House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 2
Well, thank the noble lord for that. Serbia remains in our view an important regional partner, has a decisive role in supporting security and stability in the Western Balkans. Serbia has a complicated relationship with Russia, with energy dependency and other relationships, with China for economic investment as the noble lady said earlier, with the European Union where it maintains military neutrality towards NATO but continues practical cooperation with NATO despite that. So Serbia has a complex web of relationships with regions and powers around the world. But it is a crucial partner for stability in the region and we continue to engage them on cooperation, democratic reform, and insist on its responsibilities being observed towards Kosovo and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Speaker 5
Could the Minister tell your lordships a little more about what HMG is doing to counteract disinformation and propaganda in the West?
Speaker 2
Well, thank the noble lady for that. We are doing a lot with allies in the region to respond to the threat from Russian hybrid activity in particular, including exposing the activities of the Russian intelligence services, expelling intelligence officers here and sanctioning individuals. We are working in partnership with governments and partners across the Western Balkans to ensure that they have the tools, the FIMI tools and other tools. And as the noble lady knows, the Prime Minister announced last month to set up a new National Centre for Information Defence, which we hope will provide expertise which can also be shared with allies and partners in the region.
Speaker 23
I agree with the premise of Baroness Helić's question. I would add to this short debate that it is very effective in those countries. And I would ask the question of the minister, do you now think it's time for us to enhance our understanding of what Russia and China is doing through better intelligence and make it more of a priority for us to understand how they're undermining their own journey to the European integration?
Speaker 2
Well, the noble and gallant lord asks a good question. I think he's asking specifically about Bosnia. I'm not sure which particular country the noble and gallant lord's asking about, but in general on intelligence, there is a huge focus, I know from my short time as minister, there is a huge focus on improving, strengthening, making more robust and sharing as much as is consistent with our with the demands of secrecy, knowledge with other countries in order to ensure that the direct hybrid and other threats from Russia and the way in which Chinese economic influence is changing incentives for countries in the region. We are doing a lot across government in order to improve our understanding of both and that will have to continue.
Martin Callanan
My lords, last month the former American ambassador to Bosnia and Herzegovina, Michael Murphy, said the West's approach to the region has failed. It is clear that Putin's strategy in the Balkans is to sow division and stoke sectarian division to increase Russia's influence. So what assessments have ministers made of the willingness of the United States to assist in reassessing our approach in the region to help to roll back that Russian influence?
Speaker 2
Well, we work with the United States on the region. There are specific issues where we have discussions with the US continually on the high representative issue, for example. We work with international partners, we support and complement the EU-led dialogue. We engage with leaders in Kosovo, Serbia, Bosnia, etc. We support local leaders on delivering processes to enhance stability and security.
And we work with the United States to ensure that democracy and a Euro trajectory for the region as a whole continues to be the emphasis of the partner states there.
Speaker 20
My lords, I wonder if the noble minister could clarify for me the relationship of our relationship with China at the moment in the light of the new sanction arrangements that are happening. Is China, should we be regarding China as an adversary as we do Russia, or should we be regarding them as a powerful competitor?
Speaker 2
Well, the size of China means that we have to engage with China. We have to engage with confidence, we have to engage carefully and pragmatically, but also in a clear-eyed way, as my noble friend knows. It means we have to confront the full range of challenges that are posed by China, from espionage and cyber attacks to the emergence of organised crime. But we also have to engage on the commercial level and a trade level to ensure that we can be partners with China in areas where there are mutual economic interests.
William Wallace
My lords, will the minister have time during his visit to Montenegro to investigate illicit financial flows, particularly from Russia?
He will know that there have been substantial flows of illegal currency through Serbia and Montenegro. He may also know that George Cottrell claims that his wealth comes from casinos and cryptocurrency in Montenegro, and the evidence therefore of Russian money coming in as foreign interference into British politics appears to be quite strong. Could he investigate further?
Speaker 2
Well, the noble lord's right, there are definitely issues of illicit finance in some parts of the region, as well as sanctions evasion and tools to get round existing sanctions on which, as the noble lord knows, we have led the pack, I believe. And that does continue to remain a focus of me and of the government.
Baroness Griffin
My lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Jane Sharon Taylor
My lords, I would agree with my noble friend that new towns represent a unique opportunity to use placemaking good practice to create inclusive and accessible infrastructure, housing, and communities. And indeed, accessibility is a core theme of our placemaking principles, which recommend that new towns include a diverse range of housing types and tenures to suit the needs of a balanced community, and emphasize the need to provide access to local amenities, public transport, and much more. All national policies and standards related to inclusive design and accessibility will apply to new towns.
Baroness Griffin
I thank my noble friend the minister for her answer and for agreeing to meet me on this matter. People are disabled by barriers in society and negative public attitudes rather than by their conditions. Can I ask my noble friend to continue to press that new build communities and their infrastructure are accessible by design and adaptation for disabled people, people with conditions, and the UK's ageing population?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I'm grateful to my noble friend for championing this really important issue. The new towns taskforce recommended that new towns should be more than just housing, with that high-quality placemaking that I referred to, as well as early investment in infrastructure and a focus on creating thriving communities with a distinct identity. And for me, thriving communities mean that everyone has the opportunity to succeed and to be housed in a way that is appropriate to their needs. And I will indeed continue to work with colleagues who are in the new towns team and who are also developing standards for housing to make sure we do all we can so that people's housing enables their full participation in their community and in society.
Speaker 28
Could you also ask the team to look at some of the innovative measures being taken in the North West, whereby it's not only adaptations that matter, it's the staircasing ability? So someone can get an accommodation, and as their condition changes within that block or that building, they can staircase down to wider doorways for wheelchairs, to showers that they can go into, not instantly, but as they progress. And these are becoming very, very popular, cost a little bit more, but actually make a real difference in communities because people don't have to move away and move back again. And that continuity engages people and keeps the entire communities in a more secure state on these accommodation sites.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Yes, well, we have set out clearly that we want to see at least 40%, and I mean at least 40%, of homes built to the M4(2) standard, which will help give that start of a widespread accommodation that helps with those things. And it's not just the ability to staircase in any case, it's the ability to staircase within your local area, so when you have to move on, you're not losing all your contacts with community, with local facilities, with your neighbours, and with your other social contacts.
So we've seen some very good practice on this, and I hope we'll be able to share that and make sure that as we build these new towns, we incorporate that approach throughout the new towns that we're creating.
George Young
My Lords, has the noble lady read the report published by one of your Lordships' select committees last week on the new towns called Commit and Build? And has she read what she what it says about modern methods of construction? Standardization and modern methods of construction could also mean that houses are built faster than ever before. So will she use this new generation of new towns to capitalize on the possible benefits of modern methods of construction, higher standards, lower costs, and improved safety?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Yes, I was very grateful to the to the Built Environment Committee, which also published its final recommendations of their three-part inquiry. In terms of modern methods of construction, I'm sure the noble lord will have heard me say before, I'm a great advocate for modern methods of construction. They mean faster delivery, they mean better standards because they can be standardized better. And also, in a country where unusually this year it hasn't done it so much, but normally it's raining all the time, the vast majority of the construction can take place in a factory. So I'm very keen on that, and I want to make sure that we do there were some obstacles to get over in terms of financing and insurance purposes.
Speaker 9
But I think we need to work through those and make sure MMC is a clear part of our construction for the future.
James Peter Weir
My Lords, can I ask the minister what actions the government is taking to stress test the accessibility of locations for disabled people? As someone who regularly uses a wheelchair, I can think of many locations which to the naked eye for someone who doesn't have a disability may seem perfectly fine, but when actually faced with the practicalities of someone trying to deal with it, it's a completely different situation.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I think that's a very key issue. And I recently took on the responsibility in the team for it was it was badged up as older people's housing, but I see it as accessible housing overall. And I think the most important thing is to work with everyone's needs are different, that's the first thing to say. So because something's accessible to one person with a disability, it won't necessarily be to another. So the important thing is to work with the groups that that champion the issues for those with disabilities and to make sure that we are linking them into the construction industry and that we are doing all we can to make sure that housing is accessible for all.
Speaker 25
My Lords, can I welcome the statement just now from the minister regarding off-site fabrication and the great advantages that will flow? But doesn't that also require a steady order of program of work? And isn't it really incumbent then on the department to actually work with local authorities and others in order to ensure a steady flow of work rather than the boom and bust that we've often seen before?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I hope we've demonstrated since we came into power that we do see we have our 1.5 million housing target, which is very important to this government. We've invested 39 billion in social and affordable housing. We've done all of that as well as a significant investment in the construction skills sector to make sure that we are making the the construction finance flow much more smoothly and give people the confidence both in MMC but in construction more widely to commit to delivery.
Speaker 21
My Lords, higher construction costs and regulatory complexity affect small business small house builders in particular, who are less able to absorb those higher costs. What's the government doing to involve small house builders in its new towns program?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, we've taken a number of steps to support SME builders. I learned about this from my experience in developing in my own town, that while the big construction companies can take so much, there's a great deal for SME builders to do, particularly at local level. And I think we need to make sure that right across the procurement work that we're doing, we enable those SME builders to participate in the process. We don't want to make it too bureaucratic or complicated because SME builders for the most part are building, and we need to make that procurement accessible for them.
Speaker 16
My Lords, can I just ask the minister what provisions they're taking in all this new build to make sure the houses are heatproof, which is especially important for vulnerable people going forward after this summer?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I think sustainability has been a very key part of what we've been doing. We had our Warm Homes Plan, but we're also, we see new towns presenting a significant opportunity to deliver clean, secure and affordable energy infrastructure from the outset, which will both keep the homes warmer but also reduce the long-term costs for households and businesses. And by planning that energy infrastructure alongside new development, we can make sure that new towns are future-proofed, support economic growth and contribute to that clean energy and net zero ambition, so that we are making sure the homes in those new towns are warm and affordable.
Anne McIntosh
My Lords, could the noble lady ensure, could the noble lady please ensure that new towns are floodproof? If the term 'conservative' can be please make up our mind up and ask the question. My Lords, could the noble lady also ensure that new towns are floodproof and can she give the House today a guarantee that no new town will be built in an area prone to flooding or a functional floodplain?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, all of the proposals that are currently going through a very significant strategic environmental assessment process, that's underway. That's an iterative process that will inform and improve decision-making on those locations to make sure we've got full confidence that final decisions on new towns have been reached on the best available evidence, and that includes evidence around both flooding and water availability and our understanding of the programme's environmental impact. We want to make absolutely sure that we do that and that the current environmental assessment system is adapted to make sure it's delivering the best for those new towns. They're going to be a vital feature to make sure we meet the housing needs going forward, and I look forward to delivering them.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 18
My Lords, this government is negotiating an electricity agreement with the EU to reduce the cost of trading electricity with our European partners, strengthen the UK's energy security, support investment in the North Sea and help deliver our clean power mission. As part of the negotiations, the UK and the EU will discuss the relevant rules relating to renewable energy. The detailed commitments under such agreement will be developed as part of the negotiations.
Speaker 11
Financial benefits to the UK of joining the EU electricity market will be nugatory to possibly negative. But the EU have said that in addition, the UK would have to join the acquis, which will require us to be producing 42 and a half percent of our total energy from renewables by 2030. Not just our electricity, which is only 18% of our total energy. And we'll be sanctioned by the ECJ, by the ECJ if we don't achieve that 42 and a half percent target. Can the minister confirm that the government accepts that 42 and a half percent is entirely impossible for us to achieve in any such timeframe?
And that our negotiators have been instructed to accept that target under no circumstances, or indeed to join the EU's electricity market unless we get a carve-out from that 42 and a half percent.
Speaker 29
There's a great deal in that question and I have to say I would challenge quite a part of it, but let me do my very best to address the details that the honorable lord has indicated. In fact, the purpose of these negotiations is to reduce the cost of trading electricity with our European partners. Energy UK has stated that during the price spike of 2022, between 120 to 370 million pounds per year could have been saved from efficient trading. I would have thought that all in this house would look for opportunities to reduce energy bills in this time. Trading with our nearest partners is of course common sense and makes sense.
Speaker 26
This agreement requires cooperation. It does not require membership of the single market, of the single market. The basis of this agreement is mutual prosperity and it reduces inefficiencies, encourages cooperation while it benefits consumers and businesses. And we will negotiate all the rules and we'll engage with parliament as we see fit, as we should of course as is outlined. The UK-EU common understanding sets out that any agreement on state aid should provide for the UK's dynamic alignment with relevant EU rules and respects UK constitutional and parliamentary processes.
Speaker 13
And that applies across the board. The ECJ will not be involved in the acquis.
On a more positive note. When the government negotiates to align with the EU acquis, will it seek to rejoin the North Seas Energy Cooperation agreement that we were members of before Brexit, that will allow a proper functioning grid in the North Sea, much greater resilience for energy in this country and lower costs to consumers as well?
Speaker 19
Well, this government would always take opportunities to improve our grid connections and to increase and to reduce costs. And partnership we see is part of that. It makes sense that we negotiate with people with whom we have interconnectors, so we will continue to do that. Membership of specific organizations as you, the North Sea one that you've suggested, will be part of these negotiations and these negotiations will be discussed in parliament. So we would hope to make, to develop partnerships and participate in the relevant bodies as per the agreement.
Janet Whitaker
As my noble friend will know, the European Commission funded wave energy very substantially as witnessed the remarkable prototype site in Orkney. What plans does our government have to continue this stimulation of this essential renewable for the intermittency mix?
Speaker 26
I recognize the noble lady's interest and knowledge of wave energy and she's raised with me a number of times that issue. And of course we will always take opportunities if we can to increase our renewable energy in the UK because we see it as vital to the production of clean energy, which is vital to economic security to this country. And we'll hope that we can participate as is in our interest and we'd always protect British interests first.
Speaker 33
Can the Minister explain, indeed is she even aware, why an agreement on the electricity sector, which is less than a fifth of our energy use, should need to cover the other four fifths of our energy outside the electricity sector? And given that renewables account for only 16% of our total energy use, how can we possibly meet a target remotely comparable to 42.5% in two years without crippling costs on the cost of living?
Speaker 24
I don't believe that would be the case at all. And in fact our commitment to renewable energy is ambitious in this country. We will continue to be ambitious in this country for renewable energy and we will continue to do that. The acquis allows us to integrate the electricity market, which will help bring down costs and work in the interest of British people.
Speaker 34
Does the Minister agree with me that removing ourselves from the internal energy market, which we did and we didn't have to do at the time of Brexit, was a fundamental mistake, that the internal energy market was a great support for UK energy security, vital for our future? And can she tell me how far the negotiations have now gone, when we can expect to see the outcome of these negotiations following the EU summit of May 25th?
Speaker 18
Can I thank the honorable Lord for that and emphasize again that these negotiations are ongoing and we see them in Britain's interests. They hopefully will be raised at the next UK summit, the one that's been announced. We're not sure about that, they may continue beyond that. But I would emphasize again the value of these and it was a mistake to withdraw from some of these, we've lost because of that. But this is a bespoke agreement that will help the UK and I would emphasize again that no new EU rules will apply in the UK unless and until the UK agrees to them.
John Redwood
Why when looking at the cost of renewables does the government leave out the costs of backup gas power which is needed, the big increase in grid costs which will be needed to handle unreliability, and the payments that have to be made when there's too much wind?
Speaker 18
The noble Lord has often raised the issue of the unreliability of renewables in this context, but I would also say to him that one of the big challenges this country is facing is our vulnerability and unreliability of gas at the moment and fossil fuels. We're living in a global crisis where the unavailability and the cost of gas is causing huge problems. So I would ask him when he's so keen on comparisons, perhaps he could undertake that comparison too.
Colin Moynihan
My Lords, I declare my interest as chair of Amey and Buckingham Partners. Would the Minister agree that the impact of this potential initiative are rule-taking without the right to vote at the table? And as my noble friends have said, an economy-wide renewables target in the UK is not on track to meet because, and I regret that she hasn't addressed this, it is not just the 20% of electricity we use, but the 80% of oil and gas driven power we use as well for our transport and heating, and a permanent multi-billion pound financial contribution which is uncosted and will burden British taxpayers.
Speaker 24
I would emphasize again to the noble lord that the acquis actually when the acquis is agreed that any implications for the the UK we will not agree to to those that we have not participated in and that we do we will not have to comply with the rules we have not agreed to because the agreement requires cooperation we will not have to follow rules we will comply we will negotiate rules. The UK as I said the UK EU common understanding sets that any agreement in state aid should provide the UK's dynamic alignment and any further agreement requires on other dimensions requires constitutional parliamentary processes. It also envisages appropriate transition period to allow the UK to implement any new requirements.
Speaker 39
Can the minister assure the house that the government will simultaneously look at increasing our gas storage facilities which are putting us at significant risk compared to most of Europe.
Speaker 18
Again an an important point that has been discussed and I can absolutely assure the house that our gas supplies our energy supplies are resilient and we have no question about having not had to address that in fact of having to had addressed that resilience.
Speaker 33
I'm grateful to the noble lady the minister for allowing me to come back because she keeps saying that we'll negotiate these individual rules of the electric electricity market. But the EU's negotiating periods proposals say the agreement should ensure the dynamic alignment of the laws of the United Kingdom with the rules of the Union on the promotion of renewable energy and and provide for their simultaneous application in the United Kingdom. There's no question of subsequent negotiation.
Speaker 18
What I have made what I have made clear sorry I can't see you but what I have made clear as part of the negotiations is that that will be part of the negotiations and the non the negotiations are ongoing. What I'm asserting to you very clearly that when this UK government is undertaking those negotiations we will assert the UK interest and we will not sign up we will not agree to anything that we do not believe to be in a UK's interest. We we believe in partnership and one thing I would say to the honorable lord is my I clearly have a misunderstanding of Brexit because I understood that Brexit did not prohibit further negotiation and further agreement with our our European partners. It is quite disturbing that every time questions such as this come up in this house it is as if we have to turn our our back away from partners no negotiation no joint partnership because every single time there is agreement there is negotiation you raise questions and oppose.
Speaker 40
My lords the migration advisory committee has published estimates of the static and lifetime fiscal impact of migrants in the United Kingdom on work and family routes. Settlement grants migrants the right to remain in the United Kingdom indefinitely without conditions in relation to accessing the labor market and public funds. Therefore it is right to consider the fiscal contribution of migrants with settlement over their lifetime rather than a shorter period.
Speaker 41
Thank my noble friend for that answer. He may be aware that the Home Affairs select committee were written to by Home Office officials who confirmed a net fiscal benefit of ILR recipients up to year 25 which is kind of a long medium term point.
So could I ask the minister whether these contributions and the fact that those on ILR work disproportionately in sectors like adult social care and the NHS and whether this will actually feature in final decisions to be made on the fairer pathway to settlement consultation which is to be decided soon.
Speaker 40
Well, of course he's rightly pointed out that the proposals for earned settlement model were set out in a fairer pathway to settlement which was published in November 25 and the consultation closed in February and there's been over 200,000 responses to that and sought of course the government are those responses are being analyzed and of course the final earned settlement arrangements will be announced in due course so I'm not going to be able to predict that but he's right in the sense in terms of how those calculations in terms of contributions are worked out which of course is what the migration advisory committee set out and they do vary quite substantially between different cohorts and no doubt that is what will be considered in the final outcome when the government considers consultation.
Sally Hamwee
Does the noble lord agree that it's the very resilience of many immigrants that also makes them successful entrepreneurs bringing benefits to them individually and to all of us as society.
Speaker 40
Well, there is no doubt that migration has a positive effect and a positive economic effect there is no doubt about that and I think what the foreign secretary has attempted to do in her recent conference speech to the Labour Party conference is that the role of the government is to make the country fair, fairness is what unites us as a country and I think the approach that she's taken is one that is taken by other countries to ensure that we win public confidence in the immigration system, we acknowledge that settlement allows migrants to claim support from public funds and seek work without sponsorship and we need to be fair on those issues but she's absolutely right there has been a huge positive impact on our economy from migration, all of us in this chamber I suspect have predecessors who've been migrants at one point or another.
Timothy Kirkhope
It's very important that Lord Murray's raised this very question because it is a fact that governments in this country can determine under immigration rules the categories and the types of people that we would like to see here but also taking into account the mutual benefit of having certain people in this country and we have benefited enormously as a result of rules when they've been well applied. I do hope the minister will acknowledge that as the choice is that of the government they will continue to make choices which actually are to mutual benefit and where we can see that migrants coming to this country contribute fully and positively to our economy and society.
Speaker 40
The noble lord is absolutely right and I mean just to amplify the point that my noble friend raised, I mean the MAC found that there is significant variation in migrants' lifetime fiscal contribution depending on their salary and wider characteristics, no doubt about that, for example those arriving on the skilled worker route were estimated to make a larger positive lifetime contribution, a positive of 689,000 to make a and actually than those in a lower category of occupation in health which actually in the care provision is a negative 36,000. But even within the health service of course what we have is a huge positive impact of doctors and nurses as well and that is a very, very positive impact in terms of the economic benefit to the country as a whole.
Speaker 42
Employers in sectors such as hospitality, retail, and social care will tell you that they would cease to function without the ability to hire productive migrant workers. And that's an inconvenient truth for the far-right nationalists who claim that migrants are stealing jobs from UK-born workers. But does the minister agree that with an aging population and a plummeting birth rate, our heavy dependency on migrant workers looks set to grow further rather than to decline?
Speaker 40
I'm really tempted to get into a debate about Brexit, but I won't. But the simple fact is that migration, there was an unprecedented level of migration to the United Kingdom between 2021 and 2025, and that undoubtedly will lead to significant numbers wanting settlement, which is why this government is looking at the situation and looking at fairness in terms of settlement. But, you know, there is no doubt that that period when we were seeking to fill vacancies, particularly in the care sector, the system was pretty chaotic and we're now having to deal with the consequences.
Byron Davies
There has been much speculation over the past few months about whether the government is planning to water down the reforms to indefinite leave to remain. We on these benches, of course, have offered to give the government our support in Parliament to help push through these urgently needed, if imperfect, reforms as announced last year. So can the noble lord the minister assure the House that the government will proceed with these urgently needed reforms as originally planned?
Speaker 40
Well, as I said in my response, we've had a proper consultation, we've had over 200,000 responses, we will consider those responses as a whole and then come up with a plan. And I do appreciate the noble lord's commitment to cooperate, I welcome that very much, but I would appreciate a little bit of acknowledgment that his government are the cause of the problem.
Speaker 49
Isn't it the case that we need to have balance in here? That we need the balance, well excuse me as well. And my noble friend Lord Maude for decades of evidence-based and compassionate contributions to this debate, and I might add the noble Lord Kirkhope to that, to that congratulations. But we've been swimming against the tide with the debate, and in the light of last night's shocking revelations on ITV about the way this debate is conducted within the Reform Party, does my noble friend the minister agree with me that it's more important than ever that parties represented in this House conduct the debate in the way suggested by Lord Maude and Lord Kirkhope?
Speaker 40
Well, I think my noble friend for that, and I actually do think that the debate across the chamber has been a moderate one and I think it's absolutely right. And I think, you know, the important thing is here, it, we are talking about an earned settlement process and we're understanding the reasons why we need to introduce it.
And, you know, there's been significant challenges since migration. I gave you the figures before. So we are going to see a spike. And in fact, I think one of the things that has changed dramatically is that the number of migrants coming in with dependents has increased substantially. And again, that is going to be an issue we need to consider.
But I don't think, you know, every economy in the world allows migrants to come in to address labour shortages, to address other issues in the economy. Every country, including the United States. And they haven't put a barrier to that because they know the consequences of putting up a barrier to it. We should not see migration as a negative. It's a positive in terms of both its economic impact but also its cultural impact.
Jeremy Purvis
My Lords, I hope all parts of the House recognise that one of the communities that have made a huge contribution to the UK are those from Hong Kong, who many have suffered real persecution there. Will the Minister ensure that what we have heard, which is worrying, that some applicants for BNO visas from Hong Kong are being refused access to the United Kingdom because of prior convictions of them which was purely protesting against the repression of the Chinese government? Can the Minister confirm to this House that applications on that basis will not be refused and they will be able to have sanctuary here in the United Kingdom?
Speaker 40
The process for application is very clear and it's one that's conducted fairly and equitably by the Home Office. So I'm not going to comment on the individual circumstances that he may tempt me to do so. But all BNOs can apply and their applications considered in the same way as all others.
David Hunt
Lords, I beg leave to ask a question of which I have given private notice. The question is as follows. To ask His Majesty's Government what plans they have, if any, to extend the scope of the BBC licence fee to households using streaming services, and what assessment they have made of the impact of any such change on one, household bills, two, consumer choice, three, investment, and four, the creative industry.
Speaker 51
My Lords, as you are aware, the ongoing Charter Review is considering how to secure the BBC's long-term future, including by putting its funding model on a sustainable footing. As set out in the Green Paper, the Government is keeping an open mind on all options, including considering reforms to the licence fee. Amongst the things that the Government is considering as part of the Charter Review process is indeed the impact on households, consumer choice, investment, and on the wider creative economy. The Government will set out its decisions in the White Paper by the end of the year.
David Hunt
My Lords, yet again, we are seeing significant government policy being floated in the media before Parliament has been given any clarity at all. That was criticised previously and repeatedly under the previous Prime Minister. The Ministerial Code is clear that major policy announcements should be made first to Parliament when Parliament is in session.
Now, whatever the merits of this proposal, potentially four million households could be affected. So can the noble baroness, the minister, therefore give the House some certainty today? Is the government considering extending the licence fee to households that currently use only streaming services? What options are on the table, and when will the, when will Parliament be given a full statement on the government's plans?
Speaker 51
I thank the noble lord for his question, and of course I agree that it is the job of the government to share any major policy decisions first in the two houses of Parliament. So I am unable in any way to answer the rest of your question with regret, because as I have said, the process of consideration is ongoing, and the results of the consideration will be published in a white paper by the end of the year.
Speaker 67
My lords, my lords, the noble lord opposite makes a very valid point about protecting household budgets. But would my noble friend the minister agree that the BBC also needs sustainable funding? It is a very, very worthwhile investment for our country, given that it contributes 6.7 billion pounds to the UK economy every year, supporting 77,000 jobs in the UK. It also performs a great duty in terms of social cohesion.
Speaker 51
I thank my noble friend for that question, and of course the government believes that the BBC is vital to the country, to the households that continue to enjoy it, to the 467 million people globally who appreciate and trust the BBC news services, and that it is very important that we find a long-term sustainable future to secure the future of the BBC. And that will involve and is involving looking at a range of options to find a way in which we can support the BBC, of course, but also encourage and incentivize the BBC to look at commercial options and at diversifying their income sources.
Speaker 50
I declare my previous interests and very happy to see the noble lady opposite in her place. We had the dubious and mixed pleasure of sitting together on the board of the Dome, the Millennium Experience Company, leading up to the millennium. I'd like to move away from specifics to the principles behind the government's policy. I think, does the noble baroness the minister agree with me that there are three principles that should underlie the government's policy for the BBC? One is that the BBC will not be put into competition for revenue.
Two, that any new arrangement will be progressive, unlike the regressive nature of the licence fee, and will reflect people's ability to pay. And thirdly, perhaps the most important, that the cost of the public investment in the BBC will reduce materially in future.
Speaker 51
My thanks to my noble lord for taking me back to the not entirely happy memories of being on the board of the Dome, although I should just say for the record that the Dome did achieve over six million visitors and created a lasting legacy which is now thriving as a commercial, as a commercial enterprise.
But that is not the topic for today. May I thank you also for your principles and say that whilst of course I am not in any way trying to preempt any of the findings that will be revealed in the white paper at the end of the year, my apologies to my lords, I'm going to be repeating that point several times I fear. I would like to comment on of course starting with your last very with the last very important point that my noble lord made. It is the case that the license fee has been significantly declining over the last decade and that that has been one major source of challenge for the BBC. I don't think I can yet say whether the changes that will be published in the white paper at the end of the year are going to explicitly meet your point about avoiding a regressive source of public funding.
I can of course say that the Secretary of State is on record as saying that the role of public funding continues to be a vital part of the vision of the future of the BBC. I think that I would also just question whether competition competitive finance avoiding competitive finance is is a rule that applies in all possible occasions. I can imagine some scenarios where it is a benefit for the BBC to be in a competitive environment and that they can gain from that process, but that is not in any way to preempt any decision.
Dominic Hubbard
When we're looking at this, can the government give us some idea if they're considering making those who set the level of financing that's generated in the public a more independent body? Because at the moment it has become a political football to be kicked hard and often into the long grass. Also, if we are a lot of these streamers and other services use BBC resources in terms of news and reporting, wouldn't it be a good idea if the government did actually open up the door to actually saying they should pay something for those services?
Speaker 51
My thanks to my noble lord for two very interesting questions. Of course it is the case that regulation of the BBC is independent and that is a very important principle that is dear to this government. Ofcom of course as we know is the independent regulator. I will take back your suggestion that setting the level of settlement for the charter review should also be given to an independent body. It's I think a very interesting thought which I will reflect on more and share with colleagues.
Similarly, of course it is the case now that streamers can use the resources of the BBC without paying for those services and that of course is something that can be considered in the options that will lead up to the white paper at the end of the year.
Patience Wheatcroft
In drawing up the white paper, would the government pay particular attention to the increasingly important role of the BBC in promoting local democracy through backing local news at a time when local newspapers are vanishing from the scene and the government is pushing more and more decision making down the track through devolution? It's increasingly important that the BBC's local democracy initiative is given adequate funding.
Speaker 51
I thank my noble friend for that very important point and I would say that that point applies not only to local news and local BBC services but also of course to the BBC services in the devolved nations where it is equally vital.
Speaker 57
Would the noble Baroness the Minister agree that seeking to expand the definition of usage to justify a compulsory license fee is misplaced, especially when public trust in the BBC amongst some sections of the public is going down and some people are turning away from the BBC? So could I ask the noble Baroness that as part of their charter discussion, has the department requested access to public trust data from the BBC that shows how the BBC performs amongst different demographic groups, and if not, could she commit to doing so and to take account of that in any decision that is made about future funding of the BBC?
Speaker 51
I thanks to my noble lady. My noble lady is right to say that trust in the BBC has declined, but it is still at 59% of UK respondents, which makes it the UK's most trusted news brand, and in a context of diversification, I think one could fairly say that that is an admirable achievement on the BBC's part. I would have to take the question about the collection of data to consult with colleagues and I commit to getting back to you on that point.
Meral Ece
Does the Minister agree that the most important thing really is that the BBC is funded properly and that it's sustainable, particularly and especially given at a time we're on the frontline of global information or misinformation, and secondly really, how best to engage more with young people?
Speaker 51
I entirely and absolutely agree that the key priority is to ensure that the white paper produces an option that gives the BBC funding that will enable it to be sustainable and to thrive, not simply to survive, and that is the most important task that faces the government.
Speaker 66
My Lords, does my noble friend the Minister agree that the TV license fee is actually a misnomer as over 80% of people in this country access its resources in one way or another? And does she welcome the DCMS Select Committee's report on this issue and indeed this House's Select Committee of Communications and Digital's letter and annex, both of which recognize the centrality and the growing importance of the BBC's offer in this complex world and also the importance of supporting it financially in order to deliver its role?
Speaker 51
My thanks to my noble friend and of course I am very happy to say that we welcome the DCMS Select Committee and this House's Select Committee and of course that we agree with the centrality of the BBC and its role both in the present and in the sustainable future.
Kate Hoey
One of the things that upsets local people, families, when they're paying the license fee and not earning very much is to see the huge salaries that some people within the BBC get, absolutely outrageous. Is there going to be anything in the white paper that will actually direct the BBC, if we're paying for it through public money, so that actually they can't go on having these huge salaries to some people within the BBC?
Speaker 51
I think that it is important to state that the BBC is operationally independent from the government and on the arms-length principle that we that I hope we all agree on, it is vital that it should be independent.
The BBC is working in a commercial and fast-expanding and diversifying market in terms of content production and public service, and it is vital that it makes the decisions that it needs to make operationally, not the government.
Magid Magid
My Lords, in looking at the time when local news is under threat, particularly from independent publications, the value of local democracy correspondents, often funded by the reporters funded by the BBC, is being hugely valued. I can say that for South Yorkshire, I'm sure noble Lords across the House will say that. So could the Minister commit to at least safeguarding those local democracy reporters, because they provide an invaluable service at a local level that's fast disappearing with those independent publications?
Speaker 51
I have to I have to say I cannot commit to anything in advance of the white paper, but of but I am happy to agree with the vital importance of local news that the BBC provides for local communities as a way of supporting and nourishing local democracy and local discussion, and as I said previously, we should extend this in my view also to the vital services that the BBC provides in the devolved nations.
Speaker 64
My Lords, when we hear about the data and trust that may be established by research amongst the public, and you undertook to go back, maybe we ought to really be exploring the data related to trust on Sky and the commercial sector. I find I'm paying under two hundred pounds a year to the BBC, but a thousand pounds a year now to Sky, and I hear from the man and woman in the street that is the area which they're most concerned about, not the BBC.
Speaker 51
I thank my noble friend very much for that question, and perhaps perhaps I could humbly suggest that of course for every household and every customer there is a choice, and there is always the choice of deciding not to pay for the service. And so one possible solution to the issue of whether or not my noble friend regards Sky as offering value for money is to take his money elsewhere.
Speaker 65
My Lords, might I suggest that if noble Lords wish to leave the chamber they do so now before I call next business. Questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons on Thursday the fifteenth of October on the sustainable farming initiative.
Speaker 61
My Lords, I'm grateful for the noble Baroness the Minister for repeating this question, and I declare my interest as a farmer in receipt of environmental payments. The allocation of limited SFI funds to farmers with the fastest reaction time rather than to the most impactful applications or greatest need is disappointing. This lottery underscores the urgency of moving to longer-term predictable ecosystem service schemes that deliver the best outcomes and also improve incentives to land managers by bringing in private sector finance. Given the glacial progress of developing these schemes, does the noble Baroness the Minister believe that the unwieldy Defra structure with thirty-four ALBs is fit for purpose?
Sue Hayman
Well, I'm sure the the noble Lord is aware that we've had a full review of Defra ALBs recently through the Corry report.
We are looking at how we can improve their effectiveness and efficiency, and that is ongoing work. I would say that the SFI applications may have been short, there was only a very short window before applications came to an end. But I would like to point out that in window two, the application system did actually deal with unprecedented levels of demand, and 12 and a half thousand farmers did manage to apply before the budget was allocated, so many farmers did get an SFI allocation opportunity.
Speaker 69
Does the Minister agree that the outcome in September was foreseeable? An independent estimate predicted some 40,000 applications against funding for around 15,000. When the chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee asked in the House of Commons on Thursday whether the department expected so many to be disappointed, he received no answer to that specific question. Will she tell this House how many applications Defra expected and why farmers were not warned that many of them would be disappointed?
Sue Hayman
Well, first of all, can I just say that I do very much recognize that many of the farmers who wanted to join SFI 26 will have been disappointed not to have secured an agreement. And clearly we are reviewing in Defra how the process worked and how we want to look at opening up the next window of SFI and how that will operate. Window two was open to all eligible farmers and land managers, as opposed to window one. So we did recognize that the demand could be could be high, and because of that, in August, the Prime Minister announced that there would be an extra 50 million pounds for SFI 26 window two, and then the Secretary of State in Defra added a further 20 million pounds ahead of window two opening, which took the total budget to 310 million pounds in order to help more farmers access support, and that was done because we recognized there was going to be high demand.
Speaker 58
My Lords, I declare my farming interests as set out in the register. I think I should ask the noble Baroness the Minister what her advice is to the very many farmers, the majority of farmers, who did not have a successful application. Because if we want to farm for food and to enhance the environment, then we need to have a comprehensive system in order that so many more farmers can get involved in what I think is a very important project.
Sue Hayman
Well, absolutely, I mean, the noble Lord makes a really good point that we absolutely need to get as many farmers involved in sustainable farming, in farming for the environment, as well as for profitability, as well as for food security. And there are still other funding opportunities available to farmers, such as the countryside stewardship, farming in protected landscapes, and the ELM capital grants offer. So those are still open. But I also think it's really important to say that this year we allocated a total of 310 million pounds to nearly 19,000 new agreements across both application windows. And we also now have 70,000 multi-year environmental land management revenue agreements in place across all the schemes.
And that's part of 11.8 billion pounds funding for sustainable farming this parliament, which is a huge sum of money and more than has been before.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, reports suggest that with aphids, gout fly and leafhoppers emerging in the new emerging cereal crops, that some, maybe a significant number of farmers who signed up for the SFI no insecticide option are looking at abandoning it because of the disease and pest risk. Does the noble lady the Minister acknowledge that the government needs to consider providing far more support to farmers to be able to make these sustainable initiatives to build crop diversity and to move away from the mass commodity crops that are so vulnerable to these pests and diseases?
Sue Hayman
Well, there is an awful lot of work going on around the issue of pests and disease and crops, as I'm sure the noble lady is aware, both with funding through grants from Defra, but also there is innovation funding from Defra which can help with the way pesticides are used and encourage use of different crop management. And I think it's also important to talk about the fact that the government is still very keen to move forward with genetic engineering, which can also help in creating more disease-resistant crops.
Speaker 13
My Lords, I fully agree with the ELMs and the way that it's been approached and the SFI. But although many people will think we don't spend enough money on it, it is still a lot of public money that goes into these schemes. Could the Minister explain to me, say in five years' time or whatever, how do we actually assess that these schemes have actually delivered the sort of environmental and nature effects that we all want them to?
Sue Hayman
Well, obviously Defra does review that. We get figures. We look at how the money we are spending is having a direct impact on nature. I'm sure the noble lord is aware that there are regular figures around things like invasive species, around biodiversity, around nature-friendly farming. Defra has also recently published its farming annual report.
That explains how government supported farmers in this year. We will continue to do that and that will also provide transparent information about what money we are providing and how it is being spent.
Speaker 68
My Lords, there is no doubt that the recent application window caused very significant distress to many in the farming community. I wonder if the noble lady the Minister could tell the House a little bit about what lessons have been learned from the last funding round and what will be different in the next funding round in 2027?
Sue Hayman
Well, I think the important thing to note here is that we do very much recognize that this has caused a great deal of stress for many farmers and that that does have mental health impacts. And we have been working very closely with the farming community, the NFU, in fact I'm meeting a farmer this afternoon to look at the impacts of that and how we can... we do provide support for mental health to farmers, but we need to also recognize the reasons for that. So I think the right reverend prelate makes a really important point. But we are currently looking at how we can improve the SFI offers going forward so we don't end up in this situation again. And one of the things we have pledged to do is to move away from the first-come, first-served approach.
Anne McIntosh
My Lords, the noble lady will be aware that there is concern in the farming community that the way the SFI was administered, it is skewed towards large farmers against the interests of small farmers and tenant farmers in particular. Taken the fact that a lot of tenanted land has been taken out of production for green energy projects, what support specifically is the government giving to tenant farmers and particularly farmers on common land?
Sue Hayman
Well, we work very closely with the Tenant Farmers Association and I work particularly in Cumbria, of course, we have worked closely with how we can better support common land farmers because clearly they were not eligible for the SFI.
So we've been working with the RPA to see how we can improve that. But it is important, I think, to point out that what we're talking about today is window two. Window one was only open for people without agreements and for smaller farms. And the reason for that is because previously 4% of farms took a quarter of the SFI money. And that's why we wanted to encourage more small farms to come forward and to give them that early opportunity, which is why they were eligible for part one.
Speaker 73
My Lords, I should declare my interests as set out in the register. But I wonder two things. In the last parliament, the moneys were delinked from farming to allow everybody to be able to access public money. So I wonder if the minister can highlight if there are plans to, as per the Agriculture Act, link the moneys to active farmers, people who are actually producing the food and taking the risk. And also when the plans are to have a budget that will allow all farmers to be able to access those funds.
Sue Hayman
The noble lady, I know, has got a particular interest in this and I thank her for all the work that she's done with Defra. It's been incredibly valuable. I can't directly answer the noble lady's question at the moment. All I can say is that she makes some very important points about active farming, which Defra is very interested in. We are currently looking very carefully at the way SFI has operated up till now because the more fit for purpose we can make it, the more it can get to the farmers who need it the most and the more it can actually have the outcomes that we want to see in Defra, the better we are spending public money.
Speaker 70
House to be again in committee on the Public Office Accountability Bill, Lord Lemas.
Speaker 71
My Lords, I beg to move that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill.
Speaker 70
The question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion say content. Content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.
Public Office Accountability Bill, clause seven, amendment 31, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, on the first day of committee stage, we discussed amendments to ensure that records, physical and digital, were explicitly added to the application of the duty of candour. That was because we know that there have been a number of egregious cases where information was hidden. And I spoke, for example, of the medical records of the nuclear veterans that had been hidden in a Ministry of Defence storage centre, hidden because nobody knew they were there and they were not on any index. One of the absolutely necessary reasons for this bill as a whole is that we now know there are too many cases where public officials, regardless of department or organisation, have tried to hide or even destroy key information that would demonstrate clear intention to mislead. My Lords, in July 2025, Andy Burnham, still at that point still the mayor of Manchester and a passionate supporter of justice for the Hillsborough Law, said parts of Whitehall were fighting hard to preserve the status quo because even then he felt that ministers and civil servants were misleading the public with false and unfounded claims about the then proposed legislation that has now changed positively into this bill, much clearer now and stronger.
Both the former Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, and our new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, agreed that introducing criminal sanctions for dishonesty was key to making this bill work. But I also agree with our new PM that there is still an issue of culture of the status quo. For decades, at its worst, including recent years, this has included some public officials, those who would be accountable under the terms of this bill, who have destroyed information that would have been important for evidence for inquiries, inquests and investigations, especially police investigations. So, my Lords, my amendment 31, signed by my noble friend Lady Hamwee, creates the offence of destruction of information or records that are relevant to an inquiry, investigation or inquest. It is a standalone clause that says that a public authority or public official commits the offence not just if they deliberately destroy relevant information or records that would be relevant, but also states that they know or are reckless as to whether that information is relevant to or required by an inquiry, investigation or inquest.
And sub-clause 2 of the amendment then sets out the offence under this section is on conviction liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding the general limit in a magistrate's court in England and Wales, a term of not exceeding 12 months in Scotland and not exceeding six months in Northern Ireland, and if on conviction on indictment to a prison for a term not exceeding two years. Now, each one of these subcategories are also liable to a fine or both, that is imprisonment and a fine. Now, my Lords, the reason that I believe that it's vital to specify the details of this crime, including recklessness, a phrase used earlier in the bill, is because of the history of the behaviour of certain public officials who have destroyed information that has not only re-victimised the victims because the evidence could not be produced at inquiries or investigations, but also has too frequently meant a delay to justice, and this has cost the victims and the nation scandal after scandal, successive inquiries on the same issue and has cost the state considerably more money, both in cost of inquiries but also in appropriate compensation to the victims which was delayed. Sir Brian Langstaff's infected blood inquiry report, volume seven, has an entire chapter on the disappearance and or destruction of documents over the many decades. It starts a box on page two which summarises how documents were destroyed and then denied over the years.
1988, Lord Owen's files record a note that his paper had been destroyed by the Department of Health as "normal procedure after 10 years", we'll return to that in a minute. 1990 to 91, relevant documents identified as missing during the HIV litigation. February to March 1993, registered GEB/1 files relating to ACVSB sent to the DRO. September 1994, registered file GB1 volume 4 is destroyed in advance of its review date. June 1995, Dr. Rejman notifies the solicitor's division that one of the ACVSB files has apparently been destroyed.
May 1996, documents relating to the settled HIV litigation are identified as missing. October 97 to November 98, remaining GEB/1 volumes are destroyed.
April 2000, the report of the internal audit missing ACVSB documents. And in March 2004, the Department of Health informs Lord Owen that its review into self-sufficiency, quote, does not address why papers from your private office at the time may have been destroyed, end quote. And April 2005, meeting between Nigel Crisp and Lord Jenkin to discuss missing papers, end quote. My Lords, I've quoted those headings at length to demonstrate this is not just a one-off error of destroying papers too early. This is a culture of destroying important information.
And by the way, this list doesn't even cover many of the doctors' own files and patient files that were quietly destroyed as it became clear at the turn of the 1980s that illegal blood products research had been carried out on children without either their or their parents' consent. My Lords, the first infections happened in the 1970s. Known destruction of documents started in 1988. That destruction of papers has cost governments in this decade billions of pounds. And then, my Lords, there's Hillsborough.
The Lord Taylor report was about the arrangements on the day of Hillsborough and did not focus on the behavior of the police, although he did have some concerns about that. However, the report of the Hillsborough Independent Panel, published a quarter of a century later, was able to remedy this. And chapter 11 starts at para 2.11.1: statements made by South Yorkshire Police officers in the form of handwritten recollections of their experiences on the day of the disaster underwent an unprecedented process of review and alteration before their submission to the official Lord Taylor and his inquiry. And at para 2.11.6, it says: in contrast to their professional training, the officers were instructed not to record their experience in pocketbooks, and anyone who was involved in yesterday take time to sit down and make some notes. The briefing officer asked if officers had, quote, made a pocketbook brief, end quote.
None had. The briefing officer continued, quote: do not start making pocketbook entries. Yesterday was the most traumatic experience in my life and large chunks of it I cannot remember. I am sure it must be the same for the many of you, end quote. Now, both of these two egregious examples demonstrate actions by individual public officials as well as their corporate organizational behavior.
Last year, my Lords, Inquest's report on the Hillsborough Law Family Listening Day, known as All or Nothing, powerfully set out how the key destruction of evidence was for their victims and their families. One Hillsborough family member said their loved one was not afforded the truth he should have been. It was traumatic. It, the inquest, should have been the end. My Lords, it was not.
As well as in the Hillsborough tragedy, the destruction, hiding, or changing of evidence is key to the Post Office Horizon scandal, the COVID inquiry, the nuclear test veterans, the infected blood scandal, and many more. This is not one-off. This is cultural. We cannot have further destruction or hiding of evidence. And that is why this amendment makes it clear to public officials, public organizations, and above all to the public that this must change.
Speaker 70
Amendment proposed, after clause 7, insert the new clause printed on the Marshall list.
David Alton
My Lords, I rise to support the amendments in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Brinton and the noble Lord Lord Keen of Elie, amendments 31 and 82. The noble Baroness has made a very compelling case, and I'd like to delve deeper into two of the examples which she's given to the committee this afternoon. One concerns of course the Hillsborough disaster itself, but the other concerns British service personnel who were exposed to radiation during atomic tests. One reason why in 1989 I tabled a parliamentary question in another place to establish what warnings had been given before the football match at Hillsborough on April the 15th, when Liverpool and Nottingham Forest were drawn to play in the FA Cup semi-final, was that I was worried that the letter which I'd sent to the sports minister before the match on March the 22nd would disappear into the ether. I was glad that an archive like Hansard would ensure that that would not take place.
And it records that the honorable member wrote to me on the 22nd of March about the arrangements at the FA Cup semi-final at Hillsborough on April the 15th. No other representation was received. The arrangements for the match will be among the matters to be considered by Lord Justice Taylor's inquiry. That I was right to have worried that important information would disappear, or that records would be destroyed or altered, was more than borne out in the decades which followed the destruction, the falsification, and the alteration or withholding of records. My Lords, there were decades of dissimulation and decades of deceit.
Outrageously, that became a hallmark of the response to Hillsborough until finally it was exposed how crucial evidence was either destroyed, altered, or hidden from official oversight. Recall that Ken Sutton, one of the officials involved with the Hillsborough Independent Panel, testified that when they requested original police notebooks from the South Yorkshire Police, they were explicitly told that, I quote, they no longer existed. Years later, during the statutory inquest, these same notebooks magically reappeared, with no explanation provided as to why they were previously withheld. Last week during our proceedings in committee, I referred to the systematic altering of police statements. 164 police officer statements were altered.
Content that criticized senior police command, highlighted faulty police radio communications, or mentioned historical stadium safety issues was intentionally crossed out and deleted before being forwarded to the original Taylor inquiry. Note too that unverified allegations and outright calumny regarding the behavior of Liverpool fans were left intact and framed as facts. And, my Lords, concealment went to the highest levels of government, to the Cabinet Office, restricting access to vital records. In 2009, a Freedom of Information request by the BBC seeking minutes of meetings and briefings provided to the Prime Minister in April 1989 was refused by the Cabinet Office, citing policy formulation exemptions to keep the files hidden from public view. In 1989, I asked a Home Office minister, quote, at what level the publication of statements on April the 18th by South Yorkshire Police concerning the conduct of Liverpool fans at the Hillsborough semi-final was authorized, and if he'll publish a copy of that statement and the name of the officer who made it, and if he'll make a statement.
I received this reply: Statements made by officers of South Yorkshire Police are matters for the Chief Constable. It would not be helpful for me to publish statements or counter-statements which have been made about the circumstances leading to the tragedy or to name those who made them. It is for Lord Justice Taylor's inquiry to establish the facts. My Lords, the names of the officers who gave the authorisation were not made known. The falsehoods were allowed to stand.
Taylor didn't establish the facts, nor did he discover the truth. It was left to the grieving families to continue to demand answers and to insist that justice should be done. And as the years went by, I made repeated requests for the legal cases to be reopened. In June 1992, the then Solicitor General, Sir Derek Spencer, responded that the Attorney General would, quote, take a decision on an outstanding formal application for consent under section 13 of the Coroners Act 1988 as soon as possible. Three years had already elapsed since the tragedy.
And if ministers had acted in 1992, telling the coroner to reopen the case, it would not have become possible to hide behind the excuse that the passage of time impeded accurate recall of the details of what had occurred. In 1998, in your Lordships' House, I asked what account the Home Secretary and Lord Justice Stuart-Smith had taken, quote, in deciding against a fresh inquiry into the Hillsborough tragedy of missing video tapes, changed statements by police officers, conflicting medical evidence, and complaints of lack of impartiality in the original coroner's process and in the granting of immunity from prosecution to police officers upon taking early retirement, close quotes. The minister replied: Lord Justice Stuart-Smith considered all of the material evidence submitted to his scrutiny about the Hillsborough disaster. My right honourable friend the Home Secretary, Jack Straw, accepted his conclusion that there were no grounds for a fresh inquiry. The minister told us that there was no new video evidence, that the only missing video tapes were two tapes stolen on the day of the disaster, which remain missing.
They were not police tapes, and the judge was satisfied that they would not have shown anything significant. The minister said that, quote, allegations of irregularity and malpractice are not substantiated, and, quote, they found no grounds to suggest that the original inquests were flawed or that complaints of bias against the coroner were justified. No substantial irregularities, no malpractice. But of course now we all know otherwise. As Prime Minister David Cameron then told Parliament, the Liverpool fans had suffered a double injustice, both in, quote, the failure of the state to protect their loved ones and the indefensible wait to get to the truth.
In offering a full apology, he also admonished those who denigrated the deceased and suggested that they were somehow at fault for their own deaths. In 2012, the Hillsborough Independent Panel report led by Bishop James Jones made nine recommendations on systemic archive reform which would prevent future destruction of critical records, and these amendments underpin that. My Lords, I would simply turn to one other example, and I won't do so at great length. Back in the 1980s, I raised the position of former British servicemen who had been caught up in the atomic tests that had taken place on Christmas Island and in places like Maralinga in Western Australia. I've taken the trouble to print off the speeches.
It's notable for me, and I perhaps can say this as someone who once served as a Chief Whip, that the organising of government business is something that is always in the hands of the government of the day. It wasn't really surprising then that those debates, at which I think just a handful of us attended, one took place at 3:49 am in the morning and the other took place at, I think it was 4:31 in the morning.
Sometimes you can bury truths in different ways. Nevertheless, the archives substantiate many of the complaints which have been made over the years about the destruction of records, about the refusal to provide information for those who have sought to achieve justice in their own cases. During those debates in the 1980s, I said that the then minister's failure to release all the data would run the risk of being accused of cooking the books. I complained about attempts to push the issue into the long grass and the commissioning of a survey by an organization which veterans themselves believed would serve the department's interests rather than the pursuit of truth. My Lords, anyone who saw Victoria Derbyshire interviewing the former veterans minister on September the 2nd of this year will have been shocked to hear him say that he had misled Parliament in 2018 when he had been given false information by the Ministry of Defence.
And he said that no such radiological monitoring records existed, and which he has described as a complete cover-up designed to delay the truth until the aging veterans have died. So, my Lords, these amendments matter. They are about these situations, the atomic test victims and Hillsborough, but they are also about the infected blood scandal, they're also about Primodos, they're about Horizon, the Post Office, and so many other instances. Records matter. Members of Parliament matter too, and the denigration of members of Parliament for simply trying to shine a light on the truth is something that we should all have great cause to be concerned about.
I hope that when the noble Lord the minister comes to reply, he'll say where we are up to in the current new inquiries taking place into what happened to those atomic test victims. I strongly support these amendments.
Elizabeth Butler-Sloss
My Lords, statutory inquiries are very expensive. I was chairman of a statutory inquiry about the same time as Lord Taylor. What really depresses me is if you chair a statutory inquiry and you're given a whole lot of false information, or you're not given the relevant information, the report you make will not be correct. And that's what happened to the late Lord Taylor, who was later Lord Chief Justice of this country. Just think how he must have felt if he had been alive today to find that he'd written a completely useless report.
So one other aspect of this is that state money is spent on statutory inquiries. If you can't get the truth, what on earth is the purpose of having them?
Sally Hamwee
My Lords, it shouldn't have needed the examples to back up the my noble friend's amendment, which I've also signed, because I think it stands without them, but the examples that we have heard are very, very telling. I wonder if I can raise, the noble Lord has not yet had an opportunity to introduce his amendment 82, but perhaps I can ask him a question before he does.
Does it not actually narrow the obligations? 13 1 B provides that there's an offence if a person who holds public office knows or ought to know that doing so is a serious, seriously improper act. Know or ought to know. The proposed 13 1 C is about the deliberate destruction of documents which they know, only know, not ought to know, to be relevant to the inquiry. I'm concerned that he's actually seeking partly to repeat 13 1 B, which I don't think needs amplification, but that his amendment would actually narrow the obligation.
Alex Alexander Carlile
My Lords, I'm not sure in supporting these amendments that I accept that they go far enough. There is one word that is missing from the amendment 31 and that is conceal or concealment. And the same is missing from clause 12 of the bill. And I would respectfully suggest to the minister that clause 12 subclause 3 needs to be amended to include, if it is to remain, if clause 12 is to remain part of the bill, to include concealment. Surely, my Lords, what we are trying to achieve here is that it is a given for all public officials that they do not conceal, destroy or remove any document which is an official document.
They do not know whether it will be needed for an inquiry, but it has that imprimatur of officialdom that should be the preservative that it is never removed. And my Lords, there are so many categories of documents, we've had examples very eloquently given of the, of, of inquiries in which such behaviour has caused difficulties. But let's just think about the wide range of categories in which such difficulties can be caused. Deleting emails, destroying paper files, erasing WhatsApp messages, destroying meeting notes, diaries or notebooks, something that featured very strongly in the Hillsborough case. Removing metadata or audit logs, which has happened in relation to many subjects of inquiries.
Deleting calendar entries or call records. Overwriting backup tapes or archives. Shredding draft documents which revealed the real truth until they were amended by others who did not want the real truth to be disclosed. Destroying CCTV footage, audio recordings or photographs. Most egregious, and it has happened in police cases, I referred earlier in these debates to the Cardiff Three case, senior police officers instructing others to delete records.
It took years to unravel the truth as a result of those deletions. And deleting other records to avoid disclosure. These are just examples of some of the categories which are attempted to be remedied by the two amendments we're debating now. I suggest it doesn't go quite far enough, but we really do need them if we're going to achieve our purpose of ensuring that public records are sacrosanct against dishonest or reckless removal.
Kevan Jones
I welcome this amendment in terms of making it a criminal offence to deliberately destroy documents that could be relevant to an inquiry.
I think there's another side of this which we need to look at. And that is the policy within organizations of what documents are actually kept. Now we would have thought that decision notes on decisions are kept, minutes etc. are kept. But having spent many, many hours as chair of the ISC reviewing the Mandelson papers as part of the humble address, can I say depressingly to your lordships that systems that perhaps many years ago we got used to in terms of civil servants keeping records, using meeting notes and action notes, no longer seem to be the way in which our civil service, for example, works. So I think if we are going to have this, which I fully support, we also need, I think, some recognition of how organizations not only keep decision-making but also are noted, because quite clearly in the papers which my committee reviewed on Mandelson, there were some large gaps.
And I've got to say some departments were better than others, the Foreign Office being the worst at keeping notes or action notes, if they did exist, on decisions that had taken place. The other area, and we're talking obviously in terms of Hillsborough in a pre-digital age, is now, as has just been referred to, is the digital space, which is far more complicated in terms of and far easier, I would argue, to delete information. One of the things that concerned my committee was the use of WhatsApp and disappearing WhatsApp, which you would think would be something, if you want to keep a record of what happened, would be very important. But what I think surprised me and I think other members of the committee was the type of decisions that were being taken over WhatsApp and there was no record of those at all. Now was that a deliberate attempt to frustrate the system?
Well, I'll leave it to your lordships to make that conclusion. But if you have that type of process and you don't have any strict rules around what should be kept or what in the first place should actually be transacted on WhatsApp, because clearly my committee also have raised some issues around the level of security around WhatsApp, which certainly decisions and conversations were taking place which should never have been done apart from over high-side systems. So there seems to have been a lax culture developing. And I think if we are going to make sure that future inquiries have full access to how decisions are made and the material behind them, there needs to be a radical overhaul, I think, in the current culture within Whitehall in terms of ensuring that proper records are kept and, as I say, on the electronic side, some robust procedures are put in place, because without it, not only could it lead to the issue where people could deliberately delete things, things could be deleted because, for example, on WhatsApp they disappear after so many days. So I do welcome this, but I think alongside this, organizations are going to have to have a clear set of guidance about how records should be kept.
The Baroness Finn
My lords, I thank the noble Baroness Lady Brinton for opening our debate on this group. As she will see from my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie's amendment in this group, there is happily some common ground between us.
Although both amendments in this group relate to the destruction of documents, they differ in the time at which the offense would apply. Amendment 82 in the name of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie seeks to create a specific offense as part of the broader new statutory offense of misconduct in public office for the destruction of documents by a public official that are relevant to an inquiry. Although the minister has suggested during previous meetings that this would already be covered by the new statutory misconduct offense as set out in clause 13, we are seeking clarity on that point and ideally it would be included in the face on the face of the bill. We thank the noble lord the minister for his engagement on this issue since second reading. However, we continue to believe that the most effective way to solve this is to include the proposed offense on the face of the bill.
Indeed, the severity of the impact of the destruction of documents relating to a major incident on victims who deserve to know the truth is sufficiently severe to warrant clarity. Victims always deserve to know the truth. The government should not rely on previous case law for their belief that this proposed offense would be covered. They are creating a new statutory offense that will replace existing legislation and as such previous case law may not apply in the same way to the new clause 13. This is not something that should be left in doubt and so the amendment is a sensible way to avoid any such situation.
Turning now to amendment 31 in the name of the noble lady Baroness Brinton, which relates to the destruction of documents ahead of an inquiry in a similar vein to our own amendment. As drafted, the amendment in the name of the noble lord of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie applies only after an inquiry has been opened, which is perhaps too narrow as the noble baroness Lady Hamwee suggested. On the other hand, amendment 31 appears to perhaps be rather broad with insufficient limits as to what may be relevant. And I think there is a middle ground that would probably be the most suitable solution. But given the consensus in this house on the need for a clear offense of destruction of documents and and I take note of what the noble lord Lord Carlyle said about concealment as well, I hope the noble baroness Lady Brinton will be willing to work with us on an amendment that gets the balance right ahead of report stage.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
My lords, I'm grateful to all noble lords who have spoken during this debate and I note as Lady Finn says, the noble lady Lady Finn said there has been a great deal of consensus in this debate. It is a depressing and dispiriting litany that Lady Brinton and others have set forward. So I don't at all underestimate the importance of these amendments and the behavior, the mischief they seek to address. And it is obviously central, it is clearly central to one of the main aims of this bill and it is paramount that public officials who deliberately delete or destroy information in advance of an inquiry or inquest being called upon are properly held to account. If this type of offending is not stopped, then relevant and important information may no longer exist to be considered and I take the point made by my noble friend Lord Beamish about about if I may describe it as such as the lax procedures in keeping the information too.
We're confident that the bill as drafted already protects against the destruction of documents in two separate ways which I want to set out. Firstly, clause 2 4 a requires authorities and officials to provide information likely to be relevant to an inquiry or investigation if requested.
They will not meet this obligation if they allow the information to be lost or destroyed when they ought to be providing it. Intentionally or recklessly destroying documents in order to impede an inquiry or an investigation is an offence. The individual in charge of the authority, in addition, the individual in charge of an authority must also take all reasonable steps to secure the authority's compliance with the duty, including ensuring documents are accessible. Secondly, in appropriate circumstances, and I think this goes to the question that the noble lady Finn asked me, in appropriate circumstances and where the other elements of the offence are met, the destruction of documents could also be caught by the new seriously improper acts limb of the misconduct in public office offence. So I hope that's clear.
For example, a public officer could commit this offence if they use their position with the intent of obtaining a benefit or causing another to suffer a detriment when doing so, know or ought to know that their conduct is seriously improper. And a benefit could include seeking to protect themselves or their organisation from reputational harm or damage. Actions such as shredding documents or ordering that information be destroyed could therefore potentially be caught. The criminal law can already capture this type of conduct through offences such as perverting the course of justice. In March this year, for example, a serving police officer was convicted of perverting the course of justice for deliberately disposing of digital evidence.
A number of noble lords raised with me the question of digital evidence which was contained on a mobile phone. Contempt of court could also apply where records are destroyed in contravention of a court order. This type of conduct can also be and has been caught by the existing common law misconduct in public office offence, and I've already commented on how the replacement might apply. The two new misconduct offences are intended to cover the same breadth of offending as the existing common law offence. It is important to remember, nevertheless, that the key point of the new offences is the purpose for which a person carries out the act.
This ensures that the criminal law captures those who act with improper intent. Bespoke or unnecessary duplicate offences can risk creating confusion for those enforcing, prosecuting and seeking to abide by the law, so we should try and avoid them. Though I do note the strength of feeling in the House, and I shall be very happy to continue the discussion on this and other matters between now and committee. On the question of the noble lord Lord Alton's question about the atomic tests, I promised to write to you with the latest position on that. The government therefore considers that both the existing law and the provisions in this bill already provide suitable mechanisms for addressing the deliberate destruction of relevant records.
Creating additional or overlapping offences when the conduct is already capable of being prosecuted perhaps risks unnecessary complexity and confusion for investigators, prosecutors and public officials alike. So with those reassurances, I hope the noble baroness Lady Brinton will withdraw her amendment, though as I say, I promise to carry on the conversation.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My lords, I'm very grateful to everyone who's spoken in this medium-sized debate, not terribly short by our standard of the first day, but I think actually it's really helped the debate on the issue of what happens when people destroy documents. And I'm very grateful particularly to Lord Alton, who has been working particularly on Hillsborough and the nuclear veterans for many, many years and saw first-hand some of the things that I've reported as historic data deletion.
That's been enormously helpful. And Lady Butler-Sloss's point was equally important as well. I'm very mindful of Lady Hamwee's question to Lord Keen who can't be in his place to Lady Finn and I thank her for her responding. And I do think the one point that's come up with the varied debate we've had so far this afternoon is that there is much debate to be had on how we get it right between committee stage and report stage. And I hope that the minister will agree to meet with everyone who has spoken in this debate together to see if we can start to pull it out.
I'm grateful for Lord Carlisle's very particular comment about concealment. I think that is equal to destruction and that was certainly one of the issues with the nuclear veteran records. Lord Beamish absolutely rightly raised the issue of how on earth do we cope with data that isn't paper and stored in paper archives. I thought that the recommendations on the from the COVID inquiry volume one were quite helpful about WhatsApp must never be used to make formal decisions. However, in what we're discussing is the soft areas either side of that as well.
And I think this isn't just a matter for civil servants or for your Lordships' House. This is actually a wider issue, example contract law between businesses about where decisions are made and that information held. And I do think that the government is going to have to get to grips with that. I'm very interested to hear Lord Lymos's response. He quoted clause 2 4 A and the other clause that he quoted were actually not explicit about the destruction of documents.
And I think he accepts that. He quoted a number of other areas in which prosecution might potentially occur. Word potentially always slightly worries me. Can I ask to date how many prosecutions of officials under the various routes that he's described happened? My gut feeling is it's not very many.
And I think the whole problem and why we need this bill is to start to ensure that the bill is so clear that officials and their teams will be trained in what they can and they cannot do long before an issue comes up. That way the cultural changes will happen. But on the basis that there will be meetings between committee stage and report, I'm very grateful. I withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 90
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 32, Lord Carter of Haslemere.
Jane Bonham Carter
My Lords, my amendment 32 which kicks off this second group would require the government, any government, to lay before Parliament the details of action which will be taken in response to a public inquiry's recommendation or to explain why no action is to be taken. And I'm very grateful indeed to the noble Baroness Lady Brinton for adding her name in support of it. The UK has spent 1.5 billion pounds of taxpayers' money on completed inquiries since 1990. With active ongoing inquiries cost continuing to cost taxpayers upwards of 200 million a year. These are eye-watering sums.
It's become something of an industry to set up a public inquiry that goes on for years and costs huge sums of money. And yet the government is under no legal duty to explain why it's not implementing an inquiry recommendation after it's reported. How can a government be free to spend millions or hundreds of millions of taxpayers' money on an inquiry initiated because of public concern, that's in the act, and then be under no obligation even to give reasons to the public for rejecting its recommendations? The bill's supposed to be, this bill is supposed to be about public authorities acting with quote candour, transparency and frankness.
It's designed to increase public authorities' accountability and openness. Government ministers and departments are defined in the bill as a public authority. So it's entirely in line with this bill that the government should be required to be open with the public and give reasons if they decide not to implement inquiry recommendations. Note, not a duty to implement inquiry recommendations, but simply a duty to give reasons for not doing so. That is plain common sense and there is no reason on earth not to do so.
And it's not a purely theoretical point. The NAO estimated, has estimated that 55% of inquiry recommendations are not accepted by the government or somewhat equivocally, quote accepted in principle, but with no recorded follow-through. This is extraordinary when an inquiry's recommendations are made on the basis of months or years of painstaking evidence gathering to establish the facts and to hear from real experts. For the government then to be able to hold back the reasons for declining to accept the inquiry's recommendations demonstrates a lack of accountability which is entirely at odds with the bill now before us. It's also at odds with the recommendations in prevention of future deaths reports issued by coroners, where the government is under a statutory duty to respond within 56 days and to give reasons if they choose not to implement them.
Since inquiries are often initiated because of events which have resulted in fatalities, there's no good reason on earth why there should be this disparity with coroners' prevention of future deaths reports. Our new Solicitor General seems to be of a similar mind, since at report stage in the other place, just a week or so before he was appointed, he tabled amendments to the bill to examine the merits of a new independent oversight body to follow up on the conclusions and recommendations of inquiries to improve implementation of them. As he said, quote, without candour and transparency in how public authorities respond to and act on findings and recommendations, these costly, lengthy legal processes are futile. In 2024, the House of Lords Select Committee on Inquiries chaired by the noble Lord, Lord Norton, made a similar recommendation and recommended the government be under a duty to give reasons for not implementing inquiry recommendations. In a bill about openness, candour and accountability in relation to inquiries, a duty on the government of the day to give such reasons is obvious, and I beg to move.
Speaker 90
Amendment proposed, after clause 8, insert the new clause as printed on the marshalled list.
Anderson
A few remarks on amendment 32, which the noble Lord Carter has so ably introduced. I have conducted some independent inquiries of a sort that would fall within this clause, though none of them cost millions or hundreds of millions. In some cases, the noble Lord Carter was legal adviser to those who commissioned them, whether in the Home Office or in Number 10. So it is refreshing to see that the noble Lord, who was on the other side of the fence, champions the undoubted public interest in the recommendations of such inquiries receiving a prompt response. His solution is an attractive one, but as I have discussed with my noble friend, there are a couple of reasons why I think it would not always be feasible, at least in its current form.
First, a fixed requirement to respond and lay those responses before Parliament within 56 calendar days could not easily be met if, for example, a report is submitted shortly before the calling of a general election and the arrival of a new government. Perhaps that difficulty could be accommodated by the substitution of parliamentary sitting days for days in the amendment. But in other cases, what used to be called pre-election purdah may have an impact on the timing of any response, making a 56-day limit too rigid in an unpredictable range of cases. Secondly, there are times when more than one report is commissioned in relation to the same issue. A recent example is my report on the failure of the government's Prevent program to divert the Southport attacker from the path that led him to murder three young girls in the most appalling circumstances.
I sent my report to the Secretary of State last July. An informal reaction was given and work began immediately on some of my recommendations. But the Home Secretary chose to delay her formal response until she had the report of phase one of Sir Adrian Fulford's Southport inquiry, which was published in April of this year. Our two reports made some overlapping recommendations with implications across central and local government. A consolidated response was, I think, a rational solution in the circumstances, even though I had to wait almost a year for it.
The final point I would make relates to the importance of timely publication of independent reports. It is publication that enables select committees, parliamentarians, media, and NGOs to bring the findings of an inquiry to the attention of the public and to put pressure on government to implement them. As an independent reviewer, I was always more concerned by delays in publication than by delays in the government's response. It must be demoralizing to submit a report to a Secretary of State which simply disappears, only to be published so long after the event that its impact is diminished. Unless the matter is a high-profile one, there can be no guarantee that parliamentary committees or the media will be much exercised by the delay or interested in it.
If the government's reaction to recommendations have to be published within 56 days of receipt, as this amendment would provide, that must imply that the report itself has been published within 56 days. A Secretary of State could hardly lay before Parliament a response to recommendations of which Parliament and the public are ignorant. So while the amendment does not on its face require timely publication of reports, it would appear to have that benign, I would say, side effect. Perhaps the noble Lord could comment when he closes this debate on whether this is a feature of his amendment rather than a bug. I rather hope that it is.
And I look forward to hearing what the noble Lord, the Minister, has to say about the importance of timely publication as well as timely response.
Kevan Jones
My Lords, I, sorry. Sir, can I welcome Lord Carter's amendment for a very important issue? And that's what happens to the outcome of very lengthy and expensive inquiries. The noble Lord raised what's been spent on public inquiries since 1990, and I suspect that will grow even further. Because the problem I think we've got into, and I'm as guilty possibly as a parliamentarian as any others, is as soon as something goes wrong, we call for an inquiry, a public inquiry, as though somehow the public inquiry is going to get to the truth and change things.
And having spent a long time with the victims, for example, of the Post Office Horizon scandal, what do people actually want? Well, they want, I think, two things. Yes, they want the facts out there. But they also want, which in some cases compensation, quite rightly.
But more than anything, most of them actually say, we don't want this to happen again. So it's actually about changing things in the future. Now, let's deal with compensation. I think the Public Accounts Committee report a couple of weeks ago was very good, that we need to set up a permanent body to deal with compensation. Because having sitting as I do, and I should have declared interest on the Horizon Post Office Advisory Board, you know, we've got five different schemes just in that one, that one scandal alone.
We're inventing these things every single time. And it leads to two things. One, it leads to a waste of effort, but also, I think, delay to getting victims to compensation. So I think that call for a permanent government body to deal with compensation, I think, is important. Now, I have sympathies with this amendment because it comes to, I think, something that myself and Professor Chris Hodges, who chairs the Advisory Board for Horizon compensation, have been doing some work on.
And that's how do you actually ensure that public inquiry's recommendations are actually implemented and accepted by government? Now, the problem, I think, with how it's framed here is, I think, and I welcome the debate, I think it's good that we're having it. But I think this could, governments could hide behind this very easily by just saying, well, we note the report and that, you know, things are going to be, you know, looked at possibly in the future or never, or if there's a change of government, it just gets lost off. So my personal preference to it is that, yes, I think we do need timely, you know, timely reports of inquiries, but also we need actions on behalf of the departments as well to implement the recommendations. But this is where it falls down.
I remember, for example, with the, is it Sir John Saunders' inquiry into the Manchester Arena bombing, who made some very good recommendations. But one of his concerns was how did they actually get followed through afterwards? He actually wrote to the ISC, for example, asking whether we could monitor. Well, we didn't have the capacity or were set up to do that. But that showed me that there was a gap there in ensuring that way forward.
I personally think the only way to do it is two things. One, I think we need to reform inquiries. I think we need a permanent new body, whether it's a super-ombudsman type organization which sits permanently to actually look at where scandals are generated, can actually look at these and make timely recommendations. The other thing, I think, is parliamentary oversight. I think alongside that, you could perhaps have a select committee of either joint of the two houses or whatever, which would not only be able to look at the work of the inquiry organization that I'm envisaging, but also, more importantly, look at the actual implementation of the recommendations of inquiries.
Because I think without some type of parliamentary oversight and pressure on the executive, there's always going to be a default position is that once it's out of the headlines, as Lord Arbuthnot just said, then do we really need to worry about this? And that's the problem. Public inquiries get a lot of heat and light when the recommendations come out, but what's the actual follow-through in terms of the detail, because some will take a long time and a lot of detailed work to implement and cost. But that needs to be monitored, and I think that should be a role, I think, for Parliament.
Otherwise, I think what we're going to get into is a lot of publicity around when we get the recommendations of inquiries, and then a lot of disappointed people afterwards because they don't get what I think is more important than anything for them, is that understanding that things will change for the future. You know, you talk to a lot of the victims of the Post Office Horizon inquiry, what a scandal, what do they want? And you hear it more times than anything, we don't want this to happen again to anybody in the future. And I think that is a common tenant amongst a lot of the victims of a lot of these scandals. So it's meaningful change and actually somehow that their suffering has actually had some effect in terms of actually changing things for the future.
Speaker 93
I have a great deal of sympathy with this recommendation, and I do hope that the minister, the noble minister, when replying, will commit to having some further discussions, because I also have some sympathy with the comments that have been made, not all of them, but many of them. When I chaired the Soham inquiry, I included in the recommendations a recommendation that Parliament should require the government to report back in six months. And the Home Secretary on behalf of the government accepted that. The reason that I said six months, and it would be an amendment I would make, I think, to the amendment, is that as has been said, it's very easy 56 days after a report has been published to agree it, or to agree much of it. But what we're really interested in, what we're all really interested in, is the action that has been taken.
And I felt that six months was a sufficient period for the government to actually show that it was acting upon my recommendations for a new national police intelligence service, a new vetting service, and it actually worked very well. And one of the reasons it worked really well is that civil servants, of which I was one, of course, at some point in my past, civil servants do take very seriously the prospect of a Home Secretary reporting back to Parliament in six months' time on the action that they effectively have taken. And therefore I found that they were very keen to keep me in the loop and to talk to me. I think we wouldn't have achieved anything like the success that I think we did have as a result of the Soham inquiry had I not done that. I think 56 days is a staging post, but it's too early to be sure that the recommendations have been acted upon, and that's what I think we should be looking for.
Edward Faulks
I was also on the committee of your Lordship's House referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Carter, who looked into the future of public inquiries. I have to say that public inquiries didn't get an overwhelming endorsement. Many of us thought they went on too long, they were too expensive, they were often insufficiently focused, and they were very much over-lawyered. And one of our conclusions was that we should try, unless it was absolutely necessary, to get rid of judges, excellent though they are, and focus inquiries on those perhaps who had more specific expertise. Some of those conclusions weren't welcome, but I think the time to look at public inquiries is very much there.
There are too many of them, and I see the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, was also on the committee, will remember those debates and others. But one thing we were clear upon was very much in line with the recommendation contained in this amendment, which is if we are going to have these very expensive inquiries, then if there are recommendations which they should be, and those recommendations should be responded to swiftly.
And he's quite right, that is entirely reflective of the theme of this legislation, which is one of candour. And subject to the changes that the noble Lord Anderson makes to tidy it up this, I would respectfully say to this committee that this sort of amendment is important, it's consistent with the theme of the bill, and it reflects recommendations made by a number of different bodies.
Elizabeth Butler-Sloss
I cannot resist following on from the noble Lord. My inquiry started in 1987, I presented a report in 1988, so some judges do not take a lot of time. But following on, speaking to this amendment, I think the principle is excellent, but Lord Anderson has pointed out some difficulties and it may well need to have some degree of rewriting. But what really is depressing, anyone in this chamber who's run an inquiry knows that the recommendations very often are not responded to by the government for a long time, as has already been said, but much, much more depressing aren't in fact carried out, as other noble Lords have already said. And my particular inquiry was dealing with children.
There've been endless inquiries ever since mine, all dealing with aspects of children, all coming largely to the same result without any action at all. And I think the best of all was one of my recommendations was that social services, everybody else, should listen to children. Do you know, I heard at the beginning of this year a minister in this house standing up and saying, we should listen to children.
Claire Fox
My Lords, I haven't run an inquiry, sat on an inquiry, been on a committee, but over the weekend I was chairing a debate or discussion involving Maggie Oliver, the ex-detective whistleblower who came out and spoke about the grooming gangs, and as well as her, on the panel was Emma Webber, whose son Barnaby was killed by Valdo Calocane and who has personally done so much via social media and the media to reveal the details, as it were, for laypeople about what's happening in the Nottingham inquiry to date, something I mentioned in second reading. And this was a discussion and a debate about accountability of public officials, of the state bodies, when things go wrong, when there's preventable deaths and so on, very much at the heart of this bill. And it was an event at the Battle of Ideas festival. And I was really taken aback by the reaction of the audience when I raised this particular bill that we're discussing here today and the nature of trying to ensure that the law would be brought to bear to ensure that there's truth and candour in inquiries and so on. Because there was an overwhelming feeling in the audience of hundreds who were in that particular discussion that public inquiries were a waste of time and money.
There was a sort of a sense of, oh, you know, that's just about diffusing public anger, of setting up a whole infrastructure and so on that kicks the issue down the road, you know, whatever comes out of public inquiries. Now, there will be people here who'll say, no, they're very important, and I've often been in a position of demanding a public inquiry, I certainly did in relation to the grooming gangs. But I think the merit of this very important amendment to me, even if the details need to be ironed out in terms of if it's too rigid or whatever, and I thought that what the noble Lord Carter of Haslemere was getting at was that the government and no government is obliged to act on all the recommendations of an inquiry.
That would be ridiculous. That's fine. But if they don't, they should say why not. It's simple. I mean, if you go through all of that and we've the figures have been the eye-watering amounts of money, let alone time and and and energy of an aspect of state bodies putting on this inquiry, come to a series of recommendations, then surely there is a duty of candour, if ever there was a need for a duty of candour, to be truthful to the public about what the government of the day thinks about that inquiry.
What did you think of the recommendations? Are you going to do this? Are you going to not do that? Why not? And so on and so forth.
That is surely a very minimal demand. And therefore I would suggest that this amendment for the government is a no-brainer because it will actually strengthen the real commitment of this act to being more than a just a box-ticking exercise. Because if there is cynicism about this particular piece of legislation, and by the way, there's great enthusiasm for its aims, the the danger is that people think that this will be a law that will say that you are going to have more accountability and an ethos of truth-telling and will hold people to account, but that actually the law is being used to compensate for building a different kind of culture in our public authorities. And that in some ways it could end up being a bureaucratic box-ticking exercise unless we actually get the details right. So I fully support this amendment.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I've signed Lord Carter's amendment 32, which he set out very clearly and we've had a fascinating debate as with the previous group on I think it's probably a Goldilocks issue of, you know, there are some things that we clearly need to do, but there are other things that are clearly problematic and we don't want to do. Have we found the sweet spot? I'm mixing all my metaphors and I apologize for that. Throughout the progress of this bill, we've debated a great deal about how we tackle the culture that Lady Fox just mentioned just now of public organizations to prevent the future scandals. You've already heard about Hillsborough, infected blood, Post Office Horizon, Windrush, and we haven't I think I don't think anyone's mentioned Grenfell yet today, but but I will do so.
And the amendment is one of the tools in the box to show that both structures and the culture must change. And whether it's 56 days at the end of the day or if it's longer, I don't think Lord Carter is particularly he'll respond in his own right. I think we're trying to find a mechanism to prevent the current practice, let's not call it culture, of the government usually taking a year to respond to an inquiry or other major report that it has to do, and then deciding that it needs to consult on various parts of it and then comes back with its recommendations after that. So quite often it's two plus years before practical changes are being discussed. And one of the things that is very clear from all the problematic disasters that we've been discussing throughout the passage of this bill is that where things have got stuck in a rut and into the public sector mindset of deflect, let's not do anything, is because there've been no targets for them to respond to.
And that's why I like this particular amendment. It may need to change a bit, but the most important element is that the government would have to give an initial response. And it may be, especially if there are other reports coming as well, that that might change. But the whole point of this bill is about transparency, accountability, which means if things have to change, the government should not be afraid to say so. I know it's not been in the culture of a government to say, "Oops, we got this wrong," or, "Things have changed, we need to change this."
But actually, if we're going to get all these complex, difficult issues right, we have to learn to take that approach. My Lords, I was interested in what Lord Beamish was saying about one compensation body. My amendment 111 will be discussed at the next stage. I am passionate about having one compensation body. I think, very briefly, in ten seconds, part of the problem is we move civil servants who've been responsible for the problem into the compensation body because they're the only other people who know about it.
We have to move away from that. I think we really need to focus our thoughts on the immediate response to make sure that things aren't lost. Yes, we keep going on about cultural change, but part of the cultural change inside our public official organisations and with our public officials is feeling that you haven't got the time to ignore something because it might go away if nobody does anything at all.
Faulkner
My Lords, I have come late to our debates on this bill. I was unable to be here for second reading, but I was here all of last week for the long day we had in discussing it, but I apologise to the house and I beg their indulgence to allow me to participate today and onwards. Several of the things, I have a few questions to the very commendable amendment from my noble friend Lord Carter. There are a couple of things I'd like to pick up on because I think they're pertinent and important to the very heartfelt support there is in this house for this amendment and for the desire of the house to ensure, as Lord Beamish put it, to reflect the public's desire that some action is taken. What's come of all of that time and money and inquiry?
Speaker 99
And Baroness Fox's comments on the grooming gang scandal are a case in point, where the independent investigation into child sexual abuse, which was the formal title of the J inquiry, reported, took several years and then finally reported in October 2022. We then, to pick up Lord Anderson's point, we then had a little bit of action, a couple of the recommendations were accepted out of a large number, and then there was a general election. And what happened was that the government decided that, for whatever reason that was never clear to those of us who were following it carefully, that the J recommendations weren't, or the inquiry hadn't been sufficiently deep or wide-ranging or whatever it was, and it decided that it would run parallel inquiries into the criminal actions in certain towns and cities in the inquiry, but it would also commission Baroness Casey to do an overall approach. And we were told, I think this was announced as long ago as 2024, shortly after the government came in, or perhaps early last year. But we're told that nothing will happen there in terms of the recommendations till at least next year and potentially longer, given the rather overworked Baroness Casey has several other pending items in her in-tray.
Faulkner
And I think the point to be made is that when inquiries like that, where palpable injustice and criminal acts have happened, take decades in themselves, then clearly Lord Carter of Haslemere makes the very good point that we need to hear from ministers as to what they're going to do about it.
And certainly an explanation of why they've decided to dismiss part of an inquiry or not take any action, because that was the other lot who were dealing with that and now there's a new lot and they want something else. So the explanation in part B of his amendment as to why no action is to be taken in response to the recommendations of the inquiry, I think is profoundly important. But I really do not believe that eight weeks, 56 days, will be adequate, particularly if pre-election purdah, change of government and any of the other other hurdles that come in here were to be erected. And perhaps the noble Lord Lord Carter in summing up will be able to tell us whether he's minded to perhaps give a little bit more leeway to government and extend that period so that there's a reasonable amount of time that allows government to respond.
David Wolfson
My Lords, I can speak I think briefly on this group. Firstly, on the government amendments, these consist primarily of amendments to clarify drafting and application to Wales. And so for fairly obvious reasons, I'm not going to oppose them. I do look forward however to the day when bills as originally drafted fully take into account the position of Wales, rather than amendments coming through halfway through the process. I confess the last government was probably as guilty on that point as this one, but it is something which we ought to think about.
More substantively, amendment 32 in the name of the noble Lord Lord Carter of Haslemere seeks to place a duty on the Secretary of State to respond to recommendations of inquiries related to the actions of public authorities within 56 days. This amendment respectfully we think makes a very sensible point. We agree that there should be some sort of scrutiny after the fact if a government chooses not to accept recommendations. Of course the government always holds the pen. There's no requirement that the government should accept all or indeed any recommendations of any inquiry.
But it does stand to reason we suggest that the government should at least provide reasons for not doing so. I was very encouraged by the reference of the noble Lord Lord Carter to Mr. Andy Slaughter supporting this proposition, until I heard those disheartening words a few days before he joined the government. I don't know whether the famous line, you know, presume not that I'm the thing that I was, Shakespeare tells us that applies to somebody becoming the monarch. I don't know whether it also applies to somebody attaining the lofty office of Solicitor General. But we wait to see whether there is a volte-face in his personal position.
But we do think there is a lot of force in the underlying point for the reasons given by the noble Lord and a number of other contributors to this debate. And then we do therefore look forward to the noble Lord the Minister responding to that substantive point. On the timescale, we do respectfully think that there is a lot in the point made by a number of noble Lords, in particular Lord Anderson of Ipswich and Lord Bichard, that 56 days might not be the right period. It's not self-evident that any particular time period is necessarily the right way to go about this, putting a time period into law.
There may be other pressing issues that need addressing as a priority over responding to an inquiry. Of course inquiries ought to be responded to in a timely manner and there must be a form of drafting which is capable of capturing that essential point. But we do therefore look forward to the noble lord the minister perhaps addressing these three separate questions which seems to us to arise. First of all does the government agree as a matter of principle that the government should respond to all inquiry recommendations? If so does the government agree that when the government is not accepting an inquiry recommendation it should give reasons for its decision not to accept that recommendation?
And third if the government is like us not persuaded that 56 days is the right time period what time period does the government have in mind and what are the reasons supporting that time period?
Anthony Gerard Lemos
My lords I I thank all noble lords for their contributions to this debate and I note with some humility the enormous amount of experience that has been demonstrated in this debate from noble lords who have chaired inquiries. But I'll come to those in a minute if I may. Can I firstly deal with the government's amendment? These are technical amendments to make sure that statutory and non-statutory inquiries established by Welsh ministers are subject to the provisions in the bill regarding the conduct and the reporting of conduct of public authorities at inquiries and the engagement and conduct of legal representatives. This allows Welsh ministers to set out an overriding objective regarding participation and maintain the inquisitorial nature of proceedings in relation to statutory inquiries.
We're also making an amendment to the Government of Wales Act 2006 and this should ensure that should the Senedd subsequently legislate to remove the relevant concurrent functions it would be able to do so without requiring the consent of a minister of the crown. I therefore beg that these amendments be moved. Turning now to Lord Carter's amendment my lords the government entirely agrees that there should be a clear and consistent expectation on public authorities to respond to inquiry reports and their recommendations. And to answer the specific question that the noble lord Lord Anderson asked me I do think that that does absolutely go to the point about timely publication as well. Long delays are clearly not at any stage in the process are clearly a significant problem.
I note the comment that the noble lady Lady Butler-Sloss made about the risk that inquiries overlap with each other and the many inquiries in various ways that there have been about children including her own distinguished inquiry. And she referred to the last time she heard someone in your lordship's house say we don't listen to children. I think that might have been me so I plead guilty as charged and anything I would say in my own defense is we still don't listen to children. But it is obviously vital that public authorities have enough time to fully consider the inquiry's recommendations. I think everybody would agree with that and support ministers to make informed decisions about how to respond.
Once inquiry recommendations are accepted they become government policy. This is a really important point.
That must be delivered. And I know Lord Beecham's comments about the delivery of the agreement to the recommendations, not just the agreement to the recommendations. And I'm very familiar with his work on the Salmon inquiry and how important the changes were that were made. I entirely share the sentiments of my noble friend Lord Beamish. Having talked to many victims of many different kinds of disasters over the years, the pressing feeling that what people, survivors, victims, the bereaved families and so on want is that they don't want this to happen again.
And of course the way to make sure it doesn't happen again is to deal with it promptly. You know, so we do slightly go round in circles on that point. But it is obviously right. As the noble Lord may be aware, we are taking steps to improve the government's delivery of accepted inquiry recommendations, including through the inquiry recommendation dashboard. However, the government does agree that the noble Lord Lord Carter is right to raise this issue.
And we of course know that there has been some discussion in the other place. And I will take away his proposal to consider. And I know the comments and the questions that have been raised by other noble Lords about the deadline and so on. But we will take away his proposal to consider how we can establish a clearer and more consistent expectation on public authorities to respond to inquiry recommendations. On the specific points that Lord Wolfson asked me, I think I've dealt with them in my response, but I'm very happy to do so explicitly as it were.
Yes, I think the government should respond and indeed should give its reasons and do so in a timely fashion. But we will, as I say, I will take this away. And I think the feeling of the House is that there's a bit more work to do on this to get it right. But in the meantime, I'd therefore ask the noble Lord to withdraw his amendment.
Jane Bonham Carter
My Lords, I'm very grateful indeed for all the encouraging support that this amendment has had. I entirely accept points made by noble and learned Lord Lord Anderson in particular about the 56-day period. The reason for that, as I said in my speech, was because that is the period that applies legally to coroners and so I just seized on that. Of course, that may be, there may be circumstances where that's too short. Lord Anderson's given some very good examples of that.
So I'm entirely flexible about that. But there needs to be a meaningful, timely response. That was the word that the noble and learned Lord Lord Wolfson used. And it has to have some sort of legal authority behind it. Otherwise we'll end up with these pat phrases about in due course and so on.
I don't think as the amendment stands that the point made by Lord Beamish that the government could simply note the report would actually tick the wording of my amendment, which is about giving an explanation as to why no action is to be taken. But so there needs to be some finality. The finality point goes also to the points made by Lord Beamish and Lady Butler-Sloss around things coming around again and again. That's a point that's been made a number of times. We're wasting public money when these things happen.
There needs to be finality to these things so that action can be taken and government can be seen to be delivering what the inquiry's experts and chair have reported. So I entirely accept that point. Quite simply, noble Lords have got the point. Lady Fox made it very well.
She understood entirely the substance of my and Lady Brinton as well, the substance of my thing is to just the government must be under a duty to respond and give some sort of explanation for not accepting a recommendation if that's the that's the outcome. And that's what I'm getting at. I'll think carefully about the wording of the amendment. I'll discuss it with noble peers and let's come back to this at report stage. But in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 70
Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 33, Lord Wills, not moved. Question is that clause 8 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.
Content.
Speaker 70
To the contrary not content. The contents have it. After clause 8, amendment 34, Lord Wolfson. Lord Keen of Elie, Lord Wolfson, amendment 34.
The Baroness Finn
Sorry. My Lords, I rise to move amendment 34 in the name of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie. This amendment seeks to probe the level of guidance and support that will be made available to officials in order for them to navigate this duty of candour set out in clause 2. This amendment seeks to ensure that the bill is effective in practice and that civil servants are properly supported with their legal responsibilities. In order for this legislation to be as effective as the government intends it to be, it is essential that officials know how to comply with the duty of candour and are given any necessary support in fulfilling that duty.
This matters most in the case of more junior officials who may lack experience engaging in inquiries or other similar affairs. Can the noble Lord the Minister say in his response what assessment has been made of the difficulties officials at the most junior level may face in complying with clause 2(3)(a)? Those officials who are more senior, especially those who have experience engaging with investigations and inquiries, will surely be far better equipped to comply with the duty of candour. So will the government make specific provision for those officials who lack that experience? The government has chosen to proceed by imposing a broad disparate duty of candour on all officials.
We understand why they have sought to proceed in this way given the evidence of South Yorkshire Police altering hundreds of police statements and plain paper accounts following the 1989 Hillsborough disaster. A disparate duty removes the role of the central body, preventing that body from altering statements and evidence to the inquiry. But it cannot be right that junior officials and other officials that lack experience of such engagement with inquiries should be left to navigate their legal experience their legal responsibilities alone. What legal support will officials be able to draw down either from their department directly or from lawyers funded by their department? The government might, not unreasonably, say that civil service trade unions will take on the responsibility of providing officials with legal advice where an inquiry of relevance to their work is established.
I cannot imagine trade unions would want that responsibility, but it is not unreasonable to think that they might be able to provide officials with the support that they need. I would be interested to hear whether the noble Lord the Minister has discussed the duties in this bill and their consequences for officials with representatives of the trade unions, and can he perhaps tell us what role the trade unions intend to play? Having said that, not all members not all public servants are members of trade unions, and it would not be right for the government to impose legislation that makes it virtually an occupation necessity to join a trade union. So, in the circumstances where an official is not a member of a union, as many aren't, the question remains what support will their sponsor department provide?
And departments may have an even more wide-ranging support to offer. With the broad duty of candour, there is a significant risk that a junior or inexperienced employee might want to have their department provide instructions on what they should and should not provide to an inquiry. So what assessment has the government made of the possible greater role that could and should be played by individual departments, or perhaps a central unit in the Cabinet Office, to ensure that our hard-working public officials are not left to navigate what is clearly a complex law alone? I beg to move.
Speaker 70
Amendment proposed, after clause 8, insert the new clause printed on the marshalled list.
Jonathan Marks
My Lords, first I apologize to the House that I was unable to be here for either second reading or the first day of committee, and so I've not spoken before on the bill. My Lords, as we all know, clause 2.1 insists on candour, transparency, and frankness in dealing with inquiries and investigations. And they are rightly identified in the bill as the crucial requirements for honest dealing. But my Lords Lord Keen and Lord Wolfson, and Baroness Finn, who so ably opened this amendment in their place, are also right that the standards which effectively state the Nolan principles are expressed in the bill in general terms only. And we, and the officials of whom these standards are demanded, need to be clear about what follows from the Nolan principles in terms of their practical application.
And so the bill in that regard would benefit from elucidation. And that elucidation can be given by guidance. We would of course ordinarily expect guidance. The bill introduces a specific and express duty of candour and assistance, which does amount to a new area of public duty. Certainly a new expression of a duty that might always have been implicit, but is now to be explicit.
Furthermore, clause 5 establishes a new offence of failing to comply with the duty of candour and assistance in respect of an inquiry or investigation, and that of itself is a strong reason why clear guidance is particularly necessary. So we think it right that guidance should be compulsory. I note that the member's explanatory statement for amendment 34 describes this as a probing amendment. We on these benches would be more forthright about it. The amendment is in no sense didactic about what should be in the guidance, but a compulsory requirement for guidance from government would provide a great deal.
And I note that the noble lady Baroness Finn talked about the possibility of guidance from trade unions. That is as may be, but what is required is guidance from government, which would provide first clarity, clarity as to what is to be required of officials and what support they will receive in abiding by the duty. It would provide consistency across different organisations and between different areas of the country and different areas of operation. And there's no indication in the bill now as to how consistency is to be achieved. It would provide clear assistance to officials, who above all need to know what they must do to comply with the new express duty and to avoid falling foul of the criminal law.
And it would provide assistance to the courts and to the judiciary when they come to interpret the law and, from the judges' points of view, direct juries as to their as to the requirements of the new law.
Above all perhaps I echo what the noble Lord Lord Beamish said in the last group in relation to the implementation of the recommendations by inquiries. It would provide clear guidance on what is required of officials to be bound by the assistance in helping them as officials avoid repetition of past failures which is part of what this bill is all about. My Lords for all these reasons we regard this as a sensible amendment and we would invite the government not merely to be probed by it but to accept it.
Faulkner
I have some questions to do with this particular amendment which I think relate to not necessarily those public bodies that would have access to adequate legal advice and information. In doing so I support the the amendment entirely and I wanted to make that clear up front. My questions have to do with non-departmental public bodies and arms-length bodies where I have some experience. Frequently and as Lady Finn has pointed out frequently the duties of this bill would fall on relatively junior officials who may despite training they might have received may not have the capabilities to provide the necessary information in the format in order and indeed with the with the alacrity that would be required. So my question to the government would be and this relates particularly to part four schedule six which deals with parity which we will come to later in the bill but I wanted to pick up the point here in this part.
Would it relate to to external legal advice frequently from independent counsel because an arms-length body may not have the internal capacity to get that legal advice and indeed many of them in dealing with the kind of inquiry such as the COVID inquiry entails long and detailed responses require or have to hire independent counsel to to advise them in any event. So my my question to the minister is that where it says at at part four in schedule six and I quote public authorities must have regard to guidance promoting candour and supporting the inquisitorial character of inquiries may use public representatives only when necessary and proportionate and must answer concerns raised about their conduct. What is the meaning of necessary and proportionate I would argue here and how would we ascertain that? And I therefore think that that's the reason the guidance guidance is so important.
Anderson
My Lords I am grateful to the noble Baroness Lady Finn for moving the noble and learned Lord Lord Keen of Elie's amendment which seeks to make a requirement for government to publish guidance on the duty of candour and assistance within one month of the offences coming into force. I agree with the noble Baroness that it is essential that officials under the duty understand what is required of them and where they can seek support regardless of their seniority. While broadly speaking the intention of the duty of candour is to enforce the behaviour already expected of public officials and authorities it's important that there is clarity about the new law.
I can therefore assure the noble Baroness Lady Finn and the noble Lord Lord Marks that we will provide guidance to public officials about the duty of candour and assistance, and that our intention is for this to be ready for the commencement of the duty. In response to the resourcing questions raised by the noble Baroness Lady Finn and again by Lady Faulkner, departments currently provide legal advice to officials, and we would expect the same for arms-length bodies, and we expect this to continue upon commencement of the bill. In light of these reassurances, I hope that the noble Baroness will be content to withdraw the amendment.
The Baroness Finn
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord Lord Marks and the noble Baroness Lady Faulkner for their support for this amendment and for highlighting the need for clear guidance, particularly from the government, to support officials, particularly especially more junior ones, in abiding by the duty. And I thank the noble Baroness the Minister for acknowledging the importance of this issue and welcome the commitment to bring forward guidance on this matter. In light of all of that, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Speaker 70
Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Question is that clause 9 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content.
The contents have it. In clause 10, amendment 34A, Lord Hendy.
John Hendy
My Lords, I have five amendments in this group and if it's convenient to your Lordships, I propose to speak to all five of them and then formally move the first one. And I'll be brief. My Lords, this group concerns the involvement of workers in the fulfillment of the clause 2 obligations, with the exception of the last amendment, which deals with impact assessments. I use the word workers with a precision because your Lordships will have observed that in clause 10(2), the obligation of ethical conduct is at all times by people who work for the authority. And as somebody with some experience in employment law, that to me means employees, limb (b) workers, self-employed workers, bogus self-employed workers, agency workers, workers under a personal service company, and it may even involve those who volunteer for nothing.
So that's a very broad concept. My Lords, the first amendment, 34A, is a simple one. It's to insert the words "all reasonable" in clause 10(1), which currently reads: "A public authority must promote and take steps to maintain high standards" and so on. The amendment would make it "take all reasonable steps". That's a phrase which is used in relation to public authorities in clause 2, where it says that a public official who's in charge of the authority must take all reasonable steps to secure that the authority complies with those obligations.
Speaker 105
My Lords, the second amendment I propose is 37A, which requires in the drafting of the code of ethical standards by each public authority that they should consult ACAS as experts on disciplinary matters and the recognized trade unions in the drafting of that code. My Lords, this is of course, we're talking about public authorities.
Lords, this is of course we're talking about public authorities, public sector's got a very high level of collective bargaining coverage meaning that the public authority employers do negotiate with trade unions so that the recognized trade unions are genuinely representative. And of course it doesn't bar the consultation with anybody else, but it's important I would suggest that the recognized trade unions representative of the workforce do have a say in the code of ethical standards which will of course impose not only standards of conduct but may be the cause of disciplinary measures against the workers concerned. The third amendment is 40A and this is to make clear that somebody making a worker making an allegation that the code of ethical standards has been breached on the basis of a reasonable and genuine suspicion that it has been should not be subject to dismissal or detriment including bullying and harassment. It does appear to me at least that that there should be adequate protections for those who genuinely draw attention to what they believe genuinely and reasonably is a breach of the code. That goes beyond the current protection for whistleblowers but in the in amendment 43A I've tried to do the reverse of the coin which is to make sure that the protection given to whistleblowers under the current statutory regime is also extended to people in this situation.
And finally amendment 42A is intended to impose the obligation amongst the other explanations that the bill currently requires of public authorities an explanation of how the protection of workers will be delivered. My Lords, with that I formally move beg to move amendment 34A.
Speaker 70
Amendment proposed, clause 10, page 10, line 21, after take insert all reasonable.
Speaker 106
Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 41 and 43 which stand in my name. Amendment 41, this amendment is about what happens when serious concerns are raised within a public authority and particularly what happens when those concerns are not acted upon. So we've seen in scandal after scandal that warnings were given, sometimes repeatedly, but nothing was done. And in some cases those at the top of an organization were never properly informed and in others concerns were dismissed or simply allowed to sort of disappear. And too often protecting the reputation of the institution seemed to take priority over protecting the people it was supposed to be serving.
And one of the most troubling aspects of these scandals is that when the truth finally emerges it can be remarkably difficult to establish who knew what, when they knew it and who decided not to act. And responsibility becomes blurred and decisions are attributed to processes or committees rather than individuals. And sometimes there is simply no proper record of why a serious warning was ignored.
So my amendment 41 is intended to address that problem. It would require public authorities to set out in their codes of ethical conduct how credible information about serious wrongdoing, systemic failure, or a continuing risk of serious harm should be handled. It would make clear when concerns must be brought to the attention of senior management or those responsible for governance. And importantly, it would require decisions to be recorded, including whether a matter was investigated, who was responsible for the decision, and crucially, why no action or no further action was taken, if no further action was taken. And I think that last point is particularly important because there may be perfectly legitimate reasons why an authority decides that a particular concern does not require further investigation.
But that decision must be made consciously by someone who can be identified and with the reasons properly recorded for public record. Otherwise, it is just far too easy for serious concerns to fall between the cracks or for responsibility to be passed from one person to another until nobody is accountable. And this amendment is not intended to create unnecessary bureaucratic burdens, nor does it require every allegation to result in a full investigation. It simply requires a clear process with proper escalation and a record of the decisions made. We cannot prevent every failure, but we can make it much harder for warnings to be ignored, for responsibility to be avoided, or for institutions to claim afterwards that nobody knew what was happening.
So I hope the government will recognise that this is a practical and proportionate way of strengthening the bill. And I would particularly welcome the minister's view on why any public authority receiving credible information about serious wrongdoing should not be required to record what it decided to do about it and why. And then amendment 43. This amendment deals with another straightforward problem. What happens when serious concerns are raised about an organisation, but the people responsible for investigating them are themselves part of the problem?
Now we've seen this happen in a number of public scandals: concerns raised, investigations take place internally, and the organisation concludes that there's little or nothing to answer for, case closed. Sometimes that conclusion might be justified, but sometimes it is more about protecting the organisation and its reputation rather than finding out what went wrong. And if senior management is implicated, it is particularly difficult to see how an internal investigation can be impartial. So my amendment would require public authorities to provide a route for independent consideration of serious concerns in three circumstances: where senior management is involved, where similar concerns have previously been raised but not adequately investigated, or where there is good reason to doubt that an internal investigation would be impartial. In those circumstances, the authority's code of ethical conduct would have to identify an independent person or body to whom the matter could be referred.
This is really not about requiring every complaint to be investigated externally, nor is it about creating another layer of bureaucracy. It is simply about making sure there is somewhere independent to go when the normal internal processes cannot reasonably be relied upon.
is at stake. An independent review would help ensure that serious warnings are not simply dismissed or contained within an organisation. So I'd be interested to hear from the minister whether the government believe that the existing arrangements provide sufficient independence in these particular three circumstances. Because if an organisation is accused of serious wrongdoing, we should not expect it to be the sole judge of its own conduct.
Speaker 108
My Lords, I think Baroness Faulkner might want to speak to her amendment.
Faulkner
Forgive me, my Lords, I'm slightly lost. Am I speaking to amendment 63A? Thank you. I beg the indulgence of the House for a moment while I find my my papers. Yes.
So, sorry, that's my fault, that's my mistake, I profusely apologise.
David Wolfson
Crisis averted there. Apologies. Well, if the noble lady quite rightly isn't going to speak to her amendment, I'll speak to mine, which is in this group. And so first I will address amendment 147, which is the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie and myself. That seeks to require an impact assessment on the cost of implementing the policy outlined in clause 10.
And that's a policy that would require public authorities to publish a code of ethical conduct. The reason for this amendment, which is a probing amendment, is that the existing impact assessments for the bill don't make any mention of the expected cost of implementation for these proposed measures. And it seems to us that the cost of drafting and publishing such a code, there must be a cost to those to that work. So this does seem to be an admission. If, of course, the data does exist and it just didn't make it into the impact assessment, of course we'd be very happy to withdraw the amendment.
So I just ask the noble lady the minister whether she's able to share that cost with the House. If not, why has this cost not yet been calculated? And if it hasn't yet been calculated, can it please be calculated and then shared? More generally, of course, there is limited evidence in fact to indicate that the existence of codes of conduct is sufficient to prevent scandals from occurring. There are numerous scandals in recent history that have happened within institutions that already have codes of conduct, such as the NHS.
The underlying issue really is conduct and not codes of conduct. And it's not clear to many of us that you change the former by instituting the latter. So as it stands, there is every possibility that the cost could be considerable with every public authority expected to draft their own individual code. So how has the government come to the conclusion that clause 10 is the right way forward without, it seems, having undertaken an impact assessment on the costs of this new duty? I appreciate here we do start to touch on the points made by noble Lord Lord Liddle, the call for a single code.
I'll deal with those in the next group, although of course these points do overlap to an extent. The other amendments in this group in the name of first noble Lord Lord Hendy broadly seek to protect those who raise concerns. But we on these benches would be wary of amendments that seek to add unnecessary consultation burdens that would be costly and would also delay implementation as we think amendment 37A does.
Amendment 34A, which seeks to require public authorities to take all reasonable steps to promote ethical conduct, we understand where that wording has come from as the explanatory note indicates, but the context is vastly different to the specific offence in clause 2, so it seems to us a little clunky to use that drafting in this case as well. Amendment 40A seeks to create protection for employees, but we do wonder whether that is not already covered sufficiently in the existing Employment Rights Act 1996. Amendment 42A would require a public authority to explain the protection they provide. That would also again take more time and more money to implement. We already have a huge amount of regulation in this country.
Generally on these benches we think we need less rather than more regulation. Turning now to the noble lady Baroness Featherstone's amendments 41 and 43, the noble lady is with respect right to probe how organisations will in fact undertake their responsibilities to behave ethically. We are concerned these amendments risk being somewhat overly prescriptive and we already have concerns as I've said about the cost of the implementation of clause 10. That said, I do hope the noble lady the minister will be able to give Lady Featherstone some more clarity on what the government in fact, in fact expects of organisations who will be subject to the duties set out in this bill.
Anderson
I thank noble lords, my firstly apologies to noble Baroness Lady Faulkner, your amendment had moved between groups over the last 24 hours and that is my error, I apologize. I want to thank all noble lords who contributed to this debate, beginning with amendments 34A, 37A, 40A and 42A tabled by my noble friend Lord Hendy and amendments 41 and 43 tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Featherstone. I want to be clear that the government agrees that where wrongdoing occurs public officials should be able to raise concerns in confidence and be protected from retaliation. However, without repeating arguments made by myself from this dispatch box on the first day of committee, the government's view is that existing legal protections already provide safeguards for officials under the Employment Rights Act 1996 and this bill will require public authorities to maintain codes of ethical conduct that must ensure workers are made aware of their whistleblowing rights. Furthermore, the government is seeking views on the operation of the whistleblowing framework via consultation that was launched last week.
We've already discussed the details of that consultation in committee and in the interest of time I will not repeat those points today. I do however recognize the concerns expressed by noble lords about the time required to move from consultation to reform. However, it is important to be reminded that the scope of this bill applies only to the public sector and that whistleblowing is not an issue confined to the public sector. We would not want to introduce changes through this legislation that create inconsistencies within the wider whistleblowing framework. For those reasons we believe it would be premature to legislate in this area before the consultation has concluded and the evidence has been fully considered.
However, as I mentioned last week I'm looking forward to meeting with noble lords to discuss how we can use the code of ethical conduct to make clearer existing protections and ask that those interested feed into the government consultation. I look forward to meeting especially with both my noble friend and the noble Baroness. I also want to provide some additional reassurances to my noble friend Lord Hendy regarding his amendment 43A, which seeks to make clear the definition of a qualifying disclosure.
So I'm sure that conversation will continue. Turning to the amendment 147 highlighted by the opposition front bench, I fully recognize the intention behind the amendment and the importance of ensuring that Parliament and the public understand the impact of these measures. However, bereaved families and victims rightly expect the government to implement the provisions in this bill promptly and effectively. The government is therefore keen to maintain momentum towards implementation and is not persuaded that additional measures are necessary to achieve that objective. As noble lords will be aware, the government intends to publish a revised impact assessment following Royal Assent, which will provide an updated assessment of the measures contained in the bill.
In light of that commitment, the government does not consider the amendment to be necessary, but given the questions from noble Lord Wolfson, I think it'll be helpful if I just highlight what the current impact assessment says about the estimated cost to public authorities of delivering clause 10. The code of ethical conduct provisions will create new burdens on public authorities, including local authorities. The provisions have deliberately been drafted to allow maximum flexibility in terms of implementation. Given that most, if not all, public bodies will already be covered by the form by a form of code, it is not anticipated that the impact in terms of cost to be substantial. Some lawyers' time to assess compliance and management time and some training.
I am not underestimating the cost of lawyers given who sits in your lordship's house, however. The scale of these costs will depend on the number of public bodies within scope and implementation plans informed by the legislation, the extent of the codes, how much can be standardized, etc., which can only be fully determined after Royal Assent, after members of your lordship's house have done their job in terms of scrutiny. A further assessment of impact will take place alongside the development of our implementation plans and underpinning guidance and a new burdens assessment developed at the appropriate time. I hope that answers the questions raised by members of your lordship's house and I respectfully ask my noble friend to withdraw his amendment.
Speaker 105
Lords, I'm grateful to Baroness Featherstone for her amendments which appear consistent with those that I put forward. I thank the noble Lord Lord Wolfson for his amendment and contribution. I say no more about it in the light of what's fallen from my noble friend just now, except to say that the protection currently given by the whistleblowing legislation is not considered to be adequate by many in the who practice in the field. And given that the code of conduct which is proposed is only for the public sector and only in the circumstances required by clause 2, it would appear to me that there's real justification for a higher degree of protection than that offered by whistleblowers. I thank my noble friend Baroness Anderson, the minister, for her contribution and in the light of what she says about ongoing consultation and conversations to continue, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 70
Is it your lordship's pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 35, Lord Alton of Liverpool.
I should advise the House that if this amendment is agreed to, I can't call amendments 37 to 49 by reason of preemption.
David Alton
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, the noble Baroness, Lady Anderson, and the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, have just provided the committee with a very good curtain-raiser for amendment 35. This amendment stands with amendments 51 and 61, and they stand in my name and that of my noble and learned friend Lord Hope of Craighead, the noble Lord, Lord Murray of Blidworth, and the noble Lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames. I'm grateful to all of them, and indeed to other members of your Lordships' House who spoke on this issue of one central ethical code at second reading, but also in between second reading and now. But I must also say thank you to the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, for his unfailing courtesy and engagement, and who met with my former Liverpool constituents, the mother and the sister of Andrew Devine, the 97th fatality at Hillsborough, and heard their anxieties about a plethora of conflicting and inconsistent codes of conduct instead of one clear central code, capable of adding codicils or variations, but clear on its essential elements. I acknowledge at the outset the importance of securing the enactment of this bill without unnecessary delay, and I certainly have no intention of adding to that delay.
I might say that I've just spotted the noble Baroness, Baroness Levitt, also in her place, and she too met the family of Andrew Devine, and I must say to both noble Baroness and the noble Lord that ministers have been exemplary in the way that they've dealt with families still suffering grief after all this time. The proposals in these amendments rest on three linked pillars: first, a single core code of ethical conduct; secondly, an effective framework for considering civil sanctions for serious non-compliance; and thirdly, education and cultural change, and in a way, each one reinforces the other. Clear standards should be understood, serious breaches must carry credible consequences, and our ambition must be to prevent misconduct in the first place. Although Hillsborough brought us to this point, the bill must serve far more than those affected by Hillsborough or by other disasters involving many victims, and we've heard many of them referred to during earlier parts of our proceedings today. The protection afforded by a core code and the means of securing accountability for its serious breach must never depend on the number of victims or the profile or the publicity which their case receives.
I want to acknowledge a letter which the noble Lord, the Minister, Lord Lemos, sent me only this morning, and this follows a question that I raised last week at committee, but also at second reading, concerning the question of the duty of candour on universities where a student or academic may have died by suicide. That letter's been placed in the library, and I hope that we can consider its implications on another group of amendments later in our proceedings, but it does obviously also have some relevance on a code of conduct that should be applicable to all. The first pillar I've referred to is this core code, a single national code which would state the obligations which everyone exercising public functions should recognise: honesty, integrity, candour, accountability, the proper keeping and disclosure of information, the correction of known error, and service to the public. The government have said in answer to my question HL3290 that approximately six million public sector workers are within the scope of the requirement for codes. That's a powerful reason to make the common ethical foundation clear, accessible, and consistent.
In answers HL3135 and HL3136, ministers have emphasised flexibility for individual authorities. Now, I accept that need, but why should flexibility prevent a common minimum standard? If approximately six million people are covered across a very large number of authorities, it makes very little sense for each to reinvent substantially the same fundamental ethical obligations.
A common core should be worked out, consulted upon as the noble Lord Lord Wolfson said a few moments ago, and approved, I think nationally. Authorities could then add specialist provisions. That would promote consistent understanding, avoid near-identical codes and simplify future revisions. The code need not be fixed for all time in primary legislation. The act can provide the authority, purposes, consultation duties and safeguards as our amendment seeks to do.
The detailed core code and subsequent revisions could be made by, as we've argued, delegated legislation subject to affirmative approval by both houses of Parliament. And parliamentary control and practical flexibility can then reinforce one another. The second pillar of the amendment concerns sanctions. We're not asking Parliament now to fix the amount of a civil penalty, prescribed pension-related consequence or enact a completed sanction scheme. But we do ask for a proper process of consultation and legislative development addressing the nature of sanctions, independent investigation and decision-making, fair procedures and appeal.
Any eventual penalties must have adequate statutory authority and proper parliamentary scrutiny. My Lords, on November the 25th, Sir Keir Starmer referred to disciplinary sanctions including gross misconduct, and at second reading on the 1st of September, the noble Lord spoke of expectations and consequences for breaches. The government's February 2026 annual report responding to the Grenfell Tower inquiry referred to departmental discipline and sanctions for egregious breaches. The outstanding question is how to make the principle effective where present mechanisms leave gaps. If enforcement is wholly at the discretion of individual authorities, common standards may be enforced inconsistently.
One authority may investigate rigorously while another one does not. Institutional self-interest, reputation or seniority may influence decisions or appear to do so. One gap we might consider arises when serious misconduct doesn't appropriately lead to criminal proceedings but internal employment discipline is inadequate. Another arises where the individual has retired, resigned, transferred or otherwise left office before a complaint is resolved. In reply to my question HL3137, the noble Lord said that authorities are responsible for disciplinary consequences for those who work for them.
But that doesn't answer what happens when they no longer do. The consultation should address that question expressly with fair time limits and protection against retrospective punishment. In HL3138, I asked how an individual could obtain an independent investigation and a remedy where internal discipline was inappropriate. The answer was that methods and outcomes depend on the circumstances and the authority. How then is the public to have confidence in consistent and independent enforcement, particularly where the authority itself is implicated?
What common minimum safeguards will prevent serious cases from being overlooked? Honest mistakes, my Lord, my Lords, promptly disclosed and corrected should not be treated like deliberate concealment, obstruction, retaliation or persistent misconduct. The third pillar of these amendments is education and sustained cultural change. The ambition should extend beyond instructing current public servants about employment obligations. A national core code should become a common civic standard.
Its principles of honesty, candour, accurate records, fair treatment, correcting mistakes and raising concerns should be taught progressively from an early age. Citizens would then know what to expect of those exercising public power. A junior official could refer to a recognized common code when questioning an improper instruction. And I ask the noble Lord to involve the Department for Education in considering teaching materials, consultation with teachers, a modest pilot and evaluation building on existing citizenship education.
Education alone is insufficient. Sanctions cannot create ethical culture. Together with leadership and fair enforcement, they offer a prospect of prevention. Let me also briefly cite international comparisons, which offer useful experience, not ready-made templates. The United States has common federal executive branch ethics standards and ethics training.
Canada, a federal values and ethics code with organisational supplements. Australia, statutory public service standards and graduated employment sanctions. New Zealand, an updated public sector code, effective in March this year, with common standards and organisational supplementation. And Ireland, an ethics commission with complaints investigation functions. These systems differ constitutionally and in scope.
The relevant questions are how common and specialist standards fit together, how guidance and training work, who examines serious complaints, where an authority is implicated, and what happens after employment ends. Australian public service guidance, for example, makes clear that employment sanctions cannot be imposed on a former employee. Consultation should test both the strengths and the limitations of such approaches before adopting any model. And then there is the question of economy. A common ethical foundation, drafted once, could reduce duplication in drafting, legal review, publication, training and revision.
Amendment 51 concerns consultation and parliamentary process. Amendment 61 seeks consistency between the national core and other guidance, and they complement Amendment 35. So I ask the government to accept these three principles which I have outlined to the committee: a common ethical foundation capable of revision under parliamentary control, consultation on proportionate and independently administered civil consequences for serious misconduct, including after departure from public employment, and education and sustained leadership as part of the cultural change. I beg to move.
Speaker 70
Amendment proposed to clause 10, page 10, line 31, leave out subsections 3 to 14 and insert the words printed on the marshalled list. As an amendment to Amendment 35, Amendment 35A, Lord Hendy.
John Hendy
Lords, I'm very happy to support the amendment proposed by the noble Lord, Lord Alton, and pay my respects to the persuasive exposition of the principles that lie behind it. Lords, my two amendments in this group, the first is intended to give similar protection against dismissal, detriment, bullying or harassment for somebody who makes an allegation of breach of the core code on the basis of reasonable and genuine suspicion, as I made in the earlier amendment, but this time directed to the national core code which the noble Lord proposes. And likewise, the second amendment here is that in that national core code, equally as before, consultation should be with recognised trade unions in the public sector, together with taking the views of ACAS.
Speaker 109
I take it the noble Lord wishes to move his amendment to the amendment.
Speaker 70
After subsection 4D insert the words printed on the marshalled list. And that is the amendment now before the House, my Lords.
Speaker 93
I strongly support this group of amendments. As I said at second reading, clause 10 is for me perhaps the most important clause in the whole bill because it's about improving the standards of behavior of every public official and it's about preventing some of the failures that we've all talked about so often in the recent past. It's about preventing, not addressing them after the fact. But if we're going to achieve that, if we're going to achieve the improved standards of behavior I think we all want, then we need to craft a piece of legislation that makes a real difference on the ground in every public sector organization and which is familiar to every public servant. What we don't need is a perfect statement of good intent which has no practical impact.
Because as I keep saying and Lord Wolfson said it earlier today, all of the recent failures have occurred in spite of the existence of the civil service code, the ministerial code, the Nolan principles, the business appointment rules, I could go on and on. These statements of good intent have too often been ignored and we don't need more. My fear is that as drafted clause 10 will not bring about real improvements on the ground. Indeed as drafted, I think it's likely to make matters worse. And I know from my conversations with the noble Lord the Minister that is absolutely not his intention nor do I think it's the government's intention.
In its current form, the bill could lead to a vast number of different codes notwithstanding the advice from the mysteriously named appropriate national authority. The public will find that confusing. They'll find it difficult to understand and they'll find it difficult to access. Accountability will suffer and staff moving from one public sector organization to another will have to come to terms with slightly different interpretations of ethical behavior. It just can't work, my Lords.
I know that codes alone, words alone can never be guaranteed to change behavior without very strong and determined leadership. But to stand a chance of making a difference, of having a positive impact, they have to be clear, succinct, simple, memorable, accessible and realistic. And for me that means that we need one core code which applies to every public sector organization and every public official. We need a code which makes clear that the welfare of the citizen is the first priority ahead of senior managers, ministers or the reputation of the department. And we need a code with teeth which cannot be easily circumvented by resignation or retirement, which we all know too often happens at the moment.
Amendments 35 and 51 in particular may need some further development. But taken together with these other amendments, they would if agreed provide us with a powerful new weapon to help rebuild the trust between the state and the citizen which I think has been so grievously damaged. I do hope that the noble Lord the Minister will commit to consulting further, to discussing further before the report stage on an amendment which does just that.
Faulkner
My Lords, I wish to make some observations in regard to this proposed amendment. In doing so, I declare that I am an interest in that I'm a distinguished fellow of the think tank Policy Exchange, who have themselves published a report called Legislating for Candour on this bill only last week. My main remarks have to do with subclause nine at the proposed new text of clause 10 as proposed by Lord Alton of Liverpool. In my understanding, it's intended to cover circumstances where the holder of public office ceases to hold it, ceases to be employed by the public sector, or resigns, relieved, is dismissed, in other words, is no longer effectively there to be accountable for their actions. And I understand that.
I share the outrage that the public feels when people who are so clearly implicated in wrongdoing at the first whiff of having to account for their actions resign, generally on full pay, and or move on, move out. And there is very little that can be done about that. I completely appreciate that. But I wonder if in proposing this long and comprehensive new clause covering sections three to 14, replacing sections three to 14, I wonder if the proposers might have thought to do it in a different way. And that different way in terms of subclause nine would be that instead of defining so comprehensively in nine and then in 10, subclauses 10, all circumstances where someone may no longer be in the office holder may no longer be in post, whether they might have in fact done it whereby the certain actions rather than the circumstances of the post holder be the subject of scrutiny, enforcement and sanctions.
And I say that because I have some experience of arms-length bodies and or other regulators, notably as a former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, but my personal experience is also informed by some work I did at the Bank of England, where I was a member for nine years of the Bank of England's enforcement decision-making committee. I'll come to that when I'm moving another amendment. But the point I want to make and share with the House is that when you're a public official and you take actions in good faith, you take them on the basis of advice that you've received individually or indeed collectively in discussions with other employees of that organisation or indeed with the board members and so on, perhaps even including external legal advice. Once you depart that organisation, all your records, electronic or otherwise, do not belong to you. They belong to the public body you served.
And you have a requirement to hand in all of your records, documents, discussions, informal advice, formal advice.
I recall at one point at EHRC that that requirement also included post-it notes. And the challenge became identifying which post-it note, which had become unstuck from a document, belonged to which page of which document. So it can be quite a tortuous process. And so those arguments which informed your decision, which may have been several years prior, are not yours to re-examine and try and work out why you took the actions you took, because you can't, you don't have an audit trail yourself as an individual. All you have is memory.
And hopefully other witnesses who might have been in the room at the time, who hopefully again you have good relations with and can still contact and hope they'll come to your rescue. So the obligations arising from your earlier responsibility apply to you subsequently according to these amendments, but you have may have very little in terms of a defense. Now I appreciate that the movers of the amendment agree that a consultation would be carried out on any regulations that the government drew up. But I prefer the government's own drafting on this bill, which is itself in describing the code fairly muscular and seems to have been fairly well thought through. So I don't think I'm entirely convinced by the amendment.
A final point that I would make relates to the government, a question that I have for the government relates to the overarching obligation arising from the core code in subsection three of clause ten. And that is a question that has arisen throughout my scrutiny, my reading of this bill from the outset. We know, my lords, at the moment that the former Prime Minister Starmer directed the Cabinet Secretary, Dame Antonia Romeo, to conduct an overarching review of the Civil Service Code of Conduct. And we know that that review is ongoing. I think she expects to report next year on that.
One of the principal things that we understand that overarching review of the Civil Service Code of Conduct will do is to look at several of the areas that are covered in this bill in the duty of candor. And I refer specifically to the seven Nolan principles, where the Civil Service Code as it stands and is likely if anything to be strengthened, covers honesty, accountability, integrity. In one of the earlier debates we had today on this bill, I was tempted to ask about integrity, if that was about the destruction of public records. And I was tempted to point out, but I didn't wish to detain the house unnecessarily, and I was tempted to point out that civil servants already have an obligation not to destroy records, to hold all records, comes under the duty of integrity clearly set out in the Civil Service Code. So my question for the minister is simply this: what will happen to that review and its relationship with this core code, and how will the two interact, or will this core code take precedence over the Civil Service Code?
I particularly say that advisedly because at the moment, and I disagree with that practice, but at the moment, not only does the Civil Service Code hold and apply to all senior civil servants, all civil servants, but it also allows different government departments to layer on, add their own separate codes depending on their functions.
So we're going to have a potentially a three-tier adherence on the part of civil servants to codes. One will be the departmental code, the second one will be the overarching Civil Service Code, and the third one will be the codes envisaged in this bill. And I wonder whether the government have reviewed how those three different aspects of ethical standards will apply to the six million or so civil servants plus all non-departmental public bodies and arms-length bodies.
Sally Hamwee
My amendment 36 in this group, but before I turn to that, in response to the noble lady's points about officials who have retired, resigned, and so on, I may be wrong about this, but I seem to remember that the IOPC tackled this. There was a lot of concern about police officers who had retired or more often resigned, and they tackled it, it was tackled to great general relief. I would have thought surely that a person who's caught up by this would have access to documents and so on, but that's not actually central to my argument. My amendment 36 is not a hostile amendment to Lord Alton's amendment. In fact, I consulted him before tabling it because we're both concerned that the IPA's very particular experience is made available where it can be useful, in this case to the Secretary of State, and that the IPA should be consulted and that the IPA's advice should have regard paid to it to contribute to the code of conduct.
I think more generally we're both concerned about writing the IPA into the bill.
Speaker 113
I've put my name to amendments 35, 51, and 61 in this group. I don't propose to add greatly to what the noble Lord Alton and Lord Bichard have already said about these amendments. In my view, the incorporation of a single code would result in a considerable saving of time and money. And my question to the minister is this: please could the department evaluate the difference in public spending and official time in having separate codes of conduct for all of these public bodies as opposed to one core code as advocated for in the noble Lord Alton's excellent amendment. I hear what the noble lady Lord Faulkner says about the impact of sub-clauses 9 and 10, and certainly for my part as a signatory to these amendments, I'm certainly prepared to look at that question.
Speaker 111
I can entirely understand the gravamen of the problem that she identified, but I don't think it undermines the central thrust that a core code is a good idea.
Speaker 112
My Lords, I'd like to make an observation in regard to amendment 35, and I speak informed by my time previously as the chair of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, now the Ethics and Integrity Commission. I very strongly support the suggestion in the bill that there should be a requirement on departments to have an ethical code of this sort, and it was quite astonishing to me to in talking to some departments to find that there was very little by way of ethical guidance available to their staff, which seemed to me to be a significant gap. And indeed, one or two conversations with senior permanent secretaries who said that they didn't believe there were any ethical issues in their departments rather reinforced my view that we needed to make people concentrate their minds. Nevertheless, I have some reservations about the suggestion that there should be a single code. I can see attractions to it, but on the other hand, I think there is a difference.
We have a core of common values and principles in the Nolan principles, and that is obviously relevant across all departments and agencies, and I think it's important there should be that commonality. But it seems to me that the actual way that that plays out with regard to particular departments will vary a great deal. So what is ethical behavior within an intelligence service might be very different from the way in which ethical behavior plays out for a health professional or indeed for a regulator. And I think it would be quite difficult to draft a single code which really illuminated those issues for staff in such different roles without having different codes. Now, that doesn't mean that they should take a different approach to the principles, which are common, but I think applying those in a way which actually helps people to do their jobs on a daily basis, and it's not just about accountability, there are lots of other ethical issues that governments and public service are faced with.
I think there is actually quite a strong argument for requiring departments to draw up their own codes, thinking about their own business and how the principles apply to them.
Jonathan Marks
My Lords, on these benches, we've been very clear that we greatly welcome this bill, but we wish to strengthen it. We believe that amendment 35 and the introduction of a common code would add strength to the bill and reinforce its effect. My Lords, in view of the disgraceful cover-ups that there have been in relation to so many of the tragedies discussed in relation to this bill, from Hillsborough onwards, through Horizon, infected blood, Grenfell, Windrush, and a shaming number of others, it is unsurprising that the public rationale and justification for this bill has been founded in later cover-ups of past tragedies, which have been aimed at diverting blame for what happened away from those wholly or partly responsible. The bill with these aims is laudable, but it could and should do so much more. Its importance lies not only in investigating and inquiring into the reasons why tragedies happened.
Equally important is the ambition that this bill should set enforceable standards for the conduct of officials in an effort to ensure that such tragedies are prevented before they ever happen, and that those standards should be enforced by reference to the criminal law. And in this, I echo the words of Lord Bishop and others on this issue. My Lords, the ambition is there in the bill. It's in the long title, which imposes a duty on public authorities and public officials to act with candor, transparency, and frankness, to require public authorities to promote and take steps to maintain ethical conduct within all parts of the authority.
There is no limit in the long title confining the duty to inquiries and investigations. My Lords, while part two, chapter one of the bill deals with inquiries and investigations, this chapter that we're now considering, chapter two, part two, and clause ten in particular, deals more generally with standards of ethical conduct, and it is far too weak in its enforcement. Clause two, which the principal amendments in this group seek to amend, provides principally that a public authority must promote and take steps to maintain high standards of ethical conduct at all times by people who work in the authority. And it then sets out what is essentially a restatement of the Nolan principles set out in 1995. My Lords, on these benches, we believe that this part of the bill as drafted lacks the teeth needed to enforce standards across public life so as to avoid likely tragedies before they occur.
We want this bill to seize the opportunity to raise standards across public life in real terms. The bill has often been described as requiring a change of culture, but for that it needs teeth to bite at all times. What we seek to do by our amendments is to make part two, chapter two as strong and important as chapter one is on inquiries and investigations. The Nolan principles are laudable and right, but they've been around since 1995 and in principle long before then. Yet these tragedies have happened.
The principles need serious underpinning. So, my Lords, to the code. Amendment 35, which we support, would provide, as Lord Alton has explained, for a single national core code. That code would be, as it has to be, underpinned by regulations. It would establish not only the principles and the standards, but the practical application of those standards and procedures for their implementation and enforcement.
My Lords, the core code does not preclude specific bodies from promulgating and enforcing particular codes to supplement the core code where those are appropriate. There may well be good reason for such additional supplementary provisions, usually applicable no doubt to particular types of authority or areas of operation, but they should always be consistent with the core code. Amendment 61 would make it clear that guidance specific to particular authorities must be consistent with the core code of conduct and that no public authority may substitute its own code for the core code. But our starting point for this group is that we should avoid multiple different codes, one adopted by each different public authority, and should aim to achieve a single set of standards in much more detail than the Nolan principles, applicable to the whole of public life and all officials. We see the prime advantages of this arrangement as being far more likely with a core code than with multiple divergent codes to command universal understanding of the standards expected of public officials.
A core code would lead to far more consistency. It would avoid conflicts between the codes of different bodies. What is okay for Hampshire should not differ from what is okay for North Yorkshire. A single core code would be likely to lead to a code of higher quality than multiple and divergent codes, if only because the concentrated expertise devoted to its compilation would lead to a better and more studied core code and more focused individual supplementary codes where necessary.
A single code, moreover, would lead to a build-up of a single, comprehensible and authoritative body of case law and experience of what works and experience of how standards should properly be applied. Whereas multiple codes, which might conflict, might risk the growth of satellite litigation where codes differ. A single code would save resources. The noble Lord, Lord Murray, made that point, with one body established for drafting it and updating it as the need arises. For every public body to be having working parties to set up their own divergent codes and later to update them, no doubt at different times, would be a recipe for divergence and chaos and would undermine public respect for the whole project and would be grossly wasteful of resources.
Amendment 51, to which I've added my name as well, would require consultation and report on the code within a short timetable. And the timetable has to be tight for a reason. These standards need to be in place quickly. We need to avoid further failures in our public life that damage so many lives and that demean the reputation of the United Kingdom for competent, fair and honest administration. We really must recover that reputation, and this code could be a way, this bill could be a way to do so with a core code.
My Lords, I add nothing to what my noble friend Baroness Hamwee said on amendment 36 about the need for involvement of the independent public adviser, which is plainly sensible and right. This is an important group in making this significant bill work in practice. I fear, along with others, that without a common core code, clear, widely publicized and understood and applicable across the country, backed up by enforcement provisions and provisions of the criminal law, without such a code we will betray the hopes and the justified demands of past victims. Without it, we will risk selling out on the opportunity for this bill to make actual adherence to high ethical standards a real achievement rather than an unrealized pipe dream.
Anderson
Before the noble Lord sits down, hearing what he says, but putting it together with what we've just heard from Lord Evans of Weardale about the different nature of different public bodies, does he think, or do other frontbench spokesmen think, that there might be room for a middle way here? Not one core code, but perhaps a core code for regulators, a core code for government departments, a core code for intelligence agencies. Would not that meet the noble Lord's concerns while still streamlining the process, as your Lordship and the Conservative frontbench wish?
Jonathan Marks
My Lords, that's a very interesting and careful point, and I would expect nothing less from the noble Lord, Lord Anderson. And I listened very carefully to what the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Weardale, said. And I appreciate the position from which he was coming. But frankly, his analysis depended upon relying upon principles that have been in place for a very long time. And he said on a number of occasions that the standards were standards that applied and had applied for a very long time.
And I think my argument and the argument expressed by the noble Lord, Lord Alton, is that that being the case, all the standards that would be applied across different core codes would have a common theme, a common set of standards which would be at the center of a core code. It is of the essence of my argument, and as I listened to it, the argument of the noble Lord, Lord Alton, as well, that there could be supplementary codes dealing with particular bodies, particular types of bodies, and particular types of regulators. That, I suggest, is the answer. I may not be a million miles away from what the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, is suggesting. But what I do believe is that between now and report, we ought to be able to come up with the government with a proposal for a core code commanding universal respect with provision for...
David Alton
I'm just grateful to the noble Lord just before he concludes because I want to reinforce his point that these two things are not completely irreconcilable because the noble Lord, Lord Bishard, and I have previously discussed the possibility of codicils being added to a core national code, but that there need to be some essential elements that are common to all. And that is the whole point of a common code which the noble Lord has outlined extremely well, if I may say so.
Jonathan Marks
Well, I'm grateful. We certainly agree on that. I don't think the distances between us are irreconcilable. The point that I'm making, the central point, is that this bill, after all the failures that there have been, requires teeth, it requires enforcement, it's backed up by provisions of the criminal law in relation to chapter one of part two, but far less force given to the prevention of tragedies before they occur. And that really is my central point.
David Wolfson
My Lords, the original group of amendments in this group, starting with amendment 35 in the name of noble Lord, Lord Alton, seeks to implement a single national code of conduct. There's obviously a number of amendments to that amendment. I'll mention first number 36 in the name of noble lady Baroness Hamwee, which seeks to ensure that this code of conduct has regard to the independent public advocate. And of course, we've debated the importance of the independent public advocate in previous groups. Logically prior, however, is amendment 35A in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, and also his amendment 51A, which also seek to amend the proposal put forward by Lord Alton.
Now, in the previous group, we debated, and these issues are related, an amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord, the noble learned Lord, Lord Keen of Elie, which sought to ascertain the expected cost of implementation of codes of ethical conduct. And the government's answer to that group was that we would be told, but only after royal assent. That does seem to me to be the government inviting us to dine in a restaurant where you're only told the price of your meal after you've ordered it, served it, and also eaten it. But that may be a point we'll come back to at report. But more generally, one of the difficulties of this bill is that it doesn't fully consider the impact on public authorities of creating their own codes of conduct.
If creating a single code made that process both simpler and more cost-effective, as long as it was an appropriate code of conduct, we would be open to that proposal.
So what I would suggest the committee really needs to hear from the noble lord the minister is a comparative assessment of the costs and burdens imposed by clause 10 as drafted and the same assessment of the proposal from the noble lord, Lord Alton. Now, it seems to be the case that the government might not have undertaken that work. So if that's the case, could the noble lord the minister, either if he can respond in this group, or at least undertake that he'll write to the committee with that detail, because it does seem to us to be information which we would need. It's very difficult to come to a reasonable judgment on this question without that impact assessment, because ultimately the issue here is comparing one thing to another, and therefore that comparative information seems to me to be at the heart of this debate. Amendments 51 and 61, also in the name of Lord Alton, expand on the concept of the single code of conduct with a consultation requirement, and another prevents public authorities from replacing the national code with their own authority-specific code.
Again, I would suggest these also warrant consideration from the noble lord the minister. Perhaps a single code is indeed the solution to the burden that creating authority-specific codes would otherwise create. That of course brings me to the suggestion made by the noble lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, towards the end of the debate before I rose, that if one size, if I can respectfully paraphrase, if one size doesn't fit all, perhaps three sizes might fit all. I would also adopt the response of the noble lord, Lord Marks of Henley, that that is an interesting suggestion, but I do underline I mean interesting in the positive sense, not interesting in the way that the civil servants used to tell me when I was a minister, "That's a very interesting suggestion, minister," i.e. we'll put it in the wastepaper basket and just forget about it. I genuinely mean it's a very interesting suggestion and I will certainly think about it further and again, if the noble lord the minister hasn't had enough notice, so to speak, of that point, perhaps he might include it in any letter to the committee on the issues raised in this group.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
I don't go to restaurants which don't have the prices on the menu. My lords, this has been an important and constructive debate about I think what we all agree is a very important issue and we I think we all agree that it goes to the heart of what we're trying to achieve here in terms of the culture change that we've talked about throughout these discussions. So can I begin with Lord Alton's amendment, which seeks to introduce one national code of conduct and also seek to prevent authorities from adopting their own separate codes. Before I comment on that, I would like to thank the noble lord for his time in meeting with me and I think now several discussions we've had on this and arranging for me to meet the family of Andrew Devine to discuss the bill. I'm very much appreciative of that and it was a very moving occasion.
I thank him for those kind remarks about unfailing courtesy. I'm not sure that's a description my family and friends would recognize, but different strokes for different folks. But I do appreciate the intention of this amendment is to strengthen the provisions in the bill on ethical codes by trying to prevent public authorities from adopting codes which may risk being watered down. I do entirely accept that. I can also understand why some campaigners, bereaved families and victims are keen to strengthen these provisions given the appalling way that we've all agreed they have been treated by the state in the past.
Our intention under the bill is to ensure that codes of ethical conduct are tailored and accessible to the needs of individual sectors and the noble lord, Lord Evans of Weardale, gave a very elegant and eloquent description of why that might be important.
The bill covers a broad range of public servants and different working environments where a single code may be too general. And I think all noble Lords, certainly the noble Lord, Lord Marks and Lord Alton, have accepted that there may be some things which need to be specific and therefore something too general may not be sufficiently specific to drive meaningful cultural change. The bill will ensure that every public authority is required to reflect on how to embed a duty of candour within a tailored code of conduct specific to their organisation and sector. And that the bill provides clarity on what these codes must contain as a minimum. And we will publish statutory guidance after Royal Assent which will support public authorities to make impactful codes that will drive ethical behaviour throughout the organisation.
The government is keen for the provisions on codes of ethical conduct to be implemented within an optimum period post-Royal Assent. However, I can understand the concerns that have been raised and a need to ensure that we are clear on what is expected and required in each code. So I therefore am very happy to commit to working with noble Lords and other peers who've been in this debate, but other peers too, on how best we can achieve this. I now turn to the amendment tabled by the noble Lord which would require a consultation on a single national code of conduct, sanctions and enforcement arrangements. And just on that commitment, I would say of course we'll talk about the questions about resources which the noble Lord, Lord Wilson, and others have raised.
I can't promise to write with a detailed assessment for the reasons that my noble friend gave, but we're obviously mindful of the resources point and we're very happy to debate it. Can I now turn to the amendment tabled by the noble Lord which would require a consultation on a single national code of conduct, sanctions and enforcement arrangements. It is right that when we're designing what is required in a code of ethical conduct, that we ensure the views of those who represent public servants, experts and those with lived experience of grave injustices at the hands of the state. I'm not convinced at this stage that a single code of conduct is the most effective way to achieve the cultural change we're seeking, but I am open to considering how best we can engage with relevant stakeholders when considering how we can strengthen the provisions of the bill on codes of ethical conduct. And I hope the noble Lords know I will continue to work closely with noble Lords on this.
In the same vein, turning now to my noble friend Lord Hendy's amendment, which builds on the noble Lord, Lord Alton's proposals, I hope the noble Lord will forgive me but I won't go into too much detail as we've previously discussed this matter earlier. However, I can reassure the noble Lord that the government considers that existing legal protections already provide safeguards for officials who speak up about alleged wrongdoing, as my noble friend Baroness Anderson described earlier. But the noble Lord does raise an important point regarding engaging with trade unions and relevant stakeholders, including ACAS, to ensure that their codes of ethical conduct were appropriately tailored to their organisations. And I will reflect on his comments about that that he's made here today and would of course be happy to meet with him to discuss this ahead of report stage. Turning now to the noble Baroness Lady Hamwee's amendment 36, which builds on Lord Alton's proposal, throughout the passage of the bill, the government has worked closely with members of the public who have been victims of major incidents and grave injustices, and we fully intend to continue this approach.
I can assure the noble lady that there is ongoing policy work taking place around the role of the independent public advocate, and I've been in touch with the noble lady Baroness Meacher and Baroness Sanderson about that work, and that's a very live discussion. So we'll certainly take into account the spirit of her suggestion in that conversation, but I've made clear from this dispatch box before that we see the role of the independent public advocate in victim support and representation as a critical part of the future arrangements that surround major incidents. Can I just deal with the question about retirement? Two or three noble lords have raised this from different perspectives, not all agreed. Current and former employees are covered by the code, and government's quite clear about this, of an inquiry or investigation into an incident or event when someone was in post, even if they've retired since.
So we are very clear about that. I hear what the noble lady Baroness Faulkner says, but we are clear for all the reasons that a number of noble lords made, that people will still be expected to be covered by the duty of candour in those circumstances. With regard to the code of ethics, it's obviously more difficult to apply something to people for whom it wasn't in place at the time when they were there. But on the wider duty of candour, which is the principal thing, I think I've made the position clear. On the civil service code, I responded to the noble lord Lord Young about this, but we are very clear that all codes which exist already will have to meet the requirements of the bill.
I mean, I wouldn't have the temerity to suggest anything to the cabinet secretary, but once this bill is passed and the requirements for the code of ethics, how they will be organized, she will have to ensure that whatever arrangements are in place in the civil service meet those requirements. So with these reassurances to continue the conversation, and I look forward to that, I ask noble lords to withdraw the amendment.
John Hendy
I'm grateful to all noble speakers in this debate, and in the light of what my noble friend the minister has just said, I certainly would wish to withdraw my amendment with leave.
Speaker 90
Amendment 35A be withdrawn. The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 36, Baroness Hamwee, not moved. And now, my lords, we return to the original amendment 35, Lord Alton.
David Alton
I'd like to thank everyone who's participated in this debate, and particularly thank the noble lord Lord Hendy, my noble friend Lord Bichard, noble Baroness Lady Hamwee, the noble lord Lord Murray of Epping Forest, the noble lord Lord Marks of Henley for their strong and supportive remarks during the course of the debate, and also to the noble lord Lord Wolfson for what he had to say too. If I can just go back for a moment to something that my noble friend said, Lord Bichard said, the state and citizen relationship has been grievously damaged, and that is why he argued, as others have done, that we need to rectify that. And although reservations, caveats have been entered by the noble lord Lord Anderson, the noble lord Lord Evans of Weardale, and the noble Baroness Lady Faulkner of Margravine, I think that is the central question: how do we rectify that grievous damage?
In another place in 1995 Lord Nolan who has been referred to quite a lot in the proceedings this evening by noble Lords reported back to the then Prime Minister John Major following the cash for questions scandal. I think of all the things that I was required to do during my time in another place one of the most dispiriting things of all was to serve on the Committee of Privileges and to take evidence and to inquire into cash for questions that a Member of Parliament entrapped admittedly but nevertheless willing to take a thousand pounds to put down a parliamentary question. And then of course there was much more that we heard about that followed that. It brought Parliament into great disrepute. Lord Nolan said at the time the general principle of the general principle which underlines public life has to be restated.
He also said these principles apply to all aspects of public life. So I think given that his report at that time meant so much to so many people and provided a framework it was for its time. I think we are duty bound in our time to look again at what those principles might be that unite us and why it's essential that there should be a central core. Now whether it's for reasons of expenditure, inconsistency, unnecessary duplication, whatever it may be I think having a central code of conduct of ethics is the right way. It is something that we can add to in specific circumstances which I think would attend to the point that my noble friend Lord Anderson of Ipswich referred to in his remarks.
There's nothing at all contradictory about those things. I don't at this stage my Lords want to reiterate or repeat the arguments because the noble Lord the Minister Lord Lemos has been very conciliatory in what he has said. I think he's got the mood though of the House that we want to continue these discussions, that we would want to bring it back at report stage, that it might indeed even be one of the few things that might lead us to divide if we can't sort this out and get it right. So I hope that he will meet with those who have spoken in today's debate, give further consideration to how we might make the Nolan principles of 1995, how we might make them relevant now and how this amendment which has enjoyed support from right across your Lordships' House might be put into some form onto the face of the bill. But with those words my Lords I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Speaker 115
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 37 Lord Marks.
Jonathan Marks
My Lords first of all I apologize for the delay in finding my way to this this group. I should make it clear that we do not intend by the detailed amendments in this group to undermine our support for the establishment of a core code for all the reasons that we've outlined and others have outlined in the last group.
Our amendments in this group are certainly directed to amending the bill as drafted, but I shall stress, as we stressed in the last group, that they are applicable to a single core code, taken together with any supplementary codes adopted by particular public bodies or authorities. All are directed to giving the codes teeth, requiring compliance and strengthening enforcement. Amendment 37 strengthens clause 10(3)(b), which currently requires authorities to take steps to make people who work for the authority aware of the code and the consequences for failing to act in accordance with it. That is substituted by a much stronger position, which is on page 5 of the marshalled list, which requires the authority to take all reasonable steps to ensure that those people are aware of the code and the consequences of failing to act in accordance with it, and comply with the code fully. My Lords, amendment 39 in this group would require a public authority's code to specify when a failure to comply with the standards of conduct must be referred for investigation as a potential criminal offence, in addition to setting out disciplinary consequences for breaches.
My Lords, that ties in with what I said in the last group about the importance of tying in serious breaches of the code with criminal sanctions. Amendment 44 would allow a public authority to adopt another document as its code of ethical conduct. In a sense, that is applicable to the bill as drafted rather than when there is a core code, but it would provide importantly, and that would be consistent with a core code, that the document must not be modified in a way which reduces the standards of ethical conduct contained in it. Then amendment 46 and 47 would mandate consistency between codes and would demand an explanation of how consistency should be achieved. That would be relevant to consistency between supplementary codes and a core code.
And amendment 55 would require a set of minimum requirements that any code must meet, including arrangements made to ensure compliance, which would have to be specified, and procedures which would have to be followed in the case of non-compliance. My Lords, the most important of the provisions of the amendments in this group from our point of view is the implementation of provision for a new, or the introduction of provision for a new criminal offence of a serious breach of a code of ethical conduct. That is designed to supplement the offences of misconduct in public office and misleading the public, which are already in the bill. It's part of the business of giving teeth to the imposition of ethical standards, which we regard as so necessary.
The codes are here to be obeyed. The problem with the Nolan standards and the problem with provision for ethical standards in authorities in the past has been that there has been no criminal sanction and only moderate and ill-matched sanction by disciplinary proceedings. Ill-matched in the sense that different public authorities have been free to use different sanctions. We regard it as very important that there should be ultimately recourse to the criminal law where a failure is knowing or reckless and where that failure is serious. Serious is defined in the amendment.
It has to be a failure that causes or creates a significant risk of harm to another person, a failure which involves dishonesty, corruption or abuse of public office, or which involves a serious breach of the Nolan principles, or seriously undermines confidence in the public authority or the proper exercise of its functions. That would be punishable on summary conviction by 12 months imprisonment or a fine or both, and on indictment by two years imprisonment or a fine or both. It's an essential feature of our suite of amendments and gives meaning to the imposition of compulsory standards. My Lords, we would not expect a vast number of prosecutions. But if we're serious about wanting a change of culture, we have to move from extolling standards to enforcing those standards.
And if serious breaches of the code lead to criminal proceedings, that best serves the aims of showing the public that we're serious about enforcing standards, for reasons of deterrence, to ensure that officials know that there will be serious consequences if they are guilty of a serious breach of the code, and a punishment which is a part of the process of penalties in the criminal courts. So we believe that serious cases of failure to comply with a code must be prosecuted, and that is at the heart of our approach to accountability. It's backed up by a duty on public authorities to take all reasonable steps to prevent, detect and respond to possible offences, and by regulations governing the enforcement of the provisions of a code. And we again say it should be a common core code supplemented by others. Criminal sanctions would apply whether or not disciplinary proceedings were brought.
The minimum standards would have to reflect the Nolan principles, and there would be a periodic review by amendment 58 of codes by the Ethics and Integrity Commission. My Lords, this suite of amendments together, we say, makes the enforcement of ethical standards a reality. And we're very concerned that the bill as drafted, without those backstop provisions, would not do that.
Speaker 90
Amendment proposed, clause 10, page 10, line 35, leave out paragraph B and insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Faulkner
I apologize for that attempted intervention there.
I think this would probably be an appropriate time for me to speak to my amendment 63A given how Lord Marks of Henley has set out the Lib Dem amendment. In doing so, I think I'm required by the companion to declare every time I intervene my interest, so I declare my interest as a distinguished fellow at the think tank Policy Exchange and am informed in the remarks I make by their recent report on this bill, which is called Legislating for Candour. My Lords, my amendment would seek to deal with the effect of obligations imposed by or under chapter two. Now we know that clause 10 will impose a new general duty on public bodies to promote and take steps to maintain high standards of ethical conduct at all times by people who work for an authority, for the authority. Clause 10 also imposes a more specific duty to create and to publish a new code for ethical conduct for people who work for the public authority.
We've been discussing that for the last hour. So far, so good. This amendment aims to address or ameliorate the risk that these duties will expose public bodies to judicial review proceedings, which is likely to prove costly and to undermine their ability to discharge their primary functions. Now it isn't clear whether government whether the government appreciates the risk that clause 10 without amendment may give rise to new grounds on which to challenge public action in the courts, enabling frustration of attempts to address serious policy problems, which is what we're trying to do here, and adding to the cost of doing government business. My Lords, I say that advisedly at this stage because we know that the ability to crowdfund often vexatious attempts of judicial review are increasing by the day and are adding enormously to the cost of doing government business.
Outside the context of this bill, the government seems concerned about these risks. On September 7th this year, the Chancellor, the Attorney General, and the First Secretary of State sent a joint letter to ministers about the simplification and agency of government. In the letter, the government accepts that, and I quote, "In some instances, it has become clear that the system of judicial review is out of balance." And is a dis end quote, and a disproportionate burden on effective government. The letter announces three changes and frames them in this way.
I quote, "We therefore wanted to set out three areas where this government will act with greater alacrity: on consultations, on legal considerations, and on judicial review, as initial steps in what will be a wider program of work to pare back counterproductive administrative burdens." End quote. My Lords, this is a commendable ambition. I certainly share it. It may be in some tension with this bill in general, which certainly imposes significant new administrative burdens as as set out in the report from Policy Exchange that I just highlighted.
That paper notes that as things stand, every public body in the country, from a government department to a parish council or a further education college, acquires a new set of uncertain legal obligations layered on top of the existing and already extensive and onerous grounds for review. In relation to clause 10 in particular, the government should make clear whether it intends whether it intends the duties in this clause to ground new applications for judicial review of the action of public bodies, that is to say new grounds on which a court might block them.
If this is the government's intention, it seems very hard to justify. Why would one want to empower the courts to police the ethical conduct of public bodies, a task for which they're ill-suited? It is true and important that courts protect natural justice, but enforcing a duty to act ethically or policing compliance with a broadly worded code of ethical conduct is much more general and is an ill-defined task which we should not invite courts to carry out. If the government does not intend clause 10 to widen the grounds of judicial review, then the bill needs amending. Whenever a public body publishes a code, there may be a risk that third parties will challenge the public body's actions in court by reference to the code.
There are numerous examples of that that I can send to the minister. The risk is much greater when the code has a statutory footing, especially when, as with clause 10, the code is intended to be a means to fulfill the more general duty of ensuring that those who work for the public authority act lawfully. The bill as it stands practically invites the courts to interpret for themselves the codes that public bodies publish, which may result in public bodies being held to have acted unlawfully for having misunderstood their own codes. Relatedly, the courts are likely to treat the requirements in a published code as relevant to the exercise of public power, which means that public bodies may be held to have acted unlawfully because they failed to consider or even adequately to consider some provision in those codes. Even if many or most of the challenges on these grounds fail, they will be costly to defend and will slow down and distort policy making and action.
It may take several costly years of litigation before we get clarity how the courts will handle this section and establish case law. Further legalizing the process and governing in this way is not wise, I argue, my Lords. The amendment now before the House aims to address these risks by providing that the duties in clause 10, including the requirements of any code published by a public body because of clause 10, are not to be considered in court. The point is not that public bodies should be free to ignore these duties, but rather that Parliament would make clear that the creation of these duties would not expand the scope of judicial review. The amendment provides that compliance with the duties in question may be considered by any relevant inquiry or investigation, which of itself is a powerful form of accountability, or it may be considered by the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, who is of course an officer of Parliament.
In addition, it would of course always be possible for parliamentarians to hold public bodies to account by reference to ethical conduct, including by reference to any code of conduct that they have published. The amendment is loosely based on section 4 of the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2010, which makes provision for political rather than legal accountability. The Fiscal Responsibility Act 2010 placed the Treasury under a statutory duty to bring public finances back into order on a fixed timetable. It had to ensure that public sector net borrowing as a share of GDP fell in several financial years in a row. Enforcement of that was left entirely to Parliament.
The Treasury had to report on its progress alongside each budget and pre-budget report, and once a deadline had passed, it had to say whether the target was met, and if it wasn't, to explain why.
Section 4 required those reports to be laid before Parliament and declared them to be the only means of holding the Treasury to account for those duties. It then provided that a missed target, past or anticipated, does not affect the lawfulness of anything done or left undone by anyone. So no court could quash a decision, grant a declaration, or compel compliance. The sanction for failure was having to come to the House and answer for it. Here too, there is a good case for enforcing judicial duties by political and not legal means.
The courts guard their jurisdiction jealously, but it would be a mistake to view this amendment as an exceptional limit on their powers. Parliament must decide whether and on what terms to enact clause 10 of the bill. It is for Parliament to decide whether the new duties in question are to be enforceable in a court, or whether this is sensible in view of the nature of the subject matter and the likely effects of making them justiciable. So this amendment, my Lords, is a means whereby Parliament could make clear that in enacting clause 10, it is not intending to create a new open-ended ground for judicial review proceedings. The duties in clause 10 would remain duties, but their enforcement would not be left to the courts to police, at great cost and at much risk of unwanted side effects which will take years to be unveiled.
Anderson
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, but I'm afraid not even her advocacy could persuade me that a failure by a public official or a public authority to have regard to the requirements of a code or of guidance is something that should be left entirely out of account by any court which might be called upon to decide whether that conduct was improper or irrational or negligent or unlawful. Others, I'm sure, will make the point more eloquently than I, but I did just want to record that before speaking, perhaps more prosaically, to my probing amendments 60 and 62, which I've tabled with the support of noble Lord Carlisle, Lord Leveson, and Lord Evans of Weardale, who, as was mentioned earlier, was chair until 2023 of the Committee on Standards in Public Life. The CSPL was replaced after the election by the Ethics and Integrity Commission, the EIC, whose purpose, as billed in the Labour manifesto, is, and I quote, "to ensure probity in government". The EIC's terms of reference, published in October 2025, make specific reference to this bill. They state, under the heading "Responsibilities", that the EIC will, and I quote, "advise public authorities on the development of clear codes of conduct with effective oversight arrangements in line with the planned forthcoming obligations of the Public Office Accountability Bill".
Yet the bill makes no reference to the EIC. It is given no formal role in the formulation of the codes, or as it may be, code of ethical conduct under clause 10, even as a consultee. And the guidance issued under clause 11 is to be issued by the central and devolved governments, again without any involvement on the part of the EIC. The Minister told us at second reading, and I should say I'm grateful to the Minister for engaging on this issue, he told us that the EIC would research and develop guidance which it would publish on its own website. But given its intended status as the centre of excellence on public codes of ethical conduct, at least for England, I'm a little mystified as to why the bill does not give the EIC a leading role in formulating at least the statutory guidance provided for in clause 11.
My Lords, that is a defect that amendment 60 is intended to probe and, should it go further, to correct. Amendment 62 raises a broader point. In its 2021 report, Upholding Standards in Public Life, the CSPL, under the leadership of Lord Evans of Weardale, recommended placing a number of constitutional watchdogs on a statutory footing to give them at least the protections of Parliament. Bodies such as the Independent Commissioner for Public Appointments, the Independent Adviser on Ministerial Standards, and the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments have important constitutional functions, hard-won over successive administrations, in proofing our system against abuse of power, favoritism, and corruption. Yet it would be the easiest thing in the world for a future government, impatient of such liberal notions, to sweep them all away in a first-day bonfire of the quangos, without the need even to justify its decision to Parliament.
Until such time as it is placed on a statutory footing, the same will be true of the EIC. Amendment 62 would place a parliamentary lock on the abolition of the EIC, in much the same way as my private member's bill, the Public Service Ethics, Integrity and Independence Bill, introduced during the last session, would have done for the other bodies I have mentioned. The EIC's implementation plan of October 2025 warns that, and I quote, it will take time to develop and implement the EIC's new responsibilities, and sets out what it described as an 18 to 24-month plan for the transition of the Committee on Standards in Public Life into the Ethics and Integrity Commission, subject to the necessary resources being in place. But there is no obstacle to the EIC being recognized in statute even before that transition is complete. I hope the Minister will agree that such recognition is desirable in principle, and I look forward to his comments on how and when we might expect to see it.
Alex Alexander Carlile
My Lords, I rise to support the amendments that have just been referred to by my noble friend Lord Anderson. But before I turn to that, I would like to say that my jaw was dropping as I listened to my noble friend Baroness Faulkner's attack on judicial review, and I would say to her with great respect this, because she's very eloquent and very persuasive, I'm afraid I'm not persuaded by her. We're talking here about what is popularly called the Hillsborough Bill, but we've heard mentioned at every sitting of this committee, at every part of this bill, a litany of events which have occurred, which have been disasters, despite the ostensible cooperation at all times of the public service, and I listen with great care particularly to the noble friend Lord Bichard when he was talking about these matters earlier. Some at least of those, that litany of horrific events, only came to light because of the availability of judicial review, the ability to judicially question administrative action. And sometimes it had to go to the highest court in order to achieve the prominence which those cases have rightly been given and the arrival of this bill before this house.
And I say to my noble friend that I have read the Policy Exchange report, I read it in detail yesterday afternoon and immediately penned my disagreement to the director of Policy Exchange, who is a member of your Lordship's house, because I think it is just naive in the way in which it approaches the issues we're concerned with.
And I apologize in saying that to two of my noble friends who've been involved in writing the foreword and an introduction to the Policy Exchange report, because I don't agree with them either. I think they're missing the point about judicial review. Now to what I intended to say. My Lords, this... no, I'm not giving way to the noble lady. She should not have gone before the rest of us in this debate, and I'm not giving way to her, I'm afraid.
I've said what I want to say, and I don't want to prolong the debate on that issue. What we have in clauses 11 and 12, which are probably in the wrong order, is the mother and the child. The mother is the guidance. The guidance is set out by clause 12, and the child are the codes which are described in clause 11. Now, the amendments which have been moved, mentioned, described, spoken to by my noble friend Lord Anderson are not about diminishing ministerial accountability, far from it.
They are about ensuring that the guidance which governs the codes leading to the understood standards in public life, the guidance is independent, respected, and trusted. Those who hold power should never be seen as having exclusive control, in my view, over the ethical framework by which they are judged. And amendment 60 and 62 ensure that there is no such power. They ensure that ethical guidance should be issued by an independent body, not, for example, by ministers, whether national ministers or devolved ministers, whose conduct may itself fall within the scope of the legislation. Public confidence in standards in public life is, in my view, enhanced by clear separation between those who exercise power and those who oversee ethical conduct.
These amendments reinforce the principle that integrity and ethics should not be subject to political influence or the priorities of the government of the day. These amendments allow for UK-wide consistency in standards while preserving the autonomy of Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland so far as it goes under our devolution settlement. In my view, guidance issued by an independent commission is likely to command far greater confidence than guidance issued by ministers who, by definition, have party loyalties. And it is for those reasons that I support amendment 60 and 62.
Speaker 112
My Lords, I rise to support the amendment 60 and 62, which have been very eloquently explained by Lord Anderson and Lord Carlisle. I was very surprised when I first read the bill to find that the Ethics and Integrity Commission wasn't there. It's a piece of machinery which the government has taken the time and effort to reinforce since the time when it was the Committee on Standards in Public Life, which I chaired. And in fact, it seems to me it's ideally built to do the sort of work that's in the bill. So I think it is the right piece of machinery.
And one of the reasons for that is the fact that it has on it representatives of a variety of different parties, as is evident merely by looking around the chamber today, where Baroness Finn, Baroness Beckett, and indeed the minister who's just arrived, were all members of that committee. So this is a committee which has an extraordinarily good representation from the political world as well as independent members. And it seemed to me that it is definitely the case that using them for this particular role would be the right way in which to go.
And as Lord Anderson pointed out, the current arrangements are very inconsistent. The CSPL did not recommend about itself that it should be put onto a statutory basis out of modesty, but we did recommend that regulatory bodies which have an ethical dimension do need to stand with appropriate independence and with the confidence that they are not easily abolished by the government of the day. And this amendment provides for that, and from that point of view, I commend it to the house.
Michael Wills
My lords, I hope this might be an appropriate time to turn to my amendments 45 and 48. Amendment 45 addresses some of the issues that we've already heard extensively discussed in your lordship's house, and I hope it might be helpful to the government in helping them negotiate what are very important but also very challenging issues. It recognizes that there may be differences between organizations and within organizations as to the content of their ethical codes of conduct. And among other things, this could result in ambiguities which could lead to misunderstanding, and that in turn could lead to serious consequences for individuals. Now, this amendment allows the Secretary of State to engage with public authorities to assess where such ambiguities might need to be removed, what might be needed to unify them all, and where appropriate, create a statutory binding list of obligations.
Now, it's a simple measure that empowers the Secretary of State in due course to take further action to deliver as effectively as possible the objectives of this landmark bill. Now, amendment 48 removes the ability of a public authority to exclude from its published code anything which it considers the disclosure of which would be contrary to the public interest. Now, my lords, we've seen too often how the definition of public interest adopted by a public authority is at odds with the definition adopted by a majority of the public. I'd be grateful if my noble friend the minister, if he was so minded, could give me some examples of how the public interest could justify exclusions from a code of ethical conduct. Now, I hope you'll agree with me that it is in the public interest to know what standard the public can expect of public bodies they may interact with, and what standards those bound by the duty are expected to meet.
What possibly could need to be upheld? And I should add that in light of all their bitter experience, the Hillsborough families are in favor of this amendment.
David Wolfson
My lords, I'll first turn to the amendments in the name of the noble lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames. Amendment 37 seeks to make the compliance of the code of ethics stricter, but I would suggest perhaps a little too strict. Amendment 39 seeks to require the code to set out the disciplinary measures that would be taken. This may be difficult in sectors that already have detailed and complex conduct and disciplinary regimes, such as the police, and the interplay between what's set out in amendment 39 and those existing regimes is not immediately clear.
Amendments 44, 46, 47 and 58 refer to and require consistency of the code, which is obviously sensible, but further discussion is necessary to determine what it is intended to be consistent with. As it stands, there doesn't seem to be a baseline expectation with which codes can be consistent. So as I read these amendments, it seems that the government would need to accept these amendments alongside amendments 55 and 57. Amendment 56 seeks to create a criminal offense for breaches of codes of conduct. On this, I think there is a real concern that if the codes of conduct are going to lead to criminal offenses for breach, the drafting of those codes of conduct would become even more burdensome than they would be at the moment because they would have to be used in court and also sufficiently clear that people appreciate precisely what it is they need to do because breach would be a criminal offense.
This is a point I think we'll come back to in some future groups, either later this evening or on another occasion. There's also a further problem with this amendment, i.e. that breach could result in a criminal offense because as matters stand and subject to the single code debate we had earlier, as matters stand, different public authorities would draft their own codes of ethical conduct for themselves under clause 10, which could result in the very odd, one might say perverse outcome that an employee of one authority finds themselves in breach and hauled before the criminal courts, while an employee of another authority does not face sanction for the very same action because there is a subtle difference in the drafting of the code of conduct between those authorities. That, it seems, would be a manifestation, if I can take the noble lord's example from an earlier group, of the Hampshire and North Yorkshire problem. And it might again speak to the noble lord Lord Alton of Liverpool's proposal for a single code, which I know the minister spoke to earlier and he said he would consider carefully before report stage. Amendment 59 draws on a similar point to my previous amendment in group 3, that guidance is essential throughout the implementation phase of this bill.
Turning to the amendments in the name of the noble lord Lord Wills, the amendment 45 seeks to allow the Secretary of State to make further provision about the expected standards of ethical conduct and a public authority's code of ethical conduct, which with the negative procedure could lead to insufficient scrutiny. On amendment 48, which seeks to remove the public authority's right to exclude from its published code information which would be contrary to the public interest, I can see potential examples of authorities which might mean that the exceptions permitted in paragraph C might actually protect real interests, but I look forward in particular to what the noble lord the minister says on that point. On amendments 60 and 62 from the noble lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich, which seek to place a large emphasis on the Ethics and Integrity Committee, including by placing some of its duties on a statutory footing, there is a cost aspect of this which concerns me. And I also wonder whether we should always legislate for what we fear a future government might or might not do.
Amendment 63A in the name of the noble lady Baroness Falkner of Margravine seeks to require breaches of codes of ethics to be considered only in inquiries or investigations rather than in legal proceedings. As I understand the purpose of the amendment, it's to confirm that such breaches are not themselves justiciable, including as I understood her speech in any judicial review proceedings. I certainly sympathize with the intention behind the amendment, although perhaps the real culprit is actually the creation of all these codes of conduct in the first place. Where codes go, I can assure the committee the lawyers will certainly follow. And on that point, which might command general support, I look forward to hearing what the noble lord the minister says.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
Hard to disagree with that. My lords, as mentioned in the discussion of the previous group, and obviously these two groups to some extent hang together, this bill is drafted to ensure that public authorities are required to make and publish codes of ethical conduct tailored to their organization and sector. Ensuring that these codes of ethical conduct are sufficiently detailed to drive culture change within public authorities is clearly, as we've many times discussed, an important part of delivering the spirit, the intention of this bill. Can I turn first to my noble friend Lord Wills's amendment 45 and 48? I appreciate my noble friend is keen to ensure that the government will be able to make changes in future to ensure that the bill remains a vehicle for meaningful and sustainable culture change across the public sector, across public authorities.
And we are actively considering options for post-legislative scrutiny, we'll come back to this I'm sure, to monitor the success of the bill in driving cultural change across public authorities. I do want to make it clear that that is one of the objectives we have for the bill, and therefore I will set out proposals in due course, and of course I shall be happy to discuss that with my noble friend and others before report stage. In respect of his second amendment, amendment 48, my noble friend will understand that there may be circumstances where information is sensitive and publication may have detrimental effects for the organization individually or more generally. Our current approach allows organizations to develop more detailed codes of ethical conduct containing sensitive information for employees while omitting such material from versions of the code published publicly. However, I do understand his concerns about transparency and I'm very happy to explore transparency between now and report so that we can ensure that the expectations are clear and that everyone, including the people who work for public authorities, know where they stand.
Turning to the noble lord Lord Marks's package of amendments, and I think it's right to see them as a package, these seek to strengthen the provisions of codes of ethical conduct in chapter 2 of the bill and to use the phrase he used several times, to give it more teeth. And I'm grateful for the time he's already spent with me, including during recess, to discuss these intentions behind these amendments in more detail. I will reflect carefully on the points that have been made and I'll discuss them further with officials and consider whether there is merit in exploring any of these issues ahead of report, and I'll certainly discuss them with Lord Marks and others.
Our initial assessment is that we agree there needs to be consistency across the codes and we are open to strengthening the provisions in this bill. I can assure the noble lord and this and and your lordship's house that the government will issue guidance to public authorities concerning codes of conduct and that will be statutory guidance. However the intention behind clause 10 6 is that modifications can be made to existing codes to bring them up to the standards required in the bill. Evidently modifications cannot be made such that they do not comply with the requirements of the bill. Furthermore the bill already requires authorities to take steps to make employees aware of the code and the consequences of non-compliance as part of their duty to promote and maintain high standards of ethical conduct at all times.
The bill already creates a number of new offences alongside existing criminal offences which may apply to public officials. Codes of ethics will cover a wide range of conduct not all of which is appropriately dealt with in the government's view through the criminal law a point that the noble lord Lord Wilson also made. Our initial assessment is a general offence of breaching a code of ethics would not be clear proportionate or necessary. Public officials are subject to a number of laws within this bill and we would need to consider the practical implications of attempting to list all of these in codes. However this debate has been extremely helpful in testing the issues that the noble lord Lord Marks raises about the strength and the teeth of the bill and I look forward to continuing those conversations before we get to the next stage of the bill.
Turning now to the noble lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich and the noble lord Lord Marks have both tabled amendments relating to the codes of ethical conduct and the role of the ethics and integrity committee. The EIC which was established by the former prime minister as a centre of excellence on codes of conduct has already we do the noble lord Lord Anderson specifically asked me about this has already been commissioned to develop best practice guidance for public authorities so they already have some standing in relation to this on how codes of ethical conduct can be used to drive cultural change and its call for evidence to inform this work closed last month in September. So so we do see them as involved in all this. Public authorities rightly expect
Anderson
Yes. I'm so grateful to the minister. I wonder if he could just clarify whether that guidance relates to the content of the codes or simply to the way that they can be used.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
I think that's something we will need to cover in guidance but I I absolutely anticipate and I'll correct this if this is wrong but I don't think it is wrong that the EIC will want to comment on the content and how they should be which I think is probably what the noble lord was was driving at but I'm sure that's right. But I mean of course public authorities rightly expect the government to provide them with clear guidance about what is necessary for compliance with this bill and we will do that. We are therefore preparing statutory guidance that will be available when this clause is commenced. Our expectation is that public authorities will draw on both sets of guidance when developing their codes. That is ensuring that they not only comply with the requirements of the legislation but are also informed by evidence-based best practice.
The government does not consider it necessary to place the functions of the EIC on a statutory footing. As an advisory body whose role is to provide independent advice to the government the current arrangements are in the government's view entirely appropriate. The EIC is an independent body and we do not believe it is necessary to prescribe its role in legislation. Moreover given its independent status it would be inappropriate to place it under a statutory duty to assess whether codes of practice published by public authorities comply with the terms of the bill.
The EIC's remit extends well beyond the matters addressed in this legislation. Its wider purpose is to promote the highest standards in public life and conferring what would in effect be a regulatory function upon it would, in the government's view, risk undermining that broader role. Can I now turn to amendment 63A tabled by the noble Baroness Faulkner of Margravine? We agree with the noble Baroness that the bill should not create a specific offence in the event that there is a breach of the code of ethical conduct. However, it is clearly right that the authorities who do not comply with their duty to adopt a code of ethical conduct are appropriately held to account, and I think the noble Lords Lord Anderson and Carlyle set out much more eloquently than I can exactly why that needs to be the case.
For breaches of standards by officials, the public can use the authority's complaints process and for the most serious wrongdoing, that could also constitute a criminal offence under the misleading the public offence or seriously improper acts offence. Therefore, we think the bill, alongside existing laws and processes, adequately provide appropriate avenues to scrutinize compliance with chapter two. I hope this provides some clarity to noble Lords and I've made clear the issues on which I'm happy to discuss further and therefore I ask the noble Lord respectfully to withdraw his amendment.
Jonathan Marks
My Lords, I'm very grateful for the indication given by the noble Lord that he's happy to continue discussions on strengthening the bill. And I should have said when I opened my amendment that I was very grateful for the engagement that we had between, well, for some time before the second reading of this bill on discussing these amendments and the whole question of strengthening part two, chapter two of the bill. I do take the point that while we persist in believing that the chapter needs considerable strengthening to avoid future tragedies, I take the point made by the noble Lord Lord Wolfson that particularly in relation to criminal sanctions, there is an issue which would make the Hampshire-North Yorkshire inconsistency that much more serious. That, I would suggest, as I've no doubt others would, is a very strong argument for having a core code. But it's plainly sensible in view of the indication that the noble Lord Lord Lemas has given that he will consider that issue further and will have further discussions on that, that they should await the outcome of those discussions.
So that I will be seeking to withdraw my amendments. I would, however, say that in relation to the amendment moved by the noble lady Baroness Faulkner to the effect that the non-compliance with the code should not really be justiciable in any way, I am entirely with the noble Lord Lord Carlyle and the noble Lord Lord Anderson. And I'm bound to say that judicial review has for the whole of my career at the bar been one of the outstanding contributions.
Faulkner
It's just, I wonder whether he might sit down. It's just the briefest of interventions that I would have asked Lord Carlyle if he had taken my intervention, and it is this: is not misconduct in public office already an offence?
Jonathan Marks
I'm not sure that that has much to do with what we're considering now. What I'm saying is that justiciability is of the essence of giving strength to this bill. And to abandon justiciability means that we might be going back to platitudes that have no real effect upon public behavior or public perception of government and official behavior. And that was really my point of taking issue with the arguments taken by the noble baroness. That said, I do now beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 119
Is it your lordship's pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Now I would ask your lordships to bear with me. I am going to have to go through no less than 19 pages of this in order to get to the stage where we are able to adjourn and move on to the next business. So, amendment 37A, Lord Hendy, not moved.
Speaker 117
Amendment 38, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 39, Lord Marks, not moved. Amendment 40, Lord Wills, not moved. Amendment 40A, Lord Hendy, not moved. Amendment 41, Baroness Featherstone, not moved.
Amendment 42, Baroness Kramer, not moved. Amendment 42A, Lord Hendy, not moved. Amendment 43, Baroness Featherstone, not moved. Amendment 43A, Lord Hendy, not moved. Amendment 44, Lord Marks, not moved.
Speaker 119
Amendment 45, Lord Wills, not moved. Amendment 46, Lord Marks, not moved. And 47, not moved. Amendment 48, Lord Wills, not moved. Amendment 49, Lord Marks, not moved.
The question is that clause 10 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 50, Baroness Featherstone, not moved.
Speaker 117
Amendment 51, Lord Alton, not moved. Amendment 51A, Lord Hendy, not moved. Amendment 52, Baroness Kramer, not moved. And 53, Baroness Kramer, not moved. Amendment 54, Lord Wills, not moved.
Amendment 55 to 59, Lord Marks, not moved. Amendment 60, Lord Anderson, not moved. Amendment 61, Lord Alton, not moved. The question is that clause 11 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion will say content.
The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 62, Lord Anderson, not moved. Amendment 63, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 63A, Baroness Faulkner, not moved.
Amendment 64, Baroness Jones, not moved. And 65, not moved. Amendment 66, Baroness Coffee, not moved. Amendment 66A, Baroness Jones, not moved. And 67, not moved.
Amendment 68, Lord Marks, not moved. Amendment 69, Baroness Jones, not moved. And amendment 69A, Baroness Coffee, not moved. The question is that schedule 2 be the second schedule to the bill. As many of that opinion will say content.
The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Anderson
My lords, I beg to move that the house be resumed. We will then move to dinner break business. We will therefore not return to the bill before 20:37.
Speaker 117
The question is that the house be resumed. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Question for short debate, provision for the teaching of citizenship, Lord Norton of Louth.
Philip Norton
My lords, at the weekend, the noble lord, Lord Ricketts, warned of the threats posed by hybrid attacks on our national infrastructure.
The threats are growing and becoming more dangerous. They threaten our very system of government and the values that underpin it. We're vulnerable because of the spread of disinformation and false narratives, not least through social media. Many, especially young people, lack both a critical capacity to interrogate the veracity of what is posted and an understanding of how our system works and what it delivers to them and to society as a whole. The pervasive use of social media also serves to undermine community engagement, people no longer coming together to pursue their interests and to engage in social discourse.
The dissemination of fake news by malign sources, whether domestic or foreign, serves to undermine trust in our political system and culture. The 2023 ONS Trust in Government survey found that a majority of those questioned, 57%, had low or no trust in both government and parliament. Our system of government, how we choose to govern ourselves and the values that underpin a healthy polity, adherence to the rule of law, justice and tolerance, have built up over the centuries, producing a stable pluralist society, but its endurance rests on the trust and vigilance of its citizens. As Stanley Baldwin memorably put it, we have to remember that the price of liberty is eternal vigilance, and I may add eternal knowledge, eternal sympathy and eternal understanding. My thesis is that we need to act and to do so as a matter of urgency to enhance knowledge and understanding.
That will not happen without action on our part. As the noble lord, Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts, said in an opening debate in 2018 on the report of the Select Committee on Citizenship and Civic Education, our fellow citizens of any age do not learn about how our society works by magic, it has to be taught and taught well. As he went on to say, while our committee heard evidence of some inspiring work going on in our schools, too often it appears that schools regard citizenship as a nice-to-have, not a must-have. Surely that needs to be reversed. As the committee's report concluded, the government's allowed citizenship education in England to degrade to a parlous state.
The decline of the subject must be addressed in its totality as a matter of urgency. My lords, the best defense against the attack on our democratic system is a vibrant civic culture. That is what constitutes the basis of this question this evening. The onus is on government to act as a matter of urgency, though we all have a role to play. I welcome changes that the government have announced to the provision of citizenship teaching.
They are necessary, but as I shall argue, not sufficient. The government have accepted the recommendations of the curriculum and assessment review and are making citizenship teaching compulsory for primary school children. There'll be revised national curriculum for teaching in 2028. Resources are also being made available through the Oak National Academy as well as by the Electoral Commission. However, much more needs to be done.
There is a problem in teaching citizenship at key stages three and four. Many schools lack a subject specialist. Eight out of ten teachers who teach citizenship do not have a relevant post-A-level qualification in the subject.
I fear that citizenship taught badly may be worse than no teaching at all. Fewer than 5% of pupils opt for GCSE citizenship studies. My Lords, we know from surveys the value of such education. Exposure to citizenship content is associated with stronger support for democracy, tolerance, confidence in the ability to make a difference, and intention to vote. That is exactly what is needed.
To take citizenship seriously, schools need incentives. Ofsted inspections need to give citizenship the same attention as other curriculum subjects, and as recommended by the Association of Citizenship Teaching, assess pupils' knowledge alongside opportunities for participation. Schools need to demonstrate that pupils have secured the statutory citizenship learning. Incentives need to be matched by serious investment, both in terms of recruiting and training citizenship teachers, not least through the provision of training bursaries, and in enabling primary schools to deliver on the responsibilities that are being vested in them. That investment must not be seen as some discrete responsibility of the Department for Education and a drain on its budget.
It must be embraced by government as an essential tool in the nation's defence against the threats it faces. Enhancing citizenship education is not among the recommendations of the Rycroft review to tackle foreign interference in UK politics, but it is a logical extension of what is proposed. It should be core to the work of the government's Defending Democracy Taskforce. Embedding citizenship teaching in schools is necessary, but even with adequate resourcing, it is not sufficient. We need a politically aware population.
Citizenship needs to be embedded in society. I welcome the aspiration of the Association of Colleges for every college to offer students a high-quality political literacy programme. We need to extend such literacy to others in society, utilizing any organization that draws people together. The Electoral Commission may play a valuable role. Its democratic education framework is aimed at young people, but merits being extended to bodies in civil society to reach adults.
We need to think what other public bodies can contribute to raising political awareness. Will the Minister confirm that what is needed and what she will pursue is a whole-of-government strategy to embrace and fund citizenship teaching along the lines I've outlined, to tackle the ever-growing challenges posed to this nation by disinformation and false narratives? My Lords, we know young people recognize the need to be better informed and benefit from such education. We need to ensure that they and their elders get that education for all our sakes.
David Blunkett
My Lords, I'd like to thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, and I agreed with every word he said. Thank you for referring to the 2018 Select Committee on which I served. In the very short time available, I just want to make three points. Firstly, I think it's excellent that the officials who are working extremely well from the Department of Education are working with the Association of Citizenship Teaching, of which I'm a long-standing honorary president, to actually make sure that we get the materials right and that we ensure that teaching is of the quality that we would wish. The second is to welcome the work of the Electoral Commission and the materials that they're putting out over the current year and into 2028, but to ask that they're coordinated with the work of the department and the revised citizenship curriculum so that it makes sense not just in schools and colleges, but to post-16 young people who are not in those formal settings.
And thirdly, that we actually bring forward the revised citizenship curriculum to 2027. It is possible, speaking as a former education employment secretary and someone who's taught in further education, it is possible to bring forward parts of that revised curriculum to September next year in time to inform and educate and equip young people to take on voting at the ages of 16 and 17. If we don't, it will be a dereliction of duty.
William Wallace
My Lords, just to follow the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, given that the University of Sheffield and Bernard Crick in particular were leaders in talking about citizenship education. Earlier this year, ahead of the Representation of the People's Bill reaching our House, I visited a number of secondary schools in London and Yorkshire to ask how they plan to adjust their curriculum to prepare students to exercise their vote from 16. I was shaken by how little time any of them currently had for education about democracy, law, and citizenship, including in one of England's leading independent schools. One hour a week for all aspects of personal development, from personal relationships, finance, drugs, online stress, fake and misinformation, bullying and grooming, health, careers, British values, and democracy is a crazy race through too many important topics. The students I met admitted how little they knew about political issues, but were very keen to know more.
After the first Reform Act, the Earl of Eldon argued in a debate in this House against educating the working classes as giving them ideas above their station. A recent Telegraph op-ed argued similarly that political education is dangerous because left-wing teachers will indoctrinate students with subversive ideas. Yes, democracy is about encouraging citizens to think for themselves, to challenge authority and received wisdom, and to understand the balance between rights and responsibilities that underpins our democratic society. Public trust in our political institutions is lower than in most comparable democratic states. The weakening of our local democracy has made politics more remote for most citizens.
It looks like a distant game played in Westminster. The replacement of newspapers and radio by social media as the primary source of information has left many young people desperately uninformed about the structures and the difficult choices that shape our politics. We need cross-party support for better political education and to make more room in our crowded national curriculum for students to learn about how to be active, informed, and responsible citizens.
Speaker 126
My Lords, in our Church of England schools, we're proud of the role we play in preparing young people of all faiths and none to participate thoughtfully, respectfully, and confidently in our diverse arena of public life. However, many of our schools serve small rural communities and therefore have far less flexibility when it comes to specialist staffing. In light of the government's decision to lower the voting age, can the minister say what steps will be taken to ensure that all schools are adequately resourced to deliver the high-quality citizenship education that young people will need to fulfill this new responsibility? We should also afford sufficient attention the programme of study for key stage one. We want our youngest children to recognize the difference between right and wrong, to understand that they belong to various communities, and to realize that people and other living things have responsibility to each other.
Speaker 123
By grounding early education in these fundamental values, we can foster an environment of fellowship with one another, which enables human flourishing and invests in a bright future for our communities. We should not treat early citizenship learning as an afterthought, but as a central pillar of our education that invests in a bright future for our country.
Speaker 125
My Lords, I strongly agree with my noble friend Lord Norton of Louth that citizenship education should extend deeply into other bodies engaged in civil society. So as a very long-standing local resident in the city of Westminster, and as we know all politics is basically local politics, I'm glad to see that Westminster Council now has a deputy cabinet member designated for civic matters, indeed for civic pride, and that's a very good thing I believe for local authorities to turn their attention into in order to shore up the key values of our British polity. Providentially, this debate comes at a critical time for the peaceful polity of many countries in Europe and beyond, like India, where in recent weeks we have seen a lot of uncivil youthquakes bursting out all over their societies, tragically particularly in France. I have suddenly seen these maybe harmless student demonstrations being transmogrified into something very much more serious with assaults of a very savage sort on the very ideal of fraternity, free of her benefits and education in civil society. But we in the UK, mercifully spared and long may it last this sort of thing, is we must have spread the message as quickly as possible, starting of course with schools and looking at the school record.
Speaker 124
The numbers of people studying GCSEs in citizenship has plummeted, the numbers of people qualified to teach it has plummeted. The people, there aren't the people to take up the challenge to show leadership. It isn't only within schools, but it's critically important as the noble Lord Lord Blunkett has pointed out. And what I find very hard to understand is there isn't even a bursary for initial teacher training. Please minister, why not?
Speaker 129
My Lords, the upcoming national curriculum reforms making citizenship compulsory in primary schools and deepening focus on democracy and media literacy in secondary schools are an excellent step forward. However, you can teach the mechanics of democratic system, but you cannot syllabus the courage it takes to step up and use them. True citizenship requires us to step completely out of our comfort zones. When I look back at my own journey, my real integration into society, it didn't just happen in a classroom. It happened when I forced myself into unfamiliar spaces.
Joining team sports, school orchestra taught me how to cooperate with completely different groups of people. Later, Duke of Edinburgh scheme pushed me even further. It led me to a doorstep of an elderly lady. Every week I saw her, did her shopping and simply sat and spoke with her. That single step out of my own world gave me a profound real-world understanding of my local community, and it taught me empathy, history, and shared responsibility.
My deepest concern today is that we are losing these opportunities, as many noble lords have already mentioned. Too many young people are absorbed in social media, simply reinforcing their own narrow subcultures. Even at home, the cultural landscape has fractured. The demise of mainstream terrestrial channels means families no longer gather around a shared cultural touchstone. Instead, individuals are immersed in TikTok or streaming that can cater strictly to their existing interests.
So we've stopped sharing, and that stops us from understanding and empathizing with the wider fabric of British society. So while we must applaud the government's decisive action to strengthen classroom citizenship, we cannot let the state do all the heavy lifting. Policy alone cannot build a community.
Jane Bonham Carter
My Lords, our 16 and 17-year-olds are to be given the vote, and there are around one and a half million of them. This is at a time when our politics has never been so febrile and unpredictable. There's therefore a burning question as to whether our young people are equipped with the knowledge they need to use their vote in an informed way, or even to want to vote at all. The good news is that citizenship education is already part of the national curriculum at key stages 3 and 4. This says pupils should be taught about democratic government, key elements of the UK constitution, human rights, financial matters, and a free press, etc.
But it's one thing to write these things into the national curriculum and quite another to actually deliver them in practice. The fact is that many pupils are either not being taught these things at all, or there's insufficient attention given to their importance, which explains why Professor Becky Francis's review of the national curriculum found a less than 5% take-up of citizenship at GCSE, as the noble lord Lord Norton has already pointed out. There should be more teachers trained in citizenship issues who can teach the subject in an impartial and engaging way in every school. As the noble lord Lord Blunkett graphically put it in a previous debate on citizenship education, and I quote, "We must get rid of the catch-22, which is that if you do not teach children citizenship, they will not go forward through to GCSE, and if they don't do that, there'll be less government support to train more teachers, and round we go." Could I ask the noble baroness the minister how many teachers have been recruited from the money raised through VAT on private schools, and how many of these will be trained to teach citizenship?
Ideally there needs to be a teacher trained in citizenship in every school. Only then will it be part of the national curriculum at key stages one to four in a meaningful way for teachers and pupils alike with all the massive benefits this will have for society as a whole.
Elizabeth Berridge
My lords, the lack of specialist teachers for citizenship as my noble friend Lord Norton outlined means that schools have had to be super flexible in how they teach this subject. In some schools it is a standalone with a few going on to GCSE. In some it's taught across the curriculum in history, RE and politics. In some it's merged with PHSE. In some it's part of the pastoral curriculum so taught first thing in the morning in forms.
And in some it is taught as part of fundamental British values. Such flexibility is not necessarily a bad thing as when the charity Freedom Declared Foundation of which I'm a trustee together with Regent's Park College Oxford in which I must declare an interest sought to create secondary school resources on freedom of religion or belief in the UK with RE teachers, the teachers arrived equipped with the exam board curriculums in citizenship and neatly slotted it in. However, my lords, my main question to His Majesty's government is how much emphasis is there whether at primary or secondary on why we are a democracy? Encouraging young people to vote and volunteer is necessary, but when algorithms are sending mainly boys to the glorification of the strongman view of government along with some far-right streams of thought, for how long will they be able to make the distinction between the strongman and the dictator? Are teachers being equipped with this information about the algorithms?
This month America, the so-called leader of the free world, was classified by academics Levitsky and Way as a competitive authoritarian state. I quote, where elections remain real but incumbents systematically abuse state institutions to tilt the playing field against opponents. My lords, the context in which citizenship is being taught is very different to when any noble lords were at school. Why we are a democracy is seriously under challenge. Flexibility is going to need to be supplemented by specialist training to keep apace with such algorithms.
The Lord Doyle
My lords, I want to thank the noble lord Lord Norton of Louth for securing this debate and for his excellent speech. And it's a great pleasure to follow my noble friend and former boss Lord Blunkett who has been such a great advocate on this topic. I speak as a passionate advocate myself for citizenship education and its role in building the resilient, informed and engaged citizens of the future. So how do we get from good intentions to good implementation? Well first we must acknowledge some of the problems with the habit of simply suggesting adding something to the national curriculum solves a problem.
We have a smorgasbord of RHSE, PHSE, financial and digital literacy, enterprise education, etc. While all these demands are perfectly reasonable, the curriculum cannot simply be an ever-growing list of things politicians and campaigners think are important. I believe there are therefore four things we need to do. First, understand what is already being taught rather than simply trying to add more and more obligations. Second, bring these subjects together.
What do we want our young people to know and be able to do when they leave school and why? Let's create one coherent curriculum with clear priorities and carefully sequenced content. Third, we need to give it the right time. Head teachers are already having to make choices and can't keep absorbing new demands especially for non-examined subjects.
But we already have a model in PE where schools widely provide two hours a week without making it an examined subject. Let's establish one hour a week for this new combined curriculum with a clear national expectation, including Ofsted inspection. And fourth, let's support teachers. We need excellent curriculum materials through organisations like the Association of Citizenship Teachers and the Oak National Academy, so teachers can deliver these lessons confidently and effectively. This way, we can have a coherent, stable and deliverable approach to preparing our young people for life.
Elliott
My Lords, I would like to talk about the financial education aspect of citizenship education, something I know the government is committed to improving. It's imperative that children learn the necessary financial skills for their future. To quote the money saving expert Martin Lewis, our children are sent out into a world of scams, dodgy deals and debt without the tools to cope. The useful library briefing for this debate tells us that parents, carers and students are dissatisfied with the present level of attention to financial education in the curriculum and that there is a strong appetite for more. I'd like to draw the attention of the House to the recent report entitled Jobs and Investment, published by the Jobs Foundation, a charity I'm proud to be president of, as declared in the register, which included the recommendation for the teaching of basic investment in schools.
Teaching practical skills on rates to return, basic portfolio principles and retirement planning would set children up for life, a life of financial stability. We should also teach the power of compound interest, the importance of delayed gratification to future well-being and, dare I say it, why capital gains have always been taxed at a lower rate than salaried income, because economic growth requires entrepreneurship and risk-taking to be encouraged. When the noble lady the minister responds to this debate, I'd be grateful if the House could have more detail on the government's plans for financial education and whether the principles of investment might be included as part of this. As teenagers hopefully still learn in their English lessons from reading Mr Micawber's words in David Copperfield: annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery.
Speaker 134
Micawber's principle is correct and a neat encapsulation of why financial education is a must.
Speaker 135
My Lords, my commitment to citizen education was cemented during my time working for the National Citizen Service, NCS, which brought together young people from different backgrounds to help build confidence, forge lasting relationships and develop a sense of shared purpose, primarily through volunteering in their local communities. NCS often changed young people's lives and demonstrated to me that citizenship should be an activity and not a subject, and I'd like to think we might bear that in mind when we think about future provision. Like Lord Norton, I want to focus on citizenship education's potential to strengthen our national resilience. Members of this House are acutely aware of the challenges that our country faces and the resultant sense of uncertainty and threat. In that climate, resilience depends on whether people feel whether they belong, trust one another and, significantly, trust the institutions that govern them.
And I worry that we have too little understanding of what many young people are exposed to online and of the malign influences seeking to undermine our values and institutions. I think when we look at France this weekend, I refuse to believe that amongst the chaos there is not some coordinated agitation or provocation by those that wish to undermine our values. Here in the UK in 2025, counter-terrorism police arrested 39 children, young people under the age of 17, under terrorism laws. That means that one in six of all those arrested last year by counter-terrorism police were children.
Of those arrested, 92% were boys or young men. Those figures add to my sense that we're just not paying enough attention to who is targeting our young men and to what dreadful ends they are working towards. To my mind, they deserve the boys a bit more of our support and our attention and dare I say it, our love. Citizen education cannot solve every problem, but done well it can help equip young people with the skills to think critically, challenge misinformation, understand our collective values and engage constructively with those people whose views differ from their own. Given the challenges that we face as a country and what lies ahead, it seems to me that this is an important and worthwhile investment.
The Baroness Helic
My Lords, I welcome this debate and I congratulate my noble friend on all his tireless work over the years on citizenship education and on today's speech. My Lords, I serve on your Lordship's National Resilience Committee and much of our work concerns how the country can withstand threats to its institutions and security. But national resilience of course cannot be secured by the state alone, it also depends on the judgment and conduct of citizens. Last week, Ken McCallum urged us to be clear-eyed about the more contested world we now live in. This is absolutely right, but being clear-eyed requires more than recognition of external threats.
It requires the ability to distinguish between credible information from manipulation and disagreement from enemy. Citizenship education must therefore go beyond teaching how parliament and elections work. Young people should understand why the rule of law matters, how to assess evidence, how to disagree without treating others as enemies. These are essential disciplines of democratic life and national resilience. I welcome the government's plans to extend compulsory citizenship education to primary schools in England from 2028 and to strengthen media literacy.
But policy commitment alone are not enough and provision remains uneven and schools need the time, expertise and support to teach these subjects effectively. Will the minister tell the House how the Department for Education and the Cabinet Office are working together to make civic resilience, including political literacy and the ability to recognise manipulation, an explicit part of national resilience planning? And how will the government assess whether these efforts are succeeding? My Lords, when a crisis comes, the question will not be only whether government is ready, it will be whether citizens can exercise judgment, resist manipulation and act with a sense of responsibility towards one another. We cannot assume that they will, but we must prepare them for that.
Speaker 136
My Lords, when UK adults were asked to identify approximate annual government spending in a recent poll, only 16% selected the correct answer. In another poll, when people were asked about their understanding of how laws were made, 49% said they knew not very much, knew nothing about or had never heard of the process. These figures raise an important question: how can we expect people to participate meaningfully in our democracy if they do not understand how it works?
Citizenship education is expanded, particularly into primary schools. We should focus not simply on what children will be taught, but on how they are taught it. The ability to think critically, weigh competing arguments, and understand their responsibility to the communities in which they live should run throughout the entire curriculum. Those of us who've spent our lives in public policy know that politics is fundamentally about trade-offs, balancing competing priorities, and considering unintended consequences. We should equip children with the skills to navigate these choices thoughtfully.
How they apply what they know is just as important as what they know. Citizenship education must be more than a box-ticking exercise. It must be taught in such a way that it shapes how people think, how they engage with others, and how they act in their everyday lives. Will the noble Baroness the Minister commit to ensuring that the new curriculum, when it is introduced, will have as core objectives developing citizens who can think critically and understand their obligations to the wider community they live in? And can the noble Baroness the Minister explain how the government will ensure that these objectives translate into meaningful teaching and learning in the classroom?
Prem Sikka
My Lords, to be effective, education must go beyond mere description of a socio-political system and include critique. Young people must be shown that democracy is preferable to plutocracy, and it must be protected from the power of corporations and the super-rich who buy the political system and hire legislators. The syllabus must encourage students to design community-based projects and see for themselves the effects of inequalities which deprive millions of nutritious food, good housing, healthcare, education, and pensions. Such projects must consider why elected governments are content with 1% of the population owning more wealth than 70% of the population combined. Why the state forces the poorest 20% to pay a higher proportion of their income in direct and indirect taxes than the richest 20%?
Why are governments content with fiscal rules which send 300,000 people a year to premature death due to lack of timely hospital appointments? J.K. Galbraith's book, The Culture of Contentment, ought to be essential reading, as it explains how rising affluence of the few has shaped politics of selfishness, hypocrisy, and the hollowing out of economies and democracy. Education that does not reconstruct common sense and foment possibilities of emancipatory change isn't really education.
Elizabeth Barker
My Lords, it was a pleasure to be part of the 2018 committee which looked at citizenship under the chairmanship of Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts. And although it's taken 10 years, it is pleasing to see that the government is finally getting round to responding positively to some of the suggestions that we made then. I'm also, should say, that I spend a lot of time talking to children in school children in our education centre. And I very much welcome the move to extend citizenship education to primary schools, because the level of engagement and interest and desire for further knowledge of very young children is something which is a constant surprise and delight to me.
Going back to the committee, one of the biggest disappointments that we had was the then disinterest of Ofsted in citizenship teaching. They really were not interested in seeing that schools were being assessed on the level or the quality of their teaching. And teachers were having to make up from their own time and their own resources a curricula. I'm really glad that we're going to move away from that and we're going to move towards proper standardization. I'm also pleased that we have stopped, we're going to stop mixing up citizenship with PHSE and a whole gaggle of other things.
I was critical of the National Citizen Service from its inception and I'm glad that the government was brave enough to close it down because I think it was ill-targeted and expensive and by and large not worth the money that it was being paid for. I do have a question for the noble Baroness. At its height it was paid 150 million pounds a year. That was a very big investment in a voluntary organization. What's happened to the money?
Because that's a sizeable slice of resources which could be given over to the development and implementation of new resources, which by the way, if they're going to reach young people, have got to be online at some stage because that will be the way in which young people get onto this agenda and get to find the information that they need.
Joanne Cash
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton of Louth, for securing this debate. It was really terrible to see France burning this weekend, watching Limoges-Four-Four, two at least dead so far. And it began with rioting school children. Here in the UK, we have recent polling showing that less than half of young Britons support our democratic system. So it's a natural reflex to say teach citizenship.
But how and what we teach under this subject is of vital importance because it has gone so badly wrong elsewhere. There's no time tonight, but in Illinois, in Massachusetts, in Quebec, do look at what has happened there. It's been devastating. Children should be taught our history, our constitution, equality before the law. Of course they should be taught how to participate.
But the content being written by staff in the Department for Education, taught by teachers untrained as we've heard tonight, and without any supervision or oversight as yet known to us by Ofsted or elsewhere, is simply not going to be adequate. We've heard from Baroness Paul that one in six arrested for counter-terrorism in the UK are children. Baroness Casey warned us ten years ago that there were whole communities living parallel lives and so very little has been done. So how are we going to ensure that those among us who see citizenship of this country as a very different thing are trustworthy in their roles in schools to teach it in the same way? Because my Lords, there is another place where the teaching of citizenship has failed.
France has required moral and civic education in every school year since 2015. The generation that sat through those lessons set fire to their country at the weekend. The Secretary of State said recently in a speech that she wished to look again at the curriculum and I hope very much that she will look again at some of this.
Jacqui Smith
My Lords, as others have, I want to thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, for securing this important debate on citizenship education. As a leading expert on Parliament, I know that citizenship is very close to his heart. As many noble Lords have said during this short debate, citizenship matters because it is important that young people understand our democratic institutions, their rights and responsibilities, and the part they can play in shaping our country, a point I think emphasized by the noble lady Baroness Porter. It gives young people the knowledge and confidence to become active, informed, and responsible members of society.
Citizenship is of course already a national curriculum subject, having been introduced under the previous Labour government when my noble friend Lord Blunkett was the Secretary of State and I was a lowly foot soldier minister in helping him to introduce that subject. And the statutory content already covers democracy and government, the law and rights, financial education and participation in society, as well as critical thinking and mutual respect. But that doesn't mean that we think the status quo is good enough. The curriculum and assessment review from late 2025 pointed to an out-of-date curriculum, as have noble lords this evening. My noble friend Lord Doyle, I think rightly, argued that we need to position citizenship within an understanding of what and how we teach across the whole of the curriculum.
But the review did call for explicit content on the life skills that young people need. Oracy, or as I like to think of it, speaking and listening skills, financial education as identified by the noble lord Lord Elliott, digital and media literacy, and here in particular I think my noble friend Baroness Paul and the noble lady Baroness Hellich are absolutely right to emphasize the nature of young people being able to recognize disinformation and think clearly as being a key element of national resilience. The review was clear that students need to be clear-sighted and questioning and skeptical, and that does need to be a particularly important development given some of the other issues that noble lords have raised. And also the curriculum and assessment review argued climate change education. The review said that curriculum content should be more specific and that it should build progressively through each age group.
The review also said that citizenship should become statutory in primary schools. The government agrees, no child should miss out, although I can't promise my noble friend Lord Sikka that Galbraithe will be on the curriculum for primary school pupils. The government intends to consult this year on a refreshed curriculum which will achieve those review aims. I hope that noble lords will engage with that consultation, and I know that some are already working hard alongside the department to make sure that that curriculum is right. The noble lord Lord Wallace suggested that there was skepticism reported in the Daily Telegraph about the place of citizenship.
It of course wasn't just in the Telegraph, it was also from members of the party opposite, although I note a considerably more positive approach to citizenship from the noble lady Baroness Cash than we heard from some of her colleagues down at the other end of the house, particularly during their conference, where they argued that teaching children how to engage with our democracy is somehow politicizing the classroom and of course argued that they didn't want primary pupils to have the statutory content that we believe that they should have. They argued, and the noble lady Baroness Spielman isn't here for the debate this evening, but she has argued particularly for more focus on British identity.
But what makes us British and proud to be is our democracy, our rights, the rule of law, and our tolerance and belief in strong communities built on respect that rejects the divisiveness of much political discourse today. And I think the noble Lord, Lord Patten and others in pointing to events in France recently have identified some of the divisiveness that happens not just there, but that all of us need to respond to. Removing children's ability to explore those things through citizenship education doesn't protect our children, it leaves them open to misinformation and the forces that want to divide, not to unite our country. And by the way, I think as well the noble Lord, Lord Norton was, it is not the responsibility of schools directly is right, but adults and other public bodies, including the work of the government through the Defending Democracy Taskforce, needs to make sure that that approach is taken throughout people's lives as well. But as many have argued, and the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Peterborough amongst others, whilst we know that many schools already teach the subject well in ways that are engaging and meaningful for their pupils, we need to think more carefully and take action on how we implement the change in curriculum.
Even an improved statutory curriculum doesn't give schools everything that they need. The consultation will ask people to tell us what's needed to enable effective implementation. This could include expert resources or subject-specific support, not least as citizenship includes sensitive and fast-changing topics. And on that, I recognize that it is important for schools to be aware of their legal duties regarding impartiality and balanced treatment of political issues in the classroom. The existing non-statutory guidance on political impartiality provides clear and comprehensive guidance to help those working with and in schools to better understand these duties and how to strengthen their processes both in teaching about political issues and beyond the curriculum, and to give teachers the confidence to cover these topics effectively and appropriately.
But we will update this guidance if we have evidence that it is not sufficiently enabling this. And importantly, we will continue to work with the sector, including the Association for Citizenship Teaching, the Electoral Commission, with wider government departments and the range of organizations deeply committed to citizenship to consider the best possible package of support. We will welcome pilots to test and learn what works best. We will also provide adaptable, free digital lesson resources through Oak National Academy, and support will be available before first teaching begins. And here I come to the point made by my noble friend Lord Blunkett, who pushes us to introduce this more quickly.
He will know though that the changes to the citizenship curriculum sit within the much wider change to the national curriculum that we are intending to bring in in 2028. And of course that will enable citizenship to fit within what we hope will be increased opportunities for this type of learning as we streamline other elements of the curriculum as well. But of course he's right that the important provision, the important resources created by the Electoral Commission, and in fact the existing curriculum already provide important opportunities for schools to be preparing young people for a lower voting age. Also in relation to my noble friend Baroness Gill and the noble lady Baroness Paul, can I say I also believe that activity and civic engagement are important, which is why they will be an important element of our enrichment framework.
Having enough well-trained school teachers is fundamental to the citizenship reforms. That's why our curriculum plans represent a new citizenship requirement for primary schools, but it is positive that last year we achieved 128% of the overall postgraduate training target in primary. And we know citizenship is taught by a variety of secondary school teachers, but there are more than 3,000 more additional teachers in secondary and special schools now compared to the 2024 data. I do appreciate that we would benefit from a greater number of specialist citizenship teachers. The department reviews bursaries annually to take account of things like recruitment to date, forecast economic conditions and teacher need, and we'll be announcing a new package this autumn.
Several noble lords and the noble lady Baroness Barker raised the issue of Ofsted's inspection framework, which does now have a focus on ensuring schools provide a high-quality ambitious curriculum for all pupils. Ofsted evaluates citizenship largely within the personal development and well-being area, but their toolkit now explicitly recognizes the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. They, the strong standard for this area explicitly recognizes the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. In closing this debate, can I thank the noble lord Lord Norton and other speakers for their thoughtful and well-informed contributions. This is a pivotal moment for citizenship education.
We must seize the opportunity to strengthen the subject's content and status so that it inspires pupils' curiosity about our changing society and equips them with the skills and knowledge to contribute to democracy as critical, informed and active citizens. The importance of the subject demands that we work closely with experts to ensure that it is taught to the highest standards and that teachers have ongoing support and confidence to bring the subject to life in a meaningful and lasting way. I welcome my lords' insights into how we can do that well and look forward to further discussion in this house as that work continues.
Speaker 144
My lords, as we were not due to return to the bill until 20:37, I beg leave to move that the house do adjourn during pleasure until that point.
Speaker 143
The question is that the house adjourn during pleasure until 20:37. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
My Lords, I beg to move that the House be once more in committee upon the bill.
Speaker 143
The question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment in clause 12, amendment 70.
Not moved. Therefore amendment 71 will become the lead amendment for the next group. Amendment 71, Baroness Finn.
The Baroness Finn
My Lords, I rise to move the amendment 71 in the name of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie. As with his previous amendments on the definition of recklessness, this amendment seeks to include a definition of misleading on the face of the bill.
The reason for this inclusion is to address the current lack of clarity over its definition. The definition in this amendment comes from section 227 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which defines misleading as the omission of information. I emphasize that this definition is intended to be a starting point, and although it is not necessarily an exact fit for the bill, the purpose is to show that there is a potential solution for the current problem of lack of clarity. The definition should also include a reference to the inclusion of irrelevant information, but at this stage the purpose is to raise the issue with the noble lord the minister, the purpose of needing a proper clear definition, and we're open to discussion on the final wording. Turning to amendment 80, my right honorable friend Nick Timothy argued in the other place for the inclusion of the requirement for the Attorney General to institute or consent to any prosecution of the offense of misleading the public.
This is important and it is exactly what this amendment seeks to do. Of course, to mislead the public intentionally is not a good thing, and we do not deny, we certainly do not deny the existence of cover-ups and abuses in the past. But there is a risk that this offense could be used in such a way so as to curtail political debate. In order to prevent that from becoming the case, the inclusion of the barrier of the Attorney General's consent would ensure that these claims are not made with no basis, and instead they are only made when an issue is legitimate. I beg to move.
Speaker 145
Amendment proposed, clause 12, page 13, line 8, at end insert the words as printed on the marshal list.
Speaker 49
My lords, I have amendment 73 in this group. As we've just heard from the noble lady, the new offense of misleading the public must be set at an appropriately high hurdle and should only lead to prosecution in the most egregious cases. Nonetheless, it is crucial in pushing the culture change that is behind this whole bill. There are many offenses which require proof of actual harm to an individual or group before they're perpetrated, but there are many which do not. Drug supply offenses and more relevantly perverting the course of justice, these are examples of the latter.
And my suggestion is that this offense should not require a subsequent hurdle of proving harm. The inclusion of proof of harm in the clause 12 offense is, I suggest, unnecessary for similar reasons to those offenses regarding the administration of justice. But it would also lead to various egregious examples of misleading the public not falling within the current draft of the provision, or would make them impossible to prove in reality. One real-life example is a chief constable who published false crime figures. This was intended, my lords, to mislead the public, but I suggest it would be very difficult indeed to establish actual harm.
Recent revelations by my noble friend Lord Beamish regarding the nuclear test vets case indicate that he was misled by senior civil servants regarding a proposed compensation scheme, which in turn led to the public being misled. Again, this is a case which, should it fall within clause 12, would be very difficult to prove harm. The Prime Minister himself gave evidence to the infected blood inquiry that, as health secretary, he was misled by senior civil servants as to what the then government knew about contaminated blood products. This caused him innocently to make inaccurate statements to the public. These officials, I would suggest, ought to fall four-square within the offense, but the requirement to prove harm would make that difficult or impossible.
My Lords, there have been extremely misguided analyses of clause 12 in recent days in the media. To be clear, the new offense targets only the promulgation of false facts by public officials, anathema to their function and mission to act in the public interest. My amendment doesn't alter the high hurdle of intention or recklessness, however we land with the understandable discussion begun by the noble lady. But my amendment removes an unnecessary impediment to the offense working as intended in some of the most real and relevant cases. So I urge the committee to seriously consider removing the need to prove harm from an offense of dishonesty akin to other offenses that I've mentioned.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
Okay. I thank the noble and learned Lord for bringing forward these amendments, which present the opportunity for me to provide some clarifications on the points he's raised, sorry, the noble lady, the Baroness Finn. You have to check what you're reading, don't you? Amendment 71 would set a definition of misleading for the purpose of the offense of misleading the public that replicates the definition of misleading omissions from the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, as the noble lady said. We've not set out what misleading means in order to maintain its natural meaning and allow the offense to capture the types of behavior that would be usually regarded as misleading.
And clause 12 provides that an offense is committed where the act of an authority or official is misleading and seriously improper, where what may be seriously improper is set out. But I'm sure we will engage with Lord Keen and Lord Wolfson and perhaps also Baroness Finn, so we'll carry on the conversation then. Amendment 80 requires the consent of the Attorney General before a prosecution for the offenses of misleading the public may be brought. The bill provides that prosecution for the offense may only be brought by or with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Therefore, there is already scrutiny of the decision to prosecute provided for in the bill. The consent of the Attorney for the prosecution of offences is usually required where the offence involves national security or has some international element, for example, if there could be a bearing on international obligations or international terrorism. Given the nature of the offence of misleading the public, the government are of the view that requiring consent from the Director of Public Prosecutions is appropriate and would not meet the usual threshold to demand the consent of the Attorney. Turning to amendment 73, clause 1 of the bill clearly sets out that public authorities and officials are expected to act with candour, transparency and frankness at all times, but criminal sanctions should be reserved for the most serious cases. The condition that an act has to have caused or had the potential to cause harm will achieve this effect, but it will not be a bar to prosecution in those cases.
Let me try and explain why. Firstly, the definition of harm is broad. It includes physical harm, psychological harm, including distress and economic loss. This is a non-exhaustive list and can include other types of harm. The condition also includes harm or the potential for harm.
This offence does not require there to be proof that it has caused harm against an individual. In cases like Hillsborough and Horizon, my Lords, evidence of harm caused by cover-ups is clear and apparent. We have designed this offence with historic incidents of state failures in mind, where at a minimum potential distress could be identified and in many cases much more serious harm. The requirement for an act to have the potential to cause harm is a key condition to make sure the offence applies to serious cases only. The harm threshold ensures that the public, the police and prosecutors are able to distinguish between those actions that meet the threshold for criminal sanctions and those that should be dealt with through other routes, such as an organisation's complaints process or covered by other aspects of the law.
Speaker 49
I'm so grateful to my noble friend the Minister for giving way for a moment. In the example of the Chief Constable who deliberately doctors the crime statistics in order to boost his or her own success, how easy does my noble friend the Minister think it's going to be to prove actual or even potential harm?
Anthony Gerard Lemos
Frankly, I don't think to duck the issue at all, but I really think it would be wrong for me to comment on individual examples of that sort, but I've set out what I think the issue in principle is, yes.
Anderson
Let me try again without an individual example. When the public is misled, then the harm is to public trust in those who govern us. Does the Minister say that that harm is physical harm or psychological harm or economic loss? Because if it's none of those things, under the bill as it stands, there could be no prosecution.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
No, that's a non-exhaustive list, but I'm very happy to take that point away.
I'm not suggesting that those are the only tests of harm.
David Alton
My Lords, I'd like to pursue the point really being made by the noble Baroness Lady Chakrabarti, where she cited the point made by Lord Beamish earlier on about atomic test victims. The noble Lord the Minister said in reply to my remarks earlier today that he would write to me specifically about where the inquiries into the harm that might have been done to the atomic test victims by the misleading of Parliament when Tobias Ellwood told Parliament one thing which he had been told by his officials, which was subsequently shown to be wrong. Where does the blame lie there? And it's not about prosecution. It's what do you do then to remedy or rectify that harm or the damage that is done to the individuals involved?
And given that he was interviewed on, I think I gave the date, September the 2nd by Victoria Derbyshire on BBC, so this is in the public domain. This is not something that I'm making up as I go along.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
I think that we do have to take each case on its merits. But I think the government's view is that it is important to have this harm threshold to ensure that, as I'm about to go on to say, that well, let me carry on a bit and let's see how I go. But it is the nature of public life that it is not uncommon for public officials or office holders to be accused of being untruthful, sorry, when going about their daily tasks. The risk of undermining the offense itself if it is used to trigger police investigations into vexatious claims or engage in political lawfare, rather than for the grave examples of state cover-up that it was intended. I think that's the key point we're trying to drive at here, that if there are serious and harmful consequences, then there is a case for prosecution.
But if for other reasons people are being told that they've been not telling the truth and so on, then that isn't quite the same as what we would want the police and the prosecutors to be focusing on. The creation of an offense of this kind is a bold step. I'm sure noble Lords would agree with that. Hillsborough's families spoke of the importance of individual accountability, and we listened. It is clear from our engagement across the public sector that such a strong new measure will, and I say this to reassure noble Lords, as drafted and when properly implemented, and we will have a discussion as we've said about implementation, will have a serious and real deterrent effect.
And we are confident that it and every other measure in the bill will drive a culture of candor and truthfulness. I therefore request that the noble and learned Lord withdraws his amendment.
The Baroness Finn
I thank the noble Lord the Minister, and I'm very, very pleased with my upgrade to learned, so thank you. Anyway, I thank the noble Lord the Minister for his willingness to engage on the need, on the potential need for a definition of misleading on the face of the bill. More disappointing was his response about including Attorney General consent to the prosecution of misleading the public offense. But perhaps we can explore that further, and on that basis, I'm very happy to withdraw the amendment.
Speaker 143
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that amendment 71 be withdrawn?
The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 72, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
The amendments in the previous group proposed some changes to what an offense for misleading the public. This group moves to the who and the how in an official misleading the public. I've laid amendment 72 and amendment 77 in this group. My lords, in 1989, in his interim report on the Hillsborough disaster, Lord Justice Taylor made it clear that although many fans had been drinking, he unequivocally stated that most of them were, quote, "not drunk, nor even the worse for drink", end quote. He concluded that they formed an exacerbating factor and that police seeking to rationalize their loss of control overestimated the element of drunkenness in the crowd.
However, the statements by the police to the press at the time said that they believed that it was the behavior of the fans, especially those who were drunk and violent, that was the cause of the tragedy. And many of the press believed them, with Liverpool fans carrying the blame even when Lord Taylor had contradicted this view. It took a quarter of a century later for the report of the Hillsborough Independent Panel, which noted in its report of September 2012 that Lord Justice Taylor was clear that Chief Superintendent Duckenfield was untruthful to Mr. Kelly, the chief executive of the FA, about the inrush of fans forcing open a gate. The police led press to believe that much worse had happened. Lord Taylor called it a vilification of the fans.
He had not found one single witness to support any of these allegations. These lies were believed by many in the press, some of whom began decades of negative stories about the Liverpool fans that day. The fans, their families, and the city of Liverpool have spent years trying to expose the truth. They are extraordinary. The Hillsborough Independent Panel is a testament to their fortitude.
But sadly, my lords, they are not alone. Officials in the Post Office lied to the press about some of the Horizon postmasters and about the problems with the Horizon system. In infected blood, doctors and Department of Health officials lied for decades about the true risks of using blood from America and how serious the consequences would be for people, including to the press. And that, my lords, is why I've laid amendment 72. In the United Kingdom, the press and publishers are still mostly thought to be reliable sources of information for their readers.
Victims of all three of these tragedies could not even begin to recover while these lies persisted. And the consequence of these lies, in the case of postmasters' court cases and being exposed as criminals, in the case of those who caught HIV and developed AIDS from infected blood, many were treated as pariahs in the difficult AIDS era. This bill creates other offenses, but for some reason ignores the role of giving misleading information to journalists or news publishers, and this amendment attempts to rectify this. My lords, clause 12 is important. As we've discussed in this bill, the duty of candor needs both carrots and sticks.
Clause 12 sets out the key ground rules relating to misleading the public. A public official or a public authority intentionally misleading the public or is reckless as to whether their act will do so or not. And this is critical to ensuring that the duty of candor works. The stick is the offense for which there are definite legal consequences.
But there is a carrot in this too, my Lords. All public authorities and any other bodies training their officials would have to ensure that they all understand the guardrails about misleading the public and that improper behaviour will have consequences, especially when talking to the media and journalists. To those who say that clause 12 goes too far, I respond by saying that the family of a Hillsborough victim, whose family member was not just killed that day, but their reputation was unjustly trashed because of police officers intentionally misleading the press, clause 12 would rectify that from happening in the future, and there would be consequences if a public official or a public organisation deliberately misled the press. My Lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 145
Amendment proposed, clause 12, page 13, line 8, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Faulkner
My Lords, I wish to intervene very briefly on this particular amendment. But before I move, I want to describe my motivation for this intervention. Let me be clear that my deepest sympathy goes out to all of those affected by the appalling examples of dishonesty and cover-ups that have led to the need for this bill, and which have just been referenced by the noble lady Baroness Brinton. In seeking to ask probing amendments of government, I'm merely doing my job as a member of this place in trying to improve legislation and to make it more workable in a practical sense. No one doing their job should face innuendo that they're acting in bad faith, as some campaigners may be well prone to suggest.
Now to turn to amendment 72, I of course accept all the examples given by Baroness Brinton, and I have my own catalogue of experiences of appearing in the press in misleading actions where misleading actions were attributed to me, or indeed pure lies were attributed to me. I've spoken to more defamation lawyers than I ever thought I would need to speak to in my life, but I took no action for those libels as I saw them. And the reason for that is that I believe in an independent press, which is usually in our country, and I think we have fairly high standards, is an ethical press, well-regulated, and I'm very glad that I've spoken before the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, sitting here in front of me, my noble friend. It is profoundly important in drafting legislation that we're aware of Article 10 rights for public officials as much as for any other body. Public officials do not give up their Article 10 rights when they wear their lanyard and come into work.
And I would argue that the press in being, shall we say, credulous to accept things that may be perhaps a bit improbable, were things that happened far more frequently in the past than they happen today, because proprietors, the law, and journalists themselves, in my view, are rather more ethical than they were 45 years ago. And on that basis, I'd be very, very reluctant to see an amendment of this sort enter this particular bill, whereby people would face criminal sanctions for speaking to journalists about things that they may in good or bad faith consider to have happened, and we've got to respect that in terms of press freedoms.
Edward Faulks
My Lords, I don't for a moment dispute the right of this government to bring forward legislation imposing a duty of candour.
It was in their manifesto and in any event there's general agreement across parties that public authorities and public officials should be candid. And the need for this has been graphically illustrated by Hillsborough, the Post Office and many other scandals. But the requirement for the creation of a criminal offence such as we see in clause 12 of the bill was not in the manifesto. But even if it had been, it does not relieve your Lordships' House of the task of scrutinising this legislation, particularly a clause which has such a wide potential scope. Clause 12, just a moment ago described by the noble Lord the Minister as a bold step, creates an offence of misleading the public by public officials.
It is a free-standing criminal offence. On conviction, a defendant could face up to two years' imprisonment. A public authority includes a Minister of the Crown and a government department, as well as the devolved administrations, the armed forces, police forces, local authorities, NHS bodies, schools and any other body with functions of a public nature. A public official, which appears in this context to include those who work for a school, is anyone who works for or holds office under such a body. My first question to the Minister is this: can he help with quite how many public officials would be caught by this definition so as to render them potentially liable to conviction of a serious offence?
We heard from the noble Lady Baroness Fleet of something like six million civil servants, but there are many others who would classify themselves as public officials and we have a significantly large public sector in this country. My second question is this: what sort of behaviour is intended to be caught by this clause which would not be captured by the provisions of the bill, clauses 13, 14, 17 and 18, or indeed by the general criminal law? Examples would help. I looked at the explanatory notes and one of the examples was given as, quote, "a department covering up the harmfulness of a policy". Well, that with respect seems to describe what government is regularly accused of doing in the rough and tumble of politics, and yet it could apparently be a criminal offence.
The clause is, I suggest, extremely vague, which of itself gives rise to rule of law objections. Misleading, as we've already heard, is a tricky word. When is a political statement which tends to emphasise positive rather than negative facts, or vice versa depending on the source, to be regarded as misleading? Seriously improper is defined, but it includes not only an act of concealment but also obfuscation.
What is or is not obfuscation, very difficult to say. There is a defense to which I think the noble lady Baroness Levitt is going to address the House, which is supposed to provide some form of defense. I'm not at the moment convinced how satisfactory it is. A prosecution will only proceed with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions or the Attorney General if the Conservative front bench would have its way. Is this a sufficient safeguard?
I'm not seeking to impugn the integrity of any DPP, but is he or she, aren't they going to have to take some very difficult, almost political decisions? We know that prosecuting authorities can be judicially reviewed and that mischievous people can attempt prosecutions for political reasons. So my provisional view is that this offense, although motivated by the best motives, is a big leap forward and one which renders people potentially vulnerable to prosecution who I don't think should be intended to be such a victim. And of course, many people might be prosecuted and albeit they may be acquitted, they still have to go through the process of being subjected to the criminal justice system. That's the first point.
But the second point is, and perhaps it's more important the second point, what effect will this particular provision have on public administration? May I recommend the Policy Exchange document published last week on the bill, and in particular the foreword by the noble Lord Lord Butler, who knows a great deal about public administration. The authors of the paper draw comparisons between the now much regretted Freedom of Information Act 2000 and this particular piece of legislation. I looked to see what the periodical Local Government Lawyer, probably not a publication terribly familiar to your Lordships, might say about this particular provision, section 12, clause 12. It's not generally very politically contentious, but it's there to guide local governments as to potential legal vulnerabilities.
And it said this of the bill. The breadth of offenses will likely require existing codes of conduct, employee policies, protocols and training materials to be revised. Anti-corruption measures will be familiar in many public bodies, but may not capture the full range of behaviors that will be criminalized by clause 12. That sounds like an absolute avalanche of legal intrusion into the way that public authorities will have to operate in the future. If the effect of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 was supposed to change the culture of secrecy, it has, in many people's view, made people reluctant to commit frank views to paper at all.
In fact, many feel it has had the opposite effect to that which was intended and hasn't made for better government. Clause 12 similarly runs the risk of making officials much more reluctant to put provisional or controversial views on paper.
Decisions may be taken only in small groups. Notes may well be taken very much with the prospect of being scrutinized. We heard earlier in debates about the the problem of people potentially deleting notes or deleting digital footprints. There may not be anything to delete if this becomes law. Lawyers will be involved, I suggest, as I've already indicated.
And lawyers don't always help make good decisions, whatever their intentions. And it may well be that the number of people involved in making decisions feel they'd better not write anything at all. Just to reassure the whips on the front bench, I'm not intending to divide the House over this issue. But I am seeking to probe the government as to how this is going to work. And indeed, I had some sympathy with the amendment spoken to by the noble lady Baroness Chakrabarti, the requirement for harm.
This is a step into the unknown, a step into the unknown which I'm unconvinced is going to be satisfactory. In fact, I fear for the worst.
Young
My Lords, I rise to move amendment 76 in my name and that of the noble Baroness Lady Fox of Buckley. And I declare my interest as the General Secretary of the Free Speech Union. Before I come to my amendment, just with reference to amendment 72, my concern is that it would make it much harder for journalists and public officials to communicate with each other in confidence. I know from my own experience as a journalist that quite often public officials, politicians, ministers will add a bit of top spin to the information they're providing you with. And you learn to take that into account and you counterbalance it by talking to their political opponents or to people who disagree with them.
And it's in the end you come to a mature, informed decision. My worry is that if it becomes a criminal offense for a public official to mislead a journalist, that will make it much harder to get public officials to talk to journalists. And there's one quirk in the amendment whereby the criminal offense would only apply to public officials who mislead journalists working for recognized news publishers. That would create a perverse incentive for public officials to only communicate in confidence with unrecognized news publishers, knowing that they wouldn't be liable for prosecution if whatever they told them was then published. But unrecognized news publishers would presumably do less checking, be less scrupulous about simply regurgitating whatever misleading things they've been told by public officials.
So for a variety of reasons, I think amendment 72 would be unwise. I share the reservations of the noble Lord Lord Faulks and the noble Baroness Lady Falkner about clause 12. And in particular, my concern is that it will have a chilling effect, preventing public officials from contributing to debates for fear of prosecution. The explanatory notes to the bill say that the offense is not intended to stifle public debate or prevent people from expressing opinions. My amendment simply asks the government to put that assurance on the face of the bill.
Why does that matter? Because explanatory notes are not law and public bodies are adept at ignoring them. Take the Equality Act 2010. The explanatory notes to section 26 on harassment say that courts and tribunals "will continue to be required to balance competing rights" and it names freedom of expression and academic freedom as two of those competing rights. Yet in the Free Speech Union's experience stretching to over 7,000 cases, that balancing exercise is often missing from the harassment policies of employers, universities and public bodies.
This free speech protection was written into the notes of the Equality Act but not the act itself and has often been overlooked as a consequence. Nor is the line between a false statement and an opinion always easy to draw. That's not just my view. It's the view of a review commissioned by the Government Office for Science and published in May. Its authors are not skeptics about the dangers of misinformation, far from it.
Yet they acknowledge that "false and misleading information is sometimes hard to differentiate clearly from legitimate opinion". In other words, one person's false and misleading information is another person's legitimate opinion. Let me give an example. Recently the Prime Minister told the Rest is Politics podcast that he had asked his officials if there had been Russian interference in the 2016 EU referendum and had received "the clear answer that yes there was". Some will regard that as misleading.
In the other place, the leader of the opposition said, "You can't fight misinformation with misinformation". Others, including many in this house, will no doubt regard it as a legitimate opinion. If my amendment is not accepted, the police would have to decide whether a complained of statement was one or the other. Surely we don't want the police or indeed the Crown Prosecution Service spending hours parsing the contributions of ministers to political debates to determine whether they're misinformation or legitimate expressions of opinion. The Prime Minister's remarks on the Rest is Politics are an example of "unprepared comments made by ministers during political interviews" which according to the explanatory notes "should be viewed differently to a formal statement made by the minister and released through a government department".
To protect ministers, including Prime Ministers, from being investigated by the police following the receipt of politically motivated complaints, those words should be included on the face of the bill. That brings me to vexatious complaints more generally. There are two routes by which clause 12 could be turned against an honest official and the bill safeguards, the bill's safeguard addresses only one of them and does that inadequately. The first is private prosecution. In 2019 a private prosecutor persuaded a district judge to issue a summons against Boris Johnson for misconduct in public office over claims he made during the referendum campaign before the High Court eventually quashed it.
To its credit, the government has made some efforts to close that door. Schedule 3 provides the proceedings, provides that proceedings under clause 12 may be brought only by or with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions. But is that a strong enough safeguard? The current DPP's term is due to expire in October 2028, which means a Labour-appointed DPP could be in office when there is a change of government. Who's to say that DPP would not consent to a private prosecution brought against a Conservative or Reform minister in 2029?
Speaker 151
As my noble friend Lord Faulks said, the decision would in many cases be a political decision, not a straightforwardly legal decision. It is for that reason that I support amendment 80, which would at least require the consent of the Attorney General before a prosecution could proceed. The second route is a complaint to the police and here a consent requirement offers no protection at all.
Young
It applies only when proceedings are instituted. Everything before that, from the complaint and the investigation to the interview under caution, happens without any prosecutor being involved. Section 25 of the Prosecution of Offences Act 1985 even provides that a consent requirement does not prevent a suspect being arrested. We know at the Free Speech Union from the history of non-crime hate incidents how readily the police will record and pursue complaints, in some cases arrest the people complained of, that should never have troubled them. For the person on the receiving end, the investigation is the punishment, whatever a prosecutor eventually decides.
Neither DPP consent nor Attorney General consent can prevent that. Amendment 76 goes some way to addressing this problem. It provides that an act is not seriously improper if it consists of the expression of an opinion or a good faith contribution to a debate on a matter of public interest. That protection falls away where the person knowingly asserts a statement of fact they know to be false, so the liar gets no shelter. What's protected is honest opinion and good faith argument.
By including those protections on the face of the bill, my amendment gives the police a clear basis to turn a vexatious, politically motivated complaint away at the outset. The case is stronger still in light of amendment 78 and 79, tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Lawit. They would replace the reasonable excuse defense with a narrower public interest defense and place the burden of proving it on the defendant. If the offense is going to be made easier to make out, and I don't think it should obviously, the line between opinion and falsehood must be drawn clearly at the outset. If the minister says the clause would never be used in this way, there is no cost in accepting this amendment.
If there is a risk of expressions of opinion being mischaracterized as misinformation, and the Government Office for Science's paper on misinformation suggests that there is, this House should shut it down now, thereby nipping thousands of vexatious complaints in the bud. My Lords, a law against misleading the public should not itself mislead the public about where the boundaries of lawful speech lie by including free speech safeguards in the explanatory notes but not in the bill itself.
Anderson
My Lords, the noble Lord Faulks and the noble Lord Young make a serious point and one that I don't think can simply be brushed away. The strongest answer to it, as it seems to me, is or ought to be the condition in subsection 3A that to be a criminal offense, in addition to the other criteria being satisfied, the act has to involve dishonesty that was significant or repeated. Now traditionally, of course, in our courts, dishonesty is left for the jury to decide in the light of their experience of everyday life. But this bill seeks to define a little bit what is meant by dishonesty. And it says whether by means of falsehood, concealment, obfuscation, or otherwise.
And what I'd like to suggest very briefly to the minister is a small change to this bill that might go some way towards immunizing it or protecting it from the sort of criticisms that you've just heard so eloquently expressed. We know from the way those words are drafted that dishonesty must go broader than merely a falsehood and broader also than a concealment because otherwise you wouldn't need any other words. That's the first point. And the second point is the word that is chosen, this word obfuscation. I'm afraid my iPhone subscription takes me no further than the Cambridge Dictionary, but that tells me to obfuscate means to make something less clear and harder to understand, especially intentionally.
Well, anyone reading that obfuscation is a form of dishonesty might be minded to take a very broad view of what dishonesty means, a view that obviously goes beyond merely the lie direct or the concealment of the truth. And seeing that word obfuscation there does make me a little worried that the learned lords have a point when they speak of the chilling effect and when they speak of the unpredictable extent of this offense. So although I'm afraid I haven't got an amendment down to remove that word obfuscation, I do suggest that if there're going to be discussions on this before report stage, perhaps it might be something we should all bear in mind.
Claire Fox
My lords, there's been some very important points made and I am very sympathetic to the arguments put forward by the noble lord Lord Fox. I keep thinking to myself that there's going to be unintended consequences of this. And it's difficult because this is a very, and I don't say this in a sarcastic way, this is a very worthy, noble bill and I don't want to betray its intentions. But I fear that if we don't challenge it and scrutinize it properly, it will itself betray what it's trying to do by creating a whole new set of problems. And the noble lord and learned lord Carlyle when at the last time we had committee raised some very important points about the dangers of over-criminalization and that that could have damaging outcomes too.
And it seems to me that clause 12 fits very much into that spectrum. I also think that I have a lot of sympathy with the criticisms that the noble lord Young made about amendment 72 and providing misleading information to the press and how that could be used or interpreted. Inasmuch as the press is a valuable way that we can hold power to account, it is very important that we don't inadvertently do anything that stops the press getting hold of some of the more difficult stories. And people might not intend to mislead, I mean we can think of malevolent ways that the press can be told lies about people, but it's also the case that things can be said in good faith to the press. And we want to encourage, I would have thought, more whistleblowing to the media, not less, if we're going to shine a light on wrongdoing in society.
I actually put my name down, and maybe this will explain I've got some hesitancy here, I put my name down on amendment 74, which is that a civil servant misleading a minister, that that would be included as an offense. And in a way I was trying to respond to the notion of a kind of two-tier issue.
I could see that there are documented cases existing in which civil servants and senior officials have provided incomplete, inaccurate, and misleading information to ministers or have kept key facts from them. We're aware of this, and although there is a civil service code which requires honest and impartial advice and supposedly prohibits deliberate withholding relevant information from ministers, it might seem extreme that we now say that this should be brought into the law and create a legal offence about it. But that's in a way what this whole bill's going to do. I'm a bit torn on this because, you know, everything from the UK Post Office Horizon IT scandal where we found out that, or certainly in the inquiry, ministers told that officials had misled them or failed to provide accurate, impartial advice. There's been accusations that ministers were misled on everything from the scale of backlogs of asylum and immigration cases to the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan.
And that's been documented in everything from the Foreign Affairs Committee and so on. And to quote the one of those, it was at best intentionally evasive and often deliberately misleading, to use the quote that was used. And I think that's an atrocious situation because I don't want to let ministers off the hook and I don't want to kind of get down, get into a situation of a kind of she blamed the blob. But I have myself experienced situations in which ministers have read out advice, as it happens, in particular in relation to the issues of sex and gender where their interpretation of the Equality Act 2010 I challenged, and I was, and the minister read out information which was actually inaccurate and misleading. And I felt that this was driven by a more ideological intervention at some other stage because when I challenged the minister, they were just reading out what they'd been given.
Obviously, the Supreme Court might have clarified it, but the law was the law before the Supreme Court clarified what the law was. And the ministers had been given bad advice, and yet it was difficult to challenge that. So that was kind of what had made me consider taking this seriously. But this is where I'm now going to completely contradict myself because having put my name on that amendment, I've sort of changed my mind, which is a bit unhelpful, but it might help explain where why I've ended up somewhere else, which is I suddenly dawned on me that actually those officials could well claim that they were simply using good faith judgment to advise the minister. They weren't trying to actively mislead, even though I have some sympathy with the notion that quite a lot of the civil service has been overly ideological and too partial on some highly contentious issues.
What about if they give the advice on a contested area in good faith, will they be in scope of committing an offence? And that's what leads me to the concerns that this bill could inadvertently not lead to candour of speech at all, but to the chilling of speech, which is why I absolutely support amendment 76 in the name of the noble Lord Young of Cookham.
The noble Lord Lord Wolfson of Tredegar earlier noted in an earlier grouping the dangers of criminalising breaches of a code of conduct. And every time I hear different aspects about this bill, it suddenly dawns on me that at this rate no one will say anything ever for fear of criminal consequences, for the fear of a criminal liability. And to quote the noble Lord Lord Wolfson, he said where codes go, the lawyers will certainly follow. And all I can see in this bill is more and more lawyers all over the place. And I think that we heard that from the noble Lord Foulkes.
And I thought that the example of freedom of information was a perfect example of that. I remember meeting some friends who basically said, oh, we don't write anything down now. And I thought, well, that's hardly a satisfactory situation. And I feel that that's something that could happen now. I'm worried that these provisions in clause 12 will be weaponised and that the criminalisation of misleading the public will become something that is used to both litigious point the finger at other people and just seriously risks having a chilling impact on political disagreement or debate or so on.
If I could just give one example and then I'll finish. In the early discussions on the, if you can imagine that we didn't know anything, in the early discussions, having spoken to people who were involved in the worries that they had about gangs of people raping and sexually abusing young children, young women in northern towns. Somebody like Ann Cryer MP, who's one of my heroines from that time, raised the issue, I think it was 2003, 2004, for which she was called a racist. I met some people after that who thought that there was criminal gangs operating in the school where they taught and some other people who were social workers who feared that they knew that there was an organised gang going on. They were public officials.
Now they didn't necessarily all speak out then for fear of being accused of Islamophobia or accused of racism following on from what had happened to Ann Cryer, for goodness sake, named a racist when she was anything but. But she, but they now could be in the situation where they wouldn't speak out because they could be criminally liable if they were wrong because they were speculating. They weren't trying to mislead, they would be trying to say, do you think there could be? So we want our public officials to speak freely, to be able to say what if this is the case, what do you think, could it be that? And I just am concerned that at this rate they could fear that they will be criminalised for some of the things that they will say.
And so I do not want officials to water down the advice that they give public officials on contested areas for fear of criminalisation. And I don't want public officials to start biting their tongue and being frightened to say anything in case they get accused of misleading the public when they're trying to actually on behalf of the public raise matters in good faith. And if there's nothing to concern ourselves and the government say don't worry about it, then that's absolutely fine, put it on the face of the bill and that will be a reassurance enough for me.
Faulkner
My Lords, because so many speakers in the debate on this amendment have mentioned the Freedom of Information Act, I just wanted to make one or two observations to do with that act.
And the most important one, I think, is that despite all of the evidence provided in that Policy Exchange report, Legislating for Candour, from Prime Ministers and all sorts of other people, at least the Freedom of Information Act and the deep concern I think we've heard across committee is that this will turn into another example of that kind of act which has in fact reduced candour rather than improving accountability. It actually makes public servants so cautious of what they might say that little is said orally that could be repeated in written notes. But at least in the FOIA, you have a section 36 exemption which applies to material relating to the conduciveness of good policy making. And that is used frequently by all sorts of public bodies. But in this case, in this bill and in clause 12, that section 36 exemption would not apply, which is one of the reasons that I think that the entire clause 12 really needs to be taken out of this bill.
And I agree with much of what Lord Young said in his arguments today. I was particularly mindful of that podcast given recently by the Prime Minister about Russian interference. And I'm very glad he raised it. I was going to raise it myself when I came to discuss the concerns in this bill. But I think when you have the use of language such as tests of knowing or ought to have known, seriously improper defined only by reference to subclauses where you depart significantly from what is to be expected in the proper exercise of the person's functions as a public authority or public official, and of course the issues to do with harm and obfuscation raised by Lord Anderson, I expect at report that there will be quite a lot to contemplate in terms of the deleteriousness of this clause and the impact it might have on public discourse and freedom of expression.
And I hope the Minister will be open to having deep and substantive conversations with regard to this.
Alison Frances Josephine Levitt
My Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 78 and 79 in my name. These amendments concern the defence to the new offence of misleading the public created by clause 12, and they should be considered together with amendments 85, 86, 88 and 89, which fall within the next group, because they raise the same issues in relation to the offences created by clauses 13 and 14. My Lords, these amendments matter because they determine whether these new offences provide an effective means of enforcing accountability, or whether in practice they may prove so difficult to enforce that they prove to be nothing more than a paper tiger. My amendments propose two changes in relation to all three of the new offences. First, they replace the defence of reasonable excuse with the defence that the defendant was acting in the public interest.
Secondly, they place the burden on the defendant to establish the defence. The starting point is that all three of these new offences are serious ones. Two of the three replace the old common law offence of misconduct in public office, and all three are directed at conduct that undermines confidence in public administration and erodes trust in those who hold public office.
If Parliament is creating offences of this kind, the defence should be clear, objective, and appropriately limited. So the first question: why is public interest a better option than reasonable excuse? The concern is that the defence of reasonable excuse risks being both too broad in scope and too uncertain in its application. When the Law Commission recommended the abolition of the common law offence of misconduct in public office, it recommended a public interest defence, not a reasonable excuse defence. The distinction is important.
A public interest defence asks not merely whether the office holder can explain their actions, but whether those actions were genuinely justified in the interest of the public they serve. A person may well believe that their conduct was administratively convenient, politically expedient, or justified because it protected their institution, be that institution be the civil service, the police, or the security services. But none of those things necessarily means that what they did was in the public interest. My Lord, I would suggest it's self-evident that most public officials who commit these kinds of crimes don't set out deliberately to commit an offence. They may believe that they're being pragmatic, they're protecting their organisation, or they're responding to straitened finances or other difficult circumstances.
In their own minds, they may think that what they have done is entirely reasonable. But that doesn't help the victims, and that is not the same thing as acting in the public interest. Imagine a prison governor who decides to reduce the number of suicide watches in order to save money. The governor may argue that financial pressures provided a reasonable excuse for that decision. And to decide whether that's right or not, a jury would have to consider arguments about competing priorities, budgets, judgments, and so forth.
But a public interest defence asks a much clearer question: was it truly in the public interest to expose vulnerable prisoners to greater risk in order to save money? Which question do your Lordships believe that the victims and survivors whose experiences provide the impetus for this bill would think is more important? A public interest defence is not unusual. There are many other examples to be found in the criminal law. For example, section four of the Obscene Publications Act contains a defence that publication of the article in question was justified as being for the public good.
In the context, forgive me, of all three of the offences created by this bill, a public interest defence would continue to safeguard those who require protection, particularly whistleblowers acting to expose wrongdoing. What it would not do is to permit broad and subjective explanations to be advanced for conduct that's fallen below the standard that society requires of a public officer. Which brings me to the second issue: who should bear the burden of proof? This was explicitly committed considered by the Law Commission, who considered that doing this, putting the burden on the prosecution, could create significant practical difficulties in proving these offences. Because in many cases, the facts underlying the defence will be known mainly or possibly exclusively by the defendant.
A defendant may wish to say that they acted on particular information, received particular advice, held a particular belief, or were motivated by a particular public interest concern. And yet it would be for the prosecution to disprove those assertions. The Law Commission specifically cautioned against this, and it considered that requiring the prosecution to disprove such matters could impose unrealistic evidential burdens and in some cases require prosecutors to prove the non-existence of facts.
These amendments address that problem in a straightforward and proportionate way. If a defendant wishes to rely upon the defense that they acted in the public interest, then the burden of establishing it falls upon them, but only to the civil standard. This is not unusual and nor is it unfair. It's not unfair because the prosecution would still have to prove every element of the offense beyond reasonable doubt and the presumption of innocence remains intact. And the Law Commission concluded that such an approach would be compatible with Article 6 of the European Convention.
It's not unusual because Parliament frequently adopts this approach where the relevant facts are particularly within the defendant's own knowledge. So, for example, a person charged with possessing a bladed article in a public place must prove that they had good reason or lawful authority for having it. The burden is upon them because only they will know why they had the knife with them. There are many other examples, including the defenses created by the Bribery Act, which put the burden of proof on the defendant. And the comparison with the Bribery Act exposes another oddity about these defenses.
Clause 12 6 A, which mirrors section 13 of the Bribery Act, does in fact place the burden of proof on the defendant. Yet clause 12 6 B places the burden on the prosecution. No explanation has been given for why two statutory defenses appearing side by side in the same clause have different burdens of proof. The government, my suggestion, ought to explain to victims and the wider public why it has chosen a route which the Law Commission explicitly rejected as making these offenses too difficult to enforce. After all, the explanatory notes to the bill say that its provisions are in line with the Law Commission's recommendations.
That is simply not correct in relation to these defenses to these three offenses. This matters because we need to be sure that these offenses are capable of practical enforcement. After all, the victims and the survivors deserve no less.
David Alton
My Lords, I think the committee stage of this bill is a very good illustration in the context of the speech we've just heard from the noble Baroness, Baroness Levitt, about why we need to go into the granular detail and why we need to look at what the implications may be. This touches on what the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, and the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, were talking about as well, how a bill like this could potentially have a chilling effect and why we've got to ensure that it does not. But I was struck at the contrast between, for instance, the speech of the noble Baroness, Baroness Brinton, who reminded us of how the media became involved in telling falsehoods about what happened at Hillsborough, and yet, by contrast, the role that the media can often have in being in the vanguard in exposing truth. So it doesn't always fall one way or the other. I was thinking as I was sitting here that I used to share this bench sometimes with Lord Armstrong, who as Robert Armstrong, of course, went to the Spycatcher trial in Australia and used that very telling phrase about being economical with the truth.
A far cry from Ben Jonson, who said, "Stand for truth, it's enough." But this bill, I think, is seeking to do that. It is about finding the truth, getting to the heart of the matter, and doing what we can to put untruthful remarks, whether they're made by the media or indeed whether they're made by officials or made even by politicians or human rights organizations or anybody who's a campaigner, whoever it may be. Baroness Faulkner was complaining earlier on about the role that some campaigners can have in sometimes criticizing members of both houses. I think part of this is the give and take of public life and politics, but it can go too far.
And we've then got to guard against things like cancel culture that try to stop proper debate. So it is good that we're examining these questions in this kind of detail. I want to specifically support amendment 74 being moved by the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson. We'll be have yet to hear from him his specific reasons for this amendment, but it touches on something I raised earlier in an amendment that preceded this, but also during my own remarks earlier today about atomic test victims. I've taken the trouble to go back to the debate of the 19th of December 1984 in which I participated, where I said that the document, we were talking about documents that had been concealed, gives the lie to the suggestion that servicemen were properly clothed or that proper precautions were taken.
This is in the context of ex-servicemen who were at Christmas Island or Maralinga being deliberately, it was said, exposed to the effects of radiation to test how good the the protections were or how flimsy they might be. And I said in the house, one paragraph describes what the army set out to do in the test. It's a Ministry of Defence document which was top secret. It reads, quotes, the army must discover the detailed effects of various types of explosion on equipment, stores and men with and without various types of protection, men with and without various types of protection. So the men who were to be involved in the atomic explosions were to be exposed to the effects of radiation in order to discover what the effects would be on them.
Now that is the very issue that is still being argued about as recently as September the 2nd. I referred to it earlier, the BBC Newsnight programme where Victoria Derbyshire, doing her job in the media, cross-examined the veterans minister, former veterans minister Tobias Ellwood, who said he had misled Parliament because he had been deliberately misled by officials. These are really serious charges. Now I'm not suggesting that someone should be prosecuted, but given the harms test that we were discussing earlier on, I would plead again with the minister to take a look at this particular case and say what it is that we should be doing in those kind of circumstances, what difference would this bill make? And if it would make no difference, then I think we've failed one of its tests.
Now the other brief remark I want to make is about clause 12 itself. And I don't accuse the noble Baroness or indeed my my noble friend Lord Faulks of in in any way acting in bad faith, which I think was the phrase that the noble Baroness used earlier on. Of course I don't think that they've acted in bad faith. They have absolute right to test amendments, but I would urge them to think very carefully before moving something as substantive as a clause stand part to remove a whole clause from this bill. Because when you look at clause 12, it sets out the offence of misleading the public, which is fundamental to this bill.
And I can only imagine the sense of bewilderment, perhaps even betrayal amongst Hillsborough families who've worked so hard, tirelessly for 37 years for a law to tackle the lack of accountability and injustice which characterised their experience. But as we've heard repeatedly, many others have been denied justice and truth by a system which has favoured institutions and the powerful. My Lords, if this clause were to be removed, it would represent a continuation... Yes, of course.
Faulkner
Because he's very specifically alluded to to something that I said. And it is this, that we all understand the commitment made by the government in their 2024 manifesto. And I don't think there's anyone in this house who wouldn't wish to abide by that commitment.
Lady Fox referred to it as a noble bill. And I think that sentiment is widely shared. That the things that have gone wrong in the past should not have happened under any circumstance at all. And that the circumstance of them were shocking, which is why we are here now, and reprehensible. But to go back repeatedly to the noble lord has just spoken about Christmas Island and radiation and so on.
Events of old.
Speaker 155
Apologies to noble baroness, but intervention should be short and ask a specific question.
Faulkner
So I would say to the noble lord that when he reminds us, when he's wishing to remind us that this all relates to those events of the past, will he accept, and here is my question, that as a whole, British civil servants and the British state does not set out day to day to harm people. They set out to do a job in good faith. And the implication of some of the debates that we've heard is that they don't do that and they actually set out intentionally to harm. Will he accept that?
David Alton
No, I don't accept that. And I don't think the noble baroness could have been listening to what I had to say earlier on today about the deliberate changes that were made for instance to police notebooks to tell the opposite of what had actually taken place. I don't think she's listened to what I had to say about the 20,000 ex-servicemen, some of whom are still alive, who were exposed to radiation in these tests. The families who were involved at Hillsborough, many of them who are alive today still mourn the deaths of their loved ones. If she heard what I had to say earlier today in relation to one of my amendments, she would know that the noble lord, Lord Lymos, and indeed the noble baroness, Baroness Levitt, spent a lot of time with one of those families today talking to the sister and to the mother of someone who lived for more than three decades before he became the 97th victim because he had been crushed at Hillsborough.
So these aren't theoretical issues. They're not abstract issues. They're issues that have to be settled by Parliament. And I think that this bill seeks to do that. And if it weren't for our Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, who waived the 30-year rule when he was culture secretary back in 2009, 450,000 pages of previously withheld documents would not have become public and we wouldn't, I doubt, be here today.
Let me end by reminding the noble baroness of the title of the report of the Bishop of Liverpool. It was called The Patronising Disposition of Unaccountable Power. The title of that report, I think, says everything that this house needs to hear about how we can be perceived outside. If we were to lobotomise this bill by removing the whole of clause 12, which is after all what a clause stand part amendment seeks to do, I don't regard that as trying to look at the granular detail or provide improvements to the bill. I think it would be very destructive indeed.
Jonathan Marks
Lords, in this group I don't propose to add to anything that was said by my noble friend Baroness Brinton as to why clause 12 is important and moving her amendments. It does seem to me that there is an answer to the stand part amendment moved by the noble lord, Lord Faulks, and the noble baroness, Lady Fox, and to some of the concerns expressed by Lord Young of Acton and Baroness Fox of Buckley. Which is that this offence is on the face of the bill confined to serious cases. And it involves and has to involve serious impropriety.
That's the first safeguard. The second safeguard is the consent of the Attorney General, the is a the consent of the DPP or of the Attorney General. It's the DPP at the moment, the conservative amendment is trying to make it the Attorney General. For my part, either consent is a safeguard and a serious safeguard. And I do not believe that it is likely that this bill will ever be used in the in a case that is frivolous or in a case that is simply trying to stifle free speech.
I do however agree with the noble Lord Lord Anderson that the inclusion of obfuscation as an indication of serious impropriety is bordering on the absurd, not simply because it is not easy to avoid obfuscating the meaning of the word obfuscation, but also because it is not a very serious test. As to the noble Lord Lord Young, there is much of what he said which I cannot agree with. Nevertheless, he was speaking to amendment 76 and the drafting of amendment 76 is very specific and I would suggest is not offensive. And indeed the amendment could act as a serious protection of the right to free speech and journalism. What he is saying is that an act is not seriously improper for the purposes of this section if it consists of the expression of an opinion or a contribution made in good faith to debate on a matter of public interest, unless it involves the knowing assertion of a statement of fact which the person knows to be false.
Well for my part, I could not object to the inclusion of those words in this bill, even though I disagreed with the general tenor of of some of what the noble Lord said. As to Baroness Levitt's amendments, for my part I was persuaded by her that a public interest defence would probably work better and more effectively and be more readily understood than the reasonable excuse defence, which is the catch-all in the present drafting of the bill. And I also believe that the burden of proof being put on the defence in cases like this is not remotely unusual and that would be acceptable. My Lords, I turn now to amendment 75 in my name to which Baroness Brinton has added her name. That would make it an offence for a person to encourage directly or indirectly or through a third party a public office holder to commit an offence of misleading the public.
I deal with this in some detail because ancillary liability is often misunderstood and it does generally follow the principal offence. But it is necessary for ancillary liability for there to be a principal offence. This is not simple ancillary liability that would be added by this amendment, not ancillary liability for the encouragement or instigation of an offence. This offence would be committed even if there were no principal offence. The point of it is that an attempt to get a public office holder to commit an offence of misleading the public under clause 12 would be an offence even if the public office holder resisted that attempt so that there were no principal offence.
Now this is important, and the anomaly has been highlighted by Spotlight on Corruption, to whom I'm grateful for their briefings. Normal ancillary liability of a secondary offender requires that a principal offender commits the offence. But this would be committed by anyone who attempted to get a public office holder to mislead the public in a criminal way within subsection one, for whatever purpose, even if the attempt were unsuccessful. So in that sense, the ancillary would be suborning or attempting to suborn the public office holder. And that, I would suggest, should be an offence of misleading the public, or of inciting the misleading of the public.
The attempt to undermine the probity of a public office holder by attempting to persuade him or her to commit an offence justifies criminal sanction. And for that reason, because of the suborning nature of the offence, it's unsurprising that Spotlight on Corruption have shown that interest, because it is a form of corruption that should be subject to sanction.
Edward Faulks
Before the noble Lord sits down, I wonder if he'd be kind enough to answer this. He's dealt very fully with the reason for there being an offence, and how it's justified, and how important it is that there should be, as it were, teeth to the bill. But he hasn't dealt with a second point which I made, which is: what is the collateral effect of the existence of this offence on public administration and the attitude of public officials who want, naturally, or will want to try and avoid being prosecuted or contravening these rather complex provisions?
Jonathan Marks
I think the answer is that you have to trust in the robustness of public officials, because there is no reason why they should be scared of offending against these provisions if they avoid serious impropriety. There simply isn't. This is an offence that is designed to be confined to serious cases, whose prosecution involves the consent of the DPP/Attorney General, depending on whose version you will accept. But that doesn't mean that public officials are going to be so weak that they will change the face of their own administration or their own conduct for fear of prosecution for this offence. The offence is simply not likely to work that way, and I don't believe there's any significant danger of any public official worth his or her salt being so deterred.
David Wolfson
My Lords, let me begin by addressing amendment 74, which is in the name of my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie, which I've obviously signed. And this got some indirect support, unusual for my amendments, from the noble lady Baroness Chakrabarti in the previous group, and I thank her in her absence. But perhaps more relevantly, it got a lot of support from noble Lord Lord Alton of Liverpool in this group, and I'm grateful for his support, because this amendment is a proposed extension of the new statutory offence under clause 12 for the deliberate misleading of a minister by a civil servant. The noble Lord Lord Alton gave us some examples over the years. And the short point is this: if the offence is going to apply to ministers, it seems sensible and logical that it should also apply to civil servants.
Now, the offence applies to debate outside this House. Of course, anything said in Parliament is rightly privileged. We've had that discussion in the previous group. But given that, it's of all the more importance, it's of paramount importance, that ministers are not misled by their own officials before coming to this place.
And if we don't hold, if we don't include civil servants within the offence, there is no way to hold officials to account where Parliament is misled. And I'm very grateful for the noble lord the minister's engagement to date, but I do respectfully ask him to look at this point again before report stage because we do think it is a lacuna in the bill. Now, I'm aware the noble lord the minister believes the offence to be covered by the offences in clause 13, but for this particular offence, it seems to us it would be very important and sensible to have clarity on the face of the bill. There was a suggestion that clarification is unnecessary because of existing case law on the common law offence of misconduct in public office. The problem with that argument, it seems to me, is that as this bill in section 17 expressly abolishes the common law offence, it is difficult to see how a court would still rely on case law for an offence which has been abolished.
So, whether this evening or in a letter before report, I would be grateful if the noble lord the minister could give the house clarity on that point. Turning now to the other amendments in the group, amendment 72 from noble lady Baroness Brinton seeks to include providing misleading information to a news publication under the offence. The intention obviously is to improve the quality of public debate, to tackle misleading information, that's obviously an outcome we would all support. But, and it is an important but, there is a balance to be struck. We are concerned that introducing criminal offences in this area may have a chilling effect on public debate.
We do not want to endanger high-quality free debate in the public square, and these benches seek to have, seek to encourage a public square which is vibrant, which is robust, which may even be raucous, but that's important in a parliamentary democracy. And that point was made eloquently by my noble friend Lord Young of Acton, who is a passionate and principled campaigner for free speech, and I do have a great deal of... Of course, of course.
Sal Sarah Brinton
I'm concerned that the amendment that I've put down is being seen the other way round, that it's stifling free debate with what the press say. It's not coming from that angle at all, it's coming from the perspective about the honesty of public officials rather than suppressing freedom of speech out there.
David Wolfson
I did try to make it clear that we obviously agree with the intentions underlying the amendment, it's the effect the amendment will have in practice that we are concerned about because there is a balance to be struck here. And I mean, on this point, we do not want to leave it, as my noble friend Lord Young of Acton says, to explanatory notes. And when I heard that Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames agreed with the thrust and perhaps even the wording of the amendment of Lord Young of Acton, it did seem to me that a minister faced with an amendment with the support of both Lord Young and Lord Marks is facing a very powerful argument. Now, amendment 77 again from the noble lady Baroness Brinton is, and I'll make this clear, oh sorry, you want to speak.
Jonathan Marks
My intention is very short. I hope I made it clear that it was only the wording of the amendment with which I agreed, not the thrust of Lord Young's speech.
David Wolfson
You absolutely did, and I was picking the positive bits to try and put the noble lord, Lord Marks, in the best light possible.
Now, I was going to be much more supportive of amendment 77 from noble lady Baroness Brinton, which is with respect a good probing amendment on the exception for those working for news outlets. It's particularly relevant in light of this weekend's news that civil servants were seconded to the BBC fact-checking services. Now, that was described by some as a clear conflict of interest. I can see how that risks undermining public trust in our national broadcaster, and I would invite the noble lord the minister to reflect on the importance of trust in our news outlets when he replies to this amendment 77 and say what steps ministers are taking to prevent apparent conflict of interest arising in the future. Now turning now to the amendment or the motion rather that clause 12 be left out of the bill in the name of noble lord Lord Faulks and noble Baroness Lady Falconer.
This is a view, as they've said, which has been echoed by the Policy Exchange paper, Legislating for Candour: What the Hillsborough Law is Likely to Do in Government. Again, in his absence, I know in the previous group the noble lord Lord Carlile of Berriew wasn't particularly complimentary about the paper. I'm afraid I take entirely the opposite view. I think the paper makes a number of extremely persuasive points, and with a foreword from noble lord Lord Butler of Brockwell, who's probably forgotten more about public administration than most of the rest of us will ever know, whether one agrees with the conclusions or not, it's a very important contribution to the debate, and I'm sure the noble lord the minister and his team will have looked at it. Like the noble lord Lord Faulks, I do think a few of the words in the criminal offence are vague in the extreme.
We've looked at obfuscation. I mean, obfuscation might have been invented by lawyers to ensure that even the accusation of being unclear is itself unclear. And I think it was, I think noble lord Lord Armstrong actually said being economical with the actualité, which again was a fantastically obfuscatory way of saying what he was intending to say. And I therefore do agree respectfully with the noble lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich that the words here need to be looked at carefully. It's not just obfuscation.
Repeated. Most political interviews today, the politician says the same thing about seven times. So even in a single interview, you're going to satisfy repeated. Significant. What does significant mean?
I mean, it's one of those words when you see it in an act, does it mean sort of very substantial, or does it merely mean not insignificant? And if it means the latter, not insignificant, it's a very low bar indeed. So I think all of those words need careful scrutiny, and again, I look forward to the noble lord the minister's response on that. Of course, as Lord Faulks says, clause 12 is not covered by the manifesto commitment. Let me just say a word, a further word about this.
Noble lord Lord Marks made a very important point about his amendment 75. He made the point that his amendment 75 is a standalone offence because it would be an offence even if there's no offence by the principal. He did accept, and with respect he's right to do so, that the normal principles, however, of aiding and abetting would still apply.
I think there is a real concern here because we are going to have this problem, I fear. Clause 12 could change the relationship between ministers and civil servants going forward. Let me give an example. You have a civil servant who says, "Minister, I think if you give the speech which you want me to draft, you will be making a misleading statement to the public, and I'm not going to work on that speech because if you give it, you will be committing a criminal offence and I might be guilty of aiding and abetting a criminal offence." Now, of course, the civil servant would explain their refusal as a principled objection to aiding and abetting a criminal offence.
Of course, in practice, what happens is that there are various pressure groups who put either pressure on civil servants to take that view, or civil servants have their own political views, they are human beings, and they may take that view because of their own political stance. And I'm not sort of making this up out of thin air. I remember when in the previous government, there were issues when civil servants were saying we don't want to work on particular policies because they might breach international law. Well, the minister is not personally liable under international law, the civil servant is certainly not personally liable under international law, and yet they were raising this as a reason not to work on the policy. So I appreciate this is a somewhat nuanced point and it may be something the minister doesn't want to reply to this evening, especially given the hour, but I do invite the minister to think about that carefully and perhaps again he could consider writing to the committee between now and report.
I'm conscious of the time. I'm also conscious that the noble lady Lady Levitt raised two points about the defence, both changing reasonable excuse to public interest and also changing the burden of proof. I was going to reply to those points in the next group, and if the noble lady will permit me to, without any disrespect, may I do that because as she said, they come in both groups and I've already probably spoken for long enough on this one.
Anthony Gerard Lemos
Well, my Lords, the noble Lord Lord Wolfson pointed out to the agreement between Lord Young and Lord Marks. Unfortunately, there were many issues on which noble Lords didn't agree, so if the government was seeking a consensus across the House, that doesn't seem to be available on this set of amendments. But I do take the point that the noble Lord Lord Alton made, which is this is precisely why we have committee stage to get into some of these nuances and which might appear contradictory, but on further discussion we maybe will get somewhere. But my Lords, I want to begin by saying that this offence applies to public officials and public authorities on the basis that those entrusted by the public to positions of authority must not wrongly mislead the public. That's the whole point.
We think it is right that they're held to a particularly high standard and should take responsibility for statements they make to the public. We do not think it's appropriate to extend this offence to private individuals or bodies. Just in response to the Baroness Faulkner, we're not saying that every public official is lying, of course we're not, but we are saying that we have expectations as I've set out. However, a person who is not a public authority or official could commit an offence if they intend or believe, and this is I think what the noble Lord Lord Marks was driving at, if they intend or believe that their actions will encourage or assist a public official or authority to commit the misleading the public offence.
I can reassure the noble lady that the offence of misleading the public already captures misleading the public through the media, provided such an act meets the threshold for the scope of the offence. However, the bill has been carefully constructed so that a journalist reporting on that misleading information, and this goes to the point made by the noble lord Lord Young, is exempt to ensure that the offence does not impinge on press freedom or existing regimes for media regulation. So I hope that provides the noble lady Lady Brinton with some reassurance. The noble and learned Lord Keen and I met over the summer, and I promised when we met that the government would look at amendment 74 closely. And following careful consideration, we believe that a civil servant misleading a minister would be capable of being captured by the new seriously improper acts offence at clause 13 of the bill.
The noble lord Lord Wolfson predicted that would be my answer, and indeed it is. As with the current common law misconduct in public office offence, which this bill replaces, the seriously improper acts offence is designed to capture behaviour where any public office holder abuses their office or neglects to perform their duties in the most egregious way. For this purpose, public office holder is defined in the list at schedule 4 of the bill and includes civil servants, MPs and ministers among others. This could therefore include instances of civil servants misleading a minister by virtue of their position, as long as the other conditions of the offence are met, including that they do so for the purposes of obtaining a benefit or causing another to suffer a detriment. Benefit and detriment are deliberately given very wide meanings under this offence.
A public office holder's intent or purpose in acting is also central to the offence being made out, and this is important to ensure that those who act innocently are not criminalised. Finally, a jury would also need to be sure that the civil servant knew or ought to have known that their actions or intended actions were seriously improper. It is an important principle of the criminal law to avoid unnecessary or duplicative offences, as these can create confusion for those enforcing or prosecuting the law. Turning now to the noble baroness Lady Levitt's amendments, the offence of misleading the public has a reasonable excuse defence. The defendant will have the evidential burden to raise the reasonable excuse defence, and the prosecution are required to prove beyond all reasonable doubt, as of course she knows, that the defence is not applicable.
We chose this approach as it is a common formulation of defences against criminal offences, maintaining strict adherence to the presumption of innocence under article 6.2 of the European Convention on Human Rights. We do, however, recognise the noble baroness's concern, and I undertake to take away her proposal for further consideration. Turning then to her amendment 78, which would replace the reasonable excuse defence for the offence with a narrower public interest defence. While acting in the public interest could be the basis of a defence, we think for a new offence of this kind, covering as it does all statements made by ministers and public officials on a wide range of matters, it is important to retain the breadth of a reasonable excuse defence. Turning to the noble lord Lord Young, who raises a very important point and one the government is very conscious of, this offence is absolutely not intended to restrict free and healthy political or public debate.
I hear what's been said about the chilling effect and so on, but others have taken other views. Ministers and others must be seen, must be able to contribute to that debate, that free debate for the health of our democracy, as a number of noble lords have said. We have crafted the offence carefully with that in mind. For an offence to have been committed, an authority or official must have acted with the intention to mislead the public or have been reckless as to whether their actions would do so. And by reckless, we mean a person acting with the knowledge that there is a risk that they might mislead the public and taking that risk without reasonable justification.
We've had this discussion about recklessness last time, so I've set that out now. It does not include accidental mistakes or inaccuracies. They must also have known or ought to have known that their act is seriously improper, and the minimum conditions for this are that the act involves significant or repeated dishonesty about matters of significant concern to the public. And we've had some examples of those earlier from the noble baroness, Baroness Chakrabarti, who's not in her place. The act must have caused or had the potential to cause harm, and crucially, the act must have departed significantly from what would have been expected of that person in carrying out their functions.
Taking these tests together, we are clear that either someone expressing an honest opinion or making a contribution in good faith to a debate would not be captured. I hope that satisfies the noble lord. Finally, my lords, I turn now to the notice given by the noble lord, Lord Foulkes, opposing the question that clause 12 stand part of the bill. And let me address briefly why the government considers that this provision should remain part of the bill. The offence is triable either way and carries a maximum sentence of two years imprisonment, reflecting the seriousness of the misconduct at which it is directed, which is the whole basis of this bill.
The clause also excludes acts done for the purposes of journalism. This reflects the government's view that news broadcasters who might otherwise fall within scope are not culpable when reporting information for the purposes of journalism. This ensures that responsibility remains with those who mislead the press rather than with the press for reporting that information. We do not agree that the tests for the offence are vague. Necessarily, they have to be general enough that they can apply in a broad range of scenarios, but together, rightly, they amount to a high threshold for a prosecution to meet.
A prosecutor would need to establish that that authority official acted with the intention of misleading the public or were reckless as to whether their act will do so. Recklessness here means they foresaw a risk and took it anyway without a reasonable excuse. Then they would need to establish that the authority or official knew or ought to know that their acts were seriously improper, and the bill sets three conditions that must be met: that the act involved dishonesty that was significant or repeated in respect of matters of significant public concern; that it caused or contributed to causing harm to one or more other persons or had the potential to do so; and that it departed significantly from what is to be expected in the proper exercise of the person's function as a public authority or a public official. The government's view is that the policy objective...
Anderson
I'm grateful to the minister, and I'm mindful of the hour, but the noble lord the minister speaks of a high threshold, and he says that this offence is intended to catch only public officials who neglect to perform their duties in the most egregious way.
But the central element of the offense, dishonesty, can be made out, as Lord Wilson and I between us pointed out, by repeated insignificant obfuscations. That seems a little difficult to reconcile with what the Minister is saying. And I ask him simply, would he be prepared to think again about the content of clause 12 3A before we get to report and have to vote it all out?
Anthony Gerard Lemos
The answer to that question is yes, I'm very happy to debate particularly the point about obfuscation with the noble Lord Anderson and others who are interested. I was just about to say that. The government's view is that the policy objective underpinning this clause remains both necessary and proportionate. The offenses have been carefully drafted, incorporates a high threshold and contains a number of important safeguards and defenses. The government does not consider that existing mechanisms alone adequately address this type of conduct.
Ultimately, my Lords, the question before the committee is whether this provision should remain part of the bill. For the reasons I've outlined, the government considers that it should. And so I respectfully ask the noble lady to withdraw her amendment.
Edward Faulks
I'm grateful to the Minister for giving way. He's answered from his notes very thoroughly the various points about the elements in the offense, which he describes as a high threshold. But what he didn't do was deal with any of the points that were made about the potential chilling effect or the effect on how public administration was going to work in practice, the effect that the possibility of prosecution might have on the very many people, and he hasn't answered my question about how many public officials, how they might view the possibility. Does he have a view on that?
Anthony Gerard Lemos
I think I did set out in what I said about the threshold why we thought this wouldn't have a chilling effect. That was the whole point of my peroration about the high threshold. The noble Lord might not accept that, but that is the point I was making, that the chilling effect would be to some extent protected by the thresholds for prosecution. On the question of the numbers, I think the noble Lord said there were 6 million civil servants. There aren't as yet 6 million civil servants or anything like it.
But the numbers of public officials are perhaps something we can come back to.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I'm very grateful for the very wide-ranging debate we've had in the last hour and a bit, and the hour is late, so I won't go through any of the details. Suffice to say, I think that the House has asked the Minister to engage on various points between committee stage and report stage, which I think we're all particularly grateful. And I really hope that we can move forward in the spirit of the bill and actually recognize that there are times that we will need to make sure that officials shouldn't be able to deliberately mislead and lie. I know some of that debate's happened in earlier groups tonight. But nonetheless, my Lords, given that we have got report to come back to in due course, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 143
Is it your Lordship's pleasure that amendment 72 be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 73, Baroness Chakrabarti, not moved. Amendment 74, Lord Wilson of Dinton, not moved. Amendment 75, Lord Marks, not moved.
Amendment 76, Lord Young, not moved. Amendment 77, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendments 78 and 79, Baroness Ludford, not moved. And amendment 80, Lord Wilson of Dinton, not moved.
Speaker 145
The question is that clause 12 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. The question is that schedule 3 be the third schedule to the bill.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 143
The question is that the House be resumed. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
That the House do now adjourn.