House of Lords

7 September 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
04:07 - 06:28
Speaker 4
Charles the Third, by the Grace of God, of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and of our other realms and territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith.  To all lords spiritual and temporal, and all other our subjects whatsoever, to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we of our especial grace, certain knowledge and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958, and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create and prefer our trusty and well-beloved Christina Campbell McAnea to the state, degree, style, dignity, title and honor of Baroness McAnea, of Kelvingrove in our city of Glasgow.  And for us, our heirs and successors, do appoint, give and grant unto her the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title and honor of Baroness McAnea, to have and to hold unto her for her life.  Willing and by these presents granting for us, our heirs and successors, that she may have, hold and possess a seat, place and voice in the parliaments and public assemblies and councils of us, our heirs and successors, within our United Kingdom, amongst the barons. 

And also that she may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities and advantages to the degree of a baron duly and of right belonging, which barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed, or as they do at present use and enjoy.  In witness whereof, we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourself at Westminster, in the forenoon of the seventeenth day of August, in the fourth year of our reign.  By warrant under the King's sign manual. 
06:28 - 06:46
Speaker 3
I, Christina, Baroness McAnea, do swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.  So help me God. 
10:15 - 12:45
Speaker 4
Charles the Third, by the Grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of our other realms and territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith.  To all Lords Spiritual and Temporal and all other our subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we of our especial grace, certain knowledge and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create and prefer our trusty and well-beloved Timothy John Smith, Commander of our most excellent Order of the British Empire, to the state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Smith of Ranmoor, of Ranmoor in our city of Sheffield.  And for us, our heirs and successors, do appoint, give and grant unto him the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Smith of Ranmoor, to have and to hold unto him for his life. 

Willing and by these presents granting for us, our heirs and successors, that he may have, hold and possess a seat, place and voice in the parliaments and public assemblies and councils of us, our heirs and successors within our United Kingdom amongst the barons.  And also that he may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, preeminences, immunities and advantages to the degree of a baron duly and of right belonging, which barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed, or as they do at present use and enjoy.  In witness whereof, we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourself at Westminster in the afternoon of the 17th day of August in the fourth year of our reign, by warrant under the King's sign manual. 
12:45 - 15:21
Speaker 7
I, Timothy, Lord Smith of Ranmoor, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors according to law. 
15:21 - 15:48
Speaker 2
My Lords, I should like to notify the House of the retirement with effect from yesterday of the noble Lord, Lord Wilson of Dinton, pursuant to section 1 of the House of Lords Reform Act 2014.  On behalf of the House, I should like to thank the noble Lord for his much valued service to the House.  First oral question, Baroness Maclean of Reditch. 
15:48 - 15:53
Speaker 1
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper. 
15:53 - 16:38
Speaker 8
My Lords, success will be measured against five minimum national goals in the neighborhood health framework, which was published in March 2026, and that will include improved access to general practice and better urgent and emergency care performance.  Integrated care boards and local authorities will establish locally owned neighborhood plans with metrics that reflect population needs.  An independent national evaluation, which will be commissioned through the NIHR, started this April in order to support national policy and delivery of neighborhood health and evaluate its adoption and uptake. 
16:38 - 17:16
Speaker 1
My Lords, I thank the Minister for that answer.  She set out the government policy, which states that local health and wellbeing boards will work with communities, health and care organizations, and wider partners to establish outcome measures that cover the whole life course of the individual and reflect both health and social care needs.  So can she say how, bearing in mind in particular the wider devolution agenda, the government will measure neighborhood health outcomes to allow for effective comparison between regions? 

17:16 - 18:14

Gillian Merron

Well, the noble lady set out exactly what the plan is, and I'm grateful to her for doing this. But I would emphasize that the whole point about the independent national evaluation is that it will evaluate that whole breadth of neighborhood health. It has started in April, it will run for three years. But what I would want to emphasize, it is about continued engagement, it is about developing different ways that neighborhood health can be successful, and it will also model what long-term outcomes and improvements can be depending on how you do it. Now, all of that will mean working with the local ICBs to see about their progress, but they are well aware of the expectations upon them and they will set their own ways forward.

18:14 - 18:38

Caroline Pidgeon

If neighborhood health services are to succeed, more care will be delivered through general practice and community settings. Yet NHS funding allocated to general practice has fallen over the last decade. So will the government consider introducing a primary care investment standard to ensure primary care can grow in line with this ambition?

18:38 - 19:21

Gillian Merron

We are not intending to bring forward the investment standard that the noble lady seeks. I'm aware there is a discussion going on, probably as we speak, or newly as we speak, through the Health Bill, but I would say, and the Health Bill is about to be published in your Lordships' House, that is about increasing accountability and responsiveness to local needs and improving outcomes. And I would say to the noble lady that my fear, and our fear, is that by bringing in yet another approach through an investment standard does risk undermining that.

19:21 - 19:28

Speaker 11

Successive governments since 1948 have shifted care into the community without simultaneous shift of people, estates, or money.

19:28 - 19:49

Speaker 10

We've just heard that general practice now receives its lowest share of the NHS budget for decades. Will the minister agree to redress this so that GPs can deliver continuity of care, which we know improves access, reduces demand, improves outcomes and fundamentally delivers better value for money?

19:49 - 20:38

Gillian Merron

I would say to my, to the noble lady, that actually that's what I feel that the whole neighborhood approach to the NHS is. It is about, as the noble lady is aware, about joining up around the person. It is about bringing together teams, including GPs. I think it is important to acknowledge outcomes, that we have delivered nearly 14 million additional appointments in the year to June 2026, that's through GPs, and patient satisfaction is going up with GP access. I think we also need to look at what the situation is as well as the concerns.

20:38 - 21:06

Speaker 20

My lords, would my noble friend agree that one of the most important contributions of neighborhood health service is in the preventive work that they do, things like exercise, smoking cessation, addiction counseling and so on. Would she agree that it's very important to measure those aspects which actually reduce further the demand for hospital and primary care services?

21:06 - 21:55

Gillian Merron

Certainly do agree with my noble friend who sets out what is at the core of this key one of the three shifts. And I would say that there are many examples, and for example, if we look in Kensington, Chelsea and North Paddington, their service has already supported people to access the right care in the right way. They've seen over a third reduction in GP appointments, over two thirds reduction in A&E attendances and over half a reduction in sick notes issued. And to the point, the very particular point, residents have reported a 40% increase in self-reported wellbeing. That's what can happen when we join up around the person.

21:55 - 22:28

Timothy Kirkhope

My lords, following on from the initiatives taken by the previous government to develop much greater online activity and contact between patients and their GPs, I welcome the government's continuation with that. But I do ask the minister, how do we deal with people who are particularly vulnerable, particularly the elderly, those who do not have direct access to online activity? How can they be looked after or helped to be in touch with the new facilities that are going to be available?

22:28 - 23:09

Gillian Merron

Well, because this will be locally led, in particular the priority groups will be those who are more excluded, and that may well include those who are digitally excluded. But it is an important point the noble lord makes, because it's not just about local care in a physical sense, and indeed we have already committed to over 120 in the immediate neighborhood care centers, but it's also about digital access, because that's how so many people now do access it. However, in every single case, if someone cannot, there is an alternative for them.

23:09 - 23:30

Speaker 18

My lords, I draw noble lord's attention to my register of interest as chairman of King's Health Partners. The noble lady the minister will of course recognize that increasingly pathways of care for the management of chronic diseases will extend across institutional boundaries, both in primary and secondary care, and will be delivered by multidisciplinary teams of different healthcare professionals.

23:30 - 23:49

Speaker 12

Is the noble lady the minister content that the present regime for regulation both institutional and professional will facilitate that cross-institutional delivery of care and care delivered by multidisciplinary teams?

23:49 - 24:21

Gillian Merron

Well as we develop neighborhood provision and bring care closer to home and join up as as the noble lord referred it's absolutely key that the regulatory framework supports that as indeed all the other work and we are ensuring that the regulators are able to do this. Dr. Penny Dash recently did a review and we are looking at what more needs to be done.

24:21 - 24:52

Speaker 15

I'm grateful to my noble friend Baroness Maclean for the question but I want to go back to points made by noble Baroness Pigeon and noble Baroness Gerada because successive governments have spoken about the shift from hospital to community but one reason it's not always happened is because there has not always been a commensurate or corresponding shift in the funding. So can I ask noble lady the minister once again what consideration is the government giving to rebalancing and I stress existing funding to deliver that shift from hospital to community?

24:52 - 25:51

Gillian Merron

Well first of all we are investing where it's needed particularly on new estates and on improvement support. We are also asking ICBs excuse me through their approach to refocus their existing resources. This isn't a tinkering this is a fundamental shift one of the three main shifts to deliver neighborhood health which people do very much welcome. But I would also add we're creating financial incentives so that we are creating and the national evaluation will assist us more with this funding flows and payment mechanisms and that means that savings from improved quality of care with the investment in new service will then go into investment in new services. I would say to the noble lord that hasn't always been the case in the past.

25:51 - 26:18

Meral Ece

My lords as we know and it's very well researched that people with learning disabilities face enormous barriers to and access to primary healthcare and have a lower life expectancy as a result. Can she assure me that the these neighborhood health services will be will ensure that screening and support for people with learning disabilities will be embedded in this service?

26:18 - 26:53

Gillian Merron

I certainly can do and to support that the prevalence review particularly focusing on mental health services for those in in the group that the noble lady describes will be soon coming forward with its report and that will help us greatly. But certainly there are priority cohorts and they are are listed by definition but in addition localities can add cohorts but I would very much expect the group to which you refer would absolutely be a priority yes.

26:53 - 26:57

Speaker 5

Second oral question Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe.

26:57 - 27:01

Clive Brooke

I beg leave to ask the question standing my name on the order paper.

27:01 - 27:27

Jane Sharon Taylor

My lords the ten-year infrastructure strategy sets out sets out our approach approach to private finance and infrastructure through a range of approaches. Public-private partnerships are one model and the strategy set out the circumstances in which these are considered. The 2025 budget considered public-private partnerships would be available for neighborhood health centers and projects decarbonizing the public sector estate.

27:27 - 27:39

Speaker 13

The government will carefully consider the most appropriate model for each project to ensure value for money. All of this is to be overseen by the National Infrastructure Transformation Authority, or NISTA.

27:39 - 28:19

Clive Brooke

My Lords, I'm grateful to my noble friend the Minister for that reply. I'm pleased to hear today that the Chancellor has mentioned that there is a possibility of involving mayors in these investment programs. Could I ask him to ensure that we do some further work, keep the momentum moving, that we look at the possibility that on the private side we start offering shares to the public to participate in PPPs? And in furtherance of that, secondly, could we involve the opposition in getting into this too, so that we have joint partnership in getting greater investment?

28:19 - 29:09

Jane Sharon Taylor

Yeah, we're committed to getting Britain investing again and support our wider economy. In April, we launched targeted support, a new regulatory regime to improve access to financial guidance, move the long-term asset fund into the stocks and shares ISA, and welcome the industry-led Investment for the Future campaign and review into risk warnings to promote the benefits of investing to the public. And as part of the Investment for the Future campaign, the awareness campaign has pointed out that more and more people are willing to invest their money rather than keeping it in cash ISAs. And just to confirm to my noble friend, the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced this morning that regional mayors will be involved as strategic partners in the delivery of the National Wealth Fund.

29:09 - 29:32

John Redwood

Will the government speed up the identification of suitable projects, and will it also speed up the granting of the necessary permissions, because there's plenty of private capital that could help the government? And will the government make sure that enough risk is transferred to protect the taxpayer's interest?

29:32 - 30:04

Jane Sharon Taylor

I think the noble Lord makes some very good points there. And I think if he's heard the Chancellor's speech today, that is one of the things he wants to do. He wants to break down all the regulation, look at ways of investing more money into infrastructure, etc., going forward. And he also wants to make sure that investment is there from the private sector. The National Wealth Fund has got 27.8 billion pound in it, but hopefully over five years we want to ensure that releases 100 billion pound of investment going forward.

30:04 - 30:36

Susan Kramer

My Lords, so many PFIs and PPPs were inappropriate, poorly negotiated, and cost the taxpayer a fortune, and frankly were motivated primarily to keep debt off the public books. Surely it's time to draw a line under those frameworks and instead to update those approaches with a much better record: joint ventures, concessions, and targeted capital collaborations, as well as tackling the overall weakness in government procurement.

30:36 - 31:21

Jane Sharon Taylor

I think maybe the noble Baroness has got the wrong end of the stick. We're not going to go back to the PFI contract system that we had in the past. I think that came to an end probably in about 2018. But we are going to learn the lessons from what happened with PFI. There was a lot of lessons that we've got to learn about flexibilities on contracts, investment, transparency, for example.

But I think it's also fair to say that where the PFI worked, it gave us more schools, it gave us more hospitals, it gave us more doctors' surgeries, it helped us with Sure Start. So it had some good points to it, and we shouldn't just throw it all out because there were some issues. We're going to learn from that, and we're going to reinvest in a way that's going to protect the public purse.

31:21 - 31:43

Patience Wheatcroft

My Lords, the Minister said there are still some issues with PFI contracts, particularly with hospitals. Could he confirm the scale of the debt that hospitals are still burdened with because of PFI, and what the government's going to do to renegotiate those contracts and if possible renege on them?

31:43 - 32:34

Jane Sharon Taylor

There is no possibility that we're going to go back to PFI as I've said. The lessons, we have learned the lessons from that. The figure on the total expenditure still that is out there I'm not quite sure of. I think there was something like 700 and odd projects of which 600 are still in progress. But we are going to make sure that in the future when we invest using public and private money such as neighborhood health centers we're going to make sure that the best public money is going to go to the best rewards.

So we've got for example there's going to be 250 neighborhood health centers, 120 are due to be completed by 2030 and all 250 are completed by 2035 and I think that's good news that should be celebrated.

32:34 - 33:13

Philip Hunt

My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, would my noble friend accept that where some PFI projects went wrong it was usually because at the local level the people negotiating the contract on behalf of the public sector didn't have the expertise to do this effectively? But my Lords, as a result of public private partnership between 97 and 2010 in the NHS we built 100 new hospitals. So I'd like to ask my noble friend can we expect to see as a result of what the Chancellor has said today a big expansion in capital expenditure with public and private partnerships?

33:13 - 33:50

Jane Sharon Taylor

We will obviously deploy public private partnerships where it's in the best interest of the Exchequer to do so and in the best interest of the public to do so because we need to obviously protect taxpayers' money. But my noble friend is absolutely right that we did benefit under PFI with the you know 100 new hospitals, the new schools, the health centers, that's got to be celebrated. Yes you learn the lessons but hopefully we'll go on to see more public private partnerships grow into the future but only if it's in the interests of the Exchequer to do so.

33:50 - 34:34

Speaker 24

The Minister mentioned private finance initiative because as he will well know in many jurisdictions are adopting new risk allocation systems built on PFI. These include I've got a long list here but it's France, Germany, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Canada, Australia, South Africa and Japan. So what are we doing about this as we were the inventors of it and can we make some more developments in this direction which could even help calm the bond markets and lower our appalling debt interest?

34:34 - 35:13

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'd like to thank the noble Lord for that question. Basically what I would say is that I think the government's learning from all these other jurisdictions as we go forward. We've got the 10-year infrastructure strategy set out the government's long-term plans for the economy and we're going to be investing something like 725 billion pound over that 10-year period so something like 72 billion pound a year. And obviously if we're going to do that some of that will end up being in public private partnerships but as I've said repeatedly we're only going to do that just like we would with any other scheme do what's in the best interest of the taxpayer and the Exchequer.

35:13 - 35:25

Speaker 23

My Lords, the Minister mentioned ISAs. Could he tell us why the government gives tax relief via ISAs to people who invest in overseas equities?

35:25 - 36:07

Jane Sharon Taylor

What I will say about ISAs and what we're planning to do with ISAs from next April is to reduce the allowance to 12,000 for investment to cash ISAs to encourage people to invest in stocks and shares ISAs.

We have got figures that are going to be published later this month about how much more money is being invested in stocks and shares ISAs. I think it's for the year 24-25. We haven't got the figures for the current year, but we'll see from that what kind of investment levels are being transferred over to stocks and shares ISAs and how that money is going to be spent.

36:07 - 36:30

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, will public-private partnerships form part of the Burnham government's new architecture for growth beyond the health sector, which the minister described, and decarbonization? It's good to see Lord Brooke returning to the battle on this matter.

36:30 - 37:09

Jane Sharon Taylor

It's something, I mean, we will always look at public-private partnerships beyond health centers and beyond decarbonizing the public sector going forward. But as I've continuously said, we will do that if it's in the best interest of the taxpayer and the exchequer to do that. We are looking at how best to use public-private partnerships through the National Wealth Fund. We're bringing into the system regional mayors as well. So I think that will give a broaden out what we can do with public-private partnerships beyond the two main initiatives that have been announced.

37:09 - 37:13

Speaker 27

Third oral question, the Earl of Kinnoull.

37:13 - 37:19

Charles Hay

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

37:19 - 37:58

Jacqui Smith

My Lords, decisions on the strategic priorities grant for academic year 26-27 reflect the challenging fiscal position and not the value we place on creative and performing arts courses. We recognize the important contribution that the disciplines make to our cultural life and economy. We have had to prioritize funding towards the highest cost subjects and areas facing the most acute skills shortages, while protecting 57.1 million pounds of funding for world-leading specialist providers, including 12 arts institutions.

37:58 - 38:41

Charles Hay

My Lords, far from being challenging, as the previous Secretary of State put it, this is a disastrous decision that will further imperil higher education arts courses already under threat from closure. It is at odds with the industrial strategy's commitment to the creative industries and the concerns of Skills England, including those skills combining creativity and new technology. Does the minister agree that increases in tuition fees are not relevant since that will affect all courses equally? Will the government reconsider this decision and instead formulate a strategy which will improve access to creative subjects in higher education?

38:41 - 39:25

Jacqui Smith

Well, I understand the disappointment in this decision, but just to be clear about the scale of what we're talking about, we're talking about the removal of 130 pounds per student for those taking some creative and arts subjects. That is roughly 1% of the contribution towards those subjects. And I don't think it's the case that a 6 billion pound increase in the income to higher education that comes from the decisions that this government has made about tuition fees are not significant. They are by far the biggest part of the funding for all higher education courses, including those in creative and performing arts.

39:25 - 39:57

Speaker 31

My Lords, before I ask my question, I must apologize to the House for my inadvertent failure to declare my interest as chair of the independent inquiry into the Police Federation of England and Wales when I spoke last week in the second reading of the Public Office Accountability Bill. This interest is recorded in the register. My question to the Minister is, does she agree with me that access to higher education and careers in the creative and performing arts should be open to all, regardless of wealth or social background?

39:57 - 40:38

Jacqui Smith

Absolutely I do, which is why in the strategic priorities grant we have focused on maintaining the, at least maintaining the funding that goes towards access and participation, including for students going into creative and performing arts subjects. And it's why as a government, as part of the support for the creative areas, there is also additional investment for, for example, widespread, wider spread awareness of careers in the sector, in fact a nine million pound UK-wide creative careers service.

40:38 - 41:10

Speaker 34

My Lords, given that the creative industries are one of the country's most productive money earners, is it not perverse to cut grants to young people hoping to bring their skills and talents to the world of work? I was recently up at the Edinburgh Fringe, where brilliant young musicians, actors, dancers often have to fund themselves because so tight are the purse strings for funds. Yet they give such pleasure, my Lords. How does the government propose to encourage more young people into these creative industries with these cuts?

41:10 - 41:56

Jacqui Smith

Well, to be clear, this is not a cut of a grant to students. This is a cut of 130 pounds per student to the institutions that run these courses, partly in order to safeguard the funding that goes, for example, to 20 million pounds that goes to Uni Connect to open up opportunities to get into higher education for more young people. And it goes alongside the expansion of other ways to develop skills in this area, like higher technical qualifications, creative skills boot camps, and the lifelong learning entitlement, all of which provide support and opportunities for young people and people throughout their lives to get into the creative sector.

41:56 - 42:25

Speaker 33

My Lords, universities need more teachers generally, but so do schools. The government pledged to recruit 6,500 new teachers, but the annual school workforce census shows there are now 1,900 less teachers across all schools. Does the Minister agree with Daniel Kebede, the general secretary of the National Education Union, who called it a mockery of the pledge?

42:25 - 42:51

Jacqui Smith

No, because we've been clear in our pledge to recruit six and a half thousand more teachers, but we would focus them on the areas in secondary and special schools where we aren't seeing the fall in the numbers of pupils and where we know that there is a particular need. And there we have, and I think the latest number is over two and a half thousand more teachers. We are delivering on our commitment to teachers and to pupils.

42:51 - 43:33

Speaker 35

My Lords, 76 million of capital funding from this grant has been let out to competitive bidding. That OfS prospectus, subject to separate guidelines and a guidance letter, identifies bids that relate to the creative industries nationally and locally as meeting the criteria for growth and priority skills needs. I am confused, as I'm sure the universities and the industries are.

Please can my noble friend clarify the situation and does she agree that with a new Secretary of State in DfE, it is an excellent time to reflect on the evidence base ready for next year's guidance.

43:33 - 43:46

Jacqui Smith

Um, I'm sorry that I'm not completely clear about the point that my noble friend is making with respect to capital, to SPG capital, which is I think what she was referring to, but I will write to her about that.

43:46 - 44:36

Speaker 42

My Lords, I should declare an interest at the University of Oxford. There are other ways to encourage capital and money to come into the creative education of our universities. If I can draw the Minister's attention to the recent donation of Stephen Schwarzman to the University of Oxford, 200 million pounds for a new centre for the humanities and within that, all sorts of performing arts spaces using the latest technology. If we can encourage business and commerce to invest here and make more money here, I know lots of other organisations like, for example, Bank of America and Steve Schwarzman who would put more money into the creative industries higher education in this country. Does the noble, does the noble Lord the Minister support philanthropy coming into this area to help.

44:36 - 45:32

Jacqui Smith

Yes, of course I do and philanthropy has always been an important way in which facilities in our universities have been supported. But to help that to happen, of course we've also, as other noble Lords have commented, made the creative industries part of our industrial strategy. We're supporting as a government extra investment, an extra 100 million pounds for the next wave of creative R and D clusters. We're supporting the arts through additional money to Arts England and we are making sure that there is a pipeline of young people coming into the sector as well. But given the enthusiasm that there always is in this House for the creative industries and for the arts, I know that is reflected out in the country and I hope that where people have got the money to contribute to higher education and other areas of education they will consider doing that.

45:32 - 46:05

Speaker 43

My Lords, the reason I was able to retrain as a design technology teacher is that I've got a graphic design degree. There is evidence that already that universities are reducing their creative courses. How are we going to get the new generation of people with the subject knowledge to teach these badly needed courses that are part of the new national curriculum if nobody has the subject knowledge.

46:05 - 46:45

Jacqui Smith

Well, there are, I'm not sure that the, I mean I'm very glad as I've said previously that the noble Lord has, did retrain as a teacher. I suspect, I'm not quite sure when that happened, but I suspect the availability of a bursary to be able to do it was probably as important as the first degree that the noble Lord did. And of course it's by investing in our teachers through pay awards, through bursaries for shortage subjects and through the success that we are having in retaining more of them in the classroom that we're seeing more teachers in all areas of the curriculum including in creative areas.

46:45 - 47:09

Speaker 40

My Lords, does my noble friend agree with me that she's looking forward, as I am, to the freeing up of the curriculum so that there can be much more drama and other creative subjects in the secondary phase to ensure that we actually have enough students to make sure that we are continuing with the very good place in which the creative industries are at the moment.

47:09 - 47:37

Jacqui Smith

Yes, that was an absolute theme of the government's curriculum and assessment, or the commissioning of the curriculum and assessment review. And we are already making changes to the curriculum, as my noble friend says, to ensure that the breadth, the enrichment, the value of creative subjects is reflected both across the curriculum and also of course in the wider enrichment opportunities that we want all schools to offer to their pupils.

47:37 - 47:39

Speaker 36

Oral question, Baroness Prentis of Lavenham.

47:39 - 47:54

Mary Victoria Boswell

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper, and I should declare an interest as an executor who is currently trying to sell our family farm.

47:54 - 48:36

Sue Hayman

My Lords, the government keeps all taxes under review with decisions for the Chancellor at fiscal events. We recognize the vital contribution of rural communities and businesses to the UK economy and the need for policies that actually work for rural areas. Support available includes rural rate relief, small business rates relief, a high VAT registration threshold, and the small profits corporation tax rate. We are also supporting farmers through reduced red diesel duty rates until the end of this year, and measures to promote sustainable farming and food production.

48:36 - 49:19

Mary Victoria Boswell

My Lords, the family farm tax is both hated and feared. It taxes a business asset as if it is personal wealth. I know the noble lady was not consulted, and nor was her department, before the tax was put in place. I wonder if she would reassure the House, who I know appreciates all that she does for us, that she will personally make representations to this Chancellor before this budget, as those of us who care about the countryside and the NFU are currently doing, to make sure that this hated tax can be removed.

49:19 - 50:08

Sue Hayman

Well, I'm sure the noble lady is aware that I absolutely support the importance of farming to the rural economy, and actually the importance of the work that farmers do through food security to the wider economy of the country. I'm sure she's also aware that we have discussed this matter on a number of occasions, and the Treasury has made it quite clear that it's not intending to revisit the issue of inheritance tax. I am aware the Prime Minister was asked about this during the by-election in Macclesfield. However, having said that, the government does, as I said in the original answer, always keep taxes under review, and I will ensure that the new Chancellor is aware of the strength of feeling on this matter.

50:08 - 50:47

Dafydd Wigley

My Lords, does the noble lady accept that rural businesses are hit disproportionately by the increases in petrol and diesel which we've seen over recent months, adding to their costs of inputs, adding to their costs of getting goods to the market, and adding to the costs of those working in rural areas travelling to work? So is there any way in which the amount of taxation raised on petrol and diesel can somehow be frozen and not be added every time there's an increase in international prices that this hits rural areas?

50:47 - 51:26

Sue Hayman

Well, clearly as somebody who lives in a rural area where I have to travel long distances to get anywhere, I completely appreciate the point that the noble lord is making. Of course we do have rural fuel duty relief, and we are looking at the costs of that. One of the ways, one of the things we need to look at, I think, is how do we best support rural communities and rural businesses as a whole, rather than perhaps just picking at little issues, because actually it's the cost of the whole that makes the difference, and there are other ways in which rural businesses and rural communities are being supported financially.

51:28 - 52:12

Susan Kramer

Even before the summer drought, failures in agricultural businesses had risen by 450% under the pressures of the energy costs we've just heard described, higher taxes and subsidy changes playing a major part as well. Does the government recognize that many people will be very concerned that today's announcements by the Chancellor had so little focus on actual action in rural UK, and will the government now put itself behind the proposed Good Food Bill that is being demanded by the industry to support domestic producers and indeed also provide us with greater food security?

52:12 - 52:57

Sue Hayman

Well, we've been working an enormous amount in DEFRA with farmers and other relevant stakeholders around food security. And that includes biosecurity, for example. It looks at how farmers can be supported through veterinary services, as well as looking at how we manage drought and climate change going forward. And it's not just about drought, it's also about flooding. We know that we've got potential heavy rainfalls coming this winter.

So if we are going to continue to support good food production, sustainable food production in this country, it's really important that we work cross-departmentally, including with the Treasury, in order to make sure we have the best support for farmers that we possibly can.

52:57 - 53:16

Speaker 39

Has the Minister noticed that over the last few weeks, the opposition have been calling for more public spending, at the same time of calling for lower taxes? Have they all joined the Liz Truss school of economics? Is that what they're doing?

53:16 - 53:34

Sue Hayman

Well, I think my friend makes a good point about the fact that you can't have something for nothing. You know, if we are going to have the kind of services, public services particularly that people want in this country, we have to look very, very carefully about how we intend to pay for them.

53:34 - 54:13

Speaker 46

I regret having to ask this question following the noble Lord's response, but one of the issues that I think needs to be taken extremely seriously with the inheritance tax issue, it is stifling investment. And I thought the party opposite in the government was a supporter of growth. And this is the perverse consequence of this imposition. And I do ask the noble Baroness to act on behalf of DEFRA with the Treasury and indeed the government, that this is acting as a contrary to growth tax.

54:13 - 54:28

Sue Hayman

Well, I hear very clearly what the noble Lord has said. As I said to the noble lady, Baroness Prentice earlier, I will make sure that the new Chancellor understands the strength of feeling about the inheritance tax from this House.

54:28 - 54:53

Speaker 47

My Lords, I'm very pleased to hear the noble lady the Minister talk about the whole burden on rural dwellers and farmers. In that regard then, can she say how her department is looking to minimize the burden on farmers, not just the tax burden, but the regulatory burden, and in particular for those farmers in Northern Ireland, the differential regulations that occur there?

54:53 - 55:40

Sue Hayman

Yes, I'm very aware of the kind of regulations that the noble lady is talking about, which is also why when I do visit Northern Ireland, I always make sure to meet with the Ulster Farmers' Union, for example, because there are slightly different perspectives and it's important that we understand those differentials. I think the most important thing for me, I think, is to listen to farmers and not make assumptions about what works and what doesn't. Tomorrow, for example, I'm going to be holding a meeting specifically with on bluetongue with farmers, because I want to know what is actually causing their difficulties most of all, what actually is going to make the difference, and what do we need to do so that we don't end up with so many problems next year as well. I'm very keen to work in a very kind of proactive way to provide the best support we can.

55:40 - 56:18

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, every day I become more convinced that it is business, not government, that creates growth. Now farming and family businesses in rural areas are under tremendous pressure from a series of high taxes including IHT. Will the Minister or her colleague the Chancellor meet US economist Arthur Laffer during his visit this week to discuss how the perverse effect of such high taxation might be minimized and government revenues even increased by cutting taxes?

56:18 - 56:41

Sue Hayman

I think the the gentleman the noble lord suggests I'm a bit disappointed if he met me. I'm not sure that I would fully comprehend all the very important points that I'm sure he'd be making. But I imagine that that it would be an opportune moment for him to meet someone from the Treasury.

56:41 - 57:10

Speaker 51

My Lords, this concerns the selling of a farm so that raises issues as well of probate. So when the noble lady the Minister is discussing these fiscal matters with the new Chancellor, will she also raise with him the blatant unfairness of the 7.75% charge by the government on late payment during probate as opposed to the 2.75% repayment ceiling when the government owes the taxpayer money?

57:10 - 57:24

Sue Hayman

Well, if you're looking at issues through probate, that's not just to do with the with family farms. That's a much, much broader issue. And I'm sure that the Treasury officials will be listening very carefully to this debate and will take that into account.

57:24 - 57:57

Speaker 56

My Lords, my Lords, the there is some speculation in the press that farmland might be included in the calculation of the value of a home when it came to the mansion tax. And I wonder if the noble lady the Minister could confirm whether that was true or not. Because clearly if it is, an awful lot of modest farm homes would then be included in the mansion tax and that tax at the highest rate is quite a lot for for a for a farm.

57:57 - 58:06

Sue Hayman

I'm not aware personally of any such speculation. I'm afraid so I'm afraid I'm not able to provide any further information to the noble lord.

58:06 - 58:12

Speaker 2

Private notice question on the security of the Falkland Islands, Lord Callanan.

58:12 - 58:38

Martin Callanan

My Lords, I beg leave to ask a question of which I have given private notice. The question is as follows: to ask His Majesty's government what recent discussions they have had, if any, with one, the government of Argentina and two, the government of the United States pertaining to the future of the Falkland Islands and what steps they are taking to ensure the security of those islands.

58:38 - 59:20

Rosalind Scott

My Lords, the UK remains steadfast in its support for the Falkland Islanders' right of self-determination. This is not the first time Argentina has made economic threats against the Falklands. These threats have not prevented the community's remarkable economic development and we have made clear to Argentina that the measures announced by President Milei will not change the UK's unwavering commitment to the islands. The US is our closest ally. They can have no doubt about our unwavering support for the islanders.

59:20 - 01:00:21

Martin Callanan

Can I thank the noble lady for her reply and indeed welcome her to the dispatch box to her new job. I look forward to many happy exchanges with her in the future. The Falkland Islands are British, we fought to defend them in 1982 and there should be no doubt of our national resolve. Argentina's increasingly aggressive rhetoric in respect of the Falkland Islands has no doubt been emboldened by news that the United States are reviewing their position on British sovereignty and of course by this government's restated policy of handing over another UK overseas territory, the Chagos Islands, to Mauritius. They have been emboldened by our weakness.

Can the noble lady the minister reassure us that we are preparing for all eventualities including military scenarios and can she confirm that they could provide a real deterrent to Argentina by ditching the predecessor's failed policy of handing over the Chagos Islands.

01:00:21 - 01:01:24

Rosalind Scott

Well I thank the noble lord for his kind welcome and I remember our CPA trip to Singapore and Malaysia. My lords let me be clear. Let me be clear. Very fond memories. The sovereignty of the Falkland Islands is non-negotiable as far as the UK government is concerned.

It always has been and it always will be. The whole house will I'm sure agree with me that we need to reiterate that fundamental principle. And I should say that I feel that political unity here is really, really important. He mentions defensive forces, we do have a variety of military capabilities, they're for defensive purposes, but I think it is very important that we do not speculate and get into hypothetical situations.

01:01:24 - 01:03:01

Jeremy Purvis

I also welcome the minister to her brief and I guess I should declare I was on that visit too, but I saw nothing untoward between the minister and Lord Callanan. I also this is my first opportunity since she is here to thank Baroness Chapman for her service as minister as well. My lords I've had the privilege of visiting the Falkland Islands and I will relate to the house what I've said to the Falkland Islanders as far as these benches are concerned, sovereignty has been, is and always will be in the hands of the Falkland Islanders themselves. And sovereignty should be under no question whatsoever. But there will also be obvious concern amongst the islanders that as a result of what President Trump has been saying that there could be questions marks over the health arrangements with our relationship with Chile and Uruguay.

There could be concerns over the integrity of the territorial waters which have seen almost ingressions by foreign flagged vessels from China. And there could be question marks over the lifeline satellite communication services. So can the minister reassure not this house but also the islanders themselves that when we send very strong signals to our closest ally in the White House, all of those services are part of sovereignty too.

01:03:01 - 01:03:40

Rosalind Scott

First of all, let me thank the noble lord for his kind words and his fond memories of the CPA visit and also echo absolutely what he said about my noble friend Baroness Chapman. With regard to the US, can I assure him that we of course engage regularly with the US on a range of foreign policy issues. I'm sure he will understand that I can't give a running commentary about all of our engagement with the US, but it is our closest ally.

01:03:40 - 01:03:52

Speaker 50

Argentina applied to join a few weeks ago. Now is this a point of leverage that can be used against a country that is threatening our sovereignty?

01:03:52 - 01:04:08

Rosalind Scott

The noble Lord raises an important point, but just to be clear on accession to the CPTPP, that is a matter for the member states themselves, and we don't comment on individual applications for accession.

01:04:08 - 01:04:46

Speaker 55

My Lords, can I commend my noble friend the Minister for the forthright statement in support of the Falklands and the Falkland Islanders? But does she share my concern at the interview given last week on Radio 4 Today by Simon McDonald, previous head of the Foreign Office, which indicated quite outrageously that that effectively that Britain was or should be considering handing them over and giving arguments regarding how much money was being spent and whether the British public would wear that? This was extremely unhelpful. Can she dissociate the department from that?

01:04:46 - 01:05:18

Rosalind Scott

Well, I thank the noble Lord for that question, and let me be clear, we do not agree with that position. As I've said, the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands is non-negotiable as far as the UK government is concerned, and I do welcome today the political unity that has been shown because I think it's important that we send that message from this House and also from the other House so that it is very clear that we are united from all political parties on this issue.

01:05:18 - 01:06:04

Tariq Ahmad

As a former Overseas Territories Minister, may I also welcome the noble lady to the dispatch box and also her strong statement and recognize the services of the noble lady Baroness Chapman? What representations have been made directly to Argentina? As someone who served in the Foreign Office for a long time, yes, diplomacy matters, but that diplomacy comes with the hard metal glove of our military strength as well, and I commend the fact that the Minister of Defence is sitting to her right. Would she reiterate once again that the military action as my noble friend said is on the table if required, that message may be sent privately to the Argentinians, and what bilateral representations have been made directly?

01:06:04 - 01:07:04

Rosalind Scott

Well, I thank the noble Lord for that question and I should say I'm always very reassured when the noble Lord is sitting next to me from Defence. Look, I'm very confident that Argentina understands the message that we are sending from the UK government and from this House. The Foreign Secretary posted on X, let me quote: "The UK's position on the Falkland Islands is unwavering. The islands are British and will remain so because that is the overwhelming position of the islanders. Their right of self-determination is paramount, grounded in international law, and we will resolutely uphold it."

I touched previously on the defensive forces that we do have in the area, but again I hope he will understand that I don't want to enter into hypothetical discussions.

01:07:04 - 01:07:32

Kate Hoey

My Lords, I welcome the noble lady to her position and I welcome the unanimity of the House on this issue. Argentina obviously has a lot of international support for their claim, and it worries me that if a UN advisory council committee was to say that actually the Falklands were Argentinian, would we then do exactly as we've done with the Chagos Islands and say that that has to be complied with?

01:07:32 - 01:08:08

Rosalind Scott

Our position is clear, as I've said, and when it comes to raising this issue in international forum, I should also say that my noble friend Lord Collins attended the Organization of American States on the 24th of June to provide a right of reply on the Falkland Islands on behalf of His Majesty's Government, asserting UK sovereignty of the islands and the rights of islands to choose their own future. So we do use those opportunities at international level to make our position absolutely clear.

01:08:08 - 01:08:38

Alfred Dubs

May I welcome my noble friend to her post? Isn't it a good thing that we're demonstrating clarity in terms of our determination to defend the Falkland Islanders and their right to self-determination? And that stands in marked contrast to the Thatcher government, who displayed weakness, who took ships away from the Falklands and almost said to the Argentinians, "There you are, it's yours if you want it." We are standing in contrast to that. I congratulate the government on it.

01:08:38 - 01:09:04

Rosalind Scott

Well, I thank the noble lord for his welcome and also for his support for our position. And I want to reiterate again how important it is that there's a clear message from this House itself. And so again, I do welcome the political consensus that we've seen this afternoon and thank him for his kind words.

01:09:04 - 01:10:18

Speaker 51

May I also join in the congratulations to the noble lady on her recent appointment to the front bench? I think it's extremely important that whatever we say in this country, we say together. I think the remarks of the noble lord, Lord Dubs, were unfortunate and basically an attempt to rewrite history. That is not what happened last time. Would the noble lady consider calling in the Argentinian ambassador?

And I'm all for not ratcheting this up, because this is purely electoral posturing by the president of Argentina. But would she take this opportunity of calling in the Argentinian ambassador to make these points again, that the future of the Falkland Islands depends on the people of the Falkland Islands? And so as they remain British and wish to remain British, they will enjoy the full protection of this country and everything that may mean. And at the same time, would she remind those who suggest this is a transplanted population that there have been many generations of people living on those islands, far longer perhaps than the ancestors of the president of Argentina, who arrived from Calabria in Argentina in 1926?

01:10:18 - 01:10:50

Rosalind Scott

Well, I again thank the noble lord for his welcome. And just let me say again, I think the message that will be heard today from this House reiterates our position. And our position is clear: the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands is non-negotiable as far as the UK government is concerned. That's a clear message. I have every confidence that message will have been heard.

01:10:50 - 01:11:13

John Redwood

I warmly welcome the minister to her well-deserved new post. Could she update the House on where we've got to with the very important investment in the oil field 140 miles north of the Falklands? Because isn't that also going to be transformational for the people of the Falklands who rightly wish to remain British?

01:11:13 - 01:11:40

Rosalind Scott

Well, I thank the noble lord for his kind comments. And again to say, with regard to the oil fields and the investment there, that is something which is decided by the Falkland Islands people.

It is their investment and we are absolutely supportive of the decision they have made with that regard.

01:11:40 - 01:12:49

Speaker 68

If there are no further questions on the private notice question, I would suggest that if any noble lords wish to leave the chamber they do so now before I call next business. My lords, first reading of the private members bill, Baroness Benjamin.

01:12:49 - 01:13:15

Floella Benjamin

Lords, I beg to introduce a bill to require social media companies operating in the United Kingdom to obtain a license from Ofcom, to empower Ofcom to set and enforce binding conditions on licensed operators and for connected purposes. I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.

01:13:15 - 01:13:31

David Pitt

The question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Economic affairs and seven other appointment motions, the senior deputy speaker.

01:13:31 - 01:13:37

John Gardiner

My lords, I beg to move the eight motions standing in my name on the order paper en bloc.

01:13:37 - 01:14:01

Speaker 64

The question is that the eight motions in the name of the senior deputy speaker be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. My lords, we now come to instruments previously debated in grand committee.

Building safety levy amendment England regulations 2026, Baroness Blake of Leeds.

01:14:01 - 01:14:04

Judith Blake

I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

01:14:04 - 01:14:18

Speaker 64

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Digital government disclosure of information regulations 2026, Baroness Lloyd of Effra.

01:14:18 - 01:14:26

Jenny Jones

My lords, I beg to move the motion on the order paper in the name of my noble friend Baroness Lloyd of Effra.

01:14:26 - 01:15:01

David Pitt

The question is that the motion in the name of Baroness Lloyd of Effra be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Building societies act 1986, assimilation to company law and changes to funding limit order 2026 and two other motions, Lord Pitt-Watson.

My lords, with leave of the house, I beg to move the motions standing in my name on the order paper en bloc. I beg to move.

01:15:01 - 01:15:20

Speaker 65

The question is that the three motions in the name of Lord Pitt-Watson be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. House be in committee on the local plans burial space bill, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley.

01:15:20 - 01:15:40

Magid Magid

My Lords, I understand that no amendments have been set down to this bill and that no noble lord has indicated a wish to move a manuscript amendment or to speak in committee. Unless therefore any noble lord objects, I beg to move that the order of commitment is discharged.

01:15:40 - 01:15:59

David Pitt

Is that the order of commitment be discharged? As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons on Thursday the 3rd of September on the future of Jackdaw and Rosebank oil and gas fields.

01:15:59 - 01:17:10

Colin Moynihan

My Lords, I declare my interests as chairman of Buckthorn, Amy and Acteon, and I warmly welcome the noble baroness minister back to the dispatch box. And I pay tribute to the noble lord Lord Whitehead, who was a highly knowledgeable and impressive minister. My Lords, given the government's outright opposition to the new drilling in the North Sea, does she nevertheless agree that there is no reason not to approve Jackdaw and Rosebank, which have already had drilling activity, with Jackdaw now ready for production? And in contrast to the minister's response to the statement just now, given that the government itself has the final sign-off on Falkland Islands production licenses, dating back to the early 1990s when both Tim Eggar and I were ministerially involved, what is the government's position on the Falkland Islands government's pro-oil and gas position on the Sea Lion oil field, which is at the center of a diplomatic row with Argentina? Is it consistent with the department's position in the North Sea, in other words, outright opposition to new drilling and new offshore oil and gas infrastructure?

And if not, what is the difference?

01:17:10 - 01:18:29

Speaker 70

Can I thank the noble lord for his warm welcome? We know each other and I know that we both welcome robust discussion, which is just as well I think, because I think we'll have a few disagreements along the way. Can I also reference to Lord Whitehead for his enormous contribution to this portfolio and the work that he has done, and I have learned a lot and will continue to learn a lot from Lord Whitehead. On the substance of the issue that he raises, he will know that the Jackdaw and Rosebank fields are each subject to a live regulatory process. The public notice periods closing on the 10th and 17th of August respectively were part of that regulatory process.

The Secretary of State will consider the representations received and will make separate decisions on each project in due course. It would be inappropriate to comment further on either project because it is important to maintain the robustness of the process and not preempt or predetermine the decisions. And I note the detail of what he asked me in relation to the Falklands. I refer him back to the comments of my noble friend Baroness Winterton, and it would be inappropriate for me to comment further on that. Thank you.

01:18:29 - 01:19:12

Speaker 71

My Lords, can I also welcome the noble baroness on her appointment and I look forward to working opposite her, and I also pay tribute to the outgoing noble lord Lord Whitehead. I know that the minister is unable to comment before the decision, so instead I ask if she agrees with me that the Onward report, upon which the Conservative Party have argued that we should abandon our net zero targets and could save 320 billion, is not worth the paper it's written on as it is based on an incorrect underlying assumption that future gas prices will be low and stable and would result in an extra 524 million tons of carbon dioxide emissions by 2050.

01:19:12 - 01:20:16

Kirsty McNeill

Can I thank the noble lord for that question and again thank him for his welcome and pay tribute to his work in on this issue and in this house. Again, I have learned a great deal from listening to the speeches of my noble lord and I will continue to do so.

I think everybody's a friend am I allowed to say that from time to time. But I recognize and appreciate the point he is making about the Rosebank and Jackdaw decisions. I do recognize the interest in this but I cannot be drawn on that. On his wider point he is absolutely right about the points he's been making about the Onward report and I think the general disappointment that people feel at the breaking of the consensus that we've seen from the Conservative Party over recent months and how significant that is. He will know that climate scientists and energy industry bodies have overwhelmingly challenged the report's methodology and logic as applied on grid and infrastructure costs and how they have costed the high volatility of gas and the political economic costs of gas.

01:20:16 - 01:20:56

Philip Hunt

My Lords my Lords I wonder if my noble friend would confirm that under the Conservatives between 2010 and 2024 production in the North Sea reduced by half. It's no surprise because it's a super mature basin and that giving consent to these two oil fields which I know my noble friend cannot comment on at the moment would have an absolutely minimal effect either on achieving net zero targets or on prices. And so my Lords the reality is that what the government needs to do whatever the decision on these oil fields is stick to the policy of going as fast as possible towards clean energy.

01:20:56 - 01:21:51

Kirsty McNeill

Again can I thank my noble friend for that question and again pay tribute to the work that he has done in this field and the very significant contribution he made as a minister particularly within the nuclear field. And again and I appreciate I cannot be drawn on the points that he raises. I can assure him that the North Sea and oil and gas will play a vital role in our energy mix for years to come. He will he has noted that by the end of 2016 under the Conservatives more than 120,000 UK oil and gas jobs had gone and it is a changing basin but we do see it as part of the mix but we do understand that the North Sea not only has an oil and gas sector but can play a vital role in a clean energy economy and that will make an enormous contribution not only to the northeast of Scotland but also to the wider UK economy.

01:21:51 - 01:22:36

Shas Sheehan

My Lords I welcome the noble lady back to her position on the front bench. Would she agree with me that a major issue underlying the decisions which I know she can't talk about is the widespread concern about the cost of energy in this country? And would she further agree with me that the important thing is to make some progress on decoupling the price of gas from the price of energy and electricity generally and when is the government going to make some progress in separating off those two strands?

01:22:36 - 01:23:22

Kirsty McNeill

Can I thank the noble lady for her welcome and for that for that question and recognize the work that she does and I hope to continue to engage with Peers for the Planet as a former member I hope that I can continue that. And of course she makes a central point underlying the work that we do. The cost of energy is central to the Prime Minister's mission in tackling these issues and has said that affordability will be at the center of what he tries to tackle. She's also right to emphasize the delinking of electricity and gas and that will remain a priority of our work and I look forward to meeting with her to discuss that to continuing these debates in the House but I can rest assure her that that is a priority for our work going forward as is affordability.

01:23:22 - 01:23:41

John Redwood

Why does the government wish to increase world CO2, and why does it wish to pay taxes to foreign companies and countries rather than to British ones by insisting on importing LNG rather than getting our own gas out of a pipe which generates much less CO2?

01:23:41 - 01:24:41

Kirsty McNeill

Thank you for that question, and I cannot be tempted to answer it directly as I perhaps would wish to because of the implications of what I might say. Can I ask noble lords to really appreciate the significance of this decision, and we cannot jeopardize it by any loose form of words. And I don't obviously accept some of the assumptions behind his question. This government is committed to ensuring that all companies pay due tax, they regenerate the economy, and we will work with businesses in the North Sea and across Scotland to make sure that they are thriving. And I would plead with him to understand that the work that this Labour government is doing is contributing to a thriving sector in clean energy as well, and that that is a competitive, performing element in the economy, and that will be something that we will discuss no doubt in the future.

01:24:41 - 01:25:28

Speaker 75

My lords, can I welcome Baroness Karen, my erstwhile friend I think in the Scottish cabinet, to her place on the front bench. Whatever decision is taken on Jackdaw and Rosebank, whatever decision is taken, can she confirm that clean energy, whether developed by solar or wind or other means, will remain at the heart of British energy policy going forward, and that not only does it provide the scope for decarbonization of our economy, but also for new jobs going forward?

01:25:28 - 01:26:14

Kirsty McNeill

Can I thank my noble friend colleague for that question, and he knows that I was a member of the Scottish Parliament, a minister in the Scottish government, and in that capacity met many times with the oil and gas sector and worked very closely with them and understand the contribution that they have made and will continue to make. But I will say to noble lords, there is no avoidance of the fact that we live in challenging times in terms of climate change, that clean energy is not only necessary but is a huge opportunity in terms of economic development and will help us meet the challenge of our times through reducing carbon emissions and through electrifying our economy and creating opportunities for the people within the United Kingdom.

01:26:14 - 01:26:26

Speaker 34

My lords, I'm afraid time is up on this question, so we now move to report of the Financial Services and Markets Bill, Lord Pitt-Watson.

01:26:26 - 01:26:29

David Pitt

My lords, I beg to move that this report be now received.

01:26:29 - 01:26:51

Speaker 34

The question is that this report be now received. As many as are of that opinion say content. To the contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause one, amendment one, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

01:26:51 - 01:32:08

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My lords, I am honored to open our discussions at report stage on the Financial Services and Markets Bill, a bill which we support in general but are seeking to improve. I again congratulate the noble lord the minister on his new position and thank him for his engagement. I also thank the noble lord, Lord Stockwood, whom I'm glad to see in his place, and other noble lords for their constructive approach in six expert committee sessions. Despite the scale of the bill and the complexity of the subject, we also ran to time, to the satisfaction I hope of the noble lord, Lord Wilson of Ettrick.

As this is the first day of report, I declare my registered interest in Meta and Amazon. My Lords, this is a large group of amendments reflecting the anxiety of many of us over the excessive use of delegated powers and the uncertainty this creates in the modernisation of consumer credit law, a move we support. I will be moving amendment 1 to clause 1, but I intend to focus my remarks on the final amendments in this group, amendment 93 and amendments 100 to 103 in the name of myself and Lord Altringham, whom I also thank for his work on this bill. My Lords, I hope these amendments might provide a compromise going forward. They address one of the most serious concerns that we and noble Lords across this House have raised about the approach taken in this bill.

This is the question of how we preserve meaningful parliamentary oversight as increasingly significant powers are transferred away from primary legislation and into the regulatory model established by the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. This was passed when we were still in the European Union, with scrutiny of new areas of regulation in the European Parliament and at ECON, the committee chaired by the noble lady, Lady Bowles. Post-Brexit, there is a democratic gap and therefore a huge task for the Treasury Committee in the Commons and the Financial Services Regulation Committee in your Lordships' House, so well chaired by my noble friend Baroness Noakes. We recognise there are considerable advantages to the FSMA model. Greater regulatory flexibility can allow the framework to respond quickly to changing markets, new technologies and innovation.

In areas such as consumer credit, the industry itself has argued that moving away from parts of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 could make the regime simpler and less costly to operate. However, flexibility must not come at the expense of accountability. The effect of this bill is to place considerable trust in the Treasury and ultimately in the regulators to use their new powers proportionately, effectively and with sufficient clarity for both consumers and industry. Yet we simply do not know what the regulatory landscape will look like once these provisions have been commenced. These amendments propose a simple and practical safeguard.

Before the relevant powers are brought into force, the Treasury would publish and lay before Parliament a report explaining how it expects them to be used. The requirement would apply both where new areas of regulation are being transferred to the FCA, the PRA or the Bank of England, and where the bill creates significant new powers. This includes consumer credit regulation, currently provided for under the Consumer Credit Act 1974, payment systems, anti-money laundering supervision transferring from existing professional and industry bodies, the powers relating to overseas recognition regimes and the new powers concerning crypto-assets under clause 46. As will be apparent, many of these powers are presently in primary legislation. There's a further problem with the excessive powers on access to banking in clause 3 of the bill, but we will come on to discuss a different solution to that in group 2.

The transparency that would be achieved by our proposed approach would benefit not only Parliament, but also consumers and industry. Greater clarity before commencement should mean better scrutiny, greater certainty and better regulation.

a proportionate compromise to an issue that has plagued our discussions on this bill because of the sheer scale of change envisaged. They preserve the flexibility that the government says it needs while introducing a modest but meaningful mechanism of parliamentary accountability. I would be grateful if the minister could set out what assurance the government can give that parliament will receive this kind of information before these significant powers are brought into effect. If we do not receive sufficient comfort from the government, I reserve the right to test the opinion of the house on amendment 93 and its consequentials on Wednesday. Finally, I thank other noble lords for their amendments in this group and I look forward to hearing from them.

My lords, I beg to move.

01:32:08 - 01:32:13

Speaker 34

Amendment proposed, leave out clause 1.

01:32:13 - 01:37:17

Sharon Bowles

My lords, I will speak to my non-diminution amendments 2 and 3 and to amendments 4 and 5 stemming from them. During committee, the government made it clear that it wishes to remove tail risk for firms, a theme running through the CCA and FS changes. I agree that issues such as font sizes and business practices need updating. I would certainly prefer not to have to agree instantly to a garbled recitation of terms and conditions over the phone just to access basic service contracts. But the Consumer Credit Act is fundamentally about protecting consumers from bad corporate behavior.

And aside from the much-cited font issue, tail risk usually arises from bad behavior that simply takes a long time to surface. So there's no justifiable reason for remedy to disappear. While I see the attractions of using the FCA framework, I do not accept that there should be a time limit after which bad behavior is insulated from rectification or that protections requiring judicial remedy might fall away, over which there is no current certainty. That is the purpose of my non-diminution amendments, to allow modernization but not at the cost of significant consumer rights. Now a long-standing defect in the CCA illustrates the point.

The act was drafted in 1974 before securitization existed. As a result, consumer credit has been sold on in ways that mean the statutory definition and thus obligations of the lender no longer apply. This was a happenstance of financial evolution, not intentional design, yet it seriously degrades a regulated product and directly created the mortgage prisoner problem that my noble friend Lord Sharkey has brought to this house more than once. One can foresee the same happening with student loans once they are sold off. The solution is straightforward: whenever any right stemming from lending or credit is exercised, including the setting, levying, or collecting of interest, the corresponding obligations must travel with that right.

And that must hold even where responsibilities are split across multiple entities under securitization structures that currently allow each actor to claim it is not the statutory lender. This is entirely consistent with the CCA's original assignment provisions and we have precedent because the MCOB rules already require obligations to follow the exercise of rights in mortgage servicing.

This principle works. We have explained it to the previous minister and officials before the summer, providing copies of my amendment, my first amendment and documentary explanation. Now I recognize there have been changes on the government side, but it's regrettable that there's been no engagement since, especially as collaborative working on good ideas was a stated commitment of the new Prime Minister. Now some may ask who loses? The answer is no one suffers unjustified loss.

When a regulated consumer product is transferred, the protections attached to it must remain intact rather than be severed, whether by design or accident. For consumer credit, this simply maintains existing rights, or in the case of mortgage prisoners, restores them prospectively, but they had those rights when they took the mortgages out. Taking the same principle to student loans, once sold into the private financial system, they must carry with them the standards of respectable financial products. Borrowers must be protected from predatory interest rates, and under international accounting rules, when projected non-repayment exceeds 50%, the entire corpus of loans, not just the unpaid part, is pulled onto national debt metrics. Allowing predatory interest rates simply deepens that problem.

This is the logic behind this family of amendments. I urge the minister to engage constructively as the bill progresses, and as he will know, when I have a principled solution in my sights, it does not go away, because it rests on my conscience, as it should on his.

01:37:17 - 01:42:49

John Sharkey

My Lords, I speak to amendment five in this group. Structurally, the amendment follows the approach used by my noble friend Baroness Bowles in her previous amendment, and I'm very grateful to her for the help and support in drafting. The amendment, my amendment has a simple purpose, which is to bring relief to mortgage prisoners. As many of your Lordships will know, mortgage prisoners are people who are stuck with their existing mortgage holders, who are not active lenders, on very high interest rates and who cannot access a better deal, such as the normal market fixed rate deals. As a result, mortgage prisoners continue to pay interest at around four percentage points over the normal market fixed term rates.

This costs them hundreds and even thousands of pounds extra per year. According to the Mortgage Prisoners Action Group, there were originally around 195,000 mortgage prisoners, and this number is declining slowly due to death, reaching the end of term and repossessions. The largest group of mortgage prisoners are former Northern Rock customers. After nationalization in 2007, these mortgages were placed in a government-owned company run by UK Asset Resolution, UKAR. When returning these mortgages to the private sector, the Conservative government could have sold them to active lenders who would have offered the prisoners a fair market deal.

The government did not do that. Instead, they sold the mortgages to non-active lenders and vulture funds, and the consequences we continue to see. It's not as though the government was not warned about the problem this would cause. The risk to customers was clearly identified in January 2016. Lord McFall wrote to the Treasury and UKAR warning them that, and I quote, many of those affected by these sales will be mortgage prisoners and will be unable to switch lender.

He told the government that the customers affected by the sales should be protected, offered a fair deal and given access to fixed rates.

He warned that given the prospect of rising interest rates, it's important that all mortgage customers are given the opportunity to achieve certainty over their payments by accessing a fixed rate. He told the government that he was, and I quote, concerned that some customers affected by these mortgage sales will not be offered reasonable fixed mortgage rates. UKAR responded by saying that returning these mortgages to the private sector will mean that there will be, and I quote, the option to be offered new deals, extra lending and fixed rates should become available. This requirement was not written into the contract when the mortgages were sold to the vulture fund Cerberus. And this despite UKAR telling the BBC Panorama program that Cerberus had the ability to lend to former Northern Rock customers and that UKAR believed Cerberus intended to do so.

These terms were not written into the contract of sale. The mortgage prisoners were left unprotected by UKAR's incompetence, naivety and neglect. Martin Lewis commented that the Conservative government have sold these loans to professional debt buyers who do not offer mortgages and left these people in the types of mortgages which have been too expensive, crippling their finances and destroying their well-being. He also said that mortgage prisoners have been left paying obscene interest rates for over a decade through no fault of their own. This is still the case, despite repeated attempts to bring relief and despite open acknowledgment of the suffering caused.

In 2021, for example, Labour, crossbenchers and Lib Dem peers passed an amendment to FISMA 2000 to cap rates for mortgage prisoners. Conservative MPs removed that amendment, which is why through no fault of their own, mortgage prisoners remain prisoners. Their hardships continue. There have been suicides, attempts at suicide, homes repossessed and uncertainty about the future, especially for those with expiring interest-only mortgages. We now have an opportunity to provide some relief going forward.

The amendment before us addresses the three failures that together created mortgage prisoners. The first is that statutory rights did not travel with the loan. This is fixed by subsection two of the amendment. The second failure is that SPVs and inactive lenders have continued with predatory pricing. This is fixed by subsection three.

The third failure is that SPVs claimed they were not the creditor. Subsection four fixes this. And subsection three also places a limit to be determined by reference to a market proxy determined by the FCA on interest rates, fee structures or other pricing terms. All of this is prospective. None of it is retrospective.

It is time that mortgage prison, the mortgage prisoner problem had some real help. And this amendment sets out how to do that for the future.

01:42:49 - 01:45:31

Speaker 78

My Lords, I rise to speak in support of amendment two in the name of the noble lady Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted to which I've added my name. As we've already heard, this amendment would ensure that when provisions of the Consumer Credit Act are repealed or replaced by FCA rules, the overall level of consumer protection is not diminished. The Consumer Credit Act has long provided established routes to redress to consumers. It's done so for decades. It provides a core of fundamental protections enshrined in primary legislation and developed through parliamentary scrutiny and probably is fairly well known.

As financial services continue to evolve, of course the ways in which consumers are protected has to be capable of adapting to change. But to open up the CCA to repeal by the Treasury and the FCA without putting statutory protections in place, significant statutory protections, risks reducing standards of consumer protection for all people. Indeed, in their own review of the Consumer Credit Act, the FCA stated that many of its provisions couldn't be replaced by FCA rules under their current powers without adversely affecting consumer protection. I have spoken many times before about the importance of equal financial opportunity for underserved communities, but especially those who've got less financial literacy or who face language barriers. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation tells us a record number of people in this country are currently living in very deep poverty.

Without access, equal access to financial services, they're deprived of the tools that might help them stay afloat. For many families, credit is a lifeline in the face of the cost of living crisis. It's what enables them to make ends meet. But accessibility has to be accompanied by adequate protection. Data from the last year shows that 25% of cases seen by the Financial Ombudsman involved vulnerable consumers.

It's these groups who are least able to advocate for themselves when things go wrong or to navigate complex complaints processes on their own. To increase access to financial services for vulnerable groups whilst simultaneously hollowing out the protections from which they disproportionately benefit introduces greater risk for those already stand to lose the most. My Lords, if the protections of the Consumer Credit Act are to be opened up to repeal, we must be certain that consumers will enjoy protections that are at least as strong as those from which they benefited before. This amendment is, I believe, essential to preserving the fundamental rights which enable vulnerable groups to participate fully in economic life and will provide consumers with the confidence they need that they will be protected when things, as inevitably from time to time they do, go wrong.

01:45:31 - 01:48:07

Ros Rosalind Altmann

I would like to support the amendments in this group, and I feel that this bill has an opportunity to improve or at least not diminish the protections that are offered to consumers of financial services. We have long known that from a consumer perspective, the asymmetry of information and the asymmetry of understanding leaves ordinary consumers open to being taken advantage of by financial services companies. And the law is supposed to protect them, and currently we do have legal protections in place, albeit they are out of date and need updating, which of course we have already discussed. But I certainly would hope that the noble Lord the Minister, who I warmly welcome to his place, would understand that the aims of these amendments are to ensure that the financial consumer is protected, both at the retail level and against practices that have arisen in the past and may well arise in the future, which they do need protection from. I particularly feel that Baroness Bowles's amendments about non-diminution when it comes to consumer credit, when it comes to student loans, these things are extremely important to the ordinary person in the street.

And I commend Lord Sharkey and Baroness Bowles on continuing the attempts to ensure that mortgage prisoners are treated much more fairly.

We have another opportunity now to remove this stain on our financial services landscape. And I really do hope that the government will be able to agree and accept that capping at the very least the costs that and the interest rates that mortgage prisoners have had to pay at such great cost and pain to them will indeed be a possibility that we can introduce within this bill.

01:48:07 - 01:50:21

Susan Kramer

My Lords, I'll be brief because my benches have spoken very clearly on this issue. Can I say that I share with the Conservative front bench concerns about accountability, that's with a further removal of powers directly into the hands of the regulator, and had they moved their amendment one, we would have supported it. But I want to address the other amendments just very briefly. I still am in somewhat in a state of genuine concern that the government will not accept an amendment that would confirm that the changes that it's proposing to the Consumer Credit Act, which will be absorbed now into the role of the FCA, that will not involve a non-diminution of consumer credit protection. This is the non-diminution of rights that Baroness Bowles described.

Of course, the FCA could keep those rights in place, but there is nothing that compels it to do so. And I find it extraordinary that we can't be given this reassurance. But my Lords, that's I am more exercised than anything else about the position of mortgage prisoners. The people who have been impacted, that are now many of them elderly, their situation has been shocking over the past years, and we could now give them relief for the remaining years that in which they will be tangled with paying extraordinary levels of interest on mortgages that were taken out in good faith, for which they properly qualified, that and were at the time market standard mortgages. And it's happened because essentially an arm of government that made mistakes when it sold on those loans to vulture funds.

It is shocking that we haven't corrected this. The amendment that is in this on the paper today is incredibly effective, it's new thinking, and it's incredibly effective at making sure that going forward this incredible injustice is ended. And I hope very much even in these last few minutes that the government will think again and provide support.

01:50:21 - 02:06:10

David Pitt

My Lords, it is a privilege to be here today to debate the Financial Services and Markets Bill. And I would like to put on record my thanks to my noble friend Lord Stockwood for leading the earlier stages of this debate, and also to thank all of those Lords who have contributed to this debate at committee stage and beyond. If you would allow me, I would like to say a few things about the bill itself before moving on to addressing the amendments that have been put. I think this bill has a purpose on which I think we are all agreed. That is that we're trying to construct rules which help the financial services industry to serve its customers better and to prosper as a result of doing so.

In responding to the debate in committee, you will therefore see that the government has been persuaded of some significant points that have been made there and is proposing some significant amendments which I hope will be welcomed by the House.

There are also amendments that will be suggested at report stage where the government will disagree with the specific measure proposed, but in many cases the government does have great sympathy with the ultimate goals of the particular amendment. However, there are many where we do not believe that they belong as part of the bill, in part because they are complex and require consultation and/or go beyond the scope of the bill, in part also because the aims of the amendment are not best served, we believe, by changing primary legislation, but where the government often would want to help promote the goals of the amendment, indeed sometimes it already is and perhaps seek to encourage better practice. Central to all of this, I know, is accountability and I will come to that at the beginning and end of this session and then again later on today, but let me now turn to these specific amendments. Amendments 1 and 6 would remove clause 1 and schedule 1 from the bill and prevent the government's program of Consumer Credit Act reform. Amendments 2 and 3 to ensure that the reforms don't diminish consumer protections.

Amendments 4 and 5 relate to the assignment of student loans and of mortgages. Similar amendments were debated in committee and the government has carefully considered the concerns raised. However, we have concluded that we wish to press ahead with these much-needed reforms. I think we all in this House agree that the FCA is the right body to take on the role of consumer protection and Parliament has already given it the right powers and objectives to do so, including a consumer protection objective. Since the 2014 transfer of consumer credit to the FCA, important protections, including creditworthiness and affordability assessments, have successfully operated through the FCA framework.

I recognize the concern raised both in committee and again today that Parliament is being asked to approve reform before replacement FCA rules have been finalized. However, I would emphasize that the FCA must consult on proposed rules and engage with parliamentary committees as part of the established statutory framework. This includes the Financial Services Regulation Committee, ably chaired by the noble lady Baroness Noakes. And both the FCA and the PRA are keenly aware of scrutiny. Last week they wrote to me a letter which I think has been circulated to all of you, making a number of commitments further to enhance parliamentary scrutiny and I have placed those letters in the library.

I expect to cover this detail, including those letters, in detail in a further grouping at the end of today. Turning to amendments 2 and 3, I fully agree that consumers must continue to benefit from robust protections and effective routes to redress. The government would not be proceeding with this reform if we felt otherwise. However, I don't consider that the duty proposed is an appropriate mechanism to be able to achieve this. The government has already concluded that certain important protections should remain in legislation, including section 75, which allows consumers to claim their money back from their lender where products and services purchased on credit are faulty or do not arrive, and the unfair relationships provision contained in sections 140A to 140C.

And as I have said, the FCA rulebook already contains important protections, including creditworthiness and affordability assessments. So I don't think there is anything in what we are doing here that is seeking to lessen consumer protections, the concern of the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Manchester and also of the Noble Baroness Altman. However, the Consumer Credit Act is highly prescriptive in the information requirements, which I think can produce poor outcomes for consumers. The current regime can be difficult for those with lower literacy and financial capability. Some documents require a reading ability of an undergraduate level.

These reforms will make it possible for the FCA to enable firms to tailor communications to consumer needs, which will improve accessibility and support better outcomes for vulnerable customers. The bill also repeals the statutory sanctions attached to these prescriptive requirements. Sanctions were designed for a very different regime under the Office of Fair Trading, with limited regulatory powers to ensure consumer protections are no longer necessary to ensure robust protection for consumers. Instead, consumers will be protected through the modern system of financial services regulation, where the FCA supervises firms, enforces rules, and can require redress. Consumers have access to firm complaint processes and the Financial Ombudsman Service, and firms are required proactively to redress consumer harms under the FCA regime on the basis of consumer complaints or their own regular compliance monitoring.

Finally, repeal of the Consumer Credit Act provisions will not be commenced without replacement arrangements being in place. The government's intention is an orderly transition that avoids any gap in consumer protection and provides certainty for consumers and firms alike. And to ensure that consumers can benefit from an updated framework to bring consumer credit regulation into line with comparable financial services product, the government does not believe that it would be right either to remove clause one, which would prevent this reform, or to introduce the sort of duty set out in two or three, where for example there could be an argument about the information that was provided to consumers, which might well have been expressed in a way that would not be to their advantage or to their understanding. But in all of this, there is no intention to reduce consumer protections. Turning to the important issue of mortgage prisoners, I also recognize the absolute legitimate strength of feeling across the House, and I recognize the very real pressures that are faced by the affected households.

At a time when families are already facing pressure from energy bills, from food prices, from other essentials, we must ensure that people are treated fairly.

As noble lords may be aware, the number of borrowers in closed books is still at 105,000, down I should say from 195,000 in 2021, but still too many. The fall is welcome, but it doesn't lessen the seriousness of the circumstances faced by those who remain, nor should the reduction in numbers be taken to mean that the underlying challenges have been resolved. Those who remain may be facing particularly persistent barriers to switching or obtaining a mortgage that is appropriate to their circumstances. My noble lords, the circumstances of mortgage prisoners deserve our serious attention. I'm sure many agree with me on that.

I hope that many of you will also agree that the government must ensure that any proposed intervention in this market is fair, but is also effective. And with that in mind, we have considered whether a rate cap of the kind proposed in part by these amendments would improve outcomes for mortgage prisoners. We understand the intention behind the amendment to provide relief to borrowers who may be paying more than they can reasonably afford, as a case made quite articulately by Baroness Bowles and Lord Sharkey. Nevertheless, a cap on the rates paid as envisioned by this amendment would not in itself address the reasons why some borrowers cannot switch products. Indeed, previous analysis by the London School of Economics also raised concerns about the effectiveness and wider consequences of reducing such a cap.

The government is sympathetic to the challenges that mortgage prisoners face. It is, however, clear that a cap on rates does not seem to be the right solution. Our focus is on ensuring fair treatment, proper oversight and practical routes for borrowers who are struggling or who may have been unable to access appropriate support. As to the right course of action, as I have said, this deserves the attention of the government and we will continue to work with the FCA and the industry to ensure that lenders and administrators do meet their responsibilities, communicate clearly with effective borrowers and provide appropriate support where people are in difficulty. We'll also continue to pay close attention to the experience of those who remain unable to access suitable mortgage products as we do so.

I'm sorry that that answer will not meet the issues that the noble Baroness Kramer and others have raised, but we are unconvinced that this amendment will solve the problem that needs addressing. I now turn to the issue of the sale of student loans raised by Baroness Bowles. The last student loan sale took place in 2018 and the government has no active program of student loan sales and currently has no plans to undertake further sales. I can reassure the noble lords that existing legislation already includes protections for borrowers whose loans have been sold, including provisions in the Sale of Student Loans Act 2008 designed to ensure that such borrowers are not placed in a worse position as a result of the sale. Finally, I will turn to the question of delegated powers and amendments 93, 100, 101, 2 and 3 in the name of Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

The amendments would require the Treasury to lay before Parliament a report setting out how the powers conferred in several parts of the bill will be used before it can use the powers or commence the relevant provisions.

Delegated powers are a long-standing and accepted part of the legislative and regulatory framework for financial services. The pace of innovation means that detailed primary legislation becomes out of date and ineffective, the Consumer Credit Act a good example of this, and enabling the Treasury to adjust the scope of regulation to reflect market and technological developments keeps our framework effective. This is not a shortcut or bad policy making, I think it is how the system is supposed to work. But the government wants to be as open as it can about how these delegated powers will be used. It doesn't think for that that legislation is necessary.

I would note that there is material already set out in the bill's delegated powers memorandum. This covers both powers delegated to the Treasury and to the regulator, and that report is 65 pages long and we have published two supplementary memoranda to reflect changes introduced through the amendments. I'm sure we've all heard complaints that regulations can be slow to change meaning it takes longer for consumers and firms to benefit from reforms, and I fear that these amendments would slow us down still further. It would also set a precedent to restrict the powers available to the government in this way and might delay the delivery of important reforms, and I do note that the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee, which did have comments on this bill, had not raised concerns about any of the delegated powers to which these amendments apply. But look, in the spirit of openness that I think has characterized this bill throughout its transition, I would be more than happy to meet with the noble Baroness to discuss how the government can continue in a spirit of openness, but I do not think that legislation is the correct answer to this issue and therefore ask the noble Baroness to withdraw her amendments.

02:06:10 - 02:08:34

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, I'm very grateful for the Minister for his response and his detailed explanation of how clause 1 is framed. And I'm also grateful for those others who've contributed to the debate, Baroness Bowles, the Right Reverend Bishop of Manchester, and Lady Altmann on the recasting of consumer protection law, which is very important to us all, and from the noble Lord Lord Sharkey on mortgage prisoners. I describe that as a sorry tale. My Lords, we remain of the view that when this process of recasting takes place, Parliament and industry must have a practical mechanism through which they can exercise oversight and make such representations that they need to make, such as those that we've heard today, on how the powers are used on the first occasion. The system would not be undermined by that, it's a first occasion proposal.

And that's what amendment 93 and its consequentials seeks to provide. And I believe it's a workable and proportionate mechanism which allows the government to achieve its broader objective of introducing a more flexible regulatory framework, but not wholly at the expense of scrutiny, transparency, and democratic accountability. We shouldn't be signing away any rights and protections without knowing what we'll replace them with.

I'm very grateful to the Minister for engaging with us on our concerns. I don't think the delegated power memorandum does it, because it doesn't explain what all these new powers in these various areas are going to be used for, including consumer credit. So I think there must be a meaningful mechanism to acquaint the House with how the powers are exercised, and also indeed to ensure regulatory officials turn up to the committee at the convenience of the committee and are able to question them on a suitable report on how these important changes are taking place. We support the general drift of these changes, as the Minister knows too well, but we are worried about accountability. So I do, I'm happy to have further discussions, but if need be, I plan to test the opinion of the House when we reach amendment 93 on Wednesday.

02:08:34 - 02:08:36

John Sharkey

Does the noble Lord wish to withdraw amendment one?

02:08:36 - 02:08:39

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

At this time, I withdraw amendment one.

02:08:39 - 02:08:51

Speaker 34

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment by leave withdrawn. Amendments two to four, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment five, Lord Sharkey.

02:08:51 - 02:10:09

John Sharkey

My Lords, I had hoped that the life-crippling injustice visited on mortgage prisoners by government would produce a more sympathetic approach. And in fact, it's hard to tell what approach, if any, the government is proposing. What is it proposing to do about this long-standing and obvious injustice? Let me point out perhaps just one thing, which is that there has been a lot of research in this area, a lot of it funded by Martin Lewis, a money-saving expert. And that report, three years old now, actually put forward six areas for discussion to arrive at a solution.

Martin Lewis has had no response from the government at all to his report. More talk, but less actual action would help. The difference between what the government is saying and what the amendment is saying is this. The government is promising nothing, not even making a commitment to do something thinking about it. The amendment delivers something, and I would like to test the opinion of the House.

02:10:09 - 02:13:41

Speaker 34

The question is that amendment five be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division, and I will inform the House when voting is over. Voting is now over, clear the bar.

Order. The question is that Amendment 5 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. My Lords, the contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

02:18:34 - 02:18:34

The question is that this amendment be agreed to.

02:20:44 - 02:21:28

Speaker 34

My Lords, they have voted: content 76, not content 164, so the not contents have it. We'll just have a moment for people to resume their seats. Now come to amendment 6, Baroness Neville-Rolfe, not moved. Not moved. In clause 3, Baroness Kramer, amendment 7.

02:21:28 - 02:24:52

Susan Kramer

Exceedingly remiss of me when I spoke earlier that's not to welcome Lord Pitt-Watson to his role. We've had so many conversations, I think I've begun to think of him as the established minister. And yet sitting just a few benches away, Lord Stockwood, whose presence we're so glad that he's going to stay engaged with this bill. That's and and Lord Livermore, who was with us earlier. That's he was a relentless proponent of the government position and I will miss my engagements with him.

My Lords, clause 3 deals with access to banking services. And the government has told us that the powers in clause 3 are intended to allow the government to incorporate into law and regulation recommendations from the independent public review of access to banking services chaired by Richard Lloyd and due in October. The review will evaluate the impact of ongoing bank branch closures and will review access to face-to-face banking across the UK. We on these benches strongly support this review. Banks have closed a third of their branches in the last five years and since 2015 nearly 7,000 bank and building society branches have shut down.

We have been strong advocates of the banking hub scheme to create at least some minimal access to services. 235 have opened but the commitment is only to a total of 350 hubs. Much stronger action is needed and soon. But, and it is beyond my comprehension why, clause 3 has not been drafted for the narrow purpose stated by the government of implementing the recommendations of the Lloyd review. It allows Treasury to amend any act of Parliament and to give any powers it wishes on access to banking to the FCA.

Nothing is confined to the Lloyd review. It is Henry VIII on steroids. Now I've put down amendment 7, which would limit powers to allow the Treasury to implement only those provisions arising directly from the Lloyd review, which at least has been consulted on and has had some broad engagement.

The government has not accepted that amendment. We therefore cannot accept the huge constitutional breach that clause three represents. If the Conservative benches move ahead with their amendment seven, that with which would effectively knock clause three out of this bill, I have very strong hopes that the government will come back with proper wording in the Commons, by which time the Lloyd review will have been published. As I say, we expect to support every aspect of the recommendations that come from the Lloyd's review, though we haven't yet seen them, but we cannot set the precedent of allowing sweeping powers that go way beyond the stated objective to be incorporated in a bill of this significance.

02:24:52 - 02:25:01

Speaker 20

Amendment proposed clause three, page two, line four, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.

02:25:01 - 02:29:53

The Lord Vaux

As this is the first time I speak at report stage, I should remind the house of my interests as a shareholder in Fidelity National Information Services Inc, which provides services to the financial sector, and as a non-practicing member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. I'd also like to welcome the noble lord Lord Pitts-Watson to his new role and perhaps to apologize to the noble lord Lord Stockwood for when we discussed this clause at committee stage, I jokingly referred to the noble lord the minister not always being the minister, for which I apologize. I have amendment nine in this group, which would remove the egregious Henry VIII power from clause three altogether, and I've also added my name to amendment ten, which would delete clause three altogether. As I explained at committee stage, as someone who lives in a very rural area, my nearest bank branch, now that the last branch in my nearest town has closed, is a hundred mile round trip. So access to banking is a subject to which I have a lot of sympathy personally.

And I do look forward to seeing the Lloyd report once it's been published in October and like the noble lady Baroness Kramer, I expect to support an awful lot that will be in it. The problem with clause three though is that it gives the government incredibly broad and unfettered powers in this respect, including an unlimited power to amend any act of Parliament. Indeed, there's actually nothing in the clause that would prevent a government actually reducing access to banking if it so chose to do. I don't think I can put it any better than our Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee in its report of the 17th of June, which brought these wide powers to the house's attention. And it concluded that the problem, and I quote, "the problem with clause three is that it confers a wide regulation-making power on ministers before any key policy decisions have been made, before any problem has been clearly identified, and assisted by a power to amend any act of Parliament ever made."

"Such a power severely compromises effective parliamentary scrutiny." "We consider that the power in clause three is inappropriately wide and should be removed from the bill."

My Lords, this government has form on pushing through legislation before it really knows what it wants to do with it. And this example, I think, is particularly egregious. I asked the noble Lord, Lord Stockwood, when he was the minister at committee stage, which acts of Parliament the government had in mind to alter using this power. The response, I am sorry to say, was less than illuminating. He said, and I quote, "The Treasury expects to use the power, if needed, to amend relevant legislation, for example, financial services legislation."

End quote. And he went on to say, "As the recommendations of the independent access to banking services review are currently unknown, it is necessary for clause 3 to be able to amend primary legislation to respond to any recommendations that are made." In other words, we don't know what we want to do, so we're just going to make it as wide as possible. My own guess is that it's actually highly unlikely that any primary legislation will need to be changed as a result of this, but we shall see. But I think that makes the case against clause 3.

It is not satisfactory for the government to give itself the widest of powers, including the unlimited power to change any existing acts of Parliament when it has no idea what it actually wants to do with those powers. Now, the government claims, in the explanatory memorandum and elsewhere, that it will narrow the powers once the Lloyd report has been received. But my Lords, this is report stage. We have not seen the report. It will take I don't know how many months for the government to come up with recommendations based on the report.

The bill will already probably be law by then. So there will be no real opportunity to narrow the powers. Now, I'm sure the House will support moves to improve access to banking when, in due course, the government actually has a plan. And in the unlikely event that changes are in fact required to existing law, a short focused bill can be created to do that, which, as all changes to the law should be, can be subject to the proper scrutiny process of Parliament. This unfocused clause is too wide, and any resulting changes to law would not be subject to proper scrutiny.

And that is not the right way to legislate, my Lords. At the very least, the Henry VIII clause should be removed, as I suggest in amendment 9. But the clause as a whole, I think, is too wide, and therefore I would urge all noble Lords to support Baroness Neville-Rolfe's amendment 10 to remove this unrestricted power.

02:29:53 - 02:32:52

Kate Hoey

My Lords, I am I wanted to support amendment 8, but so no one seems to be moving it, so is it in order for me to say a few words on it and move it? Because I think it's actually a very important amendment, because it deals with the only mention really in the whole bill on post offices. And of course, this amendment in the name of Baroness Tyler, Lord Holmes, Richmond, and Baroness Kramer is talking about the Treasury considering the effectiveness of alternative frameworks, including the post office banking framework, in providing access to banking and cash services. And I think that's a really, really important aspect of all of this, because increasingly we are seeing that people, particularly in rural areas, particularly in areas where there is high deprivation and people don't have access to online facilities, don't particularly want to use online, don't trust banks, enough to go online, don't trust the internet, are using their post offices. And the post offices yet could be doing so much more to widen the whole question of access to cash and money.

And I would draw attention, I'm sure most noble Lords will have seen the National Federation of SubPostmasters' report on access to banking review, which is a really well worth 18 pages of showing statistically just how much more post offices are being used by people and how they could be used even more to do services that is that is when banks close in areas and now it is usually try the post office is picking up a lot of that.

And I think that it's it's very, very important that the I'd like to hear what the noble lord the minister and I welcome very much to his his position that he would say whether in fact the government is serious about increasing the use of post offices, not just on on some of the issues to do with banking, but also, you know, you can no longer pay your television license if you still want to pay it. You can no longer pay that in the post office. There are so many services that have been taken away from the post office that actually would be make it much, much easier and more accessible for people, particularly in in rural communities. People do trust their local post office and and they find that that is somewhere that they can go and get the advice and the reassurance that they can't now get in their local bank because they don't ever see see a bank go into a bank themselves. And the lack of trust which which I mentioned.

So could I ask the noble lord to respond to that this particular amendment and say whether he is willing to actually talk directly to the National Federation of Subpostmasters to discuss these issues further and how we can make our post offices more vibrant, more more involved with the local community by being able to offer them the services that they want.

02:32:52 - 02:35:59

The Lord Holmes

My lords, I follow the noble lady and in doing so, as it's the first time I've spoken in report, I declare my technology interests as set out in the register as advisor to the Crown Estate, Simmons & Simmons LLP and as non-executive director at Avalanche Foundation, Avalanche BVI Inc. My lords, I rise to speak to amendment eight, which I had pleasure in signing. How many brands, how many businesses have we in the UK that have been on our high street for over half a millennium? That's what we have with the post office, which rode into our lives in 1511 and continues to have just shy of 12,000 branches up and down the country. Whatever happens with digital, and finance certainly is going to become and already in many areas is digital, we need and must support physical presence and human access and interaction to finance, not least for those who find themselves at the sharpest end of financial exclusion.

Because as I've already mentioned with digital, financial inclusion often and perniciously goes hand in hand with digital exclusion, compounding both of those exclusionary forces. The post office has a unique role. Of course, they have had well-known difficulties in recent times, but that does not diminish the potential role that they can play as other financial services providers retreat and have already retreated from so many of our high streets. It can be the core of the community with inclusive, accessible finance at that core and rippling out all kinds of other financial, digital and small-s social services. It has such positive potential.

We've seen this with the hub model. I'd be interested in the minister's responses to whether the government believe we have enough hubs, whether the plan for hubs is ambitious enough, whether we need to bring in indeed other players into this hub model as well to ensure that wherever you are, whoever you are in the country, in socioeconomics, you can have effective access to finance and through that meaningful, sustainable and often physical access to cash and financial services.

I very much look forward to the minister's response to this amendment.

02:35:59 - 02:37:46

Nicholas MacPherson

My Lords, I rise briefly to support the noble Baroness Neville-Rolfe's amendment 10 and to add a few of my own concerns on clause 3 and also support the remarks made earlier by the noble Lord, Lord Vaux and the noble Lady Kramer on this matter. Protecting customer access to essential banking services is of course a goal we all share. However, the granting of such wide-ranging executive powers, basically conferring almost unlimited powers on the Treasury for this matter, seems an unnecessary measure, even allowing for the understandable desire to act quickly. The Treasury's own review of in-person banking access doesn't report until October, as has been mentioned, and we're being asked to legislate before we know the nature of the problem we're solving or the policy decisions that might follow. Would they be proportionate?

Would they be effective? We really have no way of knowing this at this stage and don't even have the benefit of course of seeing the report in October. The Treasury's memorandum to the DPRRC seeks to narrow these powers when the review concludes, so the government is implicitly aware, I would assume, that the delegated powers are too broad. But the answer is not to grant excessively wide powers now and then tidy up later. Surely it would be better to wait or to bring back a properly bounded set of powers when the evidence exists.

So I'd like to offer my support to amendment 10, which would delete clause 3 altogether.

02:37:46 - 02:40:34

Ros Rosalind Altmann

My Lords, I also support the amendments in this group. I believe that the description of these extremely wide powers should in itself alert the House to the dangers that this element of the bill, clause 3, could pose. And I do believe that it is important for the government to understand, for example, what has been revealed in the latest report just a few days ago from Age UK about digital exclusion among the older age groups in this country. It is all very well for policymakers and members of this House indeed to believe that everyone can manage to bank online, you don't need to go into a physical branch. But when it comes to the older generations, that is simply not the case.

And certainly in terms of the population over age 65, the research suggests that only 15% of pensioners or of the over-65s are fully digitally included. That means they're able to do all services digitally. And that is 20% of men and 10% of women. And 1.4 million over-65s are fully digitally excluded.

The more we see bank closures, the less access to banking these people who have, the more excluded from society they become. And I hope that the government will recognize that we do need to make sure that there is an opportunity for Parliament and for the legislation to ensure that these older people are not forgotten, are not left behind, and that the access to banking that they may well rely upon is not just removed, perhaps inadvertently, from legislation that could have been avoided, for example, if we have some of the amendments in this group that would ensure either that the clause 3 is altogether removed and or that the most egregious parts of it are removed, as the noble Lord Lord Vaux was saying, and also as the noble lady Baroness Kramer was saying, that we make sure the Lloyd review, which is meant indeed to directly deal with this, is part of the legislation going forward.

02:40:34 - 02:42:41

Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor

My Lords, I'd like very briefly to support Baroness Neville-Rolfe's amendment to leave out clause 3 and also to say to say how much I agree with Lord Vaux and other noble Lords who've spoken in this debate. I support these amendments on constitutional grounds because of the importance of the separation of powers and the role of Parliament in checking executive power, as Lord Macpherson has mentioned. How can we keep the government to account if we have no knowledge of the powers proposed? But as clause 3 puts it, allows the Treasury power to make any regulations it considers appropriate, now with no knowledge of what they are. Clause 3 also gives the Treasury power to delegate powers to the FCA.

And the FCA to make rules, amend an Act of Parliament, or to make provision for different purposes. Now, there are many concerns about the regulators, and I just mention two. The regulators do not supervise or explore predictably in accordance with their own rules. You will find different sorts of interpretations given to their own rules in their rulings. And we must ensure their decisions are consistent between firms which operate businesses of similar size.

And one other example is formal decisions by the regulators do not necessarily include sufficient explanation to serve as precedents to allow the application of the relevant rules. So I'm very pleased to welcome the noble Lord the Minister to the front bench and say how much we also miss Lord the noble Lord Lord Stockwood, but I wish the noble Lord well. And it's on constitutional grounds that I would ask the noble Lord to think very carefully about these amendments.

02:42:41 - 02:46:16

Lord McKinley of Richborough

My Lords, I'll just have a couple of words on amendment 10, which I fully support in the name of my noble friend Baroness Neville-Rolfe. Because that that phrase here, the Treasury may by regulations make such provisions as they consider appropriate in connection with providing access to banking services, that isn't just wide, that is ocean wide. And that is far too wide without parliamentary consent or or any investigation as to what our democratic processes consider to be the right level of banking services and access to banking across this country. I'll also say a few words on amendment 8, and I'm very pleased my the noble lady Baroness Hoey said something about the post office. Now, when I was a constituency MP, I I faced as as anyone who who lives in in any part of this country faced, the closure of banking services, which always caused concern particularly to older residents.

Now, I purposefully kept my father, now deceased, away from digital banking because of the risk of scams and the risk of those dodgy emails coming in. I mean, he was of perfectly sound mind and very capable, but he perhaps wasn't as scam-aware as younger people are. So I wanted him a long, long way away from digital banking services. And why shouldn't he stay away from digital banking services? But we were always told by the banks that were closing, well, fear not, we have a post office network that will do all that your constituents and customers need to do in terms of access to cash and banking cheques and that that more standard stuff.

Now, I don't know about other noble lords, but you know, I do digital banking, of course I do. But when faced with a cheque, which are a little bit more rare these days than they used to be, I do struggle for obvious reasons to hold the camera, go up a bit, go left a bit, go right a bit, go down a bit, it's not all in the picture yet, and press the button. And I'm sure we've all shared that frustration. But let me leave you this with the post office. They are not the panacea of everything because Lloyds Bank over the last few months have stopped the use of post office services to their customers.

I don't know why. So this is a two-way street. The banks can have a relationship with the post office or they can at their discretion not have a relationship with the post office. For reasons known only to themselves, Lloyds have decided not to use the services of the post office. And for those reasons, I sympathize massively with the noble lord Lord Vaux, who now has to go 100 miles round trip to a bank.

No doubt there is a post office nearer than that, but if you're a Lloyds customer, hard luck, 100 miles. So this is this isn't about, you know, the quantity and texture of tomato sauce in a can of beans that we might lead to officials and statutory instruments. These are fundamentals of life that everybody faces on a daily basis. So to allow this extent of power, I think is a power too far. And I have to say, we do see far too much Henry VIII in all legislation.

That's not just from this government, that was from the government I was with over the years. It's been a temptation for this creep to happen, and I think this creep must not enter this bill.

02:46:16 - 02:49:34

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My lords, I'd start by thanking the noble lady Lady Hoey, my noble friend Lord Holmes, and Lord McKinley for reminding us of the value of post offices and the importance of banking hubs, especially in this ever-expanding digital world. There are serious issues here across the country. But I rise to speak to my amendment 10, which does a very simple thing. It removes clause three from the bill altogether. And my argument for it is equally simple.

Clause three contains no detail about what the government actually intend to do. Instead, as the noble lady Lady Kramer has explained, it grants ministers extraordinarily broad powers, including the power to amend primary legislation on access to banking. So once the Richard Lloyd review has concluded, the government may legislate for whatever it subsequently decides is necessary. That could include anything on banking services with huge implications for consumers, for banks, other financial services, and the high street. As noble lord Lord Vaux has said, a power to amend any act of parliament.

It's a huge power grab by the Treasury. It's a very significant delegation of power to ask parliament to approve in advance.

We do not know what problems these powers will ultimately be used to address. We do not know what regulations the government envisage making. We do not know which Acts of Parliament they wish to amend. Yet Parliament is nevertheless being asked now to hand over the power to do all of these things. We should be very cautious about giving any government powers of this breadth on the basis that they will decide later, in good faith, how they wish to use them.

Parliament shouldn't be asked to give ministers carte blanche, particularly where the powers include the ability to amend primary legislation with minimal parliamentary scrutiny. That would set a terrible precedent. So the right course is straightforward: Clause 3 should come out. Once the government has completed the review of access to banking and know what they actually wish to do, they can return to Parliament with legislation setting out the policy, the powers required to deliver it, and the appropriate safeguards. I'm very grateful to the Noble Lady Lady Kramer, Lady Altmann, and the Noble Lord Lord Vaux, and indeed my noble friends Lord Massey, Lord McKinley, and my noble friend Lady Lawlor for supporting this.

The minister has a problem. We have a lot of concern across this House, and it's not only amongst those engaged on the bill. It reflects the concerns by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee with its very expert membership. They've also advised that the clause should be removed. That is usually, I would say to the minister, a killer argument.

For these reasons, I do not believe Clause 3 can remain in the bill, and when Amendment 10 is called, I intend to test the opinion of the House.

02:49:34 - 02:55:06

David Pitt

My Lords, I'm hearing two arguments here: one, a huge consensus across the House of the need for access to banking and for the appropriate actions to be taken to make sure that that takes place. But I'm also hearing a concern raised, it was a concern also raised in committee, about the breadth of the power, in particular its constitutional implications and the degree of scrutiny that Parliament would be able to exercise over any regulations made under it. These are serious points, and the government has considered them and considered them seriously, but has concluded that Clause 3 is needed at this stage because the independent review, the Lloyd review into access to banking, has not yet concluded. We don't know whether it will recommend intervention, which consumers may be most affected, the nature of any detriment, what sort of form any intervention should take. Removing Clause 3 altogether, as Amendment 10 would do, would risk leaving the government without a mechanism in this bill to respond promptly if the review identifies a focused and time-sensitive need for intervention.

Amendment 9 would remove the ability to amend primary legislation through regulations made under Clause 3. If acting on the review's findings required changes to an Act of Parliament, removing this ability would risk removing the mechanism to respond promptly to the review and could delay implementation. Amendment 7 would take a different approach by limiting the powers to matters arising directly from the review.

I understand the intention behind that amendment and the review should clearly play the central role in shaping any future intervention. That's why the bill already requires the Treasury to have regard to the review's recommendations. But it would not be right to prevent ministers from considering other relevant evidence alongside the review when deciding whether and how to act. The government needs to preserve the ability to respond proportionately to the full evidence that is available. Let me then come to amendment 8.

I think it's probably one on which we all agree, Lord Holmes and Baroness Hoey, about the absolutely central part that the post offices can play in making sure that banking access is available. I can confirm that the chair of the review into access to banking services has received representations from and has engaged with the post office and the National Federation of SubPostmasters and that officials will continue to engage as part of the development. As you know, the target is more than 350 full banking hubs, plus I think it was my numbers were 10,500 post offices that were going to be involved in this and I would thoroughly commend the points that they have made. But I do absolutely understand the concerns about the Henry VIII powers which seem very broad. The government remains committed to keeping the scope of the power under review as the independent review completes its work.

Look, clause 3 does not itself impose new obligations on firms or any specific model of banking provision. We expect to narrow this power after the review has reported in October when I expect the bill will be in the Commons. Any regulations under the power would also be subject to the affirmative procedure. Once the Lloyd review is concluded, the government will be in a better position to consider the correct scope of this power. However, I would like to assure my noble lords that the government does not expect clause 3 to remain in its current form.

And for those reasons, I would ask the noble baroness to withdraw her amendment, perhaps more in hope than expectation. I forget how Baroness Kramer said her hopes would be fulfilled, but they would be fulfilled, I think, by amendments that were focused on the thing that we're all agreed to, which is that we have proper access to banking, that for older people, for younger people, for everyone. Thank you.

02:55:06 - 02:55:17

Susan Kramer

My lords, given that the front bench of the Conservatives have expressed their interest in moving amendment 10, I will withdraw 7.

02:55:17 - 02:55:34

Speaker 20

Is it your pleasure that amendment 7 be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn.

Amendment 8, Baroness Kramer, not moved. Amendment 9, Lord Vaux, not moved. Amendment 10, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

02:55:34 - 02:55:38

Speaker 88

My Lords, I seek to test the opinion of the House on this amendment.

02:55:38 - 02:59:16

Speaker 20

Question is that amendment 10 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by division. I will advise the House when voting is open.

Voting is open, clear the bar. My Lords, the question is that amendment 10 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

02:59:40 - 03:03:40

Speaker 90

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

03:04:11 - 03:07:46

Speaker 89

My Lords. The question is that amendment 10 be agreed to. My Lords, there have voted contents 247, not contents 165, and so the contents have it.

03:07:47 - 03:07:53

Speaker 20

After clause 3, amendment 11, Baroness Kramer.

03:07:53 - 03:16:38

Susan Kramer

This group of amendments is, uh, is, uh, concerns itself with financial inclusion. And I have two important but two very different amendments in this group. The first is amendment 11 to which the Bishop of Manchester has added his name and I do thank him. As this house will know that I have long been an advocate for CDFIs, community development bank financial institutions, usually banks or credit unions, which are dedicated to serving the banking and finance needs of local communities and small businesses as our high street banks once did. They do what I suppose in modern terms we would call place-based lending, knowing the community, its businesses, its people, and they are structured, staffed and skilled to provide those services.

By contrast, SMEs struggle to get mainstream bank credit. Now the government has taken steps to grow CDFIs, providing 150 million to the British Business Bank to develop a community enable fund and increasing the growth guarantee scheme by a significant 6.5 billion over four years. It has set up a UK community finance partnership task force with an impressive membership to build partnerships between CDFIs and mainstream banks. But the key piece of the puzzle is missing. We do not have the driver to create many more CDFIs or community banks if you prefer that term and credit unions across the country, especially in our most disadvantaged areas.

And that is what my amendment 11 tackles. It takes a British approach inspired by success in the United States. The FCA would assess lending to individuals, households and small businesses against deposit taking in a community to determine if the lending is proportionate. Where a bank does not wish to lend in reasonable proportion, it can fund a CDFI rather than change its business model. UK CDFIs have very low default rates and create impressive numbers of businesses and jobs, so the mainstream banks are not losers by this mechanism just as they haven't been in the United States.

And thanks to the growth guarantee scheme, the banks are required to hold capital only against 30% of their contribution. So in the USA, CDFIs now hold over 300 billion in outstanding loans. They are the primary way in which small businesses borrow. In the UK, the amount of borrowing is 188 million. If anyone wants to understand the difference in resilience and growth in our two economies, much of it lies in those numbers.

This amendment creates in effect a local banking network committed to lend to local people and to local small businesses, so it is absolutely key to delivering the very promise which John Healey as Chancellor made today, good growth in every postcode. And yet I understand that Labour will oppose it. And that is perverse.

Without this change, the change that the amendment delivers, the Chancellor's goal is really not achievable. Liberal Democrats have brought this forward because we are determined to actually achieve growth in every postcode and to make that a reality. My Lord, my second amendment in this group is number 60. The amendment is to limit an unfolding sadness. Young people turning 18 and eligible to access their own child trust funds or junior ISAs cannot do so for themselves if they lack the mental capacity, usually because of learning difficulties.

The families and guardians of these youngsters, who typically manage significant sums of money on their behalf, are unable to access the funds to spend on the youngsters because of administrative and legal obstacles which take months to surmount and require paying a whole variety of court and administrative fees, that's often amounting to 1,000 pounds, even though the typical child trust fund for these youngsters only has 2,000 pounds in it. 80,000 disabled young people are caught up in this awful snafu and some 210 million is locked in the child trust funds. Now in our house, Lord Young of Cookham and Lord Blunkett have campaigned extensively on this issue and can confirm that the obstacles that are created were never intended. Every government minister seems to accept that something must be done, but changing the Mental Capacity Act is incredibly complex because of concerns for precedence. Now this amendment takes the tack of using this bill to empower the FCA to provide cover for financial institutions holding these funds to release them based on documents from registered medical practitioners confirming incapacity and from the families or guardians acknowledging their duties.

The FCA would report to Parliament annually. It's a practical way to get the money where it needs to go, and none of this costs the government a penny. In meetings with the government, I was told that the FCA does not have scope in this case. Then last week, the FCA announced a review into child trust funds, in part to see if there are obstacles for vulnerable youngsters. Now it's not going to finish that review until next year and any action will take far longer than that, but clearly that very act of initiating the review demonstrates that the FCA does have scope.

And I've also talked extensively with lawyers who have confirmed that any authority created under FCA rules still sits inside the Mental Capacity Act framework and does not challenge it in any way. Fairness for these youngsters, many of whom have life-limiting conditions and for whom this money is a chance to use their own money to do something special, should not have to wait on an FCA review which may or may not yield anything. The amendment in this legislation can deliver change in weeks. 80,000 very vulnerable youngsters need us to act. My Lords, let me briefly address other amendments in this group.

My colleague Baroness Tyler, whom I had anticipated was going to move the Post Office amendment, cannot be here today and she sends her apologies. I have signed her amendment 61, as has Lord Holmes, and we very much appreciate his comments in the previous group as well.

It's a very modest amendment requiring the FCA to report annually on financial inclusion to Parliament and its committees on the grounds that what gets measured gets managed. The consumer duty does not fill the gap as it does not apply to those whom financial institutions decide not to serve. The financial inclusion strategy is widely regarded as insufficient and doesn't include measurable targets. Now how else is Parliament meant to scrutinize the FCA's progress on financial inclusion if we don't follow the thrust of these amendments this amendment. Lord McKinley's amendment on probate I think frankly should be a complete no-brainer for the government to support.

I know he'll make that case strongly. That's uh and I also am in support of Baroness Neville-Rolfe's amendment 94 on financial education though I think as I've said to her in the past I'm a bit cautious about trusting something as important as financial education to the FCA but the underlying thrust that we need to be making huge headway on financial education is I think absolutely correct.

03:16:38 - 03:16:50

Speaker 20

Post after clause 3 insert the new clause as printed on the marshalled list.

03:16:50 - 03:21:37

The Lord Holmes

My Lords it's a pleasure to speak in this group and indeed to follow Baroness Kramer. There is a thread which unites all of the amendments in this group. They all make sense. They're all clear and the government should accept them. I want to talk about the amendments in my name and the ones I've signed but before I get to that point I want to very much echo the points that Lady Kramer made around child trust funds and indeed to follow her in acknowledging the great work that Lord Blunkett and Lord Young of Cookham in particular have done for years on this issue.

Lord Blunkett's words are particularly pertinent to this point. He was the minister in charge at the time in a Labour government and he has said on numerous occasions in this house along the lines of this was never the intention. If this was never intended government policy from a Labour government we now have a Labour government wouldn't this be the ideal opportunity to stop this being government policy and to make the changes as set out in this amendment and if not to make the changes along the lines of these words for the department to come up with some words of their own to make this change because a review isn't the solution. We know the issues. They've been well set out over years.

We have the opportunity with this bill to resolve this issue and to make such a difference not just to the 80,000 or so individuals who have those trust funds but to the hundreds of thousands of family members and friends and communities who are adversely affected by this current position adversely affected for want of government action which could make this change and through that make such a difference. On to my amendments around financial inclusion and the role of the various regulators. The regulators have a lot of obligations put upon them but I would suggest just this. How can we have in the United Kingdom a financial services regulator which doesn't have clear responsibility for financial inclusion and a clear obligation to report on what they have done to advance it specifying in detail all of those affected because financial inclusion and indeed the adverse financial exclusion isn't just a matter of the same people having the same effects and suffering the same exclusion.

It is specific to older people, to disabled people, to those in certain socio-economic groups, to those in certain geographies, and specific solutions and a strategy which incorporates all of that and puts it into an operational roadmap is required if we're going to get behind solving for financial inclusion. We have a financial stability board. I would argue that you can't have financial stability if you don't have effective, sustainable financial inclusion. It may not be measured because the adverse impacts are often in other government departments and other parts of the state, but be in no doubt when you gross all of the costs and the implications and the consequences of financial exclusion up, that is financial instability, not just for the individuals, but for the communities, for our country. The financial regulators should take a role, a leading role amongst others to get after this pernicious problem of financial exclusion because it's dogged our society for decades, blighted lives, impacted individuals and had an impact when all put together on what the government constantly and rightly go on about in terms of growth.

Well, if you want growth, financially including individuals right across this country would be a fine place to start.

03:21:37 - 03:29:27

Lord McKinley of Richborough

My Lords, I have only put forward one amendment to this entire bill and that is amendment 70. Now I spoke at great length in committee stage and highlighted then as I will highlight now, I'm a chartered accountant and chartered tax advisor and conducted probate work over many years. Now, let's just lay out a little the framework of where we've got to in the provision of IHT 423, because it won't be familiar with everybody in this house, I'm sure. The IHT 423 arrangement was first rolled out in 2003 and only applied to banks and building societies or cash-based liquid accounts. And it allowed for the breaking of the catch-22 situation which executors find themselves in when they're administering estate.

Because an estate is often in two parts. There are two parts called the free estate, which is your cash and liquid investments. And the tax, the IHT on that has to be paid six months after the end of the month of death. Now, there's also the other part of the estate is property and often unquoted securities where there is a non-liquid market and an instalment basis can apply over 10 years. But given that the new rate of IHT interest chargeable on unpaid tax following Rachel Reeves' first budget is now seven or 4% above base, so it's currently 7.75%.

No matter if it's free estate payable immediately or a part of the estate that can be paid over 10 years, given the 7.75% interest rate, which is truly penal, most executors would like to pay the tax as soon as they possibly can and certainly by the due date of six months after the date of death.

In the old days, where IHT423 procedure, which is a means by which a financial institution before probate can release funds, I think it was working because there were very few estates that were actually hit by IHT. But because of fiscal drag, and I will admit as much as anybody else, a lot of that fiscal drag occurred over our government, where the levels of free amounts for IHT have remained unchanged since 2009, has meant that more and more estates are dragged into the IHT pot. And so the IHT423 arrangement of getting funds out of an estate before probate can be obtained, as I say, you're in a catch-22 of chasing one's tail of having to pay the tax before probate can be obtained, the IHT423 procedure was widened to investment, any types of investment. And that was negotiated by HMRC in 2024, so fairly recently. I think in recognition of the huge number of estates that are now facing IHT.

Now if you think the situation is fairly tough today, it gets a lot more tough from April next year, when pension schemes get dragged into the scope of inheritance tax. So I very much fear as a practitioner how HMRC are going to cope with this, because frankly my experience is they're not coping terribly well with the system they have to deal with today. So to then land a lot more work on a system, I'd love to hear the minister's ideas about how that would work in the future. But the IHT423 procedure is going to become more and more important. Now it is a discretion exercisable by financial institutions as to whether they want to take part or not.

My amendment seeks to make it non-discretionary and rather statutory that if a financial institution wants to do business in the UK and registered under the FCA, they must allow IHT423 and for IHT to be paid at the appropriate time. Now this came to light in my own personal experience recently in dealing with my father's estate, who sadly for me has suffered an IHT bill. So the estate has a liability to discharge and it has an asset in an investment with M&G PLC, one of the biggest investment houses in the UK. It has 380 billion pounds under management and it has 5 million customers, which means there will be a lot of executors within those customers and a lot of executor estates within those customers. For reasons unknown and known only to them, M&G have decided they do not want to take part in the IHT423 scheme, one of the biggest investment houses in the country.

So my amendment is very simple. It's good for the Treasury because money will come in at the right time. It's good for executors, and this section is about financial inclusion. Executors are often family members and they're facing a pretty tough time. To then be told by institutions, no, we're not going to assist you at this very tough time, in my view is not good enough and the government can put that right.

Now I know at committee stage I spoke in similar terms and I know the noble lord the minister was fairly new to his place then and perhaps the scope of what I was asking for had perhaps not quite landed.

But he's had some months to consider this. I know one of the issues that he raised then was a worry about risk. Now HMRC negotiated back in 2003 the IHT423 scheme with institutions on cash-based accounts because the only place the money can go is from that institution to HMRC's bank account. And I certainly hope that that is not a bank account of risk and I'm sure it is not. And HMRC negotiated with the other institutions in 2024 to expand the ability to use the IHT423 scheme to a far wider range of investments.

They negotiated it themselves and they do not feel this is an area of risk. So I certainly hope that the minister may be able to give me some assurance that this is an area that well quite frankly will need to be looked at because of the expansion of inheritance tax into pensions next year when executors are going to struggle even more to extract funds to pay the tax at the right time to avoid those rather horrendous rates of 7.75% IHT which I'm sorry to say given the state of the economy and the bond market given that it's 4% above base it could go that little bit higher. Reading in the media today there is an expectation that interest rates will go up by two quarter points within the next six months. So you could have executors facing 8.25% interest rates which isn't just high it's truly damaging. So I'll leave the minister with a bit more to think about and I very much look forward to his response.

Thank you.

03:29:27 - 03:33:18

Ros Rosalind Altmann

My Lords I fully echo the comments that the noble Lord McKinley has just made having had personal experience sadly myself of just what he is describing. And amendment 70 would be at least some relief to those executors who cannot access funds who see the interest racking up while probate delays or other delays are occurring to the estate beyond their control. But I do also urge the noble Lord the minister to take back to his department that if inheritance tax is indeed levied on unused pension funds from next April there isn't even the allowance in the new system for a 10-year delay as there is with property. So it won't just be interest that racks up there will be penalties and so on as well. There is a real problem in that regard.

And indeed there is a real issue with the costs involved in probate for those executors who cannot have the money released because some institutions have decided that even though the money is going to be paid directly to HMRC to satisfy inheritance tax they still won't release the money and of course they will still be charging fees on the funds that they retain. So I do hope that the noble Lord the minister will take seriously the ideas in amendment 70. And I would also very strongly like to support and I would have added my name had I been more on the ball to amendment 60 which was so nobly moved by the noble lady Baroness Kramer in terms of the child trust fund issue where parents and families of children who cannot make the decision for themselves but those parents or carers who are managing the money and have done since birth in some cases for these children are being told that they must go through an enormously lengthy legal process just to be able to take a bit of money.

And as soon as they reached that age, they were unable to access the funds. These child trust funds started in 2005, so this problem has already been going on since 2023 for many of those who have been unable to get money from the child trust fund. And indeed, there was a consultation in 2022 which recommended that at least a small payment scheme should be introduced, but in the meantime, nothing has happened. And as the noble lady Baroness Kramer said, the costs of going to court and obtaining an order to be able to take money out of the trust fund could use up most or even in some cases all of the money in the fund. So there is an issue which does need to be addressed.

Amendment 60 is a way of helping these families, and I hope that the noble lord the minister will take this back to the department and come back with some positive news on this issue.

03:33:18 - 03:37:12

Speaker 78

My lords, I have sympathy for all the amendments in this group, but I'm going to focus my comments on amendment 11 in the name of the noble Baroness Kramer, to which I've added my name. As we've heard, this would require the FCA to establish a framework assessing banks and building societies' provision of affordable credit. Credit is a lifeline for families who are facing financial hardship and debt. According to a recent report, 60% of the clients of Christians Against Poverty, an organisation that's very active in my diocese, find they have to borrow money to pay for household essentials and bills, not borrowing for luxuries. When credit's unavailable, they're left to delay essential spending and go without meeting their most basic needs, and sometimes spending a little now saves you spending a lot more down the line.

I'm extremely grateful for the remarks we've already heard from the noble Lord Holmes of Richmond. Credit inaccessibility has real consequences for those who are struggling the most. And according to the same organisation, CAP, 47% of UK adults who currently have debt they're struggling to manage have been unable to access their preferred credit option for the past two years. This kind of financial exclusion means that we're locking vulnerable families into a cycle of poverty. We're depriving them of the tools they need to climb their way out.

Unable to look beyond the pressing need to put dinner on the table, it's those with the most desperate need who are forced to sacrifice the most to get by. Left with limited choices, they're the ones most likely to enter riskier credit deals and to pay the greatest poverty premium. And I've worked as a vicar in parishes where loans were enforced by men with baseball bats. Since committee stage, we've had the report of the Commons Treasury Committee on the government's financial inclusion strategy. The report highlights the need for proportionate firm-level financial inclusion metrics focused on the largest providers and markets where exclusion causes the greatest harm, and that specifically includes affordable credit.

The report proposes that metrics should be designed to identify whether progress is being delivered consistently across firms and sectors.

So what's proposed in this amendment, my Lords, clearly has much wider parliamentary backing than simply the noble lady and myself. Indeed, several major lenders have indicated to the Treasury Committee that they'd be entirely happy to provide financial inclusion data as part of a statutory system. So, my Lords, this bill and this amendment to it provide a sensible and a practical solution to implement what the Treasury Committee itself is advocating. Importantly, it places responsibility for access to affordable credit on the lender. It introduces a clear framework by which banks and building societies can be assessed on how effectively they're meeting the financial needs of underserved communities.

The new requirement for this framework to be kept constantly under review would ensure that those requirements remain open to scrutiny and are adaptable to the ever-changing patterns of financial exclusion, patterns that will only become more dynamic and entrenched as society rapidly changes. This amendment is an important step toward ensuring that our financial services meet the needs and uphold the dignity of real people, rather than expecting individuals to adapt to systems that often exclude them from full participation in economic and community life. The only people who won't like it are the dodgy lenders who harass my people in my diocese. I pray that we will support this amendment.

03:37:12 - 03:41:00

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, I'm grateful to all noble Lords who've contributed to this interesting debate, and I much look forward to the Minister's response, particularly on child trust funds for those who lack capacity. I agree with my noble friend Lord McKinley that we have a problem with HMRC administration of estates, with the risk of more chaos in prospect as IHT on pensions arrives. We should be finding a way to improve the system, for example, by widening the application of IHT 423. I will focus on amendment 94 on financial education. This is an issue on which I have campaigned for a long time.

It reflects my belief that financial capability is an essential life skill, and indeed that it is essential if we are to have financial inclusion for those struggling to make ends meet. I won't repeat the strong case I made in committee on the 8th of July, Hansard column 149. Our revised amendment would require the FCA to take reasonable steps to work with the Money and Pensions Service, the Secretary of State for Education, relevant education bodies, providers of teacher training and professional development, and industry bodies to support the effective delivery of financial education, and it is good that I now have the support of the noble lady, Lady Kramer. My Lords, the financial decisions that people are expected to make are increasingly complex. Young people as well as adults of all ages need a working understanding of concepts such as compound interest, inflation, pensions, savings, taxation, borrowing, and so on.

My noble friend Lord Agnew was on the BBC this weekend and has written about how 10 million adults in Britain right now have the numeracy of a primary school child. Yet we are asking young people to make extremely significant financial decisions, sometimes, for example, taking on tens of thousands of pounds of student debt without necessarily giving them the grounding in financial concepts that would allow them to understand these decisions.

I was very grateful to the minister for helping to arrange a meeting with the Money and Pensions Service, and I recognize the good work they're doing. However, one concern I took away from that meeting was that a considerable amount of financial guidance focuses on moments when an individual has reached a major financial event, so taking out a mortgage, dealing with a divorce, approaching retirement, or experiencing financial difficulty. I believe we need to be more ambitious. Our objective should be to build financial capability throughout the population before people reach these moments, and indeed to encourage sound investment and savings for a rainy day. This is what this amendment is intended to encourage.

It does not seek to make the FCA responsible for teaching financial education in schools. It seeks to establish a practical framework for cooperation between the regulator, MAPS, government, education providers, and industry. I've discussed these issues positively with the minister, and I hope he can tell the House more about what the government are doing to build financial capability, particularly among young people and through schools, and how the FCA might contribute to the cause. I'd also be grateful if he could explain how noble Lords and others with an interest in this important area can engage with work on financial education in schools and elsewhere as it develops. The prize is considerable: a population that is more financially resilient and better equipped to make decisions for itself.

That's good for consumers, good for investment, good for financial services, and good for growth.

03:41:00 - 03:57:06

David Pitt

I'm grateful to the noble Lords for raising these issues on financial inclusion. And I think the government does fully recognize the importance of improving access to appropriate and affordable financial services, particularly those for people on low incomes and in vulnerable circumstances, and improving the financial education of the nation. And therefore, in terms of the amendments, I think we would support the intention behind many of them, but are not persuaded that putting this into primary legislation is necessarily the right way forward. But I hope I can describe what the government is doing, including actions that we have taken as a result of some of the issues that have been raised to us by, have been raised at committee. But look, let me start with the amendment 11.

So this is measuring what banks and building societies are doing in terms of affordable credit, and then setting standards for them where if they set up something like a CDFI, that would count against what they were required to do. And I'd like just to take a step back because there is quite a lot that is already happening by the government, important stuff articulately described to us by Lord Holmes. So for example, if I start just with small businesses, the Mansion House in July, the Chancellor announced the expansion of the British Business Bank's growth guarantee scheme, doubling SME lending to 3.5 billion. I share the noble Baroness's focus on community development finance institutions. Through the Community Finance Taskforce, we've brought together banks, community finance advisors, and the government.

At Mansion House, over 10 million of philanthropic funding from JP Morgan Chase and support from BNY was announced for the sector. The taskforce will publish a roadmap early next year to support the ambition of unlocking a further billion pounds of SME lending over five years. The British Business Bank's Community Enable Funding program committed nearly 120 million pounds of funding with a second phase intending to grow to 500 million pounds. We're improving competition and supply through the enhancement of the commercial credit data sharing to strengthen bank referral arrangements.

On personal lending, the government's financial inclusion strategy includes measures to strengthen community finance and partnerships between mainstream lenders and CDFIs. We're supporting practical interventions including a small sum credit pilot, which Monzo has already announced as the first participant, and a transformation fund for credit unions alongside the common bond reforms which are even part of this bill to make sure that credit unions can do their job better. I am quite taken by what it is that the Right Reverend Bishop of Manchester has said about the centrality of being able to provide this sort of fund, and I would even note that the only business person to receive a Nobel Peace Prize is someone who did that by finding a way of lending money at unsubsidized, I should say, to poor people in Bangladesh. This is important, but there is a lot that is already going on, and I wonder whether supporting that might be something that we would want to think about. This amendment would require the FCA to act against firms who do not meet minimum lending standards.

But don't we want customers and businesses to access appropriate credit and balance that with risks of over-indebtedness? The Noble Baroness Kramer is right when she says what gets measured gets managed, but equally we need to be worried that we don't create a system where people are hitting the target and missing the point. And for these reasons, I'm not sure that the government is persuaded that these amendments are the right way of improving behavior or pricing, and would ask the Noble Baroness to withdraw the amendments, but please to support the other actions that are being taken by the government to address this critical question. Amendments 57 and 61 concern how the regulators report on financial inclusion. Amendment 57 seeks to require the FCA and PRA to publish annual reports on how they have advanced financial inclusion.

61 to require the FCA to publish an annual report on financial inclusion detailing how it's had regard to financial inclusion in exercising its functions and assess the impact of its activities on financial inclusion outcomes. These amendments would impose new statutory reporting duties that risk duplicating existing arrangements for how the FCA reports about the state of financial inclusion and its impact on it. Amendment 57 would also place reporting duties on the PRA, whose statutory duty is prudential regulation, creating uncertainty about what the PRA's remit is and what it would be expected to report against. Financial inclusion is a shared responsibility across government, regulators, and particularly the industry, rather than a matter for regulators alone. My Lords, we know that exclusion is driven by a broad range of complex and overlapping factors, including wider economic conditions, technological change, behavioral drivers.

Accountability for improving financial inclusion should therefore remain a collective effort rather than being placed on one or two institutions whose powers extend only part to only part of the challenge.

The government has set out this collective approach through its financial inclusion strategy. It continues to work closely with regulators and firms and consumer groups to improve access to financial services and support those who are underserved. The strategy is subject to a public review next year to assess the progress made through this collective effort and where further work is needed. And I would look forward to members of this House's input when that is published. On amendment 60, this is about the child trust funds and has been spoken about passionately and very articulately by a number of people including Baroness Altmann and Lord Holmes.

Decisions about who may act on behalf of persons lacking capacity are governed at bottom by the Mental Capacity Act 2005 and determined by the courts. The Act provides a well-established framework including oversight by the Court of Protection to ensure that access to and management of a vulnerable person's account takes place with where appropriate safeguards are in place and in that person's best interest. This reflects the very real need to safeguard and protect vulnerable people. This amendment seeks an alternative route of access outside that framework. But we think it's really difficult to ask the FCA to put that court protection aside and the FCA do not even have the power to do so.

Legislating to permit that would essentially require giving the FCA the power to alter the effect of primary legislation through their rules via a Henry VIII power but without the same degree of oversight. And I don't think that can be the right way forward. But look, I think Baroness Kramer mentioned this, that on the 8th of July the Ministry of Justice convened a round table on this issue of matured child trust funds, not least because of debates in your Lordship's House and young adults who lack the mental capacity. That meeting was attended by Baroness Kramer as well as by other stakeholders and by the previous Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Rachel Blake. Baroness Levitt spoke directly with members, with Baroness Kramer and with members of the public and made clear that any solution to this issue would likely need to be delivered through primary legislation.

Ultimately, this is not an issue that can be resolved through the FCA rules or changes to tax legislation. Primary legislation would be required. But we do take this matter very seriously. I have raised this with the Ministry of Justice. I'd like to reassure Baroness Kramer that they are exploring how the government can best facilitate access for parents and carers to child trust funds on behalf of their children.

I don't have a solution but I think we are trying. And in the meantime, the FCA is conducting a review into provider practices under child trust fund accounts including whether there are barriers to vulnerable young adults accessing their money. And we welcome this review but as I have said, as of now the underlying issue lies in the Mental Capacity Act and it's not possible for the FCA to substitute or override primary legislation in that Act. Addressing amendment 70 next, this would require the FCA to ensure that financial institutions that are registered or regulated by the FCA facilitate the payment of inheritance tax by executors before probate is obtained through direct payment schemes. And I would thank the noble Lord McKinley for raising this question.

My Lords, I'm I'm sorry to hear of the difficulties that he had experienced. The duty of administering an estate often arise at one of the most difficult times in a person's life. And I understand the noble Lord's desire to ear to ease that process for people who face similar circumstances to himself. Look, in the past, the noble Lord has himself acknowledged that the direct payment scheme generally works well in its existing voluntary form and that it's rare to come across a case where an institution refuses a request to pay tax due. And following our debate on this amendment, we did ask HMRC officials to contact the company where the money was lodged to understand more generally their policy on the direct payment scheme.

They confirmed that they do in fact facilitate direct payments to HMRC normally through investment holdings. But there were however some type of investment products which they did not consider suitable for release directly to HMRC before grant of probate. These included certain types of bond products. That's as far as we've got on this. But I would put it to the noble Lord that his amendment proposes to mandate the use of direct payment scheme by FCA regulated institutions.

However, our experience and I think his experience is that most financial institutions most of the time do facilitate direct payment schemes. There may be certain types of financial product where releasing funds to HMRC before the grant of probate does present a particular legal and technical complexity. The advantage of a voluntary scheme but perhaps one that we can write to people who are not following well. But the advantage of a voluntary scheme is that institutions can assess the level of risk involved and make payment only if they are satisfied that they are releasing those funds correctly. And the amendment as drafted would not allow for that to happen.

The noble Lord has also suggested that this change be made through FCA rules. However, changes to primary legislation may also be required to make this change. FCA rules do not generally displace the private law framework and making this change through FCA rules could leave financial institutions on an uncertain legal footing. But we have taken most seriously the points that he raised. They are good points and this may still be an area that needs to be addressed.

But I think not by the amendment that we're looking at here. Turning then to amendment 94 which is very close to my heart. I am grateful to the Baroness Lady Neville-Rolfe for continuing to raise this important issue of financial education. As you know, I teach finance at Cambridge University and so have a shared interest with her at all sorts of levels on how we do this. But I'm not sure that placing new statutory duties on the FCA to to support financial education is the right way to achieve our aims here.

The FCA already does carry out substantial work to promote financial capability and helping customers navigate their financial lives is one of their priorities in the 2025 to 30 plan.

The noble Baroness is right to highlight that the FCA cannot do this work in isolation. It works closely with bodies such as the Money and Pensions Service, and she, as she said, has met up with the Money and Pensions Service to discuss exactly this, and I hope that she mentioned the subject of compound interest to them when she did. There is also to be a consultation from the Department of Education that I believe is coming out this month, and I'm hoping that perhaps members of the Lords, including myself and Baroness Neville-Rolfe, might have an early meeting with the minister to discuss our concerns here. We've also been approached, I hope I can say this, at least for an introductory call from the Financial Times, who do do lots of work in this area at all, and I would be happy to recruit any other members of this House who were particularly interested in this and to continue my engagement with the noble Baroness on this topic. But I don't think a legislative solution is needed and would ask the noble Baroness to withdraw her amendment.

Thank you very much.

03:57:06 - 03:57:37

Susan Kramer

My Lords, I'm not going to go and re-argue the points, and I want to thank everybody who's participated in this debate. But on amendment 11, I would just say to the minister that having cited a number of American banks, I suggest he go and talk to them, and he will tell them that this amendment both works and is vital. But, and because of that, and because of the significance of growth for the future of the UK economy and growth in every postcode, I do intend to press amendment 11.

03:57:37 - 03:57:59

David Pitt

The question is that amendment 11 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will alert the House once voting is open.

Voting is now open. Clear the bar.

04:05:54 - 04:07:35

Speaker 91

My Lords. My Lords, the question is that amendment 11 be agreed to.

04:07:37 - 04:12:02

David Pitt

My Lords, the contents 69, not contents 171, so the not contents have it. My Lords, before I move to the next amendment, I should just inform the House that there was a small discrepancy in the numbers announced for the second division, which didn't affect the result, but the result should have been as follows: contents 246, not contents 165. That was division two on amendment 10. After clause 4, amendment 12, Lord Pitt-Watson.

Two amendments in your name. My Lords, I beg to move the amendments in my name in this group. Before turning to the detail, I should briefly note that almost all the amendments in this group were previously tabled by the government at committee stage, where in light of concerns expressed about the way in which they were tabled, the government agreed to bring them back at report stage. It contains a modest number of minor and technical amendments, which are not unusual for a bill of this size. They don't alter the underlying policy of the bill.

Their purpose is to ensure the bill is relevant and relevant provision in FISMA operate clearly and consistently. I will try and be quite quick therefore in going through them all so as not to tire your lordships. First turning to amendments 18, 21, 23, 25, minor technical corrections to schedule 2 of the bill, which taken with clause 13 abolishes the payment systems regulator and gives broadly equivalent functions to the FCA. Amendment 18 removes a duplicative provision from the new section 131Z9. Amendment 21 corrects a cross-reference so that the bill refers to the correct FCA payment system.

Amendments 23 to 25 ensure that references to the chair of the PSR, which should be obsolete after the PSR is abolished, are deleted in the correct places. I hope this is all making sense, but if Lords have a particular thing they want to talk about, please do indicate. For amendment 73 to 75, once again they are minor and technical amendments. Turning to amendment 12, which relates to clause 4, it makes a consequential amendment. The new paragraph 1B of schedule 17 to the FISMA inserted by clause 4 of the bill permits any function of the financial ombudsman to be performed by any member of staff.

As regards amendment 76 to 79, they relate to clause 33. As the noble Lords will be aware, the bill introduces a more flexible senior management approvals framework, including the ability for firms to apply for conditional or time-limited approval in specified circumstances. These amendments are technical amendments that ensure that the framework operates consistently and in line with the original policy intent. As regards amendment 81, finally, when the bill before us gains royal assent, there will already exist a number of overseas recognition regimes created under existing powers in FISMA 2023 to restate regimes inherited from the EU, and the amendment enables the Treasury to make consolidating provision which would restate the existing regimes within the new overseas recognition regime framework.

This is essentially a tidying up exercise. So in summary, this group of government amendments makes technical corrections to ensure the bill works as intended. I hope noble lords will join me in supporting these amendments.

Amendment proposed, clause 4, page 3, line 34, to insert the words printed on the marshalled list.

04:12:02 - 04:12:34

Jonny Oates

I thank the noble lord the minister for bringing forward these already tabled amendments assembled this evening in group 4 and declare my interests as a director of South North Street Capital. These amendments, as the minister has explained, remove duplication, they correct drafting, they make the provisions of the bill work better together and they make the bill intelligible, internally consistent and ultimately more workable in practice and therefore we support them.

04:12:34 - 04:12:47

David Pitt

Question is that amendment 12 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. In clause 7, amendment 13, Lord Sharkey.

04:12:47 - 04:21:05

John Sharkey

My lords, I will speak to my amendments 13, 14, 15 and 99. Clauses 7 and 8 of the bill propose radical reform of the relationship between the FOS and the FCA and of the method of determining complaints to the FOS. These proposals will have a critical effect on consumer protection. They would turn the independent FOS into a subset of the FCA and make successful complaints harder to progress or achieve. Parliament designed and brought the FOS regime into being to provide accessible, no-cost procedures for quickly determining complaints.

At its heart is the fair and reasonable test. This test is abolished by the bill, despite having been explicitly confirmed in July last year in the memorandum of understanding signed by the FOS and the FCA. This bill would reduce access to free and impartial redress, would introduce additional bureaucracy and costs and ultimately risk damaging confidence in the financial services industry. The government has not supplied any meaningful hard evidence that might justify or at least explain convincingly the rationale for these reforms. It says only that, I quote, "The government's review found that in a small but significant number of cases, FOS has acted as a quasi-regulator," close quotes.

It does not say how small or how significant these cases are, or how significance was defined and gauged. And it has completely ignored repeated requests from these benches to provide a clear description of the problem being addressed and of the necessity for such radical changes. Three months ago, at second reading, I asked for hard evidence. I got none, not even an acknowledgement of the request. I asked again on the first day of committee and again with no result.

And I asked again on the last day of committee. This time, the then minister, who is in his seat, apologized for not writing in answer to my questions and promised to get back to me as soon as we have information to hand again, and I quote. And I've heard nothing since. This lack of response displays an almost contemptuous approach to parliamentary scrutiny. And it also makes it obvious that the government is unclear about the existence of any significant problem in the way the FOS and the FCA operate under their current MOU.

And I'm grateful to Sarah Pritchard, FCA Deputy CEO, for her attempts to persuade the government to answer our questions in a meaningful way.

"Following our meeting," she continues, "we have formally reiterated this request to HM Treasury and highlighted the importance of ensuring Parliament has access to the evidence and analysis underpinning these proposals." HMT appears to be with these things even-handedly, they've ignored her as well. Her letter went on to say that one area where legislative change is being proposed concerns the interaction between our rules and the Ombudsman's fair and reasonable test. The aim is to provide greater consistency and alignment between regulatory requirements and complaint outcomes, while preserving the Ombudsman's case discretion to consider the wider circumstances of the case. This sounds like the arrangements currently in place under the MOU.

But in practice, the bill goes much further. It effectively reduces the scope of this discretion and reduces the FOS to a subset of the FCA, with the FCA rulebook being the determinator. It's very hard to see that this preserves the independence of the FOS, and of course independence is desirable. In evidence given to the Treasury Select Committee on July the 15th, Nikhil Rathi said that from the FCA's perspective, and I quote, "We want an independent Financial Ombudsman Service, that is a really important safeguard for your consumers." Both Mr. Rathi and Mr. Alder, the FCA chair, in the same TSC session went on to express concern about the interaction between the FCA's interpretation of rules and FOS's decision-making.

Mr. Rathi said, "With the system where people can try to instrumentalize it, so that everything they disagree with can get pushed up to us to try to deal with in 30 days because it's deemed ambiguous, you will gum up the system." His chair emphasized the point of this saying, "To Nikhil's point, if we get this wrong, the system will be gummed up." "As a result, the main objectives of those changes in legislation will not be met." "It's very important that we get this right." "And this seems to me," and still Mr. Alder saying, "this seems to me the very real dangers of a requirement for the FCA to respond within 30 days to a referral from the FOS."

In the same session, Sarah Pritchard said, "We have been clear that we want the FOS to deliver quickly for consumers." "We do not want to turn into a backdoor appeal mechanism." "Where there are important matters around the intention of our rules, absolutely we should be there to clarify." "We already take referrals from the FOS to do that." The July 2025 MOU between the FOS and the FCA is in operations now.

It seems clear that this blueprint has taken into account current and anticipated problems. But it differs radically from the FOS proposals in clauses 7 and 8, including on the absolutely critical criterion for FOS making a determination. If the MOU is working, and if it is working as it says with a fair and reasonable test at its heart, why then is the government proposing to abolish that test and the FOS's effective independence? My amendments 13 and 14 address these issues. Amendment 13 removes clause 7 with its referral method and four other pages of prescriptive micromanagement, including a kind of Henry VIII power on page 6.

Amendment 14 restores the fair and reasonable test as agreed in the MOU.

Consumer groups have noticed the proposed changes in the bill and many are very strongly opposed. For example, Martin Lewis, a money saving expert, strongly supports the removal of clause 7 and the replacement of clause 8 with the current fair and reasonable test. In all, 12 leading consumer organisations have written to us asking for support for amendments 13, 14 and 15. I won't read out the whole list, but they have all agreed a statement that says, at a time when the cost of living crisis is pushing household budgets to breaking point, the government should not be altering the fairness test and introducing new bureaucratic hurdles in the very system that provides redress for financial loss. Finally, my amendment 15 would create a breathing space to enable a proper evidence-based review to take place and report to Parliament on its findings and recommendations.

Amendment 15 sets out the proposed independent review process and scope and timelines. It requires the review to take place not before the second anniversary of the signing of the MOU and then to report within 12 months. Amendment 99 simply puts the commencement of clauses 7 and 8 on hold until the review's report has been laid before Parliament.

Amendment proposed, leave out clause 7.

04:21:05 - 04:24:37

Bryn Davies

I congratulate the noble Lord Sharkey on making a very powerful case for keeping the existing system under which the FOS operates. I think the problem we have here, expressed in the considerable representations we've received from consumer groups, is a lack of clarity about what the problem is that this is meant to address. And coupled with the clear concerns about the loss of the fair and reasonable requirement. I think that's the central point. We have a system that works.

We have a system in which there is a degree of consumer confidence, and the reason for interfering in that system is not clear to the bodies representing consumers. So I think the government does, my government does have more to do in order to justify these changes. Now, interestingly, I had some discussions with the previous minister, who's now sharing the same bench as me, and one of the points that came up in discussion is that it's actually quite difficult for the government to point to cases where they expect a different result following this change to what was happening before. It would be unreasonable for the government to pick on individual cases and say those people really shouldn't have had that finding from the ombudsman. But that is at the heart of what is being proposed here.

Now, I have had, before my noble friend the minister's elevation, I discussed this issue with him at length, and he assured me at the time that the impact on the consumer would not be material, that the way the legislation is worded, in particular what counts as the rules that the FCA has to interpret for the FOS, would have to interpret for the FOS, embraces the concept of fair and reasonable.

And so it would certainly help me a great deal and allay the concerns that I have if those assurances could be given to the House, and also to say that, he probably can't express it in these terms, but to say these changes are contingent and they will be reviewed and judged on the effect they have, and that would allay my continued concern about what's been proposed here.

04:24:37 - 04:27:58

Sharon Bowles

My Lords, I rise briefly to support my noble friend Lord Sharkey's amendment. Some years ago, I gave a speech on ethics in finance in connection with the International Robin Cosgrove Prize, where I outlined what I called my eggshell strategy. The premise was simple: we must force firms, boards, and employees to think, not merely to comply. Worry is a warning system, and the question is never how close to the line can we sail, but how fair have we been? And the core issue here is exactly that: rule compliance is not a substitute for fundamental fairness.

And the FCA's consumer duty expresses the same principle, but that does not mean that the FCA should become the sole repository of judging fairness. We have always had the courts as the backup, and the Financial Ombudsman Service more recently because courts are financially inaccessible for most consumers. So the proposal to tie the ombudsman strictly to FCA rule compliance assumes that if a firm follows the letter of a rule, it has acted fairly. The motor finance saga demonstrated the opposite: for years, firms relied on nuances in the FCA's disclosure rules to argue that discretionary commission arrangements were permissible. But these were hidden discretionary commissions, and any reasonable person looking at those structures from a consumer's perspective could see that variable, hidden commissions with costs levied on the consumer were inherently unfair.

It's honesty and transparency that are always the best policy, irrespective of rule nuances. They are your defense. Firms must think like a consumer when considering what is fair, not ask their compliance officers how close to the line can they sail. If we shackle the ombudsman to technical rule compliance, we destroy its core statutory purpose: to provide an independent common-sense check where formal regulations have fallen short or lagged behind market practice. Equally, imposing a rigid 10-year absolute longstop creates dangerous incentives.

In long-tail products or hidden commission structures, unfairness may be actively concealed. A 10-year cutoff rewards firms that manage to keep material facts hidden for a decade, while shutting the door on consumers who only discover the harm years later.

Under section 32 of the Limitation Act, the courts do not allow time to run when material facts have been concealed. Why should the Financial Ombudsman be forced to do so? A regime that rewards concealment is not a regime that promotes fairness.

04:27:58 - 04:29:18

Jonny Oates

My Lords, we take a different view on the Financial Ombudsman Service. Our position is that the present FOS model now requires more fundamental reform. We propose that the Treasury should publish draft legislation to replace the FOS with a new Financial Adjudication Service, alongside a dedicated Financial Services Chamber within the First-tier Tribunal. We accept the need for consumers and SMEs to have access to redress which is fast, expert, and affordable. Our concern is that the FOS has evolved well beyond a simple dispute resolution function.

Its decisions can shape market behaviour and influence how the FCA rules are understood, yet without the same accountability as a regulator or the legal certainty created by binding precedent. At the heart of that concern is the fair and reasonable test. A firm may comply with the law, FCA rules, and its contractual obligations, but still face uncertainty about whether the Ombudsman will take a different view. We simply cannot have this situation if we want a regulatory landscape which is conducive to business confidence. We therefore understand the position taken by the noble Lord, Lord Sharkey, but we start from a different premise.

Our position has not changed. We want a redress system which remains accessible to consumers, but which is also more predictable and more legally certain and more consistent.

04:29:18 - 04:31:49

David Pitt

My Lords, could I start with an apology to Lord Sharkey if I have failed to respond to him appropriately, but perhaps I can in the remarks that I now make. And to Lord Davies, that I am very clear that treating customers fairly is one of the business principles of the FCA and therefore is one of the criteria by which a complaint will be able to be made to the FOS. Because, look, the FOS plays a vital role in the redress framework for financial services, ensuring that consumers have confidence that where there is a complaint about a financial services provider, there's an independent, impartial service which can resolve that complaint and has got the ability to put things right, and that role will not be changing as a result of these reforms. However, the framework within which the FOS operates is not as consistent as it needs to be, and that's not good for consumers or for financial services firms. Now, that inconsistency is not surprising because the FOS fair and reasonable was determined before the consumer duty came to the FCA.

And the government's review of the FOS found there's a small but possible minority of cases where that inconsistency in the framework could cause FOS determinations to have the effect of quasi-regulations by setting standards which may not be in line with the FCA regulations. To be clear, these are all the FCA regulations, and if you'd been with me three months ago, you would have seen me writing letters to my predecessor confirming that that was indeed the case. As far as the House of Lords is concerned, of course, the Financial Services Regulation Committee has stated in its report, Growing Pains, that the FOS actions can have regulatory impact by creating precedents that the FCA firms require to follow, again, quasi-regulator.

So that's the background to why it is that we're doing this. So let me look at clause 8 and amendment 14.

04:31:49 - 04:33:33

Susan Kramer

I'm sorry to interrupt the Minister, but back to the key issue that I think he rather glossed over, which is the evidence base for making these changes. We have been told it would be coming. It has not come. Consistently, we've been told letters are being developed, the letters have not arrived. And I asked for one specific letter and was told that indeed, of course, it could be provided, which is to say in the motor, in the car finance scandal, which was basically exposed through the FOS, while the FCA stood to the side, what would be different now in the consequences of the complaint, what would happen to the complaints that would be different?

Because this seems to be the issue that lies at the heart of this. The FOS exposed a very major scandal. As the Minister will know, car finance is the second largest financial market in the UK. Nine out of ten people who buy a car finance that car. So the redress scheme that the FCA's been forced to put into place is currently seven billion pounds.

And if I understand correctly from listening to him and to his various advisors, in the future, the FCA approach to the problem would have reigned, this scandal would never have been exposed, there would never have been redress. But I'm waiting for the letter that is supposed to tell me if that's exactly correct.

04:33:33 - 04:41:26

David Pitt

I'll try and address that question. Look, both the FCA and the FOS are independent. It's not for the government to decide what it was that was a correct or a false decision to be made. All that the government is saying is that the criteria by which the FOS adjudicates should be similar to the rules by which practitioners are trying to exercise the way in which they are working. I think that is just good common sense.

Now, there have been, and I believe there will be a publication coming out shortly from the industry of examples where the industry may think that the FOS treated them in a way that was inconsistent with the FCA. It is not for me to judge whether that took place or not. It's for the FOS to judge whether or not they think that took place or not. And I think that may be the reason that I'm proving so frustrating in being able to write back properly to the noble Baroness. To go back, though, to amendment 14, this removes clause 8 from the bill and adds a list of factors the FOS must take into account when determining what is fair and reasonable in all the circumstances.

At committee, the noble Lord and others raised concerns that clause 8 might remove the ability of the FOS to consider fairness in the round. This is not the case. The FOS will still make its determination based on all the circumstances of the case.

The amendments to FISMA made by clause 8 do not abolish the fair and reasonable test, that is the final adjudication that will be made by the FOS, and because of the principles of business treating customers fairly is one of the criteria by which a complaint could be made. But where the relevant FCA rules do apply, the government considers that FOS determinations should be consistent with those rules. Consumers and firms should be able to understand and rely on the FCA rules as providing the standards against which conduct is going to be assessed. Let me be very clear, this extends to all the FCA's rules, and I think this addresses Lord Davies's question. That includes the principles for business, it includes the consumer duty, it includes the code of conduct, and these are designed to secure high standards of conduct and consumer protection.

If a firm fails to meet its obligations under these broad principles-based rules, then the FOS may conclude that it should pay redress to the complainant, taking into account this failure and any other relevant information, such as the impact the failure had on the complainant. There is no requirement for a firm to have breached one of the more specific detailed rules in the FCA's rulebook. The consumer duty was introduced by the FCA to improve consumer protection across all financial services, and the government is confident that it sets a high standard of care that firms should provide to their customers. It includes a requirement to act to deliver good outcomes, an expectation that firms will act in good faith, avoid causing foreseeable harm, and enable and support retail customers to pursue their financial objectives. The consumer duty, as I pointed out, did not exist when the FOS was established and the fair and reasonable test was introduced.

It's right that the framework governing the FOS should be updated to reflect this landmark piece of consumer protection regulation. Without clarification, we're left with a situation where two different bodies are independently making assessments of what standards firms need to meet, and that does not seem like a sensible approach. The reforms to the fair and reasonable test strengthen consistency across the framework, they do not weaken consumer protection. Turning to amendment 13, which would remove clause 7 from the bill. In committee, the noble Lord suggested that the referral mechanism would in effect subordinate the FOS to the FCA.

This is not the case. The FOS will remain completely independent and responsible for resolving complaints between consumers and financial services firms. The FCA will not determine individual complaints, it will not investigate disputes, it will not direct the outcome of cases. These functions will remain entirely with the FOS. What the amendments to FISMA made by clause 7 do is ensure that where the FOS considers there to be an ambiguity within the FCA rules, the FCA must provide an opinion requested by the FOS.

It is entirely consistent with its statutory role as a rule-maker. The FOS will then use that opinion, applying it to the individual circumstances of the case, to make a determination. Lastly, some noble Lords expressed concerns about the potential for referrals to lead to delays, including with reference to the FCA's comment about the potential operational load. The government recognizes the importance of maintaining the FOS's quick and informal model, but the government anticipates only a very small number of cases are going to be referred to the FCA.

The vast majority will be resolved without the need for referral. To avoid delays, the timeline for the FCA to respond will be set out in secondary legislation. The FCA and the FOS are already gaining practical experience of operating such a mechanism by trialling arrangements through their memorandum of understanding. The experience gained through this trial has provided valuable lessons for the implementation of the legislative mechanisms. The government will continue to work closely with the FOS and the FCA ahead of these changes taking effect, preparing them to ensure that the new system works effectively.

The memorandum of understanding, by the way, is creating a very small number of referrals from the FOS to the FCA. As regards amendments 15 and 99, these provide for an independent person to carry out a review of the operation of the memorandum of understanding between the FOS and the FCA. The combined effect of these amendments would mean that changes delivered through the bill would not take effect until at least 2028. That means two more years of ongoing misalignment. The government conducted a review of the FOS in spring 2025, with the conclusions announced by the then Chancellor July 2025.

It then took a 12-week consultation period on the government's proposals. A further review would duplicate the government's review and introduce unnecessary delays in delivering these important reforms and is therefore not necessary. My Lords, the bill makes important reforms to the redress framework to increase clarity and consistency while preserving the strengths and the independence of the FOS. And I therefore ask the noble Lord to withdraw amendments 13, 14, 15, and 99.

04:41:26 - 04:43:25

John Sharkey

My Lords, I want to thank the minister and all the others who have spoken for the way in which they've covered the issue. But it is notable, I think, that a lack of evidence for the proposed reform proposals still exists. We still have not seen what it is that is wrong with the current system. We've not seen any hard data or soft data that suggests that there is a problem with the operation of the FOS. And it is the case as well that of course the definition of the determinator contained in the memorandum of understanding actually contains direct references to the FCA rules and their book.

And that is the expanded definition that is currently being worked on by the FOS and the FCA. But it's still the case that I can't see a problem, a compelling problem that's being addressed by the radical changes that the government seems bent on making. I would like, if possible, at some stage to continue the conversation about the evidence because I do feel that we're somewhat wide apart and perhaps unnecessarily when in fact we seem on the one hand to have a system that works very well and on the other hand we have a desire for fairly radical reform. I'm not sure that plays out happily together, but I'd be happy to discuss that if the minister is willing to do that. And having said that, particularly my remarks about the evidence, I would like to withdraw amendment 13.

04:43:25 - 04:43:32

Speaker 20

Is it your Lordship's pleasure that amendment 13 be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn.

04:43:32 - 04:43:38

John Sharkey

I would like to test the opinion of the House on amendment 14.

04:43:38 - 04:47:33

Speaker 20

The question is that amendment 14 be agreed to. As many as of that opinion will say content. And to the contrary not content.

I'll put the question again, my Lords. The question is that amendment 14 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. And to the contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division.

I will advise the House when voting is open. Voting is open, clear the bar. The question is that amendment 14 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.

The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents, my Lords, my Lords, order. The not contents to the left by the bar.

04:52:11 - 04:52:15

Speaker 96

That amendment 14 be agreed to.

04:52:15 - 04:53:48

Speaker 98

8 minutes.

04:53:48 - 04:54:19

Speaker 20

My Lords, there have voted contents 59, not contents 144, so the not contents have it. 15, Lord Starkey. Not moved. Not moved.

04:54:19 - 04:54:36

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I think this is a reasonable time now to adjourn for dinner break business. I beg to move that further consideration on report be now adjourned until 9 minutes past 8.

04:54:36 - 04:55:23

Speaker 20

That further consideration on report now be adjourned. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it, and we'll take a moment for the House to rearrange itself before we move to the statement. The rearrangement needed, my Lords, repeat of a statement made in the House of Commons today, local government reorganisation, Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

04:55:23 - 05:00:16

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, this government is committed to delivering good growth across the country and power in every postcode, with places able to set their own ambitions and integrate services to meet people's needs.

Achieving that requires a fundamental rewiring of the state, giving power held in Whitehall back to the people and the places where they live and work. As we set out in the cabinet statement on rewiring the state, effective and sustainable local government is the vital foundation of our devolution ambitions. As we are now more determined than ever to devolve power closer to the people we represent, it is only right that as a new Secretary of State, I make sure that everything we do is working towards that plan to change Britain without delay. The Prime Minister told the House last week he was prepared to look at local government reorganisation, and he has asked me as his communities secretary to do that. Throughout this process, the government has listened to representations from members of this house, councils and the public, and I want to be clear how critical, given how important they are to our democracy and the services they provide for local people.

But there will always be a wide range of divergent views, which means achieving perfect consensus will never be possible. I understand that feelings run high and people naturally have strong views, but in different directions. In that context, in the light of legal advice, I want to satisfy myself firstly that the right process is in place, that it is robust and of course complies with the law. And secondly, I want to fully test whether our proposals for local government reorganisation meet the priorities of a new administration and a new Prime Minister and any additional considerations. With those two considerations in mind, I have decided to withdraw the decisions made in March this year for Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk, and where relevant their neighbouring unitary authorities.

The government's legal representatives have notified the court of this step. I have also decided to conduct a full review of the local government reorganisation programme, including the decisions that were announced in July of this year for a further 14 areas and those two areas where decisions have not yet been taken, and I ask that reorganisation activity be paused. These 14 areas are Derbyshire, Devon, East Sussex, Gloucestershire, Hertfordshire, Kent, Lancashire, Leicestershire, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire, Oxfordshire, Staffordshire, Warwickshire and Worcestershire, and where relevant their neighbouring unitaries. I do not take this lightly. I recognise the huge amount of work that has already gone into progressing reorganisation in each of these areas, and I am very grateful for it.

I know that many members of the house and many council leaders outside the house will have lots of questions about what this means for them and their communities, and I will try to address these as best I can today. Firstly, we are working across government on rewiring the state following the cabinet statement. We recognise that effective and sustainable local government is fundamental to our ambitions for a devolved country which works better for and with communities. We will consider this issue as part of this wider approach. Secondly, as an immediate step, I've asked the Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth to undertake a rapid review of the current local government reorganisation programme, including the position in the four areas where we've withdrawn and the further 14 areas that we are reviewing and pausing alongside the two remaining areas.

New councils for East and West Surrey will be unaffected because they are already established in law and have had their first elections and are on track to go live in April 2027. Thirdly, I want to be clear in terms of what this means for elections scheduled next May. Elections will go ahead in May 2027 on existing council boundaries.

Finally, my department will provide support to council leaders, officers and members representing impacted areas, and the Minister for Local Government has written to leaders and copied members of this House. I want to ensure that all those of you who represent these areas feel included in considering their future and will update the House at the earliest opportunity. My ministerial team and senior civil servants from the department are ready to discuss and to work with you. My team will proactively reach out to discuss the implications locally in detail. My department remains committed to working in partnership with local government, both in this immediate period and in the longer term, and I commend this statement to the House.

05:00:16 - 05:05:05

Baroness O'Neill

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, the Minister, for repeating this quite significant statement. The government has suddenly paused the reorganization plans it started for local government. My Lords, this is astounding. Proposals to merge councils in Norfolk, Suffolk, Hampshire and Essex have been withdrawn. The 14 areas that formed the third tranche of the program have also been put on hold.

Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and West Sussex, who were awaiting the government's decision, now face further uncertainty. Uncertainty for residents, councillors and council officers. We're told this new review follows updated legal advice, but also to align the plans for local government with new government priorities. The only area which is unaffected is Surrey, where the two new unitary authorities have already been established. This has come too late for them.

It was only in June that we were told that this government remains fully committed to the timetable already set out. That their local government reorganization program was a once-in-a-generation opportunity to ensure that councils genuinely represent the communities they serve today and stand the test of time. Time has hardly passed and the program is paused. Let us not forget local elections were postponed. Now elections in May 27 will go ahead on existing council boundaries.

So much time, not to mention money, spent drawing together proposals, conducting and responding to consultations nationally and locally, staffing, governance, finance and service delivery about to be restructured. Without, by the way, any guarantee that this would end up saving taxpayers any money or improve services for local people. Are we now being told it may have all been for nothing because the government did not think through the legal implications, or because the new Prime Minister simply doesn't fancy it? What now is the estimated total cost of this review, both to national government as well as to the authorities affected? Do those making those decisions have any idea how damaging the uncertainty and inconsistency is to many councils, including staff recruitment and staff morale?

Councils are losing large numbers of staff who want certainty on their future and for the same reason cannot recruit replacements. Your Lordships' House spent eight days in committee and two days in report stage on the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, and the noble Baroness, the Minister, said at second reading that would drive the biggest transfer of power out of Whitehall to our regions and communities in a generation.

However, we now have the Rewiring the State White Paper to look forward to, which will focus on devolution and local government. Can the noble Baroness the Minister please clarify if this new bill is to deliver devolution, was the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act not devolution at all? As we said at the time, this is not community empowerment. It shifted power away from the local to the regional and to Whitehall, from locally elected councillors to mayors, from democracy rooted in local identities to new managerial technocratic boundaries. Will this new bill reverse that direction of travel?

My Lords, we are hearing the same platitudes from this government to disguise its lack of long-term vision. So can the noble Baroness the Minister tell us what exactly are the priorities of the new Prime Minister? How will they differ? And what certainty can she give to local councils receiving this news? I look forward to her response.

05:05:05 - 05:10:04

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

My Lords, I too thank the noble Baroness the Minister for repeating the statement. And my Lords, across England, there will be thousands of councillors and council officers who have worked for months, some for years, in seeking to deliver an effective solution to the government's top-down reorganisation dictate. They will have devoted scarce resources in funding as well as in precious time. Today, they will be despairing. All their careful planning has, with a stroke of a ministerial pen, been confined to the waste bin.

Now, the principle of devolution is the right one. Unfortunately, the government has conflated devolution with local government reorganisation, and that has resulted in this sorry mess. There are any number of questions that the noble Baroness the Minister must answer, given that in July, the Minister gave an assurance in this chamber that a decision on the final reorganisation plans for the remaining councils would be made in October. So I am confident that there will be many specific questions about individual councils, so I will restrict my questions to general principles. So the first one is this: given that the government decision has been made following legal advice, can the noble Baroness the Minister publish that advice and provide a summary for us in her response tonight?

Will the Minister tell the House when those councils with agreed plans were informed? Some councils had already developed financial planning on the basis of agreed reorganisation. What support will the government provide for those councils now facing severe financial pressure? This announcement today has left councils and their residents in limbo.

The statement makes it clear that elections for districts will take place next year. Now that indicates a longer timeframe for reorganization than a speedy review. Asking people to become councillors for a non-specific period is difficult, and equally, encouraging voter enthusiasm will be more challenging. What are they voting for? How long will it last?

Local democracy has been the real loser in all this, with elections cancelled and democratic terms of office extended on a whim. Now that new parameters for this were determined by the government for reorganization, and the process defied, I beg your pardon, the importance and relevance of local communities. For example, new councils were told they had to be at least 300,000 in population, with a maximum around 500,000, though of course one of the Surrey new councils is 700,000. That was stated when many existing unitary metropolitan councils are smaller than that. Calderdale, for instance, in my own West Yorkshire, has a population of just over 200,000.

Many of the councils in the Manchester mayoral authority are around 300,000 or less. And that was one of the reasons why communities lost out in this top-down reorganization. This is a thorough and embarrassing dog's breakfast for the government. It all stemmed from the flawed notion that the financial crisis facing county councils could be resolved by changing the seats round the table, by going for reorganization and ignoring the historic community ties around which many councils were created. So the government has much to do to put the local back into local government, and I do look forward to a good, thorough explanation from the minister.

05:10:04 - 05:19:11

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords. I have to do with the frontbenchers first, Lord Fuller. Thank you though for your enthusiasm. I'm very grateful to both noble baronesses for their comments, and believe me, I do understand the frustration that's been expressed. The noble Baroness O'Neill asked about updated legal advice and government priorities, and spoke about the fact that in June we were saying we were fully committed to the timetable.

I think it's really important that we don't conflate the timetable and the commitment to LGR. We have, as I said, first of all, there has been additional legal advice, but also we have a new Prime Minister and a new Secretary of State. I think it's only right that in the view of both of those, we take a step back and have a look at these issues. It wouldn't be right not to do so. The noble Baroness O'Neill spoke about elections being postponed and time and money that's been spent, and about improving services and financial gain.

The vision from the government is still that local government reorganization will go ahead. We're not stepping back from that in any way whatsoever, and my right honorable friend in the House of Commons stated that quite specifically and many times this afternoon, that our intention is not to row back from local government reorganization.

We do see that as a way of improving services, of generating the growth we all want to see, and of making much more use, efficient use of the finances that go into local government. And the work that's gone in already, which the noble lady mentioned, is certainly not wasted because we're not scrapping the LGR process. We're taking a step back to have a look at it, but we are not scrapping the process. The noble lady asked about the cost of the review and the uncertainty. Well, I think the uncertainty that's caused by legal uncertainty is just not tenable.

This program that we're setting in place will last probably for at least 50 years and maybe longer, the last local government reorganization did. And it's very important that that's built on a firm foundation of legal certainty, otherwise our colleagues not just in local government, but their partners in business and in the third sector will be facing that uncertainty going way forward into the future. So we need to make sure that we have the certainty we need. And I still stick by what I said when we were debating the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill. This is the biggest transfer of power out of Whitehall.

That's why it's never going to be straightforward or easy to do. It's a dramatic change to the way the state is wired, and the Prime Minister wants to see that happen. We do want to get powers and funding out of Whitehall. I think there wasn't much disagreement to that in the chamber when we debated the English Devolution Bill. And to do that, we need a firm foundation of local government to build on.

The other question the noble lady asked me was around the Prime Minister's commitment and the long-term vision. I don't think in terms of promoting devolution, you could have a stronger advocate than our Prime Minister. He has lived and breathed devolution and the devolution agenda during the time when he was the mayor of Manchester. He genuinely believes in the transfer of power to every postcode in the country, and I think he's set out very clearly that he does have a long-term vision for this country to do just that. The noble Baroness Pinnock spoke about top-down reorganization.

Well, it absolutely was not that. I've sat through many meetings with our local government colleagues. They came forward with their own proposals. They didn't always agree in each area, and it was very difficult sometimes to work through the different options that they came forward with. And it will continue to be so as they can put forward once again their views, some of them very strongly held as she's aware, as we go through this review process.

Certainly the process is not confined to the waste bin as she put it. It is very firmly still on the table and there to be worked on, and I look forward to working with our colleagues in local government as we go forward. The noble Baroness Pinnock spoke about the assurance that decisions for those areas where we hadn't taken decisions already would be made in October. Well, that's we are going to work as quickly as we possibly can on this review. My right honorable colleague, the Secretary of State, referred many times this afternoon to the fact that she wants this review to proceed at pace.

This is not a kicking into the long grass or anything like it. She wants that to move forward as quickly as possible so we can provide the certainty that local government needs. The noble Baroness Pinnock mentioned the legal advice, and of course we considered legal advice provided as part of the judicial review process, and the decision to withdraw the four decisions reflects that legal advice.

It is a long-standing principle, as she will know only too well, that government doesn't publish or comment on legal advice. The legal powers for local government reorganization remain valid. There are no court findings against the government, and as I said, it's a long-standing principle that government doesn't comment on or publish legal advice. We want to be able to review the decisions to reassure, so that the Secretary of State can reassure herself and the Prime Minister that they're the right ones, and respecting the court process means the way to do this is withdraw those and consider the program afresh. The noble Baroness Lady Pinnock also asked about what provision, when were councils informed, sorry, was her next question.

They were told today because we didn't, we hadn't, this was being, the legal advice was being considered over the weekend. The Secretary of State informed the councils involved today of the fact that the, well, the 14 that were going to be paused and reviewed and the four that have been withdrawn from the court process. So that's the answer to that question. In terms of financial provision, the Secretary of State received many questions on this this afternoon. It is of course the case that the government were putting forward some 63 million pounds to help councils through the transition phase of local government, and she will consider the issues around funding as we go forward through the review process.

In terms of elections for next year, the elections will be held on the usual boundary elections, so if your council was up for electing by thirds next year, that will happen, and if it's elections of the full council, that will happen. I think from talking to councils in my local area, they are all very keen on the process of LGR going forward, and I think they will look forward to this. They know that the process is coming. They know the process is paused and not stopped, so they will continue to work with their local parties and their local councils as they have done so well in the past. I think in terms of the importance and relevance of council size, we have always said that council sizes were not fixed, and having gone through all of the applications myself, it was very clear to see that you can't make a fixed point in terms of size.

You have to look at each area individually. Geographies are different, demographics are different, and it's very important that each area is considered separately according to its needs. And on the issue around historic communities and all of the other issues, this pause will give the opportunity for people to, who had those strong views, to put them forward again in the review process. I'm sure they'll do that. Nobody's backward in coming forward in this process.

I look forward to hearing from many of them. But I do think the right thing to do at the moment is to take this short pause and go over particularly in respect of, as I said, the legal advice and the Prime Minister's and Secretary of State's wish to review this, so that when we go forward, we will go forward with the certainty that everybody in local government needs.

05:19:11 - 05:20:11

Charles John Fuller

Firstly on cancellation of local government elections, and now the embarrassment of this one from a hapless MHCLG. Back in April, when your Lordships debated local government reorganization, I characterized the proposals for Norfolk as a cut and shut job that would shame Arthur Daley, that would create England's poorest council in East Norfolk, and which would throw up in the air the authorities responsible for homelessness, housing, economic growth, and planning.

No wonder we challenged it. Today, the leader of my council tells me the government will refund our legal costs, well into six figures. Can the minister tell us quite how much money the government will be refunding to councils across the country to reimburse them for challenging decisions which we now conclude were unlawful and should never have been taken in the first place?

05:20:11 - 05:21:55

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I think the strength of the noble Lord Fuller's representations on this matter shows the differing opinions that we have seen throughout this process. There are different views taken, they are very strongly held on all sides. In relation to his question, and it's important that we continue to take those into account, and we will be continuing to look at those as we go through the review process. First of all, and I should have made more emphasis on this when I was speaking earlier, I do recognize the amount of work that councils have already put in to preparing for reorganization. I did say that this work isn't wasted and it won't be, but I appreciate that comes with a cost and that financial commitments may have been made, and we will look at this as part of the review.

In terms of, I've already spoken about the transition costs. The overall costs of reorganization are, of course, to be taken into account. But of course, we also know that reorganization can save money. There was a ninety million pound saving in North Yorkshire and seventy-five million in Buckinghamshire since their unitaries were established. And I know that the noble Lady Scott saved money when she reorganized Wiltshire into a unitary.

So there are also, there are legal costs associated. LGR is often contested in the courts. It's a right and proper part of our democratic system that important issues can be challenged in the court system. Government engages legal advisers to defend those decisions whenever challenges are brought, and that does bring costs with it. But the questions are so significant and the implications are so long-lasting that the extent of legal costs should be viewed in that context.

And of course, legal costs will be determined in the usual way.

05:21:55 - 05:23:04

Speaker 106

My Lords, can I start by acknowledging the very hard work and real work that the, my noble friend the minister has been putting into this work over the last couple of years? And also to those councillors who've been arguing for these changes in their boroughs and counties over the last few months. Now, I speak as someone who's entirely supportive of these proposals. I think they do offer a much better way forward for local and regional government, as someone who's benefited from a similar model in London for many years. But there have been some mixed messages today, which I would ask my noble friend the minister to help with.

Firstly, both she and the Secretary of State have talked about this being a rapid review, but then I also understand that officers are being told to stand down all work, and elections obviously have been postponed, which doesn't suggest rapidity in this review. So can my noble friend the minister throw any light on this, and can she reassure us that devolution will happen in this Parliament and that new unitary authorities will be up and running by the time of the next general election?

05:23:04 - 05:24:14

Jane Sharon Taylor

I thank my noble friend for his, his support for the overall program. We are asking councils to pause work on progressing local government reorganization. It will be a short pause, and this means that councils should cease work on implementing previous decisions. But of course, there are shared projects that it will be useful in any potential reorganization, and of course they can be continued.

We want this process to be done with good local engagement and we will listen very carefully to the views that councils provide. Officials of course will be, as they have been throughout this process, will proactively engage with places and support them throughout the period. Ongoing work, for example, could include improving data quality and data sharing, mapping services, finances, workforce, assets and contracts, identifying key risks and dependencies, undertaking ICT and digital discovery work and continued engagement with partners and residents. So we want, we recognize the need to provide certainty as quickly as possible so areas have clarity over their future and we will work at pace on the review and we will report back to Parliament at the earliest opportunity.

05:24:14 - 05:25:32

Andrew Lansley

My Lords, I draw the House's attention to my registered interest as chair of the Cambridgeshire Development Forum. I think the House understands that the government will not publish its legal advice, but whether these decisions are the result of specific legal advice about the nature of the decisions that were made, or indeed changes of mind on the part of the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State, wouldn't it be better to start a rapid review by restating or amending the criteria against which the decisions are to be made and wouldn't that make the decisions ultimately less prone to legal challenge? Can I also ask, where Cambridgeshire is concerned specifically, we were told it would be a decision in October, is that still the case? And we were also told that that would lead to elections on new boundaries in May, presumably that is not to be the case. And finally, really in support of spatial, strategic spatial planning, which I know the Minister and I and others support, can the Minister say that the lack of progress on unitaries does not mean that we cannot have progress on establishing strategic planning boards?

05:25:32 - 05:27:13

Jane Sharon Taylor

I thank the noble Lord Lansley. In terms of criteria, that will be looked at as part of this review process, I think. So I think it's important that we take account of the legal advice. We're not going to publish it, but that we take account of it and look at what the impact is on the future program. It would be unwise not to do that.

In terms of the issues around Cambridge, you asked me about elections. Well, elections will, let me start with the October decision-making. We had said to colleagues in Cambridge and Peterborough and indeed in West Sussex, where decisions hadn't been taken, that we would endeavor to get decisions in October. Those both of those areas will go into the review process, so those decisions will be announced alongside the other areas that are being reviewed now. So I hope that won't give too much of a further delay for people in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and West Sussex.

But I know that noble Lords will be aware that there is the very important part of this process is the statutory instruments that have to go through both Houses. So we were on a very tight timetable for all of this anyway. So it's not likely that elections will be able to go ahead to the shadow authorities as planned in 2027. That's why we've said that elections will go ahead but on the old boundaries. So I hope that answers his questions.

Oh sorry, and the noble Lord Lansley asked me about spatial planning. I think the devolution work can continue to look at planning and how that's going to work through in the devolution process.

05:27:13 - 05:28:38

James Arbuthnot

My Lords, if the, from the Labour benches then we're going to go to the Labour benches and the Conservative benches. My Lords, if the legal concerns were serious enough to halt the program today, suddenly, rapid action, can the Minister tell the House whether any similar concerns had been raised previously by officials, local authorities or external counsel?

And will the Minister place a letter in the library of a chronology of the key decisions that led to the suspension of the program so that Parliament can understand how this arose? And being a little bit more specific, I think the noble Lord Lansley was on the same page as me in this. But I'm not asking the Minister to disclose privileged legal advice, but can she tell the House which aspect of the process is now considered potentially unlawful: the criteria, the consultation, the decision-making, or the implementation? How can Parliament scrutinize ministerial decision-making if ministers are unwilling to explain the nature of a legal defect that has caused such extensive disruption and a waste of public money?

05:28:38 - 05:29:25

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, in terms of the chronology of the decision-making, I'll have a look at that and talk to colleagues about it. But obviously, clearly, as I've said very categorically, we will not be releasing the legal advice. But I appreciate that there is a chronology that takes account of the legal advice but doesn't divulge what it actually is. In terms of which aspects of the program, I fear that would be part of the privileged advice. So I think what we're going to do is we're going to look at issues, any issues that have been raised as part of the program of review.

And we will be clear and transparent about what we're doing in the review, so I hope that will come out as part of the review process.

05:29:25 - 05:30:00

Speaker 104

My Lords, my noble friend has talked about this on some occasions, but can she assure the House that there won't be a sort of, as it were, a wholesale return to the drawing table? In other words, that all that work won't be wasted. I suppose by that what I mean is, does the government's commitment to devolution remain as strong as it has been for the past two years? Because many of us feel that power has drained from municipalities to Whitehall for probably the last fifty years, and we'd like some of it to start to go back to municipal centers.

05:30:00 - 05:31:13

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I can reassure my noble friend that there is no drawing back on the program of devolution. It's a very key part of not just government policy, but of the government's vision for the country going forward. For too long, we've had a very centralized model in this country, and many of the people in this room will have been council leaders and will have been at the sticky end of that model. We don't want the begging bowl culture where local councils have to go to Westminster for almost anything they want, whether it's a small power to do something or whether it's funding for a very important local project. So there is no rowing back from that at all.

And I'm sure that members will have heard enough, noble Lords will have heard enough from our new Prime Minister to know that his commitment to devolution has been strengthened by the years that he spent as Mayor of Manchester, not weakened or diminished in any way. So I know that he is keen that we get that power and funding out to every postcode in this country so our country can achieve the potential that we know it has, right across in every corner of the United Kingdom.

05:31:13 - 05:32:12

Speaker 107

Can I probe the Minister a little on a couple of things she said, because I think they were a tiny bit inconsistent?

The written statement says that there will be a full review. The minister said it would be a rapid review. She also said in one of her answers that outside organisations would get the opportunity to contribute, which implies that there will be a public consultation. And if it is to be a rapid review, then I don't understand why we're having elections next year. And can she give some indication to those council candidates and successful councillors the term of office that they're seeking to be elected to?

Because if it is a rapid review, arguably the decisions will be taken before those elections have even taken place, and you've got to let people have some level of certainty. So I think there's a lot of inconsistency in what the government set out, and I think it needs to clarify these sooner rather than later.

05:32:12 - 05:33:11

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I do think it's possible to have both a rapid and a full review. It does mean doing the work carefully but as quickly as possible. And I think in order to create the certainty that everybody wants to see across local government, they've been working on this for a long time, they want to see the decision-making as quickly as possible. The rapid review will look at the program as a whole and work on the rewiring the state delivery plan must include a question about the role of local government in the devolved country. Review will be in this context.

It will be led by the Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth. It will engage with MPs and all councils impacted. An extended delay is in no one's interest. And it's right that ministers listen to concerns and that the new administration undertakes this review to make sure that local government reorganisation aligns with its priorities and specifically our work on rewiring the state.

05:33:11 - 05:34:03

Speaker 50

I address as a former Norfolk MP, and just judging by my mailbox this evening, there is real anger and consternation across Norfolk. A huge amount of work and professional resources have been put into this. For example, King's Lynn and West Norfolk Borough Council and Breckland District Council have spent a vast amount of money on preparing for the new unitary, money that could have been spent on vital services down the drain. And furthermore, my Lords, dozens of Norfolk County Councillors took a decision not to stand last May because they trusted the government. They stood down, and many of those seats were taken by paper candidates put up by Reform UK.

Morale is rock bottom. The Chief Executive of Norfolk County Council, Tom McCabe, has resigned. The government has multiple questions to answer, and it should be ashamed of what it's done.

05:34:03 - 05:34:55

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I hope I've already made clear that I don't think any of the money that's been spent is wasted. The work will go ahead on local government reorganisation and on devolution. So the work that's been done, and you know, when I did the engagement meetings on this, it was really interesting to me to hear stories from around the country of councils that had literally not spoken to each other for 20 years or more, who had sat down and worked together on this. Now, we've really appreciated that working together. It's been a really good way of bringing councils and councillors together to work on this jointly.

And we have no intention of rowing back on it. So that money is not wasted. The money's not down the drain. The money that's been spent and the work that's been done will be used in the future program.

05:34:55 - 05:35:28

Speaker 111

My Lords, I want to say how much I support the government's policy in this area. It's a brave policy, and one I think the opposition parties have behaved shockingly badly about over the last few months. Today's a difficult day, absolutely, I feel it difficult as well. But I think it needs to be said that this government has support for the prospect of proper devolution. How can proper devolution take place without some local government reform?

05:35:26 - 05:36:29

Speaker 110

The two obviously go together. It's nonsense and just not right to say that there's no relationship between the, there has to be a relationship between the two. My issue, and I want to ask my noble friend about the cities, cities that lost out so badly last local government reorganization, so they've become much too small, not natural in the slightest way, and incapable of managing to get the necessary funding to be able to build even more necessary houses and of course to generate growth. Is it still the government's policy, is it still the government's policy to make sure that those cities, and include my own, Leicester, have that extra space, are expanded in the way that's intended?

05:36:29 - 05:38:03

Jane Sharon Taylor

I thank my noble friend. I don't think it's helpful for me to comment on individual areas. However, he's right to point to the focus on growth. There were three main focuses that we looked at, were the potential for growth and making sure we could achieve that across the country. Obviously, they're very key services that local government delivers and making sure that those are protected and supported going forward and that it will be possible to deliver those key services to vulnerable people.

And of course, the issue that the noble Baroness Pinnock mentioned, which is community identity. Wherever we looked at those issues, there were different opinions in different areas. But that's why we stuck very firmly to the criteria we'd set ourselves. The growth criteria came in the first criteria. We looked at all of the proposals that were before us in respect of that.

But we mustn't make any bones about the fact that we do need to change things to get the growth we want to see. That involves both making sure that local government is enabled to drive that growth forward in the way it's organized and that we have the devolution so that people who are taking the decisions around growth and the economy in their local areas as well as on key services are in that local area and have some skin in the game in relation to the decisions that are being taken.

05:38:03 - 05:38:18

Speaker 108

Can I ask the noble minister, when the elections do take place next year, what period will the people serve that are elected? Will it be one year, two years, three years, four years?

05:38:18 - 05:38:32

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, elections that take place next year, if the program works through as we anticipate it will, the shadow elections will be in 28.

05:38:32 - 05:39:17

Speaker 109

I suspect one of the main issues as to why there's been a delay now is that not enough attention has been given to the financial viability of these new authorities. And in my own area of Hampshire, I think that's certainly so. I dispute the fact that opposition parties have not been cooperative in trying to help the reorganization. But I think there's an issue about the viability of the authorities going forward. So is it a question of viability that's the problem, or is it more likely that the government is reluctant to put the resources in that are needed to make them viable?

05:39:17 - 05:40:26

Jane Sharon Taylor

To answer the last question first, we've already made a significant financial commitment to make sure that this program works properly.

In terms of financial viability, a great deal of attention was paid to that issue as we went through the process. We will need to make sure that we continue to have that focus on financial viability. It's incredibly important that these councils are financially sustainable going forward. And it is our belief, and I already stated that the councils that we've seen that have already gone into unitaries make very significant savings. So that financial sustainability is absolutely key to what we're doing on this.

But I would come back to the original points that I made. We absolutely, we're doing something which is a, you know, a generational change here to local government. We must make sure that we give the certainty going forward to local government that we all want to see and that we create a local government framework across the country that can actually deliver the power and funding that we need in every postcode to see the opportunity realized in every postcode in this country.

05:40:26 - 05:40:42

John McFall

Time for this business. Further consideration on report of the Financial Services and Markets Bill, Lord Pitt-Watson.

05:40:42 - 05:40:47

David Pitt

My Lords, I beg to move that this bill be now further considered on report.

05:40:47 - 05:41:00

Speaker 112

Order. Question is that this bill be now further considered on report. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.

Amendment number 16, Baroness Hay.

05:41:00 - 05:47:51

Kate Hoey

My Lords, this amendment follows on from the amendment tabled in committee by the noble Lord Hunt of Wirral. And I'm really bringing it to draw the House's attention to a growing and deeply concerning problem in Northern Ireland's insurance market, where the market is shrinking in insurer capacity, it's becoming less competitive, and it's leaving consumers and businesses facing higher premiums and fewer choices. And it's an issue that the British Insurance Brokers' Association has been highlighting for some time and has been getting in touch with noble peers and members in the other place. The evidence suggests, my Lords, that the root cause is claims inflation driven by various factors that are within the power of government and regulators to address. Now let me be clear to noble Lords and especially to the noble Lord the Minister, I'm not calling for a new immediate regulatory regime without proper consultation.

Rather the amendment would provide the Treasury with a targeted enabling power, subject to consultation and affirmative parliamentary approval, to extend FCA regulation of claims management companies to Northern Ireland. They are, of course, currently regulated in Great Britain by the FCA. I'd like to give just a short backdrop to this amendment, which paints a very stark picture. In home insurance, brokers in Northern Ireland now have access to just six markets, down from 11 in 2020. In motor insurance, the number of available providers has fallen from more than 15 to just eight over the same period.

And as competition is reduced, premiums in Northern Ireland have continued to rise even as prices in Great Britain have begun to stabilize or fall. In terms of motor insurance, Northern Ireland consumers are being affected by premiums increasing year in, year out, and they're already paying much higher premiums compared to the rest of the UK. And of course, as noble Lords will know, the access to public transport in the extensive rural areas is very limited in Northern Ireland. So there is no regulation of claims management companies in Northern Ireland. And this has led to many of them exercising poorer practices, which in turn leads to inflated claims settlements and therefore higher premiums for consumers and businesses.

So the prevalence of CMCs has become more apparent. The number of CMCs has grown rapidly. We estimate there are probably twice the number operating than a year ago, suggesting that it's a very lucrative enterprise. Adverts appear everywhere, pointing people to them if they have a car accident, etc. And of course, in GB, since the regulation came in, CMCs operating have halved since 2019.

Another reason for the growth of CMCs is their attraction of higher personal injury awards in Northern Ireland, which makes it a lot more lucrative for them. The difference between Northern Ireland and England and Wales is striking. Whiplash, for example, in England and Wales, a compensation of around 1,500 would be paid. In Northern Ireland, it could be up to 15,000 with psychological claims added on. Those higher awards obviously feed directly into higher insurance premiums for consumers and businesses alike.

And in some cases, we have clear conflicts of interest. Vehicle hire, legal services, and CMCs are brought together under the same commercial structure, creating clear conflicts of interest, with some CMCs operating various companies under different names but with the same overall ownership. Ultimately, these additional costs are paid by consumers through higher premiums. Now, my Lords, as we all know, insurance is not a luxury, it's essential, it must be accessible and affordable for all. And it's very unfair that we in Northern Ireland are paying a higher premium compared to those in Great Britain.

And the consequences of no regulation at all of CMCs are becoming increasingly clear. Major insurers have already withdrawn from the entire Northern Ireland, from Northern Ireland, and new entrants are refusing to come into it. Some insurers are refusing to insure young drivers at any cost, and some insurers are refusing to cover certain postcodes where there's a high prevalence of CMCs and perhaps, perhaps say a more perceived evidence of collusion. One insurer has reportedly reduced its Northern Ireland motor business by 75%, and customers of a major broker have seen their premiums rise by 45% between 2023 and 2026. And all of this, of course, could lead to market failure.

Northern Ireland consumers deserve access to affordable, fair, and competitive insurance, and to achieve that, we will need coordinated action from the Northern Ireland Executive, the Treasury, Westminster, regulators, and industry alike. And we have to work together to make this happen. Everyone agrees there is a problem, and now we have to fix it. And the issue has become quite a political hot potato in Northern Ireland because the Department of Justice, the Department of Finance, the Department of the Economy, and the Department for Infrastructure have all been examining it. The FCA are aware of the problem but powerless to protect consumers.

The Treasury is aware of the problem. MPs and MLAs continue to hear from frustrated constituents. And yet, despite all this, and I think probably in agreement between, certainly between the opposition front bench, I hope, and the Liberal Democrat front bench, despite all this, nothing actually has changed and there is no regulation. While responsibilities pass from one department, committee, regulator, and jurisdiction to another, premiums remain higher, choice remains limited, and opportunities are denied to people who can least afford it. The solution does not require years of further review or consultation, it requires action.

Primary legislation is needed, and this bill provides the perfect vehicle to deliver it. The amendment is practical, it's proportionate, and it's targeted. It seeks to address what may become a market failure and creates the conditions for a more competitive, affordable, and accessible insurance market in Northern Ireland. This is not a party political amendment. It is simply an amendment which seeks to ensure fairness in Northern Ireland for consumers and to stop the rip-off merchants operating in this field.

I hope that the government will engage constructively with this amendment and work with us before it goes back to the other place so that we can get the regulation needed. It was interesting that this bill, the actual title of the bill, is all about regulation. This is the one place in the United Kingdom that we do not have that regulation. We have the ability to make it happen, and I hope that the noble Lord, the Minister, will have some positive things to say.

05:47:51 - 05:47:53

Speaker 114

I beg to move.

05:47:53 - 05:47:59

Speaker 112

Amendment proposed, after clause 12, insert the new clause set out on the marshalled list.

05:47:59 - 05:53:12

James Peter Weir

My lords, I rise to support the amendment standing in the name of Baroness Hoey. I believe it is an amendment which is well thought through, which is balanced and modest. I think the house will be relieved that for once neither myself or Baroness Hoey are even mentioning the Northern Ireland Protocol or the Windsor Framework as part of this, albeit that may too be to our shame in that regard. It is about actually trying to tackle what is a genuine problem for consumers. And I believe it is one that is very much within the keeping of this bill because I think if part of the purpose of this bill is not necessarily to create increased regulation, but to have better and smarter regulation, and this proposal I think very much fits in with that.

It is one that is cautious in its nature because it does not compel the government to take immediate action. It gives the power to Treasury, and indeed before any next steps could be taken, there would need to be both consultation, discussion, and agreement with the devolved institutions and indeed with the respective departments. And also be in a situation in which it simply would not be acted upon by government but would have to be brought forward through the affirmative procedure. So I think this is taking this in a sensible approach one step at a time. But ultimately it's to deal with a very real problem.

I think for any of us who have been involved politically in Northern Ireland, and I'm sure across the chamber there will be agreement, that in every election whenever you're out canvassing, there will be people will raise the issue about the higher rates of insurance. And indeed even as recently as the last general election, there were a number of candidates of different parties who said that this is something that had to be tackled. Whatever the long-standing problem, and I think part of the issue is highlighted I think by Baroness Hoey, that it has tended to fall between the cracks, that it's not particularly under the exact remit of any one particular department. But whatever the long-term issue in relation to this, it has become exacerbated in recent years. We have seen particularly since the end of COVID in the last few years where we've seen shrinking choice, that we've seen the number of insurance brokers and companies reducing within both home and motor insurance.

This has led also to a vicious cycle of increasing premiums, and that in and of itself has meant that it has been more and more dependent upon the role of CMCs. And we know that the direct impact of CMCs has perhaps been to raise the overall premiums by around about 30% in Northern Ireland. Now, as indicated by the proposer of this amendment, it is not purely the role of CMCs that has led to those increases, but they've played a very significant role. And when you have part of the industry which is unregulated, which is unaccountable and unchecked, it is no wonder that this has become for some almost a license to print money. And the reality is that how that is then filtered down to the consumer has been a major impact.

...impact for any of us in Northern Ireland, we will be used to the annual exercise when we are renewing either house insurance or motor insurance of our brokers quoting us an exorbitantly increased level of cost. You will then generally speaking try to probe that by asking them to explore if there's any other options, and at best they will come back with something that is slightly less than what they originally quoted, but the prices go up and up and up for everyone. But it is particularly acute for, for example, first-time motorists who will face a situation either they are facing exorbitant motor insurance costs or in some cases simply not quoted at all. I think this is something which can be tackled. I think we've offered a very practical way forward by with this amendment.

And the government has indicated, particularly the new Prime Minister has put at the heart of the agenda the issue of cost of living, but not simply cost of living in a general sense, but doing so I think for every postcode in the country. And I think that if we are looking for something which can deliver on that promise, this is effectively quite low-hanging fruit. So I would urge the government either to accept this amendment or alternatively find some form of formula through discussions in which the spirit of this amendment can be brought forward so that once and for all we can actually start to tackle this problem, because this does offer a solution, either by way of the government intervening through Treasury or I think at the very least the sheer threat of the power may well lead to CMCs reducing back what they are, their costing. It may lead to, hopefully, good behavior on their part. So I would urge the government to give this very serious consideration and I look forward to the minister responding.

05:53:12 - 05:56:49

Reg Empey

My Lords, taking up Lord Weir's last point about the Prime Minister and his recent visits and tours of the UK, he has emphasized the primary focus of government is to help people with the cost of living. Because our population in Northern Ireland is spread out more than it is in Great Britain, there is a much heavier reliance on motor vehicles to get around, and it does have a huge impact on not only farmers but people who are resident in rural areas. Now, at one point a number of years ago as Minister for Enterprise I did have responsibility for consumer protection, but I'm, I've no recollection that financial matters of this nature were actually incorporated in the devolution settlement. So I do believe the Treasury here has a key role to play. Now, it does seem odd that we have a sector here that is unregulated, it's the only part of the United Kingdom where it is unregulated.

And what I think people need to perhaps grasp is there is a different legal framework for dealing with claims for damages under insurance. For instance, Baroness Hoey referred to a list of settlements that should be reached, whereas we have a thing called the Green Book at home and that allows for much greater flexibility and has resulted in much higher claims. So she quoted one example for soft tissue injury, but that's only one. It does spread out along and of course that is not the only potential claim because there could be other mental health claims arising from, from a situation as well. So I think the minister should perhaps reflect on this and if he's not content with this particular amendment, cautious though it might be, he could bring forward something at third reading.

But the fundamental point is we have here an opportunity to start and help with the cost of living, because as brokers are advising and insurers and market makers are withdrawing from the province simply because the economics of the claim system just doesn't pay, because an insurance company like any other business has to make a profit.

And if claims are exorbitant and the management of them is expensive which it is because quite often these claim companies result in the amount of time the vehicle is on the road expanding and that also means that the car hire charges are expanding in parallel. And of course that is a source of very significant profit. And therefore they have their own garages in some cases and obviously they have their own hire cars so that all ends up on the bill of the insurer. Then it ends up with the consumer. So I think the government would have an opportunity to take a practical step forward to help people with the cost of living.

It is simply by extending a regulatory regime that exists in other parts of the United Kingdom. There are no legal or other risks attached and indeed there's no cost to the government quite the opposite. And I would therefore urge the minister to seriously consider the points that have been made and I would like to think that he could bring some forward some proposal by third reading.

05:56:49 - 05:58:54

David Hunt

I support the noble baroness lady Hoey and also the noble lord Lord Weir of Ballyholme and Lord Empey. And in doing so I should declare my interest as past chairman of the British Insurance Brokers Association and a practicing solicitor in the city of London. We have campaigned within the broking community for proper regulation of claims management companies for a very long time. And therefore BIBA was particularly disappointed that this bill didn't address the problem which is urgent. Average motor claims costs in Northern Ireland have tracked more than 30% higher than in England and Wales since 2021.

And I think the figures given by the noble baroness bear that out. So there is a need to do something about this problem. And I agree with the noble lords who've spoken that this is a great opportunity for the government to put right the anomaly. I'm afraid claims management companies do add between 15 and 30% to a total claim by taking a percentage out of compensation that does not reach the claimant. And we have to keep reminding ourselves of that.

So we believe that this amendment would be a practical targeted correction compared with the bill's alongside the bill's wider focus on consumer protection redress and better regulation.

05:58:54 - 05:59:40

Jonny Oates

Notwithstanding the anomalies that have been discussed and of course there are significant anomalies in insurance in England as well. My lords we have some concerns about this amendment as it would hand the treasury very extensive powers to act through secondary legislation including the ability to amend primary legislation. We've raised concerns consistently throughout committee and at report about the use of broad delegated powers of this kind and we think the same concerns apply here. The fact that regulations would be subject to the affirmative procedure provides a degree of parliamentary scrutiny but it does not alter the fundamental point that parliament would be delegating significant legislative discretion to the treasury before the detailed regime and any transitional arrangements had been set out.

05:59:40 - 06:00:42

David Pitt

My Lords, amendment 16 would give the Treasury the power to extend regulation of claims management activity to Northern Ireland through secondary legislation. I'm aware of the concerns relating to high insurance costs across the UK and would be supportive of action to tackle these where we can, but we should not rush to regulate without clear evidence. The government's motor insurance task force has examined the drivers of motor insurance costs, including claims-related costs and market practices. This work has not identified clear evidence that claims management companies are a primary driver of higher premiums in Northern Ireland. Moreover, any proposal in this area would also need careful engagement with the Department of Finance in Northern Ireland and proper consideration of the devolution implications.

I therefore ask the noble lady to withdraw amendment 16.

06:00:42 - 06:01:48

Kate Hoey

My Lords, I was thinking that we had a noble lord the minister who was going to be much more reassuring, but in fact, I think that was quite a very negative response because all the things he said were things that actually have already happened and could be happening in more detail if the government was to move forward with this. And I think it really is a missed opportunity of the government on this, and it's not going to go away. It's going to have to come back in a different form. I, like I think many people probably here tonight, hadn't realized just until recently how appalling this situation is. And, you know, his facts and figures, I don't know where the Treasury or whoever he's got them from have come from, but they've certainly not come from the people who know what's going on in Northern Ireland.

There's no point putting this to a vote tonight, obviously, but I would say that I hope following this that actually the noble lord would meet with a group of us who understand this a bit more and actually make it clear to him that, you know, to the noble lord, that perhaps sometimes he might be being given the wrong advice. I beg to withdraw.

06:01:48 - 06:01:59

Speaker 112

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? No chance to the noble lady was seeking. The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment number 17, Baroness Kramer.

06:01:59 - 06:05:23

Susan Kramer

My Lords, let me address amendment 17 in my name, which is also signed by Lord Faulks, which I very much appreciate. It addresses authorized push payment fraud and would require the tech companies whose platforms are host to this fraud to share in the reimbursement of losses to the victims of such fraud. At present, victims of APP fraud are reimbursed up to eighty-five thousand pounds, half by the bank sending the payment and half by the bank receiving the payment. This is under rules set by the Payment Systems Regulator. Now, the rules and the cost of reimbursement have had a positive effect in that banks have set up a much more effective regime to alert people to the possibility of fraud.

Many of us have seen that in transactions that we do and the warnings that we receive. But APP fraud continues to grow relentlessly, and on the most recent figures is up by nineteen percent in the last year, reaching five hundred and seventy-six million pounds in the UK. Payment fraud altogether in the UK has reached one point three billion pounds a year. It is essentially forty percent of all serious crime. Now, sixty-six percent of these scams, because that's what they are, originate on online tech platforms.

And these platforms made four hundred and thirty million pounds in revenue last year from advertising these scams.

I find that outrageous. Surely these platforms should be picking up at least part of the cost of reimbursement, instead of the cost falling wholly on the banks while the tech companies pocket the advertising revenue. I don't think that the tech companies will ever stop scams and take them seriously until it starts costing them money. Now I cannot understand why the government is rejecting my amendment. Is it so afraid of the tech companies and Trump that it can't provide this protection to ordinary consumers who are being defrauded on such a scale?

But then I also had a eureka moment in understanding why the FCA hasn't acted. It came from an absolutely chance conversation. Neither the FCA nor Ofcom is apparently sure which one of them should take the initiative in trying to deal with tech companies and this form of fraud. Regulatory courtesy has led to inaction. And frankly, when I look at the number of victims and the size of the losses, this is completely unacceptable.

So this amendment breaks that conundrum, and I would expect the government to try and attempt to break that conundrum and ensure that action takes place. My Lords, other amendments in this group. I support amendments 19 and 20 in this group, I know they will be spoken to eloquently, but I admit to not fully understanding the issues in amendments 95 and 97, but I will listen carefully.

06:05:23 - 06:05:29

Speaker 112

Proposed after clause 13 insert the new clause set out on the marshalled list.

06:05:29 - 06:10:33

The Lord Vaux

My Lords, I've added my name in support of amendment 17 that the noble lady Baroness Kramer has already explained, and I've also tabled amendment 19. Both amendments relate to the continuing problem of fraud. As noble Lords are probably aware, the last Financial Services and Markets Act led to the introduction of the compulsory reimbursement for APP fraud losses by the banks, split 50-50 between the paying and the receiving bank. And this has had two effects. Firstly, it has increased reimbursement of victims, but also importantly, by imposing financial costs of fraud onto the banks, it has given them a strong incentive to take steps to protect their customers from fraud.

And, my Lords, they have done so. Now there are some valid concerns about how this might change victims' behaviour, the question of moral hazard, and I hope the FCA will keep that under review, but I think it is fair to say that the requirement to reimburse customers of fraud has generally been seen to be successful. The logic for pushing the obligation onto the banks is that almost every fraud has to be cashed out through the banking system at some point in the chain. But it is also true, my Lords, that very little fraud arises from the banks themselves. As we've just heard, most APP fraud starts either online or on a telecoms service, around 66% online and 17% from telecoms.

Once again, I'm going to name-check Meta, from whose platforms the greatest amount of such fraud originates. Well, my Lords, surely it would be better to try to prevent fraud where it originates than just reimburse it. Now, despite various voluntary charters, this is not improving at all. Your Lordships' Fraud Act Committee 2006 and Digital Fraud Committee, of which I was a member, recognized this in its report four years ago, when we said, and I quote, "Until all fraud-enabling industries fear significant financial, legal and reputational risk for their failure to prevent fraud, they will not act."

My Lords we were right they have not acted. The government's most recent fraud strategy also recognized this and it says and again I quote if industry partnership and market incentives alone remain insufficient to drive improvements the government will take legislative action within this parliament. There have been no improvements my Lords. It is time to legislate. Now I'm sure the noble Lord the Minister is going to explain that the Online Safety Act is going to deal with all this.

And it does help but only to a certain extent. It is quite limited on what it's actually covered and where in relation to fraud primarily in relation to paid for advertising which is only a small area from where fraud originates. Amendment 17 would make the tech companies directly liable for their share of the cost of the fraud arising on their platforms. And this bill gives us the perfect opportunity to take the legislative action the government has itself committed to to make the tech and telco companies take their responsibilities to their customers seriously without further delay. It's four years as I said since the committee made its conclusion on this.

So I would urge noble Lords to support the noble lady Baroness Kramer if she decides to move amendment 17 as I hope she will do. Amendment 19 that I've tabled is very simple. During the passage of the last Financial Services and Markets Bill the then government agreed to ensure that the Payment Services Regulator should prepare a report every six months that sets out how the payment services providers are performing in relation to paying out and receiving fraudulent payments as well as their reimbursement performance. Since the compulsory reimbursement scheme started that reporting has stopped. But the reports were very helpful not only in relation to reimbursement performance under the then voluntary scheme but also in identifying and publicizing which of the payment providers were the most risky.

And it did lead to some actually being closed down because their performance in identifying preventing fraud was so poor. The amendment would simply require the FCA into which the PSR has now been subsumed to continue with that valuable reporting including where reasonably possible identifying where the fraud originated for example which tech platforms as we've just been talking about which would allow us to take targeted action against those platforms that are doing least to protect consumers from fraud. The amendment introduces no new obligation no new work. It just requires the FCA to continue to do what it was what was previously agreed and was being done by the PSR. I hope the noble Lord the Minister can provide some reassurance that this important reporting will continue.

06:10:33 - 06:12:42

Greville Howard

My Lords my amendment 95 raises the issue of non-compete legislation. When this was raised at committee the noble Lord the Minister undertook to respond. His response was to refer to a 2025 working paper. But my Lords action is needed. Could I urge the noble Lord the Minister to pursue this and not allow the report to just sit.

At committee the noble Lord the Minister commented that he was not an expert on employment law. That may be the case but the ability to maintain confidentiality of important and expensive systems is vital in the financial services industry.

Algorithms and sophisticated and complex computer systems are an essential part of today's top-level financial service companies. They must be able to maintain the confidentiality of their systems. Non-compete agreements are an essential part of this. Whether or not the bill we are debating today is the right place for this is is not certain. But it must be dealt with if we wish to retain Great Britain's predominant place in the industry.

Something I hope the noble lord the minister is in favour of. Even if non-compete is not precisely within his remit, it is certainly something he should make it his business in the interest of his department. May I urge the noble lord the minister not to allow the 2025 report to just sit in a pending tray.

06:12:42 - 06:19:52

Natalie Bennett

I rise to speak to amendment 97, which appears in this group in my name, and wish to start by commending the noble lady Baroness Kramer and Lord Vaux for providing us with powerful arguments for amendments, particularly 17. And I echoed Lord Vaux's comments that if the noble lady wishes to put to the vote, the Green Party would certainly support it. We need to see the tech companies being made to pay for huge profits they are collecting while continuing to allow illegality to operate in their spaces. However, I'm just going to primarily speak to 97. And I begin by actually I wish to acknowledge the work of Joshua Terranson, who's my King's College London intern, who has actually identified this issue for me and done a great deal of work on this amendment.

So this is an amendment about a different sort of fraud from Baroness Kramer's amendment. It's about ransomware fraud. Now, this is something that I'm sure noble lords have in many cases come across, a great concern to business people, to individuals, to institutions, thinking here particularly of the NHS. And this is where a computer system or a database is locked, prevented from access, the ransomware takes it over, and companies are told pay up or you'll never get this back. Now, I think it's worth thinking about what the circumstances of this are like.

Very often payment is demanded in cryptocurrency. People are told if you don't do this in the next hour, the figure will double and double again and double again, etc. This is through alerts appearing on someone's computer screen. It's a tremendously frightening, difficult, challenging circumstance to face. Now, the figures that we have for this come from Action Fraud.

In the year from April 2025, 323 UK organisations reported such an attack. More than half of those were small and medium enterprises, and the average loss for those was 270,000 pounds, which is of course for SMEs a huge sum of money. Now, I said reported because of course there's generally acknowledged by experts in the field that there's a real issue of stigma here. Companies, organisations do not want to admit that they've fallen victim to such a fraud. And I think it's generally agreed that those figures are a tip of an iceberg situation.

Firms would have to notify the FCA within 72 hours of becoming aware of a ransom demand. The only exception provided is where the payment is needed to prevent an imminent risk to life or of serious injury, and then only with the prior approval of the Secretary of State. It covers authorized persons and firms supervised by the FCA under payment services and electronic money regulations. Now, I think it's worth going back over how we've got to the point where we still don't have any actual action. Because in January 2025, the Home Office consulted on three proposed measures on ransomware: a targeted ban on ransom payments by public sector bodies and operators of critical national infrastructure, a payment prevention regime under which other organizations would have to notify the government before paying, and mandatory incident reporting.

The response was reported on the 22nd of July 2025, recorded 72% support for a targeted ban, and the announcement said that all public sector bodies and CNI operators would be banned from paying and there would be a notification requirement. On the 14th of October 2025, answering Lord Fox's questions on lessons from the Jaguar Land Rover attack, Lord Leong told the House the Home Office was progressing a package of measures and undertook to update the House. In December 2025, the Security Minister said the ban remained a priority and was progressing, and now you know the dreaded phrase that's going to come back: when parliamentary time allows. Now, you might think that there'd be coverage of this in the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, but my understanding is that there is no coverage of such issues. Now, why does this amendment work?

Why can we do this through the Financial Services Bill? Nearly every payment would pass through a financial company, if there's any kind of scale of this at all. Whoever the victim is, the money will go through a firm that the FCA supervises. A rule on these firms therefore reaches most payments made from the UK, not just payments by financial firms themselves. Now, the amendment, I think, is quite elegant.

It does not create a new offense or a general ban on businesses. The Bill's Office said this would be outside the scope of this bill. Instead, it makes a duty on the FCA to create the rules within 12 months. This is a step forward dealing with an absolutely critical issue which is affecting businesses, organizations right now, on which the government has promised to act. It follows the government's own design.

Now, I'm not expecting the noble Lord the Minister to stand up and say, "Yes, yes, I accept this amendment." And I'm also not going to put this to a vote because I think we haven't had the time and the capacity to work through the detail of exactly how this is written. But nonetheless, I really hope that we're going to hear from the Minister word that there's going to be really significant progress in this area very soon.

I'm really hoping not to hear the phrase when parliamentary time allows, because this is something that the government has done the consultation on, has promised to act on, and surely we need to see protection in this fraud capital of the world, the UK, for firms. If ransoms cannot be paid, then it will not be in the interest of criminals to put the effort in to try and get ransoms.

06:19:52 - 06:22:41

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, we are concerned about the scale of fraud, and in particular by the continued growth of authorised push payment fraud and other forms of online economic crime. Government and the banks have made progress, but the truth is it is hard to keep up with the scammers, and the sums at stake are significant, as the noble lady Lady Kramer has explained. I therefore strongly welcome the noble lord Lord Fox's proposal for an annual report. My noble friend Lord Howard of Rising is right to be concerned about future protection of commercially sensitive information as part of a competitive UK sector. I'm glad he's brought his amendment back, and I hope the minister will be able to provide an assurance that this will be addressed.

The amendments in this group raise important questions about transparency, monitoring, and the practical steps firms can take to identify scams earlier, warn consumers, share information more effectively, and pay compensation where that is appropriate. Indeed, there's been considerable progress since the APP reimbursement regime was introduced in 2024. I always remember my card being used in Korea to buy 2,500 pounds worth of Louis Vuitton luggage. Now, that would not happen today, as banking procedures and scrutiny are so much better. However, I think the proposal by the noble lady Lady Kramer is a difficult one, as it's not clear what the technology companies could do to stop fraud systematically.

They're not passing money on in the same way as the banks, and I think that may have been what Lord Stockwood was getting at in committee when he responded to this amendment at an earlier stage. New regulations of this kind could also have a chilling effect on the supply of online services in the UK, so I think more analysis is needed before the FCA introduces new rules. We believe this is an area where the government and the regulators should be prepared to make progress, but we also understand the constraints. I should add that it is also important that people learn to avoid scams with simple procedures like Face ID and to take care over what they buy online. And I think this should be a very important part of education, and indeed the work of Ofcom working with the FCA and the tech companies should be able to make more progress here.

But I very much look forward to the minister's response in this important area and how he thinks we can best take forward this problem.

06:22:41 - 06:26:43

David Pitt

Before I respond, my noble lords, I must start with a correction because as part of the third debate I said commercial credit data sharing schemes improves banks' referrals and strengthens personal lending. However, the CCDS and the bank referral scheme are different schemes, and to correct the record, I meant that the government is improving competition and supply through enhancements to commercial credit data sharing in this bill and working with industry to strengthen bank referral arrangements. Both of these schemes help improve lending to SMEs. I do apologize for that, and I was speed-reading my way through my responses. I will try and be more careful going forward.

Look, I'm grateful to the noble baronesses and the noble lords for tabling these amendments and to all the noble lords who have contributed to this debate. On amendment 17, fraud causes profound financial and emotional harm.

As you know, this government takes the issue of fraud very seriously and is dedicated to protecting UK citizens. As my noble friend Lord Stockwood explained during the committee debates, the Online Safety Act requires tech companies to take proactive steps to prevent fraudulent content. The government remains committed to ensuring that Ofcom makes full use of its powers to undertake fast and decisive action against illegal online harms, including fraud. At the request of the Secretary of State, Ofcom will share an annual update on their enforcement strategy for online safety with Parliament. In July, Ofcom published the fraudulent advertising code consultation, proposing over 40 new measures to tackle online fraud on the UK's biggest digital services.

Amongst these measures, Ofcom proposes mandatory verification of financial services advertisers. This will support legitimate financial promotions from FCA-authorised firms while cracking down on illegal financial promotions, such as scam investments and crypto ads. Ofcom also proposed that the largest services will have to introduce new ad libraries that ensure all paid-for advertisements are publicly traceable. This will support experts and law enforcement to quickly detect and report suspected scam ads that UK users may find online. It seems clear to me that we must let Ofcom get on with this job.

Martin Lewis and consumer group Which? have said that timely implementation will be key. I now turn to amendment 19, tabled by the noble lord Lord Vaux, on the publication of authorised push payment fraud performance data. This amendment was also debated at committee stage. The government agrees that transparency over firms' performance in preventing authorised push payment fraud is important. The Payment Systems Regulator has previously published data on the performance of individual payment service providers, including data on where fraud originated.

However, the government does not consider that a specific annual reporting requirement needs to be set in legislation. Following the consolidation of the Payment Systems Regulator, the FCA will have the powers and flexibility to determine the most appropriate approach to the publication of fraud performance data, adopting reporting to developments, available data, and the wider authorised push payment fraud framework. Moving on to amendment 20, tabled by the noble lord Lord Holmes, this was also discussed in committee. Sorry.

06:26:43 - 06:26:55

The Lord Vaux

Sorry to interrupt the noble lord the minister, but perhaps he could explain why the FCA have stopped the reports that the PSR were previously providing.

06:26:55 - 06:29:32

David Pitt

I am unable to answer the noble lord's question, but might I write to him with an answer? Thank you. Lord Holmes was discussed in committee and the government's position remains unchanged. As set out in committee, there is already a range of measures in place and further work underway across government, regulators, and industry. This includes firms' use of increasingly sophisticated fraud detection systems, confirmation of payee checks, work to improve data sharing between payment service providers, and steps to ensure that fraud prevention is built into the design of future retail payments infrastructure.

Turning now to amendment 95, concerning the protection of intellectual property, I agree that weak protections can be a drag on competitiveness, on non-compete clauses in particular. There are no provisions in the Employment Rights Act 2025 that would affect the use of non-compete clauses by financial services firms.

The government has published a working paper on options for reform of non-compete clauses in employment contracts at Budget 2025. The government is currently reviewing responses and will respond to the working paper in due course. The focus of the working paper was on options for reform of non-compete clauses in employment contracts. It does not consider reform to intellectual property law or other means to protect confidential information. The government understands that a well-designed balanced intellectual property system offers confidence for business, investors, and consumers to contribute to growing our economy.

Turning finally to amendment 97 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, I recognise the continued threat posed to the UK by ransomware criminals. Following public consultation last year, this government is already taking forward work through the Home Office to break the business model of ransomware and provide law enforcement with the information it needs to understand, investigate, and disrupt ransomware activity. This includes proposals for targeted ban on ransomware payments and mandatory reporting for businesses above a certain size. Taken together, the government considers that the objectives of these amendments are already addressed through the existing framework and work is underway. It does not believe that further statutory requirements are needed.

And so with that in mind, I ask the noble Baronesses and noble Lords to withdraw their amendments.

06:29:32 - 06:29:45

Natalie Bennett

Before the noble Lord the Minister sits down, can I just ask for a potential timeframe on when the noble Lord expects to see progress on that work in the Home Office?

06:29:45 - 06:29:50

David Pitt

Again, might the noble Baroness accept that I'll write to her on that comment? I don't know the timetable offhand.

06:29:50 - 06:30:28

Susan Kramer

My Lords, the online platforms know exactly what they have to do to stop online fraud. They are just choosing not to do it. And frankly, to say that the answer will come from Ofcom, that certainly hasn't worried the platforms one iota. The platforms will only take notice when they actually have to pay out to reimburse people who have been victims of those fraud scams. And that is why amendment 17 matters, and that is why I am going to test the opinion of the House.

06:30:28 - 06:30:42

Speaker 34

The question is that this amendment be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by division. I will notify the House when voting is over.

Voting is now open, clear the bar.

06:38:38 - 06:38:38

My Lords, the question is that this amendment be agreed to.

06:40:12 - 06:41:32

Speaker 34

My Lords, there have voted: contents 26, not contents 119, so the not contents have it. We'll just have a moment or two for noble Lords to resume their seats. In schedule 2, amendment 18, Lord Pitt-Watson moved formally. Moved formally? Yes, the question is that amendment 18 be agreed to, as many as are of that opinion will say content.

Content, good. Not content, the contents have it, but very quietly. Amendment 19, Lord Vaux, not moved. Number 20, Lord Holmes, not moved. Number 21, Lord Pitt-Watson moved formally.

Moved formally. The question is that amendment 21 be agreed to, as many as are of that opinion will say content. Not content, again very quietly, but the contents have it. Amendment 22, Lord Pitt-Watson.

06:41:32 - 06:45:45

David Pitt

I beg to move amendment 22 in my name. I'll also speak to the government's amendments 58 and 59. And this is an amendment from the government that is developed from our discussions in committee. My Lords, payment systems are essential national infrastructure. They allow households to pay bills, businesses to trade, financial institutions to transfer funds securely.

As technology changes how we pay, those systems must continue to evolve, becoming more efficient and capable of supporting new services while remaining trusted and resilient. The Bank of England has a critical responsibility to protect and enhance UK financial stability. The Bank is also working with the government and other authorities to support safe innovation in payments and digital finance. The Bank has welcomed this measure and will reinforce that work while preserving the primacy of financial stability. Amendment 58 places the Bank's role in facilitating innovation on a clear statutory footing.

When exercising certain key functions for recognised payment systems, recognised digital settlement asset service providers, and in-scope service providers, the Bank must, so far as is reasonably possible, facilitate innovation with a view to improving the quality, functionality, and economy of those systems and related services. The objective is expressly secondary and does not require the Bank to facilitate innovation where doing so would undermine its primary financial stability objective. This change will also bring the regulation of systemic payment systems and digital settlement assets into closer alignment with the Bank's supervision of other financial market infrastructure. The Bank already has a secondary innovation objective for central counterparties and central securities depositories, providing a comparable objective for systemic payment systems and digital settlement assets provides the Bank with a clear and consistent statutory framework.

Amendment 58 also ensures that the Bank can be held accountable under its new objective. It enables the Treasury to make recommendations about aspects of the government's economic policy for the Bank to have regard to when considering how to advance its financial stability and secondary innovation objective in relation to payment systems. Those recommendations must be published and laid before Parliament. The Bank must explain the action it has taken or its reasons for not acting and provide updates where required. The Bank's annual reports must now also explain how it has advanced the secondary innovation objective and engaged with interested stakeholders.

Amendment 59 reinforces that accountability by requiring the Bank to publish a standalone annual report on both secondary innovation objectives. The report must explain how objectives have been embedded in the Bank's operations, processes and decisions and how it has advanced them with respect to relevant functions. This will give Parliament and industry clear sight of how the objectives operate in practice. Amendment 22 is consequential. It ensures that the mechanism already in the bill for coordination between the Financial Conduct Authority, the Prudential Regulation Authority and the Bank with respect to relevant payment functions makes appropriate reference to regulator objectives, which would now include the Bank's secondary innovation objective.

So in summary, together these amendments place the Bank's role in facilitating safe innovation on a clear statutory footing while preserving financial stability as its primary objective. They also provide stronger and more transparent accountability for how the Bank applies the objectives in practice. I hope noble Lords will join me in supporting these amendments.

06:45:45 - 06:45:54

Speaker 34

Amendment proposed, schedule 2, page 85, line 13, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.

06:45:54 - 06:47:40

Susan Kramer

My Lords, I just have a couple of very brief comments. Obviously, I support the, I'm comfortable with the amendments that the Minister has just described. But I do have one note of caution. The drive for innovation, which we all think is a good thing, can in many ways also expose the UK increasingly to a loss of monetary sovereignty, particularly where that innovation has to be brought in from overseas and gives those overseas companies far greater control of the payment systems in the UK. It's one of the ongoing fears that we've had.

Scott Bessent's been quite open in saying controlling that, controlling Western economies, tariffs very old-fashioned, stablecoin is the way we'll do it. But so I'm very cautious when I hear this drive for innovation without having some counter-warning and counter-consideration of the monetary sovereignty impacts. And I never hear those words used, nor are they captured in any way in anything that I hear around regulation. So often the move into digital assets, which is essentially what this is all about, is very much about plumbing and pipelines. It doesn't recognise the political implications.

We've seen in so many other areas where we have given away, you know, food security, energy security. We need to be very careful that we don't give away security in the financial services and payment sector.

06:47:40 - 06:48:05

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, we welcome these amendments and the movement from the government on this important issue. And I look forward to Bank of England's first report on its innovation objective and hope that it'll drive help to drive much needed growth in the economy. And I'm sure the reports will also be useful to our specialist parliamentary committees.

06:48:05 - 06:48:39

Speaker 34

The question is that these amendments be agreed to, as many amendment 22 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. And now amendments 23 to 25, Lord Watson move formally.

Again the question is that these amendments be agreed to, as many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. We now come to amendment 26, after clause 14, Baroness Kramer.

06:48:39 - 06:52:08

Susan Kramer

My Lords, that's all the amendments in this group, I'm afraid, are mine. Amendment 29 has also been signed by Lord Fox and for that I am most grateful. I will also be brief as the hour is late. The government in this bill will transfer all supervision of professional service firms in respect of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism finance from the current professional bodies to the FCA. Now members of this house have received representation from a wide range of professional groups who are frankly utterly dismayed.

They recognize that the FCA is trying to respond to their needs and to their issues, but it seems to have very little idea, or the FCA does, how to fund or resource the complex guidance and education that is required in order as part of that supervisory and monitoring process. And it seems that as far as I can understand that the FCA is now saying it would like the professional bodies themselves to continue to provide all of that work, but essentially on an unpaid basis, which is not realistic. The FCA has produced a high-level roadmap, but I hear universally that it is very short of information, very low on timing details. My Lords, I can agree that the current system has historically suffered from fragmentation. But I'm not sure that we needed a remedy on the scale of the changes that are in this bill.

The fragmentation issue, that's was being dealt with reasonably effectively by OPBAS, the Office for Professional Anti-Money Laundering Supervision, that was now that had been created to sit above the professional bodies to provide coordination standards and to make them effective. Where OPBAS had a weakness was its communication with enforcement agencies. But this is an issue that could have been remedied without the radical change on the scale that is represented in this bill. My amendments require an assessment of this transition process, particularly on issues like education, guidance and compliance support, on timetables, on regional coverage, and on supervisory fees, because there is real concern now with an additional layer, that's of supervision brought into the picture, that fees are going to increase very significantly. That's and also my amendment would require the FCA to have regard to having the appropriate expertise on hand to be able to provide that support and guidance, and that's significant expertise ranging from such things as accounting to taxation.

That's and it hasn't really taken these issues on historically.

So I'm going to I will not be pressing this issue because the FCA is trying to find ways in which to make this system work. But I honestly don't think the FCA would have wished this upon itself nor would the professional bodies wished it upon themselves. And it really is just important I think that the government understand that it needs to think much more carefully when it introduces radical change when frankly much more modest and targeted change would have served the purpose better.

06:52:08 - 06:52:17

Speaker 34

Amendment proposed after clause 14 insert the new clause as printed on the marshalled list.

06:52:17 - 06:54:09

The Lord Vaux

Just briefly to add my support to the noble lady Baroness Kramer on her amendment 29 to which I have added my name. The noble Baroness has already explained with her usual clarity the concerns that lie behind this group of amendments so I'll try not to repeat what she said. The changes proposed by the bill to the AML supervisory regime will move the AML elements of supervision from the relevant professional body to the FCA. And so firms will now have to deal with two separate regulators rather than one, the FCA for AML and the professional body for everything else. And it seems to me it's inevitable that this will have cost impacts for those firms even if as the FCA argue the actual regulatory rules themselves won't change.

And that's likely to be especially true I think for smaller firms. The impact assessment that accompanies the bill on this section is frankly almost laughably poor. It relies almost entirely on the statement that the AML rules themselves won't change. It doesn't address in any meaningful way the question of moving from one supervisor to two. So it must therefore be sensible surely to carry out an assessment of what the impact of the changes will be on firms and to ensure that the costs remain proportionate to the benefits that the FCA and the government argue will accrue before going ahead with the changes.

And that's what amendment 29 is looking to achieve. The government's commendably keen to reduce the regulatory burden on businesses. So I look forward to hearing what the noble lord the minister has to say on this. Does he agree that there is likely to be an increase in costs to firms from having to deal with two supervisors rather than one? And how will he ensure that that's proportionate to any benefits that will arise?

06:54:09 - 06:56:17

Jonny Oates

My lords these amendments reflect a number of very important concerns about the proposed transfer of anti-money laundering supervision to the FCA. We do not believe that each of these points requires legislative commitment. However we've also been made aware of serious concerns from industry about how this transition is being communicated and how the new regime will work in practice. These concerns include the governance arrangements following the transfer, the timetable and transitional process, the maintenance of professional standards, proportionality and the extent to which the FCA will retain specialist expertise needed to supervise highly technical sectors such as accounting, legal services and trust and company service provision. There are also legitimate questions about the practical support available to firms, the likely cost of the new regime and whether smaller firms in particular will face disproportionate burdens.

This is why our amendment, amendment 93 in my name and the name of my noble friend Lady Noble-Rolfe covers the transfer of AML supervision. Parliamentary and entire industry oversight of these changes will be vital in making sure that this new architecture works in the way the minister wants. The common thread running through our amendment and the amendment in this group is therefore a sensible one.

If the government are going to centralize this responsibility within the FCA, they must demonstrate that the FCA is genuinely equipped to undertake it and provide clarity to industry about how this process is going to be practically achieved. That means not simply having the formal regulatory powers, but having the right people, the right sectoral knowledge, appropriate transitional arrangements, and a clear understanding of how supervision will operate across the country. Industry is concerned about these questions and those concerns should be taken seriously. I therefore hope the noble lord the minister can make a firm commitment today to provide considerably greater clarity about how this transfer will be implemented, how professional expertise and standards and proportionality will be maintained, and what firms should expect during transition.

06:56:17 - 07:01:50

David Pitt

My lords, I'm grateful to Baroness Kramer for tabling these amendments concerning the implementation of the reform of the UK's anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing supervisory regime. The point I think that everyone is raising about the implementation of this needing to be well done is extremely important, as is Lord Oates's comment about parliamentary oversight of what it is that is taking place here. But if I could just talk to each of the amendments, first amendment 26 and 27 concerning support for firms and implementation planning. So amendment 26 would require the Treasury to publish and lay an assessment before Parliament including a comparison between education guidance compliance assistance currently available to firms and the support will be provided by the FCA. Now the government recognizes the concern that professional services firms would continue to receive clear guidance, appropriate support, and access to sector-specific expertise following the transition to the FCA.

Existing professions in the money laundering regulations which require supervisors to provide information about money laundering risks to supervised populations will apply to the FCA in relation to its expanded responsibilities. The FCA already has significant experience in providing AML CTF information and guidance to large and diversified supervised population. For these reasons, the government does not believe that a statutory assessment is necessary. Amendment 27 would require the Treasury to publish a statutory timetable for implementation. While I do not believe that such a requirement is necessary, the FCA has provided some additional clarity on the expected implementation timetables.

The current expectation is that the first businesses will begin to be supervised by the FCA before the end of 2028. Further onboarding will take place in phases with the broad aim that all firms within scope will be supervised by the FCA by mid-2030. Implementation should proceed though only when the necessary preparations are complete. This includes ensuring appropriate systems and effective information sharing arrangements are in place, that supervisory staff are adequately trained, and sufficient clarity is provided to firms about the future regime. Retaining flexibility will allow the government and the FCA to respond to stakeholder feedback and lessons arising during the transition.

Existing supervisors will continue to supervise firms, taking enforcement action where necessary and maintain standards until the FCA assumes its new responsibility.

The Office for Professional Body AML Supervision, OPBAS, will continue to oversee the existing professional body supervisors during that period. The FCA is already engaging with professional body supervisors and HMRC on information and data sharing arrangements. Amendment 28 concerns professional expertise. The government fully recognizes that effective supervision depends on supervisors understanding the sectors they regulate. Legal services providers, accountancy firms, and trust and company service providers have different business models, risks, and regulatory arrangements.

The FCA, of course, does already supervise a large and diverse population, including many smaller firms, and has extensive experience applying a proportionate, risk-based approach across different business models and firm sizes. The FCA's independent smaller business practitioner panel also provides direct insight into the perspectives and challenges facing small, smaller regulated firms. This reform is not about applying a banking-style or one-size-fits-all supervisory model to professional services firms. The future regime will be proportionate and risk-based, establishing a more consistent and effective framework while recognizing the different characteristics and risks of those sectors. I now turn to amendment 28 on supervisory fees.

All businesses, particularly smaller firms and sole traders, want assurance that the future regime will remain proportionate and that firms will not be required to pay excessive supervisory fees. The FCA will consult on the design of its future fee model before assuming responsibility for these sectors. The government expects the fees to be proportionate and consistent with the FCA's wider fee framework, where smaller firms generally face lower costs than larger firms. The detailed fee structure will depend on the final supervisory model and is therefore better developed through consultation. I turn finally to amendment 30.

07:01:50 - 07:02:08

The Lord Vaux

My Lords, apologies for interrupting the Minister. He hasn't answered the question of what assessment I suppose the government has made of the cost impact on firms of moving from a single supervisor to dealing with two, and particularly for small firms.

07:02:08 - 07:04:50

David Pitt

So, I'm not aware of an individual calculation having been done for that. I don't think that there's a belief that there will be a materially greater cost once the move is made. But the key issue that's trying to be addressed here is that we have 23 regulators right now of AML and that that job needs to be done in a more coordinated and consistent fashion. But look, if I have information on that, I would be delighted to write to the noble Lord on those costs. Finally, amendment 30 concerning the FCA's capacity to undertake effective AML/CTF supervision across all parts of the United Kingdom.

Amendment 30 would require the FCA to report on its capacity to supervise firms throughout the UK. Now, the FCA already operates across the UK through its offices in London, Leeds, Edinburgh, and anticipates having a significant presence for the new ALM regime outside London. This provides, I think, a strong foundation for maintaining regional coverage, preserving local knowledge, and ensuring that jurisdiction-specific issues continue to inform supervision and implementation planning.

This will also help with ensuring that regional risks and jurisdiction-specific considerations are understood and addressed while maintaining a consistent approach across the United Kingdom. My Lords, I recognize the objectives behind these amendments: careful implementation, appropriate support, maintenance of expertise, proportionate fees and sufficient FCA capacity. The government understands why these assurances are being sought, however, we don't believe that additional statutory reports, assessments and fixed requirements are necessary. These matters are being addressed through implementation planning, capability building, stakeholder engagement, consultation and parliamentary scrutiny of the necessary secondary legislation. The government will continue to work closely with Parliament, industry, existing supervisors and the FCA.

Our aim is to deliver a more consistent, effective and coordinated AML-CTF supervisory framework while ensuring that firms receive proportionate supervision and appropriate support. I therefore ask the noble lady Baroness Kramer to withdraw her amendment.

07:04:50 - 07:04:54

Susan Kramer

Sorry, I will withdraw the amendment.

07:04:54 - 07:05:16

Speaker 34

Okay, is it your Lordships' pleasure that amendment 26 be withdrawn? As many as that are of that opinion say content. And then we've got 27 to 30 not moved. Right, we now come to clause 16, Lord Pipp-Watson amendment 31.

07:05:16 - 07:15:52

David Pitt

My Lords, I beg to move amendment 31. Growth is the top priority for the government and the financial services sector is key to delivering this. As my noble friend Lord Stockwood set out at committee stage, the government always intended the FCA's long-term strategy would set out its priorities for advancing its international competitiveness and growth objective. The noble lady Baroness Noakes rightly questioned if our legislative drafting was clear on this point and after further consideration, the government has tabled this amendment to ensure that the law is clear on this point. I thank the noble lady for bringing this matter to our attention.

Turning to amendments 32 and 33, which would place detailed statutory requirements on the content of the FCA's and PRA's long-term strategy, including requiring descriptions of future regulatory initiatives, indicative timelines and assessment of potential trade-offs. The government agrees that this is an important part of Parliament's role in scrutinizing the work of the regulators and I welcome the commitments made by Nikhil Rathi, the CEO of the FCA, in a letter he sent to me on the 2nd of September, which has been shared with the Lords Financial Services Regulation Committee, the opposition front bench and interested peers. The letter made a commitment to proactively engage relevant parliamentary committees on their priorities before it settles future strategies. Katherine Braddick, the new CEO of the PRA, also made commitments in her letter of the 3rd September to engage its stakeholders and Parliament in the development of its strategy. As I committed earlier in today's debate, I am placing these letters in the library today.

Much of the information that the noble baroness seeks is already available or should be already available through existing channels, including the regulatory initiatives grid, which is updated regularly and is specifically designed to provide firms and stakeholders with forward-looking information on forthcoming regulatory activity. The FCA also publishes and will continue to publish an annual work program that details what it will deliver in the coming year against the strategic priorities in its current strategy. The purpose of the long-term strategy is different. It's intended to set out the regulator's strategic direction and priorities over a five-year period, rather than to operate as a detailed business plan. As the FCA sets out in its letter, the strategy is intended to provide greater clarity and predictability about its priorities and provide a strong basis on which Parliament and others can hold them to account for their performance against those priorities.

The government therefore does not consider that these additional statutory requirements are necessary. I now turn to amendment 68, which seeks to create new statutory offices for regulatory evaluation within the FCA and the Bank of England. I recognize the concerns expressed during committee stage about ensuring that Parliament has access to meaningful information about the performance of the financial regulators. It is a point well made, but this amendment would go further than this. It would establish a permanent statutory bodies, dedicated directors, governance arrangements, reporting requirements, introduce additional cost on the regulators.

And as we discussed at committee stage, there already exists a range of mechanisms to provide this information. This proposal could potentially duplicate these arrangements, and the government does not agree that more institutional machinery will necessarily lead to better scrutiny. We discussed at committee stage the importance of the FISMA model, that Parliament has enshrined the principle of regulatory independence into primary legislation through the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. And the government continues to believe that this is the model that best serves the UK's long-term interest. But I recognize the challenges that the noble lords have raised, especially the challenge that as new activities become regulated, the breadth of delegation grows.

The responsibility of our regulators has continued to grow over time, and it is appropriate that parliamentary accountability mechanisms be kept under review to ensure they are in step with the work of the regulators. The government therefore welcomes and encourages the engagement between the regulators and the parliamentary committees, and it welcomes the commitment from the FCA and the PRA to provide Parliament with further information and other assistance needed to help it fulfill its role. This includes more written updates, additional context in the PRA's annual reports, in-person sessions, where I welcome the PRA's offer of external members of the Prudential Regulation Committee also appearing before committees on a more regular basis. I know that the noble lady Baroness Noakes is keen her committee has the ability to scrutinize the PRA and FCA before regulation is finalized. That is a very proper objective, and indeed I particularly enjoyed hosting the FCA's recent drop-in session on measures in the bill that relate to it, which was a great example of both live scrutiny and of gaps being found in action.

But I would now urge the committee and the regulators to try and work together to agree a sensible model for ongoing scrutiny and engagement. And I would therefore respectfully ask the noble baroness not to press her amendment. Let me now come to amendments 51, 54, and 56, which seeks to amend clause 18 or remove it in its entirety. The reforms in clause 18 form a core part of the government's approach to improving the regulatory framework by striking a better balance between ensuring only those accountability mechanisms which are appropriate and valuable are retained, while not overloading the regulators with administrative requirements which fail to provide commensurate benefits. The government has targeted only a limited subset of lower-value requirements.

The broader accountability framework remains in place with very significant reporting and transparency requirements, and the bill also introduces new accountability measures, including long-term strategies and reporting on competitiveness and growth. Amendment 51 would restore a number of requirements which the government continues to believe, following careful consideration and engagement with stakeholders, don't need to be prescribed in statute. Indeed, during committee proceedings, noble lords expressed differing views on the value of these requirements. That underlines the case for allowing regulators greater flexibility rather than imposing increasingly prescriptive reporting obligations. And amendment 54 would require regulators to produce further explanations of how they have applied regulatory principles and statutory duties.

This would reintroduce process-focused reporting requirements that the government is seeking to streamline. Our approach is to focus accountability on outcomes and performance rather than requiring ever more detailed reports on internal methodologies. The government agrees with the importance of Parliament being able to hold the regulators to account. Through this bill, the government is introducing new requirements to support more effective scrutiny, including through the new long-term strategies. Indeed, the regulators will need to set out for the first time in one place their long-term priorities and approach for advancing their objectives.

This is intended to help Parliament better understand the regulators' priorities and how they are translating their objectives into action and results, helping Parliament carry out its vital scrutiny. Parliament will continue to have significant powers to scrutinize the regulators through existing accountability mechanisms. The regulators will continue to notify relevant parliamentary committees on relevant consultations to set out how the proposed the proposal advances their objectives and, in response to concerns raised at committee, as a result, the government's amendments 37, 47, 48, 49, these notifications will continue to set out how the regulator has had regard to the two proportionality regulatory principles. My lords, we are in agreement that Parliament has a vital role to play in scrutinizing the work of the regulators and that effective parliamentary scrutiny is an essential element of our regulatory framework. We must all, Parliament, government, and the regulators, work together to ensure that we have a regulatory environment that is effective and proportionate.

The government has heard the strength of feeling across the house and welcomes the commitments that we've had from the regulators to work with Parliament to ensure it has the information, that is, that Parliament has the information that it needs to fulfill its role. And I'm confident that the government, Parliament, and the regulator have shared ambition and commitment here that we can work together on to make a reality.

And it's for those reasons that the government doesn't consider further legislative amendments are needed, and I would ask the noble lady to withdraw her amendment.

07:15:52 - 07:20:04

Sharon Bowles

Amendment proposed, clause 16, page 18, line 38, at end insert the competitiveness and growth objective, see section 1B, and... Baroness... Um, it's late, so I shall be relatively brief and not revisit the issues that we did at committee stage. But when I tabled these amendments, I still hoped that there would be some agreement reached on restoring the information hooks that Parliament has relied on until now for oversight, and to suggest a minimum set of reporting requirements in the current void of the strategy report. But it has been made clear by the minister now, and also including in discussions between the minister and the noble Baroness, Lady Noakes, as chair of the select committee, that the government will not accept any statutory requirements.

If that is the case, then the committee will have to draw that information in itself, and the letters from the regulators do offer the promise that they will cooperate in that. And I suggest that we should take that opportunity to be able to do more things in real time rather than long after decisions are made. Now, obviously, it's for the committee to decide what it wants and when, in both written and oral information. But one way to address the gap would be a triannual cycle of structured meetings with regulators, and each session could explicitly track developments in consultations and rule-making, including the work of the statutory panels, with an additional cycle of other matters. So suitable timings could be late February.

Things you could do in February would include an operational alignment review of draft business plans, budgets, and cost-benefit analysis variances before they're locked in for the financial year. In mid-June, a session could be focused on the secondary competitiveness and growth objective, tracking live authorization times, licensing service level agreements, and regulatory overlap arising from current consultations and rule-making activity. In October, one could do a post-recess review of rule-making, Dear CEO letters, and summer period backlogs ahead of the autumn budget. Those are just examples of how you can get things to fit in with the other fiscal events. So adopting that kind of timetable would give Parliament timely visibility.

I think we could avoid boilerplate reporting and ensure accountability even though we lose the statutory hooks. But I don't think that either the regulators or the government really appreciated the message that crossing out all of these previous statutory things indicated. And it seemed as if Parliament had been totally ignored as a stakeholder and as a party that should have been consulted.

I hope that we can recover and actually come through this probably with more reporting in the end, but pulling it in at our request. I don't see that this is something that we have to negotiate. This is something where Parliament can ask and we expect that the regulators will comply. Now that sounds aggressive. I actually think that it will be able to be negotiated relatively reasonably, at least if it's anything like the experience that I have had elsewhere.

07:20:04 - 07:28:41

Sheila Noakes

My Lords, this is the first time I've spoken at this report stage and so I need to declare my interests as shown in the register, namely that I hold shares in listed financial services companies which may well be affected by the content of this bill. I should start, my Lords, by thanking the government for tabling amendment 31, which is in fact identical to an amendment which I tabled for committee. The minister, the noble Lord Lord Stockwood, who's in his place, then said that he could not accept my amendment because the government were looking into this point to determine if this is fully clear in the drafting of the clause. My Lords, that was nonsense. And I feel sorry for ministers who are told by their officials to say these sorts of things.

It was clear that the drafting of the bill was wrong and that my amendment put it right. And I'm very glad that the government have now caught up with me. Now the rest of the amendments in this group deal with the knotty issue of accountability of the regulators. The noble Baroness Lady Bowles of Berkhamsted has tabled several amendments to try and improve what is in this bill and reverse some of the changes in this bill which undoubtedly weakened the accountability arrangements. And of course I support those amendments.

But accountability means much more than plans and reports, which is what the noble Baroness's amendments tended to focus on. And some of us put forward various ideas in committee about how we could improve accountability. The point being that we were looking to get a step change in the accountability arrangements. Now it all comes back to the FSMA model, which my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe spoke about in the first group. And I support the FSMA model in principle, but it is under increasing strain, as has been mentioned already today.

It was first of all invented long before Brexit, when swathes of financial regulation were drawn up in the EU and scrutinized in detail by the EU Parliament. So when FSMA 23 paved the way for this additional delegation to the regulators of all of those EU competences, it was partially offset, only partially, by strengthening the role of Parliament, so that when the regulators use their powers to create rules and guidance, they now have to send that into the parliamentary committees, including the Financial Services and Regulation Committee, which as has already been said, I currently chair. Now I am clear that holding the regulators to account for how they are using their powers, that is real-time accountability rather than the ex-post accountability which annual reports deal with, is an uphill battle for very many reasons, not least an imbalance between the sort of resources, the scale of resources devoted to parliamentary committees compared with the vast resources that are deployed within our financial system regulators.

Now as we know, this bill creates yet more areas of delegated powers to the regulators, consumer credit which we debated earlier today, but also the payment systems which the noble Lord the Minister spoke to a few moments ago. And this again is why we need to strengthen the accountability arrangements rather than weaken them as this bill currently does. Now the government have partially recognized that the bill went too far and have tabled amendments on proportionality which we will debate on our next report day. But I believe that the balance is still shifted away too far from Parliament being able to operate effective accountability mechanisms. And that is why I tabled amendment 68 and I thank my noble friend Lord Bridges of Headley, noble Baroness Lady Bowles of Berkhamsted and the noble Lord Lord Borwick of Harringay for adding their names.

Amendment 68 proposes that both the Bank of England and the FCA set up an office of regulatory evaluation which would be independent within their organizations and tasked with reviewing and reporting on the full range of their regulatory actions. Now this could produce a much wider ranging sort of work than the parliamentary committees are able to do and if it were done well would very much enhance the way in which parliamentary accountability works. An office of regulatory evaluation exists in many international regulatory bodies. The Bank of England also set one up about a decade or so ago, though in fact it did relatively little and is now being disbanded. Now I do thank the Minister for acknowledging the concerns about effective accountability that have been expressed throughout our committee stage.

But of course the Minister has said that he will resist my amendment. Instead the Minister wants the regulators to work with the parliamentary committees including the Financial Services Regulation Committee to try and improve accountability. The Minister's already referred to the letters which the Treasury orchestrated from the FCA and the PRA setting out how they see parliamentary accountability. They do not say very much more than the regulators take parliamentary accountability seriously. And I would also note that there's been no equivalent letter from the Bank of England in respect of its non-PRA regulatory activities.

And many of the regulators' suggestions do not seem to me to address the core concerns of wanting to increase the effectiveness of real-time scrutiny of what the regulators are doing. Now the FCA's letter did declare itself open to views on how best to improve parliamentary scrutiny. The PRA's letter did not go quite that far. And in conversations with the Minister, he asked me as chairman of the Financial Services Regulation Committee to try and take something forward with the FCA to see if we can strengthen parliamentary accountability in ways which do not involve structural changes such as in amendment 68. And the noble Lord the Minister will have heard that one of my fellow committee members has already applied her mind to some creative ways in which that might take place.

And it would of course have to include not only the FCA but all of the other regulatory bodies operating in the financial services space. My Lords, I am skeptical about whether such engagement will do more than improve things at the margin. But in the spirit of being constructive, I am prepared to give it a go through the Financial Services Regulation Committee, and on that basis I shall not be moving my amendment. Now, my Lords, I predict that when we in Parliament next consider the next Financial Services Bill, which we do every few years, we will be returning to accountability. We may well not get a step change in how we hold the regulators to account until there has been a major regulatory failure, which the regulators then do not manage to talk themselves out of.

And then, my Lords, hindsight on accountability will be a wonderful thing.

07:28:41 - 07:33:27

George James Bridges

My Lords, I rise and I should declare my interests as an advisor to and shareholder in Banco Santander. You will be very pleased to know I will speak very briefly on amendment 68. My noble friend Baroness Noakes has just covered the waterfront in her exemplary manner, all incredibly well, making all the key points. But let me just briefly say this. First leg of this amendment about the FCA Office for Regulatory Evaluation.

My Lords, I think this is an extremely measured and well-constructed proposal from my noble friend. I proposed to set up something somewhat different, an Office for Financial Regulatory Accountability, which would stand outside all the regulators and would look at financial services regulation consultations and proposals in the round so as to provide an independent source for Parliament and everyone else to look at the impact of those actions and so that they could be analyzed and critically holding the regulators and supervisors to account. Many said to me that this they felt would become a backseat driver for the regulators and the supervisors and we'd have essentially someone second-guessing their actions, undermining potentially the operational independence that they have been given. This proposal from my noble friend, I think overcomes that very, very well. And while I'm very pleased that the noble Lord the Minister is making very constructive noises about the need for greater accountability and scrutiny, I'm somewhat disappointed that it seems that this proposal, which builds as far as I can see on the work of cost-benefit, of the cost-benefit panels within the FCA, would actually help Parliament hold the FCA to account with much greater independent analysis.

So I'd like the Minister when he sums up to give us a bit more argument as to why this is a bad idea. Let me now turn to the second leg of this amendment, which relates to the Bank of England and the Office for Regulatory Evaluation. Now, my Lords, it's rather sad that we are here at five minutes past ten, about fifteen of us debating one of the most important institutions in this country and how it is held to account and the means by which it evaluates its own performance. And I think this speaks volumes about how we in Parliament potentially need to up our game in how we hold the Bank of England to account. That is a criticism maybe aimed at all of us rather than the government.

But, my Lords, the independent office for evaluation, the Independent Evaluation Office within the Bank, does perform and has performed a very critical role. And when you look back and you see what various chairmen of the court have said about it, many of them have gone on the record over the last decade praising its work and saying it provides valuable input to them at the court and analyzing what the Bank is up to and making sure that the Bank is internally held to account.

And so when the Financial Times reported several weeks ago that the Bank of England was dismantling the IEO, I have to say alarm bells started to ring. So maybe the noble Lord the Minister when he sums up can answer some simple questions, and I obviously realize he's speaking on behalf of the Treasury, not the Bank of England. But what I'm trying to understand is first of all, what is the problem that this decision to dismantle the IEO trying to solve? What is it that they're actually trying to achieve, what is the progress they're trying to make by abolishing and dismantling the IEO, in particular as I say, given so many chairmen of the court have spoken in favor of it. That's the first point.

The second point builds on what my noble friend Baroness Noakes said. When the IEO is abolished and these internal external independent analysts are brought in, how many reviews does the court expect to commission? As my noble friend pointed out, the IEO has actually only published a relatively small handful of reviews. Is it going to be more or is it going to be less? Next, if the court chooses the subjects, how will we ensure that the uncomfortable issues that the bank needs to confront will be confronted?

And finally, does the noble Lord the Minister think that this move will increase the accountability and the scrutiny of the bank? That is really the litmus test that I have. Will it make sure that the bank's performance is going to be held even more to account? So my Lords, I do think that there are questions to answer here. I very much welcome, as I say, what the noble Lord the Minister has said about his wish to increase accountability and scrutiny.

I think that we're disagreeing here on the means by which to do so, so I look forward to his answers.

07:33:27 - 07:36:41

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, I want to begin by paying tribute to my noble friend Lady Noakes, to the Financial Services Regulation Committee, including Lady Bowles and Lord Vaux, and to the noble Lord Lord Bridges of Headley for their persistent pursuit of a very simple but important principle: as regulators gain more power and their remit expands, so too should the scope and effectiveness of the oversight to which they are subject. Lady Noakes has powerfully articulated the concern that the FISMA model has been stretched too far and that even our expert parliamentary committees are struggling with the volume and complexity of oversight. We need stronger, not weaker, democratic accountability, which is why we saw value in the Office of Regulatory Evaluation and or Lord Bridges' original model tabled at committee. We also share his concern about the dismantling of the Bank of England's IEO. My Lords, this is an area where the opposition will continue to develop our thinking for future legislation and would welcome engagement.

We're not comfortable with a system whose reaction seems to be to delegate every new or persistent problem to a regulator. We are however very pleased that Lady Noakes will continue to work with the Treasury and the regulators on improving parliamentary oversight through the relevant committees, and we look forward to working with her and others across the House, including Lady Bowles. I think what she's proposed represents a practical compromise which allows us to move on. However, a positive response to amendment 93 on first use of the new powers will also be important. One practical way in which the accountability gap could be narrowed a little and indeed trust in the FCA improved would be to strengthen the remit of the cost-benefit analysis panels which already sit within the regulators.

Their remit could extend beyond rule changes to include guidance and enforcement activity. They could be given the ability to request an assessment of changes which the regulator has judged to be immaterial. This would strengthen internal challenge, improve confidence in the regulatory process and provide Parliament with more useful and more independent information. I haven't brought back yet another amendment on this, but I hope the Minister can commit to looking seriously at this proposal as part of follow-up to this useful debate. I should add finally that I welcome the first amendment, the government's amendment on competitiveness and growth.

And I'm only sorry that the name of the Financial Services Regulation Committee doesn't seem to have made its way into the statute.

07:36:41 - 07:38:35

David Pitt

My Lords, I won't take up too much of your time because I think I've responded to many of the points at the beginning of this debate. As regards the Independent Evaluation Office at the Bank of England, I think the Bank is committed to independent evaluation. It's strengthening the independence of the reviews it commissions by moving to a model where it commissions external independent experts to lead the reviews. But look, what I would want to say would very much echo what Baroness Neville-Rolfe has said in thanking Baroness Noakes and actually Baroness Bowles as well, I should add, because we do have our commitment from the FCA. And indeed, if you want to be cynical about it, it's maybe not as wholesome a commitment as you might want, but it does say accountability, scrutiny and proportionality are central and they want to support effective parliamentary scrutiny, which I think is where it is that we are all coming from.

And I would just thank her and her committee for picking up the baton on all of this because we must all, Parliament and regulators and with the help of government where we can help, work together to have a regulatory environment that is effective and proportionate. But with that in mind, the government does not think that at this stage further legislative amendments are helpful and I would ask the noble lady to withdraw her amendment. Oh, in that case, I've made it to the end of day one.

07:38:35 - 07:38:58

Speaker 112

I think the noble Lord is pressing his amendment number 31. Clause 16, page 18, insert the words on the marshalled list. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.

Amendment 32, Baroness Bowles. Not moved. Amendment 33, Baroness Bowles. Not moved.

07:38:58 - 07:39:04

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I beg to move that further consideration on report be adjourned.

07:39:04 - 07:39:16

Speaker 112

The question is that the consideration on report be now adjourned. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Now adjourned.

This House do now adjourn.