House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 10
We now know that freedom of information requests that Defra knew the scheme could collapse within hours, yet the government pressed ahead regardless. Now environmental charities, including the Rivers Trust, are warning that this will undermine nature recovery. Does the Secretary of State recognize that by failing the custodians of our countryside, she is failing nature too?
Speaker 5
Well, I would, I would argue with the honorable lady's characterization of collapse for the scheme. I think we shouldn't forget that SFI 2026 has made nearly one billion pounds of support available for the next three years for environmentally sustainable farming. And we have now 70,000 multi-year ELM agreements in place, which is making sure that we support environmentally friendly farming. I would not characterize that as collapse, Mr. Speaker. I note that the Tories didn't spend the whole farming budget when they were in government.
Speaker 6
They botched Brexit, which led to a 22% fall in trade, and they concluded an Australian trade deal, which Tory Secretaries of State now admit has sold out British farmers.
Emma Hardy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We have strengthened regulation and enforcement, driving record water company investment into wastewater infrastructure to improve nearly 3,000 storm overflows across England and Wales. And the strengthened Water Bill will go further in tackling sewage pollution from water companies, private sewerage, and catchment-wide pre-pipe and source control conditions.
Colin Daniel Aldridge
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A recent report by Surfers Against Sewage alleges water companies across England failed to report more than 50,000 sewage spills within the legally required timeframe just in the first half of this year. Like many residents across Western Wirral and the villages, I'm deeply concerned about the impact of sewage pollution and will always urge the government to go faster and harder to tackle the crisis. Could the Minister tell us what more the government will do to hold water companies to account in coastal communities like mine so constituents have confidence that our much-loved waterways and coastlines are protected?
Emma Hardy
My honorable friend is quite right to be angry about the failure of water companies to report sewage pollution on time. And our Water Special Measures Act will be enacting automatic penalties for companies who fail to report sewage pollutions within four hours. And as he will have seen from the recent eight million pound fine to South West Water for sewage pollution incidents, this government takes enforcement seriously.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We desperately need to reduce rainwater runoff into our sewage system in order to prevent storm overflows. And Wessex Water in Bath runs community water butt schemes and flood mitigation pilots which prevent rainwater runoff entering our sewers, ensuring they're not overwhelmed. What steps is the government taking so that more customers and householders can actually have access to water butts?
Emma Hardy
The honorable lady raises one of my favorite things, Mr. Speaker, which is talking about pre-pipe solutions, which is in a nutshell how do you prevent... It's very exciting, very exciting. It's how do you prevent so much of the water from entering the sewage system in the first time and becoming overwhelmed. It links perfectly with nature-based solutions. It helps mean our soils are wetter, it helps against drought.
So in this, I am in agreement with the honorable lady that we need to see more of it, and that includes water companies providing water butts for more of their customers, which helps overwhelming the sewage system and helps them water their gardens when there's less rain.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last year there were 392,000 sewage spills across our country.
4,000 of those spills happened in the precious waters of Cumbria's lakes and dales. Meanwhile, last year, companies rewarded their shareholders for that failure with increased dividends of 845 million pounds. So isn't it time instead to put failing water companies into administration? In the forthcoming water bill, and it would be good if she could tell us when we might expect that, will she bring forward a plan to create a watchdog, a new one with teeth, and transform our water companies from being mutually owned so that money stops leaking out of the system and instead funds a clean-up of our waterways and of our water industry.
Emma Hardy
The honorable gentleman will have noticed, I am sure, that since we came into power we are taking enforcement seriously. Fines just this year include 7.1 million pound fine and a 2.4 million pound fine for illegal sewage pollution against Southern Water, a 7.87 million pound fine against South West Water, and I haven't even included all of the Ofwat enforcement undertakings and all of the fines that are included there. He will have heard what our Prime Minister said, that we are strengthening our water bill, we will bring that forward soon, we are not taking options off the table, and we are serious about fixing the mess that we were left to deal with when we came into power.
Speaker 5
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Waste crime is fueled by serious organized crime and it's blighting our communities. We are tackling it. Since April, we've made 21 arrests and shut down 339 illegal waste sites. Police operations have triggered over 30 criminal investigations and we're strengthening enforcement and disrupting those who are profiting from waste crime.
Ashley Dalton
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Illegal waste dumping at the Simmonswood industrial estate in my constituency has long blighted the residents in West Lancashire and in Kirkby. My honorable friend the member for Knowsley and I have worked together on tackling the Simmonswood stink, but and we welcomed the EA's permit revocation earlier this year, but the mound remains, as does the odor and the dust. What assurances can the government give that Simmonswood will be considered in the next phase of the illegal waste site clearance scheme?
Speaker 5
Well, thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know how tirelessly my honorable friend and her neighbor the right honorable member for Knowsley have campaigned on this issue. Waste crime blights local communities and the government is committed to tackling it. The Environment Agency continues to investigate activity at Simmonswood and the site will be considered for clearance alongside other illegal waste sites.
Rishi Sunak
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Waste crime and fly-tipping are a blight on rural communities, but also as the Secretary of State said, increasingly linked to organized crime. So I commend ministers for building on the work of the last government to increase penalties, tighten up restrictions on carriers, but also speed up digital tracking of waste. But communities play their part too. So could I ask the Secretary of State to join me in praising the work of the Wombles of Hambleton, whose volunteers do an excellent job organizing monthly litter picks, collecting hundreds of bags of rubbish and ensuring that North Yorkshire remains the most beautiful part of the country.
Speaker 5
Well, Mr. Speaker, as a Yorkshire woman myself, I I'm not going to disagree, although it may get me into trouble about the beauty of Yorkshire. And I'm happy to join him in praising the Wombles of Hambleton. I need him to show me a photograph of them out doing this job next time we bump into each other. But there are many, many community-organized litter picks and clean-ups that are going on in all our communities, including one that happened in my own constituency a couple of weekends ago in Seacombe. So much litter is picked up, but we have a lot of work to do to persuade people to be more responsible at that level of littering, not to drop it in the first place.
Speaker 13
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'd like to group questions four and six. The government is in the final stages of negotiating sanitary and phytosanitary agreement with the EU to make agri-food trade with our biggest market cheaper and easier by removing trade barriers for British producers. An SPS agreement could increase the volume of UK exports of major primary agricultural commodities to the EU by around 16%. A regulatory impact assessment would be prepared as part of the normal process. Details are subject to ongoing negotiations and we will not be providing commentary on those.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now, England has become a world leader in gene editing and precision breeding. This has increased crop yields and eradicated diseases. It helps to protect domestic food security and potentially global food security. But much of this technology is banned in the European Union and dynamic alignment will mean we cannot use it.
So what representation representations has the minister made to the Cabinet Office and to ministers in negotiations with the European Union to ensure that gene editing and our world-leading technologies are protected.
Speaker 13
I thank the honorable member for his question. I am committed to the Precision Breeding Act and details of the agreement are subject to negotiation and the common understanding between the EU-UK sets out the agreement which will include a short list of exceptions. I can confirm the UK has been clear about the importance of being able to support the use of new and innovative technologies.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. CropLife UK warned that the heatless rush to align with the EU could cost British farming £810 million. That's £810 million off bottom lines which are already very marginal. Further, it could also hit production in this country. So we cannot export what we we're not even growing.
What assessment is the government making of CropLife's report that that says that this EU alignment could be very dangerous for farming.
Speaker 13
The CropLife report is clear that the numbers presented are a worst-case scenario. We are building a new pragmatic relationship with the EU, markedly different to what's gone before, which will bring clear benefits with closer alignment, but negotiations are in their final stages and the government will set out further details as they conclude.
Julie Minns
Mr. Speaker, my Carlisle constituency is home to one of only two herds of European bison in the country. In order to expand that that herd and maintain a healthy breeding population, they will require access to high-quality genetic material. I'll leave it to your imagination. As part of that as part of the assessment on the SPS, will the minister ensure that we have access that the UK's import regime supports the access that herd needs.
Speaker 13
I thank my honorable friend for her question. She's a real champion on these issues, especially innovation that her industry are carrying forward. We recognize the importance of access to high-quality genetic material for maintaining healthy breeding populations. Zootechnical arrangements facilitate trade in breeding animals and genetic material, but the details of future arrangements will depend on the outcome of the ongoing UK-EU SPS negotiations.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The EU summit is to take place in just 28 days' time, but yet the farming minister cannot answer key questions, not just from us, but from our farming community. We still have no confirmation that the Precision Breeding Act, widely recognized as a huge success, will be 100% protected. We have no reassurance that our current freedom to innovate in gene editing and in bovine TB vaccine development will be a red line. And we have no acknowledgment that the alignment with the EU on plant protection products could slash £810 million from farming incomes in the first year alone.
So I ask the farming minister, what guarantees can he give our farmers right now that this Labour government won't sell them out to the EU, just like they sold out our British fishermen last May when they previously negotiated with Brussels.
Speaker 13
I mean, the brass neck of the shadow minister, Mr. Speaker, with all the deals that they did and tried to get over the line and sold out our British farmers. Now, Defra continues to work closely with industry and when negotiations will conclude, we will be able to provide more definitive answers on the exact nature of any alignment. I cannot comment on the specifics of the agreement, but we have been clear that we will only pursue an SPS agreement which has the British interests at their heart.
Emma Hardy
Thank you. With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'd like to group questions five, seven and thirteen together. Fly-tipping is unacceptable. It blights communities, harms the environment and imposes significant costs on taxpayers and businesses. Those responsible should be cleaning it up and paying for it.
That is why we have strengthened the powers and the penalties available to councils to ensure vandals face real consequences and we are consulting on making them clean up their own mess.
Melanie Onn
I thank the minister for that response. Fly-tipping is a real scourge for my Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes constituents, whether it is alleyways or local beauty spots. It is so disappointing, especially when so many members of the community are involved in doing community cleanups. Now the government, as the minister says, has done a huge amount of work to increase fines to five thousand pounds and give powers to scrap vehicles once they are seized. But these powers are only effective if they are used.
So would she join me in urging my Reform-led North East Lincolnshire Council to make greater use of these enforcement powers?
Emma Hardy
My honourable friend is right to raise this and her constituents are understandably frustrated. And I share her confusion as to why her council doesn't want to use the powers that they have been given to fine fly-tippers, seize their vans and prosecute her. And I absolutely join her in urging her council to do the job that they have been elected to do. And I hope her residents remember this lack of action when it comes to the next election.
Adam Thompson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Trafalgar Square, not the one down the road but the much, much smaller one back home in Erewash, is a private road with a persistent fly-tipping problem. There are signs up that ask people to stop doing it. I've reported it loads of times to councils, so have local people all of the time. But the piles of bulky waste in the area, if they get cleared, they come back almost immediately.
So today I'm escalating, Mr. Speaker, please could the minister elaborate on how the government is working to get a grip on fly-tipping, particularly in hotspots like Trafalgar Square in Long Eaton?
Emma Hardy
I completely understand the frustration that my honourable friend's constituents have where you have roads which are repeatedly fly-tipped and they are private roads. We are taking this seriously. We've increased the maximum fine for offenders to five thousand pounds, but we are also working on advising landowners who are obviously the owners of private land on land security through the National Fly-Tipping Prevention Group. So we're happy to sort of give that advice out there to private landowners. But where we find out who is responsible, Mr. Speaker, we won't hesitate in going after them.
Kevin Bonavia
Mr. Speaker, like many other MPs, I'm often reporting the worst examples of fly-tipping to our local councils. My most recent case is Marymead Drive, with boards and tarpaulin thrown under trees and with walls graffitied. I know and expect Stevenage Borough Council staff will be onto this as quickly as possible, but they shouldn't have to be doing this in the first place. So what assurances could the minister give me and the House about the government's war on waste crime and whether it will extend to graffiti and reduce these instances of fly-tipping?
Emma Hardy
I thank my honourable friend and it's good to hear about a council being proactive and going after and cleaning up some of this mess. And I agree that graffiti and fly-tipping offences are unacceptable. Graffiti of course is a separate offence from fly-tipping, but local councils can issue fixed penalties of up to five hundred pounds for graffiti offences and we are consulting on powers for councils to use conditional cautions requiring offenders to clean up their mess and cover the cleanup costs instead of simply walking away from the damage they caused.
John Glen
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A constituent got in touch with me last week to point out that farmers are often left to be the ones who have to deal with fly-tipping. But I note in the government's response on Tuesday that insurance is one option that could be available. Could the Minister say what progress she's making in talking to insurance companies about making fly-tipping part of a routine farm policy that farmers could take out against this scourge?
Emma Hardy
The right honourable gentleman raises an important point, and I absolutely sympathise with farmers. It is, as he's quite rightly highlighted, quite often the farmers that see the repeated dumping onto their private land. There is that national fly-tipping prevention group. I meet with insurers regularly. In fact, I met with them all last week, and I will certainly raise that issue of how we can ensure that farmers get the support they need for having to deal with a problem that was quite simply not of their making.
Andrew George.
Andrew George
Mr. Speaker, local authorities will be looking to the Environment Agency to set standards as far as enforcement action is concerned. At Trevoul Moor in my constituency is the fifth largest illegal dump in the country, affecting a nature reserve, but they've decided not to take enforcement action. And when I've discussed it with them, they've said that they deal with these matters on a case-by-case basis. So would the Minister ensure that the guidance which the Environment Agency use is published so we can properly understand where and why they make these decisions?
Emma Hardy
The honourable gentleman raises an important issue, and we have some of these illegal sites around the country, which is why we're focusing heavily on the prevention side so we can go after them before these crimes have been taken. We've already published the toughest effort ever waste crime action plan. We've given £45 million extra to the Environment Agency for frontline enforcement. We've given new powers. We've expanded the joint unit for waste crime.
We are going after the prevention. We are trying to clean up as many of these sites as possible. But fundamentally, we believe that it is the polluter who should pay for the clean-up and not the taxpayer, and that is always the first thing we will pursue.
Ashley Peter Fox
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Waste crime and fly-tipping affects rural communities across Somerset. Now, while I welcome the action that the government is taking on this, does the Minister agree with me that the very substantial increases that we have seen in landfill tax enable rogue waste operators to undercut legitimate businesses? And does she accept that these substantial tax increases are fueling waste crime, and will she join with me in asking the Chancellor to cut those landfill taxes?
Emma Hardy
Well, the main problem that we have in the country is serious organised crime behind some of these criminal activities that we see, and that's exactly what we are going after through the new crackdown group, which we're working obviously with the National Crime Agency as well. We are escalating this and taking it extremely seriously because, as the honourable gentleman said, we quite rightly want to support legitimate businesses who are doing the right thing, and we want to get the criminals out of this industry.
Speaker 13
Minister. The UK sector is a British success story, and we want to grow it further. We are supporting innovation, ensuring that vineyards can access essential labour, and through helping British producers access new export markets through our global network of agri-food and drink attachés.
Sir John.
John Whittingdale
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Is the Minister aware that Essex is now a centre of English wine production, with producers like Danbury Ridge, Missing Gate, New Hall, Crouch Valley, Crouch Ridge, all producing in my constituency?
And a number of those also offer vineyard tours which are an important source of revenue. So will the Minister support the campaign of WineGB to introduce a wine tourism relief to reduce the amount of excise duty on cellar door sales?
Speaker 13
Mr. Speaker, I think I was waiting for the invitation to come and visit those vineyards, but supporting trade and exports is a priority of this government, which is why DEFRA supports the UK wine industry to succeed both at home and abroad. He mentions the campaign, obviously matters for duty relief are matters for Treasury, but DEFRA recognizes the growth potential of the wine tourism industry, including the contribution to rural jobs and rural communities.
Adrien Ramsay.
Minister.
Emma Hardy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is working hard to prepare communities for flooding this winter. Last week was Flood Action Week and it communicated a wide range of information to citizens on how to protect themselves, their homes and their business. And my personal favorite, which is the new scout badge, so if you've got children who are in the scouts, they can now earn a badge saying 'be prepared', which I thought was brilliant. So the communication targeted young adults, renters, householders, children, rural communities and quite frankly everyone.
Adrian Philip Ramsay
I thank Mr. Speaker and I do thank the Minister for her reply. This year we have already seen the unprecedented climate impacts that we've had this summer and with the super El Niño on its way, we will see threats to global weather patterns including a forecasted colder, wetter and stormier winter for the UK. So how is the Minister working across government to ensure that preparedness for flooding risks this winter are stepped up to keep our communities safe?
Emma Hardy
The honorable gentleman raises a really important point. So just last week we held the new flood, we used to have previously had the Flood Taskforce, now it's the Flood and Drought Taskforce. In that meeting there were four ministers from DEFRA, from the Cabinet Office, MHCLG and the Department for Transport. And the focus of that meeting absolutely was on how can we be the most prepared, because I'm determined that this year because quite rightly of El Niño and the concerns that he's raised, that we need to be more prepared than we've ever been before. This is why we've sort of targeted sort of from children to families to homes all the way through to looking at our transport system, looking at resilience across government, looking at local resilience forums, are they ready if the worst should happen?
So we're going out through every area, talking to ministers across government so they can contact their organizations they're responsible for, asking them if they're prepared and ready. It's my determination, although I can't stop it raining, I want us to be as prepared as possible for when it comes.
Catherine Fookes.
Catherine Fookes
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, you'll remember it's almost a year since the devastating floods hit Monmouth and parts of the town have flooded several times in the last few years. I spoke to a constituent yesterday who actually flooded at a previous flood and that person hasn't been back in their house for two years, such was the damage. So could the Minister please look at upstream flood resilience measures over the border in England to reduce the risk of communities like mine in Monmouth flooding?
Emma Hardy
My honorable friend raises an important point and I remember when the flood happened and I commend her now as I did then on the compassionate, caring and supportive way she went out there to help her constituents and I know how much it affected her too. She's quite right to sort of talk about catchment-based flooding, how you can look upstream, how you can use more nature-based solutions and I know the Environment Agency is working well with its Welsh counterparts to see what more can be done in this area.
Douglas McAllister.
Speaker 13
Scotch whisky is a national treasure and I'm pleased to inform my honorable friend that its protected status and production requirements remain unchanged following the registration of English whisky geographical indication.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Department has recently confirmed that English producers who do not comply with the English whisky GI can still call their product single malt, leading to the possibility of three single malts with three differing production processes being on the shelves as a result of this decision. How does this align with the Minister's previous statement asserting that the definition of single malt whisky will not be watered down?
Speaker 13
Thank my honourable friend for his question. The English whisky GI has no effect on single malt Scotch whisky, which retains its own definition set out in Scotch whisky product specification and Scotch whisky regulations 2009. Other whisky definitions including Welsh, Irish, EU definitions already coexist with the Scotch whisky definition affecting its without affecting its protected status.
Seamus Logan
Mr. Speaker, I hear the Minister saying that the decision had no impact. But in a written response to a question from a colleague recently, the Minister failed to clarify whether an impact assessment had been carried out. So can he confirm today whether such an impact assessment was carried out and what its impact on the Scotch whisky industry was?
Speaker 13
We recognize that stakeholders may have different views and legislation provides a process for objections and appeals. And I understand that the Scottish Whisky Association have appealed to the first-tier tribunal which will be determined in due course. But I will say politely to the honourable member that due process has been followed and a rigorous scrutiny processes have been adhered to.
Number one, Mr. Speaker.
Secretary of State.
Speaker 5
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We've had a difficult summer with a prolonged period of no rain. This has put enormous stress on our landscapes, our farms, and our natural resources are under increased pressure due to climate change. The Prime Minister has asked me to ensure that communities have more of a say in how water is managed, and this is all the more important given the summer we've had. The warnings are clear.
If we're going to be resilient in water and food security, we have to help farmers farm differently. Resilience is also, Mr. Speaker, about ensuring that the poorest in our communities can have access to good, nutritious food.
Callum Anderson.
Callum Anderson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Farmers across North Buckinghamshire tell me that rising input costs and pressures on global on global pressures on grain prices are eroding their profit margins and their ability to produce food, which is why they welcome the government's food roadmap. So can my right honourable friend explain how she is working with farmers to boost profitability? And might she consider a trip to North Buckinghamshire to hear from my farmers directly?
Speaker 5
I think my honourable friend the water minister went last week, so he's obviously trying to get a brace. The government's backing farm profitability through 11.8 billion pounds for sustainable farming and food production, investment in productivity and innovation, and action to make supply chains fairer. We're also working to open up new trading opportunities. The farming roadmap sets out how government will support farmers to cut costs, access markets, and build resilient businesses.
Mary Victoria Atkins
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Conservative DEFRA team met more than a hundred farmers in Berkshire this week ahead of budget to continue our two-year campaign against the family farm and the family business taxes. One farmer told us, I'm sat with a ticking time bomb and it's unsurvivable for me. I will have to sell the farm to pay the bill. This is despite the government's humiliating partial U-turn.
With six days to go before budget, can the Secretary of State explain why this Labour government is putting families through this?
Speaker 5
Well, Mr. Speaker, the issues around IHT were dealt with by my predecessor and there were it wasn't a humiliating U-turn. It was actually the result of listening to what people were telling us. And if she's wanting change and then she gets up here and describes a government change as a humiliating U-turn, then I'm not quite sure whose side she's on.
Speaker 44
I'm on the side of this government, I can tell her that now.
Now, while Labour were complaining about black Labradors and pubs at party conference, the Conservatives were listening to rural business owners. They are being squeezed at every turn: energy, water, heating oil, petrol, diesel, food prices, red tape and taxes are all up under this government. Now, the Secretary of State may have heard of two of them, Jeremy Clarkson and Cheerful Charlie. In fact, she stood Cheerful Charlie up three times. They asked the question at our conference that I hear in market towns and villages across the country under this government: why would anyone start a business in this country right now?
Speaker 5
Well, I think the right honourable lady has a bit of brass neck to stand up when she was in the Treasury and food inflation was at 19.1%. We know that some of the pressures on energy and power, which are putting such pressure on everybody across all aspects of our economy, are due to global instabilities and what's happening in the Middle East. And instead and on Cheerful Charlie, I met Cheerful Charlie and by the way, I didn't stand him up three times. There were some holes in the diary which they put in. So I've met him, he's a reasonable man.
I spend my time listening to farming communities and I'm not going to take any lessons from her.
Brian Patrick Hurley
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Flooding has caused damage to farmlands in my constituency this year, affecting crop yields and threatening food security. The NFU understands that the statutory instrument needed to establish a new internal drainage board will come before the House by the end of this year. So can the Minister confirm that timetable and commit to getting this resolved?
Emma Hardy
My honourable friend raises an important point and we intend to lay the statutory instrument by the end of this year, of course subject to parliamentary time.
Rebecca Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Since the Iran war began, fishermen have seen their fuel costs roughly double, but the Minister has offered no tailored support, instead pointing to schemes that existed long before the conflict began, including rebated red diesel, Marine Voyages Relief and the Fishing and Coastal Growth Fund. Meanwhile, Ireland, France, Spain, Italy and Germany have provided millions in fuel support to help fishermen catching food for their tables. When will the government stop making excuses and back Britain's farming industry?
Speaker 13
As a Member of Parliament that represents a coastal community, engaging with our fishing community is a priority of mine and that's why I've visited Cornwall and the South West on a number of occasions. Now, we are working with our fishing and seafood sector to secure a vibrant, profitable and sustainable future and to make sure that I continue to listen to industry on their demands and concerns.
Baggy Bhagat Shanker
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given the failures of the privatised water model to put interests of people and communities first, what steps has the Department taken to explore alternative ownership models such as mutualisation that would give communities a meaningful stake in the governance and accountability of water companies to ensure that people are put first and not profit?
Emma Hardy
Our Prime Minister is committed to introducing public control to the water sector and just last month we announced that we would remove such as outdated cap on government ownership of water companies. And later this year, our 10-year plan for Britain will set out plans for stronger public control over the water sector, making it work for people and places again.
John Whittingdale
As well as producing extremely fine wines, Maldon also produces excellent oysters and I would be delighted to welcome any of the ministerial team to visit.
But will the Department do more to promote the shellfish industry, and in particular, will they look to introduce a specific aquaculture qualification to try to attract more apprentices into the industry?
Speaker 13
The honourable member would have heard what I said earlier around the value of the SPS agreement, but more broadly, obviously, Seafish has a role to promote seafish around the world, and it was a real pleasure to be in Paris earlier this week at one of the largest food and drink expos promoting British products, including oysters.
Melanie Onn
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Staff at the Sewing Shop in Grimsby are keen to see the rapid introduction of the deposit return scheme. So when can we anticipate seeing it, and will the Minister be making sure that retailers do not derail this initiative?
Emma Hardy
I thank my honourable friend. Many of our older constituents, including my mum, remembers returning bottles to the recycling bank and receiving money for them. It made sense then, and it makes sense now. Significant progress has been made on the deposit return scheme, but of course, there's still lots of work to do.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Both public and private sector organisations experience sometimes year-long delays in obtaining permits from the Environment Agency to undertake desilting and other critical watercourse flood prevention work. So will a Minister meet with me to understand these issues and ensure resources are getting to where they're needed to keep our homes and businesses safe?
Emma Hardy
I thank the honourable gentleman for his question, and I'll make sure that the relevant Environment Agency area director meets with him to look at the concerns he's raised.
Sam Rushworth
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Farmers in my Bishop Auckland constituency are concerned about the rising cost of fertiliser, which risks making them uncompetitive. So could I ask the Minister on their behalf if she'll engage with the Treasury to consider delaying the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, and also doing more to ensure that we can develop domestic fertiliser that's low-carbon?
Speaker 13
I thank my honourable friend for his question. The government recognises the pressures facing farmers and the food and farming sector. Fertiliser CBAM liabilities are expected to be below 1% of current prices, with impacts on farmers very limited. Over time, CBAM, alongside domestic farming policy, will support the transition towards more resilient, low-carbon supply chains while maintaining food production.
Charlie Maynard
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss the legal opinion I co-commissioned outlining the legal grounds that could put Thames Water into special administration?
Speaker 5
Mr. Speaker, there are many legal opinions about this issue. I'm more than happy to ensure that he gets a meeting, but lawyers have very many different opinions.
Michelle Scrogham
Speaker, yesterday I attended an event on fixing the sewage in Lake Windermere. Would the Minister agree with me that United Utilities need to address the long-overdue flooding issues at Ulverston before they add additional pressure to that area of the system?
Emma Hardy
I thank my honourable friend for her question, and she's quite right that we need to start thinking about flooding and water management in a more holistic way. We're looking at early rollout of regional planning systems, which means we'll start to address the issues around water quality, flooding, and water scarcity in the same area. And she's quite right to hold water companies to account, excuse me, to deliver on the commitments that they have already made.
Alexander Carmichael
Mr. Speaker, as the government starts the process of redesigning the SFI, can I draw their attention to an initiative launched today by Aldi and ABP Processors, Grounded in Goodness, which is paying a premium to their beef producers? It's only 4.5 million and it's one supermarket, so it's not a panacea, but it's a good start.
It's rooted in the principles of simplicity, accessibility, and food production. As she redesigns the SFI, would that not be a good model to follow?
Speaker 5
Mr. Speaker, we did simplify the SFI this year after having inherited a scheme that had not only no budget control, but over 140 different actions. I am certainly looking and am more than happy to talk to the right honorable gentleman about the principles that he's outlined as we work towards introducing a simpler, easier-to-use scheme in 2027.
Marie Tidball
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I am deeply frustrated on behalf of our local Adele River that her family farm is currently included in the Sheffield local plan and wants to see it taken out, especially because inspectors' recent report says that that land is of higher quality than the plan currently rates it. Given the further main modifications consultation closes next week, does the minister agree with me that the quality of agricultural land should always be taken into account when considering local plan site allocations?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank my honorable friend for her question. The land use framework will help deliver faster, clearer, and more coordinated decisions on housing and infrastructure, ensuring our most productive farmland is safeguarded. As part of the implementation of the land use framework, we'll complete a technical review of the agricultural land classification system by 2028.
Speaker 76
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for squeezing me in. On the 7th of September, Natural England submitted the legal orders for a 30.5% expansion of the Surrey Hills National Landscape, which would transform biodiversity and nature protection in my area. That decision is now on the Secretary of State's desk. When will she make that decision, and would she like to come to the Surrey Hills to announce it and try out some of our fantastic local pubs?
Lindsay Hoyle
Well, I presume if it's a correct answer, then the local pubs will be more welcoming than if it isn't, but I'm happy to be in touch with the right honorable gentleman about how we proceed from here.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the Second Church Estates Commissioner is unable to be in her place today, and I'm answering her on her behalf. And with permission, Mr. Speaker, I'd like to group questions 1 and 8 together. The National Church Institutions are in regular contact with DCMS about the Places of Worship Renewal Fund's operation and is collecting feedback from parishes before the third round opens.
My honorable friends will, I hope, be reassured that DCMS has committed to evaluating the scheme in response to the Culture, Media, and Sport Select Committee inquiry on protecting the built environment.
Elsie Blundell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I am so proud to represent some wonderful churches across my constituency, from All Saints and Martyrs on Langley to St. Luke's in central Heywood, but many are in need of repair and renewal. Concerns have been raised with me about Historic England's decision-making process in terms of allocating the renewal fund and how some applicants in my deprived communities are, for now, gone without the vital repairs that they need. What steps are being taken by the Church to ensure that the socio-economic analysis is being done of each applicant before future funding decisions are made?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, and if I may say, my honorable friend is making a great job in representing her constituency and the churches and church communities in it. The fund, administered by Historic England, prioritizes areas of double deprivation, combining high socio-economic deprivation with low levels of local community infrastructure or resources in rural and urban places.
My honorable friend and other colleagues may wish to write to DCMS and Historic England if they have operational questions and feedback. The Church is also gathering experiences of clergy and parishes who've used the scheme, and this user experience is essential, Mr. Speaker, to understand how the scheme may be improved by Historic England.
Kevin Bonavia
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. St. Andrew and St. George's Church in Stevenage is the largest parish church in England built since the Second World War. And oh, question two, sorry.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, with your permission I'd like to group questions two and nine together. I thank my honorable friends for their continued support of our historic churches on both sides of the border, and as I noted in my previous answer, the Church remains in regular contact with DCMS regarding the operation of the Places of Worship Renewal Fund and continues to relay the concerns and experiences of clergy and parishes.
Kevin Bonavia
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, I'll start again. I'm delighted that St. Andrew and St. George's Church in Stevenage, the largest parish church built in England since the Second World War, has recently been awarded 882,255 pounds as part of the Places of Worship Renewal Fund, and that's helping the church undertake vital roof works. Would my right honorable friend inform me of any other financial support that would benefit this church and others in my constituency?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, and I'm delighted to hear that St. Andrew and St. George's were successful in their application, and I know that my honorable friend has raised this matter before. I understand that this grant will enable the church to remain open for worship and the community to use the facilities and museum for many years to come. I'll also ask that my honorable friend is sent a copy of the Historic England advisory note, which contains details of other funding sources for any other parishes in his constituency that may have not been successful in receiving grant money.
Douglas McAllister
Mr. Speaker, can the Commissioners confirm with the Secretary of State how much money has flowed to the Scottish Government in Barnett consequentials as a result of the new Places of Worship Renewal Fund, now that we're on the second round, and how much is anticipated will be passed to Scotland over the four years to reflect the 92 million pound total allocation to the Renewal Fund in England?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Honorable members will remember that the current scheme applies only in England as heritage policy is a devolved matter. The Church of England welcomes the decision of the Scottish Government to continue providing a VAT rebate scheme, which means that places of worship in Scotland now benefit from support that isn't available in England, Wales, or Northern Ireland. The Government has confirmed twice in written answers to the honorable member for Cumbernauld and Kilsyth on the 9th of March 2026, and again on the 12th of March 2026 to the honorable member for Edinburgh West, that Barnett consequentials were not separately identified as a dedicated budget line but formed part of a wider funding given to the Scottish Government.
Christopher Chope
Mr. Speaker, as the right honorable gentleman will know that the Places of Worship scheme are mass- is massively oversubscribed. And if they can have VAT allowances against repairs to historic places of worship in Scotland, why can't we have them in England, and wouldn't that be a much more direct way of helping repairs to and the costs of repairs for historic churches, and will he ensure that that provision is included in the budget?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, as I've said previously, it's important that the scheme operated. The current scheme is not only fit for purpose, but the best that we can make it, which is why DCMS are continuing to look at that. But I hear what he says, because it has been raised before about VAT. That is a matter for the Chancellor, and the honorable gentleman will have to wait to see what is in the budget. But I am about to announce a number of days for debate on the budget, and so the right honorable gentleman, I'm sure, will get an opportunity to raise that matter directly with the Chancellor.
Robert Jenrick.
Edward Robert Jenrick
Southminster, the cathedral of the diocese of Nottingham, is facing, in the words of the Dean, the greatest financial crisis in its history due to an enormous backlog of repairs. The Dean and Chapter are in touch with the Church Commissioners seeking an emergency financial support package, or else there is a very real prospect that the doors of the cathedral will have to close next year, which would obviously be a terrible step for all of us who love the building and see it as the center of worship for our county. If the Leader of the House were able to put some gentle pressure on the Church Commissioners to help us, that would be very much appreciated.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, none of us would want to see the possible outcome that the honorable, right honorable gentleman is referring to. And I will certainly take it up with the Second Commissioner to make sure that not only will the Church, I'm sure, have heard what he said today, but to do everything that we can to ensure that the outcome is the one that his constituents want.
Nick Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Happy to give my right honorable friend a whiff, as we say in the valleys. Parliament is taking action to reduce single-use plastics across our estate. This includes removing plastic bottled water from sale, eliminating around 120,000 of them each year. We have also replaced plastic straws and cutlery with more sustainable alternatives and increased the use of reusable and recyclable products.
Parliament has also introduced a packaging sustainability policy for our procurement. This incentivizes suppliers to reduce single-use plastics. We continue to look further for greater opportunities to reduce plastic consumption across our estate.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the honorable member for that very comprehensive answer. Falmouth Town Council in my constituency adopted Plastic Free Falmouth's plan to reduce single-use plastics across the town and at events in the town. I was therefore quite shocked when I came here and saw all the plastic cups, for example, in use across the estate. Will the Commission have a long-term similar plastic use reduction plan?
Nick Smith
Can I thank the honorable member for her question. As I just set out, Parliament has made significant progress in reducing single-use plastics across the estate. And as an example, to minimize the environmental impact, the single-use plastic cups are now made from biodegradable material, and we do bags of stuff on composting. We are, though, not complacent, and we will continue to identify further opportunities to reduce unnecessary plastic use. So could I thank her for raising the question, and I'll ask officers to come back to us both on our plastic use reduction plan.
Jill Mortimer.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Church of England educates more than a million children in 4,700 schools. Church schools are committed to nurturing the knowledge, skills, character, and confidence of young people needed to flourish, helping them discover their gifts, serve their communities, and lead purposeful lives. These schools are rooted in a vision of a rounded education which seeks to ensure that every learner, including those with special education needs and disabilities, can aspire, achieve, and access opportunities to reach their full potential.
Julie Minns
I thank him for that answer, and I put on record my thanks to all the Church of England schools in my constituency for the excellent work they do. The Diocese of Carlisle's Northern Young Leaders Project gives young adults the opportunity to spend a year developing leadership, ministry, and workplace skills through placements in churches and community projects. Could I ask what support might be available from the Church to help dioceses expand programs such as this so that more young people can gain the skills and experience that are needed for future employment?
Lucy Maria Powell
First of all, echo my honorable friend's thanks to everyone involved in the schools in her constituency, and I would make that point about my own, but also Church schools across our country. As my honorable friend has mentioned, there are some good examples of work in the Carlisle Diocese to support young people, such as Trinity School, which supports pupils into further education and employment, helping grow young people's confidence and develop skills for the local labor market. It's important that our young people are supported as they look to enter the workforce, and I encourage parishes and local churches to explore local opportunities to better provide this support for young people in their community. And with permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll ask the Second Commissioner to write to her about the Northern Young Leaders Project.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank very much the Leader of the House for that answer? In February, the General Synod voted in favor of further mental health training materials for Church schools and children's groups. Providing young people with spiritual and emotional support can make a huge difference as they prepare to leave education and enter work. In my own constituency of Strangford, Christian organizations such as Young Life provide weekly clubs for young people across the Ards Peninsula, offering mentorship and opportunities to develop their confidence and their leadership skills.
So what steps will the Commissioner take to ensure that mental health support is central to the Church's work in equipping young people with the skills that they need to transition from education to work? Thanks a lot.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, the honorable gentleman raises a very important point about mental health. And of course, it's in very much in line with what the government is trying to do to ensure that young people have the support that they need. I thank his schools for showing leadership in this regard, and there are of course many across the country that are doing that. I will ask the Second Commissioner if she will get the honorable gentleman an update on what is anticipated going forward.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The National Church Institutions have reviewed the duty to report in the Crime and Policing Act 2026 and considers its existing policies, code of practice, reporting expectations regarding safeguarding are compliant with the new duty. The Church will continue to keep its guidance under review as its new as the new statutory duty is implemented. Since 2016, all Church officers have a mandatory reporting requirement to promptly report safeguarding concerns, allegations, and disclosures of abuse to the appropriate safeguarding authorities.
Speaker 85
I thank my honorable friend for his reply. General Synod papers from June claim that, to use their phrase, it is now clear that the Crime and Policing Act's duty to report child sexual abuse does not apply to religious confessionals. That comes despite many reassurances from the Home Office to me and the honorable member for Wells during the passage of the Act that confessionals would not be exempted. So what discussions has the Church had with the Home Office to inform its current position?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for this question. He has spoken over a period of time very powerfully since joining this House about the importance of safeguarding, and I thank him for that.
It is the role of this chamber to scrutinize the Church and I'm sure the Second Commissioner welcomes his continued scrutiny of this aspect of the Church. We all need to continue to do better to address safeguarding. The protection of children and vulnerable adults remains the Church's first priority. They're committed to preventing abuse and ensuring survivors are heard with compassion and care. He asks a specific point Mr Speaker about discussions between the Home Office and the Church.
I'm not across that for fairly obvious reasons I think but I will ensure that he gets an update from the Second Commissioner which I hope will answer the points that he raises.
Tessa Munt
Thank you Mr Speaker. The Church's own safeguarding bishop has said that mandatory reporting should take precedence over confidence passed under the seal of confession which is to be lauded. Confession is not a regulated activity as defined under the Police and Crime Act. So does the right honorable gentleman agree with the Bishop of Tewkesbury when he says and I quote "the responsibility is firmly in our court, their court". And can he set out what steps the Church will take to make sure that happens.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr Speaker in line with what I just said to my honorable friend if the honorable lady who speaks very powerfully on these matters would put what she is saying in writing to the Second Commissioner I'm sure that she will take it up with the Church to make sure that that view is heard and to get the answer to the question that she seeks.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thank you very much Mr Speaker. The Local Government Boundary Commission paused boundary reviews in areas affected by local government reorganization proposals in February of last year. So the government's recent review of those proposals has not had any immediate practical impact. The Commission will return to those boundary reviews when the reorganization proposals are resolved.
Blake Stephenson
Can I thank my right honorable friend for that answer. The government's management of local government reorganization must have cost the taxpayer in all millions of pounds. Can my right honorable friend advise whether there is a financial cost also to the Local Government Boundary Commission if not on the floor of the House today in writing.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I will certainly write to my honorable friend if there's anything to add to what I'm about to say but as he will appreciate the delay will have practical impact because all those waiting for such a review will have to wait rather longer but the boundary review can only review proposals for change when a new authority is legally established and that of course hasn't happened yet.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr Speaker in October 2026 the Archbishops' Council approved a detailed operating model for independent safeguarding structures in the Church of England following seven months of development by the safeguarding structures program board.
Emma Lewell
I thank my right honorable friend for that answer but it is now over three years since Professor Alexis Jay's recommendations for a fully independent safeguarding system in the Church. I understand legislation to enact this is not due until 2028. Can my right honorable friend say what can be done to accelerate this process as any system that lacks full independence is not one that can claim it is adequately meeting its safeguarding requirements.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you Mr Speaker. As usual my honorable friend makes a very powerful point on behalf of the community that she serves. Further details Mr Speaker about the new model of safeguarding structures will be published shortly. The new model provides for the establishment of an independent safeguarding authority governed by a majority independent board of trustees with responsibility for safeguarding policy, risk assessment, audit, inspection and national casework operations.
But I will, Mr. Speaker, ask my honorable friend, the Second Commissioner, to write to my other honorable friend with more details.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question to ask the Secretary of State if he will make a statement on the deployment of RAF Typhoon aircraft to defend Saudi Arabia and the extension of air-to-air refuelling support for the Saudi air operations, including those against Houthi targets in Yemen.
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm grateful for the right honorable member's question today and for the opportunity to update the House on the UK government's support to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as they respond to increased Houthi aggression in Saudi Arabia and the government of Yemen. The whole House will have seen images of the attacks on civilian airports in Riyadh and the hundreds of casualties those Houthi attacks have caused. The government fully supports the right of Saudi Arabia and the legitimate government of the Republic of Yemen to defend themselves. However, we know there is no long-term military solution to this conflict.
The support we have announced is designed to help our partners at this critical moment while supporting efforts to create the conditions for a political resolution to the conflict. Because while many of our constituents may feel that this is something that is far away, we must be clear about the direct consequences for the United Kingdom. The Red Sea and the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait are among the world's most important maritime trade routes. Continued instability increases costs for British families and businesses while also undermining security across the Middle East. Helping that part of the world be more secure and stable is firmly in the United Kingdom's national security and economic interests.
As this House will know, we have already been providing Saudi Arabia with air defense support and air-to-air refuelling for defensive Saudi Arabia air operations. The Prime Minister has now authorized additional military support. We're extending the provision of air-to-air refuelling to 90 days. RAF Typhoon aircraft will conduct defensive counter-air operations from Saudi Arabia. These aircraft will operate in a defensive role and will not conduct offensive strikes.
We will also make an RAF A400 aircraft available to support the movement of materiel within Saudi Arabia in support of defense. Mr. Speaker, we also remain deeply concerned by the humanitarian situation in Yemen and the suffering experienced by civilians. And also alongside military support, we continue our diplomatic efforts, humanitarian assistance, and work to encourage political negotiations. Finally, Mr. Speaker, all partners receiving UK assistance must comply fully with their obligations under international law. We will continue to monitor and assess this as part of our ongoing engagement.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you for granting this UQ. I'm sorry that it was necessary because there is a long-standing convention in this place that the opposition and in fact other ministers, shadow ministers, are briefed on the basis of the Privy Council in order to understand what is going on before there are military deployments overseas. Clearly that seems to have fallen out of practice, and those of us, including my honorable and gallant friend who sits opposite me today, who have served in uniform and have briefed members of the opposition, should remember that sometimes we find ourselves on opposite benches in a few years' time. It's good to get these habits back in. May I just say briefly, Mr. Speaker, why this is so important and why it is me and not my honorable friend who is sitting beside me who is asking this question?
Well, this is a political decision. This is a political judgment. This is not purely a military deployment, but this is a judgment on how to use the defensive arm of His Majesty's government and how it should be used and where it should go. Now this is a question that the Foreign Office is best asked to coordinate. And the reality is what we're instead getting is piecemeal process and not a strategy for success.
So where is, for example, the action in the United Nations? Where are the sanctions on the Houthis, who should be designated as a terrorist group? Where are the coordinating actions with others in the region? We've got the state visit of the Sultan of Oman today, and he's one of Britain's most important regional partners. But where are the voices coordinating our actions around not just Yemen, not just the United Arab Emirates or Saudi Arabia, but the whole of the Arabian Peninsula to respond to Iran's hostility?
Because we've seen the regime in Tehran killing hundreds of thousands, perhaps even millions of Sunni Muslims over the last half century since that poisonous creed of Khomeinism infected Tehran. And this isn't an isolated incident. It's a pattern of violence. And we've seen it pushing up energy prices in the United Kingdom. And as winter approaches, with our energy so low, our storage so short, although the Jackdaw decision is the right one, it's a bit late and it's not going to make a huge difference this winter, but it does make Rosebank all the more urgent.
So let me just ask a few direct questions. First, what actions has he or his cabinet colleagues taken to coordinate actions with allies in the region? Second, what support has been given to the defense of Cyprus, given Iran's Hezbollah proxy attacking our bases recently? What plans are there to designate the Houthis as a terrorist organization? Fourth, what actions are planned at the UN to call out Iranian aggression alongside their Russian and Chinese enablers?
Speaker 93
Fifth, last one, Mr. Speaker. Fifth, will the Secretary of State commit to briefings before deployments, before and finally, will the Secretary of State confirm that despite his...
Speaker 91
It's two minutes, you're now on three. I think the Minister will have grasped what you needed to. Minister.
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And it is indeed a great privilege to respond to my right honorable and gallant friend, and especially on this day, the first day of remembrance. I know there are differences in when we think it's right to put on the poppy. Just to acknowledge, I'm just because I was selling them this morning and to, you know, not to make a political point because we recognize that remembrance is important and it's something that we both care about. So just important for us to set this out.
And similarly, the right honorable member has been a doughty champion for the people of the government of Yemen. He's spoken on it many times. I've sat in the chamber and listened to him and I recognize that all the questions that he is asking are from a good place and he is deeply impassioned and very well informed on this matter. With regard to the situation that I'm here to respond to, it's very clear that the Prime Minister set out the strategic parameters and the arrangements in which any military operation would work. And that should answer the preponderance of the questions that he asked at the beginning.
The Secretary of State, when adjusting that military contribution, did so in a written ministerial statement. And I am very grateful to be sat in front of him today, Mr. Speaker, wearing my Royal Air Force tie, speaking about the those people that have brave soldiers, service personnel that have deployed on behalf of ourselves and to provide support to allies across the region. Because it is in our national interest to ensure that our allies in the region receive support when they ask, and we've set out that support, and it's something that we should be rightly proud of.
Nick Smith
Mr. Speaker, Houthi aggression fans the flames in that region. So can the Minister tell us more about the diplomatic measures in hand to help with this crucial situation?
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So the ongoing there is ongoing arrangements with our allies within the region within the region. I'm very grateful to be joined alongside me by a member from the Foreign Office who has been engaged closely and actively with our members with our allies within the region. Should he wish to have receive additional detail, that we can provide in writing.
Speaker 97
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The spiralling conflict between the Houthis and Saudi Arabia is deeply concerning. Further escalation risks intensifying regional instability at a time when the wider Middle East is already facing the devastating consequences of the US-Israel and Iran wars. While defensive assistance from the RAF is the correct response to Houthi attacks, the government must be clear about the limits of British involvement. Can the Secretary of Minister, sorry, inform the House how long it is expected to continue and what safeguards are in place to prevent the UK becoming embroiled in a prolonged regional conflict?
Diplomatic efforts must remain the priority. Britain should be working alongside its allies and regional partners to reduce tensions and prevent this crisis from widening further. We must also protect vital shipping routes through the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, currently threatened by Houthi attacks. The disruption to the Strait of Hormuz has shown us just how far-reaching the consequences of threats to international shipping can be, affecting British households as well as businesses. So can the Minister confirm what discussions are taking place with international partners to prepare for any future escalation and ensure freedom of navigation through the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait is maintained?
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll try and keep it brief this time. Continued instability risks disrupting global trade and energy supplies for British families and businesses. And therefore I reiterate it's very important that the UK continues to provide support to our allies. You would you all know that within the statement that we speak of an extension to the air-to-air refuelling capabilities out to 90 days, but we do not provide additional details which may place our soldiers and service personnel in harm's way.
Christopher Paul Webb
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I first thank the Minister for confirming that these aircraft will operate in a defensive role and not conduct any off defensive strikes to the Houthis. But can I ask the Minister if he shares my concerns that regional instability and the conflict in the Gulf can have serious implications at home, driving up the cost of living, disrupting energy supplies and rising cost of businesses.
to invest in that aircraft now and invest in that supply line in BAE Systems in Lancashire and across the UK.
Calvin George Bailey
Thanks, thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and my honorable friend is a doughty champion for our the brave soldiers and air aviators of the Royal Air Force who are operating the Typhoons within the region. And he is right to highlight the significant investment, half a billion pounds in upgrades on the Typhoon aircraft that this government agreed to earlier in the year, which is which is essential to ensure that when our people are deployed in circumstances such as these, they have world-leading capabilities that have been invested in by this government.
Speaker 99
He also mentioned a new order for aircraft, but we'll put that to one side for a moment. Mr. Speaker, can I just say to the honorable right honorable gentleman, and I don't mean this personally, but I do not know what has happened to government when they deploy British servicemen and women abroad, they should be making a statement to the House no matter what time of the day or night it is. Back in 1999, I remember the then Deputy Leader of the Labour government coming to the dispatch box at around about 9:00 PM when the then Prime Minister Tony Blair deployed RAF aircraft to Montenegro. Now, he knew his responsibilities and the government has failed on this quite explicitly. And I also ask the right honorable gentleman, why are they misusing this word defense endlessly now, not wanting to talk about what they have to do?
How do you defend against a ballistic missile once it is launched unless you attack the site that is launching it? This is a nonsense at the end of the day, we need to be honest with the British public. I'm not against them being deployed to defend by offensive action, but surely that makes greater logic than pretending they're only there to defend.
Calvin George Bailey
Minister. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's a multiplicity of questions within the question, the first of which, the first of which is about the about the deployment and why a statement wasn't made. Well, I made very clear that the strategic parameters were set out by the Prime Minister, that the deployment was laid down by the Secretary of State, and I'm very pleased to be here today to talk about the extension of an existing employment. This isn't anything new.
With regards to the word defensive, as a person with a as a gallant and significant military background and my neighboring MP, you will understand that a lay that he will understand that a layered air defense system is exactly that and defensive counter-air is a capability. We are not conducting strikes, there is no capability to conduct strikes, and therefore it is not something that we're seeking to present in any other way than it is.
James Mark Sewards
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to support the government's decision to deploy this defensive operation against the Houthis. I do know that the Minister will be aware that Britain's former ambassador to Yemen has called for proscription of the Houthis, and I do absolutely agree with him on that point. It would allow us to criminalize fundraising and support for the Houthis, disrupt any operations on UK soil, as well as freeze their assets. So what conversations has he had with his counterparts in the Home Office about proscribing the Iranian-backed threat that is the Houthis?
Calvin George Bailey
Minister. I thank my honorable friend for his remarks and for his concern for Yemen. And it's important that we remember that the reason for this is to seek a ceasefire and to allow the United Nations to come in and provide humanitarian support to those people in Yemen. We do not comment on future measures, but I will offer that we are considering all options and and offer perhaps a meeting with the member sat next to me.
John Whittingdale
Sir John Whittingdale.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I support the deployment of British forces in support of our Saudi Arabian allies. But as has become clear, the distinction between offensive and defensive support is pretty fuzzy at best. And can he say what assessment has been made of the possible increased threat to British nationals, both civilian and military, in the region, and what is being done to meet that?
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And again, first, it's important to recognize that advice to those British nationals in the region is issued by the FCDO, and I urge all of those people deployed within the region to pay attention to the announcements from their consul, the consular announcements. In terms of offensive and defensive, these are very well-known and doctrined parts of military operation. And so when I use the language defensive counter-air, that is entirely what that is meant to do. And unless anyone wants to rewrite doctrine, which I would take great pleasure in contributing to, that remains what we have deployed and that's what we intend, how we intend to deliver our military capabilities.
Kevin Bonavia
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable and gallant friend is right to set out the government's position in supporting our allies because they are taking on terrorists. And these terrorists are not just a threat to our allies in the region, they are a threat to ourselves. We have the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, and we have taken action there before. And I would like the assurance of my honorable and gallant friend that we will do all it takes to work with our allies in the region to make sure that our national interest, not just that of our friends in the region, are protected going forward.
Calvin George Bailey
I thank my honorable friend for his question and show of concern. We unequivocally condemn Houthi attacks. We fully support the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the legitimate government of Yemen to defend themselves, protect their territory and their civilian populations. We cannot allow international shipping to be threatened or held to ransom. And as he recognizes, that instability in that region, disrupting trade routes and energy supplies, increases the costs to British families and businesses here at home in the UK.
Speaker 111
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Houthis in Yemen have been largely quiet for four years. But of course, Yemen is one of those disastrous areas where humanitarian aid is desperately needed. Now that the Houthis have come out and really attacked at the behest of Iran, what action is the government taking to build a coalition of forces to actually defeat the Houthis, not contain them, but actually defeat them, so that the threat they have to the region is minimized or eradicated? Because the reality is that Iran is ordering the position to disrupt the shipping lanes of the world.
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you. I know the honorable member has again been someone that's spoken on these matters with great passion and consistency during my time in the House. We urge the Houthis to return to a UN-led political pathway, and we will continue to work with regional allies. But it's also important that we provide them the support that allows the space and capacity to engage in that activity and to provide the much-needed sanctuary for the Yemeni people.
Tessa Munt
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We are constantly reminded of the importance of plans and planning. So can I ask the Minister what specific political and diplomatic conditions would need to be met for the government to withdraw this defense support and how Parliament will be kept informed on progress?
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you. Well, we insist that all the support that is received from the UK is in accordance with the international with international law and IHL. It's a great privilege of mine to have worked in the department as part of the application of such process in the past and so I feel with great well I'm very comfortable in knowing that our processes ensure that I can speak here with great comfort that we will ensure that those processes are met and that our rules and values are upheld by allies and partners.
James Wild
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In April last year, the RAF joined the US Operation Rough Rider to degrade Houthi ballistic missile and drone attacks and at the time I asked the Secretary of State to make sure that that was sustained action rather than ad hoc action. Does he regret that it wasn't sustained? And if defensive action does not include striking potential launch sites, how will it make any difference at all?
Calvin George Bailey
Well, I think providing defensive counter-air to prevent attacks on airports and civilian structures is a fairly significant offering and that is essential to providing safety and support and sanctuary to those people that are working in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to support the government of Yemen.
Charles de Joshua.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I support I support the decision to to stand alongside our allies in Saudi Arabia. The additional deployment requires sufficient resourcing. So will the Minister confirm that despite the former Secretary of State and now Chancellor saying in his resignation letter that the Ministry of Defence needs 3% by 2030, the MOD spokesman's comments yesterday state that that commitment is not going to be met by that date?
Calvin George Bailey
When we make deployments such as this, they are taken with they are taken well the the question, Mr. Speaker, if I remember, the reason why I'm here is to discuss our deployment in in in Yemen. And so in response to that question, the the thing that the honorable member would need to be assured of is that our military commanders are content that they can meet this deployment and they can meet the other tasks that we have set out for them.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Minister very much for for his answers and also welcome government's response and and support for Saudi Arabia. I understand that this operation is intended to provide defensive support only. I'm reminded of the Red Sea crisis in 2023-2025 when defensive action to protect UK shipping from Houthi attacks escalated into offensive strikes against Houthi targets. So what assessment has the Minister and government made of the risk that British forces may be directly targeted, causing further escalation and drawing the United Kingdom into a wider regional conflict?
Thank you.
Minister.
Calvin George Bailey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I always love the opportunity to talk about my past service and commitment and on opportunities. As I said before, the we do not discuss the parameters of the assessments that are made that will that could impact the safety and security of our military personnel. We know that our military commanders are comfortable with the deployment and their responsibility towards the people and I just want to thank those brave soldiers and service personnel that are deployed on our behalf within the region delivering these missions and operations.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and forgive my alacrity before the honorable member had spoken. May I seek your guidance and advice on ensuring that the government does inform this House before military operations, doesn't have to be dragged here with your indulgence for an urgent question when there is a clear need for this House to be able to debate the actions of His Majesty's government in order to support our forces who we all support, and I respect his service and I'm sure he respects all those on this side as well. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Lindsay Hoyle
I didn't really want to be dragged into it, but obviously one gets dragged into it. Previous governments have stated that a convention has developed that before troops are committed, the House of Commons should have an opportunity to debate the matter. I personally do think an oral ministerial statement on this would have been helpful, but this is ultimately the decision for the government to make. I will leave it at that and I don't want to be dragged any further. Let us let from bench changeover.
Speaker 113
Right, we now come to business questions, Shadow Leader of the House, Jesse Norman.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Leader give the House the forthcoming business?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The business for the week commencing the 26th of October will include Monday the 26th of October, debate on a motion on the performance of Royal Mail, followed by a general debate on the emerging risks of advanced AI, the subject for these debates determined by the Backbench Business Committee. Tuesday the 27th of October, second reading of the Building Safety Remediation of Unsafe Cladding Bill. Wednesday the 28th of October, my right honorable friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer will deliver his budget statement. Thursday the 29th of October, continuation of the budget debate.
Friday the 30th of October, the House will not be sitting. The provisional business for the week commencing the 2nd of November includes Monday the 2nd of November, continuation of the budget debate. Tuesday the 3rd of November, conclusion of the budget debate. And on Wednesday the 4th of November, remaining stages of the Sporting Events Bill Lords. The House will then rise for the November recess at the conclusion of business on Wednesday the 4th of November and return on Tuesday the 10th of November.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Thank you, and I thank the Leader very much for that business. Mr. Speaker, as the Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition and others mentioned yesterday, in this week of the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster, let us never forget its victims, including 116 children, and its terrible cost to their families and their community. On a far happier note, the House will shortly come together in celebration of the Clerk on his retirement. But let me pay a personal tribute now to Tom for his unfailing genius, sense of service and courtesy to the House and the assistance he's given us all as members over 30 years. As a jobbing trumpeter coming very much from the opposite end of the quality spectrum, I can testify that Tom is a superb jazz pianist.
And like any great jazzer, he's got a remarkable ability to improvise under pressure while never losing sight of the underlying material, as in the gig, so at the table. That's no small achievement with 650 would-be Miles Davises all playing in different keys.
Some, Mr. Speaker, more in tune than others. Among Tom's heroes, Art Tatum was famous for taking a familiar tune and turning it into something almost unrecognizable. Tom has often performed the reverse feat with members' legislative amendments, taking something almost unrecognizable and turning it into something more familiar. Mr. Speaker, I hope you and the Leader will forgive another toot from me on my constituency trumpet, but this week has seen the publication of a brilliantly positive new report by Policy Exchange on NMITE, our new engineering university in Hereford. Among other things, it highlights that thanks to its accelerated degrees, it offers at least 20% better value for money for students than elsewhere, and for local students, it's almost half the cost of an equivalent chartered engineering degree anywhere else.
But the report goes further, and I think this is a matter of general interest to the House. It identifies 57 suitable towns and cities across the UK, places such as Hartlepool, Grimsby, Barnsley, Burnley, Scunthorpe in the north alone, in which this model could be rolled out across the country. Again, I'd be delighted to discuss with colleagues how we could do this with any areas and constituencies that may be interested. I end, if I may, on a more serious note. In May 2024, Lord Walney's report, Protecting Our Democracy from Coercion, made over 40 recommendations to tackle political intimidation and disruptive extremism.
Two years into its term of office, more than two years, this government has yet to respond fully. Indeed, ministers abolished Lord Walney's position last year. When they did so, they promised that his report would continue to shape the government's approach to political violence. Yet they rejected key recommendations in passing the Crime and Policing Act, including stronger powers to prevent particularly harmful marches. And they did that despite very strong appeals from Jewish community groups facing the present rising tide of anti-Semitism, and who are still more concerned, be it said, after the Green Party's appalling resolution that Zionism is racism.
The threat is clear, and I know this is an issue of particular concern to you, Mr. Speaker, on behalf of all of us. 96% of members of Parliament responding to the Speaker's conference in 2025 reported harassment, intimidation, or abuse. It's a matter of public record that last September arson destroyed the constituency office of one of our colleagues, and that another and their son received death threats. Peaceful protest is fundamental to democracy, of course. But so is the right of every person to live free from intimidation, and so is the right of every elected representative to be able to serve, and their staff, elected representatives and their staff, to be able to serve without intimidation, abuse, and coercion.
So will the Leader of the House ask the Home Secretary to publish a full recommendation-by-recommendation response to Lord Walney's report, and will he arrange a debate in government time on that response so that this House can collectively scrutinize what the government is doing and proposes to do to meet these dreadful threats?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I first of all join with the right honorable gentleman and as he says, the leaders of all parties in reflecting on the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster, which was 60 years ago yesterday.
We remember 116 children and 28 adults who tragically lost their lives when Tip 7 collapsed onto Pantglas Junior School and nearby homes, and pay tribute to the incredible courage of the rescuers and the enduring resilience of the Aberfan community. And I think it's fair to say, Mr. Speaker, because you and I are contemporaries, we are old enough, I am old enough to remember the disaster. We have been fortunate enough to live 60 years of our lives that 116 of our contemporaries were unable to do so, is to say the least sobering, but actually is a tragedy. And I want to put our thoughts with the Aberfan community and families on record. Before I turn to the other comments of the Shadow Leader, Mr. Speaker, I also want to mention Andy King, the former Member of Parliament for Rugby and Kenilworth from 1997 to 2005, who sadly passed away this week, and I'm sure the whole House joins me in sending our condolences to his friends and family.
I am also sure that the whole House will join me in condemning the horrific attack on the Australian independent MP, Dr. Helen Haines, which took place outside her electoral office. My thoughts are with Dr. Haines, her family and her team as she recovers from this appalling assault. On lighter matters, I want to extend my congratulations, I'm sure the House's congratulations, to the Member for Boston and Skegness on his recent marriage, and also further congratulations to the Shadow Secretary of State for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, who announced the birth of her son this week, and we wish them well. Mr. Speaker, today marks the start of the 2026 Royal British Legion Poppy Appeal, as thousands of volunteers gather across our country to distribute the red poppy. They raise funds for our brave service personnel, veterans and their families, and we thank them all for everything that they do.
Turning to other matters, Mr. Speaker, this summer has was filled with record high temperatures, but as we are seeing, winter is now drawing in, and the changing climate will bring more severe and uncertain weather in the years to come, and we need to make sure that we are fully prepared across the NHS, our transport system and our energy security. I think it's fair to say, and it's not a party political point, I think it's just true, that the UK has been a bit of an outlier really in not looking sufficiently and not sufficiently early at this right across government, and I just want to reassure the House that we are putting that right. Also, Mr. Speaker, we've taken a crucial step forward this week in protecting motorists from unfair enforcement and car sales scams with a new private parking code of practice, providing motorists right the right to challenge unfair private parking charges, and this has been an issue which has been raised with me several times at business questions. And also, Mr. Speaker, potholes are an issue frequently raised by to me by members in this forum, and data published today shows that more than 7,000 miles of road resurfacing has taken place this year, up 10% on last year, but clearly there is more to do. And on another theme, with your indulgence, Mr. Speaker, we've also I've also faced questions on matters of heritage and restoration, and I just want to mention my constituents Kevin and Alison Wilson, who've been involved in the successful restoration of Cullercoats Watchtower, who are joining us in the House today.
Let me turn to the points that the honorable gentleman raised, first of all about the success of further and higher education higher education in his constituency. And I have said this before, and I'm happy to repeat it, I absolutely commend the honorable gentleman for his work, which has been recognized as a really an excellent model, and as he says, I hope that other areas will look at that.
The higher education sector is an engine of an economic growth in his area and elsewhere and providers play an essential role in training students not just for jobs now but for the future. I'm very happy if he wishes that I'm sure he's spoken to them already. If he wishes to speak to ministers to discuss this matter further. But I just want to put that on record because he's right to raise it in the way that he does. This is not or it shouldn't be a party political matter.
This side of the house can learn from best experience from the other side of the house as well. And that is very much in keeping with the practical approach that the Prime Minister wants to see across a number of policies. He then raises another very important matter Mr. Speaker on the issue of the security and tackling and preparing against terrorism. And of course Mr. Speaker there is the speaker's conference which is of crucial importance. There is also the defending democracy task force that continues to look at these issues.
On the specific point about Lord Walney's reports let me take that away Mr. Speaker and raise it with ministers and see if there is something that the Home Secretary needs to come back to the house to update the house on or indeed to update the right honorable gentleman. But let me make it absolutely clear that we stand with all faiths including and particularly the Jewish faith as they come under sustained attack. And it's just a sad fact that both antisemitism and Islamophobia have increased in recent months. The government is absolutely committed to tackling that. That means putting money into the physical protection of places of worship but it also means making social cohesion a top priority.
And I would just finally point out that Sir David Bell's review of this week on antisemitism and how schools need to do more going forward is an excellent piece of work and the government intends to accept all 27 recommendations.
Catherine Eccles
Thank you Mr. Speaker. At Russells Hall Hospital which serves my constituency many patients visitors and staff have reported receiving parking charge notices despite correctly registering and paying for their parking. The hospital car park is managed by Group Nexus a private company and those receiving fines include blue badge holders and even a priest who was administering last rites. Does he agree with me that Dudley NHS Trust needs to investigate this urgently and ensure the government's new parking private parking code is followed so that my constituents are not unfairly penalized by private parking enforcement systems.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker and the issue parking as I said has been raised with me many times in these sessions and NHS trusts are responsible for car parking charges and are also expected to follow the NHS car parking guidance. As she rightly identifies some hospitals do use private companies and as I said earlier there is a new code of practice. I hope that her trust has heard her concerns today but also that other trusts look at this as well to ensure that as the new code of practice comes in that they are fulfilling their obligations.
Bobby Dean
Thank you Mr. Speaker. And can I join the leader of the house in this reflection on Aberfan disaster. Our thoughts are with all those affected and indeed the whole community. And before I begin on what I wanted to focus on today can I just say how deeply concerned it was to hear a US envoy last night describe Vladimir Putin as a humanitarian just as Russia continues to bomb Ukraine.
I sincerely hope that the government will be moving quickly to condemn those comments and they'll make time to progress the Russia Frozen Assets Bill brought forward by my colleague, the member for Bicester and Woodstock. Closer to home, the NHS Alliance has sparked a row amongst health professionals this week as it said that up to 20 maternity units may have to close in England. The Alliance make the case that the shortage of doctors and the increase in C-sections means that consolidation will be necessary to keep mothers and babies safe. But obstetricians and midwives are saying that having maternity services close to home is critical and these workforce issues must be addressed in a different way. Now, in my own constituency of Carshalton and Wallington, the women's health unit, including the maternity unit, is facing closure not due to clinical reasons, but because of aging pipework and issues with the water quality.
And this is particularly stinging for us as a local community because we've known about issues with the building for years and the promise of a new building keeps being delayed. So can the Leader of the House organize for a debate on the future of maternity services in this country? I am aware there's an adjournment debate later today, but that doesn't give full opportunity to MPs from across the House to explore this issue in full, and I hope he'll make government time to have this debate in full.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I hope the honorable gentleman will understand why I'm not going to specifically comment on the comments that he referred to earlier, but everyone will have heard what he thinks about it, and I'm sure many will share his concern. The government is doing everything that we can to assist the efforts to get peace in Ukraine, but again to put on record, we're absolutely committed to supporting Ukraine, not just in terms of the equipment that we send, but every avenue that we can to support Ukraine we will use, as was evident when the President Zelenskyy visited recently. He turns, he mentions maternity services, and he's right that every woman deserves safe maternity care, and the Secretary of State has made this issue a personal priority, Mr. Speaker. We need to make sure that services are there for women and families across the country when they need them.
And through the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce, the government will deliver the reforms needed to maternity care. I know it's an issue that he has raised before, it has been raised at health questions, and as he says, there is a debate later today, but I'll make sure that the Secretary of State hears his concerns and I'll give some thought as to whether or not a debate is necessary on the floor of the House.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Grade II listed Old Courthouse in Cockermouth still lies half-collapsed in the River Cocker, with the owner yet to demonstrate either the means or the desire to lift a finger. I ask the Leader of the House, agree to a debate in government time so members can discuss the issue of neglected heritage buildings, an issue of importance across the country.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And this is an issue that a number of members have raised from time to time, and I understand their concern and also the concern of constituents where buildings can blight local communities, which is why in some areas we're making sure that communities not only have the resources but are able to make decisions themselves about what they do with such buildings. I hope the owner of the building has heard what my honorable friend has said today and hope he gets on and does something about it. But if he wishes to expand on the points that he wishes to raise, then a Westminster Hall debate, an adjournment debate, would give him ample opportunity.
Speaker 111
Speaker, I thank the Leader for announcing business, and clearly backbench business in the chamber here will be only coming up apart from Monday after we come back from the recess. If we are granted Thursday the 12th of November, we'll have select committee statements from the Health and Social Care Committee and on behalf of the Defense Committee, followed by a debate on the 110th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme, followed by a debate on the Nolan Principles, which I think are something that many people have asked for.
The business in Westminster Hall on Tuesday the 27th, there'll be a debate on recognising the production and serving of cask ale as intangible cultural heritage. On the 29th, Thursday the 29th, debates on mandatory safeguarded 24/7 helipads at major trauma centres, followed by a debate on role and effectiveness of Ofcom. On the Tuesday the 3rd of November, there'll be a debate on the findings of the Milburn review. And when we come back after the recess, there'll be a debate on anti-social behaviour on Tuesday the 10th. Just to remind members that because we're on Monday hours, that debate will start at 11:30, not 9:30 as usual.
Could I also just make a gentle nudge to the leader that we are still awaiting the extra Labour member on the Backbench Business Committee. We're carrying one of our, one of the, one of the government members is on long-term deployment in the armed forces, and another colleague has been had, well, had a terrible accident and therefore is on crutches and finds it difficult to get to meetings. So we are having challenges on making sure we're quorate to consider the business. Now, Mr Speaker, the situation in Nepal continues to be catastrophic. And often what happens when there's a disaster such as the flooding, everyone says we must do something, and then afterwards nothing else happens.
So I want to pay tribute to Benji and Nick Gould, two young boys aged 11 and 9, who at the Harrow Wall Climbing Centre climbed the equivalent of going to the Everest Base Camp. They raised three and a half thousand pounds towards the charity. I think we should congratulate them, and I'm sure the leader would join me in congratulating them, and also say that we need to continue our work to assist the great people of Nepal.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr Speaker. On the matter of the extra Labour member, it's good that he has nudged me. I will recommit to doing something about it. He will understand that we've just had a major reshuffle and therefore we're trying to fill a number of vacancies. We're making progress with that.
That's not an excuse for not having the extra person for his committee, it's just an explanation of where we were. And I give him my word that I will go away and have a look at that. And I should have started off by saying thank you to him and the committee for the work that they are doing. I will confirm the future business as soon as possible. And I do try to give as much forward notice as possible.
I'm particularly, I particularly note the debate possibly on the Battle of the Somme because I understand that that is timely for many members. And I should put on record Sergeant Matthew Brown of the Durham Light Infantry, my relative who fought and died in the Battle of the Somme, oddly enough almost at the day that the debate might well be scheduled today. And I'm sure other members across the House will have an opportunity to reflect upon that. He's absolutely right to raise the situation in Nepal. We announced five million pounds in humanitarian assistance to support the immediate relief efforts, including helping those affected by the devastating floods.
And we're considering how our expertise in these matters can support Nepal's longer-term recovery, reconstruction and resilience. And I join him, and I'm sure other members, Mr Speaker, in congratulating the fantastic effort of Benji and Nick. We thank them for their fundraising. It's a very, very good cause.
Samantha Dixon.
Kate Samantha Dixon
Thank you, Mr Speaker. On Tuesday, I was really pleased to join more than 150 people to celebrate the Chester One City Plan, an ongoing project which has underpinned Chester's redevelopment since 2012. Often in this chamber we focus on the decline of our town centres and high streets, while exemplary work by local champions such as Councillor Richard Beacham and officers at Cheshire West and Chester Council remains unnoticed.
Can the leader of the house advise how we can showcase excellence like the One City Plan here in this place?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, I join my honorable friend in commending the work done by the Chester One City Plan and the work of all the councillors involved, but characteristically, I think she hides her light under a particular bushel because she was a very distinguished leader of that local authority and I'm sure a lot of the work which is now she's seeing may well have started under her fantastic leadership. If she wants to highlight this issue, Mr. Speaker, and indeed to reflect on the importance of local councillors working for their communities, I would encourage her to apply for a Westminster Hall debate because I'm sure there are others that might want to reflect on similar issues and councillors in their own areas.
Karen Bradley
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and can I start by joining the leader in his comments about Helen Hayes. She is a close personal friend of our mutual friend Speaker Milton Dick and I'm in touch with Milton for progress on her condition and our thoughts and prayers are with her and her family. Now, Mr. Speaker, I know how important it is to you that ministers are scrutinized properly by this house. So I'm sure you will join me in the disappointment to learn that the Home Secretary's diary office claims that there isn't a single moment between now and Christmas when the Home Secretary can come in front of the Home Affairs Select Committee. If that is the case, then since her appointment in October 2025, she will only have appeared twice in the period up to the end of the year.
So can I ask the leader, who I know has responded to these comments from the Liaison Committee when we wrote to him about it, if he might use his good office to sit down with her diary secretary and perhaps see if he can find a space for her to come and see us. We'd be very flexible, we can find a time and date that suits her, but we'd really like to see her before Christmas and I hope that the leader can help us facilitate that.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The work of select committees is extremely important, as I've said on many occasions, and the scrutiny of ministers is an essential part of that process. The right honorable lady is an experienced chair and represents her committee extraordinarily well, but the Home Secretary also takes her accountability to Parliament seriously. I know that she does. I am aware that she has appeared before the committee before.
I think the last date might have been the 15th of September, but I have no doubt that she will want and her diary secretary and her office will want to look at a further date with the committee in the not too distant future.
Lindsay Hoyle
As I've been slightly drawn into it, can I just back up the leader, but I think there must be a problem with the diary secretary because I can't get a meeting either. I've been requesting because I have a responsibility for scrutiny of members, so I understand the same frustration. I'm sure that the message will have gone back and I do hope that we can find some dates that will accommodate the chair of the committee and hopefully the speaker as well. Right, Samantha Niblett.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just 19 years old, Hannah in my constituency was diagnosed with a brain tumor and given 14 months to live, but she's now 23 and defying all odds. She took part, she won the East Midlands round of Pride of Britain awards which took place this week and airs on ITV1 and ITVX this evening, but she has turned the most incredible adversity into action and positive action for other people, creating Hannah's Hope, which is a sanctuary and a place for families going through similar struggles to have a bit of respite. And I wonder whether the leader of the house would join me in both celebrating Hannah and an incredible young girl in her new venture, H for Hope, which is about creating a community for teenagers going through similar experiences through cancer to come together.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I certainly do join with my honorable friend in congratulating Hannah, not least for her Pride of Britain award. She's doing a fantastic job in what would have been very difficult circumstances and for young people, Mr. Speaker, it is a daunting prospect to be diagnosed with something such as that and also, Mr. Speaker, for their families.
And there are many members across the House who will know that experience at first hand. So thank you to Hannah. I wish her well in the future. And it's absolutely right that we mention her and her fantastic work today.
Wendy Chamberlain
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A Gazan student who is currently displaced in Egypt has been offered a place to study at the University of St. Andrews, and following acceptance has been granted funding from several foundations. But the Home Office have declined her student visa application on the basis that they do not believe that she is a genuine student. That effectively means that her place is lost because the appeal process is going to take in excess of 12 months. I think we need an explanation, Mr. Speaker, on to why the criteria for student visas seems to have changed without anybody being informed.
And can I ask what the government is doing to remove the backlog in administrative reviews? Can the Leader of the House raise this case with the Home Secretary?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I certainly will raise the matter with the Home Secretary. She will know that it's important that if there is a backlog, then that is dealt with. But also people would expect that there be robust procedures. I don't know what's happened in this place, but I will share the case with the Home Secretary and get the honorable lady an answer.
Nick Smith
Mr. Speaker, can I thank the Leader of the House and the Shadow Leader of the House for their kind words highlighting the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan tragedy earlier this week? Can I also welcome the government's commitment to creating employment opportunities for young people through the Youth Jobs Grant? In Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney, we've already seen the benefits, with several local employers signing up. So will the government please update us on this scheme? I'm interested in looking at the eligibility criteria so that more young people across our country can get off to a good start in their working life.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I echo my honorable friend's sentiment regarding the work that the government is doing to tackle this matter. As he will know, the Youth Jobs Grant forms a key part of our broader youth guarantee and is focused on helping young people taking their first step on the career ladder. I'm very pleased to hear that businesses in his area are signing up to this. And I'm sure that the Work and Pensions Secretary will want to keep the House updated, not least given the work of Alan Milburn in this regard.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A number of constituents have contacted me recently about a pilot scheme for fitting air filters in classrooms, which they tell me has shown considerable health benefits both to pupils and to students. This would also perhaps relieve the costs of supply teachers on the school budget. Could the Leader of the House find time for either a debate or for an education minister to come to the House to give the government's position?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the honorable gentleman for raising what is an important issue. Good ventilation is essential for healthy and productive learning environments, and the Department for Education has produced guidance on ventilation and air quality in education and childcare. I'll make sure that the relevant ministers have heard his comments, but if he wishes to hear from them directly, then if he seeks perhaps an adjournment debate, he can discuss these matters further.
Helena Dollimore
Mr. Speaker, reform-run East Sussex County Council is responsible for unblocking drains and filling potholes, but too often when residents report these issues, nothing is done. I've been shocked to discover that the same contractor, Balfour Beatty, is paid to independently check the quality of pothole filling as is paid to fill them, and also to discover that today the number of miles of road that East Sussex is resurfacing this year is down on last year, bucking the national trend and despite extra money from this Labour government to sort these issues out. Does the Leader of the House agree with me that reform-run East Sussex County Council must get a grip, fill the potholes, and unblock the drains?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In short, yes I do, and I want to pay tribute to my honourable friend who's run a very effective campaign on this issue. I note that reform-led East Sussex County Council have received 21 million pounds from this Labour government to fill potholes, which is a record amount. And put bluntly, Mr. Speaker, we are doing our bit, it's time that the council matched that ambition. I hope that her council has heard the concern she's raised today and that they get on and fix this issue without any further delay.
Ian Sollom
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On Monday, the Children's Commissioner, a statutory role created by this House actually to protect children's rights, launched a report that claimed that a state of emergency existed for children across England. I'm disappointed that the Education Secretary hasn't been to the House to give a statement on that report, and ask the Leader of the House whether he would ask the Education Secretary to come to that and also schedule time for a government debate on the recommendations that the Children's Commissioner made so we can have that debate fully.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yes, I'm aware of the Children's Commissioner report. It is important, it is significant, but also the government believes that these matters are important and significant and doing everything that we can to address some of these. He asks why there wasn't a statement. The reality is that over the last sort of ten days, there has been a great deal of demand for statements and therefore it has been a question of prioritisation.
But I will raise the matter with the minister to see whether or not they need to come forward with that, or if he wants to call a debate, either in Westminster Hall or an adjournment debate at the end of the day, then I'm sure other colleagues may want to join him in putting questions to ministers.
Rinder Juss.
Warinder Juss
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A constituent of mine suffers from Turner syndrome, a rare genetic condition affecting only females for which there is no cure and she's been relying on medication for over 40 years to manage her symptoms. She can't get a medical exemption certificate because Turner syndrome is not on the medical exemption list, which was established more than 60 years ago and hasn't been meaningfully updated since 2009. So would the Leader of the House please contact the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to ask her to review the current medical exemption list and consider adding Turner syndrome onto this list, not only on behalf of my constituent, but for around 15,000 women and girls in the United Kingdom who are currently living with Turner syndrome.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honourable friend is a champion for his constituents on this matter, but as he acknowledges, it's a much more wide issue than just pertains in his constituency, and I want to pay tribute to him for that hard work. The point that he raises is a very important one. I'll make sure that the Health Secretary hears his representations and gets a full response, and following that, he may wish a meeting with the relevant health minister and I'll help him to arrange one.
Mark Francois.
Mark Francois
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can we have an urgent debate on the crisis at Basildon Hospital?
It's rated inadequate by the CQC who now, it would appear, are going to be prosecuting the hospital early next year for the sad death of two patients from sepsis in 2022 and 2023. Just the other day, there were over, there were 20 ambulances racked up in the car park outside the A&E department. To be clear, this is not the fault of the hard-pressed and increasingly demoralised staff. It's the fault of the wholly inadequate management of the hospital and sadly of the equally inadequate management of the trust they're a part of. We can't let this deteriorate further.
So can I ask the Leader of the House for an urgent debate to be replied to by a health minister, please, so we can address the problems at Basildon and do our best to put them right for both the patients and the staff.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And the right honourable gentleman raises a very important local matter and he is right to do so. And he's also right to say that there is something in his opinion happening locally here because as I listened to that, I reflected on the fact that ambulance wait times are down, admissions to A&E are up, waiting lists, waiting times are down. That's cold comfort to people in his local trust since if they're facing the issues that he outlines here. Either an adjournment debate, Mr. Speaker, in which he can ask, put questions directly to the minister and get the answers is one way forward on this, or if he wants to meet a minister to make those points to them directly, I'll help him to arrange one.
Michelle Scrogham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Leader of the House knows just how proud I am of Barrow and Furness. And since the election, this government, among other things, has announced 7 million pounds for our local health centres, 90 million for bus routes, 5 million for a Brilliant Futures fund, 4 million for our university, 20 million Pride in Place and part of 175 million for one of five defence technical colleges, not to mention a 200 million pound transformation fund. However, we still hear opposition parties without ambition for this area talking it down. Does the Leader agree with me that we will ensure that all of these incredible opportunities are fully utilised and Barrow is too important to fail.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And my honourable friend, as we can hear, is a staunch advocate for her constituency. And she's absolutely right to highlight the transformational investments the government is making in her communities and indeed in many other communities too. Every penny of this funding, Mr. Speaker, should work hard for our constituents. And I absolutely agree with her that local leaders must utilise the opportunities to their full potential.
And it is important that all parties in local areas and indeed in this House talk up local communities where that work is being done.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On Saturday afternoon, Bridlington Town FC will take on Curzon Ashton in the FA Trophy first round proper, the first time the club has reached that stage of the competition in 22 years, Mr. Speaker. So will the Leader of the House join me in wishing Brid all the very best on Saturday afternoon in the FA Trophy? And can we have a debate in government time on the importance of sports clubs and local communities.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've said before that sports clubs and local communities and all the volunteering that goes on around that are the heartbeat of our local communities. I will, at the risk of offending supporters of the other team, wish Bridlington Town the very best in the first round of the FA Cup. And this, you never know, Mr. Speaker, this may be one of those magical years when a non-league team manages to get to the final where I will go with the honourable gentleman and watch Bridlington play against Sunderland.
Speaker 125
Thank you very much. Last Sunday, hundreds of people came together in Queen's Park in my constituency for Moira's Run, which is run every year to mark the tragic murder of Moira Jones in the park in 2008.
The event raised thousands of pounds for the victims of crime. So would the Leader join with me in congratulating all of those who took part and recognizing the work of Moira's Fund and Victim Support Scotland?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I certainly will. What a fantastic way of marking what was a tragedy, but a community coming together to raise resources to make sure that these matters are tackled as we go forward. And I pay tribute to every one of my honorable friend's constituents who had anything to do with this fantastic project.
Anna Sabine
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. At Sulis Down, a housing development in my constituency, residents have moved in to find that planning obligations and landscaping haven't been completed by the developer, Vistry Homes. Once people move into new estates, they have very little leverage over developers, and in this case, Vistry is refusing to meet them. Would the Leader of the House help me secure a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss how residents of new developments can be given real power to challenge these developers?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is very keen to make sure that house owners and indeed people purchasing houses do have the information and the power that they need to hold developers to account. It's a piece of work which is central to what the government is doing. I hope that the developer has heard the honorable lady's concerns here, and I hope that they put it right. But if she wishes to meet the housing minister, then I can help her to arrange a meeting.
Josh Newbury
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Homeless mothers and children in my constituency have been housed in mold and rat-infested rooms at the Fairway Motel in Rugeley. I have raised this with Cannock Chase District Council many times. In March, I told them a full environmental health investigation was needed, yet six months on, the exact same issues have been raised again. Would the Leader of the House join me in telling the council to get its act together, and could we have a debate on how we can ensure all temporary accommodation is fit for human habitation?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend raises a very concerning matter, and I would urge the council to look into this as a matter of urgency, because everyone deserves to live in a decent home and have complaints responded to in a timely manner. This month, we've launched a consultation seeking views on extending Awaab's Law to include temporary accommodation to protect tenants, and I wish that consultation well. I'd also encourage my honorable friend to apply for an adjournment debate to speak to the minister directly and to further send the message to the council they need to get on with resolving this.
John Glen
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given that this week in London, the British-Argentine Chamber of Commerce is promoting investment opportunities in Argentina at a time when companies linked to the Falklands Sea Lion project are being pursued by Argentina with sanctions and criminal proceedings, could we urgently have a statement from the relevant minister from the Department of Trade on what the British government is doing to protect legitimate British businesses operating in the Falkland Islands?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the wider issue of the Falklands, the government is very clear that we stand four-square with the Falklands, and indeed the Prime Minister raised that matter indeed with President Trump when he met him recently. So on that account, there is a very clear position. I don't know on the matter of businesses, but I will raise it with ministerial colleagues, and if necessary, if the honorable gentleman wants to raise those with them directly, then I'll help him to arrange a meeting.
Speaker 130
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the 24th of September of this year, Melissa Premonorti was on her way to school when she was run over by a private hire vehicle on a crossing.
Her parents, her family, her friends and her teachers at Highgate School are understandably devastated. And I've had countless emails from parents who are very anxious about their children going to school, especially if they are travelling independently during rush hour. So could we have a debate in government time about road safety for children who are going to school on their own, particularly in areas like Highgate where there's a cluster of schools in one vicinity?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'm sure the whole House will join me in giving our most heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of the young girl because what has happened is is simply a tragedy. We are taking steps through our road safety strategy to make roads safer for everyone, including children around schools, but I'll make sure that she gets a response from a minister about what we are doing and what we plan to do in the future. And I'll give some thought, because this is an issue that has come up across the House from time to time, I'll give some thought as to whether or not we can have a debate on it.
Lindsay Hoyle
Can I just help everyone, I'm aiming for 12 because the business today, which is very important, so we could help each other be useful and Chuck Adama's a great example.
Shockat Patel
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This half term, the children of Leicester South should be enjoying their local playgrounds, yet many are not fit for purpose. In the Highfields area, Sherrard Road play area has been closed for over three years amongst a ding-dong between the local council and Severn Trent Water. So and many others are funding themselves their local play areas. So will the Leader of the House schedule a debate on playground funding?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed, Mr. Speaker. Playgrounds are very important for local communities and for local children, and it's important that they have somewhere to play which is safe. And it's distressing to hear about the state of the playgrounds in the honourable gentleman's area. It's very much for the local authority to get on, whatever disputes they may have with water authorities, anybody else, to get on and improve that in that way. It's probably a topic, Mr. Speaker, which would be useful for a Westminster Hall debate or adjournment debate because I'm sure there are others in the House that would want to air similar concerns.
Speaker 129
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This weekend, the clocks go back and overnight we will be plunged once again into darker and gloomier evenings. But, Mr. Speaker, there is another way. We could embrace our wartime predecessors because Winston Churchill set up a system whereby we had lighter evenings all year round. It cuts energy uses, so it cuts bills, it's a boost to the tourism and hospitality sector as well.
So, would the Leader of the House consider granting a debate in government time which I think would really bring hope into every heart?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for raising this matter, which she has done before. She's an avid campaigner on this matter. The government still believes that the current daylight saving arrangements represent the optimal use of the available daylight across the United Kingdom. Therefore, we don't have plans to introduce double summer time or any other such changes. But I do understand and appreciate my honourable friend's desire to help farmers and tourists by turning the clocks back two hours, in contrast to some on the other side who want to turn the clocks back to 1979.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And one of the great sports here in this place is who has got the best constituency. Well, the verdict of National Geographic magazine's verdict is in and the only place in the UK to get a mention in there, the best places in the planet 2027 is Dumfries and Galloway. This news is absolutely delightful. Visit Scotland has already picked up on it and promoted it on their website, but I wonder if the leader can advise me how I can get Visit Britain, financed from this place, to follow suit?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I think we all claim to have the the greatest constituency in the land, but I pay genuine tribute to the honourable gentleman's constituency because it is a beautiful place.
I hope that Visit Britain have heard what he has said today. Let me give it some thought. If you could let me have details of what he intends to try to do to heighten that. If he lets me have that, I'll see what we can do to get them to engage more.
Speaker 137
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For 26 years, Yipworld in Cumnock has provided vital support and guidance and opportunities to young people and families across East Ayrshire. Its success belongs to many people, including the fabulous Janice Hendry and her dedicated team of staff and volunteers who work so hard to make Yipworld a welcoming and safe place. Will the Minister join me in congratulating the team at Yipworld on being awarded both Charity of the Year and the Community Award of the Year at the Ayrshire Chambers of Commerce Business Awards?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I certainly join my honorable friend in congratulating Janice Hendry and everyone at Yipworld for winning the Charity of the Year and the Community Award. I'm sure it's well-deserved. It's a considerable achievement. Charities are the golden thread that run through our communities, and it's right that we celebrate their success in this place.
Claire Louise Young
Mr. Speaker, I have dozens of cases where constituents have waited months for responses from the DWP, including Dion, who has spent 18 months being routinely ignored and sidelined by the Child Maintenance Service. So will the Leader of the House ask a Minister to come to the House to make a statement on what steps they're planning to take to improve response rates?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, I'll certainly raise with the relevant Minister, Mr. Speaker, the honorable lady's concerns and make sure that gets an update on improving the service, which of course the government is committed to doing.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Law firms in my constituency have raised concerns about delays in the processing of complicated probate cases. Complex cases are experiencing delays of a minimum of 16 weeks, which is really distressing for the families concerned and can have serious financial and emotional consequences, particularly when IHT or property transactions are affected. Will the Leader either have a debate on this in government time or raise it with the Justice Minister?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend raises a very important matter, which will echo the concerns of families in many constituencies. Delays particularly arise where applications are incomplete or require further information, but to improve waiting times, His Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service has invested in additional staff, system and process improvements and an upskilling program. But I will undertake to give the Lord Chancellor sight of my honorable friend's words on this issue and see what further can be done.
Peter Timothy Fortune
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently visited the Demelza Hospice, which cares for children with life-limiting conditions and supports families across Bromley and elsewhere. They are simply extraordinary. 84% of their funding comes from charitable donations, and they have been hit, as have other hospices, particularly hard by the government's changes to National Insurance contributions, which will lead to the loss of specialist nursing provision. Can we have a debate in government time about the taxation and funding of hospices?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And first of all, let me join the honorable gentleman in commending hospices across the country who do a fantastic job. This has been raised over previous times, Mr. Speaker, in light of changes that took place in previous budgets. I don't know what's in this budget, which is coming forward next Wednesday, but it sounds to me the sort of issue that in the four days of debate he might want to raise directly.
Mary Glindon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
If undiagnosed in young babies, metachromatic leukodystrophy, MLD, becomes a cruel life-limiting disease, but there's no screening for the condition in the UK. Will the Leader of the House help me request a meeting between the Minister and patient representatives to discuss opportunities for making urgent progress in this area to prevent needless loss of life and the UK falling behind international comparators?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is absolutely right to raise this important matter. I recall that it was raised by the honorable Member for Wells and Mendip Hills last week, and I did facilitate, I did commit then to facilitate a meeting for her with the relevant ministers, so I'd like to extend the same courtesy and offer to my honorable friend.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, Liberal Democrat-run Hertfordshire County Council moved to become a county of sanctuary, essentially making it their policy to welcome illegal asylum seekers. This is an out-of-touch policy and it wasn't in their manifesto, and there's been no consultation with Hertfordshire residents. Will the Leader of the House offer some guidance as to whether he believes the government thinks initiatives like this are appropriate uses of council resources?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, I'll get from the honorable gentleman from the relevant department an update on where we are with councils of sanctuary and also on the issues that he raises. I have to say, however, I think he's been a bit harsh in terms of the success story that councils of sanctuary and in my area schools of sanctuary can bring. I think we need to, I think we need to address this. He's right to raise concerns if he's worried, but we also need to treat this in a responsible way.
Christopher Paul Webb
Mr. Speaker, can I start by thanking you and every Lancashire MP across this House for joining us in backing our bid to become City of Culture for 2029? Thanks to the hard work of the leader of our council, Phil Williams, Scott Butterfield, council officers, the Creative Blackpool, and all businesses, we're now on this shortlist and I'm sure we're going to get the title. So will the Leader of the House join me in thanking everyone that's been involved in this bid and to say that Blackpool is the best place for City of Culture in 2029?
Lucy Maria Powell
Very much indeed. I do certainly join my honorable friend in congratulating Blackpool on being shortlisted for the UK City of Culture and all those involved, and I want to pay again particular praise for him in the fantastic work that he does in supporting the whole community in Blackpool and highlighting what a fantastic place that it is. City of Culture is a great opportunity for our constituents to showcase their pride in their cities, and I wish all of them, all the shortlisted cities the best of luck, but I have to be careful, I'm not going to be tempted to pick one from the list, but I congratulate all, I congratulate all of them for having got this far and I do wish Blackpool well.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent withdrew from a police investigation into historic sexual abuse because of fear disclosing their identity. That was logged as Outcome 16. Last year, Avon and Somerset Police recorded nearly 39,000 cases of Outcome 16, but we don't know the reasons why there was a withdrawal because that data is not held centrally. Is it not time we debate on how to improve recording of Outcome 16 to understand better why victims withdraw and to help victims like my constituent to get justice?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, there should be no barriers for people to come forward and report or indeed to continue with complaints about what is an extraordinarily serious matter that she's right to raise today. She might want to, Mr. Speaker, seek an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate and hear directly from ministers because it's, it's very important that she is reassured that this matter is being dealt with properly.
Sonia Kumar
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Adam Bradley and James Bragg have opened the Forge Youth Centre in Dudley town centre, investing their own money and backed by the government's Pride in Place funding. This fantastic facility will help young people build skills, gain work, and form long-life relationships. Will the Leader of the House congratulate all involved and make time for a debate on youth provision in Dudley town centre?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, absolutely join my honourable friend in congratulating everyone involved in opening the Forge Youth Centre in Dudley, and particularly Adam Bradley and James Bragg. And I think everyone, Mr. Speaker, will be pleased to see Pride in Place funding being used to support young people, a significant amount of resource, but just as important of that, local people being able to make that decision. And I'm delighted that they've chosen to do so in this case. But I join my honourable friend in congratulating everyone concerned.
Robbie Moore.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Skipton Road in Ilkley is being dug up yet again, I think for the fourth time this year, by Yorkshire Water. And the biggest frustration for many of those that pass by is that there is no one ever seeming to undertake the works when the red traffic lights are on red. So, Mr. Speaker, can we have a debate in government time that puts pressure on the highways department at local authorities like Bradford Council to make sure that they sign off the works with a proper plan in place to cause as little disruption? And that when utility companies do undertake the works, they do it around the clock to cause as little disruption to many visitors, residents, and local businesses whose trade is being impacted?
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, and the honourable gentleman is sounds very exercised by this, and I just have to say to him, so am I. And I'm sure there are many members across the House who are exercised by this, not least those of us who were somewhat delayed this morning trying to cross Westminster Bridge, where again the road is being dug up, I'm sure for very good reason. An adjournment debate, I think, is the way forward, Mr. Speaker, to allow the honourable gentleman to make the the local example that he's talking about, but also to make a general point about what could be done across roads wherever they happen to be.
Brian Patrick Hurley
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll add my voice to the honourable gentleman in his bid for Blackpool to become City of Culture. But let's not forget the towns of culture, and can I take this opportunity in that spirit to commend the teams behind the Southport Music Board and the Southport Creatives Collective, both formed after a series of roundtable discussions I held earlier this year? Southport's arts and culture scene is thriving, and if 2027 is anything like this year, then the future's bright. Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the importance of arts and culture so that the contributions of our artists and creatives can be properly recognised?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed, Mr. Speaker. And I join my honourable friend in congratulating the work of all the people behind the the Southport Music Board, the Southport Creatives Collective, and everyone involved in making local arts events a success. The government is very much committed to supporting local communities in this regard. I would encourage him to apply for a Westminster Hall debate, Mr. Speaker, so that he can make his point in more detail, his constituents can hear, and and that be a cause for greater pride in their fantastic community.
Tessa Munt
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent's owed over twenty-nine thousand pounds in child maintenance arrears, which the Child Maintenance Service decided to write off even though the ombudsman ruled that the money was owed. The service says that recovery's too difficult and historic failures by its predecessor, the Child Support Agency, cannot be retrospectively reviewed. Mr. Speaker, this affects children directly and cumulatively and indicates a lamentable lack of care and compassion for young people. So can the Leader of the House urge the Secretary of State at the Department for Work and Pensions to undertake a full review and reform of the performance of the Child Maintenance Service so this doesn't keep happening?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And the government does recognise the that parents' experiences of the Child Maintenance Service don't meet the standards that should be expected of them.
Sometimes there are very difficult issues to address here, but they simply don't meet the standards which are addressed. And that's why we have committed to reforming the system. But I'll make sure that the relevant ministers heard what the honorable lady has said today.
Patricia Ferguson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Skin cancer is the UK's most common cancer, yet it is preventable in around 90% of cases simply by the regular application of sunscreen. Given the importance of preventing skin cancer, would the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the VAT charged on sunscreen so that members can consider the public health case for making life-saving sunscreen more affordable?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend raises important matters and I pay tribute to her for that. Prevention is an important part of tackling skin cancer and sunscreen is already VAT zero-rated when prescribed by a registered health professional. However, I will ensure that the Chancellor hears her words, but as I said at the beginning, Mr. Speaker, there will be four days of debate on the budget beginning next week and my honorable friend might want to raise these matters during that debate.
Clive Jones
Mr. Speaker, the carers allowance scandal saw thousands of unpaid carers unfairly pursued for debts caused by systems failures. Five months into the review process, only around 1% of cases have been reassessed. Will the leader allow time for a statement from the government on accelerating reviews and compensation and ending the unfair earnings cliff edge?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government does want to make sure that carers get the help and the support that they need. And we are committed not just to doing something for carers but in the wider social care situation because when we improve and we reform and we change social care, it will have the effect that the honorable gentleman is seeking. But I've heard what he said and I will draw it to the attention of the relevant minister.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Across the country, 47,000 women had toxic PIP breast implants put into them before they were banned in 2010 and the owner of the company was jailed. Would the Leader of the House be able to make time in government time to discuss the continuing ill health and chronic pain suffered by women up to now and the case for an inquiry? And would he update us on the case of the application of the medical misogyny debate which has been put into the backbench business committee in June? Thank you.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend has been a tireless campaigner on this matter and I pay tribute to her for that. Since PIP breast implants were withdrawn, two independent reviews have identified lessons learned and the Medicine and Health Products Regulatory Agency has strengthened post-market surveillance requirements. On the matter of the backbench business proposal that she raises, that's a matter for the committee and I'm sure that the chair who is in his place today will have heard what she said.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Russian atrocities against Ukraine are numerous and cataloged in this house and perhaps maybe what is less well known is the continuous persecution continues without any respite whatsoever. So will the Leader of the House ask the Foreign Secretary to make a statement on Russia's continued persecution of Christian communities in Ukraine and what representations the government is making to urge the Russian authorities to end the intimidation and detention of religious leaders, protect places of worship and uphold freedom of religion or belief?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As ever, the honorable gentleman raises a very serious issue and I pay tribute to him for that. As I've said before, the UK government is committed to defending freedom of religion and belief for all and I'm happy to reassert our steadfast support for the people of Ukraine. I will raise with the Foreign Secretary the specific concerns that he has, but at the end of the day, the way in which we can resolve this for Ukrainian people and the faith groups in there is to end this war and to ensure that Ukraine survives as a vibrant country and that Russia doesn't get any advantage from what has been an illegal war.
Colin Daniel Aldridge
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This week is Good Things Foundation's Get Online Week. Thousands across my constituency and millions across the country still struggle to get online, stay online, and be safe online. Local community groups run by wonderful people like Evie Paduam-Quan are so often working on a shoestring to deliver digital skills to our most in need. Can the Leader of the House acknowledge the cross-parliament and cross-government responsibility of this problem and if possible provide time for more parliamentary debate to keep this topic a priority for the House and get the resources we need in the places they need to be.
Paul Foster.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend raises a very important issue and it's good to raise awareness of Get Online Week. We are committed to tackling connectivity issues across the country. 88% of UK premises already have gigabit broadband and we're committed to delivering full nationwide gigabit broadband connectivity by 2030. But I do understand the frustration of households and communities that cannot benefit from that. I will make sure, Mr. Speaker, that the relevant minister hears his concerns.
Danny Beales
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's a tough time for motorists, which is why it's particularly galling that tonight Hillingdon Council meet to decide whether to increase parking charges by more than 70%. This is a second rise in just a year. Does the Leader of the House agree with me this is bad for motorists, bad for businesses, and can we have a debate in this house to discuss what more we can all do to support motorists at this difficult time.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and my honorable friend as ever raises an important matter. As I set out at the beginning of this session, parking is an issue that really matters to our constituents and it's disappointing, frankly, to hear of discussions and decisions which may well be taken or confirmed by his Conservative-run council. It is a matter for local authorities, but my honorable friend has put his concerns on behalf of his residents on the record today and I hope that Hillingdon Council will have heard him loud and clear.
Lindsay Hoyle
Could I just say to the ones who didn't get in, we've got the names for next week and I will expect to be prioritizing those names. Thank you everybody. Front bench changeover. Right. Colleagues, we now come to the motion paying tribute to the outgoing Clerk of the House.
Before I invite the Leader of the House to move the motion of congratulations to Tom Goldsmith, I should like to record my own brief tribute. Having joined the House in 1996, Tom has now served this place for 30 years. He has had a distinguished and authoritative presence at the table over the past decade, including as Clerk of the House for the last three years, a role which has been a culmination of an illustrious career in the service of this house. Members may not know this, but Tom is from a proud East End family and was the first in his family to go to university. Throughout his career, he retained his connection with those roots, welcoming children from his former state school regularly into Parliament.
On his appointment, he notably became the youngest Clerk of the House since John Hatsell in the 18th century. Tom joined the House as an assistant clerk via the Civil Service Fast Stream.
In the years that followed, he held numerous roles across select committees and procedural offices supporting the work of the chamber. Tom has also been secretary to the House of Commons Commission and was the first head of governance of the Office of Governance. These roles no doubt gave him a valuable insight into the way in which at times unorthodox organization runs. Thankfully, it did not put him off applying for the role of Clerk of the House in the years that followed. In fact, he hit the ground running as Clerk of the House, leading the House through the 2024 general election with the largest turnover of MPs in living memory, prioritizing the safety on the estate, working alongside the Director General to champion the bicameral procurement function and develop a more efficient model for the management of our estate.
On a more personal note, it was immediately before his appointment as Clerk of the House when Tom led the Table Office that I first had the privilege of working closely alongside him. Prior to that, he had led the Committee Office, driven the setting up of the groundbreaking hybrid of virtual committees during the COVID pandemic. Tom had a procedural expertise, political nous and authority that are essential for a successful clerk, but he combines them with an exceptionally clear style of communication which I value greatly. I'm not the only one that benefits of this. He has put these skills to good use as co-author of the most widely used popular textbook about Parliament, How Parliament Works.
I will always be grateful for the clear and authoritative advice Tom has provided, even on those rare occasions where we have disagreed with one another. Absolutely. He said he got the benefit of it from his Foreign Affairs Committee travels. It is not just parliamentary procedure that keeps Tom busy in this place. He has very generously also shared his talent for playing the jazz piano at many an event in Parliament over the years, including Speaker's House, something I will sorely miss.
I know the House will join me in thanking Tom for contributing 30 years of outstanding public service. Of course, I wish him well and the very best in his future endeavors. As Tom will go on to write books about jazz, he is available to play, and who knows, this could be his new line, Tom now sings the blues. Thank you, Leader of the House.
Lucy Maria Powell
Mr. Speaker, and it is a pleasure to move the motion today in my name in order to give the House the opportunity to pay tribute to Tom Goldsmith, who leaves the House at the end of this month after, as you've said, 30 years of outstanding service to this place. He has held a large variety of posts. He's been a clerk to a number of the busiest and most high-profile select committees, including the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, Justice Committee, and Energy and Climate Change Committee. He's also worked on a number of procedural roles, including Clerk of Committees and Principal Clerk of the Table Office, as well as stints in the Public Bill Office and the Table Office earlier in his career. He has been, Tom has been committed, Mr. Speaker, to making this House and the services that support all of us work.
This has been a common focus of his roles, including as Clerk of the Administration Committee, heading up what was then the Office of the Chief Executive, Secretary of the House of Commons Commission and Head of the Governance Office. And over the last few years as Clerk of the House. I've seen some of the work firsthand as Chair of the Modernization Committee, where Tom has demonstrated a great commitment to improving the accessibility of this place for all its members, staff and visitors.
As you've said, Mr Speaker, Tom was the head of the Committee Office during the pandemic and led the successful work to quickly set up hybrid and virtual committees, enabling select committees to continue performing their critical roles on behalf of this House. We remember those days, Mr Speaker, as being very difficult, but looking back, I think that is an understatement, and having people like Tom in charge of making the necessary changes meant that this place could continue to function. He was appointed the 52nd Clerk of the House of Commons in March 2023, taking over the role in October from Sir John Benger. And in his three years as Clerk of the House, he has been a public servant of the highest calibre. Whether in government or opposition, frontbench or backbench, he is a source of wisdom and invaluable assistance and has always, always put the interests of this House first, as you've said, even at the expense of not always agreeing with those who proposed a different view.
He has also seen an extraordinary amount of change during his tenure. Following the general election, we now sit in a chamber where over half of all MPs have less than five years of parliamentary experience. This required Tom to lead the House Service through its largest induction programme for new members. And I know for so many newer members, and indeed for those of us who have been here a little longer, Tom's calm and courteous approach has been deeply reassuring. I know that members right across the House will have greatly valued his guidance when navigating the complexities of our procedures and traditions.
And on a personal level, Mr Speaker, I've very much valued his advice and his guidance, whether it was when we were in opposition or since we've got into government. The grandeur of this role has not changed Tom. And as you said, he is a young man who, as a young man, he grew up in the East End. He was the first of his family to go to university. He has opened up access and opportunities to this place.
He introduced a system of direct recruitment for clerks, which ensured that they are more diverse and a more representative group. And he regularly welcomes school children, including from his secondary school, Ilford County High School, to Parliament. Beyond his work in the chamber, he is widely respected, as you've said, as the co-author of the eighth and ninth editions of How Parliament Works, which has done so much to demystify this House and help it make a more accessible place to the wider world. And at the outside of, on the outside of Parliament, as you've said, he is an accomplished jazz pianist. And let me say, in my exchanges in business questions, I've been keen to or forced to admit my admiration and enjoyment of musical theatre and country and western.
I have to admit, however, that it doesn't quite stretch to jazz. But, but nevertheless, he is, he is an accomplished jazz pianist. And it's fitting, as the shadow leader of the House said earlier, that he is so well practised at improvisation, which has meant that he's been so successful in keeping the business of this House running smoothly. From November, Tom has been appointed as a commissioner as part of the Civil Service Commission, where he will undoubtedly bring a huge amount of skill and expertise to help maintain a civil service appointed on merit with the skills that they need to deliver public services across our country.
On behalf of the government, Mr. Speaker, I wish Tom all the very best for the next chapter in his life, and I wish his successor Eve Samson well as she takes up her role as Clerk of the House next month, and I commend this motion to the House.
Paul Holmes
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and it's a genuine pleasure to speak on behalf of the official opposition and support the motion on the order paper today to offer the warmest of tributes to Tom Goldsmith as he retires after 30 years of distinguished service to this House. There are many people who contribute to the work of Parliament, but there are relatively few whose work underpins everything that we do. I've seen that contribution by Tom in my role in the government whips' office, in the opposition whips' office, and now in my short tenure, hopefully longer, as joint deputy opposition chief whip. Mr. Speaker, for members of Parliament, the House of Commons is where we come to debate, to scrutinize the government, and ultimately to represent the people who sent us here. It's a place of passion and occasionally a little theatricality.
But behind all of that stands an institution whose authority depends upon its procedures, its traditions, and the integrity of those who uphold them. Tom has devoted his professional life to ensuring those foundations remain strong. Since joining the House service in 1996, when I was eight, sorry Tom, he has served Parliament. I know I don't look it. He has served Parliament in a variety of important roles, including as secretary to the House of Commons Commission, head of the committee office, and principal clerk of the table office before becoming Clerk of the House in 2023, and also clerk to the Foreign Affairs Select Committee.
And if anyone can keep my right honorable friend the member for Tunbridge in check, then they are a very, very special man. That is a remarkable record of service and one that delivers the gratitude of members on all sides of this chamber. Mr. Speaker, the office of the Clerk of the House is not an ordinary job. It requires an extraordinary command of parliamentary procedure, a deep understanding of our constitution, and perhaps most importantly, the ability to provide clear, impartial advice when the political temperature in this place is rising, and we all know that the political temperature in this place can rise rather quickly. The Clerk must serve every member equally, regardless of party, political persuasion, or the strength of the argument being advanced at the dispatch box.
That impartiality is fundamental to our democracy. And of course, no tribute to a Clerk of the House would be complete without recognizing the qualities that sometimes can be taken for granted: patience, discretion, courtesy, and the ability to offer advice with calm authority, even when the circumstances are anything but calm. Those qualities matter enormously in an institution where strong disagreements are not simply inevitable, but essential to our democracy and the running of this House. Mr. Speaker, 30 years is a considerable period of service, and much has changed in that time, both in Parliament and the wider world and our country. But through that period, the need for impartial, effective, and trusted parliamentary administration has remained constant.
Mr. Speaker, retirement from Parliament today will undoubtedly give Tom the opportunity to pursue new challenges and spend more time away from the demands of this place, such as you've mentioned, Mr. Speaker, his love of playing jazz on the piano. And like the Leader of the House, I am not somebody that would necessarily see him play. I much prefer musical theater in the West End, but I look forward to seeing him maybe at my 40th birthday party in two years' time. Mr. Speaker, may I suggest also a career in professional poker, because if he manages to keep that exact straight face as when I tell him my own interpretation of the standing orders, he really, really go far. So on a more serious note, Mr. Speaker, I hope that his retirement brings him considerable happiness, good health, and the freedom to those pursuits that a career of such commitment may not always have allowed him time to pursue.
Mr. Speaker, I hope that the whole House, and I know that they will, will join me in wishing Tom every happiness in his retirement and thanking him for his outstanding service to the House of Commons, to all MPs, and those wider House staff who serve in this unique and special community. Thank you, Tom, and we wish you every best for the future.
Nick Smith
Mr. Speaker, could I please add some words of thanks to the retiring Clerk? I find our Clerk, Thomas Goldsmith, to be a very sage official sitting at the heart of our organisation. It's my privilege to be a House of Commons Commissioner and Chair of the Administration Committee, and I've seen Tom show good judgment, provide wise words, land on the nub of a problem, and always suggest a constructive way forward. And he does all of this, Mr. Speaker, with good grace. Tom Goldsmith is a polymath.
Like others, I've heard his excellent piano playing. I know he enjoys books, and we've often talked about our latest good reads. In a sometimes rarefied atmosphere, he's also a modest man from an ordinary background. It's been a pleasure working with him. Good wishes for the future, Tom.
Bobby Dean
Mr. Speaker, I echo the tributes paid across the House today and express my gratitude on behalf of the Liberal Democrats to the Clerk of the House, Tom Goldsmith, as he retires from his role today. I'd also like to congratulate his successor, Eve Samson, on her appointment as the new Clerk of the House. Eve will be the first woman to hold the role, and I'm sure she will continue Tom's excellent work. Parliament is famous for its architecture, its history, and its traditions, but all of us who spend time here know that it's the people that makes Parliament's status as a world-leading institution continue. From the doorkeepers to the catering staff, cleaners, and security, thousands of staff keep this place going and deal with us sometimes awkward MPs with impressive patience and positivity.
The Clerk is the steady presence at the table who ensures that whatever the heat of the debate, our proceedings run with fairness, order, and respect for the precedent. Members from every part of the House have relied on his guidance, his patience, and his deep knowledge of our procedures. And getting all the parties to agree is an achievement in itself, and today's tribute motion is supported by parties from all across the House and a testament to Tom's ability. We thank him sincerely for his service to the House and wish him a long and happy retirement. Now, 30 years of duty to the House is an incredible achievement, and since the Shadow Minister mentioned service all the way back to 1996, he mentioned he was eight, I was six.
I'm not sure if we're going to have a competition around the House from now on. But from head of the Committee Office to co-author of how Parliament works, his guidance has come in many forms and has been invaluable to us all across the House for several decades. Tom has navigated the House through periods of turbulent change. In his time as Clerk of the House, he has navigated three Prime Ministers from two different parties, as well as dealing with the largest intake of new MPs in parliamentary history, with such a huge proportion entering Parliament in 2024. I certainly had a lot to learn when I arrived in this House from Carshalton and Wallington for the first time, and I'm very grateful for the support that Tom and all the wonderful staff in the House that they provided and continue to provide.
Tom has been a steady and impartial presence, keeping the business of the House running smoothly despite shifts in leadership and political direction. His calm authority and commitment to fairness have earned the respect of members on all sides, and he has worked tirelessly to help newcomers learn the traditions and procedures of the chamber. My Liberal Democrat colleagues and I are especially grateful for his guidance as we adjusted to becoming the largest third party in a century. We had always found him fair when we were the fourth party, but support as we grew from 15 to 72 MPs was crucial, and his even-handedness, professionalism, and advice has been hugely important to us throughout this period.
I personally have always found Tom a diligent and calming presence with a firm, fair hand while guiding us through commission meetings. Tom is ever dependable, and I think it's very telling of his character that all members here across the House have found consensus today in our gratitude and praise towards him as a clerk. I and all the Liberal Democrats wish Tom the very best for the future.
Speaker 130
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Some people in the House may have noticed a year ago a foreign state took an enormous interest in me and went to town with the papers. I wasn't worried about the law as such because I knew I hadn't done anything, but I was a little bit conscious about the reputation of the House and my position here, having been an MP for 11 years. So I went to see the Deputy Speaker, who said to me that I should go and speak to Tom. She did also scornfully add, I would have much better shoes if I had the amount of money I was meant to have, which I think was a backward compliment, but I'm not sure.
So I went to see Tom, who I didn't know very well but had interacted with a few times, and I asked him what the status should be of all these fabricated allegations against me. And I explained to him that no one has ever contacted me about all these allegations, even now, because apparently they can't find me, even though I'm standing here right now in Parliament. So the advice Tom gave me, which was so calm, reassuring, well-researched, and delivered in such a compassionate way, is something that I will never forget. We are lucky to live in a country where there's rule of law, where there's a functioning democracy, where we have an amazing House of Commons. But we're also very lucky to have people like Tom, who know the procedure, know the rule of law, and can provide evidence on anything you ask him about without even consulting a book, who has the knowledge like the back of his hand.
It's not a session I'll ever forget, and I won't go into details about it, but it provided reassurance at a very difficult time. So, Mr. Speaker, not all heroes wear capes, but some of them wear black gowns and sit on green chairs.
Speaker 154
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. May I, on behalf of all SNP MPs past and present who have had the tremendous good fortune to work under the guidance and tutelage of Tom as Clerk of the House, express our gratitude and support for this motion today. We've been guided by Tom since 2021 when he became Principal Clerk in the Table Office, where he advised us on Opposition Day topics, on Brexit, the upcoming 2021 Scottish general election, where certain members in this House took issue with our use of the Scottish general election term. But thanks to Tom's even-handed approach, we were able to retain those words in our motion at that time. Since he became Clerk of the House, he has assisted us over the years across matters of sub judice, committee compositions, questions of order, and manifold conventions within this place.
Speaker 155
Indeed, Tom's support was so instructive, so comprehensive, and so helpful to the SNP, I had no option but to conclude that he too must be a committed freedom fighter to the cause of Scottish independence. And so accordingly, I scoured the membership list of the SNP to check for his entry on that list, but alas, his name appeared not. This leads me to conclude then that he does not in fact hold the SNP in a special place of his professional courtesy and boundless knowledge. He is rather a committed, consummate professional, allowing all members and all parties in this place to benefit from his patient and even-handed wisdom without fear or favour.
Speaker 154
I thank him for that and the SNP wish him all health and happiness in his future.
Speaker 153
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is a pleasure to follow the honorable gentleman and I think he really spoke again for all of us in his closing words about about Tom. And I do want to also just pay a very small tribute to the retiring clerk who has been an incredible source of advice, I know to all of us, but a great support also to me since I first got elected. It has been incredible to see his work and to see his utter dedication, efficiency, thoughtfulness and to acknowledge and to appreciate how he is always so approachable. Mr. Speaker, words have been spoken about the leadership that he showed at the time of COVID.
Seema Shimin Malhotra
And I remember that time. I remember the fear in the nation. I remember the uncertainty about how Parliament would continue. I remember the anxiety about how we would represent our constituents, how debates might continue and how we'd be able to do that all from staying at home. Tom was one of the leaders at that time that helped ensure that the functions of democracy could continue.
And it is in that spirit that I want to thank him and to acknowledge that we take for granted so often the systems, the teams, the incredible work that goes on behind the scenes so that we can continue through all circumstances to do our job here on behalf of our constituents. And so I want to thank Tom for his incredible utter mastery of procedure, of constitution, his advice and his leadership. I want to acknowledge how he has had such an incredible career of public service to this house, to our democracy and to our public life. And on behalf of my constituents from Feltham and Heston, today I say thank you.
Jim Shannon
Thank you very much. I rise today to pay a very heartfelt and an honest tribute to our outgoing clerk Tom Goldsmith as he prepares to leave this house at the end of the month. So on behalf of myself, Mr. Speaker, my party, the Democratic Unionist Party and the wonderful people of Strangford, I want to express our deepest gratitude for his 30 years of impeccable dedicated service to this Parliament. Tom has been a steadfast pillar of wisdom, guiding the chamber with unmatched procedural expertise, absolute integrity and perhaps most importantly for those of us who test the boundaries of time, blessed with profound patience and kindness. His piano expertise is to be applauded.
My apex of that is the Chinese chopsticks, falling far short of what Tom's talent really is. Whenever a backbencher needed guidance on a complex amendment or advice on a point of order, Tom was always there with a steady hand and an open door. His presence at the table will be deeply missed and we wish him nothing but the very best for good health, happiness and his well-deserved retirement. May God's blessing be upon him and his family in the days that lie ahead. At the same time, Mr. Speaker, it's a tremendous pleasure to welcome Eve Samson as our next clerk of the house.
Making history as the first woman to hold this prestigious office is a magnificent milestone. And having known Eve through her exceptional work over many years, not least her invaluable guidance on various select committees, I know that she brings a wealth of experience, sharp intellect and a deep respect for the traditions of this house which we all respect. She has a big pair of shoes to fill in Tom Goldsmith, but I have absolutely no doubt that she will serve this Parliament with the highest distinction.
She will always have the full support and the prayers of this bench as she takes up her historic duties. Thanks so much.
Lindsay Hoyle
Can I just say thank you to all the contributions to Tom? I think it's important that there's been some wonderful words said about Tom, and quite rightly, as the leader set out, Eve Samson does take over as the next Clerk, and you're quite right, the first woman speaker that I've been able to appoint. And the fact that we go back to 1363, so it's quite an amazing feat that Eve Samson takes over, must not forget that. And of course, I've just got to say to members, we do wish Tom well. I think Eve is learning to play the piano in case we need another jazz pianist.
But for now, we'll put that to bed, we'll let the front bench change over. Now come to the general debate on Black History Month. I call the Minister to move, Florence Eshalomi.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and it is a great pleasure and honor to be able to open this debate on Black History Month on such an important and timely moment. This is the third such debate in government time, and it follows the persistence of members in applying and securing adjournment and Westminster Hall debates to make sure that black British stories are appropriately recognized in this House. In particular, I want to pay tribute to my honorable friend, the member for Erith and Thamesmead, who has led on no less than three debates in the last Parliament, and I was delighted that she was able to deliver the first ever government-led Black History Month debate as a minister in 2024. I want to praise her for her persistence in ensuring that this debate is given the time in the chamber it deserves today, not just because she now leads on the committee that scrutinizes my ministerial brief. I would recommend members go and read her excellent speech from two years ago.
Although, Madam Deputy Speaker, it would be remiss of me not to correct the record to say that Nigerian jollof is the best jollof. But I do want to join her in paying tribute to her fellow Ghanaian, Akyaaba Addai-Sebo, who was the special projects coordinator at the Greater London Authority Council, who first recognized Black History Month back in 1987. Back then, just 39 years ago, Madam Deputy Speaker, there were only three black members of Parliament on these benches. They were the late Bernie Grant, Lord Paul Boateng, and of course, my right honorable friend, the member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington. And whilst black members still face challenges today, I want to honor and recognize the courage it would have taken to enter this House just a generation ago.
I'm sure many of us will see that it is sometimes difficult for me and other black members to imagine ourselves here without the trailblazing work that they did to make our path to the Commons possible. In particular, I want to express my gratitude to my right honorable friend, the member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington. I was just six years old when she was elected, and I remember that quiet hope I felt in watching TV and seeing her in Parliament, to see that yes, a black woman can have that voice, and that we don't have to stand by when decisions are made to us and not by us.
That gave me the confidence to stand for public office as a local councillor in the borough where I grew up and later for the London Assembly and to be the first black MP to represent Vauxhall and now Vauxhall and Camberwell Green. And I'm delighted to sit alongside her on these benches across this House and to see her representing her constituents as the Mother of the House. I will give way.
Jim Shannon
I thank the hon. lady. First of all, can I commend the hon. lady for Vauxhall for all she does. And the one thing that the hon. lady will speak about, I've no doubt, Madam Deputy Speaker, will be her faith. Her faith has been the strength of her character and her personality and that's something I recognized whenever I came to this House and got to know the hon. lady. I want to commend her for her leadership and the challenge that she takes on, as all the other MPs as well.
But can I also say that within our communities back home in Strangford, for instance, my constituency, we have a number of people who are from different countries across the world who add to the culture and the character of our constituencies and who work and do their bit as well. So this debate today gives us all a chance to say thank you. So I want to say thank you to the hon. lady, but thank you to all my constituents in Strangford who welcome people with ability, talent to come and work in this country and live in this country and thrive in this country as they do.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the hon. gentleman for that intervention and I'm going to need some divine intervention from the good Lord so I don't lose my voice for the rest of this debate. So I really do appreciate that. And he's right to recommend and reference the talent and diversity right across the UK and the difference that those communities make in enriching UK life. And for many of them, they do share that special area of faith. I'll give way.
Julie Minns
Just on that point, my hon. friend, and I really do hope her voice holds out for this very important debate. Historic England's blue plaque scheme rightly recognizes notable Britons, but very, very few of those plaques are to prominent black Britons and even fewer can be found outside of London. That's why I've applied for John Kent, believed to be Britain's first black police officer, to have a plaque in my Carlisle constituency because he served there in the 1830s and 1840s. Does the Minister agree with me that plaques like that to John Kent, if I am successful, are so important in ensuring that our black history is recognized right across our country?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my hon. friend for making that really important reference and it's really good to see English Heritage highlighting that plaque right across the UK, probably one of the most northern parts, and seeing that plaque outside of London. And it's important that we recognize the rich contribution of many black Britons right across the UK and I hope that she'll be successful in pursuing that plaque once it comes. Madam Deputy Speaker, the theme of this year's Black History Month debate is honoring our communities, giving us the opportunity to recognize people from black communities up and down the country who work every day to make their area and our society a better place. These are people who start a business, mentor young people, or volunteer their time to help run a community space and whose contribution too often goes unrecognized or underappreciated. Because while Black History Month is about celebrating black Britons who've delivered outstanding achievements across society, who've helped forge the country, who are here today through their visibility, it is also about recognizing the people in all parts of the country who may not make the news nationally, but who everyone in their neighborhood knows.
People like Lorna Jackson MBE. Coming to England aged five, Lorna went on to be an educator for nearly 50 years and a headteacher for 25 years. Today she continues to serve a diverse community in East London. Or Claudia Jones, a Trinidad and Tobago-born activist and journalist who was granted asylum in the UK after facing political persecution in the US. In 1958, she founded the West Indian Gazette, close to where I grew up in Brixton.
The West Indian Gazette is often referred to as the first black newspaper in Britain. After the race riots of 1958, she organised the first Caribbean carnival in the UK to coincide with the annual tradition in Trinidad. But as London is definitely a lot colder in January than Trinidad, that carnival was held at St Pancras Town Hall. And this was the predecessor to Notting Hill Carnival, which started in 1966 and continues to be celebrated and a true celebration of culture and heritage to this day, thankfully in August and not in winter. As my honourable friend just highlighted blue plaques, I was honoured to attend the unveiling of the English Heritage blue plaque dedicated to Claudia Jones three years ago on the 5th of October 2023 outside a terraced house in my constituency in Vauxhall, which Jones had called home for nearly four years, her longest place of residency in London.
Dawn Butler
Just on the subject of blue plaques, will my honourable friend agree with me that Nubian Jak do an amazing job in ensuring that black pioneers are recognised all around the country with a blue plaque?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honourable friend for making that point and I do want to praise the efforts of Nubian Jak, Jak Beula and the work that he does across not just London but across the UK in recognising black Britons and their achievements. Madam Deputy Speaker, we know that in the face of barriers, both conscious and subconscious, black Britons have driven lasting positive change in every community. Change that has profoundly shaped the arts and culture of this country. Change that has made our politics more responsive and more representative. Change that reminds us time and again that Britain's historical and present diversity is a strength, not something to be torn down, but cherished and invested in.
Madam Deputy Speaker, when we speak about honouring our communities, we are really talking about the individuals across Britain who made them. Our national story is incomplete without the story of Mary Seacole, whose statue stands proudly in the gardens of St Thomas's Hospital just over Westminster Bridge. This powerful landmark in my constituency continues to remind me of the values and aspirations which I came to this House to represent.
Speaker 163
I hope that she has a chance for some refreshment because I am a bit concerned about her, about her cold, but her talking about Mary Seacole, our constituencies have so much in common. I consider my honourable friend a really good friend and Mary Seacole spent many, many of her days in Soho Square as well within my constituency. And in terms of the themes of Black History Month, I wanted to reflect on the blue plaques as well before we move on too quickly from blue plaques, because I am very proud to represent a place where Ottobah Cugoano, an anti-slavery campaigner, lived in Pall Mall. And over Black History Month, I will be spending time telling that story, making sure that that story of his campaigning is well recognised.
And also in terms of the incredible culture as well that we need to remember during Black History Month, I want to remember today Winifred Atwell, the first black artist to have a number one single, who lived in Mayfair as well in my constituency. It is a real honor to represent such a diverse constituency with such a proud history of black Londoners and black British people. And I'm very grateful to my honorable friend for the testimony that she is bringing to this debate today. And I hope she's been able to have a lot of water today.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my constituency neighbor and recognize the many black Britons across not just London, but right across the UK, who continue to be celebrated and remembered by honorable and right honorable members from right across the house. Madam Deputy Speaker, I felt immense pride at being able to choose the statue of Mary Seacole as the backdrop for my entry to the 40% project last year, which photographed female MPs in recognition of the progress that we had made towards gender parity in this house. This year's theme also feels especially relevant to the Windrush generation, so embedded in the fabric of black British history. Their legacy is not only the work they did, but in the communities they nurtured, the opportunities they created, and the generations they inspired. Through the Windrush Day Grant Scheme, places across the country are telling stories in their own words, helping to ensure that they are remembered and passed on.
Their courage, perseverance, determination opened the door for future generations, and that legacy continues to enrich our shared national history. But the Windrush stories also tell us that we cannot ignore the struggles we still face today. Black Britons still face deep, systematic challenges every day. And although this government is committed to tackling racial inequality and racism, it is our local communities who are on the front lines. We only need to look and glance online to see the racist rhetoric that has sadly been normalized.
If anyone doesn't believe this, we just need to look at the racism, and let's call it what it is, that my honorable friend, the member for Holborn and St Pancras faced after she was announced as the candidate in the recent by-election. This type of politics has no place in our democracy, and I hope the whole house will join me in condemning it. And thankfully, my honorable friend was undeterred and went on to win resounding support for her community, and I welcome her again to her rightful place on these benches. Madam Deputy Speaker, I also want to praise the leader of the opposition for her comments during her conference speech. We can disagree about things in society, but we should never normalize questioning someone's loyalty or nationality based on the color of their skin.
We see the horrific consequences of this in the news far too often. And I want to take a moment to recognize and remember Jason Arday, whose tragic death must be a call to action for all of us. Madam Deputy Speaker, I worked with Jason when I led as the project manager at the Runnymede Trust. Jason was one of the board members, one of the youngest board members. I will give way.
Dawn Butler
Professor Arday has touched so many of us, and I will make reference to him also in my speech.
I thank my honorable friend for ensuring that his name will be remembered in this place in perpetuity.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honorable friend and I thank members that were able to join Jason's family at the tribute organized by my constituency neighbor, the member for Clapham and Brixton Hill. Unfortunately, I was not able to make that. And just this week, Madam Deputy Speaker, we saw the comedian Munya Chawawa describing the racism and homophobia he and some of the members of the cast from the Midsummer's Night's Dream faced at the Chichester Festival during its six weeks run. He mentioned and I quote, "I think I saw more racism in those six weeks than I've seen in my entire life, which is an insane concept. Some of you may have heard we had to cancel a show because one of our cast members was attacked just before the show.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I appreciate the minister for giving way and she will know that Munya Chawawa's experience was in my constituency. Chichester Festival Theatre have been supporting the cast after they have come forward and explained the racism that they saw. Munya also spoke about a pipeline of hatred which people are seeing on their screens in their algorithms, shifting the Overton window and letting people think that things like that are okay when they are absolutely not. Does she agree with me that we need to call out the far-right rhetoric that is being pushed into our teenagers' social media screens to protect people that give their lives to create wonderful art across the country?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the honorable member and I know that she's been in touch with many of the members from that play and the festival. And she's right. We have to make sure that we do not allow this to be normalized. We have to make sure that as parliamentarians, as society, as community groups, as anybody, we do not allow this to be normalized and think it is okay in 2026 modern Britain. Madam Deputy Speaker, we can disagree on many areas, but it is the responsibility of all of us in the chamber, the government and our society to make sure everyone is safe, everyone is able to live freely.
And I want to be clear that the government will not sit on its hands and watch this hatred thrive. In March this year, my department published a cross-government social cohesion plan, Protecting What Matters. This sets out more than 90 policy recommendations and commitments to improve cohesion, including measures to tackle further hate and inequality in everyday life throughout the United Kingdom's history. We have overcome adversity, coming together and showing that we have so much more that unites us than what divides us. We showed this exactly 50 years ago, Madam Deputy Speaker, with the passing of the Race Relations Act 1976, a landmark piece of legislation protecting the rights of all of us to live free from discrimination and a law that built the foundations of equality passed in 1965.
Just as we celebrated the victories of previous generations, history demands that each of us must stand up for what is right in our time, that the same unity remains our greatest defense. We must stand together against forces attempting to divide us and we must make sure that we all continue to be heard. I hope that members will agree that there is a lot more that we can do, but united we are stronger and I commend this debate to the house.
Speaker 164
The question is that this house has considered Black History Month, and I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Joey Morrissey.
Joy Morrissey
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it is a great pleasure to follow the Minister for this Black History Month debate. And may I pay tribute to the Minister and all of the work that you have done cross-party, that the Minister has done cross-party and across this house for being a champion for all communities, but really raising issues that people in the black community would have for knife crime, for single parents, for stop and search in classrooms. All of these things, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Minister did as a backbencher, reaching across the divide and caring about her community regardless of who they were or where they were from. It felt as if the Minister at the time was just trying to represent all of her constituents and to raise the issues that matter.
And that was something that everyone could connect with across this house. And I want to pay tribute to that, because in this house we come from very different backgrounds and from very different places, but there are members of Parliament from every party who put their constituents first, who put the issues that matter to them first and their community, and the Minister is one of those. And I'd like to pay a personal tribute and thank you for that. And every October we celebrate Black History Month. And this year marks its 39th year in the UK.
And it was a tradition started in 1987 by a Ghanaian activist who believed black Britons deserved to be, to have their history told, taught, and celebrated. Black history is of course British history. And please, Madam Deputy Speaker, act surprised that my speech is very similar to the Minister's. And this will probably be a rare moment where we are in agreement and saying very similar things. And this theme this year is honoring our communities and focusing on recognizing everyday contributions of black people across Britain.
For me personally, it is a moment for important reflection. I came to this country with basically nothing and knowing no one, and the first community that opened their hearts and their doors to me were my friends in the West Indian Caribbean community in West London. And they welcomed me and taught me what it was to be British. They brought me into their community groups, to their church groups. They taught me what it meant to be British, even allowed my mom to come to some of the events.
And I certainly knew about jerk chicken before I got to the House of Commons. And for me, I just, and I want to pay a special tribute to the Acton Vale Estate and to Grace and Shanae, who Grace became one of my closest friends and Shanae is her daughter who I mentored and now is incredibly successful. And they taught me what it was to be British and to care about the community. And Grace was one of the first people that said, you should think about being a Member of Parliament. And I'd never thought about that before.
And I see the member for Southall there and they know about the Acton Vale Estate. And it was a transformative moment for me to feel that anyone could come to this country and be British and be part of British society. And those British values and being proud to be British, and it didn't matter where we came from, we could be British. And that hope and that feeling of caring about our community, I learned from my friends.
And I'm here today as a result whether maybe they've unleashed they probably unleashed more than they bargained for with that, but they were the first to encourage me, so they probably deeply regret that now, but you know, that's where it started. And they showed me the very best of this country. And I pay tribute to to Grace and to Shinae, but I also wanted to pay tribute to some of the other local groups that I had worked with, Bashara and Adam Mattan for the anti-tribalism group that helped tackle anti-tribalism in the Somalian community in West London and their tremendous work. See the member of Southall nodding because they are very well known across the West London area and their incredible work with all the communities and the local mosques and working with them for years and just they really taught me so much about celebrating all the different communities and I just wanted to pay tribute to them today as well. And Black History in Britain has always been a community history.
When the Windrush arrived in 1948, the men and women on board didn't just come to work. They built churches and social clubs that welcomed people when Britain often did not. I will give way.
Dawn Natasha Irons
I thank the honorable member for giving way. I just wanted just on the point of community and people and what the black community adds to the community. I wanted to just pay tribute to the work of Croydon's BME forum led by Dr. Andrew Brown and the chair of our Pride in Place board in New Addington, Julia Wheeler. Now these people are community leaders who put their communities first, whether that be tackling mental health, whether that be tackling people who are struggling to pay the bills and whether that tackle food poverty, but there's always a warm welcome and a big smile. So I was just wondering if she would agree with me that she's that sorry.
Speaker 164
A musical compliment to the honorable member's intervention which will no doubt be coming to an end because it is an intervention and a speech and unfortunately it felt like a Christmas themed intervention which is far too early for the record. Do you wish to continue the intervention or is the point made? Marvelous. Joy Morrissey, are you ready without any music?
Joy Morrissey
The Christmas holiday arrives, that was my summons to the chamber, but it did start earlier than I anticipated, so there we are. Old age comes to you at many levels and having to put alarms, but we got there in the end and happy Christmas to everyone as well. But thank you for that and thank you for that intervention. And it is about the community and all of us have wonderful constituents who represent our communities, who raise their concerns, who have enlightened us and allowed us to speak with knowledge because of our constituents raising these issues and being community leaders. And I want to pay tribute to all of them today.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honorable member for giving way and as she's mentioned my constituency a couple of times and thank you for all that she has said and all of the tributes that she has given to local constituents there. But can I ask her if she would join me to congratulate Councillor Faduma Mohamed who has been elected the Mayor of Ealing for this year. She's a councillor in Southall West ward and in fact is the first Somali-born hijab-wearing woman to hold that position.
Joy Morrissey
I will indeed congratulate her.
And as someone who organized the first Somalian community day on the South Acton estate, and then we had to change the name to actually a wider South Acton community day to be inclusive, that's wonderful and I congratulate the new mayor. And as a fun fact for I used to ride the bus from the 207 from Acton all the way to Southall and back, and if you've not been to Ealing it's a fun journey, so enjoy that if anyone hasn't been, it's a fun way in. And like the minister, I also had my start as a councillor. And getting that experience was a wonderful way of meeting the community, understanding the community from the grassroots up, and I'll never forget that. And I believe it does make you a better parliamentarian as a result of having that experience on the ground.
And in 1963, Bristol's black community, led by the young people like Paul Stephenson, refused to accept a bus company's ban on black workers. Their boycott helped pave the way for Britain's first race relations laws. Today, black people continue to play a key role in communities across our country, helping to bring people together. And one of the reasons black history is British history is because our black communities show we can be integrated, cohesive, and multiracial Britain. We can celebrate the same values and be proud of who we are together.
And for all of us, there will be black Britons who play such a vital role in our constituencies, in our offices, and in our community groups. And I would like to pay a special tribute to a family in my constituency, Rotimi, Maryline, and Naomi Isaiah, for being sort of my right hand in everything in Beaconsfield, and I could not do my job without their incredible community support. So I just wanted to pay tribute to them in Beaconsfield and thank you for everything that they have done. So and I'm sure that all of us across this chamber could do the same today. And they do so much to personally support and encourage me in my work as a member of parliament.
And I just want to thank them. And I was going to have them here today, Madam Deputy Speaker, but next time. And turning to my work for women and equalities, I also want to recognize Nimco Ali, a survivor of FGM, who has done so much to highlight this vital issue to try and make sure that no other girls experience what she did. And now this year, the aim of Black History Month is to look beyond famous people and reflect on our contributions of everyday black Britons. But given this is the first time I have spoken at the dispatch box in Black History Month, it feels only right I recognize someone famous, just, you know, one, but a genuine role model for black female Britons.
In 1987, the very same year Black History Month began here, a young woman from Paddington walked into the House of Commons as Britain's first black female MP. Today she is the mother of the house. When she arrived, there were only 41 women in the entire Commons. She was told in a hundred ways that she didn't belong. She stayed anyways for nearly four decades.
She has represented the people of Hackney, championed black children in London schools, and chaired parliamentary groups on West Indian and sickle cell disease. She has faced more abuse than almost any politician of her generation. And she has never stopped turning up. You don't have to share her politics to recognize what her presence meant.
For millions of Black Britons, especially Black girls, she was proof that the doors of power could open and that someone who looked like them could walk through. Black history is not one month. It is being forged every day by people who see themselves first as proud Britons. And I would like to pay tribute to my leader because she is leading the way and opening opportunities for all of us and I'm very, very proud to have her leading my party. And it is British history that they across this House are writing and it is a privilege to recognize all of them today.
Speaker 164
As so many colleagues have mentioned the Mother of the House, I thought it only be appropriate to raise I was able to step in for Mr. Speaker for Mr. Speaker's Black History Month reception most recently and I was lucky enough to be joined by the Mother of the House, the member for Hackney North and Stoke and also the newest member, the member for Holborn St Pancras. It was so fantastic to be in the room with both of them. The energy was fantastic. On social media there was a huge amount of backlash as the Shadow Minister just said, we need to take a lesson out of the Mother of the House and ignore it and just keep going, which is what no doubt we will all do. Now, I will call Seema Malhotra.
Seema Shimin Malhotra
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's truly a privilege to speak in this debate during Black History Month. A month that gives us an opportunity both to celebrate Black history and Black achievement and to reflect honestly on the history that has shaped our country and on the work that remains to be done. Black history is British history. It is the history of people who have contributed to every part of our national life, to our armed forces and to our NHS, to our schools and universities, to our communities, to business, culture, politics, science and the arts.
It is the story of people who have helped build this country, often in the face of prejudice, racism and discrimination and whose contributions have not always received the recognition that they deserve. We should remember the generations of Black Britons who served this country in times of war and peace. We should remember the Windrush generation, those who have followed, those who came to Britain with hope, determination and a belief in a shared future.
David Edmund Burton-Sampson
I thank my honorable friend for giving way and she reminds me of my grandad who came here from British Guyana to serve in the Second World War and indeed my great-grandad who arrived here from Liberia in 1925 and served this country in the Second World War. Yet today people of my color are made to feel by some like we don't belong in this country but we have built and we have protected this country. Does she not agree with me that people who portray that rhetoric are wrong and need to stop withdrawing from that?
Seema Shimin Malhotra
I thank my honorable friend for his contribution and he speaks for all of us in saying that it is time to call this out. And it is vital that as a society and as parliamentarians that we say no more and that what we stand for is a country that is united and we will refuse to hear the racism that is now also rewriting and seeking to rewrite history and the contribution of his forefathers as well. Madam Deputy Speaker, in relation to my comments about the Windrush generation and those who have followed, I also want to pay tribute to the Windrush Commissioner Reverend Clive Foster for his work, Professor Uzo and the elders in Cardiff, Ros Griffiths and the Friends of Windrush Square and so many others who are leaders from communities across the UK who work tirelessly to continue to right the wrongs of the Windrush scandal.
And let me also thank all at the Black Cultural Archives in Windrush Square for their incredible work, for the documentation of history, their approach to education and awareness, from enslavement to abolition, and medicine, race, and activism. I want to also support those campaigns that we've heard about today for greater inclusion of Black people's stories and histories in our culture and indeed in our schools. This month we also celebrate the extraordinary contribution that Black Britons continue to make today, because Black History Month is about understanding and appreciating how history has shaped the present, but it is also about the choices that we make now for what kind of country we want to leave for the next generation. And I congratulate the Minister for her opening speech, and I'm grateful again that the debate is in government time. The Minister has been rightly recognized for her contribution in this House and in her community, and I also want to echo her tribute to the inspirational Lorna Jackson, Professor Jason Arday, and to recognize also the important contribution that Black people from across our community make and the racism that they experience, and particularly also to mention our Black footballers, who I think we should recognize, who do us proud every single day.
Madam Deputy Speaker, as we mark 39 years since Black History Month began in Britain, we should also recognize the role of Black women in our debate, because too often their experiences sit at the intersection of racial and gender inequality, while their achievements receive far less recognition than they deserve. We should celebrate women who have broken barriers in Parliament, in public life, in business, in education, in our NHS, in our communities. So today I want to talk about herstory, women who didn't wait for history to happen, our sisters who made it and who are still making it. Last year I had the privilege of meeting two remarkable Bristol Bus Boycott sheroes, Joyce Morris-Wisdom and Dr. Barbara Dettering. Joyce was just 14 when she joined the protests in 1963.
More than 60 years later, this remarkable grandmother continues to share her story and inspire new generations. Barbara, originally from Guyana, helped organize the movement, co-founded St. Paul's Carnival, and built lasting community institutions. Their contributions belong to a wider tradition of Black women's leadership in Bristol, women such as Carmen Beckford MBE, Bristol's first race relations officer, and Peaches Golding OBE, the UK's first female Black Lord Lieutenant. Different generations of women who've challenged discrimination, built institutions, and opened opportunities for those who followed. These are women who helped challenge Bristol's colour bar in 1963, the year my father came to the United Kingdom, contributing to the momentum behind Britain's first Race Relations Act under a Labour government in 1965.
The law was strengthened in 1968 and again in 1976, extending protections against discrimination and strengthening enforcement. This November, on the 22nd of November, marks 50 years since the 1976 Act received Royal Assent.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I also want to pay tribute to the Mother of the House, who has had more than one mention today, the right honourable member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington. Next year marks 40 years since she was elected as Britain's first female Black Member of Parliament, elected alongside Bernie Grant, Paul Boateng, and Keith Vaz. These were not simply historic breakthroughs. Their influence continues to shape Parliament and Britain today. I was the first female Punjabi Member of Parliament elected to this House.
And I also want to pay tribute to my honourable friend, the member for Holborn and St Pancras, who we were all honoured to help get elected to this House, and to congratulate her on her own first, the first Somali Member of Parliament in this House. And I note that she, like so many through history, has faced down those who said that she had no right to even be a Member of Parliament. Madam Deputy Speaker, that campaign was a wake-up call for the racism that begins even before a campaign starts, and it is for us to say to everyone, whoever they are, whatever their background, that they too, as someone who is proud to be in Britain, have a place in this House. I will give way.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
I thank the honourable friend for giving way. Earlier this year, I was absolutely delighted to visit the Festival of Britain celebration of 75 years of the Festival of Britain at the Southbank Centre. Oh God, it was in the honourable member's constituency. And it was a celebration of youth culture through the medium of dance. And it was magnificent.
And there was this one particular scene celebrating the excitement of the Windrush generation coming to our shores, but then it also talked about some of the adversity that they were facing. And it just was such a stark reminder that we are not born racist, but we, if we allow it to seep into our society like that poison that it is, that we let the bad people win, and we are not those people. So I just wonder whether the honourable member would agree with me that 75 years later, we are still celebrating as a Festival of Britain, and that festival definitely includes a very diverse bunch of people.
Seema Shimin Malhotra
I thank my honourable friend for her contribution and she is absolutely right in all that she says. And she is right also to mark the 75th anniversary of the Festival of Britain. And it was indeed the Festival of Britain that was called for by Herbert Morrison, who presented the idea to Cabinet as part of building positivity and optimism after the Second World War. And she may know that I am wanting to see us have another national Festival of Britain because I think it is time for us to look at and celebrate much more of what we are as a nation. The Festival of Britain also contributed to the thinking behind the opening ceremony of the Olympic Games that we hosted, and I hope that we can find much more opportunity to celebrate what we are as a nation today.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, let me just continue with my remarks because I want to say one thing again about our friend, our honourable friend, the member for Holborn and St Pancras, because I believe she too, in her election, is writing a new chapter in Black history. And at the last general election, 90 ethnic minority Members of Parliament were elected to this place, according to Operation Black Vote, from all benches, including 66 of my honourable friends. I also want to recognise our friend and colleague, Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon OBE.
I am so proud to have worked with her in her role as chair of the Race Equality Engagement Group to strengthen the relationship between government and ethnic minority communities. And in its first year, the group focused on access to finance for ethnic minority entrepreneurs, maternal and neonatal care, cardiovascular disease, policing and education and transition to work and opportunities for young people, with recommendations presented directly to ministers. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am also proud that earlier this year, the government published the consultation outcome and government response on mandatory ethnicity and disability pay gap reporting. Ethnic minority and disabled people are less likely to be in work, less likely to be promoted, and on average paid less than other employees. This is bad for equality, it's bad for business, and ultimately bad for Britain.
In the King's Speech in July 2024, the government committed to introducing mandatory ethnicity and disability pay gap reporting for employers with 250 or more employees. Introducing this mandatory pay gap reporting will provide vital data to help employers identify and take action to reduce ethnicity and disability pay gaps where they exist. I want to thank Diane Gayson, founder of the Ethnicity Pay Gap Campaign, and those from the business world who have supported this work and with whom I've worked, including Business in the Community, Deloitte, KPMG, PwC, BP, the London Stock Exchange Group, ShareAction, Change the Race Ratio, and Chartered Management Institute. We must find parliamentary time to move this forward, so I would be grateful if the minister in her closing remarks, who I know is doing amazing work, could update the house on what the government's next steps are in bringing forward legislation. But as we mark today, history in progress, let us remember especially that progress is neither linear nor inevitable.
Rising racism and intensifying division is tearing our national fabric apart, and it is incumbent on government and indeed all of us to take a stand for the values we believe in. In the year ending March 2024, police in England and Wales recorded over 140,000 hate crimes, with roughly 70% being racially motivated. What we have seen happen elsewhere is also increasingly close to home. And as we saw, the vicious racist Reform UK councillors exposed by the recent ITV investigation, Reform councillors calling children animals and talking about infestation. A councillor in my own constituency recorded saying he would love to have slaves.
This goes against all that residents in Feltham and Heston stand for. Investigations into such behavior must be credible, and our public life and society stand strong against forces of racism and division. Before I close, Madam Deputy Speaker, let me mention just a few of my constituents who are an inspiration to me and working to make our community a better place. Alexis Isa and Faith Lamptey, two year 13 students, young black girls who recently compared the first Hounslow Women's Conference, which I co-hosted with the Member of Parliament for Brentford and Isleworth. Another young black student, Rima Atchempong-Owusu, was our digital and video lead, including co-editing a phenomenal video about the contribution of women to Hounslow's history.
And her mother, Mabel Atchempong-Owusu, a regular volunteer at St Lawrence's Church in Feltham, also beginning her own catering business, who put her heart and soul into making sure that there was breakfast and lunch for all who came. And Hibbo Mahmoud and Daud Hassan, two stalwarts of our local Somali community, who are always there for others. And Christiana Uche, lecturer in adult nursing at Kingston University, the founder of Igbo Women in West London.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we stand on the shoulders of extraordinary men and women. They have been the torchbearers of the past, but it is we who are responsible for the legacy that we leave for tomorrow. So let us use this Black History Month not only to remember those who came before us, but to inspire those who come after us. Let us build a Britain in which equality is not simply something that we aspire to, but something people experience in their everyday lives. A Britain where diversity is recognized as a strength.
A Britain where every child, whatever their background, can look at our national story and know that they are part of it. That is the Britain we should be proud to build together.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to speak in today's debate on Black History Month and follow some incredible contributions from the Minister, from the Shadow Minister, and from the honorable member for Feltham and Heston, and I thank them. And I also thank the government for making sure that this debate is in government time as well, because it's a very clear indication of just how important it is. Britain's Black communities have enriched the social fabric of the United Kingdom, adding vitality to our streets, shops, frontline services, and culture throughout the country. And we would be a poorer, less dynamic, less exciting, and less colorful country had individuals not boarded ships such as the HMT Empire Windrush and made Britain their home. And as the Minister acknowledged, Black History Month has been marked for 39 years when it was first celebrated.
And when it was first celebrated, there were just three Black MPs at the time. And its purpose is to remember those who came before, as the honorable member said, we stand on the shoulders of those that came before us. But also it looks to the future to address the systemic issues that our Black communities still face. And in Chichester and throughout the country, we owe our Black communities so much, yet in truth, society has let them down badly and it continues to do so. Far too many people's lives are still blighted by prejudice, discrimination, and inequality.
And I thank the Minister for raising the case that Munya Chawawa has brought out into the light this week. As an actor and a comedian and a social commentator, the social commentary that he has made about his experience in the last six weeks in Chichester has broken my heart. He spoke out about the cast who've been with us over the last six weeks doing a really cool production of A Midsummer Night's Dream, one of the best versions of A Midsummer Night's Dream that I have ever had the privilege of watching. And also Munya's first time actually taking to the stage and in a Shakespeare as well. And it was incredibly inspiring to have kids from the Brit School come and watch the performance.
Munya established the Black Boys Theater Club. It is his ambition to make sure that Black children have access to theater. And I watched with delight at all of these young children talking about how much they'd enjoyed watching Shakespeare in Chichester and how cool it was to see, you know, their first experience of theater being in my constituency. And Munya spoke about that there was a homophobic attack, which has now been called a hate crime and there has been an arrest made, which caused the show not to go up.
When that happened, the rest of the cast spoke about their experiences over the last six weeks that they had experienced just walking through the city when they went for a night out in Brighton to actually get out of Chichester and they experienced racism there. And they talked about, Munya said that he experienced more racism and xenophobia in six weeks than he'd experienced in his entire life. He's been a tireless campaigner against discrimination. He's very good at calling it out and doing it in a comedic way that I think lots of people identify with. It's why he's got such a huge following on social media.
And I'm really grateful to him for calling it out because this is something, and I declare an interest, Madam Deputy Speaker, as a trustee of Chichester Festival Theatre, and it's been something that the theatre has been trying to tackle for years and years and a conversation we've been having with the board that when we invite talented actors to Chichester Festival Theatre, we want them to feel like it is their home, we want them to feel welcome, we want them to feel included and how do we make the environment around the theatre that for them. And I have been somewhat reassured by the outpouring of love both on social media and in my inbox by people saying, "I had no idea, what can we do?" And one of the reflections that the cast made to the theatre was they were in the city centre when these things happened and nobody called it out. So people were, I'll happily give way to the Minister.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the honourable member for giving way. I thank the honourable member for giving way and for highlighting what happened in her constituency. Does she agree with me that one of the issues that black people, black members raise is the fact that sometimes it can be tiring continuously when it's only black people raising this? And does she agree that by her raising this as a constituency MP, she's shining another light on this?
Jess Brown-Fuller
I appreciate the Minister for her intervention because it is not the job of those that experience the abuse to be the only ones calling it out. And I think going forward, we are working as a collective community to bring voices together so we can talk about and come up with actions as to how we can better support those because it shouldn't be the job of those that are experiencing intolerance and abuse day in, day out. And I also think we need to do some work with the police who I've spoken to at length over the last couple of weeks about when I say this is happening and they say, "Well, it wasn't reported." Well, it wasn't reported because people get really tired of constantly reporting things and then not seeing a change. For a lot of the cast members, they hadn't shared with the theatre their experience up until the point where we had this homophobic attack that caused the show not to go up.
It was then in a kind of safe space they were able to say, "Actually, that resonates with me because I experienced this, I experienced this when I was out in the city centre, I experienced this when we went out to get food." And they hadn't reported it to the police because the onus shouldn't always be on them. And so I think we need to have a wider conversation about what businesses can do, what just individuals can do in the city. Because in truth, it feels like we're going backwards. Somebody said to me the other day, it doesn't feel like the Overton window has shifted, it feels like it's fallen out of its frame.
And I would argue that much of the kind of abuse that comes from these individuals, they are emboldened by the growth and increasing acceptance of the far right on social media, in the press and across other platforms. And these are spaces often pushed by prominent politicians that make individuals, particularly young people, believe that certain language and behaviours are suddenly acceptable.
Racist abuse and far-right views gain even greater reach when they are associated with political leaders and the algorithm eats it up and sends it into those spaces. And we all have a responsibility to challenge these prejudices and behaviors, especially when having important political debates around issues such as immigration where people too often conflate immigration, race, and crime. I, for one, do not want racism to become normalized once more or for people to feel that staying silent is easier than standing up for others. We need to all call it out whenever we see it. Moving forward, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's important that we in this place reflect on the scandals of the past that have left dark scars on our society, from Windrush to Grenfell, the crisis in maternity care.
These all represent individuals and communities that have been let down, with systemic discrimination playing no small part. Individuals whose dignity and rights were disregarded because of failings within the state apparatus. So I'm proud that the Liberal Democrats are committed to fighting for racial equality, and that means unequivocally condemning racism in all its forms and tackling injustice wherever we see it. And it's a shame that my honorable friend, the honorable member for Eastbourne, cannot be here today, but I see how much abuse he receives online on social media when he puts up a comment about something he's doing to fight for Eastbourne General Hospital, and in the comments someone will write, "deport". And his response to deport is, "there's no direct flights to Eastbourne General Hospital, so I can't do that".
But the proliferation of abuse that is then liked and shared means that his experience as a black MP, I recognize, is totally different to my experience as a white MP because the abuse he receives is off the scale and is totally unacceptable. In the Liberal Democrat election manifesto, we committed to implementing a comprehensive race equality strategy aimed at reducing the disproportionately high maternal mortality rates experienced by black women and eliminating racial disparities in maternal health through a cross-departmental target and strategy. We also want to end the disproportionate use of stop and search and require all police forces throughout the country to adopt ambitious targets for improving the diversity of their workforces. We've also called for the reversal of the voter ID scheme, which disproportionately excludes minorities from democracy, and for all political parties to publish candidate diversity data. And we must also tackle discrimination in the use of new technology, beginning with halting the use of facial recognition surveillance, which is much more likely to wrongly identify black people or women.
On criminal justice, it's clear that the immense disparity seen between different ethnicities in our prison population represents systemic failing across society. As of this year, 12% of the prison population were black, far exceeding the share of general population, and this is underpinned by the fact that black defendants receive on average longer custodial sentences than other ethnicities for the same crimes. It's clear that much more needs to be done across the system to begin to address these disparities, particularly in regard to diversity and training in the judiciary, and the Liberal Democrats tabled amendments to the Courts and Tribunals Bill in this regard. And this must also include implementing a new data strategy across the criminal justice system to ensure that capacity meets demand and that we understand the needs of all users, especially victims, vulnerable people, and those from ethnic minority backgrounds. Madam Deputy Speaker, Black History Month is a vital opportunity to celebrate the immense contribution that black people make to our lives in Britain.
And I would argue to those, and I hear it, that why do we need Black History Month? It's the same argument that's used when people say, well, why do we need Pride? Have we not, have we not got there? Have we not... no, we absolutely haven't. And my example in Chichester just this week is a prime example of the fact that these things are all the more important to keep highlighting year on year, because as the honourable member for Feltham and Heston said, progress is not linear, and it is very easy that we can slip backwards.
And we all need to be alive and alert to that and make sure that we are representing all of the wonderful qualities that we want our country to represent and not those that do not, that do not represent what we feel. And so we must carry on celebrating Black History Month because we have an immense contribution to celebrate. But it also provides the chance to recognize the scale of the challenge that we still face. And I'm very grateful to the Leader of the House for granting time for this important debate. Thank you.
Speaker 164
As members have already mentioned the late Jason Arday, I took some advice from the clerk. The Jason Arday case is sub judice because the inquest has been opened and adjourned. Honourable members should not refer to this specific case. If they want some more advice, we are here to provide that too. Abena Oppong-Asare.
Abena Asare
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I also want to take the opportunity to thank you for hosting the Speaker's Black History Month event last week Tuesday. It was good to meet other individuals that served in forces, doing so much in the community, and the way you brought us all together was, was really valued. I also want to thank my friend, the government minister, for her kind words. I also felt I'd help her correct the record, because I'm sure the government minister meant to say that Ghanaian jollof rice is the best.
So, as we've all discussed already, this year's theme is honouring our communities. This means a lot to me personally, given that my parents came to Britain from Ghana, and like many others, they worked really hard to make sure that me and my siblings had the best opportunities they wanted for themselves. Before I turn to those I wish to recognise today, I wanted to say something briefly. Earlier this month, I asked people online what they thought I should mention in this debate. Many responded with really helpful suggestions and stories of Black Britons who have enriched our communities and helped shape our country.
Sadly, quite a number responded with racist abuse. I want to be clear, those voices do not represent the overwhelming majority of people in my constituency and across the country. Black History Month is not about division. It's about recognising the people whose contributions have helped build modern Britain. And I believe in freedom of speech, robust debate, and the exchange of ideas, but I also believe we need to challenge racism and hatred whenever we encounter it.
No one should feel unable to participate in public life because of abuse and intimidation. I also want to mention, and I won't be breaching any, any investigation going forward, just about Professor Jason Arday's death. It's a reminder to all of us about how inequality exists, insists, assists. He made history by becoming one of the youngest Black professors at the University of Cambridge, and we shouldn't forget that.
And his story sadly raises the treatment of black people who reach positions of prominence. And his family have spoken about the abuse he's experienced and harassment alongside that. So my thoughts are with the family. Black History Month also reminds us all in terms of how far we've come and how far we still have to go, including tackling inequality such as the unacceptable maternal mortality gap experienced by black women. So today, I want to focus not on those who seek to divide us, but on those who strengthen our communities.
So I want to pay tribute to some people in my constituency. Michelle Rankin, Assistant Director for Economy and Skills at Greenwich Council. Michelle has been absolutely instrumental in bringing pride and place to Thamesmead to help empower local community to shape the future of our area. I also want to pay tribute to Benedicta Akpobo, a Queen's Nurse who's leading the work to amplify the voices of nurses working in social care across South East London through her professional leadership and voluntary work in both the UK and Nigeria. She is an inspiration to many.
I also want to pay tribute to John Okuboyejo, chair of the Pride and Place Board, who co-founded an innovative anti-theft bag and worked with the Prince's Trust and does a lot of work in the community by being a school governor. These are just a few of the remarkable people whose contributions deserve recognition. In previous years, I've been proud to recognize many others, including members of Windrush generation and countless black Britons whose service, sacrifice, and leadership has strengthened our country. Their stories remind us that black history is British history. And that is why Black History Month remains so important, not only just to celebrate the progress, but to inspire future generations and recognize those whose contributions have helped make Britain what it is today.
Speaker 180
I also want to take the opportunity to reflect on the trailblazers who have opened the doors for people like me. I've heard a number of people mention it in the House. Diane Abbott, the first black woman elected in Parliament. Paul Boateng, Britain's first black cabinet minister, also of Ghanaian descent and has supported me. And Valerie Amos, the first black woman to serve in cabinet.
Speaker 179
But I also want to take a pause and reflect and mention one of our new baronesses who's sitting in the gallery. Baroness June Sarpong, and I don't think I need to explain any more about her. She is a trailblazer and this is her second week and I know she's going to hit the ground running or she already has. So welcome, June Sarpong. I also want to go back and say that Valerie's story is particularly personal to me.
She grew up in Bexley, I grew up in Bexley, and I had the opportunity to do work experience with her. And seeing someone like her from my community achieving so much really mattered to me. And I know I've spoken about this before, but not everybody knows the story and I think it's important that we talk about the paths we've taken to get here. So when I was at university, I was really thinking about going into politics. And I remember speaking to a careers advisor saying I wanted to explore the opportunities of going into politics.
He laughed in my face and said the chances of someone like me getting a job in politics was very slim and not to bother trying. As you've probably guessed, I'm a very stubborn person and I didn't listen to his advice. And I think that for me, I've never really forgotten that conversation. I feel that it's made me extremely resilient as a person, more determined. I think when someone tells you you can't do something, it just makes you hungry to kind of push to do something.
And I also think that for me, it's about the future generation, about how we inspire in terms of what we do in our roles, particularly to get more young people in politics or playing a different role through civic life. Because I know that I didn't get here by myself, it was people that supported me to get here. And I see that reflection within my constituency of Erith and Thamesmead, where I see constituents of mine who are doing so much in the community, I've mentioned some of them already, but in terms of what they do to make sure we as a country thrive. And I think it's great that this theme is something that we're discussing this year. So I just really want to say that as well as celebrating people that have contributed to Black History Month, I think it's also important to also recognize those people that are also making a difference and thinking about the future, but also to recognize those people when they get the opportunities to break those barriers, that they are treated with dignity and respect.
Abena Asare
Because it's not just about representation, it's not just about getting there, it's about how you've treated, treat people. So that's why I wanted to, wanted to put on record, but also to say Black History Month shouldn't be just this month, it should be all around the year, around the year, but the reason we celebrate it this month is because we've still got a long way to go before we achieve equality. Thank you, Madam Deputy.
Speaker 164
I've just noticed that the Serjeant at Arms has entered the chamber. I think we all want to notice that I believe the Serjeant at Arms is our first black Serjeant at Arms, appointed in October 2019, and he's hating me saying this, so let's stare at him a little bit longer. Carla Denyer.
Carla Denyer
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to speak in today's debate marking Black History Month. And I want to thank the honorable member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green for opening the debate with a speech so powerful that it gave me the chills, which I don't think is entirely because I think I might have caught that cold off her on Monday, although that may also be the case. In my maiden speech, I talked about how the story of my home city, Bristol, cannot be disentangled from the UK's shameful and immoral history of colonialism and slavery. That is a history that we cannot and must not turn away from. Bristol merchants financed over 2,000 slaving voyages between 1698 and 1807.
Speaker 184
These ships carried over 500,000 enslaved Africans from Africa to slave labor in the Americas. This shameful trade is an ongoing stain, and it's why my party backs slavery reparations. Since 2020, we've supported the idea of a UK government-backed all-party parliamentary commission of inquiry for truth and reparatory justice, aligned with the United Nations frameworks to address the legacy of the transatlantic trade in enslaved Africans and colonialism. And I'm proud to say that my city also backs this call, after a motion brought by my former colleague, Green Councillor Cleo Lake, five years ago. And this is work I hope to continue to push on as a member of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on African Reparations.
The UN's declaration earlier this year that the trafficking of enslaved Africans is the gravest crime facing humanity and calling for reparations as a concrete step towards remedying historical wrong is therefore very welcome. I hope this strong UN stance will encourage the UK government to mark Black History Month by acknowledging the inhumane crimes Britain inflicted on African people for centuries and the ongoing impact of those crimes on the Global South today. My constituency, Bristol Central, is also home to a blue plaque at the Seven Stars Inn in Redcliffe that marks how Thomas Clarkson, an anti-slavery activist, together with the landlord of the Seven Stars, collected testimonies from sailors in 1787 that were used as evidence in Parliament. These statements played a role in the passing of the 1807 Slave Trade Act, which eventually led to the end of the historic transatlantic slave trade. And fast-forwarding 150 years, we've already heard extensively today about the 1963 Bristol bus boycott, which was a landmark moment in race relations in the UK.
Speaker 185
On the same day that Martin Luther King gave his famous "I Have a Dream" speech in the US, in Bristol, the city bus company agreed to end its racist hiring practices following a successful boycott campaign. The boycott was widely cited as a turning point in racial justice in the UK, as we've heard, leading ultimately to the Race Relations Act in 1965. And our city's more recent history saw 15,000 Black Lives Matter supporters gather in the city in 2020 and the toppling of a statue of Edward Colston, a 17th-century slave trader who is believed to have transported about 80,000 men, women, and children from Africa to the Americas between 1672 and 1689. That statue is now displayed in a glass case in the M Shed museum in my constituency in its damaged state and surrounded by some of the placards held by protesters on the day it was toppled. Bristol City Council's culture team say this about the exhibit, and I quote: "This isn't erasing history, this is recording history.
History isn't something that can remain static and preserved; that moment was history in action." Those words feel particularly salient to this debate because in celebrating those people in our communities whose contributions are all too often unseen, as Sharon Inko-Tariah MBE, the editor of Black History Month UK magazine, puts it, we are also writing history, making the history that we want recorded and keeping it alive. To that end, I want to give a special shout-out to one of the many people making black history in Bristol today, and that's the first Lord Mayor of Bristol to come from the Somali community, Councillor Yasin Mohamud. Yasin is bringing his experience as a refugee, his experience as a member of the black and minority ethnic community, and his work representing one of Bristol's more deprived areas. He's bringing all of those to the role of Lord Mayor, and as he said shortly before taking up the post, his focus is on unity, on bringing people together to celebrate the diversity and strength of our city and to ensure that every community feels recognized and valued.
Adam Jogee
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I'm enjoying listening to the honorable lady, although I don't agree with everything she said, but I'll touch on that when I, if I catch your eye later.
But I wonder following the tribute she's just made to the current Lord Mayor of Bristol, I wonder whether she'd extend that tribute to my noble friend Lord Rees in the other place, who sets an amazing example as a black leader in local government.
Speaker 183
I thank the hon. member for his intervention and indeed the now Lord Rees, formerly the first black mayor of Bristol and in fact one of the first in Europe, also featured in my maiden speech and I recognize the great contribution he made to our city. Finally, I want to highlight the campaign launched last year for Bristol to become the UK civil rights capital. I think the fact that two members from outside Bristol have already told the story of Bristol's pivotal role in British black history supports the case for that very strongly. The campaign bringing together academics, business leaders and politicians, including the Lord Rees that we've just mentioned, well, I will quote directly from one of the campaign's lead organizers, Jules Davis, and he said, Bristol has never waited for permission to lead. This city has shown the country what change looks like.
Speaker 185
Activism has always been the lifeblood of systemic change here. Black History Month is a much needed chance to remember the importance of that systemic change and how many people are making that change happen. To quote Sharon Inko-Taria again, there is still so much we do not know, so many stories waiting to be uncovered, so many names waiting to be spoken, so much history waiting to be reclaimed, recorded and shared. That potential is very alive in this room today and in my home city of Bristol and across our communities and I look forward to continuing to work cross-party to help realize it. Thank you.
James Terry Jermy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the minister for her opening remarks and for her fortitude in delivering them. This year's Black History Month focuses on honoring our communities and I wanted to take the opportunity to bring honorable members' attention to the market town of Thetford in my constituency of South West Norfolk, because a market town in rural Norfolk may not be the first place that members think of when considering areas of social and cultural progress in the United Kingdom. But it was in my hometown of Thetford that the UK had its first black mayor. Allan Glaisyer Minns emigrated to England from the Bahamas as a child in the mid-1800s and he began his story in London. After finishing at Nassau Grammar School, he began studying medicine at Guy's Hospital not far from here.
Before the age of 30, he was already registered with the British Medical Association. Now, Dr. Minns shortly moved to join his brother who was practicing medicine in Thetford and I have a little doubt that Norfolk weather didn't quite match the Bahamas and I'm afraid that Thetford somehow lacked sandy beaches. Regardless, there was something about our town and the community that made him want to stay, because that community spirit and that cohesion resonated with Dr. Minns, because he decided to enter politics and he was elected to serve on Thetford Town Council. He was elected as a councillor in 1903 and he was elected by his peers to become mayor back in 1904. And he served for 10 years as a local councillor as well as serving as a local doctor and he was actually elected mayor of Thetford twice.
And I refer members' attention to my own register of interest because like Dr. Minns, I've served as a member of Thetford Town Council.
In my own case, I was elected at 22. I'm still there some 19 years later. And honorable members can therefore work out my age. But I too had the honor of becoming Mayor of Thetford back in 2016. And I was proud to wear that mayoral chain that was the same chain that was worn by Dr. Mimms all those years earlier.
Christopher John Vince
Will it take an intervention? Of course. Can I thank my honorable friend for giving an incredible speech and talking about a really trailblazing man in Dr. Mimms? I think we should all celebrate what he achieved in Thetford and it's a really wonderful story. We heard from our honorable friend about her experiences in getting involved in politics.
Does she share the concerns that I have that if Dr. Mimms was to put himself forward into politics at the moment with the horrible things that black MPs and black elected officials have to put up with online, it would be very difficult? And would he agree with me that it's the duty of everyone in this house to challenge that vile racism and disinformation that we see online?
James Terry Jermy
Absolutely. I thank my honorable friend for that intervention. I'm going to come on to some more recent, less positive examples, but I absolutely share the sentiment there. Now, Thetford actually lays claim to the third oldest mayoralty in the entire country and our civic history is truly fascinating. So it's particularly noteworthy that Dr. Mimms became that first black mayor.
And it's also worth mentioning that Dr. Mimms' sister, Ophelia, was also later elected onto the town council at a time when women could not even vote in parliamentary elections. It shows that the Mimms family story is a part of our wider history of people who contributed to the life of their community at a time when opportunities to participate in public life were far from equal. Today, Thetford Town Council pays tribute to Dr. Mimms' legacy by showing school groups around our Guildhall and introducing them to Dr. Mimms' story. And like me, they feel amazed and proud. And I pay tribute to local councillors like Annie Blackburn, Doug Jefferson, and Stuart Wright, as well as the staff at Thetford Town Council who are working to ensure that there is a statue of Dr. Mimms on permanent display in Thetford as we approach the 100th anniversary of his death in 2030.
Because I feel that Dr. Mimms' story reminds us that Black History Month is not something that exists separately and black history is not something that exists separately from the history of our towns and villages. It is woven into the very fabric of our communities. He was not simply making history by becoming Britain's first black mayor. He was serving his neighbors. He was contributing to civic life and helping to shape the future of our community.
David Edmund Burton-Sampson
Will my honorable friend give way? Of course. I thank my honorable friend for giving way. And on that point, last night I joined the 1987 committee set up by the fantastic Fatima Kamara and her team. And you can tell by the name 1987 it recognizes the year that the mother of the house entered this house, that historic year.
They aim to help young black people to get those opportunities to get involved in politics and political and public life. Will he join me in congratulating the 1987 committee for the wonderful work they're doing in working with young black people to get them into this type of arena that we're in?
James Terry Jermy
I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and recognize his own trailblazing experience as a fellow member from the Eastern region. I pay tribute to him and I absolutely congratulate the organizations that he's spoken about. Because it's actually really important that these achievements are recognized because sadly in the case of Dr. Mimms, his story was forgotten. And for a while it was thought that John Archer, the Mayor of Battersea, was Britain's first black mayor despite being elected 10 years later. So we must talk about and recognize these achievements.
And I apologize to the member for Battersea.
I hope that mentioning his story today will help honor his legacy and highlight the work that he did for his community. And it is a reminder that public democratic participation belongs to everyone in our communities and that the contributions of those who came before us should inspire all that follow. And it has been a difficult few months for my constituency and particularly my hometown of Thetford. We've seen violent protests in my community and amongst those who were protesting, I absolutely recognize that there were people with legitimate concerns about immigration, whether that be public safety or concerns about impact on services. But sadly there were many too motivated by racism and we must call out and denounce that at every opportunity.
And I similarly condemn those who fan the flames of extremism, particularly those who do so for political gain. Their actions led to black and minority ethnics of my community feeling unsafe and living in fear, often the fear of being misidentified as an asylum seeker. It resulted in children like my 10-year-old niece of mixed heritage being asked at school if she was an asylum seeker. We can and must do better than this. And I feel that the government and the Home Office in particular needs to do far more in relation to community cohesion, particularly in areas like mine which are close to a former military base that's been identified as a possible site to house asylum seekers or those communities that are currently seeing concerns about the dispersal policy.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way. Does he also agree with me that we need to stop politicians from profiting from sharing these views? The honorable member for Great Yarmouth has declared over 100,000 pounds that he's earned from X since being elected to this place, so it pays to say more explicitly appalling things. Does he agree with me that we should end that practice entirely?
Speaker 164
Just before the debate continues, it is etiquette when members are mentioning other members in the chamber that they give them prior notice. Terry Jermy.
James Terry Jermy
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I share the concern of the honorable member that raised that point. And I think it's clear that there is still a very long way to go to achieve equality and remembering those pioneers like Dr. Mimms, like so many of the other people that we have heard today, that must go hand in hand with examining the opportunities available to people today. And we must ask everyone, must ensure that everybody has a fair chance to progress at work, to contribute to public life and to have their voices heard. In my opinion, each act and gesture of tolerance and diversity makes us a stronger and a more united country. Black History Month gives us an opportunity to share stories such as those as Dr. Mimms and I thank honorable members for this opportunity to do that.
It gives stories fair recognition and ensures that future generations are aware of just how far we have come as a society so that we can keep pushing further.
Speaker 189
Dawn Butler, I believe, was the first black female minister, is that correct?
Dawn Butler
Oh, that's, that's, that's made my day, Madam Deputy Speaker, because normally it's only my mom that remembers, so thank you so much.
And it actually makes me really proud as the first black female MP minister of this country, and I was the first black female MP to stand at that dispatch box, to see other black female MPs do the same, like the minister. Thank you for your powerful speech and your powerful opening. And I was as proud as I was last year when the, I witnessed the speech from my honourable friend, the member for Erith and Thamesmead at the dispatch box, and the year before, my honourable friend, the member for Coventry and North West at the dispatch box. So watching generations of women come in sort of after me makes me extremely proud. The only thing I would ask the government to do is to make sure that this debate is scheduled every year in the diary so that we don't have to go around this merry-go-round of applying to the backbench business debate and then being told it's being had in government's time.
Let's just put it in the diary and have a set date, because this debate is becoming more and more fundamental, because we are, as it was mentioned earlier today, witnessing the unapologetic rise of the far right, the rise of racism and the rise of white supremacy. And when the Reform-led council, St Helens Council, shamefully announced it will no longer formally observe Black History Month, we know that the rest of us have to make sure that we observe it, put it in the books, and we have to fight to ensure that black history is not erased, because black history is indeed a part of British history. And I want to start my speech by acknowledging the man who brought Black History Month to the UK, he has been mentioned earlier, Mr Akyaaba Addai-Sebo. We owe him a great gratitude for his tireless work to ensure that black history, black achievement and black identity is not erased but celebrated. And the theme this year, in honouring our communities, recognising everyday contributions of black people across the whole, whole UK, whose work often goes unseen, is vital.
And we have lost many of those people from last year. And I apologise in advance for the many deserving names that I may not mention. But Yvonne Brewster, pioneer who co-founded Talawa Theatre Company. Gairin Beane, British black feminist and community organiser. Uriah Rennie, trailblazing Premier League referee.
Sid Lawrence, pioneering black England cricketer. Trevor Toussaint, British television and theatre actor. Sonny Blacks, one of the founders of Notting Hill Carnival. And some of my personal friends who have passed away. One of my closest friends, Kanya King, British businesswoman and founder of MOBO, Music of Black Origin Awards.
She created an award ceremony to recognise black music where the major industries didn't. Bonnie Greer, playwright, novelist and critic. Rennick Thomas, affectionately known as Tom. He had a bakery in Forest Gate and in Ridley Road. He was in a bakery war with my dad to who can produce the best hard dough bread and bun, and he was my mum's best friend after my dad died.
And lastly, Professor Jason Arday. He was an exceptional scholar of race and inequality. He joined the faculty of the University of Cambridge in 2023, and in August 2026, he was hounded to his death. And the hunt started by a self-proclaimed eugenicist and white supremacist. Madam Deputy Speaker, it would be incomplete to honour our communities without acknowledging what has been taken away.
Last Saturday, I attended a reparations conference organised by my honourable friend from Clapham and Brixton Hill, and it made me think of something.
Madam Deputy Speaker, if I stole your Rolex watch, would it become mine? Of course not. If I gave that Rolex watch to my daughter, would it become hers? Of course not. A gift does not erase a theft.
If she passed it to her child, would it suddenly become a family heirloom? Of course not. Time does not turn theft into ownership. Now imagine, Madam Deputy Speaker, that your daughter discovers the truth, that your watch was stolen. Would she not have every right to ask for that watch back?
And suppose I used that stolen watch as collateral to get a bank loan and bought a house and passed that wealth onto my children. The benefit of that theft would be in my family for generations after generations. And some, Madam Deputy Speaker, will say, but today's generation didn't commit the wrong. That would be true. But also your daughter didn't suffer the theft.
Others will say, but the past is the past, leave it alone. But the benefits of the injustice are still being enjoyed, then it's the then the consequences are not in the past at all, it is actually in the present. So that is the preparation that is the principle behind reparations. It's not about recognizing that the passage of time does not transform an injustice into rightful inheritance. Because if time alone can turn stolen property into rightful ownership, then what you're actually saying is that stealing is okay.
You just have to merely wait until people die or the truth might not be exposed or told. So the issue isn't about inherited guilt. It is about inherited benefit and inherited loss. If we would not accept that argument for a stolen watch, why should we accept it for stolen labor, stolen wealth, stolen land, or stolen opportunity? When we look at the world today, we still see the legacy of the historic injustice across Africa and the Caribbean.
The effects of centuries of exploitation remain visible. Madam Deputy Speaker, we can all recognize the iconic Louis Vuitton pattern, but where did it originate from? The Adinkra symbols of the Akan people of Ghana predate many luxury brands by centuries. These symbols are rich in meaning and history. And the oldest surviving Adinkra cloth is kept in a place that holds the largest collection of stolen property in the world, the British Museum.
So where is the line between appreciation and appropriation? Appreciation acknowledges and credits the source. Appropriation too often profits from culture while erasing its origins. Exploiting indigenous cultures for profit should not be normalized or accepted. That is why the theme of honoring our communities is so important.
The Maasai Intellectual Property Initiative is so powerful because it it was established to address the unauthorized use of the Maasai branding and it enables businesses to work with the Maasai tribe ethically, ensuring that benefits flow back to the Maasai people. It is so important that in this debate, when we're honoring communities, that we give back, especially what is stolen and what is owed. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't just talk the talk, I walk the walk. I created the Bernie Grant Leadership Programme, the one pound student fees to get young people engaged in politics, and the Parliamentary Black Caucus, because change will not happen without action.
Sometimes this period of time feels extremely overwhelming when we think about the rise of racism and far right and all that is thrown at us. But as the civil rights activist John Lewis said, do not get lost in a sea of despair. Be hopeful, be optimistic. Ours is not the struggle of one day, one week, one year. Ours is the struggle of a lifetime or even many lifetimes.
And each one of us in every generation must do our part. So my question to us and to the country is have you done your part in this struggle? Because for me, I want to see the end to racist practices and structures all across the world in different institutions. I want to see the end to that in my lifetime. And we should not be afraid to call out wrongdoings, whether it is violence against women and girls, whether it's calling out pedophiles, whether it's class wars, whether it's genocide, whether it's racism, we need to call it out so that we can end it in our lifetime.
John Lewis also said, never be afraid to make some noise and get in good trouble, necessary trouble. And I am known to get in a little bit of trouble from time to time. I may have got into trouble earlier, we'll soon see. But Madam Deputy Speaker, I show up. International Women's Day debates, I show up.
International Men's Day debates, I show up. Debates on white working class boys, I show up. LGBTQI+ debates, I show up. And if we're going to beat the racists, we have to show up. We have to show up for each other.
We have to speak out and show up and protect black and brown people. We have to show up for them when they're being abused and discriminated online. We have to show up. And when we show up, when we unite, we will never be defeated. Thank you.
Speaker 194
Before I call the next speaker, can I further remind members that the JSR Daycare case is sub judice because the inquest has been opened and adjourned and while tributes are welcome and allowed in this debate, members should not stray into the circumstances on contributory factors of his death. I call Deidre Costigan.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I would like to thank the minister for her very powerful opening remarks today and it is a pleasure to follow my near neighbor in the debate, the member for Brent East. I always get confused in East or West. Madam Deputy Speaker, as we've heard, the theme of this year's Black History Month is honoring our communities. And it's all about those ordinary black British people who have done the rarely celebrated work of building this nation, of working in our factories, in the NHS, and in so many other jobs that helped this country to grow. It is about how they stood up to everyday racism, often on a daily basis, and yet they pushed on for their children and their grandchildren to be able to succeed.
And I would love to tell that story today of the black parents in Ealing Southall who refused to accept racism in schools and so sent their kids to supplementary schools to give them a fair chance in life, of the black workers who joined trade unions to fight racism at work, and the black tenants who campaigned for fair access to housing. But Madam Deputy Speaker, on the 26th of January this year, we lost my constituent Eric Huntley, a giant of the black community, and so it is only right that I pay tribute to him today.
He is not quite an unsung hero. In fact, there is a special Nubian Jack Community Trust plaque, blue plaque, above his home at 141 Coldershaw Road, which he would proudly show me whenever I passed. But he is not sung about anywhere near enough, and I hope to help rectify this today. Eric and his wife Jessica, who died in 2013, were lifelong activists and educators. Eric came here from Guyana in 1957, and Jessica followed in 1962, when they'd saved enough for her to pay for the passage over.
In 1968 they founded one of the UK's first black-led publishing companies, Bogle-L'Ouverture Publications, from a printing press in their front room on Coldershaw Road. In 1975 they opened a bookshop specialising in black literature at 5a Chignell Place in West Ealing. Eric described it as an oasis in the desert of West London for the black community. With few other community spaces, it became an important cultural and academic hub, providing a drop-in centre for parents, students and teachers. The bookshop also offered career advice and help with job applications.
It became known globally, with visits from black authors and artists from around the world. But it also came under attack from the National Front, with racist graffiti, smashed windows and excrement pushed through the letterbox. Jessica told the story of how the Ku Klux Klan made threatening phone calls, where they were told they had seven days to pack up the shop and leave, and were left in no doubt about the consequences if they didn't. But Eric and Jessica refused to be intimidated. With other bookshop owners, the Huntleys founded Bookshop Joint Action and campaigned against racist threats both in Ealing and across London, drawing national press coverage and forcing the police to safeguard the bookshop.
Eric and Jessica were key figures in the Caribbean Education and Community Workers Association, which was set up in response to the racist labelling of large numbers of black children as educationally subnormal. They were involved in the supplementary school system, which was almost a parallel education system that black communities were forced to set up to stop their children's life chances being damaged by racism in the school system. They were also part of the Black Parents Movement, which campaigned against laws that allowed police to stop, search and arrest people on suspicion of intent to commit a crime, and which was disproportionately used against young black people in the 70s and 80s. Now the last time I saw Eric was at a poetry event last year run by CASE, the Caribbean and African Cultural Centre in West Ealing, that is very much a part of his legacy. He was as full of life and opinions as ever, and I know he would have lots to say about our new Prime Minister if he was still around today.
Eric's death in January at the age of 96 is truly the end of an era. But he and Jessica's work in building a community for black people across West London will never be forgotten, from the blue plaque at the house in Coldershaw Road where they started out, to murals of them both on the windows of West Ealing Community Library. But most importantly of all, their spirit lives on in every young black Briton in Ealing Southall today who says, I refuse to shut up, I refuse to go away, I refuse to accept things as they are. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope this House will join me today, not just in honouring our communities, but in honouring Eric Huntley, a true West London legend whose warmth, activism and determination continues to shape the lives of black Britons today. Thank you.
Adam Jogee
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I congratulate the Minister on her speech and for persevering through it. She was croaky in voice, but stood at that dispatch box and we're all very proud of her. And I'm very grateful that the Shadow Minister is still here. She's always the very example of courtesy to me and I'm grateful to her for that. We enjoy the festive tune.
I think she ought to choose God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen because there's talk of comfort and joy in that one, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the same goes for the honorable lady from Chichester for her contribution too. And we've heard excellent speeches from colleagues from across the House. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't really like germs and there's been lots of coughing and sniffing in this debate. I think my friend from Feltham and Heston needs some form of medicament, but I wish all colleagues who have the sniffles a speedy recovery.
I hope I don't upset some members who aren't here, Madam Deputy Speaker, by pointing out that I'm English. I'm a rare breed in that I'm a Black British man born and raised in England with English roots and I'm a member of this House. I've said this before, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'll say it again: each and every person who lives, learns, and works in our United Kingdom, each and every person who moved here to work in our National Health Service and on our railways, in our schools and on our building sites, deserves to have their issues, their concerns, and their needs heard, listened to, and celebrated. I'm proud to be English, proud to be British, a proud son of a Zimbabwean-born dad and the proud grandson of a Jamaican who came to our country in the 1940s to help us win World War II, as many, many other Black and Asian men did in both Great Wars and, of course, in years since. I'm proud to be Black, Madam Deputy Speaker, a Black British Member of Parliament born and raised in England with a constituency in the county of Staffordshire that's been home to my family for approaching a century.
And as the House knows, I'm the first Black man to represent a seat anywhere in the West Midlands in this House. I don't say that because I'm obsessed with myself, I promise. I say it because I don't want anyone else to have to. I'll happily give way to my... I think be careful what you wish for would be my response to the honorable member for Buckingham and Bletchley because you'll be caught out if you're not careful.
I don't say this because I'm obsessed with myself, because I want it to be normal, to be a given, and to happen right across this island home of ours that someone like me can serve in this House. Now, we all know that Black history is British history and it is certainly true in the context of our United Kingdom. That should not be a controversial or difficult thing to say. So I'll say it again, Madam Deputy Speaker: Black history is British history. And I'm tired of people who should know better, some who sit in this House, who appear to be determined to tear our communities apart.
People more obsessed with division rather than unity. People who profess an empty and meaningless care for and commitment to this country. It isn't British to walk by on the other side. And those political leaders who seek to tell us otherwise should know better. And let me also say, Madam Deputy Speaker, to some in this House, I note they're not here, if you have an identity crisis and you don't know who you are, if you're unsure how to be comfortable in your own skin, I'm really sorry for you.
But please do not project your insecurities onto the rest of us. Do not infect our national life with your complete and utter rubbish. I'm very proud of who I am and where I'm from. I was blessed to be born to a family who made sure that me and my siblings were. My great, great, well, she is great, late but great, but my white English grandmother who had some Irish in her too, my Jamaican grandfather who made this country his home, my dad's parents born in Southern Rhodesia when it was run by this Parliament.
I'm proud of my Englishness, my African roots and my Caribbean heritage. Nobody, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I mean nobody is going to make me feel otherwise, tell me otherwise or make me question that. And as we approach Armistice Day and Remembrance Sunday in a couple of weeks when our United Kingdom comes together to reflect and acknowledge the sacrifices of all the men and boys who went to war and all the women who kept the show on the road at home. Nobody in this chamber today or in any political party or in any community in our country or corner of this land should ever forget that we would never have beaten the fascists on the beaches of Normandy or at Gallipoli without the bravery and valour of young men, black, white and Asian. Their bravery won the day, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And for many of those who returned from the front line, our United Kingdom became their home. These black men and women rolled up their sleeves, they put their shoulders to the wheel and they helped rebuild a nation ravaged by war. I've acknowledged before that their skills and their smarts and with them we saw homes built, our buses back on the road, railways working once again, although for someone who has to get the Avanti train back to North Staffordshire every Thursday, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not sure what we could do with more of their railway working behavior, put it that way. Our National Health Service was established and as the husband of a nurse that's particularly important to me, restaurants were opened and food was sold with spice, seasoning and everything nice, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fabric shops and tailors ensured our country had some of the best dressed on the world stage and our United Kingdom bounced back.
So much more happened and we as a country would not and could not have done it without the sacrifices and contribution of the black British community. And you know what, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's okay for us to say that. I've said it before in this House and I'll say it again. That doesn't take away from white people or Asian people or those of mixed heritage because we all have a contribution to make and we all deserve to have that contribution acknowledged and celebrated. It's that blend, that connection and that understanding that we must use Black History Month this year and every year to hold on to.
You know, Madam Deputy Speaker, this for me is as much about class as it is about race. The black families that I represent in Chesterton and Silverdale or in Madeley and Newcastle-under-Lyme who moved to build a life to raise their families, they haven't had the same experiences of people like Kwasi Kwarteng, for example. Those families live in exactly the same economic situations as their white neighbors. And so we have a wider challenge before us. And that challenge is how do we build an economy that works for all of our people?
How do we uplift, enrich and empower all of our people? And whilst I absolutely believe that the contribution made by the black British community must be acknowledged every single day of the year, I do welcome the focus that Black History Month provides all of us to celebrate, to enjoy and to recognize. As we celebrate Black History Month, Madam Deputy Speaker, I like to reflect, reflect on the promise of our country to think that my grandfather arrived here on a boat during the war and here I am today. Now my grandfather came before Windrush, Madam Deputy Speaker, and everyone quite rightly who's spoken in this debate I think has mentioned Windrush. And I don't say this to them but I say it generally, there were black people in this country before 1948 and the experiences that my grandfather and the men who came with him on that boat in 1941 made it ever so slightly easier for those who came after them and it's important that we don't forget those people too.
And the fact that I am standing here today wouldn't happen in many other parts of the world but it happened in this our United Kingdom and we should never forget that. I am proud of my race, Madam Deputy Speaker, but it doesn't define me, it inspires me every single day. It's opened doors for me and regrettably I suspect closed a few too, but that does and it does allow me to show those who come after me that anything is possible. Now my honorable friend the Minister touched on online racism and that some seek to normalize it and so too did the honorable lady from Chichester when talking about our honorable friend the member for Eastbourne.
I've never been so conscious of the colour of my skin as I have been when calling out the racist throwing abuse towards the right honourable member for Richmond, the former Prime Minister, our honourable friend the member for Eastbourne, and the member for Huntingdon. And I was looking through, Madam Deputy Speaker, at the responses on Twitter as I was listening to other colleagues, when I called out that racism. And I will share a couple with the House. I was called another foreigner in British politics. I was born here, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Boris Johnson, the former Prime Minister, was born in the United States. Don't think he's called a foreigner. What does that tell us? Another called me a parasite. My favourite was being told that with a surname like that, you can't be English.
It's a real shame, Madam Deputy Speaker, that there are some in our country who have such little going on in their lives that they have the time to talk such garbage. And as my honourable friend from South Derbyshire, a nearish neighbour, pointed out earlier, no one is born racist. But it's important that I give this snapshot of what happens when you look like me in this House and you call that racism out. But it's not just online, Madam Deputy Speaker, it happens on our streets too. Look at what we saw in Northern Ireland earlier this year, a place I know well, my wife's from there and we spend as much time as we can.
Streets of this country saw black and Asian people chased out of their homes. Hospital workers hiding in the boots of their white neighbours because they were scared that they wouldn't get home. In 2024, that is an utter disgrace, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's not who we are, and it must never be who we become. Over the last decade, I've had the honour of attending Black History Month events at local schools, churches, and community hubs.
This is quite good going for me. When I got married and gave my speech then, I actually cried. So this is an improvement, Madam Deputy Speaker. But I did speak for 28 minutes when I got married, so I'll see how tolerant you'll be of me this afternoon. But over the last decade, I've had the honour of attending, as I say, Black History Month events at local schools, churches, and community hubs.
I've listened to children speak of their lived experiences, good and bad, and to pensioners recall the stories of their ancestors. And the overwhelming feeling I come away with every year at the end of this month is how proud we all should be of the black British contribution made to our communities. Now there has been talk of reparations in this debate and in recent weeks ahead of the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting in Antigua. I am the descendant of slaves. And I want to share my view.
And I say this, as I said at the beginning of my remarks, Madam Deputy Speaker, as someone who is very, very proud of and aware of who he is, where he's from, and what he is on earth to do. But who do we pay? What value do we put on the life of those disgracefully, immorally, and forcibly removed from their homes? Where does it stop?
I tell you where I think it can start, Madam Deputy Speaker. It can start with a British government that takes the Commonwealth seriously. That stops lumping the Africa and development briefs in the Foreign Office together. We have to stop looking at our relationship with Africa through the prism of making ourselves feel better with a development policy approach. There's more to Africa and there's more to our relationship with Africa than just development.
It starts by ensuring that we reflect on the legacy of the British Empire and our collective and complicated history. By properly and effectively trading with the Caribbean and Africa, and as much as I love Canada, Australia, New Zealand, we must do more and go further. We should be establishing genuine and real links between our leaders, and I hope that more of my senior colleagues in government will lead by example. And I say this word consciously, but I want to see more ministerial visits to the former colonies. Because it's on those visits that we can show our equal partners the respect that they deserve.
That would go so much more in acknowledging the contribution that our forefathers made and that the black community is making today, and it would show that this government gets it. When my right honourable friend the Member for Wakefield became Prime Minister, I was asked to become PPS to the Secretary of State for Education. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I was told that that's on papers the first step on the ministerial ladder. In reality, it on occasion feels a little different. But it's an important role because through it, I'm determined to ensure that everyone who needs the skills to succeed is able to get them.
That everyone who wants to seize the opportunities before them is able to. And that we give our young people, all of our young people, the tools to succeed and thrive. I said in my maiden speech, Madam Deputy Speaker, that me being a parliamentarian wasn't inevitable, but it was possible. The fact that I am tells me how far the black community has come. From my grandfather getting off the boat in a cold Liverpool in 1941 to me this morning, late, getting off the tube at Westminster station and taking my seat on these green benches.
The fact that I am in Parliament reminds us of what we need to do to lift everybody up. And is a reminder of that age-old value, and one that I've repeated on many occasions, that anything can be possible in this United Kingdom of ours. We all know that the black community has made an unbelievable contribution to the life and soul of this country. From music and the arts to film and sports, and yes, food. Although the honourable lady from Beaconsfield mentioned jerk chicken in the House of Commons earlier on, let me tell you that's not jerk chicken.
And there's a couple of places we can go if she wants to taste some. And I think in a tribute to that, my grandmother was born and raised, as I said, to a white working-class family in Birkenhead in the 1920s. And having been with my grandfather for more than half a century, my white English grandmother's rice and peas was second to none. I just wish she'd passed that down to all of her ten daughters. But under this, no, no, no, there's, we'll talk about that later.
Some things are complicated, I say to my honourable friend the Member from Brent. But under this Prime Minister, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is a renewed determination and focus to bring our country together. To tackle injustice wherever we find it and not to let the haters win. So let's get on with it.
Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's always a pleasure to speak in the Black History Month debate. It's educational, it's inspiring, and while I know many of the Black Britons we celebrate, I always love hearing about those I've never heard about before, especially when members tell us about the Black Britons from their own constituencies.
That's what makes this debate matter.
Yes, I will do.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I hope she'll forgive me for intervening on the honorable member, but earlier the previous Madam Deputy Speaker mentioned the Serjeant at Arms. So I hope she'll forgive me for laying credit to the Serjeant at Arms because he was educated in my constituency at Bishop Luffa School and just put on the record how proud Bishop Luffa School are of how far he's come.
Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy
I thank the honorable member for her intervention and we're all extremely proud of the Serjeant at Arms. Now I want to start by congratulating my honorable friend and neighbor for her powerful opening speech and I hope that there is some pepper soup in her future to help her with her cold. And I also want to join her in paying tribute to the member for Erith and Thamesmead who has in our time in this place led on this debate on a number of different occasions. And I also want to pay tribute to the member for Erith and Thamesmead because earlier this week I read out a list of names and I inadvertently missed her off. Now she may wonder why this is the fourth time that I am apologizing.
Maybe it's the death stare she gave me on the day, or maybe it's the way she's looked at me out the side of her eye ever since. Or maybe it's because of all people, my fellow British Ghanaian MP of whom I'm extremely proud, the idea that she would think that I would shadily forget her is just beyond me. So when we err publicly, I think we should also atone in the same way. So I would like to put on record in this House that the honorable member for Erith and Thamesmead has been a huge support to me, particularly in the past few months as I've dealt with a challenging time as the Member of Parliament for the Arday family. And whilst I know her well enough to know that she will look at me out the side of her eye at least until 2027, which is not too far away, I hope that this House now knows that she is somebody that I celebrate in my community.
Now as we celebrate our friends and community members, I think it's really important that we don't lose sight of the dangerous times that we live in. Online hate is rising and foreign billionaires like Elon Musk pour time, money, and energy into far-right movements like the one led by Tommy Robinson. And racism is no longer whispered, it's amplified and it's monetized and it's making its way into our politics. And that's why this debate is not a nicety, it's a necessity. Despite what some in the Reform Party would like to suggest, Black Britons are British.
Our history is British history. Our contributions are equal to those of other Britons and equally worthy of celebration. And before the online trolls pile in with the inevitable why do we have Black History Month, what about White History Month, I would remind them that had they paid attention in school, history of other Britons has dominated our curriculum and happens all throughout the year. And the reason why we have a Black History Month is just one month to honor those who were clearly written out of that history of our history books. So Black History Month is intended to exist until such time when they are truly incorporated.
It is a means to an end and it was never intended to be an end in itself. And we say Black history is British history simply as a call to action on that. Now Black History Month was first marked in October 1987 as we've heard repeatedly, but it was specifically done on the 150th anniversary of Caribbean emancipation. It was organized by Akyaaba Addai-Sebo, a Ghanaian-born special projects officer at the Greater London Council.
Now he has been trying tirelessly, particularly in this year as we move into the 40 year celebration next year, to get in touch with government ministers and the Mayor of London and others to make sure that he is included in the celebration. So I hope that that is something that members will hear about and encourage as the person that actually led on this. And in terms of the idea of black history being British history, I was very, very pleased to hear the opposition spokesperson saying that during her opening speech. And I think I was very pleased to hear that because I understand from comments that have been left on my own social media that that is not the view of everybody in the house. Now I posted a video of myself speaking during Black History Month perhaps a couple of years ago and making that very specific point that black history is British history.
And her colleague commented that, you know, this was not the case, didn't make a racist comment but made a point about how it was divisive. But on this same post, I received a lot of racist abuse and some which the of the like I had not necessarily seen in that volume before, people calling me the N-word, people telling me to F-off and go back to where I came from, people sending monkey photographs, all of these sorts of things that show just how turbo-charged it is. And I think that the honorable member for Chichester raised it when she said that things seem to be going backwards. And I think we really do need to keep an eye on this. So as we look forward to the 40 years celebration of Black History Month next year, I hope a lot more effort is put in right from the top in this house to challenging racism.
Because we have to remember that Black History Month in itself began as an act of resistance, a way to challenge racism and inspire young people and a way to repair the record. And today it's a fixture in our national calendar with thousands of events every October. And that is why you will find some members of this house are losing their voice because of those events every October. Now that did not happen by accident. It happened because campaigners, activists and educators fought for it and they still do.
And they make sure that our young people learn things that were never taught to us. They lift up names that would otherwise be forgotten and they push back against those who profit from dividing our communities. But every year, black members are forced to play a guessing game. We look on the order paper with no idea whether this month will be honored with a debate in this chamber. So whilst I am pleased that this is now being done in government time, I must say that Black History Month has happened every October since 1987.
That means it is almost as old as me. And as my aunt reminded me last week, I am much older than she thought I was. There is absolutely no reason why this debate should not be a permanent fixture. And I hope the minister will take that request to the Leader of the House. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, we cannot talk about black history without talking about reparations.
And I say that because the existence of black history is reparatory in itself. And I want to pay tribute to those members in this house, in fact first black members in this house, who have made that point repeatedly. There was the honorable Bernie Grant MP, who was the first to raise a Prime Minister's question on it and the founder of the UK reparations movement. There's been our mother of the house, who has somebody who has led many meetings in parliament on this including when I worked for her. And there's Lord Paul Boateng who continues to lead the charge on restitution of artifacts and human remains in the other place.
Now, my old history teacher taught me, my old history teacher who actually passed earlier this year sadly, Mr. Melvin Smart, he said we study the past to live the present with an eye on the future. And that's just it. Reparations is not meant to be about guilt. It's meant to be about repair, looking at what we did wrong and attempting to fix it. And it's not just meant to be about money.
And that is what always happens. We talk in financial terms. We talk about paying, we talk about who gets paid and why anybody's getting paid. And we talk about all of the things that we could very easily slam down instead of talking about all the things that we could move forward with.
Now it has been a really...
Will she give way?
Yes, I'll give way.
Dawn Butler
I thank my honourable friend for giving way and for her incredible conference last week which saw thousands of people attend and the debates that we had. And one of the signs that really resonated with me as part of reparations is first stop the harm. Does my honourable friend agree with me that that is a fundamental part of reparations?
Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy
My honourable friend is absolutely right. And that idea of reparatory justice is to acknowledge that the reason why we find ourselves where we are as a people who have to have a month to even celebrate black history is because we haven't addressed the harm. We haven't gone about repairing all of the things that are wrong, including in our education system. When we talk about all of the different elements of discrimination that black people face in this country, it's because we haven't gone about repairing those institutions that lead to this. So she's absolutely right about that.
And I think that we need to make people understand that it couldn't possibly just be about money. Money is even, I think perhaps the smallest part of it, because there would be no point in giving any individual or any country a whole heap of money if you were not first going to repair the institutions and the relationships, because things wouldn't change. And that is the reality of this situation. And I think people are beginning to realise that. And that is why this year has been a huge move forward in terms of the campaign globally for reparations.
In March, the United Nations General Assembly declared the transatlantic trafficking of enslaved Africans as the gravest crime against humanity. And you know, that was 123 nations declaring that. And in Accra, governments and campaigners have gathered to decide what comes next. The Jamaican government have gave a petition to the King, which has now been referred to the Privy Council. CARICOM have revised their ten-point plan.
And ourselves here in the UK, we had our largest conference that we've ever had on reparatory justice with grassroots campaigners, scholars, parliamentarians, heads of state speaking all with one demand, understanding where a country like ours built its wealth and why that has led to the discrimination that people face in terms of the enslavement of people and asking that what we do as a country is first apologise and then seek to do what we can to repair the damage. And that can be done in a number of ways. As I said, education, what we're doing right now is a form of reparatory justice, returning artefacts as was discussed, or even just human remains. Some of you may remember I led a ten-minute rule bill earlier this year because we have found that there are numerous human remains being held in boxes or being sold on auction sites. And many of these have come from colonial times.
It is disgusting practice. And to deny people of African descent the dignity even in death points to the discrimination that they still face. Now I hear it's, I think it's so important that this movement can no longer be ignored. It can't be ignored by this government, it can't be ignored by this House. So what we need to do now as a country is think about how we are going to go about the work of repair.
Now Black History Month cannot be only, I suppose, talking about these issues or perhaps celebrating in the way that we have throughout this debate, which I think has been really important. It also has to be about honesty and about what we are still getting wrong. Now this year our community lost Professor Jason Arday, the youngest black professor in Cambridge's history, my constituent and my friend.
How he died is a matter for the coroner, and I will say nothing that gets in the way of that. But how he was treated is a matter for all of us. And it was not right that we have not been given the opportunity to discuss this. Nearly 30,000 people stood in Trafalgar Square for Jason, and vigils were held across the country. The public itself did not stay silent.
Yet when I stood at business questions a few weeks ago and had to ask this House why it had not discussed this, I was asking a question which I should never have had to ask in the first place. This House has debated other issues in relation to press conduct before. It did so for Milly Dowler, Lucy Meadows, Caroline Flack. It's done so for others, and Jason deserved no less. And I would want to put it to the government that it's still not too late for them to come to this House with a statement.
Because, Madam Deputy Speaker, we cannot stand here every October and celebrate black excellence, then look away when black excellence is torn down in front of us. And we cannot honor the names in the history books and ignore the ones that are being dragged through the newspapers today. Celebration without reflection is just performance, and we are no one's minstrel. Now, those who are good at maths will know that next year again marks the 40th anniversary of Black History Month in the UK, and plans are already underway with resources being prepared for schools and communities across the country. And I again encourage the government and the Mayor of London to be in touch with the founder of Black History Month in the UK, Akyaaba Addai-Sebo, and his team, who really want input into the conversation, the plans that we have.
Adam Jogee
I'm grateful to my honorable friend. Her and I have known each other for a very long time, and it's— I think it's the first time I've intervened on her, so that's quite something if we go back to when we first met. She's raised a really important point about engagement with the Mayor of London, with the government. Can I, through her, encourage local authorities up and down our United Kingdom to engage? There are a number of— I think of the Staffordshire Black Business Network in my own community, who would play a really important role in helping make sure that we acknowledge that 40th anniversary in as effective a way as we can.
Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy
I thank my honorable friend for his intervention, and he's absolutely right, that should be the case. And the government should be leading the charge, providing resources and helping to support them in doing so. Because as I said, those 40 years deserve a momentous celebration. So I hope when the minister responds, she'll tell us exactly how the government intends to mark it, and I hope that the celebration will be honest about the whole of our history: the pain, the resistance, and the repair. Thank you.
Frances Olivia Blake
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I say it's been a real privilege to listen to so many powerful speeches this afternoon. My friend the honorable member for Brent East reminding us to ask the question, "Have you done your part?" and telling us to never be afraid to make noise— really important points. My friend the member for Newcastle-under-Lyme reminding us that black history is correctly British history. And a really powerful speech from my friend the member for Clapham and Brixton Hill just there, reminding us of the stark reality that today we find that racism is not just whispered but amplified.
Madam Deputy Speaker, as this is my first speech in the chamber as the newly elected chair of the Women and Equalities Select Committee, I would like to start by paying tribute to my predecessor, the member for Luton North. My honorable friend is a brilliant campaigner, and in her time as chair, she shone a light on critical issues and secured significant policy change. Her work on bereavement leave for pregnancy loss in particular leaves a lasting legacy. In debates like this one, I always admired the way in which she shared stories that don't get told often enough in this place, often from her own constituency. And so when preparing for this important debate on Black History Month, I decided to spend some time looking in the Royal Berkshire Archives to tell one story from Reading's black history.
And I came across a man called Harvey De Pass. Harvey arrived on the HMT Empire Windrush in June 1948, and after a brief dalliance with Staffordshire, Harvey and his family moved to Reading.
Harvey then took up the role of Reading's first community relations officer at the Reading Council of Community Relations, and then spent years serving our community, in particular working with local schools. He organized a conference entitled Children in a Mixed Community in October 1970, and at the time he told the local paper, "Our children aren't immigrants, they know no home other than Britain." Words, Madam Deputy Speaker, that are just as poignant today. After a decade in his role, Harvey then set up a local business, De Pass Travel on the Oxford Road, and when Harvey died in 2012, he was remembered by the local community for his big heart and his love of cricket. Madam Deputy Speaker, Harvey is just one example of the wonderful Windrush generation who have brought so much to Reading, many working in iconic local businesses such as the Huntley and Palmers biscuit factory, as well as at our Royal Berkshire Hospital and on the town's bus network.
And I am reminded of their stories every day when I drive through Reading as I pass the Reading Black History Mural, which depicts global figures alongside the local heroes who built Reading's black community. And when the site faced redevelopment which threatened the mural's future, it was local community campaigners, today's Harvey De Passes, who successfully ensured the mural was preserved for future generations. Madam Deputy Speaker, as we've heard a lot today, the theme of this year's Black History Month is honoring our communities, and as others have also said, that's not just about telling stories, it is also about confronting the inequalities that black people in our country continue to face at work, in healthcare, and on the streets of our communities. And the work of the Women and Equalities Select Committee shows how much more we have to do in this regard. Our work on health shows that black women are still more than twice as likely to die in childbirth compared with white women, more likely to experience life-threatening complications, more likely to be admitted to ICU, more likely to give birth preterm and to lose a baby to stillbirth.
On homelessness, black people are almost four times more likely to experience homelessness and experience worse outcomes as they progress through the homelessness system. In the workplace, it's more difficult to progress and there are more barriers. And throughout all of our work on the committee, there is one terrible constant: wherever people are adversely affected, be that by policies, attitudes, or actions, those impacts are disproportionately worse for people who are black. And that is why I am determined as chair of the committee to use our platform to hear from black voices on the issues that matter, to make sure the government listens, and to hold the government to account on the promises it has made to the black community, whether that's ethnicity pay gap reporting, improved maternal care, or ensuring those affected by the Windrush scandal receive the support and compensation they are owed. Because commitments are only meaningful when they lead to change.
And our history is important, but honoring our communities means we must actively confront inequality to truly commemorate the contributions of those who have made progress. I look forward to building on the committee's important work and ensuring that we continue to challenge inequality wherever we find it.
Rebecca Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I've thoroughly enjoyed sitting through the debate this afternoon, having listened to just some of the debates last year, I wasn't in for the whole debate, but it's been a really enjoyable afternoon and some really powerful points have been made. And I'll just reflect on a few of those before I get into the main body of my speech if I may. I think the first thing I want to talk about is the role of pioneers that you have in the black community in Britain, and I think none more so than was mentioned the honorable member for, the right honorable member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington, who's been mentioned by so many members this afternoon, but obviously firstly by the minister, the honorable member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green.
And I was just reminded about how important pioneers have been to the House of Commons. In fact I am an MP in Plymouth and in 1919 the first female MP to take her seat was Nancy Astor and it was 68 years Madam Deputy Speaker before there was a female black MP which I think just when you put it in that context highlights the the work that the the honourable member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington has done. The member for Feltham and Heston was the first or perhaps not the first but the one who spoke about the Windrush and the role it has in our education system. And in fact it was an exhibition gosh it was probably 15 years ago at the Southbank Centre that was the first time I really engaged with the story that that was telling when I was living in London at the time and as part of the education team obviously talking about an entire British history is is incredibly important. I studied it myself and always looked particularly at that immigration history that we have here in the United Kingdom.
She also mentioned the role of black footballers today and it would be remiss of me Madam Deputy Speaker not to use that as a hook to mention the first man to be selected to play for England was actually part of the Plymouth Argyle football team. And he experienced racism in the 1920s when he wasn't actually then allowed to play. So although he was selected he wasn't played but whilst playing for Plymouth Argyle and indeed he captained them he scored 137 goals in 400 games. So I think it's good to get Jack Leslie once again on the record. And the honourable member for Erith and Thamesmead I found her contribution particularly inspiring and especially that story of resilience.
I had something similar said to me earlier on in my career that I never won people to me when I public speak. Well I hope that after my speech this afternoon people in this chamber at least will disagree with that comment but I understand the resilience that actually regardless of our race is something that most of us have had to pursue to get here and I think that's incredibly important to mention. The honourable member for Chichester Bristol Central South West Norfolk with that gentle competition that he mentioned Brent East and Ealing Southall I think the the members that have made all of these points have been particularly important. And indeed the Ealing the member for Ealing Southall mentioned the role of stolen labourers and that's something that I won't touch on directly in my speech but is a theme of commemoration that we need to ensure we do going forward the people that fought for this country who haven't always been remembered because of the role that they played. And the member for Newcastle-under-Lyme with his particularly powerful speech that prompted me to remember two midwives that I know well in Plymouth who are of Caribbean heritage who came over here and served the city of Plymouth for many decades delivering many babies and it's a real privilege to be able to mention Liz and Yvonne today.
Right across our country we have these people who have served who have those stories of coming from far-flung parts of the country and making the United Kingdom their home. And then finally the members from Clapham and Brixton Hill and Reading West and Mid Berkshire it's been a pleasure to hear all of your contributions this afternoon. But Madam Deputy Speaker it is a privilege to respond to this interesting and inspiring debate on behalf of the official opposition. We've heard many times this afternoon how the theme of Black History Month 2026 is honouring our communities sharing inspiring stories of black British life. And I believe there's no better way to do this than by reflecting on the lives of those men and women from the Commonwealth who served during the First and Second World War.
And anybody who knows anything about me right back to my maiden speech will know that I had the privilege of working for the Commonwealth War Graves Commission before I was elected and indeed as a declaration of interest am the chair of the APPG. So forgive me for using that as what I'm going to talk about but I think it's an incredibly important story that we should be telling.
As I'm sure you know, the allied forces were comprised of many nations, but importantly a significant number of what are now Commonwealth countries. The Imperial forces as they were known saw personnel serving together from India, South Africa, Canada, New Zealand, Australia and the United Kingdom. And in addition serving under those six flags were men and women from the West Indies and other African nations such as Rhodesia, Nigeria and Kenya. And indeed we've heard again from the honourable member of Newcastle-under-Lyme whose grandfather would have been one of those men who came from Rhodesia to serve. Jamaica, sorry, but also has Rhodesia, sorry.
I was listening, I just... More than 700,000 black Africans served in the First World War with tens of thousands more coming from the Caribbean and a further half a million black and mixed ethnicity individuals served in the Second World War. And many of these are commemorated in places like Plymouth's Naval Memorial on Plymouth Hoe. You can find tales of black and mixed ethnicity service men and women in many theatres worldwide, from frontline First World War combat in East Africa and the Middle East, labour and support units working worldwide, to action in Burma during the Second World War, to the Merchant Navy and soaring in the skies with the Royal Air Force. It is quite a story.
And it is the role of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission to commemorate each man and woman who lost their life serving in the Commonwealth forces with no distinctions. Each casualty should be commemorated by name on a headstone or memorial. Each casualty should have a single point of commemoration. Headstones and memorials should be permanent. And importantly, Madam Deputy Speaker, headstones should be uniform so it doesn't matter where somebody was from, you can't tell by looking at the shape of their headstone, you have to actually go and read their story.
And there should be equality of treatment for war dead irrespective of rank or religion. And this means that right across the world, in 153 countries in fact, war dead are commemorated. I wanted to use my brief time this afternoon to highlight some of the black Britons who are included within the British forces in the First and Second World War. Now there are many stories of the contributions of black Britons who served so faithfully during both World Wars. And the examples I wish to share can be found on a new online portal that the Commonwealth War Graves Commission host, where families and historians can share the stories of those recorded on war graves and memorials across the world.
It's called the For Evermore project and I would encourage anybody who has a story or wants to advertise that in their constituency to do so because ultimately by knowing more about the names we have a much bigger picture about the cost of what was involved in those two wars. And I'm grateful for those stories and I have effectively lifted many of them, well not many you'll be pleased to hear, sorry, three of them, from that portal this afternoon. So Second Lieutenant Walter Daniel John Tull was one of the British Army's first black commissioned officers and one of England's first black professional footballers. Born in 1888 in Folkestone, Walter was orphaned young and was brought up in an orphanage in Bethnal Green. Before the war he played for Tottenham Hotspur and later Northampton Town where he remains a club legend.
Shortly after the outbreak of the First World War, Walter joined the Footballers' Battalion of the Middlesex Regiment and fought in the Battle of the Somme in 1916. He was a natural leader and in May 1917 was commissioned as an officer, a remarkable achievement given the prejudices of the time. He was mentioned in despatches for gallantry and coolness while leading his company of 26 men on a raiding party into enemy territory. He returned to France in 1918 and was killed in action on the 25th of March whilst leading his men into battle during the German spring offensive. He is commemorated on the Arras Memorial to the Missing.
He was a true pioneer whose military service challenged the racial barriers of his age. Lance Corporal Horace Wilfred Miller from the Leicestershire Regiment was born in Hinckley, Leicester as the eldest of 10 children. His father hailed from Saint Helena, a British overseas territory off the coast of South West Africa. Aged 19, Horace joined the army in January 1913, enlisting with the Shepshed company of the 5th Battalion Leicestershire Regiment. He was sent to France a year later and was known for being a keen musician and singer.
Horace was killed on the 10th of September 1915 by a German sniper in the Ypres Salient. Newspaper reports noticed that Miller was a fine man, greatly loved and admired by all of his many pals. Finally, Victor Emmanuel Tucker was born on the 22nd of December 1916 in Jamaica to parents Adrian and Lydia Tucker. Victor emigrated to England in the 1930s with the Oxford-educated Jamaican qualifying as a barrister. In 1940, he was living in Highgate, London, with his wife Wilhelmina.
He enlisted in the RAF in August 1940 and earned his pilot wings in early 1941. He was also promoted to sergeant at this point. His Spitfire was painted with a yellow island of Jamaica symbol on the nose, representing Victor's homeland. Sadly, Victor would not survive the war. He was shot down by a Messerschmitt FW 109S on a raid over Le Havre in France.
The Spitfires were escorting Boston bombers to Le Havre and turned away before the bombing run. By order, they flew a left turn, to which the pilots had protested, as this enabled the Germans to flank and attack from the sun, to attack, sorry, from the sun. Victor was one of the RAF pilots shot down in this encounter. His body was never recovered, and as he has no known grave, he's commemorated on the Runnymede Air Services Memorial in Surrey, England. And I will happily give way.
Adam Jogee
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm grateful to the shadow minister who's making a very thoughtful and appropriate speech, and I thank her for it. And can I just thank her specifically for mentioning Victor's story? Because it's one that gives voice to many of the points that we raise on this side of the House and that some on the other side of the House could learn from.
Rebecca Smith
Well, I thank the honourable member for his intervention, and I hope that all of the stories I have shared, that actually those men who I've just named, and indeed women will have played a role too, but often in the early days it was, it was more men, did that in spite of where they came from and in spite of their race and their background. And we are incredibly grateful, and that is why the Commonwealth War Graves Commission exists to be able to highlight their contribution. And so, Madam Deputy Speaker, what I've done this afternoon is sought to highlight not just Commonwealth people, but actually those who fought under the United Kingdom's flag. They were Black British men who served and who tragically lost their lives. Now, many survived, and no doubt they are the predecessor, the family members of many members in this House, but ultimately those men did sadly pay the ultimate price.
So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, these stories remind us that Black history forms a part of our shared national story. These people came from different places, yet they shared the same values of duty, courage, and service. They fought under the same flag, faced the same dangers, and made the same ultimate sacrifice. That is why the Leader of the Opposition, the right honourable, my right honourable friend, was right to state during her tenure as equalities minister that the achievements of Black Britons belong to us all, whatever our skin colour. Black History Month at its best is at its best when it reminds us of what unites us: a shared inheritance and a shared commitment to the country we all call home.
Speaker 205
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's an honour to be able to close today's debate. I would like to thank my honourable friend, the Minister for Communities and Faith, for opening the debate and everything she has done in her personal capacity and her time here for championing our diverse communities. And everyone here from across the chamber for their heartfelt, powerful, and thought-provoking contributions. It is rare for this chamber to come together in this way, and I'm pleased it's over an issue as important as this one.
I know Black History Month can at times be viewed as tokenistic, but only if we allow it to. And I agree we should mark the 40th anniversary, and it should be a regular item in government business. As we heard from the contributions this afternoon from members that represent communities from across our country, Black History Month is an incredible opportunity to honor our diverse communities, pay tribute to the huge contribution they make to our cities, towns, and neighborhoods, and celebrate the success stories that inspire people like me every single day. Stories too often left untold. This month's theme is on honoring our communities, and I would like to thank members for doing just that.
We pay tribute to trailblazers like Dr. Alan Minns, the first black mayor in the UK, first elected over 100 years ago in rural Norfolk, and I thank the member for South West Norfolk for telling us his story. Like Paul Boateng, the UK's first black minister, our first black Sergeant at Arms, Councillor Ffion Mymed, Mayor of Ealing, Lord Rees from Bristol, Yasmine Mohammed, who's the now Mayor of Bristol, now Lord Mayor of Bristol, to the member for Hackney North, who has been mentioned several times throughout this debate as the first black woman elected in Parliament. I remember sitting next to her when she became Mother of the House and feeling incredibly emotional. We pay tribute to John Oke-Mbaye, who the member for Erith and Thamesmead spoke passionately about, and others that have contributed within her constituency. And as there's an ongoing loving for this member, I just want to share and add to it.
There is a real sisterhood in this building and in Parliament, and I have felt it so strongly with my honorable friend, and I wanted to thank her for her friendship, her support, and encouragement. And I feel as though the resilience she oozes is slowly seeping into my veins, so I thank her personally for that. We pay tribute to Eric Huntley and others spoken passionately about from the member of Ealing and Southall, Harvey DePass from Reading, from the member of Mid Berkshire, to the member of Brent East for being the first female black minister in this country. Thank you very much, I got that right, yes, I remembered. And everything she has personally done to champion this cause.
I pay tribute to government's Race Equality Engagement Group members, who as we speak are all in Liverpool with the Minister for Women and Equalities discussing how we go further in making change more meaningful, and thank Baroness Doreen Lawrence for generally being an inspiration to us all, but also for chairing and bringing this group together.
Speaker 206
I'm very grateful to her for giving way. I just wondered if I could add to that illustrious list the case of Andrew Watson, who was the first black international football player when he captained Scotland to a 6-1 victory over England in the late 19th century.
Speaker 205
We do pay, I particularly pay tribute to Andrew Watson and congratulate him.
I want to add my thanks, um, to the member for Feltham and Heston for her tireless work as the former Minister for Equalities and her personal support that she has given me in my new role. To the likes of my great-granddad, Sundar Singh Sagoo, Giani Sundar Singh Sagoo, who worked closely with local black leaders 50 years ago to help change the law so that bus drivers and those riding motorbikes can do so by wearing their turbans and not compromising their faith. In fact, their family home is now owned by a Jamaican family whose dad was a Rasta and only got a job as a bus conductor wearing his locks and hat because of my great-granddad's campaign. In my home city of Southampton, where our diversity is celebrated and gave me growing up a sense of belonging, I pay tribute to the likes of Don John, Gianti Shah, Sukhi Sitaram, Lou Taylor for their tireless work in race equality. I thank the member for Newcastle-under-Lyme and the Shadow Minister for mentioning our Commonwealth soldiers who too often get forgotten when we talk about the contribution made in our world wars that helped beat fascism, that stood by us throughout it all.
We celebrate the likes of Esseline McFarlane, who I met in Bath, a retired midwife who told me she has delivered thousands of babies and was instrumental in setting up a place for ethnic minorities to meet and get support in her neighbourhood. She is...
Adam Jogee
Of course. I'm grateful, Madam Speaker, to the Minister for giving way. And on the point of meetings, a second ago the Minister described my constituency as Newcastle-upon-Tyne. We are under-Lyme. So to make up for it, will she come and meet the Staffordshire Black Business Network, who I feel sure would like to see her?
Speaker 205
Any excuse to meet Newcastle, um, and the good people within it, and I will not make that mistake again. Thank you for calling me out on it. In a nice way. Um, for in Bath when I met, um, amazing people from Fairfield House who bring together older generations, celebrate cultures through heritage, art and storytelling. They also make the most amazing food, which I felt compelled to try.
We celebrate the fact that over 98% of FTSE 100 companies now have ethnic minority representation on their boards, acknowledging that diversity at decision-making tables is not only the right thing to do, but also good for business, improving productivity and growth. We celebrate Croydon's BME Forum for all they do, and I thank my honourable friend for talking passionately about them earlier. We thank those that have taken up the mantle for race equality, accepting it cannot fall on black communities alone, reflected in members' contributions in this debate today, including the Lib Dem spokesperson in her important experience in her own constituent. But also the likes of Salisbury Museum, who gave local black communities the opportunity to own and narrate their own history in their own words on slavery. Madam Deputy Speaker, Black History Month also, however, gives us an opportunity to not only reflect on the huge strides made towards race equality, but acknowledge that fight is still not over.
As we have heard today, it is important to highlight where we are falling short, where we must go further, where we accept that we stand on the shoulders of giants, and now our generation owe it to the next generation to pick up the mantle, to deal with the issues we thought were far left behind us, and to take on the next set of challenges and continue that fight for equality.
Growing up in Southampton's inner city as the daughter of a market stall trader, my dad taught me to be a grafter like him, to work harder and to go that extra mile to get the same opportunities as others because the colour of our skin will hold us back. One of the reasons I'm in politics is to ensure I can teach my baby girl Emmy and children of colour everywhere that because of the changes our generation made, when you work harder you go further because talent, ability and access to opportunities are everywhere in every community and the colour of your skin has nothing to do with it. It's why this government intends to introduce the ethnicity and disability pay gap reporting, not as an end in itself but as a means to an end towards a fairer chance to get on in life for everyone. My honourable friend asked for an update and I'm pleased to report that we are moving at pace and keen to get in parliamentary time as soon as possible. I pay tribute to the likes of Change the Race Ratio and others who have campaigned on this issue for a number of years and I saw first hand the important work they do earlier this month.
In health, the Amos review shone a light on the shameful disparities faced by ethnic minority women when it comes to maternity care, a service that many of us know too well needs to show up for you whoever you are. I'm pleased that in response, as well as announcing the creation of the UK's first ever maternity and neonatal commissioner to hold the system to account, this government has also committed to the national rollout of the parental equity and anti-discrimination programme. This will tackle unacceptable inequalities in care and outcomes, particularly for black and Asian women, those from deprived backgrounds and other marginalised groups. Hate crime and racism was sadly a common theme in this debate, Madam Deputy Speaker. I pay tribute to organisations across the country but particularly, and I wanted to mention them because I visited them recently, Stand Against Racism and Inequality, an amazing Bristol charity that do the most inspiring work supporting victims of racial abuse but also go into schools and give children a sense of belonging.
The truth is, Madam Deputy Speaker, there are forces out there that seek to divide us and pit one community against another when in reality when we rise we do so together. There are forces out there that will tell you you are only English if your skin is a certain colour or you're from a certain race. Well I'm here to tell you they are wrong. They were wrong in the thirties, they were wrong in the sixties and they are wrong now. They will never succeed in dividing this great country, not then, not now because our diversity is a strength.
It has made us who we are today: resourceful, skilled, vibrant, talented, innovative, cultural and so much more. At a time when members of our communities are feeling vulnerable and under attack, my message is clear. You belong here.
Your heritage, your history, your culture is our heritage, history and culture, and it makes us proud to be British. We know the scale of the challenge before us is huge. That is why we must meet it with the same level of ambition to tackle it. Now is the time to be bold, be brave, be courageous, to re-own the narrative. This will only be achieved by how race equality was hard-fought for by those that came before us, by working together through steel determination and telling the world we are the great country we are because of our diversity rather than in spite of it.
Together we can and we will. Thank you again for everyone's contribution and I commend this debate to the House.
Speaker 194
The question is that this House has considered Black History Month. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
Ian Roome
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Monday, the senior management of Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust meets again to make an important decision: whether enough consultants can be found to reopen maternity services at North Devon District Hospital. North Devon's desperate maternity staffing crisis is now entering its 10th week, with all the births still being diverted two hours to Exeter and hundreds of families in my constituency deserving answers. NHS maternity services across the country face massive pressure, but the timeline of these last 10 weeks makes for sorry reading. On 27th of July, the trust announced it was about to fall below its minimum staffing levels of obs and gynae consultants needed to keep the Ladywell maternity unit open.
From the 11th of August, all births were suspended and the trust began sending expectant mothers to the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital until further notice. What follows has been agonizing. The fear and anger of frightened local moms has played out on regional and then national media. The outcry from the public has been furious. Hundreds gathered in Barnstaple town square for the first of several Maternity Matters protests.
More than 15,000 people signed my petition to get the unit reopened, and our TV and radio appeals have been answered by doctors as far away as Australia. I have written to more than 50 maternity authorities, NHS public bodies, charities and women's health organizations to ask for help in recruiting new consultants and in holding the trust to account for its decisions. The suspension was extended again on the 14th of September with seemingly no end in sight. Even as new doctors were found, I was on the phone to local landlords desperately trying to find those doctors somewhere to live in North Devon and getting the Home Office to urgently extend work visas. The tier 2 registrars' rota has now been filled with two new permanent doctors.
A new consultant locum started last week, with one candidate in discussions to fill the final vacant post. Even if that is achieved, we are not out of the woods yet. Back in April '22, when North Devon was merged into a wider trust, this was partly justified as making both trusts more resilient.
Staff could be shared between North Devon, East Devon and Exeter to deliver extra resilience in a crisis. Yet three years down the line, we discover that the consultant rotas in Barnstaple and Exeter are not even interchangeable and our maternity unit is still dangerously fragile. North Devon District Hospital is the most remotest acute hospital in mainland England, serving hundreds of square miles of North Devon, Torridge and North Cornwall. My constituents and I are left wondering if senior figures in Whitehall, in NHS England and even our own hospital trust actually understand the basic reality of the geography we are talking about.
Speaker 210
I congratulate the honourable gentleman on securing this debate and also for his indefatigable efforts on behalf of Barnstaple Hospital. As he knows, although it's in his constituency, it also serves thousands of people in Torridge, which I have the honour to represent. Does he agree with me that what the minister needs to answer today is what the government is going to do to ensure that isolated rural maternity services are resilient and can withstand the departure of a single consultant and prevent the cessation for hundreds of mothers to make the trek, in this case 60 miles as he knows very well, to Exeter to give birth? We need to have a policy that looks closely at how isolated rural maternity units can have built-in resilience and trusts must have a duty to ensure it.
Ian Roome
Thank you. I agree with the honourable member and I thank you for those comments and hopefully the minister's made notes of those comments, so thank you. So it's 53 mile drive from North Devon District Hospital to the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital. We are talking about a catchment area larger than Greater Manchester without an open maternity unit.
Anna Sabine
Sorry to jump in so quickly, but it's on this point about rurality. I was really alarmed to hear earlier in the week NHS chiefs talking about the fact that in order to consolidate services they may have to cut rural and coastal maternity services further. In Frome and East Somerset I have mothers who routinely travelling over an hour to access maternity services. I know they're not the distances that you and other colleagues are talking about, but I still think that we should not have efficiency of maternity services coming at the cost of women living in rural areas simply being able to access maternity care in a safe and accessible and timely way. I wondered if you'd agree with me.
Ian Roome
I do agree with my honourable friend and thank you for making that point. That's precisely what I'm talking about with rurality and remote services that many people face. So many of my constituents would not reach the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital inside two hours. If a hospital shuts down in London, neighbouring units can absorb some extra workload without a dramatically heightened risk to mother or baby. In this case, no neighbouring hospital exists.
Most of the road route is not even a dual carriageway. In terms of journey time, this is like announcing you cannot deliver a baby in London and diverting mothers going into labour to Bristol. Little wonder then that what would be parents across Northern Devon and Cornwall are terrified at the extra pressure of getting to Exeter. I have recently been able to get the trust to agree to move some of the triage back to Barnstaple for women over 37 weeks with suspected broken waters, but many of those are warned to travel early to Exeter, have ended up being sent back to North Devon again in round trips taking many hours. Officially the trust figures record no incidents and fewer than five births before arrival over the past nine weeks.
I hope the minister can tell me the NHS official view because I would ask whether it is credible to claim that a baby born in an ambulance or non-medical area of a hospital should not qualify as an incident.
The Daily Mirror has reported that two babies have been born in the back of ambulances, two in accident and emergency, and one in a hospital reception, something I have not been able to verify. The trust is clear that they review every one of these births before arrival carefully and cannot give a more exact breakdown without breaching patient confidentiality. However, they also insist that there is a difference between the NHS definition and a patient's definition of experiencing an event-free birth. I am a father, I am a grandfather, who remembers those tense few hours well, and I understand why trust senior management feel the need to be dispassionate about a baby arriving early. But when expectant mothers are travelling so far by ambulance, this kind of statement surely stretches the credibility of NHS guidance to the breaking point.
I will give way.
John Richard Foord
I'm grateful, and I like the analogy that he made about patients, indeed pregnant women, having to travel between London and Bristol to give birth. And it's not just that they're having to travel that distance, it's also what they find when they get there. I had a constituent write to me earlier this week from Ottery St Mary to explain that the Exeter labour ward has only ten rooms plus two birthing centre rooms. Does he agree that it's not only just a question of distance travelled, it's also the experience of the queues that they are having to encounter when they get there?
Ian Roome
I thank the honourable member for his intervention, and I totally agree with you that it is a problem. It's extending and forcing problems onto neighbouring maternity units that is an issue as well. So I do know and appreciate that Exeter now is under pressure because they're having to cope with the births coming from North Devon. I appreciate the government's maternity advisor meeting with me last week, and she speaks very passionately about fixing the crisis in our maternity units across the country. When the new Prime Minister addressed this question to this House, he was upfront that North Devon is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to structural weaknesses in NHS maternity services.
But things have clearly come to a head in the South West. First, Yeovil maternity unit suffered a staffing crisis and closure last year, and now Barnstaple has suffered the same. In Yeovil's case, a full reopening took almost a year. I am told privately by senior figures that there are other NHS trusts around the country that are also perilously close to something similar. Just like North Devon, their maternity units hang in the balance.
The National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce new action plan is due in December, and I want the government to treat this sorry episode as a case in point. Firstly, maternity units should not be suddenly suspended out of the blue. Our trust wrote their own continuity plan for our maternity services, set their own staffing benchmark below which closure would be needed, and decided their own reopening criteria. If the unit at North Devon District Hospital can reopen with a fully staffed doctors' rota, then we are at least protected against this happening again in a few weeks' time. But without national guidance on when suspension should happen, we are running this unit with an operational cliff edge of the trust's own design.
We know that the trust was struggling with maternity recruitment since at least December last year, which continued right through to the spring. It is no wonder my constituents are angry. It seems impossible that no emergency alarm was ringing months ahead of this crisis reaching boiling point. Why does it take a sudden suspension and a national media backlash driven by myself and local maternity matters campaigners to get this to the very top of the chief executive's to-do list?
Secondly, the government's workforce plan is already overdue and this needs to give a special focus to maternity services in at-risk areas. For example, I am told that when the deanery decide placements for trainee consultants, especially in their final years, the trend is towards large urban centers to offer them more specialized teaching. The unintended consequence is that many of those candidates stay in whichever area they are last trained in and already know well. That boosts the ability of urban hospitals to recruit, even while hospitals in remote areas like North Devon are crying out for doctors. So can I ask the government work with deaneries to ensure that trainee consultants are able to do their final years in rural and coastal acute hospitals.
This I believe would help tackle the maternity workforce crisis in smaller maternity units. On 2nd of October North Devon District Hospital's consultant body passed a vote of no confidence in the trust senior management. When senior NHS staff with years of experience and dedicated service say something is wrong, that should be a wake-up call. I am shocked to learn that senior figures in the trust have not even taken the opportunity to win hearts and minds by being present on site at North Devon District Hospital during the crisis. Such things are completely symbolic and that is entirely the point.
Thirdly, my constituents are owed a full independent review into how this crisis came about. We need the official record to show what led to the suspension in North Devon, what happened, how it might have been averted, and how we make sure it never happens again. The trust have appointed Audit South West to conduct this review, yet a letter I received from the trust chair of the board on the 12th of October implies that the terms of reference for the review are being set by a subcommittee of the trust board's board of directors. If this is true, I would ask the minister if the Department of Health has an official standard for an impartiality of reviews like this. Many of my constituents will suspect the telltale signs of a whitewash in the making, something that doesn't improve health outcomes for anyone and I hope we can count on the government support.
Fourth, what accountability exists for strategic failings in the NHS. A well-established structured structure exists to pursue clinical negligence and medical malpractice, but how can the NHS stamp out corporate failings, bad decision-making or simply a lack of attention given by senior managers. I have asked this question of many organizations already, but I am yet to get a clear answer. If this crisis has been even worse, as it might be at someone else's local hospital next month, what recourse would the public have. I was utterly shocked this week to read that the NHS Alliance lead director for acute care had told the Guardian that as many as 20 NHS maternity units across the country may be forced to close entirely.
In remoter parts of the country, this would be unthinkable. When services are centralized again and again, it is always remote communities like mine that pay the price. There are many more questions my constituents in North Devon need answering, but above all, how can it be that senior NHS figures feel less publicly accountable for suspending maternity services entirely than they do for staffing an open maternity unit. To answer that, I am forced to turn to the ultimate policymakers in government.
Madam Deputy Speaker, short of defending this country from attack, I can see I cannot see any greater duty of the British state than ensuring the next generation can be born safely. Most people would struggle to think of any NHS spending that should take priority over this sacred responsibility. So I would finally ask the minister, does she understand that in remote rural and coastal communities like mine in North Devon, who have suffered this nightmare for the past nine weeks, losing maternity services would be seen as the beginning of the end for the National Health Service itself. Thank you.
Wendy Chamberlain
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm very grateful to both the minister and my honourable friend, the member for North Devon, for allowing me the opportunity to contribute to this debate, and I'm very glad that we've got a little bit of time in order to do so. I have to admit that I have taken the NHS maternity services title of this debate a little broadly, but I do represent a rural constituency myself in Scotland, and I recognise many of the things that the honourable member has referred to in his speech, and indeed the contributions of other honourable and right honourable members. And indeed, I want to say to the honourable member for North Devon, he has demonstrated not only a real understanding of the acute needs in his constituency, but a broader understanding of the challenges that maternity services face, and that is, I think, the reason why it is replicated in many parts of the UK, and including in Scotland. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the UK, a baby is born roughly every 50 seconds, and given that, we might expect maternity services to be among the best resourced and best supported parts of our NHS. But we know, and we've heard this afternoon, that this is not the reality.
In Scotland, nine in 10 midwives report chronic staff shortages, and nearly three quarters of maternity units are not staffed at levels considered safe. And in rural areas, such as my own in North East Fife, these pressures can be even more acute. Despite the extraordinary dedication of our midwives, nurses, and support staff, an overstretched system too often leaves women and families without the care and support they deserve. And in the limited time I have, I do want to share just briefly the story of two of my constituents. The first, Christie Haldane, who has shown immense courage in speaking publicly about her experiences so that others do not have to suffer in silence.
She experienced both an incomplete abortion and a traumatic miscarriage, and on both occasions she received treatment that, for a variety of reasons, fell far below the standard anyone should expect. And I think it's important that we remember that it is not just that experience itself, but the impact of it has had on people's mental health, and indeed has done so for Christie. It has impacted her employment and her confidence. Following her experiences, she lost her job, she's experienced homelessness, and she has continued to struggle to access the support she desperately required. What struck me was not only the grief that she's endured, but the loneliness and isolation that accompanied it.
Because after her miscarriage, she was discharged by hospital and feels that she received little support for either herself, her partner, or her wider family. At the moment when compassion and care were needed most, she felt abandoned by our system. And I do want to take this moment just to pay tribute to the patient experience team at NHS Fife. It's something we all do as constituency MPs, is support constituents when they are making complaints. And I do think the reconciliation process that Christie has went through with my and my team's support has helped in some ways to understand what happened, but also ensure that we learn lessons.
And I just on my second point, and on my second constituent, we do talk about maternity care in the context of pregnancy and birth, but we know that there are key challenges in reproductive health more broadly.
And I do have another constituent whose experience highlights the importance of informed patient safety. Tammy Payne was prescribed the contraceptive injection Depo-Provera more than a decade ago, but was not warned about the potential increased risk of developing meningiomas, a type of brain tumour. After experiencing persistent double vision, she was diagnosed with multiple meningiomas and she subsequently underwent surgery to relieve pressure on her optic nerve. When one of the tumours returned, she required a craniotomy, a major operation involving the temporary removal of part of the skull to access the brain. She has been left without the use of one eye, but she feels betrayed by a system that was supposed to inform, protect and support her.
I want to place on record my admiration for both Christie and Tammy, because it takes enormous courage to relive these deeply traumatic experiences in public. And I do hope the Minister will engage with me, particularly on Tammy's case, to discuss Depo-Provera and the risks of that more widely. But the truth is that neither of those women should have gone through what they did. And that's one of the reasons why my party has long called for an independent maternity commissioner for England, and we do welcome the Government's commitment to establish one. In Scotland, the SNP Government has finally, following constant campaigning from the Caithness Health Action Team, the honourable member, my friend, the member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross, and the new MSP for Caithness, David Green, long-term campaigning for better maternity services in the far north of Scotland.
And we do welcome Professor McCourt's independent review with a focus on the far north that will be looking at maternity services in Scotland. And that will take account of the unannounced inspections of all of the 18 Scottish acute maternity units that are currently being carried out. That is really important, but I think, Madam Deputy Speaker, it does demonstrate that we have much, much more to do across the UK in terms of providing reproductive health support and maternity support. Women deserve better, families deserve better, and our maternity services deserve the resources that they need to deliver that better care. Thank you.
Minister.
Karin Smyth
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank the honourable gentleman for raising this as a very important matter, and he's calling attention not just to his own constituency, but as we've heard from others, to a broader issue that we do face in our rural, particularly in our rural and coastal communities. And I want to be very clear that the Government is clear that all women have the right to receive the same high-quality, safe and compassionate care wherever they have their babies. And we need to ensure, and mums need to know, that the services are there for them when they need them, including at the time they go into labour. And I'd like to agree with the honourable member for Lowestoft, we need to bear those experiences in mind, and I thank her for sharing Christie and her constituent Christie and Tammy's experiences here today.
And that is also why my right honourable friend the Secretary of State has chosen to prioritise maternity and why the work of the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce is so important. And in particular, the new modern service framework will define the standards needed to deliver care across the country, whether large inner city or small and rural places. Now, I know the honourable gentleman understands that the North Devon maternity unit was closed for a good reason, because the trust could not provide a service they knew to be unsafe. And I think it's really important that we all bear that in mind as we discuss this issue. We must support good, sound clinical assessment, particularly in this area.
But it is also unacceptable that expectant mothers are travelling all the way to Exeter or, as we have heard from the honourable member for Torrington and Honiton and Sidmouth, that to Exeter and to Bristol, that the current situation is not sustainable. I have given birth three times very healthily, I'm very grateful to the care that I had.
I only had to travel very short distance down the road and frankly that was enough. So I do empathise deeply with the women who have to endure those long journeys. Now I won't rehearse the recent history that led us up to this point because I know that the honourable member and indeed the House is well acquainted with that. And the responsible minister as you know is the noble Baroness Merron. And I will do everything though I can at this opportunity to update him and the House on where we are and follow up in writing to any specific questions if necessary.
So Madam Deputy Speaker, the trust have set the following three tests before the unit can reopen. Firstly there must be 24/7 consultant and registrar cover in place through an on-call rota. Secondly that three quarters of these staff must be employed full time. And thirdly that new staff must have gone through employment checks, onboarding and induction. And today I can update the House that last week the outlook on safe staffing was more positive but unfortunately since then some recruitment has fallen through.
And so the trust is still seeking additional clinical staff which they must have to provide a safe service. Now if I can just get these points. Madam Deputy Speaker, as the honourable member knows the issue is not that these roles are not funded. They are generously funded but I think the trust has even gone so far as to offer salary top-ups but the roles remain unfilled. So the question is how do we attract the best talent to our rural and coastal communities and show them that Barnstaple and other similar places, I should say for members present, is one of the best places in the country to build a life.
I want to thank the partners who are working with the trust on recruitment including the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. And the trust is also exploring international candidates. But ultimately we want to move to a place where the unit has enough staff to provide a safe service and that is sustainable, another point that's been well made today. So every week the chief medical officer at the trust conducts an assessment to see whether the unit is ready to reopen its doors. And every two weeks the trust updates key stakeholders on the status of the unit.
And once safe staffing is secured there will be a short period of time to stand up rotas and put services in place. And I have had assurances that during that period the trust will get in touch with every mother and give them the chance to change their birth plans to Barnstaple should they want to. Madam Deputy, I will very briefly.
John Richard Foord
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. And I accept that this is a point about recruitment but it is also a point about retention. My constituent who visited the maternity ward at Exeter heard that staff who are temporarily redeployed from Barnstaple to Exeter hospital are having to pay the full car parking charge of 20 pounds per day while they're doing the additional service of travelling to Exeter. Does she think that retention also needs to be looked at?
Karin Smyth
Yes of course. And that's what the trust do. And I would gently urge all honourable gentlemen to work very closely with the entire trust around some of these issues to solve some of these problems. If I can just say Madam Deputy Speaker, it is right that the trust is working with local MPs. That's absolutely right.
They are reviewing their decision on a weekly basis. And it's important that they communicate openly and transparently with all their partners when those decisions happen. And I'm always very clear that members of Parliament here speak on behalf of their constituents and can be helpful in communicating those messages because we want to make this work. In the meantime the trust continues to offer a range of maternity services and they have taken steps to help the women in their duty of care. There is a dedicated helpline for women to discuss their birth plans, a maternity triage line for urgent help, special appointments to talk over travel costs and accommodation, free taxis for women who do not have their own transport and are advised via the triage line to go to hospital and mental health support.
And these are good and sensible steps but it is still unacceptable for women to have to travel for two hours while they are in labour.
So Madam Deputy Speaker, trusts in our rural and coastal communities do face systemic pressures because they have fewer births and because it can be hard for the local NHS to recruit. Last year, I did visit North Devon District Hospital as part of my remit overlooking the New Hospitals Programme to see how they are also using the 30 million pound the government has made available to support the rebuild of the 50-year-old staff accommodation block and invest in MRI scanners. We are committed to those services in Barnstaple, and I think it's important for all honorable members' constituents to be clear. Our 10-year health plan produced last year set out very clearly for the honorable member, right honorable member for Torridge and Tavistock noted, that you know, rural and coastal communities, we particularly highlighted that in that 10-year health plan because we recognize that they have specific needs and do not benefit from a one-size-fits-all approach. But the broader systemic issues they face, particularly in staffing, must be addressed in our upcoming workforce plan, and I do agree that retention is a key part of that.
Madam Deputy Speaker, ministers have been clear to the NHS that we must do everything possible to help reopen North Devon maternity services. NHS England, the ICB, and the regional team in the South West are working with the trust to resolve these issues as soon as possible. And as I have said, my right honorable friend the Secretary of State has rightly made maternity a national priority for this government. She is chairing the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce to drive forward reforms and deliver systemic and sustained improvement across maternity and neonatal care, including in relation to the kinds of failings that we have seen exposed in the South West of England in recent months. The Barnstaple maternity unit will reopen.
I can't give him a guarantee from this dispatch box what the date when that will happen. It will depend on securing safe staffing. That's the problem everybody needs to focus on, and this government is focused on doing that with the local system. And we will do everything we can to help the honorable and gallant gentleman get those services back on track on behalf of his constituents.
Speaker 194
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Aye. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Order, order.