Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee House of Lords
Follow its sittingsGavin Robinson
So I I did not share nor did my community share the concerns that were expressed. I sometimes fear that the government of the day negotiated and implemented these provisions simply to assuage those concerns without thinking about the practical application of them.
And in many other aspects of the negotiated outcome between the European Union and the United Kingdom, clearly did not think about the practical outworkings of them. And so the political import of that is in my view to do the exact opposite of what was intended. The purpose was to enshrine rights and reflect protections that you can find in the in the rights chapter of the Belfast Agreement. Through a negotiated outcome that had no political support whatsoever in Northern Ireland amongst the unionist community. A Belfast Agreement that requires is predicated upon cross-community consent and yet none existed.
And the expansionist way in which we've seen Article 2 being interpreted confirms the view that in many ways, why was it negotiated, I can't tell you why, but the political significance of it is to enshrine in law an oxymoron. Something that was intended to protect rights and in doing so the very heart of the negotiated outcome undermines the rights of one section of our community within this country.
Nigel Dodds
Thanks very much Lord Chair and thank you Gavin for coming to give evidence. I know it's a very busy week for you especially with the events of the weekend coming up and so on so we appreciate it. Um so you've already started to go down the route of of of the issue of the Belfast Agreement, Good Friday Agreement and so on and how you see it being impacted by the protocol, Windsor Framework and so on. So I'd be grateful, you know people talk in terms of sovereignty, in terms of the democratic deficit, but in terms of the Belfast Agreement and famously you know one of the main architects of that agreement David Trimble was was vehemently opposed to the protocol and so on because of the arguments that you've started to outline. So maybe you could elaborate exactly where is the problem for having the protocol sitting alongside the Belfast Agreement?
What are the elements of it that you think are in breach of that agreement?
Gavin Robinson
Yeah thank you for the question Lord Dodds and I have touched on it briefly but I think fundamentally when I say oxymoron, a contradiction in terms, something there to protect against the diminution of rights, diminish the rights of half of our population. The Belfast Agreement and the rights chapter itself is clear about all of us having the right to pursue democratically national and political aspirations and I take nothing away from that within the Belfast Agreement. But in bringing forth the arrangements as our government and the European Union did with no recourse, no consultation or effective understanding of the view of the unionist community they completely diminished our view and our rights. They have called into question the appellant opportunities, the constitutional position of Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom, something which at the heart of the Belfast Agreement was settled, the consent principle and the consent required from both communities within Northern Ireland. And you can see over the last four five years the discord and the damage it has caused to political stability in Northern Ireland.
And so if the aspiration was to protect political stability it's been upended and there is a naivety to the view that these issues will subside, that they aren't as genuine or they aren't as troublesome as perhaps was made out.
That's not the case. And from a Northern Ireland perspective, understanding and recognizing the constitutional sovereignty of my country has been diminished and tarnished by the government of the day and our national parliament in agreeing the provisions of the Windsor Framework. And that is something that I as a political leader have to wrestle with. That is something that I as an individual who speaks on behalf of a community who has been burdened unnecessarily by these provisions have to speak to, but also have to maturely and respectfully operate within the realms of our political system. And I don't see any concern within this Labour government, or indeed in the previous Conservative government, that they have impinged so fundamentally on the foundations of the political settlement reached here almost 30 years ago.
Alex Alexander Carlile
Can we just focus on sovereignty a little more? You're a member of the Westminster Parliament, so you subscribe to the sovereignty of Parliament for the United Kingdom. You're talking about the sovereignty of Northern Ireland as a discrete matter, and no doubt it is, that's what all the devolved parts of the United Kingdom assume. But how far are you limited in your aspirations to sovereignty by the possibility that the United Kingdom Parliament may thwart you through the ordinary democratic process in the United Kingdom?
Gavin Robinson
I don't assert sovereignty on behalf of Northern Ireland, so I will invert the assumption that's been outlined there. I don't assert sovereignty on behalf of Northern Ireland or the people of Northern Ireland. I believe in the sovereignty of the United Kingdom, but I believe that our sovereign Parliament and our government should have had regard for an international obligation which rises above politics in the United Kingdom. An obligation to respect the settlement that was reached in the Belfast Agreement, an obligation to understand that any changes to the constitutional position of Northern Ireland require the consent of its people. So it's not that I assert Northern Ireland's sovereignty over United Kingdom sovereignty, I do not.
I am a unionist within this country, but I expect our sovereign Parliament to have regard to what is recognized as an international treaty and a treaty that brought peace. And the idea, the very idea that either our peace is predicated upon the involvement of the European Union, I think is offensive to those who fought and secured for peace in this part of our United Kingdom. And I also regret that if the aspiration or the intention was to protect the fundamentals of the Belfast Agreement, it produced an outcome which is so fundamentally injurious to it.
Alex Alexander Carlile
Does that mean that if Article 2 was not just unnecessary but very unwise and not required in any way, then when we move on to something like, when we move on to a detail like the Dillon case, you would be saying actually the Dillon case in itself is also on the face of it completely irrelevant, shouldn't have happened, and whatever decision is made of the Dillon case, we shouldn't be there?
Is that fair?
Gavin Robinson
There are probably a number of aspects to that question because of course the Dillon case didn't consider one Article 2, it considered two Article 2s. In considering legacy issues, it considers Article 2 right to life issues and the obligations on a state to investigate properly instances where there have been a loss of life. And secondly and separately then, I think the Dillon case proved fundamentally important in part in satisfying or at least providing some level of clarity to the, in my political view, outrageous expansionist approach to Article 2. No diminution of rights asserted in Article 2 of Windsor Framework is a commitment given at a period of time, the time in which we left the European Union. You know well that there are some activists, including those provided for by the Belfast Agreement to protect rights, who have interpreted Article 2 to have some level of dynamic alignment.
They also seem to infer that there is a greater emphasis or should be a greater emphasis and import on ensuring no distinction of rights between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland without any concern about the integrity of rights within this United Kingdom. And when you consider that this framework comes from Belfast Agreement and you consider that the aspiration was to protect the rights which start with the understanding and appreciation that Northern Ireland is a part of the United Kingdom, I worry. I know about the friction that arises from a trade border in the Irish Sea. I worry fundamentally that the next aspiration is a rights border in the Irish Sea where the questions of rights within this United Kingdom are not determined by our sovereign government, our parliament, or our independent courts, but determined elsewhere by others who are not there to protect our interests. That is a concern for me.
And so I think Dillon did helpfully provide some level of clarity, though not in totality, the issues that pervade and arise from Article 2. And fundamentally as this, as a member of parliament who represents this part of East Belfast of Northern Ireland and also as a political leader who speaks on behalf of Northern Ireland issues all the time, whenever we see legislation proposed in Westminster, sadly our first question isn't how will it helpfully impact our constituents or adversely impact them, how will this treat society in Northern Ireland, the first question is will it even apply? And that can't be right.
Alex Alexander Carlile
I've trespassed on your territory, but I'm sure you've got more questions to ask.
Arlene Isobel Foster
Thank you, and thank you Gavin for your evidence. So I want to ask you maybe in more detail about the Dillon judgment, but I also want to reflect on some evidence that we were given yesterday by some of the victims' groups when they pointed out to this committee that when you talk about no diminution of rights as in 2020, actually there were lots of rights that we didn't have at that stage, such as the definition of a victim which is so broad that it includes those people who blew themselves up in terrorist situations and what have you and their families. So they were very clear to us that actually when you talk about no diminution of rights, actually we didn't have those rights to start with in 2020 and they feel very strongly about that. But in terms of Dillon, it was the Supreme Court, it was the highest court in our jurisdiction, but yet there seem to be a lot of people who want to challenge that judgment and are very unhappy with that judgment. How do you see Dillon and the judgment that was handed down by the Supreme Court as impacting on Article 2?
Do you see it in a favorable way or what way do you see it?
Gavin Robinson
I think it has added, and thank you for the question, I think it has added helpful clarity, but in a discrete way. So when it talks about the provisions being too vague and transcribed in general terms within the rights and equality safeguarding opportunity chapter of the Belfast Agreement, I think it is right to curtail a level of the expansionism, but it's only one level of the expansionism. Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee took evidence, Lord Chair, if you don't mind me referencing it, last week on reconciliation. And there was an exchange between myself and one of the witnesses around the Dillon case. And I have to say that the position outlined to us, in my view, was utterly pathetic.
Pleased with the outcome in the lower courts and completely ignorant of the import of the Supreme Court. No interest in the Supreme Court's view, no reflection about how it fundamentally augments the legal advice that they had in relation to the ICRIR and how we deal with issues affecting our past. And that's where the politics and the campaigning gets in the way of either the legal understanding or indeed other associated aspects of their politics. I respect everyone has a different aspiration, but you can't read into that which is not there. And so whether it is on alignment, continuing dynamic alignment of rights, or whether it is a continued opportunity or hope that Article 2 will frustrate the sovereign will of our Parliament, that is not only negative, it is wrong.
And it is something that I think our government needs to be much more full-throated in their response to. Our government has been very disorganized, slovenly, disinterested about the import of particular lines within explanatory memorandum. We know that throughout all of our scrutiny in the past and your committee's scrutiny to this day, when officials look at proposals for legislation in a singular way, they tend not to think about these issues. They tend not to think about the import for Northern Ireland. And even when they do, there's a concern, and it was risen in the Dillon judgment, that explanatory memorandum believe that some definitional issue of victims, for example, in the European Parliament may be in scope of Article 2.
That's loose language for a government's explanatory memorandum.
Alex Alexander Carlile
Baroness Ludford may want to develop this issue a little further.
Sarah Ludford
Oh no, not at all, no, no, it's interesting just that the point resonates. I mean, I wondered what you, you said that you thought that Dillon did provide some clarity, but not total clarity, I think we'd probably all agree with that, on what is the scope of Article 2. How do you imagine or envisage that further clarity could be brought, what would be the means and the processes about how you could, you know, firm up that clarity?
Gavin Robinson
Well, I think for those issues outside of our control, there will be further examples of cases brought before our courts and the judiciary will give a view. There is still an expectation on the part of some that the Dillon judgment from our Supreme Court will be challenged in Strasbourg. And I don't know if that will come to pass or not. But what should we be able to control? I think the time has come for our government to be incredibly clear in a declaratory way as to what their interpretation is.
I don't believe it is right for this to be left solely to our courts or for the judiciary to come up with their construct with the information available to them. I believe fully in the independence of our judiciary, but it is for legislators to legislate and it is for our government to be very precise on limiting the scope of Article 2.
Sarah Ludford
So what you're possibly suggesting is a new explainer document, because the government withdrew the original explainer document and we have been led to understand, and I think some witnesses seem to have the same understanding, that the government position so far is that the written evidence they gave to this committee for this inquiry is meant to be a sort of substitute for the explainer, but we're not sure whether we're going to get a new kind of definitive document. Is that the kind of thing that you would want to see, some authoritative document from the government saying, "This is what we believe Dillon means for Article 2"?
Gavin Robinson
I think I would expect, and I'm not saying that that would be in and of itself an unuseful document, I think it would have purpose and use. But Article 2 goes beyond Dillon and the issues raised in Dillon. The court answered, as I said, helpfully some areas of clarification, but I believe the import to be much more broad and more significant. And I don't think that it can rest solely through explanatory memoranda or through notes from government or Cabinet Office to a committee of Parliament. I think government should be bringing forward in Westminster, in both Houses, be it motions or legislation, to lay out very clearly and asserting sovereignty on the interpretation of these issues.
Alex Alexander Carlile
I was following you absolutely until that last phrase, that last clause about needing further legislation. I mean, if one applies a sort of Occam's razor principle to this, that the simple explanation is often more useful than the complicated explanation, then you seem to be saying Article 2 plus Dillon has reduced the import of Article 2 to a group of issues which were reasonably well defined in Dillon, left some open. Other issues are defined by the general law, various pieces of human rights law applying to employment, non-discrimination and so on. And that really you don't need much in the way of an explainer document because the ordinary law is there. And the only following questions would be, well, are there any rights that are applicable in Great Britain that are not available in Northern Ireland and therefore would we like to look for legislation to deal with those?
Gavin Robinson
I don't think that's a fair reflection of what it was I was suggesting. I believe in fairness to our judiciary, a postscript issued by government trying to reassert the intention of the day would be insufficient for the judiciary to take it as Parliament's intention.
I believe Parliament would need to be clearer, and that's government through Parliament, clearer in what it understands and potentially legislatively for the import to be. I mean, I see a narrowing of some of the civil rights issues through the Dillon judgment. I see no sense that those who have engaged in judicial militancy or legislative militancy, or those who've used judicial activism to try and burnish their view on dynamic alignment of rights, for example, have stopped. I don't believe that they have. These issues will come before the courts again.
There were elements, as you know, associated to immigration. And I've said I don't want to see a trade border in the Irish Sea. I don't want to see a rights border in the Irish Sea. I do not want to see as a full citizen of this United Kingdom a people border in the Irish Sea either. Question: are there application or implications of Article 2 on immigration and how we as a sovereign country protect our own borders?
Question. And separately, we know from the Women of Scotland case, a very clear case drawing upon legislation that predates our withdrawal from the European Union, no diminution of rights. Still to this day, government departments in Northern Ireland either incapable or unwilling to adhere to the outworkings of that Supreme Court decision because they query whether it can stand in light of Article 2. So my view is that for as long as these things are before the courts, a postscript explainer from government would be insufficient to assist the courts in understanding Parliament's intention of the provisions of Article 2.
Elizabeth Sanderson
Thank you, Chair. Hi there. So, so the question that we have is do you believe people in Northern Ireland understand what Article 2 is for? And I suppose there's two parts to that: those with the expansionist view and using it for certain agendas, perhaps, and then that sort of, you know, the view that you have. And I suppose I'm interested in both of those sides and your views on it.
But also, you're the second person to mention a rights border today and you think it's naive to think that this won't get bigger. So I'm quite interested, even if people don't realize it's Article 2 that they're referring to, quite a few people have spoken today of the unease their constituents, their communities feel at their rights perhaps being taken away from them and feeling that on a day-to-day basis without being able to say what's Article 2.
Gavin Robinson
Yes. I think your question sort of conceptualizes it properly. If I were to walk down the Newtownards Road in my constituency or the Shankill Road in West Belfast or any other unionist part of Northern Ireland and ask somebody what their view is on Article 2, they might walk on quite quickly. But the genuine understanding of the encroachment on our constitutional position, on feeling less British, on feeling that the rights afforded to us are not the same as those rights afforded to citizens in Scotland, England, or Wales, they understand that. They understand when they go onto Amazon as consumers or eBay or Etsy and they can't buy products.
They understand when they hear manufacturers say they have to fill out forms to send items from Lisburn to Liverpool, forms that manufacturers from Leeds to Liverpool have never heard of, don't need to do. They understand it when the gift shop of the House of Commons refuses to send all of their wares to citizens in this United Kingdom in Northern Ireland.
Gavin Robinson
That is a fact. And it used to be, my Lord Chair, it used to be solely confined to products containing alcohol. It is now capturing a whole range of products because of general product safety regulations. Now you and I both, your committee and I, will have considered the Product Safety and Metrology Bill. We know that that was meant to reach a level of alignment on product safety across this United Kingdom and across the European Union.
And yet still our national parliament, a sovereign parliament, is incapable of posting items from one part of our country to another because of these arrangements. Now I know that's not Article 2 issue, so I don't wish to deflect, but I think it's important to raise it with you all. And why should a child in Northern Ireland, in fact I know Lord Dodds has somebody close to him who's expecting, and if he wanted to buy them one of our great bibs or Speaker's teddy bears for that child, then why shouldn't he be able to? Now he can smuggle it in himself, honorably as a member of the House of Lords, but he can't post it and that's wrong. So forgive me, my lady, for diverting from your question.
Margaret Ritchie
Thank you, Lord Chair, and Gavin, you're very welcome. Obviously, you have raised various issues in relation to Article 2. And for purposes of clarification, because we live in a divided society here in Northern Ireland where there are varying views on Article 2, there are varying views on rights issues, and also varying views on the Good Friday Agreement and that Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity chapter, how can the rights of all be protected?
Gavin Robinson
Thank you for the question, it's good to see you too. We have gone away from our Scrabble games. I know, that is true. But the truth is I don't even call the document that you refer to as the Good Friday Agreement the Good Friday Agreement. I call it the Belfast Agreement, so we can't even agree on that.
You are right that there are different perspectives in all of this, but go back to the foundation. The Belfast Agreement or the Good Friday Agreement accepted Northern Ireland's place within the United Kingdom unless it changed otherwise through the consent of our people. So that is there. I don't think we disagree on that. And I don't think you and I would either disagree with Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity chapter's assertion that you have the given right, the assumed right, the actual right to have a different political aspiration from me.
Nobody's challenging that. But when you have provisions that fundamentally unpick those foundations within the Belfast Agreement in a whole range of areas, whether it's trade, on rights, potentially in immigration, on gender issues and all the rest, then my point is that yes, you're right, there will be people with competing aspirations. My difficulty is the aspirations or the concerns of one section of the community, which I believe were misplaced, but you can set aside my belief they were misplaced because that's my prejudiced view, were accepted by a government and to solve those concerns impacted the rights of the other community.
And we are dealing with the consequences of that today. So I think you're right to say there are different perspectives and there are different views and all of those in my view as a unionist, proud unionist in Northern Ireland can be accommodated with this United Kingdom, within this United Kingdom. But we shouldn't be in a situation where I as a democratic elected member of parliament are concerned that legislation brought before our national parliament on national and reserved issues like immigration, for example, may be impacted upon, may be impacted upon by the provisions of Article 2 Windsor Framework.
Margaret Ritchie
And just a supplementary Lord Chair, in relation to safeguarding the union of which you were a significant negotiator, were those issues in relation to Article 2 discussed with the previous government by yourself?
Gavin Robinson
I think I've raised Article 2 quite continually in the House of Commons. So rather than talk about you will see what's there in the document, I'm not going to talk behind what's there in safeguarding the union. But I raise continually, particularly around the illegal immigration act, the illegal migration act 2022 or 3, I raised on the floor my concerns about the application of Article 2 repeatedly. Interestingly, both the Secretary of State for Home Office and immigration minister in the Home Office at that time were both conservatives and both disagreed fundamentally with my position. Neither of them are in the Conservative Party today and both of them agree with the position and concerns that we outlined.
So Article 2 and the impact on immigration is something that we have raised and continue to raise quite continually.
Thank you.
Alex Alexander Carlile
See one of the things that's happening to this committee is that we've received a lot of evidence from people who have broadly comparable views with yours and you've expressed them with special clarity in my view. But we have not received evidence from political parties which have a different view. So I think this question is, supposing that this committee were to come to the conclusion that we absolutely agreed with everything you've said and that Article 2 is now redundant, if it was ever not redundant, and these issues can be dealt with within Northern Ireland in other ways without the difficulties of Article 2, which was not required under the Belfast Agreement. What would be the political response to that in your view here in Northern Ireland?
Speaker 22
The political response would be one of great joy and jubilation from people like me. So feel free to do it. I think in fairness to your committee, I expect you to be more detailed and honorable than that and you will consider all of the issues even if you haven't been given... We have actually heard evidence, we've received evidence from written evidence from Sinn Féin and we've heard from the SDLP, but we haven't had the opportunity to hear witnesses. So I haven't read their evidence and I don't know the content of it, but I suspect that whenever they achieved what they achieved through the political theatrics of Leo Varadkar and papers with border scenes and cross-border checkpoints and all the rest, when they achieved what they achieved, they really have no interest in what this committee says.
They will be disrespectful, I believe, I'm not saying they are because I don't know what they've said, but I imagine that they will be disrespectful to the work in which you are engaged. They will have no interest in anything you do unless they fear you may achieve something by your report, at which point they will speak over your head and they will in direct terms express to government how wrong you are.
Gavin Robinson
That's what they do. They they don't care about the the detail of this nor do they engage at times from democratic scrutiny committee's perspective or indeed with Lord Murphy. I don't think Lord Murphy was given the courtesy of thorough or thoughtful engagement because when you have that which suits and you can express no concern for your neighbors who happen to have a different view then you've no need to do anything. And that's a sad thing.
Tom Elliott
Thank you Lord Chair and thank you Gavin for the presentation and for coming to the committee. And I suppose mine's more about what may happen now and obviously in light of the Dillon judgment and cognizant of of what you said about you know there's a narrowing of the dynamic alignment and that a new explainer document probably isn't going to do anything greatly. How would you see both the UK government and the Northern Ireland executive meeting the the requirements of of rights particularly rights based in their legislation any new legislation that's that's coming forward and obviously we're we're also very aware that we heard yesterday from the victims group who said Dillon didn't matter to them one way or the other because they didn't have those rights in the first place. They they didn't have their inquiries. They didn't have further questions that they could submit simply because their only process was through the ICRIR.
They didn't have the the further inquest or or inquiry.
Gavin Robinson
Yeah I mean you've referenced it and Baroness Foster referenced the evidence you have taken from victims. And I always think in these things whenever people get what they want they don't engage in in anything that would undermine the position that they have. And so one definition for a victim quite clearly I don't believe there is one definition of a victim. There was a definition established in law for the commissioning and the creation of the victims commission separate and distinct from a completely different but morally pure definition of a victim that applies and Baroness Foster fought for this continually in respect of compensation for innocent victims applies in a separate piece of legislation. Two competing definitions.
One born out of moral principle and the other born out of political expediency. And so I I mean I hear very much what the victims have indicated to you but I always think that the danger is you will hear people and people will give evidence to this committee if it were about victims issues and say there is one legal definition of a victim there is not. But you will have asserted as fact that which is promotional or expedient in the circumstances. Where do we go from here? The United Kingdom needs to assert sovereignty.
The United Kingdom needs to assert through our parliament that it is our courts that interpret our laws. I don't see a screed or a list of areas of life which the rights attached to them are fundamentally different in Northern Ireland than the rest of the United Kingdom nor do I believe that if that were to be the case that you couldn't assert those rights within our national courts. But I think the fundamental danger that our government is going to have to grapple with is this ongoing lack of clarity about our national parliament's ability to legislate in a uniform way across this United Kingdom or consider the competencies of devolved governments and their ability to legislate as they see fit within our constitutional framework.
And for me today, even post-Dillon, that is still an unclear picture. And the totality of the issues that arise from Article 2 have not been resolved through Dillon. And so where do we go from here? I think very much we need government through our sovereign Parliament to assert itself on these issues. Do I have confidence that that will happen in the short term?
No, I do not. I felt that the Lord Murphy review, good and though as he is, was a missed opportunity. I believe that the negotiations that were to assist us in Northern Ireland through the UK-EU summit have not been focused on the right issues. They're quite singular in nature. I lament that the summit that was due for the start of July is not likely to happen until the end of this year, potentially October, potentially November.
If there is an outcome, that wouldn't be implemented for at least another year. And that is on SPS and potentially some rights issues around student visas and some associated immigration issues. I don't think that has the aspiration required for the people of Northern Ireland at this stage. And I cannot ignore the commentary in the last 24 hours about the European Union's focus shifting fundamentally from those negotiations between our government and the European Union to the notion that Canada could become an associate member. And I wonder, for the complexity of things that we face here in Northern Ireland, in this one part of our country to the rest of our country, will any of the same constraints be placed on Canada?
Will the same difficult, intransigent position adopted by the European Union sustain in respect of... I suspect not.
Alex Alexander Carlile
So in the negotiations for a reset, I know there's been a change of ministers which has slowed that down, but we're still negotiating a reset. And dynamic alignment is an inevitable part of that reset. If you were given a wishlist for the parts of the dynamic alignment that might relate to Northern Ireland, what would that list be?
Gavin Robinson
You see, we're already in the uncomfortable, non-constitutionally sound position of having to adhere to dynamic alignment in a whole host of areas. I think in respect of reset, the aspiration is that England, Scotland, and Wales find themselves as subjugated as us. Now, that remains to be determined.
Alex Alexander Carlile
But if you were... if your voice was being heard, what would you want to be dealt with in the realignment?
Gavin Robinson
So the outworkings of what I believe that reset means is that England, Scotland, and Wales would be in such a position that the distinction between the two of us, Northern Ireland and the rest of Great Britain, is no longer necessary. And when I say the Labour government are lacking ambition, nobody is clear with me or capable of outlining to me how, if you have uniformity in sanitary and phytosanitary products and animal health and general product safety regulations and in a whole host of other areas, what's the need for the separate but equal architecture? Why should Northern Ireland still sit at the back of the bus?
Nigel Dodds
Just to pick up on that point, because it's very interesting and it's going to be very much a very relevant part of the debate in the coming months, and this argument will be deployed quite extensively, I would have thought, that this is in the best interests of Northern Ireland.
But would you agree that one of the problems with that approach is, oh, this will lessen the problems for Northern Ireland, is that it's a negotiation between Great Britain and the European Union? Northern Ireland's position is separate and settled, and what it does is bring Great Britain into line. But the problem with that is that that could be an entirely temporary position. A new government, and there's a realistic possibility that a new government will come in which will take an entirely different view of dynamic alignment and say, be gone.
Nigel Dodds
Particularly, well, rights, or all of this trade stuff, SPS, everything. And at that point, it isn't that everything then disappears, but Northern Ireland will be left back in the same position that it is currently. So I presume that, you know, that's one of the issues that worries us about this idea that this alignment of Great Britain is a solution.
Gavin Robinson
And worse, that the turmoil created between the constituent parts of the United Kingdom about why other parts of the United Kingdom are going to have to put up with the injurious nature and requirements that are currently required of us, that'll breed resentment within parts of our United Kingdom. We're only having to do this because of them or us. Now, it is interesting, Lord Chair, when we are talking about rights, and I did reference that we shouldn't be sitting at the back of the bus. But separate but equal, if it was unsuitable in the United States of America in the 1950s and 60s, it's unsuitable in the United Kingdom in 2026.
Alex Alexander Carlile
There's a new Secretary of State, of course, there's a new Minister for Europe, Mr. Faulkner. To what extent are the Irish political parties being consulted at the present time in relation to the reset? Northern Ireland political parties, sorry.
Gavin Robinson
Yeah, I was thinking of an answer in relation to the Irish. I mean, I have no idea about the Republic of Ireland, but I'm sure the answer is too much.
I meant the Northern Ireland ones.
Gavin Robinson
I'm sure the answer is too much. In respect of Northern Ireland, I would have had quite, I say regular, I mean, you know, every month or so, a catch-up with Nick Thomas-Symonds when he was responsible as Paymaster General. I have not had a detailed discussion with Hamish Falconer since he has been appointed, though I did have a discussion with the head of the Windsor Framework Taskforce team about four or five weeks ago when they were present in Belfast.
And the Secretary of State?
Gavin Robinson
On this issue, not at all. The engagement with the Secretary of State, aside from our introductory meeting where I was outlining our position, the focus of his attention has been on the budget situation of Northern Ireland and the Troubles Bill that's likely to return to Parliament when we return from recess.
Alex Alexander Carlile
Right, well, I'm afraid we've run out of time, otherwise we might have continued for a long time in this very interesting discussion. So I'm going to draw the session to a close by reminding you that you'll receive a verbatim transcript, you know that, which will be sent to you for correction. Thank you very much for your evidence, it's been a really, really interesting session. You've been very clear and you're concise and...