House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 9
Can I thank my honorable friend for raising this? Ministers would certainly be happy to meet with her and her constituents on this. And I am very concerned about some of the issues that she describes and that I am aware of. And also, I think that families are not being given the full information as well about some of the practices and provisions. This goes to the heart of why it is we need new regulation arrangements in place so that everyone can have the confidence that their loved ones are being shown the respect and care that all of us would want for our families.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Any regulation of the funeral sector must avoid unnecessary administrative burdens on small local providers. How is the department ensuring that any proposed regulatory framework is proportionate and does not unfairly increase costs for independent funeral directors across my constituency, Leicester East, and across the country?
Speaker 9
The honorable member raises a very important issue. It's important we get this right. That's why we are currently holding consultations and discussions across the funeral sector. We know that there are funeral providers right across the country who do an incredibly caring and compassionate job looking after families at the most difficult time. We are working with them, and we will update the House in due course.
That's why we've established the principle of regulation, but getting the practice right working with the sector will be important. Mr. Speaker, with permission, I'll take this question together with question number 19. The government's determined to give every child the best start in life. We will appoint an independent maternity and neonatal commissioner and publish an action plan covering every area identified for improvement from pregnancy to postnatal care. And we will also go further, rolling out Sure Start health services for parents and babies into every family center across the country, reaching up to a thousand family hubs over the next two years.
Speaker 21
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The maternity ward at Kettering General Hospital faces significant challenges, such as RAAC, overheating during the summer, and flooding during the winter. We urgently need to see the maternity ward rebuilt, and the money raised by families for a bereavement suite put towards a safe space for families in the most difficult of times. Can I thank the Secretary of State for all the work she has done on national maternity services, but ask her if she will meet with me to discuss the specific challenges and make sure my constituents get the maternity services they deserve?
Speaker 9
I can say to my honorable member, I will happily meet with her to talk about maternity services. And I just want to pay tribute to her as well, because I know she has been a tireless campaigner about improving maternity services, but also particularly around bereavement suites for families at the most sensitive times. And I'd pay tribute as well to all of the families in her constituency who have also been involved in those campaigns. I know there is work underway for a new maternity and neonatal facility in Kettering General, and that that will include a bereavement suite, and we want to work with the hospital and with the community on this.
John Thomas Hayes
Oh, sorry, question number 19. A new report by the Center for Young Lives advocates for putting health at the heart of every childhood. It includes putting Best Start, Healthy Babies, and remaining children's centers on a statutory footing.
Given that health services have structural advantages in providing capital management and getting new services up and running, what greater role can health services play in integrating services back at Sure Start level?
Speaker 9
Well, welcome my honourable friend's question. Having been responsible for the rollout of the original Sure Start programme, I have to say I am still angry with members opposite who supported the closures of Sure Start programmes across the country. We are now restoring health, health services and Healthy Babies programme back into the family hubs across the country because it's crucial that health interventions from the work of midwives, of health visitors, work on postnatal depression is crucial to the early start of a child's life. I hope that now we'll have cross-party consensus as we expand those services this time round.
Layla Moran
Mr. Speaker, the chief exec of NHS England and I toured the John Radcliffe's maternity units this summer. The building is in a dire state. Women give birth in rooms with no windows and no toilets. Where there are toilets, they quite often flood. In fact, Valerie Amos said it was the worst that she'd seen as part of her review.
The trust leaders are clear with us, they want a new maternity unit. So could I invite the Secretary of State to come to Oxford and see for herself? And if she's not got the time, at least have a meeting with myself and the trust leaders so we can discuss how we can move this project forward.
Speaker 9
So I will happily meet with the honourable member and pay tribute as well to the work I know that the select committee has done looking at issues around maternity services as well. Clearly, some of the issues are around the capital investment and we are substantially increasing capital investment to improve the safety of units and facilities across the country, including maternity units. But we also want to see higher standards of care, not just in around labour wards and around maternity units, but also throughout pregnancy as well. So happy to meet and talk to her about those services.
Speaker 8
Two of the things that will stick with me around maternity were receiving the, sorry, the briefing from Donna Ockenden on her report. It was shocking. The other part was listening to bereaved mums saying they're tired of telling their story over and over again. So I hope that we can find a better service for those parents. Equally, though, was the treatment of dead babies in the mortuary in Nottingham.
So can she update on the work that's being done there to ensure that those shocking things never happen to any family ever again?
Speaker 9
Can I welcome the honourable member's points on this and I know this is an issue that he has championed, both on maternity care and on bereavement. So I, like him, have spoken to some of the Leeds families as well who have been bereaved and where the Ockenden review is underway at the moment. But I would also say to him, I think the issues that he has raised around some of the babies and mortuary services and also funeral services around babies show the importance of the broader response to the fuller inquiry and to regulation around funeral services and more broadly, and we do need to take action. I'm happy to discuss that with him further.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Mr. Speaker, this week Matthew Hopkins, who until November 25 was the chief executive of one of the worst performing hospital trusts in the country and is now the acute and ambulance network director of NHS Alliance, was reported to have said that the closure of at least 20 rural maternity units was inevitable and the right thing.
Now in North Devon, we've seen the impact that closures have on women in labor who faced an hour and a half of drive on country lanes with many turning around to give birth in A&E, a sign of the national maternity crisis being out of control. So rather than agree to closures, will the Secretary of State review how we staff rural maternity services to improve safety and protect women? And will she meet with me and rural Liberal Democrat MPs who are fighting to protect mums and families?
Speaker 9
So I can say to the honorable member, in fact the work that we have done since the election has significantly increased the number of midwives across the country, which we rightly need to do. And also I have been very clear to the NHS Chief Executive that the NHS regionally and nationally needs to do everything possible to help reopen the North Devon maternity services. I know that work is underway at the moment on trying to increase the recruitment and support the local recruitment. I think there is a broader issue about making sure, particularly in more rural areas, that there is, there are proper recruitment and maternity workforce plans in place because we need to make sure that mums need to know that the services are there for them when they need it and at the time when they go into labor, at the time that they need it as well, and that will be part of the approach we're taking to maternity services.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Mr. Speaker, with permission I would like to answer questions four and 14 together. We now have the highest number of fully qualified GPs since 2015 and almost 16 million more GP appointments were delivered in the last year than in the 12 months before the election. As a result of that investment, 77% of people are now saying they have a good local service. We know there is more to do, especially in rural and in remote areas, but there is clear progress against our 10-year plan.
Speaker 35
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Vital NHS services including scans and X-rays have been removed from Oak Park Clinic, which serves every resident in the Havant constituency. Will the Minister meet me and support my campaign to restore these vital services so my constituents don't have to travel to Portsmouth or further afield?
Diana Ruth Johnson
I'm very happy to meet the honorable gentleman and I, I looked at the issue around Oak Park Community Clinic. I know the honorable gentleman's met with the ICB and what I'm told at the moment is that all options are currently being considered to provide a sustainable and accessible solution for diagnostics at the Oak Park site, but I'm very happy to meet.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm very concerned about the NHS England's GP list cleaning program at the moment and its impact on London specifically. Putney GPs have told me that in the last six months, 344,000 patients have been taken off GP lists, but 44% of those are in London. Some patients are taken off after not responding to a single letter. This means they don't get cancer checkups, they don't get vaccines, they don't get GP care.
So something is going on with the London part of the GP lists. Will the Minister pause, review this program, look into it, and meet with me and other London MPs to talk about it?
Diana Ruth Johnson
And I very much understand the concerns that my honorable friend has raised, particularly for vulnerable patients, but it's important that we get GP lists as accurate as possible. We think there's around 6 million more registrations than England's population currently, and most people flagged are confirmed to have moved abroad. So strong safeguards are in place including no patient is removed on the basis of a single indicator or because they fail to respond to one piece of correspondence. Overall it takes more than five months from identifying a patient who may no longer be residing to deregistering them from a practice system, but of course I'm always happy to meet with my honorable friend.
Luke Morgan Evans
Thank you Mr Speaker. And one thing that's hindering access and effectiveness of primary care is Labour's mandatory use of single point of access, so much so that safety watchdog has linked it to deaths. Now after the front bench dismissed the concerns raised by this side, it turns out an investigation has been set forward with the NHS strategy unit being asked to look at this. Could she set out the terms of reference the strategy unit is using, the timeframe and when this House can expect to hear the answers to make sure that this is done safely.
Minister.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for raising this and he will appreciate I'm relatively new in post but I am going to find out and I will write to him with the specific answers to the questions he's posed today.
Marie Tidball
Thank you Mr Speaker. Constituents in Stocksbridge, Deepcar, Wharncliffe Side and Oughtibridge regularly tell me how important it is for them to have access closer to home for routine blood tests, X-rays, SEND and mental health support, NHS dentistry and mammograms because of the poor transport links and delays in accessing NHS diagnostic services in Sheffield. Therefore I was delighted to welcome Stocksbridge Towns Fund board members, local health leaders and experts to visit the 519 community hub site in our town. Will the minister meet with me to discuss our proposal for a community diagnostic centre in the new 519 building to maximise its benefit to our community, mirroring the excellent Glassworks and Alhambra Centre facilities in Barnsley to bring health to our high streets locally.
Alison McGovern
Well of course my honourable friend is a doughty champion for her local area and ensuring that we have services close to populations, close to where people live. I'm very happy of course to meet with my honourable friend to discuss this.
Dr Simon Opher. Question number five. Minister.
Speaker 29
Thank you Mr Speaker. We commissioned the independent Fonagy review which made clear that mental distress has increased particularly for young people and particularly for young women. That's why we've already improved mental health support in schools for young people and we'll publish a new mental health strategy by Christmas.
Joseph Simon Opher
Thank you. And as the minister knows there's over a million young people on the mental health waiting list currently. In Stroud and also in the Southbank Centre I'm working with clinical teams and creative teams to offer early intervention to these young people with social prescriptions for music, for art, for access to nature and exercise and indeed for stand-up comedy as well. So following the Fonagy review who recommend support in the community with lower level clinical services and on an earlier basis, would she support these initiatives and can I meet her and discuss them.
Alison McGovern
Thank you Mr Speaker and of course the member can meet me to discuss stand-up comedy, I'd like nothing more. Clinical services are important, we're already asking ICBs to reduce the longest waits for children and young people and we've had a 14% decrease but good mental health for young people goes way beyond that and the member knows how much I love arts, sport and culture as well as him.
Sir Ben Spencer.
Ben Spencer
Thank you Mr Speaker. The new Weybridge Health Centre which is being built now in my constituency, rebuilt following the fire in 2017, was planned to have a range of general services provided. When I visited it recently I learned that the first floor still doesn't have tenants put in place. Would she meet with me and representatives from the Phoenix Family Practice to discuss how we can make sure Weybridge gets the best possible broad healthcare provision.
Speaker 15
Thank you Mr Speaker. As you know Mr Speaker I always meet with any member who asks me to. It may be that another minister is more relevant for his particular health centre but we'll check that and make sure he has the right meeting because it sounds like a great community resource.
Neil Shastri-Hurst
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker, and can I start off by associating myself with your remarks on the tragic events involving Helen Hains over the last 24 hours. Mr Speaker, according to Future Minds' recent report, since the last election, more than 2.7 million referrals have been made to children and young people's mental health services in England, with more than a third of those referred still awaiting treatment. How can the government seriously claim to be tackling the rising number of young people not in education, employment or training, whilst simultaneously overseeing the waiting list run out of control?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I'd like to thank the shadow minister for his question. I would refer him to the Fonagy review, which details the causes which started before COVID of the rise in mental distress for young people. As I mentioned just a moment ago, Mr Speaker, we're already asking ICBs to reduce the longest wait, and we've seen some successes with that, but we have way more to do to address this challenge and we'll have more to say in the mental health strategy that will be published soon.
Diana Ruth Johnson
First of all, I'd like to pay tribute to my honourable friend for all her campaigning around DES and her constituent Jan Hall and her family. Mr Speaker, we recognise the serious intergenerational effects of exposure to DES, including increased cancer risks and reproductive complications, and we've asked NHS England and clinical networks to improve awareness of these issues and the people affected by them. And we've commissioned evidence, an evidence review of the intergenerational effects of DES, which will form our efforts to strengthen support in this area.
Jade Jessica Toale
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I thank the minister for her answer and for the constructive way in which the Department for Health has engaged with me and campaigners from DES Justice UK. But I'm still meeting women who are being denied breast cancer screening, colposcopies and other things that are essential for their care, despite the letter from the Cancer Alliance about DES exposure risk. So can the minister tell me how we can ensure GPs and other health professionals are truly aware of the risks of DES and that the women who need this support can get it when they need it?
Diana Ruth Johnson
And I recognise that some women exposed to DES still face difficulties accessing advice, monitoring and referral. Clinicians of course should consider individual medical histories, symptoms and risk factors. Now I had a look at the letter that was sent on the 12th of December explaining what more should be done by clinicians. I'm going to ask officials again to look at whether we need to reissue that letter or whether we need to take any other action to ensure that the information about DES is spread as wide as possible with clinicians.
Alison Bennett
Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I'm pleased that the minister's talking about making sure that medical professionals are more aware of DES and the risks for those who were potentially exposed to it. But further than that, what is their assessment of the feasibility of tracking and informing those who were potentially exposed? So my constituent Heather didn't realise that she had been exposed or her mother had been exposed until long after her mother's death. Well, as I was just saying, the government is improving identification and support for people affected by DES by raising awareness amongst clinicians, strengthening dissemination of existing NHS guidance.
Diana Ruth Johnson
But there are considerable challenges associated with recalling records from the 1940s to the 1970s, particularly due to the record-keeping practices of that era and the fact that the MHRA had not yet been established at that time, but I'm very mindful of the point that the honourable member makes.
Karin Smyth
Number seven, Mr Speaker. Thank you, Mr Speaker. And you know, the honourable gentleman makes an excellent point about the importance of intermediate care.
It's a key component of supporting patients into discharge to recover outside of hospitals. And whilst community beds do play an important role, we are clear that home-based intermediate care also needs support, particularly for frail people through neighbourhood health. That should be the default pathway and we'll continue to work with the system to make that happen.
Sam Rushworth
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Ward 7 of Bishop Auckland Hospital is an example of the NHS working. Physios, nurses, healthcare workers and some excellent facilities are provided. So we were shocked to hear that our local NHS trust is planning on closing the ward and moving it to Darlington and breaking up that team. Would the minister meet with me so I can represent my constituents and the workers at that hospital and raise those concerns with her face-to-face?
Karin Smyth
I of course am happy to meet with him to discuss that further and very clear that all changes to services should be based on clear evidence that they deliver better outcomes for his constituents and people across the country. He's absolutely right that we do want to extend care close to home and as I said the default is to get more care in people's homes where they live, but of course I'm happy to discuss that further with him.
Alexandra Katherine Brewer
Mr Speaker, in North East Hampshire our community hospital in Fleet is doing a brilliant job, but it could be a much more established resource for local people, especially given the delays in rebuilding our local hospitals. Will the minister meet with me to discuss how we can make the best use of community hospitals in North East Hampshire while we wait another two decades for the rebuild of Basingstoke Hospital?
Karin Smyth
She again is right to say that we absolutely want to get more care close to people's homes. We want to get that care in people's homes. We want to support frail people in their homes before they even get into hospital. And I'm working with the ICB to make sure all that happens and I'm happy to discuss it further with her.
Gregory James Stafford
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Step-down beds in community hospitals such as the Chase Community Hospital and Haslemere Hospital in my constituency are vital. Unfortunately, neither of the two hospitals are being utilised for that purpose at the moment. At the same time, delayed discharges have hit an all-time high under this government. Over 14,000 patients a day are stuck in hospital for two weeks or more after being declared fit to leave.
That's up 12% since July of last year. Behind every one of those numbers is someone who wants to be at home and an acute bed that another patient desperately needs. So why is the government so abysmally failing at getting people out of hospital and into care at home?
Karin Smyth
Well, as the honourable gentleman knows, this is a situation that deteriorated massively under the 14 years of their government. The fragmentation of all our services, he's well aware of that. He knows how the system was fragmented. He knows what happened under those reforms. He knows that's why we're trying to change it.
He's absolutely right though, people in beds in hospitals or in a part of the system where they shouldn't be is not good for their health, not for their outcomes. That's why it's part of our three shifts and that's fundamentally why the Prime Minister is very clear that we will raise social care up the agenda, make sure that people are treated more in homes, more in community services where they are. So I welcome his support for our shift to neighbourhood and our shift to better care closer to home.
James Frith
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This government has been working to rebuild the NHS dental service since we came into office. The latest data shows 37.6 million courses of dental treatment were delivered last year, nearly 3 million more than at the general election.
David Reed
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Access to NHS dentistry is a major problem in my constituency of Exmouth and Exeter East, with 86% of the respondents to my dentistry survey unable to access one. Now, some told me that they still travel back to their old NHS dentist after moving home, and in one case a trip of more than 130 miles because no local practice will take them as a patient.
Now unlike GP surgeries, NHS dentists have no catchment areas. So will the minister please look at whether this is making it harder for local people to get an appointment?
James Frith
The honourable member raises a really important point and is a theme in the work that I am doing. 81% of those that wanted to get an NHS dentist in the last year were able to, but I recognise that too many and too often you have to have an existing relationship with an NHS dentist to access that. Since then, the general election, the government's tackling of the dental desert has seen government ring-fence 4 billion for dentistry, NHS dentistry. There is huge amounts done but there is even more to do and he has the government's and my attention on this matter.
Speaker 41
Thanks very much Mr Speaker. Since being elected I have campaigned for a new dental school in the East of England and can I thank the government for backing that at the University of East Anglia with 25 new funded places. However, Norfolk is still a dental desert where people struggle to get an appointment. I've just returned from maternity leave and I couldn't get one when I was pregnant and I am not alone in that, pregnant or otherwise. So can the minister set out what the government will do to ensure that constituents can get a dental appointment, including a timetable for the reform of the dentistry contract?
James Frith
I thank my honourable friend and welcome back from maternity leave. What a time that is. I'd like to thank my honourable friend and I know she's been campaigning relentlessly on the issue of dental schools but also in addressing the dental deserts that we speak about so frequently. We have an East of England and a South East dental school incoming. These schools will start to take on new students in September 2027 and I look forward to them playing a part in strengthening dental provision locally.
Mr Speaker, we want every cancer patient to benefit from high-quality radiotherapy regardless of where they live. There has always been a need to balance the objective of providing care closer to each person's home with the imperative of maintaining access to the specialist expertise and technology needed for safe, effective treatment.
Timothy James Farron
I thank the minister for his answer. In South Cumbria only 29% of cancer patients get radiotherapy. That's the lowest in the country and only 27% of them get that treatment within the 62-day target. All because my constituents have to travel to the excellent but far too distant Rosemere Cancer Unit at Preston, involving daily, grueling round trips of up to four hours for weeks on end, effectively excluding many from treatment. This awful, unequal access costs lives.
So will the minister set out a plan for delivering new satellite radiotherapy units in areas like mine and will he meet with me and our local hospitals trusts to help us to deliver our long-overdue radiotherapy satellite unit at Kendal?
James Frith
I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. I'm very happy to meet with him and his colleagues on it. There is a theme developing around rural and coastal communities and the demands on treatment, particularly at a time when facing radiotherapy to be expected to travel further. It is the responsibility for ICBs, supported by NHS national guidance, to strike the balance that I speak to between population needs, geography and inequalities. I understand there have been recent exchanges between him and his ICB.
Christopher John Vince
I'm very happy to have conversation with him about that and lean into what options are available hereafter. Thank you.
Thank you Mr Speaker. We know that under this government 250,000 people are being diagnosed within the 28 days, which is something we should welcome, but we also must recognise that there is more to be done. This morning I met with Prostate Cancer UK, in fact I play football against them, we did win. However, that's true, however they made the point that we still have so many men who are in this country who are dying of prostate cancer because they're not coming forward soon enough.
We know that is even more of an impact on the BAME community. So can I ask what the government can do to support wonderful charities like Prostate UK to cut down the number of men dying of prostate cancer?
James Frith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's an honour to have the opportunity to respond to the champion for Harlow in his place. It also presents me with the opportunity to make clear, contrary to reports over the summer, that should people, should men suspect of having symptoms, they can go to their GP and seek a PSA test for prostate cancer. This government is the first government to launch a men's health strategy with more information to come and very much look forward to working with him and colleagues across the house whose record is strong on this matter.
Sir Jeremy Hunt.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Mr. Speaker, one of the reasons the government committed to bring back the family doctor was because of the importance of maintaining continuity of care for patients. And I'm pleased to say that the proportion of patients who say they're able to see their preferred clinician when they make a GP appointment has risen from 61% to 68% since the election. But we recognise that there is more to do and this remains an important priority for this government.
Sir Jeremy.
Jeremy Hunt
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Has the minister read the Norwegian population study published in the British Journal of General Practice that says that people who see the same doctor over many years are 30% less likely to need out-of-hours care, 28% less likely to need emergency care, and 25% less likely to die? It's been two years since we had this pledge to bring back the family doctor, but the basic structure of general practice has not changed. Can we see some changes in the next GP contract negotiations to bring back the system we used to have where everyone has their own doctor?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well, I recognise the enormous experience and knowledge of the former Secretary of State for Health and his work around this issue and around patient safety more generally. And I know that the department has already started to look at expert advice with a clinical working group on how best to support continuity of care in modern general practice. But certainly the report that he referred to, I'm certainly happy to go and have a look at that. I haven't read it yet, but I'm going to go and have a look at it. And I'm also very happy to have a discussion with him because it would be helpful to understand more of his thinking because I know he considers this a very important issue.
Speaker 48
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Continuity of care in maternity services is based on women building relationships with maternity practitioners who meet them where they are. So I'd like to echo the earlier comments from the member for Shropshire to say that many obstetricians and midwives have been truly disappointed at comments from an NHS leader yesterday that more maternity units should be shut where he argued that only consolidation of services can make birth safer. Mr. Speaker, women in this country will not accept the industrialisation of our bodies. This Labour government has promised neighbourhood and preventative healthcare, which has to include allowing new mums to feel rooted in the communities where they'll go through their biggest physical and psychological change.
Diana Ruth Johnson
So can the minister assure me that our bodies will not be treated like a manufacturing supply chain to be optimised as she develops the asks for maternity services in this country?
Gosh, well my honourable friend made a very passionate statement there and I absolutely agree with what she's saying. And of course this work is going to be undertaken with the maternity taskforce looking at all of these issues. And I hope that my honourable friend will feel able to look at that work and contribute if that's something she wishes to do.
Caroline Johnson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now continuity of care is desirable but not always possible and in those circumstances a single patient record offers an opportunity to improve care, but it also offers the risk of unauthorised access to notes. And we've seen some recent high-profile cases where notes have been accessed that shouldn't have been done. This has led to people's worry across the country that this will affect them personally in less quite high-profile cases and what will happen when the single patient record makes records available nationally. So how is the government going to protect people's patient confidentiality?
Lindsay Hoyle
Can I just say, I think it's a bit of a struggle to get from the question we've got to where we are. The minister's happy to answer.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well, perhaps, Mr. Speaker, mindful of your, your comment there. It's totally unacceptable what's happened recently, and the Secretary of State has made that very clear. And my understanding is that those individuals who've accessed information about patients with no, with no business to access that have been suspended, and disciplinary action will follow, and dismissals possibly. So I think that that is very clear that it's totally unacceptable.
Caroline Johnson
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Um, another issue that affects continuity of care is when patient remain, patients remain in the emergency department for prolonged periods after a decision is made to admit them to a ward. This has gone up by over a third since the general election. Can the government say why?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well, actually, the, the issue around A&E is that times are being speeded up, so I'd say that to the, the honorable lady. I know she also speaks with experience because she's a clinician herself, but I'm, I'm very happy to go away and look at this and write to her if there's information that we need to let her have on this. But my understanding is that we are speeding up in A&E, getting people through and onto the ward as quickly as possible.
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the National Cancer Plan sets out how the government will continue to reduce waiting times for diagnosis and treatment, use new research, technology, and clinical trials to transform outcomes. And alongside the Prime Minister last week, I met Archie Goodburn in Downing Street to discuss with him the new action that we are taking on brain cancer and our determination to tackle every form of this cruel disease.
Richard Baker
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know that action is welcome right across the House. Each year around twenty thousand men in Scotland are diagnosed with prostate cancer, but between a half and two-thirds of those men could benefit from focal therapy, which has a five-fold lower risk of harmful side effects than conventional treatments. Will my right honorable friend share learning and data from the expansion of focal therapy provision in England with Scottish ministers, as it is still not available in Scotland despite NHS Fife being well-placed to provide a national center in focal therapy treatment in Scotland?
Speaker 9
Well, my honorable friend makes a really important point about the importance of improving prostate cancer treatment, which does affect so many men across the UK. We're investing two point eight million to expand access to focal therapy in the specialist centers in England, and NICE will be looking at the progress that that is making. We will be very keen, of course, to work with the Scottish government on this and for them to also be able to see those results. It's important that we continue to improve treatment.
Carla Lockhart
Mr. Speaker, Scott, aged thirty, is a dad, a son, and a partner, and a much-loved member of the Banbridge community, but he's battling grade four brain cancer. Brain cancer is the biggest killer of young people under the age of forty in the UK, and survival rates are lower than average across all cancers, yet access to clinical trials is negligible, with only two percent of brain tumor patients successfully accessing those trials. Can the Secretary of State indicate will she expand brain tumor clinical trials across the United Kingdom and ensure that there's fair access across all nations?
Speaker 9
Can I pay tribute to her constituent who obviously is undergoing the most difficult of circumstances. It's exactly because this is such a devastating condition that we have introduced a three-month rapid review of all of the research and all of the barriers for getting more patients into trials. We are keen of course to continue to work with the devolved governments on this because the research benefits that we can do actually benefit all of us right across the United Kingdom. And we will be drawing up a framework to get drugs more quickly into trials and also to get more patients into those trials.
Diana Ruth Johnson
I'm aware that there are a number of honorable and right honorable members who are very interested in this issue. And as the new Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety, I'm personally driving this work and am giving the Patient Safety Commissioner's report the urgent and thorough consideration that it requires. The government is committed to making meaningful progress in this Parliament as has been stated already and is advancing non-financial redress to improve health service support for those affected.
Chris Cocklin
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In 2006, my constituent Ruth had pelvic mesh implanted. It has corroded and caused her severe pain. She has been desperate for me to raise this with the government. Three years ago, she paid for surgery to remove it but it's left her tens of thousands out of pocket and she requires more surgery.
Speaker 56
What steps is the Minister taking to implement the recommendations of the 2024 Hughes report, particularly for giving justice to pelvic mesh patients and support for those who cannot access the NHS compensation scheme?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well, I am very sorry to hear about the experience of Ruth and what she's gone through. And I also just last night watched the film that had been produced around the experience of a number of women. My honorable friend for Washington and Gateshead South had provided a screening I think in Parliament last week and it's harrowing the stories that were within that program that I watched. As I said, I am looking at this. I'm very conscious that honorable and right honorable members are interested in seeing what the government is going to do.
The previous Secretary of State had made it clear that there would be progress made by the end of this Parliament. So I think that's as far as I can go today but I am personally looking at this.
Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. From pelvic mesh to DES, women have been harmed by a health system that has not and still doesn't listen to them as starkly illustrated in Mumsnet's recent report on medical misogyny, a lifetime of failure. Does the Minister agree that tackling medical misogyny must be at the heart of how we rebuild the NHS?
Diana Ruth Johnson
My honorable friend makes a very important point and that is why we've revised the women's health strategy and it's made very clear within that that this issue of medical misogyny is not acceptable and women's voices must be heard.
Ian Roome
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. May I thank the Secretary of State for her answer to my colleague. Question 13.
Speaker 9
I know he's keen to ask his question. I just as I made clear earlier, we are determined to see the support given for North Devon maternity services to reopen to provide quality maternity care. It is the responsibility of the trust to ensure that they have the safe staffing levels in place but the NHS regional and national teams are also working to support them.
Ian Roome
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. May I thank the Secretary of State for the answer that she gave to my colleague earlier on about North Devon maternity unit. As the local MP, I can attest how urgent reopening the center is to the local community. I heard what she said about plans being underway to improve local recruitment. Will the Secretary of State meet with me to update me on the work underway, and would she also update the House on the national workforce plan, which is long overdue?
Speaker 9
Well, I can say to the honorable member that the national maternity and neonatal intensive support team has visited the trust to look at what more can be done. They have a particular issue with the recruitment of consultants and measures that they thought had been put in place, or they had assured us would be put in place, in the end ended up not being effective, and so they have now got to take further action. It's really important they continue to do so. We will absolutely keep him up to date with all of the measures that we are taking nationally, but I know he is also in very close contact with the local trust as well, and hopefully the continued pressure both local, regional, and national will ensure that those services can open as swiftly as possible.
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the COVID-19 inquiry has today published its module six report on what Baroness Hallett calls the devastating impact of the pandemic on people receiving and providing care for their loved ones. My thoughts are with all those who lost loved ones in the pandemic, and especially those who endured the immense distress and harm of visiting restrictions in care homes, which meant they could not be with loved ones even as they died. I also pay tribute to all those who worked to protect the most vulnerable in very difficult circumstances, from care workers to family members. The report finds the adult social care sector was in a fragile state and insufficiently prepared for a pandemic, and that social care was too often treated as an afterthought in comparison to the priority placed on protecting the NHS. We will provide a full response to the report's recommendations in due course, but I agree with the chair when she said adult social care has for too long been undervalued and underrecognized.
Speaker 57
That has to end, and I hope we can work cross-party to support the Prime Minister's vision for a national care service in the future.
Tim Farron.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The only way children can be tested for having metachromatic leukodystrophy, or MLD, and then given life-saving treatment is if their older sibling is diagnosed, at which point it is too late to save that older sibling's life. That was the case for my constituent Nicola, whose daughter was diagnosed when she was already symptomatic, and she died aged 13. Nicola's younger son was only able to be diagnosed and treated because of his late sister's illness. This cruel tragedy could be avoided if the government added MLD to the infant heel prick test.
When will she do that, and will she meet with MLD families and myself so she can hear from them firsthand the desperate need for this change?
Speaker 9
I'm very sorry for everything that Nicola and her family have been through. The honorable member will know that the screening committee, the National Screening Committee, guides the government in screening decisions. It has looked at newborn screening and concluded there is not yet enough evidence to include the MLD. However, they are currently awaiting evidence from pilot studies looking into screening for MLD and also for the recently implemented Norwegian screening program. I can tell him that I will look further at this and also ensure that he gets a meeting with ministers to be able to talk about MLD.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
My constituent Audrina Hatton-Wright is a 12-year-old cancer survivor. She spent a huge amount of her childhood in hospital where she found the food was sometimes not of the nutritional quality to support people's recovery. She's running a high-profile campaign on this which has took her onto the BBC and ITV this morning. Will ministers meet with myself and Audrina to see where we can work on this together?
Karin Smyth
Well, can we absolutely thank Audrina for the great work that she's doing and being supported by the campaign. Food in hospitals is really important and we're very happy to do that and meet with her. Well done her.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, with a waiting list of over 7 million, the NHS needs the sharpest focus on patient care and delivery, but ministers have created disruption and distraction. I do have some sympathy for the Secretary of State. The right honorable member for Ilford North had said no to a top-down reorganization, then abruptly changed his mind without, it seems, much thinking it through. Within an hour of the first reading of the Health Bill, he had hopped it, and now it falls to her.
Speaker 62
So does she believe in his plan, and does she still believe the NHS England will be dissolved by the 1st of April?
Speaker 9
I just say to the honorable member, this is a little bit rich coming from the member who voted for the 2012 Andrew Lansley reforms, having promised no top-down reorganizations, and then having done one of the worst and most damaging top-down reorganizations ever in the history of the NHS. We are taking forward the Health Bill through Parliament. It is currently going through the House of Lords. And because what we want to do is focus on frontline care rather than have the huge expansion of bureaucracy under his government previously that ended up absorbing money away from the frontline and ended up with far too much duplication as well.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
I didn't hear the greatest statement of belief that the deadline would be hit. But now since the original plan, we know that costs are up. The transfer functions out of ICBs has been delayed, even though 8,000 people have gone. Multiple mergers are on hold. And in place of NHS England, it may be the mother of all quangos, but it seems instead we will get the sister of the mother of all quangos, the Special Health Authority as a new regional management tier.
So does she still expect there to be a net benefit of a billion pounds a year this Parliament? And if not, what does that do to frontline health funding on top of the pressures we know about on pay and on medicines? And isn't the real cost here to patient care?
Speaker 9
I've just got to say, the honorable member's party and his government that he supported expanded the number of jobs in NHS England from around 5,000 to over 20,000 in the space of just a few years. What this government is doing is actually reducing the number of jobs in administration and bureaucracy in order to put the investment into expanding the number of clinical posts across the country and across our NHS. We're already making substantial savings with further efficiency savings, productivity savings taking place this year, because this government is actually delivering lower waiting lists, more treatment, faster treatment, and improvements for patients.
Speaker 65
Mr. Speaker, East Suffolk and North Ipswich NHS Foundation Trust has made a 98 million pound application to the Estate Safety Fund for a new maternity building. Our local services support the delivery of around about 3,000 babies every single year, but this building has been not fit for purpose for many, many years. So will the Secretary of State support our bid for a new maternity wing at Ipswich Hospital to make sure that babies and families get the state-of-the-art services that they so desperately need?
Karin Smyth
The honorable member raises an excellent point about the state that these buildings were left in by the party opposite, that Lord Darzi's report made clear. We're investing unprecedented amounts in capital, giving greater certainty, and I'm very happy to meet with him to discuss the proposal from Ipswich. We're making that more certain, it's up to the local system to come forward with plans, but I'm very happy to discuss with him further.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Last week, ITV News uncovered devastating statistics that show thousands of children are now being treated on hospital corridors. They shared the heartbreaking story of Finley Roberts, whose parents spent hours in A&E waiting for help before he died, and he was just two. As a mum, I can't bear to imagine waiting and seeing your child deteriorate like this, because the Roberts family deserved better. Will the Secretary of State confirm when we will see data on the numbers of children receiving corridor care, and will she commit to ending corridor care once and for all within a year and making children an urgent priority?
Speaker 9
Well, I think the story of what happened to little Finley is just devastating and unimaginable for his family. And I would reiterate the apology that I have made to Finley's family. This happened in the summer of 2024, but it is still devastating that it should happen and that he should be treated in that way on a corridor. The, as the honorable member will know, we are now for the first time measuring corridor care now since earlier this year, because we have to end corridor care. It's not fair on patients.
I have, I am introducing new assessments of corridor care involving children, because that has to be the urgent priority. No child should be treated in a corridor.
Damien James Egan
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The steps outlined by the Minister earlier towards expanding access to NHS dental treatment is very welcome, but still too many of my constituents report that they can't see an NHS dentist when they need one. Can the Minister therefore tell us what specific steps are being taken to improving dental services across the Bristol region?
James Frith
I thank the honorable friend for his question. I do recognize that too many of his constituents will be struggling to secure an NHS dentist despite the improvements already made. Responsibility is with the ICB locally. I would encourage him through me by all means to reach a conversation with the ICB to commission dentistry. The government has provided four billion in ring-fenced funding for NHS dentistry, which has gone some way to the improvements we have seen, but I know there's plenty more to do and he has my attention.
Speaker 35
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Five years ago this month, Emsworth Medical Practice's new building opened thanks to funding from the last Conservative government. Will the Minister commit to providing funding for the expansion of more GP surgeries in the Havant constituency?
Diana Ruth Johnson
There is money available for GP surgeries, as my honorable friend has already said, many of them were left in a terrible state under the previous government. They weren't invested in over many years. There is money available. I'm very happy when I meet with the honorable gentleman to discuss that with him.
Helena Dollimore
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Many hospital specialisms are increasingly shared between Eastbourne Hospital and Hastings Conquest Hospital in my constituency. This means that the people I represent who don't drive are required to travel a long way by public transport to get to Eastbourne Hospital, between 90 minutes and two hours, and that involves a lot of walking. I know the member for Eastbourne also shares my concerns about the other direction. With so many services shared between the two hospitals, I'm calling on the NHS Integrated Care Board and the Trust and the reform-run County Council to look at providing a shuttle bus to make it easier for people to travel between the two hospitals.
Speaker 75
Does the Minister agree that this is something health commissioners should look at when planning services?
Karin Smyth
Thank you Mr. Speaker. She's absolutely right that it is the responsibility of the commissioners to look holistically at the provision of services. We want more services close to home using technology, care in people's homes etc. But she's quite right to highlight this issue. I know she'll campaign and I hope everyone's listened to her to bring people together to help her constituents.
Gregory Campbell.
Gregory Campbell
Mr. Speaker, bowel cancer rates are increasing among the under 50 age group. What targeted interventions are taking place to try and address that to reduce the instances in the future?
Speaker 9
Mr. Speaker, the national cancer plan published by the health department is about prevention, treatment and support and also crucially research for the future. And it's the research which can help benefit us across the United Kingdom.
Sharon Hodgson
Mr. Speaker, I had the pleasure last week of meeting Her Majesty the Queen to discuss the importance of having fracture liaison services in every NHS trust, something that this government has already committed to. So will the minister today on World Osteoporosis Day outline what steps her department is taking to develop the long overdue national implementation plan for universal access to fracture prevention services by 2030?
Alison McGovern
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It's no surprise to me given Mr. Speaker, sorry. Been around too long. Thank you Mr. Speaker. And it's no surprise to me given the record of my friend in campaigning on this and many other issues in the work that she did in opposition and in government that she would be in such august company to discuss this matter.
And I do pay tribute to her and all of those who've campaigned on it because osteoporosis can have a devastating impact on health. She knows we're committed to improving care, especially rolling out state-of-the-art scanners and I'm sure we'll meet very soon to discuss it.
Wendy Morton
The government proposes to abolish Healthwatch and bring its functions inside the department and local NHS bodies. But patients do need an independent champion who can challenge things when they go wrong. So what savings does she believe that will result from this and how will she ensure that this doesn't result in the loss of an independent voice for patients?
Speaker 9
I'm clear there has to be an independent voice for patients as part of the health system. It's why I said at the time that we had the third reading that the government was looking again at Healthwatch and we would report back in the Lords. We will do that very shortly in advance of the committee stage.
Rosie Collins.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Thank you Mr. Speaker. As the minister knows I work with a lot of dying people and their families, so good palliative care is very important to me and of course my constituents. Recently this House turned down an opportunity to expand end-of-life care with some opponents citing the state of palliative care as the reason for voting against assisted dying. So can the minister tell me what she is doing to improve palliative care, particularly in light of recent announcements about a national care service?
Minister.
Alison McGovern
Thank you Mr. Speaker. And I pay tribute to my friend for all the work that she has done with hospices and others on palliative and end-of-life care. I think everybody right across this House wants to see it improved. We've got a modern service framework on its way and as part of the national care service that we're working on we'll make sure that we care for the dying in a much, much better way in this country.
Paul Holmes.
Paul Holmes
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Recently I visited Newmedica in my constituency to see the vital role that independent providers have in providing NHS funded eye surgery and care. With the health bill progressing, what assurances can the minister provide that it will strengthen the right to choose across all providers and that ICBs make full use of all the choices which my ICB currently isn't?
James Frith
I thank the honorable member for his excellent question. The government is protecting choice in the health bill and a chance also to affirm the independent sector and the vital role that they play. Optometry is not an add-on to the NHS, it's an important part of the health ecosystem and very happy to have further conversations with him.
Speaker 78
As we approach winter, it's even more important that we minimize pressure on hospitals. In Welwyn Garden City, we have an urgent treatment center at the New QE2, but it's in a modern building and I believe it's got the capacity to do more. So will my right honorable friend agree with me that it's time to look at the resources that we could provide the New QE2 to provide greater community care?
Speaker 9
I thank the honorable member for his point. As he may know, we have just announced 140 million new investment in urgent treatment centers and also in same-day emergency services exactly to ensure that we are easing the pressures around accident and emergency, which have gone up substantially this summer linked to the extreme heat. And I know ministers will be happy to discuss further with him his local proposals.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
I thank the minister for her recent confirmation that the renal dialysis service would remain at Hinchingbrooke Hospital in my constituency during the build of the new hospital program. But I'm conscious that it isn't in the scope of the actual new hospital and longer term may not be there. Could she offer me some assurances that this vital service for constituents will remain at Hinchingbrooke, and if not, whether any provision is being made to make sure that this is a local resource that stays available to people going forward?
Karin Smyth
Well, I thank him, I'm glad he found that correspondence helpful. As he knows, I'm keen to discuss with all members about the new hospital program and progress. I'm sure that discussions continue to take place locally about the renal service at Hinchingbrooke and they'll continue to work together. I know he'll keep in touch on behalf of his constituents about progress of those discussions. I'm happy to talk to him about it.
Lorraine Beavers
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Blackpool Victoria Hospital desperately needs more money. This is because the ICB funding to hospital trusts doesn't account for the 20 million tourists or the complexity of care required. So I ask the Secretary of State, will she ensure that Blackpool Victoria Hospital receives its fair share of extra funding from the ICB?
Karin Smyth
I thank the honorable lady, my honorable friend for her point about that. I appreciate the concerns that she has on behalf of her constituents. We are moving systems like Blackpool away from deficit funding into a well-governed and managed system in line with fair shares allocation. I'm happy to discuss that further with her.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Torbay Hospital, which serves my constituency, is part is one of the oldest parts of the NHS estate, and the Devon and Cornwall Fire Service have recently ruled that the tower block is now unsafe in the event of a fire. A quarter of the beds in the hospital are in that tower block, so patients are now being moved, staff are extremely worried about what comes next, and it's making the hospital much less viable. So will the minister meet with me and other Devon colleagues to discuss the future funding of Torbay Hospital to make it safe and secure and to keep it operating?
Karin Smyth
I thank her. I have met with Torbay MP about this matter. Money obviously has been allocated. We are well aware of the situation with Torbay and it is also part of the program. I'm very happy to provide her further information if she's not clear on the allocations that have been made.
Speaker 80
Mr. Speaker, demand for surrogacy from the UK is leading to the exploitation of women across the globe in countries including Ukraine, Nigeria, and Mexico. Can my right honorable friend give a time commitment on when legislation will come onto the floor of the house so that we can do our part in ending this exploitation as soon as possible?
Diana Ruth Johnson
We are clear that no surrogacy arrangement should place any party at risk of exploitation, and the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office provide guidance on the risks of overseas surrogacy and the steps intended parents, sorry, and the steps intended parents must take to return to the UK with their child.
The government has no current plans to legislate to prevent people domiciled in the UK from entering international surrogacy arrangements.
Gagan Mohindra
Speaker, under the previous Conservative government, upwards of 300 million pounds was earmarked for the new Watford General Hospital, which would have been life-saving as well as life-changing for many of my constituents. When combined with the closure of the urgent care center at Mount Vernon Hospital, a lot of my constituents are now not getting the first-class healthcare that they would reasonably expect. What assurances can the minister give to my residents?
Karin Smyth
Again, Watford General, and I pay tribute to my honorable friend for Watford and others for campaigning on this in that northwest part of London as well, on the movement of services. It is now firmly part of that program. The people of Watford will have the services they deserve. Those discussions are continuing, and I'm happy to update the House as soon as possible on the final decision.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Percy, a five-year-old constituent of mine, wrote in to raise whether gluten-free products will ever be on prescription for people with celiac disease. Can the minister confirm what steps she is taking to address postcode variations in provision of gluten-free food by integrated care boards?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Well, the national position in England remains that gluten-free bread and mixes can be prescribed on the National Health Service for eligible people diagnosed with celiac disease. However, as my honorable friend says, ICBs can restrict or end the prescribing of GF food, but I'm very happy to discuss this with her.
Seamus Logan
Mr. Speaker, the department has thus far refused to publish the impact assessment associated with the US-UK pharma deal. So can I ask the Secretary of State, what is it the government are trying to hide?
James Frith
I thank the honorable member for his question. The first-nation status that we have with US pharma is an advance on usual relations. It comes with huge benefits. I'd be very happy to take away more specific concerns he has in a conversation after today.
Speaker 90
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm grateful that the department has moved swiftly to identify issues and supply issues with Bedrolite from the company that's in real difficulty in the Netherlands, Bedrocan. I understand that supply, there's confidence in supplies until 2027, but understanding from my constituents that that might depend on whether or not you have an NHS or a private prescription. Would the minister be able to meet with his officials and with me to go through some of these processes, which from my constituent's experience have been very bureaucratic?
James Frith
My honorable friend makes a really important point, and ensuring sustainable supply on something so sensitive in medicine for addressing epilepsy is uppermost in my mind. It's a live situation, and I am working at pace with officials and will update accordingly. Thank you.
Matthew Stephen Darling
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The fire service and the CQC have now served legal notice against the tower block at Torbay Hospital with more than 100 beds under threat. This is new information, and this is now a crisis at Torbay Hospital. Will the minister meet with myself and other Devon MPs to help navigate this crisis, please?
Karin Smyth
I recently met with the honorable member, as he knows. We are absolutely committed to working with the local system to do that, and I absolutely commit to updating him, if he's not aware of where we are on that, at the soonest possible opportunity. I'll get something back to him very quickly.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For those considering suicide, the message must be there's always another way. But with new ONS data showing the rate of suicide in Cumberland has increased yet again, would ministers meet with me and my Cumbrian colleagues to ensure our health system is providing support to all when they need it?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for that important question on such an important issue.
I'll of course meet. We've had a number of very important debates on this issue in the House, Mr. Speaker, just showing how important members across the House think this is.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It can take far too long for patients to receive a diagnosis of Lyme disease. My constituent Jill, she's a nurse, she gave her life to the NHS which failed to diagnose her. She had to seek treatment from abroad. Will the minister meet with me and Jill to discuss what went wrong here?
Darren James Paffey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. ITV News' damning investigation into failings in disability care covered the case of Adam Crook, son of my constituent Joanna, who raised serious allegations around alleged assault and unexplained burns, and yet these serious concerns remain unanswered. The care home still hasn't been inspected since 2021 and the provider has faced no sanctions. Will the minister please ensure this gets investigated, get CQC to act and ensure that those responsible are held accountable?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for his question and through him pass my concerns to the family that he mentions. I will write to him with what CQC are doing about it. Mr. Speaker, Baroness Louise Casey has already recommended some steps we take urgently on safeguarding, which we are doing. We have a new national safeguarding board and I'll draw the attention of the chief social worker to the case he mentions too.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Constituents in North Herefordshire and across the country want to see an end to the current postcode lottery in access to adult social care. The King's Fund published a report on this just last week on equal access. Has the minister read that report and does she agree that social care needs to be locally delivered but nationally funded?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable lady for that question. She makes an excellent point. The research is good. The crisis we're seeing in some hospitals as we turn the ship around is because we have not grappled with this issue of social care. We've got to make sure that people are cared for in their own homes and we've got to do that consistently to help our NHS.
Speaker 94
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will ministers meet with me to discuss the future of East Cleveland Hospital and what more services we can get closer to our community?
Shockat Patel
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the government's commitment to regulating the funeral services, but for Jewish and Muslim families, burying a loved one quickly is a religious duty and not a preference. So will the minister ensure that faith communities and the burial societies like MB Col in my constituency of Leicester South are consulted directly and that the new legislation does nothing to delay burials?
Speaker 9
The honorable member makes an incredibly important point because people's faith needs to be respected as part of ensuring that they have dignity in death and that they can have the care and respect for them and their families. This is an issue we will ensure is part of the consultations that are underway at the moment and will certainly be a central consideration in ensuring we have an effective regulation system.
Lloyd Hatton
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This month we heard that Wareham's chemotherapy clinic will reopen in early next year following two years of campaigning, meaning that patients across Purbeck will no longer have to travel long distances to access cancer care. Building on that success, will the minister work with me to finally restore the rheumatology clinic at Swanage Community Hospital so that many more patients can access care much closer to where they actually live?
Karin Smyth
I'm always keen to discuss and visit places in Dorset with my honorable friend. I'm happy to look with him at the overall plan from the ICB for the provision of all of those services.
Saqib Bhatti
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I recently met with pharmacists in my constituency of Meriden and Solihull East and they expressed concern around resilience in the supply chains, specifically around wholesale suppliers who may be forcing stockpiling or rumors making sure that, you know, medicines have to be stockpiled, forcing up prices. In that case it was Ramipril, but it's across the board. It's the British taxpayer and our constituents that are suffering. Is the Secretary of State aware of this and has she considered getting the Competition and Markets Authority involved?
James Frith
I thank the honorable member for his question. Medicine supply chains are complicated, global and highly regulated. The specific point he makes around price and profiteering, prospective profiteering, I'd be very happy to speak more in detail about. The overwhelming majority of medicines are in good supply.
Abtisam Mohamed.
Baggy Bhagat Shanker
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite increasing demand, the last government scrapped plans for a super new health center in Tinsley, denying our community the care and capacity it deserves. Could the Minister confirm that this government is taking a different approach and providing the NHS services in local communities like Tinsley and beyond?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Absolutely. This is a core part of the neighborhood health offer that this government is making. We've already announced in wave one a number of neighborhood health centers. Wave two will be shortly announced, but this is absolutely key to keeping people out of hospital and providing healthcare in local communities.
Helen Maguire.
Helen Maguire
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The UDA formula is broken, pushing dentists out of NHS every single day. In Epsom and Ewell there is a dentist who is restricted to providing NHS dentistry by the UDA quotas. So will the Minister reform the dental contract now and incentivize NHS dentistry?
James Frith
I thank the honorable member for her question, Mr. Speaker. The government remains committed to longer-term reform of the dental contract. I think we have to look much more at the outcomes that we are commissioning and not simply concentrating on the units of activity, which has not aged well and is part of the problem we're trying to address.
Euan Stainbank
In 2022 a monument in Oslo was unveiled to Cecilie Flatval, a woman with incurable breast cancer. This weekend I met with my constituent Sylvia who survived breast cancer and fundraised extensively through Race for Life. Will the Minister meet with myself and Sylvia to discuss how we could support a similar monument being brought to the United Kingdom?
Speaker 9
Can I thank the honorable member for raising this as part of Breast Cancer Awareness Month? This is, I think, a moment to recognize the progress that has been made as a result of huge amount of work across our NHS and in research, but there is still a long way to go and I will ensure he gets the ministerial meeting he seeks.
Final question, James Wild.
James Wild
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. On Saturday I joined hundreds of people in King's Lynn to protest against leaked plans by Norfolk and Waveney Hospitals Group to downgrade A&E, maternity and ICU at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital. Does the Health Secretary agree that services should be as local to people as possible and will she reject any plans to remove services from the QEH?
Karin Smyth
I am aware of the issues around his hospital, as he knows I've worked with him closely as part of the New Hospital Programme as well. It is up to local systems to decide on the clinical pathways across the whole patch. Also this must be clinically led in consultation with local people and local, and I'm very happy to keep an eye on that with and talk with him in the future.
Point of order, Tessa Munt.
Tessa Munt
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I submitted a written parliamentary question to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on the 28th of April, sir. I am awaiting a response.
I think I've been pretty patient. I wonder if he could give me some advice on exactly what I do to elicit a response.
Lindsay Hoyle
Can I just say it is totally unacceptable for members whichever side of this house they sit. Members are carrying out their duties on behalf of constituents. It's not acceptable. I hope that the front bench have heard it. The message is going loud and clear.
If you don't get a reply very quickly, come and see me. But there are other ways that we can find out why you've not had an answer. But I will say once again, it is not acceptable. We now come to presentation of bill, Dawn Butler.
Lindsay Hoyle
Friday the 27th of November. We now come to presentation of bill, Graham Leadbitter.
Lindsay Hoyle
Friday the 13th of November. Right, we now come to the ten minute rule bill, Social Security (Marriage), Richard Holden.
John Richard Holden
Thank you very much indeed Mr Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to prohibit the recognition of polygamous marriage, marriages within prohibited degrees and certain other marriages between close relatives in the social security system. Mr Speaker, I have brought this bill to the house today to correct an extraordinary fault within our welfare system. Something so bizarre and indefensible that I can scarcely believe that we need to address bring legislation forwards to address it here. We do not yet know what the government wishes to do in this area, but I hope that down the line if this passes today that they will not oppose my bill on Friday the 13th of November.
Mr Speaker, we should begin with a simple question: what is welfare for? Beveridge understood the principle of contribution, of responsibility, of security when hard times come. You pay into a system, you help sustain it, and it will be there for you when you need it. And alongside that, you also know that help is there for those most in need, for those who simply cannot or will never be able to look after themselves. That is the essence of a system which all sides of this house could agree to, contributory and compassionate.
But how far have we drifted when our rules make special provision for polygamy or incest to be recognised in the benefit system? Can members opposite or anywhere in the house point to somewhere in Beveridge where it is envisaged a man's third or fourth wife being supported? Where where where is any of that when Beveridge laid the foundations of our modern welfare system? Now Mr Speaker, we know that some members take a different view on Beveridge. They've never seen a benefit of any kind to anyone that they don't want to see preserved at any cost.
A system which they are unable or incapable, unwilling to say no. Whenever that moment arrives to top up a budget or to dish out another handout, they're there. But I hope that this bill in those members will stir a new feeling and the blinkers will fall from their eyes and that they will see a system which gives special treatment for men with multiple wives and potentially for incestuous marriages too is at the point where their inner conservatism breaks out. For today we're talking about the provisions that recognise overseas polygamous marriages that make allowance for additional spouses.
A second wife, a third wife, and onwards. We're talking about a man rinsing the taxpayer of social security benefits under unbelievable provisions in law that recognize polygamous marriages illegal in here in the UK. And then we chuck around welfare payments to them with free abandon. Mr. Speaker, taxpayers are entitled to ask what on earth are we doing? And that brings me to my second point, because it is about polygamy, but it's also about overseas marriages between close relatives as well.
Following my written parliamentary questions, which ministers I know appreciate dearly, we received an extraordinary answer. An uncle and his niece, an aunt and her nephew. What did the minister say about recognizing such overseas marriages illegal in the UK in our welfare budget? Unlikely. Unlikely.
Well, frankly, unlikely isn't good enough, especially when ministers can also not give me an answer as to how many polygamous marriages are currently being supported by our welfare system, or how many incestuous marriages are being supported by our welfare system. The standards at issue are hardly novel. Bigamy has been a criminal statutory criminal offense in the UK since 1604, more than four centuries ago. Marriages within prohibited degrees, including incestuous ones between uncle and niece or aunt and nephew, were made automatically void by the Marriages Act of 1835, nearly two centuries ago. And our modern legislation explicitly outlaws incestuous sexual activity between uncles and nieces or aunts and nephews.
When Parliament has rightly drawn these boundaries, surely it is right that our welfare system should uphold them. That is why I've brought this bill to the House today, backed by the leader of the opposition, backed by the shadow work and pensions secretary, to end recognition of polygamous marriages and put beyond doubt that overseas incestuous marriages cannot be recognized and should not be recognized in our welfare system for social security purposes. But Mr. Speaker, how do we get here when these marriages are already illegal in our country? How do we ensure that we were recognizing them if they were conducted overseas? This developed through our common law rules and decisions made by courts, probably well-meaning, but like in so many areas, completely inimical to a cohesive society and to a coherent polity and an anathema to the values of our country.
But the beautiful thing about our country, Mr. Speaker, our Parliament, is that we are sovereign here in this place. We can legislate. Parliament can revoke, can remove uncertainty and revoke common law where it is wrong, and Parliament must take responsibility. We decide what our welfare system recognizes, and that is the signal this House should send today. Clearly, explicitly, in the law of this country.
Time and again, I meet constituents in Basildon and Billericay who need support themselves, or on the other side who are being squeezed and squeezed more by higher taxes. People who work long hours, see their bills rise, trying to support their families. Why should my constituents not be more deserving of our attention instead when we're bundling cash first class to men with multiple wives, to overseas uncle-niece marriages? Let's take a sensible step to address this issue in a way that recognizes the values behind our benefit system, rooted in compassion and contribution, rooted in the values of our country, not there to pay for cultural practices which are illegal in our country. Surely it is insane that our welfare rules make special provision for men with many wives.
I believe that Parliament should put that beyond doubt, and I hope that this House supports this bill today and that the government doesn't, doesn't back away from it and backs us for a second reading on Friday the 13th of November. Thank you.
Lindsay Hoyle
The question is that the right honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. The question is that the right honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. The contrary no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it. Who will prepare to bring in the bill?
Speaker 123
Mrs. Kemi Badenoch, Helen Whately, Claire Coutinho, Laura Trott, Tom Tugendhat, Katie Lam, Dame Rebecca Harris, Joy Morrissey, Andrew Griffith, Nick Timothy, Neil O'Brien, and myself, sir.
Second reading what day?
Speaker 128
Friday the 13th of November. Thank you very much. Right, I will now hand over.
Speaker 136
The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day. Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, Committee. Order, under the orders of the House of the 19th of October, we shall now move to the Committee of the whole House.
Speaker 137
Order. Northern Ireland Troubles Bill. I remind members that in Committee, members should not address the Chair as Deputy Speaker. Please use our names, Ms. Ghani, or address me as Madam Chair, or Madam Chair are also acceptable. We begin with the question that clause 72 stand part of the bill, with which it will be convenient, if we're ready Mr. Francois, convenient to consider the amendments, clause stand part, schedule and new clauses as on the selection and grouping paper.
The question is that clause 72 stand part of the bill, and I call the Secretary of State. Secretary of State.
Chris Bryant
Ms. Ghani, one day more. Today we are debating parts 6 to 9 of the bill. Part 6 sets up on a pilot basis the Independent Commission on Information Retrieval, as originally proposed in the Stormont House Agreement. This will be an international body established jointly with the Irish government to give families an additional means to retrieve information about troubles-related deaths. Part 7 covers the restoration of a limited number of troubles-related inquests.
Part 8 covers further provision, including the lifting of the Legacy Act's prohibition of investigations by the police of other troubles-related offenses, including sexual offenses, ensuring that there is no bar to investigating crimes based on when they took place. It also covers the provisions regarding interim custody orders. First, Ms. Ghani, inquests. I understand the strength of feeling across the House in respect of inquests, as evidenced by the large number of amendments that have been tabled by honorable and right honorable members. The bill does not establish any new inquests.
But the Legacy Act abruptly halted a number of inquests on the 1st of May 2024. At that time, we committed in opposition to restoring some of them because we knew the hurt and anxiety this caused many families, both in Northern Ireland and in Great Britain. As we said then, it marked a very painful day for families of troubles victims. They felt the 1st of May marked a door being shut in their faces, particularly those that had been involved in inquests. The truth is, many families have received answers through inquests, and only through inquests, and I rather agree with my right honorable friend the Leeds South when he said yesterday that he'd been brought up to expect an inquest whenever there was a suspicious death.
That is why the bill strikes a balance about how to take this issue forward. It enables the resumption of the small number of inquests that were cut off midway on the 1st of May 2024.
We believe that families deserve to have that process continue and we have said so from the outset. For those inquests that have been directed but not started, the bill requires the Solicitor General to sift whether they are best handled by the Legacy Commission or a coroner based on clear criteria, including a statutory presumption in favor of the commission for cases that will involve sensitive material owing to the greater powers of the commission to take such material into account in producing reports. This is covered directly in clause 84. Madam Chair, there are understandable concerns about how we ensure veterans are treated with dignity and respect within the coronial process. That is exactly why we've introduced safeguards to protect veterans from cold calling, to ensure they do not have to travel to or within Northern Ireland to give evidence, and to ensure the operational context in which they served is fully recognized.
Let me repeat, these also apply to inquests and not just to the Legacy Commission. The bill also amends coronial law so that inquests cannot repeat processes that have already been undergone elsewhere unless essential. Let me turn to the matter of when this comes to an end, something that has been raised with me by many veterans and others. Earlier this year, the right honorable member for Goole and Pocklington tabled amendment 50 to remove clause 85. I agree with him.
So I have added my name and it is now a government amendment. It means that no new legacy inquests can be directed when the commission comes to an end. In practice, it means that we will simply vote that clause 85 should not stand part of the bill when we get to that moment. I believe this will provide a clear end to troubles-related inquests and certainty for all those involved. I'm very grateful to him for tabling the amendment and for his gratitude when I rang him to tell him that I was adding my name.
I also must make it absolutely clear that this will mean no additional inquests, full stop, punto final. Ms. Ghani, as several members pointed out yesterday, addressing the legacy of the troubles is a responsibility for both the UK and Irish governments. A unilateral approach simply cannot work, as was demonstrated by the Legacy Act. Sir Declan Morgan, the Chief Commissioner of the ICRIR, has repeatedly made clear to me, to my predecessor, and to the public that cooperation by the Garda and other Irish authorities will be essential to the commission's ability to find answers for families. That is why my predecessor negotiated the joint framework and why we are committed to implementing it.
Let's be clear about what this means, Ms. Ghani. Records held by the Irish authorities may well contain crucial information or answers as to how UK civilians and service personnel died. I have heard many people make the point to me that while the British Army kept records, paramilitaries certainly didn't. But we know that the Irish authorities may well have crucial information which is vital to this process. Of course.
Andrew Murrison
That is particularly pertinent when it comes to consideration of the Omagh bombings, of course. What indication has he had from the Irish government that they're going to be withdrawing their interstate case against the United Kingdom based on the ECHR, given the material that we're discussing today, because it seems to me that they're very reluctant to act at all?
Chris Bryant
Well, he makes a very good point. I certainly by the time we've finished this bill today, I cannot see any legitimate reason why the Irish state would continue with their interstate case at all. And I have already made that point robustly to my counterparts in Dublin. I very much hope that they will look again and think again and decide that not only did we win the case in Dylan, but also that the legislation that we're advancing today is fully human rights compliant and that therefore there is no argument for them maintaining their interstate case. Of course.
Gregory Campbell
Secretary of State, for giving way. Just on the issue, he says he very much hopes that the Dublin government would then move at the conclusion of today. Has he had a conversation with them and have they given the assurance that that is what they intend to do?
Chris Bryant
Yes to the first part. As I just said, I very robustly said this to Jim O'Callaghan and to Helen McEntee. I've said it on several occasions. And they have kept their counsel for the moment, but I'm very hopeful that by the time this gets to the House of Lords, it would seem to me inconceivable that there would be an argument for them maintaining their interstate case and therefore I hope that they would be withdrawing it. I'm being as clear as I can with the honorable gentleman.
And as he knows, he and I agree on many, many things, not least the fact that it's good to have power sharing in Northern Ireland and I shouldn't be running Northern Ireland.
Gavin Robinson
Very grateful to the Secretary of State. And I think it's important that he has reiterated the point that the commission will have the ability to take information from the Irish government. But does it not put into stark contrast, without revisiting the debates of yesterday, that information has been available for the last 28 years? It only was revealed last week. And there'll be many other instances of information that could beneficially have been considered and led to a change.
Is he at all concerned that the history we repeat time and time and time again with the Irish government not forthcoming, they're not fulsome and they withhold information should be a cause for concern for this House and how we deal with the legacy of the past?
Chris Bryant
Well, he makes a decent point. And then the question is simply how one addresses that and makes sure that one does get the future cooperation that has been promised and has been committed to from the Irish government. And I'm more hopeful, I guess, than he is. And he may say that that's because he's got more scars on his back than I have in relation to this. But I think if between the two of us, his skepticism and my hope, we might be able to get to a good set of outcomes.
In relation to Omagh bombing, we had a bit, it's inevitable, I think, Ms. Ghani, that we will end up having some of the conversations today that we sort of had yesterday a bit because members referred understandably to issues that we're actually voting on today. But I would just say to him that my understanding of the terms of reference in relation to the Omagh inquiry, I mean, we slightly disagree on this matter, but I think it would be perfectly possible for the Omagh inquiry to come to some fairly firm conclusions. But more importantly, as I said yesterday, I think it's really important that the fullest possible cooperation is shown. And where the chief counsel has already said that they're not happy with that cooperation, then I think it's incumbent on the Irish government to step up to the plate. Well, yes, though I'm this is all on one sentence, but and it's his second go, but I'll of course.
Andrew Murrison
I'm sure the Secretary of State appreciates how important, because it does touch upon the events of late 1998. And there'll be people out there watching the process of this bill wondering why they are excluded from it in effect. Now, the suspicion will be that that may very well be because the bill is drafted to spare the sensitivities of the Republic of Ireland since the material that's being referred to would then come in scope were we to extend this perfectly reasonable, reasonably to the end of 1998 rather than confine it to the events prior to April 1998.
And yesterday, if I may say, the Secretary of State gave no compelling reason why the amendments that were tabled to that effect would not be accepted by the government.
Chris Bryant
Well, Ms Ghani, you'll be aware that this is a debate that we not only had yesterday but we actually voted on last night as well. But I want to first of all make it absolutely clear that nobody drafted the bill with the date of the Good Friday Agreement in it so as to in some sense placate the Irish government. That was not the consideration at all. And I would simply note that it's the same date that was used by the previous legislation which was advanced by the government that he served in. So if he doesn't mind, I would gently suggest that that's a better date to land on than another arbitrary date.
Jim Allister
Well, oh alright. Good grace. Is the truth of the matter that the Secretary of State feels his hands are tied by the agreement that his government reached with the Dublin government that they would settle on April 98 rather than any later date? And isn't that what he's holding to for that very reason?
Chris Bryant
He must stop calling me Grace, Ms Ghani. No, honestly, I know that there's a variety of different kind of conspiracy theories flying around here now. No, we landed on the date of the Good Friday Agreement because it's a pretty solid date to land on, frankly. It's as simple as that and I don't think people need to search for any other. I understand we already had this vote and we voted on it last night.
The House has already decided in relation to the date. Let me just continue, Ms Ghani. Under the joint framework, the Irish government is committed to bringing forward its own legislation to ensure the fullest possible cooperation of the Irish authorities with the reformed commission, as of course is required under their constitution. In the summer, they published the general scheme of their bill and I want to ensure our respective pieces of legislation come into force in lockstep. I recognise the interest across the House in ensuring that the Irish government abides by their commitments.
That is why I have tabled amendment 251 which will require the government to make a written ministerial statement on the actions that the UK and Irish governments have taken in pursuance of the commitments in the joint framework prior to commencement of key aspects of the bill. This reflects the intent behind amendment 46 which was tabled by the honourable member for Brentwood and Ongar and therefore I hope that he will be supporting this as well. This should reassure members of the House that the key provisions of the bill will not be commenced until it is clear that the Irish government is honouring its commitments. This will not in any way affect the commencement of provisions required to ensure ECHR compatibility which are crucial to giving families confidence in the commission. More importantly though, I have spoken directly, as I said yesterday, to both Jim O'Callaghan and Helen McEntee and both have assured me and have stated publicly that we will work in lockstep so that their legislation and ours will come into force simultaneously.
Sorcha Eastwood
However, I do just gently want to take issue with some colleagues who have suggested that we are pandering to the Irish government or indeed appeasing them. Some have used particularly robust language in this. To be absolutely clear, Ms Ghani, the Irish government are co-guarantors of the Good Friday Agreement. They are close partners of ours and if we are to ensure that there is peace and reconciliation in Northern Ireland, we absolutely have to work with the Irish government to secure answers for families.
Sorcha Eastwood
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. Would he agree with me that actually despite what others in this chamber may think at the moment, it is vital that both the British and Irish governments work together and indeed if there are issues around disclosure or onward passage of facts that actually if we don't have that arrangement in place then that will never be flushed out.
Chris Bryant
I pay tribute to all the work that the honorable lady has done in this field. I think it's really important that people understand how significant the potential of close cooperation in this field is in terms of getting answers for people, in particular for people whose concerns may be about what happened from the south came up into the and came up into the north. One of the issues I've raised directly, I know a couple of members have raised this with me is around gelignite before Semtex and how it seems that we in Northern Ireland were perfectly able to keep all our quarries safe but there was one quarry in the Republic which managed to lose quite a lot of gelignite. These are the kind of issues that we really do need to progress because if we're going to get to a full understanding of what really happened, it won't just be what happened in Northern Ireland that is the clue, it will be what happened across the piece and that's why it's so important. I also, because I'm a socialist, I also believe fundamentally that we achieve far more by our common endeavor than we do by going it alone.
So I think cooperation is the best way to proceed. I think the honorable gentleman is on maneuvers.
Robin Swann
He said. Thank you very much Secretary of State. Just on that point, clause 72 5 actually says that the ICR must not do anything which would risk prejudicing or would prejudice the national security interests of the United Kingdom or Ireland. Can I ask the Secretary of State who's going to make that assessment if something that the ICR is looking at will actually risk the national security of the Republic of Ireland?
Chris Bryant
It's a very good question to which I don't have the answer. So with any luck I'll be inspired by the time he gets to his feet and he catches your eye Ms. Ghani and I'll come back to him. I have a horrible fear that this has now set my old sparring partner off.
David Michael Davis
To the point to the Secretary of State, when he looks at that, will he also look at those elements written into the Irish constitution, particularly with respect to the operation of the Garda in their duty to protect the reputation of the Irish state, because that will also cripple any attempt to expose information.
Chris Bryant
Well he makes a very good point, which is that sometimes the Irish constitution has actually made it far more difficult for them to be able to cooperate and that's why they've had to legislate in some of these areas in a way that we wouldn't have to in the United Kingdom. And that's why I think that the agreement that was secured by my right honorable friend is so important and why the legislation that they're advancing answers in terms directly in terms many of these precise issues. I know that they're not lost on ministers in Dublin and these are the kind of issues that we do need to address. Ms. Ghani, we have always been committed to repealing those parts of the Legacy Act which were incompatible with our human rights obligations and which we felt were morally wrong as they risked providing equal immunity to terrorists and denying UK citizens their historic right to seek civil redress. In the interest of providing swift and early clarity, we had proposed to do this via the remedial order.
However, the Joint Committee on Human Rights, whose chair was with us yesterday, amongst others, argued that putting these measures in the bill would allow greater scrutiny without undue delay. Consequently, government new clause 52 alongside amendments 244, 245, 268 and others move the operative provisions of the remedial order into the Troubles Bill.
This brings the whole package together, ensuring that there is a clear transition between the Legacy Act and the Troubles Bill. At second reading and in our engagement on the bill, there has been considerable concern about the so-called on-the-run letters, and a couple of honourable members referred to this yesterday. Indeed, the honourable members for North Antrim, Upper Bann and Lagan Valley have tabled amendments on this matter, which aim to put the status of these letters beyond doubt. I know I referred to this yesterday, but because this is the matter that is before us today, I do want to return to it. These letters did not provide any individual with immunity from prosecution, and they're not legally binding guarantees against future prosecution.
This is something that has been confirmed by the 2014 Hallett review, numerous ministers under successive administrations, including the former Prime Minister David Cameron. It has also been reiterated by the current Chief Constable of the PSNI, Jon Boutcher. However, I recognise the ongoing concern in relation to such letters, so I've tabled new clause 51 to make clear that they cannot be used to prevent or frustrate a prosecution.
Sorcha Eastwood
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way, and I just want to put on record again my thanks, but I think it's at the crux of this entire discussion that it must go out from this House that terrorism was always wrong, and that people in Northern Ireland and across the UK need to understand now that these letters never had, never will, and shall not be used to frustrate or deny any potential prosecutions that may come forward, because too many people in Northern Ireland have felt that actually there have been too many cosying up with terrorists in the past. And I hope that people will take comfort from this, and I hope that they will know that these letters never will and never had that effect.
Chris Bryant
I completely agree with every single word that she said. I think it absolutely goes, needs to go out from this House that terrorism was and remains wrong in every single regard. Those who resorted to violence did so for reasons of their own, but not reasons that we could possibly countenance, and we do not countenance in the legislation that we're advancing today. 90%, as I've said before, of those who were killed in the troubles, of the 3,500 and more who were killed in the troubles, were killed by paramilitaries. And I'd go further.
I think a lot of families that I've spoken to in Northern Ireland felt that the on-the-run letters were part of a sort of amnesty that was granted to some people and not to others, or was granted to everyone, and that that meant that they were never going to get answers to what happened to their loved ones. That was always wrong. I understand why people made difficult decisions when it came to the Good Friday Agreement, but as one honourable member said yesterday, you don't get peace without justice. The two, I think the line in the Bible is, justice and peace shall kiss one another, and I think that's what we have to achieve. I of course give way to the honourable lady.
Carla Lockhart
I thank the honourable member for giving way. With regards to OTR letters, he will know that I spoke yesterday on this very issue, and the fact that there's clarity today that you are progressing the amendment is welcome. However, they did have effect, because the Hyde Park bomber got away with his misdemeanours because of the on-the-run letters, so they did have effect. So will he confirm, as I asked yesterday, will they have effect on his ongoing new prosecution, John Downey, who by the way is hiding in the Republic of Ireland currently under cover? Will it have effect on the current prosecution that he is facing?
Chris Bryant
And not for ministers to comment when there are legal proceedings underway, as I think the honourable lady will be aware.
So I'm not going to comment on the specific instance. I've made my points, my views very clear about why there should not be any amnesty for people involved. Of course there was the legislation introduced which meant that nobody can face a prison sentence of more than two years. We understand the kind of arrangement that that was. And of course there were people who didn't support the Good Friday Agreement, political parties who didn't support the Good Friday Agreement, but and maybe these are some of the issues that they that they were always troublesome for them.
But for me, I think it's really important that at this stage now we recognise that we need to get as many answers for people as possible and that there cannot be that kind of immunity, amnesty, whatever you may call it. Ms Ghani, the government recognises that investigations by the Legacy Commission are just one aspect of addressing legacy. That is why we have agreed to establish on a pilot basis with the Irish government the Independent Commission on Information Retrieval. This was originally agreed by the coalition agreement, by the coalition government rather, and the Irish government in 2014 as part of the Stormont House Agreement, but it was never established, which is why I'm pleased to be able to establish it now. The ICIR is entirely separate from the Legacy Commission and will not conduct investigations, very clear distinction.
Its remit is to privately, its remit is privately to receive and retain information about troubles-related deaths and share that information privately again with those family members that have requested it. This will provide a different means by which families may be able to obtain information about troubles-related deaths. And I know that having spoken to quite a few families in Northern Ireland that this is something that they warmly, they warmly welcome and want to see amplified if we can make the pilot work. Members will see I have tabled some minor and technical amendments relating to the ICIR. For example, amendment 235 will ensure that the ICIR is able to produce and provide a report to a requester after its operational period has ended in circumstances where it has concluded its work on a specific case but has been prevented from providing a report due to an ongoing criminal investigation or prosecution.
Investigations and prosecutions in troubles-related cases are often complex and can take some time to conclude. We want to avoid a scenario where the ICIR has concluded its work on a case on behalf of families but is unable to share potentially important information with them in these circumstances which are beyond its control. Finally, Ms Ghani, having engaged extensively with different groups, I appreciate that there are concerns with the transparency of future prosecutorial decisions. I want to be absolutely clear, the government does not accept any suggestion that our prosecution services bring forward vexatious prosecutions. This government believes wholeheartedly in the approach of our prosecutorial services.
It is clear that decisions by the Prosecution Service in Northern Ireland and in England and Wales in relation to prosecutions are always taken independently in light of the individual facts and circumstances. But there is a public interest in how these cases are considered given both the context and the passage of time. Therefore we will bring forward a number of critical new amendments. If you'll let me just do these two proposals and then I'll come back to him. Yesterday we debated the amendments which will improve transparency around the approach to prosecutions within the Legacy Commission.
We're also introducing two significant amendments to the prosecution of troubles-related offences. Firstly, in new clause 49, we will require the Public Prosecution Service in Northern Ireland and the Crown Prosecution Service in England and Wales to work together on joint guidance on applying the relevant code for prosecutors in respect of troubles-related offences in each jurisdiction. Whilst the vast majority of troubles-related offences occurred in Northern Ireland, such offences were
Whilst the vast majority of troubles-related offences occurred in Northern Ireland, such offences were committed across the UK and there is a shared interest and obligation in addressing the legacy of the past. It will also be able to cover issues such as dealing with the complexity of historical evidence and the public interest considerations in such cases. I've got secondly to come, but I feel he's being quite patient.
Gavin Robinson
Finally from me, Ms Ghani, in respect of interventions, can I just say to the Secretary of State that he should be cautious when trying to push back against this notion that there are vexatious prosecutions or not. There are. There have been. We have seen prosecutions in Northern Ireland where the evidential test wasn't met the first time, it was revised and the evidential test still wasn't met, but it was suggested that prosecution should proceed. And at no stage during an abuse of process application or a no bill application or at any other time during the case did the evidence amount to anything close to meeting the prosecutorial test, likelihood of prosecution.
Leave aside public interest, but likelihood of prosecution. And the cases collapsed. And the judge concluded that at the very start the whole process was frail, at the very start the evidence didn't amount to satisfying the test. And so whenever we say, and we shouldn't have fear to say it, that there are vexatious prosecutions, they're very good examples as to why that is said.
Chris Bryant
Ms Ghani, I hate to suggest that the honourable gentleman has misled the House, but I don't think that that will be his final contribution today. So it's not really his finally. But look, he makes a point which I have heard from a lot of people and I understand the frustrations, the very significant frustrations that have been felt in particular by people in the veterans community. I understand that point. However, I think he meant to say the prosecutorial decision is obviously about the likelihood of a successful prosecution, in other words a conviction.
And of course sometimes the prosecuting authorities are wrong because a jury or a court decides that there isn't a case to answer and so on. So I hear what he says, but I think he was only urging me to exercise caution in using this phrase. So I will exercise caution in using this phrase. And I note that he just said thank you to me. Secondly, I'm going to do my secondly if he doesn't mind, because otherwise the logic of my speech is kind of going to fall apart.
So Ms Ghani, no Ms Ghani, you're not meant to look at me and look as if the logic of my speech has already fallen apart. Secondly. Secondly, to provide greater assurance, confidence and consistency in decisions to prosecute, we are introducing a requirement for the Attorney General, who is also the Advocate General for Northern Ireland, to provide consent for prosecutions of serious troubles-related offences. I want to be clear that when making these decisions the Attorney General must act quasi-judicially and independently of the government. There is precedent for this approach.
Some have questioned this, but this was recommended by the Joint Committee on Human Rights, and since most troubles-related deaths occurred in Northern Ireland, but some were in Great Britain, this will provide a single and therefore consistent last determinant. Let me be clear, this in no way obviates the role of the PPS in Northern Ireland or the CPS in England and Wales. In fact, we are strengthening their role, but I think this gives the right balance. I trust these amendments address the concerns raised by various members in respect of the decisions to prosecute, including those of the honorable member for Brentford and Ongar, who tabled an amendment to insert additional steps in the investigative and prosecutorial processes. I'm now coming to my finally finally, so if the honorable gentleman wants to intervene.
Jim Allister
I thank the Minister for stepping back to new clause 49. I press upon him again a point I raised with him yesterday. In new clause 32, which became part of the bill last night, the Secretary of State introduced protections when it comes to inquisitorial investigations for veterans by the Legacy Commission. New clause 49 deals with the guidance that the PPS will have to develop. Surely it is appropriate to have that guidance consistent with what's already in new clause 32.
Chris Bryant
Well, yes, I'm always in favor of consistency and I'm sure that that's how the two bodies will proceed in drawing up their guidance. Finally, Ms. Ghani, I look forward to listening to the further contributions today of honorable members as we continue to consider amendments and the clause stand part and schedule stand part. I really hope that we're able to get the bill right today. It's about achieving a balance and I hope that that's what our amendments seek to do.
Alex Burghart
Thank you, Madam Chair. And I'd like to start at the outset by paying tribute to those who spoke yesterday in the first day of committee. There were some really excellent contributions from both sides of the House and from both sides, all sides of the debate. A number of the issues discussed are not strictly within scope of the clauses and amendments today, but I will return to them in third reading because they're essential to the broader discussion that we're having. But I just want to say that there were some very powerful speeches that I think resonated across the divides.
In that spirit, I want to begin with what we welcome. Government new clause 51 effectively ends the debate on the highly controversial on-the-run letters, the so-called letters of comfort. These were letters issued by the government to Republican suspects, primarily those affiliated to the IRA. And they arose because whilst the 1998 agreement's early release scheme covered convicted paramilitary prisoners, it did not cover those who had never been charged, had been charged but had escaped, or had escaped after conviction. Sinn Féin argued that this was anomalous and that resolving the status of such individuals, many of whom were seen as important to Republican support for the peace process, was necessary.
Where Sinn Féin identified concerned individuals, the government then assessed whether they were not wanted. And if they were not, a letter of reassurance was issued. It's long been argued that such letters did not offer immunity to prosecution. However, as the honorable member for Upper Bann has pointed out, this was not so, because in 2014, John Downey, an IRA man accused of perpetrating the 1982 Hyde Park bombing, produced his letter at the Old Bailey and the trial collapsed. Whilst it was said that Mr. Downey's letter had been issued in error, there is no doubt that that letter prevented him from being put on trial for that crime.
Whatever confidence there was in the scheme then completely collapsed, and despite the considerable work of Lady Justice Hallett, doubts have lingered. The government is right to put this issue beyond all doubt and to make an amendment to its bill. Similarly, we welcome government amendment 251, which obliges the Secretary of State to lay before Parliament a statement about the actions taken by His Majesty's Government in the United Kingdom and the Government of Ireland in pursuance of the joint framework.
This is a replacement to amendment 46 which is in my name which did much the same thing. The importance of this is that the government is going to have to give an assessment of the progress that the Republic has made in laying its own legislation before ours can come into force. And I would ask the Secretary of State to confirm from the dispatch box that this statement will explicitly cover, as I think is set out in the framework, the investigation by the Garda of all unresolved troubles-related incidents within its jurisdiction. It's very important that any statement that he gives to the House when the legis- both pieces of legislation are complete cover that specific issue which was an important element of the framework.
Jim Shannon
Very quickly, just when the honorable gentleman is speaking about troubles-related crimes and those who escaped across the border, I did have the opportunity to mention about Jeremy McMonagle. The summons that was made for him was unfortunately not absolutely correct and the time it took to correct that at the Omagh court, the gentleman in particular escaped across the border. He has risen to be a very significant member of Sinn Féin. He's actually been the mayor of Donegal County Council. The fact of the matter is he murdered Lexie Cummings in 1982.
Is it not time for that gentleman to be taken to court and should he be one of those ones that the Republic of Ireland should be working with the government here to ensure that man is jailed?
Alex Burghart
My honorable friend raises an important case. I'm glad he's had an opportunity to put that on the record. So yesterday the Secretary of State said that the Irish government has committed that they will work in lockstep with us so that our legislation and their legislation will come into force on the same day. I hope the Secretary of State will be able to confirm that this being the case he will not commence this legislation until the Irish legislation is itself ready to be commenced. Yes.
Grateful to him for that reassurance. All this said, I think we should be clear-eyed about what the Irish legislation does and doesn't do and why indeed it is in no way equivalent to the legislation that this House is passing. The general scheme put forward by the Irish government is a means by which the Irish state may cooperate with the Legacy Commission. It does not require them to do so, nor does it set up any body equivalent to the Legacy Commission in the Republic. In short, while it is a step in the right direction, it guarantees nothing and it does not create an equivalent action in the south.
Yesterday we heard in very powerful terms about the failure of the Republic to engage fully with Omagh. Sadly, in the rejection of the DUP's amendment, we also heard something about this government's failure to engage on Omagh. Today, this morning, this afternoon, my honorable friend from East Belfast has raised the issue again. I draw the House's attention to the fact that in 2021 when Mr. Justice Horner recommended an inquiry, he urged an equivalent investigation take place in the Republic because one was needed. He could see, having assessed all of the evidence, that one was needed.
And yet here we are five years on and there is no equivalent investigation in the Republic at all, nor is there any sign that there will ever be one.
And I think it is a source of sadness for this House that the framework that was signed by this, by the previous administration, did not get within it an undertaking from the Republic that there would be such an inquiry. It was a very significant omission. Happily give way again.
Gavin Robinson
Very grateful, as can be to the point that the Shadow Secretary of State is making and how he is making it. The House should be aware that the Omagh families are this very day in court in Dublin trying to secure the very same rights to an inquiry from the Irish government's perspective that the UK government has offered them in the United Kingdom. But could I ask the Secretary of State just to reflect on how wrong the Secretary of State was yesterday evening to reference in part a subsequent sentence from the terms of reference when he knows that any information provided by the Irish government is only provided to answer this question: whether the UK authorities could have stopped the atrocity, not what they could have stopped themselves.
Alex Burghart
Well, this is precisely why Mr. Justice Horner in 2021 said, urged that there be a parallel inquiry in the Republic. And the fact that no such parallel inquiry has happened and that there is no sign that any such parallel inquiry will happen speaks, I'm afraid, volumes. This sadly brings us to a major point of contention, which is the issue of inquests. Yesterday, the honorable and gallant member for Birmingham Selly Oak spoke very powerfully about the problems that exist with inquests, and I know that today my right honorable friend from Goole and Pocklington will do likewise. The essence of the problem is this: the inquisitorial process in Northern Ireland has suffered a massive loss of confidence.
The reasons for that loss of confidence will be very well known to anyone who's followed the cases of Cooke and Clonoe, and it is precisely why colleagues are so concerned about the case of Loughgall, which is covered by amendment 51 in the name of my right honorable friend from Goole and Pocklington. In Great Britain, inquests exist to establish the facts, and at the first suspicion of unlawful killing, they're required to stop and pass evidence to the DPP. I nearly said the DUP. In Northern Ireland, however, inquests have far too often sought to assign blame, and this is why the honorable gentleman from North Antrim has tabled the amendment he has tabled. Yesterday, we heard moving accounts from the honorable member for Foyle and from the honorable lady from Lagan Valley of children being killed, very possibly murdered, of awful, heart-wrenching stories.
To be clear, the most contested inquests do not deal with such cases. They deal with the shooting of terrorists by security forces. They deal, in the case of Cooke... Happily give way.
Alex Easton
Thank the Shadow Minister. In terms of inquests, would he be able to shed light on the amount of inquests that are going to be granted, what those inquests are, because none of us know how many there are and what they're going to be about, and where is the money going to come for each inquest, because you're talking a couple of hundred million for each one, so can he maybe shed light what the government have been telling him on this issue?
Alex Burghart
I'm sure the Secretary of State will have heard what he said and will include some reference to it in his final remarks. The, yeah, the cases that we're talking about here deal with the case of Cooke, with Michael Ryan, an IRA man who shot two UDR officers, both in the presence of children. Happily give way.
Speaker 151
First kind words, but also for giving way. He says that the inquests only don't deal with, and I just want to make sure I'm picking him up right, the inquests haven't dealt with innocent civilians being killed. Well, in fact, they have. The Ballymurphy inquest, the Springhill inquest, you know, which brought truth to families almost 50 years or 50 years after their loved ones were murdered in cold blood by British forces. So I mean, if we're going to talk about this, let's talk about it in the round, please.
Alex Burghart
Very happy to clarify my remarks for the honorable gentleman. I'm certainly not saying that at all. What I'm saying, explaining, is why the inquisitorial process has suffered such a loss of confidence. It's because of the way that certain inquests have been conducted and the way they've behaved. And so I, yeah, I'm not talking at cross purposes with the honorable gentleman.
Um, yeah, in the case of Clonoe, we are dealing with the fact that, yeah, there was a vanload of men who shot up a police station with a fully automatic machine gun and were confronted by the security forces. Or indeed, in the case of Loughgall, when an IRA unit attacked an RUC base and was shot. Those security forces, the security forces that kept our country safe in those moments, were asked to do extremely difficult things, no longer trust the inquisitorial process because they can see where it leads. It leads to lawfare, to years of court processes where even when the judges say that this is a farce, even when they say it is ludicrous, they are powerless to prevent the legal aid cavalcade from going on and on and on. Amendment 113 in my name and amendment 84 in that of my right honorable friend for Goole and Pocklington essentially do the same thing that the honorable and gallant member from Birmingham Selly Oak was trying to do yesterday.
That is to say, enough of the multi-track approach. Let us all, let us put all of the inquests into the Legacy Commission. Let us dispense with the twin-track approach that the honorable and gallant member argued against yesterday. But of course, the twin-track approach is really a three-track approach because we still have inquiries being granted. As we argued at the time, the government should very clearly, for example, have asked the ICRIR to deal with the Finucane inquiry rather than set up a new public inquiry.
And then, because of civil cases, we will have a four-track approach. But for all the reasons mentioned here, I very much hope the government will at the very least accept that where we are dealing with military action against known terrorists, the inquests ought to be dealt with by the Legacy Commission. As my right, I will happily give way.
Jim Shannon
And I'm very mindful, as we often are, from Northern Ireland and our experiences that we have with many, many people. I think of the murder of the four UDR men at Ballydugan. The person who did that was Colm Marks. Colm Marks was then carrying out another bomb attack upon the RUC in Downpatrick. In the process of setting up a mortar bomb to attack the RUC and was shot carrying out that.
He deserved to have the capital punishment that he had in Downpatrick. That's a fact. There should never be any occasions whenever the families should try to engineer an inquiry for someone who quite clearly was a head of the IRA in that area. When he died, the IRA campaign stopped. That tells you all about it.
He's burning in hell today. Couldn't happen to a nicer person.
Alex Burghart
Well, as ever, my honorable friend makes, gives us a powerful story of some of the dreadful things that happened. Um, yeah, as my right honorable friend for Goole and Pocklington said last week, if this bill was really about human rights and justice, the first coroner's inquest would not be about whether the killings at Loughgall were unlawful. It would instead be about one of the 1,800 murders carried out by the IRA, every single one of which was unlawful. There is, I'm afraid, an inequity of priorities here.
It is not on the side of right. And whilst I am on my feet on this point, Madam Chair, I'd like to pay tribute to the veterans who are with us today who help keep our country safe.
Hear, hear.
Speaker 149
I now move to the issue. I happily give way to the right honourable gentleman.
Hilary James Benn
He might just accept in respect of the Loughall inquest, the reason why it began and then was terminated by the last government's legislation is because the Attorney General in the last Conservative government, also the Advocate General for Northern Ireland, decided having considered all of the papers that it should be held. Is he telling the House that he disagrees with the decision of the actually the right honourable member for Kenilworth and Southam?
Alex Burghart
So I whilst I have the opportunity, I just like to pay tribute to the right honourable gentleman's time as Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. Whilst there were many things on which we disagreed, he always conducted himself with great dignity and great respect and I'm very grateful to him for the briefings that he gave me whilst we were opposite numbers. I I have to say that, you know, two things are true. Yeah, our legislation would have stopped the Loughall inquest and so that was something that obviously my party supported. But secondly, I think since that time we have seen some very egregious cases in which the inquisitorial process has gone wrong.
We have seen in the course of those inquisitorial processes why veterans have lost confidence in the process and and we know that there is a viable alternative. There's a viable alternative that he was good enough to recognise when he became Secretary of State, you know, that he did decide not to completely tear up ICRIR, you know, not to close it down. And you know, he decided to develop it, in some ways we might agree with and some ways we wouldn't. But there is an alternative way of dealing with this which I believe would command the confidence of many veterans such as the one on his benches who spoke out yesterday. I now turn to the issue of new and compelling which was raised yesterday and which is back again today because of new clause 22 in the name of the honourable gentleman from North Down.
The problem here is simply that the government claims that its qualification essential will restrict repeat investigations. And but as has been pointed out by legal authorities outside the House, essential as described by the government is no bar at all. As one leading lawyer has put it, any lawyer worth their salt can find new evidence. A real test would be new and compelling. Given the fact that previously decisions have been taken to prosecute cases where there is no evidence, there should be a check and balance and a certification by a judge to support the fact that there is new and compelling evidence.
What it does is prevent a biased decision being taken in Northern Ireland. The the bill as drawn provides no protection for veterans accused of unlawful shootings from rinse and repeat investigations. They are witnesses, they are not witnesses, they are suspects. The bill is drafted expressly to permit the past abuse to continue. The Secretary of State says that it is not the case that this is not the case, but he objects to amending the bill in a way which enshrines his public statements that there should be no repeat rinse and repeat investigations.
Secretary of State has also said that witnesses cannot be approached unless there is new and compelling evidence, but this is not quite what the bill says. Rather whether or not there is new evidence is a factor to be weighed in the decision to approach witnesses. If it is considered essential and there is no new and compelling evidence, the witnesses can still be approached. There is absolutely no bar in approaching witnesses. Essential is not defined in the bill and Secretary of State has given his dispatch box definition of what it is.
But that means that what is essential will essentially be open to interpretation by the Legacy Commission and the coroners. It is a subjective term. So this feeds uncertainty. What is essential to you, Madam Chair, may not be essential to me. I happily give way.
Speaker 152
I think the key word here is essential of course and the definition of it. Is the honourable gentleman aware of any legal precedent or case law that does define this word?
Alex Burghart
The cases whose advice I have sought have not been able to produce any such definition. So this all feeds uncertainty. So decisions will be challenged in the courts and there will be more lawfare. Republicans will argue interviewing veterans is essential. The reason for new and compelling is that it is a term used, the reason why we are insisting on the use of new and compelling is that it is a term used in the Overseas Operations Act and the Criminal Justice Act 2003.
It is the very test used to determine if someone acquitted of a serious offence can be retried. So it provides, we're asking for certification in this case. The right honourable gentleman says that there's...
Speaker 155
If people wish to participate in the debate, they should do it by formal intervention so we can note it on Hansard, not chatter from a sedentary position. Alex Burghart.
Speaker 137
I'd hope the honourable member would agree there's been order throughout the debate, not just now. Alex Burghart.
Alex Burghart
Well, Madam Chair, you're quite right, as ever. It's finally good to be put right on that. I will.
Chris Bryant
It's just on this point about certification because obviously it's a key part of the amendment that he's talking about. And one of the problems with certification is of course that a certification can be presumably judicially reviewed, which is likely to lead to yet further lawfare.
Alex Burghart
I think judicial, as he knows, judicial review is a process in the system. I am asking him to refine the process that he has put forward which is inadequate. Essential is inadequate. Essential is going to be judicially reviewed. And of course new and compelling and certification will be judicially reviewed.
But it will be an opportunity to create much greater confidence in all communities that we are not going to have the sort of rinse and repeat investigations that have taken place. I will allow him to come back in.
Chris Bryant
I'm very grateful, but I think it's important that we debate these points in detail because I don't understand the reference to the Overseas Operations Act and indeed that's where we took our structure for our amendment from as well. I just don't understand why he wants certification here whereas it isn't present in that.
Alex Burghart
Because there has been a complete loss of confidence in this process. And so if the right honourable gentleman was standing up to say, well we'll accept new and compelling but we don't want certification, well let's have that debate. But that's not what he's saying. He's saying he wants essential, which is understood by legal authorities to be a very low bar. But that is not the case, that we have received legal advice that this is no bar at all.
And for reasons I've already set out, it will be very easily stepped over. Whereas new and compelling, as we know from the Overseas Operations Act, is a more significant legal test. It provides certainty in three ways. It is a filter test: no engagement with veterans unless there is new and compelling evidence. It is a term already applied by the courts, so we have one system, we have equality of treatment.
And it is not subjective like essential. First, the evidence must be new, that must be a matter of fact. Second, it must be compelling, meaning it will impact the outcome. The test of new evidence only would be meaningless as there is no threshold. Finally, Madam Chair, I turn to new clause 7 in my name.
This would require annual reporting on recruitment and retention within the armed forces. We've all seen repeated reports that our special forces are under threat because of the demoralizing effects of lawfare, both present and historic. In October, we were warned by the SAS Regimental Association, who said that it was eroding the will to fight. In November, we were warned by eight retired generals and one chief marshal that recruitment, retention, and morale were all suffering. In December, seven former senior SAS officers spoke of the dangerous operational consequences of lawfare.
And this morning, Brigadier Ed Butler, former commanding officer of 22 SAS, said in stark terms that continued lawfare was affecting recruitment and retention. In one moment. When such leaders with such experience issue such warnings, I think we all have a duty to listen. We all have a duty to take them seriously. I give way to the honorable gentleman.
Speaker 151
The honorable member for giving way. Can I just understand the point he's making here? Is it the case that he is putting forward an argument that is, if special forces aren't allowed to do whatever they want in whatever theater they're in outside of legal boundaries, then people won't join? Is that the argument that he's making?
Alex Burghart
I just reassure the honorable gentleman that that is absolutely not the point I'm making or indeed a point I've ever made. The simple point I'm making is where you have vexatious repeat and rinse investigations, it is highly demoralizing to people who once served and people who still serve. And you know, that's very, very different to what he's just alleged. I give way to my right honorable friend.
David Michael Davis
Every single time we have seen a member of the special forces in the UK speak in public about this matter, they have made it plain that they do not believe that they are above the law. On the contrary, they believe that they are there to uphold the law and that what they object to is making the process the punishment, which is where we are now.
Alex Burghart
My right honorable friend puts it better than I ever could. The, so this house deserves to be reassured that the tip of the spear is not being blunted. Whilst details of special forces are necessarily restricted, it would be a huge dereliction of function if we did not ask for these issues to be monitored. And for that process to have confidence, it should, as our amendment sets out, be conducted by an independent figure. I know that governments hate to accept such amendments, but I would really value the Secretary of State's considered response about how this house can receive reassurance that one of our most prized national assets, the special forces, is not being allowed to wither.
I know that he will say that recruitment is up generally, but this is a specific point I am making about special forces and the consequences of rinse and repeat. Madam Chair, I have to say, I return to where I started, which is that there are some things with which we can agree today. There are some things on which we can agree. However, the fundamentals are still problematic. I very much hope the government will take the opportunity now and in the Lords to put them right.
Adam Jogee.
Adam Jogee
Thank you very much, Ms. Ghani, and I'm grateful for the first opportunity I've had to speak on this most important of bills, not just as the member for Newcastle-under-Lyme, but also as chair of the Ireland and Irish-Britain All-Party Group and a very proud member of the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee.
And I don't want to cause the Shadow Secretary of State any discomfort in saying, probably for the first time, that I agreed with him. And he was right, there were many excellent speeches made in the House yesterday, and I also further agree with the tribute he made to my right honourable friend from Leeds South for his diligence and commitment to these issues. Ms Ghani, our committee, ably chaired by my honourable friend the member for Gower, has considered the painful and brutal legacy of the troubles in great and at times difficult detail. And I'll be speaking to amendment 277 and to new clause 54 tabled in the name of my honourable friend. But I would like to acknowledge all those who lost their lives, those brave officers in the Royal Ulster Constabulary and in the forces who served and were tasked with securing the peace, including extended members of my own family.
And I speak, Ms Ghani, from a place of personal connection, my late grandmother's family are of good County Down stock. And as the House knows, if they've listened to any of the speeches I've given since election in 2024, my wife was born in Northern Ireland before the Good Friday Agreement was signed, before peace on the island of Ireland, a very different place to the Northern Ireland of today. And our family's experiences and those of many friends and people across the community inform my understanding of the hurt, trauma, and yes, hope that lies at the heart of this debate. Now this bill is very important, and so are the amendments before us, amendments that are designed to make sure we get it right. And before I speak to the substance of the amendments, Ms Ghani, I hope, since this is the first time I've spoken on this bill, you won't mind me making a couple of general points that have been shaped by my view of the amendments.
Now the decades of conflict in Northern Ireland saw profound suffering, more than three and a half thousand people lost their lives and tens of thousands were injured or traumatized. Entire communities were scarred by violence, by suspicion, and by fear because of who they were, how they prayed, and their actual and perceived identity. It is in recognition of that hurt that we must approach this bill and all the amendments before us with care, with compassion, and with responsibility. The purpose of this bill is to provide a path forward, a sensible way forward that is not shaped by inflammatory language, nor a path forward that sows any further discord or disunity. We've had more than enough of that over the years.
Chair, members of this House and political leaders across Northern Ireland must match the maturity and decency of the people that the amendments we are discussing today seek to ensure is respected. It is true that this bill wasn't perfect when I wrote my first speech for its second reading back in November 2025, and I'm grateful for the conversations that I've had, the committee's had, with the previous Secretary of State, with the current Secretary of State and his ministers, because that allows us to, that has allowed us to put together amendments that strengthen this bill and ensure that it delivers the justice and the answers that families, and I mean all the families, deserve. I therefore welcome the government amendments on the paper today, particularly those that have been developed through engagement with veterans groups and with organizations like Wave, Widows Against Violence Empower, based in Belfast, led by the excellent Sandra Peake who was here just last week. This bill must be used to set a path that honours the memory of those who suffered, recognizes the service of those who served in our military under instructions to keep the peace, that supports victims and survivors in seeking answers and helps Northern Ireland move forward. We must ensure that this legislation does not simply close down what happened before us, but opens the possibility of a shared future.
We must seek to shape a legacy framework that respects the voices of victims and of survivors, and that includes those who served and those who lived the troubles. My colleagues on the committee and those of us with family and friends in this wonderful part of our country have heard firsthand the fear in the streets, the loss of loved ones, the sense of lives put on hold and the disparity of war. Those conversations have helped influence the amendments tabled by my honourable friend and our committee colleagues and that we debate today. I've also heard of the resilience and compassion of the decent people who call Northern Ireland home.
This is important, Ms Ghani, and there must never ever be any rewriting of history. There is no equivalence between those who served to protect life in our armed forces and security services and the terrorist organizations which set out to kill people. If I can turn to amendment 277 and new clause 54, Ms Ghani. New clause 54 reflects the recommendations of the report from the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee and seeks to ensure transparency and accountability in the implementation of the reconciliation and memorialization provisions contained and carried forward from the 2023 Act. And I hope that the minister will engage with that specific point when he or indeed she, whoever's winding up at the end of the debate.
And if I can gently touch on amendment 277, this is in many ways, Ms Ghani, about people. And it's about making sure that legal definitions do not get in the way of as many people impacted by what happened in Northern Ireland to get the support, the truth and the answers that they deserve. I'm also pleased that this bill will reform the Independent Legacy Investigations Commission to make it legally robust and build real and meaningful confidence. New clause 49 requires a joined-up approach between the directors of public prosecutions in Northern Ireland and in England and Wales, ensuring a consistent, rigorous approach and it has my support. New clause 50 applies well-established prosecution principles of independence and public interest.
It has my support too. And I'm very glad that my right honorable friend the Secretary of State put his name to it and adopted it. And I thank the member for Goole and Pocklington for his work on this. I mean, clearly judging by the cast and the plaster, he was so excited by the Secretary of State accepting the amendment yesterday that he celebrated a little too hard. But I hope he is well when I see him later.
We'll save that one for later, I think. I'll buy him a cup of tea. I am grateful to the Secretary of State for ensuring that there are new and effective protections for our veterans. Protections that weren't included in the Legacy Act of the previous government. And I join the Royal British Legion in welcoming amendment 240, which now gives our veterans the peace of mind that they will not be targeted with cold calls.
This is of course hugely important for all the aging veterans who are many of some of whom are in the gallery today who served our country. The bill will also ensure that nobody who carried out terrorist atrocities in towns and cities across the United Kingdom will be given immunity from prosecution, for example through new clause 51, which stops on-the-run letters, which have never been legally binding, Ms Ghani, from preventing prosecutions. And I thank the Secretary of State for the specific words he put to that earlier on. The protection from repeated investigations, protection from cold calling, protection in old age, a right to stay at home, a right to anonymity and a right for veterans' voices to be heard are all important changes that will go a long way to protecting those who served. This is also important, Ms Ghani.
I'm grateful to all honorable members from across the house who helped us get to this place today. A commitment to reconciliation, a belief in political partnership and an understanding that peace is not a single event but an ongoing process is reflected in the amendments that we discuss this afternoon. It is also important to acknowledge an uncomfortable truth, Ms Ghani. No legacy bill will ever satisfy everyone because the pain of the troubles sits differently with every individual, every family and every community. And we've seen that in the debate on and discussion exchanges on the amendments before us.
This bill is no exception and whatever amendments are tabled and approved or not, because for some it may not go far enough in the pursuit of truth and accountability. For others it may reopen wounds they wish they could finally close.
And that tension reflects not the shortcomings of any single piece of legislation, but the enormity of the suffering endured during the conflict. But we must also recognize that this bill cannot and was never intended to repair every harm or resolve every grievance. Legislation cannot rewrite the past, nor can it undo the loss that thousands of families still feel so deeply. What it can do, however, is help create a structured, principled framework to address legacy issues in a way that is fair, transparent and capable of earning the trust of the people. Most importantly, this bill must be understood not only as a measure aimed at the past, but as a step toward the future.
A step that has been made more likely with this bill and many of the amendments that have been tabled by honorable members across the house, colleagues of mine on the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee and by His Majesty's Government. Northern Ireland deserves a pathway that allows future generations to live without inheriting the full weight of division and trauma that shaped the decades that went before us. And for this bill to succeed, it must do much more than catalog history. It must help us build the conditions in which communities can live together, heal together and move forward together. We must also recognize that some of the proposals remain deeply challenging and controversial.
And we have to make sure we find a way through that. Because in addressing legacy, we are dealing with raw and painful memories, contested narratives and a future that, if we are to reach, still requires courage and patience. Ms Ghani, we owe it to the people of Northern Ireland, both victims and survivors, to those who served and to the generations to come, to make sure that we get this right. And to ensure that this bill is sent to the other place in a strong and as robust a form as possible.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Ms Ghani. Can I begin by apologizing to the house? Last week's carryover motion was a bad-tempered partisan affair with lots of angry chuntering. And I assumed this week's committee of the whole house would be similar and said something to that effect at the beginning of my speech. I couldn't have been more wrong.
There were so many profound and compelling speeches. I was here for eight hours almost yesterday listening to them. I was in awe of the members from all sides of the house speaking. It was a wonderful moment that spoke so highly of this house, no matter how we agree and disagree. I still think we should have had a committee upstairs, however.
And I want to give an example from yesterday to try and prove my point. A less formal committee, provided we had invited our Northern Ireland colleagues upstairs with us to the committee upstairs, it would have been more effective. We all, I think, want to avoid repeat investigations in the absence of compelling new evidence. And my party supported the Tories' excellent in many respects new clause 21 to that effect. But it included a certification process with a Supreme Court judge.
The Secretary of State made the point he thought was impractical. I agree. I've known a few Supreme Court judges. They don't have the time. They don't have the inclination.
And frankly, many of them don't have the evidentiary expertise to provide that function efficiently. We had a different amendment that suggested a different certification process suggested by the SAS Regimental Association, whereby the Director of Investigations would issue a certificate and give reasons. But the government also had a fair point to make in their amendment 192, that the process should only begin after other sources of evidence had been fully explored.
We all had something to bring to the table. And had we been upstairs discussing this in a sensible committee, we would have improved the bill. Please for the future can we think about having committees upstairs bringing in our Northern Ireland colleagues on bills such as this. As I've said, yesterday we heard from members across this house in powerful and often moving speeches, providing a wide array of views for the various communities impacted by this bill. I was particularly taken, hugely taken by the points raised by the gallant member for Birmingham Selly Oak and the gallant member for South West Wiltshire.
Their remarks on the passage of time, the fading of memory and the vanishing chance of achieving justice were insightful. I think the member for Birmingham Selly Oak went as far as to suggest, as I've heard from some in the veteran community also say, justice might not be possible, we should focus on truth and reconciliation. But as the Secretary of State said a little later, one cannot have reconciliation without justice. Now, you'll all accuse me of just being a typical Lib Dem, but I think both of the honourable members are correct. The key to resolving the apparent disagreement is in how we define justice.
Often in these debates the notion of justice is mediated through a lawyer's narrow conception of the word, in terms of criminal prosecution and civil liability, and essentially retributive concept. But justice is about more than just retribution. As I know from personal experience, it also includes restorative justice where truth and sometimes reconciliation are key. If one takes this broader, more holistic view of justice, it is not at variance with truth and reconciliation, but the critical component. Mediating justice through the narrow lawyer's lens risks preserving divisions and animosities, for healing will rarely be achieved through lengthy inquiries providing limited chances of prosecution.
We want to achieve reconciliation, we need to broaden our conception of justice, to move beyond the adversarial and recriminatory and focus on establishing truth and finding answers. Now yesterday I broadly focused on veterans. That's because my party and the constituencies we represent are home to many veterans, many of them having served with courage in Northern Ireland. Their protection and welfare are hugely important to my party. But in saying that, I do not wish to lose sight of who this bill must deliver for, the thousands of victims and survivors and families who lived through the troubles and still carry its weight today.
Now it has been said by others, veterans and civilian victims are not two separate groups. Those who served bravely as part of Operation Banner and their families were also victims of the troubles. The one thing nearly every victim wants is answers. In particular the families still wondering about their murdered loved ones. The inevitable questions that come with a violent death still haunt them today: how, where, who, and most importantly why.
I want to reflect on a meeting I had at the excellent Wave Centre when I visited Northern Ireland earlier this year. I met relatives whose relatives of those who had been murdered by Stakeknife. And they had gone through the Operation Kenova process. They didn't get what they initially wanted, which was prosecutions. But they were so thankful to the process, so thankful to Jon Boutcher who headed it for much of the time, for the fact they got answers, they got someone listening to their concerns and they got an opportunity to speak to those involved and got answers to what had happened.
Information answers give families restored faith. It gave them it built trust. And even though they did not get what they wanted from Jon Boutcher at the outset, they all spoke highly of the process. It helped in the healing. Information retrieval is a powerful thing.
We saw that in the recent report into Rory O'Kelly's murder by an IRA gunman, which provided catharsis to his two children. And Frances O'Kelly described the process as something sacred and transformative. The report did not reveal the identity of the killer. It could not. It did not lead to the prosecution of a terrorist for a heinous crime, but provided closure all the same.
I share, as I hope we all do, Anne's hope that as many families as possible are able to engage in this process, which has such a key role to play in reconciliation. Now, whilst I appreciate that both ICRIR and its successor the Legacy Commission have information recovery functions, they could be doing far more to promote reconciliation in Northern Ireland. In a letter to me, the Secretary of State places great emphasis on the measures in the Legacy Act, referring to oral histories. Now, I do not doubt these will have a role to play in reconciliation, but oral histories alone are not enough. The Troubles Bill represents a unique opportunity to review our approaches to reconciliation, to try and make a more active approach and broaden our understanding of justice.
Our new clause 12, which will be voted on today, imposes a statutory duty on the Secretary of State to publish a reconciliation strategy within six months of the Act. By seizing the initiative, consulting with a broad range of stakeholders and ensuring reconciliation is a top priority for the Northern Ireland Office, new ideas and approaches will emerge and can be tested, where we can actually embrace more formal structures of restorative justice. As Drumcree shows, communities across Northern Ireland are still not fully reconciled. I believe a new approach should be tried. One which incorporates principles of restorative justice.
It's not an easy process, nor is it appropriate for everyone, but the power and healing facilitated by meeting those that did you wrong, explaining the impact of their actions, can be hugely beneficial. I also tabled new clauses 18 and 19, which would allow for individuals to request access to restorative justice processes as part of their interaction with the Legacy Commission. The Secretary of State responded to my suggestions, telling me he did not wish to overburden the Legacy Commission. The Secretary of State is concerned restorative justice, and I quote, "might compromise the Commission's effective use of its resources and prioritisation of its operations." However, if this government genuinely wishes to help as many families and survivors find closure as it can, they must find the resources to ensure that restorative justice processes play a much more central role in the work of the Legacy Commission.
I appreciate that money is tight at the moment. But when the cost of inaction is so high, 5.5 million to police Drumcree, for example, it is surely better to invest in our future generations and build a Northern Ireland where children never again know the sectarian divisions their forebears lived through. Thank you, Ms Ghani.
Lewis Atkinson
Thank you, Ms Ghani. The peace that Northern Ireland has today rests on the reconciliation process we've seen in recent decades, civil rights and the rule of law, the recognition that differences must be settled through dialogue and democratic means, with respect for the rights and perspectives of every community and tradition. But the peace in Northern Ireland today was also built on the service and sacrifice of the men and women of Operation Banner, thousands of whom came from Sunderland.
They didn't go from Sunderland to the to Northern Ireland to be on either side. They came because they were actively recruited by the British state at a time when there was high unemployment in places like Sunderland. And they stood on Northern Ireland's streets overwhelmingly as a protective force on sentry and patrol duty, guarding civilians on constant alert against those who were trying to kill. Over 38 years of Operation Banner, 1,441 of our British service personnel died, 722 killed by paramilitaries. I listened carefully to the contributions yesterday as others have said, many fantastic contributions, moving contributions.
I want to pay particular tribute to my honourable and gallant friend from Selly Oak and my friend from Southend East and Rochford who's not in his place today. But actually the contribution that moved me most, sorry, he's in his place, the Southend East and Rochford is not. The contribution that was made yesterday that most closely reflects the experience of my veterans in Sunderland was from the honourable member from South Shropshire who's not in his place today, who described serving as a young rifleman on the streets of Northern Ireland and not knowing when a civilian raised their hand if they were doing it as a purely innocuous gesture or if it was to throw an incendiary device or whatever. And that was the experience of my constituents who I met for a two-hour round table to discuss this at our local Gunners Club in the recess just gone. The reality is that without the army's deployment in 1969, Northern Ireland faced the risk of far wider bloodshed than it unfortunately experienced.
Those who served held the line for long enough, for decades, long enough for politics to finally take its place and we must never stop saying thank you to them. As others have said, it is false to set veterans against victims and to suggest that veterans were not in many cases victims themselves. Serving both and all allows us all to move forward to a peaceful future. And that will take changes in the law through this bill and the full cooperation and transparency from the British and Irish governments. I'm clear that the previous government's Legacy Act failed on multiple counts.
It commanded the support of no community and no party in Northern Ireland. It undermined the ongoing process of reconciliation that recent weeks show is still absolutely essential. And it also failed victims of every background, including the families of British soldiers murdered by the IRA at Guildford and on the M62, whose killers would have been offered immunity. We should never forget that those bereaved military families were among the most vehement critics of the previous government's legacy approach and they were indeed part of the legal action against it. Many who did come home carry the cost still.
Recently they shared their views about their shared their remembrance of what they saw in Northern Ireland, how that affected their lives still, and how when they got home, they had far too little support on discharge or from the British state afterwards. While the reality is that of 300,000 Operation Banner veterans, six prosecutions have been made, too often it has felt since that the Good Friday Agreement, sorry, too often since the Good Friday Agreement, it has felt like the legal system was built to scrutinize the split-second actions of frontline soldiers with process as punishment, while comfort letters were given to suspected terrorists, the very people they were sent to protect civilians from. That system has also felt focused on individual frontline soldiers and not on the failings of the chain of command whose decisions in some cases profoundly affected civilians. Those who served with honor deserve to live out their lives in peace with our country's thanks, not fearing for a knock at the door. They were offered false and undelivered promises by the previous government, but they they did not feel that the bill as introduced was appropriate.
I've engaged on ministers in that spirit for the last year on this with the right honorable gentleman for Leeds South, and I've been clear for a significant time in our private meetings that unamended I could not support this legislation. Those the amendments that I sought are many, and some were discussed yesterday, the agreement of clause new clause 32, which is clear that action in the course of duty must never be treated as equivalent to terrorism, a new clause 43 setting a tight time limit of 14 days for new judicial review action, giving some clarity about ongoing lawfare long after legal proceedings seem to have closed. And today's amendments, I'm pleased to say, further in my view the assurances that veterans have asked for and that I've pushed for over the last year. Under new clause 50, as the Secretary of State said, no one can be prosecuted for the most serious troubles offenses without the consent of the UK Attorney General. This applies to everyone.
It's not an amnesty. As I said, the peace that we have in Northern Ireland was built on the rule of law, not sectional favoritism for one group, but it is a senior independent check outside of Northern Ireland's politics that I think goes some way to winning the trust of some veterans that have previously lost faith in the system. And I think the reality is that following the acquittal of Soldier F, no one expects further prosecutions. Second, in terms of the amendments that we're considering today, no special exit for terrorists. As other members have rightly pointed out, the collapse of the Hyde Park bombing trial and attack that killed four soldiers was as a result of an apparently mistakenly issued letter of comfort.
The member for Lagan Valley rightly said that that such terrorist action was always wrong, and there should never have been any doubt about our condemnation of that as a House. Veterans saw that old soldiers were questioned decades on while suspected bombers held letters saying they were not wanted. That ends today. Third, and for most veterans the most important, an end to being investigated and questioned again and again. Yesterday's amendments mean that investigators must go through the state's own records first and give particular weight to whether compelling new evidence exists before requiring any veteran to give evidence.
And today, new clause 84 means a resumed inquest must not repeat what has been already done unless it is essential, and I welcome the Secretary of State setting out the clear process by which inquests will end altogether.
A veteran who has given his account should not be made to relive the same night to the same questions every few years. And the protections as my honourable friend from Newcastle-under-Lyme referenced in terms of cold calling, protections against returning to Northern Ireland, that I welcome have been welcomed by the Royal British Legion. The passing this bill tonight, and I will support it as the amendments have been sufficient in my view to win the confidence of veterans. But it cannot be the end of Parliament's interest. I had an exchange with the right honourable gentleman from Leeds South asking about how the changes tonight would be kept under review.
And I welcome the fact that I think under amendment 251 there will be independent inspection of the legacy commission and a report to the House on what the UK and Irish governments are doing to ensure that the promises made in this bill are kept. Transparency must run both ways across the border and this House must play its part to hold both governments to it. The reality is that if this bill passes, veterans will have had significantly more protection than at any time since the Good Friday Agreement. Protections written into law. Protections that support justice and answers for all, including the families of British soldiers murdered by the IRA.
But I know that some soldiers, some veterans, feel today that we're not yet there. Too many have been told the opposite. My local veterans charity recounts calls from members, people who served 30 years ago, who've never been subject to any questioning or doubt about who've been picking up the phone saying, what's this I hear about the government wanting to come after me? It's clearly not accurate. And I of course respect anyone in this House and their duty to scrutinise rightly the government and each of the votes that we cause.
But I say this, anyone that says they care about the welfare of veterans does an absolute shame to scaremonger against 300,000 veterans who've never been subject to any doubt about the conduct and the honour with which they served. And people who would, there is a difference between political scrutiny and political point scoring that does no service to our veterans. And I hope the rest of this debate continues in that manner. Our veterans deserve peace and reconciliation as much as the people of Northern Ireland do. It is to the foundations that they lay through their service that the reconciliation that we are seeing across Northern Ireland is partly possible.
It is therefore in honour of their service that we must create the conditions for that reconciliation to continue. In honour of those who've served and of every victim of the Troubles, I support these amendments today and I will support the bill tonight.
David Michael Davis
Thank you, Madam Chairman. Can I start by commending the previous speaker, the member for Sunderland Central, although whilst I disagree with some of the substance of what he had to say, I find a lot to agree with in the sentiment and the support for our veterans, which is welcome. Can I also thank the Secretary of State for his telephone call at home to tell me he was going to support my amendment 50. I should have been here long enough to realise of course that when I looked on the order paper for amendment 50 in the name of David Davis, it had become government amendment 50. So I feel like I've been nationalised, but it is the only time I approve of a nationalisation, this will be it.
But thank you for that.
Can I also say to him, actually I commend him for the elegance and tone of his debate, of his speaking in the last couple of days. This is the most formidable of difficult bills facing the House. I think anybody should recognize that. And he's navigated it with great charm and has reinforced my view that he should have been in the cabinet long ago. So I thank him for that.
I'm trying to do as much damage as possible. But I stand to speak principally to amendment 51 and to some extent amendment 49. 49 basically stops any new inquest whatsoever, sorry, not any new inquest, we've already got that in 50. It stops the existing paused inquests going forward. And 51 addresses directly the paused inquest relating to Loughgall.
I've picked that out because it is the most controversial. It is the most central to what the IRA is trying to achieve. And it has got and it actually emblematic is emblematic of many of the reasons why we should not pursue any of these inquests but should put them in the proper place, which is the Legacy Commission, which can deal with it dispassionately. Before I go any further, I should draw the House's attention to my entries in the register of members' interests, not just this year but in previous years, which relates to the fact that I was the trustee of the SAS Regimental Association, I can't remember for how many years, well more than a decade anyway. Now so far, all parties in this debate yesterday and today have quite properly focused on the need to get closure for victims and at the same time to deliver justice for our veterans.
And nobody can I think argue with those two aims. And of course I focus mostly at the moment on getting justice for veterans by preventing them being punished by the process. But before I pursue that line in detail, I'd like just to address some of the words and definitions we use in this. In particular with respect to the operation of inquests in Northern Ireland, the definition of victim. Because we all have in our mind a fairly clear idea of what a victim is I think.
But unfortunately it is a little different in Northern Ireland. A difference arises from a deliberate decision taken by the Blair government, Article 3 of the Victims and Survivors Northern Ireland Order 2006 changed the definition of victim and it ruled that anyone affected by the troubles through loss, trauma or injury would be classed as a victim. Now that means that proven murderers killed in an attempt to carry out another murder count as a victim. I know of nowhere else in the world where the law treats killers as victims. And this is still relevant.
In September last year, the Democratic Unionist Party used a motion in Northern Ireland Assembly to try to restore some moral clarity by adding the word innocent before victim. Most of us would think of that as a tautology. But actually it was defeated by Sinn Féin supported by the Alliance. So I think this is incredibly central to this.
The word innocent exposes the truth. It draws a line between terrorists and their victims. But to talk to the honorable member for Sunderland's point earlier, veterans and victims are not mutually exclusive terms. Terrorists and victims are. And that's the significance of the the amendment I'm talking about today.
Because in the group of people, the IRA active service unit that were killed at Loughgall, there were any number for whom that applied. The clearest was Jim Lynagh, who was guilty of at least 20 murders, probably more than 30. His nickname was the executioner. He was not an innocent victim by any rational judgment of that word. Now, why Loughgall?
Well, it was the greatest single defeat of the IRA. The one they're most sore about, the one they still feel the scars of. Why? Because it involved a defeat of what they considered their most successful unit, the East Tyrone Brigade. What was the measure of that success?
That so-called brigade killed 250 innocent people. This defeat at Loughgall was seen as a humiliation of the IRA. And that means they are now desperate to rewrite that history, casting their murderers as heroes and British soldiers as amoral killers. Which is why they want the coroner's inquest rather than the legacy commission. Because I'm afraid in Northern Ireland, the coroner's inquest is in many ways public theater.
It just is different. I mean, my right honorable friend, the shadow Secretary of State, made the point, but I will reiterate it. In in the rest of the United Kingdom, an inquest is not allowed to pursue a case if it becomes at all apparent that it may lead to a criminal prosecution, a finding of unlawful killing. But in Northern Ireland, the reverse is true. And even the Northern Irish judges recognize the ludicrous nature of this.
And we saw it with the Coagh case for Soldier B, where there was judicial review attempt after judicial review attempt, which led to the judge saying, talking about the ludicrous nature of this challenge, funded as it is as it is by legal aid. That was the judge in that sequence that talked about having to make in slow motion, indeed freeze-frame, views or judgments on decisions, life and death decisions for the individuals concerned, made in fractions of a second. So so that's the central reason for the my objection, as it were. Now, why did operations like Loughgall or Clonoe or Coagh or any of the other ones which are challenged by the supporters of the IRA and and others? Well, the peculiar circumstances of Northern Ireland made this sort of operation necessary.
How's that? The IRA knew how to frustrate justice. They would murder or intimidate anybody who thought to be who thought they might be a witness. And not just them, but their families. I have to say, if I were in that circumstance in Northern Ireland, I would balk at giving evidence if I felt that my family might be murdered as a result of my doing so.
I would balk at serving on a jury, the same reasons. That's why we ended up with Diplock trials. You know, without juries, judges without juries, because it was simply not viable.
And Diplock himself, when he recommended that, talked about as an example a man who was executed in front of his young son the day before he was due to give evidence in a terrorist trial. So that's the background of the circumstances. But the IRA didn't just stop there. They understood that as well as witnesses, the other thing that matters in court cases is forensics. That's why they wore this strange uniform of boiler suits, rubber gloves, shoe coverings or Wellingtons, balaclavas, because they knew that they had to deny the evidence.
And not just that, when they'd carried out their crime, the cars used frequently were abandoned and burned to destroy the evidence. And there was plenty of examples, I mean, I think Clonoe was one of them, where there was a crowd prevented the authorities getting close to the car until it had burned out, for a very simple reason, to destroy the evidence. Even in the case of the murder of the previous speaker at Stormont, Norman Stronge, and his son, they set fire to the house there, again the same aim. So what does this, what does this... I give way.
Gregory Campbell
I thank the honorable member for giving way. Just on the issue of the IRA's determination to deal with forensics, would he agree with me that in addition to that, they actually blew up the forensics laboratory in South Belfast where forensic information had been gathered?
David Michael Davis
The honorable gentleman is exactly right. And it actually serves to focus our minds on the fact that this was a very deliberate strategy. That, you know, this was not something that happened by accident. They didn't just take to having boiler suits as uniforms. This was a deliberate strategy.
Which of course faced the state with a conundrum. Because doing nothing, just sitting back, doesn't work. You know, if the jury processes and the other judicial processes don't work, it's still not an option. Why do I say that? Well, I go back, let's take the East Tyrone Brigade for an example.
They killed 250 people before Loughgall. During the late eighties, they were killing people at a rate of 10 or 15 a year. Doing nothing meant 10 or 15 innocent people would die every year because the state wasn't meeting its duty. So the only way to stop it was to catch them in flagrante, in the exact act of carrying out a crime, and try to arrest them. Of course, that's always the first aim of the state, to try and do this with minimum force if possible.
But of course, the circumstance didn't always allow that. You had an armed set of terrorists, probably in the process of trying to kill somebody, who might then turn to kill you. And you had to stand up and say, "Excuse me, you're under arrest." Well, I mean, we saw actually in the process of many of these events how dangerous this was. At Coagh, the case that went through all those judicial reviews, an SAS soldier had to dress up effectively as a Unipork man to be the target, and they had to wait until he had been shot at before they moved.
We saw that at Clonoe, as I think my right honorable friend mentioned. The intel, again, another problem, the intelligence there was wrong, which made it even more difficult. But they were facing a double-barrelled DShK machine gun, 50 caliber, designed to bring down light armor or aircraft. Three seconds of burst of fire from that and the whole patrol would have been dead. And that's the sort of thing we're asking our soldiers to carry out.
And I'll come back to the Loughgall example, which is even more worse in that way. But that's the sort of thing, as I say, that we are saying to our soldiers, you must do this in order to attempt to achieve an arrest or at least a stop if we have to.
And this is not theoretical. Soldiers died, I mean hundreds of soldiers died in Northern Ireland. In the specific context of the special forces, which is what these three cases relate to, if people want to look at it, I recommend they look up the example of, I can't remember if it's Corporal or Lance Corporal David Jones, who was shot on the moment of challenge, or Captain Westmacott, and there will be others. But those will give the House clear examples of the sort of risks that had to be taken, but were taken by our brave and honourable and decent and law-abiding soldiers. And so we come to Loughgall.
Very briefly.
Of course.
Mark Francois.
Mark Francois
He's making a very powerful speech, and it explains very well why veterans have lost confidence in the coronial system. Would he, given what he said, agree with the words of the Northern Ireland Veterans Commissioner, David Johnston, who said just recently, because the coronial system allows for appeals, judicial reviews all the way up to the Supreme Court, and families can access legal aid, it is lawfare on steroids. Does my right honourable friend agree with that?
David Michael Davis
Sir David, I agree with David Johnston. I think, by the way, he's a very brave commissioner. In a sense, his predecessor was effectively fired for standing up, and he's still standing up. So yes, he's right. And just to go off at a slight tangent on this, of course our other enemies learn from this, and we're seeing it elsewhere in the world today.
And if we're not very careful, we will end up without the best parts of our armed forces because we have ourselves destroyed it. But let me come back to Loughgall. The aim at Loughgall was to destroy the police station and kill the police officers who would be coming off shift at 7:00 PM. It was actually timed at 7:00 PM. It wasn't the first, it was the third such operation after Ballygawley, where they shot and killed two police officers before blowing up the station, and The Birches, where they machine-gunned the station, fortunately missed people, but they machine-gunned the station before blowing it up.
At Loughgall, the IRA team attacked the police station in two units. In one unit in a van, which carried a team armed with automatic weapons with the intention of killing the three police officers as they came off duty. And the other unit, I think of three men, was in a digger, JCB-style digger, which was carrying in its bucket a 300 to 400 pound bomb. A 300 to 400 pound bomb. The attack happened at 7:00 PM, as I said, when the police were due to come off shift.
Inside the station at the time, because of intelligence known, there were three police officers and three SAS soldiers. I'll be frank with the House, I find it hard to imagine the level of courage taken to sit in a building waiting for it to be blown up by a 300 or 400 pound bomb. It is beyond my imagination, but that's what they did. The attack started when the van screeched to a halt and a number of the unit debussed and opened fire on the police station. They fired a total of 78 rounds.
I don't know whether all were at the police station, but I imagine most of them were. Inside the station, people report being hit by fragments of bullets as they shattered as they hit the steel frames of the windows and disintegrated. Then the digger crashed through the perimeter fence and the bomb exploded, destroying half the building and injuring the occupants. Injuring is a too mild term for this, frankly. One had a fractured skull, others had broken bones, two fell about 10 foot onto rubble, two of the soldiers, others of course had hearing injuries.
In the firefight that followed, all eight members of the IRA active service unit were killed. Now, these are the people otherwise described as victims in this exercise.
Now, I've already detailed the worst of them, Jim Lynagh. Rather than detail the rest, I'll simply say that the weapons recovered after the event were responsible for forty to fifty, on forensic analysis, responsible for forty to fifty killings, killings in every single county in Northern Ireland. The effect? Well, before the East Tyrone Brigade... No, not for a second, I'll give way in a moment if you mind.
The East Tyrone Brigade were responsible for over twenty percent of the IRA's activities and killings in Northern Ireland, afterwards they're responsible for less than ten percent. This operation saved lives. I give way to my colleague.
Speaker 151
Grateful to the honorable member for giving way. Can I just ask him to put on the record as well that another man was killed on that day in that operation called Anthony Hughes, totally, completely, utterly innocent civilian not involved in any IRA activity or any other organisation.
David Michael Davis
Indeed, I was about to come to that point and I will in fact probably come back to it again. And that is the real tragedy of that day. That is the real tragedy. He was the real, the real victim, and his son by the way, I think, who was wounded as well. And you know, one of the things about the British state is we do take our, and I know the honorable gentleman won't agree, but we do take our judicial responsibilities seriously in these matters and we have prosecuted our own soldiers.
I mean, the name Clegg jumps to mind, but there are others as well who were prosecuted and sent to prison for acting, well, even bluntly, acting irresponsibly, let alone malevolent. So, so yes, of course, the worst tragedy is literally the next paragraph, I'll give him my paper afterwards so he can see. And incidentally, that's one of the reasons I would say that this should go to the Legacy Commission, because that's a really important thing to investigate, but in a cool analytical manner, not in the, frankly, the theatre of the court. Because why do the IRA want to have a coroner's inquest rather than Legacy Commission? Because they were humiliated at Loughgall and want to rewrite history with them as the heroes and British soldiers as the villains.
Now, we've heard, and let me give you a sort of an early sign, give the House, sorry, beg your pardon, Madam Chairman, give the House an early sign of what sort of thing they're trying to claim. We've been hearing recently that these IRA people were only aiming to destroy the building, they weren't aiming to kill anybody. Completely different from the first three operations where they actually murdered them in cold blood before they started blowing it up. And of course, that doesn't explain why they were firing seventy-eight rounds at the building. Bullets kill people, not buildings.
Why they were there at the shift change when the soldiers, when the RUC members were about to come out. It's plainly nonsense, but it's the sort of nonsense that they want to perpetrate in a court. And that's why, one other reason why I'd rather see the dispassionate actions of the Commission than the activities of IRA lawyers in the courts.
Carla Lockhart
I thank the honorable member, right honorable member, for giving way. He is making a very powerful speech and Loughgall is in my constituency and he has rightly said that the East Tyrone killing wing of the IRA were the most barbaric, bloodthirsty wing of the IRA.
And I think it is important to the House just to remind them of the names Eva Martin, Sir Norman Stronge and his son James, the four UDR soldiers at the Ballygawley landmine, the two RUC soldiers murdered at Ballygawley station, Harold Henry of Henry Brothers, all names and families murdered by these people. So their CV certainly doesn't say that they were going just to blow up a building when you look at that. And he is right to mention the name Jim Lynagh with regards and he was actually under investigation for Sir Norman Stronge's at the time of the Loughgall and Patrick Kelly convicted of firearms offences as well. So today when we discuss this, the government have the opportunity to stop this second inquest. And would he agree with me that the government must do the right thing and actually include within this legislation your amendment 51 to stop this second inquest and show that when these people met real soldiers, it saved lives.
Speaker 137
Before Sir David Davis responds, I know that please, very important and sensitive points are being raised, but please know you and know your. Sir David Davis, and can I please remind the honourable member many people wish to contribute in this debate this evening. Sir David Davis.
David Michael Davis
I'm very close to the end, Madam Speaker, but sorry, Madam Chairman, there we are, I've made a mistake now. Now, he's exactly right. And that's the entire thrust of this amendment, indeed if I had my way, I'd say amendment 49 is better because it stops all of these and puts them all, it doesn't get rid of them, it puts them into a better process which the government themselves have now designed. And let me just finish on the question of the coroner's court. I spoke this morning, I mean I've listened to a number of soldiers who have appeared in these courts and now these are the people I'm talking about, you can guess who they are, tough, intelligent soldiers, but this is not their environment when they're being harassed by a lawyer trying to get a story out of them, not get the truth, get the story out of them.
And I spoke this morning to one of them who had been through more of these court cases, both in the inquests and in judicial review than most. And he tells me that IRA lawyers, his words, are more interested in drama than justice. And no, not on this for a second, I've nearly at the end, I've already been rebuked by the chairman for going on. And this, I'm afraid this is consistent with what I saw, I've never appeared in an inquest, but I've appeared in a Diplock court in Northern Ireland and a Diplock court in Northern Ireland, sorry, am I being heckled? And I saw the same, the lawyers interested in making a historic rewriting point rather than the other.
That's why the IRA would welcome the restarting of a Loughgall inquest. They would view a Loughgall inquest as a victory in its own right because it'll allow them yet another attempt to rewrite the history of the Troubles. And by the way, one aside, I mean it comes back to the honourable gentleman's point in a way, but the converse of it, one of the soldiers at Loughgall got the Military Medal. In my view, many of them should have, but he got the Military Medal. What for?
For putting himself at extra risk to save civilians, to prevent the death of civilians. That tells you what you're dealing with with British soldiers in Northern Ireland. Last point. This operation was approved in detail by the General Officer Commanding Northern Ireland. I believe it was approved in detail by the Secretary of State.
It was reviewed by the DPP, by the Director of Public Prosecutions, with all of the information to hand, forensics, witness, the lot, and remember there'd be RUC people who had been not involved directly but who would have given witness statements. So do we want to run that through a circumstance when the evidence has degraded, when people's memories have got, when some have died, I mean one of them, one of the individuals involved has got dementia, I mean is that what we want to do or do we want to do it properly by dispassionate method using an instrument that is designed for the process and actually both sides of the House agree will work. So I beg to move my amendment 51.
Claire Hanna.
Claire Hanna
Thank you very much, Ms Ghani, and thank you to all of those who have contributed to what has been a relatively constructive debate over the last two days because it's not lost on me anyway that our work in this chamber and over the coming days in the Northern Ireland Select Committee is about the legacy of the troubles, is about paramilitary transition, is about a 1990s-grating dispute as if we didn't have problems and challenges to deal with in the present day. And the sad reality is that despite the seismic changes in our part of the world over the decades, the past isn't the past. It affects and it affects politics and policing and public services every day. And that's why we need to get through it. Most of all, it affects victims and survivors who through all the decades of change have been told to wait, to wait while the rest of us and the rest of society is allowed to move on and while the murders of their loved ones are justified and explained away or minimized.
Because the truth is that for three decades the needs of those with most to hide are what have been prioritized rather than the needs of those with most to heal. And the lesson that hasn't been learned by some in this house isn't that victims have dragged this out. It's the fact that we're still at this three decades on precisely because the information that families need has had to be clawed and prized out of the hands of those with most to hide. So for them and for the SDLP, this legislation isn't about being obsessed with the past. It isn't about raking over what has gone on.
It's fundamentally about the future and our ability to move forward together. That's why we make no apology for supporting this legislation or for trying to make it better. So I want to address today's schedule and I want to address some of the amendments and some of the arguments that featured in the debate. That about the passage of time and some of the tropes about vexatious investigations and some statistics relating to those issues. I think my honorable friend for Liverpool West rightly set out in very powerful detail the healing power accessed by truth of the Hillsborough family and the meaning that has had for them.
Another fact that of course bears repeating is that tens of thousands of Republican and Loyalist prisoners did go through the justice system for their crimes, their terrible crimes which our party stood firmly against in the face of provocation and sectarian horrors from every direction. So nobody here is calling those people heroes and imperfect as that justice is, it did take place. And those who wish to describe those people as heroes, none of whom are sitting on these benches or anywhere else, are bolstered by the failure, the failure to show any sort of nuance and by the blind defense of some of the most brutal killings of the troubles. So we understand the pride that many in this chamber feel in the British Army. We understand that of the 300,000 men, mostly men, men and women who served, the vast majority did go out to try and keep the peace and to serve.
But we also need to restate that it has been in practically single figures the number of those who have been investigated. But we acknowledge that so many of those soldiers were subjected to horrors. We acknowledge their pain and indeed the interventions of many of their families who are seeking access to truth the same as any other families. Because that's what this is about, not lawfare and revisionism. And I have to ask people to be careful with their language when they use terms like IRA lawyers.
Because do you know what has happened to people in the past when they've been named in this chamber as IRA lawyers? They were shot dead in front of their family. So can we take a little bit of caution in some of the language that we are using. This is about the healing power of information and the right of families to access it. A right powerfully, as I say, articulated about Hillsborough's families, but particularly articulated in the report published last month into the murder of Rory O'Reilly.
A founding member of our party, a decent man, a family man who represented the non-violent civil rights protesters and who was brutally murdered while attending a funeral in his hometown by the Provisional IRA because of his belief in and because of his professional service to the rule of law. So his case and the report released last month with feedback from his family gives some sense of the release and the comfort families can find in investigations, even if in that case no prosecution followed. And it should be read and understood by those who want to smear those who support this legislation as being Republicans involved in IRA cheerleading. So prosecutions, we all know, won't follow in most cases, but that certainly doesn't mean they should be off the table where evidence leads. And that brings me to the amendment which designs in a veto rule for the Attorney General in London and the potential undermining of the processes we're legislating for today.
Independence of the judiciary is a principle worth protecting in general and especially in these scenarios when, and even though I appreciate this is hard for many people in this chamber to hear, the UK government was not some neutral player. They were an active participant at many times in our horrible conflict. So how can families truly have confidence in these processes when a veto belongs to a government that they feel actively participated in the conflict and at many times covered up that information. I also want to address some of the fairly wild and mind-bending interventions about the Republic of Ireland and to welcome the cooperation that this legislation represents up to and including some op-eds implying that this is a move towards EU re-entry, a combination of some of the greatest hits we hear in this chamber. The facts are that the Stormont House Agreement signed in 2014 enacted, created the potential for architecture at that time to go through legacy processes and to, I suppose, capture some of the many themes and patterns that members across the House have tried to highlight and created possibilities for us to push back against some of the revisionism and counter-narratives that many of us oppose.
That legislation was not enacted. That architecture was not built by the previous government. And we see the consequences of the practical implications when the two governments are not on the same page and in lockstep. We see that in the inquiry currently going on into Omagh. That makes clear that without the governments acting jointly, without the intricate and carefully designed terms of reference that those families deserve.
And many of us are watching in some distress that inquiry and the apparent missed opportunities to prevent that horrific bomb and the toll that it's taking on families. The SDLP is not here to say that Irish governments past or present have got everything right on legacy. We certainly aren't. But we are here to highlight the ludicrous hypocrisy of those who are decrying and inventing in many cases a lack of disclosure from Dublin while fighting tooth and nail to suppress every bit of information they can from this government. So I will finish where I started with victims and survivors for whom this is all about and for whom all of this is certainly not confined to history books.
Of all of the words written about the troubles, none get it more powerfully than the Ulster poet John Hewitt who wrote in Neither an Elegy nor a Manifesto: "Bear in mind these dead, I can find no plainer words." And we can't build reconciliation on concealment and secrets. We've tried that for the last three decades and it didn't work. We can't ask families to just accept that the truth is too uncomfortable when the truth is about the death of their loved ones. And we can't get to the other side of this ugly period without unfortunately going through it.
So this legislation, this body, it isn't perfect, but it's the last and best chance for those families from all backgrounds to try and move forward. And we commend it to the House.
Chris Cocklin.
Chris Cocklin
Madam Chair, we owe our special forces an enormous debt. I understood this more clearly when I served in counter-terrorism in the Foreign Office. But that debt has not been honored with the endless and unjustified litigation against Northern Ireland veterans. In Northern Ireland there has been a sustained attempt to paint a moral equivalence between those who are maintaining law and order and those who conducted murder. Veterans fear persecution.
That is why I support amendment 129 tabled by my honorable friend for Wimbledon that would require a new evidence certificate to be issued before the resumption of any inquest. As the honorable member for Goole and Pocklington has spoken so movingly about, on 8th of May 1987 a heavily armed eight-man IRA, Provisional IRA team approached a police station at Loughgall. They used a JCB to breach the perimeter with a 3 to 400 pound bomb in the bucket. They're engaged by the SAS and killed. It was the largest single loss of life by the IRA.
Tragically an innocent civilian was mistaken for the IRA and killed too. There have already been four investigations or inquests into Loughgall. If there is another, what further answers are the families expecting? On their own terms their loved ones were members of the Provisional IRA committed to violence for political ends. But what would this mean for veterans?
Anyone who opened fire will be anxious that doing their duty could be portrayed as a serious crime. I share the serious concerns of SAS veterans and their regimental associations. The failing in the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill is that there is no robust objective test to prevent the reopening of inquests without new and compelling evidence. Madam Chair, I may be an MP but I'm also a reservist soldier in the London Guards. I've served alongside soldiers who know that they have done nothing wrong but now worry that in 30 or 40 years' time they too could be hauled out of retirement to court.
How can that be right? British soldiers risk their lives for others.
We owe them the just protection of this amendment.
Al Carns.
Alistair Scott Carns
Thank you Ms Ghani. The conduct of this debate today and yesterday I've found deeply encouraging. I think it's been thoughtful. I think it's been meaningful and the passionate speeches have informed my insight and understanding to both Northern Ireland veterans and other issues all combined. Indeed I think the hope in democracy candour and progressive parliament has generally been restored after some other debates which I've had the privilege of sitting in on.
Ms Ghani as you'll be aware yesterday I spoke to the house about some of the changes the government have made to this bill. And I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for them. He has listened. The change on equivalence matters to me as do protections against people being investigated again and again for some of the same events. I still think however that we've got the architecture of this bill wrong from the start.
What happens to outstanding inquests is of concern and the ability to balance truth and reconciliation with justice is almost impossible and I'll explain why. We have 38 inquests which have stopped. They're going to restart under the bill. Some will go back to the coronial system with others going to the legacy commission. It would be really useful if the Secretary of State could answer me as to whether those inquests that sat with the Solicitor General once they go into legacy commission or whether they go into the inquest process can they go straight into the legacy commission or do they need to be opened as an inquest before they move as a recommendation into the legacy commission.
Chris Bryant
When the Solicitor General does his sift of those inquest of those processes they would go straight to the legacy commission.
Alistair Scott Carns
That's encouraging to know. But these are the deaths from the same conflict being considered decades later yet we're deliberately providing two different routes for dealing with them. Now I've recommended now for over 12 months that we create one centralised body to deal with the troubles related to these issues. I know there are some that that would be uncomfortable. Particularly those who represent families who've waited a very very long time for an inquest and I understand why.
I'm not suggesting for a moment that those families should lose the work that has already been done. The evidence gathered should go with the case. Nor am I seeking to prevent prosecutions. If the commission finds evidence that somebody has committed a criminal offence whether that person wore a uniform or indeed belonged to a terrorist organisation that evidence should go to the prosecuting authorities. I'm trying to get us to one process which we can have some confidence in.
There's a reason I feel strongly about this. We need to be very careful about the history we're creating through the legacy process. And also why it's impossible to balance truth and reconciliation with justice. Indeed the state kept records. They kept a lot of records during the troubles.
Speaker 175
Of course it did. Operations were recorded reports were written and the people involved can often be identified. There's an enormous amount of material about what the British state did and didn't do. The IRA and other terrorist groups did not keep operational records. There is no equivalent archive sitting somewhere with records who gave an order who carried it out and what happened afterwards.
Grateful to the honourable member for giving way. I'm not sure we know for definite that the IRA didn't keep records but that's an aside.
Speaker 151
And those files exist. Those files could tell us a whole lot about what the IRA and other organizations were up to.
Alistair Scott Carns
Thank you for the intervention. But when those records are exposed outside and threatened either national security or individual security, we've got to take that into account. Now, yesterday, I think we all agreed that families deserve justice. They deserved answers and indeed many wanted closure. But with the majority of murders in the Troubles remaining unsolved and conducted by terrorist organizations, there just isn't the evidence to get to the truth or indeed the justice.
I would like to ask, how is the bill going to change that? Let's just have a think about that. How is the bill going to change the amount of evidence? Where is the new evidence coming from? Well, we need to be honest, I think, with the families.
Do we genuinely believe ex-IRA or unionist terrorists are going to come and give information to this process? If by coming forward to offer information that would provide answers at the same time will self-incriminate the witness or the individual providing the information, how many will genuinely participate? And then I hear Ireland, I hear new biometric and forensic evidence gathering capabilities. There just isn't the evidence that will get to the truth. The reality, and I could be wrong and if I'm proven wrong I will hold my hand up, is that very few terrorists, if any, will come forward.
The quest for the truth will lie on slivers, and I mean slivers of new evidence, that doesn't mean to say we shouldn't investigate it, slivers of new evidence that are found or indeed Ireland opening and giving the UK access to its extensive archives. But do we believe Ireland will do that? It will be politically very difficult, legally painful, indeed question the reputation and moral compass of consecutive Irish governments and their reputation. We need to be honest with families. This bill will not magically produce new evidence and this creates a very real problem when 30 to 40 years later we try to establish the truth through legal proceedings.
Material available to investigators is inevitably much richer on one side than indeed it is on the other. If we then put the cases through different processes as well, we make the problem even worse. I've described this before as creating a hierarchy of truth. I don't mean that as a slogan. I mean something quite specific.
What can be investigated most easily becomes what gets investigated most thoroughly. What gets investigated most thoroughly produces the most findings. And after enough years have passed, those findings start to become the history of the conflict. I don't believe anybody in this House genuinely intends that to happen. I genuinely don't think that's the case.
But intention isn't really the point. We need to look at where the system we are building eventually takes us. The bill is trying to prevent repeat investigations and I welcome the work to do so. But a small example. Soldier B from Cook has not been charged but has had eight years of legal process.
Three court cases have ruled his actions were justified with the appropriate use of force. Yet the family have received legal aid to take the case again to the Supreme Court. Soldier B is unlikely ever to be charged but he's undergone eight years of legal uncertainty and will endure many more. This isn't about prosecutions, this is about the process being wielded as the punishment. And that is also why I come at this as a Labour MP.
The Good Friday Agreement asked an enormous amount of people to do very, very difficult things. There were decisions made as part of that settlement which many people found very hard to accept and still do. Prisoners walked out of jail, people who had been enemies were expected to sit in government together. Blair and Mo Mowlam understood that there was no settlement available which could somehow settle every account from the previous 30 years.
They were trying to stop another generation having to live the same argument. And I worry that we're in danger of doing the opposite with legacy. In 10 or 15 years' time, people in Northern Ireland's understanding of what happened will come in large part from what is being established now. And if over those years, one part of the conflict is being examined again and again, because that is where the records and the people are available, while much of the activity of terrorist organisations remains beyond reach, we should not be surprised if people begin to draw conclusions from that. That would be a poor legacy for a Labour government to leave them.
None of this diminishes what families have been through. There are people who've spent decades trying to find out what happened to someone they loved, hundreds of people. They are entitled to pursue the truth, and I would never vote for a system designed to deny it to them. But I also know veterans who have lived for years with the possibility that somebody will reopen an event which has already been examined, sometimes more than once, in many cases more than once. Many of those people are now very old men.
We cannot keep pretending that endless process is the same thing as justice. The government has chosen to strengthen the Legacy Commission, and I think that is the right thing to do. If we believe the commission can do this work, then let it do the work. Give it these outstanding cases and the material already collected, let families take part, and if it finds evidence which belongs before a court, then that is where it should go. Indeed, even the Joint Committee on Human Rights has questioned the justification for having two approaches to these revived inquests.
And I think it's a fair question, and I have yet to hear a convincing answer to it other than it will stress test the framework agreement with the Irish. I know the Secretary of State also has to deal with the Irish and the commitments which have been made there. I don't underestimate the problems of that. But Dublin has responsibilities here as well. If this process is going to have credibility, cooperation and access to information cannot run in one direction.
And I'm yet to be convinced that Dublin will open up its archives to expose the 30 years of cross-border activity that has taken place. Now, I resigned from government in part because I could not support where we'd got to on legacy. I didn't do that lightly, and I haven't changed my view simply because I now sit on this bench rather than the front bench. I want the government to get this right, put these remaining inquests into the same system, keep the evidence and work which has already been done, and let the commission follow that evidence wherever it goes. We've spent nearly 30 years trying to move Northern Ireland beyond the troubles.
At some point, we have to leave the next generation something better than another set of processes through which to fight them all over again. And for the reasons above, I cannot support the government plans for Northern Ireland legacy today.
Gavin Robinson
Ms Ghani, can I thank you for calling me, and can I say it is a huge privilege to follow the honourable and gallant gentleman. He is somebody who has been steadfast and faithful to not only the principles that he upholds and that he expounds, but to the bonds with his comrades and the consequence that is before us all in the legislation. He has acted in a selfless way, and I guess that is the mark of the man. There are many in politics who wouldn't have taken the position that he did. So it is a pleasure, Ms Ghani, to follow him, and I thank him for his contribution.
Can I also make a, I feel we need to do this given his contribution today, just make mention of the honourable member for Wimbledon. The honourable member for Wimbledon started off his contribution this afternoon almost apologetically. And last week, after the carryover motion, the honourable member took sanctuary in Londonderry with me and other members of the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee, and he feared he had done something inexplicable. He had united the House against him. I didn't agree with that assessment, Ms Ghani, but I do believe that he is approaching these issues with a level of diligence that we appreciate, and I thank him for that.
Ms. Ghani, I do, I mean, obviously I spoke yesterday more broadly on terms of the bill and in respect of those amendments before the House yesterday afternoon. Sometimes I lament that on issues like legacy, there are far too many people who hear what they think is being said because of the person saying it. And they don't listen to the contributions that are being made. There are people in this debate who will think, well, they would say that anyway, wouldn't they, always standing up for the Brits? Or they would say that, wouldn't they, always standing up for the Irish?
Or they would acquiesce, wouldn't they, always in the face of terror? And I don't think it does this debate any good. There are people that I fundamentally disagree with, we'll be in different sides of the chamber, we'll be in different lobbies from them this evening, but there are things that they say and contributions that they make in this debate that I agree with. And Ms. Ghani, I do worry that so often in this debate there seems to be a tension between victims and innocent victims, soldiers, or should we say state combatants, some would describe them as, I think it's disrespectful. But we pit individuals against one another.
Why is it that somebody like me talks about veterans and the need for veterans' protection? It's because those were individuals who volunteered to stand up for the things that we value in this country. I listened to the honorable member who's not in his place at the moment, and it was Sunderland Central, perhaps, Sunderland Central. And he said when the army were deployed in Northern Ireland, they didn't, they weren't deployed for one side or another. That's not quite right.
They were deployed on the one side that the vast majority of people in Northern Ireland were on too, and that's those that believe in the rule of law and upholding decency of democracy. They were deployed on one side against those who wanted to destroy our nation, destroy our livelihoods, and take our lives. That's why they were deployed. And that's why we owe it to them, as a Parliament, as a legislative chamber, to provide protections. And the right honorable gentleman, who I have huge regard for, though we clash many times on these issues, will know that I asked him not to talk about protections for veterans if they didn't amount to measures that protected those very same veterans.
Talk of safeguards, talk of measures you may bring forward that could provide some level of comfort, but let's not describe them as protections if they don't protect. And what we hear and what we see before us today and throughout the course of these debates are the following measures: fairness, dignity, and respect.
It's offered as a protection to veterans. There should be fairness, dignity and respect for anybody in these processes and of course it doesn't apply to veterans, it applies to everyone. Witness participation. Witnesses should not be compelled to participate unless there is new and compelling evidence. It's offered as a protection for veterans, but it's something that applies in principle to everyone.
I don't challenge that, but I don't pretend it's something it's not. Older veterans. This legislation and amendments before us will guarantee that they are treated with respect, with care, and that an assessment is made if needed at all at their participation. It doesn't just apply to older veterans. It's presented wrongly, mischievously, as a protection for veterans, but rightly it's an application of a principle that applies to all.
And then we have the provisions around the Attorney General and the consent required for the Attorney General, a government new clause 50. Veterans asked for this. Veterans asked for the Attorney General to be incorporated into this process, who also serves as the Advocate General for Northern Ireland. And that it has been offered satisfies the requests of veterans. And they do it because they don't trust, I heard earlier mentioned, the politics of Northern Ireland in prosecutions.
Well, our prosecution service is independent of politics in Northern Ireland. It is independent of politics in Northern Ireland. But this is given, the consent required of the Attorney General is given because it's been requested by veterans and veterans assume that it's going to add some level of protection. And it won't. And whenever it is challenged and whenever the Secretary of State has been challenged about why he is doing it, and challenged by victims, challenged by loved ones, and challenged by others, he gives an answer and he gave it again last night, it's in Hansard.
That's the wrong page, but it is in Hansard. Where he says, "Yes, completely, it was recommended by the Joint Committee on Human Rights." "It is important to note that the Attorney General, who is also the Advocate General in Northern Ireland, would not only have a quasi-judicial function and would use precisely the same prosecutorial process as they would for any other prosecuting decision." So what started as a request from veterans and has been welcomed by some veterans groups and think that it's going to add some level of protection or cover from the infected process they see in Northern Ireland, it's not. We know very clearly: one, applies to everyone; two, quasi-judicial process; three, just replicating exactly the same principles of the prosecutors who are making the decision in Northern Ireland in the first place.
So the question is this: why do it at all? What benefit is there at all if they are replicating the same process approached independently, which is quasi-judicial and is applying legal application, what does it add to the process at all? And I said it this morning to a wider audience in Northern Ireland, I'll say it again this evening. The problem with this proposition is that it started as a request and that request was acquiesced to and people were led to believe it was a level of prosecution, when challenged, of protection, when challenged by victims to say how can you be stepping in to protect, how can you provide a mechanism that is going to protect a certain cohort, the answer is well actually it doesn't apply to them alone, it applies to everyone and actually it's just exactly the same application of principle that you'll see in Northern Ireland and it's quasi-judicial anyway and of course it could be judicially reviewed.
And the reason I raise these points, the reason I raise these points is because I think it's fundamentally important that people speak accurately, accurately Ms Ghani.
Well I will.
Can I ask is he in favour of the Attorney General move or not?
Gavin Robinson
I am happy to sit down and take a further intervention. I ask what's the point if it replicates exactly the same process and applies exactly the same principle as adheres to Northern Ireland prosecutions? Why make it a provision in this legislation? Why bring forward the amendment? It was acquiescence to a request from veterans, that's where it started, then came from the Joint Committee.
It has been presented as a protection for some and yet it applies to everyone equally and it's a replication of a process that already exists. So my question is not a question for me as to whether I support it, the question for the Secretary of State is why it's been introduced at all.
Chris Bryant
Well I have already explained at some length both yesterday and I said earlier today, I think he was in his place when I said this, that this is not to take anything away from the prosecuting authorities in Northern Ireland or in Great Britain. They are going to be cooperating on producing guidelines on how these decisions are to be arrived at, but there will be some instances that relate to troubles-related deaths in England, there will be some, a small number, relatively small compared to the number in Northern Ireland. It makes sense that there's consistency across the whole of the United Kingdom. It is a process that has been used elsewhere and that's why we're advocating it. But I ask again, does he support the amendment or not?
Gavin Robinson
Every time the Secretary of State speaks Ms Ghani he confuses issues, he muddies the waters. Does this process apply to every case or just those in England?
Speaker 178
This is slightly odd now but of course it applies to all cases. He knows this. I just ask again, does he support the measure or not? He argued for it privately to me in the past.
Gavin Robinson
First of all I put forward the request from veterans organisations as well he knows. But secondly and separately if the Secretary of State is incapable or unwilling of arguing the added benefit of the proposition given how it is presented today then I think that will be of interest to many listening in the House, many listening in the House. Don't pretend, don't pretend that protections are being offered when they are not. Don't pretend that they do something different than they are intended to do. And for the Secretary of State to sit there and say what he has just said I think says an awful lot more about him than I.
It does. There we go. I mean it is pathetic Madam Deputy Speaker or should I say Ms Ghani.
So this chamber will consider amendments. I have no doubt just with the lack of scrutiny and the lack of interest in most that was before us yesterday, they'll be agreed on the nod. They'll go through on the nod and then time will tell. Time will tell. Inquests, Ms. Nokes, have already got a good airing in this debate.
I think it's clear just to hear from the framework document that seems to be the foundation for a lot of this with the Irish government about the numbers involved. Inquests that had already started, there are nine in total. Nine in total. Twenty inquests more recently have been directed by the Attorney General and of those four remaining inquests from the previous five-year plan. Twenty-four and nine.
There seems to be a working assumption within government as to how many will survive the sift from the Solicitor General. We haven't heard that figure today. I think it is incongruous that the government continue to present, rightly so, that the Legacy Commission complies with statutory obligations, discharges functions under Article 2, is good enough for everyone but not good enough for a select few. And so when given the opportunity yesterday, be it in new clause 55 or given the opportunity this evening in amendment 51, I haven't heard a satisfactory answer as to why government are going to resist ensuring that the Legacy Commission looks at all of these cases, particularly when there's an argument around consistency of approach. Cannot say that you'll defend to the nth degree and uphold in full that the processes provided for everybody else are compliant and then keep a select few for inquests.
The Secretary of State knows the danger of that process and yet not take steps to deal with it. In amendment 32, Ms. Nokes, I have tabled an amendment alongside my colleagues just to starkly illustrate the point that if you want to have protections, if this House wants to have protections that are for and intended to assist veterans and members of the Royal Ulster Constabulary, then they can do so. But we will see. New clause 7 that will be considered, I think, is an important reporting function. We've heard people chastise one another over the chamber yesterday.
We've heard people suggest that this will have a damaging and destabilizing impact on recruitment of our armed forces. We've heard others say that's nonsense, it's never been as healthy. I'm not sure there are many in this chamber would really agree that our armed forces have never been as healthy. There should be no fear from agreeing to new clause 7. New clause 7 is there to assist us all, not pretend that the world is as we would like it to be, but it is as it actually is.
And in new clause 12 for the Liberal Democrats and the honorable member for Wimbledon, the duty to promote reconciliation, it's often, often overlooked. Often overlooked. The old Legacy Act had a reconciliation part to it. It was at the tail end and it never gets focused upon in this chamber. That is a challenge, Ms. Nokes, for us all.
A challenge for those in Northern Ireland who wish to reconcile, but reconcile not meaning appeasement, not meaning that we shouldn't have the right to stand up for the values that we hold, to hear some repentance or forgiveness for the hurt that has been done on others across our societies, not ascribing blame, but recognizing that there is hurt on these issues and that there is a need for reconciliation. And I'm not sure, government's mantra in the past used to be it's not for governments to reconcile one person's heart to another, but they certainly can provide the right basis and the foundation for doing so.
Alex Baker
Thank you, Madam Chair. The Good Friday Agreement and the peace we enjoy today would never have been possible without the service and sacrifice of our armed forces. What unites us in this House is the debt we owe to the thousands of British Army personnel who served with honor in Operation Banner over four decades. Many of them trace their story back to my patch, the home of the British Army. We will never forget the Aldershot bombing of 1972, when the IRA launched one of its first attacks on mainland Britain against the headquarters of 16th Parachute Brigade.
Seven innocent lives were lost. Their families and all those who lost loved ones during the Troubles are in my thoughts today. These issues are woven into the very fabric of my community. It is why I have sat in this chamber for all but last week's carryover motion over a year of this debate going on in this place. It is why I wrote to the former Secretary of State in January calling for stronger safeguards for our veterans, and it's why I've spent many months pressing ministers to ensure that our armed forces are protected from repeat investigations.
And it's why I've facilitated direct discussions between veterans groups, between the Northern Ireland Secretary and Number 10, working with my honorable and gallant friend for Southend East and Rochford. Let me thank all members of our armed forces community who have engaged with me through this process, particularly the Parachute Regimental Association, the Aldershot branch of which, the Royal British Legion, and those watching over our debate in the gallery today. My determination has been to ensure your voices are heard in this legislation. Together, we have made the case for greater recognition of the challenging operational circumstances in which our armed forces served. We have made the case for veterans and their families to be given a voice in new legacy arrangements, and we have successfully made the case that there can never be equivalence between those who served to protect lives and the terrorists who were only focused on taking lives.
I welcome the progress that has been made, and I pay tribute to the Secretary of State and the Minister for Veterans and People. They have listened, engaged, and acted. I only wish we could have started from here. The bill is now much more improved than the one that first entered this House. But I will not be voting for it tonight.
To be clear, I will be abstaining on this third reading on this bill tonight.
Madam Chair, there are some in this house who would do away with this bill altogether. I disagree because then we would lose safeguards for veterans who currently have no protection whatsoever. And too many families, including hundreds of armed forces families, deserve a process to help them find answers. There are others who have dismissed this legislation as a veterans' charter. I respectfully disagree with them as well.
There must be accountability, but those who have dedicated their lives to serving us should not have to spend the rest of their lives fearing investigation over and over again. My test has always been that this legislation should give every veteran the clarity and confidence that they deserve. It is clear to me there is still more work to be done. We have heard in this debate about this case of Soldier B, the man who has been cleared three times but could face yet another process. If this bill cannot do anything for those who may face similar situations in the future, that should give us pause.
As someone who is proud to represent a seat with 5,000 serving personnel, I also want those who serve today and in the future to know we will always have their back.
Chris Bryant
I'm very grateful. First of all, I want to put on record from the dispatch box the gratitude of the whole of the Northern Ireland team to her and her gallant friend who's sitting behind her for the work that they've done. Some of the changes that we've been able to make to the bill at this stage would not have been able to be made without her contribution. And I also undertake, she referred to the process hasn't ended, I believe that too. I and the whole ministerial team will work with her and others and the Parachute Regiment Association and other associations as well to get the bill to the very right place by the time it is enacted.
Alex Baker
I thank the Secretary of State for that contribution and, you know, it is to his credit the progress that we have made in recent weeks on this and as I say the bill is in a much better place off the back of the recent process. But I want to come back to this piece about making sure that our serving personnel today know that we have their back. Whether it is in this bill or the Defense Readiness Bill that I hope will be coming very shortly to this house, I believe there is more we can do to tighten up the Overseas Operations Act so we put our armed forces in the strongest position against future lawfare. And I know our veterans' organizations when it comes to this bill have a lot of other ideas on how this bill could be strengthened. I urge ministers to give those consideration, give them the fullest consideration.
Madam Chair, doing right by those who have served our country should be above party politics. It is our shared duty. I cannot support this bill tonight. It is not something I do lightly. But I am not giving up on this bill either.
There is an incredible breadth of experience and expertise across this house. I hope we can work together with those in the other place. I hope we can still work together with our armed forces community to get this right.
And I will continue to play my part.
Suella Braverman.
Suella Braverman
Thank you, Madam Chairman. I'm the section that we're debating relates to the Independent Commission for Information Retrieval, Inquests and the relaxations of the restrictions on the police investigations. And Madam Chairman, there's only really one word to describe the measures contained in this section of the bill and indeed the totality of the bill. And I'm afraid that word is betrayal. Because now the government demands much of its soldiers.
It asks brave men and women to put their lives in danger and to sacrifice huge amounts. And what do they get in return? We have ostensibly a military covenant, but the truth is that it is honored more in its breach than in its observance. And the question really is, what do our troops get in return at a time when the government is proposing to cut the defense budget for military equipment by billions of pounds, will not promise to increase defense spending to 3% of GDP by 2030 and is at the same time asking men and women to step up and serve in its reservists. The truth is that this country treats our enemies better than it treats our heroes.
The truth is, I'm afraid, that those of our people who are our bravest get treated worse than those who terrorize us. That's what the litigation shows, that's what this bill reflects. Now, the reality is that these sections build more architecture. They build more process and process becomes punishment. That's what these measures institute.
And they perpetuate the retrospective prosecution and persecution, if you will, of our brave troops many decades after they were acting in national service. And that process, this extension of litigation, this extension of lawfare, wholly fails to comprehend and appreciate the complexities of battle and military action. Terrorists, when they are planning to attack us, have the cards stacked in their favor. They can decide what to do, who to target, when to do it, how to do it. Our military, on the other hand, often have zero notice, zero warning and have to make decisions in split seconds, life or death decisions to defend themselves and to defend others.
Now, many decades after those acts of bravery, lawyers, officials, government ministers are applying harsh rules to those people who put their lives at risk for our security. And those decisions that they made at the time were lawful. They were following orders. They were adhering to rules of engagement often set by their superiors or officials at the Ministry of Defence or ministers indeed, none of whom are being held to account decades after the act. And let's remember, our armed forces are known around the world for upholding the highest standards of engagement in battle.
They uphold the rules of the Geneva Convention, the law of armed conflict and they're known for engaging appropriately and proportionately with lethal force. But these, this legislation and indeed the minefield of human rights legislation have operated to build a labyrinthine level of complexity when it comes to military action.
We are tying our brave soldiers up in knots and as a result dragging them through the courts. Surely the cases of the late Dennis Hutchings, Soldier F, Soldiers A and C, some of whom were exonerated after several investigations over several decades, only to be re-prosecuted again on charges of murder, should provide a warning and a salutary warning to the government that the measures in this bill are not fit for purpose. They risk reopening historic investigations and avoiding the finality that many of our soldiers and many people involved in those troubles need and deserve today. And it's not just me saying it or this side of the house, but it's so egregious are the contents of this bill that the regiment associations, unused to getting involved in politics, have now come out and strongly opposed the contents of this bill, the SAS, the Special Forces, the Paras. The veterans associations have united and campaigned vociferously against the contents of this bill because they know that the impacts in this bill will be devastating.
And in my part of the world in Fareham and Waterlooville, we have many, many veterans, in Gosport, in Portsmouth, in Aldershot, in Hampshire, thousands of brave veterans and serving personnel. Many of them have spoken to me about their real concerns of this bill. The truth is that many people from the veteran community, in fact all of them, come from good, traditional, patriotic families. They are people who believe in standing up for what they believe in. And this bill and this government, they believe, is betraying those values, is targeting them unfairly and is persecuting them through legalese, through lawyers, through lawfare, unfairly and unjustifiably.
It's a slap in the face and the contents of this bill frankly move the goalposts and make it an incredibly unfair piece of legislation. Now for my part, I worked on this subject many years ago before I was an MP as a barrister involved in instructing or working on behalf of the MOD, defending our soldiers against vexatious and frankly malicious claims brought by those people in Iraq against our brave soldiers who were on military action out there. Litigation, class actions, which resulted in zero convictions, mind you, which were, which were initiated by Shiner, Starmer was involved and I'm afraid her. That disgraceful trio who should hang their heads in shame for the part they played in bringing legal actions unfairly, unjustifiably against our brave British troops.
Chris Bryant
I'm grateful. One of the things, one of the serious things that points I think she was making earlier on was around the operational context in which people served. I just wonder whether she welcomes new clause 32 that we've tabled.
Suella Braverman
It's in response to discussions from various colleagues. But the point is the contents of this, these measures that I've talked about are wholly unacceptable. They do not answer the fundamental question that they are, that this government is continuing the prosecutions, is allowing inquests, investigations and inquiries many, many years after the act to continue. And the government cannot guarantee that our brave veterans will not be hauled again in front of the courts after they've been exonerated or allowed to proceed.
And I'm afraid because the government cannot provide that guarantee, this bill and these clauses are not fit for purpose. And as Attorney General, I worked to build some of the measures contained in the Legacy Act. It was very challenging to make it compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights, namely Article 2. And it was working on this piece of legislation that actually convinced me that the UK does need to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights. Now, that Legacy Act was not perfect, but it was progress because it did bring finality to a lot of these investigations and prosecutions.
But the reality is that jurisprudence from the European Court of Human Rights, such as the cases of McCann and McKerr and Finucane, have really meant that the interpretation of Article 2, that's the right to life, has been expanded and extended and frankly distorted beyond all recognition, such that really, which has given grounds to these endless and repetitive claims 30 years after... Yes, I will.
Jim Allister
Does in fact the Gaughran case not indicate just how out of control the European Court of Human Rights has become? Because they ruled that those eight wanton terrorists who were on a murder mission and who met their just deserts, that their human rights had been breached because of the lack of proper investigation. There they were, shooting up a police station, special forces responded, but it was the human rights of the terrorists which had been denied. Is that not an illustration of just how ludicrous and out of control the European Court of Human Rights has become?
Suella Braverman
My honorable friend puts it incredibly powerfully. The European Court of Human Rights has wholly distorted the application of Article 2. Article 2 protects the right to life. No one here would disagree with that. It's an absolute right.
And it was designed to protect individuals from state, state-sanctioned killings, arbitrary killings. That was the right intention of the Article 8 drafting. But as my honorable friend, as the honorable member sets out, because of decisions like the one he refers to and many, many more, Article 2 has now become to mean that people are entitled to an unlimited level of investigation and inquiry. Terrorists are entitled to compensation. Families of the IRA are entitled to be paid out because, as the honorable member says, their human rights have become more important than the human rights of the law-abiding citizens and victims of terrorism.
Speaker 186
It's an absurdity. And that is why my position remains that we must leave the European Convention.
Speaker 185
I will not tolerate allegations of misleading, even from a sedentary position. Members must observe the courtesies of the House. Suella Braverman.
Suella Braverman
Chairman. So this bill, I'm afraid, is a retrograde step. It takes us backwards, not forwards, on from the Legacy Act. And it is really tragic that the government is asking, as I say, for many young people to join up and serve their country. But why on earth would a young person take up that offer today?
Traditionally, our soldiers have gone into battle to fight for our country. They've shown incredible heroism and courage and bravery of levels many of us can never imagine.
And they've always felt confident that the government would have their back, that they would be supported by those that whose orders they were taking. But today, there are many serving in the armed forces, many of whom I've met myself, who tell me that they question seriously whether the government would indeed back them. And when they pull that trigger or when they take that decision today, will it be, will they have the confidence of a government many years down the line to stand up for them? Will their bravery today be twisted against them in years to come? And today, frankly, they can't be sure that the government will support them in their acts of courage.
And I'm here speaking on behalf of veterans in my own constituency of Fareham and Waterlooville, who tell me that opponents there may be shaking their heads and chuntering, but I'm here representing what's been told to me by those serving on our front line. The government asks, the first duty of a government is to defend the realm. Surely, for that to mean anything, it must mean that the government stands by those men and women who put their lives in danger to defend our security. This bill fails in that duty and it should not proceed.
Antonia Louise Antoniazzi
Thank you, Madam Chair. We cannot build a more reconciled future without honestly confronting the past. And during our long year-long inquiry into the legacy of the troubles, my colleagues and I on the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee heard that message time and again from victims, survivors, and families whose lives continue to be shaped by events that took place decades ago. And it's a message that stayed with me and one I firmly believe. That is why I have tabled amendment NC54, which reflects recommendations made by the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee following our inquiry.
This amendment seeks to ensure transparency and accountability in the implementation of the reconciliation and memorialization provisions contained within and carried forward from the 2023 Act. One message came through consistently during our inquiry: dealing with the past is about more than investigations alone. Victims, survivors, and communities want meaningful progress on reconciliation. They want confidence that the stories, experiences, and lessons of the troubles will be remembered in a way that is balanced, inclusive, and capable of bringing people together rather than deepening division. Yet many of those who gave evidence expressed uncertainty about how the memorialization provisions under part four of the Act will actually operate in practice.
So questions remain about who will lead this work, how independence will be guaranteed, and what projects will ultimately receive support. Amendment NC54 asks the government to do something entirely reasonable. It would require the Secretary of State within six months of Royal Assent to set out how these provisions will be implemented, how designated persons will be appointed, and which projects will receive government funding. And those are not minor administrative details. Public confidence depends upon them.
For many families, the legacy of the troubles is not a matter of history, but of lived experience. Reconciliation cannot be achieved through legislation alone; it requires trust, engagement, and confidence in the process. But, Madam Chair, families are also at the heart of my other amendment, amendment 277. And it concerns a matter that may appear technical, but it is deeply, deeply personal, deeply personal for many of those that have been affected by the troubles. It too reflects a recommendation of our committee's inquiry.
And during this inquiry, we repeatedly heard that the impact of troubles-related death often extends far beyond the narrow family relationships currently recognized in legislation. Grandparents, grandchildren, aunts, uncles, nieces, and nephews have frequently carried the burden of loss, grief, and uncertainty for decades. The government has argued that the current definition strikes an appropriate balance by focusing on immediate family members while allowing others to come forward when no close family member exists. And I understand that intention. And I recognize the concern that requests should not be made against the wishes of the closest to those deceased.
However, family life is rarely straightforward. Grandparents have raised grandchildren, aunts and uncles have acted as parents. Extended family members have often been among those most directly affected by a loss. While no statutory definition can capture every circumstance, and we realize that, it really should reflect that reality as far as possible. The committee heard evidence that the definition of close family member should be broadened.
Both the ICRIR and the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission argued that the current definition is too narrow. Amendment 277 would therefore extend that definition to include grandparents, grandchildren, uncles, aunties, nieces, and nephews. As the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission told the committee, such an expansion is necessary to ensure compliance with articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. But ultimately, Madam Chair, this is not about legal definitions, it's about people. People who lost loved ones, who have waited many years for answers, and whose family relationships do not always fit neatly with legislative categories.
If we are serious about putting victims and survivors at the heart of this process, the framework must be sufficiently inclusive to recognize the wider family who continue to live with the legacy of the past. I therefore urge the Secretary of State and the government to reflect carefully on the substance of these amendments. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Alex Easton
Thank you, Madam Chair. I rise having carefully considered clauses 72 to 90 of the bill. And the test of any approach to the past is not whether it offers a tidy conclusion for government. It is whether it serves those who have lived for decades with loss, uncertainty, and unanswered questions. Does it give families a fair chance of finding out what happened?
Does it preserve evidence? And does it ensure that those responsible for murder, of whom 90% were terrorists, remain subject to scrutiny, however much time has passed? I am not convinced that these clauses have totally met this. Across Northern Ireland, families have carried grief throughout generations. Some have spent years seeking the truth about the deaths of parents, children, brothers, and sisters.
They should not be asked to trust a process unless it is independent, rigorous, and open to challenge. An official account cannot be the final word simply because it is convenient. Families must be able to question it, and where new evidence emerges, seek further answers. We in Northern Ireland know that the legacy of terrorism cannot be set aside for the sake of political comfort.
Despite the attempted rewriting of history to sanitize the evil of terrorism. In June 1922, Field Marshal Sir Henry Wilson, a Unionist MP for North Down, my constituency, which I have the privilege to serve, was murdered by IRA gunmen outside his London home after unveiling a war memorial at Liverpool Street Station. His name reminds us that terrorist violence has victims and that remembrance must be accompanied by determination to establish the truth. That principle applies to every family regardless of background. Opposing these clauses does not mean opposing reconciliation.
It means insisting that reconciliation must be built on honesty, accountability, and a confidence in the process, not on asking bereaved people to accept that the difficult questions have been settled for now. If this House is serious about dealing with the past, it must listen to innocent victims because it congratulates itself on finding a legislative solution. It must protect the possibility of further scrutiny and refuse to let any government decide that the search for answers has become inconvenient. Having looked at the clauses, there are some that have been improved and I recognize the on-the-run letters and that's good and I applaud the government that they're trying to get that right. There are other areas which I do still have concern and the member's not here for Birmingham Selly Oak, Selly, sorry, silly me, who made a very powerful speech and I was very taken by his comments about the Irish government and their bill that is going in process with ours allegedly and about information that will come from that bill.
But unfortunately that bill does not give a guarantee that victims, families, members of the security forces or veterans will get the answers from the Irish government. And I do think that we are being sold a pup in regards to getting all the information we need from the Irish government. And members across can sigh, but from experience from the Irish government, we do not get very much information ever and I stand by that. Recently, well many months ago, I got information from the past about a former member of the IRA, John Crowley, who did time for smuggling weapons into the Irish Republic and for trying to bomb London. In that information that I got, which I tried to pass on to the PSNI, where there was clear proof that this individual had shot a British soldier, the PSNI told me I could, they could not investigate it because it was legacy.
I was advised to go to the Legacy Commission and the Legacy Commission would not accept the case from me because as an MP I couldn't refer cases to them. The only course of avenue for me to get this case looked at because of legacy was to write to the Secretary of State. I wrote to the Secretary of State, the former Secretary of State, many months ago and I have not even had an acknowledgement of where this case is going or not going. And that makes me suspicious that something that I'm raising as an MP, which is a very serious issue about legacy, is not being addressed, yet we're expecting that this bill is going to answer all the questions. I do not think that the Irish government will give us everything we want on this.
Chris Bryant
Will you just allow me briefly? I will make sure that he gets an answer to his letter by the end of the week.
Alex Easton
I thank the Secretary of State for that, and I do appreciate it. But I do have deep concerns. It's not that I don't want truth. It's not that I don't want reconciliation. I've just had too many false dawns, and my colleagues and MPs right across Northern Ireland, we've had so many false dawns on this, and I just do not have huge amount of faith in this process.
And for that reason, I am unable to support the rest of the bill. Thank you.
Alison Suzanne Taylor
Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure to support the government in this important debate. For my generation, it seems as though the troubles were an intractable problem of the age. It was hardly possible for a week to go past without hearing about one atrocity or another. Growing up in the west of Scotland, we were aware of the troubles.
We had friends with lives that had been impacted. Northern Ireland, geographically so close, culturally close, but remote and unfathomable at the same time. That's why after more than 30 years, the Good Friday Agreement represented such a massive breakthrough. Many members will know better than me just how much went into reaching that agreement. Compromise on all sides, a willingness to move forward in good faith, and hope for the future.
The bill will continue the work of the Good Friday Agreement, and it does fulfill a manifesto commitment to repeal and replace the Legacy Act. It is about creating a mechanism that has the capacity to shed light on the darkest moments of the troubles. Sorry. It does so whilst being respectful of the families affected and provides a route to the truth in an honest and sympathetic way. I know that there are concerns from veterans and veterans' families, but genuine protections for veterans ensures that they can speak their truth with dignity and respect.
In my own constituency of Paisley and Renfrewshire North, we have many veterans who have served across the world with courage and distinction. Their service is appreciated. Nothing in this bill will detract from that service. It will ensure that veterans are not faced with repeated demands to provide accounts of events over and over again. It respects the operational realities that existed for service personnel at the time, and it respects the practical realities of being asked to provide recollections of events so many years after they occurred.
Madam Chair, I will conclude by saying, importantly, veterans' voices will be heard in a process not rooted in blame and recrimination, but in truth and reconciliation.
Sorcha Eastwood
Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to make some initial comments on the Attorney General. I will be clear, and I will be fairly straightforward in my opinion on that. I do not support that. I have severe concerns about where that's going to go.
Speaker 195
A political appointee and a member of the government to consent to the prosecution of serious troubles-related offenses.
This amendment matters greatly in Northern Ireland because it unpicks a key reform that flowed directly from the Good Friday Agreement itself. The criminal justice review mandated by the Good Friday Agreement was explicit. There should be no power for the Attorney General to direct the prosecutor whether in individual cases or on policy matters. Now that reform wasn't created out of nowhere. It wasn't in the abstract.
Sorcha Eastwood
It was a result of proven politicisation of the AG's power to overturn DPP prosecutions. A system that allows such disparity cannot be relied upon. And it is why the Good Friday Agreement sought to take the power away. New clause 50 would give it back. Our concerns around this amendment are therefore not theoretical.
They are based on past experience. Experience that the Good Friday Agreement had to rectify. This power for the AG cannot be allowed to return. I just want to make some wider points. I made the point yesterday along with many others that this can't be a debate about victims versus veterans.
But I note that there are still some veterans in the gallery. And I just want to reiterate whenever I have this last chance to do so before we lose this and it goes to the other place. I would posit a different version of events. We heard some really excellent remarks from the member for Sunderland Central and the member for Kirkintilloch and Cumbernauld hit on the same theme yesterday. Many of the people that came to Northern Ireland to serve were teenagers or they were people from largely working-class communities.
People who sometimes have told me that they felt uncomfortable in another part of the UK in terms of how they were expected to often react to events or some of the conversation and chat around them and amongst them or even about them. And there's something here and I think it was the right honourable member for Goole and Pocklington earlier whenever he was referencing the operation at Loughgall and he said it had been approved by the GOC. Now there's something to consider. I know that there has been some ground gained in terms of the contemporisation of the operational environment in which people served in both the UDR, the British Army and the RUC and for that I have the absolute and utmost sympathy. But we're not going to have a situation if it arises where it's going to be the GOC in the dock, are we?
That's just not going to happen. And I'm not sure that that's actually correct or accurate or fair. I do want to have my final say on this around veterans because there is a concept here of natural justice at play. And we shouldn't seek to suppress that. We shouldn't seek to make that dirty.
We shouldn't seek to make that something that should be at odds with every other member of society. But where I depart from some others is that there has been an element here of something that has entered this discourse and I've been involved with veterans for many, many years. And this is something that's entered the discourse recently. And I made the point yesterday and I'll make it again today. There is some sort of thesis here that seeks to suggest that people who served inherently did something wrong.
Something wrong that could lead to the so-called knock on the door 10, 20, 30 years later.
Will the honourable member give way?
Speaker 196
Thank, I thank the honourable lady for giving way. I have many veterans in my constituency, some of whom have come to talk to me and I'd like to just quote from one, a chap called Michael Kingscote. And he said, there must come a point at which the country says to those who served, you did your duty, the state sent you there, the state must not abandon you decades later. I believe that is the very point.
Sorcha Eastwood
I really thank the honourable lady for her intervention and I think that's one that a lot of members will have sympathy with. And I think it builds actually on the point that I sought to make yesterday because to me this is completely related and it is around the national security veto. We know for a fact that through disclosure in other troubles legacy related cases that actually some people involved within the security services, within the security forces at the time have said, we are being forced to redact or stop disclosure of information that frankly in the court of public opinion makes things look a hell of a lot worse than what they are. In fact, it contributes to an ongoing narrative that takes me back to the original point that I was making before the intervention around this sort of inherent thesis that everyone who served at some stage did something wrong. I don't think that is the case.
In fact, I know for certain that it isn't. But as I said yesterday, we cannot have a scenario that just because you wore a uniform means that any wrongdoing should not be investigated. And actually, it's veterans who have made that point to me, veterans themselves. And I'll reference one of them, David Crabbe, who was in this building yesterday with the Commission for Victims and Survivors in Northern Ireland and has contributed such a huge wealth of experience. In fact, I'll mention another one, a constituent of mine, Mary Moreland, a veteran in her own right, her husband shot dead, murdered in cold blood by the IRA.
And if she is prepared to support this bill, imperfect and all as it is, well then so am I. Because this is the last chance saloon. And I want it to be known and I want it to be on the official record that there were some seriously insidious and disgusting things that went on across all sides. And that includes the government. And that's uncomfortable.
And that's uncomfortable for me to say because I was brought up and I'm going to use the allegory of Loughgall that the honourable right honourable member for Foyle and Pontypool referred to. And it was this piece, IRA men arrive up, wanting to take life, wanting to murder those who were serving the state to stand against the terrorists. Yep, okay, I think we can agree with that. I think most of us in the chamber today can, can agree with that in terms of what they were trying to do to stop terrorism. But here's where that allegory becomes extremely complicated and where I think we do need to have a process and inquests and inquiries.
Because there was one innocent civilian murdered in that operation and his name was Anthony Hughes. And that was replicated right across Northern Ireland. It is not black and white. It is shades of grey. And it feeds into why I oppose the role of the AG in this.
Because what we can do for all citizens, every single person, is make sure that the law itself is our servant, that it serves everybody.
And I think it's a well-known fact and it shouldn't be controversial to state in this House that frankly there have been others who have been in previous governments who have tarnished the justice system, who have made attempts to do shoddy side deals, which is why the issue of making sure that it was absolutely beyond all doubt the on-the-run letters were null and void. That was an injustice to the court of public opinion that needed corrected. And I really appreciate the government for working with me over the last year on that and indeed other honourable members on this side of the House who have sought to make the same point. But there is something there where we will never ever know the extent to what went on unless we have a full and complete and utter inclusion of the law for everybody as it should be. That will involve the government owning up to some pretty insidious things.
And I actually think it was the honourable member for Northumberland yesterday who's a colleague of mine in the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee that said I want to start by saying sorry. And it was actually a former Taoiseach that said the exact same thing to me. Should we start by saying sorry? And I actually don't think that's a bad place to start because I know some people will and they recognise this themselves, but it is not the role of this House to stop them in the attempt, but they recognise themselves through the passage of time, through everything else that it will be highly unlikely that they will get any sort of justice through the criminal proceedings. But they want that acknowledgement.
I think sorry is a good place to start, but it can only be done if we have the truth. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Andy McDonald
Thank you, Mrs Noakes, and it's an absolute pleasure to follow the honourable lady opposite for her eloquence and her advocacy. She communicates that with such power and conviction and sense, and I want to thank her for what she has said. And I want to thank all honourable members and right honourable members and gallant members for the incredible contributions that have been made over the last two days. People have come to this vexed and troubling issue with a great deal of commitment and determination to get to the right outcome for a better future and a better understanding of the past. So I thank her for that.
I wasn't born in Northern Ireland. I don't live there, but my grandparents are from Belfast, a Protestant and a Catholic who left for the perfect peaceful idyll that is the west of Scotland. And my maternal great-grandparents from Carrickmacross in County Monaghan, and my wife's family are from Tyrone, all of them. And that part of the world supplied the working-class labour that brought about the burgeoning iron and steel industry. So our connections and associations with the island of Ireland are deep, and there's a passion for people to see a positive outcome and resolution and to include the many working-class men who found themselves at those tender years on the streets in Northern Ireland.
So I thank her for all of all of that. And I do welcome this bill as an important improvement on the previous government's deeply flawed Legacy Act.
Repealing the conditional amnesty scheme and restoring civil proceedings are significant steps towards delivering truth, justice and accountability. And I recognize the vital importance of treating former service personnel fairly, including acknowledging the extraordinary difficult circumstances in which many served. I had the pleasure to be one of the founding members of the Royal British Legion Solicitors Pro Bono Group, and I have worked with service personnel at close quarters, and I am overwhelmed and overawed by their commitment and their dedication to their duty. And I think it's been said in recent hours in this debate that nobody is questioning the performance of our service personnel who found themselves in that situation, and it is not veterans against civilians. And I met with two senior retired army officers last month, Lieutenant Colonel Reverend Nicholas Mercer and Brigadier John Donnelly CBE, thanks to Amnesty International and the Center for Military Justice.
But both challenged the suggestion that British forces have faced a flood of vexatious litigation under the European Convention of Human Rights. And I do worry about the scaremongering that's been been perpetrated in that regard. And as Nicholas Mercer has argued, the application of the Human Rights Act is vital because it means that the guilty can be held accountable and the innocent exonerated. That's an important principle. Human rights protections are not the enemy of fair treatment for veterans.
They're part of what makes that fairness possible. And I must express my concerns at the the government's chosen to publish such a voluminous package of amendments with barely seven days notice, giving us just two days to consider them. That's a concern. And I am concerned about some of the tonality, which have explicitly presented this as providing additional legal protections and safeguards for veterans. Whatever the government's intentions, some of these measures may be viewed very differently by victims' families, particularly those who've spent decades seeking answers about the actions of the state and the circumstances in which their loved ones died.
What is presented as to veterans as reassurance may be experienced by those families as another barrier to justice. That matters enormously. The Secretary of State has a responsibility not only to improve the legal framework for dealing with the past, but to rebuild confidence amongst communities whose trust in the institutions of the state have been profoundly damaged by their experience of the troubles. And he referred yesterday, I think I quote him correctly, as saying that the principle of the duty of candor will be imported into this legislation when the Public Accountability Bill passes. But I'm just wanted I'm seeking some clarification about the principle of the duty of candor.
Surely it is the duty of candor will be imported into this, not simply the principle, but I'll happy to give way to the Secretary of State.
Chris Bryant
Oh sorry, um just to be clear, he's quite right that the Hillsborough Bill, as most people think of it, um is still going through its processes in the House of Lords, as I've said to him privately and I'll say again here. And we do want to mesh together the candour the duty of candour into this bill once that bill has completed its processes in the House of Lords. It would be premature for us to do it now before the bill has finished in the Lords, but as soon as we have done that, I committed to the honourable my honourable friend who's sitting next to him yesterday that I would work with him and I'm happy to do so with him as well, um to make sure that we get this right. But it it's not just the principle, it's the concept. Um it's the duty of candour.
Andy McDonald
I'm enor- I'm enormously grateful to the Secretary of State for that clarification, that is immensely helpful. But yeah I revert to my point that this seeking to reassure one constituency, there is a risk of undermining confidence of others, not only in its approach to reconciliation, but in their ability to secure truth, accountability and access to justice. And more seriously, I fear that some of these proposals risk cutting across the detailed institutional safeguards established through the Good Friday Agreement and the reforms that followed it. First, Government New Clause 50 and the Attorney General's consent to prosecutions. This would require the Attorney General's consent before proceedings could be instituted for the most serious troubles-related offences.
And I ask the Minister, you know, what is the compelling justification for introducing this additional political safeguard into the prosecution process? It has been raised by other members and I join in that. It's not simply a technical adjustment. It does risk undermining a central reform arising from the Good Friday Agreement. The 2000 Criminal Justice Review specifically sought to protect prosecu- prosecutorial independence by removing the Attorney General's power to direct prosecutors in individual cases or on policy matters.
That reform was particularly important because of the history of political interference and concerns about the prosecution of members of the security forces during the conflict. The independent Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland already applies evidential and public interest tests when deciding whether to prosecute. Why should a further decision now rest with a government-appointed law officer, potentially exposed to representations from ministerial colleagues? The De Silva report into the murder of Pat Finucane documented political pressure on the then Attorney General over the prosecution of state agent Brian Nelson. That history demonstrates precisely why these institutional safeguards were introduced.
The amendment also appears to impose no requirement on the Attorney General to explain a refusal of consent.
While the availability of judicial review may be limited, how can families have confidence in a process where an independent prosecutor might conclude that a serious offence should be prosecuted, only for a government law officer to prevent that prosecution without adequate explanation or scrutiny? Ms. Knox, the Good Friday Agreement was not simply a political declaration of peace and reconciliation. Its implementation required detailed reforms to institutions, including the criminal justice system, designed to establish independence and public confidence. We have to tread with the greatest care not to in any way undermine the Good Friday Agreement. We should be extremely cautious about disturbing those safeguards, particularly where doing so risks reviving precisely the concerns they were intended to address.
So I urge the government to reconsider new clause 50. Fairness for veterans must not mean creating a new mechanism through which serious criminality could escape prosecution. Secondly, inquests and the closure of the Legacy Commission. Government amendment 50 would remove the Secretary of State's power under clause 85 to facilitate inquests after the Commission closes, and the Secretary of State has had an exchange with the member for Goulburn-Pocklington on that very issue. But for families, an inquest is not simply another investigation.
It is a public judicial process through which evidence can be tested, state action scrutinized, and the circumstances of a loved one's death properly established. The Ballymurphy and Springhill inquests demonstrate the importance of that process, particularly where families have struggled for decades to establish the truth. The government may intend the Legacy Commission to provide an effective alternative, but we cannot assume that every case will be resolved before it closes, or that new evidence will never emerge. Why, therefore, remove the power to provide for future inquests? Again, I fear that a provision presented as offering finality and reassurance to veterans may be understood by victims' families as the closing of another route to justice.
I ask the Minister how the government will guarantee effective investigations where new evidence emerges after the Commission has closed. Thirdly, disclosure under clauses 13 and 17 and clauses 74 and 75. I welcome clause 13's provision for full disclosure to the Legacy Commission, but that commitment must be meaningful in practice. The Secretary of State retains significant powers over sensitive information, including powers that may prevent material being disclosed to families. I recognize that genuine national security considerations must be addressed, but there is an obvious difficulty where the state retains the authority to prevent disclosure of information concerning allegations of wrongdoing by its own agencies or personnel.
For families who have already experienced decades of secrecy, that is not simply a question of legal procedure. It goes directly to whether they can have confidence in the independence and credibility of the process. I therefore support my right honorable friend the member for Hayes and Harlington's amendments 87 to 101 and the honorable member for Belfast South and Mid Down's amendment 65, which seek to strengthen the scrutiny of disclosure restrictions and reduce the scope for executive interference. Amendment 97 in particular would narrow the national security test by removing the words, quote, "risking damage to," or close quotes.
A speculative risk to national security should not automatically outweigh a family's legitimate interest in establishing the truth. Clauses 74 and 75 must likewise ensure that families can obtain meaningful information about deaths without the Secretary of State's powers becoming an obstacle to accountability. I conclude these notes with a broader appeal to the government. The Secretary of State is right to recognize the concerns of former service personnel. But reconciliation cannot be achieved by providing reassurance to veterans if the consequence is to deepen the mistrust of victims' families and communities who have long questioned the actions of the state.
Nor should we overlook how carefully the Good Friday Agreement and its subsequent reforms sought to address the historical causes of that mistrust, including through the independence of criminal justice institutions. The government has an opportunity through this bill to repair some of the damage caused by the previous Legacy Act and to rebuild confidence across communities. It would be a profound disappointment if, through the amendments introduced in the name of protecting veterans, it instead weakened confidence in access to justice and disturbed important safeguards arising from the peace process. I urge ministers to reflect on these concerns, reconsider the amendments and ensure that this bill strengthens rather than undermines the foundations of confidence on which reconciliation must rest. I want to acknowledge the views of the 200 families whose concerns were expressed in a letter published by Relatives for Justice and the Pat Finucane Centre this week.
The test must be whether this legislation delivers truth, justice and accountability on an equal basis, not whether it reassures one group while leaving others fearful that the doors to justice are being closed. That is the test that this legislation must pass.
Robin Swann.
Robin Swann
Very much, Madam Chair, and can I thank you for calling me in this part of today's debate. Reference has been made earlier on by a number of members in regards to the Stormont House Agreement and in regards to how we come about getting the Independent Commission for Information Retrieval. Can I just put on record that my party objected to and opposed the Stormont House Agreement because of the provisions in it that actually brought about an amnesty by default to all but murder, so therefore that was a flawed expedition at that point in time. But I will go back to the Secretary of State in regards to my earlier question about the Independent Commission on Information Retrieval and clause 72(5), which does say that the ICIR must not do anything which would risk prejudicing or would prejudice the national security interests of the United Kingdom or Ireland. C also says it would risk having or would have a prejudicial effect on any actual or prospective legal proceeding in any part of the United Kingdom or Ireland.
I asked the Secretary of State again in an earlier intervention, he said he would try to find out by the time I spoke, who makes that assessment? Who makes the assessment if something will be prejudicial to the national security of Ireland, or who makes the assessment that it would affect be prejudicial to a prospective legal proceeding in Ireland?
Because it's not the remit of this government. It's not the remit of this place, nor will it be the remit or should it be the remit of the ICIR, who we are as yet not knowing who the body corporate will be and who will actually be part of it. The Secretary of State said he would try to find out. I don't know if he has or if he wants to write to me. I'll give way.
Chris Bryant
I'm inspired. I'm grateful to him. So first of all, obviously national security is a matter for the respective government. So for in the UK, it's solely a matter for the UK. And the provision in the bill replicates the drafting from the ICIR treaty, which was signed by the Conservative government and the Irish government back in 2015.
And it also replicates the drafting from Ireland in their general scheme of the Troubles Bill, which states, in performing its functions, the ICIR shall not do anything that could reasonably be expected to prejudice the national security interests of the Irish state or of the United Kingdom. In other words, we look after our security, they look after theirs.
Robin Swann
I fully appreciate that, but that's not what this bill says. This bill actually says the ICIR will make the decision. I've asked the Secretary of State who makes the assessment on behalf of the Irish government as to what is national security. It's not solely about the United Kingdom's regards to that, but I'll take, I'll engage with the Secretary of State to seek clarity on that point because he quotes what was said previously. That doesn't explain to me what this bill actually contains because again, he does talk about the Irish government and its role.
And I welcome his comments and I've welcomed his comments in the past when he said the government would work in lockstep with the Irish government. And he knows the distrust that many of us have about actually what the Irish government will bring forward and when they will bring it forward. And I'll ask the Secretary of State then, what plans does he have if they don't? I know he's talked about the enactment of parts of this bill that will be in lockstep with the Irish government when they produce their legislation and actually enact it. But what happens if they don't?
Will he start to repeal parts of this bill or the parts that have already been enacted, will they still stand? I think I know the answer to that question, but it shows where we have that concern about the Irish actually acting in lockstep with the United Kingdom. Because I do see where the government is going on this and it does come from experience. It comes from experience of being involved in negotiations with the Irish government, Stormont House, Fresh Start, Haas-O'Sullivan, all those other things where I actually sat in a room with Charlie Flanagan and Danny Kennedy at that stage, who discussed what would come forward from the Irish government over Kingsmill. And there was a, he promised the release of documentation that the Irish government have.
And what did the Kingsmill families actually finish up with was a folder of newspaper clippings. And that is where that inherent concern still comes with many in Northern Ireland in regards to what the Irish government will release and indeed if they release anything in regards to a number of those substantive cross-border incidents that we still raise concerns about that I hope this legislation, I hope the Secretary of State with working with the Irish government is more productive than any other government has been beforehand. In regards to some of the other provisions that have been talked about by other members, it's, and I think the right honorable member for East Belfast raised it in regards to what in the previous iterations were put forward as protections for veterans. We were told at that stage that they didn't need to be in the legislation because the government said they were going to be there. And I welcome the fact that those protections now are part of the legislation, but they're not solely for veterans and I think it's important that that is clarified.
And I have asked the Secretary of State when we met him before in regards to those protections in regards to what would be there for veterans and in regards how they wouldn't be the first port of call, it would be to the Ministry of Defence, it would be to the corporate body in regards to that.
But what body acts on behalf of former RUC and police officers? He has said, and I do know it's in the bill, that there is a power within that to put a duty on a body, but there's no body specified in regards to that. So we're looking at a dual process in regards to what protections could be there. And I'm thinking about the joint operations, the joint vehicle checkpoints between UDR and RUC that often happened, whereas the UDR may get support via the Ministry of Defence, but there's nobody there to support that former RUC officer who was standing there at the same point, at the same duty, under the same threat and defending the same right of democracy in Northern Ireland. So it's, I would ask him to expedite who that body would be, because what worries me that it does fall then on those voluntary organisations who are currently stepping up, the likes of SEFF and indeed as mentioned by a previous speaker, the Royal British Legion, whose members are already going to seek those support from them in regards to that.
New clause 51 has been mentioned, and it talks about the on-the-run letters. It says that it will prevent the stopping of a prosecution for reasons relating to the content, still relating to the content of an on-the-run letter. Madam Chair, it is wrong that those letters exist, not that they can't be relied on any longer. So I thought it would have been better if the government had actually brought forward an amendment that actually nullified those on-the-run letters rather than simply saying that they will prevent prosecutions for reasons that are relating to the content of those letters. The Attorney General's role indeed has been mentioned in his remit in regards to this, and I've heard a number of opponents as to why that shouldn't be.
We do agree in that instance in regards to actually what was brought forward in the first iteration was a panel of judges to look at it rather than a political appointee. But I would say, and again, that that role of actually involving the Attorney General at that section is actually a replication of the Overseas Operations Bill. And what I would again seek a reassurance from the Secretary of State that this government isn't by default looking at the troubles in Northern Ireland as an overseas operation and that there are parts of this legislation that are starting to encroach upon that which would treat us very, very differently from the rest of the United Kingdom and in regards to the atrocities that were brought about. In regards to the honourable member for Wimbledon, the Lib Dem speaker, or the Lib Dem front bench, his amendment 12 in regards to reconciliation. Can I say to him, can I thank him for bringing that forward?
He has been a champion for that, and I do know that the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee are now taking a serious piece of work in regards to what reconciliation actually looks like. I think this bill has expanded the scope of who should be involved, who could be involved, not just in the work of the committee, but also the work of the government in bringing forward what reconciliation truly looks like in Northern Ireland, because it's not enough to simply put money into some communities or some community organisations or to support some individuals to encourage them to no longer carry out their activities of their past, but it's about bringing communities together, it's about bringing families back together. And it's to make sure that part of the conversation that we've had in these past two days, and it has been, I think, a respectful debate, that veterans and victims aren't different.
They're all people, they're all part of our society in Northern Ireland, and we should be working in lockstep with them as a government, as an assembly, and as individual politicians to make sure that their wishes are represented in this house. Thank you.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Madam Chair. Portsmouth is home to serving personnel, veterans, military families, and many who carry the memories of operations undertaken in the service of their country. I want to take this opportunity to thank all those who have contacted and spoken to me about this bill and the amendments, and to those who have served and are in the gallery today. Madam Chair, I was surprised not to receive more correspondence from local veterans about this bill, and I don't think that's because they're not interested or because they are fully satisfied what we've got on this bill. I fear that for some it's because confidence has been worn down over many years.
They have heard assurances before, they've been misled by those trying to score political points, and too often they've experienced uncertainty, repeated processes, and a system that did not feel that it was designed for them. New clause 49 and 50 in yesterday's amendments, I hope will start to rebuild some of that trust. And the tone struck by the Secretary of State yesterday, he recognised the important truth that peace without justice is not truly peace, but equally that justice must be pursued in a way that is balanced, credible, and capable of commanding confidence across the community. I particularly welcome the government's efforts to address long-standing concerns raised by veterans' organisations. Many of those organisations have quite rightly argued that there must be a clear recognition that there is no moral equivalence between those who sought to uphold the law and those who sought to destroy it through terrorism.
And personally, I am sorry for the time it has taken and the pain and the agony that this has caused. As the Secretary of State reminded us, we honour the overwhelming majority who served with distinction, not by defending the indefensible, but by being honest about the past. We must also honour, Madam Chair, our current serving personnel and those cadets and our future cadets, men and women who will serve our country. And although it's not related to this bill, I am moved to note that I do not recognise in my city or in government data or government policy the picture that the member from Fareham and Waterlooville painted. I am proud mum of a serving personnel, and the work we have done as a government to support our armed forces with pay, housing, legal changes in their court system, and so many other things about family life are not as she represented.
And those members are proud to serve their King and their country, and they are what we call patriotic. I want to add that I need to also set the record straight so that people can see, Madam Chair, that the previous government left a Legacy Act in 2023 which made false and undeliverable promises, and veterans leaving them in legal limbo, and it could have enabled immunity for members of terrorist groups. This was not okay, and they should be sorry for that too. Madam Chair, I know this government doesn't believe that there is any equivalence between the lawful service of our military personnel and the indefensible act of terrorism. And it is my Prime Minister who has said that we must sometimes put aside political point-scoring and have problem-solving.
And to be fair, Madam Chair, the majority of the debate in this chamber has been conducted in that way, and I welcome the contributions from across the house and have been proud to be a part of this debate. It is a challenging area and left unworkable, this government would have had to work hard to fix what was left. I would like to have gone further, but I do recognise we have moved in the right direction and I want to address some of those points. The overwhelming majority of those who served during Operation Banner did so honourably, courageously, and under extraordinarily difficult conditions.
More than 300,000 members of our armed forces served in Northern Ireland. They operated under sustained threat from terrorist organizations. They faced split-second decisions in circumstances that few of us in this chamber could fully comprehend. Any process examination taken during the troubles must therefore take proper account of the operational context in which those decisions were made. And I agree with my honorable friend from Middlesbrough and Thornaby and East, sorry, and I too am concerned about the number of amendments and the time that we've had to review it.
But I do welcome the government's determination to ensure the operational context is reflected in the legislation. I also welcome measures intended to prevent unnecessary repeated investigations in government amendment 240. Where matters have already been thoroughly examined. One of the concerns I hear most from veterans in Portsmouth is not opposition to accountability, but frustration at the prospect of being repeatedly drawn back into processes concerning events that have already undergone extensive scrutiny. Veterans are asking for a system that distinguishes between a genuinely new line of inquiry and the unnecessary repetition of work that has already been completed.
This is a reasonable request and one that the legislation must answer clearly. Most veterans, or many veterans are now elderly. Some have spent years believing that matters were resolved, only to face renewed uncertainty. Their families carry that burden. Providing clear safeguards against unnecessary repetition is therefore both humane and sensible.
And amendment 277 would widen that family members to nephews, aunties, uncles and grandparents. Consideration of the removing provisions is an opportunity to ensure that safeguarding parliament intended- intend- intent are clear, workable and capable of giving veterans confidence they will not face repeated investigations. And so in the words of amend- we see that in the words of amendment 240. However, Madam Chair, I would welcome some clarification from the minister on where this bar will be set. What criteria will be used?
What guidance will be published? How will veterans be able to understand whether the test has been made? And what assurance they will receive that an early investigation was properly considered before a new one begins? And when they will know how long until new evidence will be brought again? The manner of contact matters as well.
Veterans should not be cold-called outside of events that may take- have taken place decades ago. Initial contact will instead go through the Ministry of Defence so that the individual is informed and supported. Evidence may be given without travelling to Northern Ireland, anonymity may be requested, and decision-makers will have to consider the person's age, health and well-being. All things that were made important to me, and I'm good to see that the amendments were addressed with this yesterday. I would welcome their assurance from the minister that this support will be proactive rather than merely available on request, and that veterans will have a clear and consistent point of contact.
This cannot become a new procedure to be followed. Veterans and their families must be treated with dignity, clarity and care throughout this process. As my honorable friend from Belfast South and Mid Down so eloquently put, we must avoid framing this debate as veterans versus su- versus victims' families, because in many cases these categories do overlap. As Secretary of State rightly said yesterday, veterans have families seeking answers as well. Service personnel were killed- were themselves killed, injured and traumatized during the troubles.
Their widows, children and relatives deserve truth and dignity just as much as any other family affected by that conflict. No legislation dealing with the legacy of troubles will satisfy everyone. The wounds, Madam Chair, are too deep and the experiences are too varied for that. But I do believe the government has moved significantly towards a more balanced framework. I welcome the conversations I've had with the government, with the ministers and with my veteran community.
And although not perfect, as my honorable friend from Lagan said, it is a last chance and something that is needed. From the perspective of a constituency with a large community of veterans, I welcome the government's recognition of the unique role played by those who served, their commitment to ensuring their operational realities are properly considered and their efforts to prevent unnecessary repetition while continuing to pursue truth and accountability.
Madam Chair, we all know for too long it's been empty promises and words on a page, and rightly so veterans will and should judge this legislation not by the promises made about it, but by their experience of the system it creates. We therefore have a continued responsibility in this place and the other to listen to them, to explain the changes honestly, and to ensure that safeguards approved by this house are honored in practice for all that have been affected.
Jim Allister.
Jim Allister
Thank you, Deputy Speaker, part, Madam Chair. Secretary of State is not known for selling himself short, but I think even he would have to acknowledge that the bill he has produced and amended has fallen well short of universal acclaim, that it has unimpressed a lot of people and indeed a lot of interests. It's not that there's no good in the bill, but it's a question in many instances of the balance or the lack of balance that it strikes. And indeed I think one of the fundamental failures of this bill comes from the inherent preferences that the Secretary of State has made within it. The most horrendous in terms of the biggest number of victims of terrorism in Northern Ireland was the Omagh bomb.
And yet the Secretary of State has chosen to draw a line in this bill which excludes investigation of that bombing by the Legacy Commission. On the other hand, one of the most egregious and audacious IRA attacks was Loughgall, where the IRA with eight heavily armed terrorists came to destroy a police station with a bomb in the bucket of a digger and a vanload of terrorists to shoot up the police station. And yet the Secretary of State has chosen in respect of that matter to include it within the special category of those who will be entitled to full inquests. So on the one hand he excludes Omagh from the framework of this bill, but includes within this bill the most audacious of the IRA attacks to give to the families of those IRA chosen terrorists the right to have a full inquest, and then proceeds with an amendment to prevent other inquests. It is preferences such as that that the Secretary of State has drawn that causes this bill to suffer from the lack of balance and lack of appreciation and support across the entire community.
And when we think of Loughgall, there cannot be a more undeserving case for an inquest. Hardened terrorists, who had, as we heard from the right honourable member for Gove and Pockington, who had dozens upon dozens of innocent victims to their account of murder. Under the leadership of Patrick Kelly and Lynagh, one of the most notorious IRA terrorists that ever was involved, who had already carried out a carbon attack on Ballygawley police station and then on the Birches, and on Ballygawley they'd murdered police officers, who came at the particular hour when the new policemen would be leaving at the end of their shift, came with their digger, with their bomb concealed in the rubble of what was in the front of the digger, came with a load of terrorists to shoot up that police station and repeat what they'd done at Ballygawley and the Birches. And happily, yes, happily, they met the SAS. And happily, the SAS ensured they would never murder again.
And in that they saved countless lives, as that bunch of terrorists had already taken dozens upon dozens of lives. 2017 declassified documents showed that ballistic tests on the weapons that they had had been used in between 40 and 50 murders. These weren't boy scouts on an outing. These were fully armed, dedicated, hateful terrorists coming to murder and to kill. And when they were dealt with as they ought to be dealt with, what does the government do?
The government says, oh, within our legacy bill, we're going to give you a special place, a special protection, so that your families will have what other families won't have. You will have a full-blown inquest at public expense, will cost whatever millions it takes, we will fully legal aid all of you to be represented so that you can try and pick at the lawful actions of the SAS soldiers. That's why I say to the Secretary of State, it is by making choices such as that he has given this bill a bad name. And unless and until those inequities are addressed, unless and until some balance is put into this and you treat Loughgall as you treat any other inquest request and you send it to the legacy commission, which is the proper body now to deal with these things, then I say to the Secretary of State, he is but digging deeper into the loss of public confidence which attaches to aspects of this bill. So I do think that that is a fatal mistake within this bill.
It can be rectified. And I'm very pleased to support tonight the amendment 51 from the right honourable member for Gove and Pockington, which would do justice by removing Loughgall from the inquest parameters.
And that is what a self-respecting government should do who cares about the reputation of its special service forces. And I do say to the Secretary of State, it's not too late to do the right thing in that regard. Madam Chair, I also wish to refer to amendment 20 in my name and that of colleagues. Because in Northern Ireland we have this bizarre situation, and we saw it in one of the inquests, where unlike in England, where if you reach the point during the course of a hearing that it's suspected by the coroner that there's the possibility there was criminal behavior here, then he stops the inquest. He sends it to the PPS.
They make their decision and what happens thereafter with the inquest is determined by the outcome of that. But in Northern Ireland, you continue right through the inquest process, even though the coroner might think there's something here the PPS should look at. No, you carry on and you get to the point, and we've had this, where the coroner then issues his opinions, commenting on all the legal issues and all the liability issues, including the criminal liability, totally covering the eventual dealing with that in the proper way through the PPS process. So that's why amendment 20 says that we should replicate what happens in England and we should have within the inquest system that point where if you reach it and the coroner thinks there may be something here of criminal liability, he stops the inquest, he refers it to the proper authorities. Why would we not do that in respect of these inquests?
So I do say to the government that there is merit in considering that. But at the end of the day, no doubt this bill, with the overwhelming size of the government's majority, will find its way onto the statute book. Once discovered in this house, it's not about winning the argument because the government can always win the vote. But I do say to the government that they could take a significant step towards making this bill more palatable by removing the special status of the Loughgall inquest.
Euan Stainbank
Madam Chair, today I'm thinking of the service personnel in Falkirk and the veterans who served in Operation Banner between 1969 and 2007. Whenever I've had the chance to speak to them about this issue or more broadly about the issues affecting veterans and the armed forces and defense spending in my constituency, I'm reminded of the depth of their character, the depth of their service, and their overwhelming sense of duty. They are representative of the over 300,000 veterans of Operation Banner. I'm also thinking, as I think is the incumbent duty not just from a constituency standpoint but of the people of Northern Ireland, who especially for backbenchers from other parts of the United Kingdom, I do believe it's incumbent on us to remind ourselves must be treated as full and equal citizens of our United Kingdom, entitled to rely on the rule of law, our shared democratic institutions, and access to justice. But of our government amendments, those closest to my mind are those that strengthen the protection of Operation Banner veterans in our constituency.
We should never forget, as I think a few members have rightly commented on, that those Operation Banner veterans and their families are victims of the troubles as well. There is no false distinction that we should get into in this house between service families and an associated other of victims. And I think that is important principally because if we don't, it reduces the status of those murdered in Northern Ireland from the community and from our armed forces and impedes those victims' right to access justice. Now, whilst I'm aware it's not at this stage, I do want to rebut the point that operational context is not touched upon in this bill. NC 32 in the government's name, as the Secretary of State referred to, does require the Legacy Commission to recognize the circumstances in which our armed forces and police served in the split-second decisions they did take.
I would like the Secretary of State to elaborate a bit on how that will take into consideration the chain of command, because the question that has come up from veterans in my constituency and from members across the house. But I mean to speak very briefly to allow us to get to summing up on new clause 51 and 50, which I do think address some of the concerns that I've heard from veterans groups in our constituency. New clause 51 makes clear that no one can rely on an on-the-run letter in criminal proceedings against them. Of the issues that veterans brought up, and I want to touch on every single group, especially the excellent and fantastic Veterans Together Fort Valley, this was one of the issues that evoked the strongest anger amongst people. The mere ambiguity surrounding these letters and the idea that a scrap of paper could leave those suspected of a terrorist offense being comforted back to the United Kingdom thinking that they were immune from prosecution elicited anger.
And I am glad that it is this Labour government are decisively ending that ambiguity around those letters. I support new clause 50 as a member of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, in principle, that the Attorney General must consent to any prosecution for any serious troubles-related offense. What I hear from veterans is trust within the process is at such a low ebb amongst their community. And I do believe that placing the decision in the hands of a senior, democratically accountable law officer in this country checks, provides government accountability, but also provides the right degree of independence and accountability, and also enables us to build up confidence in the public interest of any prosecutions that are brought forward. I would welcome the minister, though, on that point, setting out in his summing up how this safeguard will support the government's commitment to protect the public interest where there may be a dispute about the high evidentiary bar and whether it has been met, especially considering the historical and complex nature of evidence that remains.
I would also appreciate if he could assure the house that the Attorney General's role is designed to prevent any political interference, so that no government now or in future can use it to politicize decisions that must be taken with the utmost seriousness of the evidence and public interest. In summing up, Madam Chair, I do believe this bill provides the last chance for many in our community, service families, to access the truth to what happened to their loved ones in Northern Ireland. Most importantly, I do believe it enables to implement real and tangible protections for veterans that the ineffective and unlawful immunity scheme that the previous government failed to deliver utterly does not. Therefore, as it represents a manifesto commitment to repeal and replace the Legacy Act, as it represents a strengthening of the position of veterans, and as more than anything, I believe it allows us to progress forward, I will be voting for this bill this evening.
John McDonnell.
John Martin McDonnell
Can I apologize to the House? I left the debate earlier because to attend a debate in Westminster Hall, which was highly relevant. It was the Heathrow expansion yet again. And 17,000, 17,000 of my constituents are threatened with the loss of their home. So that's why I attended upon that.
I just, I tabled amendments 106, 107. And they relate to the section of the bill on interim custody orders. I don't want to get involved in a debate about internment, its implications and the decisions that were taken at that stage. But I tabled these amendments because I'm anxious, I'm anxious about the introduction of forms of retrospective legislation in this House. I think it sets extremely dangerous precedent.
And it is contrary to the ECHR Article 7. If I can just read into the record the article itself. It says, no punishment without law. No one shall be held guilty of any criminal offense on account of any act or omission which does not, did not constitute a criminal offense under national or international law at the time when it was committed. Nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than the one that was applicable at the time the criminal offense was committed.
And this article should not prejudice the trial and punishment of any person for any act or omission which at the time when it was committed was criminal according to the general principles of law recognized by civilized society, civilized nations. So I find it very difficult to understand how this clause within the bill, these two clauses within the bill that have been set out, actually comply with Article 7. And the reason I say that is because once you start setting precedents like this, they can be used in other legislation, other matters. And I just refer members to the House to the section in the clause 89, which is bizarre to say the least. It says, this section is to be treated as always having had effect.
So we're inventing a historical precedent here. And we're literally creating, well, we're creating a truth when there is actually an untruth within the legislation itself. So I just raise that as a point that I think we need to guard against retrospective legislation on all occasions. It does fly in the face of the ECHR. And I'll be interested to know what the, how the government actually squares that argument and also at the same time considers it won't be open to challenge at a later date.
Chris Bryant
And, and Minister indeed. Thank you very much, Ms. Nokes. It's very good to see you in the chair as always. First of all, can I just refer to the points where I think we are all agreed? And there has been remarkably quite a lot of agreement both yesterday and today on a series of things.
First of all, on the, on the issue of on-the-run letters. I note the point that was made by the Shadow Secretary earlier on today and his gratitude for putting this finally in legislation. And this is a matter that has been raised by several honorable members. Secondly, I'm grateful to those who've agreed that it's important that we're not going to start any new inquests once the Legacy Commission has completed its work. The Legacy Commission will have five years in which people can still make applications to it and five years to complete its work.
But at the end of that period, it surely must be right that we aren't then going to be starting any more inquests. I think there has to come a time at which this process comes to an end. I'm also grateful to everybody who has recognized that we are wanting to work in lockstep with the Irish government. Not running ahead of them, not running behind them, but working in lockstep with them. Because it's only when we get full cooperation between the two governments that we are going to be able to deliver the kind of answers that lots of honorable members have been referring to.
I understand that there's skepticism around the House. The honorable gentleman who is chuntering from the front bench again, he is full of skepticism on nearly everything I think related to this government.
And in fact, I sometimes think when I see him sitting there, I think he could probably have a row with himself if he was stuck inside a cardboard box all on his own. But on these occasions, there are quite a few things where we agree together, and I think that's where I am trying to start my remarks today. I also want to agree with the honourable member for Wimbledon, who is right. I think these debates yesterday and today have proceeded much more amicably and respectfully than people perhaps had anticipated. And I think that that's probably because they've been informed by many different perspectives.
Those who have been around for many years in this house and have served, those who have never served before, those who have direct experience of living in Northern Ireland, and those who have many constituents who have served in Northern Ireland. Many different perspectives and many different political perspectives. And I think that, and that's important. But of course, it does, in the words of her late majesty, it does mean that sometimes recollections may vary. And I've heard various different accounts of almost identical occasions today from different perspectives.
And I think that that has informed our debate rather than undermined it, because in the end, what I and I know my predecessor have been very keen to achieve, and the whole government is very keen to achieve, is a balanced piece of legislation. My honourable friend, the my fellow minister, has been talking to others whilst I've been here in the chamber. She's been talking to people in some of the other armed forces associations. And one of the points that several of them have made is that they just want it to be fair and balanced. And as I said to my honourable friend for Aldershot earlier, and I say too to our three friends who are sitting at the back there, I do very much want to continue this process of making sure that we end up with a fair and balanced piece of legislation that ends up on the statute books.
And I guarantee to work with them, and I'll guarantee to work with anybody across the house to try and achieve that. And I think the other point that has been made by several honourable members, and I completely agree, is that everybody should be treated equally under the law. It is, after all, a fundamental principle of the of our rule of law in the United Kingdom. There are other parts of it, the separation of powers and so on, but the fact that everybody should be treated equally under the law is a fundamental principle that we all agree on. Now, there are things where we disagree.
And one of these relates to the Omagh inquiry. And I note the points that the honourable member has made from Belfast East. We actually decided on this subject yesterday. And as you know, Ms Nokes, it's impossible for the house to decide twice in a single session on the same subject. So we've already decided on this matter on the date in relation to the bill.
But I would just say that there is an inquiry, a public inquiry on the Omagh bombing. And it specifically sets out in its terms of reference that the adequacy of the policies and practices of UK state authorities, including the police, security forces, and intelligence and security agencies, in sharing intelligence between themselves and with the authorities in the Republic of Ireland on the activities of those dissident republican terrorists who have been involved in terrorist attacks or attempted terrorist attacks in the period from the 1st of December 1997 to the Omagh bombing, that is all part of the terms of reference, along with any other matters which are relevant to whether the Omagh bombing on the 15th of August 1998 could have been prevented by UK state authorities.
To the extent it is relevant to the issue of preventability by UK state authorities, this may include information sharing and investigations with and by state authorities in the Republic of Ireland. In other words, the terms of reference of the inquiry make specific reference to whether the sharing of information by the Irish authorities could have helped to prevent the Omagh bombing. Of course, I give way to the honourable gentleman.
Gavin Robinson
Very grateful to the Secretary of State again, but he misses the point. All of that information sharing, which is permitted and is in their gift, is to answer the question before the inquiry, which is whether UK state authorities could have prevented the atrocity. It does not deal with the other side of the coin, with information that could point to whether the Irish authorities had information that could have prevented the atrocity. That can be dealt with in one of two ways: a parallel inquiry in the south, which is before the courts today again because of refused to give it, or at least allow the fail-safe mechanism that the Legacy Commission could consider this case. Now, the reason it's raised today, because he's right that it was for yesterday, Ms Nokes, he's right, he raised it because he recognised the cross-border nature of the Legacy Commission's ability to take information from the Irish government.
Chris Bryant
Well, I think we're re-litigating a case that was decided yesterday, as I've already said. But the honourable member for Antrim North earlier made an argument that our bill was unbalanced because somehow or other we were de-prioritising the situation in Omagh. There's actually a public inquiry into the Omagh bombing, and I think it would be inappropriate to be putting this into the Legacy Commission because it is important that we let the independent inquiry do its work, just like the inquiry into the killing of Pat Finucane and the killing of Robert Hamill, which recently published its findings after a very long period of time. Now, Madam Ms Nokes, the honourable member for Belfast East also tabled amendment 39, which I think he's intending to push to a vote in a few short moments, and I just want to speak to that briefly. I think this falls at the first hurdle because, as he referred to in his speech, it would be inappropriate for us to have measures that only applied to one category of people.
We do not believe it is right that only veterans can benefit from protection from repeated investigation. We want a legacy framework which, while rightly focused on getting information for families, does so in a way that does not needlessly duplicate aspects of investigations that have already obtained valuable information. That does not serve anyone: not victims, not witnesses, and not the Legacy Commission, which will want to ensure that its resources are used as efficiently as possible. The collection of protections that the government has put forward were designed following consultation with veterans, that is true, and were not included in the Legacy Act. All of these measures have been introduced in order to protect and ensure the fair treatment of any veteran who is asked to engage with legacy mechanisms, and for those reasons, I will be opposing his amendment number 32.
Now, the honourable member for, or my right honourable and benighted friend, the member for Goole and Pocklington, his amendment number 51, I think he's also intending to have a separate division on. And I understand the anxiety and the concerns that there are. This is one of the classic instances where there are multiple views on how we should proceed. But as he will know, the government has a long-standing commitment, it's something that we committed to before the general election and as part of our manifesto, to restore those inquests that were in progress but were halted by the Legacy Act. And we are intending to deliver on that commitment.
"The opposition, i.e. the Conservative Party, cannot pretend to care about the plight of victims' families, including military victims, when their actions demonstrate the precise opposite." "Respect for veterans and accountability are not opposing principles; they are both part of the same principle: the rule of law." We're not opening a new inquest into Loughgall; we are restoring the inquest that was underway as a result of being directed by the former Attorney General, Jeremy Wright, the right honourable member for Kenilworth, in order to comply with our human rights obligations. As he said in September 2015, "Following careful consideration of a huge amount of material, I have come to the decision that new inquests into the Loughgall deaths are justified." Madam, no, there are two other issues which I think people are intending us to vote on.
Indeed, one of the reasons for that is I can quote Andy Seaman, who is the brother of Private Tony Harrison, who was murdered by the IRA in 1991. He said, "My brother's case was shut down when the Legacy Act passed.
The first is new clause 7 in the name of the Shadow Secretary of State. I must say, I think this is a very... I understand the thrust of what he's trying to say, though as he himself pointed out, recruitment into the armed forces is up now for the first time in about a decade. It's up 7% in general, and the outflow is down by about 7%, all of which is good, and I don't know... I don't think anybody in the House wants to undermine the thrust to getting more people serving in the armed forces. I'm absolutely certain that he wouldn't expect us to be being specific about the numbers in special forces. But more importantly, his amendment is... is rather cobbled together in a rather bizarre way, and the idea of setting up a new person to be investigating into recruitment and the legislation on recruitment, as he's put it in his amendment, I think is inappropriate, which is why we're not intending to support his amendment.
Alex Burghart
The Secretary of State for giving way. I understand he's not going to support our amendment. However, I hope he will appreciate what I said in my remarks about the significance of there being pressure on special forces. Can he give a dispatch box commitment that he will establish a process whereby, for example, the Intelligence and Security Committee can be given regular updates on recruitment and retention within special forces? Yeah, this is... this is extraordinary... this is extraordinary... this is extraordinary...
This is germane to the debates we have been having. He shakes his head, but I would like to understand his explanation of why he won't make this small concession.
Chris Bryant
Because it's not germane to the matter that we're considering today. And I... no, it's not germane. I completely disagree with the honourable gentleman, and I would simply say to him that I think it's inappropriate to try and make some false equation between the legislation that we're considering today and the specifics of recruitment into the special forces. And if he's going to continue making those kind of arguments, I think he will undermine himself. So I would just refer the right honourable gentleman to all of the remarks that have been made in the press over the past year by senior generals and senior former members of the special forces.
He is not arguing against me; he is arguing against them. And I strongly... I strongly encourage him to reconsider. No, I honestly think... I know he's getting himself worked up... worked up... worked up about this argument. I don't think that he really believes the argument that he's advancing. The truth of the... I... I read it rather differently.
The truth of the matter is... the truth of the matter is that I have met with the Special Forces Association, as has the... both the ministers who are here beside me, spoken to a large number of those who have served, and... and actually they are very keen to make sure that we have a bill that is balanced and fair, and that's precisely what we're going to achieve. But I think these arguments, as one of my honourable friends said earlier in the debate, I think the member for Sunderland Central, I think it does us no favours when we exaggerate and when we seek to undermine recruitment into the armed... armed forces and in particular into the special forces. Now, I'm not going to give way to the hon... no, I'm not going to give way to the honourable gentleman.
Speaker 209
Order. The Secretary of State is not obliged to give way. Sir Chris Bryant.
Alistair Scott Carns
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. The reality is across the conventional force we've seen an uptick in recruitment and a reduction in people leaving on retention issues. That's the first time in 10 to 14 years we've seen an increase, it's a huge success. We've got to be careful of convoluting two things that are going on within some of the more specialist community. One is the Northern Ireland Bill, which whether we like it or not doesn't resonate with a large rank and file of the individuals within our community.
And then other inquests and inquiries that in some cases do. And what I would say is as we move forward we need to keep a very close eye on that within the Ministry of Defence. And I'm sure the Secretary of State will work with the Ministry of Defence to ensure we're monitoring it and putting remedial action in place should that be the case.
Chris Bryant
I think my honourable friend makes a very good point, that it's important not to conflate things which don't necessarily belong together. And I think being able to filter it through the different aspects of what affects recruitment is what really ends up delivering results. And that is absolutely the role of the Ministry of Defence and my ministerial colleague is sitting here and it's one of the things that he has very much in mind. Ms Nokes, if I just proceed with a couple of other things. So the honourable member for who speaks for the Liberal Democrats, the honourable member for Wimbledon, has tabled new clause 12 which I think he's also intending to push to a vote.
That amendment adds a new duty to promote reconciliation, which he imposes on the Secretary of State. And he wants the Secretary of State to publish a strategy for the promotion of reconciliation in Northern Ireland. I know I've tabled quite a few of these kind of amendments of my own in the past and never expected or really wanted the Secretary of State ever to take these on. And I suspect that this is a sort of probing amendment that he himself has tabled. The bill itself already says that in clause 11.1 of the bill, it already explicitly requires the Legacy Commission and its individual members to exercise their functions in a way that is consistent with the principle that reconciliation should be promoted.
And that's precisely what we intend to do. Ms Nokes, two other issues that have been particular of been of particular concern. One is the question of essential. As you know, we have stated we state in the bill that there should be no replication of a process that has or duplication of a process that has already been undergone elsewhere, either in a in an inquest or in the Legacy Commission. This is a really important part of what we're doing.
The previous legislation introduced by the Conservatives used a lower bar, namely the word necessary. We think essential is a higher bar. I hear the comments that people have made about them not being convinced by that and this is one of the issues that I'm sure we will want to return to in the House of Lords. The other point is around compelling new evidence. One of the key asks that was put to me on a regular basis was around making sure that before anybody could be interviewed as a witness or brought before the Legacy Commission there had to be compelling new evidence.
I completely agree, and that's precisely why that is one of the things that we have tabled in the bill. I think we've put it in the right place in the bill, rather than right at the very beginning. And then the final point on which there's quite a bit of disagreement is around this issue of the Attorney General. I know the my honorable friend who speaks for the SDLP and the honorable lady from Lagan Valley have both said that they disagree, and I hear other members pulling me in a different direction as well because they're not entirely convinced about this. I just want to make it absolutely clear that the Attorney General is also the Advocate General for Northern Ireland.
We are not seeking to undermine in any sense at all the prosecuting authorities in Northern Ireland or in Great Britain. It will be completely, it would be completely inappropriate for the Attorney General to bear in mind at all in making this prosecutorial decision any political considerations. The only thing that they are able to bear in mind is the traditional prosecutorial issue of whether there is more than a 50% chance of a successful prosecution and a conviction, and secondly, whether it is in the public interest. I think that by doing this, we will be providing a greater sense of reassurance that there is going to be consistency across the piece. I'll end with this, Ms. Nokes.
The honorable member for Belfast East and my honorable friend for Middlesbrough both agreed in one sense that there is no point in the bill swerving from to appease one set of stakeholders and then to another. And I completely agree with them. It is more important that we make sure that the bill is balanced and that everything that we're doing right the way through is consistent with fundamental principles. I want to pay tribute to our armed forces, not only the 300,000 who served under Operation Banner, but in particular the families of those people who were killed in active service, defending our peace and trying to make sure that people could live their lives in peace. I want to say, along with all honorable members in this House, thank you for your service.
I also, however, want to pay tribute to the families who lost people, both those who have struggled for justice over the years and those who have frankly stored their pain in their hearts without any complaint. I want to say to them too, thank you for your service, because that was part of establishing the peace in the Good Friday Agreement. I also want to pay tribute to the doctors, the firefighters, the nurses, the council officers, and the witnesses to the troubles, including the children who lost their parents and the council officers who had to find new placements for children of those who had been killed. I want to say to them too, thank you for your service. I believe that with our amendments, Ms. Nokes, this will be a balanced bill, which is why I urge all honorable members tonight to vote for our amendments, to oppose those that we are resisting, and to support the bill.
Speaker 214
The question is that clause 72 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. With the leave of the committee, I will put together the questions on clauses 73 to 76 stand part.
The question is that clauses 73 to 76 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. I call the minister to move government amendment 232 formally.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. The question is that clause 77 as amended and clauses 78 to 82 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 215
Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. I call the Minister to move government amendments 233 to 235 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 218
The question is that government amendments 233 to 235 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 214
Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. The question is that clause 83 as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Amendment 51 to clause 84 has been selected for separate decision. I call David Davis to move amendment 51 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 217
The question is that amendment 51 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
Tellers for the ayes are Lincoln Jopp and Aphra Brandreth, tellers for the noes are Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal.
Speaker 222
Order, order. The Ayes to the right 176, the Noes to the left 329. The Ayes to the right 176, the Noes to the left 329, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it, unlock. I call the Minister to move government amendments 236 to 239 formally. The question is that government amendments 236 to 239 be made, as many of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 137
Of the contrary No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. I call the Minister. Shh. I call the Minister to move government amendments 236... I've done that.
Amendment 32 to clause 84 has been selected for separate decision, I call Gavin Robinson to move amendment 32 formally.
Speaker 137
The question is that amendment 32 be made, as many of that opinion say Aye.
Of the contrary No.
Speaker 224
Division, clear the lobby. Observing the rules as normal, and you should be seated if I am standing, including on my left, seated if I am standing. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye.
Speaker 223
Of the contrary, no. No. Tellers for the ayes are Lincoln Jopp and Aphra Brandreth, and tellers for the noes are Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal.
Speaker 214
The ayes to the right were 117, the noes to the left 331, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock.
Under the order of the House of the 19th of October, I must now put the questions necessary to bring proceedings on Committee of the whole House to a conclusion. I call the Minister to move Government amendments 240 to 243 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 214
Question is that Government amendments 240 to 243 be made. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that clause 84 as amended stand part of the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that clause 85 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Of the contrary No. I think the Noes have it, the Noes have it. The question is that clauses 86 and 87 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No.
I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. I call the Minister to move Government amendment 244 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 214
The question is that Government amendment 244 be made. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. The question is that clause 88 as amended and clauses 89 and 90 stand part of the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. I call the Minister to move Government new clauses 49 to 53 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 214
The question is that new clauses 49 to 53 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. New clause 7 has been selected for separate decision.
I call the opposition spokesperson to move new clause 7 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 228
The question is that new clause 7 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. Division, clear the lobby. The question is that new clause 7 be added to the bill.
Speaker 227
As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. The tellers for the Ayes are Lincoln Jopp and Aphra Brandreth, the tellers for the Noes Harpreet Uppal and Shaun Davies.
Speaker 214
Order, order. The ayes to the right 179, the noes to the left 336. The ayes to the right were 179, the noes to the left 336, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. New clause 12 has been selected for separate decision.
I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson to move new clause 12 formally. The question is that new clause 12 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Division, clear the lobby.
The question is that new clause 12, Sir Desmond, be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Tellers for the ayes are Will Forster and Bobby Dean, the tellers for the noes Harpreet Uppal and Shaun Davies.
Order, order. The Ayes to the right 184, the Noes to the left 330. The Ayes to the right were 184, the Noes to the left 330, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. I call the Minister to move Government amendment 245 formally.
Formally.
Speaker 214
The question is that government amendment 245 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that clause 91 as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
I call the minister to move government amendments 267 to 275 formally.
Speaker 214
The question is that government amendments 267 to 275 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that schedule 6 as amended be the sixth schedule to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that clause 92 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
I call the minister to move government amendments 246 to 248 formally.
Speaker 213
The question is that government amendments 246 to 248 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that clause 93 as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
I call the minister to move government amendments 249 and 250 formally.
Speaker 213
The question is that government amendments 249 and 250 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that clause 94 as amended and clauses 95 and 96 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
I call the minister to move government amendment 251 formally.
Speaker 213
The question is that government amendment 251 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The question is that clause 97 as amended and clause 98 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
Speaker 233
I beg to report that the committee has gone through the bill and directed me to report the same with amendments.
Speaker 214
Under the order of the house of 19th October, we now proceed directly to consideration. No amendments on consideration. Third reading. Minister to move third reading, Secretary of State.
Chris Bryant
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move third reading of the bill. But I want to start first of all by expressing my very sincere thanks to the team who have been working on this for some considerable time. Daniel Thrower, Charlotte Brennan, Sharon Carter, Niall Horhey, Philip Shaw, Will Durkin, and the whole of the legacy team in the Northern Ireland Office. Also to the Minister for Veterans who is sitting by my side and the Northern Ireland Minister, and of course to the former Secretary of State who brought this bill in in the first place. I pay tribute to every single one of them.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we normally associate legacy with our inheritance from our parents or from our ancestors.
In some cases, that means wealth or property, or perhaps a family tradition that has been handed down through the generations, something that one family does differently from another. For most though, our common legacy is a positive thing, a sense of our shared history, our national pride in the things that we do phenomenally well, our National Health Service perhaps, our storytellers, authors, playwrights, musicians, our bravery in two world wars, our armed forces. But the legacy in Northern Ireland is different. In many ways, it's a legacy of division, antagonism, sectarianism, a legacy of violence too, a legacy of extraordinary trauma. Trauma originally of course in Greek means a wound, but it means so much more.
It's an open wound in many cases. It's the wound felt by a woman who lost her brother, an RUC officer years ago and has nightmares all the time about how he died. Or the man who goes to Marks and Spencer's every day and sees the man who he knows killed his father who served in the armed forces. Or the man who gave up his college music course to join the army when his brother was blown up and still worries that he's never lived up to his brother because he never found out precisely what happened to him when he was killed. Or the young woman who worries that she can't even remember her daddy who was killed when she was so young, she can't even remember his face and she feels guilty about it.
Or the teenager who sees photos of his granddaddy who was murdered by the IRA before he was born and sees it every single time the troubles are reported on the news. Or the family who still haven't located the body of the family member they knew was killed. Patrick Keefe in Say Nothing wrote this: "Perhaps the cruelest feature of forced disappearance as an instrument of war is that it denies the bereaved any such closure, relegating them to a permanent limbo of uncertainty." I felt this so strongly recently when I had the deeply sobering experience of visiting an ICLVR dig at Derryclone in County Antrim where the commission's dedicated investigators are to this day searching for the remains of Seamus Maguire. Seamus was just 26 years old when he was disappeared in Lurgan in 1973 and my thoughts are of course with the Maguire family as well as with the families of Columba McVeigh, Joseph Lynskey and Robert Nairac who await the return of their loved ones.
That's a phenomenal trauma that still lives in many families' lives. And the thought that even when those had disappeared they still got letters pretending to be from their loved ones was a particular form of cruelty. When people say to me that people need to move on in Northern Ireland, my answer is no. No one has moved on more than the victims and survivors of the troubles. They're not living in the past, they're living with the past.
And if it's not resolved, if people don't get answers, that trauma will pass on to the next generation. Now I know there are lots of people who don't support every clause of this bill, there are some who don't support any clause in this bill. But I would just relay the words of the Royal British Legion who said this week: "Veterans and those armed forces families who lost loved ones in the conflict deserve answers."
It is in the interests of the whole of armed forces community affected by the troubles that steady progress is made to ensure this legislation's provisions are effective. And in recognition of the fact that although much of the debate here has been about veterans yesterday and today, actually this is primarily about families. As Joe McVey, the victims commissioner for Northern Ireland said, as parliamentarians you have the opportunity to provide legislation that puts victims and survivors at the heart of the new bill and also provides mechanisms that will give confidence to victims and survivors who have waited too long. Their voices must shape and determine what happens next. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to explain briefly why this really matters to me.
Back in 1986, I was one of the first British people to be in Argentina after the dictatorship had come to an end. Many of my friends had been tortured and I knew that they'd been tortured, they spoke about it. And one night I went to a pub or bar with a friend of mine and he went to the loo and he stayed there for a very long time and I wondered what was happening so I went to find him and he was lying down in the cubicle on the floor in floods of tears because he said that the man at the bar who was standing next to us was the man who had tortured him systematically for two months several years earlier. And I said to him, how can you possibly know, you always told me that he was blindfolded throughout that. And he said, well the thing is that when somebody pushes your head down into shitty icy cold water until you nearly drown five times a day and when they apply electrodes to your genitals three times a day, you get to know them by the way they breathe, by the way they walk into the room, by the tenor of their voice and I know that man is the man who tortured me.
And I say that story, it's from a long time ago and from a different country, but I've met people in Northern Ireland who have faced exactly the same. People who have never had an answer. They've never had a moment where it's even been recognized in the public domain that what happened to them and to their loved ones actually happened. And so this bill isn't about one group or another. It's not about special favors for one group or another.
It's about honesty, candor, the pursuit of justice and most importantly truth. Because in the end it's only truth that can really set us free.
Speaker 235
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. Shadow Secretary of State Alex Burghart.
Alex Burghart
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's been a privilege to be part of this debate over the past two days and to hear some fantastic contributions from both sides of the house and from all sides of the argument. And you know, I pay tribute to the moving story that the Secretary of State just told about about one of his friends. We could rerun the overriding arguments that we've been debating for now two years at third reading. But I don't want to do that.
You know, I think the house knows how the Conservative Party feel about the bill, but I want to try and take things forward. I want to and to do that, I want to take us back to what the last government tried to do in 2022 with the Legacy Act, which set up the ICRIR with the intention of enabling people to come forward and give information that would bring some solace to victims and their families. Some of those victims were soldiers, most of them were obviously members of the public. People from all communities. And at the same time we tried to draw a line under the troubles, inquests and civil cases and so on.
And when the government came into power in 2024, as it had in its manifesto, won the election, it said that it wanted to address the ECHR's concerns with our legislation and it wanted to put public confidence into the ICRIR. And I know that I'm not asking the Labour Party to move its position on the ECHR. I know what its positions are and I know that it will put those amendments through. What I would say is that here in 2026, it is clear that the ICRIR as constituted by the Conservative Party is working. I was very pleased that the former Secretary of State in his remarks yesterday quoted from the first report that ICRIR have published about the murder of Rory O'Kelly, when his daughter on receiving and reading that report said in incredibly moving and indeed poetic terms, it had moved the family into a place of serenity and light, all anger taken away.
That is what I am proud to say the institution established by the last government has managed to do. And I'm pleased to say that in 2026, where we are now, there are 277 cases before the ICRIR and 123 investigations. We believe it is working. There are two issues that I hope the government will consider as this bill moves into the Lords. Two issues that the Secretary of State has touched upon.
The first is about this bar to entry. We have a difference of opinion on essential and new and compelling. It's very clear from the legal evidence that we've seen that essential is not the bar that he intends it to be. As has been said to us by leading legal advisers and a KC, any lawyer worth their salt can find new evidence. So there is no essential bar and the essential in the legislation at the moment is not defined there, so it will be expanded and contested.
With new and compelling, that does exactly what it says. It is a filter test that is already applied in the Overseas Operations Act. It is a legal term that has certainty. It's not subjective. The evidence must be new as a matter of fact and it must be compelling in a way that will impact the outcome.
So I encourage the government as we move into the Lords to consider this again because I think we're trying to achieve the same thing, but obviously we believe that new and compelling will be much more effective for that purpose. The second is on what the Secretary of State has termed rinse and repeat. And he says that he wants to see an end to rinse and repeat investigations and we would dearly like him to succeed in that. And I say this next bit in the context of at the moment the veterans' groups who have been analyzing and scrutinizing this bill do not feel that the legislation will achieve that and we agree with them. At the moment there are no veterans' groups who support the bill as it stands.
As Liberal Democrat colleague from Dorking and Horley said, the Loughgall itself, which was discussed so eloquently by my right honorable friend from Goole and Pocklington, is the embodiment of rinse and repeat. It was investigated in 1987, 1988, 1995 and in 2001 and because of this government's decision it will go before an inquest again.
This is rinse and repeat. There is a way of going of doing this differently, which was discussed by the the honourable gentleman from Birmingham Selly Oak, who I'm pleased to see in his position, was also raised again by my right honourable friend from Goole and Pocklington. And that is to put the inquests into the legacy commission. It is to put us take us into a place where everything is going down the same route. Now the the Secretary of State has rightly said that he does not want an imbalance.
But the inconsistency is an imbalance. And that imbalance was drawn out very powerfully by the honourable gentleman from North Antrim where he said we have the case of Omagh, but when we compare what's happening with Omagh to what will happen with Loughgall, we see a discrepancy that we have to call out. I raise all of I raise both of these issues, overriding issues, because there is still time to improve the legislation. It will get thorough and detailed scrutiny in the House of Lords. And I believe that although we would rather the government was not undertaking this bill, that if it makes the changes that were set out not just by the Conservative party, but by colleagues throughout the unionist communities in Northern Ireland, the Liberal Democrats and indeed from within the Labour party, this bill can be made stronger on its own terms.
Hillary Benn.
Hilary James Benn
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to thank my right honourable friend for the way in which he has handled these two days of committee stage with such skill and grace and understanding. Because the fact that the temperature and the temper of the debate over the last two days has been markedly different from that which we experienced previously is a sign of what I said at the beginning of my speech yesterday, that the government has listened and that point has been recognised. I want to join him in thanking the civil servants in the NIO and other government departments for all of the work that they have done on this bill. They are as fine a group of civil servants as I have had the privilege to work with.
I mentioned yesterday that the first time I my first visit to WAVE and Sandra Peake, that wonderful human being, sat me down and she said, Hillary, one of the things that you need to understand is how intimate the violence was in Northern Ireland. And the story we've just heard from my right honourable friend, indeed the stories we've heard from so many honourable and right honourable members over the last two days and the last 28 years is proof of that. But today is a chance to recognise that this issue can now finally move on. I said to the House many times, if dealing with legacy was easy, we would have dealt with it a long time ago. It isn't.
It's really, really difficult. It's really, really hard. And the last group of people I want to thank are all honourable and right honourable members on all sides of the House for the contribution that they have made because responsibility falls on all of us to get this right in the interests of the people who sent us here to represent them.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I echo the words of the Shadow Secretary of State.
It's been a huge honour to be part of this debate over the last two days. I've heard so many profound and moving and thoughtful speeches. It has said so much about this House. Can I also thank the brave veterans who did so much during Operation Banner to preserve the rule of law and keep people safe? Can I also say to every victim, I hope you find the solace you require, the truth you demand, and the justice you deserve?
These things are utterly important. Can I also thank the Secretary of State and his predecessor, the right honourable member for Leeds South, for the constructive approach they've taken throughout? We often disagree, but you've always been helpful and constructive, and that means a lot to everyone in this House. Sadly, we will not be supporting this bill because, in our view, it still does not do enough to protect veterans. It does not do enough to promote reconciliation and justice for victims.
And because of that reason, we hope more will happen as its passage in the other place. Much can be done to improve this bill, and I hope the government is still listening. Thank you.
Speaker 237
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division. Clear the lobby.
Speaker 214
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The tellers for the ayes are Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal. The tellers for the noes, Lincoln Jopp and Aphra Brandreth.
Speaker 214
The Ayes to the right were 330, the Noes to the left 178, so the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. Motion number three on housing, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 214
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number four on housing, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 213
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number five on social security, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 213
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number six on social security, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 239
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number seven on excise, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 213
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number eight on business of the House, 21st of October, Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 238
The question is as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.
Speaker 213
Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Point of order. Point of order, Steve Darling.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier today at oral questions, the Minister gave the impression that I'd already had a discussion with her in respect of a fine notice and a CQC notice when, in fact, they had not been issued by the time I met with her on the 9th of September.
Matthew Stephen Darling
I'm concerned that the Minister could have inadvertently misled the chamber. I'd welcome some guidance from the Speaker on this matter.
Speaker 213
I'm grateful to the honorable member for giving notice of his point of order. He will know that the chair is not responsible for ministers' remarks in the chamber, but I'm sure that the Treasury bench has heard his comments and if a correction is needed, one will be made. Petition, Jerome Mayhew.
Jerome Mayhew
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fakenham needs a banking hub. It's a vibrant market town. It's got about 80 high street businesses as well as light industrial and manufacturing concerns. And it's the economic hub that services more than 17,000 adults and their children.
But all of the banks have left with the exception of Nationwide. So this petition, together with a separate petition by Councillor Liz Vickers, supported by Councillor Christopher Cushing and more than 1470 residents, requests that the House of Commons urges the government to take immediate action to ensure face-to-face banking services are available in Fakenham through a banking hub.
Richard Fuller
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I through you thank Mr. Speaker for his permission for me to speak on a matter that is of crucial importance to my constituents. And the topic for the adjournment debate is the impact of the East West Rail Bedford to Cambridge business case on North Bedfordshire constituency. And I'm very grateful for the Minister for being in his place. And I didn't have a chance, Madam Deputy Speaker, to share some of my questions, so I'm very happy for the Minister to write to me afterwards if he doesn't have answers to those.
May I start by saying what does East West Rail mean to North Bedfordshire? Well, it's an opportunity, Madam Deputy Speaker, that was lost in concept. The idea of connecting Oxford through Milton Keynes to Bedford to Cambridge is a sensible concept. Sadly, it is a concept that in practice has gone very far off track. And part of that going off track was because of a legacy of the former Liberal Democrat mayor of Bedford Borough, who supported a route through the town of Bedford and then north through rural North Bedfordshire, which is long, hilly, incredibly environmentally damaging, and despite protestations, must surely be much more expensive than any alternative.
So that's left my constituents scratching their heads about why you would build a railway line in such a damaging way.
And since then, the actions of East West Rail, and they're good people, I've got nothing against the people, but I do about the project and how it is being progressed. My constituents across North Bedfordshire have been faced with a series of questions that remain unanswered, and increasingly those of interpretation from the town of Clapham, just outside Bedford, which will be cut really in two by the development of the railway, and will take a very, very sharp turn out of Bedford and go up a hill as part of the hilliness of this railway. And their concerns about having a green tunnel still to help it somewhat with the environment stay in abatement. The villagers of Ravensden and Wilden sadly are getting increasingly resigned to the fact that their rural landscape will be carved through by a railway. At Chorlton, which is a tiny little village, a substantial amount of land has been earmarked by East West Rail so that trains can pass, and finally onto the villages of Roxton and then to Tempsford, rumored to be, on the list to be, a new town, currently a village of 300 households.
So for North Bedfordshire, this is a very significant impact on the environment, a very significant impact on our rural life. But beyond that, the business case matters for a range of reasons. First of all, it is a substantial amount of public money in the billions that will be invested to construct what is an entirely new rail route from Bedford through to through to Cambridge. And as the Minister will know, here we are just a week from a budget, perhaps the third budget in a row when a Labour government is going to come back for more taxes. The Minister will know, and we certainly know, that looking after public money is a primary duty of us here in this House.
And so if there is a case where we're seeing waste of public money, it is something that requires additional scrutiny by as many as as can be done, certainly in government but also beyond. And yet, it has been a number of years since the last assessment of the economics of East West Rail was delivered by the company, and that was available for us to scrutinize. So it's been a number of years since that, and certainly that assessment at that time, well, it was pretty bad, Madam Deputy Speaker. And when I say pretty bad, I mean bad, bad, bad from the point of view of public finances. And since then, there have been dramatic changes, some that might help the case of East West Rail, many, particularly with inflation, that may move the other way.
And so my constituents are left in this position where they just don't know whether this is going to make any economic sense at all, and it starts from the position where it clearly didn't. And I don't think it's right that the people of North Bedfordshire should be left in the dark. I also, by the way, don't think that taxpayers should be left in the dark. And that's why I'm trying to, my purpose tonight is is to convince the Minister that he, that the government owes it to the people of North Bedfordshire and to taxpayers to provide right now, tomorrow will do, but right now, the latest updated business case for the East West Rail project. And the Minister knows, and he does, I know he covers lots of other forms of transportation and covers for Lord Hendy in the other place for rail, but he must know the importance that's been attributed in our rail projects specifically to transparency about the finances of these case of these project, railway projects, and not to wait till the deal is done.
So that's my key request of the Minister, to say that he's been convinced it's the right thing to do, he's convinced by the arguments of public money, that he will allow transparency on the business case.
It's in his right to do that, it's in his ability to do that, and I'm going to explain to him why he should do it. First of all, it's because this point of transparency was surely at the heart of the reviews that went into that oh-so-disastrously managed project of HS2. If you don't remember that, Madam Deputy Speaker, you do, Madam Deputy Speaker, I remember it very much so, and frankly the taxpayers of this country will remember it for a very long time. And quite rightly, governments of the day had two reviews, the Oakervee review and the Lovegrove reviews, to try and find out how could we improve governance of our very important rail projects. And so I'd like to go through some of that, because sadly it doesn't seem that government has got the message on these things, and I'd be interested to know the Minister's thoughts of that.
So in the Lovegrove report, and I'm quoting this as in response to a request that was made by local campaigners in July of this year for the government to release the business case, and in that, the annex, Annex A of the letter from the government refusing to release, said that while the outline business case is still being developed, releasing it now would, quote, "be misleading". And that disclosure would produce a chilling effect on discussions between the Department for Transport, Network Rail, and East West Rail. So let me understand this bit: providing information about the business case would be misleading. Well, who's it going to mislead? Does the government think that we are not smart enough to understand that numbers may change, that inputs might not remain the same in terms of their costs?
I don't understand what, do you think we won't understand the numbers? It seems to me an unusual defense to say that providing the British people with information about how their taxes might be spent before those taxes are committed somehow is misleading. And what's the chilling effect? I don't see loads of private companies rushing up to provide competing rail services from Oxford to Cambridge, so it really doesn't sort of hold together. And if I can just read something from one of these campaigners, it says, Lovegrove's, I'm quoting, "Lovegrove's account of HS2's accounting officer assessments in 2019 describes a department that kept spending money on an unaffordable project, quote, 'on the basis that a process to determine its future was underway', unquote, while systematically failing to make clear to Parliament how immature the underlying costings actually were."
He goes further, describing how the HS2 board's own information packs created, quote, "a veil behind which less good news becomes difficult to assess or identify", unquote, and that this was still true two years later in 2021. The consequence, in Lovegrove's words, is, quote, "that the civil service failed to recognize the scale of the remaining intrinsic risk and gave ministers advice that fails to give a good sense of the scale of the uncertainty". What's clear to me is that the lesson from HS2 is that it is in the best interests of the government to share information as a project is going through its evaluation about its financial costs, precisely so that government can avoid some of the mistakes that were found in the HS2 project. And if it was important for HS2, it's important for East West Rail even more, maybe not in scale, but certainly in terms of relative lack of value. Now, one of the ways the government assesses the value is through the benefit-cost ratio framework.
And we do have information this back in 2023, and just so I can give the House some reference, a benefit-cost ratio of less than one is poor. There's nothing below poor, Madam Deputy Speaker. Then low is one to 1.5, medium 1.5 to two, high two to four, and very high greater than four.
And when time is tight and public money is important, one would hope that most of those are closer to the fours or the twos or the threes. So where did East West Rail stand last we stood? Well, it didn't stand at four, or three, or two, or one. It stood at 0.3. So basically, it's a railway project that wastes 70 pence in every pound.
Now that's clearly poor. The East West Rail company then came up with a thing called the theory of change to push it up. And we can understand that, right? Other things, employment changes, bringing in new houses, etc. So that boosted it from 0.3 to 0.6.
So it is clear that this railway line, from the last time the public were given sight of the business case, that this is an extremely poor value for money project, something that I think should concern the Minister, certainly concerns me. And of course over time, the milestones for the benefit cost ratio got worse. Because in 2019, the business cost ratio was 1.1 to 2.5. And now it's down at 0.3, although, you know, potentially you can get it up to 0.5 and potentially over to one. So it isn't doing very well on an absolute basis.
Now an argument may be made that there is a social benefit to railways that goes beyond the financial benefit cost ratio. The government's kind of of all stripes, by the way, so it's not just this lot, I mean it was my lot before. I mean they've kind of carried other things in already, but you know, maybe you can stretch and say there's even more public benefit from it, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'll come to what that may be in a minute, which of course causes even more concern. But let's just take a wander down the benefit cost ratios for Britain's railway projects in the recent past.
Just so we can see, is East West Rail an outlier or is it part of the pack of the usual returns? HS2 originally was the benefit cost ratio was not 0.3, it was 1.5 to 2.3. HS2 phase one, that's the London to Birmingham part, that was a benefit cost ratio of 1.2 to 1.7, getting close but still four times the benefit cost ratio of East West Rail. Crossrail two, 1.7 to 2.7, way ahead. Bakerloo line extension, two to three.
Sutton Tramlink, 1.3. I challenge the Minister to find a railway project that is such a grotesque waste of public money as East West Rail. I don't think he will. And that matters. Because being honest about public money matters.
Being honest about what used to sound like a really good idea, but when you actually put your mind to it and you do the detailed work, it starts to look like a really bad idea. You really should have the courage, we need to have the courage in this House, the Minister, governments have to have the courage to go back to first principles and say, I just don't want to be part of continuing something which has started to look completely wrong. And year after year, I make the case to Ministers of all parties to have that moment of courage, to go back to first principles, their first principle being that they should look after public money like it's their own, rather than just fritter it away because someone else in the past said it was a good idea and perhaps that's where the consensus is and so we have to stick with it because someone said. Because that is no way to have our executive of this country run, it just leads us into all sorts of mistakes.
And so Madam Deputy Speaker, my hope is the minister will be that man of courage. And I look at him and I think I'm in with a fighting chance. There we go. So in that spirit, I've got some questions if I may for the minister and as I've said earlier on, I do accept because I haven't had chance to brief the minister beforehand that he will not have, may not have those answers to hand, but if he could write to me, I'd be grateful. So first of all, the government since the last business case which was produced, at that stage they used a discount rate of 3.5%.
That discount rate the Treasury has now decided to lower to 3%. As the minister will be aware, if you lower discount rate for 3.5 to 3, you will give more benefit, more credit to revenues in the future relative to costs in the near term, which is clearly the profile for a rail project. So will the minister commit when he publishes, hopefully tomorrow, the updated current business case or financial case or full cash projections, all of those three are options, I don't mind which of those three options he does, that he will on all those cases will ensure that there is a like-for-like comparison, sorry, so that he has provided the information so that a like-for-like comparison can be made. So we need the information for the period, basically we need the numbers for the period upon which he is discounting the costs and revenues so that we can make an assessment of what the impact has been of the change in the discounted, in the discount rate. Second of all, Universal Studios, a wonderful initiative coming to Bedfordshire, has an impact on East West Rail and vice versa.
So as I understand it to handle the structural demand, Network Rail has lined up an estimated 650 million pounds of funding to help with the extension that's required on track capacity, which brings us back to the decision back in 2020 when there was a straight, more direct route south of Bedford and there was going to be a station at Wixams, a hub station at Wixams. So now that Universal Studios is being built at Wixams, would it not have made sense to look at creating that hub station for Wixams rather than going into the town of Bedford and going north? I mean, this is one of the things that has changed very significantly. I mean, Universal Studios had 10 million passengers, 10 million visitors a year, Madam Deputy Speaker. Tempsford may or may not be a new town, taking a village of 300 people and building a town of 100,000.
Big change. Now one of the problems is that East West Rail, desperate to justify its business case, may want to take credit for new housing growth at Tempsford. Frankly, I don't think East West Rail contributes very much, certainly not in the near term, to the growth of Tempsford because that planning has been there for quite a long time, expectation for quite some time. So will the minister commit to ensure that the case for East West Rail is made to stand on its own merits rather than trying artificially and in my view wrongly to claim benefits from other measures such as Tempsford New Town.
So East West Rail has built part of its railway Madam Deputy Speaker. It's built the part from Oxford to Milton Keynes and it was opened to passenger traffic two years ago this month in October 2024. As the minister knows that since then there has not been a single passenger travel on the train because they can't work out with the union whether or not there needs to be a guard to open and shut the doors. So that's two years of a zero passenger revenue against expectations surely will have an impact on the business case. So will the minister commit to publishing an assessment of the financial impact of this failure to run a railway for two years on the overall financial case for East West Rail.
Madam Deputy Speaker originally East West Rail was to run trains based on diesel. Then it was proposed to be electric. Then it was proposed to be battery. And now it's proposed to be battery electric and diesel. Can the minister confirm whether East West Rail has finalized what form of traction it will use on its railway.
It does seem to me to be kind of critical to know how you're going to pull the trains along on the line. I mean I'm not a railway engineer but even I think that's kind of a basic. So I think East West Rail needs to be forced to make a decision on this and I understand they may want to transition but it really needs it. And finally and in closing Madam Deputy Speaker as I look to the minister who I trust to be a courageous man and a good man I want to ask him a candid question. If he the minister was given a proposal to spend billions of pounds on a railway to which he could say yes or no and that he was told the railway would lose money billions and billions of pounds and he was told that on a value for money term it would be the worst railway built this century and he was told that after 20 years of operation the company had still not decided on how to power their trains and that two years after opening their railway they still had not carried a single passenger.
Speaker 247
If the minister was told all that would he really give the project the go ahead.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first of all say I'm grateful to the honorable member for North Bedfordshire for securing this debate. I have taken a note of the questions he has raised. He'll be aware that I am not the rail minister and as he gracefully pointed out I hadn't got advance notice of those questions. Certainly some of them were more of a rhetorical nature than others but I will endeavor to ensure that the rail minister does provide him with a response to those.
But I'll speak more generally to start with Madam Deputy Speaker to say that East West Rail is actually a priority transport project for the government. It will significantly improve connectivity for the honorable gentleman's constituents. It will help unlock growth jobs new homes and opportunities across the Oxford to Cambridge growth corridor. As we know the corridor boasts a number of strengths. It is home to world leading employers and universities.
It has one of the highest concentrations of high technology firms in Europe. It is attracting inward investment as we've heard from the likes of Universal for its new theme park at Stewartby and in science and innovation at sites like the biomedical campus in Cambridge.
However, the corridor's growth has been constrained with high house prices, pressure on existing infrastructure, including the road network and a long-standing lack of east-to-west connectivity. These issues are perfectly summed up for the honourable gentleman's constituents by the fact that there are no direct rail routes to Oxford or Cambridge, and it is easier to travel to London by rail than it is to get across the region. This leaves people reliant on cars, infrequent bus or coach services, or not making journeys across the region at all. The government is committed to addressing these constraints to growth and East West Rail is central to our ambition to realise the full potential of that corridor. The remaining stages of the railway involve upgrading the existing Marston Vale line between Bletchley and Bedford, and constructing the new section of railway between Bedford and Cambridge, which the honourable member has focused his comments on.
These stages will be delivered from 2030 onwards and East West Rail Company has completed its final route-wide consultation on these stages in the spring. It is currently finalising its proposals for a development consent order application, which I understand will be sometime next year. As we know, the plans for the railway include eight new stations across the region, including at Tempsford in the honourable gentleman's constituency, and for up to five passenger services per hour. And it's not just local journeys that will be improved. The new line will have interchanges with major rail lines, expanding connectivity with the rest of the country.
And at Tempsford in the honourable gentleman's constituency, the new station will also be served by the East Coast Main Line. The East West Rail line will also be partly electrified to support net zero operations using hybrid battery electric trains, providing greener and faster journeys for passengers, so I hope that in part at least answers one of the honourable gentleman's questions. But all these new changes will mean a step change in connectivity across the region and will offer benefits to the honourable member's constituents. Now, the honourable member has raised quite diligently and not for the first time the business case for East West Rail, and the BCR is an important measure of value for money, but it is only one part of the overall assessment. So together with the strategic case for East West Rail, this wider evidence informs government decision-making.
And for East West Rail, there is a clear and compelling strategic case for the project in overcoming the constraints in the region, and in particular providing opportunities for new jobs and for new sustainable communities to grow. The line will serve potential new town sites that have been identified by the government in Tempsford and Milton Keynes, as well as supporting the government's aims to unlock development in both Oxford and Cambridge. We are already seeing investment being brought forward across the planned route, whether that's in new housing developments or indeed the new Universal theme park at Stewartby, and because of this the project has backing from major employers and institutions across the region, as evidenced by the support of the Oxford to Cambridge Supercluster group. Details on the case for the project were set out in the consultation earlier this year, and the economic and technical report on the project published in 2023 provided a significant amount of detail on the different options that had been considered to improve connectivity and on the case for the railway. And the honourable member has identified that that was some time ago and there have been a number of changes possibly further strengthening the case, possibly weakening it, as the honourable member has identified, but further information is going to be provided as part of the development consent order application and a full business case will be prepared once planning consent has been secured.
Richard Fuller
I'm grateful for the minister, and but just on this point about when the business case, he's not taken up my offer of releasing it tomorrow, I don't think. So if it goes with the process the government is hiding behind, will the decision to go ahead by the government, as well as the DCO from the planning point, have been approved by the time that case has been presented to the public?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful for the intervention. I think the exact sequencing of these things is something I would need to defer to the rail minister on and I will get him to write to you. But I think it is the case that the economic benefits and the business cases are considered in tandem with these issues. But publication will be issued once the planning consent has been secured and that is, as he will know, absolutely typical for these types of projects. And I hear what the honorable member said about transparency.
I mean, he's right, this isn't going to be released tomorrow, but it will become a public document and I can assure him that he will have his opportunity to make further comment on it. It is important though to state, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the benefits the line will unlock will come from the railway as a whole, and that's in particular the new section of railway between Bedford and Cambridge. It is important to say as well that unlocking the opportunity here is a key part of the strategic economic case for the scheme and it is in accordance with departmental guidance. Additional benefits that are dependent on the scheme will be included in the overall value for money assessment. The latest assessment suggests the East West Rail line will increase the regional economy by some 6.7 billion pounds GVA per year by 2050.
Obviously those figures will be updated as we go forward, but there will be significant benefits for developing the East West Rail line. And it's important to state that the latest plans will mean delivering services between Oxford and Bletchley and then between Oxford and Bedford ahead of the completion of the line in full. And this will allow services to run to the new Universal theme park at the earliest opportunity. But I did hear what the honorable member asked about the location of the theme park and I will take that back to the rail minister as well. But it is important to recognize that benefits that the East West Rail will deliver are not, it doesn't recognize that the construction is not going to have some impact on the communities that the honorable member represents.
And significant work has been done to assess alternative routes through public consultation. And that work has concluded that serving Bedford directly and enabling faster direct journeys from stations on the Marston line to Cambridge are a key part of realizing the full benefits of the project, which may be the answer to one of the questions, but that's something I will ask that the rail minister confirms in writing to him. But he will be aware that the East West Rail company has worked to reduce the impact of the line on local communities whenever possible. That includes impacts on homes, local businesses and farmland. And in its spring consultation, the company set out a range of ways it has responded to feedback in the honorable gentleman's constituency.
This has included moving and lowering the alignment of the railway to reduce visual impacts between Clapham Green and Colston and working to reduce construction vehicle movements and potential impacts on properties. I recognize, Madam Deputy Speaker, that there are an awful lot of other more detailed matters that the honorable member raised and as I have already committed to, I will ensure that the rail minister provides a full written response. And on that note, good evening.
Speaker 250
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.