Justice and Home Affairs Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Justice and Home Affairs Committee Actual start House of Lords
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 5
Could we talk a little bit about the Rivers Centre in Scotland, where for the past 30 years we understand that NHS specialist psychological support has been offered to those who have suffered or believe that or feel they've suffered some kind of trauma through the process of being a juror? Is that something, do you know, that you're looking at?
Dan, do you want to...?
Daniel Flury
Yeah, I can do.
So we're certainly aware of what's happening, I think, in Lothian and the Rivers Centre, where it's sort of explicit, an explicit offering of psychological support after the jury trial. You know, our approach in HMCTS is, as you probably know, to sort of, you know, refer them either to their GP, who we think are best placed to sort of make a clinical assessment, or Samaritans or any other sort of charities. So whilst we do have lots of material to signpost those who've undertaken jury service, we don't make an explicit offering. Again, this is something that we are looking at, we are considering as part of the, our response to the Forsythe and Brooks report, but at present we don't have, well, no intention of replicating what they do in the Rivers Centre.
Sarah Sackman
And just to build on that point, I mean, I think we're always looking to other jurisdictions, particularly those close to home, to identify what best practice looks like, as we should. But I think one of the things that's important to sort of highlight, that out of the Fawcett and Brooks study, which was fairly broad in scope, looking at 16 Crown Court centres, when we think about the importance of, and this is one of the things we are going to institute and we might come to it, national minimum standards, which we've never had before. So I think that is a really important sort of step change in terms of consistent standards and support for jurors irrespective of where they are in the system or in the country. But what the study found was that the uptake for that really specialised counselling service which it provided was actually pretty low.
Now, that's not to say it isn't of particular value to those who are sitting on a jury where there is particularly traumatic content or where there are particular vulnerabilities. Of course that's right. But what we found is that in general terms, the majority of trials didn't evidence a demand for that specialist service. That doesn't mean that jurors aren't entitled to expect a decent waiting room, proper direction from both judge and jury officer, proper information throughout the process. Of course they should.
That's the national minimum standard.
But I think it's really important that we distinguish between where there really is a need, where you've got trials which raise particularly, you know, grim and awful evidence, which is likely to trigger a need for additional support, versus the majority of trials where actually what the study showed, there wasn't really the demand there. But, you know, but we can continue to look at this, of course, and we should continue to see what the results from the, you know, Scottish work shows.
Daniel Flury
I was going to just illustrate that point a little further. So, you know, for example, during the Lucy Letby trial, the Manchester victim support intervened and provided support to jurors who underwent or sat on that trial. We also had something similar with the David Fuller trial in Maidstone in Kent, in particularly harrowing evidence and so on. He eventually pleaded guilty, so it wasn't required.
So, you know, we can obtain support directly for very specific trials and we can work, you know, the judge may also direct us to sort of obtain specific support for certain, again, for certain trials, but these really are the exception rather than anywhere near the norm.
Speaker 5
Okay, if I could just follow up with two very short follow-ups because others have questions to ask. So, some of us were lucky enough to go last week to the Old Bailey and we had a really interesting discussion both with the recorder and those who actually manage the court. And of course the Old Bailey is in some ways exceptional in terms of some of the kind of cases and very difficult cases. And whilst we understood that the take-up might be quite low in terms of people needing more support, I would argue, if I may, that knowing the support is there is in itself a huge support, just knowing you've got that if you need to turn to it.
But also quickly, do you have a timeline for publishing minimum standards that you would like to see applied across the board?
Sarah Sackman
No, I think again all really good points and you're right, the Old Bailey in many ways is exceptional both in terms of the kinds of trials that are heard there but also the nature of that as a Crown Court centre. I mean, you know, I'm not going to gloss over the fact that there are parts of our court estate that are not where we would want it to be and it's why we're making, you know, major investment, more significant investment in maintenance than we have for a very long time.
But, but to answer your question, the national minimum standards, which as I said will set clearer expectations for the information that jurors are provided with, including that signposting to, you're absolutely right, you may not need support, but if you do, this is where you can get it. That practical support, but also how jurors can raise concerns during the process, because one might be feeling pretty resilient at certain points and then at other points in a trial feel really quite different. So that will be incorporated within the national minimum standards and our ambition is to introduce those national minimum standards next year. So that's the timeline. And so, so I should say, whilst we've got a pretty good idea of what we expect to be in them, this, this work of this committee is really well timed.
Don Foster
Well, can I, can I raise an issue about what might be contained? You said that following the, the work that was done on the trial, that you had a better idea of what is needed, and clearly accepting that even though it might not necessarily be for all jurors, that some jurors will need it.
And picking up the point that's just been made by Baroness Buscombe, the idea of jurors knowing what help is available is clearly advantageous. I have in front of me the main government document which lists all the details about jury service. Nowhere on the list of, I think it's about 12 headings, is there any reference to support for jurors. However, it is contained in the document, which is very encouraging. Amazingly, you have to find it under the heading "discussing the trial".
That's where you find what help there is for jurors. If I then look at what it tells me, it says, "if you find the trial distressing, you may be upset by the trial and want to speak to somebody privately, speak to court staff, they'll give you advice".
And in a minute, we'll come on to the issue of court staff's ability to do that. But it also says, for emotional support, speak to your GP to find out what support is available, and you can contact the Samaritans, although they cannot give advice. So you're told you go to your GP, who'll try and find some help for you, but himself, herself can't give it, and the Samaritans can't give advice. That is the sole reference to support for jurors in the official detailed government document about jury service. However, they are given a handout, and the handout doesn't actually say that the Samaritans can't give advice, but it says you can talk to them day or night, and your GP can help you find free counselling services.
Sarah Sackman
Um, so first of all, I mean, I'll defer to Daniel in relation to whether that represents the totality of the information that jurors are given because I believe they're also sent information in the form of, you know, email and which includes a video link. Um, there's also information, as I said, that is provided at court. But, you know, frankly, if one of the things we need to take away, and one of the things that if one of the things we need to take away from this exercise as we institute national minimum standards, and I say this because I see by analogy in, for example, the correspondence we now produce within the Ministry of Justice when people write about quite distressing subjects, routinely now the signposting that we provide is really quite clear. If one of the takeaways is that we need to improve that signposting, then that I think is a valuable takeaway, but Daniel, I don't know if you want to come in.
Daniel Flury
Yeah, certainly accept the guidance is in need of some codification, if I can call it that. And in some ways this is what the new standards are about. You know, you shouldn't have to look in other areas to sort of find out the full facts on it. I accept that point. But the guidance will, or the standards will cover information including the details of the video and so on.
It'll cover things about expenses. It'll cover sort of signposting. It'll cover facilities available, reasonable adjustments. It'll cover details of what to expect in court and the support you will be provided with. So it, I do accept it is in need of some codification.
Don Foster
I'm grateful for that, and we'll come on to each of those issues you've mentioned in a minute. What I am concerned about is whether or not you first of all accept that you need to do more to highlight, which I think you've said you agree with, but secondly, whether you think that what is on offer that you're going to highlight is remotely adequate. Signposting to a GP who may help you find free counseling and signposting to the Samaritans who, quote, cannot give advice. Do you think that that is adequate? However much you advertise it with huge posters and videos and everything, even so, is it adequate?
Sarah Sackman
Well, can I, can I just sort of address that in a couple of ways? First of all, we clearly don't think it's adequate because that's why we're instituting national minimum standards. If we thought the status quo was good enough, why bother? So we, we do see that there's room for improvement, building on the evidence base that we obtained through this study.
And I think that will consist, you will see that that will consist of I think a couple of different areas of work. One which is around internal monitoring of standards to make sure that we've got consistency of practice everywhere, but also the ambition to produce a public-facing jurors' charter which will explain what every juror, irrespective of where they are in the country, can expect from His Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service and also what to do if those standards aren't met. So I think that is a really big step forward. In terms, so there is a point about information and how that information is presented to jurors, which I think we all accept can be better. And I think a takeaway should be what goes in that initial summons letter as well as the information that is provided throughout, because you might not retain that letter.
The second part of your question relates to the adequacy of signposting people to their local GP, NHS 111, which has a mental health element, and Samaritans. And I think there, I think our view is we come back to the point that for the majority of jurors, um, that probably will be adequate. It will be adequate to know that there's a recognition that sitting through a criminal trial can surface things which have a psychological impact, and the best port of call are going to be, you know, dedicated charities like the Samaritans or the NHS.
However, that is not to say, and this is to come back to Daniel's point, that targeted support is going to be warranted where you have particularly traumatic subject matter.
Don Foster
I'll stop you there if I can, Minister, because some of the issues in terms of the details of what that would be will, I hope, emerge during some of the subsequent questions. So I think what we're getting is a clear understanding you accept that the signposting, whatever it is, is currently inadequate and needs to be beefed up.
Sarah Sackman
I think it can be better. I think the phrase I would use is it can be better, and we're going to make it better.
Don Foster
Right, that's very helpful. Just before we move on to the next issue, Lord Anderson.
Speaker 10
Thank you very much, and welcome. It's a very specific question really provoked by something Daniel Flury said. You mentioned that the Witness Support Service had been helpful during the Lucy Letby trial to jurors.
The Victim Support, yes.
Speaker 10
Sorry, the victim support, I'm so sorry, to jurors as well as to victims. And I just wanted to know really a little bit more about that. Was this something that was planned in advance, that victim support would get involved? What was the nature of the support? Was it during the trial, or did it extend to the period after the trial?
And you did mention one other case that I think pleaded, but are there other examples of victim support being used in this way, and are there plans to roll it out more broadly or make it more widely available?
Daniel Flury
It's very much an ad hoc arrangement. So in Manchester, we were approached by the victim support in Manchester as someone who could offer this service.
And when we spoke with the trial judge during the trial, it was something that was suggested would be a sensible thing to put in place. There's another case I know about, I can't remember the defendant's name, but it was a multiple rape trial in Manchester again as well and the same Victim Support provided that service. So it's not something that happens routinely. It would happen either because the judge asked for it to happen or HMCTS identified a particular need to support a jury through a particularly distressing trial. And there is a process whereby we can either contact Victim Support or other charities to provide this and this is something that HMCTS, if it's not free of charge, pays for itself.
Speaker 13
They are, they're not, just to be clear, they're not supporting the jury during the trial. It's post-trial support.
Speaker 10
Post-trial. Were the people offering that support the same people that had supported the victims in that trial or the victims' families?
Sarah Sackman
If I may, I just think just to put some data, just to provide context. In the study that was undertaken, the Fawcett Brooks study, where there was an end-of-trial intervention and a bespoke counselling service was made available to all of the jury trials that were covered within the scope of those 16 Crown Court centres. So of the 17,811 jurors that were captured by the trial, 10 took up the service.
Now, I absolutely acknowledge the point that for those 10 who attended at least one session, that will have no doubt, I hope, had real value. And I also absolutely acknowledge the point that Baroness Buscombe made earlier, that the fact that you knew and would know that there was this bespoke counselling service and this helpline available, a dedicated helpline, may well have provided comfort and sort of reassurance and resilience to many of those. But I think it does paint a picture, you know, 10 out of nearly 18,000 jurors. You know, we've, I think what that tells me, and I'd be interested obviously to see what the committee's conclusions are, is that it may well be that we need something more than is currently there, but it needs to be targeted, it needs to be proportionate.
The demand case for maintaining that counselling service given the cost of it at a national level for all jurors was not made out by that study. I've got to be in a tight fiscal environment really thoughtful about how we target our money. So I do think that that context is important for the committee.
Speaker 10
But I think you're saying, or perhaps you're still thinking about it, that the answer to that question is not victim support.
Very occasionally be appropriate as it seems to have been in the Lucy Letby trial, but you're not saying that that limited number of jurors could get the support they want or that they need from Victim Support.
Sarah Sackman
I'm saying that in the context of the Lucy Letby trial and the local context in Manchester, informed by the judge in that case presiding over that and ascertaining what they thought was necessary, that the skill set that Victim Support, and I understand in that case there was a phone number available, that that would provide something that would be of benefit to a set of jurors that were looking at a pretty distressing case. But I'm not necessarily saying that that is the only way that you could support jurors. We're saying that the support that's currently available obviously takes different forms. What's going to be right for one person, you know, one person might prefer to go to their GP, another might prefer to call the Samaritans. The point is to target support and signpost it clearly so people know what's available to them, because many people might not have heard of Samaritans.
Very quickly, yes.
Daniel Flury
To add a point on the Samaritans, we do offer a little more than just here's a number, good luck. It's we have a what we call a specific referral pathway which court staff can use which does get us through to an enhanced level of service in the Samaritans, so it's a little more than just sort of referring them to a telephone number or website.
Don Foster
That's helpful to know and perhaps you could just write and give us a bit more detail about that. It would be very helpful. Lord Morris.
Speaker 18
Thank you, Chair. And thank you, Minister, for your time this morning, it's much appreciated.
Could I ask, I mean, we've already alighted on the role of court staff, and we've been looking specifically at the training for them, which has now already come up. But could I ask you specifically what training is available to court staff for supporting jurors?
Sarah Sackman
You can, and I'm going to direct that one, if I may, to Daniel, because he'll give you a fuller answer than me.
Daniel Flury
So, I'm sure, or I hope the committee has seen our what we call our training workbook for jury officers, jury bailiffs, which sets out the skills and expectations and the role of jury officers. We can certainly send it to the committee if you haven't seen that. And that sets out what is required.
You know, the role has changed quite considerably over the years from one that was there principally to sort of administer the oaths, deal with expenses, usher jurors in and out of the building. You know, I talk to jury officers now, they play a far more of what they call a social worker role. And these are the sort of people we are looking for, and especially in our court ushers as well as the jury officers, in that, you know, we are looking for people with good listening skills, with good, with empathy, the ability to diffuse situations and deal with people who are upset. In HMCTS as well, we've recently rolled out a package of what we call trauma-informed training, which sort of sets out how the consequences of trauma affect certain individuals and what you can do in response to that. And it's our ushers and jury officers that really are at the front line of all of this.
So, um, we last updated our training, our workbook in 2025.
I'm expecting to further update it probably after the findings of this committee emerge because, you know, we clearly can see that the role of the usher in particular has changed quite a lot and we want to help them adjust to the changed level of expectation.
Speaker 18
And so, could I just quickly follow up? I mean, it's becoming clear to the committee and we've been looking at this very closely that the role of court staff is much more important than it would first seem on investigation and it's a highly sensitive role and it affects them as we've just heard, but it also affects the jurors quite profoundly. So, I mean, could I just follow up by asking whether you think the training is adequate and whether you think, you know, we are identifying best practice as being whether that is at the moment satisfactory?
Daniel Flury
I certainly think the training is adequate. I always think there is more to be done to improve the situation. And, you know, the difficulty with a lot of this is it's about sort of, it's about people's personalities and certain jury officers different to other jury officers, you know, in terms of how they empathize with people and so on. But there's always done, there's always room to identify and spread best practice a little further. Could I just focus on two specific things we've done for ushers and jury officers in the last 12 months?
So firstly, you know, we accept, as I've just mentioned, that the role has changed quite considerably over the last 10, 15 years. We've recently upgraded them, so they were at the lowest level of the civil service grade, what's called an administrative assistant.
They've now been moved up to the next grade above. So that's change in grade and of course change in salary reflects the increased level of expectation and the role that they play. And you know, that has been an important step of of recognizing, I think, the role they play. And again, but you know, there's more to be done, as you say, on spreading best practice and so on.
Baroness Berridge.
Elizabeth Berridge
Thank you very much for attending today. Um, a group of us had the pleasure of going to Southwark Crown Court, not the Old Bailey, and were surprised to learn that actually administrative staff who deal with the jurors, not the jury officer or the jury usher, were receiving calls two or three a month from those people who had served on juries in Southwark Crown Court and who were struggling.
And obviously the staff we saw, I really felt for them in their distress that they didn't feel they had adequate nature. So I'm wondering when you say about not routine, routinely defendants have an access service, judges have an access service, barristers have an access service, CPS have an access service, court staff are moved out if they're struggling with a trial. That actually routinely to prevent your staff who aren't trained, and this is happening they said across the London courts at that level, two or three a month are phoning in with these concerns.
Do you not accept that there does need to be a routine service, otherwise staff who aren't trained in this are picking up really distressing calls from jurors who are struggling after sitting on trials?
Daniel Flury
Yeah, we would expect, you know, it's quite a sort of large pool of admin staff in the Crown Courts. Those answering the phones one day may act as an usher the following day, so they will undergo the same level of training. Again, they'll also be required to do the trauma-informed training. But yet, I accept your point that, you know, these phone calls are made and, you know, they can be particularly harrowing and we are reliant on that referral back to a GP or the Samaritans in the same way that an usher is. We do support our staff, as you suggest, you know, if they have been sitting on a particularly harrowing trial, you know, we look to find them what we'll call a lighter trial.
It's the same for clerks as well in the following week to give them a break. But again, we are reliant on the referral routes that we've already mentioned in these circumstances.
Sarah Sackman
Yeah, I mean, I think that's right.
I mean, I think it's very interesting to...
Don Foster
I'm sorry, I just want to pick that... You keep saying that you are reliant on the referral route, but the point that Baroness Berridge made in the introduction of her question was that everybody else in court, whether they're barristers, whether they're judges, whether they're, you know, the whole lot, have all got procedures in place with specifically qualified people to provide them with support. The jurors don't, and that's the missing bit, surely.
Sarah Sackman
Look, I think that you're right, there isn't dedicated provision, but I think I'd make two points.
First of all, the court staff that are receiving those calls, as we've heard, receive—no one's claiming that they are there to provide mental health support, but they do receive the training that Daniel Flury just referred to and can direct those people to where they can access that support. That's the first thing. The second thing is, of course, you know, the examples that you've heard perhaps cut against, but we did do an assessment, an academic-led assessment.
I don't believe that Southwark was included within those 16 Crown Courts, but 16 Crown Courts is obviously a significant sample. And in that case, within the context of that study, people were directed to something which was specialist and was a specialist counseling service, end-of-trial service for jurors. The uptake, as I've indicated, was incredibly low and didn't substantiate the demand for what we're talking about here. So I'm not here saying that, you know...
Don Foster
Sorry, could you then tell us whether or not the demand for the support for barristers, for example, which does exist, has got high take-up, any higher than the jury take-up was for the trial?
Sarah Sackman
Sorry, this is the services that barristers can access. I don't have that data to hand, but I do know from engaging with the Bar that issues around self-care, well-being, those engaging in traumatic subject matters, not just in crime of course, in family as well, is something that is an area where a lot of work is being done by the Bar. So look, no one is suggesting that jurors are just, you know, pure spectators, they're obviously actively engaged in every stage of this. But there are pathways, and when a dedicated counselling service was put in place in an empirical study, the take-up was low. So we've got to identify what is a proportionate response to the demand such as it is.
I'm not for one second denying that the evidence that you heard or anecdotal evidence that you picked up at Southwark suggests that there isn't demand within Southwark.
I mean, there may well be.
Elizabeth Berridge
One specific follow-up. Have you made any comparison, though, between the fact that the jurors are the only people in the room who are compelled to be there? They are compelled and they are also cut off from all of the ordinary support mechanisms that we know from massive studies protect you: peer group, being able to talk about it afterwards. They are compelled to be there, so they might need more support than anybody else in the courtroom.
Sarah Sackman
I think we're all, I think we accept, not least by the provision that is in place, that in certain cases jurors may need support.
There may well be an, and the majority of cases, I think it's factually correct to say that in the vast majority of cases there is, there is no demand for this. That's not to say that in certain types of cases targeted support and the availability of pathways is not going to be needed. But the fact that in our jury experience survey, you know, some 60% or thereabouts report a positive experience, means that we, we just need to be, I think, quite targeted and proportionate in how we, in how we meet the demand such that it is. I don't deny that in the sorts of cases we've been referring to, the Letby trial, the sorts of cases that the Bailey or, or Southwark Crown Court might play host to, that there won't be, you might, there won't be an enhanced need.
But in the majority of trials, which may or may not involve violence, which may be at a lower level, it's not going to be needed. And that was, you know, we conducted an assessment. This is not this is not us, you know, searching for answers in the wind.
Don Foster
The assessment that you keep referring to constantly says that more is needed. It might say that the take-up was not particularly great, but it very specifically says that more is needed. But very quickly, Baroness Laskar.
Speaker 5
Very quickly, very quickly, because I think a lot of us feel when we're saying let's signpost to our GP, I can't get to see my GP and a lot of people can't. Just an idea, have you looked at or should you be looking at social prescribers? The problem with Samaritans, and I've chaired the advisory board so I know them so well, they're only a listening service.
They're not there to tell you what to do. But social prescribers, who are trained to focus on the individual through the NHS, could be an option that you look at that people could somehow link into to make them feel that there's something a bit extra there which can get them back into normal life if they've suffered trauma. Just an idea.
Sarah Sackman
I think it's a very valuable idea. I think we should take it away and look at it.
I don't think we could undertake to embed the social prescribers within court, but I think as we've acknowledged, better signposting, enhanced training for our court staff, who by the way, I do want to just take the opportunity because I've got the platform here, you know, they are the eyes and ears and the sort of public-facing, almost customer-facing part of the court. And from somebody who's toured, as you have all done, courts the length and breadth of the country, by and large they actually do a tremendous job for not very much money, and I want to acknowledge that.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Chair. Minister, in your opening remarks, you said that you're giving more attention than ever before to juror wellbeing. Yet this is the first year for some time that the government has not supported Juror Wellbeing Week. Why was that?
Sarah Sackman
I saw this in the in the notes in preparation for this and I'm not sure that's right. We shared details and information and social media about it. There's no suggestion that we as government don't appreciate jurors or indeed their wellbeing. And the fact, as I said, that we commissioned a study to look at this very issue, I think is demonstrative of that.
Daniel Flury
We did. Anything that supports the wellbeing and the good functioning of the court system we would support. And we did support this through sharing links and so on.
Speaker 22
Support it in previous years. We'll wait to hear from you authoritatively about this year. Will you support it next year?
Sarah Sackman
Yeah, I mean, I just want to be really clear here that we in our government communication supported jurors during that week. We've got our own mechanisms for engaging and recognizing the work of jurors. Anybody who's heard me in the House of Commons will have heard me do this all the time. So what I would say is perhaps there is more that we can do on that specific week. But my I want to offer you some reassurance.
I wouldn't read too much into this.
We are supportive of juror wellbeing, clearly we are, otherwise we wouldn't be doing all the work that we're doing on national minimum standards.
Don Foster
Just to save time if we can. We were categorically told by the group that organizes Jurors' Week that this year the government didn't support it. That's what we're told. So if you could be kind enough to go away, have a look at that and come back because if we've been given misinformation then you can correct us and that would be very helpful.
And if you could tell us in what way you supported it, other than publicizing it, whether there was cash involved or whatever, all of that would be very helpful and we'll pick that up a little later. Baroness Berridge.
Elizabeth Berridge
Thank you. I'm drawing again to the enhanced support for juror pilot and the evaluation of that. In that evaluation, there was no comparison to existing best models of practice. We are fortunate to be in a situation now where we do know how to support people, whether they're emergency service workers, whether they are journalists, whether they are people in NGOs reading accounts of torture, like secondary trauma. So can you explain why the evaluation doesn't make a comparison with the models of best practice that we know can help people before, during and after this kind of experience?
Sarah Sackman
The evaluation and the whole study was conducted by two highly experienced academics who took into account a large data set and conducted a structured assessment. Any omissions or failure to go wider is ultimately something that, you know, they looked at what they looked at. We are of course, and I'll bring in Daniel here if he wants to come in, we are of course always, both within the Ministry of Justice and HMCTS, looking at what best practice looks like, looking at other jurisdictions to see what they do, what we might learn from them.
So, not least in part of my briefing for this committee, I was furnished with information that the department routinely looks at from not just Scotland, but also Canada, Australia, New Zealand, so other similar jurisdictions. So, you know, the fact that it wasn't captured in the study, there were some choices made by the academics involved in that study and they've got to be left to get on with their work and the scope of their study, but we do look at what best practice looks like.
Elizabeth Berridge
And you keep making reference to targeted and proportional. Now, we have had evidence that there are on occasion trials that collapse because of jurors not being able to sit through the entirety of the evidence and of course not realizing that they would not be able to cope doing that. Have you in your costings taken into account lost trials, also trials that have to restart, that that's also common that the opening happens and people realize at that moment I'm not going to be able to do that, the costs of that balanced against the costs of extending support routinely to jurors?
Sarah Sackman
Yeah, we do look at that. Every ineffective trial, and I don't mean to try and sound too technocratic about this where there are real, you know, human beings and psychological impacts involved, but every ineffective trial is a colossal waste of time, effort, taxpayer money and has knock-on implications not just for, in the example you're giving, for the juror involved, but obviously for witnesses, victims, defendants whose lives are put on hold. But again, I think it's really important to contextualize this. We have an all too high ineffective trial rate in this country.
The by far the biggest drivers of that ineffective trial rate are the absence of counsel on either side, so prosecution or defense counsel. There are other drivers. Jurors as and and not necessarily for the reasons that you say, but juror absence, so it could it could be something nothing to do with the psychological impact of the trial, as I understand it, account for in the region of 1% of those ineffective trials and you'll tell me if I've got that stat wrong, but I believe it's around 1%.
Of that, there could be, again, lots and lots of drivers of that: childcare, juror falls sick. So, again, I understand where the question's coming from, and any trial that collapses or has to be adjourned for this reason is one trial too many. But, but, but just to put it in context, when we talk about overall system efficiency, our evidence is not that this is a major reason for trial collapse or ineffectiveness.
Elizabeth Berridge
The, if you could, and maybe you need to write to us, ineffective trial, what I've outlined, which I think we've had more evidence of, is you start the trial and then you lose a juror and you have to start again with 11 and you add a 12th to that. Is that an ineffective trial or is that an effective trial for your statistics?
Sarah Sackman
Trial can continue with, and again we'll write to you in the detail, but even if one, but even if one juror can't continue, the trial can still continue. I think it's nine and above.
Sarah Sackman
So there may well be, I'm very sorry for the jurors for whom that is the experience, that is clearly distressing and they deserve support. But, and I'm happy to write to you, but I believe the numbers of trials where multiple jurors pull out for this reason would be very, very exceptional.
Daniel Flury
The principal reasons really are sickness or if a juror has to be discharged, you know, it's where they realize that they actually know somebody, the defendant or a witness in the trial and have to tell the judge that, you know, they can no longer do it. You know, it's very rare, and there's no published stats on this, where a juror would say, you know, I can't quite cope with the material and I need to come away from this trial.
And if they did, you know, that is when the judge would make the decisions whether they could be discharged.
Lord Bach
Minister, welcome. I'm asking this factual question that maybe Daniel would be best to answer this. But there's also a supplementary, which I think I know the answer to already, so I'm a bit embarrassed to ask it. But the question, the main question is, do you have any plans to alter the juror experience survey that was done to include questions on juror mental health or wellbeing? That's the first question.
And the supplementary that really follows on, I think the answer is definitely you don't, but do you know how many jurors go on to need support as a result of their jury service? I wonder if you could answer those.
Sarah Sackman
Your question highlights the fact that in the current anonymous juror experience survey, there is no explicit wellbeing question. I think in light of the study that we've been discussing, in light of the subject matter of this committee investigation, I don't see why it can't include that. And as we embark upon an effort to get these national minimum standards right, I think it ought to.
Lord Bach
Thank you for that answer. As far as the the stats are concerned, or if you know how many jurors go on to need support, I presume the answer is you don't.
Daniel Flury
No, other than the Fawcett and Brooks study, we we don't even have a proxy measure.
Lord Dubs.
Alfred Dubs
Minister, welcome.
You've referred on a number of occasions to looking at practice in other countries. I wonder if I can continue on that theme. There are therapeutic exemptions in jurisdictions such as Canada and Australia, which allow jurors to discuss deliberations with a registered medical professional. Have you thought of introducing such a system in this country, in England and Wales?
Sarah Sackman
We have thought about it, we're aware of it.
I have enormous respect for those jurisdictions and had the privilege of visiting the Supreme Court in Ontario and engaging with their leaders there. These therapeutic exceptions, they do create legal and clinical questions which we would need to grapple with as to who can receive disclosure, for what purpose, under what confidentiality duties. And to be perfectly honest, no change is currently considered, but as I've said to the committee, we're always looking at comparisons, always looking at the ways other jurisdictions do things, but at the moment we don't intend to change how we operate here.
Alfred Dubs
And you have just referred to looking at other jurisdictions.
Are there any lessons from other jurisdictions that you think are sufficiently relevant to tell us about today?
Sarah Sackman
Well, one of the things that I am interested in and where we are putting a very keen focus related to these questions that you're raising about juror well-being and support is the Scottish model and approach, which makes provision for targeted research into what happens in the juror deliberation room. At the moment, we have no provision to enable that research, partly because of the very important principle that what happens in the juror's deliberation room needs to stay there. However, in Scotland, they have now for some time created a framework which allows for research to be done into what goes on. Now, that would, in principle, in theory, could tell us a lot more about what jurors have to go through, not just what happens in a jury room, but actually maybe some of the support or the ways that jurors might flag things or, you know, feel that they can raise some of these issues of concern that you've been talking about.
So that's something that happens in Scotland. It would need a change in the law, but you asked me what are we looking at, that's one of the issues I'm looking at quite closely, not least because it was raised with me by some of our backbenchers in the Commons and I think it's a really valid point.
Don Foster
Could I just pick up a point just so we've got it absolutely clear, sorry to interrupt. You are saying your understanding is to make that change would require primary legislation.
It would. It would.
Don Foster
Okay, just so we've got it on the record. Sorry, Lord Hunt, sorry to interrupt.
Thank you, thank you.
Can I just pick up a wider issue about what jurors can and cannot do in terms of talking to people? Now, if we're well aware that the current rules are that a juror may, following the trial, talk to anybody they'd like about the trial, everything that happened in open court, but they may not talk about what happened in the jury deliberation room, and that's the issue that we've just been touching on. However, if I am an ordinary member of the public who am observing the trial, then I too can talk to anybody I like.
I can also, as a member of the public, post on social media anything I like, subject to issues around harassment or misrepresentation and so on, but I can still do it. Could you explain to me why it is categorically stated that a juror cannot post comments about the trial on social media even after the trial has finished? This is contempt of court and you can be fined or sent to prison. Could you explain why a member of the public can go on social media but a juror cannot?
Sarah Sackman
Well, I think that's a well-established principle and for very good reason.
I think the member of the public posting on social media might be ill-advised to do so, but the whilst the law of course does not prevent jurors from seeking support and discussing what happened in open court, how it affected them, what support they need, the principle that jury's deliberations must remain confidential both during and after the trial, I think is a really important one. I think it preserves the integrity of that trial, it protects not just the juror themselves, but the other members of the jury. And I think, you know, in the same way, not just about posting, but in the same way that jurors are prohibited from carrying out internet searches on defendants and the like, I think it's a really important safeguard.
Speaker 36
I'm agreeing with every word, I'm agreeing with everything you've said.
Speaker 34
You're asking me to justify it, so I'm just saying it's the right thing to do.
Don Foster
I entirely accept that they cannot talk about what's in the jury room, and we may have exceptions for medical reasons or whatever, or we may not, but they cannot do that. They cannot say anything to anybody while the trial is in progress, and they cannot put anything on social media while the trial is in progress. All accepted. Members of the public, there are different rules for journalists, but members of the public sitting in the gallery, exactly the same rules. When the trial is over, it is finished.
Then a member of the public can post, subject to being careful not to misrepresent or whatever, because they could be put into court for that, but they can post on social media about what happened in open court.
But it specifically says that a juror may not post about what happened in open court on social media. And I'm just asking the question, why is there that distinction?
Sarah Sackman
Right. I think, I mean, I think I'm going to give you a pretty similar answer, which is that the juror has been directly involved in arriving at a verdict. Their commentary on what happened in open court on social media will inevitably stray or bleed into what is likely to have happened in the deliberation room and in the ultimate determination of, in terms of a verdict, at which they participated in arriving.
And so I think it's right that jurors be prevented from commentating on what happened in open court as well as what happened in the jury room. As for the differential treatment between the juror and another member of the public, we have an important principle as well as confidentiality in the jury room and that's one of open justice. And what happens in open court is there for anybody to see, freedom of expression being what it is, people can have their say on what happened. I think it would be very, very difficult to police that distinction between the deliberation room and open court if a juror were commentating and I think that would be a really unwise move to lift that prohibition and constraint on jurors.
Sarah Sackman
What happens in a deliberation room, what happens in the jury room is confidential. So it remains confidential and, you know, WhatsApp and other communication vehicles would be included in that.
Don Foster
Again, I'm not talking about making any comment about what happened in the deliberation room. I'm talking about what happened in open trial, which in some cases the public would have seen via television, will have heard about by newspapers, TV, everybody reporting about it, and will have been seen by people sitting in the public gallery.
In terms of all of that that is available currently, we have a situation where everybody else can go on social media, but the juror can't. I'm still struggling to understand why, but I'm then asking the separate question is, is WhatsApp considered as social media, and does that therefore mean that I as a juror cannot on my family group tell them what happened in open court? And if so, why not?
Sarah Sackman
Well, I'll invite Daniel Flury to comment in a second, but I'd just say this. Whether, so in principle, I think the reason for the constraint on jurors commenting on social media is very clear.
And I really do think it could, it could endanger the integrity of what had happened in the jury room. And, you know, you would not expect a judge post-trial beyond giving of sentencing remarks to commentate on what had happened in open court, even on a family WhatsApp group. I would regard that as inappropriate. So, in so far as it is helpful and it assists to give definitive guidance, I wouldn't get into the habit of family WhatsApp groups because we know actually that WhatsApp groups that you think are closed groups quickly can end up being broadcast more widely. So I would really, really guard against that.
It is not the place of jurors or judges to provide a commentary on what happened in the trial.
Beverley Hughes
Hopefully a more straightforward question. Although there's been changes in the Courts and Tribunal Bill on introduction to the Lords from where it started in the Commons, it still contains plans to reduce the number of either-way offences and I think some complex fraud cases being tried by jury. And, you know, that may suggest that a higher proportion of jurors will now be on more serious violent and sexual offences. Firstly, was an impact assessment of this bill undertaken before its introduction? And did, if so, did that assessment include the possible impact of more jurors dealing with more emotionally challenging and difficult cases?
Sarah Sackman
So yes, there was an impact assessment as you would expect and I'd invite members of the committee and more widely peers to refer to it as the bill has now entered your place. Did it look specifically at this question? I don't believe it did and that's for a good reason. I totally understand the premise of the question. What I would say is that the reforms to criminal courts proposed in the Courts and Tribunals Bill will not materially affect the juror experience that we are talking about.
Even under our current system, unreformed, jury trials have always been preserved for the most serious cases. The fact that 3% of our trials are conducted with a jury means that by definition the ones that we are I think most concerned about in the context of today's discussion, serious sexual violence, homicide, you know, the really horrible stuff, if I can call it that way, that's always been heard with a jury trial. So that doesn't that's not altered by these reforms because we would we were always preserving jury trial for those cases. I suppose that you're right, given that the reforms have the effect of diverting some cases that could that would be heard under the current system in the Crown to the magistrates, means that as a proportion jury trials are hearing more serious cases.
But really, those more serious cases have always been heard by a jury trial with a jury trial. That doesn't change as a result of these reforms, and therefore there's no particular need to look at that question, if that makes sense.
Beverley Hughes
Well, I understand what you're saying, but to be frank with you, it doesn't really make sense. If you think that more jurors will be hearing more difficult cases, then isn't there a case for you looking at the impact of that on the body of jurors as a whole, and whether or not you ought to make contingency for more support for jurors?
Sarah Sackman
But I don't know that more jurors will be hearing more serious cases. I think the serious cases that would always have been heard with a jury will continue to be heard with a jury.
Beverley Hughes
Some cases that would have gone to Crown will not go to Crown.
In fact, quite a number of cases will not go to Crown any longer. Now, both you and probably I are speculating, I think, in our discussion on what the nature of those cases might be. But given that previously they were indictable offences and could have gone to Crown, they will be in some way more serious cases, won't they?
Sarah Sackman
The only cases that will be retained by the magistrates under the reformed system fall in the category of triable either way, where the court under the new system deems them suitable to be heard with a magistrate.
So by definition, they would have to fall within the sentencing powers of the magistrates' court, which are obviously lower than the crown court. Juries are always being preserved for the most serious cases, including those traumatic ones. That doesn't change under the system. I hope that makes sense. So the sorts of cases that I expect to be retained within the magistrates' court, therefore not requiring a jury, are less serious cases of theft, for example.
The example that's often given is, you know, shoplifting, theft of a whisky bottle or something, which at the moment a defendant can elect for a jury trial. Under the reformed system, that right of election would be removed. The court would triage that case, and in many cases we think where the CPS makes representations and the court thinks it can retain it, it will keep it.
So that doesn't alter the jury experience. The jurors will still be hearing the diet of the most serious cases as they have always done. It doesn't change as a result of the reforms.
Beverley Hughes
So will you be monitoring the nature of the cases that hitherto would have gone to Crown that courts in future will then be able to decide that they stay in the magistrates? Will you be monitoring the nature of those?
Sarah Sackman
Yeah, I mean, I'm sure we will because it goes to, firstly, the efficient operation of our criminal justice system.
It's something we're going to look at: how is that triage being undertaken by the court operating in practice? And the other aspect to it is that as part of the bill, we've laid, we did at report stage, laid a government amendment to incorporate an independent review of how the reforms were operating, in particular to look at how that allocation plays out and is impacting those with protected characteristics, you know, really the impact on the defendant but also other participants in the system. So, yes, of course we're going to look at where cases are ending up because that is going to impact directly on our operation and the resource that we provide to the magistrates' court and the Crown Court to ensure we've got a system that's working well.
Beverley Hughes
Okay, just finally, if I may, one last point, Chair, if I may. You gave an example of theft, you know, obviously that's clearly a case of a certain kind.
But either-way offences that may no longer be heard by juries can include things like threat to kill, possession of a knife, burglary. And some of those cases, if the court decides they stay in the magistrates' court, I do put to you again, could contain issues that jurors will find difficult to cope with.
Sarah Sackman
But if they're in the magistrates' court, they won't have a jury. Do you see? I mean, we're here discussing the impact on jurors. Obviously, the allocation will be fact-specific. If it's something which has aggravating features, I'm confident the court will allocate it to the Crown.
But given what we're talking about here, which is the impact on jurors, if the court deems it suitable to be heard in the magistrates', then that will be a question for the magistrates' court, either a district judge or a magistrates' bench. It won't impact jurors at all.
Beverley Hughes
No, I take that point. But arguably some of those cases should be heard by jurors and therefore the impact on them should be considered.
Sarah Sackman
Right, but the principled question of whether you think that all these cases should be heard with a juror as they are now, that goes to the principles that lie behind the bill. And I'd remind the committee of a couple of things on that, not to get into the bill, but one, we have a crown court backlog of 80,000 cases and we undertook an independent review of criminal courts led by Lord Leveson, but also with David Ormerod and with very experienced crossbench peers, the likes of Lord Burnett, explaining that for a long time there've been many cases that have gone to the crown where both the CPS and the magistrates court have indicated they could hear them, but driven by the defendant's right to elect, they've ended up in the crown with all the resource implications and impact on the backlog that's had.
That's one of the rationales behind these reforms. The other rationale is the principle of removing the right to elect. We think that it's the court that should triage where cases, the venue where cases should take place so that the resource dedicated to them is appropriate to their seriousness. You know, of course we can have a debate about the merits of that bill, but in terms of the juror impact, which I think we're here to discuss today, if a case is retained by the magistrates because the court considers that's the best place for it, that won't impact jurors who will continue to have to hear, you know, some of the most serious cases as is right, because we think that jurors and juries are an essential feature of the English and Welsh legal system and they are a good thing and that's why they've always been retained as part of the courts and tribunals.
Elizabeth Berridge
Just on this question about the diet and when you set these national minimum standards, is the department doing any work on has the diet actually got more difficult for jurors in that there are, when we were at Southwark, there's more what they call RASSO cases, many rapes now are filmed, and is that going to be taken into account when you're setting national minimum standards, that the oral description of evidence is very different of an impact, we believe, on a juror than seeing moving footage, and the introduction of body-worn cameras means that, like, the discovery of a body can, if it's evidentially valuable, can be much more traumatic on a jury?
Daniel Flury
Yeah, no, this is just the sort of thing we do. We know that RASSO, rape and serious sexual offences, have massively grown over the last ten years, driven by, you know, police prosecution and so on. You turn the clock back ten years, fifteen years, it was lots of what we call acquisitive crimes. It's completely changed. I used to be in the London Crown Court, you know, sort of almost wall-to-wall RASSO cases going through.
And, you know, you're right as well, audio-visual has completely changed. The proliferation of body-worn camera, I think about sort of 75% of all Crown Court trials now have an element of audio-visual material. And this drives our training package.
You know, I mentioned trauma-informed training being rolled out across HMCTS. This is in response to, well, not just providing a better service to those who use the courts, but it also reflects the changing nature of the material that comes before the court, really. And we will continue to do that, either through the work of this committee or through the work of our own teams in trying to reflect what happens in the Crown and the Magistrates' Court and help our staff and those who use the Crown Court through that.
Sarah Sackman
Yeah, can I just, can I just add one more point there? I think it's a really good point. The changing pattern of crime and the increase in the number of RASSO cases, I think is a really important feature of the challenges that the criminal justice system is confronting. And you're absolutely right in that context to highlight the impact on jurors.
I mean, it's an important cultural shift in the whole criminal justice system that more of these cases are coming to court. And in that context, I just want to mention two things in addition to what we've been talking about today, but I think it's, you're absolutely right, it's pertinent to raise the impact on jurors. One is the extension of Operation Soteria principles to the Crown Court in relation to RASSO cases, and the commitment that the government's made and the investment committed to establishing specialist RASSO courts in every Crown Court centre.
Much as, you know, we're proud of that commitment, it's about a trauma-informed setting in which all the staff, the ticketed judge, everyone has trauma-informed training. Jurors will indirectly benefit from being in a setting where the material that surfaces in a typical rape or serious sexual violence case will be contextualized, handled, directed in terms of how evidence is given by court staff that are in receipt of trauma-informed training. So it's all part of a culture shift, but your question is a really good one because I think your point is don't forget the jurors.
Elizabeth Berridge
There's no trauma-informed change to the introduction to them if they're sitting on that trial before they sit on the trial that's specialist, so to that is there at the moment might be a national minimum standard?
Sarah Sackman
There isn't at the moment, but as I said, we are, we are going through a culture shift. Some of that is in national minimum standards, some of that is in the establishment of RASSO courts and the training around that, some of that is in the measures in the bill. The later, if you like, less controversial measures in the bill, some of those go to, you know, contain Law Commission clauses which go to how evidence is presented in those cases, which again indirectly will impact on jurors. And so, you know, the question is a pertinent one. What I would say is the system is responding to it in a number of ways.
Reg Empey
Good morning, Minister. Picking up what Lord Tope said earlier in respect of your first answer to the committee, you said you were paying a lot more attention to the position of jurors than had been in the past. And we know that a jury will consist of people with different backgrounds and employment characteristics, including if they're in the public sector, the chances are that they'll be paid while they're serving on a jury, whereas in the private sector, if you've a small business person, one-man band as it were, it comes back to how we pay expenses to jurors. And we know there's not unlimited resources, but when was the last review of juror expenses and when is the next one? Because the figure £5.71 is emblazoned into our memories as the supplement people are paid and quite clearly would barely buy somebody a cup of coffee in today's money.
So when was the last review undertaken and is there one pending?
Sarah Sackman
Good question. So the last review was undertaken in 2010. There has been no uplift in terms of juror expenses since. In 2023-24, we spent £36.9 million on juror expenses, two-thirds of which covered financial loss. I'm not going to gloss this.
The rates haven't been increased since 2010. The daily rate for a juror is £64.95.
That rises to £129.91 after 10 days, and then it rises to £228.06 after 200 days. You'll know that jurors can claim allowances for financial loss, additional care expenses, travel and subsistence, but no one is suggesting that the rates have kept pace with cost of living and inflation. We are asking people to do a civic duty, and I appreciate that for people from different backgrounds, those on lower incomes and certainly those working for small or even small businesses or self-employed, that can be particularly burdensome. What I can say is that we will look at this as we start to consider preparations for the next spending review.
But I do want to be entirely honest with the committee. We have prioritized within our criminal justice budget lifting the financial limit on sitting days, not least to address the backlog. That was a major financial commitment and also investing in criminal legal aid to keep these trials going. That's where we've chosen to put our money to keep the justice system going. And I just want to be as candid as I can about that.
Reg Empey
Minister, look, the committee's not naive enough to believe that money is in unlimited supply. But my goodness, 2010.
I think if anybody in the Department of Justice hadn't had their wages increased from 2010, there'd be an issue. So given the importance of the jury to the criminal justice system, I think we would like to ask you certainly to look at that very quickly. I mean, it is outrageously low, let's be honest.
Sarah Sackman
As I said, I'm committed to looking at it in the spending review and to undertaking it. But again, just to put in context the system we inherited, just as a point of analogy, in civil legal aid, the practitioners in civil legal aid, providers of civil legal aid in areas like housing, had not received an uplift since 1996.
Now, I've corrected that and I've committed 20 million pounds to civil legal aid in terms of housing and immigration. There are other areas that are yet to receive an uplift, but that is the stark position in which the Ministry of Justice found itself, being on the receiving end of real-term cuts for a number of years. So, I appreciate the point that's being put to me, and I don't fundamentally disagree with the principle and the force with which it's made. But I think we have to put in context the choices that ministers are faced with. And we are making record investments in sitting days, criminal legal aid, and also in court maintenance, something from which, again, jurors do indirectly and indeed directly benefit from.
The 287 million pound capital budget, some of that will be going on the facilities that jurors have to interact with. That is a good thing. So, I will look at it, and I will consider what can be done within the scope of the next spending review, certainly.
But I think it's important to put it in context and explain the choices that we've made.
Don Foster
Could I just ask, I think we all understand the difficulties both you have in answering as a minister and not the Chancellor of the Exchequer and so on, and we all appreciate that the department has to make choices. So we're all understand where you're coming from, but I think you will understand the committee's been very disturbed by some of the information we have received about the impact.
If we take some of the extreme cases just to illustrate it, if for example I am a juror and I am to be able to do my civic duty I need my I need childminding, taking an average childminding cost and for a two-week trial they would need to find upfront somewhere in the region of 700 pounds. Upfront. And they're not able to claim back until after the trial. And for some people that is almost I mean it's a huge sum of money.
Don Foster
So so there are issues around when people are paid and and whether or not we can't go back to a system that used to enable people to be able to pay at the time and so on. So the cost isn't going to go up, there might need to be a bit more monitoring cost I'll accept. The cost might the cost is not overall going to go up, it's just a case of payment to make it easier for the individual juror.
What thought's been given to that?
Sarah Sackman
I recognize those sorts of costs. As someone who's got two young children, I recognize those costs of childcare. There are other forms of caring responsibility. And no one is suggesting that in the current climate, the cost of living being what it is, that this isn't a significant burden. There are hardship exceptions.
One can either upon summons or even indeed at court apply for jury service to be deferred and in rare cases, but there are cases, to be excused altogether. But I think you're right to highlight that the burden on juries and indeed something we've not highlighted but on particularly where we're talking about small businesses and employers where, you know, losing a member of a team for some significant time without recompense can also be a burden as well. So no one is suggesting that this isn't a duty but a degree of sacrifice as well.
Don Foster
Well, I think we could question what level of sacrifice we should expect people to make.
But I think the real concern would be that if you have situations where somebody could, and we know that they can, say, "Look, I simply can't do jury service because I simply cannot be able to afford to do it," and they could be excused, and the rules allow that. But unfortunately, that then has an impact on the jury pool. It's no longer truly representative of society. And so it really does seem to me that looking at something about ensuring there is not a delay in payment may not solve the problem about nothing's been done since 2010, which obviously we will raise in our report, but at least payment up front is not going to cost you more money, but could actually ease the burden for quite a lot of people.
Daniel Flury
We do and we can make interim payments to jurors whilst a trial is ongoing, whether that's for taxis or certain expenses to ensure that they can get through some of the hardship that a trial may bring. But you're right, we do defer or excuse thousands each month, principally in the name of illness or mental health, but a larger number of them are for principally caring responsibilities.
Don Foster
I would strongly recommend you have a look at them and you're asking people to do that and also, well, anyhow, have a look at the forms, you might wish to consider how they're written. Look, I'm very grateful for the questions we've had on our main inquiry.
Minister, we've got a few more minutes, but only a few before I know you have to go off to other things. But I know a number of my colleagues would like to use this as an opportunity since the Courts and Tribunals Bill is beginning its passage through the House of Lords only today that there might be some colleagues with the odd question or two if you're happy to answer them. So I throw it open to any of colleagues who wish to do so. Go on.
Lord Bach
This is very dangerous stuff, but Minister, speaking personally and appreciate very much what this government has managed to do in terms of those issues you raised just now about raising fees that have not been raised for a very, very long time, including a time when I was the Legal Aid Minister.
So I don't do this with any sort of grandeur, just to ask you really, do you realize, does the department realize that law centers, and I should declare that I'm chair of a, an unremunerated chair of a law center, that law centers generally, who do, I hope you believe, very good work, are feeling very much at the moment, like everybody else, but feeling very much that some are not capable of doing it because, because the world we live in.
And Hillingdon Law Centre closed its doors after 40 years just the other week, which will have presumably a profound effect on people living in that part of West London. I wonder, given all the fiscal difficulties that there definitely are for the MOJ, whether you are giving some thought as to what you may be able to do in order to help. Now this is more like a parliamentary question than it is at a committee like this, but it's the first time we've really had a chance of discussing these issues of social welfare law and law centres. Hope that's clear, Minister.
Sarah Sackman
I hugely value the work that our law centres and other support charities, Citizens Advice Bureaus do.
They provide a lifeline and very importantly early legal advice for people. I'm visiting North Kensington Law Centre tomorrow. And I started my own career at the Free Legal Advice Centre at Toynbee Hall in the East End of London. So my commitment to law centers and my understanding of the value of the work they do runs deep. And it's why as a first step the government committed sixteen million pounds, so multi-year support, to legal support for several dozen organizations.
I think they value that multi-year support knowing they're going to have the money for future years. But as the Minister responsible for both legal support and legal aid, I'm really keen that we move to a more preventative model because getting that early legal advice is often as important, if not more important sometimes, than spending lots of money on legal aid by which time the problems become very acute. The analogy with health sometimes works, a little bit like, you know, being seen early by your GP and nipping a problem in the bud early before it gets more serious and you end up in court. So the value of law centres is patently obvious to me. I think we need more of it.
I would like to shift some of our spending to earlier in the process.
And I'd like to do that as we build up to the 80th anniversary of the 1949 Act, which instituted legal aid, to really enhance our law center movement because I think that what they do is hugely valuable. And when we talk in this country about access to justice, I think in today's day and age where there's huge amounts of information, but it's not necessarily provided by people who understand how to give that advice, there really is no excuse for legal aid deserts. So we're looking both at supporting law centers financially, but also developing sources of government-credited advice using technology so that the promise of access to advice really is a universal one. So we've got lots of exciting things happening in the department. And I just want to reassure you that your kind of enthusiasm and passion for law centers is one that I absolutely share.
Beverley Hughes
Oh, thank you, Chair. I'm sorry for asking you this question, Minister, because you're not responsible for this at all. But here you are now, and therefore I have to. You mentioned before the backlog in court proceedings, both in the magistrates and obviously in the Crown, and the delays in people waiting for their case to be heard and the lack of justice that that means for people. Magistrates' courts, I think, are really struggling, and many people are waiting for trials in very sensitive cases for years.
Can you report any progress being made in reducing the delays in court proceedings, both in magistrates and in the Crown?
Sarah Sackman
Well yes I can. Our approach, I call it the kitchen sink approach, by which I mean we've got to throw everything at it. There is no silver bullet for addressing the delays both in the Crown Court and to a lesser extent, but we keep a watchful eye on the magistrates' court. But the central insight of Lord Leveson's independent review is that you needed three things. Firstly investment, and the biggest investment which I've already referred to earlier is lifting the cap on sitting days.
When we had a financial limit on how much Crown Courts could sit, it meant that even those Crown Court centres that were operating really well, really efficiently, like in Liverpool, meant that when they hit their cap they couldn't sit anymore. We've lifted that.
What that means is that Liverpool is not just getting through its backlog, it's also taking on some cases from Manchester. I was there the other day. We are sitting more. We're getting through more cases. And if you look at the rate of growth of the backlog, I'm not saying it's coming down, I'm getting to that, but, but, but, it has stabilized significantly because of the investment we've made.
The second thing Lord Leveson said is efficiencies. We've got to make the system more efficient. We've published our response to the Leveson review. We're accepting a whole program of work around efficiencies. You'll have heard me talk about the video remand hearings.
You'll have heard me talk about a case progression officer in every Crown Court center. We're doing short trial courts, sometimes known as blitz courts. You might have seen them at the Bailey on your visit.
There are a host of measures we're doing to make the system work more efficiently. But the third one, and this is the most pertinent one for today. The IRCC concluded that without structural reform, we would not bear down on these delays. So are we making progress? We are in areas one and two.
We're making progress in so far as the bill has come from the Commons and is now coming to you for very important scrutiny. But we will not get the backlog in our Crown Court down unless we look at the whole system and really ask ourselves where do cases need to be heard. The most serious cases must always be reserved for a jury trial. But cases which don't need a jury trial and can be heard just as fairly in the magistrates' court should be retained there. That is one of the central premises, premises, the central premise of the Courts and Tribunals Bill.
And I hope that the bill will get on the statute books.
When we have all three levers, I think we can get the backlog down. That's what our modelling shows.
Don Foster
Can I just ask the sort of noddy question that people might ask? I mean, you might well succeed in getting the Crown Court backlog down, but are you not going to increase the backlog in the magistrates' court?
Sarah Sackman
Well, you're right to ask the question that I've asked of our officials who are planning, which is that we don't want to divert the problem from one place to another. The way we avoid that is twofold. The starting point is that the magistrates' court is a more efficient jurisdiction. So for a trial-either-way case that could be heard in the Crown, could be heard in the magistrates, those cases are heard four times faster in the magistrates. So it is an efficient jurisdiction.
It doesn't have a backlog, it has a caseload, but it doesn't have a backlog anything like as bad as the Crown Court. But the second thing we have to do, and we are doing, is increase the capacity of the magistrates' court. And we're doing this in a number of ways. The committee will know about the magistrates' recruitment campaign. Our objective is to have recruited 21,000, well, an additional 7,000, but to get up to 21,000 magistrates, which is where we were in 2014, by the end of this Parliament.
We are recruiting more legal advisers, 160 additional legal advisers. We're recruiting more district judges. So we have to expand the capacity of the magistrates' court in order to cope with the additional demands that we are placing on it.
But what I am pleased to report in the stats that we published just a few days ago is that in terms of our recruitment programme, which we've reformed, which we've invested in, we've increased the marketing budget by fourfold and we've got a team that is working on the uplift programme, we're on track. We're on track to do this so that by the time the reforms I hope kick in, the magistrates' court will be ready to receive that additional workload. We can't turn on the reforms unless it's ready and we won't do, but I'm confident that we can be ready.
Don Foster
And what discussions have you had with HMPPS about the impact of basically more trials overall throughout the whole system taking place and therefore the increased pressure on prisons and the probation service?
Sarah Sackman
Well, as you can imagine, that has been a really important part of the discussion. I was asked earlier about an impact assessment. That is detailed in the impact assessment.
The effect of being more efficient, you get through more trials, is you, is you increase demand and pressure on the prison system, which as we know is already under huge pressure. But what you also do is you get through the remand cases as well. And that can be of huge benefit, not just to the individuals who are on remand and whose lives are in limbo, either unable to engage with the routines that they would were they in the permanent estate, or frankly allowed to go free if they're innocent. So those, those impacts are complex, but they've been modeled to a, a really, really high degree, and that's all set out in the impact assessment.
Don Foster
No, I mean, it's very important, the reduction of the remand prisoners is going to be of enormous benefit.
I mean, it's currently 20% of the prison population, which is just ludicrous. Look, you've been very generous and you offered to be generous with your time so we could touch on a couple of issues to do with the Courts and Tribunals Bill, but for that and for your answers, both of you, thank you very much indeed in relation to our jury inquiry. If there are any further things that you sort of thought you should have told us or you wish you'd told us or perhaps want to change the words you used or whatever, please get back to us. But could I ask you to do it really quickly because just we need to get on and produce our report, so it's helpful to you in the deliberations that you are having. But on behalf of the entire committee, thank you very much indeed.
Order, order, the sitting is ended.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.