Westminster Hall

4 November 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:10 - 00:17
Speaker 2
Order.  Jamie Stone to move the motion. 
00:17 - 02:19
Speaker 1
I beg to move the motion as in my name as printed in the Order Paper.  Madam Chair, I do want to thank all the many members who have come along today to this important debate.  It's about addressing the growing impact of rising heating oils on rural households.  And I'm very grateful for the opportunity to lead this debate.  It's an issue which is causing real anxiety, I would say the length and breadth of the United Kingdom and particularly in my far north constituency of Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross. 

And I would say that, in the Highlands of Scotland, for many people, the using heating oil is not a choice, but it's the only practical way of heating their homes, especially during the winter months when it's a lot colder in other parts of the UK.  This is because we know why, but just go houses homes are scattered across a vast geography and where access to the main gas grid is not really accessible.  In fact, it's not many access points in my constituency.  So, lots of households who rely on heating oil don't benefit from the same protections as those who are connected to the main gas grid and electricity networks.  This is a point that's been made several times in this place. 

So, the regulatory safeguards don't really cover these people and they're very much hit by sudden price increases.  Now, I my office tells me that across the UK, about 1 and 1/2 million homes rely on heating oil, and a substantial proportion of this number are in rural communities.  The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has highlighted that rural households typically spend 10 to 20% more on everyday essentials compared to urban counterparts.  They're also more susceptible to higher levels of fuel poverty.  This is because they are often in older properties, which detached, more difficult to insulate, meaning they're poor energy efficiency. 

As members will be aware, the conflict in Iran has caused severe disruption to our global energy markets.  I will give way, sir. 
02:19 - 02:41
Speaker 3
I thank the honourable member for giving way.  He's making his usual excellent, well-informed speech.  But does he agree with me that it's rather sad that given the absence of any support in the budget that people in our constituencies are now looking to the mid-term elections in America to actually lead to peace in the Middle East and a reduction in prices? 
02:41 - 03:19
Speaker 1
Well, the honourable member makes the characteristically interesting point, to say the least.  There may be some truth in exactly what he says.  But the price increases because of the war in Iran has lead to some households having their bill double or even treble.  Now Age UK has given me some stats.  Here's a couple of examples. 

One 80-year-old man with serious health problems saw hit the cost of filling his heating oil tank, quote, "double".  Let me get this right: from £400 in January to £800 in March.  Can you imagine?  Another household  I will give way. 
03:19 - 03:39
Speaker 4
I thank my honourable friend for giving way.  So, one of my constituents got in touch with me last week to say that she had to order a minimum order of 500 L of oil.  It had cost her £560 and she was out of cash for the rest of the month. 

Does he agree with me that we need to bring down minimum orders as well as look at issues that affect the price of oil? 

03:39 - 04:20

James Jamie Stone

I could not agree more with my good friend. Let me give you one more example. A couple in their 70s, the increase has been equally alarming. Their bill rose from 300 to £700. Despite one of them having suffered a stroke and needing to be kept warm for obvious health reasons.

Now, these are no abstract stats, these are real people, vulnerable people who are trying to manage their household budgets, pay the bills and keep their house warm. And in several times in this place, I've talked in the past about elderly and vulnerable people having to make that invidious decision either to freeze or to switch on the heating and worry about running into debt.

04:20 - 04:21

Will the honorable gentleman give way on that point?

04:21 - 04:48

John Hayes

I'm extremely grateful to the honorable gentleman, he's done a great service bringing this matter to our consideration. In my constituency like his, those vulnerable people are often in isolated communities, I think of Holbeach Hurn, Holbeach St Johns, Gedney, Fleet Hargate. Those people depend on heating oil and they don't enjoy the same kind of protection that other energy users do. It's as simple as that, the government needs to act.

04:21 - 04:21

I certainly will.

04:48 - 05:09

James Jamie Stone

The point is extremely well-made. And being as of a cheeky chap from the north of Scotland, I thought it would be wise to write to the Chancellor ahead of the budget to make the case for targeted support for heating oil customers. I a little bit disappointed that the measures announced didn't go quite as far as I would suggest, but On that point?

05:09 - 05:42

Speaker 9

I also thank the honorable member for bringing this incredibly time sensitive and critical debate and thank him for the points that he has made so far. Does he agree with me, similar to my colleague, that it was incredibly disappointing for the people in our constituencies who were looking to this budget to provide solutions for them that not a single penny of this budget has been allocated to support those who rely on heating oil? And does he further agree with me that the UK government should take lessons from the Scottish government who have implemented the emergency heating oil support fund which has so far helped over 7,000 people?

05:42 - 06:02

James Jamie Stone

Well, the honorable member makes a good point. She may be cornering me into agreeing with something the Scottish government has done, which doesn't necessarily go with the grain of my psyche. But put it this way, the United Kingdom government will be hearing from me again with yet another of my letters. I certainly will, with pleasure.

06:02 - 06:31

Ashley Dalton

I thank the honorable member for giving way and I agree with him that households reliant on heating oil including those in my constituency in West Lancashire face particular issues, particularly around price volatility and the absence of consumer protections that users of electricity and gas might have. But does he not welcome the government's previous £50 million investment in supporting this sector including working with Ofgem, the industry and consumers to bring forward and consumer protections?

06:32 - 06:32

Sorry, Mr Stone, there's a division in the chamber, we will come back in 10 minutes.

15:30 - 15:39

Paula Barker

Order.

We'll resume the sitting. This session will now run till 4:10 p.m. Jamie Stone.

15:39 - 16:17

James Jamie Stone

Thank you very much. Aren't these divisions annoying things? The honorable member for West Lancashire did make an extremely fair point, actually, and I have actually previously welcomed the government's previous commitment of, as she said herself, 53 million to help households struggling with soaring heating oil prices. That was a move in the right direction, and I give credit where it's due. The support was well meant, well was well meant, but the trouble is that when you think it balance that money against the 1.5 million homes using heating oil, it's only about 35 quid per household.

16:17 - 16:20

Speaker 8

I certainly will.

16:20 - 16:43

John Lamont

Thousands of my constituents rely on heating oil, and whilst the government has taken VAT of electricity, that does nothing to help customers on heating oil. The government's also announced the removal of standing charges for electricity customers, but again, that doesn't help heating oil customers. Does the minister, does the member agree that the government really needs to focus on these customers to ensure that they're getting the help that they need?

16:43 - 18:10

James Jamie Stone

I do agree with my honorable colleague, and I think hopefully a debate of this nature will gradually through goodwill on all sides of all political parties shift the focus, if you like, onto the sort of people we're talking about. There is also concern about the take-up, the actual take-up of schemes and the practical difficulties involved in identifying households. Age UK has highlight- highlighted the challenges facing organizations, local authorities in reaching out to people out there who do desperately need the help. So, I think we if we can all collectively look with the government to ensure steps are taken to support people actually getting what they desperately need. Now, turning to my own party's specific proposals, we have called for 3 month, 3 months of zero-rated VAT on domestic heating oil.

That said, I do appreciate that a VAT reduction would not necessarily reverse the international price increase, which is so bedeviling this issue. It wouldn't solve the underlying problem. However, it would provide practical assistance at a time when households are facing exceptionally high bills. To quote somebody who's more august than me, it would be a breathing space. For this reason, I do encourage the government to properly assess the cost and practical implications of a temporary reduction in VAT, and we'll see what comes out of that, and I would make an appeal to the government benches opposite.

18:10 - 18:13

Speaker 7

I will gladly give way.

18:13 - 18:40

Michael Peter Martin

I thank you for giving way. I mean, I'd like to support this idea of a VAT freeze. A pensioner a couple You know, hundreds of my constituents rely on heating oil. A pensioner couple in my constituency ordered oil at 60p a liter in February. The order dragged on, was cancelled.

They were told they could reorder at 124 pence per liter, so more than double. And whilst a VAT freeze would not roll that back, it would go a long way to helping these people out.

18:40 - 20:21

James Jamie Stone

Yes. Absolutely correct. And perhaps turning to my own experience of buying oil, I live in an old stone stone-built house in the Highlands, which its only source of heating, apart from the electric we put on, is the boiler, the oil-fired boiler. And people have raised with me issues right around price transparency, the whether the quotation is really what it says between the quoted price and the final delivery price. These are sometimes not always the same things.

And indeed, we don't seem to have a proper complaints process or redress process. So, for older and vulnerable people, the people I talk about who worry about whether to put the heating on or to run into debt or what to do, it can be particularly difficult to navigate. But I also welcome the government's acceptance, in principle, of the Competition and Markets Authority's recommendations and its commitments to bring heating oil customers within Ofgem's regulatory remit.

This would can only be a good thing, but I would ask for a clear timetable on this. Households have waited a long time. This is not the first time, as honourable and right honourable colleagues have noted, I've gone on at some length about this particular issue, so that would be handy. And finally, because a lot of people who want to speak, and again, I thank each and every one, Madam Chair, for coming along, we must look beyond the immediate crisis and towards a long-term solution. I think we would all agree with this.

It is not sustainable to simply respond every time international events cause heating oil prices to rise. We do need to make rural homes warmer, more energy efficient and cheaper to heat. I will gladly give way.

20:21 - 20:50

Clare Rachel Gilmour

I thank the honourable member for giving way, and he's absolutely right in what he's saying, because the challenge is compounded by the nature of the housing stock in rural constituencies. Friends of the Earth say that in my constituency of Tiverton and Minehead, 12% of people are living in fuel poverty and 62% of homes have an energy performance certificate rating of D or less. So would he agree with me that the part of the solution to this problem is actually making our homes more sustainable in terms of energy?

20:50 - 21:36

James Jamie Stone

I do entirely agree, and of course, as we know, some of the older properties are incredibly difficult to do this work to it. And I'm bound to say that if I just return to where I started, which is my constituents in the Highlands, in the very fair, far north, if in many's a household, if I say, "Well, what about a heat pump?" they sort of laugh at me and say, "You're joking, in this old croft house? This is not a feasible thing at all." So we have to be practical in what we can do. But I do, I'm very grateful for so many members turning up to this debate.

I believe it is a start of a discussion, which as we, I think we're all on the same sheet on this one. Let's make it happen. Let's see what we can do for some of the most vulnerable in society. I thank you, Madam Chair.

21:36 - 21:50

Paula Barker

I will be imposing an immediate two-minute time limit for speeches. The question is that this House has considered the impact of heating oil prices on rural areas. Torcuil Crichton.

21:50 - 24:00

Torcuil Crichton

A pleasure to serve under your chairship, and can I thank the member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for bringing this important debate before us, and pay tribute to the Labour government for putting heating oil on the agenda for the first time. Most governments have ignored off-grid homes for a long time. Now, I know the right the honourable member would recognise a peat turf if it were thrown at him, and peat is how most of the homes in my Na h-Eileanan an Iar constituency were heated traditionally, but of course most homes have now been converted from peat to oil. 48% of homes in the Western Isles rely on heating oil to heat their homes, but because of the conditions of the homes, old houses, because of the Atlantic weather, and because of demographics of the population, 40% of households are in fuel poverty. And, in fact, it's worse than that, because 24% of households are in extreme fuel poverty.

They spend over 20% of their income on keeping their homes warm in winter. Heating their homes is a huge challenge. That's why this 10 53 million, 10 million to Scotland heating oil support scheme was very welcome. The Scottish Government added of course 5.4 million to the 4.6 the UK Government, they had to do it bigger and better, they did it centralized. And the result of course is that none of the money is getting to the Western Isles.

Only 324 households in the Western Isles have received support, another 337 have been turned down for the credit. 3% of homes, nearly 13,000 households in the Western Isles and yet only 300 have had support. And the picture in Scotland is no better. 13,900 applications, only 7,000 have been declared eligible. And there are 169,000 households in Scotland relying on heating oil, most of them in rural areas.

And instead of bleating about the midterm election, what the budget is going to do with them, I think SNP members should do what I've done, and write to the Scottish minister and ask for the rules and eligibility for heating oil to be expanded to take into account rurality and isolation and insularity and also to have a reduction in that 500-litre minimum order that households can because some households can't afford that 500 minimum.

So, we call on the Scottish Government to extend the criteria to take in rurality and insularity, and make sure this money gets out the door.

24:00 - 24:01

Steff Aquarone.

24:01 - 25:44

Steffan Aquarone

Thank you, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. And I thank my honourable friend from Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for securing this debate. When I led a debate on heating oil in April, constituents were being asked to keep or find extraordinary sums just to keep warm. Seven months on, that problem remains. More than 10,000 homes in North Norfolk rely entirely on heating oil.

One constituent's delivery has risen from £800 to £1,400. Another has seen the price jump from 55p a litre to £1.34 in just two months. You have to find all that money at once. You can't just put £20 worth in the tank and hope it gets you through the week. Now we know these extraordinary price rises are a direct consequence of Donald Trump's disastrous war in Iran, cheered on by Reform and the Conservatives, and it's ordinary households in North Norfolk that are left paying the price.

That's why I won't stop calling for a heating oil price cap. I welcome the government's response to the CMA investigation, of course, and its commitment to stronger regulation, but regulation alone will not protect people from the next price shock. Gas and electricity customers have a cap, but my constituents don't, simply because they live beyond the gas grid. The government have ruled it out, and I ask the minister today to please reconsider. In the meantime, there's something the Treasury could do now.

One constituent has seen their bill more than double, with VAT added still on top. And I've called for the VAT to be removed for months, as my honourable colleague has said. That's around 50 quid back in their pocket. It won't solve everything, but it would ease the pressure on households facing huge upfront bills. So, again, I ask, will the minister take that to the Chancellor?

People in North Norfolk accept that rural life brings its challenges. What they should not have to accept is being financially punished for it. I hope the minister will recognise that today.

25:44 - 27:36

Josh Newbury

Thank you very much, Mr Twigg. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. I've heard from constituents in the rural parts of Cannock Chase that they often feel forgotten in national discussions about energy, so I'm very grateful to the honourable member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for securing this debate. For many in semi-rural constituencies like mine, heating oil is often the only realistic means of heating their home. Last month, I held a coffee morning in Prospect Village and spoke to Ian and Linda who are on oil, and they told me that the price they were facing trebled over a single weekend.

While they face while they recognise that the cost of crude oil is outside of our control, households on oil are effectively left to the mercy of market forces, which is why we need greater regulation in the market. And I very much welcome the government's plans to do that for the first time. I'm glad that minimum delivery quantities are being looked at, as has been said, that will help households potentially manage the massive upfront costs of heating oil. The present situation, though, underlines why we must accelerate the transition towards clean and affordable energy generated in Britain to cut our reliance on imports and strengthen our energy security. For rural communities, this transition must be practical, affordable, and fair, and recognise that not all households are the same, so a one-part a one-size-fits-all approach is not going to work.

The enhanced £9,000 heat pump grant for off-grid properties recognises the extra costs that many rural households face when moving away from heating oil. With heat pump uptake still low in rural areas and with that subsidy due to expire at the end of this financial year, I hope the minister will look carefully to extend it, so that rural households have certainty about the help that will be available to them. My constituents Ian and Linda are keen to get off oil, but they will need that help to be able to do so. Ending where I started with ensuring that the households we all represent that are reliant on heating oil aren't forgotten, as we make the transition, I hope ministers will keep rural households at the forefront of their thinking.

These families face unique challenges, but they deserve the same protection, certainty, and security as every other household in the country.

27:36 - 27:37

Andrew Snowden.

27:37 - 28:38

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, and it's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. And I thank the honorable member from the very north of the Highlands for securing this important debate today. We've all of those who are, all of those who own a oil tank have all been there at that dreaded moment where you stick the upside down broomstick into the tank and pray and will that there is more oil in there than you know there actually will be, because you know that means a big bill is coming. And you put it off as I did once, resulting in us running out of oil on Christmas Eve, which has only been forgotten less by my wife than the time I forgot to get the septic tank emptied and it exploded on the public footpath down the side of our house, which was great for my electoral prospects. But I am not alone in Fylde.

Nearly 10% of all houses in my constituency are not connected to the national gas grid, and as high as 14% in some areas like Singleton and Greenhalgh. That's

28:38 - 28:39

Would the honorable member give way?

28:39 - 28:40

The honorable

28:40 - 28:58

Robbie Moore

I thank the honorable member for giving way. In my constituency in the Werfa Valley, we have a huge number of houses that are impacted by no change in this government to helping and supporting them with the heating oil. Does he agree with me that there was a major missed opportunity in Labour's budget to look at VAT and the implications of reducing VAT on heating oil?

28:58 - 30:49

Andrew Snowden

Thank my honorable friend for his intervention and a very good point that he made in an opportunity missed. As I was saying, there's 4,765 houses in my constituency alone that are not connected to the grid. And in Fylde, 28% of those people are over 65 compared to a national average of around 18% in a constituency, which means that we're not just dealing with the issues of rural isolation and of rural poverty, but also the health and well-being of older people. And as it's been touched on by other honorable members, those who have households with oil tanks often have, as I have just mentioned, septic tanks and other infrastructure that has a far more costly way of operating and maintaining than just being connected to the grid in the traditional way, and therefore it compounds the issues that are being felt now. And as has already been touched on as well, the funding that the government set aside works out, as my honorable, the honorable member sat to my left said, at £35 per house.

Well, if you work out that the average price of oil has gone up by about £1 per liter, and the average home uses around 2,000 liters of oil, that support covers less than 2% of the cost increase that the average household is facing. And many of my constituents have made that point to me. So, I would encourage the government to move faster and to find more ways of supporting those people as we head into winter who are reliant on oil to heat their home, as the bills that they are facing now are going to be crippling over the winter period.

30:49 - 30:50

Lillian Barker.

30:50 - 32:25

Lillian Jones

Thank you, and could I just thank the honorable member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for bringing about this important debate. Now, with the conflict in Iran, the blocking of the Strait of Hormuz, the price of crude oil shot up, which directly impacted around 2,700 homes in my constituency of Kilmarnock and Loudoun. Now, the UK government provided 4.6 million targeted support to the to be administered by the Scottish government to help these families, so it is disappointing to see only half of that money has been spent, and therefore I'm calling on the Scottish government to urgently review the criteria and the process to get that Scottish emergency heating oil payment out, and it's been far too slow to get to those who need it most. Since prices began to spike, I've heard deeply concerning accounts of families who've budgeted for one price only to find themselves facing skyrocketing costs after orders were canceled and then tripled. Now, this has left too many of my constituents feeling held hostage to fuel suppliers in an unregulated market.

So I welcome the action taken by the Competition and Markets Authority to secure compensation for affected customers and to recommend stronger protections for heating oil users, and I also welcome the removal of the 4% tariff on kerosene announced at the budget last week. Now government and regulators must ensure that we have a robust and fair framework for families and businesses who rely on off-grid energy supplies. What we need now is robust regulation and zero tolerance towards companies who exploit their customers. Those who do exploit heating oil consumers should face tough penalties and public scrutiny to ensure that my constituents get a fairer deal now and in the future. Thank you.

32:25 - 32:50

Speaker 29

Thank you, Madam Chair. from me for securing this debate. In Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey, 44% of homes are off gas grid, and over 16% rely directly on oil central heating, more than triple the Scottish national average, and nearly six times the UK average. Across Scotland as a whole, 142,000 households depend on heating oil to keep warm.

32:50 - 33:26

Speaker 27

Yet while grid-connected homes have an en- energy price cap, which in itself is going to see a huge increase, off-grid households have no such protection. Heating oil is an unregulated market, leaving consumers massively exposed to price volatility. When prices reached 123 pence per liter, an average household using 2,000 liters faced an annual bill of nearly £2,600, over £869 higher than the main energy price cap, and that doesn't include electricity on top. A pensioner in Findhorn wrote to me after paying £1,205 for just 1,000 liters of kerosene, describing it as simply unsustainable.

33:26 - 33:47

Speaker 28

Pensioners with severe medical conditions report orders exceeding £900 per tank, forced to choose between heating their homes and buying basic essentials. Powers over energy market regulation and consumer protection remain with Westminster. Yet ministers refuse to institute price caps or regulate minimum delivery thresholds. This underscores a fundamental truth:

33:47 - 34:07

Speaker 27

Scotland is an energy-rich nation, yet under Westminster control, forgotten homes are left out in the cold. No, I'm I'll finish. With independence, Scotland should take full control or would take full control over energy market regulation, price caps and consumer protection, preventing such a crisis happening in the first place.

34:07 - 34:09

Paula Barker

Chris Kane.

34:09 - 35:22

Chris Kane

Thank you. And from homes and towns to the outskirts of Stirling to rural communities stretched towards Loch Lomond and the Trossachs, including Aberfoyle, and north to Killin and Crianlarich on the edge of the Highlands, heating oil is not a lifestyle choice; it is the main source of warmth for thousands of households across my Stirling and Strathallan constituency. And many have contacted me deeply worried about the sharp rise in heating oil prices and the impact on their household finances. Prices have more than doubled, placing enormous pressure on families, older people and some of the most vulnerable in our communities. And understandably, there is anger and frustration too: frustration that households reliant on heating oil do not enjoy the same protections as those connected to the gas and electricity networks; and anger that this long-standing disparity has yet to be properly addressed.

There is also a wider challenge here, one that goes beyond the immediate pressures of heating oil prices. It's about fuel poverty, the particular circumstances of rural communities, and how we deliver a fair and practical transition to cleaner, more affordable heating. Yet the support available to those households can be incredibly difficult to navigate. Across the four nations of the United Kingdom, we have different definitions of fuel poverty, different schemes and eligi- eligibility criteria, and a complicated mix of responsibilities between governments and energy providers.

35:22 - 35:23

I give way.

35:23 - 35:44

Torcuil Crichton

Thanks to my honorable friend for giving way. He's making a great speech. When it comes to delivering support, the system is complicated, and Scotland is centralized rather than delivered through councils, which means that less than half the £10 million of heat of heating oil support has gone out the door to consumers. Does he agree with me that the money should have gone to local authorities and to local areas, where it would have been more efficiently handled?

35:44 - 36:41

Chris Kane

Yes, as a former council leader, I can tell you that councils, regardless of their political color, are crying out for the Scottish government to recognize exactly what can be done if you empower local authorities to deliver good local services, and it does not happen enough. And I really hope that the SNP government in Edinburgh realizes that they can do more to empower local communities through local authorities. I would ask the minister how the government intends to work with the devolved governments to deliver a more coordinated approach, one that recognizes the particular challenges facing off-grid communities. We need targeted action that gives people greater protection today while helping them move towards more affordable and sustainable heating in the future, because someone, whether they live in Stirling, Aberfoyle, or a remote home near Tier Larach, they deserve the same basic reassurance that they can afford to keep their home warm and they will not be left behind in the energy transition.

36:41 - 36:44

Paula Barker

Dr. Roz Savage.

36:44 - 38:25

Rose Savage

Thank you, Ms. Barker. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I thank my honorable friend for securing this debate. The South Cotswolds is one of England's most off-grid constituencies. One in five households relies on heating oil, which is around four times the national average. As one constituent wrote to me last month, they feel they've been forgotten about.

They're facing a doubling of cost for families already paying a rural premium of 10 to 20% on everyday essentials and living in some of our hardest to heat homes. And unlike gas bills, heating oil must be paid for in a large lump when the tanker arrives. There's no Ofgem price cap, leaving households exposed to volatile global markets, and decisions made thousands of miles away. I do welcome the government's efforts and the work of Wiltshire Council and the Centre for Sustainable Energy to get support to those who need it. But £53 million across 1.5 million oil-heated homes works out at just £35 each, enough for about 30 liters.

The 4% tariff suspension is welcome, but hardly compensates for prices doubling. And removing gas standing charges is no help to people without gas. So, I have three asks of the minister. First, will the minister press colleagues for a clear timetable to regulate the heating oil market? Second, will the minister push for further support through the Crisis and Resilience Fund?

And thirdly, will the minister commit to rural-proofing future energy and cost of living measures so that people aren't disadvantaged simply because they live beyond the gas grid? Being off the gas grid should not mean being off the government's radar.

38:25 - 38:27

Paula Barker

David Smith.

38:27 - 40:23

David William Smith

Thank you, Ms. Barker. And I commend the honorable gentleman for securing this important debate. You know, the first missiles that went into Iran, my heating oil households, their bills doubled. There's about 5,000 of them. So, it was a terrible moment, but I'm really pleased that the government stepped in with the £53 million that we've been we've been talking about.

At the same time in March this year, £5 million was given to Northumberland County Council, Conservative run NCC, including for the Crisis and Resilience Fund, but also for heating oil. And CRF can be used for heating your home, but it's very opaque. It's very unclear at this point how that money's been used, how much has gone out the door. I've been asking and not get any clear understanding yet. So, I'm pleased that Labour have been providing further relief.

You know, £100 for the council tax is A to D, this winter of energy bills the cut on the kerosene tariff. I'll be chasing suppliers in my constituency to make sure that they pass that on to consumers, and a boost to the boiler upgrade scheme, et cetera.

It's welcome that we are bringing in regulation to heating oil. But I would say I think all of the responses that we've heard today follow an important principle: don't mess with the market when it's working, and don't let the markets mess with people when it's not. And I think that's where we've got to step in here. So I'd really just ask my honourable friend, right honourable friend, the minister, what if higher heating oil prices are here to stay? You know, what can we do in the medium to long-term?

I really welcome the short-term measures that we're taking. I spoke with a development trust in Norham in my constituency last year who want to introduce, you know, a local grid through renewables, through solar, through wind. You know, Great British Energy, etc., which I fully support, is support supposed to be supporting rural communities like that. If we can circumvent this problem, if we can get people off heating oil where they don't have to be on it, if we can empower them to have local grids, I think that's where we should be pursuing. So I'd really ask my right honourable friend if she could answer, or say a little bit more about the progress on that.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

40:23 - 40:26

Paula Barker

Jim Shannon.

40:26 - 41:49

Jim Shannon

Pleasure to speak under your chairship, and a big thank you to the honourable gentleman for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for raising this debate. As I stand here today in the quick two minutes, I'm going to speak to where we are in relation to Northern Ireland and remind the House of a stark unyielding reality. For the vast majority of people in Northern Ireland, the energy price cap is a complete myth. The official statistics tell a story of systematic vulnerability. 5% of households in Great Britain rely on domestic oil heating.

63% of households in Northern Ireland depend entirely on oil central heating. And in the rural community of Strangford, where I live, dependency skyrockets to an astonishing 82%. I doubt if there's anywhere else in the United Kingdom where the 82% is the figure for the people where I live. So they when it comes to Strangford, and it comes to the Ards Peninsula, they cannot flick a switch and rely on a regulated utility grid. Instead, they are forced to watch the price of a drop of kerosene like a hawk.

that when the price of crude spikes, off-grid families face immediate, brutal, financial penalties. A matter of just three weeks, we watched the average cost of 500 L of home heating oil almost double. So what does that mean for a working family, for a small farmer, for a pensioner in Strangford? They're looking at an upfront lump lump-sum demand of over £1,000 just to keep the radiators warm. And if they can't find the cash, they're left with an empty tank and a freezing home.

Yeah, okay.

41:49 - 42:09

Andrew Snowden

I thank the honourable member for giving way, partly because I just wanted to raise the point that, actually, there's a perception that a lot of the households that are on oil are rich households or large houses, where, actually, in rural communities, a lot of the houses that are dependent on oil are smaller properties and where there is rural poverty and isolation.

42:09 - 42:58

Jim Shannon

The honourable gentleman is right, and I agree with that, and I think the minister will be listening to the facts of the case. In Northern Ireland, fuel poverty stands at 22%. That's affecting nearly a quarter of all the population in Northern Ireland. Our people are being disproportionately punished simply because of where they live. We need an urgent and comprehensive strategy that bridges the gap between off-grid rural communities and the rest of the United Kingdom.

I conclude with this: I implore the minister and the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero to work urgently with the Northern Ireland Executive to deliver sustained structural protections. We must ensure that a child growing up in rural Strangford in my constituency is afforded the same basic right to a warm home as a child living in metropolitan London. Thank you.

42:58 - 44:47

Lee Pitcher

Across my constituency, 3,603 households are not on the gas grid and are reliant on either heating oil or an alternative type of fuel for their heating. I just want to give one example today of a resident who just recently contacted me from Belton. They live in an older house, not connected to mains grid network, and they rely entirely on heating oil for their home. A year ago, to fill up their heating oil tank, it cost £864 plus VAT. This year, they were quoted £1,700 plus VAT: almost the double almost double the cost.

Traditionally, households have tried to manage these costs by filling their tanks in September, when prices are often at their lowest. But when prices are this high, even careful planning and budgeting means the money only goes so far. A full tank will only last my constituent now to the end of January before winter is even over, and they will be facing another bill and potentially even higher than the than it is currently. A constituent described the situation as simply impossible to afford on their household income. The price has doubled, their income has not.

They aren't protected by the energy price cap, and rather than spreading the costs across monthly payments, they are faced with finding thousands of pounds upfront at the uncapped cost at the moment. Now, I welcome the government's recognition of the particular challenges facing heating oil customers, including the recent announcement of plans to introduce stronger community consumer protections. Ultimately, though, heating your home is not a luxury, it is a necessity, and people shouldn't face additional financial insecurity simply because they live in a rural community without access to mains gas network.

So, I would welcome the minister's thoughts today on how we can ensure that households, like the one I've just mentioned, in Belton and right the way across Doncaster East and Axholme, and the Isle of Axholme, will benefit from the proposed improvements to consumer protections, particularly when it comes to managing the substantial upfront cost of heating oil.

44:47 - 44:49

Paula Barker

Adrian Ramsay.

44:49 - 46:51

Adrian Philip Ramsay

Thank you, Mr. and it's a pleasure to serve under your chair ship. During autumn recess, I had the opportunity to tour villages in my constituency, and the issue that came up time and time again was that of heating oil costs, because over 30% of households in Waveney Valley are off the gas grid, the highest percentage of any constituency in the east of England. And as many members have said, heating oil is unique because unlike households using mains gas and electricity, heating oil users are not protected by the energy price cap and are therefore exposed to global energy shock shocks, geopolitics, and market volatility.

And we've all heard of cases of people having to choose between heating and eating and of pensioners, of children, going to bed at night cold. And that simply cannot be right in 2026. We cannot allow large swathes of our citizens to be having to make that choice between heating and eating at the whim of Donald Trump or Vladimir Putin. Now, the government's response so far hasn't been adequate. The 53 million that was invested last April, as we've already heard,

was only would only amount to £35 extra for each household, hardly scratches the surface. And even cutting VAT, scrapping VAT on heating oil, which would be welcome, would only save £50 for a £1,000 purchase. So, what do we need most? Well, first of all, I want to see regulation of the sector, regulation of the prices.

Secondly, far more significant assistance through councils, who are seeing the funding they've been given having to be stretched further and further. And then, thirdly, as other members have said, proper investment in both home insulation measures and the announcements in the budget last week, which seem to suggest cuts to the Warm Homes Plan, take us in the wrong direction. And we need to see proper investment in things like renewable heating systems that can work in rural communities. Those green measures are essential, but, of course, they're not enough for this winter, where the efforts to reduce the costs and help people right now are what's absolutely needed.

46:51 - 46:53

Paula Barker

Terry Jermy.

46:53 - 48:05

James Terry Jermy

Thank you, Mr. and I thank the honorable member for securing this debate. The cost of heating oil has been very much at the forefront of my South West Norfolk constituents' minds over the last seven months. 25% of homes in my constituency are relying on heating oil, thousands and thousands of properties, and that sudden increase left many in a desperate situation, because my constituents, like the constituents of many honorable members here, are already paying a rural premium, given additional costs linked to rurality. I was pleased the government responded quickly,

the £53 million national support package. In Norfolk, we got the larger share of any county council in the country, more than £3 million for our county alone.

But I am furious that Reform-led Norfolk County Council has barely lifted a finger to promote this support service. If you look at their social media, as I have done, you can barely find mention of the fact this fund is available. And myself and my team have been working flat-out to encourage people to apply. Many of the people in Norfolk who are reliant on heating oil, in the west of the county, we are particularly affected. Of course.

48:05 - 48:31

Speaker 46

I'm grateful to my friend for giving way. 11% of my constituents in Banbury are reliant on heating oil and they like he welcomed the £53 million provided by government. But in our case Oxfordshire County Council has also done very little to make people aware that this money is there. Does he agree with me that national and local government, in my case, as I said, Oxfordshire County Council, need to do more to make people aware of the help that is already out there for people that rely on heating oil?

48:31 - 48:43

James Terry Jermy

It's a huge shame to hear about the Oxfordshire example, and it seems there's many examples around the country. There is money sat waiting in council bank accounts that could be put to use supporting local people. I will give way.

48:43 - 48:58

Torcuil Crichton

Thank you very much. Would does he agree with me that there is a devolutionary learning lesson here that when money is handed out from departments, or the minister, when money is handed out to funds, there has to be transparency and accountability from devolved governments like Scotland and councils and local authorities in this?

48:58 - 49:41

James Terry Jermy

I think my honourable friend for that intervention and I'm sure the minister will reflect on that, because there absolutely needs to be learning from this process, because this is a desperate situation, the money needed to be spent quickly. And here we are months later with it sat in bank accounts not being used. I had a constituent, Andrew from Welney, a village, very small village in my constituency. At the time of his crisis, a time of the crisis, his wife was going through breast cancer, completely unaware that this support was available. We managed to get him £350 worth of support, but I hope when the minister responds, she can talk more about what the government can do to pressure councils to get this money out the door to help my constituents and that of honourable members in the chamber.

49:41 - 49:52

Paula Barker

Can I just remind colleagues that we are on a tight timeline, it's up to other colleagues if they wish to accept interventions, but you may just want to be mindful. Adam Dance.

49:52 - 51:51

Adam Dance

Thank you, Madam Chair. When heating oil prices go up, and rural cons- communities across Yeovil really feel the impact. And yet, as Trevor from Hardington Mandeville and many other Yeovil constituents pointed out, the Chancellor did little to nothing to support heating oil issues. I think Heather put it best, "The weather is getting colder, and, yet again, people in rural communities seem to be get forgotten." Many constituents have also written to me about the biggest impact of heating oil cost rises come from the minimum value orders.

Residents have described having to order 500 L at a time, which is just totally unaffordable. I have also heard from residents in Haselbury Plucknett and North Perrott that they are facing fuel poverty, yet still do not qualify for government support. And, as a result, are having to dramatically cut uses. By pushing people to use less misses the bigger point. There is only so much you can personally do when prices are so high and you have no particular alternative to heating oil before you begin really impacting your quality of life, particularly over winter.

Catherine from Chard, last order costs her just shy of £2,000 for 1,500 L. Both Catherine and her tenant are retired and would like to have kept the heating off and worn jumpers to save money. But Catherine says that she can cannot do this, as her tenant is struggling to recover from a stroke, and she refuses to risk her tenant's health to save money on bills. Their property is off-grid, and upgrades are difficult or impossible without serious work.

Too many heating oil users like Catherine are stuck between a rock and a hard place and need government support. So I hope the government will look to improve targeted support so struggling Yeovil constituents are not left out. But if this government really wants to give rural communities breathing space, what we need is a price cap for heating oil because rural communities simply cannot afford to bear the cost of rising heating oil any longer.

It's all well and good having number 10 north, but what we really need is number 10 rural.

51:51 - 51:53

Speaker 43

Jayne Kirkham.

51:53 - 53:24

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Pleasure to serve under your chair ship, and thank you to the honorable member for bringing this debate. We have 5,000 homes in Truro and Falmouth off the grid, and I do welcome, as others have, the 53 million pounds support and the regulation of the market for the first time. But, similarly as others, Cornwall Council had 1.53 million,

and they're handing it out to, of, in pockets of 300 pounds for people who get council tax support, but they've only handed out 402,000 so far. They're doing a second round and putting it into the Crisis and Resilience Fund, but I do think, again, people need to know that's available and we need to push that out further. In Cornwall, we have a pilot in Kehelland village of hydrogenated vegetable oil, which is a renewable fuel, not from the Middle East. It simply needs technical consultation

with the heating oil suppliers and a statutory instrument for that renewable fuel obligation to be rolled out in a similar way that it is for transport. That could really help, and many of the villagers in Kehelland are very pleased with what they're getting there and are very pleased to see that rolled out further. The Warm Homes Plan will, of course, help people move to renewables,

but we do find in Cornwall that so many of our houses are listed properties or in conservation areas and they really struggle to make differences to their homes to enable them to keep that heat in so that they can make the most of the Warm Homes Plan adaptations.

53:24 - 55:29

Ann Celia Davies

Diolch yn fawr Cadeirydd, and it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. The cost of heating oil, can I firstly say that to the member of Clwyd, we've all been there, but we use a runner bean stick rather than an upturned broom. But the cost of heating oil is a major issue for my constituents in Caerfyrddin, and I do welcome the government's decision to include off grid households in the 100 pounds energy support payment, which has been implemented by the Plaid Cymru Welsh Government in Wales, but unfortunately most rural homes are not in band A to D. And in Wales heating oil prices have risen by 103% since January, increasing the annual cost from 605 pounds to 1,620 pounds,

and rural communities are bearing the brunt of these increases. So I would ask the government for more support with these costs, and will the government therefore consider reducing the VAT as others have asked on domestic heating oil to provide direct and immediate relief to households? And looking to the longer term, we need to ensure that schemes are supporting the transition away from oil heating are properly funded, as the majority of rural homes are pre-1910 and cladding is not an effective option. I'm proud that Caerfyrddin ranks 16th in the UK for heat pump uptake, demonstrating that households are willing to make the transition when support is available.

The MCS Foundation has warned that if installations continue at their current rate, next year's budget could be exhausted within 6 months. And with the off grid BUS grant scheme due to fall from 9,000 to 7,500 in the next financial year, it's vital that households are made aware that the applications must be submitted before the 31st of March to secure a full grant. Too often rural communities are an afterthought in energy policy. The reality is that families who have no access to the gas grid are paying the highest prices to stay warm this winter. Rural Wales and rural communities need action now.

55:29 - 55:30

Joe Morris.

55:30 - 57:13

Joseph Ronald Morris

Thank you, and thank you, pleasure to serve under your chairship, and can I commend the hon. Gentleman for securing such an important and timely debate?

It's a pleasure, as always, to stand alongside my friend and colleague from North Northumberland, as well. I want to start out speaking about a family who works four jobs between them, a tenant who can't insulate her own home because she, because it's a home she does not own, two pensioners who don't qualify for further support or a full-time worker on a modest salary. In rural communities, these are the people who are used to falling through the cracks, who are used to the system simply not working for them. And I do want to focus in the limited time that my initial speech would have expanded on what I would like to see the government do, which is consider the rural communities when we are making policy. I think for far too long, possibly due to the complacent nature that some of these communities were represented with in the past, the rural question was not particularly advocated for by those constituency MPs, and I'd urge the minister to particularly consider the importance of protecting those consumers, to do what the Conservatives never did in government, to look at fixing the roof while we can, fixing things before the crisis occurs, fixing things before it becomes a time-sensitive decision.

I do want to praise the government for seeing a problem and taking swift and immediate action when the missiles start flying in the straits of Hormuz. It was a matter of days rather than a matter of months before money was committed, but they do need to think about the future crises and what we can do to avert that. I do want to touch and welcome points made by colleagues on decarbonising these houses. It is an open question, but I would just like to finish by urging ministers to find ways to support rural households, but also the businesses and community spaces that those communities rely on. They might be off-grid, but they must not be shut out.

57:13 - 57:14

Wendy Chamberlain.

57:14 - 59:08

Wendy Chamberlain

Thank you very much, It is a great honour to serve under your chairship, and I thank my honourable and dear friend for securing this important debate. In North East Fife, about 14.6% of households are off the gas grid. I'm not as remote as my honourable friend, but it is a rural constituency. And I want to share the experience of one of my constituents which illustrates the reality facing many households today. My constituent uses an electric heater in her daughter's bedroom rather than turning on the boiler in order to preserve her remaining oil supply for hot water.

Her energy costs means that she has less for her overall costs, and she's now building up a credit card debt that she is trying to service. She told me, "I can't take my daughter to visit her grandparents because I have to ration fuel for school runs and food shopping. I make excuses because I'm too embarrassed to admit I can't afford the 80-mile round trip." No family should be forced to make choices like these, and I have met with ministers to discuss the impact not only of heating oil prices, but also the rising costs of liquefied petroleum gas and red diesel. These are creating additional pressures for rural households, farmers, and local businesses.

But I do agree with other members that while immediate support is essential, we need to focus on long-term solutions. The answer cannot simply be to in helping people cope with high energy costs of mitigating those costs. We need to do things permanently. And that's one of the reasons why my Scottish Lib Dem colleagues in Holyrood, and indeed colleagues here, continue to advocate for an emergency home upgrade programme. But I do have to say, some constituents' experiences with schemes such as ECO4 are really damaging in eroding consumer confidence in making the move to more zero-carbon and zero emissions and better heating.

And older homes, they need to be heated to be maintained. It is a real challenge for people. We need to reduce that reliance longer term, because families across North East Fife and other rural constituencies, as we hear, absolutely deserve better.

59:08 - 59:09

Noah Law.

59:09 - 01:01:12

Charles Noah Law

Thank you, Mr Foster. My constituency, covering St Austell Bay, clay country, and Newquay, contains many households that are not connected to the gas grid, and remain heavily reliant on heating oil.

oil. And for those families, fluctuations, like we've seen, in oil prices can have a very stark impact on household budgets, particularly through the winter months. So, we do need, as we've heard, a practical solution and a transition towards cleaner heating. I know that switching to heat pump, like the one I have in my home, will not be right for everyone, but for those who wish to do who do wish to go down that route, substantial support is available, including the 7,500 boiler upgrade scheme, and the Warm Homes loans, which I know should go some way to dealing with what is sometimes, but certainly not always, a significant upfront costs. And for now, there is of course the 4% tariff abolition. And I will certainly follow the lead of my honourable friend, the member for North Northumberland, in trying to ensure with local companies that pass through of those savings actually does get through to the consumer.

We'll also need to push the minister, of course, for those crucial industry reforms to come forward, like reducing the minimum order volumes. And of course, I would like to hear whether it's possible for the much-needed government extension of the crisis and resilience fund, which we saw previously give 53 million pounds back to heating oil users, whether or not it's possible to ensure more similar support come through to councils. And if we do get it, I'd like to see, of course, our local council in Cornwall ensure that it reaches a broader base of heating oil users, if we can. I know there's much more to do. We do need greater support for insulation and solutions that really work for off-grid homes.

Clean liquid fuel, such as HVO, as we've heard about, can play a huge role in that, so I'm interested to hear the minister's view on how we can support those fuels and what steps the government can take to provide additional support for heating oil users right now.

01:01:12 - 01:01:13

Alistair Carmichael.

01:01:13 - 01:03:15

Alexander Carmichael

Thank you, Mr. Barker, and I congratulate my honourable friend and southern neighbour in securing time for the debate today. Orkney and Shetland have the highest levels of fuel poverty of any community in the country. I've heard those who've complained about having a number of homes that are no access to the gas grid; I share their pain. We have absolutely no homes connected to the mains gas grid. And for us, that is something of a bitter irony, because for the last 40 to 50 years, the gas that has heated the homes in the rest of the United Kingdom, for much part, has landed in either Shetland or Orkney, then to be shipped south.

So, when we heard the chancellor, last week, in the budget abolishing standing charges for gas customers, but not electricity customers, I'm afraid, for us, that felt like just another kick in the teeth. So, for the minister today, given the shortness of time, I have a few asks. When are we going to see the extension of the abolition of the standing charges to electricity as well as to gas? Because for those who are not relying on heating oil, they're relying largely on storage heating powered by electricity. When are we going to see meaningful regulation of the heating oil market?

And at the very least, we have to see from that regulation a reduction in minimum orders and an introduction of a price cap, which will allow some certainty in budgeting for those who do rely on heating oil. And finally, as we move towards a reliance on renewable energy in the future, when are we going to see a meaningful package for a community benefit and assistance with bills so that those who live in the shadow of the pylons and the turbines are actually have given access to the cheaper electricity that they so desperately need?

01:03:15 - 01:05:00

Perran Moon

Mr. Barker, it's an honour to serve under your chairship and I thank the member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for securing this debate.

In my remote coastal constituency of Camborne and Redruth and Hayle, over 5,500 homes rely on heating oil as their only source of central heating. In villages such as Kehelland, Mawnan Smith and Port Navas, it's closer to half. I warmly welcome the two-year kerosene tariff suspension announced in the budget alongside the previous chancellor's 53 million crisis and resilience fund for low-income households and plans to strengthen consumer protections and to tackle price gouging. Now, for many, heat pumps are an answer, but they're rarely practical, as we've heard, at cost-effective for cost-effective older off-grid remote homes. Fortunately, Cornwall has part of the answer.

As has been mentioned, in the aforementioned Kehelland, in my constituency, residents have been trialling the use of HVO for the past 5 years. A 20% HVO blend can reduce carbon emissions by up to 90%, while cutting consumption by around 18% without costly retro retrofit for a heat pump. The legislation already exists for a renewable liquid heating fuel obligation, which would enable HVO to be deployed at scale, but we still await that necessary technical consultation. I would, therefore, urge ministers to examine the Kehelland trial in depth, reassure themselves that the supply issue that they have imagined doesn't actually exist and explicitly set out what specific further evidence is required so that HVO can be realized as a low-carbon, efficient option for remote off-grid homes.

01:05:00 - 01:06:51

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Ms Barker. It's a pleasure to serve under your chair person and I congratulate my honorable friend for securing this important debate. Since March this year, I, like I'm sure many members, have been inundated with pleas from my constituents, including 79-year-old Barbara from Launceston who said this, "Will the government please do something about the soaring prices of heating oil? I already can't afford to put fuel in my car, and if things don't change, I'm not sure how I'll make it through this winter." In some of the most rural parts of North Cornwall, villages like St Breward and Blisland that surround Bodmin Moor, up to 97% of households are completely off the mains gas grid and the cost of their heating oil per tank has gone from around £400 up to around £12 or even £1,500.

Many there also rely on LPG, with no specific support or targeted support outlined so far. They've often got no option to switch to a cheaper provider and when the cold sets in as it is right now, many face a long and perilous winter of damp and freezing cold. Finally, in the words of one of my elderly constituents from Nanstallon, "Many elderly folk like us who have lived off-grid all their lives cannot afford solar panels or heat exchangers. We're stuck with heating oil and LPG." So, I'd just like to ask the minister today if she could please address our concerns and our calls for a price cap on heating oil and LPG, a 3-month 0 VAT on heating oil, as the member for Orkney and Shetland already said, removal of standing charges on electric, as well as extra support for rural households to insulate and upgrade their homes.

Thank you.

01:06:51 - 01:06:54

Paula Barker

Spokesperson, Sarah Dyke.

01:06:54 - 01:16:03

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Ms Barker. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair this afternoon, and I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross, on securing this debate and on his tireless work on behalf of his off-grid households in his constituency. And I also thank all honorable and right honorable members who have spoken today. Of course, this is not just a Highlands problem, it or indeed a Somerset problem.

It's a problem for all rural households right across the UK. Around 1.4 million homes are off the gas grid, and many of them have no choice but to heat their homes with oil. The war in Iran and Donald Trump's reckless trade wars have sent shock after shock through global energy markets. And this week at the midterm elections, the American people rejected the politics of division and voted for hope. They also rejected a president whose answer to every energy question is "drill baby drill", and who pulled America out of the Paris Climate Agreement.

But a weakened president is not a more predictable one, and rural households here are still desperately exposed. Since the war in Iran began, the price of heating oil has risen by around 80%. Yet not one of these 1.4 million households is protected by Ofgem's energy price cap. The result is a two-tier energy system: one set of rules for homes on the gas grid and another for rural Britain. Ms Barker, behind these figures are real families facing a very difficult winter.

A household on mains gas pays as it goes, protected by a price cap with a regulator to turn to. A household on heating oil has none of that. They have to pay in bulk, often many hundreds of pounds in a single bill, just as winter sets in. So families are forced to make impossible choices. They heat one room to close off the rest.

They go to bed early just to keep warm. Or they put off ordering and run the risk of the tank running dry. Too often rural Britain is an afterthought when policy is made. And heating oil is yet another example of that. Ms Barker, Phil and Jenny who live in North Barrow paid 77 pence a litre in February.

They're now paying nearly double that and they simply can't afford to heat their home this winter. The Government has announced three measures on energy costs; not one of them properly reaches a home like theirs. The first is removing unfair standing charges. That is the right thing to do, but it does nothing about the cost of heating oil. The second is removing tariffs on kerosene.

Again, welcome, but the UK Trade Observatory at the University of Sussex has found that 83% of kerosene imports already come in tariff-free. So I ask the Minister: will she publish the department's own estimate of how much this tariff cut will save a rural household? Now, the third measure is the 100-pound rebate announced this last week. Any help is welcome, but will rural households actually get it? Oil-heated homes tend to be bigger, older and harder to heat, and many fall outside the rebate altogether.

So how many households reliant on heating oil does the Minister expect to receive this rebate? Now, this is a two-tier system. So will the Minister commit that every future energy support scheme is rural-proof, properly rural-proofed, with a published assessment of how many off-grid homes it will reach? Ms Barker, Jill in my constituency is a pensioner and she lives in Horsington. She is the legal guardian of her granddaughter.

And apart from child benefit, she receives absolutely no help at all. She wrote to me recently to tell me that she can't afford to fill her oil tank and her granddaughter will be coming home from school to a cold house. Now, following pressure from the Liberal Democrats, and many honourable and right honourable members here today, 53 million pounds of support was made available in March. But that equates to about 35 pounds per home. And that support was really limited.

And delivery through local councils has created a postcode lottery for rural households. So will the Minister publish how much of the 53 million pounds has been spent and by which councils? And will any unspent money be topped up and reallocated before the coldest months arrive? But heating oil, Ms Barker, is only one part of a wider cost of living crisis in the countryside.

The rural premium means rural households spend 10 to 20% more on everyday essentials. With few buses and long journeys and distances, the car is not a luxury, it's a lifeline. Now, rural households already face a fuel poverty gap of £987 compared to those in towns and cities. Ms Barker, many rural communities have found their own way to fight back. Oil clubs and consortia, across Glastonbury and Somerton constituency, oil buying clubs are a lifeline to rural communities.

By coming together and placing one combined order, they secure customers a better price and a more reliable service, and fewer tankers travel along our rural lanes. But that only works if suppliers honour the price they quote. When the war in Iran began, some suppliers refused to honour quoted prices or to quote at all. Oil clubs were forced to suspend trading just when households needed them most. The CMA found that around 1,700 customers had orders cancelled, many forced to re-order at higher prices or simply go without.

Now, I welcome the Government's decision to accept the CMA's recommendations, a code of conduct now and a new regulatory regime to follow. But will the minister set out a clear timetable so that rural families and oil clubs are protected this winter, not next? Ms Barker, I believe that the CMA got one thing badly wrong: its decision not to recommend a price cap. It argued a cap could reduce competition, but in too many rural areas, there is very little competition to protect. On the Isle of Wight, for example, households have just one supplier.

Where there is no competition, a price cap does not damage the market, it protects the consumer. So, will the minister commit to zero rating VAT on heating oil for three months and to a price cap mechanism that protects off-grid homes this winter? Ms Barker, emergency support must get families through this winter, but without urgent action on how rural homes are heated, we will be debating this same crisis every winter, and rural families will keep paying the price. As long as our rural homes depend on imported oil, they will be at the mercy of global events. Whether that's the war in the Middle East or a volatile president whose decisions can drive up the price of filling an oil tank in Somerset overnight, energy security is national security, and that means speeding up the transition to renewable energy, the cheapest new power and the cleanest, generated right here in Britain.

For rural households, it means an affordable way of getting off heating oil. But by July, the warm homes local grant had upgraded just 5,470 homes, 0.1% of its target. Yet last week's budget cut £1 billion from the Warm Homes Plan grants. The Liberal Democrats would, instead, deliver a 10-year emergency home upgrades programme, starting with free insulation for low-income households. So, will the minister make sure the new Home Energy Model properly reflects older, off-grid, rural homes so they are not wrongly assessed and shut out of support?

Now, Ms Barker, in an unstable world, rural households are facing a cost of living crisis, and they cannot be treated as second tier again this winter. So, I have three asks of the minister: first, publish these figures on what the tariff cut will really save rural households; second, zero rate VAT on heating oil for three months and introduce a price cap mechanism for off-grid homes this winter; and thirdly, reverse the cuts to the Warm Homes Plan and give rural households an affordable route off heating oil.

Because rural Britain has been an afterthought for far too long. This winter, the government has a choice: stand with rural households or leave them out in the cold. Thank you.

01:16:03 - 01:16:07

Paula Barker

Sir Ashley Fox.

01:16:07 - 01:20:38

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mrs Barker. It's a present pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Can I thank the member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross for securing this important debate, and for his thoughtful and eloquent speech. We have had a good debate this afternoon, which has highlighted the additional costs that fall upon our rural communities. I thank the honorable member for Fylde for his contribution, and I trust that he won't forget to top up his tank before this Christmas.

The member for South West Norfolk highlighted the need for local councils to take a proactive approach to getting government money out of the door as quickly as possible. It would seem that some councils are not doing that terribly effectively. Mrs Barker, about 1.4 million households across the UK rely on heating oil, predominantly in rural areas, including many in my constituency. For those households, using heating oil is not a choice. Most are not connected to the mains gas network and have little practical alternative when it comes to heating their homes.

They face particular challenges. They are exposed to unpredictable delivery costs and the burden of paying hundreds, sometimes thousands of pounds upfront to fill their oil tanks. Many are older and more vulnerable households who simply cannot absorb sudden price shocks. Recent international developments have demonstrated just how exposed those households have become. Disruption to oil supplies and shipping routes drove up household prices, with consequence consequences quickly felt here in the UK.

Households that had been paying £300 for 500 L of heating oil were suddenly facing quotes of between £600 and £1,000. For many families, that was simply unaffordable. The Conservatives raised these concerns with the government at the time, and, after rather too much delay, some support was eventually provided through the Crisis and Resilience Fund. While welcome, it addressed the consequences rather than the cause of the problem. That is why the Competition and Markets Authority's investigation was so important.

Following reports of canceled orders, sudden price increases, and demands for additional payments, the CMA identified significant concerns in the way parts of the market were operating. The CMA intervened, where suppliers may have breached contractual obligations by cancelling orders after prices surged, securing compensation for affected customers. I welcome that intervention. However, investigations after the damage has already been done does not fix the issue. I know the minister will refer to the government's intention to regulate the heating oil sector.

I welcome the fact that action is finally being considered, but households deserve more than good intentions.

So, can the minister tell us when the Government expects to implement the CMA's recommendations and when consumers can expect to see tangible improvements? What timetable has been set for the Government's work on price transparency and consumer choice? And when will Parliament be updated on the progress? Those questions matter because winter does not wait for reviews, assessments, or consultations. Now, some of the announcements in the budget may have sounded impressive on the day, but for many households they will hardly be noticed.

There may be a hundred pounds for certain households, but when some people's energy bills are set to rise by more than £500, many will reasonably ask, what was the point? It is clear, however, that the Chancellor has at least noticed the Conservatives' cheap power plan: cutting VAT and scrapping carbon levies on energy bills. I do find myself wondering where he might have got those ideas from. The broader problem is that the Government appears more interested in managing the consequences of high energy prices, rather than addressing their causes. Happy to give way.

01:20:38 - 01:20:54

David William Smith

Just on that point about managing consequences, I welcome his positivity to the things that the Government are doing. But would he agree with me that it was a terrible idea for the last government to abandon the UK's gas storage in 2015?

01:20:54 - 01:23:26

Ashley Peter Fox

That is a complicated issue because, of course, the cost of managing Rough would have been a levy on gas bills. So, it's not quite the easy solution that he proposes. It's not as if it automatically reduces all gas bills. It may, actually, in the long term, lead to higher cost to gas consumers. So, it's an important issue, but it's not the simple fix that he claims.

The United Kingdom possesses significant oil and gas resources, world-class expertise, and a highly skilled workforce. Yet, key decisions continue to be delayed. The decision on Jackdaw, for example, was delayed for months. I wonder why. Could it possibly have been an inconvenient by-election in Holborn and St Pancras?

The future of Rosebank remains uncertain. Time and again, ministers have chosen hesitation over action. Good policy is not simply making an announcement, minister, it is having a plan, delivering that plan, and achieving results. That is the test by which households reliant on heating oil will judge this Government. Are their energy bills lower?

For millions of people, this debate is not about regulation or market design. It is about whether they can afford to keep their homes warm this winter. And rural families should not be disadvantaged simply because they live beyond the gas grid. Affordable energy should not depend on your postcode. And far too often, this Government forgets our rural communities.

The Government talks repeatedly about managing expensive energy. That is not enough. People do not want energy, expensive energy to be managed. They want energy to be made affordable. So, let us have clear deadlines, measurable commitments, and action, not an obsession with process.

Because if ministers cannot tell households when they will feel the benefit of those reforms, all they're offering is more process and more delay. And families facing another winter of high costs cannot afford to wait. Mrs Barker, those households need lower bills, warmer homes, and a Government focus on making energy cheaper.

01:23:26 - 01:23:30

Paula Barker

Minister Polly Billington.

01:23:30 - 01:27:00

Polly Billington

Thank you very much, Mrs Barker, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. I have to say to everybody who has spoken in the debate that I thank them, and indeed, their correspondents and their constituents, for raising the issue of heating oil in the way in the powerful way that you have conveyed it here in this chamber.

It will be of little comfort to those people that the conditions that I find in my correspondence myself about heating oil keeps me awake at night, because it is a reality that, for far too many families in this country, the exposure to the global energy crisis is felt most hard by people who simply thought that this was the way they were going to be able to heat their homes for good. And that changes is profound and difficult transition for them, which we as a government have a responsibility to be able to support them through. There are those 1.5 million homes which people have talked about, they've talked about the thousands of people in their own constituencies and we recognize that there are those particular challenges. It is worthwhile, however, thinking about what how we are addressing that in the context of the wider global energy crisis and the efforts that we have already made.

This is an extremely difficult international backdrop. Some people have been mentioning how hopeful they are because of the in midterm results overnight. Let me reassure, I'm afraid, this chamber that even if there was to be a full and complete ceasefire in Iran now, we will not see a return to the kind of comparatively low prices that we had before this. We have had half of the recessions since 1973 have been a cause have been caused by fossil fuel shocks. And I would say to the honourable gentleman from Bridgwater, who I have an enormous amount of respect for,

if we are going to really protect these families in the future, we need to be getting off the fossil fuel roller coaster, not simply talking about drilling more anywhere at all, frankly. We know that oil and gas is going to continue to be part of our energy mix for some time to come, but the idea that we would continue to allow these families to be exposed to the fossil fuel roller coaster, for me, is a dereliction of duty. And therefore, that is why it is so important, for example, that we have committed to the boiler upgrade scheme. I'd like to correct slightly, my friend, the honourable gentleman for St Austell, is actually £9,000 for off-grid homes. And we have seen a 120% increase in the last quarter on how many people were applying this time last year.

That is an indication of the fact that people can see that if they want to reduce their exposure to the appalling consequences of this fossil fuel crisis, the best thing for them to do is to be able to take advantage of that scheme and adopt cleaner heat technology. I also want to reassure some colleagues who have mentioned the idea that possibly the housing stock in their communities is not suitable. Well, actually, the department has done a significant amount of work on this and it's suggested that more than 90% of households are actually suitable for heat pumps in the future and that would include many of the those households that are currently exposed. I do not think in any way, shape, or form that this on its own is enough. We have an urgent and an urgent emergency bearing in mind this is now early November and the costs of

Certainly.

01:27:00 - 01:27:23

Wendy Chamberlain

Grateful to the minister for giving way. In my own remarks, I made mention of the ECO4 scheme. I accept her statistics in terms of the suitability for heat pumps. For one of the key challenges, Ms. Barker, is the fact that we have little in the way of fully qualified tradespeople capable of carrying out this work, which is why my constituents have been left with completely substandard work when they've been trying to implement changes.

01:27:23 - 01:28:41

Polly Billington

Thank you very much. Well, I'm sure the honourable lady will agree with me that what will be really helpful will be the Scottish Government to understand the importance of devolving the responsibilities for this kind of thing to local government in Scotland, and ensure that they have the skills powers and potential in order to be able to deliver the jobs, the skills that will be required in order to be able to do this. That's part of our commitment under the Warm Homes Plan. I would like to see that fully implemented in cooperation, because I believe in problem-solving, not point-scoring. And we will hope to see we can work with our partners north of the border on that.

It is important to think about the about this in the context of the other things that we have done. Remember that £100 household energy payment, which colleagues will be seeing in their well, everyone will be seeing in their everyone who has a council a house in council tax bands A to D from January, 19% of those homes are in rural areas. That's 3.9 million people. 19% of the people that are qualifying are in rural communities. So, the idea that this will not reach those people is not true.

Remember the temporary zero rate on VAT on domestic electricity extends 98% of people who use heating oil are also on the electricity grid, that will benefit them. The government is also providing Certainly.

01:28:41 - 01:29:02

Andrew Snowden

I thank the minister for giving way on that point. In terms of the numbers that the minister has just quoted with regard to the band A to D council tax that's in rural areas, does the minister know how many of those houses are not actually connected to the grid so we can see whether it is the people in villages in the small houses in villages, or whether it is actually getting to the people who use heating oil or not?

01:29:02 - 01:29:45

Polly Billington

I thank the honourable gentleman for allowing me to clarify that 19% of the people who qualify are in rural communities and off-grid. So that is this specific. So I'm pleased to be able to see that they will be able to benefit. Remember also, everybody who is on the electricity grid is being able to benefit from the reduction of by £150 of the policy costs off our bills, as well as the fact that we have extended the Warm Home Discount for people on means-tested benefits to 6 million households of a £150 rebate. These are not inconsequential efforts in order to be able to take some of the pressure off people and create the breathing space that is absolutely required.

I give way to the honourable gentleman from Strangford.

01:29:45 - 01:30:21

Jim Shannon

I thank the minister for a very confident approach to the questions. And the minister is right there, it's about solutions, always life's about solutions, and I thank her for that. In my constituency, I mentioned through my contribution that 82% of my rural community live need oil to survive. So therefore the impact upon them is greater than anyone else. Minister and Government have given some help towards that, but the fact that such a large proportion of my constituency, and across Northern Ireland where it's 65%, has the Government and has the minister any other ideas perhaps how help and alleviation can be given to those who depend upon heating oil in its entirety?

01:30:21 - 01:34:00

Polly Billington

I thank the honourable gentleman. We've allocated £17 million to Northern Ireland for this, for precisely the reason that there are so many people who are dependent on heating oil in Northern Ireland. But I think it is also important to make sure that the Northern Ireland Assembly and the administration there takes up the opportunities to be able to shift people and accelerate people away from the dependence on heating oil by using similar kinds of schemes to the Boiler Upgrade Scheme that we have in England and Wales. A lot of people talked about the Competition and Markets Authority recommendations, and the fact that we are accepting those recommendations to regulate. Can I tell you that this is a long time in coming?

And I would like to remind the member for Bridgwater that we had a an oil crisis when his party was in charge. There was not a decision to call in the CMA, there was not a decision to regulate. And, in fact, people who've been involved in energy campaigning and strategy for a long time are saying, "Thank goodness, this has been decades in the coming."

The fact that we have not had regulation in this space has caused significant amount of problems for decades. And it is in the Energy Independence Bill that has been published today where we will be able to bring forward a new general authorization regime where we will be taking the powers needed to bring heating oil within a proportionate regulatory framework and strengthen protections for consumers, particularly vulnerable households. Now for this winter, I will say because that regulation will take time to get right and I'm sure honorable friends and colleagues will be aware of the fact that there are high risks in regulating at speed unless you are absolutely clear that you have ironed out all the put all the potential risks. We need to ensure that there is a voluntary cooperation with UKIFDA and the NROIF to ensure that those people are to the providers are signing up to voluntary codes of conduct and behaving properly in this winter. Because remember it was this Competition and Markets Authority that enabled themselves the in- enforced and secured compensation for consumers who were ending up being either having their orders cancelled or being charged excessively at the beginning of this conflict.

That is the kind of regulation that we need to be able to see in the future, and I am keen that we will be able to do that, including on minimum order volumes which people have talked about, and indeed payment schemes. Because it is unconscionable that on a on electricity, one can have a fixed tariff, and one can have a direct debit, and one can even if one is really struggling, you can have a prepayment meter, and yet you do not have the same way of managing things if you are on heating oil. So I am extraordinarily grateful to everybody who has made contributions to the debate today. I'm conscious of time and do want the honorable gentleman from Caithness and Sutherland to be able to sum up. But can I assure people that this that the heat heating oil and the concerns of rural communities when it comes to exposure to the fossil fuel roller coaster and the global energy crisis is absolutely in the forefront of my mind as the energy minister for consumers, and it is absolutely essential that we establish an energy market that works for people, notwithstanding particular ways of helping at the moment, but long term, we reform the energy retail market not only for those on heating oil, but for everyone, so that we are benefiting from the clean energy that we are generating ourselves and give ourselves a resilience and security that we have previously not been able to do because of our exposure to fossil fuel shocks.

Thank you.

01:34:00 - 01:34:03

Paula Barker

Jamie Stone to wind up.

01:34:03 - 01:34:37

James Jamie Stone

Thank you very much. I shall wind up very briefly by saying that it's is most encouraging, I think, to be absolutely honest, to see a minister who does seem to be on top of a brief. I think a generally good impression has been received. I want to thank each and every single person, honorable, right honorable, who's spoken, because I think that the collective discussion we've had today does advance our cause in the right direction. And that I think is one of the better things we do in this place, and I hope people watching this debate will take some comfort from it.

I thank you.

01:34:37 - 01:36:39

Paula Barker

Question is that this House has considered the impact of heating oil prices on rural areas. As many as are of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Order.

Apologies for the late start, it is because of the earlier division. Order. I will call Lola McEvoy to move the motion and I will then call the minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up, as is the convention, for thirty-minute debates.

Lola McEvoy to move the motion.

01:36:39 - 01:36:52

Speaker 69

I beg to move that this House has considered the police powers for tackling the use of illegal off-road bikes in the North East. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Barker.

01:36:52 - 01:36:59

Paula Barker

The question is that this House has considered police. Sorry, apologies, carry on.

01:36:59 - 01:37:56

Laura Marie McEvoy

Thank you. I'd like to take this opportunity to thank all of the members across the House who've come to support the need for more police powers, police resources, and a multi-departmental approach to tackling the scourge of e-bikes, battery-powered bikes, and off-road bikes on our streets. Since I was elected along with this Labour government in July 2024, it has become increasingly clear that battery-powered bikes are the getaway vehicle of choice for those who do not respect the rule of law. And I'd just like to take a moment to alert the House to my constituent, Julie Francis, who's in the gallery today. Julie's mother was killed in Sunderland by a teenager illegally riding an off-road bike, and she is as determined as am I that we get more resources and justice for Gloria and Julie and the family.

01:37:56 - 01:37:58

Speaker 65

I will give way on that point.

01:37:58 - 01:38:19

Lewis Atkinson

I thank my honourable friend for giving way and for securing this debate. Gloria Stephenson was my constituent in Sunderland Central, and her tragic death in Ryhope really affected our community. Does my honourable friend agree that we need swifter action, as shown by the amount of members here, so we prevent tragic deaths like those of my constituent in the future?

01:38:19 - 01:38:56

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank my honourable friend for his intervention, and I absolutely do agree that we need more powers, more action, and more police on our streets to tackle this. I would ask that the minister consider the following powers and resource points on this issue in her remarks. As you know, as the minister knows, we have met previously to discuss this. This is a cross-departmental issue, and we will be meeting as a group with the Department for Transport to address some of the licensing issues, but this debate is focused on what the police need now. I will give way.

01:38:56 - 01:39:29

Jim Shannon

And I share her concerns, as I we have the same concerns with us back home. We've been working on a cross-party through the assembly, a group to ensure that the justice bill will come in and make the changes where the PSNI can seize the scooters and the bikes right away without even without any warning. So, does the honourable lady agree that committing the minister should perhaps commit herself, I know she will anyway, to sharing best practice across the region to stop these reckless riders from turning our public parks into dangerous race tracks?

01:39:29 - 01:40:13

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank the my honourable friend for his intervention.

As always, he makes a clear and coherent point on why we need to support this debate. So, I would ask that the minister consider bolstering the police powers around support for our communities. Our communities are regularly reporting antisocial behaviour in the form of balaclava-clad battery bike riders, and the problem that the police have is that they do not have the resources to send out a police helicopter and a full squad to chase down every single report of antisocial behaviour. The issue that we have in Darlington and across the North East is that these are also the vehicles of choice for organised crime. So I will.

01:40:13 - 01:41:06

Julie Minns

I mean I thank my honourable friend and we've worked very closely on this. Thank you. I think it's very helpful to understand that we're talking about two types of bike here: we're talking about dirt bikes, which have been around for over a hundred years, and we're talking about e-bikes. The problem we have is that when a dirt bike is written is ridden on-road, in a park, etc, because it is un- unlicensed, it becomes illegal. Similarly with a non-compliant, electrically assisted pedal cycle, when it's ridden on-road or in a park, it immediately becomes illegal.

Now does my honourable friend agree with me that non-compliant e-bikes and those horrible kits that now create them should be banned from sale? It's something that a number of police, fire and crime commissioners have asked for across the country. And on dirt bikes, I feel, does she agree that the solution would be for dirt bikes when they are sold to have a registered keeper, and if they're going to be used off-road, to have a SORN notice registered?

01:41:06 - 01:41:44

Laura Marie McEvoy

Hear. I thank my learned and honourable friend, who is the expert in this House on this issue, and I absolutely, wholeheartedly agree. In the interests of time, I won't reiterate the points that I agree with because I agree with all of it, and it was part of my speech, so please do address that, minister, in your wind-ups. I agree that we do need to ban them from sale, but I am concerned about the use of antisocial behaviour as a mitigation against police being forced to take action on these issues. I would like to increase the prolific use of off-road electric bikes in our communities and to a criminal offence, and I will give way on that point.

01:41:44 - 01:42:22

Jonathan Brash

Really grateful to my honourable friend for giving way. One way I think that we can help the police is to better educate the public on this issue. As we're in the run-up to Christmas right now, I think it's generally misunderstood that these e-bikes are not legal in our parks, they are not legal on our roads, they are not legal on our pavements. And as one of my constituents, a young member of my constituents found out to his cost, he rode it on the road, it was seized, he'd only owned it a couple of weeks, and it was crushed. Should we not be saying to parents, can we not say to parents in this place, do not buy them this Christmas, because you are likely to lose them?

01:42:22 - 01:42:45

Laura Marie McEvoy

I absolutely agree with my honourable friend on his points there, and I have written to some of the high street retailers where you can buy some of the battery-powered scooters which are prolific in the younger generation. Children are using them, and they're also using them to copycat and mimic some of the criminals that we're seeing across the town in Darlington. That is an escalation in antisocial behaviour, and it's really dangerous for those children. I will.

01:42:45 - 01:43:04

Amanda Martin

Thank you. Would my honourable friend agree with me that we could ask the minister if they consider some targeting funding? It was really successful when we looked at the safer streets programme and when we looked at the shoplifting element and we had a police operation. So if we had some targeted funding with better intelligence and actually transparent data about where bikes are being seized and crushed. Uh.

01:43:04 - 01:44:07

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. I do agree that we need targeted funding, and I would ask that we would see targeted funding for police vehicles in Durham and the wider constabularies across the North East, because the police being able to use a motor vehicle, motorbike as a police team is actually really effective in catching these criminals.

The problems that we've got are that we cannot We are just in a game of cat and mouse with the police having to go round all of the alleys in Darlington and across the North East, and that isn't enough power for the police. We need deterrents as well. One of the deterrents I would I'll just make some progress. One of the deterrents that I would ask that the police that the policing Minister consider is around repeat reporting in hot spots and areas, seeing that we need more resources for neighbourhood policing as to act as a deterrent. And when we see repeated anti-social behaviour and off-road bikes mentioned for an estate or a part of the town, we would like to see some increased police resources to those areas to tackle just that.

I will give way on that point.

01:44:07 - 01:44:44

Luke Akehurst

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. She's being very generous with her time today, and I thank her for her tireless work on this issue. At a recent meeting I convened on this issue at Beamish Museum with stakeholders, including the police, local authorities, emergency services and community groups, a key theme was the need for stronger enforcement powers. Will she join me in urging the Minister to extend to PCSOs as well as police officers the powers to stop and seize these bikes and report road traffic offences, giving them the tools they need to tackle this persistent anti-social behaviour?

01:44:44 - 01:45:25

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. I do agree that PCSOs do need the powers further powers to be able to tackle the use of these bikes and to seize them. I myself went and attended a crushing, if that's what it's called, it seems new to my vocabulary, of 70 of these vehicles, which was incredibly satisfying. And I did, I really enjoyed myself. But I would say, it is not enough to confiscate them, because what the public want to see is they don't they don't want to see them.

They don't want them on the streets. We need to prohibit the sale of them. We need some consequences for those selling them. But we do also need community strengthened powers to ban them from areas. I will give way on that point.

01:45:25 - 01:45:59

Adam Dance

I thank you for being very kind with your time. Just on community, a lot of residents in my constituency are scared to leave their home because of these scooters and e-bikes with masks on and balaclavas, as you said. I spoke to a resident the other day who hasn't left her home in three weeks because last time she did, she was knocked over and the police are just not doing more. So, on PCC PCSOs, should would the Minister, through you, agree and write to Avon and Somerset Police to give them the authority to have handcuffs, because we're one of the only places in the country where our PCSOs don't have handcuffs?

01:45:59 - 01:47:13

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. Unfortunately, I don't know enough about that bit of the legislation, but I am sure that the Minister does and will address that point. I do think they are intimidating. The mask, the use of balaclavas to evade detection, the fact that these bikes are not licensed, they're not plated means that and they're not chipped, so it means that they have just got a getaway vehicle. And obviously, if the police were to catch and prosecute them, they could confiscate them and crush them, but in that in and of itself is not enough of a deterrent and the balance is weighted in favour of those using them.

I would like to see the Minister consider some of the some of the points that we've made, because what we're seeing is an increase in the blatant disregard for the law. So, we're seeing these criminals wearing the balaclavas, reports of them drug-dealing in plain sight in the street, reports of them carrying machetes and other very dangerous weapons. And it seems to be that they are willing to take the risk, because they don't think they're going to get caught. Now, the police are making incredible headway, as I said, with that Operation Orb, which is about seizing and crushing them, but it seems to be weighted in favour of the criminals. And

01:47:13 - 01:47:15

Speaker 65

I will give way on that point.

01:47:15 - 01:47:43

Lee Pitcher

I thank her for giving way. In Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme, this is not just destroying lives, it destroys livelihoods as well.

People are scared to go to community centres that we're giving grants to get people out, but they won't go to them. And we've got farmers in rural communities who are having their livelihoods just swept away from them by this horrible, awful scourge. Does she agree to me, agree with me, and will the Minister give us some reassurance that we're going to put much more preventative measures in for our police to actually catch these people?

01:47:43 - 01:49:18

Laura Marie McEvoy

I absolutely agree with my honourable friend on the point that he's made. I would ask that the Minister consider addressing some of the powers around this particular use of off-road vehicles and antisocial behaviour orders, because what we're seeing is the facility for us to use a PSPO to ban the use of balaclavas and off-road bikes in the town centre, for example, in Darlington, which I have called for, but that would mean that a police officer would then have to go, find somebody who wasn't committing a crime, but was actually wearing a balaclava and using an off-road bike, so in breach of a civil in breach of this PSPO, and then find them and then issue them with a £100 fine. So I would ask that the policing Minister address some of the concerns about the deterrent being skewed and not in favour of the public, because it's not enough of a deterrent, £100 fine, and you have to be caught. We need to make sure that there are other deterrents in place, like the confiscation, yes, but problems maybe with the licence of riding these, and also, who's buying these vehicles? So we know, as my honourable friend for Hartlepool mentioned, you can buy these scooters from the high street, but you can also buy these kits, as the member for Carlisle knows well, online, and you can effectively change what could be seen by a parent as a pretty safe and fun vehicle to make it a really dangerous vehicle, and that is something that we need to address.

So we need to see some more deterrents and tougher punishments for that. I will give way on that point.

01:49:18 - 01:49:46

James Jonathan Hinder

I thank my honourable friend for leading this debate, and her national leadership on this issue. She makes really important points about additional powers, but of course those powers need policing resource. We debated just in this chamber, Mrs Barker, a few weeks ago the real financial challenges that Durham Constabulary have in meeting the requirements of increasing crime. Would the honourable member agree with me that as well as additional powers, Durham police must have the proper funding it needs to really lead a crackdown on this appalling problem?

01:49:46 - 01:52:23

Laura Marie McEvoy

I absolutely do agree wholeheartedly with my honourable friend. It is right that Durham police have not got the funding formula in fa- in their favour. We do need funding formula reform, and we do need it soon. What I would say as well, in addition to that, is that it is all well and good funding neighbourhood policing, which we know will act as a deterrent, but we simply do not have the resources to tackle the organised and very serious crime that is often masked as antisocial behaviour. So I would argue that this scourge of the use of balaclava-clad electric battery-powered bikes and dirt bikes on our roads is encouraging more blatant flouting of the law in other areas.

I would also ask that the Minister address the fact that we're seeing a very comprehensive attempt by communities to report, and that then the reporting of these and of the crimes or the use of these off-road bikes, by the time somebody turns up, the police turn up, they've obviously fled on these vehicles wearing a balaclava, completely unidentified. So I would ask that there is some investigation into tracking on the sale of these bikes, or other ways that we can identify some of the wearers who are blatantly dealing drugs in the town and around in the surrounding areas. I know that the Minister will be meeting with the Department for Transport to address lots of these issues in a cross-part cross-departmental approach, but I would ask that Durham police and our North East police forces, as we are on the front line for this, is seen as a pilot for any interventions.

We know that we've had drones from our police crime commissioners. The drones are only as good as the police officers on the ground who can follow them. It's all well and good seeing where the bikes are going, but if they cannot then go and identify those who are using them because it's seen as too little of a crime to be driving one on the road, then it's not in their interest to use those resources to follow those. It's also not in police's interest to do to engage in a very dangerous high-speed chase down the main roads, because they also know that will endanger pedestrians. So, I would ask that the Minister understand some of the challenges that we're facing in Darlington and the surrounding areas.

And I urge her to see this not as a as an MP clutching her pearls and saying, "We're a lovely town," which we are, and we deserve better, but as a canary down the mine for what criminals think they can get away with. And if it's happening in Darlington in the North East, you can bet your bottom dollar it'll be happening right the way across the country. Thank you.

01:52:23 - 01:52:25

Paula Barker

Minister Sarah Jones.

01:52:25 - 01:54:42

Sarah Jones

Thank you and it's a pleasure, Ms. Barker, to serve under your chairmanship. And can I thank my honorable friend for securing what is a very timely and important debate? Can I start by the making the basic point that I absolutely recognize the challenges that she describes? As an MP myself in Croydon, I have very similar challenges, and I think probably across the country, there are very similar challenges with this emerging and nasty problem that we have with both off-road bikes and e-bikes and e-scooters, who I think it's safe to say, every MP probably in the country has a challenge with. So, I want to start by saying that.

I also want to start by saying what a privilege it was to meet with my honorable friend and her constituent to talk about the awful death of her mother, and how impactful that experience was for me in thinking about the need for us to act and the need for us to do more. And I hope that I hope that those MPs and those conversations that have been had with other people as well who've lost loved ones or been injured, that they can be reassured that we are looking very carefully at this challenge at the moment in the Home Office and across government. I would say on the sort of wider issue around funding and the wider issue of how we tackle these challenges, I am acutely aware, and my honorable friend said, how important it is to make sure we have police presence in our communities, and very aware of the challenges that the North East has more widely in terms of police funding and police numbers. And I know exactly what my honorable friend is going to ask me, but I will very happily give way.

01:54:42 - 01:54:55

Speaker 78

My constituents so I would continue to bang on about it, just to urge her to remember Cleveland Police in all of the conversations she's having around police funding and, of course, the wider North East, which honorable members have mentioned.

01:54:55 - 01:56:26

Sarah Jones

I can thank my honorable friend for that intervention. The funding situation, as we know at the moment in terms of Cleveland, is that we have secured the money to cover the mutual aid costs that Cleveland have borne, just over 5 million. Durham and Cleveland are both in a position of having applied for what we're calling sort of exceptional finance for next year, and Durham and Cleveland are both sort of through to the next stage, which is that CIPFA are doing an analysis of the challenges. That will look at the financial resilience of the organizations.

It will also look at the context within which they are operating. So, both of those forces will be going through to that. We are doing a lot of internal work at the moment on the funding formula, which we will be saying more about soon, but the exceptional finance will be for this financial year to this to it's an annual year starts in January, but the announcements will be made in December. So, we are looking at those issues now. And obviously, within the funding window, it is important to say that local police are operationally independent.

So, in terms of the tactics that they want to pursue, it is for them to make those decisions. The questions, many questions about what we can do at a national level to support the tackling of this challenge, as Yes.

01:56:27 - 01:57:15

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

I thank the minister for giving way, and I want to emphasize, of course, that my constituents in Newcastle really want to see extra resource and devolved powers to our local authorities in order to address the scourge of e-bikes, as my honourable friend the member for Darlington so eloquently put it. But I also want to make her aware, if she is not, that the Royal Victoria Infirmary in Newcastle, a consultant there told me that the hospital's 36% rise in open leg fractures in the last 3 years is due to increased e-bike use. That is a cost to in young lives. It's a cost to the NHS. And I hope is she working with her colleagues in the Department for Health and Social Care to address to see look at the costs and how they can be addressed by the policy she can put in place?

01:57:15 - 02:00:20

Sarah Jones

Can I thank my honourable friend for that intervention? And that is a shocking statistic, and certainly we will take that away and see whether that is replicated, ask our colleagues in the NHS to see whether there is data on that and how that's sort of gathered, but that would be very useful. In terms of sort of what more we can do, I'm having at the moment a series of conversations with MPs. I'm going to do a couple of round tables. I know there are a lot of MPs who are interested in this space.

I understand there is a WhatsApp as well. And I know that the there are lots who want to give their views. We have obviously taken some steps in terms of the power to seize these vehicles and not having to give notice, and also the power to extend dispersal orders, being able to dispose of these vehicles quicker than before. And just one point that my honourable friend made about the fines for PSPOs breaches, we've increased those fines to £500. So, it's not the answer to everything, but it is at least something in terms of going up from that £100 to the £500.

What we are looking at is a number of different areas, all of which, you know, have been suggested today, are things that we are looking at. I can't promise that there will be magic money in terms of being able to, which I would like to do, sort of wave a wand and give all police forces extra money to tackle this problem. But we are very much looking at this challenge in the round, and I know the Home Secretary is very interested in this area, too. There are legal changes that we can think about, which obviously involve needing to have legislation and going through that process. So, what are the things we could do sooner rather than later?

How much can we corral the policing where, in some forces, you're seeing quite big operations that are taking quite a lot of our vehicles these vehicles off the streets and are disposing of them? Can we look at that as a nationwide thing? There is issues around training for officers that we're looking at. So, you need to have to be able to pursue, and my honourable friend talked about the dangers that comes with that, but in order to be able to pursue, you need a level of training in terms of driving. And is there an issue there we need to look at in terms of the number of officers that we are training?

I talked only today with the new inspector His Majesty's Inspectorate about this, who has just started his new role, was the head of the College of Policing, about what are the kind of things in that space that we can think about that we can think about doing. There's obviously a big piece of work to be done across government about what are the rules about how these things can be used and the point that honourable friend made about people not really understanding that a lot of this is illegal I think is absolutely the right one. The existing legal situation about what you can do and what you can't do I think is messy and we need to try and work across government to do that. Yes, of course.

02:00:20 - 02:01:22

Laura Marie McEvoy

Thank you, that's kind. So, but I think, in the interests of time and the style of the debate, maybe there are a few avenues that, on this, easy wins that I would like to have addressed earlier and maybe she could address now. One of the issues that we have is that a lot of the people who are, when they are caught, are under 18 and do not have a driver's licence. Is there any avenue through the parenting orders where, if your child is caught riding one of these and on the road, that there are consequences as a knock-on for your driver's licence, because we had an incident in Darlington where parents wanted the confiscated vehicle back and were ringing up the police saying, "When can I get it back?" And they and it was similar to when a teacher takes a child's phone for using it in school.

It's not the same thing: these are illegal and dangerous and they have no place on the road, so I think we need to differentiate that for parents with some consequences if we can't do it for the young people themselves.

02:01:22 - 02:03:26

Sarah Jones

My honourable friend raises a good point about what to do with the under 18s. We've just introduced respect orders, which are useful in this space, because I think people who are consistently anti-social and are driving these bikes are prime suspects for respect orders, which we know can be a criminal offence. You can end up in prison if you breach your conditions. They are not they do not apply to the under 18s. And I think the general conversation about our under 18s and how we make sure whatever the anti-social behaviour is that there are deterrents and interventions and support where we need it as well, where the parenting is, you know, where the child is perhaps vulnerable are things that we need to look at and I will take that away and commit to looking at that.

I was just talking about how we need to look across government and look at the different laws that exist around these vehicles, and we need to make sure we're thinking in the Home Office about exactly what bit of legislation, what change, what corralling can we do within policing, how can we send out these messages about what's legal and what's not legal. All of these issues we are considering in the Home Office. Now is the time to have these conversations because we are sort of gathering what is feasible and what we can do. I think there is a general point around bikes and anti-social behaviour, which is that sort of post-COVID, I think there has been a big increase in anti-social behaviour that we have not kept on top of in terms of policing and in terms of, largely because of resources. And this is a symptom of that, where we have to make it clear to our communities that there is a way to behave, there is a thing to do, there will be consequences if you don't stick within the law.

And the message to all of our law-abiding, fair citizens should be you are abiding by the law, and we are grateful to that, these other people will not get away with what they're doing. So I think I am very much listening to what are the quick wins, what is the longer term we need to do through legislation, and how can we make sure this is not seen as something that is acceptable in any way. I'm looking at the honourable lady in case she wants to intervene again before I Yeah.

02:03:26 - 02:04:25

Laura Marie McEvoy

Thanking the honourable lady the minister for being so generous with her time. One of the things that comes up a lot on the doorstop when we're talking about this issue is that it's the same small group, and everybody knows who it is. So they might say, "Oh, everybody knows who it is and they're always driving these bikes in and out the house and everybody knows who it is."

Obviously I don't when they're telling me, because they won't tell you who it is. So, there's an issue there with policing and the neighborhood policing, but I would ask that is there any support that the minister can think of to give please around repeated multi problem hot spots and families where it is known by the community because it is driving down police confidence from the public, but it's also driving down how people feel on a day-to-day basis as has been raised by many of our friends across the house that it's making people intimidated, it's making people scared, it's making people miserable as well as being a danger. So I wondered if she'd address that point.

02:04:25 - 02:05:42

Sarah Jones

She makes a very good point. I mean, I think there is a wider issue here of the years of austerity that have ripped away services that supported parents and families to be the best that they can be, whether that's Sure Start or whether it's the various iterations of sort of family interventions that have happened over the years that have just been ripped away, so the police can do so much. I think there's an infrastructure issue around our other public services, but, of course, that's something we will look at. I just wanted to touch briefly on PCSOs because that was raised a couple of times. There are certain powers that PCSOs have that are given to them by each force.

So the issue of whether you can zones, others are not. So there is a kind of basic level of, you know, they can't arrest, they can't be carrying weapons. They, you know, there are certain rules about what PCSOs can do, but within that, local forces do have some flexibility. So I'll take that away, the questions about PCSOs and what they can do.

I'm always keen to encourage us to have more PCSOs and to use them as much as possible. So I would give them, you know, I'm very happy to take that away and look Yes.

02:05:42 - 02:06:38

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank the honorable lady for giving way on that point. I want to just put on record and I'm sure everybody will agree with me, what a stellar job the PCSOs on the beat in Darlington, across the Northeast and across the house do because they're taking huge personal risk for very low pay and often, you know, gruelling shifts. I had one PCSO who would not like me to name her, who was incredibly brave and found somebody, two people on this off-road bike, followed them and jumped them and got the bike back. And when they turned round and realised that she was on her own, they came back and they got the bike back and assaulted her. And I found it really, deeply disturbing to see that's the level that we're at in a lovely town like Darlington.

It's not right that we should be seeing that sort of the balance so skewed in favour of those who do not respect the law. So I ask the minister to keep that her in mind when increasing the powers of PCSOs.

02:06:38 - 02:07:57

Sarah Jones

I will certainly keep that in mind and there are lots of extraordinary examples of PCSOs showing great bravery and being, you know, really crime prevention agents as well as fighting crime in our local communities. And it would be wrong of me not to also say that, you know, there are three police officers who have died in the honorable lady's region over the last year, and you know, we obviously pay tribute to them and what they have given for their country and we will continue to do that and be very grateful to for what the police do. So in conclusion, I think I absolutely am here and I'm having lots of conversations about the need to look at this challenge, recognise it, and see it. The Home Secretary recognises and sees it, and we are very much in the market for kind of what are the things that we can do, so it's a very helpful time to have this conversation and this debate, and I, you know, thank all the honorable members who've contributed and do encourage them to keep talking to me and to others in the Home Office.

I will convene some sessions where we can do this in a round-table way, and I think we need a proper cross-government session as well. But thank you very much to my honourable friend for raising such an important debate.

02:07:57 - 02:08:11

Paula Barker

The question is that this House has considered police powers for tackling the use of illegal off-road bikes in the North East. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

02:08:11 - 02:09:37

Speaker 82

Order. Order. Patrick Spencer to move the motion.

02:09:37 - 02:13:16

Patrick Spencer

Thank you very much, Ms. Barker. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairwomanship. Can I thank everybody for staying a little bit later as the House rises and everyone disappears on recess? I will be honest, upon being elected, my focus was fighting for better schools in Ipswich and rural NHS services in Suffolk, as well as supporting our small and independent business sector. I never, in a moment, imagined that I'd become immersed in road maintenance as an issue, but of course, events changed that.

Over the last 12 months, the condition of roads across my constituency of Central Suffolk and North Ipswich have deteriorated massively. This has largely been a consequence of three major problems that have converged perfectly. First, extreme weather exacerbates fractures in the road surface, more commonly known as freeze-thaw cycle. It involves rainwater seeping into cracks before freezing in sub-zero temperatures and expanding in the process. Now, in November 2025, there was some 107 mm of rain across Suffolk.

That was followed by a significant cold snap in late November, with temperatures on the night of the 20th of November dropping well below 0 degrees centigrade. Overnight frosts continued for the rest of December, somewhat unsurprisingly for that time of year. These conditions wreak havoc on our roads. Now, secondly, there's been a significant uptick in heavy-duty traffic across Suffolk roads. This is a consequence of increased activity at Sizewell C, at the Sizewell C site, as well as increased housing construction across the county.

On any one day, there can be between 500 and 600 heavy-duty vehicles, some with police escorts carrying abnormally large loads, using the A12 between Martlesham and Leiston on a daily basis.

Then, there's been the proliferation of new housing developments, which brings with it more activity of HGVs along quiet country roads. East Suffolk's housing target has gone for approximately 800 homes per year to more than 1,600. Mid Suffolk has seen their housing target more than double as well. Brampsford, Framlingham, Wickham Market, Debenham are all expanding towns that have ancient road works connecting them to the outside world. The point of this speech is not to bemoan the impact construction is having on residents.

That is for a different day. Nor is it to question the ongoing commitment by Sizewell C to manage congestion on the A12, a topic they are very much alive to and are trying to manage. This is about the impact that development and others are having on the road surfaces around our country. Lastly, the third cause of poor road conditions across Suffolk in recent years, in my opinion, has been a shift in the way we allocate capital. The A12 was partially de-trunked in 2001, meaning everything north of Ipswich has fallen in terms of strategic importance and priority.

It joined the A11 A1120 and other arterial roads under the responsibility of the local highways authority, which spent years dealing with short-term funding arrangements, and then sorry, inflation-eroded longer-term pay deals. Now, I said this morning to the BBC that this debate shouldn't be about point scoring, so I'd like to pay credit to Suffolk County Council in recent years. Progress has been made in dealing with the problem. Between 2021 and 2025, they repaired some 88,329 potholes. Each year, more potholes were repaired than were reported, showing that the council was not only responding to new issues, but also dealing with existing defects.

02:13:16 - 02:13:19

Speaker 83

Of course, I give way to the honourable right honourable

02:13:19 - 02:13:57

Jim Shannon

The honourable gentleman is bringing forward an issue which, of course, is for Suffolk, but the fact of the matter is, Madam Chair, potholes are a major issue in all our constituencies. But is the honourable gentleman aware of a new system of repairing potholes? I understand that there'll be a cost factor laying out, but the return is they fix the potholes quicker, more efficiently and better. And if we've got a better system of doing it then, is it not time for government perhaps to encourage all the councils to use that new system and make sure that the potholes are repaired better, quicker, and the issue for the motorist is taken away in a quicker time?

02:13:57 - 02:23:40

Patrick Spencer

I thank the honourable gentleman for his comment. He's either read my speech or, as usual, he's far ahead of the curve, because I will get on to talking about the Dragon Patcher and the JCB Pothole Pro later on in my speech, but he's absolutely right. Back to where I was going, though. Today, only 3% of Suffolk's A road network is in poor condition, better than the English average, where the with the proportion in good condition broadly aligned to national figures. Suffolk's B and C roads also outperform national averages, with a high share in good condition and significantly fewer in poor condition.

Of course, residents are still angry about the state of the roads and disruption caused by road works. I am one of those residents. I've got to drive, not unfortunately not every day of the week because I'm here, but we use our country roads to get our children to and from school every day. I know exactly what it's like dodging potholes on a regular basis. And that's why we're here debating how we can improve the situation.

I recognise as well, as I said at the beginning, not at the beginning, but just recently, I recognise as well that the Department for Transport has increased substantial amounts of funding for potholes, an astronomic increase in funding, actually, which should be recognised as well. But I also know that the Department for Transport recently gave Suffolk County Council a red warning for road maintenance performance in January 2026, as part of its new accountability mechanism for holding highways authorities to account for their performance. Now, I am in favour of holding public bodies to account. I think it's a good thing.

It is only unfortunate that in this situation they managed to make a slight mess of the methodology. However, my first challenge to the minister would be what lessons have been learned from that entire process? I'm very wary of a system that ranks a local authority as failing when their road networks rank above average in terms of conditions. My life in the school system is fraught with this issue, where schools that achieve very good grades are also ranked as failing by Ofsted.

So, I understand that it's complicated from that perspective. But the traffic light system also includes a decarbonisation test: councils lose five points from their best practice score if they fail to prove evidence, provide evidence of plans to decarbonise maintenance operations and increase climate resilience. I also want to challenge him on what remedial support will be made available to local authorities who do not fare well on this interactive map. There have been confusing stories of support given to high-performing local authorities, whereas failing ones will be offered expert advice. Expert advice, in my opinion, is almost always useless when resources are not meeting demand.

So, can he take a moment to confirm what steps the government will take to help local authorities, like Suffolk, when they are judged to be not fulfilling their statutory role? But, as I said, the purpose of this speech is to look to the future to look further to the future and probe this government's position on a number of other long-term issues that may offer long-term remediation to the state of our road network, and not just in Suffolk, but across the country. Like I said, I recognise the government has provided more than £7 billion in funding road maintenance in funding for road maintenance over the next four years. This will kick up slightly more to £2 billion a year. It is absolutely it's absolutely right that we recognise that this was an increase a significant increase in funding, much in the same way, by the way, I would I think it's right that we recognise that is still less than what the Conservatives committed in their 2024 manifesto, which would have delivered more than £2 billion per year straight away.

But, anyway, can I ask the government to go further on a raft of issues? Firstly, will the government take reasonable steps to ensure highways authorities have access to technology and machinery that are imperative to quickly remediation of potholes in country settings? Suffolk County Council have recently deployed the use of a JCB Pothole Pro, on loan from JCB, I believe, and before that they leased the Dragon Patcher.

These are short-term and unstable arrangements. And if we want to deal with the proliferation of potholes, it strikes me as eminently sensible that local authorities are given the financial support to make the best technology available to them to sort potholes out. It's worth noting that the Conservative Plan for Drivers, launched by my leader in April 2026, commits to a national pothole patrol, with a national task force deploying hundreds of specialists repair units, using technologies such as JCB Pothole Pros to fix roads faster. Secondly, look, there is no doubt that British roads are in a worse condition than European comparators.

RAC Europe published a survey in 2024 which said six in 10 motorists say local roads in Europe are in better condition, with fewer potholes than the equivalent roads in the UK, with only a fifth thinking UK roads are in better shape than those in the continent. 57% of all drivers believe that there are less potholes on the motorways in Europe relative to the high-speed to the high-speed motorway in the UK. Despite this, plenty of people wonder why we don't deploy the same road maintenance strategies as other countries. Germany, the Swiss, the French have more efficient and technology-advanced approach to managing road maintenance.

The British government, however, does not hold data on how long councils take to repair potholes. Ministers can't tell us whether drivers are waiting longer for repairs than they used to. We rarely deploy road maintenance teams overnight on country roads while we give utility companies the power to start work immediately. Through an immediate emergency permit, we do not hold contractors to account for fast delivery of road maintenance works. I am inundated, and I'm sure others are too, with complaints from local residents who see traffic management mitigations in place but way before and way after workers are seen tending to remedial works.

Our roads are already clogged up with utility companies who carry out work on gas pipes, broadband wiring under strict regulations at low cost and involving different teams over a long period of time. This all strikes me, of course, as a classic example of British bureaucracy having a hugely negative impact on the state of British roads and our economy. The BBC published a report in 2026 which stated traffic disruption linked to roadworks cost the UK economy £4 billion between 2022 and 2023. So, what can the government do to relax the rules and the regulations around road maintenance, so that companies can carry out works at night quickly and without causing and causing as little disruption as possible? Third, next to the point above about deregulating road maintenance rules, I think everyone recognises, whichever side of the House you sit, that skills, or a lack thereof, is blighting the road infrastructure network.

In 2023, the Local Council Road Innovation Group released a report that said training budgets had dwindled, unsurprisingly in the face of prioritisation for other areas of the road maintenance budget. The quality of technical training was considered substandard with a bizarre overemphasis on net zero. The road infrastructure sector struggled with an image problem, with fewer young people looking at it as a potential career option, resulting in an ageing workforce. 36% of people in the road infrastructure construction sector are 55 years old or more. I read sorry, I read in a report online that there are some 140,000 vacancies despite a NEET population of more than a million.

I can't believe there isn't an easy solution to the problem of skills in road maintenance sector considering the underlying structure of our labour market at the moment. If we don't have the people, we won't be able to tackle something where scale is the major challenge. So, what is the government doing to encourage young people into the transport into the transport infrastructure, specifically road infrastructure sector? Lastly, can I probe the government's position on the long-term detrunking of strategically important roads? I said at the beginning of this speech that the A12 was detrunked north of Ipswich in 2001, and I'm still sort of perplexed as to why it hasn't been redesignated a critically important road, considering the fact we are building two nuclear reactors just off it.

The German road network is more centrally managed and as a result, it is far better managed, by the way. If they have longer-term funding visibility, which they do now, by the way, why wouldn't they want to broaden their remit and look after more elements of our road network, that's National Highways? Look, before ending, can I just tie this all up into what I think is an increasingly obvious perspective, that all of the above is futile if our economy doesn't grow?

02:23:40 - 02:23:51

Speaker 84

I will say this. This government, the Labour government, made the right decision by increasing funding. It was a, it was a mistake, a fundamental mistake,

02:23:51 - 02:25:01

Patrick Spencer

a consequence of the economic situation we faced in 2010, to cut budgets. I'm sure all people opposite are raring to go by the fact I've just given a speech that identified a load of problems with our road network that came from the year 2024. It is not lost on me. And I do implore the minister and, in fact, all other members to take this opportunity to try and rise somewhat,

don't give me an easy time, but rise somewhat from above the "It was all down to cuts, innit?" kind of attitude. I know the minister comes from a place that believes borrowing to spend on the infrastructure will drive long-term growth, but growth won't emerge without this government getting to grips with debt, the deficit, our welfare budget, and bringing down taxes on businesses.

We have a proud history of being at the forefront of the revolution that transformed road use when Thomas Telford and John McAdam started building roads with all-weather surfaces. There is no reason we cannot repeat history and become the best country in the world for roads. And I thank you for this, for your time. Thank you.

02:25:01 - 02:25:19

Paula Barker

Due to earlier divisions, the revised end time for this debate will now be 5:40 p.m. I remind members they should wish to bob if they wish to be called in the debate. And the question is that this House has considered potholes and road maintenance in Suffolk. I call Dr Peter Prinsley.

02:25:19 - 02:27:58

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, Ms Barker. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. I thank the honourable member for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich for securing this debate, sir. And what I would like to do is to invite all members to take a journey along the A143 between Ixworth and Stanton in my constituency. Although, I would recommend a sturdy vehicle with good suspension and at least a spare tire.

Now, this summer, the road made headlines all over the world because it was literally melting. And after months of closures and disruptions and repairs and long diversions, residents might reasonably have expected a road that they could drive on. But I'm sad to say the potholes are already back. There are slices of Swiss cheese with fewer holes than the A143. Now sadly, convention in this place does not allow me to show the drone video created by my assistant, Mr Tom Howard.

But this is available on all good social media channels, and I urge you to take a look at it. Now, the Reform administration at Suffolk County Council came into office promising a war on potholes. Well, several months into the war, I have to report that the potholes are winning. They are winning convincingly.

Now, how frustrating is that? The Labour government delivered a record £7.3 billion for local road maintenance for four years, giving councils funding and certainty to deliver lasting improvements. So the money is being provided, the tools are there, yet in Reform-run Suffolk, we still see the same roads repaired again and again.

Now, residents don't care much for party politics and party political slogans when they're dodging potholes on their school run.

They simply want safe roads, lasting repairs and value for money. Now, I wrote directly to the leader of Suffolk County Council asking for answers and a permanent solution. We need to know why have the repairs failed so quickly? And who is accountable? And is the Suffolk County Council demanding compensation from the contractor?

Because the people of Suffolk aren't asking for gold-plated roads. They're simply asking for roads where the tarmac stays down and the potholes stay filled. Thank you.

02:27:58 - 02:28:30

Speaker 89

Thank you very much, Ms Barker, it's a pleasure to serve under you today. And I think it's the second time my honourable friend has invited members of this House to visit his constituency. I am a regular visitor, it's a beautiful part of the world, but thank you for all you're doing on this issue and indeed the Ely-Haughley junction as well, which I'll come to. Every week, Ms Barker, I'm out talking to local residents and they raise the same thing over and over again with me, and that is potholes. And people in Ipswich and Suffolk are rightly fed up, and frankly, they have every right to be.

02:28:30 - 02:29:34

Speaker 91

This isn't something that's just occurred in the last year, this has been years of underinvestment. And what it is leaving, as my honourable friend has so well articulated, is rough and unpredictable surfaces which leave drivers with burst tyres, buckled wheels, expensive repairs. Cyclists are forced into rush-hour traffic to avoid dangerous craters. Parents are late to work because the school run revealed a new hole in the road. And for people across Ipswich and Suffolk, the state of our road network is not merely an inconvenience, it's a daily source of frustration, cost, and in some cases genuine danger.

So, that is why the publication of the government's road maintenance audit earlier this year was so important. And for the first time, we have an objective measure of how councils are performing when it comes to maintaining our roads. And results for Suffolk were incredibly disappointing, although not surprising for anybody who uses our roads. Suffolk received a red overall rating placing it amongst the worst-performing highways authorities in the country. But we have to be honest about what is and who is culpable for this situation.

02:29:34 - 02:33:29

Speaker 90

Is it the Conservatives at Suffolk County Council, who up until May this year were in power for there for over two decades? Was it their incompetence that led to one of the worst ratings in the country? Or was it the Conservative government here in Westminster? They were in power for 14 years and starved Suffolk and its roads of the investment we needed. This isn't just a little bit of rain.

This is huge underfunding. And between 2011 and 2020, Suffolk's annual highways allocation was cut from over £22 million to 17 and a half million. So whatever fancy unicorns we would have had in the 2024 general election manifesto, and I can only presume we put that in the same bucket the hospitals that never got funding, or Ely-Haughley, which was announced three times but never funded, we can't really believe anything that would happen given you had 14 years, or sorry, Madam Chair, the Conservatives had 14 years in power, and their record was cutting funding. Now, admittedly, this crept up a little bit towards the end of their time in office with the general election looming, but by then it's too little, too late. And the result was entirely predictable: short-term fixes became the norm, roads deteriorated, and taxpayers ended up paying more in the long run.

And this is the consequence when you marry disinterest and incompetence with a complete lack of funding as well. But I'm really pleased that our government is taking a fundamentally different approach. And to make that possible, as I'm sure the minister will come onto shortly, we're investing £7.3 billion in local roads over four years and doubling national road maintenance funding by the end of this Parliament. This is the biggest investment in road maintenance our country has ever seen. And that includes record funding for Suffolk.

And over the next four years, our county will receive £219 million to improve and maintain local roads. So, by 2029-30, funding will reach nearly £65 million a year in funding, nearly quadruple of what it was under the Conservatives in 2020. That is not a modest uplift around the tinkering around the edges or a temporary sticking plaster, it represents a fundamental change in how our roads are funded.

And instead of a hand-to-mouth approach, yearly settlements that we had under the Conservatives, this is a long-term funding commitment. So, councils like Suffolk County Council know exactly what they're getting for the next four years and can plan ahead. Instead of patch endless patch-and-mend repairs, they have the certainty and the resources to plan long-term improvements and prevent potholes from forming the in the first place, and that is what we all want to see. And that is the difference between managed decline we saw under the Conservatives and investing in renewal under our Government. However, I know investment alone is not enough and delivery matters, too.

And I will be clear, and I'll slightly depart from my honourable friend's assessment, the new reformed administration at Suffolk County Council did not create this mess. That lies squarely with the Conservatives both locally and nationally. But they have inherited record road maintenance funding, and it is now their responsibility to get this right and put wrongs that have been so clearly evident in the system for so many years. They have the resources.

They now have the certainty. And residents now rightly expect to see the results. Of course, pothole-riddled roads in Suffolk are not our county's only transport challenge. So, I'm really delighted about the package of measures the Government has allocated to our county. And that includes £9 million to improve the county's bus services, which is by the way the biggest upgrade since 1998.

They're investing £4.5 million for active travel, which includes improved walking and cycling provision. And they've committed nearly £55 million in funding for upgrades around the A12-A14 Seven Hills roundabouts. These are significant investments, but I, of course, want more. On Ely to Hawley, for example, there is a single point of failure in Suffolk, which is the Orwell Bridge. And Ely

02:33:29 - 02:33:34

Speaker 92

Can I just remind the gentleman, the honourable gentleman, to remain in the scope of the debate, please?

02:33:34 - 02:34:32

Speaker 90

Yes, absolutely. What I was going on to say is road maintenance and the maintaining of our roads relies on transport infrastructure. And this is why Ely to Hawley particularly is so important because, Madam Chair, if I may, Ely to Hawley will take a hundred thousand HGVs off the road, which is incredibly important. However, it is not a like-for-like replacement I will in a moment, I'll finish my point, thank you.

But it is not a like-for-like replacement for the Orwell Bridge, which has over 12,000 HGVs a day going across it from one of the world's bigger busiest container ports. This is a crucial piece of infrastructure. We have a job to do locally making sure that we renew the business case, which is now half a decade old, that we see if we can reduce the number of level crossings. So, this scheme has a number my wholehearted support, I know the support from across the House. And, but we have a job to do in our local system.

I'm really pleased that Transport East in particular have grasped the nettle on this. So, I'll give way to the member opposite.

02:34:32 - 02:35:30

Patrick Spencer

I thank the honourable member for giving way. It is kind of him to do so. I feel a sense of déjà vu where I am saying what I have said to him before. But it is incumbent on me to remind him he is now in government, his party is now in government,

there is a Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer, and yet last week was the third opportunity for this Government to fund Ely to Hawley. Accept, I accept it wasn't done by the previous government, so don't just repeat some tired line, well, you didn't do it, so I shouldn't be expected to do it either. But if it's so important, why are you sitting here shouting at all of us? Why is he here shouting at all of us when it is the Chancellor of the Exchequer who he needs to make this point to?

02:35:30 - 02:37:06

Speaker 90

Every time the member hasn't been in parliament for a while, so he's maybe not aware about the fact that conversations have been having across the system. Now, he's absolutely right to point out that the previous Conservative government pledged three times to move ahead with Ely to Hawley and didn't allocate a single penny of funding.

It is also the case, however, that we've met consistently with the rail minister about this particular issue. Now, the business case that was put forward for Ely and Haughley is now half a decade out of date. No, you can, the honourable member can continue shaking his head. This is a reality, and I'm giving strong feedback. This is feedback, by the way, that Transport East have grasped, that the Cambridgeshire Mayoral Authority know, that our Chamber of Commerce knows.

So, it seems to be everybody apart from the honourable member is aware of the detail here. But we have been asked as a local system to update the business case because how can we reasonably ask the government to fund something that's half a decade out of date, pre-Liz Truss's mini-budget? How can we reduce the number of level crossings along the Ely stretch, which will also reduce the cost of this important infrastructure scheme? And is there any private investment we can also pull into it in a similar way to Lower Thames Crossing? And can we build up a wider regional support for this scheme?

So, the ball is in our court. Every single stakeholder locally knows that and is advancing on that. And the other thing I would say is Suffolk has to get serious. We, collectively, have to get serious when we're pitching for funding. We're competing against every single region and nation in this country, and to sit there amateurishly say demand to keep demanding the same thing over and over again without

02:37:06 - 02:37:08

Speaker 93

Mindful of the tone, please.

02:37:08 - 02:38:59

Speaker 90

Yep, absolutely. But to make the same demands time and time again without doing any of the straightforward things that have been clearly asked of us is not feasible. So that is why, collectively, the local system is heading towards the spending review and making sure we're doing the things that has been asked of us on a local level. And I hope the honourable member listens to some of this and reflects on it and will join with the Transport East, the combined mayoral combined authority, the chambers of commerce, and actually members across this House of all parties. It doesn't look like the member is going to do that, which is unfortunate, because we could all use all power to wheel.

But what I was going on to say before being interrupted was the fact that Ely-Haughley is incredibly important. We do want to move freight from HGVs onto our rail network. However, this is not a silver bullet to our local road system. As I said, 12,000 HGVs a day cross the Orwell Bridge. We also have Copdock Interchange, which I know I've talked to rail sorry, the roads minister preceding this particular minister about a number of occasions.

This is a really crucial pinch point in our local road network, one that impacts on Felixstowe, and I'm really hoping that we can move this forward in a future RIS programme after it was pushed from RIS 3 to RIS 4. However, we do have the structural road weaknesses within our road network, and although these schemes are incredibly important, there still seems to be the single point of failure for the Orwell Bridge, and every time the bridge closes, Ipswich and the surrounding area grinds to a halt. And that pushes HGVs onto our country roads. It pushes them onto unsuitable road networks as well, and that creates an even bigger problem when it comes to road maintenance as well. Residents sit in traffic for hours.

Businesses lose money. Emergency services are delayed, and our local economy pays the price, too. I will happily give way.

02:38:59 - 02:39:41

Lee Pitcher

And I thank my honourable friend for giving way. I do welcome the government's investment in potholes. It is significant, £7 billion across this term. But, of course, what we haven't talked about today is the impact that potholes have on pedestrians. I've had members of my residents who have fallen in potholes as they've been walking across roads whilst trying to traverse potholed roads.

So I just wonder if he agrees with me that when we're talking about the investment in potholes, we need to consider accessibility, and we also need to consider the pavements as well, that have been raised for me at Oulton Ferry, at Norman Drive, at Coppice Road, and we just need to we need to tackle that with our investment, too.

02:39:42 - 02:41:42

Speaker 90

The honourable member is, right, and he is absolutely right to say it isn't just the roads themselves, but it's the surrounding infrastructure as well from our pavements as well. I walk the streets every single weekend around and the roads and the pavements alike are in incredibly poor state, so I hope the whole road maintenance network is looked at. But just to finish up my point around the Orwell Bridge as well, it is incredibly important that we get to work the Reform County Council gets to work and fertilising these potholes, but we will keep coming back to this place time and time again if we don't also deliver the major infrastructure we need. And that is certainly things like Ely and Haughley, it's certainly things like Copdock interchange. And as I say, I welcome the Seven Hills roundabout investment as well.

But we also need to address the single point of failure which is impacting our local economy, not just a bit of traffic, not just HGVs being pushed onto unsuitable road networks, including our villages as well. Well, we have to deliver the infrastructure we need, and that is why a northern bypass for Ipswich is so critical. Not just for our town in terms of the traffic, but in terms of the long-term future of Felixstowe and our surrounding economy as well. It is the only credible solution to this major single point of failure, and that has been outlined in a WSP report before, so it's really incumbent again on our local system. Reform and county council have reopened, finally, the their work on this, after it was shelved six years ago without credible alternative being put forward.

I hope, when that reports back in the spring, that we will be able to go to government and to ministers to make sure we can push ahead with this absolutely vital project. But for now, Madam Chair, our residents do deserve safe and reliable maintained roads, and our businesses do deserve infrastructure that supports growth rather than holding it back. So, our government is doing its part, and the funding is now there, and the opportunity is there for our local county council. But they, with the new administration, must get on with the job, and deliver the roads that the people of Ipswich and Suffolk deserve. Thank you.

02:41:42 - 02:41:46

Speaker 94

Order. I remind the house, the first person to speak, Steffen Aquarone.

02:41:46 - 02:46:58

Steffan Aquarone

Thank you, Mr Clive. Thank you to serve under your chairship, and I congratulate the honourable member for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich on securing this debate. Instead, he might find the recent street works inquiry by the transport committee of interest in relation to his point about street works. This was considered in great depth by the committee and a number of recommendations were made to government, which I'll kindly ask the minister to refer to in his remarks. Despite being a Norfolk MP, I'm very pleased to represent the Liberal Democrats in today's important debate.

I feel perhaps uniquely qualified, thanks to the comments by the member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, who advised thick tyres and a robust vehicle for the roads of Suffolk. I have indulged myself in an agricultural vehicle to get around Norfolk for the same reason, and I'm only too pleased to be speaking about the shared challenges faced by our neighbours south of the border. I've been quite shocked to read the evidence of the deteriorating state of Suffolk's roads. They are, unbelievably, even worse than Norfolk's. The BBC report that potholes reported annually rose by nearly 5,000 in a single year.

I think, as the member for Ipswich has already noted, earlier this year, Suffolk was rated as red in the government's road maintenance ratings. For locals, that's just not good enough, and I think they know who they have to thank for it. I will be gracious in responding to the proposer's request for being gentle, and he has at least turned up to propose this debate today, but Reform administrations at the council, as well as his colleagues who predeceased them, have presided over this abject failure in recent months and years. And for drivers already facing soaring prices at the petrol pump, thanks to the war in Iran, which Reform and, I gently say, the Conservatives were cheerleading, they now face the cost of repairing cars damaged by potholes on their local roads, too.

What will be even tougher for Suffolk residents though is that it doesn't have to be this way. We might, colleagues in this room, be all dashing for the same train this evening back to East Anglia, but can I gently encourage them to look across the border to Liberal Democrat-led Cambridgeshire Council, where they will see a council which is fixing four times more potholes than Suffolk. This is a prime example of how communities electing local champions from the Lib Dems will get better services, better roads, and a better council. And what I worry for residents in Suffolk is that instead of learning from their neighbors in Cambridgeshire, they might try and learn from the Reform administration in Norfolk instead, where their management of the highways budget is, frankly, laughable. They swanned in and chose to abolish the ring-fenced £11,000 fund for individual members to support highways projects in their constituency.

I know from my time as a county councillor, and I refer members to my Register of Interests, of the impact this funding was able to have in local communities. It wasn't just fixing potholes; we supported village gates for Melton Constable, a bus shelter and lay-by in Saxthorpe, SAM2 speed cameras for the A148, which has led to a project to reduce the speed limit on this dangerous road, and much more. That local members fund was instrumental in improving road quality in Norfolk, and it should be preserved and extended indeed in Suffolk. They claimed that robbing this ring-fenced funding from Norfolk was needed to fund general highways maintenance and repairs, but, in recent days, we've seen their budget consultation, which proposes cutting a further half million pounds from highways maintenance and reducing the verge cutting on some rural roads to only once a year. This is disastrous mismanagement of our county's roads, and the

to colleagues in Suffolk on this occasion, make sure that you do not listen to your friends in the north in Norfolk, although whether there's been much friendship left between those administrations is unclear. Rather than focusing on fixing the state of Suffolk's roads, the Reform administrations in our two counties have been locked in a battle about when to hold elections for the future mayor of Norfolk and Suffolk. And this is highly pertinent to the issue of road safety, given the powers that will be befitted on their office. Our endlessly delayed devolution deal faces yet more hold-ups because Reform are fighting with one another, and it's residents who are paying the price. They're watching on as the People's Front of Reform and the Reform People's Front stand off shouting splitters across the border at each other while the potholes grow, the road markings wear away, and the services that residents' council tax pays for simply are not delivered to the standard they expect.

Poorly maintained roads are a misery for motorists. And in rural communities, where there is no choice but for greater car use, they will see this impact them even harder. It causes issues for public transport delivery as poor-quality roads make it harder for bus operators to run reliable services to rural villages who need them most. This isn't just a clichéd moan; it's one of those ways that government failure wears people down in rural areas and makes them feel they're being or they've been given a worse deal than those in the cities. I'll bring my remarks to a conclusion as I know colleagues from Suffolk are keen to hear how the government intends to address the challenges they face, but I end with a message of solidarity from their friends and football rivals over the northern border.

We're suffering with a Reform council, too. The best cure I can see is to elect a Liberal Democrat one instead. Thank you.

02:46:58 - 02:47:06

Speaker 97

Miss Vaz. Road maintenance. I call Alison Griffiths, the opposition spokesperson.

02:47:06 - 02:51:05

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Ms Vaz. It is an absolute pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I'd also just like to pay credit to Ms Barker, who was chairing earlier on today. And I must congratulate my honorable friend on securing this important debate. He is a true champion for his constituents in Central Suffolk and North Ipswich, and I'm sure they will appreciate his work in bringing the challenges they face with potholes to this place today.

And I also wanted to reflect on some of the speeches that we've heard today. I find myself sitting opposite the minister not for the first time this week. We have been in the highways financing bill committee earlier on this week, and indeed we have sat previously on the Business and Trade Select Committee together. And I sit on an APPG with Dr. Prinsley,

and I just want to really reflect on some of the real positives of cross-party working, which Westminster Hall has the ability to demonstrate to our constituents how well we can work together. And if I reflect on the speeches that I've heard today, it's honey and vinegar, I think is perhaps the best way of putting it. And I think honey, rather than vinegar, tends to achieve the desired results.

It was absolutely delightful to go on, perhaps not for the people actually doing the journey, but in my imagination, going on the journey of Swiss melting Swiss cheese in Suffolk with Dr. Prinsley. But I was disappointed that the member, sorry, and I should have referred to you as the member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, Dr. Prinsley, I do offer my apologies. But it was, I have to say, Ms. Vaz, disappointing to hear the member for Ipswich be less parliamentary and less collegiate, and I felt rather let down the way in which Westminster Hall can really bring this place together.

But the conditions of our roads have a direct impact on all of our constituents' lives. Many depend on them to get to work, take their children to school, attend medical appointments, and run their businesses. In rural communities such as those in West Suffolk, there is often no alternative to travelling by car. Yet for many drivers, dodging potholes has become part of the daily routine. Every journey brings the frustration of trying to avoid another jolt or an expensive repair bill.

The RAC estimates that hitting a pothole can leave motorists, and I would include myself in this, facing a bill of up to 590 pounds for damage that is simply not their fault. For cyclists and motorcyclists, the consequences can be much worse. When the same potholes remain week after week, people understandably wonder when anything will be done. They put up with diversions and road closures while repairs take place, only to see the surface break up again. They want repairs that last.

My honourable friend has raised the particular challenges facing West Suffolk. He rightly praised the excellent record of Suffolk County Council's previous Conservative administration, which repaired more potholes than were reported last year, each year, rather, each year. Who asked to give way? I will give way. I will give way. Could you, I would just ask you to speak up there, because I am partially deaf.

02:51:05 - 02:51:23

Speaker 90

Sorry, I do apologize. Is that okay? Thank you. If, I appreciate the honourable member is saying about the previous Conservative administration in Suffolk County Council, but they were the ones in charge who received a red rating, one of the worst ratings in the whole country.

02:51:23 - 02:51:28

Speaker 95

That's not much of a record to be proud of, is it?

02:51:28 - 02:54:26

Alison Louise Griffiths

I thank the honourable member for making the points that he has, and I simply refer him to the speech that I am making, and the point is about potholes, and they have demonstrate that council demonstrably repaired more potholes than were reported each year. And yet, recently, the issue in West Suffolk has got worse, and pothole reports across the country rose from just under 14,000 in 2024 to '25 to more than 18,000 in 2025 to '26. It is a familiar picture in my own West Sussex constituency. The county council received almost 24,000 pothole reports last year, up by more than a quarter on the year before.

My constituents in Bognor Regis and Littlehampton want roads they can rely on. When they report a pothole, they expect it to be fixed, and for that to be that. They should not have to report the same issue again a few months later. And it is all the more frustrating when the council's own figures show that the average cost of repairing a pothole rose from around £82 in 2024 to '25 to £118 in 2025 to '26. Returning to Suffolk, the A143 between Stanton and Ixworth was resurfaced in September last year, as we have indeed heard from the member for Stowmarket, uh sorry, Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket.

So, I have two questions for the Minister. First, what assessment has he made of whether Suffolk and other rural counties have enough funding to maintain the roads their communities depend upon? Second, where councils have discretion over how they spend their maintenance funding, how will the Minister use the existing incentives to make sure pothole repairs are a priority? And when his department judges the results, will it look at how long those repairs last? Madam Chair, as we have heard throughout this debate, potholes are a nuisance that touch the lives of constituents across the country, in West Suffolk and elsewhere.

Our roads keep the economy moving and enable all of us to go about our lives. The Government must heed the vital points that my honourable friend has made today, and well, who I congratulate once again on securing this important debate. I'm sure, like me, she will hope to hear the vision from the Minister.

02:54:26 - 02:54:29

Speaker 96

The Minister Justin Madders.

02:54:29 - 03:06:16

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you. Ms Vaz, it's a pleasure to see you in the chair this afternoon. Can I, first of all, congratulate the honourable member for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich for securing the debate? He has spoken with real passion about the condition of the roads in his constituency and around Suffolk more generally, and rightly so, because of course this is not an abstract issue. This is an issue that all members, whether they're here today or not, know matter to people on an everyday basis, getting to work, taking children to school, reaching essential services, and supporting local businesses.

None of that can happen if we do not have roads. And as we've heard, for too many people across Suffolk, those everyday journeys are made harder by roads that simply haven't been good enough or safe enough. The poor state of roads is, as uh, my honourable member for Ipswich has mentioned, the product of over a decade of under-investment in our local road network, potholes left unrepaired, surfaces deteriorating, preventative maintenance deferred again and again.

And as we have heard in this debate, we are now dealing with the consequences of that. We are determined to turn the situation around. The honorable member brought the debate, complained about short term funding fixes in the past and I think it is fair to say, and I think he was gracious enough to acknowledge, that we are now on a different path. We are providing a record 7.3 billion pounds in local highways maintenance funding over the next four years, not only giving record funding, but also giving that long term certainty that councils need to plan properly to resurface roads and tackle that pothole plague that hopefully will become a thing of the past. And I think it's worth just, Ms Fovargue, if you don't mind, just saying that Suffolk County Council will receive more than 219 million pounds over those four years, including over 45 million pounds this year alone.

This is a significant increase on the 31 million pounds that they received in '24-25, and a further increase on the 43 million they received last year. And as my honorable friend, the member for Ipswich said, the figures from central government were as low as 17.5 million pounds in 2020. By '29-30, that figure will rise to 64 million pounds and as he quite rightly said, that's almost a four, a quadrupling of the funding available. That is something I think that all members should rightly acknowledge is giving the necessary resources. And I think he did, obviously, raise a number of other projects which he would like to see dealt with in his constituency and in the wider Suffolk area.

I think he has shown the right approach. It is important to bring all stakeholders together to actually present credible business cases to try and bid for, as he rightly acknowledged, what is a competitive environment. Every constituency, every local authority has lots of projects they want to receive funding for. I know the opposition spokesperson asked about whether there's been an assessment on funding for rural councils, and we have confirmed that ahead of the next highways maintenance funding cycle, we will review the formula so any potential changes can come into effect from 2030 onwards. And we will engage with local highway authorities as we consider any changes to the formula because if you decide that one area, one type of road network is more deserving, then, by definition, another has to lose out.

And we know that every area has its own challenges, whether it's geography, climate, traffic levels, or indeed, as we've heard today, the nature of the local network. That is why, currently, funding is allocated using established national datasets, such as road lengths, to provide a fair and, importantly, consistent basis for distribution across England. But, of course, funding is only one part of it. Delivery is also important. Now we've done our part and it's up to councils now to turn that record investment into visible improvements.

That's why we have introduced a strengthened system of transparency reporting, annually updated ratings and incentive fundings. This has a number of elements to it, the first of which is transparency. Local highway authorities published updated transparency reports in September setting how that out how they will spend their funding and maintain their networks. This will allow residents to see what their council plans to deliver, and it will also enable them, and indeed honorable members, to hold councils to account.

Secondly, there will be ratings. These measure road condition, capital spending and adherence to best practice, providing the public with an accessible assessment of how well each authority is maintaining its roads. As we've heard, Suffolk County Council received an overall red rating for 2025/26 and the honorable member asked in light of that rating what support would be provided to the local authority. I can confirm to him that all red-rated authorities have received support, including peer reviews by sector experts, and practical advice to tailor it to their needs. And we will, of course, publish updated ratings in early 2027, drawing on this year's strengthened transparency reports.

We are working with local highway authorities and sector bodies to refine the approach and have been given councils the opportunity to check their submitted figures before ratings are finalized, so we hopefully don't have a repeat of the bate- the debate we've had with Suffolk County Council, where one set of figures were submitted to the department and another were relied on by the council at a later date. Thirdly, incentives. To receive their full funding application, local highway authorities must meet certain requirements aimed at driving best practice and continual improvement in highways maintenance. This helps ensure that our record investment is supported by sound planning, professional capability, and a commitment to best practice. Building on this, last month also saw the publication of the updated Well-Managed Highway Infrastructure Code of Practice, underpinning highway asset management across the sector, with input from local authorities and importantly, industry partners.

This approach is already bearing fruit. This year's transparency reports show that nationally, we are starting to turn a corner. Councils report that they are spending almost £5 billion on highways maintenance this year. That is over £800 million more than was being spent 2 years ago. They plan to resurface nearly 7,000 miles of road.

This is the distance from London to Singapore, should you wish to drive that far, Ms Farris. I wouldn't recommend it. That is actually a 10% increase on last year alone. We also know that 94% of authorities are now planning preventative treatments, up from 76% and that focus is increasingly on stop pot- stopping potholes from forming, not simply patching them up. And it's so important that we are able to move to that preventative model because improving maintenance is not just about smoother journeys, but it's actually about safer ones and the more preventative work we can do, safer the roads will be.

Rural roads accounted for 60% of road fatalities in 2024, despite carrying 45% of traffic. Road users are six times more likely to be killed or seriously injured on rural roads. That's why our Road Safety Strategy has set out targets to reduce the number of people killed or seriously injured on roads in Great Britain by 65% and by 70% for children under the 16 by 2035. Good maintenance is, therefore, not merely a question of convenience. It contributes to a safer and more reliable network.

And I'll just turn before I conclude, Ms Farris, on some of the points honorable members have raised. I've tried to address some of them. I'll try and address any remaining ones. So first of all, I think the my honorable friend, the member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, raised some important points. I have to say I'm intrigued by what he got up to with the opposition spokesperson with this cheese business.

No doubt when we re-engage in the Highways Finance Bill Committee next week, she can tell the committee all about that particular Well. Well, perhaps Hansard will just have to be left guessing as to what exactly went on there. But my honorable friend raised some important points about the A143 and the issues over the summer. And actually, one of the reasons decarbonization is in the metrics is it's not just about decarbonization, but it's also about taking action to make sure roads are more resilient to climate change, using road surface materials that actually can withstand extreme heat.

There's a new transport resilience strategy which was published on the 2nd November, which strengthens how the transport sector anticipates, prepares and responds to disruptions.

And of course, it's fair to say that asset owners, in this case Suffolk County Council, are indeed responsible for ensuring that these matters are dealt with. But he said and I think he put it as an interesting phrase, that this is a war and the potholes are winning. I'm sorry to hear that is the case, but I believe that with the record funding we've delivered, with the transparency that we are requiring and the support that we are offering, actually, all local authorities should be winning that war. Turning to a couple of the points made raised by the honorable member who brought the debate, he asked about skills in the road maintenance sector that are obviously very important issue.

We do want to make sure that we've got continuity and succession planning in this vital sector. So actually, the incentive framework is about raising the adoption of best practice. It also has an incentive requirement for local authorities to undertake training and how organizations offer training is actually being reflected in increased interest in training since we've required that. And actually 10% more preventative maintenance has resulted from this increased training and obviously, as I've said, we will give support to those authorities that are red-rated. He asked about whether we hold data on how long it takes to fill potholes.

That is correct, we don't hold that data, but we do collect data in the transparency reports about whether residents can tell their council about potholes and whether then the council responds about the action they've taken. And I think from a public-facing perspective, that's actually a really important metric. He also asked whether councils can have more access to technology, particularly councils in rural settings. And actually, what I would suggest to him that is that because we have set this long-term funding strategy in place, because we have given certainty to local authorities, they will have greater capacity and ability to plan ahead and actually invest in some of this new technology.

And he may also want to refer his local authority to the Live Labs 2 innovation program, which includes several trials in rural areas on innovative practices. I think that's probably the main points that have been covered. I think it's all good in terms of the record funding, but it is incumbent on local authorities, particularly in this case Suffolk County Council, to use that funding effectively, to improve its performance and to deliver what I think all of us in this House expect, which is safer, smoother and more reliable journeys. So I thank the honorable member for bringing this debate, and I'll close on that point.

03:06:16 - 03:06:17

Thank you, Minister. Patrick Spencer.

03:06:17 - 03:09:06

Patrick Spencer

Briefly. Thank you, Mr. Eustice, to see you in the chair. I thank the Minister for a very spirited effort. I appreciate I haven't sent him my speech in advance,

many of the issues I brought up were new to him. I do appreciate his point on machinery, Live Labs 2. What I will probably do is write to the Department, reiterating some of the things that I've raised and continue this process. I don't think, you know, I'm not here just to kind of continue to frustrate his first I, you know, frustrate his inbox, but, you know, I do feel that there is a more that can be done than simply talking about funding.

I also thank the honorable member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket. He raised a very interesting point, actually, and this does turn up often, which is the issue of failed remediation work. I don't I'm sure he, as I do, as most MPs have inboxes full of residents frustrated that a pothole has emerged, it's been resurfaced, and then it's reemerged again.

I asked Suffolk County Council about failure rates, and they insisted that the failure rate was at 1%. Now, whether that's true or not is rightly for debate, but I would also say that 1%, when you're dealing with 20, 30, 40,000 potholes, is still a lot of potholes. And so there can be a case that 1% figure is true, although it might not be, and, but anyway, a point well made. I also want to thank the honourable member and the Lib Dem frontbench spokesperson for a very interesting insight into life in Norfolk and also appreciate his point around street works. To the member of Ipswich, I think, we, you know, look, a speech that reminded us all what life is like driving along roads covered in potholes, it's predictably miserable and never seemed to end.

And to the frontbench spokesperson for the opposition, some very worthy points, and I know that she takes this seriously and for whatever mistakes were made in the past with prioritizing roads, the work of the Conservative Party will prioritize road maintenance and transit transport infrastructure going forward. And with that, I thank you and I bring this debate to an end.

03:09:06 - 03:09:14

Speaker 97

The question is, as many as that of that opinion say aye, of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, that this House has considered potholes and road maintenance in Suffolk. Order, the sitting stands adjourned.