House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittingsShabana Mahmood
If they have concerns and wish to see things changed, let's have that conversation.
Nick Timothy.
Nick Timothy
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I asked the Justice Secretary to rule out reducing access to jury trials and the House will have noticed that he didn't do that. We're not talking about something insignificant. We're talking about an ancient English right, something dating back to Magna Carta. Just like with Labour's early release disaster, the new Prime Minister told everybody he didn't like it, wouldn't do it, but never got round to working out what to do instead.
The Justice Secretary once again has made much of his desire to work together constructively, although I have to say I haven't seen much of it yet in our correspondence. So will he publish, what will he publish the full details of the new plan now or does he still not know what it is?
Shabana Mahmood
This is interesting, Mr. Speaker, because the opposition don't know how to deal with either the new Prime Minister or indeed the new government, because when we talk about wanting to improve things in the collective interest of the country, we mean it. Instead, he wants to, he rather offers to be my correspondence secretary. I don't think that's quite the answer to this. I say, very good. Sorry.
Speaker 2
But it's quite serious, and I'm getting a little bit fed up of this continuation of the dispatch box. Ask a question, at least respect the answer, because I expect them when you put the question to listen to it. So I expect it both ways, please. This is becoming a habit and I don't want it to continue.
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I reiterate my commitment to him and to the House. If people have interest in this legislation or want to discuss it, our door is open.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Lord Chancellor mentioned working with experts in his previous answer. Amnesty International has recently questioned the government's own human rights assessment of the Courts and Tribunals Bill, describing the proposals as a dilution of the quality of justice, particularly in relation to efforts to combat racial discrimination. Mr. Speaker, these issues were raised at earlier stages of the bill, but the government batted away those concerns. The time is now right to change course prior to the return of the bill in October.
So can the Secretary of State confirm that these concerns are being heard by the Prime Minister while he considers the future of the bill? And can he guarantee honorable members across this House and experts in the sector will have adequate time to scrutinize the government's amendments before we're asked to debate it on the second day back after recess?
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I mean, I would assure the honorable lady that we of course will consider all evidence submitted by whoever it is, certainly by those experts that I talked about in my, in my opening answer. I wouldn't say that I'm afraid we could quite accept that characterization as set out in those terms. But what I will say is that, you know, we will look at these things very closely. We will have that interaction through ordinary parliamentary processes and beyond, because I think we have a shared interest in this.
You know, I would caution the House about defending a status quo where we all know, because it's in our constituency mailbags, Mr. Speaker, where our constituents are waiting now for trials against 2029, will soon be 2030. That that isn't justice either, and that it behooves us, yes, to make very important, as my honorable friend has, very, very important changes to the system to help immediate capacity challenges, but that we look at longer-term structural changes too. And as I say, I look forward to working with colleagues on that.
Heidi Alexander
Mr. Speaker, we inherited a criminal justice system in crisis, with challenges in prisons and criminal courts at the risk of collapse. That is why as an early priority, we launched two wide-ranging reviews, that led by David Gauke and Sir Brian Leveson, to tackle this crisis holistically. This is a system-wide challenge and requires urgent action from across the whole criminal justice system.
Brian William Leishman
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Justice Secretary said just a fortnight ago that we have to build a new criminal justice system, and I wholeheartedly agree after the damage done by a decade and a half of austerity. Now, nobody knows better how far our justice system has fallen than the hard-working frontline workers desperately trying to hold it all together, who have watched and warned about this dangerous situation coming down the track for years. So, will the department listen to the leaders of the six national justice trade unions who are calling for a Royal Commission on prisons and the wider criminal justice system?
Heidi Alexander
Well, my honorable friend is absolutely right that our workforce, whether it's powering our prisons, our probation service, or indeed our court service, is the backbone of delivering for citizens in this country. And I know that myself and colleagues routinely engage with our trade unions who are vital stakeholders in this matter. But we're not waiting for a Royal Commission. The state of our justice system requires action now.
That is why the government is making record investment in sitting days in court, in building new prisons and indeed in the workforce itself.
Liz Roberts
Mr. Speaker, as the chair of the new Justice Unions APPG, which hears from six trade unions representing workers across prisons, probation, policing and the courts. Our first action last week was to write to the Prime Minister and the Justice Secretary to highlight a joint statement by six justice trade unions calling for a Royal Commission. Workers on the frontline see that the current piecemeal approach of narrow standalone reviews can at best only tackle individual symptoms while the disease and its causes remain untreated. Surely she agrees that end-to-end reform is now essential and that a Royal Commission is key to enabling this.
Heidi Alexander
Well, as she's just heard me said, what we need is action and investment in our workforce now. That's about fair pay, it's also about ensuring that our workforce, whether in prisons or in courts, have the tools to do the job that they were trained to do and want to do properly. That's why we are empowering them with digital tools, it's why we've provided the sitting days to hear the cases that need to be processed through our court. We don't need a Royal Commission to tell us what's needed, what we need is action right now.
Nic Dakin
Minister, welcome. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The right honourable gentleman, himself a former prisons minister and highly regarded former shadow secretary of state, has raised this issue assiduously on behalf of his constituent. The project to replace a water main serving Onley Park Estate is progressing through design and development with a projected programme expected in November.
Speaker 25
I am grateful to the minister and she will know that Onley Park is still owned by the Ministry of Justice. And I welcome the funding, but these residents have been waiting years and frankly they are really worried. We've still not got a start date, the clarity around backdated bills and it's affecting house sales now. So would she agree to meet with me and representatives of the parish council so we can bring some clarity and a resolution for the residents of Onley Park.
Nic Dakin
I absolutely recognise the honourable gentleman's concerns. The, as I said, the projected programme should be with him by November. He will appreciate there are important value for money considerations as well as making sure we get this project right. It is expected to be a year long once it commences and completed by January 2027, but if he still requires a meeting, of course I'd be happy to facilitate this.
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government has increased foreign national offender returns by 41% with more than 3,000 foreign national offenders removed directly from prison last year through the early removal scheme. From next year, new powers will enable most determinate sentence foreign national offenders to be deported immediately after sentencing and I have established a cross-government task force with the Home Office and the Foreign Office to maximise removals.
Andrew Murrison
In July, the then mayor of Manchester said nothing was off the table and that he would explore all possible options to deport child rapist Shabir Ahmed to Pakistan. Where's the necessary draft legislation to amend the 1971 Immigration Act? Where's the credible threat to Pakistan to turn off visas? And where's the credible threat to Pakistan to stop money and other assistance to Pakistan if it doesn't cooperate?
Shabana Mahmood
Well, the right honourable gentleman may well have seen also in July myself from this dispatch box set out the government's approach in this regard. He will know, and I think it is important to reiterate this, the challenges in the 71 Act are not merely technical and setting them aside is not merely a technical answer. It's right that we do that properly and you will also know that we've got ongoing negotiations and discussions with lots of countries around the world with regards to foreign offenders and that we don't provide running commentaries on them.
Speaker 31
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government's progress on deporting foreign national offenders is welcome, but how will the minister work with the Home Office to ensure that receiving countries are informed of the convictions of offenders, particularly those involving violence, sexual offending or exploitation, so that they have the information that they need to keep their public safe?
Shabana Mahmood
I have a double degree of anxiety. She of course as a former Ministry of Justice minister will know very well of what she speaks, but also as a Derby MP it creates a Derby-Nottingham rivalry across the select committee room that I have a degree of trepidation about, but I know how excellently she will do that job. I've known her well and she is brilliant. She makes a very important question here. You know, we have made significant strides in the removal of foreign offenders from this country of which we make no apology for.
We want to go further and again make no apology for that either. But to do that well and in a way that endures over the years, we need to work as well as possible with receiving countries. So we want them to have the best information as early as possible. That's why we're working with the Home Office and the Foreign Office in that venture so that we can safely and securely remove people in a way that we can keep doing over the years ahead.
Nic Dakin
The recruitment and retention of probation staff is a high priority for me and for the government. We're absolutely committed to recruiting and retaining our brilliant and dedicated probation workforce so that they can supervise and manage offenders in the community and keep the public safe.
Perran Moon
Moras Hamilton-Dames, Mr. Speaker. The probation service is suffering from thousands of vacancies and a pretty appalling retention rate. The extra 700 million announced for the probation service for this government, from this government, is welcome, but does the minister accept that some of this needs to support probation service salaries which have been massively eroded after a decade and a half of pay freezes and real-term cuts?
Nic Dakin
The honorable gentleman should be reassured to know that the retention rate of the probation service has improved significantly since this government came to office. I know the South West probation service has reported some of the best probation service retention rates in the country. But we are investing 700 million pounds into probation, into the community. We are absolutely committed to supporting them and discussions around pay are ongoing.
Paul William Forster
Will Foster. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After releasing a man with a history of domestic violence from prison, the probation service told his former partner that he had made threats as he was being released against both her and her child. Unsurprisingly, she now lives in fear. The probation service even told my local authority, Wokingham Borough Council, that they need to rehouse her for her own safety.
Will the minister urgently look at this case and agree to increase the probation workforce to ensure that this incident never happens again?
Speaker 35
Yeah, I'm very concerned to hear what the honorable gentleman says. I will absolutely look further into that case and we are absolutely committed to ensuring we have the probation workforce so that people are safe and can feel confident that they are safe.
Speaker 40
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The minister knows that there has been a decrease in probation officers in the last year, yet at the same time the government has released thousands of dangerous criminals onto our streets. The government's answer now is electronic tagging, but the National Audit Office has highlighted problems. Firstly, staff have to review the tag alert. Only 10 to 50 percent of alerts result in breach notifications, and where outcomes are even recorded, nearly half result in no further action.
So can she guarantee that in the next year every tagging breach will come with consequences?
Nic Dakin
We are giving probation the widest and toughest range of tools ever to restrict offenders in their movement, to help protect victims, and we are continuing to invest in strengthening the probation service via recruitment, digital improvements. We're building the capacity after years of the service being run down under the previous government.
Minister.
Alex Davies
Thank you, Mr Speaker, with your permission I will answer questions six and eight together. We have proudly delivered a world-leading package of intimate image abuse offences which criminalise taking or creating intimate images without consent, including AI-generated deepfakes. Through the Crime and Policing Act 2026, we have introduced new powers for courts to order the deletion of these images to better protect victims. But we're not stopping there, Mr Speaker, we know there's more to do.
Sadik Al-Hassan.
Sadik Al-Hassan
Thank you, Mr Speaker. In January, I stopped using X as a communication channel because the platform facilitated the creation of illegal and deeply harmful images by its AI tool Grok. This platform is unfortunately just one instance of AI-based violence against women and girls, an issue which I know North Somerset residents care deeply about. Can the Minister confirm whether the current law is keeping pace with AI-generated intimate image abuse and what assessment they have made of whether sentencing powers are adequate to reflect the harm images cause to women and girls?
Alex Davies
Thank you, Mr Speaker, I thank my honourable friend for that question. It's an important one to recognise the abuse that this is causing. The law alone is not enough, but we are strengthening the criminal law through world-leading packages as I've stated. We're also strengthening the sentencing response to intimate image abuse and have introduced new court powers to order the deletion and destruction of these images. But more is needed.
We need to ensure that there is a stronger understanding, policing and response to these crimes and that includes a whole societal response to this, which the government is determined to tackle through the violence against women strategy.
Speaker 34
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Violence against women and girls is hardly new. But perverts and abusers today have the ability to generate huge amounts of appalling content at lightning speed. We're not currently able to respond quickly enough. What can the government do to give Ofcom the power and ability to crack down quicker on disgusting online content so that we can keep women and girls safer?
Alex Davies
My honourable friend is right. Perpetrators are able to generate and share harmful content at unprecedented speed and scale and we need to be able to respond quickly. Ofcom does have robust enforcement powers under the Online Safety Act, including substantial fines and other sanctions. The new Crime and Policing Act also requires platforms to remove, as I've stated, the images within 48 hours and prevent the re-uploading of new hash-matching technology. The government also recognises the impact of harmful pornography and we are determined to bring forward work on this imminently.
Caroline Dinenage
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. The Minister knows that technology is being used in so many different forms to threaten women. Gosport domestic abuse survivor Harmony Hayman is still living in fear of a former partner eight years after leaving the relationship and he has used an illicit mobile phone from prison to contact her. She's now living in terror of the government's decision to release abusers early from prison, domestic abusers early from prison. Will the Minister look at Harmony's petition?
She's calling on the government to review how domestic abusers are able to perpetuate their abusive behaviour from within prison, but also their eligibility for early release.
Alex Davies
I will of course look at Harmony's petition and look into the issues she raises. I recently met with a group of victims and survivors who discussed the impact that technological abuse is having on them and this gives me the opportunity, Mr Speaker, to put on record my thanks to Refuge, the incredible organisation who have a dedicated tech abuse team who help victims and survivors who are in this position. The government knows more needs to be done here. We are working with the organisations directly such as Apple and Samsung on stalking technology, on verification tools, on ensuring that these tools can't be used to further harm victims, but I will of course look at Harmony's petition to see what more we can do.
Luke Murphy.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
The surge in so-called night-life videos, in which women are filmed on a night out, covertly filmed on a night out, is absolutely despicable. These videos are shared online, accompanied by vile misogynistic abuse, which drives engagement and generates profit for the video's creators. The government has committed to making misogyny an aggravated offence, but will the minister go further and commit to making misogyny a hate crime?
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Alex Davies
I thank the honorable lady for her question, and hopefully she will have seen the Minister for Women and Equalities last week outline the government's response to tackling some of this covert filming that is causing such anxiety to women particularly and other vulnerable individuals in our society. This is being uploaded at speed. We know that misogynistic content online needs to be tackled, whether that is through pornography, through intimate image abuse, and the government is determined to do this. We will be bringing forward measures in due course, and I look forward to working with the honorable lady and others in this house to see what else we can do to tackle this holistically as a society.
Nic Dakin
We are committed to delivering 14,000 additional prison places by 2031, the largest expansion of prison capacity since the Victorian era. To date, we've delivered a thousand additional rapid deployment cells across 20 sites, with plans to deliver a further 400 by the end of 2027.
Michael Reader
I thank the minister for her answer. However, I understand that there are a number of stalled projects in the program following the collapse of the contractor ISG that aren't able to be brought forward. And also, contractors are lacking a long-term pipeline. So given the wider societal benefits of this program, it's delivered through modern methods, there's a factory condition, and the reduced operational impact, these are delivered off-site. Will the minister ask her officials to review affordability criteria to bring more of these projects forward?
Speaker 36
The honorable gentleman is rightly interested in making sure that these plans are delivered. We are clearly working flat out to deliver them on time, but indeed where we can to deliver them ahead of time also. I will certainly look into the issues he raises. These are complex projects. We're determined to get this right, and I'm happy that he's raised the issue and we'll look into it further.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The ministry would be able to deliver its rapid deployment cells program building program more quickly if it completed other building programs. The closure of Taunton Crown Court since 2023 has just been extended. In March, I received a letter saying the long-promised opening date of July was now cancelled, and in due course I'd receive an update. I haven't received any update.
And the travelling of victims and jurors extra tens of miles, an extra 30, 40 miles without public transport, is a real burden for them, exacerbated by the fact that jury recompense hasn't been updated since 2010. Could the minister look into this and also address jury recompense?
Lindsay Hoyle
This is about cells. Well, you kind of threw something, I don't think it was quite relevant to be honest. Just because you do doesn't mean to say I accept it. We've really got to stick to the question. I would have thought it would have been better in topicals personally.
Sarah Bolsover.
Speaker 40
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So rapid deployment cells are one option, but the question still remains as to why the government is not making use of certified cells. HMP Millside has an operational capacity of up to 1,500, but is currently only at 1,100 due to staffing issues. So can the minister guarantee to replace the 1,600 prison officers lost under Labour by next year?
Nic Dakin
At present, around 80% of Millside's capacity is in use. Occupancy will continue to increase as and when it's appropriate, safe to do so, and we have the correct culture and processes established within the site.
Clearly this issue is pressing. We are working as hard as we can. We've brought 110 million pounds forward in investment to bring on site any available space that is not currently in use, and we'll continue to do so whilst making up for the staffing shortages that were left by the previous government.
Alex Davies
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government recognizes the huge impact that this has on delays, and the delays that this has on bereaved families. We are committed to supporting a swift inquest process that does put bereaved families at its heart. The Public Officer Accountability Bill with the expansion of legal aid and the new duty of candor further strengthens the focus on bereaved families whilst helping to ensure the timely establishment of the facts in each case.
Alice Hobbs
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm very grateful for what the Minister said, and I know that her government has also been pushing for more use of medical examiners as well as CT scans where that's appropriate. But of course the reality is for many families they're still experiencing delays and disruption at an extraordinarily traumatic time. It's even worse when they live far away from the court that's dealing with their beloved family member's case. So could I really ask her what more can she do working with the Chief Coroner to try and get these delays down?
Thank you.
Alex Davies
Yeah, I have huge sympathy for anyone who is struggling with this issue, Mr. Speaker, whether that be because they have to travel further, because of the nature of the case, or because of religious reasons as well. This is all deeply concerning. The right honorable lady will know that coroners are independent judges, every single case is different, and coroners make decisions about the release of the body on a case-by-case basis. For that reason I am unable to comment on individual judicial decisions. However, the law does require coroners to release bodies as soon as is reasonably practicable to allow for burial or cremation once it is no longer needed for their investigation.
Shockat Patel
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A constituent of mine died in state custody of July last year. His family was told to expect the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman report within weeks, but it was quietly paused pending the coroner's post-mortem report, and they were not told about this for several months. They have now passed the first anniversary of the death with no answers at all and with no post-mortem report. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss this case and the plight of families who are caught between the investigations that wait on one another?
Alex Davies
If the honorable gentleman wants to write with me with the details of this case I will of course look into this. Delays of that nature are rare, but they can happen as I've stated because of the case-by-case basis, but I will look into the specifics of this case. Mr. Speaker, just to reassure the House, we are aware of the issues with coronial delays. This is a problem regarding access to pathology, medical examiners, as my honorable friend has said, but we are working across government with members in DHSC to look at what more we can do to establish better service to put bereaved families back at the heart of the system.
Christopher Murray
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My city of Edinburgh is a world center... oh sorry, question 10, sorry.
Nic Dakin
The prison service absolutely needs to be modernized, which is why we are building the new digital prison services supporting the transformation of core prison operations and offender management. We're developing tactical AI-enabled tools for frontline staff to improve accuracy and efficiency, and we're exploring the use of biometric technology to improve public safety.
Christopher Murray
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My city of Edinburgh is a world center for innovation and digital technology, including in areas with applications in prisons, like Vision RF, whose tech monitors signs of self-harm in prisons and therefore prevent suicides and deaths on the estate. So what role does the Minister expect technology to play in improving long-term performance in prisons, and will officials engage with Edinburgh researchers because although justice policy is devolved, tech and innovation learnings apply in all parts of the UK?
Nic Dakin
There is so much work going on in terms of technological developments that can support a more efficient prison service. We are investing 82 million pounds following the Dame Lynne Owens review because there was a chronic underinvestment by the previous government in technology, and we want to see the prison service taken into this century and beyond.
Jim Shannon
Jim Shannon. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I thank the minister and welcome her to her place and wish her well in the role that she plays, and I know she'll do exceptionally well. Minister, what the minister has responded to the honourable gentleman's question has indicated some technological advances here in the UK in the mainland, and he rightly refers to Scotland where it's devolved, it's devolved in Northern Ireland as well, but it's really important that the sharing of that technology is done. I know the minister will give me an assurance, can she give me that assurance that the policing and justice minister in Northern Ireland and her department will have the same access to that technology?
Speaker 33
I appreciate the spirit in which the honourable gentleman raises his question, and yes, he has that assurance.
Nic Dakin
Minister. With permission, Mr Speaker, I'll answer questions 11 and 20 together. This government is determined to give offenders the tools to move away from crime. To do this, we do need to address issues such as housing, employment, substance misuse, misuse, and develop personal skills and behaviours, and we're continuing to work on strengthening practice in this area.
Monica Harding
Olly Kahal. Thank you, Mr Speaker. My local police force is working really hard to get youth crime down, as I witnessed when I went out on an op with them, but reoffending is a real problem. Probation officers and youth justice workers play an essential role in the rehabilitation of young offenders, but the service in my area was operating with under two-thirds of its roles staffed last year, mostly relating to the high costs in areas like Esher and Walton. A constituent that came into my surgery had been offered a position as a youth justice worker but had waited over six months for employment checks.
The department's own data show that almost 15,000 candidates are stuck in the vetting pipeline, so what is the minister doing about that?
Nic Dakin
The honourable lady raises a really important point, and I am very much on this as an issue. I'm working with officials in the department to understand exactly why the vetting is taking as long as it is, because we need these people employed and on the front line and working to reduce reoffending, and I can reassure her that I'm very much on the case.
John Richard Foord
Tim Farron. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The early release problem that we saw over the summer is partly an issue of reoffending because a quarter of prisoners released reoffend. I've got a constituent whose sibling has moved into her small house after he spent time in prison to prevent him becoming homeless, and I understand community accommodation service tier 3 is a good scheme for supporting prisoners after they first are released from prison, but what housing schemes support rehabilitation later to stop that revolving door for some offenders?
Nic Dakin
Again, the honourable gentleman raises a really important point and one I've identified very much needs to be a priority if we're going to support people to not reoffend and not be back in our prison system. So we have committed alongside MHCLG to halving the proportion of those released homeless from prison. We need to support people into settled accommodation so that they can get into employment and stay out of crime.
Speaker 52
Sir Mo Hudson. Mr Speaker, I am pleased to see the government is extending intensive supervision courts combining rehabilitation with close judicial oversight as I saw once on a visit to Texas. Tackling the causes of crime and interrupting the cycle of reoffending not only reduces crime but helps people back into sustainable relationships and employment. So could the minister share whether future consideration is being given to extend the scheme to London in a future rollout?
Nic Dakin
This is not only to be seen in Texas, but indeed in Stockton-on-Teeside, where I visited the intensive supervision court and saw for myself the value of this approach to making sure we really tackle the challenge of prolific offending, those who commit a significant number of crimes, but it's actually a quite a relatively small group of people. And indeed, we are operating four locations in England, and there are further seven locations that are going to be operating by 2029, including with London.
Rachel Maskell.
Rachael Maskell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I refer to my register of interests. Last week I visited prison with the UCU to look at the prison education service. I saw the power of dynamic prison education, but also heard about the cuts to these privatised contracts. So I ask the Minister if she will bring those contracts back in-house and also she works with the DWP and the Department for Education to ensure that education has real purpose in people's lives and also reduces reoffending for the future.
Nic Dakin
As a former Minister for Schools, she should hopefully not doubt my commitment to education as a life-changing force, and indeed one I would like to see employed to reduce reoffending and protect the public whilst changing lives.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Restorative justice has a vital role to play in cutting reoffending and supporting victims. I would not be here today after a violent attack in my home were it not for a subsequent RJ session. I'm consequently very concerned the Prison Probation Service has recently issued this protocol that would have denied my family accessing RJ, along with the family of James Hodgkinson, on whom the play Punch is based. Now, as I understand it, no Minister has yet been formally assigned the RJ role within the MOJ, but when they are, will they meet with me and Jacob Dunne, the RJ campaigner and perpetrator in Punch, and to help reverse this retrograde step?
Nic Dakin
I thank the honourable gentleman for raising this point. Restorative justice is clearly a vital part of our system and we need to make sure it works to fullest effect, and I would be more than happy to take the meeting that he suggested.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. From the 26th of October, Labour's new respect orders will mean those persistently involved in anti-social behaviour in Ealing Southall can be required to attend drug and alcohol rehab to reduce reoffending. Would the Minister outline what work she is doing with the Home Office to ensure our courts have the guidance they need in advance of the 26th of October, so both the police and courts can act immediately to make Ealing Southall safer?
Nic Dakin
The honourable lady is absolutely right and has raised some of the practical issues around this with me, which she can be assured I have taken forward, and I will indeed take forward the request that she makes today. Clearly we work with other government departments to make sure that these support services are available to reduce reoffending and keep the public safe, and I'll take on board the suggestion she's made today.
Josh Simons.
Minister.
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A report commissioned by the Ministry of Justice and published in 2023 found limited evidence of unaccredited child contact centres. Protocols make clear that as part of family court proceedings, the judiciary and Cafcass should only refer families to centres accredited by the National Association of Child Contact Centres, but there are clearly issues with the sector in terms of costs and accessibility and we will always seek to improve it.
Josh Simons.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In cases where family court proceedings lead to child removal, parents can be forced to use unregulated contact centres, costing hundreds of pounds for just a few hours of contact. This is because of a lack of accessible regulated contact centre provision.
What assessment has the Minister made of the impact of this situation on the welfare of children and families, and will his department initiate a review of current arrangements?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, I thank her for raising this really important issue. Where it's safe to do so, we would always encourage, and the courts do encourage, parents to have contact with their children. It's always in a child's best interest to have that contact. And where contact centres are necessary, they need to be close to home and clearly affordable. This is an independent sector, independent of government, but clearly if it's not working, as we're hearing from my honourable friend, then we will look into it in due course.
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our government will bring forward legislation to end the IPP sentence by the end of this Parliament. We will do so through cross-party engagement, recognizing that these are complex cases involving important public protection and victim considerations, and it will take us time to get this right. I anticipate making a further announcement later this year.
Laura Kyrke-Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In the summer, I met a group of IPP prisoners, most of whom had been serving their sentences since 2006 or 7. They told me about the extreme toll that the protracted uncertainty of these sentences takes on their mental health, and one showed me where he had been self-harming. The prisoners also spoke about the unfairness of this type of sentence, particularly seeing other people who had committed much greater offences being released much sooner than they had been. We must always do right by the victims of these prisoners' crimes, but these are men who have now served their original sentences several times over.
So it's also right that the Secretary of State is reviewing this type of sentence. Can he set out what assessment he has made of the mental health impacts and when we can expect decisions on next steps? Thank you.
Shabana Mahmood
I'm grateful to my honourable friend's considered question, and I, like she, have had those conversations in my constituency surgeries as well. And I want to recognize those challenges that those prisoners face, as she says. In the immediate term, IPP prisoners have greater access to mental health support, including funding for specialist assessments by psychology services. She will know as well, I suspect, as the root of those conversations, that the Phoenix unit opened up at HMP Aylesbury last month to provide dedicated support for IPP prisoners. I know those prisoners and their families, and indeed their victims, are looking now to see what the government will do next.
I think it is right that we make sure that we get the, we get any changes right, balance public safety, but under the principle that these sentences have been discontinued for a very good reason, that's been a long-standing cross-party position, and it's time that we move forwards.
Speaker 67
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this month, John Dunn was convicted for trying to meet a 14-year-old boy at a train station in Suffolk. He received a two-year sentence, reduced from three on a guilty plea. This still seems lenient, considering Mr. Dunn has already served a life sentence for rape and murder. Our community, our country, will never be safe when we release people who are clearly not functioning in society.
I have written to the AG regarding this sentence. But if the government is considering IPP, what is its plan for keeping children safe in situations like this?
Shabana Mahmood
I am grateful for that question and the spirit in which it's asked. I won't, I'm afraid, be drawn on that individual case if it's with the Attorney General, because it's right that that process carry on unhindered. He will know we have a tension here. I don't think he would believe, in fact, I don't believe anybody in this House would believe that people who have served their sentence, and in many cases a decade or more beyond their sentence, should be held. That's why we've discontinued those sentences.
But he makes very important points around support, around public safety and public protection, and that's the work that we're doing at the moment, and I look forward to his scrutiny of those plans.
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll answer questions 14 and 15 together. On the 1st of September, the Lord Chancellor from this dispatch box announced a further 4.5 million pounds of investment to better support and supervise children away from criminality. And earlier this year, we published the Youth Justice White Paper, and we're getting on with the job of delivering that reform across the country.
Steve Witherden
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Early intervention is key to tackling youth offending, and our government's commitment to new youth hubs is essential in supporting at-risk young people and steering them away from a life of crime. Constituents of mine in Cefn Mawr, Plas Madoc, Acrefair and Rhosymedre have reported a rise in anti-social behavior among young people. Would my honorable friend agree that a new youth hub in Plas Madoc would go a long way to addressing this problem?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
My honorable friend's right that youth services and support for early intervention is absolutely at the heart of tackling reoffending. We know that 80% of adult prolific offenders commit their first offense when they're a child. So getting early intervention, dealing with young offenders, is absolutely at the heart of what we published in the Youth Justice White Paper earlier this year and what this government is doing.
Alexander Forbes McIntyre
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. To break the cycle of offending and reoffending in young people, we need to do more to give young people opportunity and something productive to do. What discussions has the Minister had with Alan Milburn about his review, and how can we ensure that young offenders are put on a more productive pathway going forward?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, my honorable friend's absolutely right that this is a cross-government effort. If we're going to tackle reoffending, if we're going to tackle youth crime, then it's an issue for the Department for Education, the Home Office, for the DWP and indeed the Ministry of Justice. That's why on Thursday, I'll be in Number 10 North with colleagues from across government launching our new strategy to devolve youth justice services so that it serves the places and the localities and the people within them.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents in Broxbourne are extremely concerned about the young people on e-bikes and e-scooters repeatedly committing crimes and anti-social behavior. There is a feeling that these individuals do this behavior and get away with it and put in danger other people. Can the Minister assure me that the justice system is robust enough to punish every individual involved in this reckless behavior?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, the honorable member's absolutely right, and it's an issue in my constituency as well, and I hear about it a lot from constituents and see it for myself outside my constituency office in Dinnington. What I would say is that obviously it's a matter for the police as to how they enforce the law on our streets. But in terms of the justice reforms that I've been introducing in the youth justice system, we are implementing more rigorous community punishments for young offenders and, critically, looking at what we can do about parenting orders. Because it's not just a job for government to ensure that young people turn their back on crime, it's also a responsibility for their parents as well, and we want to make sure that that responsibility is felt.
Joshua Thomas Babarinde
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Social media is being flooded by videos, often shared by young people, glorifying dangerous driving on roads like Beachy Head Road in Eastbourne, where dangerous driving claimed the life of 17-year-old Oakley Meer. While dangerous driving is a crime, the glorification is not necessarily. What steps is the Ministry of Justice taking to crack down on this, working with Ofcom to achieve justice for Oakley and his family, who are campaigning to make that road safer?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, my honorable friend's absolutely right to raise this issue. Death by dangerous driving is a horrific crime. In fact, straight after this session in the chamber, I'm meeting a victim of that very offense. I'm also meeting the chair of the Sentencing Council next week, and it's something that we can certainly look into as to how we can make sure that those that celebrate this offending are treated in the right way.
Heidi Alexander
In Croydon, as elsewhere, we are taking a three-pronged approach to reducing the Crown Court waiting list.
That involves increasing Crown Court capacity, removing the financial constraint on sitting days, driving efficiency through our courts through schemes like every Crown Court having a case coordinator, and of course the structural reforms we'll be bringing forward in the Courts Bill.
Luke Taylor
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Having recently visited Croydon Crown Court, I saw firsthand the impact that these delays are having on victims. Across London over the last decade, backlogs have increased by 122%, and that's having a particular impact on domestic abuse and sexual offense victims. Given this, will the Minister consider listening to Liberal Democrat calls to abandon plans to restrict trial by jury, but instead create specialist sexual offense and domestic abuse courts so that these sensitive cases can be dealt with as quickly as possible?
Heidi Alexander
Mr. Speaker, as a fellow London MP, I agree that the waiting lists in our London courts are appalling, because behind each and every one of those cases in the backlog, there are individual victims, there are witnesses and defendants whose lives are entirely put on hold, and it's why we've got to run hard at this problem. But the way we're going to get it down is going to involve a multi-faceted approach, and it's why the efficiencies we're making in courts, it's why unlimited sitting days, it's why the blitz courts initiatives that we are piloting in London courts are so crucial. And as I said, somebody with a vested interest in seeing London waiting lists coming down, I'll be glad to work with him to see what we can do to do so.
Nic Dakin
Distribution of property used by the Probation Service's accommodation service is regularly reviewed. It's to meet local need, operational requirements, and community considerations, as we need to make sure the properties are allocated appropriately and that sufficient capacity is ensured.
Andrew Snowden
Thank you for that answer. Properties such as run-down B&Bs have long been used as HMOs for services like probation, but also councils in large metropolitan areas who use them for adult and children's social services effectively as a dumping ground. This is a multi-government problem going on over a number of times. Can the Minister assure me that through the early release scheme, that they will not be adding to problems like in Blackpool with that concentration of HMOs used by multiple services which create transient populations?
Nic Dakin
The honorable gentleman raises an important point, and obviously that has to be a consideration. Clearly, the accommodation is demand-led. Offenders ideally should be resettled back into their communities where they have community ties and can build their life and create stable accommodation so that they don't reoffend. But obviously that needs to be taken on a local and case-by-case basis to make sure it's appropriate within the setting as well.
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As I have already mentioned, the Courts and Tribunals Bill will shortly come back to this House. The record and rising Crown Court backlog we inherited has more than doubled from around 38,000 cases in 2019 to more than 80,000 today, denying victims justice for months or even for years. To fix the system, as my honorable friend has said, we've invested, we've continued to modernize the courts, and through the legislation that will return, set in train much-needed structural reform. But the Prime Minister has been clear that the answer to justice delayed cannot be justice diminished.
So we are looking again at these proposals, considering the evidence, and listening to experts both inside and outside this House, and of course to victims. I look forward to improving the bill as it progresses so that it delivers for victims and continues to command the confidence of the British people.
Speaker 76
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Court backlogs in the South East have trebled over the last decade, facing extreme pressure on our criminal justice system. Yet a new justice quarter in Milton Keynes could provide that extra capacity which delivers faster access to justice for my constituents in the Buckingham and Bletchley constituency and deliver a modern justice hub in one of the fastest-growing cities in the UK. So would my right honorable friend grant me a meeting alongside my Milton Keynes colleagues to discuss how we take this proposition forward?
Shabana Mahmood
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recognize the ambition of local partners to develop a justice quarter in Milton Keynes. I know there's engagement gone on so far, indeed my honourable friend is to meet MPs also, but I know the Milton Keynes MPs are hunting in a pack on this and I think I've already committed to a visit which I'm sure I will do shortly, but in the meantime my honourable friend looks forward to meeting the honourable gentleman.
Nick Timothy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government held five different positions on early release in just six weeks. In seeking to exclude killers, rapists and paedophiles, something they previously claimed was impossible, the Justice Secretary has used secondary legislation. He says, quote, "no further legislation is required in the short term, but primary legislation will be considered when parliamentary time allows." Can he guarantee that after relying on secondary legislation to change Labour's early release scheme, no prisoner will successfully challenge their exclusion in the courts?
Shabana Mahmood
Yes, I can give the honourable gentleman the assurance that I've no concerns on that regard. The device that we used was the commencement order, so we chose to commence the provisions for some offences but not for others. The point I was making in writing to him is that I think for parliamentarians it would be discomforting to have things lie on the statute book that are not intended for use, so it is good practice I think to remove them. Now it would not be without precedent for many provisions to be on the statute book without being turned on, but nevertheless that's what I referred to for further legislation, but I am confident in our legal position.
Nick Timothy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Justice Secretary now proposes to let another set of dangerous criminals out of prison as well. Every IPP prisoner has been assessed as too dangerous for release or returned to prison because of their behaviour, last year 426 of them. The Justice Secretary has reiterated his commitment today to ending IPP sentences by the end of this parliament. Can he tell the House very clearly if he's decided it is indeed safe to release every single one of them?
Shabana Mahmood
Mr. Speaker, the question here is, do we really believe, and I understand the honourable gentleman to be a champion of individual liberty, I understand the honourable gentleman to be someone who believes in the equal application of liberty for individuals too. He must share my discomfort surely that there are individuals serving tariffs of 18 months who have served 18 years on those sentences. That has been for a long period of time a position of consensus, that's why his colleagues when in government discontinued these sentences. That is not to say it's easy, and in exactly the spirit in which he says must be done safely, my commitment is to do that with him and with colleagues across the House.
Josh Fenton.
Joshua Fenton-Glynn
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This government has promised to halve violence against women and girls, but in a context where over the past decade charging and conviction of perpetrators has fallen significantly, impacting confidence that victims have in the justice system. So what measures is the government taking to ensure that perpetrators are brought to justice?
Alex Davies
I thank my honourable friend for that question, who is a stalwart of campaigning on tackling violence against women and girls. He will know that pursuing and punishing perpetrators is a key pillar of our halving strategy. We have a 10-year plan to meet this ambitious goal and we are carefully monitoring the progress and will publish our one-year update in the coming months. But I want to reassure him that rape charge volumes have more than doubled since 2019, and 5,206 rape cases were brought before the courts in 2023 compared to just 1,684 in 2019.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Liberal Democrats in the other place have secured an amendment seeking to address the injustice of locked child trust funds for disabled children. The leader of the Liberal Democrats has experience of this with his own disabled son and has been a passionate campaigner for a change in the law for many years, working with other campaigners like Andrew Turner. So when the amendment comes back to this House, will the Labour government support it?
The Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Jess Brown-Fuller.
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, the honourable lady is absolutely right to raise this issue. Mr. Speaker, 80,000 disabled people are unable to access funds which are legally theirs. Now, that is a disgrace. Now, it is complex because mental capacity is a complex area of our law and we have to deal with it taking due regard to safeguarding mechanisms that we have, but it cannot be beyond the wit of this place or indeed government to overcome that obstacle. I met with the leader of the Liberal Democrats last week to discuss this issue and we're going to be making progress in the coming weeks.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently met with a high street law firm who have offices in Whitby, Scarborough and Filey. As a small company, they worry that government proposals to take a proportion of the interest earned on client accounts could lead them to shed jobs and potentially premises. Could the Minister outline what assessment she's made of the impact of these proposals and what they'll have on the viability of high street solicitors?
Heidi Alexander
Well, I thank her for her question. We recognise the vital role that high street law firms play in serving communities such as Scarborough and Whitby, and I greatly valued the meeting that we had in which she raised a number of concerns in relation to the consultation that is currently being undertaken and which we are engaging extensively with stakeholders to ensure that the potential impacts of the proposals, which are targeted, by the way, at access to justice, ensure that all views are carefully considered.
Andrew Murrison
Prison officers do an increasingly tough job that most of us wouldn't want to do or couldn't do. The least they should be able to expect is to have their pensions and their lump sums paid on time, and yet thanks to the incompetence of MyCSP, Equiniti and now Capita, that is not happening. What's the Minister going to do about it?
Nic Dakin
I absolutely agree with the honourable gentleman and am working with cabinet colleagues to make sure that prison officers that have worked hard all their lives and, as you say, work in incredibly challenging circumstances, get the retirement they deserve.
Sharon Hodgson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I visited Newcastle Crown Court before the summer recess, where I learned that the backlog of cases has reached an unprecedented high. And as we have heard, measures such as the blitz courts, which she mentioned earlier in Teesside, and specialist sexual offences and domestic abuse courts can help with this backlog. Will the Minister ensure that the Crown Prosecution Service and the police take ownership of the backlog with realistic reviews, and will she outline what measures she is taking to explore to reduce the backlog in Newcastle?
Heidi Alexander
Well, she is absolutely right that cross-criminal justice system working is vital, whether that's between the police, the Crown Prosecution Service, the judiciary and our court service. I know that in Newcastle, steps have been taken, there's been some agility shown around courtroom capacity and as well as case progression, which is starting to bear results, and I encourage more of that right across our Crown Court system.
Charles Edward Robin Morello
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Citizens Advice in Bridport and Dorchester are reporting huge demand for their services as a result of cuts to legal aid, especially in housing, welfare and immigration law. What steps is the Minister taking to restore sustainable legal aid provision and ensure rural advice services are properly funded?
Heidi Alexander
Early legal advice is absolutely essential to access to justice. And it's why one of the first actions we took when I became Minister responsible for legal aid was to give legal aid lawyers delivering immigration and housing advice the first pay lift, an injection of 20 million pounds, that they had received since 1996, precisely because of the issues he raises.
Danny Beales
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Vulnerable victims and witnesses of crime deserve full and proactive support from the CPS and the police. Yet one of my constituents struggled to get clarity about what protections would be put in place should they give evidence in court, and also whether their victim personal statement was even properly considered during the sentencing stage of the trial. Will the minister outline what is being done to better support victims, particularly vulnerable witnesses, to ensure they get proper support and advocacy in the court system?
Alex Davies
My honorable friend is right to raise this issue. He is correct, special measures do help vulnerable witnesses and victims to give evidence and reduce the stress in attending court. These include the use of screens, live video links, pre-recorded evidence. He will know that the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which is due to come back to this place soon, includes reforms to special measures, including clarifying that vulnerable witnesses and victims may use them when delivering their personal statements. We've also revised the victims' code to ensure that this is taken into account.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Ministry of Justice's contractors are acting in a deeply inconsiderate manner affecting my constituents in Edgecott, Grendon Underwood and the Springhill Road estate in the construction of a new mega prison adjacent to HMP Grendon. I asked the minister in writing over the summer if she'd come and see with her own eyes those problems. She wrote back to me yesterday to say no. Why won't she come and see with her own eyes and will she reconsider?
Nic Dakin
The honorable gentleman will know the importance of ensuring we build the prison capacity that is so lacking from the previous government. Officials do continue to regularly meet with the local council, elected councillors and parish councillors to agree all traffic management and challenges around the site. I am visiting as many prisons as I can get to and I will certainly endeavor to come and visit HMP Grendon in due course.
Speaker 93
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Failings in the family court system are having a heartbreaking impact on too many in my constituency. In one instance, a mother and her child have been waiting since last November now for non-molestation papers to be served. In the meantime, they've had not one, not two, but eight failed court hearings where process failings have meant the papers could not be served, exposing them to risk, continued stress and strain over a very long period now. Will the minister meet with them to discuss how we can put this right and fix a broken system?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Mr. Speaker, I won't just be happy to meet with them, I'm keen to meet with them because if we're going to improve the family justice system, we need to hear from those that have experienced it. We are rolling out child-focused courts which will help, but we've got to improve productivity more generally and we're getting on with that.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
It was May when I stood here and asked the minister to intervene on a pedophile moved to an open prison two years into his 10-year sentence. I was promised an answer then. I raised it again in July and again last week, and yet I still have had no answer. When will Saunders' survivors finally stop being ignored by this minister and get an answer on why this man's been put into an open prison?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Well, Mr. Speaker, I understand the force of the honorable lady's question. I will look into that immediately the moment this session ends and I will meet with her behind the Speaker's chair to confirm how we do that.
Kerry McCarthy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The minister has been absolutely brilliant in helping identify children with a parent in prison. Will he now agree to join me on 25th of November for National Children with a Parent in Prison Day, where we'll be able to hear from young people with lived experience about the important next steps, which is getting them the support that they need?
Frederick Matthew Thomas Ponsonby
Yes, I'm very grateful. The honorable friend is a massive champion of this issue. We've got over 200,000 children of prisoners across the country. I'm working very closely with Department for Education to ensure we can identify them. It was a manifesto commitment and we are making strides on it.
And now we need to go further on that. In terms of the invitation, I'd be very happy to be there at the end of November.
Anna Dixon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Jimmy, the son of two of my Shipley constituents, was given an IPP sentence of two and a half, with a two and a half year tariff in 2007. He remains in prison with no set release date, despite having passed his mental health tribunal. I strongly welcome the Prime Minister's recent announcement to review these unjust sentences, but can the Secretary of State assure me that prisoners with autism like Jimmy will get the support they need to start a new life?
Shabana Mahmood
I'm grateful for that question again. It should discomfort colleagues that there are, in many cases, lots and lots and lots of people across our communities that have served long beyond their sentence and have not been permitted their release from prison or not been able to sustain a release from prison. Of course, there's been a lot of interest about what legislative approach we may take, and that is what we intend to publish legislation in due course. But she's entirely right, we also have to make sure that those individuals who do leave have the best possible support that we can give them to make sure that they can sustain that exit.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A few weeks ago, I visited Margaret Green Animal Rescue in Wareham, and they told me that when pet owners are prosecuted for animal welfare offences, they take in the animals, but during the delay before prosecution, those animals cannot be rehomed. Now, there are many reasons that we should be dealing with the court backlog, but for the sake of animal welfare, will the Minister look at how we can make sure those animals are rehomed and not delayed in these facilities?
Heidi Alexander
Well, thank you for her question, and she's right, a backlog is a backlog, irrespective of the offence, and in all these cases, the victims might be of a different nature, they might be animals, they might be human, or whatever. Local authorities do have a responsibility in this, and I would look forward, if she wishes to write to me, to giving her a full answer about how the Ministry of Justice is doing just that.
Kim Marie Johnson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, Appeal raised a new law, Trues Law. It's a campaign looking at the actions of a corrupt and racist BTP police officer, Derek Ridgewell. The law is about reviewing the cases of all imprisoned police officers. Will the Minister agree to meet with me and the campaigners to review this law?
Danny Chambers
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's been a long and proven link between those who deliberately harm animals and then commit domestic abuse. The Links Group have researched and highlighted this link for 25 years and are having a special conference later this year to mark this. Would the Minister agree to meet with me and the Links Group so we can draw on their 25 years of expertise to help prevent avoidable harm to women and children and even animals?
Ben Kirkham.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite the MOJ not collecting numbers on the number of people in prison for joint enterprise, we know there are hundreds, and the Law Commission has sadly confirmed it won't look at that area of law under the homicide review. Does the Secretary of State intend to look at this most difficult area of law to reform it, and what will happen to those prisoners convicted of joint enterprise crimes under the early release scheme?
Alex Davies
Yes, I thank my honourable friend for raising this. She is right to draw attention to the nature of joint enterprise. She will know that the government has been looking carefully at this, and I would be happy to meet with her and others to discuss this in more detail.
Andrew Snowden
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have previously put it to the Prisons Minister in one of these sessions that anyone who fails a drug test on arrival in an open prison like Kirkham does not belong there and should be sent back to a more secure prison. So could I ask the Minister, who said they were concerned but could not agree to that, whether the department had had any more thoughts on at least consequences for failing a drug test on arrival at an open prison?
Nic Dakin
I absolutely recognise the honourable gentleman's concerns. We do have a review ongoing into these issues within prisons, led by Amber Rudd, and we'll continue to make sure that we have both the deterrents to stop drugs getting in, but also the right actions taken when they do.
Nick Timothy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In questions just now the Justice Secretary stood there and said again that he wanted to work collaboratively and he invited the House to scrutinise the government proposals on juries but these just words. This summer as the government constantly changed policy on early release I wrote to him and the Prime Minister three times in July, twice in August and received no reply until I got a short dismissive reply last Thursday by which point, by which point, what are your guidelines? By which point the policy had changed several times and just now the Secretary of State dismissed my question sarcastically saying that he wasn't the correspondence secretary. That's not only disrespectful to the House, it's disrespectful to his correspondence secretary and may explain the delays.
Lindsay Hoyle
No, I think I've got the point. No, I think I've got the point. You're quite right. Let's deal with the issues, we'll judge whether sarcastically. Of course that's never been done by the honourable gentleman, I know.
Be careful being in the greenhouse with a stone in hand. Can I just say, you're quite right to raise the issue of correspondence. I expect whether it's the Prime Minister, anybody, there should be a reply as ASAP. The point has been made, the benches heard it and I'm sure that in future the replies will be forthcoming. I will leave it at that for now.
Thank you. Let us come to the urgent question, Rebecca Pow.
Rebecca Paul
Mr. Speaker, to ask the Minister for Housing, Communities and Local Government if he will make a statement on the impact of the government's proposed overnight visitor levy on the tourism and hospitality sectors in England.
Jim McMahon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last Thursday the government published its response to the consultation on the overnight visitor levy. The Rewiring the State cabinet announcement committed to delivering good growth in every part of the United Kingdom and the visitor levy supports this ambition by empowering local leaders to deliver transformational investment, building the reputation of areas across England as world-leading destinations. Local leaders will be able to choose to introduce a levy as a way to raise money to support growth in their regions including in the visitor economy. Visitor levies are common in Europe and the rest of the world.
All over the G7 countries already have some form of tourism or overnight accommodation levy in place. The government have decided that both foundation authorities and mayoral strategic authorities will be empowered to raise a levy to support growth in their regions. This approach means that places without a mayor will also be able to invest in their region, making them better places for residents and businesses as well for as well as for people who visit and enjoy their areas. The levy will be set as a percentage of accommodation costs and that means that low-cost stays remain low cost while those who can afford to contribute more will be able to contribute more to the places where they visit. Strategic authorities will be required to consult before introducing a visitor levy.
This will inform their decision on whether to introduce the levy, how much it would cost and how revenues would then be spent. We expect that local leaders will be able to set out plans for how revenues will be invested by early 2028 and to introduce a levy before the end of this parliament. The government is engaged with the tourism and hospitality sectors throughout the consultation and we will continue to do so as the legislation is developed. Because of these changes the Labour government is introducing, it will mean more money to be invested in our high streets and our public transport system and England's tourism hotspots will directly benefit from footfall from visitors to improve their areas for people living there too.
Rebecca Paul
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Let's call this what it is: Labour's holiday tax. Although we knew it was coming, we never expected it to be uncapped. This Government has already hammered hospitality with higher employment costs and business rates. Almost 89,000 hospitality jobs have gone.
And now what is Labour's answer? Hit them again. If you tax something, you get less of it. So if we tax tourism, we will get less tourism. It's not complicated.
And less tourists mean fewer jobs. UK Hospitality estimates that up to 33,000 jobs will go, along with over 2 billion wiped from the economy. And these job losses will hit young people hardest, who are already struggling to secure those all-important first roles. And Mr. Speaker, don't make the mistake of thinking this is just a tax on foreign visitors. Tax Policy Associates estimates that trips by British tourists will generate 63% of the revenue from this levy.
This is a tax on hardworking British families. A weekend away, a family holiday, a few nights by the seaside, this will all cost more. Every pound taken in this tax is a pound families don't spend in the local pub, restaurant, cafe, shop or attraction. And it's not just Brits on a staycation impacted. It's anyone staying overnight for any reason.
So visiting a sick relative, or going away on business, or travelling for medical treatment. Why on earth should these people be taxed simply for going about their daily lives? It is not fair. The Prime Minister has repeatedly promised to give breathing space to households struggling with the cost of living. Yet this tax does the exact opposite.
British hospitality does not need another tax. Hardworking families do not need another tax. Young people looking for work do not need another tax. The Government must scrap the holiday tax.
Jim McMahon
So, where do we start? We are not starting from year zero. I think the idea that somehow under the previous Conservative Government there were somehow the good days for our pubs, our hospitality industries and our tourism economy. Just think of the thousands of pubs that closed on their watch. Just think about the bars and the restaurants and the live music venues that were left standing by themselves because they were ignored by the Government of the day.
But now they have a Government on side, which is why we've introduced measures already into this Government to give pubs and live music venues that 20% business rate cut, and we have a targeted investment in our town centres and our high streets. But in the end, you can't go to a corner of England and not look at a country that was impacted by all those years of austerity and the lack of investment that went alongside it. And so the question is, do we just accept that decline is inevitable? That the rot that the Conservatives allowed to set in large parts of this country is now a permanent fixture of our national character?
Or we decide that there's a different route that can be taken, where we invest in our economies, we invest in growth, and importantly, that we see this through the prism of this new spirit of devolution. Because there is no mandate of this.
Areas are not being made to introduce a levy at all. It's down to local leaders to make the right call for their areas, to consult on those decisions, and importantly, to present back to their community where the investment will go. And this won't just benefit people who visit. That investment in those tourism hotspots in particular, and our great cities, our countryside, and our rural economies, will benefit also the people that live there, because they'll get the better neighborhood services provided too. And in the end, everyone will win.
Emma Lewell
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. South Shields' tourism is largely made up of families from neighboring regions who've saved hard all year round to spend a few days at the seaside. They will not come, even if the increase is marginal. My constituents, family-run B&Bs, caravan parks, hotels, and wider hospitality industry have been unequivocal with me that they do not want this. It is the wrong tax at the worst time.
This extra burden on their business will tip my local industry over. Devolution only works when it reflects what communities want. So can my honorable friend please confirm that MPs, who are voices and local leaders in their community, will be at the forefront of these proposals?
Jim McMahon
I appreciate the question. Also, can I just recognize as well the champion that she has done over a long period of time for jobs in her community? So I don't take that lightly at all as a representation. But I'd just say this. There is not a part of the country where investment isn't desperately needed to improve the visitor experience, and also the experience, of course, for people who live there too.
And if we get this right, and it will be down to our local mayors and our local leaders to implement the investment, then the truth is that everyone will benefit from that improved visitor experience.
Speaker 100
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Liberal Democrats have long championed our high streets, tourism, and hospitality sectors. And while we strongly support devolving economic powers, businesses are already struggling under mounting costs, a VAT rate higher than our international peers, and the government's NICs hike. Without support, an overnight levy risks looking less like genuine devolution and more like another short-term tax grab. If ministers hand local mayors and FSAs the power to introduce levies, they must bring forward vital sector relief, an emergency 5% VAT cut, relief from NICs, and so forth.
And they must not reduce local government funding as a result. Can the Secretary of State confirm when this House will see full details of the levy, and specifically whether ministers will implement a cap and sector support to protect local tourism and hospitality?
Jim McMahon
There is no expectation that councils will see a cut in the way that she explains. I'm not quite sure what the rationale is for that. This is a new levy that local areas can choose to bring in. But it is down for local leaders, both our mayoral strategic authorities and our foundation authorities, working with their local councils, to determine if it's something they want to do, how they may want to approach it, to carry out a proper consultation, and also set out where the spending and investment will then follow. That is not central government telling places what to do.
But it is time, isn't it, that we stop trying to pretend that England was somehow one place and one size can fit all? That devolution, if it matters, must mean that local leaders can make the right choice for their area.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I welcome this as a Cornish MP. And I think it's important that those local leaders, particularly the ones in non-mayoral areas, will get this opportunity to make this decision in consultation with their businesses in their areas. Could the minister just confirm that emergency and temporary accommodation, and some of those low-cost holiday options like tents and caravans, could be maybe excluded from the levy?
Jim McMahon
Yeah, we'll certainly set out more detail as the legislation is developed on the list of exemptions. She makes the point exactly, which is, of course, the holiday hotspots like Cornwall and the Lake District and many other parts of the country benefit hugely from tourism and they support a huge range of jobs.
But it's also true to say that the impact of tourism also comes with a cost. And it's right that that cost is met by a fair and proportionate levy on the people who benefit, and with that, local areas will see the benefit and the investment that will follow.
Caroline Dinenage
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I must admit to being really puzzled by the Minister's statement. The visitor levy is not going to be ring-fenced for tourism, so how does he know it will go to its intended destination? And the levy won't be capped. We normally tax things to stop people doing them, not encourage them to do more of it.
So what evidence can he offer to demonstrate, as he says, that this will bring growth? And finally, what work has the Government actually done to prepare for this? How will they know whether the hospitality businesses, which let's face it are already collapsing in their droves under the Government's decisions they've already taken, will survive yet another tax being imposed on them?
Jim McMahon
Well, as I've already set out, this is for local areas to decide if it's right for their place. And importantly, in reference to whether this is a new tax or not, of course, every tax is a tax on the face of it. The question is, where is the accountability and where does that money go? And what mayors will be required and our foundation authorities will be required to do is to set out in the consultation how much they want to raise, for that to be proportionate to their local area, for them to do an impact assessment of the levy that's being proposed, and importantly, to set out where that money is being invested. And in places where there's not a levy in place, just think about, well, who pays for the impact of tourism?
Who puts on the events and the performances that bring people into the local area? And what is that wider experience? And I would say, if we think about where we go on holiday, and I went away to North Yorkshire for summer, my experience wasn't just the accommodation that we stayed in, it was visiting the local village and the local town and driving all around the local area. And so we just need to think about that visitor experience is wider than just the accommodation where they stay, it's the place where they go to.
Speaker 101
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. As someone who represents a seaside constituency in Bournemouth West, the vast majority of my hoteliers are supportive of an overnight levy, in part because BCP Council has axed its standalone tourism department and because we get 10 million visitors every summer and no increase in resources to deal with that. The Minister in his opening remarks mentioned that most other G7 and European nations also have some sort of overnight levy. We're really used to that if you travel in Europe. So can you tell us what lessons the Government has taken from these experiences overseas?
Jim McMahon
And I congratulate her for the champion that she does for Bournemouth and reflect as well that the experience there in terms of the cuts to local government over many years has impacted on those on-the-ground services that would have been provided both on neighbourhood services in terms of that quality of place and also that economy focus on tourism. And we need to start rebuilding that, and this is one way potentially of doing some of that. And in terms of the lessons learned, there are places that might approach this from a like a flat rate, so it doesn't matter where you go, everyone will pay say five pound or whatever. But actually, we believe at the core of this it's got to be fair and proportionate. And so we ask ourselves, why should somebody visiting a guest house in Blackpool pay a flat fee in the way that somebody visiting the Ritz here in London would?
That's not fair, it's not proportionate, but actually a percentage rate is.
Andrew Snowden
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. First of all, we had a jobs tax which reduced the amount of jobs in the economy. Then we had a schools tax that reduced the amount of children in independent schools. Then we had a farms tax that reduced the number of family farms. So by that very core, that correlation, has the Minister and the Government learned anything from this socialist tax-addicted way they're governing the country, that the tourism tax will do anything other than reduce tourism?
Jim McMahon
I think what we learned was under the previous government, taxes were high at almost every turn, but people couldn't see the benefit of where that tax was going. And actually what people want to see desperately is that the country is turning a corner, that the investment that we collectively make in the taxes that we pay, whether that's at a national level, a regional level, or at a local level through our councils, will ultimately mean that the places that we care about are improved as a result. This is one way to do it.
Christopher David Ward
Chris Ward.
Speaker, look, it's absolutely right that local communities get to decide whether to introduce this levy or not. That's a key part of devolution. But I am concerned about the pressures already on the hospitality and tourism sector, which is a very important part of my Brighton Kemptown constituency. We've already seen the closure of two iconic LGBTQ bars, Charles Street Tap and R-Bar in Brighton Kemptown seafront. And frankly, I'm worried that more face closure.
So will the minister reassure me the action the government's taking to support the sector, and would he consider taking a trip to the seaside with the Secretary of State to meet with local businesses and local hospitality sectors to hear what more this government can do?
Jim McMahon
Well, this is definitely the benefit of a wider ministerial brief. I don't just get bus councils, I also get invites to seaside towns as well, which is good news. Just on the issues of pressure, I don't think anybody underestimates just how difficult it is if you're in hospitality and leisure at the moment. These are not good times. But surely the way to grow is to invest, is to invest in that experience so that more people want to come to our towns and our cities, our seaside communities as well, because by growing that base and creating that demand because of the experience that we collectively improve, we believe that that creates a more sustainable visitor experience.
Matthew Stephen Darling
Mr. Speaker, tourists visiting Torbay already pay double the rate of VAT compared to those visiting Italy, France, or Spain. The reality is that this is just the wrong time in a cost-of-living crisis to implement a tourism tax. Can the minister please share what investigations he has made into the impact of the tourism tax, but also the impact or assurances that Airbnb operators will also pay their fair share?
Jim McMahon
He raises two important points there. The first one is the local impact assessment. Now, obviously this will be a devolved power, so it'll be down to the mayoral authorities or the foundation authorities as part of the consultation to undertake that impact assessment at a local level. And that will of course weigh up the concerns, but also the benefit of this new levy as well. And the point he makes very fairly about leveling the playing field, we couldn't have allowed a situation where our guesthouses and hotels are undercut by Airbnbs that aren't included in the scheme.
So this will apply right across the board, including to temporary lets, short-term lets like Airbnbs and others.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the overseas the visitor levy and the investment that that will bring to London's visitor economy. Has he been listening to London councils who want 50% of the money raised in the borough to return to the borough so that businesses know that that's going back to the things that they want to see, like Putney High Street cleaning? Thank you.
Lindsay Hoyle
Can I just help members who've been here a long time? Asking the minister is not how we do it. It's through the chair because that's how we try and keep the balance to make sure. Please, try and work this. We've only been here a few years, I know.
Minister.
Jim McMahon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The way that we have designed the policy is to allow as the most local flexibility as possible.
And that's recognizing that the approach in different places will require that flexibility to take into account their local circumstance. Now what that means in practice is it will be for local areas including London to decide how they want to invest the money that they come through the system. But our expectation is that there'll be partnership and collaboration between local government and our regional mayors where they exist and with the councils who are members of the foundation authorities in other places.
Desmond Swayne
Mr. Speaker, if the hoteliers of Bournemouth are gagging to pay this tax, I can assure the minister that hospitality in the New Forest is not. The minister said that everybody will be a winner. How can he possibly know when he can't tell us how much the tax will be or where it will be levied?
Jim McMahon
Because here we are setting out the principle, we're setting out the framework. And the framework instinctively is, if you grow and invest in greater footfall, in a better visitor experience, in putting on events and activities that draw people in, then actually the accommodation operators benefit from that increased footfall and those overnight stays as well. But staying as we are where some areas are really struggling to see investment that allows that growth to take place, there will be some places in the country that say we want to go further with the lever. And I think it's right that government as part of our devolution ambitions allows local places to make that call for their areas.
Rachael Maskell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recognize the pressure the hospitality sector in York is under. However, they are very clear that the levy raised in York must stay in York and not move into wider North Yorkshire. So will he ensure that it is hypothecated to the place where it is raised so it can be invested in the tourism industry and also ensuring wider services there to support hospitality and tourism as opposed to in other locations?
Jim McMahon
Well, I mean it will entirely decide how local leaders decide to design the scheme. And that will require conversations at a local level and it will require give and take, I would say. The only reflection I make, and this is a personal view, each area might approach it very differently, is if I think about the tourism economy in Greater Manchester where we are, of course everyone thinks about the city center of Manchester and how successful that is, and people might think about the rolling hills of Saddleworth and our villages and how beautiful that Pennine belt is. But actually if you're a visitor, you will pass between Oldham going to the two. And I think there's a thing around what are we doing here to invest in the whole so that the whole experience right across our regions sees the benefit of that.
But again, these are local decisions.
Richard Tice
Great news, Mr. Speaker. Yes, the reform mayors of Hull and East Yorkshire and Greater Lincolnshire have confirmed there will be no dreadful tourist tax in their respective areas. Therefore holidaymakers should come to these great areas to save money. Does the minister guarantee that as many areas refuse to impose this ludicrous tax that he and the government will not be tempted to impose a tourist tax nationally?
Jim McMahon
Well, I think in a way he embraces devolution, which is for local leaders to make the call for their areas and to present their record to the public. And I think that works both ways, of course, for mayors and foundation authorities that want to introduce the levy, they'll need to make the case and the success of that will need to be presented to the public when they come to vote. That's about that direct accountability. But equally I'll say for those that decide not to do it, if tourism stagnates, if they're not able to improve that visitor experience, then equally accountability works both ways.
Alice Hobbs
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Oxford's a great place to visit. I hope many members will enjoy it indeed and come to my great city. And many tourists agree with that. One in every six pounds spent in the city center is spent by a visitor.
But while welcoming tourism, many local residents and businesses do recognize it does cause additional costs. They want to see a levy. They've told me they want to see a levy to improve the local environment for tourists and for local people. So will the minister move ahead, persuade Oxfordshire County Council to back a mayoral strategic authority so we can get on with this? Thank you.
Jim McMahon
Well, we are ambitious on our devolution program to see devolution do two things. Of course, widen across the country, and I welcome the champion that she's doing for a mayor in her region. And also, of course, to deepen, to make sure that when mayors are in place, they have the tools and the levers to get the job done. And we are absolutely up for local conversations to progress it. Thank you.
Joe Jones.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Now, as you're well aware, five million people visit the beautiful East Yorkshire coastline every year, so any potential tourism tax would have a devastating effect on the local economy. Now, the Minister says this is a framework, there's more work to do. So where there are larger mayoral areas, for example, in my own area in East Yorkshire and Hull, can he guarantee that any money raised in a town like Bridlington or Hornsea is spent there and not spent in a larger conurbation such as the city of Hull, and make sure that is a national framework for any mayor who wishes to introduce such a tourist tax?
Jim McMahon
Well, it sounds certainly for the foreseeable future that there's no intention to introduce a tourism overnight visitor levy in that area. Well, who knows, there may well be a change of heart, let's say, in the future. Listen, in the spirit of devolution, I don't think it's right for a government to impose terms and conditions and in a way that binds local areas doing what they instinctively believe is right for their area. But equally, they'll have to present the plan through the consultation, they'll have to do the impact assessment, and they'll need to get local agreement to do that. And surely the best democratic, if you like, accountability framework are elections.
And the thing about mayors is that they are directly elected and accountable to the voting public.
Harry Bow.
Perran Moon
Whereas, Mr. Speaker, as a Cornish MP, I'm incredibly proud that this government was elected on a platform of devolution. That means trusting in the decisions of local authorities to raise an overnight levy or not. And I appreciate parties opposite don't trust their local authorities to do so, but no one is forcing these local authorities to raise the levy. So does the Minister agree with me that fiscal devolution is an essential aspect of moving powers and funding out of this place and directly into the hands of local people?
Jim McMahon
I think all of those are really important points, and the member is a fantastic champion for Cornwall and the economy there. And he also recognizes that there is local partnerships here that are developing that are really marshaling around devolution in quite an interesting way. And because of the representation that he and others have made, we have included the foundation strategic authorities, so you don't just need a mayor in place to get this done. But actually, the wider growing out here of fiscal devolution, I think, is really exciting. You know, if you believe in devolution, you can't have devolution if you haven't got the resources to actually get things done in the local area.
So business rate retention, income tax retention, and the overnight visitor levy are the first steps in that package of fiscal devolution that we've been waiting quite a long time for.
Manuela Perteghella
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Stratford-upon-Avon is one of the country's most important visitor destinations, attracting millions of visitors each year to support local businesses, theaters, heritage attractions, and jobs across my constituency. The APPG Hospitality and Tourism, of which I'm a member, in its inquiry heard evidence that a five percent visitor levy could reduce tourism spending and employment. Therefore, will the Minister commit to ensuring that any future levy is subject to meaningful consultation with the sector, with the local residents, and to the transparent ring-fencing of revenues for investment in our local area?
Jim McMahon
I think the honourable member makes a really important point here that through the work of the APPG, where time has been spent diligently going through the arguments for and against and what the benefits might be, for many who look at this, they see this as a big prize in terms of being able to invest back into the local economy. And any evidence that they've gathered through the APPG, I'd be pleased to receive.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome this step towards devolution, but York and North Yorkshire is a huge mayoral authority. In order for my constituents to feel the difference, we must ensure that money generated in Scarborough and Whitby is spent locally and not in the city of York. Will the minister consider what he can do to ensure that locally generated revenue benefits the communities that produce it?
Jim McMahon
Mr. Speaker, you know full well it takes a brave Lancashire soul to interfere in Yorkshire politics on this. But surely that is the spirit of devolution, isn't it, that it will be for local areas to decide? And as I said, I spent summer in North Yorkshire near Richmond and had a fantastic experience. But I'd also say, you know, when you think about access to public transport and that wider visitor experience, there is no part of the country that wouldn't benefit from more investment.
Joe Robertson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I think the government's plans for a tourist tax will be terrible for the visitor economy, terrible for jobs, terrible for spend on the high street. The minister thinks it'll be great. We can clear all this up, Madam Deputy Speaker. We can clear it up if the minister will include in his visitor economy growth strategy a full analysis of his plans and publish it before he brings in his detrimental tourist tax.
Jim McMahon
Well, he seems to be getting ahead of the review that he just asked for in a sense and predetermining that this somehow isn't a positive measure. Listen, because this is a framework and it's about devolved powers, clearly the impact assessment has to be done within the areas where this is being introduced. Until you know where it's being introduced, you can't do a national assessment of its impact by the nature of it.
Christopher Murray
I don't understand the... The Edinburgh Festival and Fringe in my constituency are world-class tourist attractions, and I know that the House understands this because I've bumped into about half of members in August. Edinburgh is the third biggest ticketed event in the world after the FIFA World Cup and the Olympics. And this summer, Edinburgh became the first place in the UK to implement a city-wide visitor levy of 5%, which will raise 50 million pounds to invest in the local economy to benefit tourists and locals. And this year, despite the implementation of it, we actually saw ticket sales increase by 8%.
Now, it's still a work in progress, but will the minister meet me and officials from Edinburgh to understand our learnings from the visitor levy, and we're welcome to invite any skeptics as well?
Jim McMahon
I'd be pleased to do that. And in a sense, this does stand in stark contrast to what we've heard from members opposite, because in places like Manchester too, where there is a voluntary scheme through the BID, you know, there is an agreement there that actually if we have money to invest in that visitor experience, in putting on events that draw even greater footfall in, that in the end everyone benefits from that. So the evidence base that he talks about, I'd be very happy to receive.
Adam Dance
Adam Dodd.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Those in hospitality across Yeovil have told me how a tourism tax will impact jobs, growth, and our high streets. We actually want to encourage tourism in our area, not decrease it. So what steps is the minister taken to strengthen support for rural hospitality, and will he meet with the sector and I to talk about how we can boost tourism in rural Somerset, because we need a commitment that local residents and businesses will be consulted before any decision is made?
Jim McMahon
Well, when he says this measure will impact on jobs, growth, and high streets, we believe it will, in a positive way. Because if we create more demand by increased footfall through better investment and visitor experience, that will create more jobs and more growth.
If we have money to invest in our places, in particular our town centers and our high streets, that will be better not just for visitors, but for people who live there. And this policy can't be seen just in isolation. Think about the, you know, millions that's being spent now on pride in place, on our high streets fund and more investment, I should say, still to come where we're really now reinvesting back into many parts of the country that have been neglected.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was going to start by making a joke about always being picked last, but you've ruined it because you picked me early on, so thank you for that. I'll try it anyway. I'm used to getting picked last in this place, but I was actually picked first when the new Prime Minister made his first visit to Harlow and in fact my local, where I had the opportunity to talk to Miss McMullen, the head of McMullen's breweries. He said this government is doing more to support the pub trade than the previous one did.
But can I ask the Secretary of State, ask him about how this has been, this tourist levy has been put in place in other countries in the G7 where it has been very successful and what learning he's done from other countries?
Jim McMahon
Well, as I say, members will know from their summer holidays, if you go to America or to Europe or almost everywhere else in the world, you will pay some form of a local sales tax or a visitor overnight accommodation levy. That is generally accepted as part and parcel of going away. The difference here, I suppose, is that we just didn't believe that a flat rate would be fair or proportionate for the reasons that I set out before. It's got to be in line with the overnight rate that people are paying to make sure that low cost family accommodation remains as such.
Judith Cummins
We've got two further UQs, a statement and lots of business. Let's try and keep questions short and answers. Sir Julian Lewis.
Julian Lewis
If the New Forest and Waterside were forced into a unitary authority dominated by Southampton and Eastleigh, what chance would there be of local authorities looking after the interests of rural areas?
Jim McMahon
Well, obviously this will be led in his case by the mayoral strategic authority and it will be for that authority to do the consultations, to carry out the impact assessment and importantly to decide on the investment plan.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Southall Broadway attracts wedding shoppers from across the globe, so local businesses welcome the overnight visitor levy as a great opportunity to get investment in the town center. However, unlike other mayoral areas, London is not a combined authority. What can the Minister do to ensure this is reflected in the design of the levy in London so that the Mayor and London boroughs can jointly shape how it operates and places like Southall don't lose out just because they're in London?
Jim McMahon
Well, obviously we accept, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the London devolution settlement is different than elsewhere in England because of the relationship between the Mayor with executive powers and the GLA as a directly elected body. But there is an expectation that all partners, including local authorities, GLA and the Mayor, will work together in partnership on this and other measures.
John Glen
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Nine years ago, when I was the tourism minister, I resisted the English holiday tax. And what concerns me now for Salisbury, where I see people like Brian Curry investing millions of pounds in the Cathedral Hotel, the impact it will have on domestic tourists, people in this country who can't afford to go abroad will now be burdened with additional costs to have a few days away in England.
Has the minister understood the distribution of the burden of this tax and the impact it will have on people in this country?
Jim McMahon
Well I think he makes the case here about why the percentage rate approach is so important. It's fair to say that there are large parts of our tourism economy that provide that low cost but good quality family experience and actually a percentage rate means that they will pay proportionally less than, you know, hotels here in the capital and I think that's right and proper. And it will be a requirement that all areas will carry out an impact assessment to understand the impact on their local economies and then also to present where the investment will go afterwards.
Charles Noah Law
Madam Deputy Speaker, any devolution of powers, investment or fiscal policy down to Cornwall is welcome, which is why I'm pleased our government is progressing ahead to give us the powers to raise a visitor levy, whether or not Cornwall Council should choose to go ahead and utilize that levy. But as you might expect representing an area with a significant visitor economy, it's my expectation that that money not only be invested well, but that it is done to support the common goods on which businesses in that sector and the communities they operate in rely on. So can the minister assure me that the manner in which the levy will be raised remains flexible so local leaders can use it in a way that's appropriate to the area and it doesn't just recycle back into Cornwall Council?
Jim McMahon
I think that's the key and in a sense some of the tensions in Parliament are here today, are parliamentarians who want to know the absolute detail as applied across the country. But that isn't devolution. Devolution is allowing local flexibility and for local leaders to make those choices in the way that he says.
Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The minister has referenced several times that other European countries have a tourist tax. Yet those countries, as the honorable member for Torbay highlighted, have much lower tax rates overall for hospitality. So will he commit to reducing VAT on hospitality? And secondly, on the tourist tax, will he clarify if the levy will be listed separately to the price of the room so that there is clarity and transparency for those who are using those facilities?
Jim McMahon
We're obviously still working through the detail about the collection process and the reporting process and part of that consideration will be the presentation on the bills. But let's not forget the 20% support that we're introducing for business rates for pubs and live music venues as a first start at supporting hospitality in the round.
Josh Newbury
Madam Deputy Speaker, I recently had the pleasure of visiting the Beaudesert Outdoor Activity Centre in Cannock Wood, which welcomes 50,000 young people a year, including scouts, guides and schools and gives them memories to last a lifetime. They're a charity, they keep charges low and they worry about anything that could make their offer cost prohibitive to cash-strapped groups. So given this government's commitment to expanding life chances and experiences for young people, could I ask the minister to consider exempting groups of under-18s to make sure that these incredibly valuable experiences don't become less affordable for our young people?
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure many of my constituents considering a UK break will look to Cambridgeshire where the always fiscally sound Conservative mayor Paul Bristow has made it very clear that now is not the time for such a tax. But for the rest of the country, hospitality businesses will be frightened by this. We've already got two pubs closing a day and businesses are struggling to get by under the tax burden of this government. So how low does tourism have to dip in this country or how many businesses go bust before the Treasury tells this minister that this tourist levy must go?
Jim McMahon
Well in the spirit of devolution, if the mayor believes that's the right decision for their area, then obviously the government will stand in support of that. But to be clear, there was not a good period under the last Conservative government for our pubs and hospitality. I think about the rate of closures of our community pubs and our town centre pubs and our city centre pubs at a rate of knots. Now what we're trying to do is say that decline is not inevitable and actually government working in partnership with our regions and our councils can begin to turn that around.
Danny Beales
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Millions of people move through Hillingdon visiting the country and the city of London every year going to Heathrow, travelling through and also staying at the hotels near the airport. It creates real costs for local communities around policing, around street cleaning, around transport impacts and those are the threats to the tourist economy that need funding. So I support this measure. But can the minister assure me that those issues which are often locally driven and funded will also get support in a mayoral-led system?
Jim McMahon
Well it'll be for a local area to determine how they're going to frame both the levy and the investment. And in the case of London, obviously the mayor working with the GLA, there is an expectation that councils will be collaborated with and that there'll be some agreement on how that might work in practice. But as I say it's for local area to work through that detail.
Mark Pritchard
Madam Deputy Speaker, we now have a minister for euphemism because let's be clear, this is not a visitor levy. It is a tax on tourism, a tax on the staycation, a tax on hospitality, a tax on the family holiday and a tax on hospitality jobs and a tax on mobility and the worst sin of all, a tax on Shropshire. So can I say that Shropshire tourism rejects this tax whenever it might come directly or indirectly. Is it not another case, an example Madam Deputy Speaker, of this government being addicted to raising taxes?
Jim McMahon
The only thing that we're determined to do is to make sure one, that devolution means something and that means that local leaders have got to be given the actual tools to do the job at a local level. But it's also a determination not to accept that the decline of our towns and our cities and our rural communities is inevitable after our experience under the previous government. We think there's a different way.
Luke Davis.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Many people visit Derbyshire because it has beautiful scenery and fascinating history but those visitors do provide a strain on our infrastructure. So I do think it is reasonable that we explore whether we continue to ask local people to foot the bill for that. But I recently visited Drum Hill Scout Camp in my constituency. It welcomes many thousands of young people from quite far afield to learn absolutely fantastic life skills.
And I've also engaged with organisations that provide respite holidays for disabled people. I know local leaders can decide how to shape the legislation locally but can we provide an exception for those kind of groups on the face of this bill?
Jim McMahon
As I said before in response to a similar question, he makes a very fair point about that type of accommodation. And also to reflect that for the work of Claire Ward as the mayor of that region, there is a lot of focus now on creating jobs and good jobs and also for that to be in the spirit of devolution where they want just more control over what happens in their areas. And this measure alongside business rate retention, alongside income tax retention, is beginning to readdress that balance.
Ben Obese-Jecty.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. In Cambridgeshire, the Conservative mayor Paul Bristow decided not to implement this tourism tax. And that's incredibly important because we've recently adopted the local visitor economy partnership as we seek to make gains from the creation of Universal Studios just down the road. And I know that my honourable friend the member for Mid Bedfordshire is also looking to bring in an LVEP in Bedfordshire too. But why does the minister think that a tax like this would benefit somewhere like Cambridgeshire when we clearly don't think that it will?
And what else is he doing to try and support communities like mine in Huntingdon where we are looking to build a visitor economy to take advantage of the opportunities that somewhere like Universal Studios can bring?
Jim McMahon
Well obviously it's this government that has given support to Universal Studios because of the economic benefit that that's going to bring. And also of course it just being a nice place for visitors across the country to be able to go to and enjoy that. And that will have a wider impact on the local economy that will benefit hospitality, leisure and accommodation providers too. In response to the kind of place-based investment that he talks about, obviously this government has an ambition to make sure that every town centre, every high street, realises its full potential and that also needs investment too.
And you'll see that not just in his own place but right across the country.
Elsie Blundell.
Elsie Blundell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the proud Member of Parliament for Heywood and Middleton North in Greater Manchester, I too want to see the prosperity of the centre flow out into towns like mine that are just as deserving of economic development and cultural regeneration. Does the Minister agree with me that extending further revenue-raising powers to our mayors will accelerate the regeneration that we need to see in constituencies like mine and his just as much as the city centre itself?
Minister.
Jim McMahon
And I think she's a fantastic champion for her place and she also recognizes that within our city regions as much as anywhere else, every community has a role to play. She will know the fantastic work that's done by the Middleton Arena, in fact as a fantastic venue. But with more investment and more footfall, all of our places, Middleton to Oldham and Greater Manchester can do even more.
Caroline Voaden.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As vice-chair of the APPG for Hospitality and Tourism, I have sat through several evidence sessions on this visitor levy and I have yet to hear any operator in the sector say that they support it. So I really don't understand who the Minister has been talking to. The caravan park operator who said if numbers go down in the off-season they will only be able to be open in high season, which has a knock-on effect on jobs, on the local pub, the local cafe, it has a ripple effect across the local economy. The Minister talks about growth and we need growth in the sector because young people primarily are employed in hospitality, they're vital jobs for young people.
So could the Minister tell me in what world he sees the tourism and hospitality industry growing under this visitor levy?
Jim McMahon
Well, for the reasons that I stated many times before, that if we grow and invest in our economy when it comes to tourism and hospitality, that will generate more footfall, people will enjoy the stay more and that will create more jobs including for young people.
Alice Khan.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Parents requiring hotel stays while their four-month-old daughter has neurosurgery, a new mother requiring a hotel stay to recover from a pulmonary embolism, both of these would incur a tax for a stay they wish they didn't have to do. This isn't a hypothetical, I was both. So will the Minister please mandate now from the dispatch box that anyone seeking medical treatment for themselves or their children, which can sometimes be months at a time at Great Ormond Street, will not have such a tax imposed on them and their families?
Minister.
Jim McMahon
I can certainly commit to looking into it and to respond to the honourable member in writing.
Richard Foord.
John Richard Foord
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Businesses from Devon have told me of their concern about this proposed visitor levy, including Little Court Cottages in Sidmouth. They point out that the tourist footfall might fall, not just for the cottages but for the restaurants, the attractions and the shops in the local area. This tax has been dreamt up on the basis of what it would do for cities that see a high proportion of wealthy overseas visitors, has it not?
Minister.
Jim McMahon
Well, I mean, of course it hasn't because one, devolution will be rolled out across the whole of the country and there are already significant rural areas that are covered by mayoral strategic authorities. It will include foundation strategic authorities which obviously covers places like Cornwall and other places. And as part of the next stage of devolution, we are seeing a grow-out across the south of England and the east of England that will see more coverage too. But fundamentally, it's for local leaders and local mayors to get together and work out what's right for their area.
Jacob Young.
Matt Vickers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. At the weekend I had the pleasure of joining Cleveland Scouts and seeing first-hand the fantastic work scouting does to give young people confidence, practical skills, friendships and opportunities they might not otherwise have. Can the Minister reassure those young people and their families that this government isn't seriously proposing to tax a scout for pitching a tent and confirm that scout camps and other charitable youth residentials will be exempt from his holiday tax?
Minister.
Jim McMahon
Well, as I say, that I'm as in line with a number of questions that have been asked about that youth experience accommodation and I've committed to go away and look at that.
Final question, Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of my constituents in Strangford and across Northern Ireland travel to the United Kingdom for a home-based holiday. The weather is almost as good as it is in the Mediterranean. They pay for their flights or they take their vehicles on the ferry, already paying a high fee to support tourism in the United Kingdom. So why should my constituents, British constituents, be penalised twice for supporting and buying into a British holiday?
What steps will the Minister take to ensure that those in Northern Ireland are not discouraged from contributing to having a home-based holiday in England?
Jim McMahon
For the same reason that everybody would pay the levy, which is that they would benefit from the improved experience, both in terms of what they experience in the immediate area, but also the type of events and activities that might draw people across here too. And so we believe, where local leaders decide this is right for their places, that that wider benefit will be felt by people to enjoy.
Judith Cummins
That is the end of the urgent question on tourism overnight visitor levy. If the front bench wish to shuffle over. If colleagues could be seated. Urgent question, Tim Farron.
Timothy James Farron
To ask the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero if she will make a statement on the implications of the closure of the Saudi East-West oil pipeline for UK energy security, fuel prices and global oil supply, and on the steps the Government is taking in response.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, the United Kingdom strongly condemns the Houthis' decision to resume conflict in Yemen and their recent attacks on Saudi Arabia, including the targeting of civilian and energy infrastructure. We offer our condolences to those injured and affected and stand with Saudi Arabia, the internationally recognised Government of Yemen, and our partners in the region. I know my Right Honourable Friend the Foreign Secretary has spoken with his Saudi counterpart, as has the National Security Adviser. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are closely monitoring the situation as part of our overall response to the situation in the Middle East and disruption to the Strait of Hormuz.
Saudi authorities confirmed over the weekend that the East-West oil pipeline is temporarily closed following an attack on the 11th of September. The Saudi Government has not yet provided further information on the duration of the closure. The pipeline enables Saudi crude oil to bypass the Strait of Hormuz, and since the start of the Middle East conflict, it has been used to reroute a significant share of exports. This temporary pause comes at a time of rising prices, and I know that many in this House and the public will be worried about the potential impacts. Fuel supplies to the UK have remained resilient since the start of the conflict.
As people across the country would expect us to do, the Government will mitigate where possible the potential impacts on our economy and on our domestic security, and we will continue working closely with industry and with devolved governments on detailed contingency planning for all events. We are working tirelessly, Madam Deputy Speaker, with our international partners to find a permanent solution to the conflict and minimise the knock-on impact on households, and we will keep looking at what more we can do to insulate families from the effect of rising energy bills.
Timothy James Farron
Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for his reply. Saudi's closure of the 1,200-kilometre East-West pipeline is a massive blow. This is the pipeline that allowed Saudi Arabia to export millions of barrels of crude a day and has been the key alternative route to the Strait of Hormuz since Donald Trump's war led to that regular closure.
It has predictably led to further increases in already high oil prices, 106 dollars per barrel just today. With reports that Saudi Arabia could exhaust crude available for export within days unless that pipeline resumes operation. So the consequences are huge for my constituents and everybody else's, already paying through the nose for fuel as a result of the war in Iraq, now being hit by even higher prices because of this. Rural communities relying on heating oil are especially vulnerable to shortages and price hikes. The impact on farmers and food production could do further damage to the UK's food security.
Tragic reality is that whilst the UK will struggle if the pipeline is not reopened, it could mean starvation for millions on the African continent. The latest crisis puts a further spotlight on our failure as a country to be energy secure. Even those few people, Madam Deputy Speaker, that are not yet convinced that climate change is real and needs tackling, surely now understand that energy security really, really matters. Neither Houthi rebels, nor Putin, nor Iran, nor Trump can turn off our waves, wind, sunshine or nuclear industry. It's time for siren voices to stop whining about wokery and start focusing on security.
So I ask the Minister, what reserves of oil does the United Kingdom have? Will the Government accelerate domestic energy generation? Will the Government implement a 10p temporary fuel duty cut, cuts in bus and rail fares so that people in Cumbria and across the country are not plunged into further hardship as a result of this crisis? What plans has he to accelerate the Warm Homes Plan, which sadly has only insulated 0.3% of the expected homes this year, especially in communities like mine where a quarter of our housing stock was built before 1900 and in need of more bespoke solutions? And then what will he do to bring an energy price cap onto heating oil?
And extra what will he explain he's doing with our allies in the Middle East and NATO to ensure the pipeline reopens as soon as possible?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honourable gentleman for the question and for bringing the question to the House. I'll endeavour to answer all of those points, but if there's any that I don't answer, I'll follow up with them in writing. To start with the discussions that the Government have been having with the Saudi authorities, the Foreign Secretary spoke to the Saudi Foreign Minister on Sunday and we will keep talking to the Saudi Arabian authorities to understand exactly what the impact of this might be and what the plans from that Government are. As he'll know, we have a diverse and resilient supply of energy in this country and that is something that we continue to stand by and we are not at this moment in time concerned about the impact on supply for the UK.
He also spoke about heating oil. I think he'll know we've had conversations about this in the past. The Government have already provided 53 million pounds in support to local authorities in order to assist those people who were particularly hard hit in March when the cost of heating oil increased significantly. And we of course will be looking through the autumn and into the winter about what support might be necessary to go further. But I know in some local authority areas that money has not been nearly exhausted yet and I would encourage local authorities to be using the funding that is available to them to support those on heating oil.
I think he's made a really important point towards the end of his question there about our reliance on foreign sources of oil and gas. And I think it's a really important point that members in the opposition fail to seem to grasp, even though they used to grasp it when they were in Government, that we need to move away as quickly as possible from the rollercoaster of fossil fuels and actually produce energy in this country that we control, where we control the security and the supply. And just finally to address his point around the Warm Homes Plan, he'll know that we've committed 15 billion pounds to the Warm Homes Plan and we are and have been pushing for more of that funding to reach communities. We're already delivering that through the Warm Homes Local Grant and the Warm Homes Social Housing Fund and we'll be coming forward in the coming weeks with more schemes for the for people across the country to take advantage of that scheme.
Joseph Ronald Morris
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I echo the honourable gentleman on heating oil and the concern that I have for rural communities in my constituency? Does this not demonstrate the urgency of moving away, as the Minister said, from unstable oil from unstable parts of the world, the need to double down on domestic production of renewables, not just in generating energy but also in our capacity to produce renewable renewable capacity? Would the Minister join me on a visit to Hums of Net Zero to see some community energy projects in my constituency that have already got widespread public support and are doing more to generate in Northumberland?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honourable member for his honourable friend for his comments and I would be happy to join him on a visit in his constituency in the future. He is right that we do need to double down on clean power. We do need to make sure that we have our own sources, renewable sources of energy where we control both the price and the supply. And this event once again shows why that is the right course to be pursuing for the country's energy security and for our national security.
Andrew Bowie
Shadow Secretary of State, Andrew Bowie.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Speaker, the ongoing events in the Middle East have quite rightly brought the state of Britain's energy security back to the forefront. We're witnessing growing geopolitical instability and it is having and will continue to have a direct impact on our energy security, supplies and of course bills. The attack on the Saudi East-West pipeline will exacerbate this. 4% of global oil supply flows through that pipeline.
That is not insignificant. Saudi Arabia is a key strategic friend and ally of this country. Our relationship is integral to the security of the region and our national interest. So I would be grateful if the Minister could outline what discussions he or the Secretary of State for Energy have had with their Saudi counterparts regarding security of supply and if the UK government has offered any support in this regard. We do not know when the pipeline will once again be operational and Saudi oil stocks, as has already been said, for export could be depleted within days.
With the safety of navigation through the Straits of Hormuz remaining uncertain, the continued squeeze on energy supplies will only get tighter. Brent crude has reached 106 dollars a barrel this morning and shows no sign of slowing. And it is exactly because of this situation that I cannot understand the government's actions. Because ironically, Madam Deputy Speaker, today should have been the day this government announced they were finally going to approve the Jackdaw gas field. But they have bottled it.
They've put it on ice because they are too scared of Zack Polanski and the Green Party in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are talking today about national security and the government is putting party before country. Great Britain has become increasingly and dangerously over-reliant on supplies of oil from overseas. We could be reducing some of that reliance right now by drilling and making use of our own resources, be it oil from Rosebank or gas from Jackdaw. This is a moment of great geopolitical uncertainty.
It is a moment when all countries around the world are looking to ensure and shore up their energy supply. No other government of no other nation would make such a brazenly craven decision to chase votes in a by-election ahead of its duty to defend our national and our energy security. So given the seriousness of this moment, given the threats to our energy and indeed national security, will the government change course on their position on the North Sea?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Foreign Secretary and the National Security Advisor have both spoken to the Saudi Foreign Minister. We'll continue to have engagements between the UK government and the government in Saudi Arabia on this issue and officials across government are collaborating on this topic. He would expect me he wouldn't expect me to come here and to comment on a quasi-judicial process, which is what Jackdaw and Rosebank is. And when the and when the honourable member stands at the dispatch box and he, you know, throws this the responsibility for this to this government, which we will make a decision in due course on that on those consents, we are in this mess because he because they did not conduct this process appropriately in the first instance and we were then subject to a judicial review.
So we will not rush this process. We will do this process properly in order to ensure the best outcome for people across the country and for workers in the North Sea. And I would say to him, he knows that oil and gas will be part of our energy mix for years to come. And I have said to him before at this dispatch box and I will say it again: stop talking down our North Sea oil and gas industry.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We live in an interconnected world and the events that happen in Saudi Arabia do have a direct impact on my constituents in Harlow, particularly those who are concerned about the rising price of their energy bills. Can I ask the Minister what he's doing to ensure we are not reliant on international fossil fuels? And we have to accept that the green energy solution is part of that solution. And can I also ask him what he's going to do as much as he can to support residents in my constituency of Harlow to bring their bills down?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Pay tribute to him for his continued, continued advocacy for his constituents across Harlow. He will know that we have a clean power mission and the reason we've got that clean power mission is to make sure that we have renewable sources of generation where we control the supply and the price of energy. And on the support for his constituents on their energy bills across the winter, we are obviously looking at what, what support might be on offer. But what I would say is that the Prime Minister obviously in his first week removed VAT from electricity bills from October, which I think will be welcome to his constituents in addition to the 150 pounds from energy costs that was removed at the last budget.
Edward Leigh
The honorable member for Westmorland and Lonsdale is a lovely man, but I just can't follow his logic. In one breath he says that the solution is to pursue green energy, which is fair enough in the long term, and the next, very next sentence, he says that what are our oil reserves? So surely it's not a zero-sum game. It'll be decades before we're reliant entirely on green energy. Will the Minister, I'm not going to ask him to comment on Jackdaw and Rosebank and all that, does he accept that we have to pursue oil drilling in the North Sea to make us reliant and get us out of this crisis?
Speaker 151
Thank, I thank the Father of the House for his question. And what I would say to him is that we are still, you know, extracting oil and gas from the North Sea. We have a supply coming from the North Sea every day and we have, we have that energy mix. And oil and gas will continue to play a part in our energy mix for years to come. So on that point and the mix, I agree with the Father of the House.
But we also can't lose sight of the fact that that is a declining basin and has been a declining basin for a very, for a very long time. And, you know, the honorable, the honorable gentleman is chuntering from a sedentary position. It was under his government that we saw numbers decline in terms of the numbers of people working in the North Sea. And we know that there is a, that it is a declining basin and we have to prepare for the transition. And that is what any responsible government would do.
And that is why we're investing so much in renewables across the country.
Claire Louise Young
Madam Deputy Speaker, given the ongoing risks to energy security illustrated by this latest incident, should the government be prioritizing EN6 sites like Oldbury in my constituency to supply the grid rather than private wire arrangements that don't support local industry?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The, you know, the choice of sites is obviously one for, is a national decision and involving NISO and Ofgem and through which we have, we have limited role. But what I would say is it is important that we have the diverse energy mix across the country, including renewables, in order that we have the most secure and resilient supply of energy in this country.
Douglas Lumsden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The parties that are talking down the North Sea oil and gas workers are the Labour government here and the SNP government in Holyrood. The Conservative Party are standing up for the North Sea oil and gas workers. And when I quizzed the Prime Minister on approving Jackdaw and Rosebank, he said, and I quote, that he would take a pragmatic approach and we would see that in action soon. But now we hear that there are further delays because the Labour Party want to save face in a central London by-election.
At a time when our energy security is at risk, will the government put national interests above interests of the Labour Party and approve Jackdaw and Rosebank as a matter of urgency?
Speaker 151
Let me take that in two parts. The first thing I would say is that this is obviously a decision that has to be taken carefully, where the Secretary of State has to has to make an assessment and a judgment, and they the honourable member will know that the evidence the evidence has to come to the Secretary of State for her to make that judgment, and that is what she will do in due course. He will also know that, as I said in response to an earlier question, that the North Sea basin is a declining basin. We have to prepare for the transition, and we are still extracting oil and gas from the North Sea, and that will continue for decades to come.
Adam Dance.
Adam Dance
Adam Deputy Speaker, residents in rural parts of Yeovil continue to raise concerns with me about the rising cost of domestic heating oil due to the conflicts abroad. Prices have hit as much as one pound and ten p per litre sometimes. As the nights draw in and the winter comes around, can the minister set out what steps the government is taking to develop a price cap for heating oil, because just giving this money to local authorities is not good enough, it doesn't support everyone.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable gentleman will know, and I'm sure he's seen the CMA report that was published before the recess into heating oil and the recommendations from the CMA in terms of the actions that we should take on heating oil, and we are studying those recommendations and will have a government response to them in due course. The CMA did raise concerns about the impact, though, of a potential price cap in that this is a this is obviously a market that does not operate in the same way as the traditional gas and electricity market, and we would need to carefully consider the potential perverse impacts that might be a result of something like a straightforward price cap. But there are there are other recommendations within the CMA report that, as I said, we are looking at and closely studying to make sure that people who have been affected by those increases in heating oil are are protected. The previous Prime Minister was very, very clear that the heating oil market was not working in the way that it should, and that is something that I would agree with, and I look forward to publishing the government response soon.
Julian Lewis
Sir Julian Lewis.
Well, as the minister seems to have run out of supportive backbenchers, I shall endeavour to ask him a helpful and easy question. So, accepting the fact that it will be some years, to put it mildly, before we can eliminate our dependence on oil and gas, does he accept in principle that we are more secure if we exploit our own domestic oil and gas reserves rather than relying on imports from the Middle East, which can so easily be blocked?
Speaker 151
Minister. Thank you. And as I've said in response to previous questions, we are exploiting the resources in the North Sea. We are extracting we are extracting oil and gas from the North Sea. We will make a decision on Rosebank and Jackdaw in due course, and we have a robust energy mix in this country.
But he has pointed he said it himself about the the reliance on overseas source of energy. We would still require production beyond beyond oil and gas, and that is why we're investing in renewables, whether that's wind or solar, all of which are helping to protect our energy security and our national security.
Richard Tice.
Richard Tice
Madam Deputy Speaker, we are so lucky in this great country that we enjoyed decades worth of oil and gas energy treasure. But we are so unlucky that we have an utterly clueless bunch of socialists not using this energy treasure. Will the Minister and this Government finally realize the way to reduce our exposure to overseas fossil fuels is to use our own offshore, onshore, the Falkland Islands? Let's get some growth, let's get some jobs, and let's grow the United Kingdom.
Minister.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I always enjoy it when Reform use socialist like it's a bad word and not a, not a badge of honor. Let me just, let me just come to, let me just come to this. This is, as I've said in response to previous questions, we are using the resources from the North Sea, extracting oil and gas on a daily basis, which is part of our energy mix and will be part of our energy mix for years to come.
Andrew Snowden
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister seems confused why the word socialism would be used in a negative context. It has something to do with the fact that every country that socialism touches, it destroys. And we have a prime example here. So if the Minister would take his head out of the sand and look at the member for Aberdeen South, who is sat here off the back of a stunning by-election win that was a referendum on that North Sea oil and gas issue, which shows the complete lack of confidence that industry has on the SNP in Scotland and Labour here.
It's time to drill, baby, drill.
Minister.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wasn't expecting to have an ideological debate on, on a Thursday, on a Tuesday afternoon. Look, I have said and I repeat again, we are using the resources from North Sea, oil and gas. We will continue to use it for decades to come. But if the party opposite want to put all of their eggs in one basket and reject the renewables generation that is coming from, it's coming from this country right now, that is a road to nowhere.
This is about energy security, it's about national security.
Vikki Slade.
Vikki Slade
Madam Deputy Speaker, follow that. Residents in Mid Dorset North Poole like my constituent Rhys have contacted me worried about the impact of this on, on his bills. He's shopped around, he's got a renewable-only tariff, he's insulated his home, and he's bought an electric car. And although he welcomes the VAT cut on electricity, he says the increase in the cap recently announced and the one he's now expecting in January will more than wipe it out. And he says throwing money at consumers doesn't deal with the huge profits or change supplier behavior.
So will the Secretary of State accelerate plans to fully and quickly decouple electricity prices for the whole from the wholesale price of gas?
Minister.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable lady for her question. We have obviously taken the VAT off of electricity bills from October. We took the 150 pounds out of cost last year. And I would also encourage, you know, her and any of her constituents who are struggling with their energy bills to also make sure that they are looking at the Warm Home Discount, which is obviously a further 150 pounds off energy bills.
We're obviously looking at what more we can do in terms of support through the autumn and winter. And we've already taken steps to start to decouple the price of energy from gas in as part of the previous administration and we'll continue to look at what more we can do in that area.
Mark Pritchard
Mark Pritchard.
Madam Deputy Speaker, can I just say to the Minister that the Houthis aren't going away and it's likely this is going to get worse as a crisis rather than better. On the 16th of March, the current Middle East Minister, previously in a different role in the Foreign Office, I said, I asked the question, what UK naval assets could be deployed to the region or were being deployed to the region, given it's pretty predictable at some point Tehran would put pressure on the Houthis to assist Tehran in its reign of terror in the region. So I ask again, what naval assets and what other military assets are being put in the region so we can safeguard British and partner and allied and NATO shipping and ensure that this crisis is minimized as much as it as we can. And finally, three of our Five Eyes partners have currently proscribed the Houthis as a terrorist organization. I don't expect the Minister to declare a proscription on the floor of the House, but can I ask if at least the Government is keeping it under review?
Minister.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think it's important to say at the outset that we stand firmly with our friends and allies in Saudi Arabia, who are the internationally recognized government of Yemen. I'm not going to be drawn on operational military questions of operational military activity, but what I would say is we're already obviously providing air defense support to Saudi Arabia through the defense partnership that we have, and we have a really long and proud history of supporting the defense of our partners and allies. And on the final question he asked, I'll commit to discuss that with Foreign Office officials and write to him.
Ann Celia Davies
Ann Davies. Diolch yn fawr, Madam Ddirprwy Lefarydd. Rural communities in Wales are being hit hard at the pumps. While the average price of unleaded petrol across Wales is just over 162 pence a liter, the very cheapest in Carmarthen is 165.9, so 166 pence a liter, with most forecourts of course charging more. Rural households do not have a choice but to drive, yet they are paying a premium simply because of where they live.
The government surely must step up and support these communities. So will the Secretary of State extend the rural fuel duty relief scheme to Wales to support households in rural areas?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable lady for her question. We have already put in place Fuel Finder, which I'm sure she's aware of, to provide real transparency to fuel prices in order to make sure that people are able to shop around for the cheapest fuel in their area, and it's our belief that that will help to drive down the cost of fuel. I would also point towards some of the other support that we've been offering to rural households. We've got the support for heating oil in place, which I'm sure many of her constituents have already taken advantage of.
And importantly, in home heating, to allow people to decarbonize and to move away from fossil fuel boilers, we've extended in England and in Wales the boiler upgrade scheme, adding an additional 1,500 pounds to a 9,000 pound grant for those who want to move onto a heat pump.
Joe Robertson
Jill Robertson. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Saudis' closure of the East-West oil pipeline and the continuing disruption in the Straits of Hormuz demonstrate just how important it is that the UK government issues new licenses to drill in the North Sea in our own British oil and gas reserves in order to provide national security, job security, and most importantly, reduce energy bills for hardworking families. Surely the Minister can understand that?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On that final point about reducing prices, more extraction of oil and gas from the North Sea will not reduce prices for consumers across the country. It won't reduce prices, and it will also keep us hooked on volatile fossil fuels. That is why we are moving to decarbonize our system with more renewables, more solar, more wind. But as I've said in response to other opposition members, we will continue to have oil and gas as part of our energy mix for decades to come.
John Richard Foord
Richard Foord. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The National Security Adviser Jonathan Powell has said Europe is going to experience real hardship this winter. We've seen the UK exposed repeatedly to energy shocks linked to volatile fossil fuel prices set on international markets: Russia-Ukraine, Strait of Hormuz, Bab-el-Mandeb, and now the Saudi East-West oil pipeline. Will the UK step up investment in clean, domestic renewable energy production as well as the grid to distribute it?
Speaker 151
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I think we've already had I think it's about a hundred billion of investment since 2024 into the into the UK in renewable energy and that's why it's so important. It's one of the fastest growing sectors of our economy and he is absolutely right that we need to be continuing with that investment in order to make sure that we move away from foreign sources of energy. And I would finally say that the comments from the National Security Advisor are you know are stark and you know we in this House and I think across this House will stand with Ukraine now and through the winter.
Jim Shannon
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and and thank the Minister for for those answers. The recent hostile attack by the Iranian-backed Houthis on critical Saudi pipeline infrastructure represents I believe a deeply concerning escalation that threatens not only regional stability but global energy policy as a serious attack. Can the Minister outline what specific steps the Government is taking with our international partners to bolster the maritime and the infrastructure of our allies in the Gulf and when will countermeasures to destroy Iranian-backed Houthi terrorists and murderers take place? The only thing that they understand is a strong response to stop state-sponsored aggression.
Speaker 151
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable gentleman will know that our priority is having free flow through the Strait of Hormuz and that's what we've been working on with our allies and partners globally and we'll continue to do that in order to try and alleviate this situation. I would also say to him that we are providing as I said in response to an earlier question air defence support to the Saudi government in this situation and obviously he wouldn't expect me to comment on detailed operational military issues but he can be reassured that you know we are providing those air defence supports and we will continue our discussions with the Saudi government.
Judith Cummins
That is the end of the urgent question on implications of closure of the Saudi East-West oil pipeline for UK energy security. If the Ministers wish to shuffle over we'll move on to our third urgent question. Right move on to the urgent question English whisky geographical indication single malt definition Wendy Chamberlain.
Wendy Chamberlain
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. To ask the Secretary of State for Environment Food and Rural Affairs if they will make a statement on the English whisky geographical indication single malt definition.
Minister.
Speaker 164
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The UK's whisky is a national treasure and it is rightly renowned across the world for its quality. Whisky supports jobs investment and growth across all four nations of the United Kingdom and showcases British expertise to consumers around the world. Scotch whisky is one of the greatest export successes and Welsh whisky and Irish whisky also enjoy protected status and strong international reputations. I'm pleased that English whisky has now joined that family of protected UK whisky geographical indications further strengthening the UK's four nations of whisky.
The registration of English whisky as a protected geographical indication or GI recognises it as a distinctive product with qualities and characteristics linked to the geographical origin. It reflects the growth of a dynamic sector with more than seventy distilleries now producing or maturing whisky and exports reaching thirty countries worldwide. This is also good news for local growth and British agriculture. Distilleries are supporting skilled jobs and attracting investment in regions across England while supporting British farmers by using British-grown grain.
We want to see that success continue. Turning to the specific decision before us, this followed the UK statutory geographical indication process. The application was assessed against the requirements set out in legislation and subject to an opposition process, allowing parties with a legitimate interest the opportunity to object. Those parties whose objections were considered admissible had the opportunity to consult with the applicant regarding their objections. Following careful consideration of the evidence, it was concluded that the application met the relevant legal requirements for registration.
Madam Deputy Speaker, let me be clear. This recognition does not alter the protected status, reputation, or production requirements of Scotch whisky, Welsh whisky, or Irish whisky. Nor does it alter the government's commitment to the whisky industry and its leading global success. Scotch whisky, one of the UK's most important food and drink exports. But Scotch whisky is far more than an export.
It is part of the culture, history, and identity of Scotland and of the United Kingdom. It is enjoyed at Burns Night celebrations, at family gatherings, and special celebrations, both at home and across the country. As I said, it is one of the great national treasures. I recently visited Glen Garioch, one of Scotland's oldest distilleries, where I was delighted to enjoy a wee dram and see firsthand the craftsmanship and heritage that make the Scotch whisky so famous across the world. The Secretary of State was speaking with SWA's chief executive only yesterday.
This government will continue to protect and champion the whole whisky industry: Scotch, Irish, Welsh, and English, both at home and in key exports around the world.
Wendy Chamberlain
Wendy Chamberlain.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I should declare an interest that I'm chair of the APPG for Scotch whisky, and I also hold an IBD general certificate in distilling. On Friday evening at 5:00 PM, Defra announced that it approved the English Whisky Guild's application for English whisky to receive geographical indication status, despite objections from the Scotch, Welsh, and Irish whisky associations. Let me be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, my objection is not to English whisky obtaining geographical indication status. English whisky has a long and legitimate history in its own right.
My concern is specifically about the definition of English single malt whisky that Defra has now approved. Under this definition, English single malt whisky only requires distillation at a single distillery rather than all the stages of the production taking place at a single site. The term single malt whisky carries a long-established reputation and meaning for consumers. It risks disadvantaging Scotch producers who've invested heavily to comply with the traditional single-site production model, and that includes distilleries in my own constituency such as Kingsbarns, Eden Mill, Daftmill, and Lindores. Scotch whisky is also one of the UK's most important export industries, supporting jobs, investment, tourism, and economic growth across rural communities.
Weakening an internationally recognized definition risks damaging consumer confidence and diluting brand value at a time when the Scotch whisky industry is not in the root health that I think the government mistakenly thinks that it is. This new definition could also be misleading for consumers who reasonably understand a single malt whisky to be a product produced entirely at one distillery. So I ask the minister, why was this announcement made after the House had risen on a Friday evening, and why the appeal period finishes before this House returns from recess? Can the minister explain why a decision that undermines the integrity of the single malt definition was approved, a decision that creates an uneven playing field across the UK and risks disadvantaging distilleries that have invested to uphold long-standing industry standards? Why did the Chief Secretary to the Treasury tell this House in March of last year, Defra will not be watering down the definition of single malt whisky, because I can assure you, Madam Deputy Speaker, that is exactly what they are doing.
Can the Minister also set out what discussion he has had with the Scotland and Wales offices and what assessment has been made of the implications of this decision for the UK internal market act and how were those implications considered? Thank you.
Speaker 164
May I stop by thanking the honorable member for her continued interest in these matters and for her leadership in the APPG for Scotch whisky. I know how important the Scotch whisky industry is to her constituents and communities across Scotland. Since taking up this role I've been keen to engage with the sector and I mentioned in my opening remarks the valuable visit I had to Aberdeenshire in August and I look forward to continuing to work with the APPG and the Scotch whisky industry and the wider sector as we continue. I must stress in response to the honorable member's questions that Scotch whisky's protected status, reputation, and production requirements are unchanged. The introduction of the English definition of single malt has no impact on how single malt is made in Scotland.
The government remains committed to supporting the success of the Scotch whisky industry and the wider UK whisky sector. She asks with regards to the decision-making process. I must stress again that this is a regulatory decision and a decision made by the Secretary of State. So let me assure her that this government remains absolutely committed to supporting and championing Scotch whisky at home and abroad. Nothing in this decision changes the protected status, reputation, or production requirements of Scotch whisky.
I'm very happy to meet the honorable member to discuss any further concerns that she may have.
Speaker 169
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I say that Scotch whisky is one of our great success stories and recognize that there are concerns from the Scotch Whisky Association about this proposed change. But I'm proud to have in my constituency Lochlea, a distillery on land which Robert Burns once farmed and I'm pleased that I played a small part in reducing whisky tariffs when I was the trade commissioner in Mumbai and that this government has continued to put Scotch whisky on the world stage through our very successful trade deals. I'm delighted, Madam Deputy Speaker, to see the member for Glenrothes and Kirkcaldy at her place on the front bench and will the Minister say that she, he, and the business department will do all they can to promote this great Scottish product around the world?
Speaker 164
Of course, and I thank my honorable friend for all the work that he does on trade matters. He speaks in this house with real authority on this issue. He will know that this government backs British businesses and we're keen to champion the Scotch whisky industry not only internally, both nationally, but also externally, internationally as well. And that has included securing a free trade deal with India and cut the costs to the US tariffs boosting export markets.
Harriet Iona Cross
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Across the country, businesses are under increasing pressure. Competition, cost of doing business, ever-increasing taxation and regulatory burdens are making it as hard as it has ever been for our rural businesses to get on. While I recognize that whisky producers and indeed farmers in the wider supply chain in England will welcome this announcement, those in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland are viewing it with concern. The whisky industry is a crucial sector in Scotland, supporting over 40,000 jobs, adding billions to our economy and showcasing great Scottish produce abroad.
Consistency in regulation is key across the UK. How is the government going to ensure that Scotch single malt whisky industry is not undermined by this decision? In particular, given that distilleries in England will not have to follow the same single-site production standards as distilleries in Scotland to get the single malt status. Has the Minister engaged with the Scottish government on this issue to ensure that the Scotch whisky industry is not put at a disadvantage because of this announcement? But Madam Deputy Speaker, a new designation for English whisky does not compensate for the hostile business environment being created by Labour.
The government is piling costs and regulation onto food and drink producers, including distilleries across the UK. The ever-increasing level of whisky duty, the exclusion of distilleries from the British industrial competitive scheme, and now the extended producer responsibility, which is going to add 1.4 billion pounds of cost to producers.
All of these mean that the government is making life ever more difficult for businesses struggling to keep their head above water. The huge and growing cost of doing business is making it difficult for businesses to survive, especially in rural areas. So what steps is the government going to take to ensure that these mounting costs, especially for food and drink producers, are not going to mean that we see more and more businesses going under?
Speaker 164
May I welcome the shadow minister to her place on the opposition bench and thank her for her contribution and questions and for the recognition that she has placed on the vital contribution that Scottish whisky and all whisky makes to our national identity. It would be remiss of me, Madam Deputy Speaker, not to remind the House that the last government allowed tariffs on single malt whisky exports to the United States to cost industry more than 600 million pounds in lost exports, and they stood by while one of Britain's most iconic sectors paid the price. By contrast, this government acted. We secured an agreement that brings tariffs on Scotch whisky exports to the US down to zero. So when it comes to standing up for British whisky in its biggest export market, I do think that producers will be not taking lectures from the party opposite.
On this side of the House, we got a deal done both in terms of the India deal and reducing the US tariffs. As one of the members of this House has previously said, Scotch whisky is a national treasure and one of Britain's great exports. Nobody is trying to take anything away from it. And they go on to say there is plenty of room in the market for a growing English sector alongside Scotland's. Consumers, not lawyers, should decide what ends up in their glass.
I think the honourable member for Thirsk and Malton put it very well. This government agrees that Scotch whisky's reputation and protections must remain robustly defended, while recognizing that other parts of the UK's whisky sector can also grow and succeed. We will continue to engage with others and with the devolved nations to make that a success.
Scott Arthur
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I do thank the minister for his statement. If the Secretary of State made this decision, I'm disappointed she's not able to come along today to answer this question, because I think there's real concerns here. The sector in Scotland is a hundred times bigger than the sector in England. And if it is going to grow, I do wonder what the target market is if it's not people who are currently drinking Scottish whisky.
So but when he visited the distillery in Aberdeenshire, did they explain the importance of that malt whisky brand and why that should be protected? Because it does seem that this decision today does weaken that brand.
Speaker 164
I thank my honourable friend for his question. He would have heard from the outset of what I said in terms of this protecting Scotch whisky going forward. It was a really enjoyable visit to Aberdeenshire in August, where a number of issues and concerns were raised. I can assure him from the dispatch box that I will continue to engage with the sector to understand issues and concerns to make sure the sector continues to flourish.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. English whisky rightly has a growing reputation. It's right that it should have geographical indication status. I confess to being a single malt enjoyer myself, the owner of a decent collection, including a fine bottle of Lindores, and an avid supporter of the annual Kendal Whisky Festival, where whiskies distilled in Cumbria proudly tout their wares alongside whiskies from all parts of the British Isles and indeed beyond. So English whisky is good.
English whisky from the Lakes is even better. But Defra's proposed criteria for English whisky is not good. And neither is the tiny appeal period on that status.
To put it bluntly, English whisky is too good to be held to too low, this low, a standard. It would damage the English whisky brand and it would turn in turn impact on the brand and reputation of Scotch whisky along with whiskies from Wales and Ireland. It's also quite wrong for this consultation, this appeal period to be open for only two parliamentary sitting days. Without this UQ from my honourable friend, there would have been no parliamentary scrutiny of this at all. And even with this question, the appeal period is far too brief or fair to be adequate.
I urge the Minister to think again.
Speaker 164
I thank the honourable member for his question and know that this is an issue that he has been picking up and and trying to address with colleagues in the department and thank him for his correspondence on these matters. I will stress that GI status does provide a powerful platform for producers to strengthen their brand, attract investment, access new markets and compete internationally on the basis of quality, provenance and authenticity. I know that obviously the decisions this government has made I think will go a long way to supporting the industry in his constituency and very live to the issues that he has described and certainly will take them back to the department.
James Terry Jermy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think this is fantastic news for the English whisky industry and will be welcomed by the English distillery in my South West Norfolk constituency, where at Roudham back in 2006 they were the first distillery in England registered for over a hundred years and this year won the World Whisky Awards for the world's best single malt, which is obviously great news. But will my honourable friend agree that as well as being good for the whisky industry, this is also good for our farmers and the support through the cereals and particularly barley crop in the eastern region that feeds much of the English distilleries?
Speaker 164
I thank my honourable friend for his question. He's a real champion on these issues and pay tribute to the work that he does with his farming community in his constituency. He's absolutely right. This strengthens the links between farming and distilling, ensuring more of the value generated remains within UK rural communities. Yes, it's a significant vote of confidence in British agriculture and the quality of British grown cereals, particularly our world renowned barley growers.
John Glen
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I visited Witchmark Distillery in Fonthill in my constituency a year or so ago and they had gone to considerable lengths to match the standards that they saw in Scotland on a single site and are putting down whisky casks and growing a significant business providing significant numbers of jobs in this rural constituency. I am concerned what to what the honourable gentleman said from Westmorland and Cumbria about the different differentiation of standards. So could he reassure the House that the appropriate high standards for this growing class of goods is going to be protected?
Speaker 164
I thank him for his point and it will have no impact on standards that any other UK whiskies have set for themselves and all they do is vary across the United Kingdom, but I will certainly take back the points that he raised to the department.
Chris Kane
I share the surprise of distillers in my constituency, which includes Glengoyne, Deanston, Tullibardine and the Stirling Distillery, at the terms of the decision, which does seem to cause longer term troubles for distillers in both Scotland and England with regards to consumer confidence. But that shouldn't underline the fact that this government is a friend of the Scottish Whisky Association and I wonder if the Minister could outline just some of the things that he's doing to support the 41,000 jobs in Scotland and the 25,000 jobs across the rest of the country to make sure that this continues to be one of our best exports for Brand Scotland and Brand UK?
Speaker 164
I thank my honourable friend for his question. He's absolutely right. Scotch whisky is one of the country's top global exports and that's not going to change anytime soon. We absolutely remain committed to backing it and supporting its continued success.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm really struggling to see what the government is seeking to achieve by removing the requirement for whole process to be carried out on a single site. It seems to me they risk confusing the definition for the Scotch, Welsh and Irish whisky industries. They undermine the investments that have already been made in the conventional model by other English distilleries. So is the government trying to create a new market for a different product?
And if that is what they are doing, shouldn't that then be reflected in its name?
Speaker 164
I thank the chair of the select committee for his long-standing support for the Scotch whisky industry, including as chair of the select committee. I know that he recognizes the significant contribution that whisky plays to our national identity and as a global export opportunity. As I said earlier in my statement, I can assure him that nothing has changed in terms of the protected status, reputation or production requirements of Scotch whisky. And I'm looking forward to meeting him later today where I'm very happy to answer any further questions he may have.
Douglas Lumsden.
Douglas Lumsden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The definition of a single Scotch single malt whisky is that it must be mashed, fermented and distilled at a single distillery in Scotland. But for English single malt, some of that steps may happen away from that single site. Does the minister not feel it would be better to have a consistent approach on the definition of a single malt whisky, which would then be easier for consumers to understand?
Speaker 164
I thank the honorable member for his question. It's worth me saying that the rules and requirements to use protected name English whisky and its subcategories, including single malt, are determined by product specification. And this document is produced by the applicant, in the case the English Whisky Guild, and reflects the traditions and practices of the English whisky sector. The English whisky product specification is compliant with all applicable UK legislation. And I'm very happy to write to him on the specific points that he raises.
Brendan O'Hara.
Brendan O'Hara
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My Argyll and Bute constituency produces the finest single malt Scotch whisky from Islay, Jura, Campbeltown, Oban, Mull and Ardnamurchan. Centuries of craft have gone into building that hard-earned reputation. This decision to allow lower production standards for English single malt whisky undermines that. Why has the government allowed lower standards in England?
And what safeguards is the government putting in place to protect the hard-earned reputation and the integrity of Scottish malt whisky?
Speaker 164
Madam Deputy Speaker, it's not a binary choice. You can support English whisky and support Scottish whisky. And I think it's worth stressing we are supporting the growth of the whisky industry. It's hugely important to this government and is evident in the recent international work that we have undertaken. Look at the India free trade agreement, slashed tariff rates on UK whisky exports from 150 percent to 75 percent.
And obviously the work that we've done with the US as well. This government has invested significantly in the whisky industry. With China, we're agreeing to cut tariffs on Scotch whisky from 10 percent to 5 percent and we'll continue to take action to support the Scottish industry.
Susan Murray
Final question, Susan Murray.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can the minister tell distillers in Scotland, like those who invested 12 million pounds in the Port of Leith Distillery in Edinburgh in order to achieve the prized Scottish single malt label, which I visited with the Scottish Affairs Committee earlier this year, why English producers will be able to use the same single malt label without playing by the same rules?
Speaker 164
I refer the honorable member to my previous question with regards to the issues around single malt. I'm very happy to take away the views and concerns that she's raised today.
Judith Cummins
That is the end of the urgent question, English whisky single malt definition. Colleagues, I'm on my feet, you should definitely be seated. I suspend the sitting to allow proper notice of the statement. The sitting will resume at 2:32. I will cause the bells to ring two minutes before.
Order, order.
Order, order. We now come to the statement on the Thirlwall Inquiry final report and recommendations. I call the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care.
Wes Streeting
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I apologize for the timing of the statement and thank the opposition for their understanding on this. Madam Deputy Speaker, with permission, I would like to make a statement on the report of the three-year public inquiry into events at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2018, led by Lady Justice Thirlwall, published today. I am grateful to Lady Justice Thirlwall for her thorough and devastating report. At the heart of this inquiry have been 13 families who lost their newborn baby or who saw them experience serious collapse or injury at the hospital 10 and 11 years ago.
I cannot begin to fathom the grief and pain of the parents and families. The mother of Baby J describes her grief, she says, "I cannot emphasize enough the impact of this on our whole family, who we are as people, parents, work life, spouses, children. It has cast a shadow of sadness over every part of our lives." Those parents have had to face the unimaginable, and I recognize that they have waited many years for the details set out in this report, and also that it will continue to add to the distress and the loss that they have endured. They should be in all our thoughts throughout all the discussions of this report today.
The public inquiry was commissioned by the then Health Secretary in September 2023, following the conviction of neonatal nurse Lucy Letby for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of a further six babies. Lady Justice Thirlwall has been clear it was not her role to look at the convictions or the legal process or the court evidence, and nor, and she is explicit about not cutting across the work of the Criminal Cases Review Commission. Instead, her focus was on the experiences of the parents of the babies named in the indictment, the conduct of those working at the Countess of Chester Hospital, including whether action should have been taken earlier, and the effectiveness of NHS management, governance, scrutiny, and regulation in keeping babies in hospital safe. And that is also the focus of this statement. In the words of Lady Justice Thirlwall, the report sets out a dispiriting and at times shocking account of multiple repeated mistakes and failing by organizations and individuals.
The inquiry describes the increase in neonatal deaths in 2015 and 2016 at the hospital, the concerns about the possibility of deliberate harm that were raised by clinicians at an early stage, but then repeated failures of organizations and individuals to act. Shocking failures to put the safety of babies first. Shocking failures on safeguarding. Failures in governance, in regulation, failures in the most basic duty of candour, failures in professional curiosity, and a repeated failure to refer concerns to the police, which the inquiry is clear should have been done at a much earlier stage. And Lady Justice Thirlwall comes to the devastating conclusion that some babies would have been saved if action was taken earlier.
Central to these findings are what Lady Justice Thirlwall describes as a complete failure at all levels to invoke safeguarding procedures at any point. She explains, "No one seems to have thought that safeguarding action is required when a member of staff is suspected of causing deliberate harm. Suspicion is enough." And the inquiry also identifies failure among external bodies, including the CQC, who failed to consider the data and ask the right questions, and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, who should have known as soon as they were engaged that this was a matter that needed to be referred to the police. The inquiry finds repeated failures of governance and candour by the trust and individuals within it, and disturbingly, it refers to an exercise in spin to steer away from referral to the police.
And Madam Deputy Speaker, that is an appalling finding. An exercise in spin instead of putting the safety of babies first.
Worst of all, the trust repeatedly failed the parents. It failed to keep their beloved babies safe. It failed repeatedly to provide them with information which they had a right to know. It failed to ask their consent for sharing information with external experts and other organisations, or to keep them up to date with investigations that were taking place. And for parents to be kept in the dark for years about what was happening is, as Lady Justice Thirlwall has said, reprehensible.
So let me address the issues for the families and for the parents directly. Because the suffering endured by these babies and their families is impossible to comprehend. On behalf of the government and the health service, I am profoundly sorry for the failures set out so clearly in this report. For the harm, distress and unthinkable loss for their families and for the failures to keep their babies safe. Our responsibility now is to act.
And let me be clear, the safety and care for babies, the safeguarding of every patient, the respect for families, all of these go to the heart of our NHS values. And they must be at the heart not just of what we say, but what we do. So let me turn to the recommendations. Lady Justice Thirlwall has made 17 recommendations on what needs to be done to keep babies safe. The inquiry recognises that in many areas things have changed since these terrible events took place, including welcome improvements at the Countess hospital in services for women and children.
However, the inquiry is very clear that new action is needed. I take these recommendations extremely seriously. The government will of course consider the entire report and set out a full response. But let me highlight some key areas today. On the crucial issue of safeguarding, Lady Justice Thirlwall recommends compulsory training and new protocol employment requirements.
And Madam Deputy Speaker, a revised NHS safeguarding framework was published in April 2026, but I have asked the chief nursing officer to urgently review the framework and the training in the light of this report. We need to look urgently at this. But let me be clear. This goes beyond laws and procedures, many of which are already clear. This is about leadership and responsibility.
Safeguarding is everyone's business and safeguarding must be everyone's priority. Concerns must be heard and acted upon. Staff who speak up must be protected and taken seriously. And I expect every leader, every board across the NHS, every professional and manager, every member of staff to uphold their safeguarding responsibilities. And I will not hesitate to hold the NHS to account for the highest standards at every level because at its heart this is what the NHS stands for.
Care for patients and most of all, keeping the most vulnerable patients of all safe. On safety and reassurance for parents, Lady Justice Thirlwall recommends the introduction of video baby monitors for neonatal units. I agree. I have asked my officials to urgently develop plans for cot cams, which can also help parents feel better connected to their babies when they aren't able to be with them in person. The inquiry says the sudden unexpected death in infancy and childhood guidance must be updated.
I agree, that is now underway. It welcomes the introduction of medical examiners but said it should have happened 10 years earlier. I agree. And we will set out further plans to strengthen their neonatal expertise following the inquiry's recommendations when the government sets out its full response. It recommends much stronger controls on insulin storage.
The NHS has begun that process with new guidance in January of this year, but we agree with the recommendation to go further. It recommends new regulation on NHS managers, not just on clinical professionals.
The government has consulted on and confirmed plans to apply a barring scheme to senior leaders and managers, not just to clinicians. So we will legislate to introduce the scheme as soon as parliamentary time allows, and we will consider the chair's recommendation to expand it further. The report also makes recommendations for the regulators, including the CQC, which we will ensure are taken seriously, and on technology. We have implemented the maternity outcome signal system, which provides near real-time safety alerts, but we agree we must do more. And I agree with the report that when the very worst happens and parents face bereavement, they need to be supported to the best of our ability.
The report recommends the national bereavement care pathway for neonatal death should be rolled out in 2027. I agree and can confirm that all trusts are signed up to implement it, and I will ensure that it is repeated in all versions of the NHS planning framework while I am the Secretary of State. Finally, Lady Justice Thirlwall highlights problems with past inquiry recommendations not being implemented. So my department is setting up a recommendation hub to properly track our implementation progress internally, not just for this inquiry, but for others right across the NHS. But we will work with the Cabinet Office now on improvements in this area to respond to this inquiry.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this afternoon I will discuss with the maternity task force our plan to bring forward in the Health Bill amendments to create a new maternity and neonatal commissioner to address the serious concerns around safety and standards that have been raised. Later this week, I will meet with Lady Justice Thirlwall to discuss how we take forward the conclusions of this report. But I want to highlight a final issue that has struck me while reading through the different volumes of this inquiry. Because there is a section of the report that refers to the way senior oversight of neonatal care had been downgraded in the reorganization of the Countess hospital. It includes the fact that the board and the medical director reviewed the deaths within the hospital.
However, it only covered adult deaths. And the report says, "The board did not receive any reports about the deaths of babies and children at any stage during the period the inquiry was considering." "This was a serious failure of governance which no one on the board seems to have noticed." "This is further evidence of the inadequacy of the structure which removed the voice of children and babies from the board and the lack of profile of paediatrics and neonatology." Madam Deputy Speaker, I am clear: the safety and the safeguarding and wellbeing of babies must never again be treated as a side issue.
And as I reflect on some of the safety reports we have seen in recent years on maternity services, let me also be clear: maternity and neonatal services cannot operate on the margins. They must be at the forefront, a central priority in what our NHS must do at the vital and precious start of a family's life. I want to thank the families for the extraordinary courage and dignity they have shown. I also thank Lady Justice Thirlwall and all of her team for their rigorous work. This must be a turning point for the NHS.
When concerns are raised, especially about safety and safeguarding, they must be heard and acted upon. And it is time to put maternity and neonatal care and safety at the top of the NHS agenda where it belongs. I commend this statement to the House.
Judith Cummins
I call the Shadow Secretary, Damian Hinds, because the Secretary of State ran over, the Shadow Secretary of State has six minutes.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I thank the Secretary of State for her statement and advanced sight of it. And we all thank Lady Justice Thirlwall and her team for their incredibly important work. As the Secretary of State said the report is both thorough and devastating. These were crimes that shook our whole nation. No one who has not lost a child in this way could possibly imagine the depth of these parents' suffering.
The task now for the NHS, for the state and for us as parliamentarians is to ensure that from their unthinkably terrible loss at least come reliable guards against such tragedy happening again. For this is sadly not the first or the only time that serial tragic avoidable deaths have occurred within our health service. And there are themes that recur. Dismissal or undermining of whistleblowers. Concerns about institutional or personal reputation or organisational disruption hampering the primacy of focus on immediate patient safety.
And because actually naturally the idea of a healthcare worker deliberately harming patients is so unthinkable to decent people alternative explanations are sought instead. Now today Madam Deputy Speaker we're not at the stage of the Secretary of State being able to say that the government accepts all the recommendations in full and we understand that it is a very substantial piece of work. She says they will consider of course the entire report and set out a full response. When does she anticipate that to to happen? In the time available Madam Deputy Speaker I would just ask if I may a few questions on on a subset of the aspects here.
So we welcome the points on the suspension sorry the suspicion of deliberate harms protocol. And she's absolutely right that the the message has to get out there that in such cases suspicion is enough and we must change the way that people think about that. But the report notes that the existing freedom to speak up system has operated unevenly through the NHS. It also notes that there remains a need for a national oversight body though the National Guardian's Office is no more. There are still many NHS staff the report says who do not feel it possible to raise patient safety concerns without risking career detriment.
So what else can be done to establish independent escalation pathways outside of the management hierarchy? I do worry Madam Deputy Speaker that some of what is there is being removed. If an individual exhausts a trust's mechanisms for raising concerns they could currently go to the Council of Governors of the trust but that will be abolished by the Health Bill or to NHS England that will also be abolished by the Health Bill. So if a consultant reports a concern to the board and doesn't get a hearing where where do they go? Is the Secretary of State the next person the next stage in that in that line?
I must also ask about another of the government's current proposed changes the abolition of the Health Services Safety Investigations Body. Now neither it nor its predecessor body were in existence at the time of the murders. In any event it wasn't set up to investigate individuals or criminal activity or deliberate harm. But it did create a legally protected safe space for staff to raise alarm bells confidentially outside the normal line management hierarchy and that could help to break silences and contribute to the cultural changes that are required. And the report does say that HSSIB continues to fulfill a needed function so I ask the Secretary of State will she reconsider the proposal to to end it?
To many people an obvious question arising from these terrible cases will be surely someone up the chain must have noticed the sheer numbers the severe statistical anomaly in fatalities and there was the report covers there was an alert signal in the data in 2015 but the analysis was only being reported on with a long lag and clearly what is required is real-time reporting and automated analysis to identify abnormalities in deteriorations or unexplained deaths that could trigger immediate independent external review and the Secretary of State mentioned in her remarks the near real-time process now in place. Could she say a word about how close that comes to that fully real-time automated complementing of course human understanding to trigger independent external review. The inquiry's findings on this also linked to its recommendation that NHS systems become interoperable by the end of 2028 and does she think that timetable is achievable. Recommendation one as she mentioned is on the use of cameras in cots with remote monitoring for parents and the department are to set out a roadmap by March. Now remote monitoring of course has become widespread in people's own homes and there is cot-side video I understand in use at quite a number of trusts but this I think would be rather more than is typically in place in those hospitals today and can she outline her initial assessment of how this can be achieved and when.
Madam Deputy Speaker one of the most sobering findings in this is that in her review of recommendations from previous inquiries into NHS bodies over 30 of 30 years whilst some significant changes have been made many recommendations have not been implemented and Lady Justice Thirlwall supports formation of a joint committee of Parliament to ensure recommendations are pursued and recommends that the National Audit Office should audit implementation of statutory inquiries into the NHS. I think I heard the Secretary of State say they were going to create an internal hub. Really is that I ask the Secretary of State just to consider is that enough. Would it not be better in the spirit of the duty of candour that these things were done through through the institutions through the National Audit Office and with this Parliament. Madam Deputy Speaker our thoughts our prayers remain with all those families in the unimaginable pain of their loss.
While nothing now can undo that pain it is vital that all possible lessons are learned and more important acted upon with determination and urgency.
Wes Streeting
Can I thank the right honourable member for his response and for his questions and for the compassion as well that he shows for the for those the families who have been so badly affected by the the terrible events the failures in the NHS but also to see that what has happened with the the crimes that have taken place. I can say to him that our intention will be to publish the full response within six months and to ensure that we have done so thoroughly as well and I will discuss this as well further with Lady Justice Thirlwall later this week. The issue about the whistleblowers that he raised I think is incredibly important and what the report says is the way the grievance and its consequences were handled was deplorable and the way in which the trust responded to these concerns was completely wrong also went against the guidance and the rules that they were supposed to follow.
And that's why I think, look, part of this is about making sure that there are the right systems in place, part of it is also about leadership and responsibility and culture as well, and ensuring that we are holding all of those to account at every level in supporting this and including particularly around safeguarding. The safeguarding of babies should have been taken the most seriously of all. He raised specifically the issues around HSIB, and the inquiry is very clear about the importance of the role of HSIB, the intention of our reforms is for that role to continue. As part of the Health Bill, it does involve transferring HSIB into the CQC, however that independent role and investigation is continuing. However, I will and plan to review the detail of this to ensure that we are meeting the spirit of the inquiry's recommendation on this, because it is immensely important that we have those arrangements in place.
He also referred to the issues around the systems and interoperability and also being able to have the data assessments. Of course, we do now have new systems in place, including the Maternity Outcome Signal System, that when applied to the data that emerged from the Countess, does make clear that there would have been real-time safety alerts that would have been flagged. But of course, in the hospital, the clinicians already knew. They already knew that there had been an increase, a significant increase that had taken place, but also that they had unexplained deaths as well, and a series of issues that were raised within the hospital. But there was a failure of the board to review this, there was a failure of oversight, there was a failure of governance, and there was a failure to take proper action as well.
Finally, he raised the issue about the recommendation that we need to look at a series of reports. In this case, we know there have been a series of recommendations made, particularly about patient safety, also very often including whistleblowing, that actually we need to make sure that are actually implemented. We cannot keep going round the same circles. I am also very conscious that it is shocking to me that these events took place in 2015, 2016, very soon after the Lampard Review into the NHS, which had made very clear the importance of safeguarding. So safeguarding should have been something that was on everybody's minds at that time, even if it was about very different circumstances to what happened here, the issues around safeguarding and patient safety should have been taken incredibly seriously, and they were not.
So he is right, we need to make sure that there are systems in place, but again, even immediately after reports being published, we've still had a failure in this case to adopt the implementations and the spirit of those. He will know in terms of the recommendations around the NAO, that is a cross-government issue. However, what I have made clear is what the Health Department will do about establishing a hub for health inquiry recommendations, so that alongside the cross-government discussion, we can make sure that the NHS is doing what it needs to.
Judith Cummins
Samantha Dixon, I appreciate this is particularly sensitive for you, so please take your time. Samantha Dixon.
Kate Samantha Dixon
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, I really appreciate that. This is another very dark day for the families affected by events at the Countess of Chester Hospital, those who grieve, who suffer, and who continue to live with the terrible fallout. It's crucial for them, as well as every one of my constituents and those of my right honourable friend the member for Alyn and Deeside and others, to have absolute confidence that our local hospital, my local hospital, is a safe place. Lady Justice Thirlwall's inquiry needs the firmest response possible from government. She shines a light on a truly appalling state of affairs.
Too many times in this place, in response to catastrophic events, we say, never again. I've served previously as Minister for Building Safety, my work guided by the recommendations of the Grenfell Tower inquiry. My right honourable friend, the member for Streatham and Croydon North and I argued consistently inside government for the establishment of a national oversight mechanism to capture the recommendations from important public inquiries such as this one, to make sure they're carried forward, never forgotten or overlooked. Given Lady Justice Thirlwall's evidence that inquiry recommendations are so often overlooked, will my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State, support the calls to broaden her essential recommendation beyond the NHS to all inquiries and set up a national oversight mechanism so that when we say, never again, we mean it.
Wes Streeting
Can I thank my honourable friend for raising this and for consistently speaking out for her constituents who have endured the unimaginable and who have been through the most horrendous experiences, the loss of a baby or to see the collapse taking place, to then have to go through everything that has happened since and still to have shown, as Lady Justice Thirlwall says, such huge dignity in responding to this inquiry and to, as the inquiry makes clear, that those parents, those families have given evidence exactly in the hope that this cannot happen again to other families in other hospitals as well as in Chester. And I pay huge tribute to them. I can tell her that I will take forward the point she raised about the cross-government issues in discussion with the Cabinet Office. She is right to raise that and I will certainly undertake to draw together the recommendations for NHS inquiries and recommendations as well. And then I would also highlight for her, because I know it will be important for her constituency, the inquiry specifically also says, Lady Justice Thirlwall says, in 2025, a large modern women and children's unit opened in Chester and providing integrated family care for babies and their families.
And it says, this welcome change represents a huge improvement in neonatal care at the Countess. I know that will be hugely important to families in her constituency, but it does not get away from the devastating conclusions of this report where action needs to be taken.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I start by sending my heartfelt sympathies and those of my party to all of the families who've been so cruelly harmed and thank Lady Justice Thirlwall for her inquiry and the Secretary of State for early sight of the report. Lady Justice Thirlwall's final report describes a dispiriting and at times shocking account of multiple and repeated mistakes and failures by organisations and individuals. Now, the conviction of Lucy Letby for those murders and attempted murders sets this investigation apart from others, but while it is incredibly distressing, it is also distressingly familiar. A failure to investigate abnormal levels of death or harm, a failure to act on concerns raised and deter whistleblowing, a failure to follow established protocols for investigating deaths and a management instinct to cover up failure, to put the reputation of the hospital above the safety of the babies who were in it.
The importance of stronger whistleblowing mechanisms could not be clearer. There should be a duty of candour for management as well as medical staff. Will the government accept my amendments to the Health Bill to require boards to call in investigators when they receive reports of malpractice and to give stronger powers for coroners and medical examiners to whistleblow? The review makes it explicit that there must be an external body to investigate trusts, an external body such as HSIB. Will the government now drop the measures in the Health Bill that risk patient safety?
Surely the Secretary of State will accept the amendments we and others have put forward to end the abolition of HSIB, to protect Healthwatch and to put patient safety first, including the restoration of the National Guardian's Office. I'm beyond angry that once again we are discussing the recommendations for action from an NHS scandal. It's like Groundhog Day. We are stuck in an endless cycle of expressing horror and doing nothing. The reports and recommendations over multiple scandals gathering dust on a shelf in the DHSC.
The Thirlwall Inquiry cites the lack of political will as one of the causes of this cycle. We have a new Secretary of State. Will she promise us that she will be the one to find the will to end it? Because the families who've suffered such unimaginable loss deserve nothing less.
Wes Streeting
Can I thank the honourable member for her comments and questions and also her tribute to the families and her recognition of how much that they have endured. She is right to highlight the importance of the duty of candour and also as I think one of the most shocking findings that there was the inquiry describes the exercise of spin, putting that above patient safety and also the safety of some of the most vulnerable patients of all, newborn babies, which is truly shocking. The boards are obviously already responsible to ensure that they follow the duty of candour and in fact the inquiry finds at a series of areas there were breaches, there were crucial breaches of the duty of candour and of their responsibilities including responsibilities to provide information to the reviews that were done as well as responsibilities that should have been clear on terms of safeguarding. However, we will look further at this both at the responsibility framework and also at the regulation around clinical, around managers as well as clinicians and also at what the leadership responsibilities are to ensure that that takes place. She'll also know that the local guardians remain, that is extremely important and on HSIB, I agree with her that that role needs to continue, that is the intention that that will continue as part of the CQC, but I have also undertaken to look again at those arrangements to ensure that they meet the expectations of the inquiry's report.
But fundamentally I think the point that she makes is about the anger and sense of deep frustration and injustice that we are here again discussing some of the same issues. And for me that is in two areas, firstly the issue about patient safety which has been discussed time and again where we've had these kinds of recommendations. But the second for me is the sense of the sidelining of maternity and neonatal care and the way in which in too many places this has been as seen as a side issue rather than being central and that we have to put the cradle back at the heart of the NHS. We've always talked about it being from cradle to grave, the very start of a child's life, the very start of a family's life is one of the most important moments and we have to make sure that our NHS keeps that at the centre of what it does.
Scott Arthur
This report doesn't make easy reading. And I'm sure I can't imagine how the families think just even looking at the report. And likewise, I do want to pay tribute to the the vast majority of NHS staff right across the UK who do a great job every single day, including my fantastic wife, Madam Deputy Speaker. The families' legal team have been very clear that they expect all the recommendations to be implemented. And they're asking for a timeline for that.
And I know that can't be done today, but it'd be good to hear the Secretary of State just to say that her starting point, her ambition will be that they will be all implemented in full as soon as possible. And I think the point around the timeline is really important. I think chapter 39, I think is perhaps one of the more difficult problems. It talks about culture. It talks about how in the past there's been an overreaction to blame culture.
And that means that means some managers have been unwilling to confront bad behaviors. So will the Secretary of State also commit herself to addressing that most difficult of problems?
Wes Streeting
Well, can I thank my honorable friend for that question? And he is right to pay tribute to the staff right across our National Health Service who work immensely hard every day, including in our neonatal units, including in our maternity units, to provide care, compassion, support, and quality care for people who need that support and are asking for that support at an important time in their lives. And also people across the NHS who were devastated when the police investigation, the prosecutions, and the convictions identified terrible crimes taking place. And who are determined to ensure that the best quality of care is provided. And interestingly, it is identified as an unwillingness to think the unthinkable.
That is what held some people back from actually facing up to what had happened because it does feel unthinkable that any staff should be deliberately harming a child. But actually, we have a responsibility to be prepared to think the unthinkable. And the point about the safeguarding arrangements that the report identifies is that safeguarding arrangements are not a finding of fact. The safeguarding arrangements are what you do when there is a concern, when there is a suspicion. That is when you have to do take safeguarding action in order to put safety first.
And that is what we have to be clear about right across not just the NHS but right across all of our services. Safeguarding is about what you do when things are still unknown in order to ensure that you put safety first. He rightly recognizes some of the real challenges around culture, around concerns about blame, having the confidence for people to be able to speak out and to have the support in doing so. And again, the inquiry and the remarks from Lady Justice Thirlwall are again really strong on this. It is a responsibility for everyone to identify if there are concerns, they need to be expressed and they need to be investigated.
And that is an act of good faith, not of bad faith. And therefore, it is those that if if for all of us we keep patient safety and above all the safety of the most vulnerable patients of all, the little babies, then and keep that in the forefront of our minds, that is what should guide us as we deal with all of these sensitive issues.
Judith Cummins
That concludes the statement on Thirlwall Inquiry, final report and recommendations. I'll give the front benches a few moments to shuffle over. We now come to the select committee statement on behalf of the Treasury Committee. Dame Meg Hillier will speak for up to 10 minutes, not just yet folks, not just yet. Dame Meg Hillier will speak for up to 10 minutes during which no interventions may be taken.
At the conclusion of her statement, I will call members to ask questions on the subject of the statement. These should be brief questions and not full speeches. Can I emphasize that questions should be directed to the select committee chair and not the relevant government minister. Front benches may take part in questioning. I call Dame Meg Hillier.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I am pleased to rise to make a statement on the government's response to the Treasury Select Committee's report on the student loan system. I think it's worth laying out first what our inquiry did. We took evidence from a number of people, including student and graduate representatives at the National Union of Students, Rethink Repayment, set up by a constituent of mine to on behalf of the graduates affected, and the Prospect Union. We also took evidence from the Institute for Fiscal Studies, Universities UK, and from Sir Philip Augar, who led the Augar review of post-16 education and who knows more, Madam Deputy Speaker, about higher education finance than most of us here today. And we hosted an online survey which received 52,000 responses from individuals, mostly those affected by Plan 2 student loans.
This was the second highest response to any select committee inquiry ever. And we made numerous written requests to the Department for Education, asking for all of the publicity material that the department had produced for student loans from the last 15 years. This unearthed over 200 pages of slides and videos of student presentations. So we found in our inquiry that for many years, students were sold an idea that the repayment thresholds for student loans would rise with inflation or earnings. This commitment, indeed a promise, has been repeatedly broken and graduates are now having to pay back far more over their lifetime as a result.
And that's happened over different governments of different colors. That promise and the promotional materials created by the DfE downplayed the monthly repayments that most students would have to make once they had graduated. In the committee's view, this amounted to mis-selling. But the government has exempted itself from consumer protection laws, so students have no avenue for seeking redress. And for most graduates, their student loan repayments will now act as a career-long additional income tax of 9% on top of their marginal rate of tax.
The knock-on impact of this has been that the additional rate of tax is actually harming graduates' ability to get onto the housing ladder, in turn affecting their ability to start a family and their ability to save into a pension. In the run-up to our inquiry, we had quite interesting comments made by several then cabinet ministers who had described the student loan system as broken and unfair, and the current Secretary of State for Education called the student loan system endless and unfair as recently as February. So the government's own submission to the inquiry described the student loan system as broken and unfair. So we made a number of recommendations. We heard good evidence from Sir Philip Augar that when he reviewed the system, he'd recommended that the split between student and the taxpayer should be around 50%.
So we as a committee concluded that the split between the individual and the state should be 50%. But in its response, which I'm talking to today, the government have come back and said its contribution already is in the region of 35 to 40% and that that is enough. I can tell the government that it doesn't feel like that to many of my constituents and those of my fellow committee members, who can read the government's own forecast of repayments, which show that for the average undergraduate starting in 2024-25, they will be paying back their loan for 31 years and the average amount they will pay back will be well over £30,000. It's even worse for graduates in the top 30% of earnings. The government forecast they will pay back more than they borrowed.
And I think we all understand on the committee that a national conversation needs to be had on how much society should contribute towards higher education. But we did as a committee, a cross-party committee made up of three parties of this House, conclude that a 50-50 split in the longer term should be the ambition in order to invest in the young people of today and our country. One of the most shocking elements of our inquiry was the evidence provided thanks to the Department for Education about the advice given to students when they took out loans. And we recommended as a result of seeing that that much better information needs to be provided to make it clear that when applying for a loan, that the terms and conditions of loans can change even after they've been taken out. So I'm very pleased at the government's response on this point.
We said that more can be done to support borrowers to understand the student finance system and that information should be unambiguous and as easy to understand as possible. And the government has committed, and I quote, to a transformation programme that will review the pre-application process to produce clear, relatable and trusted guidance that supports better decision making and financial planning. This would include making it more prominent that student finance is governed by legislation and that regulations may be amended by government and Parliament. These changes are well overdue and it's shameful that multiple governments have really put money into an area, have not done this when these are very young people who've been taking out loans, mostly under the age of 18. The committee also recommended that student loans promotion material should be brought in line with the requirements of the Financial Conduct Authority's consumer duty.
The government has declined this in its response to our report, based on the fact that these are not commercial loans. But the government is the monopoly provider of student loans and students can't go anywhere else for a loan of this sort. It's therefore beholden on the government to treat student loans fairly, as the competitive forces that might maintain a higher standards of customer service as in banking and other areas doesn't apply to student loans. So we'd like the government to explain which elements of the Financial Conduct Authority's consumer duty it feels it cannot comply with, given it doesn't want to commit to doing so at this stage. And we're disappointed on another point.
The committee, in fact my predecessor committee in 2018, concluded that the use of the Retail Price Index should end and we should move to the Consumer Price Index, which is a lower level of inflation measure. Back then, the government responded that the flaws in the RPI measure of inflation are well understood, but didn't make a change. And the government has sat passively by, different governments of different colours over that time, and today the government says that it will not make that change because the change is coming in 2030 anyway. But that means a long time that students have been charged at a higher interest rate and we are disappointed in that response. But one of the key things that we looked at was the change announced in last year's budget to freeze the threshold at which payments have to be made by students for two years from April next year.
And this is a cohort of students already facing huge pressures on housing costs, facing pressures on paying into pensions, the generation that is helping to grow Britain, that is working to deliver essential jobs in our economy, helping to grow that economy, the generation that will pay for the NHS and the aging population, the generation that will have the children that will be our future workers. And let's not forget the birth rate has fallen every year in the last three years and it's 1.41%. So not investing in this generation is a real challenge, is a real issue. And this is a real breach of trust to change that threshold and make students have to stick at a frozen level. This has been done by previous governments as well, but there is an opportunity here.
The government has not absolutely said it will not review the threshold, so there's a glimmer of hope there. And I urge ministers as they're talking to their Treasury colleagues ahead of the budget, there is an opportunity to show with a change of Prime Minister and a change of government that we want to invest in this generation. It's a matter of intergenerational fairness. This cohort is squeezed. And the government needs to consider the fairness of the student finance system for borrowers, taxpayers, and public finances, absolutely.
But to change the rules repeatedly around this cohort, and particularly on Plan 2, which is a very punitive system, is really important. I think that we want to honor the promises that the government has made to student loan holders. And one of the easiest ways to do that is to not bring in this fresh threshold freeze next April. So it's in the hands of the Chancellor of the Exchequer at the budget, and I hope he and his colleagues are listening to this and listening to the 52,000 people who responded to our inquiry and the many young people in their 20s and 30s who are suffering the additional burden of this punitive Plan 2 loan system, and he will reconsider freezing that threshold at the budget in October.
Judith Cummins
We have around 10 minutes for questions and answers, so they must be brief. John Glen.
John Glen
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank the honorable lady for a very clear summation of the committee's report. I just want to press her a little bit on this issue of the repayment threshold. She says that in the government's response, they haven't ruled out reviewing it. Given the relatively modest amount of money and the significant number of young people that would be positively affected, does she think that this should be one of the top priorities of the new Chancellor on the 28th of October?
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank the right honorable gentleman. I absolutely do think it should be a high priority because of this generation being so severely squeezed. And the government itself in its response to the committee says it recognizes the cost of living challenges faced by many graduates, including those with Plan 2 student loans, and understands concerns about the impact of repayment terms on borrowers. So it's keeping, it says further, we're keeping all aspects of the student finance system under review. This is one change that is relatively very simple to make, relatively cheap, well, I recognize the Chancellor has many challenges even since we put our report out, but it is an achievable one that could be done quickly and would make a big difference to this cohort.
Julie Minns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of the themes that comes through quite clearly in the report is the complexity of the student finance system and the difficulty that students have understanding what it is they will actually pay. Misselling, as I think the honorable lady described it. Given the government appear to accept that the terms are confusing, is it fair that the government continues to penalize the borrowers who were potentially misled?
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I think one good thing is that the government in response to us has recognized this problem.
But we are dealing with mostly teenagers under the age of 18. Sometimes those going to university for the first time may not have other people around them who could even advise them about the impact of this loan. And many had no choice, so they had to take out the loan. And it's that cohort that is now playing back at paying back under plan two, further penalized by the threshold change. So it's like more and more is being layered upon this particular cohort.
And we and I think there needs to be more fairness in the system.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I speak as the mother of three students, one of whom has just graduated to plan two and a plan five. And it was I was unaware, and I think they were, that they're not allowed to start repaying their debt until they graduate. And yet the interest starts from the very first day they take the loan, which is between three, four, or maybe even as suggested earlier, six, seven years. That adds between five and eight thousand pounds to the borrowing.
Did the committee look at this and have they made any recommendations on that specific issue?
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Certainly the committee in evidence we had some evidence around this. And there was but there is a logic to not paying it back while you're not because students mostly not working. So there would be a real challenge about paying it back while someone is an undergraduate or a graduate student. But I think what she's rightly highlighting there is that this has caught people a lot of people unaware, weren't aware of how much it ratchets up. So there's layer upon layer of complexity.
And the fact that parents don't even really all fully understand the impact of this. What the the bigger picture she raises that one she's got a child on plan two and plan five is that and I've looked at this over many years, that we keep the governments of different colors keep changing the student loan package. And each is more complicated almost more complicated than the next. So plan five is paid back over 40 years, plan two over 30. Try keeping up with that.
It's very confusing. And so the the government's commitment to greater transparency is welcome, but it's only a first step.
Catherine West
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And on the 27th of March 2026, the Minister for Skills wrote to the honorable member for Brentford and Isleworth confirming that the department would release an equalities impact assessment on student loan lifetime repayments and other borrower impacts for the plan two repayment threshold. Does the chair of the committee agree with me that it's high time that the equalities impact statement was published by the department?
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I think the honorable lady raised in that simple question a raft of issues. Because for many people, well most students, the only way they can go to university is a loan. And if there's been a big drive to get people to go to university who haven't been able to before, from partly because they may be from poorer backgrounds. This government of course has added in extra support through the maintenance grant and so on. But these are still huge costs on young people.
And it's really important that government in making decisions, especially as the government has committed to reviewing the student loans system, that it really understands the impacts on different cohorts.
Jim Dickson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank my honorable friend for her statement? And I was glad to be part of the committee which looked at ways in which we could start to make the student finance system fairer. Just on the issue of the threshold repayment freeze and whether we should reverse it. Does the does my honorable friend agree that we looked at a number of ways in which you could change the finances system to make it fairer, such as for instance freezing the interest rates or even cutting the interest rate cap?
But that reversing the threshold repayment freeze was the best way to get help to the great majority of those repaying loans, no matter what their incomes are.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Yeah, I think the my honorable friend and he as he said we looked at a number of of ways of changing things. But once you've got a a plan that's been set up and established, it's very difficult to unpick different parts of it. The threshold freeze though was an additional thing added on top of the plan two system. And that's why it seems particularly invidious. And it there is an opportunity that simple lever that the government can pull because it has not yet been implemented.
And it is easier. It is one of the easiest things I should say to the Chancellor if he wants looking for a quick win in the budget to deliver without causing more challenging ramifications. Pull that lever, it's done, and the biggest number of students benefit from that.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Can I thank my honorable friend for her committee's excellent work on the important issue of student loans and for the good communication that she maintained with my committee during her inquiry. The Education Select Committee concluded earlier this year that there is a genuine crisis in the financial sustainability of our universities as a result of many different pressures bearing down on them at the moment. Does she agree with me that if the government does not bring forward additional measures as she recommends to improve the long-term affordability of student loans, the risk is that more and more young people will decide not to pursue a university education and that this would not only mean that they miss out on the potentially transformative impact of such an education, but also serve further to undermine the financial viability of our universities.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank my honorable friend for for that question and for the excellent work that she and her committee does. We know that there is a crisis in the higher education system, but there is also a challenge, a huge challenge for those graduates who are paying off these loans. It is a multi-faceted picture. So I'm pleased that the government's looking at reviewing it, but a review and a new we've already just started people have just started plan five repayments. We're a review is still a long way off to seeing any changes.
And I think we do need to have this national conversation that I mentioned about the 50-50 balance. The society benefits from most graduates. Graduates aren't just taking, they're actually giving back. And it is really important that we recognize that in national conversation. And frankly, universities are really struggling partly because the way fees and and are structured, meaning they're not getting enough money, but actually it's still very expensive for the students.
So nobody is winning in this situation.
Sarah Russell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent has been in touch. He is a neonatal nutritionist. He is paying a marginal tax rate on his loan of 57%. Does the chair of the Select Committee agree with me that this is not an acceptable outcome socially and that we must have change.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank my honorable friend for that question. And when I've looked at this beyond before I was even on this committee and in previous roles, one of the challenges is that the the loan system is set up and lots of box ticking and spreadsheets happen in government departments in Whitehall a very long way from that 17-year-old who's taking out the loan and then starts paying it back after they graduate. And that we need to have them at the heart of the design. So obviously there is going to always be in government a discussion about where money is best spent and how much things cost in the short and medium and long term. But we need to make sure that graduates who are paying it back are at the heart of that discussion alongside the impact on higher education institutions.
Chris Kane
Thank you and can I can I thank her for her having a committee's excellent work. We want our young people to have confidence in their government to stick to their promises. Does she agree with me that this approach to student loans from successive governments has dented that trust and that government colleagues should reflect on that.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I think my honorable friend says it better than I could myself. There is a trust relationship. And in this case with a student loan, students have nowhere else to go for that that money. They signed up on certain terms and those terms have been changed over successive governments. And this latest threshold threshold freeze is just another one of those breaches of trust between the government and those who trusted in taking out a loan.
Danny Beales
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank the committee for their work and the report today. I completely agree with the presentation of the chair today about the level of mistrust there is amongst graduates and learners about the broken system. And does the chair agree with me that it's simply isn't a communications issue. It's not about telling people how bad the deal is they've got in clearer terms.
It's fundamentally a broken system and a bad deal that's having massive intergenerational impact. So does she agree with me that we need a full and thorough review into the student finance and loan system.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank my honorable friend and I, not only he and I agree on that and the committee, but actually government, the Secretary of State for Education herself has said there's problems and previous ministers have called it a broken system. There's a long way from moving from a broken system to a system that's fair and what what what this a lot of the focus of our recommendations were about those who are currently paying it back. It's difficult to right all of those wrongs for those people, that's why we think the threshold freeze being pulled back is an important step for them, but absolutely agree that there needs to be proper long-term thinking about how we fund education, how the loans book is structured, as well as obviously providing information to people, but it is a system that's not working as it is now.
Judith Cummins
If people wish to leave the chamber they should do so now very quickly. We now come to the select committee statement on behalf of the Public Accounts Committee. Anna Dixon will speak for up to 10 minutes during which no interventions may be taken. At the conclusion of her statement I will call members to ask questions on the subject of the statement. These should be brief questions, not full speeches.
Can I emphasize that questions should be directed to the select committee member and not the relevant government minister. Frontbenchers may take part in questioning. I call Anna Dixon.
Anna Dixon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm pleased to be giving this statement on behalf of the Public Accounts Committee, of which I am a member. Before I turn to the findings of our report on government compensation schemes, I want to begin by recognizing the individuals and families whose lives have been profoundly affected by the events that gave rise to these compensation schemes. Behind every application, every claim, and every payment is a person who has experienced loss, injustice, or harm, often through no fault of their own. No amount of money can ever fully restore what has been taken away. Compensation cannot return lost years, repair damaged health, rebuild broken trust, or erase the suffering that many have endured.
Nevertheless, where mistakes have been made, where public bodies have failed, or where citizens have been harmed by the actions or omissions of the state, compensation represents an important acknowledgment of that injustice. It is one of the clearest ways in which government can accept responsibility, recognize the experiences of those affected, and demonstrate a commitment to making amends. Properly designed and delivered, compensation is not simply a financial transaction. It is an expression of accountability and, crucially, of compassion. It signals that those who have suffered have been heard, that their experiences are believed, and that society recognizes the wrong that has been done to them.
For many people, the true value of a compensation scheme lies not only in the financial support it provides, but in the recognition and dignity it can offer. That is why it is so important that such schemes are fair, accessible, timely, and centered on the needs of those they are intended to serve. It is against the backdrop that the National Audit Office conducted a review into the way that compensation schemes have been handled, and the Public Accounts Committee conducted an inquiry whose findings were published last Wednesday. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to recognize the sub-postmasters and their families affected by the Horizon scandal, the victims and bereaved families of the infected blood scandal, the Windrush generation denied the right to remain in the UK, LGBT veterans, including Victoria in my constituency, whose service to her country was repaid with imprisonment and dismissal from the Royal Navy because of her sexuality, all of those whose experiences have informed the committee's work.
I want to particularly thank everyone who responded to our survey and everyone who gave evidence to our inquiry. Many of the testimonies we received were deeply moving and all were invaluable. If government is to improve how compensation schemes operate in future, it must listen carefully to the experiences of those who have already been through them. Our inquiry found that too often people experience lengthy delays, complex processes, and uncertainty about what will happen next. The vast majority of respondents to the Public Accounts Committee survey felt the schemes that had experienced were unfair.
Three quarters told us that the claims process itself had been distressing or retraumatizing. One respondent told us, it has become a lumbering slow bureaucracy. It is failing in its duty to get payments to people quickly. Another said, after decades of fighting for recognition, we believed we were finally at the finish line. And instead, we are being treated with suspicion as though we're trying to defraud a system rather than seeking acknowledgment of a wrong done to us by the state.
One of my own constituents, the wife of a postmaster, told me the stress caused by the Horizon scandal causing alopecia and a blood clot. On applying for compensation, she was told that her suffering was irrelevant despite being the co-owner of the post office. Compensation was paid to her husband from whom she is now divorced. These experiences highlight why the quality of scheme design matters so much and we heard many such similar stories. Compensation is not simply about the final payment.
It is about the journey people make to reach that point, a journey which must be fair, transparent, and humane. We heard from Sir Alan Bates, whose work was instrumental in exposing the Horizon scandal. He told us that schemes often end up reinventing the wheel and he argued for an independent organization capable of carrying expertise and experience from one scheme to the next. And that is what this report is recommending. Peter Gibson, the chief executive at Fighting with Pride representing LGBT veterans, highlighted the importance of making realistic commitments that can actually be delivered.
Kate Burt, representing those affected by infected blood, emphasized the importance of meaningful engagement with communities and ensuring that lessons from previous schemes are genuinely applied. Victims have lost trust in the bodies administering government compensation schemes, bodies which they view as responsible for the initial harm caused. The committee therefore recommends, and I'm pleased to see the Cabinet Office Minister on the front bench, recommends that the body administering compensation should work with individuals and organizations representing victims. Many claimants told us that they found it difficult to trust the processes administered by organizations that they associated with the original harm. And that's why witnesses repeatedly argued that independence is essential if schemes are to command confidence.
The answer is not to choose between independence and expertise. The answer is to combine them, to establish an independent body capable of developing specialist expertise, preserving institutional memory, promoting good practice, and earning the trust of those it's there to serve. So that's a key recommendation of this report, that the government establish an independent body to design and administer government compensation schemes. Madam Deputy Speaker, we should also remember that for many people the compensation process is not simply an administrative exercise. Making a claim often means revisiting some of the most painful experiences of a person's life.
It means being asked to recall events they've spent years trying to come to terms with. Gathering evidence from decades ago, recounting experiences of injustice, discrimination, illness, loss, and trauma, often to complete strangers.
The Committee heard repeatedly that the process itself can reopen old wounds. Witnesses spoke of victims feeling as though they were having to fight the same battle all over again. That is why good scheme design matters so much. It's not simply about how much compensation is awarded, it's about ensuring that the process to come to that outcome is compassionate and designed around the needs of those who've suffered. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I believe this report also highlights the unique role of the Public Accounts Committee.
Our role is to look across government to identify recurring challenges, to bring together evidence from different departments and ask what lessons can be learned. One of the clearest conclusions from our report is that the government requires stronger mechanisms for retaining and sharing knowledge across compensation schemes. Every compensation scheme is inevitably different, but the fundamentals of good scheme design are not. The Committee concluded that government needs a more systematic approach to applying what has been learned. Reverend Clive Foster, Windrush Commissioner, told us, "It is critical that impacted groups are involved in designing schemes from the outset, and that design is aligned with trauma-informed principles that consider how the claim process can be traumatizing for people."
Madam Deputy Speaker, compensation schemes exist to provide redress, but they should also provide confidence. Confidence that people will be treated fairly, confidence that lessons have been learned, confidence that future schemes will be better than those that came before. All those who shared their experiences with our Committee have given government a valuable opportunity to improve, and we should not waste it. Our responsibility now is to ensure those lessons are not lost, not stored away in reports, not revisited only when the next scandal emerges, but embedded permanently into how government approaches redress. The Committee's recommendation is therefore clear.
Government should establish an independent body to design and administer government compensation schemes, a body capable of retaining expertise, carrying lessons forward, capable of delivering redress swiftly, fairly, and with the confidence of those they serve. Above all, a body capable of restoring trust. The victims whose experience informed this inquiry deserve nothing less. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Thomas Gordon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank the honorable lady for that statement. I wondered if she might be able to outline if the Committee, during the course of its work, gave any consideration to looking at index-linking compensation payments in line with inflation. Obviously, these payments can take a very lengthy period before they can see, in which time the value that they've been awarded can have ended up being reduced. Was that something that the Committee looked at or would consider?
Anna Dixon
I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. No, that wasn't something that the Committee specifically looked at, but I totally agree with his point that many victims wait far too long, and that was something that repeatedly came up in the Committee about the length of time it took often to set up compensation schemes. The complexity of them often resulted in cases taking a long time to reach a decision and therefore for compensation to be awarded, and that was something that we urge the government to make sure is much more timely in future.
Liz Twist
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable lady for her report on the redress schemes, and it certainly reflects the experiences, I think, of my constituents who've been involved in some of those campaigns, and welcome particularly the idea of having an independent body looking at schemes. And I think here of the Hughes report into those affected by sodium valproate, mesh, and Primodos, who are still waiting for a decision.
This is life-changing stuff for constituents. Has the committee thought about how in those kind of situations we might speed up the response to those inquiries?
Anna Dixon
I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and as an officer of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Patient Safety, I'm very well aware that the Hughes report is still on the government inbox for response. And I also have constituents who are victims of the pelvic mesh scandal, obviously particularly impacting women. And I do hope that we will soon hear from the government what their response to that report is and hopefully they would be able to bring forward more swiftly a government compensation scheme that works, co-design it with the victims as our report recommends.
Rupert Lowe
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, can I just say how much I enjoy serving on the Public Accounts Committee with the honorable lady? And I think the key to correcting this, I'm sure she agrees with me, is for the government to make better decisions. There seem to be a series of bad decision-making which results in the necessity of these claims which do take too long to be heard. And I fully support the report from the committee which suggests we do need an independent body to ensure that the government is not seen to be marking its own homework and kicking the ball into the long grass for as long as it possibly can.
Anna Dixon
I thank the honorable gentleman and I guess return the compliment, although I'm not sure I do always enjoy his contributions to the Public Accounts Committee. But do certainly recognize that on this and other issues, it's also important to get behind the reasons why these scandals happened in the first place. That obviously was not the purpose of our committee. It was to look at the compensation schemes. But I do think there must also be valuable lessons learned about why these scandals occur in the first place, whether it is the Post Office, infected blood, or indeed the treatment of LGBT veterans in the armed forces.
So I do appreciate those points.
Chris Kane
Thank you. Can I thank colleagues on the Public Accounts Committee and at the National Audit Office for their work on this report? Groups representing victims expressed concern to our committee that government does not do enough to advertise and promote schemes, thus meaning some victims missing out. And the amount and type of evidence victims are required to submit a claim can make it difficult and re-traumatizing. Does my honorable friend agree with me that more care needs to be taken when designing schemes to ensure the process is not overly complex and burdensome and that these schemes need an outreach plan to maximize take-up?
Anna Dixon
I thank my honorable friend who is also another colleague on the Public Accounts Committee. I absolutely agree and the report is very clear that much more needs to be done to try and reach victims. There is a concern that the LGBT scheme is closing and there still remain victims. It's important that the institutions use the data they already hold to reach people directly and also that the evidential burden is as little as possible whilst still maintaining protections against fraud.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank my honorable friend for her statement and for the work of the Public Accounts Committee on this important issue? I have seen first-hand how unbelievably difficult it has been for my constituents who are victims of the Windrush scandal to get compensation from that scheme. The Windrush compensation scheme was not co-designed with victims and it forced victims to apply to the very department that had done them wrong for compensation through processes that were unwieldy and Kafkaesque in their bureaucracy.
So I welcome the recommendation of the Public Accounts Committee that there should be an independent body to oversee the design of compensation schemes. Would she also agree with me that it is wrong that victims of the Windrush scandal were not afforded access to independent legal representation in making their applications, and would she agree with me that this is something that the government still has the opportunity to correct and that it should do so forthwith?
Anna Dixon
I thank the honourable lady and for being such a champion for those in her own constituency who suffered from the decisions made that impacted the Windrush generation. And she's absolutely right. We heard significant evidence, not least from the Windrush Commissioner, about the poor treatment of people and the difficulties that they were having in seeking redress, in particular the complexity of that and, as she points out, the lack of legal support. It is a recommendation in here that where possible it's clear from the start whether victims would have access to legal support and a recommendation that that should be more consistent. So I do agree with her suggestion.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Final question, Dame Meg Hillier.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm pleased to see this report. It was back in January of 2024 that I asked the then, that I asked the Comptroller and Auditor General if the NAO would look at the compensation schemes. I'd looked at a number of them over my over decade on the Public Accounts Committee and different departments would set them up and they would be different foundations. So my question to the honourable lady is obviously she'll be waiting for the government's response on this in the next in the relevant set of Treasury minutes.
But when the committee was doing its thorough work looking into the schemes with the witnesses in front of them as comparison, are there a couple of good lessons that she, the committee, could take say that the new body, if the government agrees to set it up, which I hope it does, could take forward about an exemplar or even not one of the better compensation schemes?
Anna Dixon
I thank my honourable friend for that question and also commend her for all the years of work on the Public Accounts Committee and her leadership and foresight to make sure that the work was done by the National Audit Office. We did hear some examples. In particular, the infected blood scandal is not run by the Department of Health. It has a degree of independence being run out of the Cabinet Office, and I think that does make a difference. There were some examples where there had been some co-design with victims, but I think those examples were too seldom.
And unfortunately, across the ones that we looked at, there were simply too many examples of what went wrong. And I think it's the lesson learning of what went wrong that we need to make sure that in any future government compensation scheme, the emphasis is on co-design, on timeliness, and fairness for victims.
Daisy Cooper
Right, that concludes Select Committee statements. Point of order, Daisy Cooper.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Two small businesses in my constituency of St Albans, Smallford Farm Shop and Hatch, have just been hit with a revaluation from the VOA doubling their business rates bills overnight. It's taken the VOA 18 months to send this bill. The delay is entirely their fault, and but the VOA is backdating their liability by 18 months and demanding that they pay that bill right now, even though it could take a year for a challenge and an appeal. These businesses may not survive this shock.
The VOA cannot be allowed to behave like this. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, could you please advise how I can raise this with the relevant minister today, given the House is about to rise for a month, by which time it could be too late to prevent two local businesses from potentially closing down?
Judith Cummins
I understand that this is very important to the honourable lady, but she also knows because of her experience this is not a matter for the chair. But she's most definitely got her point on the record, and no doubt the Treasury front bench have noted that to ensure the right department hears of it. Point of order, Dame Meg Hillier.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week I met some of my constituents who were part of the Trans Solidarity Alliance lobby of Parliament. Unfortunately, and very unfortunately, when they were present, they heard overheard somebody who is a pass holder making negative comments about trans people. I'm sure, Madam Deputy Speaker, you would agree that this House, the mother of Parliament, should be welcoming to all people, particularly when they're on a mission to lobby their members of Parliament about issues of direct impact to them. And I wondered if there's any comment you would wish to make about how we can ensure that pass holders, well we can't control everyone, that pass holders are reminded of their importance of courtesy and that this place is a place of debate and discussion, not for negative comments about groups of people.
Judith Cummins
The honorable lady once again raises an important issue, but she is far more experienced than I even am, so she knows this is not a matter for the chair. If she wishes to pursue it, she can raise it with the Independent Complaints and Grievance Scheme, but I do not wish to get involved in matters that do not involve the chair. Right, if everybody is comfortable, presentation of bill, Secretary Louise Haigh.
Louise Margaret Haigh
Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provisions) Bill.
Judith Cummins
Monday the 12th of October. Marvelous. If the front bench are the shuffling, now is the time to shuffle over. Now come to the ten minute rule motion, Student Finance (Review), Tom Gordon.
Thomas Gordon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to declare an interest as a graduate with both a Plan 2 and a postgraduate loan. Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to require the Secretary of State to review student finance in England, to require the review to consider loan repayment arrangements and thresholds, to require the review to consider terms and conditions applying to student loans when they were issued, to require the review to consider the relationship between student finance, loan repayment thresholds and average earnings, and for connected purposes. Before I begin, I'd like to send my deepest condolences to the Prime Minister on the loss of his father. I'm sure the whole House will be thinking of them.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this is not the speech I intended to make. It's in fact not even the bill I thought I'd be presenting. I originally when I secured this slot was planning to bring forward a bill that would remove time restrictions on disability bus passes. And before I could even get to my feet or even table that bill, the Prime Minister handed me my first big win in Parliament, to which I am eternally grateful for him. I thank him for that and for his new approach to politics about problem solving, not point scoring.
I can only hope he continues in that spirit and hands me another big win today. Because the timing could not be any better. I would just like to start by paying tribute to the chair of the Treasury Select Committee and all the members of that select committee for their very thorough work on this matter that we heard about earlier. Their report asks, student loans, broken or unfair? And Madam Deputy Speaker, I think we all know the answer on both counts, both broken and very much unfair.
And let me be clear from the outset, this is not a single individual political party's failure. Every party that has sat on the government benches has had a bit of a shoddy record on this particular issue. Conservatives, Labour, and yes, even the Liberal Democrats, it might come as a surprise. Nobody comes to this debate of this chamber on this issue with their hands clean. And honesty has to start with these three things.
That repayment thresholds, the terms that graduates were sold, and whether those thresholds have kept pace with earnings.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I grew up in an ex-mining town in a working-class family. My mum had me when she was 18 and I was very much the first person in my family to go to university. For people like me, taking out a student loan wasn't an option, it was a necessity, it was not a luxury, and it was the only way that I could go through the door of university, which saw me take up a biochemistry degree and a masters in public health at Newcastle University. Today my student loans combined stand at over £65,000. Between my two loans, 15p of every extra pound I earn goes on repayments on top of tax.
And this is the cruelest part for many people across this country: the poorer your family, the more you have to borrow. In 2016, maintenance grants for the poorest students were scrapped and replaced with loans, so that students who have the least borrow the most. Graduates with the biggest debts are then charged interest on every penny of it. A system that was meant to be a ladder of opportunity has become a penalty for being born poor. This is not social mobility, it is social injustice with interest.
When I signed up, like millions of others, I was told a story. The Department for Education slides compared repayments to a mobile phone contract, about £15 a month or so we were told. Government-commissioned videos told teenagers the threshold would rise with earnings, sold like a phone contract, paid back like a second income tax. The Treasury Select Committee examined those materials and concluded they amounted to mis-selling. No other lender in this country would be allowed to sell a loan to an 18-year-old on one set of terms only to rewrite them before the ink was barely even dry.
If a bank did this, the regulator would shut it down. When the government does it, they call it a policy change because ministers wrote themselves out of the Consumer Credit Act and they've been getting away with it ever since. And with no regulator watching, borrowers are left in the dark. Now, many of my university friends when they saw I had this ten-minute rule bill, suddenly my phone and WhatsApp groups that hadn't been active in a number of years lit up with everyone getting in touch. One of my friends, Jasmine, was telling me that she was refused a straight answer on what she owed, then her balance jumped by a few thousand pounds because interest had not been properly added back in 2021.
In her words, I am livid. And my friend Rebecca had to open a case just to get back a refund she was owed. No customer of any other lender would put up with that. In 2010, the universities minister told this House that the threshold would rise periodically to reflect average earnings and that the government was committed to the progressive nature of a repayment system. That was not a hope, that was a promise made in this place.
And it has been broken again and again by governments of all persuasion, and we saw those thresholds for repayments being frozen again at the last budget for another three years from April 2027. And on top of this is a system where the interest piles up that you take out on that loan before you can even repay a penny. Where you earn more, the higher the interest rate you're charged. Madam Deputy Speaker, at its heart, this is an issue about fairness and the injustice does not fall evenly. My friend Rebecca, she took maternity leave.
While she was at home with her newborn, not making repayments and not earning, her balance rose by the best part of £2,000 in interest. Women are being charged interest for starting a family. Thinking of those living with long-term health conditions who cannot work full-time or have to take time off sick, they're already fighting their bodies and now they watch their debt grow while their earnings often stall. This is damaging to our public services and to our economy. I've heard from people who are turning down promotions because after tax and loan repayments, the extra pay is simply not worth the extra responsibility.
I've heard from doctors refusing extra shifts because once higher tax rates added, national insurance and the student loan repayments, they keep less than half of every extra pound. And at a time when our NHS is calling out for extra staff and extra support, we are punishing those very people for trying to work harder.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we have a generation on track to be the first in modern times to be worse off than their parents. They did everything they were told, they worked hard, they went to university, they tried to better themselves. And what did they get in return? Well, in addition to a housing crisis, in addition to a property ladder with the bottom rung sawn off, and a really grim graduate jobs market, they've been added on top a 9% tax that they will earn on everything above the threshold before it ever reaches their bank account. I have friends who've put off having children because they cannot afford childcare while hundreds of pounds a month leave their payslip in student loan repayments.
This is an injustice at its starkest. A generation told to borrow for the future, now paying for it with their future. The Prime Minister has rightly talked about bringing back hope. I agree with him wholeheartedly. And there is no better place to start than honouring the deal that my generation were promised.
So how has the government responded to the Treasury Select Committee's cross-party call to reverse the freeze, which it called a moral obligation? It says keeping all aspects of the student finance system under review. But it doesn't sound like it's going to reverse that freeze. Martin Lewis called it a very disappointing response that does little to help the millions of students already struggling right now. The government's answer is, in effect, we will do better for future students.
But millions of graduates are already paying under these terms today. They cannot wait for a better system to be built for people who have not yet borrowed a penny. Madam Deputy Speaker, I said at the start that every party of government has a hand in this. And I say it again because it is exactly that point why I believe we can reach a cross-party consensus. No party can claim the moral high ground, so every party can help be part of the solution.
So my message to the government, my message to the Prime Minister is simple. In the spirit of problem solving, not point scoring, can this government commit to a genuine fix? Not another promise to keep things under review, looking honestly at the deal graduates were promised and the deal they are getting. Restore the link between repayment thresholds and earnings, guarantee that terms will not be changed after people have signed them, and put right the wrongs that have already been done. And let's make sure that fix reaches every borrower, not just those who are yet to walk through a university's door.
The Prime Minister has already shown this House that when he hears a good case, he acts on it. And I'm asking him to do that again. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Select Committee asked whether student loans are broken and unfair, and we know the answer. The only question left is whether together we will commit to putting it right. I'd just like to add before I finish and conclude the absolute tremendous efforts of Rethink Repayment and Ollie Gardner and the team who've been pushing on this issue.
For the best part of two years internally within my own party, I've been banging the drum to try and make this an issue that we Liberal Democrats can be part of the solution. And I'm really, really pleased that we've seen members from across this House add their names in support of this ten-minute rule bill. So I commend this bill to the House.
Judith Cummins
The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. Many as that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no, I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?
Thomas Gordon
Vicky Slade, Liz Jarvis, Ed Davey, Dr Danny Chambers, Sian Berry, Cat Eccles, Cat Smith, Christine Jardine, Layla Moran, Ruth Cadbury, Alex Sobel and myself.
Tom Gordon. Student Finances Review Bill. Second reading what day?
Judith Cummins
Friday the 15th of January 2027. Wonderful, our front bench is itching to shuffle over, then do so now. No, no, no, you can't, it's a live dispatch box, you've got to go around. If the front benches on both sides are ready, Mr. Simmonds, if you're marvelous. We now come to the backbench debate on the potential benefits of a full ban on fracking.
I call Clay Young, who will speak for around 15 minutes. Clay.
Claire Louise Young
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to the Backbench Business Committee for selecting this debate and for giving me the opportunity to lead it. In December 2025, the Minister for Energy told this chamber that the evidence base is not there at the moment to suggest that low-volume hydraulic fracturing activities have the same associated risks as fracking for shale gas. I'm leading this debate because I want to challenge that statement and bring the government's attention to why I and many others believe that the understanding of fracking that the minister refers to is not suited for purpose, and I want this House to consider the evidence for that argument. Let me begin with the point that matters most.
We do not have a ban on fracking in this country. We have a moratorium, and the two are not the same. A moratorium is a pause, and a pause can be lifted. The previous Energy Secretary, currently the Foreign Secretary, told his party conference last autumn that this government would legislate to ban fracking for good. This government has been in power for two years, and yet I've seen no indication that a full ban is due.
Maybe the minister will care to correct me, but it seems that this government is not taking decisive action to stop all fracking activity. The reason this activity continues is because of a legal loophole, and it is worth being precise about it. The Petroleum Act 1998 defines fracking by the volume of fluid injected: more than 1,000 cubic meters at any single stage, or more than 10,000 cubic meters in total. Stay below those figures and the moratorium simply does not apply. The intent is identical to fracking, the technique is identical.
A company injects fluid at high pressure to fracture rock and release the gas inside. But because the volume is lower, the law treats it as something else entirely and waves it through. At Burniston, on the edge of the North York Moors, Europa Oil and Gas proposed exactly this: a so-called proppant squeeze at volumes designed to sit just under the threshold. In correspondence obtained under freedom of information, the company itself referred to the operation as fracking. In its planning material, it insisted that it was not.
The label changes, the drilling rig does not. The Reform Mayor of Scarborough said, "Frack ahead," although the local council voted unanimously against the plans and the Secretary of State did not choose to overrule that. However, I am concerned about the direction this is taking. Before I move on, I would like to insert a small caveat. I'm supportive of the geothermal sector, it's a genuinely renewable source of energy.
And a small number of geothermal cases employ low-volume hydraulic stimulation. My case for a permanent ban asks for fracking to be classified by intent, and therefore makes sure that the geothermal would not be under threat.
So I want to be clear that lower-volume fracking as a form of fracking is something entirely different.
I will give way.
Richard Tice
I'm most grateful to the honorable lady for giving way. Could she try and just clarify a little more on this? Because when you have a seismicity event of Richter scale, let's say, one with a hydraulic frac for energy treasure of gas, how is that different from the seismicity of one on a geothermal site? It's the same seismicity, it's the same event. It's sort of scarily called an earthquake, but it's not, in to all intents and purposes.
It's about the equivalent of moving rapidly from behind your desk on a chair. What is the difference between the two?
Claire Louise Young
I would like to clarify that I'm not suggesting that we should judge these things by seismicity, because those are not things that you can predict in advance. The point is that in one you are extracting fossil fuels. When with the geothermal, that's not the effect that you're having. I think it's a different process with a different effect.
Alex Sobel
The Burniston site she talked about, North Yorkshire County Council Planning Committee rejected it not just on seismicity grounds, but on issues about groundwater, groundwater pollution, traffic and a whole range of other issues. Aren't these sort of low-level fracking sites that are coming up, that are technically legal, still have a range of issues for us to deal with?
Claire Louise Young
Thank you very much for your intervention. I quite agree, and I think that's the point that probably best explains the point that maybe I was managing to do, which is that other issues like the potential for groundwater contamination are different in the situation where you are fracking for fossil fuels. Yeah, so ministers tell us that the evidence base is not there to show that lower-volume fracturing carries the same risk as fracking for shale gas. I would gently say to the government that the evidence is there and it's sitting in their own records. The earthquakes that triggered the 2019 moratorium at Preston New Road did not follow some enormous injection.
They followed a series of lower-volume stages, every one of them below legal threshold. The tremor that shook Lancashire, felt across the area at magnitude 2.9, came in the days after a stage that used just 142 cubic meters of fluid. The then Oil and Gas Authority concluded it was not possible to predict the timing or size of these events. The volumes proposed at Burniston were higher than the volume that caused that earthquake. This matters well beyond seismicity.
It matters for our countryside, for the rural communities and protected landscapes that would host this drilling and gain almost nothing in return. It matters for our waters, as has already been mentioned. Parts of Yorkshire were under hosepipe ban in 2025, and yet we are asked to pump scarce water deep underground and accept the risk of contaminating the aquifers that families and farms depend on. And it matters for the climate. Every new source of onshore gas means more methane, more emissions, and a direct collision with the carbon budgets this House has voted for, not to mention our net zero ambitions.
I know there are voices, Reform amongst them, who say that the answer to high bills is to return to fossil fuels and to frac our way out of trouble. I understand the appeal of a simple answer, but it's the wrong one. Gas is priced on an international market. Drilling a handful of wells in the English countryside would not move that price, and the companies doing the drilling would sell at whatever the market pays.
Fracking would not take a single pound off a family's bill. What it would do is divide communities, tie up local councils in years of planning battles, and lock us into the very fuel whose price swings caused the crisis in the first place. We would be more exposed, so I question their intentions.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Will the honorable member help me out, that fracking is a massive scar on the countryside, far more visible and far more disruptive than, for example, an onshore wind turbine?
Claire Louise Young
Absolutely, and I'm just about to come to this point, because in many cases the very same people that would argue for fracking will argue that they would want fewer wind farms, fewer solar farms and renewable energy sources due to their blotting of the countryside. So I ask those voices, how is fracking supporting the upkeep of our countryside? How is it better than those other uses, which would produce clean energy, and how is contaminating our water supply helping anyone? The honest route to lower bills and to real energy security is the one this country is already capable of taking: cheap, clean, homegrown power. And by that I mean renewables, but also in my own constituency, the prospect of new nuclear at Oldbury shows the part that low-carbon generation can play alongside renewables in a secure system.
That is where the jobs are, that is where the investment should be flowing, and that is the future. So let me come to my ask, and it is a single, clear one. I feel as if this government may need some clarity. I ask the minister to commit today to defining fracking by its purpose and its effect, not by an arbitrary measure of fluid used, so that every form of hydraulic fracturing is captured, the loophole is closed, and the permanent ban this government has promised is written into law rather than left in a conference speech and forgotten. Our countryside, our water, and our climate deserve nothing less.
Thank you.
The question is as on the order paper, and I call Alison Hume.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable member for Thornbury and Yate for securing a debate on this important issue. I first became aware of small-scale fracking when Europa Oil & Gas applied to explore for gas at Burniston, a village just on the edge of the picturesque North York Moors in my constituency of Scarborough and Whitby. I was surprised to discover that companies can still submit applications of this kind, surprised that it wasn't blocked by the moratorium on fracking, which was introduced after earthquakes linked to fracking operations in 2019 at Preston New Road in Lancashire. And it turns out it's because UK legislation defines fracking based on fluid volume thresholds: 1,000 cubic meters per stage or 10,000 cubic meters in total. This leaves a legal loophole for oil and gas companies to exploit.
So because Europa Oil & Gas's plans fall below the legal threshold, they are not calling it fracking, but proppant squeeze instead. Let's be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, proppant squeeze is just hydraulic fracturing at lower fluid volumes. The intent and technique are the same.
Europa wants to explore for and to extract gas through causing the rock to fracture by injecting a substance into it at pressure. This is fracking. There is strong evidence to suggest that small-scale fracking carries the same risks as larger-scale operations, particularly around seismicity. A report recently published by Professor Haszeldine at the University of Edinburgh found that earthquakes from high-volume fracking and low-volume fracking are equally large and equally unpredictable. And this echoes findings commissioned by the then Oil and Gas Authority into events at Preston New Road, which also showed that seismic impacts cannot be accurately predicted regardless of fluid volume.
Faced with this advice, why would we take the risk of allowing small-scale fracking to continue? Other environmental concerns with fracking remain too. These include potential groundwater contamination from methane migration or the chemicals in frac fluid, methane leaks, air pollution, and damage to the landscape. And of course, fracking at any volume leads to more greenhouse gas emissions, which contributes to climate change. After experiencing the hottest summer on record, I hope the environmental consequences of continued gas extraction are at the forefront of our minds.
In our manifesto, we committed to ban fracking. Our forthcoming Energy Independence Bill commits to do the same. However, unless we implement a full ban on fracking, companies like Europa Oil and Gas will continue to exploit the existing loophole. Rathlin Energy are about to start small-scale fracking at their West Newton site in East Yorkshire, one of 66 current licenses across the country. Our Labour government talks about banning fracking and safeguarding the places we love.
And I have the greatest respect for the Minister and I appreciate the time that the Department has spent discussing this issue with me. But respectfully, does he not see that unless the government acts boldly and closes the loophole, communities across the country such as those in West Newton and Burniston will have fracking operations on their doorstep. These communities love where they live. Don't they count? It doesn't matter to them whether it's a mini-frac or the full-scale version.
The net result is the same: drill pads, drill heads, gas flare and noise, 24/7 lights during the exploration stage, and continuous HGV lorry movements. We cannot categorically say it is safe for the environment either. The government has called for more evidence on the safety of small-scale, sorry, of small-scale fracking, but the sad truth is it looks like the evidence will be gathered on the back of another incident like Preston New Road. I don't want this for my community in Burniston, as I'm sure other honourable members and friends do not want it for theirs. Madam Deputy Speaker, unless we legislate to ban all forms of fracking in our upcoming Energy Independence Bill, then our fracking ban will be symbolic rather than material.
We have a unique opportunity to show climate leadership. We have an opportunity as a government to stand up to the frackers, to make our legislation watertight, to safeguard the natural environment, listen to the concerns in our communities, and to meet our climate commitments. By introducing a comprehensive ban based on process and intent, we can finally put an end to fracking once and for all.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Thornbury and Yate, on securing this important debate and for her excellent introduction. I also have to say I have full solidarity with the communities of the honorable lady from North Yorkshire. In my nearby Bath in 2015, there was a threat to fracking. So I know exactly what the arguments are.
I know exactly how fearful the communities are if this is coming to them. And therefore, we all have to stand together to support her and her community to stop fracking. We Liberal Democrats have long been calling for a complete and permanent ban on fracking. Fracked fuel is a fossil fuel. It cements our reliance on expensive gas and it flies in the face of our net zero commitments.
It also flies in the face of protecting our environment. I don't know who ever has made this argument that an onshore wind turbine or a solar panel is a scar on our natural environment, but fracking isn't. It's the biggest scar that we can inflict on our communities and we should not be fooled. The gases produced by fracking contribute directly to global warming and climate change, the effects of which are not a distant threat but already taking place. In the UK this summer, 28,000 deaths were linked to extreme heat.
Wildfires destroyed homes in our countryside. Over 25 million people faced restrictions on their water use. We cannot continue to support the energy of the past but must urgently replace it.
Will my honorable friend give way?
Martin Wrigley
I thank my honorable friend for giving way. Perhaps like me, she may have seen several screenings of the People's Emergency Briefing over the summer recess. That paints a devastating picture of what happens if we continue down this route, which would include fracking. Does she agree with me that we need a national briefing to educate people on this issue?
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
I thank him for his contribution and I absolutely agree. It is important that across the country, people understand why here in Parliament and the UK government must lead on climate change. There are many, many people already aware, but there's also still a lot of misinformation spreading around, trying to sort of reset the progress that we have already made. We have to not get distracted by the naysayers and what the people I call the flat-earthers, I know that's a bit of an insult, but this is science. Yeah, it is science and we must listen to the science.
Not only does fracking contribute to climate change, it is also very unsustainable in other ways. It demands vast amounts of water, which is completely at odds with public safety and security when droughts are becoming increasingly common. Additionally, the pollutants, as has already been mentioned, released from fracking sites affect air and water quality, posing serious health risks to local communities living nearby. Low-volume fracking is clearly linked to unpredictable earthquakes and poses a serious threat to public safety. Yet there are currently multiple proposals for low-volume fracking across Yorkshire and Lancashire, and my honorable friend has already explained the difference.
These cannot be permitted to go ahead. In fact, the current legal definition of high-volume fracking would not even cover the activities of Cuadrilla in the lead-up to the earthquake caused by fracking at their Preston New Road site in Lancashire. This is despite the moratorium being introduced as a consequence of this very earthquake. Fracking is not sustainable and it is not safe. It is incomprehensible that in 2026, it is not banned outright.
The government's proposal to end new onshore oil and gas licensing is a welcome step in the right direction, but it does not go far enough. It would have no impact on areas that are already licensed for fracking, which would remain covered only by a moratorium which can easily be overturned. It would fail to close the loopholes in the moratorium by hydraulic fracturing as defined only by high fluid volume thresholds.
The public supports a ban on fracking. In fact, when asked to choose, 60% of people would rather have a solar farm nearby than a fracking site for very, very good reasons. Labour made their position on fracking very clear before they came into power. They pledged in their 2024 manifesto to ban fracking for good. Yet now that they're in power, the government seems to have forgotten about their pledge.
The Energy Independence Bill, as has already been mentioned, is an opportunity for the government to honour their promise and deliver a full ban on fracking. The bill must do three things. First, it must close the loopholes which allows applications for damaging low volume fracking and other harmful fracking techniques like acid fracturing. Second, it must introduce a permanent ban in law. This would put an end to the current situation where fracking is permitted simply because a minister needs to make a statement to reverse the moratorium.
And third, it must ensure that a ban on fracking applies to all areas covered by existing licenses. I urge the government to act now and introduce a full ban on fracking to protect the security and safety and health of the public and our environment. Thank you.
Phil Brickell.
Michael Philip Brickell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the member for Thornbury and Yate on securing this debate? And as a keen environmentalist, I want to speak in support of a full and permanent ban on fracking today. In my constituency, people care deeply about our shared natural environment. They care about access to nature.
They care about protecting the landscapes that define our communities. I see that every time I visit the West Pennine Moors and enjoy our local landscapes. Those moors and fields are a place of recreation, reflection and escape and they are part of our local identity in Bolton West. What they are not is a resource to be gambled with in pursuit of a speculative industry that has never enjoyed public support in my constituency. Now way back in 2015, there were demonstrations against fracking in Horwich after the then Conservative government granted licenses to drill there, in Blackrod, in Rivington and in Belmont.
And many of us will remember even larger demonstrations against fracking in neighbouring Lancashire over the years. Local people consistently turned out in their droves because they were worried about the consequences for their communities, their environment and their quality of life. And it is impossible not to mention the extraordinary events of 2022. The then Prime Minister Liz Truss effectively turned a vote on fracking into a confidence vote in her own government. And that evening, fracking extracted her from her job far more effectively than it has ever extracted shale gas.
Fracking became a symbol of a political establishment refusing to listen to communities and refusing to recognise where public opinion had already moved. My own concerns have always been primarily environmental and ecological. And these are fears raised still to this day repeatedly by my constituents. Indeed, my friend, Horwich resident and long-standing environmental activist Stewart put it more clearly than I'd be able to. He told me that for him, the biggest problem is the toxic chemicals entering the watercourse.
And it's an echo of the sentiments rightly expressed by my honourable friend the member for Scarborough and Whitby earlier in this debate today.
Now that captures the heart of the issue. People are worried about the risk of pollution to the water table and the wider environment. Indeed, once groundwater is contaminated, the damage can last for generations. So let us today ask ourselves one simple question. Is fracking really worth it?
The reality is that fracking has always asked communities to take environmental risks in exchange for highly uncertain rewards. And the truth is that the country at large has never bought into it.
I will give way.
Chris Kane
Thank you very much. I'm struck in my constituency how there are those who work in the oil and gas industry and those who are pushing for more solar or more renewables. When it comes to fracking, it's the one area where both sides are likely to find agreement that it is not wanted and it is not supported. Does he also find in his constituency that that common ground around fracking being something that no one wants is evident?
Michael Philip Brickell
I thank my honourable friend for his contribution and that expectation that across the divide there is opposition to fracking is something I certainly see in my mailbox in Bolton West. Madam Deputy Speaker, my constituents know all about the costs of industrial exploitation. Back in the late 19th century, the North West was a hotbed of industrial extraction. Coal mining in particular left its mark across the moors and surrounding communities in a way that still scars landscapes and still undermines ecological wellbeing. We should not spend the 2020s trying to recreate the energy debates of 50 years ago.
Instead, we should be embracing the technologies of the future. That is exactly why I proudly stood on Labour's manifesto commitment to make Britain a clean energy superpower. It's a commitment this government is now delivering through its clean power mission and its commitment to legislate for a ban on fracking. But the choice is not between fracking and keeping the lights on. The choice is between investing in the industries of the future or clinging to the arguments of the past.
And I know which side of that choice my constituents are firmly on. Indeed, just last year, 200 jobs were secured at Hitachi Astemo in Horwich following a 100 million pounds of investment. That was investment into the electric vehicle supply chain. Turning our back on fracking but embracing those opportunities of the future. And that is a powerful vote of confidence in my constituency because those are exactly the kinds of jobs we should be championing.
High-skilled, high-tech jobs that support clean economic growth while driving the transition to that renewable economy of the future. Not speculative drilling. Not fossil fuel dependency. Not reopening arguments that communities settled many years ago. And after successive record-breaking temperatures and growing evidence of man-made climate change, reducing emissions and accelerating the transition to clean power is not optional.
It is essential. A full ban on fracking protects communities, it protects our environment, it protects treasured landscapes like the West Pennine Moors and the surrounding fields. It sends a clear signal that Britain's future lies not beneath the ground in ever harder to reach fossil fuels, but in the clean industries, innovation and jobs that will power the decades ahead. For those reasons, I strongly support a full ban on fracking.
Richard Tice.
Richard Tice
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, this is a fascinating debate full of nonsense and misinformation. Let's just set the context, shall we, of what we're talking about. This is not actually a debate about fracking, it turns out it's a debate about gas, shale gas for example.
And I just urge the honourable members in this House and those watching to just ask ourselves, why is it that everybody in this country is arguing and distressed and concerned about the price of electricity and energy? Why is it that the price of gas in the United States is a mere 20% of the price of gas here in the United Kingdom? Well I can tell honourable members, it's because for the last 20 plus years, yes, the United States has been enjoying the benefit of shale gas that they have extracted through one method of extraction which is called fracking or hydraulic fracking. I'm delighted to give way to the honourable lady.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
What figures of comparisons, how much fracked fuel we can actually produce in this country compared to the US?
Richard Tice
I'm delighted to, Madam Deputy Speaker, to assist the honourable lady who's clearly not informed whatsoever. We have somewhere between 30 and 50 years of gas for the whole of the United Kingdom available onshore in Lincolnshire alone, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Lincolnshire alone, there is some 10 years' worth of shale gas, a decade's worth for the United Kingdom that could generate thousands and thousands and thousands of jobs. So the context of this is very simple. In the United States, it has been transformational to the US economy.
It's the reason they have much lower gas prices, it's the reason they have much lower electricity prices. And in Lincolnshire alone, as I was just explaining, Madam Deputy Speaker, the density of shale gas in the Gainsborough Trough is believed to be double that of the most productive shale gas in Pennsylvania of the Marcellus Shale. So the opportunity is enormous. And even if honourable members were to disagree with me completely, which I suspect may be the case, maybe a middle ground might be to say, well before we make a seismic decision, maybe the answer might be to do a proper test that could be independently monitored, independently supervised and checked for, let's say, a year or two years, I'm a generous man of course. And that can then be verified.
And you could do that with a number of different wells using a number of different techniques because there are indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, numerous different extraction techniques depending on the depth to which one goes. There's some 11 techniques that can be included, including low-volume hydraulic fracking, including high-volume hydraulic fracking, including acidic oscillation and on and on the list goes. Why would we be so dogmatic, so stubborn, but bluntly so negligent against the financial interests and prosperity of all of our citizens to refuse to use this glorious energy treasure that has made the United States so wealthy? The potential is enormous. Tens and tens of billions of investment into our community, tens and tens and tens and tens and tens more billions of tax revenue potential.
Community benefits, enormous. Delighted to give way to the honourable gentleman.
Martin Wrigley
I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. I understand that he thought last summer, whilst being the hottest on record, was actually more of a millionaire's paradise than the awful situation it was for many in our country. Does he not understand the science of climate change that he is encouraging that we continue to aggravate, or is he simply a flat-earther entirely?
Richard Tice
I thank the honourable gentleman for his contribution, but I really do think we have to get real here.
The climate has changed for millions of years, and it will continue. There is not a scrap of evidence, Madam Deputy Speaker, that net zero, which is a new concept of about a decade, that all of a sudden you get to net zero and that's going to stop climate change. I mean, for example, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, I'm doing well, I'm in full flow before I come back to the honorable lady. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, it said in its, I think it was sixth report, that even if you got to net zero tomorrow, it would take somewhere between, they did say this with high confidence, which is reassuring, they said it would take somewhere between 200 years on the one context and 1,000 years on the other context to make any difference whatsoever to sea level rise. Maybe the smarter thing to do is to adapt to climate change than think you can stop it.
But I come back to the essence of the debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, which is the importance of having the decision as to whether we as a nation are prepared to impoverish ourselves by writing off one of the greatest treasure opportunities that we have. That almost any other nation in the world that has got this energy treasure, quite rightly, quite sensibly, financially productively, uses that energy treasure. But the mood of this place is no, we're going to impoverish ourselves. We're not going to use that treasure. We're going to make people ever poorer because we're going to insist on putting all our bets on renewable energy that we keep being told is going to be cheaper and cheaper and cheaper, but actually we now know from the experts, even if the price of gas goes to zero by the time of the next general election, Madam Deputy Speaker, our energy bills will be higher because the costs of renewables are going up and up and up.
And guess what? When the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shine, which occasionally happens here in the United Kingdom, you need backup. And so it's basic common sense. I give way to the honorable lady.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
I thank the gentleman for giving way. The honorable gentleman has made extraordinary claims about the reserves of shale gas, but there's currently no proven, commercially proven reserves of shale gas in the UK, and yet he is suggesting that there are billions and billions, tens of billions at hand just to be plucked, whereas the evidence actually shows that the cost of renewables is going down constantly. So I ask the honorable gentleman to pay courtesy to the conventions of the House that we speak truth in this place and to cite his sources.
Richard Tice
Absolutely I will cite the sources. Look at everybody's energy bills, they're going up and up and...
Speaker 216
Order. Now the honorable lady did point out the conventions and courtesies of the House. She has to ask the honorable member if he will give way, and it's also, and this might be helpful for everybody, if interventions are going to take place they should be through the chair. Please don't face the back of the chamber, it makes it incredibly hard for the microphones to pick up comments and indeed is quite discourteous to the chair to turn your back on me. Richard Tice.
Richard Tice
I'm grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the honorable lady asks a fair question as to the evidence. Well, the evidence is from the experts who I've just cited, who say that even if the price of gas goes to zero, our energy bills are going up and up and up. The next bit of evidence, Madam Deputy Speaker...
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way. I'm requesting that he cites his sources for the claims he has made as to the reserves of shale gas in this country.
Richard Tice
I was just coming onto that indeed. The British Geological Survey has, for example, made clear, clear estimates that there are vast sums.
No, there are, there have been tests, Madam Deputy Speaker, into the Gainsborough Trough, which is why I made the claim about the density, Madam Deputy Speaker. And then of course there is the evidence of successful businesspeople who invested hundreds and hundreds of millions of pounds because they had done the geological work and they realized that it is a huge, huge opportunity. And they are still there. And that is the evidence, because when people are prepared to invest sums of money, you know that they've done the research. And I just come back to this point.
It is gross negligence of the highest order, frankly probably of a criminal order, to refuse to even try. To not even say, okay Richard, I disagree with you, but let's have an independent test. A couple of years, a couple of different sites, a couple of different techniques, surely as a middle ground, because in the possible event, Madam Deputy Speaker, that those on my side of the debate are correct and those on the other side of the debate are incorrect, surely we have then taken advantage of this great opportunity. I then come on to, because I realize that time is pressing.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
In, Madam Deputy Speaker, in the spirit of sort of cooperation, saying, all right, even if we did this, could he explain the damage and disruption to communities in the UK if we tried on the scale as the US has done, where there are vast amounts of empty country with no people disrupted by fracking? Can he explain how that compares and how disruptive it would be for our communities in the UK?
Richard Tice
I'd delight to do. She makes, the honorable lady makes an excellent point. There are some 20 million people in the United States who live within a mile of fracking pads, shale gas pads, whatever one might wish to call them. In Lincolnshire, I have seen the numerous nodding donkeys, oil drilling wells, just in, in my county of Lincolnshire. You wouldn't know they're there because guess what, they're hidden behind trees.
And contrary to some information that a previous honorable member said, actually the reality is that a, a shale gas well, once it is drilled, you barely know it exists. It's a couple of meters high. And you can have ten pads on the size of about two football pitches, behind trees, no one would even know they are there. The misinformation, the false information, the deliberate, deliberate nonsense being peddled is depriving this great country of the opportunity to reduce our bills. Because if we carry on as we are, then our bills are going up and up and up.
Indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, just today we hear that the forecast increase in bills for I think January will be at least 15%. So we should at least have the courage to explore some alternatives. And I, I need to deal with this whole issue of, of seismicity. Some people call it earthquakes, which is a very scary sounding thing. And at the Preston Road site in near Blackpool, there was a limit of just 0.5 on the Richter scale, 0.5, which now, because the Richter scale is logarithmic, 0.5 is the equivalent of one of the clerks to the House from just gently moving their chair backwards and standing up as they leave at the end of the day.
That is 0.5. Honorable members might, might to think of if they, if they stood up, if they had a melon in their hand and they held it to shoulder height and they dropped it, just here, that would be about 1.5 on the Richter scale.
But if a bus were to go past your house, that would be in the order of 2.5, which is about the equivalent of the sort of limits applied to construction sites. So I just think we need some appropriate context, some appropriate understanding as to the realities of the situation. And I think that the opportunities here must be worth at least exploring. And I fully accept for those who have a different view to us on issues around renewables, we can all agree diversity can be a wonderful thing, diversity of technologies and sources. And maybe one day, I'm 62, Madam, maybe after I'm long dead, renewables might be cheaper.
But at the moment, that is not the evidence. Whereas the evidence in the United States is that shale gas is driving bills all the way down. So I think that we owe it to ourselves... I give way. I give way to the honourable lady.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank the honourable member for giving way. And I wonder if he would accept he's somewhat a voice in the wilderness, because fracking is unpopular with Reform voters. They don't want it. I'm standing here representing my constituents, Madam Deputy Speaker, in Scarborough and Whitby. Can he honestly say he's doing the same for his in Boston and Skegness?
Richard Tice
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I can absolutely say that to the honourable lady, indeed to the good constituents across Lincolnshire. And maybe therefore, rather than arrogantly in this place just thinking we're going to ban this process across the whole United Kingdom, given that the new Prime Minister is keen on devolution, maybe this decision indeed could be devolved to individual counties that have the energy treasure. Maybe the joy of Lincolnshire jobs for Lincolnshire gas, Lincolnshire gas for Lincolnshire jobs for Lincolnshire growth. It's like a patriotic dream in the great county of Lincolnshire.
I give way to the honourable gentleman.
Chris Kane
I wonder, Madam Deputy Speaker, if it was devolved, and even in a devolved world, the entire country said, "We do not want fracking in all of our devolved places", how would he feel about it then?
Richard Tice
That's democracy, Madam Deputy Speaker. At least I would have put forward my arguments to everybody and people would have had an individual choice, as opposed to what feels to me a somewhat overarching umbrella of, "No, you naughty, naughty children, you must not consider this", even though the evidence around the world is that actually, where there is cheap gas, guess what, you get higher GDP growth per person. And it's so important people understand this, because in the 80s and 90s, our energy use per person increased by some 20%, but yet in the last 20 years, our energy use per person has tragically declined by some 20%, whilst our GDP per person has collapsed from in the 80s and 90s over 3% per person per year to just about 0.5% per person per year. Maybe there is a direct link between the growth of the electricity and energy prices because of renewables in the last 10 to 15 years and the declining growth. I just feel that before this House considers a full ban, that it hasn't properly explored all of the options, all of the abilities to do a, it's a popular word in this place, an impact assessment.
Let's have an impact assessment by having some independently monitored shale gas wells using different techniques at different depths, independently monitored and supervised. And then, with that full information, this House can come back and it can make a decision. It could decide to devolve or it could decide that actually we make a national decision. And there, Madam Deputy Speaker, I conclude.
Brian William Leishman
Brian Leishman.
Madam Deputy Speaker, you know it's 100 days until Christmas. And in the last 15 to 20 minutes, we've just had a little glimpse at the pantomime season. But on to business. Decades of governments taking wrong political decisions have made climate change not just an environmental emergency, but also a crisis rooted in social and economic inequality. Major oil and gas corporations made nearly $93 billion in profits in the second quarter of 2026.
Saudi Aramco $33 billion net income, ExxonMobil $14.5 billion profit. Shell's net income was just under $10 billion, and BP made quarterly profits of nearly $6 billion. This is an international oligarchy benefiting from war and conflict, holding governments and citizens hostage just so record profits can be made. This rampant capitalism has created dire economic inequality, growing poverty, and ultimately it is leading to climate destruction. Companies that want to frac only care about making profit, pursuing shareholder dividends.
They certainly don't care about workers or communities. Madam Deputy Speaker, the need for a change in political direction could not be greater. Climate protection, environmental sustainability, and the provision of a genuinely just transition for workers and communities all demand the restructuring of our economy. We absolutely do not need fracking. We need a green industrial revolution, and Grangemouth in my constituency is the ideal location to house it.
I am in complete agreement with the new Prime Minister's diagnosis about the societal consequences of mass deindustrialization and deregulation. We've seen working-class communities, ex-industrial heartlands, become decimated. And I have been heartened these last couple of weeks, the Prime Minister has made enthusiastic contributions at the dispatch box about the future for sustainable aviation fuel in Grangemouth.
Chris Kane
Thank you. My honorable friend makes a good point about renewables at Grangemouth. Does he agree with me that the regional economic potential of the Forth Valley, which includes my constituency of Stirling and Strathallan, has Grangemouth as a key component? It's huge, and that fracking is not the future that Grangemouth, the Forth Valley, or the wider country wants or supports.
Brian William Leishman
I thank the honorable gentleman, my honorable friend and constituency next-door neighbor. He is of course 100% correct, because that is exactly the sort of action that Grangemouth, the wider Forth Valley area that he so ably represents in this area, we all need that. But to focus on my community just for just now, my community has been the victim of corporations amassing phenomenal wealth on the back, the talent and the skill of workers. And then these corporations decide to move on, meaning mass redundancies and leaving behind an asset-stripped community. I say to the Minister that our Labour government has the chance to change that.
Let's move away from fossil fuels and fracking. Instead, let's accelerate building the renewables industry in Grangemouth. Let's use state funds like the 200 million pounds dedicated from the National Wealth Fund set aside to finance this green industrial revolution. Quite frankly, that money has sat untouched for far too long. I say to the House that we could do something amazing in Grangemouth.
We could combine the pressing need of the environmental agenda which is so upon us with providing genuine social justice. And Madam Deputy Speaker, now it's time for a little more socialism. The government could take some form of ownership of these new industries, a popular policy amongst the general public. We could create new green, well-paid, secure jobs, apprenticeships that would transform the life chances of local young people. And with public ownership, we could reinvest profits back into the local Grangemouth community, regenerating, re-energizing life in the town, lifting living standards for generations to come.
That's the sort of corporate social responsibility that has been so missing in recent times from Grangemouth industry. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I've said many times and you've heard me say many times that Grangemouth is a blank canvas for us to build something truly special. The crucial question is, Minister, what kind of country do we want to live in? One that continues to allow oligarchs and international capital to exploit people, place and planet, or do we use politics, our opportunity in government, to be bold and transformative? Minister, let's build Grangemouth for the future in the image of a Labour government that wants the best for workers and communities.
Let's make Grangemouth the example, the shining example of what can be done. And let's do it quickly.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's an honour to follow on from my honourable friend on the opposite benches, the member for Alloa and Grangemouth, who's made a passionate and utterly convincing case for the need for a green energy revolution and the benefits that this will provide not only environmentally but socially for the communities that we are here to represent. We've heard fantastic arguments from across the House today for the reasons why we should have a full ban on fracking, not just about the earthquake risks, not just about the environmental damage to local communities, not just because it's completely publicly unpopular as another honourable member pointed out. British citizens do not want fracking. Banning fracking fully is a very, very popular policy.
But fundamentally, there's one key reason why we must have a full ban on fracking and that is because we must keep fossil fuels in the ground. Now, we know that we live in a hugely warming world. We know that... I will give way.
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the member for taking an intervention. I understand her view about leaving fossil fuels in the ground, but does she not agree with me that while we've still got a need for fossil fuels, it's much better for jobs, it's much better for the environment, much even better for the exchequer that we actually produce our own oil and gas rather than rely on imports from elsewhere?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
I thank the honourable member for his intervention.
Look, fossil fuels are traded globally. The reality is that if we open up new production of fossil fuels, that will do nothing for bills, almost nothing for energy security, and it will be a complete distraction for the investments that we must make in the transition to the clean, green, renewable energy future that is our only hope of a sustainable economy, not just in the long term, but in the short and the medium term as well. These are the industries of the future, and people who argue that we should somehow continue to invest in the equivalent of typewriters during the era of the personal computer, or continue to invest in horses and carriages during the era of the development of the car, are simply stuck in the past. We cannot continue to have our heads in the sand. I will take an intervention from this gentleman.
Richard Tice
I'm most grateful. Talking of having heads in the sand, I think the honorable lady has just agreed that it would be better to send our money overseas, to send our skills overseas, and to send our jobs overseas, and to literally be impoverished in a tent on a sandbag with our heads in the sand. Is that really the future that she wants?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
No, that's a complete mischaracterization of my argument. I mean, you know, we know that Jackdaw, for example, would generate 27 jobs. I mean, you know, the number of people that fit on the top of a double-decker bus. This is not, yes, seriously, I can give you the reference, unlike the extraordinary statistics that the honorable member was citing in his speech, which apparently have no basis in actual evidence. Fundamentally, we have to stop pouring fossil fuel on the fire of the climate crisis, and that means we need a full ban on fracking.
I'll give way to the honorable member.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Is it not true that in the end, this is a choice? It is not just that we invest publicly large amounts of money into the transition to net zero and nothing into the oil and gas industry. Our energy bills are subsidized, and we are subsidizing the oil and gas industry. Is that not true? And it is therefore not a distraction to continue to say, oh, this is a very expensive thing, and that is renewables that we need to subsidize, and then the cheap and not expensive thing of oil and gas, that is a completely wrong argument.
We do subsidize publicly oil and gas.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
I thank the honorable member for her intervention, and it is indeed true that there is considerable public subsidy for oil and gas, as well as revenues, as it should be, from the windfall taxes, because as the honorable member opposite pointed out, the fossil fuel companies are making tens of billions of pounds of profit raked in from consumers. Fundamentally, renewables are the cheap, clean, green energy of the future, and we need to shift in that direction as fast as possible. Now, we're here talking about fracking. I mean, there is no commercially viable shale gas reserve in the entirety of the UK. So this is, you know, this is an extraordinary, no, the argument that there is commercially viable production is itself a nonsense.
You simply have to look up the information from the British Geological Survey. I've already given way to the honorable gentleman and several other people, so I will move to my conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fundamentally, we're living in a burning world. 11 of the hottest years on record were the past 11 years. The three hottest years on record were the past three years.
This trajectory is going up and up, and this isn't just a question of graphs on paper and reports from the World Meteorological Organization. We are feeling this in our communities. The Prime Minister, when he's considering decisions on things like this, should be listening to communities in places like Stourbridge, West Sussex, Stoke-on-Trent, where people have had their homes burned by the wildfires that have been supercharged by the climate change that is already built in.
It would be utterly irresponsible to pour yet more fuel on that fire of climate crisis. We need to recognize the reality that is hitting us in the face, and that is a barreling and accelerating climate crisis. We need to do everything we possibly can to change direction. And the very least of those things has to be a full ban on fracking. So I call on the Minister, will he clarify that when the Energy Independence Bill comes to this House, I understand after the recess, will it include a fulfillment of the government's previous promise to fully ban fracking as a statutory thing, not something that can be simply overturned by a ministerial dictate?
And will he apply it to existing licenses, because we have to leave fossil fuels in the ground and supercharge our transition to the green, clean energy revolution that is the only fundamental basis of a sustainable and prosperous future for all of the UK? Thank you.
John Richard Foord
Which brings us to the front bench contributions for the Liberal Democrats, Richard Foord.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm very grateful to my honorable friend, the member for Thornbury and Yate, for securing this vital debate with the backing of the Backbench Business Committee. I am very far from being an elder of this House, but I'm among the minority of members to have been present that day, that evening, during the last Parliament to see out the end of the Liz Truss premiership. That period is most associated with the mini-budget, the Truss-Kwarteng mini-budget, but of course, as the honorable member for Bolton West pointed out, it should really go down in the history books as in its association with fracking. What fewer people recall is that the Truss era fractured, gave out volatile gases and combusted on the 19th of October 2022 with a Conservative Party rebellion. It was rebelling over the ban on fracking for shale gas bill.
40 Conservative MPs did not vote with their government. They did not vote against an opposition motion to ban fracking. Some of the Conservative MPs abstained because they were not in the House, but others abstained on a matter of principle, and I commend them. The case for one was the former minister, Chris Skidmore, who was certainly one of those principled MPs who would never vote in support of such a proposal. I want to set out why the rebels were right, and it is fair to say that this moratorium is not sufficient on two grounds: the first because it is inadequate, the second because of climate change more broadly.
The moratorium came into effect in 2019 after serious concerns were raised about how fracking could cause damage to nature and our communities. This ban may not cover all forms of fracking and could potentially leave significant loopholes if not addressed. And I have to say, I thought the honorable member for Scarborough and Whitby gave an excellent speech, and I completely agree with her that what we see at the moment is the exclusion of small-scale fracking, often referred to as proppant squeeze. Those guidelines in the 1998 Petroleum Act are outdated and define the fracturing of rock for shale gas to involve the injection of more than 1,000 cubic meters of fluid at each stage of the hydraulic fracturing. So we need to see the closure of that loophole, and we need to see the introduction of a proper ban.
In 2019, the Preston New Road fracking site in Lancashire recorded more than 120 seismic events. The British Geological Survey typically detects between 200 and 300 earthquakes across the whole country across the whole year. Before the fracking moratorium came into effect, drilling licenses over shale gas reserves were issued across 127 constituencies in England and Wales. And there is a risk that communities will suffer not just from the seismic activity, but from the polluted groundwater and the damage to natural habitats that flow from it. A full ban on fracking would provide certainty to our communities.
The Minister of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, the honourable member for Rutherglen, has argued in the past that government would need objective evidence in order to close these loopholes and include low-volume fracking in the ban. And I ask, what additional evidence does the government need? There is large support in this country for a full ban on fracking. Almost half the country believe we should not be fracking, and less than 30% of the British population support it. It can lead to water scarcity, it can lead to risks polluting our air, our soil, our health and our biodiversity.
Green space and nature are absolutely an intrinsic part of the life in the UK, and we should be protecting our wildlife with everything that we have. Ministers have previously suggested that all forms of fracking would be considered within the scope of this ban. And the Energy Secretary, the former Energy Secretary said at the 2025 Labour Party conference, let's ban fracking and send the frackers packing. So I welcome the point that was made in this debate by the honourable member for Alloa and Grangemouth, who reminded us of some of the traditional Labour arguments about social justice, but that they could equate to new jobs in new industries. What the public does support is action to mitigate the harmful effects of climate change.
Eight in 10 people say they are concerned about climate change. They want a transition to clean energy. In Mid and East Devon, protecting our natural environment is a priority for thousands of people who've corresponded with me on the subject. Reports of nature in decline and the loss of our precious wildlife and biodiversity is very concerning to them. And I hope this debate will not only protect communities from the damage of fracking now, but that it will, in a small way, help to protect future generations from the worst impacts of climate change.
The honourable member for North Herefordshire talked about the need to keep fossil fuels in the ground, and it is fair to say we have just seen the summer's hottest average temperature, around 130 times more likely because of human-induced climate change. Last year, of all the electricity generated in the UK, 47% was generated from renewable sources. It represents a fourfold increase in renewables since 2012, and far in advance of the pace of progress that was forecast. Yes, we will continue to see some oil and gas, and we will continue to need some oil and gas in the years to come. But really, frankly, why would anyone want us to hitch ourselves to the slow wagons, of which fracking is one, as other countries gallop away behind the technologies of the future?
Yes, I will.
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the member for taking an intervention. So the member has agreed that we will need oil and gas for years to come. So can he clarify what the Liberal Democrat position is? Do they support Rosebank and Jackdaw? Do they support new licenses, and do they support jobs up in Aberdeen?
John Richard Foord
Well, I can tell the honourable member, I know this is a matter local to him, so he will be interested. But in the Liberal Democrats, we are very concerned about the emissions from greater extraction of fossil fuels, both in UK waters and around the world. And I have to say that the oil in particular is a pointless extraction exercise given that we are exporting it so that other countries can refine it and take profits from it.
The honourable member for Boston and Skegness referred to a similar point and he made repeated references to treasure. And for those who know the story Treasure Island, he is the Squire John Trelawney of this House, a rich landowner who pays for the ship but talks too much and trusts the wrong people. There is a real danger that investments in fracking will be a catastrophic mistake as the fuels, the facilities and the resources become stranded assets. There is a real risk that they will lose their value prematurely as the tide of renewable technology advances around them. And to finish where I started, I'm concerned about the Conservative party's journey towards political extinction.
Polling suggests that support for any fracking is a complete misreading of where our constituents are. We Liberal Democrats could gloat on these benches quietly that the Conservative party has misread the room and we could enjoy the electoral dividends that this brings. But we would much rather that the Conservative party returned to the consensus. Climate change is one of the gravest issues that our generation of politicians is sent to this House to tackle. Let's not make a catastrophic mistake.
Harriet Iona Cross
Shadow Minister Harriet Cross.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I first congratulate the member for Thornbury and Yate for bringing today's debate. And as we have heard from a number of the speeches today, including from honourable members such as that from Scarborough and Whitby, Bath, Bolton West, North Herefordshire and others, there are a range of strongly held views about fracking, not least concerns about the distinction between high and low volume fracking, environmental impacts, seismic activity and wider impacts of onshore gas production on local communities. And I want to start by acknowledging this view. Local communities, in particular rural communities, too often find themselves the hosts for onshore infrastructure, be that energy, mining or transport projects. It's important, indeed critical, that these communities should have a say should any proposals for fracking projects come forward.
There are, as we've heard, mixed views on the suitability and capability of onshore fracking in the UK. So instead of us here deciding whether the UK does or does not have a viable reserves that can be fracked, I want to instead touch on two more broader principles, things that we should all be considering when discussing not just fracking, but indeed any industry.
Peter Swallow
Oh yes. I'm grateful for her giving way because she's talking about principles and the honourable member for Honiton and Sidmouth has reminded us of some principled Conservative backbenchers who rebelled against the Liz Truss government to block plans for fracking. Now we've also heard that the leader of the opposition's view is that any Conservative who wishes to stand as a MP for her party must reject net zero. So can I simply ask her to confirm today whether Conservative MPs who are opposed to fracking are welcome in the leader of the opposition's Conservative party?
Harriet Iona Cross
Thank you, after that very, very long intervention we finally got to the point. We are not opposed to net zero. We're opposed to a 2050 net zero target which makes the country weaker, poorer, which costs jobs, particularly in my constituency in North East Scotland. But back to the principles which I was talking about. Firstly, it is right that where possible countries utilize their own resources.
This is a fundamental part of a country's national security, whether for jobs, investment, industrial capability or resource security, ensuring a domestic supply of crucial materials and products should be a concern for all governments. This is becoming ever more pressing in a world that is increasingly uncertain and where the flow of goods and products is becoming less predictable than we have known for decades. And the second principle, and one I think only one member touched on today, is market forces.
It is not for us sitting here to tell the market whether or not an industry is commercially viable. Private companies with private money or bank financing looking to invest in a range of competing opportunities will decide that. The reason I mention this is relevant because whether or not fracking is or isn't banned is only half the story. Should fracking be permitted but companies cannot make it viable, it will not happen. And that is a genuine concern when it comes to fracking.
The amount of reserves we have in the UK and the viability of producing those remains an open question. And Madam Deputy Speaker, a secure domestic gas supply... Of course, yeah.
Richard Tice
I'm most grateful to the honorable lady for giving way. And on that point, surely the fact that companies have already invested over 200 million pounds in the potential for shale gas onshore proves that they believe that the reserves are very considerable.
Harriet Iona Cross
Well, as I say, companies, private companies will invest where they see opportunities. They will risk their money how they want and it's up to them to either gain or lose in the investments that they make. A secure domestic supply of gas is a crucial consideration when it comes to our energy security. I want to see UK safeguarded with a domestic supply of gas which we use and need every day. But Madam Deputy Speaker, there is a viable gas source that does not need onshore fracking, a source that has been producing in the North Sea safely entering our gas grid for decades.
While today we are discussing whether or not fracking should be banned, we should be more concerned about the government's hostile policies when it comes to North Sea oil and gas production. Take Jackdaw, a gas field which could produce enough gas to power 1.4 million homes in the UK this winter, about 6% of our gas needs. Those worried about onshore fracking should reflect that there is a choice here because they cannot be against all sources of gas. Would they prefer gas from Jackdaw or another North Sea gas field, from onshore fracked resources, or imports of LNG? Because the option is not no gas, it's just where the gas comes from.
Yes.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
I thank you for giving way. Is it not true that delaying the transition, whether that's 2050 that the honorable lady doesn't want to accept, but whatever delay we make, it will make energy more expensive for our citizens? And is it therefore not highly irresponsible to delay something that we know will cost our citizens more in the long term?
Harriet Iona Cross
What is important here is the reality and as the Prime Minister said, being pragmatic. There are 24 million homes in the UK that use gas. That can't change overnight. So whether or not we ban our own gas or import gas, that need does not change. The demand is what's important, not the supply, and the demand is what's going to dictate or not any sort of target or progression to other energy sources.
And I think the crucial question hanging over us in this debate today is why. Why is there a desire for a full fracking ban? Is it a concern about the environment, about seismic activity? And yes, I'm sure that is part of it. But I expect it is more of a continuation of the hostile attitude we have become too accustomed to towards UK oil and gas production.
Putting the merits of fracking as a means of production to one side, it cannot, or at least should not be denied, that the UK producing its own resources where at all possible, be that gas or oil or food or cement or steel, the list does go on, is a good thing. It's good for jobs, it's good for skills, good for investment, security of supply, good for industrialization, and it's good for national security.
Michael Philip Brickell
If the domestic production of gas is so fantastic for the UK economy, why did successive Conservative governments massively constrain the amount of gas that can be stored in this country to prevent those huge fluctuations in price that we see?
Harriet Iona Cross
Because unlike this Labour government, we weren't banning production, new production from the North Sea, so we would have had a flow of gas from the North Sea. But Madam Deputy Speaker, let's be serious, no one who has spoken in this debate today concerned about the loophole in the moratorium needs to fear, because there is no way that this Labour government is going to use any loophole which might mean more UK gas production, because their record offshore shows that their plan is incoherent and self-defeating. They'd prefer to ban new licenses to rely on more imports. They'd prefer to tax the industry so highly that investment is drying up and moving abroad at the expense of jobs and livelihoods here in the UK. They'd prefer to pay Norway 20 billion pounds every year to import gas from them instead of from the North Sea.
And we know that just today they've decided to put votes in a by-election ahead of permitting Jackdaw and presumably Rosebank before those results. And the result of doing all this? The UK will import more LNG gas, LNG which is more carbon intensive, which with relevance to this debate, LNG which largely derives from fracked shale gas. So it's not true to say that Labour or the Liberal Democrats or the Greens oppose fracking, same as it's not true to say that they oppose oil and gas. What they oppose is producing gas here in the UK, and therefore they oppose oil and gas jobs here in the UK.
Yes, this debate today is about fracking, but a more pressing issue is protecting the UK's established oil and gas sector, its jobs, its supply chain and the expertise which are disappearing. And the steps the government can take for this are simple, indeed the Conservatives have set them out many times. We must end the ban on new licenses, we must permit Jackdaw and Rosebank, end the energy profits levy, and we must get Britain drilling again.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable member for Thornbury and Yate for bringing this debate to the House this afternoon and for the Backbench Business Committee for approving it. After the hottest summer on record, I would argue that the need for climate action is more acute than ever. We've seen really visibly this summer why it is so necessary, and so I have to start by saying it astounds me with what we've heard from the honorable member for Boston and Skegness during this debate, where he asked the question who would forgive us. And the question I would put back to him is who will forgive us if we, as he has done, deny the climate science, who will forgive us if we fail to plan for a transition that is happening now, not a transition that is coming in years to come, a transition that is happening now that work and jobs rely on, and who will forgive us if we pass on to our children, grandchildren, the next generation, a world that is worse than when we inherited it.
And to me that is the question that sits at the heart of this debate. Now there may be parts of this debate where we may disagree, even with those who I have a lot to agree on in terms of climate and the science, but I think on these points around the basics of climate science, there is much that we can agree on.
So, it is important that the House, industry, communities and the wider public have clarity about what the Government's position is on this issue, the evidence base behind it and the safeguards that apply. So let me remind the House of our position, and that comes in three parts. First, our clear commitment to ban fracking for shale gas. Second, the distinction between that activity and low-volume hydraulic fracturing techniques used in conventional oil and gas operations and, as the honourable lady acknowledged in her speech, other industries such as geothermal. And third, the broader reality is that benefits of getting off fossil fuel reliance significantly outweigh the costs, with clean energy providing cheaper power, travel and homes for our country.
This Government has been clear in its commitment to ban hydraulic fracturing for shale gas, commonly known as fracking. There is currently no fracking for shale gas anywhere in the United Kingdom. Now, members across the House, including my honourable friend the member for Scarborough and Whitby and many others, asked about the Energy Independence Bill. The Energy Independence Bill was announced in the King's Speech and will meet our commitments to not issue new licenses to explore new fields, that's onshore and offshore, including those that could be used for fracking for shale gas. That will deliver on our commitment in law to ban fracking.
The effective moratorium on fracking for shale gas in England remains in place for existing licenses because of concerns about the prediction and management of induced seismicity. Those concerns are not minor, they're not theoretical. In all three instances of fracking for shale gas in the UK, there was evidence of induced seismicity, including earthquakes strong enough to be felt by surrounding communities. Now, where communities have concerns about safety, environmental protection and local impacts, the Government has a responsibility to proceed cautiously and transparently. Fracking for shale gas is used for gases located within very small pores of shale rock and cannot be extracted without repeatedly fracturing the rock.
It typically requires injecting high volumes of fluid and proppant at high pressure and at multiple points in a horizontal well to create high numbers of fractures extending hundreds of metres into the shale.
Martin Wrigley
I thank the Minister for giving way. Does the Minister agree with me that not only did the honourable member from Boston and Skegness exaggerate the amount of available gas that might be in the UK, less than 10% of such gas is usually recovered and that trails off after a year normally, but it's also not actually pulled out of the ground by nodding donkeys. It typically is a structure called a Christmas tree that they use, not nodding donkeys as he described.
Speaker 151
Thank Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd agree with much of what the honourable gentleman said. I would also say we are not Pennsylvania, we are not Texas, we are the United Kingdom and we will operate on the basis of our national interest, our energy security and our national security. Returning to the point I was making about the process of high-impact fracking, this can lead to seismic activity that can be felt on the surface. It differs considerably from the proppant squeeze used in conventional gas extraction and also in geothermal that uses smaller amounts of fluid to improve the production rate of gas in non-shale rock types. The Government's commitment is directed at hydraulic fracturing for shale gas where the combination of geology, scale of the fracture network, fluid volume and operational design has raised specific concerns.
Next, let me say a little more about some of the other issues raised by honourable members throughout the debate. We recognise that some concerns have been raised about low-volume hydraulic fracturing techniques such as proppant or acid squeezes used in conventional non-shale oil and gas operations. And it pains to say that this is not the same as hydraulic fracturing for shale gas extraction and is not associated with the same safety issues.
Low volume hydraulic fracturing has been happening in the UK for decades. I'll give way.
Alison Louise Hume
I thank the minister for giving way. And would he accept that this, the use of proppant squeeze is a loophole because the industry have started using it as a way to get round the moratorium and therefore it needs to be included in any ban.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would thank the honorable lady for her, for her question. I think the honorable lady in her introduction to the debate also raised the question, or raised the point around geothermal. The specific issues relating to high intensity hydraulic fracturing that we've seen is in shale, not in the types of fracturing used in conventional oil and gas, which is also, as we say, used in geothermal. Now, I've heard some division across the house this afternoon about, you know, from these benches, a suggestion that we use a definition that is linked to only oil and gas, therefore keeping geothermal out of it, and suggestions from elsewhere that a full ban might also impact on uses such as geothermal.
I think that points to why we have to be very careful and very specific about what it is we're trying to, what it is we're trying to achieve with this. As I was saying, low volume hydraulic fracturing has been happening in the UK for decades, used in not just oil and gas, but in the water industry and also in geothermal. In that time, there has been no clear evidence that it induces seismicity that can be felt on the surface. Low volume hydraulic fracturing operations are routinely used in conventional oil and gas operations. They target different types of rocks, create fractures close to the wellbore and are typically short single stage operations as opposed to the continuous fracturing characteristic of shale gas fracking.
In practical terms, these operations are limited in scale and purpose. They are designed to improve flow from an existing conventional reservoir, not to fracture large areas of shale rock. They do not involve the same high volume multi-stage process associated with shale gas fracking and they have not produced the same evidence of induced seismicity. Furthermore, all such activities are subject to a robust regulatory regime. I know the honorable member for Bath and the my honorable friend for the member for Bolton West spoke about safety.
Operators must obtain planning permission, environmental permits and health and safety approvals before proceeding, covering issues such as groundwater protection, management of emissions, handling of fluids and waste and monitoring requirements. Where health and safety approvals are required, operators must meet the standards expected for well integrity and operational safety. Planning processes also provide a route for local impacts to be considered before activities proceed. And we recognize the strong interest members expressed in the Burniston application for which the planning authority has now refused permission. So let me be absolutely clear, there is no loophole and no hidden route by which shale gas fracking can resume.
The evidence-based policy position is clear, the effective moratorium remains in place and the government will not issue new onshore licenses in England, including those that could be used for fracking for shale gas. That is the reassurance that communities across the country are entitled to hear. Finally, let me turn to the wider argument sometimes made about energy security and domestic production.
...bills. However, oil and gas, as has been mentioned in the debate by a number of honorable members, are traded on international markets and increasing domestic production does not shield consumers from global price volatility. I'll give way.
Richard Tice
I'm most grateful. I just need to clarify another honorable member, when I referred to nodding donkeys, I was specifically said oil wells, just for the clarity to help the honorable member. With regard to the, the gas price, can the minister explain why the wholesale price of gas in the United States is 80% cheaper than the wholesale price of gas in the United Kingdom? I think it completely undermines what he's just said. He has inadvertently misled the House, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Absolutely not. As I said a moment ago, we are not the United States, we are not Pennsylvania, we are not Texas. It is a different energy market. There is nothing to suggest that extraction of shale gas in this country would reduce the cost of energy, just as there is no evidence that suggests that extracting more, for example, oil and gas from the North Sea will reduce the cost of energy, if that is the point that the honorable gentleman was making.
Of course.
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the minister for taking the intervention, but does he also agree though, that if we actually produce our own oil and gas, that gives the Exchequer more money, and if they want to use that to take money off people's bills, then that's up to them?
Speaker 151
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And that is a, that is a different argument to the one that the honorable member for Boston and Skegness was making, but what is clear is that it will not directly reduce the cost of energy in this country. Recent years have shown that the answer is not to double down on fossil fuel production, but to reduce our dependence on those markets over time through clean, homegrown energy, as my honorable friend the member for Alloa and Grangemouth was setting out in his speech. This will ensure that our oil and gas workers and supply chains benefit from the clean energy transition and that we support prosperity, jobs, economic growth, communities, and energy security. This government's approach is both clear and pragmatic: ending new licenses, introducing transitional energy certificates, maintaining the effective moratorium, and accelerating the transition to clean, homegrown energy that improves resilience, supports jobs, reduces emissions, and gives consumers greater protections from global price shocks.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the House should be in no doubt: our position is evidence-based and it is clear. We will not issue new onshore licenses in England and we will maintain the effective moratorium on fracking for shale gas because the concerns that led to it have not been resolved. Together, these measures ensure fracking for shale gas is not taking place in England. We will continue to ensure that conventional oil and gas activities are properly distinguished, properly regulated, and properly scrutinized. That is a responsible course of action for communities, for consumers, for our climate commitments, and for the country's long-term energy security.
Claire Young to wind up.
Claire Louise Young
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank all the backbenchers who've spoken in this debate. When the member for Scarborough and Whitby talked about how propants grease is being used for fracking, the word, I, I was minded to say a rose by any other name, but fracking certainly isn't sweet. The members for Bath, Bolton West, and North Herefordshire all made good arguments about the climate change and other environmental concerns, and the, the honorable member for Alloa and Grangemouth set out the need for a green industrial revolution. I don't have time to dissect in detail the honorable member for Boston and Skegness's speech. I would, I'm concerned that he may be suffering from some amnesia.
He, he seems to think that the, the recognition for need for climate action is new. It was recognized back in the 1980s, including by such left-wing icons as Margaret Thatcher. And also seems to have forgotten about the decades of testing related to fracking that have already taken place. And I, he either wishes to admit or does not realize that the geological situation in America is, is vastly different as well. The, in the UK, the shale gas is deeper, it's not faulted, and it's, it's contained in much more complex geological settings.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, fracking will never shift a price set on global markets. It will never be worth the earthquakes, the polluted water and the broken trust it leaves behind. This country was promised an end to fracking. It's time to deliver it.
Speaker 216
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
I'll allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over. And we now come to the backbench debate on World Sepsis Awareness Month. I call Mike Wood, who will speak for around 15 minutes.
Mike Wood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I beg to move that this House has considered World Sepsis Awareness Month. As co-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Sepsis, I'd like to begin by expressing my gratitude to the Backbench Business Committee for granting the time for this debate today. And to the best of my knowledge, this is the very first dedicated full House of Commons chamber debate on sepsis. In the past, this devastating condition has been discussed only in Westminster Hall debates or raised through brief interventions or questions. And having sepsis debated on the floor of the main chamber during World Sepsis Awareness Month this month is a major milestone.
Not only for Parliament, but for the clinicians, charities and the bereaved families across the country who have campaigned so tirelessly to bring this condition out of the shadows. And I would also like to thank the co-sponsors of this debate. Firstly, the honorable member for Ashfield, who cannot be here this afternoon, but who led an important Westminster Hall debate on this subject two years ago, and the honorable member for Dartford, the vice chair of the APPG. We know that sepsis strikes indiscriminately, ruthlessly and with terrifying speed, without regard for background, class or indeed political allegiance. And so it is vital that we all stand united in our determination to tackle this deadly condition.
It is a challenge that completely transcends party politics. Madam Deputy Speaker, on Sunday, communities across the world marked World Sepsis Day. The international theme for this year could not be more apt: invest in sepsis, save lives. The World Health Organization recognizes sepsis as one of the leading causes of death and disability globally, estimating that sepsis-related illnesses account for one in every five deaths worldwide. And here in the United Kingdom, NHS England has made clear that sepsis claims more lives each year than lung cancer and represents the second biggest killer in our hospitals after cardiovascular disease.
Every single year, an estimated 245,000 people in the UK develop sepsis and tragically more than 48,000 lose their lives. That is a higher annual death toll than bowel, breast and prostate cancers combined. But behind every single one of those figures is a family left grieving and asking the same agonizing question: what if? What if the symptoms had been recognized an hour earlier? What if antibiotics had been administered sooner?
Madam Deputy Speaker, as you know, I do not approach this debate purely as a parliamentarian dispassionately analyzing policy responses to one of the leading causes of avoidable deaths. I stand in this chamber today because almost a decade ago, by the grace of God and the extraordinary skill and care of NHS staff, my life was saved. In January 2017, I was a relatively fit and active 40-year-old Member of Parliament. I'd developed what I assumed was merely a winter infection. Like many people, I thought I could push through it, take some paracetamol and carry on working.
What if someone had simply asked: could it be sepsis?
I traveled out to Strasbourg to take part in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on the Sunday evening. But within days, my condition collapsed. An ordinary throat infection triggered a catastrophic immune response. My body, in attempting to fight the infection, began attacking its own tissues and organs. By Thursday, after seeing a French GP, I flew back to Britain.
On Friday, attended the official launch of the local enterprise zone that I'd campaigned hard for in my constituency, but as soon as I arrived there, I was so ill I had to rest in the back room. And on Saturday morning, I got out of bed, started putting my suit on over my pajamas and told my wife Laura that I had to come down to Westminster to vote. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, like many in politics, my behavior can at times appear to some people to be a little idiosyncratic. But fortunately, Laura realized that even for an MP, this was not entirely normal behavior. She rushed me to Russells Hall Hospital in Dudley, where my blood pressure plummeted into septic shock, my organs began shutting down, and my life was hanging by a thread.
The medical team had to place me in a medically induced coma. Doctors told my family whilst I was in the coma that my chances of pulling through were no better than one in ten. And for 11 days, I lay in intensive care on life support. Or as my family sometimes remind me, I slept through the difficult bits. When I did finally wake up, my muscles had wasted away, I could barely lift my arms, let alone stand or walk.
But it could easily have been so much worse. What if Laura had left me to get some rest that Saturday morning whilst she took our daughter to her dance class? Or above all, what if the nurse who examined me at A&E hadn't had the insight to check whether the symptoms, which could easily have been mistaken for other illnesses like flu or meningitis, might be sepsis? I owe a debt of gratitude to the doctors, intensive care nurses and other staff at Russells Hall Hospital that I can never repay. But as long as I have the honor of serving in this House, I will use my voice to fight for sepsis patients and for their families.
There is a common misconception that sepsis is primarily the result of hospital-acquired infection. But the evidence demonstrates the exact opposite. A major 2024 population study led by Professor Van Staa, analyzing linked primary care and hospital data in England, showed that the vast majority of sepsis cases are community-acquired, developing in homes, in workplaces and local communities long before a patient reaches an acute hospital bed. That research also uncovered deep health inequalities in sepsis risk. The risk of developing sepsis is significantly heightened by socioeconomic deprivation, by frailty, being housebound, and by chronic conditions like cancer, diabetes and learning disabilities.
Prior exposure to antibiotics in the previous two months was also identified as a strong risk factor. And while ethnicity was not an independent biological factor, Black and Asian individuals did suffer from a higher prevalence of predisposing conditions, including diabetes, chronic liver disease, and severe anemia, which put them at a greater risk. So tackling sepsis is not merely a technical clinical issue, it's also a fundamental challenge of health inequality and community prevention. Madam Deputy Speaker, one of the most critical clinical lessons of recent years is the direct link between viral infections and sepsis. For decades, the public and medical community viewed sepsis almost exclusively as a bacterial complication.
But the COVID-19 pandemic demonstrated that viral infections can trigger the exact same catastrophic septic response. The overwhelming cytokine storms, microvascular clotting, and rapid progression to acute respiratory distress syndrome and multi-organ failure seen in COVID intensive care units were classic manifestations of viral sepsis. It is thought by many experts in the field that the vast majority of COVID deaths were the direct result of a septic reaction. Sepsis is not defined by the pathogen, it is defined by the body's life-threatening immune reaction to any severe infection: bacterial, viral, or fungal. This reality extends directly into long-term recovery.
Millions who had COVID-19 are still living with long COVID. Sepsis survivors have known this reality for generations under the name of post-sepsis syndrome. In my case, it was little more than some nerve damage and tiredness, even a decade later, but for many, the symptoms are more severe, and up to 50% of sepsis survivors suffer prolonged physical, cognitive, and psychological impairments, from debilitating fatigue and cognitive brain fog to severe muscle weakness and PTSD. The clinical insights gained from viral sepsis during the pandemic must now be used to build integrated recovery pathways for all sepsis survivors. But to curb preventable deaths, our health system must act decisively in several areas, and I'll just go through four in the interest of time.
Firstly, in ensuring consistent rapid recognition. Time is the single most decisive factor in sepsis survival. Clinical research shows that administering appropriate antibiotics within the first hour of a patient presenting to an emergency department with sepsis reduces the risk of death by a full one-third compared to delayed treatment. Secondly, in ensuring that where sepsis is suspected, appropriate clinical escalation pathways are in place. Where sepsis is suspected, early warning systems such as NEWS2 have saved countless lives.
And the ongoing rollout of Martha's Rule across the NHS trusts, which has already saved thousands of lives, is vital in ensuring that patients and loved ones can trigger an immediate independent critical review when they sense deterioration.
Thirdly, we must take advantage of innovation in rapid diagnostics. We know that administering broad-spectrum antibiotics within that golden hour that I spoke of massively increases survival rates, but clinicians often face the dilemma of judging whether that is compatible with responsible antimicrobial stewardship. But deploying rapid molecular diagnostics, bedside biomarker technologies, and wearable continuous physiological monitors can remove that guesswork and provide targeted care before septic shock takes hold and it can be too late. Fourthly, while Britain has in many ways led the way in developing and enhancing sepsis care and treatment, we must be open to learning from established international models and practices. Sweden utilizes standard sepsis alerts to prioritize patients at triage and implements mandatory post-discharge telephone follow-ups.
France, where I was when I was taken ill, has since introduced an integrated national sepsis plan spanning pre-hospital recognition, emergency pathways, and structured rehabilitation to help patients return to employment. And Australia established a national sepsis clinical care standard built around seven quality statements, ensuring end-to-end consistency from triage through to survivorship. Madam Deputy Speaker, the publication in July of the sepsis modern service framework by NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care is an important step towards doing that and learning the lessons from around the world, and I warmly welcome it. This framework is one of the first to be published under the 10-year health plan. Its headline goal to reduce deaths, severe complications, and long-term harm from sepsis by at least 25% by 2035 is a target that every member of this House can endorse.
Of course.
Vikki Slade
I thank the honorable member for giving way, and he's making a really, really moving speech. Although one in 100 cases of sepsis in adults is linked to meningitis, one in 10 for children, with harrowing consequences like Hamish, who was a classmate of my nephew Louie in Sussex, who had all four limbs amputated. Now, I want to pay tribute to his resilience of getting on with life and going to university. But can I ask the honorable member if he agrees with me that because of the link between vaccines and the prevention of sepsis, he'll join with me in calling for the MenB vaccine to be repeated for teenagers next year and every year until all children are protected, so we can reduce the risk of sepsis in young people?
Mike Wood
The honorable lady makes a really important point, and we know how these conditions can obviously come round in a cycle. In order to break that cycle, we'll need multiple years of vaccination. The modern service framework contains a number of vital commitments, but I particularly welcome action four on improving the audit and feedback of sepsis-related clinical data across trusts, action five on updating training for NHS staff, social care workers, and unpaid carers, action nine on optimizing care pathways and expanding access to rapid diagnostics and specialist advice, action 11 on standardizing digital specifications for early warning systems like NEWS2, and action 12 on reviewing and addressing capacity gaps in critical and enhanced care. However, Madam Deputy Speaker, a strategy on paper will not be enough to save a deteriorating patient on a cold winter weekend in an overcrowded emergency department. In the other place, my noble friend and our former colleague, Lord Mackinlay of Richborough, who has spoken with enormous courage about his own life-altering encounter with sepsis, has repeatedly tabled written questions seeking clarity on how this framework will be delivered.
Regrettably, the answers provided by ministers in the Lords to date have been rather generic and vague and lacking in operational detail. We cannot accept boilerplate responses on a condition that kills 48,000 people each year. So I have two direct questions that I hope the minister will answer in her responses in her response to today's debate. Firstly, what are the specific milestone-driven timelines for the delivery of each of the actions set out in the modern service framework? When will trusts and integrated care boards be expected to have these standardized pathways fully operational?
And secondly, can she assure the House that the Department of Health and Social Care is prepared to commit the dedicated investment required to make this framework work? When we call for investment, we must be clear. Funding sepsis care is not an open-ended cost. It is one of the most cost-effective investments that the department can make. Sepsis currently places an enormous financial burden on the National Health Service and the wider economy.
Too often, cases of missed or delayed diagnosis and treatment result in weeks of high-cost intensive care unit admissions, in emergency readmissions due to incomplete recovery, in complex surgical interventions including amputations requiring lifelong prosthetic and social care support, or in the permanent loss of working-age adults from the workforce. Investing in rapid bedside diagnostics, digital early warning systems, specialist outreach teams, and structured post-sepsis rehabilitation can dramatically reduce lengths of stay in intensive care, lower readmission rates, and keep people in work. Early intervention is not only clinically imperative, it is economically sound. And the theme "Invest in Sepsis, Save Lives" is a call for smart, preventive healthcare investment.
I'm coming to a close, but I will briefly.
Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner
Very briefly. Prevention is key, and an estimated 20 to 30 percent of sepsis cases are urosepsis. And I've just learned today from my campaign with Good Housekeeping magazine that a gentleman who's lost his wife due to a UTI-related sepsis. Does he agree with me that if we are to really tackle sepsis, we need to look at infection sources as well and get better diagnostics and treatment for those, particularly for ones such as UTI that are still not properly focused on?
Mike Wood
Absolutely. And of course, some infections are almost unavoidable, but where infections such as UTIs can clearly be reduced with the right care and precautions, then we must do everything we can to reduce those risks. Madam Deputy Speaker, every member in this chamber has constituents whose lives have been permanently transformed by sepsis. Some members have been directly impacted or have watched as close family and friends have encountered sepsis. We know the speed with which it strikes, but we also know that with early detection, immediate treatment, and high-quality critical care, thousands of lives can be saved.
We have the clinical evidence. We now have the modern service framework. What we now need is clear delivery timelines, rigorous parliamentary accountability, and the necessary financial backing to make its ambition a reality. And if the minister can deliver this and provide the resources and tools that the NHS needs to implement it, then the modern service framework truly can be a turning point in the fight against this silent killer and the battle to save thousands of lives.
Speaker 216
Before I put the question, could I just pay tribute to the honorable gentleman for his bravery in sharing his personal story and of course to the noble Lord McKinley in the other place who has spoken so often and with such power on this subject.
The question is as on the order paper. Jim Dickson.
Jim Dickson
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I'm very pleased to be co-sponsoring this debate alongside the honorable members for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire and Ashfield, both of whom are fellow officers of the Sepsis All-Party Parliamentary Group. And I would like to pay tribute to the honorable member for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire for that amazingly moving speech, revealing speech and for sharing his experience in a way that I hope all members will take note of and will make a difference in the way government takes these issues forward. And I'm also grateful to the Backbench Business Committee for granting the time for World Sepsis Awareness Month with World Sepsis Awareness Day having just taken place on Sunday. I was pleased to welcome my constituent John Snow to Parliament last year and I'm also extremely appreciative that he's with us today in the gallery alongside his wife Karen and his daughter Gracie. John developed sepsis in 2024.
After first believing he was suffering with muscle pain, the situation rapidly deteriorated resulting in hospital admission with heart attack-like symptoms and his lips turning blue. John and Karen weren't aware at this point that John had many of the signs of sepsis. Within hours his kidneys had shut down, needing dialysis and his body went into septic shock with doctors putting him into an induced coma. It was unclear if John would survive and the coma lasted for two weeks during which time John was transferred from Darent Valley Hospital in Dartford up to St Thomas's just across the river from where we are now. After a month, thankfully John pulled through but this good news was accompanied by the desperately difficult decision from his doctors that he needed to have a quadruple amputation.
He's received amazing support from the Dartford community who have rallied round to help fund support for his family. A special mention must go to the wonderful Dartford Working Men's Club led by the amazing Nick Barham who not only helped fundraise for the family but have held sepsis awareness events to ensure more people know about the symptoms. Notwithstanding this great community effort, there remains so much to do to improve support for people like John post-infection. I've been privileged to have kept in touch with John and Karen during John's exceptionally brave recovery journey. When we met in July, he told me of the exceptionally long delay he was experiencing in receiving his new prosthetic hand.
John was cast for the prosthetic at the end of last year but due to issues relating to the move of his local prosthetic center, it wasn't assembled, leaving him worried his body may change and the prosthetic wouldn't fit. The challenges this causes are compounded by the fact that he cannot have the casting for the second prosthetic hand until he's had the first one for a year, a timer that has not yet been able to start. John has already also experienced delays and dysfunctions in his facial surgery which he is currently undergoing with the support of surgeons and doctors. John's case illustrates how much we have to do to spread knowledge about sepsis and also to improve the care for those who have it. I'd like to commend as others have the campaigning work of Lord McKinley of Richborough who has not only helped to raise awareness of sepsis in our health system but has also met John and provided encouragement to him in his recovery journey.
I would certainly give way.
Vikki Slade
Thank you. I too want to pay tribute to Lord McKinley because when Hamish's story made the papers, he took no hesitation to go and visit Hamish as an 18-year-old and help him through his recovery. And I think when I first met Lord McKinley myself in Buckingham Palace when we'd just been elected, the first thing I went to him and said, what a hero. You know, what an incredible man to do that every time a similar case happens.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank the honorable member for that intervention? I think what you've described and what I've described is the mark of the man. He not only suffered that appalling setback in his life, has come through it with huge brio, is an active member of the other place, but has also gone the extra mile to help others who are in his predicament. And I can't thank him enough for the work he's done for sepsis, those who've experienced sepsis and John, my constituent. And as Craig himself would say, sepsis remains something we do not know enough about.
And what knowledge we have isn't as widely known as it should be. And I just thought it would be helpful to remind all those present and anybody watching of the signs to look out for in adults as set out by the UK Sepsis Trust: slurred speech or confusion, extreme shivering or muscle pain, passing no urine in a day, severe breathlessness, it feels like you're going to die, skin mottled or discolored. If you or another adult develops any of these signs, it is important to seek urgent medical attention. John's story highlights both the work we need to do to raise awareness of the early signs of sepsis, but also how we support those who have been diagnosed with it. There remains too little data on sepsis with inconsistencies in the definitions used across the country.
The Office of National Statistics data indicates there were 27,971 deaths in England in 2025 which mentioned sepsis on the death certificate, but this is almost certainly not the full story. I'll certainly give way.
Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner
Can I just verify that lack of data? Are we also addressing the issue that the lack of the infection source is not recorded as well and is that somewhere where we need to make significant improvements if we are to prevent sepsis? I know it's a slight repetition, but that worries me about the data collection.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank my honorable friend for her intervention? Absolutely. I think the data problems go much more widely than simply understanding who has died with sepsis as a related cause and who has suffered sepsis at some point in the system. All the sorts of prevention issues and early diagnosis issues that you've highlighted, I think also go to the heart of the problems we have with data and I hope the minister will address this in her response. So I very much welcome the sepsis modern service framework which was published last July and contains a much-needed plan to improve prevention, recognition, diagnosis, treatment and recovery for people affected by sepsis.
It should mean doctors are equipped to spot sepsis sooner and improve outcomes for patients like John and others who have been mentioned this evening. I hope when the minister responds at the end of this debate that she will outline how the modern service framework will change the way the NHS supports John and others recovering from sepsis so the delays he's experienced in getting his prosthetics and other people have experienced in the system become a thing of the past.
Julie Minns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I am grateful for the opportunity to contribute in this very important debate during Sepsis Awareness Month. And can I also pay tribute to the honorable members for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire, Dartford and Ashfield for bringing this very, very important debate.
The danger posed by sepsis cannot be overestimated. As we have heard, five people lose their lives every single hour to sepsis. And last year, my mother was one of those it claimed. Deaths from sepsis rise sharply in the over-65s. Older people are more vulnerable to sepsis because ageing weakens the immune system, increases the likelihood of chronic illness and infections, and reduces the body's ability to recover from severe infection, making sepsis more likely to become life-threatening.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I am acutely aware at my age that one of my significant organs is visually fading and failing, and that is my skin. But the serious point is, as our skin fails, the increased risk of cuts, tears and the formation of ulcers becomes ever more prevalent, all bringing with them the attendant risk of infection. And that sadly was the case for my mother. That sepsis is the second biggest killer after cardiovascular disease is evidence of why awareness is so important. The earlier sepsis is recognised and appropriate help sought, the better the chance of preventing a devastating outcome.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I also want to use this debate to share the experience of one of my Carlisle constituents, Kelly Patterson. Kelly developed bilary sepsis in December last year. She describes how she didn't know she had it until she woke up on a ward, having spent three days in intensive care. Kelly's story is an important reminder of just how unpredictable and unexpected sepsis can be. And what she particularly wanted me to emphasise today is that there is no one single experience of sepsis.
It can affect people in very different ways, and the seriousness of what is happening may not always be immediately obvious. And that... I'll happily give way.
Sureena Brackenridge
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. I was wondering whether she would agree with me that there's really good practice across other countries, including in Australia, where they have a national sepsis standard with standardised clinical pathways and a public awareness campaign similar to ours, which is aligned with that simple question: could it be sepsis? There is work that's been happening across the globe that has reduced sepsis mortality. So does she agree that it is worth looking beyond our borders?
Julie Minns
I thank my honourable friend for raising that very important point. I think the more best practice we can bring to our country that's available elsewhere, the better. Awareness cannot stop at the point of diagnosis. Surviving sepsis can be a major event in someone's life, and the effects can continue well beyond the immediate illness. Patients and their families may need information, support and help as they recover.
This is why I welcome the Government's Sepsis Modern Service Framework. It represents an important step forward in how we approach this condition. It sets out a long-term plan to improve sepsis care across prevention, recognition, diagnosis, treatment and recovery, with the ambition of reducing deaths, life-threatening complications and the long-term effects of sepsis by at least 25% by 2035. That ambition is significant, and the success of the framework will be measured in earlier recognition, prompt treatment and ongoing support for survivors who need it.
The framework's focus on better data, research, and innovation is particularly welcome. Improving how we identify sepsis, developing faster and more accurate diagnosis, and learning from patients' experiences can all help clinicians intervene earlier and improve outcomes. I hope, through the Sepsis Modern Service Framework, we can make sure that when people do seek help, they are heard, sepsis is recognized as early as possible, and they receive the care and support they need.
Speaker 228
Which brings us to the front bench contributions. I call Danny Chambers for the Liberal Democrats.
Danny Chambers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also pay tribute to the member for South Staffordshire for so vividly highlighting his personal experience of sepsis. That was a very emotional speech, and it's very good to see him sitting here and looking so healthy as well. Around one in five deaths worldwide are associated with sepsis. That's 11 million deaths a year.
And I recently met Ron Daniels, who's the founder and chief medical officer of the UK Sepsis Trust, to discuss the new Sepsis Modern Service Framework. And we very much welcome its ambition to reduce deaths and life-threatening complications and the long-term impact of sepsis by at least 25% over the next decade. But if we're serious about achieving this, we need to get much better at detecting infection early. Now, sepsis is the body's extreme response to infection, whether that's, you know, viral, bacterial, or fungal, and it can cause organ failure, permanent disability, and death. And crucially, it can deteriorate incredibly quickly.
Now, there's no one single diagnostic test for sepsis. Its symptoms overlap with many other conditions, and clinicians are often having to make decisions with incomplete information. And this is why rapid diagnostic tests are so important. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I recently held a meeting with Winchester Hospital, local GPs, and local authority, and laboratories, and manufacturers of various rapid diagnostic tests to look at what the barriers are to implementing rapid diagnostic tests, especially so people can have them in the community for earlier diagnosis and also prevention of hospital admissions. Better diagnostics mean earlier treatment.
It means being able to use the right antibiotic for the right infection. It means preventing patients deteriorating into sepsis. And it also means using fewer unnecessary antibiotics, which ultimately result in antimicrobial resistance developing, and this is another huge growing public health concern. Now, prevention matters too. That means reversing the falling vaccination rates we've been seeing in recent years to prevent these infections occurring in the first place.
It also means ensuring that hospitals have the facilities to isolate and care properly for infectious patients. And crucially, it also means tackling corridor care and long wait at A&E, because when someone is deteriorating in those conditions, they're often not diagnosed, well, every hour matters, as we know, and in the case of corridor care and long waits, that means people's diagnosis are more likely to be delayed and the treatment's more likely to be delayed. But Madam Deputy Speaker, there's one group of patients I want to specifically talk about, and that is cancer patients. Now, we rightly focus on treating the cancer itself, but infection and often sepsis is the second biggest cause of death of people with cancer.
Now this may seem surprising but the cancer itself can cause a reduction in in people's immunity but also the chemotherapy and various treatments cause people to become immunocompromised. This weakens the immune system, makes them more prone to getting infections. It also means that repeat infections mean they're more likely to get have repeat uses of antibiotics and more likely to have antibiotic resistant infections. And so the consequences of infection on people with cancer can be even more serious. And it's why I find one omission from the government's national cancer plan quite striking.
It's an 86 page strategy setting out how we're going to transform cancer care by 2035 and yet infection is only mentioned once in those 86 pages and that's just in the foreword. Now this isn't a minor oversight. This is a glaring omission to that risks undermining the entire cancer strategy because we would never produce a cancer strategy that treated radiotherapy or chemotherapy or surgery as sort of peripheral to cancer care. So we need to ensure that we're treating infection which is the second biggest killer of cancer patients as integral to cancer care. Infection prevention, rapid diagnostics, antimicrobial stewardship and surveillance absolutely need to be central to cancer care, not as an afterthought.
And if we fail to address infection properly, we're setting the entire new cancer strategy up to fail. Madam Deputy Speaker to finish, sepsis contributes to tens of thousands of deaths in the UK each year as well as leaving many survivors with life changing physical and psychological consequences. But I have one specific request of the government this evening and that is to update if the minister would commit to updating the national cancer strategy to incorporate infection control, sepsis and rapid diagnostic tests as absolutely integral to cancer management. And we welcome the new sepsis modern service framework. We just need to deliver it.
Caroline Johnson
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I first must start by declaring my interest as an NHS consultant pediatrician, a member of the Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health, member of the British Medical Association and a mother of three children. I then would like to congratulate my honorable friend the member for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire for securing this debate alongside the honorable members for Dartford and the honorable member for Ashford. But in particular to thank my honorable friend the member for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire for his speech which was hugely moving and I can't believe it's been such a long time since it happened but it's great to see him looking so well today. I'd also like to express my condolences to the honorable lady for Carlisle and the brave speech that she gave as well. I remember sitting in this chamber a little over two years ago Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sure you were there as well, when the honorable member for South Thanet Lord Mackinlay, the then member for Lord Thanet South Thanet Lord Mackinlay received a rare standing ovation in this place from from the house and from the galleries as he returned to parliament following his remarkable recovery from sepsis.
His his journey has been incredible and his story is one that's brought renewed attention to the disease killing which kills nearly 50,000 people every year. For context Madam Deputy Speaker, that is around the same number of people who die from bowel, breast and prostate cancer combined. But with the attention to prevention, to early identification of infection, to early diagnosis, to better treatments and the avoidance of antimicrobial resistance, we can reduce this and save people's lives.
As I said, raising awareness of sepsis and how suddenly it can change someone's condition is vital. And the previous Conservative government got the ball rolling in this regard. My right honourable friend, the member for Godalming and Ash, adopted the UK Sepsis Trust 'Just Ask: Could It Be Sepsis?' campaign in 2016 when he was the Health Secretary. The Conservatives also backed sepsis research with over a billion pounds through the National Institute for Health and Care Research. And research is important because it'll help us improve the diagnosis and treatment.
And it will help us understand why some people get an infection and it makes them a little bit ill, and some people get an infection and it turns to sepsis. Why? It helps to better understand. Now, this was a good start, but of course there is, as always with medicine, more to do. And it was pleasing to see the previous Starmer government build on this work by introducing the modern service framework for sepsis. And we have modern service frameworks now for other diseases, and it seems good to have one for sepsis specifically.
The guiding light of this framework is the government's ambition to reduce sepsis deaths by 25% by 2035. And I think that's something with which we could all agree, but saying it won't deliver it. It has to have a plan, and the plan has to be deliverable and funded as well. So I ask the Minister what funding has the government committed to implement the framework that has been written. As we know, early diagnosis is paramount, but sepsis is notoriously difficult to diagnose and very rapid as well, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I remember seeing a patient, the mum had got up in the middle of the night to use the bathroom, not something she did normally, wasn't quite sure why she had on that particular night. As she was walking back along the landing, she thought, 'Hmm, it's a bit cold, I'll just check.' And she checked her son, had his blankets on and was warm, but she just did so, just in the light from the landing, spotted a little mark on the little boy's leg. Turned the light on and saw that he was developing that rash that doesn't blanch, that goes with meningococcal sepsis. And she brought him in, and he survived and he went home well.
But I shudder to think what would have happened if she'd waited till she woke up routinely at 7 o'clock in the morning. So someone was watching, make sure that she was, he was safe, and I'm so glad that that was the case. But it is so very, very rapid, as other members have testified to. And there's no single test. There's no single thing we can monitor or measure that helps.
Flu-like symptoms mimic many other common illnesses. And on top of that, as we've heard already, diagnosis and treatment are absolutely time-critical. Now, the UK Sepsis Trust has developed the Sepsis 6: oxygen, cultures, antibiotics, fluids, lactate management, and urinary output monitoring. And all of these should be carried out within the first hour. The government's MSF commits to rapid diagnostic tools and more advanced genomic sequencing.
What infrastructure and workforce investment is required by the government to set this up, and over what timeframe does the government envisage that this will be achieved? And talking of workforce, Madam Deputy Speaker, the government decided to ditch the previous government's NHS workforce plan to create its own, which is of course absolutely its right. But their replacement was originally due to be published in early 2025 and was most recently promised as imminent just before the summer break. But we're now well into September 2026 and there's still no plan. The Minister in the other place was asked for more details about the workforce plan, and her written answer simply stated that the government will provide an update on the 10-year workforce plan in due course.
So could the Minister please update us on when this plan is going to be published, preferably with a date rather than an expression of soon or imminent? Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to also talk about Group B streptococcal infection. This is something I've seen in paediatric practice, particularly in babies. It's a common bacteria which lives harmlessly in the gut or lower reproductive tract. But there's a risk it can enter the bloodstream causing neonatal sepsis when passed to newborns.
The GBS3 trial is looking to prevent and reduce the impact of group B strep, and the government's framework commits to supporting that. So could the minister tell us more about how the government plans to do that? And then Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to talk about prevention, because prevention is something the government has said is one of its big shifts in medicine. Some sepsis can be prevented or reduced, and research has shown, for example, that if ibuprofen is given to children with chickenpox, it increases the likelihood of them developing sepsis. We know that completing the antibiotic course is important.
We know that handwashing technique is important and keeping things clean is important, particularly in preventing sepsis that is acquired in hospitals. Management of chronic disease reduces the risk too. And then there's vaccination. Madam Deputy Speaker, meningitis B is possibly one of the most scary infections and conditions that one sees as a doctor because it progresses so quickly. And it can cause brain damage, amputations, and death, but there is a highly effective vaccine which was introduced for infants born in the middle of 2015 onwards.
But as the outbreak in Kent, Dorset, and Berkshire last year showed, with three young people dying, it can still come back in older children. The JCVI met in July 2026 and suggested an increase in the vaccination schedule for these young people. The JCVI recommended that young children who had had one dose of vaccine should have another at age 15. They recommended two doses for those who hadn't had it, and a catch-up for older people starting university. Very shortly, Madam Deputy Speaker, it will be freshers' week.
And around 580,000 young people will head off to university for the first time with great excitement. But university students are seven times more likely to get invasive meningococcal sepsis than people who do not go to university. And the government have only managed to vaccinate 246,000 of those, something that the UK Health Security Agency issued a document about last week. They said that 97% of invasive meningococcal disease in 15 to 24-year-olds last year was caused by meningitis B. So I ask the minister questions that I asked her last week in the vaccine debate but haven't received an answer to yet.
When is she going to review and respond to the requests for vaccines in the younger children that haven't had them yet, those doses at 15 and the two doses for those who haven't had a dose yet? And what is she doing to increase awareness for those people starting university in the next week or so?
I will of course give way.
Vikki Slade
I thank the shadow minister for giving way and I'm really grateful to her raising this as I raised it earlier on. My son George and his girlfriend Maisie both had their two doses in the last few weeks as they turned 18. But my constituent Victoria asked me to write to the minister a few months ago about education and awareness. And I was really disappointed that the Department for Education didn't think it was necessary to start adding this into the sort of PHSE programme in secondary school about meningitis awareness. I wonder whether the shadow minister would support me in doing that.
Caroline Johnson
It's clearly important that young people are aware of the signs of infection, particularly such a serious infection, so I'd agree with that. But I'm interested in what the minister's doing to try and prevent those infections by ensuring that the right people have the right vaccines to do so. And also the government is changing the way the vaccines are commissioned from NHS England, which they're abolishing, to the ICBs are going to be responsible for vaccinations. How is this change going to impact on vaccines and how is it going to impact on vaccines for students who live in one place and go to university in another in particular?
So to sum up, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Government's ambition to reduce sepsis and sepsis deaths should be welcomed, and it is good to have a modern service framework in place. But I'm sure that charities such as the UK Sepsis Trust and families affected by sepsis would be most grateful if the Minister could provide further clarity on the Government's roadmap and the funding required to reach this important destination.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I start by congratulating the honourable Member for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire for securing this important debate from the Backbench Business Committee on the floor of the House of Commons during World Sepsis Awareness Month. And I also want to thank him for his tireless advocacy on sepsis as the co-chair of the APPG. And in his excellent opening speech, he spoke very movingly about his own experience, and he said that consultants gave him a 10% chance of surviving when he was ill with sepsis. So the odds were that he would not be with us today, but I am very grateful that he is and looking so well, and that he can be such a very strong voice in this place on sepsis. And I also want to compliment the work that is carried on by Lord McKinley in the other place, and like the Shadow Minister, I remember the standing ovation that he received when he returned to the House of Commons after he'd battled life-threatening sepsis in 2023 resulting in the four-limb amputations.
What a brave, brave and decent man, and there's been many tributes around the chamber this afternoon. I also just wanted to refer to some of the contributions that have been made. My honourable friend for Dartford, who spoke so powerfully on behalf of his constituent John, who fought sepsis and is a quadruple amputee. He talked very movingly about how the community had rallied around the family to provide support, but also spoke about how we need to do much more in supporting people like John in the post-recovery period. And then my honourable friend for Carlisle, who spoke again so eloquently about her mum, who she lost to sepsis last year, and I hope she will accept my condolences, and also her constituent Kelly Patterson, and who again reminded us that sepsis affects people in different ways, and how important it is to remember that.
And then the honourable Member for Winchester, who speaks on behalf of the Liberal Democrats, highlighted the particular risks that people with cancer face in relation to sepsis, and I will certainly take back to the department the concerns that he's raised today. Madam Deputy Speaker, sepsis is a devastating condition. It also costs the NHS really significant sums of money, over a billion pounds between 24 and 25. So during this Sepsis Awareness Month, I want to pay tribute to the charities, including the UK Sepsis Trust and Sepsis Research FEAT, who do so much to support families, raise awareness, and fund research. Their contribution to the new Sepsis Modern Service Framework was invaluable, and they acted as a megaphone for so many people whose lives have been devastated by sepsis.
Now, my deepest condolences go out to everyone who has been affected, not least Merope Mills and other campaigners, but I know that today people are not seeking my sympathy, they actually want the Government to support the case that they're making.
And if I now turn to the sepsis modern service framework, we worked hand in hand with patient representatives, clinical experts, professional bodies, NHS organisations and charities to build the framework. And this has entered the history books, I believe, as the first ever large scale engagement process for improving sepsis care. The framework spells out this government's commitment, as has been said, to transform sepsis care by 2035. It sets out priority actions to improve prevention, recognition, treatment and recovery while accelerating innovation. Madam Deputy Speaker, I completely understand that people will say, okay, you've now got the framework, so now what happens next?
And I do want to say that we are going to make real progress and by doing that, we're going to raise our game in a number of areas including science, technology and data. And that's why the National Institute for Health and Care Research, working with academia, industry and other partners, will develop a national research and innovation action plan for sepsis by March next year. This will include research calls that cover sepsis improvement priorities, whether that's vaccination and screening, faster and more accurate diagnosis or innovative treatments. Now, it's true that the most recent data from the ONS suggests that sepsis deaths went down in 2024. However, this data is incomplete and inconsistent.
This is due to changes in awareness, diagnosis and recording, making it harder to understand variation and improve care. Without this data, we don't have a full picture and that's why the framework commits to collecting better sepsis data and NHS England is commissioning a national infection and sepsis audit. This should give us a clearer picture of mortality, underlying causes and which groups are most affected. And if I turn to understanding, I think it's right to say that honourable members have highlighted that sepsis is a complex condition which is difficult to recognise because of the variation in symptoms. Many people are unaware that sepsis can develop from common infections such as urinary tract infections and few can recognise the full range of symptoms.
That's precisely why raising awareness is so important and as we've heard from members across the house today, the work of campaigners has had a huge impact across the NHS and wider society. The NHS now has a planned targeted public communications campaign to improve the awareness of sepsis symptoms and the actions to take. And the I will, yes.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way on that point. As was referenced earlier, the UK Sepsis Trust had a big bang in 2016 with those famous orange and red posters that you see in a lot of GP surgeries, hospital waiting rooms, etc, think could it be sepsis. But those information campaigns dwindle and they become samey and people get used to seeing them and then not thinking about them. How can the government have an almost permanent awareness campaign that refreshes such a huge killer in our country in the minds of our clinicians and our doctors who do wonderful work, but they're under such incredible pressure that they need that constant reminder of things like sepsis?
Diana Ruth Johnson
I think the honourable gentleman makes a very important point actually and making sure that you maintain good public campaigning and public campaigns around issues like this is something that we are working on all the time and we're reviewing what works, the best methods to use.
So I absolutely take his point and I would say it's not a one point in time you do it, it has to be an ongoing campaign. I also just wanted to refer to the NHS has got better at recognizing as well and responding to all the causes of deterioration that we might see, including in sepsis, since the introduction of the National Early Warning Score. This system helps to identify patients who are seriously ill through clear scored measures that are routinely recorded by their bedside. And it's used by every single ambulance trust and 99% of acute trusts in England, and the framework will help improve the consistency of its use. To further support the way we identify sepsis, the framework also prioritizes advancements in faster, more accurate diagnosis to improve outcomes and the correct use of antibiotics.
The framework will support better access to rapid tests in urgent and emergency care to tackle those services often under the most pressure where sepsis can slip through the cracks. In the longer term, the government is promoting wearable health technologies as part of our 10-year plan. So the framework will also explore new points of care tests that can determine exactly what kind of infection someone may have, alongside the use of wearable technologies to support monitoring of high-risk groups. If I could just say a few words more, Madam Deputy Speaker, about escalation. I think no one knows a child better than their parents or carers.
And that is why listening to patients, carers, and families is vital to support sepsis recognition and escalation. Too many cases have shown the devastating consequences when deterioration concerns are not heard. The death of Martha Mills was an avoidable tragedy. But I hope her parents take some consolation from knowing that Martha's rule is saving lives and helping thousands of patients benefit from changes to their care. I'd like to thank them for their tireless campaigning in Martha's memory and the real change this has now brought.
To remind colleagues, Martha's rule means patients, their families, and staff can request a rapid review from a different team if deterioration concerns are not being recognized. From September 24 to June this year, almost 17,500 Martha rules calls were made. 5,000 of those calls were made when families had concerns that their loved one's condition was deteriorating rapidly. Of those, 60% required changes in treatment, with 13% leading to transfers to intensive care and 47% leading to other care changes, including investigations, procedural interventions, etc. And today, Martha's rule is being rolled out across all acute hospitals in England.
It's also important that we look at what happens, and this has been raised in the House this afternoon, to people who survive sepsis and who can experience a long-term, a range of long-term physical, psychological, and cognitive health consequences. As the Secretary of State has said, the NHS is cradle to grave, and that means everything in between. It's not acceptable that when someone has been through the worst experience of their life, they are just left to get on with it. And that's why we're committed to improving access to post-discharge support and rehabilitation, with priority action set out in the framework. Of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, the best way to stop sepsis is through preventing infection.
Vaccination and infection prevention and control are fundamental.
It's been raised already, but the outbreaks of meningitis B in England this year highlight how quickly infection can lead to sepsis and death. The outbreaks highlighted the importance of prompt treatment and the benefits of vaccination. The one-off NHS MenB vaccination programme has successfully delivered almost 250,000 first doses to eligible young people across England since launching on the 20th of July 2026. And I would encourage everyone who hasn't yet come forward to do so and ensure that they get both doses of the vaccine for proper protection. The framework commits to improving vaccine access, and I know the shadow minister has a number of questions that she's put to me and I will respond in writing as I'm conscious of the time.
The framework also recognizes the tension between prompt antimicrobial treatment for sepsis and the risks of unnecessary antibiotic use. The framework complements initiatives within the antimicrobial resistance national action plan. Madam Deputy Speaker, I think there are just there's just one other thing I wanted to say, which is around funding and also implementation. Funding was one of the specific questions that the honourable member raised in his opening speech. And I want to make clear that the immediate and short-term actions will be delivered within existing funding under the current departmental allocation following the 2025 spending review.
Longer-term funding is subject to future spending reviews. The Department and NHS England are committed to prioritizing funding for sepsis in future spending bids. And the framework is a 10-year plan, and I do not pretend that we will deliver everything overnight, but it sets clear targets to reduce deaths by a quarter over the next 10 years. There is a clear metric to judge our success by and to hold ministers to account, and implementation will be overseen by the National Quality Board. In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, it has become a bit of a cliché to say things like World Sepsis Day is marked once a year, but our work continues all year round.
However, I can assure honourable members that the Sepsis Modern Service Framework is doing just that. For every single day over the next 10 years, the framework will keep pushing us to do better. And so let me end by again thanking the honourable member for raising this debate, for his leadership of the APPG, and I look forward to working constructively with him going forward.
Mike Wood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank all of the honourable members who have contributed to the debate. The honourable gentleman from Dartford who spoke so movingly about his constituent John, and was particularly pleased to hear not only how well he is now doing since recovering, but also the support that his family received from within the community, and particularly Dartford Working Men's Club, the work that they are doing within the community. Because if we're really to increase awareness of sepsis so that people understand both the signs and the risks of sepsis, it can't be left to the NHS alone. This really does need to be a full community effort, and so it's great to hear that that working men's club is taking a lead in that. He also spoke rightly about the importance of data, and part of the problem we have had is the inconsistency in the way that sepsis cases are reported, that makes it so difficult to have a meaningful figure of the number of cases, the number of deaths, the number of serious disabilities as a result of sepsis.
So we really do need more consistency in that, the way that's coded and the best practice guide.
The honorable lady from Carlisle and I join the minister in offering my condolences on the sad loss of her mother. And I know how that must have been an unbelievably difficult time. But she also spoke about her constituent Caroline, the very important message that different people do experience sepsis very differently, both in terms of the outcomes and the lasting impact, but also the nature of the sepsis. There are also important interventions from the honorable lady from Mid Dorset and North Poole, the honorable lady from Stoke-on-Trent South, and the honorable lady from Wolverhampton North East. The Liberal Democrat spokesman referred to the, I think, the force of nature that is Ron Daniels, who I think has done so much to push sepsis up the public agenda, but also to change the way the NHS understands and responds to sepsis.
And so I think we all owe him a huge debt. My honorable friend, the shadow minister, spoke about how notoriously difficult sepsis is to diagnose and the difficulties that that creates, but also the issues around prenatal strep and the additional work that needs to be done both in understanding and responding to the sepsis that arises. I was pleased to hear the, and thank you to the minister for the very kind words she offered to me personally, but also to the generally the spirit of her response, and particularly around the implementation plan and the funding. And she rightly referred to Martha's Rule and the importance of making sure that families who, as she said, do know their children better than anyone else, and so it allows those families to insist on an independent second opinion if they feel that there's been a deterioration in condition, and that's so important. I would like to just briefly, Madam Deputy Speaker, thank the many, many campaigners who have worked so hard on this issue, often because they've been sadly affected or a member of their families have been affected.
They're too numerous to name, but if I could just very briefly mention the incredible work done by Harry Redknapp, who works tirelessly and often without an awful lot of publicity and credit to raise awareness of sepsis following his wife Sandra's illness whilst he was, I think he was in the jungle with I'm a Celebrity when she was taken ill. But Harry does so much incredible work voluntarily. And also the research and charities who work in this area, Sepsis Trust, but particularly the UK, sorry, Sepsis Research, but particularly the UK Sepsis Trust, both Ron Daniels and Sarah Hamilton-Fairley, I think have really helped to keep this issue rising to the importance that it deserves. But once again, I thank all members for the valuable contributions they've made today, and I look forward to holding the minister to account as she delivers on that modern service framework.
Speaker 216
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
I will just allow the front bench to swap over before the remaining orders. We now come to motion number three relating to the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee. Mark Tami.
I beg to move.
Speaker 216
The question is as on the order paper as many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no, I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Petition, Vicky Slade.
Vikki Slade
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. When most children go home from school they may bury their head in a book, grab a football or turn on the TV, but for young carers home time looks very different. They carry burdens on their shoulders that are way beyond their years and as a result their life chances are affected. Research shows they are twice as likely to be persistently absent from school, less likely to pass their GCSEs and much more likely to face suspension from school. I've been working with MyTime Young Carers, a charity based in Mid Dorset and North Poole who've pioneered young carer champions in schools across Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole and they are seeing a difference.
And during an event with the Carers Trust last week, the Children's Commissioner herself also indicated her support for this when suggested to her. Carers charities across the country have shared my petition which now has nearly 4,000 signatures calling for a champion in every school to support young carers in their communities and the petitioners remain etc.
Matthew Stephen Darling
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Further to our online petition around NHS dentistry which had over a thousand signatures, there are, there continues to be a desperate need in many coastal communities including mine in Torbay for many, many more NHS dentists. That's why I'm delighted to present the petition here this afternoon that calls on the government to reform the NHS dentistry contract to make sure that coastal communities such as mine are served adequately by NHS dentists. The petitioners remain etc.
Speaker 216
Petition, Dentistry in Coastal Areas. I beg to move that this house do now adjourn. The question is that this house do now adjourn, Jim Dickson.
Jim Dickson
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I am grateful to have the opportunity this evening just before we rise for recess to raise the case of George Low, a Dartford resident who was tragically murdered in Cyprus in August 2016, now 10 years ago. Before I give an outline of the case, I want to pay tribute to George's parents, Martyn and Helen Low, who are with us tonight in the gallery. Since my election two years ago I've had the opportunity to meet them and never fail to be struck by their dignity and determination to seek justice for their son.
I want to say also something about my predecessor as Member of Parliament for Dartford, Gareth Johnson, who I have spoken to in depth about this terrible case and who raised it repeatedly with ministers in the last government and travelled to Cyprus himself to seek action. He pursued every avenue he could to support the Low family and I pay tribute to him. I want to speak tonight about the attack on George and his friend Ben, what we know about the subsequent events and the very difficult context in which this case sits. I have tried to keep the information that I'm going to refer to to material that is already in the public domain. George, who was only 22 years old on the night of his murder, was holidaying with friends in Ayia Napa in the south-east of Cyprus, as many people from the UK continue to do.
It was the last night of his holiday and he was coming home to the UK the next day. George had worked previously in Ayia Napa but had been back in the UK beginning what looked like it was going to be a highly successful career with Acorn Group estate agents, who paid a touching tribute to him after his death. The inquest into George's murder in Maidstone several years later heard how a dispute occurred in the area near the Bell pub in the early hours of the 14th of August 2016. After this disagreement, two men returned with a knife, resulting in George being stabbed in the neck and tragically dying. The names of the two suspects, Mehmet Akpinar and Sali Ahmed, have been widely reported since this time.
His friend Ben Barker was also stabbed four times in the back but thankfully survived, and I want to pay tribute to Ben's family for their continued support in the search for justice for George. The police collected substantial evidence from the incident, including I understand the knives used, but before any arrests could be made, the two suspects had fled across the border to the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, where despite their arrest for a series of different offences, they were not handed back to the Republic of Cyprus for trial. That same week George's parents made the first of a number of visits to Cyprus, beginning their fight for justice for George. It is later believed that both suspects made their way to Turkey, where as far as we know they remain to this day. Since 2016, there have been two inquests, one here and one in Cyprus, that the family have attended.
Both suspects have faced trials in the north for crimes related to illegal entry violations and have served time in prison as a result, but were not extradited to the south for trial for George's murder. One suspect was then deported back to Turkey and the other ended up in Turkey via a circuitous route. The one trial that has taken place related to the murder was of the girlfriend of one of the suspects, Mehmet Akpinar. She faced trial in 2016 for the assistance provided to him after the murder and would I hope be a witness in any potential trial. The diplomatic situation in Cyprus and with Turkey remains extremely difficult and there is limited cooperation between the two communities in Cyprus.
It remains the case that there is no extradition treaty in place between Turkey and Cyprus to allow the suspects to be sent there for trial. Additionally, the constitution in Turkey specifically prohibits the extradition of their citizens for any offence. This leaves the prospect of a trial taking place in Cyprus as limited, despite the Cypriot authorities possessing evidence that seemingly would make a prosecution possible. The Low family have been ably supported by the organisation Justice Abroad and barrister Michael Polak, who I'm very pleased is with us tonight, and they are acting pro bono and whose expertise, Michael's expertise on this complex situation is greatly appreciated. He has been repeatedly writing to the Attorney General of the Republic of Cyprus over the last 11 months asking that they release the evidence they possess to the family, but has not yet received a response.
Recent news coverage, including by the BBC, has included confirmation from the Ministry of Justice in Turkey that, and I quote, "the investigation was referred to the Hatay Public Prosecutor's Office, which has subsequently issued a decision of non-prosecution, no grounds to proceed, in respect of Mr Mehmet Akpinar", unquote. The report doesn't include any comment on the second suspect, which I hope may be grounds for some optimism that his prosecution in Turkey may still remain possible. The BBC report also includes the claim that a request for legal assistance in connection with the investigation had been made by the Ministry of Justice in Turkey to the UK, but they had not received a response. The family are keen to assist Turkey and receive an update from the Turkish authorities. Regrettably, our repeated requests for a meeting with the Turkish Embassy have not yet provided any result.
One of the suspects is, I understand, a dual Bulgarian-Turkish national, and I appreciate the willingness of the Bulgarian Embassy to meet with my predecessor as the MP for Dartford. I am grateful to the Minister for her time today. Before I hand over to her to respond, I wanted to set out the questions that I hope she may be able to answer in her response. I believe that the UK Government can play a key role in securing justice for the Low family, given the strong relationship it has with both Turkey and Cyprus and its long-standing position as one of the guarantor powers of Cyprus's independence and territorial integrity. So the questions are, firstly, could she provide any clarity on the request that was made by the Ministry of Justice in Turkey to the UK Government for legal assistance and why it has not been answered?
Secondly, will the UK Government make a request to the Cypriot authorities for release of the evidence they hold in this case to assist a prosecution in another jurisdiction? I understand that were the suspects in the UK, a prosecution may be possible here. Will the Minister's Department engage with the authorities in Turkey to discuss the prospect of a prosecution and how evidence might be transferred? I appreciate the Minister may not be able to say everything in the Chamber she might wish to, so finally I will ask, would she be willing to meet with me along with the family and their barrister to discuss the issues that I've raised today in more detail? At the time of his death, George's daughter was eight months old, and I understand that now aged 10, she looks very much like him, a sweet reminder to the family of George.
It's my abiding wish in this case that George's daughter must not grow to be an adult without seeing justice for her dad.
Uma Kumaran
Minister, Uma Kumaran.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to my honourable friend, the member for Dartford, for securing this important debate and for his powerful support for George's parents, Helen, Martin and their family. He spoke very movingly this evening. I will do my best to respond to the points that he raised. But first, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a deeply tragic case that continues to have a profound impact on George Low's family and loved ones.
I also want to acknowledge the impact this has had on Ben, who survived this violent attack, and on his family, who have continued to advocate on behalf of George. To George's family, 10 years on, I recognise the strength, determination and courage they have shown in the face of unimaginable pain and loss. Losing a child is an unbearable pain and something you never truly recover from. At the heart of this debate is a young man whose life was taken far too soon and a family whose lives were changed forever. They've spent a decade seeking answers and justice for George.
I understand their frustration and their pain, particularly as 10 years on, they're still seeking answers and justice they deserve. Madam Deputy Speaker, turning to the government's action. While responsibility for this investigation lies with the Cypriot authorities, the UK government has remained actively engaged on this case throughout. Consular officials have maintained contact with George's family and their legal representatives and will continue to do so. We've provided updates wherever new information has been available and sought clarification from the relevant authorities on developments in the investigation.
Consular staff contacted George's family shortly after his murder in 2016 and have remained in touch ever since, on the decade ever since. They've supported the family during visits to Cyprus, helped facilitate meetings with investigators and officials and provided assistance during the UK coronial inquest. I'm glad that the family have been able to access the specialist support services offered by the UK's homicide service and have a dedicated caseworker in the FCDO. But of course, what the family need and deserve are answers about George's death. Cypriot authorities identified two suspects and issued international arrest warrants.
The suspects are understood to have left Cyprus after George's death and now believed to be in Turkey. The case remains open with the Cypriot authorities. Throughout this time, the British High Commission in Nicosia and consular officials pushed for progress with the investigation and prosecution of the suspects. George's family have, quite understandably, engaged lawyers to represent them in this effort. I also acknowledge the support, as mentioned by my honourable friend for Dartford, of the help of Justice Abroad.
Our FCDO officials are in contact with George's family's lawyers. At the family's request, the British High Commission have asked the Cypriot authorities in 2024 to consider transferring the case to Turkey so that Turkish authorities could explore a prosecution. This year, further representations were made in support of this request. Frustratingly, the Cypriot authorities decided not to pursue this option. They believed it would be difficult for Cypriot officials to provide the evidence and testimony needed to support a case in Turkish court.
The FCDO has also engaged with the Turkish authorities directly to press them to take action on arrest warrants. We'll continue to reinforce that message with Turkey.
Speaker 240
As a matter of common practice, I'm not able to comment either way on a matter of mutual legal assistance. However, I can confirm that United Kingdom officials are following up in Turkey and Cyprus to ensure that they have opportunities to progress this case and that those opportunities have been followed up. Secondly, on release of evidence. I can confirm that we have lobbied Cyprus to transfer the case to Turkish jurisdiction. They've told us they're not in a position to do that as a result of jurisdictional issues between the two countries.
I'm aware the family's lawyer has asked the Cypriot authorities for clarity on the decision, and I've asked our officials to ensure that this is followed up. Thirdly, on progressing the investigation in Turkey. Again, Madam Deputy Speaker, I've asked officials to ensure this is followed up to ensure we fully understand the reasons for Cyprus's position. I've also asked officials to speak again to Turkey about its position on this question. And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, on my honorable friend's request to meet George's family and him.
The answer is yes. I will speak to my colleague Lord Wood to agree who would be best placed to take this meeting and I'll ensure they get a timely response. Madam Deputy Speaker, looking ahead. I understand the pain that George's family have felt for the last 10 years. 10 years without justice is unacceptable, and any family in their position would feel the same.
As the minister responding, it's important to be clear and honest about what the UK government can and cannot do. We cannot compel another country to take specific investigative, prosecutorial or judicial decisions. Those powers rest with the competent authorities in the countries concerned. But what we can do and what we will continue to do is to support the family, to raise the case where appropriate and pursue any credible avenue that would help move this forward. Looking ahead, the Cypriot authorities have confirmed that international arrest warrants remain in place and that they're ready to move forward if either suspect is detained, whether in Turkey or elsewhere.
We will continue to press Turkey to take action. Let me end by saying this. 10 years on, George's family continue to live with the devastating consequences of his murder. They've shown extraordinary determination in their search for justice, and I pay tribute to them for that. I also want to thank my honorable friend for Dartford for his and his predecessor's tireless advocacy on this matter.
I know my honorable friend has raised this matter consistently and tirelessly in this house and will continue to do so. While the UK government cannot resolve the legal and jurisdictional barriers that have complicated this case, we have not forgotten George, and we will not forget his family. We'll continue to support them, continue to engage with the relevant authorities and continue to press for progress wherever we can. Above all, George was a son, a father, a loved one, and a young man whose life was cut tragically short. His family deserve answers, and they deserve to know that this government will continue to stand alongside them in their pursuit for justice.
Speaker 216
The question is that this house do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.