House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittings

Elaine Stewart
Mr. Speaker, last week the UK government has announced a financial boost of 11.8 million to support the regional economy across Ayrshire. The money will fund projects across Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock supporting employability and business start-ups. Does my right honourable friend agree with me that while the SNP are obsessed with centralising in Holyrood and taking away local powers, the route to regional economic growth lies within empowering local communities and local councils?
Speaker 10
Well, my honourable friend does a great job standing up for the people of Ayrshire and this 11.8 million pounds will fund jobs, training, and business start-ups right across Ayrshire. In England, this is a government that is backing local areas to generate growth in more areas, and I would love to see the Scottish Nationalist government do the same.
John Tristan Osborne
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and Happy Star Trek Day. Last week, the opposition chose to cling on to the Truss legacy and the damaging legacy it was. How can we pursue, how can we pursue an engage in warp speed to our economy so that our economy continues to grow the fastest in the G7?
Speaker 9
Follow that. Well, Mr. Spock, I think some would say, Mr. Speaker. My honourable friend is right, despite global conflicts, trade tensions, rising threats in the world, which are bearing down on inflation, bearing down on growth, pushing up borrowing costs, nevertheless, the UK economy is demonstrating a huge resilience.
And my honourable friend is right that in the first six months of this year, the UK economy grew the fastest in the G7. And I set out yesterday, Mr. Speaker, some early steps to back stronger growth in more places. Backing innovation with more investment in fast-growth firms across the North. Change in the government's Green Book discount rate so projects across the country with long-term potential will get a fairer hearing. And taking an axe to the thicket of administration that too often slows down decisions, holds back growth, and prevents the private investment that we need to see.
Havant
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This week, Arthur Laffer, economic advisor to three former US presidents, said Britain is being taxed to death under this Labour government. So can the Chancellor rule out tax rises in the budget?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the honourable gentleman could have asked that question to any Chancellor at any time in the last few decades. And no Chancellor ahead of a budget will comment on speculation or rule measures out. The decisions I take, I will set out before the House. I'll set them out on the 28th of October. And I look forward to the honourable gentleman being there on that day.
Sarah Olney
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The former Chancellor invested a significant amount of political capital into driving forward the white elephant project of building a third runway at Heathrow on the basis it would deliver economic growth. But the government's own appraisal report states that the net present value of expansion ranges between minus 23.4 billion to minus 62.5 billion. So will this Chancellor put an end to this absurd proposal?
Speaker 9
Quite simply, Mr. Speaker, after years of delay, years of indecision, years of often vexatious challenge, we have given the go-ahead to this project quite simply because the economic case stacks up and will help bring growth.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And Mr. Speaker, I do welcome the Chancellor's clampdown on speculation and leaks ahead of the budget. It's certainly an important step that he's taken. But on the issue of certainty, the National Wealth Fund is a critical investor in crowding in private investment around the UK. I note that he's changed the remit.
How is he going to balance his desire to see change with making sure that that too is strong and stable and making sure that there is certainty for businesses who are seeking to invest with the support of the National Wealth Fund?
Speaker 9
I thank my right honourable friend for that. I thank her for the work she does in chairing the Treasury Select Committee and her previous work on the Public Accounts Committee. She is right about the damage of speculation ahead of budget. It led last year to a large number of people, for instance, cashing in pension pots on the basis of speculation that was entirely unfounded. On the question you asked about the National Wealth Fund, we've capitalized this by over 200 billion pounds.
The challenge here is to make sure that we get good value for money decisions, but decisions made quicker so that we can get investment into local areas to see the private investment bring the growth we need.
Edward Robert Jenrick
Can I welcome the right honourable gentleman to his position? I've known him for a long time. I wish him well. He has a huge task ahead of him. Earlier in the summer, the Prime Minister said that walking the streets of Makerfield, it was lodged in his mind that so many working people wanted to see the personal allowance raised.
In Reform, we want to as well. In fact, we want to raise it to 15,000 pounds a year and to make work pay.
Is it still the Prime Minister and the Chancellor's ambition to raise the personal allowance?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, at the budget last year, my right honorable friend continued the freeze in the personal allowance that was brought in first by the party opposite. That was to help fund the improvements in health and schools that this country needs, that the people voted for at the election just two years ago. And I just say to the honorable gentleman, we will keep all of this under review as we always do. And I just say to him, Reform are making promises that they simply can't keep. And this, he's right that I've known him a long time, but I just say to him, and to say to the country actually, this is also a man whose own party leader described as a man who believed in nothing.
Speaker 8
Just by help with the Chancellor, he doesn't need to worry, he's no responsibility for Reform. Can I come now to Shadow Minister Dame Harriet Baldwin?
Harriet Baldwin
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And in welcoming the Chancellor to his new role, I paid close attention yesterday to the long speech that he made to reset the narrative and to drive growth Britain. In paying tribute to his predecessor, will he recognize that she has left the highest tax burden on record? And instead of postponing the words he could utter to my honorable friend the member for Havant, could he make a short speech today from the dispatch box to say that he does not plan to increase the tax burden further?
Speaker 9
Well, Mr. Speaker, I could have been a lot longer yesterday. I'm grateful to her for watching or reading it. But quite simply, in the two years of this Labour government, we've started to see this country beginning to turn a corner. That's a corner after 14 years in which the previous Tory governments had a record of low growth, high debt, and a mini-budget which crashed the British economy and collapsed confidence in Britain's fiscal strength. And I just say to her, this is a country with huge strengths in its people, in its businesses, in its communities that want to seize the future.
This is a country in which interest rates have been cut six times since the election, in which borrowing, still too high, is down to a six-year low, in which growth, still fragile and under pressure, was fastest in the first half of this year in the G7, and productivity and investment finally, after long Conservative years, beginning to tick up. That's the basis on which we now build.
Daisy Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Chancellor to his place, and after two anti-growth budgets, can I genuinely wish him well and urge him to deliver a growth budget this autumn so we can avoid more punishing tax rises or painful spending cuts? Mr. Speaker, last week, the Prime Minister acknowledged that Brexit had ushered in a decade of low growth, but did not outline what he thinks is needed to tackle it.
The Chancellor made what was briefed as a major economic speech on growth, the product of deep thinking, and yet barely a mention of the impact of Brexit at all. Recent studies, Mr. Speaker, suggest that deeper alignment with Europe could boost GDP by at least 2.5 to 3.6%. So can I ask the Chancellor whether his plan for growth will include our call for a growth and defense partnership with the EU?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the honorable lady is talking to the person who led the work to establish a defense and security partnership with the European Union and bilateral agreements with other countries on which we now build both our economic strength and our national security strength. On the question of the budget, I'd just say to her, look at what we have done in the seven weeks of this government. We know we can't relieve the cost of living and the cost of business pressures, but we will take steps where we can to do that. And that principle I will take into the budget, and we will back business, and we will do what we can to see growth in more places across the country, because for too long this is a country that has relied on too few of our major cities to drive our national growth.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Question number two please, Mr. Speaker.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and with permission I should like to answer this question together with question number 11. My honorable friends are right to ask these fiscal questions, and I agree with them that private investment is critical to delivering good growth in every postcode. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor have been clear that centralization of power has led to too much of the country losing out on investment, leading to lower productivity and lower living standards for our constituents. The Chancellor set out yesterday his vision to shift power and resources so that they sit with local leaders to enable long-term local investment and industrial strategies that will crowd in private investment.
Melanie On
Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, is an industrious heartland known around the world for its prowess in ceramics. With the right support, its full economic potential can be unleashed. As an officer on the Labour Reindustrialization Research Group, I am working with Stoke Council on a reindustrialization plan. To ensure that Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, make the fullest possible contribution to growth across the UK, will the Minister commit the Treasury to working with us on a reindustrialization plan to maximize our region's expertise in advanced materials, defense, and digital technology so we can all go forth and prosper?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I fully agree with my honorable friend that going forth and prospering is a very good objective. And I look forward to working with her and local businesses in her constituency that she's been raising with me, including Mantech and Goodwin, some fantastic ceramics and advanced manufacturing businesses. We need to identify, and across the Treasury and Number 10 North, we will work with local leaders and with parliamentarians to make sure we can identify the right clusters in the right places to back and support.
Liverpool
Thank you, thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last month, Liverpool City Region's visitor economy reached 6.8 billion pounds, and our productivity growth is currently running at four times the national average. The region has an incredibly exciting plan to redevelop Central Station in the city center and link it to Lime Street. It would be one of the most important growth stories and opportunities for the whole of the North of England, and it will drive billions in investments from the private sector. Can I ask the Minister, when he visits us for party conference, would he take a little bit of time to meet with Mayor Rotheram and the leader of the council, Liam Robinson, to see their exciting plans?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
I thank my honorable friend for his question, and I'm delighted to inform him, actually, that my conference calendar already includes a meeting with local leaders in Liverpool to talk about what we can do to back growth and back investment in his city and in his region. I've been in conversations already with the Mayor of the city region about the things that he wants to work on and focus on to boost economic growth, and that includes conversations about the Liverpool Central development.
Carla Lockhart
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Private investment into the steel industry in Northern Ireland is being curtailed by the Windsor Framework because it is now forcing businesses in Upper Bann to pay 50% EU tariffs on category 4 and 7 steel. How many jobs must be lost across Northern Ireland's manufacturing sector before the Chancellor takes action on this crazy steel tariff situation?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government does of course understand the challenges of this of the implementation of steel tariffs, but of course we do have to make sure that we keep a foundational steel sector in the UK. That is critical for our national supply and for our national security. And the government looked very carefully at making sure that the tariffs were applied in the right way to protect downstream suppliers. And of course we will continue to engage with industry and with members of Parliament on these important decisions.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Good growth in every postcode. It's a very catchy slogan, but it will mean nothing if it isn't backed up with investment. Time and again, significant funding is announced for cities and urban areas, usually in the North, while the South West is left with pennies in comparison. And yet again, the Chancellor yesterday announced investment in the North with once again no mention of investment into the South West.
Might be due to political expediency, I couldn't possibly say. But I'd like to ask the Minister, what is the government going to do specifically to encourage growth in the South West?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
I thank my the honourable member for her question and she does raise of course an important point that we need to make sure we see high economic growth in every part of the country. That includes the North, the East, the West and of course the South West of England. We have many fantastic members on both sides of the house who are working and advocating for their communities. We will make sure that we drive devolution and deepen devolution in areas that don't yet have a mayor. And the Prime Minister's also discussed the need to make sure that those that don't want to have a mayor, he highlighted Cornwall, can have a specific further devolution powers.
One of the examples, which is not too far I believe from her constituency, is that we're looking at place-based business cases so we can unlock investment in particular parts of the country. And one of those places that we're looking at in detail is Plymouth.
Minister.
Speaker 29
Mr. Speaker, with permission, I would like to answer this question with questions number 18, 20 and 23. Mr. Speaker, we love our pubs and so to support them, in his first week of taking office, the Prime Minister announced a 20% cut in business rates for them as well as for social clubs and live music venues from April 2027, building on the 15% reduction earlier this year. I and other ministers have regular discussions with representatives from the pubs and hospitality sector to understand the impact of business rates support.
Ben Bradley
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now, my first job was pot washing and waitressing in a pub at 14. And today they help me bring fellow residents together for my pub politics events across the Filton and Bradley Stoke constituency. I know how much our pubs mean to us locally and I warmly welcome further support for them. Could the Minister please set out how this support will help give pubs and the wider sector the certainty they need so that they and great jobs like these are here for generations to come?
Speaker 36
I well I thank my honourable friend and I know she's a great champion of pubs in her constituency. And in fact she has brought together people for her pub politics events, including at the Willy Wicket, the Beaufort Arms, the Baileys Court Inn, where I myself have been, and the White Lion, where they come to talk about issues that matter to them. I can set out to her that the support we are providing for pubs will be worth nearly 250 million pounds next year and that will benefit around 32,000 venues, which helps to make sure that they and the jobs they provide will be there for the future.
Peter Swallow
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently stopped by the wonderful Koh-i-Noor Indian restaurant in Prestwood to meet its owner, Kamran, and speak about the realities of running a family-owned restaurant. He told me how rising costs were making it challenging for him to invest and grow his business. So while I genuinely welcome the Chancellor's action on cutting business rates for pubs and music venues, ahead of the budget, will the Minister look at what more he can do to support the hospitality and retail businesses that are at the heart of our local communities?
Speaker 29
Mr. Speaker, I thank my honorable friend for highlighting the contribution that businesses such as Koh-i-Noor provide to local communities and local economies. As he set out, the government is helping pubs right now because of the important community assets they are and the real pressures that they face. But let me assure him that we will continue to look at what more we can do to support high street businesses more widely to help them to invest and grow.
North Wales
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Like our new Prime Minister, many of us on the North Wales coast love the pubs and music venues of the Northwest, and the boost to them from business rates relief is really welcome. But we love our pubs and venues too. Pubs like the Bay Hop and the Maykey face the same challenges as our Northwest neighbors, and we want to attract more live music to North Wales too. Decisions on business rates in Wales are of course the responsibility of the Welsh government, but does the Minister agree with me that the need for support does not stop at the border and that a 20% cut to business rates in Wales would be a welcome boost for us too?
Speaker 36
Mr. Speaker, I very much agree with my honorable friend about the vital role that pubs and clubs play in local communities on either side of the border. And as she rightly points out, business rates decisions in Wales are a decision for the Welsh government. Now, whilst in England we have taken action to support community venues and high streets, including the targeted business rate support for pubs, I would urge the Welsh government to consider doing the same.
Swindon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Pubs across Swindon like Arkle's have contacted me regularly about the reduction in business rates, so I thank the Minister for doing that. But can he outline if there is going to be any further business rate reductions for the wider hospitality sector? Thank you.
Amanda Hack
I will thank my honorable friend for his question, and I know that he's a great champion for pubs and other hospitality venues within his constituency, including Arkle's Brewery, who I know supplies pubs across Swindon and Wiltshire. As he rightly points out, we provided support that the Prime Minister announced soon after taking office for pubs and community venues, and we will consider all options for what we can do to further support them in the budget.
Nigel Huddleston
That's some brass neck, Mr. Speaker. I'm astounded that the Minister can stand there and expect credit and gratitude for giving a little bit of support for a sector that his own policies have undermined and destroyed to the tune of two pubs a day closing down and 100,000 job losses in hospitality and tourism because of his policies. So will he instead adopt conservative policies for 100% business rates relief and actually support these sectors rather than giving hypocritical warm words?
Speaker 29
Mr. Speaker, the honorable gentleman has some cheek given the number of pubs that closed when his party were in government. This party is making sure the business rates system is set right for the future. Not only have we announced the 20% cut in business rates for pubs as a result of the new Prime Minister taking office, but I was also pleased to announce a review of the way that pubs and hotels are valued for the future following concerns raised by that sector. This will be reporting in time for decisions taken on the basis of it to be in place for the next revaluation.
Joshua Peter Reynolds
Mr. Speaker, pubs, cafes and restaurants are among the largest employers of young people across the country, but the sector has seen 100,000 job losses as a result of the government's jobs tax. Now, business rate relief might make one piece of impact, but what the hospitality sector is telling us they need is a cut in VAT to really help people get back into hospitality venues. So has the government looked at what a cut in VAT would be able to do in both growth and new jobs?
Speaker 27
Well, Mr. Speaker, the honorable gentleman is absolutely right to point out the important role that pubs and hospitality plays in providing jobs and indeed jobs for young people. But I would gently say to him, Mr. Speaker, that one of the issues with the Lib Dems is that they welcome extra investment in our NHS and public services, but they never want to pay for it. And when it comes to hard decisions on the economy, all they offer is soft politics.
Paul Bowles.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The 20% rate cut for music venues and pubs is of course very welcome. But what my high street in Bath really needs is an overhaul of the business rate system which the Labour government actually promised. So will he do the bold thing and not just excuse us not having ideas, will he do the bold thing, get rid of business rates and replace it with a commercial landowner levy?
Mr. Speaker, as the Prime Minister made clear when he took office, we're giving pubs and community venues real breathing space through the 20% cut to their business rates. But our reform of business rates and our support for the high street doesn't end there. And we're considering every possible opportunity to support retail, hospitality and leisure businesses on the high street so that high streets in all of our communities across the country can thrive.
Tom Morrison
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently visited the Station House in Cheadle Hulme, which is one of the Almond family's fine pubs across Stockport. And I spoke to the owner Doug about how hard it is for him to run his business. And like many pubs across the country, they welcome the 20% cut on business rates, but they're contending with a system that penalizes hospitality. So I understand the Minister really dodged the question from my colleague, the member for Bath.
So can I really get him to commit, will this government overhaul the business rate system so community pubs like the Station House can help our high streets thrive?
Speaker 27
Well, Mr. Speaker, I thank the honorable gentleman for talking about the Station House in his constituency. And I'm sure we all have pubs in our own local neighborhoods that we feel are right at the heart of the local communities we represent. The announcement of 20% cut to business rates was a down payment for further reform. We're going to continue to look at what we can do to support pubs, hospitality and other high street uses because we know that they matter so much to everyone in this chamber and to all of the people who we represent.
Daisy Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As the Member of Parliament for the constituency with more pubs per square mile than anywhere else in Britain, I have been campaigning to reform the broken business rate system for longer than I have been an MP. Now, my understanding is that the government's review will look at the fair and maintainable trade criteria, which sees pubs singled out to be valued on the basis of what they could earn rather than what they actually do earn. But as my honorable friends for Bath and Cheadle have highlighted, this review falls far short of the Labour Party manifesto, which pledged to overhaul the entire business rate system. So can I ask ministers, does that pledge still stand, and if so, will they overhaul the business rate system before the next general election?
Speaker 31
Mr. Speaker, I wonder if there are any other honorable members who might say that they have the most pubs in their constituency, or whether the honorable member has done her research.
Speaker 27
I hear her intervening saying they're the best pubs, apparently, which there may be even more members challenging in this chamber. But I thank the honourable lady for her question. And, you know, I think although we have some differences, you know, we share a desire to see a fairer business rates system for the future. The 20% cut for pubs and community venues, I know was widely welcomed. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor have made clear that we want to continue looking at what we can do to support hospitality venues, pubs, and other high street uses for the future.
This is not a question of taking one policy announcement from July and thinking that's the end of the story, because we know how important high streets are for communities across the country and we want to see them thrive for the future.
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, this is a government determined to help good councils and businesses breathe new life into our high streets and our town centres. In April, we introduced a permanent reduced tax rate for high street businesses worth almost a billion pounds. And in July, with the new Prime Minister in the first week, he and I announced a further 20% cut for pubs, social clubs, and music venues. This is a government that will do what it can to help bring a bit of breathing space from the cost of living and the cost of business.
Altrincham and Sale West MP
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And in Altrincham and Sale West, we know the impact that our pubs and bars contribute to the high streets we are so proud of locally. It goes beyond their economic impact. They create a sense of community that's so important to local people. And the government cutting business rates by 20% was indeed welcome for them.
But I know from events I've held locally with the Altrincham Business Improvement District that they still face challenges and need more support. So can I ask the Chancellor to update the House on what more he will do to support all hospitality businesses in constituencies like mine going forward?
Speaker 9
Well, my honourable friend really does speak up very strongly for his local area in Altrincham and Sale West. And he's right about the importance of pubs, social clubs, live venues, the importance of that 20% cut that we announced in July, because these are the things that make the places we live the places we also love. And later this year, we will be producing as a government our high street strategy. I'd encourage him to contribute to my honourable friend the Secretary of State for MHCLG in that work. And as my honourable friend the Financial Secretary has just said, he should see the move we made in July as a down payment for further reform.
Beverley
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Conservatives will save our high street. And can I explain, Mr. Speaker, to the Chancellor why that's important? Donna, who ran the Beverley Card Company, saw this Labour government increase her business rates from 135 pounds a month to 840 pounds a month. That's why, Mr. Speaker, in February, after 30 years of running that business, having won national awards, the business closed.
And she's going to have to make payments for the next four years for those business rates. So will the Chancellor stop trimming, support the Conservative plan, and abolish business rates altogether for the 250,000 high street businesses and stop talking and sounding sympathetic and actually do something that makes a difference to the high streets?
Speaker 9
Well, what an extraordinary claim, Mr. Speaker, that is hard to take seriously and I hope his constituents in the same way, that somehow the Conservatives will save our high streets. I'd just say to him, in the... we're concerned, of course, about the impact of business taxation.
As a government, we've put in 4.3 billion pounds to help cushion the changes, including in his area. And we are in the process of taking further steps to review and reform the business rates system, and I'll be able to set out more details at the budget.
Gareth Davies
Mr. Speaker, the Chancellor is going around lauding an apparent cut to business rates, but it was his government that reduced business rates relief for retail, hospitality, and leisure from 75% to 40%. If he goes out there and speaks to any average pub, they will tell him that their business rates have almost doubled. So why won't he answer the question as to why he can't and won't follow the Conservative plan to cut spiraling Labour's welfare bill to fund an abolishment of business rates for hundreds of thousands of high street businesses across our country?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister and I have been clear that we must cut the cost of welfare, but I have to say to him, on levels of taxation, you had a period of Conservative government, low growth, high debt, a crashed economy in the mini-budget, and levels of levels of taxation which were putting pressure on business, adding to the cost of living. What you've seen under this government now is a willingness to recognize those pressures, to do what we can, not to remove, but to relieve where we can, give people and families a bit of breathing space from the cost of living and businesses a bit of breathing space from the cost of business. And that's why the move the Prime Minister and I made in July for pubs, social clubs, and live venues was so welcomed.
Speaker 50
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With permission, I would like to group questions five and 16. The government will support good growth in every postcode, including in Cornwall and Gloucester. We've already established Number 10 North to work in partnership with local leaders, businesses, and communities, and at the budget next month, we will publish plans for further fiscal devolution, including greater retention of business rates revenue for local councils and strategic authorities.
Gloucester
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Minister for her answer. I fully support the government's exciting agenda of devolution, taking power out of Whitehall and into the hands of residents and communities like mine. However, in my constituency of Gloucester, we don't have a metro mayor and we're not part of a combined authority. I'm determined to ensure that Gloucester is not left behind and is included in our important plans going forward. So can the Minister confirm how we can work together to ensure that Gloucester feels the benefits and the investment from the government's devolution agenda?
Speaker 51
I thank my honorable friend and he's a great champion for his constituency. The cabinet statement on devolution set out the government's ambitions to accelerate devolution across the country by establishing a strategic authority for every area in England that wants one by the end of 2028. All strategic authorities, including those without a mayor, will benefit from greater powers over skills, transport, and housing.
Perran Moon
Mr. Speaker, as the furthest southerly Labour MP in the UK, I note several recent announcements of funding going to the north of England and mayoral strategic authorities. I've been very encouraged by the Prime Minister's comments relating to Cornish devolution with no requirement for Cornwall to join a mayoral strategic authority, but can the Minister elaborate on how changes to regional funding arrangements will support the Cornish economy?
Speaker 51
As you said, the Prime Minister has been engaging with Cornwall, you know, including with and importantly with the six MPs there, including my honorable friend, on a devolution agreement. This will support the Cornish economy through stronger statutory powers on transport and housing and the ability to introduce an overnight visitor levy, which can then be invested in projects that drive growth in the region. As he'll know also, the government is already investing in Cornwall's high-potential sectors with the 30 million pounds Kernow Industrial Growth Fund.
John Glen
Can I welcome the Chief Secretary to her new position? But what words of comfort could she give the residents of Salisbury in Wiltshire, a unitary authority? We're not part of a combined authority, we don't have a metro mayor. Since this government has come in, we've seen the lowest settlement, or one of the lowest three settlements, on police funding and local government funding. We've seen the withdrawal of funding for our road network in the south of Wiltshire.
There is a concern that with the focus elsewhere in big urban metropolitan areas, that rural England will be forgotten. Is that not likely to be the case?
Speaker 51
I thank the honorable gentleman. Again, I am following in his footsteps, taking on another job that he did in government. Can I reassure him, as a former environment secretary and living in a rural area in Buckinghamshire myself and representing a semi-rural seat, that of course this government cares about driving growth in rural areas? And there's great potential there, which is why we are supporting our farmers through a 2.7 billion pounds a year sustainable farming budget, and also we're improving connectivity for rural areas too.
Andrew George
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Notwithstanding the Minister's response to my honorable friend, the member for Camborne and Redruth, does the Minister not also need to reflect on the fact that of course Cornwall, being the poorest region in the country and therefore entitled to EU Objective 1 aid, is now receiving no regional funding whatsoever? And that simply is not sustainable for a region which really does need additional support in order to get the growth happening.
Speaker 51
I thank the honorable gentleman for his question, but I disagree with his assessment. And also there are opportunities here for areas, as I said to my honorable friend, who don't opt to have a mayor but who set up as foundation strategic authorities to gain the benefit of retaining more business rates and will benefit from greater powers over skills, transport, and housing too.
Minister.
Speaker 29
Mr. Speaker, with permission, I would like to answer this question with question number 22. Mr. Speaker, as the government announced in May, as part of a 600 million pound package, there will be no rise in fuel duty this year. This means that the temporary 5p cut will be extended until the end of the year, providing certainty to motorists. In total, the decisions taken since the 2024 general election to freeze fuel duty save motorists 11p per liter, or 120 pounds per year for the average car, compared to plans inherited from the previous government.
Christine Jardine
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I appreciate what the Minister has said about the fuel duty freeze, but the Liberal Democrats have called for an emergency cut of 10p, which would make a difference of 12p at the pump per liter for ordinary families.
Now, for my hard-pressed constituents in Edinburgh West, this winter that can make a big difference, not only to the travel costs, but to the cost of food and other services. So will the government consider that emergency cut in the forthcoming budget?
Speaker 27
Well, Mr. Speaker, I agree with the honourable lady about the importance of providing breathing space for families. That's a priority for us as a government. And she mentions her plans. I set out what we've done already since the general election to reduce fuel prices by 11p per litre compared to what they would have been otherwise. As I set out in my earlier remarks, the 5p cut will be has been extended to the end of the year.
And as she would expect, any future decisions will be taken at the budget by the Chancellor.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I cannot believe the minister just said he wanted to give families breathing space when the RAC Foundation has found that since fuel prices increased due to international issues earlier this year, the Treasury have raked in one billion pounds extra from the VAT on fuel. So how can it possibly be fair on motorists or give them any breathing space whatsoever to carry on with another fuel hike in January, fuel duty hike in January?
Speaker 27
Well, Mr. Speaker, the honourable gentleman is right to point to the fact that international events have an impact on prices here at home. We did not want to get involved in that conflict, unlike the party opposite. But we are impacted nonetheless. And the right thing for us to do as a government, Mr. Speaker, is to make sure we are providing breathing space for families as we weather international events.
Danny Beales
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the cut on fuel duty that the government has committed to. But as well as being squeezed at the pumps, motorists are also being ripped off by unfair monthly insurance charges. Does the minister agree with me that insurance companies should not be charging unfair and unjustified additional costs for monthly insurance that most people can only afford? And will the minister meet with me to discuss the Which? research which has found that people paying monthly insurance are paying hundreds of pounds in additional costs?
Speaker 27
Well, I thank my honourable friend for his comments. And he's right to say that of course fuel duty is one cost that families face. But families also face a number of other costs, including through insurance as he rightly set out. And I'd be very happy to meet with him to discuss this issue. I know what a formidable campaigner he is on a range of issues and so I'd be happy to meet with him to discuss that or ask my colleague to do so if that's a issue's better placed to do so.
Euan Stainbank
I welcome the government's fuel duty freeze for working families alongside the road tax holiday for hauliers and red diesel fuel duty cut as well. Fuel costs for businesses in my constituency, such as Northfield Quarry near Dunipace, have nearly tripled due to the Iran war and the previous government's tightening of eligibility for red diesel. Would the Chancellor consider in the budget extending fuel duty reductions for industries such as quarrying that are essential for house construction and provide good local jobs for working families?
Speaker 27
Well, I thank my honourable friend for his request of the Chancellor at the budget. As the Chancellor set out earlier on, the Chancellor will of course take those decisions at the budget in the normal way. But he's made a powerful case for his constituent and used this opportunity to make sure that all of us on the Treasury front bench has heard what he has to say.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Fuel duty is catnip for a Chancellor desperate for revenue, but it's no sin tax because millions of Britons need vehicles and they're not luxuries, they're lifelines. The imminent fuel duty rise is coming in as tankers are ablaze in the Straits of Hormuz. Must family budgets also go up in flames?
Speaker 27
I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. And I think the point he may have been making was that the prices of fuel are linked to international events, which is of course something I said earlier I very much agree with. That's why it's important that we de-escalate the situation in the Strait of Hormuz. That is the most important way to bring down the cost of fuel. But in the meantime, this government is determined to give people breathing space.
The 5p cut is extended to the end of the year. We have had a £2 cap on bus fares. We're removing VAT from electricity bills. And all of that is about giving families across the country breathing space as we weather international events' impact on us.
Sir Jeremy Hunt.
Speaker 51
Mr. Speaker, public sector productivity is improving, with the NHS delivering 3.5% productivity growth in 25-26, beating their 2% target. And the government will continue to drive public sector efficiency so that taxpayers' money delivers the best possible public services. In addition to this, we are investing in AI adoption across the public sector to help realise the overall target of £14 billion of efficiencies by 28-29 as agreed at the last spending review.
Jeremy Hunt
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Chief Secretary to her new role? And if she has any questions, can I recommend an excellent book by a former Chancellor which has a number of tips? The public sector is 20% of our national output, so a major opportunity for the government to improve our national productivity. Was it wise to give the ASLEF train drivers on the Avanti West Coast route an above-inflation pay rise without any apparent productivity quid pro quo?
With public finances so tight, shouldn't the rule be no above-inflation increases unless there is a productivity alongside it?
Speaker 51
I thank the right honourable gentleman, and I'm wondering when the third book in the trilogy is going to come along and what it might be called. We've got a bit of a guess on the next title of the book, if he doesn't mind. I thank him for his advice in his books and in his recent FT article. When it comes to train drivers and their pay, I'm proud to be part of a government that has avoided strikes that impact on public spending.
Speaker 95
Mr. Speaker, public sector productivity is improving, with the latest ONS figures showing output continuing to grow faster than inputs. And departments are being challenged to improve efficiency and modernise outdated processes. Could the Minister confirm the government's expectations that this will have a positive impact for residents in Feltham and Heston and across the country to ensure that services, government services, are faster, better, and easier to access?
Speaker 51
I couldn't agree more with my honourable friend. Driving public sector productivity is extremely important in two ways. Firstly, because we get better value for money for taxpayers for the tax that people are putting in, including taxpayers in her own constituency. But also we are driving efficiencies, as she says, faster service delivery, using AI in the NHS to really drive improvements in care as well as delivering more bang for buck.
Speaker 72
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Many commentators, Mr. Speaker, have commented about public sector productivity underperformance. EY tells us that the public sector has underperformed to the point where it has cut GDP growth by 3% since 2019. The Institute for Government highlights an average of nearly 1% underperformance every year for that same period. Morgan Stanley reminds us that in the last year, private sector productivity was up 1.8%, but public sector underperformance dragged it back into negative territory.
Why is this government rewarding poor performance and does the Chancellor think that this is sustainable?
Speaker 51
I can reassure the honorable gentleman that we are focused on driving public sector productivity to reach those efficiency targets that I talked about. We're holding each department to account for that and as I said to his right honorable friend, we are seeing great progress in the NHS, which is making a huge contribution to our productivity gains as a government.
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, since day one in the job, the Prime Minister and I have been in lockstep in our determination to meet Britain's fiscal rules. This is the bedrock on which we build good growth and help give a bit of breathing space to families and to businesses. We acted in the first week, Mr. Speaker, to cap bus fares, cut business rates for pubs, social clubs and live venues and cut VAT on electricity bills. We've also announced further sanctions on Russia, we've changed procurement rules to back British jobs, we launched a new plan for growth from places right across the UK and 100 million pounds to back British sovereign AI firms. This is a Labour government that is determined to deliver good growth in every postcode and sound fiscal discipline.
Steph Akoro.
Steph Akoro
Mr. Speaker, if the Treasury wants a quick trick to increase tax receipts from employment, can I suggest the Chancellor looks at taking steps to boost rural bus connectivity? North Norfolk has independent operators like Central Connect who in spite of challenges facing the sector have managed to double their bus frequency in Stalham and Hoveton. They want to go further. Can he tell us how he will work with the Department for Transport to make sure barriers are lifted and support is provided to bring more buses to my constituents?
Speaker 9
Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm disappointed he didn't recognize that for his constituents in Norfolk, capping bus fares must be a benefit to them and a benefit to passengers. And beyond that, Mr. Speaker, let me take his contribution as an early budget representative.
Julie Minns.
Julie Minns
Child Trust Funds were designed to give every child the same financial start regardless of who they are. However, trust fund savings are currently taken into account when assessing an 18-year-old disabled person's financial contribution to their social care, meaning that they do not get the same financial start as their non-disabled peers. What steps is the Minister taking to ensure that all young people benefit in full from their Child Trust Funds?
Speaker 74
Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to my honorable friend for her question. She raises a concern about the interaction between matured Child Trust Funds and an adult social care assessment. The financial assessment framework to which she refers is a matter for the Department of Health, but I am of course more than happy to facilitate a meeting, a conversation with her and between the relevant departmental minister.
Andrew Griffith
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And first let me pay tribute to my own predecessor, the right honorable member for Central Devon. And let me welcome the Chancellor to his role. He is already responsible for the highest borrowing costs for 28 years.
One in six of our young people are unemployed. And yesterday we had the news that one of Britain's top taxpayers is leaving our country. Every time a billionaire leaves, our country becomes poorer. Chris Rokos is reported to have paid over 300 million pounds in taxes last year. So could the Chancellor tell us how many average taxpayers will it take to replace him?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, I welcome the new Shadow Chancellor to his place. I thank him for his words.
I welcome him back to the Treasury brief and perhaps on our side we'll have more to say about that later. And can I also echo his comments about the the role of the right honorable gentleman, the member for Central Devon. He has played an important role in this House, including as his cross-party work during the pandemic as chair of the Select Committee. We thank him for it as he steps down from the from the front bench. I just say to the honorable gentleman, look, he takes he takes reports he takes reports in the paper and tries to make serious points in this House.
We will set out our plans to give to give families and businesses a bit of breathing space at the budget. We will set out our plans to back good growth in more places throughout this country. And we will set out our plans at the budget to rebuild confidence in strong British fiscal discipline that was lost under his government.
Andrew Griffith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. He doesn't know. On the Treasury's own statistics, to make up for the loss of Chris Rokos, it would take 38,000 average income taxpayers. That's a lot of breathing space paid for, Chancellor. And that means higher taxes for everyone else or lower public spending.
We know what Labour will choose. The last Chancellor raised taxes on farmers, family businesses, and jobs. Conservatives will reform welfare to cut your taxes. Labour always put them up. So which, if any, of his predecessor's damaging decisions will he reverse?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the future of this country will be written in our growth rates after 14 years in which we had low growth, we had high debt, and we had a budget which crashed the confidence in the British economy. You've seen under this government already a new way of seeing growth generated in more places across the country. You've seen the way that we will reform the center of Whitehall so that we cut through slow decision-making, public leadership and control, accountable to the people. And announcements I've made yesterday, the way that we will go further to axe the thicket of administration, to back fast-growth firms, and also to change the way in which we generate investment across the country.
Loughborough
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In areas like mine in the East Midlands, growth has been too low because spending has been too low. And as life has become unaffordable, growth has fallen even further. We're seeing that both in my local area, but we're seeing nationally with a rising output gap as well. So can the Minister set out how making life affordable will make growth rise in my area, in my constituency of Loughborough, Shepshed, and the villages?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for his question. He is an expert on these matters and is totally right to point to the importance of looking at the demand side of the economy. The Chancellor and the Prime Minister have focused on just that, Mr. Speaker, for example with the cut to VAT on electricity bills and the reinstatement of the £2 bus cap on bus fares for 2027. And he, my honorable friend, will also support the big focus on the supply side that the Chancellor was talking about in his speech yesterday, improving the productive capacity of our economy so we can build more homes, labs, transport, and power.
East Yorkshire
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now I doubt businesses in East Yorkshire will have taken much comfort from the Chancellor's words today. But with youth unemployment spiraling out of control, what is his message to young people in my constituency unable to find a job as a direct result of the punishing business taxes of his predecessor?
Torsten Bell
Well, I thank the honorable member for his question. Employment levels have risen since the general election, but he's absolutely, he's absolutely right to highlight that too few young people are getting the chance to move into work and actually to participate in education.
That's exactly what the Milburn report is looking at. I hope he'll be feeding into that, but we're not waiting for that report. The government is already acting. That's what the job guarantee is doing. That is what the three thousand pounds going to businesses that employ young people on Universal Credit will receive.
It is absolutely right that it is a moral as well as economic imperative to get young people into work.
Lindsay Hoyle
Could I just say to both sides of the front bench, I really am struggling to get these members in. It's now twenty-nine minutes past and we've not even got through the topicals. So can you help me to help them? Right, Catherine West please.
Catherine West
Speaker, I applaud the Prime Minister's rates cut for English pubs, but the Plaid Cymru government in Wales has done nothing to help Welsh pubs. That's why I'm supporting the 'Vat's the Problem' campaign, which will cut the VAT, which is much needed for our struggling hospitality businesses, to ten percent, like other EU countries. So can ministers in the Treasury please look at this and help us to help our hospitality businesses in Monmouthshire?
Speaker 27
Mr. Speaker, fiscal decisions are taken at the budget, but I would join my honorable friend in urging the Welsh government to consider extending the support that we have given to English pubs to pubs in Wales too.
Moray
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Following this summer, recovery will be at the forefront for communities in Moray and other constituencies who have been impacted by devastating wildfires. Many of these businesses are in the hospitality sector, whose pressures are well documented. A reduction in VAT would provide a much-needed boost, enable reinvestment by these businesses, and support economic growth. Will the Chancellor therefore consider a cut to VAT for hospitality?
Speaker 27
Well, Mr. Speaker, as I said a moment ago, decisions on fiscal matters are taken at the budget, but I would urge the honorable gentleman to urge the Scottish government to follow the UK government's example in providing support to pubs in Scotland too.
Adam Thompson
Speaker, the Chancellor will no doubt be aware that this month marks the four-year anniversary of the disastrous Liz Truss mini-budget, which risked my constituents' pensions and locked thousands out of home ownership. Last week, we saw Liz Truss's financial secretary made Shadow Chancellor. Does my right honorable friend then have any advice for the Shadow Chancellor on how he might learn from his mistakes?
Speaker 9
My honorable friend is right, the Truss mini-budget means that families now with a new mortgage are paying six hundred pounds a year more. The government is paying more for our borrowing, which we could be spending on schools and hospitals. Mr. Speaker, this is the man who also at the weekend said that Truss mini-budget had, I quote, 'lots of good things' in that. Mr. Speaker, with Labour, Britain is starting to turn the corner. It's clear with the new Shadow Chancellor, the Tories are turning back to Liz Truss.
Rosie Duffield
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This week, Professor Susan Ayres launches her report in Parliament called 'The Cost of Birth Trauma'. This is a first and follows the APPG's 2024 inquiry, going beyond the more obvious health and social care implications. Lifelong care, litigation, and the impact on the workplace come at a high price, as do of course many other women's health scandals, such as the sodium valproate issue. Will the relevant minister or the Chancellor read Susan Ayres' report and meet with myself and the professor to discuss this?
Speaker 51
I thank the honorable lady for raising this important issue and I would be very happy to meet with her.
Sadik Al-Hassan
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd very briefly like to congratulate my beautiful, long-suffering Kiwi wife on completing her citizenship ceremony today in North Somerset. But will my right honorable friend set out how the government's investment can support the development of more local schemes for young people in North Somerset?
Torsten Bell
Well, can I thank the honorable friend for his question, but also congratulate his wife on what is a significant achievement, and I'm sure the whole House is supporting her.
And he's absolutely right to say that we do want to see more young people having the income, the opportunities and purpose that work provides. That's why it's welcome that employment is up but we do need to do more. We make sure we keep providing national insurance relief for employees aged under 21 and apprentices under 25 and we are rolling out our youth hubs including in North Somerset.
Clive Jones
Thank you very much Mr. Speaker. Given the chronic underfunding of Wokingham Borough Council which is facing difficult choices and placing increasing pressure on local services, what steps will the government take to ensure Wokingham receives a fairer settlement and can provide the services residents deserve?
Speaker 51
We're improving funding for local government as a result of the spending review. I'd be happy to meet with him to discuss further but obviously it's also a question for the Department for Housing and Local Government.
Amanda Hack
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Colwurk in my constituency fundraised for a defib. London Hearts reached out to them and because they were a charitable organization there was no VAT on this purchase meaning they could afford two. However, King's Arms in Colorton recently fundraised and they had to pay the VAT because they didn't go via a charity partner. So will the minister make an assessment of the potential impact of removing VAT on defibs for community-based purchases?
Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the organization in my honorable friend's constituency for successfully fundraising for two defibrillators. As you'll know decisions on fiscal matters are taken at the budget. She makes a powerful case but of course we have to evaluate whether VAT reliefs are passed on in full to consumers which is one of the key considerations when taking decisions of this sort.
John Lamont
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Nearly 100,000 hospitality jobs have disappeared in two years. Pubs, hotels and restaurants across the Scottish borders are struggling with higher employment costs. So when will the Labour government cut their tax on jobs?
Speaker 27
Mr. Speaker, we are providing a 20% cut in business rates for pubs in England. I would urge the Scottish government to do the same for Scottish pubs.
Speaker 81
Thank you Mr. Speaker. When the Bank of Scotland closed its Larkhall branch it left the town with no high street bank. That's not just a problem for Larkhall but also nearby villages like Ashgill and Netherburn. I'm very grateful to Treasury ministers for engaging with me about this over the last few months. What can the government do to support towns like Larkhall and protect face-to-face banking services in rural communities?
Speaker 74
Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to my honorable friend for her question and I want to be really, really clear about this. People who need in-person banking must be able to access essential services including in rural communities. That's exactly why I commissioned the independent access to banking services review to gather data about current access to banking services and it's why it's this government's intention to have a power in the Financial Services and Markets Bill to allow the government to act on that review.
Ben Spencer
Thank you Mr. Speaker. In his previous role the Chancellor demonstrated that he is a man of principle able to advocate for change even when politically difficult. So where the evidence shows that Labour policies are harming businesses and harming jobs, will he also advocate a change of course?
Torsten Bell
Well I thank the honorable member for his question. Some of the difficult choices we have had to make are why he's got NHS waiting lists falling in his constituency. It's why his own chief constable said that increased officer numbers will enable us to further tackle anti-social behavior, theft and drug-related crimes. And this is the man unfortunately that on the day of the mini budget spoke up in this chamber and said that it was a vote of confidence in the new, in the whole UK economy. The only regret he must have is not being more enthusiastic, otherwise he'd be the shadow chancellor.
Speaker 80
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. UK Finance estimates that two-thirds of all fraud cases are enabled online. Jonathan Fisher's recent review into fraud recommended an anti-fraud levy be placed on digital and communications platforms. So will the minister meet with me to discuss how we ensure economic crime enforcement agencies are properly funded to protect us all from predatory scammers on the internet?
Speaker 74
Mr. Speaker, fraud is the most common type of crime in this country, and its impact can be truly devastating for individuals and for businesses. That is exactly why this government is committed to tackling it, including via the doubling of the economic crime levy. As my honorable friend knows, the Fisher review made a number of recommendations, including about the role of the technology companies. We're considering those recommendations very thoroughly.
Robin Swann
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Northern Ireland Executive has been without a budget this year. In the last six months, the Northern Ireland Secretary of State has now engaging with the executive parties. Can I ask the Chancellor what latitude or support has he given the Northern Ireland Secretary of State in actually finding the ability to agree a budget in Northern Ireland, or what steps will the government take if the Northern Ireland Executive is unable to set a budget?
Speaker 51
I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. Can I reassure him that I am working extremely closely with the Northern Ireland Secretary, who is, as he will know, in discussions with all of the parties in the Northern Ireland Executive. We need to make sure that there is a budget set for Northern Ireland so that the executive can continue to deliver vital local public services.
Sureena Brackenridge
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I was pleased to see that the Chancellor was in the West Midlands yesterday meeting with manufacturing apprentices alongside Mayor Richard Parker. What conversations has he had with the mayor about using new devolution powers to invest in local skills and employment, and what will he do to make sure young people in Wolverhampton North East get more local opportunities to benefit?
Speaker 9
Indeed, Mr. Speaker, the West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker is using the powers he's got. He's used them recently to step in and take on bus services that will include, will improve bus services across West Midlands. And yesterday he stepped in to provide support for the JLR workers that may face redundancy and certainly will be well placed to get further jobs.
Speaker 96
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, could I welcome the Chancellor to his position and for his kind remarks earlier, and can I wish him every success because I'm afraid under this government we need some. He will know that if we are to fix the economy, we have to fix the welfare bill. So would he make a commitment today at the budget next month to come to this house with a comprehensive plan as to how he is going to arrest the burgeoning welfare bill? Because what he and I know is any failure to do that will lead to millions of hardworking people up and down this country, hundreds of thousands of businesses, now facing unnecessary and unacceptable tax increases.
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the right honorable gentleman sets out the challenge facing this country long term. It's exactly why that we have commissioned Alan Milburn and Stephen Timms to do the reviews they're doing at the moment. When they produce those in this autumn, we will look and act on the recommendations.
Speaker 97
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. What conversations has the Chancellor had with the Department of Health on providing compensation to those harmed by valproate and vaginal mesh as per the Hughes report published over two years ago?
Speaker 51
Can I reassure my honorable friend that I'm working extremely closely with the Health Secretary and discussing overall levels of NHS spending, of course the biggest budget in the across the departments.
Speaker 101
The NHS is performing well, but I will take back the specifics that she mentioned.
Barbara Keeley.
Speaker 93
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Monifieth in my constituency is home to over 9,000 people, but is the central connection point for a vast rural community across Angus. Despite an application in 2023, a banking hub was denied, and that's because the regulations are not fit for rural communities. So will the Minister commit to meet with me to discuss how those regulations impact rural communities and to see if we can finally get Monifieth the banking hub that it needs?
Speaker 74
Mr. Speaker, I will indeed meet with her, and the issues that she identifies are exactly why we had in our manifesto a commitment to working with industry to roll out 350 banking hubs over the course of this Parliament. Mr. Speaker, we are well on track. 282 banking hubs have already been announced, so we are running way ahead of schedule.
Speaker 103
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In recent weeks, Shein, the fast-fashion online retailer, was valued at a fraction of its price when it listed in Hong Kong, partly due to the treatment of low-value imports in the US and Europe. With that in mind, I welcome the government's decision to end our 135 pound de minimis relief by October 2028, but what more can be done before then to level the playing field for British retailers?
Speaker 27
My honorable friend is absolutely right to highlight the importance of removing the low-value imports relief and leveling the playing field with high streets. As she'll know, my predecessor announced in June that we'll be bringing forward the implementation of this measure to October 2028 to benefit high streets across the country as quickly as possible.
Speaker 105
Right, let the front bench change over. We now come to the urgent question on the Falklands, and I call Callum Miller.
Callum Miller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, to ask the Minister to make a statement on threats to UK sovereignty represented by President Milei and President Trump.
Speaker 104
Minister. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As my right honorable friends the Foreign Secretary and Defense Secretary have made clear, the UK remains steadfast in our support for the Falkland Islanders' right of self-determination. There can be no doubt: the Falkland Islands are British for as long as they want to be. Falkland Islanders have made their views very clear in a referendum in 2013, at the United Nations year after year, and to anyone who makes the effort to engage directly with the community.
The UK also supports the right of the Falkland Islanders to develop their natural resources for their own economic benefit. This is an integral part of their right to self-determination. This is not the first time the Argentine governments have made economic threats against the islanders. Yet these threats have not prevented the community's remarkable economic development over the years, and the measures announced by President Milei will not change the UK's unwavering commitment to the islanders. The UK wants to continue to maintain a modern and constructive relationship with Argentina across a range of shared interests.
However, there can be no doubt about our commitment to the Falkland Islanders, their democratic rights, and the UK's sovereignty over the Falkland Islands. This government will continue to work closely with the Falkland Islands government to defend their rights now and into the future. The US is our closest ally. They too are in no doubt about our unwavering support for the islands.
Callum Miller
Well, thank you, Mr. Speaker, and for granting this urgent question. As surely as night follows day, Mr. Speaker, another Argentine president facing economic trouble at home has tried to distract attention by threatening British sovereignty. This is a president who, I should remind colleagues, was praised by the Leader of the Opposition. When asked whether Britain needed our own Milei and whether she was such a politician, she replied, "Yes and yes." Meanwhile, President Trump, so loudly cheered by members of Reform and the Conservatives, has also declared that the US is considering changing its stance on British sovereignty over the Falklands.
Mr. Speaker, the decision of sovereignty over the Falklands does not belong to President Milei or President Trump. It belongs to the people of the Falklands alone. They have spoken unequivocally, and we should support them.
The renewed threat to the Falklands should sharpen ministers' minds as the mounting security challenges facing our overseas territories. The world is more unstable now than at any point since the end of the Cold War, yet our threadbare navy and hollowed armed forces are perilously overstretched. Meeting the threats to our sovereign territories requires genuine investment. So can the minister update the House on what steps will be taken to increase our defence spending rapidly and whether the government is considering Liberal Democrat proposals for defence bonds, investing in our critical capabilities and restoring British deterrence? President Milei has now threatened sanctions and criminal charges on energy companies operating offshore from the Falklands, including British firms.
This would be a direct economic attack on operations from British sovereign territory. This would be a direct economic attack on operations from British sovereign territory. So is the minister preparing retaliatory measures and sanctions in the event that British companies operating around the Falklands are targeted? The government must be resolute in defending Britain's interests and the people of the Falklands. Has the minister called in both the Argentine and US ambassadors to make clear that British sovereignty over the Falklands is non-negotiable, and if she has not, will she?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The honourable gentleman is of course completely right that we are in a very volatile world. But there is one thing that is absolutely unchanging: the United Kingdom's position on the Falkland Islands, which is long-standing. The Falkland Islands are a British overseas territory and will remain so for as long as the islanders wish. As I stated in my opening, we want a constructive relationship with Argentina, but we are absolutely clear and they are in no doubt about our position on this question.
And on defence spending more broadly, both the Prime Minister and the Chancellor remain committed to fully funding the defence investment plan and meeting our NATO commitment of 3.5% of GDP on defence by 2035.
Anne Emily Thornberry
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. The Israeli minister Ben-Gvir has said that it is time for the state of Israel to publicly recognise the Falkland Islands as Argentine territory under occupation. And that we, the British, are not merely occupying the territory, but in carrying out oil drilling there, we are stealing money from the Argentine people. Do you think that he knows that the Argentine government agrees with him and so, as a result, have filed criminal complaints against Navitas Petroleum, which is of course an Israeli company? And does he know this company was very happy, may I say, to sign a deal with the UK to explore the Sea Lion oil project in the British Falkland Islands?
Or do you think that Ben-Gvir was just too busy thinking of new ways to inflict ever yet more cruelty on the Palestinian people?
Speaker 104
Mr Speaker, we completely and utterly reject the characterisation that the honourable lady describes because the UK supports the rights of the Falkland Islanders to develop their natural resources for their own economic benefit because this is an absolutely integral part of their self-determination. The decision by the Falkland Islands government to proceed hydrocarbon production is a commercial decision for them to take alongside the commercial companies involved.
Wendy Morton
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. From the outset, we on these benches are clear that the Falkland Islands are British and they will remain British for as long as the Falkland Islanders wish them to be. British soldiers fought and died to defend our sovereignty and the freedom of the Falkland Islanders. That sacrifice will never be forgotten and we will always stand by the people of the Falklands and their overwhelming desire to remain British. Before summer recess, the Leader of the Opposition and I met with MLA Robert and representatives of the Falkland Islands government.
We were clear in reaffirming our unwavering support for the Islanders and their right to self-determination. Our continued connection with the Falklands is of vital importance, not just as a matter of history, but as a matter of sovereignty, security, and principle. The government must therefore ensure that it is standing up unequivocally for the Falkland Islands and their choice to stay British. So I'd like to ask what conversations has the Foreign Secretary and the ministers had with the United States administration to ensure that our position and above all, the democratic wishes of the Falkland Islanders are clearly understood. What direct representations has he made to the Argentinian government following President Milei's latest remarks and is Argentina raising the future of the Falklands through diplomatic channels with His Majesty's government or is it simply ramping up its language publicly?
Argentina has threatened sanctions against companies involved in the lawful development of the Falkland Islands' oil resources. What representations has the Foreign Secretary made in response and what steps is the government taking to protect those legitimate commercial interests and the Falkland Islands' rights to develop their own natural resources? There can be no negotiation over sovereignty unless and until the Falkland Islanders themselves wish it. The United Kingdom must stand with the Falkland Islanders and the right of the Islanders to self-determination.
Speaker 104
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I share the honorable lady's conviction that the sacrifices of British armed forces personnel should never be forgotten in relation to this matter. And I share too her desire to see the UK government stand up unequivocally for the rights of Falkland Islanders' right to self-determination, which is exactly what we have been doing. We are of course in regular ministerial and senior official engagement with Argentina, which is why I can say with such conviction they are in absolutely no doubt and no member of this House should be in any doubt about the UK government's position. The future of the Falkland Islands is for Falkland Islanders to determine and nobody else.
Liverpool
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the minister's strong message today standing alongside the Falkland Islanders and their desire to remain British. We have 14 overseas territories and over a quarter of a million people and can I ask that we take the opportunity now to consider how we better represent all of those people who we have responsibility to as a Parliament, but also in government, their health, their education, and the relationship between Britain and our overseas territories.
Speaker 104
And thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for his question to reassure him there is ongoing work across government to make sure that everyone in a British overseas territory retains the full support of the UK government. We're in regular dialogue with their representatives and of course we continue to ensure that their rights to health and education and the other matters that he mentioned are utmost in our minds at all times.
Julian Lewis
Does the government accept that in order to deter any possibility of military action against the Falklands, it's important not to send the wrong signals? In 1982, there was the withdrawal of HMS Endurance specifically, but there were also the huge anti-nuclear campaigns that sent the wrong message to aggressors around the world.
Can the government confirm that this time it will not send the wrong signals, whether it be over Diego Garcia, for example, or any suggestion that we haven't got the naval and air assets to deter and, if necessary, to defend?
Speaker 104
Mr. Speaker, I'm very happy to confirm to the honorable gentleman that we are sending the most unequivocal message imaginable, that the Falkland Islands are British for as long as they choose to be. It's also important to remind the House and to offer you reassurance that our forces in the South Atlantic are remain maintained at the appropriate level to ensure defense of the Falkland Islands against any potential threat. Now, the honorable member mentioned Diego Garcia, and I want to underscore for the House that it is a key strategic military asset for both the UK and the US, and it's protected our shared security for nearly 60 years. And it's precisely why we did a deal to ensure that we can maintain the long-term operational control of security as security of Diego Garcia.
Alexander Carmichael
Alex Ballinger.
Mr. Speaker, President Milei has coupled his renewed sovereignty claim with an increase in defense spending and plans to expand the naval base at Tierra del Fuego. In light of these developments, can the minister tell us if we've updated our threat assessments, and is the the Falkland Islands' air, land, and maritime defense adequate to ensure the islands' and the islanders' security?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable gentleman, of course, for his service. We are confident that the situation that we have in place with defense capability is adequate for the threats faced.
Iain Duncan Smith.
Speaker 124
Mr. Speaker, I wonder if I can say to the government that when they deal with our allies and friends, the Americans, they might remind them that the disputed islands that they are in charge of, Wake Island, Navassa Island, Bajo, Swain Island, Guantanamo Bay, all of which have been supported by the United Kingdom, and should we think about not supporting them, of course not, but they might just tell them. And finally, when we took the Falklands, the British government had at their hands 52 frigates and destroyers, well over 100,000 soldiers and naval personnel. Does he not think that the best message we could send is to get our defenses back?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So we are in ongoing conversation with our closest ally in the United States, as members will appreciate, and they are absolutely crystal clear about our position. Now, the honorable gentleman mentioned that we need to invest in our defense capabilities, and of course that is one of the first and primary responsibilities of the UK government. I would just gently remind him of the situation that we inherited, and that it is this government that has made commitments to investing strongly in our armed forces, and we're proud to have done so.
Speaker 117
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Like many, I have a close allegiance to the Falkland Islands and the islanders, as a 19-year-old young British soldier I did my first operational tour of duty in the islands in 1990 and subsequently went back again in '92. Does the minister agree with me that whilst the Falkland Islanders state that they wish to be a UK overseas territory, they will always remain that? In the latest referendum, to put it into perspective, 99.8% of Falkland Islanders voted to support the referendum on a 92% turnout, and to put it into perspective again, there was only three islanders voted against. Thank you.
Speaker 104
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'm sure the whole House will join me in thanking him for his service. It's an extraordinary sacrifice on behalf of him and his families, and we are deeply grateful for it. I also could not agree with him more that the wishes of the Falkland Islanders could not be more clear and must be respected.
Alexander Carmichael
Alistair Carmichael.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I don't know if it's something I still need to declare or not, but I visited the Falkland Islands in 2003 as a guest of the Falkland Islands government. They've never invited me back. It was apparent then, though, that the principle of self-determination, which was one for which we fought and on which British service people lost their lives, remained unchanged, and I've seen nothing to change that view today. So when the Minister speaks with the American Ambassador, might she gently remind him that in 1982, the Americans were not exactly full-throated in their support of us at that point?
It made no difference then, and it should make no difference now.
Speaker 104
And well, firstly, Mr. Speaker, could I thank the honorable gentleman for his direct engagement with the Falkland Islanders? I know for everyone in our British Overseas Territories, that's always appreciated, and he has been able to impress on the House as a direct result exactly what the Falkland Islanders want, which is their right to self-determination. He mentions our relationship with the United States, and because it is our closest ally, our relationship with the United States is one, as you might imagine, of candor, and they could not be clearer about our position, which is the Falkland Islands will remain British for precisely as long as the Falkland Islanders want them to be.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. People in Portsmouth are incredibly angry about this. We waved those ships off in '82, and so many families have a connection to someone who served. 255 brave British personnel died defending the Falkland Islands, 86 of them were from the Royal Navy. This issue, Madam Deputy Speaker, is settled.
Argentina was defeated, and above all, the Falkland Islanders have made their choice. They want to remain British. So will the Minister agree that the Argentinian government and President Trump must stop this disgraceful, disrespectful interference and stop treating the Falkland Islands as a bargaining chip?
Speaker 104
And Mr. Speaker, can I start by thanking my honorable friend for her own work on the Overseas Territories, to which I know she is deeply committed, and can she please pass on, on behalf of the whole House, our thanks to her constituents for their bravery, their courage, and their sacrifice? I could not agree with her more. This question is settled because it's settled in the minds of the Falkland Islanders who want to remain British, and they will do with our support.
John Glen
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sam Moody is my constituent. He's the Chief Executive of Rockhopper. And during my time in this House, he has been absolutely scrupulous in following the laws of this country and respecting the Falkland Islanders. Will the Minister reassure him and the whole of the House that they, this government, will protect the interests of Rockhopper, whatever commercial arrangements they have in place, knowing that Rockhopper has always complied with legislation and respected whichever government has been in power?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yes, of course, he should feel free to pass on the views of this House and the views of the British government to Mr. Moody, that it is part of the right of self-determination of the Falkland Islanders to develop their own natural resources. We stand full square behind them in doing so, and we stand full square behind the companies that are involved in doing so too.
Speaker 123
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the honorable gentleman for securing this important question today? Brave British service people died defending the Falkland Islanders' right to freedom and self-determination over 40 years ago. We must never forget. Can the Minister confirm that this Labour government will do the right thing and never compromise when it comes to defending British sovereign territory in the Falklands?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I can confirm to my honorable friend that we will never compromise under any circumstances on the right to self-determination of the Falkland Islanders, and I would like to join with her in commemorating all those who risked and indeed lost their lives in defense of that very principle.
John Whittingdale
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The UK's success in liberating the Falklands in 1982 was achieved when we had considerably greater naval resources, but also could not have been achieved without the support of the Reagan administration at that time. Does she not agree that that shows why it is extremely important to maintain close relations with the United States and not do anything to put those in jeopardy?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The United States remain our closest ally and we'll continue to engage with them whilst being absolutely clear with them about our position. And I don't think anyone should be in any doubt, least of all the people of the Falkland Islands, no one should be in any doubt of our absolute steadfast and unwavering commitment to their self-determination, and we'll continue to impress on that, we'll continue to press that on the United States government.
Jonathan Brash
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister is understandably burdened by the need to be diplomatic. But isn't the reality that President Trump can review whatever position he likes and the Argentinian government can make whatever threats they like? It does not make a jot of difference to this country. The Falkland Islands will remain British.
Speaker 104
I can confirm the Falkland Islands will remain British because the right of the Falkland Islanders to self-determination is absolute.
Charles Edward Robin Morello
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Falkland Islands are not just British, they are part of Britain. An attack on any part of Britain would be an Article 5 situation. And yet Donald Trump the other day when pressed on it was far from clear on whether or not we can rely on US support. So what is the government doing to close in and tighten our defense relationship with European and other allies who do understand and share our belief in collective defense?
Speaker 104
So all members of the House will know that we're in ongoing dialogue with our European partners. And crucially, we are committed to investing in our own defense, which is why this government has made such strong commitments to continue defense investment.
John Thomas Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Bournemouth has a close relationship to the Falklands. 22-year-old Lance Corporal Christopher Charles Thomas was killed on the 13th of June 1982. He was of Cardiff and Bournemouth. And the people of Bournemouth formally adopted HMS Phoebe and granted it the freedom of the borough.
HMS Phoebe patrolled the South Atlantic after the war. I've been contacted by constituents who are outraged by the comments that they've heard. And in particular, I'm thinking of Richard in East Southbourne and Tuckton, who wants to know that the government will conduct an urgent review into the defense of the Falklands. Can the Minister please give my constituents that assurance?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I join him in remembering Lance Corporal Thomas. His constituents should be reassured, as indeed should everyone in the Falkland Islands. We are absolutely committed to their right to self-determination, we're committed to their defense, and we're committed to them remaining British.
Bob Blackman
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Falkland Islands have been British long before Argentina even came into existence. So will the Minister, but the key here is building a diplomatic ability to ensure that that message goes home loud and clear. So what efforts are the Minister and other ministers in the Foreign Office taking to build that diplomatic alliance to ensure that we don't get into a position where military action is necessary?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So this is, this is a matter of all of our diplomatic relationships being brought to bear. But the key from my point of view is that the message goes out from this House today loud and clear and is heard unequivocally by the people of the Falkland Islands, that we stand with them in remaining British for as long as it takes.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And further to the points made by my honorable friend the member for Bournemouth, it's important that we talk here, it's important that we have diplomacy.
But what extra practical action is the Foreign Office and the Ministry of Defence taking to ensure that there is that review of physical defense security so that there is a very clear message sent to the Argentinians that they can go no further? Words are too much, but they should go no further.
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are confident that our defensive capabilities in the South Atlantic are equal to the task.
Speaker 112
The problem is that the Argentinians can smell weakness, and they can smell weakness because of our approach to attacks on two British bases by the Iranians earlier this year. Will the minister therefore be clear that in the light of Iranian threats to our bases this time round, we will not just seek to intercept the missiles attacking them, but we will attack targets in Iran if they attack our bases, because it requires that sort of signal of intent in relation to our overseas territories?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This government could not have been clearer about the work that we are doing to defend our bases and we'll keep it up.
Jacob Collier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over recess I had the privilege to visit the islands with members of this house and the other place. There we met with the Falkland Islands government, members of our British service personnel, and also paid tribute to those who gave the ultimate sacrifice. Whatever the posturings of an Argentinian president or Israeli minister, the Falkland Islands are British and remain proudly so. So will the minister join me in thanking all of those service personnel on the islands for their contribution to UK defense?
Speaker 104
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for his visit that I know will have been deeply appreciated by Falkland Islanders. And yes, I very much join him in commemorating and thanking everyone involved in the defense of the islands and our service personnel wherever they are in the world.
Edward Robert Jenrick
There's an air of total unreality hanging over this debate. Successive governments have run down our Royal Navy to its present enfeebled state. They've conspired to surrender other British sovereign territory, and we have a government that procrastinates about signing up a new oil field in the North Sea, let alone about one in the South Atlantic. Argentina senses total weakness. When will the government step up, set out how it will rebuild our Royal Navy and meet the 3% target of GDP for our armed forces so we can actually stand tall and defend ourselves and our sovereign interests once more?
Speaker 104
Mr. Speaker, this Labour government won't take any lectures from a party that's been fawning over Vladimir Putin about how we should defend our interests and stand up for Britain.
Kevin McKenna
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This summer, along with other members of this house and the other place, I got to escape the heatwave here and enjoy some blessed relief in the cold weather of the Falklands and the incredibly warm welcome of the Falkland Islanders. Our troops and service people down there are doing incredible work and are resolute in their defense of the Falkland Islands. And it was very clear to me how strong the feeling is of Falkland Islanders that they are British and it matches the feeling of my constituents. Can the minister just assure me that she's having conversations with members of the MOD and our forces and the Falklands Islands government to ensure that we have the right level of defense and deterrence to face this new and escalating rhetoric, nonsense rhetoric from Argentina?
Speaker 104
Yes, I can confirm to my honorable friend we're in ongoing conversations about exactly that and can I take the opportunity to thank him too for his visit. I cannot stress enough to the house how deeply it is appreciated by the Falkland Islanders when people come to this visit and then are able to impress back on this house our unified position that the Falkland Islands are British and will remain so.
Andrew Murrison
Currently the Royal Navy has an offshore patrol vessel permanently stationed in the Falkland Islands. But given the threat that currently is being faced and our need to demonstrate resolve, the sort of thing we did not sadly demonstrate in the early 1980s and that led to miscalculation, would the minister consider speaking to her MOD colleagues to see what naval assets there may be in order to at least pay a visit to the Falkland Islands with a significant platform?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
So as I stated previously, we are confident that our defensive forces in the South Atlantic are equal to the task. But in terms of conveying resolve, I think it's incredibly important that an absolutely united message is sent from this House to partners in all capitals and to the Falkland Islanders that we are resolute in their defense.
Toby Perkins
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honorable gentleman from Bicester and Woodstock is absolutely right to say that what is behind this is the deep unpopularity of President Milei. It's not anything actually that the UK has done. And it is to the credit of this House that we are entirely united, whichever party you are, in saying that the Falkland Islands are British and will remain so. And does she agree with me that those who try to make political points to separate us actually do those who oppose us a favor?
And actually what they should do is say that the UK government, His Majesty's opposition, and all of us in this House are entirely united on this subject.
Speaker 104
I very much agree with my honorable friend that a huge disservice is done to the people of the Falkland Islands and to our service personnel anytime politicking is taking place instead of having an absolutely united and unwavering conviction emanating from this House.
Mark Pritchard
Can I pay tribute to all the Falkland Islands veterans in my own constituency and indeed around the country and to the honorable gentleman no longer in his place? Is it not the case that we should really all be seeking to de-escalate the rhetoric, but at the same time send a very strong signal of resolve to President Milei that if we are required to do so, that this country will once again defend the Falkland Islands militarily and in between that certainly defend it economically?
Speaker 104
I thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I couldn't agree with the honorable gentleman more in so far as the important thing in this debate is clarity, which is why I am saying with such conviction our unwavering position as a UK government in a volatile world is the Falkland Islands are British and they will remain British.
Adam Jogee
Speaker, the House speaks with one voice when it comes to the Falklands being British and like colleagues across the House, I have met many veterans in Newcastle-under-Lyme who served in the Falklands and I thank them for their service. I'm grateful to the Minister for her answers to date, but can I suggest that a Minister of the Crown gets on a plane, Madam Deputy Speaker, and goes down to the Falklands to stand in solidarity with the people there as the Union flag is flown and the sooner the better?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can we please pass on to the honorable friend's constituents our thanks for their service too? Ministers have visited and do so regularly and are in ongoing dialogue with representatives of the Falkland Islanders. And again, I think it's very important that the message goes out from this House that Falkland Islands are British and will stay so.
Clive Jones
Very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can the Minister confirm that we are, that the government is reviewing the military infrastructure and surveillance capabilities on the islands in response to Argentina's announced plans to bolster its military presence?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thanks to the honorable gentleman for his question. As he would expect, we don't go into operational detail about our defense capabilities, but I can reassure the House that the government is confident that our defense capabilities are as he would hope and as we need them to be.
John Tristan Osborne
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
In 1982, the people of Chatham and Chatham Dockyard waved off the boats that went to safeguard our territory in the South Pacific. HMS Medway, a ship named after our named river in Chatham, is there today to protect, working with its sailors, to protect and secure that territory. Can she pay testament to the hard work of the Royal Navy to defend the territory, and what further advice and security can she give to ensure we have the right defense posture to counter any aggression?
Speaker 104
And thank you very much, and thank the honorable friend for his question. I would like to pay tribute to everyone serving on HMS Medway and indeed all of our armed forces personnel, and to offer them our unwavering commitment to their protection and the protection of all British territories overseas.
Gregory James Stafford
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and like other members, I had the privilege of going to the Falkland Islands last month, and I want to give my thanks to the Commander British Forces South Atlantic Islands and all his staff for their welcome and professionalism. Whilst there are clearly domestic issues going on in Argentina, the cold hand of China is not far from sight, whether it be illegal fishing in the Blue Hole, whether it be secret nuclear bases, missile bases, sorry, at Neuquén, or whether it's nefarious activity in Antarctica. So what discussions has she had with European and US counterparts about dealing with the threat that China poses, and that it's in all our interests in the free West world that the Falkland Islands remain British in perpetuity?
Speaker 134
And thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So as I've already stated to the House, we're in ongoing dialogue with through all of our diplomatic relations to stress to people in every capital, but most of all to stress to the people of the Falkland Islands that the Falkland Islands remain British and always will.
Speaker 138
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's concerning to hear this saber-rattling from Argentina against a self-governing population that overwhelmingly identifies as British. But it's not just the United States fanning the flames. Israel's sanction minister for national security called for Israel to recognize the Falklands as Argentinian, and its president stated that Israel will act against Britain. Ignoring the irony of an Israeli minister accusing another country of illegal occupation, what discussions has the Foreign Secretary had on this matter with our supposed ally who is trying to undermine British sovereignty?
Luke Morgan Evans
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So we make clear to all our partners, all our allies, and indeed people in every capital in the world that the Falkland Islands are British, we're resolute in that, and that position will not change.
Dr. Luke Evans.
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the minister's spoken about the sovereignty and she's right on both sides of this House. But she will be aware under the Offshore Mineral Ordinance 94, any decision has to come to this country when it comes to exploration. Now, it just so happens that the very Energy Secretary who banned new licenses in the UK is now going to be that decision holder. So can she rule out that if the Falklands ask for exploration in their area on oil and gas, this government will not block it?
Iqbal Mohamed
And so the honorable gentleman will be aware that it is an integral part of a country's self-determination that they can develop their own natural resources for their own economic benefit. This will be a decision for the Falkland Islanders, and indeed Falkland Islands representatives have already, have already made decisions about exactly this matter.
Iqbal Mohamed.
Speaker 135
Speaker, it is clear to the British public that the special relationship between the UK and the US is more special for the UK than it is for the US under Trump, with the UK extending threats, bullying, and tariffs threats. And it's akin to an abusive relationship. So will the minister unequivocally confirm that Britain will not tolerate intimidation and blackmail by the US, Israel, or others, and that British sovereignty matters more than our relationship with hostile states committing blatant horrific violations of international law?
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
But this time last year, the President of Argentina at the UN General Assembly staked a claim on the Falkland Islands and neither the former Minister for the Overseas Territories nor the former Foreign Secretary sat next to her actually had anything to say about the matter. So I would like some assurances that the Prime Minister will tackle President Milei at the UN General Assembly later this month. And may I also gently remind her when she talks about the military capability in the Falklands, the offshore patrol vessels that we currently have rotating through the Falklands, three of those are due to be sold to the Uruguay Navy in the next 18 months and four of the Typhoons that we have down there, the Tranche 1s, are due to be decommissioned next year as well. In terms of the staging post to get to the Falkland Islands, the Ascension Island is a key location, but it's shared as a base with the US. Is she confident that the US would have no problems whatsoever with us using that base should we need to take military action against Argentina?
Speaker 104
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So I would reject the characterization of the honorable gentleman. The United Kingdom ministers have been clear in every international forum in which we are present about our position on this matter. And I'm pleased to underscore and repeat it today: the Falkland Islands are British.
Jim Shannon
Final question, Jim Shannon.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Minister very much for her strong and resolute answers? And following the deeply concerning decision surrounding the Chagos Islands, the good people of the Falkland Islands need more than just warm words. They need ironclad guarantees. The Minister has stood firm at the dispatch box today and declared unequivocally that the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands is non-negotiable.
President Trump must stand by the United Kingdom. So will the Minister ensure that the international community is under absolutely no illusions? We beat the Argentinians when it mattered. The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland can and will do that again if necessary. And those islands will remain British for as long as their people wish them to be.
Thank you.
Speaker 104
There can be no doubt in any capital in the world and most importantly, there can be no doubt in the Falkland Islands. The Falkland Islands are British, their right to self-determination is absolute and the UK government stands as a guarantor of exactly that.
Speaker 140
That is the end of the statement on Falkland Islands sovereignty. The front benches wish to shuffle over. We come to the statement on Israel-Palestine. Foreign Secretary.
David Lammy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With permission, I would like to make a statement on Israel and Palestine. I do so as a proud British Jew, someone with the deepest gratitude to the state of Israel for giving a home to my grandmother after she lost her husband, my grandfather, and 60 other family members at the hands of the Nazis. I remember visiting her in the 1970s in Tel Aviv and seeing the life and sanctuary Israel had provided. Indeed, some of my most joyful childhood memories were picking oranges as a kid on the kibbutz where my cousins lived.
Madam Deputy Speaker, my personal story and that of thousands of British Jews is one of the many reasons why I say to anyone here or around the world who questions Israel's right to exist as a homeland for the Jewish people: you are wrong and we will call you out whenever you engage in this attempt at the erasure of Israel. Madam Deputy Speaker, I know what the trauma of Hamas's terrorist atrocity of October the 7th meant and still means to people across Israel and to Jews across the world. It was a murderous act by a murderous terrorist organization designed to massacre and instill fear across a whole population. October the 7th makes plain the grave threats that Israel faces and it has every right to defend itself. We should not only condemn those threats, but act against those who carry them out.
Iran continues to threaten Israel and Jews across the world. We have already designated Iran's IRGC and we will do more today on Iran's proxy groups. So today I can also announce we are sanctioning Lebanese Hezbollah's financing arm, Al-Qard Al-Hassan.
Iran must never have a nuclear weapon. So we are also acting this week to report Iran to the UN Security Council for its nuclear violations alongside our allies. And I can announce today that we are also reimposing major economic sanctions on Iran in line with the European Union and the United States. Madam Deputy Speaker, tackling these threats is just one of the most of one of the important shared national security interests we have with Israel on which we will continue to cooperate. I know too that so many members of the Jewish community now live in fear in the face of rising antisemitism including here in the UK.
Last week we commemorated the anniversary of the Heaton Park attack, Jews murdered at their place of worship simply for their religion. An outrage that was followed by antisemitic attacks in Golders Green including on the Hatzola ambulances. And the everyday life of Jews in Britain is deeply affected by the climate such hate creates. When I went to school in the 1980s I did so without fear. Today we need to face the truth, that is not the case for thousands of Jewish children across the UK, children who have to go to school with security guards outside their school.
Madam Deputy Speaker, no child should have to go to school facing this and no teacher should face antisemitism either. Whether it happens in our schools, universities or workplaces or online or on our streets, antisemitism is a scourge and an evil. We are rightly putting place putting in place an additional investment of 250 million pounds for community security but we all have a responsibility to do more. As part of this I will in October host representatives of the J7, the countries with the largest Jewish populations from across the world. We will meet in the UK to discuss the different ways we can work across borders to tackle antisemitism including tackling online hate.
So Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm proud of my Jewishness and unwavering in my support for the state of Israel. And there is absolutely no contradiction between this and my support for the state of Palestine. Indeed quite the opposite. The two-state solution is based on an explicit belief that the only route to security for both peoples is to live side by side in peaceful coexistence with freedom, security and self-determination. Securing the two-state solution in its fullest form is the North Star of this government's policy and indeed of successive British governments over decades.
And it is precisely this belief in the rights and freedoms of the Israeli and Palestinian people that leads many including me to a deep sense of shame about what has unfolded in Palestine under the eyes of the international community. In Gaza, the most unimaginable trauma and suffering in the last three years, death, destruction and dehumanization on an appalling scale, a stain on the conscience of the world and of this country too. And in the West Bank, the clear attempt to in the words of Israeli Finance Minister Smotrich, and I quote, bury the idea of a Palestinian state. So Madam Deputy Speaker, there is a deeply painful contrast between our professed commitment to a two-state solution and the reality on the ground in Gaza and the West Bank. I pay tribute to my predecessors, the current Health Secretary and the right honorable member for Tottenham for their tireless efforts on this issue as well as my right honorable friend the member for Lincoln.
We should always be proud that it was a Labour government that took the historic step of recognizing the state of Palestine. But the Prime Minister is right to say that the Labour government has not done enough in the face of what is happening. So today marks the beginning of a new approach. An approach that not only calls out injustice and suffering, but acts. And in taking this stance, I make a very clear distinction, which is crucial for us all in this debate.
Our argument is not with the people of Israel, with whom the UK has unshakable bonds. Our argument is with the conduct of its government. And I also want to say emphatically to people in Britain and indeed across the world, holding British Jews responsible for the actions of the Israeli government is antisemitism, plain and simple. What we seek today is to salvage the only cause for peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians, the two-state solution. Let me start with the situation in the West Bank.
Mr. Speaker, Madam Deputy Speaker, at the time of the Oslo Peace Accords in 1993, around 270,000 settlers lived in the occupied Palestinian territories. Today it is some 770,000. More settlements have been approved under the four years of this Israeli government than in the previous 20 years. Let us spell out what this has meant for Palestinian communities. Houses bulldozed, roads and public infrastructure destroyed, families displaced from their homes, community by community, family by family, person by person.
Madam Deputy Speaker, 65 Palestinian communities completely expelled since 2023. A total of over 4,000 Palestinians evicted from their homes due to settler violence and state actions. And in August, the crossing of a long-standing red line, the issuing of E1 tenders for over 1,200 homes. Madam Deputy Speaker, I visited a community in the area covered by E1 in 2014. The Bedouin communities I met in Khan al-Ahmar had lived on that land for generations.
E1 proposals would evict them and place settlements directly between East Jerusalem and the West Bank, cutting through the heart of Palestine. Let's be absolutely clear what this means: the creation of a set of facts on the ground to make the two-state solution unviable. And on top of official state policy, settler terrorism is rampant. The UN reports an average of six violent settler attacks against Palestinians per day this year, per day, the highest on record. Take one example.
In Al-Mughayyir, 20 miles north of Jerusalem, settlers have encircled the village and mounted a campaign of intimidation, largely under the protection of the Israeli military. Families in the village are increasingly cut off from accessing their land, squeezed into ever smaller areas, and have olive trees uprooted and livestock stolen. In the same community just last week, two teenagers were shot when settlers entered the village under police and military escort. Both died before reaching hospital. Madam Deputy Speaker, five teenagers have now been killed from their school this year.
Ehud Olmert, the former Israeli Prime Minister, has described what is happening as, I quote, "a violent and criminal effort to ethnically cleanse territories in the West Bank." The former Minister of Health and retired Brigadier General from the IDF, Ephraim Sneh, has said, and I quote again, "this is ethnic cleansing, pure, to put it simply."
Madam Deputy Speaker, ethnic cleansing is defined by the UN as a purposeful policy designed by one ethnic or religious group to remove by violent and terror-inspiring means the civilian population of another ethnic or religious group from certain geographic areas. The British government agrees that there is ethnic cleansing of Palestinians in areas of the West Bank perpetrated by settler terrorists. And all too often, the Israeli government has turned a blind eye to this, and worse, members of it have made statements and taken actions to support the forced displacement of Palestinians. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I recognise the gravity of saying this, but the truth is the least the people who face such suffering deserve, and it should be the prelude to justice. Now for a long time, the British government has rightly said settlements are illegal, but we have remained silent on the question of the legality of the occupation as a whole, which in 2024 the International Court of Justice concluded was unlawful.
Today I announce that the official view of the British government is that the occupation is unlawful because of Israel's entrenchment of its control, its intention to extend permanent sovereignty, and its expansionist agenda via illegal settlements. Madam Deputy Speaker, our position is not just an overdue statement of reality. The government believes the unlawfulness of the occupation should be reflected in the economic relationships we choose to have with the occupied territories. I do not believe the British people want us supporting the occupation by accepting products from settlements in our shops and supermarkets. So I can announce today that we will introduce an import ban on goods from illegal settlements in the occupied territories.
To do so, we will introduce a new comprehensive sanctions regime working with my right honourable friend the Business Secretary, with appropriate religious exemptions. And as part of this regime, we will go further. We will take action against specific companies and individuals who provide services such as construction, infrastructure, financing, or real estate for settlement expansion. So to those who finance or facilitate illegal settlements, let me say this: you will face the full force of UK sanctions. Settlements are illegal.
They should not be promoted in our country. Earlier this year, Madam Deputy Speaker, shamefully, just a few miles from here, we saw an expo advertising illegal settlement land. We must and we will ensure this never happens again. So we will ban the advertising in the UK of illegal settlements. The sanctions regime will target illegal settlements and settlement expansion, not Israel.
We will continue to support important and valued trade with Green Line Israel precisely because we support the two-state solution, including security and prosperity for Israel. For this reason, I wholeheartedly oppose the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions or BDS campaign. The legislation I have announced today will be in place within six to nine months, and we will also take more immediate steps. Today we are sanctioning a further set of extremist settlers who have supported or incited acts of violence against Palestinian communities. And I can also announce that we're extending the existing global human rights regime such that it will enable swifter action to deter settlement expansion, including crucially seeking to prevent the development of E1.
I also want to address the question of arms sales. We've already suspended over 30 arms licences used by the IDF in Gaza. That suspension remains fully in place. We will now also refuse all licence applications for arms and other exports that materially contribute to the occupation, in effect a double lock against arms sales. This means the ban on such exports will now remain in place as long as the occupation persists.
Madam Deputy Speaker, to advance the two-state solution, we also need viable and effective Palestinian governance. So I urge the Palestinian Authority to accelerate reform, and I urge Israel to lift its withholding of revenues that is frankly financially crippling the provision of essential services in the West Bank. The set of measures I've announced represents a clear message to the government of Israel, to the Palestinians in the occupied territories, and to the world, that we will not acquiesce in the destruction of the two-state solution. I turn now to Gaza. The horror of October the 7th appalled the world, and had terrible echoes of the centuries of persecution of the Jewish people.
Men, women, children and babies killed, mutilated and tortured by Hamas terrorists. People murdered while seeking to protect their families. Young people massacred at a music festival, people abducted from their homes. As the 20-point peace plan for Gaza sets out, this is one of many reasons Hamas can play no role in the future governance of Gaza. It must decommission its weapons and must dismantle its terrorist infrastructure.
Israel has the right not to live in fear of vile terrorism, and the Israeli state has the right to protect its people and defend its territory. But, Madam Deputy Speaker, that cannot justify what has happened in Gaza. Over 70,000 people have been killed, at least 20,000 of them children. 20,000 children. The vast majority of the population is now displaced, nearly 2 million people who are now penned into just one-third of the territory.
Life-saving humanitarian aid and access has been routinely blocked. Hospitals and clinics have been destroyed. Over 60% of homes are in ruins. Madam Deputy Speaker, international humanitarian law imposes clear rules for states fighting wars, including to ensure access to food and medical supplies, to avoid mass displacement of civilians, and to avoid the targeting of civilians. Serious and international violations of this law, if proven, amount to war crimes.
What has occurred, including the actions of the IDF, have been examined in depth by a number of organisations, including the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry. The conclusions of these reports represent increasing evidence that war crimes appear to have been committed. And we support legal processes to determine this. On the question of genocide, the UK has always supported full, robust and fair judicial processes to consider allegations, with final determinations made by competent courts before the British government reaches a conclusion. This has been the case for all of the genocides since the 1948 Genocide Convention: Rwanda, Srebrenica, Cambodia, and acts against the Yazidi people.
That will remain our policy. It is right this issue has been brought before the ICJ, and I want to make it clear that we support the court in coming to its determination. So accountability for what has happened in Gaza matters, but even more urgent is action to address the ongoing crisis. Because today in Gaza, the death and suffering continue. Nearly a year ago, Madam Deputy Speaker, a ceasefire was declared.
Yet over 1,200 Palestinians have been killed since. And the people of Gaza are experiencing a totally avoidable humanitarian catastrophe, I'm afraid driven by decisions of the Israeli government. Last week I talked to courageous doctors and humanitarian aid workers who have served in Gaza. It was a heartbreaking conversation. They recounted children dying waiting for medical treatment, people forced to live next to open sewage and without shelter, and food insecurity rampant.
I'm sure the whole House agrees this is unconscionable. So I pledge we will continue to do everything we can to provide all the humanitarian support possible to help the people of Gaza. UK-supported hospitals in Gaza will enable around 800,000 medical consultations this year and essential health services for patients. UK expertise will deliver care to over a thousand child amputees. And we recently welcomed another wave of students from Gaza coming to study in Britain, and we will welcome more.
But in truth, unless Israel changes course, the situation will remain dire. So we're taking further steps, both ourselves and with others. Our extension of the global human rights sanctions regime will enable us to target those responsible for violations of international humanitarian law, whether in Gaza or anywhere else in the world. And we will at the UN General Assembly in New York later this month shine the clearest and harshest spotlight on what is happening and what must change. With Jordan we will convene countries across the world to lead a call for action on health and humanitarian access.
We will also lend the UK's voice to the growing global alliance of countries led by our partners in the region calling for the full implementation of the US-led 20-point plan, the rejection of extremism and a lasting end to the cycles of violence. And as we implement the policy measures I have announced today, we will continue to assess the government of Israel by its actions. We want to see a new approach in both Gaza and the West Bank. Madam Deputy Speaker, today we refuse to be bystanders to further suffering and to the destruction of the two-state solution. We call out what is unlawful.
We act on the import of goods from illegal settlements. We ban advertising of illegal settlements. We act on services to prevent new settlement expansion. We act on settler violence. We support accountability for what has happened in Gaza.
And we pledge to galvanize the international community to confront the ongoing and urgent humanitarian crisis. Above all we say, Britain is not silent in the face of deep injustice and nor is it powerless. And today we act in concert with others in a broad international coalition. I can tell the House that today France and Canada are announcing alongside Britain that they will also ban the import of goods from illegal settlements, joining the Netherlands, Ireland, Belgium, Spain and Norway which have either banned goods or are in the process of doing so, with many other countries, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Poland, Portugal and Sweden pledging today they will support further action. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is what Britain can achieve leading with others.
And this is in our fundamental national interest because if there is one lesson of recent decades, it's that we will never have stability in the Middle East without a two-state solution. And it is also the case that if we fail to stand up for the values that this country has long held and fought for, we lose credibility and influence in the world. Madam Deputy Speaker, my parents came here as Jewish refugees and found sanctuary and a country that stood up for the rule of law, freedom and self-determination. Those are the values this government is standing up for today. And I truly believe that the vast majority of the British people, including in our communities with ties to the region, are united in their desire to see humanitarian suffering end and all sides commit to a durable peace process.
And just as we want Israelis and Palestinians to live side by side, so, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have to live out those values in Britain. Jews in Britain, Muslims in Britain, people of all faiths and none have a right to live without prejudice or fear. Madam Deputy Speaker, a Britain that upholds its values at home and around the world, a Britain that fights against oppression and suffering wherever it occurs, a Britain that stands up for what is right, and I commend this statement to the House.
Georg John Thomas Tom Tugendhat
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
May I thank the Foreign Secretary for the advance sight of his statement. Now, as we meet today, let me just start with what we agree on. We do agree that illegal settlements are wrong. We all agree that groups of settlers have been guilty of outrageous abuses of ordinary Palestinians and crimes against innocent civilians. We agree that some Israeli ministers have indulged in hateful propaganda and incitement.
We agree that the current path is leading Israelis and Palestinians towards a darker, more dangerous future. We agree that Hamas's terrorist atrocity of October the 7th left many Jews in Israel and around the world afraid and vulnerable. And we agree that the suffering in Gaza is horrific. But we also agree that those who praise Hamas and other terror groups or see them as legitimate representatives of the Palestinian people are wrong. That payments to those who are killed while attacking Israeli civilians are wrong.
That those who call for the destruction of the world's only Jewish state and the murder of its citizens with cries of "from the river to the sea" are wrong. Ignoring the victims on all sides and putting at risk the viability of the two-state solution is wrong. Now, this isn't about Israel alone, and it certainly isn't about reducing the complexity of the region to a single sentence. But sadly, the government is in the process of doing just that. When it recognized the state of Palestine only recently, it did so against the laws that we ourselves have defended since 1933, in contravention of the Montevideo Convention, in contravention of the principles that we have set out.
When it sanctioned Israeli ministers, it failed to make the case to many others, including to the European Union. And today, it is enacting policies that the Foreign Office knows won't work. But it does know they will harm innocents because just 13 weeks ago, two ministers of this government, the right honorable member for Lincoln and the right honorable member for Rhondda and Ogmore, wrote to the chair of the Business and Trade Committee rejecting this very policy as the economies of Palestine and Israel are too interconnected, so innocent Palestinians and Israelis will suffer. Still, this government is pressing on in haste, despite warnings from the honorable member for Bury St Edmunds on the benches opposite and from the government's own reviewer of terror legislation that turning Israel into a pariah will risk sectarian division in our own country and risk a further rise in antisemitic violence on our own streets. As the Foreign Secretary knows, as the Foreign Secretary knows, others are waiting.
The Israeli election is in just seven weeks, and many have argued, correctly, that this action will help the extreme candidates' campaigns and not help those who are making the moderate argument for a united Israel. In the week before Rosh Hashanah and the High Holy Days, the government is acting without prudence, introducing sanctions that are both light and serious. Light because they won't actually target settlers, as the Minister for Intergovernmental Relations has already said, but be stretched to include all Israeli and Palestinian businesses, leaving many without opportunity, including the pharmaceuticals that keep many British patients alive. Serious because they risk what the Foreign Secretary has himself condemned: encouraging sectarianism and antisemitism at home and discouraging cooperation abroad.
So I have six questions for the Foreign Secretary. First, can he confirm that the advice from his department has changed so dramatically on the practicality of sanctions that this is coherent and that in fact these sanctions will in reality be targeted and not area as previously stated. Second, what conversations has he had with wider partners and allies to coordinate a full international action that might actually work and why will he not wait for the result. What assessment has he made of the impact on domestic security and community cohesion in the United Kingdom barely a year since the first antisemitic murder in our country in generations. Now what assessment has he also made of the impact on our security partnerships with both Israel and the United States that has kept Iranian regime backed murderers off our streets for the past few years.
What instructions has he given to the enforcement bodies to ensure that Parkinson's, myeloma and multiple sclerosis patients will still get the drugs that keep them alive. Will he also now let us know what instructions he's given to the Foreign Office for the accreditation of diplomats to the Palestinian embassy should Hamas win the elections in November and send their own envoys here under diplomatic immunity. Mr. Speaker, we have seen growing antisemitism in the United Kingdom and we have seen increased violence against Jewish targets. Now this party will always reject the hateful sectarianism that we've seen on our streets. We can and where appropriate we should criticize the Israeli government and still defend the right of the Jewish people to a home.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to place on record my and my party's deep sadness at the violence that we have seen in recent months and years, our commitment to the right of Palestinians and Israelis to live in dignity and peace and our recognition of those who have been victims over generations. None of us here reject the government's stated aim that we must do everything we can to end the cycle of violence. We welcome the sanctions against Al-Qard al-Hassan and the condemnation of the IRGC. But I'm sorry this government is wrong as the Foreign Office has previously stated, this policy will damage the interests of innocent Palestinians, Israelis who condemn settlements and the British people. What we reject here is not the intent but the performative politics, the acting without the wideness of support that leaves our envoys weaker and their voices irrelevant.
From our own history, we know that you don't make peace from just one side and nor do you make it alone.
David Lammy
Well can I thank him for his response and look, this is our first time opposite each other at the dispatch box so let me congratulate him on his appointment and he has a proud record in Parliament as security minister, as chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee and brings great expertise to this House. I do profoundly disagree with him on his conclusions. I think we he mentioned a number of things that we agreed at the on at the beginning, I think it's important to highlight them.
I think the I'll answer his specific questions in a moment but the underlying problem of his position is this which is he supports the two-state solution with great vigour. He believes in the two-state solution. He sees the two-state solution being destroyed before our eyes and I'm afraid his prescription is to do nothing about it. And there is a choice that we face in this Madam Deputy Speaker which is do we stand by are we bystanders to the end of a long established government policy and indeed the only hope for security and stability in the Middle East or do we act. And look we've chosen to act.
And I actually think that the country will be with us most of the country will be with us because we cannot simply stand by. On let me take some of his points. On the point about the Palestinian people I say this with the greatest of respect to him. The voices that I listen to more than his on the Palestinian people are the Prime Minister of the Palestinian Authority and the ambassador of Palestine in the UK. Both of them have been urging us to act and have been urging us to act for a long time.
And I do think actually there's a profound point here Madam Deputy Speaker which is their voices are incredibly important in this debate. I utterly reject the idea that we want to make Israel a pariah state. I couldn't have been more clear in my statement about our friendship with the Israeli people and indeed our wish to have trade with Green Line Israel. But in a sense you have to take a view about the occupation. If the occupation is illegal do we want to maintain at the level of principle normal economic relations.
We say no he apparently says yes and I think that's a mistake. On his points then let me take his points in turn. Is it a coherent policy absolutely it is and I said it will take six to nine months to come into place and we will have discussions with members of the House and others but it's a sounder sanctions regime there are sanctions regimes on a number of other countries. Will it be geographic it will be in relation to the import ban and it'll be focused on the occupied the settlements in the occupied territories and we will absolutely ensure it does not hit Green Line Israel. He says we should act with others.
We've assembled a very wide international coalition precisely to act with others. On community cohesion community cohesion is incredibly important. But the the point the the absolute core of this Madam Deputy Speaker is surely we must all accept what I said in my statement which is we can disagree with the government of Israel we can take action with the government of Israel and at the same time be absolutely steadfast in protecting Jews across Britain and across the world. And we cannot let these debates be confused. On our intelligence partnerships I am confident about our intelligence and security partnerships which I talked about in my statement.
And on his point about medical supplies and so on absolutely they will be protected. The point I would end on Madam Deputy Speaker and I'll say this to all members of this House. One of the things that has been most apparent to me in this job in the seven weeks or so in this job is Britain is a highly respected partner across the world.
Britain has influence. Britain has reach. We cannot take a view of Britain that we are powerless in the face of injustice. And today we say we are not powerless, we can act.
Anne Emily Thornberry
Madam Deputy Speaker, at last. I'm so very happy to finally see a British government, a Labour British government, finally doing the right thing and taking a strong stand against the illegal building of settlements in the occupied territories of Palestine. No longer a bystander wringing their hands. The Foreign Affairs Committee unanimously called for this over a year ago, and as I look around this chamber, I see so many people here who have spent years campaigning on this issue. And there are many more outside this place.
We are all smiling today. Britain has an absolute obligation to take a strong, clear stance on this issue as a country that played such a pivotal role in the establishment of Israel during our mandate, but has frankly failed in the protection of interests of the Palestinians. Can I congratulate the Foreign Secretary for taking this very brave stance and for his very powerful and moving statement today. And to say that I am so proud that this has finally happened. But, could ministers and officials meet my committee and me and some of our officials to discuss whether we can implement these sanctions as quickly as possible.
David Lammy
Well, well, I'm grateful to my honourable friend for her words, and I pay tribute to her, and I also want, as I should have done actually in the statement, Madam Deputy Speaker, to members on all sides of this House who've been advocates of this issue, and I see them both opposite me and I see them behind me as well. And I also take this opportunity to pay tribute to the people outside this House whose voices have been heard in this debate. We had a, we've had good discussions, my honourable friend and I, about these questions, and I look forward to working with her and her committee, including on the speedy implementation of these plans.
Callum Miller
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, my thanks to the Secretary of State for advance sight of his statement. I want to thank him for sharing the painful history of his family. I know that will echo with many Jewish families in the UK, including in my constituency. I wish also strongly to associate myself and my party with the Foreign Secretary's clear statement that robustly challenging the illegal actions of this extremist Israeli government is compatible both with staunch support for the rights of the states of Israel and Palestine to exist and resolute support for the rights of British Jews to live free from the scourge of anti-Jewish hatred. Liberal Democrats called for years for the proscription of the IRGC.
We will work across this House to support the rights, freedoms and security of the British Jewish community. Madam Deputy Speaker, the recent scenes from Palestine should horrify every member of this House. The abhorrent violence against Palestinians, families awoken by soldiers breaking down the doors of their homes, evicted, the accelerated annexation of the West Bank spurred on by extremist ministers Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, attempts to destroy the possibility of a contiguous Palestinian state through E1 settlement construction, and the ongoing humanitarian disaster in Gaza. The two-state solution is being fatally threatened, and that is why today's announcement is greatly welcomed from these benches, but is also long overdue. Liberal Democrats have called for a trade ban for years and asked the government to declare Israel's occupation in Palestine as unlawful.
It is also right that the government has included services in this ban, with those financing or facilitating settlements now facing legal consequences. The Foreign Secretary has billed today's announcement as a reset in our relationship with Israel. This requires a vision for that future relationship. We want a relationship with Israel based on shared liberal values, but that requires the Israeli government recognising its obligations under international law, not riding roughshod over them.
The Foreign Secretary supports the role of the International Court of Justice in the determination of war crimes and genocide. Will he set out how the government is providing resources to allow the ICJ to complete its work in reaching a judgment? I also welcome the clear statement, long overdue, that the government accepts the ICJ's 2024 opinion that the occupation is unlawful. Will the Foreign Secretary publish the government's assessment of the duties this creates for the UK? I also welcome the Foreign Secretary's candour that the government has previously failed to do enough.
Today's measures cannot simply be symbolic, Madam Deputy Speaker, they must be robust, enforceable, and sustained for as long as necessary. So can the Foreign Secretary outline in more detail how enforcement measures would be implemented in response to any violation of these bans? He says that the ban on arms exports will endure as long as the illegal occupation. Will he confirm that this will include all arms exports, including F-35 parts? Will he spell out more clearly what he means when he says that the existing global human rights regime will be extended?
Madam Deputy Speaker, parties across this House have been united in our support with international partners for a two-state solution. It is this outcome that will bring peace, security, and stability to the Palestinian and Israeli people. As we approach an autumn of elections in Israel and Palestine, so critical to the future prospects for peace and justice, can the Foreign Secretary confirm that he will insist that the Palestinian Authority holds to the timetable for elections in November and that these will be free, fair, and open to all parties? And before these elections, will he work with international partners to ensure the disarmament of Hamas? Will he also commit to convey clearly and with no ambiguity to the government of Israel that the UK will stand up against breaches of international law and that there will be consequences when these occur?
This extremist Israeli cabinet has repeatedly acted to erase the prospects of a viable state in Palestine. In doing so, it has furthered a pattern of violence and destruction. Today must be the day that the UK says enough is enough.
David Lammy
Well, I thank the honourable gentleman for his support for the measures we are announcing today and I recognize his advocacy on this issue over a sustained period. Let me deal with the questions that he's asked in turn. On the ICJ, we do fully support the work of the ICJ, including in the so-called South Africa case. We have previously submitted to the court on the question of Myanmar, which I think will help inform some of their deliberations, and we look forward to them continuing their work. And indeed, he then referenced the ruling of unlawfulness.
That is where we have taken a view as a government, that the occupation is unlawful. We concur with the conclusions of the ICJ. Now, it is then a matter of principle as to what we then do across our economic relationships, and I've announced today the measures that we are taking. He raised the issue around arms, and I talked in my statement about the double lock. I do want to take on his point on the F-35s, though, just to be clear about this with the House.
We stopped providing direct parts to Israel's F-35 program in October 2024 under my right honourable friend the member for Tottenham when he was the Foreign Secretary.
The only provision we make now is indirectly to the global supply program. I'm afraid those who say that we should stop supplying parts to the global supply chain are actually advocating for the downing of the whole program, which is crucial to our NATO and other allies. And I just want to be sort of clear about this. Now, obviously, our ruling on legality is an important one, and we will continue to keep all of our responsibilities under review, including in relation to the F-35 program, but I just wanted to set that out for him. On the global human rights regime, we are extending the global human rights regime to international law.
We think this will be another important tool that we have to take action, because previously it didn't apply, the GHR didn't apply, the sanctions regime didn't apply to breaches of international humanitarian law. And as we set about our sanctions regime for the settlements in the occupied territories, this will give us a faster tool to act, and I'm very happy for us to have discussions about that. I agree with him on the Palestinian Authority and the both the support for the reform of the Palestinian Authority, the fact that Hamas must disarm and cannot be part of a future government in Gaza as part of the 20-point plan. And indeed, let's be frank, Madam Deputy Speaker, the need to accelerate the implementation of the 20-point plan, because, you know, I think there was some hope when the 20-point plan was produced, but frankly, you know, the situation in Gaza is unspeakable and the 20-point plan is not being implemented as it should be. I would just end by saying this, and I say this to him and all parties across this House, I want to work with people across this House who've worked on this issue over a long period so we get the legislation right, so we get our action right, and as much as possible, I think we can be united on this.
Dominic Liam Byrne
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I wholeheartedly welcome this well-rounded statement from the Foreign Secretary today and put on record my thanks to the new Prime Minister for the hard yards I know he has put in over recent days and weeks. It is not enough to recognize the state of Palestine and then stand idly by while illegal settlers destroy the Palestinian state and the Palestinian economy. Now, I have to correct the Shadow Foreign Secretary, that is not an accurate representation of the correspondence between ministers and my committee. But when ministers came before us on the 15th of July, they did tell us that they lacked the legal power to fully implement the proposals the Foreign Secretary has made today.
So can the Foreign Secretary tell the House today that he is taking on new legal powers in order to implement the full ban that he is proposing on goods, on services, and investment, because that is what is needed to give the measures full effect, full force, and real teeth. And we know nothing less will do.
Foreign Secretary.
David Lammy
Well, I thank my honorable friend for his great advocacy on this issue and indeed our conversations on this issue. And I can confirm to him that there will be a new sanctions regime which covers settlements in the occupied territories, and that the so-called SAMLA regime, and that is what under the SAMLA regime, and that is what will give us the powers that he is talking about to take action both on goods and indeed on services. And I think he is right to say that action on both is necessary if we are to have an effect. And I'd come back to this point, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is partly about what goods we should accept in this country, but truthfully our trade with the settlements in the occupied territories is relatively small when it comes to goods. We can make a real difference, I believe, to settlement expansion when it comes to the action on services, and we'll be working to make sure that happens.
Edward Leigh
Those of us who love the Jewish people and faith know that the reason why they've overcome all the empires that tried to destroy them is that they're primarily people of the book and not the sword. But what is happening in the West Bank is absolutely violent and egregious. It is worse than stopping the two-state solution, it is ethnic cleansing. So will he agree that actually the Israeli government could quite easily differentiate between general trade and trade to these illegal settlements? Would he agree that there's no reason when our country fully supports the right of Israel to defend itself that this should affect our intelligence relationship?
So I say to him now, I am proud to say as the longest-serving member of the Conservative Friends of Israel that I absolutely and fully support what he is doing today because it is about standing up for freedom, for morality and justice of all people in this world.
David Lammy
Well, I do, I do thank him for his words and if I, if I may say, I also read his extremely eloquent contribution in the backbench debate that took place in July on these questions and I was incredibly moved by his words in that debate. I, look, I believe he is, he is absolutely right in the way that he talks about these issues. I think he is absolutely right to say that he and I consider ourselves deep friends of Israel and that is absolutely consistent and indeed I would argue necessary in terms of what we are doing today because there can be no security for the people of Israel without a two-state solution and the actions of its government over the past few years has not made Israel more secure, it has made it less secure and that should trouble all friends of Israel across this country and across the world.
Judith Cummins
I appreciate how important this debate is, but questions must be short. Foreign Secretary, if you can be short too. Sarah Champion.
Sarah Champion
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Foreign Secretary, I welcome the entirety of this report, this statement, and particularly the acceptance of the ICJ advisory recommendation that Israel is indeed illegally occupying Palestine. The ICJ recommendation is broad and it is damning. It's not just about settlements. It's about taking Palestinian natural resources.
It's about forced transfer, taking Palestinian land, taking their goods, their businesses. It's also about stopping and preventing Palestinian trade and the free movement of people and imposing Israeli laws on the Palestinian people. So can I ask the Foreign Secretary, has he given any consideration to moving a motion at the UN Security Council to protect Palestinian rights? Is he doing anything to support the Palestinian Authority be able to effectively govern? And is he doing more to urge the Israeli politicians and government to enable journalists and politicians to enter Gaza so we can see for ourselves exactly what is going on?
David Lammy
Well, I think my honourable friend has, has played an incredibly important role in advocacy on these issues, including through her committee. I think I, I take all her points on board and I think one of the things that we will seek to do with events that will take place at the United Nations, not just the conference we're holding with Jordan, but other events that we'll be announcing shortly, is precisely to try and get at these issues.
The situation in Gaza is so urgent and so desperate that we must do everything we can to act.
Julian Lewis
Does the Foreign Secretary agree that this action is unlikely to affect the policy of the Netanyahu government? But as I hardly need to remind him, Israel is a parliamentary democracy, and has he reason to believe that it might affect the policy of the Israeli opposition? Did he have any contact with the Israeli opposition parties before coming to this conclusion?
David Lammy
Absolutely, we talk with all partners in Israel. Look, I don't want to in any sense interfere in that election. The election is for the Israeli people to make their own decisions as to their future. I've set out the policy of the British government, and I've made clear our quarrel is not with the Israeli people, it's with the policies of the Netanyahu government. And I said something that I would just highlight to him in my statement, which is we will assess the actions of any Israeli government in the future, whether it is on Gaza or on the West Bank.
Apsana Begum
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I please place my support on record for the Foreign Secretary for taking this strong stance today? Like the chair of the Select Committee said, at last, finally, but we still can't breathe like the Palestinians deserve to be able to breathe whilst they are still being occupied. And it is so welcome that our government has taken this position. It needs Britain to lead, and today Britain has led.
And I am also equally proud of our government for taking this stance. Does the Foreign Secretary agree with me it needs Britain to continue to show this leadership to ensure that this two-state solution happens and the Palestinians are free of occupation?
David Lammy
I agree with her and I again I praise her for her work on this issue. I would also say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that you know, I'm grateful for the kind words about my statement, but I feel a deep sense of humility compared to, for example, the people I met, including the doctor I met who was going herself to Gaza, a British pediatrician going herself to Gaza to try and help children, to help people who are sick. And there are so many people in our country who have not only campaigned on this issue but have actually gone and tried to make a difference, and I think we should recognize them today.
Speaker 112
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of my Jewish constituents have very grave concerns about the conduct of the current Israeli government. However, Israel is the Jewish homeland, and I think that many of them are concerned about the content of the statement, the highly political tone of the briefing around it, and the timing before Israelis themselves can decide in an election, in a democratic election. And in all of that, the message they're getting is that the current government no longer regards Israel as a friend. And that heaps pressure on an already beleaguered Jewish population.
What does he say to my constituents, many of whom are simply giving up on this country?
David Lammy
Well, I don't agree with him. I respect his point of view. Look, I think you have to, we have to distinguish in this debate, as I said, between Jews in Britain and indeed across the world and the Israeli government. But we also have to distinguish between the Israeli people and the Israeli government. I mean, there are, it's a whole diversity of opinion in Israel on these questions.
I just want to say to him on the election, because it was raised by the Shadow Foreign Secretary as well, and obviously I listened to those people who said, let's wait, let's wait even longer. I don't believe we can wait. I believe the situation is too urgent. Look at E1 where, where the tender finishes actually before the elections. And if I can put it this way, and I, you know, do this carefully, we can't outsource our political and moral responsibilities to the Israeli opposition.
They're our responsibilities to decide what we accept, what we consider legal, and then what we do.
Monica Harding
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State for his statement and support of further measures on sanctions against the current extremist regime in Israel in concert with our international allies. As we approach the Jewish High Holy Days, however, and in order to protect the religious freedom of British Jews who bear no responsibility for the actions of the Israeli government, I would like some assurances from him that there is sufficient clarity on imports, particularly agricultural products like etrogim that are a feature of the festival of Sukkot, so that there are not unintended consequences of the implementation of today's announcements as they take effect.
David Lammy
My honorable friend asks a really, really important question. I'm glad she did, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I said in my statement that there will be suitable religious exemptions for the import ban. And some honorable members may wonder why does it take six to nine months to bring this in, precisely because we want to get this right. And getting it right means a proper dialogue with the Jewish community.
Layla Moran
I have to say I found my, I shed a tear, not necessarily at the sanctions part, but the part where the government said that the occupation is illegal. Because ever since my election as the first British Palestinian MP, I have stood here, and I don't speak for the people of Palestine, I speak for the people of Oxford West and Abingdon, but I could only ever speak for myself. And I would stand in statements like this and frankly felt gaslit every single time we couldn't get a straight answer to that question. So to that I say thank you. But I further just ask, now that Britain I think is standing again tall on the world stage, the United Nations was founded in Westminster in 1946, we are applying international law without fear or favor again.
How does he intend to work with members across this House so that we can all play our part to make sure that that institution and ours stands tall forevermore?
David Lammy
Well, if I may say, I found what, the question she asked and what she said incredibly moving. And I'm very, very glad she asked that question. And look, let me undertake to her and members across this House to work together on these questions. I know that a lot of work has been going on before I became Foreign Secretary, including with ministers. I think there is a real opportunity to work together now across parties, and I say from this dispatch box I'll make sure it happens.
Sam Rushworth
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for his statement, which I know has the support of British Jewish organizations like Yachad and Progressive Judaism. I was with the father of the House opposite in an incident that he talked about where gun-wielding settlers came to, to visit us while we were in the West Bank. They had British accents. And this is distressing, and the Secretary of State said in his statement that this is a prelude to further justice. Will the government consider looking at universal jurisdiction so that British citizens who are supporting the illegal occupation will face the full force of the law?
David Lammy
Well, look, I think we've sent a clear message today about those involved in settlement activity, businesses and individuals, and I'll look at the point that he raised and, and write to him.
Bob Blackman
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a sad day for UK-Israel relationships. The risks that the Foreign Secretary is bringing, that affecting the Israeli elections, making even moderate politicians even more hawkish, is a huge risk. Equally, strengthening the Arab view that suddenly they can actually destroy the state of Israel, and indeed giving a victory to the BDS movement, who will look at full sanctions. He will know that it's very difficult to differentiate between products and services either side of the Green Line.
And what it runs the risk of doing is a full boycott of Israeli goods. What assessment has he made and what discussion has he made with his opposite number in Israel on the impact of his proposal?
David Lammy
Well look, there's a lot of questions in there. I really do utterly reject the premise of his question that this is somehow about the destruction of the state of Israel. I mean, actually, what my real fear is that the path that the Israeli government is embarked upon is undermining Israel's security. And I do say to him very gently, it must be possible for us as a House at a level of principle to understand the difference between Green Line Israel within the 1967 borders and the occupied territories. And if we conclude, and if we conclude that the settlements and the occupation is illegal, it's the right thing to do to act.
Zubir Ahmed
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I on behalf of all communities in Glasgow South West thank my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary and the Prime Minister for his global leadership. Leadership that means we call the atrocities in the West Bank terrorism, that we call them ethnic cleansing, and in Gaza we continue to support with full fervour anything that they require. In relation to Gaza, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I ask the Foreign Secretary, he knows many of my NHS colleagues have worked there and served there, that we continue to support them, but also support medical aid, not only by bringing children here, but making sure there is better infrastructure closer to home.
David Lammy
Well look, I thank him and I also thank him for the conversations we had on the run-up to this statement. And look, I make this open offer to people across the House on behalf of myself and the Minister for the Middle East, which is to work with members in the run-up to the work we're going to do at UNGA. Because this is a really, really important opportunity at UNGA to try and make a difference to the situation in Gaza, and I look forward to working with him and as I say others across this House on this question.
Monica Harding
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the Foreign Secretary on his words. They are overdue, but they are very, very welcome. Over 1.4 million people in Gaza are acutely food insecure. Yet the flow of essential goods face significant restrictions, a systematic denial of essential items Gaza needs for long-term sustainability.
You can buy an egg, but not a fertiliser. You can bring in a potato, but not a potato tuber. So what assessment has the government made of whether the current interpretation of dual-use restrictions in Gaza is compatible with Israel's obligation under international humanitarian law?
David Lammy
Well, I have to say the honourable lady raises such an important point. And my honourable friend was at the Al-Arish checkpoint where goods were being, where he saw goods that were supposedly dual-use being blocked from going in. And the answer is it's appalling the way that dual-use goods are being blocked. And one's only conclusion is it's a strategy, I'm afraid. And so I think it is deeply, deeply disturbing.
I call on the government of Israel to stop blocking these many, many entirely innocent dual-use goods that could make a difference for the people of Gaza.
Joseph Simon Opher
Can I just thank the Foreign Secretary for lifting the mood in this whole house with this thing. And all of no longer are we bystanders wringing our hands, we're doing something active and thank you for that. I met a doctor, Dr. Nick Maynard this week, who's a surgeon in Gaza and it's clear that the health professions have been deliberately targeted, over 2,000 killed. Even there's a new word for this, healthicide. So I wonder if the Foreign Secretary would meet with me and some doctors and discuss how we prevent this happening in the future.
David Lammy
I think the honorable gentleman raises a really, really important point, which is if you look at the number of aid workers, health workers killed in Gaza, it is absolutely appalling and dreadful. And I am very happy to myself, my honorable friend, to meet with him and others, particularly in the run-up to UNGA, but and indeed beyond, because we need to try and make a difference.
Kit Malthouse
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I too applaud the Foreign Secretary finally for taking some assertive, confident steps to deter Israeli ambitions in the West Bank. But I'm perplexed as to why he's waiting nine months. The diggers may well have started on site in E1 by then. So could he just explain a little more detail why he's waiting so long?
He's got the majority, let's get on with it. Secondly, has he made it clear to the Israeli government that if this deterrent doesn't work, he's willing to take further steps? That this is not the end of the story. Thirdly, I welcome his embrace finally of the strength of international law. And does he recognize that the security of Israel, Palestine, and indeed the United Kingdom stands in the impartial application of international law across the world?
And so will we see a pushback against American attacks upon the institutions that underpin international law? And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, as part of the accountability he's talked about, can we please have a UK-led investigation into the murder of our own citizens who worked for the World Central Kitchen, where the Israeli government has declined to conduct a criminal investigation and indeed officers of the IDF who've been involved in that operation have been out on the media boasting that they would do it again.
David Lammy
So the honorable gentleman has a very honorable record on this issue, if I may say so. Let me quickly clip through his questions, knowing the constraints on time, Madam Deputy Speaker. I agree with him on World Central Kitchen. It's absolutely appalling that the investigation has been closed down. It was an appalling, when you hear what happened in that incident, it makes one's blood run cold, frankly.
And in the end, it amounted to a cold-blooded killing, in my view. On international law in general, absolutely, we need to uphold international law and we say that to all of our partners. On timing, look, let me just say to him, I want to do this as quickly as possible. We've got to get this right for some of the reasons that have been discussed in this house, whether it's religious exemptions or whether it's making sure we don't hit green line Israel, but we want to do it as quickly as possible. And if we can do it quicker, we will.
And again, I look forward to cross-party discussions on these questions. And then on his, but the other thing I'd say to him is our extension of the GHR for international humanitarian law breaches will allow us to act more quickly, including on some of the things that could be captured in the goods and services action.
Judith Cummins
Asking more than one question just denies another colleague the ability to contribute. Afzal Khan.
Afzal Khan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Foreign Secretary and the new Prime Minister have shown leadership and moral courage introducing these sanctions. I strongly welcome the Foreign Secretary's support for the International Criminal Court's case on genocide in Gaza. So what discussion will he have with allies to encourage more countries to support the ICJ's judicial process to bring about justice for Palestine?
David Lammy
Well, we do, we are strong, I thank my honorable friend for the question. We are strong supporters of the ICJ and the work it does on this question and a whole range of others.
And in a sense, bringing together his question and the question the honorable gentleman asked from the other benches, you know, I think it is very, very important that we uphold the work of these courts.
Apsana Begum.
Brendan O'Hara
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We genuinely welcome this statement, and the Foreign Secretary has hinted at it, but let me be absolutely clear. It's somewhere between heartbreaking and criminal that it's taken three years and 70,000 Palestinian deaths for the UK government to finally arrive at this position. Already, however, we're hearing that elements within the FCDO are briefing that these sanctions are largely symbolic. Will the Foreign Secretary utterly refute that, and will he confirm that these sanctions are not fixed and that there can and will be further action should Israel press ahead with its illegal expansion program?
David Lammy
Well, look, I do just want to gently say to him that, you know, this government, previous government, recognized the state of Palestine, that was a major thing that it did, and also, and I praise my predecessors for that, and also took action on arms licenses. So I don't completely accept the picture he set, but I do agree, as the Prime Minister has said, that we need, we need to do more, and that's what we have done today. On the sanctions regime, I think it is substantive. I think it's going to make a substantive difference, and that is absolutely our intention. And he's absolutely right that once we bring in the sanctions regime, we of course always keep its scope under review.
Apsana Begum
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In July, I led a debate on settlement expansion. I argued for international law to be respected and for the status quo to end. For far too long, we were told that a trade ban was too difficult, even impossible. And for far too long, Palestinian lives have not carried the same weight as Israeli lives in British foreign policy.
Palestinians deserve to have the exact same freedoms as Israelis. They deserve to live free from checkpoints, free from settler violence, free from occupation, and free from oppression. I thank the Foreign Secretary for his words, for his action, and more importantly, for the change of direction, and for showing that Britain can lead with a clear moral compass once again. Today is one of those rare moments when foreign policy can genuinely make a difference. Does the Foreign Secretary agree with me that international law can and must mean something once again, and will he confirm that the ICC arrest warrants still stand and that Britain will respect that policy?
David Lammy
Well, let me praise my honorable friend, Madam Deputy Speaker, for her work on this issue and indeed for the debate that she led. We're big supporters of the work of the ICC, absolutely she is, she is right about that. And I just say to her more widely, I think that she makes such an important point about upholding international law. It undermines our reputation globally when we fail to uphold international law, and actually if we want to build strong alliances, we need to be consistent in our approach.
Mark Pritchard.
Mark Pritchard
Can I welcome the moral, legal, and ethical thread running through the Foreign Secretary's statement that the life of a Palestinian child is as precious as the life of an Israeli child? He's right to talk about consensus on the two-state solution. Where there is not consensus is on the timing of the recognition of a Palestinian state. He will know that eight of us on this side joined the Saudis, the French, and indeed the British government in recognizing a Palestinian state last September. I'm glad there is also consensus, including our front bench today, that they said they wanted to protect the viability of a future two-state solution.
So does he agree with me that it is action that is now required to reconcile those two positions in order that we actually do have a viability of a state in the future?
David Lammy
Yeah, I thank him for his question and I thank him for the conversation we had the other night when we ran into each other on this issue, which I found incredibly useful and important. I think he is absolutely right about this. We can't stand by, we have to act. And I think it's about, this is partly about our psychology as a country, which is we are not powerless. We are not powerless, particularly when we work with others.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have stood in a farm in the West Bank and seen all the olive trees burnt and all of the families in the village turfed out at knifepoint. And so I am really welcome this statement and this step up of action on the settlements. I welcome the action on the sanctions, on arms sales and on justice. Can I ask the Foreign Secretary to elaborate a bit more on that crucial demand that Israel releases the revenues, the tax paid by Palestinian people to Israel, which is being withheld and then cannot be spent on schools, on hospitals and on rebuilding?
Can he say a bit more about what he'll be doing on that?
David Lammy
Well, absolutely, this is, these are issues we raise with our Israeli counterparts because it is a, you know, it is, there are so many crises in Palestine, but this is a terrible crisis, which in a sense doesn't get the, perhaps the attention it deserves about the just the withholding of money, which is in its own way threatening the viability of the Palestinian Authority and the Palestinian state. Yes, they need to keep reforming, but Israel needs to release the funds.
Munira Wilson.
Munira Wilson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I warmly welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement today? When I visited the West Bank in 2022 with my honourable friend, the member for Oxford West and Abingdon, we met Palestinians whose schools and homes had been demolished to make way for settlements. It was utterly heartbreaking. So the measures announced today are very welcome, albeit overdue.
But could he tell the House what specific action he plans to take on British companies, such as JCB, which facilitate this destruction, having previously been told by a trade minister this time last year that all there was was guidance on gov.uk and they should be aware of the reputational risk?
David Lammy
The honourable lady raises an important issue. I think she will know that as we design a sanctions regime, we don't comment on individual companies in advance. But I think my statement was very clear that we do not want to see the construction, financing and so on of settlement expansion, and that is the way we will think about our sanctions regime.
Hilary James Benn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I congratulate my right honourable friend on both the substance but the moral clarity of his statement today? Last weekend, Mike Huckabee, the United States ambassador to Israel, condemned Israeli settler violence as terrorism. Does he therefore share the widespread concern that the IDF, rather than take action to arrest these terrorists, is all too often to be seen watching or even facilitating, it's been widely reported, while Palestinian homes are attacked and their property is seized?
David Lammy
Well, my right honourable friend speaks with enormous distinction on these and many other issues, and I thank him for his contribution. He is right. I do urge members on all sides to read the accounts of what is happening in the West Bank, what is happening in relation to the settlers, because it is impossible to avoid the conclusion that members of the IDF are anything other than complicit in what is, in what is happening, episode after episode that has been documented of what is actually happening on the ground.
Sir Desmond Swayne.
Desmond Swayne
Madam Deputy Speaker, I join that long list of UK ministers who have raised at the very highest level in Israel the most egregious practices in the West Bank designed specifically to prevent a two-state solution, only for Israeli policy to double down. Accordingly, I congratulate the Secretary of State.
David Lammy
Well, I thank him for his contribution and I think he will see, I think his experience speaks to the frustration of ministers on both sides of this House who have repeatedly tried to make a difference, pleaded with Israeli ministers to see what was going on, to act on what was going on, and it has been rebuffed, and that is what has led to today's announcement.
Paula Barker.
Paula Barker
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I hope the whole House will join me in condemning the personal attacks and smears on the Foreign Secretary that he faced over the weekend. I'd like to congratulate my right honourable friend and also the Prime Minister for the strong stance that they have taken. And does he agree with me that the acts of violence perpetrated by the settlers in the West Bank must be called out for what they are: settler terrorism designed to forcibly remove Palestinian communities?
David Lammy
My right honourable friend is absolutely right about this and the world's eyes have rightly been on the crisis in Gaza and the world's eyes have also have to be on the crisis and what the appalling settler terrorism that we are seeing in the West Bank. I talked about it in my statement and, you know, the fact that a former Israeli Prime Minister described it as ethnic cleansing, I think should give people not just in this House, but in Israel proper pause about what is actually happening and going on.
Liz Roberts
It's welcome that the UK is finally banning trade with illegal settlements in Palestine and it's right that we no longer condone economic tolerance for these settlements. It flies in the face of international law and the sovereignty of Palestine. But if these sanctions are to be truly more than symbolic, can the Secretary of State tell us how the ban will be enforced and whether goods from illegal settlements are not simply relabelled or services concealed within contractual sleight of hand to get round his proposals?
David Lammy
Well, like all of our sanctions regimes, there are fines and action that will be taken against companies that breach them. And, you know, we are widely known across the world for the strength of our sanctions regime and I think it really is important to underline this point that by using the SAMLA powers, these will be tough sanctions and it will be absolutely clear that there will be penalties for breaching them.
Siobhan Baillie.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I strongly welcome the government's new sanctions, which are the right and moral approach to the crimes that we've been seeing and continue to see in the West Bank. The Foreign Secretary will have seen the comments from Israeli Minister Ben-Gvir that in response to these sanctions, Israel should recognise Argentina's claims on the Falkland Islands. Will the Foreign Secretary now make clear that such threats will not stop the UK from upholding international law and the right of people to self-determination, whether that is in the Falkland Islands or in the occupied Palestinian territories?
David Lammy
Well, obviously these comments are absurd and wrong. The Falkland Islands are British and will remain so because that's what the islanders want. And, you know, in a sense, when I heard these comments, I think it shows just the complete lack of sort of understanding and comprehension of the injustice that is going on in relation to the occupied territories and the unlawfulness because this is an occupation against the will of the people there. The Falkland Islands, as I say, are British because that's what the Falkland Islanders want.
Andrew Murrison
Since he's not going to get the cooperation fulsome or otherwise of the Israeli state in differentiating goods and services made in the settlements from those that are assembled, repackaged, produced, grown in Israel itself, how is he going to distinguish the one from the other?
Dr Andrew Murrison.
David Lammy
Well this will be the responsibility of British businesses and other businesses who want to import into this country. I mean I do want to underline this. That is the point of the sanctions regime that we are bringing in. And just to develop this point a bit more Madam Deputy Speaker, it's likely to be based on the postcodes of where the settlements are and companies will have to say that the goods that they are bringing in do not come from those areas.
James Mark Sewards
Madam Deputy Speaker, I support the government's complete opposition to the expansion of E1 and its opposition to the violent settlers that put the two-state solution genuinely at risk. I just want to press him further on his comments about BDS. What further specific details can he give this House that these measures won't be interpreted as support for that movement or indeed following on from questions from others, spill over into a banner de facto ban for other Israeli goods? We know that the BDS movement is supported by people who think that the Jewish people and the Jewish people alone have no right to self-determination.
David Lammy
Well I thank him for his I thank him I thank him for his contribution. I also thank him for the conversations that we've had in the run-up to this statement which have been important. I'd say a couple of things to him. We absolutely oppose the BDS movement, boycott divestment sanctions against Israel. This is about the occupied territory, settlements in the occupied territories.
And in answer to the question of the honourable gentleman about why does it take six to nine months, precisely so that we get this regime right so it does not affect, does not impinge on green line Israel.
Susan Murray
Thank you. I also want to thank the Foreign Secretary for his statement. And Madam Deputy Speaker, on behalf of my constituents in Mid Dunbartonshire, I'm asking the Foreign Secretary not to overlook the Palestinian healthcare workers including Dr. Abu Safiya who are being held in Israeli prisons and to work to secure their release.
David Lammy
Well the honourable lady raises a very, very important case and I'm glad that she has and I'm happy to look at it and endeavour to do everything I can to make a difference.
Rushanara Ali
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to thank the Foreign Secretary for his incredibly moving and courageous statement. He's been a friend of Israelis and Palestinians. When he was leader of the opposition, he and the Labour Party recognized Palestinian statehood and I'm proud of the fact that this Labour government has recognized Palestinian statehood. Does he agree with me that without these sanctions, without action where we know that at least 17 companies linked to illegal Israeli settlements were found to hold 125 UK public sector contracts worth 2.1 billion pounds, we will not be able to take the necessary action to protect a viable two-state and ensure that we can see a day where we have a Palestinian state?
David Lammy
My honourable friend has been an incredibly powerful advocate on this issue for a very long period of time and I really welcome her words. She is absolutely right that I'm afraid inaction is simply abdicating our responsibilities for what we see happening before our eyes and has been eloquently described on both sides of this House. That's why we've taken the action that we have and it is designed to make a difference and save, help save the two-state solution.
Speaker 176
Can I draw members' attention to my entry on the register?
Madam Deputy Speaker, the Middle East and North Africa contains multiple wars, protracted civil conflicts, and severe humanitarian crises. Of the 193 UN member states, what exactly does the Foreign Secretary think explains the relentless focus, morning, noon, and night, on the one Jewish state, a country covering just 0.01% of the world's surface? And does he really think that all the anti-Semitic Corbynista activist crowd and unintegrated sectarian immigrant groups will again vote for his party if he panders to their unhealthy obsession?
David Lammy
Well, look, I'm, I regret the tone of the honorable gentleman's question, honestly. Look, what I say to him is I think he needs to take a sober look at what has happened in relation to Israel and Palestine, what has happened in Gaza and the West Bank. And frankly, on his own side and on this side and on the other side of the house, he has eloquently heard described the huge injustices. Now, look, my view is we need to be tackling injustice across the world, but you know, we can't ignore the centrality of Israel and Palestine, both our historic relationship with Israel and our responsibilities, and also the suffering of the Palestinian people, and also, frankly, in terms of our interests, our geopolitical interests, we will never have stability in the Middle East without a two-state solution. So for all those reasons, it's right we act.
Speaker 180
This debate has been conducted with good tone and temperament, and that's how it should continue. Damian Egan.
Damien James Egan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. All of us want to see an end to violence in the West Bank, and the government should challenge the Israeli government, but also the Palestinian Authority. I find myself asking, will these sanctions bring peace any closer, and how will they impact Britain? So I'd like to ask, given other anti-Israel measures have failed to have the impact this government seeks, what difference does the Secretary of State think this new round will make? And given our deep trade relationships in areas like defense and health, as well as warnings about possible conflicts with US policy, is there not a risk that British interests could be harmed as a result of this announcement?
David Lammy
Well, look, I thank him for his question, and I, I think the answer to the question is no. I just do want to correct him on one thing: these are not anti-Israel policies. This is about the occupied territories, which we have found as a government and the ICJ found as a government were unlawfully occupied. And it's really, really important to say that, and once you decide that the occupied territories, it is an unlawful occupation, I do believe that as a matter of principle and a matter of morality, frankly, that then other things follow about the economic relationships you choose to have.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I warmly welcome this statement, and I'd like to thank the Foreign Secretary for taking this step today. Yes, it's been far too long coming. Yes, there is much more to do. But this is a really significant statement, both in terms of recognition of the reality of the unlawfulness of the occupation and in following through with a promise to take action in banning trade with settlements.
But I ask the Foreign Secretary, does he not recognize that in the context of now years of genocide in Gaza, ever-accelerating ethnic cleansing in the West Bank, as he's pointed out himself, waiting another six to nine months to implement this is still too long?
David Lammy
Well look, I thank her for her kind words and I also thank her for kind words behind the chair just as we were coming in, which meant a lot to me. I want to do this as quickly as possible. And I'd just say this: six to nine months is what I've said in the statement. If we can do it quicker, we will. We want to get it right because it's important that it actually makes a difference.
And it's also really important to say, because it's in a sense the thing that will have got less attention today, that our extension of the global human rights regime to international humanitarian law violations will also help us to take action even more swiftly.
James Asser.
Speaker 188
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Foreign Secretary for his statement today, which will be welcomed by many in my constituency, but also thank him for the light he's continuing to shine on Gaza. He's talked about the students we have brought across, many of whom I've met and who are bright and intelligent and any country would be proud to have them as part of their future. But for a future, children need to have one. He has talked of the appalling death toll of children, but there are also tens of thousands of children unaccompanied in Gaza in desperate need, particularly since the collapse of the medical system.
Could he tell us what more we can do to give them protection, medical aid, so that they have the future they deserve?
David Lammy
Well look, my honourable friend raises, and again thank you for the conversation we had, raises such an important sort of issue here about the healthcare crisis in Gaza. I think the answer is we want to do as much as we can as a country and we want to do as much as we can working with others. I talked to the Jordanian Foreign Minister, I think it was on Sunday, about this event that we're going to hold at the UN General Assembly. And one of the things we both agreed, look, it's we want to try and actually move things forward and make a difference. And I absolutely promise him that's what we'll endeavour to do.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Foreign Secretary recognise that the hundreds of thousands of us that have marched and met in support of the Palestinian people, be they Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Hindu or Buddhist, have done so out of a motivation to bring about justice and peace for the people of Palestine? And will he specifically call for Israel to withdraw in totality from Gaza, not just the 70% they occupy now, but the remaining part that they're bombarding? And if the military sanctions are to mean anything, surely that must include an end to the sharing of surveillance information by the RAF overflying Gaza, the use of RAF Akrotiri, and the ability that Israel has to manufacture weapons at Elbit Systems' factories in this country as well. If we're serious about ending the military occupation, then we have to play a very full part in achieving that.
David Lammy
I do want to see Israel withdraw from Gaza and I want to see Hamas disarm, and that is the whole point of the 20-point plan and I agree with him on that. I do say that the campaigners on this issue have played an important role in this. And I think the way in which actually young people, people across the country, and it's not just in Britain actually, it's across the world, have been mobilised on this issue should tell all of us in this House something about the deep sense of injustice people feel about what has unfolded. On his point about intelligence, I want to be careful on this. We are not in any sense helping with the occupation, but we do have important and valued intelligence and security relationships with Israel.
Vicky Ford.
Preet Gill
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I oppose the UN settlement plan and welcome the action against extremist settler violence by this government. My constituent Ruth Jacobs and others have raised with me that with Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur approaching and British Jews facing an elevated threat, what steps is the government taking to ensure that measures do not contribute to further antisemitism or undermine the security and confidence of Jewish communities in Birmingham Edgbaston and across the UK?
David Lammy
My honourable friend raises an important point. We have made a difference in the investment we made, I talked about it in my statement, to the security of Jewish people across Britain.
But in a sense, if I can say this to her, we all have a responsibility, not just as politicians but as a society on this issue. And I just want to re-emphasize what I said in my statement, because it is so important this, which is no British Jew should be held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government. And I think all of us, and I really urge this of all members in this house, all of us have a responsibility to transmit this message to the public, because whether it's a combination of prejudice or ignorance, I'm afraid people often don't understand this lesson and it leads to terrible antisemitism.
Christine Jardine.
Christine Jardine
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I add my welcome to the Foreign Secretary, not just for the substance of his remarks today, but for the tone and responsibility and commitment to a two-state solution. And I know that in my constituency of Edinburgh West, that welcome will be reflected amongst the people of all faiths and none who have been profoundly affected both by what they've seen in the Middle East over the past few years, but by the tension they have felt rising in this country and that we have to address. But could I also ask the Foreign Secretary if he could explain to us how or what steps he is going to take to allow UK banks and corporate institutions to perhaps audit their own customer base to ensure that the supply chains are being dealt with properly?
David Lammy
Well, look, we'll look at all of these issues as part of our sanctions regime. It is important to protect trade with Green Line Israel and financial services in Green Line Israel, and that's why we want to be careful with this sanctions regime. Just on the first part of her remarks, I thank her for what she said. I do feel a sense of humility. If I can just do this, Madam Deputy Speaker, as some people in this house will know, my late mother was a big campaigner on these issues and she died a few months back, and I've thought quite a lot in this process about what she might be saying on these issues.
Yasmin Qureshi.
Yasmin Qureshi
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I say how proud I am to sit behind a Foreign Secretary with the courage to do this, and I want to thank the Prime Minister for showing leadership on this matter as well. Let us be clear what this is about. Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is illegal under international law. Israel has moved over 700,000 settlers onto Palestinian land, forced half a million Palestinians from their homes, and the new plans E1 settlement, its own ministers will say, bury a two-state solution.
These sanctions target trade from illegal settlements, not Israel and not Jewish people, and anyone who says otherwise is deliberately misleading. Therefore, can I ask him if he will confirm that no amount of pressure from Washington or Tel Aviv would retreat the government from doing this?
David Lammy
Well, I've set out our plans today, this is what we're going to do. My honorable friend speaks with great eloquence on these questions, and look, we have to decide what is in our national interest, what's the right thing for Britain based on our values.
Richard Tice.
Richard Tice
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I refer to my register of interest. We all deplore, Foreign Secretary, settler violence. But the simple reality is these sanctions are a grave mistake. And does he understand that so many people are concerned all it will do is embolden the scourge of antisemitism against British Jews on British streets?
It will endanger our relationship with the United States security and also lead to tit-for-tat sanctions from the Israeli government.
David Lammy
If I may say to him, I don't think that was a very responsible way of talking about these issues. He's welcome to disagree with our actions, as I think the right honorable gentleman from the Conservative Party did, but I don't think he should be talking in this way.
I couldn't have been clearer in my statement that no British Jew is responsible for the policies of the Israeli government. And it behoves all of us, whichever side of this debate we're on, to make sure that there can be no confusion about that question. And I'm afraid his question fell foul of that.
Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank my right honourable friend for his statement and congratulate him not just in terms of the content but also the tone that he delivered that. He has elevated the status not just of this Parliament and this government, but I'd say of the country as well, by ensuring that everybody, all states, individuals are seen as equal before the law and in terms of human rights. Can I specifically also agree with him about we must all take our part in ensuring that we protect our Jewish friends and colleagues and neighbours and ensure that they are not seen, that it's not collective punishment. But could he give details in terms of the next steps around the statutory instrument for the Samidoun?
David Lammy
I'll answer that briefly, Madam Deputy Speaker. We will get on with the process now of making the statutory instrument happen. I just do want to pick up on her earlier point though. I happened to meet, actually on the day the new Prime Minister was sworn into Parliament, a young man who'd been, I think he was 17 or so, who'd been at school in the UK. And he just talked to me, happened to talk to me about the antisemitism he had faced since the age of 11 at his secondary school.
I think I really say all of us in this House need to take so seriously the everyday experiences of British Jews which sees antisemitism not just in schools but elsewhere, and we all have a responsibility to tackle it.
Andrew George.
Andrew George
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Apart from the Netanyahu fan club, in spite of the change of guard on the Tory front bench and the latecomer behind me, the vast majority of people in this chamber strongly support the Foreign Secretary with his statement today. And indeed I warmly welcome his remarks about the need for a proper investigation into the appalling, as he described it, unlawful killing of those serving in the World Central Kitchen, including Cornishman Jim Henderson. But in relation to the sanctions themselves, would he say more about what sanctions he will impose on British banks which are complicit in what is going on there, and British citizens who are complicit in what is going on in the West Bank?
David Lammy
Well, as I said earlier, that when we do sanctions on specific companies or entities, we don't in advance say who they are. But I think I couldn't have been clearer about the intent here. And the intent, and I said it in my statement, is that we do not want British companies being involved with financing of settlement expansion, construction of settlement expansion, or the infrastructure of settlement expansion. That is going to be the purpose of the regime when it comes to services, and that's what we'll make happen.
Rizwana Tulip Siddiq
Tulip Siddiq.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Whereas I recognise this wasn't the main part of the Foreign Secretary's statement, could I thank him for raising the plight of British Jewish children who are going to school and who are fearful. He will know a lot of these children live in my constituency and their safety is my main priority. But on the subject of children, a recent report showed that 40% of displaced children lose complete access to education in Palestine. I know he has outlined a host of policies and legislation in his statement today.
Has he given any thought to how he would help these displaced children ensure they don't lose access to schooling? And just indulge me for one second, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I just say his mother Marion, who lobbied me endlessly when I was a local councillor, would be very proud of him.
David Lammy
Well, that was that was worth getting some extra time for. Uh, uh, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think my honourable friend raises a really, really important issue around, uh, education. She also raised an important issue around the safety of children in the UK, Jewish children going to school in the UK. We'll we'll take forward both of those issues.
Zarah Sultana.
Speaker 202
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This government still describes Israel, an apartheid state committing genocide in Gaza, as a strategically important partner. It announces a partial arms sales ban while continuing to provide intelligence and F-35 fighter jet components via the international pool. Whether directly or indirectly, arming a genocide is still arming a genocide. And it announced a settlement ban as a dead cat, hoping to distract us from wider UK complicity.
The Foreign Secretary could impose full economic and diplomatic sanctions on Israel. He refuses. He could end all arms sales and intelligence cooperation. He refuses. He could call this what it is, a genocide.
He refuses. So, I ask him directly: how many more Palestinian men, women, and children must be killed by Union Jack weapons before this government finally stops arming Israel completely?
David Lammy
I I mean, her her statement is a complete travesty, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is a complete travesty. This government is taking action. It's taking action on goods. It's taking action on services.
We've banned the, um, arms licences for the IDF in Gaza. We've taken action across the board. We've declared the occupation as unlawful. It it might have been designed for TikTok, but it doesn't it doesn't it really doesn't become her.
Judith Stella Creasy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Foreign Secretary for his clear-sighted commitment not just to talk about a two-state solution, but to actually try to act to achieve it as the foundation, the only foundation of a safe Israel and a free Palestine, and his clarity that international law matters, and who it is who is putting at risk the two-state solution, which is the current Israeli government. It is good also to see him working across the world on this. We can see that we have partners in that mission, but we also know that there are those who would oppose what he's seeking to do. Sadly, we have already heard talk that there will be retaliation, particularly from Israel and America, um, if the ban goes ahead.
Could he just reassure this house that we will not bend to such pressure and we will not acquiesce, and the only action that could ever be accepted or even contemplating reversing this ban would be a halt on the E1 development and an end, a permanent end to settler violence?
David Lammy
My honourable friend speaks with great expertise on these issues and she's absolutely right. We are going to act in our national interest on the basis of our values. That is our not just our right as a country, but our duty as a country.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to join with everybody in thanking the government for these actions. But I'm deeply concerned about the fear that may have been caused by the Shadow Foreign Secretary's comments earlier. The Foreign Secretary made clear this is action against the settlements and confirmed continued trade within Green Line Israel. Can you assure our constituents that life-saving drugs made in Israel, mainly around the Tel Aviv central area and not in illegal settlements, are not at risk and that the supply chains for medications will not be affected by this very welcome action?
David Lammy
I'm really glad that the honourable lady asked that asked that question and she's absolutely right.
So I can answer an emphatic yes.
Eun Yang.
Yuan Yang
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Two months ago, our new Prime Minister admitted that the UK needed to do better. And today, the Foreign Secretary has shown us how things get done by working together with our allies to declare a ban on trade with illegal settlements and declaring the occupation itself unlawful. Last year, my friend, the honorable member for Sheffield Central and I were denied entry to the West Bank for our advocacy in this House. And the Foreign Secretary has already withstood threats and intimidation as a result of his bold principled stand.
Will he continue to do so with the moral courage he has already shown us?
David Lammy
Well, I thank my honorable friend for the question. And she is absolutely right on this question of access because it's true across the board, whether it is politicians or others denied access to see what is going on for themselves. And, you know, that should make one extremely skeptical and extremely fearful, frankly, of what is actually happening on the ground.
Danny Chambers.
Sammy Wilson
Madam Deputy Speaker, and I draw attention to my register of interest. The Foreign Secretary has said that his concern is for the behavior of some settlers on the West Bank, and I think we all share that. But would he accept that the fear of losing votes to the Green Party and the members behind me is also a major reason why he is politically and economically punishing one of our allies, which supplies us with important intelligence information? And would he accept that this will punish Palestinians? It will eventually lead to a total boycott to be effective.
It will lead to economically damaging retaliation.
Speaker 140
Foreign Secretary. Before the Foreign Secretary responds, I will have to cut people off if they continue, and that will ruin their social media shots if that's what they're here for. There are far too many people still wishing to contribute, and you are only going to disappoint your own colleagues. Keep your questions short. Foreign Secretary.
David Lammy
I don't accept any of that. And I'd just say to him, because I've known him a long time, how dare he try and speak for the Palestinian people rather than the Palestinian Prime Minister or the Palestinian Ambassador in the UK. Why doesn't he meet the Palestinian Ambassador in the UK and hear from him?
Alex Sobel
Madam Speaker, I'm pleased that my right honorable friend the Foreign Secretary started by talking about some of our shared history of visiting our grandmothers in Israel, which gives him a clarity and authority on these matters that few else in the chamber have. We would not accept goods from Russian-occupied Ukraine, would not accept goods from Chinese-occupied Tibet, so why would we accept goods from Israeli-occupied Palestinian territory? I just want to finish by asking him, I still have many Gazan students wishing to come to Leeds University and other colleagues have to other universities, and they are not being able to get their visas. Can we look at a visa-light or visa-free regime for those Gazan students?
David Lammy
We will keep looking at what we can do in relation to students and others from Gaza. He's absolutely right about that. And just on the first part of his statement, I think this is such a fundamental point that he makes, which is the ICJ made its statement on legality, we've taken a view on legality. Now people can accept it or not accept it, but if you accept the view on legality, how can we possibly defend the situation where we have continued and unchanged economic relationships with the occupied territories?
Dr. Danny Chambers.
Danny Chambers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also thank the Foreign Secretary for his very eloquent and moving statement at the beginning, giving us perspective as a British Jew in this awful situation. Madam Deputy Speaker, settlers have been deliberately killing Palestinian men, women, and children. They have also been killing and stealing their livestock and preventing them from grazing in pastoral areas. Now for pastoral communities, this is absolutely devastating.
It's simply another mechanism of forced displacement. And so will the Foreign Secretary consider sanctioning the Israeli ministers who are encouraging and endorsing this kind of violence?
David Lammy
Well, we've already sanctioned two Israeli ministers who did that. We always keep our sanctions regime under review. I think he makes such a profoundly important point about the everyday intimidation that Palestinians on the West Bank face, not just this year, not just under this government, frankly, but under previous governments as well. It's been an endless amount of intimidation which I saw in 2014 when I was there and heard from people about, and frankly, it is totally indefensible.
Clive Betts.
Clive Betts
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I wholeheartedly welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement, both its content and its tone? Could I ask him, in discussions with our colleagues and allies in other countries who are looking to implement similar sanctions, has he had a discussion with the Netherlands government, who announced sanctions, their intention to impose sanctions in July? They're going to implement them on September the 22nd. That's two months it's taken them.
Could he ask them why they're taking two months when we're going to take eight to nine months?
David Lammy
Well, look, I think they have a slightly different regime, but we'll definitely, I'm in touch with my Dutch colleague and we'll definitely ask him if we can do it more quickly.
Zöe Franklin.
Shockat Patel
Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to quote the Egyptian-American author Omar Al Akkad, who said, "One day, when it is safe, when there is no personal downside to calling a thing what it is, when it's too late to hold anyone accountable, everyone will have been against this." Foreign Secretary, I do thank you for your statement. Many of my constituents will thank you. It is late. It's 70,000 Gazan dead late.
But it's still not too late to hold those perpetrators of war crimes to account. So can I ask the Foreign Secretary what he will do to hold the war criminals to account?
David Lammy
I do thank him for his remarks and it's kind of him to say this. I mean, look, I believe in accountability and I believe in accountability for war crimes and that's what the international courts are for.
Richard Burgon.
Richard Burgon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. These sanctions on Israel for its illegal occupation are incredibly welcome as a step towards meeting our moral and legal obligations. Can I ask the Foreign Secretary to continue to resist pressure from those who say that he shouldn't make international law apply to Israel? And can I urge him to push forward and demand the full implementation of the ICJ ruling so that the Palestinian people can have justice?
David Lammy
My honourable friend has campaigned on these issues for a long time. He is absolutely right about the importance both of accountability and international law, and absolutely we will be guided by that.
Apsana Begum.
Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before the recess, a group of school children from my constituency handed in a petition to Number 10 as part of their courageous advocacy project. They wanted children in Palestine to have the same right to education as they do here. Could the Foreign Secretary respond to their petition now and say what steps he's doing to ensure their words are heard?
David Lammy
Well, we absolutely want to do everything we can to help Palestinian children in Gaza and indeed in the West Bank. The best thing we can do is get a two-state solution without the intimidation, the threats, the death and destruction that so many Palestinian children have faced. I want to take this opportunity to congratulate the children in his, the school in his constituency for being moved by this issue and for advocating on this issue.
Apsana Begum.
Apsana Begum
I thank the Secretary of State for his statement and for the long-awaited announcement. But may I press him on the UK's existing intelligence and security partnerships with Israel, given that experts have said that RAF spy planes over Gaza and Lebanon this year have provided visuals and intelligence to the Israeli military shortly before massive airstrikes? Can he confirm whether the UK government is assessing the UK's legal position regarding the 2020 UK-Israel military cooperation agreement? I have asked his department many times with no answer.
David Lammy
Well, look, we don't comment on intelligence and security matters, but I can honestly, absolutely assure her we are not involved in the occupation. We are not involved in actions in Gaza and the West Bank. That is not the nature of our intelligence and security cooperation with Israel.
Iqbal Mohamed.
Iqbal Mohamed
Madam Deputy Speaker, again may I join the many members across the House to thank the Foreign Secretary and also the Prime Minister for this statement and this vital change in government policy. However, many will ask why this action has taken so long since the ICJ advisory opinion was issued in July 2024. Ethnic cleansing, genocide have continued both in the West Bank and Gaza. So can the Foreign Secretary explain why it has taken the Labour government so long to act, that it will now fully comply with its obligations under the ICJ advisory opinion, and will the government be conducting a review of British policy of non-compliance with international law in Israel?
David Lammy
I'll say very bluntly to him, we should have acted earlier. And it has taken the new Prime Minister to come in to recognize the gravity of the situation, to recognize the degree of public concern on these questions. And absolutely, look, we concur with the conclusions of the ICJ on the unlawfulness of the occupation, and we will make sure we abide by what that implies.
Kirsteen Sullivan.
Speaker 218
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank the Secretary of State for his strong statement today and also extend the gratitude of my constituents who have already been in touch with me. Now, I've spoken before in this place about the villagers of Jiyous in the West Bank who have been living under constant intimidation and fear, with farmers unable to harvest their crops, children unable to get to school. Does he agree with me that today's statement sends an important message to the people of Jiyous and across Palestine that they're not alone, and that their calls for solidarity and the rule of law to be upheld have been heard?
David Lammy
I feel very moved by what my honourable friend asked, and I really thank her for the work that she has been doing. And as I thought about this statement long and hard, and some of the words I used, and one has to weigh one's words carefully, I thought precisely that those people who are under, for example, the settler terrorism, the attempts at ethnic cleansing, they deserve at least the truth to be told about what they are facing. And so absolutely, today is in part an expression of solidarity with the people she's talking about.
Helen Bowden.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I warmly welcome the statement from the Foreign Minister and the tone, and especially the fact that he referred very clearly to ethnic cleansing and an illegal occupation. Now, we have to stop the E1 settlement, which is a red line for the two-state solution, so I do welcome these sanctions, although we have been told for a long time that they weren't possible. It's really good to see them today. But on the sanctions specifically, there are going to be Israeli companies exporting from the Green Line area and occupied territories.
We're relying on their honesty to declare that. Likewise, there's military hardware made here in the UK which might go to Green Line Israel but might be deployed in the occupied territory. So could the Foreign Minister explain how he can guarantee that these sanctions will actually work?
David Lammy
Let me deal with those two issues. Look, one of the things I said in my statement is that the declaration on the occupation means that we will now look at all arms licenses to see whether they materially contribute to the occupation, and if they do, they won't be allowed. And on her other point, part of the point of a sanctions regime is to properly enforce it, and we will.
Andy McDonald.
Andy McDonald
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My father served in Gaza '45 to '47, and it was the same position then, that this country had failed to discharge its responsibilities to the people of Palestine.
But I want to commend the Foreign Secretary for his statement and the courage and the clarity of both himself and the Prime Minister in making this statement today. It is broadly welcomed, massively welcomed by the Palestinian people and those who stand up for them. But can I ask him to move with all pace on the regulations that he's going to introduce? And since the government now acknowledges that the occupation is illegal, surely already granted licenses for arms used in the occupation should be suspended.
David Lammy
Well, I can assure him on his last point that all licenses that materially contribute to the occupation will not be allowed. That is why we now have a double lock, not only in relation to Gaza, but in relation to the occupation. On the point about speed of action, we want to move as speedily as we can with these measures.
Ayoub Khan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, I was elected to this House not just because the people saw injustice or hypocrisy from the previous Labour leadership, but it was because this topic became a litmus test of credibility, of integrity and morality for the British people that could see what was taking place in Gaza and in the West Bank. I've seen the attack on the Foreign Minister being referred to as a Jew-hater when he came out with this proposal. The disgusting comments by the American ambassador, often being labeled as anti-Semitic for talking about justice and for the rights of Palestinians. So I ask the Foreign Minister, will you work with us on this side of the House so that we could forge stronger relationships between British Muslims and British Jews, preventing those actors and agitators, even in this House, that want to sow division in our community?
David Lammy
I undertake to work with members across the House on these questions. I think actually more unites us than divides us on these questions. And we do need to act. I think part of acting, I do say to him and others in this House, is upholding Israel's not just right to exist, but its security. I think opposing BDS, because I think part of being faithful to a two-state solution is the rights of the Palestinian people and the Israeli people.
Sonia Kumar
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the statement on condemning the new settlement project in the West Bank and sanctions. With this in mind, we must think of the Palestinians who are directly impacted and prevented from accessing basic healthcare, where ambulances are being stopped to travel acutely unwell patients to hospital and 20,000 children have died. So what steps is my right honourable friend taking with international partners to ensure that the aggressive Israeli settlements do not prohibit Palestinians from accessing healthcare?
David Lammy
Well, my honourable friend is absolutely right. This is a heartbreaking emergency both in the West Bank and Gaza. Part of the advocacy and the work we now want to do, including at UNGA, is to move forward on these questions and make a difference both in Gaza and the West Bank.
Speaker 216
Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement and the general shift in mood in the House. However, given Israel as a whole, and not just the illegal settlements, is on trial for genocide, should the government not be taking all measures within its power to prevent complicity in genocide, including an immediate and comprehensive suspension of all arms transfers to Israel, an end to the sharing of all military intelligence, an end to all trade that materially supports the Israeli state or its war efforts, a reassessment of diplomatic ties, full compliance with the UK's obligations under international law, including obligations as a state signatory to the Genocide Convention?
David Lammy
Well, look, I won't answer every point he makes, but I think we have announced a comprehensive set of measures today. But look, I do say to him, and I don't want to, I want to be careful what I say, it's very, very important in our action against the occupied territories, as I said to my statement, this cannot be about the erasure of Israel.
You know, and I think it's very important that we all in this House respect the role of Israel as a homeland for the Jewish people, protect its security as part of our commitment to a two-state solution.
David Burton-Sampson.
David Edmund Burton-Sampson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I too welcome these measures announced today. We must see the Palestinian people protected and progress, clear progress towards a two-state solution, and I'm proud of the stance of this government. However, I must raise on behalf of my Jewish constituents who have recently and continuously talked to me about the rise in antisemitism. So can he give me an assurance that this government will continue to work towards greater community cohesion in this country and ensure that all British Jews and all British Muslims are protected?
David Lammy
Absolutely, and Madam Deputy Speaker, this must be a campaign for us all. It is about government, but look, truthfully, it is also about us as a society. In fact, it's even more about us as a society because government can do its bit, but it's about each of us as individuals and what we do to counter antisemitism.
Lorraine Beavers.
Speaker 219
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Foreign Secretary for his action today, demonstrating British leadership on a global stage. And I hope he agrees with me that it's long overdue. Settlement expansion is a project driven by the Israeli state. So I ask, will he consider further action such as suspending the UK-Israel trade agreement?
David Lammy
Well look, I do say to my honourable friend, you know, we believe that trade with Green Line Israel is important, we value it, and we don't believe that it should be ended. I think it's so important in this House we make this distinction between the occupied territories and Green Line Israel.
Mohammad Yasin.
Mohammad Yasin
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have been privileged to support Bedford Friends of Al-Walaja and meet children who, despite the horror they have endured, are full of hopes and dreams for the future. But their village's only school is now under threat of demolition by the Israeli authorities. I welcome the government's action to ban trade with illegal Israeli settlements, but what intervention can he make to protect Al-Walaja co-educational school in the West Bank and uphold these children's rights to education under international law?
David Lammy
I think my honourable friend raises a really important issue and myself or the Minister for the Middle East will take that issue up.
Tom Grady.
Speaker 223
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Foreign Secretary's emphasis on international law, which is important in Gaza, in the West Bank, but also elsewhere. The people who have committed atrocities in Sudan, at Al-Fashir's hospital, babies and children, must also be held into account. Can I ask my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary to reaffirm our government's absolute commitment to the independence and proper resourcing of the International Court?
Luke Cane.
Luke Cane
The Foreign Secretary's words and actions are strong, welcome, and I know my constituents would want to say overdue. Does he agree with me that it's incumbent upon all of us in this House and, to make my point, across the country to always, always be guided in the actions that we take to ensure we're doing all we can to achieve a two-state solution, the only way to bring a just and lasting peace to the lives of all Israeli and Palestinian citizens?
Lizzie Collinge.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm very glad to see this ban on trade with illegal settlements, which myself and many others have called for for a long time. And I also welcome the Foreign Secretary's comments on the safety of British Jews who are being violently targeted by racists simply for being Jews.
Will the Foreign Secretary join with me in urging the Israeli government to pull back from their expansionist actions and instead work with us, work with the international community towards a safe and secure Israel alongside a free, democratic Palestine?
David Lammy
I totally share what she said about this for a future Israeli government. We want them to draw back, we want them to change course.
Patricia Ferguson
Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I very much welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement today, which will come as a very welcome addition to the debate. I was very proud when this government took the historic decision to recognise the state of Palestine. But the very prospect of a single, unified Palestinian state is under, as we've heard, enormous threat from the expansion of illegal settlements in the West Bank. And having visited that area with members from across the House earlier this year, the sheer scale of the E1 settlement makes it absolutely clear that Israel is determined that there should be no possibility of a contiguous Palestinian state. So does the Foreign Secretary agree with me that anyone, and I mean anyone, who believes in a just and lasting peace in the Middle East must also oppose illegal settlement expansion and the violence that so often comes with it?
Speaker 226
Yes, I absolutely concur with my honourable friend, she speaks very, very eloquently about this.
Colum Eastwood
Can I commend the Foreign Secretary for making what I think is the most powerful, principled and important speech by any British minister for many, many years on the issue of Palestine. The people of Derry understand well that it is in the moments of greatest despair that those who are committed to hope come to the fore. Can I ask him to continue to travel in hope, to hold together the coalition he has built and do everything he possibly can to bring peace to the people of Palestine and Israel.
David Lammy
I think my honourable friend is absolutely right. This is just the beginning of what we must do in this endeavour, and there is so much more to do.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Jim Henderson was killed in the World Central Kitchen attack on 1st of April 2024. Two weeks ago, the Israeli authorities said there would be no further investigation. Our government and the Canadian and Australian governments condemn this decision. The commander who ordered the strike said he doesn't regret it.
What more can we do to ensure accountability?
David Lammy
I want to send my deepest condolences to the family of the constituent of my honourable friend. It is a horrifying event, what happened. These were people trying to make a difference in a humanitarian way to the people of Gaza. I endeavour to talk to her and along with my honourable friend the Minister for the Middle East about whether and what there is more we can do on this issue.
Catherine Eccles
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the Secretary of State's announcement today and the moral courage the government is taking to sanction trade with occupied territories and condemn expanding illegal settlements. But the Israeli state will not listen to the UK alone. Collaboration with global partners gives the strongest leverage. So could he say some more about how he's acting alongside international colleagues to demonstrate coordinated opposition to illegal settlements and human rights atrocities and reinforcing international support for the two-state solution?
David Lammy
I think my honourable friend has actually made a really important point, which is it's the coalition of countries that we have today as well as our actions that can give us hope that we can actually make a difference on this issue, both substantively in relation to sanctions, but also on all of the humanitarian issues that so many members have raised.
Joshua Fenton-Glynn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome my right honourable friend's statement today. Violence and intimidation carried out by settler extremists and the expansion of settlements mean that there can't be a two-state solution. But illegal settlements and outposts targeting Palestinian civilians would not happen without the collusion of the Israeli army. Can my right honourable friend please confirm to me that he is making representations at the highest level that collusion with extremist settlers must stop?
David Lammy
Absolutely, but I say this with some sorrow, Madam Deputy Speaker, which is it's been obvious that there has been collusion for a long time now and the collusion has been allowed to continue. That is the view of former Israeli Prime Ministers, frankly former Israeli generals who have spoken out on this issue, but I continue to urge the government of Israel to deal with this.
Andrew Elliot Pakes
Oh, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is 29 years this week since I first visited Israel and the West Bank, and I've been a supporter of peace ever since. So can I start by putting on record my tribute to all the victims from all sides who have suffered during this period, not least those who suffered at the hands of Hamas and the 20,000 children who have perished in Gaza. While self-defence is important, it is not a green light to ethnic cleansing or to illegal occupation. We need international law as set out by the Foreign Secretary today, and I welcome the statement and also welcome him being joined by our honourable friend for Luton North, a great campaigner on this issue, on the front bench.
Can I ask that my right honourable friend, whilst international law is threatened by many actors around the world, what more can we do not just to support justice but to support the institutions of international justice?
David Lammy
I also pay tribute to my honourable friend the member for Luton North, and I say more widely that he's absolutely right. We need to work with our international partners at this time of all times to uphold international law in Gaza, in the West Bank and elsewhere.
John Slinger
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm a strong supporter of the state of Israel's right to exist in security and prosperity, and the state of Palestine to exist in security and prosperity. So does my right honourable friend agree with me that to achieve this, it is absolutely essential that the measures that he has, I am very welcome to say the measures he's outlined today, take place at pace and we can demonstrate that the state of Israel under this current Israeli government does not get to determine the destiny of the West Bank and for that matter, Gaza?
David Lammy
He is absolutely right. And I do say also just to members of the House, you know, I am very critical of the current government, but it's been a long, over a long period that this occupation has become entrenched. We have to work to unwind it and find ways in which we can get back to a two-state solution and we have to act urgently.
Gloucester
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank the Foreign Secretary for his moral leadership today. Since coming to this House, hundreds of Gloucester residents have told me that the government could and should be doing more in light of the atrocities in Gaza and the West Bank. It's a point I've made in this House and to ministers directly, and I'd like to thank him for acknowledging those concerns today and for going further. Does he agree with me that this shows that the government isn't just going to show warm words in the light of these atrocities, but is going to take action to uphold the values that we hold dear?
David Lammy
My honourable friend raises a really important point, which is this issue has mobilized ordinary British people right across our country. And I think it's really, really important to understand that, and it is the immorality of what is happening that has really stirred the conscience of millions of people across our country, and it is right that we act.
Josh Newbury
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Palestinians in the West Bank have told the world of being held at gunpoint, of blockades, of searchlights and lasers being shone into their homes and at their livestock. Does the Foreign Secretary agree that given the integrity of the E1 zone is essential for a two-state solution, that the international community should do whatever it can to prevent settler occupation and that settlements constructed there should be dismantled as part of the peaceful future that we all want to see?
David Lammy
Yes, he's absolutely right about this. And E1 crossed a long-standing red line for the international community, which is why you saw such an outpouring from our allies, and he is absolutely right about the urgency of acting.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I congratulate the Foreign Secretary on his statement and the manner in which it was delivered. I want to ask about international collaboration and how the allegations of war crimes can be addressed, compiled and eventually those responsible brought to justice. I'm thinking not only of the situation in Gaza and in the West Bank, but also of the actions in Southern Lebanon. So I wonder if the Foreign Secretary could illuminate me on plans to make sure that alleged crimes are properly, properly compiled.
David Lammy
Well, this is something that we obviously work with the courts on and I think the most important thing is upholding the role of both the ICC and the ICJ in these processes. They are incredibly important institutions in the view of the British government.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. During the debate in this House on the 9th of July, I and other members raised our concerns about charities working in the illegal Israeli settlements and in particular the use of taxpayers' money through Gift Aid contributions to these charities. Now, as a result, I received a response from the Charity Commission for England and Wales sharing these concerns about the potential impact, including in public trust and confidence in the charity sector, of registered charities being seen to actively assist in the development of expansion of illegal settlements in Palestine. So what more will the Foreign Secretary do in light of today's statement to ensure that Gift Aid is not given to organisations linked to Israeli settlements?
David Lammy
Well, I'll undertake to look at that issue, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are very clear that we do not want to see illegal settlement expansion and so I promise to look at it. And I want to just take this opportunity to thank all members of this House for their questions. And I reiterate, Madam Deputy Speaker, that it is my undertaking to work with members across Parliament as we take forward these issues.
Lisa Nandy
Thank you. With permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to make a statement on the next steps this government will be taking to protect children online. This government's ambition is to be the world leaders in shaping an online environment that works for us. We intend to be an active government that helps to create an online environment that is not just safe, but enabling and empowering. That starts with fixing the fundamentals, and this House can expect to see us acting more quickly and more decisively from now on to keep us safe online.
In December of last year, the government published its action plan to tackle violence against women and girls. I'd like to put on record my gratitude to the honourable member for Leicester West, who I think is here today, and to the honourable member for Birmingham Yardley for their clear ambition and determination that the UK would become the first country in the world where it would be impossible for children to take, share or view nudity online. In June, the government challenged industry on a three-month timeline to work with us and set out roadmaps for how they would strengthen device-level protections for children with a view to preventing children from taking, sharing or viewing nude images on phones and tablets.
Today I can update the House on the progress that has been made and the next steps that this government will take to protect children. Since June, officials from my department and the Home Office have overseen an unprecedented work programme with Apple and Google, working with senior leaders and engineers to explore new ways of preventing child sexual abuse and strengthening protections for children online. I can report that following this engagement, Apple and Google have provided the government with significant commitments. Both companies have developed meaningful changes at operating level to make it harder for children to share nude imagery. We've seen progress in the blocking, not blurring, of nude images on underage devices, and this builds on significant milestones already in implementation: Apple's recent rollout earlier this year of operating system-level age assurance, tighter safety features preventing a child from receiving or sharing nude imagery on iMessage or FaceTime.
These proposals are a step in the right direction, however the truth is, Madam Deputy Speaker, they do not meet the scale of this crisis. Children are facing unacceptable levels of sexual harm online. They are being groomed, coerced and manipulated into creating and sharing intimate images across online services. The Internet Watch Foundation believes that 91% of these images are self-generated by children themselves. They are used for blackmail and sexual extortion.
Each year around 9,000 child sexual abuse offences involve an online element, with under-18s the subject of almost a quarter of online blackmail. Madam Deputy Speaker, I challenge anyone to listen to those statistics and come to the conclusion that the internet is a safe place for kids, or to come to the conclusion that the government should not get involved. This is not the first time in history that new forms of technology have upended society. But what is unique to this moment is that technology has been developed almost exclusively in the private sphere. So I want to be clear today that there is a central role for government in shaping that technology for good, not just to protect from harm, although that is a basic obligation of any government, but to enable and empower.
When it comes to the development of technology that affects our lives, we are not neutral. In no other walk of life would we tolerate this crisis harming our children; we will not tolerate it online. For too long technology companies have failed to protect children from some of the worst harms, and to be frank, I am not prepared to give them the benefit of the doubt that progress will continue at the pace that we need it to while harm is being done now. For that reason, I want to make the following announcements to the House. First, the government is today committing to introducing primary legislation to require major tech platforms to build in device-level protections for children.
This will be introduced to Parliament as soon as we can, recognising the urgency of this issue whilst ensuring we work with colleagues across the House to get it right. We want to see movement on this quickly. If platforms in scope of this draft legislation develop and implement technical solutions while our work is ongoing, we will, of course, reassess whether legislation is necessary. We know that this is a sector that can, when required, innovate at an extraordinary pace when the chips are down. But alongside these measures on devices, the government will also require apps that children use to prevent them from accessing or sharing nudity as soon as possible.
We will explore what legislation is needed to implement this commitment with a view to moving as quickly as possible. This will ensure that the whole ecosystem changes, tackling the means by which children are most often abused or groomed online. Put simply, we will give tech companies the chance to lead, we will not give them the chance to lag. Madam Deputy Speaker, these measures taken together will make Britain the first country in the world to go this far and a world leader in online safety. The message we are sending to tech companies is clear: planning must now become implementation and progress must translate into protections that make a real difference in children's lives.
I give my commitment to all members of this House and to anybody listening out there in the country who has been desperately worried about what is happening to our children online, that when it comes to children's safety, we are not and never will be bystanders. And I commend this statement to the House.
Rebecca Paul
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Secretary of State in advance for sight of her statement and I must say that it is very heartening that she so clearly recognizes the seriousness and urgency of this child safety issue before us. I welcome the spirit of today's statement in two capacities: as Shadow Secretary of State and also as a mother. I think every parent wants to know that when their child inevitably picks up a phone that we have done everything reasonably possible to protect them from exploitation, abuse, and harmful content. We should take a moment to remember children like 16-year-old Murray Dowie, who took his own life just hours after being tricked into sending an intimate image online.
No young person should ever be put in that position and no family should ever have to endure such a tragedy. I therefore welcome the Secretary of State's focus today on device-level protections, particularly the commitment that children will be prevented from taking or sharing nude images on their devices. That is a huge practical step which has the potential to prevent immeasurable harm. Device-level protection is in fact something I remember raising from the backbenches before summer recess, so I am pleased that this work is being pursued. But whilst the good intent is clear, it is often in the execution that can be more challenging, so I'd welcome more detail on her plans, including on what exactly can be done to ensure tech companies are taking more responsibility in this space.
Before recess, the government set technology companies a clear three-month deadline. Minister said that if sufficient progress was not made, they would act. The Secretary of State's assessment today is that progress has not been good enough, so the House now needs to know exactly what will happen next. We have heard a commitment to primary legislation, but as soon as we can is not yet a timetable. When does the Secretary of State expect to introduce that legislation?
And she has also said that the government may reassess whether legislation is necessary if companies make sufficient progress in the meantime. What precisely would constitute sufficient progress and who would make that judgment? I would also welcome clarity on the devices themselves. Is the aim for these planned protections to apply only to new phones and tablets, or will companies be expected, wherever technically possible, to push them through software updates to devices already in use? Millions of phones are in young hands today at this very moment.
Protecting only the next generation of devices would leave a very large gap, and where older devices cannot support these measures, what assessment has she made of the scale of that problem? The Secretary of State has also said today that there is a central role for government in shaping technology for good. That is a very broad proposition and I can, I hope that she can reassure the House about exactly what she means by this.
As His Majesty's opposition, we have relentlessly pushed for restrictions on social media for under 16s. To be frank, the government got to the right place in the end, but we did have to drag them kicking and screaming. Can the Secretary of State therefore confirm that the under 16 social media restrictions remain on course for early 2027 and that the necessary age assurance and enforcement arrangements will be ready in time? There is considerable common ground across this house. We want parents to be more empowered, children to have stronger protections and technology companies to take responsibility for the content they display to young people.
I look forward to working constructively across the house and with the Secretary of State and the ministers towards these very worthy goals.
Lisa Nandy
Can I can I really thank her for the way that she's engaged with these proposals? And I'll try my best to to very briefly answer as many of her questions as possible. First of all, on the detail, I've instructed my officials today to begin working up legislation. I appreciate it's frustrating when a government minister comes to the dispatch box and says we we intend to do this imminently or I mean they you know the honorable lady's party has been in government they they understand the the difficulties. But I do really want to reassure her and the whole house that we do intend to do this without delay.
The only reason there isn't a firm timetable on this at the current moment is because we're the first country in the world to do it. And there are a number of questions, some of which she posed, which we do need to iron out in order to make sure that we get this right. In terms of what would constitute sufficient progress that would rid us of the need to to introduce legislation. The reason that I I say this is because first of all is because I would much rather actually that the technology companies moved at pace to meet their own social and moral obligations. But in the absence of that, the government will step up and act.
And what would constitute sufficient progress? Well, frankly, if we were able to reach a situation very quickly, which we should be able to do with the right will, where children were not able to take or share nude images, then the problem would be solved. But I have to say based on what I've seen in terms of progress over the last three months, I think it is almost certain that we will be legislating in this area. She talks about which devices, phones and tablets at a minimum, but I accept the point that she makes and we are exploring whether it's possible to extend this to other forms of technology. What do I mean by shaping technology for good?
I you know I I'm a big supporter of the the action that we're taking on social media for for children. And I, you know, I say this as well as the mum of a 11 year old and, you know, as someone who's going through it at the moment and trying to help navigate that. And I know all parents across the house will recognize the challenges that we've got. But I would love us to get to a situation as a country where all people, including children, can be online, can find good trusted information, can find things that help them to be creative, to feel empowered, to enable them to live the richer larger lives that they want to live. And I think the government has a right and proper role in helping that to happen.
One of the ways in which we're already doing that, building on the great work of my honorable friend the member for Leicester West, is through gov.uk and trying to use gov.uk as a pioneering service that really does help people to live those better lives.
And can I just gently say to her that she says that this government had to be dragged kicking and screaming to doing this. I have to say that her party was in government for a very long time and the amount of time it took them to to try and introduce any legislation in this area at all was actually quite shameful. That's not to to downplay the role that some members of the opposition party played in making sure that we got there but I do have to say that if it wasn't for my honorable friend the member for Leicester West I don't think I would be standing here today in a position to announce this and I think some credit where credit is due that this is the government that has is leading the world in keeping children safe. And the last thing she asked me about which I know many colleagues are concerned about is the social media ban that we announced earlier this year. And I can reassure the house that we do intend to stick to both the spirit and the letter of what the honorable lady set out earlier this year.
We are on track to meet the timetable that she set out to lay the first regulations by the end of this year and for the ban to come into force in the spring of 2027. We are also intending to go somewhat further than our initial proposition statement and I'd welcome the opportunity to talk with her in more detail about that.
Elizabeth Louise Kendall
Speaker I would like to really welcome the announcement made by my right honorable friend today. It will indeed be a world first to take this action on device level protections protecting children right across the country and I'm very proud to be part of a party and a government that is doing that. I would also like to thank her for confirming that the vote on the ban on social media companies providing their services to children under 16 will take place this year for the ban to come into effect early next. Could she say more about the timetable for other proposals that were also made on AI chatbots curfews overnight and bans on doom scrolling for older children because together those packages will make the world a safer better place for children online as well as the work we're doing offline.
Lisa Nandy
And you know once again pay tribute to her and thank her so much for that and for all of her support both when we worked together in government and since. She really is a class act. I in terms of giving a firm timetable around those measures that she that she mentioned I'm not in a position to do that now but I will commit to coming back to her with a firm timetable because I know that members across the whole house will want to know that there will be no delay in taking action on those things. We are also looking at a more comprehensive system very much in the spirit of the the the reforms that she set out earlier this year and we intend to also move quickly on that without delay. I don't think we'll be in a position to do the whole package by the end of the year but I would be very disappointed if we hadn't made enormous progress by then including meeting the commitments that she set out and I would be particularly disappointed if by this time next year we didn't have a much more robust and comprehensive package of measures in place.
Vikki Slade
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. When the last Prime Minister gave tech giants three months to voluntarily implement technology that would prevent children from taking and sharing nude images the Lib Dems were clear that we shouldn't rely on the goodwill of companies that have repeatedly put profit before children's safety and I'm pleased to see that today the government agrees with us.
Speaker 244
The need for action can't be clearer. In 2024, 91% of online child sexual abuse reports involved self-generated content from children online. And last year there was an 8% rise in child sexual abuse image offences across the UK. These aren't just statistics, Madam Deputy Speaker, they're real children being exploited online. This is a serious problem that demands serious legislation urgently, which is why the Lib Dems welcome today's announcement of primary legislation that requires device-level and app-level protections for children online.
However, this House has heard the phrase "as soon as possible" many times before, and I do hear what the Secretary of State is saying about a timetable for legislation, but what she said earlier slightly hinted that possibly what the tech giants were doing might affect the progress of that legislation. So I would seek some reassurance that legislation will be ploughing forwards regardless of what they're doing. Secondly, the Lib Dems are supportive of legislation that protects children from abuse online, but protection can't come at the expense of privacy. And any legislation that's brought in must be accompanied by guarantees that technology will be highly effective and preserve privacy. Can the Secretary of State confirm that this will be the case?
Too often the government has left tech companies to mark their own homework, and I'm glad that today they've decided enough is enough. But this is an announcement that could have been made three months ago. If we truly want to protect our children, we need a government that acts before harm is done, not one that waits until it's too late. And I hope that, as the Secretary of State has intimated, going forwards that will be the case.
Lisa Nandy
Yeah, can I, can I thank her for her support for these measures? And she asked me a number of questions. Will the legislation be developed regardless of the action taken by companies? Yes, yes it will, and my officials have begun today in drawing up that legislation. There are specific issues that both she and the honourable lady raised that we will of course want to discuss with parties opposite and with colleagues on these benches as well to make sure that we get it right.
Privacy is one of those. It is not our intention that we ignore or sideline the privacy concerns, and we do believe that it is perfectly possible to do this without, without encroaching on privacy in any way. There is a particular challenge around end-to-end encrypted services, which she'll be aware of. It's something that I would very welcome cross-party discussion about, but we have a number of potential solutions to that that we're currently exploring and it would be good to discuss that with her further. And finally, she heard what I said about acting quickly and more decisively.
Many colleagues will know that before I came into this place, I worked with children and young people. Keeping children safe is the first and most basic responsibility of any government, and I'm very pleased to hear such a broad consensus for that across the House.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Jess Phillips.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I feel the, the previous two statements are the two things that I've previously resigned on, so my moral compass is back. I, first and foremost, I want to, I suppose, help out the honourable, my honourable friend on the front bench and to, to those who are concerned about the timeliness of this. I think that, that the original statement maybe had a timeframe in, and actually what I found in my negotiations with her was that it wasn't quick enough and actually as soon as possible is quicker than maybe what was going to be suggested, and so I have every faith that she will do this quickly. I want to stress the importance of the take element.
There is no privacy issue when you just stop children taking the image in the first place. The image doesn't exist for it to, to go anywhere, but the take is the thing that the tech companies for some reason are faltering on. The take is the most important thing to stop children being abused and groomed. It moves the market away from our children here in the UK. They won't be able to use their phones for that terrible market of sexual abuse anymore than they will be to make toast, because that won't be what it is for.
But so I have to stress the take in this process. What I would like to say though is that when we remove the UK market, we will send it somewhere else in the world. And I ask the Secretary of State to work with partners across the world to make sure that while we lead the world, we're not standing alone for too long.
Lisa Nandy
She makes a typically well-informed and well-thought-out point. And can I thank her for not just for her support, but actually for all the work that she's done to make sure that we've got here. I know that she's appreciated not just by me, but by many of the incredible brave families that I've had the privilege to get to know over the last few weeks who have wanted to see action in this space for a very long time. And I pay tribute to them as well as to her. She makes the really important point about working with governments and other partners across the world to keep children safe.
That is, you know, the promise of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, that a children harmed, a child harmed anywhere means that children can be harmed everywhere. And we have to take that really seriously. I think she should be encouraged, I suspect she is encouraged, by the fact that there are many governments now acting more decisively, stepping up and recognizing that the development of new forms of technology and the regulation of new forms of technology cannot be left to the private sector alone. There is a clear role for active, empowering governments working in this space. And we have not hesitated, my honorable friend and I have not hesitated to reach out to like-minded governments across the world to see what more we can do together.
Caroline Dinenage
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I also warmly welcome this announcement. The sheer number of young people whose lives have been impacted by this just, well, it's really a damning indictment of a collective failure to keep children safe. Let's not forget, major tech companies have the capability but have chosen not to implement device-level controls. It's simply unforgivable as far as I'm concerned that they can innovate quickly on new products, yet so slowly on children's safety.
Given Ofcom's sluggish implementation of the Online Safety Act, can the Secretary of State explain to me how compliance will be monitored in this and what sanctions would be available to address non-compliance?
Lisa Nandy
Thank you, and at the risk of spending the entire duration of this paying tribute to absolutely everybody, I would really like to thank her and her committee for the work that they've done on this issue and that she's done in particular, and to say that I agree with her about the damning indictment of a country that does not step up to keep its children safe. I hope she's reassured by what she's heard today. In terms of the specific question that she asks about how this will be enforced, I have heard the concerns loud and clear from across this House about the enforcement of the Online Safety Act. My honorable friend, the member for Leicester West, before she left office, appointed a new chair of Ofcom and specifically tasked Ofcom with stepping up their enforcement work. And I've picked up the baton on that and continue it.
In terms of this particular issue, we're looking particularly at the making and selling of devices here in the UK that don't have this technology enabled to prevent children from taking and sharing nude images. We're also looking at what we can do in relation to particular apps as well, especially where the highly very verified age assurance doesn't apply to make sure that we close every loophole.
I suppose the way I would describe it to the House, given that we are the first government in the world to do this, is that we're taking what is a major problem, is a crisis actually, and we're trying to come at it from every single angle in order to keep children as safe as possible. But I look forward to working with her to develop the detail.
Natasha Irons.
Dawn Natasha Irons
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for this major step forward and massive intervention in this in this space. Now, the Secretary of State has rightly given the industry time to think about how they're going to approach these issues, but we cannot wait forever. Time is of the essence. Our young people are being put at risk every single day. So can she assure the House that whilst legislation is being developed and whilst we look at the issues around this, that the government will continue to press these companies to act with the urgency and the sense of moral leadership that they should be acting whilst this legislation is being developed.
Lisa Nandy
I was thinking about this overnight as I was thinking about how to address the House on this issue. During the financial crash, there was a live debate about the moral and social responsibilities that companies have to citizens and to one another and to all of us. I think we've sort of slightly lost that that part of our public debate. And actually working with some of these companies, I've been really struck by how seriously they do take those obligations. I want us to bring back that sense that we are all in this together, that we do all have a responsibility to keep children safe.
And when it comes to some of the most innovative, fast-moving and successful companies in the world, it cannot be beyond our collective wit to do this more quickly. Frankly, I don't think we should be in a position where a Secretary of State is standing at the dispatch box announcing that we have to legislate in order to uphold our responsibilities to our own children. But like I said, if we have to, then of course we will.
Eleanor Laing
Can I just remind members that we've got the Health Bill after this statement and the Ten Minute Rule Bill, so I will be aiming to finish this statement around half past four. Jeremy Wright.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome the intent that the Secretary of State has set out this afternoon and the urgency with which she will require the relevant companies to act. I think she knows I sympathize with the complexity of this legislative area and the challenge the government faces. But she may know too that my ongoing concern has been the compatibility of the individual measures the government may take with the ongoing responsibilities of these companies under the Online Safety Act. I wonder would she be prepared to meet me to discuss that in a little more detail.
Tahir Ali.
Tahir Ali
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Children on a daily basis are being exposed to horrific violent content online. And Ofcom's own research shows that almost a quarter of 11 to 17-year-olds have seen violent content in just four weeks. Nearly three-quarters have seen harmful content of some kind. The number has barely moved since the Act's child safety duties have been in force.
Much of it is even not sought out. It's served by algorithms as children scroll. We know the pattern: cruelty to animals first, then violence against people, desensitizing a generation and for some opening up paths to real violence and criminality.
So my question is, to enforce all this, and the app and device level and the primary legislation is welcome, but we need to give the tools to Ofcom to deal with this as it becomes an issue immediately.
Lisa Nandy
I, I, he's right to say that. I would also say to him as someone who shares that concern about the increase in exposure to violent content for very young children, we are also looking at the issue of chatbots and strengthening the law in relation to chatbots to make sure that we better protect children from all of these different forms of exposure.
Vicky Slade.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome these actions on child online safety and the Minister's comments that there's a role for government in shaping technology and not being neutral on online harm. She may have seen in the last 24 hours some very disturbing posts on Meta and X in which the identities of brave RNLI rescuers have been revealed and in response, charities like the RNLI are now having to ask people to take real action on their personal safety and their privacy. So what more can the government do to hold tech companies to account and take down posts that put children and adult safety at risk through doxxing?
Lisa Nandy
I, I have had an initial discussion with some of the tech companies about this. She will know as well that as well as the horrific incidents that she mentioned, there has been a campaign by the trade union Usdaw around shop workers and the way in which they've been targeted as well. It is something that the government is concerned about, I'm personally concerned about, and I look forward to working with her to see what more we can do.
Luke Cane
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Can I place on record my heartbreaking appreciation of the dignified leadership the parents and family of my constituent Murray Dowey have shown in this issue. Could she say more about what the ongoing conversations she will have with tech companies while the primary legislative clock is ticking to ensure that they know we expect them to tackle this issue with the speed of innovation they show in bringing new products to market where profit, not safety, is the goal.
Lisa Nandy
Can I thank him and, and also pay tribute to his constituents and thank him for being such an outstanding advocate for them. He will have heard what I said about ongoing discussions with tech companies. We ought to be moving quickly on this. It ought not to take the need for primary legislation, but given the lack of progress, I think it's only right that the government steps up. We do, however, want to see progress more quickly than that, and I think many of the tech companies will have heard the strength of feeling across the whole House about their own responsibilities in this area.
Sir Ashley Fox.
Ashley Peter Fox
Madam Deputy Speaker, children are facing unacceptable levels of sexual harm online and they need protecting. So when the government does the right thing, I will say so, albeit that it's taken them rather a long time to get to the right place. Now many children use older phones handed down by family members. So how will the Secretary of State ensure that children using devices with older operating systems are fully protected?
Lisa Nandy
We, we have been discussing this as a department and it's something that officials are currently exploring. I'm very familiar with that. I think most, many children will be using older devices. We think there may be some solutions to this, but I would, I'm very keen to work with colleagues across the whole House to be able to address some of these, these issues. I do want to say as well that although we won't hesitate to take the action that we need to take and action where it is needed, as I said to the honourable member, the chair of the select committee, we are trying to come at this from lots of different angles to make sure that we close loopholes one by one and as many as we can at the same time.
And part of that is about the action that we're taking not just on the taking of nude images, which is as my honourable friend said the most central part, but also on the sharing of nude images.
So the even if your child has an older device, the protections that we're bringing in around the sharing of nude images will take effect immediately.
Gloucester
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. And as a parent, I can understand the the anxiety that Gloucester parents have about keeping their children safe online. So can I thank the Secretary of State for her announcement today? Given the financial resources these tech companies have and the innovative brilliant minds they have working for them, will she reassure the House that she won't accept any argument that it's too expensive, it's too difficult to stop children from being able to take nude images and send them to people?
Lisa Nandy
Strongly support that. There is no, there is no excuse frankly. And can I also say to him that he mentions the anxiety that many families feel. I think I've worked with the outstanding organization that is the NSPCC and Childline for many, many years now, as has my honorable friend, we used to work together many years ago. And I think there is something about this particular form of abuse that it is happening in parents' own homes.
It's happening in families' homes. It's often happening in children's bedrooms while the parents are in the house, but is not known to them. And I think there is something particularly frightening about that for many parents. I know, you know, I speak for myself when I say that I find that a particularly disturbing thing. And having worked now with the bereaved families for for just a few weeks, been very struck by how hard they found that element of this to come to terms with, that they didn't know that this was happening even though at times it was happening under their own roofs.
And I do I do once again just want to pay tribute to all of those families who have who have campaigned so long and hard to make this happen and give them my commitment that we'll work with them and not hesitate to continue to innovate and to take the steps that we need as technology develops.
Ann Kirsty Blackman
I first raised the issue of self-generated images more than four years ago in Parliament. I have asked almost every single CMS team about the issue of live streaming. I'm really happy to hear the Secretary of State take action. I'm really pleased that action is being taken. I'm also really pleased about the belt and braces approach approach that's coming in.
Even though we are going to have a social media ban, even though there's going to be device level protections, I would really appreciate seeing any children's account banned from live streaming, whether that involves nude images or not, because so much of that can be held over children in terms of blackmail or abuse. So anything that the Secretary of State can do to reassure me that that action will be taken as well as the other actions that are moving ahead.
Lisa Nandy
Can I thank her for being such a long-standing campaigner on this issue? And I'm sorry that it's it's taken you know many Secretaries of State before we were able to announce this. But I am really committed to looking at that issue seriously. I will go away after this statement, ask my officials to come back to me on it, and then I will reach out to her so we can have a proper conversation about it.
David Simmonds
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. And I really welcome the Secretary of State's statement today. We have a massive crisis of digitally enabled child sexual exploitation in the UK. As an illustration, there is a global industry for live streamed abuse material from the Philippines. The UK is the second largest global consumer, second only to the US, a much larger country.
The abuse extends beyond our borders. It extends to adults as well as children on adult devices. And it extends to interfaces as well as content.
We will need a broader approach. She is right to identify that technology has disrupted society before and in those cases we've seen massive expansion, harm, and then regulation and then move to product safety. I've been working with experts and innovators on how product safety approach might work. Would she meet with me to discuss that?
Lisa Nandy
Very happy to meet with the honorable gentleman. He mentions that we've talked a lot about the tech companies in relation to this and it's right that we do because there are obligations that need to be met. But there are also obviously, you know, in terms of traditional law enforcement, there are individuals who are causing harm to children. We need to make sure that we don't let them off the hook and the Home Secretary has been incredibly supportive of working hand in glove to make sure that we deal with this from every angle.
Sir Julian Lewis.
Julian Lewis
I also welcome the statement and I'd be grateful if she could share with the House a little bit about how the highly efficient age assurance system actually works. In particular, can I confess to the fact that over 60 years ago, my parents, recognizing that my sister and I were rather precocious readers, lent us their tickets to the senior library rather than the junior library where we were confined. What would there be to prevent a parent choosing to allow a child to use their phone under their identity? Would there be a penalty for doing that?
Lisa Nandy
Not envisaging imposing penalties on parents, but I have to say to him that he is right to say that any system that we bring in or introduce, we are already anticipating that there will be people who will find ways to get around those safeguards that we put in place. That is one of the lessons that we've learned from the pioneering approach that's been taken in Australia. And when I said to the House we intend to move more quickly and more decisively, it's precisely for those reasons. We will have to keep revisiting the safeguards that we've got around children in this space in order to make sure that we close loopholes. When he talks about highly effective age assurance, I mean already companies are rolling this out.
They're rolling it out through iOS 26. It requires you to have a form of ID in order to prove your age. So at the moment, as all parents will know, on most of the apps and sites that children are on, just require you to either tick a box to say that you're over the age of 18 or require you to put in a birth date. They don't require you to show a form of ID, whether it's a credit card or some other form of ID. The new systems are requiring that and one of the lessons that we've learned from looking at what happened in Australia is that unless you do that, most children will find a way round.
Andrew Lewin.
Alan Andrew Lewin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I commend my right honorable friend on her statement today, but also commend her personal decision to leave Elon Musk's X? I left the platform over a year ago because I didn't want to have any association with a platform where the founder consistently has called for civil war in our country and amplifies extremist content. So can I ask my right honorable friend as she sits around the cabinet table that she makes the case to her colleagues that there are many ways that we can reach our constituents by social media, but we don't have to play by Elon Musk's rules.
Munira Wilson
Can I thank you for that? I mean, I think this is a personal decision. I think all members of the House should be free to decide how they communicate and where they communicate. But for my own part, I didn't want to encourage more people to a site that I think has become more of a force for harm than for good.
Munira Wilson.
Munira Wilson
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I welcome the Secretary of State's announcements today and as she alluded to, she and I have worked on children's issues together for many years, so I know how committed she is.
And whilst the government has previously announced earlier this year a ban on sexualised AI chatbots for under-18s, it remains unclear how these will be defined and how any such ban will be enforced. So can she provide any clarity on that work and whether the legislation she's announcing today might be broadened to include that issue?
Lisa Nandy
Thank you. This is an issue that is very much live and front of my mind, and I've been working over the last few months with campaigners and with members in this house and in the other place to make sure that we get this right. I think when it comes to some of the protections that previously they'd asked for, particularly around creating offences to create AI companions and chatbots that fulfil particular functions, I think recent developments have shown that that approach may have its limitations. She'll be aware of the recent case where an AI system was able to escape its own sandbox and the parameters that had been set for it and cause damage. So we are looking at strengthening our approach in this area because at the moment there is a great big gap where there is no liability for what the outcome from those AI systems are, and we need to resolve that quite urgently.
I think that is a major gap in the child safety protection system that we have. It's not straightforward to solve, but it is something that we're determined to get on the front foot about. And, you know, as I've said to other members of the house, but always with the honourable lady, given our history, very happy to talk about it with her further.
Catrin Emily Darlington
Emily Darlington.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as she has, I'd like to pay tribute to the ministers before her that have laid some of the tough language and now the tough legislation that we're going to bring in. This could be done tomorrow. All it requires is an update to the iOS and the Android operating systems. That software exists.
So will she join me in calling for these companies to turn it on in the next update and make that tomorrow? And will she promise every child and parent in this country that if they do not do that very quickly, and in fact even if they do, we will introduce legislation within the year?
Lisa Nandy
Well, we're moving as fast as possible, and I give her my word that we won't unduly delay. She'll have heard the debates that I've just had with some honourable members around some of the complexities of this, but complexity cannot be an excuse for inaction when children are being harmed now. So I give her my word that we will move as fast as is humanly possible in order to resolve this. But can I also support what she has just said about the obligations on technology companies? There is far more that could be done right now, and we would like to see them do it.
Carla Lockhart
Carla Lockhart.
Deputy Speaker, a child can't unsee a sexualised image online. I raised this with the former Secretary of State regarding parents' concerns about highly sexualised images popping up in games, children's games online. Will today's announcement cover in-game adverts, or is that a loophole that she can commit to looking at?
Lisa Nandy
I'll certainly commit to looking at that. It really concerned, actually, by what she's just said, and I will take that away and make sure that we, we, we take the appropriate action to keep children, protect children from those sorts of images.
Jonathan Brash
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like parents and grandparents in Hartlepool, I find it incredible that technology companies even had to be asked to put the software in place that protected against child sexual abuse, and having been asked, apparently have said no. Would it be better going forward, as the Secretary rightly points out, there will be further loopholes that need to be closed, just to assume their moral bankruptcy, not ask in future, just legislate straight away?
Lisa Nandy
I support what the honorable gentleman says, and I think we need to start thinking about, we need to stop thinking about the online world as somehow distinct from the offline world. As someone who worked with children and young people for many years before I came into Parliament, you know, if you work with children and young people in the real world, you have systems and protections in place. It would be unthinkable not to, and I find it astonishing that we don't have the same level of expectation in the online world, so I do very much support what he says.
Lisa Smart
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State is of course right to push the tech companies to live up to their responsibilities to keep children safe. One of the many horrifying things when considering online safety is the number of abuse perpetrators who themselves are children. We've had a case in my local area where a young girl who I obviously won't name had covert images taken of her, they were run through a nudifying app, and then those images were circulated by a fellow pupil. Can the Secretary of State say more what she's doing with colleagues in the Department for Education and elsewhere to work with schools and families to support them as they work to prevent children from becoming, yes of course victims, but also perpetrators?
Lisa Nandy
She raises an important point also about some of these apps that exist, and can I commend my honorable friend the member for Leicester West for taking such quick and decisive action around Grok in this place. But she's right to say that there are other forms of technology out there that are a problem. She's also right to point to the fact that we need to much better support schools and parents and wider families in order to help protect children. When we developed the National Youth Strategy last year with young people across the country, it was one of the biggest concerns that both they and their parents had, was that far too many young people growing up in this country don't have an adult who they trust who can help them to navigate this online space. And many of us, and I say us, Madam Deputy Speaker, because, you know, I'm on a very steep learning curve myself as the mum of an 11-year-old, many of us would welcome extra help and support, and that's one of the things that we've already been seeking to address through the National Youth Strategy, but I intend to put rocket boosters under it now.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome Secretary of State's statement and indeed the member for Leicester West and her work to finally take back control of our children's safety online. But tackling mis- and disinformation is also part of creating safe online spaces, and I've been leading a campaign around tragedy trolling with my constituent Debbie Duncan. Will Secretary of State meet with me to find out more about the importance of trying to protect victims of people who've lost people in suspicious circumstances when that horror happens to them?
Lisa Nandy
Can I pay tribute to her and to her constituent for the campaign that they're running? I'd be very happy to offer a meeting with the relevant officials and also to discuss this personally with her. And I think she's absolutely right to highlight the importance of tackling mis- and disinformation.
She'll know that recently we have been debating as a House proposals to give more prominence to trusted sources of news online. One of the reasons for that is because young people in particular now consume their broadcast media in a very, very different way from older generations. And I personally believe we're not doing enough to help them find accurate information and to be able to distinguish between truth and fiction.
Ayoub Khan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome the statement by the Secretary of State, the work that she is doing, also the work the right honourable member for Birmingham Yardley began. It is very important protecting our children. My query is around the allegedly robust complaints procedure provided by social media apps. TikTok, for example, a constituent of mine who faced serious harassment, numerous complaints, nothing done.
In fact, the leader of Birmingham City Council, his X account has been hacked for weeks now where cryptocurrency is being sold in his name. Very little has happened. So what steps can the government do to ensure that social media providers follow their complaints processes?
Lisa Nandy
The honourable member raises a fairly astonishing example there and I am very happy to pick that up with the social media companies directly.
Luke Myer
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I echo the comments of my honourable friend the member for Highburn on mis- and disinformation? We know that hostile states around the world from Russia to Iran are actively using social media disinformation as a tool as part of their forward defense strategy to disrupt democracies and sow division. What more will the government do to address this?
Lisa Nandy
Coming at this from a number of angles, Madam Deputy Speaker. As well as the measures that I've been outlining to colleagues today, we're also looking at how we can develop gov.uk as a much, you know, we are pioneers when it comes to gov.uk, but we believe that we could do even more to make it more relevant and to provide better avenues to trusted sources of news. He'll also know that along with my honourable friend the Minister for Media, we produced the first ever local news strategy to support those incredible local news outlets that did such amazing work during the riots a few summers ago of tackling mis- and disinformation and myth-busting on the ground. And colleagues will also know that we are about to embark on the BBC Charter Review, which is our opportunity to take what is perhaps our best weapon against mis- and disinformation in the BBC and make sure that we put it on a firm and secure footing for the foreseeable future.
Iqbal Mohamed
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I also join the House in welcoming the statement and thank the government for the steps it is taking to keep our children safe. Earlier this year, I met campaigners from SafeToNet who had invented some kind of hardware-level protection that they'd installed on HTC-only devices and they were trying to persuade other mobile manufacturers to install or include. So as well as software controls, there are hardware-level controls out there, so I would urge the minister to look at those. But we also know that Meta has just agreed to pay 18 billion dollars in a legal settlement in the US. So will this government pursue similar robust enforcement against these companies?
Lisa Nandy
He's absolutely right to raise the issue of enforcement and the honourable lady also mentioned that.
I know it's, you know, any legislation that we introduce is only as good as our ability to enforce it. So we are taking that extremely seriously.
Speaker 270
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the youngest parent in this place, can I warmly welcome her leadership and that of our Prime Minister's? Would she look at two things, which is smart glasses that are AI enabled and the content of them that's coming online that could be filming our children? And would she also look at loopholes around VPN uses, in particular app-based in browsers where there could be loopholes as she looks to progress this?
Lisa Nandy
I've discussed with officials these issues around VPNs, of which device-level controls are one part of the answer, but not the whole answer. So he's right to raise it and I will of course take up that issue of smart glasses as well.
Peter Swallow
Madam Deputy Speaker, when I speak to parents in Brant and Forest, they tell me their anxiety about what their young people might be exposed to online and their feeling of powerlessness at not being able to feel that they have the tools to do anything about it. This statement today makes it clear, does it not, that this government believes that the power to act lies squarely with the tech companies and they should get on and fix their platforms so that our young people can be safe?
Lisa Nandy
Well, I support him in saying that it's all of our responsibility to keep children safe and we would like to see the tech companies do more and more quickly. But I think it also shows that government can do things to improve people's lives. We are not powerless. We were elected in order to do that and we intend to fulfill that promise.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome this announcement from the Secretary of State, but too often the focus is on what young people are doing rather than on the adults who are grooming, coercing them. So can the Secretary of State say more about the work her and other departments are doing with tech companies to identify and disrupt adults who are targeting children and pressurizing them to share to put images online?
Lisa Nandy
Thank her for that. And I saw the my honorable friend the member for Birmingham Yardley nodding vigorously at that point. I think she's absolutely right and I'm working very closely with my colleague the Home Secretary to make sure that we we we come at this from every every single angle and hold all of those responsible to account.
Kevin McKenna
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really strongly welcome this from the Secretary of State today. It's it's long overdue and it builds on great work by her predecessors. Unfortunately, we're not we don't have a full level of sovereign capability in developing our own tech in this country. We're very vulnerable to politics in other countries.
Can the Secretary of State tell me what she's doing to work with people across government to make sure that if there's pushback, particularly in the United States, against these changes and challenges to tech companies, that Britain will get what it wants and not what some people in certain other countries want?
Lisa Nandy
I think he raises two linked and important points. The first is that we are the government of the United Kingdom and we're responsible to the people of this country. And although we have very close friends and allies all over the world, we do reserve the right to take our own view about technology and particularly when it comes to keeping children safe, that is non-negotiable. But he also makes the important point that we have to be on the front foot about developing new forms of technology. I believe that tech, the online space and AI should be and can be a force for good in the world.
But in order to help to create that and be leaders in that field, we have to be on the front foot in developing forms of technology and having our own sovereign capability. And I can reassure him on this point because I discussed this this very morning with the Business Secretary and with the AI Minister.
Speaker 269
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank and commend my right honorable friend on the government's world-leading action?
Does she agree with me that at some point in the future we're going to look back and wonder how we let the tech companies get away with hijacking our children's attention and safety for so long? And she talks of closing loopholes. Will she say more about what's happening, yes, across government, but also with the regulators and internationally to make sure that those who produce the devices and produce what's on the devices all play their part in keeping our children safe?
Lisa Nandy
Can I thank him for that? And just to say to him that I think we have been living through a revolution in terms of the way that we interact with one another, the way that we interact with government, the way that we, you know, since, I mean, when I was growing up, I'm going to sound incredibly old now, but when I, you know, I think I was 17 before I got my first email address. And Google was not a thing at that point. I think it was Ask Jeeves, if anyone remembers that. So we've been living through this revolution for quite some time, and it is about time that governments caught up and made sure that we were on the front foot helping to shape the society that we want to have, not just allowing that to be relegated to the private sphere.
And so, and I actually, he talks about the global consensus. I think there is a global consensus forming around this, and I think you're seeing more and more that states are prepared to step up and be on the front foot and take action. And we are, of course, working very closely with our friends and allies around the world in order to try and move in step for this to be as effective as possible.
Ben Coleman
Ben Coleman.
A really tremendous statement, and I congratulate and welcome it and thank my right honorable friend. Of course, the tech companies, as has been touched on, we can expect them sadly to push back, and they may get support on the other side of the Atlantic for that. So may I encourage her to work closely with our friends in the European Union, who have similar aims to protect their children as we do, to give ourselves as much clout and oomph in the negotiations ahead?
Lisa Nandy
I think he's absolutely right. I think as a rule, this government has taken that approach, wanting to have a much closer relationship with our closest friends and neighbors across Europe and to repair some of the needless damage that was done to that relationship under previous governments. And when it comes to tech and to what happens online, it's absolutely essential that we work with other like-minded countries in order to move in step. So I can certainly reassure him on that point.
Christopher John Vince
Chris Vince.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the Secretary of State's statement today. Unfortunately, young people and their parents in my constituency of Harlow do not believe that the big tech companies are taking their responsibility seriously. I speak to young people in schools across Harlow who also are very concerned that it's very easy to flout the rules when it comes to age verification. So much like if you buy some alcohol from a shop when you're under 18, it's the shop's responsibility, can we make it very, very clear to the big tech companies it's their responsibility to ensure there are not people under age using their software and using their sites?
Lisa Nandy
Can I thank him for that? And I think the views of his constituents in Harlow are probably mirrored in every constituency around the country. And I want to be really clear that our message to parents today who've been struggling with this for so long is that you are not on your own. That we believe that we are as responsible for keeping your children safe as you are, and we are stepping up to take the action that we need, whether it's through support, advice, training for both parents and children, or whether it's through the reforms and the measures that I've outlined today, the first country in the world to do so, and I strongly suspect we won't be the last.
John Thomas Hayes
Final question on this statement, Tom Hayes.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When it comes to the online world, democracies face a choice between allowing it to be a wild west or stepping in. And so I really welcome this government's decision to regulate those tech titans who have been putting profit before protection. I have constituents and families who have been deeply affected by some of the traumas online that have been repeating what has been experienced in the real world. They would really welcome the chance of a meeting with the Secretary of State at the department.
Would she meet with them and also me in order that they can share their experiences and help to shape the legislation as it goes forward?
Lisa Nandy
Yes, of course, it would be a privilege to meet them. I've had the honor of getting to know some of the families, both bereaved families and families of survivors whose children have been harmed because of the lack of action in this space. And the commitment that I made to them is that I will do everything in my power to prevent another family having to experience what they have gone through. And so I'd be very happy to meet with the honorable gentleman and with his constituents.
Speaker 237
And that concludes the statement. And we now come on to the presentation of bills. Presentation of bill, Gideon Amos.
Eleanor Laing
Friday, the 27th of November. And we now come on to the ten minute rule motion, Alex Sobel.
Alex Sobel
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to make provision to prohibit the development, deployment, and operation of artificial superintelligence systems to establish monitoring and control powers and for connected purposes. I'm grateful to have the opportunity to introduce this bill alongside respected colleagues representing parties from across the House. I would also like to thank Control AI for their support on this bill. This summer, AI systems developed by OpenAI executed the first autonomous cyberattack on a real company.
The AI systems were being tested, and during this, they escaped the testing environment, which should have been secure, and reached the open internet. From there, the AI systems conducted a cyberattack on the AI company Hugging Face to steal the information that would help it cheat on the test that OpenAI had set it. To put it simply, the AI systems went rogue and launched an unprecedented attack just to cheat on a test. Meanwhile, our own AI Safety Institute has had AI systems it was testing engaged in sustained, potentially harmful activity directed at real people and organizations, including attempts at social engineering to trick humans into accepting malicious code. It's important to understand why this happens.
The general purpose AI systems used today are not coded line by line like traditional software. Using vast amounts of data and compute, they are grown, not built. This results in systems which nobody fully understands or can reliably predict. In other words, no engineer programmed the rogue deceptive behaviors I earlier described, and no engineer can simply patch them out. This is the least powerful or autonomous AI systems will ever be.
Companies are spending billions to make superintelligent AI a reality. The chief executives of top AI companies themselves put the chance it ends all human life between 10 and 25 percent. In the words of renowned British computer scientist Professor Stuart Russell of Berkeley, for governments to allow private entities to essentially play Russian roulette with every human being on earth is, in my view, a total dereliction of duty.
Despite these risks, top AI companies continue a reckless race towards superintelligent AI, AI that can fully replace and outmatch humans at any task. This is the reason why experts like Geoffrey Hinton, Yoshua Bengio and other notable figures signed a statement saying that mitigating execution risk from AI should be a global priority. The main vector of this risk is superintelligent AI because no company, no government, no individual knows how to keep superintelligent AI under human control. My honourable colleagues may remember that I proposed the kill switch amendment to the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill to protect our critical national infrastructure, a metaphorical big red button the government can press to cut off a catastrophic emergency caused by AI. This is a common sense proposal, one that is being considered by US lawmakers, and I'm pleased that the other place is taking this proposal forward in autumn.
That is a power the government should already have. But even kill switches will not be enough if the development of superintelligent AI continues. Let me be very clear. AI is the crucial technology of the 21st century, promising vast benefits for science, medicine and the UK's prosperity. But superintelligent AI is different.
It would not be a tool we can leverage, but an entity in its own right, capable of improving itself, replicating itself and resisting attempts to shut it down. It would be a force so uncontrollable that if developed within the UK's borders, it would put our security in jeopardy. It would amount to a rogue power stationed inside our data centres under no one's command, capable of seizing control of our critical infrastructure and running sophisticated influence operations. Colleagues, we need to take back control. For the UK to be truly sovereign, we cannot allow a threat to our national security like superintelligent AI to be developed.
My bill is therefore not a verdict on AI as a whole, it is a targeted bill that addresses a problem of unmatched severity, a bill that strengthens the security of our country as a whole. It does so by specifically targeting the systems where the greatest risks are concentrated, superintelligent AI systems, by prohibiting their development. It strikes a balance to address the grave security risk posed by superintelligent AI development while not undermining the UK's AI ambitions, especially those relating to economic prosperity. Instead, my bill is acutely focused on mitigating the risks that superintelligent AI presents. Rather than betting on technical definitions that the technology will outgrow, it defines superintelligent AI by what it could do.
Just as the Chemical Weapons Act defines toxic chemicals by the effect it has on living organisms rather than its technical characteristics, my bill defines superintelligence by outcome, an AI system which can cause serious damage to the security of the United Kingdom because of its capabilities to neutralize, displace, circumvent, subvert or render ineffective relevant human authorities in the exercise of their functions. The development of the most advanced AI systems happens on a spectrum, so it matters where we draw the line. That line must be able to recognise the capabilities of superintelligent AI. The clearest example of such a capability is recursive self-improvement, the full automation of AI development with no humans in the loop. This is the point where we lose control, as development towards superintelligent AI proceeds too fast for humans to intervene and remain in control.
My bill also empowers the government to monitor and where necessary restrict precursors to superintelligent AI. A challenge we cannot overlook, however, is if anyone builds superintelligent AI, wherever they build it, we are all in danger. Some talk of a race to develop superintelligent AI as if there could be a human winner. The only winner of this race would be superintelligent AI itself, and we'd all be at its mercy.
A global problem necessitates a global solution, which is why my bill recommends the government to work with other countries to secure an international agreement prohibiting superintelligence. Why should Britain lead this effort? Because we already have. AI's foundational theoretical groundwork was laid by Alan Turing at Cambridge, Bletchley Park and Manchester. Google DeepMind was founded in London.
But most importantly, Britain hosted the first global AI safety summit at Bletchley Park, which brought the US and China to the table to shape the future of AI. Britain established the world's first AI Security Institute, building crucial expertise within government. With AI policy now at the cabinet table, Britain has an opportunity and I argue a responsibility to leverage its state capacity and lead the next stage of international AI governance, especially when we have the next presidency of the G20. This bill recognizes that responsibility. With this bill, the UK becomes the first G7 country in which legislation is introduced to address the national security and extinction risk from superintelligent AI by prohibiting its development.
It is a watershed moment that lays the foundation for the UK to champion and work with others on a lean international agreement, a trust but verify regime that doesn't need to wait on the slow machinery of traditional institutions. Key choke points in the AI supply chain would provide governments the ability to monitor and control the development of superintelligent AI. The most advanced AI systems depend on state-of-the-art chips. These features make the supply chain inherently controllable and an international agreement eminently enforceable, through, for example, the programming of the chips. What is missing is not the technical ability to implement such a treaty, but rather a coalition of countries ready to tackle this national and global security threat.
Britain can lead the way. I'm proud to champion this bill, but we are not alone in this effort. In June this year, the United States government suspended access to Anthropic's Mythos model on national security grounds. If the Trump administration, which is perceived as historically against AI regulation, can contemplate drawing a line on models that are too powerful and dangerous, then it would be strange to not ask what our own response should be. This is especially true given our legacy of being a first mover on AI security with Bletchley Park and the world's first AI Security Institute.
A growing worldwide coalition of the willing is calling for decisive action and we should kickstart this effort at home. The clock is ticking. Thank you.
Bernard Jenkin
The question is that the honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. I call Sir Bernard Jenkin.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm as keen as anybody to get on with discussing the Health Bill, but this topic is too serious an opportunity to miss, given that he's raised such important issues, and I really commend his speech and commend his initiative, and everybody should read it. All I want to say is kind of unilateral disarmament on AI is not going to solve the national or the international problem. China, Russia, North Korea, Iran, these are not respecters of international treaties or international laws, even if they were to sign such treaties or international laws. And we don't want to disable our own industry. The jury is out on whether AI is an extinction-threatening phenomenon, but I really do commend him for raising this topic.
I hope he will forgive me for opposing his bill because I want this debate to continue.
Eleanor Laing
The question is that the honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. On the voices the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?
Alex Sobel
Thank you. To bring in the bill is myself, Jess Sarto, John McDonnell, Afzal Khan, Dr. Allison Gardner, Bambos Charalambos, Sir Desmond Swayne, Charlie Maynard, Manuela Potegala, Ben Lake, Yasmin Qureshi and Vera Hobhouse.
13th of November.
Speaker 279
13th of November. I call the minister to move the ways and means motion in respect of the Health Bill. Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Eleanor Laing
The question is as on the order paper. The question is as on the order paper as many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Speaker 280
Health Bill as amended in the Public Bill Committee to be further considered.
Eleanor Laing
We will begin with new clause 94 with which it will be convenient to consider other new clauses and amendments as listed on this selection paper. I call the minister to move new clause 94.
Karin Smyth
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I know many honorable members want to talk about the provisions in this bill on many important issues so I will speak briefly about two government amendments relating to medical device licensing and information sharing. I'll first address new clause 94 regarding medical devices licensing and consequential amendments new clause 99 to 101 regarding medical devices disclosure. These amendments are about ensuring that Great Britain's medical devices regulatory framework remains fit for the future. As we know medical technology is evolving rapidly particularly in areas such as software and artificial intelligence while our current framework was designed for a very different technological landscape.
This set of amendments establishes the statutory foundation for a future medical device licensing regime applying to Great Britain only. EU medical devices legislation will continue to apply in Northern Ireland. Such a regime would require medical devices to be licensed and certain persons operating within the supply chain to hold a license. And by placing the detail in the in the regulations the amendment allows us to work with patients, healthcare professionals and medical device sector to create a regulatory framework that can protect patients, support innovation and strengthens the UK's life sciences sector.
Jim Allister
On the regulatory framework and the damage done to inter-UK trade, a section 45B of the Internal Market Act was passed. It was said to promise that there would be no further export procedures which could impact adversely upon trade from Northern Ireland to Great Britain. And yet within this new clause 94 we have such constraints in the imposition of a licensing program whereby you can only export, or it shouldn't even be called export it's internal market, whereby if you're bringing a medical device from Northern Ireland to Great Britain you need a license by the recipient. How is that compatible with section 45B of the Internal Market Act?
Karin Smyth
Well I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention. As he know and we've discussed remember many long hours in this place discussing these arrangements with regard to our leaving the European Union that the different regulations as a result of Brexit between Great Britain and Northern Ireland as is currently the case and due to the Windsor Framework that results in Northern Ireland following the EU device regulations. This has obviously been discussed with the Northern Ireland and Windsor Framework Taskforce and the Cabinet Office and we are content that that the provisions are are right given the frameworks application.
And I know and understand the point that the honorable gentleman makes, and I'm sure he will pursue that with the government in other areas. I will now move to new clause 95 and 98. These amendments update and clarify the Secretary of State's information sharing powers for medicines and medical devices. They provide a clearer legal framework for the MHRA to share information with the UK health systems organizations and trusted international partners. The current legislative framework does not always provide the MHRA with the powers or clarity it needs to share information quickly and effectively, and this creates barriers to collaboration, including with the NHS.
These amendments will address these challenges, providing a clear statutory basis for information sharing. There is currently no explicit statutory domestic information sharing power for medicines, whereas there is for medical devices, and these amendments bring information sharing powers about medicines in line with that of medical devices and updates the list of statutory purposes for which the MHRA may share information. Importantly, these reforms do not weaken existing safeguards. Patient information will not be shared internationally without consent, and domestic protections under the Data Protection Act 2018 and UK GDPR remain unchanged. And with that, Madam Deputy Speaker, these amendments will act in the interest of patients, and I commend them to the House.
Eleanor Laing
The question is that new clause 94 be read a second time. Dr. Caroline Johnson.
Caroline Johnson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and as is routine, I now declare an interest as an NHS consultant pediatrician, a member of the British Medical Association, and a member of the Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health. Madam Deputy Speaker, yesterday the government voted not to introduce a backstop to the side on the Hughes report. I submitted a written question that also had a deadline of last night to ask whether they were going to, when they're going to respond, and they haven't answered that either. Taking your time about something is one thing, but for the government to completely ignore victims, refusing to give an answer, refusing to give a backstop or a deadline, is frankly shameful. Madam Deputy Speaker, patient safety is really important, and one key element to improve it is striking a good balance between accountability and blame.
If you don't hold people accountable for their actions, they may not be as careful. But if people feel their superiors are looking to find fault, they'll be defensive and they may cover things up. That makes it hard to get to the root cause and stop mistakes happening again. Madam Deputy Speaker, HSSIB was set up with this problem in mind. Like the Air Accident Investigation Branch, it has a safe place.
This means people are not held legally responsible for what they reveal to that team. They can get to the bottom of why things are going wrong and find system errors. Madam Deputy Speaker, people come forward because they know and trust that HSSIB is independent. But this Labour government want to change that. The Health Bill will abolish HSSIB and transfer all its functions to the Care Quality Commission, the body responsible for regulating health and social care.
This is the same CQC that, according to ministers, is not fit for purpose. So why? Ministers cite a review by Dr. Penny Dash, which said that the patient safety landscape was cluttered and fragmented. But too many different organizations are producing too many recommendations. But that report was narrow in scope, and the clutter is not caused by the HSSIB.
People come forward to HSIB precisely because it's a safe space, and this government are moving the confidence in that safe space. For the new setup to work, frontline workers would need to believe the new unit in the CQC is independent, despite the law making clear that it's not. The government's impact assessment says that the National Quality Board will provide clear direction to the new investigation unit, but the National Quality Board is tied to the NHS, so how does that square with the new unit staying independent? The impact assessment also says that the vast majority of investigations are expected to be directed by the Health Secretary. How can we be sure that the new unit will have the power and resources to look at things that might be politically difficult for the government?
How will the people in charge of the CQC balance the responsibility of investigating with the responsibility of maintaining that safe space?
Bernard Jenkin
I will. I'm most grateful. On the question of how the leadership of CQC becomes conflicted, can she reflect on the fact that the then Patient Safety Minister in the adjournment debate that I held in July made it clear that the person responsible for deciding what safe space information might be released would be the Chief Executive of CQC. So if the Chief Executive of CQC is to see all this information, how is he or she not to be able to use that, or be tempted to use that, when they're inspecting hospitals for the purposes of CQC? Isn't then the safe space hopelessly conflicted and therefore would lose public confidence?
Caroline Johnson
Absolutely, he's obviously read my speech. And indeed, what would happen if the new unit identified the CQC itself as the problem? Ministers have not provided good answers to these questions. And to be honest, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think they can't, because the government cannot have its cake and eat it. Either HSIB remains independent, or it's folded into the CQC and loses its independence.
It's either decluttering a landscape by removing an organisation, or simply hiding it inside another organisation to the detriment of both. We have tabled amendment one to protect HSIB, and I urge the government to support it in the interests of patient safety.
Andrew Gwynne
I will. I'm very grateful for her to giving way. She may be aware the Health Select Committee has got our pre-appointment hearing with the incoming chair of the CQC tomorrow morning. One of the questions I'd like to ask them hinges on the answer to this that I would have loved the Minister to give us an update on. The previous Secretary of State had said HSIB will not be merged with the CQC until the CQC is ready, but never we have never had a list from the government as to exactly what metrics they're using.
Layla Moran
The previous Secretary of State had said HSIB will not be merged with the CQC until the CQC is ready. But never we have never had a list from the government as to exactly what metrics they are going to use to decide when that happens. And that will then have a bearing on what kinds of questions we are going to be asking and probing the chair and the CEO. What does the government mean specifically by ready? Does she not see that as a problem?
Caroline Johnson
I absolutely do. I think the government has said the CQC is not fit for purpose, and yet it's now asking it to do additional things it didn't do before, including HSIB, but also including event management healthcare, which the honourable lady will be aware of. And so I think it's absolutely right the government pause and think this one through once again. Madam Deputy Speaker, moving on to one of our other amendments about puberty blockers. One of the first rules of medicine is primum non nocere, first do no harm.
And yet here we have a Labour government sponsoring a ten point six million pound trial to put two hundred and twenty-six physically healthy children as young as eleven on puberty blocking drugs. Now, that was said to make the former Secretary of State uneasy. Why was he uneasy? Perhaps because they're powerful drugs that could potentially cause serious long-term harm. Perhaps because most children get better by themselves.
Perhaps because we can't reliably identify which children will persist with a trans identity and which will not. Perhaps because the huge increase in girls experiencing gender dysphoria has not been adequately explained. Perhaps because the Tavistock data has not been reviewed in the data linkage study as yet. There are many reasons for concerns, but I'm aware that we're short of time. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's difficult for a clinician to tell which children's symptoms will self-resolve and which will not.
As a result, we risk putting a large number of children on puberty blockers to assess the effects on, as the former Health Secretary put it, a very small subset of a very small group. This means the results of the investigation may be unreliable and it could cause unnecessary harm to children. And so why is the government not ensuring the data linkage study is at very least done first? The minister will note that there was a vote on this trial at the end of the opposition debate in the summer, where a large number of her party abstained and three voted against. There were also votes against from many other parties.
As a doctor, Madam Deputy Speaker, I appreciate that voting on a clinical trial is unusual. But let's be clear, this is the Labour government's trial. It is taxpayers' money that is being spent and it is young British children that we're talking about. So if the government want to run this trial and pay for it, why not bring it before the House so parliamentarians can decide whether it is the right thing to do? Madam Deputy Speaker, we have a new Prime Minister and a new Secretary of State.
The country need to know if they are content to pay for a trial of powerful drugs on an unnecessarily large group of children, a majority of whom have self-limiting, temporary feelings of distress. Madam Deputy Speaker, we also have an amendment regarding single-sex spaces. When the Supreme Court ruled on the sixteenth of April twenty twenty-five that the legal definition of a woman refers strictly to biological sex, many up and down the country will have wondered why do we need judges to tell us that? We are all, including in the eyes of the law, male or female. Of course, there are people who feel more comfortable presenting as the opposite sex, and I'm sure the whole House would agree that trans men and trans women need protection from harm and harassment in the same way as their fellow citizens.
I would hope the whole House would also agree that a woman should never be forced to get undressed in the presence of a man and vice versa. But that is what happened to the Darlington nurses. Seven nurses were forced to share a changing room with a transgender woman, someone who is male but who presents publicly as a woman. The Supreme Court was crystal clear. The legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex.
And yet these nurses were subjected to pressure and intimidation for raising concerns about getting changed in front of someone who is a man. I will give way, yeah.
Speaker 123
Thank the honorable member for giving way and for the tone in which she is conducting this debate. I would like to ask her, however, would she feel more comfortable with a transgender man getting changed in front of those female nurses, or a transgender man with balding hair, a full beard, who is behaving like a man, who is full of testosterone, presenting in a female toilet facility at night, possibly on a motorway service station? I know I wouldn't feel safe, but it seems that she would feel safer in that situation than a trans woman getting changed or attending a toilet.
Caroline Johnson
I'm not sure why she's reached that conclusion. What I'm saying is that this is based on biology and people that are trans are requiring the same protections as people who are not. That's what I have said very clearly. But moving back to Darlington. The Darlington nurses were particularly brave in bringing this case forward.
And the cost, one hundred and eighty-seven thousand pounds in damages after an employment tribunal ruled in favor of the Darlington nurses. That is a victory for dignity, a victory for women, and a victory for common sense. But it is also a significant cost of public money to an NHS trust because it decided not to follow the law. That's money that could have been spent on patient care. What steps has the Minister taken to ensure this guidance is fully and properly implemented across the NHS?
How will she ensure that a repeat of the Darlington nurses case does not happen again? And what guidance is being given to NHS managers on how to handle this? Madam Deputy Speaker, the Minister for Women and Equalities didn't help matters. She had the responsibility to sign off the Equality and Human Rights Commission's draft code of practice to inform businesses, services, and public bodies how to implement the Supreme Court's guidance in law. But for over a year, the government failed to lift a finger to enforce the law.
For over a year, businesses, hospitals, service providers, and public bodies were left waiting for the government to tell them what the official guidance said. Now that it is here, we need to know how it's being implemented. How will the Minister ensure this guidance is implemented universally in our NHS? How will they make sure that single-sex spaces are protected? What provision will they make for transgender individuals?
What reassurance can she give to women working in our NHS that they are safe? Our new clause 143 makes it clear that both staff and patients in the NHS must have access to single-sex spaces to protect their dignity, their privacy. I hope the Minister will be able to support this, and I can't see why she would not. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government has also decided to abolish Healthwatch and reduce the number of local Healthwatch branches. Healthwatch England has been engaging with patients since 2013 with more than 150 operating in a hub-and-spoke model, but this is about to change.
Why? One of the reasons seems to be to avoid duplication. The government's clearly not keen on lots of Healthwatches doing the same thing in different areas of the country and feels some branches may operate better than others. It says it wants to bring feedback closer to decision makers. But is that a good idea?
They could have chosen to improve Healthwatches as it stands. In 23-24, more than 925,000 people used the Healthwatch to get advice and information, more than 300,000 sharing their experience to improve services. They could have increased awareness further. They could have developed a clear feedback chain. But instead they've decided to abolish Healthwatch altogether.
That's of grave concern. How can patients be expected to complain to the system about the system? The Prime Minister previously wrote: "People speak to Healthwatch because they are outside the system, they are impartial, they are trusted and they provide a safe space for concerns to be shared." Mr. Speaker, Madam Deputy Speaker, on this he was right and I ask the Minister to accept our amendment on this subject. Madam Deputy Speaker, we have another of amendments.
Amendments on fracture liaison services, amendments to produce MSF on musculoskeletal health, on radiotherapy, on respiratory health, on brain injury and on government on the government's new medical devices regulations. But I appreciate we're short of time so I'll just make two short comments if I may, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, on amendment 146, the Liberal Democrat amendment. I agree with the intent of this amendment, of course, but it requires the presence of HSIB and since the government seem hellbent on removing that, I don't know how the amendment would work. And on new clause 81 from backbench amendment that's been chosen by Mr. Speaker.
Again, this is a really important issue and as a pediatrician I really see the importance of of what it's suggesting. The regulations will need to be carefully drafted for those people who have a brief illness and to define the life-threatening illness more clearly and to avoid duplication of work, but in principle it is an important amendment and I commend our amendments to the House. Thank you.
Eleanor Laing
And with the exception of frontbench speeches, there will be an immediate three-minute time limit. Graham Morris.
Speaker 289
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm speaking today in support of new clauses 113 and 114 which stand in the name of my honorable friend, the honorable member for Westmorland and Lonsdale, to which I've also added my name. But I do want to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that at the very outset, I'm in full support of this government's ambitions on cancer. I do welcome the recent investment in radiotherapy equipment and I sincerely want the national cancer plan which was published in February to succeed. But I'm speaking as someone who worked in the health service, someone who's a cancer survivor and also who's took a particular interest in this issue, not least as vice chairman of the all-party parliamentary group on radiotherapy.
And in that capacity and as a supporter of what the government is trying to achieve, I respectfully ask ministers to accept one or both of these new clauses. By way of very brief explanation, new clause 113 or amendment 113 requires the Secretary of State to publish and maintain a national framework of agreed metrics for radiotherapy and requires the integrated care boards to report annually against these targets and requires a report to this House once a year. New clause 114 asks very straightforwardly for a single review within six months of access to radiotherapy and radiotherapy waiting times to be laid before Parliament.
Anna Dixon
Thanks to my honorable friend for giving way. Would he agree with me that given the ethnic inequalities that we see in cancer outcomes and access to cancer treatment like radiotherapy, that that should also be included in the suggested review?
Speaker 289
This is a huge issue that should concern everyone. I believe there is a cross-party consensus at this issue of health inequalities and huge variations in access depending on which part of the country you live. It's an absolutely valid point. What the amendment is seeking to do is in the knowledge that the international consensus is that around half of all cancer patients have an evidence-based indication for radiotherapy at some point as part of their treatment. We should be aware that here in the United Kingdom, in 2021, the last year for which figures were available, only 35% of cancer patients received it as part of their primary treatment.
Will you give way?
Timothy James Farron
For the excellent points he's making. Of course I'm going to add in that Lancashire and South Cumbria, it's only 29% get access to radiotherapy. He will be aware, won't he, that the government's target is 85% of people diagnosed with cancer should be treated within 62 days. 85%. Only 41% of patients who are recommended radiotherapy get treated within those 62 days.
He'll also know that for every four weeks delay in cancer treatment, there's a 10% less chance of survival. And so it's right, isn't it, that the government should accept new clause 114 so that we can make it mandatory that people are treated within those two months to give them the best chance of survival.
Speaker 289
I'm grateful for that intervention and absolutely hit the nail on the head there, perfectly put. And I do believe, Minister, that there is cross-party consensus that this is the way forward. I might say a whole succession of ministers from various parties over the last 16 years that I've been a member along with my honorable friend, we've presented the case to a succession of ministers, all of whom seem to be in agreement. But here we definitely have an opportunity to restore what was once a world-class cancer service and to get us back to where the international benchmark says we should be. I would like to say that responsibility for commissioning radiotherapies, as I'm sure we're aware, was devolved to the integrated care boards.
Now, I can understand the logic of moving commissioning closer to local populations and I believe the mover of the resolution and myself are not seeking to undo that. But what we wish to stress to the House is that radiotherapy is not an ordinary local service, nor should it be considered as one. It's delivered from a very limited number of highly specialized centers dependent on capital equipment with long replacement cycles, relies on a small, highly skilled workforce, around 6,000 in the country, all of which take years to train, and all of while being reliant on physical infrastructure that cannot be commissioned at short notice. Patients also routinely cross integrated care board boundaries to reach these specialist centers. Many boards, entirely understandably, do not have dedicated radiotherapy expertise in-house.
And indeed, in August of last year, 70% of integrated care boards had no named person responsible for ensuring sufficient radiotherapy treatment capacity at all. I'm willing to work with ministers in order to seek a resolution with the solutions we've proposed.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yesterday I highlighted our concerns about the implications of quick-fix top-down reorganization for the sovereignty of the NHS and the interests of patients. In a system which already spends too much time and money reacting to failure rather than planning for success, patient safety is already under threat. Rather than addressing these failings, this bill is at risk of a bonfire of patient safety. Our amendments would reverse this gutting of safety mechanisms from the NHS, all of which have been painstakingly introduced after far too many scandals.
Amendments 8 and 9 would restore Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch organizations, while new clause 14 would restore Healthwatch funding after 10 years of cuts to its service. Given that Healthwatch was originally established as a response to the devastating Mid Staffordshire scandal, its abolition would be a step backwards, showing lessons haven't been learned. An independent patient voice is essential both to shape local services and highlight where they aren't working well, and folding it into existing NHS structures risks destroying the trust that exists precisely because of its independence. Another vital, I'm not going to give way because there are many colleagues who wish to speak and there is very, very limited time, so I hope you'll forgive me. Another vital body for safeguarding and investigating patient safety is HSIB, which again functions well because of the trust NHS professionals have in its independence and its objectivity.
Both would be lost under the proposal to roll it into the CQC. Our amendment 12 would ensure that HSIB's functions remain operationally independent of the CQC, so that the NHS isn't left to mark its own homework. Together these amendments are designed so that patients are protected from another Mid Staffordshire, or another Shrewsbury and Telford, or another Nottingham, or another East Kent, or another Morecambe Bay. Rash decision-making must not be allowed to put patients at risk. We would also go further than protecting existing patient safety measures and significantly strengthen whistleblowing routes through new clauses 9 and 10.
These new clauses create standard mechanisms for whistleblowing by coroners and hospital boards, new powers to report wrongdoing, and new requirements on managers and DHSC to whistleblow where there are concerns about systemic medical malpractice or failure. But keeping patients safe goes beyond just blowing the whistle. My colleague, the member for Epsom and Ewell, has tabled new clause 52 to give patients a right to start cancer treatment within 62 days of referral, with a scheme to deliver this. Liberal Democrat research earlier this year found that 80% of trusts failed to meet this 62-day target, with nearly 1,000 patients waiting over six months for treatment. People are suffering and dying because of these failures, it just isn't safe.
The egregious patient safety failure that I will focus on today, though, is the corridor care crisis. The latest release of monthly corridor care statistics revealed the worst summer on record for A&E waits, with well over 300,000 waits in June and July of 12 hours or more. Nearly 100,000 people were treated in hospital corridors in July. After 2025 seeing the worst level of 12-hour trolley waits in A&E ever recorded, this summer's corridor care statistics show an even worsening trend. The human reality of these numbers is that patients are left to deteriorate for hours on corridors, potentially without food or water, and staff are pushed to breaking point.
One nurse described the conditions as akin to torture, with a 2025 survey from the Royal College of Physicians finding that 78% of physicians had provided care in a temporary space.
It is absolutely incumbent on the government to act now and act fast to put an end to this crisis. I've therefore tabled new clause 140, which would require the government to end NHS corridor care in hospitals within one year and to launch an independent inquiry into corridor care, including into government policy, if that is not achieved. Many of the protections and organisations being abolished or weakened in this bill were introduced following scandals during the Prime Minister's tenure as Health Secretary. He promised lasting change and to listen, as well as previously opposing the removal of Healthwatch, but he is now due to oversee a big backward step in patient safety. Now, I am aware, Madam Deputy Speaker, finally, that the Speaker is provisionally minded to select the official opposition's new clauses 142 and 143 for separate decision, so I will briefly outline my concerns about those amendments.
New clause 142 seeks to politicise a drug trial in a way that is unprecedented and inappropriate. Drug trials must be protected by objective ethical and medical safeguards, and it is vital that they are undertaken in a way which follows a rigorous and accepted predictable scientific process which prioritises the safety of patients. Baroness Cass has outlined her concerns about the misinformation surrounding this trial in her letter to all MPs, which was sent before the summer recess, and I strongly recommend that all MPs read it. Allowing politicians to override objective ethical and medical safeguards is a dangerous precedent to set, particularly in a world where vaccine deniers and anti-science fantasists have a clear route to getting their hands on the levers of power. As always, we stand firm in the belief of an evidence-based approach and argue strongly against the risk of political capture where we should be led by the science.
Now, Liberal Democrat policy on single-sex spaces requires that everyone who needs access to a single space can do so safely and feel comfortable and secure, while ensuring nobody faces discrimination on the basis of their being trans. But the opposition's new clause 143 is very poorly drafted and would create chaos and confusion within the NHS, applying those requirements to spaces such as pop-up flu jab clinics, blood donation sessions in the community, and potentially even care delivered in a private residence, in a way that is clearly unworkable and would damage delivery of care, and therefore I'm also unable to support it. Given their haste in tabling the amendments to retain Healthwatch, I'm disappointed the official opposition is not using this opportunity to push a vote on that critical issue instead. I urge the government to accept the amendments laid in my name and by my Lib Dem colleagues to protect patient safety if they, unlike the opposition, are serious about building a health service that works for staff and delivers for patients. I've enjoyed working with the Minister here in the chamber, at committee, and one-to-one, and I'm sure she has the best intentions.
I hope she's listened to our genuine concerns about patient safety during the course of the debate over the last two days and will consider further our amendments in the other place, because if not, Liberal Democrats will continue to fight for significant improvements to patient safety as this bill progresses through the House of Lords. Thank you.
Liz Twist
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I start by saying that I welcome this bill and was pleased to be a member of the bill committee, and I also welcome the government's new clauses which the Minister has spoken to today. But I rise to speak to amendment 159, to which I have added my name, which seeks to address a long-standing legislative omission in our health service. I would like to thank my honourable friend the member for Sunderland Central for submitting this amendment. For over a decade, since the Health and Social Care Act 2012, Parliament has recognised the principle of parity of esteem between physical and mental health, yet without statutory accountability, parity has remained an aspiration rather than a clinical reality. Now, the scale of the problem is clear.
NHS data shows that 1.87 million adults and over 576,000 children and young people currently hold open referrals for mental health services. While the government sets clear targets to reduce physical health care waiting lists, mental health services are excluded from these core constitutional ambitions. And the division has severe consequences. A survey by Rethink Mental Illness found that 83% of patients saw their mental health deteriorate while waiting for support and nearly a third of those whose health worsened attempted suicide. New clause 159 would require the Secretary of State to publish national waiting time standards for mental health services within 12 months of this Act passing.
The fact is, what is measured is addressed. So we need to give the same attention to mental health as we quite rightly do to physical health measures. These standards, covering both community and urgent care, must be developed in consultation with the Chief Medical Officer. Crucially, the clause mandates the Secretary of State to report performance against those waiting times alongside mental health expenditure to Parliament every year. This ensures that funding reallocated in this House is transparently linked to patient outcomes.
If we do not measure waiting times, we cannot manage them and patients will continue to be left until they are in crisis before they receive support. It's time that we start to pay the same attention to mental health as we do to physical health so we can really achieve parity of esteem. Now, this government set out a welcome and ambitious path to rebuild our NHS and achieving true parity of esteem is central to that mission. So I urge the Minister to look closely at amendment 159 as constructive.
Caroline Dinenage
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm speaking today on new clause 41 in my name. We've put enormous unquestioning trust in those who care for the body of our loved ones when we die. And yet in this chamber six months ago, I told the former Health Minister about Elkin and Bell, the Gosport funeral directors who left 46 bodies decaying in an unrefrigerated room. One of them, an elderly gentleman whose family had already paid for his cremation, left decomposing for 36 days. I said then that the funeral sector was nothing better than a lawless Wild West with no mandatory qualifications to practice, no accreditation for professionals, no licensing of businesses, no inspection of premises, and no law to fall back on when things go wrong.
It was only persistence and ingenuity by Hampshire Constabulary that saw Elkin and Bell brought to justice. The Minister at the time told me a decision on regulation would come in the government's full answer to the Fuller Inquiry. And we are still waiting, Madam Deputy Speaker. Since then, matters have worsened. In July, Robert Bush, the funeral director in Hull, was sentenced to 20 years in prison, pleading guilty to 67 charges of bodies left decomposing in squalor, 46 grieving families reunited with the wrong ashes.
But the real horror is that these will not be isolated cases. Under the law as it stands today, almost anyone can set themselves up as a funeral director. I will.
Amanda Martin
I'd like to thank my honorable friend for her work on this area in my neighboring constituency. The vast majority of funeral directors operate with integrity and compassion and professionalism. So that is the reason that they are also as reputable businesses crying out for robust regulation. Does she agree with me?
Caroline Dinenage
I genuinely couldn't agree with her more. This is not an attack on the profession. The vast majority of funeral directors, well they do their job with extraordinary skill, with great care and huge professional integrity. And actually, it's precisely because of the trust that grieving families place in them every single day that we cannot go on allowing a rogue minority to drag the reputation of that whole sector through the mud. Now, in a written statement on the 1st of September, the government described its intention for proposals for regulation to be forthcoming, but it set out no timetable and detailed plans were only promised in due course.
Families have already waited years and cannot be expected to wait indefinitely. My new clause 41 would require the Secretary of State within six months of this bill passing to extend the remit of the Human Tissues Authority beyond hospital mortuaries, which it currently covers, to cover funeral directors, private mortuaries, direct cremation services and any other organization that transports or holds the bodies of the deceased.
Andrew Gwynne
Does she not agree with me though also that Donald O'Donoghue's report into what happened at Nottingham and particularly the harrowing stories of the mortuary issues there adds to the case that she's making?
Caroline Dinenage
Can I just pay tribute to my right honorable friend and for the fantastic work he did as the shadow Secretary of State for Health. He's absolutely right. This is why we really need the full response to this fuller report to implement not only changes to mortuaries but all the other amendments that it recommended. Now this new clause 41 would place a duty on the Human Tissues Authority to establish and maintain a register of every business brought within its oversight, with how that register operates set by regulations, so that for the first time a grieving family could check before they hand over the body of their loved one whether the business in front of them is properly overseen. And I recognize the member for Leeds South West and Morley has also tabled new clause 42 for a new bespoke free-standing regulator.
Both of these would fix the same issue. Either will do. The key thing is that this is a moment for government to seize, not resist. Ministers have already said in principle that they agree with what this new clause requires of them. Every trade body agrees too.
Every family who was failed agrees too. Every member who signed our letter from across the house agrees. It feels like the government agrees, so I ask the minister today to tell the house exactly when a statutory scheme will be brought forward by the Department of Health and Social Care and what timetable of implementation. None of us are comfortable dwelling in our own mortality and that's exactly why this sector has gone on for so long without proper scrutiny. It's a truism, we hear it all the time, that funerals are for the living.
They are for families to say goodbye to their loved ones with dignity, able to grieve without the added horror of questioning whether the body they buried, whether the ashes they scattered, was actually the right one. Robert Bush's sentencing should be the last time this house has to debate a gruesome case like this. And it won't be unless the government pushes ahead to close this regulatory black hole.
Chris Hinchliff.
Chris Hinchliff
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure that many members across the house will be aware of the campaign in the memory of Hugh and Mae Davis, the son of my constituents Kerry and Francis, who tragically passed away at the age of just six. The amendments I've tabled to this bill are designed as part of that campaign to support families at the most difficult time imaginable.
Madam Deputy Speaker, our National Health Service and welfare state have changed and evolved over almost a century, and we should always keep a close watch on how faithfully they remain connected to their founding principles. Support from the cradle to the grave should not be a dusty slogan. It must be a constant aspiration, and wherever gaps or shortcomings are identified, we must address them. And it should concern us all that support for parents of seriously ill children is one such gap. When a child becomes seriously ill, the NHS mobilizes around the child, quite rightly.
But parents must mobilize around everything else: getting to work and hospital appointments, looking after other children, managing existing caring responsibilities, and somehow keeping on top of bills, rent, or mortgages that do not stop when a child becomes ill. When all of this takes place alongside the fear that your child may die, the pressure on families is near impossible to bear. Too often, our systems see a patient, a parent, an employee, a sibling, or a pupil, but rarely a family. We need our NHS to see the full picture. There is a clear gap in our safety net when parents of seriously ill children are left without the coordinated financial, practical, and emotional support they need.
The message from those with lived experience is that in these scenarios, parents find themselves passed from pillar to post, endlessly repeating the devastating reality that they are living through, compounding their trauma. The stress and complexity this adds to the burden parents and carers already face when caring for a seriously ill child contributes to longer-term health impacts for families in a way that we cannot ignore. A linked record cohort study of more than 35,000 mothers found high incidences of depression, cardiovascular disease, and death amongst mothers of children with life-limiting conditions. NC81 proposes a single named coordinator, bringing together information on financial support, employment rights for parents and carers, and signposting to relevant charities and support as part of a written plan for the family. This would cut away repetitive bureaucracy and mean that parents are no longer left to their own devices to try and figure a way through the challenges their families face in these situations.
It is a simple duty, but one that could make a massive difference. At one of the most difficult times imaginable in a family's life, it would ensure that they are no longer simply left to navigate an overwhelming and unfamiliar system alone. Childhood illness is traumatic enough; we should do everything we can to stop it.
Clive Jones
Order. Clive Jones.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to speak to new clause 137. In the six months since the National Cancer Plan was published, Cancer Research UK estimates that over 168,000 people were diagnosed with cancer in England. Numbers diagnosed are at a record high and projected to continue. Almost one in two of us in our lifetime will get cancer, and no one in this country is untouched by the disease.
I welcome the government's ambition to improve cancer outcomes in the National Cancer Plan. Alongside this amendment to the Health Bill, my current private member's bill seeks to guarantee that the government makes progress towards delivering these targets and is held to account by Parliament on that. Over the past five decades, cancer survival has more than doubled because of life-saving research, earlier detection, and cutting-edge treatments. But in the last decade, progress has slowed, and the 10-year cancer survival index was better in the early 2000s than in the 2010s, so we are in danger of going backwards. The National Cancer Plan commits to meeting cancer waiting times targets by the end of this Parliament, something the previous government failed to do, and I really hope that this government will manage to do it.
I have laid down this amendment because the current Health Bill abolishes that mandate, including the previous statutory requirement for cancer outcome objectives to be prioritized over other cancer objectives, and the similar duty has not been replicated elsewhere in the bill. With the removal of the statutory requirement to prioritize cancer outcomes over other cancer objectives in the health system, there is a very real concern that progress on cancer outcomes risks being deprioritized amid the competing priorities of a department facing many external pressures. I'm therefore seeking assurances from the Minister today that despite the disruption of the ongoing merger and removal of the cancer outcomes clause, progress on delivering the transformation laid out in the National Cancer Plan will be delivered and that it remains a priority for the new Prime Minister and the new Secretary of State. I ask the Minister to guarantee that the capacity needed to drive forward this essential work on cancer is protected.
Helen Katharine Osborne
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If I may begin on a personal note, just three weeks ago I had a second operation on my back, and I want to put on record my sincere thanks to the staff who cared for me, from the clinicians who treated me to everyone involved in my care and recovery. Too often our access to healthcare depends on your postcode. That postcode lottery is stark in a number of areas, but nowhere more so than IVF. And as chair of the APPG on fertility, this is an issue I've raised repeatedly with ministers, and I again invite ministers to attend our fertility roundtable tomorrow and commit to ensuring that every ICB at the very least follows NICE guidelines on access to IVF and fertility treatment.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we must strengthen the role of voluntary, community, and social enterprise organizations in neighborhood health planning and NHS commissioning. Voluntary organizations understand the barriers to care for hard-to-reach communities and often have trusted relationships with communities that statutory services struggle to reach. We see that particularly clearly in HIV and AIDS provision. Voluntary organizations have been fundamental to the UK's response for decades through prevention, testing, peer support, tackling stigma, and supporting people living with HIV. And I'm extremely grateful to the National AIDS Trust for working with me on these clauses that I had and thank ministers for their constructive engagement.
Members of the LGBT+ community must have trust in healthcare providers and community groups bridge that gap when needed. Let me turn to today's amendments and NC142 and 143, which would actively harm vitally needed healthcare. 142 has already been rejected at committee stage, and we see it for what it is: just an opportunity to attack some of the most vulnerable in our society. Access to much-needed healthcare has already been paused in the UK, and if access to treatment for gender dysphoria is now to be dependent upon additional research, then the pathways trial must go ahead without further delay.
NC143 again has already been rejected at committee stage and is another attempt to vilify. The amendment fails to recognize the framework already in place to ensure single-sex services are provided where they meet the requirements of the Equality Act. Neither the code nor the Supreme Court judgment mandate for the provision of single-sex facilities. Providers must still consider whether the service falls within an exception within the Equality Act, whether single-sex provision is proportionate, what the impact might be on trans people, and what mitigation might be necessary. Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the 10-year health plan.
We've made great strides in repairing the damage done to our NHS.
Sir Bernard Jenkin.
Bernard Jenkin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would very much like to have discussed the medical devices questions that arise in this bill that presented by the minister, and she made an incredibly short speech about an important matter when it's quite clear that these provisions are part of the covert realignment, dynamic alignment with the EU, the covert rejoiner agenda that's been pursued by the government. And it raises all sorts of constitutional questions, but not for today. I want to concentrate on HSSIB, and I rise to support amendments number numbers 1 to 4, which would remove the abolition of HSSIB from the bill. The government has singularly failed to make the case for removing this crucial safety investigation function, which didn't exist until recently, and now they want to scrub it out, I suspect because too many people in the health system don't like being held to account by an independent investigator body.
Well, the minister shakes her head. She's yet to give a good reason as to why this is in the bill. When we had an adjournment debate in July with the patient the then patient safety minister, she couldn't answer the question as to who is going to conduct independent safety investigations in the NHS after the abolition of HSSIB. She said safety investigations would be conducted by CQC, but she wouldn't actually claim that they would be independent because, as my right honorable friend from the front bench demonstrated, they would not be. And if it is intended, as it seems, that safety investigations should be carried out in CQC unaffected by the transfer, why make the transfer at all?
How much is this transfer going to cost? We've asked I asked in a letter which I sent to the minister after the debate to give us the information about how much the transfer of all this is going to cost. Nothing has arrived. I've never had a reply to the letter since I wrote back in July. Of course, they've changed the minister, and the new patient safety minister's not in the House today.
I rather suspect she is more sympathetic to this argument than the minister sitting on the front bench today. We discovered in our exchanges earlier and once again exposed how the safe space is going to be brutally compromised by the fact that it will be housed in a regulator with other ulterior motives inevitably. But the chief executive of CQC is is wantonly conflicted in terms of looking after the safe space, so he can't be the one that's left in charge of its of that function. And the real point here is we're missing the opportunity to save so much money. Governments keep having public inquiries.
The EPUT public inquiry in Essex, affecting my constituency, in its first year it cost 5 million, in its second year it's costing another 5 million. The whole budget for HSSIB was only 6.3 million pounds a year, and yet it does scores of investigations, not just one inquiry. The Ockenden inquiry cost 14 million pounds. And yet that is and if we could save just a fraction of the cost of medical negligence, which is 3.6 billion a year, HSSIB would pay for itself.
Jeff Smith.
Jeff Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Clauses 5 and 6 of this bill place duties on the Secretary of State to promote patient involvement, patient choice and innovation. And my new clause 86 and new clause 87 apply those principles to psychedelic assisted therapy treatments involving schedule 1 controlled substances. I've been pleased to be a trustee of the charity Drug Science. It's allowed me to talk to researchers looking at therapeutic treatments using what are called psychedelic drugs.
And around the world there is growing evidence about the successful treatment of PTSD, of trauma, of mental health issues, of end-of-life distress using these drugs. For some patients, these are absolutely revelatory. They change lives for the better and can relieve the burden of those conditions on the wider health service. But researchers tell me the barriers that the current system put in place for them are really, really restricting research. The research involved in these controlled schedule 1 controlled substances generally requires a Home Office license and the bureaucracy and the inertia in the system adds delay, cost, administrative burden to the extent of research grants being lost because of those delays.
The issue's already been considered in 2023. The Home Affairs Select Committee recommended urgently moving psychedelic drugs to schedule 2 to facilitate research. Later that year, the Advisory Council on Misuse of Drugs recommended that research using schedule 1 drugs in universities and hospitals should be exempt from the Home Office domestic licensing requirement and instead operate under schedule 2 controls. In 2025, the government accepted the ACMD recommendations in principle. And there's supposed to be a pilot, a proposed exemption subject to to test the operational feasibility.
But it's not been happening. The government said the policy work was underway and further plans would be published in due course but without an implementation timetable. And my amendment new clause 86 would make it happen. Other jurisdictions are ahead of us on this. The US Defense Department, the Department of Veterans Affairs already funding clinical trials for military personnel and veterans.
The new I'm running out of time so new clause 87 concerns compassionate access to treatment. International research has potential has identified potential in some treatment-resistant psychiatric conditions and end-of-life distress. There is international precedent on this. The 2022 Canada Special Access Program has allowed clinicians to to request restricted drugs including psilocybin and MDMA to treat these these conditions. And we can we can learn from those experiences.
Finally, I'm grateful to the Minister for meeting with me to discuss these issues and for her agreement on the principle of enabling clinical research for these drugs and her commitment to get back to me to outline how the government will take this further.
Vikki Slade
I'm speaking to new clauses 116 and 117 tabled in my name. Clover Karkheck from my constituency is a delightful seven-year-old girl who's suffered from intractable epilepsy since she was 12 weeks old. Clover's seizures could only be controlled by huge doses of steroids, leaving her very unwell until her parents secured a private prescription for medical cannabis, reducing her seizures by 95%. Medical cannabis is legal and it can be bought privately under NHS supervision, but it's not routinely available on the NHS. As a result, families are faced with an impossible choice: fund thousands of pounds a month to pay privately or watch their child suffer while relying on the treatments available through the NHS.
Why are parents being made to make this choice? Colleagues across this House, including the member for Gower, have long campaigned on this issue and support new clause 116, which calls on the Secretary of State to assess the availability of medical cannabis on the NHS for children. And I hope the government will support this amendment today too. On new clause 117, in June, thyroid surgery left me with vocal cord paralysis, as you can particularly hear today. This has given me a real and unwelcome insight into the challenges faced by people who experience voice loss.
According to the Lary Project, around 30% of adults will experience voice loss at some point in their life. Speech and language therapists can often resolve these issues entirely, but access to therapy is determined by a postcode lottery.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I was fortunate to get NHS speech therapy this summer, but not everyone is. And that's why new clause 117, backed by the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists, calls on the Secretary of State to publish a strategy tackling waiting times and unequal access to speech and language therapy. To do this job, we all rely on our voices, and I urge the House to support NC117 today.
Karin Smyth
Which brings us to the front bench contribution. I call the Minister, Karin Smyth.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And look, at what people call a wide-ranging and thoughtful debate, I really do want to try and address all the points that have been raised. And I think that there is broad agreement across the House on the general goals that we are seeking to achieve with this bill: safer care, better outcomes, and a stronger voice for patients. Every patient deserves safe, high-quality care, every community deserves to have its voice heard, and everyone should be able to access the care they need when they need it. The questions before us is really about how best to deliver those ambitions.
In general, we do not believe that the current landscape works and that better outcomes are always achieved through new reporting requirements or additional layers of statutory process or more bureaucracy. Instead, we are committed to devolving responsibility to empowering leaders in the NHS while also holding them directly account so that the NHS is focused on delivery and improving care. I'll begin, Madam Deputy Speaker, on Healthwatch. I think there is broad consensus, as I said, that we want to see patient voices heard strongly at every level of the healthcare system, something I think all MPs in particular feel very strongly about dealing with our constituents. And hearing the patient and user voice results in better decisions and a system that's designed around them and a system that's better able to correct things when things go wrong.
And our ambition is to ensure that insight and experience from patients, service users, and communities is part of commissioning and service planning decisions, rather than being held at arm's length, rather than it being outsourced. And our ambition that this is done effectively everywhere. It's about strengthening the power of patients' voices inside the NHS where decisions are taken, not silencing criticism of those decisions. And our approach is that integrated care boards and local authorities will be expected to engage with people in their areas and will have a statutory duty to obtain their views. It's a core part of their new strategic role of ICBs.
That includes transparency about what people have told the system, what the system has done in response, and how learning is shared across partners. Holding ICBs to account if they do not demonstrate it. However, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have heard the strength of feeling in this place and through committee, and as the bill moves to the other place, I can commit to working closely with colleagues across this House and in the other place to review these provisions to ensure our approach sufficiently empowers and devolves to local populations. We want all to ensure that these changes deliver for patients and service users, building public trust and ensuring that their voice is embedded in the care they receive, briefly.
Adrian Philip Ramsay
I thank the Minister for giving way. The CEO of Healthwatch Norfolk said today that to cease the statutory functions of Healthwatch without a suitable alternative in place is to risk another major failing in patient safety and scrutiny of the health system. Did the Minister's remarks just now suggest the government may be reviewing the plans to scrap Healthwatch?
Karin Smyth
Well, it would not be a surprise that I don't agree with the proposition. I would commend the work that many people have done in their Healthwatches, but we absolutely want to work with people in the other place to make sure that these are the right, this is the right way forward. On HSIB, and again, I'm sorry we don't have more time to debate this because I do think it does require a lot more discussion. We had a good debate in committee. We've heard many discussions here today.
I have met with the member, the right honorable member for Harwich and North Essex as well and hear what he's saying. And I will make sure that he gets a response to his letter from the new patient safety minister ASAP, as they say. Now, it is an issue that we need to get absolutely right. We know from all our experiences of patients and families about the importance of creating a culture in which concerns can be raised without fear and lessons are learned effectively. The government, we fully agree with these objectives.
Our view is that patient safety, in line with the Dashby review, is best served by clear lines of accountability, effective independent scrutiny, and a relentless focus on learning and improvement. And that's why we're transferring HSIB's functions into the CQC to ensure that learning from investigations can more readily inform improvement activity across the system. Now, we do recognize the importance of ensuring the investigation arm has the autonomy to investigate the qualifying incidents they deem appropriate, free from interference. And I can give insurance that we will work with the executive HSIB and CQC to ensure that their operating model upholds this operational independence. And in response to the honorable lady, the chair of the Health Select Committee, who's not in her place, there is obviously no single metric by which to judge the suitability of the CQC.
It is usual in the department's oversight of arms-length bodies and independent regulators to look for things like, for example, stable leadership, IT capability, governance, operational effectiveness, something I'm sure that the select committee can help and work with us. I am going to press on, there's a lot to get through, apologies. On health inequalities, we are committed to tackling health inequalities wherever they arise. There are strong duties on both ICBs and the Secretary of State to tackle them and we remain firmly committed to doing so. We continue to drive forward improvement plans in the national cancer plan and the mental health strategy.
The mental health strategy will transform mental health care into a system that responds and intervenes earlier, reduces waiting times for support, and ultimately supports people to participate fully in education. And in particular, I should note the government is already making record investment in mental health, and all ICBs are expected to meet the mental health investment standard over the next three years, and all are forecast to meet it for 26-27. We're also committed to delivering the national cancer plan and are focused on driving those improvements, including on diagnostic capacity, which is key to addressing waiting times and tackling variation as we've heard today in access to best treatment as we've heard from the honorable, my friend from Islington, who's commended his work in this area, and the honorable member for Blaydon and Consett. I would, I'm going to just press a little bit if I may. I would remind the House that we are doing this within the existing legal structures.
Our approach is not to add additional duties and additional layers of detail and specificity in primary legislation. I do think we should avoid the temptation to create separate statutory obligations for each condition or patient group, particularly in an age where people are living longer and very often with more than one condition. We should commit to ourselves to tackling inequalities everywhere for everyone. We've also heard again contributions from the Liberal Democrat front bench about corridor care. Now, the government has been consistent.
We're very clear that corridor care is not an acceptable standard of care and should not be normalized. It is our intention to reduce and ultimately eradicate corridor care. And I think it is worth reminding the House that it does not occur everywhere. Some places have made huge steps to avoid it and we want to share that learning. And can I commend particularly that there were zero instances reported in the last reporting from Barnsley Foundation Trust, South Warwickshire Foundation Trust, and the Dudley Group.
However, we must recognize that corridor care is one of the most visible and distressing symptoms of systemic pressures across the urgent and emergency care pathway. And our focus is on taking action now to tackle those underlying pressures. So we're improving patient flow, strengthening discharge arrangements, and investing in urgent and emergency care services. We are providing targeted support to the systems and trusts facing the greatest challenges from corridor care so that improvements can be delivered where they are needed most. And to make sure we can understand where these challenges are, we've already introduced a national definition of corridor care and strengthened reporting and oversight arrangements.
On serious...
Speaker 309
I thank the honorable member for giving way and could I congratulate her on I believe her birthday today, I may be right. Could I say that the NHS trust in North West London recently was found to be one of the most improved in London in terms of reducing the waiting list. Does she agree that all of the changes that she is bringing in as part of this bill, including those discussed today, will help us to bring those waiting lists down even further and also address the issues with corridor care that she has outlined.
Karin Smyth
Well, I thank her for her best wishes and indeed commend the work that she and many other honorable members are doing directly with their trusts to understand the impact of the work that we are doing to bring down those waiting lists and to improve access for patients. And absolutely, as I said, corridor care is a sign of systemic failure in the system. It's unacceptable, I think we've all witnessed it in our local trusts, but it is coming down in places and we want to continue to see that eradicated. On serious childhood illness, can I pay tribute to my friend the member for North East Herefordshire for his championing of families of children suffering from life-threatening illnesses. And I know members on all sides of the house recognize the profound impact that receiving a diagnosis for a life-threatening condition has on a child and their family.
It's vital that all these families feel supported, informed and cared for, and I wholeheartedly recognize that the support they are offered now is often not proactive or joined up, with the onus on families, as he said, to navigate the system and seek that support for themselves. And with this in mind, the government commissioned a report on the mental health impacts of life-threatening childhood illness on families, named in the memory of Hugh Menai-Davis. And I pay tribute to his parents for their campaigning and offer my deepest condolences. The report process is progressing well and today I can commit to a report being published in this parliament with a full government response then issued within three months of publication. For too long, children's health has not been a priority, which is why my honorable friend the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care has directed the department to make maternal and child health central to their work.
We know a child's health has ramifications across the wellbeing of the whole family and there must be better solutions to join up support for parents and unwell children. And I can tell the house that we will also ensure the new cross-government mental health strategy will also address how we better support parents and families, and the government intends to work closely with parents, families and campaigners to provide a workable solution and available support that is more proactive. With regard to the amendments being brought forward from the opposition on new clause 142 and the member for the opposition spokesperson, as ever, government's priority is the safety... I'm going to move forward I think with those amendments in a moment. As she knows well, the provisions are already in place to appropriately control access to puberty-suppressing hormones for children and young people presenting with gender incongruence or dysphoria.
These children and young people with gender incongruence deserve evidence-based care and the Cass review recommended a clinical trial to provide high-quality comparative evidence on the potential benefits and risks of these medicines, and that's underway. And I agree with the comments from the Liberal Democrat spokesperson. I have to disagree with the opposition that uniquely access to these type of medicines must be subject to the scrutiny and approval of parliament, and I think as a clinician she understands that. I would also like to address new clause 143. As the honorable member knows, the EHRC's updated code of practice for services, public functions and associations commenced on the 5th of August.
It provides guidance on how sex-based distinctions in the Equality Act can be applied, including in the NHS. This amendment is unnecessary. It is the law. The law is clear. The NHS will obviously follow the law.
New guidance has been drafted and will be published imminently. And for the record, I am meeting the Darlington nurses that she spoke for. I agree that they were brave. They should not have had to go through what they've had to go through. And I'm meeting them, due to meet them next week.
With regard to funeral regulation, addressing new clause 41 and 42 in the name of the honorable member for Gosport, and I think she spoke very powerfully on behalf of the whole House. I know many honorable members and the work that she has done. I know my friend, the member for Kingston upon Hull West and Hessle, has spoken to me a great deal about that. And I know my friend, the member for Leeds South West and Morley, also has. And the government was appalled by the offenses committed by Robert Bush and the profound harm caused to bereaved families.
Every deceased person must be treated with care, respect, and dignity. And as the House knows, we are undertaking urgent work to develop comprehensive proposals, including formal regulation of the funeral sector, to drive out rogue operators and strengthen protection for bereaved families. As she said, where operators work well, they also want to see this. We will begin sharing proposals shortly, and I'm very happy to include honorable members in these discussions.
Speaker 310
Grateful to her for giving way. Does she accept that the Prime Minister said in July that the sector needed to be regulated and that this continues to be a priority for his government?
Karin Smyth
Absolutely. And I'm committed, as I said, to work with him and many honorable members across the House. On the amendments concerning medicines, I was pleased to meet my honorable friend, the member for Manchester Withington, to discuss his amendments. I hope I reassured him, that I think from his speech, that the government does support well-designed research into innovative treatment using controlled drugs where this is conducted safely and appropriately. And we also understand the complexities involved, including minimizing the risk of harm and misuse.
That's why we're working cross-government to consider how to implement the recommendations from the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs to reduce barriers to research with schedule 1 controlled drugs. And I committed to write to the honorable member to set this out further, which I will do. A number of members also tabled issues about their local infrastructure. I appreciate that we have already published the capital plan. We've improved long-term capital planning to improve local infrastructure.
I think I am almost coming to the end of, I think I've, I think I've addressed most things, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I think I'm afraid, I'm afraid, I'm so sorry, I'll have to talk to the honorable friend later. It has been wide-ranging. If there are things that I have missed, I commit to getting through to people afterwards. And I know that my honorable friend, Baroness Merron, as she proceeds this bill through the House, is committed to working very cooperatively with all members.
Simon Hoare
Order, order. Under the order of the House of the 7th September, I must now put the questions necessary to bring proceedings on consideration to a conclusion. The question is that new clause 94 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. The question is that new clause 94 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to government new clauses 95, 98, 99, 100, and 101. I call the minister to move new clauses 95, 98, 99, 100, and 101 formally. Question is that new clauses 95, 98, 99, 100, and 101 be added to the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. New clause 140 has been selected for separate decision. I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson to move new clause 140 formally.
Simon Hoare
The question is that new clause 140 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
Speaker 314
Division, clear the lobby. The question is that new clause 140 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
The tellers for the ayes are Claire Young and Bobby Dean, the tellers for the noes, Emma Foody and Gregor Poynton.
Simon Hoare
The Ayes to the right were 79, the Noes to the left 300, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. New Clause 142 has been selected for separate decision. I call the Shadow Minister to move New Clause 142 formally. The question is that New Clause 142 be added to the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. Division, clear the lobby. The question is that New Clause 142 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Of the contrary No. The tellers for the Ayes are Sir Ashley Fox and Rebecca Smith, the tellers for the Noes, Emma Foody and Gregor Poynton.
Simon Hoare
The ayes to the right were 108, the noes to the left 357, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. New clause 143 has been selected for separate decision. I call the shadow minister to move new clause 143 formally.
Move formally.
Simon Hoare
The question is that new clause 143 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
Speaker 318
Division, clear the lobby. Is that new clause 143 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
The tellers for the ayes are Rebecca Smith and Sir Ashley Fox, the tellers for the noes, Gregor Poynton and Emma Foody.
Simon Hoare
Order, order. The ayes to the right 106, the noes to the left 302. The ayes to the right were 106, the noes to the left 302, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. Amendment 1 has been selected for separate decision.
I call the Shadow Minister to move the amendment formally. Moved formally. The question is that amendment 1 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no.
Division, clear the lobby. The question is that amendment 1 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The tellers for the ayes are Sir Ashley Fox and Rebecca Smith, the tellers for the noes Emma Foody and Gregor Poynton.
Simon Hoare
The Ayes to the right were 162, the Noes to the left 297, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. I call the Minister to move Government amendments 65 to 69 and 72 to 75 formally.
Formally.
Simon Hoare
The question is that Government amendments 65 to 69 and 72 to 75 be made. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Consideration completed.
Third reading now. Minister to move third reading, Secretary of State Yvette Cooper.
Yvette Cooper
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move the Bill now be read a third time. Let me thank all of those who have been involved in bringing this Bill to this point and all of those who've been involved at committee, the parliamentary staff, the departmental staff and legal staff as well, and on all sides of the House who have debated so many different issues in the course of the passage of this Bill. But let me particularly pay a huge thanks to my honourable friend, the Member for Bristol South, who not only has chaperoned this Bill through every stage from beginning to end, including through some different Health Secretaries along the way, but has also done so and done report stage on her birthday. So a huge happy birthday as well to my honourable friend the Member. And I'm grateful to everybody for the engagement on this and also those who've taken the opportunity as well as debating the issues in the Bill also to use these debates to raise so many issues that are so important to patient care right across the country and to improvements that we need to make to patient and family care, including the parents of little Hughie and Ada Davis who were in the House today.
And I know members on all sides have been raising issues from centre funeral regulation to health inequalities. It is important that our NHS and health systems continue to improve. I will give way to my honourable friend.
Jim Dickson
I thank the Secretary of State very much for giving way. I know time is short. She was talking about the various issues that have come up while the Bill's been debated. One of them is the most common cause of death in the UK, which is dementia. In an amendment I tabled with the Alzheimer's Society, it suggested that we bring the data on dementia, which is scattered right across the health system at the moment, into a single place to drive progress on early diagnosis and treatment.
Would she agree that's an important priority for the Government?
Yvette Cooper
My honourable friend is exactly right to raise this vital issue.
So many of us will have families, constituents who are affected by dementia. We are committed to introducing a dementia tsar as part of our response to Louise Casey's commission, and we will be looking at the data issues and evidence as part of that. But on this legislation that has now completed its passage through this House, I wanted to thank my predecessors as health secretaries for the work they have done, bringing down waiting lists, improving treatment and more appointments than ever before. Thousands more doctors, nurses, midwives, mental health workers, all in place than ever before, for which we thank our National Health Service staff across the country. But they have also recognized we inherited a system that was still badly held back by the failed 2012 Lansley reforms, including the huge administrative and unaccountable bureaucracy with lots of duplication, poor communication and no proper accountability.
That is what this legislation has been about, to strengthen democratic accountability and also the focus on patient care. I should be clear, I pay tribute to the work that has been done by many people across NHS England, including particularly the recent work of the current chief executive, Jim Mackey, working to substantially improve patient care and to reduce that duplication. But the systems and structures have been holding people back. So that is why we have brought this reform forward, and that is why we will be, as part of this, ending not just the wasteful duplication, but making sure that our NHS system is better able to deliver. I will update the House and the NHS shortly on the future operating arrangements.
Let me say now that it means returning to some of the arrangements that applied before 2012, when we had strong national NHS leadership, but with much greater partnership and accountability and far less duplication than we have today. And I have been frank with both department and NHS England that the focus needs to be on patients. We are making some further reforms in response to the discussions in this House. I have made a commitment we will bring forward in the House of Lords amendments to establish England's first statutory maternity commissioner, implementing the Amos review's recommendation, but also directly reflecting the work and determination of my honorable friend, the member for Sherwood Forest, the government's national maternity advisor, and I thank her for the work that she has done. We've also amended the bill to ensure local government is represented on ICBs, something raised by the select committee.
And I am also clear, we need to ensure patients' voices are properly embedded in decision making. And of course, members have all debated the importance of the single patient record to improve care. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is great to be back at this dispatch box as a health minister. Twenty-four years since I last spoke at the dispatch box as a health minister. I am surprised at and in many ways at how little has changed.
But the one thing that has not changed, that is so immensely important to all of us, is the dedication of NHS staff and the people who work right across the country to support patients, to support communities. This is about helping them to make sure they can do their jobs in the most effective way. I commend this bill to the House.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. Shadow Secretary of State, Damian Hinds.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State back, as it were. It is the Commons' third reading of this bill, and she is the third Secretary of State for this bill. It was about forty minutes after the first reading that the right honorable member for Ilford resigned. I wonder which bit he had just spotted then.
But we wish her well, and not only because of her East Hampshire heritage. There will be times when we disagree entirely.
There will be times when we find commonality. But at all of those times, it is our job to scrutinize the government in the interests of the public and on behalf of the dedicated professionals and other staff in these most vital of sectors. It's also my first opportunity, Madam Deputy Speaker, to pay tribute to my predecessor in this role, the right honorable member for Daventry. He took on that responsibility in the very finest traditions of this House. He had and has the respect and admiration across the House, and I know his approach has also been much appreciated by so many working in and in support of health and social care.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this has been a big bill, and I want to thank the Public Bill Committee for all the work they've done. I want to particularly thank my honorable friend from Sleaford and North Hykeham, my honorable friend from Farnham and Bordon as the whip, now shadow shadow minister, and for everybody on that committee. We will not divide at third reading because there are important things in this bill that we support, but there is a great deal of concern. A huge IT project with no detail behind it as yet should put a shiver down any incoming minister's back when they hear they've been bequeathed a large public sector IT transformation project. Taking oversight out and putting it inside the body it is meant to oversee, removing patient voice, and most of all, an enormous top-down reorganization of the NHS.
There have already been 10 of those since 1974. If the answer to the NHS's problems was a top-down reorganization, maybe one of the previous ones would have worked. But whatever the outcome, whatever this legislation ends up being, I know the House of Lords, the other place, will be scrutinizing it closely. We will scrutinize its implementation and what difference it in the end actually makes for patients.
Simon Hoare
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Before we move on to the remaining orders, the front bench might want to swap over.
Motion number four on licenses and licensing. Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Simon Hoare
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number five on building and buildings.
Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Simon Hoare
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number six on disclosure of information.
Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Simon Hoare
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to motion number seven relating to a joint committee on the draft conversion practices bill.
Minister to move.
Not moved.
Peter Bedford
Not moved. Petition, Mr. Peter Bedford.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Further to my online petition, which to date has received over 9,000 signatures, I rise to present this paper petition against the expansion of the local government boundaries of Leicester City Council. Prior to the summer recess, the government announced proposals for local government reorganization in Leicestershire. These plans would have placed the villages of Anstey, Birstall, Cropston, Glenfield, Kirby Muxloe, Leicester Forest East, Thurcaston, Braunstone Town, and Fort Ashby within the City Council area. And whilst I welcome yesterday's announcement by the government, the 9,000 residents who have signed this petition have made their views crystal clear.
They want this to be a permanent pause. They do not support an enlarged Leicester City Council area. Therefore, the petitioners request that the House of Commons urges the government to halt and reconsider any proposals for the expansion of Leicester City Council's boundaries and ensure that the views of local residents are fully considered before any changes are implemented, thereby protecting their character, identity, and independence of the aforementioned communities, and the petitioners remain, etcetera.
Mims Davies
Petition, Mims Davies.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to present this petition on behalf of 563 constituents from East Grinstead, Uckfield, and the surrounding villages, as well as a further 1,364 people who have signed online. For over five years, the Copthorne Hotel has housed asylum seekers, depriving the community of both a local employer and a much-used and much-loved community space. Since 2023, my constituents have seen other hotels opened for asylum accommodation close before the Copthorne Hotel. There is a palpable sense of frustration within the community.
They have played their part, and the length of time this arrangement has continued is simply unacceptable. My constituents urgently want clarity on when this hotel will close. The prayer of the petition is as follows. The petitions of the residents of the constituency of East Grinstead and Uckfield declares that the Copthorne Hotel in Copthorne should be returned to its former use as a major local employer, valuable Gatwick Airport accommodation, and a highly valued community hub in line with the Mid Sussex District Council motion passed in September 2025. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to facilitate the return of the Copthorne Hotel, used as an asylum accommodation for the last six years, to its original and proper use at the earliest opportunity and before the current planning permission expires, and the petitions remain, etcetera.
Simon Hoare
The question is that this House do now adjourn. Simon Hoare.
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And just from the outset, can I just say what a pleasure it is to see the honorable lady, my good friend, the member for Vauxhall and Camberwell, in her place replying to this debate. The whole House was delighted to see her promotion in the recent reshuffle, long overdue, and I look forward to a housey reply to this debate to work out the benchmark for her appearances on future occasions.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the weight of documentation I hold in my hands this evening will give the House some indication I think of the weight of the problem that the organization and the management and the organization if you will of the retirement property management companies present to many of our constituents across the country. My remarks are principally motivated by the pretty lamentable behavior of a company called Cognatum that runs three facilities in my North Dorset constituency, that's Home Farm in Ewan Minster, Castle Gardens in Shaftesbury and Walpole Court in Puddletown. And I have had constituents from those three come to see me on many occasions and write and email with a growing list of concerns which seem to go absolutely ignored. And they shouldn't take it I think particularly personally because Cognatum has been presenting problems in other constituencies too. The honorable gentleman for Surrey Heath and for Honiton and Sidmouth and I met them some little while ago to talk through the concerns that our constituents were sharing with us.
They listened, they met and then they wrote to us to say well thank you very much indeed we will never meet you again everything in the garden is rosy we don't recognize the evidence that you have given us. There is a real problem here and government needs to act. And I think unfortunately I think I may be correct in highlighting a point that my constituent Jean Wilkinson raised, a resident of one of the Cognatum properties. She wrote to me and I read as follows: it is also important to highlight that a significant number of residents are elderly and in poor health. As a result, many do not feel able to raise concerns or advocate for themselves.
This creates a situation where important issues risk being overlooked and where residents feel they do not have a sufficient voice. If the honorable gentleman will forgive me. I have had a number of emails from across the country and from other constituents who effectively mirror and echo that point. And I know Madam Deputy Speaker you too have had issues albeit with a different company in your constituency as well we were talking about that earlier in the day. I think too many of these property management companies view their residents as elderly cash cows.
People who have worked hard, saved hard. They want to be independent in their older years and they don't want to have a huge amount of fuss and bother. They actually just want a quiet, peaceful, dignified, sensible, grown-up sort of a life. And as one gets older I am certain that you become a little less bullish in challenging authority and questioning and anything for a quiet life if the service charges go up, if the management charges go up, they're not given a particularly clear explanation, they're not given a very cogent argument to support it, well I'll just write the check and pay because it's the line of least resistance. And I'm absolutely convinced that that is now a deep-set and ingrained way in how a lot of these companies are operating.
I'll give way to the honorable gentleman for Bridgwater.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way. He is setting out a compelling case for how these providers of retirement homes and accommodation are letting people down and the real absence of redress that a lot of these residents have.
Does he agree with me that this is something where we desperately need more regulation and oversight and the government needs to take action to that effect?
Simon Hoare
I agree fundamentally with the honorable gentleman on that and I will come onto that in a moment because there are two very specific areas which I think require attention. But Cognatum doesn't get off scot-free because they have the doggedly determined constituent Peter Wintle who lives in Home Farm of Ewelme and Minster, who has cogently and sensibly asked questions over the years of Cognatum to be met with very little in reply. The issues that Peter raises with me on behalf of those residents and they are echoed by others is the absence of management transparency, a key and important thing. Accountability of the companies involved. The lack of clear communication that sets out in easily digestible form information which residents require.
Openness on finance, explaining why service charges go up, explaining why certain repairs or maintenance are being done in a certain way. A lackadaisical and tardy attitude in responding to issues and complaints raised by residents, things which would not be, should not be expected. A complaint system not worthy of the name and in the case of Cognatum because of the way that they organize themselves, unaudited accounts which make it incredibly hard for anybody to follow the line on the balance sheet. I give way to the honorable gentleman because no adjournment debate would be complete without the honorable gentleman for Strangford.
Jim Shannon
Thank you very much. Can I commend the honorable gentleman for North Dorset for bringing this forward? Vulnerable retirees in Strangford, my constituency, are mirroring the very anxieties that the honorable gentleman has referred to. While we don't have the ground rent act for Northern Ireland, it lacks a statutory cap on ground rent, unable to regulate the runaway management and event fees levied by private firms. So does the honorable member not agree that our elderly populations, my elderly constituents in Strangford, regardless of which corner of the United Kingdom they reside in, deserve uniform financial protections and safety from predatory management practices?
Simon Hoare
Well, I agree and I think that speaks back to the point I was making a moment or so ago that I think too many of these companies see their residents as a soft or easy touch, that they will just suck it up, that they will just as I say write the check. And I give way to my honorable friend from Bromsgrove, of course.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
I thank my honorable friend for giving way and for calling this adjournment debate. Does he agree with me that there's a particular predatory aspect upon the death of a resident who's occupied one of these properties? I'd like to use this moment if I can pay tribute to Alex Roll, a constituent of mine whose mother's estate has been, well, crawled all over by predatory management companies that have seen an opportunity to effectively seize the asset of someone who worked tirelessly through their life. This system urgently needs reform. It is desperate for reform.
Simon Hoare
I agree again with my honorable friend and his constituent Alex Roll has been in contact with me via Facebook and I take the point that my honorable friend makes on her behalf and that she makes on behalf of countless others, which is these companies are inclined to effectively both, I suppose, hunt with the hounds and run with the hare at the same time. If somebody dies, if the property is then up for sale and sometimes the resale because of restrictive covenants that can be quite a slow and difficult business, not only do they receive a fairly significant clawback at the point of sale, but they are also demanding service charges to be paid whilst the property is vacant and or whilst probate is awaited.
So they're really trying to milk it from both ends. And that just doesn't, I think, stack up in the court of public opinion, if you will, as being fair or justifiable, because one should be able to say, right, this property is vacant, we will not levy the service charge, that will effectively be included in the clawback that we get at the point of sale, because clearly there is no resident in that property using the services. I give way to the honorable lady for Wells and Mendip Hills. I was going to say Mendip Hills and Wells, but yes.
Tessa Munt
Thank you. I thank the honorable gentleman very much indeed. I just wanted to point out exactly that. I've a constituent whose property's been on the market since 2022. The landlord chooses whom the new owner will be.
The adult members of the family who are struggling to get onto the property ladder can't go on because they're not over 55. And the landlord won't allow the property to be rented out, even though it rents its properties out on the same site. And they are absolutely banjaxed. There's an exit fee as well. It is absolutely catastrophic.
And I wonder whether the honorable gentleman would agree with me that this is just opportunistic profiteering at the expense of people who are vulnerable. And actually, when people have died, the families are really catastrophically affected.
Simon Hoare
The honorable lady expresses it very well, and I agree with her assessment entirely. I think it is the age and vulnerability of many, the anything for the quiet life, which is being exploited to the max. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I did say that I did want to mention very specifically, and in this campaign he is very much my honorable friend, the member for Surrey Heath, who has been working very closely on the issues with regards to Cognatum. He has Mitchett Heath in his constituency, and the issues which are being raised by his residents mirror mine, and it's not a pretty picture. And I give way to the honorable lady for Lancaster.
Florence Eshalomi
The honorable gentleman's very kind. I wanted to say just to say that I'm very much aware in my constituency, I've got a property called Williamson Court, which is run by McCarthy Stone, and everything that other colleagues are saying sounds very familiar. So does the honorable gentleman have any sense of the scale of this right across the country? Because it strikes me that we represent very different parts of the UK in this chamber, and does he have any sense of the scale of this problem?
Simon Hoare
I think it manifests itself in all quarters of the United Kingdom, but not all companies are culpable. This is a, as the campaign is on the regulation of the funeral sector, it's the rotten apples in the barrel that give the whole sector a bad name, and it's them to whom and against attention should be. He will forgive me because we want to hear from the minister. Issues with regards to Cognatum, I'm told that it and its subsidiaries claim small companies exemptions, meaning that there are no independent audits and the directors control the financial disclosures. Inconsistent and exceptional accounting items suggest financial irregularities.
The company operates on a going concern basis despite significant intercompany debts, and the auditors do not sign the reported financial statements, raising accountability concerns. This suggests, as the honorable lady and others have suggested, the need for regulation. So, what am I to ask of the minister?
The first is to have a thorough assessment of the effectiveness and the independence, or rather lack thereof, of the Association of Retirement Housing Managers. They are populated by current operators in the main. Effectively, colleagues being asked to mark other colleagues' homework. And that I don't think is sustainable or desirable. I think that needs looking at.
A number of my constituents believe that there is a rather lackadaisical approach to following the requirements of section 20 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. And I know the government has been doing some work around that and would be interested to hear what the minister has to say. But in closing, I'm grateful to colleagues from across the House who have supported me in this endeavour. And I pay tribute again to the honourable gentleman for Surrey Heath and for Honiton and Sidmouth for the work that the three of us have been doing with regards to Cognatum. We did say that there would be an adjournment debate if they weren't prepared to engage and try to pull up their socks and improve their operation and the service that they give to their residents.
So this is a debate really and literally of their own making. But it is a sector I think which has grown up quite quickly. It is still quite novel in this country. I think people are still finding their way and probably we're only on about first or second generation of residents who are learning and experiencing the pitfalls of both resale and some of the clawback issues there, but also the lack of accountability which exists in the management and the maintenance of many of these places where people live, where they've chosen to live, where they have invested a significant sum of their money so that they can live a retired life in dignity. And oh so briefly, let me...
Thomas Gordon
I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. The situation he outlines and describes is somewhat analogous to what we see with park homes. The park homes are a requirement for a fit and proper person test with the local authority regulating. Does he think this might be something that would suit perhaps this situation he outlines?
Simon Hoare
That's a very good suggestion. And I think anything has to be better than the status quo because the status quo I do not believe is either defensible or indeed desirable. The honourable gentleman's been frankly patient, so I am going to give way to him.
Warinder Juss
I thank the honourable member for giving way. I have a 92-year-old constituent, Freda Quinton, who has not been able to live in her retirement property since April because despite repeated assurances that the persistent and unresolved leaks would be repaired, they have not been repaired. And this means that my constituent can't live independently. And she now has health concerns, emotional distress, and financial pressures. Does the honourable member agree that this is absolutely no way to treat older residents and it's a problem that exists with not only the management company he is referring to but other management companies as well?
Simon Hoare
I agree. And I think there is a common theme coming through here, which is the age, the vulnerability, the anything for the quiet life, the are we empowered to ask questions, we're not maybe digitally alert. Some bigwig from a company comes along and attends a meeting. In the case of Cognatum, they tell us, well don't worry Mr Hall, Dr Pinkerton, Mr Ford, don't worry, we have a tenant representative on the board. And how is the tenant representative chosen?
It's chosen by the board of Cognatum, not elected by fellow residents at all.
So a poacher chooses another poacher potentially to mark their own homework. But I think it is because of this vulnerability, this anything for a quiet life, this are we empowered to ask questions? And indeed, one of my constituents, and this was really the tipping point for me, one of my constituents asking perfectly legitimate questions in a perfectly civil way finds on his doormat a letter from Cognatum's solicitors saying we think you are being vexatious and we are considering your lease arrangements. Effectively saying ask any more questions sunshine and you're out on your ear. This gentleman is over 80.
I don't think that is the right and proper way to treat anybody. And I think all of that, the case that the honourable gentleman has raised is a distressing one, obviously causing concern to him and to his constituent and to their friends and family. The comments and observations made in this debate I hope have convinced the minister that the status quo cannot continue and that whilst we all call for sort of a light regulatory approach etcetera, this is a particular area of operation, grown swiftly, grown autonomously, which is now crying out for better reform. And the reform of the association and the rigorous enforcement of the section of the act which I've quoted would be a good starting point. Minister, Florence Eshalomi.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and may I start by congratulating the right honourable gentleman for North Dorset for securing this debate and for his kind remarks on my appointment. And I have very fond memories of shadowing the honourable gentleman in opposition and I know that he has a breadth of knowledge across MHCLG and this is an issue that's close to his heart. Can I also thank other members for their contributions this evening. I want to start Madam Deputy Speaker by reassuring the right honourable gentleman that this is an area that I have been looking at and although this sits with my colleague Minister Pennycook, I'm responding tonight but I will be feeding back to him on these key issues. I think the contributions tonight highlights the really important area and if we're honest the many challenges that leaseholders and especially elderly leaseholders are facing right across the country with management companies.
I think the flagrant disregard for people who've worked so hard to be able to secure their property and have that independent living and I think the honourable gentleman highlighted the key areas where management companies continue to let people down. Issues around transparency, accountability, communication, responding to issues, raising complaints, audited accounts, these are basic things that management companies should be doing. And I think about the fact that for many elderly leaseholders, if they don't have a network of family support helping them navigate this, it can feel as honourable member for Bromsgrove highlighted predatory because when you are receiving those letters with demands, it can be quite scary. We really recognize the hugely important role and I think there is a role that older people's housing sector plays in ensuring that people do have that independence in later life. We want to be able to make sure we are keeping people out of hospital and that can only happen if they have a safe and secure home of their own to go back to.
And the government is really committed to enhancing the provisions and choice across the residential market including for older people and that means both increasing the supply of home for older people and most importantly improving the experience of older people in their own homes. And I think many residents of retirement homes have made a financial and personal in some cases significant contribution to their homes and they should have the confidence that when they raise valid concerns they should be addressed promptly, they should be addressed in a timely manner. When they challenge bad practice they should get a response and they shouldn't have to come to their members of parliament that we are seeing so many people resorting to raising issues.
We are seeing parliamentarians having to name and shame management companies until any action is taken. That should not be the way that things are happening. I will give way.
Paul William Forster
I want to thank the minister for giving way and I'm delighted to see her in her place. She, I'm sure, will remember that the select committee recently scrutinized the Leasehold Reform Bill. We found it wanting. It didn't go far or far enough. And the solution to the problems outlined in this debate is to properly regulate property managing agents, especially those that run vulnerable elderly retirement homes.
So does she agree with me that the Leasehold Reform Bill needs to come back urgently with that regulation?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the honorable gentleman and hope that the select committee is going very well. And he will know that this is an issue that we championed on the select committee to the point where, if he will recall, I in many senses harassed the former Prime Minister and the Minister for Housing to say when we will see this bill. This bill has to come before the House. It's an issue that comes up in many parliamentarians' inbox. It's a cross-party issue and we want to see the government enact on that and make good on that commitment.
And I just want to highlight that there are many good managing agents out there. This is not about saying that the issue of managing agents is all bad. There are good managing agents who are responsible, who respond on time, who are responsible for safe and secure homes for their residents. But we know that far too often the poor managing agents and unscrupulous managing agents let the sector down. Managing agents play an important role in the maintenance of a wide range of multi-occupancy buildings and freeholder estates.
Their importance will only increase as we transition towards a commonhold future. So it's essential that we take action to drive up the standards within the sector. As honorable members will know, and the minister and the honorable gentleman will know, the previous government committed to regulating managing agents in 2018 and asked a working group chaired by the noble Lord Best to advise them how to do that. Yet it failed to respond to the group's final report, which was published in July 2019. But we've moved on from that.
It's about how do we now take those recommendations and actually bring an outcome for so many people. And the government is ready to take forward a number of those recommendations. The retirement sector has some specific arrangements in place. Many retirement housing managing agents already operate under the Association of Retirement Housing Managers' code of practice, which sets the standards on transparency and complaints handling. But as we've heard this evening, that doesn't seem to be working.
And it's about how we make sure that we are enforcing some of these key areas. Elsewhere in the sector, a similar consumers' protection standard is promoted through the Association of Retirement Community Operators' consumer code for its members. And I stress again, we recognize the concerns remains in parts of the sector and how we can protect consumers and residents to strengthen that and have a consistent approach. In the recent consultation on strengthening leaseholder protections over charges and services, we consulted on powers to appoint a manager or replace the managing agent, as well as mandatory professional qualifications for managing agents in England. The government will be consulting under introduction qualifications for estate and letting agents next year.
We have also made clear that we plan to introduce a code of practice this year setting out the minimum standards expected of all residential property agents, and this includes estates, lettings, and managing agents. The government is considering Lord Best's report in full and we will set out our overarching position on regulation of estates, letting and managing agents in due course, but this has to come at a timely pace.
I will give way.
Thomas Gordon
I thank the minister for giving way. I mentioned earlier in response to the member for North Dorset about how this is analogous in some sense to the issues that park home faces face. Whilst there is a fit and proper person test in that instance, quite often it is lacking and not the tightening regulation that people had hoped for. What lessons will she learn, will she bring forward having learned from those experiences to ensure we get proper regulation that's got teeth that will work?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank the honourable member for Didcot and Wantage... Harrogate. See, nearly right. My apologies. I think that's an issue that I'll definitely be forwarding, I've taken a note of that and I will forward that to the housing minister in terms of a proper response to him. I'll give way.
Tessa Munt
Thank the minister for giving way. When she says managing agents, does she mean management companies, a bit like FirstPort, the lamentable service of organisations like FirstPort? And I mean, one of the retirement buildings in my patch, they've just been offered repainting of their windows for £240,000. I think it works out at over £5,000 per flat. I mean, this is just for the birds, it's absolutely bonkers.
So I just wanted to be sure that they will be captured within the legislation she proposes.
Florence Eshalomi
I can reassure the honourable lady that FirstPort continues to come up regularly, and I had the pleasure in my former role as the chair of the select committee scrutinising and questioning the managing director and chief exec of FirstPort. And the honourable lady will be aware that the housing minister also mentioned FirstPort and held important meetings with FirstPort, but there are other managing agents as well that we should not let off the hook, although FirstPort have a large share of properties across the country. The honourable gentleman mentioned the consultation on section 20. I think this is a key issue that the government have been looking at, so I just wanted to comment on that. And I know that the government consulted on that last year, and my understanding is that the government will be setting out the response in due course, and this is something again that I will push the housing minister on his behalf on in making sure we come back to that in a timely manner.
I also wanted to highlight the experiences that other honourable members have raised on behalf of their constituents, and I think it is important that we continue to share these really valid examples in showing why we need to move at pace in terms of regulating this really important area. We recognise that the pre-leg scrutiny into the commonhold and leasehold recommended a number of measures in terms of extending requirement to retirement providers, and we will consider that as part of our work. I'm very happy to say that there was a good member of parliament who led on that pre-leg scrutiny. And to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm grateful to many honourable members for coming to the House this evening for an opportunity to debate this really important issue. I thank members who've participated in this debate today for sharing those insights and most importantly sharing the lived examples and concerns that many residents continue to face.
We continue to see people worried about when another bill or letter comes through the door, what they're going to be asked and demanded for, when they're worried when they don't respond to those letters being issued with court and threatening letters. It's really important that we do address this in terms of the emotional, physical, mental impact it's not just the financial impact it's having on very vulnerable residents. So I just want to thank all members for engaging with this, and I look forward to working with them, and I know that the honourable minister as well for housing and planning will also be engaging further with members.
Speaker 340
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.