Social Housing Bill
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Social Housing Bill House of Commons
Follow its sittings



Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Weston. And if I didn't say earlier, it's a pleasure to continue to serve on this committee with you in the chair. I thank the minister for that reassurance on the collection of data. It is very important. And I hope the committee will be able to contain its excitement in the fact that I won't be pushing this one to a vote, Mr. Weston.
Matt Western
Is everyone content for new clause 11 to be withdrawn? New clause 11 by leave withdrawn. We now move on to new clause 12, which has already been debated in group 26. Gideon Amos to move formally.
Matt Western
Happy to withdraw. Is everyone content for this to be withdrawn? Fine. We move on. We now come to group 32 and new clause 15, with which it will be convenient to consider new clause 68.
I call Gideon Amos to move new clause 15.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Weston. And it's a privilege to be able to move this amendment, this new clause, which stands in my name, which is duty to report on a social housing acquisition fund. This fund would... we're all aware of the number of disposals by registered providers of social housing for various reasons. But councils are too often, you know, unable to step in and take up those units when they need to because of a lack of funding. The Local Government Association is promoting the concept of a fund which would enable them to do just that.
The fund offers a way to help councils and registered providers indeed acquire homes at an agreed price and retain them at social rent without prescribing a sale price in statute, which is to address the classification concern in terms of the public sector net debt facility, which the minister has referred to before. To be usable, it would need to move quickly enough for councils to draw on that fund within a notification window. It would prioritize the retention of homes in rural and coastal communities. I think it's acknowledged across the committee that the isolated and small numbers of social homes in rural areas, such as, for example, the constituency of my honorable friend for South Devon, the constituency of my honorable friend the member for St. Ives and the Isles of Scilly, where there are remote clusters of social homes which are particularly at risk of being disposed. As are indeed bungalows, homes adapted for disabled people, larger homes, homes in areas of high need.
Support towards the works is the object of that fund, so that they can carry out the necessary works upon acquisition. Notification period alone isn't enough. The LGA has argued that giving councils notice of disposal is only useful if they have the financial means to act.
And the proposal specifically included support improvement works and particular priority given to those irreplaceable homes that I set out. I commend this new clause to the committee on the basis that it would safeguard those disposals of social homes that are being lost throughout the country at the moment and particularly in the rural and harder to serve areas. Thank you, Mr. Western.
Matt Western
New clause 15, report social housing acquisition fund. The question is that new clause 15 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. New clause 15 and also new clause 68, which I recognize has not been spoken to, both explore the merits of additional funding and support for councils and other registered providers to acquire homes. New clause 15, tabled by the honorable member for Taunton Deane, focuses on homes that would otherwise be disposed of out of the regulated sector so as to keep them as social housing. Although the government continues to promote new build land-led development as a way to increase overall housing supply, we are supportive of acquisitions. This is on the basis that they increase housing stock more quickly than new build and therefore represent an efficient way to rapidly meet local housing need.
As a result, we've taken numerous steps to provide councils with investment opportunities to acquire additional homes. For example, we have lifted the acquisitions cap on the use of right to buy receipts. This removes previous restrictions on the number of homes that could be acquired using this source of capital funding and offers councils greater flexibility to meet local housing need. We've also made grant funding available through the social and affordable homes program for acquisitions and have confirmed that we will look to raise its existing cap so that councils can purchase more homes from the private sector while they increase their capacity and capability to deliver homes directly. In addition, the local authority housing fund can be used by local authorities to purchase homes from private registered providers that would otherwise be lost from the social housing sector.
All homes acquired through the fund become part of the local authority's stock of housing, providing a lasting asset for local communities. I'd like to reassure honorable members that receipts received from the sale of social homes are not lost and are retained in the sector. Receipts from disposals will also often contain an element of recycled grant. In these circumstances, Homes England already sets a series of conditions on how recycled capital grant may be used. These include the expectation that providers deploy recycled grant in support of identified priorities, housing need, and in line with investment priorities set out in local plans.
There is a strong incentive for timely reinvestment. If recycled grant is not used within three years, it must be returned to Homes England or the GLA along with the interest that has accumulated. We need to recognize, though, that registered providers sometimes do have tough decisions to make. We also need to ensure that we use government money as effectively as possible. I am therefore not able to commit to further funding that would ensure homes that are uneconomic or unsuitable to invest in remain in the social housing sector, but I hope honorable members have been reassured by the funds available that I've already outlined.
Gideon Amos
Finally, we do record and publish statistics on acquisitions. This enables us to assess what role they are playing in social and affordable housing supply, and it's not clear what an additional report would add to this assessment, but I think that was on the separate new clause 68 specifically. But for these reasons, I'd ask the honorable gentleman to withdraw his amendment.
Speaker 13
Thank you, Mr. Western. I appreciate the minister's response to some of that, but the fact is that we need a specific measure to prevent the disposals that are continuing around the country, particularly in rural areas. Without that specific measure, without a specific fund, we're going to continue to lose social homes, particularly the ones I mentioned which are most scarce in terms of accessible homes, bungalows, those in rural areas. So I do wish to push this to a vote. Thank you, Mr. Western.
Speaker 14
Sikora de-Wally? No. Gideon Amos? Aye. Edward Argar?
New clause 15 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Abstain. Gareth Bacon? Abstain. Danny Beales? No.
Rachel Blake? No. Ms. Kaloskan? No. Lewis Cocking?
Abstain. Deirdre Costigan? No. Matthew Pennycook? No.
John Stow? No. Patrick Spencer? Abstain. Lawrence Turner?
Matt Western
The Ayes were one, the Noes were eight. So the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group three and new clause 16. New clause 16 was tabled by Andrew George, who is not on the committee.
Does anyone wish to move?
Gideon Amos
Yes, Mr. Western, I'm grateful for the opportunity to move the amendment that stands in the name of my colleague, my honorable friend, the member for St. Ives and the Isles of Scilly, which is rent-to-discounted-sale agreements, or covenanted housing as it might be called. I will do so briefly, but this is an important potential tenure option which can retain social housing in the long-term ownership of the sector whilst giving people the right to the ability to acquire a new home by providing them with a 50% equity in the property. That state remains, and when they choose to move on, they are that that's that equity is sold back, their equity is sold and they receive the uplift in that equity and the property itself reverts to the charity or the housing association which sold it. It's important that we do have mechanisms to get people onto the housing ladder without jeopardizing or more than jeopardizing, almost completely extinguishing our stock of social housing, which has happened with the two million the loss of two million homes since the 1980s from council and social housing stock. So this is an important tenure which deserves recognition in this bill.
It's already in operation in parts of the country and I commend it to the committee on that basis. Thank you, Mr. Western.
Matt Western
Rent-to-discounted-sale agreements. Question is that new clause 16 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Can I thank the honorable gentleman for speaking to the amendment that stands in the name of the member for St. Ives. As the committee knows well, there are already several routes for social housing tenants to access home ownership, including the recently announced Your First Home scheme. But these routes must be balanced with the need to protect social housing stock and stop homes being sold at an unsustainable rate. While this new clause includes provisions intended to ensure homes remain within an affordable housing system, it would nevertheless in our view create a new route for social housing to move from rented tenure into owner-occupation.
The government's priority, Mr. Western, as I've stated numerous times throughout our proceedings, is to protect and increase the supply of social and affordable rented homes for those in housing need. That is why this bill is reforming the Right to Buy and Right to Acquire schemes, both to retain a route to home ownership, but as I've said, to avoid unsustainable rates of sale and outflow from the system. We don't believe it would be right to introduce an additional route for social housing tenants to purchase their homes. Such a route, as I've said, would risk reducing the supply of rented social housing available to future tenants and would duplicate existing routes to home ownership. For that reason, I hope the honorable gentleman won't push this amendment to a vote.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Western.
I'm grateful to the Minister for his response. There is no automatic reason why it would lead to a reduction in social rent. It could be the government's housing of this kind could be an option within the existing quantity of shared ownership or other tenures and offered to people as a route to home ownership and an equity stake in their home. So I believe, I continue to believe, we on these benches, the Liberal Democrat benches, continue to believe this is a valuable tenure and should be expanded. But I can do the maths, Mr. Weston, and I won't push this amendment to a vote.
Matt Western
Is everyone content for new clause 16 to be withdrawn? Agreed. It's withdrawn. We now come to new clause 17, which has already been debated in group 13. I think it was Andrew George who put forward new clause 17.
Does anyone wish to move? It is hereby withdrawn. So new clause 17 is withdrawn. We now come to group 34 and new clause 18. I call Gideon Amos to move new clause 18.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Weston. Even though I can do the maths, this new clause I believe, and we believe on these benches, is particularly important. This new clause, duty to report social housing levy scheme, this new clause would require the government to report on a social housing levy scheme that would spend additional income from local holiday lets, either via levy or disapplying small business rates relief, on local social housing projects and related purposes. It stands in the name of my colleague and honorable friend, the member for St. Ives and the Isles of Scilly, who has worked extensively in the housing sector and the affordable housing sector and knows of which he speaks, Mr. Weston. He points out that in Cornwall, holiday let companies, holiday home owners have been granted over 500 million pounds in Cornwall alone during the last decade in small business tax relief and COVID aid.
But that is a transfer of subsidy which the sector can ill afford in our opinion, Mr. Weston. Yesterday's budget Chancellor extended small business rates relief and that's recognized, whether or not that would affect those premises is yet to be seen. But there has been a huge amount of flipping of second homes by second home owners from council tax to business rates in order to take advantage of the small business rates relief. That is not the intention of the system. We need to find ways, particularly in areas such as Cornwall and elsewhere, to properly control the level of second homes and not to be subsidizing those second homes from the hard-pressed taxpayer, Mr. Weston.
So on that basis, Mr. Weston, I commend this new clause which would levy those second home businesses to the committee.
Matt Western
Duty to report social housing levy scheme. The question is that new clause 18 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. Again, I thank the honorable gentleman for speaking to the amendment tabled in the name of the member for St. Ives and for highlighting the housing pressures experienced in a number of tourist areas. And it is worth saying they may be coastal, they may be rural, often in cases in London, York, and other places around the country, also urban pressures in that regard. The government does recognize that high concentrations of holiday lets can affect the availability and affordability of housing for local people and contribute to wider pressures on local communities.
However, we don't believe this amendment is necessary. The government already supports the delivery of social and affordable housing through established funding programs. We discussed many of them throughout our proceedings. But this amendment is premised on the idea that revenues associated with holiday lets should be earmarked for social housing projects and related purposes, and that is not the government's approach. Business rates revenues are not ring-fenced for specific spending programs and are available to support local priorities.
Likewise, the overnight visitor levy is intended to support local economic growth and strengthen local areas by giving strategic authorities greater control over how locally raised revenues are invested across a range of local priorities. Ring-fencing those revenues for a particular purpose would cut across the government's approach to fiscal devolution and local decision-making. The government is, however, Mr. Weston, already taking action in this area. Parliament legislated for a national registration scheme for short-term lets through the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023, and we remain committed to implementing that scheme as soon as practicable. The government has also abolished the furnished holiday lettings tax regime and continues to consider whether further measures may be needed to help local authorities respond to local housing pressures related to excessive concentrations of short-term lets.
And in light of that ongoing work, given the government's established approach, importantly, to fiscal devolution and local decision-making, we can't support this new clause. I hope the honorable gentleman may consider withdrawing it.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Weston. This is the last one of our amendments in this group. And I recognize the minister has addressed second home ownership in various ways. But the question that remains unanswered is, is it really legitimate or acceptable for second home owners to flip their homes into small businesses to take advantage of business rates relief and avoid the council tax implications of second home council tax? This is costing the taxpayer, hardworking people, as is often said, huge amounts of money.
And some claimants now backdating their tax relief claims back to 1993. For those reasons, I do wish to push this to a vote. Thank you, Mr. Weston.
Matt Western
New clause 18 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that new clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
Of the contrary, no.
Aye.
Edward Argar.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Ezra Cliskan.
Lewis Cocking.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were one and the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 35, new clause 19. New clause 19 was tabled by David Williams, who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to move it?
No one. In which case it is withdrawn. We now come to group 36, new clause 20. New clause 20 was tabled by Peter Swallow, who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to move it?
No. In which case it is withdrawn. We now come to group 37, new clause 25, with which it will be convenient to consider new clause 26. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 25.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Well, thank you very much, Mr. Weston. I would like to join the rest of the committee in wishing a very happy birthday to the minister. Mr. Weston, I rise to move new clause 25 as it stands in my name. One of the most common accusations presented against right to buy is also one of the most mistaken, and we've heard it many times in this committee. And this is the idea that right to buy is a contributor to the shortage of homes in this country.
It's a defeatist attitude masking a lazy analysis.
And this is because, as I laid out at second reading, the government's own impact assessment shows that weakening right to buy will mean fewer new social homes. The impact assessment shows that in 2026-27, the pre-November 2024 baseline was 8,050 right to buy sales leading to 5,450 replacement homes. The document goes on to show that if this bill were to pass, and I'm sure it will, and the legacy impacts wind down in the period 2031-35, annual right to buy sales would fall to around 1,100 a year with around 1,450 replacement homes.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honorable member for giving way. Any quick Google will tell you that the right to buy policy which his party introduced has seen the loss, has seen about a million homes not replaced. 80% in fact were not replaced. And yet he brings forward these amendments today to ask for like-for-like replacement. Would he admit that if he is not too embarrassed to bring these amendments forward, would he at least admit the breathtaking levels of cheek his party shows in this?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Not remotely, Mr. Weston. By the government's own analysis as I've mentioned, the government would oversee a housing system where there would be 4,000 fewer new social homes funded every year. How does this help, Mr. Weston, with the social housing waiting list that I think all members in this room would like to see lower? How does building fewer new social homes help remotely? Of course it doesn't.
I also showed at second reading that the government's own data is not the only data available that disproves the justification for restricting right to buy. The government have argued that the bill will mean that around 3,000 additional homes are retained each year, but research conducted by the House of Lords library shows that only around a net 3% of social homes become available each year for new tenancies. That means, Mr. Weston, that around 90 additional homes will be available for each tenant each year instead of 5,000. 90 instead of 5,000. That is the opposite of what the government's stated aim and completely incongruent with the pressing need for more social homes.
Moreover, the idea that the right to buy is taking homes away is a fallacy for another reason which I've already alluded to. The only people who qualify for right to buy are long-term tenants, and the government data has shown that 78% of new lettings remain lifetime tenancies. That means in more than three quarters of cases, we are looking at social homes that are unlikely ever to be available to a prospective tenant when they need it. All of that clearly demonstrates that right to buy is not the issue, it's part of the solution. I therefore urge colleagues to support new clause 25.
I now want to move on to speak to new clause 26, which also stands in my name, and this would require the Secretary of State to publish annual data on the amount of social housing replaced once sold.
Speaker 22
I thank the honorable member for giving way. In this debate, particularly on the right to buy, there's been accusations of ideological stances on both sides, so I'd like to bring us straight back to a practical question. Does the honorable member not recognize that this is a duplicative measure which is adding to data that is already collected? And would he not agree with me that actually to replace homes, particularly in London where we both represent very different parts of the world, that up to three additional sales would be necessary just to replace one?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
No, because the point of the amendment, Mr. Weston, is for the government to conduct a review 12 months after the passing of this act so that we know for certain what the figures are, and then for the Secretary of State on the basis of that judgment, on the basis of that review, to determine whether or not it should compel local authorities to do a like-for-like replacement.
And that is the whole point. So rather than just letting things play their course, is for the government to take control of it and then to make a decision about what local government should do. Now as mentioned, Mr. Weston, this is expected to make for sorry reading. The government's own figures from its impact statement are proving to be proven correct. So we will be pressing when the time comes, Mr. Weston, for a division on both of these new clauses.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I thank the shadow minister for his well wishes as well and for speaking to those two new clauses. The first new clause 25 would require the Secretary of State, as he said, to undertake a review into the replacement of social housing stock and to consider the merits of introducing a statutory one-for-one replacement requirement. A core aim of the right to buy measures in this bill, Mr. Weston, is to prevent social homes from being sold off without being replaced. Reforming the right to buy is central to that objective.
And if the shadow minister reads the impact assessment, he will see very clearly that it sets out over that 10-year period, 2026 to 36, the move from the existing baseline, pre the changes we made outside this bill but also this piece of legislation, to where we want to get to, which is a net gain of 18,000 social rented homes over that period.
Patrick Spencer
I will give way. Can you clarify for the committee if those are 18,000 vacant new homes or are they 18,000 homes with social tenants currently in them?
Matthew Pennycook
The loss, I'm struggling, I must say, to understand the point. It will vary in each instance, won't it? But there is a well-understood measurement for the loss of social homes from the sector. Shadow minister's just laid out some statistics in that regard. We're very clear, the impact assessment is very clear that we are going from a situation as a result, as I say, of this bill but also some measures we've taken outside the bill, from over that 10-year period, a net loss of 26,000 to a net gain of 18,000.
That is the difference that this legislation will make. And we've also taken significant steps to support local authorities to replace homes sold, allowing them to keep 100% of their right to buy receipts with greater flexibility on how to spend them. Our changes to discounts further ensure councils keep a larger share of the receipts. Our priority, Mr. Weston, is therefore to implement these reforms rather than commission a further statutory review. In addition, we already publish extensive information on the operation and outcomes of the right to buy, and we intend to continue monitoring the impact of our reforms through existing datasets and established statistical releases.
As announced in the consultation response, separate to the bill, we're removing the formal one-to-one replacement target for the right to buy. This is not because we're complacent about councils replacing homes sold, far from it, but we don't want to limit councils' ambitions to purely replacing homes sold under the right to buy. We expect councils to go over and above replacing sold stock and to play a central role in our supply ambitions. For those reasons, I respectfully ask the shadow minister not to press that particular new clause. Turning to new clause 26, this would require the Secretary of State to publish an annual report containing data on the number of new dwellings for social rent that have been delivered within the preceding 12 months and the number of dwellings for social rent that have been disposed of by local authorities within the preceding 12 months.
I do, of course, Mr. Weston, recognize the importance of there being readily available information about both the new supply of social and affordable homes and the number of social and affordable homes that have been lost from the sector. However, and it speaks to the point I've just said to the honorable gentleman, this information is already available. Government publishes data on affordable housing supply in England, including the number of dwellings for social rent delivered. Government also publishes data on social housing sales and demolitions and publishes official statistics in development that estimate the net supply of social housing, including all disposals from large private registered providers and local authorities with a housing revenue account for homes for social rent. For this reason again, we don't think this clause is necessary, this new clause is necessary, and I'd ask the shadow minister to withdraw.
Speaker 19
Patrick Spencer. Thank you, Mr. Weston, and I rise to speak to new clauses 25 and 26. I really appreciate the effort by the opposition to force this government to disclose the facts and to secure some new homes.
Patrick Spencer
And before I start, can I wish the minister a very happy birthday? I will expedite my speech so that we can pop down to the Two Chairmen and pick up where the Chancellor left off last night. Look, I was intrigued to have heard in the speech delivered by the right honourable member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green during the bill's second reading when she said our right-to-buy reforms will mean a net gain of 18,000 social homes over the next 10 years. This is the same claim the minister has made today. So I studied the impact assessment produced by the government and sure enough, there on page 25 is the line: following implementation of the bill, the model instead estimates a net gain of around 18,000 homes over the same period.
But dig into that figure and that 18,000 figure is not quite what it seems because it's not 18,000 new homes available to new tenants that are sat languishing on the housing register. The 18,000 net increase in homes is made up entirely of retained stock and importantly, retained tenants. That's not 18,000 new homes. That's 18,000 homes with someone already living there and who's probably probably been living there for some time. In fact, the impact assessment shows, and I assure this isn't a repeat of the shadow minister's points from the impact assessment, the impact assessment shows whereas under the old regime more than 50,000 new houses were due to be built, this bill will now reduce that to half of that, to approximately 28,000 new homes.
That's what the impact assessment says. There'll be a reduction in new homes built as a consequence of this bill, as a consequence of the fact that fewer homes are being sold and there are fewer funds available to fund new builds. And the real irony for me is that this bill effectively tackled the economic problems of right-to-buy through the admirable inclusion of clauses 6 and 10, which rebalance the economic viability of right-to-buy in the LA's favour. Those measures make right-to-buy economically viable, allowing councils to retain funds from the sale of a unit at a more appropriate price. I can understand the fundamental problem that right-to-buy posed to councils by making the deal too favourable to prospective buyers and tenants.
I accept that. Even if you take into account higher prices and higher rates of retention, councils are still going to be short-changed under this bill by a long way. And so this draws me to both these new clauses in the name of my right honourable friends because that because what a one-for-one replacement policy means within this bill. Again, I return to the impact assessment. Under the pre-November baseline, there is indeed a deficit of lost housing to the tune of 26,000.
So as I understand it, each council would be bound to replace the lost house with a new house. If we follow this new clause to its conclusion, there could be 26,000 additional new homes, which funnily enough chimes with the right honourable member for Camberwell and Vauxhall's point in the chamber.
So for that reason, I hope the minister...
Will he give way just on a quick point?
Matthew Pennycook
I think it's worth saying that previous Conservative governments advocated one-for-one replacement and they didn't achieve it. They didn't achieve it and they didn't achieve it precisely because the finances don't add up. As my honorable friend said, it takes on average, certainly does in my own London borough, the sale of three homes to replace one. It's a very simple proposition. We don't want these homes leaving the sector at the rate they are.
Yes, they might be secure tenancies in many cases, but for future tenants in due course, they will be made available and we will build more at the same time.
Patrick Spencer
Thank you very much, Mr. Weston. And there's a lot to unpack there. Previous governments have made mistakes on housing policy, mistakes that have partly been corrected in this bill. Funding has been attached where it should have existed before, for sure. But I struggle to understand, and I will always struggle to understand, and despite his eloquent speeches and his superb oratory and his very rational arguments, I struggle to understand how preventing old stock from leaving the system is somehow beneficial to the 1.3 million people who are languishing on that waiting list.
Danny Beales
I'll probably say it in less eloquent terms, so it might be easier to understand. Does he not think it's ludicrous the situation we've got into where a huge amount of council stock has been sold privately, many of it now is rented privately back as subsidized housing through the housing benefit system? So isn't it ludicrous that we're not seeing those people benefit from subsidized rents through social housing, but instead publicly subsidized higher rents through the PRS system? A huge amount of that stock is now in buy-to-let run by buy-to-let landlords. And even more ludicrous, we've now got councils buying back that stock with public subsidy to use as affordable housing.
Isn't this an awful, the opposite of a virtuous cycle, this decline of cycle of more and more public subsidy being wasted rather than keeping the stock used as affordable housing? Isn't that what we're testing today?
Patrick Spencer
Again, a lot to unpack there. My speech, my push, this clause is focused on delivering new houses. And I, you know, and the minister's point about the cost of one equaling the price of three, I recognize that imbalanced economic... but anyway, look, I feel like I'm... no, I feel like we're going round in circles to a certain extent here. The purpose of this clause is to try and get new houses onto the market and available to social tenants. I believe clauses 25 and 26 will actually secure adequate numbers of new council houses and that's why I will be supporting these new clauses.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
I have nothing further to add, Mr. Weston, other than we will respectfully decline the minister's invitation to withdraw the clauses and when the moment comes, we will divide the committee.
Matt Western
New clause 25 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
To the contrary, no.
Gideon Amos.
Edward Argar.
Aye.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Nesil Caliskan.
Lewis Cocking.
Aye.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Aye.
Lawrence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were four, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 26, which has just been debated in group 37. Gareth Bacon to move formally.
Matt Western
The question is that new clause 26 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
To the contrary no.
Gideon Amos.
Abstain.
Edward Argar.
Aye.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Nesil Caliskan.
Lewis Cocking.
Aye.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Aye.
Lawrence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were four, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 34 and new clause 27. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 27.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 27, which stands in my name. Regenerating existing social housing is a vital pathway towards providing better, safer, and more social homes. As I've mentioned before, nothing about this bill currently does anything towards delivering more social housing, which is why I've tabled this clause. According to London Councils' estate regeneration report from November 2025, London's boroughs have the potential to develop more than 10,000 new homes in a city that is starved of supply and overflowing with demand.
And that's not just true inside the M25, but across the country, as members from across the House have noted today. Estate regeneration on its own is not a silver bullet, but it can certainly make a significant contribution. Regeneration also plays an important role in taking pressure off our green belt by prioritizing regeneration of brownfield sites, something the government have done little but pay lip service to since 2024. Instead of the undesirable urban sprawling encouraged by the government, the opposition believes in building where homes are wanted and needed, and where they can be supported by existing and necessary infrastructure, such as in our cities and urban areas. Estate regeneration fits that rationale perfectly, and that is why I would encourage colleagues to support new clause 27.
Matt Western
Social housing estates regeneration. The question is that new clause 27 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. As the shadow minister has just outlined, new clause 27 would require the government to produce proposals within 12 months of the passing of this act to support the regeneration of existing social housing estates. Let me make very clear, we recognize the role that regeneration can play in the development of new or improved social homes that best fit the needs of their communities. I can think of many very effective and hugely well-supported as well, where they're taken forward through resident ballots, but estate regeneration projects across London and in my own constituency. I think in particular of the Brookhill Estate regeneration in Woolwich as a good example.
That is why, Mr. Weston, the Social and Affordable Homes Programme will continue to support regeneration schemes that provide a net increase in social housing, and why the programme will last for 10 years, allowing for the longer timeline that regeneration typically requires. We're also committed to improving existing social homes. We've published an updated Decent Homes Standard, as members of the committee will be aware, which providers must meet by 2035, and new minimum energy efficiency standards, which they must meet by 2030.
For these reasons, we don't think that this new clause is required, and kindly ask the shadow minister to withdraw it.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
And Mr. Weston, since the minister's asked me so nicely, and it's her birthday, I will agree to withdraw this clause.
Matt Western
Is everyone content for new clause 27 to be withdrawn? Agreed. New clause 27 by leave withdrawn. We now come to group 39, and new clause 28, with which it would be convenient to consider new clauses 44, 46, and 56, all in the name of the official opposition. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 28.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 28, which stands in my name. This bill claims to be about social housing, yet it says almost nothing about the people who rely on it most. Supported housing services some of the most vulnerable residents in the sector: the elderly, people with disabilities, and people who've faced incredible hardship. New clause 28 would ensure that there is a strategy to support these groups through effective stock management, rather than leave them without representation in this bill.
The clause would also require, within 12 months, the Secretary of State to publish a strategy and lay it before Parliament. It would examine the barriers to delivery, how supported housing fits within the wider stock management and long-term demand. This is not a monumental task, Mr. Weston, but it can produce effective outcomes. If the minister believes in delivering for vulnerable residents, he should have no reason to refuse. I move to new clause 44, which also stands in my name.
Stock management could play a critical role in the future of a better-run, more efficient, and more targeted social housing system. For this to work, however, the government must understand the condition of the system and the inefficiencies within social housing. The clause would work towards such an understanding by requiring the publication of a national audit of social housing stock, including stock condition, occupancy levels, rates of under-occupancy, levels of regional demand, and the number of empty properties. All of these are critical factors to understand and make work, otherwise the government of the day is failing the 1.34 million people and families on the social housing waiting list. Unfortunately, however, we already know that in many of these areas, these categories are full of inefficiencies.
For example, the English Housing Survey states that approximately 389,000 households are under-occupying social housing, and a further 164,000 social rented homes are empty. These are critically important figures, not just to know, but also to understand and act on. And new clause 44 would compel the government to make these figures known, helping local authorities and other providers to see the national picture, as well as lawmakers, so that the system works towards the efficiency that the most vulnerable, excuse me, the most vulnerable deserve. In terms of new clause 46, Mr. Weston, which also stands in my name, the government have promised a council home comeback, and the new Prime Minister has spent much time promising big things for the future of social housing. These theoretical points make for good press, but the government must spend more time focusing on what stock we already have, as well as increases we may see in the future.
With the current social housing system, there are too many empty properties, illegal sublets, and homes taking far too long to re-let. None of these issues have the same appeal and glamour as a comeback or a grand new funding project, but it is just as vital to the system that these issues are rectified. And that is why I've tabled new clause 46. This clause would require the government to publish a strategy for improving the management of existing social housing stock, and I look to the minister for assurances that such issues will be addressed and efficiencies made. Finally, Mr. Weston, in this group, new clause 56, which stands in my name, requires an essential exercise in the understanding and proper utilization of existing stock.
All right honorable and honorable members present will recognize the vital need to build more social housing, but this is not the only objective the government should have. Every empty, illegally sublet, or under-occupied home costs vulnerable people a chance to get a roof over their heads and a place to call home. That is why new clause 56 requires a national strategy to improve the management of existing social housing stock. That would see the Secretary of State publish a comprehensive plan within 12 months of Royal Assent that addresses issues within the current supply. The clause also places a requirement on local authorities and registered providers to publish a short set of data each year: voids, re-let times, subletting cases, recovered properties, and when the waiting list was last reviewed.
In the majority of cases, providers will have already provided this information, but it is inconsistently published and an easily fixable inefficiency. It also requires an annual report to Parliament so that data is scrutinized and assessed properly, not simply logged and forgotten about. The current patchwork picture needs to be un-woven and properly understood, and that is why I hope that honorable members and the Minister will support new clause 56.
Matt Western
Lewis Cocking indicated he would wish to speak, and clearly so, in which case I would like to call Lewis Cocking.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Western. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I'd like to pass on my congratulations to the Minister for his birthday today. It's a pleasure to follow the Shadow Minister, who I wholeheartedly support on these new clauses: new clauses 28, new clause 44, 46, and 56. And I want to start by speaking probably to new clause 46, and I'll just make some general points about... I do think we need a strategy about improving the existing management of the social housing stock. Because as the Minister knows, and I sort of alluded to this when he came before the Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee, obviously overcrowding is an issue within social homes.
And I suspect we speak to many constituents, as I do across Broxbourne, that are in a two-bedroom home and that need a four-bedroom home. And when in a previous life when I was a councillor on the planning committee, I always used to argue to make sure within the 106 negotiations or within the affordable housing part of a development that we would get some larger social homes, because they're very hard to come by and you have to wait years to get a four-bedroom home. But under the... Will he just give way? Under the...
Matthew Pennycook
Will he just give way? Just on a brief point. It's just worth me picking it up. The reason that so many larger social homes aren't available is because they are precisely the ones that have been sold off in most cases in the first instance under the Right to Buy. I thank the Minister.
Lewis Cocking
I thank the Minister for giving way, but I'll go back to an earlier point I made. Just because if we take all of these homes back into social housing, the same people that are living in them now would still be living in them. They're not new social homes, so we would not reduce... they would not reduce the social housing waiting list. But where I was going with my point is, I speak to constituents that are overcrowded in a two-bedroom home and that are waiting on the list for a four-bedroom home. Now, to alleviate some of their overcrowding, a three-bedroom home might alleviate some of that.
Not ideal. I completely agree that if they went into a three-bedroom home, they would still be overcrowded, and it could only be seen as a temporary fix. But at the moment, under the current system, they're forced to stay in the two-bedroom property whilst they wait and bid on four-bedroom properties, which don't come along that often. And we need to be much better at securing larger social homes on development, which sometimes developers don't want to build because they are more expensive. So would the Minister look at potentially changing the rules?
Because if I've got a family, a mom, dad, and three kids in a two-bedroom property, at least if they're in a three-bedroom property, that would... they would have that extra bedroom, they would have that extra space. And sometimes when I speak to my constituents, sometimes they say that would be a stepping stone rather than being able to have to wait in the two-bedroom property to get the four-bedroom property. So I say that in the nicest possible way, that I think we do need a strategy, because I think we can use the stock much better to make people a little bit less overcrowded. I'm not saying that solves all of the problems. As I said, some constituents would prefer to move straight into a four-bedroom property, but they understand they have to wait a considerable amount of time to do that.
And sometimes councils don't have the powers to force developers to build those larger social homes. So I wonder if the Minister can reflect on the current rules about overcrowding, because changing those slightly might make it easier for the lives of the constituents we represent.
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western.
This group of amendments all focus upon the important issue of the effective management of existing social housing. Let me start with new clauses 46 and 56. These new clauses would require the Secretary of State within 12 months of Royal Assent to publish and lay before Parliament a national strategy for improving the management and use of social housing stock. New clause 56 would also require every local housing authority and registered provider to publish prescribed stock management information each year, with the Secretary of State reporting annually on performance. On the point of principle, and I say this partly in response to the honourable gentleman, the member for Bloxwich, we absolutely do believe there is more that can be done to optimize the efficient use of social housing stock.
The government is already reviewing how effectively existing homes are managed and how tenant mobility and stock use could be improved. This work, Mr. Weston, is underway and is considering many of the issues raised in this amendment, including voids, under-occupation, right-sizing, mutual exchange, and tenancy fraud. We expect the review to report shortly, and for that reason we don't believe it would be right to legislate now for a strategy and permanent reporting framework before the evidence from the review has been fully considered. I can give the honourable gentleman the guarantee that I'll reflect on the points that he's just made as part of considering the research findings carefully and deciding what further action might be proportionate in this area. I won't go into detail, he knows it, the fact that local authorities are responsible for local allocations framework within that national structure.
Turning to new clause 44, it seeks to understand how social housing is being used by requiring the publication of a national audit of social housing stock. Again, while I recognize the intent here, the government doesn't believe this amendment is necessary. A substantial amount of data is already published on the condition and use of social housing, including through the English Housing Survey and local authority housing statistics, covering many of the issues raised in the amendment. This new clause would also duplicate the ongoing stock management review I just mentioned. Turning finally to new clause 28, which would introduce a requirement for the Secretary of State to publish a strategy on supported housing.
Again, we recognize the crucial role of supported housing in enabling vulnerable people to live independently. The Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023, and it's worth me saying when mentioning this that the efforts of the honourable gentleman, the member for Harrow East, on the opposite benches in bringing forward this Act should be noted and commended. That Act introduces a duty on local housing authorities to produce local supported housing strategies, including setting out their approach to the issues raised in this amendment based on a detailed understanding of local supply and demand. In 2024, we published research on supported housing supply and demand nationally. Earlier this year, we published guidance for local authorities on developing their supported housing strategies, and earlier this month we published a consultation on draft regulations to implement the licensing regime set out in the 2023 Act.
And finally, Mr. Weston, just last week we published the first piece of advice from the Supported Housing Advisory Panel established under that Act. This is a really important area of policy. Some of the pressures around supported housing and the misuse of exempt supported accommodation, West Midlands, for example, is a particular hotspot for some poor practice out in the sector. I know honourable members want to see us act on this. We've, as I said, set out, we've already taken action in a number of ways, and I hope that that reassures honourable members that this government is taking the necessary steps to address the issues surrounding supported housing.
So on that basis, I'd kindly ask the shadow minister to not press these amendments to a division.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Chair. Thank you, Mr. Weston. On new clause 28, we will press to a division. I will let the cat out of the bag now and agree with the minister on the other new clauses. When the time comes, we will withdraw those.
Matt Western
So new clause 28 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time.
As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
To the contrary, no.
Aye.
Edward Argar.
Aye.
Gareth Bacon.
Aye.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Nesil Caliskan.
Lewis Cocking.
Aye.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Aye.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were five, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 29, which was debated in group four with clause six stand part. Gareth Bacon to move formally.
Matt Western
Report on the impact of changes to right to buy discounts. The question is that new clause 29 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
To the contrary, no.
Gideon Amos.
Abstain.
Edward Argar.
Aye.
Gareth Bacon.
Aye.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Nesil Caliskan.
Lewis Cocking.
Aye.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Aye.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were four, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 30, which was debated in group 26. Gareth Bacon to move formally.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. This was a probing clause. We are happy to withdraw it.
Matt Western
New clause 30 is withdrawn. We now come to group 40 and new clause 31. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 31.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 31, which stands in my name. Social housing exists to serve communities, yet too many families who have lived, worked, and raised children in an area find themselves overlooked when homes are allocated. This is just wrong and unjust. This is why I've tabled new clause 31, which would require allocation schemes in England and Wales to give additional preference to people with a local connection.
Local authorities would consider current residence, employment, and family ties. There is nothing exclusionary about supporting local people who contribute to, live in, and work in their community. On top of this, new clause 31 gives armed forces personnel the respect and priority they deserve. Through their service, our servicemen and servicewomen often find themselves posted far from home, sometimes in unsafe and unstable places in order to protect Britain, British values, and those in need internationally. We have a responsibility to protect them when they return home, and that, Mr. Weston, is why I've tabled new clause 31.
Matt Western
Local connection requirements. The question is that new clause 31 be read a second time. Lewis Cocking.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Weston. Pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I rise in support of this new clause, and I'll keep my comments brief because I've got some comments to make on the next group of clauses.
I'm very proud that my local council of Broxbourne, which is Conservative-run, brought in rules for local connection in around 2010, that you had to have a connection for five years to the borough to get on the housing waiting list. I do think that's good because obviously local residents have to put up with all of the disruption that goes with the development and I do think we should try and support where we can local people first on council house waiting lists.
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. The government recognizes the importance of enabling people to remain close to their families, their employment, and the communities in which they've built their lives. Local connection can have a legitimate role in deciding how social housing is allocated. However, local authorities, housing authorities in England already have powers to take local connection into account when determining priorities between applicants within the statutory reasonable preference categories. I think it's worth pointing out to honorable members on the committee, 89% of councils have a local connection or residency test in place to determine who qualifies for social housing in their area.
The existing framework is therefore already working to allow local authorities to set local connection tests in consideration of housing need and the relevant circumstances in their local areas. This new clause would go further, requiring additional preference for applicants with a local connection without making that preference dependent on the urgency of their housing need. We don't believe that would strike the right balance. It could disadvantage households with higher needs who must move to another area, for example, to reach a place of safety or to obtain essential support. A connection to an area should not in itself be treated as evidence of greater housing need.
I will give way.
Danny Beales
Danny Beales. Listen, and I kind of echo what the minister is saying. In my experience, we've had real issues with victims of domestic violence who often have to move from places they have spent many years and we've been talking to the department about the application of local connection tests as well as rent arrears requirements for the disproportionate impact that has. I think veterans are often discussed as well, rough sleepers, and there's many groups, victims who've been involved in gang-related crime who have to leave their area. A purely local connection test really does have very worrying impacts on homelessness and housing.
And when taken to the extreme, in Hillingdon we have a 10-year consecutive local connection test. Many people will be waiting for their housing homelessness to be assessed, they'll end up sofa surfing on a neighbor in Harrow just over the border and suddenly they've lost their 10-year, they've been there nine, you know, nine years but suddenly have lost their 10-year consecutive waiting and will be deprioritized. So isn't it right that we should be proportionate in how we apply these tests?
Matthew Pennycook
My honorable friend is absolutely right and as ever we benefit from his considerable experience in local government. That is the point, local housing authorities should retain flexibility to balance priority and local connection within the statutory framework. I do also want to recognize the shadow minister mentioned the intention to ensure that members of the armed forces are not disadvantaged because their service has interrupted their local connection. There are already important protections in place in England, serving members and all former members of the regular armed forces are exempt from local connection tests when councils determine who qualifies for social housing regardless of when they last served. And we are extending that protection, as honorable members know and we've discussed through this bill, so that it applies when veterans seek homelessness assistance.
Our approach is to maintain a framework that recognizes local connection while protecting people in housing need and allowing local housing authorities to respond fairly to individual circumstances. Our review of statutory allocations guidance provides an opportunity to reinforce those expectations rather than introduce the blanket requirement proposed here. Finally, Mr. Western, the new clause would also change the social housing allocations framework in Wales. Housing is a devolved matter, as you know, so consultation with the Welsh government would be required before taking forward changes of this kind. For those reasons, I respectfully ask the shadow minister to withdraw the amendment.
Matt Western
I have heard what the minister has to say and there's much in what he's had to say, but I am going to respectfully decline his offer and we will be pressing this to a vote shortly before.
New clause 31 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Contrary no.
No. Division. Lock the doors. Sogul everybody. No.
Did you name us? Aye. Edward Argar. Aye. Gareth Bacon.
Aye. Danny Beales. No. Rachel Blake. No.
Hazel Cliskin. No. Lewis Cocking. Aye. Deirdre Costigan.
No. Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger. No.
Patrick Spencer. Aye. Lawrence Turner. No. The ayes were five, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it.
Unlock. We now come to group 41 and new clause 32, with which it will be convenient to consider new clauses 37 and 43, all in the name of the official opposition. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 32.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 32, which stands in my name. Social housing is not abundant in this country, as we all know. It is a limited resource and it's funded by the British taxpayer. The opposition laid out in the alternative King's Speech the stark and unfair reality of the British social housing system's priorities.
Too many struggling British families find themselves far down the 1.34 million strong waiting list for social housing. But for example, 72% of those who identify as Somali in England and Wales live in social housing. This comes alongside... Will the honorable member give way? Yes, of course.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honorable member for giving way, and he has been very generous today in giving way. But is he aware that 90% of those in social housing in this country are British citizens, that asylum seekers are barred from social housing, that temporary people on temporary work visas or study visas are also barred from social housing? And is he further aware that this amendment, by restricting social housing to British citizens, would stop people like myself from the Republic of Ireland and many of my constituents in the Hanwell area of Ealing Southall from accessing social housing? And in that context, has he spoken to the shadow Northern Ireland Secretary and the shadow Foreign Secretary and told them that he intends to dismantle the common travel area with the Republic of Ireland?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
I come back to the point I made earlier on in this committee, Mr. Weston, which is that if social housing were in abundant supply, then there'd be no need for this amendment. But it is not in abundant supply, nor will it be anytime soon. So the question is how British taxpayers' money should be prioritized. And I'll come on in more detail to that in a moment. As I was saying earlier on, so 72% of Somalis, 41% of Jamaicans, 34% of Bangladeshis, and until recently, Mr. Weston, the first lady of Sierra Leone was living in a British-funded council tax house, council house.
And that is why we believe that those who are not British citizens should not be able to access social housing while British citizens sit on the waiting list. An MHCLG response to a written parliamentary question revealed that every year around 33,000 new social tenancies go to households in which the lead tenant is not a UK national. At the same time, the government is spending 4 billion pounds a year on the affordable homes program to build 30,000 new social homes, and that's British taxpayers' money.
This means that spending the equivalent of the entire affordable homes program budget is going to house non-nationals and British taxpayers are footing the bill. New clause 32 is about creating a fairer system for British citizens and British taxpayers. It is not about exclusion. It is about prioritization, ensuring that British citizens are at the front of the queue for social housing in the country of which they are a citizen. It's not about birth or race.
It's about legal status.
Patrick Spencer
I thank the shadow minister for giving way. I wondered if he would comment on the fact that just earlier today the IFS published a statement regarding the budget yesterday which said that household disposable income will continue to decline over the coming years as a result of the dire economic situation this country's in. And at the same time we're looking at changes to the social housing makeup in this country which would further disadvantage taxpayers in this country. Does he have anything to say to that?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Well, I would agree with the point I think my honorable friend is making. And the point of these amendments, as I said just a moment ago, is about prioritization. It's about where we use, where we prioritize the use of British taxpayers' funding. I'm just about to wind up on this clause. We believe, Mr. Western, that in making Britain your home should be earned by working, paying tax, and integrating.
And new clause 32 emphasizes these points without making them exclusive to one race, religion, or creed, and that was quite deliberate. So I urge colleagues to support new clause 32. Moving on to new clause 37 as it stands in my name. Confidence in an already strained system is never helped when people with significant overseas wealth or status slip through the system unchecked. Current rules do not give sufficient support to local authorities to assist in dealing with applicants who hold senior public office abroad or who are closely related to those who do.
New clause 37 is proportionate and practical. It would allow the Secretary of State to issue guidance on such applications, including on disclosure requirements, the verification of overseas assets, and the position of anyone subject to UK sanctions. Local authorities would be required to have regard to it and Parliament would see it laid before it takes effect. New clause 37 gives councils the vital tools to protect public trust, ensure homes go to those in genuine need, and make the system fair. Turning to new clause 43, Mr. Western.
One of the greatest pressures on social housing, on the social housing system, is the waiting list, with 1.34 million vulnerable people and families facing a seemingly immovable backlog ahead of them. It is essential that all socioeconomic and physical pressures on the system are identified and addressed. One of them is net migration. As I've said a moment ago, every year around 33,000 new social tenancies go to households in which the lead tenant is not a British citizen. The source for that is a written answer from the MHCLG.
At the same time, the government is spending 4 billion pounds a year on the affordable homes program to build 33,000 new social homes, which means spending the equivalent of the entire affordable homes program budget is going to house non-British nationals and British taxpayers are paying for that. It is clearly necessary to look into exactly how this pressure is suppressing the efficiency of the social housing system and inhibiting its ability to help British families in need, which is why we table new clause 43, which would require the publication of estimates of social housing demand arising from net migration. Because with this data, the government and local authorities can better inform decision-making regarding the allocation of stock and better determine decisions around housing those in need. It is vital that we do not ignore an issue simply because some people find it uncomfortable to discuss. New clause 43 does not alienate anybody, nor does it take away anyone's rights to a social home.
It is a simple and straightforward requirement that leaves decision-makers better informed about the greatest pressures on an already strained system.
Matt Western
Access to social housing, British citizenship.
The question is that new clause 32 be read a second time. Danny Beales.
Danny Beales
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you so much. I wasn't intending to speak, but then having heard the opposition present this amendment, I felt, considering my experience at the weekend in my constituency, I had a responsibility to do so. At the weekend, I attended the international mass at the Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church in Uxbridge, and the priest stood up, a Catholic priest stood up in front of a packed church, standing room only, 300, they'd never been as busy for decades, full of people wearing football shirts from around the world, international dress. It was a congregation of Uxbridge residents from all over the world, I think more than 50 nations were represented, the priest proudly said.
And he considered them all to be part of our community rightly, and was speaking about how the Irish community in Uxbridge had built the Our Lady of Lourdes church, and now that the congregation were building Uxbridge. And I met social care workers there, I met people who I already knew actually, from India, who work at the hospital as nurses, people just starting businesses. All of these people are taxpayers, many of whom will have indefinite leave to remain. Their children may have been born in Britain and be British citizens themselves, even though their parents weren't. And this amendment is seeking to drive a wedge between our community and create second-class citizens and second-class residents in this country, not based on need, not actually, I mean, I take umbrage, the point that's funded by the British taxpayer.
Actually, the amendment is not talking about what is and isn't funded by the taxpayer. Many people who've come here and made their home here are taxpayers. Many people who live in council homes who may not have been born in Britain are taxpayers. And it is good, but your, the amendment of the opposition is not seeking to distinguish between contribution and who is and isn't a taxpayer. It is loaded with that language, but fundamentally it's an attack on people who have not been born in Britain, which is deeply unfair and is not, I'm very happy to give way to the member back.
Speaker 58
This is not an issue of penalizing, it's not an attack. I tell you what it is, it is an issue of equity and fairness. Standing up for what's fair. Asking someone to subsidize something else, you have to take into account whether that's fair.
Danny Beales
But I don't believe this amendment and the comments about taxpayers, this isn't, as far as I understand, an amendment that says you only qualify if you've paid tax. It isn't about that. It is about your place of birth. I'm happy to give way.
Speaker 57
Could he please point out where in the amendment it says where someone's born?
Danny Beales
As again, as far as I'm aware, the opposition amendment is not suggesting prioritizing only people who've made a certain contribution towards housing or towards the tax, that's not my understanding. That was the language that's been used by the opposition, but let's be frank, it is not the nature of what the opposition party is talking about. I'll give way one last time and then I need to move on.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you very much. No, the amendment was very clearly written. It is not about where somebody was born. We've been very precise in what we said on that. There is no reference to where someone is born in this amendment for a very clear reason.
It is about who is or is not a British citizen. And therefore, who is or should or should not benefit from the British taxpayer's contribution. That's precisely what the amendment's about. It's got nothing to do, I actually said in my remarks, it has nothing to do with race, religion, or place of birth, or creed. It is about who is or is not a British citizen.
And that is what the point of the amendment is.
Danny Beales
Well, it may be naivety or, you know, I'm sure it may be as, I'm sure it isn't a deliberate attempt, but in reality, focusing on whether someone has citizenship, whether they're a British citizen or not, will have, obviously, will preclude only those who were not born here. There'll be no people born in Britain who are suddenly going to be precluded. It's not about if you've contributed a certain amount of money or not, you're a taxpayer or not, it isn't.
The opposition are seeking to drive a wedge through our community and somehow suggest that the reason we haven't got council homes is because they've all just been snapped up by recent arrivals on boats, not because millions were sold off under the Conservative Party of old. And I must say, I hoped for better from the opposition party. I hoped we could, you know, that we started discussion about how we actually deliver more council homes. That what I thought was what we were attempting to do. But instead of doing that, the nasty party is back and instead seeking to drive wedges through our community.
And I would say that everyone I met in that church who contributes to Uxbridge deserves a fair shout of local housing if they need it.
Gideon Amos
So thank you, Mr. Western. And I agree with the comments we just heard. I mean, this is the most iniquitous and divisive amendment in this bill, as I said in the second reading. I'll tell you who it does exclude. It excludes the nurses in my local hospital, Musgrove Park, who are looking after very sick people who are no longer they'll be turned out.
They've been invited here by us, by our society, to come and work as nurses in the NHS. But no, on the Conservative government, they will be turned out of their council houses. I'll tell you who else it excludes.
Gideon Amos
Well, it's gracious of the opposition spokesperson to consent to those nurses staying in their homes. But apparently we are to invite nurses in future to come to Taunton and Wellington and elsewhere in the country, but tell them they must work for the NHS, they must pay their taxes, but by the way, if you need affordable housing, you can't have it, tough, go and find somewhere else. And I can tell you, I've had nurses in my surgery desperately looking for social housing, for affordable housing, having come here, moved their family here, moved their children here at the invitation of the opposition's government, of the Conservative government. They were invited here and they can't find anywhere to live. They will not be welcome to have social housing under the Conservative amendment.
I'll tell you who else won't be welcome. The care workers looking after our loved ones in care homes. Again, they come here at our invitation and will be told they're not allowed to have social housing. The people who come and support our high streets and our local businesses who haven't yet got leave to remain will not be allowed to have access to social housing. As I mentioned in the in the second reading debate, it extends as the honorable member for Ealing Southall would be in a if she were to apply anew be refused a council home under the Conservative amendment.
Not only the honorable member for Southall, also the first Duke of Wellington, if he if he were alive today, would not if apparently it's good enough to yes, of course I will.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
We had a bit of a spat about this at the time at second reading. The first Duke of Wellington was a British citizen. So no, it wouldn't exclude him. It's a complete nonsensical argument the honorable gentleman's making. Go back and read some history.
Gideon Amos
I think the history books will show, Mr. Western, that the Duke of Wellington was born 32 years before the Act of Union between Britain and Ireland. And Britain and Ireland are I know it'll come as a shock to the opposition, but Britain and Ireland are two different places. He was an Irish citizen, not a British citizen. And when I and since his Grace the ninth Duke is no longer in Parliament as a result of very sensible reforms to the House of Lords, I feel as Member of Parliament for Wellington, I have a duty to stand up for his line of heritage. And when I see the ninth Duke, I will explain to him that his ancestor would no longer be welcome in this legislation on the Conservative's amendment.
Of course, it's not just, not just, and the honorable member for Uxbridge was absolutely right where he identified this is related to where you're born, because the biggest single factor of whether you're a British citizen is your birthplace. Most, the vast number, the vast majority of people achieve British citizenship from being born here. Of course, Duke Wellington wasn't the only Conservative Prime Minister not born here. Boris Johnson was born in the United States. I don't know whether he would be allowed, whether he ever fell on hard times, hard to believe he would fall on hard times.
Not only, there are other national treasures, Spike Milligan, who, the main thing I remember about him was that he had on his tombstone, "I told you I was ill", Mr. Western. But his, he was born in Ireland, in India, excuse me, was born in India, was not a British citizen and objected to that fact for a number of years. Frankly, let's move away from the history though, Mr. Western. The main point is here, the fault of the, the lack of social housing is not the fault of migrants to this country. It's the fault of successive governments having not built enough and having flogged off far too many, so we don't have enough social housing.
This is a divisive, I really had hoped better from the Conservative Party. They are chasing the Reform mantra. I would hope they would have left it to the Reform Party to indulge in this kind of, of politics. It's beneath them. We should reject this amendment and we will be voting against it.
Nesil Caliskan
Thank you very much, Chair. And my friend from Uxbridge, member for Uxbridge, so eloquently put the points I was going to make, but I'll just take the opportunity to say that as a Member of Parliament for Barking, I have constituent population who have a high proportion of them from different heritage backgrounds. And the truth is, those constituents who have secured ILR, the indefinite leave to remain, have lived in this country for a number of years, making significant contribution to our society, not least through the taxes that they have paid as they have worked here legally. So the very argument that we should be fairer in our approach to allocation of social housing is reflected with the system that we have that allows those who have paid their taxes, secured indefinite leave to remain, and then access that social housing when in need. I also just want to say that for those who have no recourse to public funds, they cannot access the social housing in the first place.
So I, I appreciate the argument that we have to have a fair approach to allocating resources. I accept that. And when you speak to my constituents in Barking, they too want a fair approach. But what is fair about not recognizing that in order to become a British citizen, in many cases, people cannot afford to be able to make that application and therefore don't become a British citizen, and yet do have indefinite leave to remain and so should be able to access the rights that everybody else can access because they have made their contribution through their taxes. I think this is a divisive and unnecessary amendment.
I don't think it speaks to the spirit of the debate we've heard so far. It will do nothing to add to the additional social homes that we need in this country. And I'm happy to give way.
Patrick Spencer
I'm really grateful and making a very good speech and but and interest alluded to her constituents in Barking. I don't think anyone in this chamber, even the members for Taunton, haven't got constituents who are concerned about the social contract. And I wanted to ask her where her constituents would draw the line on what is fair for the welfare state to hand out to people who are not British citizens.
Nesil Caliskan
Thank you very much. And I think it's an interesting question. And when we come to a conversation about welfare and where you would draw the line, I would happily have that conversation.
But this bill is about social housing. And if we are talking about fairness and drawing the line, it feels very unfair to draw a line in a place that does not recognize that once you have secured indefinite leave to remain, you have contributed through taxes, through being here a long time, through having that legal status. I do not accept that this amendment does anything other than cause division. I don't think it makes a positive contribution to the net increase of social homes that we desperately need. There are better ways that we can improve a piece of legislation without creating division and hostility, which I have to say my constituency of Barking feels the brunt of when debates like this happen.
So I urge members to reject it, to recognize that there is a lot to do to provide additional social housing, but actually to target groups of my constituents that would be disadvantaged by this is not the best way to go about improving the pressures on social housing in this country.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Western. It's a pleasure to follow the honorable lady. We were both council leaders and neighbors before we both entered this place. As I've said, I've been a local councilor in local government and I've seen firsthand how social housing works, how it's allocated to different people who have different needs. And I've already said, whilst I was leader of Broxbourne Council, I was proud that our rules at Broxbourne Council were some of the strictest, requiring people to have at least five years connection to the borough to be able to get on our housing list.
And we recognize that social housing is not just something to be handed out to anyone and everyone because the money has to come from somewhere to pay for it. What deeply concerns me, I know there's a number of people that want to speak on this amendment and we're having a robust debate, it deeply concerns me that communities should not be expected to subsidize others from outside their area so they can live in cheaper housing. That's why I would encourage all councils to follow Broxbourne Council's lead and introduce a residency requirement on this. And this issue alone is bad enough, but taken with foreign nationals, we take this issue to a whole new level. London is a city that many hardworking British people would love to make their home but simply can't afford.
How can the government tell people like in my constituency of Broxbourne that they should pay more in tax so that people from abroad can come here and be put up in subsidized housing in one of the most expensive cities in the world? It is made, I'm coming to the end of my remarks, it is made even worse for young British people moving to our capital for work, having to pay a fortune for a tiny room in a shared house with complete strangers, whilst the priority rules set by left-wing councils in London mean that some foreign nationals who have never paid a penny into the system get placed in social housing with a whole flat to themselves. On this side of the house, we will never shy away from standing up for the British people and ensuring that foreign nationals who come to this country do not get a free ride on the benefit system and do not get subsidized housing at our expense, which is why I wholeheartedly support the shadow minister and support new clause 32.
Speaker 22
I thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.
I'll be opposing this amendment. I think it fits every criteria of a piece of divisive rhetoric in terms of focusing on an issue that is of relatively small impact on the broader picture and also seeks to amplify fear because it's based on an inadequate assessment of what is actually the issue here, which is the overall supply of genuinely affordable homes. There have been a number of, I hope, mistakes or misspeaking in the opposition's remarks in terms of what a taxpayer is. I'm sure that in any closing remarks or future remarks, those on the opposition benches will acknowledge that people with indefinite leave to remain do pay tax and therefore could be considered taxpayers. They've implied that it's only taxpayers who pay for council homes and social homes; it's also those people who pay rent.
I believe that they might want to correct those remarks. And I'll just close by asking a couple of really practical questions of the opposition. The first is: what would they propose to happen to families where there are British children within a family who, for whatever reason, the lead tenant is not a British citizen in a very, very small number of cases? Would they really see those British children denied the opportunity to live in a safe and secure and warm and well-designed home? I'd also put the question of why on earth are they bringing this proposal forward without acknowledging the role of people with settled status?
And finally, just one final question that hasn't been asked is: has the opposition speakers spoken to their colleagues about their approach to common travel arrangement that they seem to have just brought up today?
Patrick Spencer
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I won't speak for long, but I thought it would be relevant to raise the fact that I have at one point, and twice at two points in my life, been an immigrant in countries with very, very stringent approach to my access to public services in both of them. I didn't think that was divisive. I thought it was logical. I remember specifically when I moved to America and I was told, "Don't get yourself into any healthcare trouble or into a situation where you might be need to call an ambulance, because you will be charged thousands of dollars if you have to call an ambulance."
Will the honorable member give way?
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honorable member for giving way, and he is very good at giving way, I thank him for that. I wonder if he has ever tried being an immigrant in the Republic of Ireland. I would recommend it to him; it's a very nice place. But if he were to go to the Republic of Ireland, he would find that he would be eligible for social housing should he need it. And that is because of the common travel agreement.
And equally, people from the Republic of Ireland who come to this country are also eligible for social housing here. Would he answer the question that his colleagues seem unable to answer? This amendment would unilaterally close off this agreement to Irish citizens living in this country. So when is his party going to tell the Irish government that they are pulling out of the common travel agreement?
Patrick Spencer
I thank the honorable lady. I'll tell you what, I'll answer half of that question by saying my name, my first name is Patrick. I have blood in the Republic of Ireland. My brother was at Trinity College Dublin. I adore that country.
And I would only point out two things: the contribution of Irish people to our economy is astronomic and something we must preserve. But also, the housing policies of the Republic of Ireland perhaps reflect the fact that their economy has gone through the roof on the back of low taxes, low regulation, a pro-business approach to the economy. Where was I?
I only raised this because I think accusations of being divisive, accusations of being exclusive, accusations of being pernicious and unpleasant are not fair accusations in this context. We are rapidly becoming a poor country unable to afford the social services that we ideally would like to provide. And that leads me onto my last point, the point I had made earlier at an intervention. We have to reflect in this place as all parties under the threat of extremist populist parties that we have not got immigration right. This is a bill about social housing but the undertone of it is around welfare, it's around the social contract and what that means to people who come here.
And if we continue to get this issue wrong, we will continue to see populist parties taking our votes and we are at risk of losing this country.
John Slinger
Thank you Mr. Weston. I wish to address new clause 32 and perhaps the shadow minister will intervene if he feels that I'm not being accurate in what I say. But I would just mention that I recall hearing him use the word prioritize, prioritizing, prioritization specifically regarding new clause 32. And yet new clause 32 is categorical. And having checked the Cambridge dictionary, it refers to the word, defines the word prioritize as, and I quote, to decide which group of things, but of course for the purposes of this debate I'll use the word people, are the most important so that you can deal with them first, first.
So if he would care to intervene perhaps he could explain to me how his use of the word prioritizing relates to this clause which is categorical in stating that you cannot gain access to social housing unless you are a British citizen. And I note that he doesn't intervene on me. But I would just also add Mr. Weston that there are other groups of people, I will not rehearse the points so ably made by my honorable friends, but there are other groups of people within living in this country who would be affected by new clause 32. And they include the EU settlement scheme, people under the EU settlement scheme, a scheme brought in under the last Conservative government which allows people who are not British citizens to live here and no doubt they contribute hugely through taxation and other ways to our economy. And finally Mr. Weston, there are also many Gurkhas who have proudly served our armed forces and who I'm sure all honorable members have met and we have the utmost respect for, who often have struggled to gain indefinite leave to remain and who are not British citizens and they would also be excluded from accessing social housing under his clause.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you Mr. Weston. Let me begin by addressing new clause 32 which aims to restrict as we've heard access to social housing to UK citizens. I do think Mr. Weston, and it is my birthday, I'm trying to be as generous as I possibly can, whether deliberate or inadvertent, I think this amendment will sow division. I do think it is divisive. And I think, and the honorable gentleman the member for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich alluded to the real reasons, I think if it wasn't for the threat of Reform on the right of the Conservative party they would not be making arguments in favor of this amendment today.
After all, after all, the system that we are defending on this side is the system they presided over for 14 years in government and did not change. I also think it's really important that we have the debate on the basis of the facts and a proper consideration of what the implications of this amendment would be. My honorable friend the member for Ealing Southall made the point, quite rightly, that eligibility for social housing is already tightly controlled. If a person's visa means they can't access state benefits or local authority housing assistance, they are not eligible for an allocation of social housing, they cannot join a social housing waiting list. My honorable friend the member for Barking made the point, quite rightly, that the vast majority of non-UK nationals are not eligible, as most visas do not grant recourse to public funds.
Those arriving in the UK on skills, work, or student visas, for example, are not eligible, and nor are those who arrive in the country illegally with no leave to remain. Now, it is the case in 2024-25, 89% of lead tenants in new social lettings were UK nationals, the implication being that 11% were not. That 11% includes European nationals, including Irish nationals make up 4% of that, 8% is comprised of people with nationalities from outside of the EEA. That is broadly the same as the previous year. And I think the really important point that was made by a couple of my honorable friends is that even in those households where the lead tenant is not a UK national, they can include UK nationals.
It is not the case that every social household, every household in a social home is comprised entirely of either UK nationals or non-UK nationals. Could have an example where a lead tenant is an Irish citizen who is married to a British citizen. These are the types of families that this amendment would affect. Where non-UK nationals are eligible for social housing, they will have their housing needs considered on the same basis as other eligible applicants in accordance with the local authority's housing allocation scheme. In addition, as my ministerial colleague Baroness Taylor of Stevenage set out at report stage in the other place, under the withdrawal agreement, the agreement negotiated, signed by the previous Conservative government, the UK must treat EU citizens with settled status on the same basis as UK citizens.
New clause 32 would cut across that obligation, would put us in breach of the withdrawal agreement that the party opposite negotiated and signed. I don't think they've thought any of this through. As I say, the previous government oversaw the current arrangements for 14 years. They did consult very late in the day in the previous government on a UK connection test to determine access to social housing. The majority of respondents to that consultation did not agree with the introduction of such a test and feedback highlighted significant concerns around its feasibility and the cost of implementation.
And I think this is really important, even in practical terms, respondents were clear that such a test would increase homelessness pressures and temporary accommodation costs for local authorities. This government set out its response to the previous government's consultation on changes to social housing allocation tests on the 2nd of September 2024, and the conclusion set out in that response remain our position. We don't believe this clause is necessary or workable for the reasons I've outlined, we can't support it. We move on to new clause 37. As set out in the other place, the Secretary of State has powers to issue statutory guidance on social housing allocations to which local authorities must have regard.
Local housing authorities can already take account of whether applicants are foreign public office holders, including their financial circumstances. Any need for further guidance on public office holders and overseas assets should be considered within the existing allocations framework rather than through a separate legislative provision. We are already, as I've said on a couple of occasions previously, reviewing the statutory guidance on social housing allocations, providing an opportunity to consider whether any further clarification is needed on this issue.
Turning finally to new clause 43. The impact of migration on social housing was another issue that was raised during the bill's passage through the other place. I think it is really important to say demand for social housing comes from a multitude of factors, including economic conditions and a range of government policies, so a yearly assessment would not be proportionate. It is an artificial, in our view, and potentially misleading to seek to easily, neatly, and reliably separate the impact of net migration from other factors. Any increase in any one year of social housing lettings to migrants may not be directly due to the net migration figures.
For all these reasons, Mr. Weston, we cannot support these amendments. I hope the shadow minister will withdraw, I suspect not, we're more than happy to take a division on the issue.
Matt Western
New clause 32 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
The contrary no.
Gideon Amos.
Edward Argar.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Olivia Blake.
Hazel Clyne.
Lewis Cocking.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were four, the noes were nine. The noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 42 and new clause 33. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 33.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 33, which stands in my name. Anti-social behavior blights lives. I'm sure all of us in this room have had constituents come to us with problems. Behind every statistic is a family afraid to use their own stairwell because of people gathering after dark, or a child who cannot sleep because of the noise next door.
We believe that where a community protection notice has been issued against a social tenant or somebody living in or regularly visiting a social home, it should be a requirement for the landlord to carry out a tenancy review. And that is what new clause 33 would ensure. This is a measured proposal. It does not dictate an outcome, but it ensures that landlords look at the problem and act. Guidance would be subject to parliamentary scrutiny, and responsible tenants should not suffer because the system looks the other way.
Therefore, Mr. Weston, I encourage colleagues to support new clause 33.
Matt Western
Social housing tenancy review for persistent anti-social behavior. The question is that new clause 33 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. The government recognizes the impact that persistent anti-social behavior can have. I very much agree with both the spirit and the letter of what the shadow minister just said. Our inboxes are full of cases of anti-social behavior that absolutely blights the lives of individuals and entire communities in some cases. And we are clear that no one should feel unsafe in the places where they live, work, or visit.
In all cases of anti-social behavior, but especially where it is persistent, landlords must be able to respond quickly and appropriately. Social landlords already have a range of powers and enforcement tools to tackle anti-social behavior, and we expect them to use them promptly and appropriately, putting the needs of victims at the heart of their response. That's why we don't consider this new clause necessary. Community protection notices are designed to provide a flexible and proportionate response to persistent anti-social behavior. Where a social landlord has been designated by the relevant local authority, it may issue a notice itself.
However, linking every community protection notice to a mandatory review would, in our view, reduce local discretion and add undue administrative burdens on landlords.
The Crime and Policing Act 2026 has strengthened the powers available to the police and other agencies in this area, including an increased maximum fixed penalty for breaching a community protection notice from 100 to 500 pounds and stronger measures to tackle persistent offenders. The Renters' Rights Act has also shortened the notice period for the mandatory anti-social behavior eviction ground, and once implemented in the social rented sector, landlords will be able to make a claim to the court faster in cases of serious anti-social behavior. In that context, Mr. Western, much of what this amendment seeks to achieve duplicates existing powers and regulatory requirements. I hope I've reassured the shadow minister on that basis and hope that he will respectfully withdraw.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
I thank you. I am only somewhat reassured, Mr. Western, but we are still going to press this to a division.
Matt Western
New clause 33 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary, no.
Saqib Bhatti.
Gideon Amos.
Edward Argar.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Hazel Blyskun.
Lewis Cocking.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were five, the noes were eight. So the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 34, which was debated in group 24 with new clause 1. Gareth Bacon to move.
Matt Western
Brownfield social housing development strategy. The question is that new clause 34 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary, no.
Saqib Bhatti.
Gideon Amos.
Edward Argar.
Gareth Bacon.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Hazel Blyskun.
Lewis Cocking.
Deirdre Costigan.
Matthew Pennycook.
John Slinger.
Patrick Spencer.
Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were five, the noes were eight. The noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 43 and new clause 35. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 35.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Western. I rise to move new clause 35, which stands in my name. House building in this country is paralyzed by the layering and complexity of a range of cumbersome regulations and taxes. According to the Home Builders Federation, at present, house builders are already facing more than 7,000 pounds in taxes and levies, including 2,000 pounds in landfill tax, 2,320 pounds from the forthcoming building safety levy, 2,055 pounds in other taxes, and 985 pounds from inflationary increases on existing charges such as section 106 agreements. Moreover, developers face over 23,000 pounds in regulatory costs, including 7,780 for building regulations, 5,700 for biodiversity net gain, and 10,200 in costs linked to the future homes standard.
That's not the end. Indeed, under this government's watch, house builders have seen material and labor costs reach heights of 37,000 pounds, alongside costs of up to 7,000 pounds in additional potential site-specific elements like nutrient mitigation requirements.
Now, we all heard, Mr. Western, what the Chancellor of the Exchequer said in his budget statement yesterday, but that was about no new building regulations, not about looking at those that have exacerbated the problem. Taken together, the cumulative impact of policy, taxation, and regulatory pressures on home building means that it's so costly to build that for many companies it no longer makes economic sense to do so, not least for costlier and less profitable social housing. And that is why I've tabled new clause 35, which would require a review of the regulatory requirements on social housing delivery. That would force the government to confront the reality of these barriers and work to identify the conditions that are preventing a renewed springing of social home sites.
Matt Western
Review of regulatory requirements. The question is that new clause 35 be read a second time. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Thank you to the shadow minister for speaking to new clause 35. As he said, it would require the Secretary of State to review regulatory requirements on local authorities and registered providers of social housing relating to social housing provision. Mr. Western, the government recognizes the importance of ensuring that regulatory requirements on social housing providers are proportionate and that wherever possible they don't place barriers on their ability to deliver new social homes. We want to reduce regulatory burdens across government where we can.
Of course, we must also ensure that necessary regulation is in place to protect social housing residents, ensure that social homes are safe, that high-quality services are delivered, and that providers of social housing are well-governed and financially viable. When introducing new regulations, government ensures that a robust assessment has been made of their impact. I'd also reflect on the fact that there are overarching requirements in place which seek to ensure that regulatory requirements for social housing providers are proportionate. This includes a statutory duty on the Regulator of Social Housing to carry out its work in a way that minimizes interference and, so far as is possible, is proportionate, consistent, transparent, and accountable. I know the shadow minister and I have had debates on these issues many times.
I know that he profoundly disagrees with some of the regulations introduced by the previous government. What I hope we might be clearer on in the months and years to come is precisely which of those regulations the opposition wishes to remove. Does it wish to do away with second staircase requirements? Does it wish to do away with Awaab's Law, which was in legislation that it introduced? We could have a bit of, we could have a longer debate, I'm sure, for another period.
I feel like the energy and enthusiasm of the committee is waning. Put simply, a further review, in our, in our view, is not necessary in this area for the reasons I've given, Mr. Western. I would kindly ask the honorable member to withdraw this new clause.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
The minister is right, we have had extensive debates on this. I know he's tempting me to reveal our manifesto pledges before the election. We are not going to do that, but he is right, we will be making some recommendations about which regulations we think need to be refined or, or thought about again. So I'm going to decline his invitation and we will press for a vote on this occasion.
Matt Western
New clause 35 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division.
Clear the lobby. Lock the doors. Sagal Abwali. Gideon Amos. Edward Argar.
Gareth Bacon. Danny Beales. Rachel Blake. Hazel Clisken. Lewis Cocking.
Speaker 14
Deirdre Costigan. Matthew Pennycook. John Slinger. Patrick Spencer. Laurence Turner.
Matt Western
The ayes were four, the noes were eight, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. I beg to move that further consideration of the bill be now adjourned. All in agreement? Session adjourned.
Order.