House of Lords

2 November 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
03:40 - 05:41
Speaker 1
Charles the Third, by the Grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of our other realms and territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith, to all lords spiritual and temporal and all other our subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we, of our especial grace, certain knowledge, and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create, and prefer our trusty and well-beloved Julia Katherine Wyre Aglionby to the state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baroness Aglionby of Armathwaite in our county of Cumbria.  And for us, our heirs, and successors, do appoint, give, and grant unto her the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baroness Aglionby, to have and to hold unto her for her life.  Willing, and by these presents granting, for us, our heirs, and successors, that she may have, hold, and possess a seat, place, and voice in the Parliaments and public assemblies and councils of us, our heirs, and successors within our United Kingdom amongst the Barons.  And also, that she may enjoy and use, all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities, and advantages to the degree of a baron duly and of right belonging, which barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed or as they do at present use and enjoy. 
05:41 - 06:05
Speaker 2
In witness whereof, we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourselves at Westminster, in the afternoon of the first day of September in the fourth year of our reign, by warrant under the King's sign-manual. 
06:05 - 06:05
I, Julia, Baroness Aglionby, do solemnly, sincerely, and truly declare and affirm that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law. 
09:54 - 11:54
Speaker 1
Charles the Third, by the grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and of our other realms and territories King, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith, to all Lords spiritual and temporal and all other our subjects whatsoever to whom these presents shall come, greeting.  Know ye that we, of our especial grace, certain knowledge, and mere motion, in pursuance of the Life Peerages Act 1958 and of all other powers in that behalf us enabling, do by these presents advance, create, and prefer our trusty and well-beloved Hannah Ruth Kitching to the state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baroness Kitching of Penistone in our county of South Yorkshire.  And for us, our heirs and successors, do appoint, give, and grant unto her the said name, state, degree, style, dignity, title, and honour of Baroness Kitching of Penistone to have and to hold unto her for her life.  Willing, and by these presents granting, for us, our heirs and successors, that she may have, hold, and possess a seat, place, and voice in the Parliaments and Public Assemblies and Councils of us, our heirs and successors, within our United Kingdom amongst the Barons, and also that she may enjoy and use all the rights, privileges, pre-eminences, immunities, and advantages to the degree of a Baron duly and of right belonging, which Barons of our United Kingdom have heretofore used and enjoyed, or as they do at present use and enjoy. 
11:54 - 12:17
Speaker 2
In witness whereof, we have caused these our letters to be made patent.  Witness ourselves at Westminster in the forenoon of the second day of September, in the fourth year of our reign, by warrant under the King's Sign Manual. 
12:17 - 15:09
Speaker 3
I, Hannah, Baroness Kitching of Penistone, do solemnly, sincerely, and truly declare and affirm that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, His heirs and successors, according to law. 
15:09 - 15:46
Speaker 4
My Lords,  My Lords, I have to notify the House, in accordance with the Royal Assent Act 1967, that His Majesty the King has signified His Royal Assent to the following Act: Sovereign Grant Act. 

My Lords, I should also like to notify the House of the retirement, with effect from the 31st of October, of the noble Lord Shipley, pursuant to Section 1 of the House of Lords Reform Act 2014.  On behalf of the House, I should like to thank the noble Lord for his much-valued service to the House.  First oral question, Baroness Fraser of Craigmaddie. 
15:46 - 16:06
Speaker 5
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper, and in doing so, I draw the House to the House's attention to my relevant interests, particularly as a board member of Creative Scotland, and a former board member and current sub-committee member of the British Library. 
16:06 - 16:45
Speaker 6
This Government is committed to supporting our world-renowned cultural institutions.  Fit for purpose infrastructure is vital to that success, which is why we are investing £1.5 billion to address the capital needs of cultural organizations across England.  Through our Creative Foundations Fund, the Royal Opera House has been awarded £5 million for the this year for urgent conservation work and structural repair, safeguarding this premier venue and supporting its progress towards net zero. 

16:45 - 17:26

Fraser

Well, my Lords, the Creative Foundations Fund, whilst welcome, will not address the stark capital crisis identified by the noble Baroness, Lady Hodge. Where is the longer-term strategic approach, and what can the Minister say in response to the sector, who have called last week's Budget a missed opportunity, ignoring calls for theatre tax relief to cover the true cost of touring and excluding theatres from business rates reductions? Rather than giving institutions such as the Royal Opera House breathing space, are these short-term measures not more likely to suffocate ballet, opera, and theatres?

17:26 - 18:09

Seb Dance

This Government is deeply committed to supporting our world-renowned venues of culture and visual arts. It is important that it's been to mention that it's been over a decade since any this sector has seen the seen such investment in it. £1.5 billion of investment into arts and culture has definitely raised the bar, and it's there to help all the different bodies within the sector. And what's also important is that there's £425 million in the Creative Foundations Fund, which helps to support the capital need, which is challenging for a great deal of these industries.

18:09 - 18:39

Speaker 8

My Lords, I welcome the investment that this Government is making to Britain's cultural infrastructure, not just at the Royal Opera House, but venues across the country. But given the Prime Minister's commitment to devolving powers and things to regional and local government, could my noble friend comment on whether there we can expect further devolution of powers in arts and culture?

18:39 - 19:21

Seb Dance

This Government is dedicated and committed to devolution of power and resources and decision-making at the heart of our communities. This is why mayors are being empowered throughout England through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act to give strategic control over regional cultural investments. As I've said, that brings the decision-making closer to those who are affected by the ability to see and witness and experience our arts and culture, which we're extremely proud of, and we welcome this.

19:21 - 20:02

Jane Bonham Carter

Last week, I saw The Standard of Living about that great liberal and founder of the Arts Council, Maynard Keynes.

Forget the maintenance, he actually built a theatre for his wife. Now, we can no longer build, but we do need to maintain. And we on these benches believe he knew a thing or two about the need for intervention for economic renewal. My Lords, the majority of venues on the Theatre Risk Register are regional, like Cambridge. And will the enable noble lady, the minister, make the case to the Treasury for extending the pubs and live music venues business rates relief in England to theatres?

20:02 - 20:50

Seb Dance

This government is dedicated to supporting the arts and individual arts and the establishments that you, the organizations that you that the noble Baroness has mentioned. We've had a budget that has been focused on giving that breathing space not only to individuals, families, but also to businesses, and that includes our art, and visual, culture, and music venues. And that is something that our government will continue to work with and support with not only the through the £1.5 billion of funding that is going to be through acro- across the course of this Parliament, but also through the £425 million of the creative foundation funds.

20:50 - 21:27

Speaker 17

My Lords, will the minister agree one of the best ways in which not just the Royal Opera House, but other arts and cultural organizations could be supported would be to write off or turn the COVID loans into non-repayable grants, which is how it was set up for Germany's institutions, which have long left the COVID era behind them, whereas our own organizations still have to pay massive amounts in interest, harmful to our arts, harmful to the organizations concerned and destructive to society, since this is our money which is being moved around in such a detrimental fashion?

21:27 - 21:59

Seb Dance

I thank the noble Lord because he raises an interesting point. And I would like to remind the House that this government was absolutely resolute that such recovery funds were loans and should be cleared and repaid. Organizations facing severe financial diffi- difficulties can approach the Arts Council to explore Justin adjusting repayment schedules, but this needs to be done under strict guidance and be a measure of last resort.

21:59 - 22:35

Speaker 25

My interest as Chairman of Historic England. In 2024, DCMS put out a report looking at the Purcell report, looking at the deficit on in our cultural infrastructure of maintenance. And they came up with a number of something like £7 billion. Now, one of the biggest problems we have is we need the skilled labour in order to get into this, in into this work. So, at Historic England, we estimate there are about a 100,000 jobs that could be created for young people, and we need desperately to get these skills in there so because the there are companies out there at the moment that can't take on the jobs, even if we could pay for it.

22:35 - 23:06

Speaker 26

And also, the companies in the construction sector in this heritage sector, only 14% of them employ people under the age of 25. So, does the noble Baroness, the minister, agree that wouldn't it be wonderful if we could incentivize those in the construction sector to take on apprentices, to take on young people, to teach them the skills that we need in this country to produce the economic growth in this incredibly important sector?

23:06 - 23:38

Seb Dance

I quite agree, in fact, I 100% agree with what the noble Lord has mentioned, which is why this government is putting all its effort into ensuring that we are getting that talent pipeline. That's why we have specialist heritage apprenticeships and national arts education pipelines to ensure just that. We understand that 30 30% of, of the there's a 30%, sorry, there's a 30%,

23:38 - 23:41

Speaker 10

I'm just going to stop actually.

23:41 - 23:46

Speaker 9

My Lords. My Lords, more generally

23:46 - 24:20

Philip Hunt

into opera, would my noble friend remind the party opposite that was under their watch that the Arts Council was pressurized into basically defunding much of English National Opera's support? They reduced the amount of money for opera touring. If, my Lords, we are looking seriously at devolution, can we ask the Arts Council to re-examine their approach to traditional opera and to touring opera in particular?

24:20 - 24:52

Seb Dance

My noble friend would raise an interesting point, and the Arts Council is doing a lot of work when it comes to how we look at innovative funding. And that was one of the main points of the Hodge review. And not only that, we are making sure that we are putting that investment in now with £1.5 billion through our Arts Everywhere Fund, ensuring that everyone everywhere, regardless of their social, economic background, has access to arts.

24:52 - 25:26

Speaker 27

My Lords, amongst our nationally significant cultural institutions are our great cathedrals and churches. Yet, many are at risk of closing their doors due to the costs of maintenance and repairs, such as Southwell Minster, who unsuccessfully applied to the Places of Worship Renewal Fund. What's more, the fund is England-only. Does the noble Baroness, the Minister, recognise the cultural contribution of our places of worship across the UK? And if so, will she look to restore the previous Listed Places of Worship Grant Scheme, which was UK-wide?

25:26 - 26:19

Seb Dance

As my noble as the noble Baroness may well know, that a lot of these funding is devolved to the national regions. And with that being said, our capital grant scheme offers more targeted support for faith sector, more than the VAT rebate scheme that was mentioned. Over £230 million is being invested in such heritage buildings with £42 million being invested in to into the Heritage Revival Fund. We must make sure that when different organizations, faith, worship, place of worship apply for grants, that is done in a fair and balanced way at arm's length from the government by the Arts Council so that it is devoid of political interference.

26:19 - 26:26

Speaker 12

Lord Coaker. Southwark. My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.

26:26 - 26:52

Vernon Coaker

My Lords, the national conversation on defence and resilience is now under way across government, helping build public understanding of the threats we face and a whole-of-society approach to resilience. Outcomes include a national resilience public awareness campaign, deeper engagement with industry and local partners, and stronger preparedness across government, business and communities, alongside refreshed national defence planning.

26:52 - 27:19

Speaker 21

My Lords, it seems clear from reports of increased sales of tinned food, bottled water, radios and torches that the government's message about national preparedness is getting through. But can I ask my noble friend the Minister whether the government is confident that the public understand the level and seriousness of threats to our national security, which prompted the Defence Secretary's warnings on the 22nd of October?

27:19 - 28:06

Vernon Coaker

Well, can I thank my noble friend for his really important question?

I think the direct answer is that the remarks made by the defence secretary and others have started the conversation which is leading to that increased awareness. Does that mean everyone is aware of the threats that we face? I think there is still a job of work to do with respect to that. In particular, as I my noble friend would understand, I don't think we're going to see Russian paratroopers in Southwark, but what I do think is that the threat to Southwark, the threat across the whole of the United Kingdom, in terms of cyber attack, in terms of disruption to trade, in terms of misinformation, in terms of all sorts of threats that all of us need to understand and be prepared for, and I think there's a lot of work to be done in with respect to that.

28:06 - 28:08

Speaker 11

My Lords,

28:08 - 28:44

Speaker 22

My Lords, the national Crossbench. Crossbench. The national conversation on defence, such an important issue, cannot just be a series of rambling and random chats, nor can it be a series of sporadically issued propositions. It requires a coherent plan, driven from the top, properly resourced and appropriately targeted to the relevant audiences, most important of which, of course, are what are referred to as Generation Z, who has who have most difficulty in understanding the need. Where is the plan?

28:44 - 29:36

Vernon Coaker

Later this year, as part of the Be Ready campaign which the noble my noble friend in the other place, the security minister, announced with the support from the defence secretary, the Be Ready campaign announced that there will be a national resilience public awareness campaign. As part of that campaign, which has been built up with the devolved administrations, with the local resilience forums and with over 500 organisations signed up to it to say that they will help with the distribution of the advice that will be given to people, the national conversation will be a part of that. And the but the noble and gallant Lord will be pleased to know that as part of that, social media will play a crucial part to make sure that we don't just use some of the media that many of us listen to, that we use the media that the Generation Z and others listen to, and that will be an important part of that plan.

29:36 - 30:04

Speaker 14

My Lords, the newspapers are carrying reports of how other nations, and maybe this one as well, are expanding their defence spending without resort to government accounts by using a sort of expansion of the old PFI model, which obviously would be a great relief for bond markets and relief for further upward pressure on interest rates, which is otherwise inevitable. Could he just tell us how we're getting on in that respect in this country, for we certainly need that kind of remedy?

30:04 - 30:46

Vernon Coaker

A good question. Excuse me. The noble Lord is, as with many of his friends on both sides of the Houses, have made important statements about the need to look for other ways of financing defence spending, whether that be through a defence bank, whether that be through national finance initiatives, whether it be all sorts of different mechanisms like that. And he will have heard the Chancellor last week say, in his in the budget statement, laid out in the budget book, that what he intends to do is to launch a consultation and review as to how more of that sort of finance could be attracted in to support the defence spending that this country needs, and he's hoping that will report as soon as possible.

30:46 - 31:24

Malcolm Bruce

My Lords. His human emergency response report, he concluded that the people who were best able to cope with disasters were those who had been through them before and the people who learned from them. In my own area of north-eastern Scotland, we have got used to sustained power cuts, and one of the worst storms we had didn't just cut off power, but all communications: digital, telephones, data and everything else, for days. So, what is the government doing to coordinate the knowledge that we gain at home and abroad and ensure that all the relevant bodies in the private and public sector have access to all of that and can give their training on the basis of experience?

31:24 - 32:11

Vernon Coaker

Well, it's a very important question, and I hope he heard some of the answers that I gave to the noble and gallant lord, which is about working with the devolved administrations. There's been a lot of consultation with respect to Scotland and with the Scottish government, but also with the local organisations. The British Red Cross, for example, has been involved. Many of the other authorities responsible for water, responsible for some of the emergency services, all of those have been utilised. But alongside that, of course, the noble lord is right to point out the need to use volunteers and the need to use those who have the knowledge and experience that he speaks about.

And as part of that, we're engaging with local communities to build on that so that they can be part of the conversation as well.

32:11 - 33:03

Speaker 37

My Lords. I refer to my interests as chair of the National Preparedness Commission. Until the last couple of weeks, the national conversation has been conducted in whispers, so I'm pleased that the volume has been turned up slightly. But does my noble friend accept that any campaign of this sort has to be sustained, it has to be repeated, it has to be specific to the threats being faced at that time, but it also needs to prompt a dialogue in local communities, in on local streets, in local faith communities and so on as to how this should be done? And could he also tell us what thought has been given to how the schools can be engaged in this because engaging children means that the next generation will be more resilient and also means pester power will take it back to their homes?

33:03 - 34:05

Vernon Coaker

Well, all of that I agree with. Certainly, the campaign needs to be sustained. It needs to take place over a significant period of time. We need to involve all of the community, in particular schools, and discussions are underway with the local forums, with local education bodies, with schools themselves, with the teacher representatives, all of those sorts of things to try and understand what is the best way of doing that. So, the government is doing many of the things that the noble my noble friend has been asking for a considerable period of time.

And one of the things I'm determined to do, as he will know from our conversations, is to try and speed that speed it up a little bit, in fact speed it up a lot bit. And if he wants we'll all have our individual examples. Many people in here will perhaps know that I like to have my haircut now and again, needs a cut needs a cut now and again, but when I was having my haircut, the local barbers engaged in a conversation with me about what they should do in terms of crisis because they've heard about it on the radio. I thought that was a pretty good start, actually, so, yeah.

34:05 - 34:37

Annabel Goldie

My Lords, Cadets and our reservists have a crucial role to play in this national conversation on defence and resilience because they are, after all, the armed forces' local presence throughout the entirety of the United Kingdom. In the light of that, and so that the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association can continue their incredible work without distraction, will the noble lord, the minister, confirm if the government will drop its policy of reorganisation of the RFCAs?

34:37 - 35:57

Vernon Coaker

No, I can't confirm that, but what I can confirm as the noble baroness will understand and will know, is that between committee and report, I spent a significant amount of time talking to various individual bodies, talking to various individual peers about how in terms of the reorganisation the government is proposing, that alongside that, protection of many of the things that the noble this house raised about regional representation on the national body, about the role of Lord Lieutenants and others being on the face of the bill, about those who became part of the new national body, those regional representatives had voting rights, and making sure there was a significant number of those on that national panel, of ensuring that each region, the three or so written-up members of England could be on that body, and also each of the various devolved administrations, which was asked time and again, could there be a representative from Scotland?

Could there be a representative from Northern Ireland? Could there be a representative from Wales? And in each of those, I've voted yes.

So, in many ways, while I can't answer in the affirmative to what the noble Baroness has said, she will understand I've spent hours trying to get many of the things that she and many others demanded onto the face of the bill to protect many of the things that noble Lords regard as important under the current structure.

35:57 - 36:20

Speaker 23

My Lords, what practical steps, what practical steps does the government intend to do to invest in supporting stronger local community bonds? Because of course, individualism and individual prepping is not really going to support local resilience. And as we learnt from COVID, it is those stronger community bonds that enable the most vulnerable people to be reached.

36:20 - 37:13

Vernon Coaker

Certainly been talking to the local resilience forums as far as England is concerned, and to the devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland about the importance of local organizations and their involvement. But I tell you what I also think, and it's probably right for us to mention it now, the involvement of the cadets and the reserves and many of the other emergency and voluntary organizations in Remembrance Sunday is a perfect example of not only honouring those who have served in the past and who've fallen in the past and served today, but is also a reminder to us of the important bond that exists between armed services and the emergency the armed forces, rather, and the emergency services and local communities. And a reminder of that bond is something that we perhaps need to see how we ensure that is not just on Remembrance Sunday, but operates throughout the whole year. And I think that's something that would be of crucial importance to our nation.

37:13 - 37:16

Speaker 15

The third oral question: Baroness Spillman.

37:16 - 37:23

Speaker 16

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

37:23 - 37:46

Speaker 20

My Lords, this government is concerned about the levels of economic inactivity in our society. It is crucial our social security system supports and incentivizes work. This government will transform the system from one that writes people off to one that gives people the support and opportunities to live their fullest lives. That means supporting those who can work to do so, while always protecting those with the most severe needs.

37:46 - 38:02

Speaker 16

My Lords, if the noble Baroness the Minister agrees that work is the best route out of welfare dependency, why did the budget contain no measures that the OBR judged would have a material effect on employment?

38:02 - 38:44

Speaker 20

My Lords, the question, of course, was about the levels of PIP and Universal Credit, both of which were creations of the previous Conservative government under which, it must be said, the levels of inactivity went through the roof. If the government If the opposition wants to look at what we've done, we've already taken steps to reform the system. We've rebalanced Universal Credit to reduce the gap between the standard rate and the health rate. We've invested in the right to try. We've given out employment support and launched the biggest crackdown on fraud and error in the social security system.

This month, the report will come from the Timms review and from the Milburn review. And after that, the government will show how this system can be created into one that supports work and pushes forward. I urge the noble Lady to watch this space.

38:44 - 39:08

George Young

My Lords, in last Thursday's debate on PIP, I gave examples of websites helping people to game the system. Now, while of course applicants are entitled to professional, independent advice, at least two websites advise people to tell lies to pursue a fraudulent claim. What is the noble Lady's department doing about that?

39:08 - 39:51

Speaker 20

The noble Lord raises a really important point. We are really watching carefully. We're monitoring benefits-related content and emerging risks online, and working to ensure that people have access to appropriate support. We're also introducing in the coming weeks a new code of practice that will clamp down on activity by claims management companies who are trying to get people to pay them to be able to apply for benefits which they can do perfectly well for free.

So, that simply isn't there. If the noble lord looks out between now and Christmas, you'll see already gone live is our new don't pay to claim marketing campaign. It's out there encouraging pensioners and those who support them not to pay anyone for benefits they can get for free. So, I'm glad he's raised it, we are acting in this space, and we'll keep monitoring it.

39:51 - 40:17

Speaker 19

My Lords, the question is about the trends in the in claims. I haven't really heard anything from the noble lady, the minister, about how they are looking at the trends and what they're doing to deal with those trends. It's just we're doing the same as we've done before, and there are trends, but I don't think they're being looked at carefully enough.

40:17 - 41:16

Speaker 20

Then I apologize if I've clearly not explained myself clearly enough, let me try, because we're absolutely not doing what used to happen. We're doing different things, and they're starting to have an effect. So, when for example, when I say we rebalance universal credit, what the previous government did was to freeze the rates of universal credit, but not for disability benefits. What that happened is people were either driven into poverty, or they were diverted into sickness and disability benefits. So, what we've done is to rebalance universal credit.

We've invested in a right to try so people can take a risk on work if they're disabled, knowing that if it doesn't work out, they can still get support. But crucially, we're investing in employment support to help people to get out there and get into work. And if he looks at the trends, the numbers of people who are economically inactive because of long-term sickness have been going up stratospherically. Finally, that rise has leveled off. Now, that's the difference they're beginning to make.

My Lords, we are not going to do this overnight. No one's ever fixes this overnight. Oppositions often pretend to; governments don't. We are going to make a difference.

41:16 - 41:46

Frances Lorraine Maria O'Grady

My Lords, does my noble friend, the minister, agree that Labour's commitment to strengthen rights to flexible working will help lower the barriers to employment that many people with disabilities and mental health problems have experienced? And can you agree that rather than punish people with health conditions, one of the best ways to get more money into the exchequer is by improving dignity at work?

41:46 - 42:39

Speaker 20

My noble friend raises a really important point. We know that many people would like to work, but struggle. So, we have to do a number of things. We have to invest in them, for example, our Connect to Work programme is working with people who have disabilities or other barriers, trying to find out what work could they do, what would they like to do, matching them to a job, and crucially, supporting the employers to make that possible. Charlie Mayfield, who want did a brilliant review for us on Keep Britain Working, has produced recommendations for employers.

And we, now 10 months on from that, are developing Britain's first workplace health system, bringing together better workplaces, better support, and better intelligence. So, our job is to make sure that everyone who can work should be working, but we also if they need help to do that, it's the government's job to give them that help, and make sure employers can encourage those people into the workplace and enable them to stay there.

42:39 - 42:44

Speaker 15

Lord Shinkwin is taking part remotely. I invite Lord Shinkwin to speak.

42:44 - 43:28

Kevin Shinkwin

My Lords, one of the greatest threats to PIP and Motability, for example, I should declare an interest as a beneficiary, is a growing resentment by the public at the seemingly inexorable extension of eligibility, over which, I should add, Motability has no say. Could I ask the noble Baroness, the Minister, what measures the Government are taking to reduce eligibility, and thereby put PIP on a sustainable footing for those who need it most?

43:28 - 44:14

Speaker 20

My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord for his question. What we have been doing, we just, for example, I've said already that the Milburn review is looking at the position of young people, because we have a signi- almost a million, one in eight of our young people, not in employment, education, or training. And growing numbers of those are on grounds of sickness, or disability, or inability to work. We've also got this in growing numbers of people across the age range who are simply not able to work. So, we need to make sure the system supports them and gets them into work.

So, the Milburn review will look at young people. The Timms review from my right honourable friend Stephen Timms is reviewing whether PIP is fit for purpose. The interim report suggests it isn't. Both of those reports will be coming out this month. The government will respond soon after that, and we will be legislating in the new year.

44:14 - 44:41

Speaker 34

My Lord My Lords, earlier this year, the government told me that they do not expect to identify the impact of the evidence-led decision-making trial on people with a learning disability and have no specific available evaluation to do so with them. So, will the minister commit that the trial will not be expanded until the impact has been measured and published of on the effect of people with a learning disability?

44:41 - 45:09

Speaker 20

My Lords, I know that noble Lord has raised this before and I know it's an issue about which he's deeply concerned. What I can say to him is the government looks carefully at the impact of all the reforms that's decision-making on all those who use the service who have a range of different needs. Whenever that happens, we have to look, for example, at an equality impact assessment. We look at the impact of changes. We will continue to do that.

And all evaluation that's been published will be done at the appropriate time.

45:09 - 45:57

Speaker 39

My Lords, could the noble Lord the Minister explain how as we get people back into work, which the majority of people actually want to do, we will ensure that they don't have to work for home? I fully agree that for many it is a huge advantage, but the latest figures from the well-being survey at Bupa show how lonely young people are and how easy it is to lose employment if you don't have any social connection with the people that you're working with. So, can we ensure that the government carefully considers how employers will be responsible for bringing people into work as well, so that it doesn't become cheaper to employ people who are disabled at home?

45:57 - 46:53

Speaker 20

The noble lady raises a really important point. There are some people for whom working from home maybe the only practical thing that they can do because of their conditions, and I know with her background she will understand that very well. But I also think she makes a really important point. I know that in my very first job, I was probably frankly utterly useless for the first few months, because but a lot of what I learned I was working in an office. Yes, I know you can insert joke of your choice here, I realise, but

A lot of what I learned from listening to other people. I learned how people talked on the phone. I learned how you operated a system. I learned how you got on with colleagues. I learned how to navigate a difficult environment, which has stood me in great stead, I must say, in recent years.

So, I do think that, actually, when people are starting out on a career, in most cases, it would be really helpful for them to have experience. One of the things we are doing is looking at how we can invest in work experience as well for those early on, work experience in schools. So, when you turn up on day one, it's not the first time you've been into a workplace. So, I think she makes a really important point.

46:53 - 47:07

Speaker 33

My Lords, is it not the case that blunt cuts in benefits doesn't work, and the most effective way of reducing benefits and getting people back to work is to give them the support that they need?

47:07 - 47:38

Speaker 20

My noble friend raises an excellent point. Successive governments I mean, have looked very hard at finding ways to do this. The reason that we asked Alan Milburn to go off and look carefully at young people and the drivers behind that inactivity is we need to understand why people are not in work, not just tell them that they should be and cut money. Now, we do need to find a way to make sure that this social security bill is sustainable over time, but we also need to make sure it's doing its job of supporting people to get into work and, crucially, that they're supporting them to stay there and to flourish when they do.

47:38 - 47:40

Speaker 28

Lord Addington.

47:40 - 47:46

Dominic Hubbard

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.

47:47 - 48:19

Jacqui Smith

My Lords, we want all pupils to have access to sports and performing arts at school, supporting wellbeing, belonging, confidence and skills like teamwork. Voluntary and community organizations are key in broadening access. Our enrichment framework encourages schools to work in partnership with them, and the enrichment expansion program will support 400 schools in areas of greatest need to make links. PE and School Sport Partnerships and the National Centre for Arts Education will further support access.

48:19 - 48:56

Dominic Hubbard

I thank the minister for that reply. Can she actually expand upon this? What are we doing to make sure that schools actually have the necessary testing grounds, or experience grounds, to mean that they actually can link with these groups outside? If you come to a sport and you don't know the basics, you are much less likely to go to an environment outside to actually take part in it, the same is true of the arts. What are we doing for a coherent plan to allow you to actually have the necessary grounding to actually access these groups?

48:56 - 49:34

Jacqui Smith

Well of course PE remains part of the national curriculum from key stage 1 to key stage 4, but I also know that there are many sports organizations at local levels, clubs, supported by their national governing bodies quite often, who will also provide young people with that start and a welcome. And through the PE and School Sport Partnerships, we want better to join schools with the local and national sporting organizations that will help young people to get that experience that the noble Lord outlines.

49:34 - 50:21

Speaker 43

My Lords. No opposition. I declare my interest as a board member of the London Marathon Foundation and the Daily Mile Foundation. At a time when government data shows that fewer than half of children achieve the recommended 60 minutes of daily physical activity, The Daily Mile helps around 2 million children in England build such activity into the school day. Simple, inclusive, and free, it is accessible to all children.

So as the noble Baroness, the Minister, has said, as the new PE and School Sport Partnerships network is established, will she work to ensure schools are supported to embed everyday physical activity programs like The Daily Mile alongside PE and competitive sport to get every child active regardless of their background or ability?

50:21 - 50:52

Jacqui Smith

I think the noble Lady makes a really important point about the whole range of ways that we can help children to be active. And as she says, we don't yet have sufficient children who are meeting the Chief Medical Officer's recommendation of 60 minutes of activity every day. The Daily Mile is an excellent example of how schools can quite simply and straightforwardly increase the activity that children are engaged in, and that's exactly the type of partnership that we want to promote.

50:52 - 51:18

Speaker 55

The Young Creatives Commission, and I declare an interest as a member, aim is to promote and rebuild youth access to the arts and creativity on a par with sport. It publishes its final report in January. Does my noble friend the Minister agree its recommendations will be helpful? And will she agree to a meeting between the Commission, DfE, and DCMS to discuss progressing that agenda?

51:18 - 51:53

Jacqui Smith

Yes, whilst I haven't seen the detail of that work, I'm sure that it will be very helpful. I know that the work that DfE and DCMS have been doing together on this will I'm sure be informed by the meeting that the noble Lady suggests. And it's of course in order to be able to promote arts education that we established this September the National Centre for Arts Education, but very keen to hear further ideas about how we can ensure children can access a rich, high-quality arts education and other opportunities.

51:53 - 52:21

Speaker 17

Of course there is a community arts um project aspect to this.

So, I ask the Minister if she is in support that the that such projects should be in support of what happens to act in support of what happens in schools. Would the Minister agree that the local council and council-run facilities, and we have the question earlier on the relationship between local government and the arts, they are hugely important at a time when too many council-owned assets, including buildings, are being sold off?

52:21 - 53:10

Jacqui Smith

Yeah, the most effective both arts and sports education is going to need to use the broadest range of organizations and of facilities, as the noble Lord says. And we need to make sure, and I know that councils will be considering this when thinking about the use of their assets, building as many links as possible into schools, equally of course schools' facilities being used for others to be able to access them in terms of sports and arts. Unless we work effectively together, we won't be using the resource that we have as well as possible to be able to open up those opportunities to the most people, both schoolchildren and those of us getting a little bit older, who also benefit from those activities.

53:10 - 53:17

Speaker 47

My Lord— Oh, I'm sorry, no bishop first.

53:17 - 54:01

Martyn Snow

Thank you. My Lords, the Holiday Activities and Food Programme is a shining example of the approach described by the noble Lord Addington, offering a proven way of linking up children from disadvantaged backgrounds with a wide range of enriching activities during the school holidays. However, the current eligibility criteria result in more than 500,000 children from mostly poorer working families being unable to access the program. Will the noble lady, the Minister, commit to rectifying this by aligning the program's eligibility criteria with those that are attached to term-time free school meals?

54:01 - 54:44

Jacqui Smith

Well, the noble Lord is right that the HAF programme has provided for very many children and young people both food and activities. Of course, we do need to look carefully, whilst we've provided 21 million days to children and young people in England, and it's been delivered across 153 local authorities, we need to look carefully, notwithstanding the £600 million that's been committed to it, how we get that to as many children as possible. I can't commit to changing the entitlement rules, but I will take back the points that the right reverend Prelate made on that program.

54:44 - 54:46

Speaker 40

My Lords. Partnerships—

54:46 - 54:48

Speaker 42

Lib Dems.

54:48 - 54:51

Speaker 41

The Lib Dem benches next, then the Conservative benches.

54:48 - 54:48

I'm sorry.

54:51 - 55:21

Speaker 58

My Lords, partnerships with independent schools have often led to sharing of sports facilities, as well as expertise in music, drama, and dance. However, the imposition of VAT has been devastating for many of the small specialist schools who contributed greatly to opportunities for state school pupils, and a number have had to close or curtail their outreach offers. Will the Government please review its VAT demands on the small specialist independent schools to enable them to survive and continue their valuable work with the state schools?

55:21 - 55:58

Jacqui Smith

Well of course, as we've discussed on several occasions in this House, in fact, of course, the impact of VAT on schools has not led to a higher number of schools closing than has been the trajectory over recent years. I agree with her that where strong partnerships are built between private schools and state schools, they open up opportunities. Whilst there are some good examples of that, I'm still not sure, given that this was something I worked on the first time around when I was in the Department for Education, that we've really got the scale of that we would want to see.

55:58 - 56:26

Speaker 68

My Lords, if we want more children to have access to sport and physical activity, we need to make better use of existing facilities. The Opening Schools Facilities Programme helped open nearly 1,900 schools to their local communities, but ended in March 2025. Given the demand from organisations who are keen to deliver activities, could I ask the noble lady, the minister, to reconsider renewing the highly successful programme?

56:26 - 56:51

Jacqui Smith

Well, I will come back to the noble lady about the specifics of that programme, but it is of course a key part of the government's new PE partnership network that will be able to create those links between local clubs, local sporting organisations, and schools. And I'm sure that the partnership will want to look carefully at whatever is the most effective way of doing that.

56:51 - 57:20

Speaker 67

My Lords, the government's decision to scrap the EBacc is very welcome. However, the impact of EBacc on arts provisions in schools will not be reversed overnight. What specific steps is the government proposing to take to ensure that schools will place greater value and emphasis on arts subjects, including performing arts, within the curriculum? And if we don't support the performing arts, where will future celebrity traitors come from?

57:20 - 58:32

Jacqui Smith

Yes. I think there might be some noble Lords that might quite like being in a environment where nobody can trust what anybody else is saying and people get booted out. Perhaps that's perhaps that's more down the other end of the palace. Anyway, the noble Lord my noble friend makes a really important point about how we can promote arts education. That's the reason why we have established the National Centre for Arts Education.

It will make play a pivotal role in delivering the government's ambition to revitalise arts in schools so that every child can access a rich, high-quality arts education. It'll do that through providing strategic national leadership with a coalition of national, regional, and local partners. It will support excellent teaching in our schools through a new online CPD offer and making sure that there is full access to existing high-quality teacher development provision. And it will promote arts education to school leaders, teachers, parents, and young people, including how to progress in the arts and pursue their interests and career aspirations.

58:32 - 59:32

Speaker 63

My Lords, that concludes oral questions for today. Those members who wish to leave the chamber, should they do so quietly and quickly, please.

59:32 - 59:50

Speaker 54

My Lords, we now come to some instruments previously debated in grand committee: Renewables Obligation and Electricity Capacity Amendment (British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme Excluded Electricity) Regulations 2026, Lord Leong.

59:50 - 59:54

Sonny Liang

My Lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the Order Paper.

59:54 - 01:00:12

Speaker 54

The question is that this motion be agreed to? As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it. Licensing Act 2003 (Permitted Temporary Activities) (Amendment) Order 2026, Lord Collins of Highbury.

01:00:12 - 01:00:16

Collins

My Lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the Order Paper.

01:00:16 - 01:00:33

Speaker 54

The question is that this motion be agreed to? As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it. Third reading of the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill, Baroness Lloyd of Efford.

01:00:33 - 01:00:58

Speaker 71

My Lords, I have it in command from His Majesty the King to acquaint the House that His Majesty, having been informed of the purport of the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill, has consented to place his interests, so far as they are affected by the bill, at the disposal of Parliament for the purposes of the bill.

01:00:58 - 01:01:02

Speaker 48

I beg to move that this bill now be read a third time.

01:01:02 - 01:01:15

Speaker 54

The question is that this bill be now read a third time? As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it. In clause 2, Amendment 1, Baroness Lloyd.

01:01:15 - 01:01:40

Feryal Clark

I beg to move Amendment 1 in my name. The amendments in this group seek to tighten the drafting for consistency and clarity; first, by referring to data centre services rather than data centres in clause 2; and, second, by referring to subsection (5) of clause 30 when defining regulated person in clauses 24, 36, and 42. I beg to move.

01:01:40 - 01:02:33

Speaker 54

Amendment proposed: Clause 2, page 1, line 10, leave out "centres" and insert "centre services". The question is that this amendment be agreed to? As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". Contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it.

Amendments 2, apologies, my Lords, 3 and 4, Baroness Lloyd moved formally en bloc? The question is that these amendments be agreed to? As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content".

The Contents have it. The question is that this bill be now read a third time. I think I've already put that question, but the question is that this bill be now read a third time. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". Contrary, "Not Content".

The Contents have it.

01:02:33 - 01:02:36

Speaker 46

I beg to move that this bill do now pass.

01:02:36 - 01:02:41

Speaker 50

The question is that this bill do now pass.

01:02:41 - 01:04:01

Timothy Clement-Jones

My Lords, as we reach third reading and this bill goes back to the Commons, I believe we need to take account of where this bill now stands and the choices before us. With the successful passage of Amendment 163 on Report, this House has insisted on a vital, regime-wide effectiveness review to address critical gaps in our cyber defences. The decision now rests squarely with the government, whether to engage in parliamentary ping-pong or to accept this amendment as a sensible, constructive way forward. Throughout our scrutiny, we must acknowledge the positive steps the government has made, introducing provisions on high-risk vendors and strengthening incident reporting thresholds. And as the government's own announcements last month on AI loss of control demonstrate, ministers are finally waking up to the risks we've highlighted, but threats are moving too fast for half-measures or delayed reviews.

My Lords, I gather we can't now indulge in thanking colleagues on these Benches and other Benches and outside organisations. All I can say, my Lords, is: you know who you are and I'm grateful. My Lords, I urge to let the, I urge the House to let the Bill do now pass.

01:04:01 - 01:04:58

David Alton

My Lords, can I just say a word in support of what the noble Lord Clement-Jones, has said to the House about the amendment that will now go down to another place to be discussed on ping-pong? I would simply ask the noble Baroness Lloyd, who's been so helpful in so many respects in the context of this Bill generally, to look at the report that was published today under the chairmanship of her right honourable friend Liam Byrne, Member of Parliament, from the Business, Innovation, Science and Trade Select Committee of another place. It points particularly to the role of hostile states, notably the People's Republic of China, in this country, and I think it bears very much on the amendment that your Lordships passed only last week. And I hope that the noble Baroness will take the trouble to have a look at that report before we get into further discussion about the amendment.

01:04:58 - 01:06:00

Pauline Jones

My Lords, I'd just like to say to the Minister to thank her really for the very good sense and clarity that she brought to the issue of the trigger for reportable incidents, which I think lies at the heart of the secure this security and resilience bill. We weren't able to close the gap between us on the issue of factor lists for some operators, though we narrowed it, I think. And I'd just like to say that I hope that in the light of her acceptance of the relevance of some of the factors that I listed in my amendment, that she'll be able, when it comes to the secondary legislation, to make this an early issue. The industry is extremely anxious to be well prepared, and I think it will be helpful if this issue, which also is a very important part of being prepared for the regulatory regime, can be dealt with at an early stage.

01:06:00 - 01:06:45

Speaker 76

My Lords, I thank the noble Lady, the Minister, for bringing forward today's amendments, to which, as they're technical amendments, we have no objection. In this new spirit of the brief third readings, I won't raise any substantive points today, except to join others in thanking the noble Lady, the Minister, for her collaborative, consultative, and very open and thorough approach throughout the passage of the Bill thus far. As and when it comes back to your Lordships' House, we look forward to continuing the debate in the same spirit, but meanwhile, thank you to the Minister and to all noble Lords who participated so well in what's so far has been a very productive passage of the Bill.

01:06:45 - 01:07:25

Feryal Clark

My Lords, I did not intend to make a substantive contribution, as the Government Front Bench intends to proceed in line with the Companion guidance, recently reinforced by this House through the first report from the Procedure Committee, that the bill do now pass is usually moved formally. I have noted the points made by the noble Lords, Lord Alton, Lord Clement-Jones, Baroness Neville-Rolfe, and Viscount Camrose, relating to the substance, which I am sure we will return to. And I am very grateful for the engagement on the bill, which will increase UK's defences against cyber attacks, better protecting the services the public rely on to go about their normal lives.

01:07:25 - 01:07:28

Speaker 73

I beg to move.

01:07:28 - 01:07:37

Speaker 53

The question is that this bill do now pass. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The contents have it.

01:07:37 - 01:07:49

Speaker 54

House to be in committee on the Representation of the People Bill, Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

01:07:49 - 01:07:54

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I beg to move that the House do now resolve itself into a committee upon the bill.

01:07:54 - 01:08:27

Speaker 54

The question is that the House do now resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The contents have it.

My Lords, for Representation of the People Bill, in clause one, amendment one, Lord McInnes of Kilwinning.

01:08:27 - 01:09:22

Mark McInnes

My Lords, in moving amendment one, I shall now also speak to amendments 3, 4, 33, 301, 302, which are all in my name. Amendment one, I'm firmly of the view that you should only be able to vote in an election when you're old enough to meet the age criteria to stand as a candidate for that election. 18 remains the legal age of adulthood and is currently the age at which a citizen may put themselves forward to be elected to the House of Commons. That connection is important, my Lords, and it is alignment with the age criteria to vote. If the government is unable to support amendment one, then I hope that ministers will be able to explain why they are so keen to separate the age of voting and candidacy in this way.

01:09:22 - 01:11:25

Speaker 62

This is not an argument regarding maturity, and there is much that could be said on that topic, but I'm moving an amendment today in defence of a long-established electoral principle. It will come as no surprise to your Lordships that I do not support the franchise being lowered to enable 16 and 17-year-olds to vote, and through amendment one, it is my intention that the minimum voting age remains at 18, which would maintain alignment with the minimum age to stand for election in the Commons under section 17 of the Electoral Administration Act 2006. Through amendment one, I am seeking to preserve the existing and longstanding alignment between the age of voting for and the age of standing as a candidate. The parliamentary franchise, my Lords, is one of the very foundations of our Constitution, and I fail to see any justification by the government in the passage of this bill thus far in why such a longstanding national rule ought to change. Further still, I put it to your Lordships that the government has failed to address what the consequences of this bill are and why those consequences are justified.

Data from the Electoral Commission confirms that through this legislation, if left unamended, we will be extending the franchise to 1.7 million additional people. Make no mistake, this represents a major constitutional change. The question is not whether young people should get the vote, it's whether the government has established a principled case for changing the parliamentary franchise and whether the safeguards, preparations for the democratic concerns are commensurate with this change. As of yet, the burden of explanation that is required by the House to justify the constitutional significance of this change fails to meet what I consider to be the basic test of proportionality.

01:11:25 - 01:12:13

Speaker 66

And perhaps, my Lords, that is because the essence of this bill is sadly more about gerrymandering the franchise than it is about strengthening the electoral system. I am, however, sympathetic to this House supporting the greater involvement of young people in our democracy. That is a must. But we should not and we should not and must not mistake engagement for the single co- question of enfranchisement. If the Government has intended commitment to strengthening democratic values and engagement amongst younger people, then I hope that today the Minister will be able to commit to bringing forward a fully-funded and credible program of proper and unbiased civic education, whether or not this bill succeeds.

01:12:13 - 01:13:17

Speaker 62

Because that, my Lords, will mark whether or not this Government is indeed serious about the engagement of younger people in the process. Indeed, we only need to look at the data from Scotland and Wales, where 16- and 17-year-olds are already permitted to vote in the devolved parliamentary elections as well as local elections. Electoral Commission figures from 2025 estimate that only 61% of 16- and 17-year-olds in Scotland and a shocking 39% in Wales are actually registered to vote, despite having the opportunity to do so. This demonstrates my earlier point that the widening of the franchise does not solve the problem of engagement, and suggests the Government should turn its focus to civic education prior to any national law change. Can I move now on to Amendment 3?

01:13:17 - 01:14:29

Mark McInnes

I am asking noble Lords to support retaining the existing age qualification of 18 for the signing of a recall petition under the Recall of MPs Act 2015. When the Recall Act was passed, it was widely accepted that the power of recall was a distinct and profound constitutional act. Through this amendment, I am seeking to acknowledge the severity of the recall process by asking your Lordships to consider the recall franchise on its own merits, and not assume that every adjustment to voting age must automatically be copied. Amendment 3 would thus ensure that the age for signing recall petitions is equal to that of the established age of adulthood, and the minimum age at which people had voted in the last parliamentary election. If the Government is unable to support this amendment, then I ask Ministers to explain why changing the voting age should automatically alter the recall electorate, and why they are of the view that this particular extension can be made without full and independent justification.

01:14:29 - 01:15:26

Speaker 62

Given that the power of recall has the highly sensitive ability of removing representation, it is for Government to now justify whether or not it is their intention to change the eligible population that is empowered to terminate the mandate of people elected to the current Parliament. For if it is their intention to do this, then it is problematic for a number of reasons. If left unamended, the House will in effect be making changes to a constitutionally sensitive accountability mechanism simply as a side effect of another clause. And I put it to your Lordships that this is not a sensible way to deal with the complexity of constitutional matters. I would therefore ask Lords to back Amendment 3 as a limited safeguard.

01:15:26 - 01:15:45

Speaker 69

My Lords, I recognize that the Government made a manifesto commitment to lowering the age of voting. But I caution your Lordships' House that in such large major constitutional matters that we have and should still utilize the process of taking the question directly to the people through a referendum.

01:15:45 - 01:16:42

Speaker 62

For if it is the question of how we elect our Members of Parliament was considered sufficiently fundamental to warrant the 2011 referendum on the alternative vote, then I ask the Government to explain why the question of who should be entitled to elect them is considered any less deserving of the consent of the British people. This is, my Lords, important. When I mention earlier, we are talking here about an increasing of the franchise by an additional 1.7 million people. Through Amendment 4, I'm asking for the Government to seek the reassurance of the electorate that this is wanted, as I, for one, sense that the national mood on this subject matter is very different from the direction that the Government is taking. My amendment is a democratic safeguard that would require a referendum on lowering the voting age to 16 within two years of Royal Assent.

01:16:42 - 01:23:32

Mark McInnes

Amendment 4 should be read alongside my Amendment 301, for the former requires a referendum, while the later, latter, would prevent regulations commencing voting at the age of 16 unless a majority had voted for it. The process of a referendum would, my Lords, create a series a serious and needed national conversation around civic responsibility, one I would hope everybody would be keen to welcome. If we are to make such monumental changes, in my view, we should alter the integrity of the vote, it is only right that the decision to do so should be put to the British people. Can I move on to Amendment 33? I call on noble lords that the Government properly acknowledge the troublesome and dangerous times in which we live.

Through Amendment 33, I'm calling on the relevant Secretary of State to conduct an assessment of the susceptibility of 16 and 17 year olds to foreign interference and electrical electoral disinformation prior to lowering the franchise. In moving this amendment, I'm not in any way suggesting that young people are any more uniquely gullible to election-related disinformation and foreign interference than older people, but I am asserting the point that government has a duty to assess whether any new cohort of electors may encounter particular vulnerability or exposures, and what the state must do to protect the integrity of the information environment for the safeguarding of our democracy. The issue here, my Lords, is that our electoral environment has fundamentally changed, and I draw the Lordships' attention to the recent research by the Electoral Commission after the 2024 election. It was highlighted how 61% reported seeing misleading information about party policies, 52% about candidates, and 24% said they had seen or heard an election-related deepfake. These figures must concern us, and 16 and 17 year olds who, through greater use of chatbots, AI platforms, social media sites, would I fear be even more greatly impacted than older peers.

We know, my Lords, that foreign interference in our electoral process is a real and significant threat. Hostile states, particularly Russia, have, in recent years, shown their willingness to utili- utilise social media and the plethora of digital tools out there to interfere in the democratic process of our countries, and we would be foolish to think that we are immune to this.

With the rapid deployment of AI, it is becoming increasingly harder to establish fact from fiction, the truth from disinformation, and we know there are a lot of rogue actors. Therefore, before increasing the franchise, it is the responsibility of the government to at least understand the current risks and consider the adequacy of the safeguards. On amendments 301 and 303, as I have already out- outlined, they're in my name. Though amendment 30 through amendment 301, I'm seeking to ensure the government holds a referendum and publishes an assessment of susceptibility of 16 and 17 year olds to election-related disinformation and foreign interference. These commence- commencement conditions are highly important, as they will make the consent of the electorate in relation to amendment 4, which requires a referendum condition, rather than the courtesy, and gives the overall exercise a defined constitutional purpose.

Further to a referendum result through amendment 301, I am also seeking to require the government to discharge the duty to assess susceptibility to election-related disinformation and foreign interference under amendment 33. And taken together, I hope that noble Lords will agree that through these amendments, we are requiring two independent safeguards prior to commencement. Finally, my Lords, turning now to amendment 302, I am seeking the requirement for the approval of both Houses under the affirmative principle before the voting age is lowered to 16 for any future elections. In moving these amendments, I'm seeking to protect Parliament's role in scrutiny by reserving the final commencement decision to both Houses. It sh- should be for members to decide and test whether, through amendments 4, 33 and 301, a referendum has been carried out and whether the disinformation assessments have been properly completed.

And through amendment 302, and providing an opportunity for parliamentary scrutiny, as I do not believe that we should be left for m- do not believe it should be left for ministers to be the judge whether the pre-requisite prerequisites for extending the fresh- franchise have been adequately met. My Lords, in moving these amendments, I conclude by reminding your Lordships' committees, and yes, but the government may be confident in their policy, indeed, they have the numbers to force this bill through, but a parliamentary majority is no substitute for a principle and for democratic consent. I am moving these amendments as this bill is fundamentally flawed. Why should 16 year olds be permitted to vote, yet remain ineligible to stand? Why should the franchise for recall pe- petitions be altered without the government laying before this Parliament a distinct and compelling justification of the fairness of this?

What measures are ministers putting in place to assess the risks of the susceptibility of young people to disinformation and foreign interference? And if the government has confidence that the majority of people in this country support increasing the franchise by 1.7 million, then surely putting this to a confirmatory vote of the British people would with- uphold the integrity of our future elections. All these questions remain unanswered, and the integrity of our constitution should not be seen as a political experiment to be conducted at the whim of whichever government happens to hold office.

01:23:32 - 01:23:56

Speaker 61

I hope I have the support of your Lordships in asking that through these amendments the Government think again. My Lords, the franchise is the bedrock of our democracy. It belongs to the government of the day, sorry, it belongs not to the government of today, to the but to the British people, and it should not be altered without their consent.

I beg to move.

01:23:56 - 01:24:15

Speaker 54

Amendment proposed: clause 1, page 1, line 6, leave out subsection 2. And, my Lords, my Lords, I should advise the House that if this amendment is agreed to, I cannot call amendment 2 by reason of preemption.

01:24:15 - 01:28:16

Speaker 75

A very interesting speech by the noble Lord, most of which I disagree with. I understand the issues, but to say that there is no mandate, no constitutional basis, no political support for this measure is absolute nonsense. It was in the manifesto of the Labour Party, and when people voted in Northern Ireland, in Wales, in Scotland and in England, they voted, amongst other things, to agree to voting at 16.

And so, I see no conceivable argument constitutionally because it is a constitutional principle, the bedrock of our Constitution, that a manifesto commitment is the same as a referendum. When I was elected to the other place in 1987, 75% of the electorate voted for me. When my right honourable friend Nick Thomas-Symonds went to the polls in 2024, 49% of the electorate voted. And that's the electorate over the age of 18. And so, it isn't simply about age; it's about commitment.

And anything we can do as a Parliament, as a Government to increase the number of people voting, to increase the number of people interested in politics, is to be welcomed. Now, as the noble Lord said, Wales and Scotland have had these measures for some time, and the world hasn't collapsed, the constitutional heavens haven't come in, and in fact, there's been enormous increase in the interest in politics as a result of it.

But I do agree with him very much on one point, and that is this has to be accompanied by a really serious improvement in civic education amongst young people. We don't do it well enough. I spent 17 years of my life teaching at Coleg Harlech youngsters what they used to call British Constitution, and I hope I did my little bit to improve their knowledge of how they are governed.

And so, I hope, when the Minister does eventually wind up, she'll let us know that her colleagues in the Department for Education will be looking at ways and means by which civic education can be improved. And I think also it's important to point out that there are variations in the United Kingdom about voting, and there's nothing wrong with that. Northern Ireland, for decades and decades, had a different system of voting for the regional and provincial governments and for the local authorities from the parliamentary elections. And for the last 26 years in Scotland, in Wales, those devolved administrations have decided that they wanted to, they were able to decide the methods by which people could vote, and also the constitutional arrangements for their own Parliaments. And again, that's worked extremely well.

And to undermine that, incidentally, is to undermine the devolution principle upon which the Assembly, or the Senedd in Wales, and the Parliament in Scotland has been elected. No, I think that there's nothing wrong with this. I think we should adopt the principle. And I think also the Minister would be wise if she were to contact her colleagues in the Scottish and the Welsh governments to see how this has progressed over the last number of years. And I do hope sincerely that my colleagues, our colleagues, Members of this House will seriously reject the amendment that the noble Lord has put forward.

01:28:16 - 01:35:17

Anne Thérèse Coffey

My Lords, I tabled Amendment 2, which is a probing amendment suggesting that perhaps the voting age be changed to 17 rather than 16. And did this for a number of reasons to get a proper debate about this. The noble Lord Murphy of Torfaen, has just preferred to the Welsh Senedd elections, and it didn't do any harm. I'm sure it didn't do any harm. But it's not exactly the same as voting for the national government, in terms of turnout didn't even reach 52% across the whole of Wales in the Senedd elections earlier this year.

So we're talking about quite a different scale of representation. So, my Lords, it is in the Labour manifesto. It's one sentence. "We will increase the engagement of young people in our vibrant democracy by giving 16 and 17-year-olds the right to vote in all elections." Now, we haven't seen that happen to make that change, or we haven't seen the outcome of that really happen in other parts of the United Kingdom that's already adopted voting at a younger age.

But I'm not going to have a row because I appreciate it was in the manifesto. But I think it is useful to point out the Electoral Commission shared with us that research across several countries and states that have lowered their voting ages show that when enfranchised, 16 and 17-year-olds tend to vote in greater numbers than those enfranchised at 18. So more likely to vote, according to the Electoral Commission, when you're 16 and 17, but then not when you're 18. So there's something interesting going on here. I think there's a bit of a transition, and one of the reasons why traditionally I've opposed changing the vote from the age of adulthood is because of the significant change in what happens in the rest of your life when you turn 18.

But there are significant differences between what a 16-year-old can do and what a 17-year-old can do. A 17-year-old can drive a car. A 17-year-old can actually fly a plane, they can get a private pilot's licence. They can become a blood donor. You can't do that when you're 16.

You can join the armed forces, or rather I should be precise, the Army as an officer at the age of 17 years and nine months. You can't do that in any other of the armed forces. You can't become a police constable until you're 18. There's so many things where we have decided, in fact and changed the law in the last 5 years or so to stop people doing things until they turn the age of adulthood. So I'm trying to get a sense of why the Government has particularly chosen 16, recognising this can be an age when a lot of children Young people won't have even taken their GCSEs.

So just trying to get that sense rather than just the one-liner that we have in the Labour manifesto. Of course, when you turn 18, you can do things like serve on a jury, get a tattoo — didn't know you had to be 18 to get a tattoo till I looked it up — you can't make a will until you're 18, which is quite surprising, perhaps we can change that in another bill. You certainly can't get a credit card, and you can't buy alcohol, well, not legally, anyway. But the other thing I think that's worth bearing in mind, because the whole concept of young people at the moment and their lives is very much on our minds when it comes to talking about the statistical NEETs. And there are actually 57,000 NEETs, the ONS reckons, between the ages of 16 and 17.

Now it's the Labour government back in 2008 I think made it unlawful, a criminal offence for that young person they have to full responsibility if they were not in education training or have a job from the day of the last Friday in June when they were 16 in school, up until then it was their parents responsibility to get keep them in school. And understandably the government never, I can understand why they never chose to enact the enforcement or penalties sections of that particular bill. But they did that in a way to criminalise young people. And yet today they want to do something quite different. So instead of having a real focus on those 57,000 young people and why are they knowingly breaking the law and it's their responsibility and by the way, councils are supposed to know whatever young person is doing in their broader statutory duty on safeguarding children, they're supposed to know exactly what every child in their area is up to.

Then why haven't we got more of focus about giving people the young the attention the future that they desperately need rather than choosing 16 as the age at which they can start voting? Now have some sympathy with my noble friend Lord sorry Lord Udny-Lister apologies, on the referendum. I think that's an interesting concept. And by the way, later on I've actually tabled that we should reduce the candidates age to 17 to match this amendment that I've put in today. But I wanted to go a little bit further in seeing what the government has said about why 16, 17.

So it says where you can work, you can pay tax. You can actually do both of those things below the age of 16. You can serve the military, that's correct, but you need parental consent. You need both parents if they're in different houses or their residence is split between both houses. And then there's a contribution to society more broadly.

Well that does happen with young people. We already see that. We see wonderful examples to the Duke of Edinburgh Scheme, many of the other schemes that we have. Young people have won, I think, points of light awards in the past. So it comes back to why is it about 16?

And it has to be, I feel it is because the government thinks there's an electoral advantage to them. It's as simple as that. They think that there will be. I'd say to them, be careful what you wish for. The polling not that long ago showed as many people were going to vote reform and green as they would for the Labour Party if not, in fact even more.

So the is this really what they think is the right thing to be focused on at 16? I am concerned about the level of education that could be deployed to achieve this. And there's a lot that's going on and I'll come onto this in further amendments later when we discuss schedule one. But nevertheless, it comes back to coming back to somehow, and this is what I'm trying to get from the government, why they have picked 16. As I say, there are plenty of things we've barred them from doing.

They can't get married. You can in Scotland, you can't in the rest of the United Kingdom. There are multiple things where we've lifted the age gap. So I think it really does need a better description than one sentence, as I say three quarters of which can be done by children under the age of 16 in order to make sure that we can in fact, make sure we continue to have a credible electorate conscious of some other amendments that are coming up or are debated in that. But with that, I will be considering carefully the discussions of other honourable and noble members.

01:35:17 - 01:35:20

Speaker 70

Thank you.

01:35:20 - 01:42:39

Kate Hoey

Well my Lords, I would like to move amendment 21 which stands in my name and I would remind it'd be useful for noble lords to remind, remember the vision that lays behind this whole bill which was published in a published in the government's paper last July: Restoring Trust In Our Democracy. And just want to quote a couple of little bits from the beginning: "Our democracy is central to who we are as a country. We can take pride in its evolution and how it has continued to inspire, and as a government we have a responsibility to protect and strengthen it.

The right to participate in our democracy is a defining aspect of our national identity and should not be taken for granted." Now, my Lords, until recently, democracy kind of moved in one direction: from no democracy to partial democracy to full democracy. But I do believe that in this bill, there are elements which actually see a major reversal of democracy. And it's happening here in the United Kingdom. Because until the 31st of December 2020, it didn't matter where you lived in the UK, every adult had the right to either elect representatives who between them made all the laws to which we were subject or to stand for election to do it ourselves.

But from the 1st of January 2021, that changed, as the United Kingdom was divided into two different classes of citizens. On the one hand, UK citizens living in England, Wales and Scotland, who continue to enjoy that right to either elect representatives or to stand for election to do so themselves. On the other hand, UK citizens living in Northern Ireland subject, are subject to a second-class citizenship through which they only have the right to elect representatives to make some of the laws to which they were and are subject, or stand for election to make some of the laws to which they are subject. Because of course, as we all know, 300 areas of law, areas, not just laws, of UK citizens living in Northern Ireland have been disenfranchised and are now subjected to a second-class, truncated citizenship. On the 21st of January 2021, no laws had been imposed on us, but since that, we have seen increasing numbers of laws hedging us in, grown and grown, providing a constantly increasing reminder of our disenfranchisement that's going to get worse.

And your Lordships' House is well aware that because of this, every time there is a law imposed that requires some form of Westminster implementation, we try and oppose that by the use of our statutory instruments. And in this context, I've tabled Amendment 21, because the message this bill is sending 16- and 17-year-olds across the UK through the bill before us today, suggesting that it can be celebrated as playing a role in restoring our democracy, when it does no such thing for the whole of the United Kingdom. At the moment, our laws treat 16- and 17-year-olds across the UK in exactly the same way. None of them have the right to elect a fellow citizen and none of them have a right to stand for election.

However, the bill before us today, if it becomes law, then it will create discrimination where none currently exists. It will create, for the first time, two classes of 16- and 17-year-olds in the UK. On the one hand, there'll be 16- and 17-year-olds in England, Wales and Scotland who will be given the right to participate in elections that contribute to making all their laws to which they are subject. On the other hand, there will be 16- and 17-year-olds in Northern Ireland who will only be given the right to participate in elections that contribute to making some of the laws to which they are subject. And noble Lords should understand that this actually violates the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, because the very purpose of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement was to persuade terrorists to renounce violence and seek to pursue their political goals through the ballot box.

The agreement contains a special protection for democracy that is additional to those applying to the UK as a whole. It commits to protecting the right of the people of Northern Ireland to, and I quote, "pursue democratically national and political aspirations".

And this right to pursue democratically national and political aspirations in relation to all the laws to which they were subject, and this was upheld from 1998 until the end of 2020, when the Belfast Agreement was violated by means of the protocol and the Windsor Framework. And now there are whole swathes of life from the 300 areas of law to which the people of Northern Ireland can no longer pursue democratically national and political aspirations. And it's a, it's a, it's a wider part of the broader change in the constitutional status of Northern Ireland,

which, effectively, and I know that some noble Lords don't like me saying this, but it has made Northern Ireland part of being a colony of the EU in these 300 areas. No one in Northern Ireland can have a say in these laws that are made by a foreign parliament. We are effectively a vassal state of the EU. And at a time when everyone is apologising

for colonialism and slavery, especially in our schools, it's quite bizarre that we should be acquiescing in its reintroduction, telling 16 and 17-year-olds that they are going to be different. After I spoke in second reading, and subsequently tabled this amendment, I did receive, and I'm very grateful to the noble Baroness, the Minister, who wrote to me justifying the current arrangement on the basis that, and I quote, "It gives democratically elected members of the Northern Ireland Assembly the ability to scrutinise the rules that apply and, for those reasons, the government is committed to it."

Well, my Lords, quite apart from the fact that scrutiny is meaningless if you cannot actually change the legislation, this claim is also inaccurate because the assembly is only given the opportunity to look at some of the legislation that is being imposed on Northern Ireland. And, even if all of it went to the assembly, it would not address the fundamental issue that democracy is not about having the right to elect representatives to scrutinise legislation imposed on them by a foreign government that you cannot change, it's not, it's about electing an executive which brings forward draft laws and a legislation that scrutinises, amends, passes, or rejects those laws. So, my Lords, if the bill before us today becomes law in its current form, and an and equality impact assessment is conducted, which my amendment is asking for, six months later after the bill would come in, the assessment would necessarily demonstrate the terrible consequences of the failure of this bill to address this huge attack on our democracy in our time.

We cannot pretend that the Representation of the People Bill, with its mission of restoring trust in our democracy, could pass when it allows the most significant instigation of the disenfranchising of UK citizens, and clearly discriminates against 16 and 17-year-olds in Northern Ireland. My Lords, there has never been a greater time, a greater need for restoring trust in our democracy, and I believe that, if the government truly believes that, then they too should be supporting Amendment 21. And the logic, of course, of my amendment is that I would be supporting Amendment 2, because if anything is going to, whether we're going to go up or down with our voting age, I want it to be the same for people right throughout the United Kingdom. So I move my amendment. Hear.

01:42:39 - 01:47:11

Speaker 83

My Lords, I'll speak to Amendment 6 in my name, which is a probing amendment seeks to clarify the scope of clause 2 by excluding secure children's homes from the definition of youth detention accommodation for the purposes of the disenfranchisement of 16 and 17-year-olds otherwise newly enfranchised. But, first, echoing my noble friend Lord Murphy, I just wish to emphasise that I very much support our manifesto commitment: votes for 16 and 17-year-olds in the name of recognising their value as citizens, as is the case in Scotland and Wales,

and I'll return in a later group to the question of citizenship education, which is so important.

Now, the issue raised by this amendment was brought to my attention by Mark Alexander, a researcher at Cambridge, on behalf a doctoral researcher at Cambridge, on behalf of the steering group for the Unlock the Vote campaign at the penal charity Unlock. Now, although I do believe that some prisoners should have the vote, this is not what this amendment is about, and I don't intend to spark a more general debate on that. What it is about is exploring why children serving custodial sentences in secure children's homes, SCHs, should be denied the new right to vote when the Government accepts that residence in such a home is not of itself a basis for disenfranchisement. I realize that young people in SCHs who are not convicted prisoners will not be disenfranchised. The Minister for Democracy has made that clear both in the Commons and in a letter to Unlock.

And explanatory notes recognize that children may also be resident in such homes for welfare purposes. So SCHs will accommodate both children who have the vote under Clause 2 and children who do not. The question raised by Unlock is whether it meets the Bill's wider objectives that a conviction of a child should disenfranchise them when they are being accommodated in a welfare-oriented rather than a penal institution. The Bill is intended to increase young people's engagement with democracy, and the Government have described their objective as enabling young people to find their voice and exercise their right to vote, thereby, it's hoped, building long-lasting engagement with our democracy. These are objectives I very much share.

But arguably they sit uneasily with the exclusion of particularly vulnerable children whom the state is seeking to rehabilitate and reintegrate into our society. Surely such rehabilitative education should include an appreciation of the importance of active citizenship and public duty. The issue is especially significant because the Government themselves recognize that eligible children in SCHs will require tailored support in order to exercise their democratic rights. Arrangements are already being developed with the Department of Education to highlight the value of civic engagement and democratic participation in SCHs for some children, but not others. There's a risk that a child being told that they cannot participate in democracy alongside their peers in the same home will feel a sense of alienation and disaffection that could undermine their rehabilitative journey.

And rather than building their identity as active citizens, it could have the very opposite effect. I therefore ask my noble friend, the Minister, first, why a child serving a sentence in an SCH should be disenfranchised, thereby treating them differently from other children in the same institution; second, why the distinctive welfare and rehabilitative character of SCHs should not justify treating them differently from those in penal institutions; and third, whether the Government have assessed the likely impact of this disenfranchisement on the rehabilitation and future democratic engagement of convicted children in SCHs. My Lords, I believe Unlock have raised a valid question as to whether the justification given by the Government for the disenfranchisement of these children is sufficiently sensitive to the distinctive nature of secure children's homes.

01:47:11 - 01:47:13

Speaker 79

So I look forward to my noble friend's response.

01:47:13 - 01:52:47

Natalie Bennett

Hear. My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, and to speak to my amendment, the call that clause 2 not stand part of this bill, which goes further than the noble lady's amendment, but is headed in the same direction. Now, it is no secret that it's Green Party policy that all of those being held in detention, in prisons, should be given the vote, unless they are that is excluded by reason perhaps of electoral fraud, or similar, or indeed if a judge has decided they should not be able to exercise the vote. But that is not what we are addressing here.

We are talking about a small, important group of young people, a particularly vulnerable group of young people. Now, like the noble lady Baroness Lister, I'm I've been informed in what I'm about to say by the penal reform charity Unlock, and this addresses the fact that clause 2 of this bill risked further alienating and marginalising an already excluded group of young people from politics and society in a way that's not just morally wrong, but is also likely to be counterproductive. Whilst I understand that, and I've seen a letter from the government minister in the other place saying the government's view is that those convicted of a crime and serving a sentence in custody should be unable to vote, this, as the noble lady Baroness Lister said, is creating a real mess in secure children's homes. But more than this, my argument is that we are talking about

children who we want to include, children who we want to see themselves as part of society, as having a stake in society. Now, I think it's important to say that we are not talking about an issue here that's going to have a significant, any impact on the outcome of elections. Up to March 2025, there are 610 children in England and Wales covered by this clause. Now, of course there are equalities issues here, because those children are very significantly, minoritised communities are significantly overrepresented among those children, as are care experienced children.

Hundreds of young people are being told one more way they can't participate in society while their peers can is voting. This is going to affect the way they feel about their society, how they whether they feel valued or listened to, rather than being abandoned and judged. And I note that what I've just said is based on the testimony of lived experience from people who have been through the experience of how they felt experienced youth detention. Now, I am very strongly of the view that we need a world where everyone makes politics what they do, not have done to them. And these are young people who have had lots of politics done to them.

These are young people who have been victims of political decisions, of austerity, of others who have put them in a situation where they have fallen through the cracks, in many cases, in our society. So, that's my clause to not stand part. I'm going to restrain myself from engaging at length with the other amendments in this group, but I do just worry briefly want to note that it's interesting that actually in 1969, the Representation of the People's Act, the extension of votes to 18, the first in the world, was generally actually uncontroversial, had broad, cross-party support, and, interestingly, I think it was thought at the time that it might actually slightly advantage the Conservative Party. How the world has changed. But nonetheless, I want to pick up a point made by the noble lady Baroness Coffey, who said that 16 and 17-year-olds are more likely to vote and that's the evidence we have from other places than 18 and 19-year-olds.

But we also have evidence that people who vote in their first election are more likely to keep voting. So, we're actually engaging people at a point when they're more ready to be engaged, and that's something that's going to bear impacts decades into the future.

And I want to also just point to the Scottish Youth Parliament, because they've been absolute leaders in calling for equality of votes at 16 and 17 that of course they themselves have enjoyed for some time. And I do have to share a little story from the 2014 referendum. I remember hearing a BBC Radio 4 presenter on the streets of Edinburgh going, "I'm standing with 16 and 17-year-olds, and they're really informed and engaged." And the surprised tone in his voice said a lot more about the reporter than it said about the 16 and 17-year-olds.

Just one final point here. I'm afraid I don't really follow the argument of the noble Lord Agnew of Oulton, regarding Amendment 33, which is for the assessment of susceptibility of 16 and 17-year-olds to election-related disinformation and foreign interference. The noble Lord said he didn't actually think that 16 and 17-year-olds were more vulnerable. So I don't really understand the argument for this amendment. But beyond that, I have absolutely no doubt, if that one did a study of this, that we would find there's an awful lot of people of the age of the average age of your Lordships' House and round about that who are terribly vulnerable and definitely need some education to reduce their susceptibility.

01:52:47 - 01:56:00

Speaker 84

My Lords, I rise in support of Amendment 1. And just to pick up the last statement that was made, the reason that young people are more susceptible from act- from malicious actors is that they spend significantly more time online, and it's a much bigger source of their news, and it's something they pay attention to far more than people who are older, who have a- normally have a broader reading palette, and tend to read more from official sources, say the newspapers and the like. I know that the young people I work with, and I've been a youth worker for over 35 years, exclusively read about the world online.

If you want to hide something from them, I suggest you put it in The Times, because they will never find it. I rise in support of Amendment 1 because I do not think we should be using the ballot box as an engagement scheme for young people. This policy relies largely on an education piece, and it looks like the government have put the cart before the horse. Surely you should do the education piece before you give the added power, the new choice that young people would have. And, look, this isn't about if I believe young people can have an opinion.

I've been a youth worker for well over 35 years now. I've I have been at the wrong end of young people's opinions and the right end. I certainly know they can have that opinion. But look what we are doing: the government's risk assessment is almost non-existent. You are about to turn, minors, the place that's safest for them, school, into a political battleground.

School is the safest place, particularly if you come from a poor community, particularly if you if your family is suffering. You go to school to be safe. Peer pressure in school is a very real thing. If you are going to expose our 16 and 17-year-olds to political peer pressure, you had better see what the effects of that are before, not after, you do that. NHS data for 2023 shows that 17 to 18-year-olds, nearly a quarter of them, are battling some kind of mental health issue.

So, if surely if we're going to look after our young people, we would consider the greatest level of pressure we could give them, political, we'd think carefully before we did that. The government has to think again about the risk assessment it's taken on. The government needs to think again about the work it's done around the delivery of non-biased civic information. Teachers almost exclusively resist teaching politics because they're afraid of being accused of political bias. Well, can you imagine how much hotter a cauldron that will be when every single political party in the country has a stake in that conversation?

Teachers will be under unbearable pressure. So again, if the government are to do this, and I accept it's in your manifesto, but I also know you have not thought this through properly, because if you did, you'd have done a risk assessment that looked at the effect on young people, that looked at the effect on school, that looked at the if people actually vote when they're given this power, rather than the fact that it'll help you electorally.

01:56:00 - 02:02:12

Speaker 85

My Lords, I rise to speak to amendment 20 in my name and the name of the noble lady, Baroness Fox of Buckley, and I declare my interest as the director of the Free Speech Union. I want to draw your Lordships' attention to a disconnect between this bill and the Online Safety Act. At present, some content on social media platforms is age gated. That's a child safety duty in the Online Safety Act that kicked in July 2025, which means that in order to access content that the social media platforms deem to be only suitable for adults, you have to be able to prove you're an adult, 18 or over. But the content that has been age gated as a consequence of this child safety duty coming into force includes quite a lot of political content.

I could give numerous examples, but I know we're quite short for time, so I'll just give one. A speech by Katie Lam in the House of Commons about the grooming gangs was age gated by all the large social media platforms. They thought that was unsuitable content for anyone under the age of 18 to see. But if 16 and 17-year-olds can't access content like that, speeches being made in the House of Commons because of the age gating that social media platforms are engaging in, how can they be expected to make informed decisions at the ballot box? I'm sure that the noble Lords and noble baronesses who have rightly emphasised the necessity of improving civic education if we're going to lower the voting age to 16, I'm thinking of the noble lady Baroness Lister, the noble Lord Murphy, I'm sure they'd agree with me that if you're going to improve civic education for teenagers, it's important that they should be able to access political content, including speeches being given in the House of Commons.

Lord Bailey of Paddington, my noble friend, rightly pointed out that for most teenage children, social media platforms are their single largest source of news, and that was corroborated by some research carried out by Ofcom, which showed that social media platforms like TikTok are the primary source of news for 12 to 15-year-olds. So this is a potential problem. The Online Safety Act is requiring large social media platforms to age gate some political content, so you cannot access it unless you can prove you're 18 or over, and at the same time, the government is proposing to lower the voting age to 16, expecting 16 and 17-year-olds to be able to make informed decisions without being able to access political content on their primary source of news. Fortunately, there is a solution at hand. So, clauses or now section 17, 18, and 19 of the Online Safety Act are keep up duties.

They require social media platforms to keep up content of democratic importance, news publisher content, and journalistic content. But it may not surprise your Lordships to learn that whilst all the takedown duties in the Online Safety Act have been activated, not all the keep-up duties have, including section 17, 18 or 19. And they're not due to be activated until mid-2027. But there's nothing in those sections which requires social media companies, which means that they only apply to adults. So, it's perfectly possible that once those duties are activated, social media platforms will recognise that they have a duty to keep up content of democratic importance, news publisher content, and journalistic content, make it accessible to children as well as adults.

But that could be underwritten by the regulations I believe the government is intending to make at the beginning of next year, the regulations restricting access to social media for under-16s as well as 16 and 17-year-olds. It could stipulate in those regulations that those restrictions should not apply to content of democratic importance, news publisher content, and journalistic content. That would be, I think, a way of ensuring that 16 and 17-year-olds, younger teenagers, when they're beginning to think about how they're going to vote when they reach the age of 16, that would be a way of ensuring that they can access this vitally important content, such as speeches being made in the House of Commons. And if the government thinks it would be a step too far to stipulate in those regulations that the restrictions should not apply to teenagers in general, at the very least, the government should stipulate that they shouldn't apply to 16 and 17-year-olds, given that 16 and 17-year-olds are going to have the vote. My amendment simply asks the government to carry out a review within 12 months of this bill being passed to ensure that content that children are going to need to be able to access on social media to make informed decisions at the ballot box, to ensure that content isn't restricted, and in particular isn't restricted for 16 and 17-year-olds.

02:02:12 - 02:08:25

Christopher John Rennard

It's more than 50 years since it was legislated to extend the franchise and allow 18-year-olds to vote in general elections. It seems to me that a great deal has changed in society since 1970 when those 18-year-olds cast their first votes, and it's right we look again properly at this issue of the franchise. The debate since 1970 and this afternoon focused largely on the issues of when it is appropriate and what age to do whatever people want to do. Well, I have to say that Lord Leicester's argument that few people who are 16 or 17 in Scotland and Wales are registered to vote is not an indication that they shouldn't be able to vote. It's simply an indication about how difficult it can be to be on the electoral register when you are a young person, an issue that's being addressed elsewhere in this bill, but was sadly neglected over the last four Parliaments.

Now, my Lords, I accept that there are things that we should not let people do as soon as they are 16.

Smoking, for example, is self-harming. Alcohol carries great dangers. Gambling can be deeply addictive. And purchasing fireworks, knives, crossbows, and airguns should not be permitted by anyone under 18. But going down to a polling station or filling in a postal vote should not be seen as a harmful activity,

anymore than it is for older generations. A 16-year-old in this country can consent to medical treatment, leave school for another form of education or training, and consent to sex. With parental consent, that young person can join the Armed Forces, apply for a passport, and get married, or enter a civil partnership.

Yet, under present laws, someone whose 18th birthday falls just before a general election may not get to cast a vote in one until they are 21 or 22. And if politics is not for them when they are young, then it may never be for them. In 2003, in a debate on a bill which would have reduced the franchise from 18, I argued that maturity and political understanding do not suddenly materialize on your 18th birthday. My view remains that it's wrong to suggest that everyone over 18 generally possesses sufficient political wisdom to make choices,

whilst no one aged 16 or 17 can properly decide whether to vote or who to vote for. My own experience with political research often involved me interviewing the interviewers who sought to discuss political issues with the voters. Those people they interviewed, entitled to vote because they were 18, frequently knew so little about the issues facing a democracy that the interviewers even said to me they sometimes doubted the wisdom of the universal franchise. My Lords, wisdom, political experience, and judgment does not always come with being much older. Younger people, in my experience, are sometimes ahead of older generations in considering long-term challenges such as climate change alongside immediate priorities like education, transport, and housing.

Amendments today seek to maintain the voting age at 18 or to reduce the number of young people who will be added to the voting registers. The suggestion even is even made, I think it is a preposterous one, of having a national referendum before extending the franchise. My Lords, another referendum? And on this issue? We can only imagine what Brenda from Bristol would have to say about that idea.

Retaining the vote at 18 or pausing at an arbitrary halfway point of 17 ignores vital lessons from when the franchise has been extended in Scotland and Wales. Studies across both nations demonstrate that 16- and 17-year-olds living at home and attending school are embedded in a supportive social structure that actively fosters democratic engagement. A structure that 18- to 20-year-olds, currently entitled to vote, for those people 18 to 20 living independently, they often lack that support. In Scotland, Wales, and in other countries, such as Austria, which led the way by lowering the voting age to 16 across all electoral levels in 2007, there was no meltdown of democracy.

In fact, in local elections in Vienna, turnout among 16- and 17-year-olds reached 64% compared to only 56% among 18- to 20-year-olds. However, my Lords, we do accept on these Benches that the issue of enfranchisement cannot stand alone.

We should look to research from Jersey, which lowered the voting age in 2008. It was demonstrated there that extending the franchise in isolation, without structured democratic education, fails to deliver sustained engagement, leaving young voters facing persistent confusion over candidates' policy platforms and how democracy works. So, in a later group of amendments, we will argue that extending the franchise and strengthening citizenship education must be treated as twin pillars of a single coherent strategy aimed at improving political engagement and improving the health of our democracy.

02:08:25 - 02:16:08

Claire Fox

I've added my name to a couple of amendments, Amendment 2 in the name of the noble Lady, Baroness Coussins, because I think it is valid to ask why 16, not 17, and we could as easily ask why 16, not 15? And I think that it is, overall, an important group of amendments, not necessarily because anyone here is interested in overturning a manifesto pledge or indeed because one wants to get stuck on a row about the maturity of teenagers or otherwise, but in order to probe how far the Government has considered the impact of these changes on what it means for the adult franchise, and the problem of inconsistency in relation to age when it comes to the way we view the age of majority. My fear is that we are in danger of getting in a muddle about what adulthood means. The age of majority according to law is 18. Successive governments have created fairly hard lines about what under-18s can't do, as we've heard, whether banned from buying alcohol, nicotine products, vapes and gambling, all the sins, the harmful things, but actually under-18-year-olds are also deemed not capable of exerting full contractual capacity when it comes to loans or mortgages, or indeed to do jury service.

I think that jury service is good and I hope that by the time they grow up, there'll still be juries left for them to be recruited to. But that to one side. On the other hand, it seems to me that there is confusion about what the exact age is that the state and institutions, and indeed the political culture, now views adulthood to begin. When do we consider adult autonomy to start meaningfully? Formally, it remains 18, but there's mixed messages.

Government-backed Challenge 25, for example, has seen retailers selling age-restricted products by asking for photo ID from anyone who looks under 25, and 25 is increasingly used as some kind of magic age number for maturity. Universities increasingly treat 18-plus students as though they are school pupils. Academics are urged to act as though they're in loco parentis, with a duty of responsibility for mental well-being and emotional issues. I think that sort of infantilization has led to far too many young adults seeing themselves as dependents, and I think this has fueled the NEETs problem, actually. At the other end of the spectrum, we have criminal responsibility as early as 10.

We have an NHS clinical trial that will stop puberty for children using puberty blockers, children as young as 12, based on their, the children's subjective, not clinical, distress about gender, as though they're able to give consent in any meaningful way.

and we have a children's rights culture that too often treats children as mini-me adults whose views and outlooks are on a par with their teachers, parents, carers, as though they are self-determining. So, if the state is now, via votes for 16-year-olds, negating the concept of the age of majority at 18 in general, and I think we need to know if that could be the consequence, then surely there needs to be some consistency, and I think that's why we need this discussion and debate. The key point about the age of majority is it's the age when the state affords recognition of full legal capacity. It means that's the age the state affords you with the ability to make binding decisions and believes that you can bear the consequences of entering contracts, exercising rights without adult or state override.

All that at the moment is 18. Treating minors, that is 16-year-olds, as autonomous rights-bearers in one domain while shielding them in so many others surely erodes the idea that adulthood is the point at which you have full responsibility for your life and liberty and rights and autonomy. If the 16-year-old voter is half an adult, given some rights and a bit of autonomy, then what will that say about the 18-year-old voter? Are they to be infantilised with a bit of autonomy, a few rights, a bit of freedom? I'm worried that votes for 16-year-olds means a hugely important adult activity, the franchise, is now conferred on those we don't believe in most instances are fully autonomous or independent, are not free rights-bearing citizens.

They are most often under the care of and legal responsibility of their parents, carers, teachers. They will not be free to research political parties, as we've already heard, because the government's the government's, and indeed the opposition's, ban on social media for under-16s. And indeed, I've added my name to the amendments in the name of the noble Lord Young of Acton, on the related issue of the Online Safety Act and age gating. But the danger here is that those would-be voters are not free to research independently, and instead have to rely on official sources for news and political content controlled by adults. As the noble Lord Bailey, indicated, surely this puts especially teachers in the invidious position of being accused at least of unduly influencing the young in relation to and open to the charge, at least, of corrupting young minds.

In the debates on social media and for 16-year-olds and the ban on 16 until you're 16, sorry, under-16-year-olds, those same teenagers were discussed in this House as especially vulnerable and insufficiently mature or resilient enough to handle algorithmic pressure. I'm not sure then how in the build-up to an election they will cope with the pester power of canvassing. I mean, trying to it is perfectly right they would properly be right that they should be persuaded and influenced as 15-year-olds, soon to be 16-year-olds, about to be able to vote, but we have a law in fact which treats such stranger approaches as inappropriate grooming.

Finally, this is not about whether 16 or 17-year-olds, or indeed 18-year-olds, are smart enough, intelligent enough to vote. Indeed, I owe the House an apology for not being able to speak at second reading on this bill because I was speaking to a group of sixth-formers about free speech, in fact, who were thoughtful, articulate, mature, and I know through the schools' Debating Matters competition, which I founded, that many of those 16, 17-year-olds could run rings round people in their 40s and 50s, indeed many in this House.

but adulthood isn't a technical accomplishment. The franchise is not determined by intelligence, maturity even, or debating skills. It's about when we as a society release uh say: "You are no longer a child, you're released from childhood into adulthood." And that then gives us freedom, autonomy, independence.

My fear is that votes for 16-year-olds who are inevitably not free and are dependent will undermine adult freedoms and adult independence, and the importance of voting as an independent activity is something we should not undermine carelessly, which I fear this does.

02:16:08 - 02:16:53

Speaker 94

A great pleasure to follow Baroness Fox of Buckley and her very considered remarks. May I welcome the debate on this group of amendments, which explore the most unwelcome decision to bring children into the voting net. And uh and in particular, welcome uh Lord Hannie-Lister's uh amendments and specifically 301 on a referendum. The wording of the government's uh amendments, which no one's spoken as yet, requiring officers to investigate whether 14 or 15-year-olds live in a household, sends shivers down my spine. As does the whole concept of allowing children whose rights in so many other areas of life are correctly postponed until they are responsible enough to use them wisely.

02:16:53 - 02:18:46

Speaker 93

We had this debate after a fashion during uh the Brexit debate, when the idea of 16-year-olds was mooted and discussed and then quite rightly dismissed. The point was made then and it's obviously true now, that there is substantial scientific evidence that a person's capacity for reasoning, logical judgment, and decision-making continues to develop up to the age of 18, and many would say thereafter. The um Although it's true that some basic cognitive capacity and logical reasoning can be reached at around 16, there are other areas where they do not. In particular, studies highlight that resistance to peer pressure develops well beyond the age of 16, and this is to my mind, absolutely key, as my noble friend, Lord Bailey of Paddington, who has unparalleled expertise and experience in this area, has pointed out.

Peer pressure is not just from others of a young person's age, and it's not meant to imply peers like me who go canvassing, of course, it's meant to be teachers and other influencers, particularly these days, when most young people have access to influencers who they regard as incredibly important and relevant for matters that matter to them, such as fashion, sports, and other such areas. And maybe these influencers are skilled in fashion, sports, and related areas, but it'd be worrying if such influencers persuade people how to vote based on extremely limited understanding of the policies themselves. Scientific research has found that someone under 18 might be just as capable as an adult of understanding an argument, processing information, and reaching a logical conclusion, and I don't doubt that,

02:18:46 - 02:19:21

Speaker 95

but they are most certainly less capable of resisting peer pressure or emotional impulses. So, could the noble lady, the minister, please advise us if the government has undertaken any particular, specific research in this field to be sure of the competences of 16-year-olds, and what and, in particular, can the noble lady, the minister, explain, will such 16-year-olds now be eligible for jury service? And if not, why not forgetting of course that jurys' members are selected from the electoral roll?

02:19:21 - 02:23:07

Speaker 92

So how will that work? And perhaps she could specifically explain to me why, in July 2025, the Labour National Executive Committee decided to change the rules such that officers of local Labour parties have to be over 18. So let's look at some other glaring inconsistencies. 16-year-olds need parental consent to join the army or marry. They can't order a drink in a pub unless they're 18.

So if their side does win the election, possibly due to their vote, they can't join in the celebrations in the pub, unlike the Chancellor, exhibit their joy by inverting a pint glass over their head. Labour refused to lower the drinking age to 16, not unreasonably. Why? In their own words, to protect children from harm. Under-18s aren't capable of making that decision for themselves, say Labour.

Labour raised the age for buying cigarettes to 18 according to the Labour minister, to protect children. Why? Because Labour decided children weren't to be trusted with this important decision. Likewise, under-18s are dealt with in different courts and they can't watch the same films as 18-year-olds because the British Board of Film Classification requires a person to be 18 before being classified as an adult. And the same applies for buying as we've heard, for buying fireworks and using sunbeds and even buying knives.

Labour legislated that children had to stay in school until 18 or comparable education. Why? Because they weren't capable of taking the decision to stay or leave themselves. This is nothing to do with protection. Welsh Labour banned under-18s from tongue piercing, arguing that, quote, "Young people may be less likely to have the experience or knowledge to take that decision."

Labour don't trust children under 18 to have Botox or buy corrosive substances. They don't trust children to place bets or even enter a gambling shop. Lord Watson, then deputy leader, said that they quote, "Those who gamble have to be adults." So he confirms Labour's view that under-18s are children. And when Labour reduced the AT on children's meals, another Brexit win as it happens, HMRC confirmed that under-18s are children.

And so what will these children use for voter ID in the polling booth? Few will have appropriate ID. And for these reasons and many others, it transpires that some 95% of the world's democratic countries do not allow voting at 16. They have to wait until 18. So maybe it works in Nicaragua, Cuba, or Ecuador, but it doesn't work here.

And we will be outliers, propelled by a government rightly accused of attempting gerrymandering and, as I've just demonstrated, abandoning all its past precedents and good practice on the altar of electoral greed, which may well backfire if the voters don't actually turn out voting for them as is now predicted. So in conclusion, would the noble lady the minister please tell us what research the government has undertaken about my concerns, in particular on peer pressure on children, and whether she shares my concerns on the some of the other issues I've raised? If the government has undertaken that research, perhaps she could share it with us. And if not, then these amendments, which largely go to postpone the proposals, must make sense. A referendum would allow those who are perhaps closer to 16- and 17-year-olds to make this decision.

02:23:07 - 02:23:20

Speaker 97

So I just would like to make a couple of points. In relation to peer pressure, I wonder if the noble Lord thinks that older people are not subject to peer pressure, because I believe that they are, my Lords.

02:23:20 - 02:23:22

Speaker 96

And in terms of

02:23:22 - 02:23:33

Speaker 95

Yes. The point is that scientific research has shown that younger people are more subject to peer pressure than people over the age of 18.

02:23:33 - 02:25:05

Speaker 97

What scientific evidence I have to ask, but anyway we can come back to that on some other time. I do not wish to waste time this afternoon. In terms of gerrymandering, I entirely refute that case, and if you look at recent polling, it would suggest that young people are not more likely to vote for my party, so we're not doing it to secure votes. We're doing it because it's the right thing to do. We believe it's the right thing to do to empower young people.

I do have some sympathy with the points of view point put by the noble Lord Acton, and I look forward to the response from my noble friend the Minister. Of course, I agree with much of what Lord Rennard said, and I think that civic education and votes at 16 must go together. But I think that we don't really understand the depth of the understanding of democracy of some young people. I went to a school in West Yorkshire a couple of months ago where It was a primary school where children between years 1 and 6 were elected to the school council. They all had to do They all had to put forward a manifesto, and they patently understood democracy, voting and what everything meant.

In terms of civic education, which we will return, this is not about influencing young people, it's about informing young people so that they are aware of the rights which they will be able to exercise.

02:25:05 - 02:33:06

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, pleased to have the opportunity to support the amendments in the name of my noble friend, Lord Balfe of Lister. I think the most significant concern I have about the Government's proposal, notwithstanding it was in the manifesto, a manifesto incidentally supported by about 20% of the electorate, the lowest turnout since 2001, and Labour polled 33.7%, so one line in one manifesto needs to be taken within a broader context, but my concern is that there hasn't been a really robust case made with real-world evidence. And we look back to the halcyon days of the past because one can ask the question, if young people were so concerned about the fact that they were going to be able to be part of the franchise, 16 and 17 year olds, then their close approximation, 18 to 24 year olds, would have voted in significant numbers at the 2024 election. In fact, the turnout dropped in that age group from 47 to just 37% of the vote, so it wasn't actually a great vote getter. And I have to say to the noble Lord Murphy of Torfaen, for whom I have a great deal of respect, if you listen to him, you'd believe that Wales was a hotbed of psephological excitement and exuberance.

But in fact, that isn't the case. In the national parliament of a proud principality of Wales barely 51% voted this May for that parliament, and in fact as little as 42% voted in 2011. So has not been a significant change in terms of the number of people taking part in the ballot. I think the comments of my noble friend Lord Bailey of Paddington were very interesting. In 1950, 84% of people turned out to vote, but it was a different world then.

People were encouraged principally by their families, by their social background, it was often a battle between capital and labour, by public meetings, by newspapers, the radio, not obviously television.

Lord Bailey makes an absolutely vital point that young people are deeply influenced sometimes by a monoculture of social media. Now there's we can have many debates about that but it would be wrong and completely irresponsible to ignore the context in which 15 16 and 17-year-olds are making important decisions about how they're going to vote. In fact, as as we know in the past, the number one determinant for how a woman would vote was how her father voted. Now I'm not saying that I support that, but that was a societal factual logical fact in those days.

And we're in a different world now. We're in a different world where people don't read national newspapers, they don't watch terrestrial television shows news programmes and they're very much interested in what other similar aged people are saying on social media. And that is going to be a factor. The main point is consistency, as brought up by my noble friend, Baroness Coffey. Lowering the age whilst other adult thresholds stay at 18 is incoherent.

It doesn't make sense. And my noble friend Lord Lea of Hurley made some very important points. And I would be interested in the noble lady the minister's comments about what's good for the Labour constituency Labour parties and the Labour NEC should be good for the franchise for young people as well. I think my noble friend Lord Alistair makes a an important point. It does seem incongruous and odd that you can vote in an election, but not for someone who's the same age as you.

That does seem very strange. If you're if you're given the franchise the responsibility of choosing someone to represent you in Parliament, then surely you should be able to vote for someone who is your age. In terms of international comparisons, we've already heard that in mature liberal democracies, such as the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, they all set the voting age at 18. And this reflects a widely accepted understanding of what adulthood is. There's a weak evidence on benefits.

And I already talked about turnout. Turnout has traditionally been very low for many years amongst 18 to 24 year olds. And it is a function of a wider democratic malaise about the faith and trust that young people have in politics and government. And I fear that in the absence of a coherent argument from the government of why they're bringing forward this, other than cephological and electoral self-interest in that they believe these thousands of young people will turn out and vote Labour, I can't understand the evidential basis for this policy, because public opinion doesn't support it either. House of Commons library notes that polling suggests that the public are unsupportive of lowering the voting age to 16.

And it's not just old or very old people. And I know where I'm speaking so I won't define very old or very old in your Lordships house. But it's all manner of people from 18 onwards who are at the very best lukewarm, and in some cases, hostile to these proposals. We've talked about undue influence and interference. And my noble friends have talked about foreign interference via the internet.

And I don't think it's wrong to focus on the issue of maturity. Now I know that is not accepted definitive science about the development of the human brain amongst young people.

Obviously, colloquially and anecdotally, what one is told that people are fully formed both physically and mentally and emotionally and socially at the age of 25, but I understand and concede that will happen to different young people at different ages. And indeed, I mean, I joined a political party at the age of 16, which made me a rather odd weirdo, frankly. Lord Rennard will probably say nothing much has changed. The fact is I was atypical, but most people are not politically engaged and they do get their they do get their political information on political policies secondhand through hearsay, through close family and friendship groups. And I would make one final point about Scotland and Wales.

Scotland and Wales are of course an integral, important part of our country. But because they have decided to go their own way in terms of increasing the franchise to 16-year-olds, it does not mean England should back into that. This is the sovereign Parliament of our unitary state, of our one country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. And it is for us in this Parliament to make the decision. I do not believe my frontbench, our frontbench will oppose the principle of this, but I do think that it is beholding upon the Government and disappointing that they have not brought forward much more comprehensive, convincing and coherent argument for these proposals.

02:33:06 - 02:38:24

Charles John Fuller

Noble Lords. Lord Rennard, my noble Lord, has posed a question like, "Do we want another referendum?" And of course we of course we don't. Because in 2011, there was a referendum where we asked the people whether we wanted to fiddle the franchise and mess around with the voting system. And the people said, "No!" by a very large majority.

And I think all noble Lords just need to recognize that's not the way we want to go. Now I do certainly agree with my noble Lord Young of Acton when he proposed his group 20 about social media and that's something I'm going to return to in a later group nine. So, I won't go into the under the bonnet now, save to say that I think he omitted whilst thinking about 16-year-olds, to consider the attainers who will need to prepare to vote on their 16th birthday, but may not be 16 yet. I'd like to associate myself with the comments of Lady Hoey and also to my noble friend Lord Jackson, who has just spoken, about the muddle that we are in within our United Kingdom relating to the vote and the franchise. This bill ought to be the opportunity to bring an end to the hodgepodge of different arrangements in different parts of our United Kingdom.

At second reading, I spoke about the different systems. Clearly, there's the first-past-the-post, which is easily explainable in the pub. Obviously no 16-year-olds there. Those that person who gets the most votes wins. There's the alternative vote, which now is just for the Scottish Crofting Authority elections.

We've got supplementary votes with open and closed lists. And I Lord Foulkes, who is not in his place, entertained us in the second reading when he explained to us how he got elected to Holyrood without actually standing in that election himself. The third all-outs, the franchise is different. Any resident, whatever nationality, can vote in Scotland, but you've got to be English, or Commonwealth, or a member of the EU for local elections here. And of course, peers can't vote at all.

I was very taken by the comments of Baroness Hoey when she said such arrangements risk peace in our nation that flows from the Belfast Agreement and the Windsor Framework.

And I am concerned this is just a slippery slope. The Prime Minister has already declared he wants to review still further the voting system to consider perhaps proportional representation. And we all need to be careful of what we wish for there because PR will just lead to more sectarianism, more minority voting, more campaigning in Urdu where single-issue activists seek to hold the rest of us over a barrel, reducing trust in democracy, trust in the election and trust in the institutions they serve. Well, I'd like to move on, if I may, to consider amendment number 279 in the name of my noble friends on the front bench, coupled with the name of Lord Brady. My Lords, some months ago, I attended one of the Learn with the Lords sessions at the Education Service in the Victoria Gardens.

I was surprised. I was paired, I don't know why, with a load of gobby kids, each of them egging each other on, promoting and lionizing the Tate brothers, and in my presence. Using all sorts of unacceptable, misogynistic opinions about immigrants and women. It turned out it wasn't Learn with the Lords, it was learned from the kids, and I was really concerned. And it does play to the point that amendment 279 and also the noble Lord Hayward, mentioned about where is that boundary between childhood and adulthood.

I don't propose to go through another laundry list of the things you can do at 16, although you can sell scrap metal to a dealer getting there on a moped, it wouldn't be a big thing, you can get married without parental permission in Scotland. And I say to my noble friend Baroness Coffey, who's in her place, you could, you may not be able to get a tattoo, but you can certainly get a piercing. Now these are trivial examples, but it does play to the muddle we're in because when you are 18 you can f- you can fight on the frontline, you can get a credit card, you can take a loan, you can buy a pint, you can sit on a jury, as other noble Lords have said. You can make a will, you can buy land, property, hold a tenancy. You can rent an adult video, not that anyone rents videos of any sort nowadays, I'm going to say.

But it el- it illustrates the point that we must have the review contemplated by Amendment 279, not just to be fair to the adults in the room, but to be fair to the chil- My Lords, if I could just clarify

02:38:24 - 02:38:33

Speaker 97

that it is true that one can join the forces at 16, however, one does not fight on the frontline, as the noble Lord put it, until one is 18.

02:38:33 - 02:39:36

Charles John Fuller

I think that's exactly the point I was making. Along with those other things, I say I gave a list of the things you could do at 18 in that stanza, but let's move on. Look, we need to have this review, not least because we've got to be fair to the children, we need to be fair to adults, we need to be clear where the boundary sits. It's not at all clear now. It's drip.

It leads to confusion and insecurity. So, and my final point is that when we consider votes at 16, you have to prepare people, the attainers at either 14 or 15, in a further blurring of that line between a childhood and adulthood, as another noble friend said, I don't suppose the front bench will oppose votes at 16, it is a manifesto commitment. But we need to know what we're getting into before we get there.

02:39:36 - 02:39:44

Speaker 104

Who um I think the most interesting thing is the face

02:39:44 - 02:39:47

Speaker 105

things that were not said.

02:39:47 - 02:40:31

Speaker 107

When the noble lady, Lord, Baroness Coffey, and then the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough, went directly to the point that everyone else has been tiptoeing around, and a little bit indelicately said deliberately that this was a bill that was partisan and was psephological in its contents, that it was actually about advantaging one party over another, I watched very carefully the expressions opposite. And the minister did not swoon theatrically. There was no clamour of outrage. No one demanded that he that either of the noble Lords withdraw. In fact, with the honourable exception of Baroness Rockell, who at least tried to stand up and reject, she said she'd refuted it.

02:40:31 - 02:41:39

Speaker 106

I'm not sure she refuted it, but she did at least spiritedly reject it. The reaction everywhere else was a some studied looking at screens. And the reason for that is because they weren't saying anything remarkable. And lest noble Lords think that I'm being partisan about this has been the case with every change in the franchise. I can't think of one in our entire long history, one Representation of the People Act that has not been manipulated for partisan advantage by every party at the time.

It happened in 1832. It happened in 1867. It happened in the 84 and 85 Reform Acts. In 1918, it happened. When the voting age was last changed in 1969 by Harold Wilson, it happened.

When the Triennial Act was introduced in 1694, it happened. When the Septennial Act was introduced in 1716, it happened. When the Quinquennial Act was introduced in 1911, on every occasion, people have, perfectly understandably because politics is politics, tried to game who would benefit. So, in a sense, as King Solomon says, nothing new is under the sun. I will, of course, with great pleasure, give way.

02:41:39 - 02:41:57

Speaker 75

The noble Lord and I have taught our, the same history tutor, by the way, and I'm going to disagree with him, because, in the terms of Wales, the first time that, I think it's the first time the 16-year-olds voted, the Labour Party, which had been in power in Wales for over a 100 years, was reduced to nine out of 96 seats.

02:41:57 - 02:44:33

Speaker 107

Well, I'm always very grateful to hear from Lord Murphy of Torfaen. Of course, a reminder there that you should be careful what you wish for, and that it may just be worth considering what has changed in the opinion polls between when this measure was put in the manifesto, and what the opinion polls are showing now. But, of course, we don't need to worry about that sort of thing in our elevated position here. Look, I think what makes this one a little bit different from all of those others is not the fact of the electoral calculations and manipulation, but the flagrancy. And what I mean by that is the list we heard from the noble Lord Leigh of Hurley, right?

It's not just that parties on all sides have agreed on 18 as the standard age for maturity, the age at which you can make a contract, use a credit card, get a mortgage, serve on a jury, stand as a candidate. It's that in many cases, the age has been raised from 16 to 18 as the age of consent by the same people who are now saying that we should lower the voting age. So, when one of the first debates that I took part in as a newish member of your Lordship's house was on raising the age from 16 to 18 to get Botox treatment. And it was supported on every side, on every side, and people said, "Well, this is just closing a loophole.

This, after all, is the age that we already use to get a tattoo and buy a knife and a bottle of wine and a scratch card and fireworks and whatever else. Absolutely true. And as we heard, the last Labour government raised the voting age, sorry, they raised the age of consent for a lot of these things and certainly voted for it when other parties did, right? So the difference is not that it's happening, it's the sheer brazenness, the flagrancy of it. And that, I think, my Lords, does serve to undermine confidence in the system.

It makes people cynical because it confirms all of the negatives that people have about politicians. So, if we have decided as a country that people below the age of 18 are legally children, are we really going to say that they are not responsible enough to buy a knife or a scratch card or a firework or a pint of beer, but that they should have the right to decide whether anyone else can do those things? Is that a reasonable proposition?

02:44:33 - 02:48:56

Speaker 108

to what Lord Murphy said, and he seemed to suggest that one of the burdens of this legislation was to increase the engagement and the participation of people in the democratic process. And certainly, that is something which is important. But surely one of the bases, basic central principles in a democracy is the restoring of trust within the population. Now, he mentioned about how over the years things had changed. For the other place, my Lords, I was elected for Mid Ulster for 14 and a half years, and the range of the electorate that came out to vote over those years was between 70% and 83% participation in all of those elections.

So, there was no lack of interest or engagement as far as the population were concerned in certainly in those elections. And I know things certainly may have changed, but what we do have is for Northern Ireland as a change because the central principle surely in the democracy is that everyone's vote is equal. And whilst I heard a lot of talk about England, Scotland, and Wales, and I know that the noble lord Murphy, mentioned as regards the different methods of elections, for example, in Northern Ireland for the assembly and for the councils, we have proportional representation, and yet every person's vote in that electoral system was certainly equal, and across the United Kingdom, whilst there are varied manner of electing people, yet when it came to Westminster, everyone's vote was the same. And all of those years in my participation, and it was 25 years in total in the other House, certainly everyone's vote was equal. But that changed in 2021.

And what we find is that England, Scotland, and Wales, when they go to elect a Member of Parliament, they will vote for a person who will legislate on the matters relating to their constituents. But when it comes to Northern Ireland, that has changed because they can only legislate for some issues as far as their Now, they can participate in all the other votes in the other House for England, Scotland, and Wales. But when it comes to Northern Ireland, there is a plethora of legislation or laws that are now forced upon the people of Northern Ireland which the United Kingdom Parliament can not vote upon.

And therefore, those who elected a person in Northern Ireland is going to endure legislation and laws forced upon them that their elected representatives have never voted upon. That's completely different than any other member of Parliament. And the votes, therefore, of a person in Northern Ireland is not the same. And Baroness Bennett mentioned equality issue. Surely, my Lords, there is an equality issue here.

And therefore, I would hope that whenever it comes to the including wind-up, that the noble lady the minister will tell us how the government intends to explain to a 16 or 17-year-old, if they give them the vote in Northern Ireland, that their vote will mean less than the vote for someone else in the rest of the United Kingdom. Because without that answer, you can say, "We'll change the age," but there's still a major problem. And therefore, when it comes to restoring trust in democracy, then we surely have members of Parliament elected to be able to vote on the issues which their constituents are supposed to accept as the law of the land.

02:48:56 - 02:56:04

William Wallace

My Lords, we, on these benches, strongly support the idea of votes at 16, and of two broad reasons. First, because we want this to be a citizen democracy, not one in which passive subjects wait for the government to deliver things to them and are supposed to be thankful, but one in which people feel that they share in government, local and national, and have a voice. And we believe that bringing the voting down to 16 will help to engage people before they leave home in their democracy. We've heard a lot, we had the first question today, about the need for a national conversation. In the Strategic Defence Review last year, we heard about the need for a whole society response to the threats we now face, engaging the local communities, volunteers, and the like.

That requires people to feel that they are part of our physical community, and that they share, therefore, in the need for to decide what goes on in terms of government. The second reason is because we have, increasingly, we and France and Germany and others, a problem of democratic balance demographic balance in our politics. 30 years ago, when I was in charge of writing the manifesto of my own party for the 1997 election, I spoke to the people writing the Labour and Conservative manifestos, and among the things I was told was that you're really writing for people over the age of 45. The ones under 45 don't vote so often, and they don't care so much about the details. So, your package needs to be oriented towards benefits for the older generation.

I think that's a problem. It's a huge problem in France, where old people resist any increase in the age of retirement, for example. I have spent some time last spring going and talking to secondary schools about how they would respond to votes at 16. I've been very impressed by how serious the 16 and 17-year-olds I met were about politics, how much more they want to know, and how keen they are to be engaged.

Yes, it's going to take a shift in the way we approach education, in the way we provide information, but it's worth doing. My Lords, we've been discussing extension of franchise for 200 years, as the noble Lord Hannan rightly pointed out, and I'm sure he'll agree with me that there have only been two occasions on which the Conservatives have not opposed any extension of the franchise. The first, as he mentioned, was Disraeli in 1867 when he decided to take a gamble and discover what he called the angels in marble. And the second was in 2022, in the last Representation of the People Act, when the Conservatives pushed through an expansion of the right to vote for overseas voters for their lifetime, which the noble Lord Hannan pleased to make note, increased the number of voters by somewhere between 2 and 4 million. We're not entirely clear how many overseas citizens we have will be entitled to vote.

That was done without a referendum, without consultation with the other parties and without thinking through what it meant in terms of changing the way in which you delivered your vote, the way you got postal votes out, whatever. Cynics even thought that it was more to do with making it easier for wealthy expats to give money than actually to increase the franchise, but never mind, it was done without a referendum, without all those other things. There's been talk about capacity here, capacity and focus. The young people I was talking to, and no doubt Baroness Fox will also say, are often very concerned about education, for obvious reasons, and training, climate change, sustainability, things that tend not to concern my generation, our generation, quite so much. If we're talking about capacity and interest for the young, we might perhaps think about the old.

When I first went into politics, the local Conservative agent had an extremely good relationship with the matrons of the local care homes, who would go round, I discovered, and talk to the matron, butter her up, and he and she would help the inmates to fill in their postal votes. Nothing much to do with privacy, but it was the way one did things at a local level. Now, this is a long time ago, and I'm sure that no Conservative agent would think of doing such a thing nowadays. But in terms of capacity, if we are to start measuring it's not just the under-18s whom we have to worry about. And in terms of fiddling the franchise, I would also add, of course, the 2022 Act changed the way in which we elect mayors again, which meant that when the mayor of Bristol or near the west of England was elected, he got 26% of the vote.

Good democratic thing. And fiddling with the franchise, one sort has been done on a regular basis by both major parties, so let's pretend not pretend that we're doing that as well. Yes, if we have, when we have votes at 16, there's need for a much greater effort for education, and we have later amendments that will deal with that. Yes, we have to address the question of better information. I certainly had that coming back to me when talking to students in schools.

There are later amendments which deal with that. I must say Baroness Fox produced in passing a wonderful image of the average adult voter conducting independent research on political issues.

I'm not sure that I have met too many voters while canvassing who have been conducting independent research in detail themselves. Don't let's uh overemphasise how wonderful our electorate is. But this the purpose of this is to encourage the practice and habit of voting as a lifetime exercise for the young, to strengthen the voice of younger generations in our ageing society, and to build a more active democracy,

and for all of those reasons, we on these benches support it.

02:56:05 - 03:00:13

Robert Hayward

My Lords, before I touch on one or two other things, can I just make a comment to my noble friend, and I do refer to him as my noble friend Lord Wallace, I think he meant residents rather than inmates when he was referring to care homes. I don't intend to uh cover uh ground which has been covered by a large number of other people, um but I Lord Wallace also touched on the question of changing uh the franchise.

Baroness uh Bennett is not in her place at this moment, um but Lord Wallace was absolutely clear about the historical analogies. Uh I was one of the people who fell within that range of the 7- '69-70 Act in terms of implementation uh and there is no question about it, it was not broadly supported by the Conservative Party, because they thought they would benefit from it. Um, and I've got a very clear recollection because I fell within that age group.

I think there've been one or two important areas that have been touched on, one of which is the issue of Northern Ireland. And I have every sympathy with the um noble uh colleagues from uh from different benches who have referred to the implications of what is not an equality uh of power of vote, and I think that needs to be carefully considered. But what I was also impressed by uh was the comments from the Baroness Lister uh in relation to a very small category of people,

but they do need to be looked at incredibly carefully. Uh I have a very close friend of mine who works very is deeply involved in that community. Uh and we have to remember that 40% of all the adult inmates in prison in this country uh come from care homes. Um it is a difficult task to deal with, and we therefore need to address the sorts of issues that Baroness Lister raised.

I take the point that Lord Murphy of Torfaen raised, uh that it was in the manifesto, but the trouble is with this bill, very little else was in the manifesto. And I have said to both the current minister and to Lord Leong, this bill would be a far better bill if the government stuck to those parts of the legislation which appeared in the manifesto, rather than spending its time adding amendments after amendments, and curtailing debate both in this house and the other house.

If the government would come back with a bill that was solely dealing with the manifesto matters, I think this house would have a far more coherent debate, and it would be logical and appropriate that it was considered on all sides on that basis. My Lords, I don't favour 16 and 17-year-olds having the vote.

I could have cited large numbers of other examples of contradictions in our legislation, but they have been made over and over again with the summary message that what we are doing in the vast majority of cases is raising the age at which people should act in a certain way, whatever that action may happen to be. And in conclusion, my Lords, I just make the observation at this point that I was formerly the chief executive of the Beer and Pub Association, and I'd be quite happy to explain to my colleagues who seem to think that 17-year-olds are not allowed to drink in pubs, they are, but that's for another date.

03:00:13 - 03:04:08

Speaker 113

Cheers to that. Lord Wallace said moments ago that we've been debating franchise extensions for 200 years. Being one of the last speakers in a two-hour debate, I begin to know what that feels like. I want to just very briefly support a number of amendments in this group, but mainly Amendment 2 in the name of my noble friends, Baroness Coffey and Fox. I do perhaps come at it from a different point of view and perhaps on the lone voice on this side, which is that I actually do support the Government in lowering the voting age, and I do congratulate them genuinely on doing this.

However, both baronesses, as has been done by so many, have highlighted many inconsistencies and I think the phrase that it's a bit of a muddle seems to be correct. And I wish to add one which hasn't been raised, I don't think, which I've raised before in Home Office questions, which is around criminal sentencing where we do differentiate between adult and juvenile at 18. And I know that this is incredibly complex as is always the case in this, legalities involved in international agreements. But there has been, and this is what I was questioning the Government minister at the time, one recent and horrific case which highlighted, at least to me, why I do think we should look at whether the balance will now be right. And personally, I think it does need to change.

And I say that because if we are to lower the voting age, and I think we should, but if with that right has to come a sense of responsibility. With that right, I would argue your role in society changes, and we should properly and carefully go through these issues. And it's not just a right-wing thing to say that. It's not a right-wing thing to say that because I think President John F. Kennedy best communicated it with his line about it's not ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country. And Lord Carter of Haslemere, who was in his place earlier, I do pay tribute to him for his Private Member's Bill, where he talked about citizenship for citizenship lessons for younger people.

I don't want to stray too much into what I think is group six, but there are some amendments within this group, and it's been touched on by some already. My fear is that in lowering the voting age, we are implying that we've simply achieved our aims and overnight, without debating what it means, how to build national unity, allow for some political discourse, what being a citizen in modern Britain means, what are your rights, what are your responsibilities and how you can play your part in our country. And I think the points made by the noble Lords Young and Baroness Fox on Amendment 20 are two are valid too, and it shouldn't be scored on for by anyone to look at the issues around social media. I'm a proud father of two very young daughters, and trust me, there's a growing list of things going on in my head every night when I put them to bed about all the things that they that fill me with fear about all the things that they will face as they grow up in Britain. And we should, but we should consider what it means for younger people to be engaged and receive this information and how it happens.

Now, I will close, but fundamentally, I do support the Government, and I repeat that. But my concern is not with the principle, with the insinuation that we treat votes at 16 as an end in itself, that we congratulate ourselves and it will pass, some few people have mentioned it will pass. And somehow we now congratulate ourselves and say jobs are good and mission accomplished, let's move on.

And yet we say nothing about actually some of the many things that many people really do want to fix for the government to get on and support. And if we genuinely want to strengthen democratic participation, lowering the voting age should be accompanied by an understanding of what citizenship is and what playing a part of our free, liberal and democratic society means and entails. There should be, I think, greater clarity to help make the system work, a system which engenders active, proud and patriotic citizenship. Otherwise we do risk, which is my fear, in making a constitutional change without addressing the reasons for making it and arguably undermining it.

03:04:08 - 03:04:24

Speaker 112

My Lords, I thought it might be worth just saying for accuracy, in the Welsh Senedd elections, 16-year-olds were allowed to vote in 2021.

03:04:24 - 03:04:56

Speaker 114

Thank you for that. My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who tabled amendments in this group concerning the lowering the voting age to 16 years. I also thank everyone who's contributed to the debate and I apologize in advance for anyone I'm not going to name-check. And I'm particularly grateful to the my noble friend, Lord Hayward, for clarifying the terminology used by Lord Wallace of Saltaire. I certainly don't think anyone on these benches would refer to elderly people

03:04:56 - 03:05:14

William Wallace

My apologies, I absolutely mis- misspoke, I did. Having spent some time with my mother and with my godmother in a care home, and I have spent many a time visiting residents in and I apologize for misspeaking.

03:05:14 - 03:06:10

Speaker 115

did think that was particularly distasteful. But as I said at second reading, this is a constitutionally significant bill and therefore deserves thorough scrutiny from your Lordships' House. It may well be a manifesto commitment and therefore we will not oppose it, but we would encourage government to seriously consider all the impacts of the implementation, as indeed my noble friend Lord Gascoigne mentioned. It's in that spirit that I address the amendments of my noble friend, Lord Udny-Lister. Amendment 302 would require regulations to lower the voting age to go through the affirmative procedure, and Amendment 33 would require an assessment of 16 and 17-year-olds' vulnerability to electoral disinformation and foreign interference.

03:06:10 - 03:09:38

Speaker 116

He's absolutely right that such changes need to be properly thought through and prepared before they take effect. His Amendments 4 and 283 would require a referendum on lowering the voting age to 16. Referendums are, of course, not a requirement, nor are they legally binding, but they are used to decide major constitutional issues. They've been held three times nationally in the UK: once in '75 on our membership of the EC, in 2011 on changing the voting system, and, of course, on 2016 on our membership of the EU. Lowering the voting age is significant, my Lords, and so is re- and so it's reasonable to ask whether a referendum should be held.

Whilst we'll not oppose a manifesto commitment, as my noble friend Lady Coffey said, it was one line in a many a Labour manifesto. And I hope noble the noble Baroness the Minister would clarify in exactly what circumstances this government believes referendums should be held. This is especially relevant after a senior Labour MP in the other place has suggested Brexit should be reversed without a referendum.

Labour ministers have refused to rule out rejoining the EU without a referendum, which was the will of the people. It begs the question that if this government cares so much about the democratic representation of the people, why would it ignore the way they voted in 2016? Amendments 1 and 3, also in the name of my noble friend, Lord Udny-Lister, seeks to retain the voting age at 18 years of age for elections to the House of Commons, on the grounds that this is in line with the age of which you stand for election yourself, as well as for signing a recall petit- petition under the Recall of MPs Act 2015. He raises the important point about consistency. If this government genuinely believes this policy is right, why not apply the same logic elsewhere?

Indeed, this is why Amendments 22, 279, and 285 in my name and my noble friend, Lord Jamieson, would prevent part one of the Act coming into force until the Secretary of State has undertaken a review of the consistency of age laws. For example, the Family Law Reform Act 1969 sets the age of majority at 18. Full citizens' rights and responsibilities are given at 18. 16 and 17-year-olds need parental consent before they can join the army. They cannot drink, buy vapes, knives, fireworks, or indeed many other things have as have been outlined through Lord my noble friends, Lord Fuller and Lord Hannan.

03:09:38 - 03:13:00

Speaker 114

And to the evidence that the Lady noble Lady Royall of Blaisdon requested from my noble friend, Leigh of Hurley, it came from the respected journal, Developmental Psychology, published in an article by Professor Gardner and Steinberg. It showed that resistance to peer pressure influence increases significantly from 14 to 18. My Lords, our amendment would allow the government to take all of these policy areas into account beforehand, ensuring our Lord's our laws make sense. At the Second Reading, the noble Baroness, the Minister, said that the question is not what else you can or cannot do at 16, but whether 16 is the right age to be able to vote. Has the government justified 16 is the right age?

But of course the two are related, as Amendment 20 in the name of my noble friend, Lord Young of Acton, and the noble Baroness, Lady Fox of Buckley, points out. If we are changing the voting age, what does that mean for restrictions on access to political content? Amendment 2, in the name of my noble friend, Lady Coffey, and the noble Baroness, Lady Fox of Buckley, probes why the government have chosen to lower the voting age to 16 rather than 17. In fact, Professor David Runciman once proposed lowering the voting age to six years of age. For what reasons do the government oppose that?

All we're asking for is reassurance that the Government have properly thought through and can provide the rationale for lowering the voting age to 16 specifically, as well as whether we can expect changes to age requirements in other policy areas, as has been referenced by my noble friends, Lord Bailey of Paddington, Lord Young of Acton, Lord Lea of Crondall. And the amendments in the name of noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, raises the situation in Northern Ireland, requiring an eq- a equality impact assessment prior to extending the franchise to lower voters in the UK. I'm sure we'll come back to equality impact assessments at a later stage. My Lords, there's approximately 48,000 16 to 17 year-olds in Northern Ireland, and again, the Government needs to make sure the changes are thought through. Turning to the amendments in the name of the noble Baronesses Lady Lister of Burtersett and also the Clause Stand part in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, they have raised the need for clarification with regards to youth accommodation and secure children's homes.

What is the scope of clause 2? I hope the noble Baroness the Minister can provide that clarification. I'm grateful to noble Lords who have offered their insights so far and I look forward to the Minister's response.

03:13:00 - 03:14:30

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, the Representation of the People Bill opens up participation and strengthens the integrity of our democracy, ensuring that all eligible citizens can exercise their right to vote. It introduces one of the biggest changes to the franchise in half a century with the enfranchisement of 16 and 17 year-olds and moves us towards more automated voter registration. It reinforces trust by closing down opportunities for those who would seek to undermine our democracy with stronger political finance rules and better protections against harassment and intimidation. And can I say, it's been a great pleasure to listen to this debate this afternoon. I think the House at its best, 19 or 20 speakers, I'm not sure I wrote them all down, but 19 or 20 speakers debating the first part of the bill, and I think we've heard differing views from across the House and some very detailed scrutiny of some of the provisions in the bill, which I welcome.

I would say to the noble Lord Hayward that I know the bill has had some introductions during its passage, but it was always the intention that we would take account of the Rycroft review and introduce some of the recommendations of the Rycroft review as we went through the passage of the bill. And I think Philip Rycroft did an outstanding job on reviewing some of the key issues, particularly around political finance.

03:14:30 - 03:14:57

Robert Hayward

For that clarification, but in light of that, how does she make those observations stack up with the observation that Lord Rooker made at the end of the second reading debate on this bill and the comparison with the amount of time given to committee for this bill in comparison with the Elections Bill in 2022?

03:14:57 - 03:16:45

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I know my noble friend Lord Rooker is raising this on every bill about scrutiny. It's interesting that he was part of the process that put that process in place. He's changed his mind about that. All bills are I think the scrutiny on all bills is welcome. I welcome the scrutiny of the I think this is my sixth piece of legislation now.

I've welcomed the scrutiny that this House brings to all those bills.

In this bill in particular, we knew there would be further additions to the bill as it went through its passage, and that's the point I was trying to make. My Lords, I turn first to the amendments in the name of the noble Lord Udny-Lister, amendments 1 and 3, and the noble Baronesses, Baroness Coffey and Baroness Fox of Buckley, amendment 2. Our intended extension of the franchise will create consistency across the United Kingdom and ensure that young people have a voice at both a local and a national level. But consistency of course is not the only, or the most important reason for extending the vote to 16- and 17-year-olds. As I said at second reading, and it was repeated during this debate, the important question is not what else can or can't you do at 16, but rather the important question is: is 16 the right age to be able to vote?

And this Government is clear the answer to that question is yes, and we were elected on a commitment to make precisely this change. Now, we heard many examples of things you can't do at 16: tongue piercing, gambling, purchasing knives, tattoos, credit cards, and some points about criminal sentencing, which I hear with interest. But

03:16:45 - 03:17:03

Speaker 117

Can the Minister answer the question raised by my noble friend Lord Udny-Lister, which is why it's right for the

for a 16-year-old to be a voter in the election, but not to be a parliamentary candidate or a Member of Parliament?

03:17:03 - 03:20:08

Jane Sharon Taylor

If the noble Lord will bear with me, I want to pick up some other points, first of all. Baroness, the noble Baroness Bennett spoke about votes at 18, and that we were the first in the world to do that, and it would indeed be unthinkable now that we would go back on that. My very first election in 1975, that I voted in, was the vote to go into the European Union, in fact. I haven't changed my mind about that, I have about some other things, but certainly not about that. And when we talk about, you know, purchasing knives at 18, Lord Rennard mentioned things that might intimidate you.

I wasn't intimidated by the little stubby bit of pencil I got to cast that vote. But we believe 16 is the right age to be able to exercise your democratic right. And extending the right to vote to 16- and 17-year-olds will allow them to have a say in the government that shapes their future and set them up, as the noble Lord Wallace said, for a lifelong engagement in democracy. I absolutely agreed about the points on education and I'll come onto those in a moment. But I did want to address some of the points about how we've ended up at 16, because I think that's they were important points made during the debate.

So, I think we've looked extensively at how voting works around the world, and there are a number of places where voting has been introduced for 16- and 17-year-olds, as has already been as has already been said. And we are we've looked at a number of places, including Austria and Malta, who have successfully lowered the voting age to 16. And the step has been indeed taken already, as has been mentioned several times, in both Scotland and Wales for devolved elections, and more widely in the Isle of Man, in Jersey and in Guernsey. Evidence from these places shows that those who vote at a younger age are more likely to continue voting as they get older. By the age of 16, young people have already made important decisions about their own lives around whether to continue with their education, undertake training, pursue an apprenticeship or seek employment or volunteering opportunities.

And even by the age of 14, they have decided what subjects they want to continue to study in their education. Why is it the case that they should be considered old enough to make those decisions, which affect the rest of their lives, but cannot vote? We shouldn't fear expanding the franchise to younger people. In 1916, '69, sorry, the UK was the first country in the world to lower the voting age to 18. And extending the right to vote to 16 and 17-year-olds now is the next natural step in the evolution of our democracy.

Young people are the future of our country. It's only right that they have a say over it.

03:20:08 - 03:20:10

Speaker 118

Hear.

03:20:10 - 03:26:26

Jane Sharon Taylor

I did very much support the points made on a serious program of education. And I know we're going to come on to that in future groups, but I do want to make some points about education now, and what steps are being taken to support young people's education. We want to break down barriers and drive participation. And we know that engagement and education are a crucial part of implementing that policy. It's vital that young people understand and value the democratic process and feel that it's relevant to them.

And we are committed to ensuring that democracy education reinforces the importance and value of participating in our democracy, and inspires greater democratic engagement. We want engagement to start at 16, and continue into adulthood by equipping and empowering pupils with the knowledge and understanding they need to do so. And we will continue to work with the Electoral Commission, the devolved governments, and the civil society to continue what additional measures can support schools, colleges, and youth groups to roll out practical voter and civic education. It's vitally important that we also start that process with our youngest students, and it's this is all aligned with the government's youth strategy of engagement of young people. In terms of the noble Lord Udny-Lister's points about candidates standing in elections, there are very specific reasons why we have taken the decision not to include candidates at 16 and 17.

The government believes that the ages of 16 and 17 are a particularly important time to continue personal development and education. And that's why rules in England require that those who choose to leave school at 16 must either pursue an apprenticeship or work no more than 20 hours a week while in part-time education or training until the age of 18. The requirements of local government office holders as well are a significant commitment. Having different age requirements for local and national office would be unnecessarily complicated, and as such, the government will not be changing the minimum candidacy age for any elected offices. And I heard the points about the Labour Party NEC and constituency offices.

I'm sure that was a recognition of this, but there is definitely a very active engagement, as I'm sure there is across all political parties, of young people in my party as I'm sure there is elsewhere. Lord Udny-Lister has also tabled amendments 4, 283, and 301, which seek to require a referendum on lowering the voting age to 16, with a majority vote in favour before the change can be implemented. However, as my noble friend, Lord Murphy, set out with his characteristic clarity, the government was elected on a clear mandate, which included a commitment to extend the right to vote to 16 and 17-year-olds in all UK elections. And I think that's an important point about not having a referendum on this, we already have a mandate to introduce it.

I would say to the noble Lord Leigh, that as I think the noble Lord Rennard, said, we don't carry out cognitive tests on any citizens before they exercise their franchise, no matter what their age. So I think that this point about cognitive ability is a difficult point for him to make. The government's been very clear on its position on this matter. We genuinely believe young people are the future of our country, and it's only right they have a say in the decisions that shape their lives. And as for partisan advantage, I'm afraid I've heard

I've heard from the other side both that we are doing this as a gerrymandering exercise and that it will let in votes from smaller parties like Reform and the Green Party and so on. You can't have it both ways. We're either gerrymandering it or we're opening out the franchise to a wider group of parties. We're doing it because it's the right thing to do, because it's the right thing to introduce votes at 16 and 17. So, a referendum is not necessary.

It would be unusual to require a referendum before implementing a clear manifesto commitment on which the government was elected and has a mandate for. And I would say to Baroness O'Neill, I think she was talking about some comments a Labour member made about a Brexit referendum, if every statement in the other place by a Labour member became government policy, we'd have an awful lot more work even to do than we have already. I appreciate the interest of the noble Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle in young people's right to vote.

However, it's right that those convicted of a crime and serving a sentence in custody cannot vote. We believe that extending the franchise should bring the same rights and responsibilities as apply to other electors. And that must include the existing restriction on voting for those convicted of an offense and serving a custodial sentence. The clause ensures that this applies consistently across the different forms of youth detention accommodation. And can I also take this opportunity to reassure my noble friend Baroness Lister, who has tabled amendment 6 on this point,

and I think she recognized this, that the drafting does not affect young people in secure children's homes who are not convicted prisoners. I would say that it's very unusual for young people under 18 to receive a custodial sentence. So, those that do have usually committed very serious offenses. So, these provisions concern elections for which the UK government is responsible. Devolved elections in Scotland and Wales are subject to different arrangements.

My Lords, the provisions in this bill simply reflect the well-established position on prisoner voting and ensure that 16 and 17-year-olds are treated the same as all other electors. And the government will not be revisiting this position. Moving on to the government amendments in this group- Sorry.

03:26:26 - 03:27:00

Speaker 83

I'm grateful to my noble friend for clarifying the position, but I don't think she's really addressed this question about, when you got two groups of children living side-by-side, and one of the children will have the vote and the other won't. And if she can't address that now, perhaps you could write to myself and to the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle afterwards to- Because there is concern about the impact that will have on the children who can't vote.

03:27:00 - 03:27:10

Jane Sharon Taylor

I understand the note point my noble friend makes, and I'm very happy to write to her or meet with her to discuss that further. On the government amendments-

03:27:10 - 03:27:20

Kate Hoey

Minister, I know she's got a lot to answer tonight, but is she going to say anything about amendment 21, which was mentioned by a number of peers? Thank you.

03:27:20 - 03:30:04

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask, I'm not this I'm not doing the government amendments because they're the last bit, I'm doing them because this is where they come in the order of things, so I will come on to other amendments.

My Lords, following the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, newly eligible young people will need to register to vote. Government amendment 12 and consequential amendments 275, 295 and 296, tabled in my name, will enable electoral registration officers to obtain information about 14 and 15-year-olds during the 2027 canvass. Registration officers will be able to use that information to invite those young people to register to vote, either as attainers or as electors, once the new franchise is brought into effect. And this will help to get young people on the register and reduce the risk for our hard-pressed EROs of a large spike in registrations immediately before the first polls conducted under the expanded franchise. Turning now to amendment 20 tabled by the noble Lord Young of Acton and the noble Baroness, Lady Fox of Buckley, the Government agrees that extending the franchise must go hand in hand with ensuring young people have access to reliable information and the knowledge they need to participate confidently in elections.

However, we don't consider this amendment is necessary. The Government's proposed social media ban will apply to children under the age of 16, although they will still be able to access the online world for purposes including news and learning. Meanwhile, 16 and 17-year-olds will continue to be able to access social media, although additional default protections will apply to help ensure they can do so safely. The Online Safety Act already includes safeguards for content of democratic importance, recognized news publisher content and journalistic content on the largest user-to-user services. Ofcom is now Can I just finish the sentence?

I may answer the question. Ofcom is now implementing that regime, and there's a strong case for allowing it to run its course before introducing a further statutory review requirement through this bill. Can I just finish this section, and then I'll give way. But regulation is only one part of the answer. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport is working with the Department for Education to strengthen media literacy in the new school curriculum for primary up to age 16 from September 2028, including how pupils identify mis- and disinformation.

And this is complemented by wider government activity, including the Cross-Government Media Literacy Action Plan, and the You Won't Know Until You Ask campaign, and Kids Online Safety Hub, which helps families build resilience to mis- and disinformation, and access trusted online safety information.

03:30:04 - 03:30:41

Speaker 85

I thank the noble Baroness the minister for giving way. That sounded very positive, but just to clarify, was the noble lady the minister giving the House an assurance that content of democratic importance, news publisher content and journalistic content, when those protections are in place, that children under the age of 16 will be able to access that content? That content won't be restricted by the forthcoming regulations restricting social media access for under-16-year-olds?

03:30:41 - 03:32:19

Jane Sharon Taylor

Yes, I think that's certainly the case. The noble Baroness, Lady Hoey has tabled amendments 21, 278, 284 and 286. These amendments seek to require an equality impact assessment comparing the effects of the franchise change in Northern Ireland with Great Britain, and to delay the commencement of Part 1 of the bill until a formal report on the Government's response to that assessment is laid before both Houses. The Government is committed to extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds across the entire United Kingdom on an equal basis. This bill ensures that people across the United Kingdom are empowered to participate in our democracy.

Imposing additional statutory requirements on extending the franchise would create an unnecessary delay to delivering this commitment for young people across the UK.

The noble Baroness has mentioned the Windsor Framework in relation to this amendment. The Windsor Framework was overwhelmingly approved by Parliament. It respects Northern Ireland's place in the union and gives democratically elected members of the Northern Ireland Assembly the ability to scrutinise— can I just finish and then if the noble Baroness still wants to come in, I'll happily give way. And the government is, members of the Northern Ireland Assembly the ability to scrutinise the rules that apply, and the government is committed to it.

The government is committed to equality across the country and lowering the voting age to 16 applies identically across all reserved elections without distinction. The assessment comparing electors in Northern Ireland to those in Great Britain is unnecessary and, as I said, would delay implementation of the measure.

03:32:19 - 03:32:59

Kate Hoey

May I thank the minister for her, for the detail she's responded. I obviously don't agree with her, but could I just correct something, and it's said by many noble lords, the Windsor Framework was never voted on as the Windsor Framework either in the House of Commons, sorry, the other place, or in the House of Lords. The only way that we've had votes has been on statutory instruments, the very first one some months after 2021 when it was, the protocol was brought in, and then the Windsor Framework. There has been no vote in this place or in the other place ever on the Windsor Framework, the principle of.

03:32:59 - 03:34:25

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'll leave that comment where the noble lady left it. Moving to the amendments in the names of the noble Baroness O'Neill of Bexley, Lord Jamieson and Lord Brady of Altrincham, Amendments 22, 279, 285, which would require a report explaining why the voting age should differ from the age of majority as set out in the Family Law Reform Act 1969, which is 18. A similar amendment to this was tabled in the other place, and I can only reiterate today what my ministerial colleague said in those debates. The government is working to build and maintain a democracy fit for 2026 and beyond. The central question before us is not whether the voting age aligns with every other age threshold contained in statute.

Rather, it is whether 16 and 17-year-olds should have a voice in the democratic decisions that affect their lives and their future. The government's view is clear: young people have a direct stake in the future of this country, and extending the franchise will enable them to participate in shaping policies and institutions that will have a lasting impact on their lives and can help establish the habits of democratic engagement that will build the foundations for lifelong participation in our democratic system. I hope that reassures noble lords the government has carefully considered this matter, and we remain committed to delivering this important reform.

03:34:25 - 03:34:44

Mark McInnes

I'd like to thank the minister for her comments, but and, but I would plead with her that she does take on board the education point, which I think has been raised by a number of people in the House. But I accept this is a manifesto commitment and therefore, I withdraw the amendment.

03:34:44 - 03:35:14

Speaker 121

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment by leave withdrawn. Amendment two, Baroness Coffey, not moved. Amendment three, Lord Udny-Lister, not moved. The question is that Clause 1 stand part of the Bill.

As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. After Clause 1, Amendment 4, Lord Udny-Lister, not moved. In Clause 2, Amendment 5, Lord Frost.

03:35:14 - 03:49:04

David Frost

My Lords, I rise to move Amendments 5, 7, 30 and 31 on the marshalled list. My Lords, in considering this Bill, we're going to be considering some major changes to how we conduct our elections in this country, and we will spend a lot of time considering the what, if you like, of these changes and their justifiability.

What we're not going to spend much time doing is considering the who: who has the right to make the changes that are being brought forward, or not. And I want to discuss that question, and particularly the consequences of the devolution of the electoral franchise for all but national elections, and to suggest, as my amendments suggest, that these arrangements need to be looked at again. I emphasize the franchise. I'm not looking at the electoral system, for there's always been variation within the country on that. I'm not looking at the merits of voting at 16, or Commonwealth voting, or anything like that.

We will be coming to some of those where we've not discussed them already. It's about the wider consequences of allowing the devolved governments to change the electoral franchise and the knock-on effects that has for the wider system and the rest of the country. And that's why I've thought it right to table these amendments tonight. They're probing amendments, of course, designed to get the matter discussed. Their effect would be to make the electoral franchise a reserved matter and the same in every part of the UK; in other words, to restore the constitutional system on that point as it existed before 2013.

Just briefly, my Lords, on how these amendments would work. Amendment 30 establishes two common franchise categories: it applies the parliamentary franchise, so described, to Westminster elections, UK-wide, nationwide referendums, or similar; and it applies the local government franchise to almost everything else. The amendment therefore replaces Scotland and Wales's wider nationality qualifications, it removes Scotland's short-sentence prisoner exception, and it would make inconsistent legislative provisions ineffective. Amendment 31 goes on to prevent the devolved institutions from subsequently recreating different franchises once again. It expressly reserves to Westminster the voting entitlement in Scottish Parliament, Senedd, and local elections and referendums and polls in Scotland and Wales.

Amendments 5 and 7 make the necessary consequential changes concerning detained young offenders. Amendment 5 removes the England-only restriction on their disqualification from local government voting, and amendment 7 deletes the Northern Ireland modification that's rendered unnecessary by the earlier change. So, my Lords, that's how they would work. I want to say a word about the history and how we got to this point. And as I've noted, the devolution of franchise setting is hardly something that is in the dim and distant past.

It's not a long-established and well-accepted part of our constitution. It goes back all of 13 years. That's why I want to examine this history in a bit more detail. Scotland first: the original devolution settlement left the franchise reserved in 1998, and the then Labour government actually defended that explicitly. Lord Sewel said explicitly, so I quote: "The Scottish Executive cannot mess around with the franchise; that rightly remains reserved."

And that was not regarded as a controversial statement at that point.

The genie was let out of the bottle only with the SNP's determination to give itself the best chance of winning the 2014 independence referendum. And the government consented to votes at 16 for that referendum under a special arrangement and then agreed to it permanently in 2015. After the referendum, Scotland Act removed the general reservation on all but UK parliament elections in 2017. And controversially, actually, and your Lordships' Constitution Committee said at the time that devolving constitutional powers including the franchise risked, and I quote, "introducing variation where there should be none", end quote. It identified possible differences in the enfranchisement of non-British residents and British citizens abroad, not merely the voting age question.

It also warned that changes in Scotland could in the end pressure Westminster into matching them rather than having a prior wider UK-wide debate on how the system should work. Warnings those warnings were correct, I think, but not were ignored. And in 2020, the Scottish Government extended the franchise further, not just to short-sentence prisoners, but to all foreign residents in Scotland for everything for other than national parliamentary elections. In Wales, things went more quickly, but to the same destination. Once again, it was a referendum, this time one that never happened, about devolving tax powers, which was the first introduction of voting at 16 into the system.

The general reservation was lifted in 2018. Welsh legislation in 2020 and 2021 extended voting rights for non-nationals in a similar way to Scotland, though the tests are slightly different. And in Wales too, short-sentence prisoners remain excluded. To complete the set, my Lords, in Northern Ireland, voting rights have never been devolved, so there's it doesn't come into this question. So, my Lords, that's the situation.

What's the problem that's been created by this set of piecemeal changes to the franchise? I suggest my Lord's situation is quite unsatisfactory, and there are I think three sets of problems that have been created. The first is just practical issues. The fact that rights change as you move around the country, both on the question of age and as regards foreign residents' right to vote. Now, I think it's a good principle that voters should be able to understand whether they can vote or not without mastering the detail of the devolution law.

And indeed the Electoral Commission has in the past warned that divergent franchises can confuse voters and campaigners. There's a lot of administrative complexity in keeping different registers for different purposes and different kinds of elections in different parts of the country, not insurmountable, but it does exist and the Electoral Commission has highlighted this too in the past. So, there's a set of practical issues, but I think there are a couple of bigger ones behind it. The second is a question of constitutional logic. This is one country and in modern democracies, voters have the same rights.

We may agree or disagree with exactly what those rights should be and how we extend them. And as I said, this isn't a point about the substance. It's a point about how things are done in devolved administrations. And I think it's worth highlighting that it cuts both ways. If Reform UK, for example, had won the elections in Wales earlier this year, their policy was to end Commonwealth voting in Wales, a policy which I happen to agree with, and we'll come on to that.

but it would have introduced a huge change to the system, once again, in only one part of the country, and I contend this isn't a particularly satisfactory situation. The rights people have as electors, I think, should be the same for everyone, regardless of where they happen to be standing in the country. And in a nation state, the terms of basic democracy have to be set at country level, and in most places that is a foundational rule of the constitutional settlement. And where it isn't, it tends to encourage a feeling of difference, of separateness, which I think's to be discouraged in our current fractured state in this country.

Third, my Lords, and that really leads me onto this point, I think what we have seen and the most pernicious consequence of this is the use of franchise changes in really a highly political way in very charged environments. As I noted, the original extension to voting at 16 was really, I think, since we've allowed ourselves to break the taboo that these changes might be made for other than objective reasons, I would say the original extension to 16 in Scotland was a transparently political gesture, one aimed at giving the SNP the best chance of winning their referendum. The extension to foreign residents, all foreign residents, in Scotland and Wales, wherever they come from, once again, I think is a differ- deliberate attempt to skew the potential support for different parties and to ensure that any repeated referendum on any national question would be slanted by large numbers of non-British citizens on the register. I think sometimes also there's a attempt to show a degree of slight moral superiority, perhaps, a de- deliberate attempt, for example, on prisoner voting to show a different approach to England.

And last year, there was political pressure in Scotland to extend voting to asylum seekers, and that came close to getting into the 2025 Election Act. And I think these changes need to be discussed rationally and collectively as a country. They're not part of some race to show whether one devolved nation is more progressive or more robust, indeed, on migration than any other. So, my Lords, these are the problems, and they possibly explain why other European countries have been much more reticent in this regard than we have in the UK. Switzerland, which is of course an explicitly federal state with very highly devolved powers, even now is the only one that gives similar rights to its cantons that as those that Scotland has.

The Länder in Germany and Austria can vary voting age within constraints that are set centrally, but they're explicitly prohibited from granting voting rights to foreign residents. And we will come onto that question, but granting voting rights to foreign residents at all is extremely rare in Europe. In any case, crucially, the rights are the same for all territories in those countries. There's no asymmetric arrangements, as we have in the UK. And of course, it's this asymmetry that produces half of the problem.

All other EU countries set the rules nationally or in a small number of cases have the right to make small, technical changes within a framework that's set nationally. And of course, also apart from Spain, other countries don't have the constant push to secession, which makes the devolution of the franchise so highly political. My Lords, Britain really is an outlier on these sort of questions. My Lords, to conclude, this is why I think we need to look at these issues again.

We're not looking at a settled constitutional norm. We are looking at very recent development. The taboo on reconsidering devolved powers once devolved needs to be broken and devolve and forget is not good enough. Indeed, I think the only area that's ever been devolved to Scotland or Wales and has since been returned is the right to exploration in the Antarctica, incredibly, devolved by mistake, I think, in the original devolved, the devolution settlement. For reasons of normal constitutional logic, international comparability, and stop politicizing something so fundamentally as the electoral mandate, we need to look again.

And I think the national government has a responsibility to look at the issues and the consequences for the wider country. Devolution allows different parts of the UK to govern themselves differently. It doesn't follow that each much have, must have an independent power to determine the basic qualifications of those who entitled to elect a legislature. I contend those qualifications really ought to be settled nationally through this Parliament, and that we can and we should preserve different governments and different policies without dispersing responsibility for the democratic foundations of the state.

03:49:04 - 03:49:11

Speaker 121

Amendment proposed clause two, page two, line 19, leave out "in England".

03:49:11 - 03:51:53

Speaker 75

If I might follow Lord Frost, and he would not be surprised to learn that I don't agree with him on these issues, I understand the difference between franchise and the whole business of elections and the institutions to which we elect people. But we have to be extremely careful that we don't undermine a devolution settlement, which is not just set up by act of Parliament, but by referenda in Northern Ireland, in Scotland, and in Wales' case, two referenda. And to do that would be seriously damaging to the devolution settlement. In Northern Ireland's case, I had the privilege of chairing that those parts of Good Friday Agreement talks which dealt with elections. And what happened then was that there was an agreement amongst all the parties in Northern Ireland who were involved in those talks, and the two governments, of course, to ensure that the final Good Friday Agreement would command consensus right across the board.

Start interfering with that, we're in deep trouble. And that was agreed, of course. The 1998 settlement was agreed by referendum north and south in Ireland. Now, I'm not saying we can't change it, but those changes really need to be made with the devolved assembly itself. And in Scotland and in Wales, one of my predecessors, Welsh secretary, once said that devolution is a process.

I didn't agree with him at the time, but I think he was probably right. It is a process, and over the last 30 years, that process has meant that the relationship between the United Kingdom government and Parliament, and the devolved governments and Parliament have been developed to a very sophisticated degree. Interfere with that, you can seriously interfere with the devolution settlement. So, while, in some ways, there is some merit in thinking that perhaps that franchise should be universal, the only way you could agree with that, it seems to me, is having consensus with the devolved administrations, and they would have to agree with that. Myself, I'm not actually a great lover of proportional representation.

I have always been a first-past-the-post person, and I really do believe in a link between the elected member and his or her constituents. I don't particularly agree with the settlement that in Wales we've had for the 96 members on a closed-list system. Not sure anybody really understands it all that much.

but I do agree with the right of the Senedd to be able to establish that system, and so, therefore, I think we ought to be very careful, indeed, how we deal with these particular amendments.

03:51:53 - 03:59:22

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, I'm very pleased to support my noble friend Lord Frost, and I put my name to his amendments and the amendments 30, 31, and the two consequential amendments. I listened very carefully to Lord Murphy of Torfaen. I thought I was the only person who wasn't keen on the d'Hondt system of voting, and he puts his finger on a very important point, that it doesn't allow the voters, really, to hold a particular person, or even party, accountable. And we've seen from recent evidence in the Welsh Senedd that someone can change their political affiliation and refuse to give way, even though they've de facto been elected as a party member rather than an individual as a candidate in a set specific constituency.

I support this amendment, my Lords, or these amendments, because the practical effect of them will be to create administrative consistency across the franchise rules of all elections, referenda, and polls in the UK. And I have to say in an era of fractiousness and bitter division in politics, which is growing stronger, I think having multiple election systems, which reduce the ability of your average voter who is not engaged to engage in the political system and to see that their vote has a consequence, and that the person they voted for is likely to be elected, only adds to a sense or an undermining of the sense of common purpose and social solidarity, and make and continues to make different parts of our country more fractious and divided. I think it's perfectly possible to support these amendments, but also, broadly speaking, agree with the concept of devolution. If you go to a country such as Scotland, it had a separate legal system, a separate education system, a proud history, and, not least, in building the British Empire many years ago, and it's different to England.

But I would respectfully say to Lord Murphy that the people of England never had a vote whether they wanted to set up the Welsh Assembly as it then was, or the Scottish Parliament. And, therefore, their ability to make key decisions was undermined by that, albeit he probably will say that the Blair Government did have a mandate, and was reelected after the establishment of those two devolved administrations. But, my Lords, my noble friend has made some important points, and I won't belabor them, but a single nation-state should have a common framework for democratic membership. The United States is many times bigger than the United Kingdom, and has many more people, and yet it has the same voting system.

And we will see whether it works tomorrow in delivering the votes that people want in the midterm elections. And I think it I've said it before, and I'll say it again, we are a unitary state. It seems to me odd that if you live in Monmouthshire, you have a completely different voting system and a way of electing people that matter and are making decisions about your life than 5 miles across the border in Herefordshire. Ditto in Cumbria or Northumberland, vis-a-vis Argyll or Dumfriesshire or East Lothian. It does seem strange for such a small country.

We have single transferable vote, the additional member system, the regional list, alternative member, first-past-the-post, etc, and I mentioned the d'Hondt system before.

And voting rights, as my noble friend said, should not change simply because of someone moving across the United Kingdom between different counties, towns, and cities, and villages. And as my noble friend said, Britain's arrangements are very anomalous. Only Germany and Austria have the ability to vary the voting age. And in particular, they are very strict, as he said, concerning the capacity of foreign voters to cast their ballots in elections. Now, that's important.

If we one looks at the situation in Wales, we've heard before about the ability of Commonwealth and Irish citizens to vote. But in Scotland, they permit legally resident foreign nationals to vote in Scottish Parliament and local elections, and in December of last year, 198,000 qualifying foreign nationals were registered to vote in Scottish Parliament and local elections. That's not far off 5% of the electorate. I think that's a significant issue. Now, no one is casting aspersions on the bona fides of those people.

They live in Scotland. But if you're in the business of protecting the integrity of our voting system and that long-standing link between voting having a vested interest in your community and nationality, then I think at your peril you undermine that by allowing people who are not, do not have the same investment perhaps, constitutionally, historically, in the country in which they are voting. And I do think that these days we need to be thinking about the trust people have in the system. So, there should be consistency between devolved elections, national referenda and parliamentary elections concerning the eligibility of foreign nationals to vote and bringing devolved administrations in line with national the national qualifying standard of eligibility to vote. And I'll finally say that when we're discussing the self-interest of some party, as my noble friend said, it was an egregious example of the SNP in 2011, I think, using that legislation, the devolved competence that they had to affect the franchise for their own narrow, electoral self-interest.

And I think, if anything else, were this amendment to be adopted, it would act as a check on devolved power, limiting the devolved administrations' ability to amend their rules further, and we heard about asylum seekers earlier, encouraged by the dramatic change effected in this bill of lowering the age of 16. And this would cap the administrations' abilities to expand the franchise even further, the slippery slope argument. So, my Lords, I support my noble friend's amendments. I do think they're sensible. They don't resile from a support for the concept of devolution, but they do try and bring some coherence and some commonality in terms of our electoral systems to this country.

And I think that will be good because people would understand what they're voting for, they would be more likely to vote and exercise their franchise, and it seems common sense and sensible so to do. And on that basis, I strongly support the amendment.

03:59:22 - 03:59:44

Robert Hayward

Before my noble friend sits down, and it's not intended to undermine the coherence of his overall argument, but as a pedant alert, my noble friend said that the United States, all 50 states operate on the same electoral system.

They don't. There are differences between a host of different states in one form or another.

03:59:44 - 04:00:15

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, I bow to my noble friend's great greater knowledge. I was referring to the national ballots. I understand that for rat-catcher, county sheriff and other laws and other roles, I think there will be, of course, local differences, but on the election, for instance, of governor, members of the House of Representatives, the Senate, they are generally the same.

04:00:15 - 04:04:01

Dafydd Wigley

My My My My My Lords, first of all, I apologize. I wasn't able to attend the second reading, but my noble friend Baroness Smith of Llanrwst contributed on behalf of Plaid Cymru, and I hope she'll continue doing so as effectively again. I now rise to oppose the thrust of this group of amendments, which is hardly a surprise to anybody. I don't believe that we are in a single-nation state. We're not. We're in a multi-nation state.

While I acknowledge there is a valid argument that an election to any one single chamber of government should be on a uniform, consistent franchise basis throughout the area covered by that chamber, there surely can be no valid reason for Westminster to tell Wales or Scotland that we cannot, in our own devolved parliaments, allow our young people to vote at 16 because it doesn't happen to suit Westminster. My Lords, devolution exists to allow us to do things differently in the nations of Wales and Scotland. Indeed, if Westminster acts to take the vote off young people in Wales and Scotland, I can't imagine a stronger lever to drive those two countries towards independence, so I would invite the House to think very carefully before doing so. Our experience in this regard in Wales in the last May's election was wholly positive. The degree of interest amongst young people was impressive.

I saw it for myself in canvassing during the election, in talking to young people in my home community and to friends of my grandchildren in other parts of Wales and while acting as a booth agent for Plaid Cymru on voting day in my own home village. The turnout in May's election in Wales was in fact the highest of any devolved election in Wales. Yes, it was in the a bit over 50%, and we're going to ask why it wasn't higher in previous elections, but it was a step in the right direction in getting young people involved, because it not only involved them, but very often it involved their parents, because they got to understand what was going on and perhaps participated, whereas in the past, they hadn't done so. There's also exists in Wales a Welsh Youth Parliament, which is a very a highly respected body and which helps the development of young people's thinking in political terms on the all-Wales level. Furthermore, my Lords, the PR system in Wales ensured multi-party voices in our Senedd, which must be a good thing for democracy.

So finally, may I point out that if we had suffered a simple first-past-the-post system in our present Senedd, and voting patterns were the same as they had been in May, the 96 seats would today have given Plaid 66 and remain 30.

So, I suggest that indeed was a sensible system that we have in Wales that does respect multi-party democracy. The logic of these amendments is on the assumption that we live in a nation state. My Lords, we do not. That may have been that way we have developed into the system that we have today, and we should respect the principles on which devolution was founded.

04:04:01 - 04:06:40

John Gummer

Yeah. I am very much opposed to a system other than first-past-the-post, but I do have to say that it does seem to me very peculiar that we have a devolved system, and then we are to say that people in the devolved systems can't decide how they choose their government. I find that a very odd argument. The fact of the matter is that Wales has a very odd system of election.

It's not one that I would campaign for, but it is the Welsh who've decided that's the one they want. And I really do find it really out of all proportion of the world we live in today. We are a country made up of a number of countries. Yes, of course, we're the United Kingdom, but the Welsh are different, as somebody who comes from a Welsh-speaking father, are different from much of the rest.

The idea that because people move around the United Kingdom, somehow or other, they will be fogged by the fact that there are differences in different countries just seems to me to be very odd. Now, I happen to think that the history of electoral arrangements in the north of Ireland and Northern Ireland in general, really, and in Ireland in general, have not been very happy. But the fact of the matter is, it is for Northern Ireland to decide how it is going to be governed as far as its own devolved traditions. And it's also true for Scotland. I dislike the Scottish nationalists.

I think they are the worst government in the United Kingdom. I think they have done terrible damage to Scottish education, terrible damage to Scotland generally, but in the end, it is the Scots who have to decide how their own government is elected. And the idea that we should take back the decision about how you do that to the United Kingdom government seems to me to undermine the whole concept of devolution. I believe in devolution because I think that the closer people are to the decision-makers, the more they are likely to feel that they are engaged, that it's their government.

And I hope very much that this House will not go backwards by suggesting that we should force other people to choose their government in the way that we like it. It is right that everybody shall vote the same way for the central United Kingdom government, but it does seem to me to be frankly, very old-fashioned and out of date to suggest that we should go back on what we do now.

04:06:40 - 04:09:07

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow and almost entirely agree with the noble Lord Deben, although I don't accept his label of the current Welsh system as odd, but otherwise, 100% agreement, and it's also a great pleasure to admire the speech of the noble Lord Wigley. And the noble Lord Jackson, said that this group of amendments would be a check on devolved power. That's a check on the representatives of chosen by the people in their own nations. And I would say to those who wish to defend and maintain the Union that they should realize that denying and removing rights is no way to maintain it. Now, I note, and I hope the noble Lord Frost, would accept, that devolution is about difference: different choices, different nations.

We talk about we have different languages protected and relied on in different nations.

We have different rules about the management and treatment of land. We'll park the Crown Estate in Wales on the side for the moment. We have different kinds of politics and those nations have made very different political choices. And I don't think that there is any evidence that a change in franchise has made a significant impact on the political choices that those nations have made. However, what I mostly rise is to address a particular element of this group of amendments and one that the noble Lord Frost himself did not address in his introduction, but perhaps he might in the wrap-up.

There is an exception here. We're talking about every election being under the same franchise except for the City of London ward elections. Now, I will point noble Lords to my own amendment 269, we'll undoubtedly get to much later, which would actually abolish the business vote for the City of London Corporation elections. This would, my amendment would end the rotten borough, the nation's last rotten borough. It would introduce the principle of one person, one vote finally in 2026.

04:09:07 - 04:09:18

John Gummer

Since she said that she liked following my speech, may I just say to her that I think that is nonsense and there is no reason at all to change what happens in the City of London.

04:09:18 - 04:10:23

Natalie Bennett

I am delighted to allow the noble Lord to say just that, and I'm sure there are many people in your Lordship's House who would agree with the noble Lord. And in fact, I will point members of your Lordship's House to a book I was at the launch at last week. It's called The Aristocracy, and it's about the composition of the House of Lords. And noble Lords might find it of interest with relevance to the relationship between this House and the City of London. Coming back to where I was, I'm not going to fully cover the points that I'm going to raise in 269, but I really will ask the noble Lord to justify in this context, saying everything else has to be the same except the City of London.

If you're going to impose uniformity, why this odd little black hole in the centre of the city without democratic control, why is that being excluded?

04:10:23 - 04:12:16

Speaker 129

My Lords, I'll speak briefly as my noble friend Lord Wigley has covered some of the most important points, but also it's a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness Lady Bennett. And it is interesting the exception that is in these amendments for the City of London, but not for whole nations. So it'd be interesting to hear more about that in the closing. The only points I just wanted to raise was that the Welsh Parliament, Senedd Cymru is the people of Wales's parliament. Therefore, it's only right that the people of Wales decide how it's run.

The same goes for Scotland and the Scottish Parliament. These amendments are essentially an unnecessary power grab. Why is it the business of this Parliament how the people of Wales and Scotland decide to be represented in their parliaments in Scotland and Wales? On the point in relation to different arrangements and whether people understand those different electual arrangements and when you vote at 16, a story I wanted to share actually was during a lot of engagement with younger people across Wales, a lot of them raise how they understand the different systems particularly because of what happened during the COVID pandemic.

And during the COVID pandemic Wales and England made different decisions in terms of whether schools were open, different arrangements in terms of the healthcare arrangements. And that is something that the younger people of today have experience and have knowledge on. And they understand the different systems of and what the different parliaments make decisions on. So I think that's really important to share is that because of those experiences they do know those difference of opinions. So I think it's important to rebut that in the earlier speeches.

04:12:16 - 04:12:30

Speaker 128

And we do take a different approach on matters. And that is devolution. So I just wanted to end on the fact that this is a matter in my opinion for the Welsh Parliament and the Scottish Parliament only.

04:12:31 - 04:15:35

Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor

My Lords, I support this group of amendments in the name of Lord Frost and Lord Jackson, and I do so really because I think it's very important for this country and its constitutional arrangements that we have these changes. This country has always been a unitary power. It's one of the oldest unitary powers and it's also one of the most stable political democracies. That second characteristic matters as much as the first and its nature, both being old and unitary and being a stable democracy, are linked to each other. Constitutional change is for the whole country.

It has historically involved the whole country through broadsheets with long debates, public discussion. And for all of these, Parliament has been, as Churchill once said, the forum for the nation. In fact, it was Samuel Johnson, I think, who made Parliament popular for the public by being the first person to report systematically its proceedings, long, I think, the precursor of Hansard. Second, it is important to avoid sectional politics in constitutional decisions. And one can't help escaping the feeling that in some decisions taken by other assemblies in Wales and Scotland, there isn't the hint, if I might say, of political considerations in determining these grave constitutional matters.

And it's much harder to break the mould of a very one party popularity. And for that reason, I don't particularly think it's a bad thing that we have constant changes of political party in this country. It's very good for democracy. It's good for stability that the other people have a chance. But where you have one party tending to be dominant election after election, there cannot be anything but the suspicion, at least, that party will use its dominant power to use Lord Wallace's words in another capacity in another meaning earlier this, to fiddle the constitution.

And finally, I think it is important for consistency, not just transparency, but consistency. And the Government in its explanatory notes refers to the importance of consistency as one of the reasons for this bill.

And if we are to be consistent, we should ensure that the franchise is consistent across the country.

04:15:35 - 04:16:32

Speaker 127

My Lords, this group really provides us with a choice between devolution or top-down centralized uniformity. Now I acknowledge Lord Frost and Lord Jackson are perhaps surprising voices for enforcing centralized uniformity on a range of nations regardless of the views of those nations, but that is, in effect, what these amendments do. Although, as Baroness Bennett and Baroness Smith have both pointed out, not quite, because a special privileged position is given to the City of London, a special privileged position that may well be justified for some of the reasons we heard earlier, but which these amendments wouldn't grant to the people of Wales or to the people of Scotland. And as a Londoner for nearly all of my life, very proud to often argue the corner for London, I do think giving the City of London a special place above and beyond Scotland and Wales might be going just a little bit too far.

04:16:32 - 04:16:36

Speaker 131

I also think

04:16:36 - 04:16:59

Speaker 37

But on this important issue of the City of London, if you give it its name as the Corporation of London, and you treat it as essentially a trading estate which happens to have 14,000 people living on it, maybe the electoral arrangements that they adopt are indeed a matter for that trading estate rather than for the rest of us.

04:16:59 - 04:18:05

Speaker 127

It is an interesting point, but as the noble Lord himself said, there are several assumptions leading up to his conclusion, not all of which I would share. We've also heard the argument that the ability of Scotland and Wales to make their own choices might result in pressure on us here in Westminster. Well, I think, in a way, that is quite an advantage. Because, after all, if Scotland decides to do something or if Wales decides to do something and it works, well, that's a really good bit of pressure, I think, that we should welcome. And of course, if it fails, then it does it achieves the exact opposite.

I think seeing how variation plays out is not a bad thing to be scared of. Indeed, there is much more variation than perhaps the noble Lord Jackson, is aware of. Because he made reference to the United States, I would point out that the voting systems for Congress varies between states in the United States. And indeed, two of the states in the United States use preferential voting. So I very much hope all sides of this House will pay more attention and maybe learn from the States in that respect.

04:18:05 - 04:18:39

James Stewart Jackson

Preempts my response to my noble friend, for clarity, I did check and he's quite right. I stand partially corrected, in that the state of Maine and the state of Alaska does do ranked-choice elections, but one for governor and senator, and the other, I think, just for senator. But I'm touched that he's interested in those issues. But my general point is that the vast bulk of elections are on the same kind of electoral system across the United States.

04:18:39 - 04:21:04

Speaker 127

Indeed, but variation is present. And indeed, there is many other examples of variation. Because the argument was made that, you know, there are some administrative and burdens from allowing variation. Well, I would simply observe that with devolution, we have the ability to vary things like speed limits. We have the ability to vary things like tax rates.

And actually, I think if one is going to take that argument seriously, that there are problems with variation, one should be upfront and say that is an argument against devolution, full stop. It's not possible, I think, with powerful logic and consistency, to argue that variation for the franchise is somehow a problem, whilst variation for say tax rates is acceptable.

And that, in a way, is gets to the argument about constitutional logic because I think the constitutional logic argument works exactly the other way, which is the very logic, the very constitutional logic of devolution is that different people end up being able to make different decisions. That is the inseparable inescapable logic of devolution. And I would just finally say on the point about gerrymandering, some slightly more politic phrases were used as well earlier. I mean, I always think it is, you know, very unwise to attempt to set rules to do with elections on the basis of partisan self-interest, partly obviously for the reason of principle, but also partly because so often it backfires. And, indeed, returning to the United States, we may well see some Republicans rueing what they thought was very clever drawing of boundaries.

We may well see them rueing it when the elections come in tomorrow, although of course all of us, as we will have to be here bright and early on Wednesday morning, sadly will not be able to stay up quite as late as we may have wished to watch those election results coming in. But fundamentally, this is a question about devolution. It's a question about, do we believe that it is right for different places, who have powers devolved to them, to make different decisions? And I would join those who have argued in this debate in saying that, yes, that variation is right. And therefore on this occasion, I very much hope that we will not be hearing warm words from the noble lady the minister in due course, but the noble lady the minister, too, will defend the rights of different parts of the United Kingdom to make their own decisions under devolved settlements.

04:21:04 - 04:23:54

Speaker 116

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Frost for his group of probing amendments, including those supported by my noble friend Lord Jackson of Peterborough. This has been a much quicker debate, but worthy no less, and I thank all of those who have contributed to it. These amendments seek to standardise voting eligibility across the UK, with the exception for the City of London ward elections, as has already been said. The SNP in Scotland and Labour in Wales have already given the right to vote to all foreign residents in devolved and local elections. Those decisions were not minor technical differences between the UK's constitute parts, constituent parts, and they are deserving of debate at a national level.

This issue also relates to automatic voter registration, because whilst Wales have conducted four pilots on automatic registration, they did not have to verify the nationality of an elector as a result of their changes at a devolved level. I'm sure we will debate the security of automatic voter registration in greater detail in due course. In addition, we are concerned about the consequences for UK political donation rules, as a result of the changes by the two devolved administrations to give out voting rights to every foreign resident. This has given foreign citizens the right to make unlimited donations to politicians and political parties across the UK, opening the door to foreign finance, as well as direct electoral influence. For example, a foreign student resident in a Scottish university can legally make political donations to any political entity.

At Second Reading, the noble Baroness the Minister said that this bill will reduce the risk of foreign money entering into our politics, and that the threat to our democracy from foreign influence and hidden sources of political funding are an ever-growing danger, one that we cannot afford to delay tackling.

Will she therefore commit to closing this loophole without delay? If not, why the inconsistency when it comes to foreign interference? My Lords, this debate has touched on fundamental questions. The balance of devolution matters, but so does citizenship. It's not meaningless, as so many of those residents who have proudly chosen to become citizens can attest.

04:23:54 - 04:24:02

Speaker 132

I look forward to hearing the noble Baroness the Minister's response.

04:24:02 - 04:27:05

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, the amendments proposed by the noble Lord Frost would also apply the electoral franchise currently used for local elections in England and Northern Ireland to all elections in Scotland and Wales. In practice, this would mean some foreign citizens would no longer be able to vote in local elections in Scotland and Wales or elections to the Scottish Parliament or Senedd Cymru. For completeness, I also know that Lord Frost has tabled multiple amendments, some which remove Commonwealth citizens' voting rights as well, although these do not. The Government will not support these amendments. The Government is committed to maintaining and defending the devolution settlements.

Allowing the Scottish and Welsh Parliaments to set the electoral franchise for their own elections, as well as to local offices, is a fundamental part of those settlements. And the Government sees no clear benefit to changing that position, one which has held for many years. And I would say to the noble Lord Jackson, I think he answered his own question, actually, that there was indeed a mandate for the devolution settlements through the 1997 general election. Like the noble Lord Deben, Baroness Bennett, the noble Lord Wigley, I fundamentally believe in devolution. Our diversity across our nations is our strength.

And I fundamentally, and as we extend the devolution program, I think this Government has made it very clear that we think it should be people with skin in the game in their local area taking the key decisions about those areas. It's perfectly right that each of the Governments around the UK is free to do what they feel is right within the competence of the acts of devolution. As such, the Government cannot support these amendments. I would say on the political finance side, we're going to have lots of debate around that in future groups, so I'll part that for the moment. But I would also say that the Prime Minister is has already announced that he will be instigating a national commission on electoral reform, so all of the questions that we've heard about PR, and whether it's right or whether it's not right, will be debated.

And I think that is the right way to do it. I think it's right to have a proper national conversation on electoral reform and whether we want it or not. And my last point, the noble Lord Wigley spoke about the Youth Parliament in Wales. I think that's a very important point, particularly in view of the previous debate we had. I instigated a youth parliament when I was council leader in my town and members of that youth council sat on full council.

They couldn't vote, but they could speak in our debates. And a youth mayor for our town. And I do think it's that active participation in decision making that encourages our young people to get involved. For now, I would just repeat that the Government cannot support these amendments.

04:27:05 - 04:29:15

David Frost

My Lords, I thank the noble lady the Minister. I'm disappointed to hear she's not supporting the amendments, but not entirely surprised, I admit. I thank those who've supported them. I also thank Baroness Bennett for raising the problem of the City of London. Actually, I slightly sympathize with what the noble lady said, but I just didn't want to increase the complexity of this particular amendments by getting into that slightly niche problem.

I don't want to dwell too much on what's been said. I feel we did drift slightly into discussion of age limits and electoral systems, which we will come onto later on, I'm sure.

I thought this was an interesting discussion because it revealed fundamental differences of view about what the United Kingdom actually is as a country. Is it, as some seem to be saying, a collection of nations, a sort of mini-EU in itself, or is it, in fact, what it legally is, a unitary state which has devolved powers to devolved nations? And because it's the latter, because it has devolved powers to devolved nations, there must be a power for the Westminster Parliament to consider whether that settlement is correct in every detail. Of course, there can be variation, but it must be the role of the centre to ensure the variation is in the interests of the whole of the country, and not just a sectoral interest in one of the devolved nations. And I contend that's been the risk of devolving the franchise and the variation in that.

My Lords, my worry is that devolve and forget will one day become dissolve and forget, and I don't want that to happen, which is why this Parliament must remember it's a devolved country. It isn't a aggregate of nations that have voluntarily come together. I'm sure we'll come back to all those issues, but for now, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

04:29:15 - 04:29:42

Speaker 133

Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. Amendment six, Baroness Foster, not moved? Amendment seven, Lord Frost, not moved? The question is that clause two stand part of the bill.

As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content? The contents have it. In clause three, amendment eight, Lord Fuller.

04:29:42 - 04:37:59

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, it's a pleasure to lead this debate. I've got the first two amendments in the group, and firstly, turning to my number eight, it seems to me that registering to vote a year before the possibility of voting gives the election officials sufficient time to draw up the register at the annual canvass, plenty of time. It's not as if many will be able to vote on their 16th birthday, by arithmetic, that excitement will be restricted to just 1,917 youngsters, who can then celebrate by going down to the scrapyard on a moped to sell some metal, two of those rites of passages are permitted at that age alongside piercing, and opening a bank account without telling your mom. Now, I don't agree with votes at 16, and will not repeat the reasoning here, but if that's the proposal on the table, then registration at 15 seems to be quite sufficient. After all, we have an annual canvass for a reason.

Now, if there's anything in this if there's a theme to this bill as it relates to young voters, the government has failed to integrate these attainers, aged 14 and above, into the existing registration system. The propensity for these attainers to move around is much greater than for the older population. They turn schools, colleges, jobs and apprenticeships, while some leave home for the first time. So, my amendment number eight does not seek to fetter democracy or deny access to the vote to anybody, it's simply aimed at reducing the administrative burden of collating the register, and works along with the existing pattern of electoral registration and administration in this country, which leads me to my amendment number nine, which looks at the mechanics of how a person under 16 can, unambiguously, be identified and authenticated by the electoral registration officer before they actually come onto the register as attainers.

These youngsters may not have a passport, they certainly won't have a credit card, inevitably they won't pay an electric or council tax bill, or any tax for that matter, to identify themselves as perhaps you or I might. In the world as it is today, you register to vote by providing your National Insurance number. Whether you use the centralized online form on gov.uk, or download a paper copy or form issued by the local council, you need to provide your National Insurance number; if not, they want to know why. And that's because there's a secure, automatic authentication system that uniquely matches a person to a national to a National Insurance number across the HMRC, the DWP, and other databases. It protects the register's integrity, and in theory helps identify duplicate entries.

Even in Scotland, you need to give your National Insurance number, although helpfully you don't have if you don't have one, the ERO invites applicants to provide a utility bill. Call me old fashioned, but I don't know how many 14-year-olds pay the electricity bill, which is normally paid by their parents, but we'll put that to one side. So, if you can't supply an NI number, it triggers a complex and intrusive manual validation system. Local officers are working hard enough as it is, without more hand work, burdens being thrust upon them. I spoke to one electoral registration officer today, a returning officer in fact, and when somebody can't provide a National Insurance number as it is today, two hours over several weeks per person is the which may lead to an attestation in court, is what is needed to finally authenticate someone and validate their application to come on the register.

Put simply, the 14- or 15-year-olds who don't have this NI aren't going to be easily identifiable through the usual channels, because the young these youngsters don't have the normal set of identifiers. Now Google, summarizing the ONS census statistics, tells me there are 1.4 million 14- and 15-year-olds in the UK who'll be admitted to attain on their 16th birthday. Now, they don't have this NI number. So, these youngsters are in a bind. How are they going to prove their identity?

And the electoral registration officer isn't going to be any wiser after. There isn't just the standard administrative method. So, they're not going to have a driver's licence, only certain 16-year-olds will have a moped, they may not have a passport or gas bill as I've said. So, how do they prove their identity without reinventing the entire wheel of the administrative process that goes on in getting them onto the register? Now, consider the child from a broken home.

Perhaps he lives with mum in Acacia Avenue during the week, but with his dad in the city apartment at the weekend. I'm trying to prevent the introduction of duplicates onto the system. Now, most likely, and it is possible of course, the mum and dad live in two different electoral areas. The parents would think it was their duty to register their child, and not necessarily be forced to tell the other. And we've got the prospect of the automatic registration, perhaps by reference to the school roll the child might want to register himself.

After all, if he's trusted to choose a government, he ought to be capable of filling in the form. Now, in this example, there are two EROs, two addresses, possibly two different names, because some children will assume double-barrelled names, perhaps some of them would be relatives of the noble my noble friend the Baroness O'Neill. Is that with or without apostrophe?

Multiple registrations of youngsters isn't a possibility; it's a certainty. All these people looking after the interests of the little boy, falling over themselves to duplicate him on the register, and the ERO won't have a clue of how to weed out the duplicates. So I'm going to I want to know, and I'll ask that the noble lady the minister, who's going to be responsible for cases of double registration? Still worse, double voting by the child who didn't realize others were usurping him.

Without my amendment to change the rules to issue National Insurance numbers at 14, it's a ready excuse for ballot stuffing and family voting. Now, the impact assessment covers none of this, and it should. While streamlining voter registration using other government services might be possible for those over 18, it is fraught with difficulty for those under 16. Why didn't the assessment calculate, as I have done,

that just to register 14- and 15-year-olds is going to take 2,000 local government extra staff, just for this provision alone? So, we've got we've got an identifier already; it is the National Insurance number. My amendment proposes a review so the Government can consider reducing the age of issuance of NI numbers to the age of 14, under section 3, regulation 9 of the Social Security (Crediting and Treatment of Contributions and National Insurance Numbers) Regulations 2001— that's SI number 769 of that year.

It's an integral part of the voter system. No IT systems need to be changed; no new interfaces need to be created. It's the same system the ERO can use to dedupe this the surplus records. And critically, it will maintain the integrity of the register. And I call for a review because it's the integral part that will reduce dup duplicates and ensure confidence in the register.

And as I will explain in group 9, issuing National Insurance numbers will significantly simplify the muddle that Ofcom has got into in trying to identify youngsters for social media. Their proposals include four different methods that put regulators and parents in an impossible position. Let's sort it out. Let's issue the National Insurance numbers at 14, and if it helps the children themselves think more closely and carefully about the world of work, well, that can't do any harm either. I've said enough.

04:37:59 - 04:38:10

Speaker 133

I beg to move. Clause 3, page 3, line 15, leave out 14 and insert 15.

04:38:10 - 04:39:14

Christopher John Rennard

If we look at this group of amendments, I think we all have a duty to try and discern which of them might be considered to be motivated by partisan considerations. And my view is that amendment 8 in the name of the noble Lord Fuller, is simply about reducing the number of people who will be legally entitled to vote from being registered and therefore able to vote. And I cannot see how it can be anything other than partisan to reduce the number of people legally entitled to vote from being able to do so. Amendment 48 in the name of Baroness O'Neill of Bexley again seems to me to be a deliberate barrier to registering people who are legally entitled to vote from being able to do so because they won't be registered. And isn't that a partisan consideration?

And other amendments seek to block, or delay, or make the registration process weaker and less effective, and therefore I consider those amendments partisan. Now, my Lords, the amendments in my name—

04:39:14 - 04:39:59

Charles John Fuller

I cannot see how any of my proposals would be discriminatory in any way, shape, or form, because my provisions would provide that everybody would be given, not have to apply, be given a National Insurance number, except instead of 16, at 14, which is the age at which the government proposes these attainers would come onto the register.

There's nothing discriminatory, it's actually enabling, because what it does is get the state organized and individuals waiting to get that number so they can get on to the register. I'm sorry that the noble Lord has misdirected himself as to the effect of my proposals.

04:39:59 - 04:48:32

Christopher John Rennard

Well, the noble Lord's proposal is that to what I proposed in previous Parliaments, and his government resisted tooth and nail any suggestion about registering people at the point they got their National Insurance numbers. And my understanding of the noble Lord's amendment number eight is that rather than say you will begin the process at 14 and 15 year olds, you only started at 15, and surely that will mean less people being registered. But if I've misunderstood, I apologize. I'm concerned with the approach in general, and how I think amendments 49, 50, and 52 are all about improving the health of our democracy. Because democratic elections cannot fairly take place without people being registered to vote, and many groups of people legally entitled to vote are often not registered to vote under our current arrangements.

Now, when individual electoral registration was introduced, there were many of us who warned that without extra measures, millions of young people, students, and people who move home frequently would fall off the electoral rolls. Perhaps that was the intention of the proposal among some people. I believe that it was. I know that it was a great preoccupation of the now noble Lord Cameron, when he used to meet his deputy to discuss constitutional issues. He was determined to drive through this process, which actually, if it had been implemented as he intended, registration levels would have fallen from the level of the mid-80s to about 60% according to the Electoral Commission.

Now, the Electoral Commission briefing for this debate shows that as many as 8 million people legally entitled to vote are not correctly registered and therefore unlikely to be able to take part in the democratic process. The Commission says that it strongly supports the principles of what is commonly known as automatic voter registration, and is described in this bill as being registration without application. The problem that it seeks to address involves young people especially. The Commission's previous research indicated that whilst 95% of over 65 year olds are registered to vote, only about 65% of under 25 year olds are included on the voter lists. There are similar problems with people missing from the registers who rent privately or who come from diverse backgrounds.

My biggest concerns about the processes contained within the bill are how the plans for registration without application are going to take too long and the government is proceeding too cautiously. Too late to have many more people legally entitled to vote registered for the next election and too late for the next review of parliamentary constituency boundaries, which will draw on data from the 1st of December 2028. Hence my support for amendment 67 in the name of the Baroness Lister and my noble friend Lord Paddick and others. The first and most obvious way in which we can address the underrepresentation of young people is by registering them when they're notified of their National Insurance numbers.

The House of Lords Select Committee, which reviewed the impact of individual electoral registration, unanimously recommended that this be done. And I'm delighted that the principle had the support of the noble Lord Hayward, whose expertise is very widely regarded in this House. And when it came to debating the idea, during consideration of the Elections Bill on the 23rd of March 2022 at column 1058, the noble Baroness Hayman of Ullock, speaking from the opposition front bench, said and I quote: "People are already written to ahead of their 16th birthday with their National Insurance number. If we can do that, why can we not, at the same time, have an automatic registration to vote? We have the means to do it, so why do we not just get on with it?"

My Lords, that is the question that I ask today. A little later, I did win a partial victory on the issue when the noble Lord True, eventually accepted from the government benches that a reference to registering to vote could be made with the notification of National Insurance numbers. But, my Lords, it was a very unpressing reference. And the process should not now require specific application if the qualifications for registration are satisfied. That is the aim of my Amendment 50.

A second crucial point, at which we can get many more young people registered, is when many of them enter higher or further education. From the Labour front bench, the noble Baroness Lady Royall of Blaisdon championed the cause of registering students with her usual great skill and determination; that was during the passage of the Higher Education and Research Act 2017. The noble lady then demonstrated how easy it was and simple to have data-sharing agreements between higher education and further education providers and local registration officers. This would enable students to be enfranchised and help make their legal entitlement to vote a reality. So, we are trying again to have that principle adopted via Amendment 52.

Finally, my Lords, I want to speak to my Amendment 61. The issues of electoral registration and constituency boundaries are inextricably linked, although the tight drafting of this Bill means that we're not properly allowed to consider that link. But I would draw the attention of the government and others to this connection. There should be, in my view, consideration about how the measures in this Bill will change the data from which the electoral registers are drawn. The data will change as a result of measures in the Bill, and it will affect the process of revising the constituency boundaries, a process that will begin in two years.

The electoral registration data forms the building blocks from which Boundary Commissions must create constituencies. And they are obliged, under the rules, to create constituencies with a very narrow and inflexible margin of difference in the size of the electorates for each of those constituencies. A slight change to a single constituency's boundaries is likely to cause widespread disruption to many other constituencies, breaking them up into pieces. And the failure in the last series of Parliaments to address issues of the missing millions from electoral registers has distorted the map of constituencies. Millions of young people, private-sector tenants and people from diverse communities were left out from the registers.

We're now trying to address this. Whether this happened inadvertently or deliberately, the effect of the on the last boundary review was that many more constituencies were created that would be likely to vote Conservative, and fewer were created that would be less likely to vote Conservative. So registering many more of these groups will address that unfairness. So I think the Government must now consider if we need to allow the next boundary review to take more time, so it is able to work with the most accurate and complete electoral registers. Every year, according to the Government's impact assessment, registration levels will rise by around 1.7%, so I hope there will be time for the changes in this Bill to feed through to the next boundary review.

04:48:32 - 04:53:50

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, I'm delighted to move my Amendment 51. But I find myself almost wholly in agreement with Lord Rennard's last Amendment 61, although I'm bound to say that if the last boundary change was engineered to gerrymander a stonking Conservative victory, I have to say, rhetorically, how did that go? But seriously, I think there's a meeting of minds between himself and Lord Fuller, my noble friend Lord Fuller, on the issue of national insurance numbers and registration of younger people. And I do think there might be a consensus on that, and my noble friend made a very powerful and compelling argument for that particular age group. Now, if I can go back to also 61, I think the clauses 17 to 19 do give rise to long-term changes in electorate sizes, and the current obligations of the boundary commissioners do not really take into account what sizable changes will happen as a result of automatic voter registration or registration without application, and I think he's right to pinpoint that issue.

And it goes to the heart of my Amendment 51, which is to ensure that we proceed in an incremental way in if we are to have automatic voter registration, and not put a huge obligation on electoral registration officers. The Amendment 7 Sorry. Clause 17 is actually quite wide-ranging anyway, in terms of giving proactive powers to electoral registration officers to register people as they see fit. But the reason I am seeking to remove Commonwealth and Irish citizens is not because I don't think that they value the right to vote and the value ascribed to having the franchise, but I do believe that we should focus on the endemic problem that's that has been identified for many years under all parties, all governments, which is poor registration of younger people, and that happened under the coalition government, it's happened under the Labour government, and under Conservative administrations. And that seems to me the kernel of the issue that we need to be looking at here.

And I'm quite straightforward in saying that, as other countries do with their own citizens, I don't think we should be ashamed in this particular clause to prioritise British citizens.

And I do think that if we are if we do have limited resources we should do so. Now I can debate the situation with the Republic of Ireland and their voters, but it does seem an odd situation that you would not wish to prioritize your own citizens who have constitutional social, economic links that are stronger than some others, indeed, the citizens of a foreign country, albeit a very longstanding neighbor and friend of the United Kingdom, i.e. the Republic of Ireland. And that's what my amendment seeks to do. Under the current electoral law qualifying Commonwealth citizens and citizens of the Republic of Ireland can vote in parliamentary elections, qualifying means meeting normal age, residence, and registration requirements, and they will have permission to enter or remain in the United Kingdom. Specifically for your Lordships' House, this amendment would not change who is legally entitled to vote, however it would restrict who is automatically registered without an application to those with the strongest constitutional links to the UK.

This would reduce the risk of eligibility verification errors which would automatically registered individuals who are not legally eligible to vote. And it might be the case, for instance, those on technically non-qualifying visiting visas may very well be swept up in the system of automatic voter registration, and perhaps the minister might address and reassure the House what specific efforts the government are making to ensure that under automatic voter registration the correct people are registered. Additionally, the introduction of automatic verification is a novel and untested feature of the bill. This amendment seeks to ensure that it is introduced cautiously, to prevent accidental scope creep, and to ensure that its first implementation is thorough and effective, and only registering those with a genuine legal right to vote in UK parliamentary elections. So, for those reasons, my Lord, and time is of the essence, I'm delighted to propose amendment 51, and I also support the amendments in the name of my noble friend.

04:53:50 - 04:54:08

Speaker 134

My Lord. My Lords, as agreed by the usual channels, we need to move now to consider dinner break business. Whilst this is unusual mid-group, I, therefore, beg to move that the debate on this amendment eight, be adjourned, and we will return to it after the dinner break.

04:54:08 - 04:54:21

Speaker 133

The question is that the debate on amendment eight be now adjourned. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.

04:54:21 - 04:54:33

Speaker 135

My Lords, I beg to move that the House be resumed. We will not return to the bill before 20:09 to allow time for the dinner break.

04:54:33 - 04:56:08

Speaker 133

The question is that the House be resumed, and we will not return to the bill until 20:09. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, I'll take a short break now to allow noble Lords who may wish to do so to do so as quickly and quietly as possible, please.

Perhaps I should say very quickly next time. Repeat of a statement made in the House of Commons today, earned settlement, Lord Collins of Highbury.

04:56:08 - 05:10:44

Collins

My Lords, I will make a statement on the government's policy of earned settlement. A little over a month ago at Labour Party conference, the Home Secretary promised we would adopt a policy on this issue that is guided, above all, by fairness, fairness towards those who come here legally and play their part, and fairness towards British citizens already here, who should not be asked to bear a greater burden. It is the responsibility of the Home Secretary to ensure our migration system lives up to that ideal.

Doing so depends upon a contract between those who come and those already here. This country welcomes those who seek a new and better life within it, but I also know there's an expectation of those who do, that they will play their part, contribute to their community and become part of our national life. If we are to ask our fellow citizens to buy into a system of shared taxation and universal public services,

they must know that everyone is playing their part. Solidarity is the precondition for social justice. Creating a fair immigration system demands reform to settlement, the ability to live in this country forever. Settlement confers some of the most valuable rights that this country can offer.

With settlement, a migrant receives the right to free education, our NHS and, should they fall upon it, the welfare state. Until now settlement rights have come at five years, almost exclusively as a result of time spent in this country.

It has therefore been a right accrued with little expectation of responsibility. I do not believe this represents true fairness. Instead, I believe these considerable rights should come after responsibilities have been met, and a contribution has been made. Settlement should not be automatic.

It should be earned. Today, the Government publishes a policy called earned settlement. It ensures that the period someone must live in this country before they settle is determined by the contribution they have made. That starts by setting out clearly what we consider to be disqualifying criteria. Firstly,

a criminal record. Secondly, a failure to speak English to a high standard. And thirdly, any unpaid debt to the British taxpayer. And finally, a failure to have made three years of national insurance contributions.

This is the foundation of settlement, the non-negotiable expectations that we make on anyone who seeks to live here permanently. For those who clear these bars, settlement then varies based on the contribution made rather than simply time served. This contribution is judged crucially not just financially,

but also in terms of public services, public service. A five-year path will remain open to all higher earners on salaries over £50,000, and those who've contributed in health care and education, in professions like doctors, nurses, and teachers.

For those who make an exceptional contribution, even faster routes will be available. The highest rate taxpayers earning over 125,000 will, over the course of their lifetime, contribute 1.5 million. This funds the critical services that many, including the poorest in this country, rely upon. So, under these reforms, they will be able to apply for settlement after 3 years, as will those who arrive on our highest talent schemes. Everyone else will be placed on a 10-year path, including those earning less than 50,000.

Settlement will still be available to them; they will simply have to show a sustained contribution to this country, and they will be able to renew their existing temporary visas until that point. Conditionality runs both ways. Those who commit an immigration breach will see settlement push back to 20 years, while those who've claimed benefits must have had five continuous years without falling on the state before they make their application. A number of groups will see their path to settlement remain as today. These include Hong Kong British Nationals Overseas, members of our armed forces, those with a British connection, and those on legacy routes such as Windrush.

Before we finalise this policy, we took it to the country through a consultation. Over 200,000 people responded, and I thank them for doing so. Many of the responses were focused on one particular group, and that's social care workers. Between 2022 and 2025, 250,000 people and their dependants arrived on or switched into the social care route. They came at a time when the sector was under considerable pressure following the COVID-19 pandemic and the unique challenge of that moment.

It is also the case, however, that this route was abused. The last Conservative government may have talked of restoring control to our borders, but in truth, they lost control entirely. Never was this more obvious than when the shadow Home Secretary was an immigration minister in the Home Office. Delegations were sent across the country to encourage ever more businesses to sponsor foreign workers with little apparent interest in their suitability to do so. As a result, there was significant abuse of the care route, sometimes because of fraudulent and exploitative companies, and sometimes because individuals themselves came here knowing there was no job they could fill.

A fair solution must address both sides of this, recognising the service of those who cared for our sick and elderly at a time of immense national need, and also addressing the abuse that was present on this route. The government's solution does so in two ways.

Firstly, by providing a five-year path to settlement for care workers who lived up to the promise they made on coming to this country, worked hard and answered our call when we needed them. Those who earned £25,000 a year working in the social care sector, which was a condition of their visa, will therefore be able to settle on their existing five-year path. The second group, who have not fulfilled the conditions of their visa, represent about a quarter of those who came between 2022 and 2025, or switched into that route. We will offer them a second chance to make the contribution they came to this country to make. They will be able to apply for another five-year care visa, and they will not be tied to their old employer, allowing that those with rogue sponsors to break away from them.

The government have already stripped around 1,800 exploitative employers of their licences. And we are lifting standards in care with our fair pay agreement across the sector. The government will now help workers to find a new position with a legitimate provider and we will give them a longer period of time to do so before their existing visa is curtailed. There remain tens of thousands of legitimate vacancies in the care sector today, so those who seek a new job in care and have the requisite skills should be able to find one. At the completion of their new five-year visa, these workers will be able to apply for settlement once more.

Everyone will have a fair shot to make their contribution, and no one will be punished for the sins of their employer. But we will also preserve the critical element of this reform, that settlement must be linked to contribution. This same transitional arrangement will be applied to public sector workers in roles identified by the Migration Advisory Committee in healthcare and education, such as auxiliary nurses. This country has been highly dependent upon them, and their contribution will be recognized. These transitional arrangements apply to those who joined before this government published the Immigration White Paper in May 2025.

After that point, as our consultation shows, the government's position of a 10-year path to settlement was widely understood. These are exceptional exclusions for exceptional circumstances, and it remains the case that the rules around settlement are determined when settlement decision is made, not at the point when someone arrives. This is a position that is long established in this country, and it is one that has been tested conclusively in our courts. The responses to our consultation focused also on settlement rights for refugees and I know people of this country wish to continue welcoming genuine refugees. However, I also know there is nothing fair about allowing unsafe and illegal entry into this country.

It is not fair that our borders are run by people smugglers. It is not fair that women and children are dying in the channel. And it's not fair that after historic levels of illegal arrivals, British citizens are paying £4 billion a year to fund asylum support. So, as we open new safe and legal routes for genuine refugees, we must also discourage dangerous, unsafe and illegal crossings. Settlement plays a part in this.

We will place those who come to this country on one of our new safe and legal routes on a five-year path to settlement. This is as fast a path as higher earners entering the Britain today. At the same time, we will discourage the use of unsafe and illegal routes. The standard qualifying period for all refugees who have not come by a safe and legal route will become 20 years. A further 10 years will be added for those who entered the country by an illegal method, such as by small boat.

We do not, we do want to promote integration into this country for all those who are here. For that reason, those who enter work or study will be able to earn settlement 10 years earlier. This means a refugee who did not arrive by small boat, who is working or studying, could qualify for settlement after 10 years. Let us not forget, regardless of the question of settlement, for as long as a genuine refugee requires protection in this country, we will provide it. I know the British people's sense of fair play means they welcome refugees and those who seek to contribute to our society once they are here, but at the same time there is nothing fair about incentivising unsafe and illegal routes into this country, and I will not do that.

These reforms are the right thing to do, both morally and financially. While a full impact assessment will be completed and published as we implement the reforms, our changes ensure that those who are net contributors are encouraged to come to this country and stay here. Meanwhile, the cohort who are most likely to impose a cost at settlement must, instead, seek work and meet the conditions of their visa before they can apply. As a result, the Department for Work and Pensions estimates that our reforms will reduce the benefits bill by billions of pounds. This is a solution that is fair for those who come here legally and play their part, and fair to British citizens already here, who shot should not be asked to bear a greater burden.

Earned settlement institutes a new paradigm in our migration system, long overdue. That one of the greatest rights we can offer now depends on a contribution made and responsibilities met. The right to live in this country forever must now be earned. It will no longer be automatic. It is a fair settlement for all and, so, I commend this Statement to the House.

05:10:44 - 05:17:25

Byron Davies

My Lords, I thank the noble lord the minister for bringing the statement to your Lordships' House this evening and for the opportunity to ask questions on this statement. My Lords, it has been over a year since the government announced its plans to establish a, and I quote, "fairer pathway to settlement". The Home Secretary is to be commended for having the courage to stand up to the open borders advocates in her own party in proposing the original earned settlement plans. And I applauded those plans when they were announced last year, which, whilst being nowhere near strong enough, were at least a serious recognition of the scale of the problem and what needs to be done to solve it.

When the original policy was released, there were no exemptions to the earned settlement route, yet today we have heard from the Home Secre- we have heard the Home Secretary has caved in to pressure from those very same open-borders left-wingers on her Back Benches and indeed in the unions. The result of this climbdown is now over 250,000 low-wage care workers and their dependants will get to stay for a minimum of 10 years, with many getting settlement in five and almost 75% getting to stay in the country for ever. The costs of this reversal are significant. The Home Office's document released last year revealed that the median salaries for care workers on the health and care visa were between £23,000 and £26,000 in the financial year 23-24, which significantly is below the median full-time salary of £37,000. The OBR estimated that, as a result, they are likely to have a net negative fiscal and economic impact.

This is because the amount of tax they will pay will never cover the amount they will take out of the system in NHS costs, education costs if they have children, and welfare claims. It is the British taxpayer who will pay for this policy reversal; that is in no way fair. We have heard the arguments that this large cohort of migrants have contributed to our country and, as such, they seem to have automatically earned the right to stay, but of course, my Lords, many of them have not contributed, at least not fiscally or economically. The Home Office themselves estimated that the total cost of exempting care workers to be approximately £10 billion.

My Lords, if these workers intend to keep working in the sector, then I would have thought there should be no issue with having to wait 10 to 15 years, like everyone else. It is it only becomes an issue if they are using that sector as stepping stones to settlement and, ultimately, citizenship, and are frustrated at being made to wait to leave their care jobs. They responded to economic incentives, they were given the chance to come to the United Kingdom to work and they took it. They are exactly the same as all the other people who have come to our country on work visas. If the Government believe that it is only fair to require settlement to be earned, then it should be earned for everyone; exempting this subset of people creates a double standard.

And this is particularly true given that only 18% of those who responded to the Government's consultation were British citizens; 73% of respondents were current visa holders. And yet the Government seems to have taken their opinions to be representative of the entire country. Well, of course, people who are not British citizens would have negative views of the Government's original policy, because they are the beneficiaries of the current regime. Unfortunately, my Lords, we are now in a situation where our country's immigration policy is being decided based on the views of those who are not even British citizens.

Bizarrely, the Home Secretary even said, and I quote, "I know the people of this country wish to continue welcoming genuine refugees", unquote. We have a long history of generosity as a nation, whether that be towards Jewish refugees of the 1930s and 40s or to families fleeing Putin's illegal war in Ukraine, but, my Lords, I would suggest that most people, given the ongoing rate of illegal migration, do not support additional routes through which more refugees will come to Britain. We must get overall migration down before we even consider any loosening of our policy. But it seems to me that there are those in the Labour, and indeed the Liberal Democrat, parties who would have us believe that ever having had sorry, have us believe that ever having had a visa ought to give a person the permanent and irrevocable right to stay in the country, and this is not how the system works, nor is it how it ought to work.

Being granted a work visa, whether that be a skilled worker or health or care visa, is a privilege and not a right. Similarly, being granted indefinite leave to remain is a privilege, not a right. Just because a person has been allowed to come to the country does not mean they have the automatic right to stay here indefinitely. So I wholeheartedly agree with the Home Secretary when she said in her statement, and I quote, "settlement has therefore been a right accrued with little expectation of responsibility.

I do not believe this represents true fairness." End quote. The problem of course is that she has broken her own test with this climb-down, because now the Home Secretary's test of fairness applies to everyone but care workers, which is not fairness at all. My Lords, it says in the fairer pathway to citizens document that this is not about assimilation. I disagree.

Assimilation into British culture should be the minimum prerequisite for any settlement. And as my right honorable friend, the leader of the Opposition, has said completely correctly, we may be a multi-racial country, but we should not be a multicultural country. The so-called diversity of cultures is a recipe for disaster. A healthy society is built on trust, my Lords.

A shared culture is the underlying source of mutual understanding between groups of people who have no other way of relating to one another. It is in that way a source of trust. Without a single common national culture, and without the trust that flourishes from it, we risk undermining our future as a peaceful, harmonious, and functioning society. That is why the debate matters so much. It is not just the fiscal cost of the government's surrender on immigration, although that is significant,

it is the long-term social and cultural impacts that matter too. And on both these tests, the government has demonstrably failed. Hear.

05:17:25 - 05:23:39

Don Foster

My Lords, can I, too, thank the noble Lord, the Minister, for bringing the statement to the House? And he will know only too well how difficult and complicated issues around migration are. And I certainly saw that during deliberations of a report on immigration being put together by the Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee, which I have the honor to chair. And certainly not all members agreed with all of our final recommendations. But we were, of course, unanimous, as we are on these benches, wanting more action to tackle small boat crossings and the criminal gangs behind them.

And so we do welcome the plans for more safe and legal routes. But on these benches and among many of the committee, one of the greatest concerns about the original proposals from the government were plans to retrospectively change the rules for those already in the country. So we do welcome some of the announcements about retrospection in the statement, announcements which roll back from earlier plans. Whether they were brought about by our committee's report or by rebellions on the backbenches of the Labour Party within the Cabinet, I suppose we'll never know. But it is welcome, it is welcome, my Lords, that some social care workers, those earning 25,000 pounds a year, the BNO visa holders, members of the armed forces, the Windrush cohort, and others will now have no change to the time taken to get to ILR.

And there are other parts of the statement, taking family income in the round into account rather than individual incomes, which the committee proposed, taking maternity leave into account so that a dropped income during that period doesn't lengthen the time to ILR, and allowing children to cli- claim ILR with no rule changes. They're all, my Lords, welcome.

But there is, nevertheless, much to be concerned about. Can the noble Lord, the Minister, confirm that around half a million people will get settled later than planned, later than they were originally told and promised? Does the noble Lord, the Minister, accept that many migrants have made significant, long-term decisions, housing, jobs, children's education, and so on, with the expectation of acquiring ILR after five years? So, is extending their time retrospectively not a huge broken promise and what one which will make it much harder for people to settle and integrate if their certainty has been removed? And on income thresholds, the select committee pointed out that the planned income thresholds, which earn a reduction in qualifying time to ILR, are not linked to migrants' net fiscal impact, but instead are set at the higher and upper income tax rate thresholds.

As a result, some migrants who are net contributors to public finances would still be required to wait 10 years to acquire ILR. We argue that proposals should focus less on income and more on making a positive contribution. We argue that the income levels which lead to a reduction in ILR pathway should not be set according to income tax thresholds, but should be set on the advice of the Migration Advisory Committee. Can the noble Lord, the Minister, explain why the select committee's advice was ignored? Does he not recognise that by sticking with tax thresholds, it means that somebody in London and somebody in Gateshead can be doing exactly the same job, but one be on a five-year route and one be on a 10-year route?

Does the Minister really think that's fair? And there are other concerns about increasing the length to achieve ILR. First, will somebody facing a much longer ILR wait, not least those facing 30 years, do anything other than drop out into the shadow economy and simply stay out of touch with the Home Office? And secondly, what incentives are there to make efforts to integrate into our society? And the statement is absolutely silent about crucial issues around that issue of integration.

Requiring higher standard of English is all well and good and we support it, but what is the government doing to boost provision of English language tuition, which is very short of supply at the current time? What is it doing about changing the frankly appalling Life in Britain test, people's understanding about our country, when it has questions in the past that have included things like, what is the height of the London Eye? And finally, my Lords, I want to turn to the issue of people now being required to have no debt requirement, including repaying the cost of their asylum accommodation, which will be capped at £10,000. Now, we know, my Lords, that of those who are employed eight years after grant, 37% were in full-time work with a median earning of £23,000, with the internal analysis of published refugees integration outcomes database showing 40% earned at least the minimum wage. Now, my Lords, I would understand therefore that if somebody had £23,000 income, they could perhaps just about pay £100 a month back to the government.

I doubt that's realistic, but let's assume they could. If they could, it would take them eight years and four months to pay back the £10,000 debt. So, their ILR time would not be five years, but eight years and four months. And it's very easy to see how much longer it is likely to be. And what is the noble Lord's answer to those 60% who aren't earning even at the minimum wage?

My Lords, these are issues that simply are not fair.

We hope very much on these benches that the government will go away and think again before the final details are published next month.

05:23:39 - 05:29:25

Collins

Well, I thank noble Lords for their questions and contributions. And you know, I think I've pointed out before that what we are addressing here is a mess that was created by the previous government. And I don't want to be too partisan about it, but that is the simple fact. And when the noble Lord said noble Lord Davies says that either migration, I mean the simple fact is that we've already cut net migration by 82%. And now what we're doing is setting out a fair solution to the so-called Boris wave, fair to those who come here and play their part and fair to the British citizens who are already here.

So, I just want to make that absolutely point before I address some of the other questions. Today, the Home Secretary set out a total transformation of settlement, which is no longer automatic based on time served, but is now instead earned based on contribution to this country. And can I point out and noble Lord Foster has reminded us that we conducted a genuine consultation, and we have set out a fair response, fair to those people who came here and played their part and fair to the British citizens already here. The last government lost control of migration system. Settlement for those who came in those years will now be based on contribution and not just time served.

As a result of these reforms, as the noble Lord Foster has pointed out, over 500,000, we expect over 500,000 will settle later. And I think that has been a really important consideration. But as I said in the Home Secretary statement, we have made a determination that will be affected when people apply, and that has always been the case. So, there isn't a retrospection, but I think what we have understood and what the consultation has acknowledged is that the people who come came here and played a very necessary contribution in a period when this country faced a pandemic has been recognized, and that is really important. I think we have designed a settlement system that rewards those who contribute, that is better and less costly system than the one we inherited.

I think one of the figures that the noble Lord Davies referred to was the question of the 10 billion figure, which was if all social care visas were waved through, and this is not happening. We are setting a test that means that those most likely to claim will not be getting settlement at 5 years. As a result of our reforms, as I said, over 500,000 people will need to contribute more and wait longer before settling. And these transitional arrangements will see care workers who are in work are able to reach settlement at 5 years. Those who are not will have to apply for another 5-year visa and make the contribution they came here to make before they can apply again.

Until that point, they remain with no access to social housing or any other benefit, and DWP estimates savings in the billions to the welfare bill as a result of this policy.

So, my Lords, we've taken a fair approach to care workers. Those who've answered the previous government's call during COVID, worked in the sector and played their full part, will be able to settle after five years. Those who did not will be able to apply for a new five-year visa, making a to make that contribution themselves before they can apply again. Now, the noble Lord said that there, the noble Lord Foster, made the point about education, and I think the Home Secretary in the other place made clear that we are consulting with all government departments, particularly the Education Secretary, to ensure that availability of education support for the English language is there, and we are committed to do that. And our response will be, in terms of the implementation of this programme, will be to work on an all, cross-Whitehall basis to ensure that we have a joined-up approach, and we will ensure that applies.

We have made settlement based on contribution, not just on time served, as it was under the last government. We have cut net migration by 82% below its peak under them, but we will not leave young British people behind, which is why, again, point addressed by the noble Lord Foster, which is why we are investing an additional 2.5 billion to support almost 1 million young people into education, employment and training. My Lords, this is about getting a system that is fair, and it is a fair system that ensures that we can have the confidence of the British people, something, I'm afraid, we did not see under the 14 14 years of the last government.

05:29:25 - 05:30:37

Speaker 83

My Lords, while I, like the noble Lord Foster, welcome the compromises in the statement, I fear it will not reassure most of those migrant workers who have emailed me expressing anxiety, anguish and bitter disappointment at the retrospective measures they consider unfair, having come to this country in good faith, only for the goal posts to be moved. Nor will it reassure refugees seeking asylum and sanctuary in this country, and organisations like the Refugee Council, Coram, have expressed real concern about the implications for refugees and their children. But may I ask my noble friend the Minister why the promised impact assessments will not be published until actual implementation, too late to be of use? And can he tell me what assessment has been made of the measures' impact on the government's strategies to reduce child poverty and homelessness, and to strengthen integration, a point raised by the noble Lord Foster?

05:30:37 - 05:32:06

Collins

Well, I think the Home Secretary in the other place addressed those latter points that she made, and I think we are committed to work with the DWP. But can I just say to her that in terms of the consultation that we conducted, as the noble Lord Davies, pointed out, many of those who responded to that consultation were visa holders, and actually, they were actually quite happy with the proposals in terms of earned settlement. They recognised that as part of their commitment in coming to work in this country. And can I just say that we will continue to protect refugees, as long as protection is needed? Those who come on the UK settlement resettlement scheme, or sponsored safe and legal routes, will qualify after five years.

And it is right that we seek to disincentivise illegal entry into this country, such as by small boats. And the first stage of implementation will begin in December immigration rules, taking effect in January 2027.

Further immigration rule changes will come in 2027 and 2028. Further technical detail and a full impact assessment will be published before implementation, informed by continued engagement with affected groups and stakeholders.

05:32:06 - 05:32:41

Martyn Snow

Bishop. My Lords, at the government's own admission, some 500,000 people will take longer to be able to get indefinite leave to remain. That's 500,000 people who will be living with uncertainty in many cases for a very long period of time, up to 30 years. I wonder if the noble Lord the Minister can reassure us that the impact assessment will take account of that uncertainty and, in particular, its effect on social cohesion and integration into this country.

05:32:41 - 05:34:03

Collins

Well, I think there are two parts of that question. I just believe, and I think the Home Secretary made it clear, that, you know, it settlement gives people rights. I mean, when people come here for a visa, they work, and they comply with the conditions of that visa. And if they wish to have settled status, what we are now saying is that they have to it's not just simply a time-served arrangement.

They have to meet those commitments. But can I just say to the right reverend prelate that, you know, we are committed to, and I spoke in debates last week about this, about how we can establish safe and legal routes. I mean, we are talking today about settled status, but we do have a broader policy that is going to address, as I've pointed out, in terms of the net immigration into this country, net migration. We do need to have a very clear policy about what people are expected to do when they wish to stay here permanently. I don't think it's unreasonable.

I think the consultation reflected that, and most of the people on visas understood that.

05:34:03 - 05:35:16

Natalie Bennett

My question relates specifically to the refugees arriving through irregular routes who now face a 30-year settlement time. Some of those will be women fleeing the Taliban. Some of them will be those who I shared a room with last week as we commemorated the first anniversary of the awful massacre in El Fasher. Sudanese who share ties of history, language, family with us and, when they were forced to flee, came here, and no other route was available to them but irregular routes. Now, the Law Society has said that this 30-year rule, in its judgment, contravenes the 1951 refugee convention to which we, of course, have long been signatories.

The UK under that promised to help those coming to our country to seek protection to integrate and build a new life. Thirty years is going to be, if you're lucky, half of your adult life. So, my question to the noble Lord the Minister is: how can you possibly justify this under the refugee convention?

05:35:16 - 05:36:41

Collins

Well, I can and I will, and I think the Home Secretary has made that clear in the other place. But, you know, settlement for refugees will encourage safe and legal routes and promote integration while discouraging the use of unsafe and illegal routes.

And I think the Home Secretary is right to point out, you know, it's absolutely appalling that people and children, women and children have suffered death as a consequence of trying those illegal routes on boats. So, we're absolutely looking at policies that discourage that. Refugees on safe and legal routes will qualify after five years. That is the incentive side of this policy. All other refugees will qualify after 20 years, though there will be a 10-year discount for entering work or study.

So again, people making a contribution. Those who came by small boat will receive 10-year additional wait to discourage those dangerous and illegal crossings. So, it's not simply about sort of saying a 30-year wait for refugees. What we're doing is adopting a policy that will secure refugees' future properly.

05:36:41 - 05:37:52

Claire Fox

The noble Lord, the Minister, maybe look at that question slightly differently. Is the message to people arriving illegally on small boats, migrants: If you come to the UK, you can stay here for 30 years, not work or study, and at the end of that 30 years, you'll be given leave to remain, and in the meantime, you will have been living off the generosity of the British taxpayers and the welfare system and so on? So, could he clarify why that's a disincentive? And just quickly, secondly, last year, when the Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, launched her reforms, and I'm one of her fans, she said that migration was unaffordable and it was immoral to carry on, and she was very clear and very firm about those reforms. She's backed down on those reforms now.

Why? Isn't that, therefore, saying that we now are going to have to be able to afford what we can't afford and that, somehow, she's been forced to accommodate on her morality of last year?

05:37:52 - 05:39:13

Collins

I don't think the Home Secretary has compromised one bit. What she has announced today is a settled status that actually includes a range of contributions. I also and she made clear at the introduction of her policy that there were disqualifications to being able to earn settled status. But I think the noble lady does conflate issues. You know, there are people who have genuine asylum claims and they are properly assessed, and those people will have their status understood through the conventions that we are signed up to.

That is the country we are. We value those things. And when I had a debate last week, you know, we were talking about Ukrainian refugees that have come in here. Most of them want to return to their own country. There are many other refugees that come here that we've given protection to who also want to return to their country.

But the idea that everyone is a freeloader, I just do not accept. And that's why the system that we are in putting in place is one that recognises their contribution, whether it be work or study.

05:39:13 - 05:40:14

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, since there's time, my other question refers to the other end of the scale. I was talking about refugees' 30 years.

These are three years to settlement for the highest rate taxpayers earning over £125,000 per year. Now, I note that for the before the Budget, Bloomberg reported what was a very clear trial balloon being floated, suggesting the Government might bring back golden visas, those that thoroughly discredited scheme by which money launderers, corrupt people, criminals came into the UK, something that's very widely acknowledged. Now, of course, very rich people could easily arrange to pay themselves a large sum of money over 3 years, and then they would have got a very fast route into the UK.

What's the Government going to do to make sure that this is not another open door for the kind of people that we allowed into our country that helped to give us the label of London laundromat?

05:40:14 - 05:41:25

Collins

Well, fortunately, my noble friend who is sitting next to me is the Minister for fraud, and he's just spent a week, actually, in showing that we collaborate internationally on dressing the issue of fraud. But what this scheme is about is you know, and I we talked about higher tax uh payers uh the tax brackets, but it isn't the only contribution, but they have a net contribution over a period, so they earn that right for settlement. And you know, it is not about wealthy people buying visas. They come here to do very important work, you know, whether it be in our sciences or in other research areas.

We're not talking about, you know, oligarchs; we're talking about people who make a contribution to the United Kingdom's economy. And that contribution, through their earnings, will be recognized in terms of the ability to seek settled status, earn it. It's not about buying it.

05:41:25 - 05:41:40

Ilora Finlay

My Lords, I think it is time for the House to be again in committee on the Representation of the People Bill. Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

05:41:40 - 05:41:48

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I beg to move the House to, once again, remove itself into a committee of the whole House.

05:41:48 - 05:42:17

Ilora Finlay

The question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content. The contents have it. My Lords, will now resume the debate on Amendment 8.

05:42:17 - 05:47:49

Speaker 83

My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 59 and 67 in my name. Amendment 67 requires publication of a plan for the implementation of registration without application, and Amendment 59 requires two government databases to be in use for such registration ahead of the 2029 general election. I'm grateful to the noble Lord Rennard, the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle for their support, and now also to the noble Lord Rennard. I very much welcome the Government's commitment to improving voter registration, which chimes with public opinion as, according to the Electoral Reform Society, a YouGov poll found that four-fifths of the electorate support automatic registration, almost half strongly so.

As the explanatory notes to the bill note, in 2023, the Electoral Commission reported that an estimated 7 to 8 million eligible citizens were either incorrectly registered or not registered at all. IPPR have pointed out that young people, renters, working-class and minority ethnic citizens are more likely to be unregistered and that electoral turnout is shrinking, particularly among younger, lower-income and renter populations. Registration is as crucial to achieving greater political equality, a point emphasized also by Generation Rent.

We compare badly with other countries, as in most liberal democracies forms of automatic or assisted voter registration are the norm. And research in 159 countries by the Electoral Integrity Project at the University of East Anglia shows that it has led to more accurate and complete electoral registration. The project also found that at the 2024 general election, four-fifths of poll workers turned away citizens because they were not registered. Although it was usually only a handful of people, a few workers reported turning away over a hundred. The UEA academics, together with Generation Rent and Unlock Democracy, criticize the absence of any timetable for the introduction of automatic registration.

This is what Amendment 67, with the assistance of Unlock Democracy, would supply through the introduction of a clear implementation plan, while Amendment 59 helps to inject an element of urgency. The amendments would help to meet the aspiration of the Electoral Commission, which, in emphasizing the importance of complete and accurate registers to democratic participation, has urged, I quote, "the Government to work quickly to introduce automated systems to enable voters to be added to UK parliamentary electoral registers in time for the next general election." Amendment 59 takes up their suggestion that this could be built on existing services, such as applying for a passport, updating a driving licence, or receiving a National Insurance number at 16, which has been referred to earlier. The Government's election strategy, published in July 2025, made it clear that it was planning to deliver significant voter registration improvements, including registration without application, in this Parliament.

Yet the briefing on this year's King's Speech suggested that implementation during this Parliament is now unlikely. Where is the sense of urgency, when as many as 7 or 8 million of our fellow citizens could remain excluded from full democratic engagement without automatic registration? These amendments would help to inject it, by ensuring a suitably ambitious implementation plan. I quite understand the need to pilot arrangements, but we can learn from others such as Wales, which, with more limited resources, will have their system of automated registration ready for May 2027, despite becoming law less than two years ago. And there will be no compromise when it comes to security and accuracy, as no voter will be registered without the standard checks carried out by the electoral registration officers, as now.

The EROs would have much better and more reliable data to work with. According to Unlock Democracy, the Electoral Commission, leading academics, and international experts all believe automated registration using some government databases, as proposed by Amendment 59, is deliverable within two years. Florence Eshalomi MP was sponsoring a timeline amendment to the Bill before her promotion to ministerial office. A commitment to a timeline of or plan of some kind would represent an important statement of intent on the part of the Government. If automated registration is not in place by the time of the next election, it could be as long as 2034 before it took effect for a general election.

How many of our fellow citizens would be effectively disenfranchised in the meantime?

My Lords, these amendments are designed to support the Government's goals. I hope therefore that even if my noble friend the Minister cannot accept them, she will give a commitment to bring forward a timetable herself, preferably before report stage, so that noble Lords can consider it.

05:47:49 - 05:49:41

Speaker 97

My Lords, I agree with the point my noble friend makes about urgency, but I rise very briefly to support Amendment 52, to which I have added my name and it is virtually the same as an amendment which I moved to the Higher Education and Research Bill, as the noble Lord Rennard said, in 2017. At the time, my amendment was it went through, it was adopted at report stage. I then had negotiations with the Government and I agreed to a compromise, the compromise being rather weaker than my amendment had been in the first place. The compromise was to introduce guidance to ensure that there was that electoral officers were encouraged to share data with universities so that students could easily be registered, thus maximising the number of young people voting and also ensuring that students could also vote when an election took place during term time.

I know that many universities or some universities, this hap- happens whereby students are automatically registered or semi-automatically registered when they register at university, but it's certainly not happening in every university, and I think it should be mandatory in every university, hence my support for this amendment. I have one question for my noble friend the Minister in terms of automatic registration. When automatic registration comes in, does it mean that a student, for example, would automatically be registered both at their home and in their university? They've got the option to vote either/or, and I think it's important that they should be registered as soon as possible in both places.

05:49:41 - 05:56:20

Mark McInnes

My Lords, I want to rise to speak to my Amendment 47. Through this amendment, I am seeking safeguards that would require the verification of nationality and immigration status before an individual is automatically added to the electoral register. I fully recognise and uphold the importance of ensuring that every person who is legally entitled to vote should have the uninterrupted opportunity to register and to participate fully in our democratic process. That is a fundamental right and has long distinguished us internationally. There is an equally important principle, however, which I fear risks being overlooked in this bill, that only those who are legally entitled to vote should be entered onto the electoral register in the first place.

And I fear, my Lords, that, left unamended, this part of the bill weakens the integrity of the elections. For currently, Clause 17 in the bill introduces a significant change to our electoral arrangements and would place a duty upon electoral registration officers to register individuals automatically where certain conditions are met, without those individuals having to make an application to register themselves. While I recognise that there could be a potential administrative benefit in this, it is for your Lordships to ask whether the safeguards accompanying this fundamental change are robust enough, especially when it comes to establishing nationality and immigration status.

The Government, in presenting Clause 17, are attempting to allow for the modernisation of the system, and I welcome that. But I caution that modernisation must never come at the expense of electoral integrity, and that operational convenience must never take precedence over establishing voter eligibility.

Therefore, through this amendment, I am seeking to introduce an additional safeguard that will require an electoral registration officer to positively verify that a person satisfies the relevant nationality requirements and, where applicable, the necessary immigration status before that person is registered. The parliamentary franchise rightly extends to Irish citizens, together with qualifying Commonwealth citizens. Different nationality and residency requirements apply to other elections. An individual immigration status may determine whether they qualify for that registration. A person, for example, may be lawfully resident in the United Kingdom in employment, paying taxes and accessing public services, without necessarily being entitled to vote in a particular election.

That is not a criticism of the individual. It is simply a recognition that lawful residence and electoral entitlement are not the same thing. It is precisely why we must make sure this bill distinguishes itself between verifying someone's identity and their electoral eligibility. A government database may confirm somebody's name, address, and date of birth. A National Insurance number may assist in establishing identity.

But neither, by itself, necessarily establishes nationality or entitlement. I have tabled this amendment as I am concerned that, as government moves towards an automated system, we risk treating the existence of an administrative record as sufficient evidence of electoral eligibility. Indeed, my Lords, the Electoral Commission has itself emphasised that the success of registration will depend entirely upon the accuracy and reliability of the underlying data so that only eligible individuals are registered. Having been around the upper echelons of government and local government through much of my adult life, I must confess that an unquestioning faith in the accuracy of government-held data is something I have not been able to acquire. There is this is not to question the dedication of many officials who maintain the system, but what my experience over the years has taught me is that our systems are far from infallible.

My Lords, I also appreciate the responsibilities already placed upon the electoral registration officers. They have a mammoth task of maintaining the accuracy and completeness of the registers, often against a background of considerable administrative and financial pressure caused by local government funding. My amendment is not intended to place further obstacles in their path. Quite the opposite. It would establish a statutory requirement, supported by prescribed evidence or information lawfully obtained from public authorities.

My Lords, I would therefore be grateful if the Minister could address three questions. First, what arrangements would exist to distinguish between a person's identity and their legal entitlement to vote when records are obtained from government departments and other public bodies? Secondly, will electoral registration officers have timely access to the information necessary to verify immigration status whether it where it is relevant, and who will bear the administrative cost? Thirdly, what safeguards will prevent an individual from being entered on to a register for an election in which they are not legally entitled to participate? I put it to your Lordships that these are not constitutional niceties.

These are the questions that go to the very heart of public confidence in our electoral system. And we must remember that confidence in our elections depend not upon ensuring that the legitimate voters are included, but also upon ensuring that the rules governing eligibility are properly and consistently enforced. The right to vote is fundamental in our democracy and it can't be and it's too important to be established by assumption. If the government is determined to automate registration, then it must also be determined to guarantee the integrity of the process. I hope therefore the minister will recognise the importance of this distinction and give consideration to the safeguard I have proposed.

05:56:20 - 05:58:25

Claire Fox

Lords, I think the motivation by Lord Udny-Lister was very important, and in fact it relates also to the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough's comments earlier on amendment 51 just in terms of absolutely ensuring that eligibility is strictly adhered to. There can be nothing more destructive of democratic trust than believing that there is anyone fast playing fast and loose with who is allowed to vote in an election. And we've just sat through a statement about the new immigration status and the various degrees of it that was incredibly complicated. That will have to be taken into account in terms of eligibility and we have to be confident the system can cope with it. In that spirit, I thought that the noble Lord Fuller had done us a real favour earlier when he talked about the nuts and bolts of specifically how we deal with the fact that children will now be voting inasmuch as they will not necessarily have at their fingertips the usual adult forms of ID as he illustrated rather wittily and very well.

And I was rather disappointed that the noble Lord Rennard was so cynical that he saw that these comments were somehow partisan. In fact, I thought that cynicism by the noble Lord Rennard was itself rather partisan rather than anything else because I think it's really important that if you are going to extend the franchise in the way that we've been discussing, that we ensure that franchise is strictly and absolutely foolproof and safe-worthy. Because one of the things that the noble Lord Rennard said was surely we want as many people to vote as possible. Well, in that sense you could just carry on expanding the franchise ever younger, but you could also just say anybody who happens to be wandering in can have a... Oh.

05:58:25 - 05:58:40

Christopher John Rennard

If the noble Lady would give way just for a second. I was absolutely crystal clear and what I was saying is all those people legally entitled to vote. Legally entitled is very important and a part of the principle of everything I have argued for.

05:58:40 - 06:00:56

Claire Fox

Clarification understood. Then I would refer the noble Lord to consider that the noble Lord Fuller was trying to ensure that people who are entitled to vote were checked up upon. The accusation was that he was somehow trying to limit the franchise by only allowing, and that was I was defending him in relation to that point. Moving on. Actually, I wanted to ask the noble Lady the minister, and I know it relates to a government amendment that was in an earlier group, but I we've kind of run out of time, but it does relate to this, which is, registration officers are now going to have to obtain information about, or are going to be given the right to obtain information about 14 and 15 year olds throughout the land and to retain that information for use when inviting them to then register to vote.

I thought the point about governments' history, any government, not making a sectarian point, history of looking after data and keeping it safe was a point worth noting there, especially children's data, if it's being gathered up. But could the noble Baroness explain in relation to those register registration officers collecting that data, then how that, whether there will be some consideration of the noble Lord Fuller's suggestion of using national insurance numbers? I thought that was a really good one. And I'm really asking the government if they're open to detailed discussions on the nuts and bolts of how we're going to make this work, both in relation to immigration status and in relation to the expanded franchise for young 16-year-olds. Will there be an opportunity, or is there plans to really ensure that this is water-tight?

Because just to reiterate, if people believe that elections are happening, but are not safe in terms of people being able to vote who are not strictly checked on or registered, then it will undermine democracy, and I know that is the very opposite of what the government aim to do.

06:00:56 - 06:02:43

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, I rise very briefly, having signed three amendments in this group: 52, 59, and 67. And all of these address the issue of the missing millions, a phrase that's been used multiple times in this debate, and that is a real scar on our polity, and a reflection of inequality in our society, and inequality in access to participation in the democratic process. Just very briefly on 52, I have to commend the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, for her previous work in this area. And really, it's time we saw this finally nailed on, which is what this amendment does. But I just want to focus particularly on the two amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Lister.

And I think we really suffer, we have a great deal of distrust in our politics comes from the fact that we have seen a great deal of successive governments' ministers getting up and saying, "Look, I've pulled a lever," and everyone knew that lever was not attached to anything. Promises were made and not delivered. And just two cases that particularly come to my mind: sustainable urban drainage systems promised in planning, still not delivered;

a promise to exclude at least illegal deforestation from the supply chain, again still not delivered. We need to see not just the government making promises, but the government setting out a reasonable timeframe for delivery. And as the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, said, Wales is showing that it can be done, which is an interesting cross-reference to our earlier debate of the ways in which the devolved nations can be a real model from which England can learn and save itself a great deal of work and effort by seeing what works and just copying it.

06:02:43 - 06:10:04

Anne Thérèse Coffey

My Lords, I have put down a general Clause stand part, Clause 17 stand part. And it's about trying to understand the pros and cons of automatic voter enrollment. So, right at the last election, we had 48.2 million. About 3 million people registered in about the month beforehand when the election happened. So, that's about 7%, but it's about 4,500 person per constituency on average, I'm sure it differed.

I mean candidly, that included the person who's now the MP for South Suffolk Coastal who defeated me, who managed to declare themselves to be resident in that constituency before they were actually on the electoral roll. So, there's something here about how do we get the real authenticity of people registering. And that's where I'm getting into the pros and cons. There's a lot to be said for not having a huge rush at the last moment of what is going on in terms of people registering.

But there's also something about getting it right. Now, I'm conscious that the pilots that happened in Wales, we saw something like between 2 and 8% increase through the automatic process. And admittedly, it was only a handful of parts of Wales that were covered, but basically 14,500 people were added on through the automatic process. And there was a lot of manual checking. I don't know the cost of that.

The Electoral Commission said I think it needs to be evaluated on really how much that was costing. But I think it's worthwhile trying to get a sense of what happens in a regular process actually around the country where people have second homes. When you're applying in the normal way, actually a lot of people of those second home owners get turned down because it's not their principal residence. And I'm actually I'm actually discussing students and children at boarding school in a different set of amendments, so I won't get into that right now in detail. But on the broader scale, thinking that in the I think the review after the last election was an estimated anywhere between 7 and 8 million had not registered, were not people had not registered.

There is actually already a law in this country that people are supposed to register, and the councils, if they so wish, can pursue them with a fine of £1,000 per person having not registered. Now, I'm not suggesting that councils are going to start trying to generate lots of money, although it feels like a lot of money could be generated, if that was the case, in those councils, but to think about how we do this in a sensible way. And that's why I think there's an element of over ambition, it's not overambition, but how accurate is it going to be? Now, other amendments have talked about DWP issuing information to other to electoral registration officers. I think the amendment where it refers to those that have been issued in the last year to be sent on is fine.

Actually, HMRC is responsible for having the National Insurance database. They're the guardian of it overall. What happens with DWP is linked to what happens. And those people, by the way, who've not claimed child benefit, for example, that doesn't happen. You end up going through a manual process of trying to get your NINO.

But the broader point here is coming back to accuracy. And that leads on to, so what's going to happen if we suddenly have this huge expansion of the electorate about who's actually really entitled to vote in that place? And I think research has shown it's often people who've moved during the year and may end up being registered in more than one place becomes an issue. How does this get resolved? How does it get resolved that what's supposed to happen is that it's your principal place of where you live, when it comes to parliamentary voting anyway, is where the only place you're allowed to be registered?

And this is very strict guidance, actually, from government and also from the Electoral Commission that this is the case for local registration officers. My concern is that what often happens with a rush at the end is none of that is gone through. So we end up having a lot of people registering in places where if they'd registered in normal time, actually their registration may have been turned down because it wasn't their principal place of residence. So there is a risk of over-inflating the electorate, and what does that then mean for consideration of constituency boundaries?

I think it's Cities of London and Westminster, I think another one is Leeds Headingley, and, of course, these often match up to university towns and places of transience where people may move, okay, things may change after the renter reform that, but I think this is something the government really needs to think through. I'd be grateful to hear from the minister what lessons it has learned from the Welsh Government pilots,

what, how it intends to do accuracy, forgive me, I've got some questions on my phone, which I'm just locating now. But, I think there's a case here of rushing to an outcome which actually, instead of improving democracy, could significantly undermine it.

So, I'd be grateful, as I say, to hear from the minister on what it is that they are doing to manage the risks, as well as big up the benefits. What guarantees will prevent personal information supplied to HMRC, DWP or DVLA, for example, from being disclosed to the electoral register? Who bears legal responsibility if somebody is incorrectly registered, or, indeed, omitted,

or, indeed, registered at an address where they're not actually entitled to vote? And will automatically-created registrations at secondary addresses be excluded from constituency electorate calculations, where appropriate? I think most importantly of all, what level of erroneous registration would the government consider acceptable? How will they measure that,

and how will they address it? This is why I think, on the surface, it may seem very convenient to have automatic voter registration, but when we're talking about the integrity and ultimately deciding who forms a parliamentary constituency, who forms a government, I think, actually, a lot more detail needs to be had than what we have in this bill today.

06:10:04 - 06:17:56

Robert Hayward

My Lords, can I follow on from my noble friend's comments just now? And it picks up this question that Baroness Royall referred to earlier, which is this question of at least double, if not treble, registration. Baroness Royall said that she hoped that all universities and academic centres will ensure that they have the maximum list, maximum registration of people resident in that town or city as voters. But those people will have a home residence, as well.

And, therefore, what one's actually doing is inflating the electoral roll in university cities to the disadvantage of those communities in other parts of the country which do not have university cities nearby. Lord Rennard made reference to boundary reviews, and he also made reference to political advantage.

Well, I must admit, I admire him enormously in his comments about parliamentary boundaries in these circumstances, cuz the places which will, under automatic registration with the likes of high levels of student registration, the areas that will benefit are the big cities, the Londons, the Manchesters, the Birminghams. As he explained to his Lib Dem colleagues in the likes of Wiltshire and Somerset that, come the next boundary review, actually, there'll be fewer constituencies in Somerset, and Wiltshire, and Dorset, and the other similar counties, like Gloucestershire,

a fair number of whom, much to my chagrin, currently have rather large numbers of Liberal Democrat MPs. But I make the point quite seriously that if one is going to include all those people who register for a second residence, you will be expanding the electoral rolls quite dramatically in London and Manchester and Birmingham, to the disadvantage of the shire counties. And I do not think that's an appropriate route to go. I do think there may be solutions where people register their first home, and the second residence is not included, for example, for parliamentary boundary revision. But we cannot have a position whereby large numbers of people are registered to the disadvantage of resident communities in the neighboring shire counties.

Now, I make these comments on the basis that I've heard from a number of people, and particularly including the Liberal Democrats, that they want free and fair elections. Well, free elections is that people should be allowed to register to vote themselves: encouraged, yes, but they should have the freedom not to do so. Now, the bill goes through an inordinate great length of saying, "Oh, well, we'll register everybody, and if you don't want to be on the electoral roll, you can deregister." But it is a pretty tortuous process involved, and will large numbers of people who genuinely want to hide where they are for a whole series of reasons, and we I say take, for example, abused women as a case in point,

they're going to be on the electoral roll, and it won't be a case of, "Oh, we'll take you off immediately," because the people won't know that they're on until they're notified that they're on. Which takes me to another point, which is we've got to register all these people so that we can improve turnout. Well, actually, might it not be a good idea if politicians, and I include ourselves in that category, and those in the other chamber, improved their reputation with the public at large, so that those people wanted to turn out to vote? Talking of which, the government actually has a very good website where you can register to vote. I could walk out of this chamber now and register immediately.

People might wonder whether I haven't got something better to do on Saturday evening, but I actually went on the site, and what astonished me was that 54 people had registered in the last few minutes. I challenge noble Lords to go on Christmas Day, they will be astonished how many people actually register to vote on Christmas Day and Boxing Day. It is not that difficult. Baroness Coffey made the reference just now to in an election period 2.8 million people registered to vote, 2.8, 2.9, just between the two.

The problem there is that actually some 40% of those people were already registered. One thing that we haven't done, I think, very much so far today is praise, played enough,

paid enough credit to both the Public Bill Office here in the House of Lords for the speed with which they've drafted our amendments and ordered them, but also the day-to-day work of returning officers around the country. I shall return to this subject at a later point, but they do a phenomenal job.

And during an election where you have 2.8 million people registering extra to vote, which, as I say, seems to show that it's not that difficult to do it. And by the way, if all these students who are moving off to university are so unable to go onto a website, I have a serious doubt that some of them should actually be at university in the first place. But the burden

of the 40% of the people who registered at the last election who were double registered, imposed an enormous burden on the returning officers. I have asked over and over again

that we should move to a read-only access process. In other words, that if Robert Hayward wants to check whether he's on the electoral roll, he just goes on the website, has a password and can check that he is there.

Instead of which, because governments of all persuasions have refused to introduce a read-only system, we impose a burden on returning officers, which is unacceptable at the time of an election when they are trying to administer all sorts of other things. And it's not difficult.

We've been told by government and by officials over and over again, it's an expensive and difficult process. Is it? Local authorities, I give way.

06:17:56 - 06:18:53

Charles John Fuller

I think you've highlighted very correctly, my noble friend, how the process actually works. If you go on the gov. website and so many of the district councils, who are, or the other local councils, who are registration authorities, have their own skin on that same machine. When you type in your name and you put your date of birth and your national insurance number,

the system goes automatically to the HMRC and the DWP to validate you before you've even pressed the button. They will validate you almost immediately. And I think the point you're making, which is absolutely the correct point, is having this unique identifier, the national insurance number or some other method that might be defined by regulations, gives an absolutely unambiguous way of determining whether you've got a duplication or not.

06:18:53 - 06:20:29

Robert Hayward

I thank my noble friend for his slightly longer intervention than I'd hoped for since I want to keep to my time. But as I say, it's it, there is a system. We were told it's impossible. But what have the Northern Irish done? The Northern Irish introduced a system of read-only and they've done it themselves

without any problem,

And it operates effectively in Northern Ireland. So massive changes, what I believe are unnecessary changes, yes, advertise. And I am, I say, massive changes without great benefit. And I'm quoting here now from the impact assessment, to which I may return on another occasion. But on page 101, it says: "We assume that the completeness of registers will increase by 3 percentage points, from 85.9 to 88.9 by the end of a ten-year period."

We're going through all these changes for that? And just in conclusion, I must pick up Lord Rennard on his comments earlier on about my support for automatic registration. I believed that I have made absolutely clear that I support it for attainers, whatever they may happen to be, whatever age, because I want to introduce them to the democratic system. Thereafter, I do not support automatic registration for that very small gain.

06:20:29 - 06:27:50

Speaker 127

My Lords, I think we've heard two interesting, contrasting themes in this group, from some of us who are very keen on automatic voter registration and want to see it introduced sooner and better, and those who are nervous about the potential implications of automatic voter registration. So I think it's worth starting with a little recap of the reasons why something like automatic voter registration is required, particularly as Lord Hayward very eloquently put, as it were, the case against in many respects. Partly, I think it's because making good use of data is, when done well, an effective way of improving services and reducing administrative burdens. And indeed, it's worth contrasting how a registration process would start under AVR with the current system, because as several noble Lords have expressed concerns about how, you know, a database may result in registrations flowing from that data, but remember under the current system, anyone can request and be sent a paper form that they can fill in without having to provide a National Insurance number, and that, under our existing system, is enough to start the process rolling for registration. So actually relying on, if we are relying on the right, good quality data sets, is a much more secure starting point than anyone being able to request a paper form that anyone could fill in.

And I think it's also worth bearing in mind that just the whole way the current system works, I think was very well described by one of the sort of international experts in elections which we're lucky to have in this country, Professor Toby James, who called it a Victorian system in need of repair. And I think the this bill's efforts to repair that are very welcome. And a good example of that is this very surge in registration applications that we typically have in the run up to a general election, because the Electoral Commission's latest research estimated that between seven and eight million people are either missing from the electoral register or registered at the wrong address. So there is a substantial problem that needs addressing. And we've heard how in the run up to a general election, like for example at last time there was a surge of nearly 3 million applications.

As rightly pointed out, many of those were in fact duplicate applications. So when you strip those out from the numbers, and compare that to the seven or eight million missing and wrong addresses on the register, even that general election surge isn't really getting us that far towards fixing the problem. So action is needed. Now of course we shouldn't therefore think that any action is therefore wise, but I hope therefore we will hear positive noises from the Government, particularly on amendments 49, 50 and 52 from Lords Rennard and Wallace and Baronesses Thornhill, Royall and Bennett, all of which in different ways would improve the supply of data into the system. There's also my amendment 58, to provide ward level data, which I think is important, particularly actually with local government reorganisation increasing the size of many councils, council level data doesn't, won't really tell us how well or how badly registration systems are working in future.

We need that data at ward level. We need it to understand how the system's working. We need it for researchers and experts to work out figure out, are the promises being delivered? We need it for the campaigners of all parties and none who are in some ways trying to improve involvement and engagement with democracy to be able to see where their efforts are most needed. And we need it for media, and indeed us politicians to be able to understand how systems are working.

Turning to some of the other amendments in this group, amendment number eight from Lord Fuller. I must admit, I'm not convinced by the case that the noble lord made, because under the current system with a voting age of 18, we register attainers some age 16 and most age 17. So, the current system is that some people who are 2 years below the age for voting do get registered as attainers. And that's because of the use of the 1st of December cutoff date in the following one-year window, which means some people may be more than 1 year away and need to be in the records. So if we're changing 18 to 16, it seems to me absolutely sensible that 17 and 16 in turn also get reduced by 2 years to 15 and 14.

And therefore actually I think Lord Fuller's amendment with respect would achieve the opposite of what he argued for, because we have an existing system that is well established that people are used to using, that works, and by reducing the years across the board, we are essentially transferring the existing system over to the new voting age, rather than creating a new system that wouldn't work with that 1st of December window and following 12-month period. But I certainly think Lord Fuller made some good points on his amendment nine, and indeed, I hope it'll be interesting to hear what the noble lady the minister has to say on how we can best ensure that the right data is available, because I think it's fair to say what we've heard from the government so far on how data from educational institutions may be used is not yet fully fleshed out in huge levels of detail. I should also just touch on amendments 47, 51, and 62, all of which in different ways express, dare I say it, a slight fear of what might happen with automatic voter registration, and wanting to put in extra safeguards for particular groups. But again, I would make that contrast with how the existing system works where anyone can request the form where you're not required to provide a National Insurance number, and for myself at least, I think therefore the case is not made that actually a system based on data run by someone else is somehow less secure than the current system and therefore needs those additional safeguards targeting particular groups. And I think the key thing therefore is not just to get AVR introduced and introduced well, but for this not to be something that is some very slow-moving long-running process.

I think we all hope that AVR will be in place before HS2 gets completed. And therefore if I turn to amendments 59 and 67, one of which is in my name and which both these Baronesses Lister and Bennett have spoken to, I think it is important for there to be a little bit of pressure on the government to move at a reasonable speed, not a reckless speed, but a reasonable pace, particularly as Lord Rennard has pointed out, and indeed Lord agreed with Lord Rennard on at least this point, we do have at some point parliamentary boundary reviews coming, and part of the very logic for automatic voter registration in terms of improving the register is about improving that core basic data that parliamentary boundary reviews have to use. And therefore it is important that we have that data in as good a state as possible by the time we next get the parliamentary boundary reviews.

So I very much look forward to hearing what the noble lady, the minister, has to say on that topic.

06:27:50 - 06:27:56

Speaker 146

Hear. Well said.

06:27:56 - 06:31:08

Speaker 116

My Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 48 and 63 in my name and my noble friend Lord Jamieson, and to address the wider concerns raised by amendments in this group. The fundamental question before us is not whether electoral registration should be accessible, of course it should be. It's whether the government's proposals for automatic registration will maintain the accuracy and the integrity of the electoral register as a number of colleagues have referenced tonight. Individual electoral registration was introduced to ensure that people were properly identified and that responsibility for registration rested with the individual.

Some areas have been particularly successful in ensuring a good level of registration. The government now propose to move away from that principle without having demonstrated that automatic registration will provide equivalent safeguards. Therefore, amendment 48 would require a person's existence to be verified against three separate data sets before they are automatically registered. My noble friend, Lord Fuller, referenced my own surname earlier on and the variance that you can get in different registers. Some databases don't acknowledge apostrophes.

They certainly can't cope with two capital letters allied one another. And therefore, you know, for a fairly simple name, as I would think it, you will get different variations coming out. So, I think that it's really important to recognise that not all databases are the same. It's a modest safeguard against what's a substantial change. Government databases do contain errors,

and this is particularly prevalent in areas with high population turnover, including student accommodation and the private rented sector, and could possibly lead to postal and proxy voter fraud. The noble lady Royall earlier on referenced students at university. You're absolutely right. Can you go one step further, would it be the university building or would it be the halls of residence or wherever their accommodation is?

So, you've got a number of different variants there that could cause issues. And an inaccurate register is not simply an administrative inconvenience. It creates an unnecessary risk for the integrity of the entire voting process. There's a possibility that certain parts of the electorate could vote twice in the same election by virtue of having two different registered addresses or indeed even more. In short, this bill creates unnecessary risks for the integrity of the polling process.

06:31:08 - 06:34:16

Speaker 114

Therefore, can the noble Baroness the minister tell us precisely which databases will be used for automatic registration? How will their accuracy be assessed? And why does the government consider verification through fewer than three independent data sets sufficient?

The EROs we believe should have access to database information, and I'll also agree with my noble friend, Lord Hayward, that the EROs are certainly professions that should be called out for their professionalism, but also their amount of service, and I think that's worth putting on the record. Most importantly, will electoral registration officers retain the discretion to refuse automatic voter registration where necessary? For example, if information is incomplete or indeed contradictory, as I've said earlier. I turn now to Amendment 63, which would make clear that the proposed voter registration pilot powers cannot be used to alter the franchise for the parliamentary or English local elections. There's an important distinc- distinction between determining how an eligible person is registered and determining who's entitled to vote.

The latter should be decided through primary legislation and full parliamentary scrutiny, not merely through powers designed to test administrative arrangements. Will the noble Baroness the Minister confirm that these pilots will not extend or alter voter voting eligibility? If automatic registration is introduced in some areas and not in others, registration figures may cease to be comparable and then arbitrarily are based on some parts of the population. Does this not seek to prioritise some parts of the population over others, test only their opinion rather than the whole electorate? This could distort the 2029 parliamentary boundary review and the 2028 mayoral elections.

Can the Government guarantee that pilot locations and selection criteria will be published and that their effects independently evaluated? I welcome my noble friend, Lord Leicester's, amendment which rightly seeks to address the verification of nationality and immigration status. That is essential. Possession of a National Insurance number or inclusion in a government database does not in itself establish your entitlement to vote. The rules governing qualifying Commonwealth and EU citizens are not straightforward, and an automated system must be capable of applying them correctly.

06:34:16 - 06:34:49

Speaker 116

Can the noble Baroness the Minister explain what steps the Government are taking to ensure that checks will be undertaken against Home Office records before an individual is registered? And who will be accountable when an ineligible person is added? Will it be the Secretary of State? These questions are echoed by my noble friend Lord Jackson who proposes that an automatic registration should be restricted to British citizens. There are practical concerns.

06:34:49 - 06:37:22

Speaker 114

Does the noble Baroness accept this, and will she consider these sensible amendments? Moreover, my noble friend Lord Fuller highlights that if votes are introduced at 16, then younger voters who are registered at 15 will not meet the National Insurance criteria. Can the noble Baroness the Minister tell us how their identity will be verified where national Insurance information is unavailable? He referenced the manual in- intervention required and how many hours extra work that might need for validation.

The amendments concerning implementation tables, information sharing and independent assessment also deserve careful consideration. The government's own impact assessment anticipates only a limited improvement in register completeness over the se- over several years, whilst significant costs associated with the necessary computer system remains uncertain. Can the noble Baroness the minister provide an estimate of the full costs to the local authorities, including software, staff training, data checking and correcting erroneous entries? Who will bear those costs?

I appreciate the noble Baroness may not have all the answers with her today, so I would accept a response in writing. My Lords, the objective should not simply be to produce a larger electoral register. A register containing more names with the risk of more errors does not represent progress. Administrative convenience should not take precedence over a proper determination of electoral eh eligibility. Amendments 48 and 63 seek to establish two essential protections:

reliable verification before automatic registration, and a clear constitutional limit on the use of pilot powers. I hope the minister will address these concerns in detail because public confidence in our elections depends not only on participation, but on the integrity of the system through which the participation takes place.

06:37:22 - 06:42:06

Speaker 148

My Lords, it's been a really useful debate. A lot of technical questions, I will do my best to get through all of them, but I'll start with Amendment 8 and 9, which would change the age at which individuals can register to vote to 15 and change the age at which national insurance numbers are issued.

My Lords, we will all agree that no young person should miss the opportunity to participate in a election for the first time because there was insufficient time to be correctly re- registered to vote. By extending the age of registration to 14, this two-year window of registration ahead of turning 16 also allows for the enhanced links between the classroom and active engagement in our democracy, beginning with the act of registering to vote. I recognise the noble Lord's concern that 14 and 15 year olds will not yet have their national insurance numbers. I understand the issue at 15 years and nine months. But national insurance numbers are automatically allocated to most young people in the UK before the age of 16.

This age is set in line with the age at which young people become liable to pay national insurance contributions and the creation of an adult taxpayer record. And let me reassure the House that we will put in place an alternative mechanism using central government data in England to ensure 14 and 15-year-olds are able to proceed effectively through the registration service. I hope therefore that the noble Lord can withdraw his amendments. On Amendment 47, I share the determination that only those who are eligible should be registered, and I reassure the House that, as set out in the bill, EROs must be satisfied that the person is entitled to be registered to vote before they are re- before they are registered,

with an application that includes assurances that they hold eligible nationality and, where relevant, immigration and have where relevant, immigration status. What data will the government use as part of the measures to improve voter registration?

I think Lord Udny-Lister mentioned this. As set out in the Government's policy paper, A Blueprint for a Modern Digital Government, technology presents us with the opportunity to improve the way that Government delivers for the public, and in line with this vision, our ambition is to transform our electoral registration system, enabling EROs to use data that is available to them to move towards an automated system, so voters can easily register to vote and keep their registration details updated. We're exploring if Government data could also help identify people who may not be registered, and we are working closely with the Information Commissioner's Office to ensure that appropriate safeguards are going to be in place. Electoral registration officers are responsible for determining eligibility for direct registration. They must be satisfied that a person is entitled to be registered before adding them to the register.

If the available evidence is insufficient, an ERO should not issue a notice of direct registration, and the ERO will be held responsible for that. We are considering carefully with the election administration sector which data sources electoral registration officers will be able to use to provide evidence of entitlement. Further detail will be set out in secondary legislation under the affirmative procedure in guidance. Electoral registration officers already have powers to seek further information or documentary evidence where they are not satisfied as to the person's nationality or immigration status. They may also request that a person's immigration status is checked against Home Office records, and we are working with the Home Office on this at the moment in detail.

Amendment 48 would require an electoral registration officer to verify a person's existence through three separate databases data sets, sorry, before they could be registered without an application. And I share uh and I share the noble lady and noble Lord's commitment to ensuring that only those who are eligible are added to the electoral register. However, I do not believe that this amendment is necessary. Under the provisions in the bill, an ERO must only directly register someone where they are satisfied that the person is entitled to be registered. The Government does not consider it appropriate to specify in legislation a minimum number of data sets that should be used to determine someone's existence.

06:42:06 - 06:42:09

Speaker 147

The Yeah.

06:42:09 - 06:42:21

Anne Thérèse Coffey

Because the Electoral Commission in its evaluation of the Welsh government's pilots, said that it should be a minimum of two databases, so I'm just interested to hear why they haven't taken at least notice of what the Electoral Commission has to say.

06:42:21 - 06:44:32

Speaker 148

Basically what we're saying here is that the that uh that we don't want to legislate for a minimum number of data sets that should be used to determine someone's existence. The level of assurance provided by data set will depend on its quality and the information it contains. In some cases, one or two robust data sets may provide sufficient evidence that individuals are entitled to be registered, but others may not. Requiring EROs to consult additional data sets in every case could therefore impose unnecessary administrative burdens without improving confidence in the outcome. I hope this assurance shows uh the House that the Government is fully committed to maintaining the integrity of the electoral register, and that they will feel able to withdraw their amendments.

Amendment 49: My Lords, I welcome the intention behind Amendment 49. The Government is committed to work together work towards making better use of data across Government for registration purposes, but we do not believe that creating a new obligation for the Department of Work and Pensions is necessary or would achieve the desired outcome.

We intend to utilize the powers in the bill to make regulations to facilitate the sharing of data between government bodies and assist EROs in carrying out their functions on the basis of agreed data-sharing arrangements. As part of this, we are exploring the use of DWP data. The MHCLG already has a successful agreement in place with the DWP to check the identity of individuals applying to register to vote, and we are exploring the potential to make greater use of DWP data for registration purposes. However, we know that the DWP's database, including National Insurance data, does not hold all the data required to determine eligibility for registration; therefore, we could not solely rely on the D- DWP data. For those reasons, it does not think we The government does not think this proposal is the right way forward.

Turning Sorry.

06:44:32 - 06:45:50

Gerard James Jamieson

Sorry, I'm Just purely to help with my understanding as we go through this, because we're talking about auto-enrolment, auto-registration, which effectively means that we have an electronic system which will review a series of databases and will then throw out, right, Fred Smith should be eligible to vote in this area. Now, very ordered to do that, you are going to have to program the system, and the guidelines will be within the system. It can't be up to the electoral registration officer to just have a whole throat- lot of data thrown at them, which they then have to manually trawl through.

So, I Not necessarily to answer today, it would be quite helpful to have a flow chart of how you envisage the auto-enrolment working with the data coming in, and what the system will throw out, that the electoral returning officer will then have to review, because you make comments if the electoral returning officer is not certain, well, he can only be certain, or she, sorry, based on the information fed into the database and fed out. So, I'm I appreciate all the statements he's made, but that sort of flow-through, I find a little hard, and I think it would be very helpful for members of the House if they had that guidance and flow-through of the system.

06:45:50 - 06:55:46

Speaker 148

No, this is The guidance is something that we are working on, but at the same time, we're going to set off with a whole series of pilots to work out what works, what doesn't work, how we can improve it. And if you look at other countries, such as Canada, for example, they started this whole process in the 1990s for auto- for automatic enrolment, and they're improving the system all the time. And at the end of the day, if there is a problem with the ERO can make the final decision if he thinks that the information that he's going to base decisions on is not accurate enough. Turning to Amendment 50, we have explored the possibility of using the occasion of issuing of National Insurance numbers to teenagers when they're approaching their 16th birthday as an opportunity to register them to vote. However, I understand that nationality is not routinely recorded against all entries in the DW data.

In addition, not all young people are on the DW- D DWP database, for example, due to having been in care, or their parents have not even applied for child benefit. In line with the powers proposed in the bill, individuals will also need to be of voting age, which for reserved elections is currently 18 and soon to be 16, before they could be added to the register without submitting an application once the relevant provisions are in effect. For these reasons, while sympathetic to their intentions, the government has serious concerns for this approach the effect of this approach. Amendment 51 prevents non-British citizens who are eligible to register to vote from being registered without an application or their entry altered without an application. Amendment 62 also seeks to extend this exclusion to any pilots of registration without application.

The government has no plans to change the eligibility criteria for who can register to vote in reserved elections. We also do not think it would be fair to establish an automated voter registration system in which some eligible citizens cannot be directly registered or their details directly updated. Amendment 52, to require higher and further education providers in England to share data with electoral registration officers to enable young electors to be registered. This government is committed to supporting more universities and college students to be registered to vote. Under the powers in the bill, we plan to test registration without an application using locally available data in a number of areas around the UK.

The Electoral Commission will then review the effectiveness of the new approaches tested. As part of this, electoral registration officers will be able to enter into data-sharing agreements with higher and further education providers in their local area so as to identify eligible individuals who are unregistered or have moved. Further detail will be set out in secondary legislation and in guidance, and I hope that provides reassurance to noble Lords. Clause 17 stand part, the debate we had on that, I know that Baroness Coffey and noble Lord Hayward intend to oppose that clause 17 stand part of the bill. Voter registration is core to our democratic system.

It is right that changes to voter registration are carefully scrutinised and assessed. Direct registration, alongside other measures, will support the objective of improving the completeness and accuracy of electoral registration. Together with clause 18, which will create a new duty for EROs to update people's personal details in the electoral register when they are aware that these have changed, these changes have the potential to reduce the estimated seven to eight million people who are unregistered or inaccurately registered, which is a figure that has been used more than once during the debates this afternoon and this evening. Direct registration also has the long-term potential to reduce burdens on EROs, who should need to spend less time following up with individuals who have not responded to invitations to register to vote. In using data for direct registration, EROs must be assured that the person is eligible to be registered to vote.

Those who will be directly registered will be informed and have the right to opt out of the process during a response period. Particular categories of electors, like anonymous electors, will also be exempt. I hope noble Lords will be reassured that direct registration will at first be tested in pilots in a number of areas. This will be in different locations and settings with different characteristics and challenges. We are working with the Electoral Commission to develop the assessment criteria and ensure a wide range of different areas can participate.

I appreciate the interest the noble Baroness and others in voter registration, and I recognise the importance of getting this right. This bill and secondary legislation will play the will lay the foundations for more automated voting registration in safe and responsible ways. Amendment 58, I recognise the intention behind the amendment, which is seeking to promote transparency around the operation of the electoral registration system. It is in support of that objective that substantial information on voter registration is already made publicly available.

Noble Lords may be aware that the public may easily access information on registration applications at the online Register to Vote performance dashboard. These arrangements already provide a significant degree of transparency regarding applications to register to vote. While recognising that applications are determined by registration officers who are statutorily responsible for maintaining the register for the area for which they are responsible. The amendment would also permit the publication of information at ward level. However the Secretary of State does not hold registration data at that level of granularity and would therefore not be able to publish information envisaged by the amendment.

Amendment 59th, I welcome Baroness Lister and Bennett's enthusiastic support for the cause of automated voter registration. And I would like to reassure noble Lords that the Government is committed to moving to more automated registration, and we are putting the necessary foundations in place through this bill. And I can assure the House that the officials are working closely with counterparts at the Home Office, the passport office, DWP and the HMRC to explore data sharing in support of more automated organised registration. However, these are extremely complex new approaches, and we will need to be certain we have the right arrangements in place, and that we have tested those very robustly before they are rolled out widely.

Setting a firm deadline in primary legislation before we can be certain that we will be ready would not, in my view, be the best way to secure the progress that we all wish to see. On Amendment 61, our plans for voter registration without applications are about making registration simpler and easier. These are significant reforms, and we need to test them to ensure we get them right. We are pilots will commence soon after the necessary legislation is in effect. The Electoral Commission will undertake an independent review to inform decisions about wider implementation, so there will be a significant degree of external evaluation of the new approach.

The boundary commission for England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland are independent of Government. The timings of parliamentary boundary reviews are set by legislation which the Government has no plans to change. Amendment 61's commitment to ensuring all eligible voters can participate and are appropriately represented in our democratic process is one I share, but I do not believe a further independent review is needed. And I'll turn to Amendment 63, if the concern is that these powers could be used to alter who is entitled to register and vote, I can assure the House that this is not the case.

Clause 20 of the bill creates a new power for the Secretary of State to make regulations to pilot changes to the voter registration process. Those powers are carefully defined and are limited to what the bill describes as voter registration provision. The bill goes on to make clear what falls within that definition what falls within that definition in clause 21. It is made clear that this is limited to provision about registering individuals who are entitled under existing franchise eligibility criteria to be registered. It also allows for existing register entries to be amended or removed.

Crucially, they do not provide a mechanism to alter the eligibility criteria for registration. Amendment 67 would require the Secretary of State to publish a plan for implementing Part 2 of the bill within 2 months of this part of the bill coming into force.

I agree and share their goals that we must move as fast as possible. I'm sure that the House will welcome the news that more information about the direct registration pilots was will be published shortly. This will include further information about how the pilots will work in practice and the prospective timetable. I'm further pleased to reassure

06:55:46 - 06:56:08

Robert Hayward

the two pilots, and I ask this question out of genuine ignorance, I'm not trying to make a point, could he please provide us with details about the level of accuracy that the Northern Ireland register now has given that their process of read-only access has been in operation for some two years, I think, now, please?

06:56:08 - 06:56:49

Speaker 148

Well, that's not to hand, to be fair. But I think perhaps that we will look into that and get back to the noble lord. I'm pleased to reassure the noble lords that our plan is for secondary legislation on the direct registration pilots to be introduced quickly after the bill comes to force, into force. Under the bill, there's a statutory requirement for the Electoral Commission to evaluate the effectiveness of the pilots after they've finished. And with that, I would like to thank noble lords for the spirit and intentions of their amendments, and I hope that this information

06:56:49 - 06:57:29

Christopher John Rennard

I understand, if I just may, I'm just trying to get in my mind why it is that the things which he and his colleagues support in opposition in terms of automatic voter registration are not now considered so practical. I note his point that the DWP data is not suffic- sufficient in itself to include somebody on the electoral register. But under the present arrangements, you either online or by paper give your name, your address, and your National Insurance number, and hey presto, you're registered. So I'm not quite sure that's such a barrier now. But if it is a barrier, surely the only bit of data required is to confirm that they are a UK citizen.

06:56:49 - 06:56:49

Speaker 148

Sorry.

06:57:29 - 06:57:59

Christopher John Rennard

And since the government must know who is a UK citizen, if you have the name, you have the address, you have the National Insurance number, and you know they're a UK citizen, you should simply put people on the electoral register. And to help him answer the questions he's been asked about costs, this will be a great cost-saving exercise compared to many forms being sent out in the expensive post, all the printing costs, et cetera, and human beings having to go around door to do this. We could cut costs considerably if we speeded this up.

06:57:59 - 06:58:35

Speaker 148

The thing that we want to do is to get this right and obviously to keep costs down to a minimum. We've said that we're looking very extensively with all the database that we have offer from the Passport Office, DVLA, HMRC and as well as the DWP. And we just want to get this right. And my assessment of this is not straightforward. It can be difficult.

But we want to make it as efficient as possible because it will save money in the long run if we have an automated system that delivers what we want to see, which is a vibrant democracy.

06:58:35 - 06:58:44

Speaker 153

If the minister was able to look at some of the questions that I asked, which I don't think he's had the chance to answer, and could write to me on that basis?

06:58:44 - 06:58:49

Speaker 152

Be more than happy to do that.

06:58:49 - 07:00:55

Charles John Fuller

Lords, it is late, so I will be brief, especially as the new guidance in the Companion tells me to be so. I was confused by my noble colleague Lord Rennard in the debate when he first of all stood up to excoriate me, and then his Amendment 50 proposed something the same. So, but nevertheless and no hard feelings, which is why I've moved towards him because I sense that we are on one on the national insurance issue. Now I am concerned in the winding by the Minister, because what has become clear for the first time is that so much of the foundations of the democracy that our society depends on is to be left to secondary legislation.

"Don't worry, it's going to be all right." I heard no reassurance from the dispatch box how we're going to deal with the 14 and 15 year old attainers, although I listened carefully to what he said about everybody else. And he's placing impossible burdens on the electoral registration officers. And I do suggest that not only does he need to spend time with them, but possibly with some of the participants in this debate, because it's clear and I in danger of sounding like Lord Rooker now, there was clearly no consideration given in the other place, and this is the House of Lords at its best. I'm really concerned there are all the unintended consequences here, whether it be by identification as my noble friend Lord Jackson said on immigration status, I'm really concerned about the number of duplicates, and the different spellings of the name O'Neill for example, and is that one L or two?

What is the role of the Electoral Commission, and we're going to deal with some of these then. But ultimately, it's the integrity of the register we need to be concerned about. And I really hope that the minister will commit here and now to having a follow-up meeting on a cross-party basis from those who participate in this meeting so we can thrash this out, because what we've got up until now is a recipe for disaster at report unless there is more clarification given. I beg leave to remove.

07:00:55 - 07:01:06

Richard Faulkner

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that amendment eight be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question is that clause 3 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

07:01:07 - 07:01:20

Richard Faulkner

Contrary not content. The contents have it. After clause 3, amendment 9, Lord Fuller not moved. The question is that clauses 4 to 6 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

07:01:21 - 07:01:28

Richard Faulkner

Contrary not content. The contents have it. In schedule 1, amendment 10, Baroness Coffey.

07:01:28 - 07:07:40

Anne Thérèse Coffey

My Lords, I beg to move amendment 10. I'll also be speaking to amendment 11, and then I've also got a more general stand part on schedule 1. My Lords, actually that last debate was really fascinating, and I've heard it already said, why are unelected peers interested about elections when we don't get elected to this place? Well of course we care, because we care about democracy. And I know several peers are also elected as councillors and other legislatures, and indeed we are concerned to try and make sure that we get this right.

Now just building on from the previous debate and I appreciate that the minister said he would look through and then write to me on various matters. The reason is I did have a response to a question basically saying the centre the government doesn't hold all these different things so they can't effectively know whether people are misregistering or voting in more than one place and the like. And to some extent, they should. But an important thing is, as has just been articulated, is making sure that the electoral register is correct and authentic. And that's why, in this particular schedule, I've raised my concerns, in particular, about in it's on page 129 of the bill for people looking, and it's paragraph 4 to 6, and then, on the following page, paragraph 11.

And indeed, I will be referring to more broadly an amendment that we've just passed or due to pass we've already debated, which is amendment 12, and in particular on that, I'm looking which is page 5, 21, subsection 3. So, where I'm going with this is that we need to make sure that the register is as is authentic as possible.

And yet, the government has said for safeguarding reasons it's blocking out the fact that lots of canvassing can't be done if somebody's under the age of 16. And, my Lords, I do understand the issues that hold more broadly about that, but it is the government's desire to introduce voting at the age of 16 in all the elections across the United Kingdom and it's specially reserved, and therefore I think we do need to make sure that the people going on that electoral roll are genuine. And that is the whole point of canvass. And canvass has largely focused on actually households that don't return the registration. So, that's the principle role of what canvassers do.

I don't mean canvassers as in party political canvassers, it's actually people working on behalf of the electoral registration officer to try and get as complete a register as possible. But it's also to check and validate about people who are in that residence and who have registered to vote. Now, at the moment it's not clear to me quite how soon we'll be in a situation where the automatic registration will have happened based on our current debate, but it feels that it will be possible for people to register, young people to register far more quickly, and who knows when the next election will be. So, that is why I don't understand why it is that the government is ruling out the opportunity for a registration officer to make house-to-house inquiries in regards to somebody who's put themselves forward to become registered on the electoral roll simply because they're under the age of 16. Now, I'm conscious that there are plenty of vulnerable people who are on the electoral roll.

People of no fixed abode, anonymous electors, there's a whole series of people who could be seen to be deemed vulnerable. And I do understand the broader point, but I would've hoped that electoral registration officers and the people they employ should be trusted to deal with such sensitive or, indeed, if necessary, turn this into a regulated activity that means that it becomes eligible for a DBS check because this comes back to integrity of the electoral roll. That's why I think the canvass should be included. I'm not so focused so much on to be open with you paragraph 5 or to be open with the House, rather. But I am more concerned about a requirement under subsection (4) may not be imposed on a person under the age of 16 in relation to registration.

I am concerned about the fact that may not authorise or require a registration officer to take steps in relation to register parliamentary electors in visiting a particular address in order to speak to a person under the age of 16. And I'm particularly concerned by the new amendment G12 with 21 subsection (3), so it doesn't include the power to make inquiries. So, the answer really is why not? Why is it that something as precious as having the opportunity to vote in a general election does not come with an opportunity for that to be validated? This is something that really does concern me about how people get added to the electoral roll.

The whole point of the registration officer is they have to be satisfied. We've heard that extensively in the last debate, and now all of a sudden we're expected to be taking somebody's word for it that XYZ is just can be added to the electoral roll without any validation whatsoever if they are purporting to be of that age.

07:07:40 - 07:07:48

Speaker 158

So, my question to the government is: why?

07:07:48 - 07:08:01

Richard Faulkner

Amendment proposed: Schedule 1, page 129, line 16, leave out paragraphs 4 to 6.

07:08:01 - 07:15:39

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, I rise to amend to move the amendments or three amendments in my name. To the first two, amendment 124 and 128 are essentially probing amendments. The final one is, I think a one of much more significance and import in terms of protecting the integrity of our current electoral system. And I'll elucidate on that a little later. I'll be as quick as I can.

In terms of Amendment 124, this is about the commencement of counting at local elections. It's been a bugbear for a number of us over the years that there has been an increasing tendency for returning officers to delay the commencement of counting, particularly in local government elections, until the following day. Now, in some cases it's understandable when you have a very significant local election such as the Greater London Authority and the election of directly elected mayor to for London, a world city of 9 million people, it probably does take longer to put the arrangements in place. But most recently at the May 2026 local elections, only 46 out of 136 local authorities were scheduled to count and declare results overnight. We've talked about the size of the country.

The UK is a relatively small country. We're not talking about the sort of Australian-style parliamentary seat, which is the equivalent of the length or width of three countries. We're talking about relatively small geographical areas for which to collect ballot boxes from polling places. This amendment would bring consistency and timeliness to the electoral counting process, helping to restore voters' confidence in that process. It's not an unrealistic proposal.

At general elections, the law already requires that the counting of votes must begin as soon as practicable within four hours of the close of poll. In 2024, only eight constituencies did not begin counting within the prescribed timescale. Beginning the count at local elections on polling day can be achieved, my Lords. An efficient voter count improves the efficacy of voting as an accountability measure and a mandate conferred upon representatives, and it does have an impact on voters' decisions, and they don't, I don't think most voters favour lengthy counts, and we've got to think of the trust they have in the electoral process. In terms of Amendment 128, this is one for the serious electoral anoraks, the voting machine pilot schemes, and I look to the noble Lord Pack, in that respect, because I know that this is the sort of thing he, apart from Focus leaflets, he probably thinks about more than anything else, this kind of thing.

This new clause would allow a small number of supervised pilots of voting machines at local and general elections with a paper audit trail, independent certification, and an evaluation report to Parliament before any wider rollout.

This isn't totally unknown. It has been tested in real elections around the world. 19% of countries use e-voting at a national or subnational level. Electronic voting could reduce administrative costs and make voting more accessible and straightforward for many voters, potentially contributing to improved voter participation. Indeed, over a decade ago, the Electoral Commission called on the Government to, quote, "to bring forward proposals for a comprehensive electoral modernisation strategy, setting out how the wider use of technology in elections will ensure the achievement of transparency, public trust, and cost-effectiveness,"

stating that it had been arguing since 2007 that Government should, quote, "conduct a comprehensive electoral modernisation strategy," unquote. The Government now has the opportunity to imple- to implement through supervised pilot schemes what the Electoral Commission has believed was necessary for over 10 years. And the UK hasn't conducted electronic voting or counting pilots since 2007. My Lords, I move finally to the very important amendment, I think, about the review of the review of undue influence offences. And I'm sorry my noble friend Lord Pickles is not in his place because he would be much better qualified in speaking to this amendment.

And, in passing, I commend the amendment, again he's not in his place, the noble Lord Walney, his Amendment 136, which is a similar amendment about religious influence and coercion. My Lords, this clause requires ministers to review the spiritual injury provisions regularly. The Pickles Report recommended that the offence retain a reference to spiritual or religious influence. The Representation of the People Act 1983 prohibits spiritual injury as part of its undue influence provisions. The provision was historically an attempt to limit the perceived undue influence of Roman Catholic clergy, when introduced as the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Act of 1883.

A high a high-profile recent case involved Lutfur Rahman, who was elected as the mayor of the London Borough of Tower Hamlets in the 2014 mayoral election, but was subsequently found guilty of electoral fraud, with the election declared null and void. Erlam v Rahman 2015 found Rahman guilty of undue spiritual influence during that election for mayor of the London Borough of Tower Hamlets. And this referred, for instance, to a letter in his support signed by 101 imams. This state- letter stated that, quote, "Our opponents are spreading jealousy and hatred in the community. We consider these acts as abominable and at the same time condemnable." The court also found that Rahman had engaged in false statements about an opponent, including claims linking him to racism and hostility towards Muslims, bribery, and illegal election expenditure.

My Lords, we don't have enough time to debate this issue as fully as I would like, but I think this amendment provides an obligation for ministers to keep this issue under constant review. It is about the electoral integrity of the of our electoral system, and, significantly, it's about protecting ordinary voters, whatever their background, whatever their religion, whatever their belief, from undue influence and de facto threats by individuals and groups and organisations.

So, on that basis, my Lords, I'm happy to put forward all three amendments, and I look forward to the noble lady or the noble lord the minister's response.

07:15:39 - 07:18:55

Christopher John Rennard

My Lords, Amendment 125, in my name and that of my noble friend, Baroness Thornhill, inserts a new clause to confer upon the Secretary of State statutory powers to establish pilot schemes for flexible voting options. We worry that turnout in general elections, less than 60% in 2024, are caused, in part, because it's easy for people who are retired or not working to vote in a particular Thursday, but it's rather harder for other people to vote. That's why we want to extend the ways in which people can cast their vote and hopefully increase participation. People who are busy working, or working shifts, or long hours, or long commutes, and those with caring responsibilities, and looking after their children, they don't find it so convenient to vote, and we believe they may be discriminated against. Our amendment establishes a few possibilities which we would like to see more controlled, evidence-based innovation on, although we are aware that the Electoral Commission is carrying out a number of pilots.

In particular, we would like to see an extension of advance voting in the days proceeding the main polling day. We'd like to see additional polling days, in particular weekend voting, which I think is not being piloted anywhere, and on weekends, people with families may have much greater flexibility, and those with jobs that may still last Monday to Friday. Community voting hubs situated in accessible, busy locations could help, and different polling stations allowing voters choice over where within their electoral district to vote could all help, as could transportable or mobile polling stations bring the ballot box directly to underserved rural communities or into care environments. My Lords, flexible voting is, I think, a modernizing necessity, but it requires some other changes in the way in which we conduct elections, and in particular with by-elections and general elections, because they can be called at short notice. The Electoral Commission is seeing some pilots at the moment.

We believe they should go further in scope and at a faster speed. We'd like to see them evaluate these schemes, but we also need them to consider whether or not we need to extend the election timetable. Because there's a problem with postal voting, perhaps 26% of the votes in the last general election were cast by post. If there's early voting, say 10 days before the normal polling day, many votes will be cast at a halfway point in the election campaign. So, if we move to alternative methods of voting, we need to consider again the election timetable to ensure that electoral registration officers can conduct the process fairly, safely, securely, and that voters have sufficient time between the calling of a by-election or a general election to consider the issues before they have to cast their votes.

07:18:55 - 07:25:03

Dorothy Thornhill

My Lords, I rise to speak briefly to Amendment 125, I will chop out a large paragraph, in the name of my noble friend Lord Rennard and myself, and then talk to Amendments 136 and 124, in the name of Lord Walney and Lord Jackson of Peterborough respectively. 125 is a modest amendment and a sensible proposal, and my reason for supporting it is really to share with you my own experiences during my time in local government in Watford.

We actually participated in a number of electoral pilots. We had a very go-ahead ERO. So we had voting in supermarkets and we had weekend voting alongside other things. Now, some of these approaches worked better than others, and every innovation, not every innovation produced the increase in turn out that we'd all hoped for. In fact, one pilot involved voting the weekend after the whole country had already cast its ballots.

It felt distinctly odd. Everyone seemed discussing the results before we had even voted. It didn't work. But we did it and we learned from it and I think that's the important point that my noble friend was making. It's why pilots matter.

They allow us to test assumptions against reality, and I think we should be more eager to try them rather than finding lots of reasons to stick with the status quo. Turning to Amendment 124, Noble Lord Jackson, I absolutely understand the attraction of overnight counts. Those of us who've stood for election, we know the adrenaline rush and indeed we feel the frustration of going to bed without knowing the result and probably not sleeping. I certainly felt that myself. The whole count experience for us is a buzz and an important occasion, which definitely feels diluted the next day.

But I think we should be honest: the main beneficiaries of immediate counts are actually not the voters, they're actually all tucked up in bed, they are the campaigners, candidates, and commentators. The people who have to make it happen are our election officers, council staff, and many casual people, many of whom have already worked a very long day, especially since the hours have been extended. And, you know, we've had counts going on well into the night, more so when we haven't had enough people so fewer people have had to count, you know, more votes. And that makes it quite challenges. There was a period when we had this argument every single year until we came to an understanding of what worked for us, and this is what my argument is leading to.

My Lords, different councils face different staffing, logistical, and financial pressures. Even the geographical location of where they're counting can be an impediment against counting at 3:00 in the morning. So, what we need to do, our instincts are to trust EROs and local returning officers who often do, and in my opinion should, be discussing this with the party political agents to make the right decision for their own circumstances. And that can vary from year to year, election to election. And there can be compromises.

We've also verified on the night and counted the next day. A good counting agent can tell a lot from the verification even if it's done face down. In short, my Lords, our view is that it's not an issue for central dictat. I have some sympathy with Amendment 129 and 136, and I'm really disappointed, I'm sure there's a good reason, that Lord Walney is not in his place because I actually would have liked to have heard his views, as he has worked on this. His concerns, the concerns you've raised, Lord Jackson, are not theoretical.

I have seen the occasions outside polling stations where behaviour has crossed the line from legitimate campaigning to outright intimidation and aggression, and I've seen it very often against women.

Sometimes it actually required police involvement. That is wrong, whoever is responsible. What may appear to some as merely political disagreement can in reality be an attempt to influence voters through pressure and coercion. And what concerns me as a liberal most of all is any assumption that people should vote in a particular way just because they belong to a family, a faith, a community or an ethnic group. Democracy does not work like that.

The ballot paper belongs to an individual voter and the choice belongs to that individual voter. No faith, no family, no community leader and no political party owns that vote. This is not about any one religion or community. Pressure can arise in many different settings. We've seen recent examples of this around the world: organised efforts by religious leaders to influence voting behaviour.

The principle is the same wherever it occurs. My Lords, I believe the concern underlying these amendments is a legitimate one. For every voter, regardless of background, belief or circumstance, should be able to enter that little polling station and into that booth with the stubby pencil, as the minister referred to, and know that the decision they make is theirs alone. And to me, this is a principle worth defending.

07:25:03 - 07:25:05

Speaker 165

Hear.

07:25:05 - 07:25:12

Speaker 148

This would seem to be a convenient time to pause proceedings for the day, and I therefore beg to move that the debate on this amendment be adjourned.

07:25:12 - 07:25:19

Richard Faulkner

The question is that the debate on amendment 10 be adjourned. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content".

07:25:20 - 07:25:23

Richard Faulkner

Contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it.

07:25:23 - 07:25:26

Speaker 166

I beg to move that the House be resumed.

07:25:26 - 07:25:30

Richard Faulkner

The question is that the House be resumed. As many as are of that opinion—

07:25:30 - 07:25:32

Speaker 164

Order. Order.

07:25:32 - 07:25:36

Richard Faulkner

The question is that the House be resumed. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content".

07:25:37 - 07:25:47

Richard Faulkner

Contrary, "Not Content". The Contents have it.

07:25:47 - 07:25:49

Speaker 162

I beg to move that the House do now adjourn.

07:25:49 - 07:25:49

that the House do now adjourn.