Social Housing Bill

27 October 2026

Social Housing Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:03 - 00:14
Speaker 7
Order, order.  We are now sitting in public and the proceedings are being broadcast.  Sorry, we should read this first.  Social Housing Bill, Lords.  Right, I'll try again. 
00:14 - 01:05
Speaker 6
We are now sitting in public and proceedings are being broadcast.  Before we begin, I would like to remind members to please switch off electronic devices or move them to silent.  Tea and coffee are not allowed during the sittings.  Today we will first consider the program motion on the amendment paper.  We will then consider a motion to enable the reporting of written evidence for publication and a motion to allow us to deliberate in private about our questions before the oral evidence sessions. 

In view of the time available, I hope we can take these matters formally without debate.  There's an error on the paper.  Well, I'm just reading the script.  I first call the minister to move the program motion standing in his name, which was discussed yesterday by the programming subcommittee.  This motion can be debated for up to 30 minutes. 
01:05 - 01:07
Speaker 2
Move formally. 
01:07 - 01:20
Speaker 6
The question is the program motion as on the amendment paper.  As many of that opinion say aye.  To the contrary, no.  I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.  I call the minister to move the motion on written evidence. 
01:20 - 01:21
Move formally. 
01:21 - 01:47
Speaker 6
The question is the written evidence motion as on the amendment paper.  As many of that opinion say aye.  To the contrary, no.  I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.  Copies of written evidence which the committee receives will be made available in the committee room. 

Members are responsible for declaring any interests in accordance with the code of conduct at the start of proceedings and when speaking or tabling amendments.  Do any members wish to declare interests? 
01:47 - 01:52
Speaker 8
I wish to declare an interest by drawing members' attention to my category 8 entry in the register of interests. 
01:52 - 01:54
Speaker 1
Thank you.  Gideon. 

01:54 - 02:02

Gideon Amos

Thank you, sir Vickers. I wish to draw the house's attention to my register of interest as a social landlord.

02:02 - 03:14

Martin Vickers

We now begin line-by-line consideration of the bill. The selection list for today's sitting is available in the room and on the parliamentary website. This shows how the clauses, schedules, and selected amendments have been grouped together for debate. A member who has put their name to the lead amendment in a group is called first. For debates on a clause stand part, the minister will be called first.

Other members are then free to indicate they wish to speak in the current debate by bobbing. Please bob on each occasion on which you wish to speak during the proceedings. At the end of the debate on a group of amendments and new clauses, I shall call the member who moved the lead amendment or new clause again. Before they sit down, they will need to indicate if they wish to withdraw the amendment or the new clause or to seek a decision. If any member wishes to press any other amendment, and this includes grouped clauses in a group to a vote, this is at my discretion.

We now come to group one and the question that clause one stand part of which it will be convenient to debate new clause 55 and new clause 57 and amendments 84 and 85. The question is that the clause one stand part of the bill. Minister.

03:14 - 07:46

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. Before I speak to clause one, I'd like to put on record once again my sincere thanks to my ministerial colleague Baroness Taylor of Stevenage for so ably shepherding the bill through its initial House of Lords stages.

I'd also like to take the opportunity to thank all those noble lords who took part in debates on the bill in the other place. It goes without saying that we did not agree with all of the arguments made and we cannot accept the incorporation of clause 13 into the bill for the reasons I'll detail in due course. But overall, the expert scrutiny and challenge provided by peers has helped improve the bill with a number of government amendments that we are bringing forward arising directly from the issues raised and points made during Lords debates. Mr. Vickers, as you know, the bill has three core objectives. First, to protect much-needed social housing stock and thereby incentivize the building of more social rented homes.

Secondly, to create a fairer tenancy system with greater protection for tenants who are victims of domestic abuse. And thirdly, to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and give providers greater regulatory certainty so that they can invest in new social and affordable homes with confidence. At the heart of the bill are comprehensive reforms to the right to buy scheme designed to put it on a fair and sustainable footing for the future. Informed by the feedback that we received in the public consultation that ran from November 2024 to January 2025, these reforms are set out in clauses 1 to 10 of the bill. So let me now turn to the first of them.

Mr. Vickers, over 2 million tenants have exercised the right to buy since it was introduced in 1980. However, as we all know, many of the homes sold under the scheme have not been replaced, depleting social housing stock. There is now insufficient supply of good quality social housing to meet demand with over 1.3 million households on the social housing waiting list and almost 180,000 children living homeless in temporary accommodation. The right to buy scheme has also reduced the motivation and confidence of councils to build since new homes can be sold before the council can recover its investment. While we respect those who believe that it should be abolished outright, the government's position remains that social housing tenants who have lived in and paid rent on their homes for many years should retain the opportunity to purchase them at a reasonable discount.

However, as I argued in the opening debate on the bill's second reading, there is a pressing need to radically reform the right to buy in order to reduce the significant outflow of stock that has taken place since discounts were drastically increased by the coalition government in 2012, to incentivize councils to once again build at scale and to attract broader investment in council housing. As things stand, Mr. Vickers, to qualify for the right to buy, an individual must be a secure tenant and have spent at least three years as a public sector tenant, i.e. someone whose landlord is a public body, usually a council or a housing association. The three years do not have to have been continuous and an individual can add together any time they've spent as a public sector tenant. They're also able to count any period when their husband, wife or civil partner was a public sector tenant. Until 2014, the minimum eligibility requirement was five, not three years.

The main rationale given at the time for reducing the qualifying period by two years was explicitly to drive an increase in the take-up of right to buy, and the decision was taken in the full knowledge that a tenant occupying a property for three years is extremely unlikely to have paid rent that equates to the available discount. The government believes a more sustainable balance must be struck to support councils to rebuild their stock of homes. Clause 1 therefore amends section 119 of the Housing Act 1985 to increase the minimum eligibility requirement from three to 10 years. As under the existing law, a combination of present and previous tenancies will continue to count towards the qualifying period. Increasing the minimum eligibility period in this way has received strong support from stakeholders.

In our consultation on reforming the right to buy, 81% of respondents, including 62% of tenants who responded, supported increasing the minimum period of tenancy required to at least 10 years. In fact, the majority of respondents, Mr. Vickers, supported someone having to be a public sector tenant for longer than 10 years before becoming eligible for the right to buy. The government believes that 10 years strikes the right balance between allowing long-standing tenants the opportunity to own their own home and protecting much-needed social housing stock. 10 years is also incidentally the average length of a tenancy of someone buying under the scheme currently. This is a targeted change, Mr. Vickers, which will maintain access to the right to buy for long-standing tenants but in a way that provides for a fairer and more sustainable scheme and better supports the long-term supply of social housing.

07:45 - 08:09

Gideon Amos

Oh, thank you, Mr. Vickers. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. I simply rise to support this clause. For Liberal Democrats, this is the most important, significant clause in the bill in constraining the exercise of the selling off of council houses. And it's concerning that the Conservatives have put down the amendment that would reverse essentially the proposition in this clause.

07:46 - 07:46

Gideon Amos.

08:09 - 08:57

Gideon Amos

With 1.32 million people on the housing waiting list, 177,000 children in temporary accommodation, the last thing we need is to continue the gradual loss of social housing. We've lost two million net losses of social homes since the introduction of right to buy. If that does not show that you cannot fill the bath with the plug taken out, then nothing does. So we stand squarely in support of this clause. We would go further and give local authorities the ability and power to suspend right to buy completely, ending right to buy if that's right for their area, so they can rebuild the stock that they need in terms of council housing and social rent homes.

08:57 - 10:29

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you very much, Mr. Vickers. I echo the minister's welcome. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. Mr. Vickers, this bill fails the British people. It effectively destroys right to buy for millions of families.

It does nothing to free up stock for British nationals. It fails to introduce efficient stock management regulations. And most egregiously, it fails to build a single social home, a point completely missed by the government and by the Liberal Democrats. The opportunity we have to scrutinize this bill line by line over the next three days is therefore of critical importance to defending aspiration and refocusing debate towards the delivery of new homes. Mr. Vickers, I will speak to new clauses 55 and 57 and amendments 84 and 85 that have been tabled in my name.

With regards to new clause 55, in the past, conservative government-backed schemes like help to buy and stamp duty discounts made a real difference to people buying their first home, helping around one million first-time buyers to get onto the housing ladder. This contributed to the 800,000 people who bought their first homes under the last government. Since 2024, however, the government has not shown that it has the aspiration to match that. Instead, they have cut a lot of the products that have turbocharged first-time buyers getting onto the housing ladder. Even when the government tries to support young people into property ownership, it emerges that not all that glisters is gold.

I'm primarily referencing the your first home scheme, a policy limited to new homes and expected to be constrained by income caps. Young people deserve better than this, especially young people in social housing. And that's why we've tabled...

10:29 - 10:57

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way. He mentions the your new home product that the government has announced for young people to get on the housing ladder. Does he agree that the targeted approach of this new idea from the government is in stark contrast to the previous help to buy from the conservative government, which actually about half of the people who bought under that were already able to buy a home and it just allowed them to buy a bigger home in probably a more affluent area?

10:57 - 12:33

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I think it rather depends on the detail, Mr. Vickers. But if the income caps that we are hearing about in the press are even remotely accurate, then you can rule out the whole of Greater London and the whole of the South East of England because people will not be able to access the financing. So that would be yet another example of the government pretending to do something without actually doing it. But we await the detail on that. Right to buy is not a shameful practice, nor is it an exercise in capitalistic greed.

It's a hand up onto the housing ladder for those in need and an extension in the fundamental right to property. And new clause 55 would help realize that for young people. After all, it's critical that more is done to help young people buy their first home.

They face the greatest barriers to home ownership of any recent generation, and yet the government's answer is to cut one of their only routes to property ownership. We believe this is fundamentally the wrong approach, and I urge colleagues to join me in supporting young people by backing new clause 55. With regards to new clause 57, clause 1 in its current form not only enables the injustice of preventing future hardworking residents from owning their own homes, but also prevents current tenants from doing so. This is a retrospective change that the opposition is completely against. This government has shown time and time again that it has no regard for the property rights of individuals.

The same socialistic focus that's seen the government target landlords, freeholders, and renters now turns its gaze towards residents in social homes. The vast majority of people in social housing deserve a hand up onto the property ladder and a chance to share in the pride of owning their own home. Many people in social housing know that their best chance of getting that is through right to buy.

12:33 - 12:34

Will the honorable member give way?

12:34 - 12:35

Yes, please do.

12:35 - 13:09

Speaker 14

With regards to new clause 55, would the honorable member be able to share the evidence base of which this proposal is put forward in terms of the number of tenants that there are between 16 and 25? I'm struggling to believe that this proposal would make any difference in terms of home ownership between 16 and 25 year olds, and in fact, it's the long-run shortage of genuinely affordable homes and genuinely affordable rented and affordable home ownership products that means that young people are struggling to get on the housing ladder.

13:09 - 13:42

Andrew Gareth Bacon

That's an interesting point the honorable lady makes, but what she doesn't say, of course, is how this government is going to increase the home building. There is no increase from this home building. The point of this clause is to raise awareness of right to buy to 16 to 25 year olds. The point of this clause, Mr. Vickers, is about aspiration. It's about something this government has absolutely no idea about.

And aspiration turned into opportunity by this party in the 1980s is being arbitrarily and retrospectively axed by a bill that offers no other route onto the housing market, builds no more social housing, and effectively excludes 5 million people from the fundamental right to property ownership.

13:42 - 13:44

Speaker 10

Will he give way on that point?

13:44 - 14:33

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I'm not going to give way, I need to make some progress. This is the least that can be done to support families aspiring to own their own home, whether they find themselves on the cusp of reaching their three-year qualifying period or whether they find themselves on day one of the road towards making their dream of home ownership a reality. With regards to amendments 84 and 85, the bill opens with a statement claiming that it is a bill to make provision about social housing, but the very first clause in this bill, clause 1, makes no effort to increase the supply, build-out rates, or funding for social housing. Instead, an ideological aversion to property ownership, a fundamental right, takes top spot at the very beginning of this bill. Ever since Margaret Thatcher gave millions of people the chance to own their own home rather than rent it from the state, local authority, or a registered provider, Labour MPs for generations have sought to crush that right and the aspiration that it exists to serve.

14:33 - 14:34

Will the honorable member give way?

14:34 - 15:18

Andrew Gareth Bacon

No. Over 2 million households have exercised the right to become homeowners and gain a stake in society. Until 1980, this had been out of the reach for far too many British people, but the government are determined to wind back the clock to the 1970s and cut off the right to own your own home for hardworking families up and down the country. And that is why we've tabled amendments 84 and 85 on behalf of the opposition. Through these amendments, we will take out the extended qualifying period from the day the act is passed, thus preventing clause 1 of this bill from coming into effect for three years following royal assent.

In doing so, we will delay the government's dogma and continue to support the rights of 5 million people to find their place in the community and feel pride and safety that comes with owning one's own home.

15:18 - 15:19

Minister.

15:19 - 16:29

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers.

Can I thank the honorable gentleman, the member for Orpington, for tabling and speaking to the four amendments in his name. I should say just at the outset, Mr. Vickers, in political terms, I think it'd be fair to say that he and I could not be further apart, but he is a decent and diligent shadow minister, as is the Liberal Democrat spokesman, I don't want to leave him out, the member for Taunton Wellington, and I look very much look forward to the robust yet civil debates we'll have over the coming sessions. I don't want to dwell too long on the more general points the honorable gentleman made, but I think it is worth responding to two. We have not extinguished through this bill the right to buy. We could have abolished the right to buy outright, that is not what we are doing.

We are ensuring that those who can benefit from the scheme are those long-standing tenants who have lived in and paid rent on their homes for many years. And in response to his other point about the bill having no impact on supply, he really ought to get out and speak to local authorities who are telling us that not only are the benefits of the regulatory certainty and stability we've provided, the grant funding we're providing, but the confidence that this bill will provide in allowing them to go out and build new social homes, safe in the knowledge that after three years in respect of this clause, they won't be immediately sold off.

16:29 - 16:51

Lewis Cocking

I thank the minister for giving way, he's always very generous of his time, and I do think he's actually a very competent and diligent minister in the department. But could he just elaborate on the evidence base for what he's just said? I was a leader of a local authority, I never once met a housing provider that said to me they can't build any more social housing because of the right to buy.

16:51 - 17:13

Matthew Pennycook

That's not my experience of discussing the matter with councils. It also doesn't reflect the feedback we had to the consultation. There are councils up and down the country who are telling us they can build more if they have the certainty that their stock is not lost in the proportion it is, and certainly in respect of this particular clause, Mr. Vickers, after a minimum qualifying period of three years. But I should turn to the honorable gentleman, I'll turn to the honorable gentleman.

17:13 - 17:53

Danny Beales

Having been a cabinet member for seven years in Camden, responsible for council house building and building a thousand, I must say when you're directly delivering council homes, it is a challenge when homes could quite quickly leave your stock through right to buy, having just built them at great public expense, having borrowed on a basis of 30 years of borrowing to deliver them, but then losing the asset at a discount and not recouping that. It is a material consideration. I would just, would the minister agree with me, it might be the case that those experiences in authorities not building council homes but relying on housing associations might not have seen this problem because housing associations are not included in the same way in right to buy.

17:53 - 18:21

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and for sharing his very considerable experience in this area. I think there is a difference of experience between local authorities that have housing revenue accounts, those that don't, those that are building at scale and those that don't. But it is certainly the case that knowing you can lose stock after three years of having built it and not recuperate that investment is a disincentive to build. I should really, I will give way to the honorable gentleman and then in the interest of getting to the opposition's new clauses, which I'm told they want to speak to, I will make some progress.

18:21 - 18:59

Speaker 16

I thank the minister. I appreciate the point he's making regarding recouping the investment made by councils, which is why there are elements of the bill that change that deal for councils. What I don't understand, what my residents, what the people across this country don't understand, is why you're restricting access to right to buy to a whole group of people who, you know, young people, young parents, people at the beginning of their professional life who might want to get onto the housing ladder. It seems like you're tackling one problem by focusing on a completely wrong element of the issue.

18:59 - 22:22

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I think I understand the point the honorable gentleman's making, but I'm afraid I just respectfully disagree. It is a problem that local authorities up and down the country build new social homes and then after three years they can be purchased. That is leading to an unsustainable outflow of social housing stock from the system. A net, and you know, we are not net positive on social homes, we haven't been over many years over this government. This bill will ensure that we are, and that is the incentive that it gives to councils to build, knowing that you are building more than you're losing, and therefore that 1.3 million people on waiting lists is not going to increase, it's going to decrease over time.

Mr. Vickers, I really must turn to the response to the specific amendments that the honorable gentleman spoke to. Turn first to new clause 57. This would exempt existing secure tenants from the new 10-year minimum qualifying period introduced by the bill. A core aim of the bill, as I've said, is to better protect social housing stock and ensure more social homes are built than lost. Excluding existing tenancies from the changes to eligibility rules would mean that the vast majority of tenants would be unaffected by our qualifying period reforms.

I've no doubt that's the honorable gentleman's intention, but as a result, we would continue to see homes being sold as early as three years after a tenancy is secured. This would, as I've said, enable the continued loss of significant amounts of social housing stock, and that is not this government's aim, it is not the aim of this bill. For that reason, the government cannot accept the amendment, and I hope the shadow minister will consider withdrawing it. Turning to new clause 55, this would require the Secretary of State to publish a strategy to promote awareness of the right to buy scheme among people aged 16 to 25 within 12 months of Royal Assent. The government does not consider that a statutory strategy targeted at everyone aged 16 to 25 is either necessary or proportionate.

Many people aged 16 to 25 will not be secure tenants or will not have accrued the necessary years as a secure tenant to be eligible for the right to buy. A statutory campaign aimed at that age group would be poorly targeted and could create confusion or raise false expectations. For tenants that are eligible, Mr. Vickers, I point honorable members to our existing your right to buy your home guide, which is accessible on gov.uk to all tenants irrespective of age. This provides a comprehensive guidance on the right to buy scheme, including on the costs of home ownership, and the guidance will obviously be fully updated in light of the bill's reforms. Tenants can obviously also speak to their social landlord about the scheme and how it might apply to them.

The guidance includes information on how to access the money and pension service, which provides free impartial advice to help people make informed choices about managing their money, and this service is accessible to young people. As we do not wish to duplicate any existing guidance, the government cannot accept this amendment, and I again respectfully ask the honorable member to withdraw it. And finally, turning to amendments 84 and 85, which seek to delay commencement of clause 1 of the bill by three years. The government is firmly of the view that it is imperative that we increase the minimum eligibility requirement for the right to buy scheme as soon as is practicable to ensure that councils are not losing homes at an unsustainable rate. As such, we intend to commence clause 1 of the bill on Royal Assent.

This will ensure that we act quickly to protect social housing stock and that we prevent a potential spike in sales as a result of these changes. Allowing a three-year lead-in time for clause 1 of the bill would only increase the loss of social homes. And again, while I'm in no doubt that's precisely what the member for Orpington intends in tabling this amendment, I trust he'll understand why the government cannot accept them, and I respectfully ask him to withdraw.

22:22 - 22:55

Martin Vickers

The question is that clause 1 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

The question on new clauses 55 and 57 and amendments 84 and 85 will be put later in the proceedings when we reach them on the amendment paper. We now come to group, come to group 2 and the question that clause 2 stand part, which with which it would be convenient to debate clause 3 stand part. The question is that clause 2 stand part of the bill. Minister.

22:55 - 25:12

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Clauses 2 and 3 of the bill tighten the eligibility criteria for right to buy further to ensure that the scheme is fair and well-targeted. Clause 2 prevents existing residential property owners from exercising the right to buy, which we believe is a reasonable and rational approach. We've set out what we think is an appropriate definition of a residential property owner in this clause. The clause will apply to anyone who owns a residential property, whether owned outright or with a mortgage.

Leasehold and freehold properties will be captured, with expectations for short-term leases under 21 years, as will joint ownership and any properties owned outside England, including those held in Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, and abroad. Exemptions will be made for victims of domestic abuse who have moved from the accommodation they were occupying for reasons connected to the abuse.

As part of the application process, tenants will be required to declare to the landlord whether they own another property, and landlords will be able to check the information the tenant provides. If tenants are seeking exceptionally to buy under the right to buy scheme where they already own a residential property because they've been victims of domestic abuse, they will also be required to provide evidence of that to the landlord. Clause 3, Mr. Vickers, prevents those who've previously exercised the right to buy from doing so again, with exceptions in place for cases of domestic abuse and irretrievable relationship breakdown. Honorable members will agree that repeat purchases would undermine the objectives of the right to buy scheme. It would lead to more social housing stock being lost than those that have already benefited from the scheme from a publicly funded discount to buy their own home.

During our consultation on reforming the right to buy, 91% of respondents stated that they would support preventing someone who has either previously benefited from the right to buy or owns another property from being able to access the scheme. The terms of the reference exceptions are set out in the clause and will be reinforced by updated guidance when the act comes into force. It will be, Mr. Vickers, for social landlords to be satisfied that the expectations apply, for which they will be able to ask for evidence, as I've said, from the applicant as part of the application process. This is something obviously councils are already well practiced at doing, as under the current rules, those who've previously exercised the right to buy have their discount reduced if they seek to exercise the right to buy again. In closing, Mr. Vickers, we think clauses 2 and 3 are fair and proportionate, designed to appropriately restrict access to the right to buy scheme, and I commend them to the committee.

25:12 - 25:45

Martin Vickers

No one is catching my eyes. The question is that clause 2 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

Clause 3 has just been debated. The question is that clause 3 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

We now come to group 3 and the question that clause 4 stand part, with which it would be convenient to debate clause 5 stand part. The question is that clause 4 stand part of the bill. I call the minister.

25:45 - 28:36

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Clause 4 of the bill concerns the statutory periods that local authorities have to consider applications under the right to buy. The clause amends sections 124 and 125 of the Housing Act 1985 by extending the periods within which landlords must serve notices, either admitting or denying a tenant's eligibility for the right to buy, that's section 124, and setting out the purchase price and other required information, that is section 125. The period under section 124 will be extended from four to eight weeks where the tenant has been a tenant of the same landlord for the qualifying period, and from eight to 12 weeks in any other case. The period under section 125 will be extended from eight to 12 weeks for freehold properties and from 12 to 16 weeks for leasehold properties.

The revised statutory periods are intended to provide additional flexibility where applications raise complexity, for example in relation to valuation issues or safeguarding concerns. Importantly, they will give landlords more time to verify eligibility based on the new criteria and support them in carrying out preliminary counter-fraud and money laundering checks. Although we're extending the time periods that landlords have to respond to the right to buy application, I want to stress that these timescales are an upper limit, not an expectation. We expect landlords to continue to process applications as quickly as they're able to do so. Turn to clause 5.

This clause inserts new section 124A into the Housing Act 1985, enabling a landlord to suspend a right to buy application where there is reason to suspect that the claim may be fraudulently made. A suspension under section 124A does not cancel the application. It temporarily pauses the statutory process while an investigation is carried out and must end no later than six months after the date of suspension, or earlier if the investigation is concluded.

In response to the consultation on reforming the right to buy, we committed to carry out more effective fraud prevention, including mitigating vulnerable tenants being pressured into buying and cracking down on third-party backed applications. We're clear, and I hope the committee will support us on this principle, that fraudulent applications backed by unscrupulous lenders have no place under the right to buy. They undermine the scheme. By ensuring that social landlords have more time to investigate suspected fraud when managing applications, the clause will help prevent fraudulent applications from slipping through the cracks and maintain the integrity of the scheme. I should say, Mr. Vickers, during the period of suspension, the procedural requirements of the act, including statutory time limits, will not apply.

This will mean that the tenant will not be able to issue delay notices during this period. Guidance will make clear that timescales for processing applications can only be extended where fraud is suspected and are not to be used by landlords as a way to delay the processing of more routine applications. We'll also strengthen guidance for landlords and tenants on fraud prevention, including on third-party companies lending money for purchases. Any such companies will need to obviously be registered with the Financial Conduct Authority, which will support both the FCA and landlords with enforcement.

28:36 - 29:06

Martin Vickers

The question is that clause four stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Clause five has just been debated.

The question is that clause five stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group four and the question that clause six stand part, with which it will be convenient to debate new clause 29.

The question is that clause six stand part of the bill. Minister.

29:06 - 30:31

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. As I've already set out, the bill's reforms aim to ensure that the right to buy scheme is sustainable, including by ensuring that discounts are set at the right level to enable long-standing tenants to buy under the scheme, but without depleting levels of social housing stock. This government has already taken action in November 2024 to reduce the maximum cash discounts, returning these to their pre-2012 levels. We subsequently committed to revise the discounts available as a percentage of the property so that these align better with the revised cash cap amounts. Clause six delivers on this commitment by reducing percentage discounts so that they start at 5% of the property value after 10 years of public sector tenancy and increase for every extra year of a tenancy up to a maximum of 15%.

As is the case now, these percentage discounts will be subject to cash caps, which set out the maximum cash discount that a tenant can receive in their area. Aligning the discounts available as a percentage of the property value with the cash caps ensures that those who have been in their homes the longest benefit the most, while also avoiding disproportionately large discounts in high-value areas. The revised percentage discount aims to strike a balance between the responses received during the right to buy consultation, where many respondents supported setting the percentage discounts lower than is proposed by this clause. We're also simplifying the rules by applying a single set of discount arrangements to both houses and flats, making the scheme clearer and more consistent for tenants. I'll give way to the minister.

30:31 - 30:51

Speaker 16

I'm very grateful. Would it be possible for the government to come forward with some kind of analysis on the impact this policy will have on the number of sales made available to tenants? I think that would be very important in establishing whether, well, the long-term impact, the economic impact on the population across the country.

30:51 - 31:37

Matthew Pennycook

I'd simply refer the honorable gentleman to the impact assessment, and if he has further detailed questions about it at a future set, I'm more than happy to answer, but we've set out our analysis as to the impact of the bill, and in particular returning to that ambition to go net positive on new social homes as a result of the changes that we're being made. I was saying in closing, Mr. Vickers, the clause also extends the discount repayment period to 10 years after the original sale from the current five years, during which a purchaser looking to resell the property will be required to repay all or some of the discount on a sliding scale. This measure was supported by 72% of all respondents to our consultation, and it will ensure that there is less incentive for early resale, which can undermine the purpose of the scheme, and will encourage people buying to retain the property and discourage profiteering.

31:37 - 32:41

Martin Vickers

The question is that clause six stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no.

I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 5 and the question that clause 29. Sorry. Yes, clause 29 was debated with clause. No it wasn't.

I wasn't asked to speak. No, we moved on. And I did read that out at the beginning. Sorry, we've moved on. We now come to group 5 and the question that clause 7 stand part.

The question is that clause 7 stand part. I wasn't called. Sorry Mr. Vickers, it didn't involve Gavin. Fine, we'll move on. We now come to group 5 and the question that clause 7 stand part.

The question is that clause 7 stand part of the bill. Minister.

32:41 - 34:04

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you Mr. Vickers. Clause 7 of the bill extends the existing right of first refusal for councils to buy back homes which have previously been sold under the right to buy when they are resold. The right of first refusal period is currently 10 years after the original sale. Councils have 8 weeks to decide whether or not to buy back the home when informed by the owner that they are planning to sell, following which the property can be sold on the open market. Under this clause, the period in which councils must be given the right of first refusal will be increased so that it applies in perpetuity.

This will mean that councils will have the opportunity to buy back the property every time it is resold. This proposal received strong support from respondents to the government's consultation. The change will only apply to applications to exercise the right to buy after the measures come into force. Homes already sold under the right to buy will be subject to the terms of the covenants attached to them when they were sold under the scheme. Giving social landlords greater opportunity to buy back properties sold under the scheme in the future increases their ability to acquire social housing that may otherwise be lost to the open market.

This directly supports the government's ambition to grow the volume of council housing in this country. In sum Mr. Vickers, clause 7 is an important safeguard that supports the effective operation of the right to buy scheme. It helps ensure that public subsidy is protected, discourages short-term purchases for financial gain and supports the bill's wider objective to protect social housing stock and I commend the clause to the committee.

34:04 - 34:41

Martin Vickers

I can see no one bobbing. No. No. Right. The question is that clause 7 stand part of the bill.

As many as that opinion say aye. To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 6 which is led by amendment 90, with which it would be convenient to debate government amendment 13, amendment 104, 83 and 9, government amendments 14 and 15, amendment 91, clause 8 stand part, government amendments 16, 17 and 18 and new clause 2. I call Gareth Bacon to move the amendment.

34:41 - 38:34

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you so much Mr. Vickers, it's a pleasure. I rise to move amendment 90 which stands in my name. Since 2024, whenever the government has raised rural issues, it's often found itself in trouble. The opposition was therefore surprised to see the elements of the government's clause 7 to give the Secretary of State the power to decide what classes as rural housing and to restrict the rights of those deemed to live in rural areas. Firstly and most apparently, it's an infringement of the property rights of swathes of residents to eliminate right to buy simply because they live in England's green and pleasant land.

And even if the government wants to tarmac all over it anyway. So what secondly, what counts as rural? For example, as many members will be aware, I'm proudly a Greater London MP with my constituency relying heavily on access to the infrastructure, employment opportunities and wider economy of the capital.

But the fact of the matter is that for around half of my constituency is agricultural, and a further 10% is green or leisure areas. Despite this, there are areas of social need. Without knowledge of the ground, somebody sitting in Whitehall is highly likely to make the wrong decision. This, I assure the Minister, will be an unwelcome and unfair overstretch of the state. In restricting sales to rural areas, the government is denying local authorities the proceeds of the sale, which could be distributed to local authorities for distribution to higher demand or more pressured areas of need.

Local leaders will always be in a better position to judge local need than a civil servant or a Secretary of State tucked away in Marsham Street. And that's why I urge members to support amendment 90 and push the government to back down from this nonsensical plan to intervene in the property rights of rural constituents. Mr. Vickers, would you like me to move to the other amendments under my name? Okay, amendment 83. This bill is an exercise in ideology over aspiration.

It represents the worst of a 40-year-long socialistic, terrible obsession with Margaret Thatcher's decision to make the dream of home ownership a reality for as many people as possible. The bill acts on this by making provision for a plethora of punitive policies designed to effectively end right to buy for as many people as possible. One of these is the move to ban the sale of newly built social housing under right to buy for 35 years. This is an arbitrarily long period of time designed to complicate and convolute the process. That is the opposite of supporting aspiration, Mr. Vickers, that is crushing aspiration.

And that is why I've tabled amendment 33, which seeks to reduce the period during which newly built social housing is exempt from right to buy from 35 years to 10 years. We do have to keep in mind the practicalities of right to buy, and we agree that it mustn't be the case that once a social home is built, it is all too often sold. We believe, however, that a decade is a much more sensible balance between maintaining stock and supporting the right of those most in need to gain a footing on the property ladder. With regards to amendment 91, the worrying trend towards centralization exercised by this government must be challenged at all levels. In discussing my previous amendment, amendment 90, I've already given good reasons as to why the Secretary of State is not adequately equipped to judge what is or is not rural.

The opposition, however, believes that there is also an important constitutional point to be made. It should always be the case that Parliament fully and adequately scrutinizes the work of government, especially when that work is increasingly brought in behind closed doors of unelected civil servants. And that's why I've tabled amendment 91. This would require an affirmative parliamentary approval for regulations defining rural exemptions to the right to buy. Every honorable member present should support greater parliamentary oversight of lasting and binding policy that the government is trying to take out of our hands and away from the scrutinizing eyes of parliamentarians, and I hope therefore that members will join me in supporting amendment 91.

38:34 - 39:19

Lee Dillon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers, a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I rise to speak on my own amendment 104, but also to the member for West Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly amendment number 9. Can I just start by agreeing with the opposition that amendment 104 that I tabled was to try to seek clarity from the government around how a rural area was going to be designated. I welcome the amendments brought forward by the government since the publication of the bill, which now hands more power to local authorities to be able to determine that area. But the amendment 104 was trying to give some certainty around what classification could be used in that determination.

39:19 - 40:08

Speaker 20

So I wonder if the minister would be able to reassure us that where he also has power to set regulations for a rural area, what decision-making process would he use to come up with that designation. And then if I can move on to amendment number 9. As a party, we clearly believe that social housing is a crucial element to a settled society, and protecting that stock is a must, which is why we support the overall objectives of the bill.

But we do seek to go further than the government has currently legislated for by making sure that also community-led housing is included in that exclusion of being lost back to the private market. And that is why my honorable friend, the member for West Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, has tabled amendment nine. Thank you.

40:08 - 40:51

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise to speak to our Liberal Democrat members' new clause two, which would provide local authorities with the power to suspend right to buy in their area completely, bringing it to an end. Perhaps for the first and last time, I'll agree with the honorable member for Workington in something he said completely and wholeheartedly, which is that local areas are best placed to decide what is right for them in terms of council housing provision and council housing stock. Absolutely 100%, Mr. Vickers. That's why we would give local authorities the ability to say that they have lost enough council housing.

40:51 - 41:13

Speaker 22

Two million council homes lost to right to buy, four million social homes lost altogether. Enough is enough, Mr. Vickers. And local communities in the moment, local communities should have the right to be able to decide whether to continue to see the loss of council homes in their area.

41:13 - 41:31

Speaker 16

I'd just be remiss not to say at this moment, when you talk about council houses being lost to right to buy, they are being gained by tenants who own a property, part of a property-owning democracy that we hold dear in this country.

41:31 - 42:09

Gideon Amos

The fact is, Mr. Vickers, if we have a system where four million homes have been lost and 1.3 million people are on the council waiting list, something has gone radically wrong. And we need a different approach. The honorable gentleman is saying from a sedentary position he wants me to give way again, but I haven't yet answered his initial premise, which is that, yes, indeed, we need to find ways to help people into home ownership. That is vital and fundamental to a thriving society. We need to therefore build more homes, we need to provide more and better shared ownership arrangements, which are not working, we need to help people onto the housing ladder.

42:09 - 42:16

Speaker 21

That does not mean we need to erode and diminish our social housing stock.

42:16 - 42:35

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I'll give way to the other side. I'm grateful to the honorable member for giving way. Is he aware of the research that shows up to 40% of homes bought under the right to buy have actually ended up in the hands of private landlords? So, in fact, if we're looking to help people into long-term housing, this is not the solution.

42:35 - 42:55

Gideon Amos

The honorable member is quite right, and local authorities end up paying, not only that, local authorities end up paying over the odds for placing families in temporary accommodation, sometimes in homes that were built as council houses to provide for those families in the first place, now they are being sublet, sometimes multiple times, to provide that housing. I will give way to the honorable member for Workington.

42:55 - 44:01

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you. I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman, he's being very generous. A point he has made, which is being made across the House today and was made at second reading, is the belief that right to buy diminishes the social housing stock. And I would agree on paper it does do that. But that has to be read in the context that, and the House of Lords library has shown this, right to buy only applies to people in long-term tenancies who have been social tenants for a long time.

78% of people living in social housing are on lifetime tenancies. These properties are not available. They could not be given to anybody else because they're lifetime tenancies. So right to buy is actually providing the receipts to build more social homes, more homes for people to live in. It doesn't help one bit.

It doesn't help one bit. It does not help one bit by stopping people from getting onto the housing ladder because it does not increase the supply. And this is the point that seems to be failed, seems to be missed completely by the Liberal Democrats and by the government.

44:01 - 45:21

Gideon Amos

I'm grateful to the spokesperson. I'm somewhat surprised he's entering into the realms of supply of social housing given the record of the previous Conservative government. Of course we need to increase supply as well as saving the stock that's been built with public funds, with taxpayers' money, for the community, rather than giving it over at discounts, sometimes to the extent of 70 or 80,000 pounds transfer of cash from the public sector, from the taxpayer, into the hands of individual property owners for no particular good reason. We need to increase supply. That's why Liberal Democrats have a target to build 150,000 social rent homes per year.

I don't know what the honourable gentleman's party's target is for the delivery of social housing. They didn't build very many when they were in government. With that, Minister, I conclude that we need to give local authorities the power and the flexibility to decide for themselves whether it's right in their area to continue with the right to buy or not. And the power, if we believe in local communities and local democracy, we should give them the ability to say that right to buy and the loss of more council housing stock is no longer right for their area. And I submit new clause 2 to the committee and I urge all members of the committee to vote for it when it comes to the vote.

45:21 - 52:47

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Viggers. I will speak to clause 8 and amendments 13 to 18 in my name and then I'll turn to various amendments that have been tabled and just spoken to. Clause 8 amends schedule 5 to the Housing Act 1985 to introduce new and updated exceptions to the right to buy. Under the scheme, exceptions already include homes suitable for occupation by the elderly, sheltered housing and homes due to be demolished. 76% of respondents to our consultation agreed that the existing exceptions should be retained and we are doing so.

This clause does, however, make a small change to amend outdated terminology in the current exemption for dwellings for persons of pensionable age to update the reference to resident or non-resident wardens to resident or non-resident managers. But clause 8 introduces three new exceptions. First, it exempts newly built social homes from the scheme for 35 years, giving councils the confidence to invest in new supply. At present, councils are disincentivised from building because homes can be sold before costs are recovered through rent, undermining housing revenue accounts. A 35-year exemption period reflects the typical payback period and ensures councils are not losing new homes prematurely.

This is a significant supply-side reform, despite what the shadow minister continues to assert, that helps to deliver the government's commitment to back councils to build at a scale not seen in decades. Councils have been clear to the government that the risk of early sale deters investment. Removing that risk provides greater certainty over stock and income and supports new development. We recognise the frustration of seeing newly built homes sold so quickly before they can meet local need. The government's manifesto committed to better protecting newly built social housing from the right to buy and introducing an exemption was supported by the vast majority of respondents to our consultation on the basis it will give councils, as I've said, greater confidence to build new homes and provide greater protection than the existing cost floor rules.

Second, Mr. Viggers, clause 8 exempts homes in national parks, areas of outstanding natural beauty and designated rural areas from the right to buy. This recognises the particular pressures on rural housing, where land and planning constraints mean that homes are significantly harder to replace once lost from the social sector.

In many cases, replacement is not feasible at all, exacerbating already acute shortages in those areas. There was clear recognition of these challenges in the other place, where the difficulty of replacing rural homes and the importance of protecting stock in these areas was highlighted. This measure responds directly to those concerns and will help safeguard rural social housing. Existing rural designations will continue to have effect for the purpose of this exemption until we implement the new framework for local authorities to self-designate as rural, as set out in government amendments 13 to 18, which I'll come to shortly, as well as clause 8. The covenants attached to homes which have been sold under the right to buy in rural areas, which restrict sale to a local person or a social landlord, would also continue to apply.

And third and finally, Mr. Vickers, council-owned market rent homes would also be excluded, supporting councils to use mixed tenure and cross-subsidy models to deliver more housing. This recognizes the important role that market rent homes can play in enabling councils to generate additional income to reinvest in social and affordable homes. These changes are part of the wider package of reforms to ensure more homes are built than lost. And I beg to move government amendments 13 to 18. These amendments deliver on commitments made during the bill's passage in the other place to put the criteria for rural designation into regulations.

This was a call that came from noble peers on the opposition benches. The regulations will use the long-established criteria of a population density of no more than two persons per hectare and a population of 3,000 or fewer. These criteria will be applied using census-derived population data, and local authorities will be expected to ensure the criteria continue to be met in relevant areas every 10 years as new census data becomes available. It was also agreed in the other place that the government would explore whether the existing process under which local authorities need to apply to the government for designation could be replaced with a new system under which local authorities would be able to self-designate rural areas where they meet the criteria. I can confirm that we do intend to implement that change, and these amendments will enable that.

These changes will provide transparency on the criteria for rural designation. They'll also empower local areas and reduce bureaucracy for both local authorities and the government compared to the current process, which requires, as I've said, local authorities seeking designation to apply to the Secretary of State and for secondary legislation to be made for each individual designation. Local authorities will be required to publicize the making of a designation and ensure that the information on the areas covered is available to tenants. If an authority revokes a designation, it must also publicize that revocation. The regulations will be made by statutory instrument and will be subject to the negative procedure.

Once the new framework of self-designation is in force, the existing rural designations will fall away. There'll be a transition period following Royal Assent until the date upon which the new framework comes into effect, where the existing rural designations will continue to apply for the purpose of determining which rural homes will be exempt from the right to buy. This will ensure there's no gap in protection. The government currently intends the transition period to last at least 12 months, with the final duration to be confirmed in due course. Within this transition period, councils will be able to undertake the necessary work to self-designate ahead of the new framework being implemented.

We also intend, Mr. Vickers, to align the rural designation framework for the right to acquire scheme with the new right to buy framework. These amendments, taken together with clause 9, which we'll come to shortly, establish a clearer framework for protecting social housing in designated rural areas while reducing bureaucracy and giving local authorities the responsibility for making and publicizing designations within national parameters. I now turn to the various opposition amendments that have been tabled in this group, and I'm afraid I cannot support any of them. I want to start with amendment 90, tabled by the honorable member for Orpington. This would remove from clause 8 the new exemption from the right to buy for social housing located in national parks, national landscapes, and designated rural areas.

I've got to say I'm quite surprised that this amendment has come from the opposition, given the calls I often get from members on the opposite benches to ensure that stock in their areas is better protected.

I've already set out that rural areas face particular housing pressures. Rural social homes are often very difficult to replace and play an important role in supporting thriving local communities. Clause 8 provides an important protection for rural social housing and it's been supported by rural groups. Amendment 90 would remove this protection and increase the risk of losing scarce social homes in places where the replacement is particularly challenging. For those reasons I cannot support it.

Turn now to amendment 104 also tabled by the shadow minister. This amendment would require the government to use the urban rural classification system when determining whether an area is rural or urban for the purposes of the designated... Sorry, my apologies, my apologies. In the name of the in the name of the Liberal Democrats. As I said Mr Vickers, this would require the government to use the urban rural classification scheme system when determining whether an area is rural or urban for the purposes of the designated rural area exemption.

As I've already made clear our intention is to continue with the long established criteria for rural designation. The areas will need to have a population of 3,000 people or fewer and a population density of two persons or less per hectare. And we intend to set that criteria out in regulations. In our view that strikes the right balance in relation to defining rural designated areas and exclusion from the right to buy. Including areas with a population of 10,000 or fewer would in our view bring far too many areas into the scope of the exclusion.

For those reasons I won't be able to take back and see the honourable gentleman.

52:47 - 53:06

Lee Dillon

I'm grateful for giving way and for for talking to amendment 104. I think with the government amendment 13 and the commitments that we've just had from the front bench that I would be happy when we go to a vote not to push 104 to a vote.

53:06 - 57:23

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you Mr Vickers, I welcome that clarification from the honourable gentleman. Turning to amendment 91, this would require regulations made under section 37 of the Housing Act 1985 which allows for restrictions to be imposed in relation to the disposal of a home in a rural area to be approved by both houses before they could come into force. I understand the intention of this amendment may have been to require the affirmative procedure to apply for areas to be designated as rural for the purposes of right to buy. Under self-designation rural areas will be designated by local authorities instead of by regulations so no parliamentary procedure will need to be provided for. The new power to prescribe the criteria will be as I've said subject to the negative resolution.

In any event the government does not accept the premise that the affirmative procedure is required in this instance. There may be a principled point of disagreement on that. The current powers are subject to the negative procedure. That is the existing arrangement and that provides an appropriate and proportionate level of parliamentary scrutiny in our view. The powers either amended under or created by the bill also have the negative resolution procedure.

Requiring the affirmative procedure would add an additional parliamentary step without affecting the substance or effect of the policy. And for those reasons respectfully ask the shadow minister not to press amendment 91. Turning to amendment 83, this amendment would reduce the exemption from the right to buy for newly built social homes from 35 to 10 years. The government cannot support this amendment. Our starting point is that the exemption should reflect the time needed for rental income to repay the cost of building a new social home.

That payback period is generally between 30 and 50 years depending on the viability of the site. We therefore concluded that 35 years strikes the right balance. It protects councils from losing newly built homes before they've recovered their investment while retaining a route to home ownership for tenants over the longer term. Reducing the exemption to 10 years would not provide sufficient protection and would act in direct contradiction to our commitment to back councils to build again at scale. It would allow homes to be sold long before their development costs have been recovered.

A 35 year exemption will give councils the certainty and confidence to build knowing that new homes will remain available as social housing for a meaningful period. And I think I turn finally oh no there's two more in this very large grouping. I turn next to new clause 2 stands in the name of the member for Taunton and Wellington. I do recognise the concerns that have motivated this proposed new clause.

However, the government can't support a proposal that would allow individual local authorities to suspend or abolish the right to buy in their area. We remain committed to a reformed right to buy that continues to provide long-standing council tenants with a route to home ownership while better protecting social housing stock, and we are reforming the scheme nationally to strike that balance. This new clause would create inconsistent access to that statutory right, with a tenant's position depending on the local authority in which they live. This would, in effect, Mr. Vickers, create a postcode lottery and make it difficult for tenants to understand whether or not the right to buy is available to them. We believe the right approach is a consistent national framework supported by national reforms that better protect council housing stock.

That will ensure a fair and consistent offer for council tenants across the country. We also recognize that housing markets vary significantly across England. However, rather than creating different rights in different areas, as I've said, the government's reforms reflect those differences through the discount regime. Discounts are calculated, as I've already set out, as a percentage of a property's value and are subject to regional cash caps, helping to ensure the scheme responds to local property market conditions while maintaining a fair and consistent national entitlement for eligible tenants. And finally, Mr. Vickers, moving on to amendment 91, tabled by the member for St. Ives, but the Liberal Democrat members on the committee have spoken to it.

Again, I recognize the intention behind this amendment. Community-led housing is established to meet local needs and often includes arrangements intended to protect affordability for the long term. This government has done a huge amount in this area; there is more to come to better support community-led housing. But in our view, the amendment is not necessary in relation to the principal form of community-led housing it identifies. Homes owned by community land trusts and fully mutual housing cooperatives are already outside of the right to buy, and for those reasons, the amendment would not provide the protection intended beyond that which already exists.

And for those reasons, I ask the committee to respectfully withdraw all of those amendments, and I commend clause 8 to the committee.

57:23 - 57:27

Speaker 23

Gareth Bacon. Do you wish to sum up?

57:27 - 58:21

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Only to say, Mr. Vickers, that we do not share the government's position on this. On amendment, forgive me, let me just get the note out. 90, we believe that, yes, we just don't accept the government's position on this, and we will be pressing for a division when the time comes. On amendment 83, I understand the point that the minister has made about recouping the cost. However, we do believe that that is a convenience for local authorities, not for local people, and we're more interested in local people.

So, no, I won't, sorry, I'm summing up. So, we are going to press for a division on that because we think that 10 years is more appropriate than 35. And on amendment 91, we also disagree with the government. We think it should be a positive procedure rather than, sorry, an affirmative rather than a negative procedure for this, so we will be pressing that to a division as well.

58:21 - 58:32

Martin Vickers

Amendment 90 proposed to clause 8 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Those in favor say aye. To the contrary, no. Division.

58:32 - 59:06

Speaker 25

Lock the doors. Gideon Amos. No. Edward Argar. Aye.

Gareth Bacon. Aye. Danny Beales. No. Rachel Blake.

No. Serena Breckenridge. No. Neil Coyle. Aye.

59:06 - 59:21

Speaker 24

Deirdre Costigan. No. Lee Dillon. No. Mary Kelly Foy.

No. Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger. No.

Patrick Spencer. Aye. Lawrence Turner. No. Steve Yemm.

59:21 - 59:50

Martin Vickers

No. The ayes were 4 and the noes 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. Government amendment 13 to clause 8 was just debated.

I call the Minister to move the amendment formally.

59:50 - 59:51

Move formally.

59:51 - 59:56

Martin Vickers

The question is that Government amendment 13 be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

59:56 - 01:00:51

Martin Vickers

To the contrary No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. I understand that amendment 104 is withdrawn. Amendment 104 withdrawn. Amendment 83 to clause 8 was just debated in group six.

If Gareth Bacon or any other member wish to indicate to press amendment to a division.

01:00:51 - 01:00:52

Yes, Chair, we'd like to divide.

01:00:52 - 01:01:02

Martin Vickers

The question is that amendment 83 proposed to clause 8 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

01:01:03 - 01:01:04

To the contrary No.

01:01:04 - 01:01:06

Speaker 26

No.

01:01:06 - 01:01:23

Speaker 30

Division. Lock the doors.

01:01:24 - 01:01:25

Edward Argar.

01:01:25 - 01:01:26

Gareth Bacon.

01:01:26 - 01:01:27

Danny Beales.

01:01:27 - 01:01:28

Rachel Blake.

01:01:28 - 01:01:29

Serena Breckenridge.

01:01:29 - 01:01:30

Lewis Cocking.

01:01:30 - 01:01:31

Deirdre Costigan.

01:01:32 - 01:01:33

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:01:33 - 01:01:34

Matthew Pennycook.

01:01:34 - 01:01:35

John Slinger.

01:01:35 - 01:01:36

Patrick Spencer.

01:01:36 - 01:01:37

Lawrence Turner.

01:01:38 - 01:02:06

Speaker 24

No.

01:02:06 - 01:02:41

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were four and the Noes 11, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. We now come to amendment nine which was just debated. Amendment nine was tabled by Andrew George who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to formally move the amendment or put it to a division? No, amendment nine is withdrawn.

Government amendments 14, 15 to clause 8 have just been debated. With the leave of the committee, I will put a single question on these amendments. I call the Minister to move amendments 14 and 15 formally.

01:02:41 - 01:02:42

Move formally.

01:02:42 - 01:02:47

Martin Vickers

The question is that Government amendments 14 and 15 to clause 8 be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

01:02:48 - 01:02:57

Martin Vickers

To the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Amendment 91 to clause 8 was just debated in group six. Do you wish to push this to the vote?

01:02:58 - 01:03:07

Martin Vickers

Amendment 91 proposed to clause 8 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

01:03:08 - 01:03:09

To the contrary No.

01:03:10 - 01:03:23

Speaker 29

Division. Lock the doors.

01:03:24 - 01:03:25

Edward Argar.

01:03:25 - 01:03:26

Gareth Bacon.

01:03:26 - 01:03:27

Danny Beales.

01:03:27 - 01:03:28

Rachel Blake.

01:03:28 - 01:03:29

Serena Breckenridge.

01:03:29 - 01:03:30

Lewis Cocking.

01:03:30 - 01:03:31

Deirdre Costigan.

01:03:40 - 01:04:02

Speaker 24

Mary Kelly Foy? No. Matthew Pennycook? No. John Slinger?

No. Patrick Spencer? Aye. Laurence Turner? No.

Steve Yemm? No.

01:04:02 - 01:04:26

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four and the noes eleven, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Clause eight as amended has just been debated. The question is that clause eight as amended stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no.

I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Government amendment sixteen to clause nine was just debated. I call the minister to move the amendment formally.

01:04:27 - 01:04:46

Martin Vickers

The question is that government amendment sixteen be made. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group seven and the question that clause nine as amended stand part.

The question is that clause nine as amended stand part of the bill. I call the minister.

01:04:46 - 01:05:56

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. This is a simple and straightforward clause that ensures that the reforms to the right to buy are applied fairly and consistently. It protects tenants who've already made a valid application by ensuring that applications received by landlords ahead of the reforms coming into force will continue to be subject to the existing rules. This avoids retrospective changes that could disadvantage applicants partway through the process. The clause also makes important provision in relation to rural exemptions, which links directly to the reforms in clause eight and government amendments thirteen to eighteen, which we've just discussed in the previous grouping.

Clause nine provides that existing rural designations will continue to have effect after commencement, as if they were made under the new powers introduced by clause eight. This means there is no gap in protection for rural areas while the new framework in which local authorities self-designate as rural is implemented. Together these provisions ensure a smooth and legally certain transition, protecting both tenants' rights and the integrity of rural housing protections. Overall, Mr. Vickers, the clause provides legal clarity, fairness and continuity as the reformed right to buy scheme is introduced, and I commend it to the committee.

01:05:56 - 01:06:27

Martin Vickers

The question is that... oh, sorry, any other speakers? I'm raising hand. Right. The question is that clause nine as amended stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye.

To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group eight, which is led by amendment ninety-two proposed to clause ten, with which it would be convenient to debate amendments ninety-three, ninety-four, ninety-six, ninety-seven, ninety-five and ninety-eight and clause ten stand part. I call Gareth Bacon to move amendment ninety-two.

01:06:27 - 01:08:46

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise... I'll do them collectively, amendments ninety-two, three, four, five, six, seven and eight, which stand in my name. These amendments are concerned with the bill's proposals for the governance of capital receipts. Under clause ten of the government's bill, the Secretary of State would gain new powers to make significant determinations. This includes scope to vary provisions between local authorities and to apply determinations retrospectively.

Much like my concern about deciding the definition and scope of rural, this is not about firming up an already overly rigid system, but about ensuring that the bill does not tear away too much power from parliament and give it to Whitehall. It is only right that parliament and not unelected civil servants should decide the criteria for the allocation of capital receipts, and that's why I've tabled these amendments so that a regulatory framework can be established to provide parliamentary oversight and to give confidence and certainty to local authorities. I believe this is an essential change to this bill and we will be seeking to divide upon all of these amendments. As it stands, leaving determinations to the whim of the Secretary of State means leaving local leaders unsure of the direction of future decisions. It undermines precedent and destabilises already fragile funding requirements.

These amendments replace the proposed determinations with clear and unequivocal guidance, with amendment ninety-five specifically ensuring that such decisions come with the approval of both houses of parliament. Amendment ninety-eight doubles down on this by also requiring consultation with local authorities.

I believe that the Minister will believe that bringing such decisions in-house comes with the bonus of speeding them up. We believe that making decisions in Marsham Street's corridors rather than in town halls means that local authorities are left with uncertainty that does not speed up the building of social homes, but slows it down. Moreover, nothing would be a greater barrier to building social homes than watching receipts being siphoned away. Under the current provision in clause 10, the ability to reallocate capital receipts between local authorities will always lead to some councils losing out. And this is never going to be popular with councils when they find that after running the numbers, planning the funding, consulting local people and preparing the foundations, the Secretary of State has robbed them of their funding and given it to another council.

It sounds suspiciously similar to the injustice arriving from the government's disastrously unfair funding review. And I therefore urge colleagues to support amendments 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98 to ensure that power stays local.

01:08:46 - 01:11:03

Edward John Argar

Thank you very much, Mr. Vickers. And I rise to support the amendments tabled in the name of my honorable friend the Shadow Minister, 92, 93, 94 and 96. I'll turn to, and 97. I'll turn to 95 and 98 in a moment. I mean, I have to say, these appear to be perfectly reasonable and proportionate requests and amendments, that this House has a role in scrutinizing what is put forward by the government and what is recommended by the Secretary of State.

I spent six years as a minister. I took countless statutory instruments through DL committees. By and large, it isn't a complex process. It requires, does require a little bit of time by officials to draft it and get the drafting right. But the process in this House is not a complicated one.

And what it does do is ensure that a minister is directly accountable. They have to be on their brief. They have to be able to articulate clearly the rationale behind what they're doing and quite rightly be challenged by honorable and right honorable members in those delegated legislation committees. That is what is so important, I think, in maintaining or even creating trust from our communities through the transparency that democratic accountability brings to what, as my honorable friend has set out very clearly, will undoubtedly on occasions be relatively, if not significantly, contentious decisions relating to significant sums of money. And turning very briefly, Mr. Vickers, to amendments 95 and then 98.

In terms of amendment 95, my honorable friend has again set out the case for this very clearly. These powers, when exercised, may well see some local authorities feeling they are losing out to the benefit of other local authorities. Therefore, again, I don't think it is unreasonable, without getting into what those decisions may be, where money may or may not go, just in terms of process and democratic accountability, that both Houses should have the opportunity in the context of clause 10 powers to scrutinize. And finally, turning to... Yeah, of course I'll give way to the honorable lady.

01:11:03 - 01:11:37

Speaker 34

I'm, I'm listening with interest to these remarks. I have some professional experience in this area. It seems to me that these amendments are more about delaying what is a reasonable approach for the government to administer right-to-buy receipts. I'm interested to know whether the opposition thinks what the alternative to any kind of movement of right-to-buy receipts between local authorities would be.

Do they think it would be entirely acceptable for right to buy receipts not to be reinvested in council homes?

01:11:37 - 01:13:43

Edward John Argar

I'm grateful to the honorable lady, but she appears to be making a point that was not actually the point I was making in my remarks, which is a point about the process here. As I just said before she sought to intervene, I'm not making in my remarks here a judgment on the decisions the Secretary of State may or may not make about those capital receipts. What I am making a point about is democratic accountability and transparency. And I have to say that the delegated legislation procedure in this house, by and large, and going back to those earlier group of amendments proposed by my honorable friend, the procedure that's used when they come before delegated legislation committees in this house is not complex. It doesn't engender a lengthy delay.

It just ensures that people out there, our constituents, can see that we are considering it, that we're debating it, that the minister can answer the questions put to him. I have no doubt in the case of this minister he will be able to answer the questions put to him. Sadly, on both sides of the house, it's not always the case that every minister's capable of doing that. I'm sure he would have no challenges in coming before a delegated legislation committee and answering the questions put to him. And just very briefly, Mr. Vickers, turning finally to amendment 98 in the name of my honorable friend, the shadow minister and of the opposition whip, in terms of its call or its requirement for consultation before determinations are made on capital receipts.

Again, consultations do not have to be overly complex. They don't have to be lengthy. If you go on gov.uk at the moment, you'll see at any one time there are a myriad of government consultations out there on very, very significant issues down to issues such as, for example, the methodology used for the reporting of land use statistics in the country. All these sort of things. So the government routinely consults on a whole range of things, whether that be a significant, if I'll finish this point, then of course I'll give way to him, whether that be a significant, detailed, lengthy consultation on something that's complex or often a very short and sharp consultation, but giving people the opportunity both to have their say and for those who have something genuine in the way of expert knowledge to contribute.

01:13:43 - 01:13:45

Speaker 31

Of course I give way.

01:13:45 - 01:14:07

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I'm grateful for the honorable member for giving way. In relation to amendment 98 and the consultation, I wonder if the honorable member in the opposition have considered if a local authority had felt that they hadn't been consulted, if that would then open up legal routes to delay the allocation of capital financing and therefore slow down growth or house building.

01:14:07 - 01:15:11

Edward John Argar

Well, I think as I again found over many years, consultation done properly leaves very limited legal risk. It's where government gets it wrong, and I don't want to overly speculate on what has happened with the government's consultations and process around local government reorganization, but where they get it wrong, he is right, there is a potential there for JRs, although I would highlight that a judicial review can only focus of course on process, not on whether or not the decision should be relitigated. But I think if done well, and consultations on this I would have thought should be fairly simple, I believe they can enhance that transparency that is important in terms of bringing our constituents with us and ensuring that government is directly accountable to honorable and right honorable members in this house. When the legislation is brought forward under our amendments as a regulation, that consultation is there to be drawn on. And I genuinely believe, and I've seen it for myself, when a government is willing to listen to a consultation response, it can often, if it does it openly, come up with a slightly better or tweaked outcome.

01:15:11 - 01:15:13

Speaker 32

Of course I'll give way to the honorable member.

01:15:13 - 01:16:03

Danny Beales

I thank you for giving way, it's very generous of his time. My experience is local government, local councils are seeking to deliver new council homes. They've been calling for right to buy receipt reform for a long time.

The previous government had an overly restrictive approach to right-to-buy receipts. You were only allowed to keep a third of them for three years, and if you couldn't spend it within that time period, return it to the Treasury with interest. Many decided not as a result to take their receipts at all. So it would seem quite sensible to me not to tie up councils who are trying to build, which is quite a complicated and time-consuming process, new homes, to tie them up in consultations and discussions, but to give the Secretary of State the flexibility to work with local authorities, to give them more receipts, to increase the time period of receipts, or to reallocate them to schemes and to councils that can build within an acceptable time period. Does he not agree with that?

01:16:03 - 01:17:13

Edward John Argar

Well, I thank the honorable gentleman for the point, but again he makes the same point in a sense as the honorable lady for Cities of London and Westminster made earlier, which is not on what I'm speaking about, which is about the process. And I don't believe a consultation would tie them up in knots, delay it inordinately, or indeed that bringing these changes in through regulations rather than by diktat of the Secretary of State would cause unnecessary delay. This is about transparency and accountability. We've done it before in government. This government has done it with regulations.

I've sat on a number of DLs. I maybe I've upset the whips at some point now I've, you know, I sit on a DL almost every week while I'm not sitting on a bill committee, such is the fate of a former cabinet minister on the back benches. But the point I make is this government and other governments have used delegated legislation systems to get things through quickly, but nonetheless with that democratic accountability to this House. And that is the point made by my honorable friend in these amendments. It's about giving our constituents the confidence to trust this House has debated what the Secretary of State recommends, and knowing the majority at the moment, I have no doubt that the minister would probably easily win any votes he did bring to a DL committee on matters such as this.

But very briefly, and then I will sit.

01:17:13 - 01:17:35

Speaker 34

I'm not sure I'll go at the really delving into the process point, although I do think this is simply a delaying amendment from the opposition, but I will engage on the on the principle of the of the process point. What is it about a determination which would be could be open to, I believe, written questions or oral questions that the opposition doesn't think is transparent and democratically accountable?

01:17:35 - 01:18:17

Edward John Argar

For the very simple reason that there would be no vote on it by members of this House, whether in a committee, which is of course a subset of the House. We can debate things, we can raise things. And I have a lot of time for the honorable lady. I spent almost ten years sitting on her local council before I was elected to this place, and I and I follow therefore closely still Westminster politics. And I do know that she is a hardworking and very diligent member who engages with all these sort of issues particularly closely.

But that's the simple answer to the question, which is that members would not have a vote on the Secretary of State's determination. So with that, Mr. Vickers, if I may, I will conclude in just once again reiterating my support for the intent behind my honorable friend's amendment.

01:18:17 - 01:23:02

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Can I say to honorable members, I have never found the process of delegated legislation committees particularly fast in any instance. But I do recognize the reasonable concerns that have been put. I think they are unfounded and I hope to reassure honorable members for the reasons I'll set out. Clause 10, Mr. Vickers, simplifies and modernizes how the rules on right-to-buy receipts are managed.

Its intent is to improve administrative efficiency and provide flexibility. And I think it's important in understanding our purpose behind this clause to have a very accurate view of the current arrangements. As things stand, every stockholding authority currently has an agreement with the Secretary of State allowing it to retain all its net right-to-buy receipts, provided it spends those receipts on replacement social housing. In practice, this is hugely administratively burdensome. There are over 160 stockholding local authorities, all of whom must be issued with identical section 11 subsection 6 retention agreements whenever the rules change.

This requires issuing, tracking, and chasing agreements for signature across every one of those authorities, creating unnecessary bureaucracy for both councils and central government. Clause 10 replaces this with a simpler approach. It provides the Secretary of State with a power to disapply or modify the requirements on the use of receipts set out in regulations by determination, which will then apply consistently across all local authorities. This removes the need to replicate the same agreement process many times over. Now concerns were raised in the other place that we may be seeking to use this clause to require councils to start repaying a portion of their receipts to the Treasury.

Let me reassure you that is absolutely not the case. We fought very hard to ensure that local authorities can retain 100% of their receipts. Previous government you'll recall made that change, but it only temporarily made that change, reversing it before the last election. We've committed to allow councils to retain all of their right to buy receipts indefinitely. To further reassure on this point, clause 10 makes clear that the power of determination may not be used to increase the amount that local authorities are required to pay the Secretary of State.

The rules on the pooling of right to buy receipts will continue to be governed by the regulations, and any significant changes to those rules would continue to need to be made through a statutory instrument, which would be subject to the negative procedure. I commend the clause to the committee. Let me just respond to amendments 92 to 98 tabled by the shadow minister, and specifically the concerns that were raised by the right honorable gentleman, the member for Melton and Syston, who is a, how do I put this as be as generous as possible without embarrassing, an incredibly competent and well-respected minister. I take very seriously the points that he made. But these amendments would replace the power in clause 10 for the Secretary of State to make determinations on right to buy receipts with a requirement to use regulations subject to the affirmative procedure, and would require consultation with local authorities before a determination is in place.

We can't support these amendments because they would reduce the ability of the government to act quickly to support local authorities. I'll give an example of some of the changes made in July 2024, just three weeks after the general election. The government gave local authorities greater flexibility to spend their right to buy receipts. This included permitting receipts to be combined with section 106 contributions and removing the cap on the proportion of replacement homes that can be funded by the right to buy receipts, accelerating the delivery of new social and affordable homes. Those changes were I think almost universally welcomed amongst local authorities, but we had to go through the current process as I've said, administratively burdensome and complex.

The proposed amendments would introduce delay and complexity, would make it harder to respond to operational needs or make technical adjustments promptly in the way that we are seeking. They'd also remove the ability to make different provision for different authorities or purposes, or to apply a determination to receipts received before it was made. As I've already set out, the safeguards in clause 10 are clear. The determination power cannot be used to increase the amount that local authorities are required to pay to the Secretary of State. The core rules governing the pooling of right to buy receipts will continue as I've said to be set in regulations.

Any significant changes to those rules will therefore require a statutory instrument subject to the negative procedure and parliamentary scrutiny, in addition to all the other mechanisms that are available to honorable members. We think for these reasons that the current approach strikes the right balance between flexibility and oversight. It reduces unnecessary administrative burdens. Opposition are always telling me to reduce bureaucracy and red tape. Here's a good example of where we're doing it, but also improve responsiveness in support councils deliver more replacement homes.

And for those reasons we can't support these amendments. I ask the shadow minister withdraw them and also commend clause 10 to the committee.

01:23:02 - 01:23:36

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you Mr. Vickers. The minister has said that his intent is to improve efficiency and as always I respect his sincerity in what he says. It's simply a point of difference between us. My right honorable friend the member for Melton and Syston made a compelling case about the democratic accountability and transparency of the affirmative procedure as opposed to the negative procedure. The point that we've made in these amendments is about the process, not the outcome, and our contention is that the process should be as democratically accountable and as transparent as possible, and we will therefore be pressing all of these amendments to a vote.

01:23:36 - 01:23:51

Martin Vickers

Amendment 92 proposed to clause 10 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Amendment 92. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:23:52 - 01:23:53

To the contrary, no.

01:23:54 - 01:24:13

Speaker 43

Division.

01:24:15 - 01:24:16

Edward Argar.

01:24:17 - 01:24:18

Gareth Bacon.

01:24:19 - 01:24:20

Danny Beales.

01:24:21 - 01:24:22

Rachel Blake.

01:24:23 - 01:24:24

Serena Brackenridge.

01:24:25 - 01:24:26

Lewis Cocking.

01:24:27 - 01:24:28

Deirdre Costigan.

01:24:31 - 01:24:32

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:24:33 - 01:24:34

Matthew Pennycook.

01:24:35 - 01:24:36

John Slinger.

01:24:37 - 01:24:38

Patrick Spencer.

01:24:39 - 01:24:40

Laurence Turner.

01:24:42 - 01:24:55

Speaker 44

No.

01:24:55 - 01:25:15

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four and the noes were 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendments 93, 94, 96, 97, 95 and 98 to clause 10 were just debated in group eight. Do you wish to move amendments formally?

01:25:15 - 01:25:16

Move formally, Chair.

01:25:16 - 01:25:34

Martin Vickers

Amendment 93. Amendment 93 proposed to clause 10 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:25:35 - 01:25:36

To the contrary, no.

01:25:37 - 01:25:43

Speaker 37

Division.

01:25:45 - 01:25:46

Edward Argar.

01:25:47 - 01:25:48

Gareth Bacon.

01:25:49 - 01:25:50

Danny Beales.

01:25:51 - 01:25:52

Rachel Blake.

01:25:53 - 01:25:54

Serena Brackenridge.

01:25:55 - 01:25:56

Lewis Cocking.

01:25:57 - 01:25:58

Deirdre Costigan.

01:26:01 - 01:26:02

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:26:03 - 01:26:04

Matthew Pennycook.

01:26:05 - 01:26:06

John Slinger.

01:26:07 - 01:26:08

Patrick Spencer.

01:26:09 - 01:26:10

Laurence Turner.

01:26:12 - 01:26:14

Speaker 37

No.

01:26:14 - 01:26:29

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four and the noes were 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 94 proposed to clause 10 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:26:30 - 01:26:31

To the contrary, no.

01:26:32 - 01:26:37

Speaker 39

Division.

01:26:38 - 01:26:40

Speaker 38

No vote.

01:26:40 - 01:26:41

Edward Argar.

01:26:42 - 01:26:43

Gareth Bacon.

01:26:44 - 01:26:45

Danny Beales.

01:26:46 - 01:26:47

Rachel Blake.

01:26:48 - 01:26:49

Serena Brackenridge.

01:26:50 - 01:26:51

Lewis Cocking.

01:26:52 - 01:26:53

Deirdre Costigan.

01:26:56 - 01:26:57

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:26:58 - 01:26:59

Matthew Pennycook.

01:27:00 - 01:27:01

John Slinger.

01:27:02 - 01:27:03

Patrick Spencer.

01:27:04 - 01:27:05

Laurence Turner.

01:27:07 - 01:27:13

Speaker 40

No.

01:27:13 - 01:27:29

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 96 proposed to clause 10 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:27:30 - 01:27:31

To the contrary, no.

01:27:32 - 01:27:36

Speaker 41

Division.

01:27:38 - 01:27:39

Edward Argar.

01:27:40 - 01:27:41

Gareth Bacon.

01:27:42 - 01:27:43

Danny Beales.

01:27:44 - 01:27:45

Rachel Blake.

01:27:46 - 01:27:47

Serena Brackenridge.

01:27:47 - 01:27:49

Speaker 42

No.

01:27:49 - 01:27:50

Lewis Cocking.

01:27:51 - 01:27:52

Deirdre Costigan.

01:27:55 - 01:28:12

Speaker 24

Mary Kelly Foy. No. Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger.

No. Patrick Spencer. Aye. Lawrence Turner. No.

Steve Yemm. No.

01:28:12 - 01:28:35

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 97 proposed to clause 10 is on the amendment. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye.

To the contrary, no. No. Division.

01:28:35 - 01:29:04

Speaker 24

Gideon Amos. Gideon Amos. No vote. No vote. Ed Argar.

Ed Argar. Aye. Aye. Gareth Bacon. Gareth Bacon.

Aye. Aye. Danny Beales. Danny Beales. No.

No. Rachel Blake. Rachel Blake. No. No.

Serena Breckenridge. Serena Breckenridge. No. No. Lewis Cocking.

Lewis Cocking. Aye. Aye. Deirdre Costigan. Deirdre Costigan.

No. No. Lee Dillon. Lee Dillon. Abstain.

Abstain. Mary Kelly Foy. Mary Kelly Foy. No. No.

Matthew Pennycook. Matthew Pennycook. No. No. John Slinger.

John Slinger. No. No. Patrick Spencer. Patrick Spencer.

Aye. Aye. Lawrence Turner. Lawrence Turner. No.

01:29:04 - 01:29:29

Martin Vickers

No. Steve Yemm. Steve Yemm. No. No.

The ayes were four and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 95 proposed to clause 10 was on the order paper, on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye.

01:29:29 - 01:30:08

Speaker 24

To the contrary, no. No. Division. The ayes were four and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 95 proposed to clause 10 is on the amendment paper.

01:30:08 - 01:30:28

Martin Vickers

The question is that the amendment be... sorry, 98. Amendment 98 proposed to clause 10 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye.

To the contrary, no. No. Division.

01:30:28 - 01:30:55

Speaker 24

Gideon Amos. No vote. Ed Argar. Aye. Gareth Bacon.

Aye. Danny Beales. No. Rachel Blake. No.

Serena Breckenridge. No. Lewis Cocking. Aye. Deirdre Costigan.

No. Lee Dillon. Abstain. Mary Kelly Foy. No.

Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger. No. Patrick Spencer.

01:30:55 - 01:31:26

Martin Vickers

Aye. Lawrence Turner. No. Steve Yemm. No.

The ayes were four and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Clause 10 has just been debated. The question is that clause 10 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye.

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 9 and the question that clause 11 stand part of the bill.

The question is that clause 11 stand part of the bill. I call the minister.

01:31:26 - 01:33:20

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Clause 11 concerns the right to acquire scheme. The right to acquire scheme for housing association tenants is broadly modeled on the right to buy with most of the same rules applying. Right to acquire applies to housing association homes built or acquired with social housing grant after 1997. This bill through clauses 1 to 10 amends the Housing Act 1985 to alter rules regarding the right to buy.

We've already discussed the effect of and rationale for those clauses. Section 184 of the Housing and Regeneration Act 2008 means that these changes will also apply in relation to the right to acquire scheme for housing association tenants. The committee will understand that it's only right that the same eligibility criteria and exemptions should apply across both schemes to ensure consistency and fairness for social housing tenants regardless of whether they live in a council home or a housing association home. My officials have undertaken engagement with relevant stakeholders such as the National Housing Federation who are supportive of this consistent approach. This will also support the broader policy objective of protecting social housing stock which as we've debated at length is a core objective of this bill.

The discounts for the right to acquire are set out separately to the right to buy. They remain unaffected and will continue to be 9,000 pounds to 16,000 pounds depending on the location. Increasing them to align with the right to buy discounts would contradict our objectives to better protect social housing stock. Clause 11, Mr. Vickers, is a consequential amendment to reflect changes to the rural area provisions. This is currently an area of divergence between the two schemes.

Under the right to acquire homes in designated rural areas are already exempt from sale, recognizing the challenges of replacing that stock in those areas. Clause 11 helps ensure that the new rural exemptions introduced through the bill apply consistently across both schemes. This will provide fairness for social housing tenants as I've said support our objective of protecting social housing stock and ensure that the new rural exemptions operate coherently across both schemes and I commend it to the committee.

01:33:20 - 01:33:53

Martin Vickers

I can see no one bobbing. The question is that clause 11 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

We now come to group 10 which is led by amendment 102 proposed to clause 12 with which it will be convenient to debate amendments 101, 5 and 99, government amendment 19, amendments 6, 103 and 8. I call Lee Dillon to move amendment 102.

01:33:53 - 01:35:51

Lee Dillon

Move formally. Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Before I go into my remarks on this amendment, can I just update the committee in terms of my declaration of interest. My wife works for a social housing provider. And apologies for not declaring that when I first rose to my feet on the group 6 earlier.

Mr. Vickers, 102 is a simple amendment in that it looks to protect larger homes that are within social stock. It talks about designated rural areas, I think we've already covered that off earlier on in the bill, but also for those with four bedrooms or more. And the reason for that is quite simple. Out of all of our social stock, larger homes are our most precious commodity. And we know that of overcrowding in the UK, the social housing market makes up 48% of properties that are considered overcrowded.

If we look at Merton or Westminster Council for example, there is a 90 to 99 year wait for a three or more bed property. If we go to Rochdale further up north, about 550 families were registered for a four bed home but only 14 became available in a year. And then if we go to the west of the country to Bath, an officer there said a family could be on the register for a four bed in principle for over 200 years and added that four beds are popular under right to buy but are also expensive to build.

I think Mr. Vickers, when you add in those comments with our ambition to make sure that overcrowding impacts as few people as possible, maintaining four-bed homes from being or and making four-bed homes or larger exempt mean that we protect the homes that we we really do need.

01:35:51 - 01:35:57

Martin Vickers

Sorry, Gideon, if you want to speak to the other amendments you can do so now if you wish to continue.

01:35:57 - 01:36:25

Speaker 20

Yeah, apologies, Chair. On amendment number 101, this is similar to a previous amendment that went into more detail, but again each community land trust providing social housing, making sure that they're given notice of a sale as well. So just expanding that remit of who are notified so that if there are providers willing to take up those social homes when they're being disposed of, that we're retaining them into some sort of community ownership.

01:36:25 - 01:36:34

Martin Vickers

Amendment 102 opposed to clause 12 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Gideon Amos.

01:36:34 - 01:39:07

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise to speak to amendments 5, 6, 1 and 8 which stand in my name. Mr. Vickers, the first of those, amendment 5, would extend the notification of proposed sale to cover the regulator of social housing. Amendment 6 would extend the timescales of notice from four to eight weeks. I note that since we put down this amendment, the government's obviously been closely reading everything that we put down and decided to come up with its own amendment to extend the window.

I'm glad that we're already having an influence on the bill, Mr. Vickers, and I'd be pleased to push this to a vote if necessary to make sure the government succeeds in getting its change in the timescale that it clearly wishes to see. Otherwise, depending on the order of voting in this place, which I still sometimes have a problem following, Mr. Vickers, one or the other I'm sure will fulfill the same purpose. Amendment 1, Mr. Vickers, would require the regulator of social housing to receive a copy of the notice. And finally, amendment 8 would is effectively a stop-the-clock amendment in which if negotiations are ongoing for the acquisition of a social home by a local authority, the the time period be extended by a further four weeks. Now I recognize that this contains already the this relies on this amendment refers to the existing four-week period in the bill and that may be extended to eight weeks under other amendments.

However, I think the principle of allowing an extension of time when negotiations are ongoing is a really significant one and something that the Local Government Association would like to see. So whilst I won't push amendment 8 to a vote, I think it would be helpful for the Minister to consider whether an extension could be given where negotiations are ongoing so that the there's a real chance for that purchase of that disposal property to be completed and for that local authority to succeed in that endeavor. Thank you, Mr. Vickers.

01:39:07 - 01:39:09

Martin Vickers

Minister.

01:39:09 - 01:41:13

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I beg to move government amendment 19. I'll speak to it and then respond to each of the I think eight amendments that were spoken to in this rather large group.

I've listened to concerns raised by parliamentarians and stakeholders on this issue over recent weeks and indeed months, that a four-week period between a private provider notifying a council or other provider in their area of the sale of a social home and the disposing of that home is not sufficient for them to consider purchasing the property. In particular, I appreciate that local authorities were concerned that a four-week window would not align with their internal timing constraints, such as monthly cabinet or committee meetings. On that basis, the government has brought forward this amendment to extend the window of time that must pass between notification and the sale of a property from four to eight weeks. This amendment, we think, strikes the right balance between maximizing opportunities to retain social homes without causing undue delays to sales. I'll come to the specific point that the honorable gentleman makes about negotiations that are in train.

Turning to the various amendments that have been tabled and spoken to, Mr. Vickers, amendments 6 and 8 tabled by the honorable member for Taunton and Wellington, both seek to extend the disposal notification period. Amendment 8 would, as he's just argued, have required an extension of the window to eight weeks where a provider could demonstrate they were taking steps towards purchasing the property. The government's amendment 19 goes further than this proposal by requiring eight weeks in all cases, and I hope that he will therefore support it on that basis. Amendment 6 would require a further extension to 12 weeks in areas designated as rural. We are not persuaded by the case for a longer notification window specifically for rural areas.

A statutory minimum of 12 weeks could unnecessarily delay sales and require providers to deal with the additional burden and costs associated with having homes left unoccupied for extended periods. I should also stress that the notification period is just a minimum. We'd expect private registered providers to engage and be flexible beyond this period where there is a serious interest from another landlord in the social housing sector. Yes.

01:41:13 - 01:41:56

Lee Dillon

I'm grateful to the minister giving way. The government don't accept that there's a compelling case to extend it to 12 weeks for rural areas. But if some organization was buying a property or looking to buy a property, particularly when it's in an area of outstanding natural beauty or where you don't have infrastructure hardwired, actually there is more consideration to be taken if you're going to be taking on a social home in a rural area than in a well-developed town. Would you accept that point? And so therefore actually having longer to be able to go through the sale to make sure you've got all your ducks in the row that you can convert the property to however you might want to in restrictive planning laws, actually is a reason for giving four more weeks on top of what the government have graciously already accepted.

01:41:56 - 01:44:16

Matthew Pennycook

Minister. I'd say two points in response to the honorable gentleman, and I appreciate the concern. Firstly, I think it's just a matter of fact that there will be different challenges in different areas. What we have tried to get to with the increase in the notification period from four to eight weeks is a period where we think it is reasonable for all local authorities to consider these matters. What I haven't had, if he's got any evidence I'd like to see it, is compelling evidence to suggest that local authorities would not be able to deal with these in an eight-week period.

And I go back to the point I've just made as well, and stress that the notification period is just a minimum. We'd expect private registered providers to engage and be flexible beyond this period where there's a serious interest from another landlord in the social housing sector. I hope on that basis that he is reassured. I now turn to amendments 102 and 103 tabled by the honorable member for Newbury and the honorable member for Taunton and Wellington. These amendments would require written consent from the local authority for a sale of a social home in a rural area with four or more bedrooms.

Now, again, I recognize the strength of feeling on this matter. I want to ensure, the government wants to ensure, that every opportunity is taken to protect much-needed social housing stock. I'd expect private registered providers to think particularly carefully before selling homes that meet acute housing needs in local areas. However, housing associations do remain independent organizations responsible for their own asset management, and the government cannot support an approach that would prevent landlords making legitimate business decisions about how to manage their stock without the agreement of the local authority. And we can, I'm happy to go into with honorable members, the reclassification risks that arise in this area, and I've debated those points at length with a number of members on my own side and members opposite.

I should also point out that previous restrictions that required approval by the regulator of social housing for disposals of homes had to be removed in 2017. I know the honourable gentleman remembers this with his experience in the sector, to reclassify the housing association sector back to private. And I fear that introducing a requirement for local authority approval would represent a significant classification risk. It's not the only classification risk. These things are considered by the ONS in the round, but nevertheless is a material risk from our point of view.

I will give way.

01:44:16 - 01:45:02

Lewis Cocking

I thank the minister for giving way. And I generally asked about disposals in a nice and polite way. So I wonder what the minister's comment on this will be. When obviously housing associations or councils dispose of properties, generally they do for a reason. For example, not being able to spend the money to get it up to a certain EPC grading that the government has set for them.

So what evidence does he have that another social housing provider would be able to do something to a social home that one company can't do, for example, because they're selling it, and someone else would be able to spend the money on to increase that EPC rating? I just want to understand where we're going with these amendments and this part of the bill when we're disposing of these properties, because they're usually done for a reason. So what makes him think that someone who can't do it, someone else in the industry could do it?

01:45:02 - 01:47:56

Matthew Pennycook

I think my response to that point, again, it's a very fair one, would be that the particular reasons that individual providers are disposing of stock vary wildly across the country. In the case of disposals that are driven by increases in standards, we are seeing some of that. But it's also the case that there are occasions where local authorities or other providers are willing, for their own reasons, based on their own assessment of the stock, able and willing to take those on. So I don't think we can specify as a general rule. What we're trying to achieve here is to give local authorities and other providers the maximum possible opportunity to pick up those stocks and to retain them in the social housing sector if that is possible.

I'd just be very clear and honest with him, it may not always be possible, and those homes may be disposed of on the open market. But we do want to increase the chances of them being able to be retained in the sector for all the reasons that we've gone into. Mr Vickers, I will now move on to amendments 1 and 5, which would add the regulator of social housing to those bodies that must be notified prior to a disposal. The regulator plays a vital role in ensuring our social landlords deliver the quality homes and services their tenants deserve. As part of the regulatory framework, private registered providers must also be able to demonstrate a strategic rationale for disposals and understand the implications for their total social housing stock.

I'm not persuaded, Mr Vickers, that requiring private registered providers to notify the regulator of a future disposal would enable them to better regulate against the standards that they set. The regulator plays no role in approving such disposals, and that decision properly rests with the landlord. The regulator is already notified once a disposal has occurred, so they have an overview of the numbers and types of disposals that are occurring. Amendment 101 would similarly require community land trusts with social housing in the area to be notified. Of course, community land trusts that are registered with the regulator would already be notified under the requirements of this measure.

I'm aware that not all community land trusts are registered with the regulator. That is their choice. But the focus of this measure is to keep homes in the regulated sector where it is possible to do so. The notification process is therefore focused on notifying providers that are registered with the regulator. Turning to amendment 99 finally, this would require that a sales notice provided to the local authority and other registered providers in the local area is also published on the website of the private registered provider intending to dispose of the property.

One of the main aims of the provisions contained in clause 12 of this bill is to increase transparency around disposals. However, there is a balance to be struck between the benefits of transparency and the burdens and costs to private registered providers. We believe amendment 99 would introduce an unhelpful level of bureaucracy around the disposal notifications process. Whilst some providers may choose to publish notifications of sales on their website, requiring it via legislation is in our view disproportionate. I'm happy to give way.

01:47:56 - 01:48:19

Gideon Amos

I'd just invite the minister and committee to reflect on really the massive cost of putting something on a website. It's a difficult argument that I'm having difficulty with. It really, if we're after transparency, I understand the tradition of this place that government resists all amendments that come from all quarters unless they're their own, but this seems to be taking things to an illogical conclusion.

01:48:19 - 01:49:29

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I'll say to the honourable gentleman because I certainly don't intend, I don't make it a point of principle to resist all amendments despite how sensible some will be. And he will see in the list of government amendments we are debating many of the points we've taken on raised by noble peers. I think in answer to his question, I will go away and reflect on how much of a burden it is. But I think the, and I say this as a general point, I've sat on, this is my third bill committee as a minister, must have sat on probably 13 in opposition over the period. The natural tendency of oppositions is to call for further requirements, further regulations, further reviews, further assessments because often they've got nothing more to say on the point of principle on a particular clause.

And I think the cumulative impact of layering all of this on top of, we want to ensure that that balance is struck properly, ensuring that the disposal process is proportionate, is streamlined to an extent. But I'll go away and reflect on the particular point and review whether requiring private registered providers on this particular point would be as burdensome as we think. I will give way briefly.

01:49:29 - 01:49:57

Lee Dillon

I appreciate the minister for giving way. To support my honourable friend's comments and appreciate the minister will go away and reflect on that. Can I just add a plea that there is concern when stock is being disposed of in local communities that the community doesn't know what's going on. And actually by having it on the website here, it doesn't just allow the sector to know what's going on, it allows the local community to know what's going on with its housing stock.

01:49:57 - 01:50:05

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I take the point made and as I've committed to the honourable gentleman, I'll go away, reflect, and I'm happy to provide a fuller written answer to both honourable members.

01:50:05 - 01:50:09

Martin Vickers

Lee Dillon, do you wish to wind up?

01:50:09 - 01:50:22

Lee Dillon

No, I'd like to say just that I won't put 102 or 101 to a vote.

01:50:22 - 01:51:02

Martin Vickers

Is it everyone's content that 101 and 102 be withdrawn? Just 102. Sorry, yes. Is everyone content that amendment 102 be withdrawn? Amendment 101 to clause 12 has just been debated in group 10.

Lee, do you wish to move formally? Amendment 5 to clause 12 was just debated in group 10. Gideon Amos. Amendment 99 to clause 12 was just debated in group 10. Lee.

01:51:02 - 01:51:04

Speaker 48

I'd like to move it formally.

01:51:04 - 01:51:13

Martin Vickers

Amendment 99 proposed to clause 12 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:51:14 - 01:51:15

To the contrary, no.

01:51:16 - 01:51:39

Martin Vickers

Division. Lock the doors. Gideon Amos.

01:51:40 - 01:51:41

Edward Argar.

01:51:42 - 01:51:43

Gareth Bacon.

01:51:44 - 01:51:45

Danny Beales.

01:51:46 - 01:51:47

Rachel Blake.

01:51:48 - 01:51:49

Serena Breckenridge.

01:51:49 - 01:51:53

Speaker 51

No.

01:51:53 - 01:51:54

Lewis Cocking.

01:51:55 - 01:51:56

Deirdre Costigan.

01:51:59 - 01:52:00

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:52:01 - 01:52:02

Matthew Pennycook.

01:52:03 - 01:52:04

John Slinger.

01:52:05 - 01:52:06

Patrick Spencer.

01:52:07 - 01:52:08

Lawrence Turner.

01:52:10 - 01:52:18

Speaker 53

No.

01:52:18 - 01:52:40

Martin Vickers

The ayes were two and the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Government amendment 19 to clause 12 was just debated. I call the minister to move formally.

01:52:40 - 01:52:41

Move formally.

01:52:41 - 01:52:45

Martin Vickers

The question is that government amendment 19 be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:52:46 - 01:52:56

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Amendments 6 and 1 and 103 to clause 12 were just debated in group 10. Gideon Amos, do you wish to move?

01:52:56 - 01:52:58

Speaker 52

Sorry, which one, sorry?

01:52:58 - 01:53:01

Speaker 57

Sorry, which one? 6. Amendment 6.

01:53:01 - 01:53:03

Speaker 54

I'll push that to a vote.

01:53:03 - 01:53:10

Martin Vickers

Amendment 6 proposed to clause 12 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:53:11 - 01:53:12

To the contrary, no.

01:53:13 - 01:53:27

Martin Vickers

Division. Lock the doors.

01:53:29 - 01:53:30

Edward Argar.

01:53:31 - 01:53:32

Gareth Bacon.

01:53:33 - 01:53:34

Danny Beales.

01:53:35 - 01:53:36

Rachel Blake.

01:53:37 - 01:53:38

Serena Breckenridge.

01:53:39 - 01:53:40

Lewis Cocking.

01:53:41 - 01:53:42

Deirdre Costigan.

01:53:45 - 01:53:46

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:53:47 - 01:53:48

Matthew Pennycook.

01:53:49 - 01:53:50

John Slinger.

01:53:51 - 01:53:52

Patrick Spencer.

01:53:53 - 01:53:54

Lawrence Turner.

01:53:56 - 01:54:02

Speaker 37

No.

01:54:02 - 01:54:14

Martin Vickers

The ayes were two and the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 1 proposed to clause 12 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:54:15 - 01:54:16

To the contrary, no.

01:54:17 - 01:54:26

Speaker 62

Division.

01:54:28 - 01:54:29

Edward Argar.

01:54:30 - 01:54:31

Gareth Bacon.

01:54:32 - 01:54:33

Danny Beales.

01:54:34 - 01:54:35

Rachel Blake.

01:54:36 - 01:54:37

Serena Breckenridge.

01:54:38 - 01:54:39

Lewis Cocking.

01:54:40 - 01:54:41

Deirdre Costigan.

01:54:44 - 01:54:45

Mary Kelly Foy.

01:54:46 - 01:54:47

Matthew Pennycook.

01:54:48 - 01:54:49

John Slinger.

01:54:50 - 01:54:51

Patrick Spencer.

01:54:52 - 01:54:53

Lawrence Turner.

01:54:55 - 01:55:02

Speaker 60

No.

01:55:02 - 01:55:13

Martin Vickers

The ayes were two and the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 103 to clause 12 was just debated in group 10. Lee, do you wish to move?

01:55:14 - 01:55:35

Martin Vickers

Withdrawn. Amendment by leave withdrawn. So we move on to... We now come to group 11, which is led by amendment 2 proposed to clause 12, with which it would be convenient to debate amendments 3 and 10.

I call Gideon Amos to move the amendment.

01:55:35 - 01:56:19

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I'll be brief. This amendment would give local housing authorities right of first refusal to acquire social rent dwellings previously transferred from local authorities at existing use value for social housing. The important point here is that acquiring those properties at existing use value for social housing rather than at market value or existing use value is significant in that obviously the existing use value for social housing is lower. It's important that local authorities have that ability to acquire homes that are being disposed of so that the net reduction of social housing isn't increased.

And with that, Mr. Vickers, I move amendment 2.

01:56:19 - 01:56:29

Martin Vickers

Amendment 2 proposed to clause 12 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Minister.

01:56:29 - 01:59:23

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. The honorable member for Taunton and Wellington's amendments 2 and 3 would introduce, as he's just set out, a right of first refusal for the local authority and other registered providers notified via a sale notice during the notice period. This right would be on condition that the home would remain as social housing and would require the private registered provider to sell the home at the existing use value for social housing. There's also the corresponding amendment 10 in this group tabled by the member for St. Ives that would see the right of first refusal extended to specific types of bodies that provide or would provide affordable housing. Some of these bodies will be registered with the regulator of social housing and therefore would already be included with amendment 3, but it would also extend the right of first refusal to unregistered housing providers.

Sir Martin, I've heard clearly both at second reading and today, as I've already set out, the desire of honorable members to protect social homes. I very much share that desire. But this must be balanced with the ability of private providers to operate efficiently and manage their housing assets, including by investing in more new homes or their existing stock. Sometimes this can mean selling a social home out of the sector. Now, I can assure the committee that I have thought long and hard, challenged officials, they can verify this with nods, that we look at these issues in lots of detail about what requirements can be put in place or levers we can try to pull to keep as many social homes in the regulated sector as possible.

A key consideration when thinking through possible interventions is the reality that interfering with private registered providers' freedom to use and sell their assets as they wish would present a significant risk of reclassifying the sector. Not only would this bring 110 billion pounds of debt onto the public books, it would bring with it risk and uncertainty that could impact on the investment in the sector that is so needed. As I've already said, I hope the disposals measures in this bill will ensure greater transparency around disposals, but also support better dialogue between private registered providers and local authorities. I hope it will also focus minds to ensure we're minimizing any negative impact resulting from disposals. Of course, there is nothing to prevent a private registered provider choosing to sell to another provider at a lower price or on the understanding it remains social housing.

I'd hope that the notification requirement introduced by the bill supports such discussions, and I'm very open to ideas about what more can be done to support that dialogue. And I've also tasked my officials to work with the sector to identify and promote good practice and to explore what more government might do to reinforce it. But given the issues that I've highlighted, I believe we'll get the best results by working together with private registered providers and local authorities to explore what more they can do and where we can support them to keep homes in the regulated sector. But for the reasons I've set out, primarily around reclassification risk, we can't accept these amendments and I'd ask the honorable gentleman to withdraw.

01:59:23 - 01:59:25

Speaker 59

Gideon Amos.

01:59:25 - 01:59:54

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I appreciate the government's response there. These amendments are genuinely intended to provide the ability for councils to acquire stock rather than seeing them lost from the social housing sector.

And I think it's a particularly important area and I believe an important amendment. I understand the risks of reclassification onto the public sector balance sheet. I wonder whether the minister would be willing to publish the advice he's received on this because people in the sector want to understand why first refusal cannot be given to local authorities.

01:59:54 - 02:00:04

Matthew Pennycook

I appreciate the attempt, let's say, to have confidential advice given to ministers published in the round. That's not the usual practice.

02:00:04 - 02:00:08

Speaker 61

Order, order. It being 11:25, the committee is now adjourned. Order, order.