House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittings

Andy McDonald
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The bill we passed last night gives the Attorney General of England and Wales the power to override decisions on Troubles-related prosecutions. Yet the Secretary of State told the House yesterday, "This is not to take anything away from the prosecuting authorities in Northern Ireland or in Great Britain." But that is precisely what the bill does. The Attorney General could effectively overrule a decision by Northern Ireland's independent Public Prosecution Service.
How can the Secretary of State reconcile that with the 2000 criminal justice review flowing from the Good Friday Agreement, which deliberately removed political interference from prosecution decisions?
Chris Bryant
Let me be absolutely clear, there will be no political interference in any of these decisions. But as the Joint Committee on Human Rights of both our two Houses recommended, we think that it is appropriate that the prosecuting authorities in Northern Ireland and in England and Wales both come to their conclusions and will be drawing up guidelines on how to deal with Troubles-related issues that may follow on from the Legacy Commission. But in the end, the final prosecutorial decision is a very simple, non-political one, which is whether it's in the public interest and whether there is more than a 50% likelihood of getting a successful conviction. And I'm glad that the House yesterday evening agreed that without a division.
Jim Allister
What does the Secretary of State think that victims of the Provisional IRA felt when they heard the PSNI confirm that the Provos still exist, and that the Chief Constable and maybe the Secretary of State were influenced on Drumcree by the feelings of the Provisional IRA? What does that even mean, taking account of the feelings of the Provisional IRA?
Chris Bryant
Well, Mr. Speaker, I know you wouldn't want me to intrude on a judicial review which is ongoing, and the judge reserved his judgment yesterday, so I'm not going to do that, I'm afraid.
Andrew Murrison
The government's bill will undoubtedly open up the prospect of reopened coroners' inquests into deaths that occurred during the Troubles. What confidence does the Secretary of State have in the Northern Ireland Coroners Service to deliver truth and justice, and importantly, access to the truth for victims and veterans as well, compared with the coronial system in England and Wales?
Chris Bryant
Well, I mean, I note that it's a very similar cast list today, Mr. Speaker, to yesterday and the day before in here, and some of these issues were adumbrated in the discussions that we had. There is obviously a difference in the system, in the coronial system in Northern Ireland. I've heard people making suggestions about how we might want to reform it. One of the reforms that we've put in the bill, which I think is important, is that inquests will no longer be allowed to repeat processes that have been undergone elsewhere, just as the Legacy Commission won't be able to either.
Alex Burghart
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And as this is his first Northern Ireland questions, may I welcome the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to his place. Victims and survivors of the Troubles will, as the honourable gentleman from North Antrim said, be deeply concerned to hear that on Monday, police intelligence documents produced in the High Court in Belfast referred to the ongoing existence of the IRA.
Will the Secretary of State please tell the House, is it the government's understanding that the IRA is still active?
Chris Bryant
Well, I'm afraid, Mr. Speaker, that again the right honorable gentleman is asking me to talk about proceedings in the High Court in Northern Ireland, and I think that it would be inappropriate for me to do so.
Alex Burghart
With all due respect, Mr. Speaker, I wasn't asking him to comment on the case, I know that he can't. What I was asking him to do was to tell us what the government's considered opinion is on whether the IRA is still active. This is very important because of the document that was produced, one of the documents that was produced on Monday, which revealed that the Secretary of State was, this is for context, the Secretary of State was told by the police, and I quote, "It is possible dissident Republicans have already accessed the firearms in the Galwally Road area, and it is possible that in the event of police removing protesters, firearms may be used to attack police." It would not interfere with the court process for the Secretary of State to tell us, is it the Secretary of State's understanding that the IRA has rearmed?
Chris Bryant
The Shadow Secretary of State is asking me to comment on documents that were produced in the judicial review into my decision on Drumcree. I am not going to do that because I think that that would be a conflict with the judicial review process and I don't want to be held in contempt of court.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Troubles Bill has, as the Secretary of State has now said, has now passed to the other place, notwithstanding continuing concerns from the Senior Generals and Veterans Associations, more still needs to be done. I thank the Secretary of State for his sustained engagement and openness with veterans organizations, including the SAS Regimental Association, with whom I have been working closely. Any adversarial framing of the relationship between veterans and victims is something we must avoid, as I remain convinced a compromise can be reached to ensure proper protections for veterans can be achieved whilst delivering justice for victims. So will the Secretary of State commit to continue to work with the SAS Regimental Association and their lawyers to ensure the bill delivers the vital safeguards our veterans need?
Yes.
Gavin Robinson
Mr. Speaker, the Secretary of State will know that Micheál Martin today is going to apologize to the family of Brian Stack, who was murdered by the IRA in 1983. They apologize 43 years later and they apologize after a failed criminal justice investigation with 194 errors and omissions. They are right to do so. But Austin Stack, the son of Brian, has also asked that Sinn Féin, Mary Lou McDonald as leader, apologize on behalf of her counterparts in the IRA. And one of the things that wasn't mentioned over the last two days was how much confidence there will be that those who took lives and hold deep and dark truths share them with loved ones.
Chris Bryant
I heard the interview this morning as well on the radio, and I warmly welcome the fact that the Taoiseach is going to be making this apology. It is entirely right and proper. I think it goes to some of the discussions that we had yesterday and the day before about how the Irish government deals with the issues of the past. And this was of course a prison guard from the United Kingdom who was killed in Dublin. And I heard also the point that Austin made, his son, when he said that the apology means an awful lot to us.
I think it's incumbent on all of us to make fulsome and not mealy-mouthed apologies.
Gavin Robinson
Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for his answer. One of the fundamental principles of the debate yesterday and on Monday is about upholding the rule of law. And he will know that there are questions about how the rule of law is upheld in Northern Ireland. I know he buckled when individuals suggested that government had bent the knee to terror, and yet some of the revelations from the court proceedings over the last two days, I think, give greater clarity to the thought process that lay behind the PSNI's position. But my question is this: given the situation we are in, will the Secretary of State engage not only to uphold the rule of law and ensure the criminal sanctions go beyond blocking a road, but provide political accountability for those who breach their pledge of office?
Chris Bryant
He makes a very strong point, I think, about political accountability. I think the rule of law is something that we all pledge to uphold when we become members of Parliament, and that's also true for members of the Legislative Assembly and, for that matter, members of the Executive. I also think we need to have political accountability for finances in Northern Ireland. I think it's really important that we make sure that at some point or other, the Northern Ireland Executive gets round to settling a budget. We've set aside more than 1.5 billion pounds over the next three years.
I look forward to conversations with him and others tomorrow, and I very much hope that we might be able to settle that. But he's right: we need to have political and financial accountability, and if that means changing the Northern Ireland Act to achieve that, then I'm up for that.
Chris Bryant
She asks, Mr. Speaker, what steps we are taking to replace the Legacy Act of 2023. I refer her to the debates of yesterday and the day before.
Rebecca Smith.
Rebecca Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for that answer. Yesterday's third reading vote, though, on the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill has reopened the door to continual vexatious cases against Northern Ireland veterans, including Alan Ewan and Ivor from my constituency. Will he continue to work on the bill, which many agreed is not perfect, to ensure that there are adequate protections against lawfare?
Chris Bryant
I think it's really important that not only have we completed our processes here, but that we now, when the bill is going through to the House of Lords, I'm very happy, as I said to the honorable gentleman for Wimbledon, I'm very happy to work with all the different associations, including veterans in her own constituency if she has people who want to meet with me, to make sure that we end up with the bill that really works. But I would just urge her to say, and all honorable members, to say to veterans in their constituency, first of all, that there will be answers for veterans' families, because many lost loved ones. Secondly, that no veteran will be cold-called, and no veteran will be approached unless there is compelling new evidence. And no process will be repeated unless it is essential. These are guarantees for all, but in particular for our veterans.
Antonia Louise Antoniazzi
Chair of the Select Committee, Tonia Antoniazzi.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The previous government's Legacy Act failed to command the confidence of victims, survivors, and many, many veterans. But would he join me in thanking the organizations representing the victims, survivors, and veterans that have engaged with my committee and with members across this House and indeed with himself?
Chris Bryant
I'm really grateful to my honorable friend, the member for Gower, because she's absolutely right that the bill, although sometimes I think our debates have felt that it was an armed forces bill, this was actually a bill that was primarily about families, including the families of veterans, of course. And Joe McVeigh, who brought several members of his group along here earlier on this week, I think has very much informed the debate that we've had. But in the end, the most important thing is getting answers for families, and I think her committee has led the way on this.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Now, the government has united the SAS Regimental Association, the SBS Association, and the Special Reconnaissance Regimental Association against the Troubles Bill, with the SAS Regimental Association dismissing this legislation as incoherent, contradictory, imprecise, and muddled. They are rightly very concerned about the potential impact of this bill on special forces recruitment and retention. And yesterday, the government voted down the opposition amendment that would see Parliament have proper oversight of this. So can I ask the Secretary of State, as the bill begins its passage through the other place, can he work with the Ministry of Defence to ensure that Parliament has sufficient oversight of special forces recruitment and retention?
Chris Bryant
Well, as I said yesterday, I think it would be false to make a direct equation between special forces recruitment and our bill. I would, as I pointed out yesterday, actually recruitment in the armed forces is up at the moment, it's 7% up, that's the first time. And whilst it is true, of course, that we want to make sure that confidence and morale in the armed forces is upheld, I think our bill will actually help achieve that. I'd just push back on one point. He says that everybody's united.
Actually, there are many different views in the veterans community on the bill. I'm very happy to work with all the different associations to make sure that we get to the right answers at the end of the process.
Sarah Pouchin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Why does the Secretary of State, question number four? I think he's already called it. Yeah, number question number four.
Chris Bryant
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll answer questions 4, 7, 9, 10, and 12 together. The government is committed to supporting all our veterans, including those who served under Operation Banner, and ensuring they receive fair treatment and consistent support. That is why we're expanding the Armed Forces Covenant to remove disadvantages and recognize sacrifices, and the MOD recently announced that the Brook House Health and Wellbeing Centre, which does brilliant work to support veterans, has been awarded £1 million to develop a Valor recognized centre in Northern Ireland.
Speaker 34
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Why does the Secretary of State think that he and his government know better than the SAS, SBS, all other Northern Ireland veterans, and indeed the former Minister for Defence, who all warn that this Troubles Bill will risk further prosecutions of our brave veterans?
Chris Bryant
Well, I disagree with her, actually. I've had many conversations with a lot of veterans associations, and I think all of them have recognized many of the changes that we brought into the bill. So, for instance, introducing the concept of compelling new evidence before anybody can be called as a witness, making sure that the concept of essential is a high bar, not a low bar for people, and making sure that nobody can be cold-called. I'm very happy to work with all honorable members to make sure that the bill in its final version is one that everybody can support.
Andrew Steven Ranger
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. 47 years ago, Private Robert Vaughan Jones, brother of my constituent Edward, was one of the 18 British paratroopers tragically killed in the Warrenpoint ambush. Robert's parents passed away never knowing the facts of their son's death, and Edward fears that he too might never know the full story of what happened. Will my right honorable friend confirm that the government remains committed to providing closure to the families of Troubles victims, and that the transferal of cases from the ICRIR to the new Legacy Commission will not impact or further delay the delivery of those answers?
Chris Bryant
My honorable friend is absolutely right, we have to make sure that the Legacy Commission takes on the good work that has been done by the ICRIR, even as we are improving it so it can get more answers for people.
But I also want to push back against this idea that there are veterans here and there are families here. Actually, a very large number of the people who are seeking answers and will do through the Legacy Commission are families of veterans.
Peter Swallow
Kit Swallow. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. At the heart of this lies a really important principle. Can my right honorable friend set out why we on this side of the House do not believe it is morally acceptable to offer immunity to terrorists involved in killing both innocent civilians and, as we have just heard, those brave service people who served their country on Operation Banner?
Chris Bryant
Well, one of the reasons that we had a manifesto commitment and one of the reasons that we said this before the last general election was that we believed that the Legacy Act of 2023 was morally and legally deficient. Legally deficient as it was struck down in the courts and morally deficient because it made an equivalence between the lawful action of our armed forces seeking to preserve the peace and the deliberate acts of terrorists. And we think that that was morally wrong and offensive.
Richard Baker
Luke Baker. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Fife is home to more veterans than any other part of Scotland, many of whom gave dedicated service to this country as part of Operation Banner. Can my right honorable friend assure these veterans, who many members spoke of in the debates this week, that they will always have their rights and welfare not only protected but extended through our pledge to the Armed Forces Covenant?
Chris Bryant
One of the things that I've campaigned on for many years is acquired brain injury. And one of my anxieties about what has happened to veterans over the years in this country is it's felt as if we've sort of left them to one side. It's shocking that we still have so many veterans who are homeless. I'm proud that our Prime Minister, one of the first things he said was that he wants to end homelessness. We need to do that in Northern Ireland just as anywhere else in the United Kingdom.
And we also need to make sure that our veterans get the real support that they need to be able to live fruitful lives and work in after their service.
Luke Akehurst
Luke Cost. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Veterans in my constituency were let down by the last government's Legacy Act, which offered nothing but false promises. What reassurance can the Secretary of State give to Operation Banner veterans in North Durham that they will not be subject to unnecessary repeat investigations and that the operational context of their deployment will be taken into account?
Chris Bryant
One of the key asks of all the veterans' organizations was that we should introduce a change to the bill which said that there was no equivalence between the lawful actions of our armed forces and those of terrorists and recognize the operational context in which people were functioning, including their training, their command structure, and so on. That's precisely what we've done in the legislation. And I commend him for the way that he's raised many of these issues with me directly on behalf of the veterans in his constituency.
Robin Swann
Robin Swann. Much, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State has made much of his support for veterans and that is right, although it has come late. Will he also give that same support and reassurance from the government to the former members of the RUC and the police services who also served during the Troubles?
Chris Bryant
The honorable member makes a really good point about former members of the RUC. I was very struck when I went to the RUC Memorial Garden in Belfast where you can see that decade after decade the number of RUC officers who were killed in action. And as you get closer to the sixties, the seventies, the eighties, and the nineties, it goes from being three, four, or five to dozens. We owe them a debt of gratitude. And I say to them, as I say to everybody who served under Operation Banner, thank you for your service.
Alex Easton
Alex Easton.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can the Secretary of State reassure Operation Banner veterans that where recent legacy investigations and future ones that the government will seek all necessary records and evidence from the Irish government, because on this side of the House, we don't believe that will happen? And could you ask the Taoiseach if he would do a public statement to reassure us that the Irish government will release all their documents?
Chris Bryant
Secretary of State. I think it's absolutely essential that the Irish government fully cooperates with the process. I'm very confident that they will do so. I've spoken directly to Jim O'Callaghan and Helen McEntee, the two ministers responsible for these issues in the Irish government. But they are partners of ours.
We need to work with them to be able to get answers for the many thousands of people who lost loved ones during the Troubles era.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Mr. Speaker, first of all, can I thank the Secretary of State for that reply? Beyond the battlefield in my constituency of Strangford delivers the care for those soldiers and veterans who fall under the radar and aren't picked up by the charities, those who have PTSD and have family breakdowns, have been in prison. What can be done to ensure that Beyond the Battlefield in my constituency looks after the veterans that others forget about, to ensure that the funding that's necessary for them can be made available so they can do more and help more people?
Chris Bryant
I didn't catch all of that, Mr. Speaker. I'm not sure whether you did, but I heard the word, I think I heard PTSD. And actually, one of the, as I was saying earlier, one of the things I've campaigned on is acquired brain injury. And in the armed forces, my suspicion is that lots of people were told that they had PTSD when actually they'd had an acquired brain injury which had never been properly diagnosed. It's one of the pieces of work that we need to do far more effectively.
I really want to look at how we properly look after those who are serving now in Northern Ireland into the future to make sure that they can have the most fruitful lives possible.
Speaker 32
That completes questions on Northern Ireland. Point of order. Point of order.
Alex Burghart
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State twice refused to answer questions about documents referred to in JR proceedings in the High Court in Belfast, which refer to the ongoing existence of the IRA. Mr. Speaker, can you confirm that there is no parliamentary rule, including the sub judice rule, which would have prevented the Secretary of State from answering these questions?
Lindsay Hoyle
I can confirm that the sub judice rule does not apply to judicial review proceedings which relate to a ministerial decision, as in this case. However, the answers given by the Secretary of State are a matter for him and not the Chair, so I'm not being drawn in. Right. Order. Before we come to Prime Minister's Questions, may I extend a warm welcome to the Speaker of the National Assembly of Zimbabwe and his delegation, which is cross-party, who are with us today.
Also, before we begin, colleagues will know that today marks the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster, which claimed 116 children and 28 adults. As a child, I remember the shock that went across the nation when the news of that disaster broke. Last week was a very haunting to meet David Davies, a different one, the chairman of the Aberfan Memorial Trust and a survivor. Hearing his recollections of that horrific day was incredibly moving. I know the whole House will join me in paying tribute to those who lost their lives, their families, and the whole community in Aberfan and the surrounding area for the courageous spirit and dignity of the aftermath of this tragic event.
Speaker 41
Prime Minister. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Today we welcome the Sultan of Oman on the occasion of the state visit, an opportunity to recognize the deep and historic ties between our countries and the vital role they have played regarding the Strait of Hormuz.
Mr. Speaker, as you say, today also marks the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster. And I'm sure the thoughts of the whole House will be with the community today and with the people of Wales. I visited on Monday and heard how the injustices the people suffered at the time and in the aftermath of the tragedy at the hands of the state still hurt. This is a day to recognize that, say sorry for it, but celebrate the strength and spirit of a community that has stood together through adversity all of these years. Mr. Speaker, I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others this morning.
In addition to my duties in this House, I will have further such meetings later today.
Clive Jones
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And like you, I have recollections of Aberfan and of being in a primary school myself at that time. Too many patients are suffering due to treatment delays and having their cancers missed. My Cancer Reporting and Strategy Private Member's Bill would require annual reports to Parliament on cancer diagnosis, outcomes, and delivery. Will the Prime Minister commit to supporting this bill to ensure his government and all future governments are held to account by this House for improving cancer diagnosis and outcomes?
Prime Minister.
Speaker 41
Can I thank the honorable gentleman for his question and recognize his sincerity and personal experience in this and this regard. We do have a national cancer plan to drive the improvements that he calls for. As part of that, we've also are establishing an independent National Cancer Board, and I will ask them to look at the proposal that he is making. And last week, I met Archie Goodburn with the Health Secretary to look at how we make the UK a world leader in trials for brain cancer treatment. So there's huge progress, but we can work with him to deliver more.
Alistair Strathern.
Alexander Forbes McIntyre
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. When Ian and Emma bought their flat a few years ago, they were told there's a 10-year warranty on its conversion from office buildings. The lift broke down in February this year and it's still not fixed. Emma is disabled, she relies on that lift and has effectively been trapped in her own home for months. It turns out the warranty doesn't cover the lift and residents are being asked for 50,000 pounds to fix it.
So can the Prime Minister update the House on when Gloucester residents like Ian and Emma can expect to see his commitments to leasehold reform move forward?
Prime Minister.
Speaker 41
Can I thank my honorable friend for raising that question? And I think we all feel for Emma given the position that she is in. And I can give him an assurance, Mr. Speaker, that she and many thousands of others up and down the country need wait no longer for leasehold reform. We will bring forward the Leasehold Reform Bill as soon as possible, hopefully this year.
Kemi Badenoch
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I associate myself with your remarks and the Prime Minister's remarks on the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan tragedy and express our heartfelt and continued condolences to that community. Mr. Speaker, last week I asked the Prime Minister to stop faffing about, so can I thank him for finally approving the Jackdaw gas field. I noticed there were no cheers on the government benches.
The Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives first approved Jackdaw in 2022. Rather, rather than fighting the lefty activists that tried to block it, Labour appointed one of them as Energy Secretary. So many jobs lost, Mr. Speaker, so much time and money wasted. Britain cannot be a serious player on the world stage if the government dithers for two and a half years over approving a single license. We have the resources, the expertise, and the people.
What we have lost is the confidence to make tough decisions. So will the Prime Minister now overturn Labour's ban on all new oil and gas licenses?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, can we get something straight at the start of Prime Minister's Questions today? We have made a decision that her government messed up. That's why there was the delay, because they didn't do the process properly. And we've made a pragmatic decision, Mr. Speaker, that will allow us to do two things. Firstly, build a bridge to a renewable future, because the resources that come in now from this decision will allow us to invest in renewables, bring forward clean energy, and in this Parliament, substantially delink gas and electricity prices so that we can bring bills down.
And it will also allow us, Mr. Speaker, to do more to help people with bills. I can tell the House today that I have asked the Chancellor and the Energy Secretary to look at whether we can remove standing charges from gas bills and to report back to this House at the earliest opportunity.
Kemi Badenoch
I was surprised to see him mention process, it almost felt like it was Keir Starmer still standing. The Prime Minister talks about renewables, of course we need renewables, but we live in the real world, the world that still needs oil and gas, the world that depends on it. And if we don't produce it, Britain and Europe will buy it from Russia. In July, the Prime Minister said, and I quote, "The question isn't whether Britain will still be using oil and gas, the question is where does it come from?" He was right.
Does the Prime Minister accept that every barrel of North Sea oil we produce is a barrel that Europe won't buy from Vladimir Putin?
Speaker 41
Well, can I find a point of agreement with the right honourable lady? This decision does strengthen our energy security. It will release gas into British homes and British industry starting in the next few weeks, and it does support us in a difficult time. I appreciate that she wants us to take further decisions that she messed up when she was in government. But can I make it really clear, Mr. Speaker, the reason why they messed up these decisions is because they are quasi-judicial decisions.
We will run these decisions properly. The Energy Secretary considered this decision against our climate obligations and concluded it was consistent. We will, as she will, oversee the same process in relation to future decisions.
Kemi Badenoch
Mr. Speaker, he says that it strengthens our energy security, so that means that he should approve all new oil and gas licenses.
Blaming the process and our decisions, he's the Prime Minister now and we are facing a global energy crisis. Drilling more oil and gas in the North Sea would give us more energy, more jobs and more tax revenue, something that we desperately need. There is a red warning light flashing on the economy. Just this morning, total government borrowing hit three trillion pounds, its highest ever. That's a hundred thousand pounds for every household in the country.
Even the Prime Minister's former economic advisor, Andy Haldane, not someone I always agree with, has warned that Britain faces a precarious fiscal backdrop. So what is the Prime Minister doing to get borrowing down?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, can I just say to the honorable lady on energy, she is displaying for the House and the nation today why they got those decisions wrong. Because she didn't and they didn't give any regard to our climate obligations. These things have to be considered in the round and they have been considered in the round and that's why the decision the government has made is a decision that is the right decision. On the economy, I'm not sure that the right honorable lady has read the report from the International Monetary Fund last week. Because if she had read that report, she would see its clear conclusion that Britain is the standout nation for deficit reduction.
Britain, the fastest growing, joint fastest growing in the G7. Britain, the country that only yesterday saw unemployment down and improved labor market statistics. It's time she talked the country up rather than constantly talk it down.
Kemi Badenoch
Mr. Speaker, I asked him how he was getting borrowing down. He didn't answer. He's talking about the IMF report. I have looked at it. I don't think that he has because it downgrades the forecast for next year.
But also, also, it talks about deficit reduction plans in 2029. That's after an election. They're not going to be here after that election. They haven't made, they haven't made, they haven't made any cuts, Mr. Speaker. We are spending more on interest payments than we do on schools, the army and the police combined.
Meanwhile, the Prime Minister is worrying about loud music on trains. This is not serious. The only solution to the challenges facing our country is to cut spending and cut borrowing. The out-of-work benefits bill is set to rise by fifty billion pounds under this Labour government. So will the Prime Minister get a grip and cut the welfare bill?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, she asks me about cutting spending. I did exactly that first day in office, digital ID program, so that we could take action to support, to support people, so that we could remove VAT off electricity bills, which is what we have delivered, a tax cut. But she asks about the big decisions and I want to come directly back to what she's saying. I'm not going to apologize for doing the small things that help people have better lives. I'm not going to apologize for that.
But I also take the big decisions that they have avoided for many years. And let me go directly to one, directly to one, social care. I grasped the nettle in a way that nobody on their side ever has. And I made a difficult spending decision to lay a path towards a national care service. Have they had the time to read the COVID inquiry report yesterday about the appalling state of social care as it went into the pandemic, the hundreds of thousands of British people who suffered as a result of that, the lives that were lost?
I need no lectures from the other side about taking tough decisions on social care. I suggest they go away from this PMQs, read that report and have a period of reflection.
Kemi Badenoch
Mr. Speaker, I asked him about welfare. He didn't answer the welfare question. That's because he's not planning to cut welfare. This morning the Telegraph exposed today that the reforms he's talking about won't save any money before 2030. In fact, the Prime Minister's plan is to save money on welfare by spending more money on welfare.
This is ridiculous. He's talking about big decisions. He hasn't made any decision on social care. Talking about it is not making a decision. He is going to keep spending more and that means he's going to keep borrowing more.
We know where that leads. This morning inflation rose to three and a half percent, the third rise in a row. Families are paying higher bills and more for their weekly shop and it's leading to higher mortgage rates. Does the Prime Minister accept that his failure to control borrowing is contributing to higher inflation?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, can I say to the right honorable lady, I don't think she was listening to what I said. I did take a difficult decision to lay a path to the National Care Service and it involves a change to the triple lock. And I'm happy to stand at this dispatch box and defend that because I am confident that we should support older people financially but with better social care support in later life. That is my decision. I'm happy to stand here and defend it.
Where's their decision on social care? When are they going to respond to what the report said yesterday? On welfare, I will do the same. I don't want to see anybody in their twenties on benefits in this country. I want to see them in work, in training, in education.
And that is the reform that we will bring forward on the back of the Milburn report. She mentions inflation. She may notice that there is a situation ongoing in the Middle East where we don't have full control of that situation. But what I can say to her, the fundamentals of the British economy are getting stronger and stronger under this government. We will take the right long-term decisions and she should wait for the budget and she will see that laid out in this house.
Kemi Badenoch
Mr. Speaker, we are waiting for the budget. And next week at the budget, the Prime Minister has a choice. He can cut spending, he can cut the deficit, or he can cut tax. There's no other way. That's why that's the Conservative plan, a plan that even his former economic advisor, Andy Haldane, says is the better way.
So will he follow that plan or will he bottle it just like Keir Starmer did?
Speaker 41
Well, Mr. Speaker, as I've said, you know, there are signs of growing strength in the British economy. And I think before the budget next week, we will have a new book published about the mini-budget of a few years ago. And they've gone quiet, Mr. Speaker, because the authors of that mini-budget are sitting across these benches, including the Shadow Chancellor. Does anybody on this side or anybody around the country believe that this party of all parties has the audacity to come to this house and lecture us about how to do a budget? People in this country, British households, are still paying the price of that disastrous budget.
Claire Hanna
Last week, three-year-old Mariam Ghanam was pulled from her home in Gaza, badly burned, having watched her mother be killed by an Israeli airstrike. On the same day, Irish writer Sally Rooney's publisher announced that it would stop distributing her books across the UK because she's donating her royalties to Palestine Action, proscribed by Keir Starmer's government. The Prime Minister has acknowledged that the previous government's response to Gaza was inadequate, and his Foreign Secretary, making a powerful move on sanctions last month, has said that those campaigning for change were right. But the proscription remains in place with these extraordinary consequences for freedom of expression, including for constituents of mine who are facing terror charges for peaceful protest. Will the Prime Minister commit to reviewing the proscription of Palestine Action and righting this unnecessary wrong?
Speaker 41
Can I say to my honourable friend, Mr. Speaker, that we agree the scenes from Gaza and the West Bank are deeply distressing. It's why the Foreign Secretary has taken the action that he has. We won't stand by when the viability of the two-state solution is threatened, and he's made a further statement in relation to that this week. When it comes to the proscription of Palestine Action, it followed a rigorous and evidence-based process that came before this House, endorsed by Parliament. The matter is a live legal case, so I won't comment further than that.
Edward Jonathon Davey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I associate myself with your remarks and the remarks of others about the terrible tragedy in Aberfan sixty years ago. Our thoughts and prayers are with the survivors, their families, and the whole community there. Mr. Speaker, I find it amazing to hear the Conservative leader talk about the economy after everything her party did to wreck the economy. Mr. Speaker, the single biggest thing the Prime Minister could do to fix growth is to take the UK back into the European single market and customs union, which they failed the country on.
That would boost revenues so we could raise the personal allowance and give everyone a tax cut. When I pushed him last week on a new economic strategy based on trade with Europe, he said no. Is the Prime Minister really saying that after all he's rightly said about the damage that their Brexit has done to our economy, is he really saying that he's going to wait until after the next election before considering the single market?
Speaker 41
Well, can I say to the right honourable gentleman that we have before us a UK-EU summit, 20th of November. It is an opportunity for this House to come together and get a good deal for food producers, for farmers in this country, a good deal for Northern Ireland in relation to energy costs in Northern Ireland, and hopefully more cooperation on illegal migration. It is an opportunity to take an important step back to get growth in the British economy, more control of migration. I'm picking up that he will give us that support. We are already working to reduce the risks from the Made in Europe initiative and we're making good progress there.
If this House was to come together, it would give me the strongest position to go to that summit and get a good deal for British farmers and British food producers, and I wait for the party opposite to come to this because that is exactly what they need right now.
Edward Jonathon Davey
Speaker, we need to grow our economy, and without a proper plan, a more urgent plan on re-engaging with Europe on trade, I feel that next week's budget will not be the growth budget our country needs.
Mr. Speaker, this week Ukraine's defense system was seriously undermined by the US restricting access to Elon Musk's Starlink system. Musk says that the order came from the White House, but the Telegraph and the Wall Street Journal have revealed that Musk put the idea to Donald Trump himself. Now, I understand the Prime Minister's reluctance to criticize the President of the United States, but does he agree that directly aiding Putin in this way is beyond the pale? And will he work with European allies to prevent Elon Musk getting the licenses he wants that would make our continent even more dependent on his satellite system?
Speaker 41
Can I say to the right honorable gentleman, of course I have concerns about any move that diminishes the military capability of Ukraine in the position in which it finds itself at this moment in time. Of course he is right about that, and I'm sure that sentiment is echoed right around this country. But it is a situation that is currently fragile and needs careful handling. There were talks in Oslo yesterday where the UK government was represented. I think at this moment in time, I think we need to handle the situation carefully so that we can bring back all sides to get the support behind President Zelenskyy and Ukraine.
And I can assure him the UK government is working on every single level to bring that about.
Margaret Pamela Cox
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Endometriosis affects around one in ten women in the UK. I've heard from many women in Colchester and North East Essex who are living in chronic pain with this condition. That's a pain that's prolonged by unnecessarily long waits for treatment and diagnosis. Could the Prime Minister tell the House what steps the government's taking to speed up access to treatment?
Speaker 41
Well, my honorable friend is right to raise this condition in the House because I know there are women across the country who suffer terribly with it and often feel they are not seen, not listened to when it comes to the treatment that they need. It's why our women's health strategy set out precisely how we will improve treatment for conditions that uniquely or disproportionately affect women, including endometriosis. It's about redesigning clinical pathways, removing the need for repeat appointments. There is a lot to do, but I can assure her it's very high on the government's agenda.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Energy Secretary herself has admitted that Jackdaw won't bring down bills and will create only 27 jobs. The Labour 2024 manifesto said the climate crisis is the greatest global challenge we face. And the UN has warned today that we're breaching safe climate limits, meaning more of the heatwaves, wildfires, and catastrophic floods that killed thousands this summer. So can the Prime Minister explain why he's pouring more fuel on the fire of climate breakdown?
Does he disagree with the overwhelming scientific consensus that fossil fuels must stay in the ground, or was the oil and gas lobby simply too difficult to ignore?
Speaker 41
Well, can I say to the right honorable lady that the gas would still be needed. It would just be imported from somewhere else if we didn't use our own reserves. And in these difficult times, when we have resources, I think the public would expect us to use them to help people, to get jobs secure in Aberdeen, and I'm sure people in Aberdeen appreciate what's been announced today. But there's a big difference, Mr. Speaker, between an ideological approach, which is I think what she's putting to the House, and a pragmatic approach, which is what I am announcing today. The truth of the matter is, Mr. Speaker, the revenue that comes in from this decision to the Treasury will enable us to speed up the rollout of renewables, build towards a clean energy future, and that in the end will help us delink gas and electricity prices and get bills down.
Speaker 53
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents should be able to rely on deliveries from the Royal Mail. But post is being held up for weeks on end and it's causing serious issues for far too many people. So will the Prime Minister join me in urging the senior leadership of the Royal Mail to do the right thing by my constituents and our postal workers and put in place a system that works?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend is right. Royal Mail's service has been unacceptable for far too long. They have been asked in to see ministers on a regular basis. Ofcom is looking at the situation as well. Let's be clear, they need to bring forward a plan to restore service standards to the level they need to be at.
They need to do it quickly or we will consider further measures.
Jerome Mayhew
Mr. Speaker, last week the Prime Minister struggled to disclose all his dealings with the owners of Manchester City Football Club. So I ask him this. In September, did the Prime Minister have a meeting scheduled with Khaldoon Al Mubarak?
Speaker 41
I answered the honorable gentleman last week and I set out, I set out very clearly in the statement that I made. And it was all covered in that, in that statement and there's no more I need to add.
Lewis Atkinson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Waits for NHS mental health care are far too long. Our constituents are 200 times more likely to be waiting 18 months for help with a mental health condition than they are with a physical health one. A key reason for this is that for a long time there have been clear standards set for physical health access that we're all familiar with, four hours for A&E, 18 weeks for physical health. But such standards have not been set by successive governments for mental health.
Our manifesto promised to reform the NHS to give the same focus and attention for mental health as physical health. Will the Prime Minister ensure that the forthcoming mental health strategy delivers on that and sets clear standards to reduce mental health waits for people of all ages?
Speaker 41
I can, Mr. Speaker. The mental health strategy will do precisely that and it will confirm the plan to open 100 new community mental health centers across the country to get mental health support right into communities. And the Health Secretary is ensuring that we also bring forward 59 mental health emergency departments to give same-day support to people experiencing a crisis. And I'm pleased to say to my honorable friend there will be one of each in Sunderland.
Manuela Perteghella
Mr. Speaker, my constituent Matilda Davis was a wonderful and devoted mum and a full-time carer for her disabled seven-year-old child. Despite providing round-the-clock care, she received almost no support, leaving her physically and emotionally exhausted. Last October, social workers visited Matilda and she took her own life 15 minutes after they left. She was 36. Research from the University of Birmingham shows that 41% of parent carers have contemplated suicide.
Therefore will the Prime Minister meet with me and Matilda's family to discuss mandatory suicide prevention training for local authorities and other measures so that no more families suffer such a devastating loss?
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, I will ensure that a minister meets the honorable lady to discuss that proposal because I find myself in agreement with it. The right honorable gentleman has been very powerful on this point about unpaid carers, family carers who often sink under their responsibilities and find it very, very difficult. Sadly, in the case of Matilda, her constituent, obviously a devastating situation. So I will arrange that meeting and I thank her for raising the issue in the house today.
Michelle Scrogham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent Ian has a rare and aggressive form of cancer that is now sadly incurable. Clinicians have advised that Renora Fenib is the only remaining life-extending option. Until recently, the drug was provided free of charge through the compassionate use scheme. And following government's announcement on VAT reform, the developer Bayer have withdrawn from the scheme, the only company to do so, leaving Ian with no further options.
Ian doesn't have the luxury of time, so will the Prime Minister urgently commit to ensuring a solution to the VAT issue and provide Bayer with certainty to rejoin the scheme and meet with my constituent to see the real-life impact of these life and death decisions?
Speaker 41
Well, can I thank my honorable friend and obviously recognize that Ian is in obviously a very difficult position. I'm pleased to say the Exchequer Secretary has announced that we will bring forward a new approach to this issue. We've been working on a solution that will remove VAT as a barrier to free of charge donations of innovative medicines. It will be permanent, backdated to the 23rd of June, so that it supports companies to continue to make donations. And we'll set out the details shortly.
James Cleverly
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, the Prime Minister was kind enough to pay me a compliment, so let me return the favor. When he was Mayor of Greater Manchester, the GMP had more police officers than before he was appointed. When I was Home Secretary, Essex Police had more officers than at any point in their history. But over the last 10 years, the Metropolitan Police has failed to recruit and police numbers have fallen.
So what is it that he was able to get right and that I was able to get right, but Sadiq Khan catastrophically has failed to get right?
Speaker 41
The second round of auditions, Mr. Speaker. And I saw Essex got a mention this week, but it was still a question about London. I did increase police numbers in my time as Mayor of Greater Manchester, but he will know it's not something you can do from the local level alone. You need government support as well to do that. Sadly, that support for the Metropolitan Police was not forthcoming in sufficient quantity during the period that he was in office.
So he can't come here and absolve himself of any responsibility in his quest to come second to Sadiq next year.
Yasmin Qureshi
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister will remember that in 2013, he met with me to discuss the hormone pregnancy test drug Primodos, and he has supported the affected families since. One of them is his own constituent, Marie Lyon, who has led this fight for decades. More recently, Marie suffered a heart attack, a stark reminder that time is running out for the families who have already waited a lifetime. Now that he is the Prime Minister, will he meet with me and Marie to finally deliver the justice that this family deserves?
Speaker 41
I will, Mr. Speaker. Marie Lyon has been an incredible, indomitable fighter for women affected by Primodos.
I pay full tribute to her. I was so sorry to hear about her recent illness, but I can say from this dispatch box today, as Prime Minister, I will work with Marie, I will work with my honourable friend to get justice for the Primodos victims.
Robin Swann
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister will be aware that the Northern Ireland Executive is now without an agreed budget for the seven months of this financial year. Is he aware that that means my party colleague Robbie Butler, the Health Minister, neither has the finance nor the legal ability to pay our health and social care workers their agreed pay award for this year, and they are now balloting for industrial action? So can I ask the Prime Minister, will he work at pace with the Northern Ireland Secretary, the Northern Ireland Executive, actually to get a budget agreed that would deliver for our health and social care workers in Northern Ireland?
Speaker 41
Well, Mr. Speaker, I think the honourable gentleman and colleagues opposite will know that I did go to Northern Ireland shortly after coming to office to speak to all parties, including on this very important issue of the budget. I returned here and found more money for Northern Ireland in a very difficult situation, I have to say, when we are finding more money for defence, despite what the right honourable lady says, we will fully fund the DIP. But even in those circumstances, I found extra money. And there comes a point where people have to work together to set a budget. It can't always be our responsibility.
We stepped forward, and I ask all parties in Northern Ireland to do the same, set a budget and get Stormont functioning as it should.
Speaker 72
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent Joe Bennett, who's in the public gallery, has not seen his parents Craig and Lindsay Foreman since January 2025, when they were arrested and detained by Iran and presented with fake charges of espionage. I thank the Foreign Secretary and his predecessors for their work on this case, but will the Prime Minister consider additional action, including a clear public condemnation of their detention as arbitrary and unlawful in international law, and provide them with diplomatic protection, as we have in other cases, to increase the pressure on Iran to bring Craig and Lindsay home?
Speaker 41
Well, my honourable friend is doing a sterling job in speaking up for his constituents, and I can say to him that I agree that Lindsay and Craig's sentences are appalling and unjustifiable. It's why the Foreign Secretary has raised this case directly with his Iranian counterpart. We will continue to pursue the case relentlessly until Lindsay and Craig are safely returned home to the UK and reunited with their family.
Speaker 75
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Three million households are in debt on their energy bills, pushing up everyone's energy bills by around fifty pounds a year to cover it. As a result, energy companies and Ofgem are ringing the alarm bell that this almost seven billion pounds of energy debt in this country is now undermining the sector's ability to make the investments which could lower bills in the long term. So will the Prime Minister be more ambitious than the VAT cut on electricity and the reviewing the standing charge on gas, and introduce an essential energy guarantee where fifty percent of average use is charged at a cheaper rate permanently to cut bills and help families and the energy sector escape Britain's energy debt crisis?
Speaker 41
Well, the honourable lady makes a very strong point, and I can say to her, getting bills down, energy bills down, gas and electric, is at the very top of my list of priorities. It matters for households, and she's described the number of people in debt, which is an appalling situation for so many people to be in. But it matters to businesses too. Businesses are struggling with the cost of energy. Businesses are struggling to get grid connections.
It's why the energy sector needs significant reform, Mr. Speaker. We will make it. We will go further on the back of the VAT cut, and we'll set out more in due course.
Speaker 76
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You will remember that the last Labour government established children's trust funds, but sadly around 80,000 children across the country, including my constituent James Gilbert, are unable to access these due to an expensive and bureaucratic court process for those that lack mental capacity. Will the Prime Minister commit to ensuring this government finally fixes this problem, which has left our campaigners frustrated for over six years since they first raised this with ministers?
Speaker 41
I know how important this issue is, Mr. Speaker. Child trust funds for disabled children are crucial and it needs to be unlocked quickly. So I will ensure that Treasury ministers are working with other ministerial colleagues to make progress quickly and hopefully we will have an answer for her soon.
Charles Edward Robin Morello
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister has said that he wants growth in every postcode, but current devolution plans mean West Dorset risks being left behind as other regions gain devolved powers and investment. A Wessex mayor could unlock 460 million in additional annual funding and generate as much as 16 billion of additional economic output over the next 30 years. So my question to the Prime Minister is, will he commit to a mayor of Wessex by 2028?
Speaker 41
Yes, I'm always happy to create more mayors, Mr. Speaker. I'm not joking. Yes. I would like to see a fully devolved South West of England. I know Cornish members were in Number 10 North this week to discuss a devolution deal.
I met Devon members this week who are seeking the same. I will offer the same to Wessex members and let's move quickly to get a fully devolved Wessex and West of England, South West.
Jacob Collier
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We know the Prime Minister likes a pint and as he told me, a pint of Burton's finest Bass. So he will be sad to learn of the news from Carlsberg of the planned closure of Marston's brewery next year. This puts 310 workers at risk and our historic ales like Bass and Pedigree being brewed in Burton upon Trent. Will the Prime Minister meet with me to discuss how to safeguard this site and keep this as a brewery?
Speaker 41
I do like a pint, Mr. Speaker, and sadly I am spending less time in pubs these days, but I will certainly make it up by meeting my honorable friend and having a chat about the home of brewing in this country, Burton upon Trent. It's a proud tradition. I was sorry to hear about those potential job losses and we will see what we can do to support the honorable gentleman and his constituents.
Speaker 69
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. At Guildford's probation hostel, experienced staff are being refused skilled worker visa sponsorship because their salaries fall below the government's threshold, despite earning over 42,000 when essential overtime is included. And I understand from local probation management this could affect hundreds of staff across the 104 probation hostels in England and Wales at a time when probation services are already under huge pressure from the government's early release scheme. The government has made special visa provision for prison officers, so why not probation staff who also protect the public? Will the Prime Minister review these rules urgently before experienced probation staff are lost from a service that is already stretched to breaking point?
Speaker 41
Well, the honorable lady is right that we have to do everything we can to support our staff in the probation service right now, and I will ask the Justice Secretary to take a look at those rules and come back to the honorable lady.
Zubir Ahmed
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, 100 years ago this month, my family's proud tradition of service and contribution to Britain began when my grandfather, Imam Muhammad, travelled from Indian Punjab to serve in the Royal British Hong Kong Police Force. Does my right honorable friend the Prime Minister share my concern that in light of ITV's exposé of elected Reform politicians indulging in racist behavior, that families like them, of whom there are thousands in this country, will wonder who now represents them? And can my right honorable friend reassure me that the government that he leads will make sure everyone's contribution is respected and recognized?
Speaker 41
I will always do that, Mr. Speaker, and I pay tribute to the people who work in social care, who cared for my dad, who come from around the world to provide support to people, and we thank them for their contribution. I think it is incumbent on all parties represented in this house to root out the politics of poison which has seeped far too far into our politics. Where unacceptable racist and discriminatory comments are made, the firmest of action should be taken on the back of those revelations. That should unite us all in this house, and we're still waiting to see the right level of action from the party opposite.
John Whittingdale
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Unlike the government's shameful attempts to hand over the sovereignty of the strategically important Chagos Islands, will the Prime Minister confirm that this time the government will strongly oppose the case being made by the government of Argentina to the international tribunal to try to stop the exploitation of oil reserves around the Falkland Islands, which is authorized by the United Kingdom?
Speaker 41
Indeed we will, Mr. Speaker, and I'm happy to make that clear again today. We will take the firmest of action to support the Falkland Islands, the right of the islanders to self-determination, who chose to remain British not so long ago. The Defense Secretary has met with his counterparts to reiterate that position, the Foreign Secretary too. I raised the matter with President Trump. There is no diminution in our strong support to keep the Falkland Islands British.
Amanda Hack
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. North West Leicestershire has an out-of-hospital survival rate for cardiac arrest of just 3.5%, roughly a third of the national average. I've been championing greater defibrillator access, hosting CPR training, and last week I hosted the British Heart Foundation, Resus UK, and CRY, amongst others, for a roundtable in Parliament. Discussions focused on the importance of CPR education, defibrillator provision, and the benefits of heart screening amongst young people. October is Restart a Heart Month.
Will the Prime Minister meet with me to discuss my mission to improve cardiac arrest survival rates, defibrillator accessibility, and consider how we can reduce the shocking stat of 12 young people dying each week of an unknown cardiac arrest?
Speaker 41
I strongly support my honorable friend on this issue, having had the training myself, used a defibrillator once before. I know that they save lives, and Mr. Speaker, I think we should commit to ensuring that they are clearly and publicly available in all communities. It's something I've long called for, so I would happily work with my honorable friend on that. The 10-year health plan talks of a shift from hospital to community. My right honorable friend and myself are determined to make that reality, and I think when it comes to heart care, that's a prime example of where we can make a difference.
Speaker 71
Mr. Speaker, this week the Sunday Times reported on its front page how Ministry of Defence police attempted to prosecute five members of the SAS over bogus allegations made by our enemies. They arrested these soldiers and subjected them to continuous and frankly incompetent investigation for three years whilst they were fighting ISIS on our behalf. This action has travelled like a shockwave through Hereford, destroying morale and undermining one of our best fighting units. Nobody wants to put soldiers above the law. But will the Prime Minister speak to the Defence Secretary and stop British agencies acting with credulous complicity with our enemies trying to use lawfare against our soldiers.
Speaker 41
Mr. Speaker, I am aware of the high levels of concern amongst those who've served in the SAS and the right honourable gentleman has spoken to that today. Without going into all of the details today, I would be happy to meet him to discuss the case and see how we can resolve some of the issues that arise from it, giving the assurance to people who've served this country that we will have their back and we will always treat them fairly.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On Monday, the Children's Commissioner devastatingly found that Portsmouth is the 12th hardest place in England to be a child and the worst place to access post-16 education provision in England. Yet the county we sit in, Hampshire, is one of the top best places to be a child. Does the Prime Minister agree with me this must be a wake-up call for my Lib Dem city council and we must do all we can to ensure that this changes because Portsmouth's children and young people deserve so much better.
Speaker 41
Well, I agree they do, Mr. Speaker, and it's why we're going deeper than just thinking about how we help people in their 20s or 18s into work. We need to rethink how we support young people in the 21st century in Portsmouth and elsewhere. One of the things is an education system that balances academic and technical education, that gives people routes, young people routes into good jobs. And the Education Secretary is working hard on that. I know that that will give all young people in Portsmouth a path to a good life.
Speaker 79
It's the kind of change that would make a difference and I look forward to working with her on delivering it.
Lindsay Hoyle
Before we come to the statement on Jackdaw, I have to, I have to say to the Minister, I am sorry that I have to address you on this matter rather than the Secretary of State. It is shameful that this announcement was not made to the House first and it is an immense discourtesy to the House that the Secretary of State did not come here to make the statement. I'm sorry that Sky News is more important rather than the members of both sides. It is appalling treatment. The Minister will know that this issue has been of great interest to the House, evident from the many questions asked by honourable members from all sides of the House.
These have been asked and answered over recent months despite any concerns about a quasi-judicial process. Let me not hear that is the excuse. It is simply not good enough that it was trailed by the press last night and announced all over the media this morning by the Secretary of State before it could be properly scrutinised in this House.
And this isn't the first time on this subject. That's what's more, Speaker. It was a leak. I'm sure there will be a leak inquiry. Or is it that this department is deliberately briefing out to the media?
The Guardian, the BBC were covering it last night along with the radio. It seems ministers once again need reminding of the government's own ministerial code, which makes clear that important policy announcements should be made first to this house, especially when we are sitting. There is no excuse. I hope the minister is taking this on board. I'm sorry he's having to take the flak for a Secretary of State who doesn't care about members on this side, that side, over there, wherever.
Because in the end, we are elected. We're elected by our electorate to hear statements here, not via the media. Am I getting the message through, minister? Because we've had this conversation once before. I'm sorry that you're being set up as the patsy that has to take this ridiculous situation.
I want us to learn. I was hoping we had changed what happened previously. I thought this was a new beginning. Well, it's certainly a bad one today, isn't it, minister?
Michael Shanks
Well, Mr. Speaker, firstly, I entirely respect the comments that you've made. I hope I have always given the impression to you in my time in this house that I take this house seriously, and your points have been noted, and I will absolutely take them back to the department.
Lindsay Hoyle
It would be different if we hadn't had this conversation once before here. Previously, you promised me there'd be no more. I'm sorry that you're having to be put up when the Secretary of State can't be bothered to come. I'm sorry that Aberdeen is more important than the MPs that are elected.
Michael Shanks
Mr. Speaker, with permission, I will make a statement on the offshore Jackdaw gas field and the government's approach more broadly to North Sea oil and gas, and this supplements the written ministerial statement that I made to this house on the topic earlier this morning. The original grant of consent for the Jackdaw project made in 2022 under the last government was judged to be unlawful and was quashed by the courts. This was because emissions from the burning of extracted gas was not considered, and so it did not assess the full environmental impacts of the project. My right honorable friend, the Energy Secretary, and the regulator have now retaken the relevant decisions, fully taking into account environmental impacts. Today, I can inform the house that the Energy Secretary has decided in favor of the project, and the regulator, the North Sea Transition Authority, has now granted consent for gas to be produced at the licensed Jackdaw field.
Given the court permitted the developer to continue development at risk until a new consenting decision was made, the project will therefore start to supply gas to British homes and businesses by as soon as the end of this month. In reaching her decision, the Energy Secretary considered all relevant information in the round. She looked at the project's expected benefits to the UK, including its contribution to energy security, employment, impacts on other energy infrastructure, and other economic benefits, and carefully weighed those against the potential environmental effects, including the effects relating to greenhouse gas emissions. The full reasons for her decisions are set out in detail in the decision document, which is published on gov.uk. I want to assure the house that the government remains committed to tackling the climate crisis, to moving away from fossil fuels, and towards renewable and nuclear energy.
The recent heatwaves and weather events we have seen demonstrate why this is of critical importance. The Secretary of State will be leading the UK delegation to COP next month to drive global action and build a credible pathway back to 1.5 degrees of warming. I want to be clear, though, that this project will not prevent the UK from being able to meet its legally binding limits on carbon emissions and achieve net zero by 2050.
But even on the path to net zero, the UK will still require oil and gas as part of our energy needs for decades to come. This decision is consistent with the government's manifesto commitments to end new licenses to explore new fields and to support the management of existing fields for their lifespan. The Chancellor and Energy Secretary have also announced that the government will establish a new North Sea Energy Wealth Fund, which will use tax revenues from North Sea oil and gas to invest in net zero projects and support the green transition. This will start with an initial 2 billion pound capital injection of funding, with future revenues from the North Sea flowing into the fund over time. It will support our plans to delink gas and electricity over the course of the Parliament, ensuring that homegrown renewables and low carbon power sets the price of electricity far more than gas.
This will help to protect households and businesses from volatile fossil fuel markets and bring down bills for good. The North Sea Future Plan set out our approach to securing a managed, orderly and prosperous transition and how we will deliver our manifesto commitment to support the management of existing fields by introducing transitional energy certificates. We will legislate for those reforms when parliamentary time allows. But a small number of tie-back projects face urgent investment and operational decisions now. I've therefore asked the North Sea Transition Authority to consider whether any such projects could benefit from similar measures now before the legislation is in place.
This is a limited interim arrangement for urgent cases where operators can demonstrate committed investment, credible delivery plans and near-term activity. Any decision will remain for the NSTA in accordance with its statutory responsibilities. Mr Speaker, timely decommissioning is important for both the environment and the economy and this government is keen to unblock and progress decisions in a timely way. Today I can also announce that the regulator has invited the decommissioning program for the Brent installations, marking an important step in restarting another regulatory process that has been on hold for years. My officials are also beginning discussions with industry leaders on a refresh of the North Sea Transition Deal to ensure that future domestic oil and gas production continues to benefit the UK and to build the energy industries of the future.
First agreed in 2021, the deal aims to provide a clear path for the industry to support the UK in reaching net zero carbon emissions by 2050 while protecting jobs and supporting energy security. And finally, Mr Speaker, as the Prime Minister said a few moments ago, we are looking at removing standing charges on gas bills at the earliest opportunity. Today's decision, Mr Speaker, means we will get more power flowing directly into British homes and businesses this winter as we continue our transition to renewables and I commend the statement to the House.
Andrew Bowie
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Finally, Mr Speaker, at last, this government after two and a half years have found it within themselves to do the right thing, doing the right thing after exhausting all the alternatives. But we have arrived at this destination far later than we should have. Jackdaw was first approved by us in 2022. When in government, when in government, we approved it in line with the law as we saw it at the time and we were confident that we would win the appeal in the Court of Session and ensure we could get British gas into British homes as soon as possible.
But then enter the former Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero and in one of his first acts as Secretary of State, pulled lawyers from the appeal, ensuring and guaranteeing that it would fail. There was absolutely no reason to do this. Approving Jackdaw is about security, jobs and our economy and this government at every moment up to today has chosen to prioritize its own self-interest and winning by-elections in Holborn and St Pancras over the interest of the British people.
Mr. Speaker, Jackdaw alone will provide enough resources to heat 1.4 million British homes. Those homes will no longer need to rely on expensive and high carbon emitting LNG imports. And today we've heard the Secretary of State and the Minister talking about pragmatism of the national interest. Most gallingly, Mr. Speaker, we've heard them talking about supporting British workers. But if they are serious about a new approach, about a pragmatic approach, about British jobs and British businesses, surely that means that the forthcoming Energy Independence Bill will not have measures in it to ban any new licenses in the North Sea, a purely ideological but unfathomable decision.
If they really believe that a new pragmatism is needed, then in the North Sea, presumably that means next week the Chancellor will be announcing that he will be removing the energy profits levy. Mr. Speaker, this decision is welcome, but it shouldn't have taken this long. Labour's dither and delay over the past few years, and indeed the past few months, has cost us dear. Jobs lost, more businesses relocating, deindustrialization. There's a reason the leader of the GMB union described his department as the Department for P45s.
Now we have had oil downturns before, when global prices fell and jobs were lost in the UK. When it happened under our watch, we stepped up, we maximized recovery, we cut taxes, we turned the North Sea into the most investable basin in the world. Today there is no global downturn, prices are actually soaring across the world, the oil and gas industry is expanding. Only in Britain we now have a made-by-Labour, made-by-Miliband downturn. The only government in the world that says jobs being lost, let's speed it up.
The only country not maximizing recovery, the only country in the middle of an energy crisis, Mr. Speaker, that is choosing to ban licenses and exploration. And yet today, the workers in our oil and gas industry are to be thankful that after two and a half years of uncertainty, this government, kicking and screaming, have finally done the right thing. Now I have no doubt there will be more kicking and screaming from some of their own backbenchers today, perhaps the prospect of more tax revenue will appease them, specifically over 4 billion pounds of tax receipts, much needed revenue we know the Chancellor desperately needs. Mr. Speaker, today is a good day, finally. But in the spirit of the Secretary of State's newfound pragmatism, let's see a serious and pragmatic change in direction.
Speaker 83
Will this government now approve Rosebank, lift the ban on exploration and new licenses, end the crippling energy profits levy, and get Britain drilling?
Michael Shanks
Well, Mr. Speaker, if as the honorable gentleman said he's had two and a half years to think about it, he might have come up with something slightly better than that performance. The lack of any contrition on the fact that they made a decision that was quashed by a court is absolutely shameful. But Mr. Speaker, I would just reiterate something I said. The court was very clear in its judgment that while the decision did not stand, the project could continue to be developed. So there has been no delay in the development of that project, which is why with this decision today, the extraction from the Jackdaw field can continue.
But he also talked about dither and delay. And look, this is where we get to the truth of things. The Conservative Party left Britain with an energy system that was less secure, more exposed to international shocks, and slower to invest than it should have been. Now, I watched the Conservative Party conference in great detail, and I'm delighted that the honorable gentleman seems to be shifting his party's position back to supporting more renewables than under the previous Shadow Secretary of State. And I really welcome that, and I look forward to working with them to make that a success, because we agree with him.
The truth about this is that while this decision is important for our energy security and for jobs, the long-term pathway for Britain is not in fossil fuels. It is to build the clean power system we need for the future, to electrify the economy, to build the nuclear that he claims he cares so much about, but dither and delay got to the heart of his two years as nuclear minister, not a single thing built.
We fell behind as a country on the energy security we need. This decision is part of how we make sure we have a response to energy crises, but the long-term future means building up the industries that come next. That's important for Britain's energy security, it's important for jobs and opportunities in his constituency and right across the country. That's what this government will get on and do.
Bill Esterson
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Can I warmly welcome the minister's statement, the commitment to go ahead with Jackdaw? The Select Committee in evidence has heard again and again of the damage done by the chaotic deindustrialization of the 80s and the failure in the 2010s and the early 2020s for action in the North Sea. And actually, the phrase a North Sea energy wealth fund has stark echoes, striking echoes with what Norway did right to avoid those disastrous consequences of deindustrialization. So what we have heard in the committee, Mr. Speaker, what we have heard in the committee is just how important the supply chain companies are and their workers in the North Sea in oil and gas now and in renewables in the future.
So does the minister agree that what is really important through the announcement of the fund and also what he said in his statement about the North Sea transition deal is the way that it recognizes the fastest way, the most effective way of delivering the energy transition is through supporting existing operations and supply chains and workers in the North Sea in oil and gas so they are available as we gear up into renewables and nuclear.
Michael Shanks
Well, I do agree with my honorable friend and he's right about the transition. The vast majority of jobs in the oil and gas industry are in the supply chains, the very supply chains that we need to build the renewables and the networks of the future as well. So it's important that we hold on to those and that's also the huge opportunity. And the point I make about pragmatism is pragmatism has to go both ways. It has to be pragmatic about oil and gas in the North Sea, but doing that without doing the investment that's needed into clean power and the long-term future of these jobs is irresponsible.
And what we're seeking to do with this is do both, to make sure that transition is managed by investing the revenues from gas in this project now, two billion pounds initially, but additional revenues will flow into that to then invest in the clean power projects that help us get off fossil fuels in the long term but retain the absolutely critical workforce in the UK as well.
Pippa Heylings
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In the midst of a climate crisis, today's approval of Jackdaw is proof that Britain has not moved forward nearly fast enough to reduce our reliance on gas and oil. A Supreme Court judgment requires analysis of scope three carbon emissions of gas and oil licenses, so the decision to approve Jackdaw must be able to demonstrate that it is compatible with our climate commitments, not just our net zero targets. What is not compatible with our climate targets is our continued dependence on gas. 80% of UK households still heat their homes with gas.
Heat pumps provide heating for just 2% of households in the UK. And now we're hearing that the government's planning to cut heat pump subsidies to homeowners that are wanting to get themselves off gas. The world has changed with two global energy crises in five years. About a quarter of our UK gas demand is supplied by imported LNG. Our energy security is not strengthened when 70% of that comes from the US with a Trump who may be prepared to turn that gas on and off.
UK gas demand. It will play a limited short-term role whilst displacing more polluting and insecure imports. This decision must be the tipping point for transformative investment in renewables and electrification. So I ask the minister, in terms of our climate obligations, what will the government be doing to account for scope three emissions beyond the territorial emissions in our net zero targets? And will the minister commit to the 15 billion pounds funding in the Warm Homes Plan and support the Liberal Democrat call for a national electrification strategy to drive down our dependence on gas for good?
Madam Deputy Speaker, let me be clear about Jackdaw. It will not bring down bills.
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I genuinely am confused about the Lib Dem position because my understanding was they were now in favor of the Jackdaw field, so I'm not sure, it will maybe change by the end of the day again. But I hear the point she makes. Look, we're not waiting for a tipping point. We've been working on electrification and building the clean power mission for the past two and a half years. We've been getting on with it.
I would just gently say to the Lib Dems that when Labour left office, there were 10 sites for new nuclear projects in 2009, and it was her right honorable friend, the leader of the Liberal Democrats now, who was energy minister for a particular period of that time, and of course we didn't build any nuclear in that period, which would have helped us. But look, on the general point, which I agree with her on in terms of the climate point, look, the decision that was made here did have to weigh up all of those factors. The full decision notice is available, which goes into this in great detail, but the Secretary of State was very clear that her assessment of this decision meant that it did not prevent the UK from meeting those legally binding limits on carbon emissions or achieve our net zero target. And a managed transition, Madam Deputy Speaker, does recognize that to move to a low-carbon economy means balancing those climate objectives with the deployment of clean power, the electrification of heat and industry, but also making sure we have energy security in the short term while we are required to use oil and gas across our economy. It's about doing both and getting us to that end point as quickly as we possibly can.
Toby Perkins
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think that the decision that's come today is probably not a surprise to most people. It is right to say that it will have a relatively limited difference to energy security and probably very little difference to pricing. But I very much welcome what the minister said about this being part of a transition and the fact that we need to, we won't be ripping up the policy commitment not to have wider exploration. I agree with him that this is consistent with our manifesto pledge on that.
But does he agree with me that the absolute priority here is to reduce electricity prices, that getting off the fossil fuel rollercoaster needs to support people to make those decisions, to move to heat pumps, to move to electric vehicles, as well as the other differences that are made for industry? And that the absolute key priority is about bringing down electricity prices. So can you tell us what else he will be doing to make sure we achieve that in this budget and in further budgets to come?
Michael Shanks
Yeah, look, I agree with my honorable friend on the absolute priority. Just to agree with one thing he said, he is absolutely right to say that this decision today will not take a penny off bills. We've been consistent on that throughout, that we are a price taker as a country and no number of consenting decisions will change the fact that it is traded on the international market and it is of marginal impact on the overall price. So it does not have an impact on that. Nevertheless, it will make up around 5% of domestic gas production, so it is important from a security point of view.
His wider point though is how we move people over to electricity much more and then bring down the cost of electricity. We're doing all we can to break the link with gas, which is absolutely critical. It's why electricity bills have gone up in the last two price caps because of our exposure to fossil fuels by a war thousands of miles away that we had no part in. We are already making progress. 90% of the electricity price was set by gas a few years ago, it's now 60% and going down all the time, but we've got much, much more to do with that.
And the evidence of the past few months has shown that where people are supported to take up heat pumps or solar panels, those particular off-grid households at the moment who are facing the impact on heating oil prices have taken up those opportunities. So the public are behind us on this, we just need to make it as straightforward as possible and that's what the Warm Homes Plan will deliver.
Speaker 91
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like the speaker, I was angry and frustrated that the Secretary of State is not making the statement today because the first I knew she was actually in my constituency of Aberdeen South was when I seen her on TV this morning. Completely disrespectful to another member. So the decision on Jackdaw today is a victory for common sense. It's also a victory for the voters of Aberdeen South who sent a clear message to this Labour government in what was the most important by-election this year.
Speaker 93
Can the minister confirm if this decision will streamline the process for other North Sea developments because we need a pipeline of projects coming through to protect jobs and also to keep the lights on.
Speaker 92
Before I bring in the minister, can I respond to the honourable member and say the Speaker's been very clear on this on numerous occasions. Courtesies to members apply equally across this House. If a Secretary of State visits a member's constituency, they must inform the member beforehand. Minister.
Michael Shanks
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, as a fellow by-election MP, I can agree with him that we need to dine out on it as much as we possibly can. So he's quite right to raise it. Look, he's right about the process. Partly, I'm not going to comment on specific timelines for upcoming decisions, but there has been a process over the past two years to put in place the consideration of Scope 3 emissions, to consult on that process and then get the consenting decisions back into the decision-making process.
That has all now been done. So going through the process will be just making considerations on individual applications rather than going through all the process again. Obviously, there are considerations to be made about upcoming consenting decisions that will be based on the evidence that's submitted, not an artificial timeline that we'll set out. He talks about common sense and look, I think this is really important just to make this point. The common sense pragmatic position for the future of the North East of Scotland is to say, as I have said, that oil and gas will continue to be important for a long time.
I've been in Aberdeen enough to know how important it is to the jobs there. But it also has to go hand in hand with us investing as much as we possibly can in the long-term industries that will create jobs there. It's why I talk about decommissioning in the statement. That's a huge opportunity for jobs and supply chain in the North East. And I hope we can get a bit more cross-party consensus, maybe not on everything on oil and gas, but certainly on the need to invest in supply chains and industry to build the renewables of the future as well.
Melanie Onn.
Melanie Onn
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd just like to thank the minister for the time that he takes to come and talk to the Energy Security and Net Zero Committee. He's barely out of the chair in front of us and is very dedicated and I just want to recognise that. I think that today's decision is evidence that it was a decision that the Tories could not get over the line and that under this Prime Minister, a rapid decision has been made and that will protect jobs and critically, it will ensure that skills will be retained for a changing supply chain. I just wonder if the minister can confirm that this government will continue with investment and equally rapid decision-making for clean power projects.
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I always love my appearances before the Energy Select Committee. I would just gently point out there are other ministers in the department who would love to come and give evidence as well, but nevertheless, I'm very happy to and I always appreciate the conversations. My honourable friend is absolutely right.
We have moved as quickly as we could have to put in place the process that responded to the Supreme Court judgment on Finch and then the the Court of Session judgment on these particular applications. We've done that and we've considered all the evidence to make the decision today because the critical thing about this, whatever people's view is on it, it has to be able to stand up on the merits of the decision that have been made and it was right and proper we took time to get that right. But the broader point she makes is absolutely right. Look, the the real prize of the energy transition if we get it right is to tackle the climate crisis at the same time as creating jobs in every single part of the country. She is a fantastic champion of her community and of that industry.
If we get this right, we create the next generation of good sustainable jobs for young people growing up today who are not going to have a long-term career in oil and gas but could have a very good long-term career in renewables and carbon capture and hydrogen and all the other things. We have to do both and I hope together we can work to make sure that that is a reality.
Paul Stephen Barclay
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister in his reply to the Shadow Minister said that the delay in the decision on Jackdaw was fiscally neutral because in essence the investment was made at risk. That was his response. Is he saying the same thing? Well, he said there was no cost.
He's shaking his head. He said in reply to the Shadow Front Bench that there was no cost from the delay. Does he therefore, if he's shaking his head, accept the delay in Rosebank does come at a cost, a cost in investment and a cost in taxpayers' revenue? And if so, will he set out what that cost is in revenue ahead of the budget?
Michael Shanks
Just to be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, what I said was there was no time delay because the projects were actually not ready to extract in any event. And my understanding, it's for the developer to speak to the details, but the Rosebank project is not ready to extract now either. So the point I was making was, although we had to retake the decisions that were quashed, the decisions that were made by the previous government that were quashed by a court, the developer was allowed to continue the development of that project at their risk, which means that they are now in a place ready to extract. Now they have the consent in place to be able to do that. That's in place now, which means they can extract by the end of this month.
The Rosebank project is obviously subject to a separate regulatory process that I'm not going to comment on just now.
Torcuil Crichton
Gil Crichton. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome this announcement by by the Minister and remind us that this is not just a question for the Northeast of Aberdeen South, that there are only two postcode areas in the UK that do not have a jobs connection to the North Sea. So this affects every constituency despite the scant appearance of opposition MPs. And can I welcome this two million two billion pound investment in transition because we need these skills, we need that workforce, we need that supply chain to step stone transition into new industries.
And can I caution my own side to make sure that we are not remembered as the government that let down the North Sea workforce the way that that party on the other side let down the coalfields. And can I also ask the Minister to detail and encourage him to rush through these tie-backs and the decommissioning that will keep us in the North Sea for years to come.
Michael Shanks
Well, can I he makes the point around the postcodes point and I think that's really important for us. I hope that what we can do collectively on the transition is get to a similar place where there isn't a single postcode in this country that doesn't have jobs associated with clean energy as well. And and that is the aim that we're driving forward in terms of the supply chain investment and and everything else. He's right to center this whole conversation in the workers. For sixty years, workers have done incredibly difficult and dangerous work in the North Sea to bring energy ashore.
I pay tribute to all of them, many some of whom have lost their lives in in that process. But it is our duty to make sure that there is a long-term legacy for that workforce in oil and gas, in decommissioning, but also in other technologies that we need to invest in now.
That's the prize if we get it right, but frankly, it's also our responsibility to that workforce now and the workforce of the future.
Wera Hobhouse.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today is not a good day for any campaigner pressing for urgent action on climate change, and I know that many of my Bath constituents, including particularly young people, will be deeply concerned and disappointed. The Government has justified its position by saying that Jackdaw will create new jobs and boost growth. Can the Government just clarify which jobs will boost growth, not the jobs which rely on a Jackdaw worker buying a sandwich, because frankly, you know, anybody working in any industry sector can buy a sandwich. I mean those jobs that will be directly created, directly created by Jackdaw that would otherwise not exist.
Michael Shanks
Well, I get, I'm sorry, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm hurriedly trying to work out what the Lib Dem position is on this again, but I'm sure I'll have clarity at some point. Look, on the point about jobs, I'd just say this. Look, there are 27, the developer's figures, there are 27 direct jobs from this project, but it's also about safeguarding 273 existing jobs through this project. But it's actually about much broader than that. It is about an industry that is in transition, and we have to do what we can to protect that industry while we build what comes next.
And I've been really clear on that throughout my time as Energy Minister. I would just gently say that I think we should accept the wider economic impacts of jobs does go to the person buying a sandwich in the shop, because when we see big industry leave towns, I'm a Lanarkshire MP, I know the implication, the impact of coal mine closures and everything and steel closures in my constituency, you do see those small businesses leave and with it the important jobs that a community relies on. So I don't think we should talk down the importance of the wider economic impact of this decision.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As a member of the Energy Security and Net Zero Select Committee, I've looked in detail at both Jackdaw and Rosebank, and I think it's very important in this House that we do not confuse the two. My main concern has always been the impact on carbon emissions of any gas taken from Jackdaw. So can the Minister tell me what impact Jackdaw gas will have on emissions, and can he reassure me that this decision will not impact on the speed or scale of the low-carbon energy transition?
Minister.
Michael Shanks
Yeah, I can give my honourable friend that assurance. The amount of gas that will come onshore from this is about 5% of our production, I think 6% at the peak of production coming into our UK supply. We have a diverse range of supplies from the UK Continental Shelf, from Norway, and from LNG imports. This decision will not change the fact that the country 20 years ago became a net importer of fossil fuels. It's not going to change, but it does play a part in the security of supply.
That was part of the balancing act of that against the environmental considerations that she rightly makes. And as I've said before, the determination the Secretary of State made is that we are able to do that while meeting the climate objectives. And I can absolutely give her the assurance that this decision doesn't move us away at all from those commitments. In fact, the two billion pounds committed from the revenues for this will help us turbocharge that investment in clean energy.
Kirsty Blackman.
Ann Kirsty Blackman
Madam Deputy Speaker, I want the people who sell sandwiches in my constituency to have jobs just the same as I want the people who work in the energy industry in my constituency to have jobs. Both jobs are important. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's really good to see the UK Government creating a future generations fund from North Sea revenue. We've been calling for this for 50 years, so I'm glad they've finally got with the program on this. Can we have a reassurance from the Minister, because we've not had any details on this, of where that money will be spent?
Will the money generated from North Sea revenues in fields like Jackdaw in Scotland go into renewables projects in Scotland? Will it support jobs in Scotland? Will it ensure that people in Aberdeen have their futures protected, or will it, like GB Energy, focus on delivering solar panels in England?
Minister.
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, she speaks about 50 years. I'm not quite sure what the SNP's energy policy is right now.
It changes from minute to minute, and it changes whether the First Minister is in Aberdeen or somewhere else in the country. I can't quite fathom it. The Scottish Government put out a statement today which I read three or four times and still wasn't clear whether it supported Jackdaw or not. So she is a good supporter of the industry and I absolutely recognize that, but the rest of her party I'm not quite so sure on. The point about investment in renewables is really important.
The revenue from this, we've been very clear, will be invested in renewables projects across the UK, but the vast majority of those we are already seeing the investment going into Scotland, in supply chains as well as in the infrastructure itself. And it's easy, I think, for her to talk down Great British Energy, but its headquarters in Aberdeen is already helping to deliver investment in supply chains in Scotland. A billion pounds of investment so that we're not towing in the renewables to the Saudi Arabia of renewables that the former leader of her party claimed, but all built somewhere else, but we're actually building it in Britain. That is where the jobs come from. It's really important, and I hope we can get behind this idea, as I thought her party agreed, that public ownership of energy is important, that public investment in energy is important, and that the transition does need investment at every stage of it.
So I hope there's clearer areas for us to work together, but as I say, we're still waiting on the SNP's energy policy three years on, so I'm not quite sure what it is at the moment.
Speaker 102
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honorable friend knows that actions have consequences, but so does inaction. And ultimately, the consistent failure of the party opposite over many years to address the challenges in the North Sea have seen 70,000 jobs lost. So I welcome the statement today, clearly focused on energy security and jobs. As my constituency neighbor, he knows the importance of supply chain jobs in Lanarkshire, not just in oil and gas, but in clean energy projects too, including RES, where we both visited recently.
So does he agree with me that the new 2 billion pounds Energy Wealth Fund represents a serious step towards supporting our transition effort and delivering high-quality jobs in Lanarkshire?
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm always going to agree about high-quality jobs in Lanarkshire. It was a pleasure to visit my honorable friend's constituency to see the opening of the RES facility in Bellshill, an important example of a part of his constituency that's not going to have renewables projects directly deployed but can still get the jobs from the operations and maintenance of wind farms across Scotland and jobs and apprenticeships being created as a result of it. This is at the heart of the government's agenda to deliver reindustrialization and growth in every postcode. The jobs that go along with the energy transition that for too long governments have been agnostic about where we build things, and we've seen manufacturing capacity depleted in communities like his and right across the country. We're seeking to reverse that with the investments we're making and to get good jobs in every single part of the country.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Prime Minister's Questions, the Prime Minister answered a question quite rightly saying that if we don't use our own resources, we will only have to import oil and gas. The Minister, in his own statement, rightly said that we are going to be reliant on oil and gas for many decades to come. So whilst welcoming today's decision, albeit late, on Jackdaw, surely with the answers the Prime Minister and the Minister gave earlier, he will surely have to agree that any delay on new oil and gas licenses is damaging to the national interest.
Michael Shanks
Well, I have said in my answer that in the transition to clean energy, we will continue to need oil and gas, and of course the UK Continental Shelf continues to be an important source of that. But we have been a net importer for more than two decades, and no amount of consenting decisions is going to change that fact. But it is important, and I've said that 6% of production does matter, which is why we've made the decision we've made today. The important thing about this, and I've said this a number of times about pragmatism, is it has to work both ways. We previously had a consensus here that oil and gas and renewables went hand in hand.
The transition to what comes next, his party has built lots of those renewables and now dismisses the fact that they're important in the system. I welcome the investment the previous government made in renewables. It's just a shame that they've lost their way so much that now they don't support it.
Euan Stainbank
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The previous Tory government blundered through an unlawful consent process which required this decision to be reconsidered, unless we adopted the license revocation policies of the Greens that would have accelerated significant job losses and irrevocably deindustrialized the North East. While I've previously opposed this project, the energy security situation has changed radically this year due to the significant consequences of the US and Israel's illegal war in Iran. Can I ask the Minister to explain how this direct impact on our short-term energy security in the UK influenced this decision, and to clarify exactly how many direct and supply chain jobs this decision supports?
Michael Shanks
Well, I thank my honorable friend for the question. He's a great champion for making sure the transition does have workers at the heart of it in his constituency and across Scotland. The developer estimates, which is all that we're able to take into account in terms of the decision that I can talk about today, is 27 direct jobs on the project, but of course the significant number of jobs in oil and gas come from the wider impacts on the supply chain, on things like travel to and from offshore rigs and on wider jobs in the North East of Scotland. And it also safeguards jobs that might otherwise have been lost. And I think it's important to look at both sides of this.
On the question of jobs, I've always been really clear around we can't just look at one side of a balance sheet in terms of jobs being lost. Energy transition does mean people moving from one part of an industry to another, and we shouldn't just look at jobs being lost in one area without following through where those jobs end up, whether that's in other parts of energy or in nuclear or in defense or in advanced manufacturing. And one of the things we'll launch very soon, Madam Deputy Speaker, is the Future Jobs Service, which supports workers all the way through that process, giving them the retraining necessary so that they can take up these opportunities in the future. And I think that's how we keep the workforce delivering in energy in Scotland.
Speaker 110
Madam Deputy Speaker, drilling at Jackdaw is an act of climate vandalism, and as we've heard, it won't bring down bills and it'll only create 27 jobs. But today's announcement also reiterated the government's support for so-called tie-backs, which is a dodge to allow yet more drilling without new licenses. Doesn't the Minister recognize that the UN's countless warnings have been that we must leave all new fossil fuels in the ground? And will he admit that allowing both Jackdaw and new tie-backs are utterly at odds with the climate science?
Michael Shanks
No, I don't. And this is where we fundamentally disagree, because we agree on the need to tackle the climate crisis, but our response has to be based in reality. And the reality is that however much I want us to be able to get off fossil fuels tomorrow, that's not going to happen. And so we have to build the infrastructure that helps us get to that place. And I'm afraid the Greens oppose the very infrastructure, they oppose wind farms, they oppose pylons, they oppose solar farms, they oppose nuclear, the very infrastructure that gets us off fossil fuels, and then they come here and complain that we're reliant on fossil fuels for longer than we have to be.
They are the problem to building the transition that we need. And across the country, Madam Deputy Speaker, so-called Green politicians, who actually I'm glad to see the honorable lady because very rarely turn up in energy debates in this House, they have stopped renewable energy projects from getting off the ground. It's always not here, somewhere else, or not today, some other time. The time to build is now, and you have to get behind it if you want to get us off fossil fuels.
Speaker 105
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With everything going on in the world right now, having strong homegrown energy really matters more than ever. Like many of us in this House, I've had a number of constituents across Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock reach out to me about energy security. Can the Minister elaborate on how today's announcement helps the country move towards energy independence and how this makes us stronger as a country?
Michael Shanks
Well, I had a great visit to my honorable friend's constituency recently to see the importance that solar panels are making on a project in her constituency. We need to see much more of that investment because our energy sovereignty in the long term comes from us being able to produce the energy we need here in the UK. And that means electrifying the economy and generating that electricity through a decarbonized power system. But the transition to get there, not least on heat and on industry, will still require gas for a long time to come. And we've been clear on that as a government from the beginning.
We're not about turning off the taps in the North Sea. And so our energy security has to take both of these directions at the same time: building the industry we need for the future now, while making sure that we have the supply that we absolutely need for the here and now. Both of those things are what the government is focused on.
John Kieran Mullan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We all want to secure the future employment prospects of those working in our world-leading oil and gas sector. And one of the richest possible opportunities for that is transitioning people into working in deep geothermal in constituencies like mine and across the country. But despite repeated cross-party meetings with ministers going back years now, I'm afraid we're still billions and billions behind the money being invested in this technology in other parts of the country. Does the Minister think it would be crazy not to put a set-aside fund in the money that's announced today purely dedicated to developing deep geothermal in our country?
Michael Shanks
Well, he's a great champion of the industry and I know he does a huge amount on this and I agree with him entirely. Geothermal is a huge opportunity that I know there are projects starting to come much closer to delivery and we want to see much, much more of that. And I recognize there's more we need to do. I don't want to get into discussions of ring-fences within the fund because I think the danger is we hold back the money from actually projects that are ready to deploy. But I'm certainly very happy to speak to him about other projects and what more we can do.
Allan Gavel.
Allan Gavel
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Minister for this statement and welcome this decision? People in Ayrshire are proud of the role Scotland has played in powering our nation. Can the Minister say a bit more about what this decision means for supply chain jobs in the North Sea sector in Scotland and right across the country?
Michael Shanks
It's good to hear from the MP for my old home and my mother's MP at the moment. He's a great champion for Ayrshire and Ayrshire has a really critical role and I think could have even more of an important role if we were to build new nuclear at Hunterston, which if it wasn't for the objections of the SNP we could be looking at much more seriously. He's right to point to the factor around supply chain jobs. There's huge opportunities. We had a meeting indeed at a port in his constituency to talk about the opportunities there.
The real drive behind this is the clean energy transition for our energy security, but re-industrialization off the back of it to create good jobs in every single part of the country, to dispel this idea that we cannot manufacture things in Britain, but actually to get back to building things in every single part of the country.
Seamus Logan
Madam Deputy Speaker, just to be kind to the Minister because I'm sure he's still smarting from the verbal caning that he received from the Speaker earlier. I do want to clarify something. I welcome this decision. My constituents welcome this decision. The Scottish Government statement welcomed this decision.
But we also welcome the creation of this energy wealth fund, although albeit as my learned friend said earlier, 50 years too late. But he will be aware, he will be aware that bills are going to go up, electricity bills are going to go up twice this year, later this year. And so I say to him, can he give me a reassurance from the dispatch box today that he will accelerate the government's commitment to the Acorn project in St Fergus?
Will he give me a commitment that he will accelerate the approvals for ScotWind projects which are beside my constituency? And also finally, will he give a better answer than the one he gave earlier to my colleague, how much of this two billion will be spent for the benefit of the people of Scotland?
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Speaker, he talks about setting up wealth funds a long time ago. I probably wouldn't disagree with him on much of that, but I would just suggest the Scottish government has a ScotWind fund which it's currently drawing down to meet the deficit in its own spending. That's not building a legacy for the future, it's using it to paper over the cracks in the fiscal competence of the SNP government. So, and he may welcome this decision, but I genuinely am still not sure what the SNP's position is more generally, but nevertheless, I welcome his support for it. He's right to point out, look, on the Acorn project, he and I have had useful conversations about it.
My honourable friend next to me on the bench is the minister responsible for CCUS. Now, it is going through a process, as he's aware of, in terms of the sales process, and we continue to be very supportive of that process, and we've set aside funding to support the project. In terms of approvals for projects, he's right to flag this, but some of that sits with us, but most of it at the moment is a bottleneck on consenting decisions, which are the responsibility of the Scottish government. And look, I know I have done a bit of point scoring, Madam Deputy Speaker, but in line with the problem-solving, thank you, the problem-solving drive of this government, I would just say I have a really good relationship with Stephen Flynn, the Scottish government energy minister. We are working together on a lot of these things, but we do need to get the consenting decisions made much more quickly so projects can get out and get built.
Lillian Jones
Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the minister's statement to approve Jackdaw, particularly during a global instability. It's going to help strengthen our energy security, protect skills and jobs as we've already heard in the house, but more importantly, start supplying British households and businesses by end of the month. But does the minister also agree that if we're serious about energy security, decarbonisation and faster rollout of electrification, the SNP must rethink their ideological position to nuclear energy, a vital part of the energy mix to deliver reliable low-carbon power for Scotland?
Michael Shanks
Well, I agree with my honourable friend and, you know, I've visited Torness and met the workforce there. They are incredibly skilled workforce. And what I find difficult about the position the Scottish government takes on jobs in Scotland is that they are willing to completely turn their back on the skilled workers in nuclear power who are going searching for jobs in nuclear projects in England or going elsewhere rather than supporting and nurturing those jobs in Scotland today. Never mind the fact that every single day of the week Scotland's energy security relies on the firm nuclear power coming out of Torness nuclear power station. So we have to remove this ideological block, which is just an anti-science approach to technology that will help us get off fossil fuel, deliver clean power and fundamentally incredibly good well-paid jobs in Scotland.
Julian Lewis
Does the government now accept that the former Secretary of State for Energy and Net Zero got this important policy seriously wrong? And if so, why was he promoted to become Foreign Secretary?
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Speaker, I'm tempted to say that is certainly not a question for me, but the first part of his, the first part of his question I will answer. Look, just to be really clear, we came into government with a judgment by the Court of Session which quashed the decisions and it required us to then put in place a process that considered the scope three emissions as part of a consenting regime. We had to design that process, consult on it with industry, get to a place where it was a practical process and then consider the applications. We have done that and we have done it as quickly as we possibly can.
Speaker 111
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome this decision. Can the Minister elaborate on why this pragmatic decision does not impact on the government's target to meet net zero by 2050?
Michael Shanks
Well, the pathway to net zero by 2050 has to accommodate the fact that we will require oil and gas one way or another while we're in that transition. And the choices open to the government are to continue extraction from the North Sea, which we will do with existing fields and with existing consented fields, or import from other places. We're obviously importing from Norway, which has in fact generally cleaner imports than from anywhere else, but we also rely on LNG imports, which have a higher carbon intensity. And therefore the decision is a balancing act of how we deal with the requirement for oil and gas from different places, and the decision the Secretary of State's made is weighing up all of the evidence on that fact that we are able to make this consenting decision within the boundaries of our legally set carbon budgets.
Speaker 115
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I don't know how many people in this place know this, but I actually worked in the oil and gas industry, not for a holiday job, but for years on end. I worked at Kishorn, I worked at Nigg, I worked at Sullom Voe, and I worked in Aberdeen. Now, I'm married, and my wife and I brought up our three children in the hometown I come from. My children went to my old school in Tain in the Highlands.
So I'm a living example, I suggest to the Minister, of the good, we should remember this, that oil and gas brought to the Highlands. So my plea to the Minister and to His Majesty's Government is, please, as much as you can, can you ensure that the benefits from today's decision is spread as far as you can into the Highlands and all those communities which gained so much from the North Sea oil industry?
Michael Shanks
Well, can I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, first of all, what a great pleasure it is to see the honourable gentleman back and looking so well. He is genuinely an honourable gentleman, and it's always a pleasure to speak with him. And I completely agree with him. I suspect in his longer experience of life, there are lots of things he could bring from past experience to this House. He's also a great champion of nuclear and the difference that that made in his constituency as well.
And I agree with him on this. And it was helpful, of course, that he has taken the line much more closely of the leader of the Liberal Democrats. I've done some research, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the leader, of course, said, Jackdaw, I personally have always felt made sense because we're going to need a lot of gas in the transition. So I think the Lib Dem position is actually to support the decision today.
Brian William Leishman
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the facts are that approving Jackdaw will not lower energy bills. Neither will it bring thousands of jobs, and certainly it will not improve the UK's energy security. But a government-owned company shaping the new renewables industry and exercising market control over it certainly would. Now, the Prime Minister has said he wants to reindustrialise the country, and when he comes to Grangemouth to meet me and the local community, we are very much looking forward to hear exactly how he plans to do that for the benefit of our town.
And when it comes to Grangemouth people, Madam Deputy Speaker, let me just say that they are sick, they are tired, they're exhausted of empty promises. They do not want to hear any more about energy transition funds or sovereign wealth funds, because 200 million pounds from the national wealth fund has still not been spent. My people and communities across Scotland need action now. Does the Minister realise that the Labour Party is in danger of losing working-class communities with inaction?
Michael Shanks
Well, I, I would say to him first of all that we, as I have said to him repeatedly, regret the, the, the process that was underway when we came into government and the lack of planning for the workforce in his constituency. Contrary to what he says, we have in fact invested a significant amount of money in supporting that workforce to, to find alternative employment. And we are continuing to spend money on developing the projects that will take advantage of the 200 million pounds from the National Wealth Fund. I'm, unfortunately, I can't magic those projects up out of thin air and so we are doing everything we possibly can to support them. And I would just say to him, we've set up Great British Energy as a publicly owned energy company.
It is already investing in supply chains, in supporting the North Sea transition and in investing and taking a stake in the projects that we're, that we're supporting across the, the energy space and that will bring jobs to his constituency and across the country. And I hope that he will get behind some of the initiatives the government is driving forward.
Speaker 92
And before I bring in the next member, can I just remind people just to think of each other and to speed up on the questions so we can get as many people in as possible. Lee Anderson.
Lee Anderson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Time after time, the previous energy secretary stood in this House and told us that drilling in the North Sea would not bring down domestic prices. Just today, the Prime Minister has stood at that dispatch box and said that prices will come down as a result of drilling in the North Sea. Who's right? The former energy secretary or the Prime Minister?
Yes, he did.
Michael Shanks
Well, I'm, I'm certain he did not say that because the, the truth is that while this decision is important for, for energy security reasons, it will do nothing to bring down prices. Prices are set on an international market and no amount of extraction from the UK shelf will, will change the, the price and that's just the facts of the matter. It is important we do that. And I would just say to him and to his party, we have never been a turn off the taps party in the North Sea, but his party is for drill every last drop and ignore all of the tens of thousands of jobs in constituencies that they represent that are currently relying on those jobs in offshore wind and in other technologies. He would turn his back on all of those jobs and it is absolutely shameful that they would leave this country not more energy secure, but vulnerable at the very moment we should be building up our energy sovereignty.
Richard Baker
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This decision will be welcomed by skilled energy workers right across Scotland and UK who will have a key role in making our transition successful towards renewables and for that reason a positive decision in Rosebank in the future would also be welcome. In terms of this project, though, it's going to create and sustain some 300 skilled energy jobs. Will my honourable friend assure me he'll work with the Scottish Government as well to ensure we do have the right training in place for our energy workers for the future and could some of the resources within the North Sea Wealth Fund contribute to that aim?
Michael Shanks
Yeah, but my honourable friend is right on the, on the point about jobs. I'd just reiterate that direct jobs when we consider projects like this are often not the whole story. I think there is a whole ecosystem around jobs, but he's right to flag it. I do think skills is, is one of the most important things and it's an area that's devolved to the Scottish Government. We have had really good partnership working on a lot of the transition support for workers.
We've, we've joint funded projects for North Sea workers and we'll continue to do that because it is really important we match together the UK government's responsibilities with the Scottish Government's responsibilities. But I would just say there is clearly a real issue at the moment in Scotland with the hollowing out of further education, which is the route through many of the skilled jobs that we need in our economy, not least building the transmission system of the future, which needs highly skilled welders more than anything else. We need to get out of apprenticeships and further education and I hope the Scottish Government will invest even more in colleges across the country.
Susan Murray
Thank you, Madam. Madam Deputy Speaker, the minister says that officials are starting talks with industry leaders on refreshing the North Sea transition deal. So will the minister commit to putting money to retraining offshore workers like those in my constituency of Mid Dunbartonshire at the core of that deal, funded by money from the new Wealth Fund?
Michael Shanks
What I can give her that assurance, but it doesn't need to wait on the new Wealth Fund.
We've already committed funding to doing this. We published the North Sea future plan, which charts a course for the future of the North Sea, focused on oil and gas, but the industries that come next and the workers right at the center of it, both focused on how we provide the training support so we can recognize the huge read-across from oil and gas skills into a lot of the other energy jobs and defense and advanced manufacturing. We need to deploy those skills, but so we can support workers the whole way through that process. We're already getting on with delivering it, and the North Sea future jobs service should launch early next year.
David William Smith
Madam Deputy Speaker, I warmly welcome this statement, especially the word that the Minister has used several times, pragmatism, and how that stands apart from the ideology that we see especially of the Green Party. So does my honorable friend agree that we can't decarbonize our economy, make steps towards a fully renewable energy generation mix, or achieve energy security by relying on importing oil and gas from overseas, which is often more carbon-intensive and which in some cases enriches authoritarian regimes like Iran? And if I can just say, as representative of North Northumberland, where 14,000 households are off the gas grid, what more can his department do to help heating oil and LPG households to access less carbon-intensive products like HVO?
Michael Shanks
Yeah, both really important questions. I first of all just recognize the point he makes around energy independence. We do require gas in the system at the moment, and therefore this decision today is partly around how we increase domestic production in that. But the long-term energy security and our energy independence doesn't come from oil and gas, which we are always going to be a net importer at this point on, and so we have to build a way to get us off that fossil fuel rollercoaster into the future. The second point he makes is absolutely right.
Look, off-gas grid households have felt the significant impact of the war in the Middle East as heating oil prices have skyrocketed. We very quickly put in place a fund to provide support for those households, much, much quicker than the previous government did when Russia invaded Ukraine. I would encourage all of his constituents to make sure they have accessed that fund, as I know people will be starting to refill tanks at this time of year. But we're also doing as much as we can to support through the Warm Homes Plan the decarbonization of those households who of course have access to the electricity grid and so can take advantage of solar panels, of batteries, of heat pumps, and we'll say more about that in due course.
Speaker 125
Diolch, Madam Dirprwy Lefarydd. Gas can help balance the grid, but if we are serious about energy security and decarbonization, we need a clean and reliable source of baseload power, something the Jackdaw field cannot provide. Does the Minister agree with me that the Gwynt y Môr nuclear project on Ynys Môn can help meet that need, and will he work with me to ensure its smooth delivery and so that the energy security benefits can be realized as soon as possible?
Michael Shanks
It's a very well-timed question, Madam Deputy Speaker, because I'm joining the honorable lady in her constituency tomorrow to speak to some of the supply chain businesses that will help build the Gwynt y Môr power station and to visit the site where Gwynt y Môr will be built. And I think it's a really important example of where the last generation of nuclear power can turn into the next generation of apprentices in this new power station that are the grandchildren of people who worked at the Wylfa power station before. It's a huge opportunity, and what I want to work with her on and the Welsh Government is making sure that we get as much economic opportunity from the Gwynt y Môr project as possible with the supply chain jobs in her constituency and across Wales.
Scott Arthur
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for his statement.
I know this is a difficult area to work in, not least because the Scottish government doesn't yet know what its policy on oil and gas drilling is. Yesterday, the energy minister said it would take a year for them to reach a conclusion on that, as reported in the Scotsman. But I do thank him for his engagement with me and also the engagement I've had with the Secretary of State. And they were really open to listening to the many concerns my constituents had about this decision. So I do thank him for that.
And I hope they are reassured that so much of the money from Jackdaw will be invested in renewables. But to some extent, Jackdaw is really just a sideshow. It's really Rosebank that many, many people are concerned about. And will he confirm that despite the media speculation, the decision today will not set a precedent for Rosebank? It'll be judged on its own merits or otherwise.
Michael Shanks
Look, I agree with what he says about the importance of investing in renewables and on the broader question of consenting decisions. Every single individual application is considered on its own merits with its own evidence base and its own consultation process. The Rosebank decision is separate from the Jackdaw decision. But we currently have all of the conclusion of the evidence stage of that and the Secretary of State will make a decision in due course.
Anna Sabine
Madam Deputy Speaker, last week the government declared severe drought across parts of Somerset. And experts suggest we need at least seven months of above-average rainfall to recover from droughts across the country. There can be no question we're in a climate emergency and the approval of Jackdaw today shows that as a country we've not moved fast enough to switch to renewable energy. Does the government agree that the only way we can stop depending on gas is to generate more of our own clean power? And will the minister listen to the Lib Dems and implement our 10-year emergency home upgrade program so that Britain is less dependent on projects like Jackdaw in future?
Michael Shanks
Well look, I agree with her on the point. She's absolutely right. We are in a climate emergency. We all lived through a summer that demonstrated that more than anything we've seen. And I've heard many people say it was the warmest summer on record, but it's probably going to be one of the coldest summers in the future.
We have to do something about it. And I'm fed up hearing people say, well, we should just work on adaptation. We do have to work on adaptation, but we also have to do everything we possibly can to stop this becoming worse. And that's why we're doing all we can on an international level. But it's also why we're building renewables as quickly as possible.
John Martin McDonnell
I agree with her as well that the cheapest energy for homeowners is the energy they don't use. And the more we can do to upgrade our homes in this country, the better. That's what the Warm Homes Plan's all about. And by devolving it to local areas, they can make their own local choices about what works for them.
I'm an enthusiastic supporter of the government's policy about developing alternative energy sources undertaken by the right honorable member for Doncaster North and now, I think, incredibly skillfully developed by the right honorable member for Peckham. But we always knew there were three key decisions that would have environmental implications politically and physically. One is obviously today in Jackdaw, the other's Rosebank, but I also insert into that the third runway at Heathrow. Could I ask him to take into the discussions that he's having with his colleagues my concern that if there is now in the decision-making process approval for Rosebank and/or a third runway at Heathrow, I fear our environmental credentials could be permanently damaged.
Michael Shanks
Well, I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. I'd just say, look, I'm not going to comment on future decisions. But the decision I'm outlining today is very clearly taking into consideration environmental impact and all other decisions will do likewise. We do have a proud record as this party of passing the Climate Change Act and world-leading targets. And for those who say Britain should shrink from the world stage, those decisions have been hugely important for driving the transition to clean power in countries right across the world.
We're not alone in doing this. We have to do that even more. With the consensus across the political divide, we cut emissions enormously. I was there at the closure of our last coal power station. We've made great progress, but there's a huge amount more to do to make sure we break the link with gas, to bring down people's bills, and to tackle the climate emergency, which isn't some future threat anymore, but is an ever-present reality.
John Richard Foord
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm grateful to the minister for confirming that today's decision on the Jackdaw gas field won't do anything to reduce people's bills.
Many of the people who I represent have done everything they can to reduce their heating, but are still paying more than they can afford. Could he please say more about the government's intention to look at removing standing charges on people's gas bills?
Minister.
Michael Shanks
Look, we have heard loud and clear that the standing charge is the most frustrating part of a bill for people, because it's not driven by the individual choices you make about the use of energy, it's driven by a fixed price on the bill. And in gas in particular, the challenge with that is that we want people to use less gas, but there's very little of an incentive if the standing charge remains the same. What we have to work through, and I don't pretend that this is going to be easy, but what the Prime Minister's committed to is working through how do we move the standing charge that still has costs that have to be paid for, the gas network still has to be funded, but in a way that is fairer and that encourages people to make decarbonisation choices for affordability reasons. I think that's really important for all of us, but also crucially, obviously, to bring down people's bills.
Stella Creasy.
Judith Stella Creasy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will know that the climate science is clear that opening any new North Sea oil and gas fields is just incompatible with achieving our Paris Climate Agreement goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees. He will know that Jackdaw alone is worth 35 million tonnes of carbon dioxide and Rosebank a further 250 million. What can he say to my constituents in Walthamstow who are still clearing up after the wildfires that burnt down their homes and damaged their houses, and are now terrified about flooding from El Niño, about how this decision and our work on reducing emissions and the fund that he has mentioned will help protect their future?
Michael Shanks
Well, I hear what she says, and look, on the last point, we are absolutely seized of the fact that the wildfires, the impact heatwaves have had on people's lives is evidence enough if anyone ever needed it, and I know the honourable lady certainly doesn't because she's been a champion in this for a long time, if evidence we needed it that we have to take firm action on tackling climate change. I think that does though require us to design a pathway to get to net zero that recognises the fact we will need oil and gas as part of that transition, and that there are lower emissions to come out of the North Sea than otherwise, but balancing that against significant investment and as quickly as possible investment in renewables and nuclear and in other technologies that help us get off the fossil fuels that we're dependent on at the moment. That is the only long-term pathway to energy security and to tackling the climate crisis, and we're doing everything we can to get there as quickly as possible.
Shockat Patel
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think we have consensus in the House that Jackdaw will benefit the good people of Aberdeen but do absolutely nothing for the rising energy bills for millions of households up and down the country, and also absolutely no benefit for those facing the winter fuel poverty. My concern is this, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the gas will be sold on the international market and the profits will flow to the energy tycoons whose tax returns, let's say, will be very, very interesting. So will the Minister admit that the lobbyists have won over Labour government on this one and confirm when my constituents of Leicester South will see any benefit to their energy bills?
Michael Shanks
Well, I think his constituents will be very surprised when they reach to turn on the heating or their gas cooker that they don't rely on gas. A significant number of his constituencies will rely on gas. We want to get off that gas supply as quickly as possible, but nevertheless, we will continue to require it for a number of years. And so from an energy security point of view, I hope he can recognise why this is important. But I do agree with him on this fundamental point, contrary to any other kind of noise around this, no new oil and gas drilling will ever take a penny off bills.
It doesn't impact bills. It brings in tax revenue to the government, which we are going to invest in the clean energy that gets us off fossil fuels. Breaking the link with gas will bring down his constituents' bills, but it won't directly reduce bills, and I agree with him on that.
Ian Lavery
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
My main concern is working people, working families, working communities. And you know, as a former coal miner, I saw and witnessed the promises from government with regard to a just transition. They failed at every measure to materialize. The devastation, the fact that the communities had their hearts ripped out, were testament to the fact of failed transition. We've still got the scars to bear.
I welcome the government's commitment to invest revenues in a just transition, but workers and communities in the oil and gas industry need cast-iron guarantees of secure jobs in renewables with comparable wages, terms, and conditions. Will the minister meet with me and others who share experiences of failed transition so we can help develop a roadmap that delivers a genuinely fair future for workers and working communities?
Michael Shanks
I am very happy to meet the honorable gentleman and any others, as I always am across the House, who have experiences they want to raise or ideas about how we can do this. I chair the North Sea Future Board, which has trade unions at the heart of it to bring that worker story right to the heart of the decisions we're making. Not just because we owe it to those workers who are powering the country right now and have done for decades, but because they are the critical workforce that will help us build what we need in the future. And he's right to point to failed transitions. We will all have experience of this in our communities, but some more than others.
Tessa Munt
There is a lesson from history that if government doesn't actively engage in building the next part of the transition, we will not support those workers. We are doing everything we can on that, but there's a lot more we can do, and I'm very happy to work with them on it.
Speaker 138
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My colleagues and I have consistently called for electricity prices to be decoupled from the wholesale gas price. The minister has accepted that approving more domestic gas production won't in itself protect households from international price shocks, but that might. Will he accelerate the decoupling, and can he offer a timetable during which he's going to do that?
Michael Shanks
Well, she's right to point to that fact. We've got renewables in the system, but we're not getting the benefit of the pricing because the last marginal unit that we need in order to meet our supply is often gas. Now, that used to be 90% of the time; it's now less than 60% of the time, and we're making huge progress. Just since the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, we've been saving 50 million pounds or more a day on displaced gas costs because of the renewables that we've built. We're going as fast as we can, but decoupling isn't a sort of lever I can just pull and make happen because the marginal price setting is important for making sure we can meet our supply every single day.
Speaker 136
We're doing everything we can on that. It is a number one priority of making sure people feel the benefit of the clean power coming through onto their bills.
Speaker 139
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The minister in an earlier answer talked about the fact that the summer we've just experienced has been the hottest on record, but we fear in the future that might look cold by what's to come. And as a response to that, my constituents are becoming very engaged on issues of the environment, and I've held several MP's eco forums where attendance is going up week by week. My next forum is within the next two weeks, Minister, and I just predict that there will be a question put to me, and I hope you can help me on the floor of the House by giving me the answer, which is: what does today's decision mean in terms of the UK's leadership on the global stage when it comes to tackling climate change?
Michael Shanks
I would say two things. Firstly, we are absolutely clear that tackling the climate crisis is an absolute priority for government, for our national security, for our energy security, and for our children's futures. It is vital and we need to do even more. This decision today is about the transition period where we will need oil and gas to build into where we go next. But that is not the whole story.
And the absolute clear direction from this government is that to tackle the climate crisis, we have to break the link with fossil fuels so that we are not importing from other countries and driving up the climate problems for the future generations to deal with, but we're actually having homegrown clean energy here in the UK and we're already making enormous progress on doing that. And people rightly should feel that there is more government has to do, but I think one of the really important things on climate action is also just to recognize we are making progress. There is always more we need to do, but people shouldn't feel this sense that there's absolutely no route out of this for us. If we can work together, if we can build some of the consensus, we can tackle climate change.
Jim Shannon
Can I thank the minister very much for his statement and I welcome the decision to approve the consent for the Jackdaw gas production, a decision that will secure energy supplies for homes and businesses across the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland at a time when global conflict is putting pressure on energy prices. Now, the minister referred to in his reply to some other honorable member earlier on to the renewable sector benefits that will be used for all of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Could the minister specifically outline the benefits that will come to Northern Ireland and help them also to reduce their energy costs? Thank you.
Michael Shanks
Well, I often have to start with the refrain that energy policy is transferred in Northern Ireland. But on two fronts, firstly, our interconnector with Ireland, which takes gas from Great Britain into Ireland, will of course benefit from the security of supply that we're delivering through this, which is important. But secondly, although I don't have responsibility for decisions on energy policy in Northern Ireland, we have said from the beginning the National Wealth Fund and Great British Energy will operate in Northern Ireland and will invest in projects in Northern Ireland. And I can confirm the two billion pounds that we've set up today will be part of that picture, making sure we can invest in those projects in Northern Ireland as well.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The decision on Jackdaw today has been taken in the context of communities across the country meeting to watch screenings of the national emergency briefing on climate change. The briefing has been prepared by scientists and I have not heard any credible dissent on the science in the film. It would be very difficult to watch the national emergency briefing and conclude, for example, that drilling in the Rosebank oil field should be allowed to go ahead. So can I ask the minister what the government is doing to ensure that there is a comprehensive and effective approach to public education on climate change so that everyone across our country has an accurate science-based understanding of the peril that it brings?
Michael Shanks
Yeah, I think it's a really important question. And you know, as a former teacher, I know I used to teach pupils who would come in worried about this because they see things in the news and they feel a sense of threat from it. And that's why it is important people understand the government is taking this seriously and is determined to tackle climate change at home, but also to play our international role abroad to make sure we can rebuild some of the international consensus to make climate action a reality. I think factual information in these debates is always really important. At times, I think that might help here in this house as well.
But people should seek out the information about what we're seeking to do and the progress we're making as a country towards decarbonizing our energy system.
Richard Burgon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I must say that I am incredibly disappointed in today's decision on Jackdaw. I do believe it flies in the face of all the evidence. I do believe it will do nothing to lower people's energy bills, create jobs, or improve our energy security. Now, the minister has a strong record in making the case for Britain to be a renewable energy superpower.
So can the minister confirm that today's decision on Jackdaw is in no way implying or meaning approval of Rosebank as something that automatically follows?
Michael Shanks
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll be clear, it is a separate consenting decision. I'm not making any comment today on the Rosebank decision at all, which will be made in due course. But I do want to just say, we are absolutely committed to tackling climate change. There is no change at all in my commitment and in the Government's commitment to delivering the clean power mission and to improving homes so we can get off fossil fuels as quickly as possible. But the reality is Britain will need oil and gas for decades to come as part of that transition.
The decision today is about a particular project that helps us get that out of our own continental shelf. He's right to say it won't bring down bills, but it will provide energy security benefits, jobs and of course the investment coming in through tax receipts that we're deploying to deliver more clean power.
Andrew Elliot Pakes
Andrew Pakes. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I warmly welcome the statement from my right honourable friend and the focus not just on investment, jobs and resilience in the North Sea, but in all parts of the United Kingdom. My honourable friend will know the critical role that Peterborough plays in our national gas networks, having visited last November the gas transmission and compression sites to welcome the 870 million pound investment that National Gas has made in the network and in my city. He also met GMB reps and apprentices on that visit alongside me, people I often listen to when it comes to energy policy. So will my right honourable friend join me in thanking the commitment of GMB members across the country for their contribution to this energy debate and also confirm that workers themselves will be critical to any future discussions about our energy balance and how we get this mix right for the future?
Michael Shanks
Well, I should declare an interest, Madam Deputy Speaker, as a member of the GMB, but I'm very happy to celebrate the role that the GMB plays in this. I also am grateful for him raising National Gas and the transmission system because we often talk about oil and gas workers offshore, but actually I've met a number of those workers who help get the gas to homes and businesses across the country. It is also an incredibly skilled job and I pay tribute to the work they do with them. And he's absolutely right to say in this transition, in what is here now in the oil and gas industry, during the transition and in what comes after, workers have to be right at the center.
Amanda Martin
Amanda Martin. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know many people across Portsmouth will welcome today's measured and responsible announcement. At a time of global instability, energy security, it is crucial to have our national resilience. Homegrown energy, which we can attach strong environmental conditions to and use tax receipts from to fund renewables, is better for Britain.
But can the Minister say more about how he plans to make energy independence a key part of our national resilience plan and that today's announcement not affect our warmer homes plan and will not slow the pace of our path to clean power for all, clean power for all?
Michael Shanks
Yeah, I thank my honourable friend for the question. She's right to raise the issue of national resilience. It is front and center of my mind as the Minister responsible for our energy security and resilience, particularly as we go into the winter months. This decision is part of how we make sure that we can absolutely meet the standard that's expected for our gas supplies going into the winter. We'll see more about that in the coming days.
But it is part of a wider picture of the transition because our long-term energy security and resilience can't come from being dependent on a fossil fuel that we will always be a net importer of going forward. We've seen the price spikes that have been caused by a war we had no part in affecting people's bills right now. So the long-term answer is the clean power she talks about. And she's right to raise the point of warmer homes, which is how we get more homes to use less energy and for consumers to live in warmer conditions, spending less on their energy bills. It's absolutely critical.
Nadia Whittome
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government claims that approving Jackdaw will help fund clean energy, making it, if you like, both the arsonist and the firefighter. But the North Sea is a declining basin, meaning it's a rapidly shrinking tax base. The OBR expects the North Sea to provide just 100 million in tax per year by 2030. And at that rate, Madam Deputy Speaker, the oil and gas sector would take 20 years to match the government's injection into the energy wealth fund today.
Nadia Whittome.
Does the minister see that approving Jackdaw is a false economy?
Michael Shanks
Well, look, what I'd say is she's right to say the North Sea's a declining basin. I've said that on a number of occasions. That's not going to going to turn around by decisions that we make. But nonetheless, we were elected on a manifesto that very clearly said we would not issue new licenses to explore new fields, but we would manage existing license existing fields for their lifetime. This is on an already licensed field and so it is compliant with our manifesto.
And the investment from this will allow us to build the clean power that will get us off fossil fuels. It's about recognizing we have to do both. The long-term future comes from reducing our dependence on fossil fuels and phasing it out completely, but we will need oil and gas in the interim.
Gareth Snell.
Craig Gareth Snell
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I agree with the minister when he talks about the price spikes and the roller coaster of oil and gas, but I do take concern when he talks about coming off oil and gas, because he will know there are some sectors in this country where you are always going to have to use gas forever because there are not alternatives, whether that be glass, metal, cement, and of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, ceramics. So while the minister is talking about how this will not bring down industrial gas prices, and with the government having decided to exclude gas-intensive industries from BIPS and supercharge schemes, what actually is this government going to do to make sure that those industries that are dependent upon gas and are crucial to our reindustrialization get the help and support that they need?
Michael Shanks
Well, he's right to raise this point and I know my right honorable friend the business secretary hears that point and we absolutely are doing everything we can on industrial prices as well as domestic prices. But I know there is more we need to do. Breaking the link is crucial for the electricity bills that those industries face, but I know he is particularly focused on the gas they use. And when I talk about phasing out gas, we have always been clear there will be a strategic reserve that will be necessary for particular industries and for particular parts of the power system, but we should be using it much less. And where we do need to support industry is to find new ways to decarbonize, be it with hydrogen or with other fuels, but some will continue to require gas.
Speaker 146
And I recognize that fact and we'll continue to work with him and others to make sure we're doing everything to support those industries.
Mark Sewards.
James Mark Sewards
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's pragmatic decision on Jackdaw. Clearly it makes sense to use gas from the North Sea rather than importing it from abroad. I also welcome the minister's comments that the funds it raises in tax revenue will be used to support the green transition, hopefully with a view of bringing down energy bills in the future. But my constituents know that their energy bills are going up in January and they want help with that now.
And given that he's obviously ruled out using these funds to support them with direct help for their energy bills, can I encourage him to use any mechanism available to him to get people the support they need with their energy bills in January, possibly have conversations with the Treasury too, because as he knows the cost of living crisis is biting now.
Michael Shanks
Well, he's right on on that point. The affordability crisis is the number one thing facing all our constituents. I'm not going to cut across what the Chancellor may or may not say next week in his budget, but I hear what he says. I would just say we have already taken action here in terms of removing VAT from electricity bills and 150 pounds of costs that we took off bills previously.
But the first point he makes is critical here because the situation in the Middle East is what is driving up everyone's bills. And we can continue to take action to reduce those bills as the previous government did when Russia invaded Ukraine. But we don't fix the fundamental problem that every single time there is another fossil fuel spike, we're reliant on bailing out again the fact that we haven't fixed the fundamentals. And so deploying clean power, while it won't immediately take action for everyone, every single wind turbine we switch on and solar panel we plug in helps reduce our dependence on gas and does bring down bills for people.
Henry Tufnell.
Henry Tufnell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I congratulate the Minister on backing British industry in the North Sea. But he will know that industrial communities like mine in Pembrokeshire face existential threats from high energy costs and high carbon costs. So what measures can he set out that the government is taking in order to ensure that the government is supporting good unionized, well-paid jobs and industry right across the country?
Michael Shanks
Well look, I welcome his appreciation of the decision we've made today. I would just suggest that the longer-term impact of climate change will be felt by his constituents as much as everyone else's. And so it is in all of our interests, as I know he appreciates, for us to make sure we're taking action to tackle that. And so while this is an important decision, I also think the action on deploying clean power and breaking that link with fossil fuels is really important as well. And he is right to center this discussion in jobs.
We've worked not just to create new jobs in the clean power of the future, but to make sure those are good jobs. On offshore wind, for example, making sure there is fair work for offshore workers, work we've done in conjunction with trade unions and with the workforce. We want to grow the employment in clean power, but for those to be good, well-paid, sustainable jobs too.
Chris Ward.
Christopher David Ward
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am concerned about the message this decision will send about how serious we are about tackling the climate emergency and protecting our hard-fought international reputation as a world leader on climate change. But I'm even more concerned, and I know my constituents in Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven will be too, that this is a prelude to the bigger decision to come on Rosebank. So can the Minister confirm that when that decision is taken, the climate emergency and our international climate commitments will be at the forefront of his mind and that we will have a chance to debate that in this House?
Michael Shanks
Well, first I'd just say on the international point and the message it sends about the climate emergency, I can't be clearer about how central we still see tackling climate change to the wider agenda we have in our energy policy. The transition to a non-fossil fuel economy does require oil and gas for decades to come. And this decision is about where we get that from, not about the end goal, which is to remove our exposure to fossil fuels in the long term. And we are continuing to take action on the climate crisis in a whole range of other ways, not least the Secretary of State will lead our delegation to COP to make sure we're continuing to press for international collaboration on this. On the wider point, consenting decisions are regulatory decisions for the Secretary of State to make and then for the North Sea Transition Authority to make the final decision and issue the consent.
They're not subject to debates in this House. They are quasi-judicial debates. But I can absolutely assure him, as this decision is, it will be based on a whole range of factors of which the environmental impacts are absolutely central.
Josh Dean
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I hear what the Minister says, but there is a generation of young people growing up in the shadow of a growing climate crisis today. Countless constituents in Hertford and Stortford have written to me to set out their concern about this decision and a potential decision on Rosebank. And it's a concern that I share.
So can the Minister say more about how the Energy Wealth Fund will support this Labour government's mission to tackle the climate crisis and drive to net zero? And what would he say to reassure my constituents, many of whom are coming to my climate and nature town hall at the end of this month?
Michael Shanks
Well, I'm glad people across the country are engaging in these kind of discussions. It's really important I think that people get together and discuss this and recognize the absolute centrality of climate change to our lives right now as well as the impact it will have in the future. I would say two things. Firstly, this government takes very seriously the climate emergency and is taking action right now to tackle it, whether that is building the clean power that gets us off fossil fuels or whether it's improving homes so that people use less fossil fuel energy in heating their homes. We're taking those actions now.
And the second thing is for young people right now, they should believe that their government is taking this just as seriously despite the noise across the political debate. This government takes seriously climate action and we are building good long-term jobs for them in the industries of the future in clean energy that we can be equally proud of as a country delivering good jobs in every single community. And I hope the young people that attend his meetings will see some of those opportunities as a real chance for a career in this country but also to help us tackle the climate emergency.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today's decision feels like a backward step in our efforts to reduce carbon emissions and our reliance on fossil fuels. But one of our biggest challenges is the 88 billion pounds worth of UK pensions that are invested in this dying market, some 10 times what the funds invest in clean energy sources. So can I ask the Minister what pressure he is bringing to bear to wean our pension funds off these damaging fossil fuel investments?
Michael Shanks
Well, what we are doing as a government is making it as attractive as possible to invest in clean energy sectors, which is why we've seen more than 100 billion pounds worth of private investment in the clean energy transition since we came into government, 110 billion pounds of that investment coming in in two and a half years. So it's clear people do see the clean energy transition as a route for investment but also for helping to build our energy security. And I'd just say to all those who don't take seriously the economic opportunity from this, pension funds or others, there is a huge opportunity here to build the country we want to see in the future and to get good economic returns as a result. And we've set up things like the National Wealth Fund and Great British Energy to help crowd in that investment.
Chris Hinchliff
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's not quite the response to catastrophic climate change, wildfires and drought that I had in mind, but I accept that that appears to be a minority view in this place. Nevertheless, despite all the sophistry, the inconvenient truth remains that this choice means that more fossil fuels currently buried will be extracted and burned to pollute our planet. So does the Minister understand why so many people find it hard to believe that the hope of a livable planet will win out against short-termism and deluded self-interest?
Michael Shanks
Look, I don't agree with that actually. And look, it's the same answer I gave to the Green Party frankly. We absolutely believe in tackling the climate crisis and in building our way out of a dependence on fossil fuels. But I can't just click my fingers and make that happen overnight. You have to be able to build this infrastructure over time and there is a transition period where gas will remain the main source of people heating their homes.
Now we have to move even faster to change that so that we're electrifying heating to bring down people's bills and to get us off fossil fuels. I'm open to any ideas my honorable friend might have in how we could go faster on that.
Jonathan Brash
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I warmly welcome this decision today. New drilling in the North Sea is good for energy security, national security and jobs, jobs included in my constituency of Hartlepool in the supply chain.
So too jobs in Hartlepool being created in new nuclear and renewables. So does it frustrate the Minister as it frustrates me when certain politicians, populist politicians, put their ideology ahead of the facts and would destroy jobs in renewables, in nuclear, and in North Sea oil and gas in my constituency and across the country?
Michael Shanks
Well, I couldn't agree with him more and I'm also really grateful for him putting on record the fact that there are jobs in oil and gas in Hartlepool and in towns like it across the UK as well because although there is a concentration of jobs in the northeast of Scotland, it would be wrong to say that this is a northeast of Scotland problem to solve. There are jobs all across the country and if we get this transition right, the point I make to him about oil and gas workers, about the new nuclear that we want to see in his constituency and about renewables is that it is the same workforce that we are going to support to retrain but to bring their immense experience into what we have to build in the future. It's in our self-interest to center this transition in the workers that are currently powering the country through oil and gas but will take us through in the future. And he is right to call out those politicians who talk about pragmatism but who want it all to be one way. Pragmatism means being clear oil and gas will be important for decades to come but we have to invest now in the jobs of the future in his constituency and right across the country.
Speaker 161
And that concludes the statement. I'll just give the front benches a few moments to swap over. Statement, Education Secretary.
Speaker 157
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. With permission, I will make a statement on Sir David Bell's review into antisemitism in schools and colleges in England. But first, Madam Deputy Speaker, let me just apologize for some reporting of this in the media. The full report and the government response were laid to the House this morning and weren't given to the media first and I have ordered a leak inquiry into this matter. Today, Sir David has published this seminal review exposing the shocking scale of antisemitism in British society and how that's reflected across education.
Speaker 154
Almost three in five Jewish young people and half of Jewish teachers have experienced or witnessed antisemitism. This cannot continue. So let me place on record my sincere thanks to Sir David for his excellent report and to the reference group for their support with it. Madam Deputy Speaker, make no mistake. This is a report for every teacher, every staff member, every education leader, and every student listening today.
Speaker 157
All children and teachers should be able to go to school or college free from fear. But there's a wider responsibility for education as a whole to teach our young people British values of tolerance, acceptance, and respect for one another. Collectively, we have a duty to educate this generation and the next on what antisemitism is, on why it's wrong, and on what happens when it takes hold in society. So whether or not there are Jewish staff and Jewish students in your school or college, this report is for you too. This generational challenge belongs to us all.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we all know that antisemitism is an ancient evil. Today, it remains as pernicious as ever. But its modern mutation is in many ways more prominent and more prevalent and perhaps most concerning of all, it's especially true amongst young people. Old tropes have found new life in the modern world. The fallacy that Jewish networks control the global economy and other such delusions, once confined to the fringes, have found a new home on social media.
Speaker 155
Antisemitism is now normalized and amplified in the echo chambers online, reaching directly into children's bedrooms.
I want to thank my right honorable friend, the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, for her leadership and commitment to tackling this issue, and I'm grateful to her for her collaboration. Madam Deputy Speaker, as Sir David's report also identifies, the conflict in the Middle East has significantly fanned the flames of division here at home. Misunderstanding, ignorance, and deliberate misrepresentation can quickly lead to antisemitism, at times casual, at others more serious, and all too often unreported and unchallenged. As a House and a government, we must be absolutely clear: blaming British Jews for the actions of the Israeli government is antisemitism. Assuming British Jews have a particular political standpoint because they are Jewish is antisemitism.
Speaker 157
Targeting British Jews out of concern for Palestine is antisemitism. When such views and behaviors are expressed in any school or college, whether or not they are aimed directly at a Jewish person, they are antisemitic, and we have a duty to challenge them. Sitting at the center of our communities, schools and colleges have a leadership role in fostering tolerance, compassion, and respect for difference. And let me be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, teachers should not bring their own political views into the classroom. That is a fundamental of education.
But this principle should not lead to a shying away from difficult debates. In fact, as Sir David's report very clearly recommends, schools and colleges should be the place for important discussions. However, school leaders often fear reprisals, protests, or accusations of political bias, so they avoid discussing and addressing important topics. I want to empower our teachers and school and college leaders to tackle these issues head-on. Our young people have to learn how to navigate contentious debates thoughtfully and respectfully, and to understand that antisemitism and other forms of racism are wrong.
Speaker 158
That's a job for education, but we all have a responsibility to set the tone, here in this House and on the media too: robust debate and challenge matched with respect, tolerance, and disagreeing amicably. Madam Deputy Speaker, a new approach is needed. Antisemitism is unique in both historical context and its reach today. It demands a unique response. That is why this government accepts all 27 recommendations from Sir David's review.
Speaker 157
I'd like to thank everyone who contributed their views and experiences, but perhaps above all, I want to recognize the Jewish community directly for their bravery in engaging with this review. I don't take lightly the personal cost they have paid in recounting their deeply hurtful experiences. So they not only have my thanks, but my word that their voices will be heard, change will come. Madam Deputy Speaker, to the report's recommendations. Firstly, definition matters.
Speaker 155
Combating antisemitism starts with identifying it, and I agree with Sir David that the use of a common and consistent definition will improve understanding and confidence. So I will write to all schools and colleges to set out my expectation that they adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance working definition of antisemitism.
And as Sir David recommends, we'll strengthen the safeguarding guidance to make clear that antisemitism is a distinct risk and therefore requires a distinct safeguarding response. I also accept the recommendation for all education settings to record antisemitic incidents as a specific category. Next, Sir David identified that school and college leaders as well as head and teacher unions need more support to identify and challenge antisemitism. So we will develop and roll out high-quality training, good practice guidance, and practical resources, as well as dedicated support for leaders in managing complex and serious incidents involving antisemitism, including where escalation is needed. We'll also give schools and colleges clear and specific support for how and when controversial and sensitive issues should be discussed.
Speaker 157
Next, we'll update and strengthen the Holocaust education so that this generation and the next can better understand its horrors, how it came about, and why that should matter to us today. So I can confirm that it will continue to be compulsory in the national curriculum. But Madam Deputy Speaker, as Sir David has recommended, while it's right that every child should know about the Holocaust, that shouldn't be the only thing they know about Jewish people and their history. As part of the curriculum, we will ensure the contribution, the culture, and the history of Jewish people in Britain is well understood and appreciated. Judaism is a diverse, modern, and generous faith tradition, and the curriculum should reflect that too.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, it's not just about what happens in the classroom. One of the most shocking findings of Sir David's review was that following the Heaton Park synagogue terrorist attack, educational visits to the Manchester Museum in my constituency fell by half, just when those visits were needed the most. So we will boost opportunities for engagement with Jewish cultural experiences. And Madam Deputy Speaker, the testimonies of teachers and leaders in Jewish schools about how much of their time is spent on safety and not teaching were particularly concerning. We can't build ever higher walls around our Jewish institutions, but we will continue to work with the Community Security Trust and the Home Office to ensure that children and staff can be safe, happy, and supported.
Sir David looked closely at the issue of political symbols displayed by staff and students. He found it not to be a widespread issue and so concluded that extending existing legal duties on schools would be disproportionate. I accept his recommendation. But as Education Secretary, I am clear: I would not expect to see teachers coming to school or college wearing or displaying any political material. There are further important recommendations for leaders and schools and colleges, for teachers, staff, parents, unions, and beyond.
I will ensure that we work to do what needs to be done and to maintain the momentum. That's why I've set up an implementation group which will get to work immediately, and I've asked Sir David to conduct a one-year review on the implementation of his recommendations. Madam Deputy Speaker, while universities are not in scope of this review, I want to make clear to the House that the rise in antisemitism on our campuses is completely unacceptable. I wrote to all vice-chancellors earlier this month about the steps they need to take to combat antisemitism, and I will continue to act wherever I can. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is an incredibly important moment for education and for our country.
Speaker 155
It falls on our generation to educate the next on what can happen to a society when antisemitism is allowed to take hold and why we all have a duty to root it out.
Speaker 160
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of the statement and also for taking the time to brief me on the report yesterday. This is an important and timely review and I pay tribute to Sir David Bell and his team and those brave individuals who came forward to share their experiences, many reliving deeply distressing events. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is a great sadness and a failure on us all as a society that such a review is necessary in 2026. I've met many Jewish parents left with an impossible choice: sending their children to mainstream schools where Jewish pupils are heckled, bullied and singled out, or sending them to Jewish schools with prison-like security under constant threat from outside. I cannot imagine the fear that parents feel every day about what their children might face at school.
If we're going to address this stain on our society, advocacy across this House is vital and I welcome the review's recommendations, including adopting the IHRA definition of antisemitism, strengthening guidance, teacher training and teacher standards, something that I've consistently called for. There are two points that I want to raise which I hope will be picked up as part of the implementation review. The first is enforcement. Many of the instances that the report describes are already against existing guidance. The problem is, when impartiality guidance is breached, nothing happens.
The case of the honourable member for Bristol North East demonstrates the problem. His visit to a school was cancelled following opposition from pro-Palestinian campaigners and NEU members. When Ofsted rightly inspected the school afterwards, they couldn't investigate the very incident that actually prompted the inspection. They could only check at the time of the visit whether everything was meeting obligations. What is the point of an inspection if inspectors can't examine the incident that triggered it?
Will the Secretary of State agree to close this loophole and can she please outline in her response what she expects to happen to a school if they do not appropriately address antisemitic instances? My second point concerns the role of unions. I welcome the review's examination of their role, but I do not think that the recommendations are strong enough. Asking them to examine their own actions is allowing them to mark their own homework and we already know that this doesn't work. In the incident of the Labour MP being banned, it was an NEU official who was putting pressure on the school to make this happen.
Michaela Wild, a senior NEU official, reportedly said she was very proud of having forced the school to cancel the visit, warning critics, "Don't mess with the NEU because we're not here to play." And what has happened to her, Madam Deputy Speaker? She appears to remain on the NEU's national executive representing Bristol and the South West. Shameful. How can someone who campaigned for and celebrated preventing a Jewish MP from visiting a school continue in such a senior position?
Where is the accountability? It is deplorable. So will the Secretary of State commit today to investigate those individuals who've stood by such views and made such statements and where warranted have them removed from schools? Otherwise, we might as well go home, Madam Deputy Speaker, because without accountability nothing changes.
The last thing I want to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that schools do not exist in a bubble. Things that happen outside are too often mirrored in the classroom. The despicable, antisemitic Green Party motion encourages such sentiments to be brought up at school. And Labour ministers must reflect on their responsibility. Lack of action on hate marches, inflammatory language from the Foreign Secretary, and unenforceable performative bans on Israeli goods help no one and cause a surge in antisemitism.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, today's measures are welcome. I hope the Secretary of State can address my points on implementation, on unions and enforcement, and accept the responsibility that we all have to play. My final question is this. She rightly acknowledges antisemitic instances arising not only in schools but also in universities. Will the Secretary of State commit today to repeat this exercise for universities?
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank the right honourable lady for that and for discussing these issues with me yesterday, and also for her contribution to the review. I know that she spent time speaking to Sir David, which he really valued. And I think as she says, and as I have said, I think it's really important that this is an issue that we should address collectively with one voice as one House, because I think we all absolutely agree that we don't want to hear any more of the kind of testimonies that she outlined in her statement there. She's absolutely right to do that. Can I just pick up on a couple of the points that she asked about.
Of course, enforcement, I think data collection, measurement, you know, these are all going to be absolutely sort of critical to both ensuring that the implementation happens, but more importantly that change happens as well, and that in a year's time I am able to come back to this House to say that the situation has improved. That's why we're updating the teacher standards. It's also why we're including specifically in the safeguarding framework the obligation to regard to antisemitism. Of course she'll know that safeguarding is a key issue that Ofsted looks into and inspects. And it's also why we are updating and boosting reporting as a requirement as well, because when things are reported, action can follow much more closely.
And I think look, if we need to go further, we'll go further, but I think we have set out today in response to David's review a number of ways in which I think those things will be measured and enforced as well. On the issue of the trade unions, Madam Deputy Speaker, Sir David looked into this in his review very clearly. And he was clear in his report, and I've asked him to do this review and I take fully what he has found in that. He was clear that he does not believe that any education union to be inherently antisemitic. And he's also clear that the education unions should have robust policies and processes in place to tackle these issues and ensure members are sufficiently trained.
And I have discussed these matters with the education unions and I, you know, know that they are keen to put that right. What I would gently say to her really in the spirit of us coming together on this issue is that the fear of reprisal, the fear of media attention, political attention and other around being impartial, being politically impartial, is what has led to many school leaders, and this was testimony we heard time and time again, many school leaders, many teachers, fearing tackling these issues head on, going into these debates when they hear some of these age-old tropes in the classroom for fear of reprisal, for fear of not being supported, that they're not going into it.
And David's review was very clear that education settings, schools and colleges, absolutely should be a place where issues can be debated, challenged, discussed and brought to life. So we do have to get this balance right. If anything, I would say the balance is too far the other way. The fear of remaining politically impartial is actually hampering our teachers and school leaders from doing what they need to do. I'm glad she's mentioned, I can see there's a Green MP in her seat today.
We're absolutely clear on this side of the House that the motion passed by the Green Party is wrong, it is antisemitic. And actually, I would say to the Green Party leadership, they really do have a much deeper responsibility here because their reach into young people particularly is incredibly profound. And the repeating of this motion in campuses, in councils, in colleges, which is now happening, is causing widespread fear and is, I think, seeing a result in ever-increasing antisemitism since this report was actually published. So I would ask the Green Party to really consider these issues very, very carefully.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement today? And can I thank Sir David Bell for his work on this important review? Can I pay tribute to him for the thoughtful approach he has taken and thank him for taking the time to meet with me during the review, including the opportunity to discuss a disgraceful antisemitic attack on a child in my constituency which occurred in recent months, an abhorrent and devastating incident, the like of which should simply never happen. The review highlights the important role of schools and colleges in tackling antisemitism and in helping children and young people to navigate difficult, complex and challenging issues.
This is ever more important in an age of social media and in the context of extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds. So can I ask the Secretary of State how she will ensure that teachers have the capacity and the skills to rise to the scale of this challenge, to meet their obligations to political impartiality while helping our children and young people to navigate the serious and complex challenges in our society, to ensure that education plays the fullest possible role in stamping out antisemitism and in fostering community cohesion and creating the engaged, thoughtful and responsible citizens that all of us want to see?
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank my honourable friend and for all the leadership and work that she continues to do as chair of the Select Committee. I know of the incident of her constituent which we've discussed a couple of times and I was as horrified as she was to hear of it. And I hope that some of the students and schools that they go to involved in that incident are listening today and understanding that they should have gone further and they still can go further in challenging and taking action about what happened to her young constituent.
Look, she's absolutely right. I think how we support teachers and school and college leaders to develop the capacity and skills, to develop the confidence to feel supported in challenging these issues, in creating an environment where they can be discussed and understand why they are wrong when they're expressed and and what that means when they are expressed and otherwise is absolutely critical. We are, as she knows, we are in the middle of updating the curriculum at the moment. That includes the the new citizenship curriculum coming on stream throughout the whole of primary and secondary schools and we will ensure that's included. And we will be updating teacher training as well as well as all the other things that I've announced today in this report.
Munira Wilson
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of her very welcome statement and Sir David Bell for all his work on the review. Importantly, I'd like to thank all those who bravely shared their experiences with Sir David. Antisemitism has no place in our society and we Liberal Democrats reaffirm our commitment to rooting out this evil in all its forms. We welcome and accept all the recommendations in the Bell review, some of which we have been calling for, and we are committed to working with the government to support its implementation.
The scale of the challenge as set out in the report is alarming. Just last month, a teenage boy was attacked at Belsize Park tube station on his way home from Hasmonean Boys' School, a Jewish school in North London. It's being treated as a hate crime. When I met children and young people who attend Richmond Synagogue, they told me about their horrendous experiences of bullying, both physical and verbal, at school and at university. Most of them are having to hide their faith.
Madam Deputy Speaker, no one in this country should have to hide their faith. Our schools and colleges should be safe and welcoming places to learn where every child feels they belong, not places of fear. I want to thank the Community Security Trust for their tireless work protecting the Jewish community. Whilst extra support for security at Jewish schools is welcome, my Jewish constituents tell me they do not want ever higher walls built around them. I want in particular to welcome recommendation 17 relating to support for discussion of sensitive topics.
Some of my young constituents have told me they were not allowed to discuss events in the Middle East at school. We know that shutting down debate in what should be a safe space only pushes it into darker spaces. But my main question for the Secretary of State today is whether she will be providing any extra funding to help schools, colleges, and local authorities in implementing these recommendations or or whether they will have to rely on existing budgets. As the Secretary of State said, this generational challenge belongs to all of us, Jewish or not. All of the individual recommendations are important, but crucially we need a culture change across our society and that starts with education.
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank my honourable friend for that that powerful contribution. She's absolutely right both in terms of the fact that I think antisemitism is getting worse, not better. Even since David Bell began his review a few months ago, we've all seen and heard of the horrors that we know about, but as well as the unreported as well as reported incidents that are happening around the country and education settings reflect that. But as I said earlier, I think there is a particularly shocking rise in antisemitic views amongst our young people, which is often distinct from other forms of racism which we often find being different generations. That's why it needs to be tackled as a generational issue for all of us, for every single school and college, not just those that represent the Jewish communities.
But she is right in what she says about those attending Jewish schools and colleges.
I hear the same testimonies as she does about having to hide one's faith, hide one's identity. We're also taking forward a plan of action with British Transport Police so that buses and travel to and from school can be made safer as well. There will be funding attached to what we've outlined today. I will make sure school and college have the funding that they need to do the jobs that we need them to do. But actually, I think this is about leadership really at the moment and about ensuring that schools do feel they are able to address these issues, they're confident they will get supported.
There are often counter-protests, counter-reprisals when action is taken and that's why I want every school leader and college leader to know I will back them. I will back them in having debates in their schools. I will back them in any action they need to take.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So I welcome this important report. So I am a Zionist, for Zionism is the belief that Jewish people have a right to self-determination in their ancient homeland. Nothing more, nothing less. Let us teach that to our children.
Now, our government has rightly recognized the state of Palestine and it too must have a sustainable and secure future. But does the Minister agree with me that we must refute other spurious definitions of Zionism fabricated for political purposes? Let us teach that to our children too.
Speaker 157
Well, I absolutely agree with his words wholeheartedly. And Zionism is not racism and that is why the motion passed by the Green Party is so wholly wrong and is anti-semitic. And I want people to hear that loudly and clearly. And in the IHRA definition of anti-semitism, it is clear that denying the right to Jewish people to self-determination is anti-semitic. And that's why it's really important that schools adopt it.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State's statement this afternoon. Can't disagree with anything that she has said and the clear passion with which she said that the government wishes to tackle anti-semitism in this country. I put it to her and the House that the scale of the emergency that we are facing, when I speak to Jewish constituents in Mid Buckinghamshire who are living in fear, are reporting to me that they are removing all visual identifiers of their Jewish faith. It is absolutely alarming.
The Secretary of State herself opened her statement with the statistic that almost three in five Jewish young people and half of Jewish teachers have experienced or witnessed anti-semitism. That requires a hyper-urgent response. And so whilst I appreciate the Secretary of State saying she'll report back in a year, can she give greater confidence that there will be month-by-month, week-by-week even, tracking of the way these actions, these recommendations are actually implemented to give British Jewish communities that faith that the scale of urgency is absolutely there and that we won't find ourselves potentially in a year's time thinking we wish we could have done more.
Speaker 157
Well can I thank him for that question and contribution. And look he is absolutely right. The scale, the urgency, the how it exists everywhere in every part of society is absolutely shocking and something we all need to really take hold of. And that's why I've been really clear actually, made sure, fully made sure I'm the one leading this in my department as the Education Secretary. We've had cross-government meetings and action task forces on antisemitism across a range of issues.
He will be aware that there are a number of other reviews happening across other aspects of public services and elsewhere as well. And I think it's why I was really clear that I want, there's really important recommendations in this report and we accept them all and we will implement them all. But this is bigger than one report or one set of recommendations and their implementation. We have to have this big conversation, this national conversation about what contemporary antisemitism looks like, where it is appearing, why it is appearing, calling it out and explaining to the next generation what happens, what goes wrong in a country and a society when we fail to do that. And that is a job on every single one of us, not just me.
Speaker 168
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank Sir David Bell for his report which is as depressing as it is unsurprising. Its findings that antisemitism in our schools is on the rise, we know is not just rising in our schools, it is rising across society, it is rising across the world. It is perhaps the most depressing that what this suggests is that if we do not take the recommendations that it will embed for generations that antisemitism. As the UK special envoy on post-Holocaust issues, I particularly welcome the recommendations on Holocaust education and on the adoption of the IHRA definition.
I would like to say that it's a working definition of antisemitism. It can't just be put on a shelf. It needs to be used and in order for it to be effective, there needs to be training for all those in our schools who are using it. So will the Secretary of State commit to supporting schools to make sure that that training is provided?
Speaker 157
Can I first of all thank him for all the work that he's done on these issues over many, many years and the role that he's currently playing on the board of the IHRA. And I'm glad that he's welcoming the updating and enhancing of the Holocaust education. We're going to be working with the Holocaust Education Trust and its chief executive is sitting on the implementation task force and I know that she will be doughty in making sure that we do that very well. He's absolutely right. This is a working definition, the IHRA definition.
It's a practical guide, but it only comes to life when it is trained, when it is implemented and when people use it as an everyday tool to navigate the issues that they might be facing in their school or college.
Julian Lewis
May I congratulate the Secretary of State on what in my opinion is the best statement I have heard from any government minister on any subject since the last general election and it has rightly brought forth supportive comments both from the Conservative and the Liberal Democrat front benches and from backbenchers as well.
I have a an interest in the question of impartiality in schools because it's rather disconcerting to realize that it was 40 years ago in May 1986 that I was working with a group of peers led by Caroline Cox, Baroness Cox, and the late Professor Lord Beloff to amend the 1986 Education Bill. And the two provisions that were put forward in that bill were carried forward in the 1996 Education Act as sections 406 and 407. 406 bans political indoctrination in school and 407 lays down that when political subjects, politically contentious subjects are discussed in schools, they must be presented in a balanced and appropriate way with opposing views fairly discussed. When the Secretary of State writes to all the schools, can I suggest to her that she should as an annex to her letter just include a single page which sets out the provisions of section 406 and section 407 of the Education Act because they are as germane today as they were when first formulated for the previous act 40 years ago.
Speaker 157
Well, can I first of all thank him as as ever for all the work that he has done on this issue over many years. I I find it hard to believe that's over 40 years, I have to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, couldn't possibly be that long. But he makes a really important point and I will certainly look at those sections. He's got better history than I have of education acts and will look at including those as as an annex because he he's absolutely right. And I think people go into teaching, they become school and college leaders because they absolutely know that they have to leave their own political views at at the door and they want to educate the next generation in in all of these issues.
And we have to regain that confidence in schools and classrooms to have debate and to disagree amicably and respectfully and to hear each other's opinions in a balanced way. And that is what I want all our schools to feel able to do. So thank him for amending a bill, I know he will continue to amend bills for time to come and I will look at those annexes and include them in my letter.
James Mark Sewards
Very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Antisemitism has swept across the UK and I am so sorry to see this report confirm what I think we already knew, that schools are yet another battleground against the world's oldest hatred. That is why I do commend the government for its swift acceptance of all of the recommendations set out in Sir David Bell's review, as well as the Secretary of State's excellent answer to the question from my friend the member for Bury St Edmunds on anti-Zionist antisemitism and why it should be condemned. Just on one particular recommendation, treating antisemitism in schools as a safeguarding issue will create an explicit duty on all schools to address this as they would to a threat to any other child's safety. So how will the government support schools to enact this duty and how will they make sure they're accountable for delivering it?
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank him for that contribution and for agreeing with the findings of the report.
Sir David has recommended the safeguarding issue as an explicit duty, and we've accepted that completely, because I actually also think that is a way in which we can ensure that it is reported, it is measured, it is understood, and that there is then explicit training for teachers and staff about it, because it is a statutory duty in the safeguarding. All the resources, all the materials, all the training, everything will be available within the year for our schools and colleges to implement this report.
Victoria Collins.
Victoria Collins
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Joining my local Jewish community to celebrate Sukkot in Berkhamsted and seeing how the children are joyously celebrating was heartwarming, but then seeing how they have to have security there to stay safe is heartbreaking, and hearing how they have to hide their faith is absolutely devastating. And in Sir David Bell's survey, it revealed that many students believe reported antisemitic incidents will not be addressed. So what steps will the Secretary of State take to rebuild student trust, and how will she improve the reporting system so they lead to proper accountability?
Speaker 157
Can I thank her for that, and another testimony about students feeling they have to hide their faith, and indeed many accounts we heard through this review of teachers doing the same in their school and colleges as well. That's why we're accepting all the recommendations, that's why we want to put this issue centre stage, that's why we're having this important debate in this House today and showing that cross-party resolve that this is something we want to see schools and colleges taking action on, but we also want to see society as a whole debating, discussing, and understanding the difference between maybe some of their political views and what becomes, can quickly become, antisemitism.
Janet Daby.
Janet Jessica Daby
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for her statement and for accepting all of the review's recommendations. Antisemitism, and indeed all forms of prejudice and racism, undermine public order and safety and need to be challenged wherever they appear. I'm currently working with a community leader, Joe Burchell, a leader from my local synagogue in my constituency, to campaign to reintroduce faith officers to local police forces. Does the Secretary of State agree that faith officers could help to counter hate in our schools, and would she agree to look into this and to work with her Home Office colleagues?
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank her for that and for all the work that she's doing in her community with Joe Burchell and others. I mean, there are obviously big questions for all of our public services. This is something that every single one of my colleagues around the cabinet table take incredibly seriously, and I will certainly pass on her suggestion for faith officers in the police to my counterpart.
Iain Duncan Smith
Madam Deputy Speaker, forgive me, I'm recovering from flu, but can I commend the right honourable lady for her statement. I agree with my honourable friend that it's a remarkable statement and commend Sir David Bell's review also. I commend my right honourable friend's response from the dispatch box on this side too. In 2004, I was asked with others by the then Prime Minister Tony Blair to carry out a review of antisemitism in the UK. What we discovered then was the appalling rise, even though it hadn't been figured out prior to that, and we made recommendations.
And it seems to be the problem is that each generation seems to have to keep on looking at this and making recommendations, and yet it erupts again. You know, the Green Party's terrible motion that they moved in their conference is part of that problem. Isolate them, blame them, attack them, ban them. And can I suggest that they put into every school where teachers are reluctant to engage and just give them Pastor Niemöller's poem. The lines that are critical here are: then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out, because I was not a Jew.
Speaker 157
Well, as ever the honorable gentleman makes a profound point and he's absolutely right to do so. And I remember his review from 2004 and it was important then and he's right, every generation I think does, we do need to relearn, relearn and keep learning and make sure that the next generation are taught the horrors of antisemitism because as every generation that passes, the Holocaust, the horrors of the Holocaust get further and further in the rearview mirror and that's why we do need to update them. We do need to ensure it remains, Holocaust education remains on the national curriculum, but it is updated for the modern era as well. And his words there are really powerful. I mean, I'm sure like many colleagues in this house, I went on the Auschwitz visit with the Holocaust Education Trust a few years ago with school students from Manchester.
And that is the profound learning that you learn when you go to Auschwitz, that many, many, many good people turned a blind eye to what they knew was happening, which is how the murder of so many Jews on an industrial scale was allowed to take place because many good people turned a blind eye. And we're not going to be that generation of good people, I can reassure him of that.
Preet Gill
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sir David Bell's review lays bare the extent of antisemitism within our education system. The government is funding a partnership between the Archdiocese of Birmingham and the Board of Deputies to help pupils recognize and challenge antisemitism, including conspiracy theories spread through online gaming. Will the Secretary of State commit to publishing its results and explain how successful approaches will reach every school in Birmingham, including in the constituency of Edgbaston?
Speaker 157
Well, can I thank her for what sounds like incredibly important interfaith work and work in Birmingham there. Because she she's absolutely right, the the modern contemporary forms of antisemitism which are now, I'm afraid, rife online, are appearing online, those conspiracy theories that she's talking about that appear in gaming and other social media are therefore in children's bedrooms, in their living room, in their rooms where their screens are. And that's why we do need to make sure that every school in Birmingham, every school across the country is well trained, is well versed and is adopting the recommendations that we're setting out.
Lisa Smart
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really welcome Sir David's review and indeed the Secretary of State's response. Antisemitism is an ancient poison and it's why my nan had to flee Germany to come to this country in the late 1930s and it is, as the Secretary of State said, it's the responsibility of all of us to tackle it. I refer the House to my register of interests, Madam Deputy Speaker, because I'm in my 20th year of being a primary school governor. This review and the recommendations talk about the role of school leadership, but I noted that the Secretary of State didn't mention school governors.
I wonder if she could say how she sees the role of governors in tackling this. And I really welcome her earlier assurance to my honorable friend the member for Twickenham that money will be made available. I wonder if she could confirm if that's new new money or if it's money that's already been allocated to our schools or indeed already allocated to tackling antisemitism.
Speaker 157
Can I thank her and for sharing her family history, which is really important that we do keep sharing those stories as well.
And thank her for being a governor of what I'm sure is an excellent school in Hazel Grove, as there are many excellent schools in Hazel Grove. She raises a good point about governors and I will take that on board and make sure that training and other resources are also available to governors as well. What we're talking about is new funding as well as new resources for training, for suggested classroom resources and so on. So that will be available and hopefully schools will feel fully supported in taking this forward.
John Thomas Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I pay tribute to Sir David Bell for his review into antisemitism in schools and colleges. Unfortunately, Bournemouth has recently seen antisemitic incidents and I want my constituents to know that I stand against that every single time. And we must root out that ancient evil in Bournemouth. I also want to ask the minister about what the government will do to encourage positive engagements with Jewish cultural experiences. The Russell-Cotes Gallery and Museum in Bournemouth is about to open a new exhibition about Jewish Bournemouth called Waves of Change.
She is of course very welcome to come and visit. Equally, another minister from the Department for Education is very welcome to come and see the exhibition. But what more would she like to see happen to encourage positive engagement with Jewish cultural experiences?
Speaker 157
Um, well can I thank him for that and just once again just put on record my thanks to Sir David Bell and his team as well for the way in which they conducted themselves, not just for the outcome of their review. But he's absolutely right, positive engagement, cultural experiences, cultural exchange is absolutely critical to us fostering an environment of acceptance, of tolerance, of respect and of understanding. And it sounds like the exhibition at the Bournemouth Gallery is one such event. And we will be supporting with extra funding as well schools to take part in more of these cultural experiences.
Al Pinkerton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have no Jewish schools in my constituency of Surrey Heath, nor any formally constituted places of Jewish worship, but I do have a proud and active Jewish community. I'm also the father of two children. And as a father of two teenagers, I am deeply concerned about their exposure to deeply problematic misinformation that exists online, including conspiracy theories. And so I wonder whether the Secretary of State can, in pursuance of recommendations 4 and 12b, say a little bit more.
Because these are complex recommendations. They talk about staff being informed about the nature and risks of harmful antisemitic content when we don't really even as a society fully understand the nature and scope of that antisemitic content because it can be explicit, but it also can be insipid and implicit. And in 12b, embedding high-quality teaching in media literacy, recognizing and confronting harmful online content. These are difficult, very challenging things for any teacher to do. And so in supporting those teachers, I wonder whether the Secretary of State might say more about how this set of recommendations dovetails with the broader interest this government has in tackling misinformation online.
Speaker 177
Because I think in truth, we need a whole-of-society approach to tackle this scourge.
Speaker 157
Well, it's an excellent question, really, really is a very good point. And as a mother myself, and he says talks about a father, you know, I too have had to have these conversations at home. And it's important that we do. And it was in part why I wanted to be absolutely explicit in my opening statement about how antisemitism is revealing itself in the modern times, and being absolutely explicit and clear about that, which we all need to do. But he's absolutely right, this is hard.
I mean, this is not easy, and it's not easy for anybody. I have great faith in our teaching workforce. We have some of the best teachers in the world in our schools. But we will be, we will be working with experts to design and working with the teaching profession to design a lot of the resources and the guidance and advice that we need. And we are also, he will be fully aware that in addition to what I'm announcing today, we are on the cusp of our, you know, big curriculum review.
And media and digital literacy and equipping our young people with the ability to discern dis- and misinformation and to ask the right questions and to understand where information is coming from and therefore what it might mean will be absolutely at the heart of that curriculum review.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement and to Sir David Bell for his report. As a former teacher, I welcome the training being provided to teachers so they can absolutely have the skills and the toolkit to challenge this absolute stain on our society. And for once I agree with many of the things said by the Shadow Education Secretary, although anecdotally I would say to her, I was so good at being politically neutral in school that one year 11 girl once accused me of being a Tory. So it is possible.
But she's right when she says that school often acts as a mirror to those things we see in the wider society. And I know it's something that Harlow Jewish community, and I had a conversation with the local rabbi about this the weekend, are very concerned about. So can I ask the Secretary of State to tell me what she's going to do to work with Cabinet colleagues to tackle antisemitism both online as mentioned earlier, but also in our wider society.
Speaker 157
Well, that must have been some politically impartial class, I think, for the honorable gentleman. But can I, look, can I thank him for allowing us to end this session on that note, which is that can I thank every single colleague who's contributed to it. I think it sends a very, very important signal to the country, to our teaching workforce as well, that this is something we stand together on, shoulder to shoulder, resolutely as one, as one Parliament, as one country, as one government. And I just thought it might just be helpful if I just reminded colleagues of one thing that was exposed in Sir David Bell's review, that in a survey of secondary school teachers who teach about the Holocaust, 40% reported encountering antisemitism coming into those classes amongst their students. So this really is an issue that we all have to take forward.
Speaker 184
And can I thank every single colleague here today for their contributions.
Charles David Robertson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to make provision about financial transparency, expenditure approval limits and governance of multi-academy trusts and for connected purposes. When parents up and down the country think about their children's education, their worries and their hopes for school, multi-academy trust governance will probably never be the phrase that's foremost in many of their minds. But families across Lichfield, Burntwood and the villages know that when governance goes wrong, it's pupils and teachers who pay the price, and that's what this bill seeks to address. Before I was elected to Parliament, I taught for almost a decade across the West Midlands before working for NASUWT, one of our teaching unions.
But I really did not expect this bill to be the first that I presented to the House, until that is, at the start of this year, I became aware of just how bad things were at Arthur Terry Learning Partnership. ATLP is a multi-academy trust running 24 schools across the West Midlands, including six in my constituency. It was established in 2011, shortly after the Conservative-led government passed legislation to significantly increase the rate at which council-run schools could be turned into academies. In recent years, the trust grew rapidly, almost doubling in size since 2010. Then things started to go very, very badly wrong.
In 2024, the DfE was forced to give the trust an emergency loan to help it bail out a four million pound deficit. But ATLP insisted it was fixing its finances. Scarcely a year later, its deficit had ballooned to eight million pounds. The trust's leadership blamed an accounting error. The idea that eight million pounds had gone missing because of a mistake was hardly reassuring to me or any of my constituents, and many of us were somewhat skeptical.
In 2022, ATLP had announced it would require 11,000 iPads, one for every pupil across all of their 24 schools. Exactly how had they paid for 11,000 iPads? I put these questions to ATLP's leadership over and over and over again in meetings, alongside my honourable friends the members for Birmingham Erdington, Coventry North West, North Warwickshire and Bedworth, and Tamworth. We never really got a straight answer. And the way that they were displaying their financial data and particularly graphs that they were using really did seem to me to be designed to hide and obfuscate rather than actually explain where the trust's finances were.
And believe me, as a former physics teacher, I am more than comfortable with a graph and it was quite clear that these were not quite right. Last autumn, things got much worse. After taking yet another government loan, the trust needed to cut costs to get its finances on track. Its leadership decided that teachers and support staff would be the people who pay the price. As many as 100 jobs were put at risk of redundancy across the 24 schools.
And that led, and as much as I know that teachers hate going on strike, in that case, ATLP staff at the National Education Union felt they had no choice, and that risk of redundancy led to nine days of strike action in a number of the trust's schools. Now nobody across any part of any part of the constituencies or the communities affected wanted to see iPads prioritized over teachers, teaching assistants and school support staff. Families were right behind the teachers standing up. Closer scrutiny of ATLP's accounts at this time showed that the iPads were a symptom of a deeper problem. Most comparable trusts ask schools to pay about 5% of their budgets into a central pot for centrally procured services, often called the top slice, in some schools a slightly different system known as gag pooling.
But ATLP was asking its schools to fork out eye-watering sums, as much as 25% of their budgets for these services. And at the same time, it was preserving well-paid roles in head office whilst teachers and teaching assistants were at risk of losing their jobs. By February, things had unraveled. After those nine days of strike action, ATLP's chief financial officer and chief executive had both resigned, and an interim leader with experience of helping failing trusts was brought in and swiftly changed tack on teaching cuts and instead slashed the iPad policy and to cut down the head office.
Following that, there were no compulsory redundancies at Arthur Terry Learning Partnership at the end of last year, bringing it down to zero. The scale of Arthur Terry Learning Partnership's failings finally became clear. The trust had spent its reserves on iPads, one of the number of financial missteps that had bankrupted it. In May, after many discussions with me and many of my colleagues, the Department for Education announced the breakup of Arthur Terry Learning Partnership, one of the biggest trust closures that our country has ever seen. Throughout this process, the stress for pupils, parents, teachers and the community across my area has been really serious.
Families have feared for the future of ATLP schools, worried that great teachers would leave during that time of uncertainty and upheaval. And I do want to take some time now to thank the amazing staff and school leaders at Arthur Terry schools. And I am really pleased that now we have a clear plan for those schools to move to other local trusts where they can thrive and get the support that they deserve. But what unfolded at Arthur Terry was absolutely unacceptable and it cannot be allowed to happen at other trusts anywhere else in the country. But unfortunately, that is precisely the risk that we face.
There are not enough financial safeguards in the Academies Act, there are not enough guardrails to stop this happening again. Earlier this year, the Department for Education found serious financial issues at Sand Academies Trust in Gloucester. The trust's explanation blaming accounting errors will be eerily familiar to far too many of my constituents. The boss of Sir Ralph Sherwin Catholic Multi-Academy Trust based just up the road in Derby quit in June, having accrued an even bigger deficit at over nine million pounds.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
On that point, will he give way? A very quick one, yes. I'm pleased to sponsor his bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, and also to let him know that there's been considerable progress at the Ralph...
Charles David Robertson
Apologies, apologies, I should have said no. The examples I've given there are just some examples, there are further examples of problems with other trusts which go beyond finances as well. But indeed, analysis by Schools Week found that most trusts that end up put in financial special measures by the Department for Education end up sliding further into the red. Make no mistake, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a national issue. And that's why I've been campaigning for a change in the law to ensure that there are stronger rules on multi-academy trust governance so that no area has to go through what mine did.
Half of all schools in England are now part of multi-academy trusts like Arthur Terry, yet research by Parentkind, the national charity for parents, shows that fewer than one in five parents feel that their trust listens to them. I think many parents are shocked by the lack of oversight of trusts. I certainly know that many families in my area asked me at public meetings why the local council couldn't step in and take the schools back on, particularly when things had gone so wrong at ATLP. The National Governance Association say that is replicated up and down the country. Parents understandably assume that councils still play a significant role in school oversight when in reality, for academy trust schools, they simply don't.
When the Conservatives aggressively expanded academization, they said it would drive up standards. But what they failed to recognize is that when school leadership fails, people suffer and they failed to put in the adequate safeguards that we need. It is shocking that it took until this Labour government in 2024, more than 15 years after the Academies Act, for the inspections of trusts to be introduced. Almost a decade and a half, the Conservatives presided over a system where Ofsted had no powers to inspect the trusts that ran the schools, and we've seen in my area the problems that that failure of oversight has led to. But now we must go further.
Since the breakup of ATLP was announced, I've been consulting experts across the education sector, including teachers' unions, the NEU, NASUWT and Community, unions representing school support staff, including Unite and GMB, the Association of School and College Leaders, the National Association of Head Teachers, Local Government Association, National Governance Association, the Confederation of School Trusts itself, and indeed Parentkind. I and my honourable friends have written to multi-academy trusts to seek their views, and crucially I've been working with parents, carers and teachers across my constituency who have firsthand experience and running a survey and holding a town hall meeting earlier this month.
I would really like to thank everybody who's given their time to this. Together we've crafted a bill that makes practical proposals that would put proper safeguards in place. It would start with a financial transparency section. Parents need to know if trusts are skimming off sums that could be spent in classrooms or if their reserves are running low, and they shouldn't have to pore through accounts like a forensic accountant to be able to find out. This bill would mandate that trusts publish details of the money they're taking from schools' budgets, and if they pool and redistribute that, how they are doing so.
They would need to include how they plan to spend reserves on their website and the website of every school that they run. They would also have to publish details of the reserves they hold in the same place. If trusts cannot explain those decisions to parents, it is a warning sign. But we also need stronger oversight too. Our experience with iPads has shown how one big mistake can cost pupils.
The bill would make purchases like that additional to additional sign-off. If trusts can't justify the cost on an education basis, it shouldn't be able to happen. We need better scrutiny at board level. Governors should have better skills to ask those questions, and this bill would compel the Secretary of State to draft statutory guidance to make local governing boards mandatory for trusts and set out the competency that trust boards should have, with specific guidance for the chairs of finance committees. There is more, but I am aware of time, so I will close by saying that this bill has been a community effort, and it exists to help ensure that no other community goes through what families of the Terry Learning Partnership schools did.
Its provisions would build on the government's work in strengthening MAT accountability. We know the problems, now we can see the solutions, and we need to grasp them. Thank you.
Speaker 92
The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?
Charles David Robertson
Sarah Edwards, Paulette Hamilton, Rachel Taylor, Taiwo Owatemi, Jacob Collier, Jonathan Davies, Josh Fenton-Glynn, Lee Ingham, John Pearce, Mark Sewards, and myself, Madam Deputy Speaker.
15th of January.
Speaker 92
15th of January. We now come to the allocation of time motion. I'll just give a few moments. We now come to the allocation of time motion. Minister to move.
Speaker 92
The question is as on the order paper. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Speaker 190
Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provision) Bill, second reading.
Point of order, Sir Edward Leigh.
Edward Leigh
I want to raise a point of order on the possible hybridity of this bill.
A hybrid bill is when a government bill, a public bill is used to only affect one person. And as we see in paragraph 13, the Prime Minister professes the Roman Catholic faith, he is therefore prevented from fulfilling his constitutional role exactly. So the bill is specifically referring to one person. Now I know that in answer you might say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that this will also benefit Catholics and Jews in the future. But we have to deal with the situation as we find it now, we cannot deal with hypothetical issues.
It's rather as if you had a bill to address a condition that has only affected one person in the last 500 years. And of course we haven't had a Catholic Prime Minister for 500 years, and if there wasn't a Prime Minister who was Catholic 500 years, there wasn't even a Prime Minister 500 years ago. So it is vanishingly small that in the immediate future this bill will be activated. So I'm not, of course, I never try to cause trouble, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm not asking for an answer now, but I think it is a moot point that you might ask your clerks to investigate.
Speaker 92
I thank the right honourable gentleman for his point of order, and he can have his answer now. The bill removes a disqualification from two categories of persons as set out in clause 1. The numbers of people who currently fall into those categories for the purposes of the bill is not relevant to the test of hybridity. I'm sure the Clerk of Legislation will be happy to discuss the matter further with the right honourable gentleman. Minister to move second reading, Hamish Faulkner.
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
I beg to move that the bill be now read a second time. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a pleasure to open today's debate on this straightforward yet important piece of legislation, which I hope will command broad support across the House. The purpose of this bill is to remove historic legal barriers that prevent a Prime Minister who professes either the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths from advising the sovereign on church appointments or ministers from making appointments in their own right. For the benefit of the House, it may be helpful to briefly set out the constitutional and historic context. Since the formal establishment of the Church of England in the 16th century, archbishops and bishops have been appointed by the sovereign as supreme governor.
Over time they came to do so on the advice of ministers, and now the Prime Minister, as the sovereign's principal adviser, provides advice in relation to these and other church appointments the sovereign makes. In practice, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister does not choose between candidates, but rather provides formal advice on candidates following a selection process. Separately, certain ministers, for example the Lord Chancellor, have by virtue of their office rights to act as a patron in parish-level church appointments directly, without the involvement of the sovereign, but again following a selection process. Madam Deputy Speaker, to understand why these restrictions remain on our statute book today, it is helpful to look briefly at the 19th century when Parliament passed the Roman Catholic Relief Act and the Jews Relief Act. After the Reformation, many people believed that religious unity under the Church of England and Church of Scotland was essential to maintain the peace.
Gradual progress was then made to remove restrictions on worship outside of the established churches and expand the role of non-Anglicans in political life.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honourable member for giving way. It was the great Daniel O'Connell, elected Member of Parliament for County Clare in Ireland in 1828, but unable to take up his seat because of the oath of supremacy, who famously achieved Catholic emancipation through that 1829 Catholic Relief Act he mentions.
O'Connell was known as the Liberator, and Gladstone called him the greatest popular leader whom the world has ever seen. And yet still to this day, there is no statue or portrait to him in this House. But does the Minister agree that today, 197 years later, the legacy of Daniel O'Connell, the Liberator, will finally be complete with full equality in elected office for both Catholics and for Jews?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
My honourable friend makes a powerful intervention and she's right that the effect of this bill will be to remove the last remaining discriminations against Catholics and Jews on the statute book. And it's a historic moment and I'm very glad. I will.
Edward Leigh
Surely it's going to remain the statute book that a member of the Royal Family can't marry a Roman Catholic and inherit the Crown?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
I want to... my honourable friend was making a point about the active role of Roman Catholics in public life, including in this place. I suspect the Father of the House and I are not going to agree totally on the passage of this bill, but as neighbours I want to say he does, as a professing Catholic, play a very active role both here and elsewhere. This Act would be to take all force away from the Catholic Relief Act of 1829. It will mean that none of its provisions have any force. That is slightly different from the question of how the monarch... the line of succession of the... of the monarch, but for the purposes of this House and normal political activity in this country, it will remove all restrictions.
I will.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Minister agree... would the Minister agree that this bill today is about removing discrimination in elected office and not about inherited office?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
The honourable... my honourable friend is pithier than I am. Yes, this is about elected office. I will make a little progress if honourable members won't mind. Let me take you back to the Reformation. As my friend has said... as my honourable friend has said, until the mid-19th century, there were considerably more restrictions on Catholics and Jews, including an effective prohibition on becoming members of Parliament.
The Roman Catholic Relief Act of 1829, the Jews Relief Act of 1858 removed many, but not all, of these legal barriers to Roman Catholic and Jewish participation in public life. This included permitting people of these faiths to become MPs and to serve in various civil and military offices. But the legislation retained certain exceptions which this bill seeks to address. Under section 18 of the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829 and section 4 of the Jews Relief Act 1858, individuals professing the Catholic or Jewish faiths are restricted from giving advice to the sovereign in relation to church appointments. The penalty for breaching these restrictions is being prevented from holding a civil or military office under the Crown, which includes serving as Prime Minister.
Until now, there has never been a Prime Minister professing either the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths while in office. Following the appointment of my right honourable friend, the member for Wakefield, as Prime Minister in July, these 19th-century legal restrictions are now having a practical effect for the first time.
To ensure that church appointments can continue smoothly, the Prime Minister has temporarily transferred his responsibilities for advising the sovereign on church appointments to the Lord Chancellor. But it would not be right to continue these arrangements indefinitely. I'm sure the whole House will agree with me that in the 21st century, one's faith should not be a barrier to carrying out any of the duties of high office. Removing these restrictions from the statute book is the right thing to do. Moreover, it is important to uphold one of our core constitutional principles, that the Prime Minister is the sovereign's principal advisor and should be able to advise on church appointments just like his predecessors.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill resolves a live practical issue and removes an outdated restriction that has no place in our modern parliamentary democracy. With honorable members' support, I hope it will not detain the House for long. I understand some members might raise questions about why non-Anglican Prime Ministers or ministers should be able to advise the sovereign on appointments to a church whose faith or denomination they do not share. However, the government firmly rejects this view. The legal restrictions we are seeking to repeal only apply to individuals professing the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths.
They do not apply to people of other faiths, other Christian denominations, or of no faith at all. That is why former Prime Ministers Rishi Sunak, a professed Hindu, and Sir Keir Starmer, a professed atheist, as well as many other non-Anglican Prime Ministers in the 20th century, were able to advise the sovereign on church appointments without risking disbarment from office. While the Church of England is the established church in this country, one of the great strengths of our country is that it is made up of people of different faiths and backgrounds and who should all enjoy equal treatment under our laws. To suggest that a minister must personally share the faith of the established church in order to convey its advice would be to misunderstand the constitutional role of the crown's principal advisor. As a modern parliamentary democracy and constitutional monarchy, the King is the head of state and acts on advice of his ministers who are accountable to the electorate and to this place.
Therefore, it is right that the Prime Minister, regardless of his religious beliefs, is able to advise the King on church appointments. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll now summarize this two-clause bill. I will.
Danny Kruger.
Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger
I'm very grateful, and of course I absolutely support the principle of this bill and won't obviously oppose it. Can I just ask the minister to unpack the point he just made about the role of the Prime Minister being to convey the advice of the church when it comes to appointments? Because that is exactly how it works at the moment, whereas as he says, the Prime Minister is the principal advisor to the sovereign, and ultimately it's the sovereign who has authority to make episcopal appointments. Does he agree that the Prime Minister has himself a function to play in the advice that is given to the sovereign, or does he think it's purely a sort of procedural matter in which he simply transmitting advice that he receives from the church hierarchy itself?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Madam Deputy Speaker, the point I was seeking to just cover is that it's an important constitutional principle that the Prime Minister is the principal advisor to the sovereign. Clearly, as a matter of practice, and that includes in his role as the head of the established church, clearly in practice, the Prime Minister, as I think it's well known to this House, does not take an active role in selecting members of the clergy. But that does not mean that it is wise to continue with this discrimination, particularly against Catholics and against Jews.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the two-clause Bill includes clause 1, which makes provision to repeal sections 17 and 18 of the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829, and it repeals the Jews Relief Act of 1858 in its entirety, lifting all statutory restrictions on Ministers advising on or making church appointments. Crucially, the Bill treats and removes restrictions on Roman Catholic and Jewish individuals in exactly the same way, ensuring complete parity and equal treatment between both faiths. It also removes outdated restrictions on making church appointments referring to rights of patronage, such as those held by the Lord Chancellor to directly nominate vicars to parish benefices. While these provisions have been partially repealed and are generally no longer of any practical effect, completely repealing them removes any lingering legal uncertainty. Clause 2 sets out the UK-wide territorial extent and provides for commencement immediately upon Royal Assent.
Finally, honourable members may recall we passed a similar piece of legislation, the Church of Scotland Lord High Commissioner Act, last year. The Government's approach is both principled and pragmatic. We address archaic, centuries-old statutory restrictions like these as and when they have a live practical impact on public life. Last year, we acted to facilitate the historic appointment of Lady Angiolini, a practising Catholic, to the office of Lord High Commissioner to the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland. Now we are bringing forward this legislation because these 19th-century provisions are impacting ministerial advice for the first time.
No doubt questions may be raised, Madam Deputy Speaker, about whether we will need a third Bill to address further historic religious restrictions. Let me reassure honourable members that with the passage of this Bill, the job is complete. I can assure the House that following this legislation, there are no remaining religious restrictions affecting Ministers and other individuals appointed by the Crown, and we are confident that no further action of this kind will ever be required. And there we are, Madam Deputy Speaker, a short, simple and straightforward Bill. While it will take up only a few lines of our statute book, this legislation corrects an archaic historical wrong.
It ensures that our constitutional arrangements reflect a modern, equal society where no Prime Minister, regardless of his religious beliefs, is restricted from being able to advise the Sovereign. I hope this Bill will receive support from all sides, and in that spirit, I commend it to the House.
Speaker 199
Order, order. I will now announce the result of today's deferred divisions. On the draft Railways (Interoperability) (Northern Ireland) (Convention on International Carriage by Rail) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, the Ayes were 345, the Noes were 108, so the Ayes have it. On the draft Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices during the Recognition and Derecognition Process, the Ayes were 295, the Noes were 111, so the Ayes have it. And on the Withdrawal Agreement, Windsor Framework and Governance (Amendment) Regulations 2026, the Ayes were 345, the Noes were 108, so the Ayes have it.
Speaker 197
Before I call the Shadow Minister, just a note to the Minister, I'm sure he meant to refer to the right honourable member for Richmond and Northallerton.
Shadow Minister, Mike Wood.
Mike Wood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And let me be clear from the outset that His Majesty's Official Opposition welcomes the Government's recognition that this anomaly needs correcting and we will not be opposing the Bill today. We fully support the principle that no Prime Minister should be legally prevented from discharging all of their constitutional duties on account of their faith. The restrictions contained within the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829 and the Jews Relief Act 1858 are, as the Minister said, plainly outdated and have no place in a modern democratic society. The idea that someone should be prevented from exercising the full responsibilities of the office of Prime Minister simply because of their religious belief is clearly not fit for the 21st century.
Indeed, it is remarkable that almost two centuries after those Acts were passed, provisions remain on our statute book that distinguish between those who are permitted to advise the Sovereign on church appointments and those who are not, purely on the grounds of their faith. But when one looks at the specific provisions that this Bill repeals, both their severity and their inconsistency are striking. The law as it stands prevents persons of the Roman Catholic and Jewish faiths from being involved either directly or indirectly in advising the Crown on appointments in the Church of England or the Church of Scotland. Moreover, the punishments written into those laws are severe. Under the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829, a Catholic advising the Sovereign on a church appointment is deemed guilty of a high misdemeanor and disabled forever from holding any office, civil or military, under the Crown.
The Jews Relief Act 1858 contains a similar threat. And because the existing laws only discriminate against Jewish people and Roman Catholics, they have created the glaring inconsistency that the Minister referred to, that my right honourable friend the former Prime Minister, the Member for Richmond and Northallerton, as a practicing Hindu, and his successor, Keir Starmer, an atheist, were not legally prevented from advising on Church of England appointments, as the current Prime Minister, who is a Catholic, has been. And at a time when we rightly celebrate religious freedom, tolerance, and equality before the law, it cannot be right that the holder of the highest political office in our country should face a legislative bar based upon whether they are Roman Catholic or Jewish. However, Madam Deputy Speaker, while we agree with the Prime Minister that these laws are an archaic anomaly, in my capacity as Shadow Minister, I cannot let the occasion pass without a gentle reminder that the Government's rather sudden conversion to treating this Bill as an urgent priority. On the 5th of March last year, the Lord Privy Seal wrote to members of the other House stating that the Government was considering how to address historic restrictions on Roman Catholics and Jews advising the Crown on appointments in the Anglican Church.
But when asked about progress in parliamentary questions last autumn, the then Minister for the Cabinet Office said that while the Government will keep the matter under review, given other pressing issues, it was not a current priority. It is hard to notice that removing this statutory bar remained not a current priority for the Cabinet Office right up until a Roman Catholic Prime Minister took office. And as my right honourable friend the Member for Gainsborough observed last week, there will be some people looking at the challenges facing the country today who may well feel that there may be more important things for the Government to do, although when he rose to make his point of order at the start of this debate, I did wonder whether he was perhaps going to declare an interest with perhaps ambitions for Number 10 that might be affected by this legislation. Nonetheless, the Bill is rightly before us today, and as with any constitutional change, it is important that the Government proceed with clarity and with care.
And in scrutinizing this legislation constructively, I'd be grateful if the minister could clarify three points for the house. Firstly, can the minister confirm that the effect of the bill is narrowly focused strictly on removing these discriminatory restrictions without unintended knock-on effects elsewhere in statute. Secondly, after becoming Prime Minister, the right honorable member for Macclesfield transferred responsibility for church appointments to the Lord Chancellor to ensure that appointments could continue. Can the minister confirm that this arrangement is temporary and will remain in place only until this legislation has received Royal Assent and has come into force. And thirdly, can the minister reassure the house that this legislation will not alter the wider constitutional relationship between the Crown, the government, and the established church.
Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, while we support removing this statutory bar, we also believe it is important to maintain sensible constitutional practice. And so it is the opposition's clear recommendation that it would be sensible for Prime Ministers who do not consider themselves to be part of the congregation of the Church of England to delegate the active decision-making process on appointments to others, as recent Prime Ministers have done, while retaining their formal constitutional role in advising the monarch. On that basis, His Majesty's official opposition looks forward to scrutinizing the bill in the committee stage ahead and its later stages, but will be supporting it at second reading.
Speaker 202
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to put on record first of all my strong support for this bill, which as we have heard, removes existing discriminatory provisions preventing people specifically of the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths from being able to advise the monarch on certain crown appointments. The bill is based on the rightful principle that everyone in society, regardless of what faith they follow, or whether they follow a faith at all, should be treated equally in public life. It is unconscionable that anyone, be they the Prime Minister or otherwise, who is of a certain religion should face legislation which gives them inferior treatment, or on the flip side, preferential treatment to those of different faiths, or indeed those of no faith at all. Once we've accepted this principle, however, it's clear in my view that there are other areas where work needs to be done to remove differences in treatment in our society based on religion, and I would welcome a broader bill from the government on these topics.
Speaker 201
Between 2011 and 2021, census data shows that we are now an exceptionally religiously diverse country, largely due to the rise in those who report having no religion, up 8.5 million to 22.5 million overall, over a third of the population of England and Wales. I am a secularist, and while I'm not religious, many religious people are secularists too. I believe that politicians with a faith should be free to speak from the perspective that faith gives them, but no faith should be privileged. This bill firmly aligns with that secularist principle. And so in my view, the logic of the bill forces us to ask some other questions about religion in public life.
Speaker 203
Why, for example, do we have guaranteed seats for clergy of a certain faith in the House of Lords.
...earned a seat in Parliament. And I would ask the House how that can be seen any differently to the discriminatory provisions in the bill before us, which the bill before us rightfully seeks to repeal. It's also not unlike certain other aspects, such as collective worship in state-funded schools, where children may be forced into religious ceremonies, such as class prayers or singing Christian hymns in the morning, regardless of their faith. That's a matter of law at present. Another position I would arise, I would argue arises naturally in discussion after accepting the principles of the bill before us today, challenging religious discrimination in the public sphere.
So I wanted to make a couple of very brief points on that subject, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I just want to make clear that secularist principles are not opposed to religion in any way. I believe, as I'm sure we all do, in the religious freedom to have whatever faith, or lack thereof, that one might choose. Freedom of religion, but also freedom from religion. But for that principle to be fully realized, we need a level playing field. This bill is based on an idea, and I would welcome further discussion of what logically follows from that in public life as a whole.
Lisa Smart
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Liberal Democrats have long advocated for modernization and improvement across the Houses of Parliament, and we continue to support legislation that modernizes and hope to see many more moves towards ensuring Westminster is representative of the country as a whole. For almost 200 years, the law has said that a Roman Catholic minister, or later, a Jewish minister, may not advise the monarch on appointments in the Church of England or the Church of Scotland. Those restrictions never applied to people of other faiths or no faith at all. They were aimed squarely at two communities, and they are rooted in the anti-Catholicism and anti-Semitism of the age in which they were written.
The Prime Minister has called this an antiquated and archaic anomaly, and of course he is right to do so. It cannot be acceptable in 2026 that someone who holds the confidence of this House should be barred from part of their job because of their faith. Now we're told that Church House is content with the change, and the National Secular Society has said that the ban is increasingly difficult to justify in a modern liberal democracy. It is rare to find that much agreement on a question involving church and state, and the government is right to make this change in the law. Liberal Democrats believe in freedom of belief.
Everyone should be able to practice their faith, or none, without fear of discrimination or state interference. That principle should apply at the very top of public life as much as anywhere else. Removing this bar sends a message that the highest offices in our country are open to people of every background. But I would note that this is the very first bill brought under this Prime Minister. Now it's a sensible fix to a problem he faces personally, but there are more widespread problems with how our democracy works, problems that affect every one of our constituents, and they are still waiting for action.
Speaker 205
Take the other place. Liberal Democrats have long called for a House of Lords with a democratic mandate.
Speaker 199
Order. I would urge the honorable lady to stay within the scope of this bill. The previous speaker might have escaped me leaping to my feet by very carefully tying his comments to the provisions of this bill. I trust she'll do likewise.
Lisa Smart
And I'm always grateful to the, to Madam Deputy Speaker for her guidance on what remains in and out of scope, and I'm always encouraged when we're able to talk about the modernization as this bill does, and I encourage the government to go further and faster, as Liberal Democrats always do when they're on their feet and we're talking about political and constitutional reform. In keeping in the scope of Prime Ministerial advice and appointments, Madam Deputy Speaker, which I hope you'll agree is very much in scope of this bill, they often ingrained patronage and reinforce elitism that cause many people to lose faith in politics. And so things like the Burns Report historically, looking at cutting the House of Lords to 600 peers, would be something we'd encourage the government to get to.
We think the government could do far more, but that's for another debate probably on another day. Because none of the things that we Liberal Democrats would encourage, whether it's the ministerial code in law or a fairer voting system, are terribly complicated. All they do is restore trust in politics. We support this bill. Discrimination on grounds of faith has no place in our law, and I'm glad to see the change coming today.
But I hope the minister will treat this as very much a starting point rather than the limit of his ambitions for political and constitutional reform. Because if the government is serious about modernising our institutions, they should be going further and faster, and the Lib Dems will keep pressing them to do exactly that.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. As an Anglican myself, there's a little bit of me that would always like to see an Anglican as Prime Minister, but I recognise that that is not always desirable or possible. In fact, despite the historical measures that we've discussed today about Catholic emancipation, of course Roman Catholicism never did go away. They practiced their faith in private, often with fear of their lives. And the secret of the success of the Church of England is that it is the original broad church.
Even within the Anglican communion, there are people who hold a whole variety of views. And allowing our Prime Minister as a Roman Catholic to provide his constitutional function of advising the monarchy is very much in keeping within that tradition. A week last Sunday, Madam Deputy Speaker, I attended the High Sheriff's legal service at Derby Cathedral. It was for Dr. Syed Yusuf Iftikhar, an NHS consultant who came from Pakistan but has served over 40 years in the NHS. And it was a service which brought together people of all sorts of different faith communities, led by the Dean of Derby, the Very Reverend Peter Robinson.
But we had representatives from the Muslim faith, from the Sikhs, and from the Hindus. And that is the Church of England at its best, particularly at a time when we see in our society divisions. We talked about antisemitism in Parliament today, but we've seen recently, unfortunately, racist aspects of our political parties here. And the Church of England has an excellent role to play in bringing these communities together, and many of us will see that on Remembrance Sunday next month. So I do, yes, I will give way.
Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger
I'm very grateful, he's making an important speech. Does he agree with me that the value of this bill actually is that it could strengthen the Church of England and reconnect it with the political community that it is properly part of? And as I've intervened on the minister, does he agree with me it's not right just to leave the appointment of bishops purely to the bureaucrats at Church House and to committees there? It is a proper subject for politics. And the suggestion that this is a sort of a second-order priority, well, I recognise that, there are more pressing concerns for the country, but, you know, Gladstone thought this was the most important part of his job as Prime Minister was appointing bishops.
This stuff matters. And does he agree with me that my concern about the debate so far is that it's being interpreted as some great step of sort of progressive modernisation, which clearly ends with the exclusion of Christianity from the political life altogether? And actually what we need to see is to strengthen the role of the Church of England in the political community and remind the Prime Minister of this very important part of his or her job.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Yes, I do agree with the honourable gentleman from East Wiltshire. The Church of England is strengthened by bringing in more voices. It often does that already through the use of ecumenical canons in some cathedrals. And I think this is a step forward which will ensure that the Church of England brings in those perspectives which will strengthen its hand in the future and bring our communities together in the way in which it does so well. So I thank the minister for bringing this legislation to the House today.
I think it is an important step forward, and I do wish the Prime Minister well, from an Anglican to a Catholic, as he takes forward this important constitutional role advising the monarch on the future leaders of the Church of England. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Edward Leigh
Madam Deputy Speaker, before I begin my speech, I better declare an interest because I know it's not widely known that I am a Roman Catholic. I don't oppose this bill. Of course, the discrimination that we suffered for centuries was absolutely horrible, and it wasn't discrimination as we understand it in the modern world.
My direct ancestor, the blessed Richard Leigh, was hung, drawn and quartered simply for denying that Elizabeth I should be the head of the church in England. So, I mean, obviously I welcome anything that ends discrimination. But I hope the minister will forgive me if I just sort of make a few points to really find out, try and find out why we're moving this bill now. We're obviously moving it because we have a Catholic Prime Minister, but as the opposition spokesman said, there's been very little enthusiasm for doing so up to now. And actually, I think if we're going to move, have a bill, particularly when there are many other pressing matters, it should actually achieve something.
And of course this bill will change absolutely nothing, because since Gordon Brown was Prime Minister, although in theory one name is pushed across his desk, Gordon Brown effectively ended the veto. The last time the veto was exercised was by Tony Blair shortly after the 1997 election, when he objected to two candidates to be Bishop of Liverpool. John Major did exercise his power, I think on one occasion. Mrs. Thatcher, as you might expect, viewed this process with immense enthusiasm and exercised her power rather more regularly. So if we're going to have a bill, it's got to achieve something.
And frankly, this power of the Prime Minister has fallen into abeyance. Now, of course, this didn't occur in the past. In the 19th century, Prime Ministers, as we've already heard, viewed this part of their job with great importance. And we've heard about Gladstone. And it was worse than that.
It wasn't that they were simply trying to appoint the best people to the job. They viewed their role as entirely political. Now, those of us who love Trollope will know the novel Barchester Towers, and the central part of that plot is that the government changes and promptly the candidate, I forget now whether he was a Whig or a Tory, was promptly prevented from taking up a bishopric. And Viscount Palmerston actually packed the bishops' bench with low church evangelicals. And what successive Prime Ministers did, given that there were 26 bishops in the House of Lords and therefore they had important political power, is that they deliberately packed the episcopal bench with their appointments.
And this caused some upset. Again, to heed the lessons of 19th century history, a fascinating subject, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger
I'm sorry to jump up again, but I just want to challenge the right honorable gentleman. That is no doubt the case from the 19th century, but if you read Mark Vickers' brilliant book called God at Number 10, which is the history of Prime Ministers from Balfour to Blair, 20th century Prime Ministers, it's the opposite story. It's a remarkable account of how very different Prime Ministers all took their responsibility seriously, as he said, right up to John Major, and they honored the fact that different dioceses had different traditions. They would try to ensure ecumenical balance within the Church of England. I don't think it's beyond the Prime Minister of any party to take their job seriously, to think about the right balance for the Church of England, to maintain the broad church.
What we don't want is bureaucrats in the Church of England appointing each other, which is what we have at the moment, and that's why they're all left-wing. So surely the right honorable gentleman would acknowledge that what we need is a genuine broad church, which includes some people of different political traditions.
Edward Leigh
Well, that's a very interesting point of view from our Reform colleague. And I've got... I mean, it is an interesting point that, you know, the right honourable gentleman or the honourable member for Clacton at some future date might appoint bishops. But we'll see what happens. It may or may not happen.
So I was talking about the 19th century, the Oxford movement... All right, yes.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
We'll be appointing Anglican bishops and not bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church if the honourable member for Clacton becomes the Prime Minister, I do hope.
Edward Leigh
Sir Edward Leigh. My wife is a member of the Russian Orthodox Church, so I love her. So the Oxford movement of the 1830s in part, it was established precisely because faithful Anglicans grew disturbed at a secularised, reformed Parliament, which now included non-Anglicans, of course, held absolute power over the doctrine and leadership of the Church of England. And indeed, the House of Commons historically enormous interest. There were these huge debates in the 1920s over the nature of the prayer book.
These benches were packed with people who were interested. What a pity that these sort of wonderful debates don't attract a similar amount of attention. And then Cardinal Newman, central to the Oxford movement during his time as an Anglican earlier in life, feared the state would reduce the church to nothing more than a department of government in his many reflections on the relationship between church and state. So that was...
Jim Shannon
Jim Shannon. 200 years on from where we are now and the legislation is coming forward for the Church Appointments Act. Today's society must reflect the changes of the society we live in, must reflect the cultures, the religious makeup, the fact that the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland has changed greatly. And with that being the case of what we're trying to achieve and what the House is trying to achieve through the Church of Appointments today, society must reflect that. So the changes as has been put forward, I think are ones to be welcomed.
Edward Leigh
Well, obviously we have to reflect changes in society. So I made the point first of all that it's not going to make any practical difference. So I wonder why it's really necessary. Now my other point is that I think it would be extremely unwise and it would dig up all these past controversies if any Catholic Prime Minister was to appoint an Anglican bishop. Now I hear what my honourable friend for East Wiltshire says, but I just don't think it makes sense, frankly, for somebody who is an atheist like Keir Starmer or a Hindu or a Catholic should appoint an Anglican bishop.
I just can't see the logic in it. And therefore, frankly, the practice has been discontinued. It won't happen again. I give way again.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
I think the important thing for the Father of the House to perhaps remember is the Anglican Church is not like the Roman Catholic Church. We wouldn't be sending a Protestant representative to the conclave to pick a Pope. But this is the state church of this country and it's answerable to Parliament and therefore the Prime Minister as the most senior member of this government has a role to play in advising the monarch. And obviously at the moment we've got a situation where a Hindu in the right honourable member for Richmond and Northallerton could advise the monarch, but a Roman Catholic could not. So that's why we need to move this legislation forward.
Edward Leigh
By the way, I just want to make the point that I love the Anglican Church. I love the fact that we have an established church. I think it's wonderful in our country that we proclaim the value of religion, the bishops sit in the House of Lords, although I have to say most of them seem to spout rather woke rubbish most of the time.
Speaker 208
Order. I admire the right honourable member enormously, but I might have to give him the same warning about staying in scope this afternoon. Sir Edward Leigh.
Speaker 209
The poor Anglican bishops only have two good days in their whole career, the consecration day and their retirement day is the old joke. But he mentioned the two, one of the great converts to the Church of Rome in Cardinal Newman in the 19th century, which he is talking about. And also we had Cardinal Manning of the 19th century, whereas the 20th century produced Widdecombe and Gormley. I was wondering what his opinion on that was. But what I do want to say to the House, Madam Deputy Speaker, is I think the whole House should join me in congratulating the Father of the House on becoming a Knight of the Pontifical Equestrian Order of Saint Gregory the Great, effectively becoming a papal knight, which is rarely bestowed on us.
I think we're all very proud of him for that. And just to say that as we gallop to 200 years towards emancipation from 1829, not one piece of artwork in this House to Daniel O'Connell and that campaign. So we should rectify that in the next three years, do you not agree?
Edward Leigh
I'm very grateful for that from my good friend. Actually, I see my good friend on my fridge every night because we were introduced to Benedict XVI and there we're in the robes. So every time I open my fridge, I see the honorable gentleman and he's an ornament of this House. So I'm coming to the end of my speech. I just want to make one final point.
I want to make one final point. I've made the point that whether it is actually wise whether a Catholic or Jew or Hindu appoints an Anglican bishop or has any sort of say. But I think there is a wider debate about whether actually, although we believe in the established church, whether although the Prime Minister in effect is not involved, whether there's any reason why the Prime Minister should be involved. And any other organization, I'm afraid I have to tell the member for East Wiltshire, I agree that people rise through committees and it's all quite dull and they're safe options. But frankly, the intrusion or the lack of intrusion of the Prime Minister makes no difference to this.
And I think if we were going to actually have an entirely logical bill, surely we would remove this power of the Prime Minister altogether, although it's never exercised, so the bill is actually not going to achieve anything, and we would actually pass it to the Archbishop of Canterbury, for instance, as a final arbiter. Now, the honorable gentleman for East Wiltshire won't agree with me, but this would be entirely logical. I just don't see the logic in having a politician appoint the head of a church nowadays, not that they ever do it. So I apologize for my comments, but I hope that they give a different perspective to this bill. Thank you.
Martin Vickers.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a pleasure to follow the Father of the House, but I fear I might not be able to provide such an entertaining and historical perspective. I had intended to speak in this debate as I thought I might be the only Anglican to do so, but the member for Mid Derbyshire has beaten me to that. As a member of the established church, I, unlike my right honorable friend, I actually think, I agree for once with the reform, that I would actually like some political input into appointments to the bishops' bench and to one or two other church appointments. I'd like to think that whoever we elect to be Prime Minister, that he or she would take a very serious view of making appointments to an organization, an institution that not only has a vast historical perspective, but also plays a major part in, for example, education.
The Church of England has, I can't remember the number, but many schools up and down the country in virtually every constituency. And the bishops can often play a major part in that. I can see the Deputy Speaker asking me to move on and stay more in scope. To take the argument about appointments of bishops, I actually think that we should return to the system like the member for East Wiltshire, that we should, the Prime Minister should be offered a choice and that there should be, taken into consideration the points that I've made, some contribution towards that. I know that my right honourable friend, the Father of the House, loves the established church.
Indeed, when I was his constituency agent, I used to build in visits to choral evensong in Lincoln as often as I could. But coming back to the substance of the bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, I fully support the fact that the Prime Minister of whatever faith should have an input into the senior appointments in the Church of England.
Ben Spencer
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, look, I have to say from the start, this has been one of the most interesting, wide-ranging, perhaps unexpected debates I've had the pleasure to listen to in this House, with fascinating contributions from the member for North West Cambridgeshire, Mid Derbyshire, the Father of the House from Gainsborough and Brigg and Immingham. And I thank everyone for their contributions this afternoon. As we conclude proceedings on the second reading of this bill, I'm pleased to reaffirm our support from these benches for the changes before us. The provisions being repealed go against our principles of religious freedom, tolerance and equality before the law, to single out Roman Catholics and Jews and prevent them from carrying out responsibilities of public office solely because of their faith.
That is not a distinction which has any place in modern Britain. As a Roman Catholic myself, I find it extraordinary that such a restriction has remained on the statute book for so long. But this is not ultimately about any one faith. It's about the fundamental principle that a person's religious beliefs should not prevent them from discharging the responsibilities of public office. As an opposition, we are also clear that constitutional change, however sensible, should be approached carefully.
And we therefore welcome the narrow scope of the legislation and look forward to the confirmation from the Minister regarding the preservation of the wider constitutional relationship between the Crown, government and the established church. We believe there remains a sensible distinction between the Prime Minister attaining their formal constitutional responsibility for advising the sovereign and where appropriate delegating active involvement in the appointments process. That respects both equality before the law and the particular constitutional position of the established church. Madam Deputy Speaker, we can respect the traditions and institutions which have shaped our country while ensuring they are updated to ensure discriminatory or outdated practices are removed. Two hundred years ago, I would not have been permitted to enter this chamber or speak from this despatch box.
Progress towards equality has been made throughout history, and I welcome this latest step today. On behalf of His Majesty's Loyal Opposition, I'm therefore pleased to support this bill.
Andrew Mark Ferguson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a pleasure to close what has been a genuinely fascinating debate. I give my thanks to honorable and right honorable members from all sides of the house for their thoughtful contributions, in addition to their support for this worthwhile and historic piece of legislation. As we heard earlier from my right honorable friend, the Minister of State, this important bill will facilitate the removal of an outdated 19th century restriction. And we've spent a lot of time today talking about history, and who doesn't enjoy a little conversation about history?
I certainly do, and I know the Minister of State would agree. It's very enjoyable to be involved in preparing yourself for a debate where someone uses a phrase like "not since the Reformation". It really does remind you of the scale and scope of what we do in this place. But really, we're here today to talk about where we are in 2024. This bill ensures that any Prime Minister, regardless of their religious beliefs, is able to advise the sovereign on church appointments.
We have heard in this debate a number of views and contributions from honorable members across the house. I welcome support from across the house, including from the official opposition and the Liberal Democrats, for this bill. It is important, as has been said, that religious freedom and tolerance of faith before the law is a crucial principle that we must uphold. With regard to why we are bringing forward this legislation at this time when there are undoubtedly more important issues, I would simply say two things. One, the government is handling this in a pragmatic way, tackling minor constitutional issues as and when they arise.
This is an obvious problem with an obvious solution. It is pragmatic, it is quick, and it won't detain the house long, despite the enjoyable history lesson that we've had today. Secondly, I'm a strong believer that we can walk and chew gum at the same time, and our ambition is a matter of public record. It is to rewire the state, it is to deliver the largest reindustrialization of our nations and regions in at least a generation, and the biggest redistribution of power our country has ever seen. With regard to the specific issues raised by the official opposition, this is a narrowly focused bill without knock-on consequences.
The temporary arrangement will be brought to an end with regard to the Lord Chancellor once this bill has passed, and there are no wider constitutional changes. Happy to give a firm commitment on that. This is not a wider constitutional change, and the existing arrangements between the Crown, the government, and the established church will remain. Turning to points from honorable members, the member for Northwest Cambridgeshire talked about the wider role of religion in public life. It was an interesting contribution, but this is a tightly focused bill on this issue and this issue alone.
The member for Mid Derbyshire also entertained the house, although I would say I do not express any particular preference for any particular religion in Number 10, and I say that myself as a lapsed Methodist, if one can even be such a thing. I'm very happy to have a Catholic Prime Minister. Once a Methodist, always a Methodist. Very much once a whip, always a whip in that sense. The Father of the House particularly, I know, entertained us with a historical tour de force.
I'm afraid I do not have any historical forebears such as his to call upon in my wind-up remarks. I would simply say that it is right and proper that the senior adviser to the sovereign, the Prime Minister, should be able to advise the sovereign. And finally, to the member for Bracknell and Immingham, who talked about political input. That is not what we are talking about today, and I sense we may differ on that point, but it was nonetheless a thoughtful contribution. The debate today has indicated there is clear support for this legislation across the house.
And if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker, when I speak to my constituents, whether at Gateshead Jewish Kehilla or at Cardinal Hume School, I want the students there to know that they can play a full role in democratic life where their faith is no barrier. And I know that view is shared across the house today. I look forward to hearing further from honorable members during the remaining stages due to follow shortly, and with that, I commend this bill to the house.
Speaker 199
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Order.
Speaker 217
Under the allocation of time order of today, we now move to committee of the whole House. Order. Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provisions) Bill Committee. Can I remind members that in committee members should address the chair not as Deputy Speaker but either use our names, Madam Chair, Chair and Madam Chairman are also acceptable. We begin with the question that clause 1 stand part of the bill with which it will be convenient to consider clause 2 stand part.
Speaker 216
The question is that clause 1 stand part of the bill. I call the Minister.
Andrew Mark Ferguson
Madam Chair, I hope I will not detain the committee for long in dealing with the two clauses. Clause 1 is the only operative clause of the bill. Its purpose is to remove the restrictions which prevent a person who professes either the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths advising the sovereign on church appointments. It also removes parallel restrictions which prevent a person of those faiths from making church appointments where they have a right to do so by virtue of their office. Some office holders appointed by the sovereign, such as the Lord Chancellor, have the right to directly nominate someone to a benefice, for example, the right to nominate the local vicar of a parish.
The sovereign has no involvement in these appointments. Clause 1 achieves this by repealing section 17 and section 18 of the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829 and the Jews Relief Act 1858 in their entirety. The clause also contains some consequential repeals to church legislation which cross-referenced to some of those provisions. Finally, clause 1 provides that once it comes into force, no person can be convicted under the provisions of section 18 of the 1829 Act or section 4 of the 1858 Act. Clause 2 sets out the extent, commencement and short title of the bill.
The bill extends to and applies UK-wide. It will come into force upon Royal Assent, ensuring the Prime Minister could assume his constitutional duty to advise the sovereign on church appointments without delay. And there we are, Madam Chair. It is clear this bill commands broad consensus and I'm grateful to colleagues for their approach to this legislation. I very much look forward to the rest of today's debate and seeing the bill on the statute book soon.
Mike Wood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Chairman. I rise briefly on behalf of His Majesty's official opposition to confirm our support for clause 1 standing part of this bill. Clause 1 is the operative heart of this legislation, repealing the remaining provisions that the Minister's referred to. In some ways it feels rather fitting that the committee is considering this clause today on the 21st of October, Trafalgar Day, because while the nation rightly remembers Lord Nelson today, it was of course another great hero of the Napoleonic Wars, the Duke of Wellington, who was Prime Minister, together with Sir Robert Peel in this House, drove Catholic emancipation onto the statute book through the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829. At the time, that Act was seen as a radically progressive measure.
Indeed, such was the strength of feeling that Wellington was only able to overcome the fierce opposition of King George IV and peers in the House of Lords by threatening that his Tory government would resign and warning the King and their lordships that an incoming Whig administration would be immeasurably worse. As students of parliamentary history will know, the resulting split in Wellington's party ushered in a decade and a half of Whig dominance. Now Madam Chairman, I'm bound to say that I'm rather pleased that there is considerably more cross-party consensus around today's reform.
There is, however, an important historical lesson in how we view the statutes that Clause 1 amends today. Both the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829 and the subsequent Jews Relief Act 1858 were seen in their own day as worthy progressive steps forward, tearing down centuries-old barriers to public life. The restrictions they left behind on advising the sovereign on church appointments were the political compromises of the 19th century. But nearly 200 years on, what was introduced as a 19th-century compromise is now an archaic anomaly and unacceptable discrimination. Over the decades, Parliament has rightly repealed or amended many of the other restrictive measures originally contained in both the 1829 and 1858 Acts, and Clause 1 simply finishes that long historical journey by removing these final statutory prohibitions and their draconian penalties.
It ensures that the legal bar on a Roman Catholic or Jewish Prime Minister fulfilling their constitutional duties by advising the monarch on church appointments is similarly consigned to history. His Majesty's opposition therefore supports both Clause 1 and Clause 2 standing part of this bill.
Speaker 199
If there are no further contributions, the question is that Clause 1 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that Clause 2 stand part of the bill.
Speaker 223
As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Order, order. Order.
Speaker 219
I beg to report that the Committee has gone through the bill and has directed me to report the same without amendment.
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
I beg to move that the bill now be read a third time. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll keep my remarks brief. As we've heard, this bill's purpose is to lift archaic historic restrictions which prevent an individual of the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths from advising the sovereign on church appointments or from making church appointments where their office gives them the right to directly nominate someone. This bill will therefore ensure that the current Prime Minister and indeed any future Prime Minister who professes either the Roman Catholic or Jewish faiths can perform their constitutional responsibility to advise the sovereign on these matters without risking disbarment from public office. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to particularly heartfelt thank the insightful contributions of members, honourable and right honourable, in particular the Father of the House and my constituency neighbour.
I'd like to thank the opposition for the spirit with which they have approached this bill. Today's debates were, as my honourable friend acknowledged, both historical but also very thoughtful in the development of our constitutional arrangements. I'm grateful for the support of members, right honourable members right across the House for the approach that we have taken. I know that the House will therefore agree with me when I say that although the bill is modest, it is an important step forward in ensuring that our laws reflect our belief that a Prime Minister's faith should not restrict their ability to undertake their role, and I commend this bill to the House.
Speaker 222
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. Shadow Minister Mike Wood.
Mike Wood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as we reach third reading, I'm pleased to again reaffirm our support for this measure as we work to ensure that this particular anachronism will soon be consigned to history. Our constitutional arrangements are the product of centuries of history, and on these benches, we believe we should always approach changes to them with appropriate care. Our constitution has evolved considerably since the 19th century, reflecting the changing character of our country and the diversity of the people who serve it, and it is entirely reasonable that our laws should evolve with it. Respect for our history does not require us to preserve every historical anomaly.
There is a clear distinction between respecting our constitutional traditions and allowing outdated 19th century restrictions to remain on the statute book simply because they have always been there. At the same time, the established church occupies a distinctive place within our constitutional settlement, and the relationship between church and state is one that has developed over centuries. So in correcting the historical injustice, it is vital that we preserve both our established constitutional arrangement and the independence and integrity of the church appointments process. In practical terms, when appointing bishops and archbishops, the Church of England presents a candidate to the Prime Minister, who then advises the monarch on who to install in that role. And for nearly 20 years, the Prime Minister has not had much of a role in the selection of Church of England bishops, and Downing Street's involvement in the process has become largely a formality.
That is why, alongside supporting this bill with the repeal of these discriminatory criminal provisions today, His Majesty's opposition has suggested the clear and respectful convention for the future, following recent precedent. The Prime Ministers who are not members of the Church of England should retain their formal constitutional role in advising the sovereign while continuing to delegate any active decision-making process to others. Madam Deputy Speaker, the ability to serve as Prime Minister and to exercise the full responsibilities of that office should depend on the confidence of this House and the ability of the individual concerned, not their religious belief. On that fundamental principle, the whole House can unite today, and so we support the third reading of this bill and wish it well as it proceeds to the other place.
Speaker 199
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. I will allow a few moments for the front benches to swap over.
We now come to the motion in the name of Tim Farron on support for British farmers. I can inform the House that Mr. Speaker has not selected the amendment. I call Tim Farron to move the motion.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If there was, if there was a thin silver lining to Brexit, it was the opportunity to design our own bespoke system to reward and support farmers to care for our environment and to feed our country.
But every farmer, certainly in England, knows that the heart of this debate is the utter, inexcusable failure of both Conservative and Labour governments to deliver an effective post-Brexit farm payment scheme. That failure has undermined farm profitability and undermined the UK's food security. It is two and a half years since the Conservatives left office, and yet, as Halloween approaches, that government still looms as a spectre over our rural communities, haunting us all because this Labour government refuses to exorcise that ghost, clinging on instead to the ghastly Conservative policies that did so much to damage our farmers in Westmorland and beyond. I am in no risk at all of overstating when I say that the last Conservative government did more harm to British farmers and British farming than any other in UK history. Trade deals with Australia and New Zealand that threw our farmers under the bus.
A botched Brexit deal that ended overnight British farmers' access to their biggest external market. And the reckless, rushed removal of the basic payment scheme while new schemes were falteringly introduced at a snail's pace. New schemes that have mostly placed hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayers' money into the hands of huge non-farmer organisations while family farmers saw their incomes plummet, such as today, that today, hill farmers in Cumbria now enjoy an average income of less than half the minimum wage, and that's if you assume that they work for 40 hours a week when it is nearer 90. Now, I don't know if the Conservative attack on our countryside, taking money away from family farms and putting it into the hands of a few large landowners, I don't know if that was deliberate or whether it was incompetence. But the results are the same either way.
Those who we rely upon to feed us, treated like dirt. We bring this motion today because I want farmers to know that this House cares about them, that we think that those who get up early each day to feed our country and to protect our planet do the most awesome job in the world, that they are valued and respected and that we want a system that reflects that in practice. This debate follows the debacle of the Sustainable Farming Incentive window in September. That catastrophically short window was a long time coming. SFI was essentially set up to replace, I will, yes, I'm happy to give way, yeah.
Rose Savage
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. I left party conference when that SFI window had just opened, went straight home to speak to my Wiltshire farmers, by the time I got to that meeting, the window had closed. This is not acceptable, and what happened last year is also not acceptable. Would my honourable friend agree with me that the government needs to give our farmers some certainty so that they can plan accordingly around when that window will be open next year and how much money will be in an, in it?
Timothy James Farron
Very much agree with my honourable friend. And my view is we should be seeking to reopen the window this year, given the number of farmers who were carved out as a consequence. And I'm also happy to give way.
Claire Louise Young
Does my honourable friend agree with the point made by Latchig Green Farm in my constituency, that these, the decisions about how the funding, public funding should be spent should be made on the merits of the application, the benefits that it can bring, rather than your ability to click quickly?
Timothy James Farron
It is an issue I will, I will come to, but that is absolutely the case, that if we have a first-come-first-served system, then there is no assessment as to the quality of those bids.
Now, I'm pretty sure pretty much all of the applications were of high quality, but the differential merit were not taken into account. You were simply excluded because you were milking, or you were doing your job before the window closed. And SFI was, and I think the record will prove this, SFI was essentially set up to replace the basic payment scheme. It was implemented disastrously because it was designed disastrously. The Conservative government failed even to spend the SFI budget when they were in power, underspending the allocation by 358 million pounds.
Money that should have gone to support our farmers to keep the promises made to them during Brexit, promises that have been broken. And then, in March 2025, with absolutely no notice, this Labour government closed the SFI programme for the year, leaving hundreds of farmers outside with absolutely nothing. The Minister at the time, who is not in his place, but the right honourable Member for Cambridge, who I must say, before his removal, was becoming an increasingly important advocate for farmers within government, apologised for the closure of the SFI, explaining that the scheme was a good one, but that because the application process inherited from the Conservatives was first-come-first-served, funds were not being allocated either wisely or fairly, as my honourable friends have already highlighted. Now, I remain outraged at that closure in 2025, but the former farming Minister's point about the Tory first-come-first-served process is absolutely well-made. A first-come-first-served process means that government funding is allocated randomly at best, not achieving best value for the taxpayer.
Even worse, it means that funding disproportionately goes to those farms that are big enough to be able to afford land agents, or to be able to have a large farm staff, or be able to spend much time away from farming to fill out forms. Meanwhile, farmers working 90 hours a week up Langdale, up Longsleddale, in the Eden Valley, producing our food, caring for our countryside, with low incomes, well, they get systematically shut out. By accident or by design, the impact remains horrific either way. Now, the government pledged to learn lessons from the 2025 disaster, and so along comes September the 22nd this year, when SFI funds ran out and the drawbridge got pulled up after less than six hours. Now, I've spoken to hill farmers, protecting some of the world's most epic landscapes but struggling with dodgy Wi-Fi in their valley, so they got nothing.
I've spoken to dairy farmers who just popped out to tend their cattle and got back to their computer to discover that they had got nothing. I've spoken to land agents, heartbroken and ashamed that the majority of small farms that they bid on behalf of had got nothing. Farmers who had all their basic payment taken away, who had literally nothing else to look forward to apart from SFI, yet the system closed in less than a day and they got nothing. The government has learned nothing from the damage the Conservatives did, so will the Minister return with a scheme this autumn that ensures that farmers who had viable SFI applications are funded and not left out in the cold? I'll be happy to give way to whoever it was.
Thank you.
Speaker 227
Thank you for giving way. It was just to make the point that I think he missed SFI window one in his description just there.
Timothy James Farron
There was indeed an SFI window earlier in the year, but the bulk of the applicants were aiming for SFI two in 2026, and of course a huge number of those were cut out simply because of the way that the system was set up. Now, Liberal Democrats are determined to put this right. With our biggest parliamentary presence in this place in more than a century, we humbly seek, thank you, we humbly seek, we humbly seek to be in government after the next election. And should we be so, we would be determined to lead DEFRA.
And we would reform SFI so that every farmer was allocated a sum via SFI consistent with the capacity of their farm. That money would be theirs to claim within a long window, so long as they submitted a compliant claim which demonstrated delivery of public goods. There would be no competition as to who could press send the quickest. But the failings of our farm payment system goes far beyond the SFI disaster. At its foundation, this Tory-designed, Labour-delivered scheme is woefully flawed for one fundamental reason.
Because they have given us a farm payment scheme which, can you believe it, the bedrock of our agricultural policy, a farm payment scheme which actively disincentivises the production of food. What utter and complete madness. When Britain's food security is more at risk than at any time since the last war, we now have a farm payment scheme in England that fails to support farmers to produce food. Also at a time when every other country in the UK and every country in the European Union does provide that support. England, the odd one out.
We are failing our farmers and we are failing our people as we sleepwalk into no longer being able to guarantee that we can feed our country. Effectively locking small farmers out of the farm payment system is socially unjust. It damages our food security and it also damages our environment. Many farmers I've spoken to in Westmorland and beyond who have been excluded from SFI and other schemes are so utterly demoralised and angry that they will now just turn their back on environmental schemes altogether. These are people who have been champions of nature-friendly farming, whose parents and grandparents have spent decades promoting environmental responsibility on their farms.
They don't want to turn their back on sustainable farming, but they've got to pay the rent and feed their kids somehow. And SFI delivered well could have brought every single farmer who had received the basic payment in the past into the environmental big tent. But instead, this combination of cruelty and incompetence leaves thousands outside in the cold and we cannot now blame them if they choose to intensify and undo the good environmental work of generations that preceded them. Liberal Democrats would reverse the banking tax cuts from the last parliament and use a portion of that revenue to boost the ELMS budget by one billion pounds. We would allocate an SFI sum to every farm that would be theirs to claim.
We would therefore maximise the number of farms inside environmental schemes, protecting nature, improving water quality, sequestering carbon, protecting urban areas from flooding, providing access and enjoyment to the millions who visit the Lakes, the Dales and the rest of Britain's beautiful countryside. And we would revoke the Labour-Conservative consensus by finally making the production of food a public good, funding it as we should and starting the journey back to food security. To be parochial, Madam Deputy Speaker, just for a rare moment. The English Lake District was awarded World Heritage Site status in 2017. When UNESCO made that award, in their assessment of the beauty of those towering landscapes, they gave as much credit to our farmers who shaped them as they did to the glaciers that carved them.
For a millennium at least, our land has been curated, tended, moulded, protected and nurtured into producing the food that fuels each and every one of us. How short-sighted is it to put all of that at risk? And to be personal, just for a moment. The loss of basic payment, the failure to include thousands of family farms in replacement schemes as funds instead gravitate to the big estates and the huge non-farmer organisations has left so many families back home in Cumbria bereft.
And I don't just mean financially bereft, but in deep, heartbroken despair. Just think what it might feel like if your family had farmed your valley for generations, maybe centuries, and yet now it looks like the farm will be lost on your watch because of all this. Can you imagine the anxiety and the shame, the isolation in every sense of the word, the overwhelming desolation that there is nowhere to turn? Well, thanks to Farmer Network, to RABI, to young farmers, there are places to turn. But shall we today in this House choose to say to our farmers that we will stand with them too, that we are grateful to them for feeding us and for keeping Britain beautiful, and that we will match those words with actions?
Maybe, maybe there are members who perhaps think, well, I haven't got any farms in my constituency, this isn't relevant to me. But I'll tell you this, 100% of those members' constituents eat food, and so farming does matter to them and to all of us. Yet this place too rarely acts like it believes that. Today we give members the opportunity to affirm that they do. 70% of England's landmass is agricultural land.
If we are serious about tackling climate change, protecting our environment, then we have to start there by motivating and including all of our farmers to be on the frontline for that fight, not locking them out, demoralising and excluding them. In an increasingly volatile and uncertain world, Britain is less than 60% self-sufficient in food. That is terrifying. And yet we have thousands of farmers out there ready to meet the call if only we will call. We present this motion to the House because British farmers are the best in the world, and the best farmers in the world deserve the best support.
Speaker 229
The question is as on the order paper. Minister, Jenny Riddle-Carpenter.
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by thanking the opposition spokesperson for his speech. Farming is not simply another industry. Farmers produce the food that sustains us, manage much of our countryside and underpin a much wider food and drink economy. Agriculture alone contributes 14.5 billion to the economy, while the wider food and drink sector contributed 153.2 billion in 2023 alone.
This matters not just to the economy, maintaining domestic food production to at least current levels is integral to our national security. As the Prime Minister said in this House last month, farming and food production are as part of this country's sovereign production and manufacturing capacity, which we will need to strengthen in the years to come. We will need to depend on it and therefore we need to strengthen it more, and that is a clear commitment. That's why this government is committed to backing British farmers and maintaining domestic food production to at least current levels.
Charlie Dewhirst
I thank the Minister for giving way. On the particular points about maintaining domestic food production, she'll no doubt be aware of the problems the pig sector is facing at the moment. We've had tens of thousands of pigs backed up on farms, contracts cancelled and farmers losing up to 50 pounds a pig at the moment. So just to simply ask her today what discussions she and colleagues have had with the pig sector and what plans does the government have to support our great British pig farmers?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
Can I thank the honourable member for that very important question. I can confirm that the farming minister and colleagues have been in active conversation with the National Pig Association and are continuing that dialogue. As I was setting out, our farming roadmap sets out a long-term direction for a sector that is more profitable, more productive, sustainable and resilient and better able to withstand climate, market and geopolitical shocks. Now I do want to acknowledge, Madam Deputy Speaker, just how difficult this year has been.
The opposition spokesperson set out some of the extraordinary combinations of pressures that farmers are facing and have faced this year alone. Drought and water shortages, reduced grass and forage growth, difficult crop conditions and higher irrigation and feed cost. At the same time, conflict in the Middle East has put further pressure on fertilizers and fuel prices.
John Lamont
The minister's highlighted the issue of fertilizer cost. Last week, this government pushed through the fertilizer tax, which is going to put up the price of fertilizer between 80 and 90 pounds a ton. The Conservatives voted against that, the Liberals sat on their hands and did not oppose the fertilizer tax, which was frankly shocking. But does the minister not recognize the pressures that these farmers are facing and this additional tax which this government has imposed does nothing to help?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
I would remind the honorable member that the last UK ammonia production closed under the Conservative government without any intervention. So we do recognize that resilience is not evenly distributed and some farm businesses have significantly less capacity than others to withstand short-term shocks. The impacts of climate change and drought have been particularly severe. More than 80% of the country is now in drought. The South East and South West experienced their driest April to September period in more than a century and pressure on water resources continues despite recent rain we are seeing today.
We understand what that means on a farms. It means less grass, lower forage and crop yield, pressure on irrigation and reservoirs and greater demand for livestock water and ultimately greater uncertainty about the year ahead. So we have acted. In August we introduced a package of drought support measures. This included temporary adjustments to environmental land management agreements so farmers affected by drought could continue receiving payments while taking practical steps to protect their businesses.
We also reminded farmers and growers that they can apply to the Environment Agency for temporary abstraction flexibility through the local enforcement protections to help them access water during dry periods where environmental impacts can be appropriately managed. Members of the Lib Democrat benches are now asking what we are doing on climate and water resilience. The last time they were in government they cut flood spend by a fifth within six months of taking office. We are taking water and weather extremely seriously. But responding to one dry summer is not enough.
Farmers need greater long-term water security. That's why up to 15 million pound has been made available through a further water management grant to help build farm reservoirs which allow water to be stored when it's most readily available and used to support food production during the drier periods. This will help reduce reliance on direct abstraction when rivers and groundwater are under greatest pressure. We are also making it easier to build reservoirs by updating planning guidance and working with industry to review whether further planning reforms are needed. We have also simplified applications for longer duration abstraction licenses helping farmers secure finances for on-farm reservoirs by better aligning license duration with investment and loan repayment periods.
And for this year we have brought forward the reservoir refill season from November to October.
access water when it is available whilst also protecting the natural environment. Drought and climate change are not the only sources of uncertainty though, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Middle East conflict remains a significant source of disruption to fertilizer and red diesel prices. The continued pressures underline something fundamental: our farming system needs to become less exposed to global shocks and expensive imported inputs. That does not simply mean telling farmers to absorb higher costs.
It means helping them become more productive and more efficient. Farming schemes including actions supporting variable rate nutrient application, companion cropping, legumes and herbal leys, all of which can help improve nutrient efficiency and reduce reliance on synthetic fertilizer.
Ian Roome
I'm grateful to the Minister for giving way. Does the Minister agree that it's simply unacceptable for farmers to be expected to deliver the government's environmental ambitions, yet have less than six hours to secure the funding to do so? And will she commit to a fairer system for the SFI scheme going forward with sufficient funding and guaranteed opportunity for North Devon farmers especially to apply, rather than leaving their livelihoods to a first-come, first-served basis?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
I thank the honorable member for that contribution. We are getting ahead of myself, I will be tackling the SFI later in my speech. I will say that the Minister has been clear on many of the lessons that will be learned, but I will be setting out on it further. Across the Sustainable Farming Incentive, Countryside Stewardship and Higher Level Stewardship, 534,000 hectares are already using precision applications of fertilizer and manure. We have also increased fertilizer market monitoring and encouraged greater use of nutrient planning to help farmers optimize fertilizer use, rolling out an online tool to help farmers use fertilizers more efficiently.
Now beyond Defra, the Treasury reduced the duty on red diesel earlier this year in response to price increases resulting from the Middle Eastern crisis. And we're investing in innovation because lasting resilience must ultimately come from producing more efficiently. For 26-27, 123 million has been allocated to the Farming Innovation Programme with support for technologies and approaches that can raise productivity and strengthen that important resilience. I'm going to make progress if I may. Because I'm coming onto something very important.
I want to address the issue of SFI 26 frankly. I really do recognize the disappointment and frustration caused by the closure of the second application window on the 22nd of September. SFI is a scheme this government inherited from the previous Conservative government. They designed this first-come, first-served scheme, sent a quarter of the money to 4% of farms, and now they complain it was oversubscribed. When we inherited it, the scheme had no budget control and no proper alignment of SFI actions to environmental and sustainability targets.
It included that first-come, first-served application process. For 2026, we made improvements to the offer to ensure more farmers could access funding. We made the offer simpler and more focused with fewer actions while retaining actions for all farm types. We introduced a 100k per annum max agreement value cap to spread the availability of funding more widely. We also gave priority access to schemes for small farms and farms without existing ELM revenue agreements.
These two groups had been underrepresented in SFI previously, and this priority access through SFI 26 window one remains open for two months. SFI 26 window two was open to all eligible farmers and land managers. It experienced exceptionally high demand and closed after around six hours once available budget had been allocated.
Joshua Fenton-Glynn
I thank the honorable member for giving way. I've met with a lot of farmers since the deadline closed, and there is an overwhelming feeling of anxiety. But because they are practical, the main thing they want to focus on is that we're going to learn the lessons of this.
Could could my honorable friend please let me know what lessons we're going to learn and how we're going to move forward on that basis?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
Can I thank my honorable friend and I thank him for the work that he's doing to engage with his local farming community. I will be talking about that more, but we are work is already underway to to make those improvements and scrap that first come first served scheme element of the scheme. We anticipated stronger demand and increased the window two budget significantly over this summer. An additional 50 million was announced by the Prime Minister in August as part of the response to the dry weather that we've seen and a further 20 million was added before window two opened. Together I need I will do because it's
Alexander Carmichael
I'm grateful to my former colleague in the select committee for for giving way. These these links are important. Can she tell the depart can she tell the house how many applications did the department expect? It was modeled by some that there would be something in the region of 40,000. In fact, there was money available for 12,000.
Did it come as a total surprise to the department that they got as many applications as they did?
Barbara Jenny Riddell-Carpenter
Can I thank the honorable member for that intervention. He's correct that there was modeling that was undertaken and as a result of that modeling a further 50 million was announced by the Prime Minister and a subsequent 20 million by the Secretary of State. Now, I do recognize that substantial demand remained unsatisfied when window two closed and I understand how difficult that was for farmers who were ready to apply but did not have the opportunity to secure an agreement. Let me say let me say this clearly. There will be future SFI offers and we plan to make an SFI 27 offer available as soon as possible.
We are working with the farming sector. I am going to make progress, I'm sorry. We are working with the farming sector on how the scheme can be improved as part of that and the minister himself has confirmed that we will scrap the first come first served application within that process. But it's also important to stress that SFI is only one part of our support for farming. Across this parliament, this government has allocated a record 11.8 billion to sustainable farming and food production.
That includes 788 million this year alone in new funding for farmers to boost farm productivity, develop cutting edge technologies to drive future growth and maintain a healthy natural environment. Capital grants have provided 225 million this year for practical environmental improvements on farms. At least 50 million is available for a new countryside stewardship higher tier agreement. We have also committed 173 million in 26 27 for productivity equipment and innovation through the farming equipment and technology funds and farming innovation programs. This represents an extensive ongoing commitment to farm adaptation and improvement and I hope the opposition support these aims.
Our government support is not only about grants. Farmers need thriving markets and fair returns for the food they produce. That's why we have established the farming and food partnerships board bringing together leaders from farming, food, retail, finance and to focus on productivity, profitability, homegrown produce and national food security. We are taking action on fairness in the supply chain too. Fair dealing regulations have been introduced for dairy and pigs with further work covering eggs, fresh produce and and crops.
And our farming roadmap makes our long term approach clear. We will maintain domestic food production to at least current levels. We will protect productive land for food production.
We will support investment in technology and skills, and we will build resilience to the climate into the climate and geopolitical shocks that farmers are increasingly having to manage. I am going to make progress because healthy soils, reliable water supplies, efficient use of nutrients, and profitable farm businesses are not competing objectives. They are foundations of our food security. So farmers have endured, Madam Deputy Speaker, an exceptionally demanding period. We recognize the pressure that many, many businesses are under, and I recognize the real frustration for those who are unable to secure an SFI 26 agreement.
But our commitment to farming has not changed. We will continue to invest in farmers, support productivity and innovation, improve water resilience, make supply chains fairer, and work with the sector to build businesses that can withstand changing weather and an uncertain world. Above all, we will continue to back the people who produce our food because supporting British farming is not simply about supporting one sector. It is about our food security, our economic security, and our national resilience. And this government is determined to secure all three.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Once again, yesterday, the Shadow Secretary of State and I were out and about in the fields talking to our hardworking farmers, this time in Newbury, speaking to them about the many hardships that they are facing at the hand of this Labour government. Week after week, from farm to farm, the message is the same. Farmers are exhausted. They are worried.
They are feeling incredibly betrayed by this Labour government and that they do not feel that this government is on their side. They do not feel that this government values the work that they are doing and feel that this government has turned their back on rural Britain. So I welcome the debate because it gives us an opportunity in this House to say out loud what every farmer in this country already knows. That on Labour's watch, it's our hardworking farming families that are paying the price under this government. So let me begin by addressing the fiasco that has been the sustainable farming incentive.
As I said in this place just last week, I cannot stress enough how badly the SFI has been mishandled under this Labour government. It has been a complete and utter debacle and our hardworking farming families have once again the ones that are suffering under this government. But let there be no doubt. This did not come out of the blue, Madam Deputy Speaker. There had been plenty of warnings.
Having closed the scheme in March 25, this government caused chaos. Huge anxiety and additional financial pressure for our farmers and I will give way to the honorable member.
James William Naish
I wonder whether he thinks that it's better to close the scheme because it's overspent or to underspend the Defra budget by 358 million pounds.
Robbie Moore
Madam Deputy Speaker, what the other side don't seem to understand is that when you close a scheme which is highly sought after in March of 2025, demand inevitably builds up, which is exactly what happened under this Labour government and coupled with when you reduce the budget significantly, demand builds. And what was the result, Madam Deputy Speaker? 18 months of this government sitting on their hands, enabling demand to build, which when the scheme finally opened, it was then became a competitive scheme, a first come first served basis under this government's watch. And this Labour government created a scheme that who could get in was based on who could press send the fastest. And this Labour government knew what the consequences were going to be as reported in the Times yesterday, but carried on regardless.
And the result, Madam Deputy Speaker, approximately 40,000 farmers trying to get into the scheme, but only 12,200 farmers were successful before the application finally application window finally closed and was slammed after closed, slammed shut after just five and a half hours. All because the money had gone.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, last week I stood in this chamber and asked the minister, the farming minister, very simple questions, but there were no answers. So I will try again so that he can address these in his summing up. We know that the expiring agreements were worth more than 520 million, yet the SFI budget had been cut to just 310 million. So where has the additional 210 million gone? It is also vital that clarity and reassurance is given now to our farmers.
So when will the minister open SFI 27? It's not good enough just to say as soon as possible, we need clarity. And what will he do for those agreement holders who have agreements that are expiring to stop the cliff edge in their cash flow? And what budget has the minister set aside for SFI 27? Because we must all remember that this has been on top of the government's disastrous decision to dramatically reduce delinked payments far quicker than what was ever previously agreed to a measly 600 pounds per farming business.
I suspect it costs the government more in administrative charges to distribute these payments than it does that benefits each individual farming holding. And it's on our farming businesses that are now feeling the pain financially and emotionally, struggling right now with their cash flow. But Madam Deputy Speaker, SFI is not some isolated incident. It is part of a pattern because before Labour broke the SFI scheme, they crushed the family farm with their disastrous family farm and family business tax. Before the election, those on the benches opposite looked farmers in the eye and told them that they had no plans to change the agricultural property relief and business property relief.
In their very first budget, their first opportunity they had to show rural communities up and down the country that they cared and understood them, they didn't. They brought out the family farm and family business tax, a vindictive tax that strikes family farming businesses at their worst moment. So yes, Madam Deputy Speaker, each and every one of those Labour MPs on the benches opposite who voted again last week to keep the family farm and family business tax should be ashamed of themselves. But I know that there has been a narrative, rightly so, that there's been a partial U-turn with the threshold being raised from 1 million to 2 and a half million before the tax applies. But even at this level, it is simply not going far enough.
And we now have the bizarre scenario, Madam Deputy Speaker, that if you are in marital status, the threshold is 5 million pounds. It seems ridiculous. Because once we know the value of the farmland has been valued and the value of the farmhouse, the growing crops, the stocks, the machinery, the crops in store, the livestock, the value of a traditional farming business will be well above the 2 and a half million pound threshold, therefore exposing any hardworking family farming business to an IHT liability that they simply will not be able to afford. It's been completely ill-thought through. And that brings me on to the motion before us from the Liberal Democrats.
The Liberal Democrats' motion states here that they only regret the government's changes to agricultural property relief. It makes no reference to business property relief. Now, I thought that we were aligned on this issue, but clearly not, Madam Deputy Speaker. Business property relief is also heavily relied upon by many farming businesses. It covers trading assets not covered by agricultural property relief, including machinery, livestock, harvested crops, any rural diversification project, farm shops and holiday lets.
So I am incredibly surprised that the Lib Dems don't also regret the government's changes to business property relief as well. And I will give way to the honorable member.
Timothy James Farron
I'm very generous. I'm sure he is at least as au fait with Liberal Democrat manifesto policies as I am. And and will know the Liberal Democrats oppose the the business family business inheritance tax changes as well. He will also know, having been here a reasonable amount of time, there's a word limit on these motions, which is why it's not mentioned.
Robbie Moore
Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a Liberal Democrat opposition day debate. They have had many opportunities to prepare for this, but yet a crucial part of their motion today excludes business property relief. Now I I take the honorable member at his word that they are also concerned by the impact that business property relief will have on many of our farming businesses. But I'm very surprised, given the huge level of impact it has, it's not been included within their motion today. So let me be clear from this side of the House.
The Conservatives absolutely regret the continuous rollout of both the family farm and family business tax, and we will continue to demand that the government scraps both and puts back in place the 100% relief on APR and BPR, and urge the government on behalf of our farmers, our growers, and our wider agricultural sector that next week in the budget, the Prime Minister does the right thing and axes the family farm and family business tax. But it doesn't stop there, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Will he give way?
I will give way.
Ashley Peter Fox
I'm grateful to my honorable friend. I'm glad he's brave enough to take an intervention from a member for from Somerset. He's absolutely right to emphasize our commitment to scrapping the family farm and the family business tax. But does he agree with me that the fertilizer tax that this Labour government is going to introduce on the 1st of January, and which the Liberal Democrats are too timid to oppose, will hit farmers and increase the price of food in our country?
Robbie Moore
Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend makes an excellent point because he is completely right to outline the impact of the statutory instrument that was voted on just this week, in which all members on this side of the Conservative benches voted against. And I was just about to come onto that point because, Madam Deputy Speaker, it does not stop with the family farm and family business tax. As if the dramatic drop in delinked payments, the SFI debacle, and the family farm and family business tax weren't enough, from the 1st of January next year, Labour will hit farmers with yet another tax: the fertilizer tax through the carbon border adjustment mechanism. Industry warns that this new fertilizer tax could pile up a further 75 pounds a ton, if not more, on current fertilizer prices. This was this is simply unfeasible.
It adds an additional cost to many of our farmers at a time when they are already being pushed to breaking point. The fertilizer tax should not have been introduced, Madam Deputy Speaker, which is why the Conservatives voted against it last week. But I do have to say to the Liberal Democrats, and on that point I will give way to the honorable member.
Alexander Carmichael
I'm grateful to the honorable member for giving way because, of course, he will be aware that the carbon border adjustment mechanism was something that was started under the last government. The consultation was launched in 2023. With the benefit of hindsight, does he think it might have been a good idea at that stage to take fertilizer out of it?
Robbie Moore
Madam Deputy Speaker, I I please that the right honorable member, who I have great respect for, has raised this point. But I do gently push back and say that we are two years into this Labour government. He makes reference to a consultation that was started under the previous Conservative administration, but literally we voted on the fertilizer point this week. And it was the Conservatives, and only predominantly the Conservatives, that voted against it, which brings me onto my point that I have to say to the Liberal Democrats: where were you in voting to stop the fertilizer tax?
Because not one Liberal Democrat MP voted to stop it. So yet again, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have the Liberal Democrats all over the place. We have the honorable member for South Cambridgeshire literally saying in a debate that I attended last week, and I quote, "We Liberal Democrats support the carbon border adjustment mechanism." But yet in today's motion, the Liberal Democrats say they note farmers are concerned about the impact of the carbon border adjustment mechanism on fertilizer costs. But they can't bring themselves, Madam Deputy Speaker, to be that concerned enough to vote to stop it.
Madam Deputy Speaker, far from protecting our farmers in this house, the Liberal Democrats are simply demonstrating that they are Labour enablers, helping those on the government benches opposite to bulldoze through their plans, whilst outside this house, I suspect no doubt their leaflets will be portraying a very different message to their constituents to try and keep everybody happy. But we see through that. So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, the record of this Labour government is clear for us all to see. They broke the SFI scheme and cut its budget. They taxed the family farm and now they're taxing our fertilizers and their assets.
We have a farming minister who faints at the sight of meat. We have a countryside minister who thinks that anyone who has a black Labrador and enjoys a warm pint in one of our rural pubs is far right. What an absolute nonsense. Farmers feed this nation. They deserve a government on their side.
Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear that farmers can no longer afford another day of this Labour government.
Speaker 199
Members will be able to see that there are many of you wishing to contribute, so with an immediate five-minute time limit, Terry Jermy.
James Terry Jermy
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I begin by welcoming my honorable friend the minister to her place. I am so pleased to see her there and I know that her rural credentials are strong. As the Member of Parliament for South West Norfolk, one of the most productive farming constituencies in the country, it has been a privilege to spend a significant amount of my time over the past two years meeting farmers, landowners, growers, and rural businesses across the area. Farming is not simply another sector in South West Norfolk. It shapes our landscape, it supports our local economy, it underpins food production, contributes to environmental stewardship, and helps to define the very character of our communities.
Since being elected, I have made a conscious effort to get out onto farms and to listen. And I firmly believe that good policy starts with understanding the reality on the ground. That means standing in fields and walking farmyards and hearing directly from the people who deal with the practical challenges and the opportunities facing farming every single day. And I welcome that our farming minister has been undertaking that engagement too, and I know that it has been valued by the industry. I've now met with more than a hundred South West Norfolk farmers.
And from those meetings, I have been struck by the resilience, the dedication, and the innovation of farmers in South West Norfolk. Because agriculture today requires farmers to balance a growing range of responsibilities. Alongside producing high-quality food, businesses are managing environmental outcomes, adapting to changing weather patterns, embracing new technologies, and responding to market pressures. The scale of that challenge demonstrates the professionalism, the adaptability of modern farming, and many are doing this whilst operating on extremely fine margins. The concerns of a farmer in Weeting will likely differ from those in Nordelph.
There is not one size fits all solution for farming. And one of the clear themes from my visits is just how important confidence, clarity, and certainty are for farming businesses making long-term decisions.
Ashley Peter Fox
I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for giving way. In his discussions with farmers in South West Norfolk, are they content with the government changes to agricultural property relief, or do they still think the family farm tax should be abolished in its entirety?
James Terry Jermy
I thank the honourable member for that intervention. The vast majority of farms in my constituency are small family farms, and it's because of campaigning from constituency MPs like myself and others that we got the changes to that policy that means it now works for the vast majority of those impacted. And I reflect on the past decade or so. It is farmers who have been at the sharp end of changing political landscapes, Brexit and its fundamental change to farming policy being the most profound. Because farming is an industry that plans years ahead.
Decisions made today on investment, machinery, water infrastructure, environmental delivery, and succession have consequences that last decades. Farmers can adapt to change and seize new opportunities when there is a clear direction of travel. What becomes difficult is when businesses lack the certainty needed to plan with confidence. Across the countless conversations, farmers have told me they are desperate for that clarity, consistency, and long-term thinking from government. And I hope that the farming roadmap delivered under, developed under this Labour government is the start of that approach.
One of the biggest issues raised has been around profitability. The fundamental challenge remains ensuring that farming businesses can generate sustainable returns. And whilst discussions often focus on environmental schemes or regulation, this scheme or that scheme, as is the case with the Lib Dem motion today, neither environmental ambition or long-term investment can be achieved if a farm business themselves is not financially viable. And farming continues to be treated as a political football, whether it's by cosplay Reform, a Barbour jacket and flat cap maybe, but is there actually a single farming policy? And I note their absence from this debate today.
And what of the Tories, desperate as ever to be the face of rural Britain like it's some divine right, whilst completely ignoring the demise of farming under their watch, with the withdrawal from the Common Agricultural Policy that left our farmers exposed with no plan in place. And it will be some years before many farmers will forgive that level of betrayal from the Conservatives. Now, many farmers tell me that despite producing world-class food, margins are often squeezed by factors beyond their control. They have such limited agency over their destiny. This feeds into their frustration and, yes, the poor mental health of many farmers, which is a very real concern.
Looking forward, I remain optimistic about the future of British farming. There are many challenges and they are significant, but there are opportunities too. We have some of the most productive farmland to be found anywhere in the world. We have farmers who are innovative, entrepreneurial, and committed to producing high-quality food. And we have growing opportunities around technology, precision agriculture, water management, and sustainable food production.
But success is not guaranteed, and it will also require a recognition that food production and environmental improvements are not competing objectives. Done properly, they can and must go hand in hand. To conclude, I have three main asks of the government. With the budget looming, we must raise the annual investment allowance and, in addition, consider what I have called the green investment allowance, incentivise investment in rural areas into things like reservoirs and revamping poultry sheds, which will deliver greater environmental benefits than many SFI schemes. Will he give way?
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Just on that point. I thank the honourable member for giving way. Yesterday I had the great delight of meeting with Derbyshire NFU who agreed with the honourable member about making it much easier for them to access capital not just to invest in items like tractors but actually to be able to invest in buildings and things such as reservoirs to help them manage the change in climate. So does he agree with me that meeting regularly with our NFU members is a fantastic use of our time and they help shape the recommendations we make to government?
James Terry Jermy
I absolutely agree with my honourable friend because government cannot pay for everything but we can and should create the investment framework to encourage it. Secondly we must significantly improve the availability of on-farm water collection and storage through amending planning laws and providing capital grants. Without this land currently farmed will become unviable with increasing drought and water scarcity. And we must also focus on supply chain fairness. Turbocharging a more cooperative model such as that in New Zealand using public procurement powers and tackling imports that have lower environmental and animal welfare standards than which we permit here in the UK.
I could go on but if food security really does mean national security there needs to be tangible action and we need it now.
Alistair Carmichael.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. I remind the House of my entry in the register of members' financial interests. It's a pleasure to follow the honourable member for South West Norfolk. I can endorse his asks for the Chancellor and indeed probably add a few of my own. And like him I also welcome the new minister to her place or at least when she was in her place.
She's maybe had a slightly rocky start for some moments but I know from her time in the select committee that she does have a knowledge and a concern for the industry. And it's in everybody's interests Madam Deputy Speaker that the government should be successful so we wish her and her colleagues well. I'm not going to say a great deal about the sustainable farming incentive. The minister's coming to the committee next week and we'll doubtless spend some time on it then. But I think it would be worth him and others just reflecting on the full extent of the damage and the nature of the damage that has been done by that particular episode because we are seeing already an unpicking of land that has been managed in a way that was beneficial for nature sometimes for decades.
And farmers have found themselves overnight with massive holes in their budget. And it's not simply tenable for any of us now to turn around to them and say well what's going to happen next to say well it's okay just trust Defra they'll come up with something in the next financial year. I think what most I'm pretty sure what most farmers would say if you turned around to them and said that. So the real impact is the nail another nail in the coffin of financial investor confidence in the industry. And it comes at a time when this really is something of a perfect storm for British farming.
We've seen the price spike in input costs from earlier in the year as a consequence of what was happening in the Straits of Hormuz particularly in relation to urea for the production of fertiliser and for diesel. The Food and Drink Federation told the select committee in May that that would feel take another ten months to feed through into price inflation so we've still got the worst of that to come in the new year. Since then we have had a long hot summer where many of our arable farmers have been through the third bad harvest in succession with yields down many of them in fact let us not forget having chosen not to plant in the spring in the first place because it was made more economic sense actually just to sell the fertiliser and not plant the seed.
For the usual sources of replacements at time of a bad harvest in continental Europe, they are going through exactly the same things as we are at the moment. Our livestock farms are already feeding winter forage because they've not had the grass available for their cattle and for their sheep. Not parenthetically I would say in Orkney, where the problem we have with our winter forage is getting it off the fields at the moment after a long wet summer. The red meat sector, our livestock numbers continue to decline in a way that now risks threatening the critical mass of the industry. That if it were to fall over, we then have a massive ripple effect through the rural economy through the marts, the hauliers, the abattoirs, the vets, the merchants of all sorts.
The chicken and pork sectors are under serious pressure. I had a conversation with Cranswick, one of the biggest operators in the just last week, who told me that between them and I think two sisters, there is something in the region of 1.5 billion pounds of planned investment held up in the planning system. And that in many ways to me just sums up the frustration of the situation in which we find ourselves at the moment. Despite this perfect storm, there are people in every sector of this brilliant industry who continue to want to farm and who continue to want to invest. And really very often, you know, we've spoken about all the different agriculture policies that have an impact on it.
There are policies right across every department of government just about especially in relation to the planning system that could free up the investment opportunities that would generate the growth. The Prime Minister speaks about growth in every postcode. Well, a lot of these postcodes are in farming communities. The rural economy presents a real opportunity to generate the economic growth that we all know that we need. And, you know, for all the downsides that there are in this industry at the moment, I remain optimistic for it.
And for optimistic for one reason only and it's nothing to do with anybody in this chamber or in government. It is because our farmers continue despite everything that happens to them to want to produce food to feed our nation and they are better than almost anybody else in the world at doing it.
Ben Goldsborough
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. I refer the House to my register of members' interest. Obviously we need to talk about the SFI scheme to start off with in this debate and with the conversations that I've had with my farming community, it has been painful. There is no other way of sugaring this issue and I know that the minister is going to be diligently looking at this process going forward. However, I fear that this debate will be focused on the symptoms and not the cause.
The over-application that we have seen is because profitability does not exist within the system of farming. We have so few schemes available which ensure that our farmers can get that profitability back in, that is the problem we need to solve. I would put forward to the House that one of the things that we should look at is trying to take as many financial burdens and also regulatory burdens out of the way of our farming community. One of the things that strikes me is if we look at our Australian colleagues, for example, they set themselves, the Labour government of Australia set themselves a farmgate value of 100 billion dollars by 2030. They have hit it three years in advance.
The reason why is they have the farming resilience fund which they have expanded over recent years, which ensures in those good years that those farmers can put aside a tax-deductible lump sum. I believe that is something that we should be pursuing on a greater level within the United Kingdom, maybe up to 500,000 pounds a year. But I think what we should do different to the Australian cousins of ours is ensure that when you draw down on that scheme, if you're drawing down on that scheme for reservoirs, for example, for new silos and grain stores and also investment into your livestock, that should remain tax-deductible.
That I estimate would be a cost of around about 100 million pounds to the Treasury. I think that is something that we can show in good faith to our farming community, that we're giving them the leg up and not trying to cut them down. I also believe that changes which my right honorable my honorable friend for South West Norfolk, I gave him a promotion then, my honorable friend for South West Norfolk said in terms of we need to streamline the planning process as well. And it's not just for on-farm reservoirs. We also need to look at the aspect of how we can support that diversification of our farming sector as well.
But this goes bigger than this single issue of what comes through financial issues. We also need to look at we have got the Veterinary Reform Bill coming up as well. And I know the honorable gentleman on the other side of the House, we've had quite a few conversations about this. It cannot just be about domestic animals. We also need to look at how we can support our veterinary practices going forward into the future to again ensure that we can get profitability into the farming sector because if we don't have a secure veterinary sector, it will fall apart very, very quickly.
The other aspect which flows from that is biosecurity. I welcome what the government has done in the last two years in terms of investing into our biosecurity systems. However, there are still issues and concerns that I have, especially when it comes to the Port of Dover. A 27-mile gap until inspection of meat and produce is dangerous. When I was visiting to the agriculture ministry in Australia and speaking to her, there are concerns and issues that they have in terms of the first flight of bird influenza to their country, which they've been able to solve because of the way that they take biosecurity so seriously.
African swine fever is the real concern for us and I would like if the minister could expand in his wind-up remarks what we will be doing on that aspect there. I think going outside of that, we also need to look at our trade arrangements, which is in this motion before us today. Obviously, it raises the Australian and New Zealand trade deal secured by the previous government, which has been disastrous, especially to our upland farmers. But there has been good trade deals secured by this government, for example, the Indian trade deal. I will be honest with the House, I was extremely worried about as a huge sugar beet production area of the United Kingdom that if we had a free-for-all on Indian sugar, that would fundamentally undermine our market.
But the government took the right action and ensured there was a carve-out. And also the government has taken the right action with the US trade deal in terms of giving access to the beef market but not flooding our market. However, I would politely recommend to the government front benches that we should ban Brazilian beef within the UK market. I think as well it's a gesture of goodwill to our European partners who have done exactly the same. And as we are approaching this SPS trade agreement, which will be vitally important to expanding our food sector, that sort of action would be extremely helpful to the UK.
Of course.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
I thank the honorable member. He's making an incredible speech without any notes, super impressive, demonstrating his knowledge in this space. I met with Derbyshire NFU yesterday and one of the things that they were talking about as well as the concerns with the Brazilian beef was how much a consumer can go to the shop and think they're doing the right thing because they're buying something which has got the Union Jack like our proud British label on the front of it. But actually if you turn over the label, you'll find that actually the meat is not from this country, the product is not from this country. Does the honorable member agree with me and the member for oh gosh, South Selby, I hope I've got that right, who's done a huge amount of work on fair labeling, that we should be absolutely doing more in this country to let people know where their food is coming from so that they can make the right decision in buying British?
Ben Goldsborough
My honorable friend gives an extremely impassioned plea against the issue of flag washing that we have within the United Kingdom. And one of my concerns that flows from that is we are getting into a very easy situation of exporting our morality when it comes to food production in the United Kingdom. We cannot continue down this alley of increasing our standards to a certain level where other nations are undermining their standards. All that does is that puts our farming communities into a situation where they cannot fight that race to the bottom. So I'd really appreciate from my honorable friend the minister in his wind-up remarks to expand on, especially with the SPS agreement, what discussions has he had and his colleagues had with our European partners to ensure that when neonicotinoids, for example, are used in Hungary, that there will be an even playing field and also vitally a long transition period between the United Kingdom because we have an issue of black grass.
And if we lose our herbicides within our UK market, that will harm our yields hugely. In conclusion, this debate today looks at the symptoms, not the causes. And I really urge the minister in his wind-up remarks to explain what we're going to do to fix the underlying profitability issues.
Speaker 248
John Lamont, after which we'll drop to four minutes after John Lamont.
John Lamont
Thank you very much. I'm very pleased to be able to speak in this important debate. For many parts of my constituency in the Scottish Borders, farming is not just part of the local economy, it is the backbone of the communities I represent. Across the Scottish Borders, farming families produce the food we eat, they look after the countryside, and they keep our towns going. Today they are being squeezed from both ends by a Labour government here at Westminster and an SNP government in Edinburgh.
Now let me be clear from the outset, the Sustainable Farming Incentive applies only to England. Farm support is devolved and farmers in my constituency could not apply for it. But how a government treats farmers in one part of the country reveals a great deal about how it regards farmers everywhere. And in the two issues that hit every farm in the United Kingdom, the family farm tax and the fertilizer tax, Borders farmers are being hit just as hard as farmers here in England. On SFI, the facts speak for themselves.
In March 2025, ministers shut the scheme overnight without warning. Then, after more than a year of uncertainty, the new application window opened at 10 o'clock on the 22nd of September. By 4 o'clock that afternoon, the entire budget, around a quarter of a billion pounds, was gone. Thousands of farmers lost out, including around 12,500 who already had agreements in place. Months of preparation, advisors' fees and business plans wasted in just under six hours.
Farmers cannot run their businesses around a government lottery. Decisions on cropping, stocking and investment are taken years in advance, not between 10 in the morning and 4 in the afternoon. Madam Deputy Speaker, this Labour government's record on farming has been appalling. They created one of the biggest threats facing family farms in recent years with the family farm tax. Even after last December's partial climbdown, which raised the threshold to 2.5 million pounds, farms above that level, including many in my own constituency, still face an effective 20% inheritance tax bills.
Farmers are asset-rich and cash-poor. The value of their land does not pay a tax bill, selling the land does. Families in my constituency are still asking whether they will be able to hand the family farm on to the next generation. A Conservative government will restore agricultural property relief and business property relief in full. Madam Deputy Speaker, farmers in Scotland are being let down by the SNP too.
Just last week, NFU Scotland warned that the agricultural support budget, around 677 million pounds a year, has lost some 20% of its purchasing power since 2014. The union is calling for an increase of around 183 million pounds in the next Scottish budget. NFU Scotland has also made clear a budget that has been eaten away by inflation is simply not good enough. Farmers in the borders are sick of consultations and complicated new frameworks being dished out by Holyrood. They need a properly funded scheme that backs food production, encourages investment, and lets their businesses make a profit.
Now, that brings me to Labour's fertilizer tax. From January, the carbon border adjustment mechanism, known as CBAM, will impose a new charge on imported fertilizer. Now, some have suggested during this debate already that a carbon the border carbon mechanism was first proposed under a Conservative government. Its purpose, though, was was to stop British the British industry being undercut by high carbon imports. But there is no British ammonia industry left to protect.
Yes, absolutely.
John Cooper
I thank my honorable friend for giving way on this point. And he and I were in the the committee that discussed this carbon border mechanism. And I wonder if he, like me, shared surprise that the government didn't seem to realize it was going to affect fertilizer. There was much focus on cement, there was much focus on steel. It seemed to come as a shock to them that it was going to put as much as 70 and 80 pounds on a ton of fertilizer.
John Lamont
My honorable friend is absolutely right. I mean, the Labour government didn't seem to understand, the Labour minister didn't seem to understand the impact it was going to have. I was even more shocked that the Liberal Democrats decided not to vote against this proposal, unlike the members on this side. But as I was saying earlier, the ammonia or fertilizer depends on is now just about all imported. So for farmers, this is not about protection, it's simply a further tax on growing food.
Now, as NFU has warned, food grown overseas with exactly the same fertilizer will come into this country without paying this tax. British farmers will be put at a disadvantage in their own market by their own government. This tax will hit every farm in the United Kingdom, including the farms of the Scottish borders, the SFI never reached. Now, the Conservatives, as we've heard already, tried to stop this fertilizer tax. But where were the Liberal Democrats?
Sitting on the fence. Now, I challenged the honorable member for South Cambridgeshire, who I don't think is in her place, but was on the committee that was considering this regulation last week. She accepted their were concerns about this uncertainty and the additional cost. Yet the Liberal Democrats, when it came to the vote, when it came to the vote, Madam Deputy Speaker, they sat on their hands. They refused to oppose this measure imposing this additional tax on our farmers.
Speaker 251
The honorable member's had his had his time to give his say, but he refused to do with this. The Liberal Democrats have had their say, but have refused to justify why they failed to stand up with the farmers to try to stop this.
John Lamont
Today's motion, the Lib Dem motion, now says that farmers are deeply concerned about the impact of CBAM and fertilizer cost. Too right they are. And I welcome the Liberal Democrats' late conversion. But noting concerns in a motion is no substitute to standing up for farmers when it counts, and that is when we vote. The party that tells farmers it's on their side on one on one hand, then doesn't stand up to stop these extra costs and just walks away.
You cannot champion farmers in this chamber and then abandon them when the vote comes.
Josh Newbury
Order. Four minutes speaking limit. Josh Newbury.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Farmers should be able to make a decent living producing excellent food while being properly rewarded for stewarding the land on which we all depend. And those things should not be in competition with one another.
Farming sits at the heart of our rural economy, our national security, and Britain's identity. Farmers put in incredibly long hours, often with no respite. They carry considerable financial risk and take decisions that can affect their family's livelihood for generations. This has been an exceptionally hard year, with drought and fertilizer and fuel costs driven up by the war in Iran, which has compounded all of that. The government has offered some respite through flexibilities in ELMS agreements, 15 million for on-farm reservoirs, a cut to duty on red diesel and an extra 70 million for this year's sustainable farming incentive.
The SFI supports farming in harmony with nature from enriching soils to one of my loves, supporting our wonderful farmland birds. I want to first share a hopeful, positive story from my constituency. The Oaktree Farm smallholding started a few years ago by Sarah and Jay Taylor just outside Slitting Mill near Rugeley, secured funding in the first SFI 26 window. They are excited new entrants and plan to plant fruit trees and establish new hedgerows. I had the chance to visit recently and their love of their animals and the brilliant relationships they have with their loyal customers was so uplifting.
We should remember that the first window did succeed in allowing farms like Sarah and Jay's to get in for the first time. There are, however, many lessons to learn. After closing within six hours, the second 233 million pound SFI 26 window demonstrates the sheer level of demand from farmers wanting to participate, but also, let's be frank, desperately needing government support to tide them over after a series of torrid growing seasons. The window opened at 10:00 AM. For many farmers, that is well into the working day.
Many will have been tending livestock or out in the field, so the reality that the timing and IT system were unnecessary barriers needs to be faced up to. I welcome the government's commitment to reopen SFI as early as possible in 2027 and to scrap the first-come, first-served approach. I hope ministers will consider assessing applications on clear criteria including environmental benefits, value for money, and fair access. As the chair of the Public Sector Efficiency APPG, I would be keen to be involved in those discussions alongside of course the sector itself, which needs to be heard first and foremost. Yes, I'll give way.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Does he agree with me that one thing the government could do to make the SFI system more accessible to farmers is by publishing a timetable of when things will open well in advance and circulating that so farmers can be ready to apply when the next rounds come around?
Josh Newbury
I agree with my honorable friend. I wonder if there was a hesitance to kind of create too much demand on the pretty inadequate IT system in one go, but the reality is that will always be the case as long as people know the date. So I do think that we should have much further notice and it should really take account of the realities of farming, which I'm afraid this year's scheme didn't. A farmer should not have to be the quickest with a keyboard and a mouse to secure vital cash for margins or pastures. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater when it comes to SFI, but we also mustn't shy away from asking fundamental questions about its structure and communication.
I won't at this stage, I'm afraid, because I know many of the Liberal Democrat colleagues want to get in. I also want to raise the wider contribution that farmers make to rural communities. During severe weather, they are often the first to spring into action. I admire the example set by the last Welsh Labour government in financially recognizing what farmers do for our communities, particularly during heavy snow, fires, or other emergencies. As we set out to improve the SFI, I hope we will place a greater emphasis on measures that promote resilience to extreme weather and maybe even flag those to farmers in badly affected parts of the country.
There are also other measures the government could take to support farms of all shapes and sizes ahead of SFI 27, like the Treasury-backed loans the National Farmers Union is calling for in next week's budget. I hope that the Defra team is making the case for rapid, flexible assistance given the myriad of pressures that have come this year.
But I am optimistic, Madam Deputy Speaker, for the future of British farming because of the ingenuity, determination, and passion of the people who work in it, who I will continue to listen to and champion. We will have our differences in this place, but there is, I believe, a consensus in the House on much of what needs to happen to support our brilliant British farmers. I hope that that is what we can bear in mind in the months ahead, because they are getting on with their job, and it's time for us to find common ground so we can get on with ours. Thank you.
Clare Rachel Gilmour
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm pleased to be speaking in my party's opposition day debate. I am less pleased about the context in which it takes place. Both Conservative and Labour governments have failed to deliver an effective post-Brexit farm payment system. The consequences have been severe, not only for the viability of British farms, but ultimately for our nation's food security.
The most recent example is the farce of SFI window two. After almost a year without access to sustainable farming incentive, farmers were given little warning of its return, only for the scheme to slam shut in under six hours. A budget of just 233 million was never going to touch the sides. What is most damning, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that this outcome was entirely foreseeable. A first-come, first-served application process combined with inadequate funding was always going to create a scramble.
In that scramble, those with greater resources, more sophisticated systems, and stronger connectivity enjoyed a clear advantage.
Danny Chambers
I thank the honorable friend for giving way. I heard from many farmers in and around Winchester and Hampshire who were desperately applying for this, but most of them had to work during the day, and then by the time they got back, it had closed. And one of them compared it to like trying to get Oasis tickets. Just to touch on what my honorable friend just said, this clearly favors very large businesses who have full-time managers and full-time admin staff, and it puts family firms at a disadvantage when those individual farmers are actually outside working.
Speaker 254
I thank my honorable friend for the comments that he makes. In fact, I was about to comment on the fact that my farmers on Exmoor were immediately put at a disadvantage because they have limited broadband and limited connectivity. And I was indeed contacted by a farming family from West Bagborough who were in complete despair. They made the self-evident point that farmers cannot simply abandon a working day at a moment's notice and spend hours online desperately trying to secure support before the window closes. Madam Deputy Speaker, farmers have endured a perfect storm: inheritance tax, soaring energy costs, bluetongue, drought, and now this latest SFI debacle.
As if farmers' trust in this government was not already on the floor, this recent episode has undermined whatever scintilla of trust remained. Once again, farmers have been left with the impression that Whitehall neither understands nor appreciates the realities of farming. What remains particularly frustrating is the ongoing lack of certainty. Farmers still do not know the shape of SFI 27. What will it contain, when will it begin, or what level of support will it provide?
The farmers of Tiverton and Minehead are not interested in hearing about jam tomorrow. They need to know what support will be available today.
Adrian Philip Ramsay
I thank the honorable lady for this speech that she's making, and I agree with her that it's absolutely crucial that farmers have the confidence that the long-term policy support will be there. And my farmers in Waveney Valley tell me they want to invest in measures that support natural flood management, that restore nature such as new hedgerows, and that improve soil health.
These are critical for food security. Does she agree with me that the debacle we've seen over window two shows the level of interest there is and that far more funding is needed in the SFI funding pot?
Clare Rachel Gilmour
I wholeheartedly agree with that. In fact, it was something that we discussed at the Public Accounts Committee just last week. Farmers cannot operate in the dark. They need certainty. Farming is not a short-term enterprise.
Speaker 254
Decisions taken today affect planting, stocking, investment and land management years into the future. On the Public Accounts Committee last week, we examined the resilience of the UK's food supply chain to disruption. It reinforced something that many of us have long argued: food security is national security. As co-chair of the Farming APPG, I heard the same message in our meeting with representatives from across the sector on Monday. That is why it should never be lost on us that farmers are on the front line of climate change.
They see changing weather patterns, degraded soils and seasonal disruption before anyone else. The woodlands, the wetlands and the grasslands they manage are essential to our biodiversity and natural environment. Madam Deputy Speaker, farmers are famously stoic and resilient. Yet even the strongest shoulders can only carry so much. The financial pressures, the uncertainty, the long days, the drought, the extreme heat, bluetongue and now the recent SFI disappointment have combined into an overwhelming burden for many.
Clare Rachel Gilmour
For some, that burden has led them to take their own lives. So I will conclude with a simple message to the farmers of Tiverton and Minehead: I am with you. What my farmers, Madam Deputy Speaker, want to know and I want to know is whether this Labour government is with them.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Madam Deputy Speaker, being honest, I'm not a big fan of opposition day debates in Parliament. I made my discomfort clear in a debate on farming in 2024 when I put the government on notice of my intention to vote against the APR budget measure. But that evening, as the news that I'd voted against the official opposition's motion was circulated on social media, a motion which quite rightly called for the government to halt its planned changes to APR but also appeared to claim that the last Conservative government was the greatest gift to farming since Jethro Tull's seed drill, I noted the way my vote was being reported by members on the benches opposite. One said I'd misled the chamber and I voted to impose the family farm tax. Now, as all members know, opposition day motions do not enact change.
They're expressions of opinion, not instruments that alter policy or law, or as Erskine May says, they do not bind the government. Last week was the same. In a debate where the Conservatives tried out their new theory that sticking the word family in front of a tax makes it unpalatable and right for scrapping, I objected to the idea that a 175 million pound penthouse flat could be exempt from tax. For this, I was accused by Conservatives on social media of nitpicking, being spineless and also of toadying to get my whip back, which I've had back, by the way. The post was accompanied by a meme that only made reference to the family farms.
I'd like to be explicit. I want to see the end to the family farm tax and I urge the Chancellor to do so in the budget. But I don't believe the plight of my farmers should be conflated and used by politicians who want to give tax breaks to the mega-rich. Now, let me turn my attention to today's word salad. I like tomatoes and I agree that APR changes should be scrapped.
I like olives and I agree that SFI has been a disaster. Madam Deputy Speaker, lots of members like olives, even on these benches. The end of universal payments seems like a missed opportunity. Farmers are perfectly candid that many in the industry that receive the basic payment were doing very little for it, but I'm increasingly of the view that a universal offer linked to delivering key public goods as a baseline with a top-up ELM-style offer would be preferable. It would give all farmers a chance and provide a buffer that they may rely on when times are hard.
The farmers I've engaged with since my election have described how they take risks with every investment decision. Bad weather or market conditions can change and do change. A universal payment could not only provide a cushion but also help reassure those considering an investment that they are safe to do so. Now, last week I read an article in the FT. The article described issues faced by some farmers accessing SFI.
Quotes one Cambridge farmer saying, "I will literally take a plough to everything and we will have to go back to farming more intensively than the 1950s." It worries me we may see a position where farmers reaching the end of existing schemes simply plough up the good work they've done and look for what is commercially best for them. I believe a universal offer could, if implemented properly, prevent this from happening. So I don't object to everything in this salad and I'm quite pleased it's been served, but everyone has something they don't want in a salad. It's fennel, just in case you were wondering, Madam Deputy Speaker.
But in the case of this motion, it's the Liberal Democrats' inclusion of a commitment of an additional one billion a year to fund ELMs. It sounds tasty, but having sat through a large number of debates in this House, I know at the heart of their budget plans is their claim that re-entering Europe would pay for everything. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's as silly as claiming we could pay using lithium mined on Mars. Its presence does not preclude the fact that there's one hell of a journey before we get there. These motions are a con, a word salad full of things that members across the House love, but ultimately containing an ingredient which makes them only edible to the author.
Speaker 261
Mr. Gausmel, changing your seating in the chamber does not mean I cannot hear or see you. Wendy Chamberlain.
Wendy Chamberlain
Madam Deputy Speaker, agriculture accounts for around 15% of economic activity in my constituency of North East Fife, from the Howe, the breadbasket of Fife, to the coastal farms of the East Neuk and down towards Leven, as well as the banks of the Tay. Despite its relative proximity to the central belt of Scotland, it is very much a rural constituency. It hosts both single-family farms but also larger producers such as Kettle Produce, specialists in prepared vegetables for major retailers, and Quaker Oats in Cupar, which is supplied by arable farmers across the area. And I regularly visit and engage with people across the sector in North East Fife. And I want to take a minute, Madam Deputy Speaker, to remember the Earl of Lindsay, lately of the other place, who passed away earlier this month and was a constituent of mine.
A Fife farmer, landscape gardener and conservationist, and also a Scotland Office minister under John Major for the three Fs: farming, fishing and forestry, as well as a dedicated person in the industry post-1997. My thoughts are with his widow Diana and family at this time. And I commend the local Mid Scotland and Fife NFUS for organising regular sessions with MPs and MSPs to keep us up to date. And just last week I was at Balbirnie Home Farms learning about their low-input farming approach. And before our recent recess I visited South Straiton Farm in Balmullo, meeting with Duncan Pickard.
He was very keen that I could say in this chamber I had met a happy farmer, and now I have. But the reality is that farming is in many respects a precarious endeavour and for some it is increasingly hard to make the numbers work.
Back in 2024, I secured a Westminster Hall debate on the barriers farmers face in accessing Universal Credit. It should concern us all that the very people who put the food on our tables are often forced to rely on a welfare system that seems stacked against them. I look forward to the Timms report with interest, having engaged with him. If anything, the challenges facing farmers have become more acute. And I would say to the shadow minister that we both stood outside Parliament during farmer protests with signs saying "Family Farm Tax", and I think we all knew what we meant: both the changes to inheritance tax as well as the BPR changes.
There's no doubt that those things have left families worrying about the future of their businesses. I also want to highlight the recruitment of seasonal workers, which is badly needed to harvest the excellent produce grown in North East Fife. And I would like assurances from the minister that the seasonal agricultural worker scheme will extend beyond 2029. Farmers cannot invest in the future if they do not have certainty that they will have the workforce that they need to get food out of the fields now. Now, in Scotland, we have the Future Farming Investment Scheme, which is intended to provide certainty for farmers through to 2030, but Scottish ministers do need to set out how the proposed four-tier system will deliver a fair, accessible, and adequately funded assistance.
Yes, it should reward positive action on nature restoration and climate resilience; that matters, of course, but it is vital that it sustains food production, rural livelihoods, and smaller or remote farming businesses. Farmers across my constituency continue to face significant financial pressures, and it's clear that both the UK and Scottish governments need to do more. And sometimes, frankly, Madam Deputy Speaker, that means getting out of the way and encouraging innovation and expertise to develop organically. I haven't met a farmer yet who doesn't care about the land and the animals they rear, or is unaware of their role in mitigating against climate change. And on that note, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to invite everybody in this chamber at the conclusion of the debate to attend the 25th anniversary of the Voluntary Initiative, which meets in the Churchill Room this evening.
James William Naish
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I refer colleagues to my register of interests. When the Labour Rural Research Group polled rural voters in the summer of 2025, 75% of them told us that their communities had been neglected over the past 15 years. Over half, 51.3%, said that agriculture and the rural economy should get more government spending, a higher share than for any priority except the NHS. People really do care about this agenda, and it is important that we remember that on these benches. There is no doubt that there was exceptional demand for SFI 26, which demonstrates farmers' desire to invest in their soils, hedgerows, crops, and wildlife.
It's true to say that this was partly anticipated, which is why the government allocated an additional 20 million pounds in window two, on top of the 50 million pounds announced by the Prime Minister in August. I am pleased that through this scheme, we now have nearly 1 billion pounds of investment in nature-friendly farming as part of the 11.8 billion in funding for sustainable farming in this Parliament. The good news is that SFI 26 was allocated; the Tories didn't manage this. But farmers had been preparing for months, and some were left partway through applications that could not be completed. The government has acknowledged that too many farmers who hoped for an agreement have been left disappointed, and I welcome that acknowledgement.
But acknowledging a problem is where fixing it must begin, and we need to very quickly see the co-design of a new system. We need to see the IT systems at the Rural Payments Agency reformed, and we need to see a much clearer and more transparent roadmap on future application timelines. I do agree with part of the motion which covers some of the failings of the previous government.
The motion regrets the previous government's decision to design SFI on a first-come, first-served basis. It regrets the trade deals with Australia and New Zealand. And it's true that the Conservatives left a transition that was half-built and half-funded. And on trade, the former Secretary of State, Michael Gove, has admitted that they negotiated poorly with Australia and New Zealand. But there are therefore serious questions that need answering ahead of next year's scheme.
Firstly, the NFU has said that any decrease in income jeopardises future business planning. So when will Defra commit to a date for SFI 27? There is also potentially that gap that has been mentioned earlier today. Around 520 million pounds, sorry, 520 million pounds of existing agreements are potentially due to expire. Is that accurate in the Minister's view?
And if so, what is the government doing about it? Thirdly, I would like clarity on the timing for those whose applications failed because of the system's technical problems. And fourthly, specifically on horticulture and smaller farms. SFI must work for market gardens and smaller growers. And three-hectare minimum for SFI 26 shuts some of them out altogether.
Can that be reconsidered?
Alexander Carmichael
I agree with everything he's saying about it. But one other thing that we neglect at our peril is the sheer extra cost of administration of SFI compared to BPS. Baroness Batters had quite remarkable figures on that in her report. To pick up the point from his honourable friend about a more universal system, surely one of the advantages of that would be to, it would hardwire food production and it would be much more cheap to administer.
James William Naish
Thanks for that intervention and obviously he speaks from a point of expertise. And he's right that the more complicated you make a system, the more expensive it is to administer. And I know that ministers are looking into how a non-first-come, first-served system might work. And there are risks with it and we should acknowledge that in this place. It's not a silver bullet by any stretch of the imagination.
I did notice in the Lib Dem spokesman's contribution today that he didn't, I think, mention the word profitability. And I really think that is an essential point in any debate on farming. Baroness Batters' farming profitability review notes that the farming budget in England has hovered around that 2.4 billion pound figure since 2007, but that input costs are forecast to be 30% higher this year than in 2020. So I think we need to be really clear about what the essential mission is for farming. It's a countryside where farms are less dependent on subsidy and scheme windows and they're more independent, more resilient, more sustainable for people, for profit and for our planet.
That is the thread that ran through the Batters review and it's also the thread that ran through the Labour Rural Research Group's report on the rural economy.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
I thank the honourable member for giving way. When he's talking about recommendations for SFI going forward, when I met with Derbyshire NFU yesterday, and I'm sorry I don't have the notes in front of me to recollect the figure, but there was some concern over a proportion of SFI that wasn't accounted for. One of the key challenges they said was that when we were part of the EU, there had to be real clarity on what money was getting spent where, whereas now finding it's much harder to get transparency on moneys that have been invested. And I wonder if the honourable gentleman would agree with me that that might also be a recommendation to government.
James William Naish
There's a lot of muttering coming from opposite so I'm sure the minister heard heard that point. And I will will come to a conclusion because I know there are plenty of people wanting to speak. We should be clear, we do need to fix the SFI system and I'm pleased that the government has made indications about how it plans to do that. We must end first come first served so that the system works more fairly. But we also must collectively recognize that we have to do better on that real issue of profitability.
Absolutely.
I welcome the work that the government has done to date, but we must surely accelerate the implementation of the Batters profitability review and I hope that collectively across this house we can work to put those points into practice.
Sarah Gibson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Wiltshire, farming is at the heart of our rural economy, our landscape and our community. Farmers produce not just the food on our tables but they support local jobs and businesses and they play a crucial role in protecting and restoring the natural environment. But farmers in Wiltshire are not asking for special treatment. They are merely asking for the certainty that every business needs.
I spoke recently to Anna, a livestock vet in my constituency who works with farmers across Wiltshire and she put the problem very simply. Farming businesses plan years ahead, not months ahead. And when support schemes change without warning, farmers can't make decisions about the environmental improvements because they simply don't know what resources they will have available. And Madam Deputy Speaker, Wiltshire's mixed agricultural landscape, which combines arable farming, dairy and livestock business is exactly the sort of environment where sustainable farming practices thrive. However, if a farm does not know what support will be available, they cannot confidently plan for the future.
And in Wiltshire we have already seen what can be achieved when farmers support work alongside nature. The Bremhill Vale Farmers Group brings together 50 farms covering 5,000 hectares between Chippenham, Calne and Lyneham. And they work with the Environment Agency and Wiltshire Wildlife Trust. And those farmers are working to improve water quality, reduce flood risk and natural management. But they know that productivity and being productive can work alongside environmental stewardship, but only with the right tailored support.
But I'd like to just raise a couple of other things as well as the SFI debacle that are affecting my farmers. One of them is things like the rigidity around the machinery grants that government application windows are so tight. The other was to do with how complex and difficult the guidance can be. Even veterinary professionals who deal with these programs on a regular basis struggle to navigate the guidance and the application program. With a local vet, I looked through the welfare pathway website recently.
I found the forms difficult to locate, the timelines were unclear and minor administrative errors meant that you lost access to support entirely. And if the experts struggle to navigate the system, ministers should ask themselves how easy these are and how accessible they are for a busy family farm. So Wiltshire's farmers are ready to play their part. They deserve a government that's ready to play its part too. So I have two questions for the minister.
Can the minister tell those farmers in my constituency of Chippenham today what assurance he can give when they commit to long-term environmental improvements, is this government willing to provide the long-term funding certainty they need to support their work that they are doing?
And will the Minister commit to publishing a clear single-page timeline that sets out the application windows, the eligibility criteria and the payment timelines for the farming schemes well in advance so that farmers can make the long-term business decisions that modern agriculture requires? Thank you.
Speaker 268
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, I think this is a really important debate about support for our farmers and I was absolutely delighted a few weeks ago that I was able to go and speak to the Towcester Young Farmers. And that was a room full of our best and our brightest, our custodians for the future. And we talk about supporting them, which I want to, but I also just want to recognize the support that they already at their young age give back to us, whether that is Rosie Birch, who ran a grueling 50k ultramarathon in aid of Macmillan Cancer, or the fact that the young farmers are organizing their charity Halloween tractor run on the 1st of November to raise money for the Cynthia Spencer Hospice. They give so much back to our community already and I think that is very important we recognize that.
But that is why I am so hurt and saddened that in the face of such optimism from this younger generation, they are we are having to fight so hard against the government to make them realize the impact of the choices that this government has made. We've already rehearsed the family farm tax, the family business tax, the issues with SFI, the increase in National Insurance contributions, the fertilizer tax. Now, rather, Madam Deputy Speaker, than speaking all about as the Prime Minister is rejoining the EU or EU options on the table or electoral reform, why not prioritize these decisions that can make a massive difference to our farmers here and now? And I urge the Minister to please take this message back to the Prime Minister that this is what should be focused on. Because this, as we said, for farming is a vocation and it needs long-term planning and they need a certainty for the future.
Now, the PM, even in Prime Minister's Questions today, talked about the EU summit bringing a better deal for farmers, but the proof ultimately will be in the pudding. Now, we've had zero details about the upcoming SPS agreement. Numerous times we have asked the Minister, the relevant Minister, to come before the EFRA Select Committee to answer questions and this has been refused on numerous occasions. Now, this is very important about this SPS agreement because we will be moving potentially to a system of dynamic alignment. Now, that will have a massive impact.
We are well ahead in this country on matters like precision breeding and our animal welfare standards and I think and we all want to understand exactly what will this deal mean and I don't think it is right that we cannot be given the full scrutiny before this comes around. And the market is also talking about the importance of implementation periods. Our farmers need to know about what is happening and when. So I again urge the Minister, please, will we have some more transparency on this future SPS agreement? And forgive me if I am slightly concerned about these debates given they have sold out on our fishing rights and we couldn't even agree safe funding.
Now, I do want to though again go to finish on a more positive point. Whilst many farmers are struggling against the government's decisions and they are nonetheless very industrious and they want to come up with different measures so that they can help support themselves. And one very good measure, which I think we can all agree on and support, is that of Ben Aveling of Radmore Farm in my constituency, who is trying to encourage supporting farmers by bringing back the Sunday roast. It is an idea of making sure that we all can sit together to buy British products and chat as a family and I think that should be wholeheartedly supported. So if I can final and one element, please, can we recognize that?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Agriculture also has enormous economic potential. The industry supports 334,000 jobs in the agricultural labor force alone and sits at the center of the wider agri-food industry worth more than 153 billion pounds. Agriculture also supports many other industries, such as feed, energy, fertilizer, chemicals, logistics, and professional services with 20.9 billion pounds of intermediate inputs. Yet, the sector seems to be treated as a luxury rather than something totally essential to everything that we need in our country to succeed. And they don't get the attention and consistent and coherent support from government that they deserve.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Food, good land stewardship for nature and environment protection and indeed our enjoyment are not luxuries, they are essentials.
Now, even before the latest sustainable farming incentive farce, from speaking with farmers in my Oxfordshire constituency, they face so many challenges and headwinds. Now, it's rather concerning that the Conservatives seem to be suffering from more amnesia than in Christopher Nolan's Memento, given their role in many of those problems. Agricultural and business property tax relief changes by the current Labour government, the uncertainty and impact of Brexit, trade deals based on proving the so-called benefits of Brexit no matter the impact on our farmers, constantly changing government incentive and payment regimes. And of course now the impact of recent worldwide inflation on fertilizer prices and equipment costs and in fuel, now made even worse as a result of Trump's idiotic Middle East war. Labor shortages also as a result of Brexit, pressures from the supply chain driving down prices for produce, and the worsening impact of climate change, which we have seen particularly gravely this year.
I'll give way to my honorable friend.
Ben Maguire
I thank my honorable friend for giving way and I'd just like to add one more thing to that list of Conservative disasters, which is the underspending of the farming budget by more than 350 million pounds, which has led to this disgraceful situation where the SFI has had a huge demand because our farmers are quite literally scared that will happen again. Does my honorable friend join me in urging the minister to commit today that the budget won't be underspent by this government?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank my honorable friend for his intervention and I do join him in calling for that and it was a shame that that too was missing from the Conservative spokesperson's speech. Now, in designing sustainable finance initiative and the system for allocating it, it would appear the ministers and officials concerned may have been spending too much time here in Parliament, where members wanting to get slots for some types of bills have to become proficient in efficient use of Microsoft Outlook. That is similar to the bidding contest for SFI, which becomes as much about mastering process, IT savviness, and a race against the clock than about the substance. This is a particular problem for smaller farms, where farmers will often have to be out on their land and not sat at their computer at a time convenient for Defra rather than for them.
Will my honorable friend give way?
I give way to my honorable friend.
Speaker 274
I'm very grateful to my honorable friend from Oxfordshire for giving way. He's making a good case about the shortcomings of the SFI system. But speaking to one of my farmers this week, he told me that he is facing a choice between seeking SFI for direct drilling and seeking SFI for preserving waterways by having a grass verge before we get to the waterway. Would he agree with me that pitting carbon sequestration against the protection of our waterways from nitrate is not a good way to proceed and we should instead be supporting both of these environmental objectives through the allocation of the SFI funds in future rounds?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank my honorable friend for his intervention. He's clearly been listening carefully to farmers in his constituency and makes some very strong points. Now, the government has said that SFI will be offered again in 2027 and that it will work with farming organizations on potential changes to the scheme. However, a timetable, budget, and detailed arrangements for SFI 2027 have yet to be announced. As well as ending the bidding war process for SFI, it needs to move beyond an annual settlement.
Investment in farms and agriculture isn't an annual exercise. It is a multi-year and often multi-decade labor of love requiring hard work, forward planning, and long-term thinking. This is why the government should look at some good practice they have implemented elsewhere by moving to multi-year local government funding settlements and embrace the same approach for SFI. Now, the government has an opportunity in part to make amends in the forthcoming budget and I hope that it is one that they will seize. Now, there are many requests from the sector for the budget and I'm just going to talk three briefly so I don't take up too much time.
One is to increase the annual investment allowance AIA to at least 5 million pounds and extend its scope to include assets qualifying for the structures and buildings allowance. This would support longer-term investments in efficiency and productivity improvements including with regards to energy and water usage. The annual investment allowance allows businesses to reduce their tax bill by deducting the full cost of qualifying purchases plant and machinery from their profits. Currently such buildings and fixed structures do not qualify for AIA and instead generally qualify for the structures and buildings allowance which provides relief at 3% per annum on qualifying expenditure. This does not incentivize the kind of investment in farm buildings when other forms of investment are relieved at a much faster rate.
Similar reliefs are offered in competitor countries. For example in Ireland such farm buildings can be written off over a period of seven years and in the USA 100% relief is currently available for five-year periods. The second is our request regarding what we've already said about the approach to the carbon border adjustment mechanism introduction. The National Farmers Union estimates that fertilizer inclusion in UK CBAM will add up to 70 pounds per metric ton in extra costs. And finally the government could provide or underwrite the capital required for a temporary program of interest-free farm crisis loans.
This would really help the sector as they're suffering from current crises to do with inflation. It could be delivered through accredited commercial lenders and targeted at viable agricultural businesses that are suffering temporary cash flow pressure because of the current situation. So I hope that the government will listen to some of those requests and use the budget to help our farmers and get SFI in a much better state for 2027.
Lee Dillon
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Since being elected I have stood up for my farmers. We have been in fields together we've marched together and we've lobbied together and today they stand with me. I'm proud that our party has used our opposition day debate to hold the government to account for the latest shambles which follows on from last year's shambles too. It really does seem that lessons have not been learned.
Minister my farmers cannot speak in this chamber but I can and I want to make their voices heard and their verdict is blunt. Tim Hayward who manages 3,000 acre farm in South Fawley for over a decade described SFI as flawed and not fit for purpose popular only because the sector is in such a dire circumstance that many farms have to embrace it to survive. His countryside stewardship agreement expires at the end of the year and despite trying to secure a new SFI agreement he has received no support. He faces the prospect of putting precious pockets of land habitats that have taken years to establish back into production. James another experienced West Berkshire farmer had an expiring SFI agreement and costed alternative business plans.
As he put it I now regard the government as an unreliable trading partner. George Brown a farmer who farms Priors Farm and is the chairman of the British Farming Union told me the six-hour window was simply impossible for a family farm to prepare for let alone submit the precise land mapping rotational forecasting and multi-layered action planning and application needs. With the introduction of the family farm tax and the sudden closure of FSI in 2025 farmers feel that the rural communities they represent are not understood. Farmers play a crucial role in rural life from environmental stewardship to hosting community events that reduce isolation clearing roads of snow in the dark winter months or lifting a villager's car from a country ditch. They are the backbone of rural communities.
If we do not back our farmers, we are not backing rural life. Now, the farming roadmap rightly attempts to provide clarity, but after September's mess, distrust is as strong as ever. And nor can we look to the party on my right for inspiration. You may turn up in my seat for photo ops with farmers, but you have never apologized to them. Now, I recognize that this government inherited serious problems, but chaotic windows and abrupt closures have compounded them.
I welcome the minister's commitment to work with the NFU and move away from a first-come, first-served basis. So in concluding, can I ask the minister three things. First, publish a clear timescale. As George Brown put it, the government created a funding race that left us all wondering when the starting gun would actually fire. If the next window is to be different, open SFI 27 early, with a phased arrangement starting on the first of April, so that those who diligently prepared but were shut out get a fair second chance.
Second, make sure that the budget matches the number of agreements ending. More than 21,000 farm businesses have environmental agreements ending by March, and only around 8,800 have applied to SFI 26, so what transitional support will the government provide to close that gap? And third, use next week's budget as a clear injection of support. Back the Liberal Democrats' call for an extra 1 billion a year for farming. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government have said it's determined to rebuild trust across rural communities.
If it takes these steps, it can mark a turning point and give the custodians of our countryside the confidence and clarity they desperately need.
Speaker 276
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm pleased that the Liberal Democrats are leading on the front for our rural communities by bringing forward this debate today. Norfolk is a rural county and a farming county. It's also a county right at the forefront of the climate and nature emergency, right along our coastline, the fastest eroding in Northwest Europe. We see residents facing the loss of their homes and villages facing the loss of their identity as rising sea levels increase the speed of erosion in villages like Happisburgh and Trimingham.
And our precious natural environment with rare chalk streams and species found nowhere else in the country is at risk of collapse without action on the emergency facing them. One of our strongest allies in tackling the climate emergency is farming. And that's why the SFI is so important. Farmers are custodians of the natural environment. They care for it.
Speaker 277
They look after it and they will pass it on to generations after them. They want our natural environment to be protected and our climate to remain stable. Not just for the greater good, but because it's vital to keep their farms viable. The importance of this scheme cannot be overstated. It's a crucial part of keeping our rural environments healthy and protected and enabling farmers to do so too.
Speaker 278
How on earth then can it be right that the process for securing this funding was such a catastrophe? A mad rush, online queuing, effectively a sell-out event in a matter of hours. Now, I know that the Prime Minister is keen on Manchesterism for the whole country, I don't think my farmers need that meant making SFI applications follow the same system as getting Oasis tickets. But this farce speaks to a much deeper issue. I strongly believe that there is a lack of understanding of the workings of rural life and rural communities.
Because it just does not fit neatly into Whitehall's prescribed models or spreadsheets. Securing funding for sustainable land management might make the difference between a farm being able to employ someone to work the land and not. And if that person isn't employed, they won't bring their family to the local village to live.
That means perhaps their children don't attend the village school, which then can't make the numbers work within the funding formula. Those young people won't be able to stay and start families themselves, even if we were to tackle the cost of living crisis, which is significantly sharper the further you are from the city. When working-age people can't afford to live and thrive in rural and coastal areas, everybody loses. And as things stand, our communities are as vulnerable to erosion as our coastline. We need powerful representation at the heart of government to stand up for them.
Because just like our natural environment, our rural communities are deeply interconnected. We are an ecosystem. We rely on symbiotic relationships, on food chains, and on a stable environment. Now, when the science of rural life is disregarded and the knock-on effects are ignored, we end up with calamitous decisions like this. So much of this is down to how Whitehall works, or doesn't.
Food security, climate change, coastal erosion and flooding, fine policy, environmental protection, communities, in North Norfolk, all of our affairs are rural. And yet real change on this issue cannot be handled by Defra alone. These are the things that matter to people, to the lives that we lead, and they cut across the silos of government. I firmly believe if we had a better understanding of rural life across Whitehall, then such disasters as we saw with the SFI scheme would just not be allowed to happen. So an urgent, fundamental reassessment of how the state is supposed to work for rural communities is needed, because at the moment, it simply doesn't.
John Cooper
John Cooper, after which we'll drop to three minutes. John Cooper.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Food security is national security is the mantra from the government benches, but the reality, I'm afraid, is that it's much spun and little done. The family farm tax sent a chill through my rural Dumfries and Galloway constituency and underscored yet again the disconnect with this urban-centric government and rural Britain. Now we have the fertilizer tax coming along, and again, like the family farm tax, it's deeply flawed. We had an admission, in fact, that the family farm tax was deeply flawed, and that came from a senior government minister who pressed its case in this House.
Incredible. The price of fuel has been much backslapped today about the cuts to duty for red diesel. That is certainly helpful, but the reality again is that red diesel is up by as much as 60 percent, as an enormous input cost for farmers. It's a big difficulty as well for the fishing sector, and I've asked the fisheries minister if he'll convene a meeting with the fishermen because British boats are afraid to put to sea when French boats are able to access finance from the French government to fish in British waters. Funding, as we've heard from my honorable friend in Scotland, is devolved for farming, for agriculture, but we've also seen in Scotland the SNP government exercising sleight of hand with the agricultural budget.
Money which was intended for farming, supposedly ring-fenced, magically disappeared, only to reappear. That's not good enough, and devolve and forget is the order of the day with this government. We must have more accuracy about what's going on in Scotland because the block grant goes north, the Barnett consequentials go north. This place should have some say in what's going on there. And the debate opened, the Liberal Democrat spokesman, the honorable member for Westmorland and Lonsdale, opened this debate with his usual paean to the EU.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
And of course, the EU funding settlement is changing. The envelope under the Common Agricultural Policy is shrinking, such that farmers in Ireland are protesting about that. And I can assure this House that the farmers in Dumfries and Galloway are in no hurry at all to return to the EU and the idea of a shrinking Common Agricultural Policy. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Helen Morgan.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Three minutes is not a long time to represent over a thousand North Shropshire farmers, many of whom have been in touch with me in the wake of the shambles of the second window of SFI 2026. John, who farms in Whitchurch, was distraught when he contacted me after he was unable to get onto the latest iteration of the scheme. He couldn't apply first thing in the morning because the window wasn't open, and when he returned later on after doing some farming, he found that applications were already closed. Now he's afraid that he will have to remove acres of herbal ley as he no longer has the funds to manage them, and the hedgerows that he preserves around his farm, he told me it would be cheaper to rip them up and put fences in instead.
That's not what we are trying to achieve here. Another family farming in Weston Lullingfields watched the website repeatedly crash as the funding was scooped up, leaving them with nothing. And what's most frustrating to farmers is that everybody could see this disaster coming from a good country mile away. A budget of 233 million for farmers across England was insultingly short of the public funding needed to recognise the hard work and stewardship that our farmers undertake. One farmer said to me, "Why bother going through the pretence?"
The chaos of the first-come-first-served funding allocations disadvantaged small business and family farms. Hard-working farmers cannot afford to take huge chunks out of time out of the day and sit and watch a computer screen that will not load. But this total disregard and failure to understand agricultural life and business wasn't something that started with this government. This year's SFI failure is a direct consequence of the Conservative government's weak attempt to patch up the abrupt removal of basic payment scheme following their botched Brexit deal. They added insult to injury by signing the UK-Australia Free Trade Agreement in 2023, which undercut British farmers, threatening to flood our markets with low-cost imports but offering no protections to ensure that there was a level playing field for our world-leading UK animal welfare standards.
It set a dangerous precedent for future deals, as we've seen under the CPTPP. Farmers have felt increasingly under threat. Every meeting I've had with local farmers centres on how difficult farming has become, including through regular meetings with farmers and NFU members from across North Shropshire and indeed across the whole of Shropshire. At my most recent meeting, held in Ryton-XI-Towns in my constituency, their frustration at the SFI system failure was obvious, but they also raised concerns about upcoming changes to water abstraction licensing. After this summer's devastating drought, which left crops in North Shropshire shrivelled and livestock farmers in a desperate situation with their winter feed, the link between food security and water security is stark.
They raised concerns that the hierarchy of water abstraction will propose prioritising water for data centres over water for food production. In what sort of world is that sensible? So will the Minister confirm that that won't be the case this year? And will he confirm that we won't see a repeat next year of the shambles of the bluetongue issue, the shambles of the SFI issue, and actually take British farming concerns seriously forward?
Charlotte Cane
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The farmers of Ely and East Cambridgeshire fill the bread baskets of England. They also provide really, really good, tasty, healthy vegetables. You'd think, therefore, that we would treat them with respect and try to support them. But one of my farmers told me that the mapping system hadn't, didn't agree with his maps, and he'd been trying to sort that out for some time before the SFI window opened, but having failed, he was therefore unable to put in for the SFI.
So will the Minister undertake to sort out the mapping system so it works for farmers and that they don't find themselves in the situation my farmer was found? Another farmer told me that he and his agent were sitting at the screen trying to get his application in, and eventually the window closed before they'd managed to get the application in. And so what he's asking for is he's asking the Minister to have a proper long-term plan that not only says when the various windows will open, but is also clear and upfront about how much money will be in the various windows. Because if we keep opening the schemes with not even enough money to cover those people who already have environmental schemes, then it's not going to work.
There are going to be many, many farmers who fail to get the money that they need. And and these are people who are feeding the nation and managing our environment. In my area, that is a really fragile and beautiful environment, and we should be helping them to continue to preserve it. And I don't think the Conservatives have anything to boast about, because they promised after Brexit that farmers would get the same amount of money as they had done before Brexit. And what did they do?
They came up with a scheme to take away the basic payments. They stuck to that rigidly. That was one plan they could manage. What they didn't do was bring in place the promised environmental schemes. And as we've heard, they actually underspent by 350 million pounds.
That is utterly, utterly disgraceful. So my farmers hoped that with a change of government, they were going to get a change of attitude, they were going to get more support. And instead, they've seen the the farce of the SFI scheme, and they've also seen the family farm tax. The changes the government have introduced to that are welcome to some degree, but with land prices in Cambridgeshire, that's still going to affect an awful lot of my family farms. This this government needs to put itself behind our farmers.
Seamus Logan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I firstly apologize to you and the House for missing the very start of the debate? And I'm sorry I missed the right honorable member's speech for Westmorland and Lonsdale. The bit I did hear was excellent, and I'm sure he'll agree with many of the points I'm about to make. I rise not in support of the motion, as much of the text concerns matters that are devolved to the Scottish Government.
However, there are a number of points that are relevant to Scotland but reserved to Westminster, and I'll briefly set these out in the form of questions directly to the Minister. Firstly, no one has yet been able to properly explain to me why the Treasury can't identify the difference between those family farms that are being handed from generation to generation and tax-dodging individuals and companies. And if that could be explained, surely some tweaks could be made to to the budget that's coming before us next week. Secondly, why can't the Treasury extend the annual investment allowance and capital allowances for things like sheds and buildings so that they are fully incentivized? This would surely increase investment and ultimately food production.
Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly for our farmers in Scotland, because they lobbied me last week and this was the point they wanted to make, can the government consider pausing and reviewing the carbon border adjustment mechanism due to come in next year so that it doesn't become an additional tax on UK food production through higher fertilizer costs? And my final ask of the Minister is this: that the government maintain the reduced fuel duty rates for red diesel. This is the kind of measure which will support farmers, secure lower food production costs, reduce food inflation, and enhance our national security. It surely is a no-brainer. And in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, on July the 9th, I asked the Minister who's present here this evening here in the chamber to address problems in the pig industry by referring suspected matters to the the Agricultural Supply Chain Adjudicator or the Competition and Markets Authority.
He said from the dispatch box that he would follow up on these issues.
As far as I'm aware, he has not done so yet. Furthermore, a much anticipated round table with the pig farming industry in Scotland has not yet happened, and perhaps I've got that wrong, but I'm sure the Minister will correct me. So I'd ask the Minister in his summing up to respond to the matters that I've raised here tonight. Thank you.
John Milne.
John Milne
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As has been brought home to us in the most powerful terms since World War II, food security is once again a matter of national security, and the Prime Minister has said as much. But just like our defence capability, farming requires long-term funding and a lasting framework to operate in. The last sustainable SFI window opened at 10 o'clock on Tuesday, 22nd of September and closed at 3:48 later that afternoon. If you popped out to the shops, you missed it.
Defra has made excuses that demand was unprecedented when compared to previous ELM schemes. But setting a benchmark based on a previous flawed Tory scheme that nobody really wanted is not exactly a great metric. The Minister argues that the £100,000 cap makes the scheme fairer because a quarter of the funding used to go to 4% of claimants. Yes, that's true, but a fairer way of rationing a budget that is too small is still a budget that is too small. For decades, farmers did what governments asked of them.
After the war, food production came first, and that was rightly so. But the cost was paid in soil, in hedgerows, in wildlife, and in our rivers, with policymakers recommending the use of harmful chemicals. The SFI exists because that was not sustainable in the long term. So we can see this as a repair bill now come due for the policy that farmers were told to follow for many years. Farmers are now weighing up stepping back from wildflower meadows, from field margins and from buffer strips.
Peter Hartley, who farms in Cambridgeshire, was quoted in the Financial Times yesterday as saying, "I will literally take a plough to everything." "We will have to go back to farming more intensively than the 1950s." Proper farm funding has other benefits too. Ministers told the Lords in April that SFI actions which keep soil covered and build organic matter improve its ability to hold water, and that 35 of the 71 actions in this year's SFI would offer target flood and drought resilience. Cover crops are how you get there.
So 35 recommendations on flood and drought resilience are welcome, but again, £200 million less in the budget is not. There are practical changes that would help now with very modest price tags. Farmers want to store their own water, but the CLA says that only 34 on-farm reservoirs have been built in the last five years. When you realise that they cost an average of £45,000 just with planning permission, you can see why there's so few. And I hope that the review of permitted development rights will report swiftly.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I am sadly out of time. So if food security is national security, fund it like it is. Give farmers the certainty to plan and let them get on with feeding the country.
Charles Edward Robin Morello
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I had hoped to share some of the many, many stories of my farmers and their experiences of SFI who have written to me in the days and weeks following the closure, but in the interest of time, I shall try and be constructive and just talk to the action that is vitally needed. Many farmers raise concerns about technical problems within the application system itself. One farmer who has experience of software as well as farming reported that some options appeared without the base options needed to support them. They raised concerns about the process of measuring hedgerows, arguing that the time and cost involved could outweigh the value of the payment.
If Defra already holds land parcel information and uses satellite imagery to monitor land, it should explain why relevant information cannot be provided to farmers in advance where appropriate. The government has said that the overall SFI 2024 budget has increased by 290 million, but that doesn't answer the question of whether enough money is available to meet demand. We need a clear account of how the funding has been allocated, including by farm type, farm size and region. There are also concerns that the options and payments available do not adequately reflect the needs of livestock farmers compared with arable farms. The government should publish the evidence and assess the impact on food production.
Farmers whose existing agreements are expiring need to know when they can apply for replacement agreements and what support will be available in the meantime. Without clarity, environmental work already underway risks being stopped, not because farmers don't want to continue to do it, but because they can't afford to do it. So my ask of the government is this. Firstly, please publish a full account of the technical problems experienced during the application window and explain what remedial action will be taken. Secondly, make additional funding available for eligible farmers who were locked out when the budget was exhausted, rather than leaving them to absorb the financial consequences of a process that failed them.
Thirdly, review the first-come, first-served system. The government should consider alternatives, including allocating funding more fairly when they know that demand exceeds the available budget. Finally, the government must properly fund the rollout of the environmental land management schemes, including SFI. With an additional 1 billion a year, we believe is needed to give farmers a sustainable and stable basis for planning and investment. My farmers in West Dorset are not asking for special treatment.
They are asking for a system that works, funding they can rely on, and a fair opportunity to apply. And I hope that ministers will listen to farmers today before they are staring at empty plates tomorrow.
Gideon Amos
Farmers in Taunton and Wellington, Madam Deputy Speaker, have been hit incredibly hard by this debacle. For residents and visitors to my Taunton and Wellington part of Somerset alike, as well as to farmers, the hedges, the field margins, the wildflower meadows funded by the sustainable farming incentive are the very fabric of the countryside we know and love, from the Quantocks to the Blackdown Hills and across my constituency. Yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, all of that has been put under threat simply due to a badly mismanaged system that this government could and should fix. I met with local farmers out on the levels in my constituency the week before last, and I want to thank them for the work they do 365 days a year, putting food on our tables, caring for our countryside and bringing employment to our rural areas. Let me relay just two of the cases they raised.
The first is James Hebditch of Lillesdon Court. He's not a last-minute farmer. His fields have been registered with the RPA for years. Yet on the 22nd of September, a glitch on the government portal suddenly rejected one of his fields. He was faced with an impossible choice: apply without it or try and amend and resubmit.
By the time he could navigate the error the portal had made, the whole thing had closed. His entire application was lost. He was caught out by the government's own system on land that the RPA already had on its books. When farmers are fighting a failing portal, they do not have time to sit on hold for hours. The consequences of this failure are devastating.
The hedges and habitats James maintained for years under previous schemes will likely have to be ripped up just for his farm to remain viable and profitable. Tom Pope of Staple Farm said, with no replacement scheme, we will be forced to consider ploughing up some of our environmental areas to return them to arable production. Some of these areas have huge variety of wildflowers and provide brilliant habitat for insects and birds.
It will break our hearts, he said. Somerset is one of the hardest hit areas as well for blue tongue with 156 confirmed premises. Add to that the fact that direct payments are capped at just 600 pounds this year, diesel is top 2 pounds per liter, the heavy burden of the family farm tax, a 32% spike in ammonium nitrate, and the Conservative-designed upcoming carbon border charge on fertilizer from January. The result of all of this is farmers have been pushed to the very brink of viability and of much else. To make matters worse, the government ran all of this on a first-come, first-served basis.
It's not a serious way to run a 930 million pound public program, and at least if you don't get Glastonbury tickets, you're not required to plow up a wildflower meadow afterwards. Madam Deputy Speaker, can I finally call on the government to take four key actions: no cliff edge, extend agreements to SFI 2027, a second chance, a certainty on SFI, and protect farmers from substandard imports. Our farmers protect our countryside and feed our nation.
Anna Sabine
Me, sorry, pardon. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I hope you will permit me to quickly put on record my thanks to the broadcasting unit in Parliament who've been so helpful in providing me with additional support while I've been trying to speak in the chamber whilst struggling with vocal cord paralysis. I'm privileged to represent nearly 200 farms in Frome and East Somerset. They're not only critical to the rural economy of Somerset, generating hundreds of jobs in the wider economy, but also to providing the UK with much of the dairy and other food products they rely on.
Every time I meet farmers in my constituency, I hear the same thing: that this government doesn't understand rural communities and doesn't see that penalizing farmers undermines its own goals of growth and stability. In order to survive, many of my farmers are running a range of side hustles, from cafes to ice cream companies to farmstay accommodation. They are stretching themselves to extremes to try to keep their farms going. The SFI is one of the few forms of funding available for these farmers, but as we know in September, after spending precious time preparing long and detailed applications, farmers in my constituency weren't even able to load up the application form because the money had already gone. Money was not awarded to the best farms with the best plans to feed the nation and restore nature, money was awarded to whoever clicked the fastest.
Surely, regardless of attempts at political point scoring, we can all agree that despite any improvements the government's made to SFI, this is not a fair or smart way to spend public money. As a result, for the first time since 1945, many UK farmers now have no universal payment offer. And at the same time, the government is also chopping and changing the agricultural property relief and making cuts to Defra's farming budget.
Will my honorable friend give way?
Certainly.
Victoria Collins
Victoria Collins. You're summing up what so many of my farmers are facing. And I have one farmer in Sandwich who says he's closing doors because the government, he feels the government are not listening. And also the impact on the environment. I have one guy in Susanna and Great Gaddesden.
Their shortfall because of the extreme weather means there are 6.6 million less bowls of porridge from one farm. Would my honorable friend agree with me, this is not just important, but this is crisis moment, and the government have to listen because this is about farmers but our food security too.
Anna Sabine
Miss Collins, I wasn't summing up because I wasn't speaking, so you and yours doesn't count. Anna Sabine. Thank you very much, and I absolutely agree with what my honorable friend has just said. Funding decisions like these really matter for farmers and rural communities, but they also matter for the environment. Today the government's announced Jackdaw is going ahead, a stark reminder of the UK's continuing dependency on gas and how far we must still go to reach net zero.
If we're serious about getting there, farmers are part of the solution. The SFI rewards the kind of sustainable choices we want farmers to make more of, yet many of the farmers who want to protect nature are being locked out of the very funding that makes it possible. British farmers are the foundation of rural communities like mine. They are also key allies for tackling climate change in this country. The Prime Minister promises growth in every postcode, but can't even ensure that farmers in my postcode receive funding to help feed our country.
So will the government finally support farmers and guarantee long-term funding for all eligible SFI 26 applicants?
Adam Dance
Adam Dance.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The absolute shambles that is wave two of the Sustainable Farming Incentives is just another sample of farmers being let down by government after government. I've already mentioned this in the chamber, but Tim, who farms near Yeovil, was locked out of wave two of SFI on the same day that he was awarded Water Quality Farmer of the Year. I mean, you can't make that up, really. He and many farmers like him in Yeovil are now left in a financial hole.
Tim said that the buffer strips around fields will now have to be cultivated in the hope they can make some money, as long as the weather, markets, and business costs all play ball. It is clear that he's gambling with terrible odds. But Tim told me, what other choice does he have? And that really sums up the terrible situation so many farmers in Yeovil and across the country are facing. Extreme weather from heatwaves and flooding, spiralling costs of fertiliser, fuel, and equipment, and growing biosecurity threats from bluetongue and TB.
When you throw in terrible government policy, it is a perfect storm waiting to happen. With the time I've got left, I'd like to just touch on a few issues raised a lot at my farming forum. Firstly, on sustainable farming, while DEFRA are saying they have learned lessons for next time, farmers like Tim, Chris, John, Ollie, and many more want to know if they are going to get recognised for implementing sustainable farming practices now, because lots of them... Quickly, yes.
John Richard Foord
I'm grateful. He talks about learning lessons for next time. My constituent from Butterleigh in Devon wrote to me about the withdrawal, the sudden withdrawal of the SFI. That wasn't this year, that was last year. Does he agree that the government and DEFRA in particular can't seem to learn to get this right?
Adam Dance
I totally agree with my honourable friend, they can't seem to get it right and they are failing our farmers across the country. Because lots of them are saying their only option now is intensive farming. That is really worrying for us in South Somerset as winter comes round and it begins to flood, because our farmers are the frontline of prevention, preventing even worsening flooding. More broadly, as we have already heard, farmers need more clarity about how SFI and other schemes are going to develop in the future so they can actually plan ahead. Secondly, farmers hit by bluetongue and TB want to know what more government is doing to improve our readiness and communication systems for future outbreaks.
I hope the minister can set out when the government will bring in the new TB strategy. Finally, farmers from Yeovil are really worried more broadly about the future of farming. We have an ageing workforce and recruitment crisis, so I would ask the minister what steps the government is taking to promote pathways for young people into farming and reduce the financial and admin burdens currently stopping farmers from being able to take young people on. Madam Deputy Speaker, if this new government really is committed to problem-solving, I can think of no better place than start than farming. We all know the problems, it's time to finally get on with the actual work and support our farmers.
Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank my honourable friend for Westmorland for bringing forward this debate? He was right to express the motion both in terms of the chaotic handling of SFI by this Labour government, but also by outlining the catastrophic mismanagement post-Brexit by the Conservatives. They bear responsibility for the system we have today. Prominent Tories in 2016, including the now Father of the House, said if we leave the EU, the level of subsidy to the farming community will remain exactly the same.
Well, tell that to my farmers now. Vote Leave told the Treasury Select Committee farmers would get paid at least as much as they get now.
The former Tory Prime Minister Boris Johnson, a former holder of my seat in Henley, said he could 100% guarantee that farmers' subsidies would continue or increase after Brexit. Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think I've just shown why the good people of Henley and Thame no longer wish the likes of Johnson and the Conservatives to represent their interests. Betrayed by the Tories, they said enough is enough. But farmers in my constituency of Henley and Thame have told me how disappointed they are now with Labour and a government that just doesn't get farming. APR and BPR were the prime examples of that, but there are more.
SFI is the latest. One of my local farmers has put it best: applications should not be a scramble for Oasis tickets. He told me it's an appalling way to treat farmers and how they care for our farmed environment. Another, Jack Berkmore, who leads a Henley young farmers group, said they didn't even know when the window was going to open, what time, so they sat there waiting for it. This is not a serious way to treat people, is it?
Another one of my wonderful local farmers has described to me how lucky they were to apply for SFI 26 in the short window it was open and receive the agreement, but they now describe a feeling of guilt when so many others are in even more dire financial situations. So I'd like to press directly to the government her ideas. First, an early application window for SFI 27, with applications open in February, ready to start as soon as we hit the new financial year. Second, a priority for those farmers whose existing SFI or mid-tier agreements are ending. Failure to do so quickly will mean farmers ripping up their environmental areas in the spring and instead planting crops.
Third, a better application process, faster than fastest finger. And fourth, above all, a larger budget for SFI. Farmers face a perilous time. Further extreme weather could push many more farms out of business. With such global uncertainty, is it not time to back British farmers?
Manuela Perteghella
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Farmers in my constituency of Stratford-on-Avon and across the country have been left totally bewildered and deeply anxious by this government's handling of the SFI. The scheme, although flawed, was meant to reward good farming and environmental stewardship. Instead, farmers who had spent time preparing applications logged on, ready to apply, only to discover that the available budget had been exhausted almost immediately. This is no way to treat the people who produce our food and are doing what they can to care for our countryside.
The government's approach has reduced what should be a strategic long-term partnership with farmers into a lottery. Farmers need certainty and the confidence to invest. They need to know that when government asks them to change the way they farm, the support will be there. One of my constituent farmers summed up the mood when they contacted me. They wrote: morale is rock bottom within the industry.
Many farm businesses are on the brink. We need a sensible payment system to give us confidence. And we should also not ignore that this kind of prolonged uncertainty means for farmers' mental well-being. At a time when we know that mental health challenges are widespread within the farming community, ministers should be doing everything possible to provide stability and reassurance rather than creating uncertainty. To wait until 2027 is deeply unfair to farming and to nature.
So will the ministers make additional funding available for eligible farmers who were excluded through no fault of their own, including my constituents? And how will the farmers continue to deliver the environmental outcomes the government expects if access to the very schemes designed to support the work can disappear in a matter of hours? These failures come on top of cuts to Defra's budget and ongoing uncertainty over the future of environmental land management schemes.
Farmers have been asked to do more with less while receiving fewer guarantees about the support available to them. Instead, farmers should be rewarded properly for delivering food security, restoring nature, capturing carbon and tackling climate change. But they need support, they need a government who's got their back. Ministers must work with the sector, learn from this shambles and ensure that never again are farmers forced into a first-come, first-served scramble for support. Our farmers deserve a government that sees them as partners and treats them with the respect they deserve.
Thank you.
Charlie Maynard
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, again. The latest round of the Sustainable Farming Incentive was a disaster for small farmers, including many in my Witney constituency. They were counting on this money as a lifeline after another impossibly difficult year. As one local farmer wrote to me, it is madness to set a deadline and then require a field-by-field online application process with a limited budget and a first-come, first-served basis.
No public money should be allocated this way. Let alone money farmers were relying on to stay afloat. So I welcome the Minister's commitment to scrap the first-come, first-served basis for 2027. But what's most disappointing is that this chaos was entirely predictable. The government abandoned the rolling scheme.
The sector warned loudly that the Prime Minister's extra 50 million would barely touch the sides and the scheme ran out within the day, within six hours. Of course, the Conservatives laid the ground for this. They began phasing out the basic payment scheme, the support farmers have relied on for years, long before its replacement was ready. They cut farmers' income first and asked questions later, while hundreds of millions of the farming budget went unspent. Labour has inherited that mess, but it certainly has not fixed it.
Farmers now face a perfect storm. The summer's heat and drought are projected to have caused the worst harvest on record. That follows a drought-hit 2025 harvest and a 2024 harvest that was washed out. Farmers expect to balance bad years against good years, but three awful harvests in a row is unsustainable. And as the climate crisis deepens, there is no reason to think next year will be better.
Meanwhile, farming costs have risen at about twice the rate of inflation, with fertiliser up around 35% in a year. The government lists food as one of the 13 critical national infrastructure sectors. Yet the farmers are at the foundation of that chain and get support that is wholly inadequate. Farmers need a payment system that rewards both growing food and restoring nature. They also need help to invest in resilience, such as better irrigation and on-farm reservoirs.
So alongside reviewing the process and the budget for next year's scheme, what additional funding will the government provide to help farmers adapt and future-proof their businesses?
Speaker 293
There we have it. We come to the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Sarah Dyke.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's an honour to close this debate on behalf of the Liberal Democrats. We chose to use our opposition day on support for farmers because farmers are the backbone of rural communities across the country. And today's debate has shown just how deeply that is felt. My honourable friend, the member for Westmorland and Lonsdale, opened by outlining how the Liberal Democrats will reform SFI so every farmer is allocated a sum via SFI which is consistent with the capacity of their farm, theirs to claim within a long window.
And the right honourable member for Orkney and Shetland and EFRA Select Committee Chair reminded us that we are and farmers are in the middle of a perfect storm.
Now we've heard from members on all sides about farmers who prepared SFI applications for months on end only to be shut out in an afternoon. In Glastonbury and Somerton, this is not an abstract issue. It is about whether family farms can play can plan not just for next year, but for the years and generations ahead. On the 22nd of September, the second window opened with 233 million pounds. By 3:48 PM, it had shut.
Now farmers deserve better than a Glastonbury ticket scramble. At least festival goers know when the fallow years are coming. Farmers who missed out have been handed one with no warning at all. One farmer from Curry Rivel wrote to me and described the process simply as a disaster. And the money has been shared out badly, not just too thinly.
Window one left 3 million pounds unallocated, yet window two was oversubscribed within hours. And the scramble did not fall evenly. The EFRA Select Committee survey recently found that 60% of respondents could not submit before the window closed. Only 31% of those running farm businesses were successful compared with 68% of those with land agents. That's a two-tier system.
Those that can afford an advisor are waved through the farm gate, while those who cannot afford it are left out in the field. Now until it was privatized in 1997, ADAS gave farmers free independent advice provided by the state. Today, if you can't afford an agent, you're on your own. That was not just bad luck. DEFRA's own forecast made in April and May modeled the window closing on its very first day, predicting 12,200 applications.
On the day, 12,204 was submitted, just four more than were forecast. DEFRA saw it coming. And nearly 2,900 farmers started an application they were never able to submit. Others were let down by DEFRA's IT systems. Tom Kimber, who farms at Higher Stafordale Farm in Charlton Musgrove, had an SFI agreement coming to an end.
He applied in window two and missed out because of technical problems. He was assured farmers like him would be given a route back in. He has heard nothing since. Tom wants to deliver for the environment. And we know that demand for SFI proves thousands of other farmers are doing just that too.
But that commitment is not being matched by a government that understands the scheme. Last week, the minister told the house that first come first served will end, and I welcome that. But you can't feed a whole farm herd from a trough that is simply too small. As the NFU has asked, with expiring agreements worth over 520 million pounds and a budget across both windows of just 310 million pounds, where has the missing funding gone? Around 8,800 of this autumn's applicants have agreements ending in February.
Now Claire, who farms near Puckington, is one of them. For years she has protected the river margins on her land, slowing runoff, filtering pollution, and giving wildlife space to thrive. SFI was meant to be her way forward. Now those margins have no funding. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I move on to the Conservatives' utter failure to support British farmers, can I remind the shadow minister that the Liberal Democrats were the first party to oppose the family farm tax, which includes BPR and APR.
Now the Conservatives, the Conservatives can't escape their share of the blame for the chaos farmers are facing today. They designed SFI on a first come first served basis.
They botched the transition from basic payment schemes. They let farming budgets fall behind inflation. And they signed trade agreements with Australia and New Zealand that undercut British farmers. But this government cannot keep hiding behind its predecessor. It chose to accelerate the phase out of direct payments whilst stop starting SFI.
So that for the first time since 1945 farmers have no universal payment offer at all. It imposed the family farm tax. And it cut the Defra and farming budgets. The Liberal Democrats warned this would happen. Now I wrote to the former Secretary of State in July before the first window closed asking how the department would stop window two meeting this exact fate.
Now all of this as our farmers face one of their worst years in memory. Mark Humphrey who farms at Owl Brewers and chairs the NFU Somerset has described a torrid 18 months. Milk prices are down at 32 pence per litre selling for 8 pence less than it costs to produce. Maize yields are down 10 to 15%. But our farmers must be profitable Madam Deputy Speaker.
Yet Somerset also shows what is possible with long-term certainty. Now last week I met Damon Bridge of the RSPB and the Greater Sedgemoor Landscape Recovery team on North Moor near Langport where farmers and conservation groups are working together across 4,000 hectares. 20 year agreement not a window that slams shut in an afternoon. But only a handful of landscape recovery projects have reached delivery. And farmers need to know these will actually happen.
Because food security is national security. Madam Deputy Speaker all of this comes back to one question. Can this country feed itself? We produce only around 60% of the food we eat. Between 2019 and 2024 the farming budget was frozen at 2.4 million pounds while input costs rose by 44%.
With war in Ukraine and the conflict in the Middle East food security is national security. Yet this government still does not treat it as a priority. That is why I won't for time. That is why I brought forward my Good Food Bill. Now Liberal Democrat policy with binding targets for domestic food production and an annual food security audit reported to this House and action to drive down food waste.
And it's why we have long called for an extra 1 billion pounds a year for environmental land management schemes. So every eligible farmer who applied in good faith gets an agreement. So there's a proper bridge for the 8,800 farmers whose agreements are ending. And we invest in the training and technology that cut farmers' costs for the long term. Not fairer rationing but a bigger pot.
And with the budget next week the Chancellor has the perfect opportunity to deliver it. So will the Minister answer four simple questions? First what will be different next year so a family farm without an agent has the same chance as an estate with one? And will she look at restoring free independent advice services for smaller farms? Second will she guarantee that farmers like Tom who missed out because Defra's own IT failures will not lose out again?
And will she confirm whether any money from window two is left unallocated and if so how much? And third will she open SFI 2027 early in the new year or even before that and publish its budget now so no farmer with an expiring agreement faces a gap from April next year? And fourth will she press the Chancellor to use next week's budget to properly fund these schemes our farmers depend on and can she confirm the Defra budget will not be cut?
Madam Deputy Speaker, our farmers have kept their side of the deal. They've adapted to the end of the basic payment scheme, prepared for scheme after scheme and kept growing our food through soaring costs, extreme weather, disease outbreaks and attacks that threaten their livelihoods. What they haven't had is a government, Conservative or Labour, that keeps its side of the deal. Now this motion offers a way forward. Long-term funding for every eligible SFI applicant, reversing the farm family farm tax and a comprehensive national food strategy and an extra 1 billion pounds a year for the schemes our farmers depend on.
Madam Deputy Speaker, because a nation that cannot feed itself cannot protect itself. Thank you.
Speaker 298
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And may I start by thanking honourable members from both sides of the house for their contributions throughout the debate and for sharing issues raised by farmers and rural communities across our country. And can I thank the opposition spokesperson for raising these important matters too. Let me reiterate the words of my excellent fellow minister, the first time she's spoken at the dispatch box. We know how hard this year has been for farmers.
Behind every statistic about drought, input prices or farm income is a family making difficult decisions about crops, livestock, bills and their future. As we set out in our farming roadmap, because farmers have repeatedly asked for clarity and certainty and on this side of the house we are delivering on that. The roadmap set this government's strategic vision for farming. We want profitable, productive farms that are better able to withstand volatile weather, markets and geopolitical shocks. The roadmap also sets out that domestic food production will be maintained at least at current levels while nature recovery, economic growth and the responsible use of land and resources is supported.
And this is supported by the strong financial settlement Defra secured in the 2025 spending review. Across this parliament, this government has allocated a record 11.8 billion pounds to sustainable farming and food production. And this includes 788 million this year alone in new funding for farmers to boost farm productivity, develop cutting-edge technologies to drive future growth and maintain a healthy natural environment. Madam Deputy Speaker, where this year has exposed vulnerabilities, this government has responded. We've made drought flexibilities available, supported investment in farm reservoirs and added funding to the SFI 2026.
Now I thank the chair of the select committee for his interventions. He's now back in his place. And I think he's right to recognise the optimism and resilience of our nation's farmers, a view that I wholeheartedly support and so many members in this house will do so too. And I very much share what he said with regards to the value of providing greater certainty to the sector, something that we are very much doing through our farming roadmap, setting out the government's vision to drive more profitable, productive, sustainable and resilient farming sector. And we are doing that in partnership with the sector via our partnership board and the sector growth plans.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, a number of members have spoken about SFI and this year's two windows and the learning for future years. And I thank all members who have offered practical ideas about its delivery in future. We also recognise where things have not worked as farmers would have wished.
The speed with which SFI 26 window closed last month caused real disappointment. And I do not dismiss that frustration. I recognize the concerns raised by members across the House today and for the specific examples and concerns that they have raised with me in today's debate. Demand substantially exceeded the funding available. And we must learn from that experience as we work with the sector and in partnership on SFI 27.
Working through the options following my confirmation that we will scrap the first-come, first-served approach is absolutely a priority of mine. And I will happily give way to the honorable member.
Timothy James Farron
I'm very, very grateful. If we go back to March 2025 when the drawbridge was pulled up with no notice last time round, I mentioned him earlier on, but his right honorable friend the member for Cambridge said then that we mustn't do first-come, first-served again. And we just have done. So what guarantees can he actually give us that next time round it will not be first-come, first-served? And all the same, can he make sure that window will come very, very soon?
Speaker 298
Well, I thank him for that intervention. And he will know that we did make a number of changes to improve the scheme this year. He didn't briefly mention those in his opening remarks today. But I have been very clear that we need to learn lessons from this year's scheme. And that does mean a commitment on scrapping the first-come, first-served approach and also bringing forward SFI 27 as early as possible.
So, Madam Deputy Speaker, in today's debate, a number of members have also expressed concerns about the impact of trade deals on farmers under deals done by the previous Conservative government. And let me be clear. This government will always act in the national interest to protect Britain's farmers and secure our food security. We will never lower food standards. And we will uphold the high animal welfare standards that our country expects.
In the last year alone, we have secured agreement on new trade deals with India, the Republic of Korea, the Gulf Cooperation Council, and Switzerland. And all of these deals strike a balance that they open new opportunities for UK businesses and help diversify supply chains while also protecting the UK's most sensitive sectors. A number of members have been interested in the SPS agreement with the European Union. And I want to thank the member for South Northamptonshire, who's not in her place currently. Here she is.
For the issues that she raised. The EU remains the UK's biggest and closest export market, offering major opportunities for British food and drink businesses to reach millions of consumers. And yesterday, I was at SIAL trade show in Paris, meeting businesses from every corner of the UK who want to increase their exports to Europe. Now, the SPS agreement will reduce costs and delays for both UK and EU exporters and importers at the border, supporting the UK's food supply chains and security. It will make agri-food trade with our biggest market cheaper and easier, cutting costs and red tape for British producers.
Ben Goldsborough
I thank my honorable friend for giving way. Does he agree with me that while the huge things that we must protect within the SPS agreement as well is precision breeding? And not just the research and development aspect of it, but also how we get it to market. And I know in other conversations that I've had with him, he's been working hard with our European colleagues. Can he explain what action he is doing to make sure we can keep precision breeding as that benefit to the UK?
Speaker 298
I thank my honorable friend for his intervention. It was a real pleasure to spend time with him at the Royal Norfolk Show earlier this year, where I heard very clearly the value of our innovation and world-leading technology in this space.
And I take this opportunity to reflect on the points that he made earlier in this debate around the importance of working with our international partners and showcasing the best of British around the world. So thank you for that. He will appreciate that I cannot provide details on the ongoing SPS negotiations. The Prime Minister has obviously set out that the government will be completing these negotiations before the next EU-UK summit on the 20th of November. A number of members today have expressed concern at the impacts of reforms to agricultural property relief on inheritance tax, which came into force earlier this year.
Now, I recognise that when the government initially announced these reforms in 2024, there was significant concern in the industry about their impact. The government listened to those concerns carefully, considered the feedback, and the previous Chancellor acted. And that is why last year the government went further to protect more farms and businesses while maintaining the core principle that the most valuable agricultural business assets should not receive unlimited relief. This is a fair and balanced approach that protects the family farm while also fixing the public services that we all rely on. I will give way.
Lee Dillon
Minister, I wonder, Madam Deputy Speaker, if the minister could explain how a farm in my constituency will still have a potential inheritance tax bill of 650,000 pounds, yet only generates 18,000 pounds a year profit.
Speaker 298
I thank the member for his question. And on all these matters, the government's view is now settled. And I do recognise that the previous Chancellor made the changes as a result of the engagement that she and others had with the farming community up and down this country. But I know that he would have been keen to place his views on record, and he's obviously successfully done that. Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to turn to the points raised by my honourable friend for South West Norfolk, who raised a number of constructive points as a result of the continued engagement that he has with his farmers across his constituency.
I understand he's now visited 100 farms in his patch, and I know that he is hosting a very important event in his constituency later this week on the future of farming. And I wish him well on that event. The honourable member for South Norfolk also spoke about the importance of profitability and the value of learning from international partners, as I mentioned earlier. And I thank him again for his insights. My honourable friend for Rushcliffe, I think, gave a very eloquent speech this afternoon about the importance of co-designing the future of SFI.
And I can assure him that both myself directly and my department through my officials are working with the sector already on exploring options and trade-offs as we consider what SFI 27 will look like. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, in conclusion, farmers deserve security, fairness, and confidence to invest in the next generation. And they have a government that listens when times are hard and works in partnership with the sector to deliver on the commitment set out in our farming roadmap. That is our commitment to back British farming, to maintain domestic food production, and to ensure that those who produce our food have a resilient and profitable future.
Speaker 302
The question is as on the order paper. As many of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Speaker 308
Unlock. Colleagues, colleagues should be observing the chamber and should be seated. Should be seated. Marcus. The question is as on the order paper.
Speaker 301
As many of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Tellers for the ayes are Will Forster and Bobby Dean. Tellers for the noes are Jade Botterill and Laurence Turner.
Speaker 293
Order, order. The ayes to the right 57, the noes to the left 279. The ayes to the right 57, the noes to the left 279. So the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock.
Sorcha Eastwood
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This House may be aware of alarming press reports that Jeffrey Donaldson, a former member of this House and my predecessor in Lagan Valley, is under police investigation over allegations of rape within these Houses of Parliament. This follows his sentencing last week to 15 years for 18 charges of non-recent child sexual abuse crimes, including the rape of a child under the age of 13. Clearly, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a live police investigation and I would not wish to prejudice it. However, I know that former and current members of staff on this estate may be deeply affected by these reports.
What advice can the Chair give on how we can support those who are distressed by this news and on how we can encourage anyone with concerns to come forward?
Speaker 293
I thank the honorable member for bringing the point of order to my attention. This will of course be highly concerning allegations for all in the parliamentary community. The Parliamentary Health and Wellbeing Service can advise and assist on the range of support available for anyone affected by these reports, and there are established mechanisms for anyone with concerns wishing to come forward, while of course any criminal allegations should be made to the appropriate authorities. I'll give the front benches a moment or two to shuffle over. Right, we now come to motion number six relating to the Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy.
I beg to move.
Speaker 309
The question is as on the order paper. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now come to motion number seven relating to the Scottish Affairs Committee. Jessica Morden.
I beg to move.
Speaker 293
The question is as on the order paper. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now come to motion number eight relating to the Women and Equalities Committee. Jessica Morden.
I beg to move.
Speaker 293
The question is as on the order paper. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now come to presentation of public petitions, petition Sarah Dyke.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I present this petition regarding the severe delays in the administration of the Civil Service Pension Scheme. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urge the Government to take urgent action to restore a reliable pension service for current and former civil servants, including by publishing its assessment of whether Capita met its 30th September commitment, setting out what action it will take following the missed 30th of June deadline, prioritizing bereavement cases and setting a firm date by which all outstanding claims will be resolved, and strengthening oversight so that public servants are never again let down by a failing outsourced contract. And the petitioners remain, etc.
Speaker 305
The question is that this House do now adjourn, and I call Steve Yemm on mineworkers' pension schemes in Nottinghamshire. Steve Yemm.
Steve Yemm
Madam Deputy Speaker, before I start, I want to say something about today's date. 60 years ago, a colliery spoil tip gave way above the village of Aberfan and slid down onto Pantglas Junior School. 116 children and 28 adults were killed, and anyone who grew up in a coalfield knows the name of Aberfan. It's part of our shared history and the people of that village have carried it every day since, and I know that the whole House will have this in our thoughts today. I'm grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker, for the chance tonight to raise an issue that matters a great deal to people in Mansfield, across Nottinghamshire, and in fact in former coalfields right across the country.
That is the pensions of men and women who worked in our pits and whether we're finally going to give them everything that they are owed.
I'll give way and I'm going to take as many interventions as possible but I would ask members to be brief please please.
Speaker 315
I genuinely thank the honorable member for giving way. I had one of those dreaded calls this week from a family member to say that somebody that I've been representing, a resident of mine, had passed away without getting the justice. These people gave blood, sweat and tears for our country. Isn't it time we gave them their justice?
Steve Yemm
Well I thank the member and you know I certainly absolutely agree with him on this. This is long overdue. And you know I think from my own experience four years a group of campaigners from Nottinghamshire and right across the country refused to let this issue go.
Speaker 53
I'd like to thank my honorable friend for giving way and ask if he will join me in acknowledging the similar work of campaigners in Hamilton and Clyde Valley who have worked so hard and so diligently and so steadfastly on this matter.
Steve Yemm
And I thank the honorable member for that intervention and I absolutely agree. And of course there are too many people to thank and mention individually but one of the campaigners Mick Newton, a friend of mine for over 40 years, is here in the gallery tonight watching. And some of the campaigners are sadly no longer with us. And I hope that their families know that their work is being recognized in this house tonight.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
I thank the honorable member for giving way. As Nottingham born and bred but I've lived in Derbyshire for 20 years and I'm proud to represent South Derbyshire. There are many many ex-miners who I have met here in this place in South Derbyshire and Derbyshire more broadly that would like to say thank you to you for your leadership on this in our neck of the woods.
Speaker 293
I did not require to be thanked because I am not speaking in this debate. Is the question done? Marvelous.
Steve Yemm
And I thank the honorable member for the intervention and the recognition. Thank you very much. And that is important and it is important that we recognize those campaigners who are still fighting. And I have to say this to every one of them: you have made a difference. And a lot of what I am about to describe would not have happened without you.
Michelle Welsh
Does the honorable friend agree with me that former mine workers and their families in Sherwood Forest, these pensions are deferred wages earned through years of hard and dangerous work? With many members now facing ill health there's no time to waste. And so will he join me in urging the government to use the budget to secure a fairer agreement on surpluses and ensure that bonus pensions are protected and rise with inflation?
Steve Yemm
And I thank my honorable colleague for that intervention and I certainly agree with her completely on that. And yes I'll...
Charles David Robertson
I thank my honorable friend for giving way. And I know he's just been through a part of his speech where he's saying there's too many people to mention by name and how sad it is we've lost so many of the campaigners. But I wonder whether he'd like to join me in celebrating the work of Tommy Christopher who did so much to lead this campaign and now his nephew John who I have the pleasure to call a constituent who is chairing the campaign. And without them we would not have got as far as we are today. And I wonder if he'd like to join me in thanking them.
Steve Yemm
And I thank my honorable colleague for his intervention and I would certainly join him in saying thank you in that way. Madam Deputy Speaker, in Mansfield and across the rest of my constituency whole communities were built around the pits.
My constituents' fathers, grandfathers went underground and plenty of them went underground themselves. They kept the lights on and the factories running for this country. It was hard, dangerous work and many of them are still living with what it did to their health and the least we owe them is a decent pension. And for a long time they did not get that. When British Coal was privatized in 1994, the government of the day agreed to guarantee the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme and the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme.
In return, the Treasury took a share of the surpluses and over the years that followed, billions of pounds went into the Treasury while a lot of former miners and their widows got by on fairly modest pensions. People in our communities never thought that was fair and they were right. So I am proud that this Labour government has started to put it right. One of the first big decisions this government took... I will give way.
Speaker 105
I thank my honorable friend for giving way. On the 2nd of November, I will be meeting MPAS members in Cumnock Town Hall and would encourage colleagues right across to meet to attend local meetings. Progress so far on mineworkers' pensions is thanks to this Labour government and any further progress will be from Labour members on these benches. Would my honorable friend agree with me that our presence at these meetings as elected members sends an important signal to those members?
Steve Yemm
Thank you for the intervention and it is certainly important to raise those meetings and to have that conversation with members and trustees as frequently as possible. One of the first big decisions this government took was to hand the 1.5 billion pounds investment reserve of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme back to its members. That meant a 32% increase in their pensions. And last year, the government did the same for the British Coal Staff Scheme, transferring their 2.3 billion reserve. And that's the best part of 4 billion pounds back where it belongs and thousands of families in my constituency have felt that difference.
So what is left? Well, what is left is the question of surpluses. What happens to the money that builds up in these schemes in the future and the money that's sitting in the schemes right now? The trustees of both schemes have put forward proposals and I think they are sensible ones. The Mineworkers' Pension Scheme trustees have asked for three things.
First, that around 1 billion pounds of surplus that is currently locked up in the scheme is used to give members a new bonus pension now. Secondly, that 100% of future surpluses will go to improving members' pensions. And third, that the bonus pensions awarded in 2024 are protected so they cannot be taken away. Yes, I will give way.
Amanda Hack
I thank my honorable friend for giving way and for his leadership in this campaign. I think the three things as outlined is more than what our miners deserve. Just a few weeks ago, I went to a celebration of 40 years since Whittle Colliery closed and I can feel it in the community every time I go to see them just how much they need this funding in their pockets as quickly as possible so they get to live out the rest of their life with the money that they so rightly deserve.
Steve Yemm
My honorable member raises such an important point about the urgency of this question. And that third point that I raised really matters to people in my constituency. Members of the British Coal Staff Scheme have bonus pensions that are protected. Members of the Mineworkers' Scheme do not. And I don't think that anybody could explain to a retired miner in Mansfield why his bonus should be less secure than the one paid to someone he worked alongside at the same colliery.
And we should fix that. The British Coal Staff Scheme trustees have made similar proposals. Clear valuation showing whether the scheme is in surplus and deficit. I want to be clear about one thing. Neither set of trustees is asking for the government guarantee to be removed.
Nobody wants to put pensioners' security at risk and nobody's suggesting the schemes pay out money they might need to meet their commitments. But you cannot, as my honorable member pointed out, keep telling people in their eighties that fairness is coming at some point in the future. Yes, of course I can, I'll give way.
Sam Rushworth
I thank him for giving way and I thank him for the excellent work that he's doing on this. It was my privilege five years ago at Labour Conference to second the NUM motion on this. Five years on, many of the miners that I represent are still waiting to see some of these things come to fruition and sadly any members of my family that worked in the pits are no longer with us. And so he mentions people in their eighties. Will he join me in urging the government to take this action as swiftly as possible?
Speaker 314
And does he also share my disappointment that there is nobody on the opposition benches and we cannot be the only people on these benches who represent mineworkers?
Steve Yemm
Well, I welcome his comments and I share the disappointment. But I have also to recollect in 2019 at the general election, Boris Johnson stood on the step, the town hall steps in my constituency and committed to putting this right. And the benches opposite spent five years and did nothing for mineworkers. But let me say, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is also an economic point too. When we increase those pensions, that money gets spent in our constituencies in communities that have had decades of decline since collieries closed and that matters too.
So I have had very good discussions with ministers and with the trustees of both schemes and I know that a lot of work is ongoing. The budget is next Wednesday, so I would like to put four questions to the minister if I may. Yes, I will give way.
Josh Newbury
I thank him for giving way. He and I both represent thousands of MPS and BCSSS members in our two constituencies alone and alongside those who've sadly passed away before seeing that full justice, they have been fighting this battle for years and years. So does he agree with me that with a coalfield Prime Minister and a coalfield Chancellor, next week's budget is the time to do right by them once and for all?
Steve Yemm
I thank the honorable member for that contribution and of course I agree it is very timely indeed. And yes, I will give way.
Speaker 316
I'm very grateful. Can I compliment my honorable friend on an excellent presentation of the argument? And indeed all of the interventions have been absolutely to the point. Can I just say and direct my remarks, you know, as the son and grandson of a miner, sadly my father passed away, my mother a widow passed away before she received the benefits of last year's increases. But that this country, I'm directing my remarks to the Treasury bench, owes a debt of honor to the miners who made the sacrifices.
It's the anniversary of Aberfan. We've just marked the anniversary of the terrible disaster in the Ainsty Colliery in my constituency, 83 men killed. There was a price to be paid by those miners and those communities. And that historic debt can be repaid in part by the Chancellor at the budget next week. And I beseech the Minister to take that message back.
Steve Yemm
And thank you to my honorable friend for his comments and for his magnificent leadership over many, many years on this issue. But to return to my questions for the Minister. First, I'm curious to know if the government will commit to resolving the surplus sharing for both schemes. Secondly, if he might confirm that both sets of trustees' proposals, including protecting Mineworkers' 2024 bonus pensions and using the undistributed surpluses, are being considered by the Treasury. And third, that the government will work with the trustees so those genuinely available surpluses can be paid out as they arise, rather than elderly pensioners waiting years for the next valuation.
And fourth, will the government work with the trustees to look at the long-term future of both schemes so that they keep serving their members as well as possible as the schemes get older. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me finish with this. For mining communities, this has never been purely about money. It's about whether this country respects the people who did the hardest jobs and powered everything else in the economy. And people in Mansfield and our communities have heard a lot of promises over the years.
This government has kept more of them on Mineworkers' pensions than any that went before it. And all of us on the Labour benches should be genuinely proud of that. But we shouldn't stop short at this moment. We've given back the reserves. Now let's sort out the surpluses while the men and women who earned these pensions are still here to enjoy them.
And after more than 30 years, we have waited, they have waited long enough. And I hope that the Minister can give them some hope tonight.
Blair McDougall
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable member for Mansfield for securing this debate, for his leadership on behalf of miners, but also for taking the time to recognize and remember today's anniversary. The poet Ron Cook described Aberfan as the day when the world stood still and the mountain moved. Aberfan is one of those tragedies that's so overwhelming in its injustice that it's painful to think about, but that's precisely why it's essential to remember. The speech also brought to mind a story I read of the Victoria Colliery disaster in my own constituency where 63 men and boys were killed.
The bodies were laid out in the churchyard of St John's Church in Barrhead, and local women faced the unimaginable horror of having to identify the remains not just of a husband but of a son.
I'll come to what miners are owed in a moment, but it's right we recognize at the start of this debate that those debts can't be repaid by anyone. My honorable friend says this is not about money, but as we discuss the money in pension schemes and its distribution, we remember that my God, miners earned every penny of it. As the honorable member will know well, the British Coal Superannuation Scheme dates back to 1946 and the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme to 1952. The British Coal Board, when it was privatized in 1994, the schemes were then closed to new entrants and the remaining employees were given the rights to participate in successor schemes. The government of the day gave the mine workers a guarantee: the value of the fund would not decrease, ensuring pensions would continue to be paid, while taking half of any surplus on the investment.
The other half could be used to improve benefits through bonus pensions. For the miners' scheme, this surplus sharing arrangement has continued, although this government has not taken any money from the scheme since we came to power in 2024. For the British Coal staff scheme, the surplus sharing arrangement was ended in 2015 and future benefits were fixed, ensuring pensions could be paid with the aim of returning the reserve to government in 2033. Since the 2015 changes, the schemes' investments have performed well, building up a reserve of 2.3 billion pounds. I join with honorable members in paying tribute to the campaigners who all the way through this have spoken up for miners and ensuring they get what they deserve.
Today, there remain almost 150,000 members of the two schemes, the vast majority of whom are receiving their pension. 5,000 of these are in the honorable member's constituency and 37,000 across the East Midlands. The average age of those members, as other honorable members have referred to across those two schemes, is 76 years old. The group includes 30,000 widows with an average age of 84 years old. We owe former mining communities that debt of gratitude for their contribution to national prosperity, and we must acknowledge and recognize the hard work and sacrifice of coal miners who powered this country for decades.
Ian Lavery
Thank you very much for giving way. I must declare an interest, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm a member of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme, former miner, probably the only miner in the Commons at this moment in time. We must recognize the fact that the Labour Party had on its manifesto in 2017, 2019, and 2024 seeking justice for the mine workers within the pension scheme. It was only when you get elected you're allowed to represent and deliver on your manifesto. And let me just say that we actually did that.
We made a huge difference only a few months ago. There's a lot more to do, and I'm going to ask the minister, the same as what other people have asked, can he give assurances to the members of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme, the families, the widows, that he'll do everything in his power to make sure at the budget next week the full justice is restored to miners in our coalfields.
Blair McDougall
Well, I pay tribute to his work on behalf of miners throughout his life. I'll come to the specifics of the scheme and the ask he makes in a moment, but he's absolutely right that it's issues like this that are exactly why all of us came into politics in the first place, to deliver for those individuals.
Previous governments have failed to ensure that former British coal employees got the level of pension that they deserved. In 2021, the then select committee looking at the mine workers' pension scheme recommended that the government took no further funds from the scheme, transferred the reserve to scheme members and reviewed the surplus sharing arrangements. That Conservative government declined to accept those recommendations and miners, as my honorable friend has just said, deserve those historic wrongs to be righted. That's why the government is implementing those recommendations in respect of both schemes. We continue to guarantee both schemes, ensuring that schemes' pensions will always be paid.
In 2024, as been said, one of the first decisions we made was to transfer the 1.5 billion pound investment reserve in the miners' scheme for use as bonus pensions. The hard work of the MPs behind me meant that this increased incomes by 32% and an average of 29 pounds per week. We've also transferred the 2.3 billion pound equivalent within the British coal staff scheme and this led to a 41% increase in pension incomes last December backdated to November 2024. On average, this meant an extra 100 pounds a week in scheme members' pockets and as has been said into the local economies within their communities. That is direct support for the pensioners in the local communities which powered this country for decades.
But as everyone in this debate has said, there is more to do. My honorable friend raises important questions and we are in that terrible pre-budget period where I know lots of people stand at this dispatch box and ask for patience and I have to do the same. But I also say that with the recognition, as has been said, that we're dealing with people who are incredibly advanced in their years and cannot afford to wait indefinitely. We've been discussing proposals for future arrangements for the scheme with the trustees, including the potential for those future surpluses to be used to enhance benefits and we've been making good progress. The government will make an announcement once that agreement has been formally reached and we're seeking to do that as swiftly as possible with also, as others have said, managing wider funding risks.
The government and trustees have had very constructive discussions and I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, to be in a position to announce a way forward shortly and I'll continue to work with honorable members towards that end.
Speaker 321
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. Order, order.