Westminster Hall

20 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:11 - 00:16
Speaker 1
Order, order.  I call Richard Quigley to move the motion. 
00:16 - 00:42
Speaker 3
I beg to move that this House has considered manufacturing skills.  Thank you, Chair, and may I say what a sublime pleasure it is to serve under your superb chairmanship.  I must begin by thanking my honourable friend the member for Derby South, who due to his giddy elevation to PPS has allowed me to hijack his debate and talk about the Isle of Wight.  Derby has also quite rightly received a lot of focus, so now it is our turn.  While I will of course continue to argue that the Isle of Wight does best at everything, it would be unfair of me not to recognise what Derby does exceptionally well. 
00:42 - 00:57
Speaker 2
Whether it is trains, aerospace or the development of small modular reactors, coupled with the exciting Team Derby initiative announced in last year's budget, it is a city that demonstrates the value of bringing together industry, skills and investment to drive growth.  Now, I'll give way. 
00:57 - 01:42
Speaker 5
Indeed I will.  As an MP for Derby, or as our Prime Minister called it, the great city of Derby, we have a city that is famous for its advanced manufacturing and engineering skills, and our largest employers like Alstom, Rolls-Royce and Toyota are able to invest in skills through apprenticeships.  And just last week, Great British Railways, which will have its headquarters in Derby city centre, announced up to 600 new apprenticeships.  But would my honourable friend agree with me that what we need is even more government focus on enabling and supporting smaller manufacturers to invest and train up new apprenticeships to address the skills shortages that we have across the country? 
01:42 - 01:58
Speaker 2
I thank my honourable friend for her intervention, and the great city of Derby has two great MPs.  And I totally agree entirely with her point, the more we can do for small businesses to encourage them to take on apprentices, but anything that takes people that wouldn't go down the university route through a set of skills and into paid good paid work is is absolutely ideal.  I will indeed. 
01:58 - 02:25
Speaker 4
I thank my honourable friend for giving way.  We see a challenge in my region where foreign direct investment comes in, builds a big factory, hoovers up the existing skilled workforce from local SMEs and there isn't the pipeline there to replace them.  So does he agree with me that it's really important that regional government takes on a role working with the FE sector and employers to ensure that there's a proper joined-up skills system so we're not just bringing in new business but we're supporting our existing SMEs as well? 
02:25 - 04:42
Speaker 2
I thank my honourable friend's intervention, it's a really good point.  On the Isle of Wight we have we send 25% of our school leavers to university, but also exactly 25% end up as NEETs.  Now the amount of effort that goes in the structure and support around getting to university, you can see you can see how to get to university from the moon, but we don't put the same structure around those that would end up not going to university, so it's a very good point that we need to encourage homegrown skills.  Now, I know some of you will be used to hearing me complain about the everyday inequalities islanders face.  Don't worry, I'm not going to mention ferries, however today is a welcome opportunity to celebrate an area where the island truly punches above its weight, and that is in the advanced manufacturing sector. 

Per capita, the Isle of Wight has one of the highest concentrations of technology and advanced manufacturing businesses in the country relative to our population.  What is particularly exciting is that we are showing no signs of slowing down.  New investment, growing businesses and the development of future skills are helping to ensure that the Isle of Wight remains at the forefront of advanced manufacturing for years to come.  Far from being a peripheral economy, the island is helping to shape the industries of the future and proving that innovation can thrive in every corner of the country.  Take shipbuilding as an example. 

Once seen as a traditional industry, it is now a showcase for advanced manufacturing, and yet again is an industry in which the island excels.  At Wight Shipyard, aluminium welding skills are among the best in the world, while Diverse Marine combines that craftsmanship with cutting-edge design and innovation to produce vessels that are lighter, more space-efficient and use less fuel. 

That success is built on the achievements of island businesses who are leading the way in advanced manufacturing.  Companies such as Vestas are helping to power the UK's transition to clean energy through the manufacture of wind turbine blades, while GKN Aerospace and BAE continues the island's proud tradition of high-value engineering and world-class aerospace expertise.  Johnson Electric develops and manufactures precision motion technologies that are integrated into products used by millions of people around the world, and Rheinmetall's specialist vision systems provide advanced capabilities for defence and security operations across the globe.  Then there is Inflight Peripherals Limited, a company whose design innovation reaches millions of people every year.  If you've ever sat in an aircraft cabin and plugged your headphones or device into an in-seat power module, there's a good chance you've experienced a piece of Isle of Wight manufacturing without even realizing it. 

04:42 - 04:52

Speaker 2

These businesses demonstrate that the Isle of Wight is not just preserving industrial heritage, it is helping to define the future of advanced manufacturing and innovation in the UK.

04:52 - 05:32

Speaker 9

He mentions some fantastic local businesses in his area leading the way on the transition to clean power and net zero. Crewe and Nantwich is home to Bentley Motors, one of the area's largest manufacturing employers. The company has recently announced 93 early careers opportunities, including 29 apprenticeships, 15 graduate positions and 49 industrial placements, and that shows that they're investing directly in the skills of the next generation of workers. I wonder if my honourable friend would agree with me that employers like Bentley are demonstrating the kind of long-term commitment to skills that we need to see across the country.

05:32 - 06:55

Speaker 2

I thank my honourable friend, whose intervention is entirely correct. You know, companies like Bentley offer really good hands-on skills that can be transferred anywhere, and if they need someone to test-drive one of their vehicles on the Isle of Wight, say, for a while, I'm your person. Across the Isle of Wight, manufacturers are developing specialist composites, marine technologies and precision-engineered products that are exported all around the world. These businesses do not just create jobs, they create highly skilled careers, drive innovation and demonstrate that world-class manufacturing can thrive in the UK, and especially on the Isle of Wight. Indeed, earlier this year, I was proud to welcome the climate minister, the honourable member for Leeds North West, to the Isle of Wight, where we visited Vestas and saw first-hand the world-leading manufacturing taking place on our doorstep, and how the island can help lead the way as the country makes the green energy transition.

But what excited me even more was the announcement of the new Large Structures Innovation Centre, backed by the National Composites Centre, the High Value Manufacturing Catapult and the University of Bristol. The centre will be an open-access national facility dedicated to developing, demonstrating and industrializing large high-performance structures with an initial focus on next-generation wind energy. The significance of this goes far beyond the investment itself. If we want Britain to remain a leader in advanced manufacturing, we need a pipeline of highly skilled engineers, technicians, fabricators and composite specialists who can turn innovation into commercial success.

06:55 - 07:32

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

I thank my honourable friend for giving way and making an excellent contribution to this debate, and indeed for taking on the debate. In Derby, apprentices at Alstom, as we've heard, are making a huge difference, not just for their own futures but for the rail industry across the UK. But when I speak to manufacturers, over half tell me that the shortage in the skills pipeline is their biggest limiting factor for growth. So would he agree with me that having more apprentices throughout their early years is a key way of building or reducing that skills gap and helping economic growth?

07:32 - 10:03

Speaker 2

I thank my honourable friend for the great city of Derby for his intervention and his very good point, back to the point about university or not university. I think even just before apprenticeships, work experience and getting people to cross the threshold of these employers is an important step to providing the skills we need for the future.

We have facilities such as the Isle of Wight's CECAMM centre at the heart of that effort, giving young people and adult learners the chance to develop the cutting-edge manufacturing and engineering and technical skills that employers need. For the Isle of Wight, it's further proof that advanced manufacturing is not just part of our economy, it is a cornerstone of our future, creating highly skilled jobs and providing opportunities for the next generation. And for me, that is one of the most important parts of this debate. Our skills future matters. We must ensure that no young person is left behind or constrained by that outdated assumption that university or academia is the only viable route forward.

Just two weeks ago, my office hosted its second annual skills summit where we brought together island employers, educational institutions and training providers to discuss how we ensure that local people have the skills needed for the jobs being created on their doorstep. Because there is little value in securing new investment and new manufacturing opportunities if young people are not equipped to take advantage of them. But we need to make sure we invest in the future of this manufacturing ambition. Apprenticeship starts in engineering and manufacturing have fallen by more than 40% and many manufacturers still can't access the training they need. That is why this government's investment in vocational education, apprenticeships and manufacturing matters.

It sends a clear message that there is more than one route to success. A young person on the island who is perhaps unsure whether they want to take the conventional university path should be able to look at our thriving manufacturing sector and think, there is a career there for me. They should be able to see world-leading businesses on the Isle of Wight and know that they do not have to leave the island to build a highly skilled, rewarding career. And that is what makes this government's emphasis on investing in manufacturing and vocational education so exciting. But it's also why we must move further and faster.

After 14 years of chronic underinvestment in both advanced manufacturing and the opportunities available to young people, there is significant ground to make up. If we want Britain to lead in the industries of the future, we need to invest not only in factories, facilities and innovation, but in the people who will design, build and operate them. The success of advanced manufacturing on the Isle of Wight shows what is possible when talent is given the opportunity to thrive. Our challenge now is to ensure that every young person across the country can see a pathway into those careers, access to the training, apprenticeships and technical education needed to get there. Because... I will and then I will, yeah.

10:03 - 10:33

Shockat Patel

I'm so... I really appreciate the honorable member giving way, especially as he's making a very powerful speech. Does he agree with me that the skills shortage can sometimes start with the lack of procurement? So for example, factories in my constituency of Leicester South, which used to clothe the world and the second most prosperous city in Europe because of its textile industry, has gone from 1,500 factories to 96 because we are... we don't have the procurement and they don't want the investments into their factories then giving opportunities for skilled workers.

10:33 - 10:45

Speaker 2

I thank my honorable friend for his intervention and I couldn't agree more. I think the idea that we can move everything offshore because it's cheaper, we're forgetting what value looks like. And if you look at models of community wealth building around the country and around the world, procurement is where you start.

10:45 - 11:09

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

The members in Gorton and Denton tell me that they often have to spend two to three years on a course before they can even think about being considered for an apprenticeship. And Make UK reports that 39% of manufacturers don't think our education system can deliver the skills that they need. So does he agree that we need to make apprenticeships more accessible and flexible so that people aren't held back from skilled jobs and so that manufacturers can get the workers that they desperately need?

11:09 - 11:49

Speaker 2

I thank the honorable member for her intervention and I think, you know, the Isle of Wight and the North share a lot in common is that we don't often get the focus we've needed. And I think the point of... back to my point about we know how to get to university, that's a very structured route, even if you don't get your grades, we'll get you into university, the whole school will get you into university. The other side of it is like your options are just go off to a further education college if you're lucky. So I agree entirely with her point.

Our challenge now is to ensure that every young person across the country can see a pathway into those careers, access the training, apprenticeships, and technical education needed to get there. Because investing in manufacturing is only half the job. Investing in the skills that power it is what turns ambition into long-term economic success.

11:49 - 11:57

Speaker 6

The question is that this House has considered manufacturing skills. Jim Shannon.

11:57 - 13:48

Jim Shannon

A real pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. A special thanks to the honourable gentleman for the West for raising the debate and for setting the scene incredibly well as he often does. And I wish him well in the work that he does for his constituents. I think they can say honestly that his constituents are very fortunate to have him as their MP and I wish him well. Manufacturing is a cornerstone of the United Kingdom.

This may be in jeopardy of crumbling as young people are not entering the sector in sufficient numbers as against workers leaving the industry. So that's the background to the debate. I'll always give a perspective of Northern Ireland and hopefully it adds to the debate and where we are. And I've an ask of the Minister as well. Employment in the advanced manufacturing sector is set to rise, with projected growth of 13% between 2025 and 2035.

This is in addition to an estimated 101,000 workers expected to leave manufacturing priority occupations, bringing the total demand to around 148,000 workers. A lot of people to get trained and get prepared for work. And part of this is because the manufacturing sector has a largely ageing workforce when compared with the wider working population. Reports found that some in 2026 found that some 50% of engineering and manufacturing small to medium enterprises report experiencing skills gaps and or shortages. This comes despite government support efforts as nearly three quarters of businesses surveyed felt support to address skills shortages were lacking.

This is largely unsurprising as there's been no increase in funding for engineering apprenticeships since 2020. I know government the last few days has indicated so perhaps the Minister can tell us more about what's happening. This is the very definition of unsustainable and the quality of products will undoubtedly be affected. Happy to give way.

13:48 - 14:16

Gideon Amos

I'm extremely grateful to the honourable gentleman for giving way. Would my honourable friend agree that in terms of developing those engineering courses, colleges need more support? At the present they receive no funding at all to develop a new course, as University College Somerset have found to cater for the new Agratas factory. And they have to find their own investment to develop courses and receive no funding until those courses actually started, which really hampers innovation, hampers new training, and hampers new skills being developed.

14:16 - 15:03

Jim Shannon

I thank the honourable gentleman for the intervention and the Minister's listening intently and I'm sure the Minister will be able to respond to the honourable gentleman and encourage him and indeed encourage us all because that's the purpose of being here. The issue is not unique to Northern Ireland. I'm going to speak about Northern Ireland now. However, skills shortages will be felt particularly acutely there. Northern Ireland boasts of major manufacturers such as Spirit AeroSystems, Wrightbus, Harland & Wolff, and Thales.

And Thales is one of the defence sectors that the honourable member for Belfast East and myself go to at least once every year, primarily I go because the majority of the workers at Thales come from Strangford, from my constituency. And I ensure that they're there. But they also are encouragement from Thales has been that when it comes to encouraging apprenticeships, that every year they set a target of apprenticeships and they're always oversubscribed when it comes to that. Happy to give way.

15:03 - 15:21

Gregory Campbell

Thank the honourable member for giving way. Would he agree with me that the issues just touching on now in terms of apprenticeships, that's an issue that has to be key going forward? We have to increase the number of apprentices, increase the skills base, and also increase the productivity, which is a problem that has beset successive governments for many years.

15:21 - 18:03

Jim Shannon

I do, and I thank my honourable friend and colleague for that intervention. And on the work that Thales do with students, they pay their students' fees and they give them a good wage, an incredible wage. And some of the young boys that I know from Comber, for instance, they're young men now who have taken the apprenticeships, they're across all over the world within the Thales corporation, working incredibly hard. There's a network of smaller engineering firms too that supply the specialist services. Many of these skilled suppliers operate in and around my constituency of Strangford, making the local economy particularly vulnerable to the manufacturing skills shortages.

Harland and Wolff at this moment in time are looking for 500 new workers. They've recruited some 500 already and they're hoping to recruit another 500. So there's a demand in Northern Ireland for skilled workers. And within that, they also offer apprenticeships as well. Manufacturing accounts for approximately 11% of employment in Northern Ireland, making it a vital contributor to the regional economy.

Northern Ireland's employment is currently the third lowest in the United Kingdom, standing at some just shy of 900,000. Further strengthening and investing in our manufacturing skills could help expand employment opportunities. My question to the Minister, of course, and I welcome the Minister to her place and I look forward to her response. What discussions has the Minister had with the relevant Minister at the Northern Ireland Assembly to ensure that the policy and the strategy that is happening here can be one that we can enjoy as well? So I join other members and those who will speak after me to call on government to take urgent action to address the skills shortages across the manufacturing sector.

The United Kingdom manufacturing and engineering skills gap is estimated to cost businesses over 5 billion pound each year. So now is the time to act and ensure that the apprenticeships that can take three to four years to actually learn those skills and then add into the companies that they are employed with. I finish with this, Mr Chairman, ever mindful that there's some 12 other members wish to speak. Failing to act now will leave the next generation without the technical skills employers need. Action must be including improving women's access, and I ask that of the Minister, women's access to manufacturing careers.

I'm blessed to see and pleased to see that in Harland and Wolff and Spirit that the young ladies are getting the opportunity to have engineering skills and they're taking that opportunity. But we could do more to encourage young women in particular to get into manufacturing careers and creating more opportunities for young people to gain practical industrial skills. By widening the talent pool, government can help secure the future of manufacturing in Northern Ireland and indeed across this United Kingdom of Great Britain and beyond, particularly skilled manufacturing businesses. That's the purpose of government, that's the purpose of the honourable member for Strangford. Let's see what we can do together.

18:03 - 18:05

Speaker 13

Thank you.

18:05 - 22:43

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Mr Christopher. It's an honour to serve under your chairmanship, and I'd also like to thank my honourable friend for Isle of Wight West for securing this important debate. Wolverhampton and Willenhall helped build Britain and beyond. Generations of skilled engineers, metalworkers and manufacturers made products that were sold across the world. But manufacturing skills are fundamental to places like mine, and it calls for policymakers, for industry, for schools and colleges to come and work together to rise to this government's ambition to reindustrialise our country.

As the MP for Wolverhampton North East, I represent a constituency with a proud industrial heritage and a thriving manufacturing base today, who form an industrial ecosystem that supports skilled jobs, innovation and economic growth. While the industries have evolved, the principle remains the same: success depends on having the skilled workforce to innovate, compete and grow. Yet employers across the country continue to report shortages in the technical skills they need to grow and innovate. So I want to commend Collins Aerospace, who chose Wolverhampton to host their new world-leading engineering centre of excellence for aircraft systems in innovation, leading the charge on collaboration with industry and academia.

I was delighted this year when the City of Wolverhampton College secured technical excellence college status for advanced manufacturing. Now that's a rubber stamp of confidence in places like Wolverhampton, who are now among the national leaders in technical education and helping to develop future engineers, technicians and skilled manufacturing workers that our local economy needs. I also welcome the government's commitment to developing a new school curriculum that values technical and vocational education alongside academic achievement. For far too long, as a former school leader, I know that technical routes have been treated as a second choice. Apprenticeship starts have begun to move in the right direction, increasing in 2024 to 25, up more than 13,000 on the previous year.

It is encouraging progress after years in which apprenticeship starts consistently failed to recover to the levels needed by our economy and manufacturing sector. While many training providers report that funding bands no longer reflect the real cost of delivering high-quality technical training, employers and colleges continue to face additional costs in training welders, fabricators, CNC machinists and engineering technicians, despite these being precisely the skills our economy needs more of. A skills policy works best when decisions are made closer to the communities and employers that they affect. Greater devolution of skills and economic development powers give manufacturing communities in places like the West Midlands a strong voice in shaping local training provision. Local employers, colleges and training providers are often best placed to identify the workforce needs of our advanced manufacturing and engineering sectors.

So I ask the minister, when will the government conclude its review of apprenticeship funding bands, and will engineering and manufacturing apprenticeships level 2 and 3 be prioritised to address critical skills shortages? And will the government work with Richard Parker, the Mayor of the West Midlands, with the combined authority, local colleges and schools, training providers and employers to ensure that Wolverhampton and Willenhall have the engineering and manufacturing skills provision needed to meet the demands of major employers and their supply chains so that local people can access the high-skilled jobs that will drive Britain's reindustrialisation?

22:43 - 27:28

Gideon Amos

I congratulate the honourable member for Isle of Wight for securing this debate and on shining a light on this really important part of our economy, both locally and nationally. Specialist manufacturing is critical to my Taunton and Wellington constituency, as well as to growth across the United Kingdom. The Agratas factory being constructed just outside my constituency will employ 4,000 people and have a huge impact on the whole South West economy. Many of my constituents work there already, many local suppliers are involved in the supply chain, so the regional economy will be greatly affected in a positive way. That is what specialist manufacturing can do for regional economies, but only if we get the skills right to support that sector.

When I spoke in this hall last November, I raised the work of University Centre Somerset College Group, which is based not only in my Taunton and Wellington constituency, but across Somerset on different campuses. It's the largest college provider of apprenticeships in England. UCS has had to develop a first-of-its-kind program to meet demand, which barely existed just a couple of years ago when battery manufacturing was barely a mainstream concept in the UK. It's not an easy task, but it is exactly the kind of innovation required to build skills, the skills base that can support the new specialist manufacturing sectors that we need, such as battery production. To the government's credit, some things have moved on since then, and I genuinely welcome those.

In April, the government announced a 380 million pound grant for the factory itself, and UCS was named a Clean Energy Technical Excellence College. Last year, I also called on Skills England to invest in partnerships that deliver, rather than just producing consultation papers that plan and devise. And in March, it produced a battery manufacturing apprenticeship unit in just three months, which was fantastic progress. But there is a great deal still to do. The first pilot course this summer trained nine Agratas staff, and around 1,600 people will be needed just to start battery cell production.

In a written answer last month, the government said they are supporting UCS's work with Agratas, and I welcome that. But I'm afraid the basic problem I raised last year has not gone away. A college developing a curriculum and hiring specialist trainers in a complete new industry will only receive funding from the government or other sources once the course starts. And a further education college, as a further education college, is not allowed to borrow against potential future funding. The current FE model therefore simply does not support the upfront investment that's required, and specialist skills will suffer as a result.

Colleges are also no longer allowed to borrow in order to invest in student accommodation they need, even though that would generate income, help to regenerate towns, and deliver housing, which is a priority of this government in a particular sector and relieve pressure on local family housing. We cannot expect colleges to shoulder all the risk of these investment initiatives while the government takes credit only for the positive outcomes. The issue is not just about specialist manufacturing skills. Sites such as Agratas require an enormous amount of construction skills and labor. Agratas's own figures show that in the peak year, building the first factory alone will support more than 3,000 jobs in the Southwest, equivalent to around a fifth of all construction jobs in Somerset, coming on top of Hinkley Point C, also close to my constituency, which needs many of the same skilled workers.

If we are serious about boosting regional growth through specialist manufacturing, we need to be equally serious about training the people who will build such facilities and work in them. Liberal Democrats have called for apprentices to be paid at least the national minimum wage, and for lifelong skills grants so that adults can retrain for new industries like this one. I ask the Minister three things, four things in fact. First, when the government say they are supporting UCS's work with Agratas, does any of that support cover the upfront costs of developing courses that are innovative? Secondly, will the government make sure that colleges can set up apprenticeships and skills training in advance of factories being built?

Thirdly, will the Minister agree that colleges should be able to forward fund student accommodation, which would deliver much-needed housing? And finally, would the Minister meet with me and UCS College Group to discuss these points? For Taunton and Wellington, indeed the whole Southwest, the opportunity is right in front of us. Having backed the factory with 380 million pounds, which I thoroughly welcome and congratulate the government upon, the government now need to grab this opportunity with both hands and provide the support and the certainty on skills to turn it into a real success.

27:28 - 27:30

Speaker 15

Thank you, Sir Christopher.

27:30 - 31:14

Lee Pitcher

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. What an absolute pleasure it is to serve under your chairmanship. Doncaster has an incredible history when it comes to manufacturing, particularly when it comes to transport. Everyone will know names like the Flying Scotsman and the Mallard, both built in Doncaster, and the legacy of Nigel Gresley is still very much strong in our local culture. But right now, all eyes on Doncaster are on another form of transport.

Yesterday, we received the fantastic news that my long-standing commitment to reopen Doncaster Sheffield Airport has been supercharged by an agreement to bring the airport back into public ownership. This is an incredible achievement that comes after a huge amount of work from all involved. And the DSA project isn't just about the airport itself. The deal also covers the adjacent innovation quarter, which has the potential to become a center for advanced manufacturing, innovation, and ultimately reindustrialization of our area. Public control, reindustrialization, and localism, three things that the Prime Minister has put at the very heart of his mission for this country.

And Doncaster could not be a better case study for all three, both in terms of how badly it is needed and the enormous scope there is for the opportunity. Huge parts of my constituency were left behind when the pits closed. Deindustrialization changed the faces of Rossington, Hatfield, Thorne, and Moorends, and nothing has ever really come to fill that gap until now. But Doncaster has all the pieces in place to become a center for manufacturing and industry once again. We have excellent logistical connections through road and rail, proximity to the Humber ports, and soon the airport reopening itself.

We have major distribution and logistics hubs, including the iPort and the Unity development. We have two Labour mayors and a proactive Chamber of Commerce who work tirelessly to bring jobs and growth to every single postcode in Doncaster. And we have the educational infrastructure in place with our existing UTC and a second one now approved in Doncaster, and other wonderful FE colleges like John Leggott, New College, and North Lindsey, to name but a few. All we need now is to make sure that we are developing the skills and the workforce to match those opportunities that lie ahead. Because we cannot wait until factories are built and businesses are recruiting before we begin training the people that we will need.

So I welcome the government's commitment to advanced manufacturing through our industrial strategy and the reforms of the growth and skills levy, including new foundation apprenticeships in engineering and manufacturing. But we need to make sure that the skills we are teaching matches the skills and the needs of the industries that we are trying to attract, and that we're providing opportunities for existing workers to retrain and develop new skills as well. That means bringing together government, local authorities, businesses, and education providers to plan for the industries and the jobs of the future. So I would welcome the minister outlining how the government is working to ensure that investment in manufacturing skills is aligned with major regional development projects such as South Yorkshire Airport City. Because in Doncaster, we've seen what happens when industry disappears and nothing comes along to replace it.

We know all too well the impact on our economy, on the community, and on the people and their families. But we have a chance now, a chance to regain lost pride and purpose. A chance for the places blighted by deprivation to flourish and prosper once again. A chance to rebuild our industrial economy. And we must make sure that the people of Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme have the skills to take advantage of it.

31:14 - 35:53

Brian William Leishman

Good morning, sir. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today, and my thanks go to my honorable friend from Isle of Wight West for securing this debate to Westminster Hall. You know, we hardly make anything anymore. For decades, Scotland has been the victim of industrial vandalism with our manufacturing base hammered.

Last year, Petroineos, that's the billionaire Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Chinese government, ended a century of oil refining at Grangemouth. Ultimately, private capital and a foreign government decided that 435 jobs were to be lost on site, 2,822 in the wider supply chain, the removal of a positive destination for local young people, over 400 million pounds per annum lost from Scotland's national economy, and Scotland's fuel security weakened. Now, in my time in this place, I have been critical of both the Scottish and the UK governments, and I stand by that criticism. But the truth is that the SNP Scottish government knew about the closure for three years and did absolutely nothing to stop it. I will not allow anyone from the SNP to try and rewrite history on that, although as everyone will see this morning, I don't need to do that as they couldn't be bothered to attend this debate.

Their passion for abstentionism and lack of participation in this place they are taking to a new level. And this year, yet more industrial devastation as Alexander Dennis's Canadian owners NFI stopped bus manufacturing in Scotland. 115 job losses. Another piece of Scotland's manufacturing base deemed disposable by international capital. And yet again, the SNP Scottish government abandoned workers.

This time, 335 zero-emission buses were to be built through the ScotZEB 3 scheme. Alexander Dennis were awarded 123. The Chinese company Yutong were awarded 166. The truth is that in Scottish politics, it was the working class that propelled the SNP into generational power. And the SNP have rewarded communities with buses from Beijing, Ferguson Marine redundancies, the creation and the promotion of the Tory idea of freeports, that's international tax havens, all for private capital to extract resources and wealth from Scotland.

The SNP, make no mistake, are comfortable with all of that. Sir Christopher, regarding manufacturing, we are on the cusp of a green industrial revolution. What an opportunity we have with renewables. But what have the SNP Scottish government done to create new manufacturing jobs in that sector? Well, they've had off-the-record meetings with corporations looking to get involved in Scotland's renewable industry, and the end result, a green investment portfolio where 3 billion pounds of green assets were to be bought by private firms.

That is money that the Scottish government could have plowed into manufacturing skills, into job creation, transforming communities. Instead of building a Scottish manufacturing base that would create worker and community prosperity, the SNP went for outsourcing, privatization, and the continuation of pandering to foreign capital.

The SNP are capitalists to their very core. Now in finishing, I do not hold the desire for independence against the SNP or anyone that identifies as a Scottish nationalist. No, not in the slightest. I respect their view. The reason I have no time for the Scottish National Party is because they have decimated Scottish manufacturing and waged war on the Scottish working class.

35:53 - 39:59

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Sir Christopher. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. For many growing up in Portsmouth, they saw a shipyard was a constant visual reminder that we're a city and a country that made things. Not only that we made, not only that we made things, but important things, ships that defended our country, protected our freedom, and protected British expertise around the world. The Portsmouth that people remember was full of people with skilled jobs, men and women who took pride in their work, proud of what they produced and proud of the contributions they were making to their communities.

There was a clear connection between effort, skill and opportunity, and young people could see a future for themselves. They could look around the city and see where hard work and talent could take them. Unfortunately, Sir Christopher, over the years that connection has been weakened. The loss of shipbuilding and other industrial jobs under the Conservatives has meant that too many young people today do not see the same opportunities that previous generations had. But it's not just the challenge of young people, it is also the challenge of British business.

Manufacturers repeatedly tell us they struggle to recruit people with the right skills. Before entering politics, I was a teacher for 24 years. Throughout that time I saw countless young people with enormous potential, but too often those talents were not valued in the way that they should have been. This has to change. We need an education system that values technical excellence just as highly as academic achievement, a system that recognizes that our country needs first-class engineers as much as it needs lawyers, accountants or academics.

But if we truly want to reindustrialize Britain, we must first rebuild the pipeline of skills that make the industrialized success possible. And that is why this government's reforms are so important. I'm delighted that from the age of 14 young people will have the opportunity to combine core academic subjects such as English and maths and science with high-quality vocational subjects. They will be able to spend more time with employers and gain real-world experience and develop the practical skills that businesses are looking for. But more importantly, they will be able to see a pathway.

And that connection matters enormously. The local connection for young people means opportunity, and for employers it means confidence. It means confidence that they can invest, expand and create jobs, knowing that the skilled workers they need will be available. I have long argued that apprenticeships and training need to be more flexible and more responsive to the needs of the different sectors. So I am pleased that this government has taken those steps to manufacturing too.

Fixing the skills shortage isn't about filling vacancies, it's about building our national capability. And nowhere, Sir Christopher, is that more evident than the sector that's extremely important to my constituency, the space sector. The next iteration of the Skynet satellite program is currently out to procurement. This is a crucial decision for our national security, our sovereignty space capability and industrial future, and my city's future. At Airbus in Portsmouth, highly skilled workers manufacture the payloads, the brains of the satellites, and Airbus remains the only company capable of building large spacecraft end-to-end in the United Kingdom.

The Skynet program sustains 3,000 highly skilled jobs directly and supports 18,000 jobs across the supply chain. These are skills and capability built over decades and cannot be easily created if lost. And if we are serious about reindustrialization, we must be serious about protecting the skills industrial capabilities we already have. We can't just create shiny new jobs, we must protect the ones that we already have. It is not enough to talk about creating skilled jobs if we only safeguard the jobs that still exist.

I share the Prime Minister's ambition to back British industry, strengthen our capabilities, and create good jobs in every part of the country, and that includes my city. So I ask the Minister to impress upon colleagues in the Treasury and the Ministry of Defence about the importance of protecting and sustaining these world-class space manufacturing skills in Portsmouth, because whilst we know that rebuilding Britain's manufacturing strength begins with investment in skills, it must continue with supporting the skills and the industry that we already have. For me, ultimately, it's about ensuring the next generation can once again look at my city, just as I looked at Portsmouth's shipyard growing up, and see a future full of opportunity, purpose, and pride.

39:59 - 40:01

Speaker 23

Hear, hear.

40:01 - 41:10

Steve Yemm

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this morning, Sir Christopher. I want to begin by thanking my honourable friend, the Member for the Isle of Wight West, for securing this important debate today at a time when our economy is undergoing transformation. Excuse me. AI, robotics, and automation are changing how we manufacture and the skills that our businesses need.

And for me, if we're serious about reindustrialisation, we have to make sure that our workforce is ready to seize that opportunity that those changes will bring. And for places like my constituency of Mansfield, this means, I think, rebuilding the connections between education and local employees and employers and skilled employment.

41:10 - 41:11

Hear, hear.

41:11 - 43:19

Steve Yemm

Further education providers, including colleges like West Notts College in my constituency, I think are really critical to delivering this. On constituency visits, I've been fortunate enough to see the great work that is already being done by employers working in partnership with West Notts College and Nottingham Trent University. One such visit was to a local aerospace and nuclear electronics company, Glenair, who have recently taken on 60 new apprentices in Mansfield. I think often people consider apprenticeships as an option for school leavers, but actually what I find in my area is that these opportunities exist equally for adults, adults who want to retrain or change careers or develop new skills. And I'm therefore very encouraged that Mansfield recorded 680 new apprenticeship starts in 2024-2025, with more than half of those being taken up by people over the age of 25.

And so the backdrop to this discussion is, as Make UK has reported, there are almost 50,000 live vacancies across UK manufacturing, three in five manufacturing SMEs identifying a lack of the right type of technical skill as a key barrier to recruitment. But I think that this apparent weakness can also be seen as an opportunity, and for areas like mine, reindustrialisation and the ideas around that represent a real chance to build on our proud industrial heritage and create a new generation of skilled and well-paid jobs.

43:19 - 43:20

Hear, hear.

43:20 - 44:03

Steve Yemm

But we have to make sure that local people have the skills to take on those opportunities, whether they're young people starting their careers or those adults who are looking to retrain and learn something new and skills for a new economy.

I think if we get that right as a government and as a country, we can make sure that the industries of the future bring investment and opportunity and prosperity to places like Mansfield, and that local people are properly equipped to play their full part in sharing our economic future.

44:03 - 44:06

Speaker 24

Dr. Allison Gardner.

44:06 - 48:35

Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner

Thank you, and it is an honor to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Christopher, and I thank the honorable member for the Isle of Wight West for securing this debate today. I am incredibly proud to represent Stoke-on-Trent South, part of which includes Stoke-on-Trent, the city with a proud heritage in craftsmanship and industry. Stoke is the birthplace of the Lunar Society, a group of amazing innovative thinkers, including the great innovator Josiah Wedgwood. The Lunar Society helped fuel the Industrial Revolution, and manufacturing is embedded within Stoke-on-Trent and its people. With the government's reindustrialization agenda, now is the time to invest in creative and advanced manufacturing skills so that our young people can secure high-paid, specialist jobs.

That is why I first want to raise the excellent work underway by the My Futures initiative, raised with me by Stoke-on-Trent Sixth Form and the Potteries Educational Trust and delivered in partnership with Keele University, the University of Staffordshire, the Careers and Enterprise Company, and local SMEs. This initiative is delivering an employer-led skills framework from 10 to 19, indeed up to 25 years, to over 63,000 students. They deliver a co-designed curriculum experience for 14 to 19-year-olds with employer-linked career gateways, helping teachers embed employer engagement activities into study and address local skills gaps. My Futures are seeking support from the Department for Education to become a funded pathfinder project, and I ask the Minister whether she would work with colleagues in the DfE to support this proposal where gateways align with manufacturing. And of course, I could not speak in a debate on manufacturing without raising ceramics.

From iconic tableware manufacturers such as 1882 and Duchess China in my constituency to advanced ceramics firms such as Mantec, ceramics have shaped our local identity. While ceramics is best known for mugs and tableware, products we all love, advanced ceramics are the hidden backbone of modern manufacturing. They are essential components in the supply chain for high-tech industries, including defense, electronics, and energy. The UK ceramics sector contributes over £2 billion annually, employs approximately 20,000 people, and supports thousands more jobs through supply chains. We are incredibly lucky that North Staffordshire is the hotbed for this activity.

However, businesses repeatedly tell me that skill shortages are having a significant impact on businesses. Experienced workers are retiring, taking decades of specialist knowledge with them, and too few young people are entering the industry. Valuable heritage skills being lost entirely as employers struggle to attract and retain trainees. Indeed, I spoke recently to an amazing entrepreneur whose business using art creamware is going from strength to strength, but she is concerned for the future as the person she depends on will soon be retiring, and she risks losing his skills and we risk losing her business overseas if we do not fix our skills pipeline. This is an increasing problem, and it is time we truly focus on backing British products.

There is a need to train an estimated 200 to 400 operatives per year in Stoke-on-Trent and Newcastle in traditional ceramics alone. In advanced ceramics, emerging technologies such as ceramic matrix composites do not yet have recognized apprenticeship or qualification routes. Specialist technical manufacturing knowledge is being lost with no national masterplan to replace this capability. As such, I was delighted to see the launch of the craft technician apprenticeship earlier this year, led by Emma Bridgewater in my honorable friend's constituency of Stoke-on-Trent South, central, and supported by Ceramics UK, Skills England, and Creative Alliance. Initiatives like this are exactly what the sector needs to help the next generation of skilled workers.

I also welcome the government's 120 million investment to support energy efficiency and decarbonization in the ceramics industry, but while that funding is important, I would welcome the minister's assurance that future funding will consider skills. At the heart of our reindustrialization plans sits manufacturing in all its forms. It is the rockbed for our national economy, growth, and our resilience. We must invest in the future, we must invest in our people, and we must invest in skills.

48:35 - 51:31

Perran Moon

Sir Christopher, it's an honor to serve under your chairmanship, and I'd like to thank my honorable friend from the Isle of Wight West for adopting this important debate. It won't surprise him that I am going to talk largely about Cornwall. Across Cornwall, our beautiful coastlines hide some of the deepest pockets of deprivation in the country. That deprivation and the lack of opportunity is felt most sharply by our young people. In my constituency of Camborne, Redruth, and Hayle, we have neighborhoods where child poverty rate is over 40%.

Equally concerning is that the number of our young people claiming unemployment benefit is up 39% in the last year alone. But there is hope on the horizon for Cornwall. Our critical minerals sector offers an incredible opportunity to create well-paid, high-skilled jobs that our young people and communities need, all the while strengthening the country's industrial resilience and supporting the transition to a green economy. But we will only realize that opportunity if young people are equipped with the skills that our local economy, that our local businesses need. To that end, we are moving in the right direction.

In September, the new Engineering and Mining Academy at the outstanding, the Ofsted outstanding FE college, Cornwall College, in partnership with Cornish Metals at South Crofty tin mine, was launched. Its location could hardly be better: moments around the corner from South Crofty, the UK's last tin mine to close, now on course to reopen after 30 years. As projects like South Crofty or Agritas battery gigafactory advance, demand for mining and manufacturing skills will only grow. I therefore welcome the academy's focus not only on the engineering and technical skills associated with modern mining, but also on the transferable skills which create a clear pathway into apprenticeships, employment, or further study: welding, construction, carpentry, electronics, plumbing, a lifetime trade for our young people with their hands. These are the partnerships with industry that we must champion to support our critical minerals and downstream manufacturing sectors.

They create good jobs and give young people the aspiration and opportunity to raise their horizons, to build their futures in Cornwall. I would therefore ask the minister to consider what further steps can be taken to realize Cornwall as the UK's critical minerals skills hub.

51:31 - 51:35

Speaker 29

We've got to call the wind-ups at half past ten. Dave Robertson.

51:35 - 55:17

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Sir Christopher. It is a pleasure to take part in a debate with you in the chair this morning and indeed one led by my honorable friend, the UK spokesperson for ferries. The government is quite rightly at the moment talking about reindustrialization and I think we can see how well supported that is on this side of the house by the number of people wanting to contribute. Never mind. But too often talk of reindustrialization can be thinking about what happened in the past and trying to go back to the past and that's just not true anywhere in the country, but especially in the West Midlands where yes, we have a proud manufacturing tradition that has been depleted and many communities across the region are still scarred by that.

But actually communities are also really looking forward to a brighter future where industrialization can come back. Now central to manufacturing in my part of the world in Staffordshire is ceramics and proud to follow a Stoke-on-Trent MP talking about the ceramics in the north of Staffordshire, but in my part of the world it's a different type of ceramics. It's toilets. I think every single member in this house will have at some point spent a penny with Armitage Shanks because it's been operating for over 200 years in the village of Armitage in my constituency. It supports, sorry, the ceramics industry as a whole supports 20,000 skilled jobs, which does include toilets, plates, but also bricks, pipes and the technical ceramics that my honorable friend spoke about earlier.

Those jobs are absolutely essential to the economic growth, the economic well-being of the entire country, but especially those communities in the North Midlands where so much of the ceramics industry is based. When we look at that, that's really important to those communities, but it's also really important to what the government is seeking to achieve. The government is quite rightly talking about ending the housing crisis that we have and the need to really make sure that there is enough housing stock available for every single person in this country. I would wager that every single one of us would expect to see at least one toilet in every single one of those new houses and the last volume producer of sanitaryware anywhere in the country is in a little village called Armitage, not far from Lichfield. The government has done huge things already to talk about the importance of industry, the importance of manufacturers like Armitage Shanks and also to talk about the importance of the skills that those companies need.

We've already seen the changes to the functional skills requirement to apprenticeship, something I wholeheartedly support and something that has led to an increase in the number of young people taking up that opportunity. It's a great step in the right direction. Talk about vocational GCSEs, great step in the right direction. But as important as it is to need to see those skills coming through, we also need to make sure that those businesses are there to provide the jobs for those skills to be used in, which is why I'm so pleased that this government was able to support 120 million pound rescue package for the ceramics industry. Funding that is desperately needed to help the industry regenerate itself, look forward to the 21st century, decarbonize and push on and continue to drive that economic growth.

One of the things I would say though is that money, that funding is no good sitting in a bank account in Whitehall waiting to be delivered. We need to get that money out of the door faster so that we can make sure that both sides of this equation, the manufacturing skills, the manufacturers and the skills are working hand in hand. So the one thing I would ask the minister to do today is if she can have a conversation with her colleagues in DBEST to make sure that we are leaving absolutely no stone unturned to push that funding out of the door, get it into the ceramics sector so they can provide the jobs so that those skills that we're trying to build can be really pushed forwards into those companies and can help drive economic growth in every postcode in the country, but especially in WS15. Thank you, Sir Christopher.

55:17 - 55:19

Speaker 34

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

55:19 - 57:50

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Sir Christopher. It is an honor to serve under your chairmanship.

I pay tribute to my honorable friend the member for Isle of Wight West for securing the debate. Much like in Yorkshire, in the Isle of Wight, West is best. For too many, the vision of manufacturing is the dark satanic mills of the past, but in Calder Valley, that's not what it looks like. It's robotics, it's advanced materials, it's precision engineering. And how can we provide the skills workers for those industries without the proper training?

Too many industrial communities have been told that decline was an inevitability, a poverty of ambition since Thatcher. But in Calder Valley, manufacturing employs about 16% of the workforce. 20 years ago, it was 25%, but actually, we can go the other way. When you look at manufacturing jobs, when you lose them, you lose skills and confidence and opportunities in an area. You lose the sense that a young person can build a good life whatever they choose to do.

A manufacturing wage is about 8% above that of the average wage, and we need a skilled workforce, particularly when one looks at the NEET crisis. About 8.5% of 18 to 24-year-olds in Calder Valley are on unemployment benefits and not in training. But the industrial sector's workforce has aged faster than the rest of the workforce. The average age is over 50. It's not sustainable.

One managing director in my constituency started at 16 on a YTS. He joined me in 11 Downing Street last year. That's the kind of story of success that manufacturing skills jobs can bring, and that's what I want to see more of in Calder Valley. But manufacturing needs to feel like an option. Denford Engineering in my constituency, who make equipment for schools and run the international STEM racing competition, their chief executive said to me, "Why don't we have design and manufacturing rather than design and technology, which is less meaningful to people?"

And actually, it's that kind of shift that we need to do to think about the future of manufacturing and think about it as an option. In Calder Valley, we have just secured the Yorkshire Robotics Adoption Hub, hosted by the brilliant West Yorkshire Manufacturing Services in Brighouse. It will work with more than 300 manufacturers to get them ready to work with robotics and the skills of the future. It's those kind of innovations that can give us the skills of the future. So I ask the Minister, what more can we do to supply that confidence in business and to build skills for the next generation?

57:50 - 57:52

Speaker 35

Thank you.

57:52 - 59:41

Speaker 41

Thank you, Mr. sorry, thank you, Sir Christopher. And I thank my honorable friend for bringing this debate. And I'm particularly fond of this discussion because in a slightly tenuous link, my late granddad Bill Dibley was born and raised on the Isle of Wight, went on to become an electrical engineer, and when I was about five, made me my first circuit board to play with, which ignited my love of innovation. So I'm sure he'd be delighted that we're here supporting the great legacy of technical skills out of Isle of Wight and the whole of the UK. I'm grateful to private companies in my constituency like BAE Systems, who built the Academy for Skills and Knowledge, which trains apprentices for both its own organization and the surrounding supply chain.

But the first of two key quick points I'd like to make is that while areas like mine in Lancashire were previously one of the biggest beneficiaries under the EU of skills support and funding, now where schemes like the Apprenticeship Brokerage Service only goes to mayoral areas, which Lancashire is not, we risk losing so much of our progress. So while I've been encouraged by the Prime Minister's focus on reindustrialization and this government's commitment to growth in every postcode, we need to make sure that it means exactly that. My second quick point is that I also have a lot of food manufacturing in my heavily rural constituency. One of those is Baxi, and typically Baxi would look to take on around 30 apprentices each year, but this year, because of wider financial pressures, they've not been able to take on any. So we must address skill shortages not just by encouraging more young people into manufacturing, but making sure businesses have the means to invest in them.

So I'm grateful that this government believes deeply in technical education, and we know that the public is with us because 93% of people believe manufacturing is important for growing the UK's economy. But we have to make sure that the cost of doing business isn't too high to develop those skills, and we have to make sure that all parts of the UK are supported to contribute to building our skills base here. Thank you.

59:38 - 01:00:38

Andrew Dominic John Grady

Thank you Sir Christopher. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I thank my honourable friend the member for the Isle of Wight West on securing this debate. I meet regularly with fantastic employers in Glasgow who want to employ young people but there aren't the college places available to train the people in the skills those businesses need. This is an absolute failure and is making Glasgow poorer despite the fact we have fantastic opportunities in manufacturing in Glasgow. Glasgow has a city deal through the Glasgow City Region, something to build on for regional devolution because it's local employers, local businesses, local colleges who understand how best to get the skills in place to grow the local and regional economy.

But we have an absolutely botched reform of local government carrying out in Scotland at the minute. The SNP are making a complete mess of it. The Prime Minister was right in Scotland on Friday when he spoke about the need to get power out of Edinburgh and into the city regions and the regions of Scotland so we can help businesses thrive and give young people the opportunities we want and seize the great future Scotland has. Thank you.

01:00:38 - 01:07:41

Ian Sollom

Thank you Sir Christopher. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today and I congratulate the honourable member for the Isle of Wight West on securing this very important debate. Sir Christopher, I'll start with some numbers we should celebrate. UK manufacturing produces 220 billion pounds of output and supports 2.6 million jobs, paying on average 8% more than the rest of the economy. It accounts for 42% of our exports and almost half of all business R&D.

It's a sector of skilled, well-paid careers that we are rightly proud of. But it's also a sector that could do more if it had more of the skilled people that it needs. Skills England identifies advanced manufacturing as having the third highest proportion of skill shortage vacancies of any sector and projects that 84% of the additional jobs in its priority occupations to 2035 will need qualifications at level 4 or above. The businesses from Cambridgeshire that kindly shared their insights with me in advance of this debate describe problems that I suspect members from every part of the country will recognise. One electronics firm, Capair, told me that although electronics is the largest manufacturing subsector in our region, the county is a dead spot for the sort of technical education they need, with travel outside the county needed for training.

And there is no occupational standard for much of the work they do. As they put it, you cannot fund a course for a job the system does not recognise. Now that's a national problem for Skills England, but the lack of local provision is something places could fix for themselves and I hope that the Prime Minister's well-known enthusiasm for devolution extends to giving areas like ours the skills powers and capital funding to do it. Zeiss, another manufacturer in my constituency who make electron microscopes, make a related point about the future. Advanced manufacturing now combines traditional mechanical and electrical engineering with automation, software, data and AI.

And we need to build those capabilities now before they become critical shortages, not just fill today's vacancies. But in 2024-25 there were over 46,000 starts in engineering and manufacturing in England, but level 2 manufacturing starts fell by 80% in the five years to 23-24. And that's a significant problem in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough. Now the Liberal Democrats have long called for the apprenticeship levy to be replaced so we welcome the government's move to a more flexible growth and skills levy. But we do recognise that progress has been slow.

Apprenticeship units have been available since April, yet the skills charity Enginuity found a fifth of manufacturing SMEs had never heard of them and only one in ten think that they will fill their skills gaps.

And on the department's own forecasts, apprenticeship spending is due to fall after this year, even as levy receipts rise. Employers tell me that the system needs to be straightforward for employers to use, responsive to changing industrial needs, and attractive to young people as a genuine alternative to university. But too often it is none of those things for smaller firms. The apprenticeship model may work for large employers, but for a firm of twenty, they can't easily release a young employee for two or three days per week sometimes to a college that might be miles away, and it's difficult for them to carry the paperwork that comes with it as well. Another manufacturer in my constituency, Domino Printing Services, has pointed out employers pay into the levy but cannot use it to cover much of the real cost of employing and developing an apprenticeship.

Funding bands for many engineering apprenticeships simply don't cover the cost of delivering them. So we have employers with skills gaps, young people who need good routes into careers, and apprenticeship funding that is not fully used. Now there's a lot here the government could take from Liberal Democrat policy, as you might expect me to say. We would like to introduce skills tax credits with enhanced relief for priority sectors to reflect the fact that skills are an investment. And we would also establish the structures for skills cooperatives, and I know the Prime Minister likes a cooperative, so that smaller firms can pool training resources and even rotate apprentices between them.

We would also expand higher technical routes such as HNCs and HNDs, foundation degrees, and higher apprenticeships, building on the investment already made in FE colleges and institutes of technology. And we would like to see Skills England as a truly independent body with employers at its heart. In its short life, Skills England has already been moved from the Department for Education to the Department for Work and Pensions, and it remains an executive agency inside that department, not the independent voice for skills that employers really need. And I would urge the government to look again at giving it genuine independence. Now I do have three questions for the minister.

First, levy receipts are forecast at 4.5 billion pounds this year, but after the devolved nations' share and England's 3.3 billion pound budget, around 700 million pounds is not returned to the skills system, it stays with the Treasury. And on the government's own spending projections, that rises to about a billion pounds next year. So will the minister commit that money raised for skills is spent on skills and not clawed back by the Treasury? Second, will the review of funding bands address the shortfall of up to 8,000 pounds per apprentice that employers face in engineering and manufacturing? And third, will the minister press Skills England to develop occupational standards for a wider variety of manufacturing roles, such as PCB assembly, that the system currently cannot see?

Nyobolt, a battery manufacturer in my constituency, put it well: the opportunity now is to make sure the skills pipeline develops at the same pace as the technology.

Skills, like manufacturing investment itself, are multi-year, long-horizon decisions. What industry needs from government is a long-term, stable plan, and I hope the minister can tell us today that that's what's coming. Thank you.

01:07:41 - 01:13:24

Saqib Bhatti

Thank you, Patrick. Thank you, Sir Christopher. It is a pleasure to be responding on behalf of His Majesty's Opposition and serve under your chairmanship. And I thank the honorable member for the Isle of Wight for securing time in this House for this really important topic. And I heard a lot of good speakers, and I agree with the sentiment of many of those speakers.

Although we may not always agree on every policy issue, I do agree that our best years are ahead of us. And having previously been a director of the Local Enterprise Partnership in the West Midlands before I was a Member of Parliament, I remember my first ever meeting where I spoke to a chair of an FE college who told me about how the time between what his college could deliver and what businesses said they wanted was around three years. And that told me two things as a small business owner: that the skills landscape was incredibly complex and difficult for businesses to navigate, but also that demand played a huge role, and I'll cover demand in a bit. The UK's manufacturing sector is hugely important. The sector accounts for roughly eight and a half percent of total economic output across the country and employs roughly 2.6 million people.

And I was delighted that the member for Stoke-on-Trent South mentioned the Lunar Society, because a modern-day Lunar Society I was a member of. In fact, I helped write the constitution for, so I was pleased to see that put on record. And as a proud Member of Parliament for Meriden and Solihull East, a constituency in the heart of the West Midlands, we are also a UK manufacturing powerhouse because we are the home of Jaguar Land Rover. The West Midlands remains the UK's leading manufacturing sector, and Jaguar Land Rover is right at the heart of that, contributing 10.4 billion pounds, the region that is, and employing over 200,000 people. Just recently, I visited Rolls-Royce with the Shadow Chancellor, which has a huge facility in the West Midlands.

And I'd invite the minister to come and visit Rolls-Royce because they do a huge amount of work. And I know it was said that the UK doesn't manufacture anything anymore. I actually reject that context, actually, because I don't think that is true. I saw firsthand the engines, the control panels that were being built for some of our most important and sensitive projects as well. And I got to meet a number of apprentices as well, who just showed how important apprenticeships are.

And I'm proud that the previous government over 14 years created over 5.2 million apprenticeships. And as a Shadow Minister of State for Education, I regularly hold meetings with businesses, FE colleges, and others who are very concerned about skill shortages in the manufacturing sector. In July, I hosted a round table with Enginuity, which has already been mentioned, and we held that in Parliament. It's a charity that was focused on closing skills gaps in the UK's engineering and manufacturing sector. And it was very clear from the businesses that we met that they expect the government to do so much more to help support manufacturing and help engineering businesses recruit the best talent.

And we spoke at length about some of the findings in Enginuity's recent Mind the Gap report. And their research found that around half of surveyed SMEs reported skills-related issues within the past year, with 36 percent experiencing skills gaps and difficulties recruiting workers. And they estimate that the lack of plugging of this gap of manufacturing skills costs the UK economy 5.2 billion pounds annually. So clearly a really important area that we must all agree that we need to get on with fixing. And actually, I ask the minister if she's had about her relationship with the DfE and how she works to make sure that the advanced manufacturing workforce is skilled, not just at the NEET level but as has also been mentioned throughout people's careers and the lifelong learning element of that, because that is really, really important.

Sir Christopher, I'm very confident about the future of the UK's manufacturing sector. It is a growing industry that will offer varied and exciting jobs for the future. But I do believe there are significant challenges coming manufacturers' ways that we are already seeing and that is the result of government policy. Just yesterday, Prime Minister wrote in the Times newspaper about the prospects of Britain facing economic catastrophe and moral failure because of a generation of young workers being written off to a life on benefits. I agree because youth unemployment now is 16.4%.

When the Conservatives left office, it was 14.2%. So a significant increase. And of course, there are currently 1 million 16 to 24 year olds not in education, employment or training. And I welcome the government's focus on getting this down. For the right policies, we will support them.

Unfortunately, it is His Majesty's Opposition's view that their approach to tackling this grave injustice is still entirely wrong. The drastic shortage of jobs, and I talked about demand in this sector, the drastic shortage of jobs in sectors like manufacturing is because of the government's policy platform. Not once did I hear members opposite talk about the impact of National Insurance or the impact of tax or the reduction in National Insurance threshold or the fact that cost of employing an apprentice has gone up so much more that it's become challenging for businesses to take on apprentices. Where they do quote apprentices being taken on, Sir Christopher, actually the opportunity cost is that fewer are being taken on as a result of these policies. And it is obvious to me and to the opposition that it is the government's tax policies that are really making it harder for young people to get into good jobs.

That isn't just the view of the opposition, however. Huw Pill, the Chief Economist of the Bank of England, agrees that higher National Insurance contributions and government increase in the National Living Wage and minimum wages has priced out many entry-level workers, many of them, many, many of them are young people. I will give way.

01:13:24 - 01:13:35

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Sir Christopher. Could the Shadow Minister set out then by how much exactly in pounds and pence he thinks apprentices and young people should be paid less today than they are paid under the current minimum wage?

01:13:35 - 01:17:50

Saqib Bhatti

I reject the framing of the question because actually what is happening, what is happening, I'm sure they don't find youth unemployment funny, but what is happening is that when there is a young apprentice being interviewed by a business owner, and many business owners talk to me about this, and they say actually if they've got a 25 year old with experience versus an 18 year old with no experience, that is really hindering their prospects of hiring those people. And that is the reality. And I encourage him, I'm sure he's a very conscientious MP, I will encourage him to go and speak to his small business owners and ask that, pose that question in the way that I've framed it. When met with the reality, the government's plans on this space fall far too short. And the government has made lots of noise on recruiting targets.

In fact, I just saw that the government announced 40,000 new construction placements every single year. But can the Minister confirm, is this the same or a different version of the announcement the government made in August 25 about the 40,000 future builders, bricklayers, electricians, carpenters and plumbers? This was made, that was a, I directly quote from the press release in August 25. Because government by press release is one thing, Sir Christopher, but recycling old press releases is a whole thing else. And I think those apprentices deserve better than that.

And of course, there is no, there's been no mention about, as I talked about, the impact of the government's fiscal policies. Just as we were having this debate, I saw a headline: job vacancies are at their lowest in 12 years. That's 176,000 fewer jobs now from when Labour took office. There was also mention about, in the limited time that I've got left, there was also mention about the Education Secretary's ambition to offer, close off academic options and offer much more vocational options from the 14 to 16 age group.

And I have to say, I'm deeply skeptical of that policy. We are, the opposition is calling for an evidence-based approach. And the last time, and it was a Labour government who did these reforms, fewer children from poorer backgrounds ended up getting, going into academic subjects. They were funneled into vocational work. And actually, there were plenty of people who we believe would have been able to get into higher quality jobs, but actually they were funneled off at a lower age.

So we're deeply skeptical. And I know there's been, it's been welcomed, the policy announcement, but we are yet to see significant detail. And when I spoke to head teachers just last week, many of them talked about how they will be trained, their teachers will be trained to deliver these vocational subjects, and also where the funding will come from. Of course, the previous Conservative government is proud of the reforms that it instituted that has meant that the PISA rankings, that in the PISA rankings, England is some, the best, has some of the best educational delivery in the world. It's one of the most resilient.

We're incredibly proud of that. And if you meet people from the advanced manufacturing sector, they will laud the fact that a knowledge-rich curriculum has helped young people to create critical analytical skills. That includes numeracy skills. And so we are really worried about the fact that some of the announcements from the current Education Secretary will undermine opportunities for young people. And it's not just from the opposition that this criticism comes.

John White, Chief Financial Officer at Buildings Materials firm, Heys, says employers are struggling with the lack of incentives to hire younger people, pointing to the government narrowing the gap between the national minimum wage, as I've already alluded to, but also that government should change the rules around how employers can spend the apprenticeship levy. So I hope the Minister can shed a bit of light on some of the questions around the apprenticeship levy that are there. We are really clear that actually making it easier for employers to hire young people is really important. That's why we pledged to halve employers' national insurance for young people aged 21 to 24 to help them get into work. We've offered much more incentive for small businesses to take on young people because of course small businesses are often lauded as the lifeblood of the UK economy and the high street, but they are the greatest employers of young people across the country.

It's not actually big businesses. We believe our approach will free up the business sector and manufacturing to employ more young people. So I welcome the Minister's response to that.

01:17:51 - 01:22:37

Speaker 44

Thank you, Sir Christopher. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this morning. I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Isle of Wight West, on securing this important debate and making such a strong case for manufacturing skills, both on the Isle of Wight and across the country. As he set out, the Isle of Wight punches above its weight in advanced manufacturing, and businesses including White Shipyard, Diverse Marine, and GKN Aerospace demonstrate the breadth of modern British manufacturing, from shipbuilding and aerospace to clean energy, defense, and precision engineering. He's right that this isn't simply about preserving Britain's industrial heritage.

It's about building the industries, supply chains, and skilled careers of the future. And I particularly welcome his focus on the new Large Structures Innovation Centre and the Isle of Wight College's specialist centre for engineering and advanced manufacturing training. Investment in facilities and innovation must go hand in hand with investment in people, so that employers have access to workers with the skills they need and local people can benefit from the opportunities being created. My honorable friend was also right to recognize the strengths of Derby, from rail, automotive, aerospace to nuclear power. Alongside the Team Derby initiative, those strengths demonstrate the benefits of bringing together industry, skills, and investment to support growth.

Now, as we've already heard, across the UK, manufacturing contributed 229 billion pounds to the economy last year and supported two and a half million jobs, with advanced manufacturing alone supporting around 770,000 jobs. But we need to prepare for the future. 36 percent of the manufacturing workforce is aged over 50, and Skills England projects demand for around 148,000 workers in priority occupations in advanced manufacturing by 2035, reflecting both growth and the need to replace those leaving the sector.

And that's why skills are central to our approach to growth in every postcode. We're investing more than 1 billion pounds in sector skills packages, including 182 million pounds for engineering, to strengthen technical training and build the workforce needed by advanced manufacturing and other growth-driving sectors. But my honourable friend also made a wide, an important wider point. As well as creating the skilled workforce businesses need to grow, we also need to ensure that young people have the opportunities they need to start, stay, and succeed in these high-demand sectors. And the opposition spokesman talked about youth unemployment.

I'd remind him that between 2021 and 2024, the number of young people not in employment, education, and training rose by a quarter of a million, and they did nothing. And that's why we're reforming vocational routes for young people, including apprenticeships and technical education, investing in technical excellence in colleges, strengthening careers education, and expanding work experience to help young people move from education into skilled employment. As my honourable friend for Portsmouth North said, we need clear technical pathways beginning before young people make crucial choices and continuing into further education, apprenticeships, and skilled work. And that starts with technical education from age 14 on an equal footing with academic education, helping more young people access technical qualifications alongside their GCSEs, careers guidance, and relevant work experience. And we've, I won't because I'm very short on time, if I have time later I will.

We've also announced new vocational GCSEs, giving young people greater choice and equipping them with practical knowledge and skills. After GCSEs, young people need routes that are easy to understand and valued by employers. This week is T-levels week, and these qualifications in engineering and manufacturing combine specialist classroom learning with a substantial industry placement, giving students experience of the workplace and a route into skilled employment, apprenticeship, or further study. And from 2028, V-levels in engineering design and engineering manufacturing will provide a broader applied route, whilst occupational certificates will offer two-year routes towards skilled roles such as engineering operative, autocare technician, and welder. And foundation certificates, I won't for a moment, will help students who need additional preparation before progressing to level 3 study.

Together, these reforms will provide greater choice and clearer progression into manufacturing careers. And we'll give way to my honourable friend.

01:22:37 - 01:23:15

Craig Gareth Snell

I thank the Secretary of State. I declare my interest as the governor of the Chichester College Group. Can I just say to the minister on V-levels, the last government decimated the BTEC programme, which is where the gap came that the V-levels are filling. But V-levels are going to be short qualifications as opposed to large qualifications that mirror BTECs. I know the department are looking at the rollout for future V-levels.

Could she take back that a large qualification for V-levels that can be studied independently rather than being alongside A-levels or requiring three for a university application would be a way of making that breadth of opportunity mirror what BTECs did, but still with the values that the V-levels that the government are going to try and introduce.

01:23:15 - 01:25:46

Speaker 44

I thank my honourable friend for the point he makes, and the whole point is that we want to offer young people a range of different options and choices.

And apprenticeships will remain central to that offer because they allow people to earn while they learn and help employers develop the skills they need. I know that there are calls for the maximum funding band levels to be reassessed in certain occupational areas and we're working closely with the sector and with Skills England to determine how best to use all available funding sources based on robust evidence of cost of delivery. Transforming the apprenticeship levy into a growth and skills levy is giving employers greater flexibility and supporting 50,000 more young people into apprenticeships. New apprenticeship units will also help the system respond more quickly to changing skills needs and I'm grateful to the honorable member for Taunton and Wellington for recognizing that apprenticeship units in battery manufacturing, mechanical fitting and assembly, mechanized welding were developed by Skills England in just three months following consultation with employers and sector experts and I'm sure that the skills minister would be happy to meet with him to discuss the dedicated support that Skills England has established. We're also increasing support for employers.

We fully fund apprenticeship training for employers of all sizes for eligible young apprentices under 25 while smaller employers will receive a 2,000 pounds hiring payment when they recruit an apprentice under 25. And that support matters particularly to smaller manufacturers who are vital to local supply chains but can find it harder to meet the initial cost of recruiting and supporting an apprentice. Now alongside clearer routes and strong apprenticeships, colleges need the specialist facilities, equipment and teaching expertise required by modern manufacturing. And that's why we've established four advanced manufacturing technical excellence colleges including as my honorable friend for Wolverhampton North East highlighted in her city. They're part of a wider network of 29 technical excellence colleges representing an investment of 295 million pounds expected to benefit more than 100,000 learners by the end of this parliament.

Providing advanced facilities, expert teaching and training shaped by employer demand and through a hub and spoke approach they'll also share expertise with other providers strengthening technical education beyond their own campuses. Now a key part of very briefly.

01:25:46 - 01:26:17

Perran Moon

And very briefly I do thank her for giving way. Much of the announcements that have been made over the last two months relating to post-14 skills have been largely targeted at mayoral combined authority or mayoral strategic authorities. 48% of the country is not in a mayoral combined authority and Cornwall we never will be in a mayoral combined authority. Does she agree that we need to ensure that that skills and that flexibility the funding and the flexibility for post-14 skills needs to be spread across every postcode and not just in mayoral combined authorities?

01:26:17 - 01:28:54

Speaker 44

Well he obviously has preempted what I was going on to talk about which is that a key part of our approach is about shifting power, funding and accountability away from Westminster. And we will work with both mayoral and strategic authorities in shaping their local skills system and supporting economic growth in their regions. And I can assure him that that will apply in Cornwall just as it applies with the opportunity to work with our mayors in the West Midlands, in West Yorkshire and in South Yorkshire as colleagues asked. We want to design locally tailored vocationally focused pathways for each region and we know that strategic authorities are well placed to bring together employers, schools, colleges, strengthen the links between education and work and help broker relevant work experience. And as my honorable friend for Mansfield highlighted they can build on existing successful partnerships such as that between Nottingham Trent University and West Notts College.

They can connect skills decisions with their understanding of local investment, workforce demand and the need of employers. And that really matters because the opportunities available on the Isle of Wight are not the same as those in Derby, Stoke-on-Trent, Mansfield, Lichfield, Cornwall, Doncaster, Portsmouth, Wolverhampton, Lancashire, Alloa and Grangemouth, Taunton and Wellington, Glasgow, Cambridge or indeed Meriden and Solihull. And local leaders can shape delivery around the strengths and needs of their economies. And in fact I hope that the devolved government in Scotland is listening carefully to the points made by my honorable friends.

I'll draw my remarks to a conclusion now, Sir Christopher. My honourable friend rightly highlighted both the success of manufacturing on the Isle of Wight and the importance of investing in the workforce that will sustain it. And the businesses that honourable members across the country have described demonstrate that world-class advanced manufacturing can thrive and create skilled jobs across the country. But that's only half the job. And investing in the skills that power it is what turns ambition into long-term economic success.

That's already visible on the Isle of Wight, showing what's possible. And our task now is to ensure that more people, particularly young people in all parts of the country, have the skills and opportunities to be part of that success. I know there will be a number of questions raised by colleagues, and I haven't had chance to address, but I'm sure that my honourable friend, the Minister for Skills, will listen to their representations and perhaps write to them on any specifics. Thank you.

01:28:54 - 01:29:40

Richard Quigley

Very quickly. Thank you, Sir Christopher. I'd also like to thank the Minister for her response, as well as the engagement from members across the House, with the exception of the shadow minister who appears to be in cloud cuckoo land. I think the shared enthusiasm for growing and nurturing our manufacturing skills sector is something we should all be excited about. And I think the call to action today for us all to make apprenticeships as exciting and as desirable as university and say it's okay to learn a trade.

To conclude, I look forward to tutoring colleagues across the House so they too can find out how to create a powerhouse for manufacturing skills in their constituencies. They're the world-class businesses, the thriving skills support group from education establishments helping us develop the next generation of engineers and manufacturers. I suspect they may find it harder than we make it look on the Isle of Wight.

01:29:40 - 01:30:04

Speaker 47

Question is that this House has considered manufacturing skills. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.

The next debate. And I call Angus MacDonald to move the motion.

01:30:04 - 01:31:20

Angus Francis MacDonald

It is a pleasure to chair under your chairmanship, Sir Christopher. I am very... don't know if this is on, is that on? I'm very glad to have been able to bring forward this debate on long duration energy storage systems. And I would like to take this opportunity to focus on pumped storage and the cost benefit of hosting this technology in the Highlands of Scotland. The Highlands and Islands hope to benefit from the new Prime Minister's growth in every postcode plan.

However, we do not have defense, AI, a tech sector, or financial industry to rely on. Our major industry is tourism, which suffers from a short season and low pay in hospitality, an industry that is struggling. Now I wrote to Mr. Burnham recently and laid out some harrowing facts. Remote Scotland has a 30% higher cost of living and a 10% lower income than urban Scotland, while we have seen a dramatic drop in school rolls and a 71% increase in the number of people over the age of 75. Now I represent Inverness, Skye and West Ross, and it would be difficult to find another part of the UK with a greater interest in renewables.

01:31:20 - 01:31:21

We have the wind.

01:31:21 - 01:31:22

On that point.

01:31:22 - 01:31:23

On that point, yeah.

01:31:23 - 01:31:53

Jim Shannon

Just to give the honorable member encouragement, we see the incredible potential for this in Northern Ireland, where a hundred million pound joint venture in Enagh is set to build a massive 150 megawatt storage facility capable of powering 36,000 homes. So does the honorable member agree that government must aggressively, and I use the word aggressively, support those multi-day storage systems right across the United Kingdom, working hand in hand with devolved nations to modernize our grid infrastructure?

01:31:53 - 01:35:52

Angus Francis MacDonald

Thank you for that intervention. I think what you've hit the nail on the head, there is not enough in it for the communities to generate, to benefit from these, and this pumped storage seems to be as good a way of providing electricity as we could find. So in the Highlands, we have the wind, the water, and the geography that make the Highlands so important to our national energy system. We have been producing hydroelectricity for the rest of the country for generations, and we now have the opportunity to store much more of it as well. The Highlands already generates 12 times the amount of electricity it needs, but we have one of the highest level of fuel poverty in Britain.

Go figure, as my children would say. Alex Salmond, when he was First Minister of Scotland, declared that Scotland could become the Saudi Arabia of renewables. Yes, the hills of Scotland are covered in wind turbines, but they are manufactured abroad and are often owned by overseas utilities. From a multi-billion pound industry, Scotland's communities only got 30 million pound of community benefit last year, and the Highlands only got 7 million pound. That is just 30 pounds per head of population in the Highlands.

Now the Highlands already generates almost 8 gigawatts of renewable electricity per year, roughly a third from hydroelectricity and two thirds from onshore wind. So even before factoring in pumped storage, we play an important role in the electrification of the UK. I've said before in this House that I want the Highlands to benefit properly from the enormous value of its natural resources. I was hopeful about onshore wind investment and the jobs and opportunities it could bring, but in practice, it's been minimal. The proposed pumped storage projects are now the only remaining chance I can see to bring proper money into my left-behind part of Britain.

Now why does electricity storage really matter? Well, long duration storage has an important role in our energy future, and the Highlands has a particular ability to help deliver it. We need to be able to store electricity when there's plenty of it and to use that when we need it. Now batteries play an important role in managing shorter periods, but we need technologies capable of supplying electricity for much longer stretches. Pumped storage is a proven technology capable of providing large amounts of electricity for long periods.

These are long-life infrastructure assets expected to operate for more than a century. It uses electricity to pump water from a lower reservoir to a higher reservoir, when electricity is required, water is released through the turbines. As you can imagine with our geography, the Highlands is very well placed for this. Our lochs, hills, and mountains allow us to create the height differences that pumped storage require. The technical term is hydraulic head.

In simple terms, the greater the height difference between the reservoirs, the more energy you can produce from the same amount of water. Now this summer, Ofgem announced that they had provisionally approved three pumped storage sites in the Highlands: Coire Glas near Invergarry, Loch Kemp near Loch Ness, and Loch Earba quite near Newtonmore. These three sites will produce a collective 4 gigawatts of electricity.

That is three times as much as Greater Manchester uses. The development cost will be over five billion pounds, by far the biggest infrastructure investment ever seen in the Highlands. And there are three more pump storage sites that are keen to get Ofgem's go-ahead, namely Loch Fearna near Invergarry, and Loch Ericht and Loch Cathrach on Loch Ness.

01:35:52 - 01:36:37

Speaker 54

On that point. I thank the honourable member for giving way. He mentioned Loch Errochty, which is in my constituency, but the point he makes about the number that are included in the Ofgem list at the moment and the number that we could actually build and get benefit from differs quite significantly. And as well as being in the Highlands, there are some in the Lowlands as well, in Dumfriesshire and other areas that could benefit from government investment of time and effort into getting them on stream. Does he agree with me that we absolutely need to maximise the use of extremely reliable and an extremely well-tested and known technology of hydro?

01:36:37 - 01:37:56

Angus Francis MacDonald

Thank you very much, and thank you for that intervention. I think it's actually a far better source of electricity than wind. It is much less visual impact, and it's available when we really need it. So we have quite a lot of wind, but it's very dependent on the wind blowing. NESO's Future Energy Scenarios 2025 suggests that Britain could need between 13.2 and 16.6 gigawatts of long-duration storage by 2050.

These sites, these six sites, will go a long way to provide that. Now, the second point I wish to make is the implication for the electricity market and the people paying their bills. One aspect of this is the way the wholesale electricity market works, and excuse me for stating the obvious, but gas still sets the price of electricity when gas-fired generation is needed, even at a time when a great deal of electricity is coming from renewable sources. Mains gas is 8p a kilowatt at the moment, whereas electricity is 26p per kilowatt, more than three times as much. Broadly speaking, people in rural areas do not have mains gas across the whole of the UK.

01:37:56 - 01:38:02

Speaker 51

And in my patch, only those in Inverness city and Dingwall get mains gas.

01:38:02 - 01:38:44

Julie Minns

He raises a very valid point about his constituents who are off-gas. I have a number likewise in my Carlisle constituency, and recently the committee of a village hall, Hallbankgate Village Hall, came to talk to me about their ambition to move off the heating oil system and install solar, but to save, to store the energy, the heat, in a sand battery. Now, I don't know if my honourable friend has come across this, but does he agree with me that whatever the scale, be it pump, be it small sand batteries, that the government's long-term storage strategy needs to be technology-neutral so we maximise as many of these different technologies as possible?

01:38:44 - 01:39:12

Angus Francis MacDonald

Thank you, until I got your email yesterday I had certainly never heard of it, and sand is not one of the big features of my constituency, but thank you, and I do agree we should look at all sorts of technologies. The bottom line is that Britain will only transition to electricity, will not transition to electricity when it costs three times as much as carbon-fuel imported gas does. I think that is the bottom line.

01:39:12 - 01:39:28

Speaker 52

I thank the honourable member for taking an intervention. The member states that electricity prices is considerably higher than gas. So when you make the argument that gas is setting the price for electricity, can you explain why the price of gas was so low compared to electricity?

01:39:28 - 01:44:42

Angus Francis MacDonald

I will make a brief attempt, but there is a much more eloquent gentleman over there who will do that.

But as I as I understand it, the the tariffs and the distribution charges etc. go on the electricity, the the home-produced renewable electricity and not the carbon-fuel imported gas, which in my opinion is the wrong way round. But I'm sure the minister will will enlighten us in a bit more detail. Um, there is another problem, which is constraint payments, when we are when we're paying to stop renewable electricity being produced. When the electricity network cannot carry power from where it is being produced to where it is needed, the system's operator has to intervene. And that means paying wind farms to reduce their output.

The National Audit Office says transmission constraint costs reached 1.9 billion over the last year, with an expectation this could be as high as 8 billion by 2030. This is a shocking waste of taxpayers' money, and hopefully pumped storage will reduce this. Now, what is the opportunity for Scotland? Well, pumped storage is very expensive to build, and historically it has been difficult for developers to secure private finance because future electricity market revenues are uncertain. And the UK government has introduced the cap and floor scheme to unlock investment in this type of infrastructure.

The floor provides a minimum level of revenue certainty, and if a project's market revenues fall below the agreed floor, support is provided to cover the gap, funded through consumer bills. And the cap limits the excess revenue. If a project earns above the agreed level, excess returns are returned to the consumer through lower network charges. Now, there is an opportunity for Scotland to develop a serious industry around pumped storage. The benefits are not just the electricity stored at the end of construction.

There is the civil engineering, the tunnel, the electrical equipment required, billions of pounds worth. But given this, can we ensure that a significant amount of this supply chain work will remain in Scotland, or even in Britain? Are we educating our young with the skills they need to be employed in these multi-billion pound infrastructures? I really don't believe we are. So I want to move on to community benefits.

Do the communities impacted by wind farms and pumped storage sites welcome them? They absolutely do not. I've attended hostile meetings of the Convention of Community Councils with hundreds of attendees, and the DESNZ and Scottish government ministers have declined to attend. There is very much a feeling in the Highlands that this is being done to us. If locals had jobs at these projects, if there was legacy housing being built rather than temporary modular constructions, and if the communities got significant community benefit, or even better were shareholders, then I guarantee there would be much better support.

When we ask communities to host major infrastructure, it should be beneficial to these communities. And this is particularly important to the Highlands, where our fuel costs are prohibitive, where major developments can be very visible, where the costs of providing public sector services are high, and we have a serious problem with the availability of housing and opportunities for young people to stop them needing to emigrate to the cities. I welcome the Scottish government's recent proposal to bring pumped storage hydro within its updated community benefit. But making that guidance voluntary will result in an underwhelming consequence. Now to cover Glen Earrach, and I think this is a real model case study, and it has not yet received Ofgem's provisional approval.

Glen Earrach is an example of the scale of opportunity we have.

It has an expected operating life of approximately 125 years. It has 34 gigawatt hours of storage capacity with around 1.8 gigawatt of generating capacity, and its hydraulic head of 500 meters makes good use of the geography of the site to store large amounts of electricity efficiently. It is committed to putting 5% of its annual gross margin into a community wealth fund. The estimate is that this fund could receive 20 million pounds a year. And if you compare that, Scotland only getting, the Highlands only getting 7 million, so 20 million from one project shows how significant that is.

The Highland Council said that fund could be worth around 3 billion pounds in today's money over the 125 year operating period. Glenmuck has bravely volunteered a model where its host community will share in its success, and I strongly urge the government to recognize this as a model that can be adopted by other developments.

01:44:42 - 01:44:44

Speaker 56

Will the honorable gentleman accept?

01:44:44 - 01:44:45

I would be delighted.

01:44:45 - 01:45:21

Speaker 61

I'm really grateful to my honorable friend who's making a typically excellent cogent argument for stronger community benefit from these projects. Would he agree with me that as well as pumped storage, a cousin of that technology might be tidal range energy? In the west of Scotland, as the west of England has the highest tidal range in the world, second highest tidal range in the world, and it's a missed opportunity not to exploit tidal range energy as it is not to develop the community benefit programs that he's proposing.

01:45:21 - 01:45:41

Angus Francis MacDonald

I have always believed that tide is probably the single best energy source because it's entirely predictable and it operates well in the estuaries where our cities are. So we don't need to transform it, but I am not up to date, but I do think it's something we should really concentrate on.

01:45:41 - 01:45:43

Speaker 55

Are you allowed two interventions?

01:45:43 - 01:45:46

Speaker 57

Yes, it's a quiet debate, so it's fine.

01:45:46 - 01:46:03

Speaker 54

I would add to that geothermal. There's huge opportunity for geothermal in the Aberdeenshire area in particular, but also in other parts of Scotland. And I think geothermal and tidal stream is something that the government could focus more attention at the moment. Would he agree with that sentiment?

01:46:03 - 01:47:16

Angus Francis MacDonald

Thank you. I think we will hopefully have all these different renewable energy sources coming through, but geothermal is a big one. So just to sum up, we have an enormous opportunity in rural Scotland to facilitate the electrification of Britain. Long duration storage can help us make better use of the renewable electricity we generate. It can improve the security of supply and support a more efficient electricity system.

Rural Scotland plays a role in enabling Britain to achieve its net zero ambitions. However, the impact on our communities is currently almost entirely negative. It's like telling the inhabitants of Norway or Aberdeen in the 1970s that there will be an oil and gas boom, but the locals should not benefit from it. As things stand, these multi-billion pound pumped storage sites will produce few local jobs, no legacy housing, and minimal community benefit for the people of the Highlands, and that is completely unacceptable. Pumped storage sites are an essential part of our national energy portfolio.

01:47:16 - 01:47:21

Speaker 59

They are great for Britain. Let's make them great for the Highlands too. Thank you.

01:47:21 - 01:47:26

Speaker 58

The question is that this House has considered long duration electricity storage systems. Minister.

01:47:25 - 01:53:11

Michael Shanks

Thank you very much, Sir Christopher. It's a pleasure as always to serve under your chairmanship. Can I thank the honorable gentleman for bringing this debate? He and I have talked about this many many times, but I never tire of it because as he has rightly said in his speech, it is an incredibly exciting opportunity for the Highlands and an important opportunity for the country. And I always know, Sir Christopher, that winter is coming because the honorable gentleman's jumpers make a reappearance and I'm a big fan of them, and it's great to see him here today.

He's also a great champion of his constituency, which is an enormous part of Scotland that he represents, although having run the RSA to Mallaig half marathon, I would say he does have a significant amount of very beautiful sand in his constituency, in fact. This has been an interesting debate, not least as I'll come on to on the points he raises about long duration energy storage, but we've heard of the cousins of pumped hydro as well, of sand batteries, which is an interesting idea about how we store energy through thermal, through heat, rather than in more conventional ways. But I think the wider point around the importance of storage and of being technology agnostic to the new technologies that are coming on all the time and becoming ever ever more developed is really important. We need in our system a significant amount of flexibility to be able to store and to utilize the clean power we're generating when we need it most, and we should be open to a whole range of technologies. So I'm very happy to have more conversations about all of those.

On the issue of long duration electricity storage, the honorable gentleman I think made the case very strongly for why this is so important. We have over decades now built a significant amount of renewable energy generation across the UK, offshore and onshore, but we haven't kept pace with being able to store that electricity for when we need it most, which has meant our electricity system is not being able to get the full benefit of the clean, cheap, secure power that is being generated every single day. In fact, we're having to, as the honorable gentleman himself said, spend significant amounts of money constraining that renewable capacity because we didn't build the grid and we haven't built the storage that's necessary. And so our transition to being able to deploy that clean power on the system when we need it does require much more flexibility, and that comes from long duration energy storage. Now, pumped hydro projects, I visited Cruachan recently.

This is a well-trodden path of technology we've deployed for a very long time, that lasts for a very long time, is an important part of how we deliver long duration energy storage, and it will play a critical role in balancing supply and demand. In June, Ofgem published its minded-to list for window one of the cap and floor scheme, which is a significant milestone for the sector. And I'd just say to the honorable gentleman from Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey, completing our double act of long constituency titles, I agree with him about the ambition on long duration energy storage, but I'd also say this is the first long duration energy storage we've built in Britain in 40 years. And it is a significant amount. Seven and a half gigawatts of capacity is not nothing.

So we remain really ambitious. He's right to say the future scenarios require even more long duration energy storage, but this is a remarkable turnaround from a 40-year gap in building any of these projects anywhere in the country. Sixteen projects Ofgem has provisionally selected. Ofgem has made minded-to decisions, but there has been a consultation process which has been running, and that will conclude. Three of these projects are pumped storage hydropower in Scotland, representing over half of the capacity that LDES has brought forward, and Ofgem will announce its final decision on those projects by the end of this year.

These projects, when they are delivered, will reduce costs for consumers by being able to maximize our renewable energy generation to make it available when we need it at peak times and reducing our reliance on natural gas, which of course is the part of constraints that is often misunderstood in the press. The cost doesn't come from turning off wind, the cost comes from turning up gas somewhere else in the country. And if we deploy this LDES in the way that we intend to, we will be able to reduce that dependence on costly gas generation. Now, I understand the honorable gentleman agrees with me on the need for long duration energy storage, and we've had this conversation many times, but he also rightly wants to make sure that his community benefits from these projects being built.

The construction of these projects in themselves create a significant number of jobs over a period of several years, expected to begin by next year and continue into the early 2030s. One project which he mentions, Loch Earba, will create approximately 600 jobs over its five-year construction period, including at least 30 new apprenticeships. Another project, Loch Kemp, estimates 370 jobs in the Highlands at peak construction and has committed seven and a half million pounds to a community fund, and they've also committed to investing in projects like the Caledonian Canal and local roads. He also, the honourable gentleman, makes the point quite rightly about local supply chains and about making sure we are delivering as much of the economic benefit of these projects in local communities. This has been the single most important thing my department has been driving in two and a half years in the construction of these projects, is to no longer be agnostic about where we build things as a country, because we actually do care about industrial strategy.

And I've been very clear with all developers who expect to receive public money that they should be looking at every single part of their procurement to make sure even down to the smallest contracts they are procuring as locally as much as possible. And I recognise that that is a shift from where we have been for a long time as a country, but it's critically important because that's where we get supply chain jobs right across this constituency.

01:53:11 - 01:53:45

Angus Francis MacDonald

Thank you, Mr Christopher. The intervention, and you mentioned one of the pumped storage sites and the amount of money, seven and a half million pounds. That proposal is a single one-off payment. Now, for example, Glen Earrach is offering 20 million a year for 125 years, inflation-linked. So that's what we have to move to, I believe, is a year-after-year agreed, controlled by government, amount of money.

What do you think of that?

01:53:45 - 01:55:24

Michael Shanks

Yes, let me come onto that point because we've discussed this before. And look, my starting point here is that communities that host infrastructure should feel the benefit from that, and it should be meaningful benefits. We consulted on how we will deliver both community benefits and shared ownership opportunities for communities, and we've put a billion pounds into Great British Energy to make sure that there is the financial capacity for communities to take up that shared ownership offer, and we'll continue to push that. I've spoken before about the need for us to balance that, though, because ultimately all of the costs of building these projects is borne by consumers across the country. He and I share the objective to bring down bills as much as possible, and so there is a balance to be struck.

And I don't pretend that that is easy, because his community, and he's right to champion it, will rightly want more and more of those community benefits. My job is to balance that against the cost of these projects to make sure, first of all, they're economic and will be built, because that's important for the national interest, but secondly that they are built as affordably as possible so that we can bring down bills for everyone. So I think there is a balance to be struck, as I've said to him before. I know that he will always want us to go further, but I would just say the cap and floor scheme is designed not to provide huge public subsidy to make these projects happen, but to provide just the right amount to make them viable. And that is the key thing.

The cap and floor scheme is designed to be a viability mechanism, and so there is a risk that we end up using consumer bills to subsidise projects if we go too far. That doesn't mean I don't share his ambition, and I have been very clear with developers that we should see genuine community benefits coming forward and that those should be meaningful for communities.

01:55:24 - 01:56:01

Speaker 54

Very briefly. I'm raising these issues with colleagues in the Scottish Government as well, but whilst DESNZ has a role in this and Ofgem have a role as well, I think it's helpful for every organisation to be pushing the developers to say, what are you doing about the roads infrastructure, what are you doing about how you're getting people to and from the sites, because these are big influxes of people into areas and the local infrastructure can be lane-and-a-half roads and passing places and all of that.

So will he commit to putting some pressure on those companies to invest in that?

01:56:01 - 01:59:03

Michael Shanks

I thought he was going to conclude, Sir Christopher, by saying, well, I commit to putting some pressure on the Scottish government, which would be unlike him. But I agree with him, actually, and I've had a number of really productive conversations with Gillian Martin, the Scottish energy minister, on exactly this topic about how we can make these projects work for local communities. If we can bring that investment into local investment in roads and other infrastructure, it does leave that legacy that I think we all want to see in communities and is also of benefit to the projects where they will need to be some investment in road infrastructure anyway. Sir Christopher, just in summing up, I do want to just pick out two issues. First of all, I really welcome the honourable gentleman's recognition of how important long-duration energy storage is on our system.

The truth of the past few years has been a recognition that for decades we have had a consensus in building renewables across Scotland, but across the rest of Great Britain, but we did not spend the investment we should have in building the grid to connect that. We're now paying the cost for that. But equally, storage is absolutely central to how renewables can work on the system to give us the flexibility we need to deploy it when we need it most and to make sure that we are genuinely bringing the cleaner, cheaper power to homes and businesses when we need it, which is how we bring down bills. But it also has to be the foundation of delivering economic growth. He rightly recognised the Prime Minister's commitment to growth in every postcode.

Energy policy doesn't exist in a vacuum. It is part of our industrial strategy. We're building these extraordinarily important projects that will last for over a century or more. There has to be some legacy for the communities from those projects and we have to bring people with us on this journey. I frequently say in this place in particular, but in the House as well, that we do need to build infrastructure as a country.

That is important. But we should try to bring communities with us wherever we possibly can and community benefits and real investment is a critical part of that. The Scottish government is clearly a key partner in this given that planning decisions in Scotland are not for me but are for the Scottish government. And I know they have a shared ambition with me on both the importance of deploying long-duration energy storage but also of community benefits and they have guidance in this matter and we're working together on this. And so whether it is through community benefit funds, through the bill discounts we've announced in terms of electricity infrastructure and ongoing work that we're doing to make sure there's an industrial benefit from these projects, I hope he recognises that while we might not get everything quite at the extent that he would like, these projects are an opportunity for communities to benefit from construction and from community benefits and from, I hope, a genuine lasting legacy.

But importantly for us as a country, this is how we deliver the secure, homegrown, clean power that we need on the system, how we can bring down bills for people and how we can, importantly, continue the transition to net zero, which is so important. And I commend the honourable gentleman again and I look forward to what I am certain will be further conversations on this in due course. Thank you.

01:59:03 - 01:59:15

Speaker 6

The question is that this House has considered long-duration electricity storage systems. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

Order, order. The sitting is suspended until 2:30 p.m.