Westminster Hall

20 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:16 - 00:20
Speaker 2
Order, order.  Fleur Anderson to move the motion. 
00:20 - 05:24
Speaker 3
Thank you very much, Sir John.  It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.  And I thank all my constituents in Putney who've written to me, attended public meetings and taken part in the recent consultation on Heathrow expansion.  And I'm really grateful for this debate today and the opportunity to explain why the Mayor of London, so many London MPs and so many Londoners continue to oppose the enormous expansion of Heathrow, the third runway and all that comes with it.  And I'm also grateful to the Prime Minister and the Minister for Aviation for engaging with the concerns that I and many others have raised. 

The proposal on the table is a would be significantly adversely affecting the health and wellbeing of three million people living by Heathrow.  There'd be a 58% increase in flights.  Under this expansion proposal, the number of flights would increase by 276,000 per year, that's 756 per day.  And this debate comes at an important moment in the decision making about this proposal too, we're only weeks after the government's consultation on the draft Heathrow expansion national policy statement which closed on the 1st of September, and only days before Heathrow launches its own consultation on its expansion plans on the 27th of October.  Yet Heathrow is consulting on the expansion before the government has completed the policy framework which would govern it. 

That's the wrong way round.  Before taking a decision of this magnitude, we should ask a simple question.  Would Parliament make the same decision today, knowing what we know now, as it was asked to make when the Airports Commission reported and made the proposal in 2015?  And my case today is that I do not believe that it would.  In 2015, the Airports Commission's case rested on assumptions about jobs, growth, aviation demand, sustainable aviation fuel, carbon reduction and regional economic benefits. 

But many of these assumptions now have been blown apart and now look considerably weaker.  So I'm going to whiz through eight major things that have changed since 2015, Chair, and I'm going to also talk about three important things that have not changed since 2015.  So first of all, I'm going to focus on the major central justification for expansion, the economic case, which I believe has collapsed.  The government's own figures tell a very different story from the one we were told a decade ago.  In 2015, the Airports Commission estimated that expansion could boost GDP by around 20 billion pounds to 23 billion pounds. 

Earlier this year, supporters of expansion were still citing figures around 13 billion pounds.  However, the Department for Transport's appraisal in the NPS documents estimate GP increase of just 0.03 to 0.05% by the 2050s, equivalent of just roughly 900 million to 1.5 billion over decades. 

The headline economic benefit used to justify Heathrow expansion has therefore fallen from 20 billion to perhaps little more than 1 billion.  A project once sold as transformational now delivers an impact that's barely measurable in the context of a 3 trillion pound economy.  These figures would raise serious questions for any major infrastructure project.  The second is jobs.  In 2015, the Airports Commission argued that a third runway could support around 70,000 new jobs across the UK by 2050. 

Yet the government's own analysis again suggests much of the effects from jobs being relocated rather than created.  The DfT estimates that Heathrow expansion could draw around 21,400 jobs into the Heathrow area while contributing to losing approximately 15,200 jobs elsewhere in the UK.  Moving jobs from one region to another is not the same, obviously, as creating new jobs.  Third, the premise of spreading growth across the UK has changed.  The government cannot demonstrate that growth generated would be genuinely additional. 

If jobs, passengers, and investment is simply drawn from other airports and regions, Britain is not creating growth, it's just relocating it.  Analysis from the New Economics Foundation suggests Birmingham Airport alone could lose around 7.5 million passengers annually by 2050, alongside approximately 9,500 jobs across the airport and its supply chains.  Devolution and Number 10 in the North is going in one direction, but the Heathrow expansion being so concentrated on London and the South East takes us in another.  At a time when ministers want to spread opportunity more evenly across the country, quite rightly, Heathrow expansion risks doing precisely the opposite. 
05:24 - 05:25
Will my honorable friend give way? 

05:25 - 05:27

Speaker 4

Certainly.

05:27 - 05:51

Rupa Huq

I'm grateful to my honorable friend. She's making a really powerful point. And does she not agree that our now Prime Minister when he was Mayor warned many times that Heathrow expansion would suck the life out of regional airports? Is that not now more true than ever? And also he's really into devolution.

Our Mayor, your Mayor, my Mayor, sorry, the Mayor of the City of London, Sadiq Khan, is also against, so he should listen to our Mayor as well.

05:51 - 08:21

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Absolutely. And I would absolutely agree with my right honorable friend because that is the context of this debate. It has changed. And that's my point. Things have changed since 2015.

We're looking again at devolution and growth across the country. And that context means that Heathrow, especially when you've got the Mayor of London opposing it so strongly, really needs to be looked at again. And a fourth area is that business travel has changed. The world that produced the case for the original third runway no longer exists. Much of the demand modeling made then assumed ever-increasing business travel.

But the pandemic accelerated a permanent shift towards remote working and video conferencing. Research highlighted by the New Economics Foundation shows that over two decades before the pandemic, the UK GDP grew by around 25%, whilst business passenger numbers through UK airports showed virtually no growth at all. Today, business travel remains at about 20% below pre-pandemic levels. So the whole fundamental assumption about business travel is no longer there. Fifth, assumptions about sustainable aviation fuel have changed.

It was meant to be the great white charger that would come galloping over the hills, that we'd all be using sustainable aviation fuel and that's the answer to all the climate problems. But use is far less than predicted and is growing more slowly than predicted. It still accounts for far less than 1% of global aviation fuel use. And even under the government's own plans, around 90% of aviation fuel in 2030 would still be conventional fuel.

In effect, the Parliament is being asked to approve additional emissions now on the basis that future technology might solve the problem sometime later, but that's really not being borne out. Sixth, the climate challenge has become far more acute. The Climate Change Committee's conclusion in their report last month was clear: the UK does not currently have a credible pathway to reduce aviation emissions in line with net zero while accommodating Heathrow expansion. The committee estimates that expansion would add an additional 2.4 million tonnes of carbon dioxide every year by 2050. That's roughly the equivalent of putting around half a million additional petrol cars on Britain's roads.

It's equivalent to the whole emissions of Denmark and more than the whole emissions of New Zealand. After the summer of extreme heat...

08:21 - 08:50

Alex Sobel

Certainly. Thank you. When I was first elected, which is now nine years ago, we had people coming saying that new technology in aviation, electric planes, hydrogen planes, and SAF would significantly reduce emissions by, I think, last year, and none of that has happened. So all of these assumptions are being made on new technology which hasn't arrived and will not arrive, and we will break through our carbon budget just on increased aviation, particularly if we go ahead with third runway. Doesn't she agree?

08:50 - 12:45

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

I absolutely agree with my right honourable friend, and I thank him for that intervention, which speaks for the views of so many people are saying this, were saying this a long time ago. Look at the assumptions, but now we've got more facts about those assumptions. We know what's actually come to place, and it's not all that was promised. At a time when households, motorists, and businesses are being asked to reduce emissions, and after the summer we've just had of extreme weather, why would we seek permission to increase emissions by so much? Seventh, our understanding of the health impacts of noise has changed.

Noise is not just an inconvenience, it's not something to get used to. We know the impact on many, many health conditions now, on heart conditions, on mental health and many other ways. So this new knowledge about the impact of noise and what that will be on so many millions of extra people really should give the government pause for thought. And at the very least, the government should commit to a full seven-hour night flight ban between 11:00 PM and 6:00 AM, with a pathway towards an eight-hour ban in the future. That respite is so, so important for my constituents.

Eighth, our expectations on air quality have changed. London is now the world's largest clean air zone. The Putney High Street used to be one of the most polluted high streets in the country and is now just the same as other high streets. That's been through a lot of hard policy and hard work. The ultra-low emission zone covers every London borough and has reduced harmful nitrogen dioxide concentrations in central London by more than 50%.

There's been heavy investment on improving our air quality, but this pollution from Heathrow Airport would take us in the other direction. So those are eight things that have changed since 2018, and I'm sure the minister is listening very carefully to them all. But there are three things that haven't changed. First, there's no funding plan for the surface transport to go along with the airport. So I have been asking this question of Treasury ministers ever since the proposals came out: will the government be funding the ground transport?

No. I've been asking Heathrow: will Heathrow be funding the ground transport? No, they will not. So we've got a massive gap here about the amount of people who will be travelling to Heathrow Airport, what will they travel on, and I think this will be a real millstone around the government's neck in the future. Secondly, one thing that hasn't changed is that Heathrow is the wrong location for a hub airport of this scale.

For areas like Northern Ireland, and I know we have a member from Northern Ireland here, for Liverpool, Manchester, for Scotland, if you looked at the UK and decided where to put a hub airport, really would you put it next to one of the most densely populated parts of the whole country, or would you put it in the middle of the country? Would you put it in next with an airport that already had two runways, maybe, like Manchester?

And thirdly, another thing that hasn't changed, we do not have a national aviation strategy. Why are these decisions being made piecemeal? We've got Gatwick and Luton and now Heathrow. Where's the overall strategy for this? What are the, what's the decision making behind it?

Why don't we step back, look at what kind of aviation growth we want, need, where we want that to be, and then put this decision within that? So Chair, when the Airports Commission recommended Heathrow expansion in 2015, it asked the public and Parliament to accept a trade-off. Accept the noise, accept the environmental impact, accept the disruption, because the rewards would be worth it. We were promised transformational economic growth across the United Kingdom. But more than a decade later, we find a very different situation.

Those foundations, those assumptions are very weak. The projected economic gains are smaller than promised. Yes, certainly.

12:45 - 13:22

Alex Sobel

I think one point she didn't raise, which I think is really concerning, is the amount of houses that would be demolished and people displaced. Heathrow's own assumptions, less than a thousand, but that's only really the direct curtilage of the runway. If you look at anybody with even a quite a casual look at a map would see that the uninhabitable zone around Heathrow could be north of 5,000 homes. And who would pay for the demolition, the replacement, the compensation to those homeowners? That is something alongside ground transport that nobody's willing to pay for.

And that's an exceedingly large amount of money and also misery for those people that live there.

13:22 - 15:11

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

I absolutely have all of those communities in my mind, and I thank the member for that intervention, and I'm sure I will be hearing more of that from other members who are sitting here in the hall today, who represent those communities who will be so directly affected. And that's what I mean about the national strategy. That would be a very big factor. How many communities will be affected? What's the trade-off here?

And why again would you choose to put this hub airport next to London, which affects more people than all of the other major hub airports across Europe? Five hub airports there have fewer people affected than by this one because it's so close to London. It's not the place you would put it in if you started from scratch. So this, there was a trade-off that Parliament was being asked to have with the negative effects but the economic gains. But that whole equation has just crumbled now.

This is no longer the proposition that Parliament was presented with in 2015. It asks communities to accept many more dangers and harms but for less certain benefits. Every day my constituents live with the consequences of Heathrow. Asking them to accept more flights, more noise, more disruption requires a really compelling national case, and we just don't have it here. If the growth is smaller, the jobs are less certain, the benefits are less widely shared than promised, the responsible thing to do is not to simply press ahead regardless.

It's to stop. It's to look again. And so I hope that when the time for conclusion comes, the Minister will conclude that a third runway at Heathrow is not right for the country. Thank you.

15:11 - 15:12

Jim Shannon.

15:12 - 18:58

Jim Shannon

Mr Chairman, a real pleasure to serve on your chairmanship. And first of all, can I thank the honourable lady for Putney for setting the scene. The honourable lady and I are good friends, so I've spoken to the honourable lady beforehand, and the honourable lady and I will have a difference of opinion in relation to that. And I'll try to outline the reasons why that's the case, Mr Chairman. And I do respect everybody else's point of view, and I hope that others will respect my point of view as well.

The proposed expansion of Heathrow Airport is expected to support some 108,000 jobs across the United Kingdom, making it a very significant source of economic growth. The third runway would increase the capacity, provide for more affordable travel, and increase the reliability of flights across the UK. Airports are recognising the need to plan ahead, and I want, if I can, just give some figures and stats, ever mindful how much I respect the honourable lady and her opinion in relation to this, and probably others within this chamber here today as well. Heathrow is the UK's gateway to growth that connects people, businesses from all parts of the country to global opportunities and serves as the UK's only hub airport, the ones that we use from Belfast to be fair. The challenge is that Heathrow is operating at 99% capacity and has been for decades, which is why the third runway is imperative for the growth of this country.

Indeed, it's bursting to grow, I would suggest. Heathrow continues to perform strongly, but passenger growth is now trailing the European average. Heathrow is 1.9% where Europe is 4.6%. Heathrow's expansion is expected to add some 17 billion annually to the UK economy. 60% of the economic benefits will be outside of London and the South East.

In other words, the reason why I'm here as an MP for Northern Ireland is because I want to put forward how that will benefit us from Northern Ireland and how we see things in relation whenever it comes to government here centrally doing something, it has to be for everybody's advantage across this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The 33 billion pound of private investment into Britain, it supports the jobs, the exports, the manufacturing and economic growth at no cost to the taxpayer. So it is advantageous. Benefits begin well before the first flight and the wider economic prize goes beyond conventional transport modelling. Heathrow's expansion builds on an existing UK 1,100 business supply chain, creating the opportunities for companies across every region of the country, by way of example, Wolverhampton's Zone, there's many other places, Durham-based Coltraco as well and the Ultrasonics rely on Heathrow's connectivity.

These are just some of the companies across the United Kingdom. But for us in Northern Ireland, it's really important that we have the connectivity and look to that. Heathrow has stated this isn't a choice between the economy and the environment. It and they say can deliver both. And I think if they can show that to do that, then that's something that must be considered.

Expansion as well, they've also said we've seen a 7.5% carbon reduction in air emissions in last year compared to 2019. Again, some of the factual evidential evidence. There's also been a reduction to the noise footprint by 60% since the early 1990s. Again, I would say that shows that there has been a commitment in relation to that. I'm very happy to give way to the honourable lady, yes, absolutely.

18:58 - 19:14

Rupa Huq

I'm grateful to him for giving way with some statistics. I just wanted to give him another one. We've got the largest clean air zone on earth in London. Nitrous oxide emissions have been cut by 54%. Wouldn't that be at risk by Heathrow expansion?

19:14 - 20:29

Jim Shannon

Well, I thank the honourable lady for her intervention and as always she gives an intervention that's very, very helpful. I would suggest that those who are looking to the expansion of the third runway at Heathrow have indicated that those are issues that they can address.

And I think that we've got to give them the chance to do just that. In Northern Ireland, plans have been proposed to increase Belfast City Airport capacity, because we see the growth for us in Belfast City. It's my airport that I normally use. Others may use Belfast International Airport. But there is an opportunity, and I know in my discussions and the discussions with the member for East Belfast in particular, we've had been indicated to us that the growth that they have for Belfast City is helpful and connected and part of the third way runway for Heathrow as well.

The minister obviously is betwixt a rock and a hard place in this one, I suspect. But does the minister not agree that we do have to have a forward-thinking approach and support the infrastructure needed for future air travel? Because that's what we're trying to do is the connectivity between Heathrow and Belfast. And I see the honorable member for Doncaster here, who has ambitions for Doncaster Airport as well. We must build.

20:29 - 21:10

Lee Pitcher

Absolutely, yes. I thank my honorable friend for giving way. Yesterday we had the amazing news that Doncaster Sheffield Airport, an agreement has been reached to bring that back into local public ownership. That's going to create jobs and growth and be amazing for our area, particularly when you think about NEETs and the challenges that we have around that and the opportunity it can give for cabin crew and ground staff and pilots potentially in the future. I just wonder if my honorable friend agrees with me that when we're talking about expansion of Heathrow, we must also consider just the importance of those regional hubs and those regional airports too as we go forward as part of a strategy.

21:10 - 23:35

Jim Shannon

Yeah, I'm sure this is James Grundy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And first of all, can I thank the honorable member for that. And the honorable member deserves some credit in the time he's been in this House for the hard work that the honorable member has done to ensure that there's a way forward for Doncaster Airport. And he can take some of the credit for that, because it's been one of his primary, primary objectives in this House.

We must build for the future. We must support economic growth of the UK as a whole, and the honorable gentleman said that. And there's no better time to invest in these projects than right now. Heathrow Airport expansion is not just a London issue. It's a vital national infrastructure project that's absolutely critical to strengthening our entire union, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Because we want to promote that, concentrate upon it, and help it to happen. The London to Belfast corridors are amongst the absolute busiest domestic routes in the United Kingdom. Yet our businesses and families face constant crippling flight cancellations, slot restraints that isolate Northern Ireland from global markets. The hope for us with this to happen, the third runway at Heathrow and the expansion of Belfast City Airport, that the two can grow together and provide for our businesses and families who face the constant crippling flight cancellations, but also to and the slot constraints that isolate Northern Ireland from global markets. There can be no doubt that a third runway is urgently required to guarantee and protect vital regional slots for Northern Ireland, for Scotland, for Wales, for Doncaster.

Ensuring that every single corner of the United Kingdom benefits from global connectivity. The third runway, Mr. Chairman, I finish with this. The third runway will ensure that connectivity remains throughout the UK, and it is essential that this is a material consideration. Often it is talked about in terms of more holiday routes. It's not just holiday routes.

It's domestic connections as well for us, Belfast City to London, and those who want to go further in relation to holiday routes. This is important, but those businesses based in Northern Ireland, connections from London to Belfast in a reliable manner are the lifeblood. And we cannot afford for this to be cut off. And for this reason, I say respectfully to honorable members in this room, right honorable and honorable members, that I do support this extension. I think it's beneficial for Northern Ireland.

23:35 - 23:44

Speaker 11

I see the advantages coming through jobs, opportunities for connection, for building this United Kingdom where there is ability to grow it and supporting this and putting the needs for Northern Ireland very much before all of the honorable members here for their consideration. Thanks so much.

23:44 - 23:46

Speaker 8

Robbie Moore.

23:46 - 32:39

John Martin McDonnell

Thank you, Chair. I almost feel like publishing one of the Hansards from the dozen debates we've had on this over the last number of years. And we need to just get real. The reason we're having this debate is because the former Chancellor, when developing a speech for growth, wanted an example. And she just went for the third runway.

I can't find anyone in government at the moment seriously who privately thinks this is going to go ahead. That's where we're at. We're going through, this is a Monty Python sketch. This is the dead parrot sketch all over again. All right.

And because we're in this debate, I'll, as I always do, I'll just remind people what it means in human terms for my constituents, because that's my job. Okay, it's been mentioned. It's four and a half thousand homes will be either demolished or rendered unlivable by noise and air pollution. We think now that's 17,000 people displaced to ensure the profits of a company owned by a whole range of foreign multinationals, basically. A number of schools that'd be closed.

I held my first third runway meeting, I set up the Third Runway Action Group in 1983 in Harmondsworth School. We had to demolish that and rebuild it elsewhere because it was impossible to teach in because the noise and air pollution. This will push the runway near to the school we actually built at some distance. So we're going to lose our schools, going to lose our whole community. Before anyone votes on this, come down to Harmondsworth.

Come and see the village. Don't vote on this unless you've been there. Because you won't know what it's like devastating beautiful villages. This Harmondsworth is just London in bloom. We've got a church a thousand years old, the barn, the medieval church, again, I think the biggest in Europe, we believe.

That will be 50 yards away from the airport runway. This is absolute devastation. Where are my constituents going to go? Where are those pupils going to be taught? And on top of that, on top of that, we've been breathing this air, poisoned air, for over a generation now.

We did survey after survey about the scale of respiratory problems that there are, the cardiovascular impacts. So before anyone votes, come down there and talk to some of the people what it means. And people say, oh well, people move there. We've got generations of families who've lived there. And also, there are young families who've moved in.

Why did they move in? Because we had governments promising us there'd be no third runway. Cross-party agreement at one point in time. So no wonder we feel betrayed. And look, my honorable friend has set out all the arguments themselves.

And I, this debate, the fact we're even considering it, is a monument to Heathrow's lobbying capacity and the corporate capture that has been of different political parties over time. Just, and I honestly think, I have a lot of time for my honorable friend from Northern Ireland, he's a generous with his support on a whole range of issues themselves. But every one of the points the honorable gentleman has raised through the Heathrow briefing material, basically, has been shot through completely. The economic benefit my honorable friend mentioned in terms of what's happened, on the government's own figures in its consultation, it's reduced ten times, what's to 0.05% of GDP, and even that now is in doubt.

The number of jobs. When the fifth terminal was developed, we were promised I think it's 50,000 jobs or whatever. We didn't get anything. And in fact what's happened in our area in West London as Heathrow has developed, our industrial base has moved out. And they've moved out because they've gone to other regions which are cheaper and then have they been replaced by what?

Warehousing and we've lost skills jobs for unskilled work and exploitation basically. And when it comes to the health implications, the wider health implications, I want to come onto the issue with regard to ultrafine particles. And I want to warn honorable members about this and in government itself. I just give this example. When I was youngster I left school and went on shop floor and I worked up north in a place near Hebden Bridge.

And Hebden Bridge was where they manufactured asbestosis, asbestos. And we suddenly discovered asbestos and people at that point were even campaigning to keep the factory there for the jobs and all the rest of it. The ultrafine particles is the asbestosis of the future. Look at the research. The government has now set up a committee of experts that are looking at this particular issue and it will report in three months' time, possibly after we are asked to consider this issue.

What we know about ultrafine particles is that first of all they come from aviation fuel in particular and they come across not just the surroundings of the airport, they think at least 10 kilometers around the emissions that take place from aviation in particular. That means we've now got evidence from the working group of ultrafine particles in central London. What do ultrafine particles do? They penetrate your body into the lungs, the heart and all the rest. So what we are now discovering, cardiovascular disease and cancers that are taking place and also it has penetrates the brain too.

And what we're worried about is what it's doing to our children who have been who are growing up breathing these ultrafine particles. And I warn the government, it's a bit like asbestos. We have to recognize once this is pointed out to us and we continue to inflict this onto our population in London, we will be held responsible as a government for enabling that to happen. So I just think on those all of the issues that have been brought forward today, we've raised noise. We've just had a session a month ago with the noise experts.

They now tell us the government's level is so high, the threshold of damage to people's health is so much lower than that and we're well beyond we're well beyond the European limits themselves. And what I'm we need to shake people up because we don't even know the flight paths yet. So all we can do is look at what's been said in the past and from what's been said in the past we know at least another 900,000, nearly a million people will be affected by noise and air pollution and the health consequences of it. And when we were here last time and we were told there's an urgency of delivery of this project for the good of our economy even though we now know it's actually going to cost us 15,000 jobs. Where are those jobs going to go from?

They're going to go from the regional airports. Have a look at the New Economics Foundation analysis. Then on top of that we're told there's a sense of urgency. So what do we hear a fortnight ago? Heathrow is so urgent about delivery they've delayed it another five years.

I just and then it comes to the cost escalation. Since we've had this debate over the last couple of years the costs have doubled. The costs have doubled. 15 billion is expected to pay for the transport infrastructure. Heathrow as exactly as my honorable friend said are not putting a penny up, not a penny.

And you know where honorable members know where they're going to come to for that cost infrastructure, they'll come to two groups, taxpayers and passengers. I just think this is such a con. We've got to throw it out once and for all. I I don't want to be here in a couple of years' time. I just think there's no rationale for proceeding now.

And what we have to do is the consultation taking place, we come back, I'm hoping that the government will then will actually say look enough's enough and we kill this project off once and for all.

We can't just keep on coming back wasting resources on all of this. And I actually do think there's a responsibility that is on all our shoulders now, particularly now because we know so much more about the detriment this will be to our not just our individual constituencies, but I think to the economy overall and also to the health of, yeah, we're talking about millions of people. So the message from this debate should go to government now: just kill it off. Let's finish this ritual that we have purely because of the lobbying impact that Heathrow Airport has. We've got to stand up for our constituents.

And we've got to represent our constituents, not some corporations that actually are going to rip us off in the future.

32:39 - 35:18

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Sir John. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair this afternoon. I want to thank the honorable lady for Putney for both securing this debate but also the way she introduced it. I know my two Liberal Democrat colleagues from Southwest London will completely agree with her. I know they've got a long history in standing up to this unreasonable plans to expand Heathrow.

I want to talk from my constituency of Woking's point of view. Despite Woking being the busiest railway station in Surrey and being less than 20 miles away from Heathrow Airport, we have no rail link to Heathrow. So my request, my demand to the minister is if Heathrow Airport is to expand, the government must ensure that Southern Rail access is paid for by the airport so that my constituents in Woking and the whole southern region under Heathrow can have that proper access. It's not reasonable that we can't access it at the moment via any forms of public transport. Thankfully, there is a private company, Heathrow Southern Railway Limited, that I chaired a roundtable with recently.

They've put together a business case to ensure that we can have Southern Rail access that would not just enable that, but enable Woking and the broader West Surrey area to have a second route to London via Heathrow and then on to Paddington. Has the minister met with Heathrow Southern Railway Limited? If not, will he or another ministerial colleague? I want to draw parallels with the requirements and the planning requirements that have been given on Gatwick for their second runway. They were required as a planning condition to ensure that a certain percentage of travelers were required to come via public transport, particularly trains.

Will those requirements be made on Heathrow if it expands? It should, if it does expand, they should have those requirements. I know the Department for Transport was looking at this via the AMPS review and the public transport requirements, but I hope they make it a legal requirement that if Heathrow does expand, that there is Southern Rail access to ensure that if we have that expansion that I know many colleagues don't want to see happen, that we ensure that passengers for Heathrow can get there as sustainably as possible. Thank you.

35:18 - 42:30

Danny Beales

Thank you, Sir John. It's a pleasure to sit under your chairmanship. And I thank my honorable friend from Putney for bringing today's very timely and important debate.

And I think she's set out very well the issues that many of us are concerned about and grappling with. The issue of Heathrow expansion is one that raises significant concerns amongst my constituents in the neighbouring constituency to the airport. And it's an issue as been said that is not new. It's been going around, I was going to say since the nineties, but apparently since 1983, even before I was born at Hillingdon Hospital. Others were taking up the mantle and battling this, which, you know, I think explains why people are incredibly frustrated and jaded that yet again the same questions are being asked but seemingly no answers are coming back to those decade-long problems.

The government has been explicit time and time again about its commitment to the four tests, which I myself also share when answering the question about potential Heathrow expansion. Does it deliver economic growth in every region? Is it consistent with our climate change commitments? Will it not undermine air quality programs? And will we ensure that plans properly manage, limit and mitigate noise impact?

And if expansion fails to meet these tests, it simply should not be allowed to go ahead. That was always my starting point and I've been consistent to this day when looking at any proposals. But to be frank, the numbers we've seen are not reassuring. According to the government's own modelling, the impact on GDP is predicted to be just 0.03 to 0.05 percent by 2056, a reduction in the economic benefit by a factor of 10 compared with earlier estimates. And in addition to this, modelling done by the department suggests that once monetised costs and benefits are considered, expansion could impose greater costs than benefits over 60 years with a negative net present value of between 20 to 60 billion pounds for the economy.

And for individual consumers, a colleague from Northern Ireland mentioned the benefits potentially to consumers. Well, projections suggest that ticket prices could rise by 60 to 65 pounds or 250 pounds for a family of four due to higher airline charges to fund the development, with charges passed on to passengers. Rather than extend air travel to more, it could price out ordinary families from travelling from Heathrow. And this is why major airlines themselves are concerned about the proposals, and many members have heard from them themselves. The ethos of this new government is delivering growth in every postcode and it's one that I share.

Yet the analysis shows that Heathrow would not be the silver bullet one would hope. Modelling suggests that around 72 to 92 percent of benefits of expansion would be concentrated in London and the South East, and research by the New Economics Foundation suggesting that up to 15,000 jobs could be displaced from regions outside London and the South East, harming regional airport capacity, which many members are rightly fighting for to see growth in their regions. And despite previous claims expansion could be funded entirely from private investment, this just simply is not the case. And there are real concerns about burdens on taxpayers. Just last week, Heathrow told the Transport Select Committee they do not intend to cover the full cost of rail infrastructure.

And time and time again, we're already seeing taxpayers in London and the UK pick up the price for Heathrow-related travel. The new Elizabeth Line trains, which are now being built and rolling out soon, will not serve West Drayton and my constituents and constituents to Reading and Maidenhead because the capacity is going to serve Heathrow, with no money being provided by the airport already today. So the headlines of expansion tell us one thing, whilst Heathrow bosses admit to another. And I risk that pressing ahead with an incredibly expensive and financially dubious infrastructure project, not because it offers a credible path to growth, but it's become a symbol of whether we are committed or not to growth in abstract form.

And we've seen this again with HS2. Whilst rail expansion and capacity are undoubtedly needed in the country, we've pushed ahead with a project that was poorly scoped, poorly costed, poorly specced, and it led to decades of underperformance and cost inflation. And on the other tests, as members have already said today, the evidence also falls flat. Whether it's on noise impacts and the huge number of people that would be pulled into increased noise and disruption across London, though the flight paths are still uncertain today, so the exact scope and extent of this can't be said. Or the costs of mitigating those noise impacts from secondary glazing, from replacement housing, these costs are potentially exponential and we still don't know how they will be paid for or who will pay for them.

And on our vital commitments to climate change, the Climate Change Committee's work, which was published last month, found that aviation emissions had more than doubled since 1990 and Heathrow currently accounted for half of all UK aviation emissions. And they conclude there is no credible pathway for Heathrow expansion to be compatible with the UK's climate commitments under current policies. Meanwhile, when it comes to air pollution, serious concerns remain about the reliability of modelling and whether the impact of latest expansion proposals have been sufficiently assessed. Quite frankly, there is no point in us standing on a commitment to these four tests as criteria by which the future of Heathrow should be shaped if the moment they aren't met, we abandon them altogether. And quite frankly, it's not something that I can do and subsequently look my constituents squarely in the face.

For many of us in this place, Heathrow expansion is a perennial issue that should just be dealt with so we don't have to keep talking about it. But for residents in Hillingdon and in London, the impacts will be profound and the case just as shaky now as it has ever been. This has been compounded by what we can only describe as an incredibly poor consultation process that failed to properly engage with the strength of feeling on the issue, with consultations taking place in August over the summer months, despite multiple stakeholders, including myself, outlining the difficulty in securing proper engagement over the summer period. Heathrow's own consultation, which is taking place now as we speak, will have no consultation events anywhere in my own constituency, despite being a neighbouring constituency to the airport. Perhaps they don't want to hear the questions because as time and time again we've seen, they don't have the answer to how they will meet these four tests.

So, Sir John, we must take our time. We must think fully about the implications of expansion. We must have access to proper, thought-through data. And I echo my friend from Putney's call that we must have a proper national strategy about our aviation needs that thinks holistically about every region, about every aspect of our nation's aviation needs. And we must think again on Heathrow expansion.

Thank you.

42:30 - 51:51

Munira Wilson

Thank you very much, Sir John. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair today. And thank you also to the honourable member for Putney for securing this really important debate and for laying out the case against Heathrow expansion so clearly. And I should begin by declaring my interest as the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Airport Communities before I begin my remarks. Now, I know honourable members who are supportive of a third runway would likely say how appalling it is that we've been debating this issue for some 20 years, or as the right honourable member for Hayes and Harlington said, 40 years since I turned five was when he started his campaign.

And those members are right. It's appalling that we've been discussing it for so many years. And every time a new government raises the prospect of a third runway, communities across London feel, and especially in West and South West London, feel that once again this is an albatross around their necks that they just cannot get rid of. So it is time that we put this issue to bed once and for all.

The evidence is clearer than ever that Heathrow expansion is a white elephant that would have devastating consequences for our environment as well as our local communities, and the economic case simply does not stand up. And I'm going to apologize to honorable and right honorable members that I think there'll be some repetition in my speech of what has been said already, but I think it's very important that the minister hears that actually across parties and across London, the strength of feeling against this project. Now, when I last spoke in a debate on this issue in the chamber, I pointed out that the government had provided little evidence to support their claims of the benefits of a third runway. And since then, the government has published the Heathrow Expansion National Policy Statement, NPS as we like to call it. And rather than providing that evidence, if anything, the NPS has made it even clearer that the case for expansion is just simply not credible.

Now, in the space of 21 months since the former Chancellor announced the government's support for expansion, the promise of GDP growth has been downgraded from 0.43% to just 0.05% by 2056. That's a decrease of 90% since an announcement was made in a speech about growth just to send a signal out to the city, as the right honorable member for Hayes and Harlington laid out so clearly. And the same can be said for jobs. 100,000 jobs were promised by the right honorable member for Leeds West and Pudsey, but 61,000 are promised in the NPS, and the Department for Transport explicitly acknowledges that this is likely to be the redistribution of labor, not new jobs, and that's supported by research conducted by the New Economics Foundation, as others have said, which suggests that two-thirds of jobs will be displaced from other parts of the UK. As our new Prime Minister himself has said, Heathrow expansion traps investment in London and the Southeast, and it is the regions of the UK that will suffer for it.

So given the commitment, Prime Minister's commitment to growth in every postcode, perhaps the government should bring forward, as others have said, a national aviation strategy rather than to continue to pursue Heathrow in order to align aviation policy with that regional growth mission. Now, I and many others have also warned since the beginning that the affordability of this scheme is questionable at best. A third runway is a huge infrastructure investment which would require the relocation of London's busiest motorway, the M25, with all the ensuing congestion and chaos and pollution that that would cause. So I'd like to ask the minister if he can share in his closing remarks what work his department is doing with National Highways to assess those impacts. Now, with a price tag of 49 billion pounds and rising, it is our duty as members of Parliament to raise questions about where that money will come from, especially as others have said, the figure does not include surface access improvements, especially in terms of public transport.

And I say to my honorable member for Woking on the southern rail link, I strongly support that and I think the case is there already to build and invest in the southern rail link because as he said, his constituents can't get there from Woking. I believe it or not, I'm only a few miles from the airport in Whitton, near Twickenham, and there isn't a direct link for me to get and my constituents to get to the airport either. So I think there is actually already a strong case for the public transport investment. But the point is, as many have made the point, that actually there's no no mention of it in the in the NPS, no costing for it.

So I hope the Minister can elaborate on the government's expectations for surface access improvements and how these will be funded. No one wants to see, as the honourable member just said, another HS2 in terms of spiralling costs and delays. So that's why it was so galling, Sir John, last week to hear, after months of questioning government ministers and being told that they had full confidence in the expansion being solely privately funded, to see reports in the press that the government was hiring bankers to advise on, and I quote, the financeability and financial deliverability of Heathrow expansion. So can I ask the Minister why the government is doing this, and why now, and what level of exposure to the public purse he is concerned about that they've commissioned these bankers to do these assessments? It is grossly irresponsible.

And, Sir John, as others have said, after the summer we have just had, it is clearer than ever that climate change is having a series of impacts on the quality of life in this country, on our health, on our economy, and on our public services. At the same time, the government is proposing to expand the single largest polluter in the UK to the tune of carbon emissions equal to the entirety of Birmingham. The Climate Change Committee has made this clear in its advice to the government, arguing expansion is incompatible with our climate commitments. The same morning that the committee said that, the Minister for Local Energy and Jobs went on the radio to say it was only advice and could be ignored. So I hope the Minister will address in his remarks whether he accepts the Climate Change Committee's expert advice and what the government actually intends to do with it.

Sir John, this is an opportunity to press pause, to look again at all of the evidence, and to listen to the voice of local communities. And indeed, the Prime Minister has said that this should be a decision for Londoners. While it is Londoners who will suffer the most in terms of health and noise impacts, expansion could mean up to 3.4 million people exposed to harmful levels of aircraft noise. But we can't even be sure who, as others have said, as airspace modernisation is happening at the same time, which makes it impossible to consider the scale of the impact properly. Again, more evidence continues to come out in this area.

The ANNE and ANNAS studies done by Professor Charlotte Clark on behalf of the Department for Transport have stated clearly that the harmful impacts of noise occur at a lower level than previously understood. And that is not something, as proponents of Heathrow expansion like to say, that one can get used to. Furthermore, expansion will mean 10,000 extra tonnes of nitrogen dioxide will be produced a year, and the NPS simply does not have adequate protections for this, and it is deathly silent on the issue of ultra-fine particles that the right honourable member for Hayes and Harlington spoke so knowledgeably about. It is crucial, Sir John, that any decision on a third runway is undertaken with evidence leading the way. I welcome the Prime Minister's recent comments, and I hope he is not equivocating without thinking.

I'm looking forward to receiving a reply to my letter to him that I sent on the day that he became Labour leader back in July about the issue. The evidence is clear. Millions of Londoners are clear. We do not want a third runway at Heathrow.

I hope the Prime Minister will instead stand by his convictions, as he's promised to do time and time again, and take a third runway off the table once and for all, for the sake of taxpayers, for the sake of our planet, and for the sake of our local communities whose health and well-being risks being blighted by this project. Thank you.

51:51 - 52:14

John Hayes

Thank you. I'm now going to call the frontbench spokesman for each party. I suggest eight or nine minutes from each of the Liberal Democrats and the opposition, and then maybe ten minutes or so from the minister, and then time for Fleur to say a few minutes at the end of me to move the motion. I therefore call the Liberal Democrat spokesman, Sarah Olney.

52:14 - 59:02

Sarah Olney

Thank you very much, Sir John. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and can I thank the honorable member for Putney for her excellent opening speech. And I hope she won't mind me saying I experienced a certain sense of déjà vu because, of course, although she put it excellently as she always does, it's not something that I personally haven't heard before, although I very much hope that the minister was listening. The Liberal Democrats have consistently opposed a third runway at Heathrow because the case for expansion has never added up. With the proposed economic benefits declining by 90% in the past decade, an operational second runway at Gatwick in the pipeline, and the Climate Change Committee's recent statement that a third runway would be incompatible with the UK's net zero targets, there simply isn't even a case to be made for expansion anymore.

Despite the former Chancellor framing a third runway as part of the UK's growth agenda, the Treasury's own analysis puts the third runway's net present value to UK residents at between minus 23.4 billion and 62.5 billion over 60 years. Heathrow is already in over 17 billion pounds worth of debt, while the headline cost for a third runway, which the government asserts will be completely privately funded, stands at 49 billion. But that doesn't take into account over 100 billion pounds of carbon abatement costs, nor the billions of pounds required for investment in surface access upgrades needed. And I'm reminded by my honorable friend and constituency neighbor from Twickenham about the impact of the third runway plans on M25 and the huge cost and economic impact that that will have across a vast swathe of the Southeast. And if those passengers aren't even able to travel to Heathrow, the additional passengers, then it rather defeats the purpose of adding capacity.

And my honorable friend from Woking, of course, makes the point that we lack so many connections to Heathrow already across the Southeast. It already is incredibly difficult to travel to Heathrow, not just from Surrey, but even from my own constituency of Richmond does not have a direct link, despite that being a mainline station of Southwest London. And it's not just the lack of access for passengers, this lack of access will also limit access for employment, severely limiting some of those economic benefits that we've heard about, and the impact on jobs simply won't be possible for people to access the airport to take them up. Not to mention, of course, that Heathrow will seek to recoup their investment by passing on the cost to passengers, which will, of course, increase the cost of flying, as we've heard from a number of contributors already, and that, of course, in its own way will dampen demand. The government has recently spent 3 million pounds on a banker to advise on the strength of the economic case for Heathrow.

I think those of us here in this room could quite possibly have saved them the bother. And, of course, with the government seeking to find savings in their upcoming budget, I think we can also save them the effort. There is no viable financial case for expansion. The introduction of nearly 300,000 more flights a year will also have unavoidable environmental and social consequences.

The government's commissioned aviation night noise effects study identifies that residents exposed to higher levels of aircraft noise are twice as likely to experience severe sleep disturbance. And I know many of the MPs in this room will have heard these impacts directly from their constituents. We had a really good community meeting across Richmond Borough, my colleague and I attended, and some of the stories that we heard were absolutely harrowing. And particularly from those, particularly young people suffering from learning disabilities and additional needs such as autism, the impact of night flights and aircraft noise on those people is really unendurable. This indicator is widely accepted to be correlated with increased risks of hypertension and cardiovascular disease as well as poor mental well-being.

People living in communities surrounding Heathrow have a 24% higher chance of stroke, a 21% higher chance of heart disease, and a 14% higher chance of cardiovascular disease compared to people exposed to low levels of aircraft noise. But the flight paths for a third runway haven't even yet been designed. So how can the government produce a viable noise impact assessment and reassure residents who are not already exposed to aircraft noise that a third runway will not impact them? And I hadn't been planning to mention it, but I do just want to pay tribute to the honorable member for Hayes and Harlington and of course his very impactful comments on the, on what it means for those people whose homes are not just on the proposed site of the third runway, but surrounding it, and the very powerful case he makes for their, for the impact that this will have on their, on their lives. On the environment, on the environmental argument, it should almost go without saying that adding these additional flights to our skies will have a profound impact on air pollution and on climate change.

The government has previously used wishful thinking in their assertions that sustainable aviation fuel will mitigate the additional pollution from Heathrow expansion, although they seem to have scaled back this argument more recently. Heathrow is already the biggest single source of carbon emissions in the UK, and expansion will add an extra 8 to 9 megatons of CO2 into our environment every year. The Climate Change Committee's recent conclusion that expansion cannot be considered to be compatible with the UK's climate commitments presents the government with a clear choice: to pursue a third runway at Heathrow or to take the climate crisis facing us seriously. It seems like an easy decision to make. So I would like to ask the minister, does he agree with the Climate Change Committee's verdict that the current plans for a third runway are not compatible with the UK's climate change commitments?

The Prime Minister's recent comments which distance the government's support from a third runway were a step in the right direction, but he needs to go further, back his own convictions, and categorically oppose expansion. I'm going to anticipate that the Tory spokesman is going to reflect their party's recent conference commitment to expanding Heathrow. Not only does this show their lack of interest in the well-being of London and Londoners, but also their susceptibility to big business lobbying in the face of hard economic facts. So I would like to ask the minister, will he advise the Prime Minister that the third runway proposal is not fit for purpose and put an end to this white elephant once and for all? Thank you, Sir John.

59:02 - 59:07

Speaker 17

Hear, hear. And now the official opposition spokesman, Shadow Minister Richard Holden.

59:07 - 01:01:30

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed, Sir John, and delighted to serve under your chairmanship today. Now we all know that it was just after the Second World War in May '46 that the first commercial flights departed Heathrow, marking the beginning of an 80-year journey that has now seen over 3 billion passengers move through the airport on 22 million flights. And between September of last year and August of this year, there were 84 million passengers to go through Heathrow. Now the Prime Minister likes to talk about the industrialization of the past century, but Heathrow and our other airports across the country are symbols of the modern industrialized world where transportation between countries are a major engine of modern economic development. That leads us to the subject of today's debate: Heathrow expansion.

Now, there is a long-running and undeniably contentious issue at stake here. In her role as the member for Putney, I do not think anybody could be surprised to see the honorable lady make the case against expansion. After all, her predecessors as MPs have done so the same, all the way back to Hugh Jenkins, who was asking the government about this in 1970, when he was asked to give an undertaking that there is no further enlargement of the Heathrow Airport would be permitted and no additional runways of any kind would be allowed. However, what that figure of 84 million passengers makes clear is that Heathrow is at capacity. This lack of capacity is severely constraining its ability to grow and as a consequence, Britain's ability to grow through its hub airport.

Data published by Airports Council International in March showed that passenger growth at Heathrow was now falling well behind the European average, with 1.9% versus 4.6% with the European average rate. If we want businesses to grow in this country and to encourage private investment, we should not stand in the way of development that offers economic benefits. If we do, demand for flights will not dissipate; rather, operators will choose to fly and invest elsewhere, particularly with Heathrow being a hub airport. Most likely, that will be at competing European airports that have expanded their facilities, whether that's Schiphol or Charles de Gaulle or Frankfurt, and in many cases, build new runways as well. And alongside that will go the jobs and the other opportunities that go with it.

01:01:30 - 01:01:32

Speaker 19

I'd happily give way to the honorable lady.

01:01:32 - 01:01:46

Sarah Olney

I just wondered if he'd like to say a little bit more about those economic benefits, given that the Treasury's own figures show that the likely economic impact of Heathrow expansion is between minus 25 and minus 63 billion over 60 years.

01:01:46 - 01:02:08

John Richard Holden

I'll come to those figures down the line, because I think we can all agree that those there is certainly questioning of those figures. And it would surprise me as to why the former Chancellor of the Exchequer and indeed most recently the new Chancellor of the Exchequer are so vociferously in support of that airport if those figures are actually true. And I'd happily take an intervention from the honorable member.

01:02:08 - 01:02:38

Jim Shannon

I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman and admit that there's a growth possibility, growth and not possibility, growth and certainty for Belfast City Airport who have their own plans to grow as well. But part of how Belfast City Airport will grow will be how Heathrow grows, so the two can grow together. Does the honorable gentleman recognize that when it comes to regional connectivity, the opportunity for us in Belfast and Northern Ireland to have that opportunity to grow depends greatly upon how Heathrow grows as well?

01:02:38 - 01:05:32

John Richard Holden

I think the honorable gentleman makes an incredibly important point. I remember as a transport minister visiting Belfast, both City and International Airport, and indeed Derry Airport as well, which was I think so important actually, and they really reinforced to me how important that plugin is, not just for Northern Ireland, but for Scotland and Wales and the North of England as well, how important Heathrow is as that international hub. That hub status does not exist in any of our other airports. That's why Heathrow is under different regulations and a different model. And he makes a really important point about how that connectivity drives growth right across the UK.

I've just given way twice, but I will give way again happily later on. Since the announcement was made, the Conservative Party's leadership has been clear: expansion should go ahead provided that sensible and proportionate local mitigation measures form part of that plan.

Heathrow and the government have already set out a number of these. However, what is critical is that these measures genuinely serve the interests of local residents and do not impose excessive costs that will ultimately be passed on to passengers. Turning to the challenges posed by today's debate for the minister, the former Chancellor, the former Prime Minister, and the current Chancellor, as I've just mentioned, have all backed this project. The minister is now in the unenviable position of trying to explain whether the government of which he is a member actually supports expansion or not. The situation has become a political version of Schrödinger's cat.

The Prime Minister seems to believe that by refusing to give a clear answer and deflecting attention towards the concerns about the project, he can leave some people believing that the runway idea is alive and some people believing it is dead all at the same time. At the same time, the Chancellor of the Exchequer told the IMF the other day, Mr. Chairman, that the case for the third runway at Heathrow has always been a case for growth, creating a completely different impression of what the government's position is. Unfortunately, this good cop, bad cop approach to expansion does little to reassure investors, not just in Heathrow, but actually in the UK in general. As Heathrow made clear in evidence to the Transport Select Committee, investors want clarity about the regulatory framework so they can assess the project's business case with confidence. While there has been much speculation about the timetable for expansion, the lack of clarity over the government's position and regulatory framework risks undermining confidence further.

If the Prime Minister does not appear to give the project his support, how on earth can investors have confidence in the regulatory process which is ultimately overseen by the government he leads? I'm afraid that the discrepancy between the Prime Minister and Chancellor gets to the heart of the challenges facing this government. By giving the public the impression that it is jettisoning the previous government's commitment, the Prime Minister is once again demonstrating what has become his trademark skill: evading responsibility and avoiding difficult decisions. I will give way on that point, yes.

01:05:32 - 01:06:15

Danny Beales

He's presented in his answer a clarity that the opposition have on this issue, but my understanding is the Conservative Party quite divided about this issue. The local council, Conservative-led in Hillingdon, oppose it, as do many MPs. And the position that he put forward had a quite big if caveat in it. They would support it if there were no costs and additional measures. Those measures are not clear.

As many speeches have said, those costs are not clearly being covered. The taxpayer would have to foot the bill for significant transport improvement and mitigation measures which are not being funded. What price are the opposition willing to pay in terms of the taxpayer to have Heathrow go ahead?

01:06:15 - 01:08:26

John Richard Holden

I think we've been actually, the honorable member, there will always be, and we're fully aware of this, there's and there always have been, whenever there's a large infrastructure project in the country, there will always be local objections to it, as you would expect at council and sometimes at constituency MP level. I think everybody understands that. I think that the broader point though is that this is going to be a privately funded project, and that's what we're supporting Heathrow on the basis of. So what is the cost of failure to make this decision? It is lost growth, foregone private sector investment.

It's the same behavior that we've seen towards vital energy projects like more drilling in the North Sea. The Prime Minister wants to talk about reindustrialization without giving British companies or businesses the tools they need to achieve that. As the leader of the opposition stated, the future of our country's busiest airport is not a regional matter, which is why I take issue with some of the speeches made by members today. It is a matter for the country and a matter for the Prime Minister. So the Prime Minister needs to stop faffing about and get this runway built, and I was quoting the leader of the opposition on that.

I know that there has been much discussion today about the level of economic growth the airport would deliver, picking up on one of my previous interventions. And I know that there has been much discussion today about that. However, we should all be able to agree that the project would bring economic benefits. The 17 billion in benefits estimated by Heathrow is a considerable sum. And while I understand the department has produced different figures, I'd like to ask the minister what steps the department is taking to ensure that its economic analysis captures the full benefits for both passengers and trade in full, and indeed, as the honorable member for Strangford said, right across the United Kingdom as well.

Furthermore, the project will increase investment in the UK supply chains, create jobs, and provide opportunities for new apprenticeships. The CEO of Heathrow said only last week the billions in private sector investment, 95% were going to the UK supply chains, alongside more than 100,000 jobs that Heathrow says the project could support. With the most recent... I will give way on that point.

01:08:26 - 01:08:45

Scott Arthur

I do thank him for giving way. The right honorable gentleman quotes the CEO of Heathrow Airport, but he'll be aware that none of the airlines back his plan to expand the airport. Can he explain that, and what does he and the CEO know about this plan that the airlines don't?

01:08:45 - 01:09:06

John Hayes

I think the honorable gentleman... sorry, the honorable gentleman who just intervened should familiarize himself with Hansard, page 488, which makes clear that when you haven't been present for the bulk of the debate, it's not really polite to intervene. And the honorable gentleman who's got the floor now needs to bring his remarks to a conclusion to give maximum time to the minister.

01:09:06 - 01:09:59

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much to Sir John. I would just say that there is clearly vested interests on all sides of this part. And if he doesn't think that existing airlines with existing slots have vested interests themselves, then he's living in a different planet as well. With the most recent economic figures showing a contraction in construction output, how on earth can he justify in failure to provide clarity about such a significant infrastructure project? And I will now bring my remarks to a close.

From the outset, it is felt that the Department for Transport were trying to catch up with announcements made by the Treasury and Prime Minister. Now it appears that progress may be stalled by Number 10 instead. I'm afraid that these non-answers we've seen from the government to date demonstrate a lack of seriousness on part of the government, and I hope the minister can encourage his more senior colleagues to provide some of that certainty, and maybe he can provide some even more himself today. Thank you.

01:09:59 - 01:10:03

Speaker 23

Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Transport, Simon Lightwood.

01:10:03 - 01:13:44

Simon Lightwood

Sir John, it's also a pleasure to see you in the chair, and I'm grateful for the opportunity to respond to this debate today. I'd like to thank honorable members in attendance today, and my honorable friend, the member for Putney, for bringing forward this important debate to the House. Honorable members may have noticed that I'm not the aviation minister, who is today attending committee proceedings of the Civil Aviation Bill, but I am here as the minister for local transport. I care deeply about the impacts of expansion for a wider transport network. That means considering how people travel to and from the airport and ensuring that transport infrastructure is able to meet future demand while supporting local communities.

I think I'll make a little bit of progress if the honorable member wouldn't mind. I may not be able to... bit short on time now. The... I may not be able to respond to every question raised during the debate today, as the government is currently considering consultation responses, and parliamentary scrutiny of the draft Heathrow expansion National Policy Statement, or NPS, remains ongoing. It would not be appropriate to preempt those processes or prejudge any future decision while that work remains underway. However, I will ensure that honorable members receive responses in due course to any... on any points that I'm unable to cover today.

This government recognizes Heathrow's critical role as the UK's only hub airport, connecting businesses and passengers to global markets and supporting trade, tourism, and investment across the country. As honorable members will be aware... I'm still going to make a little bit of progress, I've limited time, I do want to reply.

Honorable members will be aware the government published the draft NPS consultation in June. It set out the proposed planning policy framework for expansion and requirements that any future scheme would need to meet, including the government's four tests on economic growth, climate change, air quality, and noise. As I've noted, we have we are carefully considering the over 27,000 responses received and will also consider the recommendations of the Transport Select Committee. Any finalized NPS would also be subject to parliamentary consideration, including a debate and a vote in this House before it can have legal effect. The draft NPS does not grant development consent for expansion.

Only when a national policy statement has been designated can proposals for a development consent order be brought. Any future proposal brought forward by a promoter of expansion would still need to progress through the statutory development consent order process and demonstrate that it meets the requirements of the relevant policy framework. It is for potential promoters to determine the timetable and sequencing of their proposals and for government to put the right frameworks in place. Any potential promoter bringing forward a scheme of this scale and complexity will need to balance pace with deliverability, affordability, and value for money for passengers. Given the current stage of the consultation process and the ongoing period of parliamentary scrutiny, I will not seek to preempt those processes and my remarks today should be considered in that context.

The government will provide a more substantive update to the House once it is in a position to do so. That said, I will address some of the points raised during today's debate where I can, of course.

01:13:44 - 01:14:26

John Martin McDonnell

I understand the difficulty the minister's in and I have a lot of sympathy for him because I wouldn't want to be associated with this thing either. But there's one issue which I'd like seriously if he could write to us on. The air quality working group will report in three months' time, that possibly could be after a decision's made by government. And one of the issues that we'd be asking for if there is any framework developed is actually we this the government now sets a limit that we should aim for on ultrafine particles. In Europe they do, and in Europe now it's increasingly becoming a legal requirement to monitor them.

01:14:26 - 01:14:52

Simon Lightwood

We have no monitoring and we have no limit. If he could write to me on that about the government's consideration of that, I think it would be really helpful.

I thank my honorable friend for his intervention. I am going to come on to ultrafine particles in just just a little bit longer. Turning first to the the four tests then, economic growth being the first, expansion could generate economic growth across the country with updated analysis indicating potential cumulative benefits of between 39 billion pounds and 52 billion pounds to UK passengers and the wider economy, including lower fares, increased flight frequencies, and fewer delays.

01:14:52 - 01:15:33

Ayoub Khan

I thank the minister for giving way. With any infrastructure projects, there's obviously going to be a a balance between growth and the economy and also the impact it has on the environment and in this case many many families. And clearly it seems that the growth does not outweigh the the negative impact. But can I digress just a little in terms of transport infrastructure? It may be not surprising that we haven't got that given the cost to drivers which have to park at airports across the whole of the UK, 16 out of 20 have an increase recently in six months by more than 33 percent.

01:15:33 - 01:15:38

Speaker 28

Drivers are calling it an absolute rip-off, 81 percent of those surveyed are saying that.

Will the minister consider reducing or involving themselves in that?

01:15:38 - 01:16:09

Simon Lightwood

I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention. I'm sure the aviation minister will be delighted to respond to that and would have heard his message today. Any promoter must evidence that expansion will deliver benefits across the country, not just locally. Analysis published alongside the draft NPS indicates that up to 40% of this estimated GDP growth is expected to accrue to regions outside of London and the South East. The draft I will for the final time.

01:16:09 - 01:16:56

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the minister for giving way. He is being very generous with his time in his limited time he has. Many of my constituents in Ealing Southall will have responded to the consultation and noise has been a particular concern. So I do hope that he will manage to make some remarks regarding how realistic steeper landing approaches and new aircraft technology might be in addressing noise. But I want to talk about jobs.

He talks about growth. Many of my constituents actually work at the airport and their worry is that in fact if it does not go ahead, we lose our status as a hub airport and their jobs might be at risk in the future. Is he able to say anything that would reassure the many workers in Heathrow Airport in good quality jobs from my constituency in Ealing Southall?

01:16:56 - 01:20:22

Simon Lightwood

Once again, I'm sure the aviation minister would have heard you today. Now I'll go on to address some of those issues in my remarks. The draft NPS introduces a new test requiring potential promoters for development consent to demonstrate through a clear evidence-based growth strategy how their scheme will support economic activity and growth at national, regional and local levels. Moving on to climate change, the draft NPS contains a clear climate change requirement where any increase in carbon emissions resulting from a proposed scheme must not be so significant that it would have a material impact on the UK's legally binding carbon budgets. For expansion to proceed, it would need to align with the government's climate goals, including our legal commitment to reach net zero by 2050.

Any increase in carbon emissions associated with Heathrow expansion would need to be considered against the government's carbon reduction targets and mitigation requirements set out in the draft NPS. On air quality, the draft NPS is also clear that a scheme for Heathrow expansion must demonstrate that it will not result in any new breaches of legal obligations on air quality or make existing breaches materially worse. As part of this, the draft NPS sets out mitigations a potential promoter should consider to minimise the impact of the project on the environment and affected communities. Last noise, finally, the draft NPS sets out a noise test requiring overall aircraft noise to be limited and where reasonably possible reduced compared to 2024, taking into account quieter aircraft and operating procedures while providing adequate and predictable respite for communities. These mitigations should include a runway alternation scheme and scheduled night flight ban.

As part of this, the draft NPS currently requires that an applicant must propose a scheduled night flight ban of 6.5 hours between the hours of 11pm and 7am as part of their proposed mitigations of noise impacts of Heathrow expansion. Expansion would increase capacity, which may provide greater operational flexibility allowing aircraft to land more efficiently and potentially reducing reliance on extended holding patterns. This could benefit people living in the areas currently affected by noise from aircraft in holding patterns before landing.

Through the consultation, we are listening carefully to the views across all four tests. However, I want to make clear that we recognize that noise and air quality are of particular importance to many local residents, and we are committed to ensuring that these concerns are fully considered as part of the process. The draft NPS also makes clear that Heathrow expansion must be supported by a credible surface access strategy that enables more journeys to be made by public transport and reduces pressure on the wider transport network. The draft NPS defines clear passenger public transport mode share targets. However, the onus will be on any potential promoter to demonstrate through the DCO process that their proposed approach can credibly achieve these targets.

Heathrow expansion is a private sector project, and the government has been consistently clear that it must be privately financed.

01:20:22 - 01:20:40

John Richard Holden

As part of that DCO process and about surface access targets, could he address the member's comment earlier on about charges for drop-offs and just how important that is to indeed those surface access proposals being put forward by the government?

01:20:40 - 01:22:53

Simon Lightwood

So again, I'm sure the aviation minister will have more to say on this, but I know we have obviously been, there's been lots in the media about the government looking at this area, and I'm sure the aviation minister will continue to engage with members regarding airport drop-offs. Back to the affordability, Heathrow expansion is a private sector project, as I said, and the government has been consistently clear that it must be privately financed. This includes surface access improvements necessary for the expanded airport. As part of the Civil Aviation Authority is continuing to develop the future regulatory framework for expansion, including considering how costs are assessed, managed, and where appropriate, recovered. The CAA's primary duty is to protect the interest of consumers, and affordability will be an important point.

There was some mention of the consultation period earlier on. We believe the consultation period of over 10 weeks was proportionate for reviewing amendments to an existing national policy statement rather than a brand new statement. The consultation period of over 10 weeks was designed to take into account the summer holiday period. It was carried out in accordance with section 7 of the Planning Act 2008 and in line with the Cabinet Office consultation principles, which require consultations to last for a proportionate amount of time. There was also mention of the Climate Change Committee.

The CCC has identified one potential pathway and important conditions that it considers necessary. We're considering that advice alongside the wider evidence and will set out the government's conclusions in its formal response. I'd like to thank all members of the House for attending the debate today. As noted, the government will give due regard to the recommendations of the Transport Select Committee alongside responses received during the consultation before determining next steps on Heathrow expansion. Without wishing to prejudge this process, any finalized NPS would also be subject to parliamentary consideration, including a debate and vote in this House before it can have legal effect, giving honorable members the opportunity to consider the proposal and exercise their right to either vote for or against it.

01:22:53 - 01:23:13

John Hayes

Thank you. Just before I call Fleur, the minister has stepped in for the aviation minister. I appreciate on other ministerial business and has committed to write to a number of colleagues to deal with specific issues. I just want to put on record that that commitment has been made and I expect it to happen. So thank you very much.

Fleur Anderson to wind up the debate.

01:23:13 - 01:25:09

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Thank you very much, Chair, and I thank the minister for stepping in, although I do recognize that he is a very responsible minister for the local transport questions that have been raised time and time in this debate, and so I look forward to hearing those answers about what will be the strategy. There's a huge hole in this whole project. Now that's not the only thing to be concerned about.

And I would say to to all those people listening in who will be responding to the consultation which starts on the 27th of October and goes to the 22nd of December that there are some concerns. If you live in London we have heard the concerns about the noise and about air pollution and very serious concerns about health. We I welcome the respite information given by the Minister. I welcome the commitment to listen really carefully to my constituents in Putney and others about the impact that any change to night flights would have in particular but also all the changes that are being proposed through the day. Although we don't yet know where the flight paths will be we know that far more people across London will be affected and so if you live in London then I think that everyone who lives in London should be responding.

For those people who don't live in London they should also be responding and looking at the promises that are being made but not delivered. Promises for economic growth across the country. There will not be hope in every heart or an increased growth in every postcode from this development although there will be huge amount of promises being made by Heathrow. Heathrow asked the government if they could increase their funding from airlines by 340 million pounds to fund the promotion of this project. So expect to be lobbied very hard across the country.

Expect there to be huge amounts of figures but please look into the assumptions behind them. If you're a passenger then I would say there will be increased fares from this highly indebted country company because they will not be footing the bill. And so I thank the the Minister for looking into this. Yes certainly.

01:25:09 - 01:26:01

John Martin McDonnell

I just want to raise this issue of jobs again. At the Select Committee inquiry one of the representatives giving information with regard to jobs there was a real concern that the company itself now if it flounders on this project as it almost certainly will with regard to financing it will come to government. But if government does say no then it will have an impact on the existing operation and put that existing operation in jeopardy. So those people who have constituents who work at Heathrow like like I do I think we're worried about the actual operation of the existing airport being threatened by the overreach with regard to the third runway. And on that basis that's why we've always argued for not a bigger but a better Heathrow.

01:26:01 - 01:27:13

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

I thank my honourable friend very much for that intervention. And I think this debate has lifted a lid on some of of Heathrow as a company. That it is a highly indebted company a very thin company with not a lot of financial backing to it. And so it does put at risk this whole project which would come to the government's door if if it failed. But also it puts at risk jobs it puts at risk all of the fear and worry that's been put onto our constituents about this project going ahead and will it just run into the sand and be a millstone around the government's neck in the future.

And I think it's also lifted the lid on the fact that the four tests really can they be met. It's a question that we've been raising as MPs concerned about this issue many many times. Unless the goalposts are being moved through the Heathrow expansion national policy statement so that they they're so wide as that that anyone could meet them. If they are really going to be strong tests that are looked into seriously I cannot see how those four tests can be met and how this project can go ahead. But I do I do welcome the consultation coming up and I just encourage as many people as possible to get involved with it.

01:27:13 - 01:27:25

John Hayes

Thank you very much Chair.

The question is this House has considered Heathrow Airport expansion. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Order order.

01:27:25 - 01:30:22

Speaker 35

The house is suspended until 4 o'clock. Just a few minutes. Thank you, Minister. Order, order. I'll call Mel Stride to move the motion, and I will then call the Minister to respond.

01:30:22 - 01:30:36

John Hayes

I remind members they may only make a speech with the prior permission of the member in charge of the debate. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up, as the convention is for a 30-minute debate. Order, order, Mel Stride to move the motion.

01:30:36 - 01:32:14

Melanie Onn

Thank you very much. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Hayes. And I'm really pleased to have secured today's debate, and I'm grateful to the number of colleagues who have come to participate in it today. It is important, it is a pressing matter shown by those who have attended, and that is for us to discuss the potential merits of statutory paid employment leave for kinship carers. It is important not only to those in this room, but to thousands of households, and one that goes to the heart of this government's aim to support families and ensure that no child is left behind.

When a child can no longer live with their parents, it's often grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings, or close family friends who step forward to offer them a loving home. Across the whole of the UK, more than 150,000 children are growing up in kinship care, and many have experienced trauma, loss, or significant upheaval.

At precisely the moment they need stability and reassurance, the people offering them that security can find themselves facing an impossible choice between caring for a child they love or keeping their job. As chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Kinship Care, I and other members in this room have heard numerous accounts from young people and carers on just how much a family safety net can make, how much of a difference it can make to a child's outcome in life. I'm happy to give way.

01:32:14 - 01:32:52

Jim Shannon

I thank the honorable lady for great, great strength in bringing this forward. Spoke to her beforehand. In Northern Ireland, there's a record 4,287 children in the care system. Some 83% of those children are in foster care. A large proportion are placed in kinship arrangements.

Because there's no statutory leave, paid leave, nearly 30% of local kinship carers have been forced to give up their jobs entirely, pushing families into financial hardships. Does the honorable lady agree with me that we should be pressing the minister to introduce a statutory right to paid leave for every kinship carer across the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland?

01:32:52 - 01:33:43

Melanie Onn

The honorable member for Strangford makes an incredibly important point on behalf of his constituents. It's over 40% of those foster care placements, I think, that are kinship arrangements. That is a significant number of families, and they shouldn't be forced to decide between continuing work or continuing to look after a child. I mean, really, the decision, it isn't a difficult one. It's always going to be to look after a child who comes to them in traumatic circumstances.

And we shouldn't rely on them taking unpaid leave that can put their career in jeopardy, can put their household finances in jeopardy, and the security with which the child moves into that home. So I thank him for making that point. Oh, we are very popular. I'll give way and then I'll come to you.

01:33:43 - 01:34:12

Perran Moon

I thank my honorable friend for giving way and for bringing this debate. But does she agree with me that with over a thousand kinship-cared-for children in Cornwall, kinship carers play a vital role in keeping vulnerable children within loving family networks, and that when 45% of kinship carers lose their job after taking on the care of a child, we must do more to ensure that those carers receive the support that they need?

01:34:12 - 01:35:00

Melanie Onn

I thank him for his intervention. And yes, I mean, he is right. The concern for parents that either they have to give up work voluntarily or that they fall foul of their employer's terms and conditions merely by taking on not only a duty but a moral duty with regard to the care of that child. And, you know, what this issue really sends in terms of a signal in society is that we recognize the importance of family arrangements and that those family arrangements do not just extend to birth parents, adoptive parents, or foster parents, they also apply to kinship families as well. I give way to the honorable lady.

01:35:00 - 01:35:49

Munira Wilson

I thank very much the honorable lady for giving way and for bringing forward this debate. Earlier this month for Kinship Care Week, I attended a kinship event in my constituency in the area of Whitton, and I met a local woman who'd worked as a probation officer in the Ministry of Justice for 20 years. She suddenly overnight stepped up to take care of her best friend's daughter when her best friend was no longer able to do so.

And the Ministry of Justice had no policy on kinship leave. It was only thanks to her very sympathetic boss that she was able to take a combination of sick leave and annual leave that allowed her to have some paid, some unpaid time off. Does the honourable lady agree with me that both the public sector but also the private sector need to now offer statutory paid leave for kinship carers, as a number of leading employers said in a letter to the Business Secretary just last week?

01:35:49 - 01:38:27

Melanie Onn

The honourable member for Twickenham makes a very powerful point, and of course she is right, as she so often is. She is right that we shouldn't have to expect these carers to rely on the goodwill of their employer. I would say that the government has made some good strides, having the term kinship recognised across government. Of course we have the ambassador now, we have got pilots across the country. I will come on to that a little bit as we go into this debate.

So there have been strides made, but to actually codify this, to have this recognised legislatively, I think would really spread the word and ensure that the private sector, where there have been some good examples of private sector employers undertaking paid leave for kinship carers, which is incredibly welcome, that they are as aware as they can be. It's much easier to kind of notify the public sector through government of these changes, but the private sector might not always be so aware. So I think that there is a big opportunity if the government is prepared to consider this closely and bring forward the outcome of the review that they are currently undertaking. We celebrated Kinship Care Week earlier this month, and I was really pleased to welcome the Minister for Children and Families to Blundell Park in Cleethorpes to meet some of our remarkable and dedicated local kinship carers and impressive council staff from the children's services team. I'm really proud to have secured North East Lincolnshire as one of the seven areas selected for the government's new Kinship Zones programme, and already we've seen more than 450 children in North East Lincolnshire benefiting from the wrap-around support that a social services integrated support and financial package on a par with foster carers as a pilot.

But the conversations that I had that day remind us how much more there really is to do. Kinship care arrangements often happen with little or no warning. Families can be given as little as an hour to decide whether they can take in a child, or sometimes several children, who they may not have the closest of relationships with, and perhaps they already have children of their own or other family responsibilities in the home. There is enormous emotional pressure and often a sense of guilt when the alternative may be that you are sending a child to enter the care system formally. I give way.

01:38:27 - 01:38:58

Speaker 37

I thank my honourable friend for being such a powerful champion for kinship carers right across the country. Those crucial early moments are vital for any parent, but unlike with traditional parental leave, kinship carers, as she's setting out, often understand the caring responsibilities they might be taking on at incredibly short notice and likely do so against a much more traumatic backdrop than most parents have to wrestle with. It clearly can't be right, can it, that they don't have any access to paid leave to make sure that they can be there for those formative moments? So would she agree with me that the government's parental leave review is a really powerful opportunity to put this injustice right?

01:38:58 - 01:40:04

Melanie Onn

I thank him for his contribution. I mean, he is right. This is a real opportunity, a pivotal moment really for the government to put right what has long been an issue that has been marked out by its inequity in provision for different family arrangements. And I am looking forward to the government and the minister setting out in a little more detail, hopefully, how far they've got with looking at that review and when we can hope to see an outcome from it. Once a decision is made by the carer, children can arrive with little more than the clothes that they are wearing.

Carers may have no knowledge of their medical or dietary needs. Suddenly they find themselves navigating school arrangements. A grandmother navigating school arrangements, the difference in systems is vast. You know, new appointments, the needs of a traumatized child, often with really very little practical support. I give way.

01:40:04 - 01:40:36

James Mark Sewards

Thank you for giving way. She is making such powerful arguments, she's a powerful advocate for kinship carers and the children they care for. The Education Select Committee took evidence on this point during our SEND inquiry, and the organization Kinship stated that 47% of all the children in kinship care have some sort of special educational need. Surely this underlines the point that we should be giving these people statutory paid leave so that they can meet the child's complex needs.

01:40:36 - 01:42:12

Melanie Onn

Well, I thank the honorable member for Leeds South West and Morley for raising that, and I hadn't been aware actually that the Select Committee had done that inquiry because it works very well with the Kinship Care APPG because we also recently did an inquiry into SEND needs for children in kinship care because I think across the whole of Parliament actually, those who have got connections with kinship care communities recognize the additional needs that these children often arrive with. And for families that have no experience of managing or dealing with that, actually, if you are in work, regardless of what your job is, suddenly having the expectations to provide, and it could be a physical need or it could be mental or emotional, cognitive, lots of different needs of this child, and you're still trying to figure it out, really to be expected to take unpaid leave to manage and navigate your way through that, I think is a step too far and not one that we should accept in this day and age. They are stepping forward to provide some safety, stability, at the same level of care actually that we would expect of foster carers. So if the state were to provide foster care for a child in need, then all of the necessary support, including the right to paid leave, would be made available, and that is not something currently available to kinship carers. I give way to the honorable gentleman.

01:42:12 - 01:43:40

Ian Lavery

Thank you very much, and can I just say what a tremendous advocate my honorable friend is for kinship carers up and down this country. You've mentioned on more than one occasion the circumstances that ordinary people find themselves in when faced with relations, close friends, potentially the kids going into care. It's a very emotional sort of thing, and lots of these people who accept these kinship carers, like Linda Watson in my constituency, they feel they've got the need to make sure that these children aren't taken into care. They feel the need that they need to give them the best possible start in life or the best way in life at whatever particular age you are. I think a lot of kinship carers, I'll conclude, a lot of kinship carers believe that a pat on the back and a robe on the back of their neck and a pat on the head, a big thank you, just quite simply isn't enough.

A lot of these people need financial support to give these kids, who are already in a difficult position in family life and the rest of it, they need a good start in life. In order to do that, kinship carers need the right support and they need adequate financial support as well.

01:43:40 - 01:44:59

Melanie Onn

I thank the honorable gentleman for his very powerful contribution. Just to build on that, you know, eight in ten kinship carers who leave their work never return to paid employment. So this isn't just a short-term problem. It can lead to lifelong issues. And when we hear, you know, the government's pledge and determination to make sure that people are in work for the long time for the long term and that they are setting an example of what work means, actually providing sufficient flexibility within our employment laws is the right way to go to make sure that those families can be self-sufficient but provide the support and love for that child as well as being able to earn a living without being penalized.

I mean, my constituent Lucy was in exactly the same position as the honorable member for Twickenham, having to take a mix of sick leave and compassionate leave and all this jumbled together by the employer very kindly. But, you know, she just said, why why should my children be disadvantaged? Why should my kids be disadvantaged because the system doesn't recognize and doesn't really work for them? I will give way.

01:44:59 - 01:45:37

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Madam Chair. I mean, what my honorable friend is also rightly pointing out, but hasn't quite sort of said so yet, is that we're also thinking about the long-term costs on the society of this. Those families that step forward stop a child going into care, which is a much more expensive and much more traumatic on the young person. That being able to go back into work in a phased period that allows you to go back into work fully stops that carer having to call on the state for support over their lifetime. So the government really ought to be thinking about this not as a potential extra cost burden somewhere, but as an investment and a genuine preventative measure that saves money whilst also improving outcomes.

01:45:37 - 01:45:40

Speaker 38

So what is there not to like?

01:45:40 - 01:46:13

Melanie Onn

Well, I couldn't agree more with my honorable friend. There is some independent analysis that Family Rights Group have commissioned that says that paid kinship leave could return over two pounds into the economy for every one pound invested. So you're doubling the amount that goes back into the local economy for the support that is provided to these families. I was just going to come a little bit to and I should I just give way to my honorable friend before I move on to the next point.

01:46:13 - 01:46:47

Speaker 40

My honorable friend has been very generous with her time. And I just wanted to go a little bit further on this point about investment, but also draw the comparison which I think my honorable friend was mentioning earlier between kinship care and foster care. Now, one of my constituents has been a kinship carer for three children for nine years. She's also a foster carer for her grandson. And what she reports to me is that because of his legal status, it's been easier for her to access the support she needs for him than it has been for the three children she's cared for as kinship carers.

01:46:47 - 01:49:14

Melanie Onn

So does my honorable friend agree with me that introducing paid employment leave for kinship carers isn't about special treatment, it's about equal treatment?

I do agree. And I think that we should hold that in our minds as we go forward and we start to look into this review in more detail, that we are looking at the issue of equal treatment for all families and making sure that some are not treated differently to others. So I thank her for that contribution. I just wanted to to say, because I am very aware of my time coming to a close and the minister will want to respond to the many points that have been made.

There have been some really good examples of private companies, including Tesco, B&Q are two really big retail employers that are that have already recognized the need for change. They're ahead of the curve and they are offering paid kinship leave. And we see that around 76%, three quarters of employers support a government-funded statutory entitlement. So it is clear that there is more to be done in supporting kinship families and to help them contribute economically and realize financial security. I will come to the point because there were there are some practical questions about how a statutory entitlement would work, particularly when caring arrangements happen suddenly.

I do think that there are credible proposals and we've got a real opportunity to make meaningful progress. We can make sure that we give kinship carers a statutory right to paid employment leave akin to adoptive and other working parents. That would keep thousands of carers out of the benefit system, helping to reduce strain on the welfare system. It would return economic benefits through carers remaining in employment with higher tax revenue and better outcomes for children. And most importantly, give children the protected time that they deserve to heal from trauma and settle into their new homes.

Therefore, it is crucial the government's parental leave and pay review finally closes this unfair gap in the law and delivers a first-ever statutory right to pay and leave for kinship carers. Mr. Chairman, a great deal has been achieved. This government deserves recognition for taking some important steps already. But I do think that there is much more that we can do. And the least that we can do is ensure that those carers have the time and financial security to be able to provide it.

Thank you.

01:49:14 - 01:49:19

John Hayes

Minister of State for the Future of Work, Kate Davies.

01:49:19 - 01:53:15

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Sir John Hayes. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair this afternoon. And I want to thank my honorable friend, the member for Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes, for securing today's really important debate, but for her incredible work for kinship carers since she was elected to this place, championing their voices and their issues in every room and at every opportunity. And to my colleagues here as well, on our benches and cross-party, for all your work. I know every opportunity you too have raised the really important issue of kinship carers with me directly and at every opportunity with colleagues across government.

So thank you very much. And I want to begin by recognizing that kinship carers, as we've heard, often step forward at extremely short notice and in immensely difficult circumstances. Many of the children involved will be experiencing some of the most turbulent and crucial days and weeks of their lives. They may have experienced bereavement, family breakdown, separation, instability, or trauma. And at precisely that moment, a grandparent, an aunt, uncle, sibling, and other relative or family friend may be asked to make a life-changing commitment.

And I also want to take a moment to acknowledge the brilliant work of kinship advocacy organizations like Kinship and Family Rights Group, who continue to campaign and work diligently to raise awareness of the role of kinship carers, many of whom might not even recognize themselves as kinship carers. And these organizations continue to engage constructively with myself and the government, bringing forward important evidence and insights into the experience of kinship families. And their work is incredibly appreciated and helps us understand not only the scale of kinship care, but the practical realities facing carers and children. I want to thank my honorable friend too for inviting me recently to the APPG that she chairs, and I had the opportunity to hear directly from a kinship carer at that meeting and about their experiences. That contribution and their contribution was both moving and instructive of the requirements of government going forwards and underlined the importance in this debate to listening to their voices at the forefront and their experiences.

And their real-life experiences is exactly what we are considering as part of our review. Because kinship carers provide that love, the stability and continuity at what can be such an incredibly time. And colleagues have raised their constituents and the stories they've heard directly and mine too. And I want to touch on Amanda, who's a kinship carer in my constituency, who took time to meet me at my surgery recently. And she provides incredible support to kinship carers across the constituency and talked so openly about her experience.

I know colleagues have heard that from their constituents and have raised that today and thank you for doing so because at every point, not only in this issue but in my wider brief, I want to be shaped by people's experiences in the workplace and their reflections when that's not unfortunately happened. And of course, taking on that responsibility can take such significant emotional, practical and financial pressures, often with that very little notice. And I want to recognise not only their importance and their contribution but also the challenges that they face. And that data from the Family Rights Group that we've talked a lot about at the APPG, eight in ten kinship carers who left work have never returned to paid employment. And that is a real stark statistic.

And I can't even imagine that difficult position that kinship carers will be in where they have to decide, as my honourable friend perfectly alluded to, that really impossible and difficult decision of looking after a child who needs them at such an important time in their life or having to choose between their job. And that insight is particularly valuable as we consider the evidence through the wider parental leave and pay review and its wider work to support kinship families.

01:53:15 - 01:53:17

Speaker 43

Of course.

01:53:17 - 01:53:57

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Aaron Bell-Pauley. Very much for giving way and I obviously congratulate my honourable friend for her years of hard work on this and for securing today's debate. The government's core mission in this is to provide stable, loving homes for every child. That's a policy that happens to have come out of the Department for Education, but what we're talking about today is something that crosses business, work, pensions and so on. Would the Minister agree that this is another fantastic example of where proper cross-government pulling in the same direction could produce outcomes for our young people which is greater than the sum of these different policy parts?

01:53:57 - 01:56:46

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for that contribution and on that note want to pay tribute to my brilliant honourable friend for Whitehaven and Workington for all his incredible work in the Department for Education for kinship carers and absolutely recognise the importance of cross-government and departmental working on this issue for those kinship carers and reassure him that that is absolutely our intention of that joined-up work of how we can support kinship carers throughout their lives and look where we need to go further and do better, which is why today's debate is welcome and really important as we consider the wider pay and parental leave review. Of course, lots of the work that we're taking in the Department for Education, which colleagues will be fully aware of and the significance of them and thank colleagues for welcoming them, whether it's the kinship allowance pilot that will provide eligible kinship carers with that weekly allowance for each eligible child equivalent to the fostering national minimum allowance, to the work that's being done on the new guidance in light of the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026. And I want to provide this opportunity to update colleagues on the parental leave and pay review that sits in my department and is cross-working with the Department for Work and Pensions as well. So lots of departments involved in this approach and that is right because there's not just one part of life that's impacted for a kinship carer, it's absolutely across everything. And we do recognise that support for the carer and support for the child can't be easily separated.

Giving a carer that time and support needed to help a child settle may contribute to the stability of that arrangement and I absolutely want to recognise that.

And that's why it's right that we are considering the experiences of kinship families across departmental boundaries, so social care as well, employment policy, education, and the wider support that's available to families. We are committed to reviewing the wider system. Colleagues will know the review was launched in July 2025, and that's why we are considering all the current parental leave and pay entitlements and the experiences and needs of working families who don't qualify for existing leave and pay entitlements, including kinship carers. We're jointly leading the review, as I've said, and engaging with a broad range of stakeholders. And I again want to take this opportunity for everyone that's fed into the review for their patience as we are taking time to go through as many evidence and hearings as we've had.

The roundtables, the bilateral meetings, the meetings with me and colleagues in this chamber today, and with parental advocacy groups that represent kinship carers. The review will conclude in early 2027 with a set of findings which outline the next steps for implementing any reforms. And I know the significant interest in what the review may conclude. Of course.

01:56:46 - 01:57:13

Craig Gareth Snell

Sir John, when I hear the phrase that there'll be the end of a review, my heart sinks because in government time, those reviews can take forever. So although the review may conclude in 2027, is the minister able to give this House an indication of how quickly after that point the department and the government feel able to publish the outcomes of that review and the next steps so that we're not waiting a year or so to know what those conclusions are?

01:57:13 - 01:59:01

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honorable friend, and he's right, of course, to push me and my colleagues on this issue. Today, I'm unable to preempt recommendations, as he knows, but know how important this is and keeping him up to date with the timelines and progress. And he has my firm commitment today that we will be moving absolutely at pace as we've taken our time to review the evidence. But I want to assure him that the government is absolutely considering this issue and how best we can support kinship carers holistically and across departmental boundaries. And I hope people watching today, kinship carers themselves, really hear that commitment and determination from me.

I know how important this is. A week and a day can make such a difference to these people, to kinship carers' lives. And I want to be clear that that's why it's been really important that we've engaged with as many people, and I hear the wider campaigns outside this room too, from trade unions, from business representatives, employers who are already going above and beyond, and I thank them for it, but just highlighting the case of the current position and joining the calls that have been made today in this chamber. So I want to finish again by thanking my honorable member, my friend for Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes, for raising this issue and giving us the opportunity to have this debate today, and also thank everyone for their engagement here and outside this room, but also a thanks to our kinship carers who are absolutely incredible people. And I'm so moved and grateful every single time I meet with them, and I know colleagues are too.

I hope they hear my commitment and determination to support them today and to ensure that future support is practical and that it's sustainable and focused on improving the outcomes for children and for families. So with that, Chair, I will conclude my remarks and hand back over to my honorable friend.

01:59:01 - 01:59:21

John Hayes

Thank you, Minister. The question is, oh, yes, no, no, no, I don't think you had a chance to sum up, Melanie, in the short debate. But as we've got extra time, just have a minute then. Have a minute. But just give me time to put the question afterwards.

Go on, 30 seconds, Melanie.

01:59:21 - 02:00:08

Melanie Onn

I will watch it. No. I just want to say a quick thank you to the charities Kinship and Family Rights Group for their research and their campaigning on this issue. If the government want people to remain economically active and financially stable to provide that stability necessary for the child or children, we have to really take this forward. I'm very grateful to the Minister for her generosity in hearing everybody.

We've had lots of contributions from members today, but that dreaded famous "at pace" comment. We will continue to keep up the pressure on our side. We really do need to get this right for every child that will go through this process while we are waiting, because between now and next year there'll be a huge number of children and we owe them and they deserve to get it right. Thank you.

02:00:08 - 02:00:29

John Hayes

The question is this House has considered the potential merits of statutory paid employment leave for kinship carers. As many of that opinion say aye. The contrary no. The ayes have it. Order.

Order. Order. Thank you. Dr. Simon Opher to move the motion. Where is he?

02:00:29 - 02:01:02

Speaker 48

He's just taking his seat. Thanks, Minister. Thank you. You're on.

02:01:02 - 02:04:33

Joseph Simon Opher

Thank you, Chair. And it's a pleasure to bring this debate here to the Parliament as chair of the Lords Reform All-Party Parliamentary Group. A few weeks ago, I showed a group of US doctors around Parliament. This involves sitting in the viewing gallery of the House of Lords, looking at King Charles' throne, the woolsack, and a scattering of some quite elderly peers. And one doctor said, "How do these guys get in here?"

When I answered that they were appointed by their mates, they all laughed. Surely I was joking, but sadly I wasn't joking. The reform of the House of Lords has been on the cards for centuries. It was actually abolished in 1649 but reinstated a few years later, and it's been the subject of intense debate ever since. The idea of unelected peers having inherited access to Parliament alongside crony appointees controlling the laws that Parliament produce is clearly ridiculous.

It's no wonder that there's a crisis of confidence in our political system, and that's at an all-time high. This government has actually taken quite big strides, and probably more than others, about the long-overdue removal of hereditary peers. And I welcome proposals to impose a retirement age and a minimum participation requirement. But we cannot afford to push this constitutional necessity further down the road. I will take this opportunity to set out the case for reform of the House of Lords and how we can go about implementing this.

So, the function of our second chamber is to scrutinize and amend legislation passed by the elected Commons. There are many exceptional lords who do a really good job at this. But their contribution is undermined by their complete lack of legitimacy. It's simply not right that our Parliament has more unelected lawmakers than those with a mandate from the people. And during the Makerfield by-election, the Prime Minister called this scandalous and expressed support for an early change to the Lords.

One of the things that has most surprised me is learning that the House of Lords remains a self-governing institution. In the last session, we saw a handful of unelected peers, many of whom were rejected by the voters at the last election, abuse this to stall the progression of legislation passed by the elected Commons. The other place is also deeply unrepresentative of our country. Over 55% of peers live in London and the South East. And I know that our Prime Minister is very concerned with this and has called for a Senate of nations and regions to replace the Lords so every corner of our country is properly represented in both of our chambers.

Also, the public want change. Only 16% actually support the current status quo. 70% have little or no confidence with the institution, and a majority actually want an entirely elected upper chamber. And the voters gave a very clear mandate for a Labour manifesto that had a commitment to replacing the House of Lords with an alternative second chamber that is more representative of the regions and the nations. What could a second chamber look like?

Well, it's a complex issue. We should convene a commission of citizens and experts to decide the role and makeup of the second chamber. It should still absolutely be possible to retain the expertise that we have, and that's exactly what our manifesto has committed us to. Labour will consult on proposals.

02:04:33 - 02:04:55

Mike Wood

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way, and he's obviously made a good start on setting out his case, but does he not see the irony in calling for an appointed committee of public and experts to look at how democratic the House of Lords is?

02:04:55 - 02:05:12

Joseph Simon Opher

Well, many thanks to the honourable member for that intervention, and I would say that, actually, no, I think we need experts to look at how our democracy works and devise a better way of doing it. How we appoint those experts should be up to us, but I'll certainly give way again.

02:05:12 - 02:05:35

Ben Morgan Lake

I'm very grateful to the honourable member and indeed congratulate him on securing this debate. Would he not agree that such a consultative process may well come about from a bill that my noble colleague, the noble Baroness, Baroness Smith of Llanfaes, has introduced to the second chamber? For indeed it should be for the experts to provide some ideas and then for us and other members of the public to consult on what is the best way forward for the second chamber.

02:05:35 - 02:07:39

Joseph Simon Opher

Yes, and I thank my honourable member for a good intervention. And in fact, I have been working with Baroness Smith around her amendment, and I do think we need to get the great minds of this country to devise a really good political system that really reflects our country and gives us our best government. So, let me find out where I was. So, I'd like really to suggest that we need a commission to look into this, and that that commission can take many experts. How that's actually constituted remains something that we can debate.

But I also would suggest that maybe they've announced that there's going to be a commission into electoral reform, and maybe this could also be extended to examine how the composition of the second chamber, because this is a holistic type approach to the system. I can see some members shaking their heads. I want to briefly touch on an issue which I know many of you care about: the lack of transparency in the other place. According to Transparency International's UK research, 128 peers hold paid political advisory roles that risk breaching parliamentary rules. And we must strengthen the House of Lords code of conduct to put beyond doubt that legislators who serve in the House of Lords should not be lobbyists.

And since 2013, almost a quarter of all nominations from political parties were political donors. So, that is the ultimate cronyism. So, to conclude, because I know many people wish to say some words, I ask if the Minister will meet with the APPG to discuss how the government intends to fulfill its manifesto commitment of consulting the public on an alternative second chamber, and will the Minister consider expanding the remit of the commission on electoral reform to cover this role and composition of the other place? It is time, Mr. Chair, to quote someone I don't normally agree with: it's time to take back control. Thank you.

02:07:39 - 02:07:55

John Hayes

I should remind members they should bob if they want to be called, and I can see a number are. I'll give priority to the people who applied to speak in the debate early. And the question is this House has considered House of Lords reform. Andrew Rosindell.

02:07:55 - 02:11:03

Andrew Rosindell

Thank you, Sir John, for calling me to speak in this debate this afternoon. I have been a Member of Parliament for 25 years, I think probably longer than anyone else in this chamber today. And I can tell you that the House of Lords, for all its faults over the years, I believe provides a balance to an elected chamber. And I think the honourable member proposing this debate, I'm afraid to say, misses the point about the House of Lords. What we do not want is another elected chamber to rival the House of Commons.

What we need is a House of experts, a House of elders, if you like, of people with knowledge, expertise, experience, that have served this country over many decades in different walks of life. And those, in a moment, and those also who represent the continuity. Sir John, you will know better than most that continuity is the foundation of the success of this nation. To ignore what has gone on in the past and not to have that continuous wisdom throughout the ages, to lose all of that is pure vandalism. So we don't want another elected set of politicians, which we know will be effectively appointed by party HQ.

The leaders' favourites will be put on some list and get put into the House of Lords, many of whom would have preferred to be in the House of Commons, but they're put in the House of Lords instead. A second set of politicians. I want a House of Lords which is depoliticised in many ways. So I'm not keen on the fact that both Labour, Conservative, and Liberal Democrats have put so many people into the Lords who are friends of the leader at the time, or special advisers to ministers and such like. What I want to see is more people who are truly representative of the whole country, but can provide knowledge, expertise, and experience to make our constitutional or parliamentary democracy stronger and better.

Now I would like to say, Sir John, that it cannot be right that one political party that came third at the last general election has zero representation in the House of Lords. There are 80 Lib Dem peers, 80, Sir John, and yet they received 600,000 less votes than Reform UK. The Greens, I believe, have three representatives. The Plaid Cymru, did you say two? Two, okay.

Plaid Cymru have representatives. The DUP have six, but only have five MPs. The thing is disproportionate. At least there should be representation of all political parties. So there does need to be, based on the votes at the last election, certainly a number of Reform UK Members of Parliament.

And can I also say that, okay, I will give way, yes, certainly.

02:11:03 - 02:11:27

Michael Peter Martin

I thank him for giving way, and there's just so much to feast upon there in his intervention. But just drawing out an inconsistency in his own speech. He likes experts and history, I like experts and history as well. Yet he says that we should have a chamber that's based upon the votes at the last election, so presumably that would be appointed by the parties. How do you balance those two, how does he intend to balance those two tensions?

02:11:27 - 02:13:20

Andrew Rosindell

Well, he will know that the way it works in the House of Lords is that it is based on party appointments.

So the Prime Minister will make nominations, so will the Leader of the Opposition, so will the leader of the Liberal Democrats, so will the leader of the Greens, and they will nominate a sprinkling of new peers every so often, usually once a year. Well, where was the invitation for the leader of Reform UK to nominate a number of Reform UK members of the House of Lords? He must surely accept that that is very wrong when you consider that Reform UK was the third largest party in terms of votes at the last election. But can I go back to my original argument? We're getting this wrong.

We will regret the day that we become only one of two elected chambers. We're going to regret that day. You'll create a rivalry between two sets of elected politicians who will claim to be truly representative of the people that have put them in there. Instead of having the primacy of the elected House of Commons, ultimately we are elected by the people of this country, we can ultimately make the final decision through the Parliament Act. We don't actually have to, at the end of the day, be obedient to the House of Lords.

What I do know is that within the House of Lords, there is an opportunity to have people there with enormous knowledge and expertise. Whether they are former cabinet ministers, former ambassadors or high commissioners, heads of industry, heads of the trade unions, it's good to have people like that, representatives of the different faith groups. It's right that we still have the established Church of England and the bishops, although these days they're rather more to the left than I would like, but they still represent the established church of this country. Yes, I'll give way.

02:13:20 - 02:13:30

Joseph Simon Opher

I thought that in the Reform manifesto they were going to abolish the House of Lords and indeed replace the House of Lords with a much smaller, more democratic second chamber.

02:13:30 - 02:16:39

Andrew Rosindell

Well, I didn't stand on that manifesto and I joined Reform UK after that manifesto, and I can tell you now that that is not our policy today. We are not going to abolish the House of Lords. We're not going to engage in constitutional vandalism. We're going to, as we've always done throughout the ages, Sir John, as you will know, we have evolved, evolved our constitutional and parliamentary democracy in a way that has given us strength, continuity, and has allowed us to change not in some radical direction whereby minorities and people with vested interests can finish up controlling the institutions of this country, but you do it in a way that is evolution rather than revolution. So there is no requirement to abolish the House of Lords.

There should not be an elected second chamber. In New Zealand, they got rid of their second chamber, so they only have one elected chamber. Now, I'd prefer that, frankly, than I would a second load of politicians in the House of Lords that wish they were MPs but they couldn't get there, so they were put in by their friends in the party HQ into the House of Lords. We don't want that. So if we do eventually abolish the upper house, frankly, it's better just to have one chamber than it is to have a second one also elected, because there will be rivalry between the two.

And if you look at it like this, if you actually choose carefully, change the system, make it more meritocratic in terms of experience and knowledge and the kind of people we really want in the House of Lords, actually, we're buying in expertise for very low cost. I mean, otherwise you're going to pay consultants and experts that work for companies to do an effective job of scrutinising legislation. So what is the point when you can actually give someone a peerage, someone with vast knowledge who's perhaps been an ambassador to a country or has headed up an important institution or has contributed to set up an amazing charity and has got vast knowledge of that? You know, people like Sebastian Coe, Olympic gold medallist, and he of course ran the Olympics in 2012.

People like that have value. But they're not going to stand for election. You're going to lose all those people. You're going to lose, you're going to lose, you're not going to stand for election for the Lords. You're going to lose, you're going to lose good people.

The great and the good will go and you'll finish up with people, as I've said earlier, who want to be politicians and will have to settle for second best. I don't think that's good enough. I think that we should do what we've always done in this country and allow our constitution, our parliamentary democracy to, yes, change by all means, but in a gentle and evolutionary way so that we don't get rid of a tried and tested system that has lasted for generations and, with all its faults, has actually done this country rather well over the centuries. Thank you.

02:16:39 - 02:16:55

John Hayes

Thank you. I shall be calling the front benches at ten past five. As you can see, there's a lot of people standing, that gives you a feel for how long you've got. So three or four minutes each, I'm afraid. And I'm going to call Phil Brickell, please.

02:16:55 - 02:18:11

Michael Philip Brickell

Thank you, Sir John, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. First, can I thank the member for Stroud for securing this critical debate. I know he's a champion in pursuing long-overdue reform to the upper chamber. Let me start with this. As chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Anti-Corruption and Responsible Tax, I have had the privilege of working with a number of excellent peers who are deeply committed, yes, to legislative scrutiny and improving our legislation.

There are many, many members of the Lords who perform a vital public service. But good people can still be trapped in a bad system. And the public can see that. Why is it acceptable in this country for lawmakers in the upper house, as the honorable member for Stroud has mentioned, to work as lobbyists at the same time? How can the public be expected to trust the system where those shaping legislation can also be paid to influence it?

In my old life as a compliance officer, that wouldn't have passed the most basic conflict of interest test. It shouldn't pass that same test in Parliament either. Transparency International UK has gone on as far as calling the House of Lords, and I quote, "a lobbying network for hire". If that doesn't set alarm bells ringing, and they are the true experts here, I don't know what will. And while we're asking difficult questions, yes, I will give way.

02:18:11 - 02:18:35

James William Naish

Thank you for giving way. While it's only a couple of individuals involved, he may not be aware there are still Lords who sit on Hong Kong's Court of Final Appeal and can be paid up to forty thousand pounds a month despite the national security law obviously effectively meaning that the courts in Hong Kong are a kangaroo court. I wonder if he would agree with me that actually nobody from this place, in either this house or the other place, should be involved in anything to do with implementing the national security law in Hong Kong.

02:18:35 - 02:21:54

Michael Philip Brickell

I welcome that intervention from my honorable friend and he is absolutely right to talk about kangaroo courts in Hong Kong that UK lawmakers should not be complicit in supporting. Now while we're asking difficult questions, here's another. Why is it possible to be appointed to the legislature of the United Kingdom and then barely show up? I can think of no other workplace where you can disappear for months, sometimes years, and still retain the right to walk back in and take part in decisions affecting millions of people. An honor should come with responsibilities.

Membership of Parliament should not be a lifetime pass with no expectation of participation. And then there's the size of the place. About eight hundred peers. Eight hundred peers. The House of Lords is larger than almost every comparable second chamber in the democratic world.

When people talk about a bloated state, perhaps they should start by walking through Westminster Hall and turning right at Central Lobby. Nobody seriously believes that adding more peers automatically leads to better scrutiny. What it does lead to is a system that looks increasingly detached from the public it serves. And who gets to participate? The overwhelming majority of working peers are based in London and the South East, and it is not right, for instance, that the North West, my region, for example, is so underrepresented.

But it's hardly surprising when the accommodation allowance is £125 a night. It sounds reasonable until you actually try finding somewhere to stay in Central London at that rate. The result's obvious. Those with substantial means or those who live close enough to commute have a built-in advantage. We should not be deciding a legislature that prices out talent from the nations and the regions.

Then there's the transparency. Why don't peers have to declare how much time they spend on outside employment compared with their parliamentary duties? Why don't they have to declare how much they're paid for those jobs? The public are entitled to know where lawmakers are earning their money and who could be influencing them. Elsewhere on standards, the new legislation on disgraced peers announced in the last King's Speech is long overdue.

And so I'd like to ask the Minister, will he reaffirm the government's commitment to that proposal? Elsewhere, what progress has been made on the government's progress on three other manifesto commitments? First, new participation requirements. Second, delivering national and regional balance of the upper chamber. Finally, and most importantly, reforming the appointments process.

Because removing the worst offenders is not the same as fixing the system that allowed them through the door. That's why we need stronger suitability and propriety checks through the House of Lords Appointments Committee. Those reforms should include putting HOLAC on a statutory footing and giving it an effective veto to demonstrably unsuitable appointments. And let's tackle one final issue head-on, Sir John. Why should major party donors be rewarded with lifelong seats in the legislature?

Public appointments should be earned through service and expertise, not purchased through checkbooks. The House of Lords does important work. But in conclusion, many diligent and hardworking peers I know feel they're having their reputations dragged through the mud by certain individuals who are exploiting or sometimes actively enabled by a broken system. A smaller house, a cleaner house, a more transparent house. That's not radical.

Surely it's just common sense.

02:21:54 - 02:21:55

Andrew George.

02:21:55 - 02:27:05

Andrew George

Thank you, Sir John. And congratulations to the honourable member for Stretford for not only securing this debate, but the manner in which he introduced it, and indeed his intervention on the honourable member for Romford, which I think rather exposed the case that he was making. Indeed, the honourable member for Romford indicated that he was happy to join the party which proposed to abolish the thing that he wants to protect, that he wants to depoliticise the thing that he wants to politicise more, and he wishes to maintain continuity of a body by changing it quite radically according to the proposals that he has. But what I would say is that one of the reasons we are here today is because a small number of the House of Lords made a very eloquent and strong case for their own abolition in the manner in which they treated the Terminally Ill Adults (Dying) Bill earlier this year. They spent many months filibustering in order to effectively block that bill, exceeding the powers that clearly the House of Lords should have.

It raises the question, indeed I've often raised the question, of why do we want what is a second chamber there for?

And I think that most people, indeed even the honorable member for Romford was suggested that in fact it is there for sober second thought, independent scrutiny of the kind of things which we send down to that place to encourage us to take a less tribal view on the legislation which we are seeking to take forward and providing the kind of expert scrutiny which is really very helpful to the process we're engaged in. However, as other people have already, and indeed the honorable member for Bolton West very articulately put, the process of patronage or the system of patronage is both corrupting and extremely corruptible. And clearly that needs to be swept away in any reforms to the House of Lords. But the question then is what do you put in its place? Now I entirely understand the emotional response which is, well you obviously elect, you have an elected chamber there.

And I'm going to challenge that by, I've often said that in fact what we want to do is to retain what is best in the House of Lords Appointments Commission because I think it provides at least the template of a very helpful function, and particularly if we can attract the kind of people that indeed the honorable member for Romford described, so that a sliver, a proportion, a minority of those members are selected according to the qualities that they can bring to the place. And indeed I would say that the rest of it should be on the basis of a jury service, in other words a citizens' assembly that has been proposed by a large number of people and organizations over time. Of course, as I say, I can entirely understand the laudable and emotional response which is that one elects this chamber. But there is a risk which indeed I think the honorable member for Romford did reasonably put forward, which is the risk that it becomes either a lapdog or a logjam to this chamber because clearly in those circumstances we saw with the Terminally Ill Bill that they would then argue that they have the democratic legitimacy to in fact undertake to actually challenge the decisions of the primary chamber. I mean we don't, for example, say that because they have political influence on the kind of things and decisions which are taken in our country, that we don't say that for example members of the Environment Agency board, Natural England, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, or the Committee on Climate Change, the Low Pay Commission, we don't say that because they have powers that they should be elected.

And therefore on that basis, I mean I would argue that the argument for an elected second chamber actually for my part, I'm sorry to say, do actually evaporate away. And I think that we need to find other ways of ensuring that we have the genuine sober second thought and independent scrutiny that I believe that this chamber needs and deserves. Otherwise, I'm afraid it would be better quite frankly to turn the place into a museum. Thank you, Sir John.

02:27:05 - 02:27:07

Speaker 60

Kim Leadbeater.

02:27:07 - 02:31:51

Kim Leadbeater

Thank you, Sir John, it's a pleasure to see you in the chair. And I thank my honorable friend the member for Stroud for securing this debate. When I became an MP more than five years ago now, I entered this place with a very open mind about most things, which is perhaps as well, including in relation to the role of the House of Lords.

I didn't feel strongly about the other place one way or the other. But since I've been an MP, I've developed not only a greater understanding of what they do and how they do it, but also actually quite a deep respect for the important role that they play in our democracy. I am supportive of a second chamber. I believe in an upper house. It scrutinises, it revises, it brings fresh eyes, new ideas, and if I may be so bold Sir John, decades of experience and expertise.

It can make our legislation stronger and our democratic process more robust. And there've been many examples of this over the years. The Domestic Abuse Act was strengthened in the Lords, where an amendment was introduced, a new fate a new offence of non-fatal strangulation, closing a gap that had let abusers escape charges. Similarly, crossbench and opposition peers spearheaded amendments creating a powerful new corporate criminal offence, failure to prevent fraud, in the 2023 Economic Crime Act, a significant moment in the fight against economic crime. That is what good revision looks like.

It is responsible lawmaking. However, I come to this debate with direct experience of where the second chamber has sadly not behaved responsibly or appropriately. As the sponsor of a private member's bill, I think it's fair to say a reasonably well-known piece of legislation, the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, I ended up spending a significant amount of time in the Lords. Following months and months of hard work in the Commons, including countless meetings with outstanding civil servants from the Department of Health and Social Care and the Ministry of Justice, a comprehensive bill committee which heard from nearly 50 witnesses, and powerful and emotional debates in the Commons at second and third readings. The bill made its way to the Lords.

It had had over 100 hours of scrutiny. It was examined line by line. It was amended and strengthened, and it passed the elected chamber with a clear majority on both occasions. Yet despite a clear majority of elected MPs having engaged at length with their constituents and taken the issue extremely seriously, voting to send the bill to the other place, what happened next was not what I think most MPs, however they voted, and more importantly, the public, either expected or deserved. I was very grateful to those peers who engaged in meaningful scrutiny and discussion about the bill, and there were many of those.

I was in awe at times of their experience and expertise, and it was a pleasure working with them. In some instances we disagreed, but we did so respectfully. I myself and Lord Faulkner, the sponsor of the bill in the other place, were open to making changes to strengthen the legislation. There were amendments we were happy to accept, and we engaged with peers in good faith. But nearly 1,200 amendments were tabled.

And as my honourable friend has said, around half of them came from just seven peers. And looking at the content of many of those amendments, which were inappropriate and at times actually cruel, it was clear to many that some peers intentionally used every tool at their disposal to bring the legislative process to a standstill. As we know, the other place, unlike the Commons, is self-regulating. There is no selection of amendments and no time limit, so every amendment that is tabled is likely to be debated. There was seemingly a desire from some peers to slow the process down and disrupt the usual legislative process.

In the House of Commons we did our job, but with shocking examples such as the amendments that were tabled in the House of Lords, the same simply cannot be said of the other place. One peer spoke for four hours and 41 minutes. That is longer than the Lord of the Rings: Return of the King, extended edition. A great film, but not the most succinct piece of cinema. And I say this not to be disrespectful to the other place, but to ask the simple question: was this responsible behaviour, and were they fairly and professionally carrying out their role as the second chamber?

I think not. Then there is the cost. The Lords' debate on this bill cost the taxpayer over 1.7 million pounds in attendance allowances. Public money spent so that a bill could go nowhere. The public have got every right to expect good value from their institutions, because we work for them, and I do not think anyone with a clear conscience can say that was a good use of taxpayers' money.

We've also got to look at the makeup of the chamber. 26 bishops sit in the House of Lords. Now I have no problem with religion per se, but nobody elected them. They sit solely because of the position they hold. The only other country in the world that gives clerics seats in its legislature in this way is Iran.

In a modern multi-faith, increasingly secular society, is that fit for purpose? We need a second chamber that supports and challenges.

02:31:51 - 02:31:52

Will the lady give way?

02:31:53 - 02:32:07

Andrew Rosindell

Is the lady actually also calling for the disestablishment of the Church of England? Is she asking, is she asking that the cross be taken off the crown so the Christian foundations of this country are no longer part of our constitutional arrangement?

02:32:07 - 02:33:11

Kim Leadbeater

I think, I may say that's quite a leap of faith to go from the comments I was making about the unelected chamber to the Church of England, for whom I have the utmost respect and have worked with many people of faith on an agenda around cohesion and the need to bring our communities together, something which I'm sure he would fully support. But we've got to question that in what is a multi-faith and increasingly secular society, whether that is the right thing to do to have unelected faith leaders in our second chamber. Look, the Prime Minister has said himself, I don't think we can justify half of our national legislature being unelected. I think this is something that in many ways is quite scandalous. If you want to cut the cost of politics, that's the first place to look.

The Prime Minister has also spoken about his desire to rewire how power works in this country. Surely we cannot do this without looking at the role of the House of Lords. I agree with the Prime Minister. And I agree with my honorable friend the member for Stroud that we do need a national commission into the future of the House of Lords, and I'm pleased to speak in support of that today.

02:33:11 - 02:33:12

Ellie Chowns.

02:33:12 - 02:37:04

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Sir John. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I thank the, my honorable friend for Stroud for securing this really important debate. I represent the Green Party, and for many, many, many years we have supported the abolition of the House of Lords and its replacement with a fully elected second chamber. I'm personally fairly agnostic to the exact format of how that should be done, but I fundamentally believe that a basic principle of democracy is that the legitimacy of the lawmakers comes from the trust put in them, the authority entrusted in lawmakers in the legislature by the people, by the voters. Not by the people in charge of a political party who draw up a list from time to time, not some of which clearly is related to the amount of money that's been donated over periods of years by some of the people that end up in the other place.

And not even through the legitimacy that an individual achieves within their specialized sphere of expertise because of many long years of practice in that field. Absolutely, we should as a house, as a parliament, be drawing on expertise from all across the full panoply of sectors in our country. But we need to ask ourselves who should fundamentally be making the laws, and it should be people who are working on the basis of the trust given them by the voters, by the people, on the basis of every vote having equal weight, which is why I'm equally passionate about the importance of a proportionally elected parliament. Fundamentally, we have a system with the House of Lords which is undemocratic, it's hugely unrepresentative in all sorts of dimensions, all sorts of areas of demographics, and it's untransparent because so much of the decision-making about who goes on it is done behind closed doors. How can that be suitable for the 21st century?

So we have a huge problem with the composition of the House of Lords.

We also have a problem with the functioning of the House of Lords. Now, yes, it's important that legislation is properly scrutinized, that there are full opportunities to amend it. And we've got questions to ask ourselves in the Commons about how well we do those things, how well our system enables us to do these things. But we don't fix them with an institution like the House of Lords, no matter how effective individual members of the Lords may be in their work. And I do, like colleagues here, pay tribute to the work of so many members of the Lords who do take their roles seriously, who do bring expertise, who do pay attention to the job that they are there to do.

But as my honorable friend has just pointed out, we've seen a huge failure in the functioning of the House of Lords because effectively the will of a few members of the House of Lords has overridden the will of the House of Commons. And that cannot be right. So we desperately need reform. And I welcome the proposal by my honorable friend for Stroud for a national commission on reform of the House of Lords. And to address a point that was raised by the opposition spokesperson earlier, I would strongly favor the inclusion of a citizens' assembly as part of that process of the national commission.

Because I do fundamentally believe that a representative sample of the British people, representing all demographics and engaging in the detail of the questioning of how we can structure our political system so that the people's voice is heard, that must be a fundamental part of any reform process. But we cannot continue as we are with an undemocratic, unrepresentative, untransparent second chamber, and we must have reform. Thank you.

02:37:04 - 02:37:17

Speaker 63

I agree with that last sentence. I'm not sure if the entire last speaker will take the time themselves down here. Sure. So one more speaker on this side. Yeah.

02:37:17 - 02:40:05

John Slinger

Well, thank you, Sir John. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I praise my honorable friend from Stroud for securing this debate. I'm glad that our new Prime Minister has referred to the importance of rewiring the state. We should absolutely rewire this place, and I offer a solution. I too have my doubts about an elected upper chamber for reasons that honorable members have already rehearsed.

So I think we can improve the best elements, we can preserve rather the best elements of the other place, the House of Lords, and we can also improve its deficiencies. The best elements are obviously its expertise, its ability to scrutinize and revise, although I must note that the behavior of a minority appears regarding the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill was shameful, absolutely shameful. But regarding improving on the deficiencies, the deficiencies are of course its patchy expertise, an opaque selection process, lack of legitimacy, lack of democracy, and its unrepresentative nature around demography, geography, ethnicity. So I'd rename the other place. I would call it another kind of place, a Senate.

I would have 50% of its members being experts, the other 50% being citizen senators, a point that has been already mentioned by the honorable members for Yeovil and North Herefordshire in anticipating what I'm about to say. Regarding experts, certainly the House of Lords Appointments Commission does a good job in difficult circumstances, but we need a more transparent system. We need a more open system. I would recommend that experts are appointed from across the range of sectors in our society. They are given a limited tenure of office of 10 years.

If the President of the United States can get a lot done in 8 years, I'm sure that expert senators would be able to do a lot in 10 years. But on the more interesting side, half of the upper chamber as I'm envisioning, citizen senators, I think these should be selected by lot, by sortition. It's a form of democracy. They would be serving as if they were, they would serve using the same principles that people who serve in juries do, whereby they forego their political biases and other biases and serve in the national interest to scrutinize legislation that comes to them from the elected chamber, which of course must have primacy.

So let's rewire this place, starting with the other place. Let's inject some more expertise, more fairly and transparently appointed. Let's bring people into the heart of this Parliament through a system of citizen senators to improve, not to block legislation through the lens of national, not party interest.

02:40:05 - 02:40:18

John Hayes

Kit Malthouse. Kit, do you want to give a minute? I'll give you a minute. Okay, in that case, fine. In that case, I call the Liberal Democrat spokesman, Lisa Smart.

02:40:18 - 02:42:26

Lisa Smart

Thank you very much, Sir John. Pleasure to serve with you in the chair and I very warmly congratulate the honorable member for Stroud both for the way he opened this debate and for the way he chairs the APPG for Lords reform. Liberal Democrats have called for a democratic second chamber for decades. We simply believe that those who make the law should at some point be accountable to those who have to obey it. In the other place, that link does not exist.

And people across the country understand this. They see a chamber filled by prime ministerial appointment where a seat in our legislature can follow years of party loyalty or a generous donation. That system ingrains patronage. It feeds the sense that politics is run by and for a small elite. And it's one of the reasons so many people have lost faith in our democratic institutions.

Now, in her excellent speech earlier in this debate, the honorable member for Spen Valley mentioned the Lords Spiritual, the 26 Church of England bishops who take their seats in the other place. And I don't think it's an excessive understatement to say that that arrangement feels a bit outdated, Sir John. Britain today is a country of many faiths and none, and nobody should have a hand in making our laws simply because of the religious office they hold. It is surely long past time to modernize. Now, peers may also be appointed as they are seen to be experts within a field.

But as there is currently no time limit on how long they sit within the Lords, this could mean that someone was indeed an expert in something 40 years ago, but the field has moved on vastly, yet they still legislate in that area being viewed as a specialist. Now, when thinking about these issues, some say that it isn't a priority. It doesn't come up very often on the doorstep. But a quick look at my inbox shows that some of my Hazel Grove constituents do indeed care about it enough to contact their MP. I've had constituents write into me about this, including most recently Kelly from Offerton, who argued powerfully that we should have an elected second chamber.

Well, I agree with Kelly. We Lib Dems supported the Hereditary Peers Bill. Nobody can seriously defend a place in Parliament being handed down through a family line. But removing the remaining...

02:42:26 - 02:42:27

Will she give way?

02:42:27 - 02:42:28

With pleasure.

02:42:28 - 02:42:45

Andrew Rosindell

On that basis, would she abolish royal consent, royal assent for bills? And does she also accept that our constitution is the King in Parliament, so the King, the House of Lords, and the House of Commons? Is she actually arguing for the abolition of the monarchy on that basis?

02:42:45 - 02:46:07

Lisa Smart

Well, he's extended himself several times this afternoon, Sir John, and I for one am here for it. There are many things I would change about the way our country runs. And I think if we were designing a country from scratch, I don't think we would have a Parliament like this. I don't think we would have a monarchy like this. I think the monarch and the royal family do a really important job in all sorts of ways, but I would change very much the relationship between Parliament and the monarch, to answer his question, yes, I would.

Removing the remaining hereditary peers on its own does not go anywhere near far enough. And that's why my honorable friend, the member for Richmond Park, tabled an amendment to the Hereditary Peers Bill to replace every unelected member with a fully elected chamber.

Sadly, neither the Labour Party nor the Conservative Party supported that, which feels to me, Sir John, like a missed opportunity to begin the transition. We continue to see events that highlight why we should have an elected and accountable second chamber. The Mandelson scandal has shown how poorly the current chamber copes when a member appointed for life has lost the public's trust. In 2025, according to an Electoral Commission study, only 14% of respondents said that they trust politicians. We must all work to improve that level of trust, and increasing accountability in Parliament feels to me like an important place to start.

In February, my right honourable friend the member for Kingston and Surbiton, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, called for legislation to strip Peter Mandelson of his peerage. Ministers told the public that reform was urgent and that they were talking to other parties, and the Removal of Peerages Bill was included in the last King's Speech. Yet we're still to see any wide-scale reform, and I'd be grateful if the minister could confirm if and when we should expect to see legislation to produce reform in the House of Lords, including but not limited to the Removal of Peerages Bill. Now, the Representation of the People Bill could have been a good place to start making vital reforms to the way the second chamber works. That bill contains welcome measures, including votes at 16, steps towards automatic voter registration, and a U-turn on the independence of the Electoral Commission, all changes Lib Dems have campaigned for, but the bill says nothing about the Lords, nothing about proportional representation, and far too little about the money that flows into our politics.

We want the government to stop tinkering at the margins and make the real changes that are needed to fix the broken political system we currently operate in. And there are steps they could take now: implement the 2017 Burns report, bring down the House of Lords to 600 members, introduce the retirement age for peers that Labour promised in its own 2024 manifesto, put the ministerial code into law so that ministers... Gareth Snell. Or not, Sir John, as you're shaking your head. Gareth Snell, and then you'd better wind up.

Great. I just need to declare my interest as well, Sir John, that my wife is the deputy government chief whip in the House of Lords, but she will know, the honourable lady will know, that the Taylor report is bringing in a retirement age, it is going to be a mandatory age of 80 for all members of the House of Lords, and things of those are then progressing. And I look forward to seeing that at pace, which I'm sure is what's going on. Indeed, my next line is move at pace to move power out of Westminster and Whitehall, but none of this is a substitute for the end goal: our second chamber needs the legitimacy that only a democratic mandate can give it, and the Lib Dems will keep making that case until it is won.

02:46:07 - 02:46:12

Speaker 67

Opposition spokesperson, Mike Wood.

02:46:12 - 02:50:35

Mike Wood

Thank you, Sir John. The question of reforming the House of Lords is obviously not a new one; successive administrations of all political colours have grappled with it for decades, indeed more than a century, discovering that constitutional upheaval tends to be far easier to promise from opposition than it is to deliver successfully from government. But that history reminds us of a fundamental truth: constitutional reform must always be approached with care, caution, balance, and a clear understanding of the consequences. Now, the House of Lords is far from perfect, I think we would all agree, and certainly no one on this side of the House suggests otherwise. But it performs a vital constitutional function.

It provides thorough legislative scrutiny, it brings unmatched expertise from law, science, business, and public service into Parliament, and it holds ministers to account. Crucially, it serves as a vital check on the executive, ensuring legislation is properly stress-tested and challenging governments when they get things wrong. As someone who was a member of the Government Whips' Office before the last election, this is not always convenient for governments, but it is a core constitutional function.

So any sensible reform must preserve and enhance that scrutiny and never dismantle it purely for political convenience or political advantage. And that is where we have serious concerns regarding the government's approach. In its 2024 manifesto, as has been said, Labour declared that the House of Lords was too large and promised to reduce its numbers. But since then, their actions have told a rather different story. Even after expelling the hereditary peers, the House of Lords still stands at around 800 members.

That's more than when the government first declared that it was bloated. Apparently, the second chamber is too big unless Downing Street happens to be the one packing the red benches. And so I hope the minister can explain that contradiction. Appointments must reflect the expertise that parliament requires, not serve as a patronage machine to manufacture a compliant legislature. Then there is the government's more radical proposition: abolishing the Lords entirely in favor of an elected Senate of the nations and regions.

But ambition is no substitute for detail. What powers would such a body possess? How would it be elected? And critically, how would it relate to the democratically elected House of Commons? These are not minor procedural queries, and the fact that the mover of this debate today seems to answer that question with an unelected panel to decide just highlights the fact that the Labour manifesto promised radical reform of the Lords, they had no idea what that radical reform meant and no plan to deliver it.

If an elected second chamber can claim equal democratic legitimacy, we invite constitutional gridlock, competing mandates, and perpetual legislative paralysis. Our parliamentary system works precisely because it respects the primacy of this elected house and has done for a century and more while giving the revising chamber the freedom to scrutinize. We should not discard that balance for an untested experiment. So when will the minister launch the proposed public consultation, or is the government expecting parliament to sign a blank check on Lords reform? Turning to immediate measures, the opposition engaged constructively with the House of Lords Retirement and Participation Committee.

We agree that peers must actively contribute. However, we hold grave reservations about an arbitrary retirement age of 80. The distinct value of the other place lies in wisdom, institutional memory, and lifetime service, and so we should assess peers on the quality of their contribution, not the date on their birth certificate. Sensible reform is possible, just as previous Conservative governments enabled voluntary retirement and expulsion for misconduct. We are ready to discuss appointments, size, and standards.

But the constitution does not belong to the government of the day; it belongs to our nation. I'll give way very briefly, but I mustn't eat into the time.

02:50:35 - 02:50:44

Andrew Rosindell

On the question of appointments, does he agree with me that it's only right that the third largest party in this country should have some representation in the House of Lords today?

02:50:44 - 02:51:27

Mike Wood

Well, I mean, it will be beyond me to decide who should and shouldn't be in the House of Lords anytime soon, but I do note that his party leader last month was talking about flooding the House of Lords with hundreds of new Reform peers, and if that didn't work to get their legislative agenda through, he's going to have a referendum on abolishing it. So I think the Reform Party's position on this does seem a little confused. Now, the second chamber does not exist to make life comfortable for ministers, but to hold power to account. The test of any reform is not whether it delivers a compliant parliament, but whether it serves the British people.

That is the test against which His Majesty's opposition will hold the government to account.

02:51:27 - 02:51:33

John Hayes

Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Cabinet Office, Mark Ferguson.

02:51:33 - 02:52:58

Andrew Mark Ferguson

Thank you, Sir John. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I'd like to begin by thanking my honourable friend the member for Stroud for securing this debate today. I'd also like to thank honourable members for their contributions this afternoon to what has been, unsurprisingly, an interesting and enlightening debate. Before responding to some of the specific questions raised during the debate, I would firstly like to set out the government's approach to reforming the House of Lords.

The government has a number of manifesto commitments in this space and is approaching reform of the second chamber in stages. The first stage is already complete. In the previous session, Parliament passed legislation to remove the right of the remaining hereditary peers to sit and vote in the House of Commons, an important and historic step. This means that no peer can now be a member of the House of Lords solely on the basis of birthright. We are currently in the second stage and focused on implementing our manifesto commitments on a retirement age and participation requirement, something I know members on all sides are concerned about.

For a long time, there's been general agreement in both houses that the second chamber is too big. However, in asking more members of the second chamber to depart by introducing a retirement age, new talent will be required. New people will need time to learn how to develop expertise and how to fulfill their duties as members of the other place effectively.

02:52:58 - 02:53:37

Kit Malthouse

Absolutely. I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. But would he agree with me that more important than the the number of people or how often they attend the house is what has become clear is that individual peers are much more powerful than individual elected members of Parliament. They have greater privileges, less transparency, they're able to influence legislation to a much greater degree than we are in this elected house. And that is what lies at the fundamental heart of the problem.

And so while we can indulge ourselves in these tweaks, and all governments have done it around the edge, in the end, unless we address that fundamental problem, the dissatisfaction will continue.

02:53:37 - 03:00:17

Andrew Mark Ferguson

I thank the honourable member for his point. I know he has very strong views on this, and I'm glad he has had an opportunity to contribute to this debate, and I'm sure he'll continue to contribute in future. Look, I I take his point. I don't entirely agree. I think the primacy of the House of Commons is incredibly important, and the primacy of MPs is incredibly important.

And again, I feel like that would be shared, unsurprisingly, by a room full of members of the House of Commons. These manifesto commitments, though, that I referred to, the retirement age, the participation requirement, these will have a direct impact on members of the other place. Therefore, during the passage of the House of Lords Hereditary Peers Act 2026, the leader of the House of Lords proposed to establish a dedicated select committee to provide the opportunity for the second chamber itself to shape how these further reforms are delivered. The Retirement and Participation Committee published its report in July and was debated in the other place in September. The committee's report has been genuinely house-led, with over 100 members submitting evidence to the committee.

The government is carefully considering the committee's recommendations and will respond substantively later this year, something I know if you are here this afternoon, you will absolutely be looking out for. The historical context of House of Lords reform tells us, though, that an incremental approach is often quite effective. Throughout the 20th century, there were various attempts to fully reform the second chamber. Some passed, some failed. Of course, there were the Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949, but there were decades of stagnation and stalled attempts.

The previous Labour government managed to introduce the House of Lords Act 1999, reducing the number of hereditary peers from around 700 to 92. In the 21st century, a Royal Commission and joint committee of both houses were established, alongside the publication of numerous white papers during the Blair and Brown years. The coalition government introduced a bill which was voted down in the House of Commons.

None of these attempts were able to bring about lasting reform to the second chamber. However, during that time, reforms on expulsion, attendance, and resignation that held cross-party consensus were able to pass. That is why the government is focused on conducting a staged approach to House of Lords reform. We're focused on delivering outcomes and keeping promises. Rather than attempting to reform the whole house in a single go, our strategy is to implement important initial reforms that meet our objectives of a smaller second chamber that better represents the country it serves.

And therefore, the third stage, which takes up a large proportion of the debate today and on which specific points I will return. The third stage of reform focuses on the manifesto commitment to consult on proposals to replace the Lords with an alternative second chamber. The government recognizes that previous public consultations and attempts to reform the house did not bring about lasting change. So the government wants to see a second chamber that better represents the nations and regions, something I personally am very interested in. I know honorable members share that vision.

There are many ways of achieving this goal and we owe it to the public to get this consultation right. Now, addressing some of the specific points made by individual members here today, I want to thank again my honorable friend, the member for Stroud. He referenced at one point the House of Lords being abolished in 1649. A lot of things happened in 1649, some of which we may not wish to repeat. It was also enjoyable and entertaining in a different way to hear from the honorable member for Romford.

Now, I was surprised to hear him say that he wants continuity when there hasn't even been continuity in the party that he's represented within this parliament. Look, I think this country needs to change. I believe in his own way he believes the country needs to change, otherwise his recent change of party is somewhat surprising. Although I did enjoy when he dabbled in unicameralism. I wasn't necessarily expecting that point, often in this place championed by former Labour member Mike Gapes, a proud unicameralist, I know.

There aren't many of them in the house, so it was interesting to hear that point made by the member for Romford. On the size and composition of the Lords, one of the many points made by my honorable friend, the member for Bolton West. Look, the government believes that all peers should make an active contribution to the House of Lords. There is a general, albeit not universal, consensus that the size of the second chamber is too big. In addressing that, we should recognize that the pace of change in every field is increasing, which necessitates new talent with up-to-date experience.

The introduction of a participation requirement and a retirement age sit at the heart of this work and, as the leader of the house has said before, we believe the second chamber works best when it is full-time with part-time members. As I've said, with regard to his point, which I will return to in a moment in regard to the number of representatives from the nations and regions, of course that is something that I think he will get a lot of sympathy from on these benches. With relevance to HOLAC, look, HOLAC is an independent, is HOLAC is independent and vetting for propriety includes checks with government departments, agencies, and other organizations including the Electoral Commission. It plays a vital role in vetting all peers and nominating crossbenchers to the Lords. With regard to my honorable friend, the member for Spen Valley, look, she speaks passionately about the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill and I know her frustrations on this matter.

It's obviously a sensitive and delicate subject matter that should be dealt with seriously. The government was and remains neutral on that specific bill and the issue of assisted dying and it is up to the other place to determine how that bill was scrutinized as with other legislation.

With regard to the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, I enjoyed the reference to Kelly or her constituent, although I would always warn against weighing the mailbag for how important an issue is. I'm sure all members would agree with that. And I was quite interested to hear the Lib Dem position with regard to the monarch. That said, loss of trust in politics, alas, comes at least as much from the Commons as it does from the Lords. With regard to removal of peerages, it is unacceptable that disgraced peers are able to retain their peerages regardless of circumstances.

Legislation to enable peerages to be removed was included in the King's Speech. The government will announce further details in due course. With regard to the opposition spokesperson, he talks of care, caution, and balance. I'm disappointed that wasn't the position they took with regard to the abolition, I'm afraid, of the hereditary principle. To conclude, once more, I would like to thank honorable and right honorable members for this very thought-provoking debate on the second chamber.

03:00:17 - 03:00:18

Order, order. The sitting stands adjourned.