House of Lords

17 September 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
03:21 - 05:16
Speaker 1
Charles the Third.  By the grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of our other realms and territories King.  Head of the Commonwealth.  Defender of the Faith. 

To all Lords Spiritual and Temporal and all other Our subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, Greeting.  Know ye that We of Our especial grace, certain knowledge and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf Us enabling, do by these presents advance, create and prefer Our trusty and well-beloved Sir Christopher Stephen Wormald, Knight Commander of Our Most Honourable Order of the Bath, to the state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Wormald, of Dulwich in Our London Borough of Lambeth.  And for Us, Our heirs and successors, do appoint, give and grant unto him the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title and honour of Baron Wormald, to have and to hold unto him for his life.  Willing and by these presents granting, for Us, Our heirs and successors, that he may have, hold and possess a seat, place and voice in the Parliaments and Public Assemblies and Councils of Us, Our heirs and successors, within Our United Kingdom amongst the Barons.  And also that he may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities and advantages to the degree of a Baron duly and of right belonging, which Barons of Our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed, or as they do at present use and enjoy. 

In witness whereof We have caused these Our Letters to be made Patent.  Witness Ourself at Westminster, in the forenoon of the twenty-seventh day of August in the fourth year of Our Reign.  By Warrant under the King's Sign Manual. 
05:16 - 05:16
I, Christopher Lord Wormald, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law. 
08:26 - 10:17
Speaker 1
Charles the Third, by the Grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of our other realms and territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith.  To all lords spiritual and temporal and all our other subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we of our especial grace, certain knowledge and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create and prefer our trusty and well-beloved David James McCobb to the state, degree, style, dignity, title and honor of Baron McCobb of Kingston upon Hull in our East Riding of Yorkshire.  And for us, our heirs and successors, to appoint, give and grant unto him the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title and honor of Baron McCobb, to have and to hold unto him for his life.  Willing and by these presents granting, for us, our heirs and successors, that he may have, hold and possess a seat, place and voice in the Parliaments and public assemblies and councils of us, our heirs and successors, within our United Kingdom amongst the barons. 

And also that he may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities and advantages to the degree of a baron duly and of right belonging, which barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed or as they do at present use and enjoy.  In witness whereof we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourselves at Westminster in the afternoon of the third day of September in the fourth year of our reign.  By warrant under the King's sign manual. 
10:17 - 10:17
I, David, Lord McCobb, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law. 
12:35 - 12:42
Speaker 2
The next oral question, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale. 
12:42 - 13:21
Sue Hayman
Lab Member of the House of Lords
Member of the House of Lords | Lords
Sue Hayman
I beg leave to ask the question standing in the name of my noble friend.  My Lords, the process for determining the UK G20 presidency objectives is underway.  Next year's presidency is a valuable opportunity to demonstrate effective UK international leadership and reinforce global economic stability, which is essential for working people in the UK.  In the near term, our focus is on engaging with the US G20 presidency ahead of the Miami summit in December.  In line with standard practice, we will communicate our objectives following the Miami summit. 
13:21 - 13:35
Lab Member of the House of Lords
Member of the House of Lords | Lords
Dianne Hayter
I thank my noble friend for her answer on this.  Could I ask the noble lady to say what in particular we will be looking at about the rights of women and their needs as we go forward? 

13:35 - 14:02

Sue Hayman

The UK is very committed to the rights of women and to addressing this issue on an international level. However, the process for determining the UK G20 presidency policy agenda is currently underway. In the near term, our focus is on engaging with the US G20 presidency ahead of the Miami summit in December. In line with the standard practice, we will communicate our policy priorities following the Miami summit.

14:02 - 14:30

Speaker 10

Can the noble lady the minister tell us what progress the government is aiming to secure at the G20 summit on tackling international fraud and in particular bringing greater transparency over really over who really owns and benefits from offshore companies, especially in the light of the decision of the Cayman Islands and the Turks and Caicos Islands to implement only a legitimate interest rather than a full public access register of beneficial interests?

14:30 - 14:46

Sue Hayman

I'm pleased to report that Lord Hanson is leading a summit on this issue. I'm happy to write with further details to the noble lord.

14:46 - 15:08

David Alton

My Lords, could the baroness tell us what priority will be given to the nearly 120 million people who are displaced in the world today during the G20 summit and in particular whether or not the war in Sudan, which has led itself to another 12 million displaced people, will be discussed there?

15:08 - 15:18

Sue Hayman

The government our government is doing as much as we can on the issue the noble lord raises. It's been a priority of this government since we came into office.

15:18 - 15:54

Mark Harper

My Lords, I've heard the message from the minister that she's not going to is not able to tell us what is going to be on the government's list of priorities.

So can I just make a suggestion and all I'm asking is that she'll at least say she'll go away and consider it. Given the leadership we've demonstrated since 2023 on artificial intelligence and the respect globally that the AI Security Institute has, can I urge her that this would be a great opportunity for the UK to show international leadership on regulating AI globally and urge her to think about that as we put our policy objectives together.

15:54 - 16:18

Sue Hayman

I'm very happy to take the noble Lord's suggestion away, as the noble Lord will be aware from the debate we had on this earlier in the week, the UK is already demonstrating international leadership on this issue and I think we're considering all policy areas, particularly those on which we can show considerable international leadership.

16:18 - 16:27

Speaker 4

My Lords, Lord Campbell-Savours is taking part remotely. I invite Lord Campbell-Savours to speak.

16:27 - 17:12

Dale Campbell-Savours

My Lord, with the whole G20 economic agenda being overshadowed by the prospect of escalating conflict worldwide, are we not uniquely placed with our Foreign Office's substantial hinterland of expertise in diplomacy to help reduce turmoil in the world by acting as brokers in the resolution of conflict? So why not develop as an objective a new peace agenda? We could start with at least considering proposals as set out on Tuesday during the statement on the Ukraine. Let the Labour government lead the way on these matters.

17:12 - 17:32

Sue Hayman

My noble friend will not be surprised to hear me say that we continue to steadfastly condemn Russia's war aggression against Ukraine. We continue in relation to peace across the globe to work through international forums such as the UN in terms of agendas around peace.

17:32 - 17:47

Speaker 14

Climate change is a world problem. Where is that going to stand on the agenda, or is it in fact hopefully going to be threaded through virtually every topic as it affects every area of our life and security going forward?

17:47 - 18:12

Sue Hayman

I'd agree with the noble lady that the issues relating to climate change should be threaded through all our discussions on an international scale. I'm happy to feed that back with other issues noble Lords wish to wish in terms of the policy agendas that are currently being worked through and will report back on the overall presidency policy agenda in due course.

18:12 - 18:26

Speaker 9

Would the noble lady agree that the UK presidency of the G20 is a historic opportunity for action on debt and will she consider the call to champion changes to the common framework laid out in the African Union's common position on debt?

18:26 - 18:41

Sue Hayman

The UK has already got an existing ask of other countries in relation to strengthening the G20 common framework. I will feed back the suggestion as with other suggestions from noble Lords.

18:41 - 19:11

Jeremy Purvis

Further to noble Lord Alton's question, the world's greatest humanitarian crisis in Sudan was not mentioned in the government setting the agenda for the G20 presidency. But surely, as the UN Security Council penholder for the world's worst humanitarian crisis, we will be raising this. So what are our ambitions for the G20 presidency for that crisis?

19:11 - 19:43

Sue Hayman

The UK has displayed its our ambitions in relation to this in Geneva and at the UN. With apologies to your Lordships' House for me not being able to say what is exactly going to be on the agenda for the UK G20's presidency, what I would say is that we intend to use our presidency in an ambitious way, however specific policy and operational details remain under active review and I look forward to updating the House in due course.

19:42 - 19:59

Speaker 7

Does the Minister feel that our national credibility at this very important summit will be greatly enhanced if by then we will have reached the promised 3% defense target?

19:59 - 20:32

Sue Hayman

The UK has a clear target in relation to defense spending, which from memory I'm not sure that His Majesty's opposition necessarily did when they were on these benches. We continue committed to increasing defense spending along the lines that we have previously committed to and again ministers from His Majesty's government will update your Lordships' House on progress on that.

20:32 - 21:04

Speaker 12

Just around the first question that was put around women, the women's agenda, given that there has been so much rollback on women's rights, particularly in Afghanistan, would the noble lady the Minister please make sure that that's at the forefront of our able to have their wider discussions and actually do the conference that my right honorable noble friend the Prime Minister David Cameron had done when he was Prime Minister.

21:04 - 21:19

Sue Hayman

We're really committed to improving the rights of women on a global sense, on the global stage. This is an issue that's been raised at the UN General Assembly and it will be an issue that the government returns to on a regular basis.

21:19 - 22:03

Magid Magid

Does the Minister, given that sadly we've reduced our overseas development aid budget, nevertheless we still have this leadership role that we've got, so would at least the Minister consider the joining other countries to make sure that we pool our resources together to make sure that those needy places, whether it's Afghanistan, Sudan or elsewhere, and in particular Palestine, Gaza, that we do look after the most needy in the world and at least commit to in the long term returning to 0.7 because it also benefits our defense and security when we invest in overseas development aid.

22:03 - 22:25

Sue Hayman

This government is committed to the 0.7 commitment on a long-term basis when fiscal circumstances allow, will continue to work collaboratively across international partnerships to ensure that our spending is focused where it can have the greatest impact, supporting the most vulnerable and advancing our modern development approach.

22:25 - 22:44

Speaker 11

My Lords, on the 9th of September the Prime Minister said national security can't come at the expense of social security. What kind of message is that to our allies in the G20?

22:44 - 23:05

Sue Hayman

I think the noble lady has taken something completely out of context. We are committed to the G20, we are committed to increasing our defense spending and global security and will play a full part in this as a member of the G20 and through other international fora.

23:05 - 23:09

Speaker 8

Second oral question, Baroness Foster of Oxton.

23:09 - 23:18

Jacqueline Foster

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

23:18 - 26:32

David Pitt

The government's commitment to the defense of this country is absolute. We have the third highest absolute expenditure on defense amongst our allies.

We will honor our NATO commitment of 3.5% by 2035 and in direct answer to the Noble Lord Bellingham's question, we will set the target date for spending review for the 3%. We're also committed to bear down on the welfare bill, but not by arbitrarily punishing those who depend upon it. Finally, I'd like to note, and I hope the house would understand this, that these two issues are not inextricably linked. And I would note that it is a danger if politicians suggest that we need to make false choices.

My Lords, I'd like to thank the Noble Lord the Minister for his reply. But the fact is, the welfare bill is heading towards 350 billion pounds. The total income tax take last year was 330 billion pounds and with public sector debt reaching 94% by mid-2026. The last government under Sir Keir Starmer couldn't persuade his backbenchers to reduce the welfare bill by 5 billion pounds per annum. So may I ask the Noble Lord the Minister, can we assume that this Prime Minister will also continue to put social security before national security in order for his members of parliament to hang on to their parliamentary seats?

You see my Noble Lords, that is exactly the sort of false choice that we need to be guarding against. Look, we're wanting to be clear that we spend the welfare budget well. That's why we have the Tims review on PIPs. It's why we have the Milburn review on MEETS of getting a system for getting people back to work. But one if I may since it was quite a long question I'd like to tell you about is about fraud.

By the end of this parliament, this government will be saving 4.3 billion pounds on fraud in the welfare system which it inherited. I think it learned from Lord Agnew, a Conservative peer and one of my predecessors who stood at this dispatch box and said that it was arrogance, indolence and ignorance that was stopping us from bearing down on it and that he hoped that his resignation would make someone do something about it. My Lords, we are and we will.

26:32 - 27:28

Speaker 24

My Lords, can I first of all apologize to the house for sounding like a broken record, but would my Noble Friend agree with me that the bench opposite should have a bit of humility? That when in government from 2010 to 2016, they cut the defense budget by 16%, made members of our armed forces compulsory redundant which led to the smallest standing army since Napoleonic times, and in collusion with their Liberal Democrat coalition partners, delayed the implementation of the replacement of the nuclear deterrent, adding billions to cost. Does he also agree that the choice which they're putting forward between defense versus welfare is a false one and that they need to explain how they would actually get money out of the welfare budget not in the future but today to reinforce the defense budget?

27:28 - 28:04

David Pitt

I completely agree with those statements. And look, just let's recognize that in 2025, this government committed to the largest sustained increase in defense spending since the end of the Cold War, after years, as you have pointed out, of decline. I hope I'll have an opportunity to come back and talk about the welfare budget and the Conservatives' proposals for the welfare budget later on in questions, but I should allow time for that.

28:04 - 28:41

Malcolm Bruce

Isn't it unfortunate that the Conservatives, who were in no way blameless for the parlous state of our public finances, are arguing the case for defense on the basis of saying the people who should bear the burden of topping up our defense budget are the poorest, the most disabled, and the most disadvantaged? That, of course, is the Conservative Party in a nutshell. But will he recognize that the sooner the government actually delivers clearly how they're going to achieve the 3%, so that procurement can start now, the sooner we can have a sensible debate on defense priorities, on the benefit priorities?

28:41 - 29:46

David Pitt

So look, as I said, the 3% timing will be declared at the spending review. But look, I don't want to do all the criticism of other parties, actually. But I do remember a couple of weeks ago, it was the right reverend prelate, I think the Bishop of Coventry, talking about old people. And she said old people are of immeasurable worth. Everyone is of immeasurable worth.

And of course, we need to be able to talk about big numbers for defense and big numbers for welfare, but real people depend on this, and those real people are of immeasurable wealth, and I think that should inform our debate.

29:46 - 29:59

Speaker 15

How should our adversaries interpret the Treasury's defense stance?

29:59 - 30:43

David Pitt

That the government has an absolute commitment to the defense of this nation. That we already have the third highest absolute expenditure amongst our allies. That we will honor our NATO commitment of 3.5% by 2035, and we will set a target for defense at the spending review for the 3%. That in 2025, we committed to the largest sustained increase in defense spending since the end of the Cold War. That's not bad.

30:43 - 31:13

Speaker 23

My Lord, would the noble Lord the Minister agree that progress towards the 3% and 3.5% target for defense spending can best be described as glacial? Would he undertake that the Treasury would look at imaginative ways of funding defense, and in particular look at the contribution, the innovative contribution that small and medium-sized enterprises can make, and also their access to private funding? It doesn't all have to come from the Treasury, my Lords.

31:13 - 31:52

David Pitt

I think the reference to private companies and to what it is that defense spending can do for the economy is a very important one. I think if I've got my figures right, that the additional investment that we will be making, or the investment that we'll be making, will create 60,000 more jobs in the private sector. So I think we are aware of it. It is an important point.

31:47 - 31:51

Speaker 26

Thank you.

31:51 - 32:18

Speaker 30

My Lords, the best causally identified root of the rise of populist parties and extremist groups in this country is poverty alongside deindustrialization, austerity, and perceived community decline. Would the Minister, the noble Lord the Minister agree with me that the duty of government to protect its citizens includes protecting them from internal threats as well as external?

32:18 - 33:06

David Pitt

I think I've made the government's position on that reasonably clear. But let's just look at the proposal that we have, for example, on housing benefit from the opposition party to take 4 billion pounds off the private sector budget is 13 and a half, 14, something like that. Have you, have we thought about how many people that is going to make homeless? Have we thought about how many of them are then going to turn up of course with the right to be housed if they have children? Have we thought about, you can hear where I'm coming from on this.

33:06 - 33:21

Speaker 29

My Lord, has my noble friend and fellow Scotsman, could he give us a few examples of sensible savings the government is making to our welfare budget?

33:21 - 33:49

David Pitt

Yeah, I mean, I think I would, I think I would turn back to that. It's 4.3 billion that is going to be saved. It's the result of the biggest crackdown in a generation. And I would thank the noble Lord Agnew for his passion about that when he stood at this dispatch box. We are responding to his call to take action.

33:49 - 34:00

Simon Russell

Third oral question, Earl Russell.

34:00 - 34:40

Sue Hayman

My Lords, the UK Food Security Report of 2024 suggests that rising temperatures will increase the likelihood of extreme weather events, which do of course represent significant risks to UK food security. So we are investing in resilience by spending 200 million pounds up to 2030 through the Farming Innovation Programme and 65 million pounds to support farmers given recent drought conditions, including an extra 50 million pounds for sustainable farming incentive agreements for short and long-term resilience to our changing climate.

34:40 - 35:23

Simon Russell

The audit office is concerned about our food security. 2026 is on track to be our worst harvest and our five worst harvests have all been since 2020. A major El Niño event will make matters worse. Adding global conflict and we have a recipe for food inflation and possible shortages. I asked the noble Baroness the Minister, a freedom of information request reported in the Guardian found just 20 of Defra's 6,613 staff are working on climate adaptation.

Is safeguarding our food security receiving adequate consideration?

35:23 - 36:00

Sue Hayman

Well, I think when you look at where staff work, it's important to take into account that actually many staff work right across different briefs in the organization. So while people may not be specifically working on something, actually there are implications across other parts of the department which are also involved in that work.

And I have to say, you know, food security is a really critical part of the work that Defra does. And we are looking at ways we can increase resilience in in the face of of increased climate change changes.

36:00 - 36:47

Anne McIntosh

My Lords, the noble lady will be aware that the NFU say there is an urgent need for on-farm reservoirs. The noble lady has frequently stated she is in favour of on-farm reservoirs, and yet at the moment there is an inconsistency in the guidance and planning for permitted development rights. Will she urgently speak to her colleagues in the housing department to ensure that these planning guidance permit on-farm reservoirs to store the water for when it is needed by farmers and horticultural growers?

36:47 - 37:28

Sue Hayman

Well, as the noble lady so rightly says, I'm extremely supportive of on-farm reservoirs. I think they're very important, which is why we've announced funding of up to fifteen million pounds through Defra to build on-farm reservoirs as part of the drought package. And we've also offered two rounds of water management grants so far, and that's provided eight point eight million pounds of funding towards management, and that includes the construction of reservoirs. We are speaking to MHCLG on a number of planning issues because there are a number of farming issues where we need to improve planning and make it make it more reactive to to requirements.

37:28 - 38:18

Speaker 31

My Lords, in order to adapt to future climate and weather, we are going to have to develop new genetic varieties of the crops we grow, and gene editing will be a powerful tool to enable us to do this. When I recently visited the Wellesbourne research station, I saw field trials of gene-edited soya plants that will be suitable to grow in the UK. And Corteva, the company that's running these trials, were passionate about the fact that our legislation is more permissive, more proportionate, and particularly beneficial for research and development. So I ask the noble baroness the minister, when negotiations to finalise the SPS agreement are reached, can we be absolutely assured that we will protect the advantage that we have in comparison with the EU system?

38:18 - 38:54

Sue Hayman

Well, I'm sure noble lords will not be surprised to say I I can't comment on the negotiations. The negotiations are taking place at the moment ahead of the the summit, which we hope to have a date finalised soon. What I can say to the noble lord is to completely assure him that we understand the importance of this. It's been critical to to the work that we've been doing here to have that flexibility that he talks about. And we are we are discussing very seriously with the EU about how we can protect what we are doing in this country in this area.

38:54 - 39:53

Speaker 33

Remind the House of my fact that I'm a small organic farmer. But may I say to the minister, she must understand that in the farming community as a whole, there's a real feeling of abandonment. She can say what the government is doing, but there is a real feeling that there is not a commitment. The new Secretary of State has begun, I think, well in trying to build this up. But can she explain to the rest of the government that farming matters, that it's crucial for the future, and it's particularly crucial when farmers have to face these terrible weather effects?

Last five years, the three worst farmers worst harvests we've ever had, two of them because it's been burnt out, and one because it's been flooded out.

So can she help the rest of the government to talk about agriculture and the countryside in a way which sounds as if they are committed?

39:53 - 40:24

Sue Hayman

Well, I'm very pleased that the noble lord thinks the new Secretary of State has made a good start. I would absolutely agree with that. I also think that it's very encouraging that the new Prime Minister has also been talking about farming and rural businesses and rural communities in a very positive way and understanding that we need to better ensure that rural communities are properly represented right across government. And it is something that Defra takes very seriously and we will continue to work with other departments to stress that point.

40:24 - 40:56

Speaker 38

My lords, it's absolutely essential for domestic food production that we have a healthy population of pollinators. And yet our pollinators have declined since the 1980s by some one quarter, particularly some bee species and hoverflies. What is the government doing specifically around that issue as it applies to the sustainable farming initiative and biodiversity net gain? We must solve this problem for the future.

40:56 - 41:33

Sue Hayman

Well, I mean one of the things the government is doing is working to promote more sustainable farming. It's sustainable farming that will turn this around, that will make the difference. And we have to support our pollinators by looking at how we farm, what we spray on our farm, which is why I'm very pleased I've recently got the pesticides brief and I'll be working to try and see what we can do within that space. But also we have threats from non-native invasive species. We know that the yellow-legged hornet is causing all sorts of problems and we're working very, very hard to try and tackle that as well because there are threats from all sides, as the noble lord says.

41:33 - 42:16

Alexander Trees

My lords, at this moment there's little we can do to mitigate climate change and severe weather events which this year are likely to see seriously deplete our UK food production, both for arable crops and livestock. So in these circumstances, would the noble baroness the minister agree with me that the policy proposal in the land use framework published in March to take 9% of our agricultural land, that's a tenth of our agricultural land, out of food production is inconsistent with the government's avowed commitment to food security?

42:16 - 43:09

Sue Hayman

Well, I think it's also important to point out that in the land use framework, the government did make a very clear long-term commitment to maintaining overall food production in England. And to do this by increasing both farm profitability and productivity, but also to develop particular sector plans, which I know is what the farming was asking for. And through those sector plans we can better underpin our food security and drive economic growth. And we have a number of things in place to support that ambition. Horticulture and poultry we're going to start with on the sector plans, for example.

We've set up, as the Batters review recommended, a farming and food partnership board. And we're also looking at agricultural land classification data in order to protect our most important agricultural land as well.

43:09 - 43:56

Speaker 41

My lords, first of all I commend the noble lady the minister for persisting with questions today despite an awful throat, brava. Now my lords, two weeks ago the National Audit Office published a highly critical report on Defra's lack of preparedness for food shortages, not having tested emergency plans in place and lacking the legal powers and specific asset tracking to maintain food supplies during a deep emergency.

And a key recommendation was that DEFRA must work more closely with farmers and food businesses to ensure that food supply is maintained. But to work more closely with farmers, will the government now call off the Treasury attacks on farmers, farming, and the countryside, driving farmers to quit in record numbers? My Lords, no farmers, no food, no security, and no countryside we love.

43:56 - 44:21

Sue Hayman

Well, I think I mean the noble Lord mentioned the National Audit Office report, which obviously does show that risks to food supplies are becoming much more complex. And that's why we're working with farmers, producers, drinks industry to to strengthen our food security. Um, we're looking at the food's findings and recommendations, and we will of course be working and discussing those findings with the Treasury.

44:21 - 44:24

Shami Chakrabarti

Fourth oral question, Baroness Chakrabarti.

44:24 - 44:30

Speaker 35

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

44:30 - 45:02

Stephen Parkinson

My Lords, we support freedom of expression, including artistic freedom. We have not made representations to the government of Israel, but we expect any action affecting an individual's citizenship or civil rights to be conducted in accordance with the rule of law and with due process. Democracy and the rule of law are amongst Israel's founding values. These are vital to a secure Israel alongside a viable and sovereign Palestinian state.

45:02 - 45:38

Speaker 43

I'm grateful to my noble friend the minister, not least because I know of his long-term commitment to the arts in general and filmmaking, I think, in particular. I wonder how we remind ourselves, let alone persuade friends and allies, that in a democracy dissent is not disloyalty, but the test of democratic values. And given the excellent debate on the first question on G20 priorities, I wonder if my noble friend could say a little more on Foreign Office work and priorities around promoting rights and freedoms in general.

45:38 - 46:26

Stephen Parkinson

My noble friend for that answer and pay tribute to her long-standing commitment to rights, freedoms, and the rule of law for many, many years. And she's absolutely right, my noble friend's absolutely right to say that dissent is the test of the health of democracy. And we remain concerned about reports of threats and intimidation directed at journalists, filmmakers, and others. I'm pleased to say that the Foreign Office is takes media freedom extremely seriously. We chair a coalition on media freedom.

There is my ministerial friend, Minister Elmore, talked about this issue to the Foreign Affairs Committee in recent months. It's going to continue to be a priority, not just in the Middle East but elsewhere.

46:26 - 47:15

Speaker 39

The noble lady Chakrabarti should know better before submitting such questions. Any revoking of Israeli citizenship requires the Interior Minister, the Attorney General, and a court to independently agree, and the noble lady knows that no such proceedings have been opened. But would the noble Lord the minister agree that as the film itself received a 25-minute standing ovation in Venice, and the filmmakers were free to make and screen a film fiercely, and I say fiercely, critical of their own government, that actually this episode shows the strength and well-being of press freedom in Israel, the strength and well-being of democratic debate in Israel, and should in fact be praised by all noble Lords and His Majesty's government?

47:15 - 48:07

Speaker 37

Well, can I start by wishing the noble Lord a happy New Year and all other Jewish members of our chamber, noble friends, noble Lords, excuse me. And the noble Lord is right to say that Israel, for example, is a signatory to the 1954 Convention on the Status of Stateless Persons and the 1961 UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness, as we are signatories to both.

I note that the Israeli Prime Minister last night made remarks about possible future legislation, but we do not comment on that, we will see what transpires. And the noble lord is also completely right that there is a venerable and admirable tradition of robust free speech and exchange, and we hope that that tradition remains in place.

48:07 - 48:52

Lynn Ruth Deech

I hope the minister will agree that it is indeed inappropriate to focus on a state where there is a stringent judicial process. We don't want discrimination. But on the international front, things are even worse. In a few days' time, the United Nations Durban Conference will be marking the 25th anniversary of the Durban Conference against Racism, which turned out to be a Durban Conference on antisemitism and anti-Israel. Can the minister confirm, because I've written to the Prime Minister and the Foreign Minister about this, that Britain will not participate in the upcoming Durban Conference?

48:52 - 49:32

Stephen Parkinson

I thank the noble lady for that. I will have to return on the question of participation in future conferences. On the broader question of government action on antisemitism, I explained in the House last week the over 300 million pounds committed to attacking and addressing antisemitism at home. Antisemitism is unacceptable, it is a scourge of any society, especially democratic society. And at UNGA, in our upcoming event hosted by the Foreign Secretary in New York, we are going to focus more on this, and there will be more to say in the government in due course on antisemitism.

49:32 - 50:11

Malcolm Bruce

The military initially responded to Noa's by saying it categorically rejects the allegations, but in a later statement, the military said the allegations require a detailed evidence-based response rather than a blanket dismissal, which I think most people would agree was the correct response. But isn't there a danger for Israel, having a minister who has suggested that he is going to move to remove citizenship, that if that was happening and it was challenged in court, at the moment the personnel identified in the movie are anonymized, but if it goes to court, isn't there a real danger that they would be identified and that would discredit the process and indeed embarrass the government of Israel?

50:11 - 50:27

Stephen Parkinson

Well, the noble lord raises a number of complex hypothetical issues around this, and they may or may not transpire, but these are matters for Israeli courts, Israeli politics, and Israel in general rather than for me.

50:27 - 50:52

Martin Callanan

My lords, building on the question from my noble friend Lord Polak, of course, as the noble lord acknowledged, Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East. They have robust rule of law provisions. So I wonder what steps the government is taking to establish those exact provisions in the rest of the Middle East, including Iraq, Iran, Syria, and all these other Arab countries?

50:52 - 51:30

Stephen Parkinson

Well, I thank the noble lord for that. I'm not sure if he remembers the announcements that were made last week about extremely robust reaction, taking sanctions action against the finance arm of Hezbollah, taking further sanctions actions against Iran, both in the transport, energy, and other sectors supporting their attempted nuclear program, and also on vessels that transport materials for nuclear program. In other states where there is terrorism, where there is hostility to the UK and our allies, we are taking robust action so that in the hope that in the future democracy may take root.

51:29 - 52:15

Speaker 51

My Lords, last month the Union of Palestinian Journalists documented 108 attacks by Israeli forces and settlers on journalists and media workers in the occupied West Bank. Those attacks included detention, beatings, and seizure of media equipment. Will my noble friend the Minister support the Palestinian Trade Union of Journalists in calling for all media workers to be able to work free from intimidation and violence, and call for those accountable, those responsible to be held accountable?

52:15 - 52:42

Stephen Parkinson

Well, I thank my noble friend for that, and she's absolutely right that attacks on all journalists are a matter of grave concern. We're very concerned by the high death toll of journalists in Gaza. Reporters covering conflicts should be, must be afforded protection under international humanitarian law, and access to conflict zones is vital for the media to carry out the role effectively, a role that we all depend on.

52:42 - 53:26

Speaker 42

The Minister rightly recognized that in Israel independent filmmakers can and do produce work highly critical of their own government. Is the government taking any steps to ensure that independent filmmakers can do precisely that in Gaza, in the West Bank, or in any other state without suffering appalling consequences? And can I also recommend to the Minister, and indeed to Baroness Chakrabarti, the new fifth season of the Israeli award-winning drama Fauda, which deals with the appalling events of the 7th of October and their aftermath?

53:26 - 53:58

Stephen Parkinson

Well, I thank you for that. I am a Fauda fan, and I haven't got to the fifth season yet, but I will do. I appreciate the pointer. On establishing freedom for artistic expression and freedom of speech in the West Bank and Gaza, in Gaza there is limited, unfortunately, limited ability for us to influence what's happening at the moment in Gaza, but in the West Bank we are working with the Palestinian Authority to help cement reforms and support the development of democracy and the rule of law.

53:58 - 54:45

Speaker 60

My Lords, non-affiliated, my Lords, non-affiliated, my Lords, non-affiliated, my Lords. My Lords, notwithstanding the due process referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Polak, does he agree with me that when a senior member of a government threatens to withdraw citizenship, that in effect can have a chilling effect on freedom of expression and indeed artistic expression? And I'd like to widen this slightly further. Will he now take action against the Turkish government for arresting LGBT activists and LGBT people merely for expressing their right to live and exist?

54:45 - 55:04

Stephen Parkinson

Well, I thank my noble friend. I actually have raised the issue on LGBT activists with my Turkish counterparts. But on the general question, I don't think it's appropriate to respond to individual comments of politicians in other countries at this stage. I think I'll leave it at that.

55:04 - 55:04

My Lords, that completes oral questions for today, so those people who wish to leave the chamber can they do so now quickly and quietly.

56:14 - 56:24

Speaker 45

Draft Conversion Practices Bill Joint Committee appointment motion, the Senior Deputy Speaker.

56:24 - 56:28

John Gardiner

I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

56:28 - 56:50

Speaker 45

The question is that the motion in the name of the Senior Deputy Speaker be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. Questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons on Tuesday 15th September on the proposed overnight visitor levy.

56:50 - 57:33

Stephen Parkinson

My Lords, it's always a pleasure to see the noble Baroness Lady Blake at the dispatch box, but it was curious this question wasn't answered by the tourism minister in another place and it's not being answered by any of the now three ministers at DCMS in your Lordships' House. Can she on behalf of the government answer a question that wasn't addressed when this was taken on Tuesday? This new holiday tax will apply to all domestic stays. Does the noble Baroness think it is fair to charge people who are staying in a hotel in order to attend the funeral of a loved one, to visit somebody in hospital, or to undergo specialist medical attention in places far away from home?

57:33 - 58:14

Judith Blake

My Lords, if that was the intention behind the levy then I would have something to say. And I'm delighted to tell the noble Lord that there will be exemptions, and particularly around, for example, we have many places that have big hospitals where parents or relatives have to go and stay. So there will be sensitivity at a local level. It will be at the local level to decide where those exemptions can apply so that it is done in the fairest possible way to protect people who have legitimate reasons that they need to be in a particular area.

58:14 - 58:50

Dominic Hubbard

My Lords, could the minister just take this opportunity to confirm this is something that should not be seen as a way of boosting income for normal expenditure? This is something that's a bonus on top. It should be set locally. What will be happening in Bath, for instance, will not probably be applicable in Barnsley. Make sure that we actually do something which is appropriate to those people, their local communities, and make sure it is for something that is a bonus for those communities that take something out of the tourism.

58:50 - 59:50

Judith Blake

The noble Lord raises a very important point and I think it is that putting that trust in local areas to work with their local partners, business community, and making sure that the benefit comes back into those areas to help promote tourism. We're absolutely committed to supporting the tourism industry and can I reassure him that there will be non-statutory guidance.

And we look forward to the plans coming forward in due course from the local areas to just have a look at the plans they have. And building on plans that are already in place, the levy is already a levy is already in place in other parts of this country, not to mention around Europe and around the world. And there are some incredibly positive examples to look to in terms of bringing enormous benefit to those local wider communities.

59:50 - 01:00:22

Speaker 44

My Lords, my Lords. Further to Lord Addington's question, a key proposal of the Cultural Policy Unit is a city tourism charge which would be ring-fenced for cultural infrastructure, including, for example, theaters, museums, and heritage sites, which would in a cyclic way also help the hospitality sector through encouraging tourism and redressing regional inequalities. But that will not happen if this charge is squandered in other ways.

01:00:22 - 01:01:06

Judith Blake

There is absolutely no intention for the funds raised to be squandered. But the ring-fenced approach smacks of centralism. It's absolutely critical that local areas can determine their needs. I come from an area that has benefited enormously from investment in cultural events, sporting events, that have brought a huge benefit, not least round-the-clock coverage from an aerial perspective of the beautiful sights of Yorkshire, for example. There are so many ways that this can be done.

We're not ring-fencing because it would not be in the spirit of devolution, but we are very mindful of the comments that the noble Lord has made.

01:01:06 - 01:01:44

Speaker 55

My Lords, Italy raises 1.3 billion euros per year from tourist taxes, with over 1,400 of their municipalities implementing the tax. Now, they have a different approach. They earmark the funds to support local tourism, to protect cultural heritage, and to manage the environment. So given that tourists who visit the UK benefit greatly from our cultural offerings, including free entry to our museums, I just wonder whether the Minister agree with my hope that mayors and strategic authorities, and it is right that they should decide these things, will channel the funds for culture as well as other support for tourism.

01:01:44 - 01:02:32

Judith Blake

My noble friend raises a point on a similar theme. And from experience of working with the business rate retention pilot back in the day, the most important thing about this is we get the right partners round the table in those localities. And those businesses that and enterprises that my noble friend refers to need to have a voice round that table. It's absolutely critical that events and opportunities that attract more visitors to come in have a full representation and encourage investment that will make visitors feel welcome, looked after, safe, and all of those things that matter on a wider perspective.

01:02:32 - 01:03:26

Ben Houchen

My Lords, I declare an interest as one of the mayors who is going to be receiving the power to implement the overnight levy. And let me put on record and be extremely clear that for as long as I continue to be the mayor of the Tees Valley, there will be no overnight levy implemented within my region, specifically because it is a significant impact on relatively poor socioeconomic families who do decide to holiday within the UK. It is an additional tax on holidays, but also it's a tax on business. We have contractors, we have the white van man, we have businesses who rely on overnight stays up and down this country. It's an additional tax on business.

But my question to the Minister is, with devolution, it seems to be a one-way street with this administration, that devolution means an ability to increase taxes. Can the Minister tell me where we might be able to see the devolution of the ability to decrease taxes?

01:03:27 - 01:04:18

Judith Blake

Can I just say, and obviously we've worked together many on many occasions in the past, that is entirely in your remit. And that is why it's not being imposed. It's a devolved matter and local mayors and strategic authorities can make their own decisions. That is the absolutely fundamental point of why we are doing it in this way. I have to say, the evidence actually doesn't support his thesis from around the world.

But of course there's concern. Of course there's concern and we need to make sure that everything is analyzed, addressed and we have full picture of impact as we go on.

01:04:18 - 01:04:38

Speaker 52

Will care be taken to study how the levy has been administered in Edinburgh, where it's been in force for quite some time now, both as to the administration and also the effect on businesses and wider effects across the city?

01:04:38 - 01:05:16

Judith Blake

So my understanding is that the Edinburgh scheme is actually relatively new and was introduced this summer. And the estimates at the moment are that it's raised 50 million pounds. Now we will be looking very, very carefully at their experience. They have not reported any decrease in visitor numbers and we expect a very positive program of how they are going to invest that money. And of course Edinburgh is home to many artists over the summer and I'm sure they would want to make it absolutely clear that they're very welcome to go to Edinburgh and will be supported.

01:05:16 - 01:05:43

Speaker 56

Is the minister aware of the Merseyside mayor's proposals to actually lever in private sector money using this levy to do some exciting schemes that will create wealth, growth and jobs? And doesn't he think that the mayor of Merseyside will know better about generation than the Tory party who abandoned lots of these areas for a long time?

01:05:43 - 01:06:19

Judith Blake

I am absolutely convinced that Mayor Rotheram knows what's best for his local area. He's absolutely passionate advocate of everything to do with Liverpool. And of course Liverpool, along with Manchester, have already introduced a flat rate levy at the behest of the business community in their areas. It's the businesses who've worked with the leaders to bring forward those. I'm pretty sure I'll be in Liverpool fairly shortly.

I look forward very much to finding out more about it.

01:06:19 - 01:06:41

Charles John Fuller

UK Hospitality has calculated this tax will cost 33,000 jobs, raise 1.6 billion and reduce GDP by 2.2 billion. That's their assessment. What assessment has the government made of the financial impacts of this proposal and will they publish it?

01:06:41 - 01:07:18

Judith Blake

It's fair to say that we don't recognize the figures that UK Hospitality has put out. We have been working with them incredibly closely through the consultation. We will continue to do so. They are an absolute vital part of our economy and we are here to give the support that's needed to make sure that the areas thrive and continue. So conversations ongoing, but can I just suggest the noble lord he looks at the wider evidence from around the world of how successful such a levy can be.

01:07:18 - 01:07:30

Speaker 45

Questions on the statement made in the House of Commons on Wednesday 9th September on education and skills reform.

01:07:30 - 01:14:58

Joanne Cash

My Lords, as ever, I thank the noble Baroness, the Minister, for bringing this statement to the House. Last week's PISA results placed English pupils in the top 10 in the world for reading, maths and science, and that's down to the dedication and hard work of our teachers executing an almost 30-year reform begun under New Labour and continued by the Conservatives. I am delighted that this statement acknowledges that success. But it does make the dismantling of the system which has given generations of children greater life chances very much harder to justify. It is laudable that the government wishes to address what is not working and to do more for those not in education, employment or training.

We on these benches share that desire, but good intentions are not the same as good decisions. The parts of the system which are working so well should be left alone. Since 2016, schools have been judged on the progress every pupil makes between the ages of 11 and 16. We know this measure as Progress 8. It is a really reliable measure because it adjusts for intake, so it quickly weeds out the schools coasting on good results in affluent areas without significant improvement, and the schools with remarkable outcomes for children in our most deprived communities, top schools like the Tauheedul Girls' School, Mercia in Sheffield, and of course Michaela.

It is such a good measure that the government's own independent reviewer, Professor Francis, recommended keeping Progress 8 completely unchanged. But the government has overruled her. And we know from the February consultation what overruling her means. It means broadening subjects to be measured and adding measures for lower-attaining pupils to reward inclusion. If ever there were words to make the heart sink.

So please could the noble Baroness, the Minister, assist us here: what evidence did the department possess to justify overruling its own expert reviewer? Now there's a very bold claim about NEETs in this statement, that, and I quote, "the over-focus on academic pathways is a major factor driving the growing NEETs crisis which has produced the current million NEETs". Now, it's not the time for an economics debate, and so I'm going to resist that temptation, but my Lords, we have data on this. Wales has been rolling out precisely the kind of skills-based, less exam-focused curriculum now proposed by this government for England. On the results published on the 8th of September, Wales scored well below England in maths, reading and science, and the Institute for Fiscal Studies tells us that 11% of Welsh 16-to-18-year-olds are NEET, against 5 to 9% across the rest of the United Kingdom, and that disadvantaged children in England score 30 points higher than disadvantaged children in Wales.

The statement then also cites 1.5 million persistently absent children as part of its reasoning against the academic curriculum. Now, I am delighted to talk about absence, school absence. We do not talk about it enough and the toll it takes on children's outcomes, and parents need to know more about that. The Education Policy Institute has found that the widening of the disadvantage gap since 2019 is entirely explained by higher absence rates among poorer pupils. But again, there is no causal link with the academic curriculum.

And we have the data. Persistent absence is 18% in England, 28% in Scotland and 37% among Welsh secondary pupils. 20% higher in Wales under the same skills-based, less academic curriculum the government now proposes for England. While absence rose across every UK nation after the pandemic, England's rate with its boring old academic curriculum is the lowest and falling.

And then we've heard a lot this week since the statement about the abolition of resits. My Lords, none of us wish children to resit exams for the sake of it, but again, we have data on this. Really solid LSE research, cited by Alan Milburn, comparing students of identical ability who fall just either side of the grade boundary, finds that just failing as opposed to just scraping a pass in English GCSE alone makes a young person more likely to be out of education and work by 18. At 16, 35% lack the grades, by 19 it's only 22%, so resits help almost a third of those to transform their life chances. So can the noble Baroness the Minister please tell us what happens to that group if the resits are abolished, and what exactly is going to replace the resits for the remainder?

Now my Lords, vocational pathways are the centerpiece of the new Prime Minister and Secretary of State's education reforms. But regrettably, from this statement, we are none the wiser what these will look like. We still do not know what qualifications we are expecting and when, which means real uncertainty for children and their families. It supposedly launches in two years, yet the qualifications are just existing technical awards with any new ones yet to be explored. There is no plan for the specialist teachers, and colleges cannot fill technical posts already today.

No plan for work experience, when T-levels still already struggle to find placements. Nothing on who decides which children will take this route, no guarantee of what it leads to, and no budget. So noble Lords, I ask the noble Baroness the Minister, which qualifications will a child starting in September 2028 take? When will we know? Who will decide which children go down this route?

And will completing it guarantee a place on a T-level, V-level or apprenticeship? And will the noble Baroness the Minister guarantee that a child who starts it can return, complete academic GCSEs and go on to A-levels if needed? I finally must press the Minister on a few other questions about timetable. The review is published in November 2025. The government promised the first teaching of the new curriculum would happen in September 2028.

The final documents by spring 2027, with four terms for schools to prepare. The draft curriculum and the Progress 8 consultation response were due this September. It is now 17th of September, the Commons has risen, this House rises this afternoon, and nothing has been published. Please could the noble Baroness the Minister tell us, on what date will the draft curriculum be published? Does the four terms pledge still stand, and if so, what does that mean for the implementation date?

And finally, will the Progress 8 consultation response come before or after schools must set their options for 2027? I thank the noble Baroness the Minister in advance for her answers.

01:14:58 - 01:19:55

Magid Magid

My Lords, I'm grateful for this debate on education and skills policy, because ultimately this comes down to one question: are we giving every young person the opportunity to build a good quality life, regardless of where they come from? There is much in our education system of which we should be proud, and as we heard earlier, the latest PISA results show that United Kingdom remains one of the highest performing education systems in the world, particularly around science, mathematics and reading. And in science, my Lords, our performance has improved since 2022, and we need to acknowledge these achievements.

But we also have to recognize that academic success alone is not enough. The ONS has estimated that more than 1 million young people aged 16 to 24 are currently not in education, employment or training, a figure that has increased over the past year. Alan Milburn's review that many of us have spoken about warns that without action, one in six young people could be NEET within the next five years. That should be a wake-up call to all of us, my Lords. We need an education and skills system that works for young people who want to go to university, but equally for young people who want to become engineers, electricians, nurses, technicians and skilled professionals.

The government's reforms to post-16 pathways have the potential to provide greater choice, including V-levels and occupational certificates. But choice alone exists if young people have access to a genuine range of choices. And my concerns are that technical education must not become a second-tier route disproportionately taken by children from poorer backgrounds while affluent families continue to choose the traditional academic pathways. There must be parity of esteem between academic and technical education and crucially, the ability to move between the two pathways. A 16-year-old should not be expected to make a decision that permanently determines their future.

That is why careers advice is so important, my Lords. Every young person should have access to high-quality careers guidance and meaningful work experience, an issue that I've often mentioned in your Lordships' chamber, so that choices are informed by aspiration and opportunity rather than postcode or family income. We also need to ask whether the system has the capacity to deliver these ambitions. Technical education requires teachers, lecturers, specialist facilities and strong links with employers. Yet colleges are already under pressure to recruit and retain staff with specialist skills required.

So I ask the Minister, how will the government ensure colleges have the workforce and the funding necessary to deliver these reforms? And will she commit to addressing disparities in pay and conditions that are making recruitment and retention more difficult? Apprenticeships must also be central to this debate. They can provide a powerful bridge between education and employment, but employers, particularly small and medium-sized businesses, need a system that is simpler, more flexible and financially viable. I welcome the government's move towards a greater flexibility in apprenticeship levy, but we should go further, my Lords.

Make apprenticeships more attractive, ensure apprentices are properly paid and give smaller businesses practical support to take on more. We also need regional flexibility. A young person in a rural community should have access to the same breadth of opportunities as someone in a major city. That would require proper workforce planning and greater involvement from regions and employers. Finally, can I, we cannot discuss education and skills reform without mentioning SEND.

Too many families are still, my Lords, fighting for support while councils struggle with the financial consequences of a broken system. Reform must put children and families at its center. That means early identification, sufficient specialist and mainstream provision and a properly funded workforce, meaningful rights to appeal for parents. My Lords, skills are not simply about filling vacancies. They're about giving people the confidence, knowledge and opportunities to shape their own future.

If these reforms are to succeed, my Lords, we need an education system that does not divide young people into winners and losers, academic or vocational, advantaged or disadvantaged. We need a system that says to every young person, your background does not determine your future and whatever route you choose, we will give you the opportunity to succeed. That should be the ambitions of education and skills reform, my Lords.

01:19:53 - 01:27:40

Jacqui Smith

My Lords, I thank noble Lords for their questions. I'll turn to the specific points that have been raised in a moment, but before I do so, I think it is worth briefly reiterating the context of the Secretary of State's statement last week. At its heart was a simple proposition, that every young person should be able to see a clear pathway from education into further learning, skilled work, and adult life. While our education system has many strengths, and the latest PISA results confirmed England's strong performance in reading, mathematics, and science, and I agree with the noble lady Baroness Cash that that should be reflected in our thanks to the hardworking staff in our schools who have helped to deliver that, but that also it does build on the work of successive governments. I am very proud of the role that I played in the previous Labour government alongside some of my noble friends here today in the focus on numeracy and literacy, on the introduction of phonics, on the support to ensure school improvement across the system, and I recognize that many of those elements were built on successfully by the last government.

But there is a slight flavor in the opposition's response to this statement, both in this House and in the other House, that somehow or other we should now place in aspic the education system and not recognize the areas where, notwithstanding the progress, there is more work to be done. Because I'm afraid disadvantage gaps still exist for our children and it is stubbornly wide. A gap between regions is widening. We have a SEND crisis that is growing, and one and a half million children persistently absent from school at the last general election, and a doubling of those educated at home since 2019, and now a million young people, all educated during the last 16 years, not in education, employment, or training. So simply standing still and resting on our laurels will not be good enough for our children.

The purpose of these reforms is therefore to build a nationally coherent, locally responsive education and skill system that supports opportunity, responds to local labor market needs, and creates stronger progression routes for young people. Central to that ambition is a new approach to technical and vocational education. Academic, technical, and vocational routes should be complementary parts of a single high-quality offer with stronger connections to employment. New technical pathways from age 14 will combine technical qualifications alongside GCSEs, careers education, and meaningful work experience, helping young people progress into further study, apprenticeships, and skilled careers. Alongside that, mayors, local leaders, schools, colleges, and employers will work together to develop those high-quality technical and vocational routes for 16 to 19-year-olds aligned to local economic opportunities and the government's industrial strategy.

These reforms are designed to widen opportunity, not to narrow it, ensuring that technical excellence is recognized and valued alongside academic achievement and that every young person can see a clear route to success. Which is why, in response to the noble lady Baroness Cash, I have to, um, I have to rebut her suggestion that this government is dismantling the system. What we are actually aiming to do is to ensure that the high standards that we can achieve for a lot of children, although not all, in our academic education are matched by high standards for those who want to take a more technical or more vocational route. And that the opportunity to do that at the age of 14 to combine GCSEs with technical qualifications is made much more widely available to young people than is the case at the moment. That is not a dismantling of our system.

That is building on what is good but ensuring that technical and vocational education has the support and the priority that many people in this house think it should have. Furthermore, we're not talking about abolishing resits. What we're talking about is abolishing the situation where young people without the additional support that they need resit in a way that simply promotes their feeling of failure. That's the reason why we're investing in teaching in further education. It's why we're introducing a new level one stepping stone qualification in order to enable young people to get the foundation that will then enable them to go on and successfully resit their GCSEs.

On the some of the detailed questions about the 14 to 16 technical route, I mean, first of all, let me, as I think I've made clear, this is not about separating pupils into academic and vocational groups or narrowing choices. All pupils will continue to study a broad and balanced curriculum. We're drawing on evidence from the interim Milburn review, the curriculum and assessment review and engagement, as I say, with strategic authorities, employers, schools, colleges and other partners as we develop those pathways. They'll be rolled out using the existing level one and two technical awards already available and we will also work with Ofqual and other key partners to develop top-quality vocational and technical qualifications which support, to respond to her point, progression to T-levels and A-levels and V-levels and apprenticeships, universities and beyond. And those qualifications will continue to sit alongside GCSEs and provide a high-quality option at key stage four.

As that work progresses, the DfE will consider how to use its existing budgets to best support delivery, including through reprioritizing budgets to ensure investment in high-quality education and clearer routes into skilled work. We are already, of course, making a difference to the numbers of teachers that we are recruiting, but of course we recognize the challenge to ensure that the expertise is there to deliver on that. The noble Lord Lord Hamit is right about careers guidance and work experience. He's right about apprenticeships, which is why we're already going further with support for employers, and he's right about reform of the special educational needs system, which is why we will bring forward the results of our consultation. We are already investing in the SEND system and we will have plenty of time in this house to discuss this government's reform program.

01:27:39 - 01:27:57

Speaker 63

My Lords, my Lords, before we move on, I would remind the house that the next 20 minutes are reserved for questions from backbenchers only, and I would also remind noble Lords of the importance of brevity when asking questions. This will ensure as many noble Lords as possible have the opportunity to ask their questions.

01:27:57 - 01:28:44

Alexander David Hugh Hannay

My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, I know that the noble lady the minister has taken a very positive attitude towards strengthening the status of kinship carers and the pilot programs that the government has introduced. Both these have a capacity to help in bringing forward the work that she's spoken of in the statement. Could she possibly give a rather fuller account of what the government is doing on kinship carers, and if that takes more time than we have available this morning, could she possibly write to me, because she and her colleague, the noble lady, Lady Blake of Leeds, have played a very, very positive role in this area, which is an important one.

01:28:44 - 01:29:24

Jacqui Smith

Well, I thank the noble Lord for that, and he's right that we are seeking ways to support kinship carers, to strengthen the opportunity for children to live with those who are close to them in those arrangements. We're also taking action to support the educational outcomes of children who are in kinship care, I think I'm right in saying, expanding the role of virtual head teachers to those children, but I will certainly write to him with more detail about our plans.

01:29:24 - 01:30:07

Speaker 65

My Lords, I very much welcome the emphasis that the government is placing on work experience, and I wonder if the minister might like to say a bit more about how the government plans to deliver this. It will be clear that work experience will be available both to students below 16 and post-16, and with the two funding streams that will now be covering those areas and the extra responsibility it will be put on schools, can the minister perhaps just give an absolute assurance that there will be a quality of opportunity for children from all backgrounds and that the extra work won't fall merely on schools. I think back to something which I think was called the Business Education Partnership, which offered a brokerage service, which meant that greater access for everyone was available and the schools weren't overburdened.

01:30:07 - 01:31:01

Jacqui Smith

Yes, I thank my noble friend for that. She's right that there is a very important theme in these reforms of the opportunity for high-quality work experience. The government's commitment, of course, to delivering two weeks of work experience for every child pre-16, with different ways to engage with employers is an important part of that work. She's right that given the ambition we also have post-16 for T-level placements, for other work experience opportunities, we need to support, for example, our mayoral and strategic authorities to be able to broker those links locally, and her ideas about support for brokerage are very important and something that we're reflecting on.

01:31:01 - 01:31:23

John Redwood

Given the need for more work experience and more apprenticeships and other support from the private sector, will the government look again at the very damaging tax rises and regulatory changes it's introduced, which have driven down vacancies in a big way and driven up unemployment, because this impedes success for this program.

01:31:23 - 01:31:53

Jacqui Smith

Well, of course, we'll keep the business environment under review to ensure that it provides as many opportunities as possible, but I do note that Alan Milburn in his interim review argued that, in fact, it wasn't, for example, changes to national insurance or to the national minimum wage that have caused the numbers of young people who are out of work. The biggest increase, of course, happened in the two years in the run-up to the last general election.

01:31:52 - 01:32:54

James Peter Weir

My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, I refer first of all to my entry on the register of interests as regards City of London College. But within the statement, the government commits to transferring responsibility and finance for 16 to 19-year-olds to mayors and presumably strategic authorities. But to date, sometimes local authorities have been quite inconsistent in their approach of support, particularly for a very differential approach at times, for instance, for young people who are in danger of becoming NEETs but don't reach the level of EHCP. So can I ask the Minister how they intend to move forward while ensuring that there is a consistent and full access to pathways for all pupils and that equal opportunities are provided for every young person irrespective of where they come from?

01:32:54 - 01:33:53

Jacqui Smith

Well, this is, if I'm completely frank, this is one of the big challenges of the very welcome devolution that this government under the new Prime Minister is engaged in. There are questions which we are discussing with mayors and with others about the relationship between national entitlements and the flexibility and the ability to be able, for example, to bring in work experience opportunities, to work with local employers, to tailor education so that it suits the types of work and opportunities that might be available to young people locally. With ensuring that there is a quality of access, it is a key objective of this government to close, not to worsen, the disadvantage gap. And we will keep thinking hard as we develop the devolution proposals about how we can ensure that happens.

01:33:53 - 01:34:24

Speaker 71

Even in the world where we are ruled by robots, it seems highly likely that genuine human creativity and culture will have an important part to play in our economy going forwards. The Secretary of State mentions drama in her statement last week, but I wonder whether my noble friend can tell us more about the wider cultural opportunities that these reforms might bring forward, perhaps in music, dance, and film.

01:34:24 - 01:35:53

Jacqui Smith

Well, of course, it was an important part of our curriculum and assessment review that we found time within a curriculum that still focuses on the knowledge that is necessary for children to succeed for broader opportunities to undertake music and drama, PE, some of those, as my noble friend says, human skills and opportunities that are so important to our children. And we are certainly, and we've discussed in this House a whole range of ways that we're supporting the development of opportunities for music and dance. But I will also at this point respond to the points made by the noble lady Baroness Cash about the accountability measures. Of course, we, in removing the requirement for children to study within the straitjacket, really, of the former EBacc accountability measures, we have freed up schools to be able to reintroduce some of those music, drama, and other qualifications that had been squeezed out by EBacc. And the point about Progress 8, of course, at the moment, whilst we consult about the changes that we want to make to Progress 8, it remains in place.

01:35:46 - 01:36:20

David Willetts

My Lords, there clearly is a tide of opinion in favour of devolving funding. The statement in the other place was absolutely clear: for the first time, mayors will have control of the 16 to 19 education budget. This is causing some concern. Can the Minister tell the House, does that include control of the expenditure of the apprenticeship levy on 16 to 18-year-olds, and does it extend to classroom-based provision for 16 to 18-year-olds?

01:36:20 - 01:36:46

Jacqui Smith

We are obviously still working on the details of that, but no, it doesn't extend to the growth and skills levy provision for 16 to 18-year-old apprenticeships. It will cover the 16 to 19 budget as it applies, for example, to post-16 qualifications, including classroom provision in colleges.

01:36:46 - 01:37:25

James Timpson

My Lords, I declare my interest as a working teacher, and I would beg the House to wish me luck teaching jollof rice to year 8s tomorrow. I broadly welcome this statement and its ambitions, but I'm slightly confused. The Becky Francis review promised us evolution, not revolution. The new Secretary of State has said there will be an education revolution. Has the curriculum review been superseded, and are we evolving or are we revolting?

01:37:25 - 01:38:47

Jacqui Smith

Well, I have no doubt with the noble Lord's skills that year 8 will thoroughly enjoy jollof rice and will come out of his class with renewed enthusiasm for cooking and hopefully a whole range of other things. No, look, as I made clear in my first answer, we are building on the successes of the last 30 years in our education system, but we are recognising where, as Becky Francis did in the curriculum and assessment review, we have overly narrowed the curriculum. In some cases, we have forced out things I think many people would consider to be important skills and opportunities for young people. We will reintroduce those, but we are also determined to do something that previous governments, many have expressed a commitment to, but none have really delivered so far, including myself in my former incarnation, and that is genuinely good, high-quality, high-standard technical and vocational opportunities for young people. So that is the opportunity that we have through these reforms, and that's an important part of the focus of the work that we're doing.

01:38:47 - 01:39:37

Speaker 70

My Lords, whilst I welcome many of the aspects in this statement and in what my noble friend the Minister said, I still feel it lacks an overall strategy in relation to future changes of demands on the employment and skills market. I ask particularly, will the department, the government, produce a strategy which is central to the economic policy of the government, which deals with the impact that AI will have on the employment and the skills requirement in the long term and the medium term? One doesn't have to be a total pessimist to see that AI is going to destroy millions of jobs, but it will change dramatically millions of them, not least entry-level jobs.

Will there be a strategy of dealing with AI and its impact on the needs of our education and skills system from the department?

01:39:37 - 01:40:35

Jacqui Smith

Well, it's precisely in order to equip children to be able to respond to the changing needs in the labor market that we're making some of the changes that we're making. But of course, that builds on the introduction by this government of Skills England. And my noble friend, I hope, will have seen some of the important work that Skills England has done about the way in which AI skills will be necessary for the future workforce, the way in which they are likely to change the nature of the skills that young people and in fact adults need. And the government has responded to that through additional skills training to support not just young people, but people throughout their lives to develop those AI skills. So I agree with him that this is a wide-ranging challenge to both the labor market and our education system, and there is more work that needs to be done, but we have certainly made an important start.

01:40:35 - 01:41:27

Speaker 74

My Lords, I draw attention to my interests with respect to Access Creative College. My Lords, only last month, the government implemented substantial reforms to the apprenticeship levy, transforming it into the Growth and Skills Levy, increasing the amount that employers must contribute to adult apprenticeships and reducing the amount of time they have to pay for the, to use their levy funds. We read in the FT recently that the government's own reviewer is minded to recommend the abolition of the apprenticeship levy. Is the government minded to go down such a path, and if so, how does it plan to backfill the four billion pounds or so that the apprenticeship levy, now the Growth and Skills Levy, brings into our training and skills system?

01:41:27 - 01:42:22

Jacqui Smith

I think it's, I mean, the noble Lord knows as well as any of us do that you can't necessarily believe everything that you read in the newspapers. And I, you know, I think as I suggested to the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, that there may well be further changes to the Growth and Skills Levy, but we have been clear. We've been clear that we want to pivot that to young people, to put right the 40% fall in young people starting apprenticeships that we saw in the last 10 years. But we also understand the role of apprenticeships and of skills training more widely in supporting people who are currently in work. So I would ask the noble Lord to wait, for example, until the final publication of Alan Milburn's recommendations and the government's response to them.

01:42:22 - 01:43:43

Colin Moynihan

Questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons on Tuesday, 15th September, on the closure of the Saudi East-West oil pipeline. My Lords, I declare my interests as chairman of Buckthorn Amy and Atium. Concentrating on fuel prices in the question, my Lords, since UK imports of Saudi oil stand at 2.5% of our total oil imports, and the UK share of our overall Middle Eastern gas supply is well under 1%, why are our domestic electricity bills predicted to be 300 pounds more per annum from January next year, a distant 600 pounds more than the promised reduction in the Labour Party manifesto, when wholesale electricity prices, the only element which gas heavily influences, contributes just 38% of our domestic bills? Would the Minister not agree that one way to reduce bills is to remove the Clean Power 2030 policy costs, which are fleecing British consumers in the government's headlong rush to net zero and decarbonization of Britain's electricity generation by 2030, which everyone knows will not be achieved and will continue massively to impede household and industrial affordability?

01:43:42 - 01:45:07

Speaker 69

Well, I thank the noble lord for his points just then and his question. I think he will recognise in talking about percentages of oil and gas coming from certain regions, he's mentioned Saudi obviously, we understand that our energy security in the UK in a positive way is reliant on a diverse range of supplies from around the world, including the Netherlands and the US, as he will well know. In terms of bills in domestic terms, clearly the government is reviewing all the time the volatility that's happening as a result not just of those most recent attacks on the pipeline and on the facilities in Saudi Arabia, but also the wider issues that are happening across the Middle East in Iran and other areas of volatility. So we continue as a government to review what we can do to help people, but as many will know, we are removing VAT on electricity bills from the 1st of October, which was recently announced, and there are other discounts to be made, both 150 pounds off bills in the last budget and for those six million households most in need, the warm homes discount, which I encourage noble lords to ensure is widely communicated.

01:45:07 - 01:45:48

Speaker 76

My lords, can I welcome my first opportunity to welcome my honourable noble friend to the benches? As a former wing commander, she adds real expertise and stature to the whole of the Labour benches and indeed to the house. Can I welcome what she replied, but also say, doesn't this terrible attack on the pipeline also indicate that the White House is responsible for terrible blunders of diplomacy in the Middle East, something that the Conservative leader asked us to back, and the consequences have been appalling and the government's wrestling with that?

01:45:48 - 01:46:32

Speaker 75

Well, I thank my noble friend and it's lovely to be able to call the noble lord my noble friend for his very, very kind words and thank you for that. In terms of the situation, and I know you're referring to the action against Iran combined from the US and Israel, as you will well know, our former Prime Minister now, Sir Keir Starmer, made an excellent judgment call in those very early days under an awful lot of pressure, both from outside groups and indeed from the opposition, and I very much commend the way that he handled that, both as a member of this house and also as a former military officer.

01:46:32 - 01:47:12

Alexander David Hugh Hannay

...that the damage done to the Saudi installations originated from a part of the Iraqi Republic, a rogue general, and are we satisfied that that will not be repeated? And could he, could she also perhaps address the question as to whether it is really very helpful of the President of the United States to say he doesn't expect anything much to happen to alleviate the supply problems in the Gulf until after the US midterm elections?

01:47:12 - 01:47:57

Speaker 77

So you make an excellent point about the fact that the drone attacks that hit the Saudi pipeline and installations generally came from Iraq, from IRGC-supported militia.

I can't give a guarantee that that may not happen again. Clearly, the IRGC are active in various parts of the Middle East, and that remains of significant concern to, of course, our government and our allies in the region. On his second point about the future, sorry, I've forgotten exactly the second point.

01:47:57 - 01:48:12

Alexander David Hugh Hannay

My Lords, I asked the noble lady whether she thought it was helpful that the President of the United States had said that he didn't expect anything very useful to happen to improve the supply of oil and gas from the Gulf before the US midterm elections.

01:48:12 - 01:48:53

Speaker 77

Yes, sorry. So to my noble lord's second question, what I would say is that we don't know how long it is going to take for Saudi Arabia to repair the pipeline. Reports are varied on how long it will take, but there are some that are optimistic that it will be sooner than that. And so I would respectfully take the advice from our Saudi Arabian allies first and foremost. And there are conversations going on, as you will expect, between both the Department of Energy Security and Net Zero and, of course, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office with our allies and Saudi Arabia in particular.

01:48:53 - 01:49:32

Simon Russell

My Lords, can I also welcome the noble baroness, the minister. Again, it is fossil fuels that prove to be insecure in supply and volatile in price. The attack on this pipeline, carrying 4% of global oil, will pile further pressure on prices already inflated as we head into winter, and we can ill afford another fossil fuel crisis. So I ask the noble baroness, the minister, how robust are our energy supplies? And as the Prime Minister has promised to take the difficult decisions, will a social tariff be introduced this winter so families can afford to heat their homes?

01:49:32 - 01:50:31

Speaker 69

I thank the noble lord for a very important question. And clearly, the UK continues, as I've said, to have a robust and secure supply of gas, oil, and other fuel products to meet the demand through a mixture of domestic production and imports from a diverse, and I said before, some of the countries that we are getting imports from. We know that worry about energy prices is right at the forefront of the public's minds, and I understand that completely. We will keep looking at what we can do to protect families from unaffordable bills. I've already mentioned some of the areas that we've been trying to make some lives better.

And I could also add, perhaps, that we are also helping those homes most in need who need heating oil to provide their heating in rural communities. But I absolutely know that this is top of the agenda in terms of continuing to review that.

01:50:31 - 01:50:45

John Redwood

This is another proof of the disruption in the Middle East. We need to get the Jackdaw gas out as quickly as possible for domestic use. And doesn't that bring a tax bonanza, which surely the government needs?

01:50:45 - 01:51:04

Speaker 69

The noble lord, I know, raised this very question with my fellow colleague in the ministry, Baroness Curran. And as I know he will have heard the answer last week, I can't comment at the moment on that project given that it is currently subject to a live regulatory process.

01:51:04 - 01:51:31

Speaker 71

My Lord, firstly, can I welcome and congratulate my noble friend on her appearance at the dispatch box. This issue really underlines the importance of Britain achieving fuel self-sufficiency going forward. So I wonder, with that in mind, whether she can tell us any more about how the government's work is going in that direction, and particularly giving communities power over energy self-sufficiency.

01:51:30 - 01:52:17

Speaker 69

I thank my noble friend for his question. And we know people are really worried about the cost of bills, as I've already said to the noble Lord, Lord Russell. And obviously we're transitioning to clean energy as a government to get off this fossil fuels rollercoaster and take back control of our energy bills. Now, in particular, today there has been announcement of a new grant package to support community energy projects. That is an announcement of 30 million pounds backed by or from the Great British Energy organization to roll out a wave of local projects.

So that's intended to allow communities in every postcode to decide what they would like to invest in, whether it's solar panels on their local library or a community wind farm. And I commend that project to the House.

01:52:17 - 01:52:47

Chris Grayling

My Lords, I refer members to my entry in the register. Of course, this attack is simply part of a mounting threat to the Red Sea, which is far more than an energy route, it's one of the world's most important trade routes. The United Kingdom has previously played an active role in ensuring, as part of the international community, to help keep that route open. Are we planning to do the same thing now?

01:52:47 - 01:53:44

Speaker 69

The noble Lord, Lord Grayling, makes an excellent point about the importance of that region. I can speak as somebody who, on an exchange tour with the Royal Navy, sailed and served through the Suez Canal, the Red Sea, and into the Gulf. So I know that region very well. And you're absolutely right about its importance, of course to this country, but actually almost more to some other parts of the world, not least Asia, with the current crisis and the difficulties with getting through the strait to the south of where the incident took place. And so I think we need to think of our allies around the world, some of whom will be actually more affected than we are.

And in terms of our actions, as we know, the best way to resolve these kind of threats and activity is through diplomacy, work alongside our allies, and we will continue that work, I assure him.

01:53:44 - 01:54:25

Speaker 80

My Lords, may I suggest that if any noble Lords wish to leave the chamber, they do so now before I call next business. My Lords, motion for debate, independent schools, Lord Lexden.

01:54:25 - 02:06:42

Alistair Cooke

My Lords, a couple of years ago, in the autumn of 2024, when I was in better health, I introduced two debates on the imposition of VAT on independent school fees, due to come into effect on the 1st of January 2025. Most speakers in those debates referred to the grave difficulties that independent schools and the families of their pupils would face as a result of Labour's education tax, the first to be introduced in Britain, and apart from a disastrous experiment in Greece, the first in Europe. The government added further to the costs of independent schools last year, and in the process helped jack up their fees after five years in which fee rises had been lower than wage inflation, by scrapping the exemption from business rates that most of them enjoyed by virtue of being charities, just like the VAT exemption, both of them scurrilously misrepresented by Labour as tax breaks. Independent schools were hit again by the increase in employers' national insurance contributions.

I declare my interests as a former general secretary of the Independent Schools Council, ISC for short, and the current president of the Independent Schools Association, one of the ISC's constituent bodies. The ISC represents some 1,400 schools where around 80% of the pupils in the independent sector are educated. The Independent Schools Association has some 700 schools, a large slice of the total in its membership. As I have stressed on previous occasions, it is among these 700 schools that many of the small schools so prevalent in the independent sector today and so valued by their local communities are to be found. Large, well-known schools that fascinate the public and the media are the exception, not the rule.

My Lords, article after article and survey after survey have provided evidence of the strain that the government's education tax is placing on hardworking families. The latest, a survey by Parentkind, found that 40% of parents with children in independent schools have been forced to cut back on household spending to meet the cost of their children's education. These are the people who work extra hours, forgo holidays, put off replacing the family car because they believe an independent school is right for their child. The education tax increases the sacrifices that they have to make. My Lords, the independent sector's contribution extends far beyond this country.

Independent schools are a major export success story and an important source of British soft power, helping attract talented young people to the United Kingdom and enhance Britain's reputation overseas. This is something the government should be championing, not chipping away at. Together, independent schools generate more than 3 billion annually through education exports and transnational education, despite intense international competition. At home, independent schools stand ready to use their expertise to help raise standards and deliver national education priorities. One clear opportunity for this is for them to work with state schools in meeting the government's new enrichment benchmarks.

These expect pupils to have access to civic engagement, arts and culture, outdoor adventure, life and future skills, and sport and physical activity, but the government have confirmed that no dedicated funding will be provided to schools to deliver this ambition. Independent-state school partnerships already make a major contribution in these areas. In the past year, more than 1,000 ISC schools have worked with state school colleagues in nearly 10,000 partnership projects across sport, music, the arts, and academic collaboration. These range from sharing facilities and running joint lessons and events to seconding staff and helping state school sixth formers with university applications. All represent invaluable opportunities for children at no cost to the state.

Sadly, the government have shown remarkably little interest in supporting and strengthening this work, even as they place greater expectations on schools to broaden pupils' opportunities. My Lords, the government claim that falling pupil numbers in England's independent schools reflect the wider decline in the school-age population, but the figures don't bear this out. Pupil losses in independent schools have been more than triple the decline in the school population as a whole.

The government also trot out the line that more independent schools have opened than closed since the introduction of the education tax. This disguises the importance of the loss of mainstream independent schools, many of them centuries-old centres of academic excellence. Mainstream schools account for 82% of the 106 school closures so far under the impact of the education tax. The schools that have opened, though numerically larger, are for the most part very different. The independent sector now has many more special schools catering for children with acute and complex special needs, which account for some 90% of the newcomers.

The growth of specialist provision is both welcome and necessary at a time of rising demand for SEND support, but the government fail to acknowledge the change in the character of the independent sector that this trend represents. Many places in special schools are commissioned and funded by local authorities, and where an independent school is named in a child's education, health and care plan, the local authority can also reclaim the VAT. My Lords, the government may argue that closures are in line with long-established trends, but the average capacity of the schools that have closed since the introduction of the education tax has been almost double that of schools which closed in the preceding 10 years. The casualties of the government's education tax include Malvern St James in Worcestershire, closed after 133 years; Durham High School, closed after 142 years; Ruthin School in Denbighshire, closed after 742 years; Thetford Grammar School in Norfolk, closed after nearly 1,400 years. Labour have been in government for little more than two years, yet the damage they have done is considerable.

Every school closure means lost jobs, disrupted local supply chains, and children losing a community that may have been part of their lives for years. The effects are often particularly severe in rural areas. Reports on closures refer to distraught teachers, anxiety amongst parents forced to find a new school at short notice, and children having to move midway through their A-levels. Mr Campbell-Harrison, head of St Gerard's School in Bangor, which closed in July after more than 100 years, has told me: "VAT, the loss of business rates relief and higher national insurance pushed us over the edge. More than 30 members of staff lost their jobs, with some unable to make mortgage payments and few comparable posts available locally.

We gave families as much notice as we could so that the children had a chance to find places before September. Some families have struggled to find suitable places, while some children now need to travel an hour and a half each way to get to school, an exhausting three-hour daily commute for a child. In an area where employment is already scarce, the closure has taken more than 1 million pounds a year out of the local economy." That is what Labour's education tax means in practice. Ministers have called the VAT exemption a subsidy, but of course the truth is the reverse.

Independent school parents subsidise the state by educating their children at no cost to the taxpayer. Every child who moves into the state sector will cost the taxpayer more than 8,500 pounds a year. The more children who are forced by the education tax to leave independent schools, the higher the cost will be and proceeds of the tax will drop dramatically. The evidence from Scotland is stark. The introduction of VAT there is already estimated to be costing more than it is raising.

Analysis by Biggar Economics, commissioned by the Scottish Council for Independent Schools, estimates that VAT on independent school fees will cost the Scottish taxpayer some 16 million this year. Over time, the annual cost is projected to rise to a staggering 181 million. Labour claimed that this policy would help fund the recruitment of 6,500 new teachers. Ministers may well try to shift the manifesto goalposts to suit their current communication strategy, but the stark reality is that the number of full-time equivalent teachers in state schools has fallen by 2,322 since 2023-24.

With teacher numbers down, where is the money going? The former Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer even suggested that the education tax had enabled the government to make, and I quote, "the largest investment in a generation in affordable housing." My Lords, Labour may dislike independent schools, but the public takes a different view. Opinion polls show that more than half of respondents believe that independent schools have a positive impact nationally and in their local communities, with fewer than one in 10 believing that the impact is negative. Independent schools are part of our cultural heritage, a source of educational excellence, a great British success story, and a powerful instrument of soft power around the world.

The government should recognize that they are a national asset worth protecting. But the sad truth is that the government won't admit is that this policy was never driven by economics. It was driven by ideology, by the old prejudice that state schools are an enemy to be overcome rather than a national asset to be supported. They are taxing families to the hilt, placing an impossible burden on some of our finest institutions, and adding pressure to a state system that is already at capacity at secondary level, and the stark consequences are now before us. In assessing the effects of their education tax, the government continue to rely on HMRC's tax information and impact note, which was drawn up almost two years ago before the policy took effect.

It must be reviewed. The government may point to the Office of Budget Responsibility's slightly higher revenue forecast in 2025, but that revision largely reflected schools having to pass on more of the tax than the government originally expected. It does not take account of the subsequent fall in pupil numbers, further school closures, or the additional costs falling on the state sector. A review is essential. There is also a need for a clear and robust methodology for estimating the revenue raised by VAT on independent school fees in each tax year.

My Lords, last week the Secretary of State said that "my interest is in the 93% of children who are educated in the state sector." Does she have no interest in the more than half a million children educated outside it and their families? No interest in the hundreds of teachers who have lost their jobs or the countless supply chains that have been affected? No interest in the wider economic consequences of this policy or the damage to our international education exports? She should begin to show some interest because surely, my Lords, every child and every school matters.

I beg to move.

02:06:42 - 02:06:45

Speaker 81

The question is that this motion be agreed to.

02:06:45 - 02:15:51

David Alton

It's a pleasure to be able to follow the noble Lord, Lord Lexden, today, not least because we've missed his well-informed and always wise and measured voice, and it's good to see him back in his customary place. I supported him, my Lords, when he spoke in September 2024, and I do so again today, and I endorse especially what he said at the end of his remarks about the need for an independent review of the assumptions that were made in introducing this particular policy. It's not just on this issue, but I don't think that we do enough post-legislative scrutiny. We push through legislation and new policies, and too often we don't go back to see whether they did what was on the tin, whether they did what was expected of them. I also would like to ask the noble Baroness the Minister to comment on a specific figure which the noble Lord cited around the cost of placing a child in the state sector.

The figure that I think we've been given in the past was £7,690 for each additional state school pupil derived and applied. How was that figure derived and applied, and do the government still stand by that figure today?

Now, for the record, my Lords, I did not attend an independent school. My father was a demob desert rat at the end of the Second World War and married my mother, who was an immigrant whose first language was Irish. I'm a typical grammar school boy whose family was rehoused to a council flat on an overspill estate. My parents and wonderful teachers were the reason I became a beneficiary of the 1944 Education Act, the first from either side of my family to enter higher education. I believe it is the duty of the state to facilitate quality educational opportunities for all, my Lords, not for ninety-three percent or seven percent, but for all.

As a teacher, I taught in the voluntary aided and state sectors and have been a governor of schools in the state, voluntary aided and state sectors. My own children and grandchildren have had a mixture of voluntary aided and independent education. In another place, I fought general elections for the commitment to increase income tax based on the ability to pay by a penny in the pound to improve state education. So I've never seen this as a binary or ideological issue, and I've always supported the independent sector and have challenged the ideological caricature of independent schools as sort of mini-Ettons replete with straw boaters and top hats and tails. The noble Lord Lord Lexden referred to exceptions, not the rule, and I agree with him.

That caricature is simply not true and doesn't lead to considered debate. It's simply wrong to suggest that all parents with children in independent schools are wealthy, which is why I opposed the targeted VAT tax, which takes little account of the ability to pay or of individual circumstances. Some middle-income families stretch their finances significantly and make great sacrifices and feel the twenty percent increase acutely. Some children in independent schools come from straitened circumstances. That money should be an impediment is one of the reasons why I broke ranks while I was in the House of Commons and voted for the assisted places scheme, and I would like to see more assisted places instead of none.

My Lords, in our 2024 debate, I pointed out that one hundred and sixty-eight thousand children were receiving financial support from independent schools, often through bursary schemes, while ten thousand were paying no fees. In 2026, the Independent Schools Council census established that ISC schools provided five hundred and thirty-eight point five million in means-tested fees assistance to pupils, with more than half of pupils receiving means-tested bursaries having over half of their fees remitted. That is remarkable. This is something to celebrate, not to denigrate. By pushing schools to the brink of financial ruin, it jeopardizes the good which these schools can do.

It's often the beneficiaries then who suffer, not those with ocean-deep pockets. Let me illustrate, my Lords, what I mean. Last Friday, I had a conversation with a bright young woman who told me that her grandfather had won a challenging custody battle to bring her up. He's used his resources to provide a stable and fulfilling education in an independent school for his granddaughter.

In parenthesis, where such schools have boarding facilities, a really committed pastoral team can literally be a lifeline. In reply to a question I tabled to the Noble Lord, Lord Livermore, and answered on the 17th of September 2024, the government confirmed that 20% VAT education tax would "also apply to boarding services". But by pricing families out of such services, it's hard to see how it meets the government's worthy objective that every child should get the best start in life. The cabinet minister recently discussed her decision to send three of her own children to independent schools. In putting her children's needs first, she is doing the right thing and should be defended for doing so.

Being able to exercise choice, not defending ideology, should be axiomatic. Let's also be clear, my Lords, in interrogating the economic justifications advanced in favour of this policy, we've done too much muddying of the waters. The statistics are worthy of intense scrutiny. For example, in the excellent library note that we have been provided with for today's debate, they say, I quote, "published figures do not fully capture the impact of the tax changes because they include independent special schools, which are largely unaffected by the new measures", close quotes. Simon Hyde, CEO of the Heads' Conference, said this is creating, his words, "a confusing picture".

Yes, my Lords, there have been some new schools, but 90% of new openings have been special schools, while 106 mainstream schools, some of which the Noble Lord, Lord Lexden referred to and which have long and historic roots, have been closed. Since 2024, according to the department's own figures, the cohort of children in independent schools has fallen by 33,231, double the estimate of 14,000 that your Lordships were given back in 2024. There are now 560,300 pupils in independent schools. That's nearly 4% down on the previous year. The largest reductions were seen in the key intake years: 5.2% in reception year, 5.6% in year 7, and 6.6% in year 12.

And it's also dissembling to suggest that the loss of 30,000 places is attributable to demographics. Unprecedented pupil losses in independent schools have been triple the decline in the school population as a whole. Now, to inform the debate, can the Noble Baroness please tell us what is the average annual cost then to the state sector in educating these children who've had to leave independent schools? What assessment has been made of the educational consequences of disrupting a child's education and moving them from one school to another? Can she tell us how many more independent schools she expects to close?

How many children will be displaced? What are the current estimates of the revenues being raised this year by extending VAT on school fees and removing business rate charitable relief? In summary, taxing education is simply wrong in principle. It's a breach of human rights, and I might say that in the EU would be a breach of Article 132 of the EU VAT Directive, which exempts education from tax. Our starting point, my Lords, should be that encouraging diversity and parental choice is a good.

Suggesting that all schools will be able to absorb punitive taxes was clearly wrong, and where schools have done so, it's been at the cost of services to parents, including bursaries and the less well-off. And note too that it has disproportionately hit low-fee faith schools.

Where schools have closed, there's been heartache, disruption, the loss of jobs, the loss of revenue into the local economy, and sometimes of heritage buildings and community assets. Lord Lexden was right, therefore, to ask the House to consider all of this again and to reiterate the need to value all schools, state or independent. And I hope that we will have the review of this policy which he has rightly called for.

02:15:51 - 02:24:58

John Redwood

My Lords, I should declare that my son does teach in the private sector, but I won't be drawing on his experiences or the views of his school in my remarks. I wish to be broader than that. Jealousy is not a great emotion. It produces bitterness and unpleasantness. And I think if jealousy gets woven into politics, it usually ends up damaging the people and parties pursuing it rather than helping them.

I remember a previous government didn't like grammar schools very much, and they decided that the families, the parents of children in the surrounding area of the grammar school, where a big majority would not have children attending the grammar school, could be given a vote on the future of the grammar school, because I think they thought that that would result in the abolition of grammar schools. Whereas when they held a vote, they discovered that the parents of pupils who had not got into the grammar school had no problem with the fact that very bright pupils had got into the grammar school, and they saw that as a good for the wider society and the local community, not as a bad. And I think it's a warning in there. Now, I think we are fortunate indeed in this country that we have some very outstanding private sector schools, some of them very famous and well-known, and some of them deliver a high quality of education. And Labour will point out that they are partly able to do that because they have more income per pupil going into the school because they can charge much higher fees.

And there is some truth in that, but there's also truth in the energy and the standards that they set and what they expect also contributes to their great success. So I think when we have a great success like this, clever governments want to build bridges, not create barriers. They wish to see how we can allow those well-endowed schools still to flourish, but how more of us can benefit from that process. Now, my parents weren't rich enough to send me to a private school, but I benefited from the fact that my local state primary put me in for a competitive examination to get a place at a direct grant school. And I was fortunate enough to pass that exam, and so I was then able to attend as a day pupil what was primarily a boarding school paid for by richer parents to send their children there.

And it worked very harmoniously, and I think we benefited from the exchanges between us from our different backgrounds and our different attitudes, the different contributions we could make to that school. Now, a previous government thought that kind of thing was wrong, and so the direct grant school idea disappeared, and those schools had to become full fee-paying schools or perish. But then there was the assisted places scheme, which was a similar kind of operation, and I think that too is an excellent idea because it gives people from low-income backgrounds who would respond well to the ethos of the school offering the place that opportunity to do so, and again blends the excellence of the private school with the opportunity of those who can compete for the places. Now, quite a lot of our great public schools, as endowment charities, are aware of their need to pursue wider charitable purposes in the educational area. And so some of those great schools do help the surrounding state schools by offering lectures, by offering specialist tuition, by organizing joint events, by being good members of the local community.

That is something again that we should value.

It is, of course, something they should do as charities, but it is there and it enriches the wider experience. We have some extremely good state schools. I'm very proud that they should be there. But we also have some state schools who could do considerably better. And that is where having both great state schools and some great private schools who can act as mentors or guides or lighthouses to illuminate a better future can be so valuable.

So I do think the government should look again about the opportunity for social and educational enrichment which can come from more sharing of facilities, more joint venturing, more cross-feeding of good ideas from state sector to private sector and from private sector to state sector. I think this unfortunate policy experiment that the government has unleashed on private sector schools is very revealing about the wider debate of the impact of certain policy interventions. One of my persistent themes, as noble Lords will probably have picked up, is that tax is usually very damaging and that tax is usually something you impose to stop people doing things rather than to encourage doing things, because it very rarely does that. And the government decided to unleash three very big tax rises on these private schools: the VAT that we're describing, which directly has to be paid by the families of the pupils going there, but also the very big hit on business rates and the very big hit on employee costs when, of course, the main item in a private school's budget is employment. And it's not just the employment of the teachers, but also the employment of all the support staff, some of them not that well paid, and these jobs are at risk the higher you put up the national insurance along with the other two taxes.

And we've seen and heard already in this debate that the result of this treble tax attack has been a substantial number of school closures, as predicted. And it's not good enough to say, well, there have been openings on the other side, because as we know, those openings are of different kinds of schools, often with different revenue streams, and you can't get away from the fact that you've lost quite a lot of good schools who just found the treble taxes too much. And we also know that some 33,000 places have had to be found in state schools as a result of the displacement. And that's 33,000 families and individual pupils whose lives have been profoundly changed. And it's not easy for a child to change school at an unusual time other than when everybody's changing school, going from primary to secondary, because you lose all your friends and then you go into a new school and maybe nobody wants to be friends with you because they can be very cliquey or difficult as groups of children.

And so it's those kind of issues which the government seems totally insensitive to, that they think it's worthwhile changing the lives of 33,000 young people and their families for some greater good, which just seems to be the idea that they don't really like people being able to buy a decent education for their children.

I would imagine that the cost of those children transferring is around 300 million a year, applying very rough multiple to the number of children. And a government that is very short of cash is not well advised to invent a policy which immediately imposes an additional 300 million a year of public spending. And we wait to see how much extra revenue growth there has really been, because as we've heard in the Scottish example, you can end up worse off when you take the balance of disappointing revenue into account with the extra costs. One of the social consequences of imposing a tax upon the schools, which means higher fees for parents to pay, is that many of the schools will not close, but they will change the people they educate. And so we will see a pattern where you have these schools for very rich foreigners, so that is an export, and for very rich people at home, but all the other strivers who would like that are priced out of the market.

Now, surely that's the opposite kind of social change to the one Labour should want. They shouldn't want the schools only to be for the children of billionaires or multi-millionaires. Wouldn't it be better if they reflected more widely and offered education to a wider number in the community? So please, government, think again, understand these schools can be a great bonus for our society.

02:24:58 - 02:33:15

Speaker 82

My Lords, what a pleasure it is to see the noble Lord, Lord Lexden, back in his place this afternoon and to hear from him in his usual erudite fashion on a subject on which he has experience and expertise of many, many decades. We have all benefited from hearing him this afternoon, and I agree with everything that he said and all of the points made by the noble Lords, Lord Alton and Lord Redwood, so I won't repeat those points, my Lords. I just want to ask one question, which is: who is the most damaged by this policy brought forward by this government? Now, there's no point, my Lords, in asking who benefits most, because nobody benefits. Nobody benefits.

The Minister will undoubtedly say that the Exchequer benefits to a very small amount in tax take, and that some of that tax take can be invested in education generally, but that is not a strong argument. The fact is that the education of our children is the responsibility of everyone in our society, because we all want to see the coming generation having the very, very best start and the very best opportunity in life. And the better educated our population is, then the better is the economic hope for future generations. So we all want to see a better education system. But dividing the education system into 93% and 7% and pretending in some way that these are separate is simply nonsense.

The fact is that the education system is one system as a whole. It affects every young person, every child in our society, in every part of our country. And if you damage any part of the education system, logically you damage all of it. So my question is: who suffers the most?

And the answer, my Lords, is not the families who are genuinely wealthy and who are despised by this government, but who are genuinely wealthy because they go on paying for their children in independent education. The people who suffer, as ever, are those who are at the margins. First of all, there are the 33,000 children who have had to be removed from independent schools and sent to other schools. Clearly, they suffer. But, my Lords, that means that 33,000 other children have been displaced from other schools.

Now, in any given geographical catchment area, what one will usually find is there might be an independent school, possibly two independent schools, and there will be three or four really good state schools, because many of our state schools, my Lords, are excellent and provide an excellent education. But then there will be seven or eight state schools which don't provide an excellent education because they have some disadvantages and some difficulties, and they possibly don't have the parental support and they're possibly in an area which suffers from some other disadvantages. The children who most benefit from attending an excellent state school are those who are at the margin and lifted out of an area of disadvantage, taken away from a school where they would not have flourished and have the opportunity of going to an excellent state school which will give them a truly good start in life. Those are the children who are going to suffer most from this government's policy, because the children who have left the independent schools are likely to live in a catchment area and are likely to have parents who know what you have to do to get your child into an excellent state school. So a child who has parents who understand the education system and who contribute to the education system is likely to succeed and to have a good opportunity regardless of whether they go to an independent school or an excellent state school.

Those who will suffer, my Lords, are those who would have had the chance of a place at an excellent state school but have lost that place because that place is now taken by a child who had previously been at an independent school but who has vociferous middle-class parents who know what to do to get the best education for their children. The children who will suffer are those whose parents are not involved in the education system, are not well educated themselves and do not know how to get their children into the excellent state schools. I am not making this up, my Lords. This is fact, and I, when I was a constituency Member of Parliament - I know your Lordships don't like one mentioning being a Member of Parliament and representing a constituency, but when you've done so for 27 years, as the Minister knows very well, it's in your heart, it's in your being, and I personally over 27 years dealt with hundreds and hundreds of families who were trying to get their children into the best schools, and I know what is now happening. The places at the excellent state schools are being taken by children who were previously at independent schools but whose parents can no longer afford it.

And so the people who will actually be most damaged by this policy and by the way in which this government is taking the education system are those children who are now being denied a place at an excellent state school. They are the people that we should be lifting up in life, not putting down. They are the people who deserve every bit of help that we as the community as a whole can give them. And it might be that whoever devised this government policy, and they didn't do it in order to raise more money for the exchequer because that, as we know from the simple arithmetic, is incidental. Whoever devised this government policy thought that they were going to damage the despised middle classes.

That's not who is being damaged. The people who are being damaged are the children who would have had an opportunity which has now been taken away from them. And I hope that this government will recognize that while they say that they care about the 93%, I care about 100% of the children in this country and the government is failing those at the margin and it should change this policy.

02:33:15 - 02:40:52

Guy Opperman

My Lords, I rise to support every word spoken by my noble friend Lord Lexden in his fine and typically erudite opening speech and indeed the words of all other speakers so far in this debate. It is telling that the government whips have not been able to muster a single backbencher to support the political choice to impose VAT on independent schools. I also note the lack of any speakers in this debate from the backbenches of the Liberal Democrats. For the noble Baroness the Minister today really is a case of herself alone. Can I also say what a pleasure it is to see my noble friend Lord Lexden back in his place today.

There are many noble Lords on these benches who have had reason to be indebted to him over many years, not least due to the fact that he gave a number of us our first job. So it is very good to see him back. My Lords, for the avoidance of doubt and like a number of others in this debate, my entire schooling was spent in the state sector, in my case in the predominantly working class constituency of East Leeds, where the local MP, a chap called Healey, was for five years in charge of the nation's finances where he presided over a severe debt crisis and bankrupted Britain. My Lords, I am talking about 50 years ago, but it does seem like today. My final school, Temple Moor, was a fine grammar school that turned comprehensive some six years before I attended, though it retained some of the grammar school ethos during my time there.

In supporting my noble friend therefore, I am clearly not defending anything from which I have ever personally benefited. Like my noble friend however, along with others on these benches, I utterly deplore and condemn the nasty, spiteful and vindictive war being waged against the independent sector by this Labour government. As has been pointed out, since it became clear that VAT was going to be introduced following the 2024 general election, 106 mainstream independent schools have closed and there has been a net loss of 79.

According to the Department for Education's own 2026 census, the number of pupils educated in the independent sector has, as we have heard, fallen by over 33,000 in the past two years. That is well over double the 14,000 estimated by the government in the short term, and is rapidly approaching the 35,000 they said would be lost in the long term, though some studies predict the final total could be as high as 90,000. And if anything epitomised the heartless approach of this Labour government, it was the decision to impose VAT in the middle of an academic year, with the inevitable consequences and traumas for schools, teachers, parents, and above all students. So will the government now commission a credible independent review of the evidence, assumptions, and modelling and forecasting underpinning these policies, tested against experience since their implementation? My Lords, in my own area of Yorkshire, some particularly fine independent schools have been forced to close their doors.

Fulneck, part of the historic Moravian settlement in Pudsey, which opened in 1753 during the reign of King George II, and which educated, amongst others, Herbert Asquith and Diana Rigg, Mrs Peel to some, as well as one of my closest friends, shut in July last year due to rising operational costs and falling numbers. I well remember on hearing the news my friend texting me to say how devastated he was, a reaction shared by many others. An institution that was part of the that was at the heart of the local community and a unique part of the heritage of the West Riding of Yorkshire is now gone forever. As the heart-wrenching statement issued by Fulneck put it, this isn't just the end of a school, it's the end of a community and a history and a home for so many. At the same time, Queen Margaret's in York, educating girls since 1901, was forced to shut, citing mounting financial pressures with the introduction of VAT, increased national insurance and pension contributions, and the ending of charitable status business rates relief as major contributory factors.

The site has recently been sold to a developer for a reported 5 million pounds. They were followed last December by the oldest independent prep school in Leeds, Moorlands, after 127 years. They too pointed to VAT, national insurance and business rates relief, and it's a similar story with Wakefield Independent School. And if I can briefly stray outside of Yorkshire, like my noble friend Lord Lexden, I too was very sad this July to see the closure of Durham High School for Girls after 142 years, not least because that's where my partner's three hugely gifted daughters, Imogen, Olivia and Libby, each received an outstanding education. They are full of sorrow that the institution which has hopefully set them up for life is no more.

My Lords, I am the first to accept that there are a number of factors at play which can lead to school closures, such as falling numbers. What is, however, now undeniable is the devastating financial impact of the policies pursued by this Labour government. They have hammered the independent sector, as my noble friend Lord Redesdale pointed out, with a triple whammy of of increased national insurance, removal of business rates relief, and the imposition of the of 20% VAT, the first ever tax on education. For many independent schools struggling with tight margins, this has been enough to finish them. As we have heard, the government seeks to justify all of this by arguing that their focus is on the 93% educated in the state sector.

My Lords, given my own history, I will take no lessons on the importance of providing good state schools for everyone.

Yet the argument that state schools will be improved by waging war on the independent sector is little short of madness. As my noble friend Lord Lexden pointed out, the education tax was supposed to help pay for six and a half thousand more teachers, but teacher numbers have actually fallen. At a time when more students from independent schools that have closed have to be accommodated within the state sector, leading inevitably to higher class sizes for many. Then in June last year, we were told by Keir Starmer on X, as my noble friend stated, that the money was actually being used to invest in affordable social housing. So which is it?

And of course, Labour's attack on the academies that they once championed risks the huge progress in the state sector, which under my party saw English students soar to the top of international league tables in reading and maths, and the number of schools rated as good rise from 68 to 90%. My Lords, Labour governments, rooted in socialist dogma, undermined academic excellence in the 1960s and 70s, and now this back-to-the-1970s government is doing the same today. They should be utterly ashamed of themselves for the damage, disruption and distress that their policies have caused and continue to cause, and I look forward to a future Conservative government reversing their nasty, cruel and vindictive policies.

02:40:52 - 02:43:46

Norman Blackwell

My Lords, I should declare my interest as a governor of an independent school, the Yehudi Menuhin School in Cobham. Like others, I'd like to share my thanks to my noble friend Lord Lexden for initiating this debate. And I share his views and those of the other speakers so far on the damage that this policy has done to the independent sector in general. The government should recognise that parents who send their children to independent schools are effectively paying twice. They pay once through their taxation to support the state sector, and then they pay again.

And they wouldn't do that, my Lords, unless they believed that they could achieve a better education or meet some special needs through paying double to send their children to an independent school. So if the government is in pursuit of fairness, rather than trying to bring down these high-quality schools through additional levies, it would be much fairer to focus on bringing up the standard of education in the state schools so that overall we had a better education system for the 100%. But my Lords, I'd like to focus my brief remarks on the specialist schools, the specialist music and dance schools in particular. These schools offer a very unique, focused education for a relatively small number of highly talented children. These children are supported and inspired by being in a peer group of other talented children who share their passion for music.

And that environment and that support is simply not available in normal schools. And these handful of specialist music schools are shaping the next generation of musical leaders who are a vital national resource for a sector that is not only important culturally but important economically. Like other music schools, the Yehudi Menuhin School attempts to operate a needs-blind admissions policy. It seeks the most talented children who are capable of achieving the highest standards, regardless of their social background, their economic status, the ability of their parents to pay fees.

02:43:30 - 02:46:38

Speaker 85

But with only 93 pupils in that school, providing a full academic education alongside specialist music training means that costs are very high. The full fees for a boarder amount to some £50,000 a year. And as a result, alongside a needs-blind admission policy, only around one in 10 parents pay the full fees. The rest need financial support to reduce the fees to the level they can support. VAT at 20% adds up to £10,000 on a £50,000 fee and proportionate depending on how much the parents contribute.

My Lords, since parents who are being supported by bursaries and scholarships are already paying as much as they can afford, they cannot simply pay another 20%. This inevitably increases demand for financial support to maintain their children at the school. Now, we're fortunate in this country, as the noble Minister knows, to have the government-funded Music and Dance Scheme, which offers means-tested support to UK residents at these schools. But that has not kept pace with inflation over the years and has not been raised to pay for the VAT levy. And these schools attract talented children from all around the world, many of whom aren't eligible for the MDS grant.

So for those coming from overseas, all the burden of funding bursaries and paying for the additional VAT that parents can't pay falls on the school and the limited funds that schools are able to raise from charitable donations. And as others have said, there have been other financial pressures on these schools from inflation, from the National Insurance increase, from the loss of business rates relief. There will be further costs from implementing the loss of zero-hour contracts on staff, many of whom are part-time music teachers. So the VAT levy now poses a real danger to the financial viability of these specialist schools, which play such an important role in maintaining the UK's cultural leadership. I'd prefer the government to think again about the wider application of VAT to private schools across the board, as many other speakers have urged.

But if they are not prepared to do that, could I please ask the noble lady the Minister if the government would at least reconsider whether the unique specialist music and dance schools should be exempted from this policy.

02:46:38 - 02:55:52

Guy Black

My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lord Lexden on securing this debate and on his powerful speech. It's very good to see him in his place after a challenging few months. My Lords, this is a really important debate. As the government frankly buries its head in the sand, wilfully refusing properly to monitor the impact of this dreadful policy, it falls to this House to do so. I declare my interest as chairman of governors at Brentwood School and honorary president of the Boarding Schools' Association.

I have three points. The first, a general one about the implementation of this spiteful policy. When this government was elected, Keir Starmer made a great deal about restoring trust in politics. Before its first King's Speech in 2024, he said, "The fight for trust is the battle that defines our political era."

Well, trust is founded on honesty, but with this policy Labour has always been far from honest. They said there would be limited impact on the numbers attending independent schools. They were not honest. The number of pupils has fallen by over 33,000 as we've heard, double the 14,000 they glibly estimated. They said there would not be significant school closures.

They were not honest. 106 mainstream schools have shut their doors, destroying jobs, displacing pupils, and wrecking communities. They said they would use the money raised to fund new teaching places. They were not honest. The number of teachers has fallen.

The government said it was closing a loophole, knowing full well this was no loophole. It was not honest. Education has never been taxed and by introducing one, the government has in fact created a glaring anomaly. No wonder they did not want to undertake a proper consultation before introducing this policy. They knew they would be found out, and so they have been.

This is not an education policy but a class warfare policy which has hit children and hard-working parents hard, and it is fraudulent. How can the government claim to want to restore trust in politics when they so brazenly introduce a policy knowing they are perpetrating a con trick on the public? It is breathtaking hypocrisy, little wonder trust in politics is still so low. My Lords, nowhere has the impact of this policy been more harshly felt than among our boarding schools, which is my second point. The UK's boarding schools are the best in the world, a powerful tool of soft power, contributing significantly to our economy.

They're a jewel in the crown of the sector, with schools like Brentwood School attracting pupils from across the globe. 33 nationalities are represented among our boarders. But VAT has hit boarding schools hard. The number of boarders at independent schools has dropped by 12% to around 65,000 pupils between 2024 and 2026, a rate double that of the sector as a whole. More than 25 independent boarding schools have either closed, announced their impending closure, or stopped boarding entirely.

In the three years before the imposition of VAT, that figure was only nine, a third of the current rate, destroying the government's erroneous assertion that closures are simply part of a long-term trend. That is nonsense. This has disrupted children's education, put teachers and support staff out of work, and had a profound impact on local communities where their local boarding schools are a vital part of the fabric of local and community life. Given these stark statistics, can the noble lady the Minister tell us how she plans to stop this deeply damaging trend and protect the remaining boarding schools in the sector? There is also, my Lords, an international aspect to this issue.

The government's own international education strategy, published only in January, aims, quote, "collectively to grow education exports to £40 billion per year by 2030," and, quote, "promote the UK as a preferred destination to study." Well, to do that, the UK needs a healthy and competitive boarding school sector, yet the government's policies are deliberately undermining it. The number of international students in independent schools is down 12% since the imposition of VAT. If government is to stand any chance of meeting its own ambitions, it will have to revisit this policy. My Lords, following on from my noble friend Lord Blackwell, my final point is about music and the arts, and I declare an interest as chairman of the Royal College of Music.

Now, the case has frequently been made in this House about the tragic decline of music education in state schools, something this government, despite its promises, has absolutely failed to reverse. That has put a huge burden on the independent sector, both to protect the future of music as it dies out in the state sector, and to do what it can to support those in state schools who are desperate to learn an instrument or take part in an orchestra or even just to sing, but who have no opportunity to do so. The role of independent schools in this area is vital. It's not something, my Lords, we have to do, it's something we absolutely want to do. In the last year alone, the Independent Schools Council has recorded almost 10,000 partnerships between independent schools on academic collaboration and enrichment.

About 2,500 of these centered on the arts, with over 600 schools providing over 2,200 partnerships to support state schools with joint musical events, participation in music lessons, dance events, access to concert halls and many other areas. Schools like Brentwood, which has one of the finest music departments in the country, provide an excellent example. This year, we're committed to an amazing project to offer all state, local state primary schools the opportunity for their pupils to participate in a massed concert performance of Rutter's Mass for Children at Brentwood Cathedral, part of an ongoing commitment to local partnerships. One of the reasons we're doing it is because, tragically, even singing, so crucial for young lives, is dying out in primary schools, and we want to help. But that takes time and money, something which is now under real pressure as a result of the imposition of VAT and the impact on revenues.

Elsewhere in the country, we see other shining examples of partnerships to ensure children from state schools get access to arts education their own schools can't provide. King's College School in Wimbledon partners with local schools to deliver an annual community drama production. For more than 20 years, Lichfield Cathedral School's music partnership has enabled over 30,000 pupils in 500 schools across the West Midlands to benefit from high-quality music education. The King's School Canterbury has for seven years provided pupils from Canterbury's city center schools with free access to orchestral instrument tuition. The list goes on and on.

Yet the government's misguided policies have put all that at risk, and I can't understand why they don't see that. As revenues come under pressure, it becomes more and more difficult to provide such partnerships, along with bursary funding increasingly demand, particularly for quality music education. Who loses out? It's the children who lose out from this policy. My Lords, time is running out.

This debate has revealed the appalling impact of the education tax on the sector. I hope the noble lady, the minister, will reflect on it and at the very least commit to a fresh review of the impact of this policy, including the impact of the withdrawal of impact business rates relief, but do so with clear methodology and an open mind, preferably that would be a credible independent study. I also hope to hear from my own front bench, although I suspect I may not, a commitment, clear commitment to repeal this cruel tax when we return to office.

My Lords, in reply, I've no doubt the noble lady, as we've heard, will again say that she's interested in the 93% who go to state schools, and of course she's right to be so. But I believe that a Minister of the Crown must be interested in the 100% and not ignore 7% of children. My Lords, great damage has been done to our world-class independent schools. It's time to put dogma aside and put the interests of parents and children first.

02:55:52 - 03:04:51

Kevin Shinkwin

My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Black of Brentwood, although I probably can't match his passion and clarity. But I'd like to join others in congratulating my noble friend Lord Lexden on securing this debate. And also, as someone who benefited from an independent school's education as a scholarship boy with parents on the staff, I'd like to thank him for his leadership on this issue. It seems incredible that almost two years have passed since we debated this issue in this House, and since I pleaded with the noble Baroness Smith instead to urge the then Secretary of State and the Chancellor to take the SEN and disabilities of the 90,000 pupils without an EHCP into account and exempt them from the extension of VAT to independent schools. I said then that they and I looked to this Labour government to show them some understanding and compassion and to give them hope.

But hope there has been none. Instead, the policy was implemented regardless of the harm caused, especially to those pupils and their families. They were simply collateral damage in the wider ideological, to quote my noble friend, dogmatic crusade against the so-called privileged class, no matter that many only attended independent schools as a result of the huge sacrifices made by their families and at a time when the system underpinning state-funded provision is on the verge of collapse. In a series of questions for written answer two years ago, I asked the noble Baroness, among other things, what measures have been put in place to support children and the parents of children with autism and neurodiverse conditions required to move schools as a result of the education tax; what assessment the government had made of the capacity of local education authorities to accommodate and meet the needs of children with autism and neurodiverse conditions required to move schools; what processes the government have put in place to evaluate the impact on their mental health and their educational attainment; and what stakeholder groups have been involved in developing such processes; at what intervals would the evaluations be conducted.

I'd be very grateful if the noble Baroness the Minister could answer those questions today, as I'm afraid her response almost two years ago came nowhere close to addressing any of those points. The pupils with SEND and disabilities and their families still deserve answers. What the noble Baroness the Minister did say in her response to my questions was that the government did not anticipate that the VAT change, the education tax, and I quote, "will prompt notable movement into the state sector, and any movement is expected to take place over several years." Listening to what has already been said in today's debate, I'm not sure that that has been borne out. According to the latest DfE figures, as we've already heard, the number of pupils in the independent sector has fallen by 33,231, or 5.6%.

My Lords, to put that in context, it's already greater than the total movement into the state sector that His Majesty's government projected by 2029 to 2030. So these figures aren't just notable, they are unprecedented. And I think it's fair to say that the noble Baroness the Minister's answer to my parliamentary questions has therefore failed the test of time. So could I ask the noble Baroness the Minister to say whether the original cost-benefit assumptions and forecasts cited by ministers, including, as we've heard, the then Prime Minister, as justification for the punitive education tax, still stand? If they do, where is the monitoring and evaluation of the assumptions and forecasts to back them up?

My Lords, I'm sure we all look forward to seeing the results of the evaluation which the DfE has no doubt carried out in preparation for today's debate. I'd be grateful if the noble Baroness the Minister would confirm that she will write to me to say when the results of the evaluation will be published and that she will place the findings in the House of Lords library. Because unless and until she does, she should not be surprised if we reiterate the simple point that the education tax is not only disrupting SEND provision, but it's also undermining the government's ability to fix the SEND system, which is bankrupting local authorities as we speak. Surely an unintended consequence of the policy is that more families are understandably seeking an EHCP for their child, thereby exacerbating pressure on the state because the state has bizarrely made private school independent school provision less affordable.

My Lords, how does that make sense? My Lords, this counter-intuitive policy reminds me that however much I respect, and I do respect, individual members on the Labour benches, I could never subscribe to socialism because this policy demonstrates that deep within itself lurks a self-righteous spite and envy that blinds it to the tragic consequences of its actions. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the case of pupils with SEND attending independent schools. They and their hard-pressed families deserve not just an answer, but a rethink. I hope the noble Baroness the Minister will show that the government is listening.

03:04:51 - 03:19:25

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, the sixth of the first steps for change, remember them, in the Labour manifesto 2024, read, and I quote, recruit 6,500 new teachers, paid for by ending tax breaks for private schools. This remains an incensing canard. As we have plainly seen, it is not the case that the numbers of teachers in state schools has increased by 6,500. In fact, they have fallen. The worst of it was the idea frequently peddled that there were tax breaks for private schools.

What rot. Step back and look at the system as a whole. Parents of children at private schools who pay tax, and I declare my interest as one such parent, not only pay handsomely for the educational places used by their children, they are also not using the places to which their children are entitled in the state sector, funded of course by their own taxes, a point made so ably by my noble friend Lord Blackwell. And of course those places not taken up in the state sector can then be used by other children. All this is very far from being a tax break for private schools.

The former system was a system of mutual benefit, as my noble friend Lord Alton, he is my friend obviously, so correctly said during his speech. Our national neighbours do not tax education. In fact, it would be contrary to EU law for them to do so, as by as the noble Lord Lord Alton said during his speech. The ability to impose VAT on school fees was a Brexit benefit. The United Kingdom seems to be the only country in the world which chooses to tax charities which provide education, a factor which speaks for itself.

This government should learn lessons from the sensible, civilized and mutually beneficial approach to private education taken by the Irish government.

An approach which recognizes the benefit both to the child and to the state itself of a flourishing fee-paid education sector. The Irish government has a system which recognizes the fact that parents have paid by taxation into a state education system which they have elected not to use. Ireland has roughly the same proportion of pupils in fee-paid education, 6 to 7%. Yet in the Republic of Ireland, the state pays the salaries of all teachers and special needs assistants working in recognized private schools. Fees are set each year by the school and they are of course much reduced as a result of the policy and therefore fee-paid education is much more widely accessible.

The justification for this system was pithily stated by Norma Foley, the then minister for the Irish Minister for Education, in a response to a question in the Dáil on the 16th of April 2024. She said this: "If the parents of children in the fee-charging sector choose to send their children to the schools in the free education system, the state would have to fund those school places." Quite so, my Lords. Here though, as the noble Lord Lord Blackwell pointed out, parents pay twice and now pay VAT and other additional levies on education charged by this government. And this extra tax revenue is used for what?

Not more teachers as promised. Presumably it's spent on the ballooning welfare budget and the interest on the ever-increasing national debt. As we've heard from my noble friend Lord Lexden, we have 33,231 fewer pupils in the fee-paid sector over the last two years. 106 mainstream schools have closed and of those which have opened, 90% have been specialist schools which benefit from government funding, not least via EHCPs and are largely exempt from VAT, a point already made but which certainly bears repetition. There are certainly many fewer mainstream school places.

There are no winners from all this. Again, as my noble friend Lord Lexden said, in Scotland, analysis from Biggar Economics published in April 26 showed that the VAT raise there was costing more money than it was raising and the same will surely be shown to be true in England. British private education is a world leader. Why damage something we do so well, among the best in the world, undermined it seems only for the sake of dogma? So over 100 schools closed, thousands of staff have lost their jobs, thousands of children have had their education disrupted at a formative time in their life.

State pupils have lost the benefit of the use of facilities which they would have been able to use as a result of partnerships between the fee-paid and the state sector, as clearly again set out by my noble friends. And this is a trend which will surely continue and accelerate. No one wins from this policy. As my noble friend Lady Laing so eloquently said, the whole community suffers. Can the noble Lord the Minister point to a single child who has benefited from the policy, remembering not a single extra teacher has been hired, but very many have been harmed by it?

My Lords, I attended a boarding school in the 80s and was a governor of another one for 10 years in the 2010s. I spoke two years ago at the noble Lord Lord Lexden's debate.

Yes, it hardly seems as if it was two years, but it is, and it's great to see him back in his place. But I regret to say that things are even worse than the warnings that we issued at the time. More children impacted, more schools closed, and none of the revenues to pay for more state school teachers who are now having to work harder than ever. The damage hasn't just been to the charities that run these schools, or to parents ambitious for their children, or especially to twice as many children than the government expected displaced with disrupted schooling, subjects not taken to examination, peripatetic activities curtailed, and friendships broken. Oh no, the collateral damage has spread much further than that which we foretold.

To the staff. Back in 2024, I bumped into a man wearing a Langley school polo shirt. It turned out he was responsible for running the minibus enterprise comprising 27 vehicles together with drivers, himself, assistants and mechanics, a 35-person sustainable transport business. All under threat. His colleagues, cooks, cleaners, matrons and groundskeepers, not just the teachers.

These are the working people engaged in that education and I want to speak for them. And for the market towns where these schools don't just support the economy, they are the local economy. In the Shires, 106 mainstream schools have closed in places like Banbury, Bedstone, Hazelmere, Windlesham and Warminster. Lovely places with wonderful high streets and a much wider range of pubs, cafes and shops than their populations would normally sustain. These aren't just market towns, these are factory towns.

The schools are the factories, factories of education and learning. They underpin those economies, not just with their direct employed staff, but with local ecosystem of contractors and tradesmen in areas many with few alternative employment opportunities. They are damaged. The damage is also to the national economy where education has been a valuable invisible export, not that Labour understands these things. We've heard about the additional burden of business rates, 100 million pounds and national insurance.

But it's hard to quantify the impact on the 93% of state-educated children whose classes are now more crowded, who are forced to travel further as their catchment catchments have been made full up. Surrey is a case in point, a county where the parents, to echo Lady Lang, are born with sharp elbows. My Lords, if you start to treat these charities as businesses, why should they behave as charities? We've heard about the impact on the music and the arts. But cancelling bursaries for the child prodigy or scholarships for exceptional sportswomen from disadvantaged families helps nobody and only drives social inequality as well as harming our national sporting life.

We're all poorer for this. Why should these charities have bursaries, scholarships, public access to facilities in the evening, during the school holidays, if there is no incentive or regulatory reason to do? This government has failed the public interest test. I will not echo the important points made by my noble friend Lord Shinkwin about SEND. But my Lords, these schools are the solution to that, not the problem.

I visited the headmaster of a public school in Norfolk, 30% of the roll are supporting SEND or other children of other families in difficult situations. That is truly public interest, something that this government has swept away. And of course, it hasn't raised any money. Labour's class obsession has resulted in a net cost to the Exchequer. They have, the government has displayed a financial ignorance of the dynamic impact of this policy.

Because if this, schools are forced to close, you're looking at the loss of PAYE and the payment of benefits. The fundamental premise, this is a revenue raiser, is a false one. Because the really rich have just shrugged it off. Whilst the striving children of police officers, nurses, firefighters, soldiers and airmen, working people with aspiration and ambition for their children, they've felt the full force. And it's benighted so many who have their own challenges who just can't thrive in the state sector and for whom at least specialist private classes have been an option.

But they've been pushed out of reach. Well done Labour, attacking those with the quietest voices who need the greatest help. But it's not hard to see why this has been worse than expected. My Lords, I was a governor of a school with just 450 places. It typically made a surplus of about a quarter of a million pounds a year to fund reinvestment.

It did not have a lot of fat on its back. It was a charity. And in all these cases, the fees from about half a dozen boarders made the difference between profit and loss, surviving or failing. The finances were finely balanced. So the fees for just five boarders amounted to the entire profit of the charity.

If just five families found they couldn't afford the extra five grand a year or so, then all the 450 children in that school fell on the state. I warn of this leverage, which has tipped these schools over the edge and spoiled the life chances and exam success for hundreds of others, whilst adding to the burdens in the 93% who were educated by the state. Throwing thousands of lower paid staff, journeymen, local suppliers and yes, teachers on the dole. It was always going to be the case. This policy has failed in its objective.

It was dishonestly framed as a money spinner. But it's just been a class war pursued by the honourable member for Sunderland, who is pursuing her personal obsession with class, with children paying the price. The Prime Minister said things were going to be different. It turns out he's just the same. Jealousy, envy and grievance, perpetuating the class war, not providing the social mobility that a scholarship or a bursary can unleash.

My Lords, there is so much more I can say. But this, these proposals, born out of populist electioneering sloganeering, have resulted in more elitism and social inequality. Less opportunity for those with talent from the most modest background. Less charitable purpose for which the local communities will suffer. Slipping down our national and international sports rankings.

Less choice, fewer experts, exports and stunted economic growth. A catastrophic effect on the economic base of our market towns and their small tradesmen. Working people in isolated areas put out of work, struggling parents, additional burdens on local authorities, listed buildings left to moulder and driving even more children to the oversubscribed state schools. The real victims here are amongst the lowest paid and most educationally challenged, whilst our economy is weakened and the soft power that helps earn our place in the world is damaged, alongside our global reputation by levelling down that export which the world used to beat a path to our door for.

03:19:24 - 03:28:27

Magid Magid

My Lords, can I also join other noble Lords in welcoming Lord Lexden back to his rightful place and also to thank him for securing this debate. I'd better also declare an interest like other noble Lords have done that I didn't actually go to an independent school, I went to comprehensive Park House School which sadly no more was demolished many years ago. I wasn't here two years ago when this debate around independent schools and VAT took place, but I suspect those that were here probably might have seen some of the old speeches being brought back in because I thought the debate today was about the impact of the VAT. So I'm going to stick to that in terms of how that's affected and the more important question is that in what impact has actually had and properly evaluate whether the assumptions on which they were based on were correct. My understanding is since January 2025, private school fees have been subject to VAT at 20% while from April 25 most charitable independent schools in England lost their 80% business rate relief.

The government estimated that VAT would raise 1.5 billion in 2025-26 rising to 1.7 billion by 29-30, whilst the business rate measures was expected to raise a further 70 million to 90 million a year. As Liberal Democrats, we believe profoundly in equality of opportunity. A child's education opportunity should not be determined by the wealth of their parents or the postcode in which they happen to be born. And the long-term answer therefore must be a state education system in which every child can access an excellent school with properly funded SEND provision, excellent teachers and genuine opportunity to progress. But we should not confuse that long-term ambition with the immediate question of whether this particular policy is delivering what was promised.

There are approximately about 560,000 pupils in independent schools in England. The latest figures show that number fell by about 3.8% in the year to January 26, but the total pupil numbers across all schools also fell by 1.2% reflecting wider demographic changes. That distinction matters, my Lords. Before implementation, the HMRC estimated that VAT would eventually lead to 37,000 fewer pupils in independent schools of whom approximately 35 would move into the state sector. It estimated that additional cost to the state sector would eventually reach around 270 million a year.

The OBR similarly estimated around 35,000 fewer private school pupils and around 3 million additional state school spending. But there is important unanswered questions here. How did the modelling move from 37,000 fewer pupils in independent education to approximately 35,000 additional pupils in the state sector? What assumptions were made about where those children would go and at what ages would they transfer and would they enter primary schools, secondary schools or sixth forms and how would the impact of various vary geographically? And how many would be home educated or leave the UK education system altogether?

These are not technical details, my Lords, they determine the actual policy and consequences of the policy.

I'm particularly interested in the figures used for the cost of additional state school pupils. If we are going to assess whether the policy represents good value for money for the taxpayers, we need to know whether the estimated cost captures the real marginal cost of additional pupils, including building capacity, teachers, SEND and high needs provision and post-16 education, or whether it's essentially an average funding. There is another issue which deserves much greater attention, my Lords, the children and families behind the statistics. I've spoken to parents in my home city, Sheffield, and also a few friends here in London, who have made enormous sacrifices to pay independent school fees. They are, they do not necessarily regard themselves as wealthy.

Some have given up holidays, delayed moving house, or made other financial sacrifices because they believe their child's education is worth that commitment. Some families who have historically just managed to afford fees may now be unable to do so. And the impact may be particularly significant for children receiving bursaries or scholarships. We should not assume that the consequences of higher fees fall equally across the independent sector. A very wealthy family, my Lords, may be able to absorb the substantial increases.

But a family already stretching its finances to keep a child in a particular school may not. And I also want to raise the question of teachers. One of the arguments for the policy is that revenues raised will support state education. This is an entirely legitimate question, but if we want to improve educational outcomes, we need to ask what happens to the teaching workforce, my Lords, and I hope when the Minister rises, she will address this issue. The independent sector employs teachers who could potentially work in the state schools.

If independent schools respond to higher costs by reducing staffing, while state schools simultaneously struggle to recruit and retain teachers, the consequences deserve careful examination, my Lords. The government's original modelling assumed that schools would absorb some of the costs, pass some through higher fees and make efficiencies. The OBR estimates that effective VAT rate of 15.4%, which roughly two-thirds of the cost passed through fees. HMRC estimates average fee increases of around 10%, although it recognises substantial variations between schools. So what has actually happened, my Lords?

The Independent Schools Council reports that amongst schools responding to its survey, average fee increased by 4.4% between January '25 and January '26, before VAT and nursery fees. We now have the beginnings of evidence, but not yet the complete picture, my Lords. This is what, this is why I believe the government should commit to a proper post-implementation evaluation. I'm grateful to the Association of Families of Independent Schooling for drawing attention to this issue for me. I do not suggest that this analysis should simply be accepted, my Lords, indeed, the same principle applies to every source of evidence in this debate.

The answer is not to commission a review designed to reach a predetermined conclusion. It is to commission an independent and a credible assessment of the evidence, assumptions, modelling and forecast, and test them against what actually happened since January 2025. We need to examine pupil numbers, destinations, school closures, fee increases, bursaries, staffing, geographical effects, SEND provision and actual additional costs to the state sector. We should also assess the combined effects of VAT and the removal of business rate relief rather than examining each measure in isolation, my Lords.

My Lords, the government made a significant policy intervention in education and taxation. It is entirely reasonable for Parliament now to ask whether the evidence is matching the forecast. So I have two questions for the Minister before I sit down. First, what monitoring and evaluation of the original assumptions and forecasts has taken place, who is responsible for that work, and when will the results be published? And secondly, will the government consider commissioning an independent review of the evidence, assumptions, modelling, and forecasts underpinning these reforms, tested against the evidence emerging since implementation?

Because if these measures are to be justified by the benefits they are intended to deliver for the state's education, then we owe it to the taxpayers, parents, teachers, and above all children to ensure that those benefits are measured properly. We should follow the evidence wherever it takes us, my Lords.

03:28:27 - 03:38:58

Joanne Cash

My Lords, I join with others to thank the noble Lord, Lord Lexden, for securing this debate and to welcome him back to his place. As I'm also relatively new to this House, I have not had the pleasure of spending time with him, and I'm very glad that that opportunity may now arise. My Lords, I would like to start by quoting from the repeat statement and what the noble Baroness, the Minister, said in response to questions by me earlier today. I had been asking about preserving all that was good in our education system and seeking a reassurance that we would do that. The noble Baroness, the Minister, challenged that, saying that there was more work to be done.

We should now not place in aspect the education system and recognize the areas where, notwithstanding the progress, there is more work to be done, because I'm afraid a disadvantage gap still exists for our children and is stubbornly wide. A gap between regions is widening. We have a SEND crisis that is growing, and 1.5 million children persistently absent from school, and a doubling of those educated at home since 2019, and now a million young people, all educated during the last 16 years, not in education, employment, or training. So simply standing still and resting on our laurels will not be good enough for our children. You might wonder why I've quoted the noble Baroness, the Minister, in this debate, and it is to identify the fact that this change was made at a time when there was no possibility of providing the children who were removed from the private system as a result with an excellent education elsewhere in the state system.

And I will come back to that. But first, I'd like to thank my noble friends and the noble Lord, Lord Alton, for their contributions today, and I'm grateful that they have saved me from repeating in detail the numbers, and particularly my thanks to Lord Lexden for his very comprehensive summary of the facts and the data around all of this and the impact of it. I even find myself in the unusual position of agreeing with my noble Lord, Lord Mohammad, in challenging a review of all of this and the actual effects that were predicted versus what has taken place since. Two significant facts have emerged in the debate today. One, the data produced around Scotland and the fact that, as we can already see in England, this change has not had the predicted effect and is indeed costing the Scottish government a great deal more and is predicted for that to increase.

And the second point of note is that the anomaly created by this government by making this change, as identified by the noble Lord, Lord Alton, in respect to EU law.

The government's predictions we have heard plenty about and how wrong they were. I won't repeat those, but I have them in mind as we continue. The point being this, that the noble Baroness, the Minister, I hope will have heard what I believe was a collective cry of pain and loss from the speeches on the opposition benches today. At the heart of this are real children, real families, and really hard consequences for all of them. Even if one agreed with the principle of this policy, its timing and its implementation was at best indifferent, indiscriminate, and yes, punitive.

For 50 years since VAT was introduced, education in this country was exempt, and that exemption was not removed in a September at the beginning of a school year, but in the middle, halfway through. And worse than that, halfway through some children's GCSE and A-level courses. It was removed before anything had been done, as we've heard from Lord Shinkwin, about a special needs system which the noble Baroness, the Minister, herself today has said is already under extreme strain. Tribunal appeals take up to 14 months. It was also removed before a single one of the promised teachers had been recruited, and we've heard from a number of my noble friends today about those numbers.

There was indifference, unquestionable indifference. The government knew what would follow, not only via debates here and in the other place, but we know from their own policy note that they accepted in advance that children with special needs who move schools would suffer disruptive impacts, to say the least. The wealthiest absorbed it, and a number of my noble friends have identified this today. Baroness Laing in her very powerful speech has called attention to the extremely unfortunate and regrettable statement by the Secretary of State for Education that she is interested in 93% of this education, children in the education system. Whatever her intent, it is a message that has landed a body blow on the 7%.

The families who couldn't absorb it are the ones we've heard about today. More than 96,000 children in independent schools receive special needs support without a plan. Every one of those families pays this tax now in full. Tim Barrow, father of three from Hertfordshire, two of them with special needs, withdrew his sons from their independent school in order to keep his 10-year-old daughter, whose needs were the greatest, in hers. The policy, he's quoted as saying, forced him and his wife to determine which of our children's educational needs takes precedence.

No parent should face that. No parent with children with special educational needs should I would ever have imagined facing that under a Labour government. Leanne Gunn, whose son Charlie uses a wheelchair and will be in a wheelchair for life, took the government to court alongside other families. She says she will work all her life to pay his fees because there's no other option for him. Those are the families who lost.

To families of modest means at low-fee faith schools, the Court of Appeal had to observe that they would still and could still resort to home education when they found against them and sent the problem back to Parliament.

It was punitive. There's no question from what we've heard today that it was punitive. No one in government weighed what these schools give to the communities around them and the value of that. Not just economic value, human value. Some examples of what these schools do: Christ's Hospital, 470 years old, 650 of its 900 pupils hold means-tested bursaries and it provides 15% of all full bursaries in the independent sector.

The London Academy of Excellence in Stratford is a free sixth form, sponsored and staffed with support of independent schools. It has produced more than 150 Oxford offers in eight years, over a third of them to pupils on free school meals. And I could go on. Every closure extinguishes that giving, that community outreach, permanently punishing the children who benefited. And of course we've seen this beginning of the transition, applications by independent faith schools into the into the state sector and an issue, a very serious issue arising at Barnet Hill Academy, where the state system now appears to be allowing and funding a school which mandates the wearing of a hijab for children as young as seven.

The school, when this was revealed during the week, said that they had changed their policy. They did. They said it wouldn't be mandated for non-Muslim girls. In this country, it is unlawful to mandate religious dress for any girl of any age of any faith. It's a complete breach of the Equality Act.

And I hope that in as this has been exposed, perhaps the one silver lining of the whole policy, that the noble Baroness the Minister will undertake here today to reassure us that this will be addressed promptly. My Lords, no government should have contemplated moving tens of thousands of children and taxing the education of the rest unless and until it could provide every child with a place in an excellent school, until special needs provision worked, and until the teachers it promised were standing in classrooms. At the very least now, the government should set out how it will replace the loss of the community contributions. And I support the call by a number of my noble peers today, including the noble Lord Lord Mohammad, that there should be a review into this policy. I may I add one one last thing I forgot to address, I do apologize, which is that of course I can reassure my noble friend Lord Black that we will indeed and have pledged to repeal this policy.

03:38:58 - 03:53:23

Jacqui Smith

My Lords, can I begin by thanking the noble Lord Lord Lexden for having secured this debate and for the long-standing interest that he's taken in independent schools and the families that they serve. It is very good to have him back on these benches and I wish him well. I will respond fully to the debate and with evidence to the points that have been raised.

But before I do that, can I just comment that I do understand that there are very strong views about this issue, but I can't help thinking that more characteristically for this House, it might have been better with a bit less questioning of the character and motives of me and my colleagues, verging in one case on unparliamentary language in my view. The motion before us asks this House to take note of the impact of VAT and other tax changes on private schools since the 1st of January 2025. It's right that we should do so. These were significant reforms, debated extensively both inside and outside Parliament before their introduction, and it's entirely proper that we continue to scrutinize their effects. The government's position, however, remains clear.

Education is central to our mission to break down barriers to opportunity. We want every child, regardless of background, circumstance, or where they happen to live, to have access to an excellent education. That means ensuring that public funding is directed where it can have the greatest impact and that difficult decisions about taxation are taken fairly and responsibly. It was for that reason that the government ended the VAT exemption on private school fees from the 1st of January 2025 and removed charitable business rates relief from private schools in England from April 2025. As the government set out at the 2024 budget, these measures combined would raise more than 1.8 billion pounds each year by 2029-30 to help support investment in public services, including education.

The government remains confident in these costings, which were certified by the independent Office for Budget Responsibility. The OBR actually revised the expected yield up slightly by an average of 40 million pounds per year in November 2025. So these measures are raising more than expected when they were announced. This was of course also a manifesto commitment, and the now government in its manifesto also set out a range of ways in which the revenue earned would be used. Whilst of course it isn't possible, as this is non-hypothecated, to directly link this spending, I would and I feel it's appropriate to identify some of the links between those areas identified in the manifesto and increased spending and provision.

We're spending more than has been raised to improve our schools and to deliver our commitment to the 94% of children who attend state schools. We're increasing our overall core schools budget by 2.3 billion in 2026-27. We have now achieved 71.6% of our 6,500 additional teachers target. There are 4,654 more teachers, 3,008 more teachers in secondary and special schools in 2025-26, and 1,646 more teachers in further education than in 2024-25. We're investing 18 billion pounds this year in post-16 education and skills, which includes funding for careers and work experience, with over 86.4 million funding for careers-related activities.

In July 2025, we announced that funded support for the Nuffield Early Language Intervention program would continue for another four academic years. We're building and expanding nurseries in schools, providing 82 million pounds of capital funding to over 600 primary and maintained nursery schools across phases one and two of the school-based nursery program, which will create over 11,000 new nursery places by September 2027.

As at March 2026, 60% of pupils in schools and learners in further education in England are covered by a mental health support team. As part of the national youth strategy, the government is committed to establishing 50 young futures hubs by March 2029. All things that we said in our manifesto that we would do, and we have done. Let me say at the outset that the government recognizes the valuable contribution that many private schools make to our national life. Private schools do educate hundreds of thousands of children, provide specialist provision, deliver bursaries and scholarships and work in partnership with state schools and local communities.

Nothing in these reforms was intended to undermine those contributions, and nothing in the government's approach seeks to remove parental choice. And I understand as well the international impact of our private school sector, which is why I raised it and pushed for further opportunities for our private schools in Saudi Arabia earlier this week. The question before us is not whether private schools make a contribution, they undoubtedly do. The question is whether it is right that private education should have continued to benefit from tax breaks that are not available to most other goods and services. This government concluded that it was not.

It's important to place recent changes in their proper context. The government always expected that applying VAT to private school fees would lead to some movement of pupils into the state sector. That was explicitly factored into our analysis before the policy was introduced. Our estimate remains that around 35,000 pupils may move into state-funded education over the course of this parliament. That represents fewer than 0.5% of the state school population.

At the same time, we must recognize the wider demographic picture. Falling birth rates are affecting pupil numbers across the education system. The latest available data show that overall pupil numbers have fallen across all sectors, not solely within private schools. And it would therefore be wrong to attribute every change in enrollment solely to the introduction of VAT. The evidence points to a combination of factors, including demographics, local market conditions, and broader economic pressures.

As ministers have consistently stated, the trends seen thus far remain broadly consistent with the assumptions underpinning the original policy. It is of course sad when any school closes. I understand the impact on parents, on children, and on communities. School closures, however, of course can be influenced by a range of factors, not just the VAT policy. And while we accept that VAT may have compounded pressure already on private schools, closures cannot be attributed to it alone.

Private schools like other organizations can close for a number of reasons. Demographic change, financial sustainability, governance issues, regulatory concerns, and mergers have all contributed to school closures long before these reforms were introduced. And I did think that at least a couple of the examples used by the noble Lord, Lord Lexden, given my understanding particularly of the history of Malvern St James, were perhaps not the best examples of the impact of VAT and possibly had more to do with the new ownership of those schools. The government's assessment remains that closure rates are within historical patterns and do not demonstrate systemic failure across the sector. On average, 75 private schools closed per year over the 20 years before the tax changes.

A total of 60 schools closed in the 2024-25 school year, and 67 closed in 2025-26, so below the average of previous years. And we also note that private schools have continued to open. The picture is therefore considerably more nuanced than some commentary has suggested.

In England, overall pupil numbers have declined by 1.2% between 2025 and 2026, so state-funded primary and secondary schools have fewer pupils and sufficient capacity. For the new school year, 98.7% of applications to primary school led to an offer from one of the preferred schools, and the same is true for 96.4% of secondary applications, and both of those figures represent an improvement on last year. Local authorities retain statutory responsibility for securing sufficient school places and continue to plan effectively for local demand. To date, no authority has suggested that pupil movements associated with these reforms have created pressures that cannot be managed within existing arrangements. The government therefore remains confident that the state sector can accommodate any additional pupils arising from the policy, and that reflects the position that ministers have consistently set out to Parliament.

Concerns about children with special educational needs do deserve careful consideration, and I recognize the points that the noble Lord, Lord Chinkwin, made not only in his contribution today, but in previous debates and as he says in his questions. The government has always recognized that children with SEND can require highly specialized provision and that stability of placement is particularly important. That is precisely why protections exist for those children whose private school placement is named in an education, health and care plan and funded by a local authority. In such circumstances, local authorities are able to reclaim the VAT incurred. Those arrangements remain in place and continue to provide protection for some of the most vulnerable children in our education system.

We will continue to monitor outcomes closely and remain committed to improving support for children and young people with SEND wherever they are educated. I note that the tax changes, in fact, have not led to fewer pupils with SEND at private schools. Indeed, the number has increased slightly, and that does include those without EHCPs, where the number at mainstream independent schools has grown from fewer than 98,000 in January 2024 to over 101,000 in January 2026. But for the majority of children with SEND that attend state-funded schools, we want every child to have the best start in life with help available earlier and locally when families need it. Every child achieving and thriving, the schools white paper published in February set out our intentions.

We will ensure that children get the right support in their early years setting, school and college. We will invest in new training for all staff and better buildings, equipment, and make sure that every setting has access to expert professional support when it's needed. We will create a new offer for children who need additional support, called targeted and targeted plus layers. Children in early years settings, mainstream schools and colleges can benefit from education and health professionals without long waits for assessments. For children and young people with complex needs, we're developing new specialist provision packages designed with experts and tested with parents to set out exactly what support and resources are required for specific needs.

Parents should of course be able to choose where they educate their children, but we must move away from a system that forces the parents of children with special educational needs and disabilities to feel they have to move their children where they can afford to do so.

We will restore parents' trust in the SEND system. These changes will be introduced gradually, but we are already investing up, but we are investing 7 billion pounds more on SEND compared to 2025-26. My Lords, what matters now is that we continue to examine the evidence clearly as noble Lords have called for today. The government has done so throughout implementation and will continue to do so. We will keep monitoring pupil movements, school capacity, school closures, SEND provision and the wider health of the sector.

Where concerns arise, they will be considered seriously and responsibly. However, after more than a year of implementation, the evidence available to us does not suggest that the fundamental assumptions behind the policy were misplaced. The education system continues to function effectively. State schools continue to have capacity. The independent sector continues to educate hundreds of thousands of pupils.

And the reforms continue to support the government's objective of raising funding to improve opportunities for children and young people across the country. Once again, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lexden, for bringing this important issue before the House and allowing me to respond as I say with evidence and commitment to ensure we continue monitoring this policy.

03:53:23 - 03:55:16

Alistair Cooke

My Lords, may I thank, as is customary, all the speakers whose contributions today have been, I think for the most part, especially powerful, many rooted in personal experience. We've had almost total unanimity of voice about the devastating impact on independent schools of the education tax. And it was notable that as my noble friend Lord Caithness pointed out, not a single voice was heard from the Labour benches prepared to defend this policy. Now, a range of important topics have been covered: bursaries, the impact on local economies, partnerships, impact on state schools and loss of opportunity, the vindictiveness of introducing VAT mid-year, the closure of historic institutions, music education and the threat to specialist music schools, special needs, the impact on boarding schools, and the doubts surrounding the economics on which this policy is based. That really is the central issue that has been brought out, because of the widespread belief that economics does not play at the heart of this, but a vindictiveness towards independent schools.

Now, the Minister is so confident in her policy and the figures and data that she has used, she will surely have no reluctance in putting the issue to the test by establishing the independent inquiry review for which so many speakers have so rightly called. So I end by thanking all those who have contributed, and I beg to move.

03:56:47 - 03:56:52

Speaker 89

Question for short debate, the mental health of those working in agriculture, the Bishop of Hereford.

03:56:52 - 04:05:26

Richard Jackson

My Lords, I'm grateful for the opportunity to raise this issue in your Lordships' House. I declare my particular interest as a patron of the Agricultural Chaplains Association and Bishop of the most rural diocese in England. Clergy and agricultural chaplains across my diocese and indeed across the nation are on the frontline of the pastoral response to the mental health crisis among agricultural workers. They're so often the ones who show up in times of crisis and sit with people at their moments of greatest need. They provide comfort to the families of the recently bereaved and take funerals.

Although it is imperfect, evidence suggests that British farming communities experience mental health concerns and likely rates of suicide disproportionate to the general population of Britain. The Royal Agricultural Benevolent Institute's 2021 Big Farming Survey found that almost a fifth of their respondents knew someone who'd attempted suicide in the last five years. Indeed, 94% of British farmers agreed that poor mental health is the biggest hidden problem facing farmers today, according to the Farm Safety Foundation's 2025 report. There are multiple reasons for this. Farmers are the worst affected by the recent turbulence brought on by climate change.

In only the last 18 months, we've experienced our two hottest summers on record and an extremely wet winter. Farmers are devastated by the loss of their crops due to wildfires, flooding and extreme heat, and the pests and diseases they bring. They've been forced to eat into their winter forage reserves, rework irrigation systems and add flood defenses. The threat of extreme weather and climate change is keeping farmers awake at night. They're faced with tackling the worst bluetongue outbreak the nation has faced, bearing the cost of veterinary bills, vaccines and other associated expenses.

The financial burden is considerable, but so too is the emotional strain of dealing with disease, uncertainty and livestock losses. I want to take a moment to thank the noble and learned Lord Baroness Mallalieu, and I hope she'll forgive me if I've pronounced that wrong, for her written support ahead of today's debate. She drew my attention to the extraordinary pressures being felt across the wider agricultural support network. She told me that kennels collecting fallen stock in her area have at times been visiting as many as 140 farms in a single day, a stark illustration of the enormous strain that climate-related pressures are placing on the wider industry.

Second, as farmers consider their approach to the future, they are doing so against a backdrop of continual policy and regulatory change. The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee's 2023 report on rural mental health highlighted the stress caused by changing regulatory frameworks and support schemes. Farmers must necessarily take a long-term view of their business, yet find themselves navigating a constantly shifting landscape of environmental incentives, land management requirements and biodiversity obligations. Farmers are resilient and even if they disagree with policy, they will make it work if they have consistency. The current challenging environment to food security suggests the need for significant cross-party collaboration for a longer-term stable regulatory and policy framework.

Alongside this uncertainty sits intense financial pressure. Rising costs for fertiliser, fuel and machinery have squeezed already tight margins. For many, concern around their farm's long-term viability remains a constant source of anxiety. A remarkable farming support charity in my diocese, We Are Farming Minds, reports growing numbers of farmers struggling with money worries, insecure tenancies, family disputes over farm succession, legal issues and the challenge of keeping businesses afloat amid volatile markets. Paperwork and administration add a further burden.

A fifth of those living rurally report poor mental health due to social isolation. For agricultural workers, this is exacerbated by long hours working alone and the increasing closure of farmers' markets, which are places of community as well as commerce. Many also express a sense that farming is undervalued by wider society, despite the essential role farmers play, a point well made by the noble Lord, Lord Leven, in his supplementary question earlier today. At the same time, cultures of resilience within farming communities can create a stigma around discussing mental ill health, discouraging people from seeking support when they need it most. And of course, in times of mental crisis, many farmers have access to firearms and agricultural chemicals, making timely and preventative support critical.

Yet there are also reasons for hope. Across the country, communities, charities and frontline organisations are developing innovative ways to reach those who might never walk through the door of a traditional mental health service. Some organisations choose to bring life-saving community to farmers, like the monthly Butty Van, a joint project between the Diocese of Hereford and the Methodist Church, which offers to farmers a breakfast, hot drink and conversation. Others organise pop-up wellbeing clinics at livestock markets and agricultural shows, like Health Huts, which offer both mental health advice and medical assistance. Still others train the people that farmers already trust.

The DPJ Foundation equips industry professionals to spot mental health symptoms and runs a Share the Load counselling service. I'm grateful to have met with the Minister earlier this week to discuss the wellbeing of farming communities, and I thank her for her sustained advocacy on behalf of farmers and for the careful attention she's given to the many interconnected pressures affecting the sector, from mental health and welfare support through to the practical regulatory challenges that shape everyday life on farms.

I warmly welcome the government's farmer welfare grant, a timely commitment of one and a half million over the coming three years. It's heartening that the minister recognizes that behind every harvest and herd are men and women carrying burdens of isolation, anxiety, and financial pressure that too often go unseen. Through this funding, projects such as the Butty Van will be better equipped to continue their vital work. I recognize, of course, the financial constraints under which the government is operating and the difficult choices ministers face across public spending. In that context, this funding is a welcome and valuable investment.

However, grants are a precision tool: their scope is limited, their budgets finite, and their duration temporary. While this funding is due to run until 2029, charities and support organizations need longer-term certainty if they are to recruit and retain skilled staff, build trusted relationships within communities, and plan effectively for the future. I hope, therefore, the minister will consider how this promising start might be developed into a more sustainable funding settlement. However, as the minister and I discussed in person, improving mental health in farming is not simply about responding to crisis; it is about creating the conditions in which farmers and farming can thrive. The minister's rightly been engaging with practical issues such as on-farm reservoirs and water storage, and I welcome efforts to reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens where possible.

Prevention and early intervention should be at the heart of the government's approach. If awareness of mental health challenges becomes second nature across the sector, we can identify problems sooner, connect people with support earlier, and help prevent avoidable tragedies. In doing so, we can build a healthier farming workforce and more resilient rural communities.

04:05:26 - 04:07:46

Gillian Shephard

My Lords, we are indebted to the right reverend prelate for so graphically describing the often ignored problem of mental health in rural communities and the part that uncertainty and unpredictability play in that problem. My Lords, this issue is a deeply serious matter. Problems of access, transport links, availability of professional help for health problems, all of these are more difficult in sparsely populated rural areas. And the prosperity and above all the confidence of the farming sector are at the very center of the whole rural economy, from jobs to sales of seed and fertilizer, machinery, food processing and livestock, veterinary services, and retail and hospitality. If farmers prosper, so do our rural communities.

My Lords, farmers produce 60% of our food. They care for our environment. They are frequently leaders in rural communities, taking part in local government, school management, and our churches and chapels. But isolation, long working hours, and financial pressures, often unpredictable, make theirs a lonely job. Farmers have to take their decisions alone, as we all know.

And as the right reverend prelate has said, they have access to firearms and pesticides. I fear that some noble Lords here today will have had firsthand experience of suicides within their own rural communities. I certainly have, and my noble friend Lord Fuller, who comes from the same county, will also have had that experience, and the right reverend prelate has graphically described the situation.

04:07:31 - 04:13:14

Simon Russell

An RABI survey found that 47% of the farming community experienced high anxiety rates, much higher than in the rest of our community. Many organizations have been set up across the country over time to help. And I can recall when I was at the Ministry of Agriculture in the early 1990s, we worked with the RABI and the Royal Show to promote better access to help with mental health for farmers. In 2008, the agricultural community in Norfolk, Suffolk, and Essex set up the organization YANA, You Are Not Alone. And it continues to provide a full-time, dedicated, and confidential helpline with trained advisors and access to counseling.

And my Lords, the statistics speak for themselves. Alarmingly, its helpline calls and the durations of those calls have increased by nearly 40% in the last year alone. Climate change, floods, drought, storms, the extraordinary international situation, supply shortages, ever-increasing energy prices, and massive uncertainty surrounding future food supplies have combined to create an unprecedentedly difficult time for the whole agricultural sector and, importantly, very high anxiety rates for those working in it. Uncertainty with regard to your livelihood is one of the principal causes of depression. Now, we all understand that uncertainty is built into farming.

Farming is all about planning ahead: what to drill, when to harvest, when to invest in irrigation systems, machinery, livestock, how to find new markets. All of this in constantly shifting circumstances. And farmers have to plan not just for one year, but for several seasons ahead, taking account of the whole farm and those working on it. And this is why the government's shock inheritance tax announcement, not only taxing our very means of food production but also its future, was received with disbelief by the whole rural community. And there have been other shock and sudden changes in support for agriculture from this government, frequently at short notice, as was the case with SFI, smashing into smithereens forward planning within the sector.

Now, I always at this stage except the noble baroness, the minister. She has taken every possible chance that she can to make improvements for the farming community where it is possible. But I must say, my Lords, that kind of uncertainty within your own livelihood can be very difficult to handle in an industry already fraught with uncertainties, especially if it is caused by government, as has regrettably happened during the past couple of years. And it is particularly serious, indeed I would say it was unacceptable, because at this time of global uncertainty, a safe, affordable, and sustainable food supply is central to our national security.

Professor Tim Lang, in his 2025 report for the National Preparedness Commission, stated that strong and resilient productive capacity is essential in facing global climate events, geopolitical disruptions, wars and blockades, and fragile food supply chains. He added that food security should be treated as part of our national infrastructure planning, as indeed it obviously must be. The mental health of those who produce our food, their success and productivity, and of those who live in rural communities is of key importance. They already live with the anxiety and uncertainties which are part of their way of life. The government should not add to these uncertainties with sudden cuts or policy changes.

They should instead recognize the vital role they play in the very survival of our nation. A minister in the other place recently advised that, in the light of the current situation geopolitically, we should be stocking up our food cupboards. That we need to make our own food supply both secure and healthy before we can follow that minister's advice will be obvious to the noble lords taking part in this debate, and I hope and believe to the noble baroness the minister.

04:13:14 - 04:22:37

Charles John Fuller

My lords, I'd like to thank also the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Hereford for bringing this debate. It's an important one, which is very much at the forefront of many people's minds. Even the Prime Minister has agreed that the war on the countryside has gone too far. Of course, it's not his fault that so many in the countryside choose to end their lives before their time. But the constant and cumulative attacks on the way people choose to live their lives in the sticks cannot help their mental health.

It's not easy when you're unappreciated, misunderstood, isolated, under financial attack from low prices, high costs, discriminatory tax, and ever-burdensome regulations. You see, oftentimes the city dweller looks down on the country mouse who lives in the sticks, well, it's they're just so provincial, you see. And that attitude is a problem, because nobody should be taken for granted or patronized in this way. It demeans them and the governing party that promotes that notion. Now, I play a leading role in the fertilizer industry, I've got a degree in agriculture, I'm a director of a large farming business, I've grown up amongst the landowners, farmers, contractors, and all those who work amongst them since, well, since as long as I can remember.

So I know more than most, if you're an outsider, it's easy to misunderstand how these rural communities function. Close social ties formed over generations make it hard for the outsiders to get in. But out in the countryside, the economy is based on small businesses, so many are one-man band affairs. Unlike in the cities, where larger firms are split into basic commercial functions, into directorates or departments. The farmer is simultaneously the sales director, the purchasing director, the head of finance, the health and safety coordinator, head of operations, contracts manager, HR executive, regulatory affairs officer, and government relations advisor.

All by himself or herself. But that's bad enough. But there are other weighty risks which don't affect other businesses. Weather risks. Three bad harvests on the trot, corn prices down and input costs high have left cash tight.

A farmer who did everything right this year still found yields down by 30%. And we've heard already that livestock farmers are already feeding winter grub. These are uncertainties over which none of us or they have any control. There's a particular issue amongst tenant farmers on the rent quarter day. And I'm delighted to see the noble Baroness Lady Rock, whose Rock report into farm tenancies is in her place.

She knows the pressures too. But when the best you can achieve financially is a black zero and relying on imports to fill the gap is uncertain, what's our government's solution to this growing crisis? Well, government, I'm afraid to say, is harming the social life in the countryside, which more than anything helps people unburden their thoughts and share the pressures they're under. The country pub, closed down by new taxes on glass bottles, sky-high electricity bills, national insurance and the need to offer guaranteed hours. And now new taxes for those pubs with rooms to rent overnight and new overnight stays are going to add to that burden.

The agricultural show societies, which do as much as anything to improve the social glue from those that live outside the M25, are at risk because HMRC is failing to follow their own rules by docking 20 million pounds of VAT when the matter was clear and determined by the upper tribunal. Country sports, a big social support and driver of the local economy, are to be banned, curtailed or subject to onerous licensing restrictions imposed by townies who think that milk comes from Tesco's, not cows. And with BPS financial support a distant memory, so many SFI subsidies and grants are restricted to hobby farmers rather than the ones that really feed us. Of course, I'm not so churlish as to say that 65 million pounds for new reservoirs isn't welcome. But frankly, it's not a drop in the bucket.

And then we have Natural England's regulatory ignorance on stocking rates, wilfully misunderstanding the vocation of being an upland farmer. And this morning, those villains again at Natural England have perpetuated a nationalisation of nature with a predatory pricing scheme on nature levies that at a stroke destroys the equity in the private nature markets by using a made-up discount rate of 2.05 when the government is borrowing at nearly 6%. These are the nature schemes that those under pressure have personal solace in creating. But a government agency has chopped them off at the knees. We've got a government that has spent two years putting our English farmers at competitive disadvantage against EU competitors.

We're to have new taxes on fertiliser in January, yet in the EU, those taxes are now recycled back to the farmers in a pointless money-go-round which demonstrates they had no place in the first place. Where we have technical advantage in genetic breeding, black grass chemistry or even bioethanol, our government seems content to trade those advantages away in late-night phone calls to the White House or in a SPSD that is sleeping rather than dead.

The country, the farmers and the people who work in the countryside have to be concerned, as we should all be, by a land use framework that contemplates fully 20% of the productive farmland in our nation being applied to solar and other non-farming uses. My Lords, vibes alone aren't going to feed us when Norfolk's breadbasket is converted to forestry as the map in that land use framework contemplates. It's not clear where these productivity gains are going to come from. One thing's for sure though, we're only going to get that 20% productivity gain with new investment. And when you're down on your luck and feeling sad for yourself, where is the incentive to invest not just in your business but our national food security?

But worst of all, as my noble friend Lady Shephard has said, the hammer blow of these taxes that only apply to family businesses, which apply generational principles and long-term patient capital, which don't apply to pension funds, hedge funds or sovereign wealth. And of course you have to feel for those people who haven't even got seven years to go, but have been recklessly placed under an intolerable burden, having taken the best advice to hold on to their farmland, feeling now that they're a burden to their families. Because sad to say, Labour has removed the English farmer's safety net. So now we get to the crux. When you're on your own and it seems that everyone hates you, when it seems you're facing global headwinds unsupported, no matter how professional you may be, no matter how many qualifications you have attained, no matter how large the financial mountain you have to climb to break even, still less make a profit, you can see why many can't see a way out.

The facts are that the instruments of death are all around these people: the shotgun, the veterinary medicines, the rat poison, the chemicals, the loneliness. And it isn't the fault of ministers that some individuals have come to take these things, but government has brought us to a place where the cumulative impact of abandoning food security, attacking our cultural ways of life and failing to recognize that farming's in trouble and must be dealt with, have instead had a war on the countryside that's gone too far. There is hope that the new administration in Downing Street with their pie and pint successors, sorry, will recognize this war will be reversed, not just for the farmers but for the social life of Britain, for the security of our nation. And like my noble friend, I pay tribute to the NFU, the CLA, You Are Not Alone and any other number of charities and programs that allow people to lift their eyes from the gutter. They give hope and a sense of value to those who live in the sticks, and where there is hope then salvation will follow.

And that's the route to healing minds, not terminating them.

04:22:37 - 04:30:49

Simon Russell

My Lord, it's a pleasure to speak in this debate and I'm very grateful to the Right Reverend Prelate the Lord Bishop of Hereford for securing the debate and for the compassion and clarity with which he opened it, which combined with his rural knowledge really gave us a very good introduction. And I must admit, the thought of the butty van sounds like a very good way of helping to make things better as best we can. The first debate I had in this House in my name was on children's mental health and obviously I have climate change in my position within my party, so I come to this debate with those two threads very much in my mind. And in truth they're all part of the same thing.

I thought Baroness Shephard of Northwold said it very well: if farmers prosper, so do our rural communities. I do just want to take issue with one point that Lord Fuller made in his speech. I would like this debate to concentrate on what we can do in terms of helping our farmers and practical solutions to the unique set of problems that they face. And to my mind, to frame this as city against country is too easy a dichotomy and one that I don't feel is particularly helpful in moving this debate forward. There is no doubt that our farmers face a blizzard of competing and unavoidable pressures, and many of them have been named by all speakers.

Climate change, the increasing unpredictability of extreme weather, growing financial strain, social isolation, long working hours, regulatory upheaval, and a historic stigma based in self-reliance that keeps too many of them from seeking the help and the support that they deserve. Research consistently shows that UK farmers have worse mental health than the general population. I was going to go through some of the statistics from RABI, from GHQ12, from the Farm Safety Foundation, but actually those figures have been mentioned. But what is true is that the farmers face greater rates of mental health than other comparable workers. And my Lords, these rates are unacceptable and this is not a new problem.

Friends in the other place have raised it, this issue has been raised across parties. What I'm also struck by is the fact that we don't have enough research on the scale of the problem. And that actually a lot of this work is being done by charities and actually a lot of the statistics we have are now a bit historic. So I guess my first question to the Minister, could I ask the Minister what actions the government might take to actually try and improve the government's understanding of the rate and the scale of these problems? And will the government do more now to widen access and help provide support directly to our farmers?

The question names three pressures. Before I start on those, I want to say it would be a mistake to treat them as separate. The truth is that these are all intertwined and compounded and they interact together, but I will look at them as separate threads, but I think it's important that we understand that. The first was economic uncertainty. So we have had obviously a big change in government policy and that process has been, to say the least, it's been slow and uneven.

We've had the basic payment scheme, the move to ELMs. And this has basically left farmers with a great deal of uncertainty within that change process. And it's that uncertainty that farmers increasingly tell us time and time again that creates the greatest stress and pressure points. So the other thing I'd like to ask the Minister is to look again at what more the government can do to commit to a proper multi-year funding settlement so that farmers can have greater certainty for long-term planning and budget cycles. I strongly believe that there are real opportunities also for, again, we've had solar, we've had Lord Fuller talked about 20% of solar on farmland.

I don't recognize those figures at all, the figures I have are less than 1% by 2050. But I actually believe that there's a real opportunity, a quarter of our farmers already use alternative forms of stable income to offset the increasing losses from climate change itself. So I wanted to ask the Minister today, there's been an announcement on GB Energy and community energy today, which is welcome, but what more could be done to actually help provide renewable energy to farmers to help provide a stable source of income?

Second as mentioned is obviously related to this is regulatory change. I'm not against regulatory change. We need to have this. But this needs to be better communicated. It needs to be signposted.

And it needs to be done with farmers and not to them as as an afterthought. It's that uncertainty and rapid changes that causes them anxiety and leads to these tragic situations. So better communication and actually the government doing much more to use trusted intermediaries to help deliver and communicate those messages is something we heard on environment and climate change committee. So third obviously is the environmental and climate pressures. And obviously we're we're increasingly moving to a cycle where we are having extreme flooding.

Your fields are flooded. You can't plant your crops. Then we move to extreme heat and that heat and sunlight destroys the crops in the field. We've talked about the worst harvest. The minister is is well aware of that.

But I will put this figure. The Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit estimates that cumulative harvest losses across 24, 25 and 26 amount to 5 billion in real terms for our farmers. So our farmers are very much in the front line of climate change and we need to do more to support them. I note in in the debate the the warm thanks that was given for the the farming welfare grant and particular the work that the noble baroness the minister has done on this and I recognize that as well. But I do think we need to take that further.

I do think there's a need for more support. I think we need more imaginative ways of actually reaching farmers and actually getting into what is actually quite a hard community to get into and to have these difficult conversations. And I want to put on the record my support and the support of our benches for the various charities and organizations from the Farming Community Network, DPJ Foundation, RABI, the Farm Safety Foundation's Yellow Wellies campaign. All of these organizations that are working extremely hard to help support farmers. And I think as well, I think it's important for all of us to say that if if there happen to be any farmers or anybody knows farmers that are struggling, it is it is absolutely essential that they get the help and the support that they rightly deserve.

I think my final message to the minister is that we need to do the changes that we need to make need to be made with farmers and not done to them. I think for me that's one of the most important things that government can do to help improve this situation.

04:30:49 - 04:35:44

Speaker 93

My Lords. Please let me thank the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Hereford for highlighting what we know to be an incredibly serious issue for the agricultural sector. And I highlight my register of interests as receiving rental income from an agricultural grain store. My Lords, it is unclear to many why the government does not appear to understand the farming industry and those whose livelihoods are connected to agriculture.

The president of the National Farmers Union summed the situation up with, I quote, "The human impact on the family farms tax goes way beyond the economics, and this is something not being considered by the government, which is so sad." Self-inflicted UK government borrowing costs at 28-year highs, hurting hardworking people, have been coupled with punitive taxes specifically targeted at those in agriculture. It is a fact that these are choices made by this government. It should therefore be no surprise to noble lords that only 15% of rural residents believe this government cares about the countryside. Nearly half feel the government has actively waged war on their communities.

The Countryside Alliance has identified 27 harmful policies since 2024 which negatively impact rural communities, the most significant of these being the government's changes to agricultural property relief and business property relief. My lords, the actions of the party opposite suggest they are simply not listening to farmers who repeatedly explain that most family farms do not have liquid assets to sell. Since the family farms tax was announced, investments in their businesses were either paused or cancelled in order to save for inheritance tax costs. As a direct consequence, as my noble friend Lord Gardner put so well during a recent oral question, that means low investment in innovation, low investment in food production, and low investment in the very reservoirs that so many people want to see. Almost one in four family farms and businesses have reduced headcount.

It is absolutely no surprise that the frightening question being asked in so many quarters is, does this government care more about social security than national security and food security? The noble baroness Lady Batters, former president of the National Farmers Union, has warned that our food self-sufficiency is plummeting. And my lords, it was only yesterday that the noble lord Lord Lemos from the government dispatch box talked quite rightly about mental health support for prisoners on license. And His Majesty's loyal opposition would say absolutely, of course, yes. But my lords, what about mental health support for farmers who have committed no crime but have lost their livelihood due to this government's policies?

My noble friend Baroness Shephard highlighted YANA, the You Are Not Alone helpline. Its calls are up 40%. And this is just one example. So why did the government close the 10 million pound mental health support fund for farmers, the Farming Resilience Fund, which came in under a conservative government, and what will now replace it, my lords? The 2025 McCain Farmdex report found that 90% of farmers feel the UK economy is negatively affecting their farm's financial position, with 86% feeling pessimistic about the UK's long-term food security.

04:35:44 - 04:38:21

Speaker 94

51% considered leaving farming altogether due to financial constraints, and 40% believe they may be forced to exit the industry within the next decade. These are not the actions of a responsible and decisive government. Do any noble Lords disagree that we need to ensure our long-term food security and therefore, as a result, we have a duty of care for both the physical and mental health of our farmers who work every possible hour of the day? The Right Reverend Prelate reminded us that behind most pieces of food that we eat is a human being, a farmer. My noble friend Lord Fuller was entirely correct when he said the farmer is the chief executive, the chief financial officer, the human resources director, the compliance director.

My Lords, these are immense pressures for just one person or one family to navigate. Last month, members in the other place signed a letter to the new Prime Minister calling on the government to fully reverse the farming inheritance tax changes, the response to which was, "We will look again." The noble Baroness the Minister said she will ensure that the new Chancellor is aware of the strength of feeling on this matter. Well, my Lords, actions speak louder than words, and the entire farming community is waiting. It is not just the family farms tax.

It is the increased employer national insurance costs. It's the higher energy costs. It's the accelerated decline of delinked payments, the cumulative wrecking ball of this government's policies. As my noble friend Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton put so well at the Campaign for the Countryside launch on Monday, we have no national security unless you have food security. And it is surely crystal clear that we should be looking after our farming communities, not destroying them.

04:38:21 - 04:48:38

Sue Hayman

My Lords, can I start by thanking the Right Reverend Prelate the Lord Bishop of Hereford for securing this debate today? And I'm very grateful for the opportunity to discuss what actually is a really, really important topic. And I'm also grateful to him for coming over to Defra to discuss these issues more broadly earlier this week. As the Right Reverend Prelate and others have very rightly said, farmers are facing challenges on multiple fronts. That's financial, economic, regulatory, and environmental pressures.

Anyone like myself who lives in a rural community cannot fail to be aware of the problems that farming has been facing. And in recent years, there's also been a growing awareness of the importance of mental health and mental health support in the farming sector. So we are fully committed to safeguarding the mental health of people in our agricultural and farming communities. And we are working closely with the sector to understand the pressures and to ensure that farmers are supported as best they can be. The government recently announced 343 million pounds for up to 159 new NHS mental health centers.

And they are going to be opening across England from this autumn and will bring crucial support directly into neighborhoods.

But the Noble Lord Earl Russell asked I thought what was a really important question, which is about better data and evidence around mental health issues. And I thought you might be interested to know the suicide prevention strategy for England set out an ambition to conduct and commission research and data linkage projects, and that includes how to support Defra to look at agricultural workers to understand the unique challenges and in order to to respond appropriately. We've also been looking at how people across England can benefit from faster and better mental health support. There have been 800, 8 and a half thousand, sorry, additional mental health workers recruited since the end of June 2024, and that meets a key government target that we had set. But also if we focus specifically on agriculture, we are tripling the previous funding that was available for farmer welfare, mental health and wellbeing support, and that comes through the new farmer welfare grant of 1 and a half million pounds, which is available over three years.

And that builds on the success of the previous grant, with the funding supported targeting interventions to strengthen personal and business resilience in the agriculture sector. The the Noble Right Reverend Prelate, the Noble Lord Bishop Hereford mentioned the grants and the fact that they are only temporary and that charities need certainty to to plan beyond this. So as part of the farmer welfare grant, we were particularly interested in receiving applications which should prove longevity. So we've been engaging with the sector and understand that some organizations are planning to use funding to launch initiatives which can become self-sustaining when the grant period ends. So we're interested in looking at how more work we can do on that, because of course the grant applications closed last week and we'll be looking at all those outcomes shortly.

In addition, we continue to fund the Farming Community Network. That provides a BTB affected farmers and their families with a national free-to-access business and pastoral advice service. And the Right Reverend Prelate in his introduction also talked about the importance of prevention, and the Noble Lord Earl Russell talked about the need for practical solutions. So what I think is really important, instead of us talking about, oh, we're doing this and we're doing that and we're doing the other, we're putting a sticking plaster on here, we actually really need to understand the root causes of the stress, anxiety and poor mental health that farmers are are suffering from, so that they don't reach crisis point. That has to be what we have to to to focus on.

There are a number ways we've started to do this. One is to make the supply chain fairer, so farmers are protected in contracts with supermarkets. Fair dealing rules, as the the Noble Lord opposite will know, have already been introduced for dairy and pig, introduced for dairy and pig. We're now looking to do the same for eggs, combined crops and fresh produce sectors. Because as we've heard really strongly today, I think is that farmers need certainty.

And also it's one of the reasons we published the farming roadmap, so that farmers have a clear direction towards a future for farming, underpinned by the four priorities of profitability, productivity, sustainability and resilience. Because we we have to build a resilience because of the changing climate challenges, the the global conflicts that farmers are facing through through climate change. So supporting British farmers and boosting the nation's security are key priorities for the government. Because the most resilient farms are profitable precisely because they're able to work with the environment.

So that's why we're backing this shift towards lower impact, input, more sustainable farming systems. One of the things that came across strongly though was about the the issues around isolation and loneliness. We know that that also means that accessibility of mental health services is more challenging in rural communities. And poor accessibility can further undermine the wellbeing of those who need that mental health support. So we have included tackling loneliness and isolation as an objective for the farming welfare grant.

And also the farming collaboration fund will enable local farmers to come together, not just to share costs and reduce risks, but importantly to socialize and to meet their to meet their peers. Just quickly, I know the noble lady Baroness Shepherd talked about fallen stock. We have met to discuss fallen stock recently and are going to be working with the fallen stock sectors to understand current pressures, just look at how we can support farmers who are struggling with with their stock, particularly regarding bluetongue. I think it's also important to remind noble lords that we published our response to Baroness Batters' independent farming profitability review. That's the that review's been mentioned.

We've we've published our response in June and we are we are implementing a number of her recommendations in order to to take proper action to grow profitability. And we also of course know how hard this summer has been for farmers. Dry conditions have clearly placed huge pressures on farming businesses. We've had reduced grass growth, lower forage availability, lower crop yields. We know farmers have been feeding what should have been the autumn, the winter food early, which is putting again further pressures on as we go through the year.

So I was really pleased that the Prime Minister did announce the sixty-five million pound package of support in August to support farmers affected by those conditions and to look at how we can further build resilience. We're also looking to build to to invest two point four billion pounds over the next two years to improve flood resilience. And we have a new flood resilience task force because we've been concentrating a lot on drought, but we know we are likely to have a stormy, potentially very wet winter, so we need to to look with support ahead of ahead of that. And again, I do think there's been some real issues for farmers around wildfires this year. Wildfire has been worse this year, hugely, than in than last year, for example, and we know it can have an absolutely devastating impact on farms and farming.

And it is a national security issue. Defra funding does embed proportional wildfire risk assessment and mitigation within land management activity. But we're we're trying to better understand as a government the impact of the kind of fires that we've had this year and not just about what we need to do to better support recovery, but also to build greater resilience for the future. And I I did also just want to to mention that in July of this year, we published the Future of Rural England report. And that report sets out key recommendations for government action to help rural communities unlock their full potential.

And these recommendations were informed by the work of the rural task force, which is a group of external rural stakeholders and departments right across Whitehall, which have been convened to identify how government can support rural businesses and communities to tackle rural disadvantage and also unlock the potential of the rural economy.

And what we're now doing in Defra is looking at that is that report and working out how we can best implement those those recommendations because many of those recommendations will help to unlock some of the support mechanisms we need for for farmers and others living in rural communities. I am about to run out of time I'm afraid but again I just want to just close by again thanking all contributions. It is an important issue. We do need to take this issue extremely seriously. So can I thank the right reverend prelate the noble Lord Bishop of Hereford for bringing us together again to everyone who's contributed and to continuing I hope to work together to look at how we can improve both mental health support and prevention in the first place.

04:48:38 - 04:49:27

Speaker 96

My Lords perhaps we might have a quick break while noble Lords leave quickly and quietly. Motion for debate the prison and probation service Lord Farmer.

04:49:27 - 05:04:31

Michael Stahel Farmer

My Lords I'd like to thank all those who are going to contribute this afternoon. I think it's quite an impressive list and I'm looking forward to hearing some valuable contributions to what is at the present time a very important subject. So thank you for making time after a very busy week. And I would particularly like to welcome Lord Leveson making his maiden speech here and looking forward very much to hearing his wisdom which I know he has a lot of in this regard. My Lords I received a very supportive email also from the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Gloucester who is a prisons bishop.

She's at the College of Bishops this week and is unable to attend and just wants us to know that she would have been here if she could have been here. This is a highly relevant debate to the public. The current state of our prisons and probation service constantly plays out on front pages of newspapers and online media sites. One of my pleas today is that politicians resist the media drama particularly of a single case and keep rehabilitation at the forefront and the fact that punishment is deprivation of liberty not grim conditions. On today's news we heard temporary prefabricated cells sized for one are now being fitted with bunk beds.

Ten years ago or more former chief inspector Nick Hardwick described such circumstances to the Commons Justice Committee as many prisoners are now effectively living in toilets. So headlines around prison spaces running out should not be ignored.

In August 2026 the total prison population was 86,843, 97.6% of the usable capacity. As around 96% are men, it's unrealistic to treat the women's estate as a readily available solution to male overcapacity. The government's female offender strategy admits some have committed crimes of such gravity that custody is the only sentencing option. Of course, women should be in prison if they have committed serious offenses. The range of contributors to current major capacity pressures include the increase in conviction for sexual offenses, many historic, but their devastating effects on victims do not expire.

Sentencing inflation of 45% over the past 15 years, a response in no small part to penal populism, has also clogged up our prisons and today's need for early release of prisoners is a predictable consequence. It is ironic that a lock-them-up-and-throw-away-the-key mentality necessitated the proposed early release of heinous criminals at the top of the new Prime Minister's in-tray of wicked policy issues. Early releases started under the last Conservative government with its end of custody supervised license emergency response, which allowed eligible prisoners to be released up to 18 and then 70 days before their automatic release date, but eligibility excluded many serious offenses. Also during the 2010s, the government then did find money for new prison places, which will only become available under this government, the availability, and this government will get the credit. Whatever, short-termism does not work in penal policy.

Even when a prison has opened under a highly experienced governor, it takes time to fill up gradually. We're building a community, not stocking a warehouse. But the current scheme of early release cannot be characterized as a continuation of end of custody supervised license. Moving the standard release point from 50% to 40% and now 33% represents such a significant change in the proportion of the custodial sentence spent in prison that sentencing is becoming increasingly meaningless. This is very worrying for public confidence in the courts and judiciary when they are under exceptional strain.

We need sentences that are understandable and reflect the seriousness of the crime, but also recognize the possibility and need for rehabilitation. Given Lord Leveson's independent review of the criminal courts, I hope he will comment on this and will say no more at the present time. One of my main points today is that the issue of prison capacity took the last government's attention away from rehabilitation and that trend has continued. The terms of reference for the Rudd review barely mention it. So whilst it is a theme in the call for evidence, it does not look like a priority.

Neither document mentions the importance of good relationships, despite them being essential to rehabilitation and to many other Rudd review priorities like safety, decency, and strategy for future prison build. Yet I find HMPPS staff very committed in this area. Their transforming prisons directorate is creatively building the importance of relationships into future prisons, but it's hard for them to build this culture without the oxygen of ministerial and political support. The 2016 white paper my first review for the government was announced in, Prison Safety and Reform, was also focused on Rudd review emergency issues such as safety, security, new build prisons, and staffing pressures. However, it treated rehabilitation, prisoner reform, as equally important and called for a huge cultural and structural change within our prisons, a transformation away from offender warehousing to disciplined and purposeful centers of reform where all prisoners get a second chance at leading a good life, unquote.

The MOJ's own data show the powerful positive rehabilitation effects of contact with families and significant ties. They exceed those of say education and employment and provide the motivation for the latter. Hence my review said relationships should be the golden thread running through all the processes of prison and probation. Narrowly seeing this as only good family visits misses the fact that everything is mediated through relationships, however difficult it might be to define and cost them. Relationships between governors and their officers, officers and the prisoners, prisoners and other prisoners, the prison and the community that surrounds it, the prison estate and the society it is part of.

The culture of prisons and probation needs to change so a relational approach becomes business as usual, working with the grain of what it is to be human rather than against it. That is how professionals in the youth custody service strive to operate. Yet when young people make the transition to the adult estate, they still too often fall over a cliff edge into a relational desert. It's 10 years since the government commissioned my first review and accepted all its recommendations, but its emphasis on relational culture is frequently cut across by policy decisions. In response to understandable public outrage over non-attendance at sentence hearings, prison rules have been changed so governors can remove all social visits for up to 27 days and restrict social visits to one visit in every 28 days for up to 84 days as a general sanction.

Prisoners' children can still visit, but that rules out a very large range of other potentially pro-social visitors, and when relationships wither, as they can quickly do when you're in jail, this might remove a key reforming influence on a troublemaker. One of the most extrovert prisons I visited, HMP Norwich, with its tourist cafe run by prisoners in open condition, holds a surgery for family members so the deputy governor can hear their concerns every week. She told me about the mother fighting her teenage son's corner when he'd given her a sob story about how badly he'd been treated, and how she turned that mother into an ally by saying, he's doing himself no favors, you need to help us help him get through this as well as possible. I'm also concerned about fathers in prison who might lose parental responsibility when the Courts and Tribunals Bill abolishes the rebuttal presumption in the Children Act 1989 that children's best interests are typically served by both parents' involvement. Being in prison does not automatically make someone a bad or damaging father or mother, but removing the presumption will make it easier to argue that they are not needed.

Can the minister confirm if any guidance will be issued to mitigate that possible unintended consequence for these parents and also their children at a profound legal disadvantage if it does become law? Such examples suggest the culture is still punitive rather than rehabilitative.

The problem with culture is its apparent intangibility for policy purposes, but its effects are anything but intangible. Where there is a culture of each government department or public service working separately and territorially, people fall through the cracks between operational silos. That still happens despite the duty to refer when people are at risk of being released homeless from prison. Some local housing authorities work very well with prisons and probation and secure accommodation for prisoners despite similar pressures on their housing stock as less integrated local councils. According to NACRO, 12% of people leaving prison were released into homelessness last year in the North West, compared to more than 20% of people released in South Central.

If agencies in every region collaborated as well as in the North West, there would be 3,700 fewer people released to homelessness every year. This would potentially prevent 1,500 re-offences. The proven re-offending rate of those released homeless, 76%, was more than twice that of those released from custody into settled accommodation at 36.4%. 4,500 inmates will be released early in 10 tranches between 1st October and 1st of June next year, in addition to the 4,500 regular releases that take place each month. Prisons and probation are on the front line of the Prime Minister's pledge to end rough sleeping.

Almost one in six are released homeless, and the most recent snapshot found half of all rough sleepers have been in prison at some point, and 15% of them have been released within the last year. This government's national plan to end homelessness calls out the deficiencies of the duty to refer and promises to legislate for a duty to collaborate as soon as parliamentary time allows. I tabled amendments to the Social Housing Bill to seize that legislative opportunity, but unfortunately to no avail. I was even told by the responding minister that the duty to refer was working fine, so my amendments, which would have brought the government's own proposed reforms into statute, were not needed. It was rather like an Alice Through the Looking Glass moment.

May I ask the minister if he can report any new progress on bringing the duty to collaborate into law, and what is being done to ensure they have good relationships and someone is there when they're released, not just accommodation? One of the most effective ways to prevent homelessness after release is to maintain existing family and other relationships or enable prisoners to build supportive connections both inside and outside prison. Effective peer mentoring schemes are creating valuable communities of support that start in prison but go beyond the gate for prisoners who have no contact with their families and cannot hope to have. Sex offenders, for example, lumped together as universally heinous, also need to be given a second chance. Programs like these should become business as usual when well supervised; they can be powerfully therapeutic.

Trusted relationships can bring home the criminogenic influences a prisoner has to struggle if they are to change. They create a sense of agency and dispel despair. Peer support can be game-changing for the 25% of male and female prisoners who are care-experienced. The Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act requires prisons and probation to share corporate parenting responsibilities as part of a new highly relational approach to care leavers, and peer support is key to fulfilling these. Can the minister provide an overview of the spread of peer mentoring in prisons and support in English and Welsh prisons, and if there are any plans to integrate them into the probation service?

The 19th-century social reformer Elizabeth Fry branded our violent and squalid prisons the nurseries of crime. She said, "The better the actual state of our prisons is known and understood, the more clearly will all men see the necessity of these arrangements by which they may be rendered schools of industry and virtue." I'll just finish on one neglected relationship I've already mentioned, between the prison and probation system and wider society. Most prisoners will be released back into that wider society, which needs to know and understand what it takes to reform someone who has transgressed, how to prioritize rehabilitation, and how to prioritize good relationships while still being appropriately tough on crime. I beg to move.

05:04:31 - 05:04:37

Speaker 97

The question is that this motion be agreed to.

05:04:37 - 05:11:47

Peter Brooke

Lord Farmer on securing this debate, and I'm grateful for the way in which he's opened it up too. I thought he was probably going to be a little bit more critical, and in turn I've been writing a somewhat counter-speech. But I myself want to speak primarily about rehabilitation, which is a subject which he's mainly focused on. As he said, one of the big factors that's been an influence has been 30 years of sentence inflation: more and more and longer and longer prison sentences being handed out. And I too look forward to the maiden speech of Lord Laveson, and with great interest to see what he may have to say on this.

And of course there's been 30 years of underinvestment in the courts, in prisons, in the probation services, and of course in rehabilitation has been the Cinderella right at the end of the line from all governments. But services have been particularly hollowed out, I believe, since 2010, when George Osborne's austerity program was introduced. Then there was the calamitous, I believe, social experiment in part-privatization of the probation service, which came from the Conservative government, and a failure to build new prison places, so that we're still waiting for new ones to come on stream, as has just been mentioned. So Labour in 2024 inherited a demoralized and understaffed workforce, with prisons full almost to capacity. We were almost at a point that without radical action, the country faced the prospect that courts would not be able to send criminals to jail because there was no places in which to incarcerate them.

And I'm glad to say that we have not shied away from that challenge. And I want to congratulate all those who have been involved in trying to right the wrongs, especially the now-departed prison minister, the noble lord, Lord Timpson, for the outstanding work he did there, that I believe was recognized across the whole of the chamber. He did this with enthusiasm, and he endeavored to engenerize, particularly which will appeal to Lord Freila, myself, to re-engenerize the work on rehabilitation of prisoners, especially those with addiction problems of drugs, alcohol, and the growth more recently of problem gambling, on which the noble lord, Lord Foster of Bath, has done such valiant work, and I'm sure we'll be hearing more of that from him today.

In addition, he recruited Professor Dame Carol Black. She was especially brought in with her expertise to assist in these long-standing addiction problems and in rehabilitation. My Lords, rehabilitation of offenders whose crimes are driven by drug or alcohol addiction is a crucial part of any strategy to reduce reoffending, but currently I believe services are still not fit for purpose. For example, half of all people on probation have a drug or alcohol problem, and over half of the people arriving in prison are assessed as needing drug or alcohol treatment. Intensive drug alcohol rehabilitation programs in prisons were delivered to 11,000 people.

That was in 2012. We don't keep the figures now on what's being done, but the guess is it's something in the order as low as 2,000 a year. A terrible fall away there. The Sentencing Act envisages increased early release on community sentences instead of short periods of imprisonment for offenders addicted to drugs or alcohol, but there are no plans to ensure these people get adequate treatment. If their addiction is not treated, we will see high rates of reoffending and license breaches.

Dame Carol will be giving an update of progress report entitled "From Hope to Delivery: Drug and Alcohol Treatment Under a New Government". She'll be doing this in Committee Room 5 on Wednesday the 14th of October, and I hope that as many of us present today and others will be there to hear the work that she's been doing to try to address particularly addiction issues linked into rehabilitation, so that we can then in turn look forward to a more detailed program of action being taken on rehabilitation and recovery. And I'd be grateful if the noble Lord the Minister could give us an indication of how they are likely to respond to the reports which have been coming from from that noble from from the Dame. My Lords, I'm also involved in some rehabilitation work being trialed shortly in a Kent addiction recovery center that welcomes prisoners into their numbers. We're endeavoring to develop an AI companion linked to the 12-step recovery program, so that prisoners there, and it'll be entirely safe I can assure you, prisoners there will be given a companion 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 52 weeks of the year if they're in need of someone to give them advice which has been based on the 12-step program.

We've managed to interest Stanford University in the USA in this, and we're hoping that King's in London will be associated too to validate a doctoral research project which is being set up alongside it. We've also got enthusiastic support of the charity Forward Trust, that the Minister will know I'm sure does such valuable work in recovery and rehabilitation within and for those leaving prison. They and we see this project as having considerable potential in assisting with rehabilitation.

And I'm wondering therefore if the Minister could give an indication of whether or not if we get this off the ground, there may be a possibility to trial it in prison because it does have great prospects of meeting some of the many deficiencies we currently have in not having the numbers around to help people in rehabilitation.

05:11:47 - 05:20:35

Don Foster

My Lords, I'm delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Brooke, and I join with him in congratulating the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, not only for the tremendous work that he's done in this particular area, but for also securing the debate and for his excellent opening speech. I also look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Lord, Lord Leverson. My Lords, just over a year ago, the Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee, which I chair, published Better Prisons, Less Crime. We quoted witnesses who described the prison service operating in or at a verge of crisis. We acknowledged the failures of successive governments, but our purpose was not to catalogue failure, it was to identify practical ways forward.

And our starting point, echoing what the noble Lord, Lord Farmer said, was simple: that we ought to understand the role of prisons. We said that punishment for the prisoner is the loss of liberty, and the role of prisons is to protect the public by reducing reoffending. And that required, we said, purposeful activity, education and training, as the noble Lord, Lord Brooke said, treatment for mental health, drug, alcohol, and gambling problems, and preparation for life after release. It also requires relationships, as again Lord Farmer said, particularly family relationships, because they are really important, yet distance from home, restrictive visiting arrangements, and limited digital access can make contact unnecessarily difficult. Family contact cannot be treated and must not be treated as an optional extra.

Our report found that purposeful activity overall was woefully inadequate. Prisoners spending up to 23 hours a day in cramped cells with little help leading them to constructive, crime-free lives when they leave. With consequences that are predictable: boredom, frustration, self-harm, and violence. With a cost to the taxpayer of approximately 54,000 pounds per prisoner per year, we get very little benefit from that expenditure. And it's not merely a failure of prison management, it is a failure of public policy.

Of course, overcrowding is a major cause, but it's not the whole explanation. We identified longer sentences already mentioned, excessive use of custody, bureaucracy restricting governors' autonomy, inadequate recruitment and training of staff, poor assessment of prisoner needs, a backlog of repairs, and complacency, frankly, within the MOJ and HMPPS. For each of those problems, the committee made recommendations to release capacity for work on reducing reoffending and public protection. Yet, little more than a year later, the picture remains deeply troubling. Charlie Taylor, the Chief Inspector of Prisons, only this weekend in a newspaper article, recently described the system as awash with drugs, organised criminals operating with impunity, serious violence going unpunished, and prisons struggling to control, let alone rehabilitate, those in their care.

A prison system which cannot maintain order cannot properly rehabilitate prisoners. One which fails to rehabilitate stores up more crime for the future.

And the impact of all this on staff is equally serious. In the last 12 months to July, my Lords, prison officer numbers fell by the equivalent of seven officers per prison. And sickness rate, sickness absence rose to 12.4 days per officer per year, compared with the national average of 4.4 for all other workers. We cannot expect officers to deliver rehabilitation in an unsafe, understaffed and demoralising environment. Overcrowding is not going to disappear quickly.

Recalls are adding substantially to the pressure. Ten years ago, my Lords, one person was recalled for every three or four released. In the first quarter of this year, for the first time ever since records were kept, more people were recalled to prison than were released. Recall prisoners now account for approximately one-seventh of the prison population at a cost according to Nacro of 750 million pounds a year. These figures raise all sorts of questions about whether the system is operating intelligently or just recycling people through custody at enormous cost.

So I urge the minister to revisit the committee's recommendations with much greater urgency than has been so far. Just a few quick suggestions in the time that remains. We must reduce the number of people sent to prison unnecessarily. We know that well-run probation-led community sentences cost less and can produce lower reoffending. I welcome, of course, the replacement of short prison sentences with community sentences, but I believe we can go much further.

And that means doing other things. The noble Lord Lord Brooke referred to the issue of gambling disorder. It is a ridiculous situation that courts currently can make changes to the sentence they give to people who've got drug and alcohol problems by linking treatment orders to a non-custodial sentence, but there are no similar treatment orders in relation to gambling disorder. So I urge the minister to look at that particular issue. I hope we'll also look at the way in which we are funding and developing our probation service.

We'll hear all sorts of fine words from the noble Lord the minister about the government's 750 million pounds, but I would point to the simple fact that since the day our report was released to July of this year, the total increase in number of probation staff is 11. And we are now in the situation where the government is actually using an ad agency to try and find additional people at a cost of 150 million pounds. And I hope the noble Lord the minister will tell us whether, a, that is true, and secondly, whether he believes that that is good value for money, and in particular, whether that's actually coming out of the 700 million pounds as a apparently very expensive way of filling staffing gaps. My Lords, we also know that the huge pressure on the probation officers is one of the key causes for the recall of prisoners because it's so much easier if there's a licence infringement to send people back to prison rather than taking up more time to deal with them. Thirdly, I hope they'll look at our recommendation again about the importance of prison education.

My Lords, the government accepted our recommendation. They said that prison education was vitally important and yet in the time since our report was produced, the budget for education in prisons has been reduced by at least 25% and it has meant that some 300 people who deliver that service have now lost their jobs. We can do other things too by looking at the way we help prisoners when they leave prison. And I would urge the minister as a final point to have a look at the work that is being done at HMS Doncaster where NACRO are bringing together all sorts of different agencies to help prisoners the day they walk out of prison. My Lords, there is a lot that needs to be done.

Only today the unions have written to the Prime Minister talking about the piecemeal approach to dealing with the multiple problems within the justice system. They urge a more joined-up approach. I hope the minister will look at that letter. It gives a lot of good advice to how we could move forward with the government working more effectively together on these issues.

05:20:35 - 05:27:02

Elizabeth Butler-Sloss

I'm delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Foster, and his most interesting speech. This is an excellent debate on really crucial issues and I'm so glad that Lord Farmer has managed to bring it forward. I would also say how glad I am that the noble Lord, Lord Leveson, has joined us. He will add a great deal to this House with his expertise on criminal law. I've been looking at another report, the Justice Select Committee of the other place.

That has dealt with, it's called Ending the Cycle of Reoffending, and it sets out in stark terms the present state of the prison estate. The lack of adequate education of prisoners or purposeful activity referred to by Lord Foster. The failure to educate children and young people. The lack of sufficient health and welfare provision, particularly those with mental health or behavioral problems. Gross overcrowding and as has already been said, the cells in the cells for most of 24 hours.

The disrepair of prisons. Princeton was closed very shortly after the last government renewed the lease, although they knew that the prison would have to be closed. There are problems with recruitment and retention of prison officers and I'm not surprised. There's a lack of training of prison officers, not only initially, but on promotion. And it's suggested in the Justice Select Committee report that governors need some training.

They also point out there's a lack of involvement by governors and the opportunity for governors to make decisions on who in fact should be employed in the particular prison. This background from the Justice Select Committee is, it seems to me, a sad introduction to this much-needed debate. One might ask who on earth would want to be a prison officer? We've heard not only from myself but also earlier what happens to them. The need for rehabilitation of prisoners is obvious.

For their sake and the sake of the public. If we just bang up people, mainly men as we largely do, they're obviously the more likely to offend and fill the prisons again and it seems a vicious circle. Many years ago as a judge, I visited Exeter Prison. I saw an absolutely splendid workshop training prisoners in how to make and repair furniture.

I went back about three years later. I asked about the workshop. It was closed. I asked why. The prison officer said it was so busy taking people to the courts they hadn't got time to look after the workshop.

Oh dear. In the present circumstances, rehabilitation of overcrowded prisons and a lack of resources, it does seem difficult to resolve rehabilitation. But the prevention of reoffending and some training of those inside seems to be crucial for the benefit of prisoners, but much more important, the benefit of the public. There have been some very successful drug and alcohol magistrates' courts in the past working on addict offenders. Surely there should also be more residential units for drink and drug offenders under probation orders.

If the offender doesn't finish the course, he goes to prison, but some at least might not reoffend. The female prison population is, as we all know, very much smaller. Many, if not most, women who offend have been victims of abuse. I'm not suggesting that no woman should go to prison, but I do suggest that many would be better off out of prison with appropriate probation orders and with, of course, support and help to live in the future. The 2007 Corston Report gave very good advice on women offenders.

I don't know how far her recommendations have been implemented, but she recommended, among others, there should be a woman-centered approach in the judicial system, early diversion and efforts to identify and address the root cause of offending. There are excellent initiatives dealing with women, and they should be encouraged and increased. Another problem, of course, is how to deal with prisoners upon release, and this has already been referred to. The early releases are leaving, I gather, prisoners without the help to prepare for time out of prison. There seems little point in release if there isn't sufficient help both inside and when they are outside.

There are too many offenders who commit offenses on release in order to go back to prison because where else can they go? And we have, of course, a serious lack of housing. What I don't know is where the overwhelming need to improve the prison estate should start. So I shall listen with great interest to the minister as to how something at least can be done. Both the prisoners and the public require it.

I would just add that the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, raised the issue of the deletion of parental responsibility in a coming bill. That is, as I understand it, would require a judicial decision, and I would hope that judges would not remove parental responsibility as a matter of course, but only if the person in prison is unsuited to be able to exercise it. And I think he perhaps is worrying too much about that particular proposal.

05:27:02 - 05:34:34

James Douglas-Hamilton

My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, and also to express my appreciation for the outstanding speech by the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, and to thank him for introducing this debate. My Lords, I propose to address only one point already raised by the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath, namely the question of recalls to custody. Let us just concentrate on that for a moment. In the past four years, recalls to custody of prisoners released under license have more than doubled in the last four years.

As has already been pointed out, in the last year there were 51,000 recalls to prison. That exceeds the number of persons sentenced by the courts to prison, which was 47,000. So for the first time, recalls now are greater than persons going to prison in the first place. A recall rate of 50,000 represents a rate of recall of about one in five of those under supervision. And as the charity NACRO points out, in 2017 the rate was about one in 13.

Have we seen an increase in risk in the last 10 years? What is going on here? There is no evidence of increase in risk, but we have now, according to NACRO, reached a situation where for every 10 beds freed up by the release of a prisoner, nine are refilled by recalls to custody. My Lords, this highly regrettable situation threatens seriously to undermine the government's early release scheme, because as already been pointed out by the noble lady, Lady Butler-Sloss, what is the point of early release if it is followed by a recall? Clearly, the present situation also greatly complicates the management of prisoners within the prison system.

And as already mentioned, also I think by Lord Foster, it is costing the prison service around 750 million pounds a year, surely money better spent on supporting prisoners on license in the community. But my Lords, the most devastating effect recall can have is on the prisoner concerned, including perhaps the loss of employment, the loss of accommodation, and most importantly, the destruction of any progress there may have been towards rehabilitation. The total interruption of the process of rehabilitation, which is so rightly emphasized by my noble friend Lord Farmer and by all noble Lords who have so far spoken. My Lords, those of us who have been around for a while will remember that 20 or 30 years ago, in admittedly very different circumstances, the culture of the probation service was that recall was a last resort. Indeed, it could be regarded as a sign of professional failure to have to recall someone that was under one's own supervision.

But today the culture seems, for whatever reason, to have swung 180 degrees in the other direction. And it seems that recall has become the first resort, not the last. I fully accept that the problem is very difficult, but it seems to me there are only three possibilities. The first possibility is that the prisoner was not properly prepared for release or was not properly looked after once released, or that post-release support was inadequate.

An important case in point is if the prisoner is recalled because of homelessness, a point already raised by noble Lords. That seems to be a major factor, and again according to NACRO, and again I think mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath, last year 15,000 released prisoners were homeless on the day of release. What hope have we got, what hope do they have to remain out of the the prison sphere? So lack of preparation or lack of support for prisoners in the community is the first thing. The second possibility is that license conditions are too tough or inappropriate or not tailored to the needs of the prisoner concerned.

Are we holding prisoners to license conditions that they are not capable of achieving, that are too heavy, are not perhaps properly designed given the lack of support, the mental health problems, the drug problems particularly emphasized by Lord Brooke, the noble Lord, Lord Brooke? In all these circumstances, the Chief Inspector of Probation has himself criticized, quote, excessive license conditions. So maybe you're just imposing obligations on people they can't meet. And both those two points really amount to setting prisoners up to fail. What chance have they got if they're not properly prepared and the license conditions are too onerous?

The third possibility, however, is risk aversion in the probation service. And it is right to bear in mind that that service has over the years lost many experienced staff, is understaffed, is managing huge caseloads in very difficult conditions. 73% of recalls are for breach of license conditions. There is widespread concern that those recalls are often triggered by minor or trivial breaches of license conditions. Recalls, I suggest, should be primarily for reasons of public safety and should not be for minor breaches of license of license conditions, and there should be stronger rules and clearer guidance on this point.

So I would ask the noble Lord, the Minister, is the dramatic increase in recalls in recent years a matter of concern to the government? What is the government what in the government's view are the reasons for that increase, and what is the government doing to tackle those underlying causes? Finally, my Lords, I add my own welcome to Lord Leveson of Liverpool, to whose maiden speech we are much looking forward.

05:34:34 - 05:44:37

Brian Leveson

My Lords, it is with real diffidence that I rise just three days after my introduction, but the way in which we treat those convicted of crime, and in particular what happens to them both when in custody and in the community, has been a real interest of mine for some 60 years. It stems from my time as an undergraduate visiting Oxford Prison and being involved in organizing camps for children from approved schools, and later on in relation to the mental health of those in custody, which was an interest encouraged by my late father, who was a consultant psychiatrist. This was in Liverpool, for which over 40 years I was proud to call my home.

I am also grateful to the noble Lord Farmer for initiating this debate and thus for allowing me the opportunity to express some views on this critical area. I must first, however, express my thanks to my two splendid supporters, the noble and learned Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers and Baroness of Maldon, who were both Chief Justices for whom I worked, along with the noble and learned Lords, Lord Woolf, the late and very much lamented Lord Judge, and Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, to whom I also pay tribute. I would also like to thank the noble Earl, the Earl of Kinnoull, and those in the Convener's office for their kindness and encouragement, and express my real appreciation to the Clerk of the Parliaments, to Black Rod, and to all those who work in this House and who have been so generous with the time that they have given to a new boy. That's not a phrase I would have used of myself very recently. It is an inestimable honor for me now to be part of this House, although I am concerned whether I can live up to the expectations which have been expressed by most of the speakers this afternoon.

Let me start with the number of remand prisoners in custody. On the 30th of June 2026, of the 85,858 in custody, 10,242 were untried and 5,144 were convicted but not sentenced. For those awaiting trial, presumed innocent, their lives are on hold. For those awaiting sentence, they cannot start to engage with a sentence plan. Many may wait months, if not years, for a co-defendant to be tried so that all convicted can be sentenced together.

What of those who have been sentenced? Rehabilitation is identified as a requirement of section 57(2) of the Sentencing Act 2020 for adults and is mandated by section 37 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 as the principal aim of sentencing for those under 18. These are core requirements getting lost as both prison and probation officers seek to contain and provide such support as they can to the unsustainable number of people with whom they have to deal, both in custody and in the community. There have been far too many reports into prison conditions. I still possess a copy of the Woolf Report, which followed the prison disturbances in HMP Manchester in April 1990.

I was then responsible for the prosecution of prisoners for conspiracy to riot and other offenses. The average prison population that year was about 45,000, and on the 1st of June 1990, there were 20,785 prison officers and 994 auxiliaries. On the 7th of September 2026, the prison population was 86,868, of which 67,652 were in public sector prisons, which, as at the 30th of June, now employ 22,001 full-time equivalent prison officers and 5,661 operational staff. So for just less than 1,300 extra prison officers, there are roughly 50% more prisoners. I quote from Lord Woolf's overview: "The members of the prison service as a whole, against heavy odds, have managed over a number of years to contain an almost impossible situation by showing immense dedication, courage, and professionalism."

With over twice as many in custody, that is even more so today.

As for activity in prison, the recent annual report of the Chief Inspector of Prisons identifies that in many prisons, services have been cut, his word, brutally, with many teachers, as we have heard, made redundant. With few exceptions, attendance in education, training and work is often appalling and insufficiently prioritized, with short working days. Similarly, the annual report of the Chief Inspector of Probation speaks of an organization grappling with serious systemic challenges with an increasingly large and complex caseload and an increased proportion of that caseload in the community. In short, he says, too few staff, too little experience, managing too many cases. The report of the Justice and Home Affairs Committee, Better Prisons, Less Crime, identifies that reoffending represents 80% of the cost of offending.

It's therefore important to examine the challenges of those who are facing and serving sentences, the vast majority of whom will, in fact, rejoin the community, whether sooner or later. Your Lordships may be familiar with the figures, but with thanks to the Howard League for Penal Reform, I summarize. In 2024-5, assessment in England identified 57% of adult prisoners as having learning difficulty or disability. Over half men and over three-quarters, almost three-quarters women, identify with mental health problems. And as your Lordships have heard, in 2021, Dame Carol Black published an independent review which identified one-third of prisoners as having serious drug addiction.

In a survey undertaken by the Chief Inspector, 41% referred to the ease with which illicit drugs could be obtained in prison. In Category B training prisons, it was 57%. In large part, that is the cohort which society has to address. Education, along with support and treatment for mental health and drug issues, together with training to allow those released to be able to aspire to obtaining work, are all critical if we are to prevent the revolving door of repeated offending. I agree and fully endorse my Lord Farmer's observations when he emphasized the importance of maintaining family relationships.

The recent NACRO report, as your Lordships have heard, over 15,000 people homeless on their first night out of prison. In short, it all requires a move away from simple containment in prison to active measures to assist those in custody to find a bed and work towards living a useful life in the community. A plan is essential. Of course, there will be some who are so dangerous that this is not an option, but those are not the bulk of those in custody. But support, both while in prison and then in the community, is critical, and the Prison and Probation Service must be equipped both with personnel and resources to do so.

That will be expensive, but nothing like as expensive as receiving them back into prison or keeping them there. There are other great benefits of promoting rehabilitation. The prison population crisis is very real. If more can be supported in the community and reoffending minimized, there'll be more room for those who should be remanded into custody and those who are dangerous. Remand prisoners will be kept nearer their courts of trial.

The police will be able to provide greater focus on offenses that cause great public concern, including violence against women and girls, other serious sexual and violent offending, phone, petrol, shop theft and more. It will be clear that although this debate is about prisons and probation, the crisis is much wider. Every aspect of criminal justice requires urgent attention. Some courts are listing trials for 2030. Criminal justice reform could be my Mastermind specialist subject, but I would not dream of testing the patience of the House by going through my recent review.

It's sufficient to say that there are solutions which I look forward to discussing with and urging upon your Lordships, working with all to address the challenges that it faces. I end by observing that we must not forget the human beings behind all these issues: the victims, the witnesses and the offenders. The state must facilitate the early identification and detection of crime. It must, within a reasonable time, ensure its prosecution. And it must do all it can to promote the rehabilitation of convicted offenders.

If it does not, it is failing in one of its most important responsibilities.

05:44:37 - 05:48:02

Igor Judge

It is a very special privilege first to have listened to the speech of the noble and learned Lord Leveson of Liverpool, and now to have the chance to add a few remarks. I wish first of all to convey the apologies of Lord Burnett and Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers that events elsewhere detained them and they're unable to be present. But I have that pleasure. Indeed, it is now more than a quarter of a century ago that as what I still think of us as youngish judges, though alas no longer so, I think I can safely say, that we started to work together with the responsibility for the circuit system and in particular for the way in which criminal justice was administered by the courts under the leadership of that great Chief Justice, Lord Judge. Lord Judge would have been especially proud and delighted to have been here today because he would have seen this as an inevitability.

Like Lord Judge, Lord Leveson had enormous experience of the common law across all of its aspects, but particularly in criminal justice. And he brought that experience to bear both in trials and on appeals, and as importantly in the leadership he gave to the successive appointments he held to improving the criminal justice system and in the many reports and reviews he has conducted to that end. But his experience is much wider. I have not the time to go through it, but one particular example occupies the time of your Lordships' House from time to time, and that is the work of his as the Investigatory Powers Commissioner. He's a man of enormous talent and will bring huge benefits to this House.

Now, I need have said none of that because the proof of what he will bring is in all your expectations, which were amply justified. But modestly, of course, he said he was a little worried he might not live up to it. His mastery of the criminal law and the criminal justice system is enormous. And indeed, as I have found over that quarter of a century, I almost always agreed with everything he has said, and I can take that opportunity of saying so today because I do not wish to add because I could not possibly improve upon his analysis of the difficulties facing the criminal justice system.

05:47:45 - 05:51:58

Speaker 106

I too, like others of your Lordships, are extremely grateful to Lord Farmer for obtaining this debate, and to the many speeches that have been made about what needs to be done. The list is almost endless. But I want to address one overarching problem, and that is what can we do best with what money we get. I recall some years ago that this was exemplified by the first matter we have to address, and that is rigid discipline over money. Something no doubt you fear that I have gone over to the Treasury's, or should I say, the dark side.

But it is important to have discipline. And in the last Labour government in the early 2000s, I remember when reforms were thought of, you had to prove what effect it would have. And this was then checked by the Home Office. They had something called the Home Office model, which showed that if you created an offence, then it would need so many more prosecutors, so many more judges, so many more prison places. I deeply regret we don't do the same now on the most important aspect, which is at the heart of today's debate, the massive increase in prison sentence lengths of which everyone has spoken.

And I think that is the first thing we must do, is to bring back a fiscal discipline so we know what money we have, because only with knowing what the money we have can we do things properly. It is no use, and I and the late Lord Judge have been bitterly critical of the constant increase in sentence lengths without consideration of how is this to be paid for, without either putting prisoners into squalid conditions or cutting the really good things that are done in prison, and in particular, education. So that I think is the first fundamental question. We need to work out what we can pay for with the money available. The second fundamental question is then to turn to explain to the public what we are capable of doing.

And this is, I think, a shared endeavour of us all, because we cannot go on as we are. And it seems to me that what we must return to is first of all, for example, truth in sentencing. If the judge says you get five years and you spend half of that in prison and half in the community, that is what we deliver. But we've had to go away from that because we have not told the public the truth, that there is only a limited amount of money available and we can only do so much with it. And so I very much hope that this fundamental question will be grappled with by us all.

I warmly commend this government for what it has said about IPPs. It has taken a huge amount of courage and a sense of justice to do it.

The greater task ahead is to adopt the same attitude to explaining to the public that if this is the money available, this is all we can do, and prison sentence lengths must come down, we must use the prison spaces more effectively, and they will be better for that. That is, I think, the next task facing this government.

05:51:58 - 06:01:11

Claire Fox

My Lords, and not for the first time, I'm feeling a bit outclassed and overawed by the legal and judicial expertise in this place that's produced so many excellent speeches. I'd like to particularly thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for inviting us to talk about the state of prisons and probation services, but I do want to start by making some broader points about context. Because during the week, we've seen the extraordinary sight of 92% of the citizens of an Oxfordshire village in Piddington, population 358, voting in a symbolic referendum to become independent from the United Kingdom. In interviews with residents, there's been a common theme: the state is exposing them to danger. Housing 1,250 young male asylum seekers in nearby Bicester Garrison means, quote, "our safety, security and freedoms are under threat".

To paraphrase one woman, if these men need government leaflets to explain that sexually abusing children or raping women is wrong, I'm frightened to go out alone. I will become a prisoner in my own house. And that's my theme in a way. This sentiment of actually being a prisoner in your own house is not confined to leafy villages, but it's felt in towns and cities throughout the country. And it's not confined to asylum policies, and indeed one key issue that's been a lightning rod for worries that state policies are indifferent to public safety is the early release scheme.

For example, those women who now feel frightened in their own houses as victims of domestic abuse, worried that their early released tormentors may show up on the doorstep. Somehow, the law-abiding are unfairly becoming the victims of failed state policies. So whilst normally I'd want to use today's debate to talk in detail about prison reform, because I'm passionate about improving educational initiatives in prison especially, and I hate the lack of purposeful activity available that's been so well described by other noble Lords and a thought a magnificent speech by the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. But it's also true that it's become particularly difficult to convince the public that the MOJ should prioritize improving the treatment of prisoners in jail when so many are being released out of jail before they've spent served their time. Discussing rehabilitation feels meaningless when the very purpose of prisons, at least in the sense of punishment in terms of deprivation of liberty not cruelty, or to protect the public as a purpose, or to let alone rehabilitation to reduce reoffending, is hard to discuss those purposes when they're made a mockery of by successive governments' failure to deliver prison expansion and now the makeshift solutions to deal with the fallout.

The problem with early release schemes is that they outsource the problem onto into our communities, literally dumping it on our streets.

The public are rightly furious that criminals now won't serve the sentences that the law, that we make here, thinks appropriate for their crimes. Recent polling shows 69% are against the early release scheme, but more troubling, 68% say they've lost faith in all government's handling of criminal justice per se. At the forthcoming annual Battle of Ideas festival, organized by the Academy of Ideas, which I run to declare an interest, one of the panel debates is entitled "Let Abusers Out Early: Solving the Prison Crisis". And that's proving to be an unexpected festival sell-out hit. And I think the reasons when I talk to people are four recurring themes that get raised.

There's a perception that the early release scheme alongside the Sentencing Act's presumption, Sentencing Act, has a presumption against prison in favor of community sentences, and with the even further reductions in release dates to a third of sentences served, people just feel that sentencing's become a joke, and that it's less a pragmatic response to a lack of prison space than an official ideological turn against incarceration as punishment, but that this is happening without public debate or consent. Then there's also a worry that the prison crisis is diminishing the diligence of policing in pursuing certain crimes. I mean, what's the point of arresting shoplifters or burglars if they can't be threatened with the prospect of prison? A third concern is that early release is a lazy reaction to the crisis. Why not other emergency options?

Perhaps the prison equivalent to NHS Nightingales or, sorry, renovating the thousands of empty prison cells currently out of action, or even tackling those shocking facts that we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Leveson, in his brilliant speech, I thought, about those kept on remand as part, such a large percentage of the prison community. That really is a disgrace. And a final concern raised is in response to the government's reassurance that early release prisoners aren't being released freely but will be under close supervision. Yet probation services themselves admit they aren't equipped to cope. But also, the whole paraphernalia of control and surveillance in the community, curfews, electronic tags, formal restriction zones, the wearing of hi-vis vests, can only result in the whole swaths of local areas feeling more like open-air prisons for all rather than a free society.

Now, possibly the only good thing to have come from the prison crisis is indeed Prime Minister Andy Burnham's commendable announcement that he will at last end the injustice of IPP prisoners. I confess that I got emotional hearing an ex-IPP prisoner, Mark Conway from UNGRIPP, declaring that it was a day that thousands of families have spent years fighting for. But he also stressed that implementing the decision needed to be swift and transparent, and that's where the euphoria is dampened. Last week, I received this message from Stacey Cloth of the Injustice of IPP campaign, and I think it's worth us all listening to her words. She said, "I think it's great what Andy Burnham has said, but he's left IPP prisoners and their families with a different mental torture by not making it clear what is going to, what it's going to, what it's going to look like, and they still have no definite date to count down to."

"My partner said all the IPPs in Wayland have gone downhill as the hopes were raised by the announcement but there's no timeframe, and so they're all worried it's a false hope." "What if there's an election and Labour are voted out?" "Then back to square one." "They have now been left with uncertainty."

If the government don't end it, there's going to be more suicides. And I gulped at that. Stacy continues, the thing is, he could order probation to release the recall prisoners without any new requirements and no new legislation would be needed because of executive powers created in 2012, powers that they've never used. They should also be recommending that anyone going up for parole with no new crime or charges on a recall should be granted release and have their license terminated and give them a supervision order instead. So my advice to the noble lord the minister is to recommend to the MOJ that you give Stacy a job because she's got it all completely right as far as I'm concerned.

There's so many inequities in the way that IPPs continue to be treated, not just that we need to have those things happen more quickly, but I do think that when you hear, for example, that IPPs, even who are granted parole, are often kept in prison for months and months and months due to a lack of approved accommodation on the outside, there's things that need to be done fast. And while the noble lord the minister defended the principle of recall questions this week, the fact that the number of IPPs recalled without any criminal charges gone up from 70% in 2023 to 77% in 2025 should worry him. I hope that the noble lords have a good recess. I will be at number 10 North on Monday along with anti-IPP protesters. Anyway, that's it.

Thank you.

06:01:11 - 06:09:21

Edward Garnier

May I begin by congratulating and thanking my noble friend Lord Farmer for introducing this debate and for doing so with his usual calmness and analysis every time he speaks on this subject and he is a renowned expert, the house listens with great care and we did so again today. I also would like to welcome and to congratulate the noble and learned lord, Lord Leveson, both on his arrival here but also on his maiden speech. He should not feel in the least bit embarrassed about waiting only two or three days after his introduction before addressing the house. He should have done so on the first day and on the second and on the third and I hope he will on many days after this because as the noble and learned lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd has so correctly pointed out, he was a judge and will be a member of this house who will provide great wisdom and great analysis and a great sense of justice to anything that he brings his mind to bear. I want to thank whilst I have them sitting there, both the noble and learned lords for helping me just over 15, 16 years ago with the introduction of the deferred prosecution agreement which they as successor presidents of the Queen's Bench Division assisted me in my political guise, they in their judge's role, bring that criminal justice tool into fruition.

And it seems a little strange to me when I last appeared in front of the then Sir Brian Leveson when he was sitting in court, he was about 20 feet above me. The layout of this chamber allows me to be 10 feet above him.

I shall savor that. My Lords, as the noble Lord, Lord Foster, mentioned a little while ago, the Justice and Home Affairs Committee of your Lordships' House produced a report on the state of our prisons, and to some extent it mirrored the report made by the House of Commons Justice Committee. I think it's fair to say that neither of those reports was complimentary about what they had looked into and what they had found. And equally, it's fair to say that nor did they say anything that we didn't already know before. And until prisons become a politically important subject of real and regular interest to Prime Ministers and Secretaries of State for Justice, despite the hard work of junior ministers in the other place and on the front bench here, very little can be achieved.

Now, I am a cracked record in human form. For years now, I have been complaining about the state of our prison estate, what we do to improve the lives and prospects of those in prison, about the provision of education and employment opportunities for those in and those about to leave prison. We recycle offenders on an alarming scale into and out of prison and then back again. The reoffending rate varies marginally from time to time, but the general picture is deeply depressing. For a hard-pressed prison governor, a good day is when nothing happens.

No one, and by that I mean both prison staff and prisoners themselves, no one dies, no one gets stabbed, no one gets punched. The infrastructure of the prison functions. The movement of people from the accommodation wings to the places where out-of-cell activities are supposed to be happening takes place without incident and on time. No one throws drugs over the walls or flies them in by drone. The provision of food and medical supplies is efficiently administered and delivered without mishap.

That's a good day. But they're very rare. Now, sadly, there aren't many good days for prison governors or their staff or for the prisoners. And as I say, this is not a new state of affairs. It will continue as it has done for decades under Labour as well as under Conservative governments, and it will get even worse as we overcrowd the prisons and create or permit the continuance of squalid and uncivilized living and working conditions within them.

They are in so many respects hopeless places. I once said to a local journalist when I was a Member of Parliament that all prisons should obviously have walls, both to keep the prisoners in and to keep the public out, but those walls should also have large windows in them so that the public could see into them, into the prisons, to know what is being done on their behalf inside, and the prisoners could see out through those windows so that they could see that there was a community out there that would welcome them back if they were rehabilitated, if they could learn to read and write, if they could get off drugs, if they could become social beings, they could become employable and so on. And the local journalist looked at me and said, "You clearly haven't thought of the public expenditure implications of building all those windows." And I think he was being serious, which is rather depressing.

Now, I suffer from analysis paralysis, and I accept that reciting what's wrong is easy. Doing something about it seems to be impossible. My Lords, this scandalous injustice must stop. The tiresome blame game played by successive governments is unproductive, and it does us no credit, still less achieve anything. I have recently written a letter to the new Prime Minister, and I gave a copy of that letter to the noble Lord the Minister, Lord Lemos, and I hope, and I'm sure he has, read it.

He probably keeps it by his bed and is setting it to music. Now, we don't need, as the Justice Union have indicated today in their statement, we don't need a Royal Commission to investigate our prisons and to make robust recommendations. We know what is wrong. What we require is a government to do something about it. What we need is determined action, led by a Prime Minister and by a Secretary of State, politically motivated and who are able to provide the political motivation and to command the system that they oversee to do what is required.

Everybody who has already spoken has indicated what is required. It just requires leadership and action. And I urge the Minister to run round to Number 10 this evening and to say that he's ready for action.

06:09:21 - 06:15:36

Robert Winston

My Lords, I too have very little experience in this area, but I thought I did have something that I thought was worth saying from a professional point of view. My experience of prisons is not as a prisoner, but I have been inside prisons to see sick patients when I was on call at Hammersmith Hospital, and indeed when they were actually probably quite seriously ill, but this was being ignored. But finally, there was no doctor present at the weekend. I was the obstetrician on call, so dealing with deliveries and surgery, but as a surgeon, there was nobody else to go to see the male patients in the male inmates of Wormwood Scrubs. And then since then, having seen the absolute squalor and appalling circumstances and the lack of hope and the complete negligence of people really understanding what was behind these people's suffering, and seeing one of these patients being brought into the Hammersmith Hospital still actually handcuffed so I couldn't actually examine his abdomen, made me realize how far we had sunk in our society.

And that was combined too with another patient who was in custody and was there for several years. His wife had been a patient of mine who had been desperate for children. She'd been trying for a child almost ten years, and she was getting older and older, and her husband recently had been sentenced and was in prison, I think for four years. And I had spent a year trying to persuade the authorities, who were completely indifferent, including many of the people in the Home Office, that we needed to get some sperm from this man. We didn't need to do in vitro fertilization, simple artificial insemination would be all that we needed.

It was the most difficult tussle, but at the time they broke a rule finally because of the persistence. Actually, it got into the newspapers, and nobody in the newspapers understood the suffering behind that. But actually, as has been said in this debate, it made a difference later on to the cohesion of that family when the child was born. And I'm quite proud of that moment. I want to say too that the letters I've had from prisoners sent to me by the Howard League of Penal Reform show just some terrible lacks which we've been talking about.

The overcrowding is massive. There's one patient, one well, prisoner who is quite clearly autistic, he points this out. He obviously has other mental health disorders. And he says he's constantly surrounded by constant noise, he can't sleep. He's there and he is absolutely unable to express his mental condition which of course as an autistic person is extremely sensitive to noise.

This is not at all atypical. And it's simply that nothing can be done about it in that environment. Another another inmate talks about the lack of training, the lack of rehabilitation. He says sometimes it might just be finally available when you're ready to be released for the first time and no chance of trade skills. What is interesting about all of these letters is that they're really not hysterical.

They're very calm. They're very limited in what they complain about, but they come to the point very well. My Lords, we have a human brain which is one of the most complicated objects in the known universe. It has about a hundred billion neurons. Each of those neurons will be connected up to two thousand times to other areas of the brain.

What we know is that as the neurons develop and as we learn, those new connections are found as a result. You can actually see this now under a microscope. I have wonderful photographs of this actually happening when there's a change in the environment, you can see how these kind of synapses connect up other nerves nerves. If those stimuli in that environment are constantly repeated, you end up learning more and more. You actually inherit the fixed learning that you need as you get older.

What we have of course here in prisons is exactly that. We have an environment which is constant and constantly against the right kind of learning. And so inevitably we end up with whole people who are already damaged but then have damaged more, been their brains have been damaged by us. This is something which we should really recognize very importantly. It's essential that that environment is absolutely critical and it is absolutely appalling.

I can't leave without saying briefly how much I valued the noble and learned Lord Lord Leveson on his wonderful maiden speech. It's not the custom to keep on going on about new but this is an exceptional it was an exceptional speech. And I think what is so wonderful is to see crossbenchers of his caliber coming into this House to improve the knowledge, the experience that we actually desperately need in this chamber. So I think we should be so grateful that he is here and his speech particularly today is a very good start. I want to say finally that this is this is not a private matter.

We this is sent away. We discuss all the time in this chamber schools. We discuss discuss defense all the time. We discuss healthcare again and again. We ask the same questions at question time.

How often do we talk about the shame of prisons? We think of course the prisoners are ashamed. No, we should be ashamed because this is our shame as a society. We need to change this and we need to do a colossal amount about it. And as these prisoners know, the prison system is under collapse at the moment.

It is really seriously threatened. And therefore there is a threat to ourselves, not our safety, but our well-being as people, as humans. Let us remember our humanity and let's try to do something about it.

06:15:36 - 06:21:36

Amanda Sater

It's a great pleasure to follow the noble lord, Lord Wilson. And I would also like to thank the noble lord, Lord Farmer, for securing this important debate. And I pay tribute to all the work he does on this subject. I would also like to welcome and congratulate Lord Wilson on his excellent maiden speech. The pressures on our prisons and probation service are stark, as Lord Farmer has spoken about so articulately today.

We have already heard the government has announced up to 500 million pounds of additional funding for probation and community services, alongside at least 1,300 additional trainee probation officers in 2026 and 2026 and 2027. However, the strain on probation has been building for a long time, as we've heard from many today. And and many in the justice system have raised serious concerns about whether even this substantial investment will meet the scale of the challenge. Finding and retaining workforce is a major challenge, whilst caseloads continue to rise. The latest workforce figures published in August show that the probation service is almost 2,000 full-time equivalent officers below its target level.

That is a significant gap. And with the changes to changes to early release arrangements next month, probation will have even more on their plate, especially with an increased emphasis on intensive supervision, electronic tagging and monitoring, alongside the the increased casework. My lords, where does that leave effective and meaningful rehabilitation, especially when reoffending rates remain high? If we are increasing the demands of probation, we must also also ask whether we are giving it the capacity to deliver the rehabilitation that reduces reoffending. Perhaps there are more important lessons we can learn from the youth justice system.

My lords, last Friday we had the second reading of the Youth Justice Board Bill, brought forward by the the noble lord, Lord Oates, where concerns were raised about the government's proposed changes to its functions and responsibilities and the extra burden placed on the MOJ. I I'm not certain that the MOJ needs any more responsibilities or work. As a former youth magistrate and former member of the board, I have seen firsthand what the youth justice system has achieved. The marked fall in youth offending and youth custody is an extraordinary achievement. It is not always how you spend the money, it is where we spend it.

Perhaps one of the most important lessons that could be learned is the holistic approach that has been taken in youth justice. As His Majesty's Chief Inspector of Probation, Martin Jones, said earlier this year of youth justice, and I quote, "We have all the building blocks of success, and we need to ensure that we carry that across into the adult system." Those building blocks could also help us address the challenges faced by young adults as they transition into the adult system, as Lord Farmer has mentioned today. As we know, those aged between 18 and 25 have some of the highest rates of reoffending. And crucially, it is a period in which effective intervention can change the trajectory of a young person's young people's lives.

So if we get the right interventions, it would mean fewer victims, fewer people returning to prison, and ultimately a better use of taxpayers' money. We know that this age group is an important stage of development: education, employment, relationships, independence and independence are still taking shape, while maturity is still developing. Therefore, we should think of the 18 to 25 age group as as more a coherent end-to-end cohort, with much greater continuity between the youth justice services and adult probation, an issue an issue again which Lord Farmer has spoken about today.

But rehabilitation is not only about what happens after someone leaves prison. It also depends on what happens while they are in prison. And this is where purposeful activity matters, as Lord Foster of Bath has already highlighted. Education, skills, training and physical activity can all contribute to a purposeful prison regime and to an effective rehabilitation. For many people entering prison with existing health needs, as highlighted by Lord Brooke, access to the right support plays an important part in their rehabilitation.

And yet purposeful activity remains a serious weakness in our prisons. As His Majesty's Chief Inspector of Prisons Charlie Taylor has highlighted, of the 38 men's and women's prisons inspected in 2024-2025, 28 were rated poor or not sufficiently good for purposeful activity. And this matters not only in prison, but through the gate too. My Lords, probation needs the resources and time to build partnerships with employers, charities, training providers, families and communities. This is fundamental to the success of rehabilitation.

As the noble Lord Lord Timpson said, and I quote, "By tackling the root causes of offending and giving people the second chance they need, we can help them rebuild their lives and stay on the straight and narrow." Therefore, may I ask the noble Lord the Minister, how can we expect the probation service to have the capacity to tackle the root causes of offending when there are so many other pressures in the pressures on the system? My Lords, we know that the true test of probation is not simply whether it can monitor someone when they leave prison. It is whether it can help them turn their lives around and build a better future. Once again, can I thank the noble Lord Lord Farmer for securing this excellent debate.

06:21:36 - 06:27:09

Frances D'Souza

My Lords, may I begin by thanking the noble Lord Lord Farmer for providing the opportunity for such a vital debate. And then, may I say how very delighted I am to see the noble and learned Lord Lord Lloyd-Jones sitting on the crossbenches and to thank him for his excellent, wise but very sobering maiden speech. My Lords, I speak as the honorary president of the Zahid Mubarek Foundation, known as ZMT, which was founded some 25 years ago following the murder of Zahid while on remand in a young offender's institution. He was placed in a cell with a known racist who had a history of extreme violence. The subsequent public inquiry uncovered 186 missed opportunities to protect Zahid and exposed institutional racism within the prison service.

The ZMT exists, continues to exist, to promote racial equality in prisons and runs innovative programs to enable greater racial equality and indeed in leadership. In the 25 years since the murder of Zahid, there have been a series of initiatives and reviews to improve racial equality in the prison service and in the criminal justice system. Despite this, my Lords, there is a worrying there is worrying evidence of significant racial disparities in both prisons and more widely in criminal justice. 27% of the prison population in England and Wales comes from ethnic communities. However, if the prison population were to reflect the UK's ethnic makeup, there would be 9,000 fewer men and boys in prison.

Offenders from ethnic minorities have a disproportionately higher likelihood of receiving custodial sentences even after taking higher not guilty plea rates into account. Defendants from minority ethnic groups are far more likely to be remanded in custody, and black prisoners serve a far greater proportion of determinate sentences.

The use of force against black prisoners is much higher. The most recent figures show 409 incidents per 1,000 black prisoners as compared to 209 incidents for white prisoners. The Prison Inspectorate's annual report for 2024-25 aggregated the data from sample surveys broken down between white prisoners and all other ethnic groups. The latter category consistently expressed more negative experiences than their white peers. On 69% of the topics covered, the other ethnic group category was significantly more likely to report negative experiences.

These included access to jobs and the library, medical appointments, education and training opportunities, and help in preparing for release. So my Lords, there's no denying that there are, there continue to be racial disparities in prisons. The question is what more can be done. A commitment by the Minister to work with voluntary organisations, including the Zahid Mubarek Trust, to monitor, for example, the implementation of the progression regime, which will be introduced by the 2026 Sentencing Act, would be very welcome, since there is genuine concern that ethnic minority prisoners will not benefit to the same extent as white prisoners. Finally, my Lords, it is disturbing that there is no national plan or strategy to promote racial equality in prisons.

His Majesty's Prison and Probation Service has nominated senior civil servant race champions, and it has a national team with a brief to advance racial inclusion. However, a letter to the co-director of the Zahid Mubarek Trust on the 1st of May of this year, from the briefing and correspondence team of His Majesty's Prison and Probation Service stated, and I quote: "There is no single overarching strategy or action plan focused specifically on reducing racial disparity within prisons, nor is there a centrally held budget dedicated solely to race equality." At a local level, prisons are required to maintain their own diversity and inclusion plans, which are tailored to local needs and are not consolidated into a single national document. Budgetary responsibility for related activity sits locally rather than being captured within a single centrally held budget. Real civil service language.

Of course, my Lords, it makes sense for local initiatives to be tailored to the local situation in a particular prison, but it is difficult to see how continuing racial disparities can be tackled effectively without an overarching national strategy and action plan to promote racial equality in the prison system.

06:27:09 - 06:30:21

Timothy Ray

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Farmer for introducing this debate, and I thank all noble Lords for their speeches today, with congratulations to the noble Lord, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, for his excellent maiden speech.

The capacity of prisons across the country remains a concerning problem, with a prison population expected to reach between 92,400 and 100,000 by November 2032. Although the government have pledged 14,000 new prison places by 2031, serious progress is needed to meet that target, progress that is not yet apparent. The government have delivered 700 fewer prison cells than last year, and no new prisons have been planned or approved since the Labour government took office in 2024. These new prisons will be essential to increase the prison capacity, so hopefully there will be evidence as to how they will reach that pledge. There is also a problem now.

The problem of immediate availability is similarly severe, and, as was discussed only last week at the criminal justice reform statement, there are 4,000 operational prison places that are not in use. The noble Lord, the Minister, did not set out what steps the government were taking to ensure that these existing places could be utilised. So I pose the same question: how will the government address the issues of officer shortages to allow those places to be used? We have heard from the sector that retention is a huge problem among prison officers. What specific steps are ministers taking to improve retention?

I now turn to the probation system, where serious concerns have been raised about the electronic tagging system. In July, the National Audit Office expressed concerns regarding public safety if the electronic tagging system was rapidly expanded to reduce the prison population. Their report noted that between 10 and 50% of alerts resulted in breach notifications being sent to the relevant officials. Further to that, serious and minor breaches were both treated the same. Will the noble Lord, the Minister, ensure that all tagging breaches are dealt with?

Last week, my noble friend Lord Wolfson asked about the barriers posed by Articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention of Human Rights and targets for the number of foreign national prisoners being deported, to which the noble Lord, the Minister, said he would come back to. Will the noble Lord, the Minister, do so now and share how they intend to address these barriers? I look forward to the Minister's response.

06:30:21 - 06:40:30

Jonathan Marks

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for securing this debate and for his excellent opening speech. The noble Lord has campaigned tirelessly on prison reform, as he has on family life, so he unsurprisingly stressed, with others, the importance of contact with their families for prisoners. My Lords, we have heard a brilliant, sympathetic and far-reaching maiden speech from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson. Our new boy, as he modestly described himself, well, we for our part are honoured to have such an extremely distinguished new boy, and we will continue to benefit greatly in this House from his wisdom, his incisiveness and his humanity. My Lords, this government inherited a crisis in our prisons and probation service.

With Lord Brooke, I pay tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Timpson, for the progress he made in tackling this as Prisons Minister. His presence in government will be missed.

My Lords, until the Sentencing Act, as Lord Brooke said, the threat of our criminal justice system collapsing for want of prison space was all too real. The last government recognized this problem far too late and introduced a haphazard series of crisis early release schemes, but without offering any long-term solution. We've at last put the management of determinate sentences on a more organized footing, moving towards an earned progression model, restructuring such sentences in an orderly way, with the first third of sentences to be spent in custody and the second third, barring bad behavior, to be served under intensive supervision by the probation service in the community. For this second stage, offenders would be subject to tagging and a series of tailored restrictions as necessary, designed to address concern among victims and the public on security and safety grounds following prisoners' release from custody. Stage three, the last third, will then be spent on license.

I agree with the noble and learned Lord Lord Thomas that we must be clear with the public about what we are doing and why. So, my Lords, we must hope the new system will work with the aid of extensive use of better technology. There is evidence from Texas and elsewhere that gives grounds for optimism, though I should add that I would have preferred to see earned release with more emphasis on rewarding good behavior in custody rather than simply punishing misbehavior. Moreover, my Lords, many have pointed out that the length of prison sentences has doubled in recent decades. Our sentences are longer than almost everywhere else in Europe, and there is no evidence that longer sentences reduce reoffending or aid rehabilitation.

On the contrary, offenders serving long sentences in overcrowded prisons become institutionalized and lose hope, suffering, as the noble Lord Lord Winston pointed out, increased mental damage over time as they do so. Overcrowding is made worse because there are too many unconvicted people in prison on remand and for far too long, as Lord Leveson said. And too many are unnecessarily recalled for inadequate reasons, as my noble friend Lord Foster and Lord Bellamy argued. Then far too many people receive prison sentences rather than community sentences, which would genuinely address their difficulties. The noble and learned lady Baroness Butler-Sloss spoke of treatment of addiction within the community, which prison cannot realistically replicate, and she was right.

My Lords, I invite the government to continue along Lord Timpson's path of according a greater priority to developing a more humane and effective penal system that prioritizes reducing reoffending and rehabilitation, that moves away from the wasteful and ineffective use of ever longer sentences of imprisonment in response to ill-advised press and public demand. End the media drama, as Lord Farmer put it. We must improve conditions in many of our unhealthy prisons. We must continue to increase staffing levels and help dedicated staff in assisting prisoners to turn their lives around. Instead of aggravating drug addiction, mental health issues, appalling violence and criminality in our prisons, lack of education and training and consequently unemployability, our prisons and probation services must be dedicated to addressing and overcoming these issues.

That was the essence of the noble Lord Lord Garnier's argument, with which I agreed fully.

These issues are often worse for black prisoners, as the noble lady Baroness De Souza said. My noble friend Lord Foster and Lord Brooke also spoke of gambling addiction, also needing urgent action, which cannot be provided in prisons. Furthermore, my Lords, release from prison is not the end of the story. The probation service has a huge challenge to be effective in continuing the rehabilitation of prisoners on release. While tagging and the enforcement of restrictions on released prisoners' movements and exclusion orders and the like are very important as safeguards for victims and for the public, the probation service is about much more than tough offender management.

Our probation officers do a fantastic job. However, to reduce reoffending, the probation service must have the numbers, the space, the resources and the training to be able to assist clients with accessing mental health and addiction services, education, training, employment and, of course, housing, as Lord Farmer stressed. To train a new probation officer takes at least 15 months, and the application process adds a further six months. So we worry that the extra 700 million pounds for probation services, welcome as it is, may not cover both the extra work needed for rehabilitating offenders and coping with the increased demands of intense supervision of many more prisoners released into the community, a point well made by the noble lady Baroness Sater. So I repeat the question I asked the minister last Tuesday to which I had no answer: what contingency plans are in place to provide further funds should this allocation of 700 million prove inadequate?

But even with the implementation of the Sentencing Act and increased work by the probation service, the shortage of prison space will not go away. Even the most optimistic predictions suggest that the prison population will rise again. Add to that the need to replace many of our older and unsuitable prisons in crying need of replacement, and we will inevitably need more space. My Lords, the government is optimistic on prison building, but we cannot build ourselves out of this crisis. So clearly more and more suitable space is necessary.

I'm concerned that the proposal to build more cells into existing prisons may increase pressure on other facilities within those prisons. Furthermore, building more new prisons involves long delays. The minister says the government has acquired suitable land and that they can mitigate the delays inherent in designing and building new prisons. I hope he will forgive me for being skeptical about that. Recent experience of planning applications for prisons and local objections to such applications gives no reason for optimism.

It is therefore very important that we consider a realistic assessment of the demand for new prison places and test it against a realistic program of acquisition and building of new prisons. Furthermore, any prison building program must allow for sufficient headroom to allow prisoners to be housed in prisons located with their needs and rehabilitation in mind, including, as Lord Farmer said, the need for prisoners to be close to their families and communities.

Shuffling prisoners around an overcrowded prison estate throughout the UK is a recipe for failure of rehabilitation and for failure in the drive to cut reoffending and for increased public expense, a point which follows from the analysis of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd. That means more crime and the public continuing to be let down by a penal system that is not only inhumane, but one that continues down a road that has failed in the past and threatens to fail us again unless we genuinely concentrate on developing and funding an approach which works. And an approach which works will ultimately bring benefits in falling crime and in reduced public expense.

06:40:30 - 07:01:28

Anthony Gerard Lemos

My Lords, I begin by thanking the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for securing this important debate and all noble Lords who have contributed this afternoon to what I think has been a sober, but very humane debate. And noble Lords will know that not every debate about prisons has those characteristics, so I very much appreciate that. For many years, the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, has brought sustained attention to the purpose of imprisonment and to the vital role that families and strong, stable relationships can play in rehabilitation. And we are very grateful to him. And I should say, I declare my own interest that I was the lead non-executive director of HMPPS until 2021 and chaired their agency board and had the pleasure and the privilege of meeting Lord Farmer and talking with him, particularly about the work that my colleagues, my then colleagues at HMPPS, were doing on the relational model, which he was a champion of and which is, I think, at the heart of what we are all discussing.

I should also, of course, congratulate the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, on a magnificent opening maiden speech. I've read both parts of Lord Leveson's court review twice, I'm proud to say. He looks shocked, but I have, and I look forward to working with him very closely, as does everyone at the Ministry of Justice. My Lords, I will start with the most immediate pressure on prison capacity. I take the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier's challenge not to indulge in the blame game very seriously, and I'll try not to, and I'll try also not to recite lots of things that other people have said before and which your Lordships already know.

I am also all too conscious that I alone stand between you all and recess, so I shall be concise but thorough. My Lords, on all these comments about prison capacity, as I say, I'm not going to indulge in the blame game, but the comments that many noble Lords have made in two regards, I think, highlight the heart of this problem and the theme that we will return to again and again. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, mentioned the great increase in sentence length, as did the noble lady, Lady Butler-Sloss. And this is at the heart, the long-running heart of this difficulty with prison capacity. And noble Lords don't need me to tell them that in the context of a prison capacity crisis, many, if not all of the things that noble Lords have said they value in prisons about education, about regime, about healthcare and about rehabilitation, they are the first things that suffer in overcrowded prisons with overstretched staff.

And so we have to get the capacity crisis under control. I'm not, as I say, I'm not going to bandy figures around, but we are providing 14,000 additional prison places and we will continue to make that commitment to prison building. I would just say this to the noble Lord Marks about that. I don't think we are suggesting that the prison numbers will come down or that the prison building programme may in the end not prove adequate. I think we do recognise that this is an ongoing thing and will go on for a very long time, perhaps even for a decade.

And I entirely agree with the comment by the noble Lord Lord Marks that we cannot build our way out of this capacity challenge, though build we must. On sentencing, my Lords, measures already in force include the presumption to suspend prison sentences of 12 months or less. The noble Lord Lord Farmer talked about short sentencing, and those are subject to important exceptions, but our view is that short spells in custody disrupt housing arrangements, disrupt employment, drug treatment, are not good for mental health, and crucially, as the noble Lord Lord Farmer says, the family ties that are at the heart of preventing further offending. Where offenders can be punished and managed safely in the community, and I'm not apologising for the use of the word punishment, we should use that opportunity to both supervise them effectively and to tackle the underlying causes of their offending and reserve prisons for those who most need to be there and from whom the public need to be protected. Over the coming months, my Lords, we will implement the progression model that was at the heart of David Gauke's recommendations and at the heart of the Sentencing Act.

And I know I've had the opportunity to discuss that with many noble Lords before today. But this is an, this is almost the most important building block to a changed landscape for prisons. And I make this offer to noble Lords in the spirit of Lord Timpson, you can think of me as a sort of polyester version of Lord Timpson. I'd be very happy, I do feel that the whole approach in the Sentencing Act of a third in custody, a third under intensive supervision, I do think we need to make sure the public understand that much better as Lord Marks and others have said. And I'd be very happy to arrange a presentation from our officials on exactly how this is going to work and how we are preparing for it.

But my Lords, it does mean a tougher probation service and I was very mindful of the comments that the noble lady Lady Sater made, who I'm working with on youth custody as well. The, we are asking the probation service to do something really quite difficult, as I think the noble Lord Lord Marks made clear. We are asking it to improve itself after a long history of troubles which started with the failed privatisation and to take on many new responsibilities under the intensive supervision model. And that is what, we know that's challenging.

I've talked about the money. The noble Lord, Lord Marks, asked me again about contingency planning. I think the whole question of government funding and the need for more funding is something we talk about all the time in the Ministry of Justice, as noble Lords can imagine. And we will approach the spending review in the usual optimistic spirit. But, and I do want to recognize finally on this question of the progression model, that we did listen to some of the concerns of victims and their families about those changes.

And as noble Lords know, we changed some of the exemptions. But we do recognize that changing release arrangements can cause victims and their family a great deal of uncertainty and distress. But that is why stronger supervision and support for victims are so important in the government's approach. Can I now turn to prison safety and security, which a number of noble Lords have mentioned. Prisons must be places of safety, security, and order, where staff can do their jobs, prisoners can engage in a constructive regime, particularly in education and training for employment, and genuine rehabilitation can take place.

And as I've said, all this is made much more difficult by serious overcrowding and overstretched staff and inadequate facilities. Drugs, illicit mobile phones, and drones fuel violence, criminal activity, debt, and intimidation, undermine staff authority, and make turning lives around substantially harder. At the heart of what we need to do is to ensure effective security. It is essential, and that is why we are investing both in the fabric and the security of our prisons, including an additional 35 million pounds this financial year, so we do get some money out of the Treasury, to strengthen counter-drone security in prisons where there's the greatest threat. We're also working closely with law enforcement partners to disrupt those bringing drugs, weapons, and other contraband into prison.

My Lords, our prison officers perform a demanding public service, and I take my hat off to them. And they need the confidence, training, and support to maintain order and build the constructive relationships that help offenders turn their backs on crime for good. In response to the noble Lord, Lord Ray, as of June this year, prison officer staffing stood at 92% of our target level, and prison officer resignation rates are at their lowest in five years. It's obviously a difficult labor market, as the noble Lord, Lord Foster, highlighted, and many pressures remain, particularly in hard-to-staff prisons. But we have had an enormous effort going back to my days in HMPPS on recruitment, as I'm sure the noble Lord, Lord Foster, would recognize.

My Lords, as so many noble Lords have highlighted, a safe prison must also be a purposeful one. And most people who enter prison, as I think the noble and learned Lord Thomas highlighted, will eventually return to the community. And this is a simple statement of fact that's too readily ignored. Nearly 80% of offenders are reoffenders, and therefore we have a responsibility to use the time spent in custody as effectively as we can, as so many noble Lords have emphasized. Our approach is to help individuals develop skills, secure employment, and stable accommodation, access to treatment for substance misuse and mental health needs.

In response to the noble Lord, Lord Brooke, we meet regularly with Dame Carol Black, and we're working with her on her report. And I and my colleagues would be very happy to meet him and his colleagues to discuss the AI tool that he was describing.

But all of these things, all of these efforts in healthcare, in accommodation, all go to the heart of Lord Farmer's proposition that what we are trying to do through all these things is maintain positive relationships. And that is a good thing, a good and humane thing to do regardless of anything else. It is a good in itself. Effective rehabilitation, but nevertheless sits alongside punishment and robust supervision as an essential part of protecting the public. Every offence prevented means one fewer victim.

I do want to recognize the comments made by my noble friend Lord Winston, which I thought were utterly compelling about the effect on the on the brain and and that seemed to me a very and I've seen research along those lines before and that seemed to me a very important area for us to develop. The noble Lord, Lord Foster, knows and we've discussed before the whole question of gambling and gambling addiction and my noble friend Lord Timpson made some progress on that and I hope I hope we can continue to that and I've no doubt at all I shall have many opportunities to discuss that with the noble Lord, Lord Foster. Purposeful activity can have a transformative effect and we are expanding vocational training and apprenticeships and improving links with employers and access to education and our track record on getting prisoners into jobs when they leave has improved and my noble friend Lord Timpson put a great deal of emphasis on that. We are seeing progress, the proportion of prison leavers in employment six months after release increased to 36.5% in the year to March 26. We know we've got a long way to go, but we are we are making some progress there.

Can I now turn specifically to the question of family and other relationships which the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, describes as the golden thread. And the evidence bears that out, research shows that prisoners who received visits were three percentage points less likely to reoffend within one year of release, but as I've said, I regard that as a good thing in itself, whatever the statistics are telling us and I'm delighted that they confirm my view. My Lords, the prison gates should not be a cliff edge for all the reasons I have set out. Prisons, probation, local authorities, health services and employment support must work as one system and of course there are many, many difficulties. And that is why alongside MHCLG, we have committed to halve the proportion of prison leavers released to no fixed abode and to increase the proportion in settled accommodation by the end of this Parliament.

Can I now say a few words about probation. I want first of all to thank probation staff for the vital work they do every day to protect the public and support rehabilitation. It's easy to be critical, but we also need to recognize their efforts and their achievements. And they have been kept been asked to carry too much for too long. We are responding with with the investment that a number of noble Lords have referred to and we have already recruited 2,300 new probation officers over the past year and are recruiting at least 1,300 more in 26-27.

But we are rebuilding the service and we are asking it to take on new responsibilities. Probation officers do, as the noble lady Lady Sace said, will have more on their plates and there is much to be learned from the experience in youth custody. I entirely agree with her about that. Moving part of a sentence from custody into the community as we are does not mean the end of punishment. We are giving probation the toughest range of tools ever to manage offenders, including tough license conditions, electronic tagging on a scale never seen before, curfews, restriction zones and recall to prison where those conditions are breached.

The noble lord Lord Bellamy spoke about recalls and I answered a question yesterday from the noble and learned lord Lord Garnier in relation to IPPs and recalls. I'm very happy to take that away and get back to the noble lord and to everyone who's spoken in this debate about exactly what we're doing to address that trend. I would say one of the things we are already aware of is that once someone has been recalled, the time taken to get to a parole decision before they can be released is something we need to address. But I don't at all demur from the general challenge and I will return to it. And again, my lords, as I have said about the progression models, my officials will be very happy to arrange a session on the changes to probation so noble lords can feel more confident at least of the steps that we're taking to build a probation service for the future.

My lords, can I say something about women offenders, female offenders, as raised by the noble lord Lord Farmer and the noble lady Lady Butler-Sloss? Female offenders often have distinct and complex needs. Many are victims themselves with histories of trauma, abuse, mental health and addiction, and many are mothers. That is why our long-term aim is to reduce the number of women in prison and in particular pregnant women and mothers of young children. That is a particular commitment of ours to which we shall be addressing ourselves with energy.

We have announced, and Lady Butler-Sloss, the noble lady Lady Butler-Sloss, this refers to what she was talking about, the expansion of intensive supervision courts for women, which use a multi-agency approach to address the root causes of offending, and I do think this is an important development which we shall watch very carefully to see if it may help in other areas too. We're also investing in voluntary and community sector provision to help prevent offending and divert women away from the criminal justice system in the first place. And the Sentencing Act's presumption to suspend sentences is expected to reduce the number of women entering prison by about a third. However, custody will of course remain necessary when the seriousness of the offense or protection of the public requires it. The noble and learned lord Lord Garnier and one or two other noble lords mentioned the government's decision on IPPs.

I'm very proud of that. We are continuing with the regular meetings with interested peers and indeed the Lord Chancellor himself is attending the next one. I know the noble and learned lord Lord Garnier looks very impressed. The independent review of the prison system chaired by Amber Rudd will examine the long-term reforms needed to build a prison system fit for the future as the noble lord Lord Farmer has challenged us, and she will report later this year and I and my ministerial colleagues will be working closely with her on that. My lords, we must protect the public and we must stand with victims.

Serious offenders must be punished appropriately. Those released into the community must be robustly supervised, and we must reduce the likelihood of further offending. If we succeed in this, that will mean fewer crimes and fewer victims. I note the comments that noble Lords have made on foreign national offenders and on remand. This is all part of the approach we need to getting prison numbers into a more sustainable future.

And my Lords, I hope I've addressed the principal points raised, but I will read Hansard with my officials carefully, and of course I will write on points I've failed to address. But I would say this: I have worked in my short time in this job, but indeed before, with many of the noble Lords in this House on these issues. And I do regard this as a collaborative cross-party venture — I was going to say advent, but certainly a venture. And I know noble Lords from across the House are working with us on IPPs, but I hope we can continue to work together more widely. And in closing, I reiterate my thanks to the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for tabling this motion and giving us the opportunity to have this debate.

And none of the problems that noble Lords have highlighted should prevent us from paying tribute to those who work tirelessly across our prisons and probation service. They undertake, as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, noted, difficult and demanding work on behalf of us all. Your Lordships, I wish you all a very good recess. I hope you don't go to too many conferences, but before that, Lord Farmer will respond.

07:01:28 - 07:03:59

Michael Stahel Farmer

Thank you. I think I'm the barrier between everyone and the recess. What I would say is, just to begin with, I think this has been a really very good debate, a very valuable debate, and it's been a collaborative debate. We've worked together. There hasn't been partisanship, and I think that's been very important because this is a very important subject.

And to be quite frank, it's a very depressing subject, and I think the reasons for depressing have become apparent from many of the speeches today. And I would just compliment, I think, every single member who has contributed today. They've been excellent contributions, and I hope that the Hansard of this debate will actually get some publicity because it needs it. People need to see clearly the problems that are going on in the prison estate, but they also need to see how we together can work and cooperate. And I very much liked the emphasis, in a way, on the prisoner as a human being.

That came out in a few speeches — the learned Lord Leveson and Lord Winston also mentioned that, but it came over in many speeches. And I would particularly concur with everybody else. It was almost an honour to have Lord Leveson making his maiden speech in this debate, and I think it was a hugely valuable contribution. So I'm not going to go on and on because we do need to get to recess and it's been a long day, but I would just thank you all for your valuable contributions. I do hope it gets widespread across Parliament and into the departments of government, but also in fact a little bit out there to the wider public, that they understand the problems that is in the prison estate at the moment.

And with that, I'll withdraw my motion.

07:03:59 - 07:04:07

Speaker 116

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.

07:04:07 - 07:04:23

Speaker 117

Well, my Lords, we're about to go on recess, so I'd just like to take this opportunity to thank all the staff of the House for their hard work and support and of course wish them and indeed all your noble Lords a very restful recess and enjoy your party conference if you're attending. And with that, I beg to move the House to now adjourn.

07:04:23 - 07:04:23

The House do now adjourn.