House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittings



Sir Julian Lewis.
Julian Lewis
Does the Foreign Secretary accept that it would be a disservice to the democratic process to identify attempts to interfere with it with invalidation of the result? And does he, like the Prime Minister, now accept that whatever Russia tried to do, it did not have any decisive effect on the referendum whether to stay or leave the European Union?
Speaker 3
I and the Prime Minister have always accepted the result of the Brexit referendum and it's important to say that, Mr. Speaker. I do think it's important whatever side we were on in that debate though, or indeed debates across this House, that I think we all recognize that Russia is seeking to interfere all the time and disrupt and destabilize our democracy. And I know the honorable gentleman has a proud record on these issues.
Pari Mon.
Perran Moon
Moraz Samit-Andar, Mr. Speaker. Last Wednesday, Georgia's Constitutional Court began hearings on a lawsuit brought by the ruling Georgian Dream party seeking to ban the country's five main opposition parties.
At a time when external authoritarian actors seek to undermine democratic institutions across Europe, what steps is the Government taking with our European allies to respond to the deterioration of democracy in Georgia?
Speaker 3
Well, whether it's in Georgia or elsewhere, Mr. Speaker, and I'm glad my honorable friend raised this, it's incredibly important that we speak out in favor of democratic norms and ways of life. We know that we face more of a threat to democracy and the rule of law really than any time since World War II from hostile actors across the world, and this Government will bow to nobody in speaking out in favor of democracy and the values shared across this House.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Mr. Speaker, Moscow ships stalk our cables, Tehran's agents seek to assassinate on our soil, and last week the Pentagon declared Confucius Institutes a threat to our national security.
In stark contrast, the powers I secured to allow these weapons of the Chinese Communist Party to be closed here in the UK were scrapped by this government. So does the Foreign Secretary think that Washington has got it wrong? And if not, will the powers be reinstated and deployed? And while at it, will he expel every Iranian official with links to the Ministry of Intelligence and Security and bring our allies together to freeze Russian and Belarusian tourist visas to protect us from their use of these visas to attack our country?
Secretary of State.
Speaker 3
Well, I welcome the honorable lady to her place. And look, she talks eloquently about the threats we face from across the world, whether it's Russia or Iran or the threats we face from China.
And it is incredibly important, and this government will be absolutely resolute in countering these threats, whatever form they take. And frankly, and this is why this question is so relevant, Mr. Speaker, that the means of threats to our national life have changed, and they are not simply the threats we are used to in the past, but this hybrid warfare is the modern threat, and we will absolutely counter it.
Calum Miller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Foreign money can be used to influence politics through sport. On the 17th of December last year, the government gave Roman Abramovich 90 days to hand over the proceeds of the sale of Chelsea Football Club to benefit Ukrainians. 314 days later, that has still not happened. What is holding the government back from enforcing its own legal contract with Mr. Abramovich through the courts?
When might Ukrainians who are fearful about the winter see some of this money? And in light of this and questions over the ownership of Manchester City by Sheikh Mansour, what conversations has the Foreign Secretary had with the Prime Minister or Culture Secretary about ensuring that overseas investors are fit and proper persons to own English clubs?
Speaker 3
Well, let me directly deal with the most substantive part of his question. I think it is shared across this House that the ill-gotten gains of Russia and Russian oligarchs must be used for the right purposes, not the wrong purposes. I think that not just on the question he raised, and I'm going to be careful what I say about that because of legal processes, but we are absolutely determined to take action on the question he raised around Chelsea. But more broadly, one of the things that we will be urging in the coming months is the EU, our EU partners and in Britain, us moving on Russian sovereign assets more generally. Because we know that one of the most important things we need to do is give proper support to Ukraine through this winter and beyond, and Russian sovereign assets are a very, very ideal way to do that.
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, we have raised the UK's serious concerns about Iran's nuclear program, including the Foreign Secretary directly with Foreign Minister Araghchi. Iran has accumulated over 400 kilograms of uranium enriched to 60%, a level which goes beyond any credible civilian justification. And Iran's ongoing lack of IAEA cooperation led us with 22 countries to vote to report Iran to the UN Security Council for its continued non-compliance and refusal to allow inspectors access. And a negotiated solution remains the way forward to address Iran's nuclear program, and we're working with partners in that regard.
John Cooper.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Iran is tiptoeing towards a bomb.
This is an existential threat for our friend and ally Israel. And I cannot understand how glad-handing the despotic Iranian regime and making fake TikTok videos in New York helps world peace. Surely we can do more.
Stephen Doughty
With the greatest respect, Mr. Speaker, the Foreign Secretary raised very seriously at those highest levels Iran's nuclear program and a series and a series of other issues, just as previous Foreign Secretaries have raised serious concerns directly with Iran, including many on his side. We are absolutely clear, Iran must never have a nuclear weapon. We are committed to working with others to ensure that it does not.
Uma Kumaran
The polar regions are areas of growing strategic importance where geopolitics, climate, and national security collide.
Our national security strategy identified the Arctic and Antarctic as emerging areas of strategic cooperation. I discussed this with my international counterparts and the honorable member and APPG Polar at the Arctic Circle Assembly in Reykjavik earlier this month. To protect the UK's interests, we know we must adapt. It's why I recently launched our updated UK Arctic policy framework.
Speaker 17
George Freeman. Thank you, sir, it's good to be back. Given the accelerating rate of Arctic sea ice melt, we're not many years away from an ice-free summer in the Arctic, with huge implications for sea levels, ocean currents, weather systems and growing commercial pressures for exploitation in the Arctic. I'm delighted, having been the minister for BAS, to be back chairing the All-Party Group for Polar Regions and to join the minister at the Arctic Assembly.
Would she agree with me that both in the Arctic and the Antarctic, not only are we now on the frontline of some very important science for global planetary sustainability, but geodiplomacy and technology, and an increasing Wild West, which this country has a major role to play in helping to regulate and convene good players in?
Uma Kumaran
I thank the honourable member for this important question, and I know he's got a long history on speaking up about these issues. He's absolutely correct. Shifting geopolitical and climate dynamics in the Arctic and Antarctic are intensifying strategic interest in new economic opportunities in the polar regions. These bring with them challenges and pose risks to regional governance and to UK interests overseas and at home, including challenges to our security and stability, domestic resilience, and supply chains. This is why we've updated our Arctic policy framework.
It's why I urge members from across the House to join the honorable member and join the APPG polar regions to have cross-party consensus on this work.
Jade Jessica Toale
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday I visited the National Oceanography Centre with the honorable member opposite to learn about the UK's leadership in polar science. And a real highlight, I got to meet Boaty McBoatface. So I wondered if the Minister could tell us a bit more about how the FCDO is coordinating cross-government work to deal with these emerging climate and security threats, as well as how we can leverage the UK's leadership in science and technology, climate finance, diplomacy and defense to this end.
Uma Kumaran
I thank my honorable friend for that question and I regret that I wasn't able to join the trip yesterday to see all of our capabilities. She's absolutely right, our climate and research work in the polar regions is vital.
We have cross-government work on this. We've updated the UK's Arctic policy framework to work on a number of these matters. It sets out our assessment of the key developments in the region. It recognises the Arctic as an area of strategic importance and that one that's vital for UK national security and domestic resilience. But it also makes sure that we're doing our part in the climate resilience of the region and making sure that our world-leading scientists are there and have the support they need to make sure we play our part in the world.
Wendy Morton
Thank you, Mr Speaker. We hear warnings from allies of China's Arctic ambitions and the risk of Beijing and Moscow dominating emerging shipping routes.
China is an Arctic Council observer, and two Chinese nationals were arrested in Norway in May on suspicion of espionage. So, Mr. Speaker, what concrete action is the Minister and the Foreign Secretary taking with Norway and our NATO allies to protect Britain's security, trade, and undersea infrastructure from hostile Chinese activity, and to prevent research and investment becoming cover for Beijing's Arctic mission?
Uma Kumaran
I thank the honorable lady for that question. We're clear there's no UK security without Arctic security. We're working closely with our partners in the region, that includes Norway. We will contest malign and destabilizing behaviors and activity that threaten our interests and the stability of the region. The United Kingdom is stepping up its investment in and capabilities for defense and deterrence in the High North, deepening the defense cooperation with allies through our NATO-first approach and the Joint Expeditionary Force to respond rapidly to the emerging threats that are in the region.
Rachel Taylor.
Speaker 3
Mr Speaker, on the 8th of September, Mr Speaker, with permission, I will answer questions four, five, nine and 16 together. On the 8th of September, I announced new measures to tackle settlement expansion, including a sanctions regime to target those that support, facilitate or profit from illegal settlement activity. We'll do everything in our power to stop the prospects of a two-state solution being destroyed by the expansion of illegal settlements.
Rachel Taylor.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Israeli human rights organisation Yesh Din has found that between 2005 and 2023, more than 93% of investigations into settler violence in the West Bank were closed without indictment, with just 3% resulting in convictions.
With the olive harvest underway, Palestinian farmers continue to face threats from settler violence. Will the Minister update the House on what steps the Government is taking to protect Palestinian farmers and ensure those responsible for violence are held to account?
Speaker 3
Janet Daby. My honorable friend asks a really important question, Mr. Speaker, and we have stepped in as the UK to support Palestinian farmers who lost their work permits in Green Line Israel. But I think the broader point that my honorable friend makes is the most important one. I'm very conscious that today is election day in Israel, and these are matters for the Israeli people, whichever government, and it is their choice, is elected today. I hope we can work with them to counter the settler terrorism that we see, because I think it is in nobody's interest, not least it is not in the interest of the security of Israel.
Nesil Caliskan
Thank you so much, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the government's new sanctions to address illegal settlement expansion in the West Bank, and of course we've all watched in great horror as Palestinians face injustice and ethnic cleansing. Indeed, a Human Rights Watch report found that Israeli forces have committed war crimes in the West Bank. Mr. Speaker, can I ask my right honorable friend, will he, as I'm sure he will, stand by his words to this House to not only call out injustice and suffering, but to act? And with that in mind, will the government sanction Israeli Defense Minister Katz and Major General Gove, who are implicated in these crimes?
Speaker 3
Well, let me join the speaker in wishing my honorable friend happy birthday and say how well informed Mr. Speaker is. The, I credit his staff myself. Mr. Speaker, in all seriousness, the situation in the West Bank is horrific and we're witnessing unprecedented levels of violence, including settler terrorism and indeed ethnic cleansing in some areas of the West Bank. I'm not going to speculate on future designations of specific individuals, but I do say to my honorable friend and others that we laid legislation this month to expand the global human rights sanctions regime to target those responsible for serious violations of international humanitarian law, and we will use those powers.
Janet Jessica Daby
Okay, I'll do it again then. Thank you.
So, I thank the Minister just for what he's, how he's been responding so far. Obviously, the E1 is a further terrifying situation for Palestinians who are vulnerable and have no protections. But can the Minister or Secretary of State really just say what sanctions are being put in place at present and what more they're doing just to ensure that those working on the E1 scheme are indeed sanctioned?
Speaker 3
Well, I think my honorable friend raises a really, really important issue which we have discussed in this House before, Mr. Speaker, which is the E1 development is a direct threat to the prospect of a two-state solution.
And I do want to be completely clear, and I said this on the day of the closing of the tenders, that those individuals and businesses who proceed with bids for E1 construction tenders risk facing the full force of UK sanctions. This is why this is much more than symbolism what we are doing. It is about substantively stopping the destruction of the prospect of a two-state solution.
Rosena Allin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As we speak here today, in the West Bank right now, Israel is yet again pursuing its brutal policy of collective punishment, with Hebron sealed off and over a thousand people due to have their homes demolished imminently. I welcome our government boldly placing sanctions on illegal Israeli settlements. And with Israelis going to the polls today, will the Minister commit to maintaining the pressure until illegal settlement expansion ends once and for all and we can truly, truly see the two-state solution that we all dream of?
Speaker 3
Well, my honorable friend speaks with great eloquence on these issues and I, and I want to agree with her, Mr. Speaker. I think it's right to say that the, the very important finding that we made was that the occupation was illegal and not just the settlements. And therefore, in furtherance of a two-state solution, the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, and that, and in furtherance of our policy of a two-state solution, we are going to take action in relation to the economic relationships we have. But my honorable friend is exactly right about this, which is it is about bringing peace to Palestinians and Israelis.
Sarah Green.
Sarah Green
The Foreign Secretary mentioned people running the risk of the full force of the sanctions regime given the new powers the government now has to sanction those funding and building illegal settlements. Can I ask about the E1 tenders which will be opened on the 19th of November and whether the Foreign Secretary will commit to sanctioning those companies bidding before that date, not once the bulldozers arrive?
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 3
Well, there's the sort of general approach that governments of both parties have had, which is not to speculate on sanctions and designations before we actually do them. But I just want to say very, very clearly to the honourable lady, because I'm glad she's raised this issue, we are determined to act to do all we can to prevent E1 from happening, the settlement building in E1 happening. And we've brought the sanctions regime, not the sanctions regime that's coming in in the next six months, but the extension of the GHR sanctions regime precisely so that we can take swift action.
Speaker 30
Mr. Speaker, the Foreign Secretary pledged to take action against specific companies who provide services for settlement expansion in the occupied Palestinian territories. Delek Group, which supports illegal settlements through the provision of refueling services to Israel military vehicles and the operation of fuel stations in East Jerusalem and the West Bank, has been flagged by the UN for human rights concerns and could receive over 200 million pounds in revenue through its majority stake in Ithaca Energy if the Rosebank field is approved. Given the Foreign Secretary has already said approval of Rosebank would be climate vandalism, what does he have to say about profits from Scotland's oil supporting illegal settlement expansion in the West Bank?
Speaker 3
I think I'm going to stick to my lane, as they say, Mr. Speaker.
Look, I don't, we don't talk about specific companies in relation to sanctions before we, before we take action. But the honourable gentleman should be in no doubt about the purposes, purpose of our sanction, sanctions regime, which is to prevent the growth of illegal settlements, which is destroying the prospects of a two-state solution.
Manuela Perteghella
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Alongside the expansion of illegal settlements, as we've heard, there has been growing concern about violence perpetrated by extremist settlers against Palestinian communities in the West Bank. Does the Secretary of State believe that the UK's current response is sufficient, and what further steps is he prepared to take to hold those responsible to account?
Speaker 3
Well, look, I say to the honourable lady in all honesty, I don't think the response of the international community as a whole has been sufficient. And that's why I made the statement I did on the 8th of September.
And in my department, across government, we are continuing to think how do we tackle the injustices we face across the world, not just in relation to the West Bank. And we will use all the powers at our disposal, including conversations with whatever government the people of Israel choose to elect, to say this settler terrorism must end. And I think that is shared right across this House.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the 14th of October, the UN's International Commission of Inquiry into the OPT and Israel published its latest report. It concluded, and I quote from paragraph 43, Israeli military operations in the West Bank since the 7th of October 2023 constitute a course of conduct that forms part of a widespread and systematic attack against the civilian population.
It continues that sexual and gender-based violence and targeted attacks against children form part of that coordinated action on the part of the Israeli military. This is not just settler terrorism, this is action of the current Israeli government. Can I ask the Secretary of State, has he read that report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry? Does he recognize its conclusions? How can he continue to treat the current Israeli government as an ally in that context?
And what further action will he take to ensure that the UK is not complicit in these abuses?
Speaker 3
Well look, I thank the honorable lady for her question. I think she will have, I have seen that report and I undertake to read it comprehensively.
Look, I would say to her, the reason we took the actions we did on the 8th of September was precisely to say we will not stand by in silence as the suffering continues in Gaza and the West Bank. You know, we called out increasing evidence of war crimes in Gaza, Gaza. We called out ethnic cleansing by settler terrorists in the West Bank. And we're going to act. And we, and we will work with her and, and others right across this house to make sure we take the maximum possible action to get what we want to see, which is peace, security and dignity for Israelis and Palestinians.
Joseph Simon Opher
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just over a year ago, the member for Bury St Edmunds and I were detained and then deported by Israeli authorities as we tried to enter the West Bank.
And just yesterday, the member for Norwich South, Arbroath, and the former MP Sam Tarry were similarly detained by Israeli authorities for eight hours whilst they tried to enter the West Bank. Will the Minister join me in condemning these cases and outline what steps the government will take to ensure that MPs can visit the occupied West Bank without obstruction or intimidation?
Speaker 3
Well, I'm glad my honorable friend has raised this case because we are obviously deeply concerned about the denial of entry to the West Bank for two members of Parliament and I believe one member of the Scottish Parliament as well, Mr. Speaker. Of course, we have raised this issue with the Israeli authorities and been in touch with the MPs to offer assistance. And I would say, you know, more broadly, that it's very, very important that members of this House, as they go about their business, not just in the UK but internationally, have free access so that they can actually do their duties to this House.
John Milne
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The government has declared the occupation unlawful and its measures on settlements depend on reliable evidence of what is actually happening on the ground. In April, the Foreign Office unit that tracked potential breaches of international law by Israel was closed because of cuts, with the work set to pass to a different team. Which team now does that work and how many officials does it have?
Speaker 3
No, I can assure him, Mr. Speaker, that this work carries on. We have excellent civil servants who work on all these issues including potential breaches of international humanitarian law. We take these issues incredibly seriously as a department and as a government.
Speaker 3
Mr. Speaker, in recent weeks I've been in Warsaw and Ukraine discussing defence and security with key allies. There is no bigger test of our values and our commitment to European security than Ukraine. And we will continue to stand shoulder to shoulder with the Ukrainian people.
We're also committed to building a stronger Europe in a stronger NATO as the ultimate guarantee of peace and security.
Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner
The attack on the then British Prime Minister's home last year was linked to Russian-backed proxies attempting to undermine our democracy. Mr. Speaker, I'm deeply concerned that our nation has become so anesthetized by online disinformation that we collectively shrugged and carried on doomscrolling. As such, I commend the creation of the National Center for Information Defense to counter cognitive warfare.
...counter cognitive warfare, but given the continued threat of Russian cognitive warfare, I ask the Foreign Secretary how he can cooperate with European partners to counter disinformation, shut down the networks, and hold technology companies to account.
Speaker 3
Well, we obviously have a defence and security partnership with the European Union, but my honourable friend speaks incredibly eloquently about these issues. Look, on the information point, we want to do, as I said in an earlier answer, more work with the European Union on these questions, and we'll be saying more about this in the coming weeks. But my honourable friend also raises the wider issues. Hybrid warfare is not just about information, information and misinformation, it is about sabotage, espionage, cyberattacks, and a whole range of issues, as we saw from the recent incident in Leipzig, and we need to be incredibly vigilant about it.
Andrew Mitchell
Thank you, Mr Speaker. As part of these discussions which he is holding with European countries, is he also emphasizing the vital role that soft power and the international development budget play in promoting security?
Does he realize that since this government's cuts to international development spend, we now allocate less for Africa out of the development budget than we allocate to UK postcodes from that same budget for first-year asylum seeker costs?
Speaker 3
Well, the right honorable gentleman speaks with enormous authority on these issues and has a proud record on these questions. And I couldn't agree with him more on the substantive part of his question about the role that international development plays. And he may know that as part of our G20 presidency next year, we have committed, in fiscally constrained times, to seek to do more on the combination of the debt burden, climate breakdown, and the need to grow and tackle poverty that developing countries are facing. We have to accept the fiscal constraints we face, but that doesn't mean we can't act, including through the multilateral development banks.
We have to accept the fiscal constraints we face, but that doesn't mean we can't act, including through the multilateral development banks, and I look forward to working with him and members across this house on these issues.
Anne Emily Thornberry
Thank you very much. Mr. Speaker, I learned a great deal in my recent trip to Ukraine last month. I learned that the Ukrainians see themselves as Europeans, they know who their friends are, they are incredibly grateful to Britain. But they are also very disappointed the fact that as they hit this very difficult winter, and we know that they are going to need about 90 billion pounds in order to get through it, there are 200 billion pounds of Russian assets frozen in Europe. What can we do as Britain to ensure that those assets are unlocked and used in Ukraine?
Is one way perhaps to lead by example? Is there something we can do about the 25 billion pounds worth of Russian assets that we have in the Ukraine, in the UK, and of course the 2.5 billion Chelsea assets that I think we're heading for an anniversary of when Abramovich was told that he had to hand them over now?
Speaker 3
Well, she speaks a good deal of sense as always, Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend, on these questions. On the fundamental point, as I said in an earlier answer, this issue of Russian sovereign assets is something we are determined to tackle. She may know there is a renewed push in the EU to take action on it. I have said to my EU counterparts that we are determined to act with them. And it goes to the broader point that she raises, which is Russia is seeking to test our resolve on Ukraine.
We must show that we will absolutely stand with the Ukrainian people until they prevail. And there's a number of elements to that, but one of them is this financial question and we are determined to act.
Mark Pritchard
On the job, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister told President Zelenskyy recently that he stood "in complete solidarity" with Ukraine over President Trump's dirty diesel deal with the Russian imports of Russian diesel. And I support the Prime Minister on that. He just mentioned to earlier question about hitting Russia in the pocket as it were. So why is it that his government that is still importing jet fuel and diesel, albeit through countries, they've weakened the sanctions against Russian diesel and fuel?
So I would suggest, Mr. Speaker, that is a complete inconsistency in UK foreign policy.
Speaker 3
If I could, I have great respect for the honorable gentleman, but even he's wrong about this. We've actually introduced a phased ban on maritime services in relation to gas, and that license is expires in January. So I just want to sort of reassure him on that point. But going be- but going beyond that, I am constantly seeking ways in my department with colleagues across government to ratchet up the economic pressure on Russia. That must be our aim, and I say to all of our allies, including the United States, that must be our aim because that is the way we get a successful outcome in this conflict.
David Reed
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In recent months, our European allies have become increasingly forthright in publicly naming hostile states responsible for attacks on their countries.
Yet Britain appears reluctant to do the same, and the Foreign Secretary has spoken very clearly about hybrid war. Now, over the weekend, it was reported that the crippling cyberattack on Jaguar Land Rover was state-sponsored. So does the Foreign Secretary agree that failing to publicly attribute such attacks only emboldens our adversaries, and more importantly, will he now name the state believed to be responsible for this unprecedented attack on British industry?
Speaker 3
I won't get into the details of that attack today, but what I will say to him is we're absolutely happy to name those who are engaging in this information warfare, and I've talked a lot in this session about Russia and about what it is doing. And the Prime Minister could not have been more eloquent at the UN General Assembly in talking about the over a billion pounds a year that Russia spends on information warfare.
I do say to the honorable gentleman, I sort of welcome him to his place, but I think there's actually cross-party agreement on this. We all want to tackle the information warfare that we face, and I look forward to working with members across the House in doing so.
Calum Miller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our defense and our economy are closely tied and both depend on our relationship with our closest neighbors. The Prime Minister wants to have an honest conversation with the public about Brexit. That begins with an honest assessment of its damage. The Conservatives' hard Brexit is costing the Treasury up to 90 billion pounds a year in lost tax revenues.
The biggest lever we can pull to reverse that damage would be to join the single market and a customs union. That would deliver the revenues we need to cut taxes, grow our defense spending, and invest in public services. The Prime Minister wants us to be led by evidence.
So may I ask the Foreign Secretary, is the Government conducting its own impact assessment into the benefits of joining the single market and a customs union? If not, why not? And if so, can he confirm when it will be published?
Speaker 3
Well, I'm not going to go all the way with the honourable gentleman, but I but I but I but I but I, sorry, that was an unfortunate turn of phrase. But look, what I do say to him in all in all seriousness, Mr. Speaker, is the status quo, we've had 10 years of looking at the the status quo and the Brexit deal we have at the moment, and that Brexit deal is not serving our country well enough. And so people in this House have to make a decision, which is, do they think the status quo is right, we should hang on to that, or can we do better?
Now I think the most important date for us in government at this moment is November the 20th, which is our EU summit, where we are going to do better on trade, on defence and security and on all of those issues. And parties on all sides have to decide, depending on what they think about this, do they think the status quo is right? We think we can do better and that's what we're going to do.
Wendy Chamberlain.
Minister.
Stephen Doughty
Well thank you, Mr Speaker, and we are all deeply alarmed by the systematic discrimination and exclusion of women and girls from public life, education, employment and decision making in Afghanistan. And that is why we are also providing 105 million a year to support the Afghan people and our aid reached 5 million Afghans last year, including 3 million women and girls.
And we continue to press the Taliban directly on women's rights, and we work through our international partners to raise these crucially important issues.
Wendy Chamberlain
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. During Evidence Week, I met with Dr. Sarah Polo to discuss violence against women and girls in conflict areas, including in Afghanistan. And whilst many aspects of the National Action Plan for Women, Peace and Security are encouraging, academics such as Dr. Polo have pointed out that there are areas for improvement, such as including victims of non-sexual violence in NAP initiatives. So can I ask the Minister what discussion has he had with academics in relation to the NAP, and how can academics engage further?
Stephen Doughty
Well, we engage with a wide range of experts on these issues, and I certainly would welcome a chance to discuss these matters with the academic she references. But I can absolutely assure the Department engaged with a huge range of civil society and expert organisations. That's very important in informing our work on these issues.
Sarah Champion
Mr. Speaker, it's not just Afghanistan where we see a rollback in protection around women and girls. Last week I was in Sierra Leone, and I was there working with the parliamentarians there to try and prevent sexual-based violence. Part of that trip, we went to the maternal health unit in Freetown. There, the UK for the last 20 years has been supporting the health industry. We cut all of our funding to that last year.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
This now means that there is no money for procurement. There is no money for any healthcare in that country. So I ask FCDO ministers, what are we actually going to do for countries where we have cut all of our funding to help them transition in a meaningful way, rather than presenting them basically with a death sentence?
Minister.
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, the chair of the committee has been a long-standing champion on these issues, even before her time chairing the committee, and she and I have discussed these issues on many of many occasions. We always welcome a conversation with her about these matters, and I'm sure the Minister for Africa and indeed my colleague who works on preventing sexual violence would be happy to sit down and discuss these issues with her.
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, we take all allegations of arbitrary detention very seriously, considering all available information and any opinions that are issued by the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, and our support is tailored to each individual and may include raising welfare or concerns about process where needed. And reflecting our commitment to supporting British nationals detained, we appointed Alistair Burt, the Right Honourable Alistair Burt, as our first envoy for complex consular detentions to work on these matters, and I'm working with him very closely on this.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My West Dunbartonshire constituent Jagtar Singh Johal was released on bail 26 days ago, but Jagtar is by no means free, Mr. Speaker. Whilst he may have walked out of Tihar jail having endured 3,254 days of illegal detention, torture and abuse, he still cannot return home to his family in Dunbarton and still faces eight outstanding cases and the death penalty. So has the Minister over the last 26 days escalated Jagtar's case to the highest diplomatic level?
Douglas McAllister.
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, I can confirm that most recently the Foreign Secretary raised Mr. Johal's case with his Indian counterpart on the 24th of September at the UN General Assembly.
And I would be very clear Mr. Speaker that we recognize the immense toll that nine years in detention has taken on Mr. Johal and his family and also thank him for his advocacy on behalf of his constituent. Obviously that release on bail is a welcome development but we recognize that there are eight cases remaining outstanding and it's crucial those processes are resolved as quickly as possible within India's independent legal system. We consistently raise concerns about his case at every appropriate opportunity.
Speaker 53
Mr. Speaker, Ryan Cornelius and his partner, British citizens, have been detained now for 18, nearly 19 years without due process by the UAE. The reality is the UAE is also supporting a huge amount of terrorism in Sudan, responsible for the huge amount of loss of life in Sudan.
And to make even worse things, they've nominated Lana Nusseibeh from the UAE to be, to take over as Secretary General. Can I say that the government, apart from demanding the release of Ryan Cornelius and his partner, also condemn the UAE for their involvement in, in Sudan brutally and to block their nomination who should never be allowed to take over Secretary General in the UN.
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, as he knows, I take the case of Ryan Cornelius and Charles Ridley very seriously, as I do any of these other related cases. I have raised that case with the UAE at high levels and will continue to do so, and indeed have discussed it with our envoy Alistair Burt, and I'm very happy to discuss it further with him. And he knows that on Sudan, the international community, including this country, has to do more to tackle this crisis.
And yesterday, my honourable friend announced further sanctions against suspected perpetrators of sexual violence and other atrocities, including in El Fasher. And we continue to raise concerns with all of those countries who are involved in this conflict in any way to urge them to de-escalate, to stop arm supplies and to bring peace to Sudan.
Lincoln Jopp
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. When President Trump met Xi Jinping last month, the US President raised with the Chairman the case of imprisoned British citizen Jimmy Lai. Has the Minister had a readout from that conversation and what can he tell us and the House of his own efforts to bring about Jimmy Lai's release?
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, the Foreign Secretary and I take this case incredibly seriously, but the Prime Minister also raised this issue with President Trump. And I repeat, Mr. Speaker, as I have on a number of occasions, that we condemn in the strongest terms the politically motivated prosecution of Jimmy Lai. The National Security Law was imposed on Hong Kong to silence China's critics. We know that at 78, a 20-year sentence is tantamount to a life sentence. We're deeply concerned for his health.
Stephen Doughty
It's a priority for the government and we raise it at every possible opportunity, both directly with China and with other partners to ensure that that case is raised.
Brenda Jess.
Kirsty McNeill
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions 10 and 21 together.
Over three years, we have seen a devastating man-made humanitarian crisis unfold in Gaza. The UK is committed to improving humanitarian conditions in Palestine and we will provide 88 million pounds in humanitarian and early recovery support this financial year to support the delivery of essential healthcare, clean water, sanitation, and hygiene services. At the UN General Assembly last month, the UK, Jordan, and Qatar co-hosted a meeting focused on driving action on humanitarian access and healthcare. We issued a call to action urging the Government of Israel to allow and facilitate rapid and unimpeded humanitarian access throughout Gaza.
Speaker 61
Mr. Speaker, Palestinian children are the only children in the world who are systematically prosecuted in military courts.
These courts do not meet juvenile justice standards, and Save the Children have found that at every stage of detention, from arrest to interrogation to transfer to incarceration, Israeli soldiers and officials have inflicted physical, mental, and emotional abuse and torture on children. So what action is this government taking with our international partners to prevent the abuse of well over 300 Palestinian children who are currently being held in Israeli military detention?
Kirsty McNeill
Can I first of all thank my honourable friend for drawing attention to this incredibly important topic. Reports that hundreds of Palestinian children are being detained and many of them, as he says, mistreated in Israeli military detention are horrifying. Children's rights must be upheld in accordance with international law. Children must only be detained in line with internationally agreed juvenile justice standards, and we call for an end to military detention where it's incompatible with these principles. So we continue to call on Israel to grant the ICRC immediate, unrestricted access to all detention facilities, and we raised this with Israeli authorities in September.
David Williams
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given the scale of civilian suffering in Gaza and the occupied Palestinian territories, could the Minister please outline what discussions have taken place and will take place with international partners to ensure international humanitarian law is upheld and that humanitarian workers can work safely?
Kirsty McNeill
So, Mr. Speaker, Gaza remains one of the deadliest places on earth to deliver aid, and we've seen countless incidents involving humanitarian personnel over the last three years.
The UK is a member of the Australia-led ministerial group that developed the declaration for the protection of humanitarian personnel and lobbied other states to join. A total of 132 states have now signed this declaration. And just last month, the Foreign Secretary met with Australia and others at the UN General Assembly to maintain momentum and drive collective action to address this fundamental issue.
Monica Harding
Luke Harding. Mr. Speaker, 340 children in Gaza have died since the ceasefire of last year. That's an average of almost one per day. And nearly half of them near the yellow line. Aid workers call it the kill zone.
UNICEF tell me that 100% of children are showing signs of stress because of trauma, hunger and risk of attack. Attack from every side, from drones above, fire at them and unexploded ordnance below them. They face malnutrition and have not had a formal education for three years.
So what will the Foreign Secretary do, whoever is elected today, to ensure that Palestinian children are protected, that sustainable humanitarian aid gets in, that the terms of the ceasefire are obeyed, that education is provided, and Palestinians are given the chance to heal?
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and the honourable lady speaks incredibly passionately and powerfully about exactly the reasons why we have declared this situation a moral emergency. As she rightly says, on average four people have died every day since the ceasefire, over 300 of them children. The civilians and children indeed of Palestine will continue to be an enormous priority for our bilateral engagement with the Israeli government, whoever the Israeli people pick. But the humanitarian situation could not be more severe, and she can be assured that we will continue to press the needs for unfettered access on the Israeli government once elected.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend has already talked about the impact on children, but there is also a significant impact on the reproductive facilities, which mean that there are more miscarriages, more children dying at birth, and effectively the erasing of the next generation in Gaza. That surely must constitute a war crime. What is the government doing to work with international partners to ensure that the future of Gaza can actually exist if there are no children?
Minister.
Kirsty McNeill
Mr. Speaker, so we did hold an event at UNGA on precisely this. Maternal, newborn, and child health will continue to be a priority for the UK government. She will also be aware that the UK has acted fast to try and get sick children to the UK for treatment.
A cross-government task force supported 50 critically ill and injured children and their immediate families to leave Gaza and receive specialist support in NHS hospitals. But as I'm sure she will agree, that is no substitute for ensuring that people can access their healthcare rights in the country that they live in, where they were born, and where we hope to provide them with safety and security through a two-state solution in the end.
James Sloan.
Minister.
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I begin by thanking him for his advocacy for children? Pressure for children's rights will always be welcome at my door. And I share UNICEF's commitment to advancing the rights of children globally, and I'm personally very committed to putting children's rights at the heart of all of the FCDO's development work. I am proud that the UK government is investing in essential services for children, including maternal and newborn health and nutrition, childhood vaccinations, foundational learning, ending child marriage and supporting children's care reform.
And I'll continue to prioritize children's needs and indeed rights across our development portfolio, and I look forward to working with him on that.
Seamus Logan
Mr. Speaker, a significant number of my constituents have written to me expressing support for UNICEF's No Choice But Childhood campaign. When reductions are made to the UK's aid budget, it is the most vulnerable children around the world who face the consequences of that decision first. Will the Secretary of State or the Minister commit to working with UNICEF to increase funding in the aid budget for children at this critical point where conflict is increasing around the globe, but so many countries are decreasing their aid for those in conflict?
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So, as the honorable member will appreciate, the money that we currently allocate for vaccination and indeed the wider health portfolio was protected in our recent round of allocations, benefits children almost exclusively.
The money that we spend on education benefits children almost exclusively. There are other large parts of our portfolio, including on humanitarian and climate action, where I imagine the honorable member will share our determination to see good outcomes achieved. There are other areas of our portfolio where it's not possible or indeed desirable to ringfence them specifically for children, although they are outsized beneficiaries of that action. My job is to make sure that we get the maximum impact for every single pound, every single pound of UK ODA. As I say, some of it specifically ringfenced for children, but much of it to the benefit of their families and indeed wider communities.
Speaker 69
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In Afghanistan, children simply cannot enjoy their childhood, particularly girls.
This summer marked the grim anniversary, five years since the Taliban began an assault on women and girls, banning girls from education. We have to stand with Afghan women and girls. So can the Minister set out whether we will support calls from Afghan women to recognize gender apartheid as a crime against humanity, and will she or the relevant Minister meet with me, other MPs, and importantly, Afghan women to discuss what more can be done?
Kirsty McNeill
Mr. Speaker, I would always be delighted to meet with my honorable friend and indeed would like to commend her and other women and members across this House for all they've done to draw attention to the horrifying, unspeakable situation facing Afghan women and girls. On the specific use of language, she'll appreciate there are sensitivities around that in the international system, and I would also want to be mindful of the views of other partner countries on that. But I'd be delighted substantively to meet with her to see what we can do to advance the cause of Afghan women and girls, which is close to both our hearts.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last year, the Intelligence and Security Committee concluded that Iran poses a widespread, persistent, and unpredictable threat. Number one. Yeah.
We come to topicals, Bradley Thomas.
Foreign Secretary.
Speaker 3
Mr. Speaker, I want to express my thanks to police and security services for their response to the incident at RAF Fairford, including the action they've taken today. As the Prime Minister has said, the IRGC almost certainly directed this outrageous attempted attack, and this Government has designated the IRC, sanctioned individuals in it, and also reimposed snapback sanctions on Iran. Last Friday in Istanbul, I attended the first-ever meeting of the E4 and R4 groups of foreign ministers, and there was agreement we must maximize the pressure on Iran to cease its reckless attacks on ships in the Strait of Hormuz, and a diplomatic way forward must be found to end the Iran war, which is having such a direct impact on the cost of living here at home.
Bradley Thomas.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Mr. Speaker, I was too keen there. Last year the Intelligence and Security Committee concluded that Iran poses a widespread, persistent, and unpredictable threat, and the Director of MI5 has reported that the intelligence services have tracked at least 20 serious plots linked to Iran. So can the Minister update the House on the Government's assessment of the domestic threat posed by Iran and what diplomatic steps are being taken to tackle this?
Speaker 3
The honorable gentleman is absolutely right to raise this. Iran and its proxies are a direct threat to us, and you only need to see what happened at, or the attempted attack at RAF Fairford to see that. We take this incredibly seriously. It's why we've designated the IRGC. It's why we've sanctioned particular individuals.
It's why we use every channel to put pressure on Iran, including with our allies, including as I said in Istanbul, to cease its attempted attacks, not just here but elsewhere as well.
Rosena Allin-Khan.
Rosena Allin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ten years on from the EU referendum, we are still seeing the negative impacts of Brexit. It has hindered trade, stunted growth, and caused young people to be deprived of opportunity. I am grateful for the Prime Minister's honesty with the public about that. With all that in mind, can the Foreign Secretary please tell us what work is being done with EU counterparts to improve ties with the EU so it benefits our economy and our young people?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to my honorable friend for the important question. I would like to inform the House that the UK will reassociate with Erasmus+ from the 1st of January 2027. Applications open this November.
They are not simply for undergraduates, university students, they're for educational institutions of all kinds. I would encourage honorable and right honorable members right across the House to work with the British Council, get their institutions engaged. That is one of the concrete ways we will be helping young people through closer relationship with the EU.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I hope you'll excuse the indulgence as I say a very quick thank you to the Clerk of the Parliaments who's in his place and who was my clerk on the Foreign Affairs Committee and indeed is probably more to blame for me standing here today than many other people in the House. May I ask the Foreign Secretary whether he now accepts the bill that was passed in the Lords under the name of Lord Weir?
Speaker 3
Let me add my congratulations also and thanks to the clerk. On the question of the Chagos Islands, which he's referring to, look, what we have always sought to do in relation to Chagos is seek to find a way forward which protects our base at Diego Garcia. That is the most important thing and I would have thought that is shared across this house. As has become clear, in the current US administration, we won't get consent for the current arrangements, but we continue to work with the US and Mauritius to safeguard our security interests.
Foreign Secretary.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Tom Tugendhat. May I thank the Foreign Secretary for his comments.
The reason I asked about the vote in the Lords is because there seems to me a real problem in the way that we're approaching this debate. And the following is the problem. That the will of this Parliament, as expressed in the Lords only last week, or in treaties that were signed in the 60s or indeed again in the 80s, are now being superseded by courts which have actually got no mandate over the issues which he is debating. So I ask the Foreign Secretary again, does he accept the will of this Parliament, the elected will of the British people, or does he instead seek to accept the now politicised will of courts that have Russian and Chinese judges that are fundamentally misshaping agreements that were signed decades ago and have now been distorted out of place? Because frankly, we have seen what China has done, whether it's locking up Jimmy Lai, whether it's threatening the marine reserve he claims to champion.
So I ask again, whose side is he on?
Speaker 3
Mr. Speaker, I can just gently remind the right honorable gentleman that the House of Commons has primacy in our legislative arrangement. And that's not a modern, that's not a, that's a long-standing convention, I would say. And on his point, on his, if he just, if he just calms down a little, on the point about the courts, I do say to him, at a time when international law is under threat across the world, I appeal, I appeal, I appeal to him that we should be defenders of international law. And we, and we absolutely believe that, and we, and we absolutely believe that maintaining our base at Diego Garcia is absolutely consistent with that.
Lloyd Hatton
Well done. Mr. Speaker, dirty money fuels crime on our streets and conflict overseas. So I welcome this government's continued commitment to hosting an illicit finance summit next year.
Getting this right really matters for our national security. So can the Minister use this extra time ahead of the summit to work with civil society and our international partners so that this summit finally delivers the tough action we need and we can turn the tide on the scourge of dirty money?
Uma Kumaran
Minister. My honorable friend raises a very important topic. I thank him and all those across the House for their efforts in relation to tackling illicit finance. We take this issue very seriously and are working across government, including with colleagues at the Treasury, Home Office, and National Crime Agency. We are determined to ensure that next year's illicit finance summit delivers tangible action.
The plague of dirty money must be eradicated, Mr. Speaker. And as the Minister for Overseas Territories, I've been raising this issue and will continue to raise this issue with elected Overseas Territories leaders as well.
Blake Stephenson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last year, more than seven and a half thousand Eritrean nationals entered the UK legally in small boats. Following talks to persuade Eritrea to accept the return of these illegal immigrants, the Eritrean embassy dismissed threats of visa sanctions as a perfunctory political gimmick. So could the Foreign Secretary please update the House on what he's doing to apply diplomatic pressure to countries like Eritrea who refuse to take back illegal immigrants?
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So as the honorable member will appreciate, every time we enter into one of these negotiations across the whole of government, our objective is to uphold the integrity and impact of our migration policies.
The FCDO has responsibility for ensuring that the policy position we have is communicated forcefully bilaterally. We'll continue to do that. I myself have been in dialogue with the Eritrean ambassador to convey exactly the seriousness with which the Home Secretary, the Foreign Secretary, and the wider British government takes this. And there will be no resiling from the forcefulness with which we promote our policy that Eritrean returns are central to this government and we'll pursue that until they're secured.
Chinyelu Susan Onwurah
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. While knocking on doors in Denton Burn in Newcastle on Saturday, a resident said to me, "We see the terrible images of families putting children onto small boats and the floods and wars and droughts all around the world, but we never hear what Britain is doing to help people stay and flourish where they are."
And I thought, well, he's right, actually. So could the Secretary of State say to me what is the most successful and the most effective thing that his department is doing to reduce migratory pressures?
Speaker 3
Well, look, my honorable friend, as always, speaks a great deal of sense, as do her constituents. And this is why she's right about the role of our G20, and the right honorable gentleman, the member for Sutton Coldfield, made this point earlier on. The work we do on debt and development and climate with our partners across the world is not just right for our values, it's right for our security as well, because failed states, climate breakdown are a threat to our security as well as our values.
Susan Murray
Canada is now part of the EU's 150 billion euro fund to rearm Europe, while British firms are stuck on third country terms. Will the Minister promise prioritize joining the fund as part of the wider growth and defense partnership so British firms can compete on equal terms with European firms?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
I'm pleased to confirm that talks about our security defense cooperation with the EU will be an important part of the summit that the Foreign Secretary mentioned in his earlier answer. I think the honorable lady is referring to SAFE. I think it was a shame that the UK was not part of it, but we are continuing our discussions with the EU to ensure that we can play our full role in Europe.
Catrin Emily Darlington
After successive governments have cut the international aid budget, the reality is the public are still donating in the millions to causes that are dear to their heart. These are usually about disasters, but they also care about women in these countries and LGBT communities in these countries and many other issues. Will the Minister meet with me to talk about how we could extend Aid Match beyond disaster recovery?
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So we don't currently have plans to expand Aid Match beyond the DEC funding appeals, which as my honorable friend rightly says are focused on crises requiring large-scale rapid response. But my honorable friend is absolutely right.
The British public continue to care very deeply about equality and about the human rights of those overseas. So we support that through our Women's Rights Organisation programme, grassroots sexual reproductive health and rights programme, and our LGBT+ rights programme. We support that formally as FCDO, but I would be absolutely delighted to talk to her and indeed any other members across the House about what more we can do to give life to the British public's impulse towards very deep solidarity on questions of equality.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Foreign Office facilitated a trip to Dublin for Scottish First Minister John Swinney. There he met the egregious Mary Lou McDonald of Sinn Féin to discuss the breakup of Britain. Why are British taxpayers paying for this nonsense?
Speaker 3
Mr. Speaker, let me say to the right honourable or the honourable gentleman, our belief in the United Kingdom and keeping our United Kingdom together is absolute and clear. And, you know, the First Minister of Scotland can have his visits.
Speaker 84
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, around 13 million people have been displaced in Sudan, but they are far from safe. Earlier this month, a drone strike near one of the displacement centers in Blue Nile killed 31 people, mostly women and children. This is the world's biggest humanitarian disaster. But where are the protests on the streets?
Where is the round-the-clock media reporting? Where is the online, you know, coverage of this? Will the Minister set out what the government is doing to raise awareness of this catastrophe and how we can galvanize international action?
Kirsty McNeill
Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend is absolutely right. Just yesterday, I attended an event in Parliament marking the one-year anniversary of the fall of El Fasher.
And honestly, at that event, I heard testimony I will never forget as long as I live. We heard about, and indeed I spoke about, bloodshed so overwhelming that the ground was soaked with blood so deeply it could be seen from space. And that should be a matter of ongoing daily outrage in our country. Now, last month at UNGA, the Foreign Secretary and I met with international partners to galvanize further action, including through an event focused on the absolutely devastating use of drones to terrorize civilians, alongside our UK-convened coalition for atrocity prevention. And just yesterday, I'm very proud that the UK announced further sanctions against commanders suspected of involvement in these atrocities in Sudan.
Speaker 86
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With increasing evidence of hybrid attacks by Russia on British targets, will the Foreign Secretary rule out shaking hands with Sergey Lavrov at the upcoming G20?
Speaker 3
We don't engage in that way with the Russians and haven't for a number of years. And as I said earlier throughout this session, we're absolutely clear about the need to counter the Russian hybrid threat.
Richard Quigley
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With Israelis heading to the polls today, the world will be watching anxiously.
With hardline figures such as Ben-Gvir and Naftali Bennett potentially emerging as kingmakers of the next government, both having supported policies relating to settlement expansion and the transfer of Palestinians from Gaza, there is real concern that the next Israeli administration could move even further away from compliance with international law. What steps is the government taking to ensure that the UK's commitment to international law is upheld in its relationship with any future Israeli government?
Stephen Doughty
Well, Mr. Speaker, I can assure him that the UK's commitment to international law does not depend on the outcome of elections. We've been clear that settlements are illegal under international law and that Israel must comply with its obligations, and we've been clear that the occupation is unlawful.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Speaker, firms like Thales in Templecombe, Needles and Pins Aerospace in Somerton, and Leonardo in Yeovil are at the heart of a Somerset aerospace and advanced engineering sector, yet Britain remains outside of the SAFE defense fund. Will the Minister commit to securing UK participation in SAFE and any successor fund on fair terms so our defense firms and the communities that depend on them aren't left behind?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Mr Speaker, I represent the great city of Lincoln, also with an aerospace background. We are making important progress in our relationship with many of our European friends, including notably with the Italians on the Global Combat Air Programme. As I said in my earlier answer, we will be discussing security and defence cooperation as part of the summit on the 20th of November.
Sureena Brackenridge
Thank you, Mr Speaker. As online abuse increasingly crosses borders, including the sharing of intimate images without consent, what is the Government doing with international partners and technology companies to protect women and girls and ensure criminals cannot exploit differences in countries' laws to escape justice?
Uma Kumaran
I thank my honourable friend for raising this important topic. The government is taking action both at home and internationally to tackle appalling online abuse towards women and girls, including AI-generated deepfakes and the sharing of intimate images without consent. The UK has some of the strongest measures against this abuse, including making the creation and sharing of deepfakes a criminal offence. We're co-developing a model national framework to reduce opportunities for offenders to exploit differences between jurisdictions. There is a global partnership for action on gender-based online harassment and abuse.
I'll continue to raise this with international counterparts and at our summit next year.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've had a great deal of trouble getting a straight answer from the government on this for some months now, so I'll give it one more go. On what specific date in August was Jonathan Powell appointed as the Prime Minister's special envoy to the British Indian Ocean Territories?
Speaker 3
I think we've answered this question before, Mr. Speaker, and don't have anything further to add to previous answers.
Alex Sobel
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I ask my honorable friend Secretary of State if any funds have been allocated for Ukraine water infrastructure, for instance within the UN water cluster project? Has the UK provided funds for defense barrier systems for water infrastructure and or provided consistent power supply for water and sewage systems? My counterparts in Ukraine said to me this is a top immediate priority to ensure that water and sewage do not overwhelm them.
Uma Kumaran
I thank my honorable friend for raising a topic which he has been speaking about passionately and eloquently for many years.
Earlier this month, the Foreign Secretary visited Kyiv, where he met Ukrainian people still living almost five years on under the constant threat of Russian strikes, energy blackouts and death. While in Kyiv, the Foreign Secretary announced a 54 million combined humanitarian and energy support package, which includes 20 million pounds to protect and maintain electricity, heating and water supply for Ukrainian families ahead of the winter. Alongside this, our 34 million pounds humanitarian package will help around 700,000 vulnerable people, including by maintaining and restoring heating and water services.
Edward Robert Jenrick
The Foreign Secretary and I represent communities 15 miles apart, decent, hardworking people who are finding life very tough at the moment.
In that context, how would he justify to working people and pensioners spending 6 billion pounds on foreign aid whilst freezing the tax-free personal allowance and cutting the state pension?
Speaker 3
Mr. Speaker, what I would say to him, and I think the answer came from the person who used to be in his party, the party he used to be in, which is that the money we spend on foreign aid is absolutely about preventing the problems from elsewhere in the world coming here to his constituency and mine. You know, he is at one and the same time the person who complains about small boats, which is partly caused by fragile states, and then says that we shouldn't be taking action to prevent it. So I'm afraid I don't agree with him.
Margaret Pamela Cox
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There is cross-party concern about an extremely concerning situation in Tanzania, that is the trial of Mr. Tundu Lissu, chair of the Party for Democracy and Progress, or CHADEMA. Mr. Lissu has been charged with treason after calling for electoral reform at a public rally during an election campaign. If found guilty, he could be sentenced to death.
The UK has long enjoyed close and constructive relations with Tanzania. Can I ask what actions ministers are taking to raise concerns about this very serious matter?
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you. We remain gravely concerned about the continued detention of Tundu Lissu and will continue to raise his case through ministerial channels and the British High Commission. We note the UN Working Group opinion that his detention was arbitrary, unlawful, and lacking of sufficient legal basis, and we await the 6th of November verdict and underline its significance to Tanzania's democratic freedoms and the rule of law. But can I also take this opportunity, Mr. Speaker, to say the UK remains firmly opposed to the death penalty in all circumstances in every country.
Graham Stuart
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. His trial was unfair. The 20-year sentence extension was arbitrary and outrageous.
Will the Secretary of State now unequivocally say that Ryan Cornelius should be released?
Speaker 3
Yes, I do agree with him, Mr. Speaker, and it is something that we are discussing with our UAE counterparts, and the role of Alistair Burt is also going to be important in this. We do want to see that release, absolutely.
Richard Burgon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As the winter bites and the humanitarian situation worsens, will the Secretary of State commit to supplying food aid to Gaza at least last year's levels, and will he use his welcome new sanction regulations laid earlier this month to sanction those Israeli figures blocking aid getting into Gaza?
Speaker 3
Well, the issue of health and humanitarian access in terms of Gaza is absolutely key and essential, and the blocking of aid is absolutely outrageous, Mr. Speaker.
My honorable friend is absolutely right. I don't speculate on the sanctions regime, but it's important that we have that regime and we want to make sure that we unblock the aid.
Speaker 98
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I wonder if the Secretary of State could outline what role his department will play in the new National Center for Information Defense, and when the government will update the House about the composition, the rollout, and the scalability of this new capability.
Speaker 3
Well, the honorable gentleman raises a really important issue. The role I think we will play in this is to bring some of the lessons we have learned from taking action with allies, for example, in relation to Moldova and the disinformation there, and bring it home, if you like, to make sure that we learn those lessons here in the UK.
Speaker 97
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
I'm grateful to the government for its additional round of sanctions one year on from the massacre at El Fasher. But we know that outside actors continue to fuel that war, including the UAE, as shown by the UN's fact-finding mission. Can the government confirm that it remains their position, as articulated by our representative to the UN, that we welcome that report, we do not contest it? Thank you.
Minister, briefly.
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We absolutely welcome the fact-finding mission's report. Indeed, we were the initiator of the fact-finding mission and we remain a huge champion of its work.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to raise a point of order on the subject of the question I just asked the Foreign Secretary.
I've asked several times to get a straight answer around the appointment of Jonathan Powell and in fact put an FOI in on the 23rd of June. That FOI was delayed on the 23rd of June from the 22nd of July to the 20th of August, then again to the 18th of September, then again to the 18th of October, and again to the 13th of November. Mr. Speaker, what can I do to try and get a straight answer from the FCDO given they've been delaying an FOI now for five months?
Lindsay Hoyle
Seems like I've ended up with this one. Look, what I would say is the honorable member seems to put a lot of questions in and FOIs and I'm sure he'll pursue it through the Table Office, he'll take good advice. What I can't do is a continued debate. I am not responsible for the answers from the Foreign Secretary, but I think if you were to sit with the clerks to come up with another way, I'm sure we might be able to get somebody to hear what you've said and I'm sure the front bench will have heard it as well. Point of order, Tim, hang on, Tim Farron, you didn't ask a question, no you can't.
Right, we're now going to— Mr. Farron, I only take points of order from people who've asked questions. You didn't ask a question, it must be one of the only few times you've never managed to get a question in. So I think that your eager to get a point of order in will come after the urgent question, where I'm sure you'll be wanting to wait to do it. Right, let us come to the urgent question.
Nick Timothy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, to ask the Justice Secretary to make a statement on the electronic monitoring of offenders.
Speaker 100
The government inherited a justice system pushed to breaking point by the last government. We had less than a hundred places left in our prisons when Labour came to power, with incredibly serious problems with electronic monitoring. We've taken swift action to improve performance, and we're now delivering the biggest expansion of tagging in British history, backed by a hundred million pounds of investment. As part of our reforms, there is a presumption...
Thank you.
Lindsay Hoyle
Minister. Please, at least let the Minister to get to the end of what she's got to say without the interruption. Minister.
Speaker 100
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As part of our reforms, there is a presumption that eligible offenders released under the progression model will be tagged, giving probation an additional tool to monitor offenders and protect the public. We're now tagging a record number of offenders, helping to cut crime and make our streets safer.
Electronic monitoring is not used in isolation. Those released from prison remain subject to license conditions and probation supervision, which can include curfews and restrictions on their movements. We've also introduced tougher powers for probation officers, including world-first restriction zones for the most serious sexual and violent offenders, where appropriate, and as well as the ability to prohibit offenders from driving, attending public events, or entering pubs, clubs, and bars. Where an offender breaches their conditions or can no longer be safely managed in the community, they can immediately be recalled to prison. We've also ensured the electronic monitoring service is ready to support this expansion.
The service was ready for first tranche releases on the 1st of October, with the equipment and staff in place to deliver the presumption to tag offenders on release. Serco has consistently met its contractual requirements since March 2026. The Ministry of Justice publishes routine extensive data on probation and tagging. It's published quarterly, and the last set of data was published just last week. It's vital that the government and the public have confidence that the information that is published by the department is accurate.
Our quarterly economic monitoring statistics, including figures for the number of prison leavers fitted with tags and the figures covering the October period, will be publicly available in January.
This government inherited a prison system on the brink of collapse, having built just 500 places in the last 14 years. It's this government who are now building the prison places we need and putting in the strictest measures possible to protect the public.
Nick Timothy
Mr. Speaker, you wouldn't believe listening to the minister that the number of prison places and the number of prison officers is actually down, but it all sounds like it's going very well according to her version of events. Labour told us that to keep the public safe from the dangerous criminals they release early, the Justice Secretary would implement the toughest tagging regime in British history, and there would be a new presumption that offenders will be electronically tagged and monitored when they leave prison.
But the Metropolitan Police told Sky this weekend that they will not act on all breaches of tag conditions by bailed offenders, blaming the pressure created by Labour's early release scheme. Just in London, there have been 100 tag breaches a day by released prisoners since the first early release scheme started, with two to three released prisoners now being rearrested every week. The Commissioner of the Met said, "We're seeing 95% plus of the tagging breaches that we arrest simply being bailed back into the community on the same conditions." He says there is zero sanction. One sergeant said there just aren't enough cops to handle Labour's early release of thousands of prisoners.
The Justice Secretary, when he stops hiding in his department and sending junior ministers to answer for him, needs to be straight with the House and with the public. Four days after his early release scheme started, he told the BBC he didn't know, that it was impossible to know, how many prisoners had been tagged.
He wrote to me yesterday admitting he still doesn't know, and it's 26 days later. The Times reports that most prisoners will not be tagged as they're released from prison, and we know that more than 5,000 offenders went unmonitored in the first half of this year because they weren't fitted with tags. This is a mess, Mr. Speaker. So chaotic is Labour's early release scheme, prisoners are being given tents instead of housing upon release. As a matter of policy, these prisoners will be in probable breach of their license and tagging conditions, which require them to have an approved address.
All because the probation service is overwhelmed. We know two-thirds of prisoners who are sleeping rough go on to reoffend within the first year. Mr. Speaker, ministers keep telling us that the full data on tagging and reoffending cannot be published until the regular publication dates.
So I will ask again. Will ministers publish full data on how many released prisoners have been tagged? Will they publish comprehensive data on reoffending by prisoners let out through Labour's early release scheme? And will the Justice Secretary apologize to the House for telling the public they'd be kept safe?
Speaker 100
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Whilst I would say that the honorable member raises some important points, I would stress again that we are working night and day to fix the broken system that we inherited.
We are working across agencies. We are working incredibly hard with the police, with probation services, with all those that work in the criminal justice system that want to keep the public safe and make sure that victims get the service that they need to from our criminal justice system. I would caution the honorable gentleman that he appears to be conflating a number of issues in his contribution. He will be aware that it is usual practice, which has been in place under successive governments, including his own, that prisoners are tagged at their place of accommodation on release, and this was always the plan for the 1st of October. That said, we know that this creates a gap between leaving prison and having the tag fitted, which is why, to address this, we have conducted a successful pilot to fit tags at prison receptions.
It's currently live in six prisons, and we are working at pace to roll this out to further prisoners leaving with a tag. And the honourable gentleman chuntered from his sedentary position to ask about the police. What he is talking about is local Metropolitan Police policy in relation to breaches of court bail, where they are the responsible agency. I think it's really important not to conflate the release of prisoners and the tagging policy, which we are working at pace to improve from the situation we inherited, and other demands on the police, which we are working very closely with them to resolve.
We inherited a failing tagging system with record backlogs, and we're investing 100 million pounds in electronic monitoring, tagging offenders before release, and importantly, strengthening victim protections with a new alert system. The MPs who share this government and the Prime Minister's ambition that no one should be street homeless, I urge them to support us in these endeavors and to make sure that their local authorities are working with us to ensure that the work to support prisoners on release, ensure they are tagged, ensure victims are protected, and ensure the public are protected is our key priority.
And we can work together across this House to achieve that. So Mr. Speaker, I visit prisons and meet with prison officers and governors every week who are working incredibly hard to keep the public safe, to transform lives, to transform the lives of individuals within our prison system to make sure that when they leave prison, they leave in a better state than they arrived, that we reduce reoffending, that we support the probation service to reintegrate these members into society and in the meantime to ensure that they are tagged and victims and the public are kept safe. We are working incredibly hard, getting on with the job of fixing the mess that we inherited, rebuilding our justice system that was left so broken. And I would urge honorable members across the House to support us in their local area with this work.
Catherine Helen Atkinson
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Victims should not have to make their lives smaller, looking over their shoulder because offenders are free to roam.
It's the offender whose freedoms should be limited. Will the Minister be more ambitious in using restriction zones which keep an offender within a defined area rather than simply banning them from particular areas as with exclusion zones? And if victims are to feel safe, tags must be fitted as they walk out of the prison gate, not weeks later. Will this be in place in January as intended?
Speaker 100
The honorable lady is absolutely right and I thank her for her assiduous work on all of these subjects.
She is absolutely right that we are right to be rolling out the world-leading restriction zones, making sure that it is offenders who are restricted where that is appropriate. And indeed we do have the exclusion zones as well where they are appropriate. And obviously these decisions are made by probation practitioners. And she rightly highlights the work that we are doing to accelerate and speed up the rollout of tagging at prisons to ensure that as soon as possible as we can, that we ensure the safety and security of the tagging system is installed at the prison gate as soon as possible.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over 5,000 offenders went unmonitored in the first half of this year due to serious delays in the tagging system. And in the year to March, an average of 300 people per week were released from prison with no fixed address, making it incredibly difficult to ensure that offenders are tagged and then managed in the community.
This adds to the strain of both the probation service and the police, who are using scarce resources to manage an increasingly large caseload and keep victims safe. The Government has repeatedly promised that they will not jeopardize public safety, but many victims, following the stories over the weekend, especially after Mark Rowley's comments, will struggle to believe them. So will the Government listen to the calls of the Victims' Commissioner to tag individuals at the gate and roll this out to every prison by January? We also welcomed the Government's announcement to introduce restriction zones for offenders that limits the movement for perpetrators rather than victims. But the effectiveness of those zones will require offenders to be properly monitored and any breaches being addressed without delay.
Is the Minister confident that there are enough resources to operate restriction zones effectively, and when will we see a national rollout of this important measure?
Speaker 100
The honourable lady makes a number of very thoughtful and helpful contributions, and indeed it is very important that housing and homelessness is tackled amongst the prison-leaver population to ensure both that they have the opportunity to build a life and not reoffend, but also ensure that we can work with local authorities as effectively as possible to ensure that prisoners are not at risk of becoming homelessness.
The honorable lady makes a number of very thoughtful and helpful contributions.
Coming homelessness and that is obviously a priority across the board to tackle homelessness by this Prime Minister and this government, which was reinforced by the announcement made yesterday of 884 pounds of priority, million pounds of priority funding to tackle homelessness. We are already extending the period by which collaboration must happen between the prison probation unit and local authorities to ensure that we have the maximum period possible to work on ensuring that those arrangements can be put in place that ensure victim safety and the public safety as well. And indeed, she rightly raises the tagging at source, which we've had the very successful pilot of. This has not been done previously by any government. We recognize this is an opportunity to really improve the work that is happening and we are working at pace to ramp that up at source.
She also raises some of the restriction zones and the measures that have been put in place. I can only reiterate that these are world-leading measures that we are putting in place.
We genuinely are not just fixing the mess that we inherited, but we are working at pace to make this system work in the interest of victims and the public and creating a society that everyone can contribute to.
Janet Jessica Daby
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the Minister for her response so far. But does she agree with me that more needs to be done to prevent reoffending when offenders are actually in prison, so that when they are released and on tags, they do not commit further crimes? So can the Minister say what she is doing to ensure that appropriate education, training, and skills takes place across the prison estate?
Speaker 100
The honourable lady is absolutely right that ensuring that we have purposeful activity within prisons and also that prisoners can gain skills, life skills and work skills whilst they are in prison will help to support reducing reoffending, will help to support our prison capacity challenge that we have. And indeed she will recognise that the current capacity challenge that we inherited does make all of that harder. It just makes everything that we are doing within the prison system harder, which is why we are both building more prison spaces, we are ensuring that we do invest and support in rehabilitation whilst in prison to reduce having to recall when people reoffend. We're tackling it on all fronts and I very much appreciate that the honourable lady supports us in these efforts.
Sir Ashley Fox.
Ashley Peter Fox
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
The Minister says the government is building new prison places, and yet she will be aware that there are fewer prison places today than on the day Labour took office. She'll also be aware that this vast flood of prisoners being released early has overwhelmed the ability of the probation service to find them accommodation, and that some prisoners are now being issued with tents, setting them up to fail. So can the Minister tell us how many prisoners have been issued with tents on their release, and has the rate been higher or lower than she expected?
Speaker 100
It is not government policy to provide tents to people being released from prison who are at risk of being homeless. We are clear that tents are never and should never be an acceptable housing solution.
He will know that overall housing responsibility does rest with local authorities in both England and Wales, and he will also be assured that we are working very closely with the MH, the Department for Housing and Local Government to make sure that we work together to tackle the scourge of homelessness across the board, but also with this prison leaver cohort that I appreciate he is concerned about. He can support with this work by encouraging his local authority to engage in pre-release panels so that this can be done collaboratively right across the UK to make sure nobody leaves prison homeless.
Jonathan Brash
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Between May and August of this year, Kevin Brown committed eight burglaries in Hartlepool, targeting businesses and charities like Alice House Hospice and Cornerstone Homeless Charity. The court handed him a suspended sentence. That is not good enough for me and it is not good enough for my constituents.
So does the Minister agree with me that we must build more prison places so that individuals like this are locked up?
Speaker 100
I absolutely agree with the honourable gentleman that we must build more prison places and we are working at pace to do that. Obviously, I would not comment on independent judicial decisions that are made in particular cases, but he should also be reassured to know that the tagging involves tackling acquisitive crime also and making sure that tagging is appropriate and individualized to the offender to make sure that it tackles their particular challenge where it might come to reoffending. An acquisitive crime GPS pilot found offenders were 20% less likely to reoffend within 12 months, so we are working across the board to tackle all of these issues in the round.
Richard Tice
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's bad enough that dangerous criminals are being released early, but my constituents are frankly terrified that these prisoners are being released without tags. The world's gone mad, Minister. Will this government commit not to release prisoners without tags?
Speaker 100
The honourable gentleman will have heard the answers I've given previously to colleagues on the usual business as usual, which we inherited, which was always the plan for the first of October, that an offender that is assessed for a tag, and we are presuming more offenders and released from prison individuals to be eligible for tags than at any point in history, and we're investing significantly in that, but that they would normally be tagged at their accommodation. Obviously, we've undertaken a pilot, which I have already mentioned, which has been shown to be successful, of tagging prisoners at the prison, and we will work at pace to roll that out further as quickly as possible.
Kim Marie Johnson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Serco continues to be awarded very lucrative government contracts despite repeated failures, while probation officers have been pushed to breaking point.
Will the Minister commit to bringing back in-house electronic tagging and probation services, as I proposed in my amendment to the Sentencing Act, so that we're not rewarding private profit over public safety? Thank you.
Speaker 100
I thank the honourable lady for her question. The contract with Serco was signed by the party opposite, and its performance did not originally meet expectations, but we have focused on driving rapid improvement and ensuring that we turn that failing performance around to make sure that it is meeting contractual expectations and that they are working with us at pace to make the improvements that we want to see in our system. We obviously will continue to keep all of these matters under review, as we would with any contracts that the government has entered into.
Julian Lewis
I welcome the fact that the government is experimenting with this scheme of tagging prisoners at the point of release. But the question then arises, those of them who do not have an address to go to and who choose to remove the tag are going to be very difficult to find. Is there a solution to this?
Speaker 100
The honorable gentleman asks a typically thoughtful question and obviously all of these matters are kept continuously under review. We work very closely with the probation service that keep, that have a range of measures that they use to manage offenders once they're released in the community, both to support them to reintegrate but make sure that the public are safe. And we obviously work very closely with the police in that work also.
And as an offender does find settled accommodation, then obviously at any stage a tag can then be put on as part of those license conditions. But clearly where there are concerns, the ultimate recall option remains available.
Dame Emily Thornberry.
Anne Emily Thornberry
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In 1842, when Pentonville Prison was built, I don't imagine anybody expected that today they would have twice the number that the Victorians ever thought ought to be kept in prison. And furthermore, Pentonville Prison is a London remand prison. It used to be people were there for six to eight months on remand in pretty terrible conditions, but now they're there for years because of the crisis within the criminal justice system. The question is this: when they are released, what should be done with them?
I was speaking to the governor at the prison on Friday, and he said that if the government wishes them to, prison officers would be quite happy to be trained and to put the tags on them themselves before releasing people.
Speaker 100
I thank the right honourable lady for her very thoughtful question, and she, like I, have the greatest regard for our prison governors who work on the frontline, keeping the public safe and keeping their prisons running. And they do come up with a lot of good ideas. I've heard many of them myself. I meet with them regularly to make sure I am very much ear to the ground on what we can do to improve matters. And indeed, many of the proposals that we are taking forward to improve things significantly from where we inherited them come from the very practical reality that prison governors themselves encounter.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Speaker. It's not just those on early release but our victims of domestic abuse like Michelle, who has a restraining order against her ex-partner until 2036 and who police say that he is regularly breaching when he is released. Ten days after his release, she contacted me for the fourth time to say he still doesn't have a tag. And as we went into half term, said, "I've not left my house all week, the children can't go out in half term, we don't feel safe, the liaison officers know that this is going to happen again, and family is now staying one at a time to make sure she's not alone." I totally understand the January deadline, you've got there's a lot of people to deal with.
But will she make a commitment that for those people who are victims, serial victims of domestic abuse will be prioritized so that children don't have to look over their shoulder?
Speaker 100
Yeah, the honorable honorable lady raises a very important case and I'm very sorry to hear about the situation that they're dealing with this this half term. Obviously, that needs to be escalated to the appropriate appropriate people to be dealt with. And indeed, there are a whole variety of measures that are used to ensure victim engagement, the victim's contact helpline, and ultimately specific orders put on domestic perpetrator offenders. But I appreciate she has ongoing concerns and I'd be more than happy to engage with her on this particular case.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Minister for the groundbreaking work of her department in tagging prisoners before release?
But can she update the House on the work that this government is doing to start fixing the failure of the party opposite to build more prison places and invest in a crumbling prison estate?
Speaker 100
The honorable lady brings us back to the crux of the issue which this government inherited and the fact that we have been dealing with the consequences of a failure to invest in our prison capacity over many years with just 500 net places when the opposite party left government. And we are working at pace to deliver 14,000 prison places. We're aiming to do so by 2031. We've already delivered 3,300 and I look forward to being at the groundbreaking and opening of many more.
Liz Roberts
The Lord Chancellor recently addressed NAPO's conference.
I was there, I was listening in to speak afterwards and he told probation officers, "Without you, our criminal justice system doesn't work." But yet NAPO is presently balloting their members on strike action following failed negotiations with the government for a pay rise after decades of pay stagnation. Surely she agrees though that technology cannot replace dedicated probation officers. They also need the proper pay, the proper conditions and the proper workloads to be able to do their jobs properly.
Speaker 100
The honorable lady is absolutely right. Justice Transcribe that she makes reference to has supported probation officers to reduce the workload when it comes to the transcribing of notes that obviously they must keep careful records of and this inevitably is helping to manage workloads. But she is absolutely right, they do a vital job.
I want to take this opportunity to thank them for the work that they are doing today and every day to make sure we keep our the public safe and they manage offenders in the community. That's why in April we secured the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade and the current offer increases that by a minimum of 5%. We want to increase our recruitment of probation officers, so do think about joining and encourage people that you know to join. And we also want to make sure we retain our brilliant probation officers and we're obviously continuing in discussions with them to that end.
Esther McVey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can the Minister confirm that criminals won't get tagged if they're classed as homeless?
For at the weekend it was revealed that prisoners released early by this government were given tents because there was no accommodation for them. So yes or no, will prisoners released and given a tent be tagged? Or will they be roaming the streets without any way of locating them, free to commit more crime?
Speaker 100
I agree with her that it is completely unacceptable for a prisoner to be released with a tent. It is not government policy. It is not something we want to see. That's why we are working at pace to improve the current homelessness situation that we inherited from the previous government to make sure that nobody, including prison leavers, leave prison homeless or have to live homeless.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you Mr Speaker. A Lords committee criticized the MOJ under the previous government for reappointing the contractors after repeated failures.
Serco has an issue with finding a tag small enough for the mother, the elderly mother of my constituent, and it delayed her release over Christmas. Can the Minister outline what steps the government are taking to make sure the contractors manage to tag all prisoners before they re- before they leave prison?
Speaker 100
Um, I'm sorry to hear about the experience of that particular case. Clearly there are circumstances where there are physical challenges to fitting a tag, um, whether that may be due to a medical reason in terms of limb, limb loss for example, there, um, or, um, swelling.
But obviously, it's important that the vast majority of people that should have tags do have tags, and we need to make sure that happens. As I said, the business-as-usual position is to tag an individual who is due to be tagged once they are in their accommodation, but we are trialling, have piloted, and will be looking to roll out tagging at the prison as quickly as possible.
Adam Dance.
Adam Dance
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've heard from far too many worried victims and parents of young victims in Yeovil about how much anxiety the potential early release of their offenders has caused, including child grooming gangs. Probation services in rural areas are on their knees. So can the Minister tell victims in Yeovil what work has been done with probation services in the South West to make sure they have all the personnel, resources, and systems in place to safely manage the release of offenders in our communities?
Speaker 100
I'm sorry to hear about the experience of young people in Yeovil and in his area. I do think that some of the rhetoric around this, we need to be very careful and have victims always in mind when we have these conversations and make sure that yes, there is robust challenge to make sure we get this right and that we push the measures that we are taking to the furthest point possible to make sure we keep people safe, but also that we do respect the work of our probation team that are monitoring these offenders in the community and are working to keep people safe. And obviously from the progression model, there are a whole range of offences that are excluded, that are not eligible for progression.
We have increased the tagging of offenders even where they are excluded from progression, but they are crimes of a nature that we would want them to be tagged and monitored post-release in any event. So I would want to provide reassurance to the young people that we are working at pace and to our at the at our very hardest to ensure that we keep the public safe and that we manage offenders as they reintegrate back into the community.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One former minister from the party opposite wrote a book which discussed the failures of the prison system to reform. Can the minister confirm she's looked at Rory Stewart's book, his concerns that the department lacked project management capabilities and support from the Treasury, required a longer tenure for prison ministers, and would she recommend the book to the shadow minister?
Speaker 100
So indeed the party opposite have a have a whole plethora of public commentary on these issues.
Indeed the book that is mentioned, but also the Prime Minister herself and her policy chief, who admitted that not enough prison places were built. I'd be interested not only in whether they might want to read the aforementioned book, or indeed apologize for the failures of the previous government. This would be a good opportunity to do that.
Gavin Williamson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government hasn't yet set out the number of domestic abusers that have been released under the early release scheme. Can the minister set out to the House what that number is and the total number of domestic abusers that will be released under this scheme?
Speaker 100
He knows as well as I do that that figure is not available. But indeed, this is an issue that we couldn't take more seriously, which is why we have got tagging under the domestic abuse perpetrators on license approach. And probation have the widest set of powers, many of which I've mentioned: restriction, license conditions, prohibiting offenders from driving, attending public events. And we know that it is right that we bring our world-leading restriction zones to ensure that victims of domestic violence are not the ones that have to alter their lives, but the perpetrators are those. And we'll continue to prioritize and work on this issue, and he's right to raise it.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I speak to victims of crime and their families from Harlow on a regular basis, and I find some of their stories absolutely heartbreaking. I have to say, and I'm sure people from across the House will agree with me, I feel really angry that there are men in our society who think it's okay to treat women the way that they do.
One thing that victims and their families raise with me is their concerns about how easy it is for these perpetrators, these vile individuals, to take their tags off. So I wondered what the Minister can say about the punishment that will be handed down to those individuals that do try and tamper with their tags or take them off.
Speaker 100
Indeed, I share his anger. Since taking on this role, I have to say I have felt very angry, not just with some of the perpetrators and the cases that we see come across our desks, but also the 14 years of failure that left us in the situation that we are currently in. So we are working at pace to improve the technology and the application of the tagging system. They chunter from the opposite benches, but they wasted 100 million pounds on tags that did not work. We are working to make sure that this is effective.
We're working at pace to pick up the pieces that were left behind.
Lee Anderson.
Speaker 123
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Could the Minister please tell the House how many people who should be wearing an electronic tag are wandering around our communities with no electronic device fitted at all? Should be a simple question.
Speaker 100
So, it has got a simple answer, that he will be, he will be able to see the data when it is published in, in January. We've just had data published for the previous three months. The data obviously needs to be verified, it needs to be accurate. We, we are not in the business of publishing data that is not robust, and we will publish it in due course in the normal way.
Jim Shannon
Can I thank the Minister very much for her answers, very comprehensive answers. While electronic monitoring of offenders can be a useful tool to manage prison capacity for individuals who have carried out non-violent crimes, there are some serious concerns about regional coordination. So can the Minister assure the House that robust safeguards are in place to ensure that private monitoring contractors are sharing real-time flawless data with police forces in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland? And what specific metric is the Minister's department doing to confirm that tagging systems are genuinely reducing offending rather than sticking plaster for a broken system? Thank you.
Speaker 100
Gosh, the honorable gentleman raises a very thoughtful question and one that probably requires a lengthy answer, which I don't have time for today. But I absolutely acknowledge the point that he makes. And I am absolutely determined that we both have the data and the monitoring and the reporting to make sure that this does work, that it's not a sticking plaster, that victims can have faith in it and probation officers can be supported and the police to do what they need to do to keep our communities safe. We're investing significantly in this technology. We need to make sure it works and he raises a genuine and good point today.
Speaker 125
Right, let the front bench change over. Next statement on security, Minister Dan Jarvis.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I wish to make a statement on the steps the government's taking to ensure that the UK is the most resilient country that we can be. I'd like to begin though by sending my condolences to the families of the two men who tragically died in storm conditions this weekend. It is an all too grim reminder of the devastating impact that storms can have. I saw this firsthand when I visited Cornwall in the wake of Storm Garett earlier this year, where weather stations recorded wind speeds of 100 miles an hour. 50,000 homes, schools and businesses were left without power.
Entire communities became trapped as fallen trees blocked country lanes. I heard families' fear as they talked about how quickly the basic necessities of everyday life were stripped away: power, water, internet. And I thank the first responders for their tireless effort clearing roads and reconnecting homes.
These scenes will be familiar to members right across the House. And on January the 8th in the South West, it was an extreme storm. Over the summer across the UK, it was wildfires. And this week, it has been Storm Austin and Storm Boulo. Climate change is making extreme weather not just more likely, but also more powerful.
And this winter is set to be difficult, with El Niño increasing the likelihood of storms and heavy rainfall. Now, since we came into government in 2024, we've been hardening and sharpening the UK's approach to resilience.
We've rewritten the government's pandemic strategy, investing more than a billion pounds to build the UK's biological defences. We've launched the Home Defence Programme to ensure our country is best prepared for the full range of potential threats, no matter how unlikely they might be. And up and down these aisles, we're taking coordinated action to prepare our infrastructure for difficult weather this winter. 1.4 billion invested in flood defences in this financial year alone. 24 billion invested to maintain and improve our roads and rails, rail network over the next four years.
And 2.6 billion invested to climate-proof our rail infrastructure with projects underway or completed in places like County Durham, Derbyshire and Cumbria. And throughout this coming winter, I'll be working across government to ensure an effective response to storms as they occur.
But reflecting on the experience of the people I met in Cornwall, it's clear to me that in the middle of an emergency, our brilliant first responders can't be everywhere all at once. It's clear that proper preparedness begins in our communities, streets and homes. Now our research shows that just 13% of people in the UK feel that they're prepared for an emergency like a severe storm that could cut them off from the services they rely on. This figure is far lower than our European neighbors. The very same research showed that 84% of people in the UK want the government to share more information about the steps they can take to increase their preparedness.
So Mr. Speaker, to give some credit to the opposition, they also recognized this resilience gap while in government and launched a new website to share preparedness guidance with the public. But that website stopped short of a proper campaign. Not enough people noticed it and those who did found the guidance hard to follow. This government is committed to having an honest conversation with the public about the risks that we face and helping them to prepare household by household, step by step, to improve our national resilience. To that effect, we've published updated preparedness guidance for households and launched a three-year campaign to raise awareness of the simple steps people can take to be ready for everyday emergencies.
Now I want to be clear from the outset that we are not launching this campaign because of any specific or imminent threat. Instead, launching this campaign brings the UK into line with almost every single European country and countless others around the world who already run similar campaigns every year. In developing this campaign, government has worked with more than 500 different organisations, emergency services, businesses, voluntary groups and local authorities to develop guidance that meets communities' needs. Now Mr Speaker, I would like to touch briefly on the guidance before outlining the campaign. The guidance is designed to help households be self-sufficient for three days in an emergency.
We've published a full checklist of the simple steps that households can take.
The two main actions are ensuring that you have three days of water and non-perishable food and signing up to the priority services register if you or someone in your household is eligible for extra support in a utility outage. Mr. Speaker, as many people who can follow this common sense guidance should follow this guidance. By playing their part, people will be helping themselves as well as others in their community because in an emergency, every household that's taken the steps set out on the checklist is one less household the emergency services need to give extra support to. We're also encouraging people to check in on their neighbors and be ready to help each other out.
We've worked hand in hand with charities to ensure the campaign is helpful for everyone, including organizations representing disabled people, people struggling with their mental health, and people who rely on food banks. Many actions on the checklist are completely free, such as signing up for the priority services register, and other actions can be ticked off over time by adding one item per week to the weekly shop. This is about helping as many people as possible to be ready for an emergency so that help can arrive to those most in need first. Now, to people who think the campaign is an overreaction, think of the people that I met in Cornwall and people in countless other communities across the UK, including tens of thousands of people who were without power this very weekend, whose lived experience proves otherwise.
Mr Speaker, moving to the campaign, it will run for at least three years and is called Be Ready. It's being run hand-in-hand with our emergency services, local councils and resilience forums and voluntary organisations. And I'm pleased to report that since launch, the campaign website has been viewed hundreds of thousands of times. The campaign checklist has been downloaded tens of thousands of times. And whilst it's too early to have formal polling data, anecdotal evidence and partner data shows people up and down the country are heeding our advice.
But this is just the start. Over the coming weeks, people will begin to see information about what they can do popping up online, on the radio and out and about in their local community. And that's just the point. This is a community-led campaign. And over the coming weeks, we'll also be sharing toolkits that partners can use to get involved.
I encourage members from right across the House to support the campaign, read the advice, and help their constituents be ready. Together, we can ensure our communities are ready for everyday emergencies whenever or wherever they occur. I hope that the Be Ready campaign will unite communities across the United Kingdom, and I'm working closely with the devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, all of whom back this campaign and the life-saving advice it will share. Mr. Speaker, before entering Parliament, I was proud to serve in the Parachute Regiment, whose motto, "Ready for anything," comes to mind today. But Mr. Speaker, what you might not know is that even longer, perhaps longer ago than I would care to admit, I was a boy scout.
Hard though that might be to believe. And honorable members opposite and across the House, all I'm sure will know the motto of the scouting movement. It isn't "dib dib dib," I don't think, as the right honorable lady has said. It is "Be prepared." Thank you very much.
Be prepared. Now, different circumstances certainly, but I think and I hope that the House would agree that there is wisdom in both of those mottos. Both remind us that we have a responsibility to be ready for the sorts of everyday emergencies that people faced just this weekend. And together, by taking the simple steps in this campaign, we can help people and communities right across the United Kingdom to be ready. I commend this statement to the House.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I start by thanking the Minister for advance sight of his statement and join him in sending my condolences to the families of the two men who lost their lives in the storms over the weekend. Now, we welcome measures to address the resilience gap, a process, as the Minister said, started under the previous government. Although I'm a little surprised to see that the Housing Secretary's suggestion to stockpile Sauvignon Blanc has not been taken on board by the Minister. But it is absolutely right that government tells people to be prepared for adversity. But I do have a number of questions I hope he's able to address this afternoon.
Firstly, the government's Be Ready campaign website lists 18 hazards, ranging from terrorism and adverse weather to animal and plant health and fires in the home. Which of these 18 does the government consider the highest risk, and has there been any recent changes to risk assessments that led to the launch of this campaign?
Secondly, I would like to address those people who are digitally excluded. How does the government plan to reach those people and will it be distributing printed resources? Printed resources, Madam Deputy Speaker, are not only vital for those who are digitally excluded but could become a lifeline for anyone who is unable to access the internet at the time of an incident. In his statement, the Minister rightly pointed out that only 13% of people in the UK feel they are prepared for an emergency. This is in stark contrast to other countries such as Spain where I believe the figure is just below 70%.
So can the Minister tell the House whether he has a specific take-up figure he would like to achieve by the end of the Be Ready campaign? I now come to the issue of costs. We all know that times are tough for people right across the country.
So how much does the Government expect this to cost the average family, and how much does the Government expect to spend on the campaign over the next three years? It has been reported that since the Government announced this last week, supermarkets have seen water and baked beans sell out, as well as a run on wind-up radios and torches. Did the Government communicate with major supermarkets and other retailers before it made the announcement to prepare them, or was it just dropped on them? With reference to emergency response coverage, the most important thing across the nation is that we have a joined-up approach so nobody is left behind. We cannot have a postcode lottery of an emergency response system.
So can the Minister tell the House specifically how he is working with the devolved administrations across the four nations and how he is working with local authorities? The Government became familiar with the emergency alert system over the summer after using it to warn people about disposable barbecues.
So since then, has the Minister reflected and made any assessment of the threshold for future use of the system and how many people may have turned off their emergency alert capability following its use in August? Next, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to address vulnerable people and what considerations the Government has made for them in the Be Ready campaign. How will the Government ensure that our vulnerable, our elderly, people with illness, parents of children with SEND and others are effectively communicated with and supported in a time of emergency? This cannot vary from place to place. Moving on to national security, the former Defence Minister said this week that the cyber-attack which caused £2.1 billion of damage to JLR last year was a state-sponsored attack.
First of all, Jaguar Land Rover deserve to know whether this was a state-sponsored attack and I hope the Government has told them.
But can the government say whether there needs to be more awareness in business that they are at risk from these type of attacks, and what more is the government doing to support our critical national infrastructure with cyber resilience and cyber security? Now the government has claimed that defense spending will reach 2.7% of GDP by the end of 2028. Considering the valuable work of our intelligence services, can the minister confirm that the entire single intelligence account is included in this, and can the minister explain how this fits with the NATO definition of defense spending? Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, the government has refused to confirm whether improving broadband infrastructure is included in the classification of critical infrastructure for the purposes of reporting against the additional 1.5% NATO commitment. Can the minister clarify today that improving broadband infrastructure does not contribute to the NATO spending commitment?
In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, we welcome the continuation of the previous Conservative government's efforts to address the resilience gap.
We will support the Government where appropriate, and we look forward to scrutinizing the Be Ready campaign as it progresses.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm genuinely grateful to the honorable member opposite for the reasonable way in which he's presented quite a long list of questions to the House today. I will endeavor to work my way through them in a systematic way as I possibly can, but if there's anything that I'm... I miss, I'll very happily write to him or very happily meet with him and discuss this matter. Not least because it is absolutely my intention that the work that we do to make our nation more resilient is a shared endeavor across this House.
I don't be that, don't believe that this should be a matter of political disagreement. I think the measures that we've brought forward are reasonable and common sense measures, and I hope that we can work together across this place to make sure that our communities, our constituencies are as resilient as they possibly can be, not least because that effort, that activity will contribute to our overall national resilience and our national security as part of this work. Now, the honourable member opposite asked an entirely reasonable set of questions. Let me run through them as best as I possibly can. He also asked specifically at the outset about whether the campaign was in response to a range of different risks, and he will know about the government's risk register, and he will have heard the point that I made earlier on about this campaign not being as a consequence of any specific piece of intelligence or not born out of any specific concern.
He and the House will understand that government at any one time are tracking a range of different threats to the United Kingdom, and this campaign will contribute, I think effectively, to our overall resilience. And I think he will also understand that there is absolutely a lot of merit in making sure that we prepare households and communities at a local level for the kind of everyday emergencies that we've spoken about today, and that there is a broader and wider utility to that preparedness when it comes to other risks that have been debated more recently, even those that are much less likely. I thought he made an important point about inclusion, and particularly with regard to those people who are not online. He's right to raise those concerns, and over the coming weeks and months, he'll see a range of different activities underway to make sure that we're able to reach into every corner of the United Kingdom, and including reaching those people who are not online.
I mentioned the radio but very happy to to think more about how we can make sure that nobody misses out in terms of being able to access this important messaging. He asked about the take-up figure. I said in my earlier remarks that this is a campaign that I anticipate will run for three years. I think the reality is the kind of messages that we're discussing today will likely run on for the longer term. And actually this work here that we're now launching in the United Kingdom is work that is done routinely in other parts of the world and particularly with partners in Europe and Scandinavia.
This kind of messaging is routine in most countries around the world and I anticipate that there will be a kind of normality of this kind of activity as we move forward in the future. The honourable member specifically asked me about the alert.
The decision to launch any alert is a decision that is taken very carefully and we weigh up a range of different risks. Whenever an alert is launched, there's always an extensive process of review and we're working through the detail of the most recent alert and very happy to discuss that further with him and other honorable members. He was right to raise specific concerns about ensuring that the vulnerable and the elderly are properly accommodated in the context of this campaign. We've worked very hard with a range of different stakeholder organizations including local resilience forums and the voluntary sector and the British Red Cross specifically to ensure that vulnerable people are properly catered for in the context of this campaign.
And I know that he will have heard the words I spoke earlier on about the importance that we attach to people signing up for the priority services register. And I think there is a job of work that I hope every honourable member will engage with in terms of looking into their own communities and encouraging their constituents to engage with this messaging and specifically where they think that they might be eligible, and there's quite a broad criteria that is attached, to sign up for the priority services register. He rightly made the point about cost of living pressures. And I hope he will have heard the words that I've spoken about there not being a requirement, obviously, for households to assemble all of these items in one go.
This is the kind of thing that people can do progressively and perhaps add a single item every week in their weekly shop. Albeit many households will likely already have many of the items that are on the checklist. But hopefully through the process of this campaign, households will think about how they draw those individual items together and be better prepared should an everyday emergency strike. So we're acutely conscious of the cost of living pressures on households right around the country. We're also absolutely determined to ensure that this campaign is done in a value for money way.
The actual costs of it are relatively low, but we think it is very good value for money, but we'll make sure that that is the case. The honorable member also asked about cyber. It's an issue that I take personally incredibly seriously, both in my remit as a Cabinet Office minister, but also through the Home Office as well. The honorable member will know that earlier this year, the government published a landmark cyber action plan overhauling public sector digital security.
And the next stage of that plan is to bring forward the national cyber action plan which will drive up standards across businesses and the wider wider society. There is a lot of activity underway across government and I hope that that is something that we can collectively all get behind. The final point that the honourable member opposite mentioned was with regard to defence spending. Now I genuinely welcome this debate because I think it's important for our national security and as the Prime Minister has said this government's commitment to the defence of our country is unwavering.
We've already delivered the biggest sustained boost to defense spending since the Cold War, committing nearly 300 billion over the next four years. We will honor our NATO commitment to spend 2.5% of GDP on defense by 2035 and set out a target date for when we reach 3% at the spending review. And we're delivering on our commitment to NATO by spending 1.5% of our GDP on wider security and resilience. This includes protecting our critical national infrastructure, defending our networks, ensuring our civil preparedness and resilience, and unleashing innovation and strengthening our defense industrial base.
Matt Western
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I commend my honorable friend and the government for starting this national conversation? As we've seen through the summer, through the extreme heat, but in just recent days, the storms ravaging our communities, or whether we've seen the issues with rogue states attacking our infrastructure, clearly there is a real need for this conversation to start.
He will know that the Committee, Joint Committee on National Security Strategy has got its inquiry underway into societal resilience. And therefore, I would welcome, as I'm sure all members around this House, what the Minister was saying about this three-year program. But will he commit to regular updates to this House, whether it be on the local resilience forums, the roles of individuals and the roles of business on how we can ensure wider societal resilience?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm very grateful to my honorable friend for his question and for the important work that he does chairing his committee. And the particular piece of work that he mentioned, I think is, is significant and important, and we look forward keenly to the findings that his committee reaches.
He's right to mention the three-year commitment that we've made. I think that's the right duration of time to aim for initially, but as I said earlier, I anticipate that we now live in a world where we'll need to constantly have these kind of conversations with communities right around the country in line with our European partners and with allies right around the world. And absolutely yes, I can give him the commitment that he seeks to make sure that we update his committee and this House.
Lisa Smart
Very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for advance sight of his statement. I'd like to place on record our thanks to the emergency services, volunteers and communities who respond to civil emergencies, whether that's storms, floods or wildfires. And I welcome the announcement of the Be Ready campaign and agree that every household that can be ready to look after itself should be ready to look after itself for at least three days.
During the first COVID lockdown, I raised more than an eyebrow when my other half stockpiled enough bottled water to keep us going for some weeks, but today he's been proved right and I fear I will never hear the end of it. The Security Minister rightly mentioned the importance of volunteers in his remarks. I wonder if he's spoken with our Finnish allies, for example, to learn from their experience in establishing a formal civil volunteer reserve who would receive non-military training and could be called upon in an emergency in the way that community first responders attend medical emergencies. Now, as he said, not everybody can stock up for three days. Those relying on food banks, older people, people with mobility difficulties are often the least able to prepare and the most exposed.
The priority services register can only work well if it's accurate.
So what more can the minister do to ensure it's kept up to date and could he say specifically what coordination is in place with the utility companies so information can be shared about their own lists of vulnerable customers. Now we know it's not just weather or climate change we need to be prepared for. Nationally significant cyber threats have doubled in the last year. The Liberal Democrats have called for a digital sovereignty strategy to ensure critical national functions are powered by technology that the UK can control. Could the minister update us on any progress being made specifically on digital sovereignty.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I'm grateful to her she raises a series of important points and I join with her in thanking the emergency services for the incredibly important work that they do in communities right around the country. She's right to raise the issue of volunteers.
I am aware of the very good work that's taking place in Finland and in Scandinavia. They've had a more forward-leaning approach to these kind of campaigns than has been the case here in the United Kingdom, but I will look more closely at the specific point that she makes about how things are working in Finland. I agree with her about the importance of the priority services register. We are working with utility companies and we are working to ensure that there is as much awareness as there possibly can be at an individual household level of the need to sign up for the priority services register. As I mentioned previously, the criteria is quite broad and therefore I would encourage colleagues across the House to engage with their own constituencies and use this as an opportunity to encourage people to check their availability on that particular register.
I thought she made an important point about sovereignty.
I work very closely across government from the Cabinet Office, but with colleagues in DCMS and elsewhere, to make sure that our digital infrastructure and our critical national infrastructure is as resilient and as protected as it possibly can be. As she knows, we face a range of different threats in that regard, and it's important that government is properly geared to stand against those threats and work closely with our international allies to do so.
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I thank the Security Minister for his statement on this vital topic and indeed welcome the much-delayed start to the national conversation. It is widely acknowledged that military effectiveness in the event of conflict is reliant on civilian systems being able to function under attack, whether that's physical or cyber. And that in turn relies on a whole-of-society approach. So can I ask the Minister why in the forthcoming national exercise, Albiston Shadow, why is that classified and therefore excludes those from outside government? If we rightly accept that resilience is a whole-of-society endeavor, then why is the government not engaging more widely with industry, with councils, with civil societies, with right honorable members in this House so that we can properly stress-test the planning and also what information-sharing mechanisms have been established to ensure that key individuals without the necessary clearance, security clearances, that they are included in the event of crisis or conflict?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, I'm grateful to the chair of the select committee and I agree with his broader point about the importance of wider societal resilience. He's absolutely right about that and that is work through the home defence programme that we lead through the Cabinet Office but working with partners across government including, of course, the Ministry of Defence. He specifically referenced Alveston Shadow. Alveston Shadow is due to be the largest home defence exercise that we've run in the United Kingdom for many, many years.
We are still working through the precise design of that particular exercise, so I'll reflect on the comments that he's made and we'll look to see whether we can accommodate some of the points that he's helpfully flagged.
Edward Leigh
In the early 1980s, with other enthusiasts, I set up the National Council for Civil Defence and worked with Willie Whitelaw. And we achieved a major milestone in the Civil Protection in Peacetime Act of 1986. And it was taken over by local government officers, a serious organization. When the Cold War ended, this whole civil defense effort atrophied because there was considered to be no threat. We now live in a very different world.
So will the minister make some attempt to try and improve our entire civil defense structure? There was a leaflet issued by the then Conservative government called Protect and Survive. Now I know war is very unlikely, but it's best to be prepared.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I certainly agree with the Father of the House that it is best to be prepared. It's interesting that he was reflected on a time where there was a greater awareness of the potential risk of conflict, but he's also right that the threats that we face today are very significant. And I think the world is more dangerous than at any point since the period that he described. I hope that he will understand that government takes these matters incredibly seriously. I hope that he will see that we're working across government to ensure that we have the appropriate defences in place and the appropriate resources to underpin those defences.
We do need to focus people's minds on a range of different threats to our national security. This Be Ready campaign will better insulate households and communities, and I hope that he will agree that there will be a broader, wider benefit to that in terms of our national security and in terms of keeping the country safe.
John Slinger
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I warmly welcome my right honorable friend's statement. Would he join me in praising Ben Brook, the Chief Fire Officer of Warwickshire, and his firefighting team and administrative team for the brave efforts they were involved in this summer, where the month of July at 771 incidents was the highest on record, double the July rate in 2021?
And would he confirm that the government will do all it can to provide the fire service in Warwickshire with the resources they need and also the support to help with reaching out to the public about the parts of his statement around their involvement in resilience?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I'm very grateful to my hon. friend and I absolutely join with him in praising Ben Brook and his team in Warwickshire. I know that they did incredibly important and difficult work over the course of the summer. My hon. friend may have seen that just last week the Prime Minister hosted our inaugural wildfire summit where he announced military planes and helicopters will take to the skies to fight wildfires for the first time as we prepare for future extreme weather driven by climate change. But amidst that announcement, I know that the Prime Minister took the opportunity to pay tribute to those who put on a uniform and serve in our fire and rescue service for the incredibly important work that they do and clearly that is the case in my hon. friend's constituency as well.
Julian Lewis
If rule number one as far as resilience is concerned is be prepared, does the Minister agree that rule number two should be have a reliable backup system? In that connection, does he share my concern that both in the field of telephony and in the field of banking, backup systems don't seem to exist? In particular, was the government consulted before British Telecom decided not only to move onto an internet-based telephone system, but actually to dismantle the copper wire system which could have given us useful levels of resilience in an emergency?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Madam Deputy Speaker, I broadly agree with my right honourable friend's rule number two. He's right to stress the importance of having backup systems.
Essentially, that is a guiding principle in this campaign, to make sure that individual households do have their own individual backup systems. But he's also right that government needs to obviously think about the bigger picture and ensure that we have that resilience across our critical national infrastructure and in the areas of business and commerce that he's referenced. I can give him an assurance that government works very closely with partners in the private sector. There are various forums that provide opportunities to engage on these matters. We take them very seriously, but I'll look more carefully at the point that he's made.
Nia Griffith.
Nia Griffith
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Well, given that tin food is key to being prepared for an emergency as you can eat it even without having power to cook it, would the Minister recognize that Tata's Trostre steelworks in my constituency of Llanelli, which makes the tinplate that is used by big name manufacturers to can their products, is of strategic importance to our national resilience? And will he stress to his ministerial colleagues the absolute necessity of ensuring that conditions such as energy prices are competitive to secure a viable future for tinplate production in Llanelli?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I think my honorable friend makes a really important point, and I know that colleagues in government will have heard it and I will make sure that they have. But she's right to emphasize the the wider kind of industrial issues at play here. She'll know that tin cans were included on the sort of checklist, and she's right to raise the point that she has, and I'll give her assurance that I'll raise it with colleagues in other government departments.
Ben Lake.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
Our subsea infrastructure is incredibly important, and we know from recent reports that the Russians have been sniffing around this, both with the GUGI submarines and the recent reports about Russian trawlers investigating our undersea infrastructure. But I'm very concerned that we only have one UK-based and UK-flagged repair ship, the CS Sovereign. It's due to go out of service in 2030. I asked a question six months ago to DSIT around what they were doing to investigate replacing this capability. Could the Minister give us some assurance as to what the government's plans are to ensure that we have UK-based and UK-flagged repair capability for our subsea infrastructure?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I think the honorable and gallant gentleman does raise a really important point around subsea infrastructure. It's something that I've taken a particular interest in working with colleagues across government, but including with the Ministry of Defence.
He's also right to raise the threat that is well understood about the threat from Russia. I know he will understand this, there's always a balance to be struck, both in terms of recognizing the threat that they face and ensuring that we're properly prepared to defend against it, whilst at the same time, and the Director General of MI5 made this point, that we shouldn't make them out to be better than they actually are and do the propaganda of the work on their behalf. But he has raised an important point. Let me look more carefully at the detail and I'll come back to him with a more precise response.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Storms can strike anywhere at any time, as I found out last week. In many of our communities, it's neighbors and volunteers who step in at critical times. In North Warwickshire and Bedworth, it's groups like the Fillongley Flood Action Group stepping in to keep homes safe.
What more can the Government do to ensure community groups can help make sure all vulnerable people are ready?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, my hon. Friend, I think, raises a really important point. And she speaks about the kind of groups that all of us will have in our own constituencies, those local groups who come together to support each other and others. On a recent visit to Leicestershire, I saw the excellent work being done by a local flood action group in terms of protecting their community following on from floods that they suffered.
We've been very careful to ensure that the design of this campaign has been worked through with both local authorities, local resilience forums, and a range of different voluntary and charitable organisations. I believe very much in that sort of sense of public and community spirit that exists right across the country, and we want to encourage and enable that activity so when an everyday emergency does strike, communities can come together and look out for each other.
Freddie van Mierlo.
Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In my constituency of Henley and Thame, Greener Henley have already sprung into action and are seeking community champions to organise street by street. So what action will the government take to support community-level organisations to improve resilience not just on a household basis, but on a street level too?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, similarly, my honourable friend makes an important point, and I reiterate what I've said just a moment ago, that the design of the campaign has been worked in conjunction with community and voluntary groups who we all know from our own constituencies do an incredibly important job.
I have to say to him that the launch of the campaign has been warmly welcomed by a range of different community and voluntary organizations right around the country. We want to work through local authorities and with local resilience forums with those kind of organizations so they feel both empowered and enabled to support their communities. But all of us as members of this House, I know, have a responsibility to work and support them at a local level.
Mary Creagh
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. You and I spent many hours in meetings managing the disastrous fallout from South East Water's outages around Tunbridge Wells and the surroundings. And I'd like to put on record my thanks to you and colleagues from around the House for your role as trusted message bearers to people caught up in those outages.
One of the lessons I took from that was the need for people who are both at the start of their lives and at the end of their lives to be properly looked after. What can my right honourable and gallant friend do to make sure that local authorities, water companies, and energy companies are working with local nurseries and, critically, acute NHS services so they know who has just left hospital, who is at end of life, and who is under five in order to put them proactively on the priority services register?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I'm grateful to my honourable friend. She speaks with great authority on these matters, not least from her own time in government, and she's right to make the points in the way that she does. I know that she will understand that there is a lot of work that takes place in local authority areas and with local resilience forums to look at the kind of issues that she's raised to ensure that there is that visibility of where there are more vulnerable households.
And that's precisely why we're taking the opportunity to encourage members of the public and colleagues in this house to get their constituents to check their availability for the priority services register. That is a really useful document in this regard. But I know that local resilience forums will be working on the kind of issues that she's raised, and of course we'll keep a close eye on them in government.
Gavin Williamson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We all know that in points of emergency and such as power outages and so many other things, mobile networks are incredibly important. The villages of Huntington and Hatherton have virtually no signal at all.
And with the withdrawal of the shared rural network, which is funding for rural communities to be able to get better mobile services, what should villages such as this look towards doing to make sure that they can get those mobile networks that are so important at these critical times?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, the right honourable gentleman is absolutely right. Mobile networks are very important, and I saw myself in the aftermath of Storm Garett in Cornwall the impact of losing that mobile and digital signal even for a relatively short period of time. There is a lot of work taking place in government, led out of DCMS, to ensure that there is that resilience and, in the aftermath of any extreme weather event, that there is urgent and ongoing work to restore capabilities where they've been lost. But my right honourable friend makes an important point, and I know that again local resilience forums will be looking at the particular challenges in their areas, working with utility providers to ensure that where coverage is lost, it can be returned as quickly as possible.
James Mark Sewards
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I welcome the Minister's statement today. He will know very well that earlier this year the Protecting What Matters strategy that was announced to this House also had some excellent proposals to strengthen community resilience. I just wondered if he could update the House on progress towards that strategy and exactly which proposals we've made progress on up to date and to this day.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well I'm grateful to my honorable friend. I think he raises an important point.
I'm limited in the amount of time that I have to respond, but I can update him that there has been positive progress with regard to that particular area of work. It sits adjacent to the discussion that we're having today, but he's right to raise it because it is the case that at points of everyday emergency or where particular communities are subject to emergency circumstances, it can be the case that there are those who would seek to use that as an opportunity to sow mis- and disinformation. So of course the government is extremely mindful of that, and that is one of the reasons why the Prime Minister recently announced the creation of NSCID.
Alistair Carmichael.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Laying in three days' supplies in the Northern Isles is what we do if we're confident that we're having a mild winter. Just four years ago, parts of Shetland were without electricity for six days, so resilience will look differently in different parts of the country. But to take him back to his answer to the honorable member for Huntingdon, the government recently launched their consultation on critical undersea infrastructure security and resilience.
They seem in that to see the answer to be one of regulation and legislation. As the honourable gentleman said to him, we need to have the capacity to effect repairs to undersea cables and not to do so with any long delay as currently happens. So will he take away that need and the experience of my constituents in recent years who suffered a number of digital breakages as a consequence?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, the right honourable gentleman is absolutely right to raise it. He and I have discussed it previously and he explained with great clarity the impact the loss of that capability had to his constituents. I hope he gets a sense of the seriousness with which we take it, but both in terms of my right honourable gentleman and the member opposite, I will write to them with more detail of the work that we're doing.
Helena Dollimore
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And I wanted to raise the issue of water outages, which I know, Madam Deputy Speaker, you have also been working on in Sussex too. I've previously lobbied the minister about upgrading how we see the risk of a water outage in the national risk register, and I was pleased to see that upgraded from the lowest form to the highest form of risk in the most recent register. But I did want to flag some issues, particularly around the priority services register, which we have encountered during outages in Hastings. The first is that blocks of flats where you have multiple residents but you have one bill payer, such as a management company, that is particularly common in sheltered accommodation. The water industry has said to me that Southern Water and the industry find that their arrangements are designed around identified account holders and bill-paying customers.
In centrally billed or bulk-metered properties such as blocks of flats, water companies typically have no direct relationship with individual residents and do not hold information about their circumstances, which creates a recognised industry challenge.
So that is something we really need to look at in terms of resilience. And also, I'm very aware they are not updating the risk register in line with the electoral register. So when people move out, it's not updated, and they then end up with so many people on the register that the deliveries become unsustainable. So could the Minister look at those issues?
Speaker 153
I'm just as interested in the response as it covers my constituency too, but we need to make sure questions are much shorter and answers on point. Minister.
Speaker 151
Mr. Pritchard, if you're happy where you're sitting, is there anyone else who wants to sit in the chamber today? Mark Pritchard.
Mark Pritchard
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Having now thrown me off my question, can I just say the Security Minister, Cabinet Office Minister knows I have a huge amount of time for him, but I want to slightly break the consensus mostly in the chamber today. I think the government's communications, mass communications, public communications are confused on this. On the one hand, we're being asked by senior ministers to stock up on corned beef and water and whatever because of storms. Well, breaking news, there have been many storms over the last 80 years in Shropshire and indeed around the country.
We've never given been given this advice before. So if it is about being on a war preparedness, a war footing, as the former Defence Secretary suggested we should all be, I think the government should just come clean and treat the British public with a little bit more respect.
And the example, Madam Deputy Speaker, is at the beginning of the Ukrainian war, defense intelligence was signed off by the then defense secretary Ben Wallace. Defense intelligence was shared with the British public, so the British public came along with the government, came along with the Ministry of Defense. And I think that's what the security minister needs to look at as a good example.
Speaker 153
In case it wasn't understood earlier, questions need to be shorter and answers on point. Minister.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I have a lot of time for the right honorable gentleman. He's basically asked a good series of questions that lend themselves more to a longer debate than I'm able to sort of do justice. But let me emphasize what I said earlier, that this campaign is about taking the simple, straightforward steps to be ready for everyday emergencies like severe storms or floods. However, at the same time, there is significant amount of bandwidth across government to be talking about some of the other threats that we face as a nation.
And I think that that is what he is referring to. Ultimately, what we've got to do, and this is done out of the center, we've got to make sure that we are preparing at a local level communities for the everyday emergencies that we've been talking about today, whilst at the same time, of course, making sure that we are properly prepared to face the very severe threats that we face from countries like Russia.
Graham Downie.
Graeme James Downie
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Just a few weeks ago, I hosted an event in Parliament with ambassadors from Denmark, Norway, Estonia, and Finland around this exact topic. And there was two commonalities of themes about their plans at home. One was around building public trust, and hopefully what we're seeing today in the national conversation is part of that. But the second was around the need and indeed the benefits of engaging businesses, both to inform employees and potentially use them as resource as well, but also to say that they could be targets for something like a cyberattack, but also part of the response.
Can the Minister confirm he will speak to those allies about that specific point around the importance of engaging businesses and that that will be considered as well?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
So I'm grateful to him and he makes an important point about engaging businesses. We're certainly doing that. We're also working closely with our allies, including the countries that he referenced. Trust is important. The polling that we've done shows that 84% of the public expect the government to be providing this information and only 13% of households think that they are properly prepared.
So it is important that we establish that honest conversation with the public to give them good common sense practical advice which will mean that they will be more resilient in their own households and that's what we're doing.
Peter Wishart
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker.
I represent the biggest river system in the UK and part of the UK that has some of the most inclement weather so I and my constituents are fully familiar with being prepared and being ready for what is what could possibly come. But where I struggle with a little bit is the other stuff in the statement and I'm baffled by the lumping together of storm readiness and other undefined threats that can't be properly outlined and named. Does the Minister not agree that storms and weather events are critical known standalone threats and there should be distinct and separate strategies for them and lumping it together with national security subsea cables and cyber threats is confusing and perhaps even unhelpful to people who just want to be prepared?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Let me say to the honourable gentleman how important we how much importance we attach to doing this right around the United Kingdom.
So this is a UK-wide campaign and we have worked closely with partners in the devolved governments to ensure that this can be as simple and as joined up as possible. The relationship with colleagues in Scotland is a really important one, not least because of the challenges that he's alluded to. I hope that he will see that this is the beginning of a campaign. Fundamentally, we're wanting to engage the public about simple measures that they can take in their own lives. This is a first step, I hope that he will join with us and support it.
Catherine Eccles
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Minister for his statement and I welcome the Be Ready announcement.
I've got friends in Valencia who were impacted by the devastating flash floods in 2024, and Spain and many other countries have long provided resilience and emergency preparedness advice to their citizens. But thankfully, my friends Eva and Pablo only lost their cars in the floods, but that culture of resilience meant they had essentials at hand and could help neighbors and vulnerable people as part of a community effort alongside the emergency services and regional authorities. So with extreme weather threats now a reality here in the UK, as we saw this weekend, does he agree this is right for us to adopt this approach to resilience and it is about everyone playing an active part in preparedness and in their communities?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I think she's absolutely right. It is about people playing an active part in their own communities to ensure that collective resilience. She's also right to reference the example of Spain. Spain has been doing this work for a considerable period of time, and what they've been able to do is build more of a culture of resilience. That's common practice amongst our neighbors in Europe and further afield, and that culture of resilience is something that we're seeking to build here.
Speaker 161
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In rural South Shropshire, we face flooding and power cuts every year, so I do welcome this campaign. However, I do not believe it's landed as the government intended because the strategic defense review set out a whole-of-society approach, a national conversation about the threats we face for resilience. And we've talked about the Finnish model. They clearly know the threats through proximity.
Speaker 160
I believe to get the public on side, we have to clearly set out the threats to critical national infrastructure that could close the internet down for several weeks or power outages, things like that. Does the Minister agree with me taking that approach will help the country prepare better?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I'm grateful for his broad welcoming of the campaign and listen very carefully to what he had to say, and I don't think there is much disagreement between us. I mean, let me say to him that the government is constantly reviewing and updating our response to a wide range of different threats and scenarios to ensure that we are prepared for every eventuality. He will know that through the Home Defense program, we've been running a variety of security and resilience exercises. There are more of those to come. This is important work, but the Be Ready campaign sits as a strand of that activity alongside other work that we're doing with other colleagues, including the Ministry of Defence.
Speaker 162
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the statement and I support the Be Ready campaign.
The committee heard from the Fire and Rescue Service who are very much in support of the whole society resilience approach, but the constant theme that was coming out in terms of resilience was clarity in terms of what role that the government would like them to play in this space. So essentially I'm urging the Minister to think when looking at the Civil Contingencies Act, thinking about the role that the Fire and Rescue Service could play in that space and make sure that they are part of the process.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I think the Chair of the Select Committee raises an important point. This was something that I know that was discussed at the Prime Minister's inaugural wildfire summit just last week. It is absolutely on the Prime Minister's mind and it's been raised with me on a number of occasions at a local level. I think she does make an important point and I know that colleagues in other government departments along with my own are looking at what more we can do.
Adam Dance.
Adam Dance
Madam Deputy Speaker, flooding in Somerset is a huge issue and one of my care homes in my constituency flooded last year within seconds.
Yes, the government have given Somerset a lot more money towards flooding, but it doesn't go far enough. What else can this government do to support rural Somerset with being ready for flooding this year?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I understand why the honorable gentleman will want to raise concerns about his own area. That's absolutely his responsibility to do so. He will, I hope, have heard the comments I made earlier about the amount of money that's been invested in flood defenses. These are matters that we take incredibly importantly. I know as a former metro mayor the importance of issues relating to flooding and working across local authority boundaries to make sure that along with the Environment Agency and water companies, we have a proper response and a proper defensive posture put in place.
It is a matter that I discuss regularly with my colleagues in Defra and if he's got any specific concerns or anything specifically he would like us to look at, then I'd be very happy to do that on his behalf.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As a Cornish MP, we had 18,000 off-grid again with Storm Austin this weekend and we all worked together closely during Goretti. And I want to mention Cormac, our farmers, the National Grid and our parish councils. This national guidance was missing during Goretti. It's really important that we now have it and we have this locally-led response with parish emergency plans in place as well.
Other countries have been doing this for years and I'm really pleased this government has finally done this and brought this in and run this campaign. One of the issues we will have though always is comms. We don't have copper wire anymore. Maybe those internet and mobile providers should be category two responders under the Civil Contingencies Act and I wonder if the Minister could comment on that.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I'm very grateful to her, not least because the Cornwall experience and the the experience of Storm Arwen has been genuinely really important in terms of shaping this campaign. And I'm grateful to her and her Cornish colleagues for the important role that they play. I know that there will be a storm summit taking place in Cornwall towards the end of November and I've asked the Director of COBRA and his deputy to be there. And I think that provides a really important forum for discussing the kind of issues that the honourable lady has raised today.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In any emergency communication is key. And in answering my right honourable friend for Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge's question earlier, the Minister talked about restoring mobile services if they'd been damaged in, for example, a storm.
But that rather misses the point for villages like those that my right honourable friend mentioned and villages in my constituency like Cuddington and Bright's Bottom that have no mobile signal right now. So through this resilience work, what more can the right honourable gentleman do with other government departments to speed up delivery of the shared rural network and get those rural not-spots the connectivity that they need and deserve?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
So I think the honourable member does make an important point. Communication is key. I know he'll understand I was responding to a specific point about where a particular capability had been lost and how that could be restored as quickly as possible. But I take his point about areas that don't have that connectivity in the first place. I'm sure that that is a conversation that we'll want to have across government to look at what more we can do working with colleagues in DCMS.
But let me take it away and I'll come back to him with some further thoughts.
Alexander Robert Ballinger
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the government's serious approach to civil preparedness. I just wanted to push back slightly against some members on the benches opposite, which said, kind of implied there was a difference between being prepared for natural disasters and being prepared for some of the hybrid attacks we're seeing across Europe. I mean, in recent months, we've seen attacks against energy infrastructure, attacks against railways, attacks against supply chains. And the same preparedness, I think, would help UK folk prepare for that as well as for natural disasters. I was in the Finnish embassy a few days ago to talk about this particular issue, as other colleagues have mentioned.
They talk about businesses working together with the voluntary sector, working together with public bodies. I wonder if the minister could say a bit more about how we're learning from countries like Finland on the whole of society working together.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Thank you. We are absolutely determined to learn lessons from our neighbors, and the Finnish example, which has been mentioned previously, I think is a very good example of that.
I know that he will understand that this campaign brings the UK into line with many other countries across Europe and further afield. It builds on the existing guidance that's already been published on gov.uk. But of course, there's another important point to make, which is the actions people take in their own households to be ready for one emergency can also help in the context of other emergencies as well.
Al Pinkerton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The United Kingdom is arguably already in a state of hybrid war against our adversaries. So my question is, with this strategy that is designed to strengthen community resilience, can I ask, is there a cognitive component that the Secretary anticipates as part of this program, not least to make this resilience program resilient against the kind of active disinformation that's likely to seek to undermine the very strategy that he is putting forward?
And in that spirit, how will this dovetail with the National Center for Disinformation?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I hope that he will see that there is, I think, a reasonably obvious correlation between resilience at a local and community level, as well as there being a kind of national resilience. Our national resilience is only able to be as strong as it can be if we've kind of underpinned it with work that takes place at a localized level. This is work that we have not done previously as a government, and we do need to build that wider societal resilience, and we're starting bottom-up by investing in individual households to ensure that that is localized resilience. There will be wider, deeper benefits to our national security as a consequence of that.
NSID was something that the Prime Minister announced just recently which will mean that we are much better placed to deter and defeat the misinformation that we've seen for too long.
Torcuil Crichton.
Torcuil Crichton
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I quickly pay tribute to the men and women of Scottish and Southern Electricity who are out there right now reconnecting homes in the Western Isles who have lost power over the weekend due to the storms. Resilience is inbuilt in the islands but as other members have pointed out we have major problems with connectivity because of this move from analog to digital phone lines which means when the power goes out people don't have the phone, they don't have the internet and often they don't have a mobile signal either.
Now, BT and Openreach's response, giving power packs to vulnerable customers who ask for it, is simply not adequate, and mobile phone providers simply do not have the means to maintain or keep their signal going during storms. Can the Minister call in these companies, get them to up their digital game to make sure there is digital resilience, and not just in the places that are easy, but on the edge, where people are vulnerable, isolated from their neighbours, where the ambulance is an hour away and the storm is 70 miles an hour?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
My honourable friend is right to raise the concerns in the way that he has. I can tell him that our telecommunications networks are a vital part of the UK's critical national infrastructure, and our emergency response in weather-related crises supports the functioning of essential services and keeping people connected when they need it most. I know he will understand there's an important role for DCMS, but I've listened very carefully to the comments that he's made and I'll speak to colleagues in that department about it.
David Reed
The Minister will know how much I want the government's Be Ready campaign to succeed, and I've shared my views with him at length because the threats are real and they are increasing. But if the government's going to go out and ask people to stock up on tinned food and wind-up radios, then they have to be honest when we are actually attacked. Now, the shadow minister raised the case of Jaguar Land Rover and the fact that a former armed forces minister said at the weekend that this was state-sponsored. This is incredibly serious. So can the Minister use this opportunity to tell us which state was responsible?
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I'm sorry to disappoint the honorable member opposite that I'm not going to use this occasion of talking about Be Ready to get into matters relating to cyber attribution, not least because I know he will understand that these are complicated processes that need to be done in a certain way.
The House will be well versed in the challenges that Jaguar Land Rover faced last year. There is a lot of work, a lot of work across government to ensure that resilience, both amongst the public and private sector organizations here in the United Kingdom. I will have more to say about it with the launch of the National Cyber Action Plan that will be coming later this year.
Frederick Thomas
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the government's Be Ready campaign, which I will champion in my patch in Plymouth. And I thank the my right honorable friend for his continued endeavor over the last several years to knot together different bits of government agenda and departments to grow greater resilience. Can he give the House some assurance that this will encompass AI and emerging technologies as well, and give us a sense of what new endeavors are being stood up given the massive acceleration in the threat to our national resilience in that space?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I'm grateful to him, not least for his kind words and his observation about the importance of drawing this together across government. This does need to be a response that is balanced right across government departments in order to ensure that wider societal resilience. He's right to reference AI. AI of course brings a number of very significant challenges that I tend to focus on, but there are also very significant opportunities including this in this particular area. I work very closely with the minister for AI in this endeavor and I'd be very happy to discuss it with him further.
Adrian Philip Ramsay
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The minister is right to highlight the growing risk of the loss of services and utilities in emergencies. Preparedness needs to be driven at a national level, but much of it needs to be delivered at a local level.
So can the Minister tell us how is he ensuring that local resilience forums are adequately funded, and can he assure us that every part of the UK has got a local resilience plan in place?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Minister. Well, I think fundamentally the honourable gentleman makes an important point, and he's right and I agree with him that this needs to be driven at a national level, and that's precisely why we've launched a national campaign. But he's also right that it needs to be delivered at a local level. And that is why for some time now there has been very extensive consultation with local authorities through the Local Government Association and with local resilience forums. I think he makes an entirely reasonable challenge about ensuring that there is that coverage in every corner of the United Kingdom.
We're certainly working very closely with metro mayors in England and the devolved governments in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales.
But fundamentally, it's my job to satisfy myself that we have got that response right around the country, and that's a responsibility I take very seriously.
Perran Moon
Perran Moon. Merci, Madam Deputy Speaker. Cornwall, the Cornish peninsula is on the front line of our Atlantic storms, and we are getting more and more storms. In January, Cornwall was smashed by Storm Gerrit, as the Minister knows. Cornish MPs then met ministers and civil servants to discuss the Cornish infrastructure issues that were exposed.
On Thursday, 18,000 properties, Cornish properties, were left without power after the first storm of the season. So can the Minister advise, following those discussions, specifically what did the Government change in Cornwall's infrastructure to improve our resilience in the nine months between 6th of January and the 22nd of October, because the time for talk is over.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I agree with my honourable friend, Cornwall is absolutely on the front line when it comes to our resilience. And I'm personally determined to make sure that we do not only learn, but also implement lessons post-Storm Garetti. There has been extensive consultation between officials in the Cabinet Office and officials in Cornwall. And I referenced earlier to my honourable friend, the storm summit that will be taking place later next month provides a really important opportunity to discuss those issues further.
Speaker 170
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Government is right to talk about national resilience and preparedness, about where we keep our torches, amongst other things. I do not wish to catastrophise, but national resilience starts with something fundamental: producing food. And that means supporting our farmers.
So does the Minister agree that if food is not being produced, this country will very quickly discover how fragile resilience really is?
Minister Jarvis.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And echoing concerns raised by members across the House, I ask the Minister to imagine an elderly constituent living alone in an isolated Lake District valley, where copper phone lines have been replaced with fibre. A storm takes out the power to their router in the night, and by the time they wake, the modest battery backup has failed, as has the mobile mast. Does the Minister share my concerns that they would have no way to raise an alarm in an emergency, and agree we need a new technological solution to protect the elderly?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I absolutely do share his concern, but I would again take the opportunity to emphasise the importance of the Priority Services Register.
Helen Maguire.
Helen Maguire
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I very much welcome the Be Ready campaign today. This government has very much been pushing for devolved responsibilities, particularly at the mayoral level, yet in his statement today, the Minister made no mention of the vital role that local authorities can play. So I wonder if the Minister could expand on the role that local authorities can play in community resilience and preparedness.
Minister.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
I think that is a little bit unfair because I've, I think, been at pains to emphasize the important work that local authorities and local resilience forums do in that regard. That is certainly my view. We've certainly been very careful to ensure that they've been absolutely involved with the design of this campaign. We've been in regular contact with the devolved governments and with metro mayors. But her fundamental point about the importance of local government, I think, is absolutely right.
I think local resilience forums do a really important job. They've long championed the need for a campaign like this, and we'll continue to work closely with them in the delivery of it.
Peter Swallow
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will know from our many conversations my concerns around the foreign state threats we face and the threats from terrorism, but he'll also be aware that Bracknell Forest, which is 33% tree, is at particular risk of forest fires, and many of my constituents are also seeing power cuts at the moment because of the storms. So can I just get him to confirm to this House that the government's Be Ready campaign is about raising not alarm, but awareness of the full range of threats that we face to our community resilience and empowering local people to have the tools at hand to address those concerns.
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, absolutely, and I'm grateful to him for his long-standing interest in these matters. He's right. This is about ensuring that the public are alert but not alarmed. It's about ensuring that the public are ready, and that is the purpose of this campaign.
Claire Louise Young
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Millions rely on daily medication to stay alive and healthy. We know the concern shortages cause. The NHS doesn't allow people to stockpile prescription medicines, and some require refrigeration. So will the NHS now allow people to keep a small amount of spare medicines, and how will the government ensure access to essential medications during widespread disruption to supplies, movement of goods, or power?
Daniel Owen Jarvis
Well, I think the honorable lady is absolutely right to raise this particular issue, and I know that she will have seen that on the checklist there's specific advice with regard to medical and health. The design of the campaign has been worked up very closely with a range of different organizations, and we've had a range of different stakeholder cohorts in mind, including those people who are medically vulnerable for a range of different reasons. So we are acutely conscious of the risk to those particular people, and we think that this campaign has been very carefully designed to ensure that they are not only at the forefront of our mind, but they will be best protected in the context of an everyday emergency.
Speaker 153
That is the end of the statement on strengthening community resilience. I'll give the front bench a moment to shuffle over.
Timothy James Farron
Madam Deputy Speaker, in Foreign Office questions earlier today, the Minister, the honourable member for Midlothian, whom I have informed, answered a question from the honourable member for Mid-Bedfordshire, who I've also informed I'd be mentioning him. They had a conversation on the matter of returning Eritrean asylum seekers to Eritrea. Indeed, they spoke of conversations between the Foreign Office and the Eritrean government. At no point during their exchange was it remarked upon that Eritrea is widely regarded as the North Korea of Africa, and under its murderous dictator Isaias Afwerki has become the fifth most dangerous place on planet Earth to be a Christian or a member of any other minority faith.
What can we do to ensure that the Minister and her officials are aware of these facts and to come to this house and explain the extent of their conversations with the Eritrean regime, given that it would be an act of extreme wickedness to return any asylum seeker from Eritrea to Eritrea.
Speaker 153
I thank the honorable member for giving notice of his point of order and also for making sure the members were alerted to before they were mentioned in the chamber. This is not a matter for the chair, but he has got his point in the record and the government front bench will have heard what he has said and pass that on. I'm now moving on to the ten minute rule motion. People are leaving the chamber, they should do so now quickly. We now move on to the ten minute rule motion, developer contributions, infrastructure delivery, James Nash.
James William Naish
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to make provision about the use of developer contributions for the delivery of local infrastructure, to make provision about the responsibilities of public authorities and other public bodies in relation to such contributions, and to make further provision in relation to such contributions. Nine billion pounds, Madam Deputy Speaker. That is how much money in developer contributions is currently sitting unspent in local authority bank accounts across this country. This is money collected from house builders and commercial developers to pay for schools, for GP surgeries, for leisure centres, for roads. It's money that has already been paid by developers and which would ideally be being spent at no extra cost to the taxpayer in local economies up and down the country today.
But it's not.
Instead, it sat in bank accounts and year on year the figure grows. At a time when every community in this country is calling for more investment, it is my view that we cannot afford to sit on this amount of money, either morally or economically, as inflation devalues the contributions originally made. For me, this is a major problem and one that all members should be interested in. And I am tabling this 10-minute rule bill today to hopefully bring attention to the problem whilst suggesting some initial solutions. Madam Deputy Speaker, I asked the internet what I could buy with 9 billion pounds.
Firstly, it told me that this was the equivalent of roughly 135 pounds for every person in the United Kingdom. It then told me that for this money, I could purchase 33,000 homes at 272,000 pounds apiece.
Nearly four years of school rebuilding funding at 2.4 billion pounds per annum. 18,000 electric buses assuming 500,000 pounds per bus. Or 1.5 million household solar installations at 6,000 pounds per installation. In short, Madam Deputy Speaker, this amount of money is transformational. It is enough money to improve several struggling sectors at the same time.
What's more, this money isn't theoretical. It exists, it has been paid, and local authorities are currently the custodians of it. For those who haven't been involved with local government finance and planning before, let me briefly describe what is happening.
When developers build homes or commercial spaces, they are normally required to pay towards the associated infrastructure as part of their planning permission. So when new homes are built, the developer contributes to new schools or school places, to GPs and or local hospitals, to leisure facilities and or to other local infrastructure. Crucially, the contribution is exactly that, a partial payment that another developer will also need to pay towards in due course to complete the intended project. Each year, the Home Builders Federation publishes data on how much money is unspent. And each year, the figure is going up.
It's gone from around 8 billion pounds in total in 2024-2025 when I first raised this issue in this place to almost 9 billion pounds in 2025-2026. Within this, the latest data shows that there is 2 billion pounds waiting to be spent on schools. There is 700 million pounds for affordable housing. And 3 billion pounds, a third of the money held, has been held for more than five years. In Rushcliffe, my own constituency, the situation is particularly acute.
Our local council is holding around 40 million pounds in Section 106 money and another 8 and a half million pounds in Community Infrastructure Levy money. This is money that my constituents desperately want to see spent, often on infrastructure that they were promised when they bought a house, sometimes many years ago.
The challenge with spending this money is so extreme that in some cases developer contributions are at risk of being returned. For example, East Leake in my constituency. It's a village that has grown by 40% since 2001. It has needed a new health centre for the past 20 years, but due to delivery and value for money challenges, we are currently in a situation where funds have been held on file for so long that almost 500,000 pounds of developer contributions are due to be returned. This is unconscionable to a community that has waited for investment for two decades.
In nearby East Staffordshire, almost 400,000 pounds was returned to a developer in 2023 after the money wasn't spent in time.
And there are many other examples across the country. In many cases, additional public sector support is ultimately required to close developer funding gaps. This is not a failure of any one council or any one developer. We all know that costs rise, that land can be lost, that partners do not act quickly, that councils can at times lack capacity. And yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, we still haven't put a backstop in place.
There is no mechanism by which ring-fenced pots of money can be pooled together, no deadline by which councils must make every endeavour to facilitate works, no power for councils to easily revisit old agreements.
In short, no obligation on anyone to act. This means the money doesn't ultimately move. It simply accumulates while residents wait for action and delivery costs increase ahead of bank interest rates. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the current economic climate, I don't think this is good enough. So I would like to propose that this bill does four things.
First, it introduces a backstop. Where contributions have not been spent within a set period, councils should have more power to reallocate them to related public infrastructure in their area, subject, of course, to democratic oversight. We are seeing that time and time again, if things aren't built quickly, the funding gap grows. We need to develop a system that recognises and seeks to mitigate this as best as possible.
Secondly, a duty to plan. Where money is held for education, health, or transport, I believe the body responsible should produce a delivery plan within 12 months of the first developer contribution being agreed. Accountable bodies must be clearer about how they plan to get a spade in the ground. Thirdly, transparency. I believe all local authorities should produce a standard public infrastructure funding statement showing how much money has been collected, what for, and when the money is expected to be spent.
There isn't currently a standardized way of doing this. And finally, I believe we need to look at a sensible bridging loan facility for local authorities to close existing or emerging gaps, to be repaid from future contributions as they come in.
This would mean a school or health center could open as families are arriving, not years later. Madam Deputy Speaker, as MPs, we all know that handled badly, new developments become a source of grievance. But handled well, they become something else, a story of investment. I know that an updated developer contribution system couldn't guarantee all promised infrastructure being built quickly. But I believe that the current situation fails everyone.
It fails councils and councillors who want to deliver infrastructure. It fails local supply chains and businesses who want to help build. It fails developers who want to deliver on their promises for multi-purpose sites.
And it blatantly fails residents who lack the services they were promised, often for years on end. But ultimately, Madam Deputy Speaker, given we have a fiscal event taking place tomorrow, it should be stated on the record that unspent developer contributions fail our economy and our country's growth strategy. 9 billion pounds in local authority bank accounts is not growth. It is deferred jobs, deferred infrastructure, deferred community benefit, and we shouldn't stand for it any longer. Good growth in every postcode needs councils that can build the infrastructure their communities need.
This bill would give them that power. Madam Deputy Speaker, I believe a more efficient, outcome-centered approach to spending developer contributions is something that everybody in this place wants to see.
It's something that we must see, and I therefore commend this bill to the House.
Speaker 153
The question is that the honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Many of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no, the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?
James William Naish
Alistair Strathern, Dr. Allison Gardner, Andrew Cooper, Chris Bloore, Dave Robertson, Leigh Ingham, Maya Ellis, Rachel Taylor, Mr. Richard Quigley, and myself, Madam Deputy Speaker.
James Naish.
19th March.
Speaker 187
19th of March. Right. The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Speaker 184
Building safety, remediation of unsafe cladding etc. bill, second reading.
Speaker 183
I call the Secretary of State to move the second reading, Secretary of State Angela Rayner.
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that the bill now be read a second time.
Madam Deputy Speaker, nine years ago, 72 people, 18 of them children, died in the Grenfell Tower tragedy. It was a deadly betrayal and a national tragedy that must never happen again. Let me start by remembering those who lost their lives and pay tribute to the bereaved families, the survivors, and the members of the Grenfell community. In the time since, the community has campaigned to fix the building safety crisis exposed by that tragedy. And that, Madam Deputy Speaker, is why we are all here today, so that no one suffers as they have.
A decent, safe and secure home is not too much to ask for, but for many, it is still out of reach. Despite nine years passing since the Grenfell tragedy, up to 380,000 residents are still living in buildings with unsafe cladding. Every single one of them tells a story of someone unable to move on with their life, stuck in an unsafe home, unable to sell and often unable to sleep at night. There are even stories of families evacuated without any guarantee of when they can return home. The mental and financial burden can become unbearable.
We have taken action and we have accepted our responsibilities, but the truth is others have not.
There are still people and companies out there who are not acting quickly enough to make homes safe. Of the 4,724 buildings where unsafe cladding has been identified, work has been completed on only 1,849. Regulators have so far had to take enforcement action on over 900 buildings where those responsible were not taking their responsibilities seriously. And as a government, we will stand up for every leaseholder who is stuck in an unremediated flat, unable to move on with their lives and facing huge costs in the meantime.
Madam Deputy Speaker, when this government came to power, the pace of remediation was unacceptably slow. That is why in December 2024, I announced the remediation acceleration plan, our blueprint to identify all the buildings with unsafe cladding. And we are now delivering on that plan, which means buildings will be fixed faster and residents are supported better.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank my right honourable friend for giving way, and I declare that I am a leaseholder that did have cladding, though happily that's now been resolved. But I represent one of the largest concentrations of new builds with cladding, and there are really serious issues, as the Secretary of State's begun to highlight today, Madam Deputy Speaker. Back in 2020, the Public Accounts Committee issued a report talking about the need for improving skills and getting more contractors available.
So I appreciate what's happened in 2024 and the grip that she took as Secretary of State then. But can she perhaps flesh out a bit more what work she's doing with other departments to make sure that we're getting the skilled workforce that's needed? Because that is one of the biggest slowdowns in getting my constituents the justice they deserve.
Secretary of State.
Angela Rayner
I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. She's absolutely right. We do need to make sure that we have the skilled workforce. MHCLG alongside other departments have put more investment into making sure that we have the people in post and we'll continue to do that piece of work. And we also launched a national identification drive to understand the scale of the problem, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And I will give way to the honourable gentleman.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way and I commend her on the bill and the work that she's done and the statement she's just made. In my constituency, the local authority has been very good and very effective at dealing with dangerous cladding and did it immediately and that's to their credit. And that is basically the story across the whole country.
However, the private sector is less like that. I have a number of places, Drayton Park, Highbury Gardens and other places in my constituency, which have had years now of unsafe cladding, massive insurance costs and as she quite rightly said, the inability to move on in their lives. Is the government able to take over this responsibility, make sure the work is done and charge it to the perpetrators of the problem and above all, ensure there is compensation to the residents for the massive, and they are massive, insurance costs they've faced over the last few years?
Angela Rayner
Well, I thank the right honorable gentleman for his contribution and he's absolutely right to highlight the devastating impact this has had on the communities. And hopefully this bill will go some way to meeting the right honorable gentleman's things that he wants to see for his constituents. And anyone who has deliberately failed to mitigate or remediate buildings over 11 meters will face tougher consequences as a result of this bill, including fines of up to 500,000 pound, Madam Deputy Speaker, and where needed, criminal prosecution. And since we did the launch of the national identification drive to understand the scale of the problem, we have found, Madam Deputy Speaker, over 200,000 building records have been reviewed. This is significantly improving our understanding of the affected building stock and enabling remediation activity to be targeted more effectively.
And to drive the pace of remediation work, we also gave social housing providers equal access to government funding schemes for the first time. And I'll give way to my honourable friend.
Janet Jessica Daby
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way and I thank her also for the work that she's been doing on remediation work for dangerous cladding. Some constituents of mine have been able to benefit from the remediation work for buildings that are under 11 metres, but I wonder if the Secretary of State could just say a bit more about when that funding will become available, because my constituents are still waiting for that release of funding for the work that needs to take place.
Angela Rayner
I thank my honourable friend for that and hopefully as we go through this you will see how we are in particular changing the emphasis on making sure that the buildings that are most at risk are the ones that are remediated first. And as I said, we have also made sure that housing providers, social housing providers, Madam Deputy Speaker, have access to the government funding schemes for the first time, investing over one billion pounds to make sure that the most vulnerable residents have safe homes. And we have ended the binary approach to remediation funding based on building height. And I give way to my honourable friend.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank the Secretary of State for being so generous of her time, but picking up on the point made by my honourable friend the member for Lewisham, a number of my constituents are stuck in blocks because they're not high priority. They don't have as much cladding to be removed, but they're down the list because there's not enough skilled people to do the work. Not always that the developer is dragging their heels, sometimes that's an issue as well.
And so for the sake of a small amount of work, their lives are on hold, unable to sell their properties, challenging to get a mortgage, all the issues that we know that people are still facing this many years on. And I wonder if she could take away to the department to revisit some of the priority issues and get some of those blocks that could be done quickly up the list.
Angela Rayner
Again, I thank my honourable friend for that intervention and I hope she'll see in the passage of this bill that we're hoping that we can do this piece of work because we do understand the devastating impact this is having on people's lives. And all buildings are now considered based on the risk presented to those living in them. And as part of this, we have announced, Madam Deputy Speaker, targeted funding for buildings under 11 metres with the highest risk so that the cost of fixing cladding on those buildings does not fall to the leaseholders. And we will always make sure that developers pay their fair share towards making buildings safe.
We have already agreed stretched targets for developers to accelerate work to assess and remediate buildings, and we will hold them to account on their progress. I'll give way.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank the Secretary of State for giving way? Over this weekend in my Dartford constituency in Ebbsfleet, we've seen the damage that a fire in a residential block can cause. And I would like to express my concern for those who were harmed in that fire and those who have been displaced by the fire in Bodiam Street in Ebbsfleet. Another block nearby, Heron Court, has recently had a waking watch imposed on it by FirstPort, with the costs accruing to residents.
Do these two instances not just underline for everyone in this House how important it is that we get this bill through Parliament so we can get some recompense and some support for residents who are suffering under the current regime?
Angela Rayner
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm really sorry to hear about the situation in his constituency, my honourable friend's constituency, and many members across this House since the Grenfell tragedy have had similar experiences of fires and actually fatalities. And as I outlined in terms of the thousands of buildings that need this remediation, as Secretary of State, it's one of the things that weighs heavy on my mind every night, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wouldn't want my family to be in a property that was unsafe, and I think that's why this bill is so important. And the honourable, my honourable friend makes an important point about waking watches, which I'll come onto in further into my speech. I'll give way to the honourable gentleman.
Shockat Patel
Thank the Minister for giving way.
I just want a clarification, minister, because I believe that only 10% of 394 pledged development projects are ever completed. But under this bill, I believe that resident management companies can face criminal charges, but the developers who signed the pledges don't. Can't you clarify that for me?
Angela Rayner
Yeah. Yes, we're trying to make sure that those that are responsible are part of that. And we know that people like manufacturers, etc., have been using routes to try and get out of paying their fair share and doing what they need to do. This remediation bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, is about closing some of those gaps that we see, and I'll be looking forward to working with the honourable gentleman as this bill goes through the House. And Madam Deputy Speaker, we have also made sure that social housing providers also have ambitious targets for the completion of all remediation work for which they are responsible.
The data is clear that the action is working. Since we published the remediation acceleration plan, over 470 more buildings are reported to have completed remediation. That's around 35,000 more residents who can at least feel safer in their homes. I'll give way one last time, thank you.
Janet Jessica Daby
I really appreciate her for giving way, and I just want to press the Secretary of State just a little bit further, because there's a block of flats that are under 11 metres in my constituency. They've already been recognised as priority, but the challenge that is being faced at the moment is the release of that funding.
And I'd just appreciate it if she would arrange to meet with me or indeed agree to look at this further.
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And my officials would have heard that call and either myself or the minister who's sat in her place will be happy to meet with the honorable member. And coming back to my honorable friend's point regarding residents paying for costly waking watch patrols, Madam Deputy Speaker, we provided an additional 62 million pounds for fire alarms in buildings with defects. This will keep residents safe until remediation work is completed and saves leaseholders around 280 pounds per month. And we are also taking action on insurance.
We will introduce secondary legislation to do two things: strengthen transparency and bring the insurance commissions ban into force.
That ban will stop people, including freeholders and property management agents, from passing those commissions on to leaseholders. This will end the incentive for unscrupulous landlords and agents to seek out unearned profits and simply pass the cost on to innocent leaseholders. I'll give way to the member at the back.
Speaker 162
Thank you. I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for giving way. I just want to thank her work on this. Some of the campaigners have raised concerns about the PAS method in terms of how the government has come to the conclusion in terms of how it's legislated. I think there's concerns that it could be gained by developers, making the situation much worse for residents.
Angela Rayner
We are establishing a single consistent approach to assessing external walls so buildings are judged on the same basis. Central to this is the PAS 9980 which will become the required standard for fire risk appraisals of external walls. And before the end of the year, Madam Deputy Speaker, we will bring forward the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill. This will put power back in the hands of residents and tackle unfair costs and charges. We will cap ground rents at 250 pounds per year before reducing them to a peppercorn after 40 years and also cap administration fees.
Speaker 193
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way and I very much welcome her back to the cabinet. It took months of legal wrangling in court battles to get a million pound refund for leaseholders and 9 million pounds in remediation works on Empire Square in Southwark. So whilst I fully support the government action to tackle the freeholder delays and neglect and some of the charges involved, could the Secretary of State set out how some of the penalty levels were set in this legislation? The sum in section 6 is capped at 14,000 which seems very low given the overall sums involved. And perhaps the Secretary of State could set out how the department is working with leaseholders and other stakeholders to set fees that secure the pace required to deliver the ambition that she and the government have.
Angela Rayner
I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. And Madam Deputy Speaker, this is about fixing the challenges we face and making sure that those that are not taking responsibility do that. And I'm happy to continue the conversations with my honourable friend to make sure that we get that balance right. But that's what we want, Madam Deputy Speaker. We want these people to take responsibility and to do the remediation work.
And the remediation bill before the House today is the next major step in the ending of the building safety crisis. Now give way to honourable member.
Tessa Munt
Thanks Secretary of State greatly, and I applaud what she's doing. But can I just ask her please, would it not be sensible to stop the business of fire engineers paid for by the building owners from using PAS 9980 to sign off dangerous cladding as acceptable, so that assessments actually confirm that buildings meet building regulations instead?
Angela Rayner
Well, we'll be, we're working on this and the PAS 9980 is the established approach used across government remediation programs and it provides a robust and proportionate way of identifying the risk of fire spreading through a building's external walls, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the action needed to keep residents safe.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a rare opportunity to get to speak and get the direct answers from the Secretary of State in the House, not as not a reflection on her, but but this is what we're here for. I have a constituent who's very expert in fire safety and we know that there's been a real issue about the Adam Kiziak forged EWS1 forms issue. But instead of having the set standards, the fire safety is now done on measures of tolerability. And I've raised this in a Westminster Hall debate with her colleague, the housing one of the housing ministers, because this is a real concern going forward. This bill doesn't address all of that.
And I wonder if this is in her mind and whether we could she could meet with other interested members of parliament across party because a number of us have this issue and my very able constituent Ian Abley who's very expert on this to discuss how we can make sure that we're future proofing this system because we cannot afford to have mistakes made as we try and solve the problems of the past.
Secretary of State.
Angela Rayner
Well again I thank my honourable friend for her intervention and she highlights that actually this remediation bill is crucial and important as part of our ongoing challenges with the remediation action plan. And the minister will be quite happy to meet with her to go through the specifics in terms of the fire safety and the regulations that we have regarding that Madam Deputy Speaker. But this bill will help us to complete the task of identifying all remaining buildings requiring remediation. It will introduce an 11 to 18 metre building register giving government a complete record for the first time of all medium rise buildings in England.
It will also mandate how external wall assessments are carried out to ensure a nationally consistent approach to remediation. And for the first time, Madam Deputy Speaker, the bill makes it indisputable that responsible entities have to remediate building safety defects with urgency through a new legal duty to remediate. They must take action now or risk severe consequences, including criminal charges where appropriate. And I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is unacceptable that enforcement is too slow and penalties too weak to compel those responsible to act. It's why we will give regulators the tools that they need, including the ability to issue escalating financial penalties or pursue criminal prosecution in the worst cases.
And from now on, no building and no resident will be left behind. Our new remediation backstop will allow public bodies to step in and carry out remediation work for themselves. This will mean that residents have a route to remediation even where the responsible entity is determined to ignore their duty to keep residents safe.
James William Naish
Will the Secretary of State give way? Thank you very much for giving way. Exactly 12 months ago, I met with the then minister alongside the mum and brother of Amanda Walker. Amanda sadly took her own life as a result of the cladding scandal, which consumed her completely. Before her death, she gave evidence to the other place seeking five changes, including closing the loopholes that leave non-qualifying and disenfranchised leaseholders exposed and an industry-funded remediation scheme.
I know the minister is aware of Amanda's case. I just ask that she would consider Amanda's asks as the bill continues through this place.
Angela Rayner
I thank my honourable friend for highlighting this case and the incredible work that the family have done. And I've wrote, Madam Deputy Speaker, to her mother today, who has been absolutely tremendous in making sure that some of the measures that are within this bill have been tabled. And, you know, it was a devastating case and I thank the member for raising it today.
As I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, our measures will be backed by tough sanctions so that responsible parties cannot benefit, including cost recovery and the potential sale of their interests in the building. We will also bring an end to indefinite decants where residents are evacuated from their homes and given absolutely no assurances as to when they can return. And we will empower residents to make sure that their buildings are safe even where the responsible entity is absent, neglect or insolvent. But Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is not just about getting the work done. It's also about making sure that the cost of the remediation work is borne by those that are responsible for the building safety crisis.
And this brings me onto construction product manufacturers who produced unsafe cladding and released it onto the market and have yet to meaningfully contribute towards the remediation work.
As well as being unjust, this puts additional financial pressure on those that are getting on with doing the work. And this bill will fix long-standing gaps in the law. Developers, contractors and others who have paid to make buildings safe will be able to properly pursue manufacturers rather than being blocked by technical legal barriers. And that's not all. I intend to table amendments as the bill passes through Parliament to go further on the construction product redress.
Through this bill, for the first time, we will require relevant construction product manufacturers to contribute towards remediation costs met by the taxpayer.
It is not right that taxpayers should shoulder the burden on their behalf. Madam Deputy Speaker, at the heart of everything that we do to make buildings safe are the residents and the leaseholders who bear absolutely no responsibility for the building safety crisis but feel its most acute consequences. The most important thing that we can do for residents is to remediate their homes as quickly as possible to ensure that they are safe. But this is not just a safety crisis. For many leaseholders, the presence of unsafe cladding on their homes has had a terrible financial toll.
Whilst the Building Safety Act protects the majority of leaseholders from substantial building safety costs, there are some groups, Madam Deputy Speaker, who remain excluded and are exposed to remediation bills.
Some are forced to pay higher insurance premiums until their buildings are made safe. And as a member of this government, which is committed to lowering the cost of living, I am not prepared to let this continue. That is why today I can announce that the government will go further than ever to shield leaseholders from the financial burden of this crisis. I am pleased to announce today that this government will commit grant funding towards the remediation of high-risk, high-cost internal fire safety defects in eligible collectively owned and enfranchised buildings. These buildings do not benefit, Madam Deputy Speaker, from the existing protections because there is no separate freeholder to carry the cost.
This funding will narrow the gap between leaseholders in these buildings and those already protected from remediation costs under the Building Safety Act, giving them greater certainty and support in making their homes safe.
Speaker 199
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and could I thank the Secretary of State for her drive and determination on this very important matter. Could she perhaps update the House on a little more of the detail relating to this particular group of residents, and in particular those who face issues with dangerous materials inside their properties, such as wood or other inappropriate materials which have led to a potential fire safety problem?
Angela Rayner
Well, again, I thank my honorable friend for raising this issue, and hopefully what I've said today and outlined today goes some way to giving reassurance to those that have raised this issue with us.
And since my return to government, my noble friend Baroness Blake, who is watching the debate today, and I have met with End Our Cladding Scandal. We have heard the requests of their members and other leaseholders to expand the leaseholder protections in the Building Safety Act, and we have heard from those who bought their first home only to find it is a non-qualifying lease. This government will investigate whether we can extend the protection to any leaseholder who owns a lease as their only principal home. We have also heard the plight of those with small portfolios who were excluded from protection. As this bill passes through Parliament, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will table amendments to expand the cap on protection from three to six properties.
And in the manifesto, we committed to reviewing how to better protect leaseholders from costs. These actions show, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we are a government who is committed to keeping its promises.
Hilary James Benn
Would my right honourable friend give way? I very much welcome what she has just announced in respect of those who found themselves the owner unbeknown of a non-qualifying flat because of the previous owner. It's clearly unfair that they should be penalized. Will that legislation be retrospective? Because I have the case of a constituent who unbeknown to him had bought a non-qualifying flat and was gobsmacked, traumatized actually, to discover that this is what had happened to him and he is facing potentially huge costs.
Speaker 200
So will someone who's already in that position benefit from the amendment that my right honourable friend has just announced?
Angela Rayner
Well, we're hoping to make sure that nobody is left out and feeling those pressures.
And the my honourable friend makes a very important point. And I think that as I outlined before from many of the groups that we've met with recently, they are making the case that we need to be pushing harder to do everything we can. And as we go through this bill going through Parliament, we're happy, the minister is happy to meet with members to see how far we can go to make sure that we're doing everything we said in our manifesto, in our commitment to accelerate the pace of remediation, to better protect the leaseholders and to ensure that those responsible for the crisis pay towards putting it right. And our record since 2024 shows that we are getting on with the job, but there is still work to do.
It's why the remediation of unsafe cladding bill will go further than ever before. Every building we make safe helps those living in these flats and those looking to buy a home the confidence that they are safe. This is about restoring trust, Madam Deputy Speaker, in our housing market, protecting our communities and bringing an end to the building safety crisis once and for all. And I pay tribute once again, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the Grenfell community, the survivors, the families that were affected and for all of us who have contributed to getting to this stage and making sure that we have this bill in front of us today, and I commend this bill to the house.
Speaker 202
The question is that the bill be now read a second time, and I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Katie Lam.
Katie Lam
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for her remarks. All of us across this House agree on the fundamental need to resolve this issue. As the right honourable lady has so movingly said, the appalling fire at Grenfell Tower and the resultant loss of life was horrifying and I join her in her tribute to the victims, survivors, their friends and family. We all agree that the homes in which people live are the place where they ought to feel safest. That so many people across the country are still living in homes which have been rendered unsafe is deeply concerning and we welcome the government's desire to put it right.
Those of us on this side of the House do have some concerns about some of the specific provisions of this bill and about whether or not the proposed measures will definitely ensure that more people end up living in safer homes. I will set some of these out today and we look forward to working with the government to improve this bill however we can.
At the moment, remediation of unsafe cladding is often slow because there are simply not enough qualified people to do the work. This point has been mentioned this afternoon by the honorable lady the member for Hackney South and Shoreditch but I would like to spend a moment on it. Every affected building needs a specialist assessment of its external walls at a time when both fire engineers and assessors are in short supply. Training new specialists takes years, yet this bill does not lay out any particular plans about the training of these skilled professionals. Contractors face the same shortage of skilled labor and materials.
Too often owners who want to act cannot find anyone to carry out the work. It is slow because the work is complicated and unpredictable. When old cladding is removed, contractors regularly find further defects so the scope, the cost and the delays all grow. On top of these practical difficulties, many of the buildings concerned are part-owned by their leaseholders.
And it is slow because practical implementation of the existing legal regime is fragmented. Remediation is managed building by building, with responsibility split between owners, managing agents, contractors and three overlapping regulators. Unsurprisingly, that drives up cost and drags out timelines, however willing the owners are. This bill's answer is to ask the three regulators to write a statement on how they will cooperate, which is not the same as getting the work done. We already have evidence that a legal obligation such as the one proposed in this bill does not by itself guarantee timely remediation.
Developers on the developer remediation contract, which the last Conservative government implemented so that developers, not taxpayers, would cover the cost of remediation, are already bound by equivalent requirements, which is why this bill exempts them. The government's own figures show that developers have finished work on only a third of their buildings and fewer than one in four of all their buildings with life-critical defects. The National Fire Chiefs Council, in responding to the Public Accounts Committee, has warned that limited workforce capacity is the primary bottleneck to remediation. NFCC Chairman Mark Hardingham put it best when he said that we cannot enforce our way out of the cladding crisis. Gladly.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank the honorable lady for giving way. And I don't want to make this a party political point because I think that we all know this was one of the biggest failures in regulation in many generations and it's affected many people very badly.
But it is a disappointment and I wonder if she can reflect as new to her post and new to in this parliament that that sometimes decisions need to be made early. And it was under James Brokenshire, her predecessor in to the Secretary of State. He made some bold decisions in the early days after Grenfell and sadly he's no longer with us. But then there were delays in things like getting fire safety surveyors trained up. It takes three years.
If those decisions had been made earlier, we'd be in a better position now. And so I just wonder, you know, in a spirit of trying to improve things, if she wants to reflect on perhaps why those decisions weren't made and why we need to be backing this government bill to make sure that we move as fast as we can.
Katie Lam
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank the honorable lady for her intervention. I think it is fair to say that there have been all sorts of ways in which the response to this appalling event and and the wider questions that it raised did not happen as quickly as we might have liked, were not as effective as we might have liked. Otherwise, we wouldn't still be discussing it today.
But I think what's important now is that we make sure that whatever plan we come up with together as a Parliament is the most effective that it can be to make sure that people are living in the safest possible homes. That is our responsibility now. It should not come as a surprise that legislating to make something true does not make it so. Passing a law which says that buildings must be fixed will not create a single new fire engineer. But rather than easing these practical bottlenecks, this bill too often assumes that the main blocker to timely remediation is owners deliberately choosing not to act.
And our fear is that as drafted, it may risk making the problem worse. Under this bill, every building must be assessed within a year, and every assessment that recommends work must be audited by Homes England, drawing on the very same small pool of specialists. There are owners who obstruct, and they should face the full force of the law. But they are the exception and not the rule.
Once again, I do not doubt the intentions of this bill are noble, Madam Deputy Speaker, but we must always be careful that legislation drafted with the best of intentions does not produce unintended consequences. Perhaps the clearest risk of unintended consequences comes with regard to the new legal duty proposed by this bill. Owners could see themselves facing two years in prison or penalties of up to half a million pounds for deliberately failing to remediate as soon as reasonably practicable. Those standards, deliberately and as soon as reasonably practicable, are broad and subjective, particularly given the severity of the punishments prescribed by this bill. And given that many of the decisions about whether or not owners have complied with these standards will fall to the regulator, can the government be sure that due regard will be given to the very real practical hurdles to remediation?
What guidance will regulators get on what counts as reasonably practicable? The government will doubtless intend that these measures are to be used only in the most extreme cases of deliberate obstruction or delay, but we must be incredibly careful when designing new legal duties and new criminal penalties. Like it or not, these will both hang over owners who are attempting to act in good faith, but are constrained by the practical difficulty of remediation. Likewise, opening up directors to personal prosecution on grounds of neglect risks generating unintended consequences too. While directors' liability for building safety is long established, this bill goes much further.
Has the government assessed how many capable people will simply refuse to be named as directors on remediation compliance plans? What will it do to the cost of directors' insurance? And what impact will it have on the willingness of well-run management firms to get involved in residential property? How many will conclude that it is simply no longer worth the legal risk?
Has the government assessed whether or not this will have an impact on access to directors' insurance more broadly? And has the government assessed whether or not this bill could create a disincentive to involvement in residential property by well-run management firms? Another point of concern derives from this bill's approach to group accountability for parent companies and firms which are deemed to exercise control. They build on powers already in the 2022 Act, but extend them from recovering costs to imposing penalties for offences, and the government must do more to explain where this stops. In 2022, Parliament let a court or tribunal look through a company structure where it was just and equitable to do so.
This bill would allow a regulator to adopt quasi-judicial powers and enforce large penalties in doing so. Limited liability is an important principle, Madam Deputy Speaker, which has endured in its modern form in this country for more than a century and a half.
It encourages investment and entrepreneurship. The erosion of limited liability that this bill represents may set a worrying precedent. Until now, Parliament has only qualified this principle through the courts. This bill qualifies the principle through regulators rather than judges. If that is acceptable in one sector, why not in others?
And even if we confine ourselves to this specific sector, can the government be sure that the erosion of limited liability will not create a direct deterrent to investment in large residential properties, including build-to-rent? Housing in this country is far too expensive for far too many people. People must be able to trust that their homes are safe, but there also need to be homes for them to buy or rent in the first place. Another concerning legal precedent emerges from this bill's provisions on retrospective liability for product manufacturers.
In 2022, the last government gave building owners a route to claim against the manufacturers of defective cladding. This bill goes much further. It loosens the test itself, so that a product need only have contributed more than trivially to a building being unsafe. The government must explain why the 2022 test was not enough. Compliant with the regulations in force at the time will no longer be a defense.
Firms that followed the rules can no longer rely on having done so. Nobody would deny the existence of bad actors, Madam Deputy Speaker, firms which have broken the rules or falsified evidence about their own compliance. Such firms and such actors have put people in danger and some of the consequences have been unimaginably awful. They must be punished. But there is no reason to believe that these firms would have complied had the legal standard been tougher.
The point is that firms which break the rules are going to break the rules, no matter what they are.
The problem is, as is so often the case, one of enforcement. And yet, in an effort to tackle this non-compliant minority, this bill extends retrospective liability well beyond what Parliament agreed in 2022, something which we must always be very cautious about. When firms or individuals cannot be sure that complying with the law today will ensure legal safety tomorrow, their behaviour can change. They may be more reticent to enter the market in the first place and certainly more reticent to innovate. Insurers will price in that risk and every new home will cost more to build.
As with so many aspects of this bill, in attempting to achieve a noble aim, the government risks undermining important principles.
The presumption against retrospective legislation, the principle of limited liability, the principle of clear legal tests, these are foundational to the way in which we have designed the law in this country. We can deviate from them, of course. In our country, Parliament is sovereign and can make whatever law that it chooses. But when we do deviate, we ought to make sure that this is done with a full appreciation of the facts and the implications. It ought only to happen when we can see no other way to solve the problem at hand.
And it should certainly only happen when we are sure that new legislation, rather than better enforcement or efforts to ease practical bottlenecks, is the right course of action. Once again, I would like to reiterate my appreciation for the intention behind this bill. That anybody should feel unsafe in their own home because of structural or material faults is a profoundly depressing state of affairs. Yet, in pursuing this noble aim, we have concerns that the government may not have given due regard to some of the unintended consequences of the solutions it proposes.
As this bill progresses, we will probe all these points and more, and we look forward to working with the same noble aim to improve this bill however we can.
Edward Joseph Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wish we didn't have to be here debating this bill today. First and foremost, because we are here largely due to the Grenfell Tower fire over nine years ago. And it is right we again remember the 72 who lost their lives in an entirely avoidable fire and recognize the suffering bereaved survivors and the Grenfell community in my constituency continue to endure.
I want to place on record my thanks to the Prime Minister for his commitment at questions two weeks ago to work with me every day for justice for the victims and for the determination of the Secretary of State to find solutions across government to implement the Grenfell inquiry recommendations and make necessary changes to how our state functions, including on building safety. Our hope and expectation is that those responsible will face the full force of the law when the Crown Prosecution Service make their charging decisions by May next year on the 20 organizations and 54 individuals passed to them by the Metropolitan Police. And while we wait for justice through criminal accountability, almost 10 years on, we must also pursue justice through meaningful change in policies, laws and culture. And that is how I approach this bill today.
But the second reason I wish we weren't here is that I believe many of the provisions in this bill should have been enacted a long time ago, and at very least should have been part of the 2022 Building Safety Act. How is it that the state of Victoria in Australia has completed works on 99% of the 1,600 buildings which needed remediation in a similar timeframe since Grenfell, while we have only completed 39% of 4,724 identified buildings, and more have not even been assessed, something this bill tries to assess. In Victoria in 2020, they passed a law setting up a group that assessed all buildings over three stories, identified those at risk using a common state-prescribed standard, and then paid for the work via a fund upfront, in part capitalized by developer contributions. I will give way.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
I thank him for giving way, and I think what he said is absolutely excellent. Does he accept that there is a sort of cultural issue surrounding this, in that the dangerous cladding on Grenfell, as on many other places, was dismissed as being unimportant because it was often poor working-class families living in those places, and they simply didn't care about it? And this bill, I hope, will change that culture as well as bringing safety to an awful lot of people.
Edward Joseph Powell
I think the right honorable gentleman is absolutely right.
Residents were ignored who raised concerns and the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea made a decision on cutting costs which resulted in the contract that was ended up being such a major contributory factor to what happened. And I should say, I haven't had the chance to say this on the record, but I'm really pleased that one of the individuals involved in that is no longer leading housing in Barnet for their TMO there. That was a wrong decision and it has been corrected and I'm glad that they've done that. And in short, what Victoria did is the government stepped in to put homeowners and residents first. And instead, in this country, the previous government took a market-based approach that has comprehensively failed in my view to deliver remediation in a timely way.
And why?
Because in my view for too long the British state has been too passive in the face of this problem, relying on private developers to come up with the answers while millions of people have suffered the consequences. Indeed, I think the British state's response to the cladding scandal has exposed many of the weaknesses I know this government wants to fix: unaccountable power, opaque ownership and shirking of responsibility, penny-wise cost-cutting that stores up massive costs in the future, and a lack of public control over the basics in life, including housing. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope this bill will make a contribution to that effort by creating more jeopardy for those delaying remediation and more options to finally fix every building that needs it. But the work to make buildings safe must continue even while we debate this bill.
There are powers that currently exist, including remediation orders and remediation contribution orders, that can be useful tools if ministers provide that hands-on grip on the crisis, coordinating local remediation plans, creating national standards, and I should say ensuring the budget tomorrow continues to fund the department to get the work moving now. I believe we belatedly do need to shift to a fix first and fast model based on risk, as the Secretary of State said, and leveraging all the existing avenues that exist to get work started.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank my honorable friend for giving way and concur with his tributes to those who lost their lives and loved ones in the tragedy of Grenfell. I remember the shock in this place when that happened. I have this real concern about tolerability and how fire safety is assessed, and this was something that built up over generations. They were not, as he's given a summary of it, but the decisions on building safety were left to the wrong people. There was no outside inspection.
And tolerability is a subjective standard rather than having a set of fixed standards. And I wondered if he had anything to say about that, because I think we need to be really clear as we're going forward, we fix that problem. It's not down to individuals where some developers can cherry-pick who will assess the building safety of a block, knowing that some people will pass when others would be more rigorous. That is not an acceptable situation.
Edward Joseph Powell
I thank her for her intervention and I think she makes a powerful point. At the very least, there needs to be independent scrutiny of these assessments so that people can feel reassured that someone is checking whether they pass muster. And it should be about the whole of the building being made safe. I think the Secretary of State referred to that.
Cladding defects are an extremely important component, but there are internal fire defects that also need to be assessed that have contributed to costs rising. So I do welcome the remediation backstop in this bill that will give Homes England and local authorities the power to step in. But in my view, that should not only be a tool of last resort, it should be something that gets the system moving as quickly as possible. And that's because we've seen how leaseholders in particular have ended up shouldering the burden in recent years. Just to give one example, others have already spoken about leaseholders that they represent.
In Earl's Court, in Kensington and Chelsea, at Shastry Place, residents approached me in 2024 after receiving huge increases in service charges driven by a disputed fire risk assessment that led to a massive spike in insurance premiums from 15,000 pounds a year for the building to 310,000 pounds for the building. The following year it went to 375,000 pounds. So for one leaseholder, their annual bill for the insurance went from 269 pounds a year to 4,146 pounds a year. The landlord in this case, Notting Hill Genesis, with a shared ownership scheme, told leaseholders that the insurance rise was linked to a fire risk assessment that they had commissioned. But residents disputed this fire risk assessment alongside the classification of the building as high-rise.
In fact, they had even miscalculated the number of stories in the building when they did the assessment, which obviously undermined confidence in that assessment. And the building safety regulator later agreed and removed the building from the high-rise register.
And several residents until recently were still receiving legal threats on the non-payment of these charges, causing them huge worry and anxiety, let alone their concerns about the value of their investment in the shared ownership scheme.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Would my friend give way? I thank my friend for being generous on this, but the insurance issue is a really big concern. It's something the Treasury Select Committee is looking into. Doesn't he agree that there is a problem with the industry, that the premiums have gone up exponentially, given that although there is an increased risk, the actual risk of that crystallising is not as high as, well, hasn't been proved to be as high as the insurance industry claims? And I wondered if he had any further thoughts on that.
Edward Joseph Powell
My experience from this case corroborates what she's saying. I met with the Association of British Insurers and the scheme that they introduced did subsequently kick in and has in the last year brought down the building insurance, but only by about half and certainly not to anywhere near what it used to be. And I hope, you know, insurance will be something that ministers can look at when when thinking about protecting leaseholders from those costs. And I should say there is a the end of this story on on this building is that Notting Hill Genesis have agreed finally to reimburse all the residents after pressure from my from me and my team and and organisers in the building to repay the difference in the increase for the past several years. And I just want to thank Thomas, Hamed, Ian and all the other residents in that building for their work.
But this is just one example of what's happening in building after building across the country. So I welcome the bill in the sense that it's an opportunity to fix some of these flaws left by the previous government and create a better system, including through the register, this consistent approach to looking at external walls in terms of fire risk assessment and listening to campaigners like End Our Cladding Scandal and the campaigners across the country who have helped to give a voice to those most affected and I know have the ear of the Secretary of State and ministers as this bill continues. And clearly one element at the heart of the bill is who should pay.
And I agree, it is high time that the construction product manufacturers who contributed to causing this crisis should pay into resolving it. I really welcome part five of the bill to strengthen and extend provisions in the Building Safety Act on retrospective liability for cladding products and the Secretary of State's announcement today on their intent to go further. The Grenfell Inquiry found that companies including Arconic, Kingspan and Celotex engaged in systematic dishonesty and deliberate manipulation of testing that misled buyers into thinking their products were safe. It is extraordinary that aside from their payments into a civil settlement, these companies have not paid into resolving a crisis of their making. In Arconic's case, their civil settlement was overwhelmingly covered by their own insurance and was dwarfed by the payment they made to their own shareholders in compensation.
It is clearly not right that leaseholders, taxpayers, and even the developer levy should shoulder the bulk of the costs while companies like Arconic do not. And this is yet another reason, in my view, that they should be nowhere near public contracts and supply chains, especially while criminal investigations are ongoing. I know the Secretary of State is committed to working across government to use every procurement power the government has to ensure that is not happening, and I will fully support her in that goal. I also look forward to the new system of construction products regulation being implemented with consistent safety standards. A single products regulator under the Building Safety Regulator, I think, will also make a big difference.
I'm also glad that the protection of costs for leaseholders has been discussed in this bill and in the debate so far.
They are not responsible for this crisis, yet they are the ones picking up the bill in far too many cases. I also hope these new powers will give local remediation efforts like the London Joint Remediation Partnership Board an extra tool to do the building-by-building analysis that cuts through the bureaucracy and delays to find a solution. And I should say on behalf of the communities who have enfranchised their buildings or exercised right to manage, I'm sure they'll be really pleased to hear the announcement today on ensuring that they are protected. We want more leaseholders to take control of their buildings and appoint their own agents and run their own affairs, and we'll see more of course in the leasehold bill coming soon, and it's right that this bill should provide some consistency in protecting them too.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the building safety crisis has become one of the defining symbols of state failure in the past decade. The entirely avoidable tragedy of Grenfell and the loss of 72 lives should have been a catalyst to make buildings safe as quickly as possible and recover the costs later. And of course, if we had listened to the coroner after the Lakanal House fire in 2009, it may not only have been possible to prevent the Grenfell fire, but it could have put a halt to new-build flats across the country being constructed with cladding that was putting lives at risk. Judge Frances Kirkham said then that Approved Document B of the building regulations concerning external fire spread, fire-resistant properties, and cladding panels should be reviewed.
That simply did not happen in the way it should have done as the public inquiry found. That missed opportunity is devastating for the Grenfell families, but also for everyone who bought a flat across the country in a building that could have been built or refurbished differently if that recommendation had been implemented. And think of the billions of pounds wasted that could have been invested in building more homes, including social and affordable homes. That is why I will continue to campaign for a national oversight mechanism to make sure that there is independent scrutiny of recommendations of inquests and inquiries so that change actually happens. And I'm delighted that the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State and the Minister are supportive of this effort and I hope we can now make rapid progress towards setting it up.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister said something on Monday at the homelessness summit that really resonated with me: names, not numbers. He was talking about how to best support people off the streets.
We need a similar approach to this crisis. Behind every statistic is a family who is stuck, who cannot sell their home, is worried about the value of their main asset, who have had to take on another job chasing answers for when the work will be finished, all while they suffer the anxiety of living in an unsafe building. I hope today marks a shift in approach under a government I know is absolutely committed to doing all it can to end this scandal once and for all. The new tools in this bill will certainly help, and the ones announced at the dispatch box today will help even further.
And with the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State and the ministerial team providing the leadership that this crisis needs, I am sure we can right the wrongs of the previous approach and deliver the solutions that so many people across the country are crying out for.
Gideon Amos
Madam Deputy Speaker, as we remember the 72 victims of Grenfell and the many who are still waiting for justice, I know the Secretary of State shares and I'm sure this whole House across all benches share the same commitment to do right by them, to ensure such a calamity never happens again and to do better for all those leaseholders and residents living with unsafe cladding through no fault of their own.
We need a bill that will once and for all make people's homes not just safer, but as safe as their residents have a right to expect them to be. Liberal Democrats remain committed to getting the removal of unsafe cladding urgently and by a statutory deadline, to getting remediation to the right safety standard, the one building regulations were upgraded to post-Grenfell, and to residents not having to pay a penny towards fixing a crisis not of their own making. I will look, we will look at the amendments that have been just outlined and we will look forward to them coming forward and study them. But sadly, Madam Deputy Speaker, as the bill stands at the moment, it does none of those things. And because of that, it is substandard and it needs radical improvement.
On the plus side, let me be clear about the positive aspects of the bill, which we do support. We support the legal duty for responsible entities to remediate, including an important extension of the duty in relation to buildings of 11 meters, 11 to 18 meters in height.
We support the stronger intervention powers against the blockers that for housing authorities and the regulator, such as through remediation management orders. We support making it easier to bring claims against cladding manufacturers, and we support requirements to have fire risk assessments for external walls and associated registers. So for those reasons, we're not going as far, and we have not gone as far as tabling a fatal amendment in this debate, despite the very serious flaws as we see it. It would be wrong to deny any of those leaseholders and residents who without this bill would get less help. But I do call on the government to consider seriously the degree to which this bill is lacking.
While I don't doubt the sincerity of the Secretary of State or this bill, government needs to think harder and bring forward amendments that are urgently needed to strengthen this bill. And in the stage that follows second reading, we will be suggesting and proposing changes and working with the government as constructively as we can to get the improvements we believe are necessary.
So where, Madam Deputy Speaker, does this bill fall short? First and foremost, in enshrining into law the discredited publicly available specification 9980 approach, or PAS 9980, which, as shown in clause 44, will allow cladding of, and I quote, 'tolerable risk of combustion' to remain on homes after they've been remediated. You would expect tolerable risk to be no more than the level of risk allowed in new buildings under the building regulations as tightened up after Grenfell. As the honorable member for Hackney South and Shoreditch has already alluded to, it's not that standard. In this bill, remediation will only be to a standard that a fire risk assessor decides is tolerable.
We're talking, Madam Deputy Speaker, about fire risk assessors paid by building owners who are more likely than not to have commercial interests in doing as few works as possible to their building. While I'm sure that most assessors are reliable professionals, when the Grenfell Inquiry report chaired by Judge Sir Martin Moore-Bick cited, and I quote, "commercial interests" in this area of work as one of the contributory factors to the fire, is retaining commercial interests in the system of fire risk assessment and assessors and building inspectors one worth taking? Of course, I'll give way.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I'm grateful to the honourable member for giving way. I think we have common cause in this respect, and I rely a lot on the expertise of my constituents in this matter. But this PAS 9980 is not something that is also reassuring for insurers. Well, there's a big problem with insurance anyway, but PAS 9980 does not solve this because it does not give them the certainty they need to do the risk assessment.
I'm not here as an apologist for the insurance industry, certainly there are very many issues there which we will be taking up with them, but this is not the answer. And I wonder, with his level of deep expertise in this matter before he came to this place, what he would propose instead, or if there is an amendment to the bill that we, and indeed hopefully the government, could coalesce around if we can reach agreement.
Gideon Amos
The honorable member is very kind, and my experience is I'm sure as great as many others in this House. But I am coming on to what we believe would be the preferable standard, and certainly our approach is that these issues of commercial interest should be expunged from the bill, but also the tolerability approach should be removed. And we believe existing housing and buildings should be remediated to meet the standard of fire safety required in the new building regulations updated in 2018 after Grenfell.
Vikki Slade
I'm grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. But I think this also, although this bill is specifically around the remediation of cladding, this does go further. Building control was typically undertaken, or at least instructed, by the local planning authority and is now instructed and employed by the developers. And my constituents Trish and Ray, when they moved into their new build in Wimborne, found that the structural issues in their properties just hadn't been independently signed off. They now find that no one has access to the structural drawings of their building other than the inspector.
So when they have problems with their roof, the council had no details, they could not access details, and they can't check compliance. So does he agree that for the protection of residents, an ethical wall needs to be created between developers and inspectors with proper enforcement and mandatory housing building housing ombudsman membership by developers?
Gideon Amos
I certainly support my honorable friend's plea there, and I will be coming onto the issues of independence of building inspectors, which is very important. But going back to the standard that remediation should meet, the building regulations are the standard that government has set that is needed for newly built homes to be safe. So the same standard really therefore has to apply to the homes people are already living in. High-rise apartments I've visited in London and elsewhere, I've seen covered in scaffolding being remediated under the developer scheme, but many of them are being left with so much cladding breaching building regulations fire safety standards that residents cannot get insurance.
And it is the insurance that really gives the game away. If it was really safe, why would the insurance premiums be so high? We have increases in insurance costs of 56% and higher. And for that reason, many owners cannot sell, they cannot get a new mortgage, and they sink into negative equity and to mortgage prisoners in their own homes. Of course, I give way to the right honourable gentleman.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
I think the member's making a very important point here. Does he not agree that the high insurance costs are in no way caused by any action taken by the residents who are now forced to pay it?
And really, in all honesty, they deserve compensation for it.
Gideon Amos
Absolutely. And the right honourable gentleman almost read, I don't know how he did from over there, the next line in my speech, which was to say that leaseholders and residents like that should not have to pay a penny due to the defects that were not their fault. Thousands of pounds in extra insurance being paid by completely innocent homeowners to compensate for a safety standard, which while of course better than nothing, quite frankly isn't the standard it should be. And that's after the remediation to the standard in this bill has been carried out. Meeting the established building regulations standard would perhaps cost more, but why should residents be condemned to live right now in buildings remediated to a lesser standard than the one we consider safe for new homes?
And Madam Deputy Speaker, the profit motive also needs to be expunged from building inspector services generally, which this bill also fails to do.
So we need to remove these commercial interests from building inspectors and fire risk assessors by placing them all under publicly controlled non-profit making authority. And there is still no statutory certification requirement of what makes a competent person to be a fire risk assessor. Can I ask the Minister when will those measures be brought forward as had been promised in previous legislation? Madam Deputy Speaker, the second big omission of this bill is that it provides no more funding for those in buildings under 11 metres in height, now the funding window has closed. While medium-rise buildings come more into more firmly into scope, which is of course welcome, why should any residents be forced to pay to put right bad practice which was not their fault?
Leaseholders in Taunton and Wellington and across the country are already paying too high in ground rent, too high ground rents to absentee landlords for nothing in return, as leasehold seems to as abolishing residential leasehold seems to receive further and further into the future. The bill also fails to give residents the right to see their building's fire risk assessment. And it fails to give local authorities the resources to deliver the new enforcement duties. And the bill fails to commit government to making manufacturers of unsafe products that cause a fire pay, leaving the onus on others to pursue them through slow and costly court action. In these ways, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's our position that the bill fails to fully implement the Grenfell Tower recommendations.
Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is no deadline in the bill by which all the defects revealed by Grenfell across the tall buildings estate will be put right. Madam Deputy Speaker, the fire safety of people's homes needs to meet the standard we require for new homes.
Existing residents are no less worthy of that than will be the residents of future homes who will benefit from that building regulation standard. The commercial interests that ran rife in building safety inspections in the lead up to Grenfell need to be rooted out once and for all. And residents and leaseholders must not be expected to pay a penny towards repairing a crisis they are completely innocent of. Make homes fully safe under building regulations revised for that purpose. Make oversight and inspection independent, not profit dependent.
Hold developers and manufacturers to account by pursuing them for the costs. Protect leaseholders, including in buildings under 11 metres, and put residents at the heart of remediation so they can see the assessments of their homes and give them a real statutory deadline. That's the bill the House needs to see today. That's the bill we will work hard to shape in the remaining stages of this bill.
Jack Abbott
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And can I thank the Secretary of State for the intent she has shown in the bill today. Can I say also what a privilege it is to be sat next to my honourable friend, the Member of Parliament for Kensington and Bayswater. I know it's his mission in this place to fight for the justice of so many of his constituents that have been left alone for so long. Far too many lives across the country have been ruined by the building safety crisis. And in Ipswich, we have hundreds of residents who have endured years of fear, uncertainty and immense financial hardship.
People who did everything right. They worked hard, they saved for a deposit and they bought somewhere to call home, but only to discover that that home was unsafe.
The Grenfell Tower tragedy, when 72 people lost their lives, each, as my honourable friend said, entirely avoidable. Since that day, leaseholders have been left in limbo across the country and what should have been a catalyst for change instead became a straitjacket for so many people living in our country. People not knowing if they're safe, not knowing if they'll lose their home, not knowing if they'll be forced to pay tens of thousands of pounds for the right failures that they did nothing to cause. And I've spoken to plenty of residents in my constituency of Ipswich about their experiences and their stories, like so many I'm sure we'll hear this afternoon, are devastating. They cannot sell their home, they cannot move, they cannot move on with their lives.
Their entire financial future is at stake, but so too is their mental health, their peace of mind.
Some have considered bankruptcy just to get out, others have thought about handing back the keys and simply walking away. And that anyone should reach this point through absolutely no fault of their own is truly heartbreaking. And I want to kind of highlight a few of the buildings we have been facing issues with for many, many years in Ipswich. And I want to begin with St Francis Tower. Remediation work on this building started in 2018, and residents spent years living under shrink wrap as remediation work dragged on.
My honourable friend the Minister for Housing in fact visited as well in a previous life when I was a candidate and he then a shadow minister. You couldn't see out through the shrink wrap, you couldn't see natural daylight.
Even when that was replaced, the work dragged on and on. And in July 2023, flooding forced those poor people from their homes after years of misery. Years of disruption followed by the trauma of evacuation. My team and I worked with the residents and the government to secure funding for repairs in November 2024, and this was an important step forward which replaced the outer cladding. But still the internals are damaged.
Still, three years on, people have not yet been able to return to their homes. And although I'm hopeful of good news in the coming weeks, it is likely that these same people, even if remediation work was able to start in the coming weeks before Christmas, it's unlikely that they'll be able to return to their homes until spring of 2028, a decade since work first started on this building. Residents should never have been put in that position.
Nobody should have had to fight for something as basic as a home, but these people can't even live in it. At Churchmans House, investigations revealed problems extending beyond external cladding: missing fire barriers, inadequate protection around structural steelwork. Leaseholders faced eye demands for eye-watering payments and the threat that they might have to leave their homes. The original developer was insolvent. People who have done nothing wrong were left facing the consequences.
This is a story we hear over and over again. On the good news, our Government confirmed funding for the necessary work to make the building safe, but not before months and years of worry. Unfortunately for residents in Cardinal Loft, they were not so lucky.
I cannot believe that a building where if a fire broke out would have ripped through that entire building because the lack of compartmentalisation was ever deemed fit for habitation. People unknowingly slept in their beds every single night, for decades some of them, without knowing how deeply unsafe this their building is, how much it posed a threat to their lives. People never returned to Cardinal Loft, that building is not fit for use. So these are different buildings all with different owners but the same injustice. Injustice shared by so many people in Ipswich and across the country, and I could name so many buildings as well in our town who have been subject to the same stories.
People have bought these homes in good faith but were sold something faulty, and they should never have been left with the cost of putting things right. And that is why this bill is so important. That for the first time those responsible will face a clear legal duty to identify and remedy unsafe cladding in residential buildings.
Building owners and others with repairing responsibilities must act. That means an end to indefinite delays as residents live with fear and financial uncertainty, trapped in unsafe buildings. And crucially, those who ignore their responsibilities can face substantial financial penalties, criminal prosecution, and further enforcement action. Responsibilities that can be enforced, consequences for those who ignore them. And I also just want to highlight the remediation backstop, as I think it's particularly important.
Where building owners fail to act, Homes England and local authorities will be able to step in, arrange for repairs, and recover costs from those responsible. So for people trapped in the middle of endless arguments over who should do the work, that matters enormously.
I also welcome measures to secure contributions from manufacturers whose unsafe construction products contributed to this crisis. We were elected to accelerate remediation and better protect leaseholders, and this bill is an important step forward in delivering that promise. It builds on the remediation acceleration plan, which I know is already helping thousands of people across the country now live in safer homes. So alongside this bill, the government has also announced plans to extend leaseholder protections and support necessary fire safety works in eligible buildings owned collectively by residents. I'd also like to take the opportunity to thank the Ipswich Cladiators and the many, many residents across our town who have campaigned so tirelessly for change, not just for themselves, but their neighbors, their communities, and for people across the country.
But they should never, ever have had to fight this hard, and we can't give them back the years they've all lost. But we can maintain a relentless focus on making their homes safe, protecting them from unfair costs and helping them move forward. And that is what they deserve, and that with this bill is what the government is doing.
Will Forster.
Paul William Forster
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before speaking about the Building Safety Bill and the wider issues in the construction industry, I just want to say my thoughts and prayers are with the loved ones of the 72 people that lost their lives in the Grenfell fire.
Earlier today, the Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee were doing a review on fire and rescue services, and unsurprisingly, building safety and Grenfell were covered. Now, I appreciate this bill focuses on buildings, construction practices, and other issues, and not really on fire services, but I was surprised to hear earlier today from the head of HM Inspectorate for Fire and Rescue Service that they haven't been consulted at all on this bill, and I think that is disappointing. Firefighters put their lives to cope with and tackle the failures in the construction industry, and I hope the Minister will agree to consult them on this bill going forward to ensure that any amendments are approved by them and it gives the opportunity for that inspectorate to suggest amendments.
My constituency of Woking has been plagued with three big building safety and construction issues. In 2023, 100 residents of the Eastgate building in Woking were evacuated from their homes after structural defects were found. Eastgate to this day stands empty, a visual reminder of how our building safety system has failed. Southern Housing, who manage Eastgate, say it's structurally unsafe. Barretts, who built it, say it is safe.
After I and the Housing Communities Local Government Ministry got involved last year, independent testing was carried out and I'm grateful for the government supporting me in that effort. The new testing on the building has been completed many months ago, but the results have still not been released. There is no way that both sides can be right in that situation. I do not know what they're hiding, but this needs to be resolved immediately.
Residents deserve to know what is going on. Either residents need to be allowed back in or the developer needs to rebuild Eastgate and pay compensation. Will the minister agree to meet with me and force the results of the testing to be released? Woking's building safety issues and construction failures sadly go beyond our homes. The Victoria Square development, which is a new shopping centre, residential towers, hotel, was built by Sir Robert McAlpine several years ago.
It was due to open in October 2020, but after problems with broken cladding fixtures on the Hilton Hotel, it finally opened four years after that. However, the main A-road that goes through Woking town centre had to repeatedly close due to cladding failures.
This caused significant financial losses to local businesses and residents. Thankfully, the road has now reopened, the cladding panels have now, only very recently, been properly secured. Under the common law of negligence, purely economic losses are not recoverable. However, this could have been included under contract law by the former Conservative Borough Council, but they did not. Why is this not standard practice for building projects?
Will the Minister agree to amend this bill so any consequential losses from dangerous cladding failures, like what happened to businesses and residents in Woking, are paid for by developers like Sir Robert McAlpine?
Madam Deputy Speaker, there's one final building safety issue from Woking I'd just like to speak about, and it's from the estate I grew up in. Lakeview in Goldsworth Park is made up of mainly four-story maisonettes. Woking Borough Council recently discovered that cladding on these homes is dangerous and quickly took steps to make it as safe as possible. The council created a plan for a comprehensive refurbishment and a long-term solution to the cladding problems on that estate. I want to congratulate and thank Woking Council, especially the portfolio holder for housing, Councillor Ian Johnson, and the strategic director for housing, Louise Strongitharm, for their tireless work on it.
Although we are getting the right result in Lakeview, what happened in my old estate shows why we as a country need to take building safety much more seriously and need to agree legislative changes. Most properties in Lakeview are council homes, but there are almost 100 privately owned leasehold properties in that area. Leaseholders will be charged for the refurbishment, but not the cladding works, quite rightly, of that construction work and refurbishment that is planned to start early January in the new year. However, if it was a private development, leaseholders would be slowly paying into a sinking fund. But local authorities are banned from running such a sinking fund.
Will the Minister not only lift that ban on local authorities having a sinking fund, but mandate that they do, so that what happened to leaseholders in Lakeview does not happen again? Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, those are three examples from Woking which show this Bill does not go far or fast enough.
It's not fit for purpose, and why my honorable friend for Taunton said we will not be supporting it, but proposing more amendments going forward to ensure that we genuinely tackle all the building safety issues facing Woking and across the country. Thank you.
Darren James Paffey
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Southampton Itchen is one of the places in Hampshire where we've got most buildings where there are unsafe cladding still. That means, as other honorable members have expressed so eloquently, people living with the worry that the horrendous tragedy that befell Grenfell those years ago could well happen to them. And even where there has been action, that is hardly ideal. Nearly 200 of my constituents are currently out of their homes.
They were evacuated in the spring and summer of last year, and they won't be able to return until at the very earliest the summer of 2028. And so this is the stark reality that drives the urgent need for this bill, and it's why I very much welcome it. I thank the Secretary of State and the Minister in her place for bringing this bill forward, and I pay tribute, as others have, to the residents and campaigners, including those in End Our Cladding Scandal, who supported one of the very first public meetings that I conducted as a new MP, and who over the years have not let this issue go.
Since I was elected, I've listened to residents affected by their unsafe cladding on their buildings. I've pressed ministers, I've put evidence to the Public Accounts Committee in their inquiry on remediation. And so this bill is very much the next installment, I hope, in resolving these ongoing issues, certainly not the last. So I do want to acknowledge the very real progress that it makes, but also to ask for some important clarifications from the minister. Madam Deputy Speaker, take Oceana Boulevard, a flagship development, part of the kind of regeneration of brownfield sites in the center of Southampton.
Built some 20 years ago, its fire safety problems were first identified nearly 10 years ago. Now since then, compartmentalization works are done, but that's all. Today, we've finally got an application in to the building safety regulator to cover cladding, to cover automatic opening vents and balcony remediation works. And yet, and sadly as we've heard, this is not an isolated story, there's still no agreement between the freeholder and the developer about who will pay for the non-cladding related remediation, and none of that work is anywhere near starting yet. In the meantime, of course, we all know residents' costs have been skyrocketing.
In Ocean Boulevard, Ellie bought her flat there brand new. Her service charge and insurance rose from £1,500 a year to £6,000 a year.
And she's not been able to keep up, so she has handed her home back to the bank. So even if not to fire, people are still losing their homes because of the issues that have taken far too long to resolve. And for that reason, alongside this very welcome remediation bill, we must with all urgency progress the commonhold and leasehold bills and the action that the Prime Minister recently announced on regulating managing agents. Happy to give way.
Peter Timothy Fortune
Thank you very much, and the honorable member is right to point out the stress on residents. Those at Northpoint in Bromley are part of a resident management company. And those RMCs have no assets themselves.
So they then tend to lean into the service charges in order to pay some of the liabilities that the company takes. Would you agree with me that those people in RMCs need to be protected as well?
Darren James Paffey
I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention and I think it's a line of argument and common cause that we all believe and all are fighting for our residents to be protected from the bills that are being landed on them through no fault of their own. They certainly didn't choose any of this. They want the simple comfort of their own home. They work incredibly hard to achieve that. And yet look at where so many of them are.
So turning to the content of the bill, I welcome the mandatory auditing of fire risk assessments to that all-important single standard.
A dispute over what is wrong with a building, as in the case of Oceana Boulevard, must never again outlast a decade, with a constant back and forth on whether the different parties will accept what they read in the fire engineer's report. And I certainly agree with a number of the comments that have been made on both sides of the chamber around picking and choosing who commissions what report and whether, in some cases it seems, they like what they read in it before commissioning a different one. So that has to come to an end. I welcome the message that waking watches are temporary. Sirocco, another development in nearby Ocean Village, residents paid for one for years.
And as one of the residents there, Roe, tells me that she had to use a freedom of information request just to see the fire risk assessments. Under this bill, remediation plans have to be published with timelines and contacts.
No resident should need an FOI to learn the truth about their own home. And I welcome the legal duty to remediate. Ben and his family have told me their story that unfortunately, again, is not the only time I've heard it, and that is that they have put their life on hold and they have put off having more children, growing their family, because they cannot sell and move on. Since when should anyone's life aspirations be subject to the stalling of many of these companies who have not bothered to get their own houses literally in order?
So being unable to sell and move on is a story I've sadly heard many times and which other honourable members have repeated too. Remediation work at the Blake building, another building close by, only began this summer, certainly won't finish before next summer, four years after enforcement action was first taken. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear that delays cost, and it's far too often the residents who are still paying for them.
Honourable member give way?
Happy to give way, yes.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honourable member for giving way, and much of what he is saying has echoes in my own constituency of Ealing Southall, where residents in Hanwell Lock have been in a battle with Bellway over remediation works to their building, where there has been acknowledgement that works are needed, but there is no clear programme of works and no progress at all.
And those residents, like his, are having trouble remortgaging, selling, and they are worried about the continuing fire risk. Does he agree that the remediation compliance plans required in this bill and the strong financial penalties against builders will make a difference to our constituents?
Darren James Paffey
I thank my honorable friend for her intervention. I absolutely agree with that point, and I will come to another point showing that it is simply unforgivable that too many still have no plan whatsoever for remediation and people are paying the price with their finances, but also their life ambitions.
Shockat Patel
Does he share my concern that the government already have remediation orders, remediation contribution orders, and the responsible actors scheme, but the Property Institute say they've seen absolutely no evidence that they have been used proactively and no developer to date has faced any consequences, and this bill must make sure it addresses that?
Darren James Paffey
Well, I certainly agree with his closing point that this bill must fix that, and that's why I welcome its progress. But I'll also be, along with others from across the chamber, following its progress very closely to make sure that it's not just a bill that gets a headline, but this is a bill that fixes things and gets things right. The Blake building sits outside the developer contract, so this new duty will finally reach it.
That is real progress that is contained in this bill. But there are points where residents will still have questions and campaigners are not yet convinced that all of this goes far enough. And I hope the minister will address some of those questions in today's debate. Firstly, the developer contract. Most Ocean Village buildings are subject to it, but the bill excludes them from the new duty because, quote, equivalent requirements are already in place.
And yet in Sirocco, in Morsby, in Hawkins and Oceana Boulevard, physical works have still not started. Nationally, we've heard different statistics. Those that I'm looking at tell me that of over two and a half thousand buildings that are in that contract, 854 have not started and have no plan in place. 854 buildings, but not a single plan between them. What will those measures mean for those living in buildings with no plan?
Darren James Paffey
Shouldn't they have ordered assessments? Shouldn't they have published timetables? Shouldn't they have a backstop if a developer stalls? I hope that the Minister will confirm that Ocean Village residents will benefit from all three. The Bill rightly focuses on cladding, but residents, we know, live in whole buildings, and internal safety matters too.
I very much welcome the announcement that we heard from the despatch box today, and I hope that in filling that gap, we will hear more detail as the Bill progresses about what that grant funding will cover. Secondly, enforcement.
The bill offers prosecution, penalties of up to half a million pounds, and a backstop allowing Homes England or councils to step in. But as we all know, a power is only as good as the capacity to use it, and the route to the backstop will still have to run through notices, representations, and tribunals. So how long will it take from first notice to a contractor on site? And will Homes England and councils like Southampton City Council be resourced to use that power? Finally, and most practically for residents like Ben, is the question of when.
The duty to remediate is there as soon as reasonably practicable, with the detail left to regulations.
The government's own 2029 and 2031 deadlines, already put forward in the remediation acceleration plan, don't, however, appear on the face of the bill. I would ask ministers to add that. I know my constituents would find that reassuring. Or if not, can she commit to dated milestones and a hard stop date on those regulations so that 2029 is a final, legally enforceable deadline that constituents need, not just an aspiration. Those who have been waiting years and who cannot move on have asked if there is any way the government would buy back those homes whilst they're waiting.
Now, I suspect I know the answer, but I will ask, particularly with budget coming up tomorrow.
We amended, the previous Chancellor amended some of the rules to ensure that actually council-owned properties are assets, not just liabilities. Could we be looking at assets that would release people from the stalemate they are in with their homes and their families and ensure that actually this government, which is building more housing, needing to own more housing, could very much use? So, Madam Deputy Speaker, in closing, I will proudly support this bill at second reading today, and for everyone who needs this bill to be the strongest it can be, I will be glad to engage with ministers and others as it progresses through the various stages. We need to fix all our buildings.
We need to ensure that work is paid for by all those who were responsible for this sorry episode that I believe is an absolute stain on our history. And in doing so, we might just be able to give people their futures back. People like Ellie, like Bro, like Ben, like the hundreds of others in Southampton Itchen and the thousands more across this country whose stories have been told by members across the House today. They've all had enough. And they all want an end to the nightmare.
This bill, if we do it right, gives them that hope.
Marsha de Cordova.
Speaker 218
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As we approach 10 years since the Grenfell tragedy, I thank the Grenfell community and families for the tireless campaigning that they shouldn't have had to do.
I welcome this cladding bill as far as it goes. It includes important measures that are needed, but there remain serious concerns that it doesn't do enough for those still trapped by the terrible cladding scandal. In particular, I want to use my time to raise the issue of remediation of unsafe cladding in buildings of less than 11 meters. This is a big problem in my constituency, but it is very much not just a Bristol issue. There are a number of medium-height blocks of flats in Bristol Central with flammable cladding.
I'm going to tell you the story of just one of those flats. It's in a mid-rise block that's part of a development of three blocks. The other two blocks are taller, over 11 meters. Same developer, all built at the same time.
All the buildings have the same dangerous cladding, and the taller two are eligible for the Building Safety Fund, but the one under 11 metres is not. A leading specialist building surveyor has identified that the shorter building also has severe cladding deficiencies in need of urgent remediation. Until recently, this flat was the home of a 97-year-old woman who eventually moved into a residential home. Because she owned a flat, she was not eligible for a council-funded care home place, so her children needed to sell the flat to fund her care. Except they couldn't.
Because the Conservative government's position was that there is, quote, "no systemic fire safety issue in buildings under 11 metres".
In 2022, the then government said that it examined specific buildings under 11 metres and found that "in the overwhelming majority of cases, it has subsequently been confirmed they do not require remediation." The Labour government under Keir Starmer maintained this position, stating in September 2024 that "the risk to life is usually lower in buildings under 11 metres and they are very unlikely to need the same costly remediation." As a result, buildings under 11 metres are not eligible for funding under the Building Safety Fund. The catch: try telling all this to the mortgage market. No lender will give a mortgage to a flat in a building with unsafe cladding, regardless of height.
So the children of this 97-year-old constituent of mine cannot sell it on the open market.
They can't persuade the company that holds the freehold to pay for the remediations from their own balance sheet, believe me, they tried. That company has insisted that they will only fulfill their legal obligations and not spend a penny more, and based on the legislation, they believe they're not liable. The building's insurance policy will also not cover the cladding work. And even if the owners of the five flats in this small block wanted to pay for the work themselves, which would be wholly unjust because it isn't their fault, as leaseholders, according to their lease, they are only permitted to contribute up to 15,000 pounds per flat. The work is estimated to cost over 1 million.
So what are they meant to do? They're trapped in an intolerable catch-22. The two adult children of this 97-year-old woman were forced to buy the flat themselves to fund her care to release that equity.
It's lucky they could afford this, although lucky seems like a wild choice of word to describe their situation. And they are now stuck in possession of an unsafe flat that they don't live in and don't want, never wanted to own. With no recourse to the developers, the insurance, warranties or anything else to rectify cladding faults. Now, in July 2026, the MHCLG launched a separate pot of funding, as we've heard, to address cladding fire safety risks in buildings under 11 meters called the Cladding Safety Scheme. They said this delivered on the government's commitment in the Remediation Acceleration Plan and supported a risk-based approach to remediation.
But the application window was only open for three months.
It's now closed. The management company of the building in my constituency has applied, but there has been no response and there is apparently no guarantee of receiving this targeted funding. And the bill before us today proposes to stick with the Conservative and Starmer government's insistence that relevant buildings means only buildings of 11 meters or more. Surely the minister can see that this is not good enough. So, please can the minister tell me, and I have a few questions here.
Firstly, is she confident that three months was long enough for 100% of those in charge of affected buildings under 11 meters to hear about this fund and apply to it, including both for-profit management companies that famously can be pretty sluggish when it comes to repairs in their buildings, and also internal management companies made up of owner-occupiers and leaseholders who are often juggling flat admin alongside a full-time job and being a parent? Second question, is the fund large enough to cover all of the affected sub-11 meter buildings? Thirdly, if the government doesn't make funding available for all of the affected sub-11 meter buildings, what will the minister's message be to the leaseholders of flats that don't receive the funding? And finally, please will she take steps to end this lottery of funding and ensure that the remediation of buildings below 11 meters is incorporated into the main bill, fully funded, and that there is a legal requirement on freeholders to do this work? Thank you.
Michael Reader
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Next June will mark 10 years since the Grenfell fire. And as many have said, you know, since the end of August, over 2,000 residential buildings still with unsafe cladding and remediation not yet started. And behind that, tens of thousands of people who cannot sell their homes, cannot get mortgages, can't get affordable insurance, and many that can't sleep at night. Those people did nothing wrong. They bought a home in good faith and they've been left carrying the consequences of the failures of others.
And that's why I welcome this bill and I'll be supporting it throughout. At its heart of the bill, it's about responsibility. And so that's who must act, who must pay, and who must be protected. So let me start with who must act.
For too long, the system has relied on expectation and goodwill. Building owners have been asked, they've been encouraged, they've been cajoled to get on and fix the problem, and many have chosen simply not to act. When we debated remediation in Westminster Hall this September with the Minister, I argued that we had to move from targets to duties and make sure any duties we set are enforceable. And that bill is doing just that. It's setting a clear legal duty on those responsible for a building to fix it.
It gives regulators real power backed by real penalties. Where an owner will not act, it will let an local authority step in and get the job done.
For residents who have spent many years being passed from freeholder to managing agent to developer and back again, that clarity will matter enormously. This bill also tackles something that has quietly undermined progress for years. And we've heard of stories today of buildings that have sat in this kind of middle ground, not quite high-rise, is that we still simply don't know where all these buildings are or who really owns them. So the register of mid-rise buildings and new powers to find out who sits behind building ownership means that owners can no longer hide behind complex structures because you cannot fix a problem you cannot see and you cannot hold someone to account when you can't find them. And it protects leaseholders by making sure that when a building owner is penalized for failing to act, the bill ensures that the bill for fixing that issue cannot simply pass back to residents through their service charges.
The people who are failing must pay, and the people who have been failed must be protected. So that brings me to the part of this bill which I have shown particular interest in, and that is construction products liability, part five. So far, the cost of fixing this crisis has fallen on taxpayers and developers. More than five billion pounds of public money has been committed to remediation, but the manufacturers who sold the products now being stripped off buildings across the country have contributed next to nothing, and that can't be right. The last government did recognize these principles in the Building Safety Act, but as we have to be honest enough to admit, the provisions meant that many manufacturers were not held to account.
There were many legal hurdles that were too high and the claims were too few. Too many manufacturers were able to sit back, confident that nobody could prove enough to make them pay.
And that bill, this bill changes that. It shifts the test away from narrow technicalities about whether a regulation was breached towards the question that matters: was the product unsafe in the way it was actually used and was the product marketed in a misleading way? It gives the courts the power to look inside these companies so we can see what they knew, when they knew it, and it makes sure that corporate structures cannot be used to put assets beyond reach. There's a really simple principle here that the polluter pays. And that approach is guided by the simple adage of fix it first and fast.
Residents should not be waiting for companies to argue over the bill. Buildings must be made safe now and the fight over who pays should happen afterwards, maybe in court between the companies responsible, but not on the doorsteps of the people living with the consequences. But I would ask the Minister to keep one point in mind as the bill goes into committee. Liability has to flow through the supply chain and the interface with other regulations such as the Defective Products Act. So if we extend liability at the top of the supply chain, but it doesn't carry through further down into the facade contractor, into their supply chain, into their suppliers, we risk loading main contractors with liability while those who perhaps supplied or made the products escaping.
Getting liability right right through the supply chain is critical to whether this bill delivers real money for remediation or simply moves the risk around. The bill is a big step forward, but it's not the end of the job, and I want to raise two areas where there is more to do. I really welcome the announcement from the dispatch box today on enfranchised non-qualifying leaseholders. And you know, these are people who were excluded from protections that many other leaseholders enjoy, often for reasons such as the date they bought their flat. And I really look forward to seeing the amendments coming forward and helping to shape those.
But the second is the people who made hay from this crisis. There are two groups who have done very, very well from building safety, and that's insurers and that's lawyers. I have heard many people talk about the challenges of getting insurance for a building, but I've also heard from contractors and developers.
I've heard of contractors who were encouraged to take out professional indemnity cover to cover works, only to find that insurers use every single technicality to avoid paying. I sat on the silver team when I worked at Mace on our building safety team, and the complexity of working out whether our liability sat there and how we dealt with our insurers to deal with the complexities of product liability as a main contractor was something that gave a lot of people many, many nights of headaches and something I don't think we have completely finished. But we risk seeing contractors collapse if we don't fix this. And I mentioned lawyers as well, because I've heard stories where the legal fees for trying to fix the cladding has vastly exceeded the actual cost of fixing the cladding itself. That cannot be right.
That is a scandal within a scandal, the scandal itself.
So this bill rightly opens up a stronger route to recover costs from manufacturers, but doesn't yet start to address those who make money out of this crisis. But it does make sure the government delivers a route for redress, not another payday. It makes sure every, it should make every pound spent on lawyers' fees and insurers' delaying tactics is not spent making, is being also spent making homes safer. So let me end where I began. This bill puts responsibility where it belongs and makes sure we are protecting those who need protection.
It builds and strengthens on the work of the previous government, but it rebalances power and makes sure we fix this crisis once and for all.
I support this bill and I hope the whole house will work to make sure it passes quickly through this place, because we need to see it come into legislation, not be stuck in committee, so that we can end the crisis of dangerous buildings in our country once and for all and end this nightmare for all. Thank you.
I call Sarah Olney.
Sarah Olney
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to start just by adding my voice to the Secretary of State and to the member for Kensington and Bayswater in the tributes that they paid to the victims and the survivors of the Grenfell disaster. And I won't forget waking up that morning and seeing that appalling tragedy unfold on our television screens, and I know many, many people across London will have felt the same.
And I welcome the government's attempts to ensure such a tragedy doesn't happen again, but it is almost unbelievable that it is nine years later, nine years later, that we are debating this particular bit of legislation in our collective effort to ensure that buildings can be made safe and that nothing like that can ever happen again. And like the Fire Safety Act and the Building Safety Act, this bill before us today is a step in the right direction, but again, it doesn't go far enough. And as the member for Hackney and Shoreditch, who's no longer in her place, has been raising repeatedly throughout this afternoon's debate, the PAS 9980 regime, which allows a fire engineer chosen and paid for by the building owner to declare dangerous cladding tolerable and decide that no work is required, will still remain in place. Now, would members in this House feel reassured if a fire engineer paid for by a building's owner declared the cladding in their block of flats to be tolerable?
The anger which followed the Grenfell disaster was directed towards those in power who repeated the sentiments that officials had known about the dangers posed by unsafe cladding but didn't care enough to act. And much of that feeling was that the people in Grenfell and others who lived in council housing did not matter enough for serious action to be taken to prevent such a disaster. And this speaks to a wider issue which we in this house all need to work to address: accessibility to safe and secure housing. New high-rise homes must be built with materials that do not burn. And if combustible cladding is considered too dangerous for new high-rise homes, what reassurances does this provide to people living in tolerable levels of danger?
And that shouldn't be our benchmark. All Londoners should be entitled to housing of a standard that is higher than tolerable.
In March 2026, the government announced that a new package of support for house building in London, which provided temporary relief from developer levies. However, Business London have highlighted that the costs associated with the community infrastructure levy relief included in this package would be effectively offset by the additional costs from the building safety levy in over a third of cases. And I welcome the government's intent to remediate building safety defects via the building safety levy, but the two policies seem to contradict each other. The Financial Times' headline just this morning read that Labour's house building target is effectively dead. We shouldn't be deciding between building houses and building houses safely.
So if it's the government's assessment that housing developments are being stalled in London due to cost, does more need to be done to incentivize developments following the introduction of the building safety levy? And I would be grateful in the wind-ups if the minister could provide a reflection upon whether the provision in this bill that construction products and their manufacturers and their developers, if they are providing some of the costs towards remediating cladding, what does that mean for the building safety levy and the particular stress that that is placing on house building in London? Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Rebecca Long-Bailey
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the minister and the secretary will both know that Salford has had a large number of buildings affected by the building safety crisis. And this has meant years of worry for residents about safety and often facing eye-watering bills that they can't afford or being trapped in a home that they can't sell, and it's all for a crisis they did not cause. And I want to, before I begin my contribution, place on record my thanks to two key organizations and individuals.
The first is Salford Council. In the early days after the horrors of Grenfell, it was one of the first local authorities to act fast, think later, in removing dangerous cladding from its council properties. It faced years of legal wranglings trying to recoup the costs from the developers themselves, but they did the right thing and they made sure that resident safety came first. And secondly, I want to place on record my special thanks to two very special individuals, Darren Matthews and Mandy Sandhu.
They were the first residents to come to me about the building safety crisis, about a building called Transport House. And they led an amazing campaign when they were faced themselves with eye-watering bills of £97,000 each to pay for building safety remediation in their building. They secured the costs that they needed to carry out those remediations from the developers and the Building Safety Fund. And they acted as an inspiration to many other campaign organizers across Salford, and there were many campaign organizers. So it's really welcome now to see that the Government seeks to fill many of the apparent gaps in the Building Safety Act.
But I just wanted to mention a few points today that I hope the Minister and the Government will take forward as this Bill progresses through the House. Firstly, continued delays at the Building Safety Regulator.
I know the government has introduced a plan to speed applications up, but in many cases it's not yet working. One building in Salford has faced significant delays, causing huge stress for residents. I visited that building and one resident there told me: "Our mortgage interest is now at 8.9%." "Our provider refuses us a new product until remediations are done." "We cannot sell as non-qualifying leaseholders as the status carries on for new owners, which might mean liability for payment for some remediations."
"I'm 65, I want to enjoy retirement and my husband has incurable cancer." "The stress is not helping, we cannot sustain all of this."
So as a priority, can I please implore that the Minister and the Government reviews what the blockages are at the Building Safety Regulator and ensure that it's properly staffed and resourced to tackle this backlog. Secondly, Salford has had huge issues with non-cladding related fire safety defects, from non-compliant wooden balconies all the way through to insufficient internal fire doors. Residents have been left either wrangling with developers in a David and Goliath style legal battle, with the cost of temporary fire safety provisions ramping up service charges year on year and huge insurance bills to boot. Many have been ultimately forced to foot the bill for remediation themselves, which is simply unjust.
Now, the issue had already been raised in 2025 by the National Fire Chiefs Council, but the bill as it stands still excludes non-cladding fire safety defects, so it must be addressed now. I really do welcome the comments that the Secretary made at the dispatch box as it suggests that this is an issue that is on her radar, and I look forward to seeing the details on this work going forward, and perhaps the Minister can divulge a little bit more detail in her summing up. Next, whilst the bill places legal requirements on building owners and responsible entities, developers signed up to the Developer Remediation Contract, I'll call it the DRC for the remainder of my comments, are exempt. Now, I know why, because the Government assumes that being part of the DRC is a sufficient enough carrot, but it's worrying, given that we already know that the auditing of assessments at DRC buildings is very thin on the ground in practice, and as End Our Cladding Scandal notes, rafts of conclusions are based on assumption rather than test evidence.
Worse still, we know that enforcement is weak. Property Week has already stated that developer-led remediation continues to progress too slowly, with only 10% of projects complete and nearly 60% still awaiting agreed scopes of work. But put simply, ruling out developers from the new remediation duty in this bill, but imposing it on resident-controlled entities, sadly just goes to highlight just how skewed and unfair the system still is.
And this is a crucial issue that I hope the government will look at getting right, because it can't be right to continue to place significant burdens on the shoulders of volunteer leaseholders, especially in buildings owned by leaseholders, which were ruled out of the leaseholder protections. The bill has no mention of protecting them at the moment, nor does it close gaps affecting non-qualifying leaseholders, shared owners, and buildings below 11 meters. These people are left fending for themselves. And again, the Secretary's highlighted that this is something that she seeks to address, and I look forward to seeing the detail on this in due course. And very briefly, one final point that I just wanted to mention, Madam Deputy Speaker, is a wider issue, and that's the capacity of fire authorities to respond to high-rise blazes.
Back in 2025, I wrote to the government highlighting significant understaffing, often due to poor pay, which was impacting both the recruitment and retention of firefighters. And this has resulted in situations where vehicles have sometimes been sent out without a full complement of five firefighters riding, or being deployed elsewhere to compensate for equipment or staffing gaps elsewhere, or simply the vehicles can't be deployed at all due to not having enough staff to crew or repair vehicles. Salford's firefighters and appliances are frequently directed to surrounding boroughs to tackle high-rise blazes because there aren't enough fire vehicles available at that particular moment in time. And this all results in fewer firefighters on the ground at the early stages of an incident in Salford, greatly increasing the risks for everyone involved. And at this time of year, with Bonfire Night approaching, this situation becomes more acute.
So there were three asks I had of government in 2025, and I'll repeat them again today.
The first is to coordinate with the Chancellor - we know we've got the budget coming up tomorrow, so you'll have to get in quick - to reverse the cuts and invest in the future of fire and rescue services with additional central government funding. Secondly, it's to urgently bring forward the plan to reintroduce national standards to remove the postcode lottery of incident responses and hold fire chiefs accountable. And lastly, it's to give firefighters a fair say through a new advisory body which includes trade union representation and powers and resourcing to investigate fires of special interest. So the bill today is very, very welcome. It's a definite good starting point identifying the gaps, but there's a long way to go.
And I hope that we'll have a collective conversation now, a collegiate one, about how we can get the final stages of this bill spot on. Thank you.
Hilary James Benn
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I unreservedly welcome this bill. The story of the cladding crisis arose out of the appalling tragedy on that night in Grenfell over nine years ago, when all those people died in the place they should have felt most safe: their home. And they died because of a series of catastrophic failures.
The first and most obvious one was the fact that cladding was allowed to be put in combination on the sides of buildings when no one had actually tested what would happen if they caught fire. It is astonishing when one looks back at it that architects were able to specify combinations, and we now know that when some of those combinations have been put on rigs and set fire to, boom, they've gone up very, very quickly. The secondly, and I thought my honourable friend the member for Kensington and Bayswater who spoke so well, the fact that here we are over nine years after the event and we still haven't sorted it out. And I am much struck by the example that he quoted from Australia. And he is right when one follows, because I have many, many constituents who've been affected by the cladding scandal, some of them, most of them I think it's fair to say the homes have now been dealt with, but there's still far too many who haven't.
The reaction of government at the time was really, well, it's not our responsibility, and it had to be forced by stages over those years to do more and more.
The failure even to build the blocks in line with the building regulations at the time, because it's one thing to look at the cladding and people said, oh, I didn't know that was a problem. But as cladding was pulled off buildings one after the other, what did we find? That the fire stopping, the fire breaks were missing, even though that was a requirement of the building regulations at the time. And this is a story of a load of jerry-built buildings that people lived in, as one member said, for many years, having no idea that they were living in a fire trap.
And I just make that point because on occasions I have sat in this chamber and heard members lambast Britain as being an over-regulated society. I mean, give us a break when it comes to this story. This is a monumental failure of regulation. People died as a result and many other people's lives have been put, as we have heard, on hold. And I want to join others in paying tribute to the End Cladding Scandal group, the Leeds Cladding Scandal, the many constituents who have raised cases with me, who've worked so hard to try and change the circumstances they find themselves in.
Because time and time again, people have said to me, as they have to all members in the House, "I thought I'd bought the home of my dreams." And actually, I find I'm living in a nightmare that I don't seem able to get out of.
And many members have referred to people's lives being put on hold. And it's absolutely true, because you can't get on with it, whether it's having a family or moving to another part of the country where you've been offered a good job, but you can't sell your flat and there appears to be no escape. The bills go up, the waking watches are costly, insurance costs are expensive, service charges go up. And I remember the first constituent I met who told me, "Well, I've had to move out of my flat." I said, "You've moved out of your flat?"
He said, "Yes, I couldn't afford the bills." "So I've moved out of my flat, I'm now renting it to raise income to pay the bills that I can't afford in the flat that I thought was the home of my dreams."
And we also know because each block, particularly the ones that haven't yet been remediated, are a very complex story. Really complex, changing ownership, developers disappeared, gone bust, legal pass the parcel reference was just made to that in the previous speech, and of course mortgage lenders refusing to lend, although the hard truth is there is no legislation that is going to require a mortgage lender to lend on a property they don't want to lend on. And therefore they have to have confidence. Of course I will.
Gideon Amos
I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for giving way and he's making a typically cogent, sensible speech.
But isn't the logical conclusion of what he's driving at that buildings should be remediated to the standard that they can be insured at reasonable levels, they will get mortgages, and that's the building regulation standard we require for new buildings?
Hilary James Benn
Well, even I understand the point that the honorable gentleman is making, but to get to the point, is he arguing that a mortgage lender should be required by law? No, he isn't. I didn't think that he was. And that is a fundamental problem. It's about confidence in the system, and it's about confidence in the property.
And too many of my constituents still worry that they could be landed with a bill they simply can't afford. And someone said to me, 30,000 quid might as well be 30 million quid because I can't afford 30,000 quid in those circumstances. I just want to raise three specific issues.
First is to say I very much welcome what the Secretary of State said in her opening speech about those who have bought non-qualifying flats. And as I was reflecting on the question I put to her about making it retrospective, that probably isn't an issue here because if you say if you have a flat that was deemed to be non-qualifying and you are the sole owner, then you will be relieved of the requirement to meet those costs yourself and you'll be eligible for the support that other leaseholders have got. But I really, really welcome what she said. Secondly is blocks below 11 metres. And I want to echo the point made by the honourable member for Bristol Central because I have a block in Leeds called The Chandlers.
Some of the blocks there are over 11 metres and some are below 11 metres. And an application has been made to the new fund that was opened, closing day I think was the, from memory, the 17th of August.
But there will be lots of applications and we don't know who's going to be successful and who isn't. Now, I just want to seek clarity from the minister in responding, because as I understand it, under the Regulatory Reform Fire Safety Order 2005, a responsible person is required to carry out fire risk assessments on all buildings and put in place measures to address fire risks they identify.
And reading the House of Commons briefing note, it tells me that since 2022, this risk assessment duty has included assessing the structure and external wall of the building, including cladding. So if there is a duty on a responsible person to do that, given that the government has accepted in respect of some under 11-meter buildings, although it argues generally that most of them don't present a risk, in cases where there is a risk, and in the case of the Chandlers, a PAS 9980 assessment was done. The residents were first told it was high risk on the 11 under 11-meter blocks, then they've been told it is a medium risk.
Well, a medium risk is still a risk, and would you want to live in a block where there is a medium risk that it might catch fire and put your life at risk? And I wanted to ask whether the powers, because I read the bill quite hurriedly in the explanatory memorandum on this point, and it appears that they apply to over 11-metre buildings. But since the government has accepted, by saying we are prepared to provide funding for under 11-metre buildings, will any of those powers under the legislation as it's currently drafted apply to under 11-metre blocks and the people who are responsible for them? And if not, if an under 11-metre block has got a PAS 9980 which says this is at risk, logically why would you not extend the use of those powers to make sure that those blocks are remediated? And finally, can I join my honourable friend the member for Southampton Itchen in making a plea about people who really, really, really need to move?
Because to require the developer to buy back a flat, or indeed, and the point was made a moment ago, for a local authority to purchase it, and we want more social housing, well you'd have one unit of social housing. I wonder whether the government could think creatively about that, because in the circumstances where you really, really need to move, your mother may be extremely ill, you need to go and look after her, to see what could be done to help people. Having said that, our constituents who still live in unsafe flats have waited far too long to have them made safe, and I look forward to this bill making very, very speedy passage through both houses.
Speaker 199
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. First of all, could I just pay my own tributes to the whole Grenfell family? I think we can all remember quite vividly the moment when we heard on the news about this absolute and utterly appalling disaster, and our hearts go out to all of those who were affected and their families at this time when so many people must be thinking about the anniversary next year as well. And it was quite clear, as other honorable members have said, that this was a complete and utter failure of regulation. I'm so pleased that today's bill is tackling this.
I would also like to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that cladding is also, as other members have said, an issue around the whole country, and I would like to address some matters in my constituency in Reading as well. Could I just start, though, by thanking the Secretary of State and the ministerial team for their drive and ambition on this important matter after some years of I think what sadly can only be described as drift under the last government? I would like to wholeheartedly welcome the bill, and in particular some of the key elements and points within it.
The fact that it creates greater certainty is long overdue. It gives regulators the powers that they need. It makes companies which made unsafe products contribute towards remediation and that is such an important point as other members have said. And most of all it ensures residents have a route to remediation which is utterly important. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am conscious of time and there are some other speakers so I would like to turn to my constituency in Reading.
There are serious concerns locally like many other members have said and described their own situations in their own constituencies.
Our town has grown and changed dramatically within my lifetime from being a county town made up of Victorian terraces and many brick buildings to now having a large number of taller buildings, many of which are blocks of flats. And obviously, given this recent crisis, this has a huge implication for our community and indeed for other towns across the county of Berkshire. At the time of the Grenfell disaster, I can remember receiving a briefing from Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue, and I can only say that this had an utterly chilling effect on those who listened to it, myself and local councillors and others. The situation they described was one of a service trying to cope with very serious concerns and issues across a large English county, for example, the problem as we've described today of cladding on many buildings, some of them below 11 metres as well, quite a number below 11 metres, but also related issues which some members have described very eloquently, the problem of poor compartmentalisation.
I remember them talking about blocks in Slough where builders had unwittingly drilled holes through walls that were meant to prevent fire. In Reading, we had issues in some blocks where there was very, there were very serious problems with compartmentalization. A whole series of issues with doors and dangerous wooden cladding, dangerous wooden fittings in foyers or doors that weren't fire safe at all. And all of this existed in just one county. Fire and rescue service staff and local authority staff were pressed enormously to deal with it.
And I remember listening to this and listening to the accounts of how waking watches had already been set up and how terrifying it must have been to live in one of the blocks that were affected, obviously just after Grenfell when people were very aware of the disaster and the horror that had happened just in London not far away.
But having to live through a waking watch every single night, not being able to have a whole range of items, not being able to cook certain types of food because of the fire risks from things like frying and other common forms of cooking. This was a huge issue for our community, particularly in the town centre and nearby areas. And I have to say that many building owners were extremely responsible and acted as quickly as they could given the supply problems with the lack of large numbers of skilled tradespeople, other problems putting up scaffolding, the pandemic which followed. And I particularly want to pay tribute to a number of housing associations which actually acted very quickly. Luckily all the council housing in Reading was not affected because it wasn't built using cladding and the council had taken a very robust approach to that.
But there were a number of problems with private blocks which were either ones which were rented or where there were leaseholders. And some of those issues have continued right up to the present day.
And there have been local media reports on ITV South, indeed on a number of cases, and BBC as well, I believe, where they've highlighted some of the problems. And exactly as other colleagues have said, I had constituents, and indeed my honourable friend from Southampton Itchen put it very well, constituents who bought flats in blocks with cladding, who were then trapped within them, who were struggling to sleep, who lived in complete stress and sometimes, almost, I think it's fair to say, had moments of terror about their lives living in these flats, where they quite clearly were at great risk. They couldn't get the work done. They were facing huge financial costs as well. And that has been a problem across the whole country.
I'm so pleased that the current government has really gripped this and wants to tackle this and introduce some reassurance and routes to remediation at much greater pace than was previously available. I would like to though press ministers on the point of the flats under 11 meters and just explore a little bit further, and I hope the minister will be able to in her... in her speech later perhaps respond to some of this. It's great to hear about the fund for the flats under 11 meters, and indeed in many medium-sized towns there will be quite a number of these. But there are also other related risks around non-cladding based fire safety issues in exactly this type of block. And in fact some of the issues I mentioned earlier, like the dangerous wooden items in a large foyer of a large block in Reading, other problems with wooden balconies, in one case we had wooden balconies next to an underground car park which was then discovered to be a huge fire risk.
Some of these are risks in blocks under 11 meters which may not be covered by the fund.
So I would ask the Minister if she could just elaborate a little bit on the nature of the fund to provide further reassurance to residents. And also perhaps if she could look into the wider issue of fire safety in buildings under 11 metres. We have a number of, in fact a significant number, as many colleagues will have, of older flats which are under 11 metres, often in blocks which might date back from the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, which may not have dangerous cladding, but where there might be issues with fire safety doors, with evacuation procedures, a whole series of things. And because of the very large number of these flats, residents will be concerned about the capability of, capacity rather, of local authorities to investigate, or the fire service to investigate. So I would ask for a little bit more information on that if the Minister could provide it.
That would be very reassuring to residents in Reading and other similar towns. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am conscious of time. I would like to conclude by wholeheartedly welcoming today's bill.
It is a huge step forward and I really welcome the drive and the the thrust of activity from the department on this matter. Could I also say once again, I'm sure the whole house will once again want to offer their thoughts to the families of the Grenfell community and I look forward to hearing more from the Minister later.
Apsana Begum.
Apsana Begum
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, six weeks ago, residents in Newtwon Tower in my constituency woke up in the middle of night to a fire. Residents had to rush from flat to flat to warn their neighbors of what was unfolding. Tragically, one of my constituents lost his life and I'm sure that all of us in this house sent our condolences to his family and loved ones.
Others, Madam Deputy Speaker, were hospitalized, and evacuated residents are being told it may be months yet before they can return. This was the first fatal fire at a tower block which has unsafe cladding since Grenfell, in a building identified as having combustible insulation in the cladding, combustible balcony floors, and defective balcony doors. While investigations are still ongoing, early indications are that the cladding itself did not play a role in this particular fire. However, the fact that the fire occurred in a building that has been awaiting remediation for so long has terrified residents in Newington Tower and the adjacent Proton and Electron Towers and Switch House, as well as the hundreds of other high-rise residentials in my constituency which need remediation work. Madam Deputy Speaker, this serious incident is a stark and grave reminder of the potential peril faced by hundreds of thousands of people in this country who feel that they are at the mercy of unscrupulous developers and managing agents.
Repairs and remediation are being delayed again and again. Their safety concerns are going unheard, all while they are tied to unsellable assets and escalating fees. Astonishingly, traumatised residents who have been evacuated from Newham Tower are still being made to pay rent and service charges in the meantime. So the fact that this bill is being put to the House is welcome, of course, as have been the engagements that I've had with the Building Safety Regulator, the Secretary of State, and officials in her department, for whom I know that the Newham Tower fire is being taken extremely seriously.
Indeed, many constituents of mine who fall into the category of having non-external cladding risks and internal defects in their homes, or are non-qualifying leaseholders, will be looking closely at this bill as it progresses through the House, and will be pleased to have heard the Secretary of State's announcement today that these areas will be explored as the bill progresses. Indeed, I also pay tribute to the End Our Cladding Scandal campaign group, who have been campaigning on these fronts for a very long time. Madam Deputy Speaker, I have also been contacted by unpaid resident directors of right-to-manage companies locally, who are worried about the new liabilities they may face regarding defects they did not cause, without any new funding or support to meet these duties.
There is then the bigger picture about the behaviors and the dispute practices which have allowed remediation processes to drag on for completely unacceptable lengths of time for so many buildings. I am disappointed that the new powers to be placed on responsible entities will exclude those developers who are part of the developer remediation contract. Because those developers who are under the DRC itself are able to delay remediation or drag their heels and avoid financial responsibility. I understand that the government's position is that, you know, there are enough existing mechanisms under the DRC which mean that the backstop powers being presented in the bill do not need to be expanded any further. But the point is that this is just not working in practice.
Many residents are alarmed that they are not seeing greater accountability for those ultimately responsible. And that's what it comes down to, Madam Deputy Speaker, ultimately comes down to the question of ambition. There is no denying the complexities at play in this decade-long ordeal.
And I'm glad that some of the glaring gaps in the bill are already being addressed to finally legislate and fix issues that we have been talking about and debating for so, so long. The question for many of my constituents, including at Newby Tower, Madam Deputy Speaker, is when will the remaining gaps be addressed? And most importantly, how long before they will finally have safe homes? Like many members in this House, I'll be following the bill as it progresses through the House very closely and looking at opportunities in and ways in which it can be strengthened even further because we cannot delay taking action any longer. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And I too pay tribute to the families of those who died in the Grenfell fire, which we will never forget, which has scarred not just that area of London, but all Londoners. And also I pay tribute to the honorable member for Kensington and Bayswater for an excellent speech and for all the campaigning work he has done to stand up for his community, but also to work on this bill and ensure that it's as good as it is. And I do welcome this bill, and I really support it today. I just wish it'd been done by the last government years ago. It's a big issue across the country.
The UK government tracks 4,724 high-rise buildings with unsafe cladding.
So 39% of those are now fully remediated, 15% have works underway, but 46% are still waiting for them to start. More than 1,000 buildings in London and several of them in my constituency in Putney. But I would begin by thanking the Minister and her team for the constructive engagement they've shown throughout its development of this Bill, for this both Minister here today but also former ministers as well. Ministers have taken the time to listen to me and I've taken case studies of what's happening to my constituents to ministers and said, would the Bill work for them? And I'm so glad to see so many ways in which it will and goes very far in many ways to redress the problems and actually hold to account those developers who built these buildings and seem in so many cases just to have been able to walk away, to delay, to obfuscate and make it really, really difficult when actually they should have stepped up and said, yes, there are these issues, these are our buildings and we're going to work to rectify them.
This bill represents a significant step and really builds on the remediation acceleration plan towards putting safety, accountability and those affected first. For too long, many leaseholders have been trapped in homes they couldn't remortgage, in some cases didn't even feel safe living in. They bought their homes in good faith, they followed the rules and they found themselves paying the price for failures elsewhere in a system that they trusted in. The human impact of these delays cannot be underestimated, as many members have said. I have spoken to constituents who are not able to start a family or increase their family, they're not able to take up jobs, they're not able to care for relatives across the country because they are stuck in their homes, unable to move on with their lives.
They've experienced prolonged disruption and financial uncertainty and huge levels of stress. So I do welcome these measures. It gives regulators stronger powers to hold those who delay or obstruct remediation to account. It introduces a statutory duty to remediate, replacing cozy deals and voluntary commitments as were promised by so many ministers in the former government. I came here time and time again with so many other members in this debate, time and time again to be told, "We will take action, it will be done."
"I have got the developers all round the table and they're all going to do it, don't you worry." And time and time again, it just did not happen at all. So no more of that. Absolutely.
Luke Murphy
I thank my honorable friend for giving way and she's making a really strong speech about the need for this bill.
Does she agree with me that this action is long overdue? Residents in my constituency in Crown Heights have waited for years and for far too long in financial uncertainty, uncertainty about their safety. They deserve a clear timeline for when their remediation works are going to be completed and residents like them will be served better in future by action that will be delivered through this bill.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
I absolutely agree and I think the member's constituents, my constituents, constituents of all members will be watching this debate half feeling glad that it's happening and half just hoping that it actually will.
And I, and there's one part of the bill that I really welcome in that respect, is that there has to be a remediation compliance plan published on the website, openly available, and it has to be proactively shared with residents. The fact that that has to be even said is a testament to how frustrating it has been for residents to try and find information. Who has built this building? Who is, who are the responsible parties? What are they going to do?
Where is the plan? Am I going to be moved out? When's it going to happen? When can I get on with my life? No, a plan has to be published, put on the website and proactively shared, and I really welcome that.
Al Pinkerton
I'm very grateful to the honorable lady for giving way. She talks about the, the need, the desire to end the culture of cozy deals, and I completely agree with her on that.
But is PAS 9980 itself not the cozy deal that was done by the former Secretary of State, Michael Gove, as a compromise to the building developers to let them off so many of the financial obligations that they would have had if they had to remediate buildings to the standard that they should have been built at? Does this bill not in fact turn that cozy deal and make it law?
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
I thank the member. And I've been following this closely as well as EWS1 forms and who fills them in. And any level of marking your own homework by the developers within this system does it does cause problems as the system goes on. So I think many members will be watching this bill, watching what's in it as it progresses through this House and the other place and to see how we can strengthen it even further.
Because we don't want to have in all good faith putting in measures, but actually in practice, the people who are marking that or inspecting it, either there aren't enough of them and so there's huge delays in the system, or they're the very people who want to minimize the amount of work that is done and keep on the delays. I do welcome the fact that building owners who fail to act could face fines of £500,000 and even criminal prosecution. Where owners refuse to do the work, Homes England will have the powers in the backstop to step in and ensure that the remediation is finally carried out, with the costs falling on all those responsible rather than the leaseholders. These measures will help accelerate the resolution of historic safety defects, require manufacturers of unsafe building products to contribute towards putting things right, and ensure that those affected have a clearer route to redress. Because for many people, the cladding scandal is not a historical issue, it's a daily reality.
Through this scandal, I have found out all the connections as well and the layers of poor regulation that have happened in building works through this. Because for many homes and many developments in Putney, it's not just been the cladding that's been unsafe, it's been many other parts as well. So in looking at the cladding, we've also found missing fire stopping or inadequate fire stopping, inadequate compartmentalisation, poorly installed cavity barriers, defective balconies, and water ingress. In a couple of developments I've been and I've watched water flowing down through electrical cupboards. The shoddy building work behind this and the way that developers seem to have been able to get away with it should also be looked at.
Not in this bill, this bill needs to be specific, we need to get on with this bill.
But I think there are questions that are being asked through this process. And I know that my residents have had to find out a lot more about whole developments and how they work, about their managing agents and how they should be working for them, in many ways not, about waking watches, about the non-communication by those who are meant to communicate about other defects in the building. They've had to become experts in inspections and how they work. They've had to work with the fire service themselves because they're the people who are kind of involved in all these different parties. And I've been to meetings after meetings where residents are calling them together or I'm calling them together to try and get answers.
It really shouldn't have been that hard. This whole process should be far easier for residents, for leaseholders to know about what's going on in their whole building. And that's why I really do look forward to the Leasehold and Commonhold Bill that's coming ahead.
Because in my constituency of Putney, Roehampton, Southfields and Wandsworth Town, I'm still working with people whose lives continue to be disrupted years after those problems first emerged. And many are currently decanted and living in other places. Many were able to, unable to rent, to sell, to remortgage. They struggle to obtain their EWS1 forms or, as has been mentioned by many other members, affordable insurance. And far too often, the service charges are also going up.
They describe uncertainty, stress and frustration. I want to draw attention, the Minister's attention, to continuing delays affected by the delays of the Building Safety Regulator. I've talked about this in the Westminster Hall debate. I've had three developments which are really affected by huge delays by the Building Safety Regulator. And two of them have now been fixed.
So thank you very much to the Ministers for doing that. But I've got one left. So I'm going to raise that now.
And that's the heritage listed stilt blocks on the Alton Estate in Roehampton. They're really iconic. People come from all over the world to come and look at our stilt blocks. We're very proud of them. However, to live inside them is not so nice.
They've got mold and they've got these windows which are really, really poor windows and they let the water and the weather in. They've endured winter after winter waiting for replacement windows. Although Wandsworth Council approved and funded new windows and stairwell fire doors in September 2023, the introduction of the new building safety regime transferred approval of that to the building safety regulator because these listed buildings are classified as high-rise residential buildings.
So they narrowly missed the approval window before the new arrangements came in, which left them in a sort of a limbo with the building safety regulator and further delays for people who've already waited far too long. So they've waited through the winter of 2023, 24, 25, and now they're approaching yet another winter with these very, very cold windows. They say they put a radiator on, they might as well just be throwing money out of the window. And it's an appalling situation. So I really hope by raising it here today, the ministers can address this.
None of us wants to return to the failures of the past. Robust regulation is essential. The whole purpose of reform is to ensure that safety comes first. But a system that leaves people in prolonged uncertainty is also failing them. As implementation of this bill proceeds, I urge ministers to continue examining how regulatory processes can be made more efficient without compromising safety.
Whether that's ensuring they have the right amount of staff or their systems are right, whatever it needs to make this system work. People shouldn't be left waiting months or years for decisions when works are ready to proceed. Safety and speed are not mutually exclusive. We need to have both. I say again as I conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I really look forward to the Leasehold and Commonhold Bill as well because I think that's really part of the package of very exciting, strong new regulatory powers that are being brought forward by this government in many ways that the last government could have done but didn't.
I support the bill and I hope that alongside these reforms we continue to focus relentlessly on turning regulation into results for the people of Putney and across the country. Thank you.
Chris Vince.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for opening this debate? And as many people have, can I also thank my honourable friend from Kensington and Bayswater for his incredibly powerful and incredibly important speech and for all the work he's done to support the Grenfell families who absolutely deserve that support, but he's a fantastic champion for them. I want to say first of all that I welcome this bill and the importance of these responsibilities for unsafe residential buildings being held legally accountable. As history has shown, these things cannot be left unmonitored.
Madam Deputy Speaker, you will know that I am forever honored to stand in this place as the Member of Parliament for Harlow and the villages. And to find myself standing in this place and listening, for example, to the right honorable member for Leeds South, I admit being a bit of a fan of his, is a bit of a pinch myself moment. But I have to say, above all of that, the biggest honor I've found standing in this place was when I spoke in my first debate about Grenfell about two years ago, and I mentioned one of my incredible constituents, Rod Wainwright, who was one of the first responders on the scene at Grenfell.
He witnessed, as you may remember, Madam Deputy Speaker, first-hand the absolute horror that was caused through the unsafe cladding used and frankly an unavoidable tragedy that took so many lives and has had a lasting impact not only on those families that I've mentioned, but also on heroes like Rod himself. He is an incredible man both personally and professionally, and people like Rod should not be suffering the consequences of other failings, and this bill is just one step towards ensuring this does not happen again. I recently spoke to Rod, who as I've mentioned previously, was medically retired due to PTSD. And it's not an issue for the front bench at the moment, but I hope members from the DWP team will listen when I say that every two years Rod has to re-prove that he's got PTSD, that he should be medically retired. This has a massive impact on Rod's mental health, and when I spoke to him, I saw that impact first-hand.
And I don't think it should be right that heroes like Rod have to go through reliving that terrible night every two years again and again, and it's really, really difficult for him and it can be very difficult for his family.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the government's wider remediation acceleration plan and the support being put in place to help protect leaseholders from unexpected costs and eye-watering bills to fix building safety defects that they themselves did not cause. In Harlow, there have been many cases of leaseholders facing these bills through defects, as I say, they did not cause. And for many years, this cladding was not seen as a defect. Criminalizing those who fail to or mitigate such important elements is a huge step in the right direction. It is clear that this costs lives, and I'm glad that this government is recognizing the seriousness of such.
I welcome the fact that the bill makes provision for offences and financial penalties to ensure a person is legally obliged to provide truthful information, something we know didn't happen in the aftermath of Grenfell, and face penalties if they do not. Furthermore, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to welcome the statutory duty to remediate on multi-occupancy residential buildings over 11 meters in height or with at least five stories in England. However, I would raise again one of my constituent's stories, Claire Miles, who talks about the tragic loss of her mother Daphne in a care home fire in April 2017. And with building safety legislation only applying to buildings 30 meters and above, there needs to be some consideration of this.
I would like to recognise that while Harlow has great fire safety with high-rises, something that has been previously recognised, previous legislation has forgotten those buildings such as care homes, and I ask as this bill moves forward that some consideration to that can be made. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank the Secretary of State and her ministers on the front bench and her entire team at MHCLG for bringing this legislation forward and for their continued championing of building safety, something I think we can all agree is incredibly important. Madam Deputy Speaker, everybody deserves a home, but more than that, and that was discussed yesterday, but more than that, everyone deserves a safe home. Thank you.
Kevin Bonavia
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Time and time again today, we have heard and remembered all those who tragically died in the Grenfell fire all those years ago now. And we look back on that not because, not only because they deserve our memory and our tribute, but because we all know in our hearts that that did not need to happen. It could have been avoided. The warnings were there years before. And that happened now nine years ago, and that's been said a few times today, and we still haven't got it right.
Speaker 233
I couldn't say any more eloquently than my honourable friend, the member for Kensington and Bayswater, as he said today.
Kevin Bonavia
And I know this has just been a few minutes of his time, but beyond many hours of days and months that he has campaigned relentlessly on behalf of his constituents, not only to make sure we learn, get and learn from the truth, but to keep championing the cause, not only their cause, but all those people who are worried and remain worried and feel now trapped in places that should be their homes and to live safely and comfortably in, but that is not the case. So I really welcome what this government is doing today, and I pay tribute to the Secretary of State and her ministers. And the Secretary of State herself in 2024 began with the remediation acceleration plan because it was taking way too long.
Legislation has been passed in this place before, but we see it's not delivering. There are too many gaps and this bill, I believe, is a real step, great step forward. And we've heard some of that today. I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for adding more to it today. And I'm sure she has been listening carefully to what's been said today and will continue to listen, not just to ourselves in this place, but to the people we represent.
I know that she and her ministers have been meeting people affected by this, representatives of the End Our Cladding Scandal. And one of the big champions in my constituency, Sophie Bichener, has been working for some years and she's acknowledged that to me.
But when we talk about examples in our constituencies, sometimes you think, well, you know, if you represent a big city, you're going to have quite a lot of these, and that might be true. And I represent a new town, just as the previous honorable friend there representing Harlow represents another fine new town not far from Stevenage. And so we don't have as many examples as you might think. But there are two that I want to highlight because it doesn't matter that we've not got many, but those residents have been trapped there for so long, really, really feel it. We've got Monument Court and Vista Tower.
And I just want to outline or relay a couple of my residents' expressions of despair that they sent to me. One in Vista Tower said, "Since the Grenfell Tower disaster, we have been imprisoned in a property that we cannot sell, has no apparent value, has continuing yearly safety improvements, but worst of all, the owners of flats have no visibility as to when this nightmare will finish." Another said, "I am living in a home that I know to be unsafe, with no clear timeline for when the necessary remediation work will be completed." "The ongoing uncertainty is causing significant stress and anxiety, particularly as I have two young children whose safety and well-being are my priority."
I am also facing increased insurance costs and am having to deplete my savings to cover the financial burden. I cannot sell my property because of the unresolved cladding issues, leaving me effectively trapped in a home that may be unsafe and unable to move forward with my life. These two residents are just two examples of people trapped in their own homes, not knowing if they are safe all these years going on. Right now in Vista Tower, they're going through a second round of remedial works. Residents have been told they are to be decanted, but for how long we do not know, when that's going to happen we do not know.
Vista Tower itself has been the subject of many legal actions that have been going on for years, and there seems no end to it. We have to give those residents a hope of an ending so that they can get on with their lives, so they can feel safe in their homes, or if they want to move on and move elsewhere, that they can do that. So I'm pleased that this bill takes some of that forward. Some of the issues that have been raised have been very, very difficult for many members here to hear. We need to ensure that non-qualifying leaseholders, like those living in Vista Tower and Monument Court, aren't left with unaffordable bills in order to fix historic defects such as fire safety.
So I'm pleased to hear movement from the Secretary of State in that regard. Happy to.
Al Pinkerton
I'm incredibly, incredibly grateful to the honorable gentleman, my honorable friend, for giving way. His stories from his constituents resonate deeply with those I hear from my own constituency. And add into that my constituents, nine of them, or nine different properties where EWS1 forms were signed by this rogue fire safety engineer called Adam Kiziak, which has introduced further uncertainty and further anxiety alongside all the other ones that he's already spoken about.
And that's why I think I feel so passionately that this bill could do just a little bit further and call for the independent regulation of fire safety engineers to bring added certainty to those who do have to commission forms that ultimately speak to the quality but also the safety of their building. Would he join me in making that case?
Kevin Bonavia
I thank the honorable member for making a very sensible point there. And I'm pleased that the bill does take forward sort of independent actors to step in. And I would always welcome the more of that the better. But we must ensure we cannot have developers or freeholders of these buildings to mark their own homework essentially.
And we do need to ensure that buildings are reviewed holistically and made safe as a whole. As I said, Vista Tower's facing a second round of intrusive works and decanting residents. So we need to ensure that this can be avoided, and that's why having these compliance plans is so important, and more importantly, that residents can be informed, but also influence and shape some of these plans. So I welcome moves in that regard. In Vista Tower, it's been now eight years of fighting.
There have been no timelines to end this.
And so with the remediation compliance plans, we need to ensure that these guarantee access to assessments, works certifications, delivery timetables and completion evidence, with real meaningful engagement for leaseholders and also to provide accessible routes to challenge decisions and raise concerns regarding their homes. That way we can give leaseholders confidence, but also the flat market as a whole confidence that when work is required, it is done properly and collaboratively. So today is a day of real progress. We are filling those gaps one by one. But I'm also pleased to hear ministers are listening and they carry on listening to make sure that this bill will become an act that really does give people living in fear of the future, uncertain what's going to happen to their home, it gives them finally that relief from all of that that they truly deserve.
Jade Jessica Toale
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker, last but hopefully not least. I'd like to thank the Secretary of State and the Minister for bringing forward this bill and of course pay tribute to my honorable friend the member for Kensington and Bayswater for all of his work to honor the victims and families of Grenfell and to ensure that nobody else suffers the horror of such an avoidable tragedy. I fully support the government's determination to accelerate remediation and better protect leaseholders who have been left carrying the emotional and often financial burden of a crisis they didn't create. As we've heard from many honorable members across the house today, too many people across the country have been trapped in unsafe homes facing uncertainty, financial anxiety and delays that have stretched on for years.
Madam Deputy Speaker, everyone deserves to live in a safe home, and that's why this bill is so important. I welcome many of the provisions in the bill, from the clear legal duty for responsibility for unsafe buildings, that stronger enforcement, the clear consequences with that, to ensure that leaseholders aren't left paying the price for failures that weren't their fault. I do, however, have to be honest about some of the practical barriers that are impacting my constituents and delaying works on the ground at present. In my constituency, Bournemouth West, residents in several high-rise blocks have contacted me repeatedly about remediation delays. In one case, a developer is ready with the necessary cladding works that would make the building safe, but they've been waiting for approval with the Building Safety Regulator since the middle of 2024.
The decision on certification has been pushed back six times. I've written to the Minister, Baroness Blake in the other place regarding this case, but this remains a significant problem and the BRS has delayed yet again only last month. Another property in my constituency is similarly impacted. The contractor has brought materials, submitted the relevant applications to the Building Safety Regulator in August of 2025, but was rejected several months later. The application was submitted again, but it was rejected in May of this year.
In the meantime, residents continue to live with significant damp and mould and fire safety issues in the building. Madam Deputy Speaker, these aren't isolated incidents and I could relay others.
In fact, actually I will, because this is quite significant. One building, a social housing building in my constituency, had some botched internal works, leaving really unacceptable conditions in communal areas and embarrassment for residents that live there, to the point that one of them brought me in, and this is a very visual example, showed me a piece of exposed wall with mould all over it where they'd affixed a name tag that said Jackson Pollock 2024. Now, that building is on a hill, and when they brought a contractor in to do the works to remediate the internal bits of the building, they discovered that the building is actually smaller on the front than it is on the back. So they then needed to reclassify the building and submit an application to the Building Safety Regulator.
So I have very little faith that these residents, who have already been waiting more than two years for the internal works on this building, will get it in good time. So this is not about weakening standards or cutting corners. It's just, it's just about robust scrutiny and effective regulation that's absolutely necessary. And the point is that residents, leaseholders, and good contractors who are doing, trying to do the right things shouldn't be increasingly frustrated by these delays. Now my residents need certainty that the plans to make their homes safe can actually take place and at pace.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, we all want stronger regulators on this side of the House, but there appears to be genuine questions about whether the Building Safety Regulator has sufficient capacity and specialist resource to process the applications they're getting as quickly as everyone would like. And concerns about delay within the regulators has already been raised elsewhere, including by the Industry and Regulators Committee in the other place. Now, the provisions in this bill are necessary and overdue, long overdue. But if the ambitions of the bill are to be realized in practice, the Building Safety Regulator must have capacity and resources to match those ambitions. So I would be grateful if the Minister in her closing remarks could address the issue of the Building Safety Regulator resourcing and capacity.
Would she also consider meeting members from across the House whose constituents are experiencing these delays so that these concerns can be discussed directly? The regulator must have staff, expertise, and support it needs to ensure that vital remediation projects are not delayed unnecessarily. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, the people living in these buildings have waited long enough.
They deserve safe homes, they deserve certainty and to see the progress. So I'm proud to support this bill today and I hope that the Minister will address some of my concerns in her closing remarks.
Katie Lam
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With the leave of the House, I would like to acknowledge some of the backbench contributions we have had to the debate today. The sheer volume and range of locations is remarkable and speaks to the scale of this terrible problem. We have heard from honorable members from Ipswich, Woking, Southampton Itchen, Bromley and Biggin Hill, Bristol Central, Salford, Leeds South, Reading Central, Poplar and Limehouse, Putney, Harlow, Stevenage, and Bournemouth West, all speaking of the challenges that their constituents have in dealing with this terrible problem, and of course, the member for Kensington and Bayswater.
It must be a great responsibility to be the Member of Parliament for so many victims and survivors of the Grenfell Tower, which happened in his constituency, an area we both know very well. And I'm sure that he feels that acutely. Some of his descriptions of rogue and dangerous activity were shocking. As I outlined in my opening remarks, those of us on the opposition benches share the fundamental aims of this bill. We too believe that every building with unsafe cladding should be fixed and fixed fast.
The questions we pose are not about the bill's aims, but about whether or not it will work in practice and whether the full implications of its provisions have been considered by the government. The evidence suggests that remediation is slow, mainly because there are not enough capable professionals to do the work, because the work is hard and unpredictable, and because delivery is fragmented.
Elements of this have been acknowledged by members on both sides of the house. In our view, there is a risk that a bill which creates new legal duties, deadlines and penalties but not a single new assessor or contractor may add more pressure on the system and risk making this problem even worse. As this bill moves forward, I hope that the government will be able to answer some of the questions raised here today. First, on capacity, every building in the scope of this bill must be assessed within a year of commencement and every assessment that recommends work must be audited by Homes England. What assessment has the government made of whether there are enough qualified people to meet that deadline and, if there are not, what happens to owners who miss that deadline through no fault of their own?
Second, on the new legal duties and the associated offences. Owners could face up to two years in prison or a penalty of up to half a million pounds for deliberately failing to remediate as soon as reasonably practicable.
What guidance will the relevant regulators be giving on what that means in cases where qualified professionals are simply not available? Can the minister be sure that an owner who is trying in good faith to commence remediation but who cannot get the work done will not be prosecuted? Third, on group accountability. In 2022, Parliament allowed a court or tribunal to look through a company structure when it was just and equitable to do so. This bill hands a version of that power to regulators through the power to issue penalty notices.
Why was the judicial route not enough? Fourth, on manufacturers' liability. The 2022 Act gave building owners a route to claim against those who made defective cladding. This bill loosens the test, but why was the 2022 test not sufficient? And has the government made any assessment of what this will do to insurance costs and the costs of building new homes?
There is also a great deal that we have not yet seen.
Remediation management orders will be set out in regulations and guidance that have not yet been published. Councils are being given new duties, including the remediation backstop, with no clear sense yet of how they will be resourced. Parliament should see the detail before it can approve these powers. We intend to table amendments at committee to test each of these points, and we look forward to continuing this discussion with our shared ultimate aim in mind.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to start by thanking members across the House for their contributions today.
As many members and right honourable members and the Shadow Secretary of State outlined, next June will mark a decade since the Grenfell fire disaster took the lives of 72 people, including 18 children. None of us can imagine the horror that survivors, families and friends suffered that day. And the community will continue to carry that trauma, the anguish and suffering throughout their lives. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a tragedy that should never have happened, and one that must never ever happen again. But we have to be honest and say that it is unacceptable that far too many people in this country still don't have the safety and security of a safe roof over their heads nine years after Grenfell.
This isn't just about building safety. It's about giving everyone a peace of mind that a safe, decent and affordable home brings. Because we have to ask ourselves, how can we expect anyone to sleep soundly and get on in life if the building they are going to sleep in every night is covered in dangerous and flammable cladding? The building safety crisis must be resolved, homes must be made safe and residents must be allowed to live with their lives.
This government was elected on a manifesto with commitments to accelerate remediation, better protect leaseholders and make those responsible for building safety crisis pay to put it right. Our remediation acceleration plan and the remediation of unsafe cladding bill delivers on that pledge. By introducing a register of 8-11 to 18 meter buildings and the national standard of assessing buildings, this bill will finally bring certainty as to the scale of the problem and the work required to fix it.
By creating a new legal duty to remediate, backed up by substantial new penalties for inaction, we will compel those responsible to fix their buildings without delay.
Gideon Amos
I'm extremely grateful to the Minister on a very serious speech, a measured speech. But a number of members have raised, she referred to the standard of remediation, and a number of members, including myself, raised that standard of tolerability instead of using the building regulations. Is the Minister, is the Government willing to review the standard of remediation so that after remediation, buildings are still not left as they are now with flammable cladding on the outside?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the honorable gentleman. I know that a number of members have raised the remediation standards, and his honorable friend next to him also raised that in the Westminster Hall debate, which I responded to.
Many members and right honorable members will be aware that the bill will be making independent auditing of fire risk appraisals of external walls mandatory. And we are confident that PAS 9980 is a robust and appropriate methodology for assessing the fire risk spread in throughout a building. The bill will also look at the independent auditing and the statutory requirement ensuring that additional checks on those assessments have been carried out properly. To reassure members, Homes England will also audit all assessments that recommend mitigation and remediation and they will also have the power to audit other assessments. I'll make some progress on that.
By delivering the remediation backstop, we will make sure that no building and no resident is left behind, even if the person responsible for their building is determined to ignore the risk it presents to residents. And by creating stronger avenues for redress against construction products manufacturers, we will ensure that those responsible for cladding safety crises pay towards the cost of fixing it. I'd like to thank the Secretary of State and the Building Safety Minister, Baroness Blake, for bringing this forward. I'd also like to thank all ministers who've come before me and the work they've done on making this bill a reality. That includes the Lord Chancellor, the right honorable member for Streatham and Croydon North, and my honorable friends, the member for Chester North and Neston and the member for Bethnal Green and Stepney.
Speaker 239
I thank the minister for giving way. On the subject of fire safety, residents in my constituency of Feltham and Heston have been shocked recently to see all internal fire doors nearly fail an inspection.
Turns out they've not been inspected for many years and allowed to fall into disrepair, meaning residents are now on the hook to replace them with high costs as well as being subjected to dangerous conditions. I just wondered if the minister would agree that that's really not on and would she ask officials to examine whether that might be happening in other blocks of flats around the country that might mean it merits government intervention.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honourable friend for making that point. And this bill deliberately focuses on unsafe external cladding because of the Grenfell Tower fire phase one report found that that cladding and external walls. But this is an area that we will be looking as the bill progresses, so I'll give him that assurance. I'll turn, Madam Deputy Speaker, to a number of comments made by honourable members and right honourable members throughout the passage of this bill. And my apologies to members in that time may not be able to cover all of them.
I'll start with the Shadow Minister in the comments she made in terms of the limited workforce capacity in fire safety technicians. This is an area that we will continue to review and there is additional funding in terms of making sure those fire assessors are in place. My honorable friend, the member for Kensington and Bayswater, outlined why this is such an important issue and I thank him for his work and his tireless campaigning and continuing to work to work with the survivors of Grenfell and highlighting some of the dangers that still exist. He also mentioned the increasing costs that many of his constituents are facing, examples of eye-watering bills that residents are having to pay out to fix this.
I know that one of the issues that I worked with him in my former role as the chair of the Housing Select Committee was looking at the national oversight mechanism. It is not right that we are having to go through those recommendations one by one and I hope that he's assured that as this inquiry progresses and the government accepted all recommendations in Grenfell, we are making progress on this. The honourable member for Thornton and Wellington outlined the issue on PAS 9988 and I hope that he will be assured that's an issue that we'll continue to look at. My honourable member for Ipswich detailed the real-life issue and the fact that many leaseholders continue to be left in limbo. Their mental state is also being challenged on this issue.
Leaseholders having to face limbo in terms of remediation, having to wait a decade out of their homes, waiting for that, and that injustice that residents continue to face, and I thank him for continuing to work with those leaseholders. My honorable member for Southampton Itchen outlined the work that he's been leading on in Ocean Village and the works there and Oceana Boulevard, a building built only 20 years ago, but 10 years into that building, fire safety defects were outlined. This shows why we have to continue to work to ensure that all buildings are safe, including some of the buildings which were deemed to be new builds. The honorable member for Bristol Central, and I thank her again for her work in detailing that really tragic case of her constituent, a 97-year-old, having to rely on her children to buy back the property to give her that certainty, a property that they cannot sell, a property that they are now lumbered with, only by doing the right thing for their parent.
No child should have to go through this and have to face these costs, being lumbered with a building which is not a, which they're not able to sell. This is why we are making sure that the developers are paying for this with the developer remediation fund. My honourable member for Northampton South, again, outlined many areas where a number of, of members have highlighted. The issue around insurance and non-cladding and non-qualifying leaseholders. This is a key area that we'll continue to look at, and the construction product manufacturer is a key area that I know that he has expertise and knowledge on, and I'll continue to engage with him as the bill progresses.
My honourable member for Salford outlined the work that she's been doing with her constituents for many years, and to praise the action from Salford Council in taking decisive action to ensure that they acted fast and they sought those costs. It shows that where possible, our local authorities are stepping forward to fill the gaps where developers have failed. But it shouldn't have to be developers, councils leading on this. Developers who built the buildings should be the ones paying, and we hope that this bill will identify those owners. My right honourable friend, the member for Leeds South, outlined the fantastic work he's been doing with the Leeds Cladiators as well.
He also highlighted the issues around the delays in building safety regulations. I hope that many members will see that we are seeing progress in building regulation standards.
Under the leadership of Lord Rowe and Charlie Busley, we are seeing more progress on that, and I hope that as this bill progresses, members will see that going forward. My honorable member for Poplar and Limehouse highlighted the tragic case and the fire at Newton Tower, which sadly resulted in a resident losing his life. My honorable member knows that this investigation is still ongoing, so it would be inappropriate to comment on that, but we are continuing to work with relevant parties to ensure the safeguard and wellbeing of displaced residents is addressed as soon as possible.
The London Fire Brigade have stated that the fire is believed to be accidental, but as this investigation is ongoing, we'll continue to engage with her and her residents. Lastly, Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable member from Harlow highlighted the PTSD that his constituent is facing. This shows the real-life consequences that many of our firefighters, who were the first respondents to that tragic fire and many tragic fires that we continue to see across the country, are having to live with. The fact that his constituent has to highlight and reapply every two years to the DWP, I hope that this is something that ministers in the other department will take into account. This is a real issue that we need to continue to engage and discuss all members with.
I hope that members will continue to engage constructively with us as this bill passes, as this bill progresses through the bill committee. Madam Deputy Speaker, the passion with which members of this house have spoken today is a testament to the desire we all share in bringing the building safety crisis to an end, to protect residents and leaseholders who desperately need and want to see action. This government is delivering on that action. We are providing more remediation funding than ever before, remediating more buildings than ever before, prioritizing the higher risk buildings and putting the safety of residents at the heart of our work. My honorable friend from Stevenage spoke about the work from his constituent.
I had the pleasure of meeting them and the Cladding Scandal members two weeks ago with the Secretary of State. No one could have been moved by listening to their testament, the real life issues and the trauma that this ongoing delay is causing so many people.
People's lives on hold, people not able to plan for their future, people in financial ruins. Tragically, some people have died waiting for this issue to be resolved. Alongside the package of measures we have delivered to accelerate remediation and support to leaseholders, the remediation of unsafe cladding and this bill will ensure that no building and no resident is left behind. I hope that members will see that this bill will bring certainty, clarity, accountability to drive forward remediation and make every building safe. This is what we owe to residents.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this is what we owe to the country. I'm grateful to members from all parties who've given their support to work with us on this bill and in that spirit, I commend this to the House.
Speaker 240
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Program motion to be moved formally.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Money resolution to be moved formally.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Ways and means motion to be moved formally.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number six on representation of the people, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the Order Paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 240
Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number seven on Northern Ireland, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the Order Paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 240
Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number eight on Northern Ireland, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the Order Paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 240
Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number nine on town and country planning, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 241
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper.
Speaker 240
As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Tellers for the ayes Harpreet Uppal, Liam Conlon, tellers for the noes David Reed, Charlie Dewhirst.
You can blame this the most if it goes wrong.
Speaker 240
The Ayes to the right with 321, the Noes to the left with 66. So the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. Motion number 10 on competition, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No.
I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number 11 on financial assistance to industry, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 240
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 240
Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now move to petitions, so if I give the front benches a moment or two if they want to move over. Petition, Ben Goldsborough.
Ben Goldsborough
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
While the recent creation of a banking hub in Wymondham has already improved access to in-person banking, Wymondham still doesn't have a full-service post office branch, even though appropriate premises exist. I have here a petition signed by nearly 1,800 South Norfolk residents calling for a new full-service post office in Wymondham town centre. The petitioners therefore request that this House of Commons urge the government to encourage the post office to establish a full-service post office branch in Wymondham town centre.
Martin Rhodes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Nearly 1,000 people have signed this petition online or by pen, calling for Yorkhill fire station to be saved from closure by the Scottish Government.
The local expertise of firefighters at neighbourhood stations like Yorkhill ensures that response times are fast and public safety is prioritised. The loss of this vital local service raises concerns that public safety would be further put at risk with longer response times after almost two decades of cuts to public services. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the Government to make representations to the Scottish Government regarding the importance of maintaining adequate fire and rescue provision for residents in Yorkhill and surrounding areas and to raise concerns about the proposed closure of Yorkhill fire station.
Josh Newbury
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I would like to take this opportunity, as I haven't had yet, to warmly welcome the Minister to his place. I know he is covering tonight for the honourable member for Workington and Whitehaven, but I'm sure he will do a fantastic job. And I know in his role around early education, which is also an area of interest for me, he will be a steadfast champion and a fantastic member of this government. So I really welcome him.
I first applied for this debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, after a conversation I had at the West Chadsmoor NHS clinic back in June.
I'd gone there to talk to the team about the fantastic Pride in Place funding that's going to be coming to our area, and to meet some of the brilliant clinicians based there who specialize in areas like children and adolescent mental health services, pediatric podiatry, occupational health, and various forms of family support. As I'm sure members across the House will have experienced, I often leave a visit in my constituency with much more work than I walked in with, but that is of course what I was elected to do, and it's a pleasure to do that work. One of the conversations that I had at West Chadsmoor raised an issue that I felt needed to be brought to this House. It was about vulnerable children being placed in Staffordshire by local authorities elsewhere in the country, and the problems that arise when the right people aren't told that those children are coming. I heard from clinicians that increasingly they are coming across young people who've been placed in our area without Staffordshire County Council having been notified, and sadly CAMHS staff sometimes encountering those children for the first time when they are in a serious mental health crisis.
The doctors I spoke to described young people who might be self-harming or experiencing suicidal thoughts. These are children who will almost certainly have experienced deep trauma, family breakdown and considerable instability. Then they are moved sometimes hundreds of miles from home and the support that they hopefully had been receiving previously doesn't always follow them. The statutory requirement is for the responsible local authority to notify the host local authority when a child or young person in care is placed within its area. But I'm hearing that this doesn't always happen and doesn't always include the relevant information regarding identified risks and support needs.
There should also be, I feel, some kind of consideration to the suitability of a placement like the availability of local services in the area.
When a local authority decides to place a child to another part of the country, that child arrives with their own history, their own vulnerabilities, and often an established package of support. Yet the authority responsible for receiving them may not even know that they are there. The clinicians who want to do their best to replicate that support are sometimes left on the back foot. They may only discover the child when something has gone wrong and they come to them in a very bad way. That's not a sensible way to organise care for any child, let alone one who is already vulnerable, which is why of course the legal duty to inform exists.
In my constituency, we have seen rapid growth in the independent children's homes in recent years, partly because of relatively low property prices, but also as we know, a chronic lack of foster carers.
And as a former foster carer myself, I very much welcome the recruitment campaign that the department launched last week. Absolutely happy to give way to the honorable gentleman.
Jim Shannon
Madam Deputy Speaker, first of all, can I commend the honorable gentleman for Cannock Chase for bringing this forward? He always brings incredibly important debates to Westminster Hall, to the chamber, and to the adjournment debate, and I congratulate him on the stand he takes and the contribution he makes in this house on behalf of his constituents is really appreciated. He mentioned fostering. The Fostering Network found only 33% of foster carers report their allowance fully covers the cost of raising a child. Approximately 66% of people believe, Madam Deputy Speaker, they could be a good foster carer if there were no practical barriers.
So during this cost of living crisis, does the honourable gentleman agree that we must recognise these additional pressures and more must be done to financially support those who have a heart for fostering children to both take this on and also to be equipped to do so?
Josh Newbury
Well, I thank the honourable gentleman for contributing to this debate and for his kind words. He always has a kind word to say and I think always has a very valuable contribution to make to any debate on any topic, which is quite impressive. And on this occasion, he is absolutely right to highlight that there are so many people in our country who would love to foster, who have the attributes to be able to do so, the motivation, but simply can't afford to be able to do so because the costs that they would have to meet exceed the payment that they might get. And I think we need to raise awareness of the fact that fostering is paid for. A lot of people don't realise that.
But I absolutely think that we need to bring those stories, as he's rightly done to this House, to highlight that we need to do far more to support our foster carers. They do an incredible amount. We know that... Absolutely, yeah.
Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner
Um, with regards to foster carers, I've constituents who are foster parents of children with extremely complex needs.
It is a laudable but very challenging vocation. However, placements often fail because the foster parents do not get the wrap-around support and indeed respite that they need. And such breakdowns can be even more challenging if the children are from out of area and then end up getting moved again. So does he agree with me that it should be that all councils must provide the correct support and respite for such of our, for our foster parents?
Josh Newbury
Josh Freebury. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I, I absolutely agree with my honorable friend. She also speaks from a, a real place of deep personal knowledge on this topic. And she is absolutely right to highlight the experience of foster carers in her constituency who all too often feel that the buck always stops with them and there is never any let-up.
And sometimes it can be an incredibly challenging role.
You know, we're talking about some of the most vulnerable children in our society who often have incredibly complex needs that present itself in many different ways. And I think it's the responsibility of our society as a whole to make sure they're well cared for. But that also extends to our foster carers because they are doing such an incredible role, and we need to make sure that they have the support and, as my honorable friend said, the wrap-around care that's absolutely needed to be able to succeed in that role. I feel that my husband and I had that when we were fostering. We were very fortunate to have that support from our county council, and I hope that that is available to everybody, and that's certainly what we need to ensure.
So Staffordshire is increasingly welcoming children placed in our county by local authorities elsewhere in the country, and I'm very glad that our county is able to play that role in caring for vulnerable young people.
The figures for Cannock Chase give us a sense of how that picture is changing. In 2025-26, five children's homes opened and two closed, with a net increase of seven places. The county council told one of the councillors in my constituency that there are 19 homes for children with emotional behavioral difficulties and seven for children with learning difficulties. Because of the high level of EBD homes in my area, the county council are even taking the step, despite the shortages we're all aware of, of asking potential providers not to set up new EBD homes in my constituency for the time being. And as more homes open, our local services clearly have a growing role in supporting children whose previous care arrangements may have been organized hundreds of miles away.
I'm proud that Staffordshire can provide care for those children, but I want to ensure that the local services placing them here are giving our services the information they need early enough to plan properly. So my point is not that Staffordshire should do less to support these children, it is that if we're going to provide that care, we must have the communication and coordination needed to do it as well as possible. These children deserve more than a placement address, they deserve a joined-up package of care that follows them wherever they move. The doctors I spoke to explained that when Staffordshire County Council receives the appropriate notification, CAMHS has a chance to contact the young person's previous NHS trust, establish what support they have been receiving and work out how that support can be continued locally. That's the difference between planning for a child's needs and reacting when those needs escalate.
Without notification, that opportunity is taken away. The receiving services may not know about the child, they may not have their clinical history, they may not understand what treatment or support has been interrupted.
What it means for GPs is they also may not know that a young person's entered their area. Diagnoses, risks and existing care plans may not accompany that placement. Responsibility for GP registration, crisis support and ongoing care may remain unclear. Services might respond without essential clinical and contextual information. Young people may experience avoidable crisis.
And emergency department attendances and inpatient stays are all too common as well. Fragmented arrangements can undermine safeguarding and continuity of care. Commissioning of provision is carried out by local authorities, of course. But if they aren't aware of what's being commissioned from the home area, which can often include a comprehensive health package to sustain the placement, it's not hard to see where things go wrong.
Local services can, in some cases, end up duplicating already commissioned input, leading to provision being double-funded. That complexity is compounded where multiple providers operate within one geographic area. Within Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, there are multiple CAMHS providers alongside specialist children-in-care health teams hosted by different organisations. Acute hospitals attended by young people might be managed by separate provider trusts, many of which don't have access to community health records that are held elsewhere. These organisational boundaries can create barriers to timely information sharing and coordinated care.
And similarly, when children move between multiple out-of-area placements, information can become fragmented across different systems, and accessing records held by external providers might not even be possible. The issue is particularly relevant to my constituency and the wider Staffordshire area where, as I mentioned earlier, we've seen an increase in the number of children's homes in recent years.
As that number grows, we need to be confident that the right safeguards, oversight, and support are keeping pace. A children's home is not simply a property with staff in it. It's a place where some of our most vulnerable children should receive the care, stability, and specialist support that they really need. To give a tragic example of how badly things can go wrong, I will share one story from Cannock Chase. Last summer, I had a constituent in Hednesford raise concerns with me about the care being provided to a vulnerable young person in an independent children's home very close to where he lived.
This young person clearly had had an incredibly traumatic experience at a very young age and very complex needs. The placement was intensive to the point where the home accepted just one child at a time, supported by several staff 24/7.
However, the company responsible for that home clearly had no intention of following through on the promised support package, which was not put in place. I heard that CAMHS weren't even contacted, despite the company having put in their bid that the local CAMHS services in my area are good and deal very well with looked-after children, and that they'd already made preliminary inquiries with them. And the promised two-on-one or three-on-one support was not followed through either, to the point where this young person was at one point left alone and was found by neighbors banging on doors, clearly in extreme distress and mental health crisis. Now, I can't independently verify every detail of that story, and I don't want to prejudge any investigation that might take place.
And I've also visited excellent homes in my constituency run by people who care deeply about providing the highest quality trauma-informed care and I believe that they are in the majority. But these concerns underline why we need effective oversight and clear accountability for the care being provided. But this isn't a narrow issue affecting only children in residential care or those in Staffordshire alone. It speaks to a wider challenge in how we coordinate support across local authority boundaries. Figures that I've seen show that in 2024, 45% of looked-after children were placed outside their home local authority, up from 40% in 2015.
And whilst 69% were placed within 20 miles of home, that proportion has fallen from 76% also in 2015. The same challenges can affect kinship families too. Kinship's 2024 annual survey found that nearly a third of kinship families lived in a different local authority area from the one that the child had lived in before coming into their care.
Of those families, 57% reported difficulties in accessing support as a result. These are different circumstances, but they point to the same question in my mind. When a child's life crosses a local authority boundary, does the support they need follow them? Whether a child is living in a children's home or being cared for by a grandparent, aunt, or uncle, or another family member, we must not allow administrative boundaries to become barriers to accessing the right support. And this leaves me with four questions this evening for the Minister, who is standing in, as I said, for the honorable member for Workington and Whitehaven, who I know is doing a lot of work in this area.
First, what steps is the government taking to ensure that local authorities meet their existing statutory duty to notify receiving authorities when placing children out of area and to identify where that duty is not being met?
Secondly, how is the government working with health partners to improve the sharing of information when a child moves, so that their clinical history, existing treatment and crisis support arrangements can follow them and the services can then plan ahead? Thirdly, how will the government ensure that its regulatory and inspection framework provides effective oversight of children's homes, so that the care and supervision children are promised is the care that they actually receive? And finally, as the government expands placement capacity and rolls out regional care cooperatives, a very welcome development in my mind, how will it ensure that these reforms improve not just the availability of placements, but also the coordination between local authorities, children's homes and health services? I began, Madam Deputy Speaker, by talking about the clinicians at West Chesmore NHS Clinic, and I want to end by returning to them. They see children who have already faced more disruption to their young lives than most of us can even imagine.
They want to give those children the stability, understanding and care that they deserve. The least we should expect of the system that supports them is to give those professionals the information and cooperation that they need to be able to do that. A child shouldn't have to experience a crisis before the services around them realize that support has fallen away. A family shouldn't have to become an expert in local government responsibilities before it can access help. And a local authority boundary should never become a barrier to a child's well-being.
I recognize that the government is taking steps to address the shortage of placements. The 560 million pound investment in children's homes and foster care, alongside that rollout of regional care cooperatives, is intended to help create more suitable places closer to where children live. That matters because the best way to manage the challenges of out-of-area placements is, wherever possible, to avoid placing children so far away in the first place.
And when they do need to move, we must make sure that their care and support move with them. I welcome the steps this government is taking to increase placement capacity, strengthen the system, and improve how services work together. The investment in children's homes and foster care provides the opportunity for us to make sure more children can be cared for closer to home. My ask is that as this work progresses, we keep the experience of the child at the very center of it. That means pushing local authorities to share information, health services being able to plan ahead, and clear accountability for making sure the support a child needs is actually there.
Every child in care deserves stability, safety, and the chance to thrive, wherever they're placed. I look forward to working with the Minister to ensure that the government's reforms deliver those outcomes for children in Staffordshire and across the country. Thank you.
Paul Waugh
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank members for attending and contributing to the debate this evening. It is indeed a deeply important subject, and I'm grateful to my honourable friend, the member for Cannock Chase, for bringing this before us today. As has already been noted, he's a doughty champion for his constituents and is an excellent constituency MP. I had the privilege of knowing his Labour predecessor in Cannock Chase, Sir Tony Wright, and he's more than living up to his example. This Government is clear that children in care should grow up safe, supported, and able to thrive, regardless of their background.
Through the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 and our Children's Social Care Reset, we're delivering the biggest overhaul of children's social care and child protection in a generation. We're now delivering the change that we've promised.
We're building a children's social care system that, firstly, puts families at the heart of our work. We know that keeping children within their immediate and wider family network, and as my honourable friend already referenced, kinship care is really important in this, we know that that's key for improving outcomes. But secondly, we want a system that builds rather than breaks relationships, ensuring that every care-experienced young person starts adulthood with loving, enduring relationships. I'd like to address the questions that the member for Cannock Chase put to me directly, if I may. On what steps the government's taking to ensure that local authorities meet their existing statutory duties when placing children out of area, and what happens when these duties aren't being met.
Let me be clear. If a local authority has to place a child outside their area, not notifying the incoming local authority is a breach of the law.
It is imperative this happens so that ongoing support can be arranged in the new area. We know that far too many children are currently placed out of their local area when they come into care, or are moved during their time in care. In 2023, 22% of children in care, that's 18,000 children, lived more than 20 miles from their home community. Sometimes this distance is for a good reason. Children might be moving to live with their wider family network.
But too often children are placed far from home, which disrupts their relationships with family and friends, their education, and their access to the services that support them.
Where concerns arise that duties are not being met, as has been indicated by my honorable friend, they should be escalated through local safeguarding arrangements, with relevant partners working together to identify risks and coordinate action. Furthermore, Ofsted takes account of whether local authorities are complying with this duty through its ILACS inspections, including whether the placing authority promptly notifies the receiving authority when a child moves into its area and ensures that child can access services that meet their needs. The Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 strengthens this information sharing between agencies, while multi-agency safeguarding arrangements support safeguarding partners to identify risks, share intelligence and coordinate action for children placed outside their home area.
Additionally, earlier this year, the Department also wrote to local authorities as part of a wider communication, reminding them of their statutory duty to inform host local authorities when placing children out of area. On his question regarding working with health partners, statutory guidance is clear that relevant services, including integrated care boards, should be notified before a child moves placement, so that arrangements can be made to meet their needs. Where a move is made in an emergency, notification must follow within five working days. The guidance also recognises that identifying the right contact can sometimes be difficult and suggests practical steps, such as using generic inboxes to help ensure information reaches the right organisation. More broadly though, the new information sharing duty strengthens the requirement on safeguarding partners, including health, to share relevant information where a child relocates, so that important information about their safety and welfare is never lost.
Importantly, the absence of a formal data-sharing agreement should not prevent information being shared where that duty applies. The DfE, the Health Department and the NHS are working closely together to improve health outcomes for looked-after children and care leavers, including ensuring that information flows effectively between services and does not become a barrier to children receiving the support that they need. Now, our reforms to children's social care strengthen multi-agency working and information sharing, and the Home Again programme will bring social care, health, education and youth justice together around a single plan for children with the most complex needs. Just last week, we announced a new mental health pilot across Greater Manchester, embedding mental health professionals to children's social care teams.
It's called Care Together. It replaces the fragmented provision that exists at the moment with faster access to expert, needs-led mental health support, including family therapy and support for parents and primary caregivers. I'm excited to see the impact that this 9.4 million pound pilot will have for 7,000 children and their families across my constituency in Rochdale and also our neighbors Stockport and Tameside. On his question on how the government ensures that its regulatory and inspection framework provides effective oversight of children's homes, my honorable friend, the Minister for Children and Families, keeps the adequacy of the regulatory framework under regular review. In April 2026, Ofsted introduced updates to the social care common inspection framework to promote high-quality inspections for children's homes and other settings.
That focus on the impact of services on the lives and relationships of children and families is absolutely crucial. They've recently consulted on further improvements to their inspection framework for children's social care and will be setting out plans in 2027 in due course.
Josh Newbury
I thank the Minister for giving way. It's good to hear that Ofsted is kind of adapting and growing the inspection regime to match the fact that, as I said, many of these children's homes are opening and the variation in practice seems to be quite large.
Would he be able to ask the the Minister for Children and Families to look into whether Ofsted's capacity is matching the growth in children's homes in certain parts of the country like mine where we're seeing quite quite rapid growth in a short space of time and whether the inspections that are being carried out are kind of matching that growth to make sure that we aren't kind of running away from ourselves in areas and perhaps seeing poorer practice where there just aren't as many inspectors as we need?
Paul Waugh
My honourable friend makes a very important point and I will certainly pass that on to the Minister for Children and Families. He's right that we need to have the capacity to match the requirements that we're imposing. On his last point on the impact of regional care cooperatives to improve sufficiency and coordination, a really, really important point. We've got seven regional care cooperatives now that cover more than a hundred local authorities, including his own Staffordshire through the West Midlands partnership. I can confirm that the regional care cooperatives are not simply about increasing placement capacity.
Children in care can be involved in multiple services as we've heard tonight across local authorities, health and justice, so coordinated regional planning and partnership working is a core requirement of these new regional care cooperatives. By bringing these partners together to forecast need and commission care more strategically, regional care cooperatives will help to ensure provision and wider support are better joined up around children's needs. And my honorable friend rightly repeatedly made that point, we should be focusing on the child, they should be child-centered, all these services around them. I also wanted to recognize the concerns about the distribution of children's homes across England, and these are very, very legitimate concerns that are shared across party, across this House, where some areas have a disproportionately high concentration of homes while others have insufficient provision. We know that this can contribute to children being placed further away from their support networks and can lead to poor outcomes.
We also know this can be driven by a focus on maximizing profits, with some providers attracted by lower property costs. We know that for sure in the North and in the West Midlands. We're taking action to reshape the children's social care market and to improve placement sufficiency to combat this. Through the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act, we're rebalancing that market, increasing transparency and supporting local authorities to secure the placements that children need. We want the right homes in the right places, so children, where it's in their best interest, are kept close to their communities.
Our aim is to support provisions where there's a clear need and the children's needs can be fully met. We're also putting in significant capital funding to deliver 540 new local authority-owned children's homes placements by March 2029 across 75 local authorities.
200 of these will be specialist placements for children at risk of deprivation of liberty. 237 placements are already completed, registered and operational. And if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to touch on the importance of the work we're leading on reforms to fostering, as has been mentioned already by several members, to ensure as few children as possible actually need to enter care in the first place. My honourable friend for Stoke-on-Trent South rightly points out that respite support for foster parents should be there. It should be in place.
And all too often it isn't. The honourable member for Stretford, who's no longer in his place, rightly said we should be removing the practical barriers to fostering.
I know my honorable friend, the member for Cannock Chase, has personal experience of the impact of being a foster carer. And I just wanted to put on record our thanks to him and all of the foster parents who do such a marvelous job day in, day out, week in, week out, with some of the most vulnerable children in our society. And we owe them a great deep debt of gratitude. In March last year, 67% of all children looked after in England were living with foster families. But 46% of those children were placed out of their local area.
This is why the government has launched the Fostering Action Plan referenced by my honorable friend. And we're committed to create 10,000 more foster places this Parliament. This includes an England-wide recruitment campaign, which hopefully members have already seen, which is challenging the myths that stop people from considering fostering and recruiting thousands more foster carers who can give children the loving, stable homes that they need and deserve.
The fostering action plan is backed by 88 million pounds of investment over two years. This includes funding for expanding dedicated regional foster carer recruitment hubs, supporting foster carers to adapt their homes in order to care for more children, increasing numbers of Mockingbird peer support clusters, which I know are much valued across the country, and the launch of the fostering innovation program to support better outcomes for children. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, we know that the best way to keep children safe and to give them the best possible start in life is to support families before problems reach crisis point.
Our Families First for Children pathfinders have tested this approach across 10 local authorities, bringing together earlier, more intensive family help, expert multi-agency child protection and wider family networks to identify problems sooner and help children remain safely within their families wherever that's in their best interests. We're now applying those lessons nationally through the Families First partnership programme, backed by 2.4 billion pounds over the next three years, including 853 million pounds in 26-27. This represents a fundamental shift towards prevention, strengthening families and ensuring that where serious safeguarding concerns arise, children benefit from coordinated expertise across agencies. In conclusion, I'd like to thank again my honourable friend the member for Cannock Chase for bringing this important matter to the House. I'll reiterate this government's aim that every child in care should receive the same joined-up support, stability and opportunity that we'd want for our own children.
We recognise that local and national government, health, education and every partner must work together around each child in our care. I know that my colleague, the Minister for Children and Families, who's done such marvellous work both inside and outside government on this area, will continue to push through the urgently needed reforms the system needs that we've debated today so that children are indeed safe, supported, close to the people and places that matter to them the most and are able to thrive.
Speaker 240
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.