is. And then finally, we are working incredibly closely with the Mayor. I have to say that the main request to us from those involved in this situation at Jaguar Land Rover is to continue to focus on that support we're giving to them in terms of innovation, in terms of supporting the supply chain, and standing behind them so that on the other side of these global challenges, they come out strong and resilient.

03:29:00 - 03:30:28

Sarah Olney

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Sarah Olney.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the same day that the Chancellor stood up and claimed his growth mission was working, it was reported that 4,000 more manufacturing jobs are being cut in the West Midlands. This news will have been devastating for the thousands of workers and their families affected by these redundancies at Jaguar Land Rover, as well as for the companies in the impacted supply chain industries. When Starmer's government announced that they would underwrite a rescue loan for JLR last year, the Liberal Democrats asked that the Prime Minister assure workers that the deal would be enough to protect their jobs. It wasn't.

This development lays bare that the government's growth mission is falling far short. So we need to see bold action from the Chancellor on growing the economy across the UK. Earlier this year, we called for the government to review their tariffs on the steel sector due to the impact it would have on our manufacturing and defence industries. Yet ministers won't even negotiate a new growth and defence partnership with the EU that would unleash our auto industry by removing crippling rules-of-origin trade barriers. So is this Chancellor's growth mission serious ambition or just words, and what will the government do to ensure that these highly specialised skills are not lost and are fully utilised within our manufacturing sector?

Thank you.

03:30:28 - 03:31:36

Blair McDougall

I thank her for those questions. She mentions the cyberattack and the 1.5 billion pound guarantee that we gave to stand behind them. I should say that guarantee is still in place. It is there as a form of market reassurance for the company. They haven't drawn on it yet, but it still has served its purpose in terms of reassuring the market.

I have to say the company are clear that that is only one of the factors within this. It is as much about challenges within the Chinese market, challenges in terms of global trade challenges. She asks about, rightly, the relationship with Europe. I can reassure her that our posts in capitals across Europe, our ministers, including myself, are constantly engaging with member states and their representatives on both of those issues, on rules of origin and on Made in Europe. I think one of the encouraging things in that process is you see not only our industry making that argument, but also the deeply interconnected other side of the supply chain across the channel also making that argument with member states.

So I can reassure her that we're working hard on that.

03:31:37 - 03:32:17

Speaker 141

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. There is concern amongst my constituents who work at JLR Halewood and amongst those who work for the supply chain in the whole of the North West of England about this news. The five week suspension of manufacturing last year as a consequence of the cyber attack has left a legacy of concern about the future and issues about financial resilience for some companies. So what steps is he taking to ensure that the full impact of this announcement on the supply chain is also mitigated as much as possible and resilience in our automotive supply chain is boosted for the future?

03:32:17 - 03:33:14

Blair McDougall

Well I know how important Jaguar Land Rover is for her own constituents and she's a constant voice of concern on their behalf. Jaguar Land Rover have been very clear that these jobs are focused largely on back end and management staff and that the productive staff will not be impacted. That should be I hope a source of encouragement and reassurance to the wider supply chain. We are investing a huge amount into that wider supply chain. I mentioned Agratas a moment ago, that's a 380 million pound investment for us which leverages in 5 billion pounds of investment.

I could just as easily talk about the supply chain pilots we're doing through Drive 35 to make sure as I say that that competitive edge we have, that excellence we have in automotive engineering survives this global challenge period and that we come out of it still as a productive and proud car making nation.

03:33:14 - 03:33:16

Judith Cummins

Saqib Bhatti.

03:33:16 - 03:33:51

Saqib Bhatti

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. In Meriden and Solihull East we have Jaguar Land Rover Solihull and I can tell him that the and he will know this that Jaguar Land Rover is in the DNA of my constituency in the West Midlands and the automotive sector. And I agree with him about the global headwinds but there is there is a massive issue here which is around the high levels of red tape through the Employment Act and also the National Insurance rises which will inevitably destroy consumer demand and make our automotive sector less competitive. Will the Minister at least acknowledge that that has also had an impact?

03:33:51 - 03:34:39

Blair McDougall

Absolutely I recognize it's our job to lower costs on the industry. That's why we are for example taking the action we are on energy costs to make it more competitive and more productive. That should take us roughly to where the European average is so we can compete with our with our nearest neighbors here. I pay tribute to his staff of Jaguar Land Rover in Solihull. I was at Jaguar Land Rover in Coventry just a few days ago seeing the extraordinary almost sci-fi level of work that they do.

And I think it's right that we all express concern today and worry for our constituents but I think we should also all celebrate the incredible manufacturing that they are doing now and will continue to do for generations to come.

03:34:39 - 03:34:41

Judith Cummins

Paulette Hamilton.

03:34:41 - 03:35:37

Paulette Hamilton

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. On Saturday I was particularly disappointed by this announcement. Over the last two years we have worked hard in Birmingham Erdington to protect jobs at Jaguar Land Rover Castle Bromwich site. Given the announcement of 4,000 job losses across JLR my constituents are deeply concerned what this means for their livelihoods after losing thousands of jobs in previous rounds of reorganization. Can the Minister give me an assurance today about the future of the Castle Bromwich site and what steps is the Government taking with JLR to not just protect jobs now but in the future if they do plan future job losses to ensure that they're working with others because we want to ensure that there are no future job losses.

03:35:38 - 03:35:40

Speaker 144

And thank you.

03:35:40 - 03:36:29

Blair McDougall

I thank the honorable lady for the question and I know how important JLR is to her constituents and she makes that very clear to myself and other ministers constantly. I would say the key thing we can do is to invest in that future productive capacity of the company. I mentioned the investment into Agretas a moment ago. It's very recently again we made a substantial investment through Drive 35 into software defined vehicle research within the company as well. And that's the conversation we are having with JLR right now is about how to protect not just the high value jobs within JLR directly but that wider supply chain and those high value jobs that so many of our constituents rely on.

03:36:29 - 03:37:18

Speaker 149

JLR's plan to cut 4,000 jobs is devastating for workers, families and communities in Coventry and across the West Midlands. JLR is based in my constituency and its highly skilled workforce is vital to our region's economy and industrial future. Trade Union Unite is right to demand urgent answers and for every alternative to job losses to be explored. The business secretary has now met JLR and Unite, so can the minister tell the house what has actually been secured from JLR, a company that has already been granted 1.5 billion pounds of public money? Will the department publish the company's plans in full, rule out compulsory redundancies and make it clear that not a penny more of taxpayers' money will support a company that is throwing thousands of workers onto the scrapheap?

03:37:18 - 03:38:05

Blair McDougall

Well, I agreed with I think the honorable lady right up until the end there. I think we have to keep investing into JLR to secure those jobs. But I met I think some of her constituents last week and felt that sense of pride they have. It's not just a job, it's not just economic production, it's part of the sense of local pride in her area. When we met with the Secretary of State, the union and management earlier on, we pressed them on exactly these issues.

We had a conversation about the phasing of these changes, how they interact with the rollout of new models that are coming and when those job losses would kick in. And that's something that the union and the business will continue to work on and we'll continue that conversation as well.

03:38:05 - 03:38:34

Preet Gill

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And today's announcement from Jaguar Land Rover is devastating for its workforce, for the automotive industry and the wider supply chain. A manufacturing supplier to JLR in my constituency of Birmingham Edgbaston has lost more than 150 jobs. So what access to finance will the government provide to help West Midlands firms diversify, enter new markets and protect skilled jobs?

03:38:34 - 03:39:28

Blair McDougall

Well, she rightly raises the issue that Jaguar Land Rover and the other big automotive names don't exist in isolation. They are part of much wider supply chains. On the issue of access to finance and funding, the Drive 35 program, obviously a lot of that goes to those larger companies, but it goes right across that supply chain investing in so many of the strengths we have across particularly electric propulsion, software defined vehicles and other other strengths that we have. In addition to that, within the West Midlands, 50 million pounds has been devolved to the mayor to work on those supply chain resiliences. And we'll continue to work with the mayor to agree what needs to be done to secure those supply chains for the future, as I say, as we go through a pretty challenging period for automotive.

03:39:28 - 03:40:04

David Reed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Jaguar Land Rover hack started over a year ago. Manufacturing ground to a halt, and the government stepped in and made the UK taxpayer the insurer of last resort to the tune of 1.5 billion pounds. Yet the government has still not said who did this to our country. And it's been widely reported that this attack was state-sponsored.

At a time when we should be having a national conversation around the threats we face, can the government tell us and use this opportunity, which country did this to us, and more importantly, have there been repercussions?

03:40:04 - 03:40:35

Blair McDougall

Well, I may look suave and debonair, but I'm not James Bond, and so I will resist commenting on the attribution of that. Look, it would be for the National Security Minister and the Home Secretary to do that. These are serious matters. What I would say is I think we were right to put that 1.5 billion pounds there. It's not been drawn on, but it did give that vote of confidence to one of our most important manufacturers at a moment of genuine crisis.

03:40:35 - 03:40:36

Chris Bloore.

03:40:36 - 03:41:25

Speaker 151

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank the Minister for his statement? As someone who represents Redditch with a proud automotive history and is home to thousands of the hundred thousand plus jobs that are part of the supply chain that support JLR, we're all deeply concerned about the statement from JLR. But as this government did everything it could with the 1.5 loan, not bailout, to support JLR, can he also assure me that if worse is to come, that this government will not falter in any way to give the support to protect these jobs? Because if these jobs are at risk further down the road, they will never come back, as other areas in Birmingham can attest to.

So can he assure me that this Labour government will make sure that whatever the headwinds facing JLR and the pressures from China, we will not lose this crucial industry as part of this country?

03:41:25 - 03:42:01

Blair McDougall

I can reassure my honourable friend on that. I should say Jaguar Land Rover in our conversations have been at pains to talk about this is a... it was described I think earlier on as bitter medicine. But they are not in any way rolling back from their investment. They're investing really significantly in the future of the company. And we will be alongside them making those strategic investments and making sure, as the honourable friend says, that this company continues to flourish for a long time to come.

03:42:02 - 03:42:19

Manuela Perteghella

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the actions taken by this government stand in stark contrast to the actions of previous Conservative governments who were happy to watch the closure of the Massey Ferguson factory, the Alvis tank factory, and Peugeot in Coventry throughout the 80s, which led to unemployment levels of 20% in the city where I grew up. Can I ask him, from those previous rounds of closures, we have seen the financial services industry come in and target workers, some of whom may be considering voluntary redundancy on defined benefit pension schemes, and target them and persuade them to transfer their pensions out?

03:43:42 - 03:44:20

Mary Creagh

Can I ask him, from those previous rounds of closures, we have seen the financial services industry come in and target workers, some of whom may be considering voluntary redundancy on defined benefit pension schemes, and target them and persuade them to transfer their pensions out into less beneficial pensions. Many of those firms then go bust and people realize afterwards that they have been mis-sold. Can he take every step he can to protect the pension prosperities of those who are going to face voluntary or compulsory redundancy at the global headquarters of JLR at Whitley in Coventry?

03:44:20 - 03:44:56

Blair McDougall

She raises a really important point and one I confess that I hadn't come across my desk yet. I will, after this statement, go away and make sure that we are raising that with the relevant regulators and perhaps talk to friends in Treasury about that because it would be awful if workers, really skilled workers who have a redundancy payment that they have earned through years of hard work, have it snatched away from them by disreputable finance companies.

03:44:56 - 03:45:31

Ayoub Khan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Learning of these potential job losses was deeply concerning for me as a Member of Parliament for Birmingham because we know that job losses don't just impact individuals and their immediate families, but it impacts local economies. Now, I know that the regional mayor has set aside half a million pounds, but that's not new money. That's money which the mayor had for other projects. So the question is, will the Minister specifically state what funding is this government going to provide the local mayor and the local councils, and I'm not talking about the 1.5 billion loan.

03:45:31 - 03:46:27

Blair McDougall

Well, as I said to other honorable members throughout the conversations we've been having, both with people in the region including the mayor and the company themselves, the ask has been to make sure we, they feel our job is to stand behind that wider sector and wider supply chain and to make sure that things are available in the future. He mentioned skills in particular. He'll be aware that the changes we've made to sort of shorter, more flexible apprenticeships, for example, are very focused on the automotive industry. So we are already putting significant amounts of funding into advanced manufacturing in the honorable gentleman's part of the world and will continue to do that. But, you know, we stand ready to work with people in the region to make sure that whatever it takes, we maintain the skills and the manufacturing within his region.

03:46:27 - 03:46:58

Margaret Rachel Taylor

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My next-door neighbor works at JLR, and people in my constituency of North Warwickshire and Bedworth have worked their whole lives at JLR. They and others in the wider manufacturing supply chain will be rightly concerned about their future, and I share their concern. I welcome the package of measures put in place by Labour Mayor Richard Parker, but I would like to ask the Minister what more he will be doing to support motor manufacturing in the West Midlands to protect our industrial future.

03:46:58 - 03:47:49

Blair McDougall

Well, she makes an incredibly important point on behalf of her constituents who work in automotive, as she always does. Many of these workers, because they are very highly skilled, because Jaguar Land Rover is such a prestigious organization to have worked in, will find themselves in work very quickly. But that's almost not the point. This will be like mourning for them because they will be leaving a company with which they are deeply connected emotionally. We are investing 4 billion pounds into the automotive industry, as I said earlier, the biggest investment in post-war Britain into the automotive sector.

And it's precisely to ensure that the high-quality jobs that her constituents rely on, not just in the big automotive primes but all across the supply chain, are there for her constituents for generations to come. And I'll continue to work with her on that.

03:47:49 - 03:48:19

Ashley Peter Fox

Jaguar Land Rover is Britain's largest car manufacturer. So to learn of 4,000 job losses is deeply concerning to workers and the whole supply chain, including Agretas in my constituency. Now, JLR is at a competitive disadvantage given the excessive energy costs in Britain. So will the Minister agree that the key to protecting Britain's manufacturing is to provide lower electricity costs to all businesses in Britain?

03:48:19 - 03:48:57

Blair McDougall

I would absolutely agree with him. This is precisely why we are taking action not just through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme but through the Supercharger as well. It is an incredibly important issue for automotive manufacturing, for advanced manufacturing, but for the entire economy in terms of the impact on our growth, which is precisely why we're acting on it. I would say in addition though to energy costs, investing in innovation is incredibly important because that's what we will compete on in this global market, not on low cost, but on better ideas and better products.

03:48:57 - 03:48:58

Phil Collins.

03:48:58 - 03:49:47

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. 4,000 job losses is going to be a massive impact to West Midlands, but also for me in particular into Birmingham Selly Oak where hundreds of jobs and people's economic futures will be cut short. I welcome Richard Parker's half a million to help support that situation. But I do worry that JLR's global market conditions boils down to three key things. One, Chinese domination of the electrical vehicle market, not just here in the UK but across the entirety of Europe.

Secondly, tariffs from America. And third, perhaps the first salvo of what we would call advanced or artificial intelligence taking over administrative managerial roles in major manufacturing companies across the entirety of Europe. What is the government doing to prepare itself for an increase of AI replacing a lot of these jobs and how are we helping them?

03:49:47 - 03:50:56

Blair McDougall

So I think he nails so many of the challenges. I mean, he mentions Chinese imports as well. I think the flip side of that is our ability to access the Chinese market with our manufacturers, in particular the difficulty of competing against highly subsidized Chinese-made cars within China, which is incredibly difficult. On the issue of technology, part of the reason we are investing so heavily into, for example, software-defined vehicles and autonomous vehicles is because we want to be ahead of that curve. We want to be the country that leads on this.

We saw just a few days ago the beginning of autonomous vehicles on the road in this city. I was in the Midlands a few days ago with Aurrigo, an incredible company making autonomous vehicles that take freight and luggage around airports. We have so many companies who have the ability to turn what he rightly identifies as a potential threat into a competitive advantage for us in the world, and that's why we're investing so heavily in it.

03:50:56 - 03:50:58

Judith Cummins

Richard Tice.

03:50:58 - 03:51:49

Richard Tice

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This House needs to wake up urgently because the truth is these 4,000 JLR jobs are being sacrificed on the altar of net stupid zero, which was introduced in 2019. Introduced in 2019, since when JLR's production has collapsed from almost 400,000 to under 200,000. Energy prices have doubled. The previous Conservative government introduced the ridiculous ZEV mandate.

Meanwhile, the Chinese imports have increased from a few thousand to almost 300,000, some 15% of the market. The whole of the UK market will be destroyed in the next five to seven years unless this government takes urgent action. Will the government do the right thing, scrap the ZEV mandates and do what the US has done, introduce 100% tariffs on all Chinese EV imports?

03:51:49 - 03:52:39

Blair McDougall

Well, I welcome his question. He knows that we are reviewing the ZEV mandate to make sure that the destination of electric remains, but the question of how quickly we go there is under review. I have to say, in standing there as the supposed defender of Jaguar Land Rover, I will simply remind him that when we stepped in with 1.5 billion pounds to protect Jaguar Land Rover, his party leader said, "I predict Jaguar will now go bust and you know what, they deserve to." He should apologize for that.

03:52:39 - 03:52:46

Judith Cummins

The honorable gentleman will allow the honorable lady to say her question undisturbed. Serena Brackenridge.

03:52:46 - 03:53:23

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've had reassurance for my residents at the i54 Wolverhampton site that they will be largely unaffected. However, for those who are affected across the West Midlands, this is deeply concerning. So I thank the mayor, Richard Parker, for the 500,000 support package. Will the minister take heed of JLR and the wider automotive sector's concern about exports flooding the UK market and act so the industry remains competitive and safeguards future jobs?

03:53:23 - 03:54:12

Blair McDougall

I'm glad she's had that reassurance on behalf of her constituents, but I think she'll know that they will be affected by it in the sense that they'll feel they're part of one fabric across JLR, which has such a strong identity as a company. As I said earlier on, we are working very carefully on the issue of Chinese export imports with the industry themselves. It's worth saying they are nervous about this issue. They are worried about the cost and the impact of the increase in the number of Chinese EVs coming into our market, but they also want to be able to access the Chinese market and don't want to get into a sort of retaliatory situation. So we don't rule anything out, but we are being very careful as we think, as we work with the industry on that issue.

03:54:12 - 03:54:51

Varinder Jass

Varinder Jass. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the minister for his statement and for keeping members of this house informed as to the situation in JLR. Although we've had reassurances that production jobs are not going to be affected, when the cyberattack happened, a lot of the supply chain companies were adversely affected and their employees as well. So can the minister give some reassurance that with the latest round of redundancies, those supply chain companies and their employees will not be affected?

And can he also please give reassurance that he will continue to work with the trade unions and other partners?

03:54:51 - 03:55:31

Blair McDougall

So I can certainly give that reassurance. Myself and the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister indeed have been in contact with unions in recent days about this. I should say, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's difficult on a day when we're talking about so many people worried about their job losses to sort of strike a positive note. But within everything that JLR have been saying, not only about protecting those sort of blue-collar production workers because they recognize they don't want to eat into their future as a company, is a reassurance that that investment pipeline will continue.

And beyond this difficult period, they and the supply chain will have a really bright future in this country.

03:55:31 - 03:55:32

Connor Naismith.

03:55:32 - 03:56:08

Connor James Naismith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will appreciate the concern that announcements of redundancies at major manufacturers like JLR will create for employees, families, and businesses across not just at JLR but across the wider supply chain and industry. In my constituency, Bentley Motors have invested hundreds of millions of pounds over the last decade. But I wonder what more the Government can do to support the UK automotive sector, and will he join me in welcoming the forthcoming launch of Bentley's first electric vehicle, the Torcal, on the 23rd of September?

03:56:08 - 03:57:00

Blair McDougall

Well, when my honourable friend mentioned the Torcal, I thought he was perhaps referring to the honourable member for Na h-Eileanan an Iar. But I was with Bentley in the Midlands at the Horiba testing facility for a round table to talk about exactly these issues the other day. And we're working very closely with the company on their plans for their next stage of activity, particularly with regards to making the most of the Indian trade deal for Bentley. I have to say I warmly congratulate them on the Torcal. I mean, some of the details about how high-end that vehicle is, a thousand layers of walnut veneer within the interior.

This is a seriously impressive product from a company with an incredible heritage.

03:57:00 - 03:57:01

Shaun Woodcock.

03:57:01 - 03:57:26

Speaker 164

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The automotive sector is hugely important to Banbury, with numerous companies supporting hundreds of jobs, including in the supply chain for Jaguar Land Rover. They will be nervous about the news over recent days. Can the Minister provide them and me with reassurance about the level of support that this Government will provide to them and other areas of the supply chain?

03:57:26 - 03:58:14

Blair McDougall

So, as I said a moment ago, the yes, the focus is rightly on Jaguar Land Rover and the individual workers, but we know that that will worry people, particularly as has been mentioned with the recent memory of the impact of the cyberattack on those supply chains. We are absolutely committed to investing in those supply chains, to learn the lessons of that attack and to invest in their resilience, which is why we're putting particular pots of money to the areas generally, but also through Drive 35, through the CAM pathfinders pots of money as well, ensuring that we're investing in that supply chain resilience, which is important for automotive but also important for defence and all sorts of other areas of advanced manufacturing.

03:58:14 - 03:58:53

Speaker 165

Well, that seems to be the end. The Minister will be happy with that. So we come to the conclusion of the Jaguar Land Rover redundancy. Shall I let the front benches shuffle over? Presentation of Bill.

John McDonnell.

03:58:53 - 03:58:55

John Martin McDonnell

Utility and Services Bill.

03:58:55 - 03:58:57

Speaker 160

Second reading what day?

03:58:57 - 03:58:59

Speaker 162

4th of December, Friday.

03:58:59 - 03:59:12

Andrew Graham Cooper

Friday the 4th of December. We now come to the Ten Minute Rule Motion, Personal Data (Digital Twins), Dame Siobhain McDonagh.

03:59:12 - 04:08:30

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring a bill to make provision about the regulation of software or algorithms which use or hold personal data for the purposes of modelling the preferences or behaviours of a person, to make provision about the rights of individuals in respect of the holding and use of their personal data by such software or algorithms, and for connected purposes.

Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, we know that tech companies collect data on everything we do, every click we make, every photo we share, every sandwich we buy, every post we like. But now that data is being combined with AI to turn an individual, for example you, Madam Deputy Speaker, into an algorithm to predict your behaviour, to target advertising at you, to persuade you to watch a particular video or believe a dodgy news report. Think about it: who is best able to persuade you to do or say something if not an automated version of yourself? And when the tech platforms have processed every action you make and applied AI to it, well that is what they have. It's called a digital twin and this bill will require explicit consent before digital twins of individuals can be made.

Now, in recognition both of the speed of technological change and the inventiveness of lawyers, the bill will use a technology-agnostic definition to capture a range of technologies which may be used to create digital twins. Madam Deputy Speaker, I may on occasion have mentioned that I am an engineer. I also want to put it on the record again that I am a tech evangelist. I believe tech can and should make life better for everyone. But this stealth digital twinning violates the integrity, uniqueness and very personhood of our constituents, of all of us.

Digital twins can take many forms, from content creation algorithms to deepfakes to chatbots which reflect aspects of your personality back at you. But it is particularly worrying when it's children who are the target. And these days kids are exposed to tech literally from the cradle. The AI camera in their cot, the smart toy on their pillow, chatbots which listen to what they say, smartphones teeming with apps to track every move. Now imagine if your child had a stranger who wanted to make money out of them following them around continuously from birth with a clipboard, noting everything they say and do, what they smile at, what they frown at, what makes them angry.

Because that is what is happening. The automated version of our kids will grow with them and with the power of AI, targeting advertising and products at them and worse. The Science, Innovation and Technology Select Committee has heard some of the tragic consequences of online grooming by algorithms and chatbots: a vulnerable boy persuaded to kill himself, a vulnerable girl fed more and more extreme dieting advice, children hooked and reeled into extreme behaviours and views. So my bill will expressly protect children from digital twinning. It is not possible for a child to meaningfully consent to the creation or use of a digital twin of themselves and parental consent cannot provide a substitute for this.

Now on deepfakes, His Holiness Pope Francis was the subject of one of the very first deepfake memes when a fake photo of him in a puffer jacket went viral. Since then deepfakes have proliferated. The honourable member for Mid Norfolk was shown crossing the floor in Parliament to join Reform, to his constituents' consternation and his.

It was a fake. And then there were the horrendous photos of women and girls naked that Elon Musk's AI created on demand. I want to place on record my thanks to the government for taking action on that so quickly. But deepfakes in general are not illegal. My bill would ensure that malicious deepfakes are tackled by protecting each of us from someone digitally replicating and altering our likeness without our consent.

I want to be clear, this bill does not ban digital twins. It simply requires that the actual human being who is being copied has to consent. Now, in the arts, entertainment and tech industries, many performers are agreeing to the creation and use of digital replicas as part of their work. Think of ABBA Voyage. But performers increasingly encounter unauthorised digital replicas of themselves, which pose a threat to their career, to their livelihood and to their reputation.

And there's no clear and reliable means of controlling and licensing likeness. Instead, performers must piece together a degree of protection from existing frameworks, all of which are uncertain and ill-suited. For those in the arts industry, the trade union Equity would like to see a contractual requirement. My bill does not go that far, but it establishes the principle that you cannot be impersonated. The current regulatory framework also does not address deepfake misinformation.

My social media feed was absolutely full of adverts showing Andrew Bailey and the member for Clacton fighting on Question Time. Now, there may be good reasons why the member for Clacton and Bailey disagree, but the fact is that this kind of deepfake harms public trust in media, undermines democratic institutions and can be used by state and non-state actors to foment unrest. Last year, my select committee's report on social media harms and algorithms called for the right to reset algorithms. We also recommended addressing the digital advertising which drives misinformation and for which so much data is collected. And this year, my select committee has heard from experts in child development about the impact of digital devices and indeed from the young people themselves.

And so I'd like to place on record my thanks to the organisations and the individuals from across academia and civil society who have contributed to making sure that the bill protects as many people as possible. I'm delighted to have the support of Equity, the Center for Countering Digital Hate, 5Rights, the Online Safety Network, Professor Ghislaine Boddington from the University of Greenwich and Professor Luke McDonagh from the LSE Law School, amongst many others. And I was also influenced by His Holiness Pope Leo's recent encyclical, Magnificence Humanity. He chose protecting the uniqueness of real people from AI impersonation as the subject of his very first letter to Catholics around the world. The Pope also highlighted how the billions on online digital twins, the billions of online digital twins constitutes an unprecedented concentration of power in the hands of a small number of men.

Madam Deputy Speaker, amongst the many consequences of the 40 years of neoliberalism repeatedly called out by the Prime Minister is a libertarian attitude to technology.

We are told governments are too slow and too stupid to shape tech and that the market knows best. The market will ensure the best, most innovative products and services are delivered to the people who need them and keep them safe in the process. I hope that we can all agree now that neoliberal libertarian complacency has not worked. The tech giants are hubs of amazing innovation, but as my committee has heard, they are controlled by a small number of extremely wealthy men without the usual corporate governance or competitive constraints. We need to limit their power with our democratic power to protect our citizens.

And what better way to do that than by giving power to people to control whether we are being copied by companies looking to make money out of us. Madam Deputy Speaker, there is only one you. We need to keep it that way.

04:08:30 - 04:08:44

Speaker 170

The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. As many as that opinion say aye. The contrary no. Ah, the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

04:08:44 - 04:09:02

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

Jess Asato, Rachel Gilmour, Neil Duncan-Jordan, Graham Downie, Gareth Thomas, Adam Jogee, Sir Roger Gale, Vera Hobhouse, Ayub Khan, Dame Caroline Dinenage, Jean Berry and myself.

04:09:02 - 04:09:41

Speaker 171

Dame Chi Onwurah. Personal Data (Digital Twins) Bill. Second reading what day? November the 13th. Right, if there's no more...

04:09:41 - 04:09:44

Speaker 168

On a point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:09:44 - 04:09:46

Luke Akehurst

Point of order, Luke Akehurst.

04:09:46 - 04:10:35

Luke Taylor

Thank you. Um, this afternoon the Metropolitan Police confirmed that a criminal investigation is underway into allegations of foreign money reaching Reform UK. Allegations under the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. The party denies any wrongdoing, it's right the police continue their investigation without any interference from this House. But we've just finished considering the Representation of the People Bill just a week ago.

It's now in the other place where it can be strengthened. I wonder if the Speaker's office or Madam Deputy Speaker has been given any indication that a minister intends to come to the House and update members on whether they feel that the government thinks that the measures in that bill are still sufficient. The public should not have to rely on an undercover reporter to reveal where their politics is being funded from. Thank you.

04:10:35 - 04:11:01

Andrew Graham Cooper

Um, the point of order and its content is not a matter for the chair. I have not been alluded to any minister coming forward at this point, but I've only just come into the chair. If the honourable member needs to seek further advice, there's no doubt the Speaker's office can let him know where he needs to go to further his point of order. If everybody is content, we'll now move on to the business. The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

04:11:01 - 04:11:07

Speaker 166

Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill [Lords], second reading.

04:11:07 - 04:14:25

Heidi Alexander

Now, Minister to move second reading, Secretary of State Heidi Alexander.

I beg to move that this bill be now read a second time. Madam Deputy Speaker, today is an important day as this bill starts on its Commons journey.

But it is a hard day on which to be talking about the criticality of our civil aviation sector given the disruption endured by so many over the last 24 hours. With your permission, I would just like to take a few moments to address this issue. A four-hour air traffic outage yesterday left hundreds of thousands of passengers facing cancellations, diversions, and delays. I would like to apologize wholeheartedly to passengers for this disruption. We often take for granted the way in which our aviation system just works, but yesterday that was not the case.

Safety must remain air traffic controllers' overriding priority. And this morning, I have spoken to NATS chief executive Martin Rolfe, who informed me this outage was due to a technical issue at their Swanwick site. So while my understanding from NATS is that we can rule out a cyberattack on this occasion, I do not believe this issue was unavoidable. We also spoke this morning about how NATS responded to resolve and minimize the disruption as quickly as possible. And I'm grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the airports and airlines who responded straight away.

But I am clear that passengers should not have to face this disruption. I have therefore asked the CAA to conduct an independent review to establish cause and ensure that our air traffic control systems can get passengers to where they need to be, and this review will report to me within six months. Madam Deputy Speaker, robust systems that support our national infrastructure are the bedrock of the measures contained in this bill, from better rights for disabled passengers and modernized airspace to slot reform and quicker enforcement of passenger rights. And whilst passengers undeniably experienced a bad day yesterday, it is still true to say that few industries match aviation's ability to adapt, evolve, and innovate. For generations, it has pushed the boundaries of what's possible, from faster aircraft and new destinations to safer technology and cleaner fuel.

Bad days like yesterday just serve to underscore how central aviation is to Britain's success, not only making our summer holidays and family reunions possible, but also connecting businesses to the global marketplace and supporting thousands of skilled jobs across our island nation. And right now, fresh challenges and fresh opportunities are emerging. Drones are beginning to transform our airspace. Flight numbers are climbing year after year. All this while global headwinds continue to put enormous pressure on the sector and those who depend upon it.

I will give way.

04:14:25 - 04:14:47

Tim Roca

I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. I'm really grateful as well for her updating the House on the NATS outage and what her and colleagues are doing to ensure that it's sorted with speed. Does she anticipate that the review that she's ordered will be the way that we make sure this never happens again, because so many of us have constituents who've been very badly and unacceptably impacted by these delays?

04:14:47 - 04:15:54

Heidi Alexander

My honorable friend is right to raise the impact on people who were caught up in this disruption. I've read reports of people having to sleep overnight in airports, people that have potentially missed weddings, and so we can't say enough about how important it is that we address this problem. Madam Deputy Speaker, I've learned in politics that absolute guarantees when it comes to managing the operation of a vast and complex transport system can be unwise. But what I can say to my honorable friend is that I will leave absolutely no stone unturned in understanding what has happened here and what can be done to drastically reduce the likelihood of something like this ever happening again. I do think we need to ask tough questions about resilience of NATS systems.

We need to ask questions about progress with planned upgrades.

And I think we also need to think about consumer redress issues as well. Madam Deputy Speaker, moving back to the bill. It is important to... I will give way, yes.

04:15:54 - 04:16:18

John Richard Holden

I'd like to thank the right honorable lady for her comments and also recognizing the issue around NATS. But would the honorable lady perhaps, given the importance of this to the House, make a statement tomorrow so that actually questions can be asked rather than in this situation of a second reading, actually on behalf of all members of the House who've got lots of questions around this serious and important matter?

04:16:18 - 04:17:38

Heidi Alexander

I'd say to the honorable gentleman, I'm keen to address these issues today. I think it's of significant importance and the public would rightly expect the Transport Secretary to answer questions here and now, stood at the dispatch box. And so any interventions that individuals wish to make, I'd be happy to take. Madam Deputy Speaker, moving back to the bill. Many colleagues will know that most civil aviation legislation is assimilated in... is assimilated EU law and the government's power to update it has now expired.

This bill will restore that power, giving government the flexibility to regulate at a pace which will enable us to keep up with the world around us. I should say I'm very grateful to my honorable friend, the Minister of State for Rail, for his excellent stewardship of this bill through the other place. And now, Madam Deputy Speaker, if I may, I would like to outline the main elements of this bill and what we hope it will achieve. Aviation serves millions of us well each year. But when things do go wrong, passengers must have confidence that they will be protected.

The bill will allow passenger rights to be bolstered through secondary legislation, helping us to tackle the issues that matter most. I would give way.

04:17:38 - 04:18:03

Thomas Gordon

I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. Other jurisdictions and other countries around the world have taken steps to look at the issue of fume events on board aircraft cabin. When such things happen, there's no requirement to engage and let passengers on planes know. And there's a lack of regulation and scrutiny around that. Would she meet with me and other members of the APPG for cabin air quality to look at this issue?

04:18:03 - 04:20:29

Heidi Alexander

The Aviation Minister has very kindly just said to me that he'd be very happy to meet with the honorable gentleman to discuss this in more detail. I know it's something that my officials are looking at. Madam Deputy Speaker, I do think that this bill can provide extra consumer protection on the things that matter most, whether it's about delays, cancellations, baggage, and very crucially on the issue of accessibility. The government did listen very carefully to concerns raised in the House of Lords about the experience of disabled passengers and those with reduced mobility. That's why we are committing to consult on a range of accessibility issues.

We want to hear directly from passengers about the problems they face and what we can do to make sure everyone feels safe and is able to fly. We've also acted immediately to scrap the unfair compensation cap for damaged wheelchairs and mobility equipment on domestic flights. These items are essential to the lives and livelihoods of many disabled people and lifting the cap reflects that reality. I hope the whole House agrees with me that this was absolutely the right thing to do. Madam Deputy Speaker, if I may now turn to enforcement.

The Civil Aviation Authority currently relies on slow and resource-intensive court action to secure redress for consumer protection issues. This bill will grant the CAA direct enforcement powers for consumer protection, bringing it in line with other regulators such as the Competition and Markets Authority. That means faster action when rules are broken, less burden on consumers to fight for what they're owed. Taken together, these measures will ensure all passengers have meaningful enforceable rights which help them to travel with ease and confidence. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill will also help to unlock the full potential of our aviation infrastructure, driving economic growth across the country.

The UK has some of the world's busiest and most complex airspace. Yet much of it is still based on designs from the 1950s. An aviation industry fit for the 21st century simply cannot rely on infrastructure that was built for the last. I will give way.

04:20:29 - 04:20:57

Andrew Dominic John Grady

Thanks Secretary of State for giving way. The UK aviation sector is one of the best in the world and in my constituency of Paisley and Renfrewshire North, Glasgow International Airport has been very successful recently in attracting new routes. Can the Secretary of State confirm that new further expansion is not going to be hindered going forward by slow regulatory frameworks?

04:20:57 - 04:21:50

Heidi Alexander

Madam Deputy Speaker, I would say to my honorable friend we want to move at pace and we want to move swiftly on these issues. And the provisions within this bill are designed to do that. I recognize the importance of the airport to her constituency and I look forward to discussing with her what more we can do to support that important economic hub for her constituency. Madam Deputy Speaker, I was talking about how our airspace is still based upon designs from the 1950s. And that's why this government believes that we must get on and move quickly to modernize that airspace for safety reasons, for reliability and capacity reasons, and for the communities who deserve cleaner and quieter skies.

I will give way.

04:21:50 - 04:22:27

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way. Many people in my constituency of Ealing Southall work in the nearby Heathrow Airport, so it's extremely important for jobs. But for many other of my constituents, the noise of the airport can be annoying to them and they worry about emissions too. Does she agree that the airspace modernization offers an opportunity to stop that stacking of aircraft over West London and to have quieter and cleaner aircraft to reduce noise and emissions? And would she also confirm that this bill will still allow local people to have a say on any decisions on airspace modernization?

04:22:27 - 04:24:38

Heidi Alexander

I can guarantee to my honorable friend that there will be meaningful consultation with local communities about airspace changes. This bill doesn't change the processes that are around that. I also say to my honorable friend that when it comes to matters of noise, I do appreciate the impact that this will have on local communities. Nothing in this bill changes the process that will happen, for example, in the case of expansion at Heathrow. She will be aware that the Heathrow National Policy Statement, the draft which we've consulted on, includes a proposal for a nighttime ban for six and a half hours between the hours of 11 and 7 in the morning.

And I can guarantee to her that I will continue to work with her and other colleagues in London on these very important and sensitive issues. Airspace modernization, Madam Deputy Speaker, is important to both tackle noise issues and reduce greenhouse gas emissions from aircraft.

If we can have planes pursuing simpler, more direct flight paths, that will reduce the amount of time that those planes are in the air. But the truth is, if we don't act on airspace modernisation, it will be passengers and businesses that end up paying the price, with up to one in five flights estimated to face significant disruption by 2040 unless we act. And that's why we've wasted no time in setting up the UK Airspace Design Service, which is already getting on with the job. This bill strengthens government's ability to ensure airspace changes which have been properly consulted on and approved are actually delivered. And we're also updating the rules on who can be charged for air traffic and air navigation services so costs can continue to be recovered fairly as new airspace users emerge.

And finally, we're making it easier for government to respond quickly and proportionately to pressure on the aviation sector. I'll give way.

04:24:38 - 04:25:19

John Milne

I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. With regard to noise specifically, the government recently changed the height at which noise is considered an important factor, reduced it from 7,000 down to 5,000 feet. So therefore, between 5 and 7, that noise is now has less impact in decision making. That was not meaningfully consulted on. It's a change that's just been made and now in force and everybody and could has an impact in my constituency and perhaps in many others.

Will she give comment now on how that decision was reached and is it changeable from here?

04:25:19 - 04:27:00

Heidi Alexander

It's not the case, Madam Deputy Speaker, that noise won't be considered in airspace design changes above 5,000 feet. It's about the relative balance between noise considerations and greenhouse gas emissions. We need to find a simpler way to make these changes because the previous mechanism was too cumbersome, and I believe that this is a sensible and proportionate change to make. Madam Deputy Speaker, I was talking about some of the changes that this bill will enable the government to be able to make in future so that we can be more responsive and flexible as a government. Honourable members will know that there has been significant uncertainty for the aviation sector given the conflict in the Middle East and the crisis there and the impact upon jet fuel.

A few months ago, my department introduced temporary changes to relax slot usage requirements and reduce disruption to passengers. However, some of these measures rely on powers that were put in place after leaving the EU, and the power I have to act in this way did expire in June. That was the reason why we took the decision we did before that point in time. This bill will introduce permanent powers, and therefore the bill will support, I believe, a more agile and resilient approach to the regulation of airport slots. This means that the UK can continue to act decisively when appropriate, safeguarding passengers and maintaining airport capacity.

I'll give way first there and then I'll come there.

04:27:00 - 04:27:26

Andrew Dominic John Grady

I thank the Secretary of State for giving way again. Airspace modernisation has been consulted on in Scotland. Will she do everything she can to ensure that the Scottish airports' airspace change modernisation programme remains a priority with NATS?

04:27:26 - 04:28:04

Heidi Alexander

We have looked to prioritise airspace work on airspace changes in the London region given the importance and the benefits that that could bring to London and the South East.

I am aware that there has been agreement over the summer to resume work on airspace modernization in Scotland, which will be of importance to her constituents. And we've got to get the balance right about bringing benefit quickly to the communities that are currently looking for improvements to improve the quality of life of her and her constituents. I give way to my honorable friend.

04:28:04 - 04:29:04

John Martin McDonnell

Thanks. I apologize, my right honorable friend. I should have checked this before the debate itself. But on the page 19 of the legislation, it refers to the new section 61G, priorities and objectives of the Secretary of State. This includes a requirement on the Secretary of State to issue a document that sets out the government's priorities and objectives overall for the CAA.

So it's quite, it's the guiding light from government to the CAA for that, which includes issues around how they consult, how the CAA consults, how it takes on board environmental principles and a whole range of things. Is this new document to be published after the legislation? Or have I, and I apologize for this, have I missed something? Is there a document already that's been produced? So it seems quite fundamental to me.

If it's a revised document, could we have her view on the timetable for the publication of it?

04:29:04 - 04:32:24

Heidi Alexander

I produce regularly a priorities letter for the Civil Aviation Authority setting out my priorities. And I'd be happy to write in detail about the timeline for my honorable friend as he requests. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is also about improving safety. This government is determined that UK airspace remains amongst the safest in our world, in the world. Yet our current safety framework is fragmented and cumbersome to update.

It holds back innovation and it puts the UK at risk of falling behind on its international obligations. To fix this, the bill will hand over responsibility for technical aviation safety and operational rule-making to the CAA. This is not a blank check. It follows a well-established model in which trusted regulators make rules within boundaries set by Parliament. Indeed, ministerial and parliamentary oversight was strengthened during scrutiny in the other place.

The bill also reinstates government's ability to update or create aviation safe, aviation safety-related criminal offenses in assimilated legislation, which was lost after EU exit. This will allow safety rules to keep up with international standards while making sure they are enforced consistently now and in the future. These steps will create a clearer, more workable system, one that maintains the UK's strong safety record and sustains public confidence in air traffic. Now, I know that some honorable members will be interested in what this bill means for airport expansion, expansions. Let me be clear that this bill does not determine whether any airport should expand, nor does it change the processes around that.

The measures before the House are sector-wide reforms that will support a safe, efficient, and resilient aviation industry. Questions about airport expansion will continue to be considered separately outside of the bill process. Madam Deputy Speaker, in conclusion, despite a bad day yesterday, for over 100 years, aviation has refused to stand still.

The industry remains at the forefront of innovation and progress, taking every challenge and every opportunity in its stride. Quite simply, the type of country we want to be, aspirational, outward-looking, full of opportunity, depends upon giving this industry the tools that it needs to go from strength to strength. The Civil Aviation Bill will do just that, bringing passenger protections into the 21st century, unlocking sustainable growth that works for our communities, and maintaining the UK's safety record in an ever-changing world. I hope honourable and right honourable members will agree that this is not a government that drags its feet. We've moved swiftly to address the concerns raised by the Lords, particularly on accessibility, accountability, and passenger protections.

Government has not just listened, but we've acted, and I believe that provides a strong foundation for the bill to continue its passage. I commend this bill to the House.

04:32:24 - 04:36:46

John Richard Holden

The question is that the bill be now read a second time, and I call the Shadow Transport Secretary of State, Richard Holden.

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I turn to the bill, the events of the last 24 hours have shown just how important effective oversight of our aviation sector is. The shocking failure at NATS has left hundreds of thousands of passengers in a lurch, and serious questions have been raised about the resilience of our air traffic control system and aviation infrastructure. As we consider legislation giving further functions to the CAA, we must therefore ensure that proper parliamentary scrutiny and ministerial accountability are not lost. When something goes this badly wrong, the House must be able to demand answers.

Now, it was my understanding, having spoken to the Speaker earlier today, that the urgent question which my party put forward, and an urgent question from the Liberal Democrats, were not accepted because there was assurances made from the government that there would be a statement tomorrow in this House. The government could have chosen to make a statement today, and it didn't, it chose to prioritize other matters. So if the Secretary of State would like to intervene on me and say that there will be a statement tomorrow in which all members can ask proper questions on what has happened, I would welcome that. Otherwise, again, a second reading debate is not the right place for questions and answers to be taken, in fact only one honourable member from our own benches has done that. It's not an appropriate way to do it.

So if the honourable member, if the honourable right honourable lady would like to confirm there'll be a statement tomorrow, if not then I'm afraid it looks like there's been a serious miscommunication with the Speaker's office and the government front bench. Sorry, is the honourable member wanting to speak from a sedentary position or does he want to come to the dispatch box and speak? Okay, well if he doesn't want to answer the questions then we'll have to drag him to the House tomorrow to answer those questions. Well yes, if the honourable member would like to speak he can stand at the dispatch box. No, the minister doesn't want to do that.

Okay, fine. Well we'll have him here tomorrow then, because we were told today that our urgent question wouldn't be accepted because the minister would be making a statement. So we'll have to see whether that actually happens. Having said all that, I would actually like to welcome the engagement from the Secretary of State and ministers in the other House on this bill, and actually the engagement that's taken place so far on this matter as well. That engagement has been very welcome and I would like to see it continue and I hope it can.

I'd also like to say that the opposition agree with the stated aims of the bill, namely to promote economic growth and infrastructure development, to strengthen consumer rights and protections, and thirdly to enhance aviation security. For those reasons we will not be dividing on the second reading today. I'd also agree with the Secretary of State's observation in a letter to colleagues of the 1st of September that the contribution of noble Lords have helped strengthen this legislation before the House today.

At its core, this is a broadly administrative bill, and we on these benches recognize that, especially as the Secretary of State highlighted, following our exit from the European Union, certain measures must be taken to ensure that regulatory gaps are indeed filled, and continuity is maintained in a way that ultimately keeps Britain's aviation industry working safely. This bill pays much attention to consumer rights and associated protections. As we on this side of the House welcome important parts of that agenda, indeed I appreciate her department showing some flexibility on these issues, particularly with regard to safeguarding disabled passengers. However, I should ask that, given this violent agreement between her and me on these matters, which I confess, Madam Deputy Speaker, isn't always the way across this dispatch box, I am slightly puzzled by one item. Why on earth did her party whip members in the other place to vote against a review of airport drop-off charges?

Why is it, Madam Deputy Speaker, that passengers are paying such exorbitant drop-off charges? Well, it would appear that the government doesn't want us to know that. Why is it, as the Times has reported, that charges at Gatwick now reach ten pounds for ten minutes, while Luton, under Labour-run Luton Council, have increased from two pounds to seven pounds?

04:36:46 - 04:37:20

Vikki Slade

I thank the Shadow Secretary of State for giving way on that. In Bournemouth, the prices have now gone up to eight pounds, and yet there are no buses to Bournemouth Airport. There are two buses that go at six in the morning and they come back at six in the evening, which serve the industrial estate, they don't serve the staff, they don't serve the passengers, and it's impossible for people to get there any other way. Does he agree with me that these should be restricted or banned until such time as the airport puts in alternatives for all passengers?

04:37:20 - 04:40:49

John Richard Holden

Well, the honorable lady makes a very clear case as to why such a review of airport parking charges is necessary. One hasn't happened for a decade, and it was great to get the support of Liberal Democrats in the other place backing Lord Moylan and the Conservative proposals on that space. So I hope that it's something that now it's in the bill, the government won't seek to remove. In any case, there are obviously concerns around the impact that surface access targets have had on some of these airport parking charges as well, especially when, as honorable members have already made clear, that genuine alternatives often do not properly exist or are incredibly expensive. I genuinely find it difficult to believe that the Secretary of State herself doesn't believe that there is a single link between Gatwick having a minimum target of more than half of passengers getting to and from the airport by public transport and soaring drop-off charges.

I hope that this perfectly reasonable proposal for a review that puts passengers first and allows that to take place will not be removed from this bill, and it'd be great to hear later if the Secretary of State or the Minister winding up does intend to actually stick with that important review which was inserted against the Labour Party's wishes in the House of Lords. Another point on this is also worth mentioning, and it's a part of the bill with the power rearranges and all the re-regulations that enables. It does offer a remarkably little vision for where British aviation should actually be heading. The government has talked in the past a lot about growth, yet have refused to set tangible targets to deliver it, whether in this aviation bill or indeed in the rail bill regarding passenger growth as well. We on these benches understand that economic growth and the competition that fuels it are essential, not merely to the success of individual airports and airlines, but to indeed to maintaining Britain's global reputation as one of the world's outstanding aviation nations.

Yet too often this government appears to regard the aviation industry as less an engine of growth and more as an ATM. Indeed, members opposite seem to be beset with some Tigger-like pleasure at finding new costs to impose on businesses while growing the welfare bill rather more successfully than they are growing the economy. Ministers must understand that every additional burden, every tax, whether that's air passenger duty or the business rates, are having huge impacts on aviation. I was with Manchester Airport Group recently, and they're now facing an effective tax rate of 77% when you combine corporation tax and business rates after facing an over 100% increase in their business rates. And it's not them alone, it's airports up and down the country facing huge increases in tax.

So I think it'd be really important I think for ministers to address that as part of those broader concerns around growth. Every charge deters investment and makes new jobs, new routes, and greater passenger choice that little bit harder to deliver. That principle must apply too to the new powers being given to the CAA. So can the Secretary of State assure the House that significant new regulatory safety and airspace decisions will be evidence-based, proportionate, and subject to the proper assessment of their costs and benefits? I happily give way to my honorable friend.

04:40:49 - 04:41:12

Andrew Snowden

I thank my honorable friend for giving way, just to touch on the point he made earlier rightly on the tax increases that airports have faced when combined with business rates and increased regulations. Airports like Blackpool where we're trying to build a business case for commercial flights coming out of Blackpool again, things like this make it really hard for airports who are trying to reopen and do new routes. Does he agree that that's something that should be looked at?

04:41:12 - 04:44:36

John Richard Holden

I'd like to thank my honorable friend for that. Obviously the airspace does not exist within this bill alone. There are huge implications for those tax changes, and whether it's a Blackpool airport or a Humberside airport, which I visited recently, who are facing real life and death pressures as to whether they will continue to be going concerns. And actually it's not just about them themselves and the jobs that they create directly, it's about the connectivity that is provided by those airports for the entire regions which they serve as well. So I think the honorable member makes an incredibly important point on that.

So I fear that as has been the case with too much legislation of late, that this bill leaves plenty of questions up there in the air. Where are the measures to secure the future of the workforce, our mechanics, our engineers, the next generation of skilled workers? Where are the measures to ease the burdens surrounding apprenticeships, an issue raised with me directly by the apprentices I met at Heathrow recently? Why is there no indication of how to champion our excellent aviation colleges at airports, like the one at Stansted I had the pleasure of visiting recently? Where is the plan to tackle pilot shortages?

Has she not received representations calling for the government to assist with pilot recruitment and training, or is she just turning a deaf ear to them? Where is the vision for Britain being a world leader in single-aisle aircraft manufacturing, something industry actually knows it's clamoring for from the rafters? I know the Secretary of State is incredibly busy selling out taxpayers to the latest meeting of her union barons who have her over a barrel. I know she was apparently too busy to join me or many of the shadow ministerial team at the Farnborough Airshow recently. And in fact, my understanding is that not one single minister from the DfT actually went to Farnborough this year.

Perhaps she could correct me if not. Europe's largest airshow, a symbol to the world of Britain's openness and leading edge in aviation. It does seem quite bizarre that as they all sat there waiting for the reshuffle that none of them popped down. Maybe it shows actually this government's general view of aviation, that it's just not interested. But you know, I mean it does seem shocking that the ministerial team didn't get there.

If they don't want to do the job, rather than shouting at me from sedentary positions, we can just swap sides of the House, Madam Deputy Speaker. Finally, too often it seems this department is in the business of delaying bills with drafting left to the last moment, then tabling realms, reams, sorry, of amendments to its own legislation before expressing surprise that the opposition might wish to scrutinise what has happened. We will not oppose sensible measures simply for the sake of it. Of course we welcome stronger passenger protections where they're needed, of course we want the highest possible standards of safety and security, but we also want a bill that really backs Britain's aviation sector, backed by a ministerial team who also back Britain's aviation sector, and also a bill which gives that sector the space to succeed and an economic environment to succeed in too, to create the conditions needed for competition, innovation and enterprise to thrive. In that vein, I look forward to the opportunity to table amendments at committee so that we can hopefully work together to improve the bill as honourable members from this side did in another place as well, to ensure that British aviation remains safe and is more competitive and remains world-leading.

Thank you very much.

04:44:36 - 04:45:06

Andrew Graham Cooper

Before I ask any other members to contribute, I just need to set the record straight. You can be seated. Government statements are within the gift of government. UQs are private and confidential conversations between members and the Speaker and should not be speculated on inside or outside of the chamber. And government statements are in the, are within the gift of the government of the day.

I now go to Ruth Cadbury.

04:45:06 - 04:49:32

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to say it's a pleasure following the Shadow Secretary of State for Transport, and I think most people here today will want to address obviously the incident that happened yesterday and the implications on passengers and the aviation sector. And more importantly, of course, the reason we are here is the bill today, and most of my remarks, unlike the previous speaker, will actually focus primarily on those. So it is an unfortunate coincidence that today's debate takes place the day after hundreds of thousands of passengers travelling to and from the UK had their journeys seriously disrupted by another outage by NATS. And given that the title of this bill is the Civil Aviation Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform Bill, so many passengers have been and many still will be frustrated and angry with what's happened, their plans in tatters, which of course not only affects them, the passengers, but their friends, their families, and if they're on work journeys, colleagues and business associates. I must put a word of praise and thanks in for all those working in aviation too, having to support and advise frustrated passengers, having to make alternative arrangements for them, and for many staff, especially aircrew, not being able to get home last night.

Our thanks and gratitude are with you. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is the third major outage of our air traffic control system in the last three years, and there's clearly widespread frustration within the sector about the system's resilience. The CAA report into the 2023 outage eventually reported the following year. It had 34 recommendations, but as of last year's interim report update by the CAA, of the 34 recommendations, only 18 had been completed.

So I thank the Secretary of State for her remarks at the start of this speech in saying that she will be reporting to the House, and she's also said that she will be delivering, she will ask NATS to do a rapid review of the incident, and she's asked for preliminary findings by next week. Now, whilst NATS say these incidents are unrelated, I hope that when she does update the House on the progress on ensuring that we learn the right lessons from 2023 and this outage, we can then start addressing the issues that I know many of us and the aviation sector have about the resilience of this key part of our national infrastructure. I know that she will be coming to the House, and I hope that she will also be coming to committee in due course. Now, linking yesterday's incident with the bill that we're here to debate, there are many questions that passengers, freight handlers, and airlines are asking about their rights when their flights are delayed or cancelled, whatever the reason. Tens of thousands of people slept on airport floors once again last night.

So I want to ask, are passenger rights fit for purpose, and will the bill and the following regulations look at this and hopefully address and improve it? Airlines, we know that airlines are responsible for providing refunds or rerouting for cancelled flights, as well as providing for the care and assistance, such as refreshments, while passengers are waiting for their flight or whatever hotel they end up in. Yes, of course.

04:49:32 - 04:50:13

Vikki Slade

I wonder if the honorable member would like to reflect on an incident that happened to me over the summer, where I was flying back from a family holiday, and our flight was continually delayed, and we kept getting extraordinary circumstances, which we know is code for you won't get compensation. And throughout the wait, that was the message, until we got on the plane, when the pilot told us the truth. And he told us a list of all of the things that had happened, and I believe he told us so that it would help us to know that it wasn't extraordinary circumstances. Would she agree with me that removal of that phrase needs to be key in changing passenger rights?

04:50:13 - 04:55:46

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

The honorable member, in her description of her holiday experience, has happened to so many of our constituents. And frankly, people, there's two issues. One is getting information regularly, updates, or even as we know from yesterday, one pilot who every 20 minutes had the decency to say, look, I don't know what's happening, but at least he assured, you know, at least that gave some assurance to the passengers waiting in that plane. So that is one thing. And the other thing is, whatever the cause of the problem, and whoever ultimately pays the cost of whatever needs doing, passengers need, they need toilets, they need refreshments, they need a bed for the night, or at least somewhere comfortable to sleep, etc., etc.

So, for instance, should airports have supplies of camp beds and emergency drinks and snacks, baby food, etc., along with allocated trained staff able to come in at short notice to support passengers, so that they're ready for these incidents?

I mean, our local authorities have contingency plans and stores in case of incidents such as homes having to be evacuated, and many of us have had to deal with those kind of experiences. So maybe airports could learn something from our local authorities, who don't start asking who's going to pay or telling one tenant and one resident they're not eligible and another is. They open the doors, there is a set contingency plan, community centers open up, etcetera, etcetera. It's not rocket science. So I'm going to now go back to the bill, and firstly what is in it and then I'll cover what I would like to see in it in an ideal world.

So passenger rights and protection for disabled passengers. I particularly welcome that passengers with wheelchairs and other expensive mobility aids will now benefit from the removal of the limit on compensation. I regret that at this point it can only apply to domestic UK flights, but I hope that this is an example of the UK leading the way and that this basic right can be extended for travelers to and from other countries. And I would particularly want to mention the work that the Member for Bexleyheath and Crayford has been doing, the chair of the APPG for wheelchair users, who sadly wasn't able to be here this afternoon, but the work he's been doing as the parent of a wheelchair user, but on behalf of all wheelchair users, trying to have a normal family holiday without and their family member being treated with respect as we all expect to be when we travel through airports. But I would like to say that's great, I mean that's all the problems solved, but it hasn't.

Disabled people are still facing a patchy experience as they travel through our airports, and our report published early last year, called Access Denied, did come across a number of issues for disabled passengers at our airports. And one of the issues is the variable quality of contractors at airports. There's a huge gulf between the best and the worst experiences that disabled passengers face. There's no single standard, and I would ask the government if some kind of single standard of treatment could be hardwired so and that airports be made accountable, or airports and airlines as well, and rather than what too often happens is that airports and airlines pass the buck when a disabled passenger is stuck on a plane or trying to get on a plane. Some airports like Gatwick have put disabled passengers on their forums to ensure that passenger experience is vetted, and there's a good example of good practice that should be the norm.

And when we're talking about accessibility at airports, they need to also consider how accessible the public transport links at the airport are. And my experience is too often the airports' response, the airports feel that their responsibility stops at the perimeter fence and that the public transport issues are someone else's problem. On wider passenger issues, I welcome in the bill the strengthened powers for the CAA on consumer rights and safety, and I look forward to the Transport Secretary's drafting of the secondary legislation on these matters, which are going to cover issues that all our constituents raise: flight disruption, lost or damaged luggage, accessibility as I've mentioned, price transparency, and airline liability for passenger injury or death.

04:55:46 - 04:56:46

Speaker 182

I appreciate her giving away, giving an excellent speech, and I commend the government for bringing this bill. Reflecting on what she said and the focus the government has had on taking away barriers for consumers and our constituents to be able to assert their rights, especially in the cost of living challenges we face, I wonder if she agrees with me that there may be a lesson for the secretary of state to reflect on from the automated delay repay that we see with rail, whereby if there are delays over a certain period, there is an automated compensation that transfers to constituents. And reflecting on experience as a colleague across the house had, myself and the experience I had with Iberia, where still to this day hundreds and hundreds of pounds that my husband and I are owed, which is not automatically been transferred to us and that we have to put lengthy time into compensation claims. Why is it not the case that these rights, which extend to all our constituents, should be automatically, that made automatic on the airline companies? And is there something in that that perhaps the secretary of state could reflect on when she is drafting the secondary legislation to which she's referring?

04:56:46 - 04:58:02

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

My honorable friend makes a very good point, and I think our the delay repay system that we now take for granted in a way on our rail system, except on Eurostar, you know, is a good model. And I agree with him that the airlines could could be looking could be looking at this, and I hope the the minister will be able to consider it as well. Now I now want to move on to airport drop-off charges. I really do welcome the review, but I'd like to see the review go wider. Why do so many of our constituents at most of our airports feel that the only way to get to the airport reliably is to get a lift?

How useful, reliable, and accessible is public transport to many airports? Even Heathrow Airport, which in theory is has lots of public transport, far more than any other airport in this country, but it's only public transport that is going between London and Heathrow, not from the southwest or north, unless you get a coach from Reading.

04:58:02 - 04:58:25

Andrew Dominic John Grady

Thank the honorable lady for giving way. On that note of connectivity to airports, she will be aware because we've discussed it in the past that there is no rail link to Glasgow International Airport. In fact, you can get a train from Glasgow Central Station to Manchester Airport, but you cannot get a train to Glasgow Airport from Glasgow Central Station. And does she have anything to comment on that matter?

04:58:25 - 04:59:04

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Am I right that you also the you have to walk some way to get to the bus to get the bus to the airport? I mean, talk about a lack of joined-up thinking in terms of our public transport, and in this instance I do include flying. I fear in this respect the UK is an embarrassment, and when we travel on holiday or for other reasons, we can see we can compare our airports with those that we travel to, and often the comparison is not very complimentary to the UK.

04:59:04 - 04:59:42

Danny Beales

Thanks to my honorable friend for giving way, to give an excellent, very thorough speech based on her and her committee's work. I agree with everything she said. The one caveat I would say is that even for those living a stone's throw from the airport, there often aren't public transport links in my own constituency or my neighbor's constituency as well.

Many people who work at the airport cannot get by public transport directly on one bus to the airport. And so are forced to drive, are forced to pay drop-off charges or park in questionable places causing disruption to communities. So doesn't she agree much more needs to be done by airports around public transport?

04:59:42 - 05:01:18

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Absolutely. And as I say, I've lived for almost 40 years with dealing with Heathrow on the issue of their lack of interest in transport. And as he is to the north of Heathrow, I know full well what he's saying. In fact, with the Terminal 5 planning decision, that one of the Section 106 conditions was that there should be a direct bus between Feltham station and the central terminal area, not stopping, that would then create, and that was long before the Elizabeth line, create a fast link from Waterloo to Heathrow. But nobody marketed it, and nobody told anybody about it.

So funnily enough, when the funding gave out, there hadn't been enough passengers to make it viable, so it didn't survive. And you know, there again and again I can think of examples. I know that many tourists, because I sometimes come in on the Piccadilly and the District line, I know many tourists use that from Heathrow and might go to say South Kensington to stay in hotels. I've had to help an elderly couple up and down stairs who've come from Heathrow. And you have to go downstairs and then upstairs at South Kensington.

You know, it's just not a welcoming environment for visitors to this country. I do, obviously the Elizabeth line has transformed that and you know, is helping, but it was long overdue. I do need to move on.

05:01:18 - 05:01:53

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member and my neighbor for giving way. She mentions the Elizabeth line, which of course we cannot miss out when we're talking about connectivity to Heathrow, and it has transformed my constituents' life. But in line with my neighbor from Uxbridge and South Ruislip, whose constituents appear to be throwing stones at the airport, mine aren't. Could I also raise the issue of overcrowding on the Elizabeth line? And I know that that is being looked at and there is potential for further trains, because I think particularly in the rush hour and when lots of people have cases, it can be a nightmare for some of my constituents.

05:01:53 - 05:04:37

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Yes, the Elizabeth line if anything has been a product of its own success and why it was right to fight for Crossrail all those years ago. So let me get, and I will actually come back to this issue about the link between what airports provide and what the actuality is. So, as I say, compared to our international competitors, public transport to and from airports is woeful, non-existent at night or in the early morning, and what there is is impossible too often for those with heavy luggage. I find it frustrating that airport expansion proposals around at the moment, Gatwick has got all its approvals, Heathrow is now in front of our committee, the National Policy Statement, it's frustrating that they're able to proceed without the rail access that everyone agrees is needed, yet our desperately needed train services are just not there. I also find that compared to most other countries, access for taxis, private hire, buses and coaches is generally an afterthought or an inconvenience.

And unless we address these wider issues, reviewing drop-off charges is scratching the surface and passengers will continue to feel that they, or rather the person who's giving them the lift, are being fleeced. I now want to quickly touch on airspace modernization. It's long overdue. It will cut carbon emissions and time in the air, which will be good for passengers and will be good for the climate.

I was concerned about the potential of what was called noise sewers of the corridors of noise across parts of the country. But if the paths are sufficiently wide, and NATS told me I think they're 10 kilometers or even 10 miles wide, I believe the noise implications will be much less than was feared. But as I say, the Transport Committee have not yet had a chance to look at the issue. I now want to cover what is not in the bill that I think should be. One is staff safety.

Unite, GMB and the other unions at the airports across our civil airports are calling for a clear national worker-led approach and response to the increase in the abusive and disruptive passenger behavior that they're facing. And a recent survey by Unite the Union found that 90% of workers in one airport had faced abuse at work. We have...

05:04:37 - 05:04:58

Amanda Hack

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. GMB, the union that operate from East Midlands Airport, one of their members told me that it was unusual if she hadn't received her first abusive customer by 5:00 AM. So I think there is some real merit in actually seeing how we can make sure our workers in our airports are treated appropriately.

05:04:58 - 05:09:25

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

I thank my honorable friend for that. I mean, we have railway behavior notices. So I wonder will the government work with airlines, airports and the trade unions to consider a similar type standard and process in the aviation sector. On EU and UK standards, the UK risks being left behind by the failure to reach an agreement with the EU on a number of issues. But for instance, a faulty emergency services helicopter which needed a spare part was unable to use the one stored at a local airport as it was from the EU.

And there are probably other examples. And in terms of recruitment and retention, the UK has long been an attractive place for pilots and engineers to come and work. And we want to continue that growth. But the industry is in real need for a mutual recognition agreement with the EU because it's impacting training, mobility of the workforce and recruitment. I now want to move on to noise.

For my constituents around Heathrow, those who have lived locally for some time know what the noise patterns are. Two-thirds of my constituents are under one or other of the approach paths used for 70% of the time when the airport is operating on westerly operation and the planes are coming from central London towards Heathrow. Planes are overhead every 60 to 90 seconds for half the day because we have daily alternation. So to some extent, residents can plan when to be in the garden, when to have friends around, etc. But for newcomers to the area, this information about where and when aircraft noise... they struggle to find the information they need.

And of course, there'll be a whole host of further tens of thousands of more residents in parts of Hillingdon, Ealing and Hounslow who will be underneath the new approach path and don't even know it at the moment should that expansion go ahead. Now, there is a noise insulation scheme at most airports. But as a constituency MP, I find it difficult to know which of my constituents are eligible for how much spent on works and by when.

And due to the timing of schemes being approved for different airports as a condition of their planning permission, there is a lack of uniformity across the country around what what these schemes have in terms of sound insulation, ventilation and so on. And the constituents are very unsure about who or what, well and MPs are as well unsure of who or what the appropriate body is to regulate noise. And noise insulation is only one example of the various mitigation measures that airports are required to implement. But for us MPs and our councils and councillors, there isn't a body with teeth that can ensure that any mitigation measures are enforced, let alone whether or not they're adequate, particularly in terms of expansion. This can include public transport as I've touched on, various community benefit schemes, environmental recovery and enhancements and so on.

And this lack of teeth, this lack of ability to be clear of the delivery of the mitigation has come up again and again in evidence to the Transport Committee on our current inquiry on Heathrow expansion. And I do ask the Transport Secretary and the Aviation Minister to look and see whether the CAA or another body can be given the powers and the teeth that I fear and I know aren't there at the moment. So that, in conclusion, I hope that the bill could be further improved beyond the safety and passenger rights that are in the bill and will be in subsequent legislation. Thank you.

05:09:25 - 05:13:05

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Olly Glover.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I start by joining the Secretary of State in thanking the House of Lords in their work developing this bill? And I'd like to pay a particular thanks to the Liberal Democrat peer team led by the noble Baroness Grender. I'd also like to start by noting that it has been a season of reshuffles and by congratulating the Secretary of State, the Minister for Aviation and indeed the Shadow Secretary of State for their reconfirmed appointments in recent reshuffles. It remains to be seen whether I survive the next Liberal Democrat one.

Now there is much to be encouraged, there is much to be encouraged by in this bill. It necessarily fills some gaps in our aviation regulation resulting from our leaving the European Union. It brings potential for improving passenger rights and it enables modernisation of our airspace, which has not been done for decades, which includes air traffic control, landing slots and optimising main routes to and from airports. Now of course the point about air traffic control is indeed very timely following yesterday's NATS Holdings air traffic control disruption, which is a fresh reminder of the need for reliability. And perhaps the one thing I would agree with in the Shadow Secretary of State's speech is that this is a somewhat unorthodox way for the government to be accountable using a second reading debate on a new bit of legislation.

And I think it is a matter of regret that the government has not decided to grant a statement to the House on that important disruption yesterday. However, we do have some concerns about the bill. The bill as drafted relies far too heavily on delegated powers and secondary legislation. By leaving critical details to future ministerial regulation, the government is bypassing meaningful parliamentary oversight and leaving passengers and local communities without robust statutory safeguards. The bill as it stands also grants sweeping powers to the Civil Aviation Authority.

Consequently, the bill could be used to support more flights at any cost. And we will be looking to the government to positively engage with amendments that would make all changes to airspace utilisation subject to strict caps on noise, carbon emissions, night operations and accompanying improving surface transport to and from airports to reduce their road congestion impact.

Now, I note the assurances given by the Secretary of State that airport expansion is not something that is connected to this bill, but we will fight to ensure that new powers in this bill cannot be used to facilitate airport expansion through the back door, and that Parliament is properly involved in any future proposals that impact our environment. Liberal Democrats will also be calling for the bill to go much further by adopting a genuinely passenger-first approach, with a focus on passengers with disabilities who are so often let down by their experience of aviation travel. Critically, we want to see a statutory air passengers' charter written onto the face of the bill to enshrine these rights in law, tackling issues such as inconsistent luggage rules, airport drop-off charges, and disruption and compensation arrangements. At this stage, we support the premise of the bill as modernization is clearly needed. However, our support at further stages will be conditional on positive engagement with our proposals for putting passengers first and environmental safeguards.

Specifically, modernization must be used to make the most of what we have, rather than increase the noise, carbon emissions, nighttime, and ground road congestion impacts of aviation. Only if the government gives assurances in subsequent stages that the bill will do this, and that it will properly commit to advancing passenger rights and protections, will it retain our support.

05:13:05 - 05:21:26

Andrew Graham Cooper

Oh, my apologies. Distracted by colleagues, my apologies. I turn to Andrew Cooper. Your lucky day.

It certainly is, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you. I'm pleased to speak in support of this bill this afternoon. The UK has and continues to be a proud, open, and outward-looking nation, a nation of traders, travelers, adventurers, and explorers, and increasingly, a nation of people wondering why it costs quite so much to drop somebody off at an airport. For the 302 million passengers that passed through UK airports last year, whether for work or a week in the sun, they rely on an aviation sector that is safe, efficient, and treats passengers fairly. And for everyone else who may not be regular aviators, it is important that we are in the best possible position to support economic growth, hand in hand with efforts to decarbonize the sector.

For my constituents in Northwich, Winsford, and Middlewich, the aviation sector is a key source of employment, as home to Jet2's retail operations center and close to two major international airports, the Airbus manufacturing site in Broughton, and aviation fuel production facilities in Ellesmere Port. Madam Deputy Speaker, we once again find ourselves in the unenviable position of having to legislate to mitigate against the haphazard and chaotic manner in which we left the EU. Aviation is one of the clearest examples of an industry where cooperation across borders is not an optional extra, but an absolute necessity. Rules governing safety, consumer rights, and the operation of our airspace cannot sensibly be considered in isolation. Regardless of individual views on Brexit, I hope there is an agreement across this House that Parliament has a duty to make the system work effectively and that protecting the rights of travelers must be at the heart of that effort.

One area where the bill is especially welcome is its focus on disabled passengers. The principle it establishes is an important one, that disabled people should be able to access air travel on an equal basis with everyone else. But this is not simply a question of physical disability. It also concerns neurodiversity, mental health conditions, and passengers whose needs may not always be immediately visible.

I know as a parent of a neurodivergent child myself, that for many neurodivergent travelers, airports can be overwhelming environments. And that's why facilities such as the Sunflower Room at the now closed Terminal 1 at Manchester Airport were so valuable. Having used this space myself and ones like it at other airports, I know firsthand that it provides a quiet space for passengers who find the main airport environment overstimulating. It's quite a good example of what thoughtful accessibility can look like. It's a relatively cheap and simple intervention, but for someone who might otherwise find the experience of traveling through an airport so overstimulated that it becomes a barrier to flying at all, it can make an enormous difference.

Manchester Airport has done some genuinely good work in this area on Terminal 1, which I hope will be replicated in Terminal 2 in due course, as well as the work many airports do by recognizing the sunflower lanyard and helping passengers with non-visible disabilities avoid some of the busiest and most overwhelming parts of the terminal. I would certainly like to see a similar approach adopted across the aviation sector and for such innovations to become norm. As the Government undertakes its consultation in this area, I hope ministers will study examples of best practice and consider whether facilities of this kind could provide a blueprint for airports across the country. I'm also pleased that the Bill addresses practical issues that disabled people face all too often. Everyone in this House will have heard distressing stories of disabled travelers being left on aircraft long after other passengers have disembarked because assistance was unavailable or because of wheelchairs and mobility aids being lost, damaged, or mishandled.

These are not minor inconveniences. They can severely affect a person's independence and frankly their dignity. For that reason, I particularly welcome the removal of the liability limit where wheelchairs, mobility aids, and other medical devices are lost or damaged on domestic flights. That is a sensible and necessary reform which recognizes the essential nature of such devices and the impact that it can have on passengers who rely on them. The Bill also provides an opportunity to reflect on the wider passenger experience, including drop-off charges and getting to the airport.

For those living in my constituency, the Manchester Airport Western Link, first proposed by British Rail in the 1990s, would represent an important opportunity to improve connectivity and make everyday journeys easier. Better access to the airport would not only improve the experience of individual passengers and airport employees, but will also support local businesses, attract investment, and strengthen links between Mid Cheshire and international markets. As members may know, Manchester Airport currently charges between five pounds fifty for five minutes and twenty-five pounds for half an hour to drop off someone directly outside the terminal. I accept that airports need to manage congestion and that we want people to use public transport where they can, but any charges must be fair and proportionate, particularly where passengers do not have a realistic alternative. And for my constituents, there is no alternative, despite the airport being less than ten miles away.

If a review is to take place, I would ask the Minister to ensure that it considers whether passengers genuinely have a realistic alternative to paying the charge, particularly disabled passengers and those with additional access needs. Drop-off charges are one of the issues on which constituents have some of the strongest views, and it's important that any review reflects their experiences. I also welcome the provisions of the Bill relating to airspace modernization and the potential benefits in terms of increased capacity, reduced delays, and more efficient flight routes.

However, technology and redesigning airspace can only take us so far if there are not enough trained air traffic controllers to operate the system. There have been shortages of air traffic controllers across Europe, and because the aviation system is so interconnected, problems in one country can quickly cause disruption elsewhere, as we have unfortunately seen this week. From a passenger perspective, it makes little difference whether a delay is caused by an airline, an airport, or air traffic control. If they are still sitting in the departure lounge three hours later, the impact on their journey is exactly the same. I'd therefore be grateful if the minister could set out what the government is doing to address the talent pipeline for air traffic controllers and whether there is sufficient workforce capacity to support the growth in aviation that the government wishes to see.

Overall, I welcome this bill because it seeks to create a more effective and responsive regulatory framework, while strengthening protections for disabled travelers represents a significant step forward in ensuring that air travel is more accessible, dignified, and inclusive. I look forward to seeing the consultation process develop and working constructively to ensure the legislation delivers real improvements for passengers across the country. Thank you.

Be seated. Order, order, I will now announce the result of today's deferred division on the draft Plant Health, Seeds, Seed Potatoes and Plant Propagating Material (Amendment) (Northern Ireland) Regulations 2024. The Ayes were 371, the Noes were 100. So the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Luke Taylor.

05:21:26 - 05:38:37

Luke Taylor

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will hope to follow the excitement of that result in the chamber. As an engineer, former aviation consultant, now chair of the APPG on the Future of Aviation, Travel and Aerospace, honorable members will have become accustomed to me calling for stronger growth in the aviation space and a belief that technology and innovation can enable us to do this whilst achieving our obligations to reach net zero and stop the climate crisis. Aviation is the bedrock of our trade agreements. It enables high-value cargo to move along supply chains in a way that no other form of transport can. It makes it feasible for businesses to operate across borders and make connections with other businesses that drive economic growth forward.

And it has meant that the last three generations of Brits have been able to take advantage of affordable foreign holidays, with massive benefits for them, their mental health, and their ability to expand their horizons and make enriching memories in unfamiliar settings. It's been so transformational for governments, businesses, and individuals that it could be safely held as one of the most influential technologies in history. But it has come at a cost. Consumer and commercial aviation has without a doubt contributed to the climate crisis we face. Estimates suggest that annually aviation accounts for 2.5% of global CO2 emissions, however it has contributed around 4% to global warming to date.

And as the MP for a constituency halfway between Heathrow and Gatwick, and from my former life in the aviation industry, I know that the politics of airports is fraught with complication, and the impact on communities if not handled properly can be deeply challenging. So it is my hope that the government will listen to and engage with the points I make about how we upgrade and improve civil aviation in this country for consumers, communities, and the planet. And that they will have understood that events like those we saw yesterday only serve to underline how crucially important this mission is, and how, following the third major failure of our airspace management in the last three years, it is imperative that this bill is amended to include measures to stop that happening again.

NATS is quite clearly not fit for purpose. We cannot suffer a major air traffic outage once a year. Following the outage yesterday, I'm told by industry contacts that again communications with airlines was poor. I would gently suggest to the Minister that whoever it was that briefed the media that the disruption was akin to a day with bad weather should be found another position far away from the media team rather sharply. In the Lords, amendment 65 was submitted by Lord Young, which would have required NATS to hold responsibility for compensation for disruption caused by their failure, rather than by airlines who were not at fault for these delays.

The Government declined to accept the amendment and Lord Hendy responded in a letter to Lord Young in July that he was satisfied that following the 2023 outage that, and I quote, "the Government was able to place considerable pressure on NATS and appointed the person who led the review into the outage." "This helped ensure that NATS took the necessary steps to prevent a recurrence of these particular circumstances." And for the benefit of Hansard, I raise my eyebrow and glance at the Minister knowingly, and I would invite him to address this issue directly in his response and seriously consider the merits of that amendment, a change that is supported by IATA and by airlines. So, that specific challenge aside, there are I think three broader challenges that this bill needs to address and I hope to work with the Government to ensure that it does. The first challenge is the generational risk of decarbonising aviation, which will require short, medium and long-term solutions as we work with researchers and companies to develop the breakthrough fuels that could reshape the industry.

This is how we enable sustainable growth to drive our economy. The second is the more procedural but equally important task of updating and upgrading our airspace infrastructure to keep it competitive whilst keeping communities impacted by these changes informed, engaged and fundamentally in control over what happens to them. Here we must secure our infrastructure at the same time as empowering communities. The third is in rebalancing the power mismatch between airlines and passengers, giving power to people and not the big airlines, giving power so that the passenger experience can be as positive as possible and not continue to allow airlines on some occasions to scam passengers like cheap fairground hucksters. So, on decarbonisation, we need to see serious measures for the airline industry to decarbonise.

It will require collaborative working across the public and private sectors, something that informed last year's Sustainable Aviation Fuel Bill, which I was grateful for the chance to work with the Government in passing. Enormous industrial transitions like this take a very long time and moving existing fleets and fuel infrastructure to green alternatives whilst they're still in use is outrageously difficult. But contrary to what some would like us to believe, it is not impossible. The interchangeability of SAF and fossil-based aviation fuel being mixed and fed into the same pipelines and engines makes this a transition that is actually unusually straightforward compared to other decarbonisation challenges. However, the sheer scale of that challenge and of the existing infrastructure is the real difficulty.

And this, as well as the laws of physics and Breguet's range equations, which I've mentioned in this chamber before, is possible that the industry may be among the last to fully transition away from fossil fuels just by sheer necessity. Now we shouldn't be afraid of that because the reality of achieving the growth we need, but we cannot ground aerospace or regulate it into submission because to do so would have catastrophic impact on our economy. We hear from neo-Luddites that we should effectively do this anyway, that we must constrain our horizons, put up with constraints and self-enforced recession and tell families and businesses that they must put up with penalties and restrictions that their peers and competitors around the world do not. The intention of protecting our world from catastrophic climate change is absolutely right, but these solutions are utterly wrong.

Aviation, like the internet and artificial intelligence, is a Pandora's box technology that once invented and tasted cannot be put back into the box. And like those technologies, the only valid pessimistic question ought to be about how we transform it to regulate the externalities and make sure it continues to serve people, communities and the planet. And the positive question concerns how we grasp the opportunities it offers to keep pushing progress forward. That means backing decarbonisation technology, which is the only way to achieve the future we need. There are great examples of this being done in practice, like Operation Blue Skies, which I spoke of as merely a concept in my speech for the SAF Bill almost a year ago, and which is now funded and ready to be trialled this winter.

This is concrete proof of the progress being made. But there are things we are failing to do as a state to remove roadblocks to this progress, and there is a need for real leadership from the Government to continue to drive forward. Yesterday I chaired a round table discussion about sustainable aviation fuels to allow MPs to hear from the industry about the progress being made and what roadblocks remain. We heard how the pipeline of SAF production is not progressing at the rate needed to achieve the SAF mandate targets over the next few years, and that further Government action is needed to ensure we don't plateau and then fall behind the 10% target by 2030 and 22% by 2040. At the Farnborough International Airshow earlier this summer, I was fortunate enough to witness the first flying demonstration by a fully electric aircraft.

And the exhibition hall showed the huge progress on hydrogen and electric aviation that will be the future of travel. Last week we had the Hydrogen in Aviation group release their report on hydrogen-powered aviation, a pathway to growth and delivery, which set out a clear set of steps forward to harnessing this exciting new technology. Particularly interesting was news of trials led by the CHOSUN consortium to be based at Bristol Airport, hoping for the first hydrogen-powered flight from a UK commercial airport by 2028. This is hugely ambitious and gives hope that solutions are available, but also remind us that the Government needs to play its part in speeding up development and roll-out even faster. So whether aviation decarbonisation ends up being achieved by SAF, hydrogen, electric, methane or some other pathway not yet discovered, it's a huge opportunity for us to grasp and to continue our great British global leadership in aviation technology.

This Bill does not bring forward specific measures on these decarbonisation goals, other than through improvements in efficiencies delivered by airspace modernisation, so I see this as a huge missed opportunity, and I'll look for chances to do so during the Bill Committee. Turning to the second task on infrastructure, I greatly welcome the elements of this Bill that help to deliver airspace modernisation, which will improve the efficiency of the UK's airspace, reduce nuisance noise pollution around airports and facilitate the decarbonisation I've just spoken about. Far from being change for change's sake, airspace modernisation is a vital step forward in upgrading our essential infrastructure, which has not been maintained and developed to keep up with changing and growing demands, and is at risk of periodic and then more consistent failure, as we all witnessed yesterday. And it should be done as part of a wider project of renewal across our transport and otherwise critical infrastructure. It is visible in the chronic and consistent mismanagement of our roads and bridges, of certain aspects of public services, and even in the political infrastructure that sits beneath everything else in this country.

That is why to unlock safe and sustainable growth and drag our infrastructure not just in the 2020s but into a state of readiness for the future, airspace modernisation is utterly essential.

But my support for this is not without reservations. In particular, I'm disappointed that this bill in its current form does not guarantee communities a meaningful say over the impact of these changes upon them. Progress and improvements in route efficiency will inevitably have negative impacts on many, with new flight paths and concentrations of disturbance taking shape over communities previously not impacted by noise. These impacts must be considered carefully and the communities impacted must have a genuine and meaningful say in the changes that will be delivered. As I've said before, my approach is a desire to get to yes on delivering these changes, but to do so requires buy-in from the communities who live with these decisions for decades.

So my response to this bill has to be once again a yes if. Yes if we build a meaningful community involvement that actually changes options. Yes if we can make sure the scheme is able to benefit from public scrutiny. And yes if it can be done in a way that is sustainable and not unlikely to be unpicked years later because it did not achieve some level of consensus. Because whilst the moving parts in aviation are aluminium, steel, and carbon, these ultimately are human systems and it cannot be that changes are made that deliver what might look on a spreadsheet or on the maps that I used to draw in the aviation industry, but actually how the human situation impacts with these changes.

On Monday, I attended a meeting of the APPG for airport communities. And we heard how the airport night noise effects study has shown the huge impact of aviation noise on families living near to airports. Whilst aircraft types have become considerably quieter over the years, the more we learn of the health and psychological impacts of noise disruption, the more it is clear the science is consistent. The impact is real, and as such we must demand programs to mitigate these impacts be made available to all of those affected. It is also true that as airline traffic approaches capacity and demand continues to grow, airlines are likely to be upgauging their aircraft fleets, which typically then leads to higher noise signatures from larger, heavier aircraft.

So we should also remember that the very constraints we put on air traffic are creating an increase in those disruptions. The parts of this bill that will make airspace modernisation easier to deliver must not be allowed to cut scrutiny of the impact of that modernisation on residents or limit their voices over the options considered and how those final flight routes are designed. I'm particularly concerned about the impact on communities in my neck of the woods in southwest London, at Heathrow and further afield at Gatwick, who have already been sounding the alarm about the impact of night flights particularly on their wellbeing. I know my honourable friends the members for Richmond Park and Twickenham have worked on this issue for many years on behalf of their constituents and this bill needs to do more to protect the interests of their residents. And I expect to hear shortly from my honourable friend the member for Horsham on a similar issue.

The Civil Aviation Authority and British Medical Journal both demonstrated that living under night flights does not just harm mental health, but will inevitably damage a person's productivity the next day and it also in extreme cases increase the risk of stroke. Airspace modernisation can, if done properly, improve many of these issues, but where it cannot we must insist on mitigations through soundproofing programs or respite periods to be implemented. Airspace modernisation has the potential to shift flight paths to less densely populated areas too, and lower the noise impact on takeoff and landing with more efficient, steeper approach and departure paths that balance emissions with noise reduction. But there is no guarantee it will do any of these things if those live in the communities affected are denied a seat at the table, either through badly designed consultations or top-down dictat. So, for turning to the third and final challenge, I'm sure you'll be glad to hear, it's important to remember that the first two will affect the planet and communities nearby airports, but the third, that of passenger rights, is the one that will hit passengers most directly.

In the Lords, the Liberal Democrats tabled amendment 36 to implement a passengers' charter for air travel with various targets for minimum service levels that an airline can deliver.

Amendments 10, 11 that would prohibit airlines from separating passengers on the same booking to force them then to pay for assigned seating or forcing other passengers to sit next to your unaccompanied minor. An amendment 2 and 20 which stopped the UK from implementing lower standards and diverging away from existing international standards. All of these are good things and I hope to convince the government of their wisdom during the bill committee. My favorite amendment, however, and what I hope to push for and convince the government of the merits of at the bill committee is amendment 13, which would the Lords amendment 13, which would require airlines to standardize the maximum dimensions for permitted cabin baggage across all air carriers in alignment with recognized industry standards. So who here has a Ryanair bag 55 by 40 by 20 centimeters?

A Wizz Air bag 55 by 40 by 23 centimeters? An EasyJet and British Airways bag 56, 45 by 25 centimeters? And an Aer Lingus bag 55 by 40 by 24 centimeters? Each one subtly different in size and each one liable to set you down for a hefty penalty if the check-in agent doesn't like the look of you. No, I didn't think so.

We don't have a number of bags or we don't have all four. It's madness, absolute madness. It's 2026. We have universal phone chargers, we have universal electric car chargers and we've had standardized shipping containers for nearly half a century. And there are also universally sized overhead lockers on aircraft.

So it is not correct, as asserted by Lord Hendy in the Lords, that aircraft have hugely different overhead and under-seat storage capacities. Setting a standard size would not necessitate using the smallest aircraft capacity, resulting in many passengers needing to use a smaller case or bag. This is incorrect and frankly insulting to the intelligence of the passenger who's just been stung for 75 pounds by an overzealous Ryanair boarding agent for an oversized bag because you picked up the wrong one to pack that morning. And that five centimeters difference cannot possibly fit into the overhead bin on a Boeing 737 but could slip smoothly into that of an A320. Passengers need protection from predatory practices.

We need the BSS, the British standard suitcase. And that's the well-regulated market the Liberal Democrats believe in. And I hope I'm able to make the government see the benefit of that during the bill committee. So in summary, this bill really is a huge opportunity to take meaningful action to improve our airspace infrastructure, to reduce emissions, improve safety and reduce noise and also to improve passenger experience and make flying less expensive and stressful. These are good aims, but they can only be achieved with careful and clear leadership that listens to the voices of industry, of communities and those of us who believe they must be delivered in the context of a wider rethink in the way we maintain and upgrade our systems in this country.

So I thank for the minister for bringing forward to this bill. I congratulate him on making a strong, if incomplete start and I look forward to helping him fix the bill in committee. Thank you.

05:38:37 - 05:41:28

Amanda Hack

As we now all reflect on the size of our baggage, I call Amanda Hack.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And you'll be pleased to know I have a wide variety of bags for my air travel. I get a lot of correspondence on airport related issues with East Midlands Airport right at the top of my constituency. So the improvement on customer rights and protection is going to be key. Having an airport in my constituency also means I've an intimate understanding of the issues facing having a neighbor as an airport that and that can create.

East Midlands Airport have been good at engaging with me on complaints that arise from constituents, but there's always more to be done with the local community.

And whilst I appreciate we're unable to legislate for all in this space, I strongly welcome the measures in the bill with regards to consultation. Airports should be encouraged and to make sure that their airports are as friendly a neighbor as possible. In terms of East Midlands Airport, I think economically we can't ignore that they employ 8,000 people. There is 3.75 tons, thousand tons of small airport freight that goes through East Midlands Airport every year. It's the largest small parcel freight in the UK, with DHL, UPS, FedEx and Royal Mail all choosing to operate out of East Midlands Airport.

So what we can do about modernizing airspace was going to be just as key for passenger aircraft but also freight too. Some 91% of travelers to East Midlands Airport though travel by car, leaving just 9% traveling by public transport. It's actually the lowest percentage in the country. Why? Because there's not a single train station in my constituency, and the one closest to the station, East Midlands Parkway, doesn't even offer a regular bus service.

People have to rely on a demand-responsive transport from the closest train station to the airport. So understandably, one of the top pieces of correspondence regarding in my constituency is airport parking. And actually people outside my constituency email in too because of the work my office has been doing on this. Drop-off charges in particular are a regular feature of my casework. East Midlands Airport has recently been made barrierless, like a lot of other individuals have said today, meaning that someone can only pay online or by using an automated phone line by midnight the following day.

It can be really easy to forget to pay.

05:41:28 - 05:41:30

Speaker 188

Will the honorable lady give way?

05:41:30 - 05:41:32

Speaker 187

Of course.

05:41:32 - 05:42:08

Andrew Dominic John Grady

I thank the honorable lady for giving way. Does the honorable lady agree that these excessive drop-off charges can lead to dangerous behavior around airports? I observed a taxi dropping off passengers in one of the lanes on the one-way system around Glasgow International Airport the other day, and I know that passengers are being dropped off further afield, leading to them to have to walk down the side of what can essentially be described as a one-way system. And I wonder if she's experienced difficulties like that at her in her own constituency.

05:42:08 - 05:48:44

Amanda Hack

I thank my honorable friend for raising that very important point. Around East Midlands Airport, we have a double red line zone, and it actually does make it incredibly dangerous, particularly for colleagues that work at the airport whose family might not be able to afford the drop-off charges to get their their loved ones to to work safely. I think of course you most airports will offer the possibility of setting up an automatic payment account, but it's simply not accessible for all who may only use drop-off services once or twice a year. Airports are essentially operating a system where it's impossible to pay at the point of sale. I've repeated asked the airport to install a pay terminal inside the airport building, but that request has been repeatedly refused.

The current drop-off parking system is unfair, and I actually wrote to the parking management company APCOA to request data about the number of parking charge notices issued prior to and following the installation of the barrierless system at East Midlands Airport. They didn't want to share that data, which I think answers my question.

So I think we also need to be looking at the infrastructure around airports when we're looking at consumer protection, actually making sure people can get to and from the airport safely has to be part of those conversations. Because travelers and those that work at the airport feel they have no choice but to drive or get a family member to drop them off at an additional cost to a holiday or to work. It's something I've raised with the department before and I'd welcome an update from the minister in his closing speech. It does have to be said though that East Midlands Airport's been doing some really valuable work on supporting and encouraging travel for people with disabilities. Their assisted travel service won a national award last year recognizing their initiatives that make travel more accessible and easier.

And I know the minister when he visited my airport last week will have experienced that first hand. They also introduced the first UK WhatsApp based live chat system for assisted travel customers. They've invested about 1.5 million pounds in specialist vehicles, mobility aids and terminal accessibility features. I have traveled on one of these, but as somebody that's frightened of heights, it didn't really fill me with confidence, but for the reason not that it wasn't safe, just because I don't like heights. They've also installed improved signage, refurbished toilets and provided quiet rooms as well as having a changing spaces toilet.

Accessibility should not be a big long conversation, it just needs to be embedded. And I do think it's shameful we're still having this conversation nationally. So I greatly welcome the government's commitment to strengthening the rights of passengers, particularly in this accessibility space and removing compensation limits for wheelchairs, mobility aids and other assistive devices that are lost, damaged or destroyed by UK domestic flights. I think one of the things that's always interesting when you deal with a piece of casework is actually wheelchairs are incredibly expensive, but it's the time away from the wheelchair that is just as important to consider. Replacing something specially adapted for a person isn't an overnight job, you can't order it from Amazon, it takes weeks to be delivered.

There is of course more to be done and I ask that the minister in his response sets out the timetable for consultation on the accessibility issues. As a parent of a child who's multiple allergic, conversations about how we treat those with allergies on flights is a really pressing issue for me. And I'm greatly pleased to see the government has committed to consult on a range of accessibility issues including allergies. With 3 million people in the UK alone affected by food allergies, it's absolutely essential these concerns are addressed. The Natasha Foundation, the food allergy charity in the UK, has put together a really detailed briefing on the issues that people with food allergies face on planes, including some real life stories.

And I don't think we can underestimate the dedicated work of Natasha's family and the personal impact that this has had on them with the tragic loss of Natasha on a plane. But it just gives you, I encourage the minister to read the report that they've introduced. But just to give you some very brief highlights, around 10% of travelers with food allergies report having an allergic reaction during a flight, accounting for 2 to 4% of all medical issues that occur on board commercial airlines. And I can genuinely say as a parent with a child with multiple allergies, sending her on a plane is absolutely terrifying. She traveled alone for the first time earlier in this year and she traveled about 5 hours on a flight and was not offered food because they couldn't manage her allergies.

So I think this is something we do have to look at incredibly seriously.

In light of the air traffic control issue that happened overnight, I think it's also poignant to talk about passenger and pilot and crew wellbeing in the event of a delay on our runways and how this could be better managed in legislation. In February of last year, I attended a round table discussion organized by the APPG on occupational safety and health, and they were hosting a group of pilots representing the British Airline Pilots Association. We heard from the delegation about the ongoing challenges facing pilots, from regulatory failures to significant welfare concerns, particularly when boarding has already taken place. One of the situations described by the pilots' access to toilets, about the delegation informing us that pilots are frequently unable to use the toilet and sanitary items are often not provided for either pilots, crew, or passengers in the event of a delay. A key factor in the lack of access to facilities are that rest breaks have been driven down to legal minimums and it's something we need to consider.

I welcome the bill's commitment to strengthen passenger protection and ensure the industry maintains high standards of safety. Could the minister set out in his response what actions will be taken to support pilots and airplane staff during delays like we had overnight? Thank you.

05:48:44 - 05:50:09

Speaker 189

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, in relation to the Secretary of State's comments on the extensive and continued disruption of passenger and air freight services that has occurred as a consequence of the NATS system falling over yesterday and which will take into the weekend to fully resolve. For people and businesses in Scotland and across the UK, this is deeply concerning. It results in lost work time, impacting productivity, it disrupts time-critical services including medical flights and cold chain delivery mechanisms, and as an example, around a million pounds worth of Scottish salmon is exported through just Heathrow every single day. That's just one sector in one of the home nations.

This level of disruption affecting all of the home nations and indeed many other countries cannot be allowed to happen again. There is a serious question over the clear lack of backup systems when this incident lasted for several hours with an estimated quarter of a million passengers disrupted. I welcome the actions that the Secretary of State set out, but in addition to those actions stated, I would urge the minister to and the department to publish an assessment of the cost to individuals and businesses of this episode as soon as practicable. And I'm certain that ministers will have cross-party backing to hold NATS to account and ensure that in future they have in place far more robust backup systems.

05:50:09 - 05:50:32

Christopher John Vince

I thank the gentleman for taking the intervention, sorry my voice still hasn't come back, but can I thank him for raising the issues around NATS. He will be aware that Stansted Airport is on very right next to my constituency of Harlow, so it's impacted a lot of people in my constituency, not just those that are travelling, but would he also agree it has an impact on those people working at the airport because of the huge disruptions that it's caused?

05:50:32 - 05:56:58

Speaker 189

Yep, absolutely, and that's people in airports up and down the country because they're having to manage the delayed flights at their end and that impacts on they're pulling in people from around the airport, it adds cost, and some of these regional airports are operating on much smaller margins and that cost of bringing in additional staff has a really significant impact on them. This incident will have been not just frustrating for many, but quite distressing, and for many very costly. Moving on, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the bill itself. The measures in this bill are predominantly very welcome and the SNP here and in government in Scotland are broadly supportive. I would, however, initially draw attention to Lords Amendment 33 that introduced a review of airport parking charges that was not in the face of the original bill.

I'm absolutely not against that in principle, but as it stood, the original bill text would not have required a legislative consent motion. It looks like the introduction of Lords amendment 33 will require such consent, and I would ask the minister in summing up, when they come to summing up, if they can address that specific point. If a legislative consent motion is required from the Scottish Parliament, then it's essential that appropriate time is built in for proper scrutiny by MSPs of this element of the bill prior to the report stage. Another specific issue that I want to raise are the issues being faced by many people with e-visas who have been refused boarding of aircraft coming to the UK where they have a legitimate right to travel and gain entry, but where ground staff are not sufficiently trained and aware of how to check and scrutinize e-visa documentation. In these circumstances, passengers incorrectly refused boarding may not have a right to be compensated, which can be hugely costly and is inherently unfair.

Legislation currently provides for protection for adequately documented passengers who are denied boarding, but does not define what constitutes being adequately documented. The Prime Minister has talked about giving people agency, but many people in these circumstances clearly do not have such agency. For digital documentation, it seems obvious that the onus should be on the carrier to check the documentation. A passenger in another country with potential language barriers and limited digital access is clearly disadvantaged if the onus is on them. The campaigning group T3M have proposed a well-considered amendment, which I'm sure the minister will be aware of.

Will the minister give consideration to tackling that particular issue through amendment of this bill, as it is a significant consumer issue for people who are entitled to travel, already have a visa, but who are being refused boarding, and it's a very costly experience if they don't get compensation for an incorrectly being incorrectly refused boarding. Moving on to a separate issue, I have two significant airports in the constituency. One is a civilian airport, Inverness, and the other is the airbase RAF Lossiemouth. Now, clearly military aircraft movements do not operate under civilian aircraft legislation, but people who live in the vicinity of a military base also experience noise issues, environmental issues. I'm not suggesting for a minute that there should be constraints that would make operational flying difficult for the for the military.

However, I think in the case of regular training exercises and regular training flights, which is predominantly what most of the flights are out of many of our military bases on a day-to-day basis, there could be more work done to improve how the military communicate with the local community and have something that's a bit closer to the expectations that we would have around a normal domestic airport. Now, I would simply ask if the minister has considered that and whether they would the department will have conversations with their colleagues in the Ministry of Defence to see how much room there is, not necessarily for hard legislation to say they must do X, Y, and Z, because it would be wrong to constrain their ability to do their core work. However, it's I think it's something that could be explored a bit in, you know, in the event of routine flights that to maybe reduce and minimize that environmental impact on people who live close to what can be very noisy bases. They're very accepting of it because the bases create a huge amount of employment, people recognize the importance of them to the defense of the to the defense of the country, so they, you know, they they are very accepting of that. But it doesn't mean that it's not an issue, doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed in the best possible way to try to try and improve things, we should always be looking at improvement.

And finally, um, you know, as somebody who commutes to this place around 40 weeks a year, give or take, um, I use 80 flights a year for that commute. Um, I spend about seven hours a week either in airports or on aircraft. Um, I would emphasize, as others have done, that that is a predominantly positive experience. Um, it is largely without significant delay. But when significant delays do occur, and that can, and people are missing connections, often on long-haul flights elsewhere, um, that can become really quite distressing for people.

So the consumer element of it and that protection of people is, is really absolutely critical. I have seen passengers regularly who have been distressed about circumstances that they're in. Um, sometimes they're flying for, for deeply personal reasons, bereavement and suchlike. And it is a, um, you know, it is a particularly, it's a more stressful form of transport than maybe getting on and off a bus on a, where you're maybe taking a single, a single bus for a few miles and you're getting off at the other end. You've got to plan for security, you've got to plan for, for your baggage, you've got to do all of those things.

So it requires a lot more thinking before you go on a plane. And if you're there for difficult circumstances, it makes it all the more important that we, um, ensure that that experience is as good as it possibly can be for people who are using it. Thank you.

05:56:59 - 06:04:06

Tim Roca

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Um, and can I start by thanking my right honorable and honorable friends in the ministerial team for their assiduous work in bringing this bill and preparing this bill and, and bringing it forward. Can I also, he's not in his seat anymore, but the member for Sale, Wythenshawe and Sale East for all the work he did as a minister, both in government and, um, in opposition as well. And also for members of the other place for their work scrutinizing the bill ahead of it coming to us here today. And it represents another example of how the government is on the side of consumers.

And upon taking office, the new Prime Minister launched a series of very practical everyday fixes to improve consumer rights in a number of areas, lowering costs, empowering consumers to take action when they've been inconvenienced. And I see this in that tradition. It's another step on that path of improving consumer rights in aviation in this regard. So by giving the Civil Aviation Authority direct enforcement powers and increasing transparency to ensure that passengers are always told who's operating their flight and how they can find redress, it's another example of the government rebalancing power back in favor of the consumer and I applaud it. Now, Macclesfield, my constituency, is well served by Manchester Airport.

There are over 500 jobs in my constituency dependent on the airport. It's the third busiest in the UK. It's the busiest airport outside of London, I understand, and it's certainly the global gateway to the north of England. Like many people, I fly out of Manchester myself. It's a great airport and a great part of the economy of the North West.

Um, and perhaps not uniquely, I might be proved wrong, but its major shareholders as well are mainly the councils of Greater Manchester. So a great example of sharing prosperity from an important economic asset. And I thank all the staff at the airport for helping 30 million people get through check-in and security and the departure lounge and fly where they need to be, mostly hassle-free, and I think we should acknowledge that. But, as I'm sure is common across all, all airports, sometimes things do go wrong, whether it's a bag that doesn't make it or a flight that's significantly delayed. Disruption can occur at any moment, and certainly we've seen that with the NATS events in the last 24 hours.

So clauses one to three of this bill will give me and other passengers much greater confidence that when things do go wrong, things can be put right. That given the changing nature of air travel and global trends, it is right that the bill empowers the Secretary of State to act on behalf of passengers without having to pass further primary legislation, whether it's on baggage damage, liability for passenger insurance, ensuring price transparency, or ensuring flights are accessible to all passengers, especially those who are disabled.

And I think colleagues have made a really powerful case about that earlier this afternoon. These new powers ensure that the Secretary of State is able to be a true advocate for passengers and quickly update the rules to ensure appropriate compensation when things go wrong. I was much taken by the comments by the member for Cardiff West about exploring an auto-delay repay system. I think that has great merit. And I certainly want to see the new British standard-sized bag when it finally emerges.

It did sound for a moment like the member for Sutton had a particularly traumatic summer with at least one airline. So I look forward to the consultation the ministers will bring forward within 12 months. And I urge my constituents, certainly, who have written to me about their own experiences, to respond to that consultation so ministers can act on their behalf. I particularly welcome the change in clause 4, providing greater compensation on domestic flights for damaged or lost accessibility equipment. A wheelchair, as has been said, is a precious and crucial asset for disabled people.

And sometimes too often, disabled people have to fight to get mobility aid in the first place. And it can often be specialist and extremely expensive. So it's right that if an airline is careless enough to lose or damage an aid, that the compensation owed to that person that they've left inconvenienced in an incredible way is done properly. And unable to navigate with the freedom they once had, that that compensation is appropriate. I mean, I can't imagine myself the levels of inconvenience that it does cause to people in those circumstances.

So I'm glad consumer rights in this area are being strengthened. And with the bill giving the CAA the same consumer protection enforcement powers as the CMA, passengers will now have a powerful new ally in the fight when it comes to compensation that is owed and is not as forthcoming as it should be. But beyond the consumer protections, I welcome the bill introducing reforms to the antiquated airspace management system, airport slot schedules allocations. It's particularly positive that the airspace changes will hopefully lead to reduced noise around airports for residents and decreased emissions through more efficient flying. These are just sensible reforms, long overdue, that help to make aviation more sustainable.

And to anyone who's been held in a stack whilst waiting for a landing spot can attest, a more efficient use of airspace to decrease the need for holding patterns is very welcome indeed. And it's good to see the government reforming those slots and those schedules. We saw during COVID that the current system is inflexible enough. And giving again ministers the power to adjust those rules, either in an emergency like COVID, for example, or to encourage competition between airlines, which is so important, it's a welcome step that will improve things for passengers. I do want to finish with an issue that a couple of others on both sides of the House have raised this afternoon and ask ministers to think carefully about it in view of the scrutiny the other House gave, which is airport drop-off charges, which a number of residents in Macclesfield have raised with me.

Manchester Airport operates a barrierless drop-off, which is great for efficiency, but constituents have complained to me that the signage isn't adequate, the prices are too steep, and the period to pay is not long enough. And certainly the fines, if you don't pay in the short period, are punishing. Manchester Airport, through ACPOA, levies a 100-pound fine if the charge isn't paid within 24 hours of drop-off or pick-up. And I simply don't believe 24 hours is a long enough period for many people, including my constituents who I say have written to me about this issue. Many didn't realize they had to pay, not seeing the signage as it was inadequate, or they struggled with the online payment system, or they had the payment system reject their car registration number, or in one case, Madam Deputy Speaker, particularly egregious, a constituent of mine was fined because their bank didn't process the payment over a Sunday.

There seems to be no reason why this payment period could not be increased, this window. And I don't see any reason why the third-party provider couldn't issue a written notice of the requirement to pay before a fine was levied.

And you do get the impression, Madam Deputy Speaker, in these cases, that the policy is designed to cause people to incur fines in order to increase revenue, rather than to encourage people to pay for parking in an orderly and appropriate, appropriate way. I'll take an intervention.

06:04:06 - 06:04:38

Christopher John Vince

I thank the honorable friend for taking an intervention. I think the other thing that the idea of these drop-off fines is to ensure, is to try and convince people to travel to airports via other means. And I would say that my airport, Stansted, is very accessible by train and they've put on new bus routes. But in the example that the honorable friend gave, and we've discussed this before, she hasn't got that option. So it seems unfair that if there isn't good transport links to an airport, that these charges exist.

As I say, in my case, it's not such an issue, but in the case of my honorable friend, I can see why it's a problem.

06:04:38 - 06:04:57

Tim Roca

I completely agree with my honorable friend. And earlier in the debate, the member for Mid Cheshire made the very powerful point that his constituents live within ten miles of the airport but don't have decent public transport links to the airport. So that certainly has to be part of the conversation as well. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, in closing, this is a practical bill... I'll take an intervention.

06:04:57 - 06:05:25

Andrew Dominic John Grady

On the drop-off charges point, would the honorable gentleman agree with me that if there are going to be drop-off charges, that at the very least they should only be increased in line with inflation? At Glasgow Airport, the increases since 2019 have way outstripped, you know, the cost of living and the normal rate of increases in line with inflation.

06:05:25 - 06:06:00

Tim Roca

I totally agree with my honorable friend. And you know, every day's a school day in this place, and I was not aware that Glasgow Airport did not have a direct rail link to the center of Glasgow, one of the UK's most important cities. And you'd think after however many eons the SNP had been in charge in Scotland, that that might have been a priority they might have looked at. But it's not for me to say. But as I was saying, in conclusion, I think this is a very practical bill, it's a very pragmatic bill.

I welcome it thoroughly and I thank ministers for all their hard work and I hope it progresses smoothly in its further stages. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:06:00 - 06:12:24

John Milne

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In my constituency of Horsham, people understand the importance of Gatwick to the local economy, not least because many of them have a job there. But the way public consultation has been handled over the last decade has created deep anxiety about what changes to airports and airspace will mean for them, their families, and the communities they live in. So it's on their behalf that I'm asking for the introduction of a dedicated aviation ombudsman, especially in the context of the need to lay out new flight paths. I am wholly supportive of the need for airspace modernization, which of course is being carried out across the whole of Europe.

It will bring very welcome improvements in both emissions and safety. As part of this process, Gatwick Airport Limited are looking for a change to a particular currently agreed flight path, such that planes leaving west and turning south to Europe will be able to do so almost immediately after takeoff, instead of building up height first. In doing so, they will inflict major noise pollution over North Horsham and three rural villages, which are not currently overflown to a great extent. When this same route, known as ADMIT, was trialed ten years ago, it provoked an explosion of public distress. The then CEO swiftly withdrew it and promised never to introduce it again.

Yet lo and behold, in the last round of public consultation, subsequently canceled, Gatwick gave Horsham people a choice of three airspace plans, all three of which contained this same identical route. Less Gatwick's choice, more Hobson's choice. Why did they do that?

Simply because it would enable Gatwick to increase the number of takeoff slots, and they, of course, are potentially worth millions. Now, this is a clear conflict of interest, and I have a great deal of difficulty believing that the financial incentive had no influence whatsoever on their thinking. Either way, it risks at the very least the perception of bias. What's particularly aggrieving is that this route isn't really necessary. Given all the other changes going on at the same time, it would make a negligible contribution to efficiency, to emissions reduction, or even to capacity, given that Gatwick is in any case heading for a huge increase in capacity owing to a second runway and other measures.

Unfortunately, the voice of the consumer plays such a small part in this process that no one is able to add up the pros and cons. It's all on the side of industry. I therefore asked the then aviation minister to include an independent member as standard on airspace review panels. He declined, and now the whole process has been restarted anyway, but we still have a situation where the citizen has no power to challenge major changes which will affect their lives. There's another CAA reform which further illustrates this point.

The department's new air navigation guidance, published last month, lowers the altitude up to which noise must be prioritized over efficiency from 7,000 feet to 5,000 feet, and I referred to this earlier in a question to the Secretary of State. So that means fewer people will be able to argue against such a route on noise grounds. Now, this happened in the same year that the CAA's own new research, the Aviation Noise Attitude Survey and the Aviation Night Noise Effects Study, found that the noise level at which people become highly annoyed is 43 decibels rather than 54 as previously advised. Communities are more sensitive to noise than the department's own evidence said a decade ago. Yet the response has been to shrink, not extend, the altitude band where noise takes priority.

Where is the voice of the resident in this? It will have a material impact on decisions in my area as well as other airports. So why is the CAA allowed to mark its own homework when no one else is? There already is an alternative dispute resolution available for consumer complaints, such as a refund, a delayed bag, or for a cancelled flight. But this is not a usable tool for regulatory decisions, such as where a flight path goes, how the noise is distributed, or which homes end up underneath it.

The government's own written answers confirm that dissatisfaction with a CAA regulatory decision cannot be pursued through the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. It can only go to internal review or judicial review. For the great majority of residents, neither of these is a realistic option. And Madam Deputy Speaker, we've been here before. Water is another industry that touches growth, employment, environment, and people's daily lives, and where trust has been totally destroyed.

The government's answer to this issue is that there should be a new legally binding water ombudsman.

So I believe and campaigners campaigners the length and breadth of the country believe that aviation deserves the same treatment. Now the Minister has written to me and argues that there is already a consultation process, but most residents will be left completely unaware of major changes. And even if they were aware, they'd be unable to do anything significant about it. The process as proposed is so completely dominated by the industry voice that even a modest request, such as not repeating the same mistake on flight paths around Horsham, can never get any kind of hearing. So I think the Minister is wrong to assume that the industry always knows what's best in all circumstances.

Fairness and objectivity should be offered on CAA regulatory decisions and on consumer and passenger rights alike. I therefore ask the government to look again and to shore up this bill with an independent ombudsman for aviation. Thank you.

06:12:24 - 06:12:27

Speaker 190

John McDonnell.

06:12:27 - 06:13:32

John Martin McDonnell

Thank you. Thank you. Can I just say with regard to the experience yesterday, which usually I will get letters from constituents all over the country because Heathrow's located in my constituency and therefore they think I'm responsible for it. So I usually send apologetic replies back. But can I also say that actually despite the suffering that people went through, behind that will be a large number of staff who are working incredibly hard at all levels of the organisation to put it right.

And this happens on every occasion. However, nevertheless, NATS management needs to be held to account. Secretary of State has said that they'll should expect a report within six months. It would be helpful to have statements during that period to reassure people about exactly what did happen and also the actions that that need to be taken. Just on that point, certainly.

06:13:32 - 06:13:54

Luke Taylor

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. Does he agree with me that particular reference should be given to the previous failures, and I think it was the 37 actions that should have been completed to resolve the previous incident, and explaining quite how this was allowed to occur again because as he says, it's critical that we get to the bottom of what happened, but also that we're able to hold them to account.

06:13:54 - 06:17:16

John Martin McDonnell

I think that goes to the heart of the debate we're having, which is levels of accountability within our structures themselves. NATS is accountable to the CAA. The CAA becomes almost, I think, accountable to who? Not often. The element, the reason I raised with the Secretary of State the references in the the legislation being proposed to new section 61G.

This relates to the priorities and objectives of the Secretary of State in relation to aviation and is a document that is a directive to the CAA. The reason I asked about it because the way it's drafted in the legislation, I thought we were going to eventually move towards a more expansive document setting out in detail some of the issues, particularly for my interest, environment, but also service to the etc. In fact, the document at the moment is simply a couple of pages of a letter that's sent on a regular basis, usually annually, and laid before Parliament. And I thought what was useful in this legislation is that we would get something more substantial that was consulted on in more detail and it would be a much much more in-detail direction to CAA about how it should implement its responsibilities and role.

And as a result of that, the CAA will then become more accountable to the Secretary of State and therefore on to this House. So that, that's my, one of the points really, and it isn't, we never, actions go, things go wrong, actions are then agreed, and then we never really get the substance of the follow-up on those actions, that's the problem. And I just raise the other example that took place, if people can remember at Heathrow, when the substation went up in, in flames, and we then discovered the fallback operations weren't working effectively as well. And there's a real vulnerability for the future. And I just, I just think we need a bit more of an authoritative role for this House in terms of how the Secretary of State can influence CAA, make it more accountable.

And that's, that's the main point I want to make really. I don't think people realize the, the massive power that the CAA has, that has implications for the lives and the health, as others have said, of literally millions of people with regard to the flight paths that, that it determines, and also the standards of performance that it, it determines. And I actually don't think as yet in the legislation, I think it needs further debate on other aspects. I don't think yet we've got much further in establishing an effective structure for airspace decision-making. As I say, the, in the decision-making itself, there's very little independent monitoring, and it becomes, as the honorable gentleman from Horsham I think has said, impossible to challenge because literally local communities haven't the resources then to judiciary review the decisions themselves.

So there doesn't seem to be that basic accountability mechanism that we'd expect of other bodies that are performing public duties like that.

06:17:16 - 06:17:55

Charles Noah Law

I thank him for giving way and I do understand what he and other colleagues, other members across the House are saying about the need for independent oversight, particularly on the sort of aviation side. But when it comes to the consumer side, does he agree with me that when the CAA works, it really does work, particularly in cases as we've heard of from the members for Mid Dorset's constituent's case, it really can work and that it's absolutely the right thing for this government to bring that, bring those powers forward for consumer protections.

06:17:55 - 06:27:27

John Martin McDonnell

I fully agree. I fully agree. And, and again, can I just also say as part of the legislation as well, the issue with regard to wheelchair compensation is significant in this legislation as well, because most of us have dealt with cases like this. But just, just to go back to this process of accountability. Just looking at some of the notes that have been provided by different organizations.

HACAN provided us with a helpful note, and I've worked with them now over 20 years. They set out, the CAA, when it's, sets out the airspace changes, HACAN remind us that actually they oversee the progress of those three stages. They approve whether the consultation, their own consultation has been adequate or not. And in addition to that, they decide on what then, whether proposals may proceed. And yeah, they, they operate their own complaints route, which are issues around airspace actually almost impenetrable.

So it, it does, the CAA has immense power and it seems to be a law unto itself in many instances. And as I say, the lack of, the lack of consultation, I think is one of its main vulnerabilities. It's been said in the House today. New flight paths are already being prepared and discussed and considered. I look at Heathrow expansion, and it won't be Heathrow that actually puts forward when it puts forward its plans for a third runway, it won't be Heathrow that will then say what the flight paths will be.

It can't be, because it's now the, the airport services that has been set up under NATS.

And I've not and with all my experience from Heathrow, I've not known a thorough and adequate consultation process take place with regard to airport routes and the development of them. So there is a I was hoping the legislation we might get more detail. And that's why this I come back to this issue with regard to the Secretary of State's document. I think that could be if it's a real that could be a really powerful mechanism in which we can determine through debates here and therefore instructions to the Secretary of State how the CAA will operate in the future. And and again it on the environment, can I just say I again I feel there's just insufficient lack of there's a real lack of firm duties and responsibilities set out in the legislation and set out in the guidance procedure that takes into account the health and the well-being of people and communities.

And the reference has been made to to noise. I I cannot believe that we're still in this same situation where we're having the use of different noise criteria used in different mechanisms and different decisions taking place. And if you look at the decisions with regard to Gatwick and Luton in which the developments are based upon, they're using two different criteria, two different levels to which they they place the restrictions. And I've gone through in the different debates and discussions that we that we've had over over the time. Some of you some of the honourable members will know we've gone from 57 to 53 to 43.

The 43 one is the the World Health Organization. I for life of me I don't understand why we don't expect respect their expertise in in all of this. And we apply the different measures for different decisions which largely get by driven by other factors rather than the health and the consequences for people and the impact of noise. At this point can I just the honourable gentleman has mentioned the APPG meeting that we had on on Monday where we received the research the latest basis of research. Can I put on record my thanks to Dr. Charlotte Clark.

She's the professor of environmental epidemiology and population health. And she's done the latest well she's done research over the years on all of this she's the expert of it. And I think she well an element of shock for for some of us she then looked at some of the health implications at the lowest levels of noise that we we'd been debating here today. And it is shocking the impact in terms of cardiovascular we know but we now know much more about the impact on on mental health in particular. And one of the issues that's come out of our discussions is that particularly and this includes the Heathrow expansion consultation as well.

The latest research on noise and health impacts has not been really sufficiently monetized in the discussions and consultations that have taken place. So we could be at a situation now decision-making particularly on the latest Heathrow expansion proposals could be on the basis of health impact monetization as a result of increased noise which is well and sometimes it's described as maybe four times the level it should be four times more than the level that's been put forward by the government so far.

And I think increasingly now our constituents themselves are becoming aware of the health impacts of noise in particular and are demanding greater protections. And from the legislation that we're debating today, I can't see how those greater protections will be translated unless we have a stronger capacity in this house to determine the guidance that's given to CAA and the parameters that have been set for them on the in the decision-making process. I just give this example just to run through for honorable members what we the debates that have taken place in in this house. For the APF we dealt with 57 decibels. For the SON we looked at 54.

Then we went to 51. And as I say 43 is in the latest analyses which relates to the World Health Organization. We can't keep on going on without I think a proper standard noise that is that will be applicable across to our whole decision-making process and that actually does reflect now the latest research in terms of its health impacts. And I don't think we're there at the moment. So again just finally I I'm pleased with the legislation.

There's some proposals that I think are meritorious. I think they will have an improvement in terms of the passenger experience no doubt whatsoever. But this legislation really doesn't take into account the community experience and the impact it will have. And that's why the running theme of this and I'll be with others I'll be bringing forward amendments. Somehow we've got to get a greater level of accountability, greater level of transparency and also a greater level of empowerment of those communities that are being impacted.

The proposal from the honorable member from Horsham with regard to an ombudsman I think is I think it would is one mechanism that could be used and could be helpful. A bit of a long stop because at the moment in my constituency when people are faced with these, they don't know where to go. It's as simple as that. And as I say just finally on the if it is at Heathrow expansion it's going to be interesting the debate that we'll have on Heathrow expansion and the new policy statement when we actually don't know what the flight paths will be. And if I was a constituent my honorable friend in Uxbridge I would be extremely worried.

In my constituency the bizarre situation is this because the flights are largely east-west, west-east, it affects Longford where you when the aircraft fly over you feel like throwing yourself to the floor. It affects a number of the Heathrow villages but doesn't as yet impact on the center of my constituency. But we are at the risk now that the flight paths may well do that. So again we're talking about maybe another million or so people coming into being impacted by the development of Heathrow itself. And yet we will not have in the debate that we have in this house about the policy statement, we will not have the certainty of what those flight paths will be.

That can't be right when you're making such a major decision like that. That's why I'm hoping when we come back and when the committee meets and when we come back at report stage we can have a a sensible debate about the sort of amendments that can be brought forward on that theme of accountability. Because if we can increase the accountability I think we can increase the confidence in government decision-making on this issue in the long term. And I agree with honorable members who've raised the issue about the importance of aviation to our economy. Of course it is.

It employs a large number of my constituents and we're trying to make sure though that we create an aviation capacity which actually yes is economically beneficial to the country but also protects our constituents in terms of their health and well-being overall.

06:27:27 - 06:27:29

Speaker 193

Noah Law.

06:27:29 - 06:31:30

Charles Noah Law

Madam Deputy Speaker, I declare an interest as the newly elected chair of the aviation APPG. I welcome the steps taken by our Labour government today to improve accessibility and protections for disabled airline passengers, to bolster consumer protections and to simplify the legislative framework and in doing so boost our economy and boost the aviation sector more broadly. So I think we've heard a lot today about the potential benefits of that. I think there are benefits as much as there are increased obligations for carriers, but I'd be keen to hear more from the ministers in winding up perhaps about some of those benefits that we can unlock at the airport and infrastructure side as well, because we have heard today from colleagues with other small regional airports represented in this House about the compliance costs associated with that. So I'd be interested to hear from ministers how this bill potentially addresses that and what other support can be in place from there, from the department to help small regional airports like Cornwall Airport Newquay that is in my constituency and my neighboring constituency.

We know in the case of Cornwall Airport Newquay that Cornwall Council is an administration that's chopped and changed in its approach. That as ministers have heard before is deeply unhelpful, but it's only by improving the passenger experience as this bill doubtless does that we will be able to encourage improved pax, improved passenger footfall and boost revenues to support the sustainability of those airports such as Cornwall Airport Newquay. But I and I thank the minister for his steps already that Cornish MPs have had in relation to the PSO as well, the public service obligation. I appreciate that ministers have left the door open to Cornwall Council to continue those or restart those conversations should they be able to bring eligible bids forward in the future. That's really important because as much as we can all work to promote commercial conversations with various airlines and there have been new routes introduced on the back of that, it really is only through support for regional airports, through improving the passenger experience as I know this bill will do today that we will boost the usage of those airports.

We've also heard of the importance of transport connectivity, integrated transport, and I know that this government's devolution program, the extension of bus franchising such as the work we're doing again with Cornwall Council there should prove fertile ground to improving those links where councils choose to take up those powers and use them in a constructive way. So I will use this opportunity, perhaps shamelessly so, to be an advocate for regional airports, the connectivity they provide to actually basket case situations as we're seeing in Cornwall's current transport links, and I call on the minister to go beyond these great steps that he's taking today to support regional airports like mine in Newquay.

06:31:30 - 06:31:32

Speaker 194

Amanda Dixon.

06:31:32 - 06:35:12

Aphra Brandreth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The UK's aviation sector continues to grow year after year, breaking passenger records as they travel in their millions. This growth is undoubtedly good for the economy, for trade and for growth, but also for the everyday British air passenger, giving us more opportunities to travel for work, leisure and beyond. We are well served in Chester North and Neston by Manchester Airport, Liverpool John Lennon and to a lesser extent Hawarden Airport. Additionally, many constituents are employed in the sector at the airports or at Airbus over the border in North Wales. Indeed, the company Axelum keeps aviation fuel flowing through my constituency.

We must, however, make sure that as the expansion of the aviation sector continues, we keep pace. Over recent days, we've seen what can happen when things go wrong, as hundreds of flights have been cancelled or delayed across the country since last night. And I'm grateful to my honourable friend the Secretary of State for her update on the NATS outage earlier this afternoon. We have a responsibility to improve the protections of air passengers to give them the confidence that they need to continue supporting British aviation, and I believe this bill is the best way to do so. My own constituents have previously written to me to express their concerns about delays and disruptions to flights.

In particular, one resident from Upton was deeply concerned about the cancellation of many flights worldwide earlier in March, triggered by rising oil prices. In recent years, major disruptions seem to have become more commonplace. From conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East disrupting flight paths and the cost of jet fuel, to global pandemics shutting down almost all air traffic globally, these extraordinary events have had huge repercussions for the air passenger and have highlighted the need for a more modern system that can adapt to a changing world. On a smaller level, we're all keenly aware of the many ways that the cost of living crisis has impacted us all. People up and down the country work hard to save for holidays abroad, and the increasingly common choice to utilise short-haul low-fare flights benefits us all, putting more money into a sector that employs tens of thousands of highly skilled workers and grows our economy up and down the country.

But we must make sure that as we look to modernise and secure the aviation industry, we protect the consumer too and make sure their custom isn't taken for granted. It's right that we work to strengthen consumer rights for air passengers, including for flight delays and cancellations, and making sure price transparency for baggage and other costs that are often hidden through drip pricing. I also welcome the attention to disabled passengers' rights, ensuring that future regulation keeps all passengers in mind and keeps the access to the skies equitable. In our increasingly global world, securing our aviation sector is a vital aspect of our wider economic growth, but beyond that, the security for air passengers that the Civil Aviation Bill proposes will work to ensure that this economic strength is delivered hand in hand with consumers' confidence that when things go wrong, they will be protected. Thank you.

06:35:12 - 06:35:13

Danny Beales.

06:35:13 - 06:40:04

Danny Beales

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for the opening remarks and for the measures contained within this bill, which are broadly very welcome for passengers and for many in airport communities such as my own. Sharing the Secretary of State's comments, my thoughts are also with those individuals and families who face significant disruption this week through the failure of NATS.

It shows just how vital air traffic, air travel is to people right across this country for business and for leisure, and what the impacts are when it goes wrong. There's been lots of discussion, although not directly related to this, but lots of discussion in this debate about the incident, about lessons that we can and should learn. And at Heathrow particularly, the major airport in my borough, we've unfortunately got somewhat used now to quite significant incidents at Heathrow. We had a grid power outage recently which caused significant disruption. There's been a number of incidents, and quite clearly we do need to look at the resilience of our air travel system.

We do need to look at planning for these incidents, which are increasingly common and can cause quite significant and harmful disruption to business and individuals. So I do hope that, as the Secretary of State said, there will be a thorough look at this, but more broadly than this incident, lessons can be learned by the sector and better resilience planning put into place. This bill, however, I think is welcome news for my constituents and travellers who come through my home borough of Hillingdon. We're a borough not just of one airport, but two. We are home to Heathrow, but also home to RAF Northolt, which has a significant and increasing civilian operation of private flights, which also come under civil aviation matters.

So we're not shy or unknown to issues which arise around civil aviation, of flights, of disruption, of balancing some of the trade-offs and challenges which come with air travel. I think whilst there's much concern, my friend, my neighbour from Hayes and Harlington, who's no longer in his place, has talked already about some of the concerns around potential Heathrow expansion and a third runway, which is a matter this House, I'm sure, will turn its attention to rightly very soon. But I think for those of us who believe in a better but not necessarily bigger Heathrow, we do need to see measures to address the current challenges that Heathrow presents, regardless of expansion. And that's why I think this bill is particularly welcome. We see much better consumer protections when things inevitably do sometimes go wrong.

We see in this bill action to come to tackle some of the Wild West kind of behaviours, the difference in approach of airlines and of contractors. It's been mentioned already the difference in approach around hand baggage, hand luggage, but also we see around compensation, around delay payments, such a different and hard-to-navigate approach from different air providers. Some of us, you know, who've experienced disruption will often remember having to hunt out air staff at 10:00, 11:00 PM at night in airports when the desk is closed, trying to find anyone who seems to work for the airline concerned to find out what's going on, to find out what compensation you may be able to get, to eventually get a five-pound paper voucher for refreshments, which will buy you about half a sandwich in a concession in an airport. So, you know, I think certainly support comments from members here around looking at best practice, upping the quality of provision and standardising it, and also learning from other sectors such as the rail sector through, I think, comments been made about the auto-delay repay of railways. You know, having recently travelled Avanti for my sins, I've had to use that quite frequently, and it is quite actually a helpful tool, and at least there is a kind of very quick turnaround of the compensation you're owed.

And notably, the compensation you get is a cash payment for the cash that you've paid for the travel you've not gotten. Unfortunately, far too often the disruption payments that we receive from airlines are an invitation to travel on their airline again, a voucher to travel again on EasyJet when you've not been able to travel the first time, which again seems quite perverse. Very happy to give way.

06:40:04 - 06:40:41

Luke Taylor

Will he give way? And and just to kind of add to the grist of all of our experiences traveling, I've had a case raised with us where the customer had chosen to pay for seat allocation to keep them together with their children. They got on the flight, they'd then been moved and they then had to claim the compensation, claim the money back on an extra service that they'd paid for deliberately, otherwise they wouldn't have got a refund. Does the honorable member agree that these sorts of things have to be automated, they have to be quickened up to improve that passenger experience and improve our customer protection?

06:40:41 - 06:46:48

Danny Beales

I wholeheartedly agree and I and I think this is a fantastic opportunity to address some of these issues which have lingered for too long in the sector and boosting the enforcement powers of the Civil Aviation Authority as well, enabling faster enforcement when those rights are not applied is also welcome. I think people here have already rightly raised the need to get a much tighter definition of extraordinary events and ensure that that is properly applied. It can't be an opt an a catch-all opt-out for airlines to get around these requirements. And I strongly welcome the removal of the cap around baggage, specialist equipment, wheelchairs. In the Health Committee and in other debates we talk a lot about the challenge of people getting specialist adaptive equipment.

It can take a long time to get this bespoke personalized equipment and then for that to be lost or damaged when you travel and not to be able to reclaim the full costs is incredibly damaging and disruptive. So strongly welcome that provision. I would just encourage the minister that when that cap is removed and when this is applied, we must ensure that that doesn't lead to unintended consequences that airlines are then unwilling to allow that equipment to be stowed, to be boarded and they refuse to fly individuals because the insurance risk around that equipment. So I just hope that in the application of what is the right policy we ensure there's no unintended consequences. I strongly support the provisions around modernizing our airspace.

It has to be the case that these very outdated routes with modern flights, with different technology emerging that is much less noise impacting, there are options, there are flexibilities which remove actually the very significant impact we do see on the very heavily trafficked flight paths that already exist. I agree that the how we do this is just as important as if we do it and it has to be done with a proper assessment and consultation of residents, but it can't be the case that it's right that we see a few heavily trafficked routes that lead to piling up of flights, the circling of flights and the unnecessary additional burden on communities. I just would like to support the comments earlier around the the value of this bill looking at abusive travelers and the impact that has on staff at both airport side and also cabin side of air travel. Air workers face unacceptable amount of abuse of all forms, physical and verbal, and it is increasing.

And the stats from a recent Unite survey of just 300 workers in Scottish airports showed that 90% had experienced verbal abuse on a regular basis, 75% intimidation and aggression, and almost a third some form of physical assault. And I think we're becoming a bit numb to this. In our hospitals, our rail workers, our shop workers, we're becoming quite numb to this abuse and regular intimidation and violence that public sector and customer-facing roles are experiencing. But we do have to take action. We have on shop workers, and I hope that the provisions in this bill around clause 13, which give additional powers to create offences, we can explore and we can use those powers to properly regulate airline and airport abuse.

And I think crucially, and Unite the Union are right about this, it can't just be in the cabin. It has to be the whole journey, from entry to the airport to your seat on the plane. Any abuse and intimidation has to be dealt with significantly, and it has to be a properly comprehensive system that ensures that when you are banned from one airline, this carries across the whole airport system. It can't be at the expense of putting others at risk in other providers. And just finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, on the issue of drop-off charges, which has been much discussed.

It's an issue we had a very significantly busy Westminster Hall debate, which the Minister attended and responded to. This is an issue of great concern to my constituents. The charges have gone up significantly at Heathrow and other airports we've heard of today. And I think frustratingly for people locally, airports do not disclose what this revenue is used for. It is not clear it is going to improve the situation, to invest in community transport to avoid having to drive to the airport.

There aren't the routes for staff and for visitors in the north of my borough to get to Heathrow directly on public transport. And it is incredibly difficult, particularly for evening and night workers, to get there on public transport. So I hope in the provisions that have been added to the bill around looking at this, we will look significantly about increasing not just the transparency in drop-off charges, making sure they are adequately advertised, that there's ways that are easy to pay them and they are fairly implemented, but also that the revenue genuinely goes to improve community transport. That the transport impacts people don't drive to the airport directly, as has been said, but they do drive to the area around the drop-off zone, and local councils are made to pick up the parking enforcement costs of that and of illegal car parks that are opened for commercial purposes without permission. So I hope that we can, through this review, properly address these issues, which significantly do lead to many concerns for my constituents and communities.

But I strongly welcome the provisions of this bill and hope it makes swift progress through this place.

06:46:48 - 06:46:49

Alistair Strathern.

06:46:49 - 06:47:48

Alistair Strathern

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a real pleasure to be able to speak in support of some really important measures in this bill that the government is bringing forward today. And I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for the way in which she set them out at the start of this debate, but also some of the updates and assurances she was able to give about the further work that will be done after recent disruption to air travel over the last 48 hours that I know my constituents would have been affected by and many other constituents of other colleagues in this House will really be welcomed to hear too. One measure I think that's deeply important to me, and I know to many of my constituents from correspondence with me, is making further progress to finally tackle some of the real accessibility issues that have affected far too many users of our airlines who have those additional needs that are just not currently being met appropriately. It's been heartbreaking hearing from correspondence over the last year since I was elected, the ways in which the dignity of some of my constituents have been failed from start to finish by the aviation sector when they haven't been able to meet those needs appropriately.

06:47:48 - 06:55:09

Speaker 197

The removal of the compensation cap I think is a really important way of tackling some of the most egregious issues that have affected my constituents. There's nothing more indignifying than losing the very means you rely on to get around, and the loss of wheelchairs and other mobility equipment by airlines is an issue that needs far greater focus, and greater compensation is a useful tool to helping to drive that. The indignity mine and others' constituents have suffered as a result of these hasn't been capped, and nor too should the compensation they receive as a result. But as my friend the honourable member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip rightly pointed out, we must make sure in implementing this, we don't allow it to become an excuse from airlines to stand back from serving these constituents too. So I would welcome any clarification from the Minister when summing up of how we can make sure when this important and long overdue action to remove the compensation cap is finally taking place, how we can ensure we do so in a way that ensures airlines aren't able to step back from providing services, but actually finally held to account for honouring the commitments they should be stepping up and delivering for those with those accessibility needs.

We know too though that accessibility needs don't stop just at the need to ensure that their equipment is properly transported safely and securely. Right from getting through airports to boarding planes to disembarking, there are many challenges that some of my constituents with additional needs continue to face at airports. So I welcome the commitment too from the Minister and Government to think about how we can start to go further to tackle some of these issues. In this day and age when so many of these issues just are resolvable, it simply cannot be right that too many people do suffer indignity, do suffer impacts on their wellbeing, do suffer things that impact their willingness to fly and travel in the future as a result of a failure to meet these needs appropriately through airport right the way to carrier. And so I look forward to hearing more from the Minister about how the Government will be consulting on important measures to put these right, and I'm sure many colleagues will be taking the opportunity to intervene on him potentially to hear at great length about some of these considerations too.

As an MP of a constituency that neighbours an airport at Luton too, I'd be remiss not to touch as well on some of the really important potential measures that could be unlocked by the Government's focus on modernising flight paths. Now there are well-rehearsed arguments about the numbers of planes that should be flying in and out of airports, but there can be no excuse for using flight paths that don't minimise their disruption and impact on the communities around them and minimise the environmental impact too. It beggars belief that for decades many of these flight paths right across the country have not been updated. And I'm glad that this Government is determined to put that right, taking a grip of the issue, taking the powers needed to drive this forward and to ensure that we can properly now consider how we manage and capitalise on the best use of new flight technology to significantly hopefully reduce the impact of airline disruption at takeoff and landing both in terms of the noise and the wider environmental impact too. My constituents near the airport deserve to know that everything is being done that could be done to reduce the impact of flight trajectories on their day-to-day lives, and I know a robuster approach to modernising flight paths can play an important part in helping to deliver that.

I know me and the Minister have spoke about that at great length before, and I look forward to him hopefully being able to share a bit more detail today about specifically how we consider using these new powers potentially in the context of Luton Airport to improve the lives of my constituents and the neighbouring villages. Alongside that, I know we've also had quite a bit of discussion today about how we support people to get to our airports better.

Luton Airport and the pathways to it are often running through my constituency, so it's one that a lot of my constituents, both those who use the airport and those who have to put up with some of the traffic from people travelling to the airport, have a really strong interest in. It was really encouraging to see the airport operator introduce a pilot scheme over August where it would refund free bus travel, create free bus travel for anyone travelling to the airport for their holidays. This seems like a great initiative to me, supporting public transport, improving the viability of our vital bus networks at a time when they've never been more important to so many in my community, cutting emissions of those travelling journeys by being able to use public transport, but also crucially reducing some of the impact of that travel to the airport on my constituents by taking traffic off the roads and onto those buses. It is at this stage, though, only a pilot. So I'd welcome the government's consideration, both through national legislation but also direct engagement with the airport, how we can consider to continue to encourage them to actively incentivise this type of active travel.

I know as part of recent consent orders, strong active travel requirements have been put in place for Luton Airport. I'd note they are not currently meeting those, and I would urge the minister and the government in their conversations with the airport to ensure they are meeting those, to consider how this pilot could be extended, ensuring that my constituents travelling to the airport can continue to benefit from free bus travel, but that also everything that can be done is being done to minimise the number of cars on the road travelling to the airport, reducing pollution but also crucially reducing some of those congestion impacts on my communities too. It sounds like a win, and I'm sure with the minister and the airport's cooperation we can deliver that big bold win for my community as well. A number of other issues have been brought up in the debate that don't currently take part in the bill, but I'm sure the minister would want to come back on and we would want to echo too. A particular one I want to touch on is the impact on those who work in the airline industry of the real rise we've seen in abuse and misbehaviour at times on planes.

Being near to the airport, a number of my constituents are very proud to work for airlines. They take great joy in the work they do, they take great privilege in being able to do it, and they feel lucky to have the opportunity to do so on their doorstep. But year after year, we've seen worrying trends of abusive behaviour from passengers making that dream become on occasions a bit more of a daily nightmare. Unite the Union's survey showed some pretty damning statistics about the increasing incidents of abuse of airline staff, and I think it's beholden to all of us in this house to make sure we're taking note of them and acting accordingly. It simply cannot be right that 75% of airline staff surveyed were subject to verbal abuse recently.

It cannot be right that a third of them have been subject to physical intimidation or assault. That is something that is in our power to start to put right. Others have alluded to the fact that it is a worrying trend we're seeing across public-facing services, but it's a worrying trend it's beholden to all of us in this house not to accept but to act on, to step up to protect our aviation workers, to protect their rights to live and work in a safe, secure workplace, and to make sure they know not just their employer but we have their backs when they're subject to abuse that they simply shouldn't be. So can I thank the minister and the government for everything they've already done in this bill, particularly the grip they're taking to modernise flight paths in a way that I truly hope can be utilised to improve the wellbeing of my community and reduce the polluting impact of flights taking off and landing at Luton Airport, but I look forward too for further discussions both in this debate and beyond about how we can continue to improve the bill to protect workers and make sure we're doing everything we can to improve accessibility for passengers at airports. Thank you.

06:55:09 - 07:01:16

Alison Louise Griffiths

Shadow Minister, Alison Griffiths.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It has been a positive debate today. But before I move on, I would just like to reiterate the point that the Shadow Secretary of State and the Liberal Democrat spokesperson have made in calling for the government to make a statement on the third catastrophic systems failure of NATS. It is simply not good enough to come only to a second reading and not to allow members from across the house to question the Secretary of State.

I'm also deeply concerned that she thinks that six months is an acceptable period of time to return a report on this subject. But moving on, Madam Deputy Speaker. On this side of the house, our ambition is to foster the conditions for a safe, competitive, and world-leading aviation industry. This appears to be an uncontroversial aim. But as my right honorable friend, the Shadow Secretary of State, has said, whilst this is an important administrative bill, the soaring ambition this sector deserves is sadly missing.

But I'd like to thank right honorable and honorable members for their contributions today. The member for Sutton and Cheam has provided significant support for Lord Young's amendment in the Lords, but I particularly enjoyed hearing about his British standard suitcase. But the wider consensus has been on airport drop-off charges. We have heard right across the house members endorsing a review and keeping clause seven in this bill. The chairman of the Transport Select Committee, the right honorable member for Brentford and Isleworth, the member for Didcot and Wantage, for Mid Cheshire, for Hitchin, Macclesfield, North West Leicestershire, and St Austell and Newquay have all mentioned and spoken at length in some cases on this subject, and I would endorse their thoughts on this.

On these benches, we believe in the world-leading potential of our aviation sector. We want to encourage the enterprise, innovation, and competition which will help it to thrive. But on the searing cost to consumers of drop-off charges at airports, we urge the government to keep clause seven in this bill. The government's surface access strategies and targets incentivize these whilst penalizing drivers. Airports openly use these charges to discourage people from traveling to the airport by car.

At Gatwick, an airport heavily used by my own constituents in Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, it now costs ten pounds for ten minutes, one pound a minute, to drop off a loved one. This cost is felt disproportionately by disabled and elderly passengers and others with limited mobility. For them, using public transport to get to the airport may not be an option. On this side of the house, we welcome that this bill will provide greater protections to disabled passengers at the airport. Yet this bill must not make it more expensive for them to get there.

The government must address this contradiction and it should accept clause seven.

Madam Deputy Speaker, yesterday we saw the limits of the consumer protections put in place by this bill. A national air traffic control systems failure that has resulted in 900 flights so far being disrupted. The knock-on disruptions are likely to last for days. In the Lords, the government voted down Lord Young's amendment. This would have mandated a scheme to reimburse airlines and passengers for failures outside of their control.

The government assured peers a reimbursement scheme was unnecessary. Yet now airlines and passengers will be forced to pick up the tab for cancellations over which they have no control. Is that fair? May I close by expressing my thanks to Conservative and Lib Dem colleagues in the other place, led by Lord Moylan. After their hard work, this bill now delivers the necessary continuity of regulation that keeps our aviation industry safe following our departure from the European Union.

And it has enhanced the safeguards around travel arrangements for disabled passengers. On this side of the House, despite the concerns that we have outlined, His Majesty's loyal opposition will support this bill's progress through the House, together with its aims of driving economic growth, strengthening aviation security, and enhancing consumer protections.

07:01:16 - 07:01:18

Speaker 199

I call Minister Keir Mather.

07:01:18 - 07:04:45

Keir Mather

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is great to be back at the dispatch box, and let me begin by thanking all members for their participation in today's debate. But before I begin, I too would like to acknowledge the significant disruption caused by yesterday's air traffic control fault and apologize to all passengers whose travel plans were affected. Civil aviation, as those events have shown, is a cornerstone of our national prosperity, supporting jobs, investment, and connectivity across the United Kingdom. This is an important piece of legislation and one that is rightly regarded as an opportunity to strengthen a critical sector for the United Kingdom.

But the aviation sector has evolved significantly in recent years, both as a result of rapid technological developments, new aircraft capabilities, and the emergence of new airspace users, including drones. The current regulatory framework requires modernization to adapt to these developments. At the same time, the UK's departure from the European Union has limited our ability to update certain areas of aviation regulation. The sector has also had to respond to major external shocks, from the unprecedented disruption caused by COVID-19 to more recent instability in the Middle East. And to meet these challenges, we need a framework that is flexible enough to adapt to change, to support innovation, and to keep passengers at its heart.

This bill will help deliver that framework. The government has also listened carefully to the scrutiny that the bill has received in the House of Lords. We made a number of significant changes during its passage through the other place, particularly to strengthen accessibility provisions, passenger protections, accountability, and parliamentary oversight. And I would like to thank peers from across political parties and the minister, the noble Lord Hendy, for their efforts to achieve this. As a result, the bill before the House today is stronger than the one first produced.

Now, I've paid close attention to the points raised across the House this evening, and I would now like to address them in turn, starting with the remarks by the Shadow Secretary of State and the Shadow Minister. And may I warmly welcome her to her place. It's great to be working alongside her. They have made an impassioned defense of the aviation sector and aviation businesses. I only wish that there were more Conservative backbenchers here to listen to their impassioned pleas.

May I just make two points, one in regard to the Shadow Secretary of State's point around making a statement.

I would say to him through my experience as a government whip that it is never wise to question the Speaker's decisions around what is allocated or not allocated. I'll just finish my point. Allocated in this House. But I would just say to him on a genuine point, I am more than welcome to come and answer any questions that he may have in this place. And I know that the Shadow Minister also raised a really important point too about the fact that the Secretary of State has asked the CAA to report within six months.

May I just say that when we had the major outage in 2023, it took two years for the CAA to make a similar report, of which they made 34 recommendations, of which 32 have been implemented. So a six-month timeframe is a much shorter, sharper window in which to get definitive answers to these questions, alongside the fact that NATS is required to provide a report to the CAA within a week of the incident taking place to fully explain the implications of what has happened. And I'll now give way to the Shadow Secretary of State.

07:04:45 - 07:05:05

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed. And I thank the Minister for that. I just want to make it very clear that I was in no way questioning what the Speaker decided. The Speaker made it very clear to me when he spoke to me that it was his understanding that the government were going to put forward a statement. That's what the Speaker...

The government front bench can shake their heads, but that's what I was told by the Speaker.

07:05:05 - 07:05:19

Speaker 202

Order, order. I understand the points that are being raised here, but the honorable gentleman might well be advised to not relate private conversations with the Speaker to the chamber.

07:05:19 - 07:05:44

John Richard Holden

Well, okay. Thank you very much. But I think the point I was making is that I was basically being accused by the government Minister of saying something which I hadn't said. And I just want to make it incredibly clear what was said, because the real question is here is for parliamentary scrutiny.

07:05:44 - 07:07:16

Keir Mather

Well, of course, if the Shadow Secretary of State is of the opinion that I've mischaracterized what he said, I will of course withdraw it. But I suppose we should let the usual channels take their course and figure this one out. I would also just like to add that I was slightly remiss in what I said previously, because it's not 32, it's all 34 of the recommendations have been implemented. I would like to turn to a very serious point that the Shadow Secretary of State raised about drop-off charges and about the amendment that was made in the House of Lords. I would like to confirm to the House that the government does not have an objection to conducting a review into this matter.

I do think that we need to think carefully about the terms of such a review, about the length of time that such a review takes to ensure that we can engage with the range of issues that backbenchers have brought up today around transparency, around charging, about ability to pay, about free drop-off points. And I do understand people's frustrations when public transport challenges prevent people from accessing airports. And the honorable member for Macclesfield made that point very powerfully. I do want to acknowledge at the same time though, Madam Deputy Speaker, that airport drop-off charges do operate as part of a wider framework. They're often used to manage congestion, a point made by the honorable member for Harlow, and to meet modal share targets and to fund infrastructure improvements.

But this could all be part of the conversation that could take place through a review, and our approach will of course always be to protect passengers while supporting our airports as businesses. I'll give way to the honorable member for Mid Bedfordshire.

07:07:16 - 07:07:48

Alistair Strathern

I thank you for giving way. And he would have heard me at probably great length in my speech, for purely good reasons, talking about the importance of the subsidized bus travel that Luton Airport had offered over the summer holidays to not just my constituents, but anyone looking to travel from their airport this August. Might this way and might these subsidies be a really positive way, rather than just increasing the costs of drop-offs, but a positive way to encourage people to make that modal shift, to travel sustainably and to take people out of cars and onto buses getting to Luton Airport into the future?

07:07:48 - 07:08:04

Keir Mather

Well my honorable friend raises a very intriguing idea and I'd be very glad to meet with him to discuss it further. We of course want to be promoting as many people using public transport to reach our airline and our airports as possible. And I will also just give way to my friend from the Transport Select Committee.

07:08:04 - 07:08:36

Scott Arthur

And I do thank him for giving way. Of course none of us wants to see the roads approaching our airports more congested than they already are. But on drop-off charges we heard about Gatwick Airport. I checked their website. It seems if you're a blue badge holder it is free to use the drop-off service.

But can I just ask though irrespective of you know when this review takes place or even if it takes place I'm sure the Minister would agree that all airports in the UK if they're charging drop-off charges they shouldn't be applied to people who are blue badge holders and it should be easy for those people to access the airport.

07:08:36 - 07:09:11

Keir Mather

My honorable friend makes a powerful point because he is of course right that people with disabilities are disproportionately more likely to use drop-off services at airports than other customers. That means that it is incredibly important that airports facilitate that wherever possible. And I'm pleased to say that more often than not robust procedures are in place to ensure that passengers with disabilities do have free drop-off at airports but that of course needs to be something that is adopted widely across the across our airport sector. May I turn oh really briefly.

07:09:11 - 07:09:47

Peter Swallow

I am very very grateful for the Minister who's been very generous. He will know on this point of getting more people to be able to access airports on public transport I've raised concerns with him that the Heathrow expansion national policy framework draft isn't strong enough on making sure that if we are to have a third runway at Heathrow we also get the improved rail links including a southern rail link which could well benefit my constituents. Can I urge him as the Government looks at the responses to that consultation to think again and really strengthen that so we can make sure we get not only the third runway but the infrastructure that would be needed to support it.

07:09:47 - 07:19:13

Keir Mather

He is of course right to say that that should be our focus because in the four tests that we have set out upon which a development consent order for Heathrow expansion would be granted all of them are dependent on ensuring that we have adequate surface access to the airport both for his constituents and people across the country and the people who work at the airport too. And that is around air quality and also around carbon impact. So that must be a focus and it will be considered now that the consultation has closed. May I turn to the remarks by the Chair of the Transport Select Committee and start by sharing her anger and frustration for passengers who have been affected over the last two days but also to thank the staff the aircrew aboard planes for the difficult work that they have undertaken to make sure that people are ultimately safe and that their welfare is protected. And I understand that that will be many of the constituents for the right honorable member for Hayes and Harlington doing that important work.

She asks if passenger rights are fit for purpose at present. Well this bill gives us the power to update passenger rights where we do not feel that they go far enough. This taking place through secondary legislation can ensure that all members can feed their experiences into this process. Clause three of the bill also means that the Secretary of State must have particular regard to those who are most adversely affected when things go wrong and when disruption does occur. And she spoke powerfully about whether we need to have proper resilience and contingency planning for airports in relation to people with disabilities but also parents and having baby food.

All these considerations need to be part of that process. And I also thank her for championing the work for the honorable member for Bexleyheath and Crayford who speaks incredibly powerfully about his family's experience of traveling and using a wheelchair to travel and fly.

And I hope that he is reassured that the measures in this bill to lift the compensation cap for domestic flights for damage to wheelchairs goes far enough. I just want to turn next to another point raised by the chair of the Transport Select Committee. She made the point that there needs to be a single standard of treatment for everybody who uses our airports, building on the commitments in her committee's fantastic report, Access Denied. I can confirm to her that the department is looking at this issue very closely through an accessible travel charter, spearheaded by my honourable friend, the minister and the member of parliament for Wakefield. It will have key expectations, pledges, commitments, and make sure that treatment is consistent for passengers with disabilities from the train that they board to get to the airport to the airplane door.

That is incredibly important. She makes a broader point as well about public transport access in relation to airport drop-off charges, and the point around taxi access is also something that I'd be glad to discuss with her further. I know that it can cause unintended consequences around community disruption, particularly around unlicensed taxis, and I know that's an issue for the honourable member for Uxbridge as well. She is also right, and multiple members are right to point to the issue around staff safety. We should all be clear in this house that any form of abuse or intimidation of those who work at our airports is totally unacceptable, and the government will work with airports and airlines to stamp it out wherever we can, and work on this issue should be forthcoming shortly.

I'm very pleased to be meeting with Unite the Union on this matter tomorrow, and I thank them for their consistent campaigning on this work. Next, I would like to turn to the honourable member for Didcot and Wantage. He raised a really important point about scrutiny and delegated powers as part of this bill and whether or not there has been overreach. When it comes to the provisions in the bill that relate to CAA rule-making and the need to have those safety-making powers within the CAA, I do believe this is critically necessary because aviation safety rule-making is highly technical, it's fast-moving, yet the current system forces every change through a process that's very duplicative and resource-intensive. There are strong safeguards to that process.

Ministers are going to be able to set the CAA's priorities through a published framework, and during Lords' passage, the government also introduced amendments to strengthen parliamentary scrutiny of the new aviation rule-making framework, and actually implemented all of the associated recommendations from the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee, who he will know are very assiduous in their efforts to ensure that parliament is robustly consulted on these issues. But I'm glad more broadly that him and his colleagues are supporting the bill at second reading, and I look forward to engaging constructively with him on his amendments. The honourable member for Mid Cheshire spoke very powerfully about his experiences at Manchester Airport, both in regard to the use of sunflower lanyards, but also the sunflower room that they have. This bill is about making sure that consumer standards are upheld and giving the CAA the ability to do that, about strengthening people's rights through the Secretary of State having the power to do so. But we also can't omit the excellent work that is already happening at airports up and down the country, carried out by the staff who make those places positive areas to travel from for people across our country.

And I think that also needs to be recognised as part of this debate. The honourable members for Mid Bedfordshire and Uxbridge both raised a concern that when the compensation cap is lifted for damage to wheelchairs on domestic flights, airports or airlines might withdraw from their willingness to be able to take these wheelchairs onto their planes. I can assure them that I do think airports will work hard to comply with these measures and airlines also, but this bill contains provisions for the CAA to enforce consumer rights, and I'm sure that that will be part of any process that takes place in this space.

I should also say more broadly, that although this extends to domestic flights and there is an issue with this extending any further due to the Montreal Convention, I was pleased to speak to the United Kingdom's permanent representative to ICAO this morning about this very issue and how we might raise it more robustly in international fora. The honourable member for Sutton and Cheam raises our common obligation to think about all questions affecting aviation with a simultaneous consideration of their effect upon the planet. I'm glad that he thinks that we're engaging on some of these questions adequately and I'm always happy for him to push me further when he thinks we're not. We are developing a world-leading SAF mandate and RCM. The changes to airspace modernisation can mean that flights are more efficient and they burn less fuel.

The Jet Zero strategy is pushing us much further in this direction. More broadly, the Future of Flight Industry Group that DfT is undertaking pioneering work on aviation sustainability, electric and hydrogen as forms of propulsion in aviation, as well as promoting higher standards through CORSIA at ICAO. So I hope he feels that we're moving in the right direction and I'm always happy for him to push me further. But he does ask me a valid question around oversight of the CAA and NATS, a view shared by the right honourable member for Hayes and Harlington. He shares my view that we need to do everything possible to minimise the chance of what happened yesterday happening again.

He will know that the CAA as a regulator can put mechanisms on NATS for delay-related targets alongside penalties that reduce airline charges when targets are missed, but we know that we need to go further than that. We know that more needs to be done and as the Secretary of State said, the CAA will undertake an independent investigation to understand what happened. And by asking the CAA to review immediately, we can ensure as ministers that there is strong oversight for passengers. And if he believes that this should lead to further enhancements for air passenger rights, it is clause one of this bill that will allow us to do so. So I think that's a point very well made by the honourable gentleman.

Now, my honourable friend, the member for North West Leicestershire, it was a pleasure to visit East Midlands Airport the other week and she raises an opportunity that presents itself in this bill through its measures on slot regulation to think about how we can help our air freight sector to perform in a more agile way to move more goods through our airports and to boost growth for UK PLC. She also raised questions about allergies and how we can protect passengers travelling with allergies. That is incredibly important and that is why it is on the face of the bill and will form part of the consultation as formed under clause two. She also asked me when the consultation on these issues should take place and that will take place within 12 months of the passage of this act. And I thank her and the member for St Austell and Newquay for making powerful arguments in defence of our regional airports.

To turn to the questions from the honourable member for Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey, I thank him for his offer to work on a cross-party basis to ensure that we learn the lessons from what happened yesterday and ensure effective oversight of NATS. I also want to say to him that we're in the early stages of understanding what the impact is on consumers and on the aviation sector, but I will of course do my very best to keep the House informed as we get more information. He raises issues to do with the Ministry of Defence and RAF Lossiemouth, which I will pass on to the Ministry of Defence around regular training exercises, their noise impacts and how that intersects with civil aviation and I'll write to him on that issue.

07:19:13 - 07:19:55

Christopher John Vince

I think the minister's given an excellent speech there. The takeoff was fantastic, I'm looking forward to seeing the landing. But what I wanted to raise was the point raised by the honourable friend from Hayes and Harlington when he spoke about some of the recent issue with the fire at the electrical substation in his constituency's airport.

I'm just very aware that we're seeing increasingly extreme weather. We've seen the heat over the summer, I suspect we'll see extreme cold during the winter. I wondered if he has considered the challenges that that is going to face our aviation sector and whether he has considered what he thinks the government can do to mitigate those issues.

07:19:55 - 07:23:25

Keir Mather

Well, I thank him for his speech, it's fantastic. It's certainly detailed and I know we've been cruising at altitude for some time, so I'll do my best to get on with it. He raises a broader point about climate resilience at our airports. I can assure him that the DfT takes this matter incredibly seriously and is progressing work cross-government to think about how we can become more adaptive in partnership with the private sector to deal with these issues. Turning back to the matter of the legislative consent motion as it relates to clause seven, I can confirm to him that it does engage the legislative consent process for both Scotland and Northern Ireland, and my officials are engaging with their counterparts on this matter and I'll be sure to keep him informed.

The honorable member for Horsham asks me about the subject of his private member's bill on creating an ombudsman for the CAA. It is my view that the costs of setting up a potential ombudsman outweigh what the benefits of it would bring. Complex CAA decisions such as changes to flight paths are already subject to very extensive consultation. I'm of the view that the CAA has robust remedies for persons who are dissatisfied with issues to do with customer service, including consideration by the independent complaints assessor, and the work of the CAA is also subject to oversight by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, and that's before we get into a broader conversation about the CAP 1616 process. But I'm happy to discuss this with him after today's debate ahead of committee stage to think about what more we can do to address his concerns.

To turn to the comments by the right honorable member for Hayes and Harlington, he also raised a concern about the CAA reporting within six months and us not dealing with this with the immediacy that it requires. I can assure him that that report will be coming through from NATS to the CAA within a week, which will provide their initial assessment of what has taken place. And we will shortly have more to say on what the impacts are and I will endeavor to keep the House informed. He raises that point about whether there will be sufficient follow-up actions. It's a fair challenge, but I would just say that when the outage occurred in 2023, 34 recommendations were proposed to mitigate reoccurrence by the CAA, all of which has been implemented.

On the question of CAA oversight, I do agree with him that this is massively important. I would just say that we have a robust system that exists currently for CAA oversight, although we can of course debate whether to take it further. There's an independent complaints assessor, the CAA's work is subject to oversight by the PHSO, economic regulation decisions can be appealed to the CMA, and there is of course the CAP 1616 process for airspace modernization. But I'd be glad to engage with him about where we can take these matters further. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, to begin to draw my remarks to a close.

This bill is about modernizing the UK's aviation framework so that it remains fit for the future, supporting growth, strengthening passenger protections, particularly for those who find traveling through our airports most challenging, and maintaining the highest standards of aviation safety and the UK's formidable reputation in this space. Our ambition is to build a competitive aviation system that delivers for passengers and keeps pace with technological and operational change. Today's debate has been wide-ranging and a useful opportunity to discuss important issues with honorable members. I thank all those who have contributed and I look forward to continuing the discussion at committee stage and with that, I beg to move.

07:23:25 - 07:23:27

Speaker 204

Hear, hear.

07:23:27 - 07:23:33

Speaker 202

The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:23:34 - 07:23:41

Speaker 202

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

Program motion, to be moved formally.

07:23:41 - 07:23:42

I beg to move.

07:23:42 - 07:23:55

Speaker 202

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Money resolution, to be moved formally.

07:23:55 - 07:23:56

I beg to move.

07:23:56 - 07:24:09

Speaker 202

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Ways and means motion, to be moved formally.

07:24:09 - 07:24:11

Speaker 206

I beg to move.

07:24:11 - 07:24:26

Speaker 202

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number six on Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation, Minister to move.

07:24:27 - 07:24:33

Speaker 208

Not moved. Point of order, Richard Holden.

07:24:33 - 07:25:02

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. Members have not had the chance today to properly raise the issue of the NATS blackout affecting over 100,000 passengers, costing UK aviation tens of millions of pounds. The Secretary of State has not indicated that the government will provide a statement today in the chamber. Could you tell me what this side of the house and all members who might be interested in raising issues around this affecting their constituents can do in order to get answers from the government?

07:25:02 - 07:25:19

Speaker 202

That is not a matter for the chair, but the treasury benches will have heard his remarks and he will be aware of other parliamentary mechanisms open to him to raise this matter further. I beg to move that this house do now adjourn. The question is that this house do now adjourn, Dr. Rupa Huq.

07:25:19 - 07:26:46

Rupa Huq

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to flashback to the summer of 2024, Labour back in power, and with echoes of 90s Britpop, an Oasis reunion. Alas, the latter is only remembered now for the ticket price rip-off that happened. Endless online queues, tickets ever inflating during the transaction process, and then our pioneering manifesto commitment to stamp it out. But two years on, legislation hasn't yet hit the statute book.

One top manager told me, "I was really encouraged by the government's public commitment to stop profiteering on the resale market, but my optimism's taken a dent through stalling and prevarication." I'm just pointing this out to the Minister today. We know our PM is famously a music fan. He's unafraid to take action when needed, for example yesterday on Palestine. So I say to the Minister, let's get rid of this once and for all.

And I have my own Sale of Tickets (Cultural and Sporting Events) Bill ready-made to do the job. Our live music industry is part of a sector that's worth 8 billion to the national coffers every year. We're the second biggest exporter of recorded music, soft power. But touts are costing the UK... I beg to move that this house do now adjourn.

07:26:46 - 07:26:49

Speaker 207

The question is that this house do now adjourn, Dr. Rupa Huq.

07:26:49 - 07:28:07

Rupa Huq

Thank you so much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think I'll carry on where I was. Look, we know that the UK music industry is a major player in our national economy. But 145 million pounds a year is being lost to touts in a cost of living crisis. And these touts aren't like the old-fashioned man in a flasher mac with sort of tickets in his pocket saying, "Oi, do you want a ticket?"

They're online bots doing it through a very sophisticated way. And as Lord Brennan, the artist formerly known as Kevin, says so wisely in his fan-led review, "Everyone's life is enriched when they gather with others to enjoy live music."

It shouldn't be unobtainable and it shouldn't be out of reach because of profiteering by the opportunistic. There's two issues here: rip-off resale and dynamic pricing. So the first, it happens when minutes after gigs are sold out, resale tickets appear on sale online for thousands of pounds. All arts ought to be accessible to all so real fans can get tickets, not that they're hoovered up by these bots.

07:28:07 - 07:28:29

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Yes, I certainly would. Would my honourable friend agree that community-owned venues are actually better protected against this kind of touting? If live music belonged to the people who watched it and used it, that would be the way it would be protected most through community ownership, through cooperative ownership.

07:28:29 - 07:28:56

Rupa Huq

My honourable friend makes such a brilliant point. The mutualisation of our venues is an important thing. We know that we now have a Prime Minister who's a Labour and Co-op MP, I believe, so we hope to see those things in practice. But actually I've got an example of the Co-op Arena I will come to, so even sadly it doesn't seem to be... I think until we have proper legislation to get rid of this once and for all, then we can have certainty.

I give way to the honourable member for Strangford.

07:28:56 - 07:29:44

Jim Shannon

Can I congratulate the honourable lady for Ealing Central and Acton for bringing this forward? And always encouraged by the honourable lady's energy and enthusiasm for the subject matter that she's brought forward. The honourable lady is aware of action taken against the company StubHub in 2024 following concerns that customers were initially shown artificially low headline prices only for mandatory fees to be added later on in the purchasing process. That meant that 50,000 UK customers were eligible for refunds. But delaying the disclosure of unavoidable fees can exploit customers' attention.

Given that transparency is key, and I think that's what the honourable lady is seeking, does the honourable lady agree that current protections should be made sufficient to ensure that customers are shown the full and accurate price of a ticket before committing themselves to a purchase?

07:29:44 - 07:31:17

Rupa Huq

I certainly do agree with that and that is one of the provisions in my excellent bill. Yes, transparency, people should know what they're getting into. And this doesn't really just apply to theatre, football, sorry, to music, football, theatre, all sorts of other things are becoming subject to these processes. In July, Which? magazine found that seats for Lewis Capaldi's current O2 run in London, tickets for those were on resale sites for 1,400 pounds when they should have been originally between 32 and 111. And even a ticket for the All Points East festival with Ray, 114,666 on Viagogo, which he mentioned.

The original price was only meant to be 80. So this surge-gouge dynamic pricing where things fluctuate, we're used to it, we're used to variability with planes, trains, Uber, Amazon, but it's creeping into all of our lives. And it's made easier with data mining because this algorithmic calculation can factor in demand, willingness to pay, availability. So Oasis actually claim that it wasn't surge pricing with them, it was tiered pricing. There were different levels of ticket, so that's why by the time people were at the front of the queue, the 100-pound ones had gone and it was 300 pounds.

But I do feel the array of these different premium standing can be a bit confusing. Would you give way?

07:31:17 - 07:31:45

Jeff Smith

Yeah. I'm grateful to her for giving way and for making a typically entertaining and informative speech. I wonder if she'd agree with me, from the customer's point of view, there doesn't appear to be that much difference between tiered pricing and dynamic pricing. It's just when the cheap seats have gone, you have to pay the premium. And there's something at best unedifying about the whole concept of tiered pricing.

And is that something that she thinks the government should be looking at when they bring forward the bill?

07:31:45 - 07:32:12

Rupa Huq

Yeah, I mean, I think if there's transparency, if you're getting a sort of fan package and you get your dinner in it as well and there's other extras on top, you could maybe understand why. But this mysterious tiered pricing when there's no difference between the two, one is called premium, one is not, it is quite baffling. And in my bill, it actually says that on the site, all the way through, there should be in real time the amount of tickets at which price, so you don't get a nasty surprise when you're at the front.

07:32:12 - 07:32:46

Craig Gareth Snell

I do thank the honourable lady for giving way. And she's touched on something that's really important because the other part of this is that length of time that people have to sit in front of a screen to get to the front of the queue. That's fine if you can afford to take a day off work. That's fine if you are flexible in your work that allows you to sit and do that. But if you work shifts, if you work in a job that takes you out of your home, actually, it means that that is a structural barrier to lower paid people, mainly from working class communities, being able to access the theatre, the arts, the sports, that is the enrichment that we're saying they shall have.

And I do wonder whether as part of her bill, she might consider looking at how we remedy that.

07:32:46 - 07:38:21

Rupa Huq

He is so right. And actually, we've seen it's happening with things like the Royal Opera House, with the ballet, and these are perceived as elitist, correctly or incorrectly. So you don't want to make an elitist system more elitist. And again, people that have the time luxury of spending time to refresh all day. In fact, I found a Times article from January 2025, his remark reminded me of that.

It says touts are loathed as parasitic, but they provide a valuable service, sorting the hassle and risk of finding new buyers and reselling tickets. What? I think there's an important bit missing from that sentence: at a vastly inflated markup price. So he's completely right. So yeah, these practices do have their defenders.

And when I was trying to get signatures for my bill, there was resistance from some Tories, some might say. They were kind of saying that this is the free market, you can't have interference in all of our lives. But our constituents want this. They deserve transparency. They shouldn't be at the mercy of predatory touts exploiting fan loyalty to secondarily sell off these astronomically marked up prices and shutting out the masses, as everyone said, from accessing cultural events that enrich us all.

So I also said in this bill that there should be a maximum price cap and tickets should have the prices on them printed as far as possible. Because as my honourable friend from Stoke said, after the adrenaline rush of the virtual queue, there's pressure when you're at the front to snap up what's left, if you've had the time to be there. And then you have the buyer's remorse afterwards. How much? How many thousands did I just pay?

And it's too late. And again, this same Times article says while I might struggle to justify paying thousands to see England play at the World Cup, the truth is others will, it is the harsh reality of the market. It doesn't need to be like that. I found an interview with Robert Smith where he says that he's had longevity because he prices his things affordably. He wants people to come back, he wants people to wear the t-shirts.

He still makes a profit, but it doesn't have to be the maximum price point that the market allows. And with Viagogo, StubHub, in terms of multiples, there's no, there's no limit. And you know, children were left in tears recently at the Co-op Arena in Manchester because they wanted to see the girl group Katseye. And on one of these horrible sites, Hello Tickets, because within seconds the real thing sold out, their parents were forced onto there, 568 pounds for four tickets. These kids got to the venue and it was for 16-year-olds only.

No notification of that, no recourse.

Awful. Look, not all resellers are baddies. So Twickets is an ethical resale site. And the Albert Hall, the Roundhouse, LW Theatres, Ed Sheeran and Adele all use this as a partner. And they only allow tickets to be sold at below or the original price, original face value price, and they actually prohibit any increase.

Every listing is checked manually to ensure there is a real ticket behind it. And you wouldn't necessarily have to do that, you could put a maximum multiple in, you could put a maximum percentage, because there might be genuine reasons why you can't make the date, you might need to resell it. The other one that caught my eye, the Tickets for Good app from Sheffield, they've distributed 1.4 million surplus unsold music, theatre, comedy and sport tickets. And they donate and heavily discount these tickets for key workers and low-income individuals. And that again, as all my honourable friends who've joined in have said, opens up live arts and opportunities.

Because let's not forget for many, even the face value price is a stretch. And music is so important for well-being, for social connection, all those things. And I have to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, actually it's 10 past so I will throw this in, because we're not as late as we would have been. Yeah, I do remember when these tickets weren't so expensive. The first ones I bought was for Blur at the time of Modern Life Is Rubbish.

A pair of them, they were 8 pounds each from the Kentish Town Forum. I went to a window, a lady, I think the cleaner said I'll have to get the right person, they came along, I handed over the cash money, got the change. I think I haven't done the calculation, but we have done actually for my constituent. I haven't done the calculation factoring in current inflation. But my constituent Ross Cowan told me that she saw The Smiths at the Hammersmith Palais in my own borough.

I've actually seen Rick Astley and Bros in the same venue. But anyway, she saw them there in 1984 and the price was 3 pounds 50. And she actually said in those days a student like me could go, have a few drinks at the bar, could afford to get home, all these things. Now, given if you put in the Bank of England multiple of inflation, guess what that is in nowadays money? 3.50, 12 pounds.

So I think these things have gone up. You and I are the same age, we remember when things weren't so, or maybe same bracket anyway. The elasticity of demand, Madam Deputy Speaker, don't you love it?

07:38:21 - 07:38:44

James William Naish

Yes, I will, thank you very much for giving way. I think one of the things that has changed over time is the fact that there's now so much emphasis on live performance for musicians to be able to make an income. Perhaps you would agree with me that also the streaming services, we need to look really closely at that because the market has become distorted so there is such a great emphasis on making money through touring.

07:38:44 - 07:44:37

Rupa Huq

Super. Yeah, he is correct. I think the most accessed site is YouTube and they get not a penny from that. And sorry, I'm guilty of looking at music on YouTube as well, the old Top of the Pops appearances from the 80s or whatever. And Runaround, that was a good programme.

Swap Shop, all of them. But anyway, no, he's right. We need to remunerate. In fact, in Scotland they've just introduced a universal basic income for musicians or something, or they're talking about it. Anyway, we don't like that Scottish Government, boo, they're not even here today.

Where are they? That's 1-0 for you. Anyway, look, Viagogo actually welcomed the delay of the legislation. And they're notorious for selling these fake tickets that when you turn up to the venue don't even work anyway. They did a briefing for MPs where they said that they're stopping piracy.

I mean, it's just nonsense. But they're very sinisterly, their CEO Eric Baker at an on-stage event at JP Morgan boasted how he has the government's ear. I hope my good friend the Minister can put the dampener on this. He said that he's been five times to DCIT and DCMS between November and May and he's got the government in the palm of his hand, they're listening to him, he's educating them on the complexities of the drawbacks.

Please don't listen to these people, listen to the constituents. The Guardian, in fact, before the last election, found some footage of a secret meeting of touts. They were near London Bridge somewhere, establishing a lobbying group and saying they would sabotage, Guardian's words, the proposals. One of them even is seen from the stage saying, look, we can all chip in, we'll get a good lobbyist, because if this happens, we are, sorry, unparliamentary language, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are F-star-star-star-ED, if you know what I mean. So look, surely that's the point, we want to do those people over because they've been screwing the public something chronic for ages.

The power needs to rebalance towards the fans so that we can have arts for all. But these guys at the moment are continuing unperturbed, undisturbed. So look, I urge my honourable friend, be bold, stand up to the StubHubs, the Viagogos, all these nasty people. Zoran Mandani, he had a campaign at the World Cup called Greed Over Good, because obviously the tickets there were sky-high and dynamically priced. And as a result, 1,050 dollar tickets were ring-fenced for residents of New York's boroughs, and he even managed to negotiate free bus travel, because in the Brendan review it does say that transport is prohibitive.

So I worry that we risk falling behind other advanced economies on this. The US Justice Department sued Live Nation, Ticketmaster's parent company, and they had to pay up 280 million dollars after a lawsuit in damages. And this was for a scandal a bit like the Oasis one, but it was Taylor Swift and the Eras Tour. Ireland have all but banned secondary ticketing since 2021. Australia this year, their one includes resale, dynamic pricing and drip pricing.

These hidden fees, what are those for? It shouldn't be, you know, if you go down to the web tonight, you're sure of a nasty surprise, because that's what's happening now. And there's a million US, sorry, Australian dollar fines, 100 million, 100 million fines for offenders. So you know, scare them with something stiff like that, please, Minister. And look, just as we speak, in Wembley, Bon Jovi are taking to the stage.

The tickets yesterday, if you looked, were 80 pounds, but then there was this service charge fee of 17 pound 06, making the whole thing 97 06, 21.3 percent. That's a huge markup. And not just them, Niall Horan, P!nk, Jay-Z, all around that 20 percent mark for processing, handling, administration. Why also per ticket and not per transaction? We've just got rid of the hated two-child limit in recognition of families, these things can add up per person.

And sadly, it's happening with, as I say, the Royal Opera House, the National Theatre, which is publicly funded, it's not a charity, they're now introducing an element of these fees and dynamic pricing. I long for the days you could see in the queue who was in front of you. It wasn't, you know, there was some predictability there. So, I'm not against dynamic or surge pricing per se, seen as exploitative, but it could go down. I once saw Elvis Costello at Hyde Park, the real headliner was meant to be Elton John, but he cancelled, so it was good for me, I'm not an Elton fan, so saw him free.

And you know, people can understand those sort of demand factors like the price of the pumps at Acton affected by the Straits of Hormuz, but it's just when we don't know why they're doing this, it annoys us. So look, in conclusion, I would say, yeah, we need to bear in mind these ethical considerations. We need transparency, we need certainty. The draft bill in the King's Speech, welcome. I love the Minister's article in the Daily Record that says touts, your time is up.

But government does seem to be taking its time on actually introducing a bill to Parliament. So I say hurry up, do it today. Look, this government already has fixed many things on the cost of living crisis. So today, can I ask the Minister, can he please confirm when this is happening? I know we've been told when parliamentary time allows, but it would be an easy win.

As I say, there's a ready-made bill here to do it. We could just make that law. You know, where there's a will, there's a way. We've done it with driving tests. And the Prime Minister is a music fan.

The Ukraine war, tragic war, four Prime Ministers, he's the only one who's strummed a guitar with the troops. So let's do this. Let's not look back in anger. Let's make it happen, Minister.

07:44:37 - 07:44:40

Speaker 213

Minister.

07:44:40 - 07:49:19

Speaker 214

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank my honourable friend, the member for Ealing Central and Acton, for what was a very dramatic speech. I don't know if she's hankering after her youth by going after the places in which she's seen concerts before and wishing she could go back there, particularly with my honourable friend for Manchester, but it was a tremendous speech and I think we would agree with every word that she has said. And she did mention Bon Jovi in her speech, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would have been there this evening, actually, as they took the stage, had I not been here answering my honourable friend's question.

And it had particular relevance for me because I'm not new to this industry. When I had my own business when I left university, the very first thing that I organised was a Scotland-wide tour of a tribute band. And if I give you the tribute band's name, you'll never guess which artist they were a tribute to, but it was Non Jovi. And those tickets were dynamically priced, so they would only ever go down because nobody ever came to see them. But never mind, that's my own hankering after the good old days.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the UK live event sector is, of course, as my honourable friend has said, a jewel in our national crown, from world-class sporting matches to unforgettable concerts, many of which have not been forgotten tonight in Blaze. These events, of course, enrich our lives, strengthen community bonds, and inspire future generations. But crucially, they provide us with our stories of the future that we tell for years and years ahead. They greatly benefit our economy, generating billions annually, and they support a dynamic creative and sporting ecosystem. This government understands this, and we have put the creative industries front and centre of our modern industrial strategy, committing to boost investment in the sector from 17 billion to 31 billion by 2035.

For too long, however, as highlighted by the Lord Brennan of Canton's report following the independent fan-led music review, the joy of attending live events has been marred by unfair practices in the ticketing market, most notably the systematic activities of ticket touts, as we've heard from my honourable friend, who crowd out fans from the primary market and resell at extortionate prices. Ticket touts, and this is a remarkable figure, take 400,000 pounds a day from fans' pockets. That's nearly 150 million pounds a year. That's money that should be going into the industry. The government is committed to tackling industrial-scale touting once and for all, improving transparency around pricing practices, and putting money in fans' pockets.

And as my honourable friend has demonstrated, far too often fans are being crowded out of the primary market by touts who are only interested in making a quick and exorbitant profit at fans' expense. The government has been clear, this has to stop. And my honourable friend is correct, as I did say in the Daily Record, their time is up and the touts' time is up. We want to improve transparency, consumer protection, and fans' access to live events. We also want to make sure that they have a safe and secure means of selling or reselling their tickets or transferring tickets and ensure money flows back into the live event sector and to fans' pockets.

This is why we're committed in our manifesto and our recently published plan for music to introduce new consumer protections for live event ticket resale. And it is why my department, alongside the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, undertook a consultation last year on the best ways of tackling this, alongside a call for evidence on pricing practices across the wider sector. We received, Madam Deputy Speaker, over 500 responses from right across the live event sector with some clear themes for us to address, and those themes have been highlighted this evening already. Firstly, genuine fans should be able to recoup the costs of their ticket when they're no longer able to attend. Enforcement needs to be effective if our measures are to have impact.

Secondary platforms need to play their part in ensuring new rules are implemented and complied with. And primary and secondary platforms are part of the same ticketing ecosystem, and the former could do more to protect their sales and, where appropriate, share information more seamlessly with resale platforms. And as a result, we are taking action. Last November, we announced a robust package of measures to tackle exploitative touting, including a resale price cap, a separate service fee cap, limits on the number of tickets able to be resold, and obligations on platforms, all reinforced by the CMA's new powers under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act of 2024. And in the King's Speech briefing earlier this year, we announced that the government will publish a draft Ticket Tout Ban Bill in this session for pre-legislative scrutiny by the DCMS Select Committee, of which my honorable friend is a member.

And I look forward to working with my honorable friend and the committee through that process. Following pre-legislative scrutiny, the government will introduce the bill when parliamentary time allows. And as the Secretary of State said in Parliament last week, we're coming to it. The Prime Minister feels particularly passionate about this issue, and we will give the legislation the priority it deserves and needs. We all want to see this on the statute book as quickly and as soon as possible.

07:49:19 - 07:49:21

Speaker 215

I'm happy to give way, yes.

07:49:21 - 07:49:42

Rupa Huq

I'm grateful to him, and I'm sorry that he missed Bon Jovi because of me. I just wondered, is there any indication, because with all the things that a draft bill brings, all the hoops of more consultation, is this going to be 2028 now? I just feel that every day people are being ripped off. You know, the clock, we've just missed another summer festival season. Can he give us a time?

07:49:42 - 07:54:19

Speaker 214

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think as I replied to my honorable friend at the Select Committee that I attended last week, there was 39 bills in the first session of this new government, 39 very important bills that took us nearly two years to get through. And this session in the King's Speech, of course, we've introduced a number of bills, of this being a draft bill. I can only reassure my honorable friend and the House that we want to get this done as quickly as possible. And that means we need to find the parliamentary time when the draft bill is prepared and ready, which should be imminent, not too many sleeps left, depends how many days you want to sleep for. We will have a draft bill that we'll be able to take forward, but it is a commitment from the department, from both departments, DBIS and ourselves, to get this done as quickly as possible.

And the reason we're doing that, I know that the honorable lady has had her private member's bill that she's waving around on this topic in the last parliamentary session. I share her concerns for fans in this regard. It is worth noting her bill was drafted before the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which imposes new requirements around price transparency, and they came into effect in April last year. Our legislation will be focused on ending the scourge of touting, thereby improving access to live events. Tackling touting and ensuring that fans are at the heart of live events cannot be done by government alone.

Of course, industry needs to play its part. It is industry-led action, innovation, and best practice alongside the government's new measures that will truly transform the fan experience. And the government recognizes that many ticketing platforms, event organizers, and venues have devoted a lot of time, energy, and resources to this issue in recent years. We know significant money has been spent combatting ticket fraud, touts, and bot use, as well as educating fans on what to look out for when they're buying tickets online, all to ensure buying tickets is as safe and as seamless for fans as possible. Nevertheless, the strength of feeling from respondents to our consultation and the call for evidence was clear.

Industry must build on existing guidance to do more to tackle exploitative practices. And this is why we strongly welcome the Society of Ticket Agents and Retailers, STAR for short, commitment to convene the sector. They will establish new best practice that ensures pricing information is clear and upfront, and that fans are empowered to make informed purchasing decisions free from undue pressure. This work is already underway and I attended the inaugural meeting in March this year. The work is organised under four headings to address some of the key issues in the ticketing sector.

In fact, it shares our strength of feeling with regards to this touting issue.

Firstly, it will look at pricing transparency. Secondly, the industry will look at how the primary market can continue to be healthy. Another workstream will look at accessibility issues, and finally the industry will look at consumer education. Let's have a look if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker, at dynamic pricing, just looking at the time. Firstly, we know that dynamic pricing is a subject that many people are concerned about.

Businesses should feel free to use whatever pricing strategy meets their needs, but they must comply with the law. Where it appears this isn't happening, the CMA has the powers to enforce that and act upon it. And when businesses fall short of what is expected of them under law, the CMA has powerful enforcement tools to ensure businesses can be penalised and brought into line. Drip pricing is another one my honourable friend mentioned. It is not right when fans are shown a price for a product only to find that has increased by mandatory charges that are added as the transaction proceeds, particularly if they have been waiting all day on a front screen waiting to join the front of the queue.

I don't know if my honourable friend from Stoke-on-Trent South has sat in his parliamentary office at any point sitting... he nodded and then changed his mind, waiting on getting to the front of the queue to try and buy tickets, but it is a real problem. In June this year, the Competition and Markets Authority fined StubHub International close to £900,000 and ordered it to issue refunds to more than 50,000 fans exceeding £590,000 for using this illegal practice. The CMA is also investigating Viagogo for similar practices. Lastly and related, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I continue again to encourage the industry to adopt the £1 ticket levy, the voluntary £1 ticket levy for live events to support our grassroots music and grassroots music venues. They are doing the levy, but are they doing enough is a big question mark and we just keep encouraging them to do as much as they possibly can.

Can I thank my honourable friend for securing this debate on such an important issue which affects the dedicated fans that sustain our live events sector. I would like to reassure the House that this Government is tackling industrious ticket touting with urgency and will bring forth the legislation to ensure fans are not priced out of major cultural and sporting events. It's something that's a priority for this Government and we will do that. I look forward to returning to this House with the draft Bill for pre-legislative scrutiny and welcome further engagement with my honourable friend and many other honourable friends who've had a deep interest in this issue to help tackle ticket touting once and for all.

07:54:19 - 07:54:26

Speaker 202

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. The Ayes have it. Order, order.