House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsIlora Finlay
My lords, following on from the very helpful meeting that the noble lady Baroness Lovett held with several of us who've been concerned about this for many years, could the minister now tell us when there have been meetings with the Court of Protection to develop a fast-track process that would then be compatible with the Mental Capacity Act and that would avoid the delays and expenses that are incurred but would recognise that these funds mature when the child becomes an adult at the age of 18 and therefore it is legally adult-to-adult transfer?
Speaker 3
I think the noble lady knows that over the years that this has been going on since 2020, various changes have been made to the Court of Protection framework to make this easier and cheaper to deal with. As I say, I won't answer your question specifically because I know this work is actively underway, but I'm very happy to set out to the noble lady exactly what the arrangements are for the Court of Protection.
I would say, and I do think this is important to reiterate, the Mental Capacity Act is there to protect people's rights, and we don't want to undermine that in any way, and we won't, but we will seek a solution to this problem.
Susan Kramer
House used the opportunity of the Financial Services and Markets Bill to send an amendment to the other place, which would enable the FCA to, in effect, enable financial institutions to release these funds based on their existing knowledge and relationship of the parents, the guardians, and the young people, whom they know because for many years those parents and guardians have been managing large sums of public money on that child's behalf. So will the government please take that seriously as that bill is addressed down the other end, because it gets us around the dynamic of having to make very extensive changes to the Mental Capacity Act and delivers a solution in a very practical way.
Speaker 3
Yes, I'm very well aware of the amendments that the noble lady put down in relation to child trust funds and junior ISAs. I think it's fair to say there are slightly different issues involved in child trust funds and junior ISAs, but as I say, and I hope she can take some reassurance from that, we have considered the amendments that she put down, which are now in the other place, and we are thinking about a solution which does resolve the issue of principle here, which is that parents who care for their children in a loving and trusting way should be able to help those now young adults to get access to these funds.
Richard Keen
The Prime Minister has consistently talked of making quick fixes, although apparently that doesn't include the economy or our defense. But we've heard from noble lords and indeed from the noble lady, Baroness Kramer, that this trust fund issue could be easily and quickly fixed. So will the noble lord the minister undertake to share the proposal with our quick-fix Prime Minister?
Speaker 3
Well, I should demur from those observations about the economy and the defense, having listened to the budget with enthusiasm. I'm not sure about quick fixes, but what I am sure about is that the Prime Minister is aware of the need to resolve this problem, and we will. It's gone on too long, I wouldn't seek to pretend otherwise.
Speaker 16
My lords, can I thank the minister for the work he's doing to improve access to child trust funds for young people with reduced capacity. But is the minister aware, my noble friend aware, that there are thousands of disadvantaged young people who are not even aware that they have these child trust funds? Is the minister aware of the work of the Share Foundation, in particular the campaign for release at 21, and will look into that with a view to liberating these funds for people who need it?
Speaker 3
Yes, I am aware of that work, and I do want to pay tribute to all the charities and other campaigners, and I do particularly want to pay tribute to Andrew Turner, who has been so heavily involved in this campaign on behalf of his son Mikey, and Sir Ed Davey, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, whose thoughtful and persistent advocacy has done so much to ensure that this issue is receiving the attention it deserves. I should pause there, shouldn't I? I endorse that hear, hear, on this issue. But I would also say that the noble Lord Young and the noble Lord Blunkett have also played an important advocacy role on this subject. But these are, this is an important campaign, those are interesting and important proposals, and I thank the noble lord for my good work, but in fact it's Minister Richardson's work, and before him the noble lady Baroness Levitt.
Speaker 9
Noble lord the minister said that he would write to the noble lady Baroness Finlay of Llandaff to say what was happening with the Court of Protection. Could he also undertake to place a letter in the library, because I'm sure we would all like to know what the Court of Protection is doing?
Speaker 8
Could my noble friend explain why the proposal for automatic release at 21 hasn't been accepted?
Speaker 3
I'm not sure I quite said that. I think my noble friend will need to wait for the government announcement, which will come not in due course, but in the coming weeks.
Baroness Barron
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Jacqui Smith
My Lords, this approach to developing technical routes and vocational GCSEs is not about separating pupils into academic or vocational routes at age 14. Rather, it is about widening pupils' choices, supporting coherent progression to a range of academic and technical post-16 options. The new technical education routes will provide every young person with a clear path into further study, apprenticeships, or skilled work by combining academic excellence in core subjects with rigorous vocationally focused qualifications of equal parity and esteem as traditional GCSEs.
Baroness Barron
I'm not sure I heard in the noble lady's answer any of the robust evidence that I asked for, but I accept the intentions of the government. But the government has justified its pivot towards generic skills and vocational routes by suggesting that a knowledge-based academic curriculum has contributed to the high level of NEETs among our young people. But given that education is devolved and Wales and Scotland have pursued these vocational routes for many years and their levels of NEETs are higher than ours, would the noble lady the Minister concede that stripping academic rigor from our classrooms is a false remedy to a structural economic problem?
Jacqui Smith
Well, on the point about evidence, evidence actually suggests that the existing technical awards are taken slightly more often by disadvantaged pupils. That's one of the reasons why we are reforming the system, so that pupils' choices are driven by their interests and aspirations rather than their background. The noble lady suggested that this government has said that knowledge isn't important in the curriculum. That's wholly wrong. Actually, the whole as the noble lady will see when we publish our plans with respect to the curriculum following the curriculum and assessment review, we have been clear throughout that knowledge is a key element of the curriculum.
Speaker 18
But it is possible to deliver high-quality academic standards and deep knowledge alongside the opportunity for pupils also to develop vocational and technical skills in a way that provides a broad and deep curriculum that is currently missing.
Dominic Hubbard
My Lords, would the Minister give us some indication of what advice they are giving not only to the pupil, but also to the parents of these pupils about the value of these new qualifications?
qualifications, because if we are to get people taking subjects they have an aptitude for, as opposed to what is seen to be the desirable thing by somebody else, we will need to make sure that people understand that process.
Jacqui Smith
I think the noble lord makes a very important point, and of course we will be consulting on the content and nature of vocational GCSEs very soon during the course of this autumn. We're also, because this is about technical pathways delivered and developed at a local and regional level, we're also working closely with mayoral authorities, with employers and others, and I'm sure they, as we do, will want to ensure that there is strong advice for parents and clear information about what it means to take a vocational GCSE as part of that broad curriculum.
Speaker 30
I declare my interest as the chair of the Building Safety Regulator. I think it's fair to say that it's well understood across both sides of this house that the construction economy is one of the most important parts of our wider economy, it employs two million people, but we also know that they're running about 40,000 construction workers short a year between now and 2030. My question to my noble friend the minister is, I know that the new proposed vocational GCSE for building construction has been widely welcomed by the industry, but what specific work is being done to ensure that the curriculum and the syllabus is built on the needs of the industry and in conjunction with the industry?
Jacqui Smith
My noble friend makes a really important point, these must be qualifications that align with and are informed by what the industry sees as important, because that is of course what provides the opportunity for the young person to know that they are on a pathway that can lead to good work. That will be a key element of the consultation that will be starting soon.
Speaker 28
My lords, I think rather like the UTC question last week, the government's in danger of asking questions that they should know the answer to. Would the noble lady agree with me that there already is an intellectually rigorous vocational subject, it's called design and technology and I teach it. All they need to do is reopen the workshops, recruit specialist teachers and get it the esteem, with a parity of esteem with parents and metrics.
Jacqui Smith
Well, I'm sure the noble lord does a very good job of delivering design technology. He will have noted that it is already the case that in the response to the curriculum and assessment review, the government has been clear that we want to create both more space and more value to some of those courses that have been lost over previous years. And it is of course also the case that in delivering this broad curriculum, we'll want, and this will be part of the consultation, to be clear about what's necessary in terms of equipment, the estate of the school and the training of teachers.
Joanne Cash
My lords, I fear the noble baroness minister may have misheard the noble baroness Lady Barran, who did not criticize the government for saying that there was, criticizing the academic curriculum, but for saying that the academic curriculum had contributed to the number of NEETs, and the government is on record as saying that. And it is of real concern to many educationalists that having seen already a focus on skills in Scotland and Wales accelerate the number of NEETs there, how is the government going to assess and monitor whether disadvantaged pupils with good results at 11 are more likely to be entered for a vocational GCSE than a better-off pupil with the same results, which is steering and lowering of expectations? We'd be very keen to understand how the government is going to ensure that doesn't happen.
Jacqui Smith
I'm very happy to go back and look at the record, but I do think the noble lady said that this government had said that a knowledge-based curriculum was, well, let's look at the record. And my point remains that what we're providing for here is a strong, deep academic curriculum alongside options for students to study more technical and vocational courses. The noble lady makes an important point, and we will, of course, both in terms of the evidence, some of which I've already cited, but in terms of the work that we do in developing vocational GCSEs, want to be very clear that this is something that is providing higher standards and better opportunities for all students, and we'll make sure that that's part of the development and part of the monitoring and evaluation.
Magid Magid
My Lords, can I just follow up the issue about monitoring and evaluation, in particular around the collection of data? I know previously we've heard from the front bench from the Conservatives talking about disadvantaged young people. Can I add young people from minority backgrounds, young people with special educational needs? Will the government be collecting data around those young people to see what level of take-up they have by region to ensure that young people from those backgrounds aren't disproportionately being funnelled towards these vocational GCSEs rather than the more academic route, and will the government commit to publishing that data?
Jacqui Smith
Well, just to be clear, of course, every student will continue to do English, maths, and science. That's a really important element of the academic opportunities that are open to them. On this point about, you know, I do think it's important that these vocational GCSEs sit within technical pathways developed at a regional level, so therefore much more likely to be able to recognize the particular needs, the particular opportunities for young people within those areas, and that as well will be part of the evaluation.
Speaker 23
My Lords, does my noble friend agree with me that actually many students were disadvantaged by the previous straightjacket of a curriculum which didn't allow for anything like enough access to creative subjects and perilously small access to technical subjects, and therefore widening the possibility for all young people is an extremely good idea?
Jacqui Smith
Yes, I do agree with my noble friend, and I think what's more, that was the conclusion of the independent curriculum and assessment review, which of course the government will be bringing forward proposals on in the near future. But I just reiterate that we also believe that the ability and the requirement, in fact, to continue with English, maths, science, to be able to put vocational GCSEs alongside rigorous academic subjects as well where that makes sense for the student is a really important part of our proposals, as is ensuring that these new qualifications meet the highest possible standards, being based on nationally set criteria, which current technical awards aren't, and being available for all students and very much not something that students should be funnelled into, but rather opening doors and opportunities for them.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, the risk to the general population is considered low. Potential health risks from lighting are not unique to LED lighting. The government does continue to monitor evidence on the health impacts of LED lighting, publishing guidance on flicker reduction and healthy lighting environments.
The UK Health Security Agency contributes to international research and standards and works with experts to better understand how light exposure affects health and also to promote good lighting design.
Davidson
I thank my noble friend for her response. May I congratulate the NHS on the opening of the new Moorfields Hospital next year? But given the cutting-edge research that's been carried out at UCL in relation to the link between daylight and health effects, can the noble friend the minister assure the house that the new Moorfields Hospital will avoid the problems of 100% LED lighting?
Gillian Merron
Well, I also very much welcome the new Moorfields Hospital, which as my noble friend says is to open next year. The architecture does integrate national daylight with 100% LED lighting. And I can assure the house that it's been developed in accordance with applicable net zero design standards, improvement requirements, technical standards, and also assurance processes, as I'm sure noble lords would expect. We are currently seeking confirmation from the trust about any daylighting studies or any assessments which will be which have been undertaken as part of the design process. And when I get that information, I'll be very pleased to write to my noble friend.
Speaker 26
Could the minister tell me what effect research is having into the effect of high beam headlights on cars? I'm not sure if they're LED, but they are currently causing people to have accidents.
Gillian Merron
Well, the DfT has is undertaking independent research, is approaching this with regulatory changes, and also through international safety standards. As the noble lord said, raised a question about why the issue of glare is a problem. It is worth making the point, and I know that the Which report, which I think was published only just yesterday on this, talked not just about brighter LED, but also talked about the height of vehicles, but also beam alignment. And indeed, DfT has just this week updated driver advice in the Highway Code on this very point and encouraging people to get it checked.
Caroline Pidgeon
My lords, my lords, my lords, my lords, the Advertising Standards Authority upheld a complaint in June about an LED face mask claiming it was clinically proven it could produce wrinkles in four weeks. So given given given there are numerous adverts for at-home LED beauty devices in the run-up to Christmas, will the government urgently assess whether existing regulation adequately protects consumers in terms of both the product safety, but also the evidence supporting claims about their health benefits?
Gillian Merron
Well, this is ongoing work, and I'm sure that many noble lords, if it was a true claim, would be very keen to benefit, myself included. But quite seriously, how kind, quite seriously, it's good that the Advertising Standards Agency is looking into this.
We do have regulations to ensure that people are not misled and are protected. And tangentially, but a bit linked, I would say is, I'm sure that the House would welcome our recent work on cosmetic surgery regulations, which really strengthens this point.
Anne Marie Rafferty
Does the Minister agree with me that the practice recently put in place by King's College Hospital in exposing ITU intensive care patients to daylight has promoted their recovery and earlier recovery and indeed should be adopted by other NHS trusts?
Gillian Merron
Well, my noble friend is absolutely right to highlight what I think is absolutely fantastic in the King's critical care roof garden and I was very pleased to see the media coverage of that earlier this year. And in particular, that they are not just providing full life support and to the patients and staff and families, allowing them to feel the therapeutic effects of being outside and in nature. Not just that, but the team are using the spaces they've developed for research to see how it does give the right support and enhance people's health. So I'm very much looking forward to what they come up with. It is really very impressive on top of their medical excellence.
Speaker 32
My Lords, given the growing evidence that exposure to artificial light at night can disrupt sleep and the circadian rhythms, does the noble Baroness agree that the government should be doing more to ensure the public are aware of these potential health risks? Will the noble Baroness the Minister commit to updating existing public health guidance to reflect the latest scientific evidence?
Gillian Merron
If there are particular things the noble Lord thinks the government isn't doing, I'd be very pleased to receive them because I'm glad that he didn't specifically refer to LED lighting as I've said. There isn't an evidence that it's directly harmful in normal use in the general population. But we are, through the Committee on Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment, developing an evidence-based review program on artificial light and health, just as he asks, and is gathering evidence and identifying gaps. We're also supporting research and working internationally. I'd be very pleased to give further details if the noble Lord would like.
Dianne Hayter
Reverting to the question of headlights that people know I've been campaigning on. There is the question with LED lights, both about the luminance, i.e. the strength, but also about it being a blue light rather than the softer halogen yellow lights. Would my noble friend agree to put the expertise of the Department of Health together with the Department of Transport, who's doing good research on this, so we can make sure these two lots of expertise tie up together?
Gillian Merron
Well, certainly the policy for lighting is shared across a number of departments, not just the Department for Health and Social Care, but also, as my noble friend says, the Department for Transport, but also Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, as well as Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, as well as a number of arm's length bodies. So we all do indeed coordinate, as well as, as I mentioned earlier, work internationally, particularly with the UN Economic Committee for Europe, because we do need to ensure that we update international vehicle lighting to meet the point that my noble friend is concerned about.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, the noble Baroness the Minister referred to blue light and its effect on children, which is correct. But similar effect biologically occurs in the retina of children once the amount of time they spend on screen usage, particularly at night, because as mentioned already, it disrupts the melatonin production, which disrupts sleep. So the same effect happens on the use of length of time the children use screens as it does for LED lighting, and particularly higher wavelength LED lighting. So thank you for commenting on that.
Gillian Merron
Well, the noble Lord is quite right and I think highlights the point I was making earlier, exactly on the first question about cars and lighting. There's a number of factors, and absolutely screen use can indeed be harmful, particularly where it replaces sleep, physical activity, or leisure time. And as the noble Lord will know, we do advise families with under-fives to limit screens around bedtime and to ensure that it is age-appropriate content. I know that our department, the Department for Education, will be publishing wider guidance for five to 18-year-olds in January.
Jasset David Cody Harlech
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Feryal Clark
My Lords, the government is proud of the success of football in this country, so can I start by congratulating England captain Harry Kane on winning the Ballon d'Or this week. The Independent Football Regulator, led by its board, rightly sets its budget independently of government. The regulator is currently consulting on its proposed levy, and we encourage football to engage fully so the levy is shaped by those paying it. The proposed levy represents 0.2% of football's annual revenues of 9 billion pounds last year. As a public body, the regulator is subject to standard guidance and controls and will lay its annual report before Parliament.
Jasset David Cody Harlech
My Lords, the regulator's proposed operating costs have doubled already and it's not even operational yet. That's together with a set-up cost of 45 million pounds over 10 years. And that set-up cost was in no part of the original estimate. And I have to say, my Lords, this is exactly the kind of problems that these benches raised during the passage of the bill and were admonished both in this House and in the press for slowing the bill down. So what powers does the government hold to challenge the regulator's budget before the levy begins next season, and how will Parliament be able to scrutinize those costs once central funding ends?
Feryal Clark
As I mentioned before, the proposed levy represents 0.2% of football's annual revenues of 9 billion pounds last year. We believe this is affordable by football. The budget is set by the regulator as an independent regulator. It will lay its report to Parliament to allow scrutiny of that. The State of the Game report, published only recently, underlines the need for change and the need for this regulator.
Speaker 40
My Lords, along with the Prime Minister, I'm proud to declare my interest in and support for Everton Football Club. To clarify how costs have arisen, can my noble friend the Minister outline what action the independent regulator has taken to establish itself since its creation last year? And it may be helpful to understand what engagement the regulator has had with every regulated football club about this proposed levy.
Feryal Clark
My noble friend is right to highlight the action that has been taken since the regulator has been set up. Already the regulator has published its state of the game report, begun testing owners, directors, and senior executives, protected club heritage by ensuring fans are consulted on key decisions, and issued 10 consultations alongside final rules and guidance. The regulator's CEO has written to all clubs ahead of the levy consultation, which will run until the 4th of December, and we encourage all clubs to respond and help shape the methodology that will determine the levy they pay.
Dominic Hubbard
My Lords, if we are looking at an industry that has 116 units being regulated, generates 9 billion pounds, and has 94% of its units operating at a loss, can the noble Baroness think of any unit that was actually calling out more for regulation?
Feryal Clark
The noble Lord makes a point that I heartily agree with. The state of the game report underlines the issues with financial stability, with governance, with the structure, and underlines the need for this independent football regulator to operate and to use its powers that it has in the three objectives of club financial soundness, working on the systemic financial resilience of the whole football pyramid, and safeguarding club heritage for fans.
Speaker 39
My Lords, let me put this 20 million pounds into context. While we've heard that the top five tiers of the football leagues generate some 9 billion in annual revenues, as we've heard, almost every club is deep in the red, losing money year after year. And as we know, one club, Man City, have been found guilty of 114 financial breaches totaling 900 million pounds over a period of eight years, eight unregulated years. That's the point. So does the Minister agree that the 20 million cost of the new regulator may well be over budget, but it's hardly excessive?
Feryal Clark
I absolutely agree with the point that the noble Lord makes. And indeed, the structure and the methodology that the independent football regulator is consulting on does put the burden, as it were, on the Premier League clubs with a higher cost, and National League clubs will pay much, much less per season because it is a revenue-based model.
Robert Hayward
My Lords, could the noble lady the Minister please write to the House, and particularly to Lord Harlech, who's asked the question, explaining how the government managed to produce an impact assessment which is already over 100% inaccurate? And could she at the same time please write to the smaller clubs who are going to face the costs associated with this regulator and apologize to them for the answers that were given so often during the passage of the bill that they would not face more than the 10 million that was identified in the impact assessment in the first place?
Feryal Clark
I stand to be corrected by noble lords who were here during the initial phases of the bill, but I believe the impact assessment was published under the last government. So in terms of the caveats, and indeed that impact assessment was heavily caveated, it was decided during the passage of the bill in setting up this independent regulator that it should set its own budget. And that is the way we have proceeded.
Speaker 44
The independent regulator has shown a very great willingness to engage with members of this house and the other place, and that is quite unusual for many regulators. And also that his interventions so far have been very constructive in saving at least one football club.
Feryal Clark
My noble friend is right to highlight the engagement that the independent football regulator has had, although I would stress that the regulator remains independent and is taking operational decisions as he makes very clear.
Speaker 32
My lords, I would like to associate the comments from the noble baroness the minister on Harry Kane, congratulating him from Leyton Orient on loan to the Ballon d'Or. What a player, what a role model for our young people. My lords, during our debates on the bill, noble lords on this side of the house repeatedly raised concerns that this regulator would not be light-touch as the government claimed and that it would be captured by scope creep. Given the levy rate and the larger budget recently announced, does the noble baroness the minister agree that this side of the benches were right and the government were wrong?
Feryal Clark
I cannot agree with that. The State of the Game report underlines the need for reform. It underlines the parlous state of the financial sustainability, the governance failings, and the systemic resilience of the game. It underlines the need for action. The independent football regulator has a tightly defined scope.
It has three objectives and it needs the resources to operate as it does, but it will do so in the most efficient and expedient way.
Speaker 43
In the light of the minister's answer on the earlier question, will she confirm that this means that the government and the Prime Minister will not attempt to intervene in the Manchester City story which the noble lord has mentioned, and would she give that confirmation, thereby avoiding the resignation of the regulator?
Feryal Clark
The case between Manchester City is an independent process concerning a breach of the Premier League's rules and it's not for the government to intervene, particularly as we know that an independent commission is currently considering the appeal lodged by Manchester City Football Club.
Speaker 42
My lords, as my honourable friend the minister has mentioned, but it is worth repeating, the cost of the regulator is 0.2% of the value of a 9 billion pound industry. But the clue is in the name: it is an independent regulator. It was originally a Tory bill and during the wash-up failed to get through before the election. I am proud of the fact that a Labour government has brought this in. The State of the Game report, I am sure Lord Harlech, like myself, has read all 245 pages, as every noble lord should.
It's weekend reading. And I think it's provided crystal clear evidence of why we need this regulator. They will be getting on with licensing in the coming weeks. It's a huge piece of work. I for one would like to invite my noble friend the minister to congratulate the independent football regulator and the Secretary of State for bringing it in.
Feryal Clark
I am only too happy to accede to my noble friend's request to congratulate the Independent Football Regulator on its report and the Secretary of State for her work bringing this in.
Speaker 47
My Lords, that concludes oral questions for today. My Lords, we now come to an instrument previously debated in Grand Committee: Enterprise Act 2002 (Specification of Additional Section 58 Consideration) Order 2026, Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent.
Speaker 46
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Questions unanswered to an urgent question asked in House of Commons yesterday on the electronic monitoring of offenders, Lord Lammis.
Richard Keen
My Lords, we're aware that more than 4,000, I think sorry, 5,000 released offenders were not fitted with tags in the first half of this year and consequently went unmonitored upon their release. With the pressure that the early release scheme has placed on the system, that number is liable to have increased. Can the noble Lord the Minister tell the House what proportion of prisoners released as part of the early release scheme were not tagged before they were released? And if he's unable to tell us today, will he commit to publishing that data in his response to the written questions I tabled on this very point on 22nd October?
Speaker 3
There are various reasons that individuals who have an electronic monitoring order are not yet tagged, including not being at their address when officers arrive and being within the contractual 48-hour period for installation. They may have been recalled or the tag may have been tampered with or cut off. Other cases are to do with the fact that the offender may have been recalled. I don't agree with the noble and learned Lord that the earn progression model and release under it is likely to have increased those numbers. The earn progression model has been planned.
The releases under that is different, and I make this point every time I speak on this at the dispatch box and it's a really important point, is not the same as the emergency early release schemes that were introduced under the last government and at the beginning of this one. It is a planned process which is happening under 10 tranches.
We did make sure that the tag resources were available through Serco. As I don't agree with that, on the question of data, we will publish data on tagging in the normal way.
Jonathan Marks
My Lords, as the government now seems to recognize, home tagging after a prisoner's release has serious problems. First, until released offenders can be actually tagged at home, they can be a frightening menace to their victims. Secondly, if they have no stable home, they can prove very difficult to tag at all. Yesterday in the other place, Minister McKinnell told my honorable friend Jess Brown-Fuller MP that tagging at prisons before release, so-called tagging at source, was being ramped up. And she welcomed a suggestion from Dame Emily Thornberry MP that prison officers should be trained to fit the tags and were willing to take such training and do so.
Tagging at source is obviously a better and I suggest a cheaper system, and one wonders therefore why home tagging was ever an option. The government have an extra hundred million pounds earmarked for tagging. Why can tagging at source not be organized almost at once? Why the delay?
Speaker 3
Home tagging was instituted under the previous government and it is part of the Serco contract as we've discussed before. The government does agree that tagging at source is the right approach, and that's what Minister McKinnell said yesterday. We are rolling that out and we are doing it in an orderly way, and we're receiving a great deal of cooperation from prison staff as we go about that. That is the right answer and that is what we're going to do. I would just say on this whole question of tagging, I think all noble Lords who work in this area know that tagging is going to be an increasingly important part of the criminal justice system in the future, and the way we go about it will evolve.
And exactly as the noble Lord Lord Marks says, tagging at source is the future and we will get there as soon as possible.
Speaker 50
The problem is constantly being framed as a lack of prison capacity, but there needs to be a very different narrative which includes a major focus on reducing reoffending and addressing what underlies so much offending. So can the noble Lord the Minister say what is being done to ensure that alongside tagging, the probation service is properly funded, resourced, supported to address the issues that underlie the offending of those who are tagged?
Speaker 3
I hesitate to correct the right reverend prelate, I know that's not good form, especially not coming from me. But I didn't frame the problem as part of the prison capacity problem. I framed the issues around tagging as being related to our earn progression model, and this gives me an opportunity to advertise the presentation I've arranged for noble Lords on November the 23rd on the earn progression model. On the question that the right reverend prelate asks me about reducing reoffending, of course we agree. I should have declared my interest at the beginning, which was that I was the lead non-executive director and the chair of the agency board of HMPPS until 2025.
And during that time, in relation to one of the key aspects that the right reverend prelate knows is part of reducing reoffending, accommodation, we secured accommodation for 35,000 people leaving prison.
Speaker 48
I do think that the government's got the right idea in terms of tagging. I support the minister in saying that. But I do think there are serious problems in the operation of it now and the ambition of it for the future. First of all, they're not being fitted, and therefore if they're not fitted on at source, then they never get fitted. Probably more importantly, the future with geolocation for devices, which allows people to be excluded from areas as well as to be kept within areas, sobriety tagging, which stops people drinking when drink is the aggravating factor in their offending pattern.
And the fact that there just is no strategy as to how this is going to develop in the future. There's no real connection to the police as well as, as already been said, the probation service. So the system at the moment means that an email goes from Serco, whoever the commercial entity are, and within the next few days the police might get some information about a rapist who breached the curfew around a rape. Now that could all be done digitally immediately. And I think the ambition is incredibly good.
Speaker 48
I am getting there. But I do think... My noble lords, are 10 minutes for this. If you keep interrupting, I won't get there. But my point is, my point is, that what is the government's ambition and strategy for rolling out tags in the future, because I haven't seen one.
Speaker 3
Well, I've disagreed with the bishop and now I'm going to disagree with the policeman. I don't accept that characterization, or former policeman. I don't accept that characterization. The situation on the specific question that the noble lord raises about knowing where people are who are on tags is that by Christmas, because we are rolling out our plan, probation officers in every region will know the whereabouts of people on tags within 10 minutes. So the situation that he describes should not arise.
I don't accept that we are, that there is no plan. I've already said this is an important part of the future. It's an important part, for example, of the work that we're doing on domestic abuse in relation to alcohol tags. The GPS tagging is improving. This will continue and it is extremely significant.
Speaker 55
My lords, the minister knows only too well that the private sector is due to pocket an extra 100 million pounds as a consequence of tagging expansions, whilst the service, as I said only last week, is on its knees. It's very difficult to see how we can improve the situation when we've got unacceptable strings on the table for the unions to accept. And therefore does the noble lord the minister agree that HMPPS needs to remove these strings and give the staff a bigger slice of this 700 million pound pie as opposed to going on strike, which we don't need at all in this country.
Speaker 3
I'm sure the noble lord will understand, my noble friend, my good friend, will understand that I don't want to comment on the negotiations that are underway. But I would say this, that the staff of HMPPS have risen to challenges that many of us would find impossible. And that is, I pay tribute to them, I pay credit to them. And as we ask more and more of them, we will of course work with them to ensure that they are motivated and properly rewarded.
Speaker 54
My Lords, can the Minister tell the House, since this scheme started in its latest format, can he tell us how many of the 5,000 plus prisoners released have reoffended?
Speaker 3
The figures on tagging, as I've said, will be released in the normal way. But on reoffending, we do publish stats on reoffending and we'll continue to do so.
Don Foster
The Minister tells us very clearly that Serco has been meeting its contract requirements since March. However, the Chief Inspector of Prisons points out that that contract requires specification of attempting to tag rather than succeeding in tagging, points out that 45% of GPS tags and 40% of alcohol tags have been fitted late, that one in five people have had to wait up to two weeks for a tag, and that amazingly one in 10 have waited up to five months for their tag. If that is contract specification, isn't there something dreadfully wrong with the contract?
Speaker 3
The noble Lord is an expert on this. He chairs the committee and he quoted all those statistics at me without reading his notes. He knows, as I know, that what we inherited was a tagging system in crisis and what we have done is to put the arrangements with Serco on a better footing. I don't deny for a moment that there are still problems. We have access to their performance data.
Speaker 58
This situation is being better managed than it was before, but there's some way to go.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I beg to move that the House do now resolve itself into a committee upon the bill.
Speaker 46
Question is that the House do now resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that clause one stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion will say content.
To the contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause two, amendment one, Baroness Merron.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I beg to move amendment one. My Lords, as I said at second reading, the abolition of NHS England is being taken forward in the interests of patients firmly at its core. It will provide greater clarity for the system, it will restore democratic accountability and free up resources to be reinvested in the front line. It will also bring about greater clarity about where responsibility lies, ensuring that ministers are accountable for national decisions whilst devolving more power to local NHS organisations. Patients will benefit from faster and clearer decision making, less duplication and red tape, and staff who are allowed to spend less time navigating bureaucracy and more time focused on care and delivery.
I will address the government amendments to clauses two and 28 together. My Lords, amendment one and consequential amendments two and three make additions to clause two of the bill, which empowers the Secretary of State to establish transfer schemes. These clauses provide a structured and transparent means of moving property, staff, rights and liabilities from NHS England to the Department of Health and Social Care, integrated care boards and other relevant bodies.
Following engagement with the devolved governments, these amendments have been tabled to require the consent of the relevant devolved government should a transfer be made to a Welsh, Scottish or Northern Ireland public body. The amendment does not change the purpose of Clause 2, but provides assurance to devolved governments that any transfers to their bodies can only take place with their agreement. I would emphasize that there are currently no plans for transfers to be made to the devolved governments' public bodies, but this amendment does provide a proportionate safeguard if such circumstances arose in the future. Likewise, amendments 103 and 104 are technical amendments to Clause 28, also in response to engagement, this time with the Welsh government. They make clear the territorial limit of the clause to ensure it could not be used to establish or delegate functions to a Welsh special health authority.
My Lords, I believe these to be sensible and proportionate amendments, and I beg to move.
Speaker 46
Amendment proposed: Clause 2, page 1, line 16, insert the words on the marshalled list.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, if I may welcome the Minister's discussion about the devolved governments and that nothing is going to be potentially imposed on them, and particularly the discussions that have been had. But could she clarify what's going to happen to some of the prevention agendas that have been in place, such as the Couch to 5K program, for which I understand that actually no outcomes have been collected, but that has been part of NHSE and the department's promotion in terms of increasing exercise, and whether these programs will actually be increasingly promoted across England as part of the prevention agenda and in discussion with the devolved governments so that we get consistency in prevention across the United Kingdom?
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, we welcome these government amendments which ensure that the devolved administrations' boundaries are protected and there is proper consultation and agreement. But devolution does need to be integral at the start of any legislation rather than an afterthought. And I think given these amendments have been tabled so late, granted you've had consultation with the devolved governments, we think it's kind of a worrying sign and it's an indication that there are things about this reorganization and possibly its governance implications that hadn't been properly thought through at the start, and also through the lens of those devolved administrations rather than simply through the lens of Whitehall and the lens of civil servants centrally. The Minister's words have provided some assurance, and I look forward to the devolved administrations being at the start and at the heart of legislation like this in the future rather than an add-on at a late stage.
Howe
My Lords, it's a pleasure to begin our committee stage consideration of the Health Bill, and I look forward to the discussions that we'll be having over the coming days. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, the Minister, and the government for bringing forward these amendments, which we understand to be principally technical in nature, although there are questions we shall want to ask in later groups around cross-border patient referrals and related issues. We welcome the clarification that these amendments provide as regards the consent of the devolved administrations and the exercise of powers in relation to devolved health bodies, and we're content to support them.
Whilst I'm on my feet, I hope the committee will allow me to take the opportunity to acknowledge the letter sent by the noble Baroness the Minister this morning concerning Healthwatch. I think noble Lords across the house will welcome the government's decision not to proceed with its abolition, and I am grateful to the Minister for listening to the concerns raised in this house and elsewhere. If I may say, I think this is a very positive example of the government engaging constructively with the scrutiny of this bill and showing a willingness to reconsider its proposals where legitimate concerns have been raised. That's precisely the spirit in which I hope we can continue our consideration of this legislation, and I welcome the approach the government has taken on this occasion. I look forward to the Minister's response.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm grateful for this brief but important debate, and in particular for the support for these amendments. As the noble Lord Earl Howe says, these are technical amendments, and I would just say to the noble lady Baroness Finlay that this is absolutely nothing to be worried about. We do work closely with the devolved governments, and actually this is an extra layer of reassurance to them that we just felt was helpful because that's what they sought. So it is no reflection on anything other than we're bringing forward technical amendments, not as an afterthought, but because that's what conversations have led us to think is just the right thing to do. And I know they very much welcome this, and I'm grateful for their assistance.
I hear what the noble Lord Earl Howe said about the letter that I sent out and also the announcement in respect of Healthwatch. Indeed, I have been most grateful to noble Lords for their engagement as we've come up to this point in the bill. And indeed, as the noble Lord acknowledges, we are always keen to listen. We can't always do exactly what every noble Lord would want, but I am glad that the noble Lord welcomes the way in which the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister have approached this. With regard to the point that's been raised by the noble lady Baroness Finlay, who also gave her support with respect to particular programs, I'm very happy to look into that particular program.
But in general terms, it's exactly as I have set out, that the intention is the work of and the programs to which we're committed will transfer to the department. What happens in the longer term on the prevention agenda is, of course, another consideration, and we do work again very closely with the devolved administrations on prevention. But ultimately, healthcare is, of course, a devolved matter. I beg to move.
Speaker 46
The question is that amendment one be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment two, Baroness Merron, move formally.
Move formally.
Speaker 46
The question is that amendment two be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment three, Baroness Merron, move formally.
Formally.
Speaker 46
The question is that amendment three be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.
The question is that clause two stand part of the bill as amended. As many of that opinion will say content. Content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it.
The question is that clause three stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion will say content. Content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it.
After clause three, amendment four, Lord Kamal, Earl Howe.
Howe
My Lords, I beg to move amendment four and in doing so express my appreciation to the noble Lord, Lord Kakkar, for adding his name to it. My Lords, I well recognize that members of the committee may be taken aback by the monumental size of this amendment, but its size is to a very real extent its point. The main raison d'être of this bill, indeed its very starting point, is the abolition of NHS England and the reorganization and reallocation of its functions and responsibilities. As monumental a process as it is possible to imagine, involving as it does just about every branch of the health service from commissioners to providers to the training of doctors. More than that, the momentous decision to abolish NHS England came largely unheralded.
Lord Darzi's report on the state of the NHS published in 2024 stated in terms that another top-down reorganization of the NHS was the last thing it needed. It seemed quite clear that Lord Darzi thought there were other ways of tackling the various issues in the NHS that he had identified. Now, whether or not the decision to abolish was taken in haste, I'm afraid that what's happened since has been a cause for criticism. The abolition was announced without any explanation being given to NHS staff about what the government was seeking to achieve and without any provision for redundancy funding. Planning for how the new department would look took months to get off the ground.
Even now, some 18 months after the decision was announced, there is still a fog of uncertainty about where a number of commissioning responsibilities are going to sit, whether devolved to ICBs or transferred to the department. Some functions, especially regulation, will need to sit centrally but will require independence from ministerial control. Others will need to be devolved nearer to the bodies responsible for delivering patient outcomes. There is as yet no clarity on the complete picture. This really does matter, not just on a theoretical level but also on a very practical one.
One example, specialized commissioning. What is the appropriate footprint for commissioning and delivering services for rare or very rare conditions? We still don't know which of the current 170 specialized services will be commissioned centrally and which by ICBs, or what the logical basis for such decisions ought to be. But hand in hand with that, we still do not know whether within ICBs there's going to be sufficient capacity and expertise to fulfill the statutory duties that they are given to deliver those services. Up to now, the process of delegation to ICBs by NHS England has progressed unevenly across the country.
At a time when ICBs are being told to shed large numbers of staff, the risks around this whole area of reform don't need spelling out.
My Lords, the government have said that abolishing NHS England will eliminate duplication, reduce bureaucracy, and deliver savings. On a theoretical level, that is language that I am sure we all understand. However, what does it mean in practice? We hear that the abolition of NHS England will deliver savings of around one billion a year by the end of this Parliament. However, the explanatory notes to the bill estimate that the cost of redundancy exits across NHS England, the department, integrated care boards, and commissioning support units will be between one billion and 1.3 billion.
That is an enormous sum of money to spend on restructuring before we've seen any of the promised savings. And the figures raise some fairly obvious questions. First, what is the full cost of the reorganization? The explanatory notes identify the estimated costs of redundancy exits, but says little or nothing about the wider costs of transferring functions, replacing systems, managing contracts, retaining specialist expertise, and establishing new governance arrangements. For example, we are in the dark as to which policy teams are to be reduced or even removed.
Nor do we know whether there will be more or fewer commissioning support units than there are at the moment. So my first question: are all of these costs included in the government's estimate? And can the minister confirm whether the original estimates of costs and savings remains accurate? Secondly, when does the government expect the reorganization to pay for itself? There is an important distinction between achieving annual savings of a billion at some point in the future and having actually recovered the substantial sums spent on delivering those savings.
When will the cumulative savings exceed the cumulative costs of the transition, and when will those savings become available for reinvestment in frontline services? Thirdly, where is the money to pay for all this coming from? Many have expressed the fear that the costs of this reorganization can only be met at the expense of frontline services and or planned capital investment and or improvements in technology, or even to the detriment of the research or education budgets. I wonder whether the minister would be willing to set out detailed answers to these questions in a letter to be placed in the library, so that between now and report stage, noble Lords can gain a fuller picture of what is planned. My Lords, the health service is an extraordinarily complex and interconnected system.
When we remove or relocate one part of that system, we need to be certain that we understand what depends upon it. The transfer of functions from NHS England will involve not only changes to governance and accountability, but also the movement of staff, contracts, information systems, and specialist expertise between organizations. These are substantial undertakings in their own right, and they will need to be managed while the NHS continues to deliver services to millions of patients.
And that process carries risks to the stability of patient services. And that is why this amendment would require the government to set out not only the financial implications of the transition, but also the principal clinical and operational risks, the measures that will be taken to maintain continuity, and the arrangements for retaining and transferring specialist staff. Exactly how will the government ensure that nationally important services, contracts, information systems, and specialist functions continue to operate without interruption as responsibilities are transferred away from NHS England? And who will be responsible on a day-to-day level for managing these risks? Because in the final analysis, my Lords, the risks involved in all of this are risks to patients.
Long-term savings of a billion pounds a year are certainly worth having, but the looked-for benefits of this major reform need to be balanced against the degree of risk that the government is now placing on the lives and the health of patients in the course of achieving those benefits. We are at a moment when waiting times are already high, hospital wards are full, and services everywhere are stretched. My Lords, I can only express the hope on behalf of us all that ministers and the good and capable officials who are doubtless doing their utmost to deliver these reforms in one piece prove more than equal to the huge task that they have been set. I beg to move.
Speaker 59
Amendment proposed after clause 3, insert the new clause as printed on the marshalled list.
Philip Hunt
Yeah, first of all, welcome the amendment because from Noble Lord Howe, because it does enable us to go to the core of what this legislation is all about. Light-touch amendment, my Lords, it was not. But I think it does go to the heart of what we need to talk about. And as I said at second reading, I really welcome the bringing of NHS England essentially into the department. I think it restores ministerial accountability to Parliament, and for a 200 billion pound service, I think that that is very important.
And essentially, it seems to me that we're going back to a 1948 Bevanite model of the NHS. And of course, no, we don't recall his dictum, but it's very famous that when a bucket of slops is kicked over by a maid in a hospital in Tredegar, its echo should sound in the corridors of Whitehall. My Lords, but Bevan also said at the time, because of course he was, he backed off Morrison, who wanted local government to control the NHS, that he wanted lots of decisions to be made locally through the hospital management committees and regional hospital boards that were set up. But of course, my Lords, the moment it started, the Department, the Minister of Health, as it then was, started to issue circular after circular after circular. And I think it's perhaps an inevitability of the way when you have a national health service funded through, simply through taxation, you get there.
But my Lords, I do think there are some genuine issues around the relationship between the center and the local National Health Service, which we do need to tease out. I also think, my Lords, that we had a roundtable in which the chief executive of NHS Alliance spoke about the concern that the Alliance has that integrated care boards will find that their room for maneuver is very limited. And my Lords, I think one response to that is that ICB's accountability was solely going to be to the center.
Now the decision of the government to keep Healthwatch is very important in terms of having more local accountability and that's why it's so welcome. I would also say, and I know noble Lords are concerned about ministers taking over responsibility for the appointment of chairs and non-executives, that I think that we should also keep Council of Governors of Foundation Trust because, my Lords, they're local people elected by members of those trusts who do the current round of appointments. We will come to this later on in our debate on clause 30, but I am really looking for the government to look at this again. I think, my Lords, there are some real issues about the future relationship of the center to locality. And I really would commend the brief that we've had from the King's Fund because it actually poses five really key questions.
What should the boundary be between legitimate national oversight and routine operational management? What will prevent this broad power becoming a mechanism for day-to-day management from Whitehall? How will you deal with bottlenecks and the practical risk that moving a large number of functions decisions towards the Secretary of State could slow the NHS down rather than speed decisions up, particularly around appointment of chairs, non-executives? Which of the Secretary of State's most consequential intervention powers will be subject to independent advice or scrutiny? In what circumstances would ministers expect to intervene in local service reconfiguration?
What safeguards would ensure decisions which are often best made locally and on clinical grounds? How is the greater role for local government and mayors to operate alongside stronger central powers and require the Secretary of State to have regard to local decision-making? What statutory safeguards will there be in relation to the powers of Secretary of State to appoint, suspend or remove the chair and other non-executive directors? And for the Secretary of State's most consequential intervention powers, is there a case for putting relevant decision-making criteria on the face of the bill? I don't know, my Lords, the answer to that, but I do think by report stage it would be helpful if my noble friend could explain in a little detail how they think the new arrangements are going to work and how you will prevent unnecessary micromanagement from the center.
Speaker 63
My Lords, I've added my name to this amendment in the name of Lord Kamall and the Earl Howe, and in so doing I must remind noble Lords of my own declared interest as chairman of King's Health Partners and chairman of the King's Fund. My Lords, I believe this to be a very important amendment, as we have heard, and fundamental to the purpose of this bill. Because ultimately, I think your Lordships' House has taken quite appropriately the explanation, reassurances and logic behind the abolition of NHS England provided by the noble lady the minister at second reading. In particular, as the report commissioned by His Majesty's Government identified very clearly that further reorganization of the NHS on a major scale, as identified by the noble Lord Earl Howe, is something that should at all costs be avoided. And so there are clearly in the government's mind important reasons why this reorganization must proceed.
Speaker 64
And I think it's important for your Lordships to respect that as a fundamental element of His Majesty's Government's policy.
However, in proceeding down this route, I think the other side of the coin is that His Majesty's Government must be clear and provide reassurance about the implications, both in the period of transition and thereafter, with regard to important functions that have sat in NHS England and will now be brought back under central Secretary of State control. And we've heard a number of those. In particular, it would be interesting for the noble lady the Minister to explain to your Lordships how the transitional arrangements that are going to be applied will reflect the ultimate structure and function of the newly defined function for delivering NHS England within the Department of Health and Social Care. For instance, how will the Secretary of State powers be exercised? What degree of delegation is there going to be?
Speaker 66
How will that be reflected in these transitional arrangements? In terms of the broader government agenda with regard to devolution to a local level, is it consistent to have brought all these powers centrally and then expect within a reasonable time period for proper devolved scrutiny and proper devolved determination of local health needs to be reflected in the delivery of the NHS? What will be the arrangements for the operational management of the NHS in the intervening period between now and the final adoption of all measures? How is that going to work? What is happening at the moment?
Is the noble lady content that on so many issues where there is granular or has been granular oversight within NHS England and its regional structures, that that kind of oversight can and will be, is be, delivered in these transitional arrangements? Because when there are crises, or indeed when day-to-day delivery of the NHS at a local level starts to falter, there is absolute need for clarity and an ability to intervene. Because as we've heard from the noble Lord Earl Howe, ultimately all of these changes will impact patients. And if we are unclear about how these arrangements are secure, how they will be governed, and how those responsible will be held accountable, then ultimately we will be sanctioning potential situations where patients may well be put at harm. At the very least, where the application of valuable resources may not be applied in the fashion most efficient, and therefore patients may wait longer, may be denied important interventions, and ultimately the important progress to improve the delivery of healthcare and clinical outcomes to which His Majesty's Government is so strongly committed will be inadvertently undermined through a program of transition and reform that has not been properly laid out and properly described in organizational terms.
Beyond that, there is, as the noble Earl has identified, the important question of the financial arrangements. At second reading, I noted that in 38 of the 40 years prior to 2020, the NHS failed to deliver services within its pre-agreed budget for the specific financial year in question. It usually overspent by about 1.3%. That was a historic reflection, maybe perfectly reasonable for explanations that are completely justified.
However, we find ourselves now in an economic and fiscal situation where it's going to be impossible for the government to continue to increase settlements year on year for NHS expenditure. And therefore it's very important for us to understand how the costs associated with this particular reform are going to be met. Are they being met from current budgets? Are additional funds expected to meet the costs of delivering these reforms and the transitional arrangements before savings are going to accumulate? And if there are no additional funds available, are the funds going to be drawn, as we have heard, from frontline clinical services, from the education and training budget, which is often vulnerable, and particularly so since a previous reform has taken Health Education England into NHS England, and so that separation no longer exists?
Speaker 65
Will it undermine the capacity for the NHS to continue to deliver on its important research and innovation agenda? That may be seen as a part of the budget that might be sacrificed for a short period of time whilst arrangements were made to deliver this transformation and this reform. These are all fundamental questions, and the answer to all of them may be no. There is no risk to any of this, which would be very reassuring, but it is something I think that we do need to understand. And none of these questions should be taken as opposition to the abolition of NHS England.
Speaker 66
As I said earlier, that is a decision that's been taken. The purpose of this committee and the opportunity afforded by this bill is to ask the questions that attend an absolute guarantee that the arrangements to be put in place will serve the purpose as defined, and the arrangements to be put in place, in particular these transitional arrangements, will serve the opportunity to secure the much more fundamental, longer-term questions about the powers of the Secretary of State, the opportunity for delegation, where operational responsibility in the NHS will ultimately lie, how this reform resonates with a devolution agenda, and what the mechanism will be for the different elements of the newly organized NHS under direct supervision of the Department of Health and Social Care to function, be it centrally, regionally, or at local level.
Stevens
I support the amendment in the name of Earl Howe and Lord Kakkar and other noble lords because I think it draws attention to the fact that we are on the cusp of a huge reorganization, and yet there is really remarkable lack of clarity as to how it is going to be given effect. And so my first question, I think, to the noble lady the minister would be: can she confirm to the committee that it is still the government's intention that NHS England will be abolished on the 1st of April? Because there is a groundswell of discussion across the center of government and the NHS that suggests that is looking to be an increasingly impractical date. So can she confirm what the government's concrete intentions now are? If she tells us that the 1st of April is still what's going to happen, then it ought to be entirely possible for the government to accede to the amendment that Earl Howe has put forward because clearly one could not, a mere matter of months away, be proceeding without already having the information that this amendment requests.
And in fact, Dr. Penny Dash, the outgoing chair of NHS England, was before the Commons Health and Social Care Committee five months ago, and the select committee in the Commons were also exploring the question that's before us now. And Dr. Dash said, and I quote, "In a few weeks' time, a paper will be coming to the transformation oversight board, or whatever we call it, giving more detail on these questions." And she went on when asked to say, is the 50% reduction a hard figure? "In terms of the national NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care, there was this sense that 50% was the right number to aspire to." "The detailed work will get us to the point of determining what the numbers could and should look like."
So if the 1st of April is really the date, can the noble lady the minister tell us what those numbers will in fact look like? Is it 50%? How is it broken down as requested in this amendment? We already have signs that pragmatism is asserting itself in the Department of Health and Social Care with the decisions on HSIB and now Healthwatch. Will this be a further example of pragmatism, or will the new Secretary of State be sticking to the plan, perhaps a little half-baked, that she has inherited?
We already have the most centralized and politicized health service in the industrial world. Going down this path takes us yet further in that direction. If that's what we're going to do, it should at least be done well.
Andrew Lansley
My Lords, I support my noble friend in his amendment. I don't want to revisit second reading issues. I just want to make one or two important points from my point of view. One is to say, along with other noble Lords, a big thank you to the minister for some of the correspondence that we've received and the way in which she and the government are listening already to the discussions that we are having in this House, and I hope we can continue to have constructive discussion. I don't entirely share the noble Lord Lord Kakkar's view that the abolition of NHS England is just a done deal and therefore we should accept it.
It wasn't a manifesto commitment. Parliament has had no say in this matter. So I think it is the more important that as we implement the government's intentions into law, we should understand what and how we are doing this thing. That is particularly true, I think, insofar as there's some speculation about whether in fact all of these responsibilities will be incorporated into the department in the way that the noble Lord Hunt of Kings Heath sees it all becoming engaged in the department and therefore accessible to ministers. If many of these responsibilities are held in special health authorities outside the department, it is very hard for some of us to understand what has been gained in accountability relative to the current situation between the department and NHS England.
I will in parenthesis just say, and of course ministers had powers under the previous legislation to exercise accountability over NHS England, not least through the process of a mandate, but often failed effectively to use those powers. So the use of powers by ministers is more important sometimes than other things.
But just coming to the key point, I think, this is about the transition. The government has put into the legislation that there will be transition schemes, but we need to see what they look like and how the timing works. I recall that the gap between the conclusion of the 2012 Act passing and the implementation was just over a year, almost exactly a year. So that does further, I think, strengthen the force of the questions that the noble Lord Stevens of Birmingham has just been asking. We do need to see what that timetable looked like, looks like.
I'd also be very interested, just from the curiosity point of view, how these savings are to be generated. Noble Lords very often say, well, a great deal of money was spent on the 2012 reforms. Well, the written ministerial statement published on the 21st of July 2015 at the end of the 2010 to 2015 Parliament told us what the outcome was. The costs totaled 1.38 billion, a little more than my noble friend said the government are anticipating the overall cost of this reorganization looks like, but not much more. But the savings by the end of the Parliament were 6.9 billion in cash.
People always, not least in some of the debates, tend to remember the cost but not to remember the savings. But I think it would be extremely useful for us to know in advance what it is that is intended to be achieved because that reorganization, according to the data that was published in 2015, arrived in that final financial year of the Parliament at a 2 billion a year reduction in cost. And the government isn't even attempting to achieve something as ambitious as that. So let's see what it looks like. I make one suggestion to which I hope the noble lady the minister will respond.
It is not unknown for the National Audit Office to engage in a process of scrutiny not after the event, but during the event. And this is especially true for major projects. I think this is a major project and over the course of the next year, I think it would be good if the department were to volunteer itself to the National Audit Office for there to be such a process of real-term scrutiny of the value for money effectiveness of this reorganization.
Speaker 68
It's appropriate for those of us who've been involved in this for the last 15 years or so to just join in on this debate a little bit. And of course, the noble Lord Lord Lansley's quite right, this is about transition. And it's about transition which affects two groups of people: our patients and indeed those people who work in the NHS. I am a veteran, I think, probably of the transitions that we've had so far because I was abolished in 2020 because I became a member of my local CCG, which I have to say I enjoyed serving on very much indeed, having worked on the 2012 legislation that created it. I then took refuge as a non-executive director in my local hospital.
So I am now experiencing and having helped create our local ICB, now being abolished and creating a super ICB. So I feel like I've been at the governance coalface of the reorganizations for the last 15 years. So this is indeed an important debate and I am in favor of the abolition of NHS England. I intend actually to mostly involve myself in this committee stage with equality, social care, the patient records and so on.
But I have one question which I'd really like to address to my noble friend the Minister. And that is about the arrangements for the people who will move from NHS England into the department and where they stand right now. Because those people are very precious to us, many of them very, very experienced. So I'd just like to know how the TUPE arrangements are progressing, what the dates are for those arrangements and when we're likely to see some documentation about how that is actually happening.
Speaker 73
My Lords, I understand and support the general thrust of this amendment. And having worked in the NHS for nearly 40 years and having worked very closely with NHS England as well as all the transitions that happened from local health boards, PCTs, CCGs and ICBs, and having worked with CCGs and ICBs across England as a provider and as a doctor, as well as with NHS England, as I said in my second reading, I wholeheartedly support the abolition of NHS England to cut the bureaucracy and unnecessary layer and support the power taken back by the Secretary of State to give it away to ICBs where patients are treated. And also it fits in with the neighborhood health plan because they are best placed to develop and deliver that. I too have questions to my noble friend the Minister, but I thank her for organizing the round table on Monday where we got some clarity and discussion about ICBs. I was quite reassured to hear about seven offices being created across, representing every region across England, and also taking control of resources, including for innovation and prevention and the population health as well, population health improvement.
Speaker 72
And I was quite pleased to hear about how these seven offices will function because I have worked with large merged ICBs like East of England for more than 12 years and I know how well they can function, how they get more clarity, consistency with protocols, less postcode lottery, as well as large purchasing power to reduce costs and to deliver more to patients. So I welcome all that clarity that was given to us in the round table on Monday about how ICBs jointly are going to deliver collaboratively for local regions. But however, this is about transition period and I understand the anxieties and support some of the concerns raised by the other noble Lords. So we do need clarity and timeline as regards to that. But I have to say I support the abolition and I totally support the resources and the power given to ICBs and I have trust in this joint ICB functions to deliver what is needed locally and also work with local authorities and local stakeholders because the plan fits in with the 10-year plan for neighborhood health plan as well as reducing local inequalities and addressing determinants of, wider determinants of health.
Speaker 71
So can I ask the noble, my noble friend the Minister how the national standards of care as well as costing and implementation of national tariffs will be managed during this period and how they will be set and by what date they will be set by and how they will be monitored to ensure that the postcode lottery doesn't get widened and also making sure that the responsibility and accountability are not lost during this period and the care doesn't slip for any patient and because we expect it to improve in the long term.
And who will oversee these transitions and who will be accountable for running them smoothly? I personally do not believe this needs to be set out in legislation but it's absolutely necessary to get this clarity as well as the timeline and also as regards to the population health improvement plans how will the resources be allocated to ensure that inequalities are addressed and there is going to be a joint system with local authorities as well as local stakeholders.
Speaker 69
Just to say thank you very much to the minister because I'm absolutely delighted the government has listened in with regards to Healthwatch and also to HSSIB because they're two very important legs of the NHS in terms of independence and patient safety and patient voice. So I do welcome that and I do thank the minister because I know she herself is also passionate about those areas. Can I also say that I really thank my noble friend Earl Howe and others who have spoken already on his amendment. It is absolutely right irrespective of what one feels about NHS England and I will certainly share my views. I think it's right that there is an operational plan.
Speaker 70
I think it's right there is a transitional plan. No business would move to such a major reorganization without having such plans and having such risk assessments with key performance indicators and indeed clarity around outcomes in relation to budgets and finance. My key question to the minister will be that if there are savings to be made when will these savings be made and how will these savings be reinvested into direct patient care? Because what I'm really interested in with all these changes what does it mean for the actual patient? How do they benefit so that we're not just spending time just talking to ourselves round and round about reorganizations?
I've been involved with the NHS oh I should say nearly over 40 years I hasten to add probably Lord Hunt we've been around a long time but I I was chairing a health authority when I was in my 20s and I was one of the eight regional chairs that chaired one of the eight regional offices of the NHS and my region was Northern and Yorkshire regions and we had a budget then of 3.5 billion pounds. So I've got some experience of transformation and I've got some experience of the difficulties and the challenges and the risks that would be involved. And if we don't have these plans if we don't have the clarity things will go wrong. And that will adversely affect patient care and that's what I think this bill is really about is trying to improve patient care. I my personal view is that I don't like to see lots of duplication in services.
Speaker 69
I do like direct and simplified governance structures in the NHS. We did have them when we had the regional offices I recollect and it was a Labour government at that time and I do recollect I think it was quarterly my memory is faded a bit but I think it was quarterly where the eight regional chairs rocked up to the Department of Health sat down with the Secretary of State with the perm secretaries the chief executive of the NHS executive and we went round to find out what the finances were within our regions which hospitals were performing well which were not where there were real issues about waiting lists and do you know what it really did concentrate the mind.
Speaker 70
And then we went back and we fed it to all the 60 or 80 chairmen that were within our regions and to their respective chief executives. So I'm not too worried and too concerned that there will be a lot of haters, but we've got to have very clear plans to enable for this to happen. And I think last and not least that I really want to talk about is really the governance structures. I've mentioned them in my speech previously, and I think if we don't have clarity around governance structures and accountability, we really won't deliver. So if there's one plea that I can make, can it be that as well, as well as the plea as I said I totally support the amendment that's been put down by my noble friend Earl Howe.
Clare Gerada
The people over the years I've most admired is an American pediatrician, Professor Don Berwick, some of you may know him, who is an international expert on healthcare and a great advocate of the NHS. In fact, he led the Mid Staffs review in 2013, and in the States he led Medicare and Medicaid under President Obama. And on the NHS's 60th birthday, and it always struck me, he wrote us a birthday card. It was a long, long, long card and I urge you one day to read it. But part of this birthday card he said, and I quote, Don Berwick offered a simple prescription for the NHS: stop restructuring.
He warned that successive reorganisations drained the workforce's energy and confidence. Stability, he argued, makes improvement easier. My Lords, would the Minister agree that his advice would be well taken?
Andrew Mawson
My Lords, I welcome this debate, and I certainly support the amendment, and I'm encouraged by the letter that we received today that there's an open mind within government and a proper discussion taking place about these very important issues. I'm a practitioner, as many of you know, and we're involved in trying to build some of this new health infrastructure around the country. Indeed, today I've been involved in a quite an exciting conversation about a health innovation campus in Huddersfield that we're supporting at the moment that have major implications for the direction of travel of this government, a lot of which I support around place and collaboration, all those things the Prime Minister has talked about. But we're also in touch at the front end of what's actually happening on the ground. And the word I keep hearing from colleagues across the country is the word chaotic, which is a worrying word to be hearing.
And I think therefore this debate and this discussion and the detail that is being discussed today really, really matter for the NHS, for patients, and for those of us who are trying to build this infrastructure. And I'm encouraged, as I say, that the Minister is starting off in this committee stage in an open, transparent, conversational manner, and that's very, very helpful. The one other point I'd make at this point, one of my concerns about the infrastructure, the changes that are taking place at the moment, is there doesn't seem to be a clear vision about prevention. Those of us who've been involved in this space, in our case in East London but now nationally for over 40 years, know when you're dealing on the ground in very challenging communities that the real determinants of health often have nothing to do with doctors. If you asked our GPs in Bromley-by-Bow, they'd tell you a person getting a job does more for a person's health than anything to do with doctors, actually.
Speaker 77
It's why in Bromley-by-Bow we ended up building 97 businesses with local people because we got real about the social determinants of health. It's about do I have a decent home that is not damp? It's why we built a housing company which now has 10,000 properties and owns 35% of the land in Poplar. It's to do with are your relationships in your family in a good place? Do you feel part of a community?
Andrew Mawson
It's to do with all these things. And the numbers people far cleverer than me come up with say it's 70 to 80% the impact of all of this. I am not clear in this real opportunity to reform the NHS in this century in the things we now know what this government is saying about the prevention agenda and how clearly it is or is not joining the dots around the social determinants. So I think part of this conversation is a really, really important part of it, but part of it needs to be about the prevention agenda and as we work our way through the committee stage, far more clarity about what that is going to mean in practice and in detail in communities across this country.
Diana Dido Harding
My Lords, it's a privilege to follow both the noble Lord Mawson and the noble Lady Gerada, who between them have many decades more experience than I do of NHS and health and care reorganization. I have only one major one from the inside, the last time we were debating the restructuring of the NHS in 21 and 22. At the time, as someone from the private sector, I was somewhat surprised to discover that the NHS got on with the reorganization before the legislation was passed. It seems this time it's sort of even odder that the NHS has started before the legislation but without a plan itself. So I do really welcome this amendment from my noble friend Earl Howe.
I think it's really essential that we understand what the plan is and what the timetable is, what it's going to cost and what benefits it's going to bring. It really is very, very straightforward. And if that doesn't exist, the idea that it can be complete by the 1st of April next year is completely gobsmacking. And maybe I'm just an innocent businesswoman who doesn't understand the ways of the NHS, but it just does not seem right. So I think that this amendment is just basic common sense.
I do support, much as I hear the words of wisdom from Don Berwick, I do support merging NHS England with the Department of Health because I saw from the inside, particularly during COVID, how important it is to have clear political accountability. So I do support the basic premise, but I am very worried that the tendency will be to centralize rather than to push resource out to the regions and to local communities. And as the noble Lord Mawson has just said, it is at the local ground level that change really happens. I'm very supportive of seeing fewer people employed in organizations that bear the NHS brand but don't actually treat patients. There are tens of thousands of people.
They all are trying hard and doing lovely, doing valuable work, but it is a long way away from patients. And so as we bring NHS England into the department, as part of this amendment, I would love to see a clear breakdown of the cost savings at the national level, the regional level versus the local level so that we've got sight of whether or not we're really pushing accountability down and pushing resource and capability down to where change will really bring the benefits that we all seek.
Anne Marie Rafferty
My Lords, said it much better.
I'd like to be brief, support the point that was made by my noble friend Lord Hunt, that due consideration, reconsideration be given by the minister to the abolition of governors. I have to declare an interest as a former governor of King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, and I spoke in the second reading about the value of governors and the extraordinary breadth and depth of feedback and accountability that they provide to trusts. And would just ask the minister to reconsider that decision, for I fear that if governors are abolished, we will have to find some mechanism to reinvent them.
Speaker 83
I have to say I have been resisting the temptation to get involved in this debate, partly because I wasn't able to join in on the second reading, and I apologize for speaking now having not done that. I suppose I ought to start off just by making one point, which is that at the beginning of this century I was running both the NHS and the Department of Health, so I had the two jobs. So I have actually seen some of what we're talking about from inside. I think some of it was extremely successful, and I think some of the point about the regional offices, there are some models there which I'm quite sure can be followed. But the reason that I actually stood up is because Lord Mawson spoke about something else, which was about prevention.
Edmund Nigel Crisp
And what I realized when I was running the Department of Health is that I, with a hospital management background, had turned it into the Department of the NHS, and we had lost some of our health focus. And the future is about health, not just about healthcare. And we've got to be focusing on prevention, but not just prevention, on creating health, creating the conditions to be healthy. Now I'm not going to get into a second reading speech here, but the question I want to ask is how is the government going to preserve the proper role of the Department of Health when it gets all this responsibility for the NHS? The NHS which runs on a, I speak as a former chief executive, on a 24-hour, you know, you get contacted all the time, 24 hours at a time.
How are you going to actually manage the really important responsibility of leadership for health across government? Because as the noble Lord Lord Mawson says, 80% is about housing, employment, and the environment. There's 20%, and I have to say it is a very vital 20% that the health system provides, particularly if you have a nasty cancer or your leg has just fallen off or something, you need that. But so my question to you, my question, I beg pardon, to the noble lady the minister, is how is the government going to preserve the proper responsibility of the Department of Health for all the health functions as opposed to the NHS functions?
Speaker 79
Honored to follow the noble Lord Crisp when he was, oh sorry, sorry, sorry.
Speaker 80
I hadn't intended, my Lords, to speak in this debate, but I've been listening very clearly, and I think what's missing is what happens to the people on the grassroots, the patients who rely on their ICBs to behave and do the right thing in terms of their care and support. When I heard that NHS England was going to shut down, I have to say my heart went into my boots.
This is because I've been working with a certain department to look at the ways that we can deliver an NHS personal health budget from when they were first conceived till now. There's an awful lot of organizational expertise, memory, support, and guidance from NHS England to local ICBs across the country. And in doing so, the personal health budgets became a very good way of delivering personalized care at home for people with complex impairments. And I should probably declare an interest because I have been negotiating with my own ICB for about 15 years. It's not easy.
What I worry about in this transition is that we don't have a plan for what's going to happen to these people in NHS England who have all that expertise, history, and know-how in terms of supporting ICBs to deliver their support to complex patients in the community in the future. And I'm afraid I'm not that positive because in the last two years, and since we heard that ICBs were going to make 50% savings, ICBs are behaving quite oddly towards people with complex, sometimes expensive care in the community. They are institutionalizing them, even though they were supported in their own homes quite happily doing their degrees. They are restricting where you can go with your personal health budget and PA, whether you can be outside the home, because they've suddenly started to say it is unsafe. So something odd is in the air since we knew that NHS England were going to go.
I believe the department said there were only four people left supporting these ICBs with their delivery. And quite frankly, they are going backwards. And so I would be really keen to have a plan about what's going to happen when NHS England go and who's going to do this work, because ICBs need guidance in this area on an ongoing basis. They haven't got the expertise locally, and somebody's got to do it. Thank you.
Speaker 84
My Lords, I just wanted to pick up some of the key points in the amendment, focusing on what the transition plan should look like and focus on. Thinking about the experience of cancer patients post the 2012 changes and what came along with them, which was the abolition of the very comprehensive cancer networks that were set up around England to deliver the then cancer plan, there was a vacuum, my Lords, following that change. And it took years to establish the architecture that we now have in place for delivery of the current cancer plan.
And since the news that NHS England is being abolished, I am really concerned that the momentum around the delivery of the current cancer plan is being impaired. And so I think the points in the amendment number four around how to set out what how the continuity of services during the transition will be maintained. So that's my worries about the cancer plan and how that will be, you know, driving forward the service improvements set out in that and all the hundred recommendations, how that will be progressed. Because it's not the responsibility of any one ICB there. It's currently driven forward by NHS England.
How is that, how are the staff associated with that going to be transferred into NHS England? How do we make sure that there won't be that vacuum? We already had a really disappointing delay in the appointment of the chair of the cancer board that's been established. So we really need to make sure that that momentum, there's a massive consensus around this cancer plan, which, you know, we should really celebrate between all, you know, there are 200 different types of cancer, more than 200 different types of cancer charities, so many different specialties. It's a really key, you know, one in two of us will get cancer at some stage in our lives.
It's a massively important area for the health service. And we need to be absolutely confident that the transition will not, you know, will not fall between all the gaps as it did in 2012 and then take years to re-establish the architecture that we need to deliver this kind of ecosystem of success that we have in the UK in terms of cancer services.
Speaker 81
I thank the noble lady for the meeting, the minister for the meeting she's arranged and for the progress we've made. And I hope that we will continue to do so as we debate this issue. But I too am very concerned about the costs and benefits in the timetable that is currently set out. And there are two questions that I really want to ask. One, has the strategy, which I firmly believe in and believe that we should move away from NHS England, been looked at against the NHS Charter?
And I ask this because item six says the NHS is committed to providing best value for taxpayers' money. It is committed to providing the most effective, fair and sustainable use of finite resources. Public funds for healthcare will be devoted solely to the benefit of the people that the NHS serves. So this question about how much this is costing and when it will be paid back is fundamental in terms of the charter. And the charter also talks about staff rights.
And though I am not working in the health service, I have many friends and colleagues who are. And this feeling of uncertainty has now been going on for 18 months. And I can say as a mental health nurse that one of the worst things for mental health promotion is uncertainty. So this amendment really is important in trying to move us forward about what the real timetable is. And I would ask the noble lady whether she can in particular say is there, as some rumors are implying, a kind of backpedaling because now we've asked Baroness Casey to move faster forward?
Are we actually trying to get to a point where we have some of the care service, I suppose, strategy in our mind? Because what could be worse than making a lot of very capable people redundant and then needing to re-employ them as we move forward?
The costs to society and the taxpayer would be enormous. So I just wanted to make those points and would welcome what the minister has to say.
Speaker 88
My Lords, I agree that it's absolutely necessary to have clarity in respect of the transition to the new system. And I would add my voice to those noble Lords who've talked about the need for clarity for the staff because I believe that successful reform, which we must have both for patients and for all staff, is absolutely dependent on retaining the expertise, experience, and commitment of the staff. And if we expect that commitment, we have to give them some security, some knowledge of what's going to happen to their careers, to their families, whether or not they're going to be made redundant. And this is of course about the systems, it's about costs, but it's about the networks, the cancer network that was mentioned by my noble friend Morgan, my noble friend Baroness Morgan. It's about the consultants, it's about doctors, it's about the nurses, but it's also about the people who keep the hospitals going.
Speaker 87
It's about the cooks, it's about the cleaners, many of whom have been contracted out, but those contracts are bound to change as well. So I think that the clarity which we're all asking the noble my noble friend the minister for is absolutely critical if we are going to ensure the success of this new enterprise.
Speaker 86
My Lords, first of all I declare an interest in my working with the NHS England. I was appointed as chair of the sickle cell and thalassemia work, which was quite not easy. You didn't know whether the people who are coming to make their presentations were just that particular trust or whether they had the authority of the then chief executive of NHS England. And it wasn't an easy job. Some people were telling us within the organization that they didn't have the money and they didn't think that we could actually achieve screening for sickle cell.
We persisted, we worked hard, we consulted, eventually that was achieved after 12 years of work. And I just want to thank particularly those doctors, nurses, workers who'd been dealing with really very, very sick people because sickle cell disease is is a tough one. The joy is now that the steering group handed over the work once the screening was accepted, the joy I had was my daughter had a baby and also during pregnancy she was being tested whether she actually is a sickle cell carrier and they found that she was. Would this also end up with a baby? But the day that our granddaughter Abigail was born, there was a simple test and it came back saying no, she's not a carrier.
Years ago, that wasn't a possibility. So there are many things that the NHS has done, but I was in the debate when the new act which created NHS England was being progressed and it is going through exactly in the same sort of regurgitation of fear and worry and concern, we need to do this.
My view in relationship to clause 4 as an amendment, yes, there's some good things in there, but the best thing is not us voting it in. What actually for me I want to recommend is that before report stage, the minister with the people who've got great expertise in this area had a conversation. A conversation which will set out matters which won't leave questions still hanging because a particular clause has been passed. And I think that'll be a very helpful, a very helpful thing. During COVID, I was sometimes feeling that we did not do a good job when we set up NHS England because we used to get Sir John Stevens speaking as the chief executive of the NHS in England.
And he spoke with great clarity. And then there was the chief executive of the different national trusts. And he was almost not really, I felt, on the side of those who were anxious, were worried, were bothered. So that system, friends, needs to change. We don't need to have these different executives representing that body, this body, that body.
It needs to have a coherence in the way it relates. When Sir Stevens, now Lord Stevens, spoke, you knew that he was actually speaking for everybody, not this particular trust, not those who had a chief executive working as this. It was absolute chaos. And this is what actually I think the government is wanting to, I wish they didn't use the word abolish because abolish always can create a lot of fear. I hope they were talking about transformation of this thing called NHS England.
So my experience and my work in and in dealing with NHS where I've had four very serious operations, those operations were well done. It didn't matter what hospital it was. But in terms of the numbers now we've got who are not either clinicians or supporters or health workers, it's grown into a huge management. And I think it needs, it needs somebody to look at it. And the good things in Lord Howe's amendment, but I don't think that actually answers the question that we all would like to ask.
Moving towards transformation, what are the building blocks which must be put in place? To me, that's the question. And people say that if there was a big thing to be done in China, they'd say we're going to build this hospital here. They don't suffer the sort of over-consultation which often does not deliver the reality. I live in a democracy, I wouldn't want to live in China at all.
I live in this country, but this country also does not grasp the real problem that needs to be dealt with. So I just hope that the movers of the amendment will find space, time, and some of you are very good at this, to work out what will be the building blocks for a good transition to get to where we are. And also we created in these lovely hospitals where I've been treated, fantastic staff. But then they're given a management which doesn't actually often works.
Um, this is the opportunity we've got to grasp and we've got to deal with it and not be the sort of people, um, who always are very difficult, um, always behaving like turkeys that don't want Christmas to come.
Speaker 89
My Lords, I, uh, thank noble Lords who have spoken in this rather revealing debate, and I particularly thank the noble, uh, uh, Earl Howe, the noble Earl Howe for, uh, introducing this, uh, group in his normal calm and measured way, but importantly giving us all the chance to ask the most basic of questions of this bill: where is the plan? Now, it is pleasing that the noble lady the Minister and the government have been in listening mode, uh, particularly regarding the, um, Health Service Safety Investigation Body and, uh, Healthwatch, and I hope that during committee stage the government continues to listen and actually make other important changes to the bill. Now, at second reading, I said this bill was a power grab. The Nuffield Trust's October briefing for this committee puts it more politely: it describes new powers for the Secretary of State well beyond those NHS England holds, which it says enables, quote, "more political control and limits real devolution." Now, the government is entitled to decide if it wants NHS England, uh, functions in the department under political hands.
Speaker 90
Now, we on these benches would caution, uh, that, uh, but Nuffield accepts that some duplication between the department and NHS England is real, and that the Minister must specify exactly what that duplication is. But if it is the aim, it has to be planned and it has to be costed. And I also would caution, uh, the, uh, noble Lord Hunt of Kings Heath and, um, Baroness Harding for suggesting that putting, uh, the NHS England functions in the department brings accountability to the Secretary of State. When we get on to clause 11, we may see that the accountability is missing, but the powers actually are about to be transferred. So, noble Lords will know the, uh, architect's maxim that form follows function.
Philip Hunt
Would the noble give way? Isn't the point that at the moment, um, parliamentarians can raise issues with ministers only to be told that that's the responsibility of NHS England? I accept what he says about how this is going to work, but ultimately now the finger is absolutely pointed at ministers for everything that happens.
Speaker 90
Well, as I say to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, let's get on when we get to clause 11, he will see that actually some of the powers that the Secretary of State now takes beyond NHS England actually will not come before this Parliament, uh, and it will just be at the signature of the Secretary of State's pen. So, in this bill, as I said, um, in this bill form comes, uh, first and function will follow in due course. We have the demolition notice, but we're still to see the drawings of what the new structure is. And let me say how far behind the government is. Uh, Nuffield, working with the Institute of Government, compared past public sector reform, uh, NHS abolitions.
It found the key factors for success are not in place here. The abolition was announced without plans to explain its goals to staff and without redundancy funding, which led to months of delay. Detailed planning for the new department began only in, uh, early 2026, almost a year after the announcement. And Nuffield's verdict is that the process has been, quote, "poorly handled."
Now, and we are still short of very basic information. At the second reading and in this committee, the noble lord Lord Stevens, who I must admit must know something about running the NHS, pointed out that the costs and benefits in the impact assessment are still marked as not available, and there's still a number of questions about the timing of when this reform will come in. What we do have is the government's estimates that redundancy exits across the department and NHS England, ICBs and the commissioning support units will cost between 1 and 1.3 billion, to be met from existing allocations. But we must ask which allocations and which services pay. And then there is the timetable.
The Health Service Journal reported on the 15th of October that abolition will have to be formally delayed beyond April 2027 unless decisions on future national structures are made within days. So I need to ask the noble lady the minister, have those decisions been made and are staff now aware of where they will be transferred? The new operating model has been waiting for ministerial sign-off for months. Ministers are still weighing whether thousands of staff are going to the department or into, as we read, potentially a standalone new agency. This bill sends nearly every function of NHS England to the Secretary of State, yet the government has not decided where the people who will perform those functions will sit.
The department says that it continues to plan for the 1st of April 2027, but my lords, planning a date is not the same as being able to meet it. And now to the job cuts. The planned 50% cuts in the department appear to require moving the large majority of central policy and analytical staff, or is it about cutting operational staff? As the noble lord Lord Crisp said, we need to have clarity about which staff and which functions are going to be in the department. It's not clear that the figure is rested on rigorous assessment of who is needed and why.
History tells us how this ends. After previous reforms that moved managers from commissioning bodies, the department consultancy spend peaked at over 600 million pounds a year and the number of managers within five years was higher than going into the reorganization. I fear this will be another cut first, rehire later and call it efficiency. My lords, we need not just take the words of noble lords in this debate. As the noble Earl Howe said, the Darzi review commissioned by the government and updated in May concluded that a top-down reorganization of NHS England and ICBs is, quote, neither necessary nor desirable, end quote.
It added that constant reorganizations are costly and distracting. We've had six statutory major reorganizations in 30 years, none with clear evidence that structure has brought about improvement. The government commissioned that review and it should read it and learn from it. So my lords, I have six questions for the noble lady the minister. When will the target operating model be published and will that be before report?
Is the latest thinking to put NHS England transferred functions and staff into the department or will they be setting up a standalone body?
Will the government publish a full costed impact assessment including benefits and where the 1.1 billion to 1.3 billion pound actually comes from? Also, what are the expected costs of disruption and how will any further delay be limited? And is the government confident that the 50% cut will not drive up consultancy spending by the end of this parliament? And will the government commit to laying a transition plan if they don't accept the Noble Earl Howe's amendment before this parliament, before report, which is in substance what this amendment is asking for? Those of us on these benches are not defenders of the status quo.
I started in the NHS in the early 1990s and lived through more reorganisations than I care to count. Everyone promised less bureaucracy and freeing up the front line. None of them delivered that. So if the government wants to put NHS operational matters into political hands, that is their choice. But they owe this house a plan, then a price, then a bill, in that order.
Speaker 91
At present we have a bill and we're still waiting for the other two. I look forward to the minister's reply.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm most grateful to the Noble Lord Earl Howe for speaking to this amendment and indeed to the Noble Lord Lord Kamall for tabling it. It certainly is as other Noble Lords have observed, a comprehensive and thorough, um, and makes the point which a number of Noble Lords have made about the importance of ensuring the right processes and assessments are undertaken as we move towards the abolition of NHS England, one of the key things, um, before us in this bill. As we're at the beginning of our deliberations, I would like to say to Noble Lords, I do listen and have listened very carefully to the points that are made. I'll endeavour to answer a number of points, but, um, a number of them I want to take away to be able to write and as ever, as Noble Lords will recall from previous bills, that will be to, um, all peers, um, and is what will be widely available because I want to do justice to the point. I want to first of all, um, address the amendment itself, which is, um, the key point here and to say that certainly we do agree with the importance of robust financial oversight throughout this transition as Noble Lords are calling for, rightly, including understanding cost savings and overall value for money.
And the reflection I'd give is that it is through existing financial planning and assurance arrangements that this transition, and the Noble Lord Lord Scriven did ask for the use of the word transition, um, that it's being carefully managed through those means. And that does include consideration of transition expenditure and the savings that are expected from reducing duplication through the bringing of NHS England and the department together. So our priority is to ensure, as is the priority of Noble Lords, we all want to make sure that resources are used effectively and wherever possible directed towards front line services and improvement for patients because that is at the core of this.
And whilst I do absolutely agree with the principle of transparency, the issue that the very detailed amendment does raise is placing additional requirements for an independently reviewed financial plan, placing it in legislation. And I think this is at this point that I part company with it, which is something that would add an unnecessary process and constraint on the government's ability to even manage the transition flexibly and efficiently. So I do take the point in the amendment and I certainly take the points that noble lords have spoken to, but I don't feel that the amendment by placing this in legislation will get us where we need to. To pick up a number of the points on first of all costs and savings, which is something raised by the noble lord Earl Howe, noble lord Lord Lansley, noble lady Baroness Mansoor, noble lady Baroness Harding, the noble lady Baroness Watkins and the noble lord Lord Scriven, and I know other lords have referred to it at all. The noble lord Earl Howe asked me to write with information and I feel that in view of the whole range of things that have been raised that that would be something that would be very helpful to do.
But I can make just some general points that we do remain on track to deliver over a billion pounds of savings per annum by the end of this parliament. And just to make the point, because the whole point about a transition is it's a process. That final total saving will be determined by a number of things, but that includes the number and seniority of staff, for example, who do leave through exit schemes, and that is currently underway. So there is a whole element, and I know noble lords understand this, transition is a moving process. But it doesn't mean it's wrong to ask for the information, but we do have to take account of the fact we, this is something in development and movement.
The noble lord Lord Lansley raised the point about the National Audit Office and I would simply observe and extended a suggestion about volunteering as I recall. I understand why the noble lord is saying that, but I would just observe that the National Audit Office rightly is independent and really it's for them to determine their program of work. To the noble lord Lord Stevens, in respect of a 50% reduction being a final figure, well to link with my comments I've just made, yes indeed our aim is to reduce staff numbers significantly across the department and NHS England. But as I said, it can't be a final figure because we haven't gone through the process of identification etc. But so I did hear what the noble lord read out and in some ways that's true, it is an ambition and one has to set that.
But in terms of the final figure, I don't think anybody would be able to give that in honesty at absolute preciseness.
But we are working, of course, closely with trade unions and staff across the two organisations, and we will continue to consult with them. My noble friend Lord Hunt did raise questions in relation to the role of the Secretary of State, as did other noble Lords. And as my noble friend indicated, we will be returning to that in rather more detail, and I look forward to doing so when we turn to looking at the power of direction in clause 11. And the points raised by the noble Lord, Lord Kakkar, in respect of operational management, I can say that transferring NHS England's functions will not require changes to established clinical audit programs, NICE-supported diabetes technologies, nor specialist diabetes services. Those programs do operate through existing statutory and operational arrangements.
The noble Lord, Lord Stevens, asked whether it is our intention to still abolish NHS England by the 1st of April. Yes, that is our intention. And I also have to add, we recognise that's a very demanding timetable, and of course, as your Lordships' House will be very aware of this, it is subject to the parliamentary passage of this bill. With regard to staffing, and I'm glad that a number of noble Lords raised this, including the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, the noble lady Baroness Watkins, my noble friends Baroness Royal and Baroness Thornton, the noble lady Baroness Mansell, the noble lady Baroness Campbell. The first thing I want to say is that change within any organisation is an anxious time for all those who are potentially affected.
And I also want to say that the changes being proposed here are absolutely no reflection on the quality of the work that is carried out day in and day out by talented staff, and I am grateful to them. This is about getting the system working for patients and for the public. And so we will ensure that people are treated properly, and we will continue to communicate information about reforms to staff through the various internal channels as we have done. I just mentioned our work in terms of consulting with recognised trade unions, and we are very grateful for their partnership because I think it's critical as to how we approach this change. And I say that as a former trade union official used to this level of and kind of reorganisation.
There were questions about retaining the talent of staff, which I think are very key. And I can say that we've taken a number of measures to retain and also to develop talent. And that includes initiating a joint interim recruitment process between NHS England and DHSC. It includes a focus on temporary lateral moves and internal promotion in order to retain skills.
And we are through organisational development and design work identifying key skills and capabilities that we will need in the future. And I anticipate that this will support a drive so we have a more expert department because we'll be focusing very much on the skills we need and also functions that ensure that we can develop and retain expertise. And the noble lady Baroness Campbell used the example of personal health budgets. And I certainly am aware, not least because of the campaigning work and experience of the noble lady herself in this area, that personalised care has a liberating effect on individuals. And I very much look forward to specifically debating those issues when we come to the amendment 178 of the noble lord Lord Lansley.
My noble friend Baroness Thornton also asked about the TUPE regulations and arrangements. And like I'm sure many noble lords, I've received a considerable amount of correspondence on this matter. And I do want to put on the record, and I'm glad for the opportunity, the bill does not remove TUPE protections from anyone. And the circumstances where TUPE applies are of course set out in the existing transfer of undertakings protection of employment regulations 2006. My noble friend Baroness Rafferty, as did my noble friend Lord Hunt, referred to the abolition of governors.
I look forward to discussing that issue also later in the bill's passage at clause 30. And to the noble lord Lord Scriven, and I am aware I'm making a general response and I will look closely at the specific questions that he's asked of course. But the kind of duplication that we are speaking about does include HR, IT, communications. I've got my own experience as I'm sure other noble lords who've occupied my position before me will have done about how, and actually my noble friend Lord Hunt put it well, about the, I'll call it a tension between what ministers are expected to have control on but haven't got control on. And that in my view creates not just difficulty of duplication but immense frustration, which I also experience in this chamber, and I understand that.
I should say in those functions I've just referred to as examples, many of them did sit in the department prior to the establishment of NHS England. And I don't think this is just a recreation of the pre-2013 system. And a number of noble lords did make the point, which I completely understand, about their despair at reorganisations. And the noble lord Lord Lansley also made the point, for example, that it wasn't in this government's manifesto.
That's true. I recall when we came into government on this very issue, we also did not want to, and the then Secretary of State made it quite clear that he did not wish to enter into reorganization, but the harsher reality was as we worked through it and we got into our stride, we realized this was unsustainable. When faced with what is unsustainable, we can either put effort, resource, and energy, or otherwise known as blood, sweat, and tears, into trying to make something work we know cannot work, or we bite the bullet, and that is what we are doing here. So we are recasting the role of the center in respect of the rest of the system. We are making it smaller, we are changing the way it works, so that the center only does what it must do or can do most efficiently, and that we can better serve patients through local decision-making.
And again, we will return to that very point and the relationship between the two later on in the bill. And I am, can I say, I'm most grateful to noble Lords who've engaged through roundtables and have engaged directly with me and also have received the correspondence that I've sent. I will be glad to continue to do that as we go through committee stage and beyond. And to reassure noble Lords, we do remain committed to parliamentary scrutiny throughout the transition, and we absolutely will continue to publish updates as we move forward.
Speaker 90
Just before the noble lady sits down, I did ask one specific question which she may not be able to answer at this moment in time, but she could put in writing. I did ask, is it, if the intention as you, as the noble lady's just pointed out to the noble Lord Lord Stevens, is it the government's intention to transfer all those staff into department, or is a standalone body being looked at as a potential route to put some of those staff in?
Gillian Merron
The intention is the former, but I will gladly write further to the noble Lord on this point.
Howe
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Baroness the Minister for her wide-ranging response and to all noble Lords who have contributed to this important debate, which I think has been very useful. I think the committee has spoken with one voice in underlining the scale and complexity of the task which lies ahead and the importance of ensuring that the abolition of NHS England, or its transformation, as the most Reverend Lord Sentamu put it, is managed carefully, transparently, and with proper accountability. As I said at the outset, we're not opposed to efforts to reduce bureaucracy or improve efficiency in the health service, but we have to be confident that the government has a clear understanding of the costs involved, the savings which can realistically be achieved, and the risks associated with a reorganization on this scale. Above all, we mustn't lose sight of the people whom these reforms are intended to serve. The ultimate measure of success must be whether patients receive better, safer, and more timely care, rather than simply whether we've succeeded in changing the administrative structure of the NHS.
Now, despite what she said, I hope the Minister will have recognized that my amendment was put together as a giant probe of the government's transition plans, rather than a model form of words to be written into the bill. I therefore welcome her assurance that she will reflect carefully on the concerns that have been raised today, particularly around the need for a clear and independently assessed transition plan, and we will consider the Minister's response ahead of report. But for now, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 92
Is it your pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. After clause 3, amendment 5, Lord Kamal, Lord Han.
Howe
My Lords, I beg to move amendment 5 standing in my name and that of my noble friend Lord Kamal. I'm grateful to the noble Lord Lord Hunt of Kings Heath for his amendment 211 in this group. Amendment 5 concerns the future ownership and governance of Supply Chain Coordination Limited following the abolition of NHS England. It is a rather more specific amendment than the one we've just debated, but I think it raises an important question about the wider process of transition, and particularly how the government intends to ensure that essential services and functions continue to operate effectively as NHS England is abolished. As I emphasized earlier, NHS England sits at the center of an extraordinarily complex and interconnected healthcare system, with responsibilities, contracts, assets, and operational relationships extending throughout the NHS.
And when we interfere with one part of that system, we need to be certain that we understand what depends upon it, and this is particularly important in relation to procurement and supply chains. NHS England currently holds the shares in Supply Chain Coordination Limited, which plays a central role in the NHS supply chain arrangements through which hospitals and other healthcare providers obtain essential equipment, medical devices, and supplies. Now, these are functions which may not attract a great deal of public attention, but they are absolutely fundamental to the day-to-day operation of the health service. Hospitals depend on reliable access to medical equipment, consumables, and other essential supplies in order to deliver treatment. And when those supplies are disrupted, the consequences can obviously be very serious indeed: procedures can be delayed, costs can increase, and clinical staff can find themselves unable to provide the care which their patients need.
It's therefore essential that as the government undertakes this reorganization, we don't inadvertently destabilize or create disruption in areas of the health service which are currently operating effectively. That's the concern which this amendment seeks to address. As NHS England is abolished, its shareholding in Supply Chain Coordination Limited will need to be transferred. Our amendment doesn't seek to prevent that transfer, nor does it prescribe what the future ownership arrangements should look like. Instead, it asks the government to set out clearly how that transfer will be managed, who will be responsible for the company afterwards, and what measures will be taken to ensure that its operations continue without interruption.
There are, I think, some fairly straightforward questions here. First, who will assume ownership of the company, and who will exercise the shareholder responsibilities both during and after the transition? It surely can't be intended that day-to-day control of the organization will fall to the Secretary of State.
But if not, then to whom and under what organizational structure? Secondly, pursuant to that, what governance and accountability arrangements will be put in place? Will there be any changes to the company's operating model and if so, what assessment has been made of their potential consequences? Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, what assurances can the government give that the transfer will not disrupt the procurement, storage or distribution of essential supplies across the health service? I'd be particularly interested to hear what assessment has been made of the risks involved in transferring these responsibilities and what contingency arrangements will be available if the process proves more complicated than anticipated.
Procurement and supply chain management depend on experienced people, established relationships and systems which have been developed over many years. We know that NHS reorganization will involve staff cuts. To what extent will this organization be subject to cuts in staff and at what levels? What steps are being taken to ensure that the relevant expertise is retained and whether any independent assurance has been obtained about the resilience of these arrangements during the transition? More broadly, I regard this amendment as representing a microcosm of the larger questions that surround the abolition of NHS England.
The success of this reorganization will depend not only on whether the government can transfer functions and responsibilities on paper, but on whether the systems which patients and clinicians rely upon continue to work in practice. I hope the minister will be able to provide some reassurance on these points and I beg to move.
Speaker 92
Amendment proposed after clause 3, insert the new clause printed on the marshalled list.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, I very much agree with Earl Howe that procurement is important in itself, but it is an illustration in a sense of how the new arrangements might play out. Where I disagree with him, I mean he was really inferring supply chains doing a good job, we don't want to disrupt it. Actually, there are a lot of concerns about the current performance of the supply chain which I'd like to come to because I think this is an opportunity actually to improve what it does and in particular to try and get the relationship between supply chain and local NHS bodies on a much better footing. Okay, so my Lords, my amendment 211 is grouped with this and it has the support of Noble Lord Lord Markham, the former health minister who has been a great advocate of value-based purchasing. I should declare an interest as patron of Health Care Supplies Association, which is the organization for professionals in health service procurement who contribute so much to a very important function.
My Lords, of course procurement is there to ensure value for money for the health service, but it can do much more. We know since COVID the essential need for supply chain resilience, effective procurement can provide this, ensure investment in innovation, supporting UK industry and I believe it can link closely with the government's ambitions on matters of sovereignty, regional development and growth. Supply chain has a clear role in this and I think it's absolutely right to scrutinize what the arrangements are going to be when the shares transfer from NHS England to the Department of Health.
And I particularly want to raise the shortcomings of the supply chain and the 2024 Public Accounts Committee report, which found that NHS England had been weak in its oversight and support of NHS supply chain. The PAC reported that neither NHS England nor the department had validated the savings the company reported and that trust satisfaction with the service was already in steady decline. And my Lords, nor was the committee's criticism confined to NHS England. It found the department, which owned the company before 2021, had been far too lenient in its oversight. Now, my Lords, returning the shareholding to the department really doesn't change this one way or the other.
But as I said earlier, it is a chance to put the relationship between NHS supply chain, its shareholder, ministers, and the NHS organizations it serves on a much clearer footing. And I want to make this point: it's there to serve the NHS. It doesn't, however, behave in a way which actually recognizes that its customers are local NHS bodies. I believe, my Lords, I think I should say here that there is a view it's very, very arrogant in its dealings with NHS bodies. This is what we want to see changed, and I hope my Lords' ministerial control will actually do something about it.
I should also say that the ABHI reported to me that currently, supply chain does not publish the agendas, papers, and minutes of its board meetings. I find that very, very surprising, and I think my Lords, the noble Lord Scriven, I think, will raise this in relation to clause 11. I, at the very least, would hope to get some assurance that that will be put right. So, my Lords, I also just want to ask her about whether under the department, they will continue their commitment to value-based purchasing. This is very important.
I've long argued for it. The noble Lord Lansley is very much with me in this. And my Lords, the point about it is trying to get away from always going for the lowest price and trying to go for quality to improve patient outcomes. We are making, I really acknowledge, my Lords, we are making progress. The department itself is very supportive.
And I just wanted to quote one example. So it was launched this year, value-based purchasing to ensure a higher quality of healthcare by raising standard procurement. During a pilot in South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust working with Essity, patients were provided with the most appropriate absorbent continence product for their clinical needs and preference, even if that product was more expensive than other options under consideration. The result showed an 8% reduction in the number of incontinence products used, a 48% reduction in leaks, and 71% of patients said they were now finding it easier to change the product themselves. And you know, this is a wonderful example of hugely improved patient outcomes because they didn't go for the cheapest product.
So that's what this is all based on. We know NHS supply chain has committed to this. But within the supply chain, there's a tension because they also have something called the core list, which is to enable it to manage the source and supply of a core range of standard commodities on behalf of all providers. And the key phrase here is standard commodities. So when it's a question of scissors, clinical waste bags, batteries, pencil sharpeners, this is eminently sensible.
But a few days ago, supply chain slipped onto their website, with no advance warning, no announcement to key trade associations, such as the Urology Trade Association, a list of an additional 79 categories of product to be assessed for potential inclusion in future versions of the core list. This included urinary catheters and colostomy bags. Now, my Lords, these are not standard commodities. These are very personal things. And I'm very worried that the supply chain, by just doing this without any consultation at all, is actually going to reduce patient outcomes.
So, my Lords, clearly this is a little aside from the core aim of this legislation. But actually, the way this is handled will be an indication of how the future arrangements are going to be. And I do think, my Lords, that having a commitment that the supply chain, one, will actually commit to value-based purchasing, and two, will actually recognize that its real, it's owned by the Secretary of State, or will be, but its job is to help the local NHS, and it shouldn't treat them in an arrogant way. It should treat them as, basically, its customers.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, I added my name to the amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, because it seemed to me that this actually goes almost to the heart of the way that we account for what we do and what we buy in the NHS. And one of the problems is the accounting lines. So a piece of equipment that might appear at face value to look expensive, in fact, saves an enormous expenditure and patient distress and morbidity from a different budgetary line. So the saving is actually a fallacy. So I really welcome the value-based procurement and acknowledge the work that's been done by the Medical Technology and Innovation Directorate in the department, and encourage that this goes right across the whole of the NHS and social care system.
It is the clinicians who know that the cheapest is not necessarily the best, but at face value that may not always seem adequate. And NICE have certainly produced examples of where the cheapest is certainly not the best. If I can give a very specific example relating to something which is quite expensive, and that is cardiac pacemakers. Now, most cardiac pacemakers have wires on them. There are some which are eight times more expensive, but they do not have leads on them.
Now, it might seem a lot of extra money, but the thing is that if patients have had radiotherapy to their shoulder and the left side of the chest, or if they are at very high risk of infection because they're on immunosuppressants or because they have a condition where they're immunosuppressed, then actually they are at high risk of getting infection on the leads because the leads are a foreign body in their body. And the cost of sepsis, of managing sepsis, of patients in ICU, vastly outweighs the cost of using these different pacemakers for a small number of patients. When we think about things like urinary catheters, again, those patients who self-catheterize may well find that one type of catheter is much easier for them to use than another. And if they use it well and properly, their risk of infection is much lower. And self-catheterization, I would say, I think is easier for men than it is for women generally, but certainly women who have a disability may find that they have got used to one, manipulating one type of catheter to self-catheterize.
So it becomes actually very cost-effective. And the clinicians are the ones who know what the outcomes are for particular devices. So that needs to be embedded in the tendering process. And I hope that the voice of the clinicians determining the overall outcomes will be considered ever more as this goes forward. I would use the example from Wales where we actually do have value-based health and care as an academy in Swansea University.
And that produces some very interesting work and is internationally recognized as being a leader in the field because it's a different way of thinking. So I do hope that there will be reporting to us on how this works when the change has happened.
Andrew Lansley
My Lords, I want to speak briefly to this group in support of amendment 211 in particular in the name of Lord Hunt of Kings Heath and Baroness Finley. I should declare an interest in that I am an officer of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Medical Devices, on Medicines and Medical Devices, which has held meetings particularly relating to this issue of the value-based procurement of medical devices. And I chair a group looking at breakthrough implantable devices who have also interested, taken a specific interest in the procurement of just the kinds of devices that the noble lady Baroness Finley was just talking about and the importance that we've put forward of the clinical input to the process of understanding the potential value of particularly these innovative devices. I wanted to intervene just really to say I very, I mean the noble Lord, maybe some members of the committee know that I've been an advocate of value-based procurement and indeed where medicines are concerned, value-based pricing as an approach in the National Health Service. There is work being done and I think there's some good work being done in the department in promoting value-based procurement.
We just need to make sure that it is understood and implemented correctly. And what has particularly worried me has been evidence in some early tenders that the attitude is that the assessment of value should be conditional upon the achievement of a pricing threshold. And sometimes the pricing threshold is set at a point where the calculation of potential value is effectively nullified. And if we are serious about understanding value-based pricing, you cannot put in a pricing threshold. You may well attach greater or lesser weight to the pricing element, but not, you can't attach a threshold and believe that you are implementing value-based pricing.
And of course quite often, of course, as part of the value assessment, it looks at exactly the issues of patient experience, the outcomes that are to be achieved, and the long-term life of a product and how it's used in order to arrive at the overall value of the product. Now this is perfectly normal in commercial procurement. It's not, I'm not, I don't think we're talking about something that should be regarded as exceptional to the NHS. It should be something that's regarded as normal procurement and best practice in procurement. And I think there's been a lot of progress.
It's slightly dispiriting in the sense that I've seen an awful lot of progress on procurement in the NHS since 30 years ago I was, I think, working with Unipart before I came into Parliament, working with Unipart in trying to encourage the NHS, for example, to have just-in-time delivery and barcode-based procurement. It's an awfully long time ago. We've progressed a long way.
Speaker 93
And I very much support what the noble Lord, Lord Hunt said about that.
Speaker 90
My Lords, I speak for these benches on this short but very important group. And I'd like to thank the noble Earl, Lord Howe for the amendment on supply chain coordination limited and for the to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath for his very important amendment on value-based procurement. Now, my Lords, these amendments may look technical, but they go to something that matters in every clinic and every operating theatre, and that is how the NHS buys what it needs and who is accountable for when things go wrong. The NHS supply chain manages an estimated 8 billion pounds a year of NHS spending on products. And since 2022, as has been suggested, it's been carried out by the department's PPE sorry, it has carried out the department's PPE program.
Yet under clause 2, its shares can be moved by a transfer scheme at the Secretary of State's discretion. There is no requirement to tell Parliament where they are going, who will exercise the shareholder role or how continuity of supply will be protected. Asking for a plan first seems modest. If the pandemic taught us anything, as the noble Lord, Lord Hunt suggested, it is that supply chain resilience is first and foremost a patient safety issue. But a report is not a safeguard in itself.
The real risk is that the transfer happens in the middle of a reorganization cutting central head count by half. The very people who understand how this company works may be gone before the scheme is made. And the National Audit Office found it was only meeting only seven of its 18 key performance indicators and that trusts spend more than 3 billion pounds outside it. A company with that record needs careful handling, not a transfer done in a rush. And on value-based procurement, we welcome the direction of travel.
And as the noble Lord, Lord Lansley has just pointed out, this is not novel. We don't even have to take his experience in Unipart as an example. If we look at NHS value value-based procurement elsewhere, Denmark, Canada, Italy, and even Indonesia. So there are models which the government could use to look at how it's done. And the national guidance published in June is a genuine step forward, asking what delivers the best outcome across the whole patient pathway rather than simply what is the cheapest price.
But with financial NHS pressures, the temptation will always be to grab the lowest price today without the skill, the capacity, and finance regime that rewards long-term value. So could I ask the noble lady, the minister, what thinking is being done not just for the pilots but as part of the new powers that the Secretary of State will have from the transfer of NHS England on rewarding long-term value in the finance regime? So what changes if any will the government be making to that finance regime?
And there's a wider point actually of both amendments exposed. NHS procurement still sits apart from the rest of the public sector. When the procurement bill passed through this house, my noble friend Baroness Brinton, with support from all sides, including the noble lord Lord Hunt, asked why the NHS should be treated differently. She warned that NHS arrangements were not visible and that they were, in her words, quote, SIs at the discretion of any Secretary of State for Health, end quote. So today we have one regime for healthcare services and another for goods.
NHS buyers are told to take legal advice on how the new value guidance fits both. With NHS England abolished, all of that discretion will now sit with the Secretary of State. And my noble friend's warning has become even more relevant. So I ask the minister four simple questions. First, where will the shares in Supply Chain Coordination Limited go and when, and will Parliament see the plan before the transfer is made?
Secondly, what independent assurance has been commissioned on continuity of supply during the transition? Third, after NHS England's abolition, who will own value-based procurement and make sure that it is built into national service frameworks? And finally, will the government now review whether two separate procurement regimes for NHS services and goods still make sense, or will they at least publish how the boundaries between them will be policed once the Secretary of State holds the pen on both? My lords, these are modest amendments asking for sensible things, and I hope the minister can give the committee reassurance.
Gillian Merron
My lords, I'm most grateful to noble lords for their observations and the way in which they've dealt with this today. I at the outset want to pick up the point that my noble friend Lord Hunt started with and others, including the noble lady Baroness Finlay, developed further, that products are the ones we are particularly concerned with, personal and need to be personalized. And I think that the illustrations that noble lords have given have been most helpful. And that's the reason for the changes, I think, to see more of that. I will with permission address amendments 5 and 211 together, but if I can turn first to amendment 5 in the name of the noble lord Lord Kamall who tabled it and introduced it, and I thank the noble lord, the noble lord Earl Howe.
Amendment 5 does highlight the importance of a clear and managed transition as we move towards the abolition of NHS England. And in answer to one of the key points that the noble lord Earl Howe raised, the intention is for the shareholding in Supply Chain Coordination Limited, which of course we refer to, I'm being very formal, we refer to as the NHS Supply Chain, that shareholding will transfer to the department as part of the wider transition. And the transfer of shares will have no impact on the services delivered by the company, and NHS Supply Chain will continue as it always has to play its role in securing value for money and ensuring resilient supplies for the NHS.
To pick up some of the questions that were raised, the, I mentioned about ensuring that there will be no disruption to storage and supply. The noble Lord Earl Howe particularly raised this. The transfer doesn't in itself alter operational responsibilities or the contractual arrangements, and it will continue, the NHS Supply Chain will continue to provide services through the transitions. And our anticipation is that the current arrangements will remain broadly in place. But as part of the new operating model, there will be consideration given more widely to the efficient and the effective management of shareholdings.
And I heard my noble friend Lord Hunt express concerns about the way that NHS Supply Chain currently operates. And as I said, there will be consideration given to how management can be, management of the operation can be more efficient and effective. And as I said at the outset, I heard very clearly the reasons for that, so I need no persuasion, I think, would be my observation. My noble friend also asked about the commitment to value-based purchasing, which other noble Lords, including the noble Lord Lord Lansley, spoke on positively about. And NHS Supply Chain is fully committed to the adoption of value-based procurement and has moved to a comply or explain model for future frameworks.
NHS Supply Chain, if I could add, also considers the application of pricing threshold approaches on a case-by-case basis, looking at specific market dynamics. The noble Lord Lord Scriven, if I could refer to the strategy of NHS Supply Chain. The strategy does focus on the principles of, and I realise I'm lifting these words, so please bear with me, buying smart, supplying right, and partnering expertly. I'm sure the noble Lord's familiar with that kind of terminology, but I would translate that to prioritising the needs of patients, communities, and outcomes in how we source and how we supply, and that is key. With regard to some of the questions the noble Lord Lord Scriven has risen about, has raised about shares and the plan.
As I said, the NHS Supply Chain will continue, and it is going back to the department, which is where it was indeed before. And I will look at the other very specific points in considering this whole area. But if I can return to the amendment, amendment five. As drafted, the amendment would introduce a new statutory requirement to publish and lay before Parliament a formal report before the shares, the NHS England shares in the NHS Supply Chain can be transferred.
As I've already said, the department did previously exercise that shareholder function and the intention, as I said, is to return to those arrangements and for that reason we would consider the amendment unnecessary. If I can turn to amendment 211, I know and welcome the fact that my noble friend Lord Hunt and the noble lord Lord Lansley and other noble lords have been long-time advocates, as I mentioned, of value-based procurement. And I am grateful to your lordship's house for the ongoing support of this policy. In June, we did deliver on the commitments made in both the 10-year health plan and the life sciences sector plan to publish national guidance for value-based procurement for medical technology. And I very much am somebody who welcomes that that guidance shifted the focus of procurement decisions towards value and, I emphasize this, outcomes for patients, as well as shifting the focus towards the health system and the environment rather than just the lowest cost.
For me, publishing the guidance is just the first step and the department has set out its implementation plans including commissioning independent monitoring and evaluation of the guidance with annual reports over the next three years, which of course will be published on the impact of the guidance. And it is the intention that business as usual means value-based procurement when it comes to NHS procurement teams purchasing medical devices, consumables and services, and our existing reporting arrangements will help to ensure that this is the case.
Howe
My lords, I'm grateful to the noble baroness the minister for her response and to all noble lords who have contributed to this debate. I'm particularly grateful to the noble lord Lord Hunt of Kings Heath for his insights into the performance of NHS supply chain and its current shortcomings. I was also very impressed by his advocacy in favor of value-based procurement, which incidentally I would distinguish from value-based pricing, a policy in relation to which as a former health minister I bear the scars. I very much agree with Lord Scriven that we need reassurance that responsibility for value-based procurement will rest with NHS supply chain with active ministerial support, and I think we heard the necessary reassurance on that from the minister. I admit that the criticisms of NHS supply chain voiced by the noble lord Lord Hunt are ones that I chose to gloss over because, as I said at the outset, my concern was simply to ensure that the abolition of NHS England doesn't disrupt the essential services and systems on which the wider health service depends.
NHS supply chain is an important example of this and we must be confident that its future ownership and governance arrangements are properly considered and that continuity of supply is protected throughout the transition. I was largely reassured by what the minister had to say about this, but I will study her reply carefully. Ultimately, changes to the administration of the NHS must not come at the expense of its ability to deliver care to patients. I hope the government in turn will reflect on the points raised today, but for now I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Richard Faulkner
Is it your lordship's pleasure that amendment 5 be withdrawn?
Amendment 5 is by leave withdrawn. In clause 4, amendment 6, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb on behalf of Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle.
Speaker 95
Thank you. My Lords, I rise to speak to the four amendments in this group in the name of my noble friend Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, and also the noble lady Lady Whitaker, who is ill at the moment and unable to be here, and she asked me particularly to mention that she supports the inequalities 15, 16, and 17 amendments in this group. In amendment 6, a duty of "must have regard to" as currently in clause 4 really isn't much of a duty. We can have regard to many things, but it doesn't mean we'll actually go on and do anything about them. And so I support the amendments in this group that want to strengthen that duty to something where we can see some action.
The aim of this amendment is to strengthen it further and to put improving public health, reducing inequalities, and addressing the social, economic, and environmental determinants of health into the Secretary of State's statutory responsibilities. We talk a great deal about the pressure on the NHS. We talk about waiting lists, hospital capacity, workforce shortages, and the money needed to keep services going, and these are all obviously extremely important. But we also need to ask some more fundamental questions: why are so many people becoming ill in the first place, and why are some people so much more likely to become ill than others? So, as the noble Lord Lord Crisp said in an earlier group, we need to shift our focus from treating sickness to creating health.
Health is not simply a matter of what happens when somebody walks into a GP's surgery or a hospital. It's shaped by conditions in which people are born, grow up, work, and live. It's shaped by whether somebody has a secure home, a decent income, good food, good education, safe working conditions, and clean air to breathe. And these things should make up health policy. Because a person living in a cold, damp home, especially near a busy road, as so many people do here in London, they are more likely to suffer from respiratory problems.
And someone who can't afford nutritious food faces consequences for their lifelong health. And a child growing up in poverty can face disadvantages that will affect their health for the rest of their lives. So this amendment takes all that into account and requires the Secretary of State to take reasonable steps to do something about it. Because here in the UK, those in the most deprived areas can expect to live almost 20 fewer healthy years than those in the least deprived areas. That is a quite staggering statistic.
And prevention won't eliminate the need for hospitals, medicines, or specialist care, but a health service shouldn't just focus on what happens after people become ill. Prevention means more than telling people to make healthier choices. It means making those choices possible. It means tackling food poverty and ensuring people can afford nutritious food. It looks like investing in public health and early intervention.
Because there's not much point in treating the consequences of poverty without addressing the circumstances that make people ill. So what's the point of treating respiratory disease while allowing people in damp homes or to breathe polluted air? Human health and the health of the natural world are connected: clean air and water, access to nature, healthier food systems, and action to prevent us from the effects of the climate crisis are all public health measures.
And as we know, the benefits of a healthy environment aren't shared equally. People on lower incomes are often least able to move away from pollution, poor housing, and unhealthy surroundings. The inequalities we see in health are therefore connected to inequalities in wealth, power, and the quality of the places where people live. I know that the noble lady opposite also spoke about inequalities, and that is a primary pressure on our beloved NHS. And the gap in healthy life expectancy between the most and least advantaged communities is a measure of inequality that the government should actively be trying to reduce.
And a statutory duty will not by itself remove these inequalities, but the wording of a bill does matter. It establishes what the government is required to do rather than merely saying what it would like to do. Going on to amendments 15, 16, and 17, they aim to strengthen the provisions in clause 4 for all communities facing health inequalities. These amendments address three essential requirements: visibility in health data, recognition in decision-making, and accountability for progress. For example, Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller communities experience some of the most severe and persistent health inequalities in England.
They face poorer physical and mental health, barriers to accessing healthcare, and discrimination within healthcare settings. The 2021 census found that Gypsy or Irish Traveller people were more than twice as likely to report bad health or very bad health as the rest of the population of England and Wales overall: 12.5% compared with 5.2%. Nearly one in six reported being disabled and limited a lot in their daily activities by long-term physical or mental health conditions, compared with around one in 13 of the overall population. And research has found that Gypsy or Irish Traveller women in England and Wales are twice as likely to die by suicide as those in the White British women category. Yet a 2020 review by Friends, Families and Travellers found that, of 79 local suicide prevention plans covering 138 areas in England, only five mentioned Gypsy and Traveller communities, and only two included action to address suicide inequality.
So despite the inequalities in health outcomes, the communities' needs are not being consistently identified in national health data or adequately reflected in the planning and delivery of services. Collecting properly disaggregated ethnicity data is essential. Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller communities are not a single homogeneous group, and grouping them together under one category can obscure important differences in their health experiences and outcomes. Data should enable us to understand the distinct experiences of Gypsy, Roma, Irish Traveller, and other communities, rather than masking inequalities within broad categories. More broadly, the same challenges affect other inclusion health groups, including people experiencing homelessness, vulnerable migrants, people in contact with the criminal justice system, and victims of modern slavery.
These groups often experience overlapping disadvantage, social exclusion, and barriers to healthcare. Clause 4 provides an important opportunity to address these inequalities, but as it stands, a general duty to have regard to reducing inequalities in access to health services and health outcomes won't by itself ensure that the people experiencing the greatest inequalities are identified, considered, and supported.
effective in practice. Amendment 15 would require national health data services to collect, analyze and publish data sufficient to identify and monitor these inequalities. Amendment 16 would ensure that the particular barriers facing inclusion health groups are considered when the Secretary of State exercises the health inequalities duty. And Amendment 17 would require annual reporting on progress, including action taken in relation to Gypsy, Roma and Traveller communities. And this is essential for transparency and for accountability.
And these amendments are all complementary. They would help ensure that inclusion health groups are visible in the evidence used to make decisions. They build on existing commitments to reduce health inequalities and they aim to ensure that the system we have is better able to recognize and respond to the needs of these communities. I beg to move.
Richard Faulkner
Amendment proposed, clause 4, page 5, page 3, leave out lines 22 to 29. Amendment proposed, clause 4, page 3, leave out lines 22 to 29 and insert the words printed on the marshalled list. I should advise the committee if this amendment were agreed to, I would not be able to call amendments 7 to 15 for reasons of preemption.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, I think we enter the phase of debate in this bill which I personally consider to be the most crucial part. Why do I consider it to be the most crucial part? It is tackling health inequality is central to the revival, if not the survival, of NHS and the broader economy. So I'll speak mainly to my amendments 7, 13 and 19. But before I do so, I want to say something because I feel strongly about it.
I regret that consultants have decided to go on strike. No doctor should ever, under any circumstances, withdraw their services from the sick and the vulnerable. And I think any doctor, and I hope every doctor in this House, would support that idea. They might have grievances, but they could settle that without going on strike and they should not withdraw services. And I hope the professional bodies, including the Royal Colleges, will align with that comment.
Having said that, my amendment about, my amendments about reducing inequalities are because what we have in the bill just now is a direct transfer of the issue about reducing inequalities from what was in the NHS England's duties and already in the ICB's duties. There is nothing new in the bill about reducing inequalities. That in my own view is a great pity that this opportunity is being missed to this government to put a mark on how to reduce inequality. Why do I say this government? Because in the 30 last years, 30 years, it was only once that we've succeeded in reducing health inequalities.
And that was from 2000 to 2010. A strategy devised by the then Labour government that succeeded on a review, academic review of a proper assessment that demonstrated that both in mortality, infant mortality and ill health, that strategy managed to reduce health inequalities. But we've now come to a point where actually it's rising all the time for all kinds of reasons.
Now who were the people who were responsible at the time? Their names were Alan Milburn, John Reid, now Lord Reid, Yvette Cooper, now Secretary of State for Health, Lord Darzi of Denham, who produced the report on NHS, Andy Burnham, the last Secretary of State in that government, now the Prime Minister. Surely the present government can find people of such caliber who can tackle health inequalities. Or maybe not. So what were the... what was the strategy?
It actually was a cross-governmental public service agreement, so-called PSA. That legally binding framework that government used, the HM Treasury, to... the Treasury for doing spending review process through the spending review process. It was as simple as that. My amendment could be argued that it's too strong. It makes the... it makes the Secretary of State responsible.
And that can't be, I might be... I might be told, because it removes the Secretary of State's autonomy and flexibility. And that's... therefore putting it on the face of the bill is not appropriate. If it's not, then it doesn't make the policy of inequality or a strategy development inappropriate. Because as demonstrated in 2000 and 2010, the then government found a way of a cross-governmental ministerial responsibility where although the strategy was driven based on ill health, all the other ministers were responsible for making sure that their ministries contributed to that improvement in health... reducing health inequality. So if the minister doesn't like my amendment, 19 I think mostly it is, then there might be another ways of government deciding how the same could be achieved through another strategy.
For instance, the same kind of agreement as the government did in 2000 and 2010, or through a Cabinet Secretary responsibility, as the Cabinet Secretary is responsible to making sure all the ministers, different government... the government departments contribute and are mindful of a strategy that reduces health inequality. In my view, if we don't do this and there's no strategy coming forward, then nothing will change. We will be talking the same thing as we've been talking for the last 15 years in this... quoting the same statistics as already been given about the life expectancy going... being reduced in... in disadvantaged population and the time spent unhealthy will increase, infant mortality will go up, the maternal mortality will go up, as is doing now, and all the other things. And I thank the noble Baroness Cass, who might speak after me regarding the child... children's issues, and I also thank Baroness Mansoor, who put her name down to my amendment. My Lords, I hope the minister, in answering, might agree to four things that I might like to ask her.
It's not a question, it's asking her to agree. Agree that health equality and health outcomes are key to overall welfare of the NHS and the broader economy. To agree that now, after two decades, there's not been any improvement. To agree that the improvement occurred was as a result of cross-government strategy.
That health equality driving the increase is being driven ill health in England is rising. And the bill does not have any plans for a Secretary of State or the Minister of Crown in other governments to demonstrate to reducing inequalities.
Hilary Cass
My Lords, I'll be very brief because I'm supporting the amendments of Lord Patel, Baroness Tyler and Lord Hunt, and it won't surprise you yet again to hear that I am planning to focus on children. But as my amendments on inequalities in children come much later in the bill, I will defer to other noble Lords to speak during this group. But I will give you a spoiler alert, which is that the Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health State of State of Child Health report shows that inequalities are widening and particularly in marginalized groups, those who are living in deprived circumstances or minority ethnic groups. And so more of that anon, but meanwhile I defer to my other colleagues.
Claire Tyler
My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow on from the noble lady. As the noble Lord Lord Patel, I think, has already made very clear, this is a very, in my view, a very important group of amendments. It gets to the nub, I think, of what we should be talking about about for the NHS. Quite a few of these amendments, if I'm honest, are calling for quite similar or interconnected things and outcomes, and I don't mind too much how we get there as long as we do get there. But I just want to speak specifically to amendment eight, which is in my name, and I'd like to thank the noble ladies Baroness Royall, Cass and Lister for adding their names.
I also want very briefly to touch on amendments eight to ten in the name of my noble friend Baroness Walmsley, who is sadly is unable to be in her place today and to which my name is added. And then I will also briefly, I hope, speak to amendment fourteen in the name of the noble Lord Patel of Bradford, who also is unable to be in his place and again my name is attached. There are also other very important amendments in this group to which I'm very sympathetic and of course particularly of course the amendment twenty in the name of my noble friend Baroness Pidgeon. I think the case is well known and has been well made already, so I'll just say about why tackling health inequalities more effectively is so important. Just very briefly, all the research shows that the nation's health is under real strain.
Analysis of healthy life expectancy internationally shows sadly that we are falling behind. We now have an eighteen-year gap in life expectancy between different postcodes in the UK. And of course, it's not just about health, important as that is to individuals, it's also about economics or what I like to call wellbeing economics. A nation cannot prosper whilst large parts of its population are having their lives cut short and whilst in most deprived communities are on average living only fifty-two years in good health. And the number of people with a work-limiting health condition is rising, and poor health amongst young people is one of the drivers of the increasing number of sixteen to twenty-four-year-olds who are NEET, not in education, employment or training.
But before we get too despondent, if you flip it on its head, the good news is there is real potential for what I'd like to call health-enabled growth. Modeling by the Health Foundation suggests that just returning to 2014 levels of health would see six hundred thousand people back in work, GDP grow by two percent and save the Treasury seventy billion nationally.
So, my Lords, I think we all understand that health inequalities are not simply driven by how the NHS functions and operates, but by wider social, economic, and environmental factors, including poverty, poor quality housing, lack of green space, poor working conditions, and barriers to accessing affordable and nutritious food. And I know if she was here, my noble friend Baroness Walmsley would really want to emphasize that. Now, as others have already pointed out, there is a real opportunity now in this bill. I think the noble Lord Lord Patel made this point very strongly, to place a stronger duty on the Secretary of State to improve health and reduce health inequalities. And that, but that needs to be supported by a statutory framework for coordinated cross-government action and accountability.
It's an overall package we need, if you like. And I think that coupled with consistent joint working at national and local level, this could really support the shift I think we all want to see from sickness to prevention. It's in the 10-year plan and indeed the devolution agenda. So turning now to amendments 8, 9, and 10 in the name of my noble friend Baroness Walmsley. Clause 4 in the bill currently only transfers existing duties on NHS England to the Secretary of State regarding equity in access and outcomes from healthcare services.
The clause does not strengthen these duties in any way or address the wider determinants of health across government, as we've already been discussing. And I do think this really is a missed opportunity and why Baroness Walmsley's amendment number 8 is so important. It would strengthen the Secretary of State's duty as to reducing health inequalities from a duty to have regard to the need to reduce them to a duty to actually take steps to achieve their reduction. So, you know, it's about actually taking action that's going to make the difference. And Baroness Walmsley's amendments 9 and 10, I think, are simply consequentials on this, so I won't go into any detail there.
But what I would say, my final point on amendment 8, is a stronger health inequalities duty would send a signal, I think, to the Secretary of State and all ministers that Parliament expects them to actively take steps to prioritize prevention alongside treatment rather than just have regard to it. And now turning to my amendment number 18. This is about requiring the Secretary of State to produce a health inequalities strategy and to have an annual report to Parliament on it. It is similar, indeed, to the noble Lord Lord Patel's amendment number 19, but I've been a bit more generous and Lord Patel gave six months, I'm suggesting a year here. And I think the need for the strategy, such a strategy, actually was very well debated in the other place recently during the passage of the bill and indeed by the Health and Social Care Select Committee.
They both found that just changing a duty is, although it's important, it's necessary, it's not sufficient for achieving the goals I think we all want to see.
What's needed is action across government, both nationally and locally. And it actually took me back to my days, it's a very long time ago now, but when I was director of the Social Exclusion Unit in government, I remember seeing how central coordination can support cross-government working on what you might call those wicked cross-cutting issues like homelessness and indeed health inequality and other things and really, really start to make a difference. And my Lords, I think there was a time when strategies were slightly out of fashion. But maybe, you know, times do change. We have seen a recent strategy on women's health and child poverty.
And I know, and I'm very, very pleased that the minister, the noble lady the minister is herself developing a mental health strategy. It's something I'm very, very much looking forward to. So I think perhaps the time has come now for a cross-government health inequality strategy with the proper parliamentary accountability built in. And I'll just finish by talking briefly about amendment 14. I was pleased to put my name to this amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, and the noble Lord, Lord Hunt has also added his name.
I know if the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford had been here, he would have set out very cogently the absolutely compelling case for recognizing coastal health inequalities. And I do want to acknowledge his outstanding work here. But I just want to focus very briefly on the consequences for prevention, mental health, and young people. My Lords, the difficulties facing coastal communities are not confined to the prevalence of illness. They reflect a combination of poorer health, economic disadvantage, restricted access to services, limited transport, and in many places fewer opportunities for young people.
And of course these factors compound one another. And poor access to prevention and early intervention can allow ill health to become more serious. And as I said at the beginning, long-term illness can then push people out of employment. So economic inactivity and financial insecurity can worsen health and well-being and it's just a vicious cycle. And I just want to mention to conclude mental health, which I think needs to be really front and center of any response.
Many coastal communities face particular challenges in accessing timely mental health support, particularly for children and young people. And in places where transport's difficult and specialist services can be, you know, many miles away, access to early intervention can become a serious problem. And it's absolutely acute when it comes to suicide prevention. My Lords, the relationship between mental health, isolation, economic insecurity, and access to services is just so important in these communities when support is difficult to reach. I'm sure if the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford had been here, he'd have put it far better than I can, but I just want to conclude by saying that this amendment would ensure that in exercising health service functions, the Secretary of State has specific regard to reducing inequalities between coastal and inland communities, particularly in prevention, planning, and commissioning and the health workforce.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, first of all, can I say that I thought Baroness Tyler and noble Lord Patel made some very important points about cross-government working. And I was thinking back to what Lord Patel said about basically what started under Tony Blair was continued under Gordon Brown.
I think it was backed up by one specific cabinet committee which underpinned the inequalities work and secondly by what were called PSA targets which tied different departments in. And I think that was a very good mechanism. I would though say in defense of government is that the most important work that is being undertaken in relation to health inequality by Alan Milburn and working with different government departments is going to be pivotal because it embraces my Lords the terrible outcomes for so many people come under the NEET category but it also is looking at the really dreadful mental health support for children and adolescents which of course goes to the heart of many of these issues. And I think if we can pull this off then we can really start to achieve some of the equality issues that we've been talking about. Secondly my Lords, like the Baroness Tyler, I'm here to just say a few words about coastal health because Lord Patel of Bradford told us we must do.
What I would say is two things really. I mean the Chief Medical Officer five years ago devoted his 2001 annual report to health in coastal communities. He identified high levels of poor physical and mental health, an aging population with increasingly complex needs and serious challenges in recruiting and retaining the healthcare workforce. And Lord Patel basically has three asks which I just want to reinforce what Baroness Tyler said. Basically we've no strategy five years after the CMO's report.
Will the government publish a substantive account of progress against his recommendation? Second, how will the government ensure that coastal populations are separately identified because unless you do it you don't have the data in which then to plan and strategize and actually see whether improvements can be made. And thirdly would the department work across government to develop and test commissioning prevention and workforce models suited to the distinctive geography and needs of coastal communities. And I think my Lords I'd be very grateful if my noble friend would perhaps agree to meet with Lord Patel of Bradford to just discuss this further because I think this is a very important consideration. So my Lords my amendment 11 is related to the terrible distribution of GPs in England that we currently have and to ask for a much more equitable distribution.
And I'm very grateful to Baroness Gerada, Baroness Hodgson and Baroness Mansoor for their support. I also was very fortunate to have a meeting with Minister Dame Diana Johnson and her officials last week which I found extremely helpful and I was grateful to her officials too for the way they've been prepared to communicate on this. So my Lords this morning the RCGP published a report on the state of general practice 2026 and chapter four of that report is about fair and sustainable general practice care, equitable care, and makes clear that action is needed. And one area where I believe we need action is what Lord Darzi described as the huge and unwarranted variations in the number of patients per GP. And data from the NHS general practice workforce team shows that national average list size of fully qualified full-time equivalent GPs hovers around 2,200 patients.
John Gooderham, a retired civil servant who once worked for me actually, undertook a number crunching exercise showing the differences in average list sizes is almost unbelievable. So his evidence which was published by the Institute of Health and Social Care Management showed that at least 20 areas with average list size ranging from 8,300 to 4,400 patients. That's almost four times as many as the national average. And my Lords all of them are clearly severely under-doctored. At the other end of the scale there are 20 areas with average list size ranging from 1,000 to 1,144 patients.
The trouble is there's no, there doesn't seem to be any approach or system to rectify this. We used to have the Medical Practices Committee which was set up by Nye Bevan in the '46 Act and lasted until 2001. And there I've got to confess, I took through the legislation abolishing the MPC. I mean, mea culpa, my Lords. It was a mistake.
At the time, the line that I took, because I looked it up, was that area health authorities would sort it all out. Where are area health authorities, I ask? But they didn't, and none of their successors has. And so I think, my Lords, we need to go back to a system that really does identify areas that are over- or under-doctored, to consider how we can really justify this situation. It cannot, my Lords, I think, be allowed to continue.
I know that the officials feel that the kind of MPC system we had would not fit, is not fit for today's more modern circumstances. But I think, my Lords, one way or another, either through financial incentives or through some restrictions, we've got to do something about this, and I hope the government will be sympathetic.
Speaker 70
Can I say that from where I stand, and many of you will know that I'm passionate about improving health of all. The National Health Service is the National Health Service, not the ill service. And so many of disadvantaged, marginalized groups are not receiving the care or the health that they need. And I won't go back into the disparities and the health inequalities. Lord, I've added my name to Lord Patel's amendment, and he has spoken very clearly, and a very simple amendment, but such a very pivotal and key amendment to this bill.
I also support Lord Hunt's amendment, because without having that first line of defense with GPs, then these marginalized groups don't have the access of doctors that they desperately need. Everybody knows the effects of the inequalities both on the economy, on the NHS, and indeed on the individuals on themselves. And I think the government has got a great opportunity to actually enhance the power that the Secretary of State has got and strengthen it rather than transfer the current power. I, as I indicated earlier, in my region, we did have the duty to bring down the inequalities in a very deprived area. And I did work very closely with Alan Milburn and other ministers, including the then Prime Minister Tony Blair.
And it did work. There were, when you put that key emphasis and key monitoring in place, and that key duty, that key strategy. But we do need a strategy, and we do need a health strategy as Lord Patel indicated. So I leave the question on the table for the government to say this is a fantastic opportunity. It's not about all the structural change that we've been talking about previously.
This is about making a real difference to people's lives and to the health of our nation.
Clare Gerada
I rise to support amendments 11, 14 in the names of Lord Hunt and Lord Patel of Bradford, who also asked me to speak to his amendment.
First I'd just like to say that I find it helpful and listening to this debate even more helpful to separate out health inequalities and healthcare inequalities. And health inequalities are due to the social determinants of ill health as we've heard so housing, employment and the like and those certainly do require cross-government involvement to address. And if we think about the lowering of the unwanted teenage pregnancy rate which was a fabulous cross-government initiative that had fabulous outcomes. And healthcare inequalities are due to the distribution of healthcare services which is what I'm going to address. But I get very confused if I don't separate out those two and I think sometimes we get in a muddle because it is not for the NHS to deal with housing even I take the point about Bromley-by-Bow but the NHS is there to deal with health, ill health, prevention etc.
Of course it should be involved in cross-government. But let me say I want to start with a GP. In 1971 Julian Tudor Hart, a fabulous Welsh GP who worked in a mining village in South Wales wrote a pivotal paper in the Lancet. And in it he described what he called the inverse care law: the availability of good medical care tends to vary inversely with the need for it. So put simply those who need care are least likely to receive it.
That was 50 years ago and I'd love to tell the House that that's now a historical curiosity but it is not. And if anything it's getting worse. And I want to talk about two particular places where we see that most clearly: one is general practice and the other is our coastal towns. So let me start with general practice. So Lord Hunt has already given some figures and I'm going to highlight a few more into why it's so important to have an equitable distribution of general practitioners.
And I would say many of the indices of ill health I would say are due to the drop in numbers of GPs and if you want to debate with me about that I can show that there is an absolute line towards that. So as Lord Hunt said the Royal College of General Practitioners published for the first time they've ever done it the State of General Practice report this week. And we have to take their findings very seriously if we're going to address our population's need. Just one figure to pull out from the report which Lord Hunt mentioned is that as of last month, so September 2026, there were only 36 more of full-time equivalent GPs than they were in September last year. So slightly better than when I made my talk in the second reading but not that much.
Now in the same period the BMA, British Medical Association data showed that the number of hospital doctors has grown by nearly 50%. And these figures are reflected in the number of patients GPs care for such that the average number of patients per full-time GP has gone up by 12% and at the same time and according to data in the British Medical Journal the number of patients per consultant has fallen by 18%. Now GPs are doing their best to meet the demand, okay? And over the last 12 months approximately 388 million appointments were carried out in general practice by the whole team but largely by GPs. 45% of them were booked for the same day, 82% within two weeks and 60% of appointments were face-to-face and that excludes home visits.
And that is tens of millions of appointments more than before the pandemic. Now the government has rightly said that care should move out of hospital into the community. But we have moved the patients without moving the resources. So it's perhaps not a surprise that the Royal College of GP survey showed that three-quarters of GPs say their workload is compromising patient safety and the GPs themselves have the highest burnout rates of all the professional groups.
And here is the part I find difficult to understand. We now have, thanks to government initiatives, over 5,000 doctors in general practice training, the highest now for years. But the BMA analysis shows that half of those who finished training between 2018 and 2024 were not working in a GP practice a year later. It's not that the practices don't want them, they just can't afford to employ them. My Lords, this is the contradiction at the heart of the problem.
Demand is rising, yet the workforce has not kept pace. And as Tudor Hart would have predicted, those who lose out most are those in most need. According to the Health Foundation, after accounting for increased workload and higher health needs in poorer communities, practices in deprived communities receive roughly 7 to 10% less funding than those in the affluent areas. And I now know in a way where that's come from, thank you Lord Hunt. We are not just failing to tilt the playing field towards needs, we are tilting it the wrong way.
This is the case for amendment 11. If we are serious about reducing healthcare inequalities, general practice distribution must reflect the population's needs. Which brings me to the amendment 14. And as we've heard, the Chief Medical Officer's report on coastal communities found that those living in seaside areas have shorter lives and spend more of those lives, those years in poor health. We've also heard about the challenges that they have: poor transport, geographic isolation, older population.
Now you might expect that the health service to send more staff to areas with higher levels of illness, such as coastal areas. But my Lords, too often it's the opposite. In Hastings, lovely place, for example, each GP cares for more than 3,700 patients, the highest number in England. In Kingston upon Hull, again a lovely place, there is roughly one GP every 3,000 patients. In Kingston upon Thames, it's roughly 1,900.
Similar name, very different experience. And the GPs and nurses who work in those places describe it vividly. In Skegness, an area where I spent many of my childhood holidays, staff told researchers about constant firefighting, burnout, isolation, and about patients who couldn't get their appointments because of poor transport. And the problem extends beyond general practitioners to community nursing, where recruitment and pay parity have fallen even greater than for GPs. The evidence is clear.
Reducing healthcare inequalities requires services and workforce planning to reflect the needs of the communities they serve. That is why amendment 14 matters. It would place explicitly, it would explicitly place the need to reduce healthcare inequalities between coastal and inland communities within the Secretary of State's duties under the bill. Funding must reflect the health needs of the population, not merely the number of patients on a practice list. As care moves out of hospital and into the community, staff and resources must move with it.
These amendments are not seeking preferential treatment for GPs, they are seeking fair treatment according to need. And robust evidence spanning more than 50 years shows that more GPs per head of the population means better health outcomes, fewer premature deaths, a better patient experience, more preventative work, and lower cost to the NHS.
I hope the Minister will recognize that these amendments would give practical effect to the Bill's ambitions to reduce healthcare inequalities. My Lords, the inverse care law was identified 50 years ago. We should not accept that this remains patients' experience today. They did not choose to live in the deep end, but we can choose whether to leave them there.
Speaker 99
I too put my name to amendment 11 and I don't want to repeat everything the noble Lord Hunt and Baroness Gerada have said, but it is so important that people have access to a GP. And too often we hear that people cannot get in to see their GP. And this is one reason that A&E departments in hospitals are becoming overwhelmed because people then go there. I too am concerned that GPs are being asked to see far too many patients and many patients can't just be dealt with in 10 minutes. And the stress of all this is creating burnout for doctors at GPs as we've heard.
So please can we ensure that everyone has access to their GP without having to wait weeks or fight with the receptionist. And patients need continuity of care. We all know that when GPs know their patients, the outcomes are hugely better. I'm not medical, but it's common sense that if a patient can get in to see a GP quickly, often things can be resolved sooner and conditions picked up early, making treatment easier. We need to ensure equality of access.
And if we can get the GP system functioning better everywhere, this will lead to helping deal with some of the enormous strain that's in other parts of the healthcare system at the moment.
Speaker 88
My Lords, I'm very pleased to support many of the amendments in this group and I absolutely acknowledge that there is a difference between health inequalities and healthcare inequalities, but both need to be addressed. And I shout out to my own GP practice, which is Chatfield Health Centre, and they are utterly brilliant and it's a very sort of mixed economy that they are serving. The noble Lord, Lord Patel, rightly said in my view that unless we address the issues pertaining to inequalities, then the survival or the healthy survival of the NHS is in question. And currently I do not think that we're in a fit state to address the inequalities and this Bill is a golden opportunity to do that and we absolutely must. My Lords, I go back to the Labour manifesto of 2024, which included a fairer Britain where everyone lives longer with a shift to prevention and to halve the gap in HLE between richest and poorest regions through tackling the social determinants of health.
This was followed up by the 10-year plan, both of which have got an excellent vision, but I fear that too often short-term pressures hinder long-term plans. I regret, for example, that the mission delivery unit was disbanded and that long-term prevention no longer seems to be prioritized. That's why I think it's crucial that in this Bill we strengthen the duties on health inequalities. I welcome the government's devolution agenda about which we hear so much, including the English Communities and Devolution Act that we passed earlier this year and the strong duty on strategic authorities in that Act to improve health and tackle health inequalities. The amendments before us today would place the equivalent duty on the Secretary of State for Health with a requirement that ministers across government have got regard to them.
I agree that health inequalities should be addressed locally and that devolved power to strategic authorities and local authorities will help enable those who are well placed to address the wider determinants.
However, in a devolution-first world, the responsibilities and the budgets of Whitehall departments mean that central government has got a pivotal role and responsibility in addressing the many policies which have a profound impact on health that have been mentioned in this debate. Your Lordships supported and achieved parity of esteem for mental health, and the duty before us today would create a parity of esteem for prevention, and it would be embedded as a shared goal across national, regional, and local government. It's crucial. The government has made great progress in some areas like smoke-free generation or ending the two-child limit. These changes will have a long-term benefit for health and reducing inequalities, but they do not represent a strategic across-government approach.
In other areas, there've been good ambitions such as the healthy food standard, but implementation has been slow and there've been loopholes. Such a patchy approach will not achieve health in all policies and will allow inequalities to keep widening. The approach must be across government. As the noble Lord Patel and my noble friend Lord Hunt said earlier, 2000 to 2010 we made great progress thanks to that cross-government approach. Indeed, the Prime Minister himself, he was part of that government of course, and in 2010 he launched the Marmot Review as Secretary of State, and subsequently he made Greater Manchester the first Marmot city region.
He has pledged to tackle regional inequality for good growth in every postcode, as we know, and also to rewire the state in favour of prevention. We've heard many facts and figures today which demonstrate that this pledge must become a reality if our country is to fulfil its potential. I pay tribute in passing to Sir Michael Marmot, who I think his work is transformatory. My noble friend might well speak of additional burdens, but she herself tabled amendments to the last Health and Social Care Act 2022 requiring consultation and regular planning and reporting on health and social care workforce. These amendments take a similar approach.
They do not create a lot of processes. In fact, they codify what ministers have already committed to but is too often deprioritised. There are several precedents for creating accountability frameworks for cross-government agendas that are much more cumbersome, I would say, for example, Climate Change Act, Child Poverty Act, not that they're not important, they certainly are. My noble friend has certainly been in listening mode, and it's a pleasure to have interacted with her in so many meetings. And I would strongly urge her not just to listen to the arguments made this afternoon, but to act and to amend the bill so that we do have a duty to address inequality and it's done on a cross-departmental basis.
And then we'll have a... it will make such a difference to the life, the health of the citizens of our country and consequently to the economics of our country.
Speaker 73
It's an honour to follow my noble friend Baroness Royal. I rise to support the amendment by Baroness Tyler, amendment 18, to publish a cross-governmental strategy to reduce health inequalities in England. This debate has been extremely humanitarian is what I would describe because addressing health inequalities is a matter of social justice and human dignity.
My Lords, health is not created in hospitals or GP clinics. It's created in homes, workplaces, and in our communities. And if we want to fix health, which is so fundamental, as Sir Martin Luther King said, of all forms of inequality, it is health inequality which is injustice and inequality in health is the most shocking and the most inhuman. That is what we are talking about, addressing something that is of humanitarian nature, addressing health inequalities around our country. And I know my noble, the noble Baroness Mansoor said about NHS being criticized, I mean NHS has often been criticized as not a National Health Service but a National Sickness Service.
And if we really want to transform our NHS to become a National Health Service, we have to address health inequalities, which don't lie within hospitals or clinics, but in our society and social determinants of health. I declare an interest as the founder and trustee of the charity Health Equality Foundation, which works in this area, and also I have had the honor of working with Sir Michael Marmot in helping with addressing social determinants of health. One of the greatest challenges we face is this nearly 20-year gap in healthy life expectancy, and this cannot be addressed by one department alone, not simply by hospitals. Like the child poverty strategy, we need a whole government approach to tackling the wider determinants of health, where we're born, how we live, and the conditions in which we grow up, which account for 80% of health outcomes. After having served in the NHS for nearly 40 years and over 30 years as an NHS consultant, I have seen firsthand that I was treating the consequences of inequality, but I wasn't able to address the causes of inequality.
And to address that, we have a huge opportunity, and I welcome the government's commitment, the manifesto commitment as my noble friend Baroness Royal said, and the 10-year plan commitment to address health inequalities around our country. And that has never been stronger, not that I know previous health bills well, but it has never been stronger, the commitment to address health inequalities. The economic case is as compelling as the moral one. If the North of England achieved the same health outcomes as the rest of the country, it could add 18.4 billion to our economy each year. Poor health reduces productivity.
It increases welfare spending and constrains growth. And we know if we want good growth in every postcode, we need good health in every postcode, not just good healthcare in every postcode, which is absolutely essential as we all know. I support, critically why I support this amendment by Baroness Tyler, is the need for cross-government strategy. And I have actually previously spoken in this chamber about the need for cross-government task force or a board, and also written about that. So I believe it's a cross-government strategy and also a task force needed to address our health inequalities.
And that task force would go beyond this to tackle wider and general determinants of health. And if we want to seriously address this, we must have a cross-government strategy. I recognize the important work already being undertaken by the government in this bill and the 10-year health plan. But given so many of the underlying causes of poor health as they sit outside our health service, has my noble friend the Minister given any consideration to developing the cross-government strategy and potentially also a task force similar to the one as in child poverty strategy to address the wider determinants of health? And are there any lessons from that approach that could be applied to tackling wider health inequalities?
Speaker 101
Honored to follow the noble, my noble friend Lady Norgrove. I've added my name to a number of the amendments in this group, clearly calling for a clear duty on the Secretary of State to take action to reduce health inequalities and produce a cross-government health inequality strategy. I'm also supportive of the other amendments on this theme, including that in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle. As we've heard, her amendment makes specific reference to inclusive health groups, including Gypsy, Roma, and traveler communities, who experience some of the poorest health outcomes of any group in England, as the noble Baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb spells out. As Just Fair points out, there is a right to health under the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights.
In its 2025 concluding observations, the UN Committee on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights raised a number of concerns about the provision of health services in the UK, including inequalities in access to care, as we've heard about. At second reading, I and a number of other noble Lords spoke in favor of a clear duty on the Secretary of State to tackle health inequalities and of a cross-government health inequality strategy that would underpin the preventative approach that the government rightly initially favored, and indeed that the Chancellor referred to in his budget speech today. Our interventions reflected calls from a wide range of health and other bodies, many of whom are supporting Health Equals campaign to put tackling health inequalities on a statutory footing and to reboot the government's emphasis on a preventative approach. It also reflected the position of the Health and Social Care Committee in their scrutiny report on the bill. The government themselves have emphasized the importance of addressing health inequalities in their child poverty strategy, as I pointed out at second reading.
Indeed, the strategy declares that addressing healthcare inequality is at the heart of their health mission. Moreover, in September, the Minister for Women and Equalities, in announcing the establishment of a new class unit, described it as a pivotal step in embedding a focus on socioeconomic inequality into the heart of government as part of their drive to tackle entrenched inequality. Given all that government ministers have said about inequalities, I'm therefore puzzled as to why they seem so reluctant to translate this commitment to tackle entrenched inequality into a statutory duty in this key piece of legislation. In the Commons, Minister Smith failed to give a convincing explanation as to how mere empowerment is more effective than a duty to address health inequalities, which she herself said remains a government priority. But my Lords, it might not be a priority for a future government, so warm words are not enough.
And in the second reading debate in your Lordships' House, my noble friend the minister reiterated the government's commitment to working for greater equality, but did not engage with the arguments put by a number of us and explain why a power is better than a duty to achieve this.
I therefore hope that she has been able to reflect on what was said and on the growing pile of evidence of health inequalities, especially among children, some of which we've heard about today, and that today she will be able to respond more positively and commit to bringing forward a government amendment at report that meets the objectives of the various amendments debated today.
Andrew Lansley
I think I may be the first speaker not to have signed any of these amendments. It doesn't mean I don't agree with them. I think there's been a great deal that has been said with which I agree, and the importance of this debate, I think, can hardly be overstated. What I just want to contribute one thought if I may, which is that in taking all of these issues and understanding how it relates to this bill, we have to put it in the context of what is already in the National Health Service Act. So I just want to very quickly outline that.
The bill that we see before us is, in my view, an improvement on what is in the NHS Act as far as the Secretary of State's duties are concerned, because it extends the duty from not just equal access to healthcare services and facilities, but seeking to reduce inequalities and secure equity in outcomes from healthcare services. That's what's in the bill. I think that's a significant improvement. The bill focuses at this point on what it is that the health service, the National Health Service, is doing to secure the prevention of illness and the promotion of successful treatment. It isn't about the improvement of public health at that point.
So let's look at the NHS Act. The NHS Act also has, I might say just by way of Baroness Tyler of Enfield was talking about this transferring a duty to the Secretary of State. In fact, actually, the NHS Act has the same duty on the Secretary of State and on NHS England. They're concurrent duties. So in fact, we're not transferring the duty.
This isn't part of a transfer from NHS England to the Secretary of State. In the NHS Act at sections 2A, the Secretary of State has a duty for the protection of public health, which are all those things to do with vaccination, immunization, etc., etc. At section 2B in the NHS Act, which was inserted by the 2012 legislation, as my noble friend on the front bench will be recalling, inserted into the NHS Act a duty as to the improvement of public health, and that is on both local authorities and on the Secretary of State. It's not, I think, phrased as we would want it to be. There's more that needs to be done to look at that.
But I would just suggest, and this picks up the point that I think noble lady Baroness Royall of Blaisdon was talking about, when we talk about the wider determinants of health, we are looking at a strategy that not only relates to the Secretary of State, i.e. to the government, but relates to local authorities, and she made that point very rightly. But it is in the Act. It's in the NHS Act. Both the local authorities have a duty to improve public health in their area and take such appropriate steps as they can to achieve that, and the Secretary of State has such a duty to improve public health in section 2B of the NHS Act, unaffected as I understand it by this bill.
So when we come to look at it at report, I hope those who are thinking about how we create the right strategy for the improvement of public health don't think that it's just done by attaching it to the responsibilities of the Secretary of State in relation to the NHS, but also look at section 2B.
Speaker 88
I'm grateful to the noble Lord for giving way. I recently read section 2B of the NHS Act. I think one would find that local government and strategic authorities must improve health and reduce inequalities, but the Secretary of State only may improve health. I think that's a very interesting to look at, and I think that perhaps something that we need, that's a wrong which I think we ought to right.
Andrew Lansley
The noble lady is absolutely right. Yes, local authorities must take such steps as they consider appropriate, the Secretary of State may take such steps as the Secretary of State considers appropriate. I think I was right in saying, and she's illustrated it, we can improve what is in section 2B. I would just make the point, when we come to report, I think it is really necessary not only to look at what is in this bill, but to look at how the improvement of public health is promoted through the NHS Act, including sections 2A and 2B.
Speaker 68
It's intent by and large to follow always to follow the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, when I make a remark to your Lordships' House. And I'm not going to go into the reasons about health inequalities and inequalities because they've been spoken very more very adequately by the noble Lord, Lord Patel, my noble friend Baroness Royal, Lord Hunt, and indeed my friend Baroness Nagund. But I want to say something about social care because actually, whilst the noble Lord, Lord Lansley is quite right about public health and the need for prevention, none of this is going to work, and I make no apologies for saying it and I will keep saying it, none of this is going to be delivered, the 10-year plan, integrated care, unless we also address the issues of social care inequalities. And as chair of the Social Care Institute for Excellence, you would be expecting me to talk about that. We recently did research which has been published, which was about the inequities experienced by people who are experiencing social care.
And I just thought it might be useful just to make just to remind the House what this said, because it will sound very familiar when we're talking about health inequalities. The policy and practice implications reflected in the participants, and this was about people with lived experience because our work in SCIE is based on people with lived experience and co-production. A named point of contact to help them navigate a complex system. Better continuity of carers to improve the quality of care and reduce the burden of having to explain one's needs time and again. Clearer and more proactive information to ensure everybody is aware of their entitlements.
Investment in the workforce to encourage greater professionalism and retention. More consistent provision across areas to reduce postcode lottery. Well, my Lords, we could be talking about the inequalities that we've just been debating. The same applies in social care. So the reassurance I'd like to seek from my noble friend the Minister is that that will be recognized as we go through this legislation.
Andrew Mawson
My Lords, I find this a very interesting debate, and I'm very sympathetic to Baroness Bennett's amendment, and particularly to Lord Patel, because I think he's right that actually very little is being learned.
And my colleagues and I over the years have listened to lots of conversations about health inequalities. And when you spend your life in very challenging housing estates and see very little changing, you know the distance between all the words and the practice. And it's why many years ago we decided to focus on practice and the doing of things rather than the talking about things. And we began to realize what every parent knows, actually, that you only really learn by doing. And actually, when I started to work with GPs originally in East London, they began to tell me that that's how you became a GP.
You heard one, you did one, and then you taught one. It's a very practical matter. And actually, business and entrepreneurs nowadays know, business and entrepreneurs know that you learn by doing things. Yet actually in the state, which often feels so out of date, and the NHS, that actually there isn't a learning-by-doing culture, actually. There's a learning by writing very fine reports at 60,000 feet often that seems very unengaged with practice.
Over the years, it's been very interesting to observe what happened through practice. The Bromley-by-Bow model is well known, so I won't use it. But Earl Howe knows that I also was responsible for the transformation of a street following a murder and 10,000 illegal injections being given out in a housing estate with some terrible violent circumstances going on at the time. And actually, it was when I brought the first key people on those streets together, all of them, the GP, the school, the housing association, were saying, "We cannot deal with this on our own." "We need to do it together."
These things are so interconnected. And we built together the St Paul's Way transformation project, which started with nothing and led to a new £40 million school, £16 million health center, 600 homes, now a new primary school, joined it up. And Professor Brian Cox and I led our 14th science summer school in June this year with a masterclass at the end of it on quantum physics with the children, same housing estate, same children, same families, now one of the best performing schools in Tower Hamlets. Earl Howe actually helped us greatly at one key point, learning by doing, when he met the whole group, actually, housing, health, education, when the NHS was getting in the way of us completing on the deal on the health center, and was very helpful in enabling that to actually happen. It was actually Duncan Selbie, the chief executive of Public Health England in 2015, that gave me £20 million and said, "Andrew, take this culture that you've been developing into the north of England."
We built 10 learning-by-doing innovation platforms, actually, in Rotherham and Bradford and Doncaster and Bootle. All of which was about bringing people together to learn about these matters. It was very interesting when I went and met the public health officials in each of these places, lovely people quoting all the same data I've heard many, many times before. When I then said to them, "What are you actually going to do about that data?", there was absolute silence. It wasn't their fault.
They did not have the skills to know how to turn fine words into practice in some of the most challenging communities in this country. My Lords, it is my view that one of the things that is being missed in this moment is this real serious need to get real about innovation and learning by doing. My colleagues and I, and I declare my interest at the moment, are creating at place, on the ground, with local people and professionals, what we call these learning-by-doing innovation platforms, so that actually you bring together actually the GP and actually the business person and actually the local resident, and you begin to explore these issues together. Because in the modern world, health is everybody's business.
It is not just a matter for GPs, actually. It is interconnected and we need to explore what that means. And my concern about where we're at at the moment in this discussion and this bill, which is a fantastic opportunity for this government, actually, and for this country, to move into a form of health that is this century and not last century, is we're going to end up building a lot of biomedical boxes around this country that do not explore these interfaces in some of our most challenging communities in this country. My Lords, Lord Patel is right, and we need to worry about why he is right and why things are not being learned. I finish with the thought, it is our experience over the years that sadly we have to say that in so many respects the NHS is not a learning organisation.
We must have hosted 70 government ministers over the years to our work. They all come and say, "Wow, this is fantastic, we need to do more of it." I can name the four who did anything practical about that, and the 66 sit on a list in this pocket. It's not to do with bad people. It's about whether as a nation we are now going to get upstream into prevention and health creation and create a learning-by-doing environment in which we all learn together and in which local people are part of all of that process.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, this is a very important group of amendments and has been a really, really excellent debate. One of the most pressing issues facing us is the widening gap in health outcomes between different communities, and healthy life expectancy has fallen in recent years and the gap between the most and least deprived areas of England, as we've heard, now stands at around 20 years. I thought a point made earlier by Lord Crisp, talking about the role of the department as leadership for health across government, not just running the NHS, is really important as we approach this group of amendments. And we've heard quite clearly the current legislative framework places relatively weak duties on government to address these wider determinants of health and tackle inequalities. The House of Commons Health and Social Care Select Committee in its scrutiny of this bill called for stronger focus on improving the nation's health and tackling inequality, emphasizing the need for clearer accountability and a more robust approach to prevention across government.
And many of the amendments in this group would help achieve that aim by ensuring that reducing health inequalities becomes a central objective of health policy and that progress is measured and reported transparently. Now, my noble friend Baroness Walmsley's amendments, spoken to by my noble friend Baroness Tyler, and Lord Patel's amendment seven, strengthen the duty on the Secretary of State to take steps or action rather than simply have regards to, really important. And Lord Patel of Bradford's amendment 14, supported by so many members of the House today, would require the Secretary of State to have specific regard to reducing inequalities for coastal communities. And the point has been made really clearly of the added complexities for such communities, whether it's workforce-related or local service provision. These are really important.
My amendment 20 in this group looks at health inequalities in urban areas and requests a strategy and annual report. Now, Impact on Urban Health, which is part of Guy's and St Thomas's Foundation, recently reported their state of urban health research and found that preventable mortality is 2.7 times higher in the most deprived urban neighborhoods in England than in the least deprived.
So urban areas also face some of England's starkest health inequalities, with people living just streets apart experiencing significant differences in health. And you've only got to look over the river in the London Borough of Lambeth, where Impact on Urban Health is actually based. Females living just over one mile apart face an eight-year gap in life expectancy. So these inequalities are driven by unfair and avoidable differences in everyday environments, as we've heard, including exposure to air pollution, differences in housing quality, and access to healthy, affordable food. So I pulled this area out for specific attention, rather like the coastal communities amendment.
They both need specific actions. Now, my noble friend Baroness Tyler spoke strongly to amendment 18, which requires a cross-government health inequality strategy and then annual reports to Parliament on progress. And in my mind, that would focus minds and energy across government and would address the key point from the Health and Social Care Select Committee and actually many of our suggestions in amendments and the debate we've had today. But if we are serious about narrowing the gap in healthy life expectancy and giving everyone the opportunity to live a healthier life, then action on the wider determinants of health and tackling health inequalities must sit at the heart of this bill, not at its margins. I look forward to hearing the noble lady the minister's response.
Joanne Cash
My Lords, I would like to begin by thanking all noble Lords who've tabled amendments in this very important group. And for the high quality of debate at this time in the evening, it falls to me to be as brief as possible. And as the quality of debate and the points made have been so thorough, I will try not to repeat any of those. We are all very much agreed in any event, it appears to me, on these benches. You've heard from Lord Lansley, from Baroness Mansoor, and from noble Baroness Hodson.
We care a great deal about the inequalities in health outcomes in this country. But I'm very grateful to the noble Baroness Garrard and to the noble Baroness Royal for drawing the distinction between healthcare inequalities and health inequalities. And it is important, and it is important for the purpose of the bill and the duties that ought to be placed on a Secretary of State for Health. It's incredibly challenging and painful to hear the data regarding the ongoing inequalities. And of course, we know that healthcare isn't the reason why it is in that state.
But the factors that play a part sit in different departments. And it's why we welcome from these benches the amendments which ask for a look at a strategy. And I do hope that the noble Baroness the minister will consider joining up some of the very significant work being done by the government in, for example, the Fonagy review and the Milburn review, looking at all of these issues together. It would be very helpful also to hear from the noble Baroness the minister about the specific actions the Secretary of State would be expected to undertake to ensure the duty as it's currently drafted and how Parliament would be able to assess those decisions. We've heard from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, about how we might improve upon the current legislation, and I think it's important that we hear how that might be done.
The inequalities in general practice are really so significant and so challenging that I look forward to hearing from the noble Baroness the Minister in how we might hear from the government on how to address this. Incentives to serve in different areas, targeted work plans, ensuring that there is enough training and development and recruitment going on in those areas, all of these issues I hope will be subject to consideration by the noble Baroness the Minister. We can't expect to reduce health inequalities without addressing these disparities in primary care and we look forward to hearing what might be done and what might be included in this bill to do that. We have to judge success in the end by whether patients have access to the healthcare needed at the point of delivery. Look forward to the Minister's response.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble lady Baroness Jones for opening the debate on this group on starting with the amendment laid in the name of her noble friend Baroness Bennett. And I'm extremely grateful to noble Lords for their consideration on what is absolutely key to this bill and also to all of our work, including, and I will return to this, through the 10-year health plan which provides the framework, as I say, for all that we do. Let me start by addressing amendments 6 to 11 and 13 to 20. And I can also, of course, I say of course, but I do want to assure your Lordships' House of our commitment to tackling inequalities. We've debated this a number of times and rightly so in this chamber.
And I would certainly agree with the comments including by the noble lady Baroness Cash. This is about people's ability not just to access services but also to achieve the right outcomes for them regardless of who they are, where their background is, where they live. So with amendments 8, 9 and 10 tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Walmsley, spoken to by the noble lady Baroness Tyler, and amendment 7 in the name of Lord Patel, these test whether the duty on the Secretary of State is strong enough. And I think that's right to discuss that point. I do appreciate the intention and that was emphasized by my noble friends Baroness Royal and Baroness Lister and also the noble Lord Lord Lansley to ensure that we are taking action because actually that at the end of it all is what we are here to do.
But I would caution about amending the bill in the way that the amendments seek. The 'have regard' formulation in legislation, as a number of noble Lords will be aware, does have a number of precedents across the statute book and it is familiar to government departments and it is familiar to decision-making in the public sector. Also there was an exchange between the noble Lord Lord Lansley and my noble friend Baroness Royal over the sections 2A and 2B of the NHS Act and I would tread with some trepidation into that at this stage.
But certainly in relation to the duty in 2B of the NHS Act, I would observe that we don't believe that it is necessary to change the duty from 'may' to 'must'. And again, it's for the point that I've just made about risking confusion because it's moving away from the usual way of doing things, but it will also potentially reduce the ability of ministers to make decisions about priorities. But it is no practical intention to reduce the importance of tackling inequalities. The noble lady Baroness Gerada has moved her place. I'm sorry to hear it's cold, but I'm glad she's here.
I did appreciate the distinction that she drew, which I thought was useful, about what we are talking about when we talk about inequalities. My Lords, if I can move to address amendment 18 tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Tyler and amendment 19 tabled by the noble Lord Lord Patel that regard have regard to new strategies to tackle health inequalities. I know your Lordships' House is aware, but I think it's worth saying it again, that our commitment to what is a very comprehensive 10-year health plan absolutely remains. It was drawn up with a very wide range of input, and importantly, it's been referred to in this group and elsewhere, it was underpinned by the independent investigation of the NHS by the noble Lord Lord Darzi. And tackling inequalities runs is in the very core of the 10-year health plan, which dictates everything that we do.
And I would suggest, therefore, that it is more it is important that we focus on that practical action rather than diverting to developing new strategies. And I would repeat to noble Lords as an assurance that tackling inequalities is what I would call core business. It isn't an add-on or a sidecar, it is absolutely key. And the noble Lord Lord Patel asked me a range put a number of observations to me and asked whether I agreed with them. I appreciate them all, and I agree with most of them would be the answer.
And but I do want to say I particularly welcomed the acknowledgement by the noble Lord Patel and also that of Baroness Mansoor and a number of my own noble friends about the achievement, which was somewhat exceptional in the period of time we've been talking about, of the last Labour government. The only point I'd make to the noble Lord Lord Patel when he was running off a list of ministers at the time, I did hope he might mention me. But I'm mentioning it. But I was very proud to have been the public health minister working with Andy Burnham and to have been part of that.
But it isn't enough just to rest on one's memories or delight at that, but it's actually to indeed take what worked and to bring it into the current time. But I absolutely agree with the noble lord, Lord Patel, that tackling health inequalities is key to not just the NHS, but also the broader economy and of course the well-being of people. And I agree with all the noble lords that have said a cross-government approach is absolutely crucial. But that is why we've got that and that's underpinned by the 10-year health plan. And when I refer to the 10-year health plan, tackling inequalities, for example, informs its absolutely key initiatives.
For example, neighborhood health centers. And on that, we are starting in the most deprived communities. We're not going to the, if I might say, easier communities to work with. We're starting where there is most challenge. And I really welcome that because I do think that is a radical approach.
I also would make the point on accountability. I believe that's extremely important. But I can offer the reassurance the department will continue to report on action taken to address health inequalities as part of its annual report alongside a whole range of published metrics, including the health inequalities dashboard, where the measures in that cover 20 indicators and that does include, for example, prevalence of adult and childhood obesity and it also includes healthy life expectancy at birth. I give you that, I give noble lords that just as a couple of examples. My noble friend Baroness Nogand, in again supporting the call for cross-government strategy, I would actually say that we are already doing that.
Recent cross-government action in this area, for example, the Warm Homes Plan, the Keep Britain Working review, the homelessness strategy, all of these speak to the points that noble lords are calling for. And again, that is one of the reasons I would caution against putting a duty to develop some independent strategy on the face of the bill when in fact it's core to what we are already doing. In respect of amendment 13 tabled by the noble lord, Lord Patel, and amendment 14 tabled by the noble lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, and my noble friend Lord Hunt asked if I would meet the noble lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, and of course I'd be very pleased to do so and indeed open that meeting up to other noble lords who are interested in coastal and rural areas. And then if I could refer also to amendment 20 tabled by the noble lady Baroness Pigeon. These are concerned, of course, with tackling health determinants and inequalities in coastal and other areas.
And it is the case that health is determined not just by our healthcare system, but by our wider environment.
And we do know there is geographical variation. It has grown up over a number of years and it is this government that seeks to tackle that. That runs from housing and employment to education and our local high streets, to name just some. And that has informed both the content of our 10-year health plan and the overall guiding aim that we have, that we pursue, to halve the gap in healthy life expectancy between the richest and the poorest, as noble lords have referred to. That's why we're having the neighborhood health centers that I've referred to, where they are needed most.
But we're now going further by devolving power to local communities so that those who know their areas best can make sure that the services are there for them. And I would just remind noble lords that ICB funding allocations, for example, are adjusted already for health inequalities and to take account of factors like an aging population, like deprivation. And the Core20PLUS5 approach does give ICBs a range of tools to tackle inequalities. And we will and do hold ICBs account to account for their progress. I'm also grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt for bringing forward amendment 11 on accessing GP services.
And noble lords, including the noble lady Baroness Gerada, also spoke to this area. I do agree that equitable distribution of GPs is crucial to ensure people in all areas get timely access to care. But when I say that, I don't mean that every area has exactly the same amount, but that that distribution is sensitive to the needs of that area. Progress is being made. There are 2,600 more GPs compared to July 2024.
That is the highest figure since 2015, with the average number of patients per GP in practices improving. And we continue to boost recruitment through the GP practice-level reimbursement scheme in 26-27. And I would observe that because GPs, like other professions, are more likely to practice where they have trained, we're delivering 1,000 more GP training practices by 2028, targeted towards the areas of greatest need. And we're also reviewing the Carr-Hill funding formula because we have to ensure, as noble lords expect, that resources are allocated much more accurately to reduce health need. The noble lady Baroness Hodgson also commented on this area.
And we are uplifting the GP contract by 611 million for 26-27. And that builds on last year's 1.1 billion pounds of additional investment. And in the year to August 26, including COVID vaccinations, 15.8 million additional appointments were delivered compared with the previous 12 months. This is the way in which we are going. And when I make these points, I am not saying the job is done, but I am showing movement and improvement.
My noble friend Baroness Thornton spoke rightly about having regard to social care. I know my noble friend knows this, but I just will say that adult social care of course has its own statutory framework under the Care Act 2014, which is separate to the Health Bill. That said, I absolutely of course agree with her that social care and the NHS are inextricably linked, which is why we've committed to establishing a National Care Service alongside our National Health Service. I do, I am glad also, my noble friend, if I can just return to the points that he made, he referenced his meeting with my ministerial colleague, the Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety, to talk about concrete actions, which are key rather than additional legislation. And I'm glad that he found that helpful and constructive, and I'll certainly feed that back.
I am grateful to the noble lady Baroness Bennett for recognizing the significant inequalities that are experienced by a range of inclusion health groups, including Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller communities, which the noble lady Baroness Jones spoke to, and I know that if my noble friend Baroness Whitaker had been here, that she would have done likewise. And disadvantaged populations, including Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller communities, are already explicitly recognized within the NHS's Inclusion Health and Core20PLUS5 approaches, and we will be continuing to deal with this approach. I think we should have regard to better data, which has been raised a number of times, and NHS England's ethnicity recording improvement plan is certainly strengthening the quality and consistency of that data, and the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities has established a national inclusion health data and intelligence resource. I guess if I had to summarize the points I've made, that we do believe the existing statutory duties are a more flexible and proportionate basis for addressing these inequalities, rather than specifying individual populations and reporting arrangements in primary legislation. If I can just finally turn to amendment six, I do, which has been tabled by the noble lady Baroness Bennett, spoken to by the noble lady Baroness Jones, I have a lot of sympathy with the intentions, but I do believe that a broader duty as described is unnecessary.
The Secretary of State does have an existing duty to take steps to protect the public from disease and other dangers to health, and powers to take appropriate steps to improve people's health, something that has come up as noble lords have spoken about that. Under section one of the NHS Act 2006, the Secretary of State must continue the promotion of a comprehensive health service designed to secure improvement in the prevention, again called for by noble lords, of physical and mental illness, as well as its diagnosis and treatment. And the recognition that health is influenced by a range of socio-economic factors is very much at the heart of our commitment to achieve a long-desired left shift to prevention.
My Lords, I feel we've had a wide-ranging debate. I will of course reflect on points that have been raised in reviewing what was said, but I would just end by saying that this government is very committed to practical action. I've given some examples of that already and the way in which we are moving. Primary legislation that we've got before us as currently drafted does give us the necessary legislative basis for what it is that noble Lords seek. I actually think our biggest challenge is to deliver that.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, before the noble lady sits down, I thought she would do what I thought she would do, which is to point to areas in the legislation which might help reduce inequalities in health and inequalities in outcome and therefore it is inequalities in healthcare provision too. She mentioned ten-year health plan, but she was not able to point to where it says what the gap is, which is cross-government action. Neither did she mention examples in the bill which demonstrate that there is a cross-government action. So the one area that she said she did not agree with me, maybe it was that one.
Gillian Merron
Oh no, I do agree with the noble Lord about the need for cross-government action. I am simply parting company with the idea that needs to go into primary legislation. That wouldn't be usual because that is a process and I also referred to examples of where we already have cross-government action to deal with health inequalities as distinct from healthcare inequalities as the noble lady Baroness Gerada referred to.
Narendra Patel
Why not, when you were so successful on a previous occasion where you were part of, as you mentioned, the government that demonstrated how they could implement cross-government action and reduce inequality? So why not?
Gillian Merron
I'm not sure we're that far apart on this. I'm just picking up the point about primary legislation rather than the intent of the noble Lord, which I agree with.
Speaker 95
I'd better stand up before anybody else does. I thank the noble lady the Minister for her replies. I really admire the positivity in them. I've been using the NHS since 1949 and it's absolutely amazing. My working-class parents were incredibly delighted by its introduction, but I rather suspect that my age cohort has had the best of it.
I hope that's not true. I'd love to respond to a lot of the points, including the coastal communities which are often suffering from huge environmental pollution from rivers and seashores and so on. But it's been a fascinating debate and I can see a very exciting report stage in the offing. But in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw.
Speaker 104
Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 7, Lord Patel, not moved. Amendment 8, Baroness Tyler, not moved, and 9 and 10, not moved. Amendment 11, Lord Hunt, not moved.
Speaker 102
My Lords, I beg to move that the House be resumed. We will then move to dinner break business. We will therefore not return to the bill before 21:07.
Speaker 103
The question is that the House be resumed. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 104
Railways interoperability in Northern Ireland, Convention on International Carriage by Rail, Amendment Regulations 2026, Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill.
Seb Dance
Due to an administrative error, with the exception of the Minister and Baroness Hoey, speakers in this debate will have five minutes rather than six minutes. Today's list was reissued earlier with the correct timings and all speakers have been contacted. I would be grateful if noble Lords could stay closely to the five minutes to ensure there is sufficient time for the Minister's response, which I'm sure all noble Lords will wish to hear.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My Lords, before I begin, I would like to convey heartfelt condolences on behalf of the United Kingdom government to the families and friends of those who lost their lives today in the tragic high-speed railway collision in Spain. Our sympathies are with all those who have been injured or affected by this terrible incident. My Lords, I beg to move that the draft regulations laid before the House on the 29th of June 2026 be approved. These regulations implement the UK's obligations on rail interoperability under the Windsor Framework and update domestic legislation implementing the Convention concerning International Carriage by Rail, commonly known as COTIF. The regulations establish the conditions and technical requirements that railway vehicles, infrastructure and component products must satisfy before they can be placed on the market or put in service in Northern Ireland.
Interoperability is about making sure trains, railway infrastructure and railway equipment can operate safely and effectively across connected rail networks. The interoperability framework in Great Britain is set through the Railways Interoperability Regulations 2011, but however, during the UK's withdrawal from the European Union, EU states migrated to a new interoperability framework based on Directive 2016/797. Under the Windsor Framework, the United Kingdom is required to apply this directive in Northern Ireland in so far as it relates to the placing on the market, putting into service and free movement of railway products. These regulations implement that requirement by creating a dedicated interoperability framework for Northern Ireland. The framework established by these regulations facilitates interoperability between the Northern Irish and Irish railway networks whilst providing legal certainty for industry.
The railways on the island of Ireland are functionally and technically distinct from Great Britain's, with key differences including the track gauge of five foot three in the whole of Ireland as opposed to four foot eight and a half in Great Britain. The rail technical standards applicable in Britain and Northern Ireland have always reflected these inherent differences, even when the whole UK was applying EU interoperability law. There is therefore more practical benefit in Northern Ireland having closer interoperability with Ireland's railways than Great Britain's. The Northern Ireland Minister for Infrastructure shares this view. The Minister wrote to me about the benefits of aligning with Ireland's rail technical regime, which range beyond the operation of cross-border services.
These include joint procurement of train fleets with Ireland and economies of scale for rail equipment, reducing procurement and operational costs.
I quote: "The more fundamental consideration is whether the conditions exist to support the long-term development of an integrated railway network across the island of Ireland. The standardized regulatory approach currently provided through the Windsor Framework creates an enabling environment for joint investment, shared procurement, and coordinated railway operations. This is particularly important in the context of the recommendations emerging from the All-Island Strategic Rail Review, itself a key recommendation of the Union Connectivity Review." And indeed, the joint procurement of the fleet of eight new trains for the Enterprise service between Belfast and Dublin, due in 2030, a joint service between Northern Ireland Railways and Irish Rail, was facilitated and made cheaper because there was only one technical regime between the two countries and and a and one under which the successful supplier, who comes from the European Union, is familiar with. This legislation will therefore help the democratically elected government in Northern Ireland achieve its strategic policy aims in rail.
I'll now turn to the issues raised during parliamentary scrutiny. The Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments considered the regulations and did not draw them to the special attention of either House. The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee raised several questions regarding implementation, consultation, and the wider policy context, and I'll address those matters now. The committee questioned the period between the UK's obligation to implement these requirements arising under the Windsor Framework and the laying of these regulations. The UK had not implemented this directive before leaving the European Union.
As a result, introducing these arrangements as required careful work to ensure that Northern Ireland and Great Britain can continue to operate effectively under their respective rail frameworks. Delivering these regulations required extensive technical and legal work. It required close engagement with the Department for Infrastructure and the European Union Agency for Railways to ensure the new arrangements would operate effectively. And the regulations make changes in a range of technical areas, such as vehicle authorization, which ultimately relate to rail interoperability and safety. The instrument is technical and legally complex, establishing a complete rail interoperability framework for Northern Ireland to implement the obligations under the Windsor Framework.
Substantial implementation work was required to ensure that the regime could operate effectively in practice. This included developing Northern Ireland national technical rules necessary to supplement the EU technical specifications. These regulations principally apply when introducing new equipment on the railway or making major changes to existing vehicles and infrastructure. The department is not aware of any such rail project being unable to proceed whilst this implementing legislation was in development, and the department took steps to ensure this through interim measures, including publishing technical notices specifying the EU rail interoperability requirements applicable in Northern Ireland. A Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee report questions the department's understanding that legislation was needed.
We have always been clear that legislation was needed and have been working at pace to get this right and in place as soon as practicable. The department implemented interim administrative arrangements that allowed the new interoperability regime to operate in practice whilst the legislative framework was being finalized. We also informed the European Commission of this work whilst the implementation legislation was in preparation, and therefore many of the requirements in the directive already reflect practices and standards in operation in Northern Ireland. Committee also asked why updates relating to COTIF are only being brought forward now. The amendment reflects the UK's position following EU exit.
The committee also questioned the decision not to undertake a formal public consultation. The government carefully considered this issue. These regulations implement obligations that the UK has already entered into under the Windsor Framework and COTIF. There was therefore limited scope to take a different policy approach. Whilst the policy outcome itself was constrained by international existing international obligations, the department adopted a targeted engagement approach with those organisations most directly affected by the legislation, including the Department for Infrastructure, Translink, the Office of Rail and Road, the Rail Safety and Standards Board, and conformity assessment bodies to inform a practical approach to the legislation.
Whilst the UK was a member of the European Union, this issue was addressed through the EU's arrangements. Following EU exit, it became necessary to reflect the UK's position directly in domestic legislation.
Our subsequently also asked the UK industry trade body, the Railway Industry Association, whether their members had reported any adverse effects or expect any in the future. They said they had no adverse comments from their members. I know that the noble Baroness Lady Hoey has tabled a motion of regret relating to the absence of a formal consultation, and whilst of course I respect those concerns, the government's view is that targeted the targeted engagement undertaken was proportionate given the nature of the regulations and the limited scope for alternative policy options. During scrutiny, concerns were raised regarding the existence of different regulatory arrangements in Northern Ireland and Great Britain, including in a submission from Mr Jim Allister MP. I recognise those concerns, but it's important to be clear about the purpose of these regulations.
They don't create the United Kingdom's obligations under the Windsor Framework, which are set out in the withdrawal agreement. These regulations are concerned with implementing those obligations and providing a clear and legally operable framework for industry and regulators. The department also continues to work closely with the Department for Infrastructure to understand and manage any future impacts arising from divergence between regulatory frameworks in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I beg to move.
Speaker 107
The question is that this motion be agreed to. Amendment, Baroness Hoey.
Kate Hoey
Lords, here we are again, another SI, another dinner hour, and as many of us have warned for some time, until we actually stop allowing a foreign power, the EU, to take over making the rules for part of our own country, we will be continuing with these SIs. In welcoming the noble Lord to his place, and I know his genuine interest in railways, so I imagine he will have read what is actually I think the largest ever statutory instrument I've seen, some 40-page document, 54 regulations, and I know that his opposite number, the noble Lord Morley, will also have read it with great interest, and probably both of them could actually recite the technical details in detail. But my Lords, apart from 30 minutes in a committee in the other place, this will be the only scrutiny to which this legislation will be subjected to in this Parliament. Once again, we've got regulations which will introduce a divergence in law and authority between two parts of our country, and once again without this Parliament making the laws. The real significance of this statutory instrument is that whereas today the whole of the United Kingdom is subject to the same law in relation to railways, once this comes into effect, the country will be divided in two, with one law applying to GB and another a law applying to Northern Ireland.
And these regulations will introduce and give effect to a law made in, as I've said, a foreign parliament that will be imposed on part of the UK. The lack of opportunity to even debate them, never mind change them, makes this absurd, and it's also constitutionally an outrage that a part of this country should be reduced by laws we do not make and we cannot change, and yet that's what we're doing tonight. There's been no consultation. Nowhere else do we legislate without at least the facade of consultation with the public, but when it comes to the Northern Ireland, that's always null and void. And why has there been no consultation?
Because a chat with the Department of Infrastructure and its minister and a chat with Translink is not consultation. What about all the businesses affected, the suppliers who are involved?
But the government, I have to say, are at least being honest by saying more or less that there's no point in consultation. I think the noble Lord himself said limited scope. It would be a pointless exercise. And of course, the noble Lord tonight, whether he likes these regulations or not, he is obliged to implement them because of the Windsor Framework. In the other place, the minister suggested that the debate on these regulations was not the place to raise constitutional questions of disenfranchisement because Parliament had already voted to adopt the Windsor Framework.
Well, the noble Lord, the minister, hasn't said that, but the minister in the other place was just wrong. My Lords, I would remind my Lords that we never voted specifically on the Windsor Framework, and any votes have been in relation to different aspects of it through statutory instruments, the first one being on the 29th of March 2023 on the democratic scrutiny legislation. So in this context, where is the place to address the constitutional implications of these regulations if it's not actually now and in a debate like this? Because if not, when? We're effectively told we have no choice.
And what sort of way is that to run any government, to run our country, to rule that any part of the United Kingdom, the law is being changed by some people and some institution that we have no say in? Is it something that other members would accept for their county or their area, that they cannot change the laws that are imposed and that they have simply the obligation, as this SI will have, upon criminal sanction to implement them? We're creating in these regulations a scenario where railways will be governed in a part of the UK not by an agency of the United Kingdom, but by the EU's Railway Agency. And when we look at regulations 28 to 30, we discover that for a supplier in GB to supply any railway equipment to Northern Ireland, they must apply and obtain a declaration of conformity that they are complying with the handed-down laws of a foreign parliament. The government and indeed the noble Lord, the minister, have not even acknowledged that there will be impact on businesses in Northern Ireland and in GB.
We're creating a separate railway regime for Northern Ireland, and so businesses supplying equipment to Northern Ireland will have to meet the requirement laid down by the EU, and this will lead to additional paperwork, declarations, and cost. Is the noble Lord, the minister, and will he, when he's summing up, will he actually deny that there will be extra costs for businesses? My Lords, what we're seeing is a drip-drip moving Northern Ireland further away from the rest of the United Kingdom, and this cannot be allowed to continue. Our railways in Northern Ireland have been safe despite the many years of the IRA trying constantly to blow them up and block the line from Belfast to Dublin. They go through some of the most beautiful parts of Northern Ireland.
I'm sure the noble Lord, the minister, would prefer to be discussing how we could have them electrified and how we could get railway lines back to parts of Northern Ireland like Fermanagh where we used to have them. But instead, we're discussing what the public would really be interested in, instead of discussing what the public would really be interested in, we're discussing because of the government has lost control of what happens in one part of our own country. It really is shameful, and that is why despite these regulations being technical, unless I hear something very, very important from the noble Lord, the minister, I will be opposing them tonight. They were opposed in the other place. There was a vote in the other place, and the vote was over a hundred members of parliament voted against this statutory instrument.
And I'm very pleased that gradually more and more people are beginning to realize that the Windsor Framework is destroying businesses in Northern Ireland, destroying businesses who want to work in Great Britain to go to Northern Ireland, and that we have to do something about it.
So I beg to move my amendment.
Speaker 104
The original question was that the regulations laid before the house on the 29th of June be approved, since when an amendment has been moved by Baroness Hoey at the end to insert the words set out on the order paper. The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to.
Speaker 111
My lords, I congratulate the noble lady Baroness Hoey on securing this debate. And I want to make it clear how offensive regulations of this sort are to all unionists, whether they live in Northern Ireland or Great Britain. It's offensive and unnecessary to have different laws in Northern Ireland and Great Britain. It's offensive that those laws should be imposed by a foreign power. It's offensive that there was no consultation.
Speaker 110
It's offensive that Northern Ireland electors have no say in their making and cannot reject them. And moreover, it's offensive to electors in Great Britain that some aspects of the laws changed by this statutory instrument apply this side of the Irish Sea, and I hope the noble minister will confirm that, though he didn't bother to mention that he was changing the laws of Great Britain in his opening speech. And in fact, that is the main reason the EU insisted on the Northern Ireland Protocol, now rebadged as the Windsor whatever it is, so that they wanted to use it as a lever, and use Northern Ireland as a lever to impose EU law on the whole of the UK. I recall attending a meeting at the LSE during the debates about the withdrawal process when the EU negotiator said, "The EU is a legislative hegemon and it intends to remain that." They have as an objective in itself want to impose their laws outside their own territory, not actually something that's particularly necessary, but what they want to do.
Speaker 111
It's not because, as some of the nationalists and Sinn Fein say, the objective was avoiding a border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. That wasn't really their objective, and we can see that in these regulations, which actually create a border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. It says in clause 5.5, well, 5.5 of the explanatory memorandum, tier 3, that, if I can get it right, that a change in area of use will also occur in the case of a vehicle that crosses the border on the island of Ireland. A change in the area of use of vehicles and so on will trigger the need for new authorization to take place in the market. So it keeps a border in Ireland from the regulatory point of view, but it imposes in addition, as most EU stuff does, additional bureaucratic procedures.
Previously authorized vehicles need to be reauthorized if they change their area of use, and moving from Northern Ireland to Southern Ireland is such a change. Even if a vehicle is intended for use only in Northern Ireland, then they have to be reauthorized.
The only difference is that then the vehicle owner has the option of applying to the agency set up by the EU or the Department for Infrastructure. My Lords, ministers and noble Lords may be irritated by the stream of regulations and statutory instruments and the debates that they trigger, generated by the Northern Ireland Protocol/Windsor whatsit. They should, however, brace themselves because dynamic alignment, to which this government is committed, previous Chancellor in her Mays lecture said she wanted to see dynamic alignment unilaterally applied to virtually every area of trade with the EU. Dynamic alignment will require us to accept all regulations passed by the EU since we left. And we know roughly how many they are because each regulation bears a number.
And so far this year, they've got up to number 2106/26, i.e. the ones passed this year, 2000 this year. There've been over 25,000 regulations introduced since we left in 2020. So look forward, my Lords, to a tsunami of statutory instruments of this kind and debates of this nature as we try to absorb in our legislation everything that's happened since we left. Now, why do they have so much legislation? Because they're committed to it.
It is what they do. They've had innumerable reports, most recently pointing out that the reason the EU is the slowest growing continent in the world is because they are overregulated. But they can't stop themselves doing it. It's what they do, just as drug addicts take drugs. And why we should consider joining such an organization or unilaterally adopting their regulations and forcing on ourselves the very things that have made them the slowest growing economy in Europe beats me.
Speaker 112
We're growing faster than the major countries in Europe thanks to Brexit. Let's keep it that way.
Speaker 114
My Lords, another night, another statutory instrument connected to the Windsor Framework. And I fully accept the many frustrations that have been connected with the implementation of the Windsor Framework, which are widely understood in Northern Ireland. I'd like to thank the Minister for his very clear exposition, in many ways clearer than the statutory instrument document that we have in front of us, very substantially so, and I'm grateful to him for that. But I also accept that Baroness Hoey is right. There is a problem in general about the government's mode of address and on consultation on these Windsor Framework related documents.
Speaker 113
And as I say, this is not the first and it won't be the last that we have enjoyed in this chamber at dinner hour. But this matter of mode of address is important. And let me say one thing that is really quite significant. I understand why it often seems that the problems associated with this particular legislation are so small, the problem is just for Translink at one point it says. Well, we need to know more about what those problems might be for Translink.
Again, it's not exactly clear, and Baroness Hoey is right, what the problems for business actually are. But it may be that they are slight. But it does not matter. The point is this is a big politically sensitive area in Northern Ireland. That's the big thing the government has to address.
And the government's relationship to the Windsor Framework is a problem. Let us be clear, by the way, the Windsor Framework passed with a larger majority in the House of Commons than the Anglo-Irish Agreement of 1985 by some long way.
And we have to therefore take it seriously. But the Windsor Framework is not just simply an agency under which we have to cope with this sort of Euro legislation. The Windsor Framework is important also because what it says clearly in the command paper page five, it is an unhooking from the pressure in the earlier phases of the negotiation accepted by our government, Tory governments in 1917, 2019 documents of withdrawal that for example the British government will work to create an all-island economy. That's the unhooking, very clear in page five for example of the command paper which makes it clear that this will be a different path of development for Northern Ireland, a path of development which has been hugely successful. It's widely accepted that the Belfast Agreement is that Northern Ireland region is now the fastest growing, Belfast probably doing better than Manchester, can we say that?
Can we get away with that? But the figures look as if that's the case. And the problem has been because the government will not, it will only come to the House and tell you here is the latest irritating thing we're doing under the Windsor Framework, but will not draw to its major area of success, something which this government fully supports the Windsor Framework, in its major area of success in the growth of Belfast, the debate turns so downturn, so miserable, so depressed. And that's why I'm saying the government's mode of address on this subject really is just read page five again of the command paper and add to it something that the command paper doesn't actually specifically mention, the defense expenditure now of the UK in Belfast. This is the context that Northern Ireland's economy at the moment has rarely looked stronger and it relates to that key element in the Windsor Framework.
And that key element exists along with these myriad other irritations. Now one final point I said another night on another SI, but actually it's not quite the same as before. We are on the eve of some form of reset and I don't know the November the 20th I think is the date between the United Kingdom and the EU. And what this will mean to put this very crudely and it's already been more than hinted at by Lord Lilley is that actually we're all going to become rule takers. Northern Ireland specifically look and let us consider what is proposed or what one reads about for the SPS deal.
The United Kingdom itself and the United Kingdom Parliament is going to be accepting rules in the same way that Northern Ireland Assembly has had to do with one exception of course it won't actually have a Stormont brake. But that is what the government and the democratically government is moving towards. But the specificity of Northern Ireland's uniqueness at the present stage that it alone has to be a rule taker from the European Union looks as if it's going to change quite markedly and especially when we get into next year, especially when we consider what we read about what an SPS agreement is likely to include. So in conclusion my Lords it's not another night, another Windsor Framework. It's the last of an old type of debate.
Nigel Dodds
My Lords, I appreciate the opportunity to take part in this debate and congratulate Baroness Hoey on securing this debate which it is important to continue to debate on a regular basis laws that apply to part of the United Kingdom, especially when they're set by others, not by the House of Commons or the House of Lords or the Stormont Assembly, when they're set by people who don't live in or vote or have any role in the United Kingdom I think it's fair that we should examine in great detail what these laws are all about. I listened very carefully to the noble Lord Lord Bew and obviously great respect for his views, but I would remind him in terms of the narrative that the investment in Northern Ireland is coming in is mainly in the services area and the services of course are outside the Windsor Framework.
Nothing to do with the Windsor Framework. That's where the growth is in Northern Ireland. In terms of the all-Ireland economy he says was removed as a result of the Windsor Framework, references to it, but of course every piece of legislation under the Windsor Framework is to align Northern Ireland with the rest of the United Kingdom, with the rest of the EU and the Republic of Ireland rather than the rest of the United Kingdom. That's the fundamental problem with the Windsor Framework which he well knows because we've debated this many many times. On this particular SI my Lords I would ask the noble Lord the Minister just to address the point that was raised by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee when the government said that the 2016 directive which is being implemented as a result of these regulations already applied in Northern Ireland as international law by consequence of the Windsor Framework's ratification.
At paragraph 81 of its report the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee was scathing about the government's response and said that this was completely untrue. And I wonder would the government tonight take the opportunity to deal with that assertion by the committee that this is incorrect in terms. In terms of what we've been asked to scrutinize, this is a done deal. We don't have the opportunity in this House or elsewhere in the Stormont Assembly or in any house of this Parliament to actually change what is before us. It's already been decided by others and imposed upon us.
What is striking is in its answers to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee the government set out how extensive the discussions have had to be with the European Commission to reach consensus and to engage closely with them on the legal drafting and timelines for implementation. There wasn't any such consultation or close detailed negotiations and discussions with anyone in Northern Ireland. The noble Lord Lord Bew is right to raise once again the issue of public consultation. The government says again in its response to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee that the scope for policy discretion in how the directive is reflected in domestic law is limited. Well that's an understatement if there ever was one, it's not just limited, it's impossible.
And that's why they didn't consult with anyone other than the Department for Infrastructure and Translink. Now these are very very serious matters my Lords and every time we examine these regulations and SIs we do come back to the fundamental themes of laws that are being imposed upon us, about the lack of any proper convincing consultation with those who are affected by it. We come to the point of divergence between Great Britain and Northern Ireland and I'd like the Minister to explain if he sees any risk to the supply chain for industries in this area in Northern Ireland. I note that again in their response to the Scrutiny Committee the government said that they have no active plans to implement the content of this 2016 directive in Great Britain. They've spent enormous amounts of time negotiating with the EU about imposing it on part of the United Kingdom.
If it's good for Northern Ireland why is it not being considered for the rest of the United Kingdom? Could the Minister tell us what is what having done all this work it would be quite simple to transpose it for the rest of the United Kingdom as well so what is the reason for not doing that?
And then could I finally ask the Minister, it says that there are arrangements have existed with the Department of Infrastructure in Northern Ireland to consult and to have arrangements to ensure that there isn't a lot of divergence. I wonder could the Minister set out in detail what exactly those arrangements are? He says they were effective during the first major revision of Britain's national technical specification notices for rail interoperability. I'd like to know who is engaged in those arrangements, what is the accountability mechanisms for them, how does the Northern Ireland Assembly members interact with them and so on. But again, I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations, but I will like to say that if the noble Baroness Hoey pushes this to a vote, we will certainly be in the lobby against it with her.
Speaker 117
My Lords, I'm grateful to Baroness Hoey for bringing forward this regret motion this evening. The regulations before the House concern railway interworking in Northern Ireland and arise from arrangements linked to international and post-Brexit obligations. And while members may differ on the merits of the regulations themselves, I want to focus on an issue that should concern this House, but especially elected representatives in Northern Ireland, on the manner in which decisions affecting Northern Ireland continue to be made with insufficient consultation and very little accountability, not only in this issue, but other issues as well. My Lords, consultation is not a perceived nicety, it is a fundamental part of good government. Decisions which affect the people, businesses, and the infrastructure of Northern Ireland should not simply be presented as take it or leave it.
Those who will be affected by such changes should have a meaningful opportunity to express their views before decisions are taken, not merely after they have been announced. My Lords, too often Northern Ireland finds itself in the position of being informed rather than consulted. And that approach risks creating a sense of detachment and frustration among those who are expected to live with the consequences. There's also the question of accountability. One of the strengths of our constitutional arrangements is that ministers can be questioned, challenged, and held to account by Parliament.
Yet where regulations flow from external obligations or complex arrangements, there can be a growing perspective that responsibility becomes very diluted. My Lords, those in Northern Ireland have a right to expect that decisions affecting their transport infrastructure and the economy and daily lives will not simply be handed down to them. Whether one supports or opposes these regulations, surely we can all agree that people have a meaningful opportunity to influence decisions before they are made, not after. My Lords, whatever view we take on the merits of these regulations, we should insist that Northern Ireland's voice is heard and that decision-makers remain answerable for the consequences of their decision.
My Lords, this House has frequently emphasized the importance of engagement, transparency, and public confidence in decision-making. These principles should apply to no less than Northern Ireland than any other part of this United Kingdom. My Lords, for these reasons, I believe Baroness Hoey's regret motion performs an important service. It reminds us all in this House that good government depends not only on what decisions are made, but how they are made, and I'm fully supportive in the regret motion that's before the House this evening.
Speaker 118
My Lords, it is important that we debate these regulations because if they come into effect, they will end the existing arrangement that testify to the reality of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland subject to a common legal framework in relation to railways. Now, they cut our country into two, placing one part under one legal regime, another part under another. What is striking about this, that the different law that is being applied to one part of the country through the legislation before us this evening is not the legislation of a devolved legislature within the United Kingdom, reflecting the wishes of the people of that devolved legislature, which in turn reflect the wishes of their constituents. In actual fact, even if all the Assembly unitedly opposed these, it'd make no difference. That's just what the bottom line is.
Speaker 119
The basic content has been devised by a foreign parliament in which the people of Northern Ireland are not represented. Now, to some that is acceptable, but to those who believe in the United Kingdom, it is not. This is in actual fact an extraordinary humiliation, not only of the people of Northern Ireland, but of the whole United Kingdom, which is through this imposition having its territorial integrity disrespected by 27 states. Now, we know that the doctrine of recognition in international relations means that diplomatic relations can obtain between two or more sovereign states if they recognize each other's territorial integrity on a reciprocal basis. Through these regulations, however, the EU 27 not only refuse to recognize the territorial integrity of the United Kingdom by means of claiming a right to make the laws of the United Kingdom, they actually effectively make those laws and in so doing undermine the territorial integrity of the UK.
Speaker 118
Now, this is in stark contradiction and violation of international law, which states: "Every state shall refrain from any action aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity or territorial integrity of any other state or country according to the Charter of the United Nations." These regulations testify to efforts of 27 states to do the exact opposite, to disrupt the national unity and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom.
Now to those who say, but this will ensure that the railways of the United Kingdom, Northern Ireland connect with those of the Republic, implying that this is somehow providing a clinching argument. I would remind them, however, that while we in this country are more used to sea borders than land borders, most countries have real borders with other countries, many of them more than one on one front. However, even those that have only one real border with another country do not find it a reason to subject themselves to the laws of the neighboring country. The United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland should approach the question of how railway lines move from one country to another as do other sovereign states, by means of agreement, not by dictating the law by a foreign parliament that the people of Northern Ireland has no representation. The indignity in this legislation has been greatly compounded by the decision of our government not to hold a public consultation on this legislation.
Legislation, my Lords, that runs to many provisions and is more like a bill than a statutory instrument, albeit amendable. One can of course sort of understand the logic. What is the point of having consultation? The United Kingdom will still have to bow in submission to the legislation set by parliamentarians elected to represent the constituents of other countries, not Northern Ireland. This, however, only serves to underline the reality of our humiliation.
Not only are the people of Northern Ireland disenfranchised, now they are not even worthy of consultation. Perhaps the noble Lord, the Minister responding, he can tell us and explain whether the government has formed the judgment that they're content to allow divergence. When it comes into force, the standards in Great Britain will be different from those in Northern Ireland. So this applies to run our railways that previously came from GB will no longer be able to come unless GB suppliers are prepared to go through the problem of having to get the EU declaration of conformity under regulations. My Lords, in conclusion, can I say to the Minister, one believes in actual fact it's pushing and forcing to redirect our supply chain from the rest of the United Kingdom into the Irish Republic, and those who support the Windsor Framework would be quite happy.
Susy De Martini
My Lords, I would like to begin with joining with the noble Lord, the Minister, in sending our from these benches our very sincere condolences to the people of Spain and the truly awful railway accident that happened today. Our heart goes out to the families of those who have lost loved ones. I'd like to thank the noble Lord, the Minister, for his explanation of these regulations, and I would also like to thank Baroness Hoey for allowing this short debate this evening as a result of her regret motion. From these benches, we support these regulations. In many of the debates we have had stemming from the Windsor Framework, there have been understandable and justifiable concerns about the Windsor Framework leading to increased divergence between Northern Ireland and the rest of the United Kingdom where previously any divergence was minimal.
In the instance of these regulations, however, Northern Ireland and Britain's railways run to different specifications and gauges for historical and geographical reasons. Northern Ireland's rail network inevitably has to connect with the rail network in the Republic of Ireland.
Unless and until a tunnel is built under the Irish Sea, there is no direct rail connections between Northern Ireland and Great Britain. I'm very like noble the noble Lord Dodds, I'm very grateful to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee of your Lordships' House for the short but excellent and extremely useful report on these highly complex and long regulations. As that report states, there has been a considerable delay in implementing the 2016 EU directive in Northern Ireland, which is required under the Windsor Framework. Now the Minister referred to this in his introduction, but I'm sure he will admit that to most people this seems like an exceptionally long delay before implementation. The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee report also stated that there are no active plans to implement the 2016 directive in Great Britain, but that there will be a review as to whether greater alignment with the directive might be beneficial.
Can the Minister say when he expects the findings of that review to be published? My Lords, as usual in these debates, the concerns are less about the regulations themselves and more about the understandable constitutional and parliamentary scrutiny issues stemming from the Windsor Framework and the adoption of EU law when there is no longer any direct UK involvement in the drafting of that law. I should note, however, that these particular regulations are implementing a 2016 EU directive that was drafted and agreed upon at a time when we were still a member of the European Union. In previous debates, I've shared the concern of the noble Lords opposite about the lack of parliamentary scrutiny. It is something that we all need to be concerned about.
And as noble other noble Lords have said, it's also highly regrettable that there was not wider consultation. As there is now more moves towards greater alignment with the European Union, which from these benches we welcome, it is equally important that new and improved ways are found to allow this Parliament to have a greater say and involvement, most especially at the earliest stages when legislation is being drafted. And that this is particularly true, I think as I've said in previous debates, because the House of Commons no longer has a European Scrutiny Committee. And I believe, my Lords, that is something that I hope they will rectify very soon.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, may I thank the noble Baroness Lady Hoey for her regret motion and may I join with the noble Lord the Minister and the noble Baroness Lady Suttie in expressing the condolences of these benches to the people of Spain and to those affected by today's tragic accident in Spain. My Lords, I start by acknowledging that the EU has a legitimate interest in railways. That springs from the need for interoperability between national systems if their single market is to be perfected. It explains, for example, why the EU has been requiring adoption of a single signaling system throughout its realms. But that goal of interoperability is and will remain a complete chimera as far as Ireland is concerned.
As the noble Lord has already explained, the Gauge Act of 1846 settled on a standard gauge of 4 foot 8 and a half inches for Great Britain and an Irish gauge of 5 foot 3 inches for the railways of Ireland.
For reasons too lengthy to explore now, the standard gauge was adopted in time throughout most of Western Europe, while the Irish gauge established itself only in parts of Australia and Brazil. It follows, my Lords, Irish engineers. It follows, my Lords, that no European train, indeed no British train, could run in Ireland because it would not fit the tracks. Even if the considerable difficulties of transporting it across the substantial body of water that separates Ireland from her nearest neighbor in the European Union could be overcome. The argument from interoperability for EU involvement in Ireland's railways, north and south, fails dismally, therefore.
These regulations replace for Northern Ireland alone the Railways Interoperability Regulations 2011, which have until now governed rail interoperability across the whole United Kingdom. It's worth stating that cross-border arrangements in Ireland, arrangements which include practical cooperation between railway authorities on both sides of the UK-Irish border, have never been criticized for a lack of effectiveness in the operation of Irish trains. Well, very occasionally, I'm sure there has been cause for complaint, but generally the system works well. In the place of those regulations, Northern Ireland is to implement the 2016 EU directive, together with the technical specifications adopted under it. Regulation 2 defines both the directive and those specifications as they are amended from time to time.
So this is dynamic alignment in perpetuity. This means that the rules governing Northern Ireland's railways will change, not just today, but in the future, whenever the European Commission chooses to change them, without any further act of this Parliament and without any vote in the Northern Ireland Assembly. The mechanisms of democratic consent and the Stormont brake, whatever their merits, offer scant means of effective objection. The noble Lord the Minister wants a single directing mind in charge of Great British Railways. He seems to be happy that it should be a single directing foreign mind, based in Valenciennes of all places, in charge of railways in the rest of the UK.
I do not criticize my right honorable friend Rishi Sunak for not having the Gauge Act 1846 at the front of his mind when he negotiated the Windsor Framework. Nonetheless, it is not right that people in one part of the United Kingdom should be governed by rules in whose making they have no say. And I would have expected the European Union, with its long-standing commitment to democratic norms, to be the first to understand that. The regulations have some intriguing implications. They require the whole of Ireland to adopt the European Rail Traffic Management System, the single European Union signaling system that will allow interoperability with trains that cannot get to Ireland and won't fit the tracks if they do.
Why is the British taxpayer paying for this in respect of Northern Ireland? Is this what the people of Northern Ireland want? We'll never know. There has been no public consultation. Manufacturers, suppliers, those who work on the railway, and above all passengers, could get no say.
Can the Minister explain why he has been asked by a number of noble Lords? My Lords, we have never taken the view that the Windsor Framework was the final word, or beyond improvement in what is an evolving situation. We will always look at constructive proposals for change and reform. One such proposal would have been persuading the European Union not to proceed with these frankly daft regulations.
It would be good to hear from the noble lord the minister whether His Majesty's government ever approached Brussels with such a proposal. My lords, we need to ensure that legislation works for all parts of the United Kingdom. This does not, and for that reason, if the noble baroness divides the house, we will support her.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My lords, I thank noble lords for their contribution to today's debate and for the thoughtful points that have been raised. I will briefly respond to the issues that have featured in this debate. Noble lords have raised the question of consultation, and the government carefully considered whether a formal public consultation was appropriate. These regulations implement obligations that the United Kingdom has already entered into under the Windsor Framework and COTIF. As a consequence, there was limited policy discretion available regarding the fundamental policy outcome.
However, that does not mean that engagement did not take place. The department worked closely with those organisations most directly affected by the legislation, including, as I said, the Department for Infrastructure, Translink, the Office of Rail and Road, the Rail Safety and Standards Board, and conformity assessment bodies. That engagement informed the practical approach to implementation adopted in these regulations. And as I said in my opening speech, the railway supply industry trade body for Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the Railway Industry Association, reported have reported no adverse effects so far and no adverse effects anticipated for their for their members. And that I think deals also with the point about the effects on business, the impacts on business, because the business of maintaining and improving railways is very limited and many of the people who do it are members of the Railway Industry Association.
I will write to the noble Lord Dodds of Duncairn. He asked a number of questions and it would be more convenient if I write to him with with all of the answers. The noble Baroness Suttie raised the question of the of the delay which the SISC raised. And as I outlined in my opening remarks, substantial technical and legal work has been undertaken to ensure that the framework could operate effectively alongside existing domestic railway legislation and provide a workable, durable, and legally robust regime for industry and regulators. It's a complex set of regulations.
It's taken quite a long time to achieve, but actually it's the right thing to do in these circumstances. The noble baroness also asked about the the review, and the the outcome of the review will be published by March 2027 along in the post-implementation review of the Great Britain implementation regulations. These these regulations provide the legislative framework necessary to implement the UK's obligations relating to railway interoperability in Northern Ireland and to update domestic legislation implementing the convention concerning international carriage by rail. They provide clarity and certainty for regulators, infrastructure managers, operators, and manufacturers, support the continued operation of cross-border railway services on the island of Ireland, and ensure that domestic legislation accurately reflects the UK's international obligations.
They are the right solution for Northern Ireland's railways and the industry that supplies them given the unique technical characteristics of rail across the island of Ireland. And as I said, the eight train sets ordered for the Enterprise service from Belfast to Dublin, ordered jointly between the two governments, demonstrates precisely the benefit of these regulations. The vehicles will run on the railways of both countries under a set of rules which are absolutely the same in both, and that relative simplicity has enabled a cheaper purchase and from a supplier in the European Union who is familiar with the regulations. They are technical regulations, but they perform an important function in providing a clear, stable, and legally operable framework for the railway industry in Northern Ireland, and therefore I commend the draft regulations to the House.
Kate Hoey
Lord the Minister for his response, and I hope he will write for the number of questions that were not answered in the time available, particularly to do with the supply across the United Kingdom and also the costs. I just want to say that anyone who's listened to this whole debate tonight can see, particularly after what the noble Lord Moylan said, this is a nonsense. These are actually nonsense regulations in the way they're being done and the fact that we really don't need them in this sense, and we certainly don't need the European Union telling us what to do when they don't have any interest in that sense to do with the railways. But I just want to correct one thing that Lord Bew said. He said that the Windsor Framework had had a huge majority in the Commons.
Can I remind him that that vote was no more a vote on the Windsor Framework than the vote on tonight's regulations. We've never had a vote on the Windsor Framework. It was a vote on the Windsor Framework Democratic Scrutiny Regulations, and I think that's very, very important. I still feel that we haven't actually, I understand about the regulation tonight and I accept that both the front benches and probably everyone who's read it, all 50 pages, 58, will recognize that they're probably needed in that sense, but we shouldn't be doing it in this way. And as far as the Windsor Framework is concerned, this has to be looked at.
It is unsustainable. We can't keep having other parts of the world who've got no, should have no say in our country, dividing our country with statutory instrument after statutory instrument. And because of that, and because I think it's important that we actually recognize what these SIs are doing, that I would like to press my amendment on consultation, which there was none.
Speaker 9
The question is that the amendment in the name of Baroness Hoey be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division, and I will advise the House when voting is open. My Lords, voting is now open, clear the bar.
Order. Order. Order. The question is that the amendment in the name of Baroness Hoey be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content.
Content. The contrary not content. Not content. The contents will go to the right by the bar and the not contents the contents will go to the right by the throne and the not contents the left by the bar. Clear the lobby.
The question is that the motion in the name of Baroness Hoey be agreed to.
Speaker 9
My Lords, there have voted contents 20, not contents 63, so the not contents have it. The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Gillian Merron
I beg to move that the house now again be resumed into committee. Oh, resolved into, forgive me, that is my fault.
Speaker 9
The question is that the house do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 12, Lord Rennard.
Christopher John Rennard
My Lords, my father might be considered to have been lucky in that despite losing a leg in the First World War and developing diabetes in the 1920s, that was the decade in which insulin was developed and it saved his life. His treatment with insulin was so successful that it enabled me to be born in 1960 when he was over 70. When I developed diabetes myself in my 30s, it became way out of control and I needed daily insulin injections for 20 years. But with great support from St Thomas's Hospital, making major lifestyle changes, obtaining a continuous glucose monitor and being prescribed Mounjaro, I was able to come completely off insulin two years ago. My long-term blood sugar levels have now fallen to just 41 millimoles, which is below the pre-diabetic range.
But my Lords, many people are much less fortunate than me and they do not get the care which I do, whilst at the same time the prevalence of diabetes is increasing. Over 4.6 million people in the UK live with a formal diabetes diagnosis and that number is predicted to exceed 5 million very shortly.
An estimated 1.3 million people are living with undiagnosed type 2 diabetes, whilst 5.7 million people in England, adults, live with pre-diabetes. In total, more than 12 million adults, one in five of them, are living with diabetes or pre-diabetes. The direct cost of diabetes care to the NHS has been estimated at 10.7 billion pounds per year, representing around 10% of the entire NHS budget. When indirect impacts are included, total costs exceed 23 billion to 26 billion pounds annually. Diabetes UK estimates that this will surge to between 39 billion to 44 billion pounds per year by 2035 if current trends continue.
Most damningly, 80% of this vast expenditure is spent not on proactive care, but on treating people with largely preventable complications. Every week across the UK, there are many preventable complications arising from diabetes: on average, 812 strokes, 568 heart attacks, and 2,909 cases of heart failure. In England alone, there are more than 160 lower limb amputations every week, four out of five of which could be avoided with timely, high-quality care. People with diabetes occupy one in every six hospital beds, and diabetes is taking a severe toll on economic productivity, with over 360,000 working-age adults living with diabetes now economically inactive due to long-term sickness, a 43% increase in seven years. My Lords, we cannot continue to address this crisis with short-term financial thinking.
Treasury models, such as those we hear much about today, too often demand short-term savings within tight budgetary cycles, ignoring the immense long-term savings that could result from preventing complications. Nowhere is this short-termism more evident than in the unwarranted regional variation and postcode lotteries, exposing vulnerable patients across our health system. The flagship "Get It Right First Time" national report on children and young adults, published this year, reveals alarming disparities across England's integrated care boards. For the 56,000 children and young adults living with type 1 diabetes and 9,000 with early-onset type 2 diabetes, median blood sugar control ranges from just below 55 in top-performing units to over 70 in others. While some pediatric units complete all essential annual care checks for 98% of young patients, others achieve just 6%.
Patients are literally forced to move house across ICB boundaries just to access life-changing technology.
We now possess transformative tools that can eliminate these disparities if made consistently available. Continuous glucose monitors, or CGMs, have reached over 60% of people with type 1 diabetes, yet access remains quite restricted for those people with type 2 diabetes who, like me, could benefit from them immensely. Similarly, while over half of children with type 1 diabetes now use hybrid closed-loop systems, known as artificial pancreas systems, overall adult pump provision in the UK stands at just 15% compared to over 60% in the United States and far higher rates across Europe. Furthermore, for those under 18, hybrid closed-loop uptake ranges from 37% to 79% across different ICBs. Equally vital is the issue of early diagnosis and then intervention and specialised care.
Currently, 25% of individuals with type 1 diabetes and up to 30% of children and those from deprived backgrounds are only diagnosed with diabetes when presenting in emergency departments with life-threatening diabetic ketoacidosis, known as DKA. Evidence from Germany demonstrates that systematic early screening reduces DKA presentation rates from 30% down to just 2.5%. Likewise, we must confront the alarming rise of early-onset type 2 diabetes among working-age adults and under-40s. As we approach yet another major NHS reorganisation, we need to guarantee long-term sustainable funding for targeted initiatives like the NHS T2 Day program and the Diabetes 2 path to remission program, while rolling out at greater pace GLP-1 medication supplies like Ozempic and Mounjaro for many more people with diabetes. This brings me directly to the amendments tabled in my name after clause 84.
If we plan to abolish NHS England, we must address a critical moment of vulnerability for our public health infrastructure. My first amendment establishes a statutory requirement for the Secretary of State to secure the continuity of key national diabetes programs to at least the same extent as before the potential abolition of NHS England. This encompasses the NHS Diabetes Prevention Programme, the Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Programme, national provision of continuous glucose monitors, the rollout of hybrid closed-loop technology, and essential diabetes audits, including those for foot care and inpatient safety. It requires an explanatory statement on continuity before making any transfer schemes, alongside mandatory reports laid before Parliament detailing patient access, waiting times, and clinical outcomes. My second amendment requires the government to publish annual assessment reports over the next four years, specifically evaluating the impact of NHS England's abolition on diabetes services.
These reports must scrutinise changes in funding allocations, the operation of clinical audits, patient access to glucose monitoring and insulin delivery services, as well as specialist workforce capacity.
My Lords, consistency in high-quality care, equitable access to modern technology, robust prevention and early diagnosis are not luxury add-ons. They are the essential building blocks of a sustainable healthcare system, a productive economy and a healthy society. I hope therefore that the noble lady the Minister will see how these amendments will protect national diabetes services, enforce parliamentary accountability and ensure that the millions of people living with diabetes the care they need and which is very much in the national interest. I beg to move.
Speaker 9
Amendment proposed, clause 4, page 3, line 29, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Philip Hunt
It does seem to me that this actually goes to the heart of some of the issues we were discussing in relation to the noble Earl's amendment number 4, which is the balance between what the noble Lord is really attempting to seek, which is much more central direction in relation to diabetes services, and the wish of the NHS locally to be able to make their own decisions. Going back to the round table we had on Monday, when the CEO of NHS Alliance was concerned about central interference, if you like, as I think he would call it, into decisions made locally. On the other hand, if you take diabetes, the kind of variations the noble Lord has spoken about, when you think of the scale of the issue we have, the impact it has on population health, the cost it has to the health service, it's really almost unbelievable that you can have such variations. And I think actually there is a pushback here to people in the service, because how can it be justified that on such an important disease area, these kind of variations are allowed? I mean, why for instance isn't diabetes one of the top five priorities for integrated care boards?
But it doesn't appear to be. And it's sometimes difficult to work out how ICBs make their decisions in relation to prioritization. And so I think for me, my Lords, it is a salutary reminder that some of the reasons why we wish to have central interventions is because the local NHS seems incapable of actually sorting things like this out. So I think that I'm not sure about the noble Lord's amendments, but I think what he's aiming at are really, really important.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, these amendments tabled by my noble friend Lord Rennard raise some really important points and are intended to safeguard national diabetes services following the planned abolition of NHS England and to ensure that patients do not lose access to proven programs during that transition. And actually this is a point that has come to me time and time again from different charities representing different disease groups who are really concerned that the specialism and some of the services that are commissioned are going to be lost. And I'm sure we're going to be discussing this time and time again on other committee days.
As we've heard, diabetes is one of the greatest health challenges facing us all. According to Diabetes UK, over 12 million people in the UK are living with diabetes or pre-diabetes, and it costs the NHS around 10.7 billion every year. And that expenditure is linked to complications that can often be prevented through early intervention, effective treatment, and then the consistent monitoring as well as routine diabetes care. The amendments would therefore require the Secretary of State to maintain at a minimum the current provision of key national programs. As we've heard, they include the NHS type 2 diabetes prevention program, the diabetes path to remission program, continuous glucose monitoring, the rollout of hybrid closed-loop technology, and the national diabetes audit program.
And I should just flag that the type 2 diabetes prevention program, I understand, is recognized as a world-leading prevention intervention. We don't want to see that lost with this reorganization. The amendments would also strengthen transparency and accountability. Before any transfer of functions, the Secretary of State would be required to set out how continuity of these services will be guaranteed. Annual reports to Parliament would then provide clear information on patient access, waiting times, and outcomes, while separate assessments over the first four years following the abolition would monitor the impact on funding, workforce capacity, clinical audits, and access to technologies.
So I think at a time when diabetes continues to rise and the impact of it is felt by both by individuals and financially throughout the NHS, it's so significant, it's essential that we have confidence that these vital national programs will not only survive the organizational change but continue to improve outcomes for people living with diabetes. I look forward to hearing the response from the noble lady, the Minister.
Howe
My Lords, I too am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, for bringing forward these amendments and for drawing the committee's attention to the important issue of diabetes prevention, treatment, and care. I particularly welcome the focus in these amendments on innovation because this is an area in which we're seeing some genuinely promising developments. And one example was mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, and indeed by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, the emergence of hybrid closed-loop systems. For people living with type 1 diabetes, this technology has the potential to make an enormous difference. In April 2024, NHS England began a five-year program to roll out this technology to eligible children, young people, and adults living with type 1 diabetes.
And that was a very welcome development, and I hope that we will continue to see the program expanded so that more patients who would benefit from this technology are able to access it. It would be helpful to hear from the Minister about that and how the rollout of the program is progressing and how many patients have received the technology so far. As with any issue like this, improvements in accessing the technology are always forefront of commissioners' minds. So again, if she can say anything about that, it would be helpful. I'd also be interested to hear what assessment the government have made of the availability of specialist staff to support this rollout.
Developing an effective new technology is one thing, but ensuring that patients can actually access it and that clinical teams have the resources and expertise to provide it is another.
More widely, I think these amendments raise an important question about the future scale and impact of diabetes in this country. The noble lord, Lord Rennard, highlighted the statistics and the predictions from the International Diabetes Federation. Those predictions present a considerable challenge, not only for patients and their families, but also for the health service. And they also reinforce the importance of prevention, particularly in relation to type 2 diabetes, where earlier intervention can make a very considerable difference. Can the minister tell us what steps the government are taking to strengthen prevention and early diagnosis and to support the wider adoption of new technologies?
Finally, I also want to touch briefly on amendments 225 and 226, which raise a rather wider point about the abolition of NHS England and the continuity of existing national diabetes programs. We've discussed at some length during our consideration of the bill the importance of ensuring that the abolition of NHS England doesn't disrupt the delivery of essential services or lead to the loss of programs and expertise which are already delivering benefits to patients. The noble lord is absolutely right to raise that concern in the context of diabetes. I'm not necessarily persuaded that we need to place each of these requirements in statute, but I do think that the noble lord raises some entirely legitimate questions and I'd welcome assurances from the minister that these programs will continue to receive the attention and support they require throughout the transition. I look forward to what the minister has to say.
Gillian Merron
My lords, I am most grateful to the noble lord, Lord Rennard, for bringing this before the house and also to other noble lords for their contributions. The government does indeed recognize the importance of high-quality diabetes prevention, treatment, and care services, and I believe that our actions on this reflect it. So programs such as the NHS Diabetes Prevention Program, the Type 2 Diabetes Path to Remission Program, and the National Diabetes Audit all play an important role in improving outcomes for people living with diabetes. Turning to specifically amendments 225 and 226, this bill does allow, of course, for the transfer of functions and responsibilities from NHS England following its abolition, and that means a transfer that will not impact service provision. And to the noble lord, Earl Howe, the government does support effective diabetes services and innovations in various ways, but that includes ensuring the continued commissioning, monitoring, and improvement of these programs without the need for disease-specific provisions in primary legislation.
Moreover, specifying programs at this level of detail would, I believe, restrict our ability to adapt to new and changing evidence on effective treatments and technologies, and I know that's something that noble lords would not want to restrict. Similarly, a diabetes-specific reporting clause would duplicate existing monitoring and oversight arrangements, which are providing additional assurance without adding administrative burden and additional bureaucracy.
Turning to amendment 12, improvement of outcomes for people with diabetes does include absolutely reducing health inequalities. And that's already captured, and we've just had a debate on that in an earlier group, that's already captured in the general duty to reduce health inequalities set out in clause 4 of the bill. Furthermore, the modern service framework for cardiovascular disease, which was published in July, advocates a holistic cardiovascular kidney metabolic approach, including finding those with undiagnosed or unmanaged diabetes, initiating treatment, and increasing the number of people whose treatment is optimized with a strong focus on reducing inequalities. And with regard to amendment 25, I'd like to reassure your Lordships' House that the Secretary of State and the NHS already have powers to promote innovation across the health service, and the risk of singling out diabetes technologies in primary legislation is that it would create inconsistency with the approach taken for other conditions. Finally, rollout of glucose monitoring and automated insulin delivery technologies are already supported through NHS implementation arrangements based on established NICE guidance, therefore listing specific technologies in legislation could reduce the flexibility of the NHS to be as truly innovative as we would all want as new technology emerges.
Christopher John Rennard
My Lords, I thank the noble lady the Minister for her sympathy on these issues, and I'd like to thank all the people in her department who I know are very sincerely committed to trying to help people with diabetes, to help prevent its occurrence, and to provide the best possible care and treatment. But at the heart of the problem is what Lord Hunt of Kings Heath said, that there is a dilemma, that as people try to treat medical conditions like diabetes differently and say there should be a localist approach, there was a fundamental problem for the whole of the country in that if you fail to deal with this, the costs on all of us, the costs to taxpayers, the costs of people not working, the costs of not paying to HMRC, the costs of drawing down upon the DWP is growing enormously. And this is such a huge problem that as I think we've said many points in today's stage of the committee, we have to look across all government sections how we're all working together on all of these issues. And on that note, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 9
Is it your pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 13, Lord Patel, not moved. Amendment 14, Lord Patel of Bradford, not moved. Amendments 15, 16, and 17, Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, not moved.
The question is that clause 4 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. After clause 4, amendment 18, Baroness Tyler of Enfield, not moved.
Amendment 19, Lord Patel, not moved. Amendment 20, Baroness Pitkeathley, not moved. In clause 5, amendment 21, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath.
Philip Hunt
Well, clearly it's not ideal to start a debate, a really important debate at this time of night, so, but I hope noble Lords will feel they're able to take part in it as they would have done if we were meeting, actually doing this at a reasonable time. So I have four amendments in this group, 21, 173, 174, and 214. I'm very grateful for the support of the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle, the noble Baroness Lady Finlay, the noble Lord Lord Blackwell, and the noble Baroness Lady Barker.
Now, my Lords, during second reading debate, many peers expressed the wish to promote actions that would directly improve health outcomes and experiences of NHS patients. Here, my Lords, I believe there is a good opportunity. There were fewer mentions of social care, yet the lived experience of people reliant on care services, particularly those in residential care, is just as important as those being treated in hospitals. Many of these considerations also apply to mental health service inpatients. We know clearly many people are fearful of entering hospital.
Some say they would rather die than move into a care home. Treatment in mental health units must routinely be enforced by the process of being sectioned, a term which evokes fear. My amendments are designed to offer all service users the assurance that if there is someone who matters to them and is prepared to support them when they're receiving care or treatment, not only in their own home, they can nominate that person as their health and care partner. In most cases, this will be an entirely voluntary role, accepted by a spouse or partner, a close relative, or a special friend. Some people who live with a paid companion or individuals with complex needs who employ a personal assistant may choose to nominate that person as their health and care partner.
The essential element is that it must be the individual who makes the choice. When I first raised this matter in your Lordships' House in December 2022, it was in the wake of the terrible distress caused by the separation inflicted on care home residents and those who loved them during the COVID pandemic. Time did not allow for my Protection of Care Recipients and Carers Bill to proceed, and a similar fate befell a measure entitled the Care Supporters Bill, introduced in the other place in October 2023, which would have included hospital patients as well as care home residents. Instead, the then Care Minister used a statutory power to amend Regulation 9 of the CQC fundamental standards to protect visiting. A review of this legislation, published in March this year, judged it to have been well-intentioned but ineffective.
It re-promised primary legislation when parliamentary time allows. My view, my Lords, is the time is now. Now, Baroness Hallett has recently published her sixth report from the UK COVID Inquiry. She has used the language of rights when listing the principles that must determine future policy towards care home residents and those dear to them. For those who were then separated from people they loved and had promised to care for, the publication of the report has reopened those wounds.
"This is an open-ended trauma, a wound that won't close," Jan-Wier Wierzbowski told the inquiry. My Lords, I think we need to offer a response, to offer some solace, assure people they've been heard, that action will be taken to ensure that any one of us residing in a care home or entering the hospital will always have access to a nominated health and care partner. This person will not be a visitor in our lives; he or she will be an essential component. This enacted within this Health Bill would immediately make a tangible difference to patient experience, the quality of care, and outcomes. Just consider the difference it would make to someone whose language is not English, to someone of any age who suffers from anxiety or cognitive impairment, who may have difficulty understanding what is happening, yet may have a very complex decision to make.
When someone is approaching the end of life, they need their dear ones more than ever. People who have kept vigil with a dying relative are likely to discover that they can alleviate suffering in small practical ways in partnership with the clinical team.
The term health and care partner may be unfamiliar, but it has been chosen after thoughtful discussion within the NHS, where senior nurses have been meeting with a range of stakeholders to develop a policy that's now ready for implementation. Where it's already been piloted, staff have found it supportive, patient outcomes have improved, and complaints have reduced. My Lords, I have had and seen a lot of case studies where visitors, relatives, friends have raised concerns about the person who is resident and then have found themselves banned from visiting. And I think, my Lords, this is really a very, very difficult situation. I do think we have to shift the power imbalance in health and care settings.
These amendments are one way I propose to do so, and I do hope the government will be sympathetic. I beg to move.
Speaker 9
Amendment proposed, clause 5, page 3, line 34, after carers, insert health and care partners.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, I added my name to several of these amendments because I think they are crucially important. I read them very carefully to make sure that in the event of there being major safeguarding concerns, that this wouldn't cut across them. And I don't believe it would. I think it will improve care. I would just say that I do think it requires a change of attitude on behalf of healthcare staff to accept the fact that sometimes the person who is the relative, the carer who's been looking after someone at home, knows only too well exactly how to communicate with them if they have communication difficulties, exactly how to manage even complex equipment, such as managing their ventilator, sucking them out or whatever.
In the hospice when I was medical director, I clearly remember one lady with a very horrible tumor, and her children wanted to do her dressings for her, and she wanted the children to do them. And it was really important for those children to be able and helped and encouraged to care as they wanted to, so that they were with her right through her illness. And we provided accommodation for them to sleep there when she was dying. We also provided a family room and even had beds that we could put together and zip together so a relative could actually sleep next to somebody. And it really transformed care.
It took a lot of pressure off the nursing staff because there was somebody there all the time, and if they became agitated, they could call for help. The staff, however, in many units can feel threatened by relatives who say, no, no, the person would prefer something done one way or another. And it's important that if there is someone with a person who's the patient, that they have access to food, they have access to drink, that they have a comfortable seating to sit on, not a hard plastic chair, that it's clear where they can use the toilet or even take a shower and be accommodated. It does not cost anything, but it saves a lot of staff time. So I really hope that this, these amendments would be adopted into the main bill to bring about that change.
Those of us who went to the meeting about Debra, which is epidermolysis bullosa, were very touched by the stories that we heard, the cases we heard, where the mother in particular was doing the child's dressing changes.
And it was essential that the mother could go with that child into hospital, even when they became an adult, that they could go there on an adult ward, because they knew exactly the least painful way to do those dressing changes, which the staff who didn't know the person beforehand just didn't have the same knowledge and therefore couldn't apply the same skills. Baroness Campbell of Surbiton spoke very powerfully about the need for a personal health budget, and I know she has extensive experience of having her husband with her on many occasions when she's been in hospital, and there have been occasions when he's actually saved her life. This is not minor, this is very important.
Claire Tyler
My Lords, I underline first of all what the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, said about how less than ideal it is to be dealing with such an important group of amendments of such sensitivity this very late in the day, but, you know, we are where we are. And I very much support the amendments put forward by the noble Lord. I remember very clearly my personal anguish at not being able to visit my mother for a long time in her care home. It really was an absolute agony for me. And I just think what happened during COVID, it must never be allowed to happen again.
I think of those care home residents that died without the love and support of any of their relatives by them. It's an absolute scandal, it's shocking, we must make sure it doesn't happen again. My Lords, moving on to my amendments, which are about unpaid carers and their relationship with the NHS. As we know, unpaid carers have a very frequent contact with the NHS, but recognition and support for them can be very variable indeed. And I think that the present Health Bill presents a really important opportunity to place essential rights and support for unpaid carers in legislation for the first time, in order to bring these on a par with existing rights that carers already have in relation to local authorities.
And my amendments are designed to improve the identification, health, and wellbeing, as well as improving the provision of breaks to which carers should be entitled. My Lords, there are some 4.7 million unpaid carers in England, and the value of carers' support is worth 152 billion in England alone. And actually, do you know what, that happens to be about the same as the budget of the whole of the NHS. And we have so many unpaid carers, they are holding the NHS together. Turning to amendment 88, the duty to identify and record unpaid carers, the Care Act 2014 already places duties on local authorities relating to the identification of unpaid carers, but no equivalent duty exists for integrated care boards, which commission the vast majority of health services.
And unpaid carers are more likely to come into contact with health services earlier than they are with local authorities. And there's evidence of significant under-identification of unpaid carers within the NHS. Indeed, analysis by the Nuffield Trust of 13 million GP records found that for every one carer identified by GP practices, four were not, meaning around 1 million carers were effectively missing from GP records. So there's real problems with identification rates, and that's compounded by the fact that more carers are identified in affluent areas compared to deprived areas. And there's so many very cogent reasons why identification is so important.
For example, public health measures can be targeted at unpaid carers: free flu vaccinations, assessments for common health problems, etc. Winter pressures on NHS can be alleviated with targeted support and advice for unpaid carers.
and of course inclusion of unpaid carers in hospital discharge planning could help to reduce avoidable readmissions and that's just to name but three and ironically and this is the last key point I want to make here unpaid carers can take a long time to actually identify themselves and understand that they are carers in fact some research I saw showed it took for some 36% of them it took them up to three years to understand they were a carer so without a statutory duty I fear that identification of carers will continue to depend on local priorities and resources and whilst some areas have excellent systems others identify very few carers and a statutory duty here I think would introduce much greater consistency
moving on to amendment 89 a duty which places a duty on ICBs to promote the health and wellbeing of carers my Lords I think we all know that unpaid carers consistently experience poorer physical and mental health outcomes than non-carers and this is and they just forget and neglect their own their own health needs just just one one statistic here the GP patient survey 2025 found that 72% of carers report a long-term condition or disability compared with 60% of non-carers and many many carers are just unable to prioritize their own health
I think most tellingly Carers Week research from last year found that 40% of current carers said they had postponed or cancelled a medical appointment test scan treatment or therapy because of caring that's an estimated 4.8 million people my Lords the final point here is that ICBs rely heavily on unpaid carers to keep people well at home and reduce hospital admissions therefore supporting carers' health I would maintain is vital to NHS sustainability finally moving to my amendments 175 and 176 these are about a right to a break for unpaid carers and a national respite scheme
and I very much thank other noble Lords who have added their name actually to all of my amendments in this group but these two amendments essentially do the same thing they ensure that carers who are assessed as being entitled to a break actually receive one because although many carers in England are entitled to this assessment under the Care Act many assessments just do not result in meaningful breaks or replacement care there's many statistics here but I will just mention one which is official data from 2023-24 shows that only 8% of all unpaid carers were assessed or supported by their local authorities and I just think that's an absolutely shockingly low figure so unsurprisingly carers describe severe exhaustion burnout isolation and worsening mental health resulting from being unable to step away from these caring responsibilities
my Lords local flexibility in the delivery of breaks has too often resulted in inconsistency and postcode variation whether an unpaid carer can access a meaningful break should not depend on where they live or the financial pressures facing their local authority and that's why in amendment 176 also places a requirement for the Secretary of State to provide financial assistance to deliver it my Lords there was much more I wanted to say but the time is late and thank you very much
Speaker 127
Lords will not be surprised to know I rise to give very enthusiastic support to the amendments about unpaid carers in the name of Baroness Tyler
As she's very clearly said to us, one of the great difficulties about the carers' movement is that people do not identify themselves as carers. And that's partly because you become a carer in different ways. Sometimes it creeps up on you. You know, you start by doing your dad's shopping and then you gradually do more for him until you're in the caring situation. Another time, your mum suddenly has a stroke and there you are suddenly in the carer role.
But either way, you don't prepare for it, you don't discuss it with anybody, and you certainly don't identify yourself. And that's why having somebody else identify you is of huge importance. And the only way, in fact, that you're going to identify yourself as a carer and therefore have access to any kinds of services at all. And ironically, although carers have rights with local authorities under various other acts in the past, they have no rights as far as the health services are concerned. And yet, it'll probably be with their GP that they make initial contact.
We did at one point have a duty on GPs to identify carers, but sadly that fell by the wayside during a different government. So I very much think that identifying carers should be something that is a duty in order to help carers and to help support that huge workforce. Similarly, that applies to promoting the health and well-being of carers. Because as we've heard, 72% of carers report a long-term condition compared with 60% of people who are not carers. And they don't take care of their health because they're too busy caring, and so they neglect their own health.
And as ever with unpaid carers, there is an economic as well as a moral case for supporting them. Because here's this huge workforce, five million people, providing care worth, as the noble lady has reminded us, the equivalent of another health service. It's in everybody's interest to keep them well and doing what they want to do. They do lovingly and willingly usually, but to support them as much as possible.
Speaker 81
I rise just to support the amendments in Baroness Tyler's name and really have little to add to what both Baroness Tyler and Baroness Pitkeathley have said, except to say that for young carers, respite is absolutely essential and regular respite. That might be going to a club once a week to get out of the house and maintain other connections outside school, for example. And we know how important that is in terms of preventing mental ill health. The other thing I wanted to say was there is huge inequality. I was a carer for my mother for nearly three years who had Alzheimer's disease.
When I'd had enough, I could afford to pay, together with, you know, she paid, but I could put her into a really nice nursing home for two weeks, which is in fact where she ended up for the last eight months of her life. But it wasn't difficult if you had the money to plan it. And there are lots of people who do not. And I really can't emphasize that enough, that I think that kept me well and it also, in her moments of lucidity, made her feel independent that she was paying to go to give me a break. So I just think we need to think about how difficult it is for people who can't do that.
And the third thing that I wanted to say was that particularly for people with dementia, Admiral Nurses should be able to identify those carers that are really in need of respite.
And for many people, two weeks may not be what they need. What they need is 24 hours once a week. And again, the care home that my mother was in is now offering that and managing to have kind of three people twice a week, and that enables other people to go off. Now, I'm pleased to say that some of the beds in that nursing home are now paid for by the local authority, so, you know, things may be a bit more equitable than they were then. But there is clear evidence that if you give respite to foster carers, foster carers can go on.
And let's learn from that and see how we can apply that to carers right across the country, but with a particular emphasis on those who really cannot fund anything themselves to help.
George Young
My Lords, I want to follow briefly in the slipstream of the noble ladies, Baroness Tyler, Pitkeathley and Watkins, and speak about carers. They all spoke very movingly. I want to speak in particular about young carers. Last week at oral questions, I pointed out there were 15,000 school children spending more than 50 hours a week looking after their parents or siblings, and of those, 3,000 were aged between five and nine. And in that context, I pointed out the disadvantages they face in the field of education, being suspended, arriving late and underachieving.
But also, those young carers underperform, if that's the right word, in terms of mental and physical health. Also, they are rarely identified until on average three years by the relevant authorities. And in health terms, that could be the GP, it could be other health practitioners, or it could be those providing mental health services. As I said, it takes an average of three years to identify the young carers. And if you look at polling from Carers Trust, it found that just under a third of young carers said that they felt stressed or worried simply because of their caring role.
And the GP patient survey shows that young adults, young adult carers, are notably more likely themselves to live with long-term physical health conditions, around 40% for young carers as opposed to 29% for young adults who are not carers. But despite these health inequalities, very few young carers are identified by health professionals. And that was brought home by the recent tragic case in the child safeguarding practice review, Cooper and Harris. Two boys were living with their mother who had multiple health issues and had regular emergency hospital admissions. She told the hospital and the medical staff several times that her young sons looked after her at home, and also the ambulance staff recognized the distressed experience experienced by the boys when their mother had a particularly bad fall.
Despite this, they weren't picked up as young carers. Neither boy was identified as a young carer, and tragically, because the support for that family was not adequate, one of them found his mother lifeless one morning and had to call the emergency services. Now, while the previous NHS long-term plan included specific measures relating to young carers, such as top tips for GPs, improving access to local support for young carers, the current long-term plan does not mention young carers at all.
My Lords, amendment 88, as has been explained by Baroness Tyler, would go a long way to helping improve identification of unpaid carers of all ages, including young carers, by placing requirements on the ICBs to identify them, mirroring the responsibility of local authorities. Amendment 89 would introduce a duty for integrated care boards to promote the health and wellbeing of carers, including young carers. And through my role as vice chair on the APPG of young carers and young adult carers, I routinely hear about the impact of caring on the health and wellbeing of young carers. Sutton Trust's study found that young carers were more likely than young people without caring responsibilities not just to report severe psychological distress, but also more vulnerable to self-harm and also attempts on their own lives. And the harrowing child safeguarding practice review, headed Molly, showed that even though the young carer was identified, professionals supporting Molly's mother, such as GPs, did not sufficiently consider the needs of Molly, who took her own life with her mother's medication when she was just 14.
Finally, turning to respite care mentioned by Baroness Watkins, the provision of regular respite breaks can help support the health and wellbeing of unpaid carers, and one of the things which carers always say makes the biggest difference is that break. And for young carers, respite can take many different forms, from young carer groups, trips in the school holidays, which so many miss out on, or even being supported to access opportunities as a family. The Welsh government actually does this. So finally, these amendments I think complement the recent document, Unpaid Carers Action Plan: Recognise, Refer and Reach, which I welcome, and I very much hope the government can respond sympathetically to this group of amendments.
Carys Davina Tanni Grey
I rise very briefly to speak to amendment 214, which complements other amendments in my name, and this is specifically around people with high support needs when they go into hospital and the care that they receive. Two of my stays in hospital in the summer, I was repeatedly asked if I had a carer, and at the time it felt very patronising as opposed to supportive. But the second reading of this bill gave me another opportunity to have a lived experience of the NHS, and this time I spent a week in St Thomas's, which was an entirely different experience, but also gave me the opportunity to talk to a number of people who would be affected by this amendment. So nurses might be trained, but they might not be able to offer the appropriate support that someone with high care needs requires. And if they're unwell, it might be very difficult for a person to explain quite complicated care.
And there's a real fear of a number of disabled people with high support needs about going into hospital in terms of the impact it'll have on their personal health budget, that it might be taken away, it might be changed, and also who pays for that care while the individual is in hospital. And at a time of great worry, you don't want people to avoid going into hospital because they're worried about their personal health budget. Hospitals might be accessible, but they might not have the appropriate facilities for disabled people. And this is where carers can make a real difference. Another individual contacted me to say that the nursing staff didn't know how to use the hoist, so it took four members of staff to operate it, where it takes one person at home, but that one person wasn't allowed on the ward to help the individual.
And another case, someone with cerebral palsy, they're waiting for surgery, they can transfer into a hospital bed, but have been told if they can't transfer to the surgical bed, they can't have the surgery, which they can't do. Their carer is not allowed in to help them, so actually they're wasting all the pre-operative time to be, they know they're going to be told that they can't have the surgery.
So there are some of these issues I think we need to explore further, we might be able to do in further groups of amendments, but the current system is at best disjointed, and surely we should be able to do better around the whole issue of carers.
Speaker 130
My Lords, this would seem a convenient time to pause proceedings for the day. I therefore beg to move that the debate on this amendment be adjourned.
Speaker 9
The question is that the debate on amendment 21 be now adjourned. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it.
Speaker 9
The question is that the House be resumed. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it.
The question is that the House do now adjourn.