House of Commons

13 October 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:10 - 00:16
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Order, order.  We start with questions Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero.  Liz Jarvis. 
00:16 - 00:19
Liz Jarvis
LD Member of Parliament | Eastleigh
Member of Parliament | Eastleigh
Liz Jarvis
Question number one, Mr. Speaker. 
00:19 - 00:54
Lab Member of Parliament | Doncaster North
Member of Parliament | Doncaster North
Edward Samuel Miliband
Mr. Speaker, we know that energy is simply unaffordable for too many people and we are very clear that we need to get bills down for good.  Now, one of the ways that we can do this is to decouple the price of gas and electricity, and we are already making progress by bringing on more clean power than ever before so that gas sets the price less of the time.  Gas is currently setting the price 60% of the time compared to 90% in 2020.  We need to go further, but we're taking action to do that.  And we're also expanding contracts for difference that fix the price of renewables. 
00:54 - 01:05
Speaker 7
So we will take the action that is necessary over the coming months so that we can break the link between gas and electricity and so that consumers can benefit from cheaper renewables. 
01:05 - 01:46
Liz Jarvis
LD Member of Parliament | Eastleigh
Member of Parliament | Eastleigh
Liz Jarvis
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  I previously raised decoupling of gas and electricity prices with the former Energy Secretary in March, so I welcome the government's continued commitment.  However, eight months into the illegal war in Iran, rising gas prices have pushed the price cap up 4% this month, wiping out VAT savings on energy bills, while Trump's lifting of sanctions on Russian diesel leaves fuel prices once again at the mercy of Putin.  In my constituency of Eastleigh, over a quarter of households are in fuel poverty and I've spoken with many businesses struggling with spiralling bills.  So will the Secretary of State go further and faster on decoupling gas and electricity prices, including by investing more in homegrown renewable energy? 
01:46 - 02:30
Speaker 7
Mr. Speaker, the answer to that is simple: yes, absolutely.  And look, we are very clear, everyone can see with their eyes what is driving up energy bills.  It is our exposure, our acute exposure to global fossil fuel markets that we do not control.  This side of the House, we are very clear that our pathway out of this is by investing in renewables, by investing in clean power, so that we do have homegrown energy that we control.  And it is candidly, Mr. Speaker, an absolute shame and a travesty that the party opposite that agreed with us for a very long time and that there was cross-party consensus is reneging on that and reneging on our ability, on our ability to control our energy system so it impacts on our consumers. 
02:30 - 02:38
Speaker 4
Can I just remind everybody, it's meant to be through the chair, not looking at the members, just try and take some confrontation and try and keep the chamber calm.  Thanks for that.  Mike Reader. 
02:38 - 02:57
Lab Member of Parliament | Northampton South
Member of Parliament | Northampton South
Michael Reader
Mr. Speaker, the Secretary of State is right that gas sets the price for power most of the time.  Every wind farm and solar array built in our country weakens that link, but Reform and the Conservatives repeatedly object to developments in Northamptonshire.  Does the Secretary of State agree with me that the route to cheaper bills is to build and invest and not retreat from green power? 
02:57 - 03:17
Lab Member of Parliament | Doncaster North
Member of Parliament | Doncaster North
Edward Samuel Miliband
Mr. Speaker, my honourable friend is completely right.  We are very clear that the route to getting bills down is through clean power.  That is why we are proud that over the course of the last two years we have unlocked 100 billion pounds of investment in clean power.  We will do what is required.  It is just a shame that the party opposite has lost the plot. 
03:17 - 03:19
Speaker 1
Pippa Heylings, Liberal Democrats spokesperson. 

03:19 - 03:56

Pippa Heylings

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Households and businesses have been left at the mercy of a broken energy system and they're paying the price for that.

As we've heard, gas is still setting the price of electricity. Gas is now at a three-year high, due to go up again in January when winter energy prices, you know, fuel energy use goes up. While other European countries are responding to the energy crisis by accelerating electrification, we in the UK don't have a plan. So will the Secretary of State agree with us that we need a national electrification strategy to bring down bills, decouple gas from electricity, and also to make the most of our increasing renewables?

03:56 - 04:32

Speaker 7

Mr. Speaker, the honorable member is completely right that our route out of this is through clean power and we need to ensure that consumers and businesses feel the benefit through electrification. Now I will reassure her we do have a plan and we do have a strategy and we're getting on with it. And what we're doing, for example, through our Warm Homes Plan, is about ensuring that across the country homes and businesses have access to solar, to heat, to clean heat that will ensure that they benefit from this. So we are clear, electrification is the way forward. Countries across Europe are watching the UK and seeing our progress and we will absolutely run at it.

04:32 - 04:33

Tristan Osborne.

04:33 - 04:38

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number two.

04:38 - 05:37

Edward Samuel Miliband

With your permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions number two and seven together. Look, we know that people are worried about rising energy bills at a time when the cost of living is biting. And we know that we need to provide breathing space. That's why one of the first things the Prime Minister did on the job was to scrap VAT on electricity bills. That is on top of 150 pounds that we took off the cost of energy.

But look, we are really, really clear that the scale of what we are seeing requires us to have a concerted effort to get bills down. That is why we are running on clean energy to reduce our exposure to global fossil fuel markets. That's why we're rolling out the Warm Homes Plan so that we can upgrade our homes. Solar, batteries, clean heat can reduce bills by 600 to 800 pounds. But critically, that is why we are determined to put the public back in control of an energy system that the party opposite lost control of so it can work in the interest of consumers.

05:37 - 05:56

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I thank the Minister for that response? In my constituency in Stodland, Octopus Energy is working with social housing tenants to reduce energy bills and cut costs this winter. What more can the government do working with the private sector to promote renewable technologies to reduce bills this winter?

05:56 - 06:29

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend is completely right to highlight the example of Octopus Energy in his constituency. And we are really clear that upgrading our homes is a key route to how we reduce bills. And that is why through the Warm Homes Plan we are investing records, billions, in upgrading our homes. Solar, batteries, clean heat, insulation can save households 600 to 800 pounds. We are committed to devolving this so that what we see is a huge acceleration, street by street, area by area, estate after estate.

06:29 - 06:33

Speaker 10

That is why, how we drive down energy bills for good.

06:33 - 06:59

Jim Dickson

Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for her response? Clearly a lot is being done to protect low-income residents from the effect of rising bills, but can I ask her, with the energy cap expected to rise considerably at the start of next year, what further conversations she has had with the Treasury in order to find additional ways to protect those on the lowest incomes from the effect of rising bills?

06:59 - 07:22

Speaker 7

Look, Mr. Speaker, can I thank my honorable friend for asking this important question? We understand and we know that low-income families will be the ones that will be hardest hit by rising prices and we are acutely aware of that. So we are working across government, including with our colleagues in the Treasury, to think about how we give people some breathing room. But it's important to emphasize that we have acted.

07:22 - 07:44

Edward Samuel Miliband

We have removed VAT from domestic electricity bills. That comes into force straight away. We are taking cost, 150 pounds of cost off bills, and we are also delivering the Warm Homes Discount, that's 150 pounds to 6 million of our lowest earning households. So we understand the pressure that households are under. We will act and we will stand by people to support them.

07:44 - 08:18

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There are many people, not just in my constituency but right across the country, who rely on off-grid energy. And I recognize the government has taken steps to try and help them, but so many of them have been exposed to massive shocks and leaps in the cost of filling their tank with oil or gas. Can the government look at doing a little bit more to help so many people who are incredibly vulnerable to these energy shocks?

08:18 - 08:46

Speaker 7

The member raises a really important point. We know that families, that households off-grid are under a huge amount of pressure, and we are taking action to support them. We have put aside 50 million to support, for example, families on heating oil. This is something that we are encouraging, because the uptake has been lower than we want. We're encouraging households to do that, but we're also bringing forward regulation of heating oil so that we can protect households.

We know that there is more that we can do and we're absolutely committed to getting it done.

08:46 - 09:10

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Cornwall Insight's forecast energy price cap will increase by a further 16% in January. Now I know the Secretary of State has spoken about VAT off electricity bills. That's 45 pounds to an average household. In reality, that's like trying to fill a swimming pool with a thimble.

It's not going to work. So how will the Secretary of State help to protect families who are already struggling, and will she consider an essential energy guarantee so all of the energy that we need can be affordable for every household?

09:10 - 09:53

Speaker 7

Mr. Speaker, we are very clear about where the end destination is. We need to get to an energy system that is affordable for everyone, and we absolutely recognize that at the moment it is not. We are taking short-term action to give people breathing space, but ultimately I come back to: why are families under so much pressure? It is because we are acutely exposed to global fossil fuel markets we do not control. So when we talk about clean energy, it is because that is the route to which we get bills down.

We have to take the long-term action. We've also got to make sure that we're reforming the market so it works in the interest of consumers. Breathing space, standing by people because we need to, but absolutely taking the hard long-term action so we fix this problem for good.

09:53 - 10:13

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With approximately 15% of Derby South households estimated to be living in fuel poverty, too many families will be dreading higher energy bills as the nights draw in. What reassurances can the Secretary of State offer my constituents that as much help as possible is on its way?

10:13 - 10:49

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, thank you to my honorable friend. Look, we know that families across the country will be very, very worried this winter. I've been to his constituency, I've been to constituencies across the country, and I understand the pressure that people are under. We have taken action on breathing space. We will have the 150 pounds of the Warm Homes Discount.

We're also driving forward home upgrades because that is the way that we can get bills down. We're doing that through local authorities. But be in no doubt, we understand that the status quo is untenable, Mr. Speaker, and we will take the action that is necessary to drive bills down.

10:49 - 11:39

Edward Robert Jenrick

Last week the Secretary of State signed off a massive solar farm called The Steeples in my constituency. It comes on the back of another massive solar farm called One Earth that was approved by her predecessor earlier in the summer, and a third sits on her desk today called Great North Road. In aggregate, if she signs off this latest one, 10% of the entire landmass of my constituency will be solar farms, and my own constituents will see no benefit from this in terms of their own energy bills. I wrote to her earlier in the summer, congratulating her on her new position and saying, would she like to come to my constituency, meet my local residents, and make the case for these giant solar farms to my constituents if she really believes they're in their best interests?

11:39 - 11:48

Lindsay Hoyle

The honorable member's been here a long time. Please look at the chair rather than the person that's answering the question. These are the rules of the House, not my rules. Secretary of State.

11:48 - 12:32

Speaker 7

Mr. Speaker, the thing I would gently point out to the honorable member is that less than 1% of land use will be taken up by solar farms even under our most ambitious assumptions. But look, let's come back to the conversation that we're having. Energy bills are too high. We are far too exposed to global fossil fuel markets. We therefore need homegrown energy that we control.

Solar is a cheap and effective way in which we do that. So look, the member opposite may not have a plan or indeed care about having a plan about how we get energy bills down. We on this side of the house are very clear about what we need to do and renewables is our route to driving bills down and that is the thing that the public expect of us.

12:32 - 12:37

Lindsay Hoyle

Shadow Minister Dr. Sir Ashley Fox. Welcome.

12:37 - 13:23

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Britain already has the highest electricity prices in Europe, which makes all our families worse off. Now the Prime Minister's decision to end VAT on household electricity bills for only six months is a tiny step in the right direction. But this government needs to do much more. So will the Secretary of State reduce household energy bills by 200 pounds a year by adopting the Conservatives' cheap power plan?

Will she extend that VAT cut, axe the carbon tax and scrap renewables obligation contracts so that all British households are better off?

13:23 - 14:10

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, I don't think the honorable member should have mentioned the cheap power plan, the plan that is based on dodgy figures that they can't add up. Look, what I would say in the spirit of not point scoring is candidly, and candidly, if we, if we were sitting on the record of the party opposite that were in power for 14 years, that had the opportunity to decouple us from global fossil fuel markets, that had the opportunity to invest in clean energy and did none of it, we are in the position that we are in, Mr. Speaker, because of the inaction and the failure of the side opposite. So I think a little bit of humility. There is no plan. Their cheap power plan is based on dodgy numbers and candidly we do have a plan for how we get bills down.

14:10 - 14:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Ollie Glover, question three please. Minister.

14:14 - 14:38

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer we all felt the impact of climate change, whether in our homes, workplaces or in our schools. The Warm Homes Plan will ensure that cooling as well as heating measures are available for the most vulnerable homes and additionally in England and Wales all eligible households can benefit from the expanded boiler upgrade scheme which now includes air-to-air heat pumps which are able to heat and cool homes.

14:38 - 15:06

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government's commitment to improving the energy efficiency of our homes is welcome and is a stark contrast to the Conservatives' apparent embrace of a Fred Flintstone home standard. This year saw the hottest summer on record and climate change science indicates these temperatures are going to become the norm. So can the Minister assure the house that the standards that he mentioned will take full account of those trends and the need to efficiently cool our buildings?

15:06 - 15:18

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I can give him that assurance and he will also know that we are currently reviewing part O of the building regulations on overheating in order to ensure that buildings in the future are well prepared for the temperatures that we may face and be able to adapt to climate change.

15:18 - 15:19

Alistair Strathern.

15:19 - 15:38

Speaker 30

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With this summer's extreme heat showing the effects of climate change are very much with us in the here and now, it's vital we support households to adapt to this new reality as well as tackling the effects of climate change at source. The inclusion of air-to-air heat pumps which provide clean cooling as well as heating tech is very welcome, but despite this announcement, the delay so far in accreditation mean that uptake has been incredibly slow.

15:38 - 15:50

Speaker 22

I convened over 50 MPs over summer to push the accreditors to get a move on and ensure more homes can benefit from this. How are ministers holding these accreditation agencies to account to ensure more households in my constituency can benefit from this cooling tech?

15:50 - 16:11

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to praise my honorable friend for the work that he's been doing and working collaboratively with us to put some gentle pressure on the accreditation bodies to ensure that we see progress in this. I'll be meeting with the relevant bodies soon and we hope to be able to unlock this at pace.

16:11 - 17:04

Pippa Heylings

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The new norms of extreme weather that we're seeing now caused by climate change mean that, as my honorable friend has said, we've got to think about not only warming our homes but cooling them. And thousands of families are dipping into hard-earned savings to install heat pumps and to cut emissions. In my constituency of South Cambridgeshire, we are 25th in the country for heat pump uptake, and I'm really proud of that. And that's as a result of heat pump subsidies, which is why I'm really worried, Mr. Speaker, that we've heard rumors that the government is considering deep cuts to the Warm Homes Plan.

So would the Secretary of State agree with me that failing to electrify at scale keeps us needlessly chained to overseas gas and volatile petrostates, and to rob energy security to fund defense is a fool's errand?

17:04 - 17:35

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thanks the honorable lady for her question. We fully support the Warm Homes Plan and the Boiler Upgrade Scheme. We've had a record-breaking year this year on the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, over 8,000 applications in July, which is more than double what we saw in the previous year, not least because of those homes that were off-grid deciding to adopt a heat pump. I'm sure many of them were in her constituency.

And we continue to support the Boiler Upgrade Scheme and I'm sure we will see continued uptake of it over the coming months.

17:35 - 17:38

Pippa Heylings

Question number four, Mr. Speaker.

17:38 - 18:09

Sarah Jones

Good morning, Mr. Speaker. With your permission, I will answer question number four and 10 together. My colleagues raise an excellent point. In June of this year, I alongside the Cabinet Office launched a climate and nature security task force to assess our resilience, the first meeting of which will take place next week with external experts to challenge our preparedness. Sadly, this task force became even more relevant after the extremes of this summer and allowed us to feel what scientists have been telling us for many years.

18:09 - 18:15

Speaker 25

The Prime Minister has also confirmed that he will host a wildfire summit this month.

18:15 - 18:44

Speaker 50

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over the summer, my constituents in East Worthing and Shoreham, like many across the country, endured unrelenting and scorching heat. For many years, we've focused on cold homes in winter and now we need to turn our attention to hot homes in the summer, and it was good to hear in an earlier answer some of what the government has been doing. What steps is the department taking to help people adapt homes and public buildings to our increasingly hot summers?

18:44 - 19:19

Sarah Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for raising this. We are indeed living through the extremes of climate change and feeling it so intensely this summer. It should encourage us all to accelerate our efforts to mitigate but also to expand those opportunities to adapt. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme, as my honorable friend has already allowed for air-to-air heat pumps, which are both able to heat and cool our homes at the same time. But we want to go further, and that's why the Warm Homes Plan set out our intention to introduce passive cooling measures into our capital-funded schemes, including solar shading, shutters, reflective window coatings, and cooler building materials.

19:19 - 19:53

Anna Dixon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As colleagues have said, we endured one of the hottest summers on record with 10 days reaching 35 degrees, that's double the previous record.

And together with that, we saw deaths from extreme heat. When we think about insulating homes, we think about keeping ourselves warm, but home insulation is just as critical in protecting against extreme heat. So can the Minister say a little bit more to the House about what steps the government is taking to ensure new homes that we're building are designed to protect people against extreme heat.

19:53 - 20:33

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend for raising this and she's been a long-standing champion on retrofitting, but as for new build, this side of the House, we are proud of the future building standards which requires all new homes must be zero carbon ready to ensure they adapt to and can mitigate to the impacts of climate change. Within the building regulations, it states new homes must be designed to reduce overheating risk, prioritizing passive measures such as limiting exposure to heat from the sun and openable windows to remove excess heat. But a full technical review is underway to ensure those regulations remain effective and fit for the future.

20:33 - 20:35

Lindsay Hoyle

Patrick Spencer.

20:35 - 21:06

Speaker 56

The Eastern Letheringham solar farm application in my constituency has finally been forced to get an environmental impact assessment. Considering the vast size of the proposed development, over 200 acres across fertile farmland, it was a complete waste of time to think that it would ever get through planning without one. So can the Minister make a commitment to consider forcing all solar developments on rural land to get an environmental impact assessment.

21:06 - 21:46

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable colleague for this question. I'm a little unsure how it totally relates, but in terms of I think we are looking at how to make sure we align the the... I think I'm speaking from the dispatch box, but thank you. In terms of I think in terms of you were talking about the environmental assessments of the solar farms, we we do obviously want to make sure that our policies are in line with Defra policies at the same time. We've worked very closely with Defra, we continue to do so in terms of the land use framework and make sure that we are delivering on our clean power at the same time as improving our nature restoration at the same time.

21:46 - 21:52

Speaker 26

And it was great over the recess to talk to solar providers who looked at biodiversity increase from solar farms.

21:52 - 21:53

Sarah Dyke.

21:53 - 22:16

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Mr. Speaker, British food security is in real jeopardy. Extreme weather is becoming more severe, more frequent, and more unpredictable, and the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit warns that 2026 could be the worst UK harvest on record. So what discussions has the Minister had with Defra colleagues to strengthen British farms' resilience to extreme weather.

22:16 - 22:48

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend for her very important question. It's one of the reasons why we launched the Climate and Nature Security Taskforce before this summer. As I said in my previous answer, sadly it's become even more relevant after this summer, the impacts that we have been having on farming and on food security. We're working hand in glove with Defra to make sure that these things are considered at the same time and those cascading climate and nature impacts on food security will be considered. That'll be a core part of our Climate and Nature Security Taskforce.

22:48 - 22:49

John Lamont.

22:49 - 22:52

John Lamont

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, question number five.

22:52 - 23:17

Michael Shanks

Good morning, Mr. Speaker. National Grid Electricity Transmission has concluded its first consultation on the English section of the Cross Border Connection with further consultation expected next year. The Scottish section is being developed by SP Energy Networks with consenting decisions on that portion the responsibility of Scottish Ministers. It's for the developers to progress their proposals and seek the necessary consents.

23:17 - 23:48

John Lamont

Mr. Speaker, the mega pylons comprising the Cross Border Connection will have a major impact on residents in the Scottish Borders.

I mean, I have data centers, wind farms, solar farms, substations and battery storage plants which will follow in the wake of the pylons. But local councillors and local residents feel powerless to influence these developments. So will the Minister agree to meet me and local Scottish Borders councillors to discuss their concerns? And will the government support my Electricity and Digital Infrastructure Planning Bill, which will provide certainty to local communities and the council as to how these developments should be considered?

23:48 - 24:19

Michael Shanks

Well, I have met in the past and I'm very happy to meet again the honourable gentleman to discuss these issues. But I would just reiterate the point that the decisions on those applications are not for me. They're for the Scottish Government, as all planning matters are in Scotland. He can shake his head, but it nevertheless is true. It is important that we bring communities with us in this.

That's critical in the planning process. It's also why we announced that communities that host this infrastructure right across the UK should benefit from bill discounts directly, but also community benefits in communities like his.

24:19 - 24:43

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The proposed route of the cross-border connection will cut a swathe across the North Cumbria section of my Carlisle constituency and pass through or close to four sites of special scientific interest. I recognise the importance of the project. However, will the Minister please urge National Grid to maximise undergrounding on this section of the project?

24:43 - 25:16

Michael Shanks

Well, as I said, it's for individual projects to go through the planning process and to develop their projects. But we do as a government, as the previous government in fact had exactly the same position, have a preference for pylons rather than undergrounding, not least because they are four or five times more expensive and it's consumers across the country that pay that additional cost. We are very clear that building the grid is absolutely critical for how we get clean, cheaper power to people's homes and businesses. It's the job the previous government never did, and that upgrade is now absolutely critical.

25:16 - 25:20

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number six, please.

25:20 - 25:48

Blair McDougall

Mr. Speaker, we recognise that energy costs remain a challenge for businesses across the country. Our British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, which is now open, will support over 10,000 businesses, cutting electricity costs by up to £40 per megawatt hour, alongside the British Industry Supercharger's enhanced support for our most electricity-intensive firms. We know this is not enough, and we're working across both of my departments to explore further options.

25:48 - 26:23

Speaker 48

Thank you, sir. I thank the Minister for that answer. I've recently been investigating the extraordinary regional differences between different parts of the country when it comes to domestic electricity standing charges. But I'm increasingly concerned that the same underlying network charging system may also be imposing substantially higher fixed costs on businesses in Merseyside and Northwest. So will the Minister ask Ofgem to investigate the impact of regional network charging on business competitiveness as well as household bills?

26:23 - 26:47

Blair McDougall

Well, Mr. Speaker, as ever, he is a champion for business and industry in Southport. The short answer is yes. I'll be writing to Ofgem about this matter and will share the response with the honourable member. In the meantime, I'd reassure him that Ofgem's cost allocation and recovery review is considering how costs should be recovered from consumers, which includes arrangements for recovering network costs.

26:47 - 27:20

Speaker 57

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In terms of business costs, I agree entirely with the comments made already. But it also applies across the public sector. Local authorities, NHS trusts and boards all pay substantial amounts for their energy, particularly organisations like leisure trusts who have swimming pools and ice rinks and provide a great deal of community wellbeing. Will the Minister commit to addressing those issues at the same time for public authorities as for businesses?

27:20 - 27:43

Blair McDougall

Well, he makes one of the many really good arguments for acting at pace to get towards cleaner energy. Not just is it good for business, not just is it good for household consumers, but as he says, it saves a considerable amount of money for the public sector too, which is exactly why we're investing in, for example, rooftop solar across the public sector, and we'll certainly work with the Scottish Government on that.

27:43 - 27:44

Shadow Secretary of State, Andrew Gwynne.

27:44 - 28:15

Andrew Bowie

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, businesses are being crushed by the weight of energy costs in this country, and it's leading to the deindustrialization of Great Britain, from the ceramics industry in Stoke to the chemicals industry in Grangemouth. Labour's policies are making Britain poorer, more vulnerable, and leading to thousands of job losses. Does the Minister think that's why Gary Smith of the GMB has described government energy policy is, and I quote, "batshit", and the department as the Department for P45s?

28:15 - 28:55

Blair McDougall

Well, Mr. Speaker, as has happened so often at the dispatch box, we find ourselves rising to answer questions from the front bench about why we have not been quick enough at fixing the mess that they left us. By all means, criticize the speed and the scale of ambition that we have. We're certainly ambitious for going quicker down that. But when his proposal is to return and to regress to the very policy of reliance on fossil fuels that got us into this mess in the first time, it just doesn't bear any scrutiny.

28:55 - 28:59

Lindsay Hoyle

Chris Webb.

Minister.

28:59 - 29:22

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Warm Homes Plan is already delivering in communities across our country, and last month the Secretary of State announced the devolution of the Warm Homes Plan, giving power to local leaders and communities to make decisions about the areas they know best is essential to upgrading homes at the scale and pace that we need. And it's key to bringing down bills, reducing fuel poverty, and creating skilled jobs.

29:22 - 29:44

Christopher Paul Webb

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In Blackpool, too many families still live in cold and poorly insulated homes and face disproportionately high energy costs. So could the Minister tell me how the Warm Homes Plan is benefiting households in Blackpool, and what more the government is doing to secure for my constituents cheaper energy bills to support that they're entitled to and how they can access it?

29:44 - 30:15

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Look, I want to start just by paying tribute to my honorable friend for all the work he's doing to champion his constituents in Blackpool South. Around 600 households in his constituency received home upgrades under government schemes in 2025-26. I'd encourage any of his constituents who want advice on how to upgrade their homes now to go on to gov.uk and search for energy grants, and they'll be able to find information there. And we'll also soon be launching a new tool to make it even easier for people to find support.

30:15 - 30:17

Lindsay Hoyle

Claire Young.

30:17 - 30:40

Claire Louise Young

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Many of my constituents in Thornbury and Yate are off-gas and rely on heating oil, and they're once again writing to me about rising costs. With no price cap to protect them, the best way to cut their bills is to move to low-carbon forms of heating. So can the Minister confirm that the uplift in grant for off-grid properties will not be a victim of budget cuts?

30:40 - 31:06

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We've guaranteed that the grant will be there until March of next year, and obviously decisions for the future of that scheme and that uplift will be ones for the Chancellor to take later at the budget. What I would say about that uplift is that it has seen a significant increase in the number of heat pump applications and applications through the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, over 8,000 in July alone. So we can see the success that it's having and the support that it's providing to off-grid homes.

31:06 - 31:10

Lindsay Hoyle

Shadow Minister, Dr. Luke Evans.

31:10 - 31:32

Luke Morgan Evans

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And in January this year, the former Energy Secretary stood at the dispatch box and with great fanfare announced 15 billion for the Warm Homes Plan. So I have a very simple question to the side opposite.

Can the Minister confirm today and guarantee that every penny of that commitment remains intact, yes or no?

31:32 - 32:01

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to welcome the honorable gentleman to his place and to his new position. He wouldn't expect me to stand here and make commitments that will be made by the Chancellor in the budget, and obviously they will be made at the end of this month. But what I would say is this is coming from a party that is trying to make us more dependent on fossil fuels, that is trying to turn back the clock on the future home standards, which would leave people across the country tens of thousands of pounds worse off.

32:01 - 32:04

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Question number nine, please, Mr. Speaker.

32:04 - 32:25

Michael Shanks

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given regulatory processes underway, I can't comment on particular projects. However, we've been very clear that any consenting decisions for new oil and gas must be compatible with our climate obligations, and we've set that out at every stage of the process since we inherited the court judgments on the previous government's handling of these consent decisions.

32:25 - 33:01

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've had many of my constituents in Putney writing to me about this. They're very concerned about the Rosebank's lifetime emissions equivalent being 254 million million tons of CO2 equivalent. This summer, as has been mentioned by many colleagues, we've seen extreme weather. London Ambulance Service say they had more call-outs this summer because of the heat wave than they did during COVID.

So with this background, does the Minister, can the Minister tell me whether approving Rosebank is compatible with the UK climate targets and obligations under the Paris Agreement?

33:01 - 33:32

Michael Shanks

Well, firstly, Mr. Speaker, let me just reiterate that I can't comment on particular projects that are currently being considered for decisions. But on the more general point that she rightly raises, it is absolutely imperative that we look at the impact that climate change is having. We've all lived through the summer that we've just had and seen the evidence of that up close. It is important that any decisions we make are compatible with our climate obligations, and even as the opposition has now accepted, it is worth remembering that any new projects in the North Sea will not take a penny off bills.

33:32 - 33:57

Speaker 58

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Producing our own oil and gas means we will import less dirtier hydrocarbons. So it's common sense that we use our own resources. But while Labour dither on approving Rosebank and Jackdaw, thousands of my constituents in Aberdeen South are losing their jobs. So will the Minister set out a timetable for deciding if Rosebank and Jackdaw can proceed?

33:57 - 34:34

Michael Shanks

Well, as I've said on a number of occasions, we are considering the evidence that has been submitted on these particular projects. We have had to pick up a process that was left behind by the previous government, and we've done that as quickly as possible. We will make decisions in due course. But I would just make this point. He says about common sense.

There are thousands of his constituents who are also reliant on jobs in renewables, in carbon capture, and in hydrogen. And he stands here time after time and opposes the investment in that. If he's in favor of jobs in his constituency, he should be in favor of all of them.

34:34 - 35:23

Speaker 53

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In Canada, Prime Minister Carney has taken a more pragmatic approach to the energy transition than his predecessor, notably by designating the West Coast oil pipeline as a project of national interest. In this country, the Prime Minister says that drilling in the North Sea is something he is pragmatic about. So can the Minister tell us how, whether he agrees with continued drilling in the North Sea, but also in return, whether he sees a similar approach to that taken in Canada being applied in securing agreement for emission reductions in return for such drilling?

35:23 - 36:00

Michael Shanks

Well, it's always useful to hear from the chair of the select committee and I will look into the example that he gives. But I will just say on the issue of pragmatism, we have been very clear that we want to see a pragmatic future for the North Sea. That does mean continued oil and gas for many, many decades, but it also means investing in what comes next in the North Sea so that there is a fair and prosperous transition. The North Sea remains an absolutely vital asset for the country, supporting jobs, supporting growth and supporting our energy security. We're determined to make sure that there is a strong pathway for the communities and for jobs.

Oil and gas will be important, but it's also critical we build up the other industries that come next.

36:00 - 36:02

Lindsay Hoyle

Dr. Tilda Chance.

36:02 - 36:36

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Previously, the Secretary of State has said that to have any shot at meeting our climate change targets, and I quote, "we can't have any new oil and gas." She's also said that new fossil fuel development is, and I quote, "irresponsible and short-sighted." There is nothing pragmatic about pouring more fuel on the fire of the climate crisis. So I'd like to know, does the Secretary of State still agree with herself?

And if so, why will the government not rule out Rosebank and Jackdaw?

36:36 - 37:07

Michael Shanks

Well, I think first of all, I would say it is pragmatic to say that oil and gas will continue to be a critical part of an energy mix for decades to come and the North Sea remains an important part of that. We are not about switching off the taps in the North Sea and we said that in our manifesto and we'll deliver on that. But we are about building clean energy in the future. I would just say to the Green Party, who come here and pontificate about a lot of these issues, but then oppose the very infrastructure that would actually get us off fossil fuels. They can't have it both ways.

37:07 - 37:09

Lindsay Hoyle

Harriet Cross, Shadow Minister.

37:09 - 37:45

Harriet Iona Cross

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We are in a global energy supply crisis. Oil shipments remain stuck, a fifth of global LNG supplies have been disrupted by the war in Iran and across Europe, gas reserves are at record lows heading into winter. But good news, Mr. Speaker, Jackdaw and Rosebank could be producing oil and gas this winter. The bad news is that we have a government either too scared of their green lobby or too naive to the supply risks we face to act.

So now that the Holborn and St Pancras by-election is over, and before we get too close to COP, when is the government finally going to take our energy security seriously and permit Jackdaw and Rosebank?

37:45 - 38:37

Michael Shanks

Well, firstly, Mr. Speaker, can I welcome the honorable lady to her new role as Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland as well as clearly staying in the energy brief as well and congratulate her on that. She actually very eloquently outlines in her question exactly the problem at the heart of the Conservative Party's policy on this. She says very clearly that the issues in the Middle East leave us exposed to an energy crisis, but the very plan that that party has, Mr. Speaker, is to increase that exposure, to have even more gas in our energy mix. It is simply not credible. And their own plan has already been ridiculed for the fact the figures were wrong when they published it and were based on a gas price that isn't based in reality, given everything that's going on in the Middle East.

We will make pragmatic decisions on the future of the North Sea, but we'll also be all about our energy security long into the future, when they remain stuck to the very exposure that's driving up everyone's bills.

38:37 - 38:38

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

38:38 - 38:40

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Number eleven, please, Mr. Speaker.

38:40 - 38:41

Minister.

38:41 - 39:11

Sarah Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I play tribute to my honorable friend who has been a champion for Yorkshire and for both the issues on climate change mitigation and adaptation. We recognize our peatlands are vital habitats for biodiversity, storing carbon and water, and we have strong protections in national planning policy which guide developers to avoid peatland and where not possible to mitigate. We are working with DEFRA to strengthen and collaborate on both climate and nature policies.

39:11 - 39:49

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We can't strengthen one part of our climate response by weakening another. Peatland stores fifty percent of the country's soil carbon. That's three billion tons of the stuff.

It's the equivalent of all the carbon stored by forests in the UK, Germany and France combined. Building on peatland releases that carbon, which is why there are rules against it if you're doing it for development or farming. Would the minister please look at bringing some consistency in cases where it's something like a wind farm or another energy project on such on on that peatland so that there's consistency across the board.

39:49 - 40:17

Sarah Jones

My honorable friend is is right to highlight the hugely valuable role of peat in storing carbon, water and biodiversity, and it's why this government announced forty-seven million pounds to restore our peatlands in June. As I said, there is national policy guidance, but we are working with Defra and Natural England to improve that interaction. I will follow up with the department to ensure we are reviewing policy options to deliver clean energy in tandem with protecting our natural environment, and I'm very happy to keep him in the loop on this.

40:17 - 40:19

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Roger Gale.

40:19 - 40:37

Roger Gale

Mr. Speaker, we don't have an abundance of peatland in East Kent. But we do have acres of wonderful marshland and sites of scientific interest. On that land... He's shaking his head very badly at me. Sir Roger, one of us is going to have to, please.

40:37 - 41:04

Speaker 83

It might be helpful, there is some peatlands in Kent, so there is a link to the question, so I don't need any help, you shaking your head so violently won't change Sir Roger's question. Sir Roger. I'm most grateful, Mr. Speaker, let me go back to the beginning. We don't have acres of peatland in East Kent. But we do have acres of wonderful marshland and sites of scientific interest.

41:04 - 41:52

Roger Gale

On that marshland, National Grid is proposing to build a ninety-foot high converter station, the size of five football pitches, floated on two meters deep of concrete. The Secretary of State is due to determine the planning application in short order. When the Secretary of State takes that decision, could I ask for an assurance that she will take into account the irreparable environmental damage that this ill-conceived project will do to the environment.

41:52 - 42:20

Sarah Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the clarification, and I thank my other honorable member for all of his for his question. Look, everything we do has an environmental impact, but clearly we want to make sure we minimize the environmental impact of any infrastructure that we build. I cannot comment on any individual planning applications as he will well know, but I do take his wider point that we will look to minimize at all places the environmental impacts of any of our clean energy infrastructure.

42:20 - 42:21

Sonia Kumar.

42:21 - 42:23

Sonia Kumar

Question twelve, Mr. Speaker.

42:23 - 42:27

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

42:27 - 42:56

Sarah Jones

We all felt the impacts of climate change this summer, whether it was in our schools, our homes or in classrooms. The Warm Homes Plan and the measures within it to ensure cooling as well as heating measures are available for the most vulnerable homes. In England and Wales, all eligible households can benefit from the expanded boiler upgrade scheme which now includes air-to-air heat pumps which are able to heat and cool our homes.

42:56 - 43:23

Sonia Kumar

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer extreme heat was responsible for thousands of excess deaths across the United Kingdom. While I commend the department's mission to tackle climate change and the root causes of extreme heat, but the but does the minister recognize we must go faster and further in adapting and supporting households, especially vulnerable households, from extreme heat, and does she recognize that we need a cold homes plan for across the country.

43:23 - 44:12

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend for her excellent question. Look, as we've mentioned a few times today, the Warm Homes Plan also has already announced the intention to introduce some passive cooling measures, whether that's shading, shutters, reflective windows, or cooler building materials. And the delivery plan of the Warm Homes Plan that's been devolved to mayors and local government and communities presents a real opportunity to shape that in the most locally appropriate ways. But of course we want to go faster, and I would to make sure that new homes are built to resilient standards. That's why we're committed as well to the net zero standards, and we're reviewing the overheating building regulations to ensure our homes are fit for the future.

I would like to make sure that we build together heating and cooling options, so we're thinking about the integration of both climate mitigation and adaptation at the same time.

44:12 - 44:38

Timothy James Farron

Mr. Speaker, 25% of the properties in my constituency were built before 1900. They are very hard to retrofit, they are solid wall properties, and it's therefore very important that there should be a bespoke scheme to ensure that homes, particularly in rural communities like mine, that are so hard to retrofit, are able to be made cooler or warmer in these more extreme temperature times.

44:38 - 44:56

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable member for the question. He's absolutely right that some of our properties are more challenging to retrofit. It's why we are working with many heritage organizations to see about the best way to do that, and we are learning at all times to make sure that that mitigation and adaptation at the same time, and I'm very happy to keep him in the loop on progress on that.

44:56 - 44:59

Darren James Paffey

Question 13 please, Mr. Speaker.

44:59 - 45:33

Michael Shanks

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our electricity grid is one of the most important pieces of infrastructure in the country, but it was allowed to get into a complete mess by underinvestment and a failure to tackle the grid connection queue, which got to over 700 gigawatts under the previous government. We have grappled with that legacy head-on, reducing the queue by 300 gigawatts and ensuring that accurate connection offers are issued. We have made progress on this, but there is much more to do to make sure the grid works for the people of this country, and that's why we're injecting public control back into the system by launching Great British Grid.

45:33 - 46:10

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the minister for his answer. Southampton's port electrification and decarbonization projects are ready to go, but we still can't get the national grid upgrades that we need for at least another decade. The Prime Minister himself has said that this drives costs up, it drags growth down, and it holds Britain back. So I really welcome the announcements around Great British Grid. Will the minister say when GB Grid will be able to start filling those gaps that exist at the moment, and will you meet with me and Southampton's businesses so that we can find a way forward and get good green growth in Southampton's postcodes?

46:10 - 46:36

Michael Shanks

Well, I thank my honorable friend. He's absolutely right to highlight the point the Prime Minister made about how critical fixing the fundamental problems with connecting to the grid is. That's why we have announced we've set up Great British Grid as part of Great British Energy. We've made substantial progress on reforming the queue, but we do have to build the grid after decades of underinvestment. And I'm very happy to meet my honorable friend to discuss this issue, and I'm fairly confident that we can make sure National Grid's part of that conversation as well.

46:36 - 47:17

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Bute Energy is building a big wind farm, or is planning to build a big wind farm in Mid Wales, and it's going to connect that wind farm over 47 kilometers of pylons into a substation in North Shropshire. That doesn't exist yet. I found out on NISO's website that that substation is likely to be a 24-bay 400-kilovolt substation in a place where there are no substantial roads and a very good amount of substantial and useful farmland. Will the minister meet with me to discuss the appropriateness of the site, because I think it could go elsewhere, and I think it would need, it would require a shorter run of pylons for Bute Energy, and I think it would be, there are more appropriate places to build it than Lower Frankton.

47:17 - 47:32

Michael Shanks

Well, look, I'm very, very happy to meet the honorable lady as I always am to meet members across the House to discuss it.

I will just say that it is not for me as a minister to decide the exact locations of substations, but I'm very happy to engage with her and to raise the issue with the relevant transmission owner.

47:32 - 47:38

Lindsay Hoyle

Come to topical questions. Topical one, sir.

Secretary of State.

47:38 - 48:50

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, we are clear that energy is an everyday essential that everyone should have access to affordable prices. We're also clear that for too many people, energy is simply too expensive. That is why lowering bills for households and businesses is at the very heart of our agenda. Cutting VAT on electricity bills and removing 150 pounds of cost to give people breathing space whilst we deliver the big changes that will get bills down for good. Clean homegrown power to break our dependence on global fossil fuel markets we don't control, devolving warm homes so we can upgrade millions of homes to get bills down, and putting the public back in control of an energy system that they lost control over simply will be at the key of how we do this.

Great British Energy giving our communities a stake in the energy we produce, Great British Energy Nuclear putting the public at the very heart of nuclear generation, Great British Grid accelerating the build out of grid infrastructure and connections. Mr. Speaker, we have a plan to get our energy system to work for our community again and we are absolutely committed at running at that plan.

48:50 - 49:23

Speaker 79

Fuel prices are through the roof, but it's okay, Mr. Speaker, because the Prime Minister says that he gets it. He's tweeted, I won't accept that there's nothing I can do to help, and he's proved it by pointing to a forecourt price comparison app. But what he didn't mention, Mr. Speaker, is that his government is adding VAT on top of those price increases. That's a windfall of two to three billion pounds. So if the Prime Minister gets it, why is he adding 20% to the misery of motorists?

49:23 - 50:21

Polly Billington

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. In fact, if you'll find it is a good way of making sure that people are able to see the transparency that is required in the market for it to really work. The Competition and Markets Authority has found that fundamentally the market works competitively, but and therefore if anybody does find that anything is they see they see anything that's suspected to be price gouging, they should report that exactly to the Competition and Markets Authority. I would also like to point out that we have frozen fuel duty so that therefore diesel, for example, is 11 pounds cheaper than it would have been under the previous government.

So I think it is important to recognize under the previous government before 2024. So I think it is important for the members opposite to remember that we are doing what we can in order to be able to bear down on the costs for the motorist and indeed to make sure that the market works as transparently as possible.

50:21 - 50:22

Jim Hicks.

50:22 - 50:51

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Watt Tyler is a historic 15th century pub in Dartford town center. Recently, Jamal Akkas, the owner, contacted me because he wants to get his energy bills down and to increase the energy efficiency of the building. I wonder if the minister can help me to help him by outlining what support might be available to Jamal and the Watt Tyler to do just that.

50:51 - 51:19

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Let me pay tribute to my honorable friend. He's managed to combine two things that are two of my favorite things in one question: energy efficiency and the pub. I'd encourage the Watt Tyler to access the UK Business Climate Hub, which provides advice to businesses on how to reduce energy costs, and they may also be eligible for the boiler upgrade scheme, which would offer them a grant of up to seven and a half thousand pounds to replace their fossil fuel boiler with a heat pump or other clean technology.

51:19 - 51:22

Lindsay Hoyle

We come to Shadow Secretary of State, Andrew Bond.

51:22 - 51:53

Andrew Bowie

Much, Mr. Speaker.

I'd like to take this opportunity to congratulate and welcome the Secretary of State to her new post. I look forward to working collaboratively with her on issues where we agree. I'm sure we'll find some at some point. In the last 20 minutes, Mr. Speaker, the Daily Telegraph is reporting that in an act of extreme irony, the former Secretary of State for Energy has signed off on drilling for new oil in the South Atlantic off of the Falkland Islands. Why is drilling for new oil and gas okay in the South Atlantic, but not in the North Sea?

51:53 - 52:47

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, the Falkland Islands is an independent self-governing, it's not a matter for us. But, Mr. Speaker, let me answer, let me answer the specific question. We are and we have been very clear that oil and gas are part of our energy mix for years to come. We have also been very clear that we will manage existing fields and that is what we're committed to doing. But I can't reiterate this enough.

If we care about getting bills down, if we care about energy security, we must diversify our mix. And that does mean clean power and that does mean renewables. This side of the House, we are pragmatic because at the very heart of it are consumers that are under pressure. That side of the House, one minute they're in support of renewables, I think I have a quote from the honorable member himself, the next minute they're against it. We have a plan, they have no plan.

52:47 - 53:09

Andrew Bowie

Speaker, oil and gas workers in Scotland will be feeling cold fury this afternoon. The Labour Party creating jobs in oil and gas in Port Stanley whilst killing them in Aberdeen. Now, why is the pragmatism, the unusual pragmatism we've seen in evidence from the former Secretary of State for Energy apply in the South Atlantic? Why does that same pragmatism not apply to the North Sea oil and gas industry?

53:09 - 53:47

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, I would ask the honorable member to show some humility because under his watch, under his watch from 2016 to 2024, 75,000 oil and gas jobs were lost. 75,000 oil and gas jobs were lost because they had no plan. So candidly, Mr. Speaker, I will not take lectures from the party opposite. We are very clear, we are very clear that there will be a plan for oil and gas workers in this country because we do not do what the Tories do, which is industrial transition that absolutely denudes our communities and guts them out. That is not the Labour way.

53:47 - 53:53

Speaker 75

We will have a plan, they have no grounds to stand on.

53:53 - 54:18

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Saint Anne's School, Grove House Nursery and North Primary School in Ealing Southall are all getting new solar panels because of this government's investment in Great British Energy. Does the Minister agree with me that the work he is doing to bring down energy bills for schools will allow more money to be spent where it matters, on teaching and learning?

54:18 - 54:42

Michael Shanks

Well, can I congratulate Saint Anne's, Grove House and North Primary School on solar panels going on their rooftops. I've visited schools that have had solar installed and it is fantastic to see the young people learning about renewable energy at the same time as bills going down in the school and more money being invested in frontline teaching, which is exactly what we want to see delivered by Great British Energy.

54:42 - 55:22

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Families on the Isle of Wight were interested to hear the Prime Minister wanting to do his little bit to help by telling us where we could buy cheaper fuel at the forecourt via a fuel finder app. Our interest waned somewhat when we discovered the cheaper fuel was available in Portsmouth, involving a two-hour round trip on a ferry. Does the Minister accept that this is a city-focused Prime Minister leading a city-focused government that doesn't understand the realities of life in rural and coastal communities, including when facing high energy costs?

55:22 - 56:02

Polly Billington

I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. And as a fellow coastal MP, I would absolutely rebut his idea that this is a government that doesn't understand coastal or rural communities. Indeed, not only I accept the challenges around the fuel finder that he found in terms of the Isle of Wight, and we do need to make sure that that full transparency also extends to making sure that there is the cheapest fuel available possible in all communities. I'd like to point out, however, that many of his residents will be benefiting from the announcement that we made today on the regulation of heating oil, because off-grid heating oil has up until now not benefited from regulation, and now it will do.

56:02 - 56:32

David Edmund Burton-Sampson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer has seen the first hosepipe ban imposed by Essex and Suffolk Water on my constituency of Southend West and Leigh since 1997. However, some members on the benches opposite would deny that the results we are seeing are as a result of climate change. So does the Minister agree with me that the weather we saw this summer is evidence enough that the work towards net zero must continue as a priority for this government?

56:32 - 57:02

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend. The science has been very clear for years, but this summer for the first time it allowed many people to really feel it in the UK for the first time. He is absolutely correct that net zero remains the goal of this government. I understand that some people want to try and weaponize this, but ultimately, if we want to tackle the climate crisis, then at some point we have to stop the polluting gases into the atmosphere if we want to protect the people and the places we love.

57:02 - 57:22

Blake Stephenson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All of our constituents are paying a high price for energy. It's impacting households and we all know it's impacting small businesses. Earlier the Secretary of State said that she would take any action necessary to get bills down. Does that include reducing green taxes and levies to reduce gas bills?

57:22 - 57:54

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, we have already taken action to reduce the cost on bills, 150 pounds that was done earlier. But I come back to the point, we will do whatever we can to give households breathing space as we drive the big change. But part of the big change is diversifying our energy mix, and that does mean more renewables, that means more nuclear, so that we are not as exposed as we are to global fossil fuel markets. His constituents, Mr. Speaker, can see that. They can see what is driving up bills.

We have a plan to tackle that, the party opposite doesn't.

57:54 - 58:17

Speaker 98

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the government entered government with a target to decarbonize the grid by 2030. The Public Accounts Committee looked at the previous government's plans to do that by 2035, which itself was over-optimistic. Will the new Secretary of State, and I welcome her to her position, reassure us that she's going into detail into that project, and when will she announce to the House what the real date will be?

58:17 - 58:52

Michael Shanks

Look, when we came into government, we set this incredibly ambitious target to decarbonize the power system, which meant 95% of our electricity coming from clean sources, and we've done everything possible to move towards that, and we are closer than we've ever been. But it's worth just saying every single solar farm we switch on and wind farm that we switch on helps us get off gas. And just in the past few months since what has been happening in the Middle East has taken course, we've been saving 5 million pounds a day in displacing gas from the system because of the clean power mission. So we're making huge progress and we'll continue pushing towards it.

58:52 - 59:13

Speaker 85

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ministers have repeatedly stated their intention to establish local trading to unleash the full potential of community energy, but details have still not been forthcoming. Will the Minister set out a timeline to give community energy projects the clarity they have so long been waiting for?

59:13 - 59:23

Michael Shanks

Well, can I as I always do recognize the honorable lady's championing of this sector. We on these benches agree with her about how important this is, and she won't have to wait very long.

59:23 - 59:43

Jade Jessica Toale

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent Chris Harris has developed Enviroship, a battery-based solution for transporting excess renewable energy via repurposed LNG ships to areas of high usage around the UK. Will the Minister meet with him to discuss the role that this solution can play in meeting our energy demand and net zero goals?

59:43 - 59:53

Speaker 87

Yes, Mr. Speaker, I will meet with my honorable friend who is a brilliant champion and her constituent.

59:53 - 59:57

Speaker 81

We're going back over, totally thrown now. David Mundell.

59:57 - 01:00:35

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can the Secretary of State assure me that those people who are prevalent in my constituency who are off-grid are at the heart of the government's thinking in terms of energy support? And whilst I welcome regulation in relation to heating oil, which has spiraled in price, it is not clear that that regulation alone will bring down prices. And therefore, if the Chancellor is to support, give energy support, can off-grid be part of that?

01:00:35 - 01:01:05

Polly Billington

I thank the honorable gentleman for his question, and I appreciate that he actually represents one of the most rural parts of the country. And therefore, the importance of us having allocated 53 million pounds across the UK to help the most vulnerable people is very important. 4.6 million pounds has been given to the Scottish government, and it is important that they get that money out of the door in order to be able to help the most vulnerable people in his constituency and many others across Scotland.

01:01:06 - 01:01:25

Luke Myer

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently met Paul Hughes, who proudly showed me his AI-enabled heat battery boiler. I'm delighted that the government has made that tech eligible in the boiler upgrade scheme. Would the Minister also consider speaking to Treasury colleagues about having this technology a part of the energy-saving materials VAT relief framework?

01:01:25 - 01:01:42

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thanks to my honorable friend for her question. As you know, decisions on tax are a matter for the Chancellor. But what I can say is that my department's announced our intention to make heat batteries eligible for a two and a half thousand pound grant under the boiler upgrade scheme, and a committee of this House will actually be considering legislation for this on Thursday.

01:01:42 - 01:01:44

Speaker 77

Dame Karen Bradley.

01:01:44 - 01:02:16

Karen Bradley

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. There is a great deal of concern in Staffordshire Moorlands about the Peak Cluster proposal, which is a proposed project to take carbon from four cement plants in the Peak District and pipe it into Morecambe Bay. Whilst I'm not opposed to carbon capture, many residents are extraordinary concerned about the impact this will have on them. So can I ask the Secretary of State to look carefully at this project and see whether there are alternatives to ensure that we can keep our cement industry in the United Kingdom without perhaps destroying our environment in the Peak District?

01:02:16 - 01:02:38

Michael Shanks

Can I thank her first of all for what she said about carbon capture more generally, and we are absolutely looking at those alternatives around decarbonizing those hard-to-abate sectors. The Peak Cluster is not a government-backed project. It is for them to do all of the community engagement, and I've heard from a lot of members across this House that that hasn't been as good as it should be. I'd encourage them to make sure that that is as strong as it can be, and it would be subject obviously to a planning application when it comes forward.

01:02:38 - 01:02:39

Dr. Scott Arthur.

01:02:39 - 01:03:11

Scott Arthur

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I want to return to Jackdaw and Rosebank. Last week, Jess from my office organized a showing of the National Emergency briefing, and it was very well attended. And afterwards, I don't think anybody I spoke to thought that Jackdaw or Rosebank should go ahead. And I know the Secretary of State won't be drawn on this for legal reasons, but it'd be good to hear her acknowledging the deep concerns that many people have about this issue.

And one person did ask that if it does go ahead, could every single penny of the money raised by the government be invested in the transition? Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:03:11 - 01:03:38

Edward Samuel Miliband

Mr. Speaker, I obviously can't go into the specifics of consenting decisions that are quasi-judicial. What I would say to the House is that we are trying to make those decisions at pace. The other thing I'll be very clear about is any decision I make will be compatible with our climate commitments. That is the first responsibility I have as Secretary of State, and that will be absolutely clear. And I think my honorable friend and his constituents should hear that loud and clear.

01:03:38 - 01:03:39

Alistair Carmichael.

01:03:39 - 01:04:01

Alexander Carmichael

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Can I also welcome the announcement today about the government's intention to regulate the market in heating oil for communities like mine completely off the gas grid with the highest levels of fuel poverty in the country. This could be a significant moment. What my constituents would like to know however is when they might see this proposal become an implemented reality.

01:04:01 - 01:04:46

Polly Billington

I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. I think it's important to make it quite clear what kind of proposals we're considering taking forward. Working with the regulators and industries to make sure we have a proportionate regulatory regime, stronger protections for consumers so that we develop a robust and evidence-based framework. We will work with the industry to strengthen consumer protections in the code of conduct and we will review industry practices which currently set minimum order volumes at 500 liters for some customers. We'll raise the awareness of payment plans to make sure customers have the right options available to them.

We want to get this right Mr. Speaker and that is why we will work with the industry and with consumer organizations to ensure that regulatory framework really makes a difference for consumers in the honorable gentleman's constituency and across the country.

01:04:47 - 01:05:16

Afzal Khan

Thank you Mr. Speaker. I'm proud to stand behind the government who is taking climate action seriously. However we are already overshooting critical limits and climate change will only get worse if we do not stop burning fossil fuels. So can I ask my right honorable friend whether a full direct climate impact of Rosebank and implications of the international community's efforts transition away from fossil fuels will be considered in making the decision.

01:05:16 - 01:05:39

Michael Shanks

Well look as I've said in a number of answers I can't comment on the particular project but just on the general point the very reason we're in this situation with these consents is because we have to take into account because of the court judgment the scope three emissions of these which does mean there'll be a full environmental assessment and we've been very clear that that environmental assessment is critical in the consenting decisions that we'll make in due course.

01:05:39 - 01:05:40

Alicia Kearns.

01:05:40 - 01:06:00

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you Mr. Speaker. As the Secretary of State says the Falkland Islands are independent but she seemed to gloss over the fact the Foreign Secretary still has to give approval to oil drilling. Now will she therefore give her full-throated support to the decision today and support the Falkland Islands in this important venture and also tell us when she was consulted on the decision.

01:06:00 - 01:06:19

Michael Shanks

Can I just say to the opposition party this is quite a change in foreign policy of the party opposite if their position is now that we should interfere in the day-to-day decisions of the Falkland Islands government. That has not been the position of that government. That has not been the position of the party opposite and it's not the position of this government.

01:06:19 - 01:06:22

Speaker 88

Kerry McCarthy.

01:06:22 - 01:06:39

Kerry McCarthy

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Ahead of the budget I've been talking to many small businesses in my constituency. The minister might be particularly interested to know that includes 12 independent breweries. They're really struggling with their energy bills. What representations have been made to the Chancellor about the need to support them.

01:06:39 - 01:07:16

Blair McDougall

Go on the breweries. Thank you Mr. Speaker. I'm the one who can organize something in a brewery apparently. We hear lots of representations from honorable members in support of small businesses and their energy costs and we recognize the challenges they face. Obviously eligible small businesses are already benefiting from the VAT cut on top of that we'll see measures coming forward to deal with third-party intermediaries who are often ripping off small businesses.

But as I said in my earlier answer we're keen to go further and I'm working across both of my departments towards that end.

01:07:16 - 01:07:17

Sheryll Murray.

01:07:17 - 01:07:43

Susan Murray

Thank you Mr. Speaker. When Torness closes in 2030 Scotland will be left without a nuclear power station for the first time since the 1950s. That steady low-carbon power will still have to come from somewhere and the SNP government still refuses to back nuclear. What discussions has the minister had with the Scottish government about keeping Scotland's lights on once Torness closes.

01:07:43 - 01:07:45

Speaker 82

Well can I thank the honorable lady for her question.

01:07:46 - 01:08:25

Michael Shanks

I know she has a debate on this subject as well, and I completely agree with her. Torness nuclear power station has been keeping the lights on in Scotland every single day of the week, and it is a disgrace that the Scottish government is refusing to accept the critical role that that firm power plays on Scotland's system. Scotland has absolute potential for new nuclear, for good jobs in every part of that country. They are missing out on thousands of jobs because of the anti-science ideological position of the Scottish government. I take every opportunity I can to persuade them of the error of their ways, but since they don't even bother to turn up in this house, I'm afraid I'll have to continue having that debate with Scottish ministers.

01:08:25 - 01:08:57

Stephen Doughty

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last year some of us warned that distributing heating oil support through local authorities carried risks, with some councils imposing strict means tests that helped too few, and other councils setting limited criteria, meaning nearly all applicants were successful, got very little, and then blamed the government for insufficient support. In Cumbria, that's exactly what happened. What more can the Secretary of State do to ensure the right people receive the right level of support?

01:08:57 - 01:09:33

Polly Billington

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I appreciate the question from my honourable friend. He's right that local authorities in England in particular are the ones who are making decisions about how they use their crisis and resilience fund money that has been allocated to them in order to be able to support heating oil households. However, I will say here at this dispatch box that they should be on notice from us: if they have been allocated money to their crisis and resilience fund in order to be able to support vulnerable homes, vulnerable households who are using heating oil, they should be creating criteria in order for them to be able to access it.

01:09:33 - 01:09:58

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this year, Lindsey oil refinery in my constituency ceased production, creating both job losses and also means a greater proportion of our diesel products have to be imported at greater cost. Does the ministers now regret not giving additional support to the continuation of production at Lindsey oil?

01:09:58 - 01:10:25

Michael Shanks

Well, Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the honourable gentleman's engagement as we were going through that process. The house will remember that it was an insolvency driven by decisions that the directors of the Prax Lindsey oil refinery had made at the time. That investigation continues into their actions. We did try to seek everything we could do to find a buyer, and I'm glad that P66 next door has taken over those assets so that we can continue to make use of that site and to do everything we can to support the workers who do an incredibly important job.

01:10:25 - 01:10:27

Speaker 104

Final question, Ryan Lynchman.

01:10:27 - 01:10:54

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. 15,000 pounds in 1991 is certainly not 15,000 pounds now. So will the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss amending the outdated schedule 4 of the Coal Mining Subsidence Act of 1991 to raise the 15,000 pounds statutory cap on the home loss payment so that my Coal Snorton constituents can receive fair compensation as they face dealing with demolishing their homes?

01:10:54 - 01:11:25

Michael Shanks

Mr. Speaker, can I firstly pay tribute to my honourable friend for all the work he's done with the community in Coal Snorton? I visited there recently and met with householders. It is a hellish situation that they are going through, none of their own making. The Mining Remediation Authority is working on a case-by-case basis with individual households to make sure there is a process in place that works for individual households. We are limited by the legislation, but UK government has been very clear: we'll meet all of the costs for those households.

I'm very happy to meet with them to discuss it further.

01:11:24 - 01:11:25

Point of order, Alicia Kearns.

01:11:25 - 01:11:52

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm sure the Minister didn't mean to, but he seemed keen to misrepresent, one might say, the relationship between the Falkland Islands and the UK Government. The Falkland Islands are independent, but the Foreign Secretary has a responsibility to sign off any such decision on oil drilling, which is not what the Minister said. It was also a surprise that the Secretary of State, when directly asked my question, chose that she did not want to give her support and directly answer the question. How might I get the Ministers to make sure they accurately represent the relationship between the overseas territories and ourselves?

01:11:25 - 01:11:25

Point of order, Mr. Speaker.

01:11:52 - 01:12:39

Speaker 111

Let me just say to the honorable lady, we can't continue the debate, and I know that the honorable lady will find many other ways in which you can seek that answer, but I think we'll leave it at there for now. Right, complete questions. Right, we come to the next urgent question, Nick Timothy.

01:12:39 - 01:12:44

Nick Timothy

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, to ask the Justice Secretary to make a statement on the early release scheme.

01:12:45 - 01:15:54

Speaker 109

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This Government inherited a prison system on the brink of collapse. In July 2024, men's prisons were operating at 99% capacity. At one point, there were fewer than 100 places available across the male estate. Without intervention, we risked running out of prison places, leaving courts unable to sentence offenders and police unable to make arrests.

This Government has acted to increase capacity and to reform sentencing. We have committed to delivering 14,000 prison places by 2031 and have already delivered 3,200. The last Government added just 500 net places in their time in office. We have also accelerated the removal of foreign national offenders, returning around 11,700 to their countries of origin. It is within this context, Mr. Speaker, that we launched the independent sentencing review in October 2024 and subsequently passed the Sentencing Act earlier this year to place the prison system on a more sustainable footing and ensure there is always space available for the most dangerous offenders.

The Act also aimed to avoid the chaotic emergency release schemes carried out with little scrutiny or warning by the Conservatives. But we know that aspects of these changes cause concern and are determined to do the right thing for victims. That is why the Government listened to the concerns raised, paused implementation of the progression model, and conducted an urgent review. As the Lord Chancellor confirmed in this House on the 1st of September, in addition to the 18,000 dangerous offenders already ineligible for the progression model, this Government has excluded rape and serious child sex offences from eligibility for changes to release dates under the Sentencing Act. Unlawful killings, including manslaughter, causing or allowing the death of a child, and death by dangerous driving are also excluded, as well as indecent assault, ensuring more historic child sex offences prosecuted under older laws are treated consistently with equivalent offences today.

This means hundreds more dangerous criminals will be staying behind bars for longer, including those who killed PC Andrew Harper in the line of duty. The first releases under the progression model took place on the 1st of October, Mr. Speaker, with His Majesty's Prison and Probation Service working closely with operational partners to ensure eligible offenders were released safely into the community. As the second tranche of releases begins today, on the 13th of October, robust arrangements remain in place to manage releases, support probation practitioners in supervising offenders, and ensure that those subject to electronic monitoring requirements are fitted with a tag. As part of the supervision of offenders released into the community, HMPPS will maintain rigorous oversight of those on license, with measures in place to recall those who are non-compliant. We recognize, Mr. Speaker, the significant effect that changes to release dates can have on victims.

I've also instructed my officials to attempt to contact victims not in that scheme to provide information should they wish for that to happen. We have launched the victim support offenders release helpline with nearly 19 million pounds worth of additional funding. This will provide victims with emotional support, practical advice such as safety planning and general information about the sentencing changes. Mr. Speaker, it's important to add that the Minister for Prison, Probation and Reducing Reoffending is unable to be here herself today because she is currently speaking with governors about early release and how implementation of the progression model is going.

01:15:37 - 01:15:37

Speaker 110

We will ensure those in the victim contact scheme that are affected by these new exclusions are informed if there are any changes to the release date of the offender in their case.

01:15:54 - 01:17:53

Nick Timothy

Shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Two weeks ago, 700 prisoners were released from prison across the country and today a further 650 will be released, most after serving just one third of their sentence. The Justice Secretary told the country that proper safeguards would be put in place with a presumption that all released prisoners would be tagged. He called it the toughest tagging regime in history, but that was nonsense. Four days after the first release, the Justice Secretary admitted he had no idea how many had been tagged and he protested it was unreasonable to expect him to know how many had been tagged so soon into the scheme.

Mr. Speaker, I have some advice for him and his ministers. It is better to work out how to implement your policy before it starts, not after. We know a majority of prisoners are not being tagged before release and we know reoffending is off the charts already. The Met says there have been 100 tag breaches in London each day since Labour's first early release scheme began, while two or three prisoners released early are being rearrested every week. Mr. Speaker, I don't want to hear the same old lines from the minister, although I notice he has changed his tune since the Prime Minister took office in July.

I don't want to hear the same old lines about prison building. Since the election, not a single new prison development has been planned or approved. Those were his words in a written answer. The only new prison opened started under the last government and prison places are unused because officer numbers are down under Labour. So can the minister tell us very clearly the answers to the following three questions?

How many prisoners released so far have and have not been tagged? How many tag breaches have there been by released prisoners? And if he doesn't know the answer, when will the Justice Secretary and his team find out and tell the House of Commons?

01:17:53 - 01:18:39

Speaker 109

Well, I'm grateful for the honorable member's questions. I noticed over the conference recess that the member for Harborough, who I think is the Conservatives' policy chief, did apologize for the lack of investment and action on criminal justice over 14 years of Conservative government. It would be welcome to hear that from the dispatch box today, but alas, we will still have to wait for that apology. In terms of the questions asked, we have set out the numbers of prisoners that will be released in each tranche and that's publicly available on the government website. We will be setting out data in relation to prison releases as we always do and the next batch of data will be released in January of next year.

This is a new sentencing regime. It's a new sentencing regime and it's right that we release the data in the appropriate way as we have always done.

01:18:39 - 01:19:49

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Catherine Atkinson, Chair of the Select Committee.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Tagging could be a way to provide real reassurance to communities and victims, but only if tags are fitted promptly and offenders monitored. In April of last year, the Justice Select Committee raised concerns in writing about the time being taken to fit tags. And the Institute for Government found between January and April of this year that more than 5,000 people who should have been monitored were not tagged. That equates to 15% of all people with an electronic tagging order.

And almost 1,600 people wearing a tag were wearing a tag that didn't send a signal due to technical faults or the device not being charged. So can the minister tell us if anything has changed since April? Specifically, what percentage of GPS tags are now being fitted on time? What is the longest time an offender can wait before monitoring begins?

And when will offenders be tagged on day one as victims and the public should be able to expect?

01:19:49 - 01:20:14

Speaker 109

Well, she's right to raise the importance of not just having a tagging regime which works, but makes sure that it's robustly monitored and scrutinized. There have been improvements by Serco, the company that's operating the tagging regime since March of this year. We've, she would have seen no doubt the National Audit Office report and we'll be responding to that in full detail as and when the full report is published later this month.

01:20:14 - 01:21:26

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The prison capacity crisis that the Conservatives left behind is unforgivable, but the situation we find ourselves in two years later is a national emergency waiting to happen. The entire criminal justice system is in freefall. Victims have been left looking over their shoulders for their released perpetrators. More than a third of the places that were freed up with the last wave of releases were filled again within a week.

And the very probation officers that are overseeing these releases will decide in the coming weeks whether to take strike action. The government has never had a grip on this. Everyone who comes into contact with the criminal justice system is being failed and tinkering around the edges won't fix it. So will the minister commit to tagging prisoners immediately upon release at the gates, ensuring that perpetrators are not allowed to evade being tagged or are left unmonitored for days as called for by the Victims Commissioner? And will the minister commit to a Royal Commission on the entirety of the criminal justice system so we can finally get to grips with the deep-rooted issues caused by successive governments' complacency and mismanagement?

01:21:26 - 01:22:13

Speaker 109

Well, I thank the honorable member for her question. In terms of the tagging, of course we want to ensure and have a situation that prisoners when they are released and it's necessary for them to be tagged and there's a presumption for those that will be released to be tagged will be at source as soon as possible. Of course, those operational decisions are matters for the probation service. In regards to her suggestions to a Royal Commission, in the first two years we've managed to stabilize the criminal justice system. We've begun to get some stability in terms of prison capacity.

It was necessary to pass the new Sentencing Act and implement the new sentencing regime. And over the course of the following years we'll make progress in terms of the Crown Court backlog which we're debating later today and tackling reoffending which is at the heart of the criminal justice system crisis that we face.

01:22:13 - 01:23:14

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Mr. Speaker, it has historically always, whether people were released at the right time or not early under various different schemes of various different governments, been rubbish for victims of domestic abuse. They're often not informed, the proper safeguards aren't put in place. And so I hear the minister saying that now there's better talking to them, there's helplines. I have to say, we have to be better than what the opposite, the opposite party did. There needs to be a proper systematic approach for victims of domestic abuse to make sure that every single possible safeguarding opportunity has been taken in every single case.

And I'm afraid to say I feel as if the department doesn't know what's going on in the world because I'm meeting women every week who have not been informed and have not had any safeguards provided. Can he assure me that there is vital work going on on this at the moment?

01:23:14 - 01:23:47

Speaker 109

Well, I thank her for her question. Of course she's a long campaigner on these issues and she's right that for too long the criminal justice system has failed domestic abuse victims.

The Victims Minister is working at pace with the Prisons and Probation Minister alongside the Victims Commissioner to ensure that everything is done to try and support victims during this period. We have invested more money, but it's not just money, it needs to then work. And of course, I'll make sure that the Victims Minister and indeed the Prisons and Probation Minister reach out to the honorable member to get the details of any cases that she has.

01:23:47 - 01:23:49

Speaker 117

Sir Julian Lewis.

01:23:49 - 01:24:23

Julian Lewis

If I understand it correctly, the Minister said earlier that past victims and therefore presumably potential future victims are being informed and supported. Does that not imply that if they need this sort of information and support, the people who are being released pose a threat to them? What sort of category of person is being released? Is it a dangerous person? And if it isn't, why do the victims need the support which the Minister described?

01:24:23 - 01:25:18

Speaker 109

Well, Mr. Speaker, in terms of the cohorts of those that are subject to the new regime, we've debated that at length in this place, both as the passing of the Sentencing Act and the changes that were made over the summer, and we returned to this place and the Justice Secretary quite rightly came to the dispatch box on the 1st of September to update them. Going to the key heart, we release 4,500 prisoners every month in this country, and we have done for the last 30 years. Of course, there is an assessment as to what measures should be in place and what notification should be made to any victims that is undertaken by brilliant probation staff every single day. Brilliant probation staff which were gutted by the last Conservative government. So we are investing in our probation service to undertake that difficult work that they do week in, week out to keep our country safe.

01:25:18 - 01:25:20

Speaker 116

Debbonaire.

01:25:20 - 01:26:20

Speaker 109

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Getting prisoner numbers back down to manageable levels depends in part on an effective and well-managed probation service. But as I've heard from probation staff in my own Bristol constituency, after years of cuts, the service is simply overwhelmed. Can I therefore ask what steps are being taken to support the ability of the probation service to manage the specific challenges posed by early release as well as the strains facing the service more broadly?

Well, he's absolutely right. Probation and our probation service don't get enough attention in this place or indeed in public debate more generally. We've implemented a 750 million pound investment into probation service. That's the biggest investment in the probation service for a generation. And we can compare that to what happened under the last government, where they were gutted, the failed privatization experiment by Chris Grayling, absolute disaster, one of the most acute disasters of the last 14 years in my mind.

01:26:20 - 01:26:33

David Chadwick

So it's right that we invest in them. We appreciate there are more challenges to come, and we are working at pace with the probation service. Indeed, that's where the Prisons Minister is today, speaking with our probation colleagues this morning.

01:26:34 - 01:27:19

David Chadwick

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Kaylen Hippsley, who grew up in Austergunlais, was just 13 years old when he was killed tragically by a driver under the influence of drugs and alcohol in February 2024. The Court of Appeal increased his killer's sentence to nine years, with at least six years to be served in custody before being considered for early release. Yet Kaylen's family have now been informed that his killer has been transferred to an open prison after serving barely two years and will soon be out on day release. Can the Minister explain how this has been allowed to happen and what assurances can be given to Kaylen's family that the sentences imposed by the courts for offenses like this will actually be upheld?

01:27:19 - 01:27:46

Janet Jessica Daby

Well, I thank the honorable member for raising that clearly tragic case. I'm not able to comment on the details of the case, as I'm sure he'll appreciate, and I'll make sure the relevant minister writes to him about that.

And indeed there was a pilot conducted by Catch22 that worked across 135 local authorities, really supporting and working care leavers that find themselves in the criminal justice system, but in particular those leaving prison itself. Would the minister agree to look at the outcomes of this pilot in his efforts to work towards releasing people from prison?

01:27:30 - 01:27:33

Speaker 109

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the Minister for his response. I'm sure the Minister will very much be aware that care leavers represent some of the most vulnerable children and young people in our society, but yet they are overrepresented in our prisons.

01:27:47 - 01:28:27

Speaker 109

Yes, absolutely. She's right that the disproportionate proportion of the prison estate is taken up by those that have been in care. And this goes to the heart of this debate, Mr. Speaker, which is about how do we confront reoffending? We know that reoffending makes up such a large degree of the criminality that we see on our streets. So when people do come into contact with the criminal justice system, too often than not they leave it more likely to commit crimes.

We've got to tackle that. That is an issue of capacity. It's also an issue of investment in probation. And in fact just earlier today the leader of the opposition has said that she wants to support dealing with reoffending, which is a sensible grown-up intervention from the leader of the opposition. I was quite surprised to read it and I look forward to working with her on those issues in the months ahead.

01:28:28 - 01:29:09

Simon Hoare

Speaker, I have Guys Marsh prison in my constituency. It provides valued jobs and I pay tribute to the prison officers who work there. The minister will know that all of these policies flow from the pressure on the spaces in our prison estate. Not that long ago, government had crown and prerogative powers to bring forward new prisons or extend prisons without going through a lengthy planning process. That would solve the problem at a stroke.

Why will the minister not investigate that in order to speed up an expansion in prison spaces?

01:29:10 - 01:29:44

Speaker 109

The honorable member's raised this point on a number of occasions when we've had the opportunity to debate this issue. He's right. We need to look at how we can fast-track planning infrastructure projects of real national importance such as prisons. And I know that the prisons minister and indeed the justice secretary is taking a close eye on that. I would just gently push back to the honorable member that some of his colleagues on that side of the chamber spend a lot of their time in their constituencies opposing the building of prisons.

The member for Market Harborough, who's apologized for the Conservatives' record on criminal justice, spends a lot of time opposing the prison that we're building in his constituency.

01:29:44 - 01:29:45

Ben Obese-Jecty.

01:29:45 - 01:30:17

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The reality is that there would not be an early release scheme if the party opposite had not presided over a record where they left our prisons at 99% capacity, having built a staggeringly low 500 places in their 14 years in government. But my constituents are angry about the situation that we find ourselves in. So I wonder if the minister can set out what steps the government is taking to reassure victims and also to ensure that we never end up in this situation again.

01:30:17 - 01:30:42

Speaker 109

Well, my honorable friend is right. And I can tell, Mr. Speaker, I can set out very clearly what we're doing. By the end of this parliament there'll be more criminals behind bars than ever before under a Labour government. And that's, Mr. Speaker, and that's due to the fact that this government is spending three times, three times more on prison building than the Conservatives ever did. The Conservative government closed 23 prisons, we're building 14,000.

That's the difference between a Labour government and a Conservative government.

01:30:42 - 01:30:43

Richard Tice.

01:30:43 - 01:31:30

Richard Tice

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The sad truth is that dangerous sexual predators are being released early under this scheme. The sister of a friend of mine was told by police just a few weeks ago that her heinous assailant was being released in a few months' time and there was nothing they could do. She resigned her job and she has fled the country in terror. This is where things have got to.

I would say to the minister, there are some 4,000 cells empty requiring maintenance and refurbishment. There are 10,000 cells occupied by overseas nationals. Will the government use those places in order to stop dangerous offenders from being released early?

01:31:30 - 01:32:12

Speaker 109

In terms of the case that the honorable member raises, I'm very happy to ensure that he has the appropriate information needed and we'll be able to look into that case individually.

In terms of capacity more generally, this is still a challenge, the prison capacity. Although there may be 4,000 places available today, obviously there are different categories of prisons, there's a geographical need, it's not quite as simple as simply a numbers game. It's about a bit more of a complicated picture than that. And just in terms of the foreign national offenders, I'm proud that this government has increased the deportation of foreign national offenders by 40%. And we will continue to deport more foreign national offenders when the new ERS scheme comes into effect early next year, and I look forward to members from across the House supporting the government in its efforts.

01:32:12 - 01:32:13

Belinda Jeffs.

01:32:13 - 01:32:45

Speaker 138

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The prisoner early release scheme is here simply because of the failings of the previous Conservative government, and that is absolutely clear. But as the minister has already acknowledged, what we do not want is those prisoners to end up back in prison within a short time after being released. So what is being done to stop those prisoners from reoffending, particularly as regards their re-employment and resettlement?

01:32:45 - 01:33:16

Speaker 109

Well, he's right again, coming to the heart of this issue of this debate is how we can confront reoffending. It's why we're working with local employers and we've got regional councils to try and ensure that people have opportunities for work and housing. It is a challenge. It's been a challenge for decades that ex-offenders when they leave prison often don't have the right support. Now, it's why we're investing in the probation service.

It's why we're working with local authorities at pace to ensure that ex-offenders when they leave prison are given the opportunities to build a stake in society and not commit offences again.

01:33:17 - 01:33:54

Liz Roberts

And I refer members to my register of interests and my role as the chair of the Justice Unions APPG. This second tranche of early releases is coming so soon after the first, probation staff are just in despair at the level of their workloads. And though there was a workload measurement tool and it was used to help balance workloads, but it was switched off from the 25th of September this year. So workload pressures and insufficient pay is why probation union NAPO is holding a formal ballot on industrial action next Monday. Does he recognise therefore that the probation system is on the brink of collapse?

01:33:54 - 01:34:34

Speaker 109

Well, I don't accept that the probation service is characterised as she does so. There are great challenges though, and the prisons minister, prisons probation minister is today at a conference with probation colleagues, meeting them, listening to them, working with them because we need a probation service to work with us on the challenges we face ahead. I would gently say that this government has invested, as I said before, 750 million pounds in probation, the biggest investment in probation for a generation. We've introduced new technology, Justice Transcribe, an app which helps probation officers save huge amount of time with paperwork, building into their capacity. But we accept there are challenges ahead, Mr. Speaker, but we are meeting with colleagues and we'll work with them to meet those challenges.

01:34:34 - 01:34:55

Christopher Paul Webb

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can the minister confirm to my constituents in Blackpool South that the most dangerous offenders, including rapists, are excluded from the progression model? And what steps has his department taken to repair the prison estate left on the brink of collapse by the party opposite and ensure we never reach this crisis point again?

01:34:55 - 01:35:24

Speaker 109

Well, my honourable friend is right and I can confirm, Mr. Speaker, as the Prime Minister has and indeed the Justice Secretary has at this dispatch box, that rapists are not going to be subject to the new regime. And he's also right that constituents like his, like mine, expect us to meet this challenge by building more prison places. That's why we are investing in 14,000 new prison places by 2031. There'll be more criminals behind bars at the end of this parliament under a Labour government.

01:35:24 - 01:35:44

Ashley Peter Fox

Mr. Speaker, the Minister will know that the 3,000 new prison places that have come online since the election were all started by the last Conservative government. So will he tell the House why this government has not planned nor approved any new prison spaces since it came to office?

01:35:44 - 01:36:13

Speaker 109

Mr. Speaker, we hear this a lot. Conservative MPs saying, well, we didn't do anything for 14 years, we didn't spend much money, and in the final few months we thought, gosh, we've got a prison capacity crisis, we better start planning, and then we called an election. It's absolutely hopeless. What we are doing is the biggest prison building program since the Victorian era, 14,000 places by 2031. Now, the policy chief for the Conservatives apologized for their record, the leader of the opposition has apologized for their record on criminal justice, will he?

01:36:13 - 01:36:47

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Minister for that and of course the legacy of the inherit is the inheritance of the failure of the previous government that didn't build enough prison places and left it until the last minute to to sanction new places. I appreciate the clarity from the Minister around the new prison places this government is investing in, 14,000 in the future. Can I also ask about recruitment of prison officer staff to ensure that we have those personnel in place to support that expansion so that we do not have to resort to early release in the future?

01:36:47 - 01:37:07

Speaker 109

Well, he's absolutely right that there's a challenge alongside our prison building program, which we are again, the biggest bis the biggest prison building program since the Victorian era, we do need to recruit staff to staff those prisons. It's why again, we are implementing a new range of recruitment initiatives to ensure that we have the prison officers in place to make those prisons safe and workable.

01:37:07 - 01:37:40

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have several constituents who've been in touch with me who are victims of domestic abuse and desperately need to move. Emotional support and safety planning is cold comfort when their offenders are cutting off their tags, when they're making threats to kill, and when the victim's address has been disclosed to them. And still these vulnerable families are coming 12th, 15th, 18th on the list for being moved for new social housing. So what is the Ministry of Justice doing with local authorities to ensure these families are properly prioritized?

01:37:40 - 01:38:02

Speaker 109

Well, Mr. Speaker, that absolutely shouldn't be the case and I'll ensure that the right minister appropriate minister meets with her and discusses those individual cases. As I've said, we've invested in community safeguarding measures with another 18 million pounds for victim support as well, but I appreciate entirely, Mr. Speaker, the victims want reassurances to their safety, not just warm words, and that's what this government is committed to doing.

01:38:02 - 01:38:36

John Thomas Hayes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Residents and I are deeply concerned about the possible return of a convicted child sex offender to Townsend following his planned release. On Saturday I held a community meeting which was joined by the Police and Crime Commissioner as well as Dorset Police, and it's clear that people are concerned about this man not just being a cause of concern in his own right, but being a magnet for violent and antisocial behavior to himself and to the wider community. Will the Minister arrange for a meeting with the Probation Minister and myself and local residents because the last thing we want is to see Townsend go through this sort of ordeal?

01:38:36 - 01:38:48

Speaker 109

Well, my honorable friend has raised this particular issue and indeed this issue more generally with me on numerous occasions and and I will to the extent that I'm allowed to make these promises at the dispatch box will ensure that he has the right meeting with the appropriate minister.

01:38:48 - 01:39:16

Charlie Dewhirst

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I must take umbrage with this idea the last government was too slow to react. HMP Millsike in my constituency was given planning approval in September 2019, but it took six years to build. That prison, according to the MOJ's latest figures, Mr. Speaker, still has 344 empty cells. So shouldn't the Minister be moving heaven and earth to ensure we fill every available cell rather than releasing dangerous criminals back onto our streets?

01:39:16 - 01:39:55

Speaker 109

Well, Mr. Speaker, as I've said, the leader of the opposition's apologized for their record, but some of them haven't got the message.

In terms of using the space, he's absolutely right that we need to maximize the prison estate. The Lord Chancellor and Justice Secretary at this dispatch box made it very clear that he was looking at how we can maximize all parts of the prison estate. As I've said before answering a question earlier in the session, Mr. Speaker, it's not quite as straightforward as just a numbers game because there are different categories of prisoners, there's different geographical demands. One in seven of the prison population are on recall, many are on remand, so need to be near the appropriate court. It's not quite as straightforward as the honorable member would like to suggest, but of course we are determined to use every single space that we can.

01:39:55 - 01:40:33

Christopher John Vince

Chris Binns. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Minister for his comments about probation. We saw the failure of the privatization experiment done by the previous government and the impact that had on probation staff and those people that were using the probation service, so I welcome those comments. Like the member opposite, I'm really concerned about those that are using tags and cutting those tags off, and I've spoken to victims of domestic violence in my constituency of Harlow who have raised that directly to me. So what reassurance can he give me that that won't be allowed to happen, and if it does happen, those people that are on tags and take those tags off will be treated severely?

01:40:33 - 01:41:17

Speaker 109

Minister. My honorable friend is right that any attempt to interfere with tagging is very serious and will be treated with in the toughest possible way. There have been concerns raised about the tagging regime by the NAO and others, and the government will be responding in due course. Performance has improved since the interim report was published a few months ago, but he is also absolutely right that at the heart of this is how we tackle reoffending and how we bolster our probation service. We have invested in our probation service, there are challenges that have been raised that we accept, but I will not, Mr. Speaker, take lessons on the probation service from the party opposite after the failed privatization that they implemented on the probation service under now Lord Grayling, Lord Grayling, one of the biggest failed experiments in public service reform in the last 40 years.

01:41:17 - 01:41:55

Speaker 85

Wera Hobhouse. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week I held my regular roundtable of local domestic abuse organizations in Bath, and there was fear, Mr. Speaker, I mean real fear about those from those organizations who represent survivors and victims about the number of early releases. Avon and Somerset Police was at the meeting, at the roundtable, and tried to reassure the group that they had the capacity and could manage the situation, but how will the government actually make sure and assess and review that Avon and Somerset does have the capacity to support victims and survivors? How do we assess that, when will there be a review?

01:41:55 - 01:42:32

Speaker 109

Minister. The honorable member is right, and this government understands there are concerns, understandable concerns from victims' groups and victims themselves. The Lord Chancellor and Justice Secretary was at this dispatch box and accepted that, and we've invested more into our victims' liaison work to ensure that we are doing a better job at reaching out to victims, ensuring that they are heard, and also listening to them to make sure that we are able to put into effect safety measures that will help them. We are regularly talking with the police and investing in the police as well to ensure that as much as possible we keep communities as safe during this period.

01:42:32 - 01:43:17

Clive Efford

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for taking me even though I had to leave the chamber briefly for duties elsewhere in the house. 650 people being released today. We know they're coming, we can anticipate the fact that we need to release 650 people. Now I Googled, what's the reason we can't tag people on release, and it says it's the lack of capacity of the companies that have got the contracts for actually attaching these tags. Now that seems to me that they're not fulfilling the contract.

It can't be beyond the technological ability to tag people on release, so what are these companies going to do about that?

01:43:17 - 01:43:51

Speaker 109

Minister. Well, he's right, Mr. Speaker, that there has been question marks, to put it mildly, about the performance of these companies who undertake the contracts.

We are working closely with Serco to see that has seen an improvement in the implementation of the tagging since March earlier this year. I would also suggest although there is a presumption for every person to be released to be tagged, ultimately this is an operational decision and a decision for the probation service as as is the case for the 4,500 prisoners who are released every month as per normal.

01:43:51 - 01:43:53

Speaker 132

Jim Shannon.

01:43:53 - 01:44:41

Jim Shannon

Thank the minister very much for his answers. Can I say to the minister they I'm sure he watched the TV this morning where the Met Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley was on saying he's arresting two or three early release offenders per week. If that is the case and it seems that it is so and he gave an example of the person who was arrested last week, sorry was released last week for for theft from shops and he lasted a whole few days and he's back in again for the very same thing. But more worryingly the Met Commissioner said this morning those who have been convicted of of criminal armed of firearms offenses have been released. Surely minister it's time to ensure that gun-toting criminals aren't allowed back out in the streets again.

01:44:41 - 01:45:38

Speaker 109

I thought that there was going to be a session without a question from the honorable member so it's reassuring to have the question. The the point here is that we know that for example one in seven of the prison population are in prison on recall already. There are recall provisions in in in operation and that's right if people are released from prisons and they break their license conditions or indeed commit a further offense they should be brought back to prison. Now that is the system working. We want to bring down that number because we want to tackle reoffending and make sure when people do leave prison they don't turn to crime again and that's a lot of the work we're doing with the probation service and local authorities.

01:45:38 - 01:45:45

Speaker 130

We now come to next urgent question, Secretary of State Tom Tugendhat.

01:45:45 - 01:46:01

Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat

Thank you very much Mr. Speaker. I'm grateful this is the first time you've granted me an urgent question in this role. I have a fear that it won't be the last but I am I am grateful for you doing so. To ask the Foreign Secretary if he will make a statement on the threats posed by Iran to British interests.

01:46:01 - 01:49:02

Stephen Doughty

Well thank you Mr. Speaker and I'm grateful to the right honorable member for his urgent question. And can I Mr. Speaker also welcome him to his role. He's always been a good colleague and friend and indeed thank him for his service to this country not only as a former minister but also in his past career. Mr. Speaker the government takes the threats posed by Iran to British interests extremely seriously. We have acted robustly in response to them and we will continue to do so.

Iran's hostile activity both directly and through its proxies and networks continues to pose a significant threat to the United Kingdom to our partners and allies and to the rules-based international system. And we know the threats posed by Iran and whether that is directly or whether it's through partners like the Houthis or indeed militias in Iraq or indeed Hezbollah many many other groups that he is more than aware of we will act and protecting the British public and defending our national security is the government's first duty. Yesterday Mr. Speaker the government sanctioned two Iranian IRGC officers for their role in state threats activity. We have sanctioned nearly 240 individuals and entities in relation to Iran whose actions threaten our people and security and we'll continue to keep all those tools under review and will not hesitate to take further action where appropriate. Yesterday Mr. Speaker I summoned the Iranian ambassador to the Foreign Office in response to Iran's activity and informed him candidly and forcibly that this government condemns in the strongest possible terms the Islamic Republic of Iran's continued attempts to undermine the safety and security of the United Kingdom and our allies.

Yesterday, Mr. Speaker, the Foreign Secretary signed a statement with 35 other foreign ministers across the Five Eyes and Europe, making clear that we will not tolerate state threats activity on our soil and that we are committed to facing those threats together. And earlier this year, Mr. Speaker, we strengthened our legislative toolkit through the National Security Framework, and these measures provide enhanced powers to investigate, expose, and counter hostile activity that threatens our security, and he will note that we immediately designated the IRGC and the IMCR under that framework. We will continue to work closely with the police, intelligence agencies, and international partners to identify, disrupt, and deter hostile activity directed against the United Kingdom and our allies. And as recent events have demonstrated, the threat from Iran is not theoretical. The Prime Minister yesterday made clear that in relation to the incident at RAF Fairford, this was highly likely coordinated in Iran and almost certainly directed by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, although investigations remain ongoing.

And more recently in September, Mr. Speaker, law enforcement agencies disrupted an alleged plot targeting Jewish communities in Manchester involving individuals suspected of links to actors in Iran. So, Mr. Speaker, we will continue to take the action necessary to protect the public, safeguard our democratic institutions, defend communities at risk, and ensure those that are responsible for threatening British interests are held to account.

01:49:02 - 01:51:22

Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Look, I'm grateful to my honorable friend, actually, and he is a friend, for his response today. After almost a decade, however, of consistent Foreign Office advice being to reject photographs and particularly handshake photographs with Iranian officials because of the propaganda tool that it gives the regime, it seems that our Foreign Secretary has just been ambushed in New York. Now, either it has been an ambush by a snapper or it has been a change of policy, and I think it's important that we understand which, because while it is certainly clear that the Foreign Secretary didn't look happy, Araghchi was absolutely beaming. Now, if this wasn't deliberate, has the Foreign Office changed its advice, and if so, why?

Because frankly, following the threats against UK airbases that not only has he mentioned but the Prime Minister has, following the state threats that the head of MI5 has listed, which have been reported on today, following the murder of 40,000 of their own people, their expansion of violence in Yemen using the Houthis to target civilians in Riyadh, their attacks on Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, and the United Arab Emirates, I'd be very grateful to know what made the Foreign Secretary believe that this was worth giving them a propaganda win. Perhaps the Minister will tell me that this doesn't matter. Now, he knows better than that, of course. He knows that images project a message, and in this case, they project the message that the Iranian regime is equal to the moment. Well, they're not.

The reality is the Iranian regime, in fact Mr. Araghchi himself, is merely the front for the IRGC, which is of course the terror group responsible for the murder of thousands in Lebanon, Syria, Israel, Iraq, and elsewhere. So maybe I could just finish by asking the Minister very briefly a few questions. The first is, was the Foreign Secretary aware of his Iranian friend's threats to the United Kingdom before he decided to shake hands with him and have it photographed? Was the UK aware that the US and Israel had given warning to the British government that the Iranian regime's threats to the US airbases in the UK were credible? And lastly, has the policy of the UK reverted now to not giving propaganda wins to such a vile regime?

01:51:22 - 01:54:15

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, the Foreign Secretary followed the standard practice of previous UK Foreign Secretaries of both parties and many countries in meeting with the Iranian Foreign Minister. In fact, Foreign Ministers including William Hague, Philip Hammond, Boris Johnson, Jeremy Hunt, sorry, I should refer to him by his new constituency, Liz Truss, David Cameron and others, and they've all engaged. And I think what's important, Mr. Speaker, is to understand what the Foreign Secretary raised with Foreign Minister Abdollahian. He met with him to strongly raise the UK government's objections to Iran's behaviors to protect our interests. He told the Foreign Minister that Iran should choose de-escalation and diplomacy instead of prolonging war and conflict.

He underlined the importance of restoring freedom of navigation and the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. He reiterated the UK's unwavering resolve to combat threats from Iranian-backed groups on UK soil, including attacks on the British Jewish community. He made clear that we will not tolerate intimidation, threats or hostile activity on UK soil and set out the measures we would take in response. And he also raised, Mr. Speaker, I know would be a matter of great interest to the House, the ongoing detention of Craig and Lindsay Forman, repeating our call for their immediate release and stressing that their welfare remains a priority for the government. And Mr. Speaker, he knows full well that Iran's threats to the UK are public, and indeed the evidence that the Prime Minister, Foreign Secretary and others have set out are public.

So we are fully aware of the threat that they pose to the UK, our interests and our allies and partners. I'm not going to comment on intelligence matters. He knows why I won't do that at the dispatch box. I would strongly encourage him to avail himself of opportunities for Privy Council briefings. We'd be very happy to arrange those.

Mr. Speaker, I know the Leader of the Opposition and others have taken those opportunities up. He's very welcome to come in and have a briefing on those matters. He rightly raised, Mr. Speaker, issues relating to Iran's threats more broadly, not just to the UK and our interests directly, including to partners in the Gulf. What Iran has done in relation to whether it's Kuwait or Bahrain or other partners is utterly unacceptable. I met with all of our Gulf partners in New York and over recent days to reiterate our support for them and another reason why we're engaged in such heavy diplomatic and other efforts to find a resolution.

And just this morning, Mr. Speaker, I've spoken with my Saudi counterpart and indeed the Foreign Minister of Yemen in relation to the appalling Houthi attacks not only on the people of Yemen, but also of course on Saudi Arabia and the Kingdom in recent days, including the attacks at the airport in Riyadh and other threats. And so he can be absolutely assured that whether it is direct threats from Iran or whether it is indirect threats through proxies and partners and others, we take these matters incredibly seriously. A substantial amount of our diplomatic and other effort is involved in countering them, and I welcome his engagement and cooperation in the national interest on these issues.

01:54:15 - 01:55:09

Anne Emily Thornberry

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the calling out of what seems to be the IRGC's actions in Fairford, not just by the UK, but by 30, at more over 30 of our friends and partners from Albania to the USA. And I thank them for standing in solidarity with us. Much of the IRGC's divisive work, whether it's feeding antisemitism or through bots wearing kilts, is done quietly and in the shadows and often online. This time, it looks like they have been caught out through the diligence of a local resident.

Would the Minister agree with me that our approach needs to change? That we need to be clear about what Iranian attempts to hurt our country actually look like, both offline and online, with more examples, so that the public are confident to identify these attacks, just like they were at Fairford.

01:55:09 - 01:55:52

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, the right honorable, my right honorable friend, the Chair of the Select Committee, raises very important issues. And it's a fact that Iran poses threats across a range of domains, and she rightly raises the issue of information and disinformation as well. And I know her committee's been doing very important work on that, and certainly the government has taken that on board very seriously with the announcement of our new Center for Information Resilience the Prime Minister referred to yesterday.

But she's absolutely clear we need to be very open-eyed about the threats that are posed. We certainly do attempt to keep the public informed as to the nature of these threats and indeed the threats not just in this country but abroad and we will continue to act across a range of measures to deter and to disrupt them.

01:55:52 - 01:56:52

Calum Miller

Calum Miller, Liberal Democrats spokesperson.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Iranian regime is a threat to global security, to the UK's interests and to its own citizens. The question is how best to respond to that threat while protecting people at home. The unilateral US and Israeli attack on Iran and the conflict that has followed has driven up prices for British families while emboldening the Iranian regime. I visited Oman last week and refer members to my register of interests.

At the Maritime Security Center, we were told that shipping rates are less than half the rate they were prior to the conflict with a mere 35 to 50 vessels passing through Omani waters in the Strait of Hormuz each night, every one of them at risk of attack from Iranian drones or missiles. So can the Minister set out what steps the government is taking with other maritime nations to protect shipping and secure safe passage through the Straits of Hormuz and Bab-el-Mandeb, keeping food on our shelves and fuel in our tanks at prices that British consumers can afford?

01:56:52 - 01:58:32

Stephen Doughty

Well, he absolutely raises the reason why all of this matters, not just the threats to our security but to our economy as well and to the prices that British people pay and indeed people around the world pay for whether it's energy or indeed consumer goods on the shelves because of course that disruption to energy of course has a wider implication of course it's the fertilizer and other things that come out of the Gulf that also impact on those prices. I'm delighted that he visited Oman. I also was in Oman just a few weeks ago. They're a key partner, friend and long-standing historic relationship with the UK is crucially important to us. We're looking forward to welcoming His Majesty the Sultan of Oman to the UK soon.

His Majesty the King looks forward to welcoming him. It's a crucial partnership for us. He's absolutely right to talk about maritime security and the work we do in that domain. I'm glad he saw the work in his visit. I also visited just last week our Joint Maritime Security Center at Portsmouth and the incredible work done there jointly between the Royal Navy, Border Force, UK Maritime Trade Operations and a range of different civilian and other agencies.

It's crucial that we understand the threats to shipping and then that we are able to provide information to mariners, avoid threats and avoid risk. We continue to work internationally with partners on this, just at the UN in New York at the General Assembly, the Foreign Secretary working with Bahrain and others brought together I think nearly 80 countries to stand up for those principles of international navigation and it's crucial that we recognize this isn't just what happens in the Strait of Hormuz or indeed in the Red Sea, this is a threat to the very principles of freedom of navigation and global trade and that is why we need to stand up and defend those.

01:58:32 - 01:59:01

Alexander Robert Ballinger

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I enjoy the government took the very welcome step of designating the IRGC, criminalizing support for their hostile activities. Given Iran's support for the Houthis, their recent attacks on Saudi Arabia, their threats to international shipping in the Bab-el-Mandeb and Red Sea, is this a step the government is considering taking against the Houthis or are they looking at proscribing the organization as a terrorist group?

01:59:01 - 01:59:51

Stephen Doughty

Well, he knows I don't comment on future designations but he can be assured that we take the threat posed by the Houthis both in the region and more broadly incredibly seriously and indeed as I said I spoke with the Foreign Minister of Yemen this morning. Utterly appalled, Madam Deputy Speaker, to also hear how the Houthis are using child soldiers, enforced re-education of citizens in areas they've taken, the attacks that are currently taking place around Taiz and the humanitarian crisis, hundreds of thousands of people displaced. So it's not just the kinetic and appalling attacks we've seen on Saudi Arabia and within Yemen, it's also the humanitarian suffering that's caused by their actions. And we stand with the recognized government of Yemen and indeed with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and others. But he absolutely rightly points to the work we've taken in relation to the IRGC and the IMCR and indeed individuals and that relates to the sanctions we issued just yesterday.

01:59:51 - 01:59:52

Dr. Kieran Mullan.

01:59:52 - 02:00:13

John Kieran Mullan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When the Iranians risked the lives of armed forces personnel by attacking RAF Akrotiri earlier this year, members opposite took great pleasure in mocking the leader of opposition for suggesting that a direct attack required a direct response. Doesn't this latest episode just prove to our enemies that when we don't respond with force that they're encouraged to come at us yet again?

02:00:13 - 02:00:24

Stephen Doughty

I am absolutely assured that we will respond to defend our bases and our allies and our partners and indeed UK interests in this country with absolute resolution and vigour.

02:00:25 - 02:00:56

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the Minister's statement today. As a member of the IDC committee, I regularly hear about conflicts such as the war in Gaza, Lebanon, and Yemen, while Iranian proxies are actively fighting, destabilizing countries and causing death and despair. Can the Minister say what the FCDO is doing to support victims of Iran in these countries and to ensure that Yemen, Lebanon, and Palestine have functioning states free of Iranian influence?

02:00:56 - 02:01:22

Stephen Doughty

Well, I completely share her objective, which is eliminating that Iranian influence and destabilizing factor in all of these contexts. And she rightly mentions a number of those. I already mentioned Yemen and what we're doing there. We also announced 10 million additional to the humanitarian appeal from the United Nations to respond to the terrible situation. But she also points on Lebanon, and we're working closely with the government of Lebanon to respond to the crisis there in a range of ways.

02:01:22 - 02:01:55

Julian Lewis

Sir Julian Lewis.

Does the Minister agree with me that it sends a strange signal when people suspected of mounting a terrorist attack backed by Iran are let out on bail? And does he also share my concern at recent media reports of several fortunately foiled terrorist attacks which were being planned by people who came into this country illegally on boats crossing the channel?

02:01:55 - 02:02:26

Stephen Doughty

Well, as he'll understand, I'm not going to comment on the ongoing investigations into the events at RAF Fairford or police operational decisions. That's very much for them to make. But in terms of the broader point he makes about threats and challenges, he will know that MI5 identified at least 15 credible Iranian-backed plots to kill or kidnap people in the UK between 2022 and 2023 alone. This is obviously activity over a sustained period of time, and it's exactly why we have made clear at the highest levels to the Iranian regime that this must end immediately.

02:02:26 - 02:02:27

Jessica Toale.

02:02:27 - 02:02:47

Jade Jessica Toale

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As we know, Iran's use of criminal networks and online disinformation is a threat to national security and a threat to British safety on our soil. I welcome the recent designations, but does the Minister agree with me that further sanctions are required on Iran and the IRGC to restrict their capacity?

02:02:47 - 02:03:03

Stephen Doughty

Well, she will know that I don't comment on future designations, but I can absolutely assure her that we will continue to keep all possibilities to deter and disrupt Iranian state threat activity on our soil or indeed their activities elsewhere. We keep these measures regular under review, and the action we've taken in recent weeks I think is testament to that.

02:03:03 - 02:03:33

Charles Edward Robin Morello

Edward Morello.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The incident at RAF Fairford just proved yet again a point that we have long known, which is that Iran is an exporter of terrorism and violence around the world, not just in the UK but also crucially in the region. We've seen the support for Hezbollah undermining security in Lebanon.

We have seen the attacks on our ally Saudi Arabia. What is the government planning on doing to increase the level of support that we provide to our allies in the region to counter the Iranian threat?

02:03:33 - 02:04:07

Stephen Doughty

Well, he's absolutely right on the scale of the threat and that's exactly why we announced measures and a statement with many, many countries yesterday, joining efforts really to respond to these threats. But, you know, whether it's in Saudi Arabia, the air defense support we're supplying at the moment, or indeed the air-to-air refueling, or whether it's the work that we did to support air defense in many Gulf partners when they were undergoing attacks, we won't cease in our efforts to support our partners and our allies in responding to and defending themselves from unprovoked Iranian aggression.

02:04:07 - 02:04:26

Speaker 151

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Just this morning, the chief of MI5 warned about the implications of AI reducing the barrier to advanced terror and cyber attacks on the United Kingdom. So can I ask the minister what work he and his colleagues have done in assessing how Iran is using this technology and how we can defend ourselves?

02:04:26 - 02:04:49

Stephen Doughty

Well, the implications of AI for our defense and security are obviously significant. He knows there's important work being done by my colleague, the honorable member for the Vale of Glamorgan on this issue. It's crucial that we look at this not just in any one individual context. He rightly mentions the risks of Iran or others using this technology, but of course this applies more broadly and I can assure him that we are leading international efforts on these conversations.

02:04:49 - 02:05:56

Mark Pritchard

Mr. Pritchard, are you content with your seat? You seem to be bouncing around the chamber. Are you happy where you are? Marvelous, Mark Pritchard.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I hope the minister, who I have a lot of time for as he knows, Minister of State, will confirm to the House he's read the Intelligence and Security Committee report on Iran published in July 2025, because many of the issues raised in that report have been raised on the floor of the House today. But in 1862, Madam Deputy Speaker, the first Iranian to become a British national, dual national, in this country. Since then, we've around 120 British Iranians live in this country. Not all of them are dual nationals, but many of them are.

Given that Iran does not recognize dual nationality and many British Iranians are traveling back to see family in Iran, what further consideration has the minister given to the current travel advice by the Foreign Office, given that they are, unfortunately, the Iranian regime are detaining people illegally?

02:05:56 - 02:06:24

Stephen Doughty

Well, he rightly illustrates the level of risk to people and I would strongly encourage anyone, whether they're dual national or otherwise, to read and to heed the FCDO travel advice in relation to Iran. These are very, very serious threats and we know from people previously being detained and we know the very high-profile cases I referred to one of them of the risks that are involved. So we would encourage people to follow that advice very closely and I will certainly look at the report that he mentioned.

02:06:24 - 02:06:45

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the minister for his responses to some of the questions so far and I would reiterate the concerns raised by some of my colleagues about concerns about online disinformation, which are clearly designed to undermine our democracy in this country. But can the minister give me more information about what this government is doing to tackle the hostile activity by Iran and its network of proxy groups?

02:06:45 - 02:07:23

Stephen Doughty

Well, we're acting against the threats posed by these in a number of different ways. And we in June, and I mentioned the statement that we just signed this last few days, but in June we actually engaged in a joint statement with 24 other countries relating to the lethal plotting and other malign actions by Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Intelligence Organization, the Quds Force, and the Ministry of Intelligence and Security, including threats against dissidents, journalists, Jewish and Israeli communities. This is a wide range of activities that they're undertaking and we need to work together with other key partners to deter and disrupt this activity.

02:07:23 - 02:07:57

Brendan O'Hara

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I ask the minister about the assessments that the government has made about the threats we currently face from the IRGC or its proxies? So what assessment has the government made of the impact of February's US-Israeli attack and does it show whether those attacks have strengthened or weakened the regime in Tehran both internally and externally?

And do those assessments show whether the UK has become more exposed to events such as we witnessed recently or less exposed as compared to before February?

02:07:57 - 02:08:29

Stephen Doughty

Well, he knows that I'm not going to comment on intelligence assessments, but what I will say is that we continue to seek diplomatic resolution of the crisis in relation to the Straits of Hormuz. And there is a huge amount of common ground between all partners in relation to Iran. Firstly, that they cannot be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon. They must cease their attacks on partners and allies and indeed our interests. They need to stop this malign activity in our country and others.

02:08:29 - 02:08:36

Speaker 154

And of course, they need to stop the repression of their own people. So I think there's a lot of common ground, but I'm not going to comment on specific assessments.

02:08:36 - 02:08:57

Speaker 152

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The threat of Iranian surveillance is very real in my constituency with communities, faith communities and residential communities sharing with me the real fear that they face. Can the Minister share with us the processes that are in place between the FCDO and the Home Office to make sure that communities are as safe as they possibly can be and that intelligence is appropriately shared?

02:08:57 - 02:09:33

Stephen Doughty

Well, she's absolutely right to highlight these threats and I cooperate very closely with the Security Minister and others in these matters. And I referenced the number of plots that MI5 had identified. Of course, those threats continue and we've seen some very, very high-profile examples that the Prime Minister and others referred to. She can be absolutely assured that not only are we putting in place the necessary protective security arrangements, including with faith communities and particularly with the Jewish community, but also that we are very aware of where threats are originating from. And that's the nature of the response that we have conveyed directly to the Iranian regime.

02:09:33 - 02:09:34

Dr. Andrew Murrison.

02:09:34 - 02:10:12

Andrew Murrison

The regime is using every opportunity to reach deep into our communities and into society. Even charities in this country are at risk and the Charities Commission has embarked upon an investigation into the extent to which the regime, particularly the IRGC, is percolating into its sector. What assessment has the Minister made of whether or not Iran has got itself involved in British charities? And if he believes that it has done, how is he going to expunge that particular malignancy?

02:10:12 - 02:11:33

Stephen Doughty

Well, he raises an important wider issue which is not just Iran but other hostile states attempting to undermine or utilize mechanisms in the UK to conduct their activities. I welcome the work that Charity Commission's doing in this regard. We'll look very seriously at any findings that they that come out of that investigation. But crucially again, this is a matter for the Security Minister and our agencies to look at. We take any threats or any activity of that nature incredibly seriously and won't hesitate to act.

Madam Deputy Speaker, with Iranian efforts to weaponize social media widely acknowledged, not only to promote its own propaganda but also to spread disinformation and shape UK politics, can I ask the Minister what work is being done to hold the social media companies whose algorithms boost dangerous content to account?

Well, it's an important question. He'll know the work that's been done through the Online Safety Act and other measures. But the wider challenge and threat of disinformation is growing. We spend a lot of time focusing on Russian disinformation in this place and the billions that they are spending. But of course, it's not just Russia, it is Iran, it is others.

And that's exactly why the Prime Minister is bringing together our capabilities, responding as well to the Foreign Affairs Select Committee recommendations with the new Center for Information Resilience.

02:11:33 - 02:12:20

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think there's a real fear that Iran has actually achieved its aim in terms of its attack on RAF Fairford, because what you saw is the US responding to that by removing the very important military capability away from Europe, away from the United Kingdom. Does the Minister agree, and I know that he's very thoughtful on this matter and sympathetic to it, that there is a need for increased military spending, and would he use his office to put pressure on Downing Street and Treasury to come forward with a settlement for our armed forces to make sure that we have the capabilities to properly defend bases like RAF Fairford and so many more up and down the country?

02:12:20 - 02:12:56

Stephen Doughty

Well, he'll know that we're spending hundreds of million in defensive measures around bases in the UK, and he will also know that operational decisions for the United States are based on a range of factors, and of course the US continues to retain a very significant presence, and rightly so, in the United Kingdom as our closest defense and security partner. He'll know also that we've raised defense spending, spending 300 billion over the course of this Parliament. We've increased to 2.7% from the 2.3% under his government, and we will continue on that track to the 3.5% by 2035.

02:12:56 - 02:13:22

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Two weeks ago, the Minister was clear that if Iran or the IRGC was confirmed to be behind the plot at RAF base Fairford, then every Iranian diplomat who assisted in acts of terror should be expelled, up to and including the ambassador. That has now been confirmed, and I wondered what the Foreign Secretary intends to do and when.

02:13:22 - 02:14:02

Stephen Doughty

Well, as I said, the ongoing investigations into the RAF Fairford incidents are continuing, and it's right that they're able to take their course. The Prime Minister set out very clearly the situation and the Iranian involvement in that yesterday. But what I would say is that I have conveyed at the highest levels, and indeed I summoned the Iranian ambassador yesterday to make clear, absolutely and categorically, our condemnation of Iran's actions and our expectation that they cease them immediately. We always ensure that diplomats operating in the UK are able to do so in accordance with the Vienna Convention. We keep all of that always under review.

02:14:02 - 02:15:08

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Minister very much for his answers as well. We all in this House recognize the commitment that the Minister has, truly has, to the job that he does. The hostile activities of the Iranian regime, both through state actions and dangerous proxies across the Middle East, pose a direct, undeniable threat to the national security of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The Minister and I share many things, including Iran's worsening track record of human rights abuses and religious persecution and hanging of prisoners whose only crime was a peaceful protest needs to stop.

Can the Minister outline please what robust coordinated steps government is taking alongside our international allies to dismantle Iran's cyber warfare capabilities and its funding of global terror? And what, and can the Minister reassure my constituents in Strangford and across Northern Ireland that our own domestic infrastructure is fully secured against Iranian state-sponsored cyber threats? Thank you.

02:15:08 - 02:15:40

Stephen Doughty

Well, we're fully aware of the threats that Iran poses, and our agencies do important work in identifying those threats and responding to them. And we have excellent teams that work in cyber defense. Of course, cyber defense is a responsibility of all in society, businesses, individual citizens, and government and agencies, so we all have to play a part in that endeavor. And in terms of internal repression in Iran, including of religious minorities, I share his deep concerns, our abhorrence at the death penalty being used.

And that's exactly why we do maintain diplomatic relations and we engage closely through our ambassador and others to raise those concerns and to try and hope for a better future for all people in Iran and globally.

02:15:40 - 02:23:02

Pat McFadden

That is the end of the urgent question, threats posed by Iran to British interests. I'll give the front benches a moment to shuffle over. If colleagues are settled, we now come to the first statement, Adjusted Triple Lock, Secretary of State Pat McFadden.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to make a statement on the government's plans for the future uprating of the state pension. Security and dignity in later life is a mission that has run through every Labour government. Harold Wilson was the first to introduce the statutory link with earnings. The creation of pension credit in the early 2000s increased the incomes of the poorest pensioners and saw pensioner poverty halve under the last Labour government.

And in our 2024 manifesto, we said we would keep the triple lock for the duration of this Parliament. That is a promise we will keep to pensioners. And keeping that promise means that this year, the full new state pension is rising by 575 pounds. It is set to be over 2,000 pounds a year more by the end of this Parliament compared to when we took office in 2024. That will make, will take the new state pension to over 30% of average earnings by the end of the Parliament.

This is forecast to be a record high. In the future, we will adjust the triple lock to make those gains permanent, but also to put the state pension on a sustainable basis. Let me set out how this will work and how it will deliver a state pension that rises each and every year. The uprating mechanism will retain its current three elements. There will be a universal state pension that protects against inflation, ensures a material rise every year, and enables pensioners to share in the wealth of the nation as wages go up.

So from April 2030, the state pension will continue to go up by the highest of inflation, 2.5%, or what is required to maintain its record high level against average earnings. This will lock in for the future all the gains from the triple lock up until April 2030. This adjusted mechanism will mean the state pension grows in line with earnings over time instead of outpacing them, as is the case with the current triple lock. This will end what is known as the ratchet effect that makes the triple lock consume a greater and greater share of national wealth over time and which means that reform at some stage was inevitable. In simple terms, it will mean the state pension will continue to rise but not permanently grow as a share of average earnings.

We know that people want security in retirement. We are committed to protecting the poorest pensioners and under our plans, pensioner poverty is set to fall. In addition, we've asked the Pensions Commission to include suggestions for further supporting lower income pensioners in their final report to be delivered next year.

But Madam Deputy Speaker, a good retirement is about more than income. It's about security and peace of mind too. And that is why it is so important that savings from this change will make a significant contribution to a new settlement for older people, a rising, more sustainable state pension alongside free personal care through a new National Care Service. This is a policy that is better for pensioners, better for families, and better for the NHS. Better for pensioners because so many worry about what will happen to them in their final years.

Better for families because those worries are shared by children and grandchildren who want to know their elderly relatives will be looked after when they need it. And better for the NHS because it will ease the pressure we see on the NHS today where failings in our social care system mean many pensioners are kept in hospital longer than they need to be because social care beds are unavailable. The cost of inaction, the cost of turning away from this, is more pressure on the NHS, more ambulance call-outs, more A&E admissions, more corridor care, and more people stuck in hospital when they don't have to be, and that is why change is needed. Now the triple lock has of course been subject to much debate. Economists and commentators have proposed a range of options, as have the party opposite over the years, from removing the earnings link to scrapping the triple lock altogether.

Some have called for the state pension to be means-tested, but we have rejected these proposals. We believe our plan is the right answer to a difficult question that has been ignored for far too long. I am enormously grateful to my honourable friend the Minister for Pensions for his work in this area and for helping ensure we could have a system going forward that is sustainable and retains in an adjusted way the three current elements of the triple lock system. Now Madam Deputy Speaker, this will mean that the state pension will not continue to outpace average earnings as it would have under the current triple lock, and the savings from these changes will reduce spending by an estimated 15 billion pounds a year by the end of the next decade, rising substantially to around 50 billion pounds a year by 2050. These pension and social care changes are a new settlement which puts the universal state pension on a more sustainable footing so it is there for decades to come, while also giving pensioners and older people a better deal on social care.

Pensioners can be confident that they'll have a rising state pension every year, and they can also be confident that we are sorting out one of the most difficult problems the country has faced for a long time, and that is the issue of social care. So, a new settlement for pensioners, a rising pension, a sustainable system, and a plan to fix our social care system. That is what we will deliver, and I commend this statement to the House.

02:23:02 - 02:28:02

Helen Whately

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. 30 years ago, nearly one in three pensioners in our country lived in poverty. Today that figure has halved, in no small thanks to the decisions made by our party in government to stand by pensioners. People who have done the right thing, worked all their lives, and paid into the system.

That's a fair thing to do and it's the right thing to do. Yet we are faced with a government that doesn't seem concerned about what is fair or right. Can the Secretary of State explain why his party has chosen to go after pensioners instead of tackling the fastest growing part of the benefits bill, working age welfare? Working age benefits are costing us 140 billion pounds a year and rising fast. That includes the cost of benefits of 6 million working age people who are not working.

Many could and should be, but instead they are spending decades of their lives on benefits. It's unaffordable and it's morally wrong. Yet he's done nothing of substance about it. And now his party's refusal to bring down the welfare bill is putting the state pension in jeopardy. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister is desperate for cash to pay for his new National Care Service.

That's why he's ditching the triple lock. And let's not beat around the bush and say it's some kind of adjustment or something, it's ditching the triple lock. But let's look at the numbers for a moment. The savings he's hoping for will hardly touch the sides. Come the mid-2030s, a National Care Service is forecast to cost over 18 billion pounds versus potentially 4 billion a year in savings from the triple lock.

And that's extremely uncertain. The care service could well cost more, demand does tend to grow for something that's free, but scrapping the triple lock could save less. At the very least, Labour's policy creates a 15 billion black hole in the public finances. And what a way to announce it, in a couple of lines in a conference speech. No proper explanation, no detail, just millions of pensioners left wondering what it means for their retirement.

Labour backbenchers should remember how these things go. Their last Prime Minister came after pensioners' winter fuel payments, not a plan that stood the test of time. Their first U-turn. How many of the honourable members sitting here today defended that ill-conceived policy only to see it abandoned in the face of pressure? Listening to the Secretary of State's statement, it's clear he's branding this plan as the Pension Minister's idea.

It's not his first rodeo. I suspect he can see this is a U-turn in waiting. How long has it got? And all this before the government's own Pensions Commission has even reported. Did the Secretary of State forget he had one?

They asked it to look at whether people will have enough to live on in retirement. Why bother asking for independent advice if he has already made up his mind on the biggest question? The right honourable gentleman will know that more women rely on the state pension than men. Before rushing to this change, has he even thought about them? And what happens if the savings from scrapping the triple lock are lower than the Secretary of State expects?

Will the government scale back its social care plan or push taxes up even higher? The Conservatives introduced the triple lock to give pensioners dignity in retirement after the humiliation of Labour's 75p a week pension rise, and we have backed the triple lock ever since. Unlike working age adults, most pensioners live on fixed incomes and most are unable to work. If the Prime Minister wants to make savings, he should start with working age welfare. That's what a Conservative government would do.

We have a plan to save 36 billion pounds from the benefits bill and get Britain working again. But the reality is that with the budget looming, the Prime Minister has no plan for fixing the country's finances. And this announcement is simply a distraction from the tax rises that are coming. This is Labour doing what Labour does best: dodging the tough choices, ducking a fight with their welfare-loving backbenchers, leaving a black hole in their fiscal plans, and hammering those who've worked and paid into the system to give more handouts to Benefit Street. I'm appalled, Madam Deputy Speaker, but frankly I am not surprised.

All we've seen on welfare is a government missing in action without the backbone to do what is right. They're clearly not on the side of pensioners, nor hardworking taxpayers. The question is, whose side are they on?

02:28:02 - 02:31:36

Pat McFadden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you to the Shadow Secretary for her response. I listened to her carefully outlining her opposition to our plans. The trouble for her is that so many in her party actually agree with the case for change. The Shadow Chancellor, for example, has said we should unpick the triple lock. The Shadow Foreign Secretary has called it simply not affordable and described it as a Ponzi system.

The Shadow Justice Secretary actually wrote the 2017 manifesto that pledged to replace it with a double lock. But my favourite, my favourite is Lord Gove, who told LBC that if Andy Burnham changed the triple lock he would, and I quote, declare that I will be campaigning at the next general election exclusively for Stella Creasy in Walthamstow. So I look forward to seeing him at the end of the Victoria line at the next election with a red rosette on his chest. I could go on, Madam Deputy Speaker, but we'd be here all day. Let's just say I have a file as thick as my morning porridge full of quotes from the Tories saying that the triple lock is unsustainable and will have to be changed.

They say it in private, they say it before they join the front bench and they say it after they leave it. But the Shadow Secretary didn't say it. So that leaves her with some questions. How will she fund her opposition to what we have announced? Will it be, as they did before when in government, through faster and faster rises in the state pension age, asking people to work into their 70s before they even get a pension at all?

And if she won't tell us that, how can she tell us how they'd fund the future of social care? Do we simply add it to the list of unfunded tax promises that they come out with on an almost weekly basis? Stamp duty, inheritance tax, national insurance, private schools, all funded from fantasy welfare savings that they never managed to achieve in office. And she spent her time attacking the system they designed, created and legislated for. She spoke about welfare bills rising.

They are rising at half the rate in this Parliament than they did in her last Parliament in power. She spoke about pensioner poverty. It rose under the government in which she served. Now we look forward to the report of the Pension Commission next year. I referred to it in my statement.

And Baroness Casey will also report on how and when the national care system will be rolled out. She did ask about welfare reform in the midst of her attacks against the system that her own party created. We've already cut the gap between the health and standard elements of Universal Credit. We have made changes to the Motability scheme. We have stopped people buying British pensions on the cheap and we will make more changes following the reports of the Milburn and Tims reviews.

The truth is, there is a stark contrast here today between a party that's prepared to take the decisions needed to offer a new settlement for older people and their families and one that is in the frankly pathetic position of resisting that change in public while one after another they agree with it in private.

02:31:36 - 02:31:40

Speaker 163

Well, the Secretary of State definitely had his porridge this morning.

02:31:48 - 02:32:00

Pat McFadden

Just a reminder, we do not reference colleagues by their names but their constituencies. I appreciate that was a quote. I'm going to call Clive Betts and afterwards I'll be turning to Steve Darling. Clive Betts.

02:32:00 - 02:32:45

Clive Betts

Thank you, Madam Speaker. Could I particularly welcome the element of the Secretary of State's speech there, the statement in relation to improvements to social care. Some of us have been campaigning for this in this House for more years than we care to remember. Could I ask the Secretary of State just to confirm, just to confirm that this is intended to make sure that individuals do not have to pay for their own care directly, but also the burden will be lifted from council taxpayers, many of whom now have to pay for social care for those who can't afford to pay directly themselves. That's really important, which will make sure that council tax goes to other services and not particularly and massively towards social care.

02:32:45 - 02:33:05

Pat McFadden

I thank him for his question and he's absolutely right to say that this is designed to cover the kind of personal care that people are having to pay for out of the current system. It is also, as he suggested, a national system and less reliant on the various local differences that we see throughout the current care system.

02:33:05 - 02:35:36

Matthew Stephen Darling

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Steve Darling.

Thank you, Speaker, and Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for sharing his statement in advance. And the Liberal Democrats have a proud history around the old age pension. In fact, it was Asquith and Lloyd George who introduced this in 1908. And then in comes Margaret Thatcher in 1980 and broke the link with earnings, and that sadly stayed with us for 30 years. Sadly, the Brown and Blair governments didn't ride to the rescue during that period of time regarding link to earnings.

And it took the Liberal Democrats introducing the triple lock when they returned to government in 2010 to have to actually start to tackle that pensioner poverty and drawing that to a conclusion there. The reality is that the triple lock has been a really powerful tool of tackling pensioner poverty. It has almost drawn together now the pension gap between males and females in respect of the state pension. It's helped some of the most vulnerable people receiving their pensions. And looking to the future, it ensures that there is a solid foundation that people can build upon when considering their future for their future pension savings.

That does not detract from the fact that there continues to be a cost of living crisis and that there are many people who are not saving enough towards their pensions because there is a set assumption within the system for lots of our society that people should be saving towards their pensions. But we have some serious questions to put to the Secretary of State. In respect of an impact assessment on pensioner poverty, I would we would welcome the Secretary of State sharing any impact assessment that they've undertaken on this. And in respect of social care, the IFS have identified that the savings from within these proposals would actually do not actually cover the finances that the government have suggested. So are the IFS lying, Secretary of State?

Thank you.

02:35:36 - 02:37:02

Pat McFadden

Secretary of State response. Mr. Darling, you were over by 30 seconds, just for future reference. Secretary of State.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me begin with a cross-party point of agreement when he draws attention to the Liberal legacy in establishing state pension system.

He is right about that. He's also right how the break with earnings for many years hurt pensioner incomes. That damage has been put right through many years of pension state pension rises. And when we get to April 2030, when the new system kicks in, those gains will be locked in under this adjusted triple lock for future years. So I began my response by reaching out to him.

I'm afraid I've also got to point out to him that his party did support faster than expected rises in the state pension age during the time when they were in power. He asked about pensioner poverty. Pensioner poverty is set to fall under our plans and the details of that were published on the 29th of September. And he asks about the pace and scale of the National Care Service that we've set out. That is a matter for Baroness Louise Casey to report on and she will issue her final report next summer.

02:37:02 - 02:37:44

Marsha Cordova

Harshika Deva.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first thank the Secretary of State for his statement and welcome the action that this Labour government is taking, a plan that will protect pensioners and ensure that they will have access to good quality care when they need it. Unlike the party opposite, they did nothing to fix the broken social care system and created a hostile social security system. So does he agree with me that it's time that pensioners deserve clarity from the Conservatives when their shadow foreign secretary has called the pensions triple lock a Ponzi scheme and is unsustainable?

02:37:44 - 02:37:46

Speaker 168

Secretary of State.

02:37:46 - 02:38:27

Pat McFadden

My honorable friend is quite right to say that we deserve clarity. And if the party opposite is going to set its face against the changes that we have announced when so many of their frontbenchers past and present have supported change, then why should they be believed for one instant on all the welfare savings that they talk about elsewhere? And if they can't be believed on those things, I'll tell you what that leaves them with, a bunch of unfunded tax pledges. We are keeping score. They have not identified the funds to pay for these and they are racking up promises that at the moment they have not said how they can pay for.

02:38:27 - 02:38:28

Sir Gavin Williamson.

02:38:28 - 02:38:57

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think that many of us would agree with the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State about the need to tackle the issue of social care. I think it's been very interesting the plans that have come forward, but there's a real concern. There's an 18 billion pound bill. The Secretary of State has identified 4 billion pounds to go towards it.

Where's the other 14 billion pounds coming from?

02:38:57 - 02:39:22

Pat McFadden

Well, as I said to the Liberal Democrat frontbench spokesperson, the pace and scale of the rolling out of the National Care Service will be set out next year by Baroness Louise Casey. And I would remind him that in my statement, I also pointed out that the changes we've announced today will actually result in savings of 50 billion pounds a year by 2050.

02:39:22 - 02:39:23

Seema Malhotra.

02:39:23 - 02:39:40

Speaker 169

Madam Deputy Speaker, one question that pensioners in Feltham and Heston have asked is whether their pension will continue to rise every year with the adjusted triple lock. Can the Secretary of State confirm this will be the case?

02:39:40 - 02:40:18

Pat McFadden

Just before the Secretary of State responds, I know that the Speaker reminded colleagues this morning when they are speaking, they are speaking through the chair, they must not turn their back on the chair. Secretary of State.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me say to the pensioners in Feltham and Heston and every other constituency in this House that the state pension will continue to rise every year. It will rise by earnings, average, sorry, it will rise by prices, by two and a half percent, and the gains that it will show in relation to average earnings will be locked in from April 2030 onwards.

02:40:18 - 02:40:51

Andrew Murrison

Dr. Alan Whitehead.

Madam Deputy Speaker, when the triple lock was introduced by the coalition government, many of us were surprised that the British basic state pension was bumping along the bottom of the European average, and the aim was to make sure that over time it improved so that it was at the top as befits a country like the UK. By April 2030, is it the Secretary of State's judgment that we will have reached that point or not?

02:40:51 - 02:40:53

Speaker 176

Secretary of State.

02:40:53 - 02:41:23

Pat McFadden

Madam Deputy Speaker, it's important to appreciate that here in the UK we have a dual system of a state pension and additional second pensions, and we have a very healthy second pension system, trillions of pounds of investment, and it's important to look at pensioner incomes taking both of those things into account. And by that measure, we have a healthy pension system, and under the plans that we've announced today, the state pension will continue to rise each and every year.

02:41:23 - 02:41:25

Speaker 175

Rosie Wrighting.

02:41:25 - 02:41:52

Speaker 183

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The British public deserve politicians who are going to be honest with them about what is necessary in order to rewrite a social contract in this country that works. Therefore, does he share my genuine disappointment that the party opposite chose to come here today and play politics rather than get behind our plan, which so many of them say in private they know is in the interest of the British people?

02:41:52 - 02:41:54

Speaker 172

Secretary of State.

02:41:54 - 02:42:23

Pat McFadden

My honorable friend is absolutely right, and she knows that many MPs on the benches opposite also agree with that. However, the front bench has chosen to adopt a different position, which is to talk about reducing the DWP budget and then when a decision is made to make it sustainable in the future, to run for the hills. That's what they've done today. Everyone will have seen it. It undermines everything else they say about savings in the DWP budget.

02:42:23 - 02:43:22

Seamus Logan

Trevor Logan.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, based on the government's own figures, pensioners in Scotland will be four billion pounds worse off by 2050. That's these are the government's own figures, two thousand pounds for every pensioner in Scotland. And in the context of what has already been referred to as one of the worst state pensions in Europe. Now, we already have free personal care in Scotland, Madam Deputy Speaker, and suspicions abound that Scottish pensioners are now being asked to fix a failed English social care system.

So, can the Secretary of State give me a cast-iron assurance that for every pound spent on fixing this English social care failure, that there will be a Barnett consequential for Scotland so that we can restore this money to Scottish pensioners?

02:43:22 - 02:43:24

Speaker 171

Secretary of State.

02:43:24 - 02:44:14

Pat McFadden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me say first of all, Scottish pensioners will see a rising state pension every year. The IFS has said that the First Minister was wrong to claim that that was not the case. Let me turn to his complacency. It is hugely complacent to suggest that somehow the social care system in Scotland is not in need of improvement.

Let me remind him, almost 10,000 Scots are waiting for social care assessments or packages. It is Scotland's place in the UK that secured a record financial settlement for the Scottish Government. What have they done with the money? And it is Scotland's place in the UK that means there will be extra funding for social care in Scotland as a result of the changes that we have announced.

02:44:14 - 02:45:05

Patricia Ferguson

Patricia Ferguson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I know the Secretary of State shares my pride that it was a Labour-led government in Scotland that introduced free personal care for elderly people in 2002. Since then, our ambition has grown in Scotland, and we've campaigned for 10 years to introduce a social care system. Something the SNP promised, spent 28 million pounds trying to establish, and then dropped. So can the Secretary of State confirm today that the money that is spent on social care in Scotland will be replicated by Barnett consequentials that will be available to the Scottish Government to spend on social care or on anything else that it wishes to spend it on.

02:45:05 - 02:45:49

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is quite right to remind the House that it was Labour in Scotland who introduced free personal care. I notice that she did not make the claim that somehow the Scottish system is perfect and is not in need of improvement, because it certainly can be improved. The answer to her question on Barnett consequentials, which in plain English means a suitable share of extra money spent in England, will be there to be spent on social care, or the Scottish Government could decide on something different, but it's certainly there to be spent on social care. And perhaps it needs to be when almost 10,000 Scots are waiting for social care assessments or care packages.

02:45:49 - 02:46:51

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Dr. Ellie Chowns.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's stated commitment to tackle the crisis in social care. It does pensioners no favours if we continually fail to address this and kick the can down the road. And that requires a cross-party approach. And it requires an honest and comprehensive conversation, including, I think, an honest conversation about the triple lock and other potential sources of funding.

But that conversation must be comprehensive. As the Secretary of State has pointed out himself today, this won't kick in until 2030, and yet the social care crisis is urgent. We need money now to fix it, and much more money than will be released through this. So can I ask the Secretary of State, does he agree with me that funding fixing the crisis in social care also requires taxing wealth fairly?

02:46:51 - 02:47:36

Pat McFadden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is right that we do not wait until April 2030 before trying to improve the system. There is extra money going into the social care system now as a result of decisions made by this government. We also need to do more to support the social care workforce through the fair pay agreement that this government has promised. So we will certainly not wait until April 2030 before improving the system.

But what this announcement does is gives a long-term plan which makes it different from many of the previous reviews and reports that have been issued on this, because it identifies a sustainable and growing source of funding to pay for the National Care Service which the Prime Minister set out in his conference speech.

02:47:36 - 02:48:08

Brian William Leishman

Brian Leishman.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now the Secretary of State says there's been a range of options put forward, but what about taxing the wealth of multi-millionaires and billionaires? Because funding social care should come from taxing them instead of reducing pensioner security. Now there are two million pensioners in the UK currently living in poverty and that's even with the triple lock. Why won't the government tax the wealthiest to pay for social care instead?

02:48:08 - 02:48:52

Pat McFadden

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have of course changed the system of non-doms since we came into office. We have changed the taxation regime for the wealthiest in society. More broadly I have to say to him, tax is a matter for the Chancellor. He has to weigh all these things up and I believe that the way that we're doing this is a fair way and is a new settlement for pensioners that ensures a rising basic state pension but also tackles this long-running issue of social care. That's not just a new settlement for pensioners but for their families too who very often are worried about what will happen to their elderly relatives as they approach their final years.

02:48:52 - 02:48:53

Deirdre Costigan.

02:48:53 - 02:49:19

Speaker 186

Madam Deputy Speaker, this government has said more than once that pensioners who rely on the state pension as their only source of income will not have to pay tax on it during this Parliament. However, the proposed reforms to the triple lock would take effect in the next Parliament. Can the Secretary of State confirm that pensioners reliant on the state pension alone will not have to pay tax when these reforms come into place?

02:49:19 - 02:49:42

Pat McFadden

Well, on the matter of tax, of course many pensioners do pay tax at the moment, but for those who are purely reliant on the basic state pension for their income, the Prime Minister and Chancellor have made clear that people in that position will not have to pay income tax for the duration of this Parliament and the Chancellor will announce further details at the budget.

02:49:42 - 02:49:43

Deirdre Costigan.

02:49:43 - 02:50:18

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Ealing Southall, there is a wonderful culture of extended families living together and looking after elderly relatives at home. But families, mainly women in families, do this often without government support and at a cost to their own opportunities in life. Does the Secretary of State agree with me that this National Care Service funded by this adjustment today to the triple lock will make a real difference for families and unpaid carers, all while ensuring the state pension continues to rise every year for pensioners in Ealing Southall?

02:50:18 - 02:50:43

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is quite right. She's right to draw attention to the immense contribution made by carers at home. The package that we've announced is good news for carers. As I said, this is a new settlement not just for pensioners but for the many younger relatives who are looking after older relatives and who can now look forward to a new National Care Service being developed in the coming years.

02:50:44 - 02:51:19

Ayoub Khan

Madam Deputy Speaker, more than a quarter pensioners in my constituency of Birmingham Perry Barr already claim pension credit on top of their state pension. So even with the triple lock, they will be choosing between heating and eating this winter. And now they're being told that their social safety net may be cut even more. Pensioners are worried. The triple lock cannot be lifted until we put an end to the cost of living crisis and we provide more support for the most vulnerable pensioners.

So what is the Secretary of State doing to achieve this so we can ensure that the poorest pensioners aren't left worse off?

02:51:19 - 02:51:54

Pat McFadden

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I refer to our introduction of pension credit which has done significant amounts to reduce pensioner poverty.

We've had an increase in claims of over 30,000 in recent times. Under the plans that I've set out, pensioner poverty is set to fall, but in addition to that, we have asked the Pensions Commission to look at what further measures may be needed to ensure that we bear down on pensioner poverty in the future, because of course security in retirement is absolutely vital for older people.

02:51:54 - 02:51:55

Rachel Maskell.

02:51:55 - 02:52:47

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's ambition to have free personal care, and I welcome the ambition to keep the triple lock for the duration of this Parliament. But the Secretary of State will know that I have deep concern about the levels of pensioner poverty. 1.7 million pensioners making those difficult choices today. 880,000 pensioners not claiming the pension credit which they could.

I therefore ask the Secretary of State to raise his ambition to end pensioner poverty in this Parliament and ensure that we find mechanisms to give sufficiency to those pensioners not claiming their pension credit, but also to publish an impact assessment so we can have a real understanding of the consequences of the implementation of these proposals.

02:52:47 - 02:53:12

Pat McFadden

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, let me pay tribute to my honourable friend for campaigning on this issue. We did publish a document on the 29th of September, which showed that pensioner poverty was set to fall under these plans. But we're not complacent about that. That is why, in addition to that, we've asked the Pensions Commission to look at what further measures may be needed to reduce pensioner poverty in future years.

02:53:12 - 02:53:13

Dave Robertson.

02:53:13 - 02:54:01

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The shadow, sorry, the Secretary of State has clearly been in this place for a few years longer than I have, and I'm sure he's seen just as many people getting in touch with him on a weekly and monthly basis about the problems that they face in the care system. It is so bad for families out there, and I have lost count even in my short time in this place of the number of people I've had in tears in my surgeries talking about the difficulties of navigating personal care for elderly relatives. Can I really thank him for the work that he's done on this, because unless we get that care system right, we are absolutely turning our face away from one of the great evils that are left in this country. The triple lock is a difficult thing to unpick, but I think the steps that he's taking are proportionate and should lead to that really essential care system, so can I thank him for the work that he's done in this space.

02:54:01 - 02:54:34

Pat McFadden

Let me thank him for his comments. He is right to point out the deficiencies and worse that exist in the current care system. And perhaps an under-discussed part of it all is the pressure it puts on the NHS. As I said in my statement, if we turn away from this and we don't tackle the kind of things that he spoke about, we will have more A&E admissions, more ambulance call-outs, and more elderly people kept in hospital when they would actually be better off in a social care setting.

02:54:34 - 02:54:35

Gideon Abbott.

02:54:35 - 02:55:16

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The SNP wasted over 28 million pounds of taxpayers' money on social care plans which went nowhere. No improvement to outcomes, no improvement to the terms and conditions of social care workers in Scotland, and now they're trying to hoodwink my constituents in trying to tell them that these plans would make them worse off. These plans would increase Barnett consequentials for Scotland, which could be spent on a national care service. So will the Secretary of State learn from the SNP's failures and reassure my constituent?

02:55:16 - 02:56:02

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is absolutely right to stress the importance of the social care workforce.

That is why we are not waiting until April 2030 to make improvements for the social care workforce. She is also right to say that as a result of the changes that I've spoken about in my statement, extra funding will be available to the Scottish Government in addition to the record financial settlement it has already received since the general election. Were we in a different environment, we could have a constructive discussion with the Scottish Government about how to build the best social care system throughout the UK. Instead, we have the usual claims of perfection, which she knows are not the experience of her constituents.

02:56:02 - 02:56:50

Andrew Dominic John Grady

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The party opposite show remarkable flexibility when it comes to the triple lock, but absolute commitment to the reckless management of public finances and uncosted pledges. Can my right honourable friend the Secretary of State confirm the following points to pensioners in Glasgow East and Scotland? The triple lock will remain in place until 2030. Following 2030, the pension will always keep track with prices.

Further, it will rise more than this if needed to keep its relative value for earnings. Scottish pensioners are protected under our proposals. No pensioner will lose money as a result of our proposals, and the Labour Party always has Scottish pensioners' back.

02:56:50 - 02:57:38

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is right to point out that the state pension will continue to rise in each and every year. He is also right to point out that the Shadow Secretary, having confirmed that they oppose these changes, is now left with the question of where they will find the money to continue paying the triple lock should they ever come into power after the next election, and where they'll find the money to fund social care improvements. Her failure to respond to these questions completely undermines their waving around of more and more savings to fund their growing list of unfunded tax promises. Madam Deputy Speaker, we have seen that movie before. We know how it ends because the British people are still paying the price.

02:57:38 - 02:58:23

Christopher Murray

Fears for your finances and care in old age keep many people up at night. This is the biggest issue of our generation, and we must tread carefully. Shamefully, the First Minister of Scotland is exploiting people's fears, wrongly claiming Scots will lose their pension, and he doubles down even when corrected by independent voices like the IFS. Does the Secretary of State share my outrage at this blatant politicisation of the most serious issue facing communities, and will he confirm the state pension will continue to rise for Scottish pensioners and the Scottish Government will get extra cash for any care spending in England?

02:58:23 - 02:59:09

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is absolutely right. The state pension will continue to rise for Scottish pensioners in each and every year. Furthermore, extra funds will be allocated to the Scottish Government as a result of the social care changes that are part of this package. He is also right to point out that the Institute for Fiscal Studies said the First Minister was wrong to claim what he claimed over the state pension. But I also think there's another thing on top of that, which is the enormous complacency which suggests that the Scottish care system cannot be improved.

It can be improved. There are almost 10,000 Scots waiting for social care assessments, and he knows that's true of his constituents and the many other constituents who are represented here today.

02:59:09 - 02:59:49

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We should be clear that setting future indexation to a proportion of average earnings means that over time the state pension will be lower than under the current system.

Given that future generations will increasingly rely on the state pension, this seems like we're going in the wrong direction. But actually, the real concern is that this policy is asking pensioners to pay for the care of other pensioners. So can I ask the Secretary of State why we are not sharing the cost amongst us all for a new national care service?

02:59:49 - 03:00:57

Pat McFadden

Well, can I say to him, in terms of the relationship to average earnings, what this will mean in future is that the gains from almost 20 years of the triple lock by the time we get to April 2030 will be locked in in future years. The difference will be that instead of outpacing average earnings as the current system does, the state pension will be linked to the level of average earnings that it reaches in April 2030. On his second point, this is a new settlement which guarantees a rising state pension every year, but also over time releases funds for one of the biggest issues facing the country. I think the Prime Minister deserves credit for facing up to this. His criticism of politics, which is merited, is that too often difficult long-term issues have been ducked, and that has left them to fester unresolved.

In putting forward this new settlement, he is ensuring security for pensioners' incomes, but also a means of tackling this issue.

03:00:57 - 03:01:42

Speaker 195

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. As one of the people on this side of the House to call for a look at an adjustment of the triple lock six months ago, I can confirm that many people who approached me after I wrote about that were indeed from the opposition benches, saying that they wish their own party had the courage to say the same thing as well. Can I sort of thank the Secretary of State for his statement today and for that bravery that he rightly speaks about about how to tackle those tough problems? When he talks about a new settlement for older people, which is absolutely to be welcomed, how we future-fund and reduce pensioner poverty at the same time, can I also ask him to update on how we are suggesting we also have a new settlement for younger people to ensure they have the opportunities that they deserve so that they can benefit from the current system and indeed pay into it as well?

03:01:42 - 03:02:17

Pat McFadden

Well, I thank the honourable member for his question. He probably heard from a great many Tories who agree that change is needed. Perhaps he even heard from both the leader of the opposition's PPSs, who have both called for change in the system to add to the tally on the file beside my porridge. This is a new settlement for pensioners, as I've said. It still ensures a rising state pension every year, but enables us to also face up to this long-term issue of social care.

03:02:17 - 03:02:57

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for confirming that the state pension will continue to rise and match earnings into the future, very important for reassuring pensioners in my Dartford constituency. But does he agree with me that pensioners, some of us soon to be pensioners, but actually the whole country will be better off with a new national care service, which not only provides free personal care, I hope very much it will cap lifetime costs, but also improve the pay and conditions of those who work so hard in the care system, and that as a result we will all be better off and that adults can live a dignified life into the future?

03:02:57 - 03:03:23

Pat McFadden

I thank my honourable friend for his question. He is right to draw attention to the social care workforce. It has been undervalued over the years. The jobs that these people do are incredibly important for the people that they look after, and we are not waiting until April 2030 before addressing some of those concerns and putting forward a better deal for the social care workforce.

03:03:23 - 03:03:56

Stephen Doughty

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Rural pensioners are often more reliant on the state pension, experience higher heating costs, higher travel costs, poorer service access, many often experience stricter criteria or less outreach for council support. How do we ensure changes to the triple lock don't leave my rural constituents behind and ensure rural communities are not the last to benefit from the vitally needed National Care Service, especially considering recruitment challenges we have in areas like Cumbria?

03:03:56 - 03:04:32

Pat McFadden

I thank him for his question. He's right to draw attention to the needs of rural pensioners. The changes that this government has made will result in energy bills being 150 pounds lower than they otherwise would have. We've also put forward special help to local authorities in areas where large amounts of people are reliant on home heating oil. We have said that we will remove VAT from electricity bills and we'll continue to do what we can to help households through rises in energy bills which are caused by external geopolitical events.

03:04:32 - 03:05:02

Speaker 198

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister for having the courage to grasp this issue? I was saddened but not surprised by the response from the opposition front bench. But I would say, whilst he's not in his place, there may be cause for hope because the Father of the House has been a consistent advocate of reform of the triple lock and proving the maxim that wisdom comes with age. Would the Secretary of State then confirm to me that under our adjusted triple lock, pensioner poverty will continue to fall in the 2030s and beyond?

03:05:02 - 03:05:19

Pat McFadden

Mr. Ponzi scheme is here. Well, I very much agree with my honourable friend that wisdom comes with age. It's not a view I used to hold, but it's warming to as the years go past. And I welcome to the front bench the Shadow Foreign Secretary, of course, referred to the triple lock as a Ponzi system.

03:05:19 - 03:05:55

Douglas McAllister

Douglas McAllister.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. All of us need to do politics differently, to work with other parties constructively rather than feeding into a narrative of grievance. The people of Scotland deserve honesty from their politicians, not deceit and scaremongering. Does the Minister agree with me that the pensions of my West Dunbartonshire constituents will continue to rise year on year as they will across the UK and that the Prime Minister's reforms will result in billions of pounds flowing to Scotland over the decades, which can help fund Scotland's creaking social care system?

03:05:55 - 03:06:27

Pat McFadden

Well, I can certainly assure the pensioners of West Dunbartonshire that the state pension will continue to rise in each and every year. That is true for his constituents and throughout Scotland. I can also assure his constituents that funds released from this package will flow to the Scottish Government to spend on social care if they so wish, because we believe that the social care system throughout the UK is in need of improvement and through this new settlement, that can happen.

03:06:27 - 03:06:28

Josh Babington.

03:06:28 - 03:07:19

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The need for a functioning care system has been clear for decades. Dilnot's report was published in 2011. The Care Act of 2014 said we'd get one by 2016. That plan was then postponed till 2020 before being quietly scrapped entirely.

Then Boris Johnson rode to the rescue and he said we'd get it by 2021. He then postponed it to 2023 and then said we'd do it in 2025, but had no funding. And what has that led to? It has led to more people in hospitals who don't need to be there. It's led to care workers having only 39p an hour more than minimum wage and care workers, skilled workers, should be treated that way.

So can the Minister promise me we will not hide behind the triple lock, we will not fumble the ball like those opposite have done, but when Baroness Casey releases her report, we will actually implement it and make a change?

03:07:19 - 03:07:57

Pat McFadden

My honourable friend is right to say that there have been many reports and many reviews over the years. There are differences this time. The first is that in making the changes and putting forward this new settlement, we have identified a source of funding that will grow over the years that will help to fund the social care system.

And the second is political will. It is that the Prime Minister has put this front and center of his ambitions in his role as Prime Minister, front and center of his speech to party conference a couple of weeks ago, and is really putting his shoulder behind getting this resolved once and for all.

03:07:57 - 03:08:01

Speaker 196

Final question, Gordon McKee.

03:08:01 - 03:08:29

Speaker 151

The fundamental problems with social care that the Prime Minister outlined so powerfully in his conference speech are the exactly the same fundamental problems with social care that my constituents in Glasgow experience, and indeed my own family experienced when my grandparents had dementia. So can I ask the Minister if he agrees with me that rather than play politics, the Scottish and Welsh governments should work with the Prime Minister to help design a national care service that works for every corner of Britain?

03:08:29 - 03:09:54

Pat McFadden

My honorable friend is absolutely right. And as I said, it would be a better future on this if governments in Scotland, Wales, and the UK could work together on an issue that is a common challenge. That is the approach that should be taken forward. That is the spirit in which the Prime Minister announced this in his speech at party conference. It is a new settlement, and we should be taking it forward together.

That is the end of the statement on pensions triple lock. I'll give the front benches a moment or two to shuffle over. Order, order. I remind the Minister that under paragraph 9.5 of the Ministerial Code, the opposition front bench and the Speaker's office should be sent the text of a draft statement a minimum of 45 minutes beforehand. This statement was not received on time.

I do not wish to suspend the House on a busy day, but it is regrettable that this important standard was not met in this instance. And I now call the Minister for the statement on Falkland Islands, Minister Uma Kumaran.

03:09:54 - 03:19:13

Uma Kumaran

Madam Deputy Speaker, I apologize for the delayed submission. We respect the processes of this House and will ensure that does not happen again. Madam Deputy Speaker, with your permission, I'll update the House on Argentina's escalating campaign against individuals and companies in the United Kingdom and around the world involved in the lawful economic development of the Falkland Islands. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me state from the outset, the Falkland Islands, South Georgia, and the South Sandwich Islands are British. The United Kingdom has no doubt about its sovereignty over them and their surrounding maritime areas.

As the Prime Minister told the House yesterday, as part of conversations at the UN General Assembly, he and President Trump discussed the islanders' clear and declared will to remain British. The Prime Minister reiterated that message to the UN General Assembly. Let me once again repeat what the Prime Minister made clear to this House yesterday. We will always do whatever it takes to uphold the will of the Falkland Islanders. The Foreign Secretary and I have reiterated this government's commitment to the Falkland Islanders' right to determine their own political and economic future and livelihoods.

I made this point very clear in my public statement published online on the 30th of September and in my subsequent meetings with members of the Legislative Assembly. I welcome Jack Ford, Chair of the Falkland Islands Legislative Assembly, here in the gallery today. I know the whole House will want to show him and the Falkland Islanders our full support.

Madam Deputy Speaker, in recent weeks we've seen inflammatory remarks from President Milei at the UN General Assembly and increasingly aggressive public statements from the Argentine Foreign Minister. The Argentine government has threatened sanctions and warned that it will pursue criminal measures against businesses and individuals connected directly and indirectly to the Sea Lion project. The Sea Lion field lies on the Falkland Islands continental shelf. The project is lawful and regulated by the democratically elected Falkland Islands government. Argentina has no jurisdiction over it.

Let me be absolutely clear. This government will not stand by while Argentina uses economic coercion against the people of the Falkland Islands. We will do whatever it takes to support them. What's particularly disappointing about this is the brazen attempt to use the people of the Falkland Islands as some sort of political prop by President Milei ahead of Argentina's elections next year. Madam Deputy Speaker, we will not allow the Falkland Islanders to be used as a tool of Argentine domestic politics.

The government of the United Kingdom is responding in four ways. First, we have confronted Argentina directly. On the 17th of September, the Minister for Latin America made clear our position to the Argentine ambassador and rejected the attempted application of Argentine law to the Falkland Islands. He also reaffirmed Islanders' right to develop their natural resources. Our message is unequivocal.

The measures announced by President Milei on the 3rd of September threatening companies and individuals for lawful commercial decisions are economic coercion. They will not change the United Kingdom's position or weaken our commitment to the rights and wishes of the Falkland Islanders, nor will they halt lawful economic activity. We will respond firmly and promptly to Argentine threats to apply measures beyond its jurisdiction, which are intended to frighten businesses. Such conduct damages legal certainty and confidence in Argentina as a reliable economic partner. Second, the government is engaging with affected businesses to understand their concerns and make clear the government's position.

The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, working closely with the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, is having regular discussions with the Sea Lion operator and its supporting supply chain. Here, our message is straightforward. Legitimate commercial activity in the Falkland Islands remains lawful, and the British government stands behind those engaged in it. We're also speaking to wider UK business interests to explain the government's position and understand the potential consequences of Argentina's actions. Third, I can confirm that the Business Secretary will, subject to the necessary parliamentary protocols, deploy the powers available to him under the Protection of Trading Interests legislation against any Argentine measures that seek to influence or regulate lawful activity beyond Argentine jurisdiction.

These steps will provide additional protection for UK businesses against attempts to compel them to comply with measures Argentina is trying to enforce outside its jurisdiction. They'll also demonstrate that the government is prepared to use the tools available to defend lawful British commercial activity. We'll continue to talk to business as the situation develops to understand how best to support their operations. Let me emphasize that this action responds to Argentina's attempted extraterritorial application of its domestic measures. Fourth, we're mobilizing international partners.

Our diplomatic network, acting on the instruction of the Foreign Secretary, are engaging to set out what Argentina's conduct means for international businesses, secure supply chains, and predictable global commerce. We're engaging G7 and G20 partners and governments across Europe, the Americas, and beyond. We urge countries who value open markets, legal certainty, and stable trading relationships to stand against the intimidation of companies undertaking lawful business.

that the United Kingdom will prepare additional measures if this situation persists. They will be legal, they will be proportionate, and let me assure you they will be robust. Madam Deputy Speaker, the United Kingdom never sought this confrontation with the current Argentine government, and less so with the Argentinian people. We do not want to see wider implications for our two countries. Let us not forget the reconciliation and progress we have seen since the events of 1982.

Next year, we will mark 45 years since British forces liberated the Falkland Islands. For some of those veterans who fought in that conflict, this may be one of the last major anniversaries they see. To mark that occasion, to celebrate the liberation and remember all those who paid the ultimate price for the freedom of the Falkland Islands, and they should never be forgotten. Today, I can announce that the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, in partnership with the Ministry of Defence, will support commemorations on the islands and here in the United Kingdom. Madam Deputy Speaker, addressing the situation at hand.

There should be no doubt that the government will defend the Falkland Islanders, defend them from bullying, defend them from threats, and defend their right of self-determination. Every part of this response is being developed in close coordination with the democratically elected Falkland Islands government. The islanders' interest and wishes remain at the heart. The principle at stake is simple. The Falkland Islanders have the right to determine their own future.

In 2013, the referendum, 99.8% of those voting on a turnout of 92% chose to remain a British Overseas Territory. Their wishes could not have been clearer. The United Kingdom will open, the United Kingdom will remain open to dialogue and practical cooperation with Argentina where it benefits both countries and our peoples. The honourable gentleman would be minded to listen to my statement. But the progress must rest on international law and respect for the rights and wishes of the Falkland Islanders.

Firmness in defending those principles is entirely consistent with keeping the door open to diplomacy and dialogue. Madam Deputy Speaker, on the 28th of September, the government of Argentina formally notified the United Kingdom that it was commencing arbitration proceedings under Annex VII of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, or UNCLOS as it's known. Argentina demanded that the United Kingdom prevent hydrocarbon activity in the North Falkland Basin in relation to the Sea Lion project. Argentina threatened to seek provisional measures from the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea. I can confirm that the United Kingdom government's intention is to engage with this process, consistent with our long-standing position in respect of international courts and tribunals.

On Sunday, the 11th of October, the British Embassy in Buenos Aires delivered our formal response to Argentina's notification. That response sets out clearly the United Kingdom's position. The House will understand that while legal proceedings are contemplated or underway, I will not provide a running commentary, but I assure members we will defend the interests of the Falkland Islanders and the United Kingdom robustly. At the same time, I want to be clear about what Argentina's action does not do. Its notification does not constitute a judgment by an international court or tribunal.

It does not invalidate licenses issued by the Falkland Islands government. It does not alter the islands' regulatory authority, and it does not require lawful activity on hydrocarbons development to cease. Madam Deputy Speaker, His Majesty's government stands shoulder to shoulder with the Falkland Islanders. We are in no doubt about their sovereignty. We will defend their security, their livelihoods, and their right to determine their own future, while remaining ready to resolve differences with Argentina through diplomacy, dialogue, and international law.

03:19:13 - 03:19:17

Speaker 201

The United Kingdom's resolve is absolute. I commend this statement to the House.

03:19:17 - 03:24:11

Wendy Morton

I call the shadow minister, Wendy Morton.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for advance sight of her statement, although it was somewhat belated. Let me start by welcoming Jack Ford, Chair of the Falkland Islands MLA, to the gallery today. Yesterday marked 44 years since the Falklands Task Force victory parade, when more than 300,000 people lined London's streets to honor those who liberated the islands. Their sacrifice reminds us of our enduring responsibility to defend the Falkland Islanders' freedom and their right to self-determination. Argentina's increasingly hostile rhetoric and threats towards the islands, their people, and their economic interests are wholly unacceptable.

The islanders are overwhelmingly have overwhelmingly expressed their wish to remain British. No amount of intimidation or economic coercion from Buenos Aires will change that. The Falkland Islanders deserve more than words of reassurance. They deserve to know that the British government will stand firmly behind them, protect their interests, and defend their right to determine their own future. So I welcome reports that the Foreign Secretary has signed off on the next steps for Sea Lion.

The islanders have every right to develop their natural resources, but I am a little perplexed, Madam Deputy, because at energy questions today, ministers suggested this was not a decision for the British government. So can the Foreign Minister clarify the Foreign Secretary's role, precisely what he has authorized, and whether further decisions are required? In fact, was the Energy Secretary even consulted? And if the Foreign Secretary can support Sea Lion in the South Atlantic, why is the government still leaving Rosebank and Jackdaw in the North Sea waiting? But back to the Falkland Islands, Madam Deputy Speaker, we welcome the measures today outlined, but approval alone will not protect those involved from Argentina's threats.

British nationals and businesses operating under licenses issued by the Falkland Islands government should not face intimidation or threats of legal action. And there are some questions that need answers and clarity today. The Minister has announced their intention to extend the protection of trading interests measures to cover Argentina. What will this mean in practice for companies and individuals facing Argentine legal action, and what risks will remain? Can she confirm reports that the government has approached Interpol and set out what assurances it has received that politically motivated requests will be rejected?

Has the FCDO sought assurances from international partners that British citizens will not face arrest or detention when traveling abroad? What practical legal, consular, and travel support is being offered to those affected, and how will the government help companies resist attempts to disrupt the project's financing and supply chains? What direct support is being provided to the Falkland Islands government to ensure development can proceed without interference? Because alongside these protections, there must be consequences if Argentina continues to escalate its threats. Has the Minister examined targeted sanctions or other proportionate diplomatic and economic restrictions?

That must also inform our wider economic relationship. President Milei cannot simultaneously threaten British interests while expecting Britain to facilitate closer economic cooperation. Argentina has applied to join the CPTPP. The Shadow Foreign Secretary has made clear that Britain should be prepared to oppose that application if Argentina continues to threaten peace and stability in the South Atlantic. Is the government prepared to use Britain's position within CPTPP to make clear that such behavior carries consequences?

Because these developments underline a wider point about Britain's standing in the world. When Britain appears unwilling or unable to defend its interests, it risks encouraging those who would seek to challenge them. That's why we on these benches are committed to fully costed plans to increase defense spending to 3% of GDP by 2030.

So will the minister confirm what discussions she's had with the defense secretary about the resilience of Britain's military presence in the South Atlantic and whether any additional measures are being considered? Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain must bring together its diplomatic, economic, and military strength to defend its interests and stand up to those who seek to intimidate us. Argentina should be working to strengthen its own economy rather than threatening the livelihoods of the Falkland Islanders. Exactly. There can be no question of bargaining away their democratic rights or their future.

So I will end where I began. The Falkland Islanders have chosen to remain British. We on these benches will always stand with them and defend their fundamental right to self-determination. Minister Camera.

03:24:11 - 03:28:12

Uma Kumaran

I thank the right honorable lady for the important points that she's raised today. I'll try to take some of those in turn. Let me be clear, the Prime Minister was in the house yesterday. This government will defend the Falkland Islanders' right to self-determination relentlessly. The Falkland Islanders are British overseas territory and they will remain so for as long as the islanders wish.

In relation to Argentina, we've made clear to Argentina that attempts to obstruct lawful economic activity in the Falkland Islands are not the act of a responsible of responsible international engagement. They damage legal certainty and raise serious questions about Argentina's reliability as an economic partner. On some of the questions that she's asked relation in relation to the PTI and CPTPP, we don't speculate on possible future sanctions or designations, but we will consider continue to consider all appropriate measures in accordance with our legal framework and wider policy objectives. We the UK doesn't comment publicly on CPTPP accession discussions. Our focus now is on the merit of an application to maintain the strongest agreement, although Argentina's current behavior does though raise very serious questions about their reliability as a partner for the United Kingdom.

On the question on UNCLOS, the house I'll get to that. On the questions of UNCLOS, the house will understand that while legal proceedings are contemplated or underway, I will not provide a running commentary on that. On defense matters, on the questions of defense readiness, the Ministry of Defense is confident that our military presence is at the appropriate level to defend the islands and that that posture is kept under constant review. Indeed, I've had conversations with the minister who's present here today also. Since 1982, the United Kingdom's maintained a continuous military presence on and around the Falkland Islands.

HMS Medway is currently patrolling the South Atlantic. And we've got the current Tranche 1 of Typhoons will be replaced with more modern Tranche 2 aircraft in 2027, alongside significant investment to ensure that Typhoon remains at the cutting edge of capability. So you will see that those conversations are ongoing. In relation to matters to do with climate and natural resources, the honorable lady will understand that the core tenet of self-determination is ensuring that the Falkland Islanders themselves and their government can make decisions to do with their natural resources. Finally, on business and what we're doing to give businesses assurance, the government is continuing to support businesses affected by Argentina's actions.

We're engaging closely with companies involved in the Sea Lion project and its supporting supply chain. My message to those companies is straightforward. Their activity is lawful and the British government stands unequivocally behind them. As I set out in my statement, the business secretary is prepared, subject to the necessary parliamentary processes, to deploy powers under the protection of trading interests legislation against any Argentine measures that seek to influence or to regulate lawful activity taking place outside Argentine jurisdiction. The process is straightforward to provide additional protection to UK businesses facing pressure as a result of Argentina's actions.

Madam Deputy Speaker, on the issue of the Falklands, this House has long had consensus that we stand together, that we stand with the people of the Falkland Islanders, who, as we all know, are feeling quite scared about these measures. They are feeling very uncertain about their future. It is our job as a Parliament to stand together. I have met and spoken with a number of those in the Falkland Islanders. They are very worried.

They are scared. They are scared. And it is our job to offer them reassurance and stand together and show them that the United Kingdom stands full square behind them.

03:28:12 - 03:28:55

Margaret Rachel Taylor

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the Minister to her place. Constituents in North Warwickshire and Bedworth will be really pleased to hear her announcements on the commemoration events, and I look forward to being able to take part in those in my constituency. But does the Minister agree that the action we're taking today is a clear indication of this Labour government's position that if Argentina continues to threaten the Falkland Islanders' right to self-determination, we will prepare additional measures, no matter what threats or economic coercion Argentina carries against the Falkland Islanders.

03:28:55 - 03:29:27

Uma Kumaran

I thank my honourable friend for that question. I know she's spoken passionately about these matters. Let me be very clear: the United Kingdom government will continue to do all that's necessary to protect the Falkland Islanders and the government of the Falkland Islands. Next year, as I said, is the 45th anniversary of the conflict. We are very much looking forward to working with the Ministry of Defence, the FCDO and Ministry of Defence together on the commemoration and celebratory events around Falkland 45.

03:29:27 - 03:31:40

Al Pinkerton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the government's commitment to Falkland Island sovereignty and the Islanders' right to self-determination. But in the light of President Milei's escalating campaign, I think a little history may be in order. The Falkland Islands were first sighted by English navigators in 1592, claimed by Britain in 1765 and continuously settled since 1833, and some Falkland Islands families can trace their roots back nine, even ten generations. And of course there is a particular irony in Argentina's claims of colonial injustice. One of two countries in this dispute, it was only Argentina that systematically dispossessed indigenous peoples of their homes and their homelands.

And Argentina's sovereignty claim rests substantially on its asserted inheritance of the Spanish Empire, whose imperial ambitions were sanctioned themselves by a 15th-century Pope and the Treaty of Tordesillas. Now the colonial history is rather more complicated than the government of Argentina perhaps like to acknowledge or remember, which is precisely why self-determination matters so much. In 2013 I was in Stanley to witness myself the referendum in which 98.99% of Islanders voted to remain British. They spoke for themselves as a self-governing, self-determining, distinct and identifiable people. Yet President Milei now seeks to use UNCLOS arbitration to deny Islanders economic sovereignty and deny them the right to shape their own future.

That is neo-colonialism dressed up as anti-colonialism. So I have three questions for the Minister. Will Britain challenge any attempt to use UNCLOS to determine territorial sovereignty? And if she's not willing to give an express account of whether the CPTPP negotiations will be narrated, can she at least acknowledge that the Auckland principles that underpin CPTPP are inconsistent with Argentina's desire to undermine the Islanders' right to develop their own economy?

And finally, what concrete measures will this government take to ensure that Argentina's threats do not deter investment in the islands?

03:31:40 - 03:32:38

Uma Kumaran

I thank the honourable member and I know he knows lots about this, indeed I believe he's a professor who specializes in some of these areas, so I thank him for the brief history lesson that he's treated us to today. On the question of UNCLOS, the answer to that is yes. On CPTPP, we expect good practices from all our international partners and I've made very clear our expectations from the government of Argentina, how they're behaving at the moment isn't in line with what we would expect. On his third point, on this matter, we're expecting all partners to get round the table. Diplomacy and dialogue remains a very important part of moving this forward.

We've been very clear, we will engage with this process in full on diplomacy, on dialogue, on matters of international law, the United Kingdom will play its full part.

03:32:38 - 03:33:05

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I'd like to thank the minister in particular for her support for the 45th anniversary coming up of what was some pretty heroic action from the UK armed forces, including Buster Brown who took me through marine training many, many years ago. Does the minister agree with me that the Argentinians and UK government will not cower in any way, shape or form or be intimidated by any aggressive or threatening language from Argentina?

03:33:05 - 03:33:11

Speaker 205

I thank my honourable and gallant friend for that question. The answer to that is an unequivocal yes.

03:33:11 - 03:34:01

Paul Holmes

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I declare an interest that I visited the Falklands a number of months ago as a trustee of the Armed Forces Parliamentary Scheme and can I welcome the minister to her position? I entirely endorse the sentiments of her statement that maintain that the Falklands must remain British and I welcome the chair of the Legislative Assembly to the gallery today. But as well as diplomacy, we must match that diplomacy against Argentina with military deterrence. And when I visited the islands, I was most concerned that permanent refuelling capability for our military assets on the island was not on the island and indeed was based elsewhere.

So can I ask her, and I don't expect a detailed answer although I see the minister next to her, could I ask her to see that that permanent refuelling capability for the Typhoons is back on the islands if it is not already?

03:34:01 - 03:34:21

Uma Kumaran

I thank the honourable gentleman opposite for that important question. You could see that the defence minister was explaining that he will have some conversations with you about this. We don't comment on our operational matters in relation to this, but we are moving our capabilities and our assets in the area.

03:34:21 - 03:34:28

Pat McFadden

Just to remind the minister and all colleagues, no you and yours, we're speaking through the chair and I was not responsible for that question. Dan Carden.

03:34:28 - 03:35:10

Speaker 210

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I spent an hour with one of my constituents, James, last week who was shot in the face in the Falklands war and I've met him many times to work on issues with him in recent months. Can I also add my welcome to Jack Ford who's in the gallery today and say that I want to give my fullest, strongest backing to what the minister said today. And just mention two little things. One, how is discussions with our allies in the Latin American region, with Uruguay and Chile in particular, going and will she make sure that they are a focus of the talks that she is having?

03:35:10 - 03:35:38

Speaker 207

And I think we must find a way to assert our sovereignty, and I want to say this as gently as possible, but to assert our sovereignty against what are spurious often claims against us in international courts that basically allow our foes to challenge sovereignty.

We've seen it recently and we're seeing it now again.

03:35:38 - 03:36:19

Uma Kumaran

I thank my honorable friend for that question and I know he's spent many years engaged in these matters. On the question he asked about conversations with partners in LatAm, the Minister for LatAm is in regular discussion with friends and allies in the region. They are important partners on this matter, particularly for support of the islands. On the matter of sovereignty, the United Kingdom government is in no doubt about the sovereignty of the Falkland Islanders. We will follow their wish at every turn.

03:36:19 - 03:36:49

Speaker 213

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Whilst we at Reform of course welcome the Minister's commitment to allowing the Falkland Islanders to determine their own governance, can she confirm that we actually would as a nation be in a position militarily to defend the Falkland Islands if ever called to do so by the islanders, when we couldn't even get a single warship to the Strait of Hormuz?

03:36:49 - 03:36:53

Speaker 208

The direct answer to her question is yes.

03:36:53 - 03:37:25

Luke Morgan Evans

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now the Minister was asked specifically about what the Foreign Secretary had signed off. So can she confirm he granted consent under the Mineral Ordinance 1994? And if so, what does she say to the people of Aberdeen who've been told they cannot drill, but 8,000 miles away we can drill to protect the global climate change? That is incongruent, it doesn't make sense, and what does she say to them?

03:37:25 - 03:38:11

Uma Kumaran

I'll remind the member opposite that this is a very different situation. The UK oil and gas licensing policy does not apply in the Falkland Islands. I've made very clear that their right to develop their natural resources is in line with their self-determination. When deciding whether to consent new hydrocarbons licenses in the islands, the Secretary of State acts in accordance with the applicable Falkland Islands legislation. We do not comment on individual licensing.

I'm pretty surprised that he's attempting to bring domestic politics into a matter that this House has long had consensus on, that is the sovereignty and self-determination rights of the Falkland Islanders.

03:38:11 - 03:38:51

Charles Edward Robin Morello

I also welcome the Minister restating Britain's commitment to the fact that the Falkland Islands is British as long as the people of the Falklands wish to remain so. The Minister has said that Argentina has threatened to seek provisional measures through the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea. President Trump, an ally of the Argentinian President, has spoken in support of Argentina's claim and has recently sanctioned the ICC. So I'm interested to hear what the government is doing to ensure that no pressure is brought to bear on international tribunals and that the rule of law is protected.

03:38:51 - 03:39:32

Uma Kumaran

I thank the honorable member opposite for that question. It's an important one. As the Prime Minister told the House yesterday and at the UN General Assembly in New York, the Falkland Islands were a matter of discussion with President Trump and the clear and declared will of the islanders to remain British was part of that conversation. The United States is our closest ally. We talk to them on a range of issues.

This remains one of the issues that we talk about. Our officials remain in constant communication. On matters to do with the international law and courts, look, we're in constant discussions on this matter and it's something that we can pick up and I can write to him further if he would like a fuller answer.

03:39:32 - 03:40:06

Mark Pritchard

Antonio Guterres, the Secretary General of the United Nations, will retire in December. One of the leading candidates is a senior Argentinian ambassador, Rafael Grossi. Is it the UK's position that they are supporting the Argentinians in this important role? If not, does the Minister agree with me that it should also disqualify the Costa Rican and the two Ecuadorian candidates, should they have made public statements supporting Argentina's claim to the Falkland Islands?

03:40:06 - 03:40:17

Uma Kumaran

The member opposite asks a pertinent question, but he will know that the UK government doesn't comment on UN SG processes from the dispatch box.

03:40:18 - 03:40:54

Ayoub Khan

Madam Deputy Speaker, our overseas territory, which voted to remain British, where our brave troops fought and died for the Falkland Islanders' right to self-determination, is now once again being put in jeopardy because a warmongering Argentinian government is seeking to rally its base to hide their domestic failures and failing economy. Many international companies are being deterred from investing in that region because of the noise that's being created. What more can this government do to ensure international companies that want to invest can do so with confidence?

03:40:54 - 03:41:17

Uma Kumaran

I'll assure the honorable member opposite, matters of sovereignty are not in jeopardy. I've been very clear in my statement today that the United Kingdom stands resolute behind the Falkland Islanders. Conversations with businesses are ongoing and letters of comfort have been issued to those businesses that we deem necessary to send those letters to.

03:41:17 - 03:41:18

Kit Malthouse.

03:41:18 - 03:41:58

Kit Malthouse

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As I'm sure you are aware, as well as applying to join the CPTPP, the Argentinians are in the final stages of accession to the OECD. Now, membership of that organization brings with it significant benefits in terms of the risk premium attached to national debt, which could be worth hundreds of millions of dollars, if not billions, to Argentina. However, membership requires consensus from existing members that you're allowed to join. Would the Minister agree with me that the conduct of Argentina in this regard is unlikely to engender the kind of consensus needed for them to accede to the OECD?

03:41:58 - 03:42:15

Uma Kumaran

I thank the honorable member opposite for a very eloquently put question. We will continue to consider all options. Indeed, the behavior of the Argentine government is not what we would expect. We've been very clear today in my statement. I hope they'll reflect on that.

03:42:15 - 03:42:16

Dr. Sandip Morrison.

03:42:16 - 03:42:56

Andrew Murrison

Is it any surprise that President Milei is citing UNCLOS Annex 7 in defense of his claim in relation to the Sea Lion field, when this government is using Article 298 to defend its position in relation to the Chagos Islands? And on the subject of UNCLOS, will she use its strictures regarding freedom of navigation to ensure any thoughts that Argentina might have of frustrating the upcoming sea route between Punta Arenas and Stanley are given short shrift?

03:42:56 - 03:43:26

Uma Kumaran

Madam Deputy Speaker, the House will understand that while legal proceedings are contemplated or underway, I will not provide a running commentary. The UK's established position is that provisional measures ordered under the applicable international legal framework are binding on the parties and that the UK complies with its international obligations. On the matters raised in relation to Chagos, the situation is in no way comparable.

03:43:27 - 03:44:24

Julian Lewis

Sir Julian Lewis.

May I strongly welcome all three front bench statements on this vital matter? I would like to say as someone who was politically active in 1982 that I well remember the failure of deterrence which was partly fueled by mass agitation for nuclear disarmament, an unrelated subject at that time. So although the minister says that there is no connection or no parallel with the Chagos dispute, let me assure her that the signals that have been sent by the government over Chagos are undermining of deterrence. So will she therefore make it crystal clear to Argentina now that any military action against the Falkland Islands will be met with an overwhelming military response?

03:44:24 - 03:44:56

Uma Kumaran

I'll be very clear to the member opposite, we will do everything and anything it takes to protect the Falkland Islands. There is, we have strong support for the nuclear deterrent. On the issue of the Chagos Islands, I would remind members across the house these situations are in no way comparable and bringing domestic politics into these matters does not help us. We have a united approach on how we deal with matters of the Falkland Islands and I think we should go forward in that spirit.

03:44:56 - 03:44:58

Speaker 216

Last but not least, Douglas Lumsden.

03:44:58 - 03:45:17

Speaker 58

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's been asked already but I'm still unclear on the process of consenting new drilling at the Falklands. So can the minister tell us if the government has a role in consenting new drilling in the, in the Falklands, yes or no?

03:45:17 - 03:45:38

Uma Kumaran

I'll reiterate my answer which I said minutes ago. The issues to do with drilling in the Falkland Islands are a matter for the government of the Falkland Islands and are in no way comparable to domestic licenses.

03:45:38 - 03:46:14

Speaker 220

That is the end of the statement on Falkland Islands. I'll just give the front benches a moment to shuffle over. Point of order.

03:46:14 - 03:46:52

Ann Kirsty Blackman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We had a council by-election in my constituency and in my colleague's constituency over the course of the break. I was very surprised to see a picture tweeted by the Secretary of State for Scotland standing in front of a street sign in my constituency with the road very clearly written on it, despite the fact that he hadn't given me any notice that he was intending to be in my constituency. Madam Deputy Speaker, how can I raise with the Secretary of State for Scotland the importance of notifying members if he intends to be in their constituency and to campaign in their constituency?

03:46:52 - 03:47:26

Pat McFadden

No doubt this will be raised many times by colleagues and there is the document called the Rules of Behavior and Courtesies in the House of Commons which deals with this matter. When a member visits another member's constituency except on a purely private visit, they should take reasonable steps in advance to tell the member in which constituency the visit is taking place. The guidance also states that failure to do so is regarded by colleagues as very discourteous. No doubt that will be passed on by the front benches to the members commented on. I am well, move on to the ten minute rule motion, Ruth Jones.

03:47:26 - 03:54:34

Ruth Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to establish a close season from the start of February to the end of September during which the killing or taking of brown hares is prohibited, to protect mountain hares, to repeal the seasonal prohibition on the sale of hares in the Hares Preservation Act 1892, and for connected purposes. Before starting my speech, I would like to pay tribute to the work of Baroness Hayman in the other place. She's been a tireless champion of this cause alongside the wider animal welfare sector. Indeed, it has been a privilege to work alongside her in putting together this bill. Now, despite being affectionately heralded as an inhabitant of the British countryside and featuring on the Bank of England's recent banknote competition, they came fifth, the brown hare is not originally native to these lands.

The species is thought to have originated in Central Asia and spread across Europe alongside the expansion of agriculture. Academics believe the brown hare was introduced to Britain following the Roman invasion, although some suggest the hares might even have arrived before the Romans. Now, following their introduction to Britain, the hare population continued to grow, peaking in the 18th and 19th century. Unlike other wild species, agricultural reforms, land enclosure, and predator control on larger estates all created favourable conditions for hares to thrive. Experts at the University of Bristol estimate that the hare population reached four million in the late 19th century.

As a result, the species became deeply embedded in rural culture and folklore. But these conditions were not to last, however. By the early 1990s, gamekeepers and rural ecologists were beginning to sound the alarm. Brown hare numbers had declined sharply, especially since the 1960s. The National Brown Hare Survey organised by Hutching and Harris in 1996 estimated that the brown hare population had fallen as low as 817,000, barely a fifth of the number a hundred years ago.

Hare numbers were estimated to be falling by 2% a year during the 1990s. Shooting, coursing, and poaching were specifically cited as cause of this decline, alongside wider changes in farming intensification, decreased crop diversity, and the loss of headlands and hedgerows. Despite having been a priority species since 1992, the estimated number of brown hares continued to decline, with targets to double the spring population by 2010 being missed. Estimates in 2022 put the population at fewer than 600,000, with surveys such as by the British Trust for Ornithology only reporting a recovery in the last few years. It's this worrisome decline which my bill seeks to respond to, building on existing best practice to protect local hare populations.

Principally, it does this through introducing a statutory close season for the killing of hares in England and Wales. Currently, hares are the only game species in England and Wales without a statutory close season and may therefore be killed throughout the year. This makes England and Wales outliers compared to Scotland, Northern Ireland, and the rest of Europe. The gap in protection, Madam Deputy Speaker, makes brown hare populations uniquely vulnerable from commercial shooting. Most organised hare shoots take place during February and March following the closure of the game bird shooting season.

This almost exactly aligns with the hare breeding season, meaning shoots can devastate the local population. The Game Conservancy Trust estimated that a February hare shoot can remove 60% of the breeding stock. In low population areas, such devastation can also pose the risk of localised extinction. Such impacts are already reflected in guidance and voluntary codes, which have clearly proved ineffective. Researchers at the University of Bristol found that shooting hares in February resulted in a profoundly damaging combination of population shrinkage and the orphaning of leverets with consequent animal welfare impacts and poor population recovery outcomes.

Madam Deputy Speaker, put simply, the killing of pregnant or nursing female hares during their principal breeding season cannot be reconciled with a modern and coherent approach to animal welfare. At a time when we are committed to restoring nature and biodiversity, such reckless practice only risks putting brown hare populations at further risk. When considering the welfare of hares across England and Wales, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's critical we do not neglect the mountain hares, the upland cousin of the more common brown hare. Whilst their numbers have declined significantly since the 19th century, the Peak District maintains an established wild breeding population in the Dark Peaks of Derbyshire and South Yorkshire. In Wales, however, the mountain hare population has all but disappeared, despite efforts to reintroduce the species in historic habitats.

The lack of any specific wildlife protections for mountain hares in England and Wales has been a key contributor to their decline, with moorland and scrubland habitats being lost and intensive culling efforts linked to red grouse shooting. In responding to these intensifying threats to mountain hare populations, in 2021, the Scottish Government extended full protection under Schedule 5 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, a crucial step given that Scotland is home to most of the native British mountain hare population. Clause 4 of my bill seeks to extend the same protections afforded to mountain hares in Scotland to those in England and Wales. This would mean it would become generally unlawful to intentionally or recklessly kill, injure or take a mountain hare without a license. By providing greater protection, we can give this vulnerable species the breathing room it needs to recover, boosting local ecology in the process.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, having seen near my static caravan in St Davids in West Wales, the hares out and about in the spring and summer and autumn evenings, it's a delight to watch them, and I would want to make sure that we make all efforts to protect these marvelous little creatures. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, this Labour Government was elected on a commitment to deliver the biggest increase to animal welfare in a generation, providing increased protection for domestic, farmed and wild animals. The recently published animal welfare strategy was a major first step in delivering this, including a priority commitment to introducing a close season for hares. This Government has also committed to reversing ecological decline and boosting species abundance. We've had the warm words and now it's time for action.

The Government must urgently back this bill or an equivalent in the other place to introduce a close season and better protect our hares. Deeds not words will determine how this Government is judged before the next election. This applies to animal welfare and the environment as much as anything else. I therefore commend this bill to the House.

03:54:34 - 03:54:46

Pat McFadden

The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. Many as that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no, the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

03:54:46 - 03:55:02

Ruth Jones

Irene Campbell, Sir Desmond Swayne, Kerry McCarthy, Sir Roger Gale, Neil Duncan-Jordan, Tim Farron, Ben Lake, Tonia Antoniazzi, Terry Jermy, Simon Hoare and myself, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:55:02 - 03:55:22

Speaker 224

Ruth Jones.

03:55:22 - 03:55:26

Speaker 223

Hares Bill.

03:55:26 - 03:55:27

Second reading what day?

03:55:27 - 03:55:29

Speaker 221

19th of March 2027.

03:55:29 - 03:55:50

Pat McFadden

19th of March 2027. Before we get onto the next bit of business, I've been updated that the Foreign Office statement was indeed received on time, and I did tell the Minister off earlier, but maybe we can pass that information onto her. The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

03:55:50 - 03:55:56

Speaker 222

Courts and Tribunals Bill, as amended in committee, to be considered.

03:55:56 - 03:56:11

Pat McFadden

Now, we will begin with the government new clause 23, with which it will be convenient to consider other new clauses and amendments as listed on the selection paper. I call the Minister to move new clause 23.

03:56:11 - 04:00:54

Heidi Alexander

I beg to move that the bill now be considered. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is an honour to open the report stage of the Courts and Tribunals Bill and to bring this important piece of legislation back before the House. This is a bill with victims at its heart. Its purpose is urgent and long overdue, to ensure that justice in this country is delivered fairly for both victims and defendants. Currently thousands of victims, witnesses and defendants are trapped in the long slow wait for justice.

That is simply unfair. For some, justice may never come. The old maxim rings true in our country today: far too often, justice delayed is justice denied. Madam Deputy Speaker, occasionally there are stories that stop one in one's tracks. I appeared on the Newsnight programme to explain the situation in our courts, backlogs reaching 80,000, far too many people waiting for justice.

And on that programme I was confronted with the story of Moena Lowman, and she spoke of the devastating impact that these court delays had had on her life. Moena was violently raped in February 2023. In her case she was forced to wait over two years for her attacker to be convicted, after her trial was cancelled not once but twice at short notice. During that time she lost her job, her home, her sense of self. And to be honest, Madam Deputy Speaker, her story has stayed with me ever since.

It's exactly people like Moena that I have in my mind's eye as I return to the House with this legislation. For far too many survivors, delays themselves have become another source of trauma. We cannot sit idly by, we have to act now to resolve this situation. This bill seeks to turn a crisis into an opportunity, an opportunity to rebuild a justice system that is swifter, stronger, and that has victims' voices at its core. A system that gives courts the ability to triage cases rather than defendants, and that transforms our approach towards the culture around rape and serious sexual violence.

That is the ambition of this bill, not just to repair what is broken, but to build something better in its place. Madam Deputy Speaker, this government inherited a criminal justice system on its knees. Trials taking longer, hearings constantly cancelled, victims facing unacceptable delay. And years of inaction and underinvestment had led to a court system that, as Lord Leveson's report concluded, was simply and remains simply unfit for purpose. Today the Crown Court backlog stands at almost 81,000 cases, and the pressure is growing.

Cases themselves are increasingly complex, not least because of the growth of digital and forensic evidence.

A single smartphone can hold the equivalent of 50 million printed pages and this adds to disclosure complexity and the time it takes to reach a verdict. The police are arresting more criminals, something we make absolutely no apologies for, but a system already under strain cannot continue to absorb ever-rising demand without reform. Old structures are creaking under new volumes and new types of crime and if we do not act, the situation will continue to spiral. Madam Deputy Speaker, we're not only failing victims, this situation, these unacceptable delays are corrosive of public trust in the justice system itself. We can and we must do better.

To do that, we need a sensible, principled and pragmatic approach. As no doubt we will hear, the opposition have offered plenty of objections but precious few answers to the reality facing our courts. And we'll not take lectures from the party that left the criminal justice system in this state. This government has a plan, a serious package of measures designed to drive down the backlog and ensure victims get the fast, timely and fair justice that they deserve. Lord Leveson's conclusion in the independent review of criminal courts was absolutely clear: there is no silver bullet for addressing this problem.

04:00:54 - 04:01:14

Speaker 225

We need to pull every lever: investment, modernization and structural reform. This government is doing precisely that. Let me begin with investment. For a start, we have removed the financial limit on court sitting days. We have recruited more judges and magistrates.

04:01:14 - 04:02:47

Heidi Alexander

By un-capping Crown Court sitting days meaning there is no financial limit on the number of cases that courts can hear, we have unleashed the potential of our Crown Courts who are hearing more cases than ever before. We're investing an additional 287 million pounds in court repairs and digital upgrades, alongside record investment in criminal legal aid to support the solicitors and barristers who run our criminal cases, alongside a package of over half a billion pounds for victim services over the next three years. In addition to that, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm also proud that we've announced a 23 million pound package to introduce specialist rape courts, a manifesto commitment in every single Crown Court centre. This will improve the experience of victims of rape and other sexual offences at court and I want to pay tribute to my honourable friend the member for Warrington North whose bravery and determination has driven forward these changes. But modernization and efficiency matter too.

I abhor inefficiency. It's so frustrating and when I speak not just to victims, but to defendants, to people who work within the system, it is so frustrating the wastefulness of ineffective trials, stories of trials being put off because a prisoner wasn't produced on time or because counsel was unavailable. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, working with the judiciary, we are modernizing our system and we are throwing the kitchen sink at it.

04:02:47 - 04:03:16

Gideon Amos

I'm extremely grateful to the minister for throwing the kitchen sink at the problem, but throwing everything at it including court repairs. In Taunton Crown Court we wish to see those repairs make progress. The minister was good enough to write to me at the beginning of the summer to explain that the court's been closed since 2023 will be closed for longer. Can I ask the minister to contact me and let us give us an update on when Taunton Crown Court will finally be reopened?

04:03:16 - 04:09:37

Heidi Alexander

Well, I'm very grateful to him and I was glad to meet with him to discuss the situation at Taunton which I know has been a deep source of frustration.

Nothing could exemplify more the years of neglect of our justice system than our crumbling court estate presided over by the party opposite. This government is investing in the fabric of our court estate, not just in the bricks and mortar, but also in the digital upgrades that are so important. And it's that that I'm coming to now. The use of remote hearings. We have the technology now.

We need to be deploying it. This government will be developing a pilot of virtual remand hearings so that we don't need as many prisoner transfers as previously, working with our judiciary to develop a new pioneering national video model. The model allows suitable cases to be allocated to available judges across different locations. It might be that a judge in Cardiff is hearing a matter based down in London, helping to alleviate the pressures there, helping to make much more effective use of capacity and target those areas facing the greatest backlogs. We're also adopting a new national listing tool, harnessing the capacity of AI to schedule cases in a more efficient way.

Case progression officers in every single Crown Court making the more complex cases progress further and faster. Working with the judiciary to set up short trial courts, which hear similar cases together over concentrated periods so they can be dealt with more quickly. We're also expanding a scheme already used in Manchester, Bristol, and Nottingham to allow prison vans to use bus lanes. So to those who say we need to make the system more efficient, I agree with you entirely and we are stretching and straining every sinew to do exactly that with the investment to go with it. And we welcome in particular the judiciary's reforms to prioritize rape and serious sexual offenses and end the unacceptable practice of floating trials for these cases, giving victims greater certainty about when their case will be heard.

But Lord Leveson's review was clear. Investment and modernization can only take us so far. No single lever can fix a crisis which has been years in the making, decades of underinvestment in a system that has simply not kept pace with the 21st century, where cases now take twice as long as they did 25 years ago. So our third lever is pragmatic, principled structural reform to ease the pressure on the Crown Court and make sure its time is concentrated on the most serious cases. That is precisely what this bill delivers.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the case for reform remains as strong as ever. But good government requires us to listen, and this place exists to scrutinize and improve legislation. When concerns are raised, it's right that the government reflect and react. When the Prime Minister took office, he committed to looking at these proposals again, and that is why over recent months the Prime Minister, the Lord Chancellor, and I have listened carefully to stakeholders, to members across this House, to people who worked within the system. We've heard that strength of feeling and we've acted.

So I can confirm today that the government has brought forward an amendment to the bill to remove clause 3, the bench division. The effect of that will be that all defendants facing a trial in the Crown Court will be heard with a jury. That decision does not change the destination or the ambition of this bill, which has always remained the same: swifter justice for victims. And by simplifying our approach and avoiding some of the operational reforms that would have come with a new division in the Crown Court, this gives us the opportunity to move faster in implementing the changes that are set out in this bill. Implementing these changes more efficiently will free up court capacity and make better use of court time, helping us to bring about fast, fair justice for victims.

And we remain confident that the package of reform, the guts of this bill, backed by the record financial investment I've outlined, along with the ambitious program of modernization, that this will be sufficient to free up Crown Court time to turn the tide on the backlog within this Parliament. This is the right decision for victims and it's the right decision for the justice system. Now I know that the opposition have tabled amendments to remove the remaining clauses that relate to Lord Leveson's review from the bill. But I'm afraid that is to bury one's head in the sand. We are proceeding with other structural reforms in the bill, including removing the right for a defendant to choose whether their case is heard in the magistrates or the Crown Court when it is an either-way offense.

As in Scotland, the reform that we've always put forward is that it should be the court rather than the defendant that triages cases. This has a double effect. Not only is it more efficient, so where the prosecution and the court decides that a case can be heard in the magistrates, that is where it's heard, it's also fairer. What this does, it's about putting the power in the hands of the court rather than defendant, giving a far greater say to victims whose voice can be heard through the prosecution that puts its case as to what venue the case should be heard in, alongside hearing from the defense. What this means is that cases are heard based on their seriousness, not simply on the preference of the defendant, exactly as the case is in Scotland.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this is exactly the right thing to do. These measures will not only reduce the demand on the Crown Court, it will prevent defendants from gaming the system, electing a jury trial in the simple hope that the delays drag on and that the case falls apart when the victim or witnesses withdraw. So the reforms today are not only pragmatic, they are principled. So too, giving magistrates' courts greater sentencing powers means that more cases can be dealt with more quickly. The magistrates' court is an efficient jurisdiction.

It currently deals with trial-either-way cases around four times faster than the Crown Court. We're also reforming the automatic right of appeal. Of course I will.

04:09:37 - 04:10:00

Geoffrey Cox

As concerned as I am about the backlog in the magistrates' court, which is four times larger than that in the Crown Court and growing at 16% a year, whereas the Crown Court backlog has stabilized, if it really is a reform in the interest of efficiency, shouldn't she be sparing the magistrates' court at a time when their backlog is growing so fast?

04:10:00 - 04:19:54

Heidi Alexander

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't accept the premise of that question. I don't accept that we do have a backlog in our magistrates' court. What we have is a substantial case load, but you will know that the magistrates' court hears over 1.5 million cases a year. The magistrates' court is coping well. What I do acknowledge, and I will say to this House, is that we need to grow the capacity of our magistrates' court.

It's why we are increasing the number of sitting days in our magistrates' court. In 2025, 114,000 sitting days, we are growing that to 130,000 by 28-29. The other thing we're doing is increasing the number of magistrates. Under the previous government, the number of magistrates in this country halved. We are going to restore the magistracy to its former glory.

The changes that we have made to the application process, the investment that we are making in recruitment, quadrupling the budget, is already reaping the rewards and we are on target to meet that 21,000 target. So the honorable member is right, we do need to grow capacity as we see a more expanded role for the magistracy, but I believe that we can do it and we are on track to do so. So we are reforming the automatic right of appeal. It's vital that of course there is a right of appeal, but it's also reasonable to ask a defense to identify grounds of appeal. So by introducing a permission to filter out cases without merit, what we avoid is a situation where victims are needlessly put through unnecessary rehearings where the appeal totally lacks merit.

These reforms, as I said, must be matched by the capacity to deliver them. And it's why, as I said, we're investing in our courts, in the people who make justice possible, and we remain on track to reach our target of 21,000 magistrates by 28-29. And not just magistrates, strengthening judicial capacity, boosting the number of district judges and legal advisers who need to see better pay and better and better career progression. There remains too a strong case for judge-alone trials in the small number of cases that pertain to complex and lengthy fraud and financial matters. And I can confirm to the House that we will be proceeding with this measure, which has had strong support from those responsible for investigating and prosecuting serious economic crime.

Our primary objective here is minimizing the burden on ordinary people who sit as jurors on such trials. We know that these trials can be lengthy, often lasting months at a time, which can mean long periods away from work, family responsibilities, lost income, and real pressure on family life. So we are clear, reform must bring down delay and improve victims' experience. And it must also command public confidence and protect the principles that have made our courts respected the world over. The destination has not changed, it never has wavered, swifter justice for victims, and we will continue to pull every lever to bring down the backlog so that people no longer have to wait years for their day in court.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is also, as I said, about making our justice system work better for victims and survivors. And I know that this part of the bill commands a good degree of consensus across this House. It introduces vital reforms on giving evidence to challenge harmful myths about rape and sexual violence based on Law Commission research, such as the preconceptions about how a victim should behave or respond. We also make special measures easier to access and simpler for practitioners to navigate so that victims feel safer, better supported, and able to give their best evidence. The government also remains committed to repealing the presumption of parental involvement within the Children Act 1989.

Alongside a national rollout of child-focused courts, this measure strengthens our approach to protecting children from the harm posed by abusive parents. And today we are joined by Claire Throssell, who I've had the privilege of meeting and who has campaigned so bravely, bravely and tirelessly, forgive me, for this change following the tragic murder of her sons Jack and Paul. And I also want to pay tribute to my honorable friend the member for Penistone and Stocksbridge for her tireless work on this campaign. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the time I've got left, let me now turn to the rest of the government amendments and new clauses being brought forward at this stage. Madam Deputy Speaker, fairness must be the foundation of any justice system.

People must be able to trust they will be treated equally before the law, whoever they are and wherever they come from. Before introducing this bill, we carried out a full equality impact assessment. And while that assessment found no evidence of discrimination arising from these reforms, we are aware that long-standing disparities remain in the criminal justice system. People from black and minority ethnic backgrounds are more likely to be victims of crime, whilst defendants from black, Asian, and minority ethnic backgrounds are also more likely to be remanded into custody before trial. So when we talk about tackling delays, it's not simply a question of efficiency, it also becomes a question of fairness.

We also know that gaps in data make these disparities harder to understand and therefore harder to tackle, limitations highlighted nearly a decade ago by my friend and colleague the right honorable member for Tottenham in the Lammy Review.

That is why we are bringing forward new clause 23 and consequential amendments 35 to 37, which give this new clause effect. This requires an independent review of the court reforms in this bill, considering whether differences in treatment or outcomes experienced by defendants from different racial and socio-economic backgrounds are exacerbated as a result. The Lord Chancellor will appoint an independent reviewer within six months of the first reforms taking effect, and there will be an initial report within 12 months and a full report within five years, which Parliament will have the opportunity to consider and that the government will formally respond to. I will now turn briefly to four technical government amendments. The first, amendment 38 to schedule 2, clarifies that new audio recording requirements in the magistrates' courts appeals will not apply to single justice procedure cases.

These cases are generally dealt with on a computer without an oral hearing to record. Government amendments 39 to 41 to schedule 2 make further changes arising from the new permission stage for appeals, ensuring magistrates' courts have the necessary powers over bail and costs, including to return an appellant to custody where appropriate. Government amendments 29 to 31 to clause 8 clarify that where the court can exclude sexual behaviour evidence that would require significant satellite litigation to be relied upon. This essentially follows the Law Commission's recommendation that the extent to which the evidence will distract the fact-finder from the main issues in the case is relevant to the evidence's admissibility. Government amendment 32 to clause 10 makes clear that a victim's failure to report a previous allegation of a sexual offence cannot, by itself, provide a basis for suggesting in court that the allegation was false; there must be additional evidence capable of supporting such an assertion.

And finally, government amendments 42 to 44 to schedule 3 replaces three mentions of the Chancellor of the High Court with the new terminology, President of the Business and Property Division. Clause 18 and schedule 3 make a range of changes to the current provisions for senior judicial leadership of the tribunals in order to unify tribunals and courts in England and Wales under the leadership of the Lady Chief Justice and reform the role of the Senior President of Tribunals. Madam Deputy Speaker, I will now turn briefly to amendments tabled by other members. In relation to the amendment proposed by the honourable member for Bexhill and Battle and the member for Chichester, who I know will speak to amendments which relate to a sunset clause to repeal the measures if they're found to be ineffective. As I've said, this package of measures is principled and pragmatic.

They're not simply a short-term emergency fix. They recognise that fundamental changes both in crime, evidence, and the nature of technology requires that we put our courts on a sustainable footing for the 21st century. We believe in these reforms and we think they are here for the long term. Our ambition therefore extends beyond simply reducing court delays, but in delivering lasting improvements about how the justice system operates, including a better balance between the interests of victims and defendants. Madam Deputy Speaker, I close by returning to the central purpose of this bill.

We inherited a criminal justice system under severe pressure. Victims, witnesses, and defendants facing unacceptable delays, and some victims dropping out of the process altogether. As I said, I think of Morwenna Lowman. This bill is a serious and practical response to the challenges we face. Rather than bury our head in the sand, it confronts that problem on every single front: investment, modernisation, and reform.

It will ensure we rebuild a justice system that is fit for the pressures of the modern age, whilst remaining grounded in the fundamental principles of fairness and the rule of law that English and Welsh law has always stood for. Our task is not simply to reduce the delays that exist today, but build a sustainable justice system for the future. And I look forward to hearing contributions from across the chamber and responding to the points raised in what I hope will be a thoughtful and constructive debate.

04:19:54 - 04:20:02

Judith Cummins

The question is that new clause 23 be read a second time.

Shadow Minister Dr. Kieran Mullan.

04:20:02 - 04:24:02

John Kieran Mullan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's my pleasure to take part in the further consideration of the Courts and Tribunals Bill as we repeat, as we reach report stage. Madam Deputy Speaker, not for the first time with this ministerial team, with this Justice Secretary and with this Prime Minister, what we were told was necessary has turned out to be unnecessary. What we were told was impossible is now possible, and what we were told was unavoidable was avoidable after all. Because this Minister told us again and again at second reading and throughout the Bill Committee that each and every one of the measures in this bill was the only way to get on top of the court backlogs, each and every part of their proposals. But apparently not.

Because only days ago, the Justice Secretary appeared on national television to announce a significant U-turn. The government is dropping clause 3. We were told that this new division of theirs of judge-only trials was the only way in which the Crown Court backlog could be brought down, and it couldn't be brought down without it. Yet now, Ministers inform us that removing this very provision will actually allow the work to proceed faster. We welcome this decision, and I welcome the fact the Justice Secretary put his name to our amendment removing clause 3.

But how we got here matters. Because this is not the first time this ministerial team and this Justice Secretary have let their backbenchers defend the indefensible and then dropped them in it. This same ministerial team, this same Justice Secretary, told us the release of various serious sexual and violent offenders was an absolute necessity, that they had no other choice than to put victims through the distress and upset that they did over the summer, and then they did. Why does this matter? Most of the time in politics in this place, we debate choices, which choice we should make as MPs, as different parties, weighing up the pros and cons of the options.

But sometimes Ministers attempt to cut through that to secure the support of MPs. And they do that by saying they have no choice. When MPs resist, when they tell them their concerns over what the government is proposing, Ministers have a fundamental duty to this House, to their own backbench colleagues in particular, and that is a duty to test that proposition that there is no choice to destruction. Only the Ministers have the army of civil servants or the data, the costings, the honest advice. When a Minister tells their own MPs they have no choice, surely it must mean exactly that.

That is how they secure the support of their backbench colleagues, but these Ministers have failed in that duty and they have failed their colleagues. Ministerial credibility is a precious resource, and this Minister has exhausted hers. If clause 3 was never truly required to tackle court delays, we must ask what other assertions made by this front bench are equally unfounded? How can they expect their propositions of no choice to be accepted in future, and not just in future, but on this very bill before us today? Because we must also be clear, despite the headlines surrounding this partial retreat, the core damaging framework of this bill remains almost entirely intact.

The government continues to press ahead with clause 1, which completely strips adult defendants charged with triable either-way offenses of their historic right to elect a jury trial. At the same time, clause 6 doubles magistrates' maximum sentencing powers up to 24 months. This means complex, high-stake cases including sexual assault, actual bodily harm, burglary, will be retained in summary courts, exposing defendants to two-year prison sentences without ever having access to a jury.

Clause 7 and schedule 2 dismantle the automatic right of appeal from the magistrates' court to the crown court. Instead of a full rehearing before a judge and lay magistrates, wrongly convicted individuals will face a restricted permission barrier on written papers alone. It should be clear that taken together, we're still facing a fundamental attack on the existing rights to a jury trial in this country. These provisions still represent a sweeping contraction of access to jury trial and summary justice safeguards. The opposition from legal professions, victims' groups and civil liberties organisations remains as firm today as it was on the second reading.

04:24:02 - 04:24:32

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

As somebody who has had people elect to have a jury and is now awaiting a trial till 2029 on a simple order breach, I ask him if he is in his defence of jury trials, does he think a victim should be able to say whether they want it to be tried by a jury or just the defendant because that's the system that we have today in this country. And in light of his desire to see jury trials, does he think that the system should be changed so that anyone can just say no, I want it to be heard in front of a jury?

04:24:32 - 04:25:25

John Kieran Mullan

What we're talking about is where we draw the ledger. Because I don't think that the member opposite would suggest we should have everything done by magistrates. Why not have everything done by magistrates if it's fundamentally unfair to allow people to have a jury trial? Why not let everything be done by magistrates? It's unfair on them, the victims don't have a say in whether it's a jury trial.

And the point that they're making, the point that we're clear about is this is an unprecedented erosion of that right, an unprecedented erosion of that right. And it wasn't in their manifesto, up until recently was largely opposed by very large numbers of their own MPs and based on a premise of necessity that I'm afraid is paper thin on the basis that they've turned around and said things that they had to do to get the backlog down, it turns out they didn't have to do anyway.

04:25:25 - 04:25:58

Catrin Emily Darlington

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think the honourable member misses the point of the question that was just raised. The question he seems to misunderstand is the fact that the right to choose a jury trial is being used by perpetrators to continue the abuse on the victim-survivors. And does he think the state should be party to continuing that abuse and allowing them to play the system through a jury trial selection or an appeals process?

04:25:58 - 04:26:26

John Kieran Mullan

I listened very closely to the words that the member opposite used and we heard this again and again from Labour members during committee stage. She talked about perpetrators. May I remind her that defendants are not guilty until found guilty and the same erosion of rights is for innocent people too and that members opposite repeatedly forget that. Just because you're accused doesn't make you a perpetrator and I ask her to think about that carefully.

04:26:26 - 04:26:45

Ayoub Khan

Can I thank the shadow minister for giving way? Will he agree with me that justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done? And one of the key cornerstones of getting that justice is being tried by your peers and giving that to a defendant builds confidence in a jury system.

04:26:45 - 04:30:20

John Kieran Mullan

And he's absolutely right. And as I pointed out at the start and as again members opposite have highlighted, it isn't just people concerned about defendants that have raised concerns about these proposals. Victims as well, victims' groups wrote an extensive letter to the Secretary of State and to the Prime Minister asking them to think twice about the erosion of jury trials. And so any criticisms that they make of me, I'm afraid would then have to be levelled at the victims that don't agree with them. Victims are not all in one voice on this issue and we should respect that instead of assuming every single victim agrees with them, which they don't.

And so as I said, the erosions that we've seen in relation to this are significant. And when it comes to this government in which trust is so low, they also seek for themselves an extraordinary power to do what they set out to do in clause 3 through the back door by clause 4. When not only will they be introducing judge-only trials in the crown court for what they describe as lengthy and complex cases, but giving themselves the power to add to the list of eligible cases through order alone, bypassing the fullest scrutiny of parliament.

Quite extraordinary from a government that when in opposition concerned itself greatly with the proper use of delegated legislation. We remain as concerned as everybody is about the Crown Court backlog. We know victims and innocent defendants are suffering as a result. But so much of this bill won't help and may make matters worse. That is the reality.

And I notice that the Minister was happy to say in committee repeatedly that opposing these measures does not in any way suggest that people don't have a concern for victims, and I hope that she sticks to that line during the rest of this debate and I encourage all of her colleagues to listen to the words that she expressed in committee. Being concerned about an erosion of jury trial rights does not in any way mean we don't care about victims, and I hope the Minister repeats that later. I was able to visit the Supreme Court yesterday, and I encourage any members mulling this over to head to the exhibition space and take a look at the replica of the Magna Carta. Read for yourself the words illuminated against the wall, that at its heart laid down that the highest form of justice, the best form of justice, is justice delivered by your peers. And this brings me to the position of members opposite, not just yet.

Prior to this partial U-turn, dozens of Labour backbenchers, including 37 MPs who signed a public letter, expressed deep opposition to the bill's proposals to curtail jury trials. They rightly described the stripping of jury rights as madness that would cause more problems than it solved. Members on the benches opposite spoke forcefully about the unique value of the jury. Yet today, following the removal of just one clause, just one element of this damaging bill, the government expects those same members to walk through the lobbies in support of it. I ask those members directly, what's actually changed?

Clause one still abolishes the right of an ordinary citizen to elect for a jury trial, clause six still pushes serious cases into summary courts where backlogs are already surging, and clause seven still cuts off automatic appeals. If removing the right to elect a jury trial in either-way cases was wrong before, it remains wrong today. Dropping one element of a bad package does not make the remaining elements good law. During committee stage, opposition members and backbenchers put forward a series of modest, constructive amendments designed to insert basic safeguards into the bill, and the government rejected every single one. We tabled amendments to preserve a natural justice exception, ensuring that where a defendant could demonstrate that a summary-only trial would result in a clear breach of natural justice, a jury trial would remain available.

04:30:20 - 04:31:20

Margaret Rachel Taylor

The ministers defeated those amendments. We pressed the government on the severe misalignment in legal aid. A defendant in the Crown Court benefits from higher legal aid eligibility thresholds. The government rejected those amendments. Everything we sought to do to protect natural justice and to worsen the impacts of this bill was blocked.

I thank the honourable member for being generous with his time. I would like to ask what his government did in 14 years to ensure that people were tried by their peers, because that is exactly what magistrates are there to do. And I know all too well because my dad served as a magistrate for over 40 years in Warwickshire, and I am really proud to stand here and say that, because magistrates' courts are the bedrock of our justice system. And his government did nothing to protect that. And this is exactly what we're doing, investing in more magistrates so that more people can be tried by their peers and supporting those magistrates in doing that job effectively.

04:31:20 - 04:31:26

Speaker 232

The member asked what we did to preserve the right to trial by jury. We brought the backlog in the Crown Courts down to lower prior to the pandemic than the one we inherited from the previous Labour government, which is something they all conveniently seem to forget.

04:31:26 - 04:32:12

Kit Malthouse

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend. He's making a very powerful argument in defense of jury trials, and members are rightly thinking about the impact on victims and defendants. But would he agree with me that there are also significant implications for the judiciary themselves at the erosion of jury trials? At the moment, jury trials very often stand between the public contemplation of a trial and indeed the defendant or the convicted and the judge. By removing that shield between the two, the judge, their prejudices, their demographics, how they are selected, becomes more and more a focus of public contemplation and may in the end lead to political interference in the selection of judges.

04:32:12 - 04:32:45

John Kieran Mullan

He's right on both points, and as he was speaking, the Secretary of State in charge said we've removed that clause, which again, perhaps he doesn't understand his own bill. You're retaining judge-only trials for complex and lengthy cases and retaining a power to use delegated legislation to allow judges alone to sit on those cases. So exactly the sort of scenario that the member talks about would be produced. And again, magistrates have a degree of confidence and community support in proportion to the use of their powers. If we significantly increase the use of their powers, the pressure and scrutiny over magistrates, I'm afraid, is also likely to increase.

04:32:45 - 04:32:51

Speaker 234

And picking up on that point, I do really want to make sure that the House fully understands.

04:32:51 - 04:32:57

Speaker 233

That is the third time I think I've heard the shadow minister say you, it's not my legislation.

04:32:57 - 04:36:19

John Kieran Mullan

Thank you, lucky you, Madam Deputy Speaker, but indeed I'll take that point. The schedule one powers that I've talked about are a significant Henry VIII power. Under proposed statutory instrument powers, the Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State would have the authority to add further categories of offence to schedule one by secondary legislation. I'm not aware of any time before in this Parliament where using secondary legislation, the Secretary of State could erode and remove the right to a jury trial from a particular defendant. That is completely unprecedented and indefensible.

Mr. Speaker, the opposition does not merely criticize this bad package of legislation. We have repeatedly sought to put forward practical, evidence-based alternatives that tackle the actual delays without taking a sledgehammer to our constitutional rights. The government must fix the operational failures that currently waste thousands of court hours every year. Last year, between 23 and 26 percent of Crown Court trials were ineffective. Rather than stripping citizens of jury trial rights, ministers should be focused instead on prison transport, the failures in prison transport that stop hundreds of trials being derailed simply because defendants are late to the dock.

They must keep all existing courtrooms open and fully funded and use new AI tools for disclosure and listing that expand live video participation. Madam Deputy Speaker, the ministers are chuntering saying they're doing that. If they're doing that, why is the Crown Court backlog going up? You are clearly not succeeding in the measures that you're bringing forward, and a number of things are actually getting worse. Second, we must improve case management and incentivize earlier case resolution.

Instead of forcing complex cases into the overburdened summary courts, where the backlogs, extraordinarily, the minister claimed there wasn't a backlog in the magistrates' courts. I don't know how she decides what is or isn't a backlog, but the record number of cases up in 10 percent in one year is a backlog by any other measure. I visited Liverpool Crown Court, Madam Deputy Speaker. The wait to trial in Liverpool Crown Court is roughly half the wait for trial in other parts of the country. The government should replicate the proactive case management model successfully pioneered in courts like Liverpool, Preston, and Cardiff, where active CPS case ownership and early trial readiness reviews have driven down backlogs.

And our sunset clause draws the closest attention to the true motivations of this government. If the government sincerely, as it has argued repeatedly to its backbenchers, feel these measures are a necessity to bring the backlog down, our clause is quite clear. When the backlog is down to the pre-COVID average for a period of four quarters, then these damaging, rights-eroding measures should be withdrawn.

And I don't expect the government will support that today because, actually, fundamentally, they don't have the same faith we do in the importance and value of a jury trial. The government's partial U-turn demonstrates that sustained scrutiny can force a rethink, but a partial U-turn is not enough. The central flaws of this legislation remain: the abolition of the right to elect trial by jury, the risky expansion of summary jurisdiction, the restriction of appeal rights, and the creation of secondary powers to expand jury-less trials. We should not erode centuries of procedural safeguards to achieve marginal administrative speed. I urge members across the House, especially those who previously spoken out against these measures, to stand by their previous words, to stand by their principles, and reject these remaining clauses tonight.

04:36:20 - 04:38:14

Karl Turner

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I begin by welcoming the Justice Secretary to his place? And can I thank him, Madam Deputy Speaker, for his engagement with me over recent weeks? But more particularly, could I thank him for the appointment of Holly Lynch, the former Member of Parliament for Halifax, who apparently, I goodness knows why, is still a big fan of me, Madam Deputy Speaker, despite the fact that I've opposed these policies in previous months. Goodness me, Madam Deputy Speaker, a lot's changed since I addressed this House on this bill, and that's not just the bill itself.

I welcome the removal of clause three, the idea of the Crown Court Bench Division. But let's not pretend that it's because of rebels, or because of the opposition across the House, or because of the Bar Council, or the Criminal Bar Association, or the Law Society, or indeed, I'm told, the Lady Chief Justice herself being opposed. The reality is, Madam Deputy Speaker, that CCBD was completely, unbelievably unworkable. That was the reality of it, and that's what members across this House warned the government about. It wouldn't have worked, it couldn't have worked, it will never work.

04:38:14 - 04:39:08

Speaker 238

So I welcome the fact that the government have done the right thing, they've listened to those of us who were bitterly opposed to the idea of CCBD. They've done the right thing. But I regret to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I can't support this bill today. I can't, not in its current form. The reality is, by doing away with the right to elect, what will happen is the backlog which exists in the magistrates' court, 380,000 and rising, the backlog as I understand it in the Crown Court is 80,000 and fairly static and probably falling, the problem will be transferred, Madam Deputy Speaker, from the Crown Court.

04:39:08 - 04:41:12

Karl Turner

The government say they estimate 25,000 fewer cases will be heard in the Crown Court and five and a half thousand trials will be moved effectively from the Crown Court to be heard at summary trial in the magistrates' court. Well, that just removes, transfers a problem from the Crown Court into the magistrates' court.

Well I don't care what we call it, whether it's a backlog or the system's different or whatever the government want to describe the fact that there's 380,000 cases currently sitting in the magistrates' court. Let me say this, that's 380,000 criminal cases where complainants are waiting for their trial, that outcome to be concluded. 380,000 cases and rising. Now I agree, a trial in the magistrates takes a lot quicker than a trial in the Crown Court. Of course it does, it's swift summary justice, it's fast.

And that's why we need to be very cautious, Madam Deputy Speaker, about what category of case is heard before a bench of lay magistrates in the magistrates' court. It matters because the accused's rights are at stake, the accused's liberty is at stake, and that's why we limit the time, the power of magistrates on sentencing in the way that we do in this England, this system in England and Wales. So I can't support clauses one and two of the bill. Clause four, judge-only trials. Look, I'm concerned about this, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm worried as well because the government are in listening mode, I'm grateful to them.

04:41:12 - 04:42:12

Speaker 240

But Jonathan Fisher King's Counsel was independent reviewer, he's reviewed this and he said it makes no difference. It is true to say that there's been a very complex and lengthy fraud trial in the Crown Court, but that doesn't necessarily seem to immediately jump to the conclusion that the jury didn't understand. I'm sure the members of the jury understood very well. The question might be, Madam Deputy Speaker, whether the judge properly understood, because it was the judge who dismissed the jury and decided to call it a day and start all over. It is a concern to me that we, this is the thin end of the wedge for me, and I think the problem we have is the powers are available to the government to keep pushing forward with more quote-unquote complex cases.

04:42:12 - 04:42:17

Speaker 235

I give way to the former Shadow Attorney General.

04:42:17 - 04:42:50

Jeremy Paul Wright

Extremely grateful to the honourable gentleman. And he's talking about complex and lengthy trials. I wonder has he considered the effect on the Court of Appeal of making those types of trial judge-only? Because if I've understood the government's proposals correctly, they wish to require a judge to give reasons for conviction. Juries need to give no reasons for conviction.

Does he think that will change the rate and frequency of appeals to the Court of Appeal in cases like that?

04:42:50 - 04:43:32

Speaker 240

The right honourable gentleman makes a very good point, of course it does. When a judge is required to give reason, counsel for the appellant by then is pouring over the judge's statement, looking at every single line. Clever people like the honourable gentleman over there, the very eminent King's Counsel, I forget the right honourable gentleman's seat. But people will be instructed, lawyers will be instructed to pour over the judgment of the judge in those cases and of course the likelihood of an appeal will increase.

04:43:32 - 04:44:01

Karl Turner

The beauty of a jury trial, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that the men and women, the ordinary people picked at random, citizens, ordinary people summoned to the court to hear a trial as a member of a jury, go home at the end of the case and very rarely, certainly not publicly, never speak about that case again. There's no requirement to give reasons in that scenario. Of course I give way.

04:44:01 - 04:44:24

Ayoub Khan

I thank the honourable member for giving way. Talking about appeals, if elected trials do not happen and they are summarily dealt with, there is a prospect, a good prospect, that those appeals will also find their way into the Crown Court, which would not allay the concerns that the government wants to address. Does he agree?

04:44:24 - 04:45:22

Karl Turner

I agree completely, Madam Deputy Speaker, and he makes the point very strongly indeed. Clause 6, magistrates' sentencing powers. I can't support the idea of the sentencing powers of magistrates to be between 18 and 24 months, Madam Deputy Speaker, not without a credible plan to address the dire, desperate need to recruit magistrates, legal advisers as well, court staff and lawyers. It just risks transferring the pressure rather than solving the backlog. That's the reality of where we're going with this bill.

04:45:22 - 04:46:39

Speaker 237

Which brings me, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the anomaly in this bill. As the way the bill is drafted currently, it provides a fairly obvious problem, actually. A scenario whereby a defendant of good character, no previous convictions, never been arrested, interviewed, charged, prosecuted or convicted. That's the point, Madam Deputy Speaker, convicted of a criminal offence, is likely, by virtue of the sentencing guidelines on an either-way offence, to be tried in front of a magistrates' court. Yet the defendant with numerous previous convictions, numerous previous convictions, by virtue of the fact that that offending behaviour on the guidelines exceeds the three-year threshold, gets the benefit of a Crown Court trial.

04:46:39 - 04:47:03

Karl Turner

Now let's just picture the scenario. An either-way offence, triable either-way offence, section 47 ABH, fairly serious assault, Madam Deputy Speaker, serious assault in a domestic scenario. Defendant A, no previous convictions, never been convicted by a criminal court.

04:47:03 - 04:47:17

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Will the honourable gentleman give way? Because a domestic abuser has no prior convictions does not mean he does not have priors, and actually does not mean he has good character.

04:47:17 - 04:48:32

Speaker 237

Absolutely agree with my honourable friend. She's absolutely right, of course. Very often, in my experience, that offenders appear in incredibly serious cases of violence in domestic scenarios and have never had previous convictions.

But imagine this scenario. Just imagine the fairness of this scenario. Defendant A, never ever been convicted of a criminal offence at all, charged with a section 47 ABH, appears in a summary trial for a section 47, very serious assault actually, an ABH. But the defendant with numerous convictions, the defendant who over his adult life, and let's be honest, it's mainly men who commit domestic assaults, that's the truth of it in reality, the defendant B with numerous convictions over a period of many years gets the benefit of a trial in front of a jury. How is that possibly fair?

04:48:32 - 04:49:11

Karl Turner

Well, it's a benefit, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm hearing why is it a benefit? Because the reality is, Madam, well not, I'm told by a sedentary position and I've got an awful lot of time for my honourable friend, I truly have, she's a mate of mine as it happens, Madam Deputy Speaker, but there is a benefit. And the reality is this, when a defendant appears in a summary trial before a bench of lay magistrates or indeed a district judge, it's swift, fast, summary justice. The evidence is heard, but the evidence is not heard and presented in the same way as a Crown Court.

04:49:11 - 04:49:31

Speaker 240

That's just the truth. A Crown Court trial in that scenario would last four, five, potentially into the second week. Defence evidence, there's an opportunity to call defence evidence. There's legal aid available for experts. There's reports potentially by for the defence.

04:49:31 - 04:49:59

Karl Turner

There's reports for the prosecution as well potentially. It's about equality before the law. That's the reality of the scenario, Madam Deputy Speaker, and that is something that I cannot believe is a consequence which is intended by this government, this Labour government, Madam Deputy Speaker, and that's why I say I can't possibly support it.

04:49:59 - 04:50:18

Catrin Emily Darlington

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Is he aware of the Rape Crisis report that actually says that juries bring misconceptions and bias into the system and are less likely then to convict? And I'm sure he's not talking about that being the benefit, is he?

04:50:18 - 04:50:34

Karl Turner

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for the intervention. I didn't, I'll be honest, I didn't know about the report, but I'm keen to go away and have a look. The benefit of a jury trial, I'll give way to the minister, shadow minister.

04:50:34 - 04:50:59

John Kieran Mullan

Remind members, as I said in my opening speech, a number of victims, women's victims' rights groups, women's victims' rights groups were the leading proponents of the criticism to get rid of jury trials. So again, to make out that victims have a single view on this and they're unhappy with it, there are different opinions amongst victims' groups and many of them agree with the member opposite.

04:50:59 - 04:53:09

Karl Turner

Yeah, well, I'm not going to get into the whys and wherefores of this particular juncture of the debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, but there's an easy fix for the scenario which I've described. My amendment, amendment 47, says where a defendant has no previous convictions and the court has decided that the case is suitable for summary trial, that defendant should be entitled to elect to the Crown Court to have their trial in the Crown Court.

I don't think the numbers will be very big. I think it's possible, impossible probably for the MOJ to do modeling, although I have to say the 16 years that I've been a member of this House and been involved in criminal justice matters and debating criminal justice issues, I've got to say I've rarely seen modeling from the MOJ which has been anything near accurate, Madam Deputy Speaker. But even if they could model, I suspect they can't because those, that data's not kept, the numbers would be tiny. Why? Because 0.4%, 0.4% of all cases, convictions from the Magistrates' Court are appealed.

0.4%. Yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, 41% of the 0.4%, it's a tiny number, 41% of those cases, the conviction is overturned in the Crown Court because there's been a wrong decision. And the Bar Council produced data now, current, more up-to-date data, which suggests that that number of 41% is actually 56% now. So more than half of the cases which are appealed from the Magistrates' to the Crown Court for a rehearing end up with the defendant who's been convicted in the Magistrate acquitted in the Crown Court. So why do I say there's a benefit, Madam Deputy Speaker, of a Crown Court hearing?

04:53:09 - 04:53:31

Speaker 237

It speaks for itself, Madam Deputy Speaker. Um, what could the government do instead? I think there's plenty, Madam Deputy Speaker. They could implement the relevant recommendations from the Leveson review. The relevant recommendations from the Leveson review.

04:53:31 - 04:54:28

Speaker 240

They could improve the coordination between police, CPS, the courts to progress and identify unnecessary prosecutions earlier. It does happen to be a fact that prosecutions sometimes end because actually the CPS, the Crown, throw the towel in. Madam Deputy Speaker, there are lots to welcome in this bill, and I do, but there's too much in the bill for me to support at this current time. I just finally want to say a few words of gratitude. I want to thank the Prime Minister because from the very outset of my opposition to the worst excesses of this bill, the Prime Minister was there supporting me in the background.

04:54:28 - 04:55:29

Karl Turner

Similarly, Lord Sadiq Khan was there texting and encouraging and supporting of me when it mattered. But my biggest thank you of all, Madam Deputy Speaker, is reserved for the honorable member for Warrington North. Because the truth is, her bravery, standing up, waiving her anonymity, explaining her personal situation to the criminal justice system in the face of all of that pressure that was being exerted on members who had the audacity, that's the reality, to say that these measures were not suitable for a Labour Party and a Labour government to be implementing, we suffered pressure exerted upon us. And that member, the honorable member for Warrington North, showed real bravery, real determination, and for that I will forever respect her.

04:55:29 - 04:55:38

Speaker 242

Can I just emphasize to members that votes will come at 6 o'clock, which leaves us very little time and inevitably not all members are going to get in.

04:55:38 - 04:55:40

Judith Cummins

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Jess Brown-Fuller.

04:55:40 - 05:02:18

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The entire criminal justice system is on the brink of collapse. We can all agree today that the current backlog in our crown courts is unacceptable, untenable, and unsustainable. The situation we face, a backlog sitting at over 80,000 cases and victims of rape waiting on average 424 days for their case to complete, is the direct result of the historic and monumental failures of successive governments. Whether it is a lack of prison places, soaring reoffending rates, or the horrendous backlog in the crown courts with a growing backlog in the magistrates, it's a national emergency waiting to happen.

But the government's plans to address this situation have been equally dangerous. Under Keir Starmer, this government led us down a path towards curtailing jury trials, presenting it as the only way to deal with the backlog. This was despite widespread opposition from the legal profession and Parliament, including from their own benches, and the absence of any coherent modeling or trialing to demonstrate the impact of the proposed crown court bench division. Political capital was wasted pursuing a solution that was never feasible. What we are presented with today is still fundamentally a flawed plan.

We remain deeply concerned about the pressure that these changes will place on magistrates' courts. The plans for those charged with either-way offenses to lose their right to elect trial by jury, alongside the increases in sentencing powers and the removal of the right to appeal, will place immense and dangerous pressure on magistrates' courts while simultaneously removing vital safeguards. The government now predicts that an additional 25,000 cases will be added to magistrates' court caseloads each year, and the current rate of increase in the backlog of open cases is expected to be 9%. It's exceeding that of the crown court backlog. Whilst increasing complexity also raises questions regarding the suitability of summary justice to deal with these cases.

This is a point that's been raised by the Bar Council and others, and I also have profound concerns about the experiences of victims in summary justice as well. It is not just the crown court where victims are so often failed. The minister spoke very powerfully about Morwenna. I remember Morwenna's powerful testimony. I'm thinking today about Georgia, whose case in the magistrates' court was postponed four times in a row, which took her months and months of building herself up to that moment and then being totally failed because she didn't get her day in court.

So the government has done little to address those concerns, which is why amendment 11 tabled in my name remains on the amendment paper, and that would prevent magistrates' sentencing powers from being increased beyond 12 months. The Liberal Democrats also fundamentally oppose the removal of the automatic right to appeal decisions made by magistrates. This is a vital safeguard for summary justice, where lay magistrates are expected to make decisions with significant and real consequences. And on the whole, we all agree they make these decisions very well, with fewer than 1% of cases being appealed. But of those cases, the latest figures show that 56% were successful.

So we are now expecting magistrates' courts to hear more complex cases carrying higher sentences at the same time as the government is bluntly removing this protection against those miscarriages of justice.

So the government wants to speed up the process within the system, but changing the appeals process at this point is unnecessary and frankly dangerous. And the reasoning, as per their own response, is: "If we do not reform the appeals process, we expect absolute volumes of appeals to the Crown Court to increase, given the impact of other reforms to retain more cases in magistrates' court." Let's just reflect on that for a moment. Over half of current appeals are currently successful, and because they believe this number may increase, the government is satisfied to remove that. How can the minister defend a position that removes that vital safeguard in summary justice, while also accepting that the safeguard would be more needed than ever?

There is also scant provision in this bill for, or consideration of, the implications for legal representation in magistrates' court. Currently, there are differing income thresholds for legal aid between the Crown and magistrates' courts. Shifting cases from the Crown Courts will mean that many more defendants who may be accused of crimes carrying sentences of up to 24 months will be ineligible for legal aid, leaving them unrepresented. Baron Leveson in the other place reflected in his review that the differing thresholds for legal aid could be creating a perverse incentive for a defendant to choose a Crown Court, but the government have rejected Baron Leveson's recommendation in their response yesterday. Not only does this have a profound effect on fairness in our justice system, but it also affects the government's assumptions about how quickly the backlogs can be cleared, because a lack of legal aid impedes efficiency and will slow down cases.

It leaves victims and defendants waiting once again. This is why we have tabled amendment 18, which links legal aid to the severity of the sentence rather than the venue of the trial, and we have written to every member of the House asking them to support this amendment. New clause 20, tabled in my name, Madam Deputy Speaker, requires all new contracts for court-related services to include performance penalties to put an end to these sham contracts which are currently failing to deliver prisoners on time. We in the Liberal Democrats also believe that opportunities have been missed to maximise the use of time within the existing court structure. There is scope to increase the number of trials heard in selected courtrooms across England and Wales from one to two a day.

This approach was trialled during COVID, and it resulted in 3.5 trials per week being cleared, compared with fewer than 0.9 trials in courtrooms operating under standard hours. And new clause 4 calls for a review of the feasibility of hearing two trials a day in selected courtrooms, split between morning and afternoon sessions, with each trial sitting for four hours. Solutions such as this, which have not been explored by this government, as confirmed during the bill committee, would help supercharge the Crown Court process with a specific focus on clearing the backlog.

05:02:18 - 05:03:06

Jeremy Paul Wright

I'm grateful to her for giving way, and I recognise her enthusiasm for making the criminal courts work more efficiently. But can I put to her a practical problem with the solution she's proposed? If the courts were to start at 9 o'clock in the morning, especially and even worse if we weren't able to resolve the problem she identified before, which is that the prisoners aren't always brought to court on time, she will recognise that from the point of view of those of us who've represented criminal clients in the criminal court, you don't start the day at the time that court starts, you start a lot earlier. And the opportunity to speak to your client, to discuss the case properly with them, and perhaps to discuss a way of resolving the case without the need for a trial, is extremely valuable time. Does she recognise that's a problem?

05:03:06 - 05:06:46

Jess Brown-Fuller

Absolutely. I think the honourable member makes a really important point about the PECS contract and making sure that defendants are delivered to court on time. But I also recognise that not all defendants that are going into a Crown Court are being held on remand. There are also defendants who are on bail, who can get themselves, and that would be up to the listing officers to make sure that those cases are potentially heard in the mornings, which would then take off the pressure that the PECS contracts clearly have in delivering people to start at a 10:00 AM slot. Instead, those defendants might be arriving for a 2:00 PM slot in the afternoon.

But he raises an important point and gives me a lovely opportunity to explain why I have thought about that and how we would overcome that. New clause 2 supports the implementation of these courts to fast-track rape and serious sexual offences. And we have heard powerful testimony across the House during the passage of this bill about the need for rape and serious sexual offence courts, something that we also on these benches called for. It is therefore so welcome when the government announced its plans to implement them, but puzzling as to why it has not included or supported the provisions in this bill. Because there is no point in waiting.

These courts should be implemented urgently to bring an end to the disgraceful waits that these victims are facing. And the government also announced when they agreed to roll out these RASSO courts that all judges presiding over them will undergo specialist trauma-informed training. Recognising the government's decision not to include domestic abuse cases in these RASSO courts, that would surely strengthen the case for having universal specialist trauma-informed training for all of the judiciary, and that is something we've been calling for throughout all stages of this bill. New clause 11 would give victims the right to receive transcripts of all judicial summings up and bail decisions relevant to their case. And amendment 15 is particularly relevant given the direction of this bill, and it would ensure that magistrates' court transcripts are free for victims and accessible within 14 days.

Madam Deputy Speaker, on the issue of transcripts, the government has made real progress, which I welcome. Many victims choose not to attend the entirety of their hearing or trial. And even when they do attend, being able to process the events of a court case afterwards provides a valuable opportunity to better understand why those decisions were made. Transcripts being freely accessible aids in moving forward with one's life. And at every turn, the Liberal Democrats will continue to push the government to go further.

And finally, I turn to new clause 17 tabled in my name. The Courts Act 2003 introduced His Majesty's Inspectorate of Court Administration, which was established in 2005 but then closed in 2010. A 2022 Justice Select Committee report found that the argument for closing it had not stood the test of time and called for the re-establishment of an inspectorate body. Baron Leveson also recommended a mechanism to inspect HMCTS in his review, which was rejected by the government. This is a particularly important time to introduce the additional oversight that a courts inspectorate would provide, a position that is also supported by the Victims' Commissioner.

Madam Deputy Speaker, in conclusion, the government has approached this issue in the wrong way, pushing unworkable measures opposed by those working in the legal sector who have to deliver these reforms and eroding the safeguards that protect those that come into contact with the criminal justice system, be it defendants or victims. The bill we have today makes dangerous changes which will have little effect on the backlog, and it's why we in the Liberal Democrats unfortunately will not be able to support it, especially with the good clauses at the end which deal with the serious issues around presumption.

05:06:46 - 05:06:50

Speaker 243

Chair of the Justice Select Committee, Catherine Atkinson.

05:06:50 - 05:09:58

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I first put on my barrister's robes and my horsehair wig nearly 20 years ago, victims and defendants weren't commonly waiting years for trial. Victims of rape and serious sexual assault weren't seeing their cases adjourned at the last minute multiple times. And it wasn't common to see significant numbers of defendants in the magistrates' courts facing custodial sentences without lawyers representing themselves.

Years of austerity, court closures, pandemic pressures, court sitting day limits, and increasingly complex evidence have driven the Crown Court backlog to up to 80,000 cases. And removing the limits on court sitting days hasn't been enough. The backlog is still going up, and our criminal justice system remains in crisis. So I welcome that this bill is now back before the House as further action is needed. And I thank the government for responding last week to the Justice Committee's June report on this bill.

I welcome government amendment 3, which directly answers the concerns raised by the committee and members across this House regarding the proposed Crown Court bench division where a judge without a jury would have decided cases. The committee raised a number of other concerns, and I want to focus on three: the impact on magistrates' court delays, how they will determine whether cases stay with them or go to the Crown Court, and how it will impact the already too high number of people representing themselves in our criminal courts. In order to see the backlog in the Crown Court coming down in this Parliament as the government intends, reforms are to be brought forward sooner, and I want to see rapid action. But we cannot ignore the storm that is gathering in our magistrates' courts. Clause 6 doubles magistrates' sentencing powers to up to 24 months' custody, shifting significant caseloads out of the Crown Court, but we are already seeing the backlogs in our magistrates' courts climbing month on month.

Even without these reforms, the workload in the magistrates' courts over the last three years has increased by 65%. And the committee made clear that without significant additional support, our local courts will not be able to cope. It is positive that the government is confident that they're on track to meet their target of 21,000 magistrates, taking the numbers back to where they were in 2014. And I welcome additional recruitment of trainee legal advisers and district judges. But, Madam Deputy Speaker, will this be enough?

Will it happen fast enough? And do we even have enough physical courts to cope with demand when 165 magistrates' courts were closed between 2010 and 2020? I will give way.

05:09:58 - 05:10:14

Ayoub Khan

I thank the honorable member for giving way. Isn't there another problem, even if we had the capacity at the magistrates' court where trials would be taken away from the Crown Court? Isn't the elephant in the room that we don't have enough lawyers?

05:10:14 - 05:14:45

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I thank the honorable member for his intervention. And while there are some on these benches, there are many coming through the ranks, but we do need to ensure that they are going into the criminal justice system as well. And I do, I am concerned that we are not seeing enough taking that path. Accelerating reforms means accelerating the strain on our magistrates' courts. So will the minister bring forward target dates to match this accelerated timeline, and precisely what capacity will be added to the magistrates' courts before this wave of work arrives?

Removing the right to elect in either-way offenses drives an even bigger wave of work into the magistrates' courts. And I understand the government's concern that more and more defendants are electing jury trial, many exploiting the Crown Court delays, betting that victims and witnesses will tire and pull out. And I've spoken to lawyers and judges who share that frustration. But if the right to elect is removed, then the allocation guidelines that the magistrates apply in deciding whether or not defendants should face a magistrates' court or a jury trial should be reviewed.

Currently, the magistrates only send cases to the Crown Court on two narrow grounds: that sentencing will be more than they have the power to impose, or that it is too complex. The Justice Select Committee warned that this was not enough and it's too inflexible. Just three examples as to what might lead magistrates to consider it just to send to the Crown Court. One, where the defendant is of good character, with no previous convictions. Where their conviction would potentially pose exceptional hardship to others, so a single parent where custody would force their children into care.

Or where victims have justifiable reasons for also wanting a jury trial. In cases like these, limited, rigid rules fall short. And that is why I tabled amendment 69, which would grant the magistrates' court a more flexible discretion to send a case to the Crown Court whenever the interests of justice demand it. We should trust our magistrates with that judgment. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are also seeing far, far too many defendants representing themselves in the magistrates' courts because they earn too much to qualify for legal aid.

Our legal aid report found that as many as 48% of defendants appeared in 2023 without representation for imprisonable summary-only offences. And we found that today, an adult working full-time at national minimum wage may earn too much to qualify for legal aid in the magistrates' court. So we have low-paid workers walking into courtrooms without a lawyer to advise and guide them. Where they don't understand the rules, and where the consequences if they lose could mean they lose everything. Their job, their home, their family.

This may be an inherited crisis. But making it worse is a choice. Legal aid means tests are tougher in the magistrates' courts than the Crown Courts, and the government's equality assessment acknowledged that the bill could mean that defendants who currently get legal aid in the Crown Court wouldn't in the magistrates' court. Baroness Leveson and the Justice Committee called for the threshold in the magistrates' court to be increased to stop that happening. But the government's response published yesterday, as we have heard, rejected that recommendation and said that they'd only look at thresholds once the changes in the bill have been implemented.

So I have tabled amendment 70, which is based on the committee's recommendation that would require the government to increase legal aid thresholds in the magistrates' courts before the removal of the right to elect can be implemented. And I would urge the minister to consider giving us that commitment today. Because otherwise, the House is being asked to double the magistrates' sentencing powers and remove the right to elect without any reassurances defendants who cannot afford to pay privately will be legally represented. I will give way.

05:14:45 - 05:15:09

Jess Brown-Fuller

I'm confident I should just turn the page that she's probably going to also go onto the fact that at the same time the government are proposing removing the automatic right of appeal and if you have no legal background and you can't navigate a system that is totally alien to you, you're not going to know how to follow the process or know what legal backing you could have if you did have grounds for appeal.

05:15:09 - 05:15:48

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I thank the honourable member for that intervention. I am very conscious of the time that there is for this very important legislation and so I am turning the page to conclude. Madam Deputy Speaker, may I return to where I started and welcome the government's commitment to bringing down the backlog. But if we sweep the queue away from the steps of the Crown Court only to lengthen the line around the block at the local magistrates' court, we don't serve that aim.

And we will continue to fail the victims of crime and defendants alike.

05:15:48 - 05:15:54

Speaker 244

And with a five-minute time limit from after the next speaker, Sir Geoffrey Cox.

05:15:54 - 05:20:35

Geoffrey Cox

Thank you. I draw my attention, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the attention of the House to my entry in the register of members' interests. It has been a peculiar pleasure to listen to the two speeches from the benches opposite. Both the speech of the honourable member for Kingston upon Hull East and the speech, if I may say so, of the honourable lady, the chairman of the select committee for Derbyshire North, has been a treat to listen to. And I feel almost that it would be no better than I could say than to listen to both of them.

But it would be wrong of me to say that this bill is one that I would oppose in its entirety. The truth is that you can see that in its some of its provisions there are very useful and reasonable directions of travel. Personally, I don't have the profoundest objection to the appeal to the Crown Court for grounds to be given. I think that would be a reasonable thing to require, provided the honourable lady, the chairman of the select committee's warnings are heeded and that those who have to fill out that appeal are given the opportunity of advice. And as was said, I think, on these benches on this side, the problem is there's a lack of legal advisers in the magistrates' court, what we used to call magistrates' courts clerks.

And that brings me to another way in which I should commend the minister and commend the government. The initiative to drive forward an enhancement of the resources of the magistrate court can only be a good thing. The recruitment of more magistrates, which I must warn the honourable lady, we looked at years ago when I sat in the position that she sits. It's social, economic factors which are affecting the diminution and those willing and able to put themselves forward for this onerous type of public service. So it isn't going to be remediable just by brave words and advertisements.

It's going to have to be a sustained campaign and it will not happen even in the term that she will serve as minister, long may that be continued. That wasn't a wish, that was an observation, but nevertheless, it was heartfelt. But I have to say that with those cautious, cautious commendations given, I have to return to the very focus and centre of this bill. It's a bit like asking us to be grateful to the crocodile who leaves us our head after it's taken our legs. The reality is that the right of election of trial by jury is at the very heart of the right itself.

And since the 17th century, Madam Deputy Speaker, governments of colours, all colours, that have come and gone have continued to respect that as a right. Not as a concession or a privilege afforded by the state to a defendant. It is perfectly true that in Scotland that's the approach they take. In Scotland, it is the court that decides whether or not the defendant should enjoy a right of trial by jury. But in England, Madam Deputy Speaker, it has always been a right.

A right given broadly speaking to anybody accused of an offence serious enough to warrant more than 12 months' imprisonment. And for the first time in English legal and political history, a government has decided to breach that right and to make it the decision reside with the representatives of the state.

And that places out of the hands of a powerless defendant, some of the most powerless in our society. Some of them may very well be guilty. Many of them may very well be guilty, but the system that we have adopted over the centuries, Madam Deputy Speaker, does not legislate so much for the guilty but for the innocent caught up in a system. And so many examples in history have shown how the innocent can be caught up in this system. And it is for the innocent that the criminal justice system is ultimately designed, for their vindication and to require against them the level and burden and standard and the presumption of innocence which the criminal justice system enforces.

05:20:35 - 05:20:45

Speaker 245

Because time is short, I will give way to the honourable lady, right honourable lady, honourable lady, but only she, but only she.

05:20:45 - 05:21:15

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

As I keep saying, always. The what he is saying about it the system being designed for the innocent is very compelling. The system is absolutely not designed for the person who is absolutely innocent in the system, and that is the victim. No part of the system asks them to be able to elect where the trial might go. No part of the system asks them if they think it should be appealed.

The innocent, actually, the real innocent, the definitely innocent, gets no say.

05:21:15 - 05:26:40

Geoffrey Cox

Well, that invites a long answer which I haven't got time now to give, but any defendant who appears before a court enjoys the presumption of innocence, and it's upon that basis that any system has to proceed. And if you in England, the right has been accorded to those who have this presumption, who enjoy this presumption of innocence, to decide where they should be tried. And the moment it is taken for an offence that carries above 12 months imprisonment, and any abrogation of that right removes the power from the individual and hands it to the state. And in England, peculiarly in England, it has always been regarded as the right of a defendant. And make no mistake, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is an historic bill for this reason: to remove and abrogate the right of an election to trial by jury of your peers has exactly the effect that the honourable member from Kingston upon Hull East has said.

A person of good character, a professional person, an employee in the workplace accused of theft from his employer, all of these would have had the right to say, "No, I wish to have the careful and meticulous process that the Crown Court provides, not a swift and summary justice that the magistrates' court provides." And yet that person may suffer for the remaining years of their life the most profound impact upon their history. A member of this House accused, tried before the magistrates' court despite the impact and consequences that that might produce. And yet in the magistrates' court their only criteria will be, "Might it receive more than two years?" Many such offences would not of imprisonment, and that is broadly the criteria that's applied by the magistrates.

And so I strongly support, if this egregious act is to be taken by this House, then I strongly support that the chairman of the select committee's recommendation is taken on board by the minister.

Because it is only if the magistrates have the express ability to consider if you are of good character, if you have a profession, if it would mean you'd be disqualified forever from whatever profession it is you are in, or expelled from your work in your employment, massive implications for the rest of your life. Unless the magistrates are able to take that into account, how can it be fair or proper to impose upon them a system of summary justice that does not at its heart, is not able to achieve the kind of levels of fairness that a Crown Court trial does, not only because legal aid is available, but because of the kind of forensic scrutiny the allegation is placed under. And that is why the automatic right of appeal has always been provided even where the sentence would be less than 12 months. Because it has always been acknowledged that the kind of justice distributed in the magistrates' court is necessarily swift and necessarily summary. There are not the provisions for the disclosure of unused material.

What is to be done about those if offences are now going to be tried that might carry a two-year imprisonment? None of these things have yet been thought through within this bill. There has simply been a transference from the Crown to the magistrates' courts in breach of a provision and a right that has been respected in this country for 300 years. So I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, listen to the right hon. to the member for Kingston and Hull East. Listen to the honorable lady, the chairman of the select committee from Derby North.

They spoke the milk of human wisdom, and I suspect the fact that it came from them, I suspect the fact that it came from them is not wholly wholly unrelated to the fact that each of them have years of experience in professional practice in the courts. Heed them, I urge the minister, even if she is to take the step that I profoundly oppose and regard as being an historic mistake, the abrogation and dilution of the right to trial by jury, no longer making it a right but a but a concession made by the state to the individual. But if that is what she's going to do, then please listen, I urge her, to the to the recommendations and warnings given by her own side. For to be to have before you somebody for the first time before a court facing a two-year sentence of imprisonment of good character and the magistrates unable to consider such a factor would be the profoundest injustice in many cases and risks over the coming years all those appalling, wearisome, grievous experiences of realizing that injustice has actually been done and the whole system that we have devised over the centuries has been designed to avoid that at all costs.

05:26:40 - 05:26:41

Yasmin Qureshi.

05:26:41 - 05:31:28

Yasmin Qureshi

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm coming to this debate from experience. I spent 15 years as a prosecutor and during that time, I was designated as a sexual abuse prosecutor, so that meant I dealt with a lot of cases to do with sexual abuse and of course domestic violence and others. I also then defended as well, both in the in the magistrates' court as well as obviously in the Crown Court. And I welcome the government's decision to get rid of clause 3.

I also welcome the government's decision to introduce the Reso court and the money that's going to go with it to make sure it happens.

So, I'm very grateful for the fact that the government has listened. But the central plank of my argument, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that it seems that somehow restricting jury trials is the panacea to solving the court backlogs, both in the magistrates' court as well as in the crown court. And that, with respect, is not the case. The reason we have a backlog, both in the magistrates' court and in the crown court, are virtually identical. Firstly, COVID played a massive part in it, but so did court closures in the magistrates' court as well as in the crown court.

Judicial sitting days being cut massively in the crown court, and of course not enough justices, enough courtrooms being sitting in the magistrates' court as well, because we have a record shortage of lay magistrates as well. In addition, the cuts in legal aid to defendants, both in the magistrates' court and the crown court, has caused problems in that quite often in the crown court, defendants don't get to know what they're doing until they have sorted out their moneys and then they can get legal advice from lawyers. And in the magistrates' court, a lot of people attend who are not represented. At the same time, and we must not forget the fact that the police and other bodies in the criminal justice system have also caused delays in the sense that evidence is not ready when trials start, especially unused material, forensic evidence. Quite often, pleas have not been discussed.

And I know even now, a lot of lawyers who are in court find that on the day of the trial, they find there's gaping holes in evidence. And that is something we don't talk about. Therefore, there is a capacity issue in other parts of the criminal justice system which all must be fulfilled as well. And of course, the prison services, the people who produce defendants to courts, have also had a problem because quite often defendants don't get produced in time, which then impacts on trials and they get adjourned to other days. So the backlog is caused by these factors and not because on either-way offences, defendants have been electing a crown court trial.

So what I would say is that the government has started right. They've spent money on having more judicial days sitting. I would ask them to go further to have even more sitting days, open up even more courtrooms, both in the magistrates' court and in the crown court, and of course ensure there's proper legal provision for everyone. And of course the other things I mentioned. I think these things together will bring the court backlogs down.

The other thing that I'm concerned about is in this bill, however, and this has been discussed by others previously, that if you are convicted in the magistrates' court, at the moment you have automatic right of appeal against a sentence and a conviction. Most people who appear in the magistrates' court are unrepresented. And if you need, as the bill currently states, that you need to make a reasoned argument to the judge to get permission, leave to appeal, there's no way an ordinary lay person is going to be able to draft those complicated legal arguments to justify why their conviction or sentence should be taken further, especially when it comes to a conviction. I know if I had to draft grounds for appeal, it would take me hours and days. And so I can't imagine an ordinary person being able to do that because they'll have to say, well, fundamentally you're wrong in so many aspects.

So I would say that again, because of that, we have an unfairness taking place, will take place in the magistrates' court if those people were not given their right. And we've heard that 56% of the cases, people are successful as well. So it's a system that's there for a purpose and it helps. Now, coming back to the Nightingale courts as well. I know it's been talked and some of my colleagues have talked about the victims.

Of course we all believe to protect the victim. But as the honourable member for Warrington North herself said—

05:31:28 - 05:31:32

Speaker 247

Order, order. Sir Andrew Mitchell.

05:31:32 - 05:31:34

Speaker 246

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to draw the House's attention to new clause 22, which I have tabled together with the honourable lady for Yardley, my parliamentary neighbour, whose absence from the front bench—

05:31:41 - 05:31:45

Speaker 252

Order, order. Sir Andrew Mitchell.

05:31:45 - 05:36:48

Andrew Mitchell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to draw the House's attention to new clause 22, which I have tabled together with the honourable lady for Yardley, my parliamentary neighbour, whose absence from the front bench is a matter of regret to all of us on these benches. I should also like to thank both the Lord Chancellor and the shadow Lord Chancellor for engaging with us on these issues. And the new clause to which I refer would restrict immunity from civil suit for police officers in relation to certain conduct in preparation for criminal court proceedings. I want to draw the House's attention to the deeply troubling development in our law.

Last year, the Court of Appeal handed down a judgment that in my view risks placing police forces beyond proper accountability for serious wrongdoing committed during the preparation of criminal cases. If left unaddressed, this new legal principle could make it far harder for victims of police misconduct to obtain justice, even where the harm they have suffered is severe and life-changing. This doctrine has been described as a form of police misconduct immunity. We all know that the rule of law depends on a simple principle: no one is above the law, not politicians, not public officials, and not the police. That is why the amendment I have tabled together with the honourable member for Yardley would restore accountability and make clear that there cannot be one rule for the police and another for everyone else.

The issue arises directly from the 2025 Court of Appeal case, Chief Constable of Sussex Police and CPS versus XGY. And I know that the honourable lady is going to refer to case, the case of XGY when she comes to speak if she catches your eye. She was forced to flee again, having had the address given, the victim of the abuse who gave her confidential address refuge to the Sussex Police, and that address was later disclosed in court, exposing her location to the abuser. The Court of Appeal answered the question by extending what is known as core immunity. Historically, this immunity was narrow, but existed to protect witnesses and advocates for what they say and do in court, allowing them to give evidence freely without fear of being sued.

But the court's judgment went much further. It expanded that protection beyond the courtroom and into the wider process of criminal investigation and prosecution preparation. In practical terms, it means that certain police actions connected to a future prosecution may now be shielded from legal challenge, even where those actions cause significant harm. The court's ruling therefore raises serious concerns about whether victims will be able to seek redress when police misconduct, negligence, human rights breaches, or serious errors occur. These were grave crimes.

And that is why this case matters far beyond the individual victims involved. At the time, I was engaged as Secretary of State for International Development in the government's response to the kidnapping through COBRA. I want to illustrate the practical consequences of this doctrine and the human cost through another case with which I have been closely involved for some years. But we now know that Ali Kolo was innocent. That is the case of Ali Kolo.

A Kenyan court has since overturned his conviction. The evidence showed that he had become a scapegoat in a deeply flawed investigation. And what makes this case particularly troubling is that the Metropolitan Police played a significant role in supporting that investigation. An Independent Office for Police Conduct found that a senior Metropolitan Police officer had a case to answer for gross misconduct. The investigation concluded that the evidence provided by the officer had the potential to mislead the court beyond because important forensic information had been omitted.

The consequences for Mr. Kololo were catastrophic. He spent 11 years in prison. He faced a death sentence. He endured abuse, illness, and separation from his family. He lost years of his life that can never be returned.

Although his conviction was eventually quashed and he was released, he has yet to receive redress for the harm that he suffered. Let me be clear. The original principle of witness immunity serves an important purpose. Witnesses should be able to give evidence without fear of personal litigation. Our justice system depends upon that protection.

But extending immunity far beyond the courtroom and into the wider conduct of criminal investigations risks creating an accountability gap. This is not healthy.

05:36:48 - 05:36:51

Speaker 255

Order. Dr. Marie Tipple.

05:36:51 - 05:43:06

Marie Tidball

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Clause 17 of the Bill, Jack and Paul's Law, fulfills my constituent Claire Throssell's promise to her two beautiful boys after they were killed in a house fire set alight by their known domestically abusive father during a court-ordered contact visit. Claire promised her sons that no more children should lose their lives like they did at the hands of an abusive parent. For nearly 12 years, she has campaigned relentlessly to honor that promise. When I first met Claire, I told her that if I was elected, I would do all I could to help her fulfill that promise.

So it is a pleasure to have her in the chamber with us today. Colleagues across the House, I urge you to support this Bill and ensure no more children die like Claire's sons did, and that no more towns like our hometown of Penistone will be left to grieve. Clause 17 will put repeal the presumption of parental involvement in the Children Act 1989, with our government putting children's best interests first and tackling the pro-contact culture which prioritizes parental involvement over children's welfare. This is urgent. Domestic abuse continues to be everyday business in the family court, featuring in 90% of the cases reviewed by the Domestic Abuse Commissioner in 2025.

Being a parent is a privilege, not a right, and when a parent poses a serious risk to a child, the law must act. And yet, Conservative governments had a decade to act after the tragic murder of Claire's boys and her campaign to change the law. But I will give way.

I thank her for giving way. I would just like to ask whether she agrees with me that it is staggering that the Shadow Minister didn't even mention an amendment that has been tabled with his name attached to it in his opening remarks.

I do indeed agree with the honorable lady, because the Tories failed to act while they were in government, despite the fact that it was a Conservative government that commissioned the Harm Report published in 2020, which stated that presumption should not remain in its present form and recommended addressing its detrimental effects.

The report specifically said that the court pro-contact culture operates as a barrier addressing domestic abuse with presumption reinforcing that culture and children's voices being muted or unheard, leaving children invisible and silent like those referred to only as child A or B in serious case reviews. But Conservative governments did nothing with the retention of presumption continuing to be fatal. Since Jack and Paul's murders in 2014, 19 more children that we know of have died at the hands of known domestically abusive parents, including Sarah Sharif. This makes a total of 68 child homicides since Women's Aid started researching this issue. And yet today, the Conservatives have the audacity to attempt to remove Jack and Paul's law from this bill with their amendment 67.

The audacity to ignore a report their previous government commissioned and table this amendment after the inaction of no less than five Conservative Prime Ministers. I will not stand for it. Claire Throssell, my fearless constituent, will not stand for it. The people of Penistone and Stocksbridge, so many of whom have stood behind Claire and held her up, will not stand for it. I ask this house to show that it will not stand for it either.

That it will vote to finally repeal the presumption of contact in law to demonstrate that this house believes that every decision this government makes in the family courts and justice system must prioritize children's safety, wellbeing and their right to grow up free from harm. At the heart of Jack and Paul's law is a simple principle: a child's safety must always come first. As the Minister for Victims has said, removing the presumption of parental involvement will mean courts approach every case based on what is based on what is best for that individual child. Where a parent poses a risk, courts will continue to be able to restrict their involvement. Children have a right to live free from harm.

Claire's loss was the ultimate loss for any parent, but the violence which ended with Jack and Paul being murdered by her ex-husband had started with his violence against her. Other measures in this bill will cumulatively act as a shield and a sword for victims like Claire. Two years ago in my Westminster Hall debate on presumption, I implored the courts minister to let us not just imagine a world where the voices of children are put at the heart of our family court system, but also to legislate for it. So that children such as Jack and Paul are listened to, not ignored, for a world where childhood is free from fear and oppression and where they live the lives they deserve to live. That minister listened.

Today, we have the opportunity to vote for this clause and this bill so we no longer need to imagine that world but make it a reality.

05:43:06 - 05:43:07

Sarah Champion.

05:43:07 - 05:44:46

Speaker 213

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I make my contribution this afternoon as someone who served as a magistrate for 20 years. I am deeply concerned about increasing the magistrate's sentencing powers to two years of custody. This must be accompanied by rigorous training because in reality you get good and bad, experienced and inexperienced magistrate benches. And for a lay person to remove the liberty of another is one of the biggest decisions you can make.

I'm also concerned about the presumption of suspension on all custodial sentences of up to 12 months.

That's what it says in the guidelines, however in training they are currently, magistrates are currently being told of a presumption of up to 18, of sentences of up to 18 months. Punishment should not be dumbed down because of insufficient prison places. Furthermore, the government is leaving the requirements of the community orders in the hands of probation. How can they be qualified to do this when they are not trained to do so like the magistrates? Even more troubling is the fact that the probation service is being given the powers to cancel the community orders if they feel that the offender has sufficiently been rehabilitated.

At a time when the probation service has never been so overwhelmed and underfunded. Both the policies of presumptive suspension of sentences and removing the magistrates' powers to decide on community orders betray justice for victims. Thank you.

05:44:46 - 05:44:47

Jess Phillips.

05:44:47 - 05:49:49

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise, there's so many things in this bill that I could rise to talk about, but I shall start by following up where my right honourable friend from the royal town of Sutton Coldfield, I'm from the royal town of Birmingham Yardley, left off. And I suppose to just get members to understand what we are seeking to change and clarify in the law really that has changed is that when we are in here we don't get sued for the things that we say. But until I walk into this building and all the work that I am doing before, anything I say, I wouldn't say it on X because I wouldn't go on it. But like I can be held accountable for my work, I can, civil actions could be taken against me for work that leads up to it.

And what the judgment that my honourable friend has talked about has meant is that in cases where police are making or the CPS are making mistakes in all the time that leads up to them entering into that courtroom, of course they should have immunity like any witness does. But that immunity cannot cover them against civil action for everything that happened in the case. If I had a pound for every time I have seen terrible mistakes made by police officers or the CPS, well, I could get rid of your backlog. Not your backlog, Madam Deputy Speaker, the nation's. I just want to be really clear about how dangerous the sort of the overreach of the court decision to allow this immunity would have and to lean on some cases that I know have affected the front bench to change the law.

And these were legal cases taken by victims of rape and domestic abuse and other forms of sexual violence that have now changed the laws of our land. They were based on civil actions taken by those victims against police and CPS, such as Jade Blue, the survivor of rape who waived her anonymity and brought a claim against the CPS after they made an erroneous decision to discontinue the proceedings against her abuser. The consequence of Jade's civil action and campaign and her successful claim against the CPS, which could be threatened by this new overreach in the law, which I hope the front bench will tell us how they intend to sort out, is that in a prior bill that the minister has spoken to, we the government have rolled out the early victims' right to review scheme on the basis of a civil action taken by a rape victim.

If we do not allow for victims of domestic abuse and sexual violence, who, for example, or any victim actually, or anyone frankly, who is treated poorly by the police and the CPS, to take civil action against them, we are missing the opportunity in this place to make the laws that are better, as well as just it's a deeply, frankly, if I can be held accountable, so should a copper, and so should the CPS. And so I understand there is a Supreme Court judgment awaiting, but I would be interested to hear what the front bench can say to allay the fears of victims of domestic abuse and sexual violence all over the country who might have their address given out wrongly and then have no recourse to civil action for the danger that they have been put in, for example. So I would be interested to hear that. I just want to make, I mean, I the powerful speech by my honorable friend and the years of working myself with Claire Russell, I find it, I find it a tiny bit as the shadow minister has stood up and tried to say that victims' groups all think don't all think the same about the jury part of this bill. I can tell him now that victims' group all think the same thing about the presumption of contact.

And the fact that he didn't even mention it in his remarks that he has laid an amendment that would really genuinely endanger victims of domestic abuse across our country, I think is, I think it, well, I don't ever know what I'm allowed to say and what I'm not allowed to say, but I think it's a bit cowardly. Should have stood by his words and argued the case. I would also like to say just on a final point, that as a victim who has been redragged back to court on a completely unmeritorious appeal case by people who stalk me so that they can get me in another room, I feel pleased by the changes and that I so often in these debates think that this building thinks that the very worst thing that could ever happen to a person was for them to be accused of rape. I think that worst thing that can ever happen to you is that you are raped and no one believes you.

05:49:49 - 05:49:50

Dr. Neil Shastri-Hurst.

05:49:50 - 05:51:46

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I draw the House's attention to the fact that I'm a member of the Bar of England and Wales and my wife is an employment judge. Notwithstanding some noble and commendable elements of this bill, particularly in clauses 12 through to 17, in its totality, I'm afraid this is a bad bill. It was a bad bill when it came before the House for second reading, it was a bad bill when it left committee stage, and without significant refinement, it will be a bad piece of law should it come onto the statute books. Of course, this is not the Lord Chancellor's legislation, this was inherited by him from his predecessor, and I think it is right to welcome, it would be churlish not to, the efforts that he has put forward around government amendment 3 to recognize that clause 3 is unsustainable. He has listened to the legal profession, he's listened to this House, and most importantly, he has listened to the public who raised serious and significant concerns.

But I'm afraid it does not go far enough, Madam Deputy Speaker, because if this bill is the answer, then the exam question is fundamentally wrong. And that can be no clearer than in clause 6, and that is why I'm very supportive of amendment 7 in the name of my honorable friend, the member for Bexhill and Battle, which seeks to remove clause 6, because as we have heard already, this merely moves the problem from one part of the system to another. It pushes, I think on a conservative basis, some 25,000 cases into the magistrates' court, about 5,500 of those are likely to be trials. These are not necessarily straightforward trials, these are trials that may take more than a day or two, if not longer to be heard, and we're asking an under-resourced and ill-equipped magistrates' court to deal with them. That is not the way to deal with the backlog that in the last year in the magistrates' court raised by more than 9.5%.

05:51:46 - 05:51:47

I will give way.

05:51:47 - 05:52:17

Speaker 261

Grateful to the honourable gentleman for giving way. I think I'm right in saying that a lay magistrate is required to sit 15 days a year as a lay magistrate. Very often, magistrates can sit for a day at a time, a day every other week. The scenario which the government presents is expecting a lay magistrate to sit for a day, two days, three days, potentially into a second week. Does he agree that's unsustainable?

05:52:17 - 05:56:09

Neil Shastri-Hurst

My honourable friend, the honourable member, as always has his finger on the pulse on these issues, because of course it narrows the pool of potential magistrates who are able to deal with these cases by virtue of the time commitments that would be foisted upon them. I want to spend a little bit of time in respect of clause 4, because this deals with complex and lengthy cases. What in essence it does through schedule 3ZA is confine these to fraud or fraud-aligned cases. However, importantly, there is a provision that the Secretary of State can increase the number of offences that are contained within this particular provision. The danger of that is that there is a slow accretion of the offences that would be encapsulated by it.

It is not beyond the realms of possibility, for example, that misconduct in a public office could be added to that list. And it fails to recognise the very important work that was done by Jonathan Fisher KC in his independent review, who pointed out that these cases are not held up because of a jury, they would be delayed because a judge has to weigh up the evidence, has to consider it, write up a judgment and reach it. It also fundamentally undermines the issue that facts of dishonesty, and these are as set out in the schedule cases around dishonesty, are matters for judgment by the ordinary citizen. And to remove the jury element risks the civic ownership of these cases and their engagement within the criminal justice system to be eroded. It also has the chilling effect that you can develop a powerful narrative around powerful defendants that these cases are being heard behind closed doors.

And it stems from a single case, it stems from a single case from 2005, the Jubilee Line case, which when reviewed came down to the very sensible conclusion this was down to the poor strategy of the CPS in the process of the case and not down to jury trials themselves. And therefore amendment 4 again tabled in the name of my honourable friend the member for Bexhill and Battle is eminently sensible. If the House is not with me on that, however, there is an alternative which is amendment 52 by my honourable friend the member for West Suffolk, the Shadow Justice Secretary, which seeks to limit the scope of this provision to trials where all the offences a defendant is charged in are those that are captured by schedule 3ZA. That seems eminently sensible in those circumstances. I want to just mention for a moment the rule of law, because if the rule of law is to be taken into account, it must mean that we have an impartial system of adjudication.

And that in turn means a fair hearing, which in turn must mean there is the ability to challenge. And therefore amendment 54 must be right. It must be right that in complex or lengthy cases, a defendant has an opportunity to challenge the decision that the case is not to be heard by a judge sitting alone.

In the short time I have remaining, I just want to spend a few moments on new clause 25. This bill was brought before the House on the proviso, the narrative that we heard coming out from government repeatedly, was that this was to deal with the backlog in the Crown Court. It appears from the remarks of the Minister, who knows I have enormous respect for her, that this is more of an ideological argument. So the question today is whether members of this House want to do this to deal with a backlog, a specific problem, in which case a sunset clause is entirely and eminently sensible, or are we making an ideological argument that I think is much more chilling on our society.

05:56:09 - 05:59:02

Marie Tidball

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am speaking today as a victim of domestic abuse who has found going through the court system especially triggering, and on behalf of constituents who have shared their harrowing experiences with me. One who wrote to me and said that the system still allows a father to weaponize the child, to throw accusations whilst protecting his position, while none of the issues I raised got any acknowledgment. And another who felt that the process itself has repeatedly failed to meet the standards expected of our justice and child protection systems. I'm going to start by looking at new clause 6 on victim-led intensive case management, and I'd like to stress that this is an issue across all courts.

Recent experience of the court is that special measures are still not being properly implemented. A lack of common sense approach communication is a problem still in 2026, when great technological advances have been made. And I'd like to commend the member for Chichester on her many amendments seeking to improve experiences for victims, namely on judicial training as outlined in her new clauses 7 to 9. And I'd like to also stress that it should be all members of the judiciary always who have to access training. And in fact, that they should have to hear from victim survivors firsthand of what their experiences are like as part of that training, because it doesn't matter how many times somebody tells me that they understand what I've gone through or that they acknowledge what I've been through, they really don't unless they have lived it themselves or they know somebody who has.

The phrase trauma-informed is incredibly powerful and crucial here, and it should always be trauma-informed training, which brings me on to new clause 13 and the duty to provide trauma-informed training, which I also think needs to include looking at the way that we communicate what will happen in court with victims, as well as the impact those proceedings will have on victims themselves. And I'd like to take this opportunity to point out that there are severe issues around diversity and representation across all levels of the judiciary, and I'd be interested to hear more about what our government is doing to ensure better representation. New clause 16 looks at remote participation, and as someone who has been through this very recently as a victim, we absolutely need to include an assessment into special measures here as well, and look at whether these are adequately communicated to victims. In my case, they were not. I experienced an online hearing recently where I had my perpetrator staring at me the entire time.

I wasn't able to blur the background on my screen, and I wasn't able to hide his face. And then the hearing was adjourned because the relevant documents didn't reach the right parties on time, despite the fact that email exists and has done for some time. I will give way.

05:59:02 - 05:59:39

Jess Brown-Fuller

I thank the honorable member, one for her bravery in standing up today and sharing her really powerful story, but also highlighting that special measures doesn't work if people don't know that it's available to them. During the Bill Committee, I made the argument that special measures should be the standard, and then if somebody chooses to face their perpetrator in court, they can absolutely ask for those things to be removed, but they should just be there as a standard. Does she agree with me that that's something that we could very easily roll out across all of our courts, but it would mean that every victim is protected from the moment they arrive?

05:59:39 - 06:02:38

Marie Tidball

I thank her for that intervention and I do absolutely agree. I think that should be looked at as being a standard measure. I did ask for special measures, but when I turned up at court, they weren't implemented, so I had to walk past my perpetrator before going into the courtroom. And that's what I'm experiencing as a Member of Parliament. I dread to think what, well I do know what some of my constituents are experiencing.

On New Clause 24, I'd like to commend my honourable friend the Member for Scarborough and Whitby for ensuring children's voices and views are enshrined in the family courts. I know Women's Aid are here, as well as the formidable Claire Throssell, and I'd like to commend my incredible friend the Member for Penistone and Stocksbridge as well on her tireless efforts in making this happen. The pro-contact culture is embedded into the court system and it puts too many children at unnecessary risk, and I'm really, really pleased to see that the Government is removing this. I'm also pleased to see my honourable friend the Member for Calder Valley has addressed the issue of post-separation abuse in the form of his amendment and how the courts have facilitated that, and I'd like to thank him for being a strong ally and for standing up for his constituents. He and I have both experienced a deluge of constituents contacting us about the abuse that they are facing and their experiences of the court system, and it is always good to have his support.

I'm really grateful that this Government is taking steps to go further for victims by introducing the victims' helpline, addressing the issue of the automatic right to appeal so that victims are not re-traumatised, and the establishment of specialist RASSO courts. But I did want to put on record my experiences as a victim and those of my constituents to ensure that the system truly supports all victims, that it ensures victims are genuinely heard, properly communicated with, that they know what their rights are and what is available to them, and that we are all shielded from further triggering and traumatic experiences involving our abusers. Because, Madam Deputy Speaker, I am fed up of people and institutions telling me that they understand and then going on to take action that tells me that they don't. I'm fed up being told that they are familiar with domestic abuse or coercive control, but then telling me that it actually doesn't matter. I'm fed up of feeling ignored and dismissed, and so are my constituents.

Our justice system exists to protect victims, not enable perpetrators, and we should always, always remember that. And we are still allowing our perceptions about how good a person looks on paper to cloud our judgments. Madam Deputy Speaker, perpetrators walk amongst us. They are police officers, they are teachers, they are fathers, they are mothers. They are here in every aspect of our daily lives, and we cannot judge somebody because of how good they look on paper and give them the benefit of the doubt because of that.

We have to look at the facts, we have to ensure victims are heard, and we absolutely crucially need to make sure that their voices are put at the heart of every decision that we make and that they are properly and adequately supported at every single step of the way. Thank you.

06:02:38 - 06:05:41

Ashley Peter Fox

And with an immediate three-minute time limit, Sir Ashley Fox.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to start by expressing my relief that the Government has removed Clause 3 from the Bill. I congratulate the Lord Chancellor for performing this U-turn so swiftly upon taking office. Now, in earlier debates on this Bill, the Courts Minister said that curtailing the right to a jury trial was a good thing in any event, and that she would go ahead with the change even if there wasn't a court backlog. So what caused her to change her mind? Perhaps, Madam Deputy Speaker, it was the change of Prime Minister.

Now, the honourable lady is a skilled orator. I'm quite sure she will manage to persuade the Lord Chancellor that she meant something completely different, that she always supported his position, and her rise through the ranks of Government will continue.

We on these benches wish her well. The Crown Court backlog is a serious challenge and both victims and defendants deserve timely justice. Throughout this debate, ministers have struggled to demonstrate that curtailing jury trials would meaningfully solve the problem. I still have concerns about clauses 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7 of this bill, which serve to add restrictions to jury trials and transfer more power to magistrates' courts. That is why I support new clause 25, tabled by my honourable friend the Shadow Justice Secretary, which seeks to put a sunset clause in this bill.

This would see those remaining restrictions on jury trials proposed by the government ending when the backlog is reduced to its pre-COVID level. I would urge the government to be cautious about the expansion of the powers of magistrates. The evidence is not clear that this will result in the reduction of the backlog. Where is the assurance that increased jurisdiction will not simply create new delays in different courts? Thousands of additional magistrates will be required in the coming year, yet previous recruitment efforts have failed.

What will be different this time? The Justice Select Committee described these targets as unrealistic, so perhaps the minister should consult her new Solicitor General and ask what his views on the subject are. The government still intends to remove the right to a jury trial for those charged with an either-way offence. I oppose that, and I support amendment 1 proposed by the Shadow Justice Secretary. This poses a particularly grave threat to those who would face professional ruin if they were convicted of an offence of dishonesty.

Solicitors, barristers, members of Parliament, for example, would all have their careers destroyed were they convicted of theft, which is an either-way offence. So that is why I support the sentiments between amendment 47 proposed by the member for Kingston upon Hull East and amendment 69 proposed by the chair of the Select Committee. I appreciate that we will not be voting on those amendments tonight, but I do hope that members of the House of Lords will look at this issue again when they come to consider the bill.

06:05:42 - 06:06:27

Lee Baron

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, just to raise three issues. As a magistrate for 20 years, I think one of the things that's led to the problems has been the closure of so many courts across the estate. And one of the things I think need to be involved in the mix of this is to potentially reopen some of those sites in order to be able to get the magistrates' courts up and running. In terms of the right to elect a court, I mean, I don't, I was opposed to clause 3 as most will know, and the minister will know, but I never got, it wasn't a red line for me in relation to electing what court people or the right to elect. And the reason that it didn't is in Scotland it doesn't happen.

06:06:27 - 06:07:11

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

I don't see their constitutional skies falling in upon their system. So to me, it wasn't really the issue that I was going to, as I say, have a red line around. But I do want to raise an issue, Madam Deputy Speaker, if I may, in relation to some changes I'd like to see in relation to the victim contact scheme. At the moment, at present, the victim contact scheme doesn't allow victims to be advised of whether or not an offender has changed their name or whether or not an offender has changed their appearance. So it's not the information which is routinely shared with victims because it's considered to be sensitive personal data and means that there is a presumption that it will not be disclosed and there is lawful reason to do so.

06:07:11 - 06:07:30

Lee Baron

Well, take the Heslip family for instance. In 2003, Mick Heslip was violently murdered in his home in Corby. Ricky Stewart was convicted of the murder and received a mandatory life sentence. When he was released in July 2024, he'd changed his name to Rory Wilson.

06:07:30 - 06:07:59

Rebecca Smith

Nobody informed the family of that. The family were absolutely unaware that he had changed his name. The omission, they say, has undermined their ability to understand movements, monitor their own safety, and engage meaningfully with the victim contact scheme. In addition to that, in 1986, Adam Stein murdered six-year-old Colette Gallagher. He was, he has changed his appearance and his name multiple times.

06:07:59 - 06:08:47

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

And Colette's youngest sisters, Lauren and Claire, fear for their own safety if he's ever granted parole again. Don't know what he looks like, don't know what his name is, family not aware. These people are living in plain sight, and I think that's a loophole that we need to close in order to make sure that we remove the presumption that it won't be disclosed to the presumption that it will be, so that families know. Because if you put the shoe on the other foot, Izzy was murdered by her husband as their two young daughters slept in the room next door. Izzy's mum, Helena Sharrott, was granted special guardianship order.

There's a request then to change the children's names. They've said no because the father who murdered the mother has had a say in it. That is wrong, that is unjust, and we need to change it.

06:08:47 - 06:08:48

Rebecca Smith.

06:08:48 - 06:09:31

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Clause 17 would repeal the presumption of parental involvement contained in section 1(2A) of the Children Act 1989. That presumption currently provides that unless the contrary is shown, the involvement of each parent in the life of the child will further the child's welfare. Now, amendment 67 in the name of my honourable friends would keep the presumption that parental involvement is beneficial for the welfare of the child. It's my belief that our legal system should reflect the fact that in most cases, a child benefits from having both parents involved in their life.

06:09:31 - 06:10:01

Marie Tidball

Clause 17 would do the opposite. It sends a serious social signal that the active involvement of both parents is no longer our expected starting point when considering a child's welfare. Yes, I just wanted to finish my sentence.

Does the honourable member not agree with the harm report commissioned by her own government, which found on the basis of the evidence that in fact this presumption creates a pro-contact culture, which means that the voices of children are hidden and unheard, and the evidence from Women's Aid demonstrates that 68 children have lost their lives because of the presumption?

06:10:01 - 06:10:17

Rebecca Smith

I thank the honourable lady for her intervention and for her powerful speech earlier. But ultimately, the impact assessment for this bill says that there would be no impact, and I believe that the impact on families more broadly is not worth the change in this. Yes, I will.

06:10:17 - 06:10:38

John Kieran Mullan

As the member's pointed out, as she said, the impact assessment says that this particular measure on its own won't make any difference to the harm of children. That's what the impact assessment says. But we absolutely recognise that as a whole, the checklist and the way in which this is working does need to be reformed, but we think a more wholesale reform of the checklist is more appropriate than just attracting interest in one particular element of it.

06:10:38 - 06:13:04

Rebecca Smith

Exactly, and I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. Because my concern is that in some cases, this clause would increase the state's power to erase one parent from a child's life, and we know that that is often their father. Clause 17 rebalances the relationship between parents and the state. No, I've already given way twice, I'll lose time. I won't have any, I won't get any more time, I'm very sorry.

We must avoid a situation where the law views children as the state's ultimate responsibility, whilst parents must justify their involvement on a case-by-case basis. And we must also avoid anything that presumes that the state makes a good or better parent than the actual parents themselves. All that to say, of course the state should intervene when a child is at risk. But our default position should be that wherever it is safe and appropriate, children benefit from the love and guidance of both of their parents. The state should only step in when there is clear evidence to do so, and we're not refuting that point this evening.

If we remove this principle from the law, we take another step towards a system in which parental involvement becomes discretionary and the state's role becomes paramount. And I do not believe that this is a healthy direction for family justice. I recognise of course that this is a sensitive issue for survivors of domestic abuse.

To be clear, there is no absolute right to contact under existing law. Courts already have the power to restrict unsafe contact. The presumption of parental involvement is already qualified by risk of harm to the child. So why do we need this clause at all? Surely we should be ensuring together across this House that current safeguards work properly instead.

As I said in a recent debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, on fathers and male role models, there is already a widespread perception that family courts make it difficult for fathers to maintain a meaningful relationship with their children. One possible solution would be a child-centered parental relationship test. This test would direct courts to consider the quality and sustainability of the child's relationship with each parent. It would help courts distinguish between safe contact and harmful contact. As things stand, there is a real risk that Clause 17 will weaken, not strengthen, children's relationships with safe parents without addressing the current failures that leave children exposed to their unsafe ones.

06:13:04 - 06:13:15

Speaker 268

Fundamentally, parental involvement is a relationship recognized by the state, not a privilege granted by the state. Both parents matter, and we should not be afraid to say it.

06:13:15 - 06:13:16

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

06:13:16 - 06:15:54

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to address my remarks to Clause 17 on the presumption of contact. Now, my involvement in this started with a letter from a constituency, a mother trying to protect her child from an abusive ex-partner. And in these cases, the court can play a role in re-traumatizing people and even be a tool of that abuse. Since I first spoke out about it, I've heard from countless victims, and I want to say to them, thank you for telling your story.

Sorry that the justice system has failed you for so long. We will make progress, and we will not allow the opposition to ignore your lived experience and the hard evidence that has been given to us by people who work on the front line. I want to pay tribute to Claire Throssell in the gallery today. Her boys, Jack and Paul, were killed by her abusive ex-partner in horrific circumstances. No mother should have had to have shown the strength that Claire has shown.

But she's changed the law, and she's saved lives, and I will vote today to make sure that the opposition do not block this legacy. The presumption of parental involvement is so damaging because it's allowed abuse to continue through the courts. Safety of children must always be the top priority. Over the past 30 years, 68 children have died because the presumption of involvement was applied when it never should have been. That's 68 children who should have grown up, but their lives were taken from them.

I am proud that this bill will ensure that that terrible number never rises again. But changing the law can only be the start. Judges, magistrates, and Cafcass operators operate within the pro-contact culture that has been set by the laws we have at the moment. The Judicial College must take that on board. In the almost two years I've been working on this, the worst opinion I have heard has been from a family magistrate who told me about his friend's experience of the parental alienation myth, ignoring the evidence, letting his anecdotes override it.

Survivors in Calder Valley tell me that they fear not being believed, being blamed, or being pushed into unsafe arrangements. They fear the drive to drop off their children with an abusive ex-partner.

They fear the agonizing wait for their child to be returned to them safe. For too long, the judicial system has felt unreliable, as a deeply traumatic tool of abusers. This government has committed to halving violence against women. This change is a step towards that. There's more to come, but our courts must put victims and children at the center of the decisions.

Thank you.

06:15:54 - 06:18:05

Sarah Russell

And I will be starting wind-ups at 5:52, so with the last two minutes, Sarah Russell.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I draw attention to my declaration of interests as a solicitor. I continue to have two concerns about this bill as drafted, and I'm very, very grateful to the government for changing their position around clause three. I entirely agree with my honorable friend the member for Corby, who said that the right to elect is being abused and probably isn't critical, but there are two things that are. I support amendment 70 by my honorable friend the member for Derby North around the importance of legal aid in the being extended in the magistrates' court. As solicitors, we have a saying, which is that the lawyer who represents themselves has a fool for a client.

So as solicitors, we do not attempt to represent ourselves, even in our areas of interest, and I have given employment law advice to an employment lawyer. Yet we expect lay people to go into the magistrates' court with now sentencing powers of up to two years with no legal advice and representation. When as Justice Select Committee we asked what evaluation had been made of the impact on unrepresented litigants in person on the Crown Court backlog, the answer from the MOJ was that no evaluation had been done of that. May I say that I feel very strongly that we need to look at that as one of the causes of delay. The second matter that I want to draw attention to is that sentences under the unduly lenient sentencing scheme only apply in the Crown Court.

When we double the magistrates' courts' potential sentencing powers to two years, we will take very large numbers of offenses out of the purview of the unduly lenient sentencing scheme overnight. So fear of domestic violence, stalking involving fear of violence, coercive and controlling behavior, first-time, many first-time sexual offenses will be likely to attract sentences of less than two years. They'll be heard in the magistrates' court, and if those sentences are unduly lenient, there will be nothing that we can do about it.

06:18:05 - 06:18:12

Speaker 269

And to wind up, Minister.

06:18:12 - 06:25:50

Heidi Alexander

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, we live in an era of problem-solving, not point-scoring. And indeed, as the courts minister, that has always been my focus. No bigger challenge in my portfolio than the unacceptable, indeed intolerable delays in our criminal courts, and that has always been the approach. The to do politics is ultimately to make choices, and the choices that we have made as a government are around the action that's needed to reform our criminal justice system, to invest in it, and to modernize it so that it is fit for purpose.

And whilst I always enjoy, and I'm sorry that he's not here, the oratory of the member for Torridge and Tavistock, he talks about our ancient rights. Magna Carta is absolutely clear: to no one will we ever deny or delay right or justice. And that is a recognition that timeliness is an essential ingredient of the thing that the state must guarantee, which is a fair trial. And a trial that arrives for a victim today in 2029 or 2030 is neither fair on the victim or defendant alike.

It was said that we should try to invest. Well we've done that. We've lifted the cap on sitting days and we've made record investment in legal aid and in our court estate. It was said we should look at the Liverpool model. And I've been to Liverpool.

It is indeed an excellent model and we're entrenching many of those practices in the new national listing framework in the introduction of case progression officers. It was said that we should make prison vans run on time. And we are pulling out the stops to do just that, asking local authorities, TFL and others to open up bus lanes whilst ensuring that PECS actually does its job. But the fact is the opposition and those on the opposition benches, they say Nightingale courts, they say let's work longer days, but it doesn't recognize the fact that the court day doesn't start at 10:00 or 10:30 as we know. That judges and barristers are working around the clock, around the court day to prepare cases and get the show on the road.

We cannot ignore the conclusions of the independent review of criminal courts, which is that there is no single solution. It needs to be investment, there needs to be modernization and we're doing both those things, but there also need to be structural reforms as well. And I do want to thank members across the house for the valuable contributions in the context of this debate, which have raised some really important themes which I've got to address. The first is the impact that these changes will have on our magistrates' courts. Whether it was the member for Solihull West and Shirley, Derby North, East Warwickshire and Bedworth who talked so credibly about the contribution of her own father as a magistrate.

Those who act as magistrates, who volunteer their time, do an incredible job. They bring local voices, lay voices into our justice system, something that is incredibly precious. But it's right. It's right that we are challenged and held accountable for whether we are increasing capacity in the magistrates to absorb the additional work. And indeed we are.

Whether it is the recruitment drive that we are making, not an unrealistic one as the member for Bridgewater put to me, but actually a credible one to get back to where we once were in just as recently as 2014 of 21,000 magistrates. And I'm pleased to report to the house that we are on track. The recruitment of additional 166 legal advisors since April 2025, an additional 100 district judges. This is what I mean when I say we are rebuilding our justice system from the bottom up. So the impact on magistrates' courts and capacity, yes it's important and yes we are doing it.

And the member for Runcorn made the point about training. And it's a really good one. The judicial college is working overtime to ensure that magistrates and district judges alike are trained so that they are able to exercise the sentencing powers which this bill would give them. The second excellent point that was made was around the allocation to where trials should be held, whether that be in the magistrates or in the crown court. And now the member for Kingston upon Hull East, he and I have had our differences in the course of this debate, but I've always respected his voice in this debate and I've always listened.

The member for Derby North makes a similar point around the allocation process. Let me be clear. The exercise that we are committing to in this bill is the same as has always existed in primary legislation, whereby the court will look at allocation guidelines published by the sentencing council. So sentencing and likely sentence is a relevant factor. But so too will hearing representations from both sides, the prosecution and the defense.

The next point that was very forcefully made and well made by the honorable member for Chichester, for Derby North, for Congleton and one or two others in relation to new clauses 18 and 17 was in relation to legal aid. There is no greater champion of access to justice and the importance of legal aid than this government and myself. I am a powerful advocate for legal aid, not least because I saw firsthand when I was in practice before coming to this place the vital importance that it plays in our justice system. That is precisely why one of the first steps we took and that I took as a minister was to invest in our criminal legal aid system, 160 million pounds for criminal solicitors and an additional 34 million pounds for criminal legal aid for advocates. That investment is important, but it won't go all the way and I recognize that.

The prosecution being able to bring in that victim's perspective, not just on likely sentence, but on the seriousness and complexity of the case at hand. Given the procedural, legal and factual complexity and any aggravating factors, that holistic exercise will determine where a case should be heard, so that the determining factor is the seriousness of the case rather than the identity of the defendant.

That is why we need to review the support that we give to unrepresented defendants in our magistrates' courts or indeed in the crown court in the rare cases that that arises. But as I've said in our response to the Leveson review, we will look again at those thresholds once these reforms have been embedded. I do want to address new clause 22 very briefly in relation to police accountability. I'm sorry I've got to be very brief, but he will be aware and the member for Birmingham Yardley will be aware that there is currently a case before the Supreme Court relating to this matter, so he will understand that the government has to carefully consider the outcome of that before giving a full response to the issue raised around police accountability. I do want to conclude around what I said around the removal of the right to elect.

This bill is designed to bring down the backlog, it is designed to deliver timely justice, but it's also about building a better and fairer system, one in which the court triages cases, not the defendant. That is about redressing the balance of power between defendant and victim. It's also about the improvements we make in terms of open justice, enhancing transparency, expanding the use of transcripts, improving the laws of evidence, improving training for our court staff and judiciary in terms of having trauma-informed as the member for Bolton North East implored us to do. To govern is to choose, we are making that choice in the Courts and Tribunals bill. What we deliver is not only timely justice, but a fairer justice system and one which puts what has been the pride of the world, the English and Welsh justice system, back on its feet.

06:25:50 - 06:26:22

Sarah Russell

The question is that new clause 23 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. The question is that new clause 23 be added to the bill.

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. New clause 25 has been selected for a separate decision. I call the shadow minister to move new clause 25 formally.

06:26:22 - 06:26:24

Speaker 274

To move.

06:26:24 - 06:27:21

Speaker 275

The question is that new clause 25 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper.

06:27:21 - 06:27:26

Speaker 273

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Tellers for the ayes David Simmons, Rebecca Smith, tellers for the noes Craig Pointon, Harpreet Uppal.

06:40:38 - 06:41:27

Sarah Russell

Order, order. The Ayes to the right 189, the Noes to the left 306. The Ayes to the right were 189, the Noes to the left were 306. So the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock.

Amendment one has been selected for separate decision. I call the Shadow Minister to move the amendment formally. Can we, can we have some quiet please? Order. The question is that amendment one be made.

06:41:27 - 06:42:03

Speaker 277

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.

06:42:03 - 06:42:05

Speaker 276

Of the contrary No. Tellers for the Ayes David Simmons, Rebecca Smith, tellers for the Noes Gregor Poynton, Harpreet Uppal.

06:53:17 - 06:53:21

Speaker 279

Order, order.

06:53:21 - 06:53:32

Harpreet Uppal

The Ayes to the right 196, the Noes to the left 304.

06:53:32 - 06:55:04

Sarah Russell

The Ayes to the right were 196, the Noes to the left were 304, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it, unlock. I call the Minister to move Government amendments 3 and 24 to 28 formally. The question is that Government amendments 3 and 24 to 28 be made, as many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.

Amendment 18 has been selected for separate decision, I call Jess Brown-Fuller to move the amendment formally. The question is that amendment 18 be made, as many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.

06:55:04 - 06:55:06

Speaker 278

Of the contrary No. Tellers for the Ayes Bobby Dean, Will Foster, tellers for the Noes Gregor Poynton, Harpreet Uppal.

07:06:02 - 07:07:04

Sarah Russell

Order. The ayes to the right 89, the noes to the left 312. The ayes to the right were 89, the noes to the left 312. So the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock.

I call the Minister to move government amendments 29 to 44 formally. The question is that government amendments 29 to 44 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

We now move on to third reading. Consideration completed, third reading. Minister to move third reading.

07:07:04 - 07:14:11

Heidi Alexander

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that this bill be now read a third time. But before I turn to the substance of this important bill, I would like to recognize those who've helped bring it to this stage. Those of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, who've sat in the chair both in this chamber and in committee, the excellent clerks of the House who serve us so well, the whips on all sides, of course the honorable and right honorable members who served on the Bill Committee and did so with such vigour, my honorable friend the Minister for Courts, my predecessor, my right honorable friend the member for Tottenham, and of course members from across this House for their contributions to this debate today and at previous stages. Especially those who've shared their or their constituents' experiences, and you know, those legal professionals from outside of here who've engaged with us also.

I'd like to give a specific recognition, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the artist formerly known as Sir Brian Leveson, who of course during this process has been elevated as the Noble Lord Liverpool. For his landmark review. What a public servant he is. What work he did in his review. And I want to recognize those efforts in this space, but frankly in many other aspects of British life as well.

And it's a real pleasure to work with him and we are grateful for his work that very much underpins this bill. And of course, crucially, the victims and survivors who have shaped these reforms, including those who join us today. Who should be very proud of what they have done, because I know that it comes at a cost for them to bring their stories forward to make change. But we are very, very lucky that they do so. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a bill with victims at its heart.

Its purpose is urgent and it is long overdue. That's to make sure that justice in this country is fast and is fair. Because victims today are facing intolerable delays. People suffer appalling crimes. They summon extraordinary courage to come forwards.

They relive their most traumatic experiences and they put their trust in the system that justice will be done. What happens next is that they wait. And they wait. And they wait. Trials are pushed back, cases drift further into the future.

Years of anxiety before a trial can even begin, whilst confidence in the system drains away. And all too often, victims give up because the process is unbearable. Madam Deputy Speaker, as my honorable friend said and as the age-old maxim goes, justice delayed, justice denied. This government cannot and will not accept that. And this is a bill that grips a previous problem that the previous government simply would not.

And it tackles the record and rising Crown Court backlog that we inherited that sits now at nearly 81,000 cases, more than double the level in 2019. And it is, I'm afraid, a testament to the Conservative Party's record in government, for their failure to grasp the nettle, to tackle the reform needed to wrestle our criminal justice system back on track. And again, we've seen today, they simply deny their reality, refuse to reconcile with their record. But let's be very, very clear. Left unchecked, our modeling shows exactly where this trajectory leads.

Even deeper delays, collapsing confidence, and a justice system that cannot fulfill its most basic promise, that justice will be done swiftly and fairly. And this government will not normalize that delay and allow victims, witnesses, and defendants to bear the burden of a system under strain. And we cannot continue to try to meet 21st-century pressures with a 20th-century model. Now, we've heard in the previous debate, but throughout this process, we've heard colleagues call for greater investment. They are right.

We are investing at record levels with unlimited sitting days for our criminal courts. Others have called for modernization. They are right and we are modernizing. Greater use of technology, AI, to maximize the capacity we have, to speed up justice and to ensure that our system responds to the changing nature of crime, with massive increases in digital evidence and demands on court time. But again, investment alone will not solve the crisis.

Modernization alone will not solve it either. And as the Noble Lord Liverpool made clear and as all the evidence shows, it's only when we add to this structural reform in the form of pragmatic changes that we really begin to turn the tide on the backlog. And that is what this bill will deliver. And yes, Madam Deputy Speaker, I make no apologies for this, that we looked again, myself as a new Lord Chancellor, my right honorable friend the Prime Minister as a new Prime Minister. Of course, we looked again at some of the measures included in this bill.

And we listened to the strength of feeling from across this House and from across the legal sector. And we have made changes, which mean now that almost all defendants facing trial in the Crown Court will continue to be tried by a jury.

But this bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, is not solely about bringing down the backlog. It's about making the system work better. I'm proud that during the proceedings on this legislation outside of this bill, we've been already able to bring forward measures to improve victims' experiences of courts, with new specialist courts for survivors of rape and sexual offences. And I want to recognise, as other colleagues did, the work of my honourable friend the member for Warrington North in previous stages in bringing us to this point. But this bill goes further to supporting that wider effort, challenging the damaging myths that so often silence rape victims, making it easier for victims to access the special measures they need so they can give their best and proper evidence.

And crucially, in the family courts, it will finally repeal the presumption of parental involvement, because the safety of children must always come first. And I would recognise the incredible efforts of Claire Throssell to bring this forward, to make this change a reality today. That's come at again at extraordinary cost, but I, you know, I hope that this is a day of pride of what is a significant step forwards. Madam Deputy Speaker, much debate around this bill has invoked tradition. But the history of our justice system has never been the history of standing still.

It's always been a history of adaptation, of institutions evolving to meet the demands of a changing society and a changing age, those timeless values but applied in a modern context. And we are acting to put the interests of the British people first, because the status quo, which take our courts to a point of no return, which continues to deny fast, fair justice to those who need it, which damages public confidence, damages public consent, is simply unacceptable to us. And we are the only ones, we've heard in the stages, all the stages of debate this, we are the only ones on this side of the house with the courage to address these challenges head-on. That's why we're pulling every lever within our power to rebuild a court system capable of delivering justice fairly, swiftly and sustainably. This bill chooses that path, because the cost of doing nothing is simply too high.

07:14:11 - 07:14:15

Nick Timothy

And with that, Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this bill to the house.

07:14:15 - 07:14:21

Speaker 282

The question is that the bill be read now read the third time. Shadow Minister.

07:14:21 - 07:19:54

Nick Timothy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Time and time again, for more than a year now, ministers have come to the dispatch box and told the house that their attack on jury trials was essential to making the courts work efficiently. Time and again we told them, more than a hundred of their colleagues on the benches opposite told them they were wrong. That the right to a trial by jury is an ancient English right, a vital part of our national inheritance, a necessary safeguard against the might of the state. They ignored us.

They said we didn't understand. They briefed against their colleagues and in the case of the honourable member for Kingston upon Hull East, smeared him disgracefully. And now they admit that they were wrong and we were right. All those ministers and Labour MPs who stuck to the government line in face of all the evidence should reflect on the limits of blind party allegiance and the instructions of their whips, because it makes them look very foolish today.

I want to remind the Courts Minister in particular of our exchange in the House in June, when I told her that the incoming leader of the Labour Party, now the Prime Minister, was going to scrap her prized policy. She told the House I misunderstood his position. The right honourable member for Makerfield, she said, did not in fact oppose their assault on jury trials. And yet here they are with their policy largely abandoned and her authority as Courts Minister lies in pieces. Like Monty Python's Black Knight, she declared in June, I move for no man.

As her policy lost one limb, she insisted it was but a scratch. As it lost another, she claimed it was just a flesh wound. And now this bill is left completely dismembered. The Courts Minister has gone from insisting I'm invincible to finally saying, all right, we'll call it a draw. But it's not a draw, it's a very serious defeat.

And it's a victory for our constitutional settlement, our rights under the crown, and the sacred principle that no one shall be convicted and deprived of their liberty except by a jury of their peers. This was a battle that should never have been fought. In the last year, 17,601 sitting days were lost because Crown Court rooms sat empty. Around 16% of Crown Courts are not sitting on average on any given day. We've repeatedly called for the government to get the courts sitting throughout the year.

That is how they should cut backlogs, not by attacking juries. Madam Deputy Speaker, I said the attack on juries had been largely abandoned, but the government hasn't completely given up and there remain serious problems with this bill. It will remove the right of defendants to elect a jury in either-way cases, and it will increase the sentencing power of magistrates' courts so more cases are heard there. But the magistrates' backlog has reached 380,000 open cases, a 9% increase on the previous year. The government hasn't told us what additional resources will be given to magistrates to manage this increase in workload, nor what new safeguards will ensure justice.

Indeed, there has been no assessment of the likely effect of this change on appeal rates. And we know of appeals against verdicts given by magistrates, up to 56% are allowed. The bill will also remove jurors from what it calls complex and lengthy trials, normally said to be cases involving fraud. The independent reviewer of fraud, Jonathan Fisher KC, concluded there was no justification for this change. But clause 4 doesn't only concern fraud trials.

The government seeks to extend the scope of judge-only trials to other complex cases in later years, and to do so by secondary legislation. This would give the government the power to resume its attack on jury trials without proper scrutiny or debate. This proposal is a disgrace and we reject it emphatically. The bill as amended would also establish a review of the court system with the specific remit of considering inequality of outcome based on racial identity. Once again, the party opposite is trying to engineer judicial outcomes based on identity rather than treating us all as free individuals accountable before the law.

We will resist this and stand for the principle that it is only our actions that matter, not who and what we are. Madam Deputy Speaker, we on this side of the House are committed to the ancient right to trial by jury. But while the principle of jury trials is sacrosanct, there is increasing evidence from recent cases that juries may, in some examples, have been compromised by the political or religious bias of some jury members. We've seen the acquittal of violent thugs, including the man who smashed a female police officer's spine, apparently because he was a member of Palestine Action. We've seen vandals from Just Stop Oil found not guilty despite clear evidence of their guilt.

And many in the legal profession are concerned that this is an increasing trend in courts across the country. If those who break our laws walk free because jurors feel kinship towards them, or because the cause for which the defendant committed a crime is just, then justice is no longer blind. That flies in the face of the rule of law and it must be stopped. I will give way.

07:19:54 - 07:20:08

Jess Brown-Fuller

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. He mentions that many in the legal profession are sounding the alarm about the perceived bias of juries. Can he please state which legal organisations have expressed that view to him?

07:20:08 - 07:20:58

Nick Timothy

Well, if the honourable lady listened, I said individual barristers, I didn't say organisations. And, and the Justice Secretary and others ought to listen to those professionals who experience the justice system every day. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government's handling of this bill has been a shambles from start to finish. It still contains dangerous provisions which limit the right to elect, to appeal, to allow ministers to attack jury trials by secondary legislation, and to put more cases through the magistrates' courts. So we will vote to reject this bill to preserve equality before the law and the right to a fair trial.

07:20:58 - 07:22:18

Speaker 275

The question is that the bill now be read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper.

07:22:18 - 07:22:27

Sarah Russell

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Tellers for the ayes, Greg Smith and Harriett Uppal. Tellers for the noes, Blake Stephenson, Rebecca Smith.

07:33:42 - 07:33:48

Speaker 284

Order, order.

07:33:48 - 07:34:00

Harpreet Uppal

The ayes to the right 301. The noes to the left 193.

07:34:00 - 07:34:16

Sarah Russell

The ayes to the right were 301, the noes to the left were 193, so the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. We must now take the motion related to deferred divisions, Minister to move.

07:34:16 - 07:34:17

I beg to move.

07:34:17 - 07:35:05

Sarah Russell

The question is the motion relating to deferred divisions, as many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, we now come to the carry-over extension motion for the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill.

I remind the House that this is a procedural motion. I encourage members to focus their remarks on the issue of the carry-over extension. I also remind the House that Mr Speaker granted an ongoing waiver to allow limited reference to active legal proceedings related to historic troubles-related deaths. We now come to motion number three on Northern Ireland Troubles Bill carry-over extension, Secretary of State to move.

07:35:05 - 07:37:13

Chris Bryant

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move the motion on the order paper in my name. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a short motion, but it stands for a lot. Strictly speaking, all it does is allow the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, which was introduced a year ago, to continue its passage through Parliament.

But it's actually about far more than that. It's about families who lost loved ones during the Troubles, often in the most awful circumstances imaginable. Daddies, mammies, brothers, sons, daughters. More than 3,500 of them. 90% of them murdered by paramilitaries.

It's about families living for decades with doubts, uncertainty, and unacknowledged grief, families desperate for answers about what happened to their loved ones, answers that might help them understand the how, the why, and even the who. Answers that might help provide some degree of comfort. We're joined, or we will be joined in a few moments in the gallery today by Mo, Pat, Jennifer, and Laura, all of whom lost loved ones during the Troubles and who have bravely, admirably, and heartbreakingly spent years trying to find the truth of what happened. They deserve answers. Let's not forget that more than a thousand of those who were killed were members of our security forces, serving under Operation Banner or targeted by the IRA in military barracks and towns across England.

25% of the investigations involve victims from the military, a further 17% relate to victims who were police officers. So I'm determined that veterans' families will get answers too. The Hillsborough families had to wait far too long, and so too have many families across Northern Ireland and Great Britain. We promised in our manifesto that we would put that right, and that is what we're going to do. Of course.

07:37:13 - 07:38:51

Jim Shannon

My cousin was murdered 10th of December 1969, 55 years ago. He was murdered alongside him was his friend called Danny McCormick, a Protestant and a Roman Catholic, but they both served in uniform. Nobody, nobody in 55 years this December the 10th, nobody in 55 years has ever been made accountable. The people, the three-man IRA team that killed those two gentlemen on that morning of the 10th of December, they ran across the border to sanctuary and safety. So with great respect, Secretary of State, you tell me as my family that we can have, we can have justice.

We don't see justice. 55 years waiting for justice, but I don't believe it, Secretary of State. And can you tell me honestly for all of the families, and I can name many, many other ones who have been murdered over the years as well, I think of the four UDR men, one person made accountable, but the people who killed that, the four UDR men at Ballydugan some 36 years ago, no one accountable for their murders. I say on behalf of the victims, on behalf of my family, on behalf of all the families, Secretary of State, we need justice. And I want justice for my family and I want justice for every one of those victims who served in uniform, RUC men, UDR men, British Army, who gave their lives for this province and for this country.

07:38:51 - 07:44:57

Chris Bryant

Madam Deputy Speaker, I pay tribute to the way the honourable gentleman has presented his case because it's remarkably similar to what I heard from others this afternoon and I've heard repeatedly in Northern Ireland. There's one man I've met whose father served and was murdered, and he meets the man who he knows murdered his father every single week in Marks and Spencer's. It's not even been acknowledged in any tribunal of any kind. And that's why it's so important that we get answers for people because the kind of pain that the honourable gentleman shows is the kind of pain that exists in so many families. And many of them are families who lost loved ones who served.

I remember going to the RUC Memorial Garden. It's very, very touching because it has decade after decade the names of the RUC officers who were killed. And for decade after decade it's like three or four, three or four, six, eight, and then dozens, dozens and dozens.

And many of those families have never had an answer. And if there's one thing I feel very strongly after all the communications that and the conversations I've had with individuals and veterans groups over the last few months, it is that there isn't one set of people which is families and there's another set of people which is veterans. Actually, the largest group of families are veterans' families, and they deserve answers too. Madam Deputy Speaker, we went further in our manifesto. We committed to replace the previous government's Legacy Act.

Why? Because it was legally flawed, it offered equal immunity to terrorists as to our armed forces, and it didn't carry the confidence of communities in Northern Ireland. So I pay warm tribute to my predecessor, my right honourable friend the Member for Leeds South, for negotiating the joint framework with the Irish government and for introducing and working to improve the bill and for all he did to repair trust and address the hurt that was caused by the previous Legacy Act. Yesterday, following extensive engagement with bereaved families and veterans' associations, I tabled a series of amendments. These can only be considered, Madam Deputy Speaker, if we agree the motion tonight.

One thing that has been clear in our discussions with veterans is that few ever wanted immunity at all, either for the armed forces alone or for veterans and terrorists. Indeed, many saw the previous government's immunity provisions, which were conditional, as implying an equivalence between their actions and the actions of terrorists. So we will amend the bill to bar the commission and coroners from treating the lawful actions of the security services as equivalent to the actions of paramilitaries. Moreover, because our soldiers operated in a unique operational context during the Troubles, and because the use of lethal force was lawful in certain circumstances to prevent harm, we will seek to amend the bill to ensure that factors such as soldiers' training, experience and, crucially, the orders they were operating under must be taken into account in any investigation. The Shadow Secretary of State, my honourable friend for Worsley and Eccles, and the honourable members for North Down and South Holland and the Deepings made these points in previous debates, so I hope they will gain cross-party support.

We have also listened, Madam Deputy Speaker, to concerns raised by the right honourable member for Belfast East, the right honourable member for Goole and Pocklington, and the honourable members for North Antrim, Upper Bann, Lagan Valley and others over the on-the-run letters. These never provided immunity from prosecution, but we will put in black and white in the bill that these letters cannot be used to prevent or frustrate potential prosecutions. Where there is evidence of criminal wrongdoing by terrorists, such letters will never act as a barrier to them being convicted. We have also heard the cries for dignity from families who have never even been able to get death certificates. We want to make that easier, and we will give oversight of the commission's work to His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary, which will improve the efficiency of investigations and thereby the process for victims and families.

There is more we can do, Madam Deputy Speaker, if this motion is allowed tonight. The men and women who serve in our armed forces represent the very best of our country. They volunteered to place themselves in harm's way, accepting significant personal hardship and sacrifice on behalf of this country, as did their families. In return for their service, they are entitled to expect that the state will support them and their loved ones throughout their military careers and, crucially, long after their service has ended.

Where a service member has made the ultimate sacrifice, this commitment includes giving their bereaved families the opportunity to establish the circumstances of their loved one's death, which is what we will create through the Legacy Commission. I am very grateful to my honourable friend the Member for Aldershot, who unfortunately can't be here today because of a family situation, but since this bill was introduced, she has fought for the veterans in her constituency and she's played a key role in bringing about a number of changes to the bill in the amendments that we've talked about. She has, alongside the Members for Southend East and Rochford, for Swindon North, for South Ribble and the Member for Halesowen, argued for greater protections for individuals to prevent an endless cycle of what I call rinse and repeat. We have heard those concerns and brought forward significant amendments to address them. First off, a provision that no process that has already been undergone can be repeated by the Commission or, crucially, by a coroner unless it is essential, which is a very high bar, much higher than in previous legislation, because, for instance, there is new information or a new forensic process.

07:44:57 - 07:45:07

Alex Burghart

I wasn't sure whether that came... oh, there, sorry.

I'm very grateful to the Secretary of State for giving way. Could he set out in greater detail for us what the word 'essential' is going to mean in law?

07:45:07 - 07:47:51

Chris Bryant

Well, as you'll know, the word 'essential'... so in the Legacy Act, the word that is used is 'necessary', which is a much lower bar. 'Essential' traditionally in lots of legal judgments already is a higher bar. The kind of thing that we're talking about is where there is a new forensic process which wasn't available 30 years ago, so for instance you might be able to examine a fingerprint on a piece of shrapnel much more effectively today than you could previously, or where there is literally a new piece of information. That's the kind of thing, but it is essential to be able to conduct the work of the organisation. Secondly, Madam Deputy Speaker, a new provision that the Legacy Commission must obtain and review any information it needs from the state itself before it considers even whether to request an individual to come as a witness.

And thirdly, another new provision that the Legacy Commission must not request information from a witness unless it has considered whether compelling new evidence exists or the likelihood of a witness being able to provide new information. Fourthly, putting the protection from cold-calling into law and strengthening the provision for remote attendance, ensuring it applies to all aspects of the Commission's work. And fifthly, prosecutions in troubles-related cases are rare, and I expect them to be rare, but to provide greater assurance and confidence in decisions to prosecute, any future prosecutions of serious troubles-related offences will require the consent of the Attorney General acting quasi-judicially. This will apply regardless of whether the offence relates to state or non-state actors. I'm grateful to my honourable friend the Member for Birmingham Selly Oak, who I know was committed to making this change both inside and outside of government and who rightly pointed out that there is precedent for this approach and it in no way changes the thresholds required to proceed with a prosecution or the prosecutor's independence in considering the evidence before them.

I have also tabled a number of amendments in relation to the Legacy Commission's Victims and Survivors Advisory Group, providing clarity that former paramilitaries cannot be appointed to the group and that former service personnel, many of whom are also victims, must be represented. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Legacy Act's immunity scheme was previously being repealed from statute, excuse me, via a remedial order.

To enable Parliament to consider the changes we are making in the round, we will now repeal it through the bill. This addresses a recommendation of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, to whom I am grateful. Of course.

07:47:51 - 07:48:32

Andrew Murrison

And can I say how much I appreciated the joint letter that he and the Defence Secretary sent to colleagues, which I think has pacified a lot of our concerns. However, what he is describing is a wholesale filleting of the legislation. Is he going to comment on why that legislation was drafted in the way that it did in the first place, and apologize to those servicemen, many of them in their 70s now, who have been deeply troubled by the fear that they're going to be a victim of the 3 o'clock knock?

07:48:32 - 07:49:58

Chris Bryant

Well, look, I arrived in post a few months ago and I sat down with the Defence Secretary. We looked at some of the amendments that had already actually been drawn up by my right honorable friend, and we were convinced that we needed to go a little bit further than that. So, for instance, the amendment in relation to the Attorney General is a new amendment. The amendment in relation to compelling new evidence likewise. And I really do want to proceed as much as I possibly can in a consensual way across the whole of the House.

That's why I've provided as many opportunities to take people through all the details of all the amendments as I possibly can to the opposition and to other political parties as well. I, you know, sometimes we need to get our legislation right. I think one of the problems was that we had a very long period when these, some of these amendments could have been dealt with several months ago, and we might have got to a better place sooner. And then we wouldn't have needed the carry-over motion either. But I think there's not much point in crying over spilt milk.

It's much better just to try and get the bill right, which is precisely what I'm trying to do. And indeed, I should say actually, this is an important point to say to the honorable gentleman. All of the amendments we have tabled are wholly consistent with our human rights obligations and the fundamental principle that everyone is equal before the law. Madam Deputy Speaker. Oh Lord, yes.

07:49:58 - 07:50:09

Geoffrey Cox

What substantive difference does he think the Attorney General's consent will make to a decision of this kind?

07:50:09 - 07:51:35

Chris Bryant

Well, obviously it was a material consideration for us as to whether this was the right step to go down because for all the obvious reasons that maybe others will adduce in the debate later on. But it was very keenly felt by a lot of those in the veterans community that it would be much better if this decision were not being made just by the prosecuting authorities in Northern Ireland and that it would be better if it were made here. Now, obviously the standard prosecutorial question, in other words, is it more than 50% likelihood of getting a successful conviction, and secondly, is it in the public interest, that doesn't change at all. The Attorney General will be acting in a quasi-judicial function, as she is very keen to point out. But I think that this does provide a degree, and I've had this back from large numbers of veterans, it does provide a degree of confidence and reassurance to those who have been worrying about this.

And of course, it applies equally to anybody who might be investigated, for instance, might be prosecuted, for instance, for being involved in the M62 bomb or the Guildford pub bombing. So I take the point that he's making, but it was one of the things that was asked for. Where possible, I've tried to make the argument as strongly as I possibly can on behalf of the veterans to make sure that we get the bill right. Yes, of course.

07:51:35 - 07:52:04

Alex Easton

I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. In terms of the commission advisory board, who makes the final decision on who goes onto that? And can he also assure me that while it's good to know that no paramilitaries will be allowed on that board, can he also assure me that political parties that have supported violence and those paramilitaries will not, the members of that political party, Sinn Féin, will not be allowed to be allowed onto that commissioning board?

07:52:04 - 07:53:51

Chris Bryant

He makes a very good point, and indeed it's a point he made to me yesterday as well. It's the Secretary of State who makes the decision about who sits on that board, on the advisory group. The advisory group is a key distinction between the legacy commission. I think one of the things that I've heard again loud and clear and repeatedly is that this whole process needs to be focused on the families and the victims. And the only way you can secure that is if you have an effective advisory group.

He's quite right about there shouldn't be anybody on there who espouses or has espoused the use of violence. And that will be one of the key responsibilities that the Secretary of State would have to ensure. We're saying that at least one member of the, there can be between three and seven members of the advisory group, and we're saying that at least one of those must be a veteran or a former member of the police or one of their representatives. And of course it might be more than that. Madam Deputy Speaker, cooperation and sharing of records by the Irish authorities, and this may meet the point that was being made earlier on, I think, may be the key to obtaining information for families about the circumstances in which their loved ones died and who was responsible.

For the precise reason that sometimes people, I will in just one sec, sometimes what happened was that somebody popped over the border, did the killing and then returned. And that's why I think it's very important that one of the things that my right honourable friend secured in the agreement with the Irish government was their full cooperation in this process. Well, I was just going to give way there first, and then I'll give way to the others if that's all right. Yeah.

07:53:51 - 07:55:02

Jim Shannon

I thank the Secretary of State. And very clearly my own family members are aware of the three IRA murderers who escaped across the border, who stayed across the border and didn't return home. But also can I just put on the record, Gerry McMonagle, involved in the murder of Lexie Cummings in Strabane in 1982, he escaped across the border. Not only did he escape across the border, he became the mayor of Donegal Council. Now, there's a person who should be accountable for his actions.

He escaped because there was a wrong notification done by the police in relation to the summons, and he was able to run out of court, get on a motorbike, cross the border and live a new life. Also the two superintendents murdered at the border as well, Garda Síochána collusion, collusion from the Republic of Ireland government. There has to be accountability for those people in the Garda Síochána who gave evidence, has to be accountability for those people in government at that time who overseen it and did nothing about it. So the role for the Republic of Ireland, for the government, plays a big role to play. Let's make sure we keep their feet to the fire and keep the heat on the back of their neck.

07:55:02 - 07:55:35

Chris Bryant

Well, this is precisely the point I was making, which is that the Irish government needs to step up to the plate and provide answers. And where it fails to do so, we will of course want to take issue with them assertively. But that's the key difference that I think my right honourable friend made is making sure that the Irish government is introducing legislation which will require them to cooperate in this process and in many cases provide the answers which are essential to the kind of person that he refers to. Of course I give way, and then.

07:55:35 - 07:56:39

Gavin Robinson

I'm grateful to the Secretary of State. And the Garda legacy unit has been much lauded, particularly by his predecessor.

It formed part of the framework that was published last year and it was meant to be operative from January. Is he aware that they have failed to provide any answers, any responses, answer the telephone or respond to emails with any information from that date to this? Is he aware that there was a public perception that they were providing information until we challenged Helen McEntee as the minister responsible? She then said that there would be no information passed at all until the legal uncertainties were cleared. They were cleared by Dillon in Supreme Court.

They have been cleared or when this legislation passes. And yet the ICRIR continue to investigate cases. They continue to seek answers for families and they're getting no response whatsoever. Does he have an indication that they will provide those answers either following tonight or next Tuesday?

07:56:39 - 07:57:08

Chris Bryant

I'm going to come on to some of the answers precisely and to those questions in just a moment. But I've spoken to Helen McEntee myself repeatedly and made some of these points and and for that matter to Jim O'Callaghan as well in the Irish government. It's very important that the Irish government plays its part because otherwise what's the point? And but he makes a very strong point. He's made these points to me before as well and I have made them to the Irish government.

I'll give way to the honorable gentleman and then I ought to make progress.

07:57:08 - 07:58:03

Jim Allister

Secretary of State lays great store by the southern authorities in the Republic of Ireland cooperating. But did we not yesterday have a classic example of the duplicity of the Dublin government when in the Omagh inquiry it emerged that they'd sat for 28 years on an intelligence document which indicated that the night before the Omagh bomb there was a phone call to Finner Camp of the Irish Army indicating the bomb was coming with the declaration Omagh, Omagh, Omagh. And it was never passed on that night to the RUC and sat upon until now with with the allowing to grow the narrative that in fact it was the RUC that had been negligent when in when it was quite clear that the southern authorities had withheld back information which could have avoided that horrendous bomb.

07:58:03 - 08:00:33

Chris Bryant

Well I too have read the reports that the honorable member has refers to and of course they are very disturbing. There is an ongoing inquiry and it's not my job to do the job the work of the inquiry. But it is absolutely the job of the Irish government to provide all the information that the inquiry needs to be able to do its job effectively. And now Madam Deputy Speaker, the Irish government has set out the framework for its own legislation and we want to see that progress swiftly in parallel with ours. And I know that in previous debates there was some question about whether we had to complete our legislation and then the Irish government was going to do its legislation.

To give further assurance we will require the Secretary of State to lay a written ministerial statement before the full commencement of the Troubles Bill outlining the progress made by the UK and Irish governments. And I have spoken directly to Minister McEntee and she has said repeatedly now in public that they will march in lockstep with us in terms of legislation with the aim of having both of our sets of legislation come into force on the same day. Madam Deputy Speaker, committee stage will be next week and colleagues will want to consider all these matters in depth. But I do want to end by urging everyone not to underestimate the importance of us enabling our enabling families to get the answers that they require.

We've already heard we've already heard amongst our own members in the chamber the pain and the grief and the anguish and sometimes sense of revenge and anger that comes with the fissures that opened up many many years ago. I cannot tell members how many times I have heard those same calls often from people who lost members in the armed forces serving under Operation Banner and often from people who served in the RUC. There was a moment I suppose when the Good Friday Agreement came about when everybody thought we've done our work now peace has come. The last couple of weeks has shown that peace can sometimes be a very thin veneer. And sometimes the people who bore the biggest brunt of that peace who had to sort of suck it up were the families who had lost loved ones and they've never managed to get answers.

I don't think we can ever really build a strong future for Northern Ireland unless we fully understand the past and understanding the past means making sure that we get answers for people.

08:00:33 - 08:00:38

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper I call Shadow Secretary of State Alex Baker.

08:00:38 - 08:03:58

Alex Burghart

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and I thank the Secretary of State for his comments and the briefing that his team gave mine at the start of this week. And I want to say at the outset that I can see that he and his team have worked very hard to try and make improvements to this bill. But I'm afraid Madam Deputy Speaker that the bill is a mess. That mess is attested to by the fact that we are still debating it when it was introduced a year ago tomorrow and we have yet to breach committee stage. It is attested to by the fact that we are debating a carry-over motion tonight for the second time.

It is attested to by the fact that the government in April told us that it was going to submit its amendments after six months of delay but only published them yesterday after another six months. And just look at them Madam Deputy Speaker. 144 government amendments now making a pack of about 300. 119 pages. This is a mess in the process of becoming a bigger mess.

And I know the Secretary of State has been handed this mess I know it is not of his making and that he has been given the unenviable task of fixing it. But this but this is the case that it cannot be fixed because the fundamentals are wrong. And however much one scrubs off some of the worst corners and the worst excesses the fundamentals are still there. Next week we will have a chance to debate some of these amendments. Though the amount of time set aside for the debate of this legislation and so many amendments is wholly unequal to the task.

For reasons I cannot understand the government has effectively denied the House report stage. That's to say that only an hour has been set aside for report and it is inevitable that committee stage will eat that away entirely. As a backbencher I know the Secretary of State was a defender of the the role of this House in scrutiny. I think it's very upsetting that we are not going to be able to give this bill proper treatment in the Commons and it will have to only it will only get proper scrutiny in the Lords. This of course is only a minor quibble in the face of the problems in the bill itself.

In simple terms Madam Deputy Speaker we cannot support this legislation because it reopens the door to vexatious litigation against those who served in Northern Ireland during the troubles. In the long time in which this bill has been in the table office a number of cases have come to public attention which illustrate both the problem that requires fixing and the inadequacy of the government's response. In November last year we debated the findings in the case against Soldier F from Bloody Sunday.

and most detailed inquiry in British legal history. Judge Patrick Lynch told Belfast Crown Court that even after such an investigation, the evidence fell well short of the standard required. He said a 53-year-old statement cannot be cross-examined. I will give way to the honorable gentleman in a moment, but I will finish my sentence. He said a... because I was in the middle of... I was in the middle of speaking.

He said 53-year-old statement cannot be cross-examined, nor can I assess the demeanor of a sheet of A4 paper. It is becoming vanishingly difficult to get convictions. I'll give way to the honorable gentleman.

08:03:58 - 08:04:37

Speaker 298

I'd be grateful for the member for giving way. It would also be grateful if he actually mentioned a victim in his speech. We're three minutes in, not one mention. He talked about Soldier F, who murdered lots of people on Bloody Sunday along with his colleagues, unarmed people, unarmed people, proven by a British Prime Minister-appointed court of tribunal and understood and recognized and supported by a Tory Prime Minister. Will he mention some of the victims of Soldier F or some of the other victims that we should be talking about tonight instead of people who were willingly, openly going into streets and shooting people down who didn't have a gun in their hands?

08:04:37 - 08:07:37

Alex Burghart

So, the honorable gentleman, if he had waited a moment, would have heard me talk about the victims. The victims, the victims who suffered so much are being promised the... given the promise of convictions that will never come. They will never come. That even when we have the most detailed inquiry in British legal history, no conviction comes. And yet this House is now expected to believe that this legislation before us is going to open the road to all of these convictions.

It won't happen. It is a promise that will not be fulfilled. But that does not mean that soldiers who did their duty, did nothing but their duty, will not be pulled through the courts time and time again. In February last year, this House debated the terrible ruling in the case of Conno from 1992. On that occasion, four men known as terrorists, known... known terrorists, Madam Deputy Speaker, armed with semi-automatic weapons and a Dushka machine gun, attacked an RUC police station and then moved on to commit further crimes.

They called themselves an army, they carried weapons of war, they sought to kill, and they operated entirely outside of the bounds of the law. And yet we were asked to believe that the use of lethal force against them was not justified. These men will now be subject to unjust and unfair scrutiny of the decisions that they had to make in exceptionally difficult circumstances decades ago. The case of Soldier B, a former SAS officer, has been raised repeatedly in this House. In 2024, a coroner ruled that he had been justified in using lethal force in Coagh in 1991.

Then, in 2025, the case was taken to the High Court in Belfast where it was thrown out by a judge who described it as ludicrous and said it should never have come to court. Despite this, in April this year, the case went to the Court of Appeal where it was again thrown out, and then last month an attempt was mounted to take it to the Supreme Court and that attempt is ongoing. Soldier B, Soldier B has been dragged through the courts for five and a half years when the legal system in this country admits that the case against him is ludicrous. This... happy to give way.

I would just gently point out to him that that's under his legislation. All of that is under his legislation.

And I am giving him an example of the things that will not be stopped by his, that this will continue. This bill, the bill that is before us does not solve this problem. No, the honorable lady says our problem. Our legislation drew a line in the sand that meant things like that would never happen again. That case had already started, and if the honorable lady was familiar with the Legacy Act, she would know where the line in the sand was drawn.

I'll give way to the honorable gentleman.

08:07:37 - 08:07:43

Speaker 297

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I just want clarification on whether the problem that you state is access to the Supreme Court.

08:07:43 - 08:07:48

Speaker 295

The problem that he states. We cannot have yous creeping into this. Alex Burghart.

08:07:48 - 08:07:51

Speaker 296

I wasn't patronizing the right honorable lady.

08:07:51 - 08:08:02

Speaker 294

Can I remind members that debate in this chamber occurs through the chair. I will not have unseemly yelling at each other across those dispatch boxes. Alex Burghart.

08:08:02 - 08:10:58

Alex Burghart

Apologies, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was pointing out to the honourable lady and the gentleman in question exactly the sort of problems that the Legacy Act was designed to solve. There was obviously a cut-off point which meant that it didn't... There was obviously, as I'm sure the honourable members know, the Legacy Act had a cut-off point and that cases that had already started were not caught by that. But I am giving an example of similar cases that are now going to come because of their legislation.

As Philip Barton KC has written in the Spectator this week, the government's attempts to solve this and the government's proposed protections are wholly inadequate to the task. They fail on their own test because the bill and the government's amendments, I quote, "will permit repeat investigations". As Philip Barton KC says, where the right honourable gentleman Secretary of State earlier raised the case of the word "essential" and he talked about new evidence. As Philip Barton has pointed out, any lawyer worth their salt can find new evidence. This is an extremely low bar.

It might sound like a high bar, but it is an extremely low bar. All the while this has been going on, this year and a more that we have been dealing with this legislation, the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery set up by the Legacy Act has been doing its work. And a few weeks ago, the ICRIR published its first report which laid out the details of Mr. Rory O'Kelly's murder by the IRA in 1977. This was an information recovery exercise that concluded that no perpetrators were ever likely to be identified, but it still provided answers to questions that have haunted Mr. O'Kelly's family for half a century. His daughter described in extremely moving terms how the report moved the family into a space of serenity and light, all anger taken away.

But now, just as the ICR is starting working as intended, the government is to reprogramme it into what two generals today have described as essentially a criminal investigations body, charged with collecting evidence to a criminal standard, despite the fact that we know that the chance of prosecutions is incredibly unlikely. Those who work in the ICRIR are desperately concerned that this will lead to a massive increase in their workload with no increase in funding, and that this will inevitably mean long delays and distraction away from the core information recovery exercise which was intended to be their central function. The government benches may not want to take the case that I am making against this bill from me, I understand that. But they should take it from the retired generals and soldiers who have repeatedly spoken out. Happy to give way to the honourable lady.

08:10:58 - 08:11:49

Katrina Murray

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. He's talking a lot about veterans and the roles of those veterans. My concern is particularly in the range of my constituents, those who served but never got to be veterans because they did not survive their service in Northern Ireland. What those families want is the truth, and they want a truth that is undebatable. Would he not recognise that actually what we should be talking about is the victims and the survivors, rather than trying to make this a false, absolutely a false dichotomy of where there is more than one level of victim in here, one tier of victim.

08:11:49 - 08:13:31

Alex Burghart

Now look, the honourable lady speaks powerfully on this point.

She's absolutely right that many victims were veterans, were people who served. And, but, as I was saying about the way in which ICRIR works and is now being seen to work, ICRIR can be used by families, by victims' families, regardless of, you know, who they were, when they were killed, can be used in order to assist in that information recovery process. And one of the advantages of ICRIR is that it is a non-adversarial system that has enabled, already started to enable families to find out things they didn't know before. She is absolutely right that process is very valuable, and it's why it was put in the Legacy Act by the last government. The, I hope that those opposite and anybody in the House who is thinking of supporting the continuation of this legislation will listen to the two retired generals who wrote today saying that the government should stop pretending that its amendments offer veterans meaningful protections.

The consequence of continuing down this route will be that some men, like Soldier B, not Soldier B himself, but men like Soldier B into the future, who served decades ago, will spend years in the jaws of vexatious litigation, that victims will not receive the justice that they are being promised by this legislation, and that many, many more people, many, many more veterans, will continue to live with that nagging sense that those using lawfare may come for them. And they are already being punished by the idea of this legislation. The failings of this bill... I'll give way to the honorable lady.

08:13:31 - 08:13:47

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way, but would he agree that his party's Legacy Act actually gave no protection whatsoever to veterans' families because it was found to be unlawful and therefore he has let those families down?

08:13:47 - 08:14:28

Alex Burghart

The honorable lady will know that her government when it came in did not appeal the case against that, and did not appeal the case against that. And in any case, if the human... we have a human rights framework which is wholly inadequate to dealing with cases that were decades ago, wholly inadequate. And it's clear that the current government would rather protect that framework than protect people from that period. The failings of this bill, should it be passed, will be quickly seen and long felt. The House has the power to stop it tonight.

If we do not, and the government persists, the next Conservative administration will repeal it and once again draw a line under the Troubles.

08:14:28 - 08:14:31

Speaker 299

Chair of the Select Committee, Tonia Antoniazzi.

08:14:31 - 08:18:33

Antonia Louise Antoniazzi

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as Chair of the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee, I've met many people whose lives were forever shaped by the Troubles and who decades later continue to search for the truth about what happened to their loved ones. And as the Secretary of State has mentioned today, I hosted victims from and family, families from WAVE in Parliament, and they also had the opportunity to meet with the Prime Minister, which I was really pleased about. And I'd like to just pay tribute to Jennifer, who was twelve when the IRA took over their family home and her father Patsy was abducted then killed, and Pat Malloy, whose son John was eighteen when he was killed on his way home, and Mo Norton, whose brother Terence, who was serving at the time, was killed in the M62 bus bomb in 1974, and finally Laura Burns, whose dad Robert was killed in their home. It's always emotional, Madam Deputy Speaker, listening to all victims.

So I'd personally like to thank them for speaking to us today and say thank you to them because they are now in the gallery.

And but Madam Deputy Speaker, as we debate this bill today and consider the next steps in this process, we must keep those people at the forefront of our minds. My committee completed a year-long inquiry into the legacy of the past at the end of last year. Now it was a serious and comprehensive piece of work, engaging extensively with all communities and revealing a strong cross-party consensus on a number of key issues and areas where the bill can be improved. And our hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that the detailed evidence and recommendations contained in our report will help shape debate in this house and beyond. And so I would encourage all colleagues to review our report as we move through considerations of this bill.

My committee heard powerful testimony from victims, survivors and families who continue to live with the consequences of the past. Many are still struggling to obtain answers, accountability and a measure of closure. We cannot build a more reconciled future without addressing the past. And it is for that reason that we must ensure this bill is carried over so that Parliament has the time to give these issues the careful consideration that they deserve. There is still much that we need to do to improve this bill, that is clear, to ensure that victims and survivors remain at its heart and to address the concerns raised during our inquiry.

But time and again, Madam Deputy Speaker, witnesses pointed out to the importance of resources. Whatever structures Parliament creates, they will only succeed if they are properly funded. Without adequate resources, expectations will be raised that cannot be met. We also heard concerns about whether victims' and survivors' voices will be fully reflected in the new arrangements. This process should never, Madam Deputy Speaker, be framed as a choice between different groups.

The focus must remain on those who continue to carry the burden of loss and trauma. More broadly, questions remain about how the new system will work in practice. Who can access investigations, how information will be disclosed and whether confidence can be built in the process. These issues go to the heart of public trust. And in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, while views differ on many aspects of legacy, one message came through clearly.

People want a process that is properly resourced, commands public confidence and places victims and their families at the center. But the challenge now for the Secretary of State and the NIO is to deliver it. We owe it to those still carrying the legacy of the past to get this right. Thank you.

08:18:33 - 08:18:36

Speaker 303

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Paul Kohler.

08:18:36 - 08:20:12

Paul Kohler

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As has been said many times before and ignored just as often by my Conservative colleagues, the Tories' Legacy Act utterly failed our veterans, drawing an acceptable equivalence between the actions of those seeking to uphold and defend peace and the rule of law and the terrorists who sought to undermine it by maiming, murdering and doing all they could to encourage sectarian division and hatred. Now, of course, the Conservatives are trying to argue they are defending the interests of our brave veterans, when in reality they are cynically using them to score political points. That's why so many veteran organisations will have nothing to do with their grandstanding. The Legacy Act failed to uphold our obligations under the ECHR.

At the time it was just collateral damage, but now it's become central to their ill-conceived plan to leave the ECHR and thereby fatally undermine the Good Friday Agreement and the Brexit deal of which they are so unjustly proud.

It also failed the communities of Northern Ireland. No political party from the unionist, nationalist, or non-aligned tradition support the Conservatives' flawed legislation, which fundamentally failed to gain the support of those it was supposed to protect. Most devastatingly, it failed the innocent victims and their families by barring the pathway to justice, truth, and reconciliation. As we've seen throughout these debates, the Tories are still in denial over the Legacy Act's failings, just as they're in denial over their many other failings in government, from Brexit to their financial mismanagement. I'm sorry to say it's what we've come to expect from a once great party.

08:20:12 - 08:20:32

Speaker 306

Shameless, and you should be shamefaced. The Labour Party's willingness to deal with these failings... Order. Mr. Coda, please could you focus your comments on the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill and not a dissertation of history. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

08:20:32 - 08:23:09

Paul Kohler

The Labour Party's willingness to deal with these failings is therefore most welcome. At which point may I, with your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, give my brief thanks to the previous Secretary of State, the right honourable member for Leeds South, who was the architect of the original bill, for the courtesy and time he gave me when I first became my party's spokesperson for Northern Ireland, an approach I'm pleased to acknowledge has also been followed normally by the Shadow Secretary and the new Secretary of State. Now, although 156 government amendments landed with a thud in my inbox yesterday morning, we are not meant to be discussing those today. Under the mysterious procedure of this place, we are simply revisiting the carry-over motion we passed before the end of the last parliamentary session. I'm sure there are good historic reasons for such repetition, but trust the member for Christchurch and his fellow trailblazers on the Modernisation Committee will give due consideration to reforming many of our time-wasting practices.

The bill we are consequently considering today is the same one we considered the last time we debated it, and thus my party will again be voting against the motion. I've worked closely with veteran organisations like the British Legion and the SAS Regimental Association throughout my time as spokesperson on Northern Ireland. The anxiety regarding future threats of lawfare, with veterans being dragged through repeated investigations, has been at the heart of every conversation I have had. Against this backdrop, clear and robust safeguards must be established. The original safeguards within the bill were vague and did not go far enough to ensure the process does not become the punishment.

And I commend both the current Secretary of State and his predecessor for engaging with me on these issues. As they both promised, the Secretary of State has now published the aforementioned draft of 156 amendments. However, there is now just a week before the committee stage. This raises serious concerns about scrutiny as we and the various veterans' organisations wade through pages of bizarrely numbered and then renumbered government amendments. The devil, after all, is in the detail.

Only today I had to ask the Secretary of State to point me in the direction of the most important amendments. He did, although I've now discovered a table the NIO helpfully produced detailing the key ones. That is indeed very useful. But what we and the veterans' groups need is time to work through the implications of each amendment and talk to our veterans. That is simply not possible when you have only been given a week to do so.

08:23:09 - 08:23:40

Chris Bryant

As the Secretary of State knows, I also have concerns that scrutiny is being undertaken by a committee of the whole House. What this legislation requires is detailed line-by-line examination of each clause, but what we will have is two days of the usual pantomime in this chamber. I think it's a really important point to explain why we do a lot of Northern Ireland legislation not in a committee upstairs. It's so that a lot of the members can actually take part in these debates. I thank the Secretary of State for his intervention, but I was coming to that.

08:23:40 - 08:25:24

Paul Kohler

I am told, as he has just told me again, the reason we have a committee of the whole house is because of the need to include our colleagues representing Northern Ireland. However, I do not see why the absolutely legitimate point could not have been addressed by the three major parties giving up some of their places to MPs representing Northern Ireland constituencies, a solution I suggested and was ignored by the Secretary of State. This legislation will have profound consequences for victims and veterans. Ensuring we get it right is essential to maintaining the confidence of communities across Northern Ireland, alongside that of current and former members of the armed forces. Our amendments propose clear statutory safeguards to prevent repeated investigations unless there's materially new evidence, certified as necessary and proportionate.

They establish a presumption of remote participation so that veterans are not compelled to relive traumatic experiences in person unless it's strictly essential. They also provide for anonymity, proper welfare support, and regulated contact through official channels. They additionally seek to ensure veterans' views are properly represented through a guaranteed place on the victims and survivors group, and to establish an independent reviewer reporting annually to Parliament, ensuring protections are consistently applied, properly scrutinized, and upheld in practice. The government's amendments do indeed seek to address many of these points, but we need to work through the detail of the drafting before we can say whether they achieve what is needed. For example, the clause requiring compelling new evidence to exist, or be reasonably expected to exist, before a witness can be contacted is already giving us cause for concern, as the director of investigations will be the sole judge of his own decision.

08:25:24 - 08:25:41

Adam Jogee

Madam Speaker, I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman who I enjoy working with on the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee. I've also enjoyed listening to his many amendments and talking us through them. Does he not realize, though, that we won't be able to consider or vote on those amendments if he doesn't back this bill this evening, or this motion this evening?

08:25:41 - 08:27:28

Paul Kohler

The point is, the point is, I would say to the honorable gentleman, is we only have a week to consider 156 amendments. That's not... and then we only have two days to discuss them. We need line-by-line scrutiny. This legislation does not exist in a vacuum. The House is aware of how tensions have increased in the wake of the decision to both allow the Drumcree march and then ban it.

Against that backdrop, it's even more important this legislation provides genuine routes to reconciliation, to ensure future generations growing up in Northern Ireland no longer have to experience the divisions of the past. On that point, I'm still disappointed by the lack of weight given to restorative justice in the bill. This process cannot only be about legal mechanisms that conceive of justice through an all-too-narrow lawyer's lens. That is why we have proposed a statutory duty to promote reconciliation, alongside a framework for restorative justice. This would offer victims and survivors, where they choose to participate, the opportunity for truth-telling and acknowledgment outside purely adversarial processes.

For many, the primary question is not about punishment, it's about understanding. The recent report from ICRA into the death of Rory O'Kelly, who was murdered by an IRA gunman, shows how important answers, not retribution, is key. His daughter, Frances, issued a powerful statement describing the catharsis and closure that the report brought to her and her brother Roger, who died shortly before its publication. The work undertaken ensured that Roger did not die without knowing what had happened to his father. Yes, this was a form of restorative justice, but our amendments would allow more intensive forms of RJ.

08:27:28 - 08:27:42

Speaker 309

Perhaps the honourable gentleman would reserve his arguments about his amendments for when this comes back in committee, and we could focus this evening on the carry-over extension.

08:27:42 - 08:27:57

Paul Kohler

Madam Deputy Speaker would point out with respect the Secretary of State has told us much about his amendments during this debate. I remain to be convinced this bill, even after 156 amendments...

08:27:57 - 08:28:11

Speaker 294

The honourable gentleman will confine his comments to the carry-over extension, and he may gesture all he likes at the Secretary of State. Can I remind him, I'm in the chair now.

08:28:11 - 08:28:30

Paul Kohler

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I remain to be convinced this bill, even after 156 amendments, can deliver on its essential function. And I'm concerned that we cannot properly scrutinise the proposed wording to see if it will. For these reasons, we will continue to oppose this motion.

08:28:30 - 08:31:07

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm voting in favour of this carry-over motion because we need to debate this and we need to have this bill. We need to have this for the future of peace in Northern Ireland. Not only are the victims of the terror attacks looking at this bill for us now, and many are with us here today, but also the eyes of the world are upon us. This is an international issue.

We have shown the way in bringing peace here to Northern Ireland with the peace agreement, with the Good Friday Agreement, which is the Labour Party's one of the proudest legacies that we have. And with the tireless work by community activists, by the members opposite in the different parties from Northern Ireland, representing a future full of peace. But to do that, we need to understand the past, Madam Deputy Speaker, and there are over a thousand families who have not got the answers about what happened to their loved ones. That is a pain that's almost too hard to tell for those families. They don't know what happened in the last minutes of their loved ones' lives.

They don't know who committed those atrocities. They don't know where they are in many circumstances. And that pain is being passed on through themselves to future generations who they understandably are really worried about. Today, I also met with members of the Wave community in Belfast. Sandra Peake and Wave do an amazing job of addressing the trauma, the trauma that's continuing.

And they do enable us as politicians to hear from some of the families. And they were hard to hear, but I want to share some of those words because that is why I support this carry-over motion. It's on their behalf. It's important to get legacy right now, or it will keep affecting our children and future generations, is what one victim said. It's important to have this motion debated and the right product set up so that we can move on.

One person said, my mum has been fighting for decades and she's now passed it on to me, but she should have the answers before it's too late. Someone else said, I really would like the truth. Who was responsible? People need the truth. People have been researching what happened in some cases for 20 years or more, for decades.

And they know some of the names, they've been able to piece some of it together. There's always the concern that there might be an investigative journalist knocking on the door with some of the answers, but with no actual investigation to back it up with, to say what really happened. One person said, yes.

08:31:07 - 08:31:31

Robin Swann

Listening to the very powerful message that the member's given, does she have a concern then that moving away from ICRIR and the work that has already been done, moving into a commission, that that trust, that search for truth will actually be lost and some families, some veterans, some victims may actually be put off the process because they see yet another body?

08:31:31 - 08:34:26

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you, and I really welcome that question because I think this act will enable us to build on the work of the ICRIR and prove itself. As the investigations go forward, and if this bill isn't agreed to, these won't go forward at the pace that they need to. Then that justice is stopped.

But I think it will prove itself and that more families will come to the commission in its new form, in a new improved form, and then more families will have answers. Otherwise, if we don't have, if we don't approve this carryover bill, that we don't approve the bill that's going to be behind it, we won't see that improvement for the commission, that it won't be able to continue doing the work. Too many of the court cases have been stopped because of the Legacy Act, too much justice has been stopped. And we now need this to go ahead at pace, and so that's why I'm supporting this motion tonight. The Conservative bill, the Legacy bill, led to too much, as I've said, being stopped, too much being halted.

More than a thousand police investigations, including investigations into deaths of over 200 members of our armed forces and civilians, were stopped. It failed to win the confidence of families and victims, it shut down civil claims, it halted inquests. So now we need that to, this good work of peace and reconciliation, to go ahead. At the same time, the government has rightly recognized, and I pay tribute to the former Secretary of State and the current Secretary of State for their work in delivering this. Because this bill rightly recognizes the need to protect veterans.

The overwhelming majority of those who served during Operation Banner, and several of my constituents have come to talk to me about what they did, they did that with courage, professionalism, and distinction in extraordinarily difficult circumstances. And the bill's protections against unnecessary repeat investigation, recognition of operational realities, and safeguards for witnesses will help to ensure that there will be fairness for those who served our country honorably. More than a quarter of a century after the Good Friday Agreement, Northern Ireland has made extraordinary progress, as I've seen for myself. But far too many families, the shadow of the troubles remains. We cannot change what happened or undo the enormous suffering that was inflicted, but we can ensure that families have the best possible chance of discovering the truth.

That chance will only continue to wither away if there's more delays in this, because it will be harder to get the evidence, harder to talk to witnesses, and harder to get to the truth. So this government has chosen not to look away, Madam Deputy Speaker, it has chosen to act. I therefore welcome this carryover motion and the bill that will follow, and the commitment it represents to victims, to survivors, to families, for the whole of the Northern Irish community, that there can be justice.

08:34:26 - 08:37:37

Gavin Robinson

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a pleasure to follow the former minister and enjoyed working with her in that role. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is incumbent upon me to make two initial points. The first is that we only have 30 minutes left in this 90-minute debate and this is the first substantive Northern Ireland contribution, and because of that I will keep my remarks as brief, and uncharacteristically brief, as I can. Can I also uncharacteristically welcome the tone of the Secretary of State in how he introduced this carryover motion.

It should be no surprise to him that I lament that we are here debating this. I lament the fact that a government who came in with such a majority on a promise of repeal and replace is doing neither. I resent the fact that it took 18 months for us to receive the bill a year ago, and our advice, my advice and the advice of my colleagues six, eight months ago was if you're going to so substantively amend the government's own legislation, it would be better to withdraw it and reintroduce it with a level of coherency and consistency so people can look at it and understand its implications properly.

What we have now is but one week. And I said this morning and I'll say again, I think it is deeply unfortunate for victims, for innocent victims and for veterans to have but a week to consider and to comprehend the import of the amendments, scores of them, sixty additional pages in this book, and to understand the impact that'll have on their quest and their rightful quest for truth and for justice. The Secretary of State will know if he's educated himself on these issues and the history of them that we didn't support conditional immunity. We don't support those measures and we are pleased to see some of the issues that the Secretary of State has opened today and released to the media and to parliamentarians yesterday. I lament that during the Legacy Act process that the former Secretary of State, now Brandon Lewis, did take on board a lot of the amendments that were tabled by myself and my colleagues but couldn't do it in this House of Commons, in this representative House of Commons, had to leave it to the House of Lords.

And here we have again series of amendment after amendment after amendment where the government, thankfully, finally have listened to some of the amendments that I have tabled, my parliamentary colleagues from the Democratic Unionist Party have tabled and those behind me in the Ulster Unionist Party, Traditional Unionist Voice, Independent and Alliance have done that but have tabled their own. Now I don't understand, I don't understand why the Labour government resisted for so long committing to legislate to rule out equivalence between those who upheld the law in Northern Ireland and those who set to destroy law and order in Northern Ireland, between veterans and paramilitaries. I am glad that that is going to be put beyond doubt because it was a statement of fact before and it should not have been resisted.

08:37:37 - 08:38:12

John Hayes

I'm grateful and the honorable gentleman is right to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the Secretary of State has tried to weave a certain degree of asperity and dexterity, a silk purse out of a sow's ear. We've ended with something satin and it may not be a purse at all, but what's certain is we need more time to consider that. It would be preposterous to have such a short time to consider those amendments offered, I suggest in goodwill, but goodwill needs to prevail and we need much, much more time to consider this than the very short time that's been allocated next week.

08:38:12 - 08:41:37

Gavin Robinson

I'm grateful to the right honorable gentleman and I'm pleased to see that there's a new Deputy Chair so I don't have to hold myself to the commitments that I made earlier on. Can I also say to the Secretary of State, I am pleased now, pleased that the government have accepted that they will legislate on the matter of on the runs, again a statement of fact, something I could never comprehend why the Labour government were resisting such an amendment. And so too that they're going to legislate to ensure that paramilitaries, former paramilitaries, people who sullied themselves and tried to destroy our society will not form part of any advisory board to the commission. That was right. I couldn't for the life of me understand why the Labour government was resistant to that approach and I am grateful, I am grateful.

No, it was always indicated that it wouldn't happen in practice but they would not legislate on the face of the bill. That's right. And I say they, I mean the Labour government, but I'm glad that at least that concession has been given. But I am grateful that the Prime Minister is here, I have to say, because I want to make a fundamental point and it draws on comments that were opened earlier and given the week that's in it, it's not often I agree with the honorable member for North Antrim, but I am pleased, I am pleased, I am pleased, I am pleased that he referred to what happened yesterday in the Omagh inquiry.

It is beyond me, and I hope it's beyond every sensible member of this house, that the government are still resisting the dates for the Legacy Commission. The Legacy Commission has to stop its work on a given date, the date the Belfast Agreement was signed. Yet the largest atrocity of the Troubles occurred just three months later in Omagh. And the government are resistant to allowing the Legacy Commission to consider the case of Omagh. Why is it important, Madam Deputy Speaker, because the Omagh inquiry is set up, its terms of reference only allow the inquiry to look at what the British state could have done to prevent the largest atrocity of the Troubles.

And yet the Irish government have questions to answer. And when John Ware yesterday, the former Panorama journalist, opened up his evidence in court, he referred to the Irish soldiers who received a bomb warning the day before, on the 14th of August, in Finner Base, as has been mentioned. And I have every word of that. I would ask the Secretary of State to ask immediately to get a copy of that document, because he knows it goes further. He knows it says very clearly on the 14th of April they have to inform the guards, and they have to inform NISF, Northern Ireland Security Forces, and they have to place people on the border checkpoints, BCPs 196, 194.

It was very clear, very precise. Why was it opened up yesterday? Because the belief is in a 1500-page bundle the Irish didn't know they'd given it, and they were worried it was going to be taken back and not opened up. If the Irish government had information that the Omagh bomb was going to be placed in Omagh the night before at Finner Base, as was opened yesterday in the inquiry, that needs to be explored. And yet it falls outside the terms of reference.

All we have asked in the amendments is that we legislate for ourselves to say that the Legacy Commission can at least consider the largest Troubles-related incident, though it sits outside the dates of the Troubles.

08:41:37 - 08:42:01

Jim Allister

I will, sir. And is his point not strengthened by the fact that the Dublin government, despite a recommendation from the Northern Ireland High Court, has refused to hold an inquiry into its role and knowledge of the Omagh bomb, and therefore the fact that the Legacy Commission can never investigate it means that it will never be investigated anywhere?

08:42:01 - 08:43:43

Gavin Robinson

He's absolutely right. And it was Mr. Justice Horner, as he then, maybe Lord Justice Horner, in 2021 declared there should be an inquiry on both sides of the border to deal with the jurisdictional issues. The Legacy Commission will have the ability to look at the issues, provided the dates, Prime Minister, are moved from the 21st of April 1998 to the 31st of August 1998. It's easily done, but it's so fundamentally important for those victims and those families who suffered at Omagh and require truth and require justice. And I make the plea, Madam Deputy Speaker, knowing that I'm going beyond the bounds of a carryover motion debate, that this is so fundamental that we cannot allow this point to pass where the government fail those families yet again.

And yesterday's revelation is as stark and as telling as it needs to be. The information shared yesterday falls outside the terms of reference, and yet the Legacy Commission should take on and could take on that work. I intend to revisit this again next week, Madam Deputy Speaker, but in the interim I would implore the Secretary of State, and I know I've raised this with him on numerous occasions, and the Prime Minister, and I'm grateful that he's here, to consider the import of what was shared yesterday in the inquiry, what was withheld from the Sir Peter Gibson review in the past where it was emphatically said the Irish had no warning, they had, and yet still the inquiry's chairman is incapable of drawing conclusions from it because it falls outside his terms of reference. This Legacy Commission could do that work, and it needs to be done.

08:43:43 - 08:43:54

Sarah Russell

Members will be aware that we are pressed for time and I am going to try to get as many people in as we can. So I'm reducing the time limit and we're having an immediate three-minute time limit. Al Carns.

08:43:54 - 08:47:05

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, I would like to thank the Secretary of State for the engagement he's undertaken throughout the process. Generals, veterans, veterans commissioners, ex-chiefs of defense staff, victims, those that live in Northern Ireland, he's engaged with them all and I think collectively they're very thankful for that. And indeed the government amendments are also welcome. They are moving absolutely in the right direction.

One thing I would just request on both sides of the house that underneath the victims, the soldier Bs, the soldier Fs, the passion, the emotion, there are human beings. And we've got to ensure that the message we send them in this house that we're after their best interest and remember that they will be watching this and it affects every single factor of their life. I also know what it's like to be in the dark faced against terrorists when you have to make snap decisions in a difficult environment. Unfortunately, I also know what it's like to console family members of lost loved ones. What I don't know what it's like, and I pay great tribute to the people in the gallery today, is to have all of that wrapped into a community, into neighborhoods and neighbor on neighbor, street on street.

And so I commend the individuals in the gallery today and thank you so much for attending. Now I resigned from government in part because I could not support the approach we were taking to legacy. In particular, I remain concerned about the different routes we were creating to examine the same conflict and some of the same incidents. Indeed, from my belief, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are adopting a twin-track approach to truth, justice and reconciliation. On one hand, we have inquests.

The chances of prosecution is vanishingly small, but the prosecution often isn't the end state. The process has become the punishment at a minimum cost of 20 million pounds on average with a maximum cost of 20 million per inquest. The total equates, as one policy exchange paper would put it, to in excess of a billion pounds of taxpaying money. Then on the other hand, we have the legacy commission. Let's build it.

Let's make it better. Let's make it the single route to truth, reconciliation and justice. It has more investigative powers, it can move faster and indeed it will bring the end state and a cost to the delivery a fraction of that of inquests. What other country delivers reconciliation through a twin-track approach? It just doesn't happen.

What I hope to highlight, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that whilst I will vote in support the carryover motion tonight, there is more to be done to streamline the route towards truth, reconciliation and justice. So my vote tonight should not be taken as support to the bill as it stands. I do believe there is better way and more work to be done. One route, one process, no more lawfare, no more twin-track approach, stop the legal exploitation of the system and put all the inquests through the legacy commission. So I will vote to carry the bill over tonight, but when we get to committee, it must change.

08:47:05 - 08:50:12

Robin Swann

Robbie Swan.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I move to talk about the carryover motion that we have in front of us tonight this evening because much of what we've heard from the Secretary of State was what we heard from the previous Secretary of State in regards to why we needed to see the remedial order rushed through, a remedial order that went nowhere. But now we're compensating and bringing it into the legislation that we've been asked to consider next week.

But I would reiterate the contribution from the right honorable member from East Belfast in regard to the number of amendments that have been laid before us in regards to considering the bill and the very short time that this government has given everybody to consider, not just the legislators in this house, but also the victims groups and the veterans, not just of the United Kingdom, but of Northern Ireland and those small family groups who will find it extremely difficult to work through that booklet of amendments to see how it applies to them, how it applies to their cause, how it applies to their loved ones and how it supports them in their search for truth in regards to that. So I would ask the Secretary of State to look to the timing of the committee stage and also to look in regards to what contribution Northern Ireland MPs will actually get to give in this house. And I would plead to the front benches of both the opposition and the government members, let's not use victims and veterans in Northern Ireland as political playthings. And we've heard that from the other side from the Labour benches and government, you are as bad at times as what we've seen from the opposition and the Lib Dem spokesman, I think has a lot to apologize for here tonight in regards to the opposition in regards to the topics that he brought forward in regards to that. So in regards to the bill that we have in front of us, I could ask the Secretary of State to look to the Keeling schedule, a schedule that actually sets out in legislation how amendments apply to current legislation and the amendments that have been brought forward and actually lays out in clarity what can be brought forward and how they amend because it does make a big difference.

And can I also say why we are here as well in regards to that. The Secretary of State strayed away from the carryover motion into some of them amendments. Can I ask them to look seriously and can I ask the government to look seriously at my amendment number four, which brings sexual crime under the remit of the new commission. And I know what the previous Secretary of State said, I know what the Northern Ireland Office said, but it is actually one of those things and it's often quoted in here that the previous government's troubles bill didn't receive any support from Northern Ireland parties. That amendment has support from every Northern Ireland MP who takes their seat in this house, as well as Labour members and Lib Dem members as well.

So could I ask the government seriously consider it and when I did meet the Secretary of State in regards to this, he was very open and honest and he said that the government would consider non-government amendments in regards to making this bill better because it has a long, long way to go before it could be acceptable to many in my community.

08:50:12 - 08:53:17

Alexander Robert Ballinger

Alex Ballinger.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I will be supporting the carryover motion today. I'd also like to pay tribute to the victims from the Wave Trauma Centre who, alongside many of us, have shared their powerful stories with parliamentarians the last two days. Nearly 30 years on from the Good Friday Agreement, these men and women are still seeking truth and justice for the awful crimes inflicted upon them. And with your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to share a couple of the stories that they shared with me. The first, the story of Jennifer Gillespie.

Jennifer was just 12 years old when masked Provisional IRA men broke into her house and took her and her mother hostage, forced her father Patsy to drive into an army checkpoint as a human bomb. Patsy, who was a civilian cook in the local barracks, was chained to the driver's seat of a van packed with a thousand pounds of explosives, followed by kidnappers in a separate car while his family was held at gunpoint. He was forced to drive into the checkpoint. As he approached, Patsy shouted a desperate warning to the troops guarding the checkpoint, but the IRA detonated the van, killing Patsy and five soldiers from the King's Regiment. And this was just one of three coordinated proxy bomb attacks that evening.

Jennifer and her mother Kathleen are still seeking justice so many years after this horrible attack.

I also met Mo Norton, whose brother Bombardier Terence Griffiths was one of 12 killed in the M62 bombings. A provisional IRA bomb was stowed in their coach luggage locker and exploded as the young soldiers and their families were returning to Catterick after their weekend's leave. Nine soldiers and three civilians were killed, including two children aged just five and two. Mo is still devastated after all these years and she and her family in Wigan are still seeking answers. I never served in Northern Ireland myself, but I have served alongside many soldiers and marines who have.

And they spoke of the constant threat of snipers and bombs, not knowing who amongst the local population might be trying to kill them or when they would strike. And they took on strict rules of engagement, serving alongside inside the United Kingdom among British citizens to protect them. And they fought paramilitaries unencumbered by those same rules as the cowardly attacks I described earlier explain. We owe a huge debt of gratitude to these veterans. But victims and veterans are not two separate groups.

264 members of our armed forces were murdered by terrorists. They had their unresolved cases terminated by the 2023 Legacy Act. And we owe these families a chance of justice. I believe the last Conservative government attempted in good faith to draw a line under the Troubles, but their offer of conditional immunity was unacceptable to bereaved families and the courts found it unlawful. The Legacy Act must be replaced.

Today's motion allows that work to continue. And the families have waited decades and so I urge the House to pass this carryover motion today and allow this bill to proceed.

08:53:18 - 08:56:03

Alex Easton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government asks the House to grant the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill a further extension of carryover. This is not a trivial request. Carryover extends the life of a bill and this House should not grant it lightly, particularly where the legislation in question remains as contentious as this. I ask a basic question: what will the extension actually achieve?

I am aware of the government's proposed amendments and the government will always be aware of the substance of the amendment I proposed, particularly encapsulating in their amendment that seeks to bar former paramilitaries from appointments to the Victims and Survivors Advisory Group. I welcome that. My proposed amendment has been substantially engaged with, but a single government amendment or amendments, however welcome, cannot cure a bill that must be judged in the round. Taken as a whole, this legislation remains substantially flawed. Behind this procedural motion lie real people.

Madam Deputy Speaker, victims and survivors who have waited decades for truth and acknowledgement. Veterans who served this country with courage and distinction, who now face the prospect of repeated investigations into the events from more than 50 years ago. And that's my impression. Isn't it the reality that neither group is served by legislation that commands the confidence of either? William Faulkner wrote: "The past is never dead.

It's not even past." Nowhere is that felt more keenly than in Northern Ireland. Families will seek answers about loved ones they lost. Veterans who served under extraordinary pressure deserve fairness and certainty in equal measure. We must also speak honestly about the history, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Around nine in ten Troubles-related deaths were caused by terrorist organisations, not by the state. Any legislative framework that does not reflect that reality with clarity and proportion risks compounding injustice rather than resolving it.

Lord Hewart reminded us over a century ago that justice must not only be done, but must be manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done. That principle cannot be satisfied by a bill extended through procedural convenience while its fundamental flaws remain unaddressed. Madam Deputy Speaker, carryover should be the exception, not the default, granted where a bill is close to being fit for purpose, not where it remains substantially flawed. Extension will not repair this. This House owes victims, survivors and veterans more than delay dressed up as progress.

08:56:03 - 08:56:07

Speaker 316

I urge members to oppose this motion tonight. Thank you.

08:56:07 - 08:56:08

Jonathan Brash.

08:56:08 - 08:56:43

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Politics is ultimately about confidence. Leaders cannot lead without the confidence of their party, a government cannot govern without the confidence of this House, and legislation cannot work without the confidence of the people it affects. The legislation passed by the previous government did not have the confidence of any party in Northern Ireland, victims' groups or ultimately the courts. But it is entirely apparent that this legislation has never had the confidence of veterans.

08:56:43 - 08:57:58

Speaker 320

And I genuinely believe it unlikely that it can be recovered. Veterans like Mick Male, a member of Hartlepool's Armed Forces Liaison Group, who came to my office to express his lack of confidence in this bill and who invited me to meet his veteran colleagues who said similar. Now, I fully appreciate the efforts of our new Secretary of State and his attempts to rescue this bill and restore that confidence, and also the efforts of my right honourable and gallant friend, the member for Birmingham Selly Oak, and his efforts to go further to restore confidence. And on balance, I believe these arguments deserve to be heard and debated. But my veterans in my community of Hartlepool deserve to be able to debate these as well.

And I'm deeply skeptical that in the next few days they will have the opportunity to make their views heard the way they should be allowed to to their elected representatives. And so I say very clearly to Mick and all the veterans in Hartlepool, if ultimately in just a few days' time this bill does not have their support, then it will not have mine.

08:57:58 - 08:58:00

Speaker 315

I call Sir David Davis.

08:58:00 - 09:00:55

David Michael Davis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With the Prime Minister sitting next to him, I hope it won't influence the future of the Secretary of State when I tell the House that he and I are very long-standing friends and even occasional allies. And he has obviously done all he can to mitigate what is a morally flawed bill. A year after the government introduced this bill, the central question remains unanswered. How will it deliver justice without subjecting soldiers who served lawfully and honourably to punitive investigation, endless punitive investigation?

My judgment hasn't changed since October's debate, nor April's. The bill was sold as a defense of human rights and the rule of law. I yield to no one in this House on human rights and defense of the rule of law, but this is not that. Instead, it's morally bankrupt and makes a mockery of both. If this bill was really about human rights and justice, the first coroner's inquest wouldn't be about whether the killings at Loughgall were unlawful.

It would instead be about one of the 1,800 murders carried out by the IRA, every single which, every single one of which was unlawful. The government unfortunately has prioritised its relationship with Dublin over its duties to its own veteran soldiers.

Ireland will undoubtedly come to regret its own role in this bill. Scrutiny of its actions during the troubles will show it was never the impartial party it's trying to present itself as now, but instead a partisan in a criminal insurgency. The Irish government provided active sanctuary for IRA terrorists. And justice cannot mean relentless scrutiny for British soldiers, but selective scrutiny for the Irish government. It must accept the scrutiny of itself that it demands of others.

And we might start with an independent review of its role in the Omagh bombing, which we've heard something of today. I'm afraid this is a nation much of whose politics is hostile to Britain. We shouldn't, we can't avoid that fact. And Britain must not sacrifice its soldiers for an illusory diplomatic advantage. This vexatious use of lawfare is designed with one intent.

It's to represent the behavior of IRA killers, murderers, vicious psychopathic murderers as somehow liberators, heroes, by destroying the reputations of our own soldiers. The government must not pursue this course. The government must drop this evil bill and start again.

09:00:55 - 09:00:57

Speaker 322

Sorch Eastwood.

09:00:57 - 09:02:05

Sorcha Eastwood

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's at times like this that you do feel very despondent. And I have to share some of the frustration expressed by the member from South Antrim tonight, where I don't think it is really ideal that I'm sitting here with 180 seconds to try and sum up what this carry-over motion and this means. The people of Northern Ireland have heard it all before. This is not perfect.

The manner in which it's being done is far from perfect. But people have died. People have died waiting. We have been at this in Northern Ireland for at least 20-odd years. I'm not going to stand in the way of any family.

I have held the hands of families, families who I know from my constituency, people who served, people who were innocent Catholics, people who were innocent Protestants. No one person is above anyone else. And I hope to God that those people in the gallery understand that tonight and they don't go away from this place despondent tonight. And I'm glad more people from Northern Ireland aren't listening to this. I really, really am.

09:02:05 - 09:02:19

Speaker 324

Because there's been a lot of grace lacking in this. A lot of grace. Let's stop playing games. No one has any right above another. It's been many, many years and many mistakes have been made.

09:02:19 - 09:02:50

Sorcha Eastwood

And all I want anybody in Lagan Valley and Northern Ireland and across the UK and wider afield where people have been drawn into what was such an intimate and insidious and disgusting conflict, I want them to know that you're seen and that you all matter. We're not going to get this 100% right. But if we don't act now, people will die. Many already have without the truth. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I will be supporting this carry-over motion tonight.

09:02:50 - 09:02:55

Speaker 321

And with the final one and a half minutes, I call Jim Allister.

09:02:55 - 09:04:19

Jim Allister

Speaker, the right honorable member for Goole and Pocklington put his finger on this matter. The genesis of this is important. The previous Secretary of State went to Dublin and entered a legacy framework agreement in September 2025, in good faith I'm sure on his part, where the Dublin government promised the fullest possible cooperation. Yet we saw exposed yesterday just how meaningless that is when it comes to the most serious and extensive terrorist attack there ever was, when they sat on the intelligence from the night before that there was a bomb heading to Omagh.

Omagh, Omagh, Omagh is what the message said and it was ignored. Secretary of State referred to the fact there were many cross-border dimensions to this. Yes, there are. There were hundreds of people whose killers crossed the border, took sanctuary in the south of the border, were supplied from the south of the border. And yet we're talking about a legacy arrangement where no answers will come from the Dublin government.

They were sent 52 questions by the Omagh inquiry. They answered two of them. That is the extent and scale of the good faith. And yet that is a government which tonight is still suing the United Kingdom government in the European Court of Human Rights.

09:04:19 - 09:04:31

Sarah Russell

Order. Order. Order. Under Standing Order number 80A, I must now put the question necessary to bring proceedings to conclusion. The question is as on the order paper.

09:04:31 - 09:05:36

Speaker 277

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. Division. Clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper.

09:05:36 - 09:05:45

Sarah Russell

As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. Tellers for the Ayes, Gregor Poynton, Harpreet Uppal. Tellers for the Noes, Rebecca Smith, David Simmonds.

09:14:44 - 09:14:45

Order! Order!

09:17:10 - 09:17:15

Speaker 326

Order. Order.

09:17:15 - 09:17:27

Speaker 328

The Ayes to the right 304, the Noes to the left 179.

09:17:27 - 09:17:45

Sarah Russell

The Ayes to the right were 304, the Noes to the left were 179. So the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. Point of order, David Davis.

09:17:45 - 09:18:00

David Michael Davis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In the rush to fit my speech into three minutes, I omitted to draw the House's attention to my entry in the Register of Members' Interests, some of which has direct relevance to Northern Ireland legislation. So I do so now.

09:18:00 - 09:18:10

Sarah Russell

I thank the honorable gentleman for his point of order. He's now put that matter on the record. We now come to motion number four relating to the Speaker's absence. Minister to move.

09:18:10 - 09:18:11

I beg to move.

09:18:11 - 09:18:25

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number five on adjournment, November, Christmas, and February.

Minister to move.

09:18:25 - 09:18:26

Move formally.

09:18:26 - 09:18:39

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number six on human rights.

Minister to move.

09:18:39 - 09:18:40

I beg to move.

09:18:40 - 09:18:52

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number seven on Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation.

09:18:52 - 09:18:53

I beg to move.

09:18:53 - 09:19:13

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. Division. Clear the lobby.

09:19:13 - 09:19:17

Speaker 325

The division is deferred until tomorrow. I can't tell the time.

09:19:17 - 09:19:23

Speaker 327

Motion number eight on Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation. Minister to move.

09:19:27 - 09:19:28

I beg to move.

09:19:28 - 09:19:32

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper as many as are of that opinion say aye.

09:19:33 - 09:19:34

Of the contrary no.

09:19:35 - 09:19:42

Sarah Russell

The division is deferred until tomorrow. Motion number nine on Trade Unions Minister to move.

09:19:42 - 09:19:43

I beg to move.

09:19:43 - 09:19:46

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper as many as are of that opinion say aye.

09:19:47 - 09:19:48

Of the contrary no.

09:19:48 - 09:19:50

Speaker 329

No.

09:19:50 - 09:19:57

Sarah Russell

The division is deferred until tomorrow. Motion number ten on iron and steel Minister to move.

09:19:57 - 09:19:58

I beg to move.

09:19:58 - 09:20:02

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper as many as are of the opinion say aye.

09:20:03 - 09:20:14

Sarah Russell

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number eleven on carbon border adjustment mechanism Minister to move.

09:20:14 - 09:20:15

I beg to move.

09:20:15 - 09:20:18

Sarah Russell

The question is as on the order paper as many as are of that opinion say aye.

09:20:19 - 09:20:20

Of the contrary no.

09:20:21 - 09:20:27

Sarah Russell

The division is deferred until tomorrow.

09:20:27 - 09:20:30

Speaker 330

I beg to move that this house do now adjourn.

09:20:30 - 09:20:36

Sarah Russell

The question is that this house do now adjourn. David Reed.

09:20:36 - 09:26:21

David Reed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a real pleasure to lead this evening's debate during Bone and Joint Week, raising awareness of an issue that affects millions of people but receives nowhere near the attention it deserves. I want to also start by thanking Arthritis UK and Arthritis and Musculoskeletal Alliance, known as ARMA, for the work raising awareness of these conditions and for the information they have provided ahead of this debate and for the parliamentary event they put on today. Musculoskeletal conditions or MSK conditions affect our bones, joints, muscles, and tissues that hold them together. They include arthritis, osteoporosis, chronic back pain, and joint injuries. For some, these conditions are manageable, for others, they are utterly debilitating, leaving people struggling to walk, work, or carry out basic everyday tasks.

More than twenty million people in the UK live with an MSK condition. Ten million have arthritis, including an estimated fifteen thousand people in my constituency of Exmouth and Exeter East. They are the single biggest cause of pain and disability in this country, accounting for around one in seven GP consultations. Yet I fear that we underestimate their seriousness, perhaps because they're not rarely immediately life-threatening. But while they may not kill people, they can slowly rob them of their mobility, independence, ability to work, and quality of life.

Now I want to explain why this matters to me personally. Six years ago this month, my life changed significantly, although I didn't know it at the time. It's something that I've avoided talking about publicly and if I'm honest, struggled to accept myself. But I believe we should draw on personal experience in this place, particularly when it might help improve our country. In October 2020, I was an extremely fit and physically robust former regular Royal Marine with multiple operational tours behind me.

I was also competing at the highest level of wingsuit skydiving as a member of the Team GB squad. Now I can see members thinking that those activities and MSK injuries are natural bedfellows and they're probably right. But nothing prepared me for the debilitating consequences of what happened that October. On a grey and windy day in Devon, I'd decided to go parachuting and now this was a near weekly occurrence. As a reservist member of the Royal Navy parachute display team, I needed to keep current for the following season.

I was practicing precision landings and convinced myself it would be good training. I also chose to wear trainers rather than my usual military boots, which provided ankle support. The plane took off and we climbed to 15,000 feet, the green light came on and I jumped. Everything went to plan until the landing. Rather than landing in the middle of the muddy field, away from obstacles, I decided to land closer to where I would be picked up.

I completed around seven hundred jumps and I wasn't frightened, this was like any other day. But what I did have is something far more dangerous, complacency. The winds were strong and the parachute center had restricted jumping for experienced parachutists only.

It was a lazy decision and it was a stupid one. As I approached the ground, gusting winds caught my parachute, lifted me and slammed me into the side of an aircraft hangar. My left foot took the initial impact before the rest of my body smashed into the building. My parachute went over the roof, leaving me dangling from the hangar. Fortunately, I remained conscious, managed to release my harness and fell the remaining five or so foot to the ground.

I remember lying there in shock, checking everything was still attached, then came the searing pain in my left ankle. My wife came and picked me up and drove me straight to A&E. After examinations and scans, I was told that I had suffered a severe sprain. I was advised to get the ankle moving and seek private physiotherapy because timely NHS support was unlikely to be available. Having had little experience of the NHS, I trusted that advice.

Over the following months, I worked hard at rehabilitation. Gradually I regained strength, but I remained in considerable pain. I took the classic Royal Marine approach, crack on and hope it gets better. Having served alongside men who lost limbs in Afghanistan, I considered myself lucky and I certainly wasn't going to complain about a sore ankle. But six months later, something was clearly wrong.

My physiotherapist recommended an MRI, which I paid for privately because again I was advised that the NHS process would take too long. And when the results came back, I had to catch my breath. My ankle had been broken the entire time. The fracture had been missed at A&E and I had spent six months rehabilitating an injury that had never been properly diagnosed. I was then advised to see a private consultant, again because of the time it would take to access specialist help through the NHS.

And this is where I was incredibly fortunate. By complete chance, the consultant I went to see happened to be ex-forces himself. Having discussed my injury and background, he suggested I come see him through his NHS practice where he could continue to oversee my treatment. I'm enormously grateful for him for doing so. After months of uncertainty, pain and frustration, I finally felt I had someone who understood the problem and could help me work out what came next.

And I want to make an important point here. My experience has left me deeply frustrated with parts of the NHS, particularly the difficulties accessing timely diagnosis and treatment. But it's also shown me that there are some outstanding people working within it, who go well beyond for their patients, above and beyond for their patients.

09:26:21 - 09:26:24

Speaker 335

Of course. Jim Shannon.

09:26:24 - 09:27:23

Jim Shannon

First of all, may I thank and commend the honourable gentleman for Exeter for bringing this forward. I spoke to him this morning to ensure he would be okay to let me have an intervention. And I want to underline from Arthritis UK, they have said that there's an escalating musculoskeletal health crisis. In Northern Ireland, some 550,000 people are now living with arthritis or another similar condition in Northern Ireland, nearly one third of the population. Those living in chronic pain face the long, painful waits, just the very thing the honourable gentleman refers to, with some reporting waiting for up to eight years for a rheumatology appointment.

Many are unable to work or live independently as a result, and almost 80% report their mental health has deteriorated significantly. It's not just the physical part, it's also the mental health. So does the honourable member agree that while more must be done to reduce the waiting lists, we must also ensure that in the interim, patients living with chronic pain have timely access to appropriate mental health support?

09:27:23 - 09:34:34

David Reed

I thank the honourable gentleman from Strangford for his intervention. They're points that I'm going to come on to, but he is completely right. We have to look at these problems within the round, because it's not just physical health, it's mental health, and people that were once fit lose that fitness both physically and mentally, and then they are a bigger burden then on the state.

But I will come to those points. Going back to the surgeon that helped me out. I've been fortunate to have benefited from that care. But I also recognize that I was lucky. At the time, I had the means to access private treatment.

And through that process, happened to find a consultant who could help me back into the NHS system. That should not be a matter of luck. And it certainly shouldn't be dependent on someone's ability to pay. Six years on, despite the excellent care I now receive, I am left with osteoarthritis that can at times be severely debilitating. I can no longer run.

I avoid activities that cause my arthritis to flare up. And I face the prospect of eventually having the bones in my ankle surgically fused. For the first few years, I held on to the hope that I would recover and return to active life, the active life I once had. I have now accepted that I most likely won't. That's difficult when physical fitness and independence have been such important parts of your life.

And at times, it has been an incredibly lonely journey. My NHS, my current NHS consultant gives me hope that advances in medical technology may offer better options. But because I limp, other bones and joints are now beginning to suffer. I know that I'm likely to place increasing demands on the NHS in the decades ahead. Now, my experience has shown me that a health service that can be brilliant at dealing with life-threatening emergencies, but can be pretty poor when it comes to conditions considered less serious, even when they fundamentally change someone's life.

And I was fortunate enough to be able to afford private care. Millions of people can't. They are left waiting, living with pain, and sometimes watching manageable conditions develop into lifelong disabilities. And that brings me to the wider purpose of this debate, Madam Deputy Speaker. People living with MSK conditions are around one and a half times more likely to experience mental health problems.

And I understand why. When pain becomes part of everyday life and you can no longer do the things you enjoy, it takes a toll. But there is another dimension that we must urgently address in this house. The economic cost of doing nothing. In 2024 alone, 26.5 million working days were lost to MSK conditions.

Arthritis UK estimates that working days lost to osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis cost 2.58 billion pounds in 2017, with that figure projected to reach 3.43 billion by 2030. Around 646,000 working-age people claiming sickness or disability benefits cite an MSK condition as their primary reason. Now, I'm not suggesting that they can all return to work or that every disability is preventable. But I do believe that too many people deteriorate when early intervention might have kept them healthy, independent, and economically active. Imagine someone working in construction, hospitality, or healthcare.

They develop a back problem or knee injury. They cannot access timely treatment, so they carry on through the pain. Eventually, they cannot carry on. They fall out of work, their health deteriorates, and they become increasingly dependent on public services. The taxpayer potentially picks up the bill several times over through the NHS treatment, welfare payments, and lost tax revenue.

And the individual pays an even greater price. We focus too much on the immediate cost of treatment without considering the potentially much greater cost of failing to treat someone early.

Surely, this is economically illiterate. If timely physiotherapy, imaging, or specialist intervention could prevent lifelong disability or someone losing their job, we should see it as an investment, not simply as another NHS cost. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is not all doom and gloom. There is, however, reason for optimism. In my constituency of Exmouth and Exeter East, the Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust held its first MSK community appointment day in Exmouth.

More than 100 people attended, accessing clinical assessment, rehabilitation advice, and community support together. Patients particularly valued being listened to. Early results suggested fewer unnecessary follow-ups. Now, one pilot does not provide all the answers, but it does show what can happen when services are organized differently and patients receive joined-up support. Now, that brings me to my questions for the Minister.

First, where is the national leadership on MSK health? The previous government recognized MSK as one of six major conditions in its major conditions strategy, yet it has not received a firm commitment to a dedicated modern service framework under the current government. Will the Minister commit to establishing such a framework with clear accountability and measurable outcomes? Will the Minister also commit to a national approach with clear responsibility and a measurable outcomes and meet ARMA to discuss it? And I thank the Shadow Health Minister, my honorable friend the member for Sleaford and North Hykeham, who has tabled an amendment to the recent Health Bill calling for just a framework, just such a framework.

Second, what more can be done to improve early diagnosis and timely access to rehabilitation, preventing avoidable deterioration while patients wait? Third, will the government work across the Department of Health and Social Care, the Department for Work and Pensions, and the Treasury to properly assess the economic case for early intervention? And lastly, Madam Deputy Speaker, as a veteran, I want to raise veteran issues. MSK injuries are a major reason for medical discharge from the armed forces, and their consequences can follow people long after they leave service. Will the Minister work with defense colleagues to improve access to rehabilitation for veterans and examine whether the Armed Forces Covenant properly addresses their long-term MSK needs?

Because it cannot make sense for any one part of government to save money by delaying treatment, only for another part to spend considerably more dealing with the consequences. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll finish where I began. Six years ago, I was a soldier. I could run for miles, jump out of aircraft, and represent my country in sports. Today, I have to think about every physical activity and the associated cost in pain for doing so.

I don't share that to seek sympathy. I share it because I understand how profoundly an MSK condition can alter someone's life. And millions of people across this country are living with far worse circumstances than mine.

09:34:34 - 09:35:31

James Frith

Minister.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by congratulating the honorable member for Exmouth and Exeter East on not just securing this debate on bringing bone and joint health to the floor of the House during Bone and Joint Week, but also for his personal insights and personal testimony. Can I also thank him for his service and give him the assurance that I am very happy to talk veterans, very happy to talk specifics and the insights he has as to how we look after and deliver on the Armed Forces Covenant as somebody that signed Berry's first Armed Forces Covenant when I was Armed Force Champion, not the service level that he was accustomed to, but I take very seriously our need as a country in debt to men and women who have put themselves in harm's way or given the ultimate sacrifice in service to their country.

09:35:31 - 09:35:36

Speaker 337

So thank I thank him. I thank him. I'll give way.

09:35:36 - 09:36:03

Jim Shannon

Can I say that the the I was trying to get in just before the honorable gentleman had sat down but while one door closed when he had when the honorable gentleman had his injury another door opened. The open the door that opened was the to be the MP to be here to represent those people. So the honorable member has an opportunity to speak up for all those people who have the injuries and that's the door and that's the voice that the honorable gentleman has now.

09:36:03 - 09:43:45

James Frith

I thank the honorable member for his intervention and as ever our honorable friend sees the upside and the half glass full of every of life's experiences. Can I also continue by thanking and paying tribute to the charities, clinicians, researchers, carers and campaigners who support patients and refuse to let these conditions be overlooked. Bone and joint conditions are too often overlooked or dismissed as an inevitable part of aging or frailty and they are not and nor should we accept them as that. Arthritis, osteoporosis, fragility fractures and other musculoskeletal conditions MSK can mean relentless pain, loss mobility, loss confidence, loss work, loss independence. In 2024 almost one in five adults in England reported a long-term MSK condition.

That is not a niche issue. It's a national challenge. Our task is clear: diagnose early, earlier, treat faster, prevent more illness and help people remain active and independent. The government's 10-year health plan is built around three decisive shifts: hospital to community, analog to digital and sickness to prevention. For people with MSK conditions that means simpler access and the ability to refer themselves through the NHS app to services including physiotherapy, pain management and orthopedics.

And if I may the honorable gentleman sought advice as to how we educate sooner, inform sooner. The work that we are doing with the single patient record, the new iteration of the NHS app, the development of NHS online or digital doctor as I'm calling it internally is about providing that useful information in timely manner as accessible as we have become accustomed to in how we consume information online whether through retail or consumer habits. That is the level of expectation we should have for services as this which can give our future patients the certainty and knowledge that they might otherwise endure pain whilst waiting to access at a later point. It's really important distinction. On osteoporosis we are acting before the fracture not merely after it.

This March the government invested 2.6 million in 20 new DEXA scanners across England following 1.9 million for the 13 scanners last year. Earlier scans means earlier treatment and fewer painful life-changing fractures especially for older people and women. Patients must also benefit from effective medicines. Since 2022 NICE has recommended Eladinos and Evenity for osteoporosis in postmenopausal women an important distinction within the debate. Both strengthen bones and reduce fracture risk.

The UK National Screening Committee is reviewing the case for screening women for osteoporosis.

Its consultation closed last week, we will consider its independent recommendation carefully when it reports. We must be frank. Community waiting lists for MSK remain the longest of any community service. Every delay means can mean more pain, less mobility, and a greater risk that somebody leaves work or loses independence. And I agree with the point that he raises of ensuring a cross-departmental approach to ensure the support is timely to prevent people going off work and losing their income and their identity and their self-esteem and worth and everything we understand to come with with forced departure from work.

That is why getting it right first time MSK community delivery program is backed by around 6 million in 26-27. It is redesigning services, improving referrals and connecting patients to wider support. The first cohort saw waits over 18 weeks fall by around 20% in participating systems. That is real progress and we must spread it. We are also expanding MSK physical activity hubs.

They use the skills of the leisure and fitness workforce to improve mobility, reduce pain and fatigue and help people stay in or return to work. The principle is simple. Care should come to people, not force people to navigate the maze. Throughout neighborhood health, community MSK services, physiotherapy and occupational therapy will support recovery, protect mobility and manage long-term conditions closer to home. We have a set clear national ambition by 2028-29, at least 80% of community health services activity should take place within 18 weeks.

National guidance will define a consistent core offer and bear down on unacceptable variation or postcode lottery. General practice is often the front door. We are increasing capacity so patients are seen sooner and urgent cases are directed to the right care on the same day. Elective recovery matters. We remain committed to the constitutional standard by March 2029.

92% of patients treated within 18 weeks. For bone and joint conditions, that means stronger links between primary, community and hospital care and faster access to specialist advice. Women's health must be central to this argument as well, not peripheral. Menopause-related hormonal changes raise the risk of osteoporosis and frailty. The renewed women's health strategy therefore focuses on earlier recognition, easier access, better treatment and practical support at work.

Bone and joint health is an inequalities issue as well. Chronic MSK conditions are a major cause of poor health and work limitation, often alongside mental ill health as the gentleman has described. And obesity, as well as often concentrated in poorer communities. A postcode must not determine whether pain is relieved, mobility restored or independence protected. Reducing delays and unwarranted variation is not an optional extra, it's a matter of principle of fairness.

So in conclusion, let us reject the idea that these conditions are simply to be endured. Pain is not inevitable, disability is not inevitable, a life-changing fracture is not always inevitable. Earlier identification, effective treatment, rehabilitation, prevention, all change lives. And save the NHS the greater cost of acting too late. So I thank again the honorable member for his service and for securing this debate and all those working through bone and joint action week.

The government will work with the NHS, local government, clinicians, charities and patients to turn ambition into action. Fewer fractures, shorter waits, better mobility and more people living independently for longer. Thank you.

09:43:45 - 09:43:51

Sarah Russell

The question is that this house do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.