House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 6
Well, can I thank her for that question? She's put it really well. Can I just reassure her that we absolutely do keep these things under review? I have said it's top of my in-tray and it remains so. I'm acutely aware of the cost of living pressures that many graduates in their 20s and early 30s, particularly those on Plan 2, are under, and it is affecting their decisions about work and life.
And that's why this issue is one that I'll continue to push at, and hopefully I'll have something more to say soon.
Jonathan Luke Charters
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
May I also pass on my condolences to the Prime Minister and his family? Mr. Speaker, I would declare that I am a Plan 2 borrower myself, and I know firsthand how unclear the loans were at the time. Would my honorable friend, right honorable friend, say a little more about how the government's clearing up the guidance given to borrowers and how she wishes to overhaul the Student Loans Company?
Speaker 6
Well, can I thank him and thank him for all his campaigning on this issue, which I've followed closely? He's absolutely right. In response to the excellent report of the Treasury Select Committee, we have committed to much clearer guidance for students before they make decisions about going to university, so that they can be much clearer about how the student loan system will work and possibly affect them in the future.
And I think this is a really important piece of work. And can I also just say that we have capped the maximum interest rates this year, and we are reintroducing maintenance grants, Mr. Speaker.
Saqib Bhatti
Saqib Bhatti, Shadow Minister.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I associate my remarks with the Secretary of State's regarding the Prime Minister's father. Despite previously calling the student loan system egregious and saying reviewing the system is a top priority, she just said it's at the top of her in-tray. The Treasury response to the Treasury Select Committee rejected a series of recommendations that would have alleviated some of the burden on Plan 2 student loans. So I ask the Secretary of State, what exactly is her plan to fix the student loan system?
Speaker 6
Well, as I've said, you know, I'm determined that we get these things right. And the two things can be true at the same time, that I feel that this system is unfair and in need of reform, whilst also at the same time we have to sit that in the context of the wider public finances and all the pressures and priorities that are falling on it. But I do have to say, Mr. Speaker, I do feel it's slightly audacious of the party opposite. You know, they introduced the Plan 2 system. They froze the threshold four times when they were in government.
They're not independent campaigners on this issue today. It now falls in my lap to actually deal with it, and I will do that, unlike the party opposite.
Speaker 6
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions two and six together. Firstly, I'd like to thank Alan Milburn for his commitment to our young people.
This is one of our country's biggest challenges, and I agree with him that education is the faltering foundation. Our current system is leaving too many behind. Countries that combine high academic standards with quality technical education boast low levels of NEET rates, and that's why I'm determined to make this country a technical education superpower.
Christine Jardine
Thank you very much, and can I associate myself both with your own comments, Mr. Speaker, and those of the Secretary of State. Figures quoted today in the BBC suggest that as many as one in five of young people in education may not be attending regularly at college courses.
So the situation may actually be even worse than outlined in the Milburn report. And while I welcome the Secretary of State's commitment to a fundamental encouragement of technical education, does she think that we are at the stage where we are approaching a crisis and what we need to do is rethink exactly what it is will engage our young people in education, that they're not getting from it what they need to feel prepared for their future life, and how we should go about that?
Speaker 6
Well, can I first of all thank my honorable friend? She's I think one of the highest contributors to education questions, as she was when I was Leader of the House in business questions, and I look forward to continuing debating these issues with her. She's absolutely right.
Attendance, inclusion, and critically engagement are also pivotal to this issue. And that's why we do need to look at not just the curriculum and new qualifications that young people can have, but ensuring that they have the passport that they need for life and they are engaged and wanting to go to school or college every day.
John Grady.
Speaker 12
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over summer, I met with many brilliant businesses in Glasgow East who are desperate and determined to give young people apprenticeships, opening the door to a lifetime of opportunities. But what many of them told me was that they have to give basic training on maths to help young people thrive in jobs like plumbing, joinery, and welding. And they rightly think that schools in Scotland and Glasgow should be teaching this. Does my right honorable friend agree with me that much more needs to be done in Scotland to improve the teaching of maths in schools?
Well, absolutely.
Speaker 6
Last week's PISA results show the importance of those foundations in English, maths and science, which over a 25 or 30 year consensus we've really motored on in England. Scotland, however, not so well. And he will know that Scotland's education system used to be the envy of the world. That's not the case today. And I think it's about time the Scottish government really took a leaf out of England's book.
Rishi Sunak
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for her commitment to this issue and indeed the honourable member for Glasgow East's focus on maths? On Friday, I visited Allerton Steel, a steel fabricator in Northallerton. They do a great job providing high-quality apprenticeships for young people every year, regardless of the cycle. I was lucky to meet David, Oliver and Jacob.
Wonderful to see their passion, their excitement about their futures. So will the Secretary of State join me in wishing them well, but also commend businesses like Allerton Steel, local companies up and down the country, that are ultimately the ones providing these opportunities for our young people?
Speaker 6
Well, I'm absolutely delighted to join him in thanking Allerton Steel for all the work that they do in supporting young people in and around his constituency with apprenticeships. And he's absolutely right. I held a summit at Number 10 North, which I'm sure he's wanting to come and visit at some point soon, last week with school and college leaders, with business leaders as well. And you know, there's a real sense of galvanizing the whole of the business community who are really determined to play their part in tackling this issue.
Lloyd Hatton
Mr Speaker, Dorset Innovation Park is home to a number of defence firms that are looking to expand.
However, too many young people right across South Dorset are unable to get the qualifications that these employers are looking for. So will the Minister work with Dorset Council, Yeovil College and myself to establish a satellite college at the Innovation Park, giving more young people that direct pathway into high-skilled, high-paid jobs?
Speaker 6
Well, can I thank him for all the work that he does in his constituency on these issues too? And he's absolutely right, we've got to get opportunities to young people near where they live, working in the kind of partnership way that he describes. And I'm happy to meet with him to discuss how we can get such opportunities well into his constituency.
Rebecca Smith
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
The government continues to point the finger for NEETs at one of the areas that is performing comparatively well: our schools. Meanwhile, in Labour-led Wales, which ignored the Conservative government's education reforms, school standards have fallen and the NEETs crisis is even worse than in England. So why is the government blaming schools for NEETs when the bigger problem is the collapse of entry-level jobs for young people?
Speaker 6
Well, can I just gently say to the honorable lady, it's not just that we have over a million young people not in education, training, or employment, most of whom were educated under the party opposite. We also now have one and a half million students persistently absent from school. We have a very stubborn disadvantage gap which didn't close under their watch. We have widening regional attainment gaps.
We have a SEND crisis that we're having to deal with that they didn't do. And I think perhaps more importantly, the treadmill of resits that this party opposite put our young people on, failure after failure after failure. Just this summer, Mr. Speaker, less than 14%, less than 14% of our young people passed their resit in maths. That's the legacy that they left and I'm going to rectify it.
Munira Wilson
Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Munira Wilson.
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Could I also send my condolences to the Prime Minister on the death of his father and the condolences of everyone on the Liberal Democrat benches. Mr. Speaker, Alan Milburn is clear that exposure to the workplace for teenagers is critical to helping them secure employment when they leave education. Yet we know that less than a third of year 13 students have completed work experience.
Now the government has said it's committed to more work placements, which is welcome. So can I ask the Secretary of State, instead of overhauling the school system, will she instead focus on working with the Chancellor and the Business Secretary to reverse the jobs tax and other policies that have made it increasingly difficult for businesses to offer either work experience or a traditional first job for young people?
Speaker 6
Well, can I thank her for that? She, look, I think we need to do all of these things. Alan Milburn was absolutely clear that education was the faltering foundation. We're seeing too many young people leaving school without the qualifications that they need to go on and get either an apprenticeship or into work, and that's why there's so many NEETs there as well.
And we're seeing too many young people disengaged from school much earlier on as well, and this is all part of the NEETs crisis too. Of course, young people aren't subject to NICs in the same way as older people are, and neither are apprenticeships either. And we have put in place a number of things, like the support for those wanting to take up an apprenticeship, the four thousand pound bursary. So we're doing a huge amount at the other end as well, but we do need to deal with the supply issue.
Jane Croft.
Speaker 6
Yeah, it's me again, Mr. Speaker.
I feel under pressure as a former Leader of the House to know exactly where I am in the order paper. But can I first of all thank my honorable friend for all the work that she does on the issue of SEND, and I listened closely to her speeches in the recent Health Bill debate, and can I assure her that these reforms are essential and that no one department can do them alone, and that's why we're working closely with the Department of Health.
Jennifer Craft
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I do welcome the Secretary of State's kind words just now. I'd also like to associate myself with her remarks and the remarks of yourself, Mr. Speaker, relating to the Prime Minister's very sad loss. She speaks of the health debate that was up last week, where I received a commitment to much greater accountability via the Education Bill for the health sector in delivering the health part of the SEND system. I'd be grateful if she could outline what work has been done with colleagues from the Department of Health to bring this forward.
Speaker 6
Well, again, can I thank her for her really doughty campaigning on these issues.
She's absolutely right. We have to, as part of the SEND reforms, Mr. Speaker, we have to ensure that we've got accountability right through the system. That means in health as much as in education and other sectors as well. And I can assure her that we're working incredibly closely with the Department of Health. And I've spoken to the new Secretary of State for Health a number of times about this issue.
And I look forward to shaping those reforms with her in the coming weeks.
Mark Pritchard.
Mark Pritchard
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I congratulate the right honorable lady for her return to the Cabinet?
The two main points that parents with children with SEND in my constituency would make to her in her new role is one, the length of time it takes for the education, health and care plans to be decided, and secondly, the number of specialist school places that are available both in Shropshire and in Telford and Wrekin. And so can I ask the Secretary of State what plans she has to improve that and to intervene where local authorities are not performing?
Speaker 6
Well, again, can I thank him for having raised these issues many times? And he's absolutely right. The current system isn't working for parents and it isn't working for children. It's far too adversarial. There's too many delays in the system.
And then often parents find they can't get the support that they actually want at the end of it.
So making sure we've got adequate places, which is why we've put already put in an extra 3.7 billion pounds to support those extra places, but also why we need to make sure there's there's strong levers of accountability here with local authorities and others as well and I can rest he can rest assured that we are looking at all of those issues right now.
Samantha Debley.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In my constituency of South Derbyshire, schools including Fairmeadows Foundation Primary applied to Reform-led Derbyshire County Council for capital funding for SEND provision within their mainstream setting. They were told their application was successful in July and again in September of 2025. Funding to come from a pot believed to be around 7 million with an extra 500,000 being mentioned on the 10th of September this year. But so far, no funding has been released.
So I personally raised this with the leader of the County Council Alan Graves in June and we've chased for this again and chased again last week and we were told that the SLAs are still being worked on.
So can I please ask the Minister to join me in calling upon Derbyshire County Council to get on with releasing these moneys?
Speaker 6
Well, I'm really sorry to hear that the Reform-led council in Derbyshire is not following through quickly enough on its commitment to SEND families in the council area. She's... we will of course pick those up, and that's why we are working very closely with all local authorities on their SEND reform plans, and we're making sure that they will be actioning them quickly.
Speaker 23
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Research from the Department for Education confirms that children who move schools frequently often suffer poor outcomes, particularly children with special educational needs.
And this is why a number of service families, armed forces families, people on average incomes, choose to use independent education to minimize the disruption that follows from their postings. So can I ask the Secretary of State and new education team, will she publish, perhaps jointly with the MOD, just some research showing whether the introduction of VAT on school fees has led to an increase in in-year moves, particularly for service families?
Speaker 6
Well, he rightly identifies an issue. That's why we're introducing new individual support plans, which will be national, they'll be digital, so that they will move around with children as well. We obviously want to minimize the number of times that students do move schools or have to then reassess their support when they get there. I don't believe there's been a particular issue for children from armed forces families in relation to the VAT on private schools, but I'm happy to look into it for him.
Speaker 6
It's still me, it's still me. Can I first of all thank the honorable lady for all the work that she does on the Education Select Committee. Reforms to curriculum and assessment go hand in hand with our vision to ensure that education is a passport for work, life, and success. Becky Francis did a fantastic job for us on this and we will soon publish proposals to go out to consultation that build on this review. These proposals will ensure a broader, more inclusive education system with fewer barriers to progression, stronger technical and vocational options, more emphasis on oracy, as well as more stepping stone qualifications.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government has committed to providing an enrichment entitlement for every child, including access to nature. And evidence shows that outdoor education can be part of the solution to some of the biggest issues facing our young people: the mental health and obesity crises, the rise in NEETs, and also a failing SEND system. But when a fifth of children in the most deprived parts of the country never spend meaningful time outdoors, something has to change. And a framework for schools isn't enough.
We need a step change. So will the Secretary of State back my Outdoor Education Bill so that every child can grow up outdoors with better mental wellbeing, physical health, attainment, attendance, and employability?
Speaker 6
Well, again, can I thank her for all the campaigning she's done on this issue and for bringing forward, you know, I think a really important bill to this House so that we can debate these issues.
Actually, I think they go wider than the school system. I think this is more a bigger piece about what childhood means in the 21st century and how we can all support children to be independent, to have success and good wellbeing and to be happy. And of course, playing and being outdoors is a critical part of that.
Speaker 27
Thank you, Mr Speaker. An important feature of the curriculum assessment review was the recognition and the commitment to strengthening financial literacy as a vital life skill for young people. To make sure that we can deliver on that ambition, participating in the OECD's PISA financial literacy assessment can help us both measure our progress and also identify gaps in that progress.
So can the Secretary of State set out what assessment she has made of the merits of UK participation in 2029 and might she meet with me to discuss it?
Speaker 6
Well, first of all, can I say we've expressed an interest in taking part in the financial literacy assessment for PISA in 2029 because as he's absolutely right, we recognize the importance of financial education for children and young people. And we're going to be strengthening this in the maths and citizenship curriculums coming up. And I'm really happy to have a meeting with him to discuss how we can take this further.
Tim Farron.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I commend my honorable friend and member for South Devon for her bill that she's already spoken about?
And can I draw the Secretary of State's attention to the change of the law in the Scottish Parliament recently, which means that every young person at school has an entitlement to four nights residential, five days out and about in a residential situation, because the massive benefit that will bring to their resilience, their love of learning, their capacity to work together in teams. Isn't it time, given that 81% of children from the poorest backgrounds never get access to outdoor education, that we should consider doing something similar?
Speaker 6
Well, I'm absolutely with him on the importance of residential activities and for every young person to have access to them. I'm not sure if Ghyll Head is in his constituency, he's nodding away, which I went to as a child, it's owned by Manchester City Council and my children have been to Ghyll Head. It's a fantastic facility and of course my ambition is that every child has the opportunity to go somewhere as fantastic as Ghyll Head and I'm happy to work with him on these issues.
Peter Swallow
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer the Prime Minister set out his ambition for our education system, saying that whether you choose construction, coding or classics, Labour will build an education system where you'll get the skills you need.
As the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Classics, I really welcome this. Can I ask the Secretary of State to set out what her vision is for arts and humanities in our curriculum so we can make sure that those subjects which are so good at empowering young people with skills are taken up by more young people?
Speaker 6
Well, he's already spoken to me a number of times about these issues because he's a very good chair of the APPG on Classics. And can I thank him for his question? And he's absolutely right. I mean, I think that's what we have got to recognize, Mr. Speaker, is that the current offer in our education system has got narrower and narrower. And even bringing in measures like EBacc has not actually helped to preserve important subjects like classics and computer science.
In fact, they've fallen significantly since its introduction. So I want to ensure that all our young people have got access to these great academic subjects as well as technical ones.
Patrick Spencer
A welcome to new shadow minister, shadow minister Patrick Spencer.
Mr. Speaker, over the weekend, the Secretary of State backtracked on an interview she gave to the Observer where she said she wanted to reintroduce coursework. Now, for the record, we were very, we were very pleased to hear this. However, in that same interview, you made, she made a number of other commitments, which included reducing the number of exams children take at the age of 16 and introducing a GCSE in football coaching.
Speaker 6
Oh dear, Mr Speaker, honestly. You know, they had a go at it last week and it didn't go very well, so they're having another go this week. If you can find where I said that I wanted to bring back coursework, bring it to me because I didn't say that. No, I didn't, I didn't at all. I gave a 10-minute statement to this House last week, Mr Speaker, and I answered questions for 90 minutes, and I think that gave a very clear account of what I want to do.
But you know, they want to defend their narrowing and narrowing of the curriculum without actually accepting responsibility for the effects of that. Yes, I do want to ensure that great subjects like computing actually involve using a computer, because they took that out of the curriculum entirely. I want to make sure that PE actually involves some PE. Call me a radical, Mr. Speaker, but you know, I think that is something that goes hand in hand. And I make no apology at all either for wanting to see oracy very much at the heart of our curriculum in school.
They send their kids to private school where they all come out really confident, where they all come out confident in speaking, and I want that for every child.
Paul Waugh
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Apprenticeships are the responsibility of the Department for Work and Pensions, but the DfE is supporting apprenticeships by introducing new technical and vocational pathways from 14 to 19 years, including new V-levels from 2027, new level 2 pathways, and even more T-levels, from which young people can progress to apprenticeships and higher education. These new 14 to 19 qualifications will enable students to progress more easily and onto apprenticeships.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Minister to his place and congratulate him on his appointment. The government is right to focus on the importance of parity between vocational education and academic education. However, when comparing the academic year 2025-26 with 23-24, the number of people that have started apprenticeships has dropped by 9% and the number that have completed has gone down by 17%.
So, in with reference to the Minister's point about vocational pathways, can he update the House on what steps the government is taking to ensure that these are linked with the needs of industry so that this in itself does not become an academic exercise?
Paul Waugh
Well, may I return those congratulations by congratulating the honorable member on his elevation to the shadow front bench, and can I congratulate him too on the work he's done on vocational skills, including in his jobs fair in Bromsgrove. It's worth saying that actually, V-levels are precisely designed to tally with what employers want. That's exactly why we're reforming the system to make sure that every child is going to have the right technical education. And more importantly, I think that more broadly, the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State have said that that parity of esteem between vocational and academic education is exactly what everyone in this country wants.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I put on record my condolences to the Prime Minister on the sad loss of his father.
The Education Select Committee strongly agrees with the government's focus on expanding opportunities for apprenticeships and high-quality technical and vocational education across the country. But too often young people wanting to pursue apprenticeships are left to do their own research across multiple different platforms with varying application timescales. Last year, the Education Select Committee recommended that to help young people understand the full range of opportunities available to them and provide parity of esteem, there should be a single point of access for information about apprenticeships alongside vocational, technical, and academic courses.
Will the new Minister look again at this recommendation and seek to ensure young people wishing to do apprenticeships and vocational and technical courses are just as well supported as their peers who are applying for university?
Paul Waugh
Can I thank my honourable friend for the hard work the Education Select Committee's done on exactly this topic? She's absolutely right, there should be that parity of esteem, there should be the equivalent of an UCAS system for our children that are going into technical education. My honourable friend the Baroness Smith is looking at precisely this subject and we aim to come up with some answers very soon.
John Hayes
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You will recall, Mr. Speaker, and the Minister in his earlier life will too, that when I was the Skills Minister, we built the biggest number of apprenticeships in modern history. And I did so because I believe in elevating the practical. But too often careers advice and guidance delivered in schools drives people down the academic route to study degrees that have neither academic rigour nor economic value.
So will he look again at the advice and guidance given to people so their aptitudes, talents and tastes can be met by good quality vocational technical education.
Paul Waugh
I thank the honorable gentleman for all his hard work as the former skills minister on exactly this subject. I think the House is in agreement on this subject. The Prime Minister rightly says, Mr. Speaker, that we should be focusing on problem solving rather than point scoring. Given that he mentions apprenticeship starts, it would be remiss of me not to point out that apprenticeship starts under this government have gone up by 8.7% whereas they collapsed under the last government since 2020.
Speaker 42
Mr. Speaker, can I just say to my right honorable friend that it's obviously the crucial role that further education colleges play in apprenticeships and the support they give for education.
I wonder whether he could tell me what extra measures the government is doing to ensure that further education colleges can actually ensure they provide a wide range of education and technical skills to apprentices coming into their colleges.
Paul Waugh
My right honorable friend is a doughty champion for the FE within his own constituency, and that's exactly what many members are doing across the House. He's right about FE education. Many of our specialists who are engaged in teaching further education and vocational skills are indeed addressed at addressing this point. And that's why many of them support our move to V-levels because they are aligned with what employers want. Employers are telling us they want those job skills to be more in tune with the academic skills, and that's what we're delivering.
Apsana Begum.
Minister.
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, the inclusive mainstream fund is part of a four billion pound investment over three years to support early intervention and SEND support. Long term, the government aims to move more money from the high needs block directly into school budgets, ring-fenced for SEND, so they can plan their workforce, intervene earlier, ending the long waits for support that too many young people see in the current system.
Speaker 45
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Following a recent visit to Tushingham Primary School, the headteacher raised concerns with me that for many small rural schools like Tushingham and Shocklach, the new inclusion fund does not compensate for the impact of changes to the school's block funding. Now, not every child with SEND needs one-to-one support, but many do need teaching assistants and other staff to help them regulate, access learning, and benefit from targeted support.
If school budgets are being squeezed, it's often that support which is, which ends up having to be reduced. So how will the Minister ensure that these funding changes do not inadvertently reduce the support that children with SEND need in order to thrive in mainstream schools?
Minister.
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I thank the honorable member for, for that question. The, the reforms are not fully coming in until 2030, so the extra money through the inclusive mainstream fund is sitting alongside investment through the current system and EHCPs. So once the reforms are fully in place, there will be more money going directly into schools, and the inclusive mainstream fund is to build up that, that funding in the meantime. And schools will also be benefiting from the experts at hand service, which is 1.8 billion into specialists.
Sonia Kumar.
Sonia Kumar
Dudley can't afford to lose another generation of young people to unemployment, exclusion, or missed opportunity. Our NEETs rate was recognized in Alan Milburn's review. Local leaders at my February NEETs roundtable were clear: an alternative provision for children with SEND is desperately needed, and Dudley College has brought forward a credible plan. Will the Minister recognize that urgency and back children in Dudley by approving this plan?
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I thank my honorable friend for her question. We're investing 3.7 billion into new specialist places, and I will of course meet with her to discuss the specific school.
Saqib Bhatti
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Six months ago, the previous Secretary of State revealed the government's plan to carry out SEND reforms.
Since then, we've had a new Prime Minister and a new Secretary of State, who did last week state her intentions to carry out those reforms. Yet there was little detail as to how the government will fill the 2 billion pound black hole in SEND budgets, while we all know that fiscal pressures on the government continue to increase. So I ask the Minister, when will the legislation come to the House, and where will the money come from? Parents, teachers, and children deserve answers.
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, we've been absolutely clear about the investment we're making into SEND: 4 billion into early intervention, 3.7 billion into capital investment, funding that did not come when their government was in power.
We really welcome the opportunity to bring all of the ideas of the House together, but I am waiting to hear what the honourable members opposite actually think about the SEND reforms and I really look forward to them clarifying that.
for children, including those with neurodivergence. The work undertaken by a neurodivergence task and finish group has
But we do want to go further, and SEND will be a core focus for the 2027 review, as well as—
Alison Bennett
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
For some neurodivergent children, mainstream school is not a place where they can succeed. One such child is Libby, who's 14, and following a mental health crisis, EOTAS has been an absolute godsend for her. But her mum, her amazing mum Carrie, is really worried about the future. So can the Minister tell me what steps she's taking to ensure that parents and children have a say in what future EOTAS provision looks like?
Mr. Speaker, I'm sure the Minister will agree that for a child with a PDA profile of autism, you're going to require a totally different strategy from staff at the reception desk or from teachers.
Speaker 49
With different profiles of autism, you're going to require a totally different strategy from staff at the reception desk or from teachers. So will the Minister commit to ensuring that the Department works with the autism community to design teacher training to really focus on these different profiles and the responses to them? And could she confirm that this will be part of the core training for all school staff?
Proposals were carefully working through all the detailed responses we got to those questions.
Speaker 44
Proposals were carefully working through all the detailed responses we got to those consultation questions and we will be bringing forward the bill as quickly as possible.
Speaker 50
Merci, Mr Speaker. Several schools across my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency are reporting to me their profound concerns about the lack of availability of educational specialists right across Cornwall, including occupational therapists, educational psychologists and speech and language therapists.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I speak to parents, young people and teachers in my Harlow constituency about the SEND reform and the need for SEND reform all the time. And one of my best friends is actually a SENCO who tells me often how broken he and his colleagues are having to battle this broken SEND system for so long.
So can I ask the Minister, as well as making sure these SEND reforms cater for all the young people in Harlow that need them, they also make being a SENCO an attractive proposition again?
Speaker 44
Mr Speaker, I really appreciate that question and I have talked to SENCOs around the country and I know how much pressure they're under, how often they feel that they have to go into battle for the children that they're supporting. They play a critical role in our schools and we want to make sure that they're supported to do that. That's why we're introducing a new SENCO NPQ to make sure that they have the training and the support that they need to do that vital job.
Speaker 52
The Minister will know that in my constituency of North East Hertfordshire, there's a real shortage of specialist places for children with SEND. What steps is she taking to ensure that there are more specialist places for families today as they're needed now, not in the future?
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, over the last two years, we've already started that 3.7 billion of investment that I've mentioned. This is money going in today to local authorities so they can start building the schools, building the places, taking the action that their government failed to take.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Barely a day goes by where I don't get a new family whose child is struggling or worse, hasn't got a school at all. And given the long delays in autism and ADHD diagnosis, what consideration has been given, the length of time it takes to get these packages in place, what consideration has been given to early screening for neurodivergence at the very earliest stage so we can actually plan more properly for those schools?
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I hear the same stories from families about those those long waits and our new system that we're proposing is all about identifying those needs as early as possible. So through the national inclusion standards, which the independent panel are working on, they'll be developing new tools to support schools to be to identify needs early and then working with experts at hand service to be able to put interventions in to support those young people.
Hannah Kathrine Spencer
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Children in Gorton Denton are being left without suitable education whilst families wait for SEND tribunal appeals, but they're waiting for school places that don't exist.
So does the honourable member agree that we actually need an independent assessment of SEND school capacity because the government reforms won't help if we don't first fix the capacity crisis?
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I absolutely agree that we need more places within our schools and we are working as quickly as possible to get money into local authorities to deliver that capacity. And that includes growing the number of inclusion bases that can be built faster and often allow children to be educated in their community. And as I travel around the country, I've seen how life-changing that has been when the money that we've put in is already creating those new places and we'll continue to invest this year and next. Question 13, Mr. Speaker.
Joshua MacAlister
Part of the kinship zones is testing an allowance equivalent to the fostering allowance alongside a robust impact evaluation. But we are not waiting for this evaluation to improve England's approach to kinship care. Our families first reforms are unlocking the potential of kin-based care across the country through family group decision-making by default and practical support through family network support packages.
Speaker 55
Will the Minister join me in thanking the kinship carers in Northampton and across all our constituencies who give children a stable and loving home? Outside those seven zones the Minister mentioned, funding is still means tested. So will he commit to publishing interim findings before the end of the pilot in 2029 so families have an answer on parity before the next general election?
Joshua MacAlister
Mr. Speaker, I will and I would also like to pass on and share my thanks to all the amazing kinship carers we have across the country. Outside of kinship zones there are a number of councils that are showing that they can take steps to go further than others. Plymouth City Council, Sheffield City Council and North Tyneside Council are great examples of this.
Speaker 44
Apologies, apologies Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I've heard from parents, young people, teachers and members across this House the scale of the challenges facing the SEND system and the impact on families. We're transforming support for special educational needs across early years settings, schools and colleges so that more children and young people can get the right support locally.
Speaker 58
Mr. Speaker, it's difficult to overstate the trauma that the SEND crisis has inflicted on children in North East Hertfordshire. So the government's commitment to reform is very welcome, but given the scale of the failure they've experienced, many families are nervous. So can the Minister reassure me and my constituents today that the reforms won't mean pushing children into a one-size-fits-all approach and will ensure there's a firm legal backstop so that every child receives the support they deserve?
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I can confirm these reforms are designed to make sure that in every community there is the right support available for children, that there is accountability on every part of the system to deliver for families and young people who've been let down for too long.
Speaker 44
With permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions 15 and 18 together. The Department is bringing forward reforms to improve the SEND system long-term. With this investment in local authorities and other parts of the systems comes a strong focus on improvement, and through SEND reform plans we'll be carefully monitoring performance, offering support, but also intervening strongly where there is persistent failure.
Nesil Caliskan
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And creating additional SEND spaces is critical for my constituency.
We've had a 100% increase in EHCP plans and extra 1,000 students now need special educational needs support. So can I ask the Minister, when the School Bill comes through, can she give us reassurance that as part of the proposals there will be additional support for supporting mainstream teachers to have the training they need so that there is support in mainstream schools?
Speaker 44
Thank you, Mr Speaker. My honourable friend has been a passionate campaigner on this issue and and it is because of representations from her constituents and and many others around this chamber that we will be introducing a compulsory professional development for teachers on special educational needs and disabilities backed by 200 million.
Al Pinkerton
Thank you Mr. Speaker. A growing number of children across Surrey have been left without special educational provision that they need this year and a disproportionate number of them live in the West Surrey new unitary authority area. 64% require specialist autism provision. Given Surrey County Council's historic failure to align provision with need and with very worrying reports that the SEND system is being allowed to collapse in Surrey's final year of operation, can I ask the Secretary of State will she directly intervene to ensure that DfE capital investment prioritises the specialist autism places that West Surrey desperately needs and would she meet with me and the incoming leaders of West Surrey to see how that can be done? Thank you.
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I will absolutely meet with the honourable member to discuss this. I've heard directly from from Surrey parents and and heard from him. We are investing we invested 16 million last year and close to 19 million this year into specialist places in Surrey.
We are carefully looking at Surrey's reform plan as part of our work on local authority accountability, and I will keep working with him on these important issues.
Secretary of State.
Speaker 6
Mr. Speaker, today we are introducing a once-in-a-generation change to school food, making them tastier, healthier, and giving over half a million more children free school meals. We've worked with schools, pupils, parents, and many more to ensure that these meals are of good quality, attractive to children, and deliverable for schools. With free breakfast clubs and a huge expansion in free school meals under this government, children will be better able to concentrate and learn. I want to put on record my thanks to the Minister for Early Years, and it also happens to be his dispatch box debut.
Luke Murphy
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I welcome my right honorable friend to her place. Can the Minister update the House on the package of cost-saving measures announced by this Labour government to give families in my constituency of East Worthing and Shoreham more breathing space this September as they return to school?
Speaker 6
Well, can I thank him for that question. We're giving families more breathing space by helping them with school uniform costs, expanding government-funded childcare, free school meals, free breakfast clubs, and in East Worthing and Shoreham, 4,100 children will now be eligible for the free school meals.
Speaker 66
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and on behalf of my party, can I send the condolences to the Prime Minister for the death of his father. On to questions, Mr. Speaker, I want to ask the Secretary of State a very simple one.
Does she think it is acceptable for young girls to be required to wear a hijab to school as part of their school uniform?
Speaker 66
I'm actually delighted by the answer, thank you. This is not a hypothetical situation. A school in Barnet, which has recently become state-funded, says it's compulsory for girls as young as seven to cover their heads as part of the uniform. Given her very welcome repudiation of this, will she intervene to stop the school's policy?
Speaker 6
Well, as she would expect, we have been in close touch with the school. Obviously, it's a decision for the local authority that this school has now become a voluntary-aided school, and the school, as I understand it, has now clarified that the hijabs are not compulsory.
Daniel Francis.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
This term has seen three new free breakfast clubs open in my constituency at St. Paul's in Slade Green, Gravel Hill in Bexleyheath, and St. Fidelis in Northumberland Heath. So will my honorable friend outline timescales for when further breakfast clubs can be rolled out across Bexleyheath and Crayford to ensure that every primary school-aged child in my constituency starts the day with a healthy meal?
Speaker 6
Well, I'm really proud of our commitment to free breakfast clubs. They're not only great for children, they're great for parents. We hear these testimonies all the time. I know they're incredibly popular and we'll continue to roll them out.
Munira Wilson
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The government claimed that its policy to cap the number of branded uniform items would, excuse me, cut costs for parents, yet we know that some schools are getting around the rules by making optional branded items that would keep children warm in the winter.
So will the minister now reconsider Liberal Democrats' proposal to cap the cost of uniform rather than number of items so we can genuinely put pounds back into parents' pockets?
Speaker 6
Well, I'm very clear that this is not just about the letter of the law, this is about the spirit of the law. And I want to see schools following the spirit of these, this new legislation. I have further powers, should I need to use them, to pull in a school's uniform policy. I don't want to see jumpers and things like that that children actually have to wear being branded.
Speaker 70
The funding affecting high-cost creative subjects will cost Arts University Bournemouth in my constituency more than 300,000 pounds this financial year. This will affect jobs, course availability, and undermine student choice. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss the funding crisis affecting our creative arts university and work with us to protect these vital institutions?
Speaker 6
I'm really happy to meet with her to discuss it because our creative arts universities like that in her constituency are providing fantastic qualifications for young people to get jobs they need.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Mr. Speaker, while I welcome the changes to school food standards, government buying standards for food still don't mandate local or British sourcing, leaving farmers in Glastonbury and Somerton locked out of supplying local schools. My Good Food Bill would fix this by requiring public bodies to prioritize the procurement of fresh, local, sustainably sourced food. So will the Minister commit to strengthening government buying standards and back my Good Food Bill so that schools can buy produce from local farms?
Speaker 6
Where schools can and local caterers can, we absolutely want them to buy local. This is an important part of the sustainability. We've tried to get the balance right with these food standards so that they are deliverable by schools, they are affordable, we're not putting up the cost of school meals, but they are providing tasty, healthier meals that ideally are locally sourced.
Lee Pitcher
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As Doncaster Sheffield Airport moves towards reopening, I want young people in my constituency to be excited about a future career in aviation. With the first officer pilot apprenticeship now at risk of being withdrawn, what will the Secretary of State do to ensure that young people still have clear and affordable routes into aviation careers, and will she work with BALPA and the industry to help make that happen?
Speaker 6
Well, I think I originally branded my honorable friend Mr. Doncaster Airport, and I'm pleased that he's still living up to that name today, Mr. Speaker.
But he's absolutely right. This is why we are working already very closely with mayors and local employers and others so that local areas like his in Doncaster can ensure that young people have access to the qualifications and work experience they need for his local economy.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've been contacted by many parents in Worcestershire. What assessment has the Secretary of State made of the adequacy of SEND provision in Worcestershire? What steps is government taking to improve it? And if she doesn't have a comprehensive answer, perhaps she could write to me.
Speaker 6
I'm happy to write to him about that, but rest assured we're working with all local authorities on their SEND plans at the moment to ensure that they are robust, deliverable, and affordable.
Mary Glindon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this year, Ravensworth Primary School in Newcastle applied to the schools rebuilding program as surveys have deemed the school building to be beyond repair. A subsequent visit promised by the department hasn't materialized. Can the minister expedite a meeting with the department, the school, and Newcastle City Council's cabinet member to discuss the current status of the application?
Speaker 6
The Minister for School Estates, who's sitting next to me, is really happy to meet with her because I know how important this issue is to her constituents.
Luke Murphy.
Speaker 73
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Several of my Basingstoke constituents have contacted me about the broken SEND transport system. Several of them didn't know what transport was going to be put in place for their children before the term started. The decisions were delayed. Some of them still don't know how their SEND children are going to get to school.
Paul Waugh
This government's SEND reforms will create a more inclusive school system with fewer children needing to travel to access the quality education they deserve. I take on board exactly what the right honourable member's concerns are. We're listening to them. We want to make clear, absolutely clear, that ensuring drivers and passenger assistants have received the training necessary to respond to all children's needs is central to government policy.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer we found that the number of GCSE and A-level music entrants were down in line with the general trend we've seen over the last 16 years. I know the government wants to address this, which is why it commissioned the National Centre for Arts and Music Education, which was due to start its work at the beginning of this academic year.
So can ministers tell me whether the centre is up and running and who has won the contract, who has won the contract to run it?
Speaker 6
Well, can I thank him? He raises a really important issue. Music education, music qualifications have fallen off a cliff. That's why we're taking these steps. The procurement process has begun and so I can outline for him soon what further steps we're taking.
But I want to also work with musicians like Ed Sheeran and Fatboy Slim and others who've been campaigning for a music curriculum that actually attracts, not distracts, young people from taking it up.
Ian Sollom
Mr. Speaker, last week's PISA results confirmed that the gap in outcomes for disadvantaged pupils remains stark throughout their education.
So would the Secretary of State commit to looking seriously at proposals from the Lib Dems and others at extending the pupil premium to post-16 education?
Speaker 6
Well, he raises a really important issue. It's not just about further education and keeping young people in further education and the measure that he outlines would assist with that, but it's also about engaging young people in school more thoroughly as well, which is why the whole range of reforms that I've begun to sketch out are so important.
Speaker 78
Alistair Strathern. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Shockingly, 16 to 19-year-olds face higher rates of domestic abuse than any other age group. So with the worst corners of the internet peddling increasingly extreme attitudes to them around sex and relationships, surely we owe them better. That's why my private member's bill builds on the inspiring campaigner Faustine Petron's work to make it mandatory to ensure young people up to the age of 18 have healthy spaces to explore these issues in school and at college.
Will the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss how we can make this vision a reality?
Speaker 6
Well, I know my friend the Minister has spoken to the honorable gentleman because I think his bill's raising a really important issue and I want to see relationship education and all of the issues around that extended as far and wide as possible because it's absolutely critical in the social media age.
Gideon Amos.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sampad Arundel, Rockwell Green, Thurlbear, and Bishop Henderson schools are just four in my constituency that planned their grants on the basis of having the sport premium grant. Now that that's been removed, how are they going to fund sport and how has the government made any assessment of how many PE teachers are losing their jobs as a result of this change?
Speaker 6
Well look, I want to see sport and PE flourishing in our schools and that is something I've already spoken about, so I'm happy to meet with him to discuss that further.
Daniel Zeichner
I welcome the announcements on school meals, but given that young campaigners at Bite Back last week identified that some three-quarters of secondary schools aren't providing meals that meet government standards, what can the minister do to boost enforcement?
Paul Waugh
These updated standards that've been announced today will ensure that school food will be delicious, nutritious and practical for schools. I was very proud to see Bite Back and a range of sector leaders welcome our standards today and I thank them all for the hard work they're doing in helping schools achieve what we want.
Speaker 81
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We all know that child safeguarding is non-negotiable. So does the Secretary of State share my concern that the NSPCC's most recent schools briefing appears to put the safety of girls at risk, given that they've removed the express requirement that adult supervisors of pupils getting dressed should be of the same gender or sex? Does the Secretary of State agree with me that the NSPCC should clarify its guidance to comply with the law, so that men and boys have no place in girls' changing rooms?
Speaker 6
Well, can I just say that the Department for Education guidance is really clear on this and it differs from the NSPCC, so I would refer her to the DfE guidance.
Luke Murphy.
Darren James Paffey
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A new report by the charity Become shows that personal advisers in some cases are supervising up to 46 young care leavers each, and these are the people who can make a difference between young people setting out into adulthood well or feeling completely on their own.
Will the Minister therefore commit to not just reviewing support, but a funded national strategy, a cap on caseloads, so that no care leaver in Southampton or anywhere in this country has to face adulthood alone?
Joshua MacAlister
I welcome Become's report, and it builds on the review into early deaths of care leavers that I commissioned a few months ago. And I'd like to thank Ashley John-Baptiste and Claire Chamberlin for the important work they've done bringing to the country's attention the tragic number of young care leavers who die far too young. And that transition to adulthood is a really important moment to get right. PAs play a crucial role in doing that. We are looking at additional training for PAs and also changing the regulation that sits around them so we can set a higher expectation.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Transport is a key barrier to accessing education and other opportunities. A 19-year-old told me recently it cost her more than £9 for a return fare to the county town, Hereford. Hereford Sixth Form told me 21 young people dropped out last year because of transport problems. Does the Secretary of State recognise the cost of travel is a big barrier to accessing education, training, and work, and will she work with cabinet colleagues and the Treasury to implement free bus travel for all young people to invest in them?
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 6
Well, she raises a really important issue, and I think she's absolutely spot on. I've seen the difference in Greater Manchester of the former mayor's Our Pass, which is still there for 16 to 19-year-olds, free travel, the difference that can make, and also the difference it made over August for all young people to have free travel in August.
She can rest assured that the Prime Minister is making an absolute priority around bus travel, the cost of bus travel, particularly for young people, and I'll continue working with cabinet colleagues on it.
Speaker 85
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In Brighton, Kemptown and Peacehaven, we're lucky enough to have two brilliant universities, and both are trying everything they can to adapt to the funding pressures they're under. But it still means the University of Sussex is making cuts of 35 million pounds a year, and just this morning, the University of Brighton announced plans to potentially sell one of its campuses. So what can the Secretary of State do to reassure me and to give hope to my students and staff at the universities that we're going to get a grip of the funding crisis we inherited from the last government and make universities thrive?
Speaker 6
Well, he's absolutely right, he has fantastic universities in his constituency, and I am worried about the pressures facing HE funding.
I am looking at these issues closely. As he will know, they are autonomous organisations, but I am doing what I can with cabinet colleagues to make people aware of the precarious nature of the situation.
Jess Brown-Fuller.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Students on the Manhood Peninsula in my constituency have no access to post-16 education unless they travel into the city to go to the brilliant Chichester College. And those parents that are paying for the bus fare are currently struggling to find on average £1,200 a year to be able to get them there. With one in five students estimated to not be in regular education even though they're signed up for college, what can the Secretary of State set out to make sure that all of those people living in coastal areas can access post-16 so that the parents can afford to get them there?
Speaker 6
Well, I absolutely hear her and I know how closely related transport and transport costs are to young people having access to the education and training that they need. And rest assured, this is a priority for this government.
Janet Jessica Daby
Mr. Speaker, my constituent's 11-year-old daughter, who is autistic, attempted suicide last year and she continues to experience severe anxiety and autistic burnout. The family still have no clarity about her education provision for this new term. For children like my constituent's daughter, will the government ensure that schools are only able to offer placements when they have the staffing, expertise, resource, and specialist support necessary to meet children's identified needs?
Speaker 44
Mr. Speaker, I'm so deeply sorry to hear about the experience of your constituent. Nobody should have to go through that.
We want every school to be an inclusive school where teachers are trained, where there are experts at hand to support children, so no one is in that position in the future.
Andrew Rosindell
Mr. Speaker, sir, will the Secretary of State for Education join me in commending my right honourable friend, the member for Fareham and Waterlooville, on her proposals that every school in the land should fly the Union Jack every day of the year, and that every school assembly should at least once a week sing the national anthem? Is it not, is it not something that government could implement now instead of waiting for a Reform UK government to implement that policy?
Speaker 6
Well, I did miss my exchanges with the honorable gentleman from being Leader of the House, but now he's in his new place over there, I will look forward to having them. Look, obviously it's a matter for headteachers to decide for their schools, and I'm all for headteacher autonomy. But British values is absolutely running right through our curriculum. Like a stick of rock, you can see British values right at the heart of them, and I'm very proud that that's the case.
Jonny Reynolds
With your permission, Mr. Speaker, I would like to make a statement on Speciality Steel UK.
And as I do so, I know the thoughts of the whole House will be with the Prime Minister following the passing of his father, Roy, earlier today. Mr. Speaker, the workers at Speciality Steel UK have faced years of uncertainty. The plants have been mothballed and the jobs furloughed for several years. This outrageous situation is a monument to years of neglect by successive Conservative governments who let this industry decline. But since entering government, we and I have taken a different approach.
We have done all we can to rebuild the sector and we have confronted its challenges head-on.
In the specific case of Specialty Steel, complex ownership structures and opaque financing arrangements have amplified the headwinds of the wider sector. I also note that Specialty Steel UK was acquired by Liberty Steel in 2017, following a deal brokered by a former Conservative Prime Minister. Now, as the House may recall, Specialty Steel UK entered liquidation in August last year, with the independent, court-appointed official receiver managing the liquidation process. Since then, the government has provided funding to enable the official receiver to carry out his statutory duties, including maintaining site safety, supporting employees, and conducting a sales process for the business and its assets. Throughout that period, our priority has been to facilitate a private sector solution.
The official receiver engaged with a range of interested parties and early this year identified a preferred bidder.
That bidder subsequently requested government support to make their purchase of Specialty Steel UK possible. Following extensive engagement between the bidder and its advisers, alongside all the due diligence and consideration taxpayers would expect in these cases, the government has decided, however, that it cannot provide support on the proposed terms. Now, this decision has not been taken lightly. For over a year, we have funded the official receiver process while working constructively on efforts to do this, but we had serious concerns about the proposed financing of it, the protections for UK taxpayers, and whether it would be able to offer the long-term stability for the local economy and community.
So, having concluded that we cannot support the preferred bidder's proposal, we are faced with a choice. We can allow events to take their course through the liquidation process and risk being left with no say in the future of these sites. Or we can act. Mr. Speaker, this government chooses to act. We have made a commitment to reindustrialise Britain, to bring good growth to every postcode of our country.
And backing the proud communities of Stocksbridge, Rotherham, Wednesbury, and Brinsworth is absolutely part of that commitment. These workers and those across the wider business have endured a prolonged period of uncertainty.
And the government cannot accept the prospect of another prolonged process that will create more worry and anxiety for workers, that will deter business and will hang over the local community. Nor can we accept a situation where decisions impacting the future of communities in South Yorkshire are effectively taken by default, rather than through a deliberate assessment of what will best support growth, opportunity and prosperity in the years ahead. We will therefore engage with the official receiver's sale process and develop a proposal for the public acquisition of SSUK. This will preserve strategic control and ensure that all critical options for the future of the business remain open.
We are taking this step because SSUK occupies a unique place within the UK's steel ecosystem. It offers specialist capabilities which have served advanced manufacturing for decades. It is capable of supplying the growth-driving sectors of our economy, those which we have committed to supporting through our industrial strategy. SSUK's strategic value extends well beyond its economic contribution. It lies in its specialist steelmaking capabilities which historically have produced products like aircraft landing gear, helicopter rotors, as well as missiles and other munitions.
It would not be right to let this go by default. Now, Mr. Speaker, I want to make one very important clarifying point.
We will work towards public acquisition, but it is not the end of the process, nor is it the end of the conversation over the long-term future of the business or its sites. Instead, it means keeping our options open while government, local leaders, industry experts, private investors, workers, and other partners consider what is best for the business and the taxpayer. I want to thank those members of this House with SSUK sites and their constituencies for their engagement with my department, and I welcome their continued input. That includes my honorable and right honorable friends, the members for Rotherham, for Stocksbridge and Penistone, for Tipton and Wednesbury, and for Rawmarsh and Conisbrough. I also want to recognize the role played by the Mayor of South Yorkshire, Oliver Coppard, and his team for ensuring we have a joined-up vision for the future of South Yorkshire.
And I welcome the work I know we will be doing in lockstep to deliver this future. Working towards public acquisition will create the necessary time and space to undertake a full assessment of the opportunities available. It will let us consider future industrial use, regeneration opportunities, and the role that specialist manufacturing capabilities could play in supporting growth and our national resilience. One option that will be assessed carefully is the future of speciality steel production. However, we are not prejudging the outcome of that assessment.
All options will be considered rigorously against their economic and industrial benefits, their impact on regional growth, and their value for money. And I should note that all future decisions and spending commitments will be subject to detailed due diligence and funded from existing government budgets.
Mr. Speaker, our announcement today must also be seen in the wider context of the government's commitment to the future of the British steel industry. Steel remains fundamental to our economy, to our infrastructure, to our energy system, our advanced manufacturing base and to our national security. It underpins critical supply chains and supports thousands of skilled jobs across the United Kingdom. That is why we nationalised British Steel earlier this year. It's why we intervened to secure stability and maintain production at the site while we develop long-term options.
And it's why we secured a better deal for the steel communities of South Wales with 500 million pounds of government support for a new electric arc furnace at Port Talbot. In our steel strategy, we committed to stabilizing and rebuilding the steel sector. What's more, we set out a goal of supporting productive and profitable steel producers that can meet their customers' needs, that can strengthen our national security and provide high-quality, secure, long-term jobs backed by private investment. Now, that was not an empty promise, nor was it wishful thinking. We have, of course, also acted to tackle the challenge posed by global steel overcapacity with trade measures protecting our domestic production from unfair pressure and supporting the viability of the nation's steelmaking.
But I do want to speak directly to the workers of Specialty Steel UK, who have been stuck on furlough, unable to do the jobs they're so rightly proud of through no fault of their own. And I know they feel ignored and let down by previous governments. But as Business Secretary, I will not duck these difficult decisions, and neither will this government.
I will do all I can to secure a bright future for you, your communities and your families. Taken together, Mr Speaker, these actions demonstrate that this government is serious about reindustrialising Britain with the steel sector playing its part. We want to attract private investment, we want to strengthen domestic supply chains, and we want to ensure that industrial communities have a genuine opportunity to thrive in the decades ahead. And that is why we are moving towards the public acquisition of Speciality Steel UK. And as ever, Mr Speaker, I will commit to keeping all members informed as this important work progresses.
And I commend this statement to the House.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and on behalf of this side of the House, we send our thoughts to the Prime Minister following the tragic passing of his father.
I thank the Minister for his statement. In her statement to the House following the insolvency of Speciality Steels in September last year, the then Minister of Industry stated that the Government would work to grow a resilient domestic steel industry. We can all agree that the compulsory winding-up order against Liberty Speciality Steels created a great deal of uncertainty, especially for the more than 1,000 workers employed there. Indeed, I'd be keen to hear how the Government has kept its promise to stand by the entire workforce throughout this process, including in the overseeing of bids to sell the former assets and if any redundancies will follow this nationalisation.
However, continuous operational failures had already pushed businesses into a state of chronic uncertainty, namely the failure to file the government has undertaken, including any steps to recover money that may belong either to the business or the
Traditional bulk commodity steelmaking is vital for national infrastructure, and new modern advanced steel manufacturing is essential for the green transition.
Jonny Reynolds
An electric arc furnace, obviously incredibly energy intensive. It means that the supercharger package that we've introduced is incredibly important. And I think it's fair to say that the business environment we inherited from the Conservative party was not a satisfactory one and we had to act and that's why we have done so. It is about maintaining domestic production, it is about being a country where the rules of the game apply. And if we want people to be based here, we have to have a level playing field for competition, though I know that's an issue for the downstream users, but that is I think the position the country has to take.
On carbon border adjustment mechanisms, I think that's a new policy since I was last here where the Conservative party perhaps disowning the policies they had at the end of the last government because they certainly were committed to CBAMs.
entity to take on. I think the state, if we do end up with a public ownership position, is better able to take that on. But it is the legacy of neglect that has been the barrier. That is exactly what this side of the House is doing.
Sarah Champion
Thank you for understanding the potential in the Rotherham, Brinsworth and Stocksbridge sites that work hand in hand with Liberty Steel, so fits exactly, I would say is the linchpin to the government's industrial strategy. Thank you for continuing the pace so far. Thank you for committing to continue it for the next six months. The workers are grateful to be furloughed, they want to be working, and that means that they need to be fit at the day you say we can go.
Jonny Reynolds
Put on the record and Hansard before Mr. Speaker, it's the homologation. So it's the, it's the assets of these sites in terms of the accreditations they have for what is such a specialty set of products that they are incredibly valuable. Not many parts of the world can actually produce to the standard that we are talking about. So we now have a process, I want that to be as short as possible, where we can assess that. I'll remain in close contact there with her, where I want to be able to be in a position where if we can take this forward, we can pass that good news to her constituents.
Daisy Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First of all, may I pass on my condolences and that of my party to the Prime Minister on the sad passing of his father? And can I thank the Secretary of State for his statement?
We Liberal Democrats recognize, of course, that national security, energy security, and food security are all intertwined. And steel, of course, is critical both to our renewables sector, to our defense, and our national infrastructure. In a previous debate on this company, we said on record that nothing should be off the table, and we look forward to receiving further details from the Secretary of State as this process continues. A few questions for the Secretary of State, Mr. Speaker. First of all, on the question of jobs and the employees there, could the Secretary of State offer any further information, not just on training, which another honorable member has raised, but on the timeline by which staff will have more information about what this decision means for them?
Mr. Speaker, the Secretary of State highlighted that this may end up in a situation of public acquisition.
I'd like to know whether the Secretary of State is in a position to say how much that is likely to cost the taxpayer, or to give a sort of broad estimate or region of how much those costs might be. Related to that, Mr Speaker, I note that the Secretary of State did say that it would be funded through existing budgets, and I just wonder whether the Minister could say a word as to where that money might come from, and whether it might get redirected from other sources of funding, whether for transport, energy projects, or something else. And two final questions, Mr Speaker. We know that the warning lights were flashing for a very, very long time. The Secretary of State himself has mentioned that.
Can I ask if there will be any formal process to actually look at the lessons learned, both politically and administratively, to make sure that something like this never happens again? And finally, Mr. Speaker, the Secretary of State will know that as well as using domestic steel supplies for our own British procurement, the way to really boost British industry is to have a stronger relationship with Europe so that British steel can be used throughout supply chains and the procurement right across Europe. Will the government look at strengthening that relationship? Thank you.
Jonny Reynolds
Well, I thank the honorable member for her questions. I absolutely endorse what she said about the centrality of steel to security and infrastructure and echo, in fact, her words. This is entirely pragmatic. I'm seeking to resolve a series of long-running problems which frankly a great many, and there were a great many of my Conservative predecessors, all frankly ignored as being too difficult. That's the central lesson I would learn.
You have to be willing to confront these hard problems. Yes, you might think you can pass them on to the next person, but that is not, I think, serving the country in the way that is required. In answer to her specific questions, I anticipate this process to take between four and six months.
I want it resolved as quickly as possible. I think it is important to say to the House, Mr. Speaker, there are costs either way. There are costs to running the business in public ownership. There would also be costs to the state of remediation and regeneration, partly because of the legacy of public ownership, but also frankly these big steel industrial sites come with so many issues to resolve if they are remediated that some of that would fall on the Exchequer. If it were to be the matter for public ownership, we'd have to pay off the creditors, reach accommodation with them, acquire the assets, and then inject some working capital over a period of between one and three years.
I would anticipate the costs of that to be around 350 million pounds.
I would compare, to be frank, that to be somewhere comparable were the option to be regeneration and remediation. In terms of existing commitment in our manifesto for two and a half billion pounds on top of, on top of the 500 million pounds that was granted to Tata in Port Talbot under the previous government. We have spent some of that but not actually the lion's share of that. Some has gone to British Steel, the support for Tata has continued, some has gone on the electric arc furnace.
Speaker 100
In terms of the relationship to Europe, well look, she will know when the European Union...
Speaker 101
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the direction that the Secretary of State has set out today. Wednesbury Bright Bar is in a high-value industry area. It's used for automotive and for advanced manufacturing across the Black Country and beyond.
It's not primary steel production and will need a clear strategy separate to that for the primary steel production, which is the business in Rotherham, in Stocksbridge, elsewhere in the country. Can the Secretary of State set out what specific consideration he will give to securing the long-term future of Wednesbury Bright Bar as part of work towards the public acquisition of Speciality Steels UK, and how this will support the skilled jobs and the manufacturing supply chains across the West Midlands and beyond?
Jonny Reynolds
I'm grateful to the honourable member for support and engagement again on behalf, and obviously on her behalf of her constituents. There is a, there is a codependence, Mr. Speaker, between the four sites in terms of how the business operates, but any long-term consideration, whether in the private or public sector, of the business is going to have to consider products, customers, markets in order to run the business profitably. That will be central to the assessment that we can now make, but I would, I can give her the reassurance that every part of this business clearly has worth. That's why they've been grouped in this way historically and in a contemporary sense, and of course we are seeking the best solution for the workers at all four of the plants.
Edward Leigh
Speciality Steel has been severely impacted, we know, by high electricity costs. And we know from my neighbouring constituency of Scunthorpe, which is a very heavy user of electricity, just what this means. They're paying 50% more for their electricity than is being paid in France, for instance. And yet the government insists on phasing out the blast furnaces. Once we have electric arcs in Scunthorpe, they'll have to use twice as much electricity, paying much more.
So we can't reindustrialise Britain, would the Secretary of State agree, simply by public ownership? We have to reduce our energy costs.
So will he take steps over the next year or two to not worry about green energy and all that, but just reduce our energy costs roughly equivalent to France?
Jonny Reynolds
Well, I'm always grateful for the support of the Father of the House and he's had a long-standing interest in all industrial matters. But I would say to him that I consider myself more obsessed with industrial energy prices than frankly any other member of this House. I'm great company when this subject comes up. But quite frankly, on electric arc furnaces, which would be and are the technology in use here and will hopefully be at Scunthorpe at some point, we already have a set of policies in place that don't just make us on par with some of our rivals, actually give us a competitive position.
That's the supercharger scheme for the most energy-intensive electricity users. He will know as well as that we've launched as part of the industrial strategy, which is about to come into force, the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, effectively a scheme for manufacturers, which again is significant, significantly moves the dial on their competitiveness. So I recognize this issue, but we have done more than previous governments, we continue to do more on it. I agree entirely with his case, but I do think we've got to recognize the very substantial work that has already gone on. I consider BICS to be the centerpiece of the industrial strategy when we launch it because it moves the dial so significantly on our competitiveness, not just for steel, but across a range of manufacturing sectors.
Jessica Morden
Thank you very much Mr Speaker and can I thank the Secretary of State and acknowledge the substantial support given to the steel industry as my honourable friend for Rotherham said in direct contrast to the party opposite who did very little when they were in. But he will know of the particular concerns in Llanwern steelworks about the new quota levels for galvanised steel. Can I ask the Secretary of State to acknowledge that and to tell us what more he's doing to listen to the concerns of those workers at Llanwern?
Jonny Reynolds
Again grateful to my honourable friend she and I have been discussing steel matters for many years in this House. I am aware of the specific challenges at Llanwern. I believe that's a very sound business. Our trade defence measures will directly benefit it. I know again the balance we have to strike.
Sometimes people would like it further in one direction than the other but it is all part of the support we've given the steel industry and the downstream use that she talks about I believe is central to the future of steel production in Wales.
Speaker 106
But there is a sort of central inconsistency in the Secretary of State's argument.
Mark Pritchard
He talks about steel as a strategic asset, and of course I agree with that, but so is oil and gas, and yet the government don't seem to be coming forward any proposals on that. Now he mentions that the government is going to pay this from, in his statement, his oral statement, from "existing government budgets". Then earlier to a answer to a question, he said that the money will fall on the Exchequer, possibly. So how much is this going to cost? He also mentions that he would prefer this to remain in the private sector, and that's encouraging to hear.
So does he have any indicative timetable when this might go back to the market and be sold?
Jonny Reynolds
Grateful to the honorable member for his question. He'll understand I'll not comment on matters pertaining to the Secretary of State at DESNZ.
I will stick to the considerable number of issues that are in the domain of BIS. But he asked specifically on costs. So the cost of the official receiver is eleven million pounds a month. That is in the main meeting payroll for the over twelve hundred members of staff that the sites employ. That's what we've done to date.
That's what we will continue to do. In terms of returning to the private sector, well first of all we've got to see if there's an opportunity to save this business. Now that might require public acquisition as I've laid out in my statement. If it were the case that we followed the path in that direction, we would have to inject working capital, perhaps a sum of money. This is what the process now can ascertain to make the kind of products and the business plan what it will need to be to be attractive to return to the private sector.
But that's a long way frankly down the road. What I would say is if we put public money in, I want a return for that public money.
So of course I'm more than willing, keen in fact, to see this business return to the private sector. But obviously I'll want to protect public money if we put that money in to turn this business around. And I think that's again an entirely pragmatic, reasonable consideration to have.
Luke Myer
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome this statement today? Once again, a Labour government stepping in to protect jobs and protect our specialist steel industry. What steps will the government take to get steelmaking back up and running in the business? And what intervention will they be making with the downstream sector to support them to buy British wherever possible?
Jonny Reynolds
I thank my honourable member for his question. I mean, the process to date has effectively been working with potential private sector bidders on the viability of their plans.
That is an entirely different task to what we can do now, which is assess essentially is there a viable future for this business under public acquisition. If there is, and we know again the strength of the products, the history of these sites is well known, well discussed in the House today. If there is, then that is the opportunity as it presents itself to return to steel production. In terms of some of the changes to procurement my honourable friend mentions, yes, there have been considerable changes to what we can do in terms of procurement. Though in the main, I would say when products are made, when steel products are made in the UK, they do tend to be purchased in the UK.
There's a significant export side to the UK business, but they are in the main purchased around that. Historically, the problem has been goods and products that we frankly don't make in the UK and we've had to import. And again, I think there are gaps in the market in that regard.
Richard Tice.
Richard Tice
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I congratulate the government on making this decision to take Speciality Steels into public ownership. But the truth is it should have been taken somewhat earlier because the preferred bidder was never going to perform.
They've never made any steel. They didn't have any money. They were seeking aggressive financing and they were using an investment advisor who fundamentally failed. And I'm troubled that the government is now using the same investment advisor to advise it on British Steel. Can I urge the government and the Secretary of State, who are doing the right thing with steel, to come up with a combined vision for Speciality Steels, British Steel, merge them, invest in them, get the working capital going, get the production going.
That will make it viable. That will get the cash flow positive again. And that is in the strategic national interest.
Jonny Reynolds
I welcome the support from the honorable gentleman for the decisive action that we are taking.
On his point of potentially combining British Steel and, if it were acquired in the public interest, Speciality Steel UK, I would urge caution on that regard. The job that is required at Scunthorpe and Teesside for British Steel is in itself a significant industrial transformation. Not many transformations of this kind of this scale have actually been done in Europe. What Tata are doing in Port Talbot with us is a significant example of that. This is another set of issues.
Again, I think the House is aware that a different set of factors that really do pertain to ownership have led us to this situation. So, two distinct problems. I am taking, we are taking action on both, but they are distinct. And I wouldn't at this stage actually recommend the bringing together of those two things. That's too big a task.
I think we're better served by looking at these as distinct things to solve.
Catherine Eccles
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I thank the Secretary of State for his positive announcement today. Downstream businesses in Stourbridge, Brierley Hill and Netherton used to source many items from Speciality Steel, and I spent a lot of time working with them and the department and ministers to update product codes ahead of the tariffs being introduced, and I'm grateful for their engagement during that time. And I understand the upscaling of production will take time, but will he commit to continuing to work with the industry as these products come back online in the UK so that other businesses in my constituency or elsewhere in the country are unfairly penalized?
Jonny Reynolds
Well, I thank her for her support and for her question. You know, my ideal is I want steelworkers making steel. I don't think that's, that's complicated, but it has been too complicated to date. And all we are seeking is a chance for those proud people to be able to return to the jobs that they so love and have defined their communities for so many years. This will not be easy, I'm grateful for the support across the House today, but this will not be easy.
But we are deliberately taking on this challenge rather than ignoring it, rather than walking away, as I believe other governments have done. And I will remain closely engaged with her on the questions she raises as to how best to do that.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In his reference to the wider steel industry in his statement, he mentioned Scunthorpe, and he knows that I have consistently supported the government in the actions they've taken to keep the works going. I think he's a little too eager to criticize the last government. I would just gently remind him for about 18 months they paid the wages and the bills at Scunthorpe to keep the jobs there.
Could he outline when he... I appreciate we get written statements, but when does he anticipate being able to come to the House and give an oral statement about the future of Scunthorpe?
Jonny Reynolds
I'm grateful to him. He and I had to discuss this many times. I remember calling him to tell him we're about to recall Parliament at that particular significant time in relation to the site at Scunthorpe. I'm always aware of his substantial constituency interest. We will rekindle that relationship if that is the right terminology.
We have just appointed a chair of British Steel. He will have seen that. I am eager to crack on with the work that is required on a transformational plan for Scunthorpe. As soon as I've got substantive information to share, I'm more than happy, always happy to come to the House to talk about steel. But if he has any specific questions, he knows he can contact me directly and I'll always seek to give him the answers he needs.
Speaker 112
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the Secretary of State for his statement and his support of domestic steelmaking.
People don't often think of Monmouthshire as a steelmaking community, but we have downstream, really excellent downstream steelmaking companies. And of course, we have hundreds of workers going every day to Llanwern in my honourable friend's constituency of Newport East. So can he share with me what we're doing to support downstream steel and to ensure we're buying more Welsh steel across the UK in all the UK projects and construction that we're undertaking?
Jonny Reynolds
Grateful to my honourable friend. I believe that the downstream products that we create in the UK, particularly in Wales, I think not only are the quality of those products well known, I think there are gaps in the market.
I often compare the level of domestic consumption in most European countries to where we are for domestic production in the UK, and there are clearly gaps, I believe, in that market. That's always been about the need to improve the business environment, to work constructively with the government, to provide the kind of public-private CAPEX solutions which we've seen quite a lot of across Europe but hadn't seen very many of in the UK. And I am grateful to her and all colleagues who make the case for what is still, I believe, a business and a sector fundamentally important to the UK.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State mentioned the wider steel sector in his statement, and I wonder if I could raise the issues of Fowler & Gilbert and Everedge in my constituency, both of whom manufacture steel products and have been impacted by quotas and tariffs on steel imports, particularly on materials that aren't produced in the UK, because that's essentially adding a manufacturing tax to the work that they do.
And while their raw material cost is rising, there aren't any equivalent restrictions on imported finished products, particularly low-quality cost and low-cost imports from China. So they're in a situation where it's cheaper to import from overseas than to manufacture in the UK. Will the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss the concerns of those businesses, and they are significant local employers in my constituency, to find a solution that works for the whole steel sector? Thank you.
Jonny Reynolds
I acknowledge very much the issues the honorable lady raises. She knows our trade defense measures are a necessary, I believe, response to global overproduction. It is a problem every trade and commerce and business minister around the world has to grapple with. The role of our trade defense measures are to provide a level playing field for domestic production.
If she believes there is some inconsistency there between the products that she needs for her constituency, of course we're happy to meet with her to take that forward. There are sometimes misalignment between certain product codes and how you can align trade defense measures around that. But I do believe, genuinely believe, there is a consensus across the House that we have to be a country that is willing sometimes to intervene to make sure there is a level playing field, both for the sectors directly affected and because, frankly, no one would base their business here if they thought they could be wiped out by the kind of unfair competition which, I'm afraid, is a feature sometimes of the global economy.
Pamela Nash
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I wholeheartedly welcome this statement today and this government's action to secure the Speciality Steel UK sites in England. The Secretary of State is aware that the workforce in Motherwell's Dalzell plate mill have been repeatedly and sorely let down by Speciality Steel.
They've left the site underfunded and unable to to carry out contracts. And they've also been let down by the SNP Scottish government who sold the site to these cowboys in the first place and then left the playing field. DL was part of British Steel. This plate mill is the jigsaw piece that completes our steel offering in the UK and it makes sense for it to be brought back into the fold as soon as possible. So can I ask the Secretary of State today to confirm to the House that he will take all necessary actions to save DL and take all the actions needed to get it up and running again and make sure that we have growth in every postcode and that includes ML1 2?
Jonny Reynolds
I'm grateful to her for her question and again for the advocacy she has on behalf of her constituents and she and I have discussed this matter several times which I'm aware of. For colleagues who are perhaps less aware of this, DL is a separate legal entity, a separate company to the four plants specialty steel business that we are talking about today and it is still owned by the Gupta family group, though many of the same issues are there. She knows because that part of the business has not been in the same position as what we're talking about today, it's not being run by the official receiver, it's a different set of circumstances. Any interest that we had there, we would obviously have to establish the level of liabilities, the flow of public money, what would be required to bring that as part of the former associations that it has. We haven't got current plans to do that but we will remain closely engaged with her around this.
I know for the people for her constituents, they want to be back to work, and I share their frustrations that they have got, but I appreciate the House being aware it is in a different position to the rest of SS UK.
Llinos Medi
Diolch, Dirprwy Lefarydd. First of all, can I pass on our condolences as a party to the Prime Minister and his family? Whilst recognizing the 500 million transition fund to Port Talbot, there are real concerns regarding the Welsh steel, that the Welsh steel will not receive the fair share of the 2.5 billion steel fund. And today, the Secretary of State has announced that the public acquisition of Specialty Steel will be funded from that steel fund. Can the Secretary of State then please reassure the Welsh steel sector that Wales will get its fair share of the steel fund following today's announcement?
Jonny Reynolds
Yes, Wales on a per capita basis, on a per head basis, and in fact on a straightforward cash basis, had until fairly recently had the lion's share, the biggest allocations from government because of the significance of the transformation program at Port Talbot.
So it remains and is a fundamental part of the steel sector across the UK. But also, being frank, it is one of the success stories. I mean, the transformation at Port Talbot is a major project supported by significant public money and significant private capital. It's exactly the kind of transformation we're seeking in other parts of the UK. And you know, it is, I think, to the credit of the workforce at Port Talbot that they are at the forefront of this.
Notwithstanding, I know the difficult issues such a transformation takes, it is something to be proud of.
Perran Moon
Merci, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I very much welcome the Secretary of State's statement today, but does he agree with me that workers and communities are ultimately paying the price for the reckless conduct associated with Lex Greensill and that this government is and those who championed his business model, and that this government is now stepping in with the leadership that was so previously lacking?
Jonny Reynolds
Well, I'm grateful to my honorable friend, he tempts me to comment on some issues I might swerve a little bit, but he is right to say that I think the priority for politicians should be trying to resolve these issues and get steelworkers back to work. And I think anything that detracts from that or went in a different direction is deeply regrettable.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank the Minister very much for that response.
Businesses in Northern Ireland that rely upon imported steel from large producers such as Specialty Steel, these changes create a significant risk of increasing costs, forced changes to suppliers and disruption to supply chains. Steel is a critical input for Northern Ireland, contributing some 10% of the workforce. So the potential consequences for manufacturing, construction, engineering industries in Northern Ireland are significant. So does the Minister agree that every effort must be made to ensure Northern Ireland is not economically cut off by steel import arrangements and protection for GB that must not be at the cost to Northern Ireland businesses? Thank you.
Jonny Reynolds
Well, he's right to say historically these plants have served a number of first-class manufacturers, engineering works in Northern Ireland. They obviously haven't been to date because the workforce has been furloughed and the plants haven't been operating. I would love to rekindle again that relationship and see these issues resolved.
That is the focus of the statement today and the decisive action that the government has made. I would also say on the wider complexities of steel imports and movement of steel products between Northern Ireland and the island of Great Britain, that is a complex situation that reflects the Windsor Agreement. There are things, particularly in the reset of the government's relationship with the EU, that Northern Ireland particularly stands to gain from. This is one of those areas and of course, again, that is a priority for the government to resolve.
Judith Cummins
Can I thank the Secretary of State for his statement this afternoon and I will allow a few moments for the front bench to swap over. Which brings us to a statement on the Robert Hamill Inquiry Report. Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Sir Chris Bryant.
Chris Bryant
Madam Deputy Speaker, I too pass on my condolences to the Prime Minister on the death of his father, and I'm enormously grateful to the First Minister of Northern Ireland, Michelle O'Neill, who texted me a few moments ago to pass on her heartfelt sympathy as well. I'm sure all honourable members would want to share in that. Madam Deputy Speaker, with your permission, I'd like to make a statement on the Robert Hamill Inquiry Report, which is published today. I start by paying tribute to the extraordinary grace and honour Robert Hamill's family have shown in the 29 years since he was murdered. It is hard enough to grieve the death of a loved one, it is even harder to grieve a loved one who was violently assaulted and brutally murdered.
And even worse to grieve a loved one without clear and coherent answers about the circumstances of their death for years and years. Many victims of the troubles have told me of the pain that gnaws away at them because they have no answers. And today will be particularly difficult for Robert's family. So I send them my heartfelt sympathy and I'm sure the sympathy of the whole house. Madam Deputy Speaker, the facts are bleak.
At about 1:20 in the morning of Sunday the 27th of April 1997, a 25-year-old Catholic man, Robert Hamill, a father of three, left a dance at St Patrick's Hall in Thomas Street, Portadown and walked with others down towards the junction with High Street and Market Street where RUC officers were in a parked RUC Land Rover. There, a group of Protestants attacked Robert and left him with such injuries to the head that he never recovered consciousness and he died in hospital 11 days later on the 8th of May 1997.
The inquiry is clear. Robert Hamill suffered head trauma either shortly after that violence broke out or a little later when Protestant youths kicked him while he was on the ground. This trauma included axonal injury, in particular in the brain stem. We find that these injuries directly caused his death. They refer to there being at least three blows to the head and state, "Robert Hamill's death was murder because those who assaulted him must have at least intended to cause him serious injury."
The people who attacked Robert did not know him. Robert had done nothing to provoke such a vicious and violent attack. He was killed simply for being who he was.
To put it bluntly, he was killed solely because he was Catholic. I cannot imagine the pain felt by his family and his companions that day, who were clearly outnumbered as they watched him lying there on the pavement. Madam Deputy Speaker, the intervening years have been plagued by delay. Following the Weston Park talks in 2001, the retired Canadian judge Justice Peter Cory examined six cases and recommended that a public inquiry be launched into Robert's death, which was then established in November 2004, chaired by Justice Sir Edwin Jowitt. He completed his work in 2011, but the government committed not to publish the report until ongoing criminal proceedings had been exhausted.
These ended on the 14th of June 2024 with the conviction of a former RUC officer, Robert Atkinson, for his role in failing to properly investigate the incident and for perverting the course of justice. Given the passage of time and Sir Edwin's health, a new chair was appointed, Sir John Evans, a member of the panel. I am pleased Sir John's report is finally published today, but I fully acknowledge the significant delay, which is through no fault of the inquiry. That delay of 15 years from completion to publication is far too long and has no doubt caused family members additional frustration and anguish. I truly regret that.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the inquiry terms of reference did not include attributing responsibility for Robert's murder, but it addressed two areas of public concern regarding the conduct of the Royal Ulster Constabulary.
First, whether the officers in the Land Rover were in any way responsible for Robert Hamill's death, and second, whether the subsequent investigation into his murder was inhibited by any wrongful act or omission on the part of the RUC. The inquiry finds that, although the RUC Land Rover crew parked near to the outbreak of violence were distracted talking to two members of the public, this did not facilitate Robert Hamill's death. It also finds that the officers in the Land Rover were not guilty of any wrongful act or omission in relation to the death of Robert Hamill. This last point was not the unanimous view of the inquiry panel, as the former chair Sir Edwin Jowitt expressed a dissenting view that the officers were guilty of omission by not keeping watch. The report also finds that the officers did not in any way condone or collude with the attackers.
However, on the second area of public concern, the inquiry findings are disturbing. They conclude that RUC officers were guilty of wrongful omissions and that those omissions arose both at the scene and during the initial investigation between the 27th of April and the 7th of May 1997. These omissions included failure to carry out an initial debriefing both at the scene and immediately upon return to the police station, with multiple officers finishing their shifts or going onto other duties without recording what had happened. This had a serious and significant impact on the murder investigation and these omissions were negligent. Secondly, failure to carry out a full debriefing of all officers who had been at the scene once it became clear that Robert Hamill's injuries were life-threatening.
This omission was negligent.
Thirdly, a wrongful omission by two officers to supply relevant information in relation to an individual they had seen at the scene. This inhibited and obstructed the investigation and was, in the case of one officer, negligent, and in the case of the other, deliberate. The inquiry finds that one RUC officer, Robert Atkinson, is guilty of a wrongful act for making a telephone call to the home of Alistair Hanvey, who was present the night of the incident, which resulted in that individual destroying or putting beyond the reach of police the clothes he had been wearing that night. This deliberately obstructed the investigation. Mr. Atkinson subsequently conspired in September and October 1997 to cover up the tip-off telephone call at an important point in the murder investigation.
The conspiracy amounted to an obstruction of the murder investigation and was deliberate. It was this conduct that resulted in the conviction of Mr. Atkinson in 2024 for conspiring to pervert the course of justice. The Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland, Jon Boutcher, will want to reflect on the report's findings, and I do not want to preempt any comment he may make. I note that policing and justice are now devolved responsibilities, but these events happened under the Royal Ulster Constabulary. I merely say that it is especially disturbing that Mr. Atkinson carried an RUC badge for years when he had so evidently and heinously failed in his duty and acted as a criminal.
Mr. Speaker, the report says there was a catalogue of failings by the RUC.
It is difficult not to agree. The inquiry was empowered to make recommendations and although it makes none for the Northern Ireland Office or the government, I would make a couple of broader points. Firstly, today is a landmark moment and I am proud to be the Secretary of State that can finally share the report with the House, but today is also a reminder to all of us of the long shadow of the troubles and its deep and lasting effect on the people of Northern Ireland and beyond. So we must never forget that many other families still wait and yearn for answers about how their loved ones were killed. My second point is that the peace that was ushered in by the Belfast Good Friday Agreement the year after Robert's death was an extraordinary achievement.
Yes, power sharing is difficult, but we should never take that peace for granted.
After all, Robert's death happened against the background of deep sectarian division. Nobody wants to return to that. Which is why we must always double down on compromise and rise above our immediate instincts to seek a more harmonious way forward. I want to thank the current and former chairs to the inquiry, Sir John Evans and the late Sir Edwin Jowitt, the Reverend Baroness Kathleen Richardson and all those who played a part in its delivery, including Paul Murphy, Lord Murphy now, who commissioned the report. I'll lay a copy of the report in the libraries of both Houses and it will be published in full online.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this will be a difficult day for Robert Hamill's family. He would have been coming up to his 55th birthday in December, younger than me.
He might have become a grandfather or a great-uncle by now. But he was murdered, and murdered just for being a Catholic. We all pay our heartfelt respects to him and to his family. I end by noting one of the final paragraphs of the report. The murder file is still open, and to this day no one has been convicted of causing Robert Hamill's death.
I commend this statement to the House.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I thank the Secretary of State for his statement this afternoon. And may I start by echoing his opening remarks and pass on my own condolences to the Prime Minister and my deepest sympathies to the Hamill family on this most challenging of days. The killing of Robert Hamill was a tragedy, and we on this side of the House condemn all heinous sectarian violence.
Robert Hamill was beaten to death in his own town. His death should never have happened, and his killers should be brought to justice. His family have been waiting 29 years, and Sir Edwin Jowitt did not live to see his own report published. This inquiry took too long. It has long been argued by some that the police did nothing to prevent Mr. Hamill's murder, and yet the report has found, and I quote, "In the event, we have found no wrongful act or omission which facilitated Robert Hamill's death."
The failings of the police were due to a lack of due diligence, and there was no overarching conspiracy in the events that led up to his death. The report does highlight police failings of investigation. These were entirely wrong. In the case of Atkinson, which led to a conviction for perverting the course of justice, we condemn those actions entirely. And we believe that 12 months served is not enough for such a crime.
Those in the RUC who shamed themselves dishonor the many thousands of officers who served with integrity, standing between bombs, bullets and civilians. It is clear that the inquiry has found that this was negligence and there was no overall conspiracy within the RUC to prevent a proper investigation. Those who murdered Robert Hamill could still be walking the streets today. We find it deplorable that they have not been brought to justice. Can I take the opportunity to thank all of those who've been involved in this report.
I'd like to ask the Secretary of State a number of questions. Firstly, thousands of people served in the RUC in one of the most difficult policing environments imaginable.
Will he agree that the vast majority of them carried out their duties with exemplary skill, bravery and deserve our thanks? Secondly, does the Secretary of State accept that the central finding of this report, that no officer in the Land Rover acted wrongfully, is a majority finding from which the inquiry's own chairman dissented? Further, how have the Hamill family been supported throughout the process of publication? Next, this is one of the last of the Cory inquiries to report. What is the government's assessment of those inquiries, of what those inquiries have collectively cost, what they have delivered and what they tell us about the inquiry model as a route to legacy truth recovery?
This inquiry had cost 33 million by the time it was initially completed in 2011 and took a further 15 years to reach the public. What lessons does the government draw for the Omagh bombing inquiry and for the inquiry into the murder of Patrick Finucane?
The Finucane inquiry is already behind schedule. How will the material gathered by the inquiry, more than 20,000 documents and 174 witnesses, be preserved and will it be made available to the body now handling legacy cases and to the Public Record Office in Northern Ireland? And finally, does the government consider the questions raised by this report to be closed by publication, or does it accept there is unfinished business in relation to the DPP's role, which the family had to go to judicial review to have considered? Madam Deputy Speaker, and in conclusion, I finish by joining the Secretary of State in condemning all sectarian violence.
Chris Bryant
Thank you very much, and I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman, and I should welcome him to his post, because he's new in post.
And look, the first thing point I want to make is it's something like 300 RUC officers were killed in the troubles. And I want to pay tribute to the many hundreds of RUC officers who did the and thousands of who did their jobs diligently in very difficult circumstances and with great courage and dedication to all communities in Northern Ireland. That is why a report like this is so painful, including for the many RUC officers who formerly served because they see that the reputation of the organization is brought into disrepute by the actions of some. It's very difficult when you read all the paragraphs and the chapter in here around the investigations and the failings in the investigations not to put your head in your hand and sort of go why on earth could this be the case?
There were manifest failings. And as the honorable member has already referred to, the actions of Robert Atkinson are absolutely despicable. And he has rightly been convicted. The, and indeed when I visited recently the RUC Memorial Garden in Belfast, I was struck by the fact that there were decades when maybe two or three or five or six RUC officers were killed in a decade, and then there were decades when dozens and dozens were killed. But of course we have to take seriously when there are criticisms of processes and we need to make sure that we get those right.
The fact that many of these recommendations were made for the RUC and for the PSNI were made many years ago and have now been implemented, I think is noted.
There aren't any particular questions or recommendations for the government for us to adopt. He asks me about the inquiry cost and he's right that the figure was at something like 33 million and a few more since. I mean I feel a bit conflicted. On the one hand I've met so many people in the short time that I've been Secretary of State for Northern Ireland who lost loved ones and have no idea what happened. I've met people who see the person they believed killed their brother or their husband or their father going to Marks and Spencer's or going about their daily business without ever having been interrupted by the legal system at all and they find that phenomenally painful.
So I do want to get answers for as many people in Northern Ireland as is possible. I also don't want to overpromise, because the truth is that sometimes—there's an irony about this sentence—the truth is complex and nuanced and depends on whose point of view you take. I also note that there are several points in the report where the inquiry panel point out that they would have been able to do more if more people had been able to provide witness statements, but lots of people didn't do so because they felt that they were under threat or they were being cajoled into not doing so. So all of that makes it very difficult to get to truth, but it's why I'm very committed to the Troubles Bill to make sure that it really does deliver a Legacy Commission that is able to get to truth for as many victims as possible.
I often think that one of the things that the Good Friday Agreement did was it brought an end to the fighting, well not immediately, obviously you referred already to the Omagh bombing, but it also meant that lots of people had to try and forget. They were effectively asked to forget what had happened in their own family lives and that's they've borne the brunt of that pain for many decades. So that's why the more we can do to provide answers the better. He asked about the Finucane inquiry, he will know that it's starting its processes in earnest this week. Several governments had promised that there would be an inquiry in that particular case, which is why I think I want to pay tribute to my predecessor for setting up that inquiry and I hope that it will get to answers.
And then the final point he raised was about the DPP.
I would just say that the report itself says, "We have come to the firm view that the process by which the decision was reached to discontinue the prosecution of Reserve Constable Atkinson was riddled with significant flaws." "We have reached the clear view that it was not carried out with due diligence." In fact, of course, subsequent to their interim report, the DPP returned to its original decision to prosecute two people, and that's what led to Mr. Atkinson being convicted.
Hilary James Benn
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I begin by congratulating my right honourable friend on his appointment as Secretary of State?
It's the first chance I've had to do so, and to wish him every success for the future. This is a shocking story of a young man, Robert Hamill, the victim of a sectarian murder, but also of the deliberate decision of a police officer to ring up a suspect to warn him, a few hours after the murder, to dispose of his clothing because it might incriminate him, rather than to fulfill his duty to uphold the law, and then lied about it. Does my right honourable friend agree that it is so important to tell the truth finally about what happened during the Troubles if reconciliation in Northern Ireland is to be progressed?
Chris Bryant
First of all, can I warmly commend my right honourable friend?
If only I could be as nice, sage, honourable, decent, and gentlemanly as he in this role, then I think that I would have performed a decent task. He's absolutely right. There's another thing that is absolutely shocking here, that there's never been an inquest. In fact, this is the first time that it has been declared that this was murder. That of itself is truly shocking.
And this is not the only case in Northern Ireland where there has been no answers provided for individuals. And he's absolutely right. The behaviour of Mr. Atkinson would shock a drama, let alone the fact that it is the truth that he deliberately perverted the course of justice.
And I should say that the inquiry is very keen on making the point that deliberate actions, of course, are much more blameworthy than casual omissions.
Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Paul Kohler.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for early sight of the report and the statement? I want to begin by echoing the Secretary of State's tribute to the grace with which the family of Robert Hamill have faced the wait of nearly three decades for answers. Such a lengthy delay in justice is unacceptable, especially in the face of the heinous sectarian violence that resulted in Mr. Hamill's murder simply because he was a Catholic.
The Minister acknowledges that the delay in publication of this report was no fault of the inquiry because of the understandable decision to wait until proceedings that eventually resulted in the conviction of the former RUC officer, Mr. Atkinson, was concluded. However, I remain bemused it took 13 years for Mr. Atkinson to be convicted for his despicable acts regarding the tip-off to one of the suspects in the murder and subsequent cover-up. This is particularly hard to understand given the facts relating to his criminal behavior were clearly established long before the report was finalized in 2011. Is the Secretary of State able to shed any light on the reason why it took 13 years for these proceedings to be concluded? Furthermore, what actions will the government take to ensure future inquiries do not fall foul of procedural pitfalls to ensure grieving families are given answers in a timely fashion?
Finally, the report identifies many failures of the Royal Ulster Constabulary with regard to negligence, a lack of due diligence, and the failures of inexperienced, untrained officers.
However, it also makes a number of recommendations relevant to the PSNI. As policing justice is now a devolved matter, what role does the Secretary of State envisage for the Northern Ireland Office and himself personally in ensuring those recommendations are implemented and the PSNI embodies the values of accountability and transparency all the communities in Northern Ireland have a right to expect?
Chris Bryant
I'm grateful for his comments. First of all, it is vital that all public, all those in public office exhibit candour. And that is as important for police officers as it is for anybody else, as became painfully apparent throughout the whole process of trying to get justice for those involved in the Hillsborough disaster.
And that applies equally to the PSNI as it did to the RUC. He is right in saying that these are primarily matters now either for the PSNI itself directly or for the Justice Minister in the Northern Ireland Executive. And I'm sure that they will be wanting to look, go through the report with a fine-tooth comb. I should say it's not only that nobody has said up until today that this was a murder. It is also that nobody had actually decided on what was the cause of death until today.
And I would urge honourable members to read the report because the report goes in some detail into precisely what happened and it's very distressing reading.
Claire Hanna
I thank the minister for his very thoughtful statement. I was in sixth form in 1997 and the nightclub his killers were leaving was a haunt of classmates and I, so I think that is why this murder remains in my memory so viscerally. It was so brutal, so sectarian and so many years of injustice for the family. As so often a proper exploration has uncovered collusion as has been the case certainly not all RUC officers but far too many. It is it is painful and difficult for society but the minister will know that suppression does not aid the healing and reconciliation that we need.
It is also impossible to ignore the context of that murder and 20 other human lives wasted around the time of the Drumcree standoff in those years. Would the Secretary of State agree with me that disclosure must be properly addressed in the body he is currently legislating for, and that it is a bleak and a dead-end campaign to reopen the wounds so deep as Drumcree?
Chris Bryant
Well, first of all, I mean, I think everybody wants to condemn sectarianism, but it's awfully easy to stir it up is the truth in every society in the world.
And again, reading the report, it is very striking not only of some of the terms of abuse that were shouted from one side to the other, but also when Robert Hamill's, a couple of witnesses referred to the fact that when Robert Hamill's body was being stretchered into an ambulance, that people were shouting, "I hope he dies." And we need to remember the bitterness that sectarianism can instill in people's hearts, even especially when people are gathered in large crowds. So anything we can possibly do to calm sectarianism, I think is a really important part of my job and all of those who are involved in the politics of Northern Ireland. She makes a very fair point about disclosure and we will be coming to talk about the Troubles Bill in a couple of weeks' time and those are one of the issues of course we'll be addressing.
Carla Lockhart
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and this relates directly to my constituency. I welcome the opportunity to speak to it today.
Robert Hamill's murder was a brutal and appalling crime and my thoughts are first and foremost with his family. They have many questions, as do many families right across Northern Ireland. But the truth matters and the truth today is clear. Paragraph 21 finds that four RUC officers were not aware of the assault until they got out and did not in any way condone or collude with the attackers. Paragraph 75 concludes: "We have found no wrongful act or omission which facilitated Robert Hamill's death."
Put simply, they did not sit idly by, they did not collude, they did not facilitate murder, something that has been hurled at them for the last 30 years.
The complaint advanced by Rosemary Nelson has been demolished by the inquiry, which also found that she failed to cooperate fully with the RUC and did not improve the situation. This goes to the heart of the nationalist republican legacy activism whereby truth and the rule of law are subjective terms to be weaponized to seek to arrive at a predetermined political outcome. More than 300 RUC officers were murdered protecting the entire community. Will the Secretary of State now end this decades-long smear, defend these four officers, and reject any attempt to rewrite history or attach collective guilt to the RUC?
Chris Bryant
Well, that was a slightly partial version of what's in the report. And if she reads the whole report, I think she would come to a rather more subtle position. She's absolutely right that on the issue, on the first issue that the inquiry was asked to look at, namely whether there had been, whether in some way the behavior of those in the crew in the Land Rover were in some way had contributed to the death, the report is absolutely clear that there was no collusion with the attackers. The, however, there are quite serious criticisms of the way the investigation was pursued or was not pursued, was not pursued effectively. And of course then there is the additional issue of how Reserve Constable Atkinson behaved and that whole saga.
I think it's best to tell the whole of the story just rather than just part of the story. I should say I didn't answer one of the questions that was asked earlier about the support for the family.
And I spoke to very briefly I spoke to Diane over the weekend. Of course the Northern Ireland Office has been in contact with the family throughout the process. And in the end of course the most important thing is making sure that the family get the answers that they need.
Speaker 131
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I suppose I think I would expect in this House that if people are going to utter Rosemary Nelson's name they should be calling for justice and the truth around her case as well. Because if people don't realize Rosemary Nelson was also killed by loyalists not that long after.
This report is clear, and I want to send our message of thanks and good wishes to the Hamill family, who've had to struggle for far too long for this report to be released. It's clear there were massive failings corporately on behalf of the RUC and in terms of an individual who deliberately went about his business trying to cover up what happened to Robert Hamill. The impact of legacy is clear on the everyday workings of policing in Northern Ireland today. That is why we have to deal with the legacy issue, and those people in this House who do not want to see prosecutions, even the opportunity for prosecutions for what happened in the past, should read this report and listen to the Hamill family today. Can I also, Madam Deputy Speaker, ask the Secretary of State to join with me, because we need to remember the context, as my right honorable friend has said.
This happened during a murderous sectarian time that all revolved around the issue of Drumcree. And would he join with me in calling for everybody to take a step back to remember what happened not that long ago and try to take us away from using those old issues to stir up hate and sectarianism and potentially much, much worse.
Chris Bryant
Yes, I mean it is often very difficult, including for a well-resourced inquiry, to get to the truth. I just read out another clause from the report. It says, "We are left in no doubt that the decision by so many to have no recollection was by no means always spontaneous but was the result of suggestion, cajolery and in some cases threat." This has added to our difficulties. The truth is that sometimes the sectarianism doesn't just lead to the murder, it also leads to the cover-up.
And that's why I'm very keen to make sure that we do everything we possibly can to diminish that. There's a Purcell anthem I used to have to sing a lot when I was at university and at school, which includes the lines, "Let your moderation be known unto all men." And perhaps that should be our motto.
Jim Allister.
Jim Allister
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I should declare that in a previous life, I was one of the defense counsel in the murder case which arose from the shocking death of Robert Hamill. So there was a murder trial, and there was a jury verdict of not guilty. And I think we shouldn't forget that either.
But could I suggest to the Secretary of State, after 33 million pounds and more, what is it that we now know from this report that we didn't know from the public murder trial, that we didn't know from the public appearances and reporting and trial of Robert Atkinson? We have spent over 33 million pounds and most of what's in this report was already in the public domain. Perhaps what wasn't in the public domain was the fact that the audacious, constant propaganda that the police officers had colluded in the murder, that that has now been wholly debunked.
And the report quite properly finds that they did no wrongful act or omission facilitating that murder. But that's a big price to pay to arrive at that conclusion. And there was no collusion, contrary to the constant refrain of some for almost 30 years. And in that, I welcome the fact that that at least has been laid to rest.
Chris Bryant
Um, well, first of all, just because nobody has been convicted of murder doesn't mean that a murder wasn't committed. And indeed, I think one of the most painful aspects of all of this is that clearly, um, as this report finds for the first time, um, there was a murder.
The cause of death was at least three beatings to the head that Robert Hamill received, possibly two or more being kicks to the head when he was already lying on the ground, possibly a third from a bottle. And I mean, it does sort of beggar belief in this country that we can all decide that somebody was murdered, but no one ends up facing justice for the murder. And I suppose that's one of the pains that has often arisen in many of the cases that we deal with here.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Madam Deputy Speaker, can I thank the Secretary of State very much for his answers. For grieving families, the absence of answers prolongs the pain and the grief. There's also, of course, a wider public interest in ensuring legacy cases such as Robert Hamill's are dealt with both efficiently and fairly.
But does the Secretary of State appreciate that inquiries and investigations that last decades continue to place significant demands on police time and resources and require large sums of public money, and that complex legacy cases can take time to investigate properly and due process must always be respected? Thank you.
Chris Bryant
Yes, of course I recognize that, and in addition to that, of course there is the problem that for the families and for all the witnesses and the many other people who were there that night, for instance, there's the anguish of going through that process through multiple legal processes, judicial reviews, considerations of the DPP, the original report by Justice Cory and then the eventual launching of the inquiry.
All of that, of course, has an emotional cost as well as a financial cost. I'm not wanting to set the financial cost aside, of course, that's a consideration for government, especially at a difficult time fiscally. But in the end, I think we want to get as many answers as we possibly can for people. And I say this as much for the families of the 300 or so RUC officers who were killed, or the 1,100 members of the security services who were killed in Northern Ireland, and the families who were killed in whatever set of circumstances in Northern Ireland. That's why I want to make sure that the Legacy Commission really is able to do the job that we're setting it up to do.
And that's why I think it's important that the Troubles Bill goes through its passage. I'd just say one other thing, which is that it's one thing for us in the British government to be candid.
I think it's also important that the Irish government be candid. And that's why it's such an important part of the process that we're undergoing with the Troubles Bill, that when I've spoken to my opposite numbers in Dublin, Helen McEntee and Jim O'Callaghan, they've been very keen to say that they want to make sure that their necessary legislation, which enables them to participate in the process of providing answers for people and giving information, happens in lockstep with ours, so that they would be implemented at the same time. I think if you can get the two governments working together to provide answers, then there will be many, many more families who will have, I hate the word closure, but will at least have a moment when they're able to understand that this moment is done.
Richard Tice
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to apologize to this House for failing to declare an interest when participating in a Westminster Hall debate on the 22nd of June 2026 on the topic of pro-Israel influence on UK politics and democracy. When speaking in the debate, I failed to declare the relevant interest, which was that I went on a visit to Israel between the 26th and the 30th of September 2025, funded by Reform Friends of Israel. And whilst the trip is properly recorded in my register of interests, I should have declared it during the speech. That, Madam Deputy Speaker, is a breach of the rules, and I apologize to this good House.
Speaker 136
Can I thank the honorable member for his point of order.
There will be no further points of order on that issue. I'll allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over. We now come to presentation of bill, Vicky Slade.
Speaker 143
Friday the 5th of March 2027. We now come to the allocation of time motion, minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 136
The question is as on the order paper. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Torsten Bell
Minister, Torsten Bell.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I beg to move that the bill be read a second time. This bill relates to the Sovereign Grant, which Parliament has provided to support the official duties of the monarch and the work of the Royal Household. This bill implements the conclusions of the recent Royal Trustees' review of that Sovereign Grant. In doing so, it resets the grant level for the next financial year, giving effect to the commitment of successive governments and the expectation of the Royal Household for a reduction in the level of funding following the completion of the Buckingham Palace reservicing program, which keen members will have heard about on the news this morning on the back of the discovery of some historical documents.
The bill also makes targeted improvements to the statutory framework for this funding, introducing limited flexibilities to ensure that funding levels remain appropriate even in exceptional circumstances. This will make it easier to respond where funding would otherwise become inappropriately low or inappropriately high. To support the monarch's official duties, the Sovereign Grant funds the staff, official travel, property maintenance, and essential services required for the sovereign to fulfill their unique constitutional role. And that role extends beyond ceremonial functions. It includes hosting heads of state, supporting diplomatic engagements, representing the United Kingdom overseas, and strengthening our relationships across the Commonwealth and indeed the world.
These activities support UK interests, including trade, investment, and security.
At home, the grant supports the sovereign and the wider royal household's significant role, from recognizing charitable and voluntary service to bringing communities together across the United Kingdom. Since 2012, the level of the sovereign grant has been determined through a statutory framework established by Parliament in the 2011 Sovereign Grant Act. That framework requires the annual grant amount to be calculated by reference to the previous year's expenditure and a percentage of the profits of the Crown Estate, an independent public corporation whose net revenue profits are returned to the Exchequer. To ensure that funding levels remain appropriate, the 2011 Act also requires the Royal Trustees, that is the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Keeper of the Privy Purse, to conduct regular reviews. These must take place, of course.
Jim Shannon
That's been set incredibly well and he's right that the British monarchy has very clearly been a source of stability across the world.
And he's also right to say that their presence and unity in a world full of division remains irreplaceable. But does the Minister agree that whilst we acknowledge the ongoing need to review and to adjust the Sovereign Grant, that it is vital that the monarchy remains appropriately funded? So perhaps maybe when the Minister's summing up or indicating further, can he assure us that they will be effectively funded to fulfill their duty for this country, the Great United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland?
Torsten Bell
Well, I thank the honourable member for his question and for his tribute to the Monarch and the way he describes what he would like to see in the setting of the Sovereign Grant reflects exactly what has to take place. As I was just explaining, the Trustees, those three individuals, are required to take into account exactly the funding levels that are required to be able to deliver the function that we all want to see our Monarch to deliver. Of course.
Speaker 23
I'm very grateful to the minister for giving way. And the sovereign grant annual report and accounts, which this bill refers to and which he's just describing, has what might or might not be an important innovation in the text of this year's report, which usually the sovereign's role is described as including the term the defender of the faith. Those that term doesn't appear in this year's report and accounts. Instead, the monarch is referred to as the supreme governor of the Church of England. Good.
Also, that he protects the space for faith within the multi-faith nation. Also an admirable ambition. I'm just concerned to check and invite the minister to confirm that there is no alteration to the monarch's role implied in this change.
And if there were to be such a change, that that's something that would be debated properly in Parliament rather than introduced quietly through these sorts of official reports.
Torsten Bell
I thank the honorable member for his question as well, and I know this is a topic he's shown interest in over a very wide number of years and in a lot of different environments. I think this is a question of and rather than or. As the honorable member says himself, the document he's referring to spells out that His Majesty is the supreme governor of the Church of England. And if I encourage him to go on to the Royal Family's own website, he will see the language about the defender of the faith very prominently displayed. So I hope that gives him the reassurance that he is seeking in this House today.
Andrew Murrison
Of course. Extremely fortunate to have a monarchy, in particular this monarchy.
Since the reign of George III, the profits from the Crown Estates have accrued to the Treasury, and in return the institution of monarchy receives a grant that we're debating today. And part of that is levied on a proportion of the profits annually determined. However, outside exceptional expenditures such as Buckingham Palace, the institution presumably requires some sort of stability and certainty in relation to the receipts necessary to carry out its functions. Is it therefore logical for that to be predicated on a proportion of profits that are inevitably, because they're commercial, going to vary year in, year out?
Torsten Bell
Well, I thank the honourable member for his question.
I think everybody in this house will agree with the thrust of what he's trying to well not trying to he's successfully arguing which is that a royal household with an important role both as the sovereign but also in maintaining an estate of grade one listed and monuments needs certainty in its income. That's why the 2011 act and it's not for me to defend the the previous government the 2011 act provided two basis on for funding. One was the mechanism that the honorable member has mentioned about a proportion of the profits of the royal of the um um the Crown Estate. But with a second proviso that you would not see a fall year to year in the level of the grant to provide exactly the stability he's talking about. That's why that we are taking forward this primary legislation given that that was the dual lock to see this reduction this year purely to take into account of the bring into an end of the Buckingham Palace repair ten year project.
But that then provides that ongoing commitment to the royal household and to the monarch that the grant will remain at least at the level that it will be next year.
I hope that offers him the reassurance on the point that he is raised. As I was saying, a key point of context for the House today is that Parliament agreed this temporary uplift to the grant that ran from 2017-18 to 2026-27 to fund the Buckingham Palace reservicing program. That program has been a major 10-year investment to modernize aging infrastructure, replace critical electrical and mechanical systems, and to safeguard the long-term future of one of the nation's most historic buildings. As that program now nears completion, now is the right time for the level of funding to be reassessed. Earlier this year, the then Royal Trustees completed the latest review and considered both the Royal Household's projected expenditure and the Crown Estate's projected revenues for the period from 2027 to 2032.
The Trustees concluded that with the Buckingham Palace reservicing programme nearing completion, the exceptional funding requirements that justified that temporary uplift no longer exist. They therefore recommended that the level of the Sovereign Grant should fall from 137.9 million in 26-27 to 99.9 million in 27-28. That does represent a reduction of almost 38 million, or more than a quarter compared with the current year. At the same time, though, the Trustees recognised that the Royal Household continues to face operational pressures in delivering what we all think is important, crucial work. The recommended level of funding will enable the household to address a maintenance backlog that was exacerbated by the pandemic and to replace ageing digital infrastructure to strengthen cyber security.
The grant level provided for by this Bill therefore ensures value for money for taxpayers and that the Royal Household can continue to discharge its crucial functions effectively.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill delivers a fair and proportionate funding settlement. It reduces the level of the sovereign grant following the completion of a major capital program. It improves the resilience and the sustainability of the statutory framework established in 2011 while maintaining parliamentary oversight. And it ensures that the sovereign grant can continue to fulfill its core purpose, supporting the official duties of the monarch and maintaining the occupied royal palaces on behalf of the nation. And on that basis, I commend this bill to the house.
Speaker 152
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. Shadow Minister Richard Fuller.
Richard Fuller
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I thank the minister for his speech on the second reading. This follows a debate recently on the ways and means which his colleague, the Exchequer Secretary, had with one of my colleagues. I don't wish to repeat a number of points that were made there.
His Majesty's Official Opposition is supportive of this bill. As the Minister laid out, Madam Deputy Speaker, the 2011 settlement has really sort of run its course. It's done well for its time, but there were some aspects of that that were due some reconsideration. And secondly, as the Minister has said, the recent significant program of upgrades to royal residences for public purposes have now reached their conclusion. I think this year is the final year of the additional funds, and so it is a timely moment for us to look for a change in structure.
I'd like to thank his colleague the Exchequer Secretary because on the 11th of this month he wrote in reply to questions from my colleague that answer some of the points that we may get into as we go through a detailed representation of the bill. In principle one of the substantial changes here is that the ongoing ratchet that was effectively in place by the 2011 bill act has become essentially a backstop of 99.9 million. And I think the minister in response to a question from my honourable friend in answering the question about potential variability has given some some confidence that at least in planning they know there won't be some absolute reduction. There do remain some questions however about the extraordinary power or extraordinary circumstances under which the Treasury would be able to reduce the amount of the settlement in any one year. And I think that's in reverse also a question that the Liberal Democrats will be asking about changes to the percentage that may occur as well.
But these are matters that we can get to in the midst of the next section, Madam Deputy Speaker. His Majesty's official opposition recognize the tremendous work that His Majesty the King and the Royal Family do on behalf of our nation. We understand the power that that provides our nation in our international relations, the comfort that it gives to the people of this nation, and we support this bill at second reading.
Brian Leishman.
Brian William Leishman
Madam Deputy Speaker, good afternoon. My sense of patriotism does not come from a flag or an anthem or the Royal Family.
Instead, my patriotism comes from things like our National Health Service, or movements like the Levellers, who were committed to popular sovereignty, extended suffrage, equality, and religious tolerance. Or how Britain stood up and defeated the evil of fascism, both abroad during the Second World War and at home in places like Cable Street, where Jewish residents, Irish dockers, trade unionists, socialists, and others united to stop Britain's British Union of Fascists movement from marching through Jewish neighborhoods. That's the sort of patriotism I love. Madam Deputy Speaker, I wish to say that I have the utmost respect for any citizen that believes that the Royal Family is a fundamental part of British life. I have no issues with that opinion.
People are entitled to it. But simply, it is not one that I share. There were many reasons why I joined the Labour Party.
One was to change...
Speaker 155
Order. Now, I'm sure the honourable gentleman is expecting this. It is important that he focuses his remarks on the Sovereign Grant Bill and not wider issues to do with the monarchy, patriotism, or indeed why he joined the Labour Party. Brian Leishman.
Brian William Leishman
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will just put a red pen, a very dark red pen obviously, through some of the comments I wished to make. And I'll accelerate to say that it's clear that we have a nation of persistent inequality. So I fully appreciate that the role of the Royal Family is way down the list of pressing issues that my government have to deal with. But when looking at the intense suffering millions of people are experiencing, I can't help but feel that the Sovereign Grant money could and should be directed elsewhere and not to a family that is worth an estimated 21 billion pounds.
Bobby Dean
Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Bobby Dean.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Liberal Democrats understand the purpose of this bill and accept some of the government's conclusions about how the grant needs to change, but we maintain some concerns about transparency. It's important to make clear at the start that the Sovereign Grant provides no personal income to the King or Queen or any member of the Royal Family, and the funding is tied entirely to the running of the institution. We recognize that the household's budget has increased, but the bulk of that is increases earmarked for maintenance backlog across the Royal Palaces, green infrastructure, and cybersecurity in an increasingly hostile international landscape. And we agree that it is right for the grant to be reset now that the Buckingham Palace program has finished.
However, it is right that taxpayers will have questions about where and importantly who this money goes to. Having disgraced his chartered office, the government must ensure that not a penny of this grant goes to Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor.
Speaker 136
Order. I'm going to reiterate my comments. We are going to stick to the scope of the Sovereign Grant Bill, which is very specifically only the amount of the Sovereign Grant and how it is to be determined in future years. The honorable gentleman will be aware that the grant goes to the King. Bobby Dean.
Bobby Dean
Thank you, Madam Speaker, I'll move on to our amendment directly. This inserts a new subsection stopping the Royal Trustees from proposing any future increases to percentage of Crown Estate profit used in the grant formula unless three conditions are met first.
The National Audit Office must be commissioned to carry out a value for money assessment of the proposed change.
Speaker 136
Order. Apologies, and I appreciate I'm now leaping to my feet with monotonous regularity. It would be more appropriate for the amendment to be discussed in committee than at second reading.
Bobby Dean
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Clearly I've been very well briefed. I think at this moment my comments at the beginning are probably sufficient, that we understand the purpose of the Sovereign Grant Bill changes. We have some concerns about transparency, which I will turn to later.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for a second time.
As I said during the Ways and Means debate, I welcome the government's decision to bring forward this legislation to make it possible for the Sovereign Grant to be reduced in the future if necessary and to return any unspent grant more quickly than has been the case before. I am also grateful to the Exchequer Secretary for his letter this morning, which covered some of the points I'd made previously in the debate. But today's bill feels like a real missed opportunity, especially when there remain a number of issues surrounding the grant that I believe the government should address. Now, the first is the link between the grant and the profits of the Crown Estate. Members will know that the Crown Estate commands a massive 16 billion pounds portfolio, including much of our coastline and the corresponding seabed.
But it's not the private property of the monarch. Neither do the revenues from the estate belong to them. In fact, the Crown Estate is quite separate from the monarchy and operates to generate revenue for the Treasury. The inference of this current arrangement is that the monarch foregoes his profits from the Crown Estate in return for a payment of a percentage via the Sovereign Grant. Yet all the profits are actually public funds.
This therefore seems a very odd form of indexation and begs the question why the grant isn't based on the needs of the monarchy or its actual costs. It would have therefore been better if this bill could have broken the link to the Crown Estate and given power to the Royal Trustees to decide the appropriate figure based on actual need. This then raises a second question, Madam Deputy Speaker, of how the grant should be set. I believe this should be done on an annual basis and it's important that the funding of the monarchy is transparent and open to MPs for debate. All public funds should rightly be open to scrutiny and parliamentary oversight.
Numerous times I have tried to table questions about these issues only to be told this is not something for Parliament to discuss. This has to change.
And that's why I will be supporting amendment one that will be debated later. Thirdly, the bill calls for a substantial increase in the grant and a rise from 12% of the Crown Estate profits to 20.5%. Yet the Royal Family is smaller than it was in 2011 when the grant was first introduced, and the King and Prince of Wales are said to favor a slimmed-down monarchy. Making the anticipated increase to 99.9 million pounds is not based, it would appear, on any assessment of actual need.
And I'd appreciate if the Minister could explain exactly how we have arrived at a figure that is 322% higher than it was when it was first introduced in 2012. Even allowing for inflation and the building maintenance program that's been mentioned, the proposed grant is well over twice the real value of its starting point. Now, as I mentioned during the Ways and Means debate, there are also some anomalies when we look at the monarch's wider financial arrangements. For example, why is no account taken of the profits of the Duchy of Lancaster when setting the level of the Sovereign Grant? Ideally, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I can see you're very keen to bring me to book, we should have a bill before us that ensures the amount of the Sovereign Grant is appropriate to the relative needs of the monarch and that MPs are not restricted to just approving a new percentage figure once every five years via an arbitrary and unnecessary link to the Crown Estate.
It's a missed opportunity in my view to modernize the monarchy and I look forward to the Minister's comments.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Which brings us to the Minister, Dan Tomlinson.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank all honorable members from across the House for their contributions to this debate. And I thank my honorable friend, the member for Poole, in particular for his engagement at Ways and Means debate and I was glad to be able to write to him and the opposition in the intervening days in order to clarify a few points and I hope expand on some of the information I set out at Ways and Means.
Just briefly, just to touch on the headline of the three things the bill is doing, then I'll come to the points raised and wrap up in good time. First, the bill resets the level of the Sovereign Grant to reflect the fact that the exceptional funding requirement associated with the Buckingham Palace resurfacing program is coming to an end. Secondly, it establishes a revised mechanism for calculating the grant in future years. And thirdly, introduces limited powers to adjust the grant in exceptional circumstances, powers that have already been discussed in proceedings, including where funding would otherwise become inappropriately high. Taken together, it's the government's view that these changes amount to a measured and sensible reform.
To turn to some of the points raised, my honorable friend the member for Grangemouth made a valuable contribution. I would have enjoyed to hear more of it, but I understand and I'll make sure I keep within scope, Madam Deputy Speaker, too. The point he made in finishing is that he didn't think it was appropriate for this sum, the 99.9 million, to go to the royal family. It's of course worth clarifying that this grant is not for the family for their personal purposes, but this is to enable His Majesty the King and the working members of the royal family to carry out their official duties on behalf of all of us and on behalf of the country.
Turning to the points made by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, well, I look forward to debating the proposed amendment in more detail at committee stage, and I thank the Liberal Democrats and the official opposition for their support and engagement on the bill. And then to turn again to my honorable friend, the member for Poole, if I understood right, his key question is why is the grant set relative to the profits from the Crown Estate at 20.5% rather than the needs of the household? And I would like to reassure him that the key thing really is the needs of the household rather than the 20.5%.
The way that the trustees arrive at the relevant figures is via a bottom-up assessment of what is required in order to enable the Royal Household to carry out their duties on our behalf, not via starting with the relevant percentage of the Crown Estate profits, but instead starting with the specific needs and the requirements for the monarchy. And just on his specific point about the increase in the Sovereign Grant over recent years, he is right to point out, Madam Deputy Speaker, that it is set to increase by a larger amount than inflation.
But there are a number of particular reasons for this that were interrogated by the trustees when the decision to get to a 99.9 million grant was determined, including, for example, an 11.7 million addition for a 10-year program to replace the gas heating systems at Buckingham Palace and Windsor Castle as part of the Royal Household's clean energy transition, 4.3 million to modernize aging digital infrastructure and strengthen cybersecurity and replace some legacy IT systems, some of which are over 20 years old, 11.5 million for other cost increases like utilities, travel, housekeeping, equipment, and professional services. And on the point around inflation, which I do take and understand the point he's making, I would also point out that the grant will be frozen effectively, well, it will be frozen in cash terms throughout the next five-year period.
This goes both to the point that the honourable member made around stability for the finances for the royal household and does go, I think, some way to explaining why it's not the government's view that coming back each year and setting the grant would have been the most appropriate and efficient way to set the grant, rather to set it at a level that those who are seeking to deliver value for money for the taxpayer, particularly in terms of long-term capital expenditure via the sovereign grant, are able to do so, much more easy to do that when, when it's possible to plan on a long-term basis. I would happily give way to the honourable member.
Jim Shannon
Quick one in relation to the buildings that the royal family have all over the country. The very nature of the buildings are, they're of some age.
The very nature of the buildings are that there's a deterioration because of the size, because of the heating, because of the roofs, because of the way the buildings and the and the length of time that they've actually been in existence. Does the minister agree that when it comes to responsibility of the Royal Family and looking after buildings, that fuller consideration must be given to those buildings which are showing years, maybe hundreds of years of deterioration?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Yes, I would agree with the honorable member on this point. These buildings are Grade I listed and scheduled ancient monuments which have a very significant part and part of our national story and for many our national identity. And on the point he raises about the quality of the estate, I can tell the House that independent surveys found that 52% of the estate was at the target condition in 2020 and that had fallen to 38% by 2025.
To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, the question before us today is really a practical one. Do we wish to leave in place a framework that no longer properly reflects the end of the exceptional reservicing expenditure on the palace, or do we wish to put in place a revised framework that resets the grant, improves flexibility, and preserves the ability of the grant to fulfill its core purpose? The government's view is that the right course is the latter. And Madam Deputy Speaker, these measures are targeted, proportionate, and they do deliver value for money for taxpayers. They improve the existing framework to the sovereign grant so that it continues to operate, I believe, as Parliament intended.
And I commend this bill to the House.
Speaker 136
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Order.
Speaker 164
Under the allocation of time order of today, we now move to Committee of the whole House.
Speaker 136
Order. Sovereign Grant Bill Committee. Can I remind members that in Committee members should not address the Chair as Deputy Speaker, please use my name when addressing the Chair or Madam Chair, Chair and Madam Chairman are also acceptable. We're going to begin with Clause 1, with which it will be convenient to consider Amendment 1 and Clauses 2, 3 and 4. The question is that Clause 1 stand part of the Bill.
I call the Minister, Dan Tomlinson.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Thank you, Madam Chair. I will turn briefly to each of the short clauses in this bill in turn in opening at committee stage. Clause 1 gives effect to the central purpose of the bill. It sets the amount of the Sovereign Grant for the financial year 2027-28 at 99.9 million and in doing so resets the level of the grant following the completion of the Buckingham Palace reservicing program. As that program nears completion, the temporary funding associated with it is no longer required.
Both the previous government and this government recognized that the level of the grant should therefore be reset and legislation would be necessary to achieve that outcome. This is what clause 1 does.
It establishes a grant of 99.9 million for 2027-28, reflecting the conclusions of the 2026 Royal Trustees review. The practical effect of this is therefore that funding falls from 137.9 million in this financial year to 99.9 million in 2027-28.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Chair. I desperately tried not to intervene at all today, but I couldn't stop myself. I was on the Modernization Committee when the Modernization Committee had the opportunity to visit Buckingham Palace and see some of the regeneration work that was being done. So would he, does he feel reassured as I do, that they did that renovation work as efficiently and as practically as they possibly could, bringing in apprentices from elsewhere? I don't think any of them came from Harlow, unfortunately, to make sure that that was a success.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Yeah, I thank my honorable friend for that intervention.
And he is right to highlight that the works on Buckingham Palace over the last 10 years have been carried out with efficiency and effectiveness. And in fact, the National Audit Office took a look at the program of work and were able to commend it for its effective use of taxpayer money, which is of course very important. Yes. Clause 1 therefore delivers the intended reduction in funding following the completion of that work and implements the conclusions of the Royal Trustees' review to establish a new baseline for future years. Turning to clause 2, having reset the grant for 2027-28, clause 2 turns to the framework that will determine grant funding in future years.
It has, the grant has since 2012 been linked to the performance of the Crown Estate and that principle, that underlying principle remains unchanged by this bill. What clause 2 does is update the percentage of Crown Estate profits used within that calculation so that the framework remains appropriate after the grant has been reset through this bottom-up calculation. And it sets the relevant percentage at 20.5%. Returning to conversations that we had at second reading, I want to reassure members at committee that that figure is not arbitrary and it comes directly from the conclusions of the June 2026 Royal Trustees' review, which assessed both the Royal Household's expected expenditure requirements and the Crown Estate's forecast revenues over the period 2031 to 2032.
Turning to clause 3, this clause introduces targeted safeguards to ensure that the funding framework can continue to operate effectively, Madam Chair, in exceptional circumstances. This is to make sure that where royal trustees conclude that the amount produced by the statutory formula would result in the reserve, the Sovereign Grant Reserve, falling below 10% of annual expenditure or exceeding 50% of annual expenditure, and where the existing framework cannot adequately correct that outcome, the trustees must explain that conclusion in their annual report and identify the new amount that they believe would be appropriate. The Treasury must then implement that through regulations.
This reform allows greater flexibility to prevent reserves becoming either too large or too small, and it means that action can be taken before reserve levels move outside of a sustainable range, rather than waiting until existing statutory mechanisms have been triggered. The second mechanism is a limited power to increase the grant during a financial year in genuinely exceptional circumstances and is intended as an emergency power. It can only be used where unforeseen circumstances arise during a financial year that cannot be reasonably addressed through the normal annual funding process. Clause 4, Madam Chair, contains standard provisions relating to commencement and the short title of the bill, and I commend this and all the clauses to the committee.
Richard Fuller
Shadow Minister Richard Fuller.
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Chairman, and thank you also to the Minister for his very clear exposition of the clauses in this bill. And he emphasized the importance of the 2026 Royal Trustees' review. And it really is on their—the interesting thing here is it's on their forecasts of their needs over the next five years upon which a lot of this mechanism rests. And notwithstanding some of the comments that were made by some of the backbenchers on the government side, actually a lot of this intention is on financial restrictions on expenditure rather than excess in the future. So I would be grateful, and as I say, I am grateful for the Minister's letter to my honorable friend, the member for Dumfries and Galloway, to just, if he can in his summing up, just give a bit more comfort and clarity on some of these matters.
So the 99.9 million pounds, if I'm right for the minister, is the estimate of what is required this year based on a view of what the forecast expenditures or requirements may be through to 2031-32. Could he explain how those assessments were made on a financial basis, what discount rate was used to work out what the estimates might be? I'm not questioning it, I just think we just want to know from... I don't need the precise figure, Madam Chair. What I'm really looking for is some comfort from the minister that he feels that those financial projections, that model and the work of the trustees, give him adequate confidence that the baseline that he is setting today of 99.9, he feels comfortable with that, because that leads in turn, Madam Chair, to why we have 20.5, which is then what the variability is over the next five years. Secondly, I was interested in his response to my honorable friend about the use of other income.
And in his letter, he says that, uh, the household forecasts that this income will increase by around 25% over the review period based on recent performance, detailed modelling, increased visitor capacity. Um, but he says if income were lower than forecast, there is no expectation that the grant would increase above 99.9 million pounds per year. And I think that's right, isn't it, if I may say, Madam Chair, and the Minister can confirm, that essentially the other income is being treated exactly as that, that is supplementary to what, uh, we see as the duty of us under the Sovereign Grant Bill.
I'd just be grateful for the minister reconfirming what he put in his letter. I am interested in the clause, if I can get it right, 2, no, 3C, subsection 5, which is the reserve fund, the treatment of the reserve fund will be no lower than 10% and no higher than 50%. So that is of interest, it's the duty really to change the amount of the Sovereign Grant. There is an issue about whether that reserve at 10 to 50%, to what extent is that seen as is going to cover reasonable expectations of expense. This gets to the point that my honorable friend who is no longer in his place was making earlier on about the long-term planning, because if you are looking for long-term plans, there are significant capital expenditures due, then your reserve by its very nature will be quite variable during the period.
Just some comfort from the Minister that that rate, which sounds on face value 10% to 50%, Madam Chair, to be a pretty reasonable range, just some comfort that in the modelling that was seen to be correct. In his advice, just one slight concern about the Treasury's thinking on this. Under a question that my honourable friend the Member for North West Norfolk asked about powers to adjust the grant between reviews and the circumstances in which it might be used, the answer from the Treasury was: "These powers are intended for exceptional circumstances and are not expected to be used routinely", which of course is a definition of exceptional. But it does then go on to talk about major fire, flood, etc. Just in those circumstances, any adjustment would require a parliamentary approval through secondary legislation.
Could the Minister advise: will that come for an affirmative vote or not?
Because I think to a certain extent, as he answers questions from the other members, they may want to raise that as well. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Bobby Dean
Thank you, Madam Chair. The Liberal Democrats support the thrust of this bill. It understands why the household budget has increased and agrees that it's right for the grant to be reset now that the Buckingham Palace program has finished. But it remains concerned about transparency and has put forward an amendment to that effect. Our amendment inserts a new subsection stopping the Royal Trustees from proposing any future increase to the percentage of Crown Estate profit used in the grant formula unless three conditions are met first.
The National Audit Office must be commissioned to carry out a value for money assessment of the proposed change. That NAO report must be laid before both Houses.
And finally, the House of Commons must debate and approve the change by resolution. Now this contrasts with the current bill, which sets the figure straight into primary legislation on the strength of the Royal Trustees' own conclusions, with no separate independent check built in for the next time that that percentage is revisited. And this matters because it is the Royal Trustees who produce that report, and they are the Prime Minister, the Chancellor, and the Keeper of the Privy Purse. In other words, the people proposing the change are marking their own homework, with no independent body or vote required to test whether it represents good value for the taxpayer.
This amendment isn't about opposing the grant or blocking today's readjustment, which the party accepts is right now and the resurfacing works are complete. It's about ensuring that if the percentage is proposed to go up again in the future, that the taxpayers get an independent NAO assessment value for money check and their elected representatives get an actual vote on it, rather than the change simply following through the trustees' own formula. So to conclude, Madam Chair, the Liberal Democrats believe that greater transparency and independent scrutiny of taxpayer money must be built into the system for the future, not treated as optional, and that is best guaranteed by external checks, not simply taking the government's word for it.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Minister.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And I thank opposition spokespeople for their questions and comments. Turning first to the questions from the opposition spokesperson.
The OBR forecasts for inflation, interest rates, etc. were used as the underlying basis for the projections going forward. And to the extent that we members across the House support the OBR and its independent forecasting duties, then I hope that they would support the Royal Household using those forecasts. On the point he makes about the reserve, it was previously the case that the household had aimed to maintain reserves of at least 5% of annual expenditure. So this legislation does formalize a slightly higher reserve at 10% as the floor, with 50% being the ceiling. It is our judgment that that is a reasonable.
Of course, 50% is a significant reserve.
And on the point, on the question he makes about over time if the grant, what was the point he was making, give me one second, Madam Chair. Yes, on the point as to what happens to the reserve, of course it can be drawn down on in times when the Royal Household does face significant in-year financial costs. And it wouldn't be that the first reaction of the Treasury and the trustees would be to come to the House to ask for a vote to increase the expenditure if there were an additional in-year cost. And instead it would be hoped that capital programs could be smoothed out over time and that the flexibility that the reserve allows could be drawn on.
He asked the specific question about whether or not the vote would be affirmative or negative in the House if there were to be changes. And I can confirm that it would be an affirmative vote. We would have an option to debate and discuss if the percentage were to go up. If the percentage were to go down, my understanding is it would be a negative vote on that. On the points made by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, obviously grateful to the honorable member for raising important issues of transparency, accountability, and value for money.
However, it's the government's view that this amendment is not necessary. Under the existing framework, any future proposal to increase the percentage used to calculate the sovereign grant would already require a published report from the trustees setting out the rationale. And as I've just said, it would require a Commons approval through an affirmative statutory instrument.
So members of this House would have analysis and opportunity to debate any proposed change. The National Audit Office already plays an important role in scrutinizing the Sovereign Grant. It audits the grant annually and can undertake value-for-money examinations where it considers that such work would assist Parliament, and it has exercised those powers as we've discussed in relation to the Buckingham Palace resurfacing program. The amendment would also create a unique test that is not applied in other bodies funded by the public sector. And it's the government's view, Madam Chair, that the Sovereign Grant is already subject to robust arrangements for accountability and scrutiny, including managing public money principles, accounting officer oversight, National Audit Office audit, and parliamentary approval for legislative changes.
So for those reasons, I respectfully ask the honorable member not to press the amendment.
Speaker 136
Could I just clarify whether the honorable member wishes to withdraw the amendment? Amendment by leave withdrawn. So the question is that clause 1 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. With the leave of the House, I will put a single question on the remaining clauses. The question is that clauses 2 to 4 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 168
I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order. Order. I beg to report that the committee has gone through the bill and directed me to report the same without amendment. Under the order of the House of today, we shall now move to third reading of the bill.
Minister to move third reading. Dan Tomlinson.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you, and I thank honorable members on both sides of the House for their contributions today as this bill has progressed.
I believe we've done it justice. We have interrogated at committee stage and at second and at second reading various points of contention and clarification. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this bill to the house.
Speaker 136
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. Shadow Minister Richard Fuller.
Richard Fuller
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to thank the minister for presenting this bill. But most importantly, I'd like to thank His Majesty the King for his gracious service on behalf of all members of this house and all people of this country and the territories and nations overseas. And that he will use the sovereign grant as wisely and sagaciously as his governance service allows. And I support the bill at third reading.
Bobby Dean
Liberal Democrat spokesperson Bobby Dean.
I'd like to thank the Minister for his comments in response to our amendment that we laid earlier. We recognize the arguments that he made in response to us, and I support this bill at third reading.
Speaker 136
The question is that the bill be now read the third time. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye." Of the contrary, "No." I think the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it.
Motion number four on business of the House today. Minister to move.
Speaker 136
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye." Of the contrary, "No." I think the Ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now come to the motions relating to select committee chairs period of leave, select committees participation, privilege, and standing orders etc. machinery of government changes, which will be debated together. Before we begin, I should note that there is a small error in the printed order in the motion on standing orders etc. machinery of government changes under section B, related provisions, paragraph two, sub-paragraph two. The committee names should be swapped around. A corrected version of this motion is available from the vote office and the online version of the order paper has been corrected.
I call the leader of the house to move the motion relating to select committee chairs period of leave. Leader of the house.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move the motions in my name on the order paper. I've brought forward these motions today seeking approval for recommendations by the Modernisation Committee, the Committee of Privileges and the changes to standing orders following machinery of government changes. And I will briefly address each motion. I should make it clear that in speaking to the motions relating to the Modernisation Committee, I am effectively wearing two hats: firstly as the Leader of the House and secondly as the chair of the Modernisation Committee.
And I want to take this opportunity to thank all my colleagues on the Modernisation Committee for their hard work in developing these proposals. I'd also like to pay tribute to the chairs and members of the Liaison Committee and the Procedure Committee who fed into our work and who have been supportive throughout.
Let me turn now to virtual participation. Regarding virtual participation in select committee meetings, as colleagues will know, it is currently the case that virtual participation by members in select committee meetings is not permitted. Committees routinely hear oral evidence from witnesses virtually, but members themselves must be in the room. There are, of course, good reasons for the emphasis on in-person participation, however.
When the Modernisation Committee held its consultation exercise in the autumn of 2024, it did hear from people who argued for the benefits of virtual participation. The issue also rose during our previous accessibility inquiry, and so the committee decided to further consider the matter. As a result of that, the committee is recommending that virtual participation by members in select committee meetings should be possible for limited and specific purposes. The very strong expectation, however, is that in-person participation will continue to be the default. Let me be clear about what the specific circumstances are.
Firstly, for business continuity reasons when access to the parliamentary estate is significantly restricted or prevented entirely.
And secondly, when reasonable adjustments need to be made for an individual committee member on the grounds of health and wellbeing, following the guidance produced by the Liaison Committee. Although the circumstances set out by the Modernisation Committee in its report are very specific, the possibility of virtual participation is nonetheless a significant change. And I want colleagues who are perhaps more skeptical about the value of virtual participation to be assured that the Modernisation Committee was conscious of this when it made the proposals and when it has worked with colleagues, and it has worked with colleagues on the Liaison Committee to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place. If agreed today, the motion will come into effect on the 30th of November, the delay being necessary to ensure that technological support is in place.
The second Modernisation Committee motion will introduce a scheme for acting select committee chairs. There is currently no formal mechanism to enable a select committee chair to take a period of extended leave from their role, perhaps, for example, for parental leave. This situation arose on the Health and Social Care Committee last year, and although in that case the situation was handled locally, it raised a number of procedural and practical issues. As a result, we are proposing the introduction of a new scheme to allow a chair to take a period of formal leave and for another member of the committee to stand in for them and to have the same powers as the chair.
We spent some time considering who would be eligible to be an acting chair and we decided that the acting chair must be a member of the committee and that for those chairs elected by the whole house, the committee should appoint an acting chair who comes from the same party as the chair unless there are compelling reasons to do otherwise. And once again, I'm grateful to colleagues on the Liaison Committee who produced detailed guidance which sets out how this will work in practice.
Speaker 173
I thank the Leader of the House. I was just somewhat confused about the concept that after the period of seven months had elapsed, the decision was then given to the chair of the Liaison Committee when the Speaker would have already have deemed that that individual was indeed entitled to leave generally across the House. And I just wondered if he could give some clarity on why that decision was taken.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you and I'm grateful to my honorable friend.
The reason why we need to look ahead if these, if this change happens in a committee is that we need to keep this under review. We need a clear set of rules about what will happen at the beginning, but it also needs to be kept in our thoughts as we go forward. And there is a similar system in place, for example, when someone gets a proxy vote where they need to come back and that permission needs to be given for that to continue. So there are some comparisons there. As I've said, the motions are temporary in nature.
If the House agrees them today, they will run until the end of the current Parliament. There will be time to assess how they've worked in practice and whether the House wants to make the changes permanent.
And I hope colleagues agree that both motions improve the flexibility available for select committees and members, while preserving and enhancing committees' ability to perform their vital function. I want to turn now to a motion relating to the Committee on Privileges report into the actions of the Charity Commission, and I welcome the committee's consideration of this matter. As the committee sets out, this report is at its heart about the provision of information to the House and whether it is appropriate to use the courts to prevent information from being provided. The report outlines that the Charity Commission had sought a judicial review seeking to prevent the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration from laying a special report before the Commons.
The case was referred to the committee to consider whether, in seeking to prevent the flow of information to Parliament, the Charity Commission's action constituted a contempt of this House. As the report outlines, the obstruction of provision of information to Parliament is wholly unacceptable. The committee concludes that the Charity Commission committed a contempt of Parliament in seeking to prevent the laying of the report. The committee recommended that the chief executive of the Charity Commission should apologise to the House for repeatedly saying that the Commission's legal action was not intended to quash the laying of the reports when that was precisely its purpose. And the board of the Commission, which backed the legal action, should take responsibility for the contempt and should apologise to the House.
And I'm pleased to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, since the committee's report was published, the Charity Commission has provided such apologies. The government has confidence in the leadership of the Charity Commission and is confident that the board is taking action to address the concerns raised by the committee's report and to learn lessons in its handling of similar cases going forward. The motion invites the House to agree the report and endorse its conclusions and recommendations. And I hope that the House will support the motion. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, the motion relating to standing orders following the machinery of government changes announced in July.
The work of our select committees is extremely important and today's changes demonstrate the value that we place on them.
The motions before the House ensure all existing committees remain in place and are aligned to the departments and bodies that they scrutinize. With respect to the changes on science and technology, given the abolition of the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, we are reverting to the situation that the committee had in its setup prior to the establishment of that department. And I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, that members will support these motions today, and I commend them to the House.
Alberto Costa
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I would like to support the motion in the name of the Leader of the House and to thank him for his opening remarks.
The motion asks this House to agree with the findings in the report by the Committee on Privileges, of which I am the Chair, relating to the actions of the Charity Commission in taking legal action to prevent the laying of two reports to Parliament by the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration. Now, before I go any further, I would like to thank my honourable friend, Member for North Dorset, who's Chair of the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, first brought this matter to the House's attention and moved the motion to refer it to my committee just over a year ago on the 4th of September 2025. Madam Deputy Speaker, the issues raised in our report deal with a rather technical but very important matter concerning all of us: the question of parliamentary privilege.
But we must not forget that the case arose from serious complaints and allegations made against a number of charities, including the alleged concealment of child sexual abuse. The PCA reported on these complaints and made recommendations to the Charity Commission. Having concluded that the injustice had not been remedied and was not likely to be remedied, the PCA decided to lay reports to Parliament, as was her right under section 10(3) of the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967. I should say at this point that it was not the role of my committee to reach a judgment on the substance of these cases, and so we did not do so. Our role is to consider the matters of parliamentary privilege, and in this case, the obstruction of provision of information to members of this House.
Before touching on the details of the case, I should acknowledge at the outset that the Commission has already accepted, as the Leader said, and acted upon one of our recommendations. On 14th July, the very same day we published our report, the Chair of the Commission, on behalf of the board, wrote to the Speaker, to the Chair of PACAC, and to me as Chair of the Privileges Committee, with an unreserved apology, and the CEO, Mr. Holdsworth, apologized in writing to the Speaker. The letter to me has been published on the committee's website. I welcome the fact that the Commission has finally acknowledged its error, albeit at a regrettably late stage.
I hope it will not try members' patience if I remind them on the findings and significance of the report. Even though, as I said, it deals with seemingly technical issues at its heart, it is about the flow of information to this House. It is therefore of the greatest importance to the House and its ability to function to each and every one of us. The Charity Commission interfered with that flow of information when it sought to prevent the PCA from laying reports to Parliament using the powers given to her in legislation.
To make matters worse, the Commission refused for a very long time to accept that this was a privilege matter and persisted in its efforts to prevent publication. This was despite repeated written advice, including from Speaker's Counsel, that its legal action was an improper interference with the House's right to be informed and could not be considered by the courts as it would entail impeaching and questioning proceedings in Parliament, contrary to Article 9 of the Bill of Rights. This is deeply regrettable, Madam Deputy Speaker, especially given that the reports related to the Commission's failure, as the PCA saw it, to properly implement recommendations arising from its handling of the very serious complaints to which I referred earlier. At the same time as agreeing to refer the matter to my committee, this House has also ordered that the PCA's reports be laid.
This resolved the immediate issue, which was the interference with the provision of information to the House, as a result of which the courts ruled that the case was academic and the legal merits unarguable. It remained for my committee, however, to consider whether the behavior of the commission was a contempt of Parliament and to come to a view on whether reports laid under section 10(3) are indeed proceedings in Parliament, as Speaker's Counsel had advised. In conducting our inquiry on behalf of this House, we took evidence from Speaker's Counsel, the PCA herself, and three representatives of the commission: its then interim chair Mark Simms, its CEO David Holdsworth, and its head of litigation Felix Rechman.
Whilst we are grateful to all the witnesses for giving evidence, our report was highly critical of Mr. Holdsworth, in particular especially for repeatedly insisting, in both his oral evidence and elsewhere in correspondence, that it was never the Commission's intention that Parliament should not see the information in the reports. The Committee could not see how this claim could be squared with the Commission's pre-action letter, which specifically sought to quash the decision to provide Parliament with that information. In light of this, we recommended that both Mr. Holdsworth and the board of the Commission apologize to the House.
As I said earlier, and as the leader confirmed, these apologies have now been made. The inquiry sought to establish something that has never been explicitly considered by the courts, not even, as I explained earlier in this case, since the judge ruled the legal merits were unarguable, namely whether reports to be laid under section 10(3) of the '67 Act are in fact proceedings in Parliament. This is crucial to the rights of Parliament since Article 9 of the Bill of Rights confers on proceedings in Parliament protection from being impeached or questioned in any court or place out of Parliament. This is one of our most foundational constitutional principles.
If such a report is a proceeding in Parliament, any attempt to obstruct its laying could be a contempt of Parliament. The report found that such reports were intimately connected to the House and that they were therefore proceedings in Parliament and so covered by Article 9. It consequently found that any attempt to prevent the laying of a paper before one or both Houses was capable of being a contempt and that in this particular case, the Commission had clearly committed such a contempt. It is deeply regrettable that the Committee had to consider this case at all.
I very much hope that the Charity Commission and indeed other public bodies will ensure that they learn lessons and we avoid a repeat of these unfortunate events. In winding up, may I place on the record my thanks to the other members of the Privileges Committee, to the clerks, especially the then clerk of the journals, now clerk of the House, and to Speaker's Counsel for helping us to navigate what was at times an incredibly procedurally difficult subject. I hope that my speech and that of the Leader of the House have demonstrated to all of us, however, that it was also one of great importance to the proper functioning of this House of Commons. I hope that members will agree the motion. Thank you.
Dame Meg Hillier.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I rise to speak on the motion about substituting members if a member takes leave and on virtual participation.
And I want to put on record my thanks to the Modernisation Committee and also to the Procedures Committee and my honourable friend the member for Lancaster and Wyre for their work and for a number of clerks who did some amazing work to help us navigate this issue. So on virtual participation, there was a very clear view among chairs that there is a real benefit to being in the room when we make decisions and carry out our work as select committees because of the conversations that we need to have both privately and in public. But we were very aware that where in ordinary workplaces reasonable adjustments should be made for serious health or disability, that we needed to be in a modern, modern space for this.
But there was also, and I should reflect some of the discussion, serious discussion, that I think doesn't need to, does not necessarily have a problem, there's no issue with what's been decided. But that if someone is very unwell or on maternity leave, that actually they should have the right to take that leave and not be present and should not be criticised for not being present. That this change, even with a proxy vote, should not require people to attend and there should be no approbation laid upon them for not doing so. Because for both those reasons, there may be, you know, that people have the right, we've fought hard for sick leave and for maternity leave and those are rights that members should also enjoy. So there should be no pressure just because people can participate virtually.
And of course the other point about virtual participation is if we were to experience an issue such as the ash cloud or COVID again, under the previous standing orders this would have meant no activity at all in this place. And for those of us, those of you who weren't here during COVID, the House rapidly pivoted over the four, five weeks after the Easter period in, when we were locked down in COVID over that Easter period, to ensure that virtual participation could take place across the House in committees. But it required a change of standing orders to do that.
So this puts this on a proper footing, and I think that is right to modernize, but it doesn't diminish the need and importance of sharing opinions in person and doing so. And there are also important safeguards in there to make sure that if anyone is participating virtually, they're doing it in an appropriate place, not from a car or a train, and not with someone else in the room. And I think it is right that we have explicitly said that because the work of select committees is important and privileged proceedings of this House. And on the issue of allowing chairs to be replaced more officially when they are on sick leave or maternity or parental leave, I think this is really important. I pay tribute to my honorable friend the member for Birmingham Erdington, who pioneered this approach.
And there are a few others who've done this over the years, but she really stepped up and took on the acting chair of the Health Select Committee and did some amazing work in that job. And she did that without all of the normal formal procedures that this motion puts in place. So this motion sets the tone, it picks up on some of the best practice of proxy voting so that there is a review period so that it can't go on forever. And of course, ultimately, there is the, while it should be because these roles as chairs are elected on a party political basis, that there needs to be some thought to that. But it does allow that flexibility if, for example, there is a member of the committee who regularly steps into the chair and the rest of the committee decided that they might be the more appropriate person to do it.
It allows that wiggle room to allow the relevant and proper person to be the chair, even if it is not perhaps a member of another party.
And that's important thrown up perhaps more in this Parliament than in some others because of the large majority on the government side which means there are only two members on most select committees from the other two main parties. So I think the Modernisation Committee has done a sterling job of navigating both these issues and making sure that we have modernized while retaining the integrity of the House, the integrity of select committees and making sure that we can all participate as we properly should.
Catherine Jane Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to put on record on behalf of the Procedure Committee my thanks to the Leader of the House for bringing forward these motions today. I never had any doubt that he'd be a radical and reforming Leader of the House and I'm very pleased to see that today's motions are evidence of that radical reforming nature that he has always had in him.
The Procedure Committee has corresponded frequently with the Modernisation Committee. On the 4th of March, we put down and his committee has published this, the committee's wholehearted support for the acting select committee chair role. And on the 25th of March, we supported the motions for virtual participation. I think this reflects the nature of us being a modern and welcoming workplace, a workplace whereby regardless of our health status or perhaps parental leave, that participation of MPs is done in a way by which these things that can happen to any one of us do not necessarily bar us from participating and representing our constituents' views in this place.
I think that this obviously comes from a line of reforms including proxy voting, which have ensured that we are that radical and reforming Parliament that will be welcoming to anyone regardless of their family setup. But I would like to put on record that my views around the priority will always be for members to be in person in committee and speaking as a committee chair, how much easier it is to chair a meeting when members are in the room rather than necessarily all on screens. And I'd like to ask the Leader of the House whether or not he foresees that we would have a thorough and timely review of these schemes in time to assess whether or not they may be able to be made permanent or whether or not there are any reforms that need to be made to it at that stage. But I welcome the motions and I hope the House will choose to support them today.
Chris Vince.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Leader of the House for his statement. I agree with my honorable friend, he is radical and forward-thinking and progressive and we thank him for that.
He will know that I served on the Modernisation Committee for a very short period of time. It was the strangest part of that experience was having to come face-to-face with my predecessor who gave evidence to the committee, and his evidence to the committee was really important and part of the reason I feel so it's important I stand up and make sure that his voice is heard here. I welcome his statement about the changes being made to select committees. I think we would all recognise the important role that select committees do in the running of this place. I think, for example, of my short period of time, it's always been a short period of time on committees, short period of time on the Education Committee, and I thank my honourable friend who's in her place for the work she did in getting securing a government apology for those victims of the forced adoption scandal.
So select committees can make a huge, huge difference to things that happen in this place and beyond as well.
However, I would also recognise that it is a balance. It is important that we make select committees accessible. And as the member for Harlow, I take that accessibility very seriously on behalf of my predecessor. I also recognise the importance of in-person scrutiny. I have sat on a number of virtual meetings, including virtual council meetings during COVID.
And I don't think they're necessarily as effective, particularly when you have huge numbers of people joining online. And I equally would echo the points made by my honourable friend from Hackney South and Shoreditch when she talks about the importance of having very strict rules around that. We don't want to have select committees necessarily where a dog or cat appear on the screen.
I don't think that necessarily is... it happens to all of us, doesn't it? But it's not necessarily setting the right precedence, particularly if we're really trying to scrutinize somebody from an outside body that very much needs that scrutiny. And I would also echo her comments made by my honorable friend from Hackney South and Shoreditch about maternity rights and sick pay. It is important that we support everybody in this House to have those. I think that's a really, really important point.
But finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would just say that I think in this case the Leader has absolutely got that balance right and I absolutely support what he's been saying.
Leader of the House.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And first of all, can I thank all members for their contribution to today's debate.
If I briefly respond to them, I'm eternally grateful to the chair of privileges, and I agree very much with his remarks, including about the timeliness of any response from the Charity Commission and also the significance of this issue. I would point out the importance, if I need to point out, of his committee and their findings on in this instance, because they had the desired effect, and I'm grateful for that. I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, that lessons have been learned, not just by the Charity Commission, but by anyone else who may feel tempted to go down this misguided route. Let me turn to the comments of my right honorable friend, the chair of liaison. I'm grateful to her committee and to her work on that committee and indeed more widely.
I agree absolutely with her about the importance of protecting the rights of members.
The measures that we propose today are about enhancing those rights. It is, as she said, about modernising and maintaining integrity. And I'm pleased if the House thinks that we've got that balance right. My honourable friend, the chair of Procedure, I want to thank her and her committee. We work very close together, Madam Deputy Speaker, as committees.
And therefore, if this goes horribly wrong, just to point out that she shares my radical instinct on these matters. But I'm sure that they won't. She's right to emphasise that member participation should be in person and that these motions are time-limited. She asks a question about whether or not there will be a review. I have a feeling, but it is no more than that, obviously I hope that these measures, these changes are successful.
And therefore that when the time comes, the House will want to carry these forward. In which case, it's absolutely right that we review them before that.
And I want to finally comment on the comments of my honorable friend, the member for Harlow. I thought he wasn't going to mention Harlow, but he managed to get there in the end. He may, Madam Deputy Speaker, have spent only a short time on committees and indeed a relatively short time compared to some of us in this House, but I have to say he's been extraordinarily quick in picking up many of the best elements of working in this place and central to that, because he knows my view, the importance of select committee work. So with those comments, Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope that members will support these motions today and I commend them to the House.
Speaker 136
The question is the motion relating to select committee chairs' period of leave. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion relating to select committees' participation. Minister to move formally.
Move formally.
Speaker 136
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion relating to privileges.
Minister to move formally.
Move formally.
Speaker 136
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion relating to standing orders etc., machinery of government changes.
Minister to move formally.
Move formally.
Speaker 136
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no.
Speaker 180
I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. I am going to allow a few moments for the front benches to swap over. And we now come to the general debate on Israel and Palestine. I call the minister, Stephen Doughty.
Stephen Doughty
Well thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and I beg to move that this house has considered Israel and Palestine.
And as this is my first debate as Minister of State for the Middle East, can I begin by paying tribute to my predecessor, my right honourable friend the member for Lincoln, who spoke from this dispatch box on this important issue many times with great conviction and clarity. And I also acknowledge the broad terms of the debate before us, but with your leave, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will obviously focus on a number of very specific issues, but I'm sure that honourable and right honourable members will want to cover a number of topics. And I want to acknowledge the very strong views of members across this House, and indeed views on issues related to Israel and Palestine are reflected in my own constituency of Cardiff South and Penarth, where I'm proud that we have people from many different backgrounds and many different heritages. I'm proud to represent constituents of Palestinian and Israeli backgrounds, and indeed a diversity of all faiths and none.
And I draw attention to my past work on these issues and indeed before in my time as an MP in this place and minister and my declarations. And as my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary said in the House last week, we need to start from some very, very clear principles: that this is a country that stands up for the rule of law, for freedom, for self-determination, and in this case in the cause of peace and a secure future for all Israelis and Palestinians. And it is with those principles that we approach this important issue. I'll happily give way.
Jim Shannon
If I first of all can commend the minister. The minister is much liked in this House.
He puts forward always a very balanced point of view. But at the weekend, after the decision by the Labour party last week, I have to say that my Jewish friends, my Jewish constituents, those from contacts from Israel, have been on to me in large numbers expressing deep concern about what the government and what the Labour party has put forward. And ever mindful at a time of unprecedented threats from Hamas and other terrorist entities, they say that the government and Labour have introduced a one-sided, and I quote them, a one-sided trade ban. Now, if that is the case, how can the Minister and how can this government reassure my deeply, my constituents in relation to their deeply important security and intelligence sharings with Israel that they refer to? There is a danger of a major diplomatic clash with Israel and the United States of America.
These drastic steps could and will affect the lives of British people, in particular those of the Jewish families. Thank you.
Stephen Doughty
Well, my honourable friend raises important points about the important security, intelligence, defense relationship that we have with Israel. And I need to be clear at the outset, and I will be clear, that the measures that we took are very much in relation to our dispute about the actions of this Israeli government, not with Israel, certainly not with the Israeli people. And with regard to his Jewish constituents, I absolutely recognize the significant concerns and fears about the threats that Jewish communities in this country and indeed across the world face, particularly from rising antisemitism, violence. And of course, we marked some very somber events just in recent weeks, and I have heard that reflected from my own Jewish constituents. And I can absolutely assure him that the government engages closely with representatives of the Jewish communities in this country.
But he will also recognize that there are a range of views that are expressed, and indeed have been expressed in relation to the government's announcements last week.
And Madam Deputy Speaker, I am clear, if I make a little progress then I'll happily give way. If I can be clear, the British people, including those with ties to the region, want to see the suffering and violence in the region end and a path to peace and a two-state solution restored, one in which a safe and secure Israel exists along a sovereign and viable Palestine. And that is also within the context of recognizing the very real threats that Israel faces, including from Iran and its proxies. I will happily give way.
Andrew Murrison
The Minister will have to be very careful about what we say and what we do because of the effect on Jews in this country.
In that regard, what assessment has the Minister made of the Campaign Against Antisemitism's report and findings on Jew-hate in our National Health Service? Does he agree with me that everybody needs to be assured that when they're at their most vulnerable, they will be dealt with equitably without reference to their colour, creed, race or anything else? And yet we find that patients are being abused simply because they're Jewish and Jews who are working in the NHS are similarly being disadvantaged.
Stephen Doughty
Well, the concerns he raises are very serious ones. And he can be absolutely assured that the government wants to root out antisemitism in all of its forms in this country and indeed in every walk of life. And I think whether it's the health service or whether it's in our education, I've heard very, very concerning examples of antisemitic incidents in schools, in universities.
And that is why this government is investing not only in the security of Jewish communities in this country, but also indeed in specific measures in public services. And so I take very seriously any concerns that he raises. And of course he has distinguished medical experience himself. I think it's also very important, Madam Deputy Speaker, to recognize that next month will mark three years since the atrocity of the 7th of October, as the Foreign Secretary said, a murderous act by a brutal terrorist organization designed not only to instill fear across a whole population and cause death and destruction in Israel, but also to instill fear across the world.
the world, and this was the worst attack on Jewish people since the Holocaust. And I'll be clear again, there is no justification for the actions of Hamas, and of course Hamas's rejection of peaceful coexistence between Israelis and Palestinians, and indeed they can play no part in that future, and indeed must disarm. And we avidly and and and continuously support the 20-point plan and the efforts to bring about peace and a and a secure future for the people in Gaza and indeed across the whole of Palestine. And I will happily give way in a moment. And I also let me be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, reject those, as the Foreign Secretary did, who take any attempt to delegitimize Israel or support the so-called BDS movement.
Our disagreements are with the government of Israel and its actions, not Israel, and certainly not the Israeli people. I will happily give way.
Danny Beales
Thank my honorable friend for giving way and for his speech.
He mentions the commitment to peace long term. Part of that is never unfortunately seen further away potentially than today. But part of that will be building bridges between communities in Palestine and Israel, supporting civil society which itself has been under attack in both Gaza and in Israel unfortunately by the government. The last, his predecessor and the last Prime Minister committed to the International Peace Fund which many of us were advocating for. Could my right honorable friend provide an update about this government's position on the Peace Fund, its support I hope for its continuation and its growth and what role he thinks it can play in building these bridges.
Stephen Doughty
Well I wholeheartedly support the type of work that the honorable gentleman points out and indeed have been involved in various different initiatives over the years in a range of different conflict contexts.
And he will be happy to know that I think I've just answered some parliamentary questions on the International Peace Fund, and that will hopefully provide him with the assurances that he seeks. But Madam Deputy Speaker, the appalling reality in Gaza and indeed the West Bank is also placing that two-state solution that we all want to see under immense strain as are the actions of this Israeli government. And as the Foreign Secretary set out, for three years, Gazans have endured unimaginable trauma and suffering. There is increasing evidence that war crimes appear to have been committed, and we support legal processes to determine this. And at the same time, we are witnessing unprecedented violence in the West Bank, including settler terrorism and indeed ethnic cleansing perpetrated by settler terrorists.
And we condemn settler violence and settlement expansion, which are contrary to international law and a grave threat to the two-state solution. And indeed, it's been asked why now, why was it necessary for the government to act?
And I will set out clearly the reasons for doing so, but I think we need to recognize that last year was a record year for new settlements. In August, we saw a long-standing red line crossed when the E1 tenders were issued for more than 1,200 homes. And I point out, and I will give way in a moment, the Foreign Secretary pointed out at the time of Oslo, around 270,000 settlers lived in occupied Palestinian territories. Today, it is some 750,000. And more settlements have been approved under the four years of this Israeli government than in the previous 20 years.
And we've seen 65 Palestinian communities completely expelled since October 2023, and a total of over 4,000 Palestinians evicted from their homes due to settler violence and indeed state action. So this government refuses to stand by and watch further suffering and the destruction of the two-state solution.
I'll happily give way.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank my right honourable friend for giving way, and I commend him and the Foreign Secretary last week for the tone in which they laid out this decision recently on the settlements. I too have constituents who are Jewish who are very scared, but it is, I think, right, as the Minister said, to, if you've got a friend, to call them out when their behaviour goes too far. And we know there are big issues obviously about the legal definition of genocide in Palestine. I wonder if he's had any conversations at all, or the department has, with the Israeli government or the ambassador to the UK about the Foreign Secretary's statement last week, and if he can update the House.
Stephen Doughty
Well, indeed, in advance of the statement, we had expressed, when the Foreign Secretary came to office and indeed I took on this ministerial role, we were of course in contact with the Israeli government.
The Foreign Secretary spoke to Foreign Minister Saar. I spoke with the Israeli chargé here and we have had continual contact with the government of Israel over our concerns and what we believe needs to change. But she will have seen the reaction and the commentary in recent days, which was deeply regrettable and deeply unfortunate. But what I would say is that of course we maintain close and important links with Israel in a range of other measures. And this is very, very much focused on these actions that we see on the ground, the actions of, for example, settler terrorists and those who are backing them to expand those settlements, the withholding of aid into Gaza and these actions.
This is not a quarrel with Israel or the Israeli people.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we should always be proud that it was a Labour government that took the historic decision to recognize the state of Palestine. And it is also important to recognize that our engagement to further the agenda of reform and inclusion in the state of Palestine, we work very closely with the Palestinian authorities, hampered as they are by continued withholding of tax revenues and a range of other measures taken by the Israeli government. We've been resolute, as I said, about that Hamas cannot be part of government going forward and must be disarmed. And indeed, as many people have rightly raised, we've taken action to work with them closely on, for example, reform of prisoner payments and that welfare payments must be needs-based. And we are very, very clear that there needs to be reform, there needs to be an inclusive process in Palestine.
We want to see a viable, secure, prosperous and well-governed Palestine going forward, and we've always stood there as a partner for them to do that. Of course, when that very state is threatened geographically or indeed in the functioning of its institutions, if we say we believe in a two-state solution, we must believe in two states geographically and indeed in ability to function. And the reality is, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we have seen that goal come under even greater pressure in recent times. We've also been very, very clear in our engagement with both the Israeli government and the Palestinian government.
I spoke to the Palestinian foreign minister recently and have also engaged with those involved in the transitional processes that would hopefully lead to a settlement and new administration in Gaza. I met with the head of UNRWA when I was in Egypt recently and have discussed, even in these difficult times, the ways we can look to a positive and productive future. I must also be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, as the Foreign Secretary made clear, that the official view of this government is now that Israel's continued occupation of Palestine is unlawful. This concurs with the central finding of the ICJ's advisory opinion of June 2024. We've come to that conclusion for a range of reasons, but the Foreign Secretary and others have mentioned that Israel's entrenchment of its control, its intent to extend permanent sovereignty, and its expansionist agenda and support for and facilitation of illegal settlements are key in this.
This is a clear position. I think it's very important, as I set out, values, what we aim at, and the legal position, and that leads us on then to the actions that we must take. I'll happily give way.
Alex Sobel
Thank you, Madam Deputy Chair. I know constituents that have moved from Israel to Leeds because of the actions of the Israeli government and actually applaud what we've done in banning Israeli settlement goods and services. So there's many of us that stand squarely behind international law and human rights and commend the Minister and the Foreign Secretary in their actions.
Stephen Doughty
I thank him for his support and I know he is extensively experienced on issues on this matter. And I think he is right to say that there are many across diverse voices in this country who have welcomed the actions. I'll happily give way up there and then make some progress.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
Giving way, he's been very generous in giving way.
In his discussions with the government of Israel, has he ever raised the issue about Israel never defining what its borders actually are? Because this seems to me to be a fundamental problem in any discussions that take this issue going forward.
Stephen Doughty
Well, ultimately, we've always been very clear, as he will know, that these matters must be determined in future negotiations, but that fundamentally when we're talking here about the actions that we're taking, we're clear about 1967 green line. And that is why we're making a very clear distinction here in the actions that I will come onto about illegal settlements and about green line Israel. I'll make a little progress and then I'll allow some other interventions. The Foreign Secretary announced new sanctions regimes and powers through which we are going to be banning trade in goods from illegal Israeli settlements.
We will be also taking action on services, including creating new designation powers to go after individuals and companies that support, facilitate, or profit from illegal settlement activity. We will be banning advertising or the promotion of land and property in illegal settlements. And we will also be strengthening our existing global human rights sanctions regime to go after those who defy international humanitarian law, whether that be in Palestine or indeed around the world. And I can think of a range of other contexts, and as sanctions minister, a range of other matters that I know members raise in this House, including, for example, in relation to Sudan or Yemen or Myanmar or other contexts. It's important that government has the powers to be able to act against those who defy international humanitarian law or, for example, deny humanitarian aid access or frustrate the actions of humanitarian organisations.
And we are using our existing global human rights regime to sanction several extremist settlers who've supported or incited acts of violence against Palestinian communities. I'll happily give way again.
Jim Shannon
Minister, you're incredibly generous. Minister, you're very clear in the comments that you made in relation to Hamas, that Hamas cannot play a part in the future of whatever the settlement may be, and I welcome that. And I know my Jewish friends and my constituents would also welcome that. But can the Minister perhaps outline how he envisages the future which shows that Hamas have no part to play and cannot play a part? I'd be very keen to hear the Minister's ideas now.
Stephen Doughty
Key to that of course is going to be ensuring that they put down their arms. And I think we have important lessons that can be learned from honorable friend's parts of the world and, you know, imperfect as many matters are there, we have important lessons I think that we can share not just in relation to Gaza but actually to other contexts too and I've been discussing that with a range of partners over recent recent times. But, you know, we have a process in place, we have the plan, the 24-point plan and the 15 points. It's deeply regrettable that we have not made further progress on that in recent weeks and months and of course we will work closely with the United States, with other partners and others to further that agenda and find a way forward. But it's absolutely clear and it's absolutely clear as well that we need to have a unity, that we have to have a functioning state between Gaza and the West Bank and and and a state of Palestine that can function and ensure that all forms of violence and extremism are rooted out.
Fleur Kathleen Anderson
I thank the Minister very much for giving way. On the issue of the functioning state, one of the issues raised by me to me by constituents who've come to my surgery, and I have had people coming from the synagogue and also from people who volunteer in Palestine, is that the Israeli government has withheld five billion pounds of revenue from the Palestinian people.
It was curtailed in 2019 but then stopped in 2023. And that is money that should be going on hospitals, on schools, and a functioning state, as he says. Has the Minister had meetings with the Israeli government about the return of those revenues, maybe through a third party that they could trust to make sure that it goes to the right places?
Stephen Doughty
Well, we have of course raised these issues on a regular basis, and indeed I've also discussed with Palestinian ministers about the impact this is having on their ability to function. So that is a very important point that she raises. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to make a little progress because I know there's a lot of members who want to speak.
I know that a number of members will want to raise the issue of arms sales and export licensing, and I want to be clear to the House that we have already suspended or refused over 80 export licenses in relation to Gaza, and our suspension remains fully in place. And I'd also remind honorable members, there's a lot of misinformation about this issue, that not all export licenses are for military purposes or indeed provided to the Israeli Defense Forces. It includes, for example, exports of crucial medicines or body armor or indeed defensive capabilities or material not used in Israel but is actually used in important components for allies. But I want to emphasize very, very clearly, as the Foreign Secretary said, because of our view that the occupation is itself unlawful, we will also now refuse all license applications for arms and other exports that materially contribute to the occupation. In effect, that provides a double lock against all relevant exports that we will determine our export licensing on the basis of.
And that means the ban on exports will remain as long as the occupation persists for relevant items.
And that is very, very clear. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to just clarify, I think it's important what these measures will not do. Our sanctions regime will not target important and valued trade with Green Line Israel. We oppose the boycott, divestment and sanctions campaign, including attempts to exclude, for example, Israel from sports or cultural activities. This is not a ban on travel or religious visits, or indeed religious expression.
I think that's very important, and we will put in place the appropriate religious exemptions. And I want to thank all of those who've raised important matters and sensitive matters with us on this. It's very important we listen to those communities and we listen to those, and it's important we also do not share misinformation around the fact about what this regime does or doesn't do.
And it's very, very clear that we will work to make sure that there are not unintended consequences from the measures we set out. On the timing, Madam Deputy Speaker, the expanded global human rights regime will come within weeks in the near future. We expect the legislation for the wider new sanctions in relation to settlements to take around six to nine months. But as the Foreign Secretary said, if we can do it sooner, we will. And I want to explain to the House that it's because sanctions are impactful, they're powerful, but they're also technical.
We have to take time to carefully design them to make sure they have the impact that we want them to have, and that they're lawful, that they're proportionate, and they don't have unintended consequences, and crucially, that they are enforceable. We are also building our... I'll just give way because I haven't given way to my honorable friend.
Alexander Robert Ballinger
I thank the Minister for giving way.
Can I raise the film 'Nazar' that's been recently shown at the Venice Film Festival? It talks about the targeting systems that the IDF used in Gaza and where they've specifically waited for Hamas fighters to return home so they could target them in a place they know, but it has huge civilian casualties. There was one whistleblower that suggested 500 civilians were killed in a strike on a single Hamas target. We have an example in the UK where that has happened against three British servicemen, former servicemen at the World Central Kitchen. So could he reflect a little bit on that documentary and how we're going to get accountability for those British servicemen that have been killed with this awful targeting system that's being used?
Stephen Doughty
Well, I haven't seen the documentary he mentions, but the fact is that there have been horrendous humanitarian deaths, including the ones he mentions, and of course appalling numbers of civilian deaths in Gaza.
And I was very clear and the Foreign Secretary was very clear that the decision about World Central Kitchen was shameful. We've been in contact with the families and we've obviously urged the relevant authorities to to reconsider that decision. And look, you know, in the end, all of these matters will be reviewed and understood in the end by courts and by other competent authorities. But we are very clear that there is significant evidence of of atrocities being committed. But on that specific case, I've been very, very clear about it.
I am also clear that we're taking action on those involved in settler violence already using the powers that we have. That includes the five extremist settlers that we sanctioned last Tuesday, and we have also alongside partners including Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Norway sanctioned extremist Israeli ministers Smotrich and Ben-Gvir in their personal capacities in response to their repeated incitements of violence against Palestinian communities. But I think it's also important, Madam Deputy Speaker, to recognize, and this perhaps didn't receive as much attention last week but is very, very important, that we absolutely recognize the threats that Israel faces, and not only Israel but other countries in the region from Iran. That is why we imposed a number of sanctions on Iran last week, and we also sanctioned Lebanese Hezbollah.
And we also, in light of the current actions that we're seeing in Yemen and around the Bab-el-Mandeb, absolutely condemn the actions of the Houthis, the atrocities that they're responsible for, and are absolutely working closely with partners, including the government of Yemen and others, but recognizing that the Houthis have previously struck against Israel, I think it's absolutely crucial to recognize that. In coming to some conclusions, Madam Deputy Speaker, I just want to reiterate, as a number of members have raised, and I'm conscious that we're in the High Holy Days, that no community must face discrimination, violence, or hate, or the threat of violence. Antisemitism disgusts me, as I am sure it does all of us in this House. And the Foreign Secretary is very clear: the actions we took are against the Israeli government, not Israel, not its people, and certainly in any case holding British Jews responsible for the actions ever for the actions of the Israeli government is antisemitism, plain and simple. And I have heard directly from Jewish communities in my own constituency the threats, the risks that they face.
I know we have all heard those. We are living in a time when we've had the horrific attacks in Heaton Park and indeed what we saw in Golders Green. And that's why we're putting in the investment of 250 million for community security. We're taking action on antisemitism in schools and communities.
And in October, the Foreign Secretary will host representatives of the G7 to discuss how we can work across borders to tackle antisemitism. And I praise the work of the honorable member for High Peak on post-Holocaust issues and indeed more broadly the work of the member for North Northumberland on freedom of religion and belief. I'm going to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, because I know many members want to speak. But let me end by saying that we know the actions that we announced last week would prompt strong reactions, but that didn't mean they were any less necessary. And it's deeply regrettable the Israeli government has announced measures such as wanting to close our consulate in Jerusalem, but we stand by our actions.
If we are guided by values, by the law, by the facts on the ground, we need to see action, we need to see leadership. And that is the right thing to do to defend the two-state solution, which is in the interests of Israelis and Palestinians, but also our national interest.
And we've been joined by others, including France and Canada. Peace and security depend on our resolve to create the conditions in which Israelis and Palestinians can live side by side in their own states, confident in their futures. And we might be far from that hope being realized at present, but it's one that we will work absolutely assiduously to deliver. And we have to speak and act with clarity to achieve that. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I look forward to the contributions of members across this House today, and I am glad to have been able to open this debate.
Speaker 187
The question is that this House has considered Israel and Palestine. I call Shadow Minister Alicia Kearns.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by expressing our condolences at the death of a member of our armed forces in Ukraine on Saturday and thank them for their service, and also say to their families that we hold them very much in our hearts.
As we approach the anniversary of Hamas's barbaric 7th of October terrorist attacks next month, we also approach three years of war. 251 people were kidnapped that day, over 1,200 murdered, and hundreds raped. It was not until January this year that the remains of the final hostages were brought home. May their memory be a blessing. After three years of immense suffering, recent months have on paper hinted at real progress towards peace.
A UN Security Council resolution, a roadmap and transitional committee, and the first Palestinian legislative elections since 2006 scheduled for November. Yet on the ground, neither the Israeli nor Palestinian people feel any safer.
Hamas remains armed despite promises to the contrary, and Iran remains a destructive force, willing to sacrifice the futures of whole nations through its proxies in Palestine, Yemen, Lebanon and Iraq, creating instability to ensure the survival of its own despotic regime. As my right honourable and gallant friend the shadow foreign secretary set out last week, there is much that we agree on across this House. And even where differences of approach exist, we share a deep concern that current events are taking Israelis and Palestinians towards a darker future. We are acutely aware of the immense suffering in Gaza and the fragility of attempts at peacebuilding. We agree that some Israeli ministers have espoused unacceptable, dangerous and hateful rhetoric, even targeting our own country in recent weeks.
And that groups of settlers in the West Bank are engaging in illegal acts and violence, often encouraged by this same rhetoric.
We also know that most in Israel reject this and seek a peaceful future, and we must keep them in our minds and not mistake the loudest voices as the most representative. Before I turn to the government's decisions, let me say something as a friend of Israel, as someone who has worked with Israel to defeat shared enemies like Daesh. We have learned from failures in Iraq and Afghanistan that how you prosecute the operation to defeat terrorists determines whether or not you build and secure peace for your people in the long term. You do not defeat an insurgency by creating conditions in which the next generation is recruited. And my fear is that three years on, Hamas is still armed, still governing and still recruiting.
Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, then spokesperson for the IDF, said, "Hamas is an idea, and that whoever believes it can be eliminated by force alone is mistaken." And he is right.
You cannot bomb an ideology out of existence. You must allow an alternative and create the space for political transition. And that is not a moral nicety. It is the operational lesson of every counter-insurgency campaign our country has ever fought, including those we've lost. The defeat of Hamas is important to our security here in the UK, and these lessons cannot be dismissed if we are to create a safer future for us and the region find peace.
We all want to see a better future for the Israeli and Palestinian people, but to do so we must have constructive channels of communication open with our partners in the region. As Foreign Secretary, Lord Cameron was able to secure additional aid to Gaza and to open new crossings by using our relationship to benefit those most in need, and it is imperative that the government maintains those relations to reflect the strategic importance of this relationship and to allow us to continue to influence events as friends. I believe the world is a better place when Britain is at the table, and there is more clarity needed on the government's position. The Board of Peace has had its efforts largely rejected, at least on sequencing. Hamas will not disarm first, Israel will not withdraw first, but the government has said nothing about what the sequencing should be in the British view, and that silence benefits no one.
With Israeli elections next month and Palestinian elections in November, there is a small glimmer of hope, hope that elections bring more moderate voices to the fore.
And that is why we remain concerned that sanctions announced by the government so close to the Israeli election may empower the very voices most opposed to peace. Now, before the Foreign Secretary's announcement, Israeli news was awash with headlines that Netanyahu allegedly failed to pass on a warning from the President of the United Arab Emirates to Israeli intelligence 10 days before the Hamas attack. Britain's sanctions wiped that news off the news cycle. It is no longer being discussed. Given that Israel, a true democracy, is about to go to polls, did the timing not warrant more reflection?
I have spent years arguing this country imposes sanctions without plans to ever lift them, to punish rather than to deter or change behavior. So let me ask the Minister what I'd ask of any sanctions regime. What must change for these measures to be lifted? And will it be published and made clear so that you can achieve the effect you wish to see?
Turning to Palestinian elections, there is a real possibility that Hamas could win a share of power. If Hamas wins the Palestinian elections, will the government give diplomatic accreditation to one of their representatives as ambassador? Because we must all speak honestly and accept that the odds are stacked against any Palestinian moderate while Tehran funds, arms and outbids all of them. A Hamas election victory could mark the first time the British government accredits an ambassador appointed by a proscribed terrorist group. So can the minister confirm in their wind-ups that no circumstances will the government accept a Palestinian ambassador drawn from Hamas?
And I'll ask for a written ministerial statement setting out the accreditation criteria before the 6th of November. The Iranian state continues to support Hamas to use violence to advance its political aims.
Therefore it is vital the Palestinian Authority security forces can maintain the peace needed for an election to take place. So it is deeply regrettable that following the Foreign Secretary's statement last week, that the UK training advisory mission to the Palestinian security forces has been terminated when it is most needed. So what efforts has the government made to replace our contribution, be it with Jordanian or EU or other authorities and forces? Likewise, the closure of our consulate in Jerusalem severs our main diplomatic channel to Palestinians in Jerusalem and the West Bank when the situation is getting worse and West Bank should occupy more of our debate in this place. The Jordanians are doing an important job to protect stability and the stability that there is.
But Christian communities, amongst the oldest in the world, are being harassed, attacked and driven from their homes.
So how is the government now going to assess the situation there and speak up for those being persecuted? Now the minister responded just now to a question from his backbenchers about the strike on the World Food Kitchen. James Henderson, John Chapman and James Kirby are three British veterans killed by Israeli fire while delivering food in Gaza. Their families are still waiting for the unedited drone footage to be handed to the coroner and a resumption date for the inquest. So can the minister give more clarity on what the government is doing to secure that footage and that date?
And when we will get answers about how in January 2024 an Israeli airstrike hit a residential compound in a designated safe zone in Gaza where British surgeons working for Medical Aid for Palestinians were living? Thankfully none were harmed.
This conflict sits within a wider regional destabilization that threatens us all. It is indisputable that the Iranian regime is by far the biggest sponsor of global terrorism and Iran must never achieve its goal of nuclear armament because a nuclear-armed ayatollah is concerning enough. But who amongst us can truly say that we trust that that regime would not share such a weapon with the Houthis or with Hezbollah? We would be one step from nuclear-enabled terrorism. Now just last week the Houthis briefly captured the pivotal Perim Island in the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait.
Although Yemeni government forces have since repelled the attack, this must serve as a warning. Taken with the Houthi strike against the Saudi East-West oil pipeline, there is a real and escalating risk that Bab-el-Mandeb will, like the Strait of Hormuz, come to be closed.
If the situation at both does not calm, the coming winter will be marked by rising inflation, economic hardship, medicine and food shortages, and energy crisis and worse. So given this, we must count the Houthi threat and assist Saudi Arabia and other partners in maintaining maritime freedom. The previous Prime Minister did at least work earnestly to establish an international coalition aimed at protecting the flow of trade. So the Prime Minister now needs to convene this group, otherwise he will walk into a winter of discontent. The British people need him to take action.
So what contingency plans have been drawn up if the Houthi campaign continues and the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait and Saudi pipeline infrastructure are degraded? Given this context, the choice to delay the decision on North Sea Jackdaw gas fields in the North Sea is mistaken.
And briefly, because we must not put our head into the sand, the reality is that next year we may find ourselves in a three-theater conflict: Ukraine, the Strait of Hormuz, and what would be the greatest shock to the global economy and the cost of living in my lifetime, Taiwan. We must be prepared. Now Britain did not choose this conflict and we cannot choose to be unaffected by it, but government action is needed to protect our economy, our supply chains, and our people, because Iran and its proxies continue to target us directly, feeding and funding a national emergency of antisemitism in our country and working to undermine our freedoms and security. Just last week another two individuals were arrested on suspicion of assisting Iranian intelligence.
That takes us to 15 in the last two years. The government must also take action to shut down blatant propaganda operations on our street. Al-Masirah, the Houthis' main television station, LuaLua TV, which has an Ofcom broadcasting license, and the Islamic Centre of England in Maida Vale, whose director has to be appointed by the Ayatollah himself. There are various cutouts across our country currently sponsoring visas, giving terrorists not a back door but a front door into our country. And we must end this game of whack-a-mole and unplug the machine.
And that means we must designate Iran's Ministry of Intelligence and Security. It is in our interest, Madam Deputy Speaker, to see a lasting peace in Israel and Palestine, and indeed across the whole region. We have a historical obligation not to look the other way, and the suffering of the 7th of October, Gaza and the West Bank pain us all. The consequences of that day continue to reverberate and grow ever more pressing for us.
So while we hope for the best, there are small glimmers of hope, but there is action that is needed to protect us here in the UK by assuring and ensuring our interests in the region. So let us prepare for the worst and ensure if it comes, we have the means and will to vision to weather the storm. Thank you.
Andy McDonald.
Andy McDonald
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'll confine my remarks to the subject of Israel and Palestine. And I confirm my interest as co-chair of the Britain-Palestine All-Party Parliamentary Group, and I very much welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement of the 8th of September, and particularly the fact that the government has now made clear that its official position is that Israel's occupation of Palestine is unlawful, it is illegal.
That is an important change, and at long last it brings the United Kingdom into line with the International Court of Justice's 2024 advisory opinion. But as the Minister said, the Court's conclusion was rooted in Israel's entrenchment of its control, its clear intention to extend permanent sovereignty, and its expansionist settlement agenda.
It's also welcome, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the Foreign Secretary acknowledged the increasing evidence identified by bodies including the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry that war crimes appear to have been committed in Gaza, and we support the appropriate legal processes to establish responsibility for those crimes. On genocide, I welcome the Foreign Secretary's commitment to full, robust, and fair judicial processes with final determinations made by competent courts. But the UK does not need to wait for a final determination before acting.
The UN Commission of Inquiry stated in September 2024 that Israel has committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, and that state parties to the Genocide Convention had been on notice of a serious risk of genocide since at least January 2024. That serious risk itself triggers a duty to prevent genocide. The UK must therefore recognize that risk and act now, ending political, financial and military support that contributes to it, sanctioning those most implicated, committing to execute ICC arrest warrants and supporting South Africa's case at the ICJ.
I also welcome the government's commitment to refuse arms licenses where exports materially contribute to the unlawful occupation. But the Foreign Secretary did not clearly confirm when I asked during last week's statement whether existing licenses will be cancelled, will be cancelled where they meet that test. So will the Minister therefore confirm that the new double lock will apply to existing licenses and set out the criteria by which the government will determine whether an export contributes to the occupation? Colleagues will wish to know whether British arms exports currently available for the IDF in the West Bank will no longer be licensed.
And I welcome the proposed sanctions on goods and services linked to illegal settlements. And I have to say that I very much welcome it in the context of the previously ridiculous position where properties were being marketed in this city for sale in the West Bank and the response at the time was to send in the Advertising Standards Agency. It was wholly inappropriate and I very much welcome the movement from the front bench. So will the government confirm that these measures will cover all settlements, including existing settlements, and that the ban on goods will apply to exports as well as imports, and that there will be no re-export to settlement clauses in contracts, as modeled on the guidance issued in respect of Russia?
Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I sincerely hope that this reset will be furthered and sustained, as only by doing so can the commitment to a two-state solution be truly achieved. Thank you.
Monica Harding
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the Minister to his place. I look forward to working with him, and I also pay tribute to the work of his predecessor, who was called into this chamber many times. And I also want to pay tribute to the Consul General in East Jerusalem, which I visited as part of the Select Committee, which did some really truly fantastic work.
I regret that it has been closed and I hope it is reopened swiftly. We Liberal Democrats welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement last week designed to protect the two-state solution and the territorial integrity of the Palestinian state, and finally bringing forward a ban on trade in goods and services with the illegal Israeli settlements. This was long overdue and something Liberal Democrats have called for for years. Many of my constituents in Esher and Walton also have called for it, as did members of my Jewish community, some of whom have been campaigning for it. The government must now ensure this ban is comprehensive and rigorously enforced, leaving no room for doubt as to the legal consequences for business involved in supporting or sustaining illegal settlements and enforced urgently.
The government must outline how it will monitor and implement this ban and commit to ensuring that the burden of proof is placed on Israeli authorities to provide verifiable certification that imported goods originated within the internationally recognized pre-1967 Green Line borders, denying UK entry to any uncertified items originating from those illegal settlements. It should draw on the legal provisions set out in Schedule 1 of the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act (SAMLA) to ensure the ban on services is comprehensive, and introduce secondary legislation to amend the SAMLA, place a legal duty of due diligence on UK banks and financial institutions to verify that none of their direct operations, supply chains, or customers are financing the purchase, construction, or other service provision for illegal settlements.
We'd also like the government to outline that any violation of these bans would result in enforcement measures under the UK-Israel Trade and Partnership Agreement. And we also call the government to impose a comprehensive ban on all arms exports to Israel, including the sale of F-35 components, and that sanctions should be expanded on ministers in the Israeli government's security cabinet who are encouraging settlement expansion, and that should include Prime Minister Netanyahu himself. A two-state solution represents the only political settlement which can deliver peace, dignity, and security for Israelis and Palestinians alike. But as a brutal terror organization which threatens the survival of the state of Israel, Hamas can have no role in the future of Palestine.
The UK, together with international partners, must develop a plan to progress urgently the disarming and disbanding of this terror group. Preserving the territory of Palestine must be a foundation stone for the building of the Palestinian state, but another must be the strengthening of the governance capabilities of the Palestinian Authority. There are vital reforms that must take place within the Palestinian Authority to ensure that it can act as an effective state-building force, and these must include the strengthening of the rule of law and protections for freedom of expression, cracking down on corruption, and following through on ending the operation of the martyrs' fund. The government must support and hold the PA to account for implementation of these reforms. And it is critical that the upcoming Palestinian elections are free, fair, and open to advance further democratic reform across Palestine.
So will ministers work with President Abbas and the Palestinian Authority to help deliver these, including ensuring access for international election monitors? We must also recognize that current Israeli restrictions are contributing to the severe economic insecurity in the West Bank. The government must put pressure on the Israeli cabinet to make sure that the Palestinian Authority has the revenues it is entitled to and access to the banking systems to support the economy. The Israeli legislative elections in October are an opportunity to deliver a new vision for the country, which reverses illegal settlement growth, prioritizes diplomacy over territorial expansion and champions engagement with moderate partners in Palestine to deliver a better future for both communities.
If the cycle of violence continues, it will only strengthen the voices of extremists on both sides who reject coexistence between Israelis and Palestinians. And meanwhile, the UK government must use every leverage it can, working with international partners and with the Israeli government to stop the loss of civilian life in Gaza, even after the ceasefire. As of the... I will give way.
Speaker 192
Thank you. I thank the member for giving way on that point where the UK government needs to work with all its partners. But the reality is, unless America takes action, Israel is not going to back off from the atrocities that it's carrying out.
And unless America gets involved, we need to push all the levers available to us to make sure that America's on side because even at the United Nations Security Council resolutions, they were almost all vetoed by America on some. And without America getting behind this peace plan, there is no peace in Palestine or Israel.
Monica Harding
I thank the honorable member for his intervention. He is absolutely right that America has a critical role to play in this conflict. To give some numbers, as of the 6th of August, at least 300 children have been reportedly killed in Gaza in the 300 days since the ceasefire was announced. That's an average of one child per day. Gazans continue to remain in the grip of a man-made humanitarian catastrophe in the strip, and the UK government must do more to alleviate the humanitarian crises there and the one growing in the West Bank.
Over 2 million people in Gaza are living on around 30% of the territory, sheltering in unsafe conditions among destroyed buildings, rubble, and waste. 70% of Gaza remains under IDF control, and the UK must now apply genuine pressure to Netanyahu's government to ensure food aid, medical supplies, and other essentials can reach Gazans now, without impediment and under the auspices of the UN, and that children and all civilians are protected. I have called on UK ministers to pressure Netanyahu's government to lift its arbitrary restrictions on NGOs supplying humanitarian aid to the strip. Last week, I noted in this chamber that more than 1.4 million people in Gaza are acutely food insecure, yet Israel's current interpretation of dual-use restrictions means that Palestinians are routinely and systematically denied essential items, including those used for rehabilitation by the tens of thousands of people who have suffered life-changing injuries during this conflict.
The Foreign Secretary agreed that blocking these goods is appalling. He also seemed to suggest that it was a strategy. So what does the minister think is the strategy by the Israeli government, and will he put pressure on them to undo these dual-good restrictions to allow the Palestinians to be self-sufficient, that aid is sustainable, and that they are no longer expected to live hand to mouth? From October, the World Food Programme will cut the number of people it can feed in Gaza from 1.1 million to 600,000. Not because the need has reduced, but because the money has run out.
These are people who will go without food in a territory where 100,000 women and children are already expected to need treatment for malnutrition in the coming year. The UK is the ninth largest donor to World Food Programme operations in Palestine, behind the USA, behind Germany, and behind France. Our annual contribution fell from $18 million in 2024 to $9.3 million last year to just $4 million this year. That is a reduction of 78%. The government cannot truly speak of its commitment to the Palestinian people while presiding over cuts like this.
So would the Minister explain how these two things are reconcilable? The brutal cuts to our aid budget has meant that our response to all humanitarian crises is limited.
I have asked many ministers in this House when we should expect, at the very least, a roadmap for restoring the 0.7% aid budget, a commitment that we in this House have enshrined in law. So again I ask the Minister, can he set out this timeline and can he confirm that his party, the party of DFID and Making Poverty History, is committed to seeing our aid budget returned in full?
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
I thank the member for giving way and she's making a very strong point about food security, or lack of it, for the Palestinian people in Gaza. Would you recognise that Israel now occupies around 70% of Gaza, so the population is restricted to 30%? Some years ago, there was actually a huge move to make Gaza a major food-growing area once again, which it traditionally always was. Does she not think this should also be part of a development process again?
Monica Harding
I thank the honourable member.
I 100% agree, and I made this point last week, that the dual-use restrictions mean that you can bring an egg into Gaza, but you can't bring a chicken. You can bring a potato into Gaza, but you can't bring a potato tuber, which means that Gazans are living hand-to-mouth and are absolutely reliant on the Israeli state for their well-being and health. The government must also engage with international partners and the Israeli authorities to ensure that journalists and human rights investigators are allowed into the strip. This is essential for accountability of war crimes on both sides of the conflict. We believe that robustly challenging the illegal actions of this extremist Israeli government is compatible both with staunch support for the rights of the state of Israel and Palestine to exist, and with resolute support for the rights of British Jews to live free from the scourge of anti-Jewish hatred.
Antisemitism has no place in our society. We stand in solidarity with the Jewish community and all of those affected and reaffirm our commitment to tackling hatred in all its forms. Those who spread antisemitic hatred or incite violence against Jews, whether online, at marches or elsewhere, must be stopped. It is never acceptable. Lastly, this is a debate on Israel and Palestine, but any serious discussion of the situation must also consider the situation in Lebanon.
In Lebanon, over 350,000 people remain displaced and more than 1,200 civilians have been killed in this latest phase of fighting, including children and health workers.
Israel has reportedly seized and occupied 230 square miles of Lebanese territory, creating a yellow line restricted zone similar to that of Gaza. The Israeli government must cease its military operations in southern Lebanon and withdraw from the country. I will give way.
Yasmin Qureshi
I thank the honorable lady for giving way. On the point of the people who've been displaced in Lebanon, would she also agree that if there's to be a comprehensive settlement of peace between Israel and Palestine, all the 700,000-odd people who were forcibly dispelled during the Nakba from West Bank and Gaza and others, they must also be allowed to be able to return back because at the moment all of them are just at are in refugee camps in Lebanon, in Syria, in Jordan, and in Egypt.
Monica Harding
The honorable member, and I agree, the plight of refugees that are emanating from this crisis, including the countries that are supporting them, countries like Jordan, we must stand with them and make sure that our commitment to those countries, including financially, is secure. Israel's continuing occupation violates Lebanon's sovereignty and is exacerbating the humanitarian crisis as we've just spoken of. So this House must also recognize and reaffirm that Hezbollah is a brutal terror organization from whom the Israeli government has the right to defend itself and its people. It must be disarmed, but that must be achieved by working with leaders in Beirut and through international organizations. So will the Minister set out what role the UK is playing in pushing for a proper ceasefire in Lebanon and for the disarmament of Hezbollah?
I thank the honorable member, and I agree.
Will he confirm that Israel must withdraw from all sovereign Lebanese territory? Madam Deputy Speaker, progress has been made in this last week that we on these benches have long called for. But we must be certain that statements are followed up with robust action and that we stand up as the UK as we always must for international law and international humanitarian law and for peace.
İmran Hussein
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I also begin by acknowledging and welcoming the important, hugely important step announced by the Foreign Secretary earlier and reaffirmed by the Minister today.
The ban on imports of settlement goods, the powers to target those who support them, facilitate from them, or profit from settlement activity, and the conclusion, in line with the ICJ's substantial ruling, that Israel's continued occupation of Palestine is unlawful, is a hugely welcome step taken by this government. Equally, I will do shortly. Equally important is the government have made it clear about the complete reset in our relationship, which of course is very important.
But equally we must be clear that any reset must mean more than a change in just language. It must mean serious consequences for those who flagrantly breach international law. I'll give way to my honorable friend.
John Slinger
I thank my honorable friend and I agree with him that it is very good that we heard last week from the government that they recognize that Israel's occupation is unlawful.
And does my honorable friend agree with me that since it is unlawful, it is absolutely vital that it is obviously the Palestinian people, but also the international community in the widest sense that gets to set what happens in the future in these territories of Palestine, rather than being solely Israel's view that it's its Israel's responsibility.
İmran Hussein
I of course my friend makes a very important point. And it must be, and that's the point I'm making, and I'm going to come on to the international rules-based order shortly, and that will perhaps answer his very important question.
Madam Deputy Speaker, many of us in this House have called for these measures for years. And let's be honest in this House, many of us have stood here in debate after debate speaking about these very issues only to be told by ministers time and time again that they are reviewing what action to take, they are looking at the ICJ advisory opinion.
İmran Hussein
I will shortly. Thank you. Madam Deputy Speaker, whilst we were having those debates in this House, the Palestinians did not have the luxury of waiting while we deliberated.
And frankly, frankly, it has taken a change of government to get us to this place. And let us be clear, when we are dealing with a genocide in Gaza, war crimes across Palestine, and ethnic cleansing of whole Palestinian communities, the previous government should have acted. They failed to stand against injustice, they failed to stand for human rights, and they failed to stand for the international rules-based order. I'll give way.
Speaker 197
I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. He is giving a very passionate speech. He, like me, will have had many members of his constituency, I'm sure, lobbying him on this issue over the last few years.
And in my constituency, it is the Hanwell Friends of Sabastiya, which is a village in the West Bank, who have often come up to speak to me. Would he agree that community organizations, friendship groups like this, have had an important role to play in influencing this government to take the robust steps that they have now taken?
İmran Hussein
Thank you very much to my honorable friend who raises a much broader point. Actually, let us pay tribute also, not just to the fantastic community groups in all our constituencies, but the millions of people who quite rightly marched on our streets when our government got it so wrong.
And I want to pay tribute to each and every one of them for making sure that through peaceful protests, they were right and those making the decisions in this place were wrong. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to concentrate my remarks this afternoon or even early evening, not about the direction of the recent announcements, but the pace at which this government should now travel.
Like my honourable friend for Middlesbrough, who as always made a powerful contribution, he's absolutely right, whilst I also, like him, welcome the government's announcement in terms of the double lock on arms licenses, there is some clarity that still needs to be put to this House today, and I very much hope whether the Minister could clarify whether that applies to existing licenses. Now, my absolute sincere request to this government is we must go further.
We must now end all remaining arms sales to Israel and in particular close the F-35 loophole and ensure that no UK origin equipment directly or indirectly supports genocide in Gaza or war crimes anywhere in the occupied Palestinian territory. Madam Deputy Speaker, the scale of death and suffering caused by the right-wing Netanyahu government's genocide in Gaza demands urgent and further immediate action. With more than 70,000 Palestinians killed in recent years, including over 21,000 children, the scale, the scale of this horror should shame the entire international community. I will do shortly.
The blockade, the denial of aid, the destruction of civilian infrastructure and the forced confinement of Palestinians while Israel illegally occupies most of their land has created the most serious humanitarian crisis. This is a product of the machinery of genocide and war crimes that Israel continues to operate. Children continue to be forced and denied food, water and medicines. Families continue to be pushed into impossible conditions. So if we are serious about international law, we must go further.
We must press for the full and immediate lifting of the blockade, unimpeded humanitarian access and the protection of UNRWA's mandate, staff, premises and operations. And let us also be clear, aid funding of course is welcome and the honourable lady, the spokesperson for the Liberal Democrats, put it very rightly in terms of how there is a different debate to be had in terms of our contribution to international aid and how that has disappointingly dropped down on the agenda. But of course aid is important there, but aid cannot be a substitute for the political action needed to stop the war crimes and conditions of genocide that make that aid necessary in the first place. I'll give way to my honourable friend.
Speaker 198
Madam Deputy Speaker, my honourable friend repeatedly mentions the word genocide, yet the government repeatedly says that only a competent court can formally determine whether genocide has occurred in Gaza.
Does my honourable friend agree with me that that is not the issue? And does he agree that genocide prevention law exists precisely because waiting for a final judgment may mean that it is too late? And does he agree that we have an obligation to act not once genocide is found by a court, but as soon as there is a serious risk that genocide may be occurring?
İmran Hussein
I thank my honourable friend. Of course, I agree with him, and the genocide is unfolding right before our eyes.
I would say to him very gently that my reading of what the Foreign Secretary said, of course he is somebody who has to, he is somebody who is, his language is within the scope of this House. However, he did list off genocides which to me alluded that he accepts that there is a genocide. There are enough scholars, there are enough legal minds, there are enough people across the globe that have confirmed this is a genocide that is unfolding right before our eyes. Madam Deputy Speaker, I, I will be very brief now, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome again the announcement with regards to the West Bank.
The Foreign Secretary was right to call out the settler terrorists in the West Bank. That matter, that matters because Palestinian communities know exactly what that violence is designed to do: frighten them, isolate them, and drive them from their homes. The powers announced recently are the right powers, now they must be used. Sanctions on all settler terrorists and the full settlement enterprise with them, those who finance from it, profit from it, build it, advertise it, and politically sustain it, must come as soon as possible. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to make some final submissions with regards to the ICJ and ICC.
Now, we must stand, and I welcome again the comments made by the Foreign Secretary, that we will stand with the ICC and ICJ. And frankly, it is disgraceful that judges of those courts have come under pressure, faced sanctions, faced pressure. An international rules-based order counts for nothing if we abandon the institutions that uphold it the moment their rulings become inconvenient. We cannot cite the ICJ's advisory opinion one week and say nothing while its judges are threatened the next week. We must continue to stand with the international rules-based order.
Madam Deputy Speaker, in closing, recent announcements are an important first step, but it is only the start. The war crimes, genocide, and ethnic cleansing must end, and the international community must commit to do that.
Those responsible for genocide, war crimes, and ethnic cleansing must be held to account. And in this House, we have a moral, ethical, and legal duty not to stop until that happens.
Brian Matthew
Madam Deputy Speaker, I and I know many across the House welcomed the announcement from the Foreign Secretary over the banning of products from illegal settlements in the occupied territories. Back in the early 80s, I was a kibbutznik based at Kibbutz Re'im in the Negev, where I was conducting agricultural research.
In those now far-off days, I would go with my Israeli friends to meet their Palestinian friends in Gaza to meet, to trade, to drink strong black Arabic coffee. Reim was one of the kibbutzim that was attacked on the 7th of October 2023. So I can say I understand something of the area and the tensions, and also that peace is possible. What I would like to bring to the House though, to this debate, however, is a topic raised by one of my constituents at a surgery in my constituency of Melksham and Devizes last Saturday.
The subject raised was the closure of the unit tracking potential law breaches as announced in the Guardian on the 24th of April this year. The FCDO's International Humanitarian Law cell closure is doubly worrying at this time, especially when it means that funding for the conflict and security monitoring project run by the Centre for Information Resilience, CIR, will as a result come to an end. The center's... I will.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way on that point. To add to his point, he may not be aware that the government has also closed the Atrocity Prevention Centre that was set up in the Cabinet Office that I spent two years fighting for the integration of. And the whole point of it is to identify very early on the signs of ethnic cleansing or something going on so that the government can send experts in to improve the response of the Foreign Office.
Does he not agree with me that's really concerning given that we are only seeing more conflict around the world, not less?
Brian Matthew
I heartily agree with the with the the honourable lady. And if I can continue, the the centre's work for the FCDO included the world's largest open source monitoring of incidents across Israel, Palestine and Lebanon. This is the only program in the UK that collects, verifies and analyse analyses human rights and conflict incidents in Israel and the occupied territories.
The closure of the monitoring program will mean that the Foreign Office will lose access to a database of 26,000 and counting incidents in the Middle East stretching back to the 7th of October 2023. The database also helps FCDO teams decide whether arms export control licenses to Israel should remain suspended and is used by officials discussing whether international humanitarian law concerns such as proportionality are being breached. It also understood the head of the war crimes team in the counter-terrorism unit underlined the importance of CIR's work in helping the Metropolitan Police consider war crimes allegations including the lawful, unlawful shooting of minors in Gaza. I hope the Minister will be able to clarify these particular cuts have been if they've been reversed or not.
As for the government to be operating blind at this time is extremely concerning. Furthermore, it casts light on the importance of FCDO's work and the self-defeating nature of the government's cuts to our aid program, which those in my party and I suspect many across the chamber condemn. Thank you.
Matthew Patrick.
Matthew Patrick
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. This weekend was Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year. Jewish families wish one another Shana Tova. They dipped apples in honey in the hope that the new year ahead was a sweet one. And as Rosh Hashanah closed, those families started a 10-day journey through to Yom Kippur, the Jewish Day of Atonement, a day where we seek forgiveness for our failings and we vow to do better.
Today is the first of those 10 days. It is a period of profound seriousness, a chance to reflect on the past to ensure the future is brighter. Last year on the high holy day of Yom Kippur, Jihad Al-Shami went to Heaton Park Synagogue armed with a knife to murder Jews. As he stabbed one worshipper, he shouted, "This is what they get for killing our children." It is no wonder that this is a sensitive time and a sensitive debate for the Jewish community because, as Mr. Al-Shami's actions show, there are those who would cloak their antisemitism in the concerns around the actions of Israel, those whose murderous intent and racist ignorance is dressed up as a moral crusade.
And so I choose to reflect on the past year. And I hope to use that to help to build towards a brighter year ahead. Because surely that is what each and every one of us in this House is here to do, to chart a way forward. Our job is not to amplify grievance, it is not to give in to hopelessness. It is to do the hard yards of understanding and perhaps even the harder yards of playing our role in getting us to a better place.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank my honourable friend for the tone of his comments and for reminding us of some of the seriousness, particularly what took place in Manchester last year.
And he seems to be suggesting that dialogue between the peoples of our countries is an important thing. Does he not think that twinning with Jewish, with sorry, with Israeli cities is actually an important thing to do because that means the people of Israel and the people of London and the people of London and the people of Palestine can talk to each other and that we shouldn't just be led by what governments do?
Matthew Patrick
I think my honourable friend makes a powerful point and I think the opportunities of twinning, of hearing that dialogue, of making sure we're not shutting out people who are directly impacted by this is an important one and I certainly support it. And I'd say at next year's Yom Kippur, I hope dearly that we have an opportunity to look back at a year of progress. I hope that the threat of E1 settlements has ended and with it the violent expansions of settlements across the West Bank who terrorise Palestinians.
I hope that extremism no longer has any influence on the government of Israel. I hope that the everyday leadership of Israelis and Palestinians, of Jewish and Muslim communities, inspires people towards peace and towards love. I hope that the Palestinian Authority, often considered the best hope of leading the Palestinian people, ends once and for all the abhorrent practice of paying terrorists each and every month based on the level of destruction and death they wreak upon the Jewish people. I hope that the Palestinian people and the Palestinian children are not taught using textbooks that say I am to be hated because I am Jewish. I hope those children are not brought up to believe that hating Jews is as necessary a life skill as learning maths or science.
I hope that Hamas, an evil that has inflicted untold damage on the people of Israel and the people of Gaza, is no more. I hope that in their place is a leadership that sees aid as an opportunity to feed its people, to build out infrastructure that might make the everyday life of Gazans better. And I hope, as I have called for in this chamber many times in the past, that Israel has increased the flow of aid into Gaza so that people have no worry about from where they might find their next meal or dose of medicine.
I hope that those in Gaza who have stolen more than a billion pounds of what should have been public money to build an underground terrorist tunnel network and ply it with weapons become marginalized voices, recognized for the malign influence that they are. I hope that the current Iranian regime, without whom this conflict could never be sustained, the regime that exports terrorism right across the globe, including here in Britain, is over and that in its place is a government that treats all the people of Iran, man or woman, gay or straight, Jew or Muslim, as equal people deserving of love and respect. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am an optimist. I cannot give up on the idea of a two-state solution, but let me say, and it's difficult to say this, I understand why some people have. I've spoken to lifelong peace activists in Israel who decided that the depravity of October 7th and the celebrations that followed it showed them that they would be fools to believe that they could share peace with people that want them dead.
I too understand that if you have grown up in Gaza and known war and hunger and destruction and death, that you similarly might not see an alternative path.
You may not see your neighbors as partners towards peace. But my optimism doesn't dismiss these views and it doesn't simply wish that they would go away. My optimism is a belief that we can change the course. And it's been done before. In this House, we are rightly proud of what we achieved in Northern Ireland through the Good Friday Agreement.
That was anything but easy. Prejudices ran deep, terrible injustices were inflicted upon people, hurt reached into every corner and every community of Northern Ireland. More of the same was not an option. But that required change and it required courage. It placed a demand on those that wanted peace, an uncomfortable demand, to see and pursue an alternative that hardly seemed possible.
We can learn from them. It starts with us here, with understanding, with compassion, with humanity and dignity in everything we do. It requires us to listen, sometimes to views we don't always like, and sometimes to people who aren't on our side. It starts with ending a culture here in the UK and around the world where we take sides on this issue as if it is a football match. That is not a path to peace.
And I say, if we fail to start from the idea that even in the most intractable and bloody conflicts, children and non-combatants should be kept safe, then we will never find that path.
If we want to play our role in this place in building a two-state solution, we must not see this as a debate needing more heat, but instead needing more light. Where there is anger, understandable, justifiable anger, we must work to ensure that the words we speak do not entrench that anger and in so doing block any future chance of progress. The UK and our allies owe that to the people of Israel and Palestine. Those who are doing the hard work of trying to find peace in the most difficult of circumstances, we owe them our solidarity. The alternative is that we risk looking back in a year at another missed opportunity.
Will the member give way? I'm happy to give way.
Speaker 205
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm incredibly grateful to the honorable member for giving way.
He's giving a hugely powerful and I think intelligent speech. I, and he may well come onto it, but would he join me in asking the government to redouble its efforts to secure the international fund for Israeli and Palestinian peace that will actually give a chance to those communities to build peace up from the bottom when the political leadership is failing from the top?
Matthew Patrick
I know my honorable friend speaks with great experience on this and I'm sure the front bench will have heard that. Any opportunity to fund those people who day in, day out are making the future of peace still possible is one we must take and I'm sure the front bench have heard that. We owe them, as I say, our solidarity. Because the alternative, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that we look back in another year at more missed opportunities, with more anger, more hate, peace ever further away.
I do not want that on my conscience so I commit to learning those lessons.
Ayoub Khan
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week represented an important change in Britain's approach to Israel and Palestine and I welcome it. For the first time this government acknowledged the reality staring us in the face that the occupation is unlawful that illegal settlements are destroying any prospect of Palestinian statehood and that in parts of the West Bank Palestinians are being ethnically cleansed by what the Foreign Secretary himself called settler terrorists. Those are not my words. They are now the words of His Majesty's government.
And that makes the question before us today all the more urgent. If we finally recognize what is happening, why are we still refusing to confront those responsible for making it happen? Because this is not simply the work of a few rogue extremists. Under this Israeli government, more settlements have been approved in four years than in the previous twenty. Some 800,000 settlers now live across the occupied Palestinian territories.
The Foreign Secretary himself told the House that settlers have attacked Palestinian communities under Israeli military protection.
And that Israeli government ministers have supported ethnic cleansing. We need to stop pretending that the settlements are somehow separate from the Israeli state, because the settlements are a monster of their own making. By tinkering around the edges with sanctions on settlers and leaving the government at the heart of their enterprise untouched, I'm afraid this Labour government is trying to tiptoe around raindrops and not get wet. But they will be, as the previous government, soaked in complicity. And these sanctions do not punish the real architects of this apartheid.
Settlers are murdering Palestinians with IDF protection. The Israeli government is giving them the land to invade in the first place.
So if we are serious about ending illegal settlements, where is the ban on trade with the nation of Israel itself? Because government policy now contains an extraordinary contradiction. We will sanction the people who finance settlement construction. We will penalize companies that build settlements and ban the products coming from within. Yet when the Israeli state allocates the land, approves the plans, and sends armed forces to protect settler terrorists, suddenly the consequences stop.
As I said before, when I asked the Foreign Secretary a question only last week, this is a litmus test of our most basic principles.
If those who help establish illegal settlements should be sanctioned, why not the officials who authorize them? Why not the institutions that finance them and the state contractors that build them? And why should our wider trading relationship remain untouched when settlement expansion is official Israeli government policy? Of course.
Warinder Juss
I thank the honorable member for giving way. The July 2024 advisory opinion of the ICJ did declare that Israel's continued presence in the occupied Palestinian territories is unlawful under international law.
Israel must end the occupation as quickly as possible, stop all settlement activity and evacuate all settlers. Does he agree that it is time therefore to honour that advisory opinion? But would he also agree that we should make a distinction between the actions of the Israeli government and the state of Israel itself?
Ayoub Khan
Well, can I say in so far as the first part of his statement, I wholeheartedly agree with the honourable member. Of course, we should uphold international law. But I'm a little confused with the latter part of his statement. It's the Israeli state that drives policy. And one cannot distinguish between the Israeli state and the government.
And I entirely agree that we must not conflate the Israeli people because that would be wrong. And I suspect all honorable members in this House want to see the scourge of antisemitism tackled, as well as anti-Muslim hate. There was a massive increase in anti-Muslim hate following October the 7th across the city of Birmingham and across this country. And we must do whatever we can in this House, unified by one principle, the principle of humanity, that where we see wrong, we address it.
And we do it without fear or favor. And I have said before, one of the prime reasons why you have independent members of Parliament, why protesters came onto the streets, why you have students at universities protesting, was they are not anti-Semitic. And of course I accept that there has been occasions where there's been anti-Semitism, we must all condemn it. But in the main, they were all championing one aspect, and that was the freedom of the Palestinians, which have been under the oppression for so many decades. And so I come back to my original point, that we must all work together to prevent the anti-Semitism rise in this country, as well as anti-Muslim hate.
And we must all try to address this conflation, because what we have witnessed, for example, doctors being suppressed from freedom of speech by their regulators, when all they have done is questioned some of the actions. Israel cannot claim to be a victim, the state of Israel, not the people, the state, when they prevent journalists from entering.
And and we should also say, if you are open and transparent, allow journalists to come in. Allow them to document what is taking place. But I suspect that they will be unwilling to do that precisely because of the genocide that we are witnessing. In Gaza, more than 73,000 Palestinians officially recorded as as dead. Murdered.
Homes reduced to rubble. Air obstructed. Entire bloodlines wiped out. I have no hesitation in calling out what everyone is seeing with their own eyes. A genocide livestreamed for the world to see.
And Netanyahu's government has demonstrated time and again an extraordinary contempt.
Extraordinary reporting raises profoundly disturbing questions about what Netanyahu knew before that attack. According to Haaretz, the President of the UAE warned him a week and a half earlier that Hamas was planning a major operation. And Netanyahu did not pass that warning to his security chiefs. How absurd is that proposition, that as a Prime Minister you are being informed of an imminent threat and you do not advise your chief security officer? Either he didn't believe the information or, and I quote, "he wanted to see what plan they could come up with and come down on them hard."
Those are not my words.
Those are the words of none other than Hillary Clinton. We were told for years that the destruction would stop when hostages were released. Netanyahu said the war could end if Hamas surrendered and returned them. Yet Haim Rubinstein, a spokesperson for the Israeli Hostage Families Forum, said as back as as far as 2025 that Israel rejected an early proposal to release civilians hostages if the IDF did not enter Gaza. This is the regime that we continue to do business with.
Last week's announcements can be remembered in one of two ways. It can be the moment Britain finally changed course, or it can become another intolerable status quo: tougher words, narrowly drawn sanctions, business as usual elsewhere, and yet another year in which the prospect of a Palestinian statehood crumbles under the weight of Israel's never-ending bloodshed.
Acknowledging the problem cannot be the end of British policy. If we truly believe Palestinians have the right to self-determination, then this must be only the start. Because, as my honourable member for Bradford East said, time is not on our side. And we cannot, must not wait until there is no Palestine left to recognise.
Patricia Ferguson
Patricia Ferguson.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the contribution by my honourable friend this evening and that of the Foreign Secretary from last week.
Having supported the cause of the Palestinian people since the early 1990s and having a keen interest in Jewish culture and religion, I was particularly keen to visit the countries for myself to better understand the situation. I did so in May this year with colleagues from across the chamber, and I'm very grateful to Yachad for organizing the visit and would want to declare an interest in that regard. Now, like most members, I've read a lot and thought a lot about the events of the 7th of October, about the attack on the kibbutzim and on the music festival, the murder and kidnapping of so many people, and the treatment of those held hostage. Dreadful events, each and every one of them.
But to visit a kibbutz and hear how the attack unfolded there with armed paragliders descending on the kibbutz in the early hours of a Saturday morning and the murder and kidnapping of members of that kibbutz was frankly shocking. But it also took the IDF more than 24 hours to get to those people and even longer to safely escort them to safety and that was heart-wrenching. The actions of Hamas on that date and beyond were monstrous. But the woman who showed us around the kibbutz lost her home and her son, a father of three on that day. But when we asked her what she does now, she told us that she does what she has always done.
She goes into schools to talk about peace. Many Israelis we spoke with expressed similar hopes, and also their great hope that the elections next month will make a difference, and also that a public inquiry into the events of October the 7th, perhaps as my friend the member for Perry Barr suggested, should be held. Israelis are right to be saddened, angered, and outraged by those events. But their government's response against the people of Gaza has been disproportionate and is a stain on the conscience of the world. But of course, the problems did not begin in 2023.
Indeed, my late father was stationed in the Middle East during the Second World War. He loved the region, but was depressed by what he saw then and by what unfolded in subsequent decades.
Now I am proud that this government recognised the state of Palestine, and I'm even more proud that we're now committed to banning sales of goods and services from settlements. And I'm also proud that we've taken such a strong leadership role internationally to get to this point. The international effort is crucial if there is to be progress. But let's be under no illusion. When we talk about settlements, we're not talking about small villages with rudimentary services and a rural lifestyle.
Many are large industrial towns with successful industries and excellent public services. Most are strategically placed to prevent a Palestinian state from ever being contiguous, and all of them are illegal. E1 is potentially vast and just the latest addition to that policy, which of course isn't new.
In Hebron, the second largest city in the West Bank, a settlement was created in the middle of the city in 1968. And as a result, the city center is now a ghost town. Now we see on our televisions and online the extreme actions of the settlers, and I'll come back to that. But we shouldn't underestimate for a moment the sheer grind that Palestinians in the West Bank experience each and every day as they try to go about their lives. Checkpoints, roads that are off-limit to Palestinian cars, or to Palestinian cars and commercial activity, or just off-limit to Palestinians full stop.
The village of Khirbet Zanuta in the South Hebron Hills was home to some 250 Palestinians.
They were forced off their land by settlers after a campaign of harassment and intimidation.
Will my honourable friend give way?
Of course.
Speaker 211
I thank my honourable friend for giving way and she's giving a very thoughtful and detailed and balanced speech and I'm grateful for that. A report by the West Bank Protection Consortium documents forced nudity, invasive searches, sexual harassment and threats of sexual violence against Palestinian women, men and children. It has found that sexual violence against women and girls was a factor in families deciding to leave their homes.
Does my honorable friend agree that where sexual violence is being used to intimidate and forcibly displace Palestinians, we must make it clear to the Israeli government that those responsible must be held to account?
Patricia Ferguson
Indeed, and I would agree with my honorable friend. We heard of examples of that when we visited this year. And of course, that is deliberate. And it consisted of instances such as she describes, but also of people peering in windows and polluting watercourses used usually by the women of a village. So that kind of behavior is just not acceptable.
But the villagers of Khirbet Zanuta actually won a Supreme Court ruling that they could return to their village. And many of them did. But they were then forced out again. This time, the settlers bulldozed the village, including its school, which had been built in part with UK taxpayers' money. At Umm al-Khair, we saw how settler outposts had expanded directly alongside the village and heard about the death of Oda Hathaleen in July 2025.
Oda was shot dead by Yinon Levi, a settler already sanctioned by the UK government.
And despite video evidence, and I mean really strong video evidence, no charges have ever been brought and no prosecution has taken place. We visited the American Coordination Center in Kiryat Gat, and I have to say that was quite an unreal experience. There are military personnel from around 20 countries working on aid delivery and the monitoring of the ceasefire and planning for reconstruction of Gaza. And we discussed with an Israeli army officer the distribution of aid in Gaza and our concerns about the designation of many items as being potentially dual-use and as a consequence banned from Gaza.
This included items such as tent poles, therapeutic toys for children, and cochlear implants for children too. We also met with the Norwegian Refugee Council and their assessment of the volume and effectiveness of humanitarian aid could not have been more at odds with what we heard at Kerem Shalom. But whatever the facts of the matter are, it's clear that the humanitarian situation is still dire and that life for Palestinians in Gaza is a question of survival rather than living. With little in the way of healthcare and education, it would be helpful if the Minister closing this debate could indicate whether we will expand our support for Palestinian students wishing to study in the UK and for injured and sick Palestinians struggling to access healthcare.
It is a sad fact, well actually it's not sad, it's horrifying, that Gaza has per capita the highest number of child amputees in the world, many of whom have not had access to proper treatment, rehabilitation or appropriate prosthetics. We must do more to help. Madam Deputy Speaker, the way ahead will not be easy, but the only way forward is for a safe and secure Israel to be able to live with a safe and secure Palestine as its neighbour. Hopefully that aim will be helped by the election of a new government in just over a month and the continuing efforts of the government and its international partners. I was struck by something my honourable friend the member for Wirral West said in his speech and was reminded of the comment made at the time of the Good Friday Agreement, which is, and I'll close on this, that you don't make peace by talking to your friends.
Martin Vickers
Martin Vickers.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wasn't able to attend the House last week when the Foreign Secretary made his statement on Israel and Palestine and wanted to put take this opportunity to put on on record my support for what he proposed. On the day of the announcement, I tuned into Radio 4's six o'clock news and included in the headlines was a a sentence from what the Minister had said and also they also broadcast the comments or some of the comments of the Father of the House, my right honourable friend the member for Gainsborough, when he too supported what the Foreign Secretary had said but added how much he admired the Jewish people and their faith but deeply regretted what is happening on the West Bank.
It is in that context that I make clear that I share my right honourable friend's views of the Jewish people, and he said he was a Conservative friend of Israel, and I too would put myself into that category. My criticisms are of the Israeli government. Madam Deputy Speaker, after the appalling events of 7th of October, it was inevitable that there would be a response from the Israelis, and rightly so. But tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed, many of them children. Surely it would have been possible to target the leaders of Hamas without the loss of those innocent Palestinian lives.
I can understand the determination of Israel to take an extremely robust approach to defending itself when there are those in the region who want to wipe the country from the face of the map.
That is perfectly, so their actions in that respect are justified. But I ask the Israeli government why that involves repeated violations of international law. If the international community seriously believe in a two-state solution, then we need to call out Israeli policy for what it is: actions to prevent this ever happening. I can understand, I'll happily give way.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
Thank you for giving way, and he's generous with his time. Is he aware that both the Prime Minister and the alternative Prime Minister in Israel have both said in terms that they do not accept the idea of the entity of a Palestinian state?
Martin Vickers
I was aware that ministers within Israel had indicated that, and I thank the right honourable member for his intervention. As I say, if the international community is seriously supportive of a two-state solution, it needs to call out the fact that Israel are deliberately implementing policies to thwart that. I can understand and fully support Israel as the home of the Jewish people. They should therefore recognise the desire for the Palestinian people to have their own homeland.
When I was elected in 2010, my focus was entirely on my constituency and was determined to earn myself a second term. But during those the five years of the coalition government, if memory serves me correctly, I undertook just two foreign trips. And being mindful of the fact that the Israel-Palestine issue may well come to the fore and I may have to make a decision on that. So I traveled both to Israel, but my first trip was actually to Gaza. Interestingly enough, when we got to the border, we had a call from the Jerusalem the consulate in Jerusalem advising us not to cross the border.
But we were determined, having got that got that far, and we insisted on crossing over. I witnessed the tragedy of what so many of what the residents there had to face. It's much worse now, of course.
That and the events what I witnessed had a considerable impact on how I viewed this seemingly never-ending dispute. In October 2014, I was one of 39 Conservative members who supported a motion to recognise Palestine. Sadly, only three of the Conservatives remain, one of whom is the Father of the House, who I mentioned earlier. I appreciate that to some extent it is only symbolic, but nevertheless it is extremely important. Returning to last week's announcement, how effective it will be remains to be seen.
One thing is certain is that public opinion is broadly supportive.
My inbox and those who visit my surgery to express their views on this issue are most certainly critical of Israel. Oh, I should be more specific and say the Israeli government. One particular constituent I have in mind is so passionate about this issue who comes to see me on repeated occasions. She will be absolutely delighted. Though I say to the House as I said to my constituent, and she is someone who regularly travels to London in order to take part in the many demonstrations.
Contrary to the views expressed by one of the members earlier, I don't think that the continued demonstrations are actually beneficial to the Palestinian cause. Madam Deputy Speaker, Israel is an ally, a democracy and a nation that as I said at the outset has every right to exist and defend itself. I fully support that, but their government need to recognize that they are losing further support and if they continue with their illegal acts, that will only continue.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Speaker 215
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I also put my thanks on the record for the Minister's predecessor, the Member for Lincoln, for all the work that he has done in getting us to this place and indeed the work that him and his team are doing at the moment and particularly last week. I welcome today's general debate on Israel and Palestine. It's a timely debate and one that rightly deserves the attention of this House. There will no doubt be a small minority online who will ask why events thousands of miles away should take up time in the British Parliament.
So let me address that from the outset. Firstly, Britain does not exist on a planet of its own, detached from the rest of the world.
What happens beyond our shores has consequences here at home. We also have a particular historic and moral responsibility when it comes to Israel and Palestine, given the Balfour Declaration, the British Mandate and our country's historic role in the region. But even putting aside history, whether we like it or not, conflicts elsewhere affect the lives of people right here in Britain. A war in Ukraine, a war involving Iran, or instability across the Middle East can mean higher prices at the petrol pump, higher energy bills, greater inflationary pressures and ultimately higher borrowing costs for families.
And more fundamentally, growing instability around the world threatens the peace, security and freedoms upon which all our lives depend. Britain therefore has both an interest and a responsibility in seeking peace, upholding international law and preventing further conflict. Secondly, we cannot discuss this conflict without confronting the extraordinary loss of human life. According to figures published by the UN, more than 73,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since October the 7th, 2023. More than 21,700 of those killed have been children.
21,700 children. I'm happy to give way.
Ayoub Khan
The honorable member may be aware that the United Nations inquiry revealed that the IDF were intentionally targeting children as a way to end the future generation. And that inquiry should prompt this government to take even further steps towards sanctions.
Speaker 215
I thank the honorable member for his intervention. And as certainly the government has made clear that they will be seeking advice from the ICJ and they are continuously supporting those inquiries as our Secretary of State did highlight in his remarks last Tuesday. But he makes a very important point.
We live in a world, sadly, where we can go about our daily lives and not always feel the seriousness of the pain or comprehend the magnitude of the killing in Gaza. Putting those hundreds of thousands of deaths to one side for just a moment, as mothers and fathers in this chamber and beyond across the country, can we not feel the pain being felt by the people of Gaza? Only recently I saw a video, Madam Deputy Speaker, of a father who believed his child was dead, only to be reunited with his son more than two years later, having thought that he had been killed and buried beneath the rubble of Gaza's destruction. He holds his son, he pulls him close, he cries uncontrollably, completely overwhelmed with emotion. Can we imagine being that father?
If we had lost our child, can we imagine the happiness, the relief and the overwhelming emotion of that moment of being reunited? This is one story that at least has some happiness at the end. And it makes us tear up because we imagine, what if this was my child? What if this was your child? But I ask, what is the feeling of the mothers who will never see their beloved children again?
Those fathers who will never again hold their children tightly to their chests. Those children growing up in Gaza with no mother, no father, no guardian and no shelter. Living in a conflict zone where if you are a journalist like Hamza al-Dahdouh, you can be killed in an Israeli airstrike. Or like Shireen Abu Akleh, you can be shot dead while doing your job.
And years later, there is still no accountability that brings justice to their families. Where you can be British, Australian, Canadian, or Palestinian aid worker for the World Central Kitchen trying to provide basic food and humanitarian assistance to people living among the rubble and be killed by the IDF. The seven World Central Kitchen workers were traveling in a clearly marked convoy and coordinating their movements with the Israeli military. Three of those killed were British. They were returning from delivering food and humanitarian assistance to people in Gaza when their vehicles were struck.
Their deaths showed the extraordinary danger faced by aid workers trying to feed civilians in a war zone. Israel acknowledged serious failures in the strike and dismissed two officers.
Yet the families of the World Central Kitchen themselves call for an independent accountability and that is falling on deaf ears. This is the treatment of journalists, aid workers and others whose very purpose is to help and bear witness. So where is the justice? Where is the accountability? And where is the protection of life for everyone in Gaza?
And God forbid you stand up and consistently speak out against the oppression, the killing and the destruction of Palestinian people. We call for sanctions in line with international law, in line with the position held by successive British governments for decades, and the response is that Israel sanctions people like me.
Speaker 192
I thank my friend for giving me way on that very important point. Speaking up against war crimes, speaking up against ethnic cleansing, speaking up against genocide, if that means being banned from entering that country, wear it as a badge of honour, and you should be proud of that. But should the rules be applied equally to Israeli diplomats in this House? Because just when China banned our members, elected members, from China, the Speaker imposed a ban on the Chinese ambassador from coming to this place.
I would like to see that to be repeated in equal measures to the Israeli ambassador.
Speaker 215
I thank my honourable friend for his points and he makes them very strongly and I was actually coming onto the reference of China. If the intention of sanctioning me was to silence me, it will not work. You cannot call yourself the only democracy in the Middle East and then sanction British parliamentarians for speaking out. China previously sanctioned members of this Parliament for speaking out over the human rights abuses in Xinjiang, as the member has just pointed out. Those sanctions did not silence British parliamentarians either, nor will these.
Because the justice and equality that I and many others in this chamber fight for does not consider your nationality, your faith, your ethnic background, or who you are. If more than 33,000 Palestinians are killed in Gaza, if Palestinian land in the occupied West Bank is taken through illegal settlements, if Palestinians are being forcibly displaced and subjected to what many international experts and human rights organizations have described as ethnic cleansing, and if the viability of an independent state of Palestine alongside a state of Israel is being systematically undermined, eroding every opportunity for a two-state solution and lasting peace in the Middle East, then I have a moral duty to speak up.
And if you murder innocent Jewish people, as Hamas did in the horrific attacks of October 7th, when around 1,200 people were killed, then I have exactly the same moral duty to speak up and call that out. And outside of this conflict, as I have done in the past, I have stood shoulder to shoulder with the minority Christian community in Jaranwala in Pakistan against their persecution. The justice that I believe in means that I have a moral duty to stand with them too. Additionally, in response to the government's measures to prohibit trade with illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, the Israeli government announced that it would close the British Consulate General in East Jerusalem.
These measures were taken alongside France and Canada, with other international partners also supporting action to protect the two-state solution. Yet Israel chose to direct its retaliation principally against the United Kingdom. This is not the conduct we should expect from an ally. It looks like an ally lashing out because Britain has chosen to uphold international law. There is also the fundamental question about Israel's legal authority to take this action.
This is not the British Embassy in Israel. It is the British Consulate General, which represents the United Kingdom in Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza, and conducts our relations with Palestine.
And we must, Madam Deputy Speaker, see these three areas as one entity, because that is what they are. East Jerusalem is occupied territory. The International Court of Justice has confirmed that Israel holds the status of an occupying power there, and Israeli sovereignty over East Jerusalem is not internationally recognised. Israel may exercise the practical power to force the consulate's closure, but practical control is not the same as lawful sovereignty. By what legal right, then, does the Israeli government seek to close a British diplomatic mission in occupied East Jerusalem?
Madam Deputy Speaker, I also want to bring to the House the attention of B'Tselem's report today, an Israeli human rights group. It's the most comprehensive report to date on the West Bank, gathering over three decades of evidence of Israel's human rights violations and 2,000 testimonies since October 2023. And the report is called The Elimination Project.
It shows a correlation between the widespread destruction of homes and infrastructure and the network of roadblocks and checkpoints, the attacks by armed settler militias, the expulsion of communities and unprecedented expansion of settlement outposts and farms. B'Tselem and Yesh Din say these are not separate phenomena, rather an Israeli project to eliminate the Palestinian collective to establish a permanent and Jewish control, permanent and controlled Jewish Israeli control over the entire area. The Israeli elimination project did not begin, they write, with the current government, but since late 2022, and they are entering a new phase being deployed faster and broader, much broader.
And this is why I would like to ask the Minister what, given the report today, is there, will the government be expediting the announcement that it has made last week with its settler, with its trade ban with the occupied West Bank in particular and the settler, the illegal occupation and trade with those areas. This is really, really important. The Foreign Secretary made clear last week to this House, Britain is not powerless when international law is being torn apart.
So once again, commend the Prime Minister and the government for demonstrating the power of international diplomacy and for leading action alongside France, Canada and other international partners against illegal Israeli settlements and those who profit from them. Thank you.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
Jeremy Corbyn.
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a pleasure to follow the member for Bradford West and the contribution she made and the huge contribution she's made to supporting the Palestinian people over many years in this House. This debate is obviously very welcome and I acknowledge that the government's statement last week on a resetting of policy is a very important and highly significant change in government policy and whilst I welcome some aspects of it, I do feel it doesn't go far enough, it's taking far too long to bring it into operation and it's very unclear about what kind of ultimate sanctions would take place against Israel in the event of them invading the sanctions concerning Israeli settlements.
And it's very unclear about what kind of ultimate sanctions would take place against Israel in the event of them invading the sanctions concerning Israeli settlements. And it's also very unclear about what military cooperation there will be with Israel in the future. And I think these things must be clarified. And I hope when the minister replies at the end, we'll learn a little bit more about the details of the policy, but in particular, why they've given themselves so many months to bring it into operation. Succeeding generations will ask very serious questions of all of us as politicians.
Our children are taught in school the horrors of the Holocaust against the Jewish people.
They're taught the horrors of so many other genocides around the world and taught the way in which racism leads into that particular horrible scenario. And they will ask questions about why we were so unable to do anything to prevent the massive loss of life in Gaza at the hands of the Israeli forces. As the member for Bradford pointed out, 73,000 people have been killed in Gaza. Those millions of tons of rubble hide many more bodies. And as the Israeli Defense Force carts some of the rubble away to be hardcore for building somewhere in Israel, there are bodies within that rubble.
There are human remains there. There's DNA evidence there. What we see is the most massive killing of civilian and innocent life in Gaza.
And uh we haven't been able to stop it. It still carries on and just there's many statistics one could quote, but the simple one to me is this. The estimate is there are 63 million tons of rubble in Gaza and there are 2 million people in Gaza. That's more than 30 tons of rubble per person. Almost every building damaged or destroyed.
And the um destruction has moved on to the West Bank where the activities of the settlers destroying land, chopping down olive trees, polluting wells, driving people out of their homes, burning villages, driving people away.
It's the sort of activities that the frontiersmen from Europe, the white people that invaded Native American land in the Wild West did against Indian villages at the time. That is the equivalent of the horror that's going on there. And sometimes we seem to pretend that we can continue with normal relations with Israel. And yet this, these are not random acts of people that are acting isolated, alone or illegal. These are condoned by the government of Israel.
The settlers are protected by Israeli police and by the IDF and armed by them. And it gets worse and worse as many colleagues have pointed out. The idea of a contiguous Palestinian state disappears if E1 is settled in the way the E1 plan proposes.
But that's not the end of it. We now have Israel occupying a very large part of southern Lebanon, or Israeli forces doing so, and basically they feel, look to me as though they're there to stay. They've every intention of remaining there. And Israel is also taking part in the wholly illegal bombardment of Iran alongside President Trump. So isn't it time that we were a bit stronger and a bit more assertive against the wholly illegal acts?
What I do recognize is that the government has made it very clear that it recognizes international law, it recognizes the international legal instruments, and it expects every other country to do the same. Good, that also therefore applies to Israel. The Foreign Secretary, when he made the statement, very interestingly acknowledged the role that public opinion in Britain has taken in bringing about this change in policy. And I have been on a very large number of marches in respect of Palestine, and there are probably about a million people in Britain that have made their views very clearly known, either by attending a demonstration, sending letters, emails, petitions, all sorts of things. They've made their opinions very clearly known.
And the marches are made up of large numbers of people, some of whom have never been involved in anything political before at all. They come from a very wide range of society and they are many people. They're Jewish, they're Muslim, they're Christian, they're Hindu, they're Buddhist, they're atheist, they're humanist. They're a whole range of people. And it's very, very clear that we will not allow any of those marches to descend in any kind of racist hate speech of any sort.
These are marches of support and solidarity with people who are victims of the most atrocious bombardment that's going on. And I thank all those people that have come along and made their voices very well known. They're all people there. So in accepting the process of international law, I think it's important that the government goes a bit further. I attended the ICJ hearing for the South African application.
It was a deeply moving experience actually, sitting there in the Palace of Peace in the Hague.
It's a beautiful building, stunning. And listening to the South African application, and my mind went back to the apartheid years. My mind went back to all the demonstrations and so on to try and bring about an end to apartheid, and the bravery and the suffering of the South African people in trying to throw off the yoke of apartheid. I thought, how brave of South Africa to do that. How brave of South Africa to present that case.
And what's their reward? Extra tariffs by President Trump, extra attacks by President Trump. And then later I was in South Africa with my good friend Dr. Mustafa Barghouti, addressing a meeting in Cape Town about Palestine.
And an elderly man who had been part of the anti-apartheid struggle in South Africa, had been very badly beaten and treated by the South African army and police force whilst he was campaigning to end the apartheid in his country. He said, and he got up and spoke, and he said, the treatment of the people of Palestine is far worse than anything that happened to the black community in South Africa. They didn't carpet bomb cities and villages in the way that the Israeli forces do at the present time. So if we respect international law, then arrest warrants issued by the ICC for a number of individuals in the Israeli government must be enforced should they pitch up in this country.
And as my friend from Blackman pointed out in his intervention earlier, and my friend from Perry Barr asserted this point as well, if the ICJ considers that acts of genocide could be committed, that's their opinion, it's a very important opinion, then anyone that provides arms to continue the support for those acts of genocide themselves become complicit in genocide. And I hope that the government will understand the dangers of all of this. And so I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we will be very assertive about what the settlers and the settlements are doing.
We will bring in real sanctions against Israel, but also recognize that whilst the Israeli body politic, the all the major parties essentially support the strategy being pursued by Netanyahu, maybe in mildly different forms, but fundamentally they're of the same mind. There are also people in Israel who do absolutely oppose what their government is doing and absolutely detest the way in which the Palestinian people are being treated. But are we to be silent bystanders while these ghastly acts of genocide go on, denying people food and denying people decent medical facilities? As other members have pointed out, Britain's role in all of this is not one of a recent arriviste on the scene.
Britain's been involved since the 19th century in the issue of settlements, in the issue of preventing Palestinian people asserting their statehood, obviously involved in the Balfour Declaration and the secret Sykes-Picot agreement. And so I think for historical reasons, for moral reasons and for all other reasons of courage, we should be far clearer in what our role is in all of this about bringing peace and justice to all of the peoples of the region and oppose racism in absolutely any form within our society in this country or anywhere else. The last thing I want to say because I'm conscious other colleagues wish to wish to speak is that I tried to introduce, I did introduce a ten-minute rule bill calling for a public inquiry into Britain's policy in Gaza in the same way that there was the Franks report into previous conflicts, in the same way that Sir John Chilcot was appointed to undertake an inquiry into Britain's policy in Iraq. I think we need to know what was going on in the Foreign Office and the Ministry of Defence, what was happening at RAF Akrotiri and other places.
And so when it became clear to me that this bill wasn't going to make any progress in the House, we put together a tribunal. I was part of it, along with Professor Neve Gordon and Dr Shahad Hamouri, and we held a Gaza inquiry over two days in Church House in Westminster. 29 expert witnesses. It was a deeply moving occasion, listening to young people from Gaza explaining what their life had been like, listening to medical practitioners talking about the horror of everything they'd been taught they couldn't do.
They've inflicted pain on people in order to try to prevent further pain, amputating the limbs of children without anesthetic, antiseptic, or even water to undertake the operation properly. And all the heroic, heroic works that they did. And then thinking only a few kilometers away from where they were trying to operate in these ghastly conditions under a piece of canvas, there was food, there was water, there was electricity, there was medicines, antiseptics, everything that's needed, deliberately denied to the Palestinian people by the IDF. And aid workers killed. And as an interventionist pointed out earlier, the aid that's limitedly getting in is deliberately designed to prevent there being a sustainable way of life in Gaza.
You can import some foodstuffs, but you can't import tuber tomato, tomatoes and seed in order to develop agriculture for the future.
Our Gaza inquiry pointed out the levels of depravity of what's gone on, and I thank all those people that took part in it. But I want there to be a proper public inquiry so we know what those surveillance flights were doing. And when the former Prime Minister Keir Starmer pointed out there are things going on at RAF Akrotiri he's not able to talk about, I think it's time somebody did talk about it and did talk about what's actually going on there. We need to know the truth. The truth will help to set us free.
The truth will help to bring about, I believe, what's essential, which is peace and justice for the people of Palestine.
Peter Richard Prinsley
After the next speaker, I will have to impose a speaking limit to get the remaining ten people in in the next hour that we have. So please be mindful of the speeches if you're having to correct them. Dr. Peter Prinsley.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's an honour to speak in this debate.
There have been endless debates about this subject since I've come here as a Member of Parliament. So what can be done in Israel-Palestine so that all its inhabitants may live in peace and tranquility with none to make them afraid? These are the lines of the sacred prayer for peace which we say in our synagogues every Shabbat. We have prayed in vain for what seems like an eternity, and here in Parliament we have endlessly debated this. Since the dreadful attacks of October 7th, the seizing of hostages and the mass destruction in Gaza, there have been countless debates and questions to ministers.
The government recognized the state of Palestine last year, fulfilling a manifesto commitment.
This was controversial at the time, when there were still hostages, but I supported this. For a formal recognition of a Palestinian state, separate from a secure Israel, is the two-state solution we all know must come, and represented the repudiation of Hamas and its sinister refrain from the river to the sea. So now we have a fresh package of sanctions, internationally coordinated. The need to act at a time when we see increasing settler violence and so little progress in Gaza seemed urgent, and that is the view, I am sure, of our new Foreign Secretary, for whom I have the greatest respect. However, I worry about the timing of this announcement, for the Knesset is dissolved and there is an election in Israel.
I fear that the attitude of the Netanyahu government will simply harden. And I fear that the electorate may swing behind Netanyahu as a reaction. This is the very last thing we want, since what I'd like to see is surely what many honourable members like to see: a new government in Israel with a completely new approach. We have this weekend celebrated the Jewish New Year, Rosh Hashanah, for 5787. I wish all members a happy and peaceful New Year.
Next Monday is Yom Kippur, a holy day of repentance. Let us politicians pray for progress and pray for peace.
John Richard Foord
A limit of six minutes, Richard Foord.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week's statement from the Foreign Secretary marks a significant moment in British policy on Israel and Palestine, and I congratulate the ministers on the front bench for these changes. For years, the Liberal Democrats have argued that simply declaring the West Bank settlements illegal while otherwise continuing business as usual was not enough. And the government appears to have conceded that words need to be matched with actions. The government agrees that it has just gone on for long enough and has recognized the occupation as unlawful.
It has recognized that a ban on imports is necessary and it has recognized that further sanctions on extremist settlers are required. These are positive steps.
But the reality in the region today remains bleak. Benjamin Netanyahu and his cabinet have rejected proposals for peace and have declared that a Palestinian state will not be recognized while he remains Prime Minister. And at the same time, Hamas remains a terrorist organization that has shown no convincing evidence that there is any reality there that it will disarm or dismantle itself. And this is a transnational actor. This is a transnational threat.
Indeed, we saw that just last week with the arrest of seven suspected Hamas members in Germany as part of a terror plot. On the ground in Israel and Palestine, the prospects for a two-state solution are being systematically undermined. And the Foreign Affairs Committee saw this when we visited last year.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of the FCDO is in her place. She saw, as I did, when we visited the Jordan Valley, how escalating settler violence was meaning villages were subjected to intimidation. And now with the announcement of the E1 settlement, there are blatant attempts to make a viable and contiguous Palestinian state impossible. There's been some debate so far this afternoon about the timing of the government's announcement. A suggestion that somehow that might be meddling in the affairs of Israel as it approaches the Israeli election.
I have to disagree with the honorable member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, though.
If if the government is convinced that more sanctions are required, then it has a responsibility to introduce them as soon as it makes that determination, not to wait the internal democratic electoral affairs of of the Israeli state. And indeed to have delayed would have been the interference in the domestic affairs of Israel. I welcome the fact that the government has finally acted. I welcome that the Foreign Secretary and the Prime Minister have acknowledged that the previous administration did not go far enough. And I welcome the decision to ban settlement goods connected to settlement expansion.
But I would call for the government to go further and adopt a ban on all services and all services trade with the with these settlements, just as the the Dutch government has done. If these settlements are unlawful, then the financial and commercial structures that sustain them should enjoy no benefit from trade with the UK.
Sanctions are a similar story. The government has recently sanctioned extremist figures like National Security Minister Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Smotrich, who have repeatedly demonstrated their disdain not just for a Palestinian state, but for the Palestinian people themselves. These sanctions should be extended to all members of the cabinet who are complicit in illegal settlement expansion, forced displacement, and the ongoing erosion of a Palestinian state, and that includes Netanyahu himself. Accountability can't rest just with the most extremist of members of the security cabinet if others are enabling the same agenda.
The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights has said that Israel's forced displacement of more than 33,000 Palestinians in the West Bank could amount to crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing, the largest and longest displacement crisis since 1967. And meanwhile in Gaza, the scale of death and destruction has shocked the conscience of the world. And the government says that there is increasing evidence that war crimes may have been committed and supports the ICJ in reaching its determination in relation to genocide. And I do understand that the government desires to defer to a competent court, but I note that it took nine years between atrocities carried out against the Yazidi people in 2014 and the recognition by the British government in 2023 that Daesh had committed a genocide.
Hamas remains a terrorist organisation and there can be no future peace while armed groups backed by Iran retain the capacity to threaten Israeli civilians and sabotage any political settlement. Their disarmament and their disbandment must be part of any lasting solution.
Speaker 192
I thank the member for giving way. On the issue of disarmament, right, should we not be also calling for Israel's disarmament as well, given the atrocities that have been committed? Previous governments have intervened in the Middle East to take action to save human rights abuses and protect international trade routes. Isn't it about time that military action is taken against Israel also?
John Richard Foord
Grateful for the intervention.
The peace plan of course requires that the IDF pulls back from Gaza just as Hamas disarms. So I do see the onus on the IDF to pull back just as Hamas must disarm. Hamas, as far as this state is concerned, is a terrorist organisation, and I don't draw any equivalence between the state of Israel, internationally recognised, and Hamas as a proscribed terrorist organisation. So yes, last week's shift in British government policy represents a welcome change in direction. It is a break from years of denial, years of hesitation and years of inaction.
Yet the British government has further to go. It has further to go before Britain is fully matching its commitment to international law, accountability and the two-state solution that remains the path to a just and lasting peace for Israelis and Palestinians. Thank you.
Joseph Simon Opher
Dr Simon Opher.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My remarks today will focus on the murder of healthcare workers in Palestine and also the tremendous work of Jewish-led organisations that campaign against the illegal occupation. There's one moment which will always stick with me over the last two and a half years as an MP. On June the 24th, 2025, I was making my way to the chamber for oral questions and I received a phone call from my colleague Dr. Rebecca Inglis of Healthcare Workers Watch. She told me a GP, like myself, but who worked in Gaza, had just been shot in the head by an Israeli soldier.
More than 2,000 healthcare workers and 595 humanitarian aid workers have been murdered at the hands of the Israeli army.
And 95 Palestinian healthcare workers remain detained by Israeli authorities, subject to the most inhumane conditions and reported torture. And despite even the ceasefire, this goes on. And in fact, a UN commission found that the Israeli state had committed the crime of genocide through deliberately targeting of the Gaza healthcare system. And to be honest, this is not restricted to Gaza. It took place in Syria and in Sudan as well.
It has also got a new name called healthicide, and this British government must fight against it. In Gaza, over 90% of the healthcare infrastructure of the Gaza Strip has either been destroyed or damaged. There's been cables just cut to stop people in Gaza getting proper healthcare. I've heard directly from British doctors in the area who have witnessed the deliberate destruction of medical equipment in front of their own eyes.
And this healthicide extends to the West Bank as well. And indeed, myself and my colleague, the right honourable member for Bury St Edmunds, were denied access when we tried to look at the healthcare facilities in the West Bank approximately a year ago. The Israelis have withheld billions of dollars of tax revenue from the Palestinian Authority, and that means that healthcare workers are not being paid. They sometimes haven't been paid for the last six months. And so healthcare workers are cutting their hours and clinics have had to close.
And in fact, I found out today from the Medical Aid for Palestine that healthcare workers have to wear bulletproof vests when they go outside because they are being targeted by Israeli forces. Medical staff are regularly harassed, ambulance movements are restricted, and checkpoints delays are costing lives when every minute matters in medical emergencies. And indeed, this is getting worse.
The WHO said that in June of this year, there were eight attacks on healthcare workers, and in July, there were 37 attacks. And also in July, a four-month-old Palestinian boy died after Israeli forces at a military checkpoint west of Ramallah prevented his transfer to a hospital. So, I agree with our Prime Minister. Our party's rhetoric and our government's actions have been totally inadequate in response to these atrocities. But we are now beginning to right this wrong.
We have a Foreign Secretary who has restored dignity and credibility in this chamber. And we have a government that is finally acknowledging that war crimes have been committed and that the occupation is illegal, backed up by meaningful action. A government that will stand up and not stand by. It's long overdue and we must go further, but it's such a welcome change.
So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to end my speech on a positive note. Amidst all the horror of the last few years, there have been people who have refused to give up on the possibility of peace. I want to pay tribute to two brilliant Jewish-led organisations, Standing Together and Na'amod. So Standing Together brings Jewish and Palestinian citizens of Israel together around a simple belief that the future of one people cannot be built on the destruction of another. And here in Britain, Na'amod have shown extraordinary moral courage.
They're a movement of British Jews campaigning against the occupation for the freedom and dignity of Palestinians. And in fact, two hours ago, I was particularly proud to be hosting them here in Parliament.
So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, I am glad that our government will no longer be bystanders, but we must be bolder and move faster. We must use every lever possible to help bring this illegal occupation to an end, because history will judge us on whether we did enough when it really mattered. Thank you.
Speaker 226
Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to start by congratulating the latest iteration of the Labour government for finally growing a backbone and doing what anybody with a moral conscience would and should have done years ago, because while I genuinely welcome the statement and the sanctions that were announced last week, I really do.
I think it is crucial that we remember that this is not the end goal and that we do not lose sight of just how long Israel has been conducting violence and terror against the Palestinian people and for how long the UK government has known in detail and failed to do anything about it. Because it was 25 years ago that Israel constructed a wall in the occupied West Bank barricading Palestinians in, separating families, denying them access to their land and enforcing a regime of illegal annexation and apartheid, treating an entire population like they were animals. The UK government knew this and did nothing. It was 22 years ago that the ICJ confirmed that the construction of that wall was an unlawful use of force and violated international law. At the time, the UK government accepted that and still did nothing.
It was 20 years ago that the UK government accepted that Israel was systematically abusing human rights in Palestine. It was a Labour government at the time, and yet no action was taken because there was no political will to do it. For decades, the UK government, successive UK governments, have known in detail the level of harm that Palestinians have suffered at the hands of the Israeli government: arbitrary detention, torture, burning farms and farmland, killing children, destroying entire villages.
Members of Parliament from across this House have gone to the West Bank and seen it with their own eyes, and yet no action has been taken. There have been debates, there have been statements of condemnation, and yet thousands of Palestinians have been killed, thousands of homes have been destroyed, and thousands of children will grow up without their parents because the UK government had no political incentive to act. I want to thank the honorable member of Glasgow West for raising the death, the murder of Odeh Hafalin, who was killed a year ago, murdered a year ago by an Israeli settler in the village of Umm al-Khair. Odeh was a friend of mine, I knew him well, and I grieve his murder every single day.
But Aude was known to this house because in 2024 he visited Westminster. He spoke to parliamentarians. He visited government officials in the FCDO and he detailed the horror that it was to live under illegal occupation in the West Bank. And he asked the UK government to act and at the time they did not. So just think how many Palestinian lives could have been spared if the UK government 25 years ago had acted on the information and the facts that were in front of them.
How many Israeli lives could have been spared?
Now, I might be new to this House, but I have watched every single debate in this place on Palestine and Israel, not just for the last three years since the genocide, but for years before that. And I'm not going to make any friends when I say this, but I am so disappointed at how few members across the House have raised their head above the parapet to condemn the UK government's continued support of Israel, and how so many members are doing so now just because it is politically convenient for them to do so. So I genuinely welcome the statement given by the government last week, and I genuinely hope that this causes a change, that this saves Palestinian lives. But I cannot forgive, and there are so many others who will never forget, just how long it has taken the UK government to finally do the right thing.
Helen Hayes.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
I've had the privilege of visiting the West Bank on two occasions on visits organized by Caabu and by Yachad, and I put on record my interests in respect of both of those visits. On the second occasion, I also visited some of the kibbutz communities in the south of Israel, which suffered horrific losses in the atrocity committed by Hamas on the 7th of October 2023. These were extraordinary conversations with people who had lost their loved ones, who had suffered the most horrific violence in their communities, who had been and continued to be long-term peace campaigners, and who were still committed to working for peace.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
They included Maoz Inon, who has written so movingly with his Palestinian friend Aziz Abu Sarah about their hopes for peace in his book, The Future is Peace, and I commend that book to the House. That visit was extraordinarily humbling. In the West Bank, we visited communities that had been the subject of settler terrorism. In Turmus Ayya, we met Palestinians whose homes had been burned, who faced constant harassment, intimidation, and threats from settlers. In the village of Zanuta near Hebron, we spoke with members of a 250-strong community who had been threatened that if they did not leave, they would be killed.
A month after they left, the settlers came and destroyed the whole village, including a council building funded by the EU and UK government.
We stood in the ruins of two schools, again funded by the EU and UK governments, completely razed to the ground by settlers. And we saw the decades-long desolation in Hebron where Palestinians have been banned from their homes. We also saw settlement after settlement after settlement, new homes and communities built on land from which Palestinians have been displaced. It is impossible to avoid the conclusion that this activity is, as the Foreign Secretary said last week, ethnic cleansing, and that it is strategically designed to undermine the possibility of a two-state solution.
The E1 settlement takes this even further, aiming to divide the West Bank from the south and to divide the West Bank north from south and sever it from East Jerusalem. As a former town planner, I can say it is simply the use of the planning system as a tool of oppression, an attempt to make a two-state solution an impossibility. I welcome the decision of the government to recognise the state of Palestine. There cannot be a two-state solution without two states. But it has been a source of frustration and deep regret that it has taken so long to see action to stop funding from the UK through trade from supporting and sustaining illegal settlements.
Clarity on human rights and international law is in everyone's interests and words must be backed up by meaningful action.
I welcome the ban on trade in goods and services from illegal settlements, and I welcome the government's confirmation that it agrees with the International Court of Justice that Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is unlawful. I welcome the Foreign Secretary's moral clarity on the utter horror of the situation in Gaza, where the scale of death and destruction is unimaginable and people are living in utterly desperate circumstances. And the Minister on the front bench this evening has rightly described this as a moral catastrophe. As the government has announced meaningful action, can I press the Minister on the urgency of the humanitarian situation in Gaza?
The Israeli government must allow essential items such as prosthetic limbs, crutches and wheelchairs into Gaza, as well as permitting more medical specialists to enter Gaza to meet the needs of the population there, and the Israeli government must stop the killing. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, can the Minister confirm which of the measures announced in recent days requires legislation and confirm that the government will take all measures possible to ensure that legislation is delivered as quickly as possible? The situation in Israel and Palestine is so far away from a peaceful two-state solution, and progress towards it will require sustained effort over a long period of time. So can my honourable friend assure this House that he will leave no stone unturned in maintaining the clarity of the government's position and ensuring that the position is always supported by meaningful action that furthers the cause of peace and the imperatives of justice and accountability?
Lindsay Hoyle
Right, just before we go to the next part, I want to announce the results of the select committee elections that were held earlier today. In the Housing Committee and Local Government Committee election, 463 votes were cast, of which three were invalid. There were 406 valid votes in the fifth round, excluding those ballot papers whose preference had been exhausted. The quota to be reached therefore was 204 votes. I can announce Abena Oppong-Asare was elected with 242 votes.
In the Justice Committee election, 462 votes were cast, seven of which were invalid. There was a single round of counting with 455 valid votes.
The quota to be reached therefore was 228. I can now announce that Catherine Atkinson was elected chair with 250 votes. In the Women's and Equalities Committee election, 463 votes were cast, of which three were invalid. There was 421 valid votes in the second round, the quota to be reached was therefore 211. I can announce that Olivia Blake was elected with 213 votes.
All three chairs will take up their post immediately. I congratulate them on their election and thank all of those who stood. And I'd like to thank the staff of the House who've worked on this election.
The results of the counts were under the alternative vote system and will be made available as soon as possible in the Vote Office and on the internet. We now go back to the business. Dr. Ellie Chowns.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to use this debate to do two things. First, to reiterate that international law and human rights are absolutely critical. And secondly, to reflect on the responsibilities that they impose on the UK and on our wider responsibilities as parliamentarians and indeed as citizens. International law and human rights frameworks are vital guiding principles.
The terrorist atrocities of October the 7th were a clear and obscene violation of these principles. Every single person responsible for these horrors must be held to account.
And every life taken, every life damaged, must never be forgotten. Equally, the collective punishment of the people of Gaza is also a clear and obscene violation of international law and breaches basic human rights. We've seen mass atrocities, displacement, deliberate starvation, indiscriminate bombing of hospitals, withholding access to water, medical supplies, targeting of journalists and aid convoys. We must call what has been happening in Gaza what it is: genocide. And in the occupied West Bank too, the violent expansion of illegal settlements, ethnic cleansing, the execution of children, detention without trial, people forced to live under apartheid, settler terrorism.
All of this has been happening for decades, worse since October the 7th and with Prime Minister Netanyahu emboldened by the current US President.
Now political leaders have largely fallen short when it comes to holding the Israeli government to account for their human rights crimes and their flagrant disregard for international law. But political leaders come and go, and meanwhile the international courts get on with their work, upholding the standards and the UN resolutions that the world has collectively agreed to. We need political leadership and we need it to be guided by international law and human rights frameworks. So it was hugely welcome to hear the Secretary of State last week recognize the 2024 ICJ conclusion that the occupation of Palestine is illegal, that he reiterated the illegality of expansionist settlements, and that he took the important, the vital first step of banning trade with and advertising of those illegal settlements, their illegality absolutely clear under international law.
The UK has done the right thing in recognizing the role of international law and human rights standards and starting to act accordingly. But genuine respect for international law and human rights means you can't pick and choose. Suspending the licenses of some arms used by the IDF in Gaza and the licensing of other arms and exports that materially contribute to the occupation makes a difference. But the double lock that the government has announced does not include components for the F-35 combat aircraft, which according to Campaign Against the Arms Trade is the most substantive part of the UK's arms trade with Israel. It cannot be beyond the wit of officialdom to find a way of tracing these parts so that they are not used to ensure that the UK remains complicit in Israel's genocide and war crimes until it ends its role in supporting Israeli force.
So I urge the UK government to be consistent in its commitment to the legal and human rights frameworks that underpin its recent decisions. I welcome the steps it has taken. They're too little, too late, and there is so much more to be done. But secondly, I want to reflect on the wider responsibilities that we all have, especially as parliamentarians. In the context of rising hate crime and growing divisions in our communities, we each have a responsibility to show leadership, to stand against antisemitism, to stand against Islamophobia, to not conflate criticism of the Israeli government with antisemitism and to call it out when we see others doing this, to not hold the Jewish people responsible for the actions of the Israeli authorities or the ideologies that drive them, to not hold Palestinians responsible for the actions of Hamas.
We have a responsibility to recognize the many ways in which those who advocate for Palestine are defamed, often as antisemitic, as a way to shut down or silence their advocacy. And the damage this does by distracting from critical work identifying and confronting antisemitism, which is so crucial at a time when attacks on Jewish communities and Jewish spaces in this country and around the world are increasing. We have a responsibility to recognize anti-Palestinian racism and the multiple ways it manifests in our politics and our society. A responsibility to stop putting people in boxes, stop defining them as either allies or enemies with nothing in between. A responsibility to resist the whipping up of hatred and the way in which nuanced understanding and compassion are being bludgeoned to extinction in public discourse.
All of us need to show leadership in our dialogue, in our constituencies, communities, our own parties, and demonstrate in our words and our deeds that there is no competition, no contradiction between supporting and defending Palestinian human rights and supporting and defending thriving Jewish communities here in our country. I'm making these points in this debate because the response to what's happening in Palestine and Israel is being used by some political actors here in the UK to whip up antisemitism, by some political actors to advance anti-migrant and anti-Muslim agendas, by some to justify chilling restrictions on civil liberties, our rights to free speech and to peacefully protest, and by some to stoke division between minoritised communities. Leadership requires being alive to these realities and risks, to recognise how they might prevent the emergence of shared visions of justice, democracy, human rights and religious and political pluralism.
And this underscores the importance of defending and upholding the international legal and human rights frameworks we already have, fully and wholeheartedly. Madam Deputy Speaker, 25 years ago I took up a job coordinating the UK arm of the Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme in Palestine and Israel, an atheist working for a Christian organisation with Jewish, Muslim and Palestinian and Christian communities in the lands of Israel and Palestine to build peace. The spirit of working across boundaries is the only thing that will get us to peace and justice.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Order, order, because of the interlude backbenchers are now on five-minute speaking limit, Jane Caton.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government's decision last week to ban trade with illegal Israeli settlements, strengthen sanctions and state clearly Israel's ongoing occupation of Palestinian territory is unlawful was very welcome.
The humanitarian situation in Gaza remains appalling. There have been over 1,303 fatalities and 4,336 injuries in Gaza since the ceasefire began in October 25, with children most affected. Two-thirds of the population still face critical and emergency levels of hunger, according to the World Food Programme, and the water situation is catastrophic, with Gazans dependent on water trucks normally reserved for the immediate aftermath of a crisis. Although now more aid is getting in, for a long time this was not the case, with Israel restricting those life-saving supplies, leading to famine, a man-made famine, being declared in August 2025 by the IPC's Famine Review Committee.
Additionally, Gaza has been for the past three years the deadliest place on earth to be a humanitarian, making up over half the humanitarian deaths around the world. And it's in this context that my constituent James, Jim Henderson, was providing vital security support for World Central Kitchen in Gaza in 2024. A former Royal Marine, his family say he was passionate about doing good and showing up for people in dire need thousands of miles from home. On the 1st of April 2024, Jim, along with six colleagues, was travelling in a clearly marked World Central Kitchen convoy on a road identified as accessible for humanitarian aid, transporting food to the north of the Gaza Strip, close to the famine.
The convoy was subject to an IDF drone attack and all seven humanitarian workers were killed. I welcome the steps the government has taken to secure accountability since the attack, including pressing the Israeli ambassador for an investigation. And I know the former Prime Minister, Middle East Minister and Foreign Secretary met with the Henderson family. So I was very disappointed to hear on the 19th of August that Israel would not be launching a criminal investigation into the attack. The joint statement by the governments of the UK, Australia and Canada condemning the situation as shameful was the exactly the right thing to do, and I strongly believe further action must be taken.
Rather than demonstrating remorse, the commanding officer, Colonel Mendel, has reportedly sought to justify the strikes and says he doesn't regret the order that he made. The IDF has maintained it believed Hamas had taken control of the WCK convoy after it deviated allegedly from an approved route.
However, World Central Kitchen has strongly disputed this account, stating the IDF was fully aware of the convoy's movements, activities, and purpose. An independent investigation into the WCK killings remains essential to establish the full facts of what occurred and deliver justice for the victims and their families. Confidence in the integrity of any investigation obviously depends on it being independent and transparent. There's one point that I and the family would like the Minister's confirmation of. There have been persistent rumors that there were RAF planes flying that day and that they passed intelligence on the convoy to the IDF.
Could the Minister please reconfirm that that wasn't the case? What happened to Jim and the other brave humanitarian workers should never have happened. Aid workers play a critical role in saving lives in conflict zones and must be able to carry out their work safely and without fear of being targeted.
I was pleased to hear the Middle East Minister agree earlier that those responsible for those deaths must be held to account. The international community must send a clear message that attacks on humanitarian personnel by the IDF cannot go without justice.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker. During his statement to the House last week, the Foreign Secretary said that we'll never have stability in the Middle East without a two-state solution.
This line touched me as when I was invited to go on a visit to Israel and Palestine more than a decade ago, the very same words were used to explain why the visit was so important and why understanding the relationship between the two places and the fears and threats they both faced was important to see. On my visit way back then, I saw the withholding of water from Rawabi, settlers encroaching on the hillsides of the West Bank, the way families whose children had played together were gradually pulled in different directions as the time came towards national service, the difference in the day-to-day lives between the people of Ramallah and Tel Aviv, and the tension between the two populations. And like every schoolchild in that country, I visited Yad Vashem and I learned about the horrors that came before the Holocaust, the dehumanising of Jewish people in Europe and how antisemitism can manifest itself in the most unusual ways. What I saw will never leave me, but it did leave me convinced that a two-state solution is the only way. Fast forward to 2023 and the horror of the atrocities inflicted on the people of Israel by Hamas.
Every person who took part in the murder, torture and kidnapping of people on kibbutz, at the music festival or simply going about their lives must be held to account. But the pain of the Israeli people and the Jewish diaspora, which cannot be underestimated, does not justify what followed in the following two years. The killing of 20,000 children, 70,000 people, the destruction of everything that is Gaza. And what happened since the official ceasefire, with the continued attacks, the violence and intimidation in the West Bank, the attempt to take more land cannot be ignored and we must not turn a blind eye as President, as Prime Minister Netanyahu attempts to destroy Gaza. This is why I was pleased that the UK recognized the state of Palestine and why I'm relieved that the Foreign Secretary has taken further measures to show the UK is prepared to stand up for what most of my residents believe.
But I know that this does cause nervousness in some parts of our community, and I recognize that people are worried that this suggests UK is no longer a friend of Israel.
And to this I say, when a friend is attacking their neighbor, when they are stealing their land, and when they are hurting their children, a friend holds them to account. But we must make sure that our Jewish communities here and the Jewish people in Israel who do not support this are not blamed for what this government is doing to them. I know some residents want us to go even further and I hear their calls, but for now, I believe the government is close to getting the balance right, but we need to keep that in a fluid situation. And I hope for reassurance that if the government in Israel continues and they do not hear the changes that we and countries like Canada and France are calling for, that we will keep everything on the table. And importantly, that as we head towards winter, that the children in Gaza are protected from famine, from the cold, we must not go quiet on the humanitarian front.
But the one area I struggle to reconcile, and I'm surprised I'm the only person to have mentioned it, I raise on behalf of my constituents who've been caught up with it, and that's proscription. Now, I'm not sure what my parliamentary privilege allows me to say, so I'm going to choose my words extremely carefully. But I cannot be the only honourable member that struggles to see masked people intimidating our towns and abusing our rescue crews being treated as activists, when elderly or silently seated people holding placards that name a group find themselves not only arrested but treated as terrorists. I should stress I absolutely condemn the breaking and entering of property, criminal damage and all other offences, but they are already crimes.
And I know that protesters who insist on naming a proscribed group probably know the consequences, and that among those decent people hide cowards, racists and people who are just there for the thrill. But as we move forward in our position, I wonder if we should ask if this is still proportionate, particularly as some companies are starting to take action against people who are wearing badges for Palestine. They don't worry about my badge for Ukraine. So I just ask the question, should we be thinking about it being proportionate?
Madam Deputy Speaker, I do not apologize for those who break the law, but I do ask the government to reflect, and I am using my words carefully here, that given that the government have now recognized the state of Palestine and has taken action in support of Palestine, maybe it's time to review the prescription of the group wearing those exact same words but in a different order.
Brian William Leishman
Madam Deputy Speaker, like my honorable friend from Bradford West, I believe that historical context is essential when it comes to this debate because Britain has been an important participant in creating the situation Palestine and Israel are in. Because our country's role as the former colonial power in Palestine, issuing and implementing the Balfour Declaration of 1917 and presiding over the dispossession and disenfranchisement of the Palestinian people is an awful stain that has gotten deeper with the failure to stand up for the inalienable rights of Palestinians for the decades after the Balfour Declaration. Britain was an architect in establishing Israel, but over time the relationship has changed.
Britain and Israel have become a partnership. A partnership largely defined by imperialism, colonialism, and capitalism, and the oppression, apartheid, and poverty those traits have created. Cooperation between the British and Israeli governments goes beyond the "normal" relations most nations have. It was a year ago the then Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer welcomed the Israeli President Isaac Herzog to 10 Downing Street. The House should remember that President Herzog is the man who said an entire nation was responsible for the October attacks perpetrated by Hamas, and that the collective punishment of Palestinians was right.
President Herzog came to protest British positions including the at the time potential recognition of a Palestinian state and Britain supporting humanitarian efforts. The result of the meeting was not resounding condemnation of Herzog's abhorrent views, but instead stressing that Israel is a long-standing ally and how important our ongoing partnership with Israel is. The appeasement of the president of a state that carries out a genocide is a much more recent stain on our nation. The time for the UK to show international and moral leadership like we did last week was long overdue. I like many others in this place welcome the change in outlook from our new Prime Minister and our government with the Foreign Secretary's statement.
It was a real change, a massive step towards Israel being held to account for its blatant, flagrant, and repeated violations of international law. But it must just be the start. Our government must act much more quickly because Palestinians cannot wait six to nine months because they are still subject to human rights abuses because of Israeli state-sanctioned settler violence. The UK should not be financially facilitating this a day longer. So I say to the Minister that the UK government must target the infrastructure that funds, sustains, and supports Israel's unlawful occupation, impose measures on key entities including Israeli government ministries who are implicated in establishing, maintaining, and providing material support to illegal settlements and settlement infrastructure.
End any political, diplomatic, financial and military support that contributes to Israel's serious and systematic violations of international law. Suspend the UK-Israel Trade and Partnership Agreement and impose sanctions, targeted sanctions, including travel bans and asset freezes against Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel Katz, Itamar Ben-Gvir and all Israeli officials directly implicated in the ethnic cleansing and forcible transfer of Palestinians in the West Bank.
Madam Deputy Speaker, there is no doubt in my mind that we have witnessed a genocide take place. So the UK must now act swiftly in response by ending all political, diplomatic, financial and military support that contributes to Israel's ongoing genocide in Gaza, the sanctioning of Israeli officials most implicated in the commission of genocide and committing to execute ICC arrest warrants. And finally, support South Africa's genocide case against Israel at the ICJ, just as the UK has done in support of the Gambia versus Myanmar. To finish, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wish to reiterate that our government has done the right thing in shifting our position. But we must go further and quicker if we are to repay the historical debt that we owe the Palestinian people.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Stephen Jordan.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and for calling me last, I now owe the member for Alloa and Grangemouth a pint, so thanks very much. Yeah, you weren't to know, of course. Last week, the Foreign Secretary firmly committed the UK government to supporting the call for accountability for what has happened in Gaza and the West Bank. And it's on that matter that I wish to reflect, because last month, an Israeli prosecutor announced he would not pursue criminal proceedings for the murder of my constituent, John Chapman, an aid worker from Poole, who was killed by the IDF while working with World Central Kitchen in April 2024, already mentioned in this debate by my honourable friend for Truro and Falmouth.
The officer responsible for the strikes claimed the workers were identified as targets after a brief encounter with armed guards presumed to be from Hamas. This has been found to be a baseless accusation. The IDF operating a policy of guilt by association then attacked the aid convoy.
The IDF conceded that the murder of the aid workers was the result of an erroneous assessment that Hamas military operatives were present in the vehicles, but concluded that this did not give rise to a reasonable suspicion of a criminal offense. Madam Deputy Speaker, the IDF is getting away with murder of John and his six colleagues, including two other British citizens. This is an absolute disgrace. And the Minister said in his opening remarks that this will be for the courts to decide, but I think the IDF have got an effective get out of jail free card. The world we leave to our children is not set in stone, it's one our government and its allies help to shape.
Every action and every failure to act sets the boundaries of acceptability. What is tolerated and what is condoned. These choices mold norms, they establish red lines and decide whether the world becomes safer or more dangerous.
The Foreign Secretary's step last week was one such choice. It takes us closer to upholding human rights and democracy. But the killing of John and his colleagues cannot go without accountability, and I would welcome the government setting out the steps it will take to secure justice for John and his family. This is the very least they deserve. Because if international law is to be meaningful, then justice must prevail and someone must be held responsible.
Going forward, the government must set out a pathway to a comprehensive arms embargo with the state of Israel. These weapons are being used to commit war crimes.
That is clear. They are turned on aid workers like my constituent, including British citizens, and they are used recklessly without any accountability. Challenging this, Madam Deputy Speaker, is how we become a world leader for peace, and I urge the government to go further and faster to achieve this.
Lincoln Jopp
We now move on to the front benches and I call the Shadow Minister Lincoln Jopp.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I refer the House to my register of members' interests. I think we've had a good debate here this evening, and I would like to pick out a number of contributions. Apologies if you didn't make the list, if honorable members didn't make the list, but I'm slightly time-constrained.
The member for Bradford East called on the government to go further and to include F-35s in the sanctions program. The member for Melksham and Devizes gave us his personal experience as a kibbutznik. He has seen peaceful coexistence, and that should give us some hope. The member for Wirral West spoke incredibly powerfully and informedly and created a balance in our debate this evening. And I applaud his moral courage in doing so.
The member for Glasgow West quite rightly reminded us of the unspeakable actions of Hamas on October the 7th and expressed what I believe is a view held widely across the House regarding settlers and settler violence.
The member for Brigg and Immingham again brought personal experience to our debate, including visiting Gaza. The member for Bradford West spoke of the extraordinary danger faced by journalists and aid workers trying to do their work in Gaza. The member for Islington North ranged widely in his speech, and I was pleased to hear him refer to the unacceptability and absence of religious hate speech on the many marches that he has attended. The member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket quite rightly, in my view, put his contribution in the context of the elections in Israel. The member for Honiton and Sidmouth brought a healthy dose of reality and realism to our proceedings.
The member for North Herefordshire, whilst welcoming the government's recent moves, called on the government to go further and faster, as did many members across the house. And finally, the member for Mid Dorset and Poole chose her words incredibly carefully when she described the government's approach to being, quote, "close to getting the balance right." Naturally, this conflict holds interest to many people both inside this house and outside. We cannot forget the harm that both British Jews and Muslims have suffered because of this conflict, and no conflict in another part of the world should be allowed to feed hatred at home. The Conservative Party believes that settlements are not a help to a long-term peace.
We urge Israel not to take steps that could make a two-state solution more difficult and to use its legal system to clamp down on settler violence. I believe that across the House, there is a general consensus for a two-state solution that guarantees security and stability for both the Israeli and Palestinian people. However, His Majesty's opposition believes that in banning goods from Israeli settlements, the government is enacting a policy that it knows will not work. Just 13 weeks ago, two government ministers, the members for Lincoln and Rhondda and Ogmore, wrote to the chair of the Business and Trade Committee rejecting this very policy because the economies of Palestine and Israel are too interconnected. The fear is that the innocent Palestinians and Israelis will suffer as a result of it.
We must avoid performative actions and instead use what influence we have. Which is why the banning of goods leading to the closure of the British consulate is so unhelpful. Foreign policy cannot be detached from security policy and decisions. Israel is one of our most important intelligence partners and cooperation has helped protect British citizens from terrorist attack and hostile activity over many years. Indeed, we continue to share security concerns regarding Iranian activity and regional instability, making intelligence cooperation strategically important.
And whilst we welcome that the Israeli intelligence services have given us assurances that that information sharing will continue, the fact that it was put into question in the first place is troubling.
To finish, I have a number of questions for the Minister. It was revealed last week that the Prime Minister had not yet spoken to Prime Minister Netanyahu since taking office. If we aren't even talking to the Israelis at the most senior level, then how are we supposed to influence Israeli policy in the West Bank? The government cannot simultaneously say that it wants to influence Israel, but then weaken the channels through which it can do so. Can the Minister explain how a ban on trade with settlements would be implemented in practice, and whether the government has assessed claims that such a move could amount to a de facto boycott of Israel?
There is no way to stop the British flow of goods into settlements without banning trade with Israel more broadly.
Is this something that is under the Government's consideration? Finally, 25% of pharmaceuticals used in the UK are reportedly made in Israel. Has the Secretary of State braced himself for the potential retaliation, and what message does he give the British people who are worried about delays to essential medications? Given the track record of this House, this will quite rightly not be the last time we debate Israel and Palestine. My only hope is that when we do, we consider this in a similar tone to that which we have done so tonight.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Members who have contributed with speeches during a debate should make the effort to return to the chamber to hear the Shadow Minister and the Minister speak.
No doubt they'll be rushing their way in. I believe it's the minister's debut at the dispatch box. I wish the minister well. Minister Im-Kum-Ran.
Uma Kumaran
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank honorable and right honorable members from across the House for their heartfelt contributions in today's debate. And I pay tribute to cross-party calls for the actions this Labour government has taken.
I want to thank the honourable members for Isha Walton, Halesowen, Rugby, Ealing Southall, Middlesbrough and Thornaby East, Melksham and Devizes, apologies if I've mispronounced any of these, Wirral West, High Peak, Birmingham Perry Barr, Strangford, Brigg and Immingham, who also mentioned work of the father of the house, Glasgow West, Wolverhampton West, Islington North, Bradford East, Birmingham Hall Green, Stoke-on-Trent South, Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, Honiton and Sidmouth, Stroud, Dulwich and West Norwood, North Hertfordshire, North Herefordshire, apologies, Truro and Falmouth, Mid Dorset and North Poole, Alloa and Grangemouth, and the shadow minister, the honourable member for Spelthorne. I pay tribute to the Foreign Secretary for a deeply moving and powerful speech last week and for taking action. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Foreign Secretary's speech resonated with so many across the country. The history of his family and the power of his words and actions was felt by my constituents in Stratford and Bow.
And on a personal level, I felt profoundly the weight of his remarks and the action taken by the United Kingdom. Madam Deputy Speaker, as you have mentioned, these are my first remarks from the dispatch box, so I hope you'll allow me briefly to reflect on the poignance of this moment. The Foreign Secretary spoke of the sanctuary his family were given. My parents, like so many, were given sanctuary in Britain. It's why I was born in East London and that I stand here and have gone in one generation from the daughter of Tamil refugees who fled persecution and war to standing here as a minister in the Foreign Office is a testament to the United Kingdom.
As my honorable friend, Minister for the Middle East, said at the start of this debate, the United Kingdom is a country that stands up for the rule of law, freedom, and self-determination. But as the Foreign Secretary powerfully said last week, many of us feel a deep sense of shame about what has unfolded in Palestine under the eyes of the international community.
We also condemn the atrocities of October 7th and condemn the murderous terrorist actions of the vile Hamas terrorist group. Madam Deputy Speaker, members during this debate have rightly welcomed this government being stronger in standing up for what is right and bolder in the action that this government have taken. The situation in Palestine is a moral emergency. What the Israeli government have inflicted on the people of Gaza is a stain on the conscience of the world. The occupation is unlawful.
There is increasing evidence of war crimes and they appear to be committed. We're witnessing unprecedented violence, including settler terrorism and ethnic cleansing in the areas of the West Bank. It is for these reasons the British government have been bolder in the actions we have taken. Madam Deputy Speaker, I've listened carefully to the concerns that have been raised and I will try and respond to some of the key points.
And from the offset I'll address the meaningful remarks by my honourable friend, the member for Wirral West, on the importance of MPs not amplifying divisions and promoting understanding. Many members have focused on timing, how sanctions will work, concerns about rising antisemitism, on arms sales, and concerns about E1 expansion. So I'll take these in turn. On timing, there is an urgent need to respond to the deteriorating reality in Palestine. We've seen a sharp rise in settler violence, accelerating settlement expansion, and a persistent failure to hold those responsible for violence to account.
These recent developments threaten the viability and prospects for a lasting peace, security and prosperity for Israelis and Palestinians. Our immediate priority in our designations will be to prevent settlement expansion, including in E1. We've not done this alone.
We're acting alongside France, Canada, joining the Netherlands, Ireland, Belgium, Spain and Norway, which have either banned goods or are in the process of doing so. Many other countries, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Poland, Portugal and Sweden have pledged their support for further action. On implementation and if matters can be expedited. Madam Deputy Speaker, implementation will take six to nine months. This is a reasonable and necessary timeframe.
We're working intensively on implementation. Sanctions are powerful and technical. We must take the time necessary to ensure these measures are effective and enforceable. On legislative changes that may be needed, we're acting as swiftly as we can. But we're also taking more immediate steps.
As the Foreign Secretary announced last week, we've sanctioned a further group of extremist settlers who've supported or incited violence against Palestinian communities. We've expanded the existing global human rights sanctions regime, enabling swifter action against those involved in violations of international humanitarian law, whether in Gaza or anywhere else in the world. And at the UN General Assembly in New York later this month, we'll shine a harsh spotlight on what is happening and what must change. On genocide and arms export licenses, the UK has always supported full, robust, and fair judicial processes to consider allegations, with final determinations made by competent courts before the British government reach a conclusion. It is right that this issue has been brought before the ICJ, and I want to make clear that we support the court in coming to its determination.
I will briefly.
Andy McDonald
I'm very grateful to the Minister giving way. She's setting out the criteria around the crime of genocide. But will she accept that the duty actually bites when the risk of genocide is known, not at the determination of the legal processes? That's when the duty upon the United Kingdom is to act, and I welcome the steps that have been taken thus far.
Uma Kumaran
My honourable friend makes a valid point, and as I've said, the final determinations will be made by competent courts before the British government reach a conclusion. I'll carry on if I can. These measures are not a ban on travel, tourism, or visits to religious sites. British citizens will continue to be able to visit Jerusalem and religious sites in line with FCDO travel advice.
They are not a ban on religious expression. The measures force on, the measures focus on settlement-related economic activity, not on people because they're Israeli, Jewish or any particular nationality or faith. We continue to oppose the boycott, divestment and sanctions campaign and will provide religious, appropriate religious exemptions and will continue to listen to the British Jewish community and their concerns. On export licenses, on export licenses, apologies, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to address the question of arms sales that came up multiple times.
Britain has already suspended or refused over 80 export licenses used by the IDF in Gaza. On how the sanctions will work and when they will be lifted, which the honorable lady, the shadow minister, raised.
Through our new sanctions regime, we will ban the import of goods from illegal Israeli settlements, create new powers to act against individuals and companies that support, facilitate, or profit from illegal settlement activity. On when they will be lifted or when they may not be lifted, we will continue to address and assess the actions of any Israeli government in the future, whether in Gaza or in the West Bank. And the ban on such exports will remain in place for as long as the occupation persists, and the ban on advertising and promotion of land and property in illegal settlements. We're working intensively on these measures. Sanctions are a powerful and technical tool, and it's important we design them carefully so that they have the impact we intend.
It is designed specifically to target activity linked to illegal settlements, particularly that which underpins the expansion of settlements, while protecting legitimate trade between the UK and Green Line Israel. The enforcement of sanctions is a priority for government.
The Office of Trade Sanctions Implementation, HMRC and the National Crime Agency all have important roles in enforcement and implementation. We'll work closely across government to ensure in practical terms settlement postcodes will be identified and appropriate checks will be put in place to verify compliance. When breaches occur, the government has a range of civil and criminal powers available. These range from civil penalties to prosecution in the most serious cases, including powers to confiscate assets found to be in the proceeds of crime. Detailed guidance will be published alongside any future legislation.
But let me be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, companies that do not take sanctions compliance seriously will face real and full consequences. In response to concerns about antisemitism, and members have rightly raised concerns about rising antisemitism. These are concerns we take seriously. Antisemitism is a scourge and an evil. We must call it out at every turn.
In East London, where I represent, we're proud to have Jewish and Muslim communities living side by side, and long may that continue. Madam Deputy Speaker, the measures announced today are in response to the deteriorating reality in Palestine. We have seen, as we have heard today, rising settler terrorism, accelerating settlement expansion, and a persistent failure to hold those responsible for violence to account. The government must be able to disagree with the policies of the Israeli government, uphold international law, and act in relation to illegal settlements. But let me reiterate, as the Foreign Secretary and the Middle East Minister have said, holding British Jews responsible for the actions of the Israeli government is antisemitism, plain and simple.
On humanitarian support, members have rightly raised the appalling suffering that children are enduring in Gaza.
Last year, a cross-government task force supported 50 critically ill and injured children, together with their immediate families, to leave Gaza and receive specialist treatment in NHS hospitals across the UK. As confirmed in a written ministerial statement in June, the UK will resume this support this year for those identified as needing urgent medical care. This support gives children access to specialist treatment that is not currently available locally. We recognise that many of these children and their families have experienced lasting and profound trauma. The member for Esher and Walton raised this point and matters on humanitarian aid.
The Minister for the Middle East met with the World Food Programme. And she raised, the honourable lady raised questions on aid budget.
The Minister of State today has reaffirmed this Labour government's manifesto commitment to 0.7 of GDP when fiscal circumstances allow. To the children in Gaza, their safety and their well-being remain our highest priority. The United Kingdom also remains committed to supporting humanitarian assistance to Gaza where basic needs remain unmet. We continue to prioritize health, nutrition, water, sanitation and hygiene programs. This financial year we're providing 23.3 million to UNRWA, supporting healthcare, education, social services, emergency food assistance and shelter.
My honorable friend for Glasgow West and Dulwich and West Norwood raised deep concerns on supporting children and students. In May, we announced a new partnership to deliver rehabilitation and prosthetic limbs for children with blast injuries. We also continue to support UK-Med field hospitals in Gaza.
On the World Central Kitchen, which my honourable friend for Truro and Falmouth and Poole raised, this matter is deeply concerning and I pay tribute to their constituents who were killed. I know that the Foreign Secretary has committed to meeting with them and I thank them for continuing to be powerful advocates here. The Government pays tribute to James Kirby, James Henderson and John Chapman. Our thoughts remain with their families. For more than two years, we've pressed Israel to deliver the justice and accountability that the families deserve.
We have raised this with the Israeli authorities and will continue to push for answers. But I want to reassure my honourable friend and the family of her constituent that the rumours they have heard are simply not true. Madam Deputy Speaker, in addition, we're providing a further one million for mine action in Gaza this year, on top of four million last year.
Alongside this support, we'll continue to work with a growing alliance of countries led by Arab partners in the region to advance the 20-point peace plan and support practical efforts to secure a lasting peace. Last year, we supported over 100 students to exit Gaza and take up their places at top UK universities. This support is continuing with the first group of students arriving at the end of August and more planned over the coming weeks and months. Turning briefly to wider regional security. We recognize that events in Palestine are not happening in isolation.
Iran barbarically slaughters its own civilians. It continues to threaten Israel and Jewish communities around the world, and it continues to threaten and endanger people across the Middle East and here in the United Kingdom. Those consequences are felt far beyond the region, including here at home, through pressure on energy prices, food security, and household budgets.
We've already designated Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, and as the Foreign Secretary has made clear, we'll continue to target Iran's proxy groups. Iran must never be allowed to acquire a nuclear weapon. That's why, alongside our allies, we're reporting Iran to the UN Security Council for its nuclear violations. We're also reimposing major economic sanctions on Iran in line with the European Union and United States. On Yemen, the United Kingdom strongly condemns the Houthi decision to resume conflict in Yemen and in Saudi Arabia.
We offer our condolences to those injured and affected and stand with Saudi Arabia and the internationally recognized government of Yemen and regional partners. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me close by thanking members for a thoughtful and considered debate, as mentioned by the honorable gentleman shadow minister opposite.
I will make progress because Madam Deputy Speaker has already given me the look. And reiterating that the let me close by reiterating that the two-state solution, freedom, security and self-determination for both the Palestinian and Israeli people is the guiding principle of this government's policy. This is why we're taking action. We refuse to be bystanders to further suffering and to the destruction of a two-state solution. This government is not silent in the face of deep injustice, nor is it powerless.
The only route to security for both peoples is a safe and secure Israel and a safe and secure Palestine living side by side in peaceful coexistence. I have seen that cooperation is possible. I visited the West Bank and Jerusalem last year as the then member of the Foreign Affairs Committee. It was a young Israeli NGO worker who bravely led me to her friend, a Palestinian grandfather. His house had been demolished.
His her security was at risk for the very fact that she had led us to him.
But together, they spoke of their dreams for peace for both the Israeli and Palestinian people. It is that hope for peace and a hope of a two-state solution that we must keep alive.
Peter Richard Prinsley
The question is that this House has considered Israel and Palestine. As many that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it.
We now come to motion number seven relating to the Joint Committee on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill, Minister to move.
Peter Richard Prinsley
The question is as, colleagues, if they can show some patience, I'm on my feet. The question is as on the order paper, as many that opinion say aye. Many that opinion say aye. Contrary no.
The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Before we go on to the presentation of public petitions, if those on the front bench wish to shuffle over, and if colleagues wish to exit the chamber, they should do so swiftly and quietly. Petition, Rebecca Smith.
Rebecca Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Along with almost 1,700 signatures from a similar online petition, I present this petition of residents from across Plymouth, Plymstock and the rest of my South West Devon constituency about the ongoing closure of Mount Batten Beach and Peninsula. This important city beach, accessible by public transport and used by thousands, has been closed since the 10th of July 2024, when significantly high levels of asbestos fibers were discovered in the sand. Fencing has been erected around the entire area. Since then, over 140 local residents have attended a meeting to raise their concerns about what this closure means for the local community, including businesses located at the beach, and campaigners have continued speaking out about the need to find a way to reopen the beach for the future.
This petition is calling on Plymouth City Council and the government to do all it can to ensure that measures be taken to see this beach safely reopened and safeguarded for future generations, the fight continues.
Vikki Slade
Petition, Vicky Slade.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, the balance between nature, green space and the need for housing is a delicate one, and it is always really sad when people who wish to maintain open spaces between villages are described as NIMBYs when they are simply trying to maintain good mental health for their communities. Green belt was created to ensure that protected open land is of high quality between communities and serves a purpose, so to see new legislation erode that purpose and at the same time require local decision making to be eroded on sites coming forward at the same time as no relevant local plan is deeply concerning.
This led to local residents in Mid Dorset and North Poole to ask me to present their petition signed by over 900 local people to request that the House of Commons urge the government to uphold the purpose of green belt and demonstrate this by calling in and rejecting the planning application for 1200 homes on green belt between Merley and Bearwood. And the petitioners remain, etc.
Speaker 238
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
In the government's own consultation about the future of Leicester, nine out of ten people said they were against it. And now, with millions of pounds of taxpayers' money wasted so far, ministers are having to do a complete reworking of this whole chaotic, undemocratic process amid accusations of gerrymandering. And despite this, the Mayor of Leicester and the government want to press on regardless. But local people do not want this. And so I present this petition, which is part of a county-wide petition which has now gained 40,000 signatures.
I would like to thank everybody who has signed it, and we are making progress.
So, the petition of the residents of the constituency of Harborough, Oadby and Wigston states that the petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to halt and reconsider any proposals for expansion of Leicester City Council's boundaries and to ensure that the views of local residents are fully considered before any changes are implemented, thereby protecting the character, identity and independence of the aforementioned communities. And I agree.
Speaker 240
Petition: Proposed Leicester City Council boundary expansions. If you're ready, petition Alicia Kearns.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This petition calls on the government to abandon its plans to force local government reorganization designed by the cities of Lincoln and Leicester across our rural communities in Rutland, Stamford and the Harborough and Stamford villages.
In every single proposal, the government is imposing the least popular option on our communities. And that is why in the last few weeks, 1,326 residents have signed with their handwritten signature on top of 7,247 online as part of 40,000 people across Leicestershire. So therefore, 8,573 people are rejecting the government's plans for our communities. So, the 1,326 petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to take into account the concerns of the petitioners and to reject the proposals for local government reorganization being imposed on us.
Speaker 240
Local government reorganization in Leicestershire, Rutland and Lincolnshire.
Petition.
Peter Richard Prinsley
The question is and this that this House do now adjourn and I call Apsana Begum on community cohesion and the 90th anniversary of the Battle of Cable Street. Apsana Begum.
Apsana Begum
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's an honor to be able to speak and lead this adjournment debate. And I will state say at the start because another colleague wants to speak, I will be taking two very short interventions with members that I've already had conversations with before this debate.
Madam Deputy Speaker, next month on the 4th of October, thousands of people in East London will be marking the 90th anniversary of what is commonly known as the Battle of Cable Street, when the Jewish community and allies stood together to march off Oswald Mosley and his Blackshirts. This victory is held up today as a high-water mark for so many causes: for anti-fascism, grassroots Jewish activism, and cross-community solidarity. It echoes from 1936 to the present in so many ways. Madam Deputy Speaker, anti-Semitism and hate crimes are again on the rise in Britain. Just last week, a man was charged for making a Nazi salute outside of a synagogue, and of course, we must never forget the victims of recent anti-Semitic attacks in North London, including the stabbings in Golders Green earlier this year and the abhorred Heathen Park terrorist attack a year ago, which took the lives of Melvin Kravitz and Adrian Dolby.
We are also seeing the return of far-right and racist agitators who seek, much like Mosley, to exploit the struggles of working-class people in this country to sow hatred, intolerance, and division. In the UK, migrants and asylum seekers are a sharp target, with anti-migrant pogroms in Belfast just one among many chilling incidents of racist violence that we have seen in recent months. Across Western Europe, I'll give way for a short intervention.
Jim Shannon
I commend the honorable lady for popular and timely for bringing this forward. And it is indeed important that we remember this occasion of the 90 years ago that prevented a fascist march from passing through Cable Street in London. Northern Ireland has been especially afflicted to deep divisions running through our community.
The Peace Plus action plan has been one of those ways to try and address the issues. Does the honourable lady agree that expanding and supporting cross-community initiatives across the UK and Northern Ireland can help strengthen relationships between communities? And remembering these events help us to do just that. Thank you.
Apsana Begum
Well, I thank the honourable member for his intervention. It's absolutely correct to say that communities must work with one another to be able to challenge and deal with the challenges of our time, particularly the rise of racism and fascism that we see across the world. Across Western Europe, we are seeing far-right parties winning elections, so we must start to look seriously and carefully at our own history and how we have overcome these challenges in the past.
Madam Deputy Speaker, fascism was not defeated in Britain over the course of a single day, but no day alone contributed as much as October the 4th, 1936. And so I'm pleased that the Minister is here today, a fellow London MP, as well as my constituency neighbor, the Member for Bethnal Green and Stepney, where Cable Street is now situated after the boundary changes in 2024, here to debate the 90th anniversary and to understand how the battle came to be. By the year 1934, the British Union of Fascists was concentrating its efforts on building a menacing street movement in inner-city areas. In East London, the BUF had four large branches. Thousands of supporters were based in a diverse and economically struggling area, where the largest minorities were of Irish Catholic and East European Jewish heritage.
Around 100,000 Jews lived in East London.
Shop signs there were written in Yiddish, and over 100 synagogues and shtiebels were established. Fascists attempted to set Irish Catholic and Jewish communities against each other, accusing Jews of taking English jobs, smashing their market stalls and attacking and beating Jews returning from synagogue or from shopping. Then on the 26th of September 1936, Mosley announced his intention to march provocatively right through these Jewish neighborhoods and hold rallies with his supporters. But within two days, 100,000 signatures were collected by the Jewish People's Council, a local grassroots campaign formed only that year, to petition the then Home Secretary for a ban on the march to, and I quote, "retain peaceable and amicable relations between all sections of East London's population."
Local mayors and local MPs, including one of my predecessors, the great Labour MP George Lansbury, handed in the petition. Yet shockingly, the then Home Secretary refused and instead decided to send 7,000 police officers to protect Mosley and the Blackshirts. Just hours after the refusal was issued, the Jewish People's Council began to distribute leaflets calling on citizens of London to make sure the fascist march would not take place. Madam Deputy Speaker, far from being a spontaneous uprising, it took an extraordinary amount of effort to organise East London's resistance. The Jewish People's Council frantically worked to mobilise Jewish and non-Jewish communities locally, while Communist Party, Independent Labour Party and trade union branches all mobilised the area's textile workers, dockers and railway workers.
I will give way to the right honourable gentleman.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
I thank the member for giving way and compliment her on the wonderful speech that she's making. As one who's had family members there as part of that demonstration in 1936 against the march of fascism, would she acknowledge that when we commemorate them on Sunday week in her constituency and in her borough, that we're actually also opposing the rise of the far right in this country and all across Europe? And remember that in 1936, all of officialdom said to the people of East End, "Shut up, do nothing about it and let them march."
They refused to let them march. It was the biggest defeat that Mosley and the fascists ever had in Britain. And we should thank them for their bravery at the time.
Apsana Begum
The right honourable member is absolutely correct. And today's debate is about recognizing those really courageous, brave efforts. And he speaks to his own family's contributions, his parents who were at the Battle of Cable Street and have spoken to him over the years about stories from his parents. By the time that the human blockade was formed, tens of thousands of protesters had gathered at Gardiner's Corner at Aldgate, hugely outnumbering the 4,000 fascists and their 7,000 strong police protection. It's important to remember that younger anti-fascists, children as young as 12, acted as runners, delivering messages and directing for reinforcements.
Far too often overlooked is the role of women who leafleted and organized workers in the run-up and on the day, in their thousands, defended barricades.
To clear the path for the fascists, the police then brutalized protesters with truncheons and attempted to charge their horses through their path. Hundreds of Jews and anti-fascists engaging in self-defense were seriously injured or arrested, and later accused by the police of having instigated the violence. Police were unable to force their entry via Aldgate or Whitechapel after huge confrontations there, and eventually closed in on Cable Street. They broke through the first barrier at Cable Street, but fierce resistance pushed them back, and by late afternoon, Mosley was instructed to retreat westwards, the police withdrew, and celebrations erupted across the East End of London that evening. Madam Deputy Speaker, as the daughter of migrants who moved to East London, I feel it's all too important to consider how community solidarity and resistance continued in the aftermath.
The BUF did not disappear overnight, but anti-fascists were able to build upon the battle to form a confident and united mass movement in the East End of London. Leafleting and public campaigning took place to keep out Mosley's fascists in local elections held five months later, while initiatives such as the Stepney Tenants' Defence League were pivotal in uniting the Irish and Jewish communities which Mosley had attempted to divide. Jews stood with Irish Catholics and vice versa against evictions and exploitation by landlords. They made clear that their struggle was a class struggle, and this cut away at the remaining support for the BUF's anti-Semitic politics in East London. Madam Deputy Speaker, this for me and for anti-racists across East London and much, much beyond is an enduring inspiration.
Many of those present spoke movingly about the cross-community solidarity that they saw at Cable Street that day.
People such as Charlie Goodman. Charlie was arrested at Cable Street and after three months in prison went on to fight for the Republicans in Spain. He spoke of the, and I quote, "Orthodox Jews with long silk coats and soft, soft felt hats and sidepieces standing shoulder to shoulder with Irish Catholics, dockers and Somali seamen." "They all felt there was a need to be out there to stand on that particular day." In other words, Madam Deputy Speaker, they knew that an injury to one is an injury to all.
This too is how subsequent generations of East Enders have united in the face of hostile racist threats.
Indeed, in the decades after Cable Street, East London's Bangladeshi community, especially its youth movements and socialist and trade unionist allies, mobilized in response to the racially motivated murder of a 25-year-old textile worker, Altab Ali, in 1978. A huge demonstration marched Altab Ali's coffin to Downing Street to demand their rights, while Bangladeshis and anti-racists together organized night patrols to protect communities from neo-Nazi threats. In the 90s, communities on the Isle of Dogs in my constituency came together to confront the BNP. Trade unionists, the Bangladeshi community and allies once again organized huge demonstrations and mobilized across communities to challenge the BNP's support base.
And ahead of the then 75th anniversary of the Battle of Cable Street, Madam Deputy Speaker, the EDL were marched off Whitehall, and even more recently, UKIP failed in their attempt to drive a crusade towards mosques last October and in their provocations again this year in January. Generation after generation of East Enders have had to confront attempts to divide our neighbours or to target and attack and intimidate them and spread fear in our communities. As the historian, educator and author David Rosenberg has often reminded us, the anti-fascists at the Battle of Cable Street did not have a blueprint, but left us one with their sheer courage. Madam Deputy Speaker, as difficult as this may be for some, we must also pay attention to the catastrophically poor decisions from the police and political establishment at the time. The shameful decisions of the then Home Secretary amounted to tacit consent for the fascist assault in East London.
His mounted police cracked skulls and arrested scores of protesters, some of whom received custodial sentences with hard labour for defending themselves and their communities.
Six fascists were arrested, compared with 79 anti-fascists. Others, including the then Labour leadership, urged members to stay away from Cable Street that day. However, rank and file members, trade unionists, and grassroots socialists all saw the necessity of defeating the Blackshirts and continued to organise and mobilise. The victory at Cable Street has been memorialised in the iconic Cable Street mural, a major piece of public art unveiled in 1983 on the wall of the former St George's Town Hall. It depicts a chaotic scene of mass resistance and street battles, and itself was a grassroots piece of cultural resistance with its own fascinating history.
I'd like to know whether the Government will be working to protect that cultural heritage, particularly as it sadly has been vandalised numerous times.
I know that unlike in 1936, the government has invested resources into building community cohesion and interfaith activities in my borough of Tower Hamlets. And I'm pleased that my local council along with voluntary organisations locally have been awarded the Common Ground Resilience Funds to build social connections across communities, complementing numerous initiatives from the Mayor of London. Madam Deputy Speaker, next month on the 4th of October, East London will be standing together: trade unionists, Jews, Muslims, Bangladeshis, Somalis, socialists and many, many thousands more at Cable Street once again to mark the history, legacy and values of all those brave people who stood together 90 years ago to say 'no pasarán', they shall not pass.
I wonder if the Minister will join me today in paying tribute to them, as well as the organizing committee, including the Jewish Socialist Group, who have done so much to immortalize the legacy of Cable Street, and tell us as well how the government itself will consider honoring the legacy of Cable Street and the anti-fascists of that day as we confront the rising antisemitism, racism, and division of today. Because, Madam Deputy Speaker, as my friend Rabbi Herschel Gluck OBE said, "Cable Street isn't just a place on the map, it's a concept, it's an idea."
Florence Eshalomi
The message of Cable Street is that we must never let evil pass.
Rushanara Ali
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I start by congratulating my honorable friend and neighbor for securing this very important adjournment debate. She represented Cable Street until the last general election and I'm very proud to be the MP for Cable Street. She and I both have much in common. We are the beneficiaries of all those who came before us who fought in the Battle of Cable Street to make the East End the place it went on to become.
And the generations after those who fought in the Battle of Cable Street, those who fought against the racism of the National Front, some of our colleagues who are here in this room, in this chamber and in this House, who made the East End a safe place for us to grow up in. We also studied in the same secondary school and have been the beneficiaries as children and young people, along with our peers, in learning about the Battle of Cable Street by visiting that memorial that she speaks of, which continues to inspire young people and the generations that came after us as well as before us. The significance of what happened almost 90 years ago, as we look to the 90th anniversary that we will mark on the 4th of October, remains absolutely crucial for our society if we are to fight the modern-day intolerance and hostility and hatred that we are seeing yet again in even greater force, fueled by disinformation and online hatred that's playing out in our society, in our communities up and down the country.
Growing up, I heard the testimonies of so many in our community. I am a few years older than my honorable friend, so I was able to meet the many powerful advocates of the anti-racism movement, including two of my former constituents who are no longer with us. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to pay tribute to their struggles and what they did. They were young people when the Battle of Cable Street took place and they took part.
The late, great Max Levitas, who I had the good fortune of being able to campaign with as a Member of Parliament, who fought against the English Defence League and other far-right groups that sought to exploit division, that sought to stir up hatred in my constituency when I was first elected. And the late Beattie Orwell, who died in 2023 aged 105, who also took part in the Battle of Cable Street. Two people who inspired me and supported me through my political career, along with many others in our community who told their stories, told the story of the anti-racist movement and continued to work across community. My honourable friend has eloquently highlighted and spoken about that period, but also what happened afterwards. The fight against intolerance and hatred continues.
We have to build on the legacy of that generation that worked so hard to ensure that division is not amplified by those who seek to divide us. I hope that as we look to the, as we mark the 90th anniversary of the Battle of Cable Street, we can all work together to redouble our efforts to build strong communities, to build cohesion, to build strong interfaith relations as well as relations with those with no faiths, and recognize the challenge today, the modern-day challenge of intolerance and hatred is even greater in some respects, though much has been achieved, and we have to be vigilant and we have to work together to ensure that we stand against racism and fascism and intolerance of the kind we are seeing grow once again.
And I look to the Minister to work with us to do that. Thank you.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to congratulate my fellow London MP and honourable friend for Poplar and Limehouse for securing this debate, this timely debate. She referenced a number of issues that sadly are still happening across our streets. She also referenced the tragic death of the 25-year-old Altab Ali in 1978.
And when you go to Whitechapel and you see that arch, I remember when I first learned about the history of that park and the fact that that park was renamed in 1998 following his death in 1978. And the history and the significance of that quite powerful. And my honourable friend for Bethnal Green and Stepney highlighting their shared connection in that proud part of East End. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Battle of Cable Street was a defining moment in the history of the city that both I and the member for Poplar and Limehouse proudly represent. When Londoners blocked Mosley's anti-Semites from marching, they showed the world that hatred and intolerance have no place on these streets.
London, both then and now, is built on solidarity across our differences. I'm proud that we are a hugely diverse city. It's a key component of our success. And we are bonded by being Londoners.
We look out for each other in London. And this is the point that the fascists could not comprehend back then, and it is exactly what the far-right and extremists today fail to understand. The 4th of October 1936 was not just a significant moment in London's history, it was a pivotal one in the history of British Jews. It was Jewish communities that Mosley was targeting. And it was Jewish communities who led the response and built the barricades against the fascists, made of anything they could find from the nearby streets and builders' yards.
And in the many years since, the Jewish community has been at the heart of London's culture, identity and great achievements.
Yet 90 years on, Jewish people continue to face the same ugly brutality and racism here in our city. I can testify to this first-hand as an MP working directly with many different communities. I was deeply disturbed to be confronted by the daily casual day-to-day antisemitism on our streets. We will remember with deep sadness the victims of Heaton Park. I attended a recent memorial on bank holiday the 31st with the Secretary of State, meeting the families of the two people that were tragically killed.
The stabbing of the two Jewish men in Golders Green.
But we must do much more than remember. We must confront this hate where it persists in educational settings, in workplaces, public services and beyond. Today we are here to celebrate the resistance of 1936, but we must also draw lessons from it and how we confront the hatred we see today. In the aftermath, as my hon. friend mentioned, ministers tried to introduce a ban on marching in uniforms and require demonstrators to notify the police of their intentions. These are principles which remain important today.
The government has demonstrated through action its unwavering commitment to tackling antisemitism.
We must also be alert to how Mosley's political violence was financed by far-right extremists abroad. And we must raise our defenses again today. But the most important lesson from Cable Street is that it was the local community themselves who stood up against hate and division.
Will the minister please give way?
Warinder Juss
I thank the minister for giving way. Is the anniversary also an opportunity for us to pay tribute to the trade union movement and the countless working people who stood against racism, fascism, and hatred?
And it's actually in the spirit of the trade union movement's best traditions: collective responsibility, solidarity and fighting prejudice and discrimination wherever it occurs.
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honourable friend for raising that and the importance of that solidarity which again my honourable friend from Poplar and Limehouse highlighted. It was local residents from all different backgrounds, including trade unionists, East Enders and migrant communities who told the vocal minority: your hate does not represent us. Today, our Jewish friends and neighbours in the face of antisemitism need us all to stand with them again.
This government is taking a firm stance against antisemitism, and it is tackling it across businesses, civil society, health, education, culture, and policing. That commitment is backed by action, including £32.4 million for Jewish community protective security, alongside a wider £251.1 million policing package over the next three years, a £1 million expansion of the Common Ground program for communities facing antisemitism, and up to £7 million to tackle antisemitism in schools, colleges, and universities.
Madam Deputy Speaker, in 1936, the fascists wanted to march through the East End because it was boroughs predominantly which were Jewish. Today, it is also home to Muslims, and for that reason, the far right today often try and whip up their hate through so-called demonstrations through the East End.
They will not succeed. Be it in Whitechapel or elsewhere in the country, for the same reason they failed back then. London and Britain is home to good, decent people. People who are proud to be British across ethnicities and religions. We are addressing the root cause of division through investment in cohesion and interfaith.
As we set out in our social cohesion action plan, protecting what matters, we have provided a further 800 million pounds to bring communities together to decide where investment is spent in our neighborhoods.
Overall, our pride in place program is providing up to 5.8 billion over 10 years to support 284 places. This will serve as a cornerstone of this government's support for communities. We are also supporting interfaith work, continuing to bring programs like near neighbors, which brings people together in religiously and ethnically diverse neighborhoods, and growing interfaith week to strengthen understanding and interaction between people of different faiths. I'll give way on that point.
John Slinger
I thank my honorable friend. Does she agree with me that peace walks, such as the one I attended yesterday in Rugby, where members of the community, members of faith groups, people of no faith, walked between different religious establishments from different faiths, is a very important part of that interfaith work that she's doing, showing that ordinary people want to come together, irrespective of their background and their faith or their ethnic background, and unite as one community against those who would divide us?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honorable friend for Rugby for raising that. So many community initiatives, including many peace walks, some that I've attended in my constituency, are so vital where people can come together. And as my honorable friend for Wolverhampton mentioned, local people, real people, trade unionists, all coming together to show that solidarity. And we are taking wider steps to boost faith and belief in literacy, Madam Deputy Speaker.
But none of this can substitute a very clear position that antisemitism, far-right extremism, and political violence has no place in Britain. So I say to the blackshirts then, and to the thugs now, we continue to say, no pasaran, they shall not pass.
Speaker 249
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as that opinion say aye. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order. On your feet.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.