House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittings
Speaker 5
For ten years I was the special envoy on post-Holocaust issues and I'd like to commend to the House the work of my successor John Pearce who's done a I think a remarkable job. But the honorable gentleman puts the hammer on the nail. There is no restitution in Poland that is recognized. It is not an accident. It is a deliberate policy of the government.
I would ask the Minister for another attempt at the highest level of government between ourselves, the United States and the European community to press upon Poland the need for action because it remains a great stain on that great nation's reputation.
Speaker 2
Well, I thank the noble Lord for the question and also for the work that he did previously as special envoy. And I wonder if it might be helpful if he came along to the briefing as well because I think it would be important to show the continuity between the work that he did and the work that John Pearce as the current special envoy is doing. He makes a very important point and what I would say is just to emphasize again that the special envoy agreed recently a coordinated approach to Holocaust era restitution in Poland with his US counterpart. And he also raised the issue directly with the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Warsaw. And with international partners, and I think it's important that we do this with international partners, we continue to press Poland to confront this historic injustice and deliver a fair, comprehensive and final settlement of outstanding restitution claims.
Lynn Ruth Deech
My Lords, Poland has been an outlier in this situation for many, many decades and one feels they're waiting for everyone to die so that they can avoid making restitution. May I encourage the Minister to take this issue to the Council of Europe, which is the best forum for this? At the Council of Europe, it should be proposed to Poland that they allow litigation outside Poland, provide access to relevant records, establish a central fund as other countries have done to at least pay partial compensation and preserve the memory of the dispossessed by placing Stolpersteine outside their former homes, which they have so far refused to do in an attempt to obliterate the memory, as I've seen for myself there.
Speaker 2
Well, again, I thank the noble Baroness for her question and for her long-standing campaigning on this issue. I know how deeply she feels about it. Some of the issues that she's raised, I know the special envoy has already been looking at. But I will have further discussions with him about the point she makes about the Council of Europe. Obviously, there are parliamentary delegations to that and so it may be something that she might wish to raise as well with representatives from this House who are on the Council of Europe too.
Martin Callanan
Building on the points of Baroness Deech and my noble friend Lord Pickles, it is the case that many families, Jewish families, have not been reunited with their property looted by the Nazis and the special envoy, as has been said, has a responsibility to support restitution. So could the noble Baroness the Minister say what estimate the government have made of the number of British families that have not been reunited with property stolen by the Nazis? And could she tell the House when the special envoy last met with the Independent Spoliation Advisory Panel?
Speaker 2
I don't have the figure to hand of the number of British families, but I will certainly see what I can find out about that and write to the noble Lord. With regard to again to the particular, and I didn't quite hear the particular body that he named then, but I will ensure that the special envoy is aware of the point that he's raised and again, if it would be helpful to arrange a briefing for him with regard to that particular international body.
George Foulkes
My noble friend the minister knows I have the honor of being one of the representatives of this Parliament to the Council of Europe and I can assure the noble lady that we will make sure that this is taken up. On another matter, can I ask the minister if she could ask the envoy to look into the revelations in the ITV documentary which was shown on Sunday night about some of the antisemitic and other racist remarks made by members of Reform UK and consider what action might be necessary.
Speaker 2
Well, first of all, I thank my noble friend for his offer with regard to the Council of Europe, of which he is a distinguished member, and I'm confident that he will discuss with the noble baroness what action may be taken. And I will certainly ensure that the special envoy is aware of the program to which he referred and to see whether there is any action that needs to be taken in that area as well.
David Blunkett
I beg to leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
David Pitt
My Lords, the government is committed to ensuring cash remains a viable method of payment. As regards the initiatives with the finance sector, that includes Link to ensure that cash machines are available, the Post Office for withdrawal and deposits, Cash Access UK for banking hubs and others, and we await the Lloyd report. Regulation of these services is done by the FCA. Cash acceptance by businesses remains voluntary and levels of acceptance are kept under review.
Speaker 18
I thank my noble friend. I should remind the House that some time ago I asked the then minister, Baroness Vere, if she would come to dinner with me on the proviso that if I couldn't access the payment system, she would be the one to pay. We never had the date. Would my noble friend bring pressure to bear on the UK Finance in order to ensure that their terminal approval system actually mandates tactile covers for flat screen payment devices so that people with little or no sight can maintain their privacy and have the equality that others take for granted.
David Pitt
Yeah, it's a really good question. I mean, there are some initiatives I think that we should commend from UK Finance, for example, accessible cards code of practice in where the largest card issuers have committed to common standards for design and future cards. UK Finance, it has also developed accessibility guidelines for touchscreen chip and pin devices as well as an approved list of accessible card terminals and vendors. And UK Finance and the British Retail Consortium are working together to identify opportunities to embed these features where customers need them most. But there is still work to be done and officials continue to raise the issue with UK Finance.
Speaker 10
As I'm sure the minister knows, some of the most vulnerable people rely on cash to budget and to administer their daily life. As you've pointed out, acceptance of cash is voluntary. Will the government legislate so that essential services are forced to make sure they always accept cash because some of the most vulnerable people only can operate in cash.
David Pitt
So there is no plan right now for legislation, but this is being monitored. The British Retail Consortium believe that all their members are accepting cash. I think 99% of corner shops are accepting cash. The Bank of England did a survey where 40% of people accepted that they had not been able to use cash, but had found somewhere else that they could get the service that they wanted. So this remains under review rather than there being any plan at this stage, but the issue that's being raised is an important one.
Susan Kramer
My Lords, this is getting more complicated. In a year or so, payments, including some salaries, will start being paid in stablecoin. What happens if you don't have an electronic wallet? Even if you have a smartphone, how can you use it to access cash from an ATM? Who is going to pay for interoperability, and is it going to fall on the consumer or the banks, but not on the companies that will be making increased profits out of stablecoin?
David Pitt
So in terms of access to cash, I think in fact in terms of people getting hold of cash, that there are initiatives that are taking place on this. In terms of future payment systems, there is the National Payments Vision, which is trying to put together what an entire system would look like using different payments methodologies. But I think some of this is work in progress in terms of where it is that we are and where it is that we're going.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, has my noble friend looked at the experience in Sweden, where a few years ago there were a number of crashes and online payments were completely halted? And I think the conclusion in Sweden was that they had to have an element of continuing cash payments. Are we looking at that?
David Pitt
Yes, we are in terms of this question of resilience. There is, for example, a project with Mastercard, for example, to support point-of-sale terminals from 2027 if the system failed, so the system would still work. There is also a multi-year campaign on preparedness more generally, where the notion that, for example, our payment systems, all ATMs could fail, that we're thinking about what are the backups to that. Again, though, that is work in progress, as is the Mastercard, because it's not here yet.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, the truth is that not everyone is sophisticated financially, and those who are not tend to use cash, especially the elderly. There's a lot of concern in the House. Given the increasing drift away from cash, for example in car parks, will the government take steps to ensure that those who use cash can play a full part in the life of our nation and actually get on with this?
David Pitt
So yeah, look, it is a good question, and the availability of cash through the system, through the banking system, I think that we are on top of that. But it is the case that acceptance of cash is voluntary, whether it's a car park or a retailer or the rest of it. And that is an issue that is under observation, if I might say, rather than something on which there are direct plans.
I might also point out, though, the other way that one can deal with this is to make sure that people do have a way of being able to pay by card. So, for example, the reduction of people who don't have bank accounts from about 1.2 million to 900,000 over the past four years, I think is positive progress. But the point that the noble Baroness is making is a good one.
Kate Hoey
The noble Lord mentioned a review. Is he consulting pensioners' groups across the country on this, because they particularly are affected by the lack of cash and having to use these modern devices? And can he give a commitment that no government department or institution will ever make it compulsory to have to use that, and that there will always be the option of being able to use a card or cash?
David Pitt
So, what I have talked about some reviews. When I've talked about the voluntary acceptance, that is voluntary acceptance. And as I say, we have data from the British Retail Consortium, the Local Shop Association, the Bank of England and so on about whether that acceptance is currently a problem. There isn't a consultation on anything that would make acceptance of cash mandatory right now. And so, whilst the pensioners' groups will be involved in those areas that I have talked about where reviews are taking place, it would not be the case that there is a review that is taking place right now of retail acceptance.
Speaker 31
My Lords, my Lords. My Lords, whilst taking cash is obviously necessary for some groups, it's an increasingly expensive thing to do for a dwindling amount of cash. Would my Lord consider, would the noble Lord consider how one ensures that corner shops and high street shops don't bear the cost of this while people who are online only just get away scot-free? And this must be a cost of providing cash that is borne across the retail and utility sectors as a whole.
David Pitt
So, right now, as I've explained, the choice is an entirely voluntary one by the people who are accepting the cash. Local shops, 99% of members of the Local Shop Association are accepting that cash right now. I do realize that there are some fixed costs in accepting cash and that that makes it more and more costly. That's why, as I say, this is something that is under observation by the government to make sure that we don't slip to a point where people are not able to buy the things that they need.
Speaker 27
My Lords, my Lords. My Lords, can I ask the House not to forget the purpose of this question as it started, which is to ensure that there is access to machinery by those, for those who are either blind or partially sighted? We've moved on to other issues which are of course important, but the whole point of the question was to ensure that those people with sight issues can have access to such equipment as is available. So please don't forget that.
David Pitt
No, that is absolutely right, and the government recognizes that individuals with visual impairment must be able to pay for products easily and safely. Some considerable progress, I think, being made on the cards. Some progress still to be made on how it is that chip and pin and pin services are used. And I will be reinforcing that message from the House with UK Finance. Thank you.
Caroline Pidgeon
I beg leave to ask the question standing on my name, in my name on the order paper.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, corridor care is unacceptable and we are tackling its causes by preventing avoidable admissions, improving patient flow and accelerating safe discharge. Just this weekend we announced almost 140 million pounds for 14 urgent care schemes alongside 25 new or expanded sites which are due to open for winter. Despite unprecedented summer demand, around 50 trusts reduced corridor care. We are working to end corridor care by the end of this parliament.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, the Royal College of Emergency Medicine reports today that two thirds of clinical leads say their trust does not count patients on chairs in corridors, patients who've been put on chairs in waiting rooms or even patients in corridors on the way in as corridor care. So what action will the government take and by when to make sure that every trust counts every patient so that we have a true picture of corridor care in this country?
Gillian Merron
Well, we're a lot closer to having a true picture because we introduced a consistent national definition, something I know the noble lady's been very keen on, but a national definition of corridor care and that was done in March of this year. But I would also add for the first time that monthly national data has been published since June and that is giving us greater visibility of where corridor care is occurring and in particular it's allowing support to be targeted at the most challenged hospitals.
Speaker 24
My Lords, my Lords, in the 1990s when I was a little boy, I was director of the Association of Community Health Councils and each year we ran something called National Casualty Watch which involved local community health council members going into every local casualty department, not only counting the number of people there, but asking them how long they'd been waiting. Successive secretaries of state, some of whom are in this chamber, in your Lordship's chamber, were not very happy about this, but it did have a profound effect on making people realize that this is not a way to run A&E departments. Could my noble friend assure us that given that the government is rethinking its plans to abolish Healthwatch and National Healthwatch, that facilities will be available for that sort of thing to continue in whatever new arrangements come forward?
Gillian Merron
Well, the principle of assessing patient experience as my noble friend describes is absolutely key to the health bill and I know we will discuss this more. But I would also say since my noble friend was a young pup as he described himself as in different ways, that actually we've now got the facilities as I say to be much more transparent and to use data. I mean it's probably important that I do say the collection of data which only started this year and didn't exist before is new and we are continuing to work with providers to improve the consistency and quality of reporting. That's absolutely key.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, given that three quarters of physicians report difficulties in accessing essential equipment, sometimes resuscitation equipment for patients in corridors and even more report compromised care, what work is the government now undertaking with the Royal College of Emergency Medicine to increase the provision of medical assessment units and particularly working with the clinical governance leads for those emergency departments?
Gillian Merron
Well all of this is important as my as the noble lady says, but we have a number of actions that are already being undertaken and one of them is about additional urgent care capacity. So for example, in total there's some two billion pounds going into urgent care and in particular capital projects, which the noble lady didn't specifically say, but I do think the improvement of facilities which is part of this is absolutely key as is getting care closer to home. And so I think that the kind of improvements that we are seeing for example, Basildon has an improvement to its emergency department as well as refurbishment as does North Tees. In all of these ways and working with the clinical leads we will improve what is a long-standing situation which should never have been normalized that we are saying should only be exceptional.
Speaker 25
I'm sure the minister has seen some of the hospitals that have actually solved this problem and I wonder if there a problem with hospitals that have overcome what is a very difficult problem actually sharing that information with other hospitals who are struggling. It always amazes me that when you see best practice you just don't understand why it's not shared and if they don't voluntarily share it is there anything the minister can do to make them share it?
Gillian Merron
Well the noble lady is right in what she says. Whilst I would say that we are very mindful of the need to make more progress, actually sharing best practice is actually key to how we're improving things across the whole pathway. It's probably worth me saying to the noble lady is actually the majority of corridor care is actually in a small number of trusts and that is why we're putting in targeted teams to work with those trusts to do exactly what the noble lady suggests.
Speaker 28
My lords, I pay tribute to the NHS staff who provide vital care under immense pressure. Recent reporting from the Queen's Medical Centre in my diocese of Southwell and Nottingham has highlighted their compassion and their professionalism. Does the minister agree that the challenge of corridor care is not only one of clinical safety and privacy but also of human dignity? Hospital chaplains provide invaluable pastoral and spiritual support to patients and families at moments of vulnerability and distress. So what consideration has the government given to ensuring that access to such support is not diminished when patients are cared for in temporary settings?
Gillian Merron
Well I would pay tribute to the service provided by hospital chaplains because I know that they extend support across those of all faiths and none and that is quite crucial. I think the main point I'd make, corridor care is not an acceptable normalization, we want to end it by the end of the parliament and I also would agree that dignity is very much part of it. So guidance given to hospitals is where there has to be corridor care in exceptions must take account of supporting the patient in the best way possible and that can of course include support for example from hospital chaplains.
Speaker 23
My Lords, the noble lady the minister has said that the department or maybe NHS England have been able to identify those hospitals where corridor care is at its worst levels. So can I ask the noble lady the minister what specific targeted support does the noble lady the minister's department or the NHS England intend to offer to those particular hospitals in order to reduce those high levels of corridor care?
Gillian Merron
Well, we are putting in specialist teams to work with those particular hospitals. The Secretary of State's made it quite clear that ending corridor care for children is an absolute priority. And we are also ensuring that as I said to the noble lady earlier that best practice is applied. But because of the additional funding we have been able to and will be able to extend capacity. And I know the noble lord will have looked at the areas that are receiving targeted financial support.
But there are the issue where we have greater levels of corridor care. Our teams are working with those hospitals to say why is this the case, this is how to sort it out and making sure that they can. Because of course that small number of trusts does mean that we've got greater reliance in some areas than others and that isn't all right.
Speaker 35
What additional support is the government going to give to the healthcare staff in accident and emergency departments who are feeling very demoralised following a difficult summer and now facing a difficult winter? And most importantly, isn't it time that we really linked care in the community in a preventative terms by subcontracting some beds in care homes so that those patients who could be discharged immediately if that was available can do so to enable things to be a bit better for those staff and patients this winter?
Gillian Merron
Well I would share the views of the noble lady as with the comments from the right reverend prelate about the role that our healthcare staff do play. And the noble lady's right about the connection with social care. I would add in that better patient flow and discharge actually relies on that. And that is why we have published the model emergency department and the model acute pathway and model discharge pathway so that we can see earlier assessment, timely senior clinical review, improved discharge and better patient flow. Because it is down to beds and also the pressure.
And if there's one thing we're promoting in terms of prevention is for everybody to get a flu jab who is eligible. Because we want to prevent people unnecessarily presenting at hospital, that will assist us greatly.
Margaret Ritchie
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Sue Hayman
My Lords, over 80% of England is in drought and that affects around 50 million people. Parts of the country have entered severe drought for the first time due to depleted reservoirs following an extremely dry summer.
This government is committed to a twin track approach to improving water resilience and has secured 104 billion pounds of private investment to fund urgent action to improve water efficiency and reduce leakage alongside new supply infrastructure which includes nine new reservoirs.
Margaret Ritchie
My Lords, as my noble friend the minister has stated, only last week a severe warning for drought was declared in parts of Southern England. And given earlier warnings about the severity of the El Niño effect this winter, what discussions have been held with the National Drought Group about conserving and storing water supplies as part of that monetary allocation during periods of persistent rainfall over the winter time, including the removal of barriers to the construction of farm reservoirs which would help protect food security throughout the year.
Sue Hayman
Well, in answer to my noble friend, government does engage with water companies, the Environment Agency, the Met Office and key sectors through the National Drought Group because what we want to ensure is proper coordinated action. And the Met Office regularly updates on the potential impacts of El Niño, which helps to ensure that the group is prepared to respond. And of course, the impacts of El Niño are uncertain, but we are aware it could contribute to continued dry conditions into autumn and winter, which could further reduce the opportunities to refill reservoirs. Defra has announced a further 15 million pounds of support to build on-farm reservoirs through the water management grant. And to enable farmers to make better use of water during wetter periods, Defra is also taking steps towards a more dynamic abstraction licensing system.
And the Environment Agency has committed to reviewing its approach to abstraction and has introduced a regulatory position statement which brings reservoir refill season forward from November to October.
Speaker 58
Does the minister agree, my Lords, does the minister agree that with the severe droughts declared in parts of the Southwest and Southeast and water companies still losing nearly 3 billion litres a day to leakage, the Clean Water Bill is needed now. Are the rumours true that it has been delayed again? Can she tell us when it will be introduced, given she told us last month she hoped to bring it shortly.
Sue Hayman
I can assure the noble lady that we are actively working on the Water Bill. It is an absolute priority not just for the department but for the Prime Minister. And we absolutely need to get it right. There is a lot of work going into it. There are a lot of changes that are needed to the water industry if we are going to really make the difference that we want to make.
And in fact, I've only had a meeting where I've discussed it today, so it is something we are very, very, very much actively working on.
Anne McIntosh
My Lords, may I commend to the noble lady the report from the Select Committee on Environment and Climate Change on the drought preparedness and the need to have environmental and economic assessments every year before the next drought. I obviously regret the situation in Yorkshire that we've entered drought for the first time. This morning I was at a meeting of the Association of Drainage Authorities. They say there is a crying need for small on-farm reservoirs, but the barriers are still there. These are taxation barriers, permitted development and planning barriers and others.
Will she please use her best offices to make sure these barriers are removed and that small on-farm reservoirs can proceed to be built.
Sue Hayman
Well, I mean, the noble lady makes a very good point. One of the issues, not just of on-farm reservoirs, but for other issues around farming, is actually the planning system. So we've been working very closely with MHCLG as a department to update planning guidance in order to strengthen support for agricultural infrastructure, whatever form that infrastructure takes. The National Planning Policy Framework that was published in August is looking to start to do this, and we're working with industry to look at further planning reforms that we could bring in that would help.
Speaker 56
My Lords, thank you. The Minister referred to leakage. I believe it is still government policy to try and reduce leakage by 50% by 2050. In view of the severe drought conditions this year and generally, would it not be wise to have a more ambitious target?
Sue Hayman
I always like ambition. I think ambition's a very good thing. What we have to do, though, is set targets that are also attainable and achievable. As the noble Lord has said, water companies have to halve leakage across the industry by 2050. That's compared to 2017-2018 levels.
We have seen last year there was a 12% reduction in total leakage, and we want to continue that and actually to move faster. So we have invested £720 million through the current Ofwat price review period in smart technology, including meters, in order to help identify and reduce leakage. And I'm sure if we can move more quickly, we would be very happy to do so.
Speaker 39
My Lords, in view of the kind of climate that we're all now entering into, I wonder what thought the government has given, perhaps in the Water Bill, to the construction of desalination plants?
Sue Hayman
Well, obviously, desalination is an important part of moving forward when we've got concerns around the amount of water that we have. And we are very keen to kind of work more proactively in this space. I mean, one thing I'm sure my noble friend is aware is that water companies do actually need to demonstrate that schemes will maintain secure water supplies, and that includes the eight new desalination schemes that have been proposed in the current water resource management plans. So it's something we're keen to move forward.
Speaker 52
My Lords, I declare my interest as a farmer and landowner. My Lords, water company investment in nature-based solutions to drought resilience, as well as flood prevention and water quality, are disadvantaged against grey infrastructure due to the continued skepticism of the Environment Agency and the bureaucratic approach of other arm's-length bodies. Rewetting, decanalizing, riparian planting, and peatland restoration demonstrate strong results in short timeframes while delivering significant benefits to our rural economy and to nature restoration. Can the noble Baroness the Minister assure us that the government will remove this bias in the forthcoming Clean Water Bill and allow the acceleration of nature-based solutions?
Sue Hayman
Well, clearly I'm not in a position to tell noble Lords what's going to be in the bill, but what I can assure the noble Lord on is that nature-based solutions are a very important part of the government's work in managing the situation regarding climate change and drought, because providing more integrated, sustainable solutions is actually where we make the difference. Even things like creating better soil quality can make a huge difference. So I think the three main aims around nature-based solutions for water that we're looking at are better groundwater resources, improving low flows in rivers, improving our resilience to drought. And what we need to do is look at the effective schemes that we can bring forward, and that doesn't just have to be through the Water Bill.
Speaker 38
My Lords, the company Thames Water, of whom I am a customer of, is running out of money within the next few weeks. Now, 18 months ago it was given 3 billion to keep going, and now it's asking for a further 2.4 billion. Why on earth is Thames Water not in special administration already?
Sue Hayman
Well, I think the simple answer to that is that the rules for special administration actually make it quite difficult for government to put it into special administration while it is still financing itself. Now, I know the noble lady is saying it's about to run out of money, but on paper and to the finances, it is continuing to operate as a company and provide water. The question is, is how long is government prepared to accept the current situation, and that's something we're looking at.
Speaker 47
My Lords, could I ask the minister to reflect on the irony of the Liberal Democrats raising the issue of water shortages in the South East and South West when their party was at the forefront of campaigning against new reservoirs, particularly in Didcot in the Thames Valley.
Sue Hayman
Well, I think we had a question on reservoirs last week, and I think I made the point then that I'm going to make now, is that people are desperate for reservoirs before they've been built because they haven't got enough water. As soon as you try and build a reservoir, all of a sudden people don't want it in their area. We have got to come together as a country and sort this out.
Polak
My Lords, I beg leave to ask a question of which I've given private notice. The question is as follows: to ask His Majesty's Government, in the light of growing antisemitism and recent violence against British Jews, what assessment they have made of the role of the National Security Adviser in tackling antisemitism in the UK to protect Jewish communities.
Speaker 41
I'd like to start by commending the noble lord for his work in tackling the scourge of antisemitism. The role of the National Security Adviser is to coordinate security and intelligence issues of strategic importance across government and support the National Security Council. Combating antisemitism is a whole-of-government and a whole-of-society effort. This includes ensuring that national security capabilities are deployed effectively to protect Jewish communities, individuals and sites. But it cannot just be about security.
That is why this government is taking steps across education, health, culture and in the online space to go further to ensure that Jews in Britain are able to go about their day-to-day lives without fear.
Polak
My Lords, the vast majority of British Jews identify as Zionists. So when Zionists are the target, most of the British Jewish community are the target. When there are anti-Israel leaflets outside Jewish schools, boycott Israel good stickers on ambulances in Golders Green weeks after others were set alight, my Lords, this is not protest. It is singling out and the intimidation of British Jews. Only yesterday, a woman pushing a baby in a pram in Stamford Hill was punched in the face.
My Lords, it's not more and more money, and it's not higher and higher walls. I would urge His Majesty's Government and the National Security Adviser to take a good look at its policies, at the Department of Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, and specifically the FCDO, and examine how they are adding to the problem.
Speaker 41
There is no place for antisemitism in this country, and this government will do everything we can to tackle it. I would only add to what I previously said and say that British Jews should not be held to account for actions by the Israeli government, and that we will do whatever we can, and I know Jonathan Powell will do whatever he can to tackle antisemitism in this country.
Bruce Grocott
My Lords, in agreeing strongly with my noble friend's response to this question on antisemitism, for the record, can I get it clear, because there's a lot of loose language around this, that to support strongly the establishment of a Palestinian state is not antisemitic, to criticise the current government in Israel is not antisemitic, and to condemn as loathsome the views of one or two members of the current Israeli government towards Palestinians, that is not antisemitic either.
Speaker 49
My Lords, can I express agreement, of course, with what Lord Grocott says. Does the Minister agree that combatting antisemitism is not just the responsibility of the government, it's the responsibility of all responsible political parties? Does she also agree that we should celebrate the extraordinary contribution of the Jewish community to this country in terms of science, arts, business, the law, sport perhaps not so much, the Jewish community should not be defined by antisemitism.
Speaker 45
Absolutely agree with the noble Lord on that point. I think he expressed it better than I could myself.
Speaker 11
My Lords, the previous speaker made the big mistake, I believe, I hope the Minister will comment, of conflating what is happening in Israel and the Palestinian territories with what is happening in the UK. In the UK, we are plagued with increasing antisemitism. My question to the Minister is, will she assure this House that the National Security Advisor is not over-influenced by the comments his wife has made in national newspapers this week?
Speaker 41
The views that the noble Lord alludes to are held by an individual who does not represent this government in any capacity. As the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government said earlier today, the person concerned is a wife of the National Security Advisor, not the National Security Advisor, and it is important in political discourse to maintain a distinction between government employees and their families.
Martin Callanan
My Lords, the Campaign Against Antisemitism has expressed serious concerns about the public comments of Sarah Helm, the wife of the National Security Advisor, the noble lady just refers to. She said, the government have said, quite rightly, that Sarah Helm does not represent the government. However, in a post in public exchange on X last night, she denied, she said "nope" in response to a question, was her husband involved in that decision to proscribe Palestine Action. So could the noble Baroness tell the House how Ms Helm knew whether her husband was involved or not? None of us know who in government was involved in that decision.
Speaker 41
It's a government decision and the government's position on Palestine Action is clear. And the Court of Appeal has found that Palestine Action carried out acts of terrorism, celebrated those who took part in them, and promoted the use of violence. The Court of Appeal found this and the prescription of Palestine Action does not affect lawful protest. So I think the government's position on Palestine Action is clear and Parliament has decided that it should be prescribed and we continue to hold that view.
Speaker 14
My Lords, of course it's possible to criticize Israel and its government and its policies without being antisemitic. But if Israel is held up to standards not applied to other countries, singled out for criticism not made of other countries, and if the only country you happen to campaign against just happens to be the only Jewish one, please don't tell me that you're not an antisemite. And I have to say this as well, Parliament's obsessive focus on Israel, the constant and false allegations made against Israel and its conduct, is driving antisemitism in the UK. And every party in Parliament needs to consider this very, very carefully.
Speaker 41
This government remains supportive of a two-state solution and maintains the right of Israel to exist. I think you can hold two views and we can have legitimate criticism of the Israeli government alongside supporting the country's right to exist.
Speaker 46
We still have time for questions from more than one bench. We'll turn to go to the Labour benches first.
Speaker 64
My Lords, after my letter to the new Prime Minister outlining some serious issues in relation to security and well-being of the Jewish community, I'm delighted to hear that last week for the first time in our history, the National Security Council was convened specifically to discuss the government's response and actions on antisemitism. The Minister agree with me that what's crucial going forward is a cross-government response to antisemitism, not one that hides in individual departments, but the one where the whole of government using the principles that the National Security Council will have met on to take forward a whole government response.
Speaker 41
We have to have a whole government response, otherwise we cannot tackle this. I'd like to thank my noble friend for his work in his review into antisemitism, racism in the NHS and healthcare system. I'd like to point towards the fact that we're expecting the findings of Sir David Bell's independent review into antisemitism in schools and colleges shortly. Unless we look at and tackle antisemitism wherever it is found and wherever it manifests its ugly head, we will not tackle it effectively and this will definitely require an all-government, whole-of-government approach.
Sarah Ludford
My Lords, I would normally resist making spouses responsible for each other's pronouncements, but this situation is worrying for a very highly sensitive position. If vetting for the post of National Security Advisor encompasses the family, the household, were Sarah Helm's posts ignored, or were they accepted as okay?
Speaker 41
The views, as I stated previously, are held by an individual who does not represent the government in any capacity. I can only just repeat that again to the noble lady.
Speaker 55
While there's still time, I wonder if the noble baroness, the minister, would welcome an intervention at this point from representatives of the Green Party?
Speaker 41
I, um, that's a matter for the noble lady. It's not up to me to say who should ask me questions.
Speaker 62
Could I ask a very simple question? Why is it that 82 years after they first opened the camps that showed the abysmal way in which Jewish people were treated, the six million, and yet 82 years later, we are having a rise in antisemitism? Can we not have an analysis of why this is happening? Because all I find is people saying, yes, there's this, it's going up, it's going up, it's going up. But where's it coming from?
Why is it that I talk to hundreds of young people who say, I am not an antisemite, I'm an anti-imperialist? So where is this coming from?
Speaker 41
I respect the noble lord's views. This government will look both at where the antisemitism is coming from and also how we can best tackle it. I'd say we can best tackle it, however, both on a cross-government approach, but also we definitely need a cross-party approach to tackling the scourge of antisemitism.
Speaker 65
Thank you. With many on these benches, I am deeply concerned by the rise of antisemitism, hate crime, and violence in this country. Following the publication of MI5's recent domestic threat update, it was deeply concerning to hear that the security services have dealt with so many individuals seeking to carry out attacks against synagogues, mosques, and other faith buildings. And I'd like to thank His Majesty's government for the Places of Worship Protective Security Scheme. But can I ask the noble baroness, the minister, whether any assessment has been made by His Majesty's government as to whether this provision is enough, given the current level of threat?
Speaker 41
We'll always look at what more we need to do. And as the right reverend prelate will be aware, the Home Office is committing considerable amount of money to the Jewish Community Protective Security Fund. We're clear that we need to follow what Lord Macdonald said and review public order and hate crime legislation to make sure that we both protect but also prosecute where appropriate.
Speaker 63
May I ask the noble lady, the minister, a point arising from what the noble lord, Lord Polak, said about how the word Zionism is used as a sort of cover? I think it would help this, your lordship's house and the country, if the noble lady, the minister, would explain how the government defines Zionism.
Speaker 41
Well, I think we would define it as the right for Jews to have their own homeland. I think we're really supportive of the two-state solution. At times that looks like it's an impossible goal, but we remain committed to a two-state solution and the right of the Jewish of Jewish people to their homeland.
Magid Magid
Just pick up on the point that actually I spoke to Lord Polak about outside is that often people that hate one minority community also hate another. And in my case, we said, actually, people that hate us probably hate us both. But can I actually raise a point with the minister around a loophole that often we see councillors who make comments and when they're referred to standards board, often it's referred as they did it in their capacity outside being a councillor. I'm sorry, my Lords, but if people are elected to public office, then we need to hold them to account for what they say. And maybe the government needs to go and look at that loophole because too many councillors up and down this country, not just also in that ITV, that Vi- ITV investigation that we saw, but people are getting away with saying things that hold public office that claim they've said it in a personal capacity.
Speaker 41
I would agree with the noble Lord that people need to take responsibility for what they say. I'm very happy to take his suggestion away.
Speaker 59
My Lords, the time for the private notice question is up. It may be a convenient time for those Lords who wish to leave the chamber to do so quickly and quietly. My Lords, Cyber Security and Resilience, Network and Information Systems Bill, order of consideration, Baroness Lloyd-Webber.
Speaker 54
My Lords, I beg to move the order of consideration motion standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 53
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Third reading of the Commercial Payments Bill, Lord Lyon.
Speaker 60
My Lords, I have in command from His Majesty the King and His Royal Highness the Prince of Wales to acquaint the House that His Majesty and His Royal Highness, having been informed of the purport of the Commercial Payments Bill, have consented to place their interests so far as they are affected by the bill at the disposal of Parliament for the purposes of the bill. My Lords, I will now make a short statement on the position regarding legislative consent on this bill. My Lords, this bill affects the whole of the United Kingdom. We have been engaging constructively with the devolved governments throughout the passage of the bill and are hopeful of securing legislative consent from Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Following the common framework agreed between our four nations in March, I want to recognize the work that the officials and ministers in the devolved governments have contributed to this bill and tackling late payments.
Sonny Liang
I'm confident that legislative consent motions will be granted by all three devolved legislatures, noting that provisions in the bill which touch on devolved areas are subject to a consent mechanism from the devolved governments, respecting the devolved settlements. However, it is not unusual for issues related to legislative consent to be resolved in the second house, and we hope to have more to say in the other place. My Lords, I beg to move that this bill now be read a third time.
Speaker 53
The question is that this bill be now read a third time. As many of that opinion will say content. Content. Thank you. The contrary not content, the contents have it.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, the recent Procedure Committee report agreed by the House reinforced the companion's useful guidance that the motion 'the bill do now pass' is usually moved formally. In line with that, I do not intend to make any further remarks other than to say I beg to move that this bill do now pass.
Speaker 66
The question is that this bill do now pass. I won't be saying anything either. Well, I, my Lords, I was going to say something, in particular thanks very much indeed to the minister for his excellent engagement, but given that everybody else is being brief, so will I. The question is that this bill do now pass. As many of that opinion will say content.
Speaker 53
Content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. Questions on a statement made in the House of Commons on Thursday the 15th of October on the National Care Service.
Speaker 23
My Lords, could I begin by thanking the noble lady the minister for allowing time for questions on this statement? And let me be, let me begin by agreeing with the noble lady the minister that it's imperative for us all to address the issue of an aging society, as I'm sure many of us in this house will appreciate, but to do so in a, an affordable and sustainable way. Now in 2024, this government committed itself to the creation of a National Care Service. We're now being told that only the groundwork will be laid in this parliament and that a National Care Service will be enacted after 2029. But we have no detail.
Will it be a nationalized care service with no role for mutuals, cooperatives, friendly societies, charities, social enterprises, non-profits, and family-run, family-run care providers? We have no detail of any of that yet. Now we on these benches recognize the extraordinary contribution made by those working in social care, as the noble Baroness Pitkeathley often points out, by the millions of unpaid carers who provide indispensable support to their families and their loved ones. They deserve our gratitude. And as the Minister for Social Care, Mental Health, Alison McGovern pointed out, there are now more than 13 million people aged over 65 in the United Kingdom, and this is going to grow, reaching 18 million by 2050.
So it's essential that any reform commands public confidence, but can also endure itself beyond the lifetime of any one government of any particular color. And I am concerned that the proposals that the government has set out so far do not meet that standard.
of the new social care system. Now that is welcome. But can the noble lady the minister confirm that if Baroness Casey's conclusions challenge the government's proposals today, that ministers will alter their approach, or will it merely be too late? Such an independent review must be allowed to inform policy rather than endorse decisions that may have already been taken. Now while we welcome serious efforts to improve social care, the Prime Minister's announcement of a National Care Service does raise a number of questions about its scope, about its funding, and about its practical delivery.
Therefore, I will be asking for some clarification on a few issues. The government has committed to a National Care Service providing free personal care. But as my right honourable friend Damian Hinds has carefully highlighted for us, personal care and social care are not interchangeable terms. Residential accommodation, nursing provision, and other essential support can represent a substantial proportion of the costs faced by individuals and families. So can the noble lady minister therefore explain precisely which services will be provided free of charge and which costs individuals will remain responsible for meeting?
And how will eligibility and assessment need to be determined? And will the arrangements apply equally to working adults with care needs too, not just the ageing? These questions are important because they relate directly to how families plan their finances in anticipation of old age. My Lords, the government's also placed considerable emphasis on improving the social care workforce. And we obviously welcome the recognition and the dedication and skill of care workers who quite often are undervalued when compared with healthcare workers.
But commitments on pay, pensions, and employment rights must be matched by a credible plan for recruitment, retention, and funding. So how will the proposed integration of the NHS and the National Care Service workforces operate when so much social care is delivered by independent and voluntary providers? And can the minister tell us the number of the expected workforce and what the cost of training and retraining might be? And what reassurance can the minister give that additional employment costs will not undermine the viability of those smaller care providers? And this brings me to my final point.
The government suggested that these reforms will relieve the pressure on hospitals and reduce delayed discharges and corridor care. We've all known the mantra: you don't fix healthcare until you fix social care. Now that would be a desirable outcome, but it requires far more than funding requirements. The challenges facing social care are too important for political slogans or promises. What we need to hear is practical detail.
Because those who rely upon care, the families who support them, and the dedicated people who deliver that care deserve clarity, certainty, and a genuinely sustainable settlement. So we on these benches will approach meaningful reform constructively and support the government where it makes a clear case. But the government must demonstrate that their proposals are affordable, deliverable, and fair to all generations. I do hope that the noble lady the minister can provide the House with those detailed assurances that have sadly been too absent.
Caroline Pidgeon
Social care is one of the greatest unresolved challenges facing our country, and every one of us will either need care ourselves or know someone who does. Yet too many people are left waiting, too many families are carrying unsustainable burdens, and too many patients remain in hospital because the support they need in the community is simply not available. And the consequences are felt across our country. Families are facing rapidly rising care costs, councils are struggling under mounting financial pressure, and thousands of hospital beds are occupied by patients who are medically fit to leave but cannot do so because social care provision is not in place.
And as I raised earlier in questions, this has knock-on impacts for our emergency departments and paramedics and the corridor care we are witnessing every day. Critically, we must remember the millions of unpaid family carers who quietly hold the system together. They save the state billions of pounds, often at great personal cost, yet many face financial hardship, exhaustion, and inadequate support, and quite frankly, they have helped save the care system from collapse. That is why any meaningful reform of social care should meet three fundamental tests. First, family carers must be placed at the heart of reform with proper rights, support and respite.
Secondly, there must be a universal safety net of care that guarantees dignity and independence, including access to free personal care. And thirdly, people must be protected from catastrophic care costs so that no family is forced to lose their savings or home that they've worked over a lifetime for simply because a loved one develops something like dementia or another long-term condition. And for me, lost in this debate are those people who need long-term care throughout their life, not just in later years, which seems to be the framing of the current debate. This also needs addressing. The country has waited too long for a sustainable settlement on social care, and the need for reform is urgent, and delay carries a growing cost for families, the NHS and local government alike.
So I therefore ask the noble lady the minister three questions. When will the government bring forward concrete proposals on social care reform? There is an opportunity for enabling legislation in the health bill currently, which could help with the pace of change. Will the government commit to putting unpaid family carers at the center of its reforms, including improved financial support, greater access to respite care and stronger statutory rights? And will the government introduce measures to protect individuals and families from those catastrophic care costs?
I'm really pleased that this issue is now up the government's agenda. But my lords, the time for reviews and promises has passed. What families, carers and those in need of care require now is action.
Gillian Merron
My lords, I'm most grateful to both front benches for their contributions and also I think coming in on what I think is a broad consensus that we are seeking to make, which is both politically but also in terms of the public, which is why the noble lady Baroness Casey is conducting the big conversation to ensure that the public comes with us too. And the noble lady Baroness Pidgeon just made the point, which is absolutely right, that adult social care has for a very long time been widely recognized in terms of needing reform, something I know the noble lord Lord Kamall also spoke to. What we are seeking is a lasting settlement and frankly that has evaded previous governments for various reasons of all colors. We want to ensure that we find the way forward and that is why the Prime Minister very early on set out a very clear direction and instruction and that's towards a National Care Service. And to highlight the main points, it'll be person-centered, preventative and closely integrated with the NHS because of course, as we've discussed so many times in this chamber, social care reform, healthcare reform, they are interchangeable and they are linked.
So I certainly accept that point and that this will also include fully funded free personal care for older people. I do think it's only fair that it's acknowledged that this is a long-term commitment and the Prime Minister has already accelerated the work needed to turn that vision into a deliverable plan. I'm sure that I would very much share the views of both noble lords in terms of wanting progress, but we all know we have to get progress accelerated, which is what the Prime Minister's done, but we have to make sure it is possible to do that. So the government has asked Baroness Casey to bring forward the timetable for her independent commission. It will now report in the summer, which is considerably sooner.
And I do want to make the point that we are already working in government to deliver Baroness Casey's early recommendations, including developing a new pathway for those with motor neurone disease, progressing the recruitment of a dementia tsar, publishing the modern service framework for frailty and dementia later this year, and also establishing a new national adult safeguarding board. So we're not waiting, and I think it's important that we emphasize that. And we are also making over 4.6 billion pounds of additional funding available for adult social care in 2028-29 compared to 25-26. And that will include 500 million pounds to deliver the first ever fair pay agreement for care workers, which will be introduced in 2028. To refer to the points that let me start with Lord Kamal's points.
Indeed, we are working in partnership with local government to put in place the foundations that we need to build the National Care Service. And I was grateful for the support the noble lord offered. And a critical part of that is how local authorities actually commission services. And through that practice, they will shape the local provider markets. So there will be cases indeed, as the noble lord said, where the role of family-run services, cooperatives, it is a mixed market, so to speak, and it will be for local authorities to commission as they feel fit, but also to create the circumstances for the services to be provided.
As I mentioned, Baroness Casey will make recommendations next year for a National Care Service. The government, we will consider this and we will publish a response and how we will deliver a National Care Service shortly, and I'm sure noble lords will hold me to that, shortly after the commission reports. And I say that in respect of the noble lord's question about approach by ministers. The noble lord asked me to clarify the distinction between free personal care and social care. So the National Care Service will provide fully funded free personal care for older people.
And to define that, that includes support with activities such as help with eating, bathing, and also using the toilet. And existing council support for eligible individuals will remain. It will be for the noble lady Baroness Casey to advise on exactly how and when free personal care should be introduced and how it will be built up in a sustainable way.
In terms of the workforce, well we are legislating as I mentioned for a fair pay agreement backed by 500 million. And most importantly, the Secretary of State very recently announced a new workforce action plan, again something that your Lordships' House has pressed me on and rightly so. And that will support recruitment, retention and career development. I think it's important, and Noble Lords have made this point, how we regard and support our workforce who we rely on to provide care is absolutely crucial and frankly they haven't had the deal they should have done. And that is why fair pay but also looking at their broader conditions including their training, the respect in which they are held with.
I know your Lordships' House has great respect and I certainly do, but that's... they could be regarded as just words. Words are important but we will continue as I say to support them as the professionals that they are. The... there will also be the first national collective pension scheme dedicated to care workers and an expansion of sector-based work academy programs so that we can help more young people and job seekers find routes into care careers. We do find that younger people are not well represented in terms of providing care, we would like to harness their interest and their expertise. In regard of the costs, as the Prime Minister has said, the provision of free personal care for older people will be fully funded through adjusting the triple lock from 2030 and the government will not borrow to pay for reform and will indeed continue to meet its fiscal rules.
The Noble Lady Baroness Pigeon raised the point about unpaid carers and the Secretary of State did recently announce a whole package of reforms including plans to appoint the first unpaid carers champion. And again I know that's something that Noble Lords have been keen to see. In order to ensure care throughout life, not just later in life, I would say to the Noble Lady we absolutely recognize working age adults who are high users of social care, I think that's often overlooked. They have different ambitions and it is right and proper that that includes participation in society and employment and their needs are very different to those of older age adults. So Baroness Casey's independent commission will consider reform for all those who need care including working age adults.
I should also say we are strengthening that join up that I referred to that I know Noble Lords want to see between health and social care services so that people have a more integrated and person-centered care by developing both neighborhood services but also reforming the Better Care Fund and we are enabling people to have more choice and control over their care, for instance by promoting the greater use of direct payments.
So, my Lords, I am grateful for the welcome for the work that we are doing. I completely agree how long overdue this is and as I say that is a view I know shared on all sides of the House, but I hope that the commitment of the Prime Minister, but also the actions we've already taken and will take will reassure your Lordships' House about the progress that we intend to make.
Speaker 68
My Lords, for some of us who are usually called the usual suspects who've been waiting for this for 40 years, these are happy days. But I think we have to remember that what we're seeking is a lasting settlement and therefore the National Care Service is only part of this. And would my noble friend agree that one of the really important things that Baroness Casey is doing in her research and in her proposals is to encourage the national conversation, because one of the major problems about social care is that nobody talks about it in their family. They don't make plans. They don't make plans for what might happen or what will happen.
If we can actually encourage people to think about the future for their own family, including of course the huge contribution that the unpaid carers make, somebody's suggested millions, it is of course 190 billion plus that unpaid carers do, but that conversation about what families plan will be of the utmost importance.
Gillian Merron
I do agree with my noble friend. I know she hasn't been patient for 40 years and nor should she have been as she has pressed all governments to take action. And the public are important for a whole number of reasons, not least of all how this will be funded, but also because it affects all of us one way or another at some point. The first phase of the big conversation on care that Baroness Casey started closed last month and the second phase will start soon. I would also add that some 125 people have also been randomly selected for a public panel on care to look at reforms of key reforms and their views on it.
So yes, consensus politically, consensus publicly.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, when we're looking at the interface between health and social care needs, and I must declare my role as president of Attend, the voluntary sector have a large number of people who can contribute very much to this. And I'd like to make have confirmation from the Minister that they are considering clarifying that relationship between voluntary providers both in the health care arena and out in social care to define their accountability and their shared objectives, to make sure that their relational insights are recognized and that they're able to maintain their independent identity as a voluntary organization, but are also recognized as being major contributors to enable the whole passage to be smooth and to provide additional support to those unpaid carers who are within a family as well as the unpaid carers who are volunteers belonging to some of these organizations.
Gillian Merron
Well the voluntary sector has always had and will continue to have a strong role. The points the noble lady makes are are very reasonable ones. And I go back to my point that I made to the noble Lord, Lord Kamal, about what I described as a mixed economy of provision. And it is the decision on services will be down to local authorities and how they commission.
Andrew Lansley
My lords, we have a direction but not yet a roadmap. I look forward to it. But one component of that was referred in the report on the 12th of October from the King's Fund. I hope the minister has had a chance to look at it on the future of social care reform. And it said that an essential element would be a cap on care costs as indeed the noble lady Baroness Pitkeathley referred to.
Parliament has legislated for this in the 2014 Care Act. Will the government now commence the relevant provisions?
Gillian Merron
Well, I'm very grateful to the to the King's Fund for their thinking and also their examination of this whole area. I would take the noble lord back to my point about Baroness Casey through an independent her independent commission is looking at this whole range of aspects, one of which he's referred to, important it is, and she will make her recommendations and the government will consider that. I take the noble lord's point.
Bryn Davies
May I welcome the statement and thank minister my noble friend the minister very much. I particularly welcome the section in it to which he referred about the collective pension scheme for carers, which is a seriously good idea. And I hope it can be introduced as they say at pace. However, the minister also referred to unpaid carers. And of course unpaid care is heavily gendered and is one of the main reasons for the gender pensions gap.
Is my noble friend prepared to consider a proposal whereby there could be support for unpaid carers by payments on their behalf into this collective pension scheme?
Gillian Merron
Well, I'm glad that my noble friend welcomes the recent announcement. I think it's only right and fair and proper also. And like him, I'm an enthusiast for this. On the specific point the noble lord makes, the noble lady Baroness Casey will consider various matters. I think our commitment has been the first national collective pension scheme dedicated to care workers.
So I'm not in a position to be able to agree directly, but I'm sure my noble friend will make sure that Baroness Casey is aware of his proposal and indeed I'm sure she will take note of this debate.
Claire Tyler
My lords, on a point of clarification, could I ask the noble lady if she can confirm that the references made to free personal care for older people, and I think she referred to that on a number of occasions, that the thinking is that will also apply to working age disabled adults? Because I don't think I heard her specifically say that. And of course working age disabled adults may need long-term care throughout their lives. So I'd be very grateful for clarification of that point. And separately, very briefly, may I ask the noble lady on the day that the COVID inquiry's report, an absolutely devastating report on the impact of the pandemic on care homes is published, will there be an opportunity for this chamber to debate that report?
Gillian Merron
That will be a matter obviously for the usual channels and I will ensure that that request is brought to their attention.
On the point about definition, personal care for older people will be free and will take the form that I've already described. We wouldn't want to preempt Baroness Casey in her absolute definition of that. And I should also reemphasize, although I think the noble Lord Kumar referred to this, that existing council support for eligible people will remain. Baroness Casey will also advise on how free personal care should be introduced.
Speaker 72
I welcome the direction of travel, and I think there's a fantastic opportunity currently with the Health Bill going through. And if we really are serious about integrating health and social care, now is the opportunity to do it. Because one of the barriers to social care has been that budgets are being held by local authorities, different budgets have created significant delays, for instance, even getting basic equipment for people that are ready for discharge. Will the government look into this and give it really serious thought, because budgets are indeed the biggest barrier? And if we are going to be integrating care and NHS workforce, what a wonderful opportunity to do it.
Gillian Merron
It is a wonderful opportunity, and it is very challenging. But, and I would certainly agree that NHS services and social care services have to work together through neighborhood health and also through joined-up care. And that is why over nine billion pounds will be committed to the Better Care Fund, some of that provided to local authorities, some of it provided to integrated care boards. I should also say that we are acting now on workforce, on commissioning, on data, and on digital infrastructure whilst the independent commission does develop its recommendations. But the point the noble lady makes is right, the Health Bill is a great opportunity, but ultimately greater integration will come, I think, in the wider changes that we do make.
Speaker 71
I apologize if I missed the answer already that the minister's made, but on the social care workforce plan, when is it intended to be published? And will it be published at the same time as the NHS workforce plan to ensure there is clear integration between the two proposals?
Gillian Merron
My noble friend missed nothing. But I'm very happy to clarify. We, as my noble friend knows, we are committed to publishing the NHS workforce plan soon. We were keen to ensure that the views of the new Secretary of State were taken into account so that we could be accurate. So the simple answer is it can't be at the same time because the NHS workforce plan will obviously come before there's a social care workforce plan on which more work needs to be done.
Speaker 73
My Lords, may I first begin by paying my tribute to my noble friend Baroness Pitkeathley for absolute decades of outstanding commitment and dedication to making carers' lives better. And I declare an interest that I have a son who lives with autism and learning disability.
So I really appreciated the comments that was made about making sure that adults with special needs and other care is something that's also addressed in this wonderful new opportunities to get as much right as possible. Having said that, I've been experiencing, my whole family has experienced over the last three weeks, the care of our mother at hospital. And I can tell you, I mean, shivers down my spine about the incredible dedication of the staff in the hospital caring for my mother and all the other mothers and grandmothers and everyone that's in the hospital. The transition, however, has been incredibly difficult, not for my mother because she has an army of extended family and we're going to do everything we can when she arrives home. But there are many, many women who are laying in that hospital bed simply because the community care is not in place.
So I think the transition must be seamless or it's never going to work and we're still going to continue debating this for another 30, 40 years. The last point I wish to make really is, and I have raised this issue on many occasion, given the desperate nature of local authority funding, there must be something in our approach now from now on which actually designates the fund. I can't momentarily forgot, it's, it's, designate the fund, I can't remember.
Ring-fencing.
Speaker 74
Yes, ring-fencing, thank you, thank you, Baroness Pitkeathley. It's ring-fencing. Will that govern, will the government consider this as part of the integrated care approach?
Gillian Merron
I'm sure that the whole House would share the noble lady's comments about my noble friend Baroness Pitkeathley and the difference that she has made over the 40 years to which she referred. And I thank the noble lady for bringing her personal experience of her family into the chamber. On the point of discharge, which I think is what my noble friend was referring to, I'm grateful to the noble lady Baroness Pigeon who gave me that question earlier today. And I won't repeat myself, but just to say that we are acting across the whole discharge pathway. And just this weekend, and I will repeat this, we did announce almost 140 million for 14 urgent care schemes alongside 25 new or expanded sites due to open for winter because we do need additional urgent care capacity.
But we also need targeted support for the most challenged hospitals as well as a whole range of other things, and that is exactly what we're providing.
Kath Kathryn Pinnock
My Lords, for 10 years now, council taxpayers have had to pay an additional 2% on their council tax for the social care precept. This now adds up to around about 300 pounds for a band D property. Clearly that varies across the country. Is there hope for council taxpayers that in the brave new world which I hope will come of free personal care, that council taxpayers will have a rebate?
Gillian Merron
Well, the noble lady does tempt me of course to usurp the Treasury, but I will resist her invitation. But I'm sure her comments will be heard by the Chancellor.
Fraser
My Lords, I want to join in welcoming a long-term cross-party approach to tackling social care. And I want to echo my noble friend Lord Kamall's earlier comments that social care and free personal care aren't necessarily the same thing. In Scotland, we have had supposedly free personal care since 2002, and it was extended for the elderly, and it was extended for anybody over 18 from 2019. But unfortunately, free is never free, somebody has to pay for it. And what we are finding at the moment in Scotland is that free personal care means you've got to be pretty desperate to get anything.
So definition of what these terms actually are and responsibilities of who's providing it are extremely important. And we've also toyed in Scotland with the establishment of, as I know the noble lady the Minister knows well, the establishment of a free National Care Service. And to date, since 2022, the Scottish government has spent over 44 million pounds to achieve absolutely nothing. So can the government please look at Scotland as a caution rather than a model? But please can I be reassured that we are looking at it and learning for the whole of the UK to benefit pensioners and working-age adults with disabilities who need care in Glasgow as well as Gateshead, and that we're not all going to have to sacrifice the triple lock for the pensions for nothing.
Gillian Merron
Well, I have had the opportunity to read the letter that the noble lady had published in the media. And I know the noble lady knows this, but funding decisions on health and social care are of course devolved matters, and that doesn't change. But it is the case, of course, that Scotland as well as the other devolved governments do receive funding via the Barnett formula as usual. And to the point she raises, indeed, I totally agree with her that definitions are important, and that is not just definitions, but practice and how we're going to actually really make this long-lasting are really the stuff of the independent commission, and that's why we've acted already. But the other thing is, of course, when I talk about a national conversation about social care, that does mean also learning from each other across the UK, and the noble lady can define that however she wishes.
Speaker 78
My Lords, how will the government ensure that everyone gets the same standard of care, particularly when there's going to be so many different service providers? For example, my mother-in-law came out of hospital, had two carers visiting her, and every time she'd ask them to do a task, they said, "We can't use the equipment," or "We don't have the training." And she turned around and said, "What on earth are they being paid for? I can do these tasks myself that they're willing to do." And she ended up cancelling her care.
Gillian Merron
I'm sorry to hear that that was the case. We have a whole suite of ways in which we already in the NHS ensure and seek standards. However, it is of course important, this is a personalized care service, and what is right for one will not be exactly the same for another, and I know the noble lady understands that.
But the noble lady also reminds me to make the point that in all of this we've got a great opportunity that's already happening about embracing technology particularly in the home. And whilst person-to-person care remains key, there's actually so much we can supplement now which we didn't used to be like home monitoring kits, reminders to avoid missed medications and for example sensors to detect and prevent falls. All of these along with person-to-person care are enabling people to live longer and healthier lives in their own homes along with the extra money we've put into making adjustments to people's homes.
Speaker 84
My lords, perhaps noble lords wishing to leave the chamber might do so quickly. Report of the Armed Forces Bill, Baroness Annabel Goldie on behalf of Lord Coaker.
Speaker 81
Question is that this report be now received. As many as of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it.
Speaker 79
My lords, before we start debate on report stage, the first group of report stage, I'd just rise to remind the house of some useful guidance on report stage in the companion. In keeping with the spirit of report, I will of course keep my remarks brief. Firstly, speeches should be more concise overall and arguments deployed in committee should not be repeated at length. Noble lords should not summarize or repeat at length points made by others and should not speak more than once except with leave of the house, usually only briefly to clarify a material point. Finally, the house will recall recently agreeing a procedure committee report that reinforced that when pressing or withdrawing an amendment, members must be brief and should not summarize the debate nor revisit points made when moving the amendment.
If we collectively adhere to this very useful guidance, I believe we can make swift progress and complete the report stage at a reasonable time tonight.
Speaker 82
My lords, before I turn to amendment one, Baroness Annabel Goldie. My apologies. My lords, before I turn to government amendment one, I wish to acknowledge the rather obvious point that Lord Coaker is unable to be in the house today. I'm sure your lordships will join me in wishing him a speedy recovery from his illness. He hopes to be back in the house next week.
Ann Trebus
I'm also sorry that Baroness Goldie, the noble lady Baroness Goldie is temporarily away from the chamber and I send the noble lady my best wishes as well. As a result, I'm here in the noble minister's stead. As noble lords know, I have been alongside Lord Coaker throughout all the stages of the bill and have learned so much from the informed contributions of noble lords across the house on this important legislation. We share I know a deep interest in matters of defense and security and in this context specifically the well-being of our armed forces in all areas, understanding the importance of that not just for its own sake but for the defense of our nation. So I thank noble lords for their thoughtful scrutiny and constructive engagement with the Armed Forces Bill both in this chamber and in the many conversations and meetings that the noble minister Lord Coaker and I have had with individual members and interested organizations.
I look forward to continuing in that constructive spirit in today's debate. I should also declare an interest from the outset that my husband serves in the Royal Auxiliary Air Force as a reservist. So starting with government amendment one which takes forward the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee recommendation that regulations bringing guidance under section 343AE into force should remain subject to the draft affirmative procedure, I beg to move.
Jasset David Cody Harlech
My lords, I declare my interest as a serving officer in the Army Reserve. I'll speak to amendment 2 in my name and that of my noble friend Lady Fraser of Craigmaddie. May I also take this opportunity to send my best wishes to noble lord Lord Coaker and Lady Goldie and to welcome the noble baroness the minister to her place. So this amendment merges the two that I tabled in committee and confines them to health bodies alone. That change answers the noble lord the minister's objection in committee which was that national authorities and ministers make decisions about the armed forces community in general rather than about individuals.
However, where a health body is dealing with an individual, it would have to establish and record whether that person is a serving reservist although answering would remain voluntary and a refusal could not affect any treatment. The body would then be required to have due regard to that person's need to meet the medical and dental fitness standards required for call-out. Clinical need would continue to govern treatment decisions throughout and reserve status could be weighed only as between patients of equivalent clinical priority so the provision is a tie-break which cannot displace a single patient with a greater clinical need. Let me deal at the outset with the noble lord the minister's point in committee that the amendment would require preference irrespective of the needs of everyone else. With respect, it would not and the text before the house says so in clear terms.
The case for the amendment rests on two things. The first is that the duty in clause 2 cannot operate on a cohort that nobody can see. In committee, my noble friend Lady Goldie asked the noble lord the minister directly whether the obligation lies on the reservist to declare or on the body to ask. And the answer was neither. He told the house that it was not the reservist's responsibility and that the government regards identification as good practice to be encouraged through guidance rather than a statutory requirement.
So, my Lords, we're creating a statutory duty of due regard while declining to provide the means of exercising it. The noble Lord the Minister also told the committee that the recording of someone's armed forces status does not always happen as it could or should, and I agreed with him. The National Health Service has a clinical code for reservists, has had a clinical code for reservists for years, but it's barely used. And in my own service, I've never once been asked when booking a medical or dental appointment whether I'm a member of the armed forces. My Lords, the second reason is capability.
This bill extends liability to serve, with recall to the age of 65 and a lower threshold for mobilization. And each of those provisions assumes that the individual is fit to deploy. The noble Lord the Minister confirmed in committee that reservists will not be mobilized unless they meet the relevant service medical standards, which is precisely the point, because a reservist who cannot obtain a dental appointment fails that standard and becomes non-deployable. That is not an inconvenience, but it's a capability loss, and it's one that the state has created by asking that person to be ready in the first place. My noble friend Lady Fraser gave the committee the clearest illustration when her daughter, who I have the honor of serving alongside in 1st Battalion London Guards, received call-out papers for Kenya with the Welsh Guards.
She'd been waiting treatment for a wisdom tooth and was very nearly undeployable, were it not for the rules to be adapted. I asked the Minister two questions in committee and received answers to neither. What is the department's assessment of the proportion of trained reservists who are currently medically or dentally non-deployable? And will the government publish the fitness standards irrespective of what happens to this amendment? Nobody can have due regard to a standard it is not permitted to see.
This amendment creates no charge on public funds. So I look forward to hearing what the noble Baroness the Minister has to say in light of this amendment, and indeed from the conversations I've had with other noble Lords outside of the chamber, I feel that there is growing concern over this issue and that the government and the Ministry of Defence needs to start taking some action here.
Fraser
I just rise very briefly in support of my noble friend because I've co-signed the amendment and add my wishes that Lord Coaker gets better soon, Baroness Goldie gets better soon, but welcoming the noble lady opposite, it's lovely to see you there. My noble friend has actually already given you the example of, you know, I declare an interest, my daughter's a reservist. But I think the problem we have here and the reason I am so keen to support the noble Lord Lord Harlech with this amendment is that I think what the government and the people in Main Building think happens and what actually happens are two very, very different things. And this is a very carefully worded amendment that isn't about putting, you know, putting any, it's not about clinical need, it's not about asking people to do things that over and above and beyond, but it is about operational readiness and it is about ensuring that when there is a blockage in the system, there is a simple way to unblock it.
And, you know, as I say, I think having due regard, that is very welcome. But if it is not actually being implemented, then we are leaving people unable to deploy because of things that are easily fixable. So that is why I'm supporting my noble friend. And I think whatever happens to this amendment, please could the noble lady ensure that what the spirit of the covenant and everything is, that it actually happens on the ground.
Speaker 89
My Lords, I too would support Lord Harlech's amendment number two in this group, which proposes a modest enhancement of the support that the NHS offers reservists. In looking at the redraft that he's produced since committee, I applied three short tests. Is it workable? Would it be beneficial? And is it fair?
Speaker 88
And I think the answer on all three is yes. Workable because, as he says, there are no essentially no additional costs associated with this. The people who would be eligible have already been deemed to have a clinical need for some sort of procedure or support from the NHS. This is not expanding eligibility above and beyond that that is already there. And in fact, I think we have an easier mechanism on offer to mean that individuals are not repeatedly being asked the same question because if we look at the debate that's happening on the Health Bill in parallel, we see that we are set to have a single patient record.
And that in fact will answer a lot of the administrative complexity that otherwise have arisen were this amendment being implemented absent what the Health Bill is likely to bring about. So I think it's certainly workable. Is it likely to be beneficial? Well, I think it's actually a very modest measure, perhaps too modest. It places additional duties on local hospitals and community services.
It does not place duties on general dentistry, for example. So it may well be frankly that more help would be of benefit. But it is certainly likely in its own modest way to make a difference for the reasons that were articulated at committee stage. And then the third question of course, is it fair? Is it displacing large numbers of other people from the from the waiting list?
And just sort of doing a bit of back of the envelope maths on that, I think the answer is clearly not. I mean, we've got six and a quarter million unique individuals waiting in England for some form of routine care. Even if every reservist in the country were on the waiting list, we'd be talking about under two percent of the slots. So the differential impact on everybody else is minimal. And in fact, this is not a new principle.
For those who are students of the National Health Service, you will know that between 1953 and at least 1997, the principle was well established that certain classes of veterans from the First and Second World War received priority treatment for certain conditions. And even today, rightly, merchant seafarers receive fast track access for routine care under the Dreadnought Medical Service on offer at St Thomas's Hospital so they can get back to sea as fast as possible. The principle is well understood, has been in place for many decades across the health service. We're just looking to apply it in this particular case. So my conclusion anyway is workable yes, beneficial yes, fair yes.
We're going to be having a debate in the next twelve or eighteen months on the Defence Readiness and National Resilience Bill. We're going to need to have a lot more of this kind of national conversation. If we can't even get this modest measure over the line, I hesitate to think about what the bigger debate will yield.
Julie Smith
My Lords, I rise with some trepidation, noting that the Minister is not in his place because he's ill, and the noble lady Goldie is not in her place because she is ill. I have, for the benefit of the House, I have done a COVID test today. I do not have COVID. I have not traveled to Kenya or anywhere else, so I have not caught anything in international travel. So I think I'm fit and safe to be here.
Obviously, we send our best wishes both to the Minister and to the noble lady Baroness Goldie for swift recoveries, and welcome the noble lady Baroness Ann-Trebus to this speaking role from the front bench. I'm delighted that the first amendment is indeed a government amendment, and one that I assume is in response to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee's request that we move so to ensure that the any statutory guidance is subject to the affirmative parliamentary procedure. Needless to say, we support that from these benches. At committee stage, I also gave these benches' support for the amendments brought in the names of the noble lady Baroness Fraser of Craigmaddie and the noble lord Lord Harlech. And as the noble lord has pointed out, this amendment before us today, amendment two, is focusing very much on the health bodies.
It is in many ways, as the noble lord Lord Stevens has pointed out, in many ways a small amendment. One question I suppose I have for the Minister, because it also relates to an amendment I have in a later group, is whether she and His Majesty's government are satisfied that actually everything is in place at the moment, that if somebody is a reservist, they are going to be able to get the dental or other treatment they would need to be able to go on deployment and aren't going to be held back by a wisdom tooth. Because clearly we need all of our forces, regulars and reservists, to be fit for training and deployment whenever that is required. So I am supportive of amendment two, but it would be useful to understand His Majesty's government's position on this.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, may I first give apologies to the House on behalf of my noble friend Lady Goldie, who is unfortunately unable to be here today because of illness. The noble Baroness, the Minister, whom I welcome to her place, will have to make do with just one Scot on the opposite benches today. May I assure the House that my noble friend is well on the mend. I've spoken to her several times today, as I'm sure you can imagine, and has every intention of being back amongst your Lordships at the earliest opportunity. May I also wish the noble lord Lord Coaker a very speedy recovery.
We miss him. I'm grateful to the noble lord the Minister for tabling amendment one to respond to the recommendations of the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee. I concur with the findings of the committee and agree that the guidance on the covenant duty is subject to the affirmative procedure. On amendment two, tabled by my noble friend Lord Harlech, I entirely appreciate the intent behind the amendment, and I would agree that better care for service personnel and veterans is required. Both categories of service personnel deserve the very best of health support, and this House has enduring admiration for their service.
This is particularly the case given the government's expansion of the covenant duty to cover all health bodies.
possible that such a duty ends up placing additional administrative burdens on for little medical benefit. Accident and emergency departments already end up asking a vast array of questions to patients, many of whom are in distress or pain and don't want to answer a huge deluge of questions. I offer these not as a criticism of the amendment, but as some food for thought in the practicalities of a particular situation.
Ann Trebus
Well, first apologies to the House for my keenness to get up and respond at several moments. I'll try and restrain myself for the remainder of the debate. And I would thank noble lords, noble ladies for their very kind words. I will pass on their thoughts to the noble minister, Lord Coaker. And I'm grateful, despite the way that I acted, for all those who've contributed to the debate.
And I think thank very much the noble lord, Lord Harlech, for his service in the reserves, for championing reservist matters as he's doing in this case, and for his time, thank you, in discussing the amendment as well. Now, the government agrees that reservists must be medically ready for mobilization as much as possible. Service fitness standards are already assessed, as everybody knows, through established pre-mobilization medical checks, and no reservist is mobilized unless they meet the required standards. I think we all agree. And I am grateful to the points made, you know, by the noble lord, Lord Harlech, and the noble baroness, Baroness Fraser, about the specific case studies issues, which I know from service background, I do appreciate them and understand them.
So you're speaking to somebody who is in sympathy, I would say. So, just quickly in answer to the question regarding the number, Lord Harlech asked about the number of personnel that were unfit or the proportion of reservists. I'm afraid we don't release information on the number of people deployable or the level that meet fitness standards for reasons of national security. So I apologize to the noble lord that he didn't get an answer earlier, and I'm happy to discuss further with him outside. The amendment, amendment two, would place a new statutory duty on UK health bodies to take reservist mobilization status into account when delivering healthcare.
That does risk undermining the long-standing principle that NHS treatment is based on clinical need, not employment status, albeit I note the noble lord, Lord Stevens's point about the merchant navy, which I wasn't aware of. We recognize concerns about whether reservist status is consistently identified and recorded across relevant health settings. And I would say, you know, we are committed to working on the gap that the noble lord, Lord Harlech, has identified and others have, that other noble lords have referred to. We understand that there is work to be done in this space. This is not a statement disregarding the points made, more that the approaches that the MOD are taking are slightly different from the way suggested in the amendment.
I agree that reservists are vital to defense, as noble lords will know, in the light of the strategic defense review recommendations. Significant work is ongoing across the piece on reservist experiences, which remains an important topic for discussion in your lordship's house. We are already working with defense and health officials through the reservists medical readiness summit to identify available evidence and where we can work to improve that gap that I've mentioned. That work, rather than a new statutory duty, is the right way, we believe, to improve reservist readiness. This bill already strengthens support for reservists by extending the armed forces covenant duty to health bodies, helping to address disadvantage arising from service life.
We'll continue to work across government to help develop understanding of the covenant and what practical application can look like to support our armed forces community, of which our reservists are a vital part.
Speaker 81
Question is that amendment one be agreed to. As many of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment two, Lord Harlow, not moved.
Not moved, not moved. Therefore we now come to the group of amendments beginning with amendment three. After clause three, amendment three, Baroness Smith of Newnham.
Julie Smith
My Lords, I rise to move amendment three in my name and consequential amendment, which I think is number 60. But is very, yes, thank you, very minor at the end. But this amendment on single living accommodation, or what we are now calling military home standard, is one that would have a profound impact on many service personnel and indeed their families. Much of this Armed Forces Bill talks about accommodation for service families, and that is obviously vitally important. But there appeared to be an omission on single living accommodation.
In the Renters' Rights Bill, my noble friends put forward amendments to ensure that decent, that family accommodation, service family accommodation, should reach decent home standards. But that didn't reach to single living accommodation. In his response to my amendment at committee, the noble Lord the Minister pointed out that there wasn't a decent home standard for single living accommodation and reminded your Lordships' House that, for example, students don't have a standard of accommodation that is enshrined in law, and that people in shared houses don't have a similar standard. My Lords, the analogy seemed apposite in many ways, but it isn't. As my honorable friend in the other place pointed out, many service personnel spend the whole of their service lives in single living accommodation.
They may be single, they may be married, they may be in long-term relations and have families, but because of the way they have chosen to be living away from home maybe during the week, they will find themselves in single living accommodation. My Lords, noble Lords may remember their student accommodation. It may have been very lavish. It might be something where they would feel, yes, I'd be happy to spend 28 years in that sort of single living accommodation week in and week out. But most people feel they want to move on from student accommodation, and we need to think about what we are asking of our service personnel.
So I went away and looked to write, produce a different amendment that would meet what we hoped to do in terms of ensuring a decent home standard for single living accommodation. So the amendment that is before your Lordships' House today is substantially reworded and reworked from that at committee stage. It is intended to create a decent home standard for single living accommodation for service personnel that would be no lower than the decent home standards applying in the Housing Act 2004.
My Lords, I think across the House we are united in our support for His Majesty's Armed Forces, for the service personnel and their families. In terms of recruitment and retention, we owe it to all of our service personnel to ensure that their accommodation is indeed of a decent standard. I hope that your Lordships might feel able to support this amendment.
Craig
Just very briefly, I'd like to support the noble Baroness in what she said. It doesn't seem to me right that there should be two standards or two approaches to standards in relation to any serving personnel. And having lived myself in service accommodation, admittedly not until I was a squadron leader because none was available, but now that the services are smaller, there is more chance that service accommodation will be made available. And if we want to ensure that not only the service person but their family and their spouse or partner are also part of that family, accommodation of a high standard for all is required.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, at committee, my noble friend Lady Goldie and I tabled a number of amendments in relation to the new Defence Housing Service, one of which was to oppose the question that clause 3 stands part of the bill. As my noble friend said then, I appreciate that the establishment of the DHS as a non-departmental public body is a settled position of the government as a result of its defence housing strategy. We did not sense sufficient support from around your Lordships' House for removing that clause, and for that reason we haven't retabled such an amendment for report. Whilst I do remain critical of the form in which this new body is to be constituted, I believe that if it is to exist, we must make every effort to ensure it works for those whom it is intended to serve, our valued Armed Forces personnel. And my Lords, that is why we've tabled amendments 6 and 7.
These amendments are a simplified version of that which we tabled at committee and would require the board of the Defence Housing Service to have three representatives of Armed Forces with recent experience of living in service family accommodation. The intent here is to ensure that truth is spoken to power, giving service personnel direct involvement in the operations of the new body and a realization that the remaining members of the board have lived experience amongst their number. I am extremely grateful that the noble Lord the Minister took the time alongside his officials for a briefing before the recess. I was reassured at the level of service engagement in the defence housing strategy and the fact that the government envisages ongoing involvement in this new service. And as such, I will not be seeking to divide the House today on these amendments.
My Lords, on amendment 3 from the noble Baroness Lady Smith of Newnham, I do offer my support. At that same briefing I previously mentioned, I did note that the government intends to run a second review to look at single living accommodation and produce yet another strategy. I have to confess to being dubious of this proposal. Would it not have made much more sense for the last strategy to address all aspects of the military housing as opposed to only focusing on family accommodation and leaving those in single living accommodation potentially in the lurch? My Lords, whilst we are discussing such a key issue as defence housing, I must say that it is a grave concern to these benches and I'm sure others that the government has reduced the budget for repairs to military housing this parliament.
Particularly so given the absolute assurances made by ministers during the public bill committee in the other place. On the 18th of March, then minister Al-Khan said, and I quote, the nine billion pounds has been ring-fenced. On the 26th of March, he further clarified that the quote nine billion pounds will be allocated to the defence housing service. And on the 25th of June, the Minister of Defence Readiness and Industry, Luke Pollard, gave a written answer stating that four billion of that money will be spent this parliament and five billion will be spent in the next parliament. However, when the defence investment plan was published a mere five days later, it allocated only 2.7 billion for upgrades to service family accommodation over the entire period from 26 to 30.
My Lords, even this commitment hasn't been endorsed. In a letter to the chair of the Public Accounts Committee in September of this year, the department confirmed 800 million of the investment into the service family accommodation had been deferred to the next parliament. And perhaps more worryingly, that letter also confirmed that a further 950 million deferral of investment into single living accommodation. Could the noble baroness the minister please confirm with a simple yes or no whether the department stands by those last two last stated figures? Will there be a 950 million pound deferral of investment in single living accommodation?
This is highly regrettable and undermines the delivery of the government's previous commitment. Could the noble baroness the minister confirm whether or not the government believes this new funding profile is sufficient to deliver the full planned upgrade? Rather neatly, the combined value of these two deferred investments is precisely equivalent to the amount of shortfall over which the then Secretary of State for Defence and current Chancellor resigned over. And my Lords, how will the Ministry of Defence find this money from its already overstretched resources when the Treasury is still refusing to commit to a date when defence spending will increase to 3% of gross domestic product?
Ann Trebus
My Lords, I would say as the noble minister, my noble friend Lord Coaker set out at committee stage and as he explained in some detail previously, the government does not consider it appropriate to tie the single living accommodation to the decent home standard. What I will do though is address as many of the points as have been made as I can now on SLA. First of all, regarding the review which the noble Lord Elminto referred to on single living accommodation, that is ongoing. It was launched in 2026. It's examining and developing recommendations on standards, including how they will be modelled and monitored, and it is due, I am told, to be published very shortly, very shortly.
And I look forward to discussing and debating the outcomes of that review as soon as it comes out. In terms of the standards, we don't consider the defence home standard to the noble lady Baroness Smith of Newnham, the defence home standard to be the appropriate mechanism for assessing single living accommodation due to the nature of having shared facilities, as the noble lady alluded to in discussing student accommodation. Clearly, we've all had varied experiences of student accommodation. I certainly would want it to be probably of a higher standard than some of mine, but that was some time ago.
And I also take the noble and gallant Lord's, Lord Craig's point about the state of service single living accommodation and the importance of improving it. That is, I absolutely agree. Indeed, I've stayed in single living accommodation over the last few years myself. I know that it needs improvement. In fact, and I've also taught non-commissioned officers and I know the problems that they have with their accommodation at RAF Halton, some of which are issues still to be resolved.
The noble Lord Elminto asked me about the spending and the results of the defense investment plan. We are going to be deferring 950 million this parliament under current planning assumptions, so approximately 10,100 single living accommodation bed spaces will have been impacted by the dip. So, but despite this deferral, there is substantial investment in SLA still programmed, including more than 1.4 billion pounds of direct investment in new build SLA planned before 2030, so in the first four years of the defense investment plan. Moving to government amendments four and five, these are clarifying amendments to ensure the legislation is clear that the Defense Housing Service will benefit from crown immunity for the transaction of acquiring property as well as when it holds the property. This is the current situation in the Ministry of Defense and the amendment seeks to maintain the status quo in the management of defense property.
My Lords, the government welcomes the intent behind amendment six and seven and confirms we entirely share the objective. The government is fully committed to ensuring that the voice of service families is at the heart of the new organization and I'll briefly set out how this objective will be achieved. First, the independent board which will hold the DHS to account will include a dedicated non-executive member with service family insight. And when I say service family insight, I mean someone with in-depth experience of service family accommodation. The recruitment for this crucial board member has already been launched, reflecting the priority the government places on this position, and a representative from the Army Families Federation will be involved in the selection of this candidate.
Second, a governance framework has already been set up in advance of the DHS being formally established, which will ensure service family voices are heard in the day-to-day running of the organization. A new customer committee has already been established, featuring representatives from the Armed Forces Families Federations. In addition, new regional customer experience committees will be established, recognizing that the views of personnel and their families will differ across different nations and regions. Third, one of the benefits of the DHS being set up as a public purpose public sector organization within the MOD family is that it will include military personnel on its staff. And when I mention staff, I am also asked for clarification, I'm talking about the staff in the Defense Housing Service, not the members of the board, to be clear.
So the broader staff. This includes a new DHS chief of staff military position, which has already been filled, and this post, as I've alluded to just now, will sit alongside a number of other military personnel working within the DHS, ensuring the voices for voices of service personnel are at the heart of the organization. Fourth, the government is determined that DHS empowers service personnel and their families to hold it to account directly. In this spirit, the Secretary of State recently launched an initiative to pilot the sign-off of repairs by families alongside a red tape challenge for Armed Forces families to propose rules and processes that can be simplified or removed entirely. I can give an example that was recently introduced, some may be aware, for example, the default right to have a pet in a service family home.
That's just an obvious thing to make a default position. And we look forward in the MOD to working with forces families to find out what other areas we could easily make changes that will make life so much better for them on a day-to-day basis and less burdensome and bureaucratic.
I could talk Haythornthwaite review all day but I'm not going to get started on that right now. Parliamentarians as well as ministers will be able to hold the DHS to account via its reporting to Parliament, not just on the outcomes it achieves but on its responsiveness to the needs of service personnel and their families. And I would say that in terms of military home satisfaction, that has increased by 12% over the past year, 25-26, with 75% of families now saying they're satisfied, higher than the 71.3% national average for civilian landlords, which is quite a considerable achievement, I would say, considering the challenge that has been faced by the Ministry of Defence and this government with the state of accommodation. I hope I've provided the necessary assurance for the noble Baroness Lady Smith and that she can withdraw her amendment.
Julie Smith
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble lady the minister for her response. And clearly, it is significant that His Majesty's government is looking into a review for single living accommodation. But as the noble Lord Minto pointed out, funding has been reduced for single living accommodation. And if it is indeed the case that a report on single living standards is going to be coming forward, then having this amendment to the Armed Forces Bill surely will enhance the hand that the MOD will have in ensuring that single living accommodation is up to standard. And therefore, I would like to test the opinion of the house.
Speaker 81
The question is that this amendment be agreed to. As many as that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary, not content. Not content.
The question will be decided by a division and I will inform the house when voting is open. Voting is now open, clear the bar.
Speaker 96
My Lords, the question is that Amendment 3 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary, not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.
Speaker 100
My Lords, the contents 259, not contents 173, so the contents have it.
Speaker 97
Amendments 4 and 5, Baroness Annelay of St Johns formally. The question is that amendments 4 and 5 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.
Amendment 6, Baroness Goldie, not moved. Lord Minto, not moved. 6. And amendment 7, Lord Minto, not moved. Not moved.
After amendment 7, we go to amendment 7A on the supplementary list, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I want to start by thanking Lord Coaker and Lady, um, not, and their officials for the meeting last week and with Lady, with which was held with Lady Royal, the Suzy Lamplugh Trust and Aurora New Dawn. It was a very helpful meeting and even if we didn't agree on everything, the discussions were helpful and the government amendments in this group are welcomed and I thank her for that. I'm sorry Lord Coaker is not able to be in his place and the same for Lady Goldie and hope they both recover swiftly. And I look forward from hearing from Lord Catts in due course on this bill. Despite the fact that there are nearly 17 amendments in this group, a number are responding to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform report, as well as issues raised by myself and by the Bishop of Norwich in our respective movements.
Turning to my amendments 7A and 7B, which I have laid in the light of the response at committee stage and the discussion that we had at the meeting last week with the ministers. Amendment 7A would provide a coordinated multi-agency response known as MASIP to cases of stalking across military and civilian public bodies, which will improve risk management and victim protection. Now, the aims of this bill to ensure that the military court system provides as close a similar system for victims of serious crimes as the civilian system is laudable.
But as Lady Royall and I mentioned at committee, there are still some marked differences in the treatment of stalking offences and therefore victims of stalking compared to the civilian system. Amendment 7A uses the language used in both the Home Office and Ministry of Justice and in recent legislation. Amendment 7B would require the Secretary of State to publish annual reports on progress in addressing stalking and managing it within the armed forces, including data on service stalking protection orders, the implementation of MASIPs and specialist stalking training. My Lords, earlier on I relayed amendments 8, 9 and 10 on stalking protection orders, continuity of protection as individuals who have either been stalked or have been convicted of stalkers move between the military and the civilian world. And importantly, that the service victims' code must always apply to victims of sexual offences and domestic abuse offences, including giving service victims the right to access victims' services.
These were laid before the minister had laid his amendment, amendments G11 to 15. They don't, the government amendments don't go quite as far as I would like, but they are progress and I recognise that. I've also signed the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Norwich's amendments, including the protection of service police officers in the broader legislation to protect the police and other emergency workers, which seems eminently sensible. And his amendment 48, which seeks to make impersonating a service police officer an offence and giving service police the same protections as their civilian counterparts. They are really important amendments and I'm delighted that the minister has laid amendments to bring these into law.
Amendment 11 specifically ensures that the victims' code in service justice system will be presented to Parliament. And this responds to some of the concerns of the Delegated Powers Committee, but provides a partial reassurance to my concerns that reviews of the implementation of this new legislation would not be reviewed publicly or transparently, and if that's carried through, it will be. However, I'm still not sure that these government amendments provide as much protection for victims as I would like, and certainly they don't quite yet match the civilian standards, including those people being stalked. And as the amendments that I've laid and look forward to hearing from the noble lord the minister, and in the meantime I beg leave to move my amendment 7A.
Speaker 99
Amendment proposed, after clause 7, insert the new clause, the words of which are on the supplementary list.
Speaker 65
My Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 47 and, sorry, 48 and 47 and 48 in my name and that of the noble ladies Baroness Goldie and Baroness Brinton. I welcome the noble Baroness Lady Annelay to her place and I wish the noble lord Lord Coaker and the noble lady Baroness Goldie well in the speedy recovery from whatever bugs or beasties have got them. I declare an interest as the father of a soldier. I'd like to pay tribute to the way the noble lord Lord Coaker has listened well and sought to improve this bill. The minister has worked in a positive way with the amendments I brought at committee stage and now at report that seek, as the noble Baroness Lady, the noble lady Baroness Brinton has already said, seek parity for service police with their civilian counterparts when they are assaulted or impersonated.
I thus fully support the government amendments 45, 46 and 47, and I'm grateful to the minister and to the officials who have worked on the complexity of these amendments across the nations of this country.
So thank you to the government for listening to service police and for bringing these important amendments. It will not be a surprise to your lordships that I will not be moving the amendments in my name.
Julie Smith
My lords, I was assuming that my noble friend Baroness Brinton had made all the points that needed to be made and wasn't intending to speak, so I will merely reinforce everything she said.
The Earl of Minto
My lords, I'm pleased to support the efforts of the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Norwich to include service police officers in the scope of the offences of assaulting an emergency worker and impersonating a police officer. And to that end, I signed his amendment at committee, and my noble friend Lady Goldie has signed them again today. At committee, noble lords will recall I raised the further point that the differential treatment by the law towards civilian police and military police is also replicated in Scotland and in Northern Ireland, and I'm pleased that the right reverend prelate has updated his amendments to reflect this. It is particularly welcome that the government has listened, realized that the right reverend prelate has identified a lacuna in the law and acted. When the government does right, we, His Majesty's opposition, will support them.
Speaker 102
As such, amendments 44, 45 and 46 have the full support of these benches.
Speaker 79
My lords, I will begin by addressing amendment 8 and thank the noble lady Baroness Brinton for her views, for her contribution to the debate and indeed through committee stage as well. And I would like to join her in thanking the work of the Aurora New Dawn and the Suzy Lamplugh Trust, who of course their invaluable work on this important issue has very much aided, I think, all noble lords' consideration of this very important issue. I'll deal first with the issue of specialist stalking training. The service police already train to nationally recognized standards. The Defence Serious Crime Command maintains alignment with the College of Policing's professionalizing investigation program, and our service police receive offence-specific training aligned with the College of Policing standards.
We will build on these arrangements with stalking-specific training not only for service police but also frontline personnel. This will enable personnel to recognize stalking behaviors, understand escalation and risk, and apply and enforce the new orders effectively. I'll turn now to clause 7A from noble lady Baroness Brinton on multi-agency stalking intervention programs, MASIP. A statutory MASIP model will not be practical in the service context. Cases may involve different jurisdictions across the UK and overseas, where local provision and responsibilities vary.
Prescribing a single program in legislation could constrain the flexibility needed to assemble the right partners around each case, leading to duplication of existing safeguarding arrangements and indeed uncertainty over accountability. However, we recognize the importance of multi-agency working and information sharing. Our Violence Against Women and Girls Taskforce will draw on expertise from across government and the wider sector to connect multi-disciplinary networks and work closely with the Victim Witness Care Unit. Together, they will deliver risk management and victim protection. Turning to amendment 9, the bill already provides continuity protection.
A service stalking protection order will automatically convert into a civilian stalking protection order when the person ceases to be subject to service law or service discipline, removing the need for a new order. That legal continuity, my lords, is supported by existing operational arrangements. The Defence Serious Crime Command police public protection unit can notify civilian forces when an order is imposed. Service police can also share information through public protection notices, national policing systems, direct liaison with civilian public protection units and the service police 24-hour operations room. These mechanisms ensure that responsibility for enforcement can pass between jurisdictions without interrupting protection.
Training, referrals and information sharing are better maintained through guidance and operational practice so they can be updated quickly as risks and policing practice evolve. We'll continue to work with specialist organisations, the military court service, the service police, the armed forces and civilian partners to design and implement effective training, guidance and support for victims across the defence establishment. The government recognises the concerns raised in the operation of these orders and the intention behind new clause 7B requiring annual reports on progress in addressing stalking in the armed forces. To reassure the noble lady Baroness Brinton, the government will commit to update parliament on the effectiveness of service stalking protection orders 12 months after the provisions have been commenced. Turning to amendment 10, victims' code.
All victims within the service justice system are entitled to support under the code for victims in the service justice system, should they choose to receive it, irrespective of the nature of the offence committed against them. This includes victims of sexual offences and domestic abuse where specialist support is available. The code for victims in the service justice system provides parity with the statutory rights for victims in England and Wales and will contain the same key principles within legislation set out at clause 11 and the same 12 rights to ensure that victims of service offences and civilian victims receive equivalent standards, protections and entitlements. If a service person is a victim whose case is being investigated by the civilian criminal justice system, defence policy gives personnel the right to comprehensive welfare support, including specialist welfare delivered by trained staff when necessary, regardless of the civilian criminal justice system outcome. The victim witness care unit is well placed to support those who are dealt with in the service justice system by providing information and updates as the case progresses through dedicated victim liaison officers, but they do not provide welfare support.
Extending the remit of the victim witness care unit to victims in the criminal justice system will not materially change the services provided to such victims. Turning to government amendments 11 to 15. These simply give effect to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee's recommendation that the code of victims in the service justice system receives the same level of parliamentary scrutiny as the civilian code for victims in England and Wales, and indeed I'm pleased that the noble lady Baroness Brinton and I think the opposition front bench as well recognised them as progress. Turning to government amendments 44, 45 and 46. I'd like to begin by thanking the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Norwich for raising this important issue at committee.
The government welcomes the intent of these proposals, indeed I believe they're welcome across your lordship's house, and agrees they will have a positive impact and continue to provide the necessary and important protections for our service police. As a result, the government has tabled the following amendments. Amendment 44 amends the Assaults on Emergency Workers (Offences) Act 2018 to list the service police as an emergency worker within section 3. Additionally ensures consistency by including the service police to the equivalent legislation in Scotland, the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Act 2005. This will provide prosecutors with an additional offence to consider, as appropriate, where instances of assault on service police are reported.
Subsequently, section 68 of the Sentencing Act 2020 is amended to include service police. This again defines emergency workers for the purposes of this act, where section 67 requires courts to treat offenses committed against emergency workers as an aggravating factor that increases the seriousness of that crime. Amendment 45 applies section 90 of the Police Act 1996 to members of the service police forces and provides that in its application to service police, section 90 has effect throughout England and Wales and Scotland. For Northern Ireland, amendment 46 applies 67 of the Police (Northern Ireland) Act 1998 to members of the service police. Taken together, these provisions mean that the relevant impersonation offenses will apply in each of the three UK legal jurisdictions.
I hope this provides the necessary reassurances to the Right Reverend Prelate, the Bishop of Norwich, and so I hope he feels that he's able to withdraw his amendments and support the government has brought forward to address his concerns. And I hope indeed that my previous comments gave enough assurance to the noble lady, Baroness Brinton, so that she can indeed withdraw her amendment.
Sal Sarah Brinton
Very grateful to the noble lord the minister for his response on these details. I mean, I think without taking any time at all, just to say that progress has been made, but I'm not quite sure yet that we've got the parity that the minister spoke about at the dispatch box between the civilian system for supporting victims and stalking victims separately, but both of those. But it is improving, and for that, my lords, I'm very grateful. We certainly heard from Aurora New Dawn and Suzy Lamplugh Trust that there was concern about people moving from the military environment into the civilian environment, whether protection orders and other things would move swiftly. And actually, if that's going to happen, if the one thing that the amendments have done and these two organizations have done is to make sure there is a smooth transfer, then that is also going to be a win.
The victims' code being written into law is extremely helpful for the military side as well. On that basis, my lords, I'm happy to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 97
Is it your lordships' pleasure that amendment 7A be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 7B, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Not moved. Amendment 8, not moved.
Or 9, not moved. Or 10, not moved. Question is that clauses 11 to 15 be agreed to en bloc. Baroness Annandale, move formally. The question is that amendments 11 to 15 be agreed to en bloc.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. After clause 27, amendment 16, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My lords, I have relaid Lord Thomas of Gresford's amendment from committee stage and have done so because he is still recuperating from his surgery a few weeks ago. We miss him and hope to see him back here very soon. Lord Thomas of Gresford is the president of the Association of Military Court Advocates and has repeatedly raised in your lordships' house the issue of the arrangements for sentencing in a court martial. At the second reading of this bill, Lord Thomas said, "In this country, the sentence is determined by the board sitting with a judge advocate, who advises the members on the law and the scale of the sentence recommended by the Sentencing Council for a particular offense." "In the event of an equality of votes amongst the members of the board, the judge advocate has a casting vote."
"I have argued in the last two Armed Forces bills that in the modern era, the judge advocate in the UK system should sentence alone, on the basis that the exercise of sentencing today is highly technical and beyond the competence and experience of the lay members of the board who, unlike magistrates, have no training and have probably never been in a court before and are unlikely to be there again." At committee stage, I referred Lord Thomas's arguments in this matter, and Lord Coaker responded to me saying, "The judge advocate is of course the expert on sentencing."
It's true that any sentence passed by the court martial must be determined by a majority vote meaning that the judge advocate's vote could theoretically be outweighed. However the judge advocate will give the board the legal framework identify the relevant sentencing guidelines and set the proper parameters within which the sentence must be considered. Failure to have regard to these guidelines and parameters opens the way to an appeal in the court martial appeal court. Later he added it's also important to remember that while military experience informs sentencing it does not displace the legal principles governing it. Any mitigation advanced on behalf of an offender whether arising from a previous operational service commendations awards or personal circumstances must be assessed within the sentencing framework directed by the judge advocate and in accordance with the applicable sentencing guidelines.
To be clear he said the board members are not free to substitute personal views of military merit for the lawful sentencing exercise and any sentence that failed properly to reflect the relevant legal principles would be liable to appeal. My lords the problem is that these two paragraphs actually contradict each other. If the judge advocate advises the other members of the panel to go in one direction and they choose not to then the judge advocate vote is powerless against the majority. Arguing that any such decision could then be liable for appeal demonstrates exactly the argument that the judge advocate is the expert. So can I ask the minister if there's any data collected on the reason for any appeals in court martial since 2011 where we could see if this was actually an issue rather than matter of principle that Lord Thomas says it is important and we should consider.
And if there are any examples how many relate specifically to a majority decision made against the advice of the judge advocate. That's why amendment 16 proposes that the judge advocate should make the decision alone and whilst we're not going to make progress on this today my lords my noble friend Lord Thomas of Gresford is undoubtedly an expert in this area and his argument effective and aims to strengthen the court martial. I beg to move.
Speaker 97
Amendment proposed after clause 27 is sought insert the new clause the words of which are on page 7 of the Marshall list.
Speaker 79
Well I I thank the noble baroness lady Brinton for tabling amendment 16 on behalf of the noble lord Lord Thomas of Gresford and I would like to join her in wishing him very well a speedy recuperation and I hope we all hope join her in hoping to see him back in his place as as soon as possible. As the government set out at committee I don't think I'm going to quote committee as extensively as the noble noble lady did the judge advocate and the service members of the board discussing and deciding on sentence to sentence together is not in our view an anomaly it or a weakness of the court martial it is indeed one of its strength. I acknowledge the noble and learned lord Lord Thomas of Gresford's concerns that lay board members may have not had the training and exposure in matters of sentencing the judge advocates and magistrates have had while the board members exercise unrestricted sentencing powers. The judge advocate in any case is the expert on sentencing as my noble friend Lord Coker said at committee they give the board the legal framework identifying identify the relevant sentencing guidelines and set the proper parameters within which the sentence must be committed.
The discussions of the board, like the deliberations of a Crown Court jury, are confidential and should never be disclosed or discussed outside the board itself, so no formal records are kept of individual views expressed during board deliberations. Failure to have regard to the relevant guidelines and parameters in sentencing would open the way to appeal in the Court Martial Appeal Court. And in response to the noble lady Baroness Brinton's questions from 2025, 20 appeal notifications were submitted to the Court Martial Appeal Court. 12 were related to the conviction, seven to the sentence, and one appeal was related to both conviction and sentence. These eight are just over 3% of all the Court Martial sentences in 2025.
There is no information recorded about whether a majority decision was made against the advice of a judge advocate for the reasons that I have already set out. The amendment would reduce the board's role from one of equal participation to one of consultation only. That is, the board's understanding of modern service life, operational pressures, values and standards and current military capability and technology could be consulted, but ultimately rejected. The current position whereby the judge advocate and the military members of the board discuss and decide sentence together is one of the strengths of the Court Martial system. The balance is the right one.
The government would contend the balance is the right one. The judge advocate provides the legal expertise and safeguards, and the lay board members provide current military experience and judgment. The recent Court Martial Appeal Court judgment in the case of R versus Daniel Barton Kennedy acknowledged the value of this collective military experience, expertise in applying sentencing guidance to reach the appropriate sentence. My Lords, I hope I've provided at least some assurance to the noble lady in absentia, the noble lord Lord Thomas of Gresford. I suspect from her comments we may be revisiting this at a future date, but for the meantime will hope that she is content to withdraw her amendment.
Sal Sarah Brinton
Very grateful for the noble lord the minister's response, which was very similar to that of Lord Coaker at committee stage, which is perhaps not surprising. I think if Lord Thomas were in his seat, he'd say it matched the responses that he's had now over nearly 15 years of raising this issue, not just in the Armed Forces Bill, but also in a number of regulations as well. I know he feels passionately about this as a matter of principle, and I think we will find, try and find another vehicle by which we can raise this forward. In the meantime, my Lords, I withdraw the amendment.
Speaker 97
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that amendment 16 be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 17, Baroness Annis.
Ann Trebus
I rise to move the government amendments 17 to 21, which are consequential on clause 32. They do not alter existing policy, but update section 13 of the Reserve Forces Act 1996 to reflect the direct transfer arrangements in primary legislation. This will preserve the existing position that ex-regulars who leave the volunteer reserves before completing any remaining compulsory reserve liability will revert to the ex-regular reserve for the balance of that period. Amendments 19 to 21 protect the choice of those who have chosen not to accept the changes to terms and conditions of service introduced by the Armed Forces Bill. Without these amendments, an individual who subsequently leaves the volunteer reserve could be automatically brought back into the new arrangements.
So these provisions ensure that their original decision is respected and preserved in legislation unless they choose otherwise. Whilst it is right that we introduce these measures to strengthen defense readiness and improve our access to trained personnel, it is equally right that we provide service personnel with a clear choice. These amendments strike that balance in enhancing readiness while safeguarding individual decision-making. My Lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 97
Amendment proposed, clause 32, page 57, line 16, leave out and three and insert to 3A.
Fraser
My Lords, I have countersigned my noble friend Lord Harlech's amendment number 23, which is about the right to time off for reservists. I hope I do him some justice by talking to his amendment, but I speak as an employer of a very small charity. And this amendment will only apply to businesses with 50 or more employees. So, and it would give them a right to up to 10 days unpaid leave per year to fulfill specific requirements of a reservist. Now, these requirements are outlined by section 22 of the Reserve Forces Act 1996, and they importantly include an annual period of continuous training.
This amendment would also include the right to time off for a course of instruction leading to promotion or the award of a qualification recognized by the Defence Council. You could only be covered by this amendment if you have been an employee for not less than 26 weeks, so it's not a day-one entitlement. There must be reasonable and written notice for the employer. And very importantly, because we all know how these things sometimes work, if the training is cancelled or curtailed, the employee can get the time, get the days back, because courses and camps do get moved, as we know. Now, in committee, the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, was concerned that this would create an additional workforce administrative or operational pressure for employers.
And those, that might be particularly significant where employers rely on specialist skills or shift patterns. Well, I employ people with specific clinical skills that are booked up to provide appointments to children and adults with cerebral palsy up to six weeks in advance. And I come across these issues when staff are called up for things like jury duty. And there is often a mechanism whereby people can say, "I'm terribly sorry, I can't make the date that I've been called up for," and so there is an element of toing and froing that suits both the employee, the public duty, and the employer. And I was minded to look up as an employer what I need to statutorily give employees time off for for public duties, regardless of whether I employ 50 employees or not.
And, you know, I notice that all employees must be allowed to take time off for jury service, fine. But what qualifies for other reasonable time off includes being a magistrate, a councillor, a school governor, a member of any statutory tribunal, member of a managing or governing body of an educational establishment, a member of a health authority, member of a school council or board in Scotland, a member of the Environment Agency or Scottish Environment Protection Agency, a member of a prison independent monitoring board, a member of Scottish Water or Water Customer Consultation Panel, or a trade union member for trade union duties. So I am slightly surprised, therefore, that you are not already entitled as a member of the reserve forces not to be able to request time off. I need to declare an interest because this is another debate, my daughter is a serving member of the reservists. And this comes back to the previous debate about operational readiness.
The reason the Reserve Forces Act states specific training time, and particularly the annual continuous time off, is to ensure operational readiness. And at the moment, employees in the reserves only have certain protections if they are called up for service, not for their routine readiness. And I know that there are continuous problems for people in trying to juggle the needs of their employer with the needs of their voluntary, I note it is a voluntary commitment to be a reservist. But I feel that in current times and our focus on operational readiness, we should be making it as easy as possible both for the reservist to be encouraged to continue with their service year after year and to put them, frankly, on a par with members of the Scottish Water or Water Customer Consultation Panel and that they should be allowed the right to reasonable time off. Now, I do not wish, this amendment in no way jeopardizes the already existing schemes for employers, you know, the voluntary commitment that various businesses sign up to, whether gold or silver.
But to be frank, there aren't enough businesses signed up to gold and silver protection of the Armed Forces Covenant. And, you know, I completely support these routes to promote genuine practical voluntary support from employers. But at the end of the day, if we are trying to encourage operational readiness of our reserved forces, this, we always call them modest amendments in order to smooth the path of reservists to be able to keep up their commitment, I would urge the government to give it full consideration.
Julie Smith
My Lords, as in the committee stage, the noble Lord, Lord Harlech and the noble Lady Baroness Fraser have brought forward important amendments. They may not be the largest amendments, but we rely on the reserves and we've seen in repeated SDRs the importance of our reserves. One question I would therefore have of the Minister, because I think amendment 24, which talks about detriment on grounds of membership of the reserve forces, in theory, there shouldn't be any detriment to being in the reserves. But could the noble Lady the Minister explain to the House whether she feels, or His Majesty's Government feel, that this amendment is unnecessary because sufficient legislation is in place to protect the rights of the reserves? And in particular, does the government feel that by bringing the whole of government within the purview of the Armed Forces Covenant, for example, we've begun to change the dynamics, or do we actually need to push further on reserves?
Because it is clearly important that just as we don't leave out people in single living accommodation from the rights that everybody else enjoys, we shouldn't be leaving members of the reserves out of the rights that would be extended to those in the regular services. So I think from these benches we are broadly supportive of these amendments and would very much like to understand whether His Majesty's Government really feels that there are sufficient safeguards in place for the reserves.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, my noble friend Lady Goldie and I have tabled amendment 25 to test the merits of a tax-free reserve service policy as proposed by my honorable friend James Cartlidge as Secretary of State for Defence in the other place.
The purpose of such a policy is to completely remove income tax from the first 30 days of reserve service in any one year. This reflects the Conservative Party's respect for the value of reserve service. For a private on an annual non-reserve salary of 30,000, this would save them 380 pounds a year. For a corporal on an unreserved salary of 35,000, that's 575 pounds. And for a lieutenant on 50,000 pounds, it would save them 1,087 pounds a year.
This means that all reservists get to keep more of their hard-earned money while offering our country their commitment and support. My Lords, Charlie Munger of Berkshire Hathaway renown famously said, show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome. Currently, the incentives to join and remain in the reserves are nowhere near as pronounced as they ought to be. If we are serious about increasing the size of the reserve forces, as my party certainly is, then we must fix and enhance these incentives. The outcome would definitely be positive.
Indeed, as the Strategic Defence Review committed to increasing the size of the active reserves by 20%, should the government not be further considering improving the financial offer to reservists? On the amendments from my noble friend Lord Horlick, I do appreciate that these also attempt to target some of the incentives, particularly relating to the reservist employers. However, in my opinion, we should be targeting the financial incentives with costs that can be borne responsibly by the state, which could, for example, be funded by reinstating a two-child benefit cap. This is surely preferable to a policy that increases costs on businesses. Each of my noble friend's amendments might be acceptable on their own, and in a more favourable economic environment, we might be inclined to support them.
However, with the tax burden at a post-war high, the Employers' Rights Act further creating more red tape, and the likelihood of further tax raised on the in the upcoming budget, businesses, particularly SMEs, are already buckling under the cumulative pressure of life under a Labour government. As evidenced by further reduction in vacancy reported this very morning by the ONS. Given this, while respecting the invaluable role that the reserve forces fulfill, I do think we should be doing everything possible to reduce the burden on businesses.
Ann Trebus
My Lords, I'm grateful to those who've contributed to this debate on this group and I turn to the amendments in this group that have just been debated. Can I thank the noble Lord, Lord Horlick, for his amendment, but then of course the noble lady Baroness Fraser for putting forward the amendment and making its case. And I listened with care and I'll try and address a couple of her points as we go through. And in fact, to that end, the MOD obviously, as you as the noble lady acknowledged, works closely with employers to promote the benefits of reservists to companies and many actively recognize this, hence, as was mentioned, the silver and gold schemes and the noble minister Lord Coaker did go into more detail, so I will just leave that there, but they have their place without doubt. There are over 9,000 companies that are in fact part of the employee recognition scheme that requires employers to have reserve positive policies in their workplace.
We also have a number of existing statutory safeguards in place to ensure that the reserves are protected when we mobilize them. My Lords, we are not complacent. As global instability increases and the importance of our reserve forces continues to grow, we are committed to improving reservists' readiness. However, we believe this must be done in partnership with employers and industry, whose ongoing support remains vital to the future success of the reserves. And while I accept that some businesses, such as the noble Lady Baroness Fraser's, would welcome this amendment, I take the noble Lord Elminto's point that there are problems with potential increased costs on business as well.
And for that reason, we therefore do not believe these amendments strike the right balance. And to the noble Lady Baroness Smith of Newnham, to just directly address the points that she made. The government remains committed to ensuring reservists are supported and not unfairly disadvantaged. The concern is not with the principle of supporting reservists, but with whether the amendments are the right mechanism, the right legal mechanism, I should say. And the government believes employer engagement, covenant commitments, as was mentioned, and targeted support are more appropriate and proportionate than creating a broad new employment status.
And we feel that the amendment could create uncertainty for employers, particularly small and medium-sized businesses. And to the noble Lady's point specifically, worry that they may make ordinary workplace decisions more vulnerable to tribunal claims, even where decisions are based on legitimate operational requirements. And that could discourage open discussion about reserve commitments, undermining the partnership approach between defense, employers, and reserves. I'll now turn to amendment 25, which concerns compelling the Secretary of State to undertake a review into tax-free payments for the first 30 days of a reservist's service each year. While I recognize the intent behind it, I do not consider a statutory review necessary.
The government keeps pay conditions under continuous review, and reservists already benefit from a generous package of support, including a tax-free annual bounty of up to 2,391 pounds. And this point, I think, is incredibly important, is the government believes that making reserve pay tax-free would also create a significant disparity with our regular personnel. Those of us, and there are maybe a couple in this chamber, that remember Pay 2000 and introducing discrepancies and differential pay, and the effect that had in particular on the Royal Navy, would, I think, want me to make this point emphatically. We do not want to create a disparity between regular and reserve personnel pay conditions in this way. I do, however, share the noble Baroness's commitment to improving reserve recruitment.
Our approach to recruitment and retention is to improve the offer. So, with that, my Lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 97
The question is that amendment 17 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary, not content. The contents have it.
Amendments 18 to 21, Baroness Goldie, move formally en bloc. The question is that amendments 18 to 21 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary, not content.
The contents have it. In clause 39, amendment 22, Lord Elminto.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, the House will not be surprised that myself and my noble friend Lady Goldie have retabled our amendments from committee to remove clause 39 and schedule 6 from the bill. As a short reminder, these provisions abolish the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations as currently constituted and replace them with a single... am I reading the right thing?
Yeah, I am. Abolish the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association as currently constituted and replace them with a single non-departmental public body, a quango, with a far greater degree of control exercised directly by the Ministry of Defence. My Lords, I was incredibly buoyed by the widespread support from around the House that this amendment received at committee. In particular, this amendment received from the noble and gallant Lords, Lord Craig of Radley, Lord Stirrup, and Lord Dannatt, the noble Lords, Lord Moore of Etchingham, Lord Fox, and my noble friends Lord Swire, Lord Howe, Baroness Fraser of Craigmaddie, and of course Lord De Mauley. Can I also say to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham, that her support and that of her party is extremely welcome.
I even detected a hint of skepticism about the government's proposal from their own benches, and I thank the noble Viscount Lord Stansgate for his intervention. This support from diverse corners was indeed indicative of both how strongly noble Lords felt about the value of reserves and cadet organisations, but also their commitment to the value of a level of self-determination. My Lords, it is clear from the strength of feeling in the House that the government have got this wrong. I am in no doubt that the noble Lord the Minister has only good intentions, but I'm afraid that he is pursuing, whether at his own behest or that of the behest of the civil service, a course of action which will change the RFCAs for the worse and risks causing lasting damage to a system that works so well. The source of my ire is the government's insistence that they must seize control over the associations for the sake of accountability.
I'm fully aware that the Sullivan review identified weaknesses in the governance of the RFCAs, but an enormous amount of work has already been done to rectify those problems. And yet the government still intends to pursue reorganisation. It is as if the MOD is searching for a problem to justify their desire to exercise ultimate control over the associations. The government speaks of accountability, but I say accountability to whom? Is it the accountability of the membership of the associations that the government is concerned about?
Is it for those volunteers, cadet leaders, reservists, and staff who make the RFCAs the enormous success that they are, or is it to further the MOD's interests, which is why the government seeks these reforms? For if anyone thinks that creating yet another quango is going to improve accountability, either to those who really matter, the reserves, the cadets, and the membership, or indeed to the government itself, then I fear they may have spent the last few decades with their heads buried fairly deep in the sand. My Lords, if it is financial probity and government governance which the government is concerned about, then they have little to fear from retaining the current arrangements. For example, as this is quite a good example, the Yorkshire and Humberside Association managed to negotiate the purchase of a new location for York Officer Training Corps for 2.85 million pounds, down from the quoted price of 3 million pounds. By contrast, the anticipated cost for the Ministry of Defence's plan for the relocation was 10 million pounds.
Because of the local connections and autonomy of the current arrangements, the Yorkshire and Humberside RFCA was able to save the public purse 7 million pounds. The government says they are worried about financial responsibility and accountability, but as this simple example demonstrates, the RFCAs are clearly more responsible and accountable than the Ministry of Defence could be. I know if I was still in the commercial sector who I'd want on my side in a negotiation. I should say, however, that I do appreciate the efforts of the noble lord the minister has gone to in trying to address some of the issues raised by my noble friend Lord De Mauley at committee. Particularly welcome is amendment 39, which places the role of the Lord Lieutenant into primary legislation as opposed to the government's previous position of leaving governance arrangements solely to secondary legislation.
Amendment 27 is also welcomed as it permits the chairs of regional councils to sit as representative members on the national RFCA board. However, my lords, it is evident that whilst the government has made some movement, they still intend to seize greater control over the associations through structural means. Of particular concern is the proposed new structure of the board. Amendment 26 increases the number of non-executive members from 5 to 10. And amendment 28 states that the number of non-executive members must be greater than the number of executive and representative members combined.
This definition is almost worth repeating, it is so unusual, but don't worry, I shan't. The effect of this government amendment is to place a cap on the number of representatives of the regional councils that could sit on the national board, as the number of representatives and executive members combined could not be more than the number of MOD-appointed non-executive directors. This could lead to a situation where there are actually no representative members appointed to the board at all, surely that cannot be right. For example, if the MOD appoint four non-executive members, which for an organisation of this size would be a pretty standard number, there would be room for only one representative, since there are approximately three executive members on the board, including the chief executive officer. While the MOD could now theoretically appoint up to 10 non-executive members and therefore appoint all six of the permitted representatives, this would create a board of 20 people, which as anybody who has sat on corporate boards of almost any size will tell you, is absolutely ludicrous.
For comparison, the average size of the board of a FTSE 100 company is 9.9 directors. In fact, it would be so impractical that the MOD would never even countenance it. In short, the government has by amendment 28 guaranteed complete MOD control over the board and placed what I believe to be an unacceptable restriction on the representation of the membership of the RFCAs. And in this regard, this concession is not actually a concession at all. My lords, the nub of the issue is this.
There were governance and accountability issues identified, those problems were fixed, but the civil service will not be satisfied until they exercise complete control over the RFCAs. They can dress this up in as much bureaucratic newspeak as they wish, but the fact remains that this is a wholly unnecessary and ultimately damaging reform.
And for that reason, my Lords, clause 39 and schedule 6 should be struck from this bill. I beg to move.
Rupert Ponsonby
My Lords, I was sorry to hear that the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, was unwell, and I was very grateful to him for his letter of the 13th of October last week, in which he set out a number of government amendments to the bill, including several on the RFCA element in clause 39 and schedule 6. And my Lords, I should mention my interest as chairman of the Council of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations. I thank the noble Lord Coaker in his absence, as did my noble friend Lord Minto, for agreeing to bring the Lord-Lieutenants back into primary legislation and for the establishment of a National Council. He also said that arrangements would be made for up to six regional council chairs to be appointed as members of the RFCA board and that they would be able to participate and vote, maintaining the historic links between defence and the regions. I'm very grateful that they will be able to participate fully and to vote, my Lords.
My issue is with the little words "up to" in the context of the number of regional chairs to be appointed to the board. My noble friend Lord Minto referred to the importance of having six regional chairs out of our total of 13 regional regions represented on the board. That is because it would allow representation of each of the devolved administrations: Scotland, Northern Ireland, and Wales, and would provide three representatives for England. That is three out of its nine regional chairs, while Northern Ireland and Wales each would have its only chair permanently on the board and Scotland would have one of its two. England is by far the most populous of the four countries, being home to, according to Google, 85% of the population of the United Kingdom.
So it would be ridiculous to suggest that England should not have half of all the regional chairs element of the board. That inevitably leads to a need for not less than six representatives of the regional chairs on the board. The nub of the issue I have with the government's amendments, therefore — and the noble Baroness the Minister must not think me ungrateful, because I appreciate they have come a long way — but the nub is in government amendment 28, the effect of which is to make clause 2(2) on page 135 of the bill read: "The number of executive members and representative members must be less than the number of non-executive members." My noble friend Lord Minto has explained how the MoD could arrange that in reality, therefore, no representative members sit on the board. Although the government have allowed themselves by amendment 26 to appoint up to 10 non-executives, this is discretionary and it seems to me unlikely to happen, both because it would create a large board, which I can't think any of us would find very attractive, and because the Treasury would surely question payment to so many non-executives, because the bill still insists that they be paid.
Compounding this in paragraph 4(c) in amendment 39, government amendment 39, where it says: "But there shall be no more than six representative members at any time." My Lords, this has all come about because of a concern amongst officials that the regional chairs might somehow outvote the other board members and expose the organisation to unacceptable risk — something, of course, none of us wants. There are, however, so many reasons why this is unthinkable. Of the RFCA's total annual spending of £120 million, for example, over 95% is tied down in payments for leases, rent, rates, people costs, fixed contracts for IT, property maintenance, and so on, and in projects for which the business cases which have the approval of one of the single services.
There's therefore literally no latitude for spending outside the set parameters. Furthermore, the chief executive being appointed by the department as the accounting officer can exercise his or her veto if any board member is to propose any inappropriate action as set out in His Majesty's Treasury's own publication, Managing Public Money. Which brings me to what is perhaps an even more important point. Amendment 28, by suggesting that the executives, including the chief executive and the finance director, would gang up against the chairman and non-executives is completely absurd. You would be placing your entire trust in the non-executives who, albeit are appointed through the OCPA process, they are paid some but by no means all of their income by you.
But you won't trust the executives who are also appointed by you and are even more heavily vetted and are entirely reliant on you for their pay packet. This really is something which could only have arisen out of the thought process of a mad conspiracy theorist. So I would be keen to see the back of amendment 28, while I warmly welcome my noble friend Earl's Howe and Minto's amendment 39A. My Lords, let us focus on the big picture. We are attempting either to create an effective NDPB or to strengthen further the current model, as in fact was suggested by the National Audit Office.
In a national organization which stretches from the Outer Isles, Shetland and Orkney to Land's End and the Channel Isles, one that embraces the rich regional heritage of the United Kingdom, why wouldn't one wish for appropriate regional representation on the board to provide that vital link between national strategies and policies and their implementation at local level, rather than dancing on a pinhead about some theoretical perception of risk? To put that regional representation in doubt, as these government amendments do, flies in the face of Prime Minister Burnham's stated aim to push power down to the regions of the UK. Giving members the impression that they might only have minimal representation on the national board because it is not in accordance with Cabinet Office and Treasury guidelines, as it may might create financial and government risk, is frankly nonsense. It is an insult to volunteers who readily give up their time at no cost to the taxpayer because they understand the importance of the reserves and cadets to the national effort, to resilience, to defense of the homeland, and who wish to serve and support. They should be applauded, not treated as high-risk vigilantes.
Furthermore, there are plenty of checks and balances in the Treasury's own guidance, Managing Public Money, chapter 3, and Defense Council letters of delegation to regional chairs, to ensure that board members carry out the duties assigned to them in accordance with government guidelines. My Lords, a further matter that I've not today pressed by way of amendment is my suggestion made in committee that the detail of how the membership of the RFCA is to be selected should be set out in primary legislation. Can the noble baroness, the minister, assure me that the draft regulation that the noble Lord Lord Coaker showed us, which did indeed indeed set out the detail, will indeed be brought before Parliament in substantially the form we have been shown?
Tom Elliott
My Lords, just to make a few brief comments on on these group of amendments and I do wish the noble Lord the Minister Coaker well in his recovery and hopefully he'll be back here in the not too distant future. But I always feel that I'm a reasonably balanced person when looking at at some of these aspects, others may not agree, but most most people will. So I'm always open to consideration of changes. And in normal circumstances, I wouldn't contemplate supporting amendment 22, which to me is is almost a dead end and bringing us back to the status quo.
But sometimes you have to have that knee-jerk reaction, particularly when you see what else is in this group of amendments. And to me, it's seriously short-changing a group of people who really want to make a contribution, who are making a contribution. And what it's going to do is leave some areas disadvantaged. Either the region of England isn't going to have the representation that we feel it deserves, or on the other hand, Northern Ireland, or maybe Scotland, or maybe Wales, won't have any representation whatsoever. Or it could be all of those.
So I think that I'd have liked to seen a much better proposal coming from government here that would have allowed me to support it. But unfortunately, I'm put in a situation where I don't particularly like amendment 22, but feel under the circumstances I'm probably going to have to support it because it's not giving that fair representation to the other regions that I see. So I would ask government maybe to look at this again, have a reconsideration, and give us something that I can support. Otherwise, I'm going to have to go with amendment 22.
Speaker 109
My Lords, I rise to support amendment 22. I should begin by apologizing for not speaking in the earlier stages of the bill. And I also should declare my interests. I'm the honorary colonel of Outreach, and I have also been asked to help interview for the advisory assessment panel for the appointment of the chair of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association. My Lords, I think that we all recognize the value of the RFCA, and this has been laid out well by others, and I don't intend to repeat what's gone before.
There is a well-used phrase, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it", which I think really applies here. As this involves the duties of a Lord Lieutenant, my first question is whether the Palace has actually been consulted on this reorganization. I don't propose to go lay out all the arguments as others have done far more eloquently than I could. However, there is a real concern that this reorganization will damage the voluntary ethos of the association. The proposed reorganization will appoint non-military independent directors, and this will remove the incentives for military and ex-military volunteers to remain involved, and they add so much to this organization.
Speaker 108
So by abolishing the 13 regional organizations, it cuts across the regional local connections that are so incredibly important as we've already heard from others. Especially at this time when we're told to be war-ready, the RFCA has an incredibly valuable role to play. Please do not let us reorganize something that works perfectly well now. Let's leave it alone to continue its excellent work.
Reg Empey
Like many other members, I wish to wish a recovery for Lord Coker. I never either convened or attended a ministerial meeting which he convened before the recess with so many civil servants present. There were a few of us there, it was a mini mass meeting. And it was very kind of him to bring them along, and they were all there for all the different to answer all the different questions. But they also say that one of the first things a politician must learn is how to count.
Now, if we look at amendments 26 and 28, it seems to me that we can't count. Because on the one hand, the minister said, this is what I think we should do, we should open things up, we realize that we have to get regional representation. But then when this thing is put before us and dangled before us, we think, ah, we've got a solution here. But then amendment 28 potentially takes it away. So it's not specific that it would be taken away.
But when you use the phrase in legislation, we may appoint, we may appoint. So that is the fundamental weakness. Now, I do not believe that it's impossible for the minister to resolve that. And I think it could easily be resolved by third reading. And I hope it will be resolved by third reading because I think most people want the same outcome.
We shouldn't be arguing over this because it's in our national interest. But I do have to say that the potential, and don't forget, the current government might, we don't know, we could have another government using this legislation that would take a totally different view. And we have to look at the alternatives going forward. There's a way to fix this. As Lord De Mauley rightly said, you've got all these regions, England 85% of the national population, nine regions, we can't have every region represented.
We know that, otherwise the board would be far too unwieldy. And as Earl Minto pointed out, big companies, 10 people max, even our own committees are limited to 11 or 12. So if we shouldn't be therefore asking people to just don't do as we do, do as we say. So I would appeal to the minister to take this back. It can be resolved, I'm quite sure.
I don't see any threat. I don't think there's going to be a coup amongst the members of a board that will cause any distraction for the government. We should be all on the same page here and let us hope it can be resolved.
Speaker 112
I also rise to support amendment 22 and believe very firmly that schedule 6 should be removed from this bill. Frankly, my lords, if ever there was a problem looking for a solution, or solution looking for a problem, it is this one. Noble lords pointed out the errors in this. And I think the fundamental issue is moving away from the volunteer ethos. That is what underpins the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association.
And I think if we are to start moving to paid officials, it seriously undermines and we will see, we will lose those volunteers almost immediately. So, my lords, I really do feel that section, schedule 6 must be removed from this bill. There are, in my view, and many other noble lords would share with me, many issues that need to be sorted out in defense, particularly at this time of growing national crisis. But frankly, tinkering with Reserve Forces and Cadets Association, their structure and their organization is definitely not one of them.
John Nicholas Houghton
I sort of hesitate to stand up to knock a nail that is almost invisible out of sight, but I'm going to because when I was Vice Chief, I led the Cameron review on reserves, Future Reserves 2020. And when I stood down as being CDS, I became the president of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association for three or four years. And those two roles or those two activities bred in me a close understanding of and familiarity with the very localized and nuanced natures of reserve and cadet issues and the remarkable and freely given service of prominent figures locally.
More recently, in the latest strategic defense review, it's emphasized the need for a whole-of-society approach to national defense, one which fully involves local communities and civil societies in national resilience. And then, it was touched on by Lord De Mauley, more recently still, the Prime Minister's barnstorming conference speech spoke of the need to rewire the UK system, to devolve responsibility by default, to empower every postcode, to champion stronger public control, to strip away unnecessary centralized regulation and overwatch. So I do wonder, has the Prime Minister read this bill? Does he realize the degree in which it's going against every principle he stated in this speech that rocked the nation? The bill establishes, or aspires to establish, an RFCA board and MDPB which enjoys a permanent majority of funded non-executives, and under certain scenarios, the board construct can eliminate any local representation at all.
I started to wonder whether or not this was an act of malfeasance, which I had to check in the dictionary, but I just think actually it's a cock-up of drafting, because one of the intended statements after one of the amendments completely inverts the purpose of the amendment. But all I do say, and I say it from my experience of the time I've had with reserves, is to requote the lady: do not fix what isn't broken. It is absolutely unnecessary. Vote to get rid of clause 39.
Fraser
My Lords, I'm just rising briefly because I'd like the noble lady the minister to, I'm in a sense of confusion with these amendments, and I'd like her to hopefully help me out on this. At committee stage, I supported the removal of this clause, and I because I felt that the RFCAs, as other noble lords have said, are rooted in their communities. And yes, while defense is reserved, many of the institutions and the community organizations, whether it's employers or local government or whatever it is, are devolved matters. And so my question to the noble Lord Coaker was: where are the devolved nations, as Lord Empey referred to, where is their input in this new body? And, you know, I'm going to get fed up saying it, I think, in this chamber, because Scotland and Ireland and Wales are not just other regions of England, despite the Google population things that I take my noble friend's point.
But when I asked the noble Lord Coaker, he said to me that he would, you know, they're all part of the regulations, they're in draft form at the moment and he'll share them. And I thank him very much for sharing them, and I have gone through them, and I had asked the question: where are the devolved nations and those reserved, those devolved matters being fed through to this new national board? And I cannot in any way, reading through the draft regulations, see where that happens. And I was assured that these things will be sorted out by the regulations, but at the moment they're not. So I remain confused, and therefore I support my noble friend's amendment 22, and I hope maybe the noble lady the minister will make me not confused.
Speaker 114
My Lords, I rise to declare two interests to make one very simple point. I am the current president of the reserves and cadets, appointed in stead of Field Marshal the Lord Houghton, and I am sitting currently in your Lordships' House on the Committee for National Resilience.
And my point is very simple. My lords, we need national resilience more than ever. We get that national resilience by connecting ourselves to our own society. That connection comes through His Majesty to His Majesty's Lord Lieutenants. In the case of mobilization, that falls to the reserves forces and cadets associations.
Stuart Peach
When we have a moment of serious conflict, we need our reserve forces. That's what saved us in two world wars. We need them again and we need to grow them. So the simple message is we need to do all we can to make them as strong as possible as part of our national resilience.
Ffooks
My lords, I am a spoke at committee and I'm not going to repeat what I said there. I have one simple point. I wondered whether there was some deep and mysterious legal reason for the government's desire to reorganize the reserves. But I was reassured in no uncertain terms by Lord Coaker that there is no legal reason for this move. So it follows that this is a question of political choice.
And my lords, it's a very bad choice.
Julie Smith
My lords, the noble Lord Minto stole my thunder from these benches right at the start of this group of amendments when he thanked me and my benches for the support we were giving on the issue of reserve forces and cadets association. This has been by the standards of this particular bill a long debate and I don't intend to detain the house for more than two or three sentences. Because my lords, clause 39, and I can understand why the noble Lord Minto was slightly confused because the original version of the bill it's clause 38. So I spent a bit of time trying to work out what we were talking about and then I discovered no, no, it's now changed its numbering. But it hasn't changed its content and it hasn't become any better.
And the particularly pernicious bit isn't actually what's in, I would suggest, clause 39. It's schedule 6 to which it refers, which is actually where most of the really serious issues are. I have not heard across the chamber anybody who sees a good reason to abolish the current situation. We've already heard from the noble Lord Coaker there is no legal reason to do so. There is clearly no military reason to do so.
And in terms of our national security and national resilience, there seems to be no desirability to do so. So for those reasons from these benches we will be supporting amendment 22.
The Earl of Minto
My lords, as I mentioned in my opening comments, I've been struck by the support for this amendment from all sides of the chamber and that's much appreciated. The noble baroness, the minister, who herself has given distinguished service to this country in the RAF cannot be blind to or unmoved by the strength of feeling in this house about this issue as to why their lordships feel so strongly. The noble baroness is an able and respected advocate for our armed forces and I ask her to convey this message she has heard so forcefully today to the department. I very much hope... Oh, apologies, I think it's probably the sequencing means there probably should be the minister in response to the contributions made by and I did open the debate as it's your amendment, the noble Lord's amendment.
Ann Trebus
It's nice to be looked after. Thank you for all of the noble Lords, noble and gallant Lords and noble ladies' contributions and I have listened to them carefully as I did in previous stages of the bill. I'll do my best to answer the points that have been made. First off, and most importantly, this debate is not about whether the RFCAs should continue. They should, this government is fully committed to their future, there is no conspiracy.
The question is whether an organisation entering its second century should continue to operate through the government's arrangements designed for 1908 or through a model fit for the defence challenges of the 2030s and beyond. We know the RFCAs support our reserve and cadet forces, steward a substantial estate and oversee significant public expenditure. I'll come back to this point. And those responsibilities have grown significantly, but the governance framework has not kept pace. A proud history is a reason to preserve and modernise the RFCAs, not a reason to exempt them from change.
And part of my PhD was actually on the establishment of the first Royal Auxiliary Air Force squadrons, which of note, although the first two were created in London, the second two were created in Birmingham, Glasgow and Edinburgh, so very regional I would suggest for an early Royal Air Force. The case for reform rests squarely on the findings of three reviews. And I make this point because there's been quite a lot of questions from your Lordships' House about why the need for this. The reviews identified fragmented accountability, inconsistent governance arrangements and an absence of clear responsibility for public money. Those findings were not a criticism of the dedicated people who serve the RFCAs.
They were a critique of the structure within which they have to operate. So the NDPB is not the objective, it's the solution. It creates a single accountable organisation, a clear chain of responsibility, independent oversight and proper stewardship of public funds as the government should ensure happens. Without governance reform, the system cannot be fixed and secured for the future. The alternative cannot be the status quo and I know many have made the case for that.
As the noble Minister Lord Coaker set out, the status quo has already been judged inadequate by three public reviews. So and also the NDPB protects rather than threatens the RFCA model because with the amendments put forward we are keen and committed to preserving regional footprint, local knowledge, community engagement and the volunteer ethos that have always been its greatest strength, its strengths. But this move, as I've sort of alluded to already, to an NDPB is not a new proposal of this government. The decision to pursue the model was taken under the previous government following the Sullivan review and work to implement it has been underway for a number of years. The opposition when in government had set out in this House that the existing arrangements created a situation where decisions on public money could be taken by individuals who are not accountable to the Ministry of Defence's permanent secretary.
And to a specific point by the noble Lord Altrincham early on about Yorkshire and Humber RFCA, that situation would not change, that's not to do with the NDPB, I just want to reassure him.
And so the government agrees with the opposition's position under the Sullivan review. Indeed, successive RFCA annual reports reflect an expectation that the organization would transfer to an NDPB and a commitment to working with defense to make that transition successful. And the 2020-21 annual report, RFCA annual report, stated the transition to an NDPB is one that we should embrace, confident that the critical role of regional membership would be reflected in the future governance structure. This reform is not a rejection of the RFCA's proud history. It's how we ensure their continued success in the decades ahead.
This is not change for its own sake, as has been alluded to in several of my noble lords' and noble ladies' comments in the debate. It is governance reform required to preserve the RFCA's strengths, address weaknesses that successive reviews have identified, and ensure the organization remains fit for the future. Throughout the passage of the bill, considerable attention has rightly been given to the future of the Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations and how the strengths of the existing regional structure can be preserved. And I pay tribute to noble lord Elminto for listing the contribution. I was going to list some of them myself.
I was busy ticking them off as you went through. I'm pretty sure you caught everybody, but I did want to acknowledge just how much interest has been shown in this lordship's house about this issue. And I have read through again, having sat on these benches in committee stage, I've read through again all comments, so I take them firmly to heart. In discussions with the RFCAs, members of this house, and other stakeholders, a consistent theme has emerged: the importance of ensuring that strong regional voices continue to play a meaningful role within the future organization. The government gets this.
So the amendments before the house seek to respond to these concerns. Their central purpose is to ensure that the future RFCAs retain a strong regional dimension and continue to benefit from local knowledge, community connections, and experience. And to my, the noble and gallant lord, Lord Houghton, you know, the amendments were intended to address these points. So I take all of his points, but I, the movement and particularly that Lord Coaker has broached over the last few weeks is to do as much as possible to address the concerns raised. Let me just turn to the amendments.
First, they strengthen provision for regional councils by placing greater clarity in the legislation about their leadership and composition. They ensure each regional council will have its own chair and formal arrangements for the appointments of presidents and vice presidents. In doing so, the amendments recognize the long-standing and important role that those on the ground have played in support of the work of the RFCAs. And for generations, as has been raised by several of my noble lords, lord lieutenants have provided a valued link between defense, civic society, and local communities across every part of the United Kingdom. The amendments therefore do provide for the president of a regional council to be an appropriate lord lieutenant wherever one is available to serve in that capacity.
And I would just like briefly here to address the point made by the noble and gallant lord, Lord Peach, about the importance of our reserves being as strong as possible as part of national resilience. I have spoken in this chamber and I continue to support the work that he is doing, sorry, the noble and gallant lord is doing on his committee and in his other endeavors. And we, I hope, will continue to work together on that important point. The reserve forces are central, as the noble and gallant lord pointed out, and have been in previous conflicts.
Secondly, the amendments allow for a number of regional council chairs to become representative members of the RFCA, ensuring regional perspectives can be brought into discussions at the national level. It may be helpful if I also address how those arrangements will be implemented in practice. The government's intention is that all regional councils should continue to have a strong voice, including through the representative member arrangement. However, it will be important to ensure that the board is established in a way that maintains the governance safeguards expected of a modern public body, including a majority of non-executive members. Now, if I could briefly address a few points around this area.
To Lord Elliott on the representation from Northern Ireland, the Northern Ireland representative will be one of six regional chairs and the devolved nations will be represented. And to the noble lady Baroness Fraser's point, and I'm reassured that the amendment 40 is devised in order to ensure that that takes place. Now, going back to the makeup of the board, as a consequence, the appointment of representative members may need to proceed, so representative members as in regional representatives, may need to proceed alongside the recruitment of non-executive directors as the new body is established. In practice, this may mean building up the number of representative members incrementally during the transition period, rather than appointing all representative members on day one. So when we go to this magic number of six, as clause 39A refers to, no more than and no fewer, the RFCA could not operate as a full board until the six regional chairs and required NEDs were appointed if the amendment was passed.
In practice, this may, I've covered that point, I apologize. That approach is not intended to diminish regional representation, rather it is the practical consequence of establishing the new organization on a sound governance footing from the outset. And I would like to convince Earl Minto, but also Lord de Mauley, that I am, I promise, not a conspiracy theorist, but clearly people would never know if they were, would they? So perhaps that needs looking at. I'll take other people's advice.
And a point I want to make to the noble Lord Lord Dannatt, because he brought up the payment issue, which I know that the noble minister Lord Coaker covered. And he made the point that at the top of voluntary organizations all around the country, there are people, including board members, who are remunerated. And we'd not expect them to be able to do that job of work without remuneration. I want to emphasize that the noble minister Lord Coaker is extremely adamant on that point and would want me to revisit that just briefly. So the government's objective remains clear, to ensure the strong regional voices are represented within the future RFCA while maintaining independent oversight and accountability arrangements that Parliament would rightly expect of a national body.
Thirdly, the amendments establish a National Council bringing together the chairs of regional councils. In fact, I've covered this point to some extent. The intention is to create a formal forum through which regional experience, advice, and expertise can inform the work of the organization, help maintain strong links between the center and the regions.
There's also a recognition in the amendments that regional councils have long played an important role in providing advice and assistance on matters affecting their local areas. Accordingly, provision is made for regulations to confer appropriate advisory functions on regional councils and, where appropriate, on the national council. My Lords, these amendments demonstrate that modernisation need not come at the expense of tradition, and nor would I wish to see that, I can reassure my Lordship's House. They preserve the regional identity, local relationships, and civic leadership that have long underpinned the success of RFCAs, as we have debated in earlier stages of the bill, while supporting clearer accountability and stronger governance. I'm confident these amendments therefore strike the right balance between maintaining valued local connections, ensuring an effective and accountable organisation for the future.
I hope, but I appreciate all the comments that have been made, that amendments would reassure noble Lords, the RFCAs, and their many supporters that the future organisation will continue to draw strength from the regions, and the government is firmly committed to that principle, and it serves us well, well-being equipped to meet the challenges and opportunities of the years ahead.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, firstly, allow me to apologise for getting carried away earlier. So I won't, I'll just carry on. If I could ask, if I could humbly ask the noble Baroness, as an able and respected advocate for our armed forces, and I ask her to convey the message that she's heard so forcibly today from this House back to the department. I very much hope that the government realises the error of their ways, and that should the House decide to remove clause 39 and schedule 6 from the bill today, they do not seek to continue with this folly when the bill goes back to the other place. My Lords, the course of action the government is pursuing here is not far off using a wrecking ball as some form of construction tool.
They appear to want to abolish the voluntary ethos of the reserves and cadets, sweep away their independence, and seize control of the associations that have done so much for our cadets and reserves over many generations and to this nation's abiding gratitude. I hesitate to leave your Lordships with a warning, but good things, once gone, seldom, seldom return. The Reserve Forces and Cadets Association are, as we've heard from almost throughout today, undoubtedly a very good thing indeed. We would be doing our nation a great disservice if we ended up disbanding them. I would like to test the opinion of the House.
Speaker 35
To clarify, Earl Minto, amendment 22 moved formally. The question is that amendment 22 be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division.
I will advise the House when voting is open. Voting is now open. Clear the bar.
Speaker 117
Order, order. The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.
Content.
Not content.
The contents have it.
The not contents have it.
Division. Clear the bar.
Alan Beith
My Lords, there have voted: contents 243, not contents 168, so the contents have it. Amendment 23, Lord Harlech. Not moved. Amendment 24, Lord Harlech, not moved.
Amendment 25, Baroness Goldie, not moved. Amendment 26, Lord Coaker, Baroness Antrobus, not moved. Are there a series of amendments the government wish not to move en bloc? 26, as a consequence of that decision, 26 to 39. Question is that amendments 26 to 39 be agreed to en bloc.
As many of that opinion will say content. Not, sorry, it's a complicated night. Amendments 26 to 39 are not moved en bloc. Which brings me to amendment 39. We've dealt with that, which means I can't call Lord Hauser's amendment 39A, because it's an amendment to something that the government has not moved.
Amendment 40, Lord Coaker, not moved. Amendment 41, Lord Coaker, not moved. Amendment 42, Lord Coaker, not moved. Amendment 43, Baroness Goldie, not moved. I'll go back to amendment, let's nobody be confused, back to amendment 43, which is Baroness Goldie's amendment.
That is to be moved, is it? Amendment moved, leave out schedule 6, which is consequential, the government therefore accepts. Question is that amendment be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content.
The contents have it. So we come to 44, Lord Coaker, not moved, move formally. Amendment 44, after clause 43, insert the new clause set out on the marshal list. Question is that amendment be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content.
To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 45, Lord Coaker, move formally. After clause 43, insert the new clause set out on the marshal list. Question is that amendment be agreed to.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 46, move formally. After clause 43, insert the new clause set out on the marshal list.
Question is that amendment be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 47, the Lord Bishop of Norwich, not moved.
Amendment 48, the Lord Bishop, not moved. Amendment 49, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
I declare an interest as a member of the Legal Affairs and Human Rights Committee at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. I'm grateful to Lord Coaker for his letter dated the 25th of September and for the meeting with him and his officials between committee stage and report with Lord Thomas of Gresford, myself, and the Center for Military Justice. I have relaid my amendments for amendment 49 from committee stage following these discussions because there remain some key issues that are important to us and I hope that Lady Antrobus will be able to help with some answers. At committee stage, a number of noble lords asked the minister for clarification on how it was possible for the US Air Force to ask UK police officers to transfer serious sexual cases allegedly committed by the US servicemen on British soil out of the UK justice system and into the US system with no reference to senior personnel either in the police or the CPS and without any reference to the Ministry of Justice. Lord Coaker's letter of the 25th of September helpfully confirms that there are no separate bilateral agreements of legal provisions that determine the allocation of criminal jurisdiction between the UK and the USA other than the NATO Status of Forces SOFA agreement 1951.
My Lords, this is reassuring. It's always concerning to see in legislation, in this case the Visiting Forces Act 1952, that such agreements could be kept confidential, and I'm grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for being able to confirm that there are no such agreements. However, this doesn't remove concerns that such decisions in a number of cases are being taken at a very local level and without any reference either to senior CPS or MOJ personnel. It's even more worrying that there appears to be absolutely no data collected on such cases, hence my amendment 50. So can I ask the Minister if she feels that the letter from the College of Policing dated the 15th of July to all Chief Constables, which sets out the need to strengthen the arrangements and processes for cases like this.
However, that letter also uses phrases like "Chief Constables may wish to consider practical guidance and operating procedures". It's not direction, it means that a thousand flowers may bloom. My Lords, this is a very light touch approach and it doesn't define the level of police, let alone CPS decision making in such cases. And it's clear that these cases have sensitivities beyond the actual incident between the victim and the alleged offender. Diplomatic relations are important as well as divergence between our legal systems and support mechanisms for victims, which a local police force may not know.
And that's why my amendment goes on to say that no decision on such cases can be made without the agreement of the Chief Police Officer of the relevant police forces and the Chief Crown Prosecutor for the relevant CP service area, and they must agree formally that the transfer is appropriate under the Visiting Forces Act 1952. Now it's clear to many people that the transfer of recent cases that we debated earlier in this bill are not, and the system needs to change. But our justice system needs to know about how many cases and who is dealing with them. So my amendment sets out how that data should be collected and then sent to the DPP, the Secretary of State, and because of the public concerns about these cases, shouldn't the MOD also report to Parliament on the annual data relating to these cases? Indeed, I think it's now clear to everyone who've been involved in this debate and reread the Visiting Forces Act 1952 that not one of the recent cases highlighted by the Guardian should have been transferred to the US military justice system.
Serious sexual crimes are excluded in that act. So will the noble Lord the Lady the Minister agree to collecting data on these cases and that there should be a change of decision on these cases, ensuring no ad hoc transfers happen in the future? Lady Bennett's agreement 51 sets out the qualifying sexual offences where there are restrictions on relinquishing of jurisdiction would apply, and I look forward to hearing the Minister's reply to my amendments on this and to hers. Finally, my Lords, amendment 56 in the name of Lady Goldie. I am concerned about this amendment at two levels.
Firstly, disapplication of the European Convention of Human Rights, even if only for a specific and narrow issue, is complex, as we've debated in this House before. And I know the noble Lady Goldie is concerned about the possible abuse of cases under human rights law.
However, disapplication for any overseas deployment, many of which are not active war zones, where I think most of the actual cases of lawfare have come from, is a very broad brush that might produce unintended consequences. An extreme example of that might be if a future government decided to replicate the actions of the current US Defense Department at the moment, where women, ethnic minorities, and LGBT military are having their jobs curtailed, including deployment or removal, because there is no human rights protection in the same way that we have here. This has already happened to very senior military who have outstanding careers in America. My second example reminds your Lordships' House that families of soldiers who died in the unsafe Snatch Land Rovers, known as mobile coffins in Iraq, were able to use the European Court of Human Rights to win their cases against the Ministry of Defence. Article 2, the right to life, put a duty on the MOD to provide suitable equipment to keep soldiers safe.
It would be dreadful if our servicemen and women lost that protection. My Lords, returning to my amendment 49, I beg to move.
Alan Beith
Sorry, I couldn't quite hear the noble lady. She's after clause 43, insert the following new clause: Visiting Forces Agreements. Question is that the amendment be agreed to.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the noble lady Baroness Brinton on this group of amendments, most of which refer to the cases of assaults on British women by US military, which we canvassed extensively at committee. Horrific cases, which your Lordships' House, I think I could fairly say, looked horrified about, absolutely rightly. I'm pleased to attach my name to amendment 50 from the noble lady Baroness Brinton. And I think it's very clear that what we're talking about here, and it's something that I very much hope we might hear from the noble lady the Minister, the government acknowledging that this is something that needs to happen, that we need to know how big the scale of this problem is. We only know about the problem at all because of quite extensive, no doubt expensive, journalistic work by the Guardian.
And I hear tell that there are actually a number of further cases which are likely to emerge in the near future, including one case where the US military did not inform the UK police at all. So therefore, this is something we need to be keeping track of, which is what the noble lady Baroness Brinton's has done. Now, some of this information was uncovered using freedom of information requests, but that doesn't always produce a result and is again reliant on individual initiative, which we should not be relying upon. And I think the point made by the noble lady about the need for a reporting to Parliament so that Parliament actually knows what's happening here is absolutely crucial. I think it's also interesting the final subclause of the amendment, that the decision does not take effect until the Secretary of State has reviewed and approved it, is I think absolutely crucial.
We need to see serious political responsibility taken for any decision that denies a British victim of serious sexual crime the protection of the British courts and any person who is found to be a criminal, that they receive what the British state, the British government, the British people regard as an appropriate punishment. This is not something, I believe, that should be handed over pretty well practically ever. I cannot see any arguments for that. But I come now to amendment 51, which the noble lady Baroness Brinton kindly backed.
And this is bringing back the amendments that I had at committee because I'm afraid of the assurances we had from the noble Lord Lord Coaker then did not address the fundamental problem of the need for stronger safeguards. The existence of legislation is not enough if it's failing to protect victims in practice. Now the noble lady Baroness Brinton referred to the letter from the chair of the National Police Chiefs. But as the noble lady said, this is only guidance. Please think about doing this.
And we know how much pressure our police forces are under in terms of resources. And obviously if you do not react to that letter, there is no obvious penalty or action to be taken in response to it. Now the minister also referred to the Crown Prosecution Service guidance. But guidance alone is not a sufficient safeguard, particularly when questions remain about how the existing arrangements have been interpreted and applied. The approach should start from a clear principle.
The UK should retain primary jurisdiction over alleged offences committed here against victims, particularly although perhaps not solely those with no connection to the visiting forces. There has to be clear justification for any departure from that principle under very narrowly defined circumstances. It should not appear to start from the circumstances in which a foreign service court has primary jurisdiction then explain why the UK does not. The presumption should be that the UK retains responsibility unless there is a compelling and legally justified reason otherwise. And we should also be very cautious about treating notifications of victims as a sufficient safeguard.
As we canvassed extensively at committee, what victims are told, what they understand, the pressure they're under, the shock and suffering they've been through does not necessarily equip them to be able to make a reasonable judgement of what they really want to happen or what they might on reflection have wanted to happen. Now the government has, I will identify, acknowledged the seriousness of the cases that have brought this issue to our attention. And I appreciate the fact that there has been desire from the government to see a review. But identifying lessons and issuing guidance are not the same as clear legislation. If the government agrees that jurisdiction should only be ceded when absolutely appropriate, why is it unwilling to put the independent decision at the heart of the process?
Speaker 125
So that concludes my comments on Baroness Brinton and my amendments. I will just say, probably to no surprise of the House at all, that the Greens are against amendment 56.
Ffooks
I would like to speak to amendment 56, which rather confusingly appears to be in this group and the next group. But I promise you I will spare the House a reprise of what I'm going to say. The amendment is in fact similar to one debated at committee and it's concerned with lawfare, the danger that our troops, whether cadets, reserves or regulars, face, not from adversaries on the battlefield, but from lawyers and the dead hand of the law. I should begin by making it clear that I'm not for a moment suggesting that our troops should operate in a law-free zone. And the amendment makes it clear that they should and always will be subject to the law of armed conflict.
But the concern arises from the ECHR and its incorporation in our own Human Rights Act. We cannot amend the ECHR and as a matter of choice we have legislated to take account of Strasbourg jurisprudence.
Now in practice, this means that we almost always follow the jurisprudence of the European Court in Strasbourg. At committee stage, I referred to some of the decisions there and here that have left our troops inappropriately constrained by the law. Al-Skeini being one and Smith versus the Ministry of Defence, in fact referred to obliquely by the noble lady Baroness Brinton, is another. That unfortunately had the effect of essentially eroding the concept of combat immunity, which was well established in our common law. The incursion of law into military operations has left our troops in an embarrassing position with some of our allies.
Because of legal advice, they can be sidelined and accused of something called legal freeloading. Accidents happen in war. Actions taken in the heat of battle may be regarded as excessive when studied by judges in the calm of the courtroom, particularly when viewed through the prism of that slippery word proportionality. For some time, Policy Exchange has highlighted this particular problem, beginning with Tom Tugendhat's paper, The Fog of Law. What this amendment does is to provide a carve-out from the Human Rights Act for our troops when they are engaged in overseas operations.
Some of the persecution of our troops by the likes of Phil Shiner for events in Afghanistan or Iraq, not obviously European theatres of war, would have been avoided had this amendment been part of the law. When I addressed your Lordships' House at committee, the noble Lord Lord Koker said he found my remarks incomprehensible. I will try and be a little clearer today for the benefit of the noble lady who is in his place. I think the noble Lord's point was that it was no good amending the Human Rights Act, which we are entitled to do as a sovereign legislature, because litigants can always take their cases to Strasbourg. I don't disagree with that, but we are entitled to amend our domestic law.
How Strasbourg would respond is not always easy to predict. There is considerable respect there for our national courts. I'm clear on that, having visited Strasbourg and spoken to judges there. Furthermore, the Convention is a living instrument and the Court is perfectly capable of changing course. So that while the noble Lord was right, it does not relieve us of the task of improving our law and giving our armed forces better protection.
Noble Lords will be aware that it has always been open to a country to derogate from the Convention in times of war, see Article 15. The amendment elevates the word may to must. This is a change at domestic level, unfortunately justified by experience. My Lords, the likelihood of our troops being engaged in military operations has increased and is increasing. We should provide our troops with adequate legal protection.
I do hope those noble Lords who wish to remain in the ECHR will recognise that this amendment does not represent a dilution of adherence to the ECHR, the HRA, or Europe more generally. It reflects the fact that even the best laws need amendment from time to time, and I am rather more interested in the fate of our troops than an overzealous adherence to the ever-elusive concept of human rights.
Speaker 127
My Lords, I rise to support the amendment just proposed by the noble Lord Lord Ffooks, and I obviously speak as a barrister practising in the human rights field and a member of the Joint Committee on Human Rights.
It's clear that the convention as signed by the contracting parties in 1952 provided in its first article as follows: "The high contracting parties shall secure to everyone within their jurisdiction the rights and freedoms defined in section one of this convention." The only reason that our forces have been considered to be subject to the convention when acting in the Middle East or in Afghanistan is by reason of expansion caused by decisions of the court in Strasbourg, which have then been applied domestically, as the noble Lord, Lord Ffoulkes said, in Al-Skeini and in the Smith decision. This is a misstep that the court has taken, and in my submission, removing the opportunity to bring domestic proceedings by amending the Human Rights Act in relation to the actions of our forces overseas would be a proportionate and appropriate step and stop this fog of law occurring in the operations of British forces overseas.
Julie Smith
My Lords, I rise to support my noble friend Baroness Brinton in the amendments she moved so effectively. There is some confusion and the reason why noble Lords have been moving around the chamber. The amendment 56, which has not formally been moved yet by the noble Lord Al-Minto, appears to be in two groups: this group and the next group. So, yes, if the government...
Speaker 79
Apologies for the clerical error. It's definitely 56 is definitely in this group rather than the next group. So please continue.
Julie Smith
Thank you. So the amendment in amendment 56, if it had been very narrowly painted as something that might have been in the case of war, in the case of active engagement, but it's very broadly written and as such is not something that these benches could possibly support. And I'm going a step further than most of my colleagues would go, who would say there should be at no point any derogations to the ECHR. But my Lords, there have been cases where lawfare may have got in the way. But the amendment as proposed is far too general and from these benches we will not be supporting it.
The Earl of Minto
My Lords, I set out at committee why these benches cannot support the amendments from the noble Baronesses Lady Brinton and Lady Bennett. And as this is report, I have no further comments to add. My noble friend Lady Goldie and I have retabled our amendment 56, as it is the firm view of our party that the ECHR, however well-intentioned, has through the ever-expansive jurisprudence of the Strasbourg court mutated into an instrument that is actively opposed to our national interest. At a time where it is widely acknowledged that Britain faces the most significant threats to our security and safety in decades, and where politicians of all parties are frequently repeating the phrase "national security is the first duty of government", how can it be right that those who we ask to serve and face up to real danger on all of our behalf continue to face the possibility of being hauled before courts for simply doing their job? None of us has an issue with the words as written down in the convention all those years ago.
The issue lies with the application of the convention and expansion of its interpretation. My noble friend Lady Goldie mentioned at committee the Al-Skeini ruling in 2011, which is just one such example of this ever more expansive application. Noble Lords will be aware of lots of other such vexatious examples. My Lords, at committee, the noble Lord the Minister said the argument the government put forward is that the disapplication of the Human Rights Act does not prevent the application of the ECHR. I appreciate that and indeed I agree.
I know that so long as we remain a party to the European Convention, domestic legislation cannot remove the application of the convention. But my Lords, this is not what I'm arguing here. What I am saying, and the noble Lord Lord Faulks expressed this point with customary clarity at committee and indeed today, is that the Human Rights Act permits a person to bring proceedings against our armed forces relating to overseas operation in reliance upon the convention rights in our domestic courts. This is the situation that my amendment attempts to rectify. By removing the domestic remedy of the Human Rights Act, but most importantly only in connection with the actions of our armed forces personnel when deployed by government on overseas operations.
This would not solve the whole problem and I do not claim it to be a silver bullet. However, short of leaving the ECHR entirely, which would be ultimate preference from these benches, the solution offered by amendment 56 must be seen as the next best option. I shall reiterate because it is an important point that I do not wish to give our armed forces blanket immunity. None of us wishes to see British soldiers engage in looting, deliberate mistreatment of prisoners of war or sexual violence. Those remain crimes and they must be prosecuted.
Importantly, our armed forces wouldn't want complete immunity either. They are taught to hold themselves to the highest standards and they would expect us to continue to do so. That is why we have included in this amendment a declaratory subsection explicitly stating that British troops deployed on overseas operations remain bound by the law of armed conflict. I appreciate this has no legal effect because they remain bound by that law regardless, but it is there to ensure the fact is put beyond any doubt. My Lords, there is a problem here, as I note even the noble Baroness Lady Brinton acknowledged to some extent at committee, and we are offering the government a way of rectifying it.
I hope the government will soon see sound sense and understand that we cannot in reality be seen to ask our armed forces to serve, fight and potentially pay the ultimate sacrifice while we permit the possibility of future persecution in our courts. This just cannot be right. Therefore, when amendment 56 is called, I will seek to test the opinion of this house.
Ann Trebus
So first I'd like to thank the noble Baroness Brinton, the noble lady Baroness Brinton for her proposals and acknowledge her commitment to addressing concerns about jurisdiction matters between the UK and visiting forces.
Beginning with amendment 49, I'd like to reassure noble lords that the legal frameworks governing the allocation of jurisdiction between the UK and a visiting force are as has been discussed, set out in Article 7 of the NATO Status of Forces Agreement and are incorporated into UK domestic law through Section 3 of the Visiting Forces Act 1952 with further reference to Section 12. These agreements are already publicly available and the principles within them are and should be applied by UK prosecuting authorities on a case-by-case basis when questions of jurisdiction occur. There are no other separate legally binding bilateral agreements or legal provisions that determine the allocation of criminal jurisdiction between the UK and another sending state. Turning to amendments 50 and 51, as stated previously, the government is committed to identifying and applying, importantly, the lessons arising from the troubling cases that have been highlighted during the course of this bill. This includes the appropriate application and operation of jurisdictional arrangements under the Visiting Forces Act and how these are implemented across the criminal justice system.
Further to the action already taken by the National Police Chiefs' Council of writing to constabularies as referred to regarding their commitments under the Visiting Forces Act and the point made by the noble baroness Lady Brinton, the body is now working with constabularies, the Crown Prosecution Service and wider government colleagues on the production of robust guidance for all forces on the appropriate implementation of the legislation. This will seek to develop specific instructions and I hope the word instruct is helpful as opposed to as the noble lady, noble baroness Lady Bennett referred to, the can you, please, please, instructions to ensure that decision-making is appropriately informed by the legislation. In particular, the government will be seeking to ensure decisions are taken at an appropriate level with guidance or decision-making as appropriate from the CPS for serious offences such as sexual offences and to the noble baronesses', both noble baronesses' points, robust data reporting built into those processes to ensure clarity and accountability. I believe that had the existing legislation been applied correctly in practice in the Captain Wilson case, jurisdiction would have been retained by the UK authorities and not ceded to the US. As a result, the government firmly believes that robust implementation guidance will be the most effective approach to ensuring that the legislation is applied correctly in practice so that future cases are heard in the applicable jurisdiction and are appropriately auditable.
On the proposed inclusion of the Secretary of State as raised by the noble baroness Bennett as a final signatory on decision-making, the police and CPS exercise their respective functions independently of one another and are operationally independent of government and ministers. Against that background, we consider that the approach to formal guidance currently in development provides an appropriate framework to support the proper consideration of questions of jurisdiction. I specifically want to thank myself and on behalf of my noble friend the minister Lord Coaker, Baroness Brinton and Baroness Bennett in particular for their leadership and engagement on this important issue to date and their commitment to ensure lessons are learned from the experiences of the victims they've personally engaged with. I'd like to assure them that their contributions through this bill process have and will continue to inform the government's approach to the ongoing discussions with amongst others the National Police Chiefs' Council. I hope this will provide the necessary reassurance so the noble baroness is able to withdraw the amendment.
Natalie Bennett
Before the noble lady sits down and I want to put on record my appreciation both for her serious engagement with this issue and that of the noble lord Lord Coker as well. Um just the point the noble lady made and I acknowledge about police and prosecutors operating independently of government. But I can't think of another circumstances where police or prosecutors are having to deal with international national diplomatic conditions. And I don't really see how police or prosecutors can be equipped to make decisions that may have diplomatic consequences. So are they not going to consider diplomatic consequences or or are they going to be swayed by diplomatic consequences without really knowing how to take account of that?
I'm just concerned about how those two bodies are able to actually make decisions in international context.
Ann Trebus
The noble baroness makes a a sensible point that um I haven't considered in detail myself at this point. I think the best thing I can do is perhaps respond to her in writing with some thoughts around how that will work in practice because we know what the system is but how that all interacts is perhaps something that we can discuss in more detail. Thank you. My lords I'll now turn to the amendment 56 which seeks to make provision for members of our armed forces who've been deployed to be exempt from the ECHR. I want to begin where I think there's some common ground.
The noble baroness the noble lord Elvinto and others have raised serious questions about what is sometimes described as lawfare. About repeated investigations and litigation. About the legal certainty available to those who we ask to make extraordinarily difficult decisions in conflict. And about the proper relationship between international humanitarian law and human rights law in the conduct of military overseas operations. And clearly these are incredibly important questions.
Let me deal first with the proposed disapplication of the Human Rights Act in relation to overseas operations and I will follow in the lead of my noble friend the minister Lord Coker when it comes to legal matters and sticking to formal comments except perhaps in my closing remarks. The European Convention provides rights to those within a state's jurisdiction. As set in committee in certain circumstances that jurisdiction may extend beyond the state's territory and the case law on extraterritorial jurisdiction has developed over time. I acknowledge the point made by the noble lord Faulks in committee lord Lord Faulks in committee that the position on how the convention applies outside the UK has evolved over time through the decisions of the UK courts and the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. But it's also important not to suggest that the result is that the convention automatically follows a member of our armed forces wherever they are deployed.
Or that every action occurring during overseas operation necessarily falls within convention jurisdiction. The starting point in Strasbourg remains that jurisdiction is territorial and that extraterritorial jurisdiction is exceptional. Whether it arises depends on matters such as the authority and control exercised over an individual or effective control over an area. The Strasbourg court has itself recognized limits to the doctrine including in the context of active hostilities. That is important context.
There's a legitimate debate about how the jurisprudence has developed but it's not correct to treat the present law as imposing an unlimited or automatic extension of the convention to every battlefield decision.
I turn to the practical effect of the amendment. The proposed new section 7A would prevent proceedings being brought under section 7(1)(a) of the Human Rights Act in respect of overseas operations. The noble Lord Lord Faulks made an important distinction in committee. His point was that the UK was bound by the convention before the Human Rights Act and that Parliament can nevertheless restrict the remedy available under our domestic law. He accepted that ultimately an applicant might still seek a remedy in Strasbourg.
I accept that distinction. But this is where the government takes a different view. We do not believe the answer is to restrict access to our own courts. The convention is based on subsidiarity. The government believes national authorities should have the first opportunity to address and where appropriate remedy alleged convention violations before the matter is brought to Strasbourg.
As it is the government's view that we remain compatible with Article 13, then the question is if the section 7 route is removed, what effective domestic remedy should replace it. I now turn to the derogation because here I want to be particularly clear. Article 15 exists for a reason. It expressly recognizes that in time of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation, circumstances may require a state to take measures which depart from some of its ordinary convention obligations. So let me make clear the government's position.
If circumstances arise in which Article 15 is engaged and derogation is necessary and appropriate in accordance with our obligations under that article, the government will consider derogation. But that is different from imposing a statutory requirement automatically to derogate whenever an overseas operation is considered significant. However, I'd like to end on this point. Although the government cannot accept these amendments, it does not mean that we should refuse to confront difficult questions about lawfare on the application of human rights law to modern conflict, a subject I have been involved in teaching in my previous work. We should confront these questions and there is a wider debate to be had about them and I hope that we continue to do so, but this particular amendment does not provide the answer.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I want to thank everyone who's spoken during this debate on two very different but very important issues. I want to particularly thank Lady Bennett for supporting my amendments and in return I support hers again. And I thank the noble lady the minister for what she said about the campaign that we've been able to join. We were not the instigators. My Lords, there are more cases that are going to be made public.
I'm hearing tens of, tens of cases and I realize that they're historic. I think my greatest fear is if the system that the noble lady the minister described to us is going to start catching the future ones quickly. And that's why I want to ask her if the guidance she referred to is going to be police and CPS guidance and binding on both parties because we must, even if we don't have, excuse me, things going back to the Secretary of State, it is abundantly clear that the CPS need to be involved in any formal decision involving these particular very difficult and hard cases. I'm really grateful that the government is looking at robust data reporting on this. I think that's extremely helpful.
And I thank the minister for agreeing to write to both Lady Bennett and myself with some of the harder questions that we asked that might need a bit more thought and we look forward to working with the minister in future if we can be of any help. Finally, my Lords, I just want to thank the Center for Military Justice who have been doing an enormous amount of work on this in the background and without them and the Guardian we would not know about these cases at all. My Lords, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment 49.
Alan Beith
Is it your pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn?
The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 50, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 51, Baroness Blower, not moved. Amendment 52, Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay.
Stephen Parkinson
My Lords, when I saw that my amendment 52 had been grouped this way in a group titled by the Government Whips' Office 'Service Personnel Welfare', I did wonder whether it sat easily with some of the other issues which we will touch on over the course of this debate. But on reflection, I think it does, because the huge debt of gratitude that we owe to our service men and women lasts long beyond their time on active service, and in the case of those who have very sadly laid down their lives in the service of our nation, it of course lasts forever. I should say, as I did in committee, that I support the aims of clause 49 of the bill and the changes that His Majesty's Government is seeking to make to speed up the processes and broaden the remit of the Protection of Military Remains Act 1986. I do think, as we've touched on in our earlier stages of debate, that that might benefit from greater precision about the term 'in military service', as mentioned in 49(2)(b). Does that, in the case of vessels, relate solely to those which have been formally commissioned or requisitioned, or is it to be assessed by reference to the functions and activities that they were carrying out?
If the Minister is able to say more about that, that may be helpful. But the noble Baroness the Minister will be aware of the concerns that I raised in committee about a specific but consequential area of law as it relates to military shipwrecks. That was informed by research conducted by a team of academics at the University of Plymouth, led by Associate Professor Jason Lowther, and brought to my attention by the Joint Nautical Archaeological Policy Committee, whom I know from my time at DCMS when I was the Heritage Minister. In brief, these academics' research has led them to the conclusion that the UK has inadvertently removed, or at least weakened, the protection of sovereign immunity which is afforded to Royal Navy wrecks and other Crown vessels. That long-standing principle is used to protect some 5,000 British vessels which lie at the bottoms, the bottom of seas and oceans across the globe.
Quite apart from the heritage and historical significance of these vessels, many of them constitute the last known resting place of UK military personnel who've given their lives in the service of this country. The removal of the protection afforded through sovereign immunity places these vessels at risk of salvage by foreign nations or other actors, such as has most regrettably occurred in the recent cases of HMS Prince of Wales and HMS Repulse off the coast of Malaysia, and HMS Exeter and HMS Encounter in the Java Sea. We should, my Lords, be clear what that means. It is the graves of British service personnel being looted for scrap metal. The academics who conducted this research were naturally concerned at their finding and have taken great pains to raise it with the Ministry of Defence and others before they are compelled to publish the research that has been publicly funded.
I'm very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, for taking the time to meet me and Professor Mike Williams from that research team, along with officials and lawyers from the Ministry of Defence to discuss this matter, and I, like others, wish the noble Lord a speedy recovery. Though it was a helpful meeting, I think, you know, there is still a point of law that is at least debatable, and this is a matter where clarity is certainly needed.
So I've retabled the amendment which I laid and brought before your lordships in committee. It is as I said then not an elegant or complete solution, not least because of the problems of scope in this bill. And I hope the noble baroness the minister will be able to say a bit more about the government's thinking in relation to the question of law that the academics have raised. If she's able to say is it still the position of the Ministry of Defence that section 231 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995 applies only in UK territorial waters and that sunken state wrecks beyond our territorial waters remain protected from unauthorized salvage under the principle of sovereign immunity. Is she confident that a salvage claim by a foreign nation or vessel could be resisted under a reasonable prohibition under article 19 of the International Salvage Convention.
But above all, will His Majesty's government act with some urgency to ensure that the legal position which offers protection to the remains of military vessels and to the war graves of British service personnel is clearly understood not just in our courts but around the world. I beg to move.
Alan Beith
Amendment proposed in clause 39, page 69, line 36 to insert the words on the marshal list.
Julie Smith
My lords, I rise to move amendments 53 and 57 in my own name and to speak to amendment 54 in the names of the noble and gallant lord, Lord Craig of Radley and Baroness Penn. My amendment 53 is a retabling of an amendment brought at committee and it's really to seek further reassurance. The noble lord the minister did discuss this with me ahead of this stage of the bill. And my understanding is that what we're asking for should already be the case that records should be passed on within a month or so. But that appears anecdotally not to be happening and there have been issues.
So that's why that amendment has been tabled again. And amendment 57 on the defense investment plan and looking to have more parliamentary scrutiny of it. If we were earlier in the day, I would perhaps suggest a fuller and more comprehensive debate on it. However, I'm not going to detain the house with that. But what I would like to do is very strongly support amendment 54 and obviously the noble and gallant lord will move his amendment in due course.
But this is something that was a manifesto commitment for all three parties, removing immigration fees for non-UK family members of those who served with His Majesty's forces and from these benches we strongly support it. We also support the amendment in the name of the noble lady Baroness Penn and the noble lady Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle over occupational paternity leave and pay. So from these benches we give the current set of amendments with exception of amendment 56 which has sort of sneaked into this group fair wind and support.
Craig
My lords, my amendment number 54 follows on from the one I tabled in committee. I am grateful for the support of the noble lady Baroness Penn and for the guidance of the Royal British Legion in framing this amendment.
All three major parties in their manifestos for the 2024 general election undertook to waive the visa fees for spouses and children of serving or former members of His Majesty's Armed Forces who had served for four or more years but did not already have UK citizenship. Over the years there have been numbers, mainly Gurkhas and Fijian nationals, who have applied successfully but had to pay a fee of 155 pounds per individual, not even the 305 which I inadvertently mentioned in committee. But since April this fee has risen dramatically and is now 3,226 pounds. So the undertaking of the political parties has become even more pressing. The noble lord the minister Lord Coaker kindly arranged a meeting after committee to discuss this issue with officials.
It is a matter that the MOD alone could not resolve as the Home Office and of course Treasury have direct interest. I should stress that this is just the sort of issue that requires consideration of due regard at departmental level for the direct application of the military covenant and this is dealt with elsewhere in the bill. I did suggest in the second reading debate that there might be a temptation to play ping-pong between departments when an issue of due regard would require the agreement of two or more of them and a silo approach might inevitably lead to delay. A lack of certainty of how many families would be involved, for example, was raised by the Treasury officials and added to an impression of a departmental finding difficulties rather than the solution promised in the manifestos. My lords, we are now well over two years since that 2024 election with little sign of progress to an agreed date.
What is required promptly is not only a choice of lead department and I am grateful now for the assurance from the noble lord the minister that MOD is taking the departmental lead, but approval is required for a firm date of resolution. Officials have already had over two years to research, develop and solve such an important type of electoral promise. Surely such a straightforward problem must be solvable in two years or so by any civil servant. As suggested in my amendment, the Immigration and Nationality Fees Regulations 2018 would seem to be the correct power, statutory power for eliminating these fees. I have included in my amendment the request for a transparent description of the exchanges between departments in reaching this solution.
Speaker 133
An indication of how such interdepartmental issues of due regard so closely affecting the military covenant will be addressed in the future would be helpful. This is, my lords, a tripartite party manifesto commitment and yet there is still no date. Surely that is unacceptable to His Majesty's government or indeed to the other two parties involved.
Speaker 134
Much as I do not wish to hold the noble lady to account for the lack of progress, I feel that the view of the House supporting the manifesto commitment and fixing a date for implementation might assist in persuading the government that a solution honoring it must be reached and soon. This is an opportunity for the government to be seen to be gripping a manifesto commitment, to demonstrate that my own fears are groundless and that the government has reached a timely solution to give to the House. I look forward to the noble lady's response.
Joanna Penn
My Lords, let me add my support to the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley's amendment 54 on fees for indefinite leave to remain for families of serving personnel and veterans with a minimum period of service. As the noble and gallant Lord has said, families have waited long enough. I won't add to his words except to say I hope that MOD has been successful in its work in corralling other government departments to finally get this commitment delivered on, and I like others will listen carefully to the minister's response. Turning to amendment 55 on paternity leave, I'd also like to thank the noble baroness the minister and the noble Lord, Lord Coaker in his absence for their engagement on this issue. As I said at committee, this amendment is both about how we support military families, but also at its heart is it's about military capability.
I understand feedback from the services raised concerns about the impact of extending paternity leave on operational capability and effectiveness. And also, I think it is fair to say some skepticism about the importance of this issue to members of the forces and their families. And I'll take the two points in reverse. Since committee stage, the Dad Shift conducted a survey of over 1700 members of military and MOD. Nearly a thousand fathers responded, and whilst 95% had taken paternity leave and 92% had taken the full two weeks, 94% felt that two weeks was simply not enough.
And when asked about retention, of the 544 that responded, 35% said their experience of paternity leave had influenced their thinking about leaving the armed forces. This does not match the view reported from service leaders at one of the meetings we had that this is not an issue particularly for forces families. And I'm also concerned at the declining take-up of existing paternity leave policies and at what appeared to be a view that this should be seen perhaps as a positive rather than as a warning sign around culture and workforce issues within our services. Turning to operational capability, I would appreciate greater clarity from the noble lady the minister on why, given that paternity leave, like other policies under JSP 760, can only be taken at the service's discretion and subject to operational requirements, that an increase in paternity leave cannot be managed without impacting on operational effectiveness. That must already be the case where discretionary leave is granted, for example in the cases where a birth is via C-section, making up nearly half of all births in our country today.
And given that all our major allies manage policies significantly more generous than our own, I'd like to understand whether any efforts have been made to understand how they manage the operational impact of those policies or indeed the benefits they may see on retention within their services.
I appreciate the work that is going on within the MOD to look at this issue further, and I understand that focus groups will be conducted across all three services later this month. And I'd be grateful if the noble lady the minister could confirm that these will be focused specifically on parental leave and paternity leave in particular, and that the results of these focus groups will be made public and available to Parliament. And to follow up on that work, whether the MOD will commit to questions on parental leave and paternity leave specifically being included in the next tri-services families continuous attitude survey in 2027. It would also be useful to hear further information about the planned awareness raising activities for the families day in November. My Lords, at second reading I referenced the workforce crisis highlighted by the strategic defense review, a crisis not of just of recruitment, but of retention.
It's unclear to me at the moment that the MOD or the services have serious plans to make the changes needed to address this, but I very much hope that I'm proven wrong.
Natalie Bennett
Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble lady Baroness Penn, and to congratulate the noble lady on both the powerfulness of her speech and the fact that she the noble lady is clearly making an impact and we're seeing some reaction from the military, but we need to see much more. And I'm just going to add one point to the points made by the noble lady about military capability and the effect on families. I think it's crucial that we also talk about the effect on society. Children growing up having strong stable relationships with both of their parents is something that's going to be good for society in the coming decades. It's not just an individual benefit or a military benefit, it is also a benefit for society and that's something we really should be should be highlighting.
And I just want to also offer support for the amendment of the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig of Radley. We have impossible immigration fees that are affecting so many people very badly as part of a hostile environment that's creating huge numbers of problems. I'd like to see this addressed more broadly, but very clearly within the scope of the bill, this is addressing a group of families, a group of people who we should not be making it impossible for them to maintain their immigration status through fees that we know the levels of pay just will make this impossible for some people and that's not an acceptable situation.
Jasset David Cody Harlech
My Lords, I declare an interest as an officer of the all-party parliamentary group on Fiji. I support amendment 54 in the name of the noble and gallant Lord Lord Craig of Radley, and amendment 55 in the name of my noble friend Baroness Penn. On amendment 54, I'd like to put one point to the noble Baroness the minister, which is that our own rules currently contradict themselves. A non-UK service leaver qualifies for indefinite leave to remain as of right after four years of service, and that's the entitlement. Yet the fee waiver begins only at six years.
So for two full years a veteran holds a legal right to settle in this country and is charged over three thousand pounds to exercise it. I do not believe that anybody designed that, and it's it's not a question of generosity but of incoherence, which the four-year trigger in this amendment would correct. My Lords, then there are the families who are not covered at all. So the fee is now three thousand two hundred and twenty-six pounds per person, as we've heard from other noble Lords, against one hundred and fifty-five pounds in 2003. Twenty-six percent of army other rank spouses hold non-UK nationality.
So we're talking about a quarter of the families of the soldiers who make up the bulk of the army set against other rank pay. So for comparison's sake, in the United States, serving personnel and veterans pay no fee whatsoever to apply for naturalization because it's a statutory exemption and it delivers full citizenship, whilst we're currently charging over 3,000 pounds a head for something that offers considerably less than that. The noble lord the minister was candid in committee when he said that the government is committed to this and added that even even to his own government he sometimes says, can we get a move on? So I do hope the noble baroness the minister will say that again today and and give the house a date. On amendment 55, as as my noble friend outlined so so eloquently, the service personnel accept that operational need comes first.
And when they take the oath, they accept that they'll miss birthdays, christenings, weddings, because that comes with the territory. But what what this amendment addresses is quite different, which is the absence of a father in the first weeks of a child's life at a time when he's not deployed, but simply back at base, back at barracks. And nothing in the amendment changes the position that leave remains subject to operational requirements. I mean, the problem that where they can't let anyone go is because the armed forces are too small. Right, if we if we were staffed enough, if we had the right number of workforce, it wouldn't be a problem to let, you know, people go for paternity leave.
The noble lord the minister told the committee that the wider parental leave review concludes in early 2027, by which time this bill will have passed, so the review cannot help the families this amendment is about. And I do hope that the government will make more progress in this area and fast.
The Earl of Minto
My lords, it's the end of a long day, though not as long as it might have been, I suppose, as we reach the final group on this bill, and so I shan't detain the house for long. As at committee, these benches fully support the efforts of my noble friend Lord Parkinson to raise the issue of salvage law and possible inconsistencies that affect our underwater military heritage. I understand he's had discussions with the Ministry of Defence and that and that if he is content with their response, then so am I. The noble and gallant lord, Lord Craig of Radley, has retabled his amendment 54 requiring the government to amend the Immigration and Nationality Fees Regulation 2018 to waive the fees for indefinite leave to remain for close relatives of service personnel. As has been mentioned, this was a manifesto commitment for my party, the Labour Party, and the Liberal Democrats.
I understand the noble and gallant lord has reached an agreement with the government, which is welcome, and I hope that the noble baroness the minister will confirm this in her closing comments. Had the noble and gallant lord been pressed to test the opinion of the house, we would have supported him.
Ann Trebus
So I'll address each amendment in the order they appear on the marshalled list, starting with amendment 52. I am grateful to the noble lord Lord Parkinson for bringing forward amendment 52 and for the meeting he has with Lord Coaker on the 12th of October in relation to salvage claims against military and Royal Fleet Auxiliary vessels via section 1 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995, which is a principal piece of primary legislation in the United Kingdom that governs maritime law, ship registration, and safety standards, and personally for his thoughtful and important remarks about the protection of military remains, and I share in his grave concerns, and I know he meant it in that sense.
I have a small point of clarification, I'm not sure if it completely answers, if not, I can write to him afterwards. But to be classified as in military service at the time of their loss, vessels must have been formally requisitioned, utilized for armed forces purposes and operating under military command. Now, whilst it is recognized there is an issue that requires clarification, it was agreed I think at the meeting that further assessment would be needed to fully explore the potential impact and unintended consequences that amending section 230(1) would have on maritime legislation. So for that reason, we cannot accept this amendment now to the Armed Forces Bill. But I'd like to reassure the House that my noble friend the Minister, Lord Coaker, will raise this with the Department of Transport ministers and other government colleagues to determine a way forward as this is legislation that sits in their area.
I hope this provides the necessary reassurance to the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson, and on these grounds I ask him to withdraw his amendment. Turning to amendment 53 on leaving Defence Medical Services care, or DMS for short, service personnel are provided with a medical case summary for their GP from for their GP at their release. It is a summary, I accept, and are provided with a form for the GP to request full records access. In most circumstances, providing a complete healthcare record on discharge does not benefit the patient or GP beyond current methods of handing over care. Automatic provision also removes patient choice and provides a large volume of records, some of which may not be relevant to the service leaver's future care.
And creating a second statutory duty duplicates existing law rather than improving access to records or healthcare. I do take the noble Baroness Lady Smith's point about anecdotally not happening and will continue to focus on that on compliance with data protection and security protocols. That presents a significant workload which should be prioritized for clinical care and cases which require this level and volume of records administration and disclosure. Also, there are some good reasons not to provide a complete healthcare record to the individual unless it's been requested. An individual's full unfiltered medical record may include sensitive mental or physical health notes, third party information, complex diagnoses or provisional opinions, probably a reason that I haven't requested mine to be honest.
As such, when a patient's full DMS health record is requested, their NHS GP is usually asked to request it to supplement their NHS record. This ensures that it is received by healthcare professionals in full for summarization and in the correct registered practice. The future medical digital system under program Cortisone aims to make the transfers of records faster, electronic and more reliable. It will ensure when leaving the military, service leavers will not have to wait for health records to reach their NHS providers. Transfer and record sharing will occur digitally upon registration with a new practice.
Turning to amendment 54, I thank the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig, for his amendment. I thank him for making time to meet with me and I think he knows I will work hard and fast in order to progress with his point. The government has been clear that it remains committed to delivering the important manifesto commitment as referenced by several people and I welcome the contributions from Lord Harlach and others in support. We are supportive of the intention behind the noble and gallant Lord's amendment and will therefore commit to bringing a revised version of this amendment forward at third reading. Turning to amendment 55, as mentioned previously, there's currently an ongoing review on a government review of parental leave and pay.
The review is considering costs, benefits and potential reforms across the system as a whole. While the review principally covers civilian parental leave and pay entitlements, the MOD will consider the outcome of that review for applicability to the armed forces. To increase uptake of paternity and family leave in the armed forces, which has been an issue in the past, the single services believe clearer communication would help to increase uptake. From late October, defense analysis surveys will assess awareness across the Royal Navy, Army and Royal Air Force through focus groups. Findings will follow when the report is complete and we will share these.
And I just want to address a couple of the questions that the noble lady Lady Penn raised. The focus groups that we are putting together will look at leave in the round, but with an emphasis on the awareness of paternity leave issues as well as uptake of other leave provisions. The results will inform the evidence base and development of any case for change in policy provision. We are considering specific questions on parental leave and paternity leave for the 2027 tri-service families continuous attitude survey. As I've said, internal communications have been drafted to promote existing parental leave policies and to address the take-up of paternity leave.
These will be published imminently. And we will be factoring into our work on the evidence base where and how allies have implemented more generous leave without impacting on operational effectiveness, as the noble lady Baroness Penn pointed out, and the positive potential impact that might have on retention and indeed to the noble Baroness Lady Bennett's points around society more generally, which I take note of. And finally, I turn to amendment 57. The DIP is a deliverable and affordable plan which details investment priorities out to 2035, but as with any long-term plan, it would be prudent to keep it under review. We've committed in the DIP to an annual update to Parliament before summer recess each year on progress against the DIP and any changes in financial investments.
While the publication of the DIP took longer than originally anticipated, we do not accept that a separate statutory assessment of the impact of delay is needed. And the MOD did not pause delivery while waiting for its publication. Over 31 billion was spent with UK industry last year and the MOD has continued to engage closely with industry partners, including SMEs, throughout the development of the DIP and post-publication. I thank noble Lords for their time and the debate today.
Stephen Parkinson
My Lords, I'm very grateful to the noble Baroness Lady Ann-Trebus for the reply that she's just given and repeat my gratitude to the noble Lord Lord Coaker for the meeting that he and officials from MOD had. I should say as well I express my support for all the other amendments that were moved in this group and commend the government for the third reading commitment that they've just made. In relation to amendment 52, as the noble Baroness says, the meeting that we had earlier this month did show that further research and work is needed with not just the Department for Transport, but the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, which relates to the heritage aspects of it.
And I do encourage the government to carry that out with some urgency. In the case of HMS Exeter, which was sunk in the Second World War in 1942, the wreck was not discovered until 2007. And a very moving service was held the following year, 2008, where some of the veterans from the Second World War attended in a service facilitated by HMS Kent. And a Royal Navy ensign was placed on the wreck of the ship as is naval tradition. Eight years later, by 2016, the remains of that ship had been entirely stolen.
This is the speed with which these crimes are being committed in waters around the globe. So there is some urgency here as well as some legal precision. So I'm very grateful to her and to the noble Lord Lord Coaker for taking that forward. And on that basis, I'm happy to withdraw my amendment 52.
Speaker 138
Is it your lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 53, Baroness Smith of Newnham. Not moved. Amendment 54, Lord Craig of Radley.
Craig
I welcome very much the remarks and expression of support from the minister. And may I also commend her for rising so admirably to replace the noble Lord Lord Coaker at very short notice. I think I should also remind her that about 18 months ago, the Ministry of Defence spokesman in the other place assured the house, that house, that the Ministry of Defence and the Home Office were actively working on this manifesto commitment. And so I hope she will agree that further six months would be far too long to wait to carry forward the promise in that manifesto.
Speaker 137
Not moved, Lord Craig of Radley. Not moved. Amendment 55, Baroness Penn. Not moved. Amendment 56, the Earl of Minto.
Speaker 138
The question is that amendment 56 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will advise the house when voting is open.
Voting is now open. Clear the bar.
The question is that amendment 56 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion say content. The contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.
Question is that amendment 56 be agreed to.
Speaker 138
My Lords, there have voted contents 67, not contents 168, so the not contents have it. My Lords, amendment 57, Baroness Smith of Newnham. Not moved. Amendments 58 and 59 moved formally en bloc. The question is that amendments 58 and 59 be agreed to en bloc.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 60. The question is that amendment 60 be agreed to.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.