Press conference by the Members of the LIBE rule of law mission to Budapest (Hungary), chaired by Tineke STRIK (Greens/EFA, NL)

16 April 2025

No chapters available yet

European Parliament

01:14 - 01:36
Speaker 1
Means that the same filming rules apply as in all premises of the parliament.  That means also it includes also that if members do not wish to answer questions, that's their right to do so, and you cannot have a camera running when they refuse to give an interview.  Thank you.  May I introduce the members of the delegation, please? 
01:36 - 01:41
Speaker 2
We have Teneka Strick from the Guinness.  She's the head of the delegation, 
01:57 - 02:02
Speaker 1
from the left.  And with this, dear missus Fritz, floor is yours. 
02:02 - 04:11
Speaker 3
Thank you.  Thank you very much, and warm welcome to all of you to this press conference about the legal mission to Hungary in the framework of the Article seven procedure.  Four years ago, the European parliament undertook effect finding mission with members of the Liber Committee in the rapporteur and the shadow rapporters on the rule of in Hungary.  Rule of in Hungary.  So now in the new parliamentary term with new members, but also with a lot of new developments that have taken place in Hungary, we thought it would be good to do an update and look at the new developments that have happened and are ongoing in Hungary. 

We are representing five political groups.  The patriots ECR and ECM decided not to join this mission.  The last three days, we had meetings with a wide range of actors.  We talked with the deputy minister of European affairs, bodies and associations of the judiciary, journalists, several NGOs working on human rights, corruption, rights, corruption, freedom of media, political parties, trade unions, and academia.  Unfortunately, the minister of justice, the minister of interior, the constitutional court, the supreme court, as well as the commissioner of fundamental rights declined our request to meet. 

Let me tell you a little bit about the context of this mission.  As you know, the article seven procedure, which is triggered or can be triggered in case of a breach of the European values as enshrined in article two in the treaties, has been triggered by the European Parliament in 2018.  And as you know, also this procedure is still pending in 
04:11 - 04:12
Speaker 1
the council. 
04:13 - 07:56
Speaker 3
But since then, both the Parliament and the Commission have made a large number of recommendations to the European to their Hungarian government.  And also, European courts, both the EU Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights have delivered a significant number of judgments towards Hungary in the field of rule of law, democracy, and fundamental rights.  Unfortunately, the Hungarian government has not complied with the vast majority of it.  Both the recommendation and the judgments and specifically the most substantial ones.  On the contrary, in this new mandate of the European Parliament, see on top of the noncompliance with these recommendations and The National Sovereignty Act has been adopted with the establishment of the Sovereignty Protection Office aimed at the preventing of combating a foreign interference. 

While this aim is in itself legitimate, we see in practice that the office is targeting journalists and NGOs who are monitoring compliance with EU law.  It is problematic that EU funding is apparently perceived as foreign interference and that this objective seem to be merely used to crack down on civil society.  Then we see many developments regarding the judiciary.  Based on recent agreements with courts where they where the very necessary raise of salaries for judges and their staff was coupled with a significant number of reforms that may endanger the independence of the judiciary.  It is very rare that judges take to the streets and protest and that they did that in the recent months that I shows that they are worried about the necessary independence to do their work as a guardian of the rule of law, including compliance with EU law. 

In his speech of one month ago, the prime minister announced further plans to restrict civil society activities, in particular, the right to assembly, which also endangers the freedom of expression, core values of the EU.  And this is a very serious development.  In order to ensure the right to assembly and make clear that the EU is ready to defend the EU values, this delegation has sent a letter to the European Commission urging it to ask for an interim measure at the Court of Justice in the pending LGBTIQ case to get a ruling from the court in time so that the pride can take place lawfully and peacefully.  We plan to draft a new interim report where we will draft our findings and recommendations partly also based on the meetings that we had the last days.  And these will be discussed and adopted by the European Parliament probably after summer. 

07:56 - 08:52

Speaker 3

And we will debrief the ambassadors quite soon after this mission in preparation of the hearing that they will have in the context of Article seven, end of May. Let me finally thank all services who worked so hard to make this mission a success. First of all, my pray this to my member colleagues and their political advisors, but also the wonderful parliament services. The Liber Secretariat, the interpreters, eplock staff and the parliament media sources and also the transparency registered because many actors had to be registered in the speedy procedure. I leave it for for now here.

We are open to questions afterwards, but not only after my colleagues have also highlighted

08:52 - 08:54

Speaker 4

a few points. Thank you.

08:59 - 08:59

Speaker 1

Good

08:59 - 09:12

Speaker 5

morning. Let me put some remarks from you, from my side, very briefly. What we could observe during this mission is indisputable deterioration

09:13 - 09:13

Speaker 1

of

09:13 - 11:33

Speaker 5

the situation, and I would even say an open denial of the rule of law. This includes the process of reducing the systemic independence of the judiciary. EU standards and the guarantees in this respect are not being upheld. In addition, we are dealing with the government's intentional refusal to implement a huge number of key rulings of the European courts, especially those which are important from the point of view of the values described in article two of the treaty. We heard several times during these missions from a couple of authorities that there are good and bad rulings of the European courts.

So the government is entitled to select those rulings or verdicts which are implemented and which are not implemented. And I would like to say I would like to remind that there is a principle of sincere cooperation, which is also called a loyalty within the European Union that requires the EU member states to facilitate the union's task and to adopt all necessary measures to fulfill their obligations under the treaties and to refrain from any actions that could jeopardize the realization of EU objectives. So Hungarian government is definitely obliged under this rule to implement all the judgments of the court of justice, and it's not competent to refuse this obligation. All of the violations which we observed are going to be precisely described in the in the report. And at the end, my very personal perception that I believe is shared also by the rest of the delegation.

Unfortunately, on the number of meetings with the authorities, we experience very aggressive approach towards us in a rude behavior. Thank you.

11:35 - 13:22

Speaker 6

Good afternoon, everyone. What we believe in and what the parliament European parliament believes in is a quality before the law and the principle of nondiscrimination. And we perceive those two values as one of as the pillars of the rule of law, and that is why we, on this mission, scrutinize the state of protection of LGBTIQ rights in Hungary. During our mission, we met with a number of civil society organizations, including those fighting for LGBTI rights. They expressed their concerns on the recent legislative developments here in Hungary, like the recent restrictions to the law on assembly that will directly impact LGBTI community events here in this country.

The LGBTIQ community is already facing direct legal restrictions. For example, the ban on legal gender recognition as well as so called anti gay propaganda law that prohibits any kind of information about LGBTIQ rights in a public sphere. All of this creates a very hostile atmosphere for LGBTI Hungarians that has already led to rise of physical violent attacks and other types of hate crimes. What we are witnessing is a wider trend of restrictions on fundamental rights in Hungary, freedom of assembly, freedom of association, freedom of expression, and rights to access information. These rights are covered by article two of the treaty, the charter for fundamental rights as primary law of the

13:35 - 16:27

Speaker 7

Thank you very much, and good afternoon, everybody. First, probably a word of thank. Thanks as our Chief of Delegation has expressed, of course, to the team, also to all entity and the authority who accepted to see us even if some conversation were probably harder than others. If you allow me, I would address the question more in specificity about the media. As you know, we have met some of them, and our concerns are growing.

First of all, on the pluralism and the diversity of information. We know that 80% of all market revenues channel to pro government media, and you understand very well that this serves to amplify the government narrative, while simultaneously weakened economically destabilizing and pressuring independent media outlets into abandoning critical position. Second concern is about indeed the financial control that I just touched upon. We see that there is no progress that has been made to ensure transparency of fairness in the distribution of state advertising. Third point I would like to make is about the restriction on freedom of information.

It has been reported several times that independent journalists faces severe information, but also the use of a very aggressive rhetoric. Like my colleague said, aggressive rhetoric that we had found ourselves confronted to on many occasion when we had meetings with authority, which is very regrettable because we were here to have answer on very neutral question. But not least, the pressure on independent media. Missus Tineco strict touched upon it when she talked about the adoption of the National Sovereignty Act, which created, of course, the Sovereignty Protection Office that we just met before this meeting who has indeed a broad mandate to decide investigation, no external oversize, and which, of course, is going to only worsen the situation. And I have to tell you that after this this meeting, was not reassured far from it.

Thank

16:27 - 16:28

Speaker 1

you very much.

17:17 - 17:55

Speaker 8

Additionally, accessing the Hungarian territory is practically impossible for migrants and seal of seekers. 15,000 people have been pushed back in 2024, and there is a shocking figure. And municipalities led by the opposition are being financially suffocated. For 15, the parliament majority has been used to to travel the rights of minorities and has become the tyranny of the majority. The ban on the private events is a test case that will show whether the European institutions are up

17:55 - 17:56

Speaker 1

to

17:56 - 18:25

Speaker 8

their task. This progressive measure violates the right of freedom of assembly based on purely ideological grounds. Organizers and participants of the Budapest pride risk facing criminal charges for marching peacefully in support of diversity, equality, and freedom as they have done for the last twenty nine years. The impunity of the Hungarian government in circumventing

19:10 - 19:16

Speaker 9

ministers were not ready to meet you. Did they give you any reason why they are not ready to meet?

19:17 - 19:35

Speaker 3

No. Unfortunately, not. I mean, we are let me first say we're very thankful for all the actors who did talk to us. It's mister missus Wilmers also said. But indeed, that a number of key actors from the authority side did not want to meet with us is

20:33 - 21:08

Speaker 4

about the latest report of the European Court of Auditors, which stated that the funding metal between the European Commission and NGOs is not transparent enough. And I have one more question for Mr. Smrzek because you are, as far as I'm concerned, you are the representative of the committee responsible for the parliamentary immunity of Peter Madar. So the question is, how come and what is the reason that there has been no official hearing in the last eight months during this topic?

21:08 - 22:54

Speaker 3

You. You. Well, the last question cannot be answered because that's outside of the scope of the mission. The first question, sorry, I have to recall about Patriots ECR and ESM. Definitely, they are, as political parties, completely involved in this article seven procedure from the parliament side and they it was their decision not to join and not to come up with proposals of who to meet.

That links to the next question like, did we meet with MEPs? No, rule of law emissions are never accompanied by MEPs from the real estate concern because we want keep it in Russia. We met with many members of the national parliament, but not here with members of European parliament. Of course, we talk with them are are at the moment that they are presented in the parliament almost immediately adopted. And this leads to a lot of difficulties for all kinds of actors in society to be consulted and to provide their opinion.

And this is, of course, hampering the democratic process, but also the quality of

22:54 - 22:55

Speaker 4

the decision making.

23:33 - 23:51

Speaker 3

Maybe it's good to remind you about the scope of this rule of law mission. We are here to assess the situation of the rule of law democracy and fundamental rights right here in Hungary. So we are not entitled or at the mandate to respond on these kinds

23:51 - 23:53

Speaker 4

of questions at the EU level.

24:04 - 24:14

Speaker 2

Thank you, Mahatam from Deluxe. And I have a question or at two questions about your meeting with the representative of the Hungarian

24:43 - 25:25

Speaker 3

You mean the meeting with the deputy minister of foreign affairs European affairs. Right? As my colleagues already referred to this meeting and other meetings of authorities, we were quite surprised about the sort of hostile attitude that we were experiencing. And what I remember most vividly from this meeting is that he came up all the time with examples of situation in other Hindustan trying to make certain points, maybe as a way to evade the questions that we were posing. And that's always the problem problematic issue here.

We are here

26:36 - 26:45

Speaker 5

Hello. My name is Balesh Korotzky from index. I have just only one question. I'm here. What concrete step does the European Parliament plan to take

27:13 - 27:55

Speaker 3

We encounter the dialogues with member states to see how much more effective could you use this instrument of article seven because it's meant for the member states to address each other's shortcomings. This is not something that we can do ourselves. The only thing we can do is provide them with information that they could use. Indeed, the commission has its own instruments like freezing, funding, but also starting infringement procedures. I think this has to continue as long as there are violations.

But it's true, it doesn't immediately lead to improvement. But we

27:55 - 27:55

Speaker 1

will

27:55 - 28:55

Speaker 3

need urge the commission to do its work as part of the treaty. And we therefore also urge the commission now to start a request for intra measure because we cannot wait for years for the court of justice to decide as these developments are coming so rapidly in the wrong direction in I would like to thank all of you and and let me remind you that what we do this for the Hungarian citizens and the Hungarian society. We we we equally want this country to turn back into a real democracy because we think that Hungarians as The US citizens should enjoy the same rights and values as we all do into the EU.

28:55 - 28:56

Speaker 1

Thank you very much.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.