Home Affairs Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Home Affairs Committee House of Commons
Follow its sittingsAndy Cooke
And I drove both of those very strongly from the start, with the simple intention of understanding that doing that in the right way would increase the confidence and trust of the community. And at that time in 2022, when I wrote that report, that State of Policing report for Parliament, it was at its lowest ever level. It's started to improve again, I'm glad to say. On the downside, what would I have done differently, I think, was the question? I think I would have pushed harder with the Home Secretaries to do more thematics.
There's always a question in the inspectorate. It's a very small budget. It's a very small proportion of the overall budget that policing gets, too small in my view, but I would say that. I would have liked to have done more thematic inspections during that time. Unfortunately, finance wasn't available to do that.
It's important to be able to choose as the chief inspector what thematics you do, what thematic inspections you do, because you are operating, you are independent of the government. The amount of inspections that the government were asking me to do during that time, and I think in total there was 382 inspections done during that time, meant there was very little other time to actually do some of the issues that I would have liked to have done, and in 2022 particularly, that would have been about leadership.
Peter Richard Prinsley
So, if you were to appoint an inspector for the inspectorate, what would you ask that person to do?
Andy Cooke
Be impartial throughout, be fair, be hard on the sector because you're working for the public, not for the police or the fire service. Be brave in the decisions that you make, keep at the forefront that the community should always come first in everything that you do, and work as part of a cohesive team, because there's 280 people within the inspectorate, work as part of that cohesive team to actually improve community safety.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Do you think that there are things that you could easily measure if you're an inspector of the inspectorate?
Andy Cooke
We measure an awful lot of things right through, you know, not just outcomes. One of the things I did when I took over as chief inspector, the inspectorate then was, some might say, it was a very much a tick box organization. So you have If you had a great strategy, you'd get a nice, big tick. If you had a great plan, you'd get a great, big tick. As an ex-chief, I know that's pointless because it's what the staff on the ground do in relation to those plans and strategies that matters.
So I changed the focus into a very outcome-based approach. So you can only be a good police force or a good fire service if you are doing the right things for the public, not producing the glossiest, most expensive strategies you possibly could. And I think that's worked. I think that's why we've seen increases in performance in policing and fire. I think that why we've seen improved culture in the fire service and the police service, although neither organisation are anywhere near perfect.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Well, I think you should be congratulated on what you've achieved. Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Karen Bradley
Can I just ask you on, you've talked about thematics versus the sort of focused force-wide ones. In terms of manpower and timing, what's the difference between that? How long would it take you to carry out one of your sort of inspections that was looking at a particular force or a particular area of police force, and how much would it be to do a thematic across policing and whole, as a whole?
Andy Cooke
PEEL's a good comparison. Now we inspect every police force and every fire service every 2 years across England and Wales. That is an awful lot of work to do on its own. In addition to that, we receive commissions from the Home Secretary and on occasion from PCCs who would like us to look at a specific piece of business. Those thematic inspections can take anywhere from, depending on the Home Secretary and how quickly they want it, 3 months to 12 months.
To do a really in-depth piece of work, it can take 12 months to interview all the relevant forces, the relevant other people, to go through all the data that's required to draw some good judgments in relation to it. But, you know, on the other side of that, the former current Home Secretary asked me to do a short inspection on, for instance, the West Midlands Police, which was done in a very short time, and came to the right conclusions, I believe.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you, Chair. Sir Andy, thank you. Just before, declare my interests, I'm also a former police officer myself, so thank you for your service. During your tenure, you investigated many forces, I believe that were perhaps not as good as they could be or not as effective in the basics, such as basic investigations and crimes. How much confidence do you currently have that forces can improve to get these basics right?
Andy Cooke
There's still an awful lot of work to do for forces. I mean, it's a lot of unfinished business in relation to it. I mean, I'll go back to the first state of policing report that I produced, I talked very much about the basics. The public expect the police to do the basics well. We talk about loss of confidence and trust in policing.
Undoubtedly, some of the scandals that we've seen involving serving police officers over the years have dented that terribly and quite rightly. But I think one of the key issues for people is that, for the volume, if I can call them volume crimes, you know, the crimes that people see on the doorsteps every day, I think there was a growing fear the police were ineffective at dealing with them. So, that's why the push back to neighborhood policing and effective neighborhood policing, where officers took action in relation to those who were ruining other people's quality as life quality of life, was so important to me. But the basics, I mean by the basics, it's not a return to Dixon of Dock Green. It is very much about, I'm probably one of the few old enough to remember Dixon of Dock Green.
Thank you. It's very much about, you know, answering the phone quickly, giving the right advice on the phone, deploying quickly, attending quickly, investigating properly, keeping victims informed, doing the right forensic work, preserving that golden hour, that's so important, and hopefully catching the offender in relation to it. Elements of inexperience in policing, elements of poor supervision, elements of poor leadership mean that doesn't happen as well as it should do. Some forces are getting a lot better at it. But it's very much a postcode lottery about which forces are good and which aren't.
I draw that right back to a great extent to two things. One is the inexperience of the young cops and the young supervisors, but the other's quality of leadership as well. Chiefs have got to have, as well as being able to inspire the staff and look after the staff, they've got to have a close, tight grip on performance alongside that. And if they haven't got that close, tight grip on performance, the sergeants, who are the most important rank in the police, won't have that either.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you. Just packing a few of those and coming back. You mention neighborhood policing, and I remember neighborhood policing coming in myself. Do you think that the focus on neighborhood policing perhaps has come at the expense of some of the basics and investigative capacities and capabilities?
Andy Cooke
It depends what you call neighborhood policing. I call neighborhood policing officers who are known in the local area, who will take action against those who are committing crime and committing nuisance. That is exactly what policing needs. They need those the visible representations of policing within the community, those visible representations of security and law and order in the community who are known to them. And sadly, I mean during the austerity years, some chiefs unfortunately thought that neighborhood policing was a nice to have.
It's not, it's a bedrock. It's an absolute bedrock. I was smiling on Saturday when I saw Sir Stephen Watson's comments in The Times, I think it was The Times, about, you know, neighborhood policing is the bedrock. They're the exact words I used in the 2022 State of Policing report. It is absolutely the bedrock.
Getting those basics right is absolutely so important to increase that confidence and trust in policing. The police do some things fantastically well. You know the higher end, the homicide investigations usually 99% of the time are really good. The way they deal with organised crime can be really good. What is that lower level that people see every day that some forces just aren't good enough at.
And that's why some of the detection rates, some of the outcome rates are so low.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you. And I know you've spoke a lot about the barriers for forces to achieve getting things right. Do you think the lack of effectiveness in addressing crime, do you think it's predominantly a resource issue or one of capability of forces and officers, or a mixture of both? What do you think?
Andy Cooke
It's absolutely a mixture of both. I would say, you know, you get the police service that you pay for. Yeah, you know, if there was more money for policing would be more effective. If it wasn't, you could very clearly hold chiefs to account for that. There is still a large element of inexperience.
There is a lot of people do not want to be detectives anymore, for various reasons. But policing can do better with the resources that it has. It would do better again if it had more resource. But then we come into the structure of policing and those issues as well, you know, and you do start to wonder, just putting the money in to address some of these issues, is it going to solve the problem? No, it's not.
The problem will be solved by, in my belief, reorganising the way policing actually works and by a greater reliance on the good technology.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
My last question, we talk about resources and experience, we've mentioned that many times. So, do you think there is fundamentally a problem with retention in the police currently? And again, which is the bigger problem, is it retention or is it something else that's bigger?
Andy Cooke
It's inexperience. Retention is a big issue, and we're seeing more and more young officers leaving than ever before, I think I'm right in saying. I've not got the percentage, unfortunately. There are certainly more leaving than ever before within the first five years of service. Now, whether that is because the wrong people were recruited during the 20,000 recruitment, which was needed by policing, but was done very quickly and mistakes were made in relation to it, whether the wrong people were recruited or it's just not the police service they thought they were going into before they joined is an individual issue for those cops who have left.
But it's sad to see so many young cops leaving. Workload is a real issue. I mean, I speak to, in one of my roles that I do now, I'm a professor at Liverpool John Moores University, and I speak to young policing students on a regular basis. The amount of actual investigations that they are carrying, that they're having to investigate, is more than, as a seasoned detective, I was carrying with 15 years experience. So, something is wrong in the balance of the workload.
They've been asked to do too much. There is a high level of stress, which means that the wellbeing provision from forces needs to be a lot best than it is now. So, I think it's a number of issues. It's a resource issue, it's an inexperience issue, it's a capability issue and it's a complexity issue, because crime has got more complex.
Paul Kohler
Paul Kohler. Thank you for joining us. Thank you for interrupting your retirement to join us. Can I just press you a bit on what Matt was asking about neighbourhood policing? The College of Policing define neighbourhood policing as accessibility, accountability, engagement, and collaborative problem-solving rather than investigatory skills.
And in your 2025 report on investigate, a national inspection, you talk about a lack of an investigative mindset and an operating model that did not provide, promote that mindset. So, is there a tension there, and is that a tension that's being addressed?
Andy Cooke
It shouldn't be a tension. It shouldn't because basically a neighborhood officer should be able to do all of the above. Yeah? It's no I'm not I'm not putting too great an expectation on them. Every police officer, no matter what their role is, should have an investigative mindset.
That's You join policing to reduce crime, prevent crime, and solve crime. Every police officer should have that at the forefront of their mind. It's not about driving around in fast cars. It's not about doing the Excuse the I'd say the sexy bits of policing. It's about actually serving the community, making the community safer, and making them feel they're safe in their houses and they're safe on the streets that they walk every day.
That's what the role of a neighborhood police officer is. Problem-solving, yes, absolutely comes into it, because if you can prevent more, that's fantastic. Well, taking quick action against those who are really impacting on the quality of life of the citizens of this country is just as important, if not more important, because for every criminal you catch, that is great crime prevention, because they're not going to go on and commit more offenses once they've been caught, hopefully, unless obviously they're out the next day.
Paul Kohler
I understand that's how it should work, but you in 2025, you said there's a problem. So, in the on the ground, is there a problem between the mindset, what people have been told neighborhood policing is, and what you want it to be?
Andy Cooke
I think if you bring in the current Chief Inspector of Constabulary, his view would probably be much very much the same as mine. I mean, that's how the college frames it. My view as an ex-chief and an ex-detective is probably slightly to one side of that. Well, if a cop hasn't got an investigative mindset, then they shouldn't be a cop. If they're not prepared to investigate crime to improve people's quality of life, then they shouldn't be a cop.
Andy Cooke
Probably a bit too soon to say. What did improve was the fact that we now have the white paper on police reform, which I am fully supportive of, I think it's fair to say. So, have things improved at the moment? Well, yes. Performance is improving, detections are improving, some forces are getting a good rate of
Andy Cooke
It'd be impossible for me to say if, you know, in relation to individuals, but I do know that the that increase in the outcome performance can only be a result of more people being arrested, better investigations being done. So, I think it's fair to say that, yes, there is more of an investigative mindset now than there was previously.
Paul Kohler
I'm going to get told off by the Chair, cuz I'm not asked my questions, sorry. So, moving to my questions, can you tell What's your view of the financial challenges facing police forces at the moment?
Andy Cooke
Last time that I was briefed in relation to it, certainly some forces have big gaps in their finances moving forward. Policing has not had a capital allocation for some time. They're spending an awful lot of the funding that they have, for instance, for IT; 90% is on current IT, so there's very little room for improving that IT. Reserves certainly in a number of forces are far less than they were previously to make up for some of that shortfall. So, without identifying individual forces, some forces, I know, do have significant financial problems.
The current police funding formula, again going back to when I first came into the role, I was saying it needed to be changed. It hasn't been changed, despite various governments saying that they would consider it. I'm glad to see it's in the white paper that it will be considered because the current way that police is funded is just inequitable.
You know, why should the forces with the highest demand not always be the forces that get the money to deal with that demand? A lot of it is based upon council tax. You know, if you and fair play to anyone that lives in Surrey, if you live in Surrey, you have council tax is high. If you live in Cleveland, it's very low. So, the money that the police get from the council tax draws that inequality.
I mean, Cleveland is a very good example actually because it's a it's a it's a small force that's got real metropolitan issues, some real challenges, but the funding it receives isn't fantastic. It's not, certainly, on a par with some of the forces who don't have those sort of challenges. So, that whole approach to how forces are funding needs to change dramatically, and there'll be winners and losers. But surely, this is about getting a grip on the criminality and the issues that we have, whether that's disorder or anything else within our communities, and actually making a difference in relation to it.
Paul Kohler
In the last annual report, no police force got a good or outstanding. Is that down to financial issues, or is that part of the answer? Is it possible to get a good or outstanding under the current financial model?
Andy Cooke
I would say, yes, it is possible to be outstanding, and there are some forces who have improved quite dramatically. You know, Manchester looks like it's improving, greater Merseyside looks like it's improving. There are some forces who are focused on actually dealing with the investigations in a way that keeps victims happier than they were previously, and actually catches those people responsible. So, it is possible to be good. Resource does come into it.
You know, because a chief has got to and have every sympathy for chiefs they've got to balance that resource across so many different things. But these issues that are on the doorstep of people on a daily basis are important. That's where the confidence and trust will be brought back if they do that right.
Robbie Moore
Thank you. Just to build on the question just to do with funding, have you noticed obviously with the change in employers' National Insurance impacting the public sector, I know that there was a report done by the House of Commons Library which indicated that there had to be a effectively a rebate that was negotiated or a grant that was given out to cover the increase in employers' National Insurance. Do you think that change in taxation policy has been challenging for police forces to reconcile with?
Andy Cooke
I think any changes on top of the general budget that they get impact greatly. I mean pay rises impact greatly, depend the size of the pay rise, what policing can afford to do moving forward. And it'll be no different with the employers' National Insurance issue. You know, it's all another thing that means that the citizens of this country are getting less service because money is being pumped elsewhere, not into where it's needed to keep people safe. If you ask me to go into any more detail in relation to that, I will struggle, so please don't.
Robbie Moore
No, don't worry. That's fine. I just wanted to move on just to do I mean it's been briefly touched on already, but recruitment, morale and well-being within the police force, as well. So, just as an overview, what would you say the biggest challenges to improving police officer morale and well-being has been, and how can that be addressed?
Andy Cooke
The morale, on whichever survey you look at, for policing isn't good across the country. It's better in some parts than others, but it isn't good across the board. Chiefs really do need to make the effort to put police officers first and police staff first, in relation to what they think, very closely after looking after the community, because the instance of mental health, of officer assaults is exceptionally high. And we if I can give you an example, we did an inspection after the disorder of 2 years ago,
and we looked specifically, amongst other things, at how staff who were involved in some of those exceptionally vicious incidents that they were involved in were looked after. And it was I was delighted seeing some forces, they were looked after really well, and it was at the forefront of the senior officers' minds.
In other forces, it was an afterthought. And that can't be right because it should be, and that's one of the reasons we're bringing in a national police service I've got to say, it's one of the reasons why officers can't understand why the force next to them is getting such a good welfare response while they don't in their own force. There's no balance in relation to it at all.
So, how do you improve morale and welfare? Certainly, police officers feel unloved, sometimes by their own bosses, sometimes by government, sometimes by media. The police covenant is one thing that's been going on for a long time now without resolution. You know, if you really do care about the police officers who are risking their lives on a daily basis for you, let's get the police covenant sorted out.
Let's get it in the right place. And that's the successive governments who've not, who've looked at that and have discussed it and discussed it and still not come to resolution in relation to it. You need to make police officers feel that they're wanted. But you also on the other side of that, you need to address some of the issues about the workload that they do have, and I mentioned workload before.
That means embracing technology a lot more than policing has done, and having the finance to embrace that right technology. You know, I'll use the dirty word, AI, in relation to that. It can make a massive difference used in the right way if it's sovereign AI and we're sure about the safety in relation to it. So, there's an awful lot policing can do to improve those officers' lives. So, addressing workload,
really being serious about their welfare, being led well, which is not always the case unfortunately. It is in some forces, but not others. And feeling once again that they are part of a team that make a difference, take away some of the bureaucracy that they've got to be dealing with on a daily basis.
You know, whether that's criminal justice bureaucracy, or self-inflicted, or on occasion, you know, mea culpa, inspectorate bureaucracy that's put them through it. I tried to cut a lot of that out, but there's still some of it left. And letting them get on with the job. I think the current statistic is that a police officer spends 13% of the time on patrol, 13%. That should be 80%.
But they are now data inputters, not police officers.
Speaker 10
And during your time as chief inspector, do you feel that the trends, or the feeling changed in terms of retaining experienced police officers?
Andy Cooke
I don't think there's any real effort done across the board to retain those experienced police officers. A lot of them come back on new short-term contracts when forces are short. But an awful lot of the experience has gone from policing, particularly over the time when there was no new recruitment coming through, but officers were leaving at the other side. And it's important that police officers learn to do things the right way. You know, is it right that a tutor constable's got two-and-a-half years' service?
You know, I don't think so. This when I will swing a blue lamp now, but going, you know, when I joined the police, there were experienced cops who taught you how to do the job. Now, you got inexperienced cops teaching other inexperienced cops on occasion.
Speaker 10
Just, I know you touched on it briefly on, but the police uplift programme, just in your view, how do you feel that forces have been able to effectively develop and retain recruited members of the team through the uplift programme?
Andy Cooke
I welcomed the police uplift programme because it returned the numbers that were taken away in 2010 to 12-ish.
It was done very quickly. The inspectorate has reported in 2020 20,000 sorry, 2022 the concerns it had in relation to the fact that some people were getting into policing might not be the right people for policing because of that rush to actually bring people through. And that's unfortunately proven to be the case. So, that's why we're seeing such a such difficulties with retention of the officers coming through. That's why we're seeing officers who didn't quite expect policing to be like they thought it was.
So, yes, the uplift was good. If I'm sure if any government or anyone had the time again, they wouldn't try to cram those people in so quickly because the pressure that put on the police forces themselves on the recruitment of the right people was Catastrophic is too strong a word, was dangerous in the circumstances. However, not every police force can walk away with it without thinking about the fact that they made some real mistakes during that time as well.
Robbie Moore
And obviously culture and leadership within different forces varies dramatically, but is incredibly important obviously for steering that force in the right direction. Seven forces were rated as requiring improvement for leadership and force management in the last inspection period. Why is poor leadership such a persistent problem, in your view, in policing?
Andy Cooke
I do have some concerns in relation to how chiefs particularly are appointed. You know, one person makes that decision, and that's at the moment the PCC. You know, previously, before 2010, there was a Senior Appointments Panel who would draw the right people together, make sure the right field was there. Can it be right now that there's only one person applying for the chief constable's job? You have to ask the question why that is.
Can it be right that on so many occasions, the deputy chief constable becomes the chief constable because they are known, perhaps, maybe, to the person who's appointing? I, you know, there are some chiefs who'd only ever served in one force, and there's some good chiefs who've only served in one force, don't get me wrong, but that can't be a good thing, because that's the only operating environment they know, that's the only organisation they know. How do they learn? How do they know how things can be done differently? So, there is a real issue about appointment of senior officers.
I do have, and I've stated my concerns previously in relation to the small fields that are going for these jobs, and the lack of incentive for people to actually apply for the jobs when they believe that the homegrown candidate is going to be successful.
Robbie Moore
Do you think, obviously the government have laid out plans for changing the structure of, you know, PCCs are going. Do you think that will have an impact on the recruitment process for senior leadership, or for the chief constable? Or is it more than just replacing the structure of who's
Andy Cooke
Well, I think the White Paper says is that they intend to introduce the Senior Appointments Panel chaired by the Chief Inspector of Constabulary, which doesn't make it infallible, but it will also have people from the college, local government involved as well to make sure that the right field has been drawn together for the right reasons for any particular role. So, putting that national approach back onto choosing a chief constable, I think is the right thing. You know, it should be the decision at the end of the day locally, but the field should be the right field and it should be open to scrutiny in relation to who's chosen. And, you know, whoever chooses that chief should be available to be asked, well, why that person, as opposed to just one person being that the judge and jury.
Robbie Moore
And also, and just in terms of those that are coming through to those leadership positions, what, if anything, do you feel needs to be changed in terms of the support, the training, the assistance given to those that are moving their way up through the hierarchy to be able to get to the ability of effectively going for the top job as being chief constable?
What, if anything, needs to change to support that progression?
Andy Cooke
You know policing hasn't been great at identifying people who've got the promise to become chief officers. It's quite often promotion in some parts is based upon how good you are at the job you're doing as opposed to the job that you will be doing. That's the same as many other industries, I know. I do note in the leadership commission, they talk very much about how they can bring people through from those ranks so to have a leadership academy as part of the college or as part of policing, which I'm very much in favour of, something just focusing directly on identifying those people who are younger in service who may one day be future leaders.
So I'm fully supportive of that. I'm less supportive of direct entry at superintendent level from the leadership commission's report. I think we've tried that before and I don't see any great success from it. I can point to one or two people who've done well, but there were an awful lot more people than that haven't done as well as perhaps would have been expected, and it was a very expensive approach to take.
So developing those people within policing I think is important, giving those people who are in policing at the senior levels, not just chief level, but superintendent, chief inspector, opportunities to go and work outside of policing for 12 months in other parts of industry, third sector, wherever, to get a different perspective on life. I would very much be supportive of.
Karen Bradley
Can I just ask, one of the things we hear quite often is around training and with comparison of the number of weeks of training that's given to senior police officers compared to the military. Do you have any comments on Yeah. I mean
Andy Cooke
you can become a chief and only have done about nine months' worth of training in total. I mean it's just not right. The college, I mean, Sir Andy Marsh, my replacement, who was in charge of the college, I mean, he would forever try to get more training done, but for chiefs, it's difficult because you have to release people, things don't stand still for you. I mean, the armed forces, example, for the armed forces,
they're not always in combat. For police officers, every day there's challenges going on that they need to address, so they don't get that much time. But the training's got to be better. And it's got to be better from an earlier time in the career, as well, not just from the 10 weeks you do to become a chief constable or to become a chief officer.
Speaker 15
It's got to be right through the career. It's got to be tailored towards what is required to make a successful police leader. And policing maybe needs to look outside of policing for assistance in relation to that to other people who've done it well. Thank you. And just it's this particular bugbear of mine, but the role policing plays in dealing with people in mental health crises.
Karen Bradley
And I will pay tribute to Merseyside when I did the job as minister, Merseyside was the exemplar for having health-based places of safety rather than putting people into police cells, which is absolutely the right thing to do when somebody is having a mental health crisis. We don't lock somebody up with a broken arm. Why would we lock someone up with a broken mental health situation? Has that improved over the years?
Andy Cooke
Is it still something where police are spending a lot of time dealing with it? I think policing is still dealing with an awful lot of mental health issues. They are far better at it now than they used to be, I'm glad to say, but it takes an awful amount of an awful lot of police time in dealing with these issues. And police officers, I mean, if my daughter had a mental health episode, I don't want a police officer dealing with it.
It's not a policing job. So, but it's the police who are always called, because they're the ones who are always there. They're the ones who will get there.
We need to look again at how we deal with this issue, because it's not a job for police officers. They will do the best. No malice in relation to it, they will do the best they can, but they are not mental health professionals.
Karen Bradley
I mean I In my experience policing became the agency of last resort, that every other agency failed and policing was the one that always came in to pick up the pieces, spending time doing things that aren't criminal, not dealing with crime, but dealing with societal problems. And it was policing that was always brought in and it's a frustration that it still seems to be the case, 10 years on, that this is still the issue.
Andy Cooke
It is. I mean, a lot of good work was done in relation to changing how that was dealt with and the responsibilities of other parts of the organizations, the Right Person, Right Care, Right Person approach. It is. Um, but there's still too much emphasis on dealing with some of the issues there. And, you know, it's not just mental health issues.
It's missing from homes. It's children are absent from care. It's dealing with some of the care homes across the They take up so much of policing's time, because the first thing is to phone the police. Yeah, they have got to have some parental responsibility for these people they are looking after, not for the police to do.
Karen Bradley
Missing people is the thing that has frustrated me more than anything else over the years, the inability of this to be treated and seriously by all the agencies, and it relies on policing and it's not policing's job. But those missing children in particular, the ones who have been abused, exploited, but carrying out the crimes on County Lines, you know, this is at the hub of so many of the problems we have, and yet, no one seems able to find a way to grasp it.
Andy Cooke
No, it, you know, I used to joke when I was a young detective, or not that young, but the 5:00 social services call with a difficult problem on a Friday. You know, and you knew you're getting the call, because they're going home for the weekend. And
Karen Bradley
We're the same with a homeless person. You know, when my office gets the call on 4 4:30 on a Friday, what do we do with this one who is homeless? Where do you go apart from policing?
Andy Cooke
Correct. And you know the public want policing to be focused on the issues that they really care about. You know, and mental health issues is a really important issue, but it's not for the police. The absent from care issues shouldn't be for the police. Missing from home is on occasion are because of the urgency to find someone, etc., etc.
But it shouldn't be the long-term responsibility of the police to do it.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you, Chair. Sir Andy, you kind of already answered part of my question. My question to come back to you initially was do you support direct entry, which you've already kind of mentioned. Do you agree, though, that and could you maybe elaborate a little bit if you do that in many careers, a headteacher of a school would be a teacher, a senior consultant in medical would have been a doctor, junior doctor, whatever, done all the training? We're talking about policing, which is quite important, they protect us, we know that, and if you're going to be the chief constable of a police force, you should have at least had some experience of frontline policing of all parts of policing, so CID, investigating crime, traffic, firearms.
They were making life and death situations decisions sometimes. Do you agree that there should be at least a minimum term of frontline policing before?
Andy Cooke
Absolutely. Look, I mean I'm one of the few exceptions in policing, I was a slow learner, I was a constable for 11 years before I got promoted, and I got promoted really quickly after that. That time that I spent on the front line makes a massive difference for how you deal with issues moving forward and your understanding of issues moving forward. People always equate, you know, direct entry in policing to direct entry in the military. We're talking right here direct entry to superintendent.
There's no direct entry to colonel in the military. You know, so why would you think it's going to work in policing? Why do you think those people will get the respect that they need of the frontline officers who know that they haven't done it in policing? It's so much harder for them. There have been one or two exceptions who've done well, I accept that.
But that's the exception that proves the rule as opposed to being the right thing to do moving forward in my opinion. Now, the current Chief Inspector may have a difference of opinion. I'm giving a personal opinion on this.
Well in my 41 years of experience dealing with policing, you cannot beat that understanding your operating environment. Having seen some of the difficulties that people who you are looking after go through on a daily basis, some of the worst situations that you can't unsee going through that career. If you haven't seen that, how can you properly understand what it's like to actually be in charge of the thousands of police officers and police staff?
Peter Richard Prinsley
Thank you. So, the other place where the lights are always on of course is the accident and emergency department, so it's either the police or the hospital, those are the two places where people go. So we've learned in an earlier session that large a relatively large number of chief constables are not at work, they're suspended for one reason or another, I think it was eight or nine out of 42, but that might be wrong, but anyway it seemed like a very large number. So, I mean if that were the case say in a surgical department in the hospitals, that would be a massive great problem. So, my question really is are we really asking too much of chief constables?
Have we created a situation in which we've asked them to do something which is impossible?
Andy Cooke
No. No, now look, it's a tough job being a chief constable, I mean you know in your local area you're probably the one individual with the most power in that area, you know, and include mayors and others because you've got the power of liberty of people, etcetera. It's a real responsibility being in that position. But it's not asking too much. It's a thankless task on occasion, because you have 24-hour surveillance on police officers these days.
You've got, you know, the 24-hour media. It really is a difficult environment to work in, and mistakes will get made. Well, it's not an impossible job. Yeah, even the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police who's got the toughest job undoubtedly, it's not an impossible job. I mean whether not many individuals come out of that job with the reputations as 100% as they were when they went in.
But if they do it right, if they have the right intention, if they set the right standards, and bear in mind the chief is there to set the standards, so that many chiefs suspended at one time raises a question, yeah? And I'll go back to who appointed the chief in the first place, is one of the questions that needs to be asked. I'm not saying they're all wrong, or they're all guilty of what they've what's been alleged in relation to them, but that is by far the most I've ever known of chief officers being suspended at one time. Some of them would have done nothing wrong, I'm very keen to make that clear, yeah, and that they're just allegations. Well, it doesn't put policing in a good light when those who set the standard are those who are under investigation.
Peter Richard Prinsley
It was certainly one of the most striking statistics that we heard I think in much of the conversations we've had about this.
Andy Cooke
Disappointing. You know, and let me also say as well, I know of at least one occasion, maybe more, where the chief has been suspended and should never have been suspended in the first place. But that's a difference issue.
Ben Maguire
Thanks, Chair, and thanks Sir Andy for coming in today and sharing your expertise with us. Do you think the Police Leadership Commission has made effective recommendations to address the shortcomings in police leadership?
Andy Cooke
I do, across the board, yes. I mean, I had the opportunity to speak to Lord Herbert and Lord Blunkett as part of that. As I mentioned, I don't necessarily agree with every single recommendation they've made, but I think they're absolutely right, there needs to be a change. There needs to be a positive change in relation to leadership not just a chief officer level, but right through policing.
The Leadership Academy undoubtedly is the right thing to do. Identifying that talent at a far earlier time is absolutely the right thing to do. So across the board, yes, I'm supportive of what they are trying to achieve. I know the College of Policing will be following up in relation to that. I agree with the senior constable issue as well, which is one of the issues that they put forward, that there should be a senior constable rank to reflect better those who want to stay doing that front-line job, but don't want to, you know, go any further.
Other countries it works, and I think Australia is one place where they do that. So overall, yes, I am supportive of the general thrust of what the Leadership Commission has proposed. I hope policing continues to follow through with 90% of it.
Ben Maguire
I've got a case study from my own force of Devon and Cornwall, and following on from Peter Princely's point about suspended chief constables, we've currently got two suspended chief constables still on full pay. And I completely agree with your point about the person appointing the chief constable, and it's interesting what you say about just one person versus the previous system with the panel. We've just heard that nine women were paid compensation by Devon and Cornwall last week over police abuse claims, including rape, assault and coercive control not being taken seriously at the time, with complaints being ignored. One of the questions I had here to ask you was about misconduct of individual police officers.
Is this about individual officers, or is it, as we've just been talking about, a serious issue of police leadership? And this is obviously just one example, one force, but the Casey review of course pointed to similar issues in the Met.
Andy Cooke
Whether you look at the Casey review, the Angiolini review, the reviews that we've done, you know, we have found bad culture across policing and fire and rescue on a number of occasions. That can't be denied or hidden. I won't look at an individual force, you know, the current chief constable of Devon and Cornwall I've got a lot of respect for.
I think he's a very good chief. He might not have been dealt the best hand in life, but he's got he's certainly a decent man. Leadership does come into it, undoubtedly, because the leaders should set the standard, absolutely. Recruitment and recruiting the right people comes into it. Vetting is a massive part of that, and not just vetting for new officers coming in, but continued vetting for officers across the board.
And when either corruption or particularly bad behavior is identified, how quickly you remove those people, and how you publicize removing those people, too. I think I saw a figure recently that more officers than in the recent past have been sacked from policing over the last two years, and that's absolutely quite right. Policing needs to do its dirty washing in public. It needs to show that they're getting rid of these individuals who besmirch the 98% of officers who, bravely, on a daily basis, do a fantastic job on our behalf.
And I've got no doubts about that at all, but the those small number of people besmirch the whole reputation of policing. So it is incumbent upon chief officers, chief constables particularly, to maintain the highest standards, to use whatever means necessary to rouse out those who let policing and the public down in such a disgusting way as we've seen, and for other officers also to identify these people within their midst because, you know, I don't know the detail behind the Devon and Cornwall case you've just mentioned, unfortunately, but it gives a terrible impression of policing when issues like this come out.
Ben Maguire
And I completely agree there are fantastic officers that do lots of good work every day and it's not to in any way take away from that. And that was just one example where the forces had that specific problem, just to illustrate that issue, and particularly following Casey Review in the Met Police, it's clearly not just a Devon and Cornwall issue. Well, it's--
Andy Cooke
Listen, that you will find you will find bad culture across every organisation in this country, not just police and fire. You'll always find elements of bad culture. It's how well the leadership deals with that, and how quickly it deals with that, is so important before it spreads wider.
Ben Maguire
You mentioned about strengthening vetting procedures, so I'd be keen to hear your views on that, but we also hear credit, as you say, to James Vaughan, the new Chief Constable, for apologising for this and taking action, but we often hear action will be taken. What, in your view, needs to happen so that actions not just taken in the heat of the moment, but then also reviewed and followed up on further down the line to make sure none of this ever happens again?
Andy Cooke
No, absolutely. I mean, squaring that circle to make sure that learning is actually learnt, because you do hear an awful lot of people saying, you know, "We will learn from this." I think we've heard it quite recently. Part of the role of the inspectorate is to see if they have learned those lessons moving forward. And my ex-colleagues, I know, are like a dog with a bone at doing so on occasion, to see if that learning has actually happened.
But not just in that force, it's incumbent upon policing as a national body of 43 chiefs to learn from each other as well. So, it's no good if the lessons learned in Devon and Cornwall and it isn't learned in the West Midlands, for instance. So, and policing isn't very good at that, because what policing is a-- Policing is a world leader in many things. It's also a world leader in organisational arrogance, yeah?
It's the Hampshire way of doing it, or the West Midlands way of doing it. There's always a better way, if you're prepared to look for it, and that's what policing doesn't do enough of.
Ben Maguire
Right, thanks for that. And just following on from that, what do you see as the role of the IOPC in this landscape, and how effectively do you feel it's currently being performed?
Andy Cooke
I think we've seen a distinct improvement in how the IOPC performs over the last couple of years. Rachel Watson, the Director General of the IOPC, I think, is doing exactly the right things to improve that organisation, and improve the way it deals with police officer misconduct. It won't get it right all the time, but it's definitely improving. It's not there yet, it's unfinished business, but I think we see definite improvements in relation to that. The accountability review that Dame Lynne Owens is doing with Jason Beer will shed more light on that, exactly how the best way to proceed in relation to that is, and that hasn't reported yet, so--.
Ben Maguire
And the next question I have was the performance and efficiency of the Professional Standards Department in dealing with complaints, and I've had at least two or three constituent cases that have taken, in some cases, years to get a response to their complaint, and often the homework is being marked by the colleagues of the policeman or woman who the complaint has been made about. And there's been some talk about perhaps getting other forces from other parts of the country to actually look at the complaint independently, because of course before it even gets to the IOPC, that process has to be followed through, and some kind of wrongdoing has to be found. And particularly in that case I referenced earlier, with the nine female victims, complaints were ignored, and in some cases counter-allegations were made and they were arrested. I'd be quite interested to hear from you what can be done to improve that complaints process, make it more independent?
Andy Cooke
in inspections that we did you know quite clear that at times some inspections took far too long in relation to who should investigate the complaint. Members of the public will say that the police complaints are too soft, police officers will say it's too hard, yeah, and it's too draconian. The regulation
Ben Maguire
That is the heart of it, isn't it? It's the independence part of it is the key.
Andy Cooke
I mean as a chief I did give other forces investigations on my behalf depending on what they were and you find that does happen with the more serious investigations. Yeah. Rather than investigate yourself you'll ask another force to do it. So that does happen, but you know, the best person to investigate a corrupt cop in my view is a cop,
yeah, because they know exactly what they should and shouldn't be doing. And I've worked with some absolutely outstanding anti-corruption police officers in my time, absolutely outstanding, who would go to the nth degree when they knew something was wrong to actually get these people out and get them to prison on occasion. So you know, I can't speak for every PSD across the country, but generally they play exactly by the rules. They take too long on occasion to actually get to the conclusion they need to get to.
At times things could be dealt with differently than going through a full formal investigation process, but they are doing the best in difficult circumstances. And I've got a good degree of confidence in relation to it. Again, it's unfinished business, it's work to be done to make it better, and I think once the accountability review does actually report on its findings, once the IOPC continues to improve the way that it does its own business as it is doing, I think things will start to improve.
Ben Maguire
I mean to press you on that independence point, and you said that some complainants think it's too soft, some police feel it's too harsh. Wouldn't it just make it so much more straightforward and fair if it was a completely independent, outside person? We all know we have our own biases when we're for example investigating colleagues and things like that, even with the very best will in the world. Would it not make more sense just to make it completely independent and then you don't have those two sides conflicting with each other?
Andy Cooke
Who would do it would be my first question. I know who I want to investigate a cop and that's another experienced cop, because they know how to investigate properly. But from a different area, so they're not actually working day-to-day with each other. There would be an awful lot of cross flow of officers back and forth, would be a very expensive way of doing it. Would it work?
Not for every complaint. For the more serious complaints, would it work? It could work. So I'm not saying it's the wrong idea. It does happen on occasion.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you. Turning to the reforms in the white paper that we've discussed, which aspects of the proposed reforms do you think in your opinion will make the biggest difference to the effectiveness of policing?
Andy Cooke
I think if you just take parts of the reform white paper and just pick bits out, I think it would be less effective than if you take the vast majority of it and use that as part of reform. Reduction in forces, I think, is essential. I know there's been numbers bandied around in relation to that, but I think this will be a really missed opportunity to actually professionalize policing to the nth degree if we don't take up the opportunity to reduce the number of forces we have. Forty-three forces in this country is too many.
Some of the forces are too small to exist. They can't do anything that should that is needed to be done in a modern day. Policing is no longer local like it was previously. A lot of it is regional, national and international, as we've seen with, excuse me, some of the fraud issues. Many of the changes are a years and some decades overdue.
It was a great model for that 1964, '65, whenever it was when it was implemented.
It's not a great model anymore. The amount of public money that is being wasted in relation to procurement, in relation to IT, in relation to, wants to do things one particular way because the way they feel is the right way to do it with no evidence based to support that, surely those days have gone. And we need to have some direction in relation to police forces across the country. That makes them more effective, and certainly more efficient, than they are now.
I obviously welcome the new powers for the inspector that is passed the reform, as you'd expect, because I've pushed hard for them over a number of years. I fully agree that the Home Secretary and the Home Office should have a greater say in policing. You've got to balance that with operational independence, but it's operational independence, not organizational independence, and I think chiefs themselves get confused about that sometimes. Looking again at the peo- at the police funding formula is absolutely the right thing to do. I think the trick, in relation to making this acceptable across the country, is to make sure that the local policing areas are the right local policing areas, with the right governance over them,
that reassures people that their policing is still local. What you do not need 43 headquarters in a country this size. Yet, no other company would have 43 headquarters, to fi- fi- for doing the same job, or what should be the same job, across a country this size. But you do need that very clear approach to local policing.
So, for me, the key to cracking this is the local policing area approach, making sure that is right, making sure the governance over that is right. Well, for national issues, the Home Secretary should have a far bigger say in what policing does, how it works together. Let me give you a quick example in relation to that. Disorder, the disorder of a couple of years ago, the inspection we did in relation to that.
One of the recommendations in the white paper is for a national coordinator in relations to disorder. Because we went into detail about how quickly police mobilized, the intelligence behind how they mobilized, et cetera. There is no one person in this country who can say, "Policing, you must do this." The national police service will give us that. They will be able to say, "For issues of national importance, we will work together like this, and this is what we are going to do."
Not having an individual chief constable derogating from decisions, because on the National Police Chiefs' Council rules, if a chief doesn't like it, they can derogate from the decision, they don't have to do it. That is not how you deal with some of the serious issues that we have in this country at this time. And those issues aren't going to get better. They're always going to be challenges for us. Now is the time to actually professionalize our police service in the right way.
And for me, this is how we do it.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Thank you. And so you've touched on some of the risks there that you feel. What about the timescales and timeframes? How soon do you think that the key benefits of the paper, if the majority, as you say, is left as it is, could be realized?
Andy Cooke
Yeah. Difficult to give a timescale, isn't it, but I think if we delay, nothing will happen. I think a decision needs to be made by the government to actually go ahead with this or not. If they don't, I think it's a massive mistake, I'll be honest. Well, they need to if they're going to go ahead with it, they need to find the right finance to actually get it moving, to get the national police service in place,
to start saving the long massive long-term savings that there will be through bringing procurement, ITC, T, the NCA into one place together. To actually reducing the number of police forces that we have, because that will, on the you know, I have no doubt that would improve the way that police are delivered in this country. And it will save a fortune. And that money can be redirected into keeping our citizens even safer, and it's crying out for that.
Policing can't carry on as it is at the moment. And any delay in decision making for this white paper on reform, I think, is a massive missed opportunity.
Adrian Matthew Bishop
Okay, thank you. And my last question would be, given the pressures that we've discussed today, and you've talked about, and not any potential issues in policing, how difficult, or easy, do you think it's going to be to realize these benefits, bearing in mind some of the serious concerns that have been raised today?
Andy Cooke
It takes the will. Let me give an example. This police reform white paper, I mean, the system leaders in policing are fully behind it. I was fully behind it. This change was needed.
It's the first time I can recall in my policing service that the head of the Metropolitan Police, the head of the college, the head of the Inspectorate, the head of the NCA, the head of the IOPC, were all agreed on what needed to be done to improve policing. Now, the amount of years of expertise that sit behind that, surely that is a good judge of character that something needs to change. The only thing that will prevent it changing is localism. And it's misplaced localism because, by adopting that localist approach, you are not going to keep your local community safer. You're just going to waste more money, be less effective, be more inefficient, and you won't have the benefits of better IT systems, better procurement approaches, and a National Crime Agency and counter-terrorism approach that works hand in hand, dealing with some of the same sort of issues at the same time.
So, I just think it's a massive win for this country to take this forward, and take this forward as soon as possible.
Karen Bradley
I'm, you probably are not surprised, I'm slightly sceptical, representing a constituency that's a bound a border area. I mean, I'm bound My boundaries are Cheshire and Derbyshire, so I'm West Midlands, but they're East Midlands and North West, and I'm quite a long way from the centre of the West Midlands. So, I do worry about that, and my ex- the example of what happened with Staffordshire ambulance service going into West Midlands Ambulance Service is not a happy story from the point of view of my constituents. So, a lot of work is going to be needed to sell this one to me, so I will
Andy Cooke
And dame Karen, I agree, and I think that's why it's crucial that the focus is really on those local policing areas and the powers they have to deliver what needs to be done for local people, while leading the national to a national approach.
Karen Bradley
And I But I think national police force, I think, is the right approach, so, and I think this is something that, probably, has been evolving over time with the creation of National Crime Agency and others, that there has been this move towards that. So, I don't disagree with the national police force. It is, as I say, my cynicism is about my constituency and how it might work, but Paul Kohler might have equal cynicism. I'd never know with Paul.
Paul Kohler
He's not. He's not. They've asked my questions, really, but let me quiz you a bit harder because could you not address the issues of procurement and IT by giving less autonomy to these individual police forces? Because part of the problem, the systems they don't talk to each other. You could deal with that by actually mandating the systems they use.
So, could you maintain the local whilst addressing the problems of procurement and IT by simply taking that from them?
Andy Cooke
Look, yes, basically, yes. There's different approaches that could be taken. You could mandate. Governments consistently have been reluctant to mandate on policing, yeah? I've asked on occasion for governments, for home secretaries, for police ministers to mandate on certain issues to improve policing before, and they are very reluctant to do so, for whatever reason that is.
There are different approach that could be taken. I was on the advisory board for Lord Bernard Hogan-Howe when he was drawing together this reference. I've seen the work that's gone into this, the testing of different approaches in relation to what can work, what won't work, what is the what has the best chance of working, and that's why I've got the faith in what he's put forward in relation to this. So, other things can work.
You know, it's not a one size fits all, but I do think this is a great fit for policing in England and Wales.
Paul Kohler
And how will you address that concern? Because the Scottish example is that it was success on many levels, but at the local level, there was that tendency between local and regional or local and national in that context. So how do you actually address the local? What would you be doing? I don't It has got to be addressed.
How? How?
Andy Cooke
I think very strong local policing areas, with a chief superintendent or similar who is in charge of that area and has a good deal of autonomy to deal with the local issues as they find them, with a good governance, which involves local mayor, local council, local policing board, whichever it is, for that local policing area. Now, the trick is obviously you're going to have governance there, governance at that force level, governance nationally. It's about making sure that they are complementary and they're not working against each other in relation to it. I don't think it's beyond the wit of policy makers to achieve that, but I do think it's exceptionally important that people do feel that local policing is there for them. You don't need a headquarters, you know, round the corner.
You really don't. I mean, you know, someone who's inhabited headquarters for as short a time as I possibly could, you really don't need them. The work is done on the front line. The difference is made on the front line, yeah? And those chief superintendents and those borough commanders, whatever you want to call them, are the ones who can really make a difference for that local area, without excessive interference from headquarters.
Paul Kohler
Well, I must say, I was persuaded by the arguments, but then I was petitioned by the City of London, who were very concerned about losing their City of London Police force, saying that has a specialist force that cannot just be absorbed into the Met. What would your view be on that?
Andy Cooke
Right, that's a good question. Look, the City of London is an historic police force. It's well supported by the city itself. It's always had that bit of autonomy, that bit of additional funding for various reasons, and they are very proud as a police force, even though it is a very small police force and very different from most other police forces because of the low residents, etc., etc. Part of me says it should continue.
Part of me says, under a new world, can you justify its continuation? So, I'm opting out of the answer.
Paul Kohler
Oh, straight to that? Oh yes, indeed. You talk You've talked about technology, and I think that the figure is 97% of police money spent on IT systems, on legacy systems, is quite extraordinary. Your um Your successor, when he came before us, said, "I want to be absolutely clear with the committee, policing is barely in the foothole foothills of data insights." Would you agree with that?
Andy Cooke
Absolutely agree with it. I mean, policing does have a lot of data, but doesn't use it very well, what it does have. It doesn't have it to hand. The systems that policing uses to collate that data and to make it available for the individual who needs it are far too complex. Policing has been romanced into buying various, different computer systems over the years which layer on layer.
That is not the answer. The answer is to start again and look what really police officers on the front line need to do the right job, what commanders need to understand what's happening in their area. And, overall, policing doesn't have that. So, policing does need to invest quite significantly in new technology that will make a difference, and not just layer on top of the current technology that they have. I mean, a great example, the Police National Computer is nearly as old as me, I think.
I mean, that's ridiculous. In this day and age, we need to actually look at how policing can better deliver for the citizens of this country and have the tools at the fingertips to do so. It's complex enough, investigations complex enough, now crime has increased in complexity. The amount of data that's coming in is incredible, and policing are at the very I agree the foothills of this, but they don't have the finance to do it differently, and they can't just ditch the legacy systems they have, so it will require finance to make a difference.
Paul Kohler
A question we explored with Sir Andy was that he was telling us that in Avon and Somerset in 2017 he was federating data, and with great success. Why did that learning not get absorbed by the police service more generally?
Andy Cooke
I'll take you back to what I said before about the sometimes the arrogance of different forces in relation to what they think they need. Sometimes they're tied into long contracts, which means they can't pick up something new that comes through. IT companies are very keen to sell to policing. There's 43 customers there, all who want slightly different things, and it's a great pot. I mean, when we have a national police service, there'll be one person to purchase from, which gives you far better ability to adjust the prices that have been talked about that we've seen.
Some of the prices of some of the police IT has been, I think, ridiculous. Some of the things that have been bought so when you've got amateurs buying equipment here that is with them for a long time, it's not actually improving the safety of citizens or the ease of the police officers to do their jobs themselves for many reasons which I won't go into at the moment. But there's an awful long way for policing to go in relation to it. Andy in 2017 was, I'm sure, doing some good work in Avon and Somerset. I mean, I was chief in Merseyside at the time.
I didn't know what work Andy was doing in Somerset. is one of the reasons. But technology's moved on so quickly, what Andy was doing in 2017 isn't going to make a difference now. We need to look differently at start from the bottom, work right through what police officers do, and what IT can we introduce, how can we employ the right AI, how can we bring in the right robotics that allows police officers to get back on their patches for 80% of the time and not the 13% of the time that they're doing at the moment. That's where you start, because police officers nowadays, to a great extent, are purely data-imputers.
They spend too long tapping away at keyboards, double-keying, treble-keying, 15-keying on occasions to try and get the right information. That is not 2026.
Paul Kohler
Indeed not. The issues are the same. There are now perhaps new software providers offering solutions. Again, good, bad, indifferent, we don't know. Do you have any views on the Palantir saga with the Met?
Andy Cooke
If I can if I can recuse myself on that question, because one of my roles now is working for a AI start-up. So, it would be wrong of me to comment. Okay.
Paul Kohler
Let me try and say if it's inappropriate for you to answer. We saw this committee saw how AI was misused in the Tel Aviv Maccabi affair, and there's a real temptation, and we all have it, where we use AI as a shortcut. Is that an issue for policing? How is policing going to address that issue?
Andy Cooke
Yeah, look, for the start, my view has always been there needs to be a human in the loop in relation to it, but you can't trust everything that comes off a general AI platform.
So, how do you address that for policing? How many systems are actually built for policing? The systems that come into policing have usually been developed for the health service, developed for defence, etc., etc. They've never been specifically built for policing. Maybe that's something that we should start on, and look at actually what policing needs as opposed to what can be fitted in to slightly improve the half percent in relation to policing. Well, it would be wrong for me to say any more about that.
Karen Bradley
Can I just check in terms of use of technology, so facial recognition, number, all the different things. I mean, are you confident that there's a statutory underpinning that gives confidence to law enforcement to use this technology?
Andy Cooke
I think it's important that there is an underpinning statutory underpinning of what policing does, because you know, some of these issues make the public feel uncomfortable. So policing needs to properly explain what they're doing, why they're doing it, and the results of what they're doing in relation to it. I mean, I think there's, at times, a lot of misinformation around the likes of facial recognition. I mean, these images aren't kept. It's not that there's a big store of people's faces somewhere, you know, because that just doesn't happen.
But it should, the computer alone, be able to say, "Yes, that's the person"? No, it needs a human in the loop. So, on a facial recognition identification, if I was a cop, would I arrest someone on it? It would give me cause to say, "I want to make more inquiries in relation to you before I take the next steps." No.
Karen Bradley
That's the same with AI, isn't it? That you need that person that's going to have to apply judgement and that was the thing that was missing, it seemed from our experiences previously. Is there anything else you want to say to the committee as your final moment before retirement takes you away from appearing in front of select committees?
Andy Cooke
My wife disagrees that I'm in retirement. I'm thinking I'm working more than before, but. One thing I will say and I mean this from the heart. Please support your police officers, who 99% of the time get it right, are doing a thankless task in sometimes impossible circumstances. Sometimes they're well led, sometimes they're not, but those cops actually make a difference and, you know, I've been so proud in my 41 years association with policing.
Some of the compassion I've seen, some of the bravery, some of the professionalism, has taken my breath away, and continues to do so. And it doesn't matter if it was cops 41 years ago or cops who are just joining now, they all deserve the same respect for what they do, and they're doing it on our behalf, and they're doing things that most of us wouldn't even dream of doing. So, I think that's all I'd like to say in relation to it. Please support the police.
Karen Bradley
Thank you very much. I look forward to thanking my officers when I see them on Sunday at remembrance events, which I know we will have many as I'm sure other colleagues will. But thank you, Sir Andy, for your time. Thank you for giving us the reflections you've given us. We will use them to scrutinise your successor, but also scrutinise the work of police reform and other matters as we go through our work over this Parliament.
So, I will bring this to a close. Order.