Education Committee and Work and Pensions Committee
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Education Committee and Work and Pensions Committee House of Commons
Speaker 2
So obviously we talk to children not just for this piece of work for the poverty strategy. So we've done a massive piece of work recently, the Children's Plan, where we talk to, you know, thousands and thousands, think we had ninety eight thousand children with special educational needs. So we talked to children and I've just published yesterday a piece of work of children who can't get out of hospital often because of poverty issues, because care packages aren't working. So we really have dug deep. But I would say the data is so difficult.
It's so difficult to know who these children If you ask me is, you know, in deep material poverty, is it, for example, asylum seeking children? Well, we know children from families seeking asylum are more likely to be in poverty but we don't know the exact figures and the data is not great. So I think my challenge would be we've got to get better at the data on who these children are. We know most children who fall into the poverty category are British born. We know that.
But it actually was quite a challenge to make sure we had, you know, really understood understood who these children were and that was why we went out and talked to them.
Speaker 3
Thank you so much. Last year you said that there was an almost Dickensian level of poverty facing children today. So do you feel that the child poverty strategy contains the right policies to begin to address this and solve solve the problem of child poverty?
Speaker 2
Yeah. So look, think again I was pleased to see the child poverty strategy identify children in deep material poverty. And when I talked about Dickensian poverty and gave those examples, that's exactly what I was talking about. I think it goes some way. I was pleased to see the two child limit lifted.
I argued for that. That was a change for me. And my experience of talking to children over the years and seeing things change, up to 2021 to '23, actually made me think this is actually the best way, you know, the most efficient and widest reach way of doing this. So I was pleased to see that. I was pleased to see Family Hubs.
I think that that is putting back in that service bit. And I was pleased to see the B and B, the limit on six weeks. Now, do I think it goes far enough? I think there's some great vision there. I think there are a lot of initiatives, but what will really lift children out of poverty, I think, is making sure and this is the bit that's hard to do and as a you know, I was a Tony Blair's sixty ninth academy principal.
So actually was there when we did that piece of work of actually eradicating child poverty the first time. Do I think that we do I think this goes far enough? I think we need whole scale reform and accountability and investment into developing local services. Until we have a proper outcomes framework that all public service leaders are working to in local areas, we're not going to be able to deliver this because children do not say, Hi, I'm here. I'm afraid.
I'm poor. What children do is they know if, you know, they can't afford their dinner, if their school's not very good, if they're waiting for a health appointment, if they're you know, it's these it's how we're delivering local services that really impacts on children's experience. I don't want to pathologize low income low income families. I was from a low income family and had a great upbringing. But when things go wrong or when services aren't working, that's where it gets difficult.
So I think child poverty strategy is a start, but there is a lot more to do.
Speaker 3
The best way to have a long term impact on addressing child poverty is to invest in public services.
Speaker 2
Public services that work together locally properly because I think I did a piece of work in Manchester for Andy Burnham on running his attendance alliance a couple of years ago. And we got it to move but I got all the big heads in room. So 400 schools but also nurses, doctors, police, social care and what I realised was that none of them were seeing each other's data and none of them had a shared outcomes framework. And that's the bit we need to grip if we're going to make a poverty strategy work, which we should.
Speaker 4
Thank you. Interested what you're saying there about what more needs to be done. I guess my question is, does the strategy do enough to lift children from the deepest poverty, moving them from just below the poverty threshold to just above it? Is there what specifically more needs to be done to make sure they're above that threshold rather than just below it? Okay.
I'm gonna
Speaker 2
yeah. So I think obviously lifting the two child limit is a really, really important move in terms of impacting on the largest number of children. But and I think I've talked there also about a really needing a really outcomes framework and public service, public public sector really working to make sure all the things that feel like poverty to a child are Now, I'd say two things. One is we I think we need to give local authorities more scope to be able to intervene with things like emergency funds, I think, to make sure that no child is facing a situation of, you know, because of something that happens of terrible poverty. But I think we then need to get really ambitious and that's this is in answer to your question.
You know, when I a couple of years ago, I did a family review, an independent family review for the government and the families in this country, low income ones as much as others said, you know, when they when they felt the thing that mattered most to them was their family, when they felt they needed something, they wanted to turn to family first, friends, they wanted services to feel local, familial, they wanted to work, they were ambitious for their children, you know. And when it comes to children, our ambition should have no limit. So, you know, what would a really ambitious poverty strategy like? It would be it would be an outstanding education for every child. It would be and I'm really pleased to see in the latest school's white paper and send send white paper, we're now talking about bringing back statutory additional help because I surveyed every single head teacher in this country and they who are committed to this, let's be ambitious children.
And they said their five biggest worries, you know, there was social media online world, there was mental health services. Then I was absolutely shocked. They were more concerned concerned about the budgets of wider services for children than they were of their own budgets. Now, as a former head teacher, to get 90% of head teachers to say that is pretty incredible because we normally just moan it's our budgets, right? I think there's something quite strong and powerful in putting the additional needs that we need around a school to support children so that they actually can have that outstanding education.
And let me absolutely underline the importance of education because, you know, most of your childhood is spent in school. When I speak I've spoke to a million children. I'm about to survey a million more in my final year. And the thing they say to me is, when I ask them, is your mom worried about putting food on the table? Every hand goes up.
When I ask them, you know, when I'm going around the country, when I ask them, what's your ambition? What do you want to be? It's everything from prime minister to engineer to whatever and it's like, and how do I get there? And how do we get there? So it's that how can we really, really rocket boost that ambition for the children and for the families.
Speaker 5
Thank you, Kirk. Thank you. You've mentioned data already and the challenge with with data and knowing exactly what's going on on the ground. Do you think government we generally know enough about how child poverty affects different groups? In particular, I'm thinking those with SEND.
Speaker 2
Yeah. Yeah. I don't I think I think right. First off, I there's different ways of knowing. So there are number there's the numbers of knowing and then there's the deep qualitative work that shows us how children actually experience it.
So to give you and I've been very involved in trying to support the Send White Paper. We did launched a big children's plan that floated lots of the ideas that came through to the Send White Paper earlier in the year. We for example, one group that I'd completely missed, I knew the numbers but I completely missed were that I published on yesterday, were children serious illnesses and disabilities who are not getting the care plans they need, so they're either stuck in hospital or when they are and I mean, I had examples that I never thought I'd see, like one mum telling her child has died now, but for three years she had a very sick son who she wanted at home and he had an oxygen tank to help him breathe and she had narrow stairs. For three years, while she was waiting for the local authority to get her a lift or sort her stairs out, she used to have to take his oxygen tank off at the bottom of the stairs so he couldn't breathe, take him upstairs, then put it back on again for three years. Now no number is gonna tell you that.
Right? And so I think the work we did for this, I think, is a model for every piece of policy we're doing about children and groups of children in which we've got to go out and speak to them because we will find things that totally surprise us and take our breath away actually with how, you know, and what parents are putting up with.
Speaker 6
Thank you. Thank you, chair. So do in your opinion, do you think that the the strategy include appropriate interventions to address the differences regionally and locally, but also different groups. So for example, I represent a very rural constituency where children live in isolated villages, houses are off grid as well, so families are not even protected from the energy cup. And and where the the the use of the food bank has just gone up so much.
And some anti poverty organizations are calling for auto enrollment, for example, of free school meals so that you catch all the children. What is your thought on that? Yes.
Speaker 2
Yeah. Look, I think the strategy is a good first step vision and it sets a direction and I think I've identified some of the things that I think are good in it, but I think it absolutely isn't exhaustive and and I think my if I've got one strong point, it's that, you know, we need a target of zero for, you know, deep material poverty. And in order to get that, we need local plans and local and those local plans, you know, for public services to ensure that that they are delivering to the particular needs of every child. And and, you know, I hear that, you know, in different parts of the country. We see different problems in different parts of the country.
So I would say, good start. Intentions are right, but it's got to be built on, you know, it's got to be built on deep reform, in local areas. It can't just be a great discussion up here. Many poverty strategies have died in rooms like this. They're great but actually they must not be built on sand.
Speaker 7
Thank you so much and good morning Dame Rachel. I think I've you've just mentioned what you think about targets. I was going to refer to a recent paper that's out in the BMJ from professors Dale wrote David Taylor Robinson and Kate Pickett who are making exactly that that point. And compare, for example, how when the legally bound targets that were in the child poverty strategy previously, those countries that have carried on have seen massive reductions, ongoing reductions in child poverty such as Canada, and New Zealand. So if if you thinking back to your, answer to Manuela then, you agree that there should be, targets.
Do you think that they should be legally bound and and also have have a time frame around them?
Speaker 2
So, you know, I have had, as children's commissioner, the great opportunity. I've been able to go look at child poverty and child services in both Canada and Australia, as well as in The Nordics and in Europe. So have seen some of those differences. And, of course, we are a different country that have had different made different choices and had different economic shocks at different times. You know, and I was there, first time around and saw us eradicate child poverty and the commitment to that.
So I and I'm also, you know, I am a former academy principal and trust leader and I do believe targets can be deeply motivating if they're done right, and thought through properly. And I'm always in favor of you've got to measure it, you know, we've got to be know what we're working for. So I am very positive about targets. But the only thing I would say is the two thousands were really, really different from now in terms of where the public sector is. And I think there is a job to do as well that is building back the public sector locally and working together and and accountability on leadership.
Otherwise, we will set targets and nothing will happen underneath. So I think at I I think I am in favor of targets. Legally bound, I choose my time to do that. I would be if I was making decisions, I'd be investing like mad in developing public sector leadership, working together on the ground, an outcomes framework and then, you know, apps and really clear measurements so we know exactly how many children we've got, what we're dealing with, what the groups are, then absolutely let's have some really tough targets for motivate us and get it worked towards because no child should be living in deep material poverty in this country.
Speaker 7
Also, another paper specifically on targets before the strategy was out. I take your point. I think it's a very wise point to make in terms of the timing. But what we currently have is a not particularly ambitious program with no targets which may reduce about 10% of child poverty. In the paper that modeled what would would be the outcomes, and you talked about outcome frame framework of a 35% reduction in child poverty.
They've estimated that total decreases in infant mortality of two ninety three children. Children who are looked after massive outcome which, you mustn't forget these children, a reduction of nearly 5,000 children looked after children and a reduction in emergency admissions of nearly 33,000 a year. So massive impacts around that. Do you have ultimately, when we do think about targets, do you have in in mind what we should you mentioned zero. I think we didn't achieve those in the previous strategy even in the good times.
What do you have in mind in terms of what you think is a realistic realistic target? Target?
Speaker 2
So again, I'm sticking with zero for deep material poverty because we're the sixth richest nation in the country in the world and we should be able to do it. And I'm not going to budge on it. It would be immoral of me to say otherwise. But I do one of the reasons I've been talking about an outcomes framework at local level is to address just the things you're talking about, which is, you know, only, one in five children in relative poverty achieve five good grades at GCSE whereas it's, you know, seventy five, seventy six percent, you know, of other children. We absolutely should be narrowing the gap educationally and in health outcomes.
I mean, I could sit and plot the targets for you, but basically, we should narrow the there should be no gap and we should have a set of targets that narrow the gap. But I'm sticking on deep material poverty, and I hope everyone in this room will, to 0% because they're really what I have seen and what we have seen we just shouldn't allow.
Speaker 8
Yeah thanks and good morning. Just in terms of the implementation now of the strategy, do you think there is enough practical detail in the strategy to support its implementation over the ten year period?
Speaker 2
Yeah. Look, I could get into nuts and bolts about the strategy, but my simple answer is no. Because I think what needs I think there's good intention, but I think what we need now to do is to pull the whole public sector to sit underneath it with a really strong framework for delivery. And I think we need to we need to we need to really unpack what we mean. We're talking about a poverty strategy, but I think we're talking about lots of different things.
And I think we need a strategy to deal with education gaps. And it's great to see the new, you know, the new white paper trying to do that. Gaps for kids with SEND and disabilities that and all the groups that cross into this group that we talk about when we talk about poverty. And that, again, is a whole public sector job. Housing, I mean, I think the, you know, with the housing plans, strategy, with the new white paper, we're starting to move in the right direction.
It's all it's pulling in the right place and it feels good like we're for the first time. To actually deliver this, I think it's it's gonna take a huge amount of detail and commitment from everyone. And you shouldn't be afraid of asking public sector leaders to deliver. We're yeah, everyone's paid quite a lot, you know, the leadership. We should be we should be challenging them and making sure that they are accountable and do deliver.
Speaker 3
Yeah. Thank you, Dame Rachel, for for coming in and your evidence so far. It struck me, you spoke about young people and talking about their aspirations and, you know, wanting to be the next prime minister or wanting to be a pilot or whoever it might be. And I think in my constituent of Harlow, you'd probably get that at primary school, then somewhere along the line, they would lose that ambition. So I think it's about how do we keep that.
My question specifically was on on the point you made about we must make sure. I think you used the phrase built in sand, I think is was was was really important. So what do you think will be necessary to ensure this child child poverty strategy is sustainable both for this part and but also for this part as well? Because surely what we need to do is get in place structures that could be eroded.
Speaker 2
At the risk of repeating myself, I think some of the most hopeful things I've seen so if we go top down or bottom up, you know, I think top down we've been talking about targets, measurement, really understanding the situation, using data to make sure we're narrowing the gaps, every single government department working towards that and pulling pulling in the same way every piece of legislation, here you know, making sure it hears from children so that it's it's, actually accurate and is is dealing with the real problem, not not what Westminster perceives the problem is. But then I think there's the bottom up bit, which is we have to build up real localism. And I say this in a completely non political way. Frankly, having seen it myself, you know, if the police aren't online with the with the GPs, with the with the teachers, with whatever in terms of understanding what we're trying to do with children, we're not gonna get anywhere. So I think there needs to be a real commitment to getting, you know, really good local working together.
And wrapping around that, I'm so pleased to see in the news, Send White Paper, that Brit Schools White Paper that we're actually starting to talk about again and I pushed really hard for this in the Children's Plan because of all those head teachers and children who've spoken to me about bringing additional needs back onto a statutory footing because not you know, we have to address what is genuinely holding kids back from achieving and thriving. So we, you know, that would be really important and again I think I said that but
Speaker 4
Thank you. What's your view about the government's decision to move the child poverty unit from the cabinet office to the DWP? Do you think that's going to make any impact at all? I
Speaker 2
mean, I think what really what we need is prime ministerial commitment. If there is proper prime ministerial commitment, you know, your commitment from the prime minister to to drive it around the cabinet table, I'm not going to be too you know, I'm not sure of the ins and outs as to you know, obviously cabinet obviously feels more central, but maybe d DWP is a recognition that lots of the decisions are around income and around supporting income. So I can see swings and roundabouts but I think if we've got prime minister prime minister number 10 and cabinet commitment to this, then it will happen. Do you think we have that? I'm hopeful.
Jess.
Speaker 9
In sort of similar vein, now the strategy has been published, do you think that this work is still a priority for secretaries of state? It's really important in what you've said that this is truly cross governmental. And I guess the nature of the question you've just heard is speaking to a concern that now it doesn't have that unit, that it will be less able to to kind of poke into, the prime minister in number 10, because people will think it's safe with one secretary of state at the DWP. And you'll know the nature of government is is that there are many other pressures on departments, and so essentially this might fall away and lose its priority. Do you have a concern that that's going to happen?
Speaker 2
So I think I go back to my last point. I've been blessed and challenged by working with many different governments and many different I was gonna say head teachers, many different prime ministers. Uh-huh. Yeah. And what for all for all the discussion, basically, what what that leadership believes is important is what happens.
It would be a travesty if child poverty wasn't absolutely top of that list with this particular government, I would say. And I'm heartened when I speak to, for example, Gordon Brown, who still, you know, retired on, is still phoning me up about child poverty every few weeks. I'm beaming in and talking to my children. That's the level of commitment I'd expect from this cabinet and this prime minister. I hope it despite the disbanding of the poverty unit, which seems a shame, I hope and it moving to that, I I hope that that remains.
And I certainly will be holding the cabinet and the prime minister to account on what they're doing on child poverty because that's my job.
Speaker 10
Thank you. Just lastly on this area. The the unit's been set in the DWP. So what mechanisms do we need to put in place to make sure it works in the DWP? The decision's been made.
Now what do we need to move it forward?
Speaker 2
Okay. So I think I think the the the really the thing coming from being a public sector leader, so an academy principal, a trust leader, a teacher a teacher for many years, for decades, to coming into Westminster was my absolute shock about siloed working. And when it how many times, whether it's a child like, you know, a child that's that's been killed and we do a review, you know, and what we say is, oh, joint working wasn't happening. And the only way to make joint working happen properly, multi agency work working happen properly on the ground is if we do it up here. And so I my exhortation to DWP would be to say, okay, it might have come to you but actually, it needs to be everyone and you need the power and be empowered to pull the levers to make sure that every single cabinet is thinking about child poverty and health will cancel it.
Otherwise, if they if you can't do that there, it's not gonna happen there.
Speaker 11
Thank you, chair. Good morning, Dame Rachel. In terms of monitoring and evaluating the strategy, the government's going to be publishing its first baseline report, it says, in summer. You said a moment ago you've got to measure it. So in your view, what should be set out in that baseline report?
Speaker 2
So if you want a proper technical answer to that, then I will write to the committee. If you want my, you know, and I'm happy to do that and I will do that and look at what's been promised and do it because I haven't got it at the top of my head. But I would say we what we can't just have is we delivered 25 initiatives and that's the danger. What we need to truly look at is how many children, who are the children and what are their outcomes in terms of education, in terms of, you know, the narrowing of the gap in education, in terms of health, in terms of disability, you know, we need to be I think we need far bigger we need to be looking at something far bigger than we've promised to do x initiative, Oh, yeah. And TIC would deliver it.
Because that isn't change on the ground that people feel, you know, people and children feel who are living with this. So I would go for the big the big the big things and involve the whole cabinet and say, look, this is our strategy. But I will write to you about about exactly what's been asked.
Speaker 11
I mean, that would be really welcome, I'm sure. Are there from the work that you did, the consultation with many hundreds of thousands of are there very clear key indicators that you think emerge from that work which which ought to be leading the monitoring and evaluation work?
Speaker 2
So some of the things that that struck me when when looking when looking around the world were just just again, and again, I'm very happy to share a more detailed but with anybody who wants to, but were in Australia was just how fantastic health were at leading multi agency working for poverty and children and they were it was amazing. Go to Brisbane Children's Hospital, unbelievable. Improving work on poverty, indigenous rights, just like fantastic. Just something we don't see. So I urge, urge all our bright paediatricians to be doing that.
In Canada, I think it was a really strong regional government and we did see saw that in Australia as well. You know my argument about localism? So being able to there are there are some problems if you've got a particularly difficult area like, say, Alice Springs in or the Northern Territories in Australia. But in the main, localism, really good local decision making, seem to produce far better outcomes. I think our data is really strong.
So although I've been criticizing us on data, looking around the world, our data's pretty good. So we can be proud of that. And in The Nordics and I know it's like, you know, money might not be an issue there, but just, the absolute commitment to the best interest of the child. So that embedding of u n NCRC and making it a reality so that everyone I spoke to, from the chief of police to people running hospitals, to nurses, to politicians, talked about best interest of the child and that is how we make decisions, to make decisions first. So they would be the big lessons I've seen around the world, really.
Speaker 12
for your answer to Darren. Just a little bit further on monitoring and evaluation. I'd like to ask you who you think should be responsible for monitoring the progress strategy and whether you think there is a voice there or a role either for the Office of the Children's Commissioner or for children themselves and how would you like to see them involved in monitoring the strategy?
Speaker 2
You just answered my question. One thing the Children's Commission's Office gives you is totally independent, impartial monitoring. So we are not afraid to say what needs to be said. And whether we are asked to monitor the strategy or not, we will monitor the strategy and make it make absolutely clear what we think about it. And, look, I'm so proud of the government and the poverty, the poverty unit for asking for children's voices, let's not.
Let's keep that going. Let's make sure that children's voices are involved in all of it. And again, what I'd like to see is all the places I've been talking about, all the departments that have something to do with children, actually seeking children's views on their policies. Not to do everything they say because that wouldn't be fair, but to actually make sure that they're heard and visibly seen to be heard and to open their minds to think a bit about is the Westminster discussion we're having really reaching the kids that we need to reach, the children and families we need to reach. So yeah, I think, I think Children's Commissioner's Office is always happy to be of service and will be whether it's asked or not and children, absolutely yes.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Can I ask, Dermot, before we finish, so you've spoken quite a lot about leadership in various different areas of the public sector and in the government? You've spoken quite a lot about the sort of income measures to increase income and deliver more income security. You've mentioned some really distressing examples around housing and the sort of fundamental role of housing in the security of children, in their material situation and it's kind of basis really for everything else that they need to do in in life. And, you know, I represent a constituency that's at heart of the housing crisis in in London.
We're in that firestorm. I just wondered if you had anything more to say about what the government needs to be doing to make sure that where children sleep is better for children living in poverty and that essential security because that it strikes me that that's an issue that goes beyond leadership and beyond income poverty and it's a hard challenge to solve. I would welcome your further thoughts on that.
Speaker 2
Yeah, and again I think about this a lot because, you know, when we it's strange that we even have to try to make the case for this, that families with children should have somewhere secure and, you know, decent to live, whereas, for example, arguments around pensions and things and the elderly are one. Everybody agrees. We should support that. And I think we need to put as much support into having a healthy, happy childhood. And an absolute bedrock of that is having somewhere to that's safe and clean and secure and not moldy and not rat infested and that you're not moved from every six weeks.
And, you know, there are schools just down the road and many in your constituency where more than half of children are in temporary housing, been moved every few weeks. Now, it's great that in the poverty strategy they've talked about that's mega and it was something I called for, as well as many others, that six week limit for being in B and Bs. What I think we need to do is make sure that's really happening on the ground, for starters, but also we have to invest in housing for our young and support our young families. It is nigh on impossible. I have an office full of young professionals who have got two working parents and young children and they can barely afford housing, let alone families in cities that get you know, who are on lower income, who are on UC or who get find themselves in any struggles or have got no recorded funds or whatever.
So we have to invest in housing and be creative about it and prioritise it. We cannot have kids living in rat infested, mouldy, health denier and kids who are disabled often or have a disabled parent because that's who ends up there. So we must invest in this. There are a number of ways we could do it. That could be at, you know, the national level, you know, about building more housing, you know, council housing, whatever.
It could also be at the local level, you know, giving local government the ability to be a bit more creative to get this sorted and funding them to do it. But however it's done and it and, you know, sitting alongside that, you know, making sure that these families can get out and get good jobs that can pay for them to be able to have, you know, have a decent house and somewhere to live and bring up the children.
Speaker 1
Do think that there's more that can be done from the children's sector, from the whole sector of organizations that we have that champion children's rights and that work on child poverty to change the debate about objections often made about new house building from people who are already well housed, and we have children who have to curl up because their bed is too small for them to sleep in. Is there something wrong with the state of our debate across the country that isn't prioritizing children's rights enough in the debate about house building?
Speaker 2
So, yes, I think I and I think in my investigations and speaking to children, housing and their poor quality housing is a key issue. What I would say is if you are, say, in Sheffield where my family live, you know, the housing stock is cheaper, better and way more plentiful than if you are in, you know, London or certain parts of London or whatever. So I think we can have a we should be having a sensible and nuanced discussion that shows the difference around the country of the quality of housing stock and the availability of housing stock and its impact its impact on children. It really is in the cities like London, Manchester and others where I've seen the absolute worst in the South East. And that's where we've got to prioritise decent quality housing whether however, whether it's private, whether it's it's council, whether it's whatever, I I I don't care.
What I care about is that we haven't got children living like this. It's for you all to have the political debate. And I think, yeah, absolutely, children's sector should step up to the plate on this because it is, you know, it is income, housing, you know, those are the big things when you look at you know, look look deeply into the children in deep material poverty.
Speaker 12
final Just a very quick follow-up. Last week the Education Select Committee went to Estonia and we were looking at kindergartens. 95% of their children attend kindergarten and it was just quite amazing to see what they're doing there, preparing children, ready to learn so that all children are, you know, sort of closing that gap. And you were talking about education being a really important point of this, part of this poverty strategy. Do you think that that's the kind of model we should be looking at in order to give those poor children a better chance of better outcomes later on in their school journey?
Speaker 2
Yeah, particularly poor children but all children. The one thing I know as an educationist that the one thing the data is totally secure on is that high quality early years education has the highest is the biggest factor to impact outcomes at 16. So absolutely we should be focusing on a high quality offer. I was pleased to see an announcement, I think I think was it last week or earlier in the week about more school based nurseries. And thinking and I think again that much more sensible, thoughtful thinking about what early years experience looks like.
I mean I would rocket boost child minders but also have really good school based or wider early education kindergartens that could match around that and give children a much better experience than some of the experiences we hear about. But yeah, absolutely. Thank
Speaker 1
you very much, Dean Rachel, for coming to give us your evidence today. I'm going to suspend the sitting now so that we can switch chairs and switch over to the second panel. Order, order.
Speaker 7
Order to order, and welcome to the second oral evidence session of this joint inquiry between the education select committee and the work and pensions select committee. And it's a pleasure to welcome this morning Tom Cave from Child Poverty Action Group, Laura Hutchinson from Citizens Advice and Priya Edwards from Save the Children and Henry Parks from the Institute of Public Policy Research. So a very warm welcome to all of you. I'm going to start the questions if that's alright. I I hope that you heard the questions that I asked Dame Rachel before, so specifically on targets.
So could I direct the same question to you? What what do you think of the absence of targets and should we should we be looking more broadly at what targets that we should have, whether they should be legally bound, whether there should be a a time limit to them and so on? Who would like to start with that? Can Tom? Off you go.
Speaker 13
I I think targets are a a really good way for government to drive change, and they kind of enable accountability and a continued focus on an issue. So without targets, it's it's harder to achieve those. And I think, like, one of the reflections on the strategy is that there's quite a lot has happened immediately in the strategy, and those are, like, a really positive step forward. But, actually, there's not a great deal of detail about, like, say, further investment in Social Security. And so in absence of those, targets would be really important in in maintaining that focus and allowing for further action further down the line, really.
And I I feel like within a strategy, you need to be able to to measure your success in it. And, actually, without that, I I think it it makes it much harder. And it makes it much harder for other people to scrutinize the the success of the the strategy and the measures that you're you're bringing into it. So I think to actually embed the strategy within the machinery of government targets would be would be very helpful in everyone being able to see the the strategy being used, reflections on what more can be done, and they the kind of ensuring the longevity of the the strategy over over the long term, really.
Speaker 14
Not entirely different. I can certainly see the value in targets and metrics but systems advice were less wedded to them as part of our formal engagement process and the strategy. I found very interesting what the children's commissioner was saying in her evidence session around metrics having limitations and they do provide sort of very valuable indicators of sort of projections and what's happening but they don't always provide a live picture, and they don't always provide a very accurate picture about the complexity of people in children's lives in particular. And so any reporting, that will be done in summer and then subsequently annually, what we're really keen to see is that human story, at the heart of the reporting and actually sort of a painting of a picture that really gets to the root causes, of the difficulties that children and family face and the complexities of how they move through life because that's not always evident just through data, and metrics as well. But we do think that, having an accountability mechanism in the strategy is certainly a very important thing and perhaps we can come on to that later.
Speaker 15
I would agree with Laura and just add that involving children in the monitoring and evaluation is one of the kind of central ways that you can monitor its effectiveness in real time and because the most important thing we want to see from the child poverty strategy is is it making a material difference to children in poverty's lives? And and we would really encourage the government to be focusing on, like, how can the monitoring and evaluation be as effective and as robust as possible. Henry?
Speaker 16
Yeah. Just to add. So, you know, the government has identified two kind of headline metrics and, like, they are a good complementary set. So it does make sense to monitor them. I think there's probably a third around very low incomes, which is potentially missing, so very deep poverty, which we know kind of is an issue caused by certain policies like benefit cap, etcetera.
And that if we just use those two headline metrics, we might lose sight of this kind of group of people who have severely low income, which is also a group that we want to obviously substantially reduce. So just to say, yeah, a third a third kind of headline measure of that would be welcome, and and, yeah, to be very specific about where you would like to get to, and when, you know, what is the scale of the government's ambitions is best communicated by, where those where they set those targets at different points. But, yeah, just to agree with other panelists that clearly, data won't be able to capture everything. You need to have qualitative insight. And another thing as well, most of the existing metrics that we have, they have pretty big lags, and so we need to think about metrics which are, a little bit more timely.
We've got the child poverty statistics coming out, this Thursday, I believe, but they will relate to the period March 2024 to April 25. It's, you know, it's it's a year ago, and we need more timely understanding of what's going on. So, there's probably a role there for more timely data collection as well.
Speaker 7
Given again that currently the strategy will cover about an impact, about ten percent of children living in poverty at the moment, would you be wanting to see a target that is is a bit more ambitious that?
Speaker 15
I think that we have a really ambitious baseline. Like, this is the largest number of children that will be taken out of poverty in a single parliamentary term, and, like, that is that is a monumental achievement, and we should really give credit for that. What remains to be seen is the longer term of how do we continue the momentum. And next parliament, the parliament after, how do we continue to make sure that the same number of children, if not more, are taken out of poverty. And I think that is something that we want to see, not necessarily a target, but a really robust plan of how we get there and what is the structural change that is needed to get there.
Speaker 6
Do you feel that the measures in the child poverty strategy reflected the key themes that were discussed by the people and communities that you engaged with? So I can start with Laura. I think the themes were very well reflected. There was
Speaker 14
quite a big chunk of the strategy dedicated to community engagement, and that was a theme that emerged very, very strongly in all the work that we did, that need for the government to really understand what, sort of different what's happening in different regions, what that demographic looks like, what that poverty looks like in that area, and then how do you build sort of very tailored and localized support systems and networks that can help address that. So I think it was definitely something recognised. On the delivery front. We're still waiting for quite a lot of guidance and information on how that will be implemented and how we can work, as community organisations with local authorities, for instance, and with other partners in communities to really enable the delivery of that side of the strategy, because a lot of it hinges on that successful community engagement, and sort of buy in from local partners. And, I very much appreciate the intention of the government sort of devolving that power to communities.
I think that's really, really important. But a bit more steer from the centre around sort of best practice or just guidance on implementation, I think, would be very welcome.
Speaker 13
Yeah, so we we as part of the engagement work we hosted two round tables with ministers, sector experts and people with lived experience and one of those was on social security specifically and one of them was on employment but I think a common theme actually throughout all of the engagement work was the critical importance of social security as a way of supporting families at a time where they have greater costs when they have children. And I think that is really seen in the strategy. The strategy definitely recognises that, like, the two child limit was the single most effective investment in Social Security to lift children out of poverty. And, similarly, some of the other measures, like extending free school meals, were really beneficial. I do think that there there is a need for the for for for more in that down the line.
And if we're kind of looking at some of the policies that break the kind of link between need entitlement within the system. There's there's three of them. So the two child limit, the benefit cap, and local housing allowance rates. And the strategy's done a great job at removing removing one of those issues, but the the the kind of other two still remain there and are still going to have a kind of real negative impact on on families' abilities to to kind of meet their costs.
Speaker 15
So we did 25 engagement sessions with local partners, with children, and with parents and family members on sort of better local support. But one of the central things that came up was social security. So again echoing what Tom said that it's really really welcome that the strategy recognizes that. The other thing that to some extent I'm surprised but pleased to see in the strategy is children and parents talk a lot about the experience of living in poverty and the experience of interacting with public services and that often feeling, in their own words, dehumanizing, degrading. And one of the things that we are really pleased was recognized particularly in some of the work around family hubs is that support needs to be more person centered and it needs to be more child centered and we're really pleased that there's a shift towards that.
Speaker 16
We worked with Changing Reality as a kind of lived experience group with experience of life on low incomes to determine kind of what we thought the priorities should be, immediate priorities for the strategy. There was like some good overlap in terms of specifics around, obviously, describing the two child limit and the extension of free school meals to all children on UC. Huge things that were clearly top of the list and priorities. There were also, for instance, movements on things like child maintenance. We got lots of feedback that basically child maintenance is pretty broken and and that it needs, reform, and it's good to see that the government was taking action on that and saw that as part of the anti poverty strategy picture, as being a source of income there.
There was also good recognition on things like wider school costs, which were huge, Like, I don't want my kids to miss out. Every time I have to buy a new school uniform, it's like a big cash shock. The government recognized that in its strategy through some action on uniform costs and some better stuff on enrichment. Basically, the idea that just because children are on low incomes, they shouldn't miss out. On that,
Speaker 16
say specifically, we would have liked the government to have gone a bit further sort of provide sort of ring fence support so that children could get sort of who were their on free school meals or or universal credit, they could get sort of automatic access to enrichment activities, support for cost with school trips, etcetera. At the moment, the system is very discretionary. It all kind of works through individual schools. Like, let's have a kind of automated, if you are on these benefits, you'll get this support. Obviously, the government didn't go as far as that, but maybe that's something they can take forward when they're looking at how to kind of ensure that this opportunities for enrichment are kind of consistent across the piece, with kind of, yeah, more of a systematized approach to making sure people don't miss out from from from being on lower income.
Speaker 6
Thank you. And are there particular groups of children, families, or organizations you were who you were not able to engage with or areas and you mentioned enrichment as well to do a bit more research on that and be more engagement to that. Where do you think further engagement may be needed? Laura?
Speaker 14
I think for me, one of the biggest gaps in the strategy was around no recourse to public funds. So there was a section on an RPF in the strategy, but it didn't go as far as we would have liked it to. So it it mainly centered around providing new guidance for local authorities, around how to enforce section 17 of the Children's Act, when children are reporting as destitute. And then there was commitment to do better reporting, and sort of data collection on no recourse to public funds to try and get a better picture of how many children actually sit in this, demographic and live in poverty because it is genuinely shocking that success successive governments haven't collected this data before. It's a really hidden level of poverty, often a very deep level of poverty in in this country.
It can be a very difficult demographic to sometimes engage with because, there is hostility sometimes or, a distrust in public services or official services amongst this demographic. And because, obviously, they're not going through the sale same sort of eligibility, entitlements as people, they don't often come into the same contact as you would with, for instance, like the DWP or your job center or those types of services. And so trying to get a better understanding of, you know, what's happening to these children and how could they be supported from the government, would be a really welcome step. And we really hope that the Home Office take this forward along with groups like the DFE and DWP as well.
Speaker 13
I'd just briefly add to that that there's a bit of a tension, I think, between some of the priorities in the the child poverty strategy and some of the proposed changes to settlement for migrant families. So the plan to sort of extend pathways for families who do receive financial support from the state will, kind of, ultimately lead to some families maybe choosing not to seek help when they're they're destitute, which could then, basically, extend the length of time in which children are living in in real deep poverty as a result. So I think a better understanding of of of how the the two interact would be really positive.
Speaker 16
Yeah. Likewise. I mean, I I think oh, sorry. We can say Oh, sorry. Was gonna say, likewise, I think, like, having more data is really gonna help.
That's a really good first step for for us to understand this problem. But, you know, we do need action. We do need children with without request public funds to get access to support that would lift them out of poverty. But, yeah, we don't fully understand the scale of it and that they do need to do more work on it.
Speaker 17
Thank you. So following on from the points that you've just shared, just to be a little bit more specific and give you the opportunity to give more considered commentary, how ambitious do you think that the child poverty strategy actually is with regards to policy steps and actions and funding commitment? And I'll start with Henry.
Speaker 16
Sure. So, basically, so government, when when it sort of took office, right, it had this projection for poverty that it was going to rise significantly, which obviously was kind of driven by the two child limit, which affects more and more families over time. And so when it's taken the policy action that it has, particularly on the two child limit and also on free school meals, what it's largely doing is countering that rise in child poverty that we, were expected to see or that modelers were show were expecting. So what it means that even though we've done all this and it's great and, like, we we're really happy with, that they've the government has done all that, it means that the actual poverty rate by the end of the parliament won't be terribly much lower than when the parliament started because of all these kind of positive headwinds that are going on. So so so in effect, yes, poverty will be down by the end of the parliament compared to the start of the parliament, but not actually by a huge amount in terms of number of children.
So, yes, it's great that they've done it, and that does reduce poverty relative to a world where the two child limit remains, but the bottom line is that poverty numbers will still be not that much lower. So we do think that the government probably does want to go further, if it wants to actually sort of achieve a substantial decrease in the number of children in poverty, relative to when it took office. In terms of the forms that that could take, I mean, there there are lots of options. One, for instance, is that we still have benefit levels which are affected by the decisions of previous governments on freezing and and sub subinflationary uprating of benefits, which we could start to slowly undo, over time so that we sort of have increases in things like the child element, over and above inflation to try and restore, the levels of benefits to where they really should be had those freezes not taken place. I think in particular, if you were thinking about where you would put money in the social security system, the child element is probably the most attractive.
Obviously, we sort of see a version of this in Scotland. We have the Scottish child payment, you know, that that is a top up of over £100 a month per child at the moment. You know, it's risen significantly since its introduction. It is possible to do this. You know, the government the the Scottish government obviously found thought that it was a priority to do so, and it has substantially reduced the poverty rate in Scotland.
Maybe not enough to hit their targets, but have a good dent. And also just to say that that also allows us because that has happened in Scotland, it has and you know, organizations like the Institute for Fiscal Studies have kind of looked for kind of evidence of whether this is affecting work incentives, etcetera, and they are not finding evidence of that. So it's quite useful that in Scotland, we have a situation where the child element is effectively more generous through the Scottish child payment, and, you know, things are ticking along. The poverty rate has been reduced, and there is probably some learnings there for the UK government in terms of where you might want to put additional investment in social security. Very quickly, I'll just say as well, housing support, like one of the reasons why the poverty rate is kind of in default kind of drifting up over time is that we have local housing allowance that is still frozen at a historic rate.
Rents are obviously rising fast. The government has obviously plans to increase the availability of affordable homes, etcetera, over time. That's all well and good, but children are here right now, and they need that support right now. So, basically, the longer we leave that, the more people will experience shortfalls in support in their housing, and that sort of erodes their disposable income. And so that is also another key area where we think actually, you know, the government, is pretty comfortable that it should uprate, general benefits by CPI.
That's kind of taken as a given. It's kind of a a a collective wisdom. But in housing, we we some for some reason, it's seen as discretionary whether we should increase housing support or not. Even though the exact same logic applies, you've got costs rising, benefits should change to reflect those rising costs, and sort of increasing LHA is the way to do that and stop this kind of upwards drift, of the poverty rate that, we will expect to see over the parliament if don't take action.
Speaker 15
What I would say is that the scrapping of the two child limit at the extension of free school meals is a kind of ambitious keystone for tackling child poverty. If the two child limit were to remain in place, we would see the sort of catastrophic levels of poverty that Henry just described and that is to be commended. That is an ambitious thing to do. What I would say is that not all children are gonna benefit right now from the scrapping of the two child limit because of the benefit cap remaining in place and also because as Henry said LHA rates are not being uprated in line with some local market rates for housing. And the other thing we really want to see is the kind of long term vision for tackling the structural drivers.
So wealth inequality in work poverty are still rising and wealth inequality is locked into the housing system. And we would also like to see above inflation reuprating of children's benefits. We have a policy that save the children around thinking around a sort of child lock for children's benefits, which I'd be happy to write to the committee about properly after. The other things we would like to see in terms of ambition is making sure that ambitions around child poverty are embedded in future reviews, future strategies that the government is like taking out. So for instance the parental leave review that's currently happening, there's lots that can be done for pregnant mothers to ensure that child poverty is tackled before a baby is even born.
We want to see more in the childcare system to really tackle some of the barriers to work and barriers to good well paid work for families. In the long term, investment in housing is necessary. We need a lot more social homes, but we do think this is an ambitious first step.
Speaker 14
We just want to see the second, third, fourth steps. Thank you. Laura? Obviously to echo everything that's already been said on the two child limit, we were extremely pleased that the government took the decision to lift the two child limit, and, it's if you look at the data in the strategy, it's very clear just in terms of numbers how much of the heavy lifting, that single policy lever actually does, in terms of numbers on child poverty. So without that, it would we would have been a very difficult different situation.
I think the main area that I would just sort of touch on here is private renters. So we had a section in the strategy dedicated to children living in temporary accommodation. Mhmm. And it talked through, you know, how we could get better guidance, again, out to local authorities to sort of stop illegal practices around temporary accommodation. And there was policies in there about preventing the discharge of newborn babies into temporary accommodation, all of which we would support.
But it is very important that you get downstream of this problem. Temporary accommodation is astronomically expensive to the state and to local authorities. It's a terrible situation for children to find themselves in. It's terrible from an education point of view, but it's also terrible from a sort of labor market perspective in terms of the impact that it has on parental employment. And so to get downstream of this problem, you really have to look at policy levers in the private rented sector, and the big one of those is upgrading of local housing allowance.
So we were disappointed not to see that commitment made in this strategy. It has been frozen since 2024, and since 2024, private rents have risen by around fourteen, fifteen, 16%. So that gap between LHA and rent, is is becoming increasingly wider for families, and it's causing a lot of, homelessness. It's reflected in our data. We have helped around 13,000 families last year facing eviction problem from the private rented sector and were facing imminent homelessness.
So, yes, we appreciated the focus on temporary accommodation and understand why the government was so passionate about about doing that, but they needed to do more to get downstream of the problem to stop that flow of children into temporary accommodation in the first place.
Speaker 13
Yeah. Again, I'd I'd echo a lot of what's been been said already. Like, the the two child limit and and free school meals extension were a massive step forward, really. But as as Henry was talking about, there there kind of has been a series of cuts, freezes, and sort of sub inflationary rises in the Social Security system that have now actually led to the government spends $5,050,000,000,000 less on Social Security than it would have done without those in place and, in particular, say the child benefit is worth 20% less in real terms than it was in 2010. So I think, whilst there's a kind of, I think, a bit of a theme in the strategy about some really big measures have been taken by central government, the kind of next bit of the implementation really seems to look almost to kind of push the next bits of implementation towards local actors, which I think is a really positive step in terms of enabling them to do to to kind of take positive action in that kind of region and and address some of the the differences that you get there.
But the reality is that the big levers that work are things that central government needs to look at, which is more investment in social security. So we would kind of push for that and as I mentioned before, the benefit cap and local housing allowance are two of those issues as well as greater investment in social security for children.
Speaker 17
Yes. So I think it's come quite clear from all on the panel that uplifting the local housing rate is critical and that's not a policy that's within the current child poverty strategy. Is that the most effective, policy that could deliver the best return on investment to tackle child poverty, or is there something something else that would give a better return on investment? And I'm happy to open that up.
Speaker 7
Can I just say we are getting a little bit time pressured, so if you if one of you could pick up on that and if there are any dissenting voices, just just a quick one sentence response?
Speaker 16
So, yeah, I think there are different there are different routes, but local housing allowance is particularly effective because it channels money to people with the biggest housing shortfall. So it's so it's so the money flows to people who kind of are suffering the most and and are most affected by the freeze. So on that basis, yeah, I think, you know, it would be a it would be a priority area for investment first.
Speaker 3
Thank you. And this question and thank you for the panelists for their evidence so far. And this is specifically Supriya Edwards. In the Save the Children's written report to this inquiry, it recommended framing positive reductions as a core outcome of family hubs. Could you describe what you envisaged by this?
Speaker 15
Yeah. One of the things we heard a lot in the engagement work that we did is that families really struggle when services and support isn't joined up, and that's across public services but also across the voluntary sector. And so one of the ways that you could best support children and families in poverty through family hubs is by making sure that child poverty outcomes and local child poverty reduction is considered to be part of the success framework for family hubs. And that would enable and encourage family hubs to make sure that things like welfare advice, debt advice, other forms of sort of income support and crisis support are properly connected to family hubs locally. We're not necessarily wedded to an exact framework of how that would work right now, but what we want to see is the two areas really drawn together.
So educational outcomes for early years and child poverty together.
Speaker 7
Apparently we finish a little bit later with this joint enquiry than, what my committee normally finishes. So apologies, to to Serena for for for that. So we do have a a little more a little more time flexibility. So I'll now hand hand over to Marx, who's
Speaker 18
Thank you very much, chair. Does the government understand how child poverty affects different children? So for example, children with special educational needs, children with disabilities, children who live in different localities. We heard in the previous panel about rural people who live in rural areas having lower access to fuel or having to spend more money on it. And if the government does understand it, does it have the strategy to address these differences?
Anybody can take this by the way.
Speaker 15
So I think where we are now with the child poverty strategy is the government has a far greater understanding through the engagement directly with children and families that's been done by us, by the children commissioner, and others of the kind of differing experiences of child poverty. I would encourage the government to continue to do this and to embed listening to children and listening to parents in the monitoring excuse me, in the monitoring and evaluation of the child poverty strategy. There's absolutely more that can be done and a lot of what we would like to see going forwards is the kind of localism that the Children's Commissioner talked about in her evidence session. So really empowering local authorities and combined authorities to have oversight and have powers in order to really make sure that they're meeting the needs of the children in poverty in their areas. And we'd like to see the VCS more involved in that.
We want to see communities directly involved in shaping what that looks like locally.
Speaker 14
Just to come in on the rural point because it's a really interesting one and it was something that the Child Poverty Unit was talking to us about throughout the process so there was definitely that sort of will to try and understand how different demographics and different regions are impacted by this. But you you mentioned fuel being being one thing. We also heard from a number of people who live in rural areas about, like, the price of sort of what we would term, like, daily basics. So things like groceries and the fact that your essentials in terms of groceries track consistently higher if you live in a rural community because you perhaps don't have access to a bigger supermarket. You might be more reliant on your sort of village shop or, you know, one of the sort of, like, smaller branded supermarkets that don't always stock more affordable foods.
So there wasn't the the levers that the government have around that are really tricky. So I think there is still more work to do in trying to assess of what can be done around sort of grocery pricing in rural communities and how that disparity is felt across different regions. But I I definitely appreciate that it's a really sticky issue and, it's a it's a very hard problem to solve. But, transport is something that the government could, and should be doing something on in terms of sort of how that impacts different regions and the impact that has on child poverty. So what we heard a lot on is things like, you know, sort of, fair freezes are great, but they're only great if you have a bus in your local community.
And actually, for many people, they couldn't take public transport because it didn't run through where they lived, and therefore they couldn't get to their childcare provision, and then they couldn't get to work, let alone get to sort of crisis support or a food bank. And so there's an infrastructure point Yeah. That needs to be thought of through more of a child poverty lens, and it is currently at the moment. So as part of the strategy, it it does talk about the Department for Transport taking on more of a poverty, I can't remember how it's exactly described, but a poverty sort of lens across some of the work they do. And that would be really welcome to see how that, impacts because it it it's a sort of sticking point to accessing loads of different things in rural communities.
Speaker 13
I think just very quickly, when we're looking at what's in the monitoring and evaluation framework, I think having some real breakdowns in terms both so things like black and minority ethnic children, households containing someone with a disability, lone parent families are really important. But similarly, I think, actually, like some form of regional focus within the kind of reporting would be really helpful. So maybe even sections that are looking at different regions and not just the kind of the stats but actually what is what's been implemented there. If we're going to kind of devolve some of the implementation to to a local level, there'll be lots of different things happening in different areas that might be addressing particular issues there, but there's loads of learning that can be taken from that and applied to other areas as well.
Speaker 16
And then, yeah, just quickly, so the government produced a pretty chunky evidence pack around who was at higher risk of poverty. Household composition is a major driver, so obviously large families and lone parents being the most significant groups. We've had a big policy movement on the two child limit, obviously which will affect the two sorry, the larger family poverty rate. But lone parents are going to continue to have a very elevated poverty risk. And there's a question mark, I guess, about what we should do about that beyond what is in the strategy.
One thing that we discussed was basically whether universal credit should maybe treat loan parents a little bit more favorably. Mhmm. So for instance, should they be able to retain more of their earnings before they are hit by a taper given that their ability, particularly when their children are younger, their ability to, work a large number of hours are is constrained. Similarly on childcare we've had, lots of extensions of, free hours, but still, questions which are most significant for that group around access, like can I get the childcare hours where I need them, for the work I need to do, and also that the free hours aren't actually covering the full cost, of of childcare settings, with things like top up fees, etcetera, which, you know, have taken a a a have risen significantly, I mean that those three hours aren't so free, and the impact that that can have on the ability of single parents to participate in the lab market and and get out of poverty?
Speaker 18
And then very quickly, chair. So none of you would disagree with the fact that the government do understand the differences between these different groups and the things that affect poverty amongst these different groups?
Speaker 14
With the exemption of exception, sorry, of no recourse public funds like we mentioned earlier. I think they do need to do much more work to understand that demographic.
Speaker 18
That's good. With that exception in mind, are there any others you want to flag? That's incredibly helpful. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you. Caroline Boden. Thank you chair. So my question is for Thomas first and then if anybody else has anything to add. So the government is using relative low income after housing costs as a new measure of deep material poverty as its two headline measures to monitor the progress.
What is your view of this approach?
Speaker 13
Yes, I think on the headline measure of poverty it makes absolute sense. Think on the material deprivation measure we see benefits to it but I think we would probably prefer a slightly different approach, basically because of the fact that it's based on those 13 items that kind of are deemed essential. But that makes it a needs based measure, so it's much harder to actually understand the impact that particular new policy might have on that. It's kind of harder to track that. And similarly, because it's kind of methodologically different to the main poverty measure, understanding the interaction that particular policy might have between the two is harder.
I think we'd probably look to sort of supplement it with a relative measure which would say 50% of household averaging income which would enable you to kind of track that. But we certainly see why having that deeper measure is really, really, really useful.
Speaker 12
There are things in that 13 item list that could be affected by all sorts of outside forces, like if the local swimming pool suddenly decided to offer free swimming for all kids under 10, for example. Suddenly, you're ticking a box that you weren't ticking before, but it doesn't necessarily mean that you've moved out of poverty.
Speaker 13
Yeah and as well as that it's kind of static in time and I think if we say if we look back say ten, fifteen years I think people would probably say that would be less likely to say that access to the internet was a real kind of essential part of being of being able to
Speaker 13
of interact with modern society and things like that. But at this point in time, we we probably would see that, like, if you don't have access to that, you'll kind of really struggle to get by for for many different reasons. And I think, you know, if we're looking ten, fifteen years down the line, we can't predict how the what is essential could change a little bit.
Speaker 12
Do you think those items should be able to change over the ten years or would that then make that measure unusable if it
Speaker 13
It does make the measure more complicated I would say. Like you certainly wouldn't be able to compare to different periods in time on it and I think that's why we would just favor the kind of supplementing it the this with a deeper relative measure.
Speaker 15
To add to what Tom's been saying, one of the most helpful things you can do from an accountability perspective as an organization like ours is track the trends in child poverty as the actual understanding of the numbers can be a little bit more complicated. So the relative poverty after housing costs, it's an internationally comparable measure, and you can track the trends across time so you can understand what dynamics are at play when understanding child poverty. Where I would differ from Tom is that we do encourage a wider suite of measures to understand the complexity of child poverty. Deep material poverty as a sort of supplementary measure can be really helpful in understanding do children have essential needs? But what we would really encourage and I for the record, would like to push back against what the children's commissioner was saying earlier around deep material poverty and really emphasize that we need to focus on relative poverty after housing costs as the headline measure of what child poverty is because that enables us to really understand the trends over time.
Speaker 16
yeah, I agree that relative poverty is the key measure. I guess what we don't want to there are lots of things about children's lives which are not being captured by that measure, and therefore having supplement supplementary measures makes sense, and I think it's a good thing to include them alongside a relative poverty measure and a deep poverty measure, which Tom's already mentioned. Just to give an example, there are just certain things like for instance, overcrowding, for example. So overcrowding does not show up in income. You know, you're crowded in your house.
It's terrible. It affects your opportunities, etcetera, etcetera. But, you know, it might be overcrowding is a consequence generally of people not having money for suitable housing. So they end up in a house that's not suitable. So from an income perspective, they might look great.
It's like or they might look fine, but they're really not fine because the housing that they're forced into is inappropriate. So it does make sense to have measures which are slightly wider than the income measure, not only the kind of qualitative evidence stuff that we've already talked about. But, yeah, I think there are some metrics out there. And, you know, I think the the the deprivation measures are getting at some of that, where we do want to give the government credit for when other things improve, which are not gonna be captured by those that kind of conventional headline, AHD AHT measure of poverty, even though we would say that should be the primary measure.
Speaker 10
chair, thank you to the panel for coming to speak to us today. Laura, you mentioned him previously in your your testimony so far is about capturing the human story, and and Pri, you were talking about experience and how do we get that children's voice. So reflecting on that, what do you think should be set out in the baseline report this summer and the subsequent annual reporting on the child poverty strategy? And I'm really interested to see how you would capture those, things that you would identify as maybe less able to measure.
Speaker 14
Yeah. I'm afraid I don't have an exact answer. I can talk through what I would sort of like to see represented in the the reporting this summer. What what I don't want to see and what I don't think would be helpful is a very heavy data report. And I do think getting across, in whichever way that sense of what it feels like to grow up in poverty is incredibly important, not just from a sentimental point of view, far from it.
From an actual very practical point of view of understanding where the pain points are in people's lives, and the complexity which a problem like poverty can impact so many different, areas of sort of education and your access to services, your housing, and how that all interconnects. So I would very much be in favor of anything that tries to capture that holistic picture of what it is like for a child and a family and parents to grow up in poverty and how that connects to, you know, the labor market and educational systems, and that type of thing. I would like to see, perhaps a discussion about how we could better capture children moving throughout the whole stage of their life. So at the moment, the way that the strategy has been positioned is as a ten year strategy. I can't say for certain, but I would assume that that's done because, it's based on two successive government terms as opposed to actually being mirrored on taking a child through naught to 18, say, which I think would be a much more effective way of trying to sort of ascertain what happens to children as they go through sort of, you know, every stage of their life.
And, we've we've heard about sort of but children go through different stages of their own life and there are different hurdles and barriers facing them at each one of those. And so trying to capture that better, I think, would be really important. Thank you. I would
Speaker 15
really agree with everything Laura said there. In terms of practically how you could do this, locally and regionally, things like poverty truth commissions do a really effective job of understanding what is the picture. There could be a national one. There be a children's one. We could have some kind of summary of the poverty truth commissions that already exist.
And or there could be a sort of national children's board that is part of the accountability mechanisms that is actively monitoring what the strategy is feeling like for children. Save the Children has experience with this. I'm sure other panelists do. There's lots of experience out there, and we would be really keen to work with the committee, work with the government to support the enabling of children and families' voices throughout the monitoring and accountability.
Speaker 10
In in the children's commissioner's, testimony earlier, she did talk about that devolution and looking at localized solutions to to pro progress on child poverty. So how should the government's approach to devolution and local progress to be be looked at?
Speaker 15
So one of the things we would really like to see is, combined authorities having more statutory authority and more statutory powers on child poverty in order to sort of encourage child poverty action plans across all local authorities. There's like there's a lot that's already been done at combined authority level. We really commend what's happening in the Northeast. We'd like to see the central government really encouraging and empowering combined authority level to do that so it's embedded in growth plans, it's embedded in the work that's already happening in transport. And and then very locally, what we would like to see, and this is sort of at community level, not even local authority level, though local authorities have to be involved, is families, but children as well, being really involved in some of the local decision making, like, where is the park?
Where is the play space? How can I get to it? Because they are the things that are really felt in a child's life. And so the more that can be done locally to enable children and enable parents, enable families to have a say in shaping what local solutions are, the better.
Speaker 14
And I think the government aren't already doing pilots and programs that will hopefully really make a difference on that point. So things like the pride in place program, where you're giving power and agency back into the hands of communities can have a really transformational effect, not just, you know, the experiences of people living in those communities, but in outcomes as well. So anything that sees those times of schemes rolled out more, I think, would be really welcome. But, yeah, the I mean, the thing on localized solutions is there's so many amazing pilots and initiatives going on across the country. There is a challenge for government on how it captures what is happening and, what is done at a local level and how it can sort of share that best practice and learnings much wider.
Because organisation like Assistance Advice where, you know, we do have the benefit of being very spread out across the country and seeing all these local initiatives, it's not always apparent how we feed those learnings back into central government. But I think they are there is an attempt to try and rectify that through appointments appointments like like the, Richard Walker to the cost of living champion, appointment, for instance. That could be a position where, you know, it's a very much go out, see, learn, and then report back to government about what's going on in communities and what works and what doesn't. I mean, I my constituent's in
Speaker 10
a devo desert, and it's even worse. It's right next door to a a devolved mayor in the East Midlands. So therefore that that inequity feels feels much greater. So I'm I'm really interested to sit test to see how this this sort of evolves. But, we've heard, that recommendations that the government should incorporate public involvement into the monitoring and evaluation of the strategy.
What do you think that would look like in practice? Don't know, Henry, if you wanted to
Speaker 16
Sure yeah. Yeah, it's already been alluded to I think, kind of in our annual reporting we would see a kind of substantial qualitative component where you actually ask people, are you actually feeling the effects of these policies? Are they working as intended? It's a way to both kind of hold the government to account, but it's also a way to improve the quality of policy. Right?
We've done this sort of or the government has done this ongoing exercise to begin with, and it should carry on doing so to sharpen up policy and make sure that it that it hits the mark. So in terms of how that should be done precisely, you know, potentially a panel basically of parents and young people who are kind of recruited from across the country. You have to ensure they're obviously representative, you know, with with with a with a good distribution of the issues that young people and parents might face, and to kind of commit within those annual reporting cycle to those qualitative findings. You might need to sort of source that out so it's kind of an independent assessment of that evidence for obvious reasons. You don't want sort of cherry picking of qualitative research.
But you know, there is a way I think there is probably a way forward for for us to kind of, you know, to supplement that other data. And and, yeah, I do think there is a role for good data collection and presentation as well, particularly at regional and local level using kind of administrative data. So there is a a big data part of this I think. But yeah, it will only be complete if we have a kind of an independent qualitative assessment with a standing panel is kind of how
Speaker 10
Thank you. That's really useful. Thank you, chair. Thank you. Darren Paffy.
Speaker 11
Thank you, chair. Ultimately, what we all want is for a strategy that deals with the issue and gets it done effectively. And one of the things the liaison committee has said about what effective strategies are, those that, bring together policies, activities, and resources over time to achieve a stated outcome. With that definition in mind, how effective do you believe the child poverty strategy is? Tom, do you want to start us off?
Speaker 13
So I've sort of already mentioned that it is a great start and it has identified the most effective policies that can be immediately implemented on it. But the longer term picture is a bit more challenging because where it's kind of enabling local implementation, that's a little bit less clear about what's happening, which is a good thing in terms of allowing devolution, allowing different approaches in different areas. But as I've already said, the the the needs to central government needs to maintain a focus on it. It needs to understand what's happening in in those local areas. And I think putting things in the monitoring and evaluation framework can really help with that in terms of tracking outcomes locally.
But at the same time, there needs to be a sense of what central government might do in the longer term within there as well, which should either be commitments to further investment in Social Security or it should be targets that will necessitate that that kind of commitment further down the line. And and without one of those two things, there there is a danger that the the strategy, like, loses moment momentum in in the longer term.
Speaker 14
I suppose where it could probably be, in those three buckets, slightly stronger is in the activities one. So, yeah, that all the stuff that Tom was just talking about in terms of the implementation and the rollout in communities, there's still perhaps a bit of a uncertainty around exactly how is that gonna be driven from the center and what sort of, can government do to make those services in communities much more joined up than they currently are. So we, took evidence as part of our engagement, and one thing that came out really strongly from local communities is just then the sheer number of hoops they have to jump through in order to access support in their areas. So it won't surprise you that SureStart came up a lot as this sort of idea that you can go through the doors of a service and you can get you can come out with the right support that you needed. Whereas now, it's much more fragmented.
It's much harder to sort of navigate those systems self and know where to go. And so I think there's a role for central government in, you know, advising, providing guidance, whatever that looks like, helping to sort of shape that joined up connectivity between services.
Speaker 15
Yeah. Yeah. Would really agree with what both Tom and Laura have said on the kind of activities and join up of services. Data sharing between central government departments to enable this locally, I'm sure it comes up all the time, but just the more that can be shared, the easier it is for families downstream. The other thing I would add on the kind of outcomes bucket is that and we haven't really talked about the fact that there are child poverty strategies in both Wales and Scotland.
Northern Ireland has anti poverty measures in place. Making sure that all four nations work on child poverty is pulling in the same direction, and and Westminster enables what's happening in Scotland, what's happening in Wales, to continue to thrive whilst also ensuring that England can catch up is a really, really important thing. And we'd like to see with the outcomes that eventually the child poverty rates in all four nations are all lower but equivalent. There isn't disparity across borders.
Speaker 16
Yeah I would say I think the child poverty strategy has some of the hallmarks of a good strategy in the sense of a good problem diagnosis. They've clearly spent a lot of time thinking about that and there is a clear flow through some of the policies from diagnosis, and so from that angle it is a good strategy. But where it does fall short, and it kind of relates to Tom's point I think, is that you need to know, for it to be a strategy you need to know how it's been successful, and like what does success look like, and I think that is still quite vaguely defined. So I would loop it back to the conversation about targets. There are lots of targets to choose from, but like you need to know if your strategy has been successful, and and I think that needs to be better defined.
Thank you.
Speaker 7
Thank you. Four more questions, folks. So if we could focus our minds on that. Lee Barron.
Speaker 8
Yes. Thank you, and and, good morning and thanks for coming along. Everybody knows that a strategy like this won't be done and dusted within one parliament. You know, it's probably gonna need need at least two and then some sort of continuation. So my question really is around how we move this forward, and how we and what can be done to to to gain both public support, but probably more importantly, cross party support to make sure that this does go into the long term we can deliver for the future of children.
Speaker 13
Yeah. So I I think that I think there is more consensus than we we often often believe there is. Like, I think everyone agrees that every individual child matters and that no one really supports child poverty as an outcome. So we know from research we've commissioned that 89% of the public supports action to address child poverty. I think where it becomes slightly more difficult is what measures we actually take to address that issue.
And I think actually a useful approach is probably a bit more of a greater recognition of the fact that investment in children's futures has a lot of impacts on both them individually, but actually our our economy as a whole. Like, there's massive potential that we can unlock in young people. And actually, child poverty costs our economy £40,000,000,000 a year in both loss of future earnings potential, but also additional costs to public services as a result of not using things like social security as a prevention and it leading to worse health outcomes, worse educational outcomes. Lots of the other issues that government's trying to tackle at the moment, such as sort of rising issues around mental health and declining well-being in children are linked to other agendas like NEETs and actually looking at child poverty as a bit more of an underpinning sort of foundational block to basically support our society as a whole would I think be very beneficial.
Speaker 14
Yeah I completely agree with that. I think the rhetoric that the chancellor used in her autumn budget when she was talking about the reasons for scrapping the two child limit were really important. That, sort of central theme about the impact child poverty has on public services, is something that is very strongly evidenced, and I think talking about it through that lens can help people to really understand just how important a problem this is to solve. So a lot of it is a is a framing point, I think. Tom was speaking about NEETs there.
I think most people would agree that what's happening, with that sort of demographic in society now is is shocking, and that, if if you go downstream of that problem, that is a problem of of children growing up in disadvantaged backgrounds. So the need to tackle things early on cost the state much, much less, as you go down the line. And I know that's just not an obvious point for many in this room, but I think it is an important one to keep making very consistently. Poverty is extremely expensive. And another point, I think that has particularly, particularly compelling in recent years after the pandemic and, the cost of living crisis is that narrative around people's change in circumstances Mhmm.
And how easily that can happen to people. So, I think that can really help build support and consensus, particularly in things like the social security system, with sort of a more of a narrative and an argument around the fact that, you know, this is a a safety net for people, and you never really know at this, you know, point of volatility, with what's happening in the world and and what could potentially come down line when your circumstances could change and when you might need that extra support. And so I think just positioning it, in that framing would be helpful.
Speaker 15
I really agree with what both Tom and Laura have said. What I would add and I think it's been alluded to quite a lot in this session and with the children's commissioner as well is that there's a quite widespread recognition that in lots of different ways childhood in The UK is in crisis and, you know, we talk to parents. Parents are really worried about their kids. They're worried about other people's kids. And I think that more could be done to articulate a greater ambition for what childhood should look like in The UK, and tackling child poverty is the sort of foundational piece of that.
Children have to be able to eat. They need a good home in order to have their own ambitions to enjoy their childhoods. And I think more of a conversation about every child deserves a good childhood, however woolly that might sound right now, but, like, that can do a lot to tackle some of the stigma that parents tell us about. That's something actually I very specifically encourage the government and others to challenge more actively is the kind of stigmatizing rhetoric that can come out around the children, the parents in poverty, one, because it damages the argument we're trying to make, but also it has a really detrimental and direct impact on the mental health and well-being of those kids. And and that's not really a state of affairs we should accept.
Speaker 7
Lee, our other questions have carried have pulled out so you can carry on to the last question.
Speaker 8
Okay. Thanks. Chair, we had a lot earlier on in relation to, you know, where this sits in government. And as you know, the child poverty unit now has come out of the cabinet office and gone into the DWP. Does that concern you in any way in relation to it being a DWP issue?
So therefore not other departments issues and, you know, could get a little bit lost.
Speaker 14
I do have some concerns over it. So I think the reason why it was placed in the cabinet office to begin with is because child poverty needs to be recognized as something that has to be tackled from a cross government point of view, and resiloing the unit into the DWP regardless of sort of what, mechanisms or accountability structure you give them, that does send a signal across government departments. Departments. I I think think that that this this is is a a DWP issue. So I would have liked to see it either remain in the cabinet office or to see a sort of greater sort of team being built out through 10, that sort of focuses on the monitoring and the accountability of the sort of progress and delivery of the strategy.
Speaker 13
Yeah. And I think that the day to day reality of, like, working in government is that it's basically just easier for cabinet office to get people to to engage with them on on something when they're when individual departments are compete like, have lots of different competing priorities and things like that. I think one thing on top of where it's actually located that I think the committee might be interested in looking at is actually what the staffing capacity within the child poverty team is and whether that's enough to maintain and continue momentum on this.
Speaker 15
I think the only thing I would add is that if it is in DWP, what can we do now to ensure that it is as cross governmental as possible and it does need to tap into NHLG. HCLG. It needs to tap into education. It needs to tap into transport. I'm going to forget departments.
But, like, what can we do now to ensure that the unit wherever it sits is empowered to do that, and that really comes from support from the prime minister and from the chancellor to really continue to drive forward a story about the government tackling child poverty and a commitment to tackling child poverty for the rest of the parliament and beyond?
Speaker 16
Yeah. Sorry. That was gonna be my point really, which is I think it could it can work at DWP. I understand why it's there. They hold a lot of the levers.
A lot of the levers that we would probably emphasize, so so in that in that regard. But yeah, political commitment will be required for it to work and it still be based at DWP and that is like yeah. That's not about machinery of government, that's just political commitment and can happen.
Speaker 7
Thank you so much everyone. And that concludes our second panel for this child poverty strategy implementation inquiry. Thank you.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.