House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Commons
Follow its sittingsBrian William Leishman
Good morning, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, very recently, Syngenta in Grangemouth have announced 377 redundancies. This, along with recent closures to Versalis, Fujifilm, and of course the Grangemouth oil refinery, means a real reduction in possible positive destinations for local young people. Now, what can the UK government do to accelerate the readiness of sites in Grangemouth to unlock the 200 million pounds from the National Wealth Fund so that we can build Grangemouth and Scotland's industrial future?
Speaker 5
Well, I'm grateful to my honorable friend for this question and obviously the immediate activities in supporting the affected employees throughout the consultation period. He will know the use of the powers of government, the powers of the state, to make sites available quickly for inward investment to the UK has always been a priority of mine. He's right to say the National Wealth Fund has already made a nominal allocation to Grangemouth, and there are other programs such as the Strategic Sites Accelerator that were part of the industrial strategy, which are all about trying to improve the pace at which we can take advantage of the investment opportunities the UK is presented with. But I can promise him I'll remain in close consultation with him and of course the Secretary of State for Energy Net Zero about this.
Speaker 8
Thank you. It's British Beauty Week, which, Madam Deputy Speaker, I can see you've been celebrating. I'm sure that the Secretary of State has, I'm sure the Secretary of State has been celebrating too. But it's tough out there for our salons. It's tough.
Julia Dockerill
The industry has lost one in five employees last year. That's the largest loss of employment of any job type in the UK. Now, many will have been young people starting their careers in the industry, but fewer salons can afford to employ and train them because they are getting hammered by the jobs tax, soaring business rates, and higher utility bills. What hope is the Prime Minister offering them?
Speaker 5
Well, I'm grateful to the honorable lady for her question. I noticed she didn't go to me first on British Beauty Week, Madam Deputy Speaker, she went to you and that is a fair contribution. British Beauty Week is an important moment, not least to celebrate the contribution of the sector, but also I believe of over 5,000 new apprentices who'll be starting in the sector in every corner of the UK this year. In terms of the hope she asks effectively, what is the big economic story in the UK? And I would say hope comes from the fact that despite the challenges that exist in the global economy around the world, the economy under this government is clearly performing more strongly than it did for 14 years under the Tories.
My proof points of that are that wages are rising faster than prices and crucially that GDP is rising not just overall but per head, as opposed to the modest increases we saw under the Conservatives really from population increase through large-scale immigration. So an economy that's performing more strongly is in the interests of every business. And in terms of the opportunities for young people, both those tax and fiscal incentives that I talked about and again a further agenda coming through the Milburn review.
Sarah Olney
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Youth unemployment stands at 15%, and in London that figure is 25%. 700,000 graduates are out of work. Retail and hospitality are cornerstones of the everyday economy, providing vital employment, driving local growth, and creating thriving town centres. But average employment costs have increased by 11% since Labour took office, which disproportionately affects sectors which traditionally offer those entry-level jobs. Policy decisions taken by this government are making it impossibly hard for businesses to provide young people with their first foot on the career ladder.
Will the Secretary of State acknowledge the damage being done to young people, and will they ensure, as they implement the secondary legislation from the Employment Rights Act, that they balance the rights of employees fairly with the needs of businesses to actually provide those jobs for young people?
Speaker 5
Hear, hear. Well, a few issues there from the Lib Dem front bench, but I would say, first of all, doing a job like this, doing any job in government, has to acknowledge the trade-offs. And the simple truth was the kind of things we'll be talking about in this session that everyone in the House wants to see funded were not funded in the plans that we inherited. So yes, it's always difficult to raise the tax burden on anyone in the UK, but where you have priorities, things that have been promised to the British people, in the case of this department, the successor department, it was the money for the Port Talbot transformation, the steelworks. It was the money for Post Office compensation for the sub-postmasters.
They were not funded. So the Chancellor at the time did have to raise or find the money in order to fulfill the existing pledges that had been made. I can always promise her, however, that the aggregate impact, the balance on business, whether it's on employment rights, whether it's on taxation, is always something that this department fights very hard for in government, because we're aware the only way to fulfill the true ambitions of the British people is an economy that's performing strongly, employing more people, giving them hope and opportunity for the future. But I do believe this new department, with the extra things that have come into it, a genuinely exciting opportunity to bring a more coherent story to these interventions from government. That is the best way to a strong economy.
Anna Spencer.
Hannah Kathrine Spencer
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Funding for the e-MERLIN radio telescope... Number two. Question number two. Sorry.
Speaker 5
Thank you. I welcome this question from my constituency neighbour and grateful to her for raising it. The Prime Minister and I have been clear that Jodrell Bank has a secure future. Just to be clear to the House, what is happening here is the primary radio astronomy project is going to move from the e-MERLIN radio telescope from March 2028 to the Square Kilometre Array Observatory at that point going forward. However, that was a science-based decision, but we are exploring the long-term options for the sustainability of Jodrell Bank.
Hannah Kathrine Spencer
Anna Spencer. Thank you. Madam Deputy Speaker, funding for the e-MERLIN radio telescope network is due to end in 2028, putting Jodrell Bank's future at risk. And people across Gorton and Denton have made clear to me the vital role that this observatory plays in opening science up to people of all ages. Many of us went there on school trips as kids.
And the Prime Minister assured us that his government will find funding, a funding solution. So will the Secretary of State explain how the government intends to honour this heartfelt commitment and secure Jodrell Bank's long-term future as an active sovereign scientific facility? Thank you.
Speaker 5
Well, I'm grateful to her for raising this, and I recognise the strength of feeling that she has talked about in her question. She will know on a clear day you can see Jodrell Bank from Matley Lane in Tameside, and it's a wonderful sight. It's important, given that we have a very significant R&D budget in the UK, that scientific decisions are made on the basis of the science. But that still doesn't mean there isn't a future for Jodrell Bank as an asset that is consistent with making sure we're making science-based decisions on the prioritisation of that funding. I met with the University of Manchester just a few days ago about this, and the local MPs for the area have been incredibly supportive in finding a solution, and I hope to have more to say soon on that.
Speaker 18
Backbench MPs can only come in if the question is about Jodrell Bank Observatory. Okay. Shadow Minister, Peter Fortune.
Peter Timothy Fortune
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The renationalisation of the railways is not working. The Drayson partitions exist to ensure that costs which the UK must meet and cannot change, such as international subscriptions that give us access to scientific facilities, are treated separately to costs which we have control over, such as grants funding. With the STFC given a flat cash settlement, but with international subscriptions rising with inflation, STFC now has less money to spend on actual research, leading to world-leading scientific research being dropped by STFC to the closure of facilities like Jodrell Bank. Can I ask the Minister, who made the decision, who made the decision to disregard the Drayson partitions?
Speaker 5
It's good to see the Shadow Minister. Thank you for the question. Let me just be clear with the House. If you take the UKRI budget in aggregate for this spending review period, it's nearly 39 billion pounds. If you take the overall R&D budget for the UK in this spending review period, it's 86 billion pounds.
So this is record levels of funding making a difference. It is absolutely crucial within that that we do make sure that these decisions on the prioritisation of funding are science-based ones. Now, the issue he identifies between the tension between research projects and subscription projects and the funding between them, I am familiar with it. I do know he's making a serious point that has to be explored. But in terms of who has made this decision, that has been a process that runs through, I think, 30 different meetings of the Research Council.
It has a process where submissions are taken from a very wide range of areas. There will always be more people wanting more funding than is available, no matter how big I make the spending pot for it. But I just think as a House we should be clear that we want these decisions primarily made on scientific basis.
Adam Thompson.
Number three, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Minister.
Speaker 15
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as this is my first run out in my new brief, I thought it might be nice to just take a moment to recognise the work of Lord Vallance as Science Minister and Lord Stottwood as Investment Minister and thank them very much for their work. As we've just heard from the Secretary of State, the government is making record investments in science and technology to keep the UK at the forefront of global research and innovation. We're committing 86 billion pounds to R&D between 26-27 and 29-30, including 38.6 billion for UK Research and Innovation. These investments are translating into jobs, innovation and economic opportunity across the UK, including in the East Midlands.
Adam Thompson.
Adam Thompson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the new Minister to his new place. Despite the government's significant funding increases to science generally, the Science and Technology Facilities Council, STFC, is facing significant cost pressures. I met recently with some STFC-funded former colleagues who fear an exodus of professional talent from the UK because of these pressures. Given the importance of STFC-funded facilities in the UK's scientific capability, can the Minister then set out what he's doing to ensure that the Council's financial position is put on a sustainable footing without undermining the long-term pipeline of researchers and the UK's ability to participate in major international science programs?
Speaker 15
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think first of all it's important to recognise that in the changes that STFC are making, there's an impact on the staff who work for STFC. I've been in the unfortunate position of working in a company undertaking such a restructure and of having to do such restructures myself in the past, and I do appreciate how difficult that is for staff. I've spoken to the Executive Chair of STFC, and at the core of this program is exactly as my honourable friend has described, a desire to get STFC into a position where it has appropriate financial management whilst also increasing productivity and modernising in response to new technology. The government is supporting this with an increase in STFC's funding to 842 million pounds by 29-30 from the 835 million in 25-26.
Victoria Collins
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Harpenden is the home to Rothamsted Research and our universities lead the world, yet too much of that brilliance never leaves the lab. So will the Minister look at Lib Dem proposals to bring in a standard national framework for spin-out IP and quadruple the proof of concept funding so Britain's discoveries scale here and not abroad?
Victoria Collins.
Speaker 15
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I agree very much with her point about the need for Britain's discoveries to be scaled here at home rather than abroad. I'm taking an end-to-end approach on this, starting with scientific discovery and ending hopefully with large companies listed on the London Stock Exchange and supporting businesses throughout the whole of that process. Innovate UK, UKRI Innovate UK doing some really great work here and supported as well by the increased role of the British Business Bank.
Chinyelu Susan Onwurah
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And let me welcome the Minister to his new role and particularly this government's emphasis on driving growth through innovation in every region of our country. As recommended by my committee's recent report, Flying Blind. Now the reason it was called Flying Blind was because it identified a real lack of data and information about what the factors that drive growth and how to measure success in our regions and across clusters and called for a dashboard. Could the Minister tell me what progress has been made on that dashboard and in particular has he looked at the Manchester x Cambridge baseline report which identified a number of indicators including company stock, funded accounts, disclosed funding by employer, etc.?
Speaker 15
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My right honorable friend and I share a great confidence in data and a desire to make decisions on a data basis. As these regional disparities that she is describing, I've looked precisely at this data and there is a clear distinction between the proportion of UKRI funding and UKRI spin-outs for instance and then the ability of those companies to attract investment. In fact, the level of funding they receive is based on their proximity to London. So I do share her concern.
We are looking at the data for that and I will certainly be happy to work with her and her committee on how we ensure that regional funding is more appropriately spread.
Alison Bennett
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Universal Quantum are born out of the University of Sussex and they're based in my Mid Sussex constituency. They are developing a unique trapped-ion modular technology for quantum computing at scale. They received 77 million dollars from the German government in 2022 and have just last week secured 100 million dollars of Series A funding from investors including the Singaporean government. They have, however, been unsuccessful in getting any funding from our own government.
Speaker 17
Can the Minister explain how this tallies with their department's commitment to investing in exceptional homegrown companies?
Speaker 15
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The situation that she describes about the loss of UK quantum companies largely under the previous government is exactly why my predecessor was so determined to set up the Pro-Q program to ensure that the UK is leading not only in the procurement of quantum computing but that we enable the growth of UK businesses to do that. In March 2026, the government announced a landmark commitment of up to 2 billion pounds for the next stage of the national program and our ambition is that we will see UK quantum companies scale and stay in the UK.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and good morning and I thank my honorable friend for his question. This was a key aspect of our recent consultations which proposed a duty for online marketplaces to due care to identify, prevent and remove unsafe goods from their sites. The consultation package also proposed a modernized enforcement toolkit and my intention is that future regulations will set out strong new duties on online marketplaces backed by appropriate sanctions.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to the Minister for her answer.
So residents of Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, like millions of us across the country, increasingly rely on online marketplaces for everyday purchases. Yet the consumer magazine Which? continues to uncover dangerous products being sold on these platforms. So will the Minister ensure that forthcoming regulations place a clear legal duty on online marketplaces to identify and remove unsafe products backed by meaningful penalties for those that fail to protect consumers?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank him for raising this really important issue and bringing it to the House today, reflecting the changes in preferences for his constituents and those across the country in how they buy products online and interact with online marketplaces. I also want to take this opportunity to thank the brilliant work that Which? does in this space. Our recent consultations on modernising the product safety framework included proposals for clear duties on online marketplaces, including a clear duty for online marketplaces to take due care to identify, prevent and remove unsafe goods from their sites. We also proposed a modernised enforcement toolkit, including civil monetary penalties to complement the existing criminal sanctions that exist, and fines would be set proportionate to risk and respond to an offence appropriately. We're also considering bespoke enforcement measures to ensure that online and international supply chain actors can be effectively addressed.
We'll respond to these consultations in due course and I thank him for his engagement in this space.
Vicky Slade.
Vikki Slade
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Countless constituents have written to me about their concerns about the proliferation of high-powered e-bikes, e-scooters and conversion kits, many of which are bought online. Now when you buy them in a shop, I've been liaising with Currys, and they're being as proactive as they can in telling people their point of sale material makes it clear what the law is, but online it is a wild west. So given the failures in cracking down on the vehicles where they're not permitted by the police, will the government consider limiting their online sales using the Product Regulation and Metrology Act?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank the honourable member for raising this issue. I know she has campaigned on this and colleagues across this House and I share their concerns. In our recent consultation on reforming the product safety framework, we did seek views on additional measures and responsibilities that are needed to improve the safety of products sold online. This included lithium-ion batteries and their use in consumer goods such as e-bikes. We'll be happy to keep her updated on the progress of this work when we respond in due course.
Number six please.
Minister.
Speaker 5
Madam Deputy Speaker, as we have heard, this new department brings together a range of essential policy areas to back industries, technologies and jobs that will power future growth. For me, sustained economic growth can only come through greater private investment and private capital, and the business investment figures for the UK are encouraging and our industrial strategy has used the policy tools at its disposal to attract over 390 billion pounds of private investment commitments since it came into force.
Speaker 40
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the GDP figures which have been published this morning. If we're serious though about growth, we need to ramp up our capacity in manufacturing and ensure that GDP growth is matched with jobs growth. So will the Secretary of State consider setting an ambition of a million new manufacturing jobs in the next decade, putting reindustrialisation at the heart of the government's growth strategy?
Speaker 5
Well I warmly welcome my honourable friend's question about reindustrialisation, which is an essential part of the government's programme. Backing reindustrialisation does not mean we don't recognise the tremendous contribution of services and it's not nostalgia, it's about looking at the brilliant innovation we have in the UK and seeing it scaled up. To do that requires policy interventions and I'm extremely pleased that we'll shortly have coming online the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, which will bring down our energy prices, electricity prices for 10,000 British manufacturers, ending the situation we had from the Tories where we had the highest energy prices of any industrialised major nation. On a target, I think we have to look at targets, I'll look at the one he has proposed, but I also think there are other areas we have to include in that to get the holistic impact we need.
Max Wilkinson.
Max Wilkinson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Golden Valley development at West Cheltenham enjoys the support of this government and I can see the Minister smiling because I've spoken to him about it a lot. It also enjoyed the support of the last government. It's driven locally by the local council and supported by businesses like the developer HBD. It's going to generate 12,000 jobs and close to a billion pounds of investment supporting our cyber and tech industry, crucially supporting the work of GCHQ.
But to really unlock the success of the development, we need to be given designated area status so the local council can then start reinvesting in the local business community as it has done so far at that development. Will the Secretary of State have a word with the Chancellor ahead of the budget to see if we can bring about a success in this bid?
Speaker 4
Grateful for the question, everything the honorable gentleman has said sounds hugely attractive to me, he's clearly already engaged with government to some degree but I will follow up on his question and see what we can do to support his local area.
Mark Garnier
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Um, can I just start off by, by thanking actually the Secretary of State for his very measured and intelligent thoughts about GDP growth rate. Um, but can I, uh, lament that some other people in his, in his government, uh, seem almost complacent that the, the IMF has increased GDP growth expectations from 1% to just 1.3%, which puts us second in the G7. Doesn't that show a certain lack of, of reality in the government that actually what we should be looking for is more like 2.5% GDP growth? The reality of it is, is the, the G20, uh, is we're averaging 3.1% and we're 14th in the G20.
So my question to the Secretary of State is, does he recognize that over-regulating, over-taxing and charging too much for energy is holding back our great entrepreneurs and businesses who could be delivering that GDP growth that this country really needs?
Speaker 5
Well, I believe what the figures show is a level of resilience in an extraordinarily difficult global climate, but in terms of ambitions, yes, I'm pleased that we are turning around some of the underperformance of the 14 years of Conservative government, but I want more. I'm very ambitious and hungry for that. But in order to do that, we have the kind of interventions this government has already committed to. That point I've just made, I mean, we did inherit the highest industrial electricity prices of any developed nation. We're bringing those down by a quarter for 10,000 British businesses.
Of course I want more in that space, of course I'll be speaking to the Chancellor about further work in that agenda, but bringing down the costs for business, giving them new markets through the success we've had in our trade deals, making sure that the regulatory system supports those objectives, all of this contributes to what I believe is, as I said, of tremendous opportunities for the UK because of the assets that we've had and we should be ambitious for the future.
Cat Eccles.
Question number seven, please.
Minister.
Blair McDougall
Madam Deputy Speaker, the government is determined to tackle the scourge of late payments which causes the closure of 14,000 businesses and costs the UK economy almost 11 billion pounds a year. The Commercial Payments Bill currently progressing through Parliament will give the UK the strongest laws in the G7 and represents the most significant reform of payment practices in over 25 years. The bill will ensure that small businesses spend more time on growing, investing and creating jobs and less time on chasing late payments.
Catherine Eccles
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Late payment destroys thousands of viable small firms each year and poor practices have seen large firms using small suppliers as a free overdraft.
In my Stourbridge constituency, the impact is felt by manufacturers and fabricators with local metalwork and transport supply sectors facing the longest payment delays in the UK. How is he ensuring that there is a change in payment culture and lifting that burden from small businesses?
Blair McDougall
Well, she's absolutely right and I know from personal experience how frustrating it is to have large firms use small firms as that source of free finance. The bill that's going through Parliament at the moment will clamp down on those late payments through introducing maximum payment terms, providing stronger rights to interest and strengthening the powers of the Small Business Commissioner. But she's right on the need for a culture change and I think the message from government is that this legislation is coming, this change is coming and that large companies should get their payment practices in order right now.
Jim Shannon
Madam Deputy Speaker, thank the Minister for his answer. Rising business rates, wages going up, energy prices rising, National Insurance contributions, all those things have impacted upon small business. But one of the things that my small businesses tell me is the very issue the honourable lady referred to, those who don't pay on time. What can be done to specifically help firms who find that they are not getting the money from the suppliers that they can somewhere they can refer to, someone can help them if that's possible, thank you.
Blair McDougall
Well, he's absolutely right to raise that and I know it's a huge problem in Northern Ireland as it is in the rest of the UK. And one of the great problems with the current system is that you as a small business have to be aggressive towards your own customers to chase those late payments. This bill will turn that power relationship on its head and people will expect to be paid on time and if they aren't there'll be mandatory interest on that.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know all too well the devastating impact that rogue traders can have on my honourable friend's constituents given similar discussions in my own constituency and on many colleagues across the House too. That is why my department supported the Independent Furniture and Home Improvement Ombudsman's new approved code and payment protection scheme backed by independent dispute resolution to help hardworking families identify trusted traders and make sure people can spend their money with greater confidence and security. We remain committed to supporting the CMA and local trading standards in their ability to impose penalties via the courts. This is this Labour government delivering everyday fixes to protect families and give them the room to breathe.
Speaker 28
We need to move a bit faster so questions and answers must be shorter, Bill Esterson.
Bill Esterson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Joanne paid eleven thousand pounds for a new kitchen. Her house was left in a terrible state and she was unable to get the builder to return to rectify the substandard work. It also turned out he was associated with twenty-one other companies, mostly in the building trade, many of which have been dissolved. She mentioned quite rightly the new code for the home improvement sector which will give confidence to consumers and support to reputable traders.
But isn't there more needed to go after these cowboy builders to ensure that constituents like Joanne can get the remedy that they so much need?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend and I'm sorry about that incident with his constituent. The damaging impact it can have to people who've saved their entire life of savings for home improvements, to feel unsafe in your home, to feel robbed by that is absolutely dreadful. And that's why we're taking action, starting with the backing obviously the Furniture and Home Improvement Ombudsman scheme that I'd mentioned earlier. But I'm absolutely not complacent in this space. We are determined to ensure that customers know what protections are available and can use them with confidence and I look forward to working further in this area.
Christopher Chope
Madam Deputy Speaker, rogue traders operate with impunity in the park homes sector, yet the government has refused to supply sufficient money to National Trading Standards to enable them to carry out a national investigation and bring these rogues to book. What is the Minister going to do about it?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank the honourable member for his question. Regrettably, funding for trading standards has faced a real terms funding cut of more than fifty percent since twenty-ten under the previous government. The system is therefore under severe strain.
However, I absolutely back the incredible work that Trading Standards do across this country and know just how much support they need. That's why we are committed to backing them. We want to commit those longer-term plans to overhaul the wider consumer protection landscape, particularly for Trading Standards, to help them continue cracking on with their brilliant job.
Speaker 46
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We work closely with the Environment Department, with the Energy Department, with departments right across government to make sure that critical infrastructure developments are sustainable for local resource capacity. The planning system takes into account a number of those questions and they also ought to account for the long-term implications for water and wider resource supply. We have specifically designed our AI growth zones to be investments in areas where there is sufficient energy capacity and where infrastructure can be enhanced.
Caroline Jane Voaden
I thank the Minister for his answer, but Water UK says data centers in England are using about 6.6 million liters of drinking water a day, set to triple by 2030. Meanwhile, households in Devon and Cornwall have been under a hosepipe ban since August and businesses are now facing water restrictions. So given the dry weather that we've had and the fact that there is probably a lot more of that to come, has the government considered legislating to require new data centers to operate with low water dependency, particularly when they're being built in the south of England where water shortages are going to become even more pressing?
Speaker 46
Madam Deputy Speaker, let me say three things. One, it's important to be clear on the data. The estimates we have at the moment suggest data centers account for approximately 0.2% of non-household water usage in England in particular. Second, when people build data centers here, we want them to build in the light of our values and what local communities need. That in turn means investing alongside technology infrastructure in clean energy infrastructure and in wider resourcing locally as well.
And thirdly, I'm always very keen on ideas for how further improvements in demand flexibility, both for resources on energy and water, can be supported by data centers. I'll continue to look at the ideas she has proposed.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are environmental consequences caused by the emergence of data centers. There are also overblown claims as to their ability to create large numbers of jobs. But the biggest concern is in whose interests will they be operating? So what steps are the government taking to ensure that AI works for the people, not just for big tech companies?
Speaker 46
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank my honorable friend for a question that I know we have discussed at length as well. The central point, Madam Deputy Speaker, is in the last wave of technology, we neither built public trust nor did we build British technology. In this wave of AI, we are focused on building both trust and technology so that we can have sovereign control over what we're building here.
Blair McDougall
Madam Deputy Speaker, the industrial strategy sets out the government's long-term approach to boosting investment, productivity, and growth, building on the UK's industrial strengths, including advanced manufacturing. Through the complementary advanced manufacturing sector plan, backed by 4.3 billion of government funding, we're helping manufacturers to grow and thrive.
Richard Quigley
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I just say how shocked I am that the honorable lady suggested your appearance needed any augmentation. On the Isle of Wight, we are incredibly proud of our advanced manufacturing sector, and for an area our size, the island has one of the biggest concentrations of advanced manufacturing and high-tech engineering jobs in the country. And employers on my side of the island are racing to employ under-25s. But we always want to do more.
So can the Minister set out how the government's drive to buy British, alongside its renewed commitment to strengthening our defense capability, will create new opportunities for island manufacturers to secure them contracts, invest in growth, and create the next generation of skilled jobs on the Isle of Wight?
Blair McDougall
Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, he's absolutely right to highlight the huge opportunities for manufacturers on the Isle of Wight. We are determined to use procurement strategically, as other nations do, to back British industry. It's particularly important with shipbuilding, where we're expanding the role of the National Shipbuilding Office to oversee that. And that renewed investment in defense and in shipbuilding will create opportunities right across the maritime supply chain, including for the Wight Shipyard Company and other island manufacturers.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Government is clear that Royal Mail's quality of service has been unacceptable for too long. Royal Mail published a plan to improve reliability, and I've been frank in my conversations with their CEO that they now need to increase the pace of improvement and deliver on that plan. I understand there have been operational challenges in the Lark Lane and Liverpool North delivery offices, and I urge Royal Mail to improve their services for local people. They must do better.
Paula Barker
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Royal Mail has failed to meet Ofcom delivery targets for first-class mail since 2017. Yet over that time, Ofcom has allowed the price of a first-class stamp to increase by 166% and relaxed targets. Royal Mail's continual failure affects the most vulnerable groups in our society, those who receive letters about hospital appointments, court dates, or social security decisions, and these are arriving late, Madam Deputy Speaker. Much of the bulk mail lies outside the universal service obligation.
So will the Government review both that and Ofcom's remit so they ensure that Royal Mail provides a timely, affordable service for all post, one that doesn't prioritise parcels and ensure that failure is not rewarded?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend for her question and for raising this in the House today on behalf of her constituents and those all across the country, because Royal Mail's service must improve and it must improve quickly. Customers, particularly the most vulnerable, are being let down, and delayed letters can have serious consequences: the legal correspondence, hospital appointments, as she rightly raises. And where people are paying more for postal services, they rightly expect reliable and timely delivery. The Government has been clear that Ofcom should carefully consider the role of bulk mail and whether additional regulatory measures are needed to secure high standards of reliability for all postal customers. Much of the correspondence that people rely on falls outside the current quality of service targets.
Speaker 45
We'll continue to press for a reliable postal service that meets the needs of all users.
Michael Peter Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My question relates to the Tonbridge and Cranbrook delivery offices, which I know also deliver to your constituency, Madam Deputy Speaker. I ran a survey recently: 85% have experienced delays, 25% have missed a deadline or an appointment, and extraordinarily, 20% of people have experienced a three-week gap between postal deliveries. This is obviously totally unacceptable. So can I ask whether the Government have had conversations with Royal Mail specifically about the TN, the Tango November postcodes?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank the honourable member for raising this on behalf of his constituents, share his concerns, and know from my own inbox as a constituency MP the challenges when people don't receive their post on time and the significant delays. I've been frank in my conversations with the CEO of Royal Mail that its service has been unacceptable for too long and the pace of improvement must improve. The public and his constituents deserve a reliable postal service and they are right to expect better. If he wants to share those data with me and with Royal Mail and add to that pressure, I'd welcome it.
Blair McDougall
Madam Deputy Speaker, place is central to the industrial strategy. We've been working with Plymouth and the South West peninsula to support the development of distinctively nationally significant clusters. I myself visited Plymouth and Cornwall earlier this year to meet with the freeport, to understand the opportunities around marine autonomy, and to see for myself Cornwall's incredible critical mineral potential.
Charles Noah Law
Madam Deputy Speaker, as you know in Cornwall we've a resurgent minerals industry which can make our country and our communities wealthy once again. But we can only do this if we process what we dig out the ground. So having strong supply chains is also imperative from a national security and resilience perspective. So what steps is the Minister taking together with Number 10 North, the Treasury and other departments to ensure that that key investment case for our area, including the missing midstream that is battery active material production, will prevent us having to ship that wealth abroad and ensure that we create those Cornish jobs back at home?
Blair McDougall
Well, he and the other Cornish Labour MPs are incredible advocates for critical minerals and the potential in the UK. The projects in this part of the world are essential to our ambitions. We're supporting lithium projects in Cornwall, including an offer in principle of 9.8 million through Drive 35 for Geothermal Engineering Limited, as well as a 31 million pound equity investment through the National Wealth Fund in Cornish Lithium. And we'll continue to work to make sure we keep more of that value in the UK.
Rachael Maskell.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Government recognizes the vital role that post offices play in communities across the UK. We've committed to maintaining the 11,500 national minimum branch requirement and the Government set access criteria, including the requirement that 90% of the UK population live within one mile of their nearest post office. We're backing this with up to 180 million pounds in network subsidy funding over the next three years to support the cost of meeting these policy requirements, protecting access to crucial services.
Rachael Maskell
Thank you. When York's Crown Post Office closed after 138 years, we were given assurances with WHSmith that we would have a sustained solution. However, Moderna Capita, which has taken over WHSmith, closed their post office yesterday. We only have a teeny-weeny post office in the city centre. We have businesses dependent on it, residents as well as tourists.
We need a solution. I've met with the Post Office, they say six months to get a solution. I need a solution to our post office now. What steps will she take to ensure we've got a temporary solution before we get our sustained outcome?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I recognize my honorable friend's concerns about the availability of post office services in York city centre in the coming months. Post Office has confirmed it remains committed to restoring a replacement branch and has received interest from several potential applicants. Whilst these are operational matters for the Post Office, I'll ask them to consider capacity concerns and will keep my honorable friend updated and ask officials to work with her and the Post Office in finding that temporary solution as she rightly raises.
Olly Glover.
Speaker 46
Madam Deputy Speaker, we have a series of areas of regulatory focus on artificial intelligence already: data protection, competition policy, equality legislation, online safety. And I was particularly proud that we were one of the first countries to make sure that the egregious impacts of AI chatbots on our children are mitigated against. As well as I've mentioned earlier in the week, I'm looking forward to working right across the House on any further regulatory measures required to tackle any harms of artificial intelligence too.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. AI has the potential to transform science and research, including on campuses like Harwell and Culham in my Oxfordshire constituency. However, those benefits will only be realized if the risks of AI are taken seriously. So will the Minister support the call of over 85 parliamentarians for the Government to use our 2027 G20 presidency to champion an international agreement to properly regulate AI and prohibit superintelligent AI development?
Speaker 46
Well, firstly, can I thank the honorable member for him raising the advances at Culham in particular, a site I've visited and take great pride in as a national asset for us on nuclear fusion and the combination of AI and energy innovation. On his particular point on the G20, I'm very proud, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the Prime Minister has set out that AI will be top of the agenda and we will be looking to play a leadership role in making sure we arrive at a global code and principles for safe AI.
Sir Julian Smith.
Minister.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Hospitality businesses are at the heart of our high streets, communities and our local economies, supporting jobs and growth across the UK, and we recognise the pressures many continue to face. That is why we're providing targeted support for pubs, clubs and live music venues, including 15% business rates relief in 26-27 and an additional 20% discount from April next year, while reviewing pub and hotel valuations to help ensure a fairer, a fairer and more predictable business rates system. We're also investing 10 million pounds through a new hospitality grant scheme to support growth, create jobs and strengthen local economies.
Speaker 67
I thank her for the answer. As she knows, the hospitality sector in areas such as mine provide the bulk of employment for young people. Could I urge her to look at the proposals from our front bench and also proposals from Hospitality UK to provide a lower NICs rate at the upcoming budget to allow those businesses to employ more young people?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank the honourable member for raising this today. Hospitality, as he mentioned, is an absolute key employer of young people in the economy, providing rewarding routes into work. It's a critical sector to help us with resolving the NEETs crisis. It's a key priority for this government and we really want to work closely with the sector in providing those solutions. I'm sure he'll welcome the announcement today of our significant intervention in partnership with the hospitality sector, working closely with Hospitality UK, providing those job opportunities, new work experience programs to turn this around, and hospitality is key to that.
Jacob Collier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank ministers for their engagement following Carlsberg's devastating news about the closure of Marston's brewery next year? This risks 310 jobs along with our heritage ales from Burton like Pedigree and Bass. Hospitality relies on brewing, and brewing was left out of the industrial strategy and industrial energy schemes. Will this now be changed?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend for his question. My heart sank when I heard the news and I pay tribute to my honourable friend for not only raising this today but for all his work in the sector since he came to this House and on behalf of his constituents. I spoke with the chief executive of Carlsberg Britvic yesterday and I know that the proposal to close the brewery has not been taken lightly. He reassured me that the team at Burton have shown exceptional commitment, skill and professionalism and have made an enormous contribution to Burton upon Trent's proud brewing tradition. This proposal is not a reflection on them or their quality of work.
Consumer tastes are constantly evolving and this proposal reflects the particular long-term challenges of cask ale that I know I've spoken to him about and will continue to work with him closely on. I know it will be a concerning time for workers at Marston's. Recognise the impact that these proposals may have on these workers, their families and local community as the company begins to consult and I look forward to discussing this further with him.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The hospitality sector provides around 300,000 jobs for young people every year and contributes 96 billion pounds annually to the economy, but despite this the government continues to hammer them with a series of blows to the extent that this sector has the highest effective tax rate of any sector in the economy, paying the equivalent of 82 pence of every one pound of pre-tax profit made in taxes. This eclipses the 50p average rate across our economy's 11 main sectors. Can the minister outline what steps the government are taking to tangibly lower business costs so that hospitality businesses can employ more young people?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
My first job was in hospitality. I remember it fondly. It's given me the skills throughout my career and in my life. It supported my family when we really needed them. I absolutely know the significance and importance of this sector, not just to our economy but the difference it can make to people's lives and change them.
They are a key employer of young people all across the country, in his constituency, in mine and of colleagues across this House. They provide that rewarding route into work and a critical sector in resolving the NEETs crisis and many challenges we face across the country. As we grow our economy, we want to grow the hospitality sector. I work really closely with them and the Hospitality Sector Council to make sure that we can look at all the challenges but also the opportunities, how we can work together to absolutely provide those more opportunities, provide those jobs, grow the sector in every constituency across this country, and I'm determined to deliver that.
Speaker 5
Madam Deputy Speaker, I have just led one of the largest trade missions we've ever sent to India, the fastest growing economy in the G20. I was joined by Northern Mayors, the Environment Secretary, the Scotland Secretary and a Great North delegation of more than 200 businesses. We announced over 1 billion pounds worth of new deals, benefiting a host of British firms including Menzies Aviation, Panacea and Oxford Nanopore. Since our trade agreement was signed, 12 billion pounds in new business has been announced, supporting thousands of jobs and driving good growth in every postcode of our country. During the visit, I co-chaired the Joint Economic and Trade Committee with Minister Goyal on tackling any remaining trade barriers.
And with our Northern Mayors, we also launched the UK-Maharashtra Growth Partnership to foster closer regional ties and drive the creation of high-value jobs in both our countries. This is just the start. Our FTA is forecast to boost bilateral trade by over 25 billion pounds a year. We have opened the door, Madam Deputy Speaker, and businesses are walking through it with government backing them every step of the way.
Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo
Madam Deputy Speaker, the Diamond Light Source facility and ISIS Neutron facility neighbor my constituency of Henley and Thame. They're on the frontline of cuts to the STFC. And now there are concerns that further savings may be required. Can the Minister confirm to the house today that these facilities will remain open and operational by the end of the financial year and through to 2028?
Speaker 5
I'm grateful to the question, this championing of science. I would refer to the comments I made about the scale of investment this government is making in science and R&D and the prioritization of funding which comes from, firstly, a science-based assessment. There is an element in funding the defense package where we've had to find the money from the former DSIT budget to do that. I will write about any concerns he has, but I reiterate this is a government and a country committed to science.
Alexander Forbes McIntyre
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yesterday I met with the Chief Executive of Ofcom with colleagues from this house to discuss our frustration at the lack of effectiveness of their enforcement action in improving Royal Mail services in my constituency. In Gloucester, we're getting post every couple of weeks at best. People are missing hospital appointments, they're missing important legal deadlines and quite frankly they're wondering whether they should put their Christmas cards in the post this week so that they might arrive in time for the 25th of December. Will the Minister set out how we can actually ensure that Ofcom have the powers to effectively enforce the USO so that Royal Mail services actually improve in my constituency?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I want to thank him and colleagues on this side of the house for their work on this. I agree that Royal Mail service has been unacceptable for too long and the pace of improvement must increase. My constituents share exactly the same frustrations. The government expects Ofcom to use its full range of existing tools to secure better outcomes for postal users and I'll continue to work closely with them and with colleagues in this house to deliver that.
Julia Dockerill
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State confessed last month that business leaders have urged him not to return to the political uncertainty around our relationship with the EU. The Prime Minister has now completely ignored him and them and says the UK could pursue a customs union, a single market or go all the way back in. He clearly was not in the 2017 to '19 Parliament, Madam Deputy Speaker, he's barely been in this one. So can the Secretary of State tell businesses which of these is the Prime Minister's preferred option?
Speaker 5
I'm grateful for that question. I'm proud of the trade deals this government has done with the rest of the world. We've talked about India, the Gulf, South Korea, Switzerland, we've retained the membership of CPTPP. But there is uncertainty that comes from actions on the European side. This is the Prime Minister's point.
Speaker 4
The Made in Europe agenda is one of great uncertainty to UK businesses. It's primarily about automotive and aerospace at this stage, but it runs through some 50 different bits of EU legislation. The Prime Minister is right, first of all, to have an aspiration of a closer trading relationship with the EU. I support that entirely consistently with our work with the rest of the world, but also to get to a point where we remove uncertainty by getting clarity on what this will mean for the long-term future of our relationship to the European Union.
Julia Dockerill
The Secretary of State could not say what the Prime Minister's preferred relationship is. I think that's because the Prime Minister himself doesn't actually have a clue. Now, the Business Secretary trumpeted today the free trade agreement struck with India. He's been taking northern mayors and a rep from Man City on his trip this week to expand it. Sir Keir Starmer spoke about his pride and relief at telling Jaguar Land Rover workers that he had struck a trade deal with America on cars that would save their jobs.
Now, these deals are possible because we are not in the EU. So can the Secretary of State guarantee that the Prime Minister will offer no concessions in the UK-EU trade talks underway that could jeopardize our non-EU trade deals?
Speaker 5
First of all, I'd just say we took 200 businesses to India. The mayors took their own delegations. The Manchester City representative came with the Mayor of Greater Manchester rather than me, so I would just like to put that on the record to avoid any lack of clarity about it. Yes, look, again I say, a lot of the things that were promised by the Conservative government, they weren't able to deliver on trade, were delivered and have been delivered by this government. Of course, I am proud about that.
But the fact is the Prime Minister is right, first of all, to have that aspiration for a closer trading relationship. Seven of our major top 10 trading partners are other EU member states, and to seek clarity for the future. That is what he's doing and I support him in that.
Speaker 88
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know the Secretary of State and the Minister enjoy a good pub as much as the next person. So do they share my concern that in Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven, our pubs and hospitality sector is under real strain and that we've recently lost two iconic LGBTQ+ bars, Charles Street Tap and R-Bar? So will they come to the south coast, meet with me and local businesses, and see what more we can do to support our hospitality and pub sector?
Speaker 5
Grateful to my honorable friend for the question. I do recognize the specific issues in Brighton about what the closure of R-Bar and Charles Street Tap will mean for Brighton's LGBTQ+ community. The government does recognize the needs of hospitality. We've talked in this session about lower business rates. We've also talked about the doubling of employment allowance.
But of course, I want to work with him and I'm grateful to him for raising it directly with me, and no one ever turns down a visit to Brighton, so we'll see if we can get that sorted.
Sarah Olney
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Monday, the Prime Minister joined the Liberal Democrats in acknowledging that refusing to countenance closer UK relations with the EU would be a dereliction of duty. However, the government remain committed to their red lines. Joining the single market and a new UK-EU customs union could boost UK GDP by at least 3.6% and result in around 27 billion pounds a year in extra tax revenue. So would the Secretary of State not agree with me that by refusing to cross these red lines while knowing the damage that Brexit continues to cause to businesses up and down the country is, in fact, a dereliction of duty?
Speaker 5
Well, I would say when I reflect on my first year doing this job after the election, there was some mixed advice from Liberal Democrats on trade at various times, particularly on our engagement with the US and with the EU. I do believe our package of measures that forms the basis of the UK-EU reset is ambitious. I mean, if you look at SPS agreement, what that would mean for small businesses, for the honorable lady's constituency, for all of us, would make a fundamental difference. So of course we're right to recognize it has been very hard for business. There is more red tape for people exporting to our major export market.
Speaker 70
We've got to recognize that, but I really do get frustrated at times when people don't acknowledge the kinds of things that already form part of these negotiations would make a difference to British businesses. And I think we'll have more ambitions or our own views on how that should go. There's an ambitious package that we should all get behind.
Callum Anderson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This summer, the Bletchley Investment Taskforce, which I established last year, finalised our investment prospectus, setting out all the opportunities that our town offers. And will the Minister meet with me and the taskforce to discuss how we can work together to attract the new business and jobs that ensure that we deliver growth in our postcode?
Speaker 15
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, I'd like to commend my honourable friend for the work of the Bletchley Investment Taskforce and thank him for the very many letters that he's sent me updating me on the work of the taskforce. I've learned about Bletchley's strengths in innovation, advanced manufacturing and digital technologies, all aligned with our industrial strategy. So of course I'd be very keen to come and meet the investment taskforce and perhaps we can talk about how the work of the Ox-Cam growth corridor can link in and bring more investment to Bletchley too.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Tomorrow I will be in Scunthorpe to attend a meeting of the council-led British Steel Development Board. Is the Secretary of State in a position to give me some positive news that I can pass on?
Blair McDougall
I was also in Scunthorpe very recently meeting with British Steel management and the unions. I think the positive news we can give them is Al Nevels now in place as chair is working hard to stabilise operations, improve health and safety and develop that long-term plan, which I know he has worked so hard with us to achieve.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the last year, I've also had countless constituents contact me about the adequacy of postal delivery services across Bexleyheath and Crayford. Along with colleagues, I met with the chief executive of Ofcom yesterday to look at what more they can do. But could the Minister please outline what assessment has been taken of the adequacy of those services across Bexleyheath and Crayford and what more the government can do to help my constituents?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend for raising this on behalf of his constituents and the frustrations that I know he shares and they do too. I've been clear with Royal Mail that its quality and service has been unacceptable for too long. I understand the concerns in the honourable member's constituency relate to the Bexleyheath delivery office and I know that he met with Royal Mail this summer and I encourage all members to raise their concerns directly with its management and similarly hold the company to account as I will continue to do. His constituents deserve a reliable postal service and a right to deserve better.
Dan Carden.
Edward Robert Jenrick
Shaun Egan from Morrisons in Walsall, Gary McCarthy from Sainsbury's in Wycombe, George Costa from Sainsbury's in Hertford. These are all workers who were sacked by their employers for confronting shoplifters. One, Gary, just hours after he'd applied CPR to the store's only security guard who would otherwise have died. Does the Secretary of State agree with me that these workers deserve their jobs back and that we do need greater protection for workers who just do the right thing and confront shoplifters?
Speaker 4
More than happy to look into the cases the honourable gentleman raises and we'll be in touch with him about it.
Josh Newbury.
Josh Newbury
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I visited Alpro and Navarra Oat Milling over the summer, I heard how rising energy costs are putting pressure on food manufacturers with knock-on effects for their supply chain and ultimately on food inflation. Given the importance of these energy-intensive industries to our economy, how's the department helping British manufacturers remain competitive, attract investment and mitigate rising food production costs?
Blair McDougall
So I know he's a great champion for that sector in particular. As has been said, the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme is open now. In addition to that, we'll be reviewing the supercharger later in the year and we'll be working very closely with the food manufacturing sector as we do that.
Chris Law.
Speaker 100
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As well as breaking the UK's legally binding climate commitments and contributing to global climate disaster, the approval of Rosebank will result in the UK continuing to facilitate illegal Israeli settlements in Palestine, being complicit in breaches of international law. Israeli energy company Delek Group, who owns Ithaca Energy, has been named in a UN list of businesses whose activities in the West Bank have raised particular human rights concerns and they receive over 200 million in revenue from the Rosebank field. Given Norway's sovereign wealth fund and largest pension fund have already divested from Delek, will the Secretary of State confirm that Delek Group Limited will be one of the companies sanctioned for its role in illegal settlement expansion?
Speaker 4
Madam Deputy Speaker, the honourable gentleman knows licensing of North Sea oil fields is a matter for the Energy Secretary, but in relation to his point about our announcement around sanctions for illegal Israeli settlements, I think we've made a clear and consistent stand.
We've talked about how the legal regime for that will be the SAMLA regime, the one that will provide more certainty. It will have real consequences, it's not just a symbolic gesture. I won't comment on any individual company, but I think if the honorable gentleman's intentions and aspirations are for strong action in this area, this government is providing it.
Henry Tufnell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's support for British industry, including through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme. However, the oil refinery sector is not included within this scheme, threatening thousands of jobs and our national energy security. So will the Secretary of State consider expanding the scope of the scheme and also reviewing its broader eligibility requirements?
Blair McDougall
Well, I thank him for that and for his consistent support for the refining industry. I've been meeting with that industry this week, discussing issues including the energy issues that he mentions. We recognize the sector's facing real challenges. The work to consider the impacts and the feasibility of bringing refined products, for example, into the scope of the UK CBAM remains ongoing, and we'll certainly continue to engage with him on energy costs and other issues.
Tessa Munt
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've been contacted by Petruth Paddocks, a family-run camping business on the outskirts of Cheddar, which welcomes over 20,000 visitors a year and supports more than 50 jobs. Their business rates liability this year has increased by almost 2,700%, from £1,070 per annum to £28,820 per annum, with no meaningful warning and no chance to plan for this catastrophic hike. Will the Minister or the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss what can be done in rural Somerset, where so many businesses depend on hospitality and tourism, but really cannot take this kind of a kicking?
Speaker 4
Well, those are obviously dramatic figures. I assume it's through revaluation and we'll endeavor to get her in contact perhaps with the Treasury rather than this department to support her constituents.
Dominic Liam Byrne
On Tuesday, the head of MI5 warned that AI could help terrorists develop bioweapons, while in committee, OpenAI and Anthropic told us that statutory AI safety controls are now essential. We are blessed to have the AI Security Institute in this country, but it's no longer enough. So will ministers confirm that we will have government amendments at report stage of the Cyber Resilience Bill to ensure that we have statutory AI protections to keep this country safe?
Speaker 46
Well, can I thank my right honorable friend for his advocacy and leadership on this matter over the course of the last many weeks as well. I have mentioned already this week that I want to work with parliamentarians across the House, including him and his committee, on ideas for the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, looking in particular at protections on AI security.
Christine Jardine
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. A lot of work is being done in Scotland, in Edinburgh, Glasgow, and elsewhere to develop a space culture, space technology, satellite technology. With the controversy this week about the potential interference with Ukrainian war effort using satellite technology, is the government intending stepping up the investment and support for research and development in this area in the interests of our own national security?
Speaker 5
I was very much hoping for a space question and I'm very grateful to the honorable lady. Space is, I think, one of the most exciting and fundamental horizontal technologies for our economy. I recently attended the International Space Summit in Paris about that.
We launched our space strategy. Scotland is key to this. She will know about the SaxaVord launch capacity investment. And I can assure her we'll keep her involved in the progress of this successful strategy.
Speaker 79
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It will surprise no one in this House to hear that I believe growth in every postcode should start in our towns. So would the Minister please tell me what we are doing to support brilliant businesses like Hill Helicopters in my constituency grow, thrive, and export?
Blair McDougall
I spent a fantastic day with the aerospace industry last week. And over and over again, they spoke so enthusiastically about ATI and the investments we're putting into that sector. I pay tribute to the company she mentioned in her constituency. Advanced manufacturing of all sorts is one of the things we are really good at in this country, which is why we're backing it with the industrial strategy.
Paul William Forster
Madam Deputy Speaker, last month McLaren announced a 500 million pound investment which will create a thousand jobs, particularly beneficial in my constituency of Woking. I know the Secretary of State visited the constituency to share in that good news. What steps is he and the government taking to ensure McLaren and other businesses can expand like that?
Speaker 5
Well, it was always a pleasure to visit McLaren and I was delighted it was part of an investment in the automotive sector this month of 850 million pounds alone. Incredibly strong and supportive investments that reflect the incentives we put in place in the industrial strategy. I know there's a specific issue locally on making sure that investment happens. We're talking to the company about that. And of course our trade, our innovation, our wider business agenda is all about supporting successful companies like this.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Secretary of State join me in congratulating Malcolm Wilson OBE and the team at M-Sport in Dovenby on re-securing the Ford World Rally Car Championship program, creating new skilled jobs for Cumbria? And can the Secretary of State tell us what support the department can provide to help high-performance automotive firms like M-Sport create skilled apprenticeships for our young people?
Speaker 5
I will thoroughly endorse that. I believe he and I once campaigned quite close to where the business is based. And it's brilliant news and reflects the tremendous industrial heritage of Cumbria.
Susan Murray
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I suspect I'm going to add to the Secretary of State's frustration when I ask on behalf of Scottish food and drink exporters who still face paperwork and border checks that didn't exist before Brexit. If growth is the mission, will the Secretary of State open talks on a customs union with the EU?
Speaker 5
Mr. Speaker, we can all go for breakfast soon. Of course I understand, particularly on food and agriculture. That's part of the EU-UK reset to do that. I would also point to, for instance, the tremendous opportunities we've created. If you look at the tariff on Scottish whisky in India, 150% down to 75%, then 40% in time.
Scottish salmon as well is part of that. So I promise her we are always championing in every market the interest of her constituents.
Alison Louise Hume
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Boulby Underground Laboratory in North Yorkshire is competing to host XLZD, a prestigious physics experiment that could deliver Nobel Prize-winning discoveries in the UK. In the light of the STFC cuts, can the Minister reaffirm the government's commitment to securing the XLZD dark matter experiment for the UK?
Speaker 15
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's quite a number of years since I was underground at Boulby, but I do remember the experience and how important that dark matter laboratory is. This particular issue at the Boulby mine is that they've increased their capacity there and so their rental charges have gone up. And within the scope of their existing budget, that means about half a million pounds of their 1 million pound operating budget has been taken forward into the 4 million pounds overall budget that they have. The government has funded the development of the laboratory that she describes until 2027-28.
Speaker 74
If the UK is successful, though, that would require additional funding above and beyond existing budgets.
Julie Minns
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. There is much interest from aerospace companies in the 1950s Blue Streak launch facilities at RAF Spadeadam in my constituency. Can I ask the Minister what assessment has been made of UK sites for the potential of developing heavy lift rocket testing in the UK and will he meet with me to discuss the potential of Spadeadam?
Speaker 15
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Spadeadam is of course another amazing facility that I have visited in recent years and she's quite right. There is the potential there and I do agree with her that a fuller assessment of this alongside our other launch facility in the Shet- in the Shetland Islands must be made.
Euan Stainbank
With Grangemouth operations despite the government's substantial offer to intervene we have a narrow window to avoid this incredibly well-positioned site lying vacant. What interventions are the government prepared to make to seriously secure new industry and new jobs for this site and more broadly the Grangemouth industrial complex this side of 2030?
Blair McDougall
Sorry. I- well he's a constant advocate for the Grangemouth site. Last night I met with the National Wealth Fund with the Office for Investment and my own officials to push forward on this. We have a task force meeting on Monday where amongst other things we'll be pushing for faster action to prepare the groundwork for investment so that we can deploy the 200 million from the National Wealth Fund that we've set aside.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Truro lost its post office last week as well without a temporary alternative. Would the Minister consider consulting with the Post Office on alternatives when this happens in main cities and looking again at that franchise model which seems to leave post office branches very vulnerable?
Speaker 78
I thank her for raising this and bringing it to my attention. I'd be more than happy to meet and discuss further.
Perran Moon
Madam Deputy Speaker plans to revive Cornish tin and tungsten mining are well advanced with the support of the National Wealth Fund but tin or tungsten were it to be brought to the surface today we'd have to be shipped to the other side of the world for refining and process with a process with only a fraction coming back to the UK and at seriously increased cost. When Cornish MPs meet with the Minister next week can we discuss plans from government to invest in domestic refinement of tin and tungsten?
Blair McDougall
Well absolutely discuss that. As he knows because he talks to me about this at every available opportunity we're determined to make sure that more of the value of that entire process remains in the UK which is why we're putting 50 million pounds on the table for exactly that sort of development work.
Ian Lavery
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Royal Mail sorting offices in Blyth and Ashington in my patch are in absolute chaos. They're in meltdown. I'm really concerned that someone in my patch is going to end up in a tragic situation because of the lack of service. What I've met with the Royal Mail on numerous occasions there's been no change whatsoever in fact it's getting worse.
What can the Minister do to remedy the situation before somebody needs to be accountable for a very serious situation?
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend for his question and share his frustrations and concerns. Whether it's the biggest issue in my inbox and constituency to colleagues that I've heard from across the House it's clear and I've made it very frank in my discussions with the Royal Mail CEO they have to do better. They have to deliver improvements at a much quicker pace. I'll continue working with him to make sure we can deliver for his constituents and those across the country that need a reliable postal service.
Speaker 102
That is the end of Business Innovation Science and Trade questions. I'll give the front benches a moment to shuffle over.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. To ask the Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs if she will make a statement on the sustainable farming incentive.
Speaker 84
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In summer 2024, we inherited an SFI scheme from the previous Conservative government with no budget control and no proper alignment of SFI actions to environmental sustainability targets. The farming schemes were underspent, meaning millions of pounds were not going to farming businesses. This government implemented many improvements to SFI 26 to make it more focused, more transparent and fairer, so that as many farmers as possible can benefit from agreements. For example, we introduced the new rule that each farm business can only have one SFI 26 agreement, which cannot exceed 100,000 pounds per year.
We streamlined the number of SFI actions to remove complexity while still having plenty of actions available for all farm types. We held a first application window earlier in summer, which was only open to two groups: small farms and also farms without existing environmental land management revenue agreements. Window two of the sustainable farming incentive 2026 opened on the morning of Tuesday the 22nd of September 2026 and closed at 3:48 PM on the same day. It was open to all farmers and land managers with at least three hectares of agricultural land. Now, I recognize some farmers who wanted to join SFI 26 will be disappointed not to have secured an agreement this year.
There was an exceptional demand for SFI 26, which demonstrates farmers' desire to invest in the environment because healthy soils and thriving habitats are fundamental for farm profitability, productivity, sustainability and resilience. In anticipation of high demand, we allocated additional 20 million pounds to window two, on top of the 50 million announced by the Prime Minister in August, so we could fund as many agreements as possible. We have therefore allocated a total of 310 million pounds to nearly 19,000 new agreements across both application windows in SFI 26, including 253 million pounds and 12,200 new agreements through window two. We now have 70,000 multi-year ELM agreements in place. These agreements will invest a total of 930 million pounds in environmental sustainable farming over the next three years, nearly a billion pounds of investment in nature-friendly farming, as part of 11.8 billion in funding for sustainable farming in this parliament.
We plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027 and we will look to open the 2027 offer as early as possible to ensure farmers can access funding. We are already looking to make changes to improve SFI for next year, continuing our close work with farmers and stakeholders by listening to experiences and learning lessons from this window. In keeping with the commitments made in the farming roadmap 2050, we plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027. As part of this, we are scrapping the first-come-first-served application process for SFI in 2027. We will look to open the 2027 window as early as possible to ensure farmers can access funding and we will work with farming representative organizations, including the NFU, to consider how we refine the scheme for SFI 2027.
Speaker 83
As set out in the farming roadmap published earlier this year, this government is committed to a farming sector that is productive, profitable and resilient.
Robbie Moore
Madam Deputy Speaker, I cannot stress enough just how bad the mishandling of the sustainable farming incentive has been under this Labour government. It has been a complete and utter mess and our hardworking farmers and nature have once again lost out under this Labour government. But it wasn't without warning, lots of warning being given to this government well in advance.
After 18 months of inaction following the government's choice to close the scheme in March 25, for the first time ever, the scheme was changed to operate on a first-come, first-served basis, making it competitive with no quality control, simply based on who could press send first. The consequence, a build-up of nearly 40,000 farmers trying to get into the scheme when it finally opened. But only 12,200 were successful. The application window closed within five and a half hours after it was open after all the money had gone. Farmers had been designing their applications for months and many are now under even more financial and emotional strain.
So I ask the Minister, given the value of the expiring agreements was over 520 million and the budget for SFI 26 was significantly reduced to 310 million, can the Minister explain where the 210 million has gone? With so many farmers being locked out of the scheme, clarity and certainty for next steps is needed now. So can the Minister confirm when applications for SFI 27 will open? Will he publish a forward plan now so that farmers can start preparing? What support will he give those with expiring agreements to minimize gaps in cash flow?
And what budget has the Minister allocated for SFI 27 so that he can be certain that we will not see this same debacle all over again? The Minister has now had a month to reflect on these issues. Our farmers want answers now, not more warm words or surveys being given out by the farming minister saying that he's in listening mode. Answers are needed right now to the questions that have been raised.
Speaker 84
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm not going to claim that this scheme is perfect or it is working at all, or is it what we want it to be. But this is a scheme we inherited from the previous government and it's one we are fixing. Under them, just a quarter of the funding went to 4% of farms, often large ones, with no targeting. We've already made changes to address that with a window earlier this year specifically for small farms and those that hadn't participated in the scheme before.
If they thought this scheme wasn't working, why didn't they do anything to fix it when they were in years of power? And if they didn't think that it should be a first-come, first-served approach, then why didn't they change it? I mean, I noticed that the Shadow Environment Secretary said at party conference, and I quote, "After 18 months of inaction, Labour chose to design the scheme for the first time ever on a first-come, first-served basis." I mean, this simply isn't true. And I'd encourage him to correct the record.
And as I say, it's a bit rich that he's coming here today with all these different things. He could have done something to change this when he had the opportunity to do so. So they couldn't even get all the funding out the door, leaving money on the table when it should have been going into farmers' pockets. And I won't accept that criticism, Madam Deputy Speaker. This scheme was designed by them, but we are fixing it.
And that's what I will continue doing.
Daniel Zeichner
Thank you, Minister. When the Conservatives introduced this scheme in the last Parliament, the plain truth is it was a complex scheme, but particularly the IT systems weren't in place to administer it properly. And the front bench know that. And these IT systems take years to develop. So colleagues at the RPA have done a heroic job working around using existing systems.
That is why it is so difficult to make this scheme work for the very difficult circumstances across the country. So does my honorable friend agree with me that a little contrition on the other side would be welcome as we try and fix this system?
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for his question and also place on the public record the hard work that he undertook as Minister of State in the department.
He was a tremendous contributor to many of the things that I've now inherited to deliver for our country. He's absolutely right to point out the hypocrisy of the party opposite on the SFI scheme. And I remind him that of course it was Michael Gove, I think, first introduced the first-come-first-served approach. And I also want to pay tribute to the hard work of the RPA who have worked incredibly hard in light of the level of applications and demand we've seen on this scheme. And I look forward to working with him as we take further improvements to ensure the success of this scheme next year.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. SFI is the foundation of resilient food systems and it delivers for nature. When it closed without warning last year, the Liberal Democrats warned of the damage to farm finances and our environmental goals. Now farmers face a two-tier system once again. Claire farms near Puckington.
Her countryside stewardship scheme agreement is ending and SFI was meant to be her way forward. Now farmers deserve better than a Glastonbury ticket scramble. So I welcome the end of first-come-first-served, but a fairer queue for the same small pot just changes who gets turned away. The Liberal Democrats would back farmers with an extra billion pounds a year to produce food and protect nature, not choose between them. With the budget just two weeks away, will the minister back our call and press the Chancellor to fund SFI properly?
Speaker 84
I thank the shadow spokesperson for her contribution and the constructive way that she's been engaging with me and my department on these issues. I absolutely recognize it's been an incredibly challenging time for farmers. And I mentioned in the outset some of the funding that we have been putting into sustainable farming, 11.8 billion over this Parliament. And I mentioned the significant figure this year alone via various schemes, 2.3 billion has been made available for the farming budget this year. I will certainly take on board the points that she's raised and reflect on that as we design the scheme for next year and look forward to working closely with her on next steps.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Isn't it time we simply admit that the SFI experiment has failed? The last government couldn't get the money out the door. We now have an IT system so bad we may as well not have a door. Farmers don't believe it's fair.
They don't believe it's getting to those that need support or believe it's delivering the public goods it stated to. Perhaps we should start again, reconsider a universal baseline with best practice conditions.
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for his question. I know he's yet to write to me on any issues that his farmers have raised on SFI 26 and I'd encourage him to do so. I meant it when I said it in my opening remarks that I'm really keen to work in partnership with others to design a scheme that works for all farmers next year. I look forward to his proactive engagement with me in order to get the scheme right next year.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. So just how many applications did the department expect they would receive when they opened the window? The Soil Benchmark, the farming software platform, publicly estimated that there would be about 40,000 applications and they thought there would be budget for about 15,000 successful ones. In event it was about 12,000. So if Soil Benchmark could do that calculation, why didn't the department, or did the department do that calculation and did they then open the scheme in the knowledge that approximately two-thirds to three-quarters would be disappointed at the end of it?
Speaker 84
I thank the chair of the Select Committee for his measured intervention and look forward to being before the Select Committee later this month. We obviously anticipated there would be high demand for the scheme this year, hence the reason why we had two windows and increased funding for the overall pot to 310 million.
I've obviously mentioned earlier the window two and the window two process. Defra expected strong initial demand and made clear before the window opened that its duration would depend on the rate of applications. Ministers obviously allocated the 50 million and then the additional 20 million as well. We're really keen to learn from all in the sector on what we could do to improve the scheme going forward and I look forward to his contributions in due course.
Josh Newbury
Avid readers of the Sun may have seen some of my comments on this situation already, and I could ask many questions, but I'll limit myself to this one. Many would-be applicants once again experienced technical issues and those who phoned the Rural Payments Agency reported hours-long wait times, and I hope that his team are looking into that. The Department has said that there will be a further very limited window for those who had technical issues, but could the Minister tell the House whether that only includes those who were able to speak to someone and report those issues, or whether it'll also include those who frankly gave up when they knew they'd have to wait hours to speak to an RPA agent?
Speaker 84
I thank my hon. friend for his question and indeed the way he's been engaging with me in terms of thinking through the design for the scheme for next year. He's right to say that some farmers reported technical issues on the application service which prevented them from applying. It's normal to receive these reports after the application windows close; some of them will be valid. The RPA is currently working through them as we speak. If he has any particular examples he wants to share with me, I can certainly take those away and raise the questions with relevant officials in my Department.
Roger Gale
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, Kent was once rightly regarded as the garden of England. Faced with intolerable pressures upon their finances, many of the small farmers in Kent having looked to the sustainability scheme for help and having been denied it, are now having to sell their land for housing and other development, further denying us national sustainability in food. Can the Minister tell the House how many farmers in Kent are benefiting from the scheme?
Speaker 84
I thank the hon. member for his question. We are publishing the figures for applications across counties and constituencies, so I can certainly make that information available to him. More broadly, he makes the point around the demands that farmers are faced and our farming roadmap published earlier this year is a 25-year plan to commit to a more profitable, productive sector and building resilience in the farming community, and I'm very keen to work in partnership with the farmers in his constituency and area to make sure that is delivered.
Perran Moon
Madam Deputy Speaker, when the Shadow Minister next gets to the despatch box, I hope he will withdraw the inaccuracy that the scheme was for the first time ever built on a first-come, first-served basis. This is simply not the case and they know it. Does the Minister agree that farmers deserve better than the rewriting of history from the party that left a half-built, half-baked transition, and can the Minister expand a little bit more on his plans to reform the RPA in time for SFI 27?
Speaker 84
I thank my hon. friend for his question. He's a real champion for farmers in his constituency and it's very evident from the contributions that he makes which are so informed in this House. He's absolutely right to call out the opposition for the action or inaction that they took when they had the opportunity to take forward work to improve the lives of farmers across our country. I'm very happy to meet with him on the specific points that he raises to make sure that I have his insight as we design the scheme for next year.
John Glen
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Most farmers invest in a plan over several years. And there are over 12,000 who have been in receipt of previous grants who were unable to fulfill what they expected this year. What thoughts does the Minister have on those individuals where significant sums of money already invested through the taxpayer will essentially go to waste? And with the RPA, what's he going to publish in terms of the barriers?
Most farmers get very frustrated that they can't work out what they've done wrong.
Speaker 84
I thank the right hon. member for his question and the way that he's engaging in these issues.
Obviously our annual report sets out how we spend the farming budget. If he's not yet had chance to see that, I encourage him to do so. And on the specific points around the RPA and issues and frustrations of farmers in his constituency, I'll certainly take that back to the Department and look into those issues that he's raised.
Julie Minns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government was absolutely right to redesign the SFI to prioritize smaller farming businesses so that taxpayer money supports more farms. However, in Cumbria, 54% of the land is less favorable, which means that my farmers have to hold more land in order to get a viable farm, pushing them into the window two. Will the Minister, when he looks at the next SFI, please ensure that acreage alone should not determine which window farmers apply in?
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for her question. It was a real pleasure to have met her recently on some of the particular challenges that her constituency is facing and wider issues around bluetongue and other matters. I will certainly bear in mind the constructive points that she's raised today as we design the scheme for next year.
Speaker 123
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Anthony Henman farms Pegtop Farm at Woodeaton. He has SFI agreements that expire in March of next year. When I spoke to him this morning, he told me that these are vital to us, we can't survive without them. Does the Minister understand the huge pressure facing our farms, not least in light of the extraordinary global price of fertilizers, and that many of them are simply on the edge?
And what assurances can I give Anthony and other farmers in my constituency that the SFI 27 will be announced early, adequately funded, and properly managed?
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for his question. I absolutely recognize the difficult year that farmers have faced across the country and indeed in his own constituency. And that's why I'm keen to open SFI 27 as early as possible, and I gave that assurance earlier from the dispatch box. It's worth noting that this year through all the schemes 2.3 billion is going into the farming budget and over the lifetime of this Parliament 11.8 billion. But certainly keen to hear any further thoughts as we design the scheme for next year.
Chris Hinchliff
Madam Deputy Speaker, the fundamental problem is that for years our country hasn't allocated enough of our national resources to growing food in a way that boosts biodiversity. We've now got a nature crisis that is increasingly a threat to our national security. We need every farm that can to do more on nature-friendly farming. So can the Minister reassure me that his department is talking to the Treasury about securing greater investment in SFI going forward?
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for his question. He will know that we were responding to our settlement from Treasury and therefore, you know, there's always more we can do. And that's why we published our farming roadmap earlier this year, which sets out the direction of travel we want to take around building a more resilient, productive farming sector working in partnership with the sector to deliver nature-friendly farming.
Speaker 115
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the 21st of December, my constituent spent the day with the Minister. So therefore it is unsurprising that on the 22nd of September he went to market. However, he got home at 3:50 in the afternoon to complete his agreement that had already been worked on to find that he was two minutes too late and £50,000 down as a result. He said to me, I am jumping mad, this is a insert expletive here show.
How can anyone be expected to manage a small business and compete in a fastest to the button lottery like this? I just wonder how the Minister would have felt if he had to apply for his parliamentary seat in that way.
Speaker 84
Well, I thank the honorable member for her question and for her encouragement for me to visit Dartmoor recently. I know she wasn't able to join me on that visit, but it was a very insightful visit. And I absolutely recognize the human difficulty it's been for farmers that haven't been able to apply for the scheme this year. If she's got particular examples as she's just described she wanted to feed into me, it's really important that I hear those. So I thank her again and know that there is obviously wider support available for farmers which we can signpost people to via the blog post on the Defra website.
Speaker 117
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As my honorable friend for Carlisle said, upland farms by their very nature have to be larger. I met with upland farmers in Northumberland recently and I heard from them their frustration that window one of SFI excluded them simply because their farms were too big geographically to be included within it. So can he commit to working with myself, working with other Northumberland MPs, work with my honorable friend from Carlisle, but also working with the NFU uplands group to ensure a redesigned scheme properly supports upland farms?
Speaker 84
I thank my honorable friend for his question, the way that he's been engaging with me already on learning lessons from SFI 26 and for convening colleagues in doing so. Uplands are an area of priority for me. I'm very impressed by the work that Dr. Hilary Cotton's been doing in Dartmoor and obviously we're looking to deliver that scheme elsewhere in the country. It's absolutely something that I want to take forward with him and I look forward to doing so.
Charlie Dewhirst.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The simple fact of the matter is that this scheme portal opened at 10:00 AM and closed at 3:48 PM at a time when most farmers are at work. And for agents representing farmers, that was simply not enough time to fill in multiple applications. So a very simple question to the minister: will you apologize?
Speaker 84
I thank the member for his question. The scheme was what it was. We inherited a mess from the previous administration. I am keen to learn lessons from what worked. And as I recognized earlier, I appreciate the heartache it's caused many farmers and therefore there's more action we need to take.
Adam Dance.
Adam Dance
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Because SFI wave two funding closed within hours, many Yeovil farmers were shut out despite being prepared. That included Tim, who was awarded water quality farmer of the year literally the same day. Does the minister recognize that even farmers who have been awarded for environmental friendly land management are now left in a financial hole? So what is the government going to do to encourage sustainable farming in Yeovil?
Speaker 84
The member will have heard what I said at the outset with regards to our farming roadmap, which sets out the long-term vision for delivering a more nature-friendly farming sector. This year alone, as I mentioned, we've announced 2.3 billion extra, well, 2.3 billion going into the farming budget with 11.8 billion going in over the lifetime of this parliament. There are other schemes available for farmers and I'd encourage him to look at the Defra blog, which sets out those details further.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As if farmers in my constituency didn't have their heads in their hands enough at the attitude to farming of this government, this latest debacle, turning something so important to our farmers' livelihoods into some sort of perverse six-hour first-fingers-on-the-buzzers game show, has them even more in despair. And I'm afraid the minister's nothing-to-see-here answers that he's given this afternoon will cause even more distress. So perhaps he can engage with some of the detail. My honorable friend the shadow minister asked him a very, very specific question about the 210 million pound difference between the value of expiring agreements valued at over 520 million pounds and the 310 million pound SFI budget.
Speaker 84
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll take no lectures from the party opposite in the fact that they had a scheme that was half-baked and didn't even deliver anything or put money in the pockets of farmers.
Robert Jenrick.
Edward Robert Jenrick
When I went to my agricultural shows in Nottinghamshire in August, all the farmers told me that this was going to be a complete shambles. And it was a complete shambles. This isn't a surprise. Everyone knew this was going to be a disaster. And we've just heard in an answer to the previous question that the minister knew this was going to be massively oversubscribed.
And yet he proceeded. He said the scheme was half-cocked, but he's now put his own name to it. Is he going to apologize for the complete fiasco that he has put my farmers through and what is he going to do next year to ensure this insult is never applied again?
Speaker 84
It's a little rich coming from the member opposite who served in the previous Conservative government that designed this scheme. But I mean if he wants to be constructive and engage with my department on any particular examples of how we can improve the scheme going forward, I'd like to hear from him.
Luke Morgan Evans
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I know the minister's a good man, I've worked with him to secure funding on schools when he was a school's minister. So does he understand and will he simply say sorry to those small farmers who are out working in Hinckley and Bosworth up and down the country who don't have a land agent to get it in within six hours? Will he show some contrition and simply say that on his watch this scheme didn't work, he'll learn the lessons and simply say sorry?
Speaker 84
I said at the outset, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's been a brutal year for farmers across our country with drought, with input costs rising and obviously various other factors as well. I hear those messages loud and clear from the regular engagement I have with the farming community. We need to learn lessons, but I remind him that most of this scheme we inherited from the previous government.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The minister recently visited Dartmoor and Richard, a farmer on Dartmoor, was just one of the many farmers who wrote to me following the SFI scheme to say that he, his farm, which which protects and enhances the beauty and the environmental environment of of Dartmoor, they've been in a scheme for 30 years and they lost out on this application. And he and his wife are now seriously wondering how they're going to make ends meet. And I've heard from numerous other farmers who have lost out, whose schemes will now end and don't know how they're going to survive. I think it would be really good if the minister could show a little bit more contrition and humility and just say, yeah, it didn't work and we're really sorry and we're going to do better next year.
Speaker 84
Can he guarantee that the scheme will be better designed next year, will operate better, will support the smaller farmers who rely on it for their future and will be adequately funded?
I thank the member for her question. I said at the outset that there are lessons that need to be learned from this scheme this year, so I hope she's heard that message loud and clear. If she's got particular examples and frustrations from farmers in her constituency, then I encourage her to get in touch with me because it's really important we do learn lessons from this scheme this year as we continue to make improvements for next year.
Speaker 120
Madam Deputy Speaker, I refer to the register. Does the minister have any idea how long it takes to design and then apply for an SFI? And all that chucked away in a six and a half hour lottery. And his response today, and he's got his back to me, he's not even listening to the question. His response today has been symbolic of the shrugged shoulders attitude of the lanyard classes to farmers for far too long.
He's had two and a half years to fix this problem if, as he says, he inherited it. Does he understand even the boiling sense of frustration and anger that farmers have?
Speaker 84
I thank the honorable member for his question. I'm engaging all the time with farmers across the country and with their representatives. They are at the heart of our redesign of the scheme for next year, with workshops starting today. And I've already met with representatives from the NFU and been on the farms listening to farmers and their views about those that applied and those that were unable to do so. Absolutely I understand the frustrations that people feel, but I'm committed to improving it for the future.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister knows, because I wrote to him the day after this latest SFI shambles, that farmers in North Herefordshire are livid about this problem. Farmers in Orleton, Puddleston, Linley Green, Kimbolton, Dilwyn and more have all written to me to tell me not only that they're hopping mad, but they're also distressed and depressed at the devastating impact that this is having on their livelihoods and their prospects of continuing to run their farms. So will the Minister recognise that farmers do need to hear sorry? They need support, they need sustainability and certainty, not a lottery of fingers on the buzzers.
And fundamentally, they do need direct answers to these questions. Why is there less money available now under this than there was previously? Why did the government not learn the lessons from the failure last year, and what are they going to do to genuinely own this problem?
Minister.
Speaker 84
I don't accept that we haven't learned lessons from the past, and that's why we made a number of changes for SFI 26, as I set out in the outset of my statement today. And of course I am sorry if people applied for the scheme and were unsuccessful, and I understand people's frustrations, and that's why I'm working hard to put it right.
Andrew Murrison
Deputy Speaker, many farms in Wiltshire are marginal at best, and now they're having to divert investment into a pot to pay future inheritance taxes, they honestly are being pushed over the edge. What does the Minister think this latest is going to do for their businesses, and what assessment has he made, regardless of attribution of blame, on how many farms are actually going to be sold up, that families will pack up and go away as a result of this latest round of Defra incompetence?
Minister.
Speaker 84
I thank the member for his question. As I said at the outset, it's worth noting that 2.3 billion has been made available for the farming budget this year, with 11.8 billion for sustainable farming throughout the lifetime of this Parliament. If he's got particular examples he wants to share with me in terms of farmers that have been unable to apply for SFI 26, I encourage him to share those with me. For the first time since the Second World War, a government has published a farming roadmap to bring certainty to the sector, and I'm busy getting on delivering that, working in partnership with the sector to ensure profitable, productive and a more resilient farming sector for the future.
Wendy Morton.
Michael Peter Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. At a time when the government really should be supporting the producers of our food and the guardians of our countryside, they saw fit to open the new SFI scheme offer and then close it down after just six hours. Will he acknowledge that his government got this wrong? Will he provide a roadmap, a forward look for the farmers, detailing what the next scheme will be, give them more notice and assure them and this House that they will have more time next time round?
Speaker 84
I thank the honourable member for her question, and I mentioned at the outset that it was her government that introduced the first-come, first-served approach. But absolutely keen to make sure we make changes and improvements for future years, and if she's got practical ideas about how we make that happen, I'd be delighted to hear from her.
Tessa Munt.
Wendy Morton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I just, I wanted to point out to the Minister that a lot of the farmers in my area have terrible difficulties with buffering, or broadband access, internet access is poor. And I had actually thought...
Tessa Munt
Tessa Munt. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I just, I wanted to point out to the minister that a lot of the farmers in my area have terrible difficulties with buffering or broadband access, internet access is poor. And I had actually thought that those who had agents were the lucky ones, but I was informed quite neatly after I'd said something about this on the fact that actually most of the agents only managed to get eight, nine, ten applications in the very short window that was available. So that wasn't the case.
He's mentioned the fact that he's going to be running workshops with farmers, but has he actually asked the Rural Payments Agency to do a high-speed review, because he's not got very much time before 2027. So that the barriers to applicants, particularly those who had expiring agreements and those who do use agents, can be removed.
Speaker 84
Thank the member for her question, and I can assure her that I've obviously met with the RPA on lessons learned from the scheme and what worked well this year, and we will do the analysis of what the applications tell us.
Ashley Peter Fox
Ashley Fox. Madam Deputy Speaker, farmers across Somerset have been left without certainty and support by this latest snafu by Defra, and they will not be consoled by the thought of a workshop. How does the minister envisage farmers will be able to plan financially for the year ahead if they don't know when the next round is or how the funds will be allocated?
Speaker 84
We will publish more information about future rounds in due course. He would have heard my message that we're keen to open SFI 27 as early as possible into the new year. There are lots of ways that farmers can feed in their thoughts and views on the scheme for the future, and indeed there are other funding schemes available for farmers, so I do encourage him to check the Defra blog for that information.
Gideon Amos
Gideon Amos. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The dozen farmers I was with out on the levels last week from North Curry, Stoke St Gregory and surrounding areas were visibly shaken by the economic impacts they're facing, the price of diesel, and this latest debacle has been disastrous for farmers. They are considering ripping out the trees and margins that were planted under previous funding initiatives because they simply won't be able to continue without the funding being provided under this initiative, which seems to have only gone to around 12, 10-12% of farms in the country. Can the minister tell me what he would have me say to those farmers about the loss of the wildlife that they've already put in?
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Alicia Kearns. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The NFU and farmers were a klaxon on the impending car crash that unraveled. The words of a local farmer, a debacle, the words of a Labour MP. Having had no decency to warn farmers it was coming, today was an opportunity for humility rather than gaslighting that some of the technical complaints, only some, were legitimate.
Will the minister at least now publish a transparent breakdown of how the farming budget in its entirety is being spent, because that is the least that farmers deserve after this debacle?
Speaker 84
Thank the member for her question. Obviously our annual report sets out how the farming budget is spent, and when we announce future rounds of schemes we set out the overall budget available. I mentioned earlier the amount available that was for SFI this year. We will continue to be as transparent as we possibly can be on the figures available for farmers.
Jim Shannon
Final question, Jim Shannon. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thank the minister for his answers. While the Sustainable Farming Incentive applies specifically to England, the funding allocation underpinning it directly impacts upon devolved regions. And given that the Ulster Farmers' Union, I declare an interest as a member, have expressed severe concern over long-term stability of the multi-year agriculture budget and the transition away from direct support, what discussions has the minister had with the DAERA minister and the Northern Ireland Assembly to ensure that the unique family farm structure in Northern Ireland is strengthened and protected within the Barnett consequentials and the UK-wide funding envelopes and to help towards soaring costs?
Thank you so much.
Speaker 84
I always appreciate a question from my honourable friend and will certainly look into the issues that he describes, but he will know that farming is a devolved matter, but he will know my commitment to working in partnership with the Northern Ireland government and have already met with my counterparts in Northern Ireland.
Perran Moon
Point of order, Perrin Moon.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier, the Shadow Minister may have inadvertently led the House by stating that for the first time this scheme was changed to operate on a first-come, first-served basis. That is simply not the case. First-come, first-served was set up under the Conservatives. Can the Deputy Speaker advise how the record may have been corrected?
Speaker 6
I thank the honourable member for his point of order. Members themselves are responsible for what they say in the chamber and not the chair. If the Shadow Minister wishes to clarify his earlier remarks, that it is for him, but he needs to keep it short because I do not want to continue the debate. Shadow Minister.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As a matter of fact, when the SFI window was closed under this Labour government in March of 2025, that process in itself led to a huge demand that came up to September this time, therefore making it competitive and first-come, first-served. That is exactly the scenario.
Speaker 144
We're not going to continue the debate. Order, order. We are not going to continue the debate. The urgent question is over. If the front bench may wish to shuffle over.
Speaker 133
Right, if we're ready for business questions, I call the Shadow Leader, Jesse Norman.
Speaker 132
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Leader give the House the business?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The business for the week commencing the 19th of October will include Monday the 19th of October, Committee of the whole House of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill day one, Tuesday the 20th of October, conclusion of Committee and remaining stages of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, Wednesday the 21st of October, consideration of an allocation of time motion followed by all stages of the Church Appointments Repeal of Discriminatory Provisions Bill followed by an opposition day, a half-day opposition day on a motion in the name of the Liberal Democrats subject to be announced, Thursday the 22nd of October, tributes to the Clerk of the House followed by a general debate on Black History Month, on Friday the 23rd of October the House will not be sitting. The provisional business for the week commencing the 26th of October will include Monday the 26th of October, a general debate on the performance of Royal Mail followed by a general debate on the emerging risks of advanced AI, the subjects for these debates determined by the Backbench Business Committee, Tuesday the 27th of October, second reading of the Building Safety Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc Bill, Wednesday the 28th of October, my right honourable friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer will deliver his budget statement, Thursday the 29th of October, continuation of the budget debate, and Friday the 30th of October the House will not be sitting.
Alexander Jesse Norman
I thank the leader very much for the business. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me associate myself first of all with everything that's been said in the previous debate about the fiasco of the sustainable farming incentive. We meet today on the fifth anniversary of the death, the murder of Sir David Amess. I know all colleagues will want to join me in celebrating David, his perennial optimism, his beaming smile, his enormous gift for friendship and his unfailing energy in assisting and supporting his constituents. The independent report into his murder led by Sir Robert Buckland cannot come too soon.
I have three matters to raise. The first relates indirectly to David Amess. As the leader will know, at Prime Minister's Questions yesterday, the Prime Minister described the man charged with the murder of our former colleague Ann Widdecombe as the man responsible for her murder. That statement breached the legal presumption of innocence, discussed a case which is sub judice and misled the house. It must have been inadvertent, but there has been no clarification yet.
Speaker 135
We don't accuse each other of misleading the house. Inadvertently is the word we use prior to that. Justin Orme.
Alexander Jesse Norman
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, as I think I said it's inadvertent whatever took place. But there's been no clarification from the Prime Minister or any minister, no withdrawal of the remark and no apology. That is deeply disrespectful, disrespectful of this house and of the chair. Will the leader now correct the record, withdraw the remark and apologize on behalf of the Prime Minister? Secondly, as the house will know, Manchester City has been found guilty by an independent commission of 114 of the 115 charges brought against it by the Premier League, including inaccurate financial reporting, undisclosed remuneration and failure to cooperate with the investigations.
This week, having previously been neutral on the issue, the Prime Minister sought to distance himself personally from the club and its owners, but otherwise he and ministers have remained remarkably quiet, especially since his own club Everton had an eight-point deduction for two breaches, that's 112 fewer than have been found here, just three years ago. So can the leader set out the government's position? Does it regard these breaches as extremely serious, or does it believe that a few eggs may have been broken but broadly speaking everything is all right, and when will we get a statement from the sports minister on this subject? Finally, last November, I highlighted the severe flooding suffered by Ewyas Harold in my constituency. Homes were inundated, people and businesses were evacuated, families left with huge financial and emotional costs.
Insurance premiums have gone up where insurance remains available at all. The school, the doctor's surgery and access for emergency services were cut off. Other nearby villages, including Clodock, Kentchurch and Altyrynys were similarly afflicted. But now, 11 months later, despite an all-party meeting which I convened last March and repeated representations to ministers, to the Environment Agency and Herefordshire Council, there has been no substantive progress. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government's own Office for Science believes El Niño is likely to be bigger than ever this year.
My constituents are deeply anxious that floods this winter will drive them yet again from their homes and businesses. Fixing this does not require some vast engineering project. Better drainage, watercourse maintenance, management of runoff and other practical mitigations could all make the difference. But the residents are in a catch-22 situation that will be familiar to many people across this house. No one in authority is taking any responsibility, but they are not allowed by law to help themselves.
The works could all be done legally, quickly and effectively this year by local companies at less than half the cost of the EA's framework contractors, but that is prohibited. No one will come to the aid of these people, but put one foot into the watercourse just to clear the debris and they risk prosecution.
I've made a final, a formal budget submission to the Chancellor on this matter. Will the Leader now take it up personally with the Chancellor and the Environment Secretary and make funding this scheme the first order of business for the government's new flood resilience task force?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I first of all associate myself absolutely with the comments of the Shadow Leader of the House with regard to Sir David Amess, as he said today is the anniversary, the fifth anniversary of his tragic murder, and I know that the thoughts of the whole House will remain with his loved ones. He was well regarded on both sides of the House. He was a mentor to lots of new members and a fantastic constituency MP, and what happened was an absolute tragedy. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to welcome members back to the House after the conference recess and congratulate the new member for Holborn and St Pancras to her place as she joined us on Monday.
It's also good, Madam Deputy Speaker, to see the Shadow Leader in his place. We missed him earlier in the week, and I was concerned that he was still in the half-empty conference hall in Birmingham, wondering whether the Shadow Chancellor had actually finished his speech or not. It was a busy conference season, and at the Labour conference the Prime Minister made several important announcements, including outlining plans for a National Care Service, which will provide the elderly with free personal care. The government has also announced that the triple lock will remain until the end of this Parliament, following which it will be adjusted, not least to pay for the new National Care Service. Now, I don't blame the official opposition for doing this because partly it's their job, but they did jump in very quickly to oppose any change to the triple lock.
And I find that quite surprising, Madam Deputy Speaker, because in August 2021, the Shadow Chancellor wrote a comment piece entitled Unpick the Triple Lock. And I understand that this view that it should be unpicked is shared by the current Shadow Secretary for Communities and at least one former Chancellor. And it appears to me, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the party opposite are really tying themselves in knots on this matter, and it would be very helpful if the Leader of the Opposition or someone from her shadow cabinet came to the House to clear up the confusion. I want to turn to the budget, and I did announce in the forthcoming business the date of the budget and the beginning of the debate which will be following. And in that debate, I hope that the House will be able to reflect on Britain's economic outlook.
And to that end, the House's attention to the positive report of the IMF this week, upgrading our growth to 1.3% this year, joint second highest in the G7. Also the comments of the IMF's chief economist, who said that the UK stands out, his words, not mine, on deficit reduction, with our deficit falling significantly more than other G7 nations. And also other good news this morning with GDP having grown more than expected. We're not complacent, Madam Deputy Speaker, but the Chancellor is absolutely focused on priorities to boost business, help with the cost of living and support people in every postcode, all underpinned by the fiscal discipline which characterizes this government.
I also want to talk about flood action week and this ties in really with what the right honorable gentleman said about the situation in his constituency. Monday marked the start of flood action week and the government has invested 4.2 billion pounds in flood protection measures and we've new targets to improve flood protection for 200,000 properties. We've also launched the flood action online portal on Monday which brings together clear actionable guidance for people to check their flood risk and find the latest weather alerts. This is an issue which has been raised regularly at business questions by members from both sides of the house and I thank them for doing so. That doesn't address the particular issue that the right honorable gentleman rightly raised on behalf of his constituents.
So let me say two things further on flooding. One is that if he wants to make his case to the floods minister I will arrange for him to do so and he asks about making representation to the chancellor. I'll make sure that the chancellor hears what he has said today. I'm not going to say obviously because I don't know what is in the budget but I will make sure that the chancellor hears that. In terms of the other points that he made I'm not sure that he's been characteristically fair as he normally is because the prime minister has acknowledged that he misspoke.
The right honorable gentleman was out quite quickly and rightly to make his case yesterday and the prime minister did respond. He said that he misspoke. He has apologized and he has corrected the record. And I think Madam Deputy Speaker there isn't an excuse for misspeaking in the house and I'm not trying to explain that away. But this prime minister is characterized by an authenticity and a passion in the way that he responds.
It's not unusual either for prime ministers or for anybody else to speak in the house. As long as you correct the record which he has done then I think that that should be put into perspective. He also raises the issue of Manchester City. And the prime minister again has been characteristically very clear about this. He's made clear that the initial judgment on the club is very serious and that there is no one suggesting that anybody is above the rules.
There is an ongoing independent process. It's important that it is allowed to run its course as quickly and as fairly as possible. And at the end of that if the sports minister needs to come to make a statement to this house I'm quite sure that she'll do that.
David Edmund Burton-Sampson
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. And as the shadow leader and leader of the house pointed out today is indeed the fifth anniversary of the tragic murder of Sir David Amess in my constituency. And my thoughts today are with his family, his conservative colleagues here and in Southend and indeed all colleagues and constituents who knew Sir David. As his plaque behind me says may his light remain. The children's parliament was founded by Sir David Amess and it was a project that was really close to his heart.
And I'm delighted that today on this anniversary we're going to be joined by the current child MPs here in parliament today and I'm sure it's going to be a really lively debate. So will the leader join me in celebrating the enthusiasm of these children who are showing a keen interest in democracy at a young age?
Lucy Maria Powell
I certainly join my honorable friend in everything that he said about David Amess and also recognize the importance that Sir David gave to involving young people in our parliamentary process. And I welcome them to the house today. I wish them well in everything that they do. And it's important that we support them not just learning about the political process but perhaps exploring how they can contribute more to it.
Bobby Dean
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I join the Leader of the House in his tribute to Sir David Amess. It's clear how well-loved he was across the House, and our thoughts are with his family on today. The Leader of the House also mentioned the party conference season, and I think Liberal Democrats want to warmly welcome the Prime Minister's moving towards our positions on Europe, social care, and electoral reform at conference. We'd urge him to go further and faster on all three fronts.
Not appreciated by these benches over here, but we certainly appreciate progress on Europe, social care, and electoral reform. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to raise an issue today that I think is an emerging scandal, and it's relating to the treatment of Hongkongers entitled to British National Overseas status. Now, the UK obviously has a historic commitment to those people, with the promise of democracy being maintained in Hong Kong, or a pathway to the UK itself for those citizens. And many, of course, have taken that up. However, we've received reports that many BNO applications are now being refused on the basis of past convictions made in Hong Kong.
Now, UK rules state that if their conviction is an offence in the UK and the sentence is for longer than 12 months, then that should result in an automatic refusal. And some Hongkongers were convicted for longer than 12 months for the offence of rioting, which is an offence in the UK, but of course they weren't really rioting, they were engaging in peaceful democratic protest. Now, we've raised these concerns directly with the Home Office and they say that discretion can be applied, but the guidance we've seen says otherwise. And the fact is, we know that people are now being rejected on this basis. And to add insult to injury, these rejection letters say that these decisions have been made by a competent foreign court.
I hope the Leader of the House agrees that this would be a betrayal of the UK's historic commitment to these people. And so can he organise for the ministers to issue clear guidance about the specific discretion that is required in these cases.
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sure the House won't have missed the opening comment of the honourable gentleman when he talked about his party's positions on Europe. It's not unusual for the Lib Dems to have many positions on many things. In terms of conference, I'm sure he enjoyed his conference, not least because he probably got more sleep when he was there than he might have done with a young child at home. But there we are. But what I would say is a difference between our conference and his is that our leader of the party came out strengthened from our conference.
I'm not sure the Lib Dems can say the same. On the serious matter, on the serious matter which he raises, because it is a serious matter, we have granted over 230,000 visas under the British National Overseas visa route, and we are honouring our commitment to supporting Hongkongers facing political pressure. We remain committed to supporting Hong Kong residents and welcoming eligible applications under the scheme. Every application involving a prior conviction is assessed individually on its merits. And we are ensuring that actions which are not considered criminal offences under UK law do not bar applicants from safety.
But I give him my word that I will go back to the Home Office, and if that needs to be clarified, then I will draw that to their attention.
Torcuil Crichton
Madam Deputy Speaker, the Western Isles have been struck this week by maritime tragedy with the sinking of the fishing vessel Kildare in a Tuesday night storm off the coast of Lewis, with what is feared is the subsequent loss of three souls aboard. Can I pay thanks and tribute to the Coastguard officers, the RNLI crews, helicopters, and police officers who are still involved in the search for two of these missing men. These winds and events like this cut deeply into our communities and leave salted wounds of grief. I think of Ness, Barvas, and Carloway, and the homes and villages that these crews left from.
And that pain of grief will be echoed in other coastal communities across the country. All those who fish will mourn and they that spread their nets on the ocean will languish. And for that reason, can I ask the Leader of the House to join me in expressing deep condolences to the families and communities affected and to all the other families and fishers who touch that razor's edge of the deep every day and for our good go down to the sea in ships.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure the whole House will join me and the honorable gentleman in extending our most heartfelt condolences to the friends and families of those who have lost their lives. I want to join him in paying tribute to the brave members of the RNLI and Coastguard involved in the search and rescue. And as a coastal MP myself, and it's coming up to the 60th anniversary of the loss of the Gaul, the biggest single trawler loss in the industry's history, and six men were from my constituency and we marked that event over the summer. I know absolutely the importance of loss and how it's felt to fishing communities.
Speaker 151
And I know how important the work of the RNLI and Coastguard are and how deeply appreciated they are.
Bob Blackman
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I join with others in paying tribute to the late Sir David Amess. He was always here for business questions with a topical question and a smile on his face. I thank the Leader for announcing the business for the 26th of October in the Chamber. And given the experience this week on Monday of the baby loss awareness debate, I thank him for giving protected time for that debate.
Given, as you will know, Madam Deputy Speaker, the debate on the performance of Royal Mail given business and trade questions this morning is likely to be extremely well attended. I would ask if the Leader could consider giving protected time for those two debates, particularly if there are going to be government statements or urgent questions. Now, the business in Westminster Hall for next week for the 20th of October will be a debate on manufacturing skills. On Thursday the 22nd of October, there will be a select committee statement from the Science, Innovation and Technology Committee, followed by a debate on compensation for Rectual Life policyholders, followed by a debate on the legacy of the Jarrow Crusade on the 90th anniversary. On the 27th of October, there'll be a debate on recognizing the production and serving of cask ale as an intangible cultural heritage.
I thus prefer drinking about it, drinking it rather than talking about it. On Thursday the 29th, there'll be a debate on mandatory safeguarding 24/7 helipads at major trauma centers, followed by a debate on the role and effectiveness of Ofcom. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, a couple of house notes. We are short of a Labour member on the committee and I hope that that can be filled quickly because we had a problem this week where we had the bare quorum in order to do our business. I'd also say that we did have an application for obviously for Black History Month.
I notice this is now a government debate. The risk here is, however, the front benches get two bites at the cherry, which reduces the time for backbenchers to contribute. This would have been a backbench business debate led by the backbenchers, but I understand completely that the Leader wants to offer that as a general debate.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are in the course of Navratri, a celebration for Hindus across the world, and it's a joyous occasion. We are literally halfway through it. But last Saturday, I attended the World Sindhi Congress, and this week I received a delegation of ex-Bangladeshi politicians and Sanatans. They raised the same issue, and that the plight of Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh is is desperate right now. I receive messages literally every day of atrocities committed against the Hindu population of Bangladesh and Pakistan.
Now, I know the Foreign and Commonwealth Office is obviously concentrating on the illegal war between Russia and Ukraine and the crisis in the Middle East. But could we have a statement on what the government is going to do to help protect these minorities in Pakistan and in Bangladesh?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the honorable gentleman for his work chairing the committee and indeed the work of the whole committee in terms of the baby loss debate. I think there was an element of discipline this time, which was it wasn't just that there was the it was timed, allocated time, but there was an element of discipline which I welcome. I don't think it was perfect, but I think we are getting better. I'll bear in mind what he says about Monday the 26th, but but my initial reaction is it isn't always either necessary or welcome that we have a a time for a guaranteed time for debates. I think maybe we should take it on a case-by-case basis, but I'll give some thought to what he says.
I also take away the point about making sure that the committee has full membership, and I'll seek to ensure that this is resolved as quickly as possible. And I'll also raise with the frontbench spokespersons on Black History Month to bear in mind what he is said to make sure that backbenchers, because it would have been probably a backbench business debate otherwise, that they do get the time that they need. I just want to get onto the the point, the serious points that he made about the protection of minorities. But it would be remiss of me if I didn't, and I hope the whole House will join with me in doing this, send our most heartfelt condolences to the friends and family of those impacted by the tragic school collapse in Pakistan, which the news came out overnight, and we send our heartfelt best wishes to those communities. In terms of the treatment of Hindus and others, the UK strongly condemns all instances of hate or violence directed towards minority religious communities in Pakistan, including Shia Muslims, Ahmadis, Christians, Hindus, and Sikhs.
And we do work with the international community to promote human rights in partnership with Pakistan. But I will draw his comments to the attention of the FCDO. And I hear what he's saying about there being lots of other things going on and and not least what is happening in Ukraine and in the Middle East, but that's no excuse for taking our eye off the ball if we can do something to help in a situation like this.
Speaker 158
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Vincent Chand abused baby girls at a Bright Horizons nursery in my constituency for seven years. The Guardian has now revealed that three years before he was arrested, a complaint was made about Vincent Chand, which was investigated by Bright Horizons and overseen by Camden Council, which cleared him and allowed him to return to work where he continued abusing little children until he was arrested. I have asked Camden Council and Bright Horizons for the full documentation relating to the investigation that took place in 2021. But could I ask the leader if we can have a debate in government time about strengthening the safeguarding practices in nurseries, particularly in the Bright Horizons chain, where Ofsted has taken the unprecedented step of issuing two welfare requirements notices to the nurseries in their chain?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to thank my honorable friend for raising this matter again. She's doing an excellent job in keeping it at the forefront of our minds. The safeguarding of young children is our utmost priority. We have announced a range of measures to improve early years safeguarding over the summer, and the Department for Education has established an expert advisory group on safeguarding, including CCTV and digital devices in early years settings, and that will report before Christmas. But if my honorable friend is seeking a meeting with the department to get an update on these matters, I'll help her to arrange one.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like many members across the House who attended their various party conferences, I visited the Guide Dogs stand at our party conference, and they made the point, as they regularly do, about the dangers of pavement parking, not only to those with guide dogs, but to the disabled and other groups. I know the government have recently had a consultation and taken a view that further legislation is needed, and devolving the power to local authorities is fine, but of course they need the resources available to them. Could the Leader arrange for a statement from the appropriate minister?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, and I too met with Guide Dogs at my, at our conference, and they do a fantastic job campaigning on what is a really important issue. As the honorable gentleman has said, we have made some steps forward in government on this, but we recognize that there are more things to do. I can't guarantee him a statement, but if he wants to hear from the mouth of ministers about what our plans might be going forward, then if he was to seek perhaps a Westminster Hall debate or an adjournment debate, then he might get that.
Kim Marie Johnson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Palestinian families have been denied family reunification, and this has been found to be unlawful in the court. These include the families of Obeida and Mahmoud, two boys who met with the former Prime Minister last year, who promised to do everything he could to ensure their families were reunited with them. So can the Leader of the House provide debate time in government time to debate Palestinian visa schemes so that we can scrutinize these very important issues?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend is a strong advocate on these issues, and should she again seek an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate, she can put it directly to ministers. The government is very keen to do all that we can in this regard, but I think a debate, an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate is the way forward for her.
Edward Leigh
With regard to the Church Appointments Discriminatory Provision Bill, I'm not sure that many of us Jews and Catholics have really felt discriminated against since 1829, and we think there may be more important things for the government to do, and I'm not sure many of us want to actually be involved in appointing Anglican bishops, although we might improve the number of bishops who talk about God rather than social issues. Can I just turn to a much more immediate and important issue: restoration and renewal of Parliament. The Leader knows I've been involved in this for many years, constantly urging action. We really need to get on with it. We need to repeal the existing bill, which stops work carrying on around us.
There's a horrible rumor that we're now going to go back to delaying the whole thing to 2032, talking about full decant.
Speaker 157
So can you give us a report on how we're going to get on with repairing this building?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm sure the right honourable gentleman will make his points about the Catholic Relief Act or indeed the discrimination from the 1860s banning Jews from certain things. I'm sure you'll make that in the debate if he is able to. But perhaps the difference is of course that we have a Catholic Prime Minister and therefore it's very keen that if he is to take part in any of these deliberations that he has that nothing gets in the way of that. But this is, you know, outdated legislation and I'm sure that we would be keen to, the House would be keen to want to make those changes.
In terms of renewal and restoration, there was a report, there is a report suggesting a way forward. I have committed to bringing forward a motion in order to, because I do agree with him absolutely, it's time that we did actually get on with this. There isn't full agreement across the House about what that actually means, but it is important that we get that debate. I wouldn't believe everything that he has been told or indeed read about any postponement. The purpose is not to postpone it.
The reality is it's been postponed for far too long. The longer we postpone it, the more it costs, not just to keep this place functioning, but also the cost of eventually getting round to doing something about it. My approach however, and I admit, has not been one to rush into this and get the House to rush into this, because I want a consensus if we can. I think that's the best way going forward actually. There isn't a consensus, but I think that we can work towards doing that.
And I want to build in as many safeguards as possible. For example, I'd like to see the outcome of the inquiry by the Public Accounts Committee, because quite rightly, MPs will be asking how do you actually ensure that this is going to be, if we do decide to do it, value for money. But in terms of timing, all I would say is we do need to get on with it, so watch this space.
Marsha Cordova
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Albert Bridge in Battersea has been closed now for more than eight months amid safety concerns. Obviously this is causing severe delay and disruption to my constituents and businesses alike. Now, we know the bridges in Battersea and bridges across London play a vital role in keeping London moving. So can we have a debate in government time on how we can make our bridges a strategic asset under the national government oversight?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Two things, either my honourable friend may want to make that point directly to DfT ministers or indeed if it's essential infrastructure to the Cabinet Office and I can help to arrange that for her. Or of course she could seek a debate because I'm sure there are colleagues, not least from London, across the House who will share her frustration about what is currently happening and hear from the minister how best if possible the government can resolve the matter.
Michael Peter Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I don't know if the Leader of the House has seen the Sky War Games series recently, but the central message of that is that we are not ready. We might be more ready had the promised Defence Readiness Bill come into this session of Parliament, but it was inexplicably dropped from His Majesty's speech. Could the Leader advise whether there are plans to bring this bill forward at some point and whether he's had any conversations or will he have conversations with the Defence Secretary to hasten it along?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Of course this session was quite crowded and one shouldn't read into the fact that a bill doesn't appear is the fact that it's not important to the government. It is a question of sometimes of priority and what needs to be done. I hear what he says, but the government is absolutely committed to doing everything that we can to make sure that this country stands by our allies but also we're able to defend ourselves too. I'm not going to speculate about what's in the third session either, but I will go away and give some thought and talk to the Defence Secretary as the honourable gentleman has raised and to ensure that it's the forefront of his mind.
David Pintor-Dushinsky
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sometimes in our lives, we are fortunate to meet someone truly inspirational. Rabbi Bernt Koshland was such a person. Bernt came to this country on a Kindertransport just aged eight. His parents were not so lucky.
Speaker 164
He never saw them again. Many of us would have been broken by such a tragedy, but Bernt triumphed over this adversity. He dedicated his life to education, teaching generation after generation and telling his story to children around the globe. In 2018, he was awarded an MBE for his role as one of this country's leading Holocaust educators. Bernt was a man of huge compassion, warmth, humility, and humour.
He loved his family and was a proud great-grandfather. It was my honour to call him a friend and talk to him almost every week for many years. We lost Bernt over recess. Our community in Hendon mourns him dearly, but his legacy will live on. Will the Leader of the House join me in celebrating Bernt's life, thanking him for his huge contribution to this country, and passing on this House's deepest condolences to his family?
Lucy Maria Powell
Yes, I will, Madam Deputy Speaker. Rabbi Bernt Koshland led a remarkable life. He dedicated himself to educating us about the horrors of the Holocaust, which we must never ever forget, and we are eternally grateful to him for his significant contribution to our country. And I'm sure the whole House will join me in sending our condolences to his friends, his family, and all those who knew him.
Julian Lewis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And may I invite the Leader of the House and other colleagues to do their best to watch the 15-minute video on the MACE YouTube channel entitled "The Medical Mesh Scandal: Ruining Women's Lives", which was screened last night at a meeting chaired excellently by the honourable member for Washington and Gateshead South. This deals with, of course, the scandal about pelvic mesh, and it is rather disconcerting that two and a half years after the publication of the report by the Patient Safety Commissioner, Professor Henrietta Hughes, the government's response on her proposals even for interim redress has not yet been made. Will the Leader of the House take up this cause, which is supported by people in all parts of the House?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the right honourable gentleman is right to invite members to watch that to be more informed on what I know is an issue of considerable concern across the House. We do recognise the profound life-changing impact that these harms have had on individuals and their families, and as he will know, we are carefully considering the Hughes report. But I understand the frustration and the timescales, and I will ask that ministers will update him and indeed anyone else who's interested in this.
Sharon Hodgson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And following on from my honourable friend across the House, I, along with many other colleagues of all parties, attended this brilliant, if I may say, for something that was so devastating to watch, for so many women who have been harmed by mesh. And the honourable member has already laid out the details of the Hughes report, why we're still waiting for a response. And I would also encourage colleagues to watch the MACE documentary and to share it with as far widely as they can.
And also if I, we seem to be at a stalemate with this. The government changed hands after the Hughes report was published, but we are now over two years on. There is definitely a stalemate, so will the Leader of the House meet with me and my honourable member from the Conservatives to discuss how we can take this forward?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I certainly pay tribute to my honourable friend who's been an assiduous and tireless campaigner on this matter, and she continues rightly to raise this. As I said to the right honourable gentleman, I do appreciate the frustration in this regard and also the timescale that it has taken. I don't know why it has taken so long, but rather than to meet with me, I think it would be more useful perhaps if she met and perhaps the right honourable gentleman met with ministers in order to see if this can be sorted out.
Roger Gale
Madam Deputy Speaker, may I first associate myself with the remarks that have already been made about the murder of Sir David Amess five years ago to this day. David was a dear personal friend. He came into the House on the same day as myself and the right honourable gentleman, the leader, the father of the House, in 1983. And I think I'm right in saying that had David lived as he should have done, it would be he who would have been the father of the House today. Madam Deputy Speaker, David was a passionate supporter of animal welfare issues.
Earlier this week, my friend, the right honourable lady, the member for Newport West, introduced a ten-minute rule bill to have a closed season for the killing of hares, something that I lent my name to and I know that David would have been, would have done had he been here. That bill is due to have its second reading on the 19th of March 2027. As a ten-minute rule bill, ordinarily it would not go very far. Would the Leader of the House see if he can find his way to ensuring that it has government support?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I also pay tribute to the right honourable gentleman who again has been a passionate supporter on animal welfare issues and a consistent supporter on animal welfare issues and echo his words about Sir David Amess. I'll look out for the ten-minute rule bill. I do hope that the House gives its support. I'll give some thought as to what the government might be able to do to assist that, but without giving him any false hope, we are looking at a third session to see if there is scope for wildlife issues in that. And therefore it may be that even if the government doesn't bring forward something, then I'm sure he will find a way of attaching it to anything that's got the world, the word wildlife in it.
Julie Minns.
Julie Minns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Cumberland and Westmorland wrestling is one of my region's most distinctive sporting and cultural traditions. And I'm delighted that plans are underway for Carlisle to host the 2027 European Championships of the International Federation of Celtic Wrestling. Will the Leader of the House join me in welcoming this exciting opportunity to showcase this unique UNESCO-recognised living heritage sport? And can he assist me in securing a meeting with the sports minister to discuss how the government might support this prestigious international event?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Hosting the 2027 European Championships of the International Federation of Celtic Wrestling in Carlisle is fantastic news. And it will do two things. First of all, people will learn more about the sport, I hope, but in visiting they'll also learn more about the fantastic city of Carlisle. And I'm sure it will bring wider benefits than just the sport itself.
Speaker 171
And I will ensure that she gets the meeting with the sports minister that she requests so that there is a, there is a continuation even after the championships have finished of an acknowledgement of this sport and the impact that it can have.
Alexander Carmichael
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Might we have a debate in government time on the various growing crises facing the UK fishing industries? I've learned today, Madam Deputy Speaker, that recently one Norwegian trawler, the Havstrand, landed from one trip 787 tonnes of saithe caught in the waters around Shetland. So that's one 70-metre freezer trawler landed from one trip an amount roughly equivalent to half of the quota that is available for all Shetland boats in one year. This is not a new problem.
Alistair Carmichael.
Alexander Carmichael
I've complained about the imbalance between UK and Norwegian boats for a long time now, but it demonstrates surely that if these problems are not going to be addressed, then they will be, and this has become urgent.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I believe that the best way forward for the right honourable gentleman is for him to make his case directly to ministers. If he waits for DEFRA questions, which I think are next week, or if he wants a perhaps longer and greater opportunity to do that, then I'll arrange for him to meet the fishing minister.
Mohammad Yasin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's pledge at conference that the days of leaseholders being squeezed for every penny are coming to an end. In advance of the government's planned leasehold reform legislation, will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on leaseholders' concerns, including spiralling service and insurance charges, non-qualifying leaseholders, and bills that are opaque, duplicated, or contain errors, so that members can raise their constituents' experiences and press for an end to these unfair and often unaffordable costs?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and let me join the House in wishing my honourable friend a happy birthday. In terms of leasehold reform, we are committed to ending the feudal leasehold system and bringing forward legislation to deliver as quickly as possible. And it is, as the Prime Minister said at conference, a priority for him, and that's about implementing the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act of last year, but also going further. If he wishes to make the strong case before any further legislation comes forward, if he wishes to begin to make the case that he is putting forward today, then I suggest an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall would be well attended.
John Lamont
Thank you very much. As the Leader of the House will be aware, the recent works to Carriage Gates here at Westminster cost the taxpayer over 62 million pounds, which was significantly over budget. But it's now been brought to my attention that fire engines may not be able to get through these new gates. So can the Leader undertake to urgently investigate this further, and can the Leader assure us that these arrangements in place, that the arrangements will be put in place so that fire engines will be able to get into the Palace of Westminster if there is a fire?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm very concerned to hear that, and I simply hope it's not true, but I will go away and investigate. There is, for example, a commission meeting on Monday where perhaps we can raise this question to get reassurances.
But it also underlines the importance of making sure that we get on with R&R and we address some of these issues because there is a huge fire risk in this place. That's not overegging it, there just is. And it is important and as I said, I hope it's not true, but I will take it away and think about it and find out whether it is true.
Speaker 174
Madam Deputy Speaker, the government's announcement yesterday that it was partnering with UK hospitality firms to deliver 100,000 jobs to young people not in education, training or employment was hugely welcome. But one such partner, amid widespread claims of bullying, sexual harassment and discrimination, has been placed under monitoring by the Equality and Human Rights watchdog. Will colleagues be bringing a statement to this House so that they can assure us that appropriate safeguards are going to be put in place for any employee taken on?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's absolutely vital that those safeguards are put in place. And if she wishes to discuss concerns with ministers, I'll help her to arrange a meeting. But I'll also bear in mind what she's said because the government is doing some important work in trying to support hospitality, but also crucially trying to get young people into work. And if there is a need for a statement in the future, then I will make sure that one is delivered.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week I was contacted by a constituent who faces a £300 a month shortfall between her rent and her local housing allowance. She's deeply concerned about the rent arrears and indeed risk of homelessness that that might force her and her family into. And it's a situation affecting people across the country. On that very same day, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation published a report showing how rent controls could reduce the cost to the Exchequer of the unfreezing of local housing allowance by more than a billion pounds by 2030-31.
So can we have a debate in government time about the urgent need to unfreeze local housing allowance and to institute rent controls so that we can avoid these risks of homelessness and the devastating impact and worry and distress that this is causing to so many of our constituents?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government is absolutely committed to everything that we can to support people with the cost of living crisis. That includes the cost of housing, but also making sure that we get rid of the problem of homelessness and not add them to them. Should she seek a debate on these matters, then she can put those points to the relevant minister. But I have to say that rent controls in the government's view are not the panacea that she seems to suggest.
Ian Lavery
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the 1st of January next year, the government will rightly ban the disgraceful practice of fire and rehire, yet some employers appear determined to exploit the situation before these protections take effect. In the North East, Taylor Wimpey has just issued dismissal notices to 31 joiners and 19 scaffolders in an attempt to force them onto worse terms and conditions, leaving hardworking families facing uncertainty in the run-up to Christmas. Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on this shameful practice and join me in urging Taylor Wimpey to withdraw these notices and return to meaningful negotiations with the workforce and Unite the Union?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend as ever is a champion for working people in his constituency and the reports which he raised, which I know from contact with my constituency, are deeply concerning. As he points out, the Employment Rights Act aims at preventing unscrupulous fire and rehire practices and guarantees fundamental protections for working people. But let me be absolutely clear, it is unacceptable for any employer to attempt to degrade workers' terms and conditions before statutory protections come into effect.
And I hope that employers, including Taylor Wimpey, hear his comments today, because I can assure you that if they don't, he's going to continue to make them.
Ashley Peter Fox
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The quality of life of many local people in Bridgwater is being undermined by a small minority who show little regard for others, with street drinking, drug misuse, shoplifting, and other forms of intimidating and anti-social behaviour. There is widespread perception locally that Somerset Council and the police are not responding with the urgency that the situation demands. So can I ask for a debate in government time on what more can be done to support towns like Bridgwater, so that the interests of decent, law-abiding residents and businesses come first, and we can restore pride and confidence in our town centre.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The total funding settlement for the police for 2026-27 provides up to 21.2 billion pounds for police forces, for counter-terrorism policing and wider systems. But it's only important if that money actually finds its way to the front line, particularly in town centres, because what he has said will actually echo in other town centres too. And it's important that we use that money to get extra neighbourhood officers on patrol. But I hope that his local council and indeed his local police force have heard what he has said, because they have an absolutely crucial role to play in this.
If they're getting the resources that they need, no excuses: they need to get on and use them to make sure that people feel safe in their town and village centres.
Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I chair the APPG on Reparations, and this Saturday, the 17th October, will be our fourth annual conference. This has been an eventful year in the global campaign, with the UN declaring the trafficking of enslaved Africans as the gravest crime against humanity, the King referring a petition from Jamaica to the Privy Council, and a UK representative even speaking at a UNGA side event on restitution. Yet the FCDO still hasn't accepted our invitation to address the conference. Given the changing global landscape and the likely focus at the upcoming Commonwealth Heads of Government Summit on reparations, will the Leader of the House encourage his colleagues to send a minister, or at least let us know when we might expect a slightly changed statement on the government's evolving position on reparatory justice?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed. The government's position on reparations, and I saw what happened in particular with the petition that came from Jamaica, the government's position hasn't changed. But I will take away her request to see whether FCDO can provide a minister, because it's important that we work together even if it's the case that some people will not want to necessarily hear what the government has to say.
Douglas Lumsden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before recess, senior officials from Ofcom gave a dreadful performance at the Scottish Affairs Committee as they failed to justify why my constituents in Aberdeen South were denied bespoke news programme coverage via STV North. And it was Ofcom who allowed this to happen, despite clear local opposition. Now Ofcom's local responsibilities have grown substantially in recent years, yet it appears unable to fulfill its basic duty to ensure sufficient regional news coverage. So can I ask the Leader of the House if he will grant a debate in government time on whether Ofcom is still able to fulfill the legal responsibilities it was founded for.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed. I'm a big fan of the select committee process, but however, it does need people to, when they give evidence, to actually take part in that in good faith and actually give a good response to the questions that come from members. Let me take away to the relevant department and think about this, but if he wants a debate to make length the cases that the case that he's making, then a Westminster Hall debate or adjournment debate is the way to do that.
Callum Anderson.
Callum Anderson
Madam Deputy Speaker, over the conference recess, I had the pleasure of joining pupils, staff, and parents at Buckingham Primary School to celebrate their platinum award for outdoor play and learning, which is so crucial to helping children foster a sense of creativity, independence, and confidence. So will the leader join me in joining in in congratulating the school on their achievement, and might he consider a debate in government time to grant a debate on the importance of outdoor play on children's health and well-being?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed, and I certainly join my honorable friend in thanking the staff at Buckingham Primary School and nursery, as well as teaching staff across the country for their hard work and their commitment. I've seen it first-hand in my own constituency, the importance of outdoor play and outdoor learning, and I agree with him, it is so important. I'd encourage him to apply for a Westminster Hall debate, however, so that he and other members can actually highlight the benefits of outdoor play because as I say, I think this is a really important matter going forward.
Sarah Dyke.
Joanne Sarah Dyke
Madam Deputy Speaker, as the nights draw in and temperatures start to drop, householders who rely on heating oil are facing bills that have doubled in a year. Unlike gas and electricity, heating oil has no price cap to protect them. The sector simply isn't working for consumers. That's why the Liberal Democrats are calling for the cap to be extended to every household that relies on heating oil. So will the leader of the house urge the relevant minister to meet me without delay so no family in Glastonbury and Somerton is left to face this winter in a cold home?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government has already made some important steps in this regard, and I'm not going to speculate, but but cost of living and the cost of energy and heating is certainly I know at the forefront of the Chancellor's mind. But if she wants a meeting with the relevant minister to draw attention to the particular issues affecting her constituency, then I'll help her to arrange one.
Tracy Gilbert.
Tracy Gilbert
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The leader of the house may be aware of the recent coverage around the industry's concerns on the future deployment of floating offshore wind technology in the North Sea. Significant investment has already been made, including in my Edinburgh North and Leith constituency, to service floating offshore wind deployment and the government's clean power 2030 action plan, which details the energy and economic opportunities for floating offshore wind technology. Will the leader of the house confirm that the government will support all emerging renewable technology going forward, and will he schedule an oral statement on the future energy generation mix in the North Sea?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The only way to bring energy bills down for good is taking control through renewables to deliver energy security with clean homegrown power. We've already secured 100 billion pounds of private investment in clean power since the election and secured enough clean energy projects to power 23 million homes. We're supporting workers through the transition to clean energy, including through doubling the number of clean energy jobs across the UK by the end of the decade. And I'm sure, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the department will want to keep the house updated on what is a very important matter.
Lewis Cocking.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fuel prices in my constituency of Broxbourne are consistently higher than neighboring areas. A liter of petrol costs 1 pound 82 in the north of my constituency in Hoddesdon compared to 1 pound 64 in Enfield, and this is from the same company.
Can we have a statement so the government can set out what is being done to stop my constituents in Broxbourne getting ripped off when they fill up their cars and vans at the petrol pumps.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and the honorable gentleman raises an important matter which affects a number of constituencies. The recent introduction of the fuel finder does create greater price transparency and increases pressure on retailers to price their fuel fairly but also the Competition and Markets Authority is using this data to monitor how fuel prices vary between different areas to ensure competition in the fuel market is working properly and I know that that is a particular concern to the government about what is happening in rural areas.
Paul Davies
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier this week as chair of the tackling loneliness and connected communities APPG I led a round table which discussed the topics of youth education and skills development. It's clear that many young people face many challenges in this areas in this area but it's also highlighted by the WEA that around 9 million adults in the UK lack essential skills such as literacy and numeracy. With this in mind will the government make a statement on the important role of lifelong learning when it comes to closing this very concerning skills gap.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. We believe that everyone should have the chance to develop their skills no matter what stage of their life they are. The adult skills fund is helping adults across the country access the learning that can transform their prospects and I would encourage my honorable friend who is a powerful advocate on these matters to apply for a Westminster Hall debate so that we can explore how further what further steps can be taken to promote lifelong learning.
Ben Lake.
Ben Morgan Lake
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Almost three quarters of homes in Ceredigion Preseli do not have a connection to the mains gas network meaning that they rely on oil and LPG for their heating and cooking. Further to the point that the honorable member for Glastonbury and Somerton made they are therefore not able to benefit from the energy price cap but are fully exposed to the significant increase in prices following the crisis in the Middle East. Could we have an urgent statement from the government on the support that will be made available to off-grid homes this winter.
Speaker 186
Thank you. I just want to add that if the honorable lady is seeking a meeting with ministers in a cross-party spirit then perhaps the honorable gentleman won't want to join her.
Rachael Maskell.
Rachael Maskell
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. 125 years ago Seebohm Rowntree launched his report Poverty: A Study of Town Life which was an encyclopedic understanding of the levels of poverty in York. Just last week the University of York launched a similar report looking at the city today where poverty still is embedded in our communities. Could the Leader of the House say what government is doing to ensure that government is coming together to address poverty and also look at the work that the University of York is doing with myself to bring our communities together to ensure people who have lived experience lead that agenda.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and I commend my honorable friend on the work that she describes because ending poverty is not just a noble aim it is something which she will find has great sympathy for in this government. We are taking action in this area with our child poverty strategy which will lift half a million children out of poverty by 2030 but as she acknowledges there are still lessons to be learned and future progress further progress to be made and as I announced in the future business we are approaching a budget in a couple of weeks' time and there'll be ample opportunity in the budget debate for my honorable friend to make her to make her case.
Alison Griffiths.
Alison Louise Griffiths
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. In West Sussex we are still waiting to hear what the shape of a future unitary council might look like. And yet members quite possibly across the chamber will be aware of a WhatsApp message circulating which suggests that MHCLG has already confirmed a timetable and has yet to bring it to this house.
So can I please ask the Leader of the House to encourage the Secretary of State to come to this House and update us as soon as possible.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's really important that obviously that we get reorganization right, which is why the Housing Secretary has withdrawn or paused decisions in 14 areas. And we will set out next steps as soon as possible because I do understand I do understand the frustration across the House on this.
Laura Kyrke-Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier this week, the Prime Minister spoke in this chamber about misinformation and disinformation and the threat it poses to our democracy. Trusted local media is a really vital counter to the false information that's out there. And yet our local media are struggling to stay afloat, including Bucks Radio in my constituency, who recently missed out on funding from the government's local news outlet fund. Can the Leader of the House find time for a debate on the importance of trusted local media and the government's role in supporting it.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And my honorable friend is absolutely right to highlight the importance of local radio within our communities and the importance of trusted news sources. We have launched our local media strategy, increasing community radio funding to a million pounds per year. I do appreciate that not everyone will be able to benefit from that at this point in time, but I'd encourage her to apply for a Westminster Hall debate to see if we can further expand on her scheme on her theme because I'm sure it will resonate with a lot of people across the House.
Paul William Forster
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I had the privilege recently of spending time with the amazing staff and volunteers of Woking's homeless shelter and charity, the York Road Project. They do a great job at turning around people's lives, but they're not able to do so and get them into new homes if we are not building them. In my constituency of Woking alone, we've got 2,000 properties that have got planning permission, none are under construction, some had planning permission granted before the pandemic. Will the government agree to a debate to ensure that developers are held to account for this and we introduce use it or lose it powers so we grow our economy and build the homes we desperately need.
Lucy Maria Powell
The honorable gentleman will know that this is a priority announced by the Prime Minister, not least because of his experiences when he was the Mayor of Manchester. And we're very keen that schemes are unblocked so that we get new homes, but also that we explore all sorts of other possibilities as well. Should he seek an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate, then perhaps he can get the latest from housing ministers and homelessness ministers actually about what further action is envisaged by the government.
Speaker 192
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I recently had the pleasure of visiting the much-loved Next Page Books in Hitchin to learn more about their Ask Me What I'm Reading campaign, which is getting people right across the town talking about the joy of a good book. Now, I've always been a huge Very Hungry Caterpillar fan myself, but I wonder if I could tempt the Leader of the House to share with the rest of us what he's reading at the moment. And if we could maybe have a statement from the government about what more we can do to support much-loved independent book sellers like Next Page.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As my honorable friend will know, this year we launched the National Year of Reading 2026 to encourage good habits and to address the long-term decline in reading enjoyment. And I thank the Ask Me What I'm Reading campaign for helping us to achieve that. In answer to his question, I am currently reading The Generals by Iain Dale, a collection of essays on leadership and generals and how to improve leadership. And when I'm finished, I'm going to lend it to the Leader of the Opposition.
Wendy Morton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the democratic deficit that's created by the new planning scheme for delegation in planning? Because by restricting councillors' ability to call in applications in these changes, we will be denying, they will be denying communities a meaningful voice in planning decisions. We urgently need more clarity and to understand how the government reconciles this with its commitment to devolve power and will it reconsider these changes to protect local democratic accountability?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's really important that we hear the voices of local people and they're not just heard, but they actually can influence the process. But at the same time, as she points out, the Prime Minister's absolutely committed to further devolution and making sure that decisions are made closer to where they have effect rather than coming out from some centralized system or indeed centralized planning infrastructure process. If she wants to seek an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate about planning, then she can see the direction of travel if she puts that to the relevant minister.
Warinder Juss.
Warinder Juss
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many families who inherit retirement properties with age-restricted occupancy requirements are finding them increasingly difficult to sell and bereaved relatives, many of whom are pensioners themselves, can then face years of ongoing service charges, council tax liability, maintenance costs and significant loss in property value, which causes considerable financial and mental distress. So will the Leader of the House please facilitate a meeting with the Minister of State for Housing and Planning so we can discuss these issues with the retirement housing sector and see how bereaved families in this situation can be helped?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And we are committed to ensuring that leaseholders, including those living in retirement houses, are protected from unfair and unreasonable practices. And we are giving consideration to the recommendations of the Older People's Housing Taskforce, including further work on resale values. I'll make sure that my honourable friend does get the meeting with the planning minister that he seeks. But this has been a theme, I'm not sure it's exactly the same issue that's been raised before, but they're very, they're similar enough to ensure that perhaps one meeting with the planning minister would allow all of these issues to be aired.
Adam Dance.
Adam Dance
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yeovil's new police station will not have a custody unit after it shut under the Conservatives because years of underinvestment in Avon and Somerset Police mean there is not enough money or staff. So officers have to keep wasting hours a day going to Bridgwater station. Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the need to give rural police forces like Avon and Somerset a fairer funding boost so we can get a custody suite back in Yeovil?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable gentleman might want to look to an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate to make that specific point about his constituency and he's justified in doing so. The government is providing more for the police settlement for this year and as we've stated on many occasions, we're very keen to ensure that rural areas and rural forces get their fair share. But ultimately how the infrastructure of the force is either maintained or indeed stays open is a matter for local police and crime commissioners.
Becky Gittins.
Becky Gittins
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Saturday, I will be addressing a conference of cooperative movement members in Wales. And next year it's the 100th anniversary of the partnership between the Labour Party and the Cooperative Party, a milestone that will be celebrated by having a cooperative Prime Minister in Number 10. Will the Leader of the House therefore make room on the floor of this House for a debate both celebrating that achievement and looking at how we can grow the cooperative movement, not least to the benefit of the members in Wales?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the Prime Minister made clear, he's very proud to be a cooperator. And as she points out, we have a cooperator Prime Minister and he has said that he wants to embed the principles and values of the cooperative movement into what the government is doing. And I think that's an important step forward. I'll give some thought as to whether or not we can find time for a debate on this because I think it affects what government is striving to do in all sorts of areas.
Andrew Murrison
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can we have a debate in government time on the increasingly feral behavior of residential property management companies such as FirstPort, Remus, Fexco, who are blighting the lives of too many of our constituents with unreasonable financial demands and complete lack of accountability and transparency? This has gone on for too long and there is an opportunity with the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill for ministers to do something about it. Can they come to the House to explain what they will do about it?
Lucy Maria Powell
Indeed, the right honorable gentleman is absolutely right to call out practice when it is inappropriate or damaging. And he's absolutely right and I hope that they've heard what he has got to say. The government is committed to bringing to not just the legislation that we have in front of us, but to continue this process to support people who are caught out by this. And therefore there will be debates from time to time on that, but I will give some thought as to whether or not we need a particular government debate outside of that process.
Speaker 198
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Bedrolite is a medication for those with a very rare form of epilepsy. There are, I understand, four private prescriptions and three NHS prescriptions in the country. It's made by a company called Bedrocan, which was in the news this weekend because it is going bust and it's based in the Netherlands. One of my constituents' families is deeply affected by this and needs this medication and their prescription is running out in December.
Speaker 199
You can only imagine the deep concern that his family feel at the moment. I've written to the Secretary of State, I've written to the minister responsible. I believe that this may also be assisted by some parts of the Foreign and Commonwealth Development Office in terms of their relationship in relationships in the Netherlands. Can the Leader of the House support me in bringing together all parts of government to address this really urgent issue for anybody using this important medication?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a really serious matter. My honorable friend is right to bring the concerns to the floor of the House because it's a huge concern to the families affected. She said that she had written to the Secretary of State and the relevant minister. I'm not sure whether she got a response, but I will make sure that she does get a response to that and then we'll see whether or not there needs to be a wider conversation across government or whether it really is a matter that the Health Department can get a grip of.
Clive Jones
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. While the government has committed to a workforce plan for social care, many carers are pleading for urgent action to help resolve the high vacancy rate and to incentivize people to stay in the sector. Will the Leader allow for a debate on delivering the skills and professional development that social care needs to retain its workforce?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed. The honorable gentleman will have heard what the Prime Minister had to say about these matters at our conference and indeed outside of conference. It's of real importance to him and I do hope that we are able to make progress on the wider issue of social care and that all of the parties across the House will have their but I would with respect say to him that following this business statement, there will be a statement on social care. He might want to put it directly to the minister.
Perran Moon
Whereas Madam Deputy Speaker, party leaders come and go as some members of some parties know and members of other parties may shortly be finding out. However, the longest serving party leader in the UK is standing down. The well-respected Dick Cole, the leader of Mebyon Kernow, the party of Cornwall, has served his party with distinction for an astonishing 29 years. Will the Leader of the House congratulate Dick on his achievement and wish him well with the words 'Keslowena ha mur ras'?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed Madam Deputy Speaker and I absolutely join my honourable friend in congratulating Dick Cole, the leader of the party of Cornwall on this remarkable achievement. Whatever our political differences, nearly three decades of service to his party and to public life is a significant contribution and one that deserves recognition across the House. I wish him well for the future and the way in which I express that, I'd ask my honourable friend to take my best wishes back and to use the language appropriately because I'm sure he pronounces better than I would.
Luke Morgan Evans
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Now over the summer in Hinckley we had a massive fly-tip. Now make no mistake, it's a criminal act and they need to be held accountable. But so does the landowner and in this case it's the Liberal Democrat run borough council. When two JCBs get on and drop two and a half thousand tonnes worth of waste, someone needs to be held accountable to make sure that questions are rightly asked saying what was done to secure this site and to clear it up.
Now that bill is going to be 1.3 million pounds. Now I have taken up the request by the council to write to Defra to ask for help with this. I haven't yet heard from Defra. Would the Leader of the House use his good office to follow up with Defra while I follow up with the borough council about what they're doing?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, the honourable gentleman as I've said before is a strong advocate for his constituents. I pay tribute to him for that and he's right to raise this matter. I know that Defra take these matters very seriously indeed and I give him my word that we will contact Defra after this session to help to ensure that he gets a response to his letter. The case that he raises is concerning. I hope, I trust him to get on and deal with the council himself and I do hope that they treat the Member of Parliament with respect and give him the answers to the questions that he asks and I know, I expect that they have heard his words today.
Sonia Kumar
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. This month the historic UNESCO Wren's Nest celebrates 70 years. Would my right honourable friend join me in thanking the friends of Wren's Nest such as Paul Floyd, geologist Graham Worton and others who ensure that the 425 million years old treasures are protected for the next generation? And would the leader allow a debate on protecting such precious habitats such as the Wren's Nest and he's always welcome to visit my constituency and pick up a fossil?
Lucy Maria Powell
I'm very tempted to go down... ...rather frightened they'd retain me as a fossil if I go down. Listen, I pay tribute to everything that is happening and I wish them well and I thank them for that. It allows me to say what I've said before on these occasions, volunteers are just so important, they're the golden thread that runs through our communities. And this is a remarkable achievement and I thank them for what they do and I wish them well in the future.
Tessa Munt
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Metachromatic leukodystrophy, known as MLD, is a devastating genetic disease which progressively destroys the nervous system. Children born apparently healthy lose their ability to walk, talk, see, hear, swallow and then eventually they lose the ability to breathe.
Most do not live to enjoy their fifth birthday. Existing MLD treatment on the NHS is highly effective at halting the disease and is delivered at the Royal Manchester Children's Hospital. But early diagnosis is essential. We already test for ten conditions on the newborn on newborn babies, and without the need to take any additional blood, MLD screening could be added to each newborn baby's heel prick test at a cost of 17 pence per test. Could the Leader of the House ask the Health Department to meet with me to discuss this simple and inexpensive solution which would save the life of a child per month in this country?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I agree with the honourable lady that for those affected by MLD, it can be a devastating and life-changing disease. She's absolutely right to say that early diagnosis is essential and is highly effective actually at halting the disease, and it's important that every government department, but especially the Department of Health, does look at ways of investing early on to make sure that there's not even greater cost and tragedy further down the line. I'm happy to try to facilitate with a meeting with the relevant minister so that she can discuss them further.
Johanna Baxter
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last month, I visited Save Ukraine's Hope and Healing Centre in Irpin to see the incredible work that they are doing to rehabilitate children who have been rescued following abduction by Russia. During my visit, I had the honour of delivering beautiful tartan scarves and toys to the children which had been generously generously donated by Ewan McDonald of Houston Kiltmakers based in my constituency. The children were thrilled with their gifts and intrigued to learn about the history of tartan and Paisley's own textile heritage. So will the Leader of the House join me in thanking Ewan McDonald and his whole team for their generous support for the Ukrainian people and for continuing the proud tradition of Paisley's textile industry?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend has been a tireless campaigner for the Ukrainian cause, and I pay tribute to her for that. I'll absolutely join her in thanking Ewan and his team for their generous support for the people of Ukraine and their remarkable work. I pay tribute to all those involved in the Hope and Healing Centre for their incredible effort supporting children in the most horrific circumstances, and I thank her for the work that she's doing.
Charlie Dewhirst
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, you will no doubt be aware that East Yorkshire is blessed with some of the most productive farmland in the country, yet the Humber Head solar project threatens to plaster 4,000 acres in solar panels. Even more concerning, Natural England appear to have amended the boundaries of the proposed Yorkshire Wolds Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty around the village of Lonsborough to avoid coming into conflict with this solar farm project. So can I ask the Leader of the House if we can have a debate in government time on the proliferation and cumulative impact of solar farms and the detrimental effect on domestic food security?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd simply advise the honourable gentleman to seek an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate on these matters. He's right to raise the concerns of his local constituents on that, but also an opportunity to put directly to ministers in an expanded way the concerns that he's raised with me today.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It was reported in Derby Telegraph this week that Derbyshire County Council in failing SEND children has in the past year cost the taxpayer 79,000 pounds in compensation paid out, with 20,000 to one family alone. However, these families don't want to be getting to the point of compensation being paid out, they want help. Yet I have in the past three months of DCC's MP surgery had little progress and little way of updates for families my team and I support in South Derbyshire, including Hayley Archer, who is an incredible, incredible advocate for her son, but whose life is being ruined by Derbyshire County Council. Yet Derbyshire County Council is one of the councils having 90 percent of its deficit wiped out by this Labour government.
So does the Leader of the House agree with me that this huge help to DCC should see a marked improvement in outcomes for people I represent in South Derbyshire, and that the council should be held accountable for evidencing value for money by delivering for SEND families instead of ignoring them?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, and my honourable friend is a great advocate for her constituents, and I join her in paying tribute to Haley Archer. She's absolutely right that her constituents have a right to see improvements in this vital area, and yet too often in business questions we hear about reform-led councils who are simply letting down the people that they are supposed to be representing. I hope that Derbyshire County Council has heard what my honourable friend has said and takes action urgently to deliver for SEND families.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This week another young life was lost on Dorset's rural roads. It's the second Wimborne man died this year after the roads around this small town saw the deaths of four people last December, and another family narrowly avoided tragedy after a vehicle plowed into the front of their house on the Cranborne Road. While the incidents are subject to investigation, the 60 mile an hour default speed limit on country lanes means that road safety requests have to go through long, costly processes for each and every one, making it a matrix of delay, whereas a rural speed limit of 40 miles an hour would better suit the countryside where the roads simply weren't built for the level of traffic. So in advance of legislation linked to the road safety strategy, will the Leader of the House make time for debate in government time on reducing road deaths?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, the honourable lady raises very important matters as well, not just in her constituency, but I'm sure it echoes what's happening across the country. We have announced the first road safety strategy in over a decade. It will save thousands of lives over the next decade as we implement a plan to reduce deaths and serious injuries by around two-thirds by 2035. But that's cold comfort to people who are caught up in these tragedies. We're also keen as a government to reduce the red tape to make sure that decisions can be made locally and made quickly, so I will raise the matter with the relevant minister and get a response for her.
Speaker 205
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Leader of the House join me in sending his condolences to the family and friends of Labour councillor Dave Perkins? Dave was a proud veteran, a diligent and compassionate councillor for 32 years in Huncote, and who in his most recent election of 2023 secured 80% of the vote. An example to us all. Mr. Huncote will be sorely missed by all of us in Hinckley and Bosworth.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed, and I'm sure the whole House will join me in sending condolences to the family of councillor Dave Perkins and to thank him for his years of public service, but also thank his family for sharing him with a life in politics and a life of public service. The commitment of our local councillors and public servants is vital to the success of our constituencies. I thank my honourable friend for raising this today, and I send our condolences to the family of councillor Perkins, but also our thanks.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Leader of the House ask the Foreign Secretary to make a statement on the Inter-American Court of Human Rights' recent resolution concerning the safety, the health, and the freedom of the Catholic Bishop Abelardo Mata in Nicaragua, and what representations the government has made to urge the Nicaraguan authorities to end the persecution, the harassment, the intimidation of religious leaders, respect their right to express their views and practice their faith without any fear of retaliation, and to protect Bishop Mata's life, health, and liberty? Thank you.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you very much indeed. As ever, the honorable gentleman raises a serious matter. We are committed to defending freedom of religion and belief for all and we continue to urge the authorities wherever to release political prisoners immediately, unconditionally, if they're held as a matter of faith or belief. I'll make sure that he receives a response from my honorable friend, the Minister for the Americas.
Mark Sewards.
James Mark Sewards
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I represent a 15-year-old constituent with a serious heart condition that he's awaiting surgery for. He's been told not to overexert himself because even walking puts his health at risk. Sadly, his family's appeal for a blue badge have been turned down because they can't demonstrate he'll have this problem in three years post-surgery. But we know that certain individuals on qualifying benefits can get a short-term blue badge, but in this instance, he doesn't qualify despite his health condition.
Will the Leader of the House grant a debate in government time on the need to change this scheme so we can help people, especially children, avoid this needless trap?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honorable friend raises an important case regarding the gap in the provision of blue badges. I will make sure that he gets a response from the relevant minister. If that is not a sufficiently appropriate response to his concerns, then I would encourage him to seek an adjournment debate so that he can make his case more strongly.
Gordon McKee.
Gordon McKee
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Residents in Cathcart in my constituency have been waiting more than five years for a gate to Linn Park to be fixed and reopened by Glasgow City Council. Thanks to the work of the Friends of Linn Park group, progress is finally being made, but does the Leader agree with me that it's taken far too long and will he join me in recognizing the work of Friends of Linn Park?
Lucy Maria Powell
It certainly sounds, Madam Deputy Speaker, as if it's taken far too long. I don't know why the council has prevaricated in this regard. It allows me to say that the settlement to Scotland is the highest on record and that if that has got down to a local level, then councils can't claim that they don't have the resources in order to address these issues. And I hope that the council has heard what my honorable friend has said, but I also pay tribute to the volunteers for their successful campaign to alleviate the situation.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the financial impact on local authorities and government of the loophole which allows retrospectively classification by the Valuation Office of second homes as holiday let businesses? That has led to councils having to refund years of council tax, up to 10 million pounds in somewhere like Cornwall, and central government having to reimburse councils for future shortfalls.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a concern which will be held by members across the House, which is why we published a call for evidence seeking views on the tax treatment of holiday lets, which we'll publish its evidence in due course. And I will, if she seeks a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss this topic further, I'll help her to achieve that.
Steve Yemm
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Following on from the Labour government's 4 billion pound transfer of reserves to the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme and British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme, both sets of trustees have set out proposals for how future surpluses could benefit the thousands of scheme members, both in Mansfield and across the country.
Would the Leader of the House press the Government to address those trustee proposals in the October budget so that former mine workers and their families can receive that fair and sustainable settlement that they've fought for for many decades?
Lucy Maria Powell
Madam Deputy Speaker, my honourable friend's been an ardent campaigner for former mine workers in his part of the world and I pay tribute to him for that. He raises an important point regarding the proposals, and if he gives me further details, I'll make sure that the Chancellor receives them and hears what he's saying during his deliberations on what might or might not be in the budget.
John Thomas Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sobro Beach is a brilliant business and a thriving community, but it's set to close. An eleventh-hour U-turn this week saw BCP Council give Sobro Beach an 11-month delay to the inevitable, which is their closure, despite saying that such a move was an impossible. There are concerns that the council leadership may have made incorrect statements into the council meeting that decided on that closure. Will the Leader arrange a meeting for me with the relevant minister so that I can raise my concerns on behalf of my constituents?
Lucy Maria Powell
Nearly 10,000 people signed a petition to save Sobro Beach.
Thank you very much indeed. I thank my honourable friend for his question and he's a tireless campaigner for his constituents and I will help him to arrange a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss those concerns because they are serious concerns.
Patricia Ferguson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We're still in October and my office is receiving a great many representations about the anti-social use of fireworks in many of our communities, but particularly in the area of Knightswood in Glasgow West. I welcome the Government's consultation which has recently closed on the issue of fireworks, and I would just ask members to note that my own private member's bill will be having its second reading on the 4th of December, so I hope that's in the diaries. But can the Leader of the House tell the House what the timeframe for responding to that consultation will be and what its plans are thereafter in terms of timeframe? We're obviously too late for this year's bonfire fireworks season, but next year we have to do better.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and of course this is a timely opportunity to raise this matter and I'm sure it'll be raised as we approach bonfire night. The consultation on targeted reforms to fireworks and pyrotechnics legislation closed recently and we are reviewing the evidence, which is the right thing to do before we publish our response. I also understand, I hope I'm correct, that my honourable friend will soon be meeting the minister where they can discuss these matters further. I'm not able to say what the timescale is, but I'm sure that my ministerial colleagues appreciate the urgency of this.
Euan Stainbank
2026 marks the 25th anniversary of the Millennium Link project. This project restored the Forth and Clyde and Union Canals as the arteries of Falkirk's tourist economy and built the iconic Falkirk Wheel which connects the two canals. Would the Leader commend the staff, Voluntary Canals Associations and everyone else involved in this project over the years and join me to visit the new traditional skills centre currently being built at Lock 16, which will regenerate the former Barr's factory, provide new jobs and opportunities for young people and is being supported through the Falkirk and Grangemouth Growth Fund and the Pride in Place Impact Fund?
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I absolutely join my honourable friend in congratulating everyone involved in the Millennium Link project. It sounds to me that they've done a remarkable job in cleaning up the area. I thank him for his enticing invitation to visit the Scottish Canals Skills Centre site to see the fantastic work which is being done there, not least because it's about environmental improvement and about heritage, of which I am have keen interest and a big supporter, but of course it's also about jobs that are created in these projects, and that's really important for his constituency and other constituencies.
Jim Dickson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Dartford Grammar School for Boys, known locally as an academic powerhouse and centre for learning excellence, sits at the heart of our community in Dartford. This year it has turned 450 years old. And among the many notable alumni are Sir Mick Jagger of the Rolling Stones, war poet Sidney Keyes, computer scientist John Rushby, and sprinter Adam Gemili. Would the Leader of the House join me in wishing Dartford Grammar School, including headteacher Julian Metcalf, chair of governors Robert Tibbott, and all the trustees, the staff, the parents and the students, a very happy birthday.
Lucy Maria Powell
Deputy Speaker, I indeed join my honourable friend in wishing Dartford Grammar School a happy and historic 450th birthday. What a remarkable achievement, Madam Deputy Speaker, for a school to have reached its 450th anniversary. And I want to pay tribute, as he says, to headteacher Julian Metcalf, but also all the hardworking teachers and students over the years that have made this school such a success, and I wish them well for the future.
Phil Brickell.
Michael Philip Brickell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Councils across the country are spending millions of pounds on single-occupancy taxis for SEND transport while ageing minibus fleets go unreplaced. One manufacturer in my Bolton West constituency reports that complex procurement processes, excessive bureaucracy and lengthy tendering delays are preventing councils from ordering new vehicles despite there being clear demand to do so. So can the Leader use his good offices to secure a statement from the Government setting out how it will ensure that the Buy British agenda helps councils modernise fleets, reduce transport costs and supports British manufacturing jobs.
Lucy Maria Powell
Deputy Speaker, the honourable friend raises a crucial issue for his constituents. The Government is committed to ensuring that the 400 billion pounds of taxpayers' money spent on public procurement each year actively supports British industry. He raises a very interesting point, and I will make sure that he gets an update from the relevant department.
Andy MacNae.
Andy MacNae
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. McDermott is building 71 homes in my constituency on a sensitive site in Bacup. The development was originally refused by the council but approved on appeal. From the outset McDermott have been dismissive of planning conditions and residents' concerns, particularly regarding ecology, site access and road safety. The issues persist despite a stop notice, three breaches of conditions, magistrates' fines, which seem to offer no deterrent at all.
The council is left managing numerous complaints despite having refused the original application. The community bears the cost of a decision made by a remote inspector in Bristol. Would the Leader agree to a debate on how we can better support local authorities in such situations and ensure developers such as McDermott are held accountable when they repeatedly breach planning conditions.
Lucy Maria Powell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The case my honourable friend raises does sound concerning. Local planning authorities do have a wide range of enforcement powers with strong penalties for non-compliance, including unlimited fines. It is for them ultimately to decide how to take action, but I hope that the offenders, if you like, have heard what he has said today. And I would encourage his local authority to make use of them.
And I'll also ask a minister to write to my honourable friend, and following that he may wish to consider either an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate so they can make his case in more detail.
Speaker 216
Can I thank the Leader of the House for his responses this morning. I'll allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over. Which brings us to a statement on the National Care Service, Minister Alison McGovern.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before I begin the statement on the National Care Service, I just with your permission want to pay my own tribute to Sir David Amess and his family.
We're all thinking of them today and I'm particularly reflecting on how much he gave to this House. Madam Deputy Speaker, with permission, I would like to make a statement on the creation of a National Care Service. In the news this week, Aubrey Joslin is celebrating almost 80 years of service to the NHS. This remarkable lady who has been working since the day it was founded in 1948, and today she is volunteering at the Royal in Liverpool. Happy birthday also to my constituent Vivica Nicklin, turning 80, having spent 60 years as a nurse caring for patients.
Madam Deputy Speaker, when I read about these women, I feel nothing but pride. To know that they're from my hometown in Merseyside just about makes my heart burst. These incredible women show what a wonderful thing it is that people are living longer. More grandparents living to see their grandchildren as adults. But it also sets a test for our generation of politicians.
When Aubrey began her career, there were fewer than 6 million people aged over 65 in the UK. Today, that figure is over 13 million and according to the ONS, by 2050, 18 million people will be 65 and over, those aged 75 and over will rise to more than 10 million, and the number aged 85 and over will have doubled. Therefore, as the Prime Minister said yesterday, we cannot turn away from the question of social care. People who depend on care deserve better, and the dedicated staff deserve better too. Now, this issue of social care has often been overlooked for two reasons.
Firstly, who it is that mostly does the care. And I can explain this reason in three simple words, Madam Deputy Speaker: working class women. Working class women never get a fair hearing in this country, but those in social care need to be heard right now. The second issue is what happens to people when they experience a failing care system. It is not that people don't like talking about getting old.
It's that too many people who go through our care system are traumatized by that experience and it's too hard for them to talk about it. Madam Deputy Speaker, as the Prime Minister said at Labour Party conference, social care workers often feel invisible. And who can blame them when 80% of care workers working for independent providers receive within just 10% of the minimum wage. Now, we all look forward to the findings of Baroness Casey's very important review, but the truth is we cannot afford to wait for her to finish that work before getting on with the job. As any family will tell you who has gone through the nightmare of trying to sort out care for their loved ones, the status quo cannot be accepted.
And beyond the immediate impact on families, the NHS is paying the price of our failure to get a grip. Hospitals are dealing with 999 calls from a failing care system. We have the appalling spectacle of corridor care in hospitals across the country. And if we carry on like this, broken social care will break the NHS too. We cannot let this happen.
On these benches, we remember we were elected on a manifesto to build a National Care Service, to improve the lives of the people who draw on care and to build a system that puts people before profit. We're already working hard to deliver Baroness Casey's early recommendations, whether that's on motor neurone disease, dementia, or on safeguarding.
And that's why the Prime Minister has taken the decision to build the National Care Service with free personal care and adjusting the triple lock to make it possible. Baroness Casey will report next summer and meanwhile we will prepare the ground now for a new service. I am sick, Madam Deputy Speaker, of people looking down their noses at social care staff. Those people who do what is a highly skilled job that could provide the young people of this country with a great career. Yesterday I spoke to our partners at Skills for Care about our workforce action plan.
At the heart of this is a commitment not just to older generations who need care, but for younger generations who just need their chance in life. Being unemployed for any period can damage your confidence, but doing a skilled job like social care can give you a sense of pride and a pay packet you earned yourself. That's why we'll offer thousands more academy places to help young jobseekers into good jobs in care. We're bringing in the first national collective pensions scheme dedicated to care workers. And we have already passed the Employment Rights Act, which gave over a million people access to sick pay, many of them care workers, and we have raised the minimum wage.
We're going to introduce the first fair pay agreement in adult social care, backed by half a billion pounds, putting care workers under the protective umbrella of collective bargaining, giving them the power they deserve, not just as a one-off, but forever. For unpaid carers, we've announced the biggest expansion to the carer's allowance since the 1970s, and we will soon appoint the first unpaid carers champion to be a voice for people who provide unpaid care. For too long, social care has been a Cinderella service, with care staff held back, not having the tools they need to look after people. But recently, Madam Deputy Speaker, we've been making good progress. Digital social care records are helping to reduce paperwork, improving the quality of information available to staff, which is vital for good care and saving precious time.
And today I can update the House that digital records are now used by 84% of care providers compared to just 72% when this government took office. And 92% of people who draw on care are now benefiting from that modernisation. We're supporting the adoption of preventative technology that was the stuff of science fiction just 10 years ago. Home monitoring kits to identify infections early, reminders to avoid missed medication, and specialised sensors to detect and prevent falls. If we can put the best technology in the hands of skilled and emotionally intelligent people, the result will be working-age adults with self-determination, choice, and independence in life, and older people at home for longer in better health, and with a much, much better chance of dying at home in comfort and in dignity when the time comes.
Madam Deputy Speaker, as my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions said on Tuesday, a good retirement is about more than income. And to those who say we cannot afford the National Care Service, I would answer that you are asking the country to pay for the cost of failure. This issue is not going away. If our response to the test of an ageing population is just to find an even larger bucket of sand to stick our heads in, the impact on the NHS already plain for all to see will only grow worse. If the decade after 2010 taught me anything, it's that you don't save money by tearing chunks out of the fabric of our society and then making the NHS pick up the pieces.
Most important, if we improve population health, people will have a much better quality of life.
I don't pretend that it's easy. But our pensioners deserve security and peace of mind and our national care service will be better for them, better for families and better for the NHS. It will ease the pressures we see today where failings in our social care system mean many pensioners are kept in hospital longer than they need or want to be because social care beds are unavailable. And the cost of inaction will only be more pressure on the NHS, more ambulance call-outs, more A&E admissions, more corridor care, more people stuck in hospital when they do not have to be. Madam Deputy Speaker, we're at a crossroads.
Our choice is either to pay the financial and human cost of the failed system we have now or to build the national care service, stabilize our public finances and enable people to live happier and healthier lives. And I urge colleagues not just to think of the consequences of inaction but also what it means for our constituencies if we get this right. In place of fear, the rising population of elderly people we represent can then grow old in a good society. Instead of corridor care, a thriving NHS where unnecessary admission is prevented and if people do become unwell they recover quickly and enjoy their lives. Care workers recognized for their work and all of us gaining peace of mind over what happens later in life.
Madam Deputy Speaker, when Audrey began her lifetime of service to our country, she was part of a generation that left the greatest legacy anyone could hope to build, that when you fall ill you never have to worry about the bill. Today we have the chance to carry her generation's torch into the 21st century and to leave to our children and our grandchildren something as significant as the creation of the NHS itself. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are ripping off the plaster and I commend this statement to the House.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for advance sight of her statement and join with her in what she said about Sir David Amess today again we remember his service, his remarkable contribution to Parliament and to public life including today the Children's Parliament. Madam Deputy Speaker, in my lifetime life expectancy has risen by almost a decade and that is a wonderful thing but it does as she said mean many more people now needing care for extended periods, sometimes very extended periods, and that number is only likely to grow. It is imperative for society to address this issue and it is imperative for us as politicians to find a system that is compassionate, sustainable, affordable and fair. And so much the better if there can be common ground across this floor for on this subject a sustainable approach is also one that can survive multiple changes of government and we will approach this subject constructively and positively. I was though, Madam Deputy Speaker, surprised to hear the Prime Minister announce fundamental and apparently fixed parts of this policy at the Labour Party conference.
And so the first question I think is what are the implications for this for the Casey review? We don't yet know what the big conversation on care will yield. Is the noble Baroness free to make recommendations that may not be the model that the Prime Minister has announced? The Prime Minister managed simultaneously apparently to set constraints but also omit a huge amount of practical information that people need and I think it would be one could say charitably that today's statement adds limited detail to what he has set out. From the use of the phrase the National Care Service, people may understandably have heard something more comprehensive than what is actually being proposed for this is not about all the costs of long-term care.
It's not about the part that for many people is the biggest part, residential care, it is only about personal care and terms like personal care and social care often get conflated but can be different.
So what is the government's definition of what this service is to cover? The statement says it will be based on need rather than ability to pay. Does that mean that they do not envisage for those in a care home a fixed contribution as in Scotland but rather about meeting the costs of individually assessed needs? Will there be any changes to continuing healthcare or funded nursing care? Half of those receiving local authority long-term social care support in the community are working age adults.
And we assume that what the government has said about staff obviously also applies also to this important part of the care sector, but what else? And speaking of staff reforms, what the Prime Minister says about integrating the care and NHS workforces, how is that to work in care which is overwhelmingly in the private and voluntary sectors? The government statement says this system will be introduced in phases so its scope can grow as the savings increase from adjusting the triple lock and as workforce and provider capacity are built up. So is spending on the National Care Service dependent on savings being made from the triple lock, though of course those are not currently budgeted costs, so the definition of savings is itself an interesting one. Does she clearly commit to no new taxes or borrowing for this plan?
The bit about allowing capacity to be built up suggests not only a transfer of cost from individuals to the state but also a net increase and so how much net increase in provision is the government projecting? In the there is one there is one change, Madam Deputy Speaker, which appears it may affect residential the costs of being in a residential care home. The Prime Minister said that no care charges would be paid out of your basic state pension. That seems to imply an end to payments from income for care home residents below the lower capital limit down to the weekly personal expenses allowance. Is that interpretation correct?
And please, Madam Deputy Speaker, I ask her when answering, please do not say these are all details for the Casey review because you cannot have it both ways. Personal care costs are closely linked to these other aspects of the system. And if the government wanted to allow space for the commission to look at the system in the round, it could have done. If it really wanted to allow time to develop a cross-party consensus on on the structure, it could have done. The government itself called what the Prime Minister set out at the party conference a clear plan to fix the system.
So please can we have these answers?
Alison McGovern
Um, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Shadow Health Secretary for um his response. And I'll try to um respond to the points the questions that he's raised there um as as much as I can, but if I do miss anything, I'll I'll follow up in writing afterwards. And perhaps I might just um say to him that he's absolutely right that whilst politics is what it is, um as much as possible we want to um work across the House um on this issue, and I'll be very happy to meet with him um regularly to discuss this for that for that very reason. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Shadow Health Secretary um mentioned whether Baroness Casey was free to um consider issues that she wished. She's obviously she's obviously got terms of reference.
My personal experience with Baroness Casey is that um you try stopping her having having opinions about anything that she wants to have opinions on. So but um we're obviously working closely with her. I've met her a number of times and was really pleased to welcome her to my constituency too. On personal care, obviously um what we mean by that is help using the toilet, cleaning, having a having a shower and so on, but um cleaning oneself. And I'll happily I'll I will happily pick up the question that he the questions that he raised with me um in writing.
He mentions continuing healthcare. There are obviously a number of ways in which, as was under the previous government, under which the interface between NHS funding and social care funding really matters, not least the Better Care Fund and continuing healthcare. We continue to look at those and I will happily discuss with them. There are improvements we can make in the short term that will help even as we wait for the Casey review next summer. And likewise on integration with the NHS, members across this house will all know of good examples where because of collaborative working on the ground, we do see systems that are well integrated.
The problem is that's due to good fortune and good relationships rather than a system and a structure that enables that. He asks me about taxation. That's obviously a matter for the Chancellor and we'll be having a budget shortly, so I'm sure there'll be many questions asked of the Chancellor. And he asked me a couple of other questions as well, which I didn't quite catch, but I will review his statement and write to him.
Deirdre Costigan.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I draw attention to my register of interests as a proud member of Unison. For too long, care workers in Ealing Southall have lived on rock bottom wages with no chance to progress in their jobs. So I hugely welcome this government's half a billion pounds investment in the first ever fair pay agreement for social care. Does the Minister agree with me that we will never have a good quality social care service in this country unless we value our care workers properly? And can she set out how this half a billion pounds, how far it will go in achieving this?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for her question. She's absolutely right that at the heart of the problems we have in the social care system at the moment is the workforce, the way that they're looked down upon by others, and the problems that we have with low and uncertain pay in too many areas. We're cracking on with the fair pay agreement for all the reasons that I mentioned and that she knows only too well. It's about time that social care was seen as the great and fantastic career that it actually is.
Clive Jones
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Minister's statement on the National Care Service and thank her for early sight of her statement. My Liberal Democrat colleagues and I believe that everyone deserves to be able to live independently with dignity and to receive the care they need in their own home where possible. Hundreds of thousands of people are desperately waiting for the care that they need, and 13,000 people every day are left stranded in hospital beds, unable to leave because their care packages have not been put in place. One in seven people over 65 are now paying more than £100,000 for their care in their lifetime.
Spiralling social care costs have left many councils like my own in Wokingham struggling to fulfill other basic services that residents want to see. Social care services are in crisis and have been for too long. This has been recognized for many years by Ed Davey, the leader of the Liberal Democrats and a carer himself.
Speaker 224
The honorable gentleman will know that he must refer to his party leader by his constituency, not name. Clive Jones.
Clive Jones
Apologies for that, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are also pleased that the Prime Minister has recognized from his own experience that social care needs fixing. The Liberal Democrats are keen to work on a cross-party basis to fix social care. Failure to act on social care would be a catastrophe for families, for the NHS, and for local services. Liberal Democrats have set the government three tests for social care reforms.
They must put family carers front and center with guaranteed rights for every carer and replace the broken carer's allowance system. Reforms must include a universal safety net of care, including free personal care. And thirdly, the government must protect people from catastrophic costs so family finances are not decimated and people don't have to lose their family homes. I'm pleased that yesterday the Prime Minister committed to arranging another round of cross-party talks to fix social care, and the Liberal Democrats would engage in these discussions and urge others in this House to do the same.
Alison McGovern
I'm just to say thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the to the gentleman's comments there. The House will have heard the interchange between the leader of the Liberal Democrats and the Prime Minister yesterday, and I would also just thank him for pointing out the rather extreme impact of this situation on the NHS. We all have a choice, we can't leave it as it is.
Ashley Dalton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This House knows that in recent months the issue of end-of-life care has been at the forefront of our discussions and debate. Can the Minister tell us how the National Care Service will dovetail with end-of-life care and support families and those at the end of their life?
Alison McGovern
Um, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my friend for all she did as a health minister and for raising that question. It's extremely important. It's an often overlooked fact that in end-of-life care, the members of staff who might see a person and their family the most will be social care staff. And if we can't get the NHS working together with social care for people when they're dying, we won't be able to do it at any time. So that is an absolute priority for the work that we can do before the Casey review, and I'll happily meet with her to discuss that further if she'd like.
Edward Leigh
The average cost of a home in the Gainsborough constituency is just 204,000 pounds. Typically, you spend three years in a care home in your lifetime, which will cost you 150,000 pounds. Everything over 23,000 pounds, the upper capital limit, is taken. This is what really upsets people that they've given a lifetime in all over the country, and this is a real issue outside London and the Southeast where house prices are much higher. So will the Minister, if she's going to abolish the triple lock and change it to a double lock, which most commentators think is now inevitable, will she look at the issue and either bring raise the upper capital limit so people keep more of their money or have a life a cap on lifetime contribution, which was of course the policy of the last government?
Alison McGovern
Um, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Father of the House for his comment. The point that he raised is an important one. That's for the further discussions we'll have next summer once the Casey Commission has reported. I would say to him that the steps that I wish to take in the immediate weeks and months are focused on improving what we can now within the care system, but he nonetheless raises a very important point.
Jennifer Craft
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the statement and I hope that the National Care Service affords an opportunity to develop the sufficient roadmap to community support for the over 3,000 people with a learning disability and autism who are currently locked away in secure mental health units that are inappropriate and in some cases actively harmful. This was given as a commitment to me at the dispatch box by the Minister's predecessor nearly a year ago, and I'd be grateful if the Minister would be able to meet with myself, Mencap, and those campaigning to bring these people home from hospital.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and of course I will meet with my friend. She will know that I'm also the Minister of State for Mental Health, so across those two responsibilities I'd happily work with her to fulfill that commitment.
Vicky Slade.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Speaker. For the last year I've been campaigning for Richard's Law after Louise and Richard were robbed by their care worker in their own home in Dorset. The law would ensure that all care workers are DBS registered, have minimum levels of training, and most importantly are on a single national carers register. This is supported by Visiting Angels and the National Care Agency as it will allow carers to move employers more easily, reduce employers' costs, and professionalize the sector. Will she support this?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable lady for her point. She rightly raises a very important issue. One of the interim recommendations of the Casey Review was that we create a national safeguarding board. So if she would like to send me the details of her proposal, I will happily raise that with the Chief Social Worker.
Anna Dixon.
Anna Dixon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I refer the House to my register of interest as the chair of the APPG for Carers. The Minister sadly knows from personal experience the challenges that family members face in trying to secure care and support for our loved ones, and it's even more distressing when they are close to the end of their life. So will she outline how the government will ensure that the National Care Service will give peace of mind to families and carers that care and support will be there when they need it, regardless of their finances or where they live?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and my friend asking the question gives me the opportunity to thank her for all the work that she does in Parliament to raise the issues that relate to family carers within the care system. She mentions that I sadly have recent experience of the social care system at the when my mum died in July, and I can only say that the system that we want to try to achieve is one that takes burdens off the shoulders of people at that time, not the one at the moment where unfortunately the complexities only add to the distress.
Ed Argar.
Edward John Argar
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I associate myself with the Minister's remarks about the amazing work done by care workers day in and day out across our country. Labour governments, Conservative governments, governments with Liberal Democrats in them have all been unable to find a way to implement significant changes for the future of social care, not I suspect from a lack of desire but due to the complexities of it and indeed the complexities of securing meaningful or a degree of meaningful agreement across parties in this House. Therefore, can the Minister confirm that the contours of what cross-party discussions can consider and potentially conclude and the contours of what the Casey Commission can consider and potentially conclude are in no way predetermined by the Prime Minister's announcement?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the right honorable gentleman for his question. He's been a minister in the Department of Health and he knows and understands the challenges very well and was an excellent and courteous minister. I would just say to him, the Prime Minister has set out his position from that's long-standing view that he's held.
He acknowledged at Prime Minister's Questions and on other occasions the ups and downs of this debate that we've all been through. We all want to try to work cross-party to get to a better place on this. And I can only refer the right honorable gentleman to the remarks that the Prime Minister made at PMQs yesterday about how determined he is to find cross-party agreement.
Chris Vince.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I also declare an interest as a member of the trade union Unison? Can I thank the minister for her statement and can I welcome her and the PM's comments and commitment to a National Care Service, something of course that I welcome and I know has the potential to make a big difference to residents and also carers in my constituency of Harlow. I'm really interested in the role of the unpaid carers champion, this isn't me putting in a pitch for the job. But what I would like to know is how she will ensure that this role will make sure that carers and also young carers, which she will know I've got a passion for supporting, their voices are heard as part of this conversation.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know that the only job that my friend ever wants is to be the Member of Parliament for Harlow. Such a great job that that is. I would just say to him, you know, it's really, really important as we build the National Care Service that the voice of family carers, of unpaid carers is heard loud and clear. They have a specific viewpoint on some of the changes that we're trying to achieve.
So once we've made that announcement, I know that whoever it is who's appointed will work very closely with him, particularly on young carers.
Alison Bennett.
Alison Bennett
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm very appreciative that you've called me at this point because at 1:50 there is a debate in Westminster Hall on support for unpaid carers and I'd encourage all honorable members to join us then. My question for the minister is does she think that the National Care Service can be funded through efficiencies in the NHS?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd like to thank the honorable lady not just for her question but also for seeking the debate that she has done in Westminster Hall. I would apologize to her for not replying to it myself, but there is a sort of time clash going on. So my very good friend, minister in the Health Department, the member for Bury, is going to be responding to her. And I would just say to her, the argument that I was making in my contribution is that unless we're prepared to grapple with the issue of social care properly, we will pay for the cost of failure, most especially in what we're seeing in the NHS.
So I feel sure that it's the right thing to do financially for the country as well as to make sure that people can live very good lives into old age.
Nadia Whittome
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I very much welcome the minister's statement today. I'm glad that the Prime Minister has already committed to a National Care Service that is free at the point of use, a vital principle that mirrors our NHS. Would the minister also agree that one of the key problems in our current system is our reliance on private providers? And will she explore how we can make the new National Care Service publicly run with people who receive care, care workers, and unpaid carers co-producing that system?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I just thank my friend for her question. The system we've got at the moment isn't working. It's far too fragmented and I've got a lot of concerns about the situation that the workforce face. Members of this House will have noticed yesterday that the Prime Minister responded to a question regarding the role of co-ops in the future of social care.
And I'm very interested in all ideas that members have on how we can make sure that we have the best possible mix of organizations involved in the national care system.
Dr. Andrew Murrison.
Andrew Murrison
Madam Deputy Speaker, the trauma of care that the Minister refers to includes keeping frail elderly people in acute hospital units well beyond their date of expected discharge. It is dreadful for them. It means that they are likely to succumb to hospital-acquired infections and various other things that are attendant on hospital stays and mean that they are not in homely settings in the community, which is where they need to be, where their families want them to be, and which costs a quarter the cost of keeping them in an acute hospital unit. Will the National Care Service incorporate savings that can be made for our NHS through getting people the care that they need, that is to say care in the community rather than in busy acute hospital beds?
Alison McGovern
Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank the right honorable gentleman for his question and I couldn't have put the argument better myself. That is exactly the trauma that I'm referring to. It is a terrible thing to see an older loved one in hospital, which is not a good environment for them and where you know that they are likely to become ill through infection or they're losing mobility or other things. Nobody wants that. I do think, as I responded to the honorable lady just a moment ago, I do think that's the right thing financially, but frankly, for quality of life reasons, it's got to be done.
Rachael Maskell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I share the Minister's pride with my mother turning 89 today, having dedicated her life to the NHS. But I also extend that pride to the 1.6 million care workers and believe that we could do so much more to lift their confidence in the professional skills that they bring. I welcome the Prime Minister extending his interest into care cooperatives because that can empower staff as well as service users. Could she say if she will work with the Co-op Party, who's done extensive work in this area, to deliver that model?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In response to her question, yes, of course I will. Can I just through her wish her mom an extremely happy 89th birthday? She and I are both daughters of people who worked in the NHS and nothing makes me more proud.
Adam Dance
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I first want to welcome the Minister's statement today. There's a lot of good in there. But if we are not getting a National Care Service in this Parliament, I'd ask the Minister what steps the government would take now to ensure continuity of social care across local authority borders? Because one constituent's mother moved from Dorset to a care home near her family in Somerset. They sought support from the council because their personal funds were running out.
Sadly, the constituent's mother passed away before the complex dispute over which council should pay was ever resolved.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable gentleman for bringing this point forward. We have a lot of work to do with our colleagues in local government to get this system right. Helpfully, my previous job was Minister for Local Government, so I'm aware of some of the issues. If you'd like to send me a little note with that border issue, I'll happily look into it because that sounds like the sort of thing that's probably happening in loads of places.
Liz Twist
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I first declare my interest as co-chair of the Unison group of Labour MPs and a Unison member. I thank the Minister for the work she's doing on the workforce issues. But many unpaid carers struggle to balance their caring responsibilities with paid employment, with consequences for their household finances and their future pensions, and indeed many have to give up work because they can't balance it. So what steps is the government taking to make sure that carers get the support they need to stay in work if they wish to do so?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for her contribution and through her to thank all of the Unison group of MPs and to Unison for their input on this issue. She raises a very important matter that is one of the reasons why we're going to appoint a champion for unpaid family carers because in addition to all of the other financial impacts that we've been talking about on this failure, there is the economic impact on the labor force of people giving up work to care for an older loved one. And I think we have to take that impact into consideration as well as we build the new National Care Service.
Edward Robert Jenrick
Instead of cutting foreign aid or net zero subsidies or benefits for migrants, the government's chosen to cut the state pension to pay for its care system. But most experts agree that that doesn't even touch the sides of the problem. There's an 18 to 40 billion pound black hole. Would the Minister accept that to pay for this, taxes are going to have to rise a lot? And because people are very worried, will she use this opportunity to rule out the death tax where the government would go after people's homes, their nest egg at the end of their life?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the right honorable gentleman for his question. I do not accept what he just said and I don't agree with it either.
Clive Efford
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the statement, I welcome any move towards a National Care Service. But as my honorable friend knows as much as I do, that what people experience out there is a clash of bureaucracies quite often which leads to slowdown in the delivery of care or care packages. Many people stuck in hospitals are there for a variety of reasons, but many of them are because they can't resolve that in order to move them from hospital in a timely fashion. We can't wait for that to be resolved.
That's something that we need to resolve now. And could she give me a reassurance that she is working on that because if we can solve that, we can solve a large parts of the problem in the next big in this parliament, not have to wait for the next.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank my honorable friend for his contribution. He makes exactly the argument as to why we have to take steps now to improve the system. And in my statement, I mentioned the increase in the number of organizations using digital care records to help smooth the system. But it also takes the working together of NHS organizations, local authorities, and care companies.
And this is happening in some places. The problem is it's not everywhere. And he's absolutely spot on, we've got to do this now.
Ian Sollom
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Maxwell has spinal muscular atrophy and needs a significant amount of personal care. He's just started a graduate job, but because of the frozen 23,250 pound capital limit, any savings he builds up go on care charges, so he can't save a deposit for a home or the safety net that his disability demands. Now, the member for East Hampshire said that we assume it, but will the Minister confirm that the free personal care will be included for working age disabled adults like Maxwell? And until it arrives, would she unfreeze and raise the capital limit so we're not placing a limit on his aspirations?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable member for raising his constituent's situation. If he would like to send me details of that, I'll happily look into it and formally reply to him and his constituent. Baroness Casey's commission is working on recommendations for fixing the social care for everyone who needs it, including working age adults. But I would just acknowledge that some of the challenges are different, so we need to take that into account as we move forward to the future system.
Speaker 240
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and could I declare an interest as I have a close relative working in the care sector. I would like to welcome the Minister's statement today on this very, very important matter. Could she say a little bit more about how the Department she plans to build a consensus across the wider community and with stakeholders as well as with political parties?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the my honourable friend for his question and whichever of his relatives it is who's working hard in social care. I've been very, very lucky to be in touch with a wide number of organisations. We had a opening meeting with lots of organisations in the Department a month or so ago, and there is a lot of expertise out there. This issue has to be seen differently from the viewpoint of those who are involved in the different parts, but also the different conditions and different experiences people have. So I feel positive about that work so far.
Many people have engaged with the Casey Commission, and I'm sure we'll do so going forward.
Dr Ellie Chowns.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really welcome this statement from the Minister today, as I'm sure will many people in North Herefordshire, people who draw on care, people who provide care, both paid and unpaid. I'd like to ask the Minister, does she agree with me that we really need to end the lottery of care, the postcode lottery of care being provided in different ways in different places, and the life lottery of your access to care being partly determined by your circumstances, and the lottery of whether you end up having catastrophic care costs at the end of your life and potentially losing your life savings? And so can we agree that we need to ensure that care is locally provided but nationally funded? And will she lobby her colleague the Chancellor to include fair taxation of wealth in the mechanisms that she considers to fund that?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honourable lady for her contribution. She makes a good argument that I think we would all see about how disjointed and fragmented the system is. The Shadow Health Secretary is trying to help me out by explaining that her question was probably slightly out of scope of my policy responsibilities, but I will certainly mention to the Chancellor if I bump into him that she had a view she'd like to share with him.
Clive Betts.
Clive Betts
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I very much welcome the statement by my right honourable friend, and we've really talked about this issue for so many years, and it's time we get on with it and try and get cross-party agreement as well. While we're waiting for the Casey report, and I know Louise from old will be robust and independent in what she recommends, is the idea that we set out a national framework where government lays down standards and hopefully the funding, and then the service is organised at local level by local authorities working closely with primary care, with public health, and with local housing providers who are often missed out in the important join-up we have to achieve?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my honourable friend for his question and for his experience on this, which he has shared to me shared with me over many years, and I really appreciate it. He described that situation well. We both need a system that is much less fragmented and easier to understand, and also one that responds to the local context. It's very different providing care in urban versus rural areas, for example. So we have to think through those issues.
There are certain things which I've laid out in my statement that I think we need to crack on with now, such as giving young people the chance of a job in social care, and other issues we'll work through alongside local government colleagues and, as he says, housing providers too.
David Chadwick
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Those demographic statistics are alarming. In Powys, the average occupancy rate across the community hospitals in the nursing beds is 91% in Llandrindod Wells, 82% in Ystradgynlais. Yet Powys Teaching Health Board is currently consulting on potentially cutting the number of community hospital beds from 160 to 60. Does the Minister agree with me that community hospital beds play a vital role in the care system, and does she share my concern that if those beds were to be cut, it would just mean that more elderly residents from Wales are left stranded in English hospitals?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honourable gentleman for his question. I'm sure the health board that he refers to that covers his constituency will have heard his opinion very strongly given. We need to make the system work better and I'm sure they'll want to reply to him directly.
Darren James Paffey
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I join my honourable friend in praising care workers up and down the country, and I pay particular tribute to those who gave such excellent care to both my parents in their final years. Madam Deputy Speaker, from day one as an MP, my constituents in Southampton Itchen have come with increasingly distressing stories of what is happening when things go wrong, so I really welcome the long-term statement to put it right. But in the meantime, given the urgency, while we wait for Baroness Casey, can my honourable friend assure us that there is a plan to do the most urgent improvements starting now?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and yes, I can assure my friend of that. That's part of the reason for this statement today, whether it's on workforce, making sure that we make improvements on technology, local authority commissioning, or the initial recommendations of the Casey review on MND, on safeguarding and dementia. Those things that are urgent and can be done now, we are getting on with them.
Ben Morgan Lake
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first congratulate the Minister not only on the statement but specifically on the creation of a National Care Service? It will undoubtedly have a transformational impact on so many people. Can I ask whether she'll ensure that representatives from political parties in Wales can be included in some of these cross-party talks? For although the provision of social care in Wales is a devolved responsibility, there are important considerations, including the arrangements for cross-border packages and matters of funding that are perhaps best understood and addressed at an early stage.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and let me say diolch to the honourable gentleman. And I would say yes, we can definitely do that. As somebody whose constituency is very close to North Wales, I understand what he means.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's move towards a National Care Service because, as the Minister said in her statement, everybody knows that we won't fix the NHS until we fix social care. But tens of thousands of care workers are currently facing a change to their immigration status. We shouldn't be changing the rules for those that are already here and making a valuable contribution to both the care sector and our wider society. Does the Minister agree?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the issue that the honourable friend raises is rightly one for the Home Office, and I will pass on his question to the relevant Minister. I would just say in addition that whether it's the NHS and its founding and its creation or social care down the years, where people have come to put in a shift and take care of the ones we love, we're grateful to them.
Michael Reader
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could the Minister confirm, and I think she has to a previous answer already, but that the interface between health and social care will remain front and centre of the National Care Service, particularly not only for those being discharged from hospital, but once people are in care, particularly residential care, the challenges of accessing health services back into the system?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm very, very happy to confirm that point to my honourable friend. I think we all understand how challenging and bureaucratic that border between health and care can be, and that is one of the urgent matters that I'm looking at.
Claire Jodie Gosling
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really welcome this statement, and especially the recognition of the trauma caused to families when services fail, which is why it's so important to preserve strong local services like Mary Ann Evans Hospice in Nuneaton, which provides dignity in death to thousands of families at home, but is currently on the breadline in insolvency talks with last-minute legacy donations extending the deadline from the end of this month to the end of the year. I am in talks with the ICB and we're doing everything, but there is a fundamental formula problem with the funding level. So what can we do to protect these fragile services now so that we can build on them in the future?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I just thank the my honorable friend and just pay tribute to all the work that she is doing with her local hospice and with her community on this issue. Members across this house will understand that we have a challenge in hospice funding, which I'm looking at as part of the end-of-life care work that I'm doing. It sounds like she is more than on top of it with her ICB, but if I can be of any assistance to her at all, I'd be happy to do so.
Brian William Leishman
Thanks very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the creation of a National Care Service is in the very best socialist traditions of the Labour Party. However, pensioners funding its creation through the removal of the triple lock is not, especially when we have over two million pensioners living in poverty. Now, the IFS have said that the fifteen billion pounds worth of savings by the reduction of the triple lock is actually more like four billion pounds, and making any savings is a bit of a speculative gamble because if we see high inflation, then there's potentially no savings to be made. So, if there is going to be a financial shortfall in providing the National Care Service, how will it be funded and realized?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for his question. In responding to him, I would just like to quote the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions in his statement to the House this week, who said that we know people want security in retirement and we're committed to protecting the poorest pensioners, and under our plans, pensioner poverty is set to fall. I hope that my friend will have read the statement that the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions made earlier this week, and I think I hope that he will understand why I respectfully disagree with him.
Speaker 247
Madam Deputy Speaker, in Scotland our health and social care partnerships face a five hundred million pounds funding shortfall, and the SNP failed to deliver on their commitment to establish a National Care Service for Scotland. Will the Minister assure me that as the government takes forward its vital plans for social care she has set out today, she will ensure that her counterparts in the Scottish Government are regularly updated on this work so they can learn how improvements in social care can be made effectively and they can be encouraged to fulfill finally their pledge for the improved social care services my constituents need as well?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my honorable friend for raising this very important question. I'll certainly agree to the suggestion that he makes because when I've heard about the situation in Scotland, I have to say that it worries me, Madam Deputy Speaker, so I'll happily agree to his suggestion.
Nesil Caliskan
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as I listened with great interest to the Minister of her statement on the care sector in our country that has persistent vacancies, I was thinking about the one in six young people in my constituency of Barking who are out of employment and not in education. And with that in mind, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I ask the Minister, does she agree with me that building a National Care Service means we can improve care for older people, but also create rewarding career pathways for young people in my constituency too through training and better pay in the care sector?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for that question. I've visited her constituency before and I know what amazing young people there are. And they deserve a better chance, I think. Working in care can be an absolutely fantastic career, particularly if you're a young person who's perhaps experienced unemployment. Maybe you need a bit of confidence.
Actually, being in an emotionally intelligent profession like social care can be a really great start to your career, so I'll happily work with her on that if she'd like.
Chris Hinchliff
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Minister for her powerful statement today. 84% of care beds in England are run by private companies, and Baroness Casey has highlighted that currently private equity is often holding councils to ransom so they can extract maximum profit for the public purse. Noting the Minister's earlier answers on ownership models, can the Minister confirm that Labour's national care service will put an end to the essential care of our parents and grandparents being used as a profiteering investment vehicle by private equity?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I would refer my friend to both the comments that I made in my statement about the importance of putting people first, and also to the response that the Prime Minister gave yesterday about the development of co-op organisations in the care system. I think we can make important progress on this and I'm happy to work with him to do that.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I draw the House's attention to my membership of Unison. And firstly, I'd like to pay tribute to former Conservative county councillor David Westley, who I found out has recently passed away. He was the chair of the Lancashire Health and Adult Services Scrutiny Committee. I served as his deputy and we worked together in Lancashire to try to address the problems that the Minister is trying to sort out now. Now, my constituency has large rural areas, so can the Minister assure me that the problems in rural care will be addressed as part of her plans?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank my friend for her question, and could I through her pay my respects to Councillor David's family and all of those who love him and miss him. I've already mentioned in response to colleagues, actually it is important to think about this from the point of view of the different communities that we have across England. There are challenges in rural areas and we need to be cognisant of them as we move forward and think about the shape of what the care service looks like on the ground.
Mohammad Yasin
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's commitment to put in unpaid carers at the heart of a national care service. But as I heard when I visited Blue Sky Carers Support Hub in Bedford recently, this must mean more than words. So what concrete, properly funded commitments will the government make to ensure unpaid carers receive meaningful breaks, financial security and support to balance caring with work or education, particularly young carers, so that we don't just recognise carers, but really care for the caregivers?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to thank my friend for his question. He raises rightly a really important issue. We can't really think about the welfare of people who are receiving care if we're not thinking about the welfare of people caring for them. This is why we are going to appoint an unpaid champion for unpaid carers, to can be that voice as we build the new national care service to make sure that all of the issues that he rightly raises are considered and taken forward through this process.
Speaker 192
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think most of us or our friends and family will be familiar with the really personal, emotional, financial and frankly human cost of our broken system. And it's a cost resulting from successive generations of politicians' failure to face into the difficult choices and act, and I hold my own party as accountable as any other in that. So can I thank the Minister and the Prime Minister not just for stepping up on this, but also facing into some of the difficult choices, including the triple lock adjustment that will be needed to fund it. My constituents tell me they'll be perfectly happy to pay more and make sacrifices if they can be confident they'll be getting the care they need when they grow older.
So will the Minister assure my constituents that over the next Parliament every penny we're saving through that triple lock adjustment will be invested by her in ensuring the care service that my constituents really do deserve.
Minister.
Alison McGovern
And thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my friend for an insightful and important question and the work that he does making sure that his constituents' views are put forward here. I think what matters in order to fulfill the test that he sets for the National Care Service is to be really clear on outcomes, because a number of members have mentioned the travesty of people staying in hospital longer than they need to be. A number of members across the House have mentioned how traumatic it is when you experience a loved one towards the end of their life not cared for in the way that we would wish. So we've all got to be clear about what the outcomes are that we want to see from this new service and then we'll be able to meet the test as constituents set.
Samantha Niblett.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The reason I joined the Labour Party in my thirties, quite late, was because of the National Health Service and the welfare state, two incredibly important institutions in this country that look after people at their most vulnerable. If it were after today, the National Care Service would be the third reason I would be joining the Labour Party. The reason I mention this is because in my constituency of South Derbyshire we saw the closure of a most beloved care home called Castle Court Care Home in Gresley by the Reform-led County Council. So it was quite galling to see a couple of their county councillors this week celebrate the fact it's been bought by a private company, hurrah for them coming in to save the day, by the way, when they were the ones responsible for closing it, putting staff out of a job and residents out of a home.
So does the Minister agree with me that it's Labour and only ever Labour government that do this sort of thing and create institutions that look after people when they need the help the most?
Minister.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank my friend for that question and I'd like through her to thank all of those people who've campaigned for good care in her constituency. She tempts me, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm trying to be very cross-party today and she is sparking my inner party political fire. But I would just say to her that all of us can make a contribution, all parties can make a contribution in getting this right. We are rightly proud of our party, the Labour Party's role in founding the NHS, and I want us to be just as proud of what we do to create this National Care Service from this point on.
Andrew Pakes.
Andrew Elliot Pakes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I refer to my register of interests as a GMB member. Can I welcome today's statement and thank the Minister for grasping the issue of a National Care Service, because for too many constituents in my constituency of Peterborough it's been a national profit service, with many of the big care providers owned by private venture capital or backed by private venture capital. I think all of us as MPs will recognize casework and constituents we meet where people feel they have no voice when it comes to the care system, be that people in care, their families or our amazing, brilliant care workers who don't get listened to enough in the system. The Prime Minister gave a very powerful commitment yesterday alongside the example of his father that cooperation and cooperative values will be integral to how we build a service which we can be proud of. Can the Minister, my right honourable friend, give a commitment that the likes of not just the Co-op Party but also Co-operatives UK and existing examples of brilliant care cooperatives are fully involved in the Department's work as we think about the diversity of provision we need?
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my friend for that contribution. He is absolutely right. People feel like the current system is a fog at best. It is totally fractured and it is too hard to navigate for people when they're already dealing with what is of some of life's biggest challenges. So those co-op values are an important factor of what we're thinking about as we move forward in the National Care Service.
Minister.
Alison McGovern
He mentions the Prime Minister's comments yesterday and I'm really glad to confirm that because we're trying to make sure that people are empowered and have their voices heard and people work together for the good of those who need care, those are exactly the values that we want to bring to this discussion.
Speaker 216
Can I thank the Minister for her statement this afternoon? Can I ask members who are leaving the chamber to do so as quickly as possible and I'll allow a few moments for the front benches to swap over. The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Speaker 253
Now, the reasoned amendment in the name of Mr. Richard Holden has been selected. Minister to move second reading, Justin Madders.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that this bill be read a second time. Madam Deputy Speaker, I realize today's bill may seem rather dry at first glance. It primarily covers how we finance major road building, financial frameworks, licenses and regulators, may not get the hearts of the public and dare I say even honorable members racing. So I hope the House will allow me to start with why all this matters.
Why it matters not just for the future of this government's second largest infrastructure asset, but for the future of the country. Colleagues across the chamber I'm sure will know the importance of the strategic road network, four and a half thousand miles of highways that frankly punch above their weight. It represents less than 3% of our road network by length, yet carries a third of motor vehicle miles and two thirds of lorry miles. So if trade is the lifeblood of our economy, then the strategic network is our national arteries, transporting almost all the goods we rely on for our way of life. But it does even more, unlocking house building, connecting people with opportunity, and underpinning the integrated transport network we want to build.
Mark Francois
The Minister just mentioned roads to unlock house building. Why is it then that when Labour want to build 100,000 houses in South Essex from Grays to Shoeburyness, they've cancelled the widening of the A12 some months ago and last week they cancelled the upgrades for the A127? It makes no sense to want to build all those houses anyway, but if you're going to do that, it's insane to cancel the road upgrades that you need to accommodate them. So why did Labour do that? None of this is joined up, is it?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I'll happily address why certain schemes have been cancelled. It's because the party opposite put far more schemes into the program than they'd actually put funding in for, so any understandable frustration ought to be directed at the honorable member's own colleagues. So anyway, Madam Deputy Speaker, much of the strategic road network is over 45 years old.
Speaker 256
No, I'm sorry, he can't get away with that. They cancelled the A12, which had been planned for years, Labour cancelled it. And they've cancelled the upgrades to the A127. Please answer my question. How can you propose to build 100,000 houses whilst you're cancelling strategic road programs?
It doesn't make sense.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Look, the bottom line is the previous government committed far more schemes than there was actually funding for, so we had to do evaluations on those that were the least value for money and the least advanced. It's nothing more than that. And I'm afraid the honorable member may be frustrated, but perhaps promises should not have been made by the previous government that couldn't be delivered. Demand is only going to go in one direction though, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Road vehicle mileage is set to rise on the strategic road network by 12% over the nine years to 2035. And climate change continues to bare its teeth across our transport infrastructure, with our strategic roads no exception. All these challenges bear down on a network that holds up our economy every day. That is why I'm proud, Madam Deputy Speaker, the government published the third road investment strategy earlier this year. Not only did this commit 27 billion pounds to future-proof our roads, not only did this commit to resurfacing a quarter of our entire network, but it's also committed to three major enhancement schemes in the north of England, working even closer with local leaders.
It proved to MPs such as myself that road investment can address regional inequalities and that it is compatible with our promise of greater devolution. So when we talk about growth and power in every postcode, that is exactly what I mean. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is the context in which I present today's bill. I mentioned what we've already delivered, but the truth is there is much more that needs to be done. Delivering the roads this country needs that connect our ports, our major cities and our communities requires substantial investment over many years and across several parliaments.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Of course, public investment will continue to play a vital role, but we can go further when private investment is harnessed to meet public goals, when government and the private sector come together in partnership. And when we balance certainty for private investors with safeguards for the public interest, we give ourselves more tools to build the modern infrastructure Britain needs. This bill creates such a tool, and it does so in two ways.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful to the minister to allow an intervention, and I welcome all of the measures in this bill to invest in our road system. But I wonder whether he would like to comment on the technological advances which are going to happen to vehicles, in particular over the next decades we will see most vehicles will eventually become self-driving, which will mean that there'll be much less congestion. The vehicles will communicate with each other so there'll be much simpler junctions, there'll be less accidents. And what account is the government taking of the technical changes in vehicles?
I'm grateful for my honorable friend's intervention. Clearly we are working on projections about what we know about the road network now. We know that Dartford in particular is over capacity and needs to be addressed. I think in terms of whether automated vehicles actually reduce congestion, I would say we need to see what actually happens in practice. But I'll go on, Madam Deputy Speaker, about the regulated asset base, or the RAB model, which will be applied to trunk roads in England.
This model isn't new. It's the same one used to fund the Thames Tideway Tunnel and Sizewell C, but this is the first time it will be used on a road network. And for our roads, it starts by granting a license for a specific highway project to a private investor. The framework for that license is set in this parliament, starting with construction through to operation and to maintenance. This means any infrastructure project under this model starts as it should, with a sound legal and regulatory foundation.
The Office of Rail and Road will then act as the independent economic regulator. It will have a wide range of powers in the public interest, monitoring performance, obtaining information, issuing penalties, and if necessary, taking enforcement to revoke a license. Madam Deputy Speaker, these public interest safeguards are vital and will never be compromised. There can also be no disparity between the operation of a privately funded highway and one managed by National Highways. So I can assure the House that this bill means roads operated under the new licensing regime can be held to the same standards as the rest of the strategic road network.
But even when difficulties arise, it ensures road users are protected and there is continuity of service on the network. Finally, this bill allows a private operator to make a regulated return on their investment. Any charges or tolls will be levied under strict conditions set out by the Office of Rail and Road, which will be required to consider the interests of road users. But let me be crystal clear, this bill isn't and will never be national road pricing by the back door. And this bill isn't and will never be a way to charge motorists across the wider network.
The provisions in this bill apply only to roads brought within the financial and legal framework we are debating today. And let me be clear, that framework is not open-ended. Licenses may only be issued for new road projects, capacity-enhancing improvements, or the continued operation of a previously licensed road. And any road specified in a license must be a trunk road in England. This is about strategically important routes, not minor improvements to the road network.
Government policy is that tolling will normally be used only for costly river and estuarial crossings, and nothing in this bill is set to change that. So I'll now turn to the second major feature of this bill. Some of the legislation governing toll collection dates back to the 18th century. It's high time that they were updated so we can unleash the benefits of modern technology on our roads. Many of us have at some point experienced long queues at toll booths.
It adds unnecessary delay to your journey and drivers will rightly wonder when regulations will catch up with technology. Free-flowing tolling systems do not require vehicles to stop at traditional booths, and by allowing payment after use, they ease congestion and shorten journey times. This bill doesn't mandate a certain approach to toll collection, but simply allows new technologies to be adopted and creates a modern statutory framework for enforcement practices. And I have little doubt drivers will welcome measures which remove friction from their journeys. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is no secret that our desire to push forward with this legislation stems from the Lower Thames Crossing.
The Lower Thames Crossing will almost double road capacity across the Thames to the east of London. It will improve journey times and it will tackle chronic congestion at Dartford, which is bursting at the seams. Its 2.6-mile dual tunnels under the Thames will be the longest road tunnels in the country and the largest in Europe by diameter. And it will set the standard for carbon-neutral construction. In short, it's exactly the sort of ambitious and world-leading infrastructure project Britain should be building.
We've been clear the RAB model is our preferred financial approach for the Lower Thames Crossing, but this bill isn't about the Lower Thames Crossing's design, nor does it grant development consent. That work has already been done. It simply creates the financial framework that can deliver the Lower Thames Crossing as well as appropriate future road projects. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me finish by reminding colleagues what lies at the heart of this bill. A recognition that too many people in too many places remain held back because of poor connectivity.
This bill does not ask the House to choose public finance or private finance as a matter of ideology, but it provides another tool at our disposal to deliver the infrastructure that Britain needs. And this financial model won't be used in every case, but it does step out one practical approach. Guided by a financial framework set by government, a compliance regime enforced by an independent regulator, private capital provided by investors, and public safeguards protected at every stage. It's the balanced model that this bill will deliver, and I commend it to the House.
A recognition that each congested road and every delayed journey stifles productivity.
John Richard Holden
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are here today to primarily debate the measures to deliver the Lower Thames Crossing, an infrastructure project that I think is right to say has support from across the House. It will deliver jobs, it will deliver growth, it will deliver the economic opportunities local communities in the region, including in my own constituency of Basildon and Billericay, are absolutely crying out for. But I'm afraid to say that is not all we are here to debate today, because Labour could have brought a project-specific piece of legislation to the House that would get this project over the line. Instead, today we are here partially as well to challenge the government, this Labour government, as it opens the door to a road charging scheme to hammer motorists.
They say, the minister has said, that this bill only concerns these existing big toll roads. We say that's obviously not the case. In fact, under this bill, motorists all over the country could be forced to stomach another blow to their wallets, forking out their hard-earned cash as the bill's sweeping powers mean that anything new on the road, anything, a new smart motorway camera perhaps to replace one of those 400 miles on the road network that currently don't work, anything new could be swiftly followed up with a new toll. And what's more, Clause 81 says that, and the minister said it's only on trunk roads, Clause 81 allows the minister to direct the power to make any road a trunk road as well. So it absolutely opens up the entire road network of the country.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would be shocked, but in truth... I happily give way.
Christopher Chope
Would he not agree that it would be very sensible for the three London bridges which are in disrepair to be designated as trunk roads so that they could be repaired under the provisions of this legislation?
John Richard Holden
Well, I mean, my honourable friend makes an important point. In fact, my understanding is that on some of the piece of the legislation which was put forwards by this government in order to actually have a look at some of those projects, those local councils actually came to the government to say that the funding that they were putting forwards under their own schemes, not even included in this legislation, weren't even suitable for the particularly for the Hammersmith project. So I think there's lots of options available, and that would be an important one given the importance of those river crossings to the people of London but also to the wider country. But in truth, we all know that Labour doesn't care about motorists, because if they did, where is the Secretary of State? Where on earth is the Secretary of State on a piece of legislation to discuss the biggest road infrastructure project that this country has done in decades?
Where is she today? Too busy to bother about motorists. I happily give way.
Jennifer Craft
Thank you very much, thank the honourable member for giving way. Perhaps he could clarify where the Conservative government were over the last 14 years when it came to building this project, which has delivered so much uncertainty for people in my constituency who've been on tenterhooks for years being told that it will happen and then that it won't.
John Richard Holden
Well, the honourable lady can look at the road projects that we were putting forwards under the last government and the projects that have been cancelled already under this government.
We'll come onto some of those later on. In fact, as the minister said, all of the, as the minister said, if the honourable lady would care to allow me to speak, the minister said all of the planning and all of that has already gone through. That's what the last government was doing, getting us to and exactly to this point. So the honourable lady shakes her head, but the minister's already contradicted her. She could just listen to the honourable member's speech.
And happily give way to the honourable friend.
Mark Francois
As a South Essex MP, I had my first briefing on the Lower Thames Crossing about a decade ago. And the estimated cost at that time was between two and two and a half billion pounds. After, I think, five rounds of consultation, partly at the behest of environmental activists, which have delayed the whole thing for years, we now have, we now have a bill of between nine and ten billion. But the government's policy is, whereas first off it would be paid for by the state, 90% of it will be paid for by the private sector. I've asked the Transport Secretary three times which banks or companies will pay for it.
Does he know, because she won't tell me?
John Richard Holden
It's a very important point that my honourable friend makes. We just do not know who is going to fund this yet. And perhaps the minister, if he'd like to intervene on me to say if any companies have been lined up already, who is looking forwards to fund this piece of legislation, to fund this under the scheme which is being proposed. Not at the moment. So I don't think my right honourable friend's going to get an answer to that question today.
Too busy, the Secretary of State, to, I've just given way several times, so let me make a little progress before I give way again. Too busy to bother about motorists until they become useful cash cows for Labour's ballooning welfare budget that shows no signs of changing under this new Prime Minister, no matter how many pints he poses with. The honourable, the right honourable lady, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, couldn't even be bothered to mention fuel in her speech at party conference, even though it's just hit two pounds a litre on diesel for the first time ever. Though to be fair, she did mention drivers once, but only to tell us that railways were the drivers of change, whatever that means. Madam Deputy Speaker, make no mistake, Labour do not care about Britain's motorists unless it's a tax, unless it's a charge, a new fine, a new yellow box junction.
Labour, the government, their backbenchers, their councillors, will never stop trying to fleece motorists. And this bill proves that in spades with its open-ended approach to what could happen. New sweeping powers are in there for road charging right across England, next to with next to no future parliamentary approval. It's not even as if the Secretary of State, Secretary of State has been out there banging the drum for Britain's automotive sector. Otherwise we would have seen the changes to ZEV mandate that so many in the industry, and including some really good Labour backbenchers, some Labour backbenchers are demanding.
In fact, we've seen actually them turn the screw even further on it since they came to power. Some Labour ministers though, we know, are on the side of motorists, such as the member for Stockton North, the minister in the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade. But the Transport Department has shown absolutely no indication that they are on the side of Britain's car industry or those who work on it in good jobs, often with trade union representation up and down the country, or on the side of those who go out and drive for work or leisure day after day. What has this government done? Well, they've been busy merrily cooking up a story with the Treasury and merrily pressing ahead with plans to put an extra six p a litre on fuel in the new year, busily slicing out road scheme after road scheme, road upgrade after road upgrade.
So much for the road investment strategy that the minister says. Under this government, how can we have any confidence they're going to deliver this scheme at all when we've just seen the A303 cancelled, the Blyth relief road cancelled, the A31, the A10, the A12, the A17, the A454, the A127 growth corridor, as my honourable friend mentioned just before, and many more. Madam Deputy Speaker, they have cancelled the growth corridor, their own growth corridor they've cancelled.
And she, well she's not here, but maybe the honourable minister can tell us, expects us to swallow this, that they're suddenly going to be on the side of motorists and road users with this new scheme, which opens the entire road network, the entire road network, to as soon as anything new, new, any new enhancement is put in, maybe a central reservation enhancement, can be opened up, opened up to potential road charging. When I read the other day to my amazement that National Highways have banned diesel from construction sites on the Lower Thames Crossing, banned diesel, are, is this government absolutely mad about trying to keep costs of this project down? And my honourable friend makes a good point. And now they've devised a new cunning plan. They're not just banning diesel, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Oh no. They're banning HVOs. Yes, you heard that right. They're going to wipe out vegetable oils which are being repurposed as diesel from the sites as well. It's going to have to be all electric, Madam Deputy Speaker.
How much cost are they actually going to be ramming through onto this scheme? And who in the end's going to end up paying it? It's not going to be the private company who runs it. It's going to be everybody who crosses the Thames. So this is exactly what this government is doing.
Opening it up and driving costs in from day one on the biggest road scheme that this country has done in decades, and the Secretary of State isn't even here to talk about it. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is neither the time or place. I happily give way at this point.
Jim Dickson
Shadow Secretary keeps mentioning the fact the Secretary of State isn't here. Is he aware that one of the first things she did on assuming her role was to agree the development consent order for the Lower Thames Crossing, which your government, the last government, Madam Deputy Speaker, had failed to do over 14 years because they weren't prepared to stand up to the environmental groups who slowed the thing down and allowed dither and delay.
John Richard Holden
Well I think the honourable, given the fact that the last government fought tooth and nail through the courts to deliver this scheme, I think the honourable member and got those planning consents all the way through, I think the honourable member should really take a little bit of note of that. This isn't something that this government dreamed up overnight and is delivering. But what it is actually doing is it's ramming costs right through the heart of this scheme, which his constituents are going to be paying for in the years to come because of the way that it's going to be constructed. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is neither the time or place for one of Baldrick's cunning plans. But does the minister know how much is this scheme going to cost?
If not, why not? How on earth is any private sector company going to look at investing if it's an open-ended cost? They say that they want to deliver growth, but instead they spend their days screwing over motorists, cancelling road schemes, calling Heathrow expansion a hypothetical or a matter for London. Madam Deputy Speaker, this, they are not a serious party intent on delivering growth. They are only there to whack up the welfare budget and leave the rest of us to pay for it.
We have set out a clear plan in my party to tackle some of the costs of infrastructure, including at our party conference leaving the Aarhus Convention, and I'll take an intervention on that exact point.
Peter Richard Prinsley
I'm grateful to the honourable shadow minister for taking the intervention. What I'd like to ask the shadow minister is whether he is opposed in principle to the concept of tolls for any of these projects.
John Richard Holden
Honestly, I'd like to thank the honourable member, my occasional squash partner, for asking that question, and he often beats me in that as well. We are not opposed to tolls per se. What we are opposed, because in fact obviously we've had them on the Lower Thames Crossing, the current Lower Thames Crossing at Dartford for years. But we did take them away on the Severn Bridge, an important thing for iconic connectivity to Wales.
And what we are totally against is opening up the entire strategic road network to charging. And that's what this piece of legislation actually does.
Will my honorable friend allow me again?
I would allow him.
Mark Francois
I'm very grateful. For the record, the first Dartford Tunnel opened in 1963 under a Conservative government, and the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge at Thurrock opened in 1991 under a Conservative government. But isn't the risk now that with the Lower Thames Crossing, if it's 90% private finance, which I'm not opposed to in principle, but the toll charges could be so ruinous that it would be very difficult for ordinary motorists to afford it? We'd have some confidence if we knew who was going to fund it, but until we know who will be funding it, we're going to be worried, aren't we?
John Richard Holden
And I'd like to thank the honorable member for that point because nowhere in this legislation is there any talk of the exact price that people are going to have to pay to cross the river at all. There's no idea of who's going to build it. There's no idea of the cost of it. There's no idea of how much people are going to have to pay to cross. So there are huge amounts of open-ended questions left by this piece of legislation.
But as I was saying, my party's outlined plans as to how we're going to reduce the cost of infrastructure, including leaving the Aarhus Convention so that we can tackle the rules that allow costly or protracted legal challenges. The Minister smirks there, but it's costing his department hundreds of millions of pounds a year. And that's one of the reasons if they got if they pulled out of it, they could deliver some of the road projects that his government's just cancelled. That's exactly what we should be doing. Every man and his dog at the moment can challenge the government on any important piece of road infrastructure that is being built in the country, or in Jolyon Maugham's case, every man and his fox.
From using those rules to delay projects and costing the taxpayer with costs capped for an individual of £5,000, for a campaign group at £10,000, but costing the taxpayer hundreds of millions of pounds a year. That's where the honorable member for Dartford should be thinking about how he can save money for his constituents crossing the road in the future and why it took so long for this piece of legislation to come forward because it took so long for the planning to happen. And what plan have they set out? To be a world leader in greenwashing road building? To be a world leader in making roads more expensive than anywhere in the world?
We have a government run by a man whose only care for transport is whether it's in Manchester or not. Madam Deputy Speaker, I have no doubt that if the LTC were actually somewhere in Manchester, then the government would be falling over itself to get it built, rather than with no answers to the big questions that we have. No, I'm finishing off my speech now, thank you. What on earth is the government doing? Where are the safeguards against higher charges for motorists?
He doesn't know. Well, I have read the bill and obviously when we talk about clauses 33 and clauses 81 and the fact that this could lead to road charging schemes right across the country, the Minister seems to have not read the bill, his own bill. What safeguards are there? How much will his plans to ban diesel add to the cost of construction? Does he know?
Would he like to tell us? No, he's not going to say. So my shadow ministers, my honorable friends, the members for Mid Buckinghamshire and Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, will take the government to task on this toe-to-toe in committee, defending motorists against unlimited tolls and endless charges. That is why we have tabled our reasoned amendment today, to call on the government to see sense, to keep costs for motorists down, to get this project built and deliver the growth we desperately need in this country. Thank you.
Speaker 216
The original question was that the bill be now read a second time, since when an amendment has been proposed as on the order paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Mike Reader.
Michael Reader
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of you will know I joined the industry 20 years ago as a civil engineer. And through my career, I've been very fortunate to work on a lot of major infrastructure, including Lower Thames, A303, and some of the big National Highways frameworks like SPaTS and RIPDIP.
And I now chair the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Infrastructure. So I come at this bill from someone who has priced major contracts, who has bid for them, and who has seen what happens when the money just isn't there. But I thought I would just start my contribution to this debate with a safety moment. For those of you who have been around the sector, you know safety culture is absolutely critical to delivering our road network and delivering our road network safely. And a safety moment that's always stuck with me is one from National Highways.
It's about a lady I'm going to call Jane. Jane had a busy day at National Highways. She jumped in her car, was driving home, was involved in a very low-speed traffic collision. When she hit the car in front, her airbag went off and caused her lanyard to be forced through her chest and end up in the hospital. So it's always a good reminder to start today, when you leave today, if you rush to your car to drive home, don't only remove your lanyard for your security, but also for your safety.
I want to start though with why this matters to Northampton. Why would an MP for Northampton be talking about a scheme in Essex and Kent? Well, Northampton sits at the heart of the logistics network. 2,640 logistics businesses operate out of Northamptonshire. That's 35,000 people work in haulage and logistics in my county.
Every day, goods move between warehouses in my constituency and the channel ports, many of them crossing through the Thames via Dartford. And when Dartford jams up, those costs are felt in my constituency, it's felt across the Midlands. And I support this bill. I think it is the right thing to do to deal with that problem. But I agree with the view of the RHA and many hauliers that we must also consider the cost on freight operators, and when these licensing agreements come forward, that we consider the considerable business costs and fuel costs that many businesses in my constituency are facing.
Now, planning has long been the biggest barrier to building roads. The DCO process for Lower Thames particularly has been torturous, and I know that fact unfortunately first-hand. But the second biggest barrier has often been money. The Treasury can only fund so many projects at one time, and every project competes for the same pot. And this bill brings in the private capital to build things that would otherwise sit in the queue.
And I've long argued that private finance does work in the sector. We saw when the Silvertown Tunnel opened earlier last year, it showed that modern public-private partnerships can deliver for taxpayers, and I still believe that. But I want to be straight with this House, because when I spoke to the minister who was previously responsible and now the current minister, this is an ambitious thing we are doing. The regulated asset base model is not used elsewhere in the world, I believe, for road infrastructure. Traditionally, we see it delivered through concessions or availability-based PPPs.
But I was concerned initially, so I went out and spoke to industry. Rather than sitting and shouting at the department, "Where's the money coming from?", I went and spoke to investors. I went to speak to investors through the GIIA, through some of the big advisers to the investment community on this project. And they said actually this is quite an exciting opportunity, particularly because it should reduce the cost of capital. By creating a regulated return with a review by an independent regulator, it should deliver cheaper finance and, importantly, more competition for that finance.
So it's completely right the department can't say who's funding it yet, because we need to go out, run that competition to get that funding in the first place. The better certainty we give to the market through a model like this, the better chances we have of securing that finance at a much lower cost, of course.
Mark Francois
He's obviously spent a lot of time looking into this, and I commend him for that. As a result of his discussions, could he estimate, A, when we might know who the funders will be? Is it another year or two or when? And B, what does he think the initial toll will be for a lorry going through the tunnel, as he's obviously spoken to the Road Haulage Association as well?
Michael Reader
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wouldn't want to speculate on the government's timetable for this. I think what's important is this bill goes through, then we go through the licensing arrangement to find the the right partner to deliver this and obviously finance. But, you know, the delays that happened under the previous government, the first failed DCO when they completely ignored the local community, and then the second DCO ending up in the courts because, as my honourable friend said, the challenges brought forward by the environmental lobby were not dealt with. And I'm really disappointed to see the the opposition playing that card now when they stood up and campaigned against the Planning and Infrastructure Act, which brought forward many measures which would have solved the problems that Lower Thames had.
But the question of risk is another important point on this, because a RAB model moves construction risk onto the people who are financing and building and delivering the scheme, but the treatment of risk in delivery of a major infrastructure project can make the difference between success and failure. The question is who holds that risk? The Competition and Markets Authority review into the civil engineering sector rightly identified, particularly for major projects, the transfer of risk down the supply chain from tier ones, from financiers into the supply chain can make a big difference to the insolvency and and how that project is delivered. So we have to make sure that in the licensing arrangements for that come through this bill, there is provision for government to require equitable risk management and risk treatment within delivery of projects and prompt payment through the supply chain to make sure that this billions and billions of pounds of investment, that money flows through quickly into the supply chain and isn't stuck at tier one level. So I have a couple of questions for the minister to round off, and I'm very grateful for his and his predecessor's engagement on this bill.
The Secretary of State told the Transport Committee that the process for setting tolls in the first settlement period, which would answer the right honourable member's question, would be set out as the bill progresses. Can the minister confirm that is still the case? The standard license conditions will be set by the Secretary of State without parliamentary procedure, so will the government commit to publishing the core principles for investor return and price reviews before any license is guaranteed? The bill puts new requirements on the ORR, who I've had relatively good experiences with, but this is a new skill and capability they have to have. So what is the government going to do to strengthen the capability of the ORR to manage these contracts effectively?
And on existing roads, to address the point from the shadow bench, the government confirmed already in a written answer they have no plans to currently use these powers to toll roads that are currently free, and I welcome that. So could the minister in his closing remarks put that that confusion beyond doubt from the dispatch box? Madam Deputy Speaker, many or some will say this is a paper journey model that will change Britain's roads, but I don't believe it is. It's a way of getting the biggest schemes, the schemes that get stalled for years if not generations, off the drawing pad and into delivery, and I fully support this bill.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I start by welcoming the minister to his place? And he has been blessed with the opportunity to bring another scintillating transport bill to this House, which clearly has excited a very large number of honourable members. Starting with his comments about the Lower Thames Crossing, which is clearly a major reason for why this legislation's been proposed, he's quite right to say that there is a clear need to relieve pressure on the Dartford crossings, which connect the two ends of the M25 across the Thames. But I think it's it's always interesting that we seem to make an assumption that traffic growth is inevitable, which certainly from the perspective of the railways bill has been an assumption that the government was not quite so ready willing to make, opposing passenger growth targets with that. And I make that point purely because, yes, of course we need to cater for future increases in road demand, but there's also a lot we can do, particularly for long-distance traffic, to transfer that demand to other transport modes, both passenger and freight.
And indeed, in that context, whilst the Lower Thames Crossing has merit in terms of relieving the existing Thames crossings, the government appears to be repeating the mistake of many past Labour and Conservative governments where road building is seen as the sole answer and rail infrastructure is neglected. The Channel Tunnel is one of the engineering wonders of the world, yet continues to be underutilized, especially for rail freight. In fact, it largely doesn't exist beyond lorries going on Le Shuttle, or whatever it's called this week. Channel Tunnel use charges are one of the barriers, as are the capabilities of the UK rail network within Kent. There are well-developed plans for upgrades to the Kent conventional rail network to accommodate W12 loading gauge freight trains and intentions to create a freight hub served by High Speed 1 at Barking, but that would benefit from acceleration.
So I just wanted to make those general points about Lower Thames Crossing. Now, the bill as drafted would also give the government significant powers to impose road tolls and charges on major roads. And I think I would note at that point, a new financing model for the strategic road network, whilst local roads that make up 99% of the country's roads in terms of length and are facing an 18 billion pound repairs backlog, is an interesting choice by the government. But let's engage with that choice directly. There are examples of the concept of tolls and charges working well both here and abroad.
The M6 toll road is one that many choose to use instead of the M6, despite the fact that there is a fee to pay because it reduces some of the road-to-hell experience that the M6 often is for many. And in France, motorway tolls are common, if not universal, and many European countries use a system called a vignette, which is that's where you pay for a sticker or a digital version of that to go on your vehicle and that enables you to use motorways and trunk roads. Now, the advantage of that system is it means that people who want to use motorways and trunk roads pay a little bit more so that they're able to do so, but people who only use their car for very local purposes don't have to pay that cost.
John Richard Holden
Would the member accept that actually this legislation allows for exactly what we see in France, which is toll roads across the entire strategic road network?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the right honorable gentleman for his intervention. Not all French motorways are tolled. It's certain sections of them and often the busiest. So I'm just going to come on a little bit in terms of what he said earlier about what this bill does and what it doesn't do. Now, our position on this is the way that such charges and tolls, like the ones in Europe and M6 that I mentioned, the way they're implemented needs very close attention to detail and scrutiny.
But the bill leaves all of those questions of operation, management, oversight, and regulation of tolls and charges largely undefined and often relegated to secondary legislation. Now, the government must ensure that road users are not held ransom by license holders who must be properly regulated. And we have seen some of the disastrous effects in other sectors where these things are got wrong. Now, the minister and the honorable member for Northampton South gave some good examples of how a regulated asset-based approach and indeed private finance initiatives can be used to good, but of course, there are many bad examples as well. In the water industry, I'm not sure too many people believe that the current water industry's approach to use of the regulated asset-based approach has necessarily been enormously successful.
And certainly, regulation of private investors and making sure that the triggers for the special administration regime defined within the legislation, it's very important that those triggers aren't too weak. And of course, there are many examples of public-private partnerships and private finance initiatives in the past that have not ended well, particularly with hospitals and the London Underground.
Will the honorable gentleman give way?
Mark Francois
A very thoughtful speech. I was recently on a private holiday in Texas, being driven by a friend. They have a number of toll roads in that state. So they have a chip basically in the windscreen or attached to the windscreen, which allows you to transition from as it were public roads to toll roads and back again, and the chip records what you pay as you go from one to the other, in effect. So the technology to do this already exists.
I saw it with my own eyes. We're just a bit worried that this government might be a bit too keen to adopt it.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention. I think he's right to say that if we are going to go down that road, it needs to be very transparent. It needs to be done in a way that gives consumers confidence, because car drivers and road users, they are consumers, and we should think of them in the same sense as we do as customers on the railway or in planes, etc. So if it is going to be done, it needs to be done with great care and great thought. And that is why we need to scrutinize this legislation carefully.
I give way to the honorable lady.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
And on that subject, it's hardly new in London. We've had the congestion charge for many, many years now. And drivers in and around our major cities are used to that as a charge they have to include in their budgets.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the honorable lady for her intervention. Yes, London is another example of where some of these things are already happening. But the fact that they have at times been controversial is exactly why they need to be done with thought and ideally in a manner that avoids some of these interminable culture wars that we must always have on every topic these days, and instead with consensus and based on sound reason and analysis. However, because we're not satisfied that the bill as drafted does provide that transparency and accountability, we're not going to take a view on it as a whole, but we hope that the government will be more receptive to some of our ideas to improving the bill at later common stages than perhaps they have been hitherto.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I listened to the debate today. And from the opposition benches, I do, they have amnesia over some things that have happened over the years. You know, the Dartford Crossing order in 2013, the Silvertown order in 2018. These things, which directly impact my constituents every single day in Bexleyheath and Crayford, happened under their watch.
And their Conservative MPs in my part of Southeast London go around campaigning, how dare you increase the Silvertown charges this year. It was their legislation which insisted that happened. They really do forget what happened under their watch. Can I start, Madam Deputy Speaker, I should have said by declaring I'm an officer of the APPG for Better Roads, the chair of the APPG for Wheelchair Users, and I do drive, because I'll refer to it later, a mobility vehicle on behalf of my daughter. My constituency of Bexleyheath and Crayford sits less than three miles from the Dartford Crossing.
And for businesses in my constituency, particularly those industrial businesses in Crayford and Slade Green, it's a central link. A number of those businesses are located around Thames Road in Crayford. Over 20 years ago, as Bexley's cabinet member for transport, I worked to ensure funding was forthcoming from the then Labour government and Transport for London to upgrade Thames Road in Crayford to a dual carriageway. And unfortunately, one part of the scheme was never completed, which leaves a pinch point at the Craymill railway bridge on Thames Road that carries the North Kent railway line.
The road's constricted due to that single carriageway to pass through the bridge arches and this pinch point can cause long queuing during busy periods and it's a matter that I'll be continuing to raise both with my local authority and with the government. And similarly, a couple miles down the road at my honorable friend from Dartford's constituency at the Littlebrook interchange as vehicles approach the Dartford tunnel to travel north across the Thames, there are further delays for my constituents. These issues, however, are resolvable through engineering terms, but the congestion at Dartford each day is a lot harder to resolve. The delivery of the Lower Thames Crossing will reduce the number of vehicles, particularly lorries, which have crossed the channel, which then need to cross the Thames, relieving that congestion. And I've warmly welcomed that Lower Thames Crossing will double road capacity east of Crayford in my constituency.
And for my businesses, the Lower Thames Crossing will deliver reduced costs and opportunity for them to grow, which is why I'm amazed actually that later today the Conservatives will vote on a reasoned amendment calling for the bill to progress, leaving the scheme which would leave the scheme without a mechanism to fund it. So this afternoon, the Conservatives will actively try to stop this bill that supports growth and investment for businesses in my constituency and across Southeast London and the Thames Estuary. Now, of course, I would say to members opposite, the time to try and amend the issue if they've got concerns is at bill committee and at report stage rather than just try and kill the bill in its entirety this afternoon. And I know there will be issues, of course, in that bill as it progresses, which will need looking at. I know my constituents and businesses would want us to look at mechanisms within clauses 7, 8, 24, 25 and 26 to ensure there are consistent tolling arrangements at both the Lower Thames Crossing and the existing arrangements at the Dartford Crossing.
And in particular, the mouthful of schedule 3 of the A8282 trunk road Dartford-Thurrock crossing charging scheme order 2013 passed under the previous government outlines that a vehicle which is exempt from vehicle excise duty due to carrying disabled people doesn't pay the toll. Now, that normally relates to mobility vehicles and I'm clear that we do need to ensure there is consistency across both the Dartford and Lower Thames crossings that that legislation mirrors itself so that mobility users have some consistency across the two. Also, I believe that consideration needs we need to look into the detail of clauses 33, 87 and 92 rather as the bill progresses to protect arrangements on that tolling and the consistency that there currently is. Now, clauses 87 and 92 allow arrangements which would see the removal of toll booths at other toll roads and crossings such as the M6 toll or the Mersey tunnel. And I again warmly welcome that.
You know, it would relieve congestion and as the honorable gentleman for Didcot and Wantage has referred to, you know, actually that's happening more and more in France currently. I had a panic moment this year actually when I was on a toll road without a toll booth and I realized I hadn't paid. So so that that is happening more and more and and there are lessons that, you know, we need to learn from our French counterparts on that matter. But for business again, relieving that congestion is a real benefit. And and what I would say as well is it doesn't solely need the bill, but the bill can be a catalyst to how we begin to look at the interoperability of toll systems.
Currently, if you're a business in Crayford and you want to cross at Dartford and then use the M6 toll and then maybe use another toll somewhere else, you've got to set up several accounts across different toll roads. And the cost that has to business, the amount of work in your internal accounting systems in your business, we've got to look at that. And the interoperability arrangements both for businesses and also for disabled people at the moment, you need a separate mobility account on every single toll road, some of which at Dartford is free, at Silvertown is free, but you have to register at Silvertown, you don't have to register at Dartford, but on the M6 toll, on the Mersey tunnel, you do have to register, you do have to pay an annual charge.
It's hugely confusing for disabled people that this arrangement exists across different toll roads and it's a different arrangement at each. And so for business and for disabled people, I would warmly encourage the government to work with, and I know very much so that conversations are already being had between the Dartford crossing and the M6 toll about the interoperability and bringing those systems into one arrangement and looking at how we can encourage that across all toll systems in our country. So as I say, for my business Bexley and Crayford, I'm sure they would welcome bringing those toll roads and crossings into one system. And similarly for those mobility users. So I do support the bill, Madam Deputy Speaker.
It will bring benefits to my constituents through the delivery of the Lower Thames Crossing. It will allow that conversation I hope to start on interoperability, which will support those businesses and reduce complexity both for them to help encourage growth in our economy and for mobility customers. And so I warmly welcome the bill and I look forward to hearing the minister's comments later in the debate.
Christopher Chope
Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a pleasure to follow the honorable gentleman and I think that the problems with relation to the different varieties of charges and the way in which they are enforced is not just a problem for people with disabilities, it's also a problem for the general motorist. And that's why the current Dart charge, for example, as I understand it, almost half the income from penalties is almost as great as the income from the charge itself, which shows the level of confusion caused to the people who use that crossing. Can I begin by saying that I had the privilege of being the duty minister in October 1991 when the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge was opened by Her Late Majesty. And that was an occasion which I shall never forget with flypasts and I think the QE2 was there underneath the bridge and it was a great celebration of private enterprise at its best. Because members may recall that that bridge was built in only three years and two months.
It cost 120 million pounds. It was delivered on time and to budget. And the way in which it was financed was set out in the Dartford-Thurrock Crossing legislation in 1988. And I hope in responding to this debate, the minister will explain why a similar proposal is not being applied now to the Lower Thames Crossing. But when that 1991 bridge was opened, that's 35 years ago this month, I checked this out, part of the remarks that I made as the minister at the time was a reference to the fact that we were working on the Lower Thames Crossing.
And that's 35 years ago we recognized that there would be a need for an additional crossing of the Thames, the Lower Thames Crossing. And the idea then was that the funding from the tolls on the Dartford crossing would eventually be used to help fund the Lower Thames Crossing. So let's recall, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I think this is why I'm supportive of my front bench's amendment to this bill because I think it shows a certain skepticism about all these promises that are made. Because at the time of the opening of the QE2 bridge, I promised, and it was a promise that was repeated, a repeat of a promise that had been given by conservative ministers before, that the tolls would be ceased to be payable once the costs of the bridge had been paid for.
And the legislation provided that there was a maximum period of 20 years through which the tolls would need to be paid, or could be paid, in order to fund the bridge. In the end, I think the period of the tolls was only about 12 years because, or should have been about 12 years, because at the end of that period the bridge had been paid for. There was then an extension of one year for tolls to ensure that we had sufficient income to pay for the ongoing repairs and maintenance costs. And that should have been the end of the burden on the motorist, the financial burden on the motorist using that crossing. Of course it wasn't, because then the Treasury got involved and said, "No, we need to keep the income coming in from that crossing."
And how do we justify that? Well, the justification was that by continuing to have tolls on that crossing, we would then be able to fund the Lower Thames Crossing. And that continued for a bit of time, and then in due course, I think it was under a Labour government, they decided that they didn't want to have the income from the tolls dedicated to a future road project across the Thames, but the money would go into general taxation. And so we lost the dedicated fund, the allocated resources which should have been there to fund the Lower Thames Crossing, and the money that continues to be paid by those who use the Dartford Crossing is just going into general taxation. Is it any surprise that people are skeptical about promises that are made when legislation like this is being debated?
The minister says that this is not going to be used as a vehicle for toll roads across the country. Frankly, from my own perspective, I once argued that I thought the best thing for us to promote the important highway infrastructure in this country, and I'm no apologist, I believe that roads for prosperity is what we need to be building in our infrastructure, and that was the title of the 1990 roads white paper which led to an enormous expansion in our road network and which I was lucky enough to be able to be involved with in my time as the roads minister.
Mark Francois
I thank my right honorable friend. He's bringing, if I may say so, valuable ministerial experience to the House. It is fair to say, I think, that the Lower Thames Crossing has a very long and very checkered history, just as HS2 has a very long and very checkered history, and in both cases under governments of different colors. But he's absolutely right that the skepticism about future tolls on the Lower Thames Crossing is largely based in South Essex about the fact that the tolls on the QE2 bridge are still in operation.
Christopher Chope
Well, I thank my right honorable friend for that observation. And that's why we need to be very skeptical about what the government's proposing. But let's look at the issue around the Lower Thames Crossing. It's said now that a figure of 10 billion pounds is going to be the cost of it. And people say, "Well, how are we going to raise that money?"
It seems to me that it won't be difficult to get the capital from the private sector if a return can be obtained on that capital. Indeed, when Sir Nigel Broackes, who was the boss of Trafalgar House, was bidding for the Dartford Crossing, he went out and he obtained the money, the capital money, he got it from the Bank of America.
So I don't think there's any doubt that the money will be forthcoming. The question is, what will be the cost of the whole project? Will the project have a finite amount of cost of about, maybe 10 billion pounds? If so, over how long a period will the government be allowing the operator and construction vehicle to have that paid back? Because will the tolls be designed to pay back the costs of the tunnel within 20 years, 30 years, 50 years?
And the answer to that question will determine what the level of these tolls is going to be, and are they going to be affordable? My own view is that it's reasonable that in order to provide this infrastructure, the costs of so providing it should be paid for by the people who are going to use the infrastructure. I don't have a quarrel with that. The honorable lady, I give way to the honorable lady.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
It's been really interesting listening to the former minister with his distinguished career, and I can't speak for the former funding of the Dartford Crossing. But does he not recognize that with a RAB model, which is overseen by the Office of Road and Rail, as with other RAB projects, the funding is in effect hypothecated to the scheme and is clear and transparent, unlike what he alluded to earlier about drivers not knowing whether their funding was being merged in with general taxation income? And also, how long will it last? Surely that depends on what risk and for how long the investors are prepared to offer to the government in their bidding to take on the license.
Christopher Chope
Well, I hear what the honorable lady says, but what the question I'm asking is why can't we have dedicated legislation for the Lower Thames Crossing in the same way as we had for the Dartford-Thurrock Crossing? And in the primary legislation which went through this House, it was specified that the tolls should only be there for the length of time it took to repay the costs of the construction. It was subsequent governments that changed it in the way that I've described. And that's because any legislation can obviously be changed by a subsequent Parliament. But at the, I'll give way again in a minute, but at the outset, when that bill was put through and approved by Parliament, it was clear that the tolls were only going to be for the duration of what was necessary in order to pay for the construction of that infrastructure.
I give way to the honorable lady.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
I appreciate his response to me, but as it's clear in the bill today, the funding through the RAB model of the Lower Thames Crossing and other schemes is not only for the construction, it's for the ongoing maintenance, necessary improvements and so on. So it is a long-term scheme, not merely for the cost of the actual construction itself.
Christopher Chope
I understand that, and that's one of my concerns, that we may find that the tolls continue for far longer into the distance when the need for those tolls to pay for the maintenance of the infrastructure, for example, will no longer be there.
So in a sense, the model which is being espoused for this project, the Lower Thames Crossing project, could have exactly the same consequences for the motorists, which is that they end up paying a lot more than the actual cost of the tunnel which they will be using in the Lower Thames Crossing. So I hope the Minister can explain why we couldn't have had ring-fenced specific legislation on this rather than this general bill. And it seems to me that if we had actually done that, we would have been able to make a lot more progress. I'm delighted that my right honourable friend on the front bench is saying we, the Conservatives, would like to leave the Aarhus Convention because it inhibits progress on projects. And I can remember again when I was the Roads Minister, all the difficulties that we had with the European Union around the legislation, European Union legislation, which was preventing the completion of the M3 around and through Twyford Down.
And that was environmental interference which ultimately cost our economy a significant amount of money. And if anybody uses the M3 now, they'll see that that just blends into the landscape and it's a really well-designed project. But the question I put to my right honourable friend on the front bench rhetorically is why didn't we do something about the Aarhus Convention when we were in government? Because like a lot of other things, I'm delighted that our new leader of the Conservative Party shows herself to be a real Conservative. And I fear that we're still suffering from the hangover of a so-called Conservative government which didn't get to grips with some of these issues like the Aarhus Convention.
So I'm with my right honourable friend on that very much. During I made an intervention in relation to the scope for extending the provisions in this bill to projects which are not currently part of the main highway network, trunk road network. And it seems to me that if we want to deal with the problems in London bridges, we're going to have to find some way of funding those bridge repairs. And I speak as somebody who's got an interest in the sense that my home in London for many years has been just south of Waterloo Bridge. And recently we've heard rumours that because of cracks in the bridge, that Waterloo Bridge may actually be closed.
If it is closed, that would be the third central London Thames crossing which will be unusable. This is intolerable, Madam Deputy Speaker. And surely we must find a way of funding the repairs and reconstruction which is necessary to keep those London bridges open. Sometimes my grandchildren talk about London Bridge is burning down and all the rest of it. But we're not talking about London Bridge, we're talking about three other key bridges in London which are either already closed or about to be closed.
And so what are we going to do about it? And I'd be interested if the Minister would be prepared in his response to say, yes, I agree that the model set out in this bill is one which could be applied to the bridges in London which are in desperate need of repair.
Daniel Francis
I hear what the honourable member says, but of course under the last Conservative government rather, we saw the 2018 changes which introduced tolling at Blackwall and Silvertown, voted for by Conservative MPs who now run around southeast London blaming that matter on the Mayor of London. So can he assure us that if we were to take those matters forward, the Conservatives on the other side would take ownership of those changes rather than pointing the finger at other people as they do?
Christopher Chope
Well, I can't obviously make an assurance like that. That's a very rhetorical question. All I can say is that I think that people should take responsibility for their decisions and we should face up to the fact that if there are costs associated with particular bits of infrastructure which can't be funded out of general taxes, then we should be prepared to ensure that they are funded by the users. And to have a situation where you effectively close down a thoroughfare across the Thames and with no solutions to what's going to happen, then that is totally unsatisfactory. And I'd like the Mayor of London to take some action on this because it comes within his responsibilities and he could easily use some of the income from, for example, the congestion charge or the ULEZ charge to fund that.
But it doesn't seem as though that's happening, which is why I put forward the suggestion that the provisions in this bill could be used for that very purpose.
Daniel Francis
Of course I will. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I just seek clarity on that matter? My understanding is not all the bridges in London are the responsibility of Transport for London. Some belong to local authorities, some belong to charities.
So the Mayor of London doesn't have direct power over them in all cases. So could the honorable member just clarify that on the record, given he's just said it is a Transport for London and Mayor of London responsibility?
Christopher Chope
Well, I'm not going to try and clarify that because it sounds as though what I've said is only partially accurate. So and but in a sense it reinforces my point, which is that whoever owns those bridges or has financial responsibility for them, the financial vehicle identified in this bill could be used to pay for the repairs and ensure the maintenance of those bridges to ensure that they're brought back into use. I don't purport to be an expert on who owns which bridges and so on and which ones, I didn't know that any of them were owned by charities, but the honorable gentleman seems to say that they are. That's I'm not going to dispute that, but I don't think it alters the principal point that I was making. I am concerned about some of the other provisions of this bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, some of them identified in the reasoned amendment put forward.
Massive new powers for the Office of Road and Rail at a time when I thought the government was rowing back on arms-length bodies being given such powers. Great powers under clause 99 to basically repeal or any existing legislation retrospectively which as a consequence of the measures in this bill. I couldn't really understand the references to the insolvency legislation. How would that fit in, for example, to what happened with the building of the Channel Tunnel? Because that was a private investor exercise and ultimately the people who were the initial investors lost most of their money, but that was as a result of them taking the risk.
Is the government suggesting it would be taking these powers in relation to insolvency legislation that some different arrangements should operate in the future? And so that's what I'm skeptical about this. But frankly, Madam Deputy Speaker, when I was a backbench Conservative MP, I proposed that we should privatize the whole of our motorway network because then that would give a really good benefit to the taxpayer and it would ensure that the funding of the motorway network was paid for by the people who use the motorway network. Earlier this month, I drove back with my wife from Strasbourg. From Strasbourg to Christchurch is about 550 miles and the tolls amounted to about 100 plus euros.
And that was a contribution that I made towards the costs of the French motorway system. And why shouldn't we embrace, if we are true radicals, and this may be too radical for my right honorable friend on our front bench, but why can't we privatize our... We can't privatize the whole of the trunk road network, Madam Deputy Speaker, because the trunk road network includes all sorts of rights of way and bridleways and complications. But the motorway network is set up in a dedicated way so that it could actually be the subject of what would be one of the largest ever privatizations. And I think, going back to my original point about the success that there was in the 1980s in having private capital and private entrepreneurial activity involved in the development of the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge, why don't we extend that more widely across our road network?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it was a pleasure to follow the honorable gentleman opposite with his deep experience and a very interesting perspective on bringing in tolls to all of our motorways, which may be the case in certain countries in the world, but I suspect the whole funding of their road network is somewhat different to ours. So I'm going to go back to focus on the bill now. But actually, as someone who's driven on roads in other countries and across the bridge to Wales in the past, it does seem entirely natural to introduce a toll for the Lower Thames Crossing. It's parallel to the tolled Dartford Crossing and is hardly, as we know, going to be the first toll road in the UK.
So I therefore welcome this bill. It will enable the funding of the Lower Thames Crossing to be delivered and maintained through the tunnel users paying to use it. But it's the first time for a road project has used the regulated asset base model, the RAB model, a model that is already used for energy and water infrastructure and for Heathrow Airport. Delivery now and improved transport infrastructure is core to this government's growth mission. So I'm glad the government is exploring a range of both tried and tested and new methods of working with private sector investments to deliver projects.
These include not only the RAB for the roads for the first time, as in this bill, but using SIL and also further exploring the capture of land value uplift on new rail schemes. I know that some of the early PFI schemes in the mid and late 90s gave public-private funding partnerships a bad name, but I'm confident that the relationship now between state commissioners and long-term private capital has matured in a way that can only be mutually beneficial.
However, on the RAB model, I do have some concerns. Whilst it provides confidence for investors and actually a rock-solid return, as the representative of potential investors in the Lower Thames Crossing told me recently, there is also a history of gold-plated, over-engineered schemes, and sometimes, as in the case of Heathrow Airport, poor value for money, as airlines and businesses who are captive tenants there also tell me. And Thames Water, all of Thames Water's bill payers are funding the Thames Tideway Tunnel, but a project that provides no benefit to my constituency and the health of the River Thames in my constituency because we're upstream of the intake of the Tideway Tunnel. In this bill, whilst there is a regulator, the Office of Road and Rail does play a very important role, but I do wonder, as with many regulators, does it have sufficient teeth and funding? Does it have the right powers and sufficient powers over issues such as sustainability, safety, customer focus, and local communities?
And again, looking at the example of Heathrow Airport, I fear that the Civil Aviation Authority is far too weak in areas other than its core responsibilities of the economy and, of course, air safety. And there's one final issue about the Lower Thames Crossing that has been exercising the road haulage industry and me, is the removal of any truck stop or motorway service area from the plans. The Transport Committee report in 2022, that the honourable member now on the front bench, I think, was also on the committee with me on, our recommendations, our conclusions showed the critical impact of the shortage of safe, secure driver facilities around the South East and particularly on routes to and from Dover. And this was a message repeated to the committee again in March this year by haulage industry and driver union representatives. Drivers are required to rest every four and a half hours, and they also need somewhere to stop and sleep in a place where they and their load are safe.
Yet we were told that Medway and Thurrock services on each side of the Thames, if a driver isn't in the motorway service area by mid-afternoon, they'd have to go and find an A-road lay-by: no toilets, no food, no safety.
Will she give way on that point?
I certainly will.
Jennifer Craft
Thank you, and I very much thank my honourable friend for giving way. She mentions Thurrock services, and Thurrock is an area that will be heavily impacted by the Lower Thames Crossing. I'm very glad she mentions the lack of a service station built in. We already have significant issues with lorry drivers parking in inappropriate places on roads that are not built for that to get the rest that they need because they can't get into a service station. Will the lack of a services facility as part of the Lower Thames Crossing, does she believe that that will exacerbate this issue?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
I absolutely do believe that it will exacerbate the issue because the Lower Thames Crossing is going to significantly increase vehicle throughput and particularly trucks and lorries on that part of the network, which is already a busy network anyway. And, you know, the originally proposed MSA or truck stop, I'm not sure which, has been removed from the plans.
I'm told there's no plan and there's no requirement to bring one back. And this illustrates a national policy gap. So, if one drives, again reference to the French motorway system, you can see so clearly there that there is a full MSA every 50 kilometres and partial ones every 10. And I really do hope that it's not too late. I mean, I am told it's not too late for proposers, but it would have to be a planning application from a landowner in order to bring one in.
But I can't believe it wouldn't be a profitable opportunity for investors to do that and in due course and then and link it into the Lower Thames Crossing, because of course it's only just along the road from the docks anyway, so there's going to be bound to be demand. So, now I want to just pick up on the opposition amendment. I mean, it says this House, I quote, "declines to give a second reading to the Highways (Financing) Bill because it has no confidence in the government's ability to deliver the project on time and on budget, given its record of cancelling major road schemes across the country," unquote, "oh, and risks costs spiralling further out of control." Well, that's rich coming from the party opposite that oversaw most of HS2's lifespan, a scheme that our rail system and northern cities so desperately need. Yet what did that government do?
They started construction before the design was agreed and complete. They halted and removed about half the length of HS2, and thus completely undermining the business case. I could go on. Back to the Lower Thames Crossing. It was commissioned because the Dartford Crossing has miles-long queues onto it.
And then looking at the M25, extra lanes have been built on that, and we have all-lane running on many other motorways. Yet on many of them, traffic still crawls along at slow speeds due to sheer congestion. So, whilst there's no doubt that Lower Thames Crossing will relieve pressure on the Thames crossings for a few years after it opens, how long will it be until the toll payers, instead of paying to cross to the other side of the Thames, will be effectively paying to park on the approach road? The DfT forecast road traffic growth, as the Minister said, to grow by 12% on motorways over the next 10 years and 10% on all other roads. If our roads are not to grind to a halt, then I really look forward to a policy that will incentivise alternative travel options so that road space is available for those journeys for which there can never be a choice.
For instance, increasing the capacity of the Ely-Haughley junction or any number of rail bottlenecks would increase rail capacity for freight and passengers at a fraction of the cost of the Lower Thames Crossing or another lane on a UK motorway. I do hope my honourable friend the Minister and the Secretary of State can assure me and this House, because unless there's an overarching transport strategy that supports modal shift, it won't be long before we need an even lower Thames crossing.
Jim Dickson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituents will be delighted to see this piece of legislation before the House.
It is, as others have said, the key to unlocking new infrastructure and finally ending the traffic chaos that plagues my Dartford constituency daily, with the new Lower Thames Crossing planned to be the first new road project funded in this way. The Dartford Crossing and the M25 motorway, which along with the A282 provides access to it, cut across the heart of my constituency, providing, as has been said by others, the one crossing over the Thames east of London, and this represents a single point of failure, and fail it often does. This crossing, the Dartford Crossing, was designed for 135,000 vehicles a day, and as has been said by the Minister, the crossing now averages 150,000 vehicles a day and needs to be carefully managed around the clock, and when failure happens, it's the residents of Dartford that pay the highest price. When the crossing has to close, which happens regularly, it leaves the town at a complete standstill. Journeys that should take 10 minutes can take four to five hours.
Children can't get home from school, tradespeople can't get to jobs, and medical appointments are missed, and Dartford residents have been waiting for years for this to be addressed. Earlier this year, for example, on the 23rd of January, an over-height lorry somehow evaded the sensors designed to detect and halt such vehicles and caused significant damage to the roof of one of the tunnels, leading to a closure of more than 30 hours and absolute chaos for residents on both sides of the crossing as traffic backed up for miles around. And even when there isn't a major issue like the tunnel closure, most days see heavy traffic. For those heading northbound in the evening, 95% of journeys feature delays, with two-thirds taking twice as long as they should. This high level of slow-moving traffic also has health impacts on Dartford residents, with air quality far below what we should expect.
For our country more widely, delays at the crossing affect goods coming to and from ports in the South East, with the delays estimated to cost the UK more than £200 million every year in time lost sitting in traffic. It's therefore incredibly welcome that the building of the Lower Thames Crossing is now proceeding rapidly forward after moving slower than traffic over the Dartford Crossing on a bad day under the last government. And now we've seen the reasoned amendment to this bill declining to give it a second reading because they don't believe the government can deliver it on time, which is quite some accusation given their record of, how can I put this kindly, glacial progress on this project. 14 years of dither and delay, followed today in this House by active attempts to block progress. That's going to go down really well in Dartford, and I have no doubt Dartford Conservatives will be ecstatic at the antics of their colleagues in the House today.
The new crossing, when it's finished, will take over 10 million vehicles away from Dartford, freeing up almost a full lane of traffic. It's also going to be hugely beneficial for the local economy. Thousands of jobs will be created during construction, with half the workforce recruited locally, and I hope this will kickstart a whole generation of new careers in construction for young people across North Kent and Essex. And once built, the new road will increase access to jobs for those living on both sides of the Thames, providing crucial employment opportunities for my constituents and others living nearby. The campaign to get this piece of infrastructure up and running has been the single biggest priority in my time as Dartford's MP, and I really welcome this bill as a crucial step forward towards getting the crossing built and open.
And I want to send my thanks to residents, businesses large and small, organisations across Dartford and North Kent, national trade bodies including Logistics UK, local government representatives, and from colleagues across this House and in the other place for their support with the campaign.
And to the Secretary of State for Transport and Treasury ministers, including the previous and present Chancellors, for the planning and the funding decisions that they have already made. I appreciate the Roads Minister's time to discuss this project in the summer, and hope he will indulge me by answering just a few outstanding queries that I have about the operation of this bill and its impact on the new crossing. Firstly and most importantly on tolls. Local residents in Dartford and in Thurrock are entitled to discounted use of the Dartford crossing. Can the minister clarify if this legislation has any impact on the operation of a future resident discount scheme for both Dartford and for the new crossing?
It's crucial for my residents that the tolls across the two crossings are set at an equal value, as well as remaining affordable via the discount scheme, and I'd be grateful for any assurance the minister can provide on this issue. The arrangement clearly won't work if there's a financial incentive for goods vehicles to use one crossing rather than the other. It's important to recognize that at its core, this bill allows private companies who are licensed by the government to charge tolls on newly built roads, the mechanism by which we unlock capital to build much-needed new infrastructure. British motorists already pay substantial revenue to the government through fuel duty and vehicle excise duty, so would the minister agree that while tolls on new infrastructure are right to use in certain circumstances such as this, we really don't want to see new toll roads created on currently untolled highways, and I'm sure the minister will be able to give us reassurance on that. I also have some concerns about the vulnerabilities highlighted by the government's final stage impact assessment with the Office of Road and Rail, which has been appointed as the independent regulator.
How will ministers address the concerns that have been raised about information asymmetry, including that in some cases private firms bidding for and then building and operating the development may possess more detailed information about actual project delivery and operational costs than the ORR, and that this might allow them to inflate costs with knock-on inflation to the charges that users will eventually pay? So some reassurance on that would be useful. Notwithstanding those queries, which I'm sure the minister can answer, I'm very, very happy to support this very welcome bill, and I know that it is widely welcomed as the key to unlocking the critical funding needed to build this vital piece of new infrastructure.
Jennifer Craft
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm grateful to get the opportunity to speak in this bill today, and to particularly talk around its primary focus on the financing of the Lower Thames Crossing. My constituency Thurrock will be one of two areas most impacted by both the operation and the construction of the Lower Thames Crossing. And I'm not going to spend too long dwelling on the question of the road itself. I've been quite vocal in my reservations about the wider scheme, as both of the ministers on the front bench are nodding along to, but that decision has long been taken. And with one billion pounds of public money already been invested in the scheme, it seems unlikely that this would be reversed.
But the finance mechanisms in this bill will, however, provide much-needed clarity for the many thousands of people who will be directly impacted by the Lower Thames Crossing that the project will go ahead. And I'm quite determined that my constituents will benefit in as many ways as possible from one of the most significant national infrastructure projects in a generation being constructed on their doorstep. But first I would like to seek the minister's reassurance on certain aspects of the regulated asset base model that this bill provides, particularly how the model allows for an operator to recoup the costs of construction and maintenance via a toll mechanism, mitigating the financial and construction risk of an operator building Lower Thames Crossing in a kind of private-public partnership.
It potentially creates a natural monopoly, and the Office of the Rail and Road regulator are going to be overseeing this. My constituents and myself have some, I think, probably fairly justifiable concerns around a private enterprise levying tolls, particularly via the use of ANPR over toll booths, because there have been a number of experiences under the current Dartford Crossing toll operator that have proved that where things go wrong, it's quite hard to get redress to this system. Due to faulty ANPR, a not insignificant amount of drivers have found themselves accruing quite hefty fines, sometimes into the thousands of pounds, for journeys they haven't even undertaken. And when trying to actually get redress for this, or the fines cancelled or written off, they can find it very difficult indeed. And when I attempted to contact the operator of the scheme, I discovered that it was an offshore entity operating, I think, out of the United States, and all but impossible to transparently see who was running the tolls and to hold them to account.
So I'd be quite grateful for the Minister's assurances around the transparency and accountability of any toll operator of a future Thames Crossing, particularly as to how we might get redress when things might go wrong. And I'd also welcome assurances as my friend, the honourable member for Brentford and Isleworth... Brentford and Isleworth, my apologies, did indeed raise the lack of teeth that potentially the Office for Road and Rail has. And we all know the difficulties that Ofwat have had in regulating the water industry, and quite rightly there is a national outcry now about the effectiveness of that regulator to be able to hold private companies to account. And I think it is fair enough to question whether the Office of Road and Rail are sufficiently equipped and have the ability to hold a private toll operator of the Lower Thames Crossing to account, particularly when it comes to redress if things go wrong, or indeed to look at how the tolls are operated. There is also some assurances I would like around congestion.
My friend, the honourable member for Dartford, has spoken about the issues with congestion caused by the Dartford Crossing, and believe you me, I know that all too well. I'm a lifelong resident of the place that I have the honour of representing, which is Thurrock, and the congestion at the Dartford Crossing, or as we affectionately know it in my patch, the bridge, is legendary. It causes misery for people when they, particularly when they're crossing from the Kent side to the Essex side. The tunnels every day will see a backup of up to four hours for motorists using that part of the road. And when something goes wrong at the Dartford Crossing, it doesn't just stop people from being able to cross, it causes congestion around the entirety of my constituency.
I've had people spend eight hours making a ten-minute journey, people spend hours trying to get home from school, you know, stuck in traffic for hours and hours and hours on end. And it is complete and utter misery. So I am concerned, I do have some concerns about whether the Lower Thames Crossing will mitigate this congestion. And my other concern is particularly related to any tolls levied. If there is a disparity in the amount of charge for using the Lower Thames Crossing as there is the Dartford Crossing, I think it's fairly obvious which one most people will choose to use, particularly in terms of a residents' discount.
Now my predecessor, the former Labour Member of Parliament for Thurrock, Andrew Mackinlay, was quite instrumental in getting a residents' discount on the Dartford Crossing for residents of Dartford and Thurrock at the time. And it has proved quite invaluable to actually an acknowledgement of the fact that we probably bear the brunt of that crossing and of the journeys that are made across it.
Similarly, there should be equal consideration given as to the Lower Thames Crossing and the impact that will have on my constituents and the residents' discount thereof. And I am concerned that people may opt to use the Dartford Crossing if it is cheaper than the Lower Thames Crossing, as this will exacerbate a number of the issues that we see. And there are wider issues with the Thurrock road network. Junction 31 of the M25, which leads directly onto the current Dartford Crossing, is a really, really key part of the national road infrastructure. And when that goes wrong, it absolutely messes with our logistics industry, people travelling to and from work.
My honourable friend and member for Northampton said why am I talking about something that impacts a constituency in the East of England? Well, the truth is that that is something that backs up all the way up to the Midlands, all the way around the South and all the way around the East of England. And it's such a tiny junction that has so much potential to go wrong. Recently, just before the recess, someone spilled a large quantity of oil on Junction 31 in the early hours of the morning while we were experiencing the heatwave. Now, that took the Highways Agency up to, I believe it was close to 20 hours to address.
That road remained shut for that entire time, and the congestion that it caused in my patch was completely insurmountable. And I've had a discussion with the Highways Agency afterwards and the police to say, you know, what can we do to actually properly get to grips with the fact that there is this crucial bit of infrastructure in my patch that when it goes wrong, impacts so many people. One of the things that they have suggested, and which I would be grateful to discuss with the Roads Minister in future, is potentially having a traffic police dedicated force for the Dartford Crossing, and I imagine that would cover the Lower Thames Crossing as well, given its proximity to so many, many crucial parts of our industry. And I will move on to also talk about the fact that it's only right that my constituents, who will be the most impacted by the Lower Thames Crossing, that they must be those who will benefit most from it. And I would like to flag a few places where the Lower Thames Crossing are currently falling short in some of their commitments to ensuring social value is seen in those communities who are most impacted.
And I don't believe these difficulties are insurmountable or impossible to get through. There is a commitment to employ a significant amount of local people in the build and construction of the Lower Thames Crossing. However, the geographical area that encompasses local people is, I believe, far too broad. It encompasses most of the Greater London area. So for my constituents, who are a small proportion of people within that area, they can often really, really struggle to get a look-in.
And I would like to see the geographical area that accounts for local jobs be much more restricted to those constituencies most impacted, namely Thurrock, Gravesham and Dartford. Similarly, there is a commitment to use and involve small and medium enterprises in a number of the construction parts. However, a number of small businesses in my patch, including Labour Based Solutions, have been unable to engage with the project so far, despite trying on numerous occasions, and they have instead seen that national contractors, from their experience, seem to be getting priority. I would be very grateful to have a discussion with the Minister about what he can do to help change this, because this is enterprise, this is money, this is industry, this is growth that really should be coming to my area given that we are going to be the most impacted by this. However, I believe that this bill has the potential to go further and to really deliver on something that is completely key in the transport area for my constituency, and that is in ensuring the return of the Tilbury Ferry.
If my friend the honourable member for Gravesham was here, she would call it the Gravesend-Tilbury Ferry, but in my patch, we know what it is properly called. This is a ferry service that has been running for the best part of 600 years, having been given the charter by Henry VIII to provide a river service. It was, up until its closure, I will give way.
Richard Quigley
Thank you for giving way. My honourable friend makes a very good point. I have no skin in the game on either crossing, but the mention of ferries, I couldn't let that pass without standing up. The whole of the House would be very angry with me, I'm sure. But she makes a very important point, that those of us that have to travel by water feel that ferry travel isn't part of integrated transport.
So does she agree that ferry travel should be part of integrated transport, especially in her situation?
Jennifer Craft
Thank you. And I am very grateful to the honourable member for his intervention. I think it's a bit like Beetlejuice: you mention ferries and he appears at some point. He's absolutely correct that ferries should prove a vital part of public transport infrastructure. And I will get as to the... I will get to the important part that the Tilbury ferry did play in our public transport infrastructure locally, and talk about the really huge role that it played.
It ran continuously up until 2022, when unfortunately, due to historic bankruptcy by the then Conservative council, they were unable to pay the subsidy that was needed to keep the ferry running, and it came to a close. This was an absolute tragedy for my area. Not only did the ferry provide a vital commuter route for a number of people... a number of my constituents attend schools in Kent, for example, and they are now having to make a journey that is rough... that is about an hour, an hour and a half every way, and they are encountering the problems at the Dartford Crossing that could simply have been avoided by a quick 10-minute hop across the water. My honourable friend the member for Gravesham, her constituency has a high street that used to lead directly onto the ferry terminal. Those businesses have been hit so, so hardly by the loss of this very, very vital transport link.
And in my patch, it not only has all these fond memories, not just for myself and my family, but for so many of my constituents. I put a call out for people to share their memories of the Tilbury ferry and to sign my petition, and the numbers hit the thousands within the course of a couple of days. It is something that people are desperate to see the return of. The main issue with the return of the ferry is the cost of the subsidy of running it. There is absolute public will to get it back.
There's will from businesses in the area: the Port of Tilbury, Forth Ports, DP World, a whole host of other people really want to see it, because they know it provides that link as well, and it increases the ability for where they can encourage people to come and work for them to both sides of the river. And the other thing it would do, if we're talking in terms of trying to get people off of our road networks... a number of the people, a large amount of people that cross using the Dartford Crossing and who are projected to use the Lower Thames Crossing, it's short hops, it's short journeys either side of the river. This would allow people an alternative that is not that road network, to be able to do it in a way that is much more sustainable and that is much better than adding to that congestion that already exists. It's a much, much greener way of travelling. What I would ask the ministers to very, very strongly consider and seriously consider is putting a very, very small proportion of a toll that is made on the Lower Thames Crossing... and I am talking around 0.01%, which is less than a penny, to enable the Tilbury ferry to be funded in perpetuity.
There is precedent here. The Dartford Crossing used to fund the subsidy of the Tilbury ferry, until that was given over by to the running of the two local authorities at the time, Kent County Council and Thurrock Council. A levy on the Lower Thames Crossing would allow the Tilbury ferry to be insulated from potential shocks, such as we saw with the bankruptcy of Thurrock Council.
It would allow it to keep running well into the future so it can serve my children and my grandchildren. It will take people off the already overloaded road network. It will bring life back to Graysham High Street. It will make sure that people on my side of the river can visit their relatives, can go to their hospital appointments, can, you know, go to work, can go to school, can just enjoy a really nice day out. And actually prove to people in my patch that actually we can have nice things and we do deserve it.
It's a crucial part of our infrastructure. And I believe, given that people in my patch will be bearing the brunt of the construction and the operation of the Lower Thames Crossing, that they deserve this. So I would ask the Minister to seriously consider the possibility of allowing this piece of infrastructure to fund a vital and critical part of the local transport infrastructure and help me bring back the Tilbury Ferry for good.
Mark Francois
Can I begin by apologizing to the honorable lady for Thurrock for missing a bit of her speech? Just to be clear, I nipped upstairs briefly to see the Children's Parliament in action in room 14. It's something our great friend Sir David was passionate about, so I hope the House will forgive my absence. No disrespect was intended. If it helps her, I've heard anecdotally there's a lot of support for bringing back the Tilbury Ferry, so if I say that, perhaps she'll, perhaps she'll forgive me.
There's been some debate about whether or not the Conservative Party were committed to long-term infrastructure projects. Just for the record, in 1963, the first Dartford Tunnel opened. I think Sir Alec Douglas-Home was Prime Minister at the time. In 1986, the first section of the M25 was opened by Margaret Thatcher. In 1991, the QE2 Bridge opened.
In 1994, the Channel Tunnel opened, both during the premiership of John Major. So we can trade historical dates, but I think those four examples show fairly conclusively that the Conservative Party has been committed to major infrastructure down the decades. On the Lower Thames Crossing, as I said before in an earlier intervention, the truth is this has a very long and complex history. I know in the honorable lady for Thurrock's constituency it's been very controversial, also in what is now South Basildon and East Thurrock. This really had a genesis, I think, under the Blair and then Brown government.
So it goes back a very long way, and it is a fact that the project has been delayed by multiple consultation exercises over a period of years. But we are where we are. And because of the points that my right honorable friend for Christchurch was making about the whole history of the tolls on the QE2 Bridge and were they ever going to be canceled or not, because of that, I hope the Minister would understand that there's understandable skepticism, certainly in South Essex, about what would ever happen to the tolls on the Lower Thames Crossing. Now, I had, for the record, asked the Transport Secretary three times on the floor of the House over the last year or so which financial institutions are now going to finance the 85 to 90 percent residual cost of the Lower Thames Crossing. And I hope what the honorable gentleman from the Midlands said about these negotiations are still ongoing.
But I hope the Minister would understand, in all seriousness, that given the history of the whole project, he could understand why some people in South Essex are skeptical that the government can't yet tell us which companies or financial institutions would in fact pay for it. So I wonder if when his honorable friend winds up, he could answer two very specific questions, in fact three, about the Lower Thames Crossing itself. One, given all of this complex history, what is the government's latest estimated year in which the crossing will open to traffic?
Two, what is the government's latest estimate of what would be the toll when it opens for a family car? And what is the government's latest estimate when it opens, what will the toll be for a 38-tonne lorry? So those are three very specific questions. I'd be grateful if the minister could at least attempt to answer in his wind-up. For the record, I want this crossing to go ahead, but I want to know when and I want to know what it's going to cost my constituents to drive through it, be they a private motorist or a lorry driver.
So this bill is about highways financing. So I want to just take a few more minutes to explain to the minister, who I've dealt with before in a different context when he had a different job and who's always struck me as a reasonable man. So let's get that on the record. But I wonder if he could understand the frustration in South Essex over this recent decision to cancel the proposed upgrades to the A127. They included a scheme to straighten out what is now the chicane in effect at the old Fortune of War roundabout and also to add a third lane to the A127 in the southbound direction between the Halfway House, as it's known, and the site of the old Fortune of War.
Both of those would have increased flow and capacity on the A127. The incoming Labour government some months ago cancelled a proposed widening of the A12, which has been in gestation for almost as long as the Lower Thames Crossing. So I just hope the minister could understand why in South Essex this has caused immense frustration. The government, a different department, MHCLG, want to build 100,000 houses from Grays to Shoeburyness.
That's their departmental objective. The Department of Health and Social Care have a challenge particularly at Basildon Hospital, which is pretty much maxed out as it is. According to the NHS's own planning metric, they work on a basis of 2.4 additional potential patients per dwelling. So the plans say there'll be 28,000 additional houses in the Basildon borough, 35,000 in Thurrock, thanks to Reform and Labour. So that's 63,000 in total.
So when you add the 2.4 multiplier, that's 151,200 additional patients, at least by my maths, for a hospital at Basildon which is completely maxed out today as it is. I see the honourable lady is, you know, nodding in assent to that. The hospital is rated inadequate by the CQC. It's part of a trust, the Mid and South Essex Hospitals Trust, with Broomfield at Chelmsford and Southend, which is a failing organisation. So how can you build all those houses where there is no real plan of any kind to expand the capacity at the hospital?
And now we're cutting road programs on the A127, which is one of the two fundamental east-west arterial roads between London and South Essex. And the A12 obviously feeds into that area from the north. So the point that I'm seeking to get across to the minister is none of this is joined up. We've got one department of the government that wants to just build vast numbers of houses. We've got another department of the government which is responsible for healthcare and has no idea whatsoever how to cater for what could be a quarter of a million extra people if you use the NHS metric.
And we've got the Department for Transport cancelling upgrades to the roads which were supposed to increase capacity. The A127 and the A13 in the morning and evening peak are at 99% capacity as it is, Minister. I've seen the heat maps and the darker the red, the busier the, sorry, the busier the road, the darker the red. And both those roads metaphorically glow scarlet in the morning and the evening peak. So we've got three different government departments with completely conflicting objectives.
But my constituents in South Essex and other people who live there have to bear the consequences. So having dealt with the Minister before on a constituency case, which I won't go into now, he was very reasonable then and he did listen. So my plea to him this afternoon is please accept what I'm saying as true and please don't cancel anything else in Essex. And for God's sake, whatever you do, don't cancel the upgrade to the Fairglen Interchange at Rayleigh on the A127. Because if you think I'm upset now, you want to see me then.
So those are the points I wanted to make, Madam Deputy Speaker. Some of them directly about the Lower Thames Crossing, some of them about other issues. But I think my fundamental point about these key infrastructure projects is it's all got to be joined up. And we cannot tolerate a situation where we've got three different government departments, of which he's only responsible for one, pulling in three totally different directions. I hope that's not an unreasonable point to try and make in a debate of this kind.
John Tristan Osborne
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's a real pleasure to speak alongside other Kent colleagues today from Dartford and to see the member for Gravesham here and also speak to others across South Essex that will directly benefit from this project. I think everyone will know that if you've travelled down this stretch, that this crossing is absolutely vital part of the North Kent infrastructure. And we know when there are problems with the Dartford Bridge that these can spread all the way down into South East London, but actually into Kent, including into the area of Medway where I represent. I want to speak to four elements to this today.
So first of all, actually the benefits of the new crossing in terms of the direct investment it could see in both Essex and in Medway in my local area and why that's so crucial. Second of all, the vehicle that is going to be used by the government to deliver this and learning from the National Audit Office review of the Sizewell program and others, some of the considerations from that that we need to be mindful of around costs. The opposition's amendment and then lastly, the importance of this to get it delivered on time and necessity. So as many will be aware, the crossings itself at Dartford was originally conceived over the years to cater for 136,000 vehicle movements. It's currently now catering over 150,000.
We know through projections that freight movements are due to increase over the next 15 years. As has been mentioned by my colleague on the other side, we are due to see expansion of population across all of the South Essex and North Kent corridor over the next 15 years as part of that urban sprawl that is moving east of London. And so we know that capacity on many road networks, including the ones he's mentioned, but in my area as well on the A229 that crosses from Maidstone into Medway and the Medway Tunnel is a particular focus which I'll come on to. We know there's constraints around Gravesham and Dartford as well around some of the roads connecting there around Galley Hill in particular.
Mark Francois
Just for the record, I'm completely opposed to the urban sprawl. I think the government are trying to impose far too many houses in South Essex. That hundred thousand is nearly seven percent of their entire 1.5 million target in one half of one county. But nevertheless, if he'll take, if he'll believe that I'm being honest in arguing for on behalf of my constituents, I'm prepared to believe that he's being honest in arguing on behalf of his.
Very happy to give way.
John Tristan Osborne
Right, can I thank the honorable member. And of course, housing targets were not unique to this government. They were existed in previous iterations throughout the last several decades indeed. So housing has been built in South Essex under his previous government and under conservative control councils there, I'm sure permissions were given. And similarly in my area, the Medway conservative-led council as it was then delivered housing projects as well.
So we have to be realistic that infrastructure is needed to cater for these future developments. And this crossing is necessary because of the capacity issues that have just been raised. It has an, the impacts of a blocked crossing have profound implications not only to people trying to get to health appointments, residents inconvenienced, town centers blocked in the case of Dartford and Thurrock, but also on the freight and logistics industry so eloquently expressed by colleagues from around the country because the South East being the key link to European trade. I'm really also very proud that this department led by the current Secretary of State on day one of taking office sought to give the consent order for this program, clearly showing the direction of travel and focus as a government to deliver some of these big infrastructure projects. And alongside Sizewell C and other government programs, we know that private investment working with government can deliver on significant projects going forward.
We know the cost around ten billion is a government mega project scheme and I would ask that this be considered to be on that government program of mega projects. We know that with HS2 where there's been deliberation about whether mega, whether that has been a mega project or not, that that has caused some delays, especially around the Euston development site. And that was covered in the NAO report. I know tolls are a sensitive topic and I would agree with my colleagues here that there needs to be some consideration for those that live in the direct surrounds and not only Dartford and Thurrock, but also the new site around Gravesham and Medway and in particular on the other side in South Essex as well around whether they should be also considered for toll relief to ensure that they get fair discount. Happy to give way.
Speaker 285
On that point, I'm grateful for my hon. friend for giving way. Gravesham will bear one part of this, this the length of the tunnel. And so it's important that those people that are most going to be affected will be able to hold to account those toll regulators, but also have their accountability for making sure that those tolls are properly cared for and enhanced for local residents.
John Tristan Osborne
I absolutely agree. And I know there's been a number of thoughts today and a number of points made to the minister around what those tolls might look like. Of course, the duration of this program, the finance that is involved and also ensuring there's parity with the Dartford crossing to ensure that people aren't making a market choice to go to a cheaper crossing will also have to be considered in the round. And I look forward to representations in the future around that. But I know from my residents' perspective, whilst we can see the massive investment benefits of a new crossing in terms of new businesses opening, new residents taking with the connections with HS1 that are potentially there as well through Essex, the actual creation of some form of corridor now between the Medway towns and Southend.
Previously we can overlook each other from the sides of the river. This connection now actually allows us potentially to get to one another's conurbations within ten to fifteen minutes, which previously would take forty-five minutes to an hour. I think that will, the relationships between businesses and small businesses are not, haven't been discussed today, but this has the potential to be a significant multiplier for a lot of different businesses across South Essex and North Kent.
I also accept that this bill does protect those who will use the road. I accept that the the Office for Rail and Road will become the independent regulator, and I understand that they need to be given robust powers around license conditions. We know through HS2 that previous regulatory regimes have not been necessarily that efficient, and I would ask the minister learns from some of the NAO reports which have highlighted where some of these have failed in the past. The license holder must share information with the regulator and the Secretary of State. And if the company behind the road ever gets into financial trouble, a special administration regime should and must keep the highway running.
Investors get the certainty that they to commit the capital, and drivers get a regulator watching over what is built and what is charged, because I believe that that transparency, given some of the high-profile issues with major government programs previously, I think is absolutely necessary. There is practical measures in this bill too. It allows barrierless charging on tolled roads. Remote payments mean smoother journeys, I can testify to that in many roads around the country, less congestion at Dartford, though we do need to see continued improvements to the M2, including at junctions around the A229, in particular Bluebell Hill, and I know Kent County Council have made that representation. And let me just turn to the reasoned amendment.
I agree it starts by recognizing the urgent need to deliver the crossing after 14 years of numerous DCOs and numerous court appeals and delays and dither, but it's taken this government to progress ahead and get the spades in the ground. Yet when it asks the House to deny a second reading to that one piece of legislation that provides the funding route, it questions whether the project can be delivered on time and on budget, which is the exact thing which many of their own members have raised this afternoon. And I would point members to the structure of the bill, which puts the independent regulator in charge of scrutinizing the costs, and I encourage them to pick up some of those issues at bill committee if they don't believe that there is a robust understanding. But to reject the bill on the basis of the reasoned amendment, I would say would cause the delays that they are of themselves complaining might indeed occur. And just lastly, I would be remiss of me not to mention that there are other crossings nearby as well, which could get considerable amount of congestion as a result of this.
Medway Tunnel, which is a key crossing within the Medway conurbation, is currently putting in a bid to the structures fund to ensure that its 150,000 crossings per day that we see gets support for increasing investment in the future. It was a private construction through KCC and the Rochester Bridge Trust, an historic anomaly that was transferred onto the council ownership some 15 years ago. And I would encourage ministers to look at that bid very closely around Medway Tunnel, because any potential impact on the second crossing will be profoundly consequential to other crossings in Medway. And if we weren't to get that DfT funding for improvements to Medway Tunnel, it could cause significant problems for the three MPs that represent those areas. So just lastly, this crossing has a long and checkered history.
As has been said, previous Conservative governments opened parts of it, and Labour governments are now progressing with this next stage of it. But we should all be proud that this is a great British project which could deliver jobs and opportunities for many thousands of my residents and also the knock-on benefit to tens of thousands of people across the rest of the country.
Every delay to this legislation moves those dates back for families who have already waited for too long, for people who own homes and businesses who look to get this infrastructure project started. So I urge the House to reject this amendment put forward by the opposition, give the bill its second reading, and let us get on with building this crossing. Thank you.
Peter Dowd.
Peter Dowd
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. First of all, can I make, give my thanks to the Minister, the honourable member for Ellesmere Port and Bromborough, for setting out in a very clear and unambiguous fashion the nature and the content of the 104 clauses and three schedules. And I know that my honourable friend, the member for Wakefield and Rothwell, will be equally clear when he winds up later on. I'd also like to thank, very belatedly, Winston Churchill, who in 1929 provided 2.5 million pounds towards the first Mersey tunnel crossing on the Queensway crossing, which was opened by His Majesty King George V at the time. Can I say that was 1929, and that was the last time the Tories did anything worthwhile for Merseyside, frankly, giving us that 2.5 million pounds.
My honourable friend, the member for Widnes and Halewood, behind me, sitting behind me, has been used to the whole question about the development of a crossing, the crossing against the, crossing against the Mersey, on top of the two tunnel crossings, toll tunnels that we've had since the early 30s and 1971. So there is a history of tunnel tolls, road tunnels, tunnels in this country, many of them have been on Merseyside, the two under the Mersey tunnel and two, and two across the Mersey. And the question I wanted to ask myself is, what's wrong with that? What's wrong with a regulator and an organisation which is going to allow for the, what's wrong with legislation that's going to allow for the Office of Road and Rail regulator to be the independent regulator? What's wrong with that?
Speaker 289
What do the Tories have against that? What do the Tories have against providing a license regime for construction, operation of those proposals? What do they have with the problems with laying out highway authority functions in relation to license holders, or ensure fair charges for cars and transparency in service standards? What's wrong with that? I don't see there's anything wrong with that at all.
Speaker 290
How about the ability and the capacity, as in the bill, to provide transfer schemes for the allowance of property and rights and liabilities to be transferred, and the provision of a special administration regime? What's wrong, and backstops there? I can't quite see what the Conservatives have got wrong with that. I referred to crossings. We also in Merseyside have crossing, my honourable friend who's now gone referred earlier on to the ferry.
Speaker 291
We have a ferry across the River Mersey which has been going since 1150, a long time. It was actually King Stephen who was the monarch at the time during the anarchy as it was called. We had 14 years of anarchy under the Tories, so they know all about that. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't want to take much time of the House. What I do caution, what I do, I'm listening to the whips as well, I do pay clear and unambiguous attention to the whips.
Peter Dowd
What I do want to ensure is that when projects are introduced, developed, communities are part of that development. My experience with the Highways Agency, in relation to the A5036 for example, has not been as good as it could have been. So I hope when and if schemes are developed, whatever the nature of the scheme, toll or otherwise, those provisions in this bill and those agencies which may have a part to play in it do act with integrity, with honesty and passion, because if they don't, members across this House will ensure that they do. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Shadow Minister Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. How we pay for infrastructure is a matter that this house needs to take extraordinarily seriously. When this government announced that it would bring forward measures previously set out in the King's Speech to use private finance to build new roads, Labour members should not have been surprised. After all, the Prime Minister was one of the most effective defenders of PFI schemes in the NHS during his previous period in government. And as Mayor of Manchester, his effusive praise of the investment from Manchester City shows his willingness to back private finance.
So it should come as little surprise that this government is interested in how we can leverage private funding for our roads. Although indeed, as the Minister set out in his opening remarks, he said it was the biggest change since the 18th century. Well, thinking of the 18th century, this bill does indeed open the back door to highway robbery once more. Reflecting on today's debate and listening to the contributions from members across the house, I think most members recognize the importance of finding innovative methods to build infrastructure. Across the house, we can look at the cost overruns on infrastructure, particularly the Lower Thames Crossing, that use private money and incentives to increase road capacity and improve the experience for drivers.
As the government's own slightly outdated figures in its impact assessment set out, the vast majority of miles traveled across our country are in our cars, with over two-thirds of freight also transported on the strategic road network. And that has shone through in many of the contributions we have had this afternoon, starting with the honorable gentleman for Northamptonshire South with his public service safety announcement, followed quickly by the Lib Dem spokesman who in true style of the third party could not muster a speech without a European comparison, followed quickly by my right honorable friend for Christchurch who brought us his memories of 1991 with Her Late Majesty, focused on a case of private enterprise at its very best on the QE2 bridge, before sharing ideas with the house based on his ministerial experience. His points on the London bridges actually were a particularly well-made point.
Speaker 292
The issue of London bridges is particularly highlighted by Hammersmith Bridge, Madam Deputy Speaker, which has been closed since 2019. Is it not time for the government to get a grip on Labour-run Hammersmith and Fulham Council and the Labour Mayor of London and get that bridge reopened?
Greg Gregory Smith
Well, I'm very grateful to my honorable friend for that intervention. Both he and I many moons ago were both of course Conservative councillors in the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. And I remember in 2014, after we'd had a small electoral mishap and the Labour Party had taken control of that council once more, being the then leader of the opposition on that council, trying to call out the Labour-run council for failing to take the steps necessary to put a plan in place to fix Hammersmith Bridge. And today it still remains closed to traffic. And that is a bridge owned by the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham, Labour-run, Labour failure to get that bridge open again.
Daniel Francis
I think we were all very interested to hear the honorable member for Christchurch's view that charging should be spread across London river crossings. So could I ask the honorable member to give his analysis of that proposal that's been given this afternoon, that taxpayers across London should have river crossing charges spread more widely?
Greg Gregory Smith
I think I'm grateful for that intervention. My right honourable friend from Christchurch, I think, put some ideas in front of the House that are not necessarily shared by the front bench. However, that fundamental point, that fundamental point, that fundamental point that we have London bridges closed to traffic where Labour councils like Hammersmith and Fulham are failing to fix them is a point that desperately needs to be addressed for the interest of motorists in London at large and particularly in that case the residents of the London boroughs of Hammersmith and Fulham and Richmond.
Louie Thomas French
On the point of charging Londoners for driving, what we've seen and particularly over bridges, what we've seen over the past two years is the introduction of the Silvertown Tunnel and the Blackwall Tunnel charge the first ever time by the Mayor of London which the price has already been risen on drivers. But even on Dartford Crossing, the government have increased the charge by around 40%.
Greg Gregory Smith
Grateful to my honourable friend for that point and we'll come on to these charges later because of course one thing that has shone through in the debate we've had this afternoon that no one can tell us unless, unless the minister in his wind-up is going to pull a rabbit from a hat and give us a figure, no one can tell us what the charge will actually be to use the Lower Thames Crossing once it is actually built. Now, I will give way once more.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm aware my neighbour from Old Bexley and Sidcup hasn't been here for the debate and clearly we did discuss in the debate that the charges at Blackwall and Silvertown were introduced as a result of the 2018 order introduced by the previous Conservative government and the increases in it are within that order introduced by the previous Conservative government. So can the honourable gentleman confirm all those measures were introduced not by this government but by his.
Greg Gregory Smith
If he wants me to get onto road charging, I really don't think that the Labour Party want me to go through the record of the Labour Mayor of London in introducing the ULEZ and hiking up the congestion charge to unaffordable levels. Now, talking of other London members of Parliament, the chairman of the Transport Select Committee said that she wanted more powers for the ORR on sustainability as if banning diesel and HVO in the construction of the Lower Thames Crossing was not completely bonkers enough. But I do agree with her, I do agree with her on the point she makes about HGV driver facilities. I remember in the last Parliament serving alongside her on the Transport Select Committee as we did that important report and remembering indeed as we visited Thurrock services and the lorry driver was not what I would classically call delighted as the whole Select Committee was shown the shower facilities that he was using at the time to see how the tiles were falling off and everything was not fully in order. Later in the debate, my right honourable friend for Rayleigh and Wickford injected some common sense to the debate asking serious questions steeped in the history of the project that affects his constituents and their skepticism of the cost and the opening date of the Lower Thames Crossing as well as thoughtful contributions from the members from Chatham and Aylesford, Bootle, Bexleyheath and Crayford, Thurrock and Dartford.
However, Madam Deputy Speaker, the point raised by my right honourable friend the Shadow Secretary of State for Transport during his opening remarks raises a fundamental question: is this the right type of legislation? And why on earth have the government drafted the bill in a way that could feasibly allow charges to be imposed simply for using roads beyond the tolls themselves?
And why is this a concern? Well, to quote clause three of the bill: "A licensing authority may grant a license to a person authorizing the person to charge tolls in respect of the use or keeping of road vehicles on a highway specified in the license in return for the person securing works involving the maintenance, operation or improvement of a highway specified in the license which has been constructed in pursuance of the license or another license under this section." In this case, I fear we risk smuggling in charges on drivers through the back door, opening the door to the tolling of the M25 and beyond. At a time when drivers are getting squeezed at the pump and the government is cancelling multiple schemes, we must completely be clear that the bill as it currently stands is not acceptable. That is why my right honorable friend has tabled our sensible, reasoned amendment.
We cannot pass a bill that could impose costs on drivers without requiring it to deliver significantly increased capacity and new schemes. When the government says that only new big roads will be included, it fails to explain why the bill allows new infrastructures to fall within the scope of tolling. Using the term infrastructure may paint a picture of an entirely new road scheme, but what could stop it from being something as small as a new set of smart motorway cameras? The government may protest that that is infeasible. If so, why not amend the bill to make that abundantly clear?
Put it on the face of the bill. By going well beyond the scope of the Lower Thames Crossing, the legislation puts in place a scheme that is not fit for purpose. If we do not limit its scope, I fear the words of the president of the AA will be ringing in the ears of drivers when he said that drivers already pay for roads with 34 billion pounds in fuel duty and road taxes, so extra charges across the road network would be a toll too far. And as I said earlier, that is not least as no one can tell us what these tolls will actually be for the private motorist and the HGV driver alike. Instead, what we want the government to do is bear down on the costs of building that make these projects so expensive.
That is why we announced at our conference that we would leave the Aarhus Convention and tackle the rules that allow costly and protracted legal challenges. If we want to achieve low toll prices, drivers and incentivize private investment to build the project at a lower cost, we must reduce the regulatory burden on those involved, as opposed to imposing burdens such as banning diesel machinery. We should use the equipment that is cost-effective to get the best deal for motorists rather than trying to achieve ideological purity. But it is not merely these costs that we have to consider. There is also the structure of the scheme.
As has already been noted, the RAB model used by the government will be dependent on the work of the Office of Rail and Road. At a time when the government is trying to restrict the powers available to the ORR to uphold competition in rail, the organization that will regulate the scheme will have to have regard to matters including efficiency and economy, the ability of license holders to finance their license activities, safety, impacts on the wider strategic road network, sustainable development, competition and regulatory best practice. It is one rule for road and another for rail, no consistency from this government. And that really matters. As the government's own impact assessment sets out, using the RAB model on the strategic road network would be a new application of the model.
In the literature about this scheme, one of the central principles is the need for a regulator that can control costs and serve drivers. The ORR may be able to achieve that, but we are going in blind. We need the complete clarity from government about how it would actually work. This is in addition to the fair questions that have been raised across the House about the tolling regime.
We cannot treat drivers like a piggy bank. At the Labour Party conference, the Prime Minister told the country that people needed breathing space now and that he was determined to provide it. Therefore, if Labour MPs want to follow the Prime Minister's message, they must send a clear message back. Unless this bill clearly prohibits charging drivers for using existing roads, it cannot be allowed to pass through this house.
Simon Lightwood
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to thank honorable and right honorable members from across the house for their thoughtful and constructive contributions to today's debate. The house has heard a range of views this afternoon. Some members have spoken about the opportunities that this bill presents. Others have rightly pressed the government on how users will be protected, how local communities will be treated, and how we can ensure that major infrastructure is delivered in a way that provides value for money. Before I turn to some of those specific points, I want to return to the more fundamental question: why is this bill needed?
The answer is straightforward. This government believes we should have a wide range of tools to deliver nationally significant infrastructure, and we should avail ourselves of these tools to offer the best deal for taxpayers and help us provide connectivity that our economy needs. The immediate context for this legislation is, of course, the Lower Thames Crossing. The house knows the importance of this project. Dartford is operating well beyond the volumes it was designed to carry.
It has become a critical pinch point on the strategic road network, affecting commuters, businesses, supply chains, and communities across large parts of the country. The Lower Thames Crossing will provide additional capacity, greater resilience, and a new strategic connection across the Thames. The bill... I've got a lot to get through and I've heard a lot from the member already. The bill provides the statutory framework needed to support the government's preferred financing approach for delivering that project. It does not grant development consent, alter planning requirements...
Speaker 294
The honorable member very well knows it is up to the minister's discretion whether he gives way or not. Minister.
Simon Lightwood
The honorable member has had numerous opportunities to intervene, which were accommodated by my honorable friend. As I said, it does not grant development consent, alter planning requirements, or remove scrutiny. It provides a financing framework for delivery. But this bill is not simply about one project. At its heart is about ensuring government has another option available where that is the right solution for delivering nationally important infrastructure.
This is infrastructure that very likely could not exist without this new mechanism or something like it. It's also worth remembering what this bill is and what it is not. This bill does not create the concept of privately financed toll roads. Parliament has already provided a route for private companies to finance, construct, and operate toll roads through the concession arrangements under the New Roads and Street Works Act of 1991. That route remains available today and in the right circumstances can work effectively.
The M6 toll is an example of that approach. The principle that private capital can play a major role in road infrastructure is therefore not something being invented by this bill. But this bill creates a different model. Some roads... for some roads, a concession arrangement may be entirely appropriate, where users have clear alternatives, commercial incentives can play an important role in protecting users' interests and encouraging good performance. Some infrastructure, however, performs a very different function.
Some roads are nationally significant strategic assets. They form critical trade corridors. They support economic activity far beyond the communities through which they pass. And for many users, there may be limited practical alternatives. In those circumstances, government believes there is a strong case for independent regulation sitting alongside private investment.
That is why this bill places the Office for Rail and Road at the heart of that framework. The Office for Rail and Road will oversee performance, scrutinise costs, protect users' interests, monitor financial resilience and hold operators to account. It would have substantial enforcement powers, including the power to intervene where performance is inadequate. The bill also provides important safeguards to ensure continuity of service if a license holder encounters serious financial difficulties. So the purpose of this bill is not to enable private charging where none has existed before, it's about expanding the government's toolkit to better address the range of possible circumstances.
Furthermore, Madam Deputy Speaker, the bill will help modernise the way tolls are collected and enforced on existing tolled roads. Some of our operators have already moved from free-flow tolling, but the legislative framework has not kept pace. In some cases, existing arrangements are not working as effectively as they should, while in others, the necessary powers simply do not exist to make that transition. It is right that the law keeps pace with advances in technology and this bill provides a clear route for operators to move to a modern tolling system while ensuring that enforcement remains effective. Madam Deputy Speaker, that brings me to the theme that has featured predominantly through today's debate.
Madam Deputy Speaker, today we've heard just how important local services are to communities across our nation. This government backs local people to make the right decisions for their communities and we are striving forward with ambitious plans for devolution that will drive growth in every postcode. Fundamentally, this bill is designed so that users make a contribution towards the costs of major infrastructure from which they derive substantial benefits. Toll revenue should meet the efficient costs of constructing, operating and maintaining the infrastructure for which users are being charged. It would not be right to expand this proposition to a form of centrally imposed local taxation.
And I thank the honourable friend for Thurrock and indeed the member for Gravesham. I know the Prime Minister has personally committed the assistance of Number 10 North to the honourable member for Gravesham in her campaign to find a suitable way to bring the Tilbury-Gravesend ferry back and we remain open to working with local leaders on similar issues. Madam Deputy Speaker, the clear theme in today's debate has been whether this framework will provide regulation strong enough to protect users and avoid the failings seen in other sectors, including water. We have learned those lessons and this bill equips the Office of Rail and Road to be a strong and effective regulator from the outset. The Office for Rail and Road already has substantial experience overseeing roads and rail and its new chief executive, Paul Smith, brings extensive regulatory experience from the UK's aviation, energy and payment sectors, as well as senior regulatory roles in Australia.
Under this framework, the ORR will monitor license holders' financial resilience and long-term performance closely and the regime will incentivise the right behaviour. But where an operator falls short, there will be meaningful consequences and ultimately, the ORR will have the ability to suspend tolling whilst issues are resolved. But the bill also provides a clear backstop for this nationally important infrastructure when necessary. National Highways, I will indeed.
Speaker 285
I thank the Minister for giving way very briefly to me. So obviously Gravesham is going to be one of the half of the centre point of this. Yes, it's a nationally significant infrastructure project, but fundamentally the people of Gravesham need to make sure that there is that accountability so that things that we've learned and seen in Dartford does not happen here. So will there be local representation and local voice so that the ORR can look at what's happening on the ground and make it work better, you know, that thing.
Simon Lightwood
That was crystal clear, honestly.
There will indeed be a stakeholder group and opportunities for, for people to feed into that. Now, my honorable friend, the chair for the Transport Select Committee, was right that transport works best when there's a clear sense of direction and purpose. This government is committed to providing that through a coherent program of investment, reform, and delivery. That will create a more reliable, more integrated, and sustainable transport network. Indeed, that is exactly why we published our Better Connected strategy in April, setting out for the first time a single vision of how roads, rail, buses, and active travel should work together to serve the people and places across England.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to address directly the reasoned amendment before the House because it goes to the heart of what this bill is and what it is not. To be honest, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's as if the opposition has, has pleaded with ChatGPT to find any conceivable reason why they could disagree with this bill. The first thing to note, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that whilst the immediate context for this bill is, of course, to aid the delivery of the Lower Thames Crossing, the bill is about far more than that. So I'll not be taking or talking about the budget or project timelines, and I won't dwell on the shocking hypocrisy, frankly, of the party opposite that oversaw ballooning costs to HS2 lecturing this government on financial management. There are other times and places for that kind of discussion.
Let me simply say this. The project is progressing, with construction activity already underway. Decisions on the project continue to be subject to rigorous scrutiny, with value for money remaining at the heart of decision-making. That project already has its necessary planning approvals, which included the approval to charge tolls for use. So in bringing forward this bill, Parliament is not changing that approved scheme.
It would just be providing another option in a suite of tools that the government has to fund major road projects. I'm confused, Madam Deputy Speaker, because, because I don't understand why the opposition wants to withdraw from the Aarhus Convention at this stage of the process for the Lower Thames Crossing. The main thing in that convention, the main thing it does is allow public participation in the planning process and ensures environmental information is made available. This protects public access to reasoning and decision-making during the planning process. That stage has already passed in the, in the case of the Lower Thames Crossing.
Withdrawing from the convention now on behalf of the Lower Thames Crossing does absolutely nothing. The environmental information has already been produced. It's already been scrutinized publicly and published. That stage has passed and would not save money now. The third thing to note, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that as I've just explained, there are already acts approved in this place which allow the Secretary of State and indeed local government to introduce new road schemes which involve charging or tolling without recourse to parliamentary approval.
Finally, and most importantly, I must address what can only be described as, as misunderstandings, Madam Deputy Speaker, contained in the reasoned amendment. It is important that this House takes its responsibilities for clear and fair communication with the public seriously, and I want to address this head-on. This bill provides a mechanism for new infrastructure to be funded through future tolls in a way that regulates the potential impact on road users and provides certainty for investors, and it allows for existing physical tolls to be replaced by free-flowing virtual toll systems. The party opposite supports both these measures, as far as I understand. There's nothing else in this bill.
There's nothing to say about applying new tolls on existing roads. It's got nothing to say about wider road user charging. It's got nothing to say about LTNs, about 15-minute cities, or who shot JFK. There are no conspiracies here. Now, I know the party opposite like to whip up the culture wars whenever they see the opportunity, but their rantings and their ravings about the war on motorists in this place and outside are obviously wide of the mark.
What sensible honorable members will see in this bill is a common sense approach to managing our roads infrastructure now and in the future, nothing more, nothing less. Our constituents would frankly be better served if we scrutinized actually what's in the bill rather than harping on about things that are not. Madam Deputy Speaker, ultimately this debate comes down to a simple question: should the government have another tool to help deliver nationally significant infrastructure, a tool that enables a practical partnership with private sector that in the right circumstances can offer a good deal for taxpayers and users and that comes with a strong regulatory protection? I believe that it should. This bill does not require the government to use that model in every case, it does not place private finance above public finance, nor does it ask the house frankly to make an ideological choice between the two.
It simply ensures that where private investment can help deliver nationally important infrastructure with strong independent regulation and robust safeguards for users, the government has the option to use it. That is pragmatic, that is proportionate, and above all it's focused on delivery, and I therefore commend this bill to the house.
Speaker 297
The original question was that the bill be now read a second time, since when an amendment has been proposed as on the order paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
Speaker 298
Division, clear the lobby. As on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary no.
Tellers for the ayes David Simmons, Alicia Kearns, tellers for the noes Gregor Poynton, Rachel Hopkins.
Mesdames et messieurs, la séance est ouverte.
Speaker 301
Order, order. The Ayes to the right 76, the Noes to the left 231. The Ayes to the right 76, the Noes to the left 231. So the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock.
Speaker 297
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Program motion to be moved formally.
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Money motion to be moved formally.
I beg to move.
Speaker 297
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Ways and means motion to be moved formally.
I beg to move.
Speaker 297
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number five on business of the house.
Minister to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 297
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
Speaker 297
The question is that this house do now adjourn. Let's wait a few moments. The question is that this house do now adjourn. Douglas McAllister.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful for the opportunity to raise the urgent case of my constituent Jagtar Singh Johal, a British citizen from Dumbarton who's facing the death penalty in India on trumped up political charges. Jagtar was arbitrarily detained in an Indian prison for 3,254 days.
He's been released on bail but continues to face capital punishment in eight dubious cases against him, which duplicate allegations in which he was acquitted last year. While Jagtar has now been released on bail, he's by no means free. He faces restrictions in almost every aspect of his life and is at great risk while he remains in India. Justice may only be served by returning him to his family and his home in Dumbarton.
On that point?
Tanmanjeet Dhesi
I thank my honourable friend the member for West Dunbartonshire for his strong leadership on this important issue on behalf of his constituent, because many of my Slough constituents and I have watched on with deep concern at the case of Jagtar Singh Johal. No doubt the Johal family will be considerably pleased and relieved that Jagtar has been released on bail after nine long years, but they will still be under considerable uncertainty and distress. Does my honourable friend agree that this case has, this matter has gone on for far too long and it needs to be swiftly resolved, and the minister also needs to update the House as to what discussions have been had with their Indian counterparts to achieve that aim?
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend the member for Slough for his intervention. I agree entirely with his comments and I'll touch on those points during my speech. But can I also take this opportunity, Madam Deputy Speaker, of thanking my colleague, my honourable friend, for his continued and long-standing support and encouragement to me with respect to the fate of my constituent. He never lets a day pass where he doesn't ask me for an update and he's shown great solidarity to me and to Jagtar Singh Johal and I thank him for that. Madam Deputy Speaker, this case has attracted concern from parliamentarians across this House, from human rights organisations, from legal experts and from the United Nations.
Will my honourable friend give way?
Yes, of course.
Zubir Ahmed
Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you, thank my honourable friend for giving way, especially as he's getting into the substance of his speech. But I do want to place on record my appreciation and the appreciation of my constituents in Glasgow South West, where there's a large Sikh community, for the efforts of my honourable friend. He has been tireless since the first day that he was elected to this place in trying to secure the release of Jagtar, and that resonates very strongly with my constituents in the Sikh community at Glasgow South West. I wonder if he will agree with me, though, that although we're slowly starting to move in the right direction, there is still deep concern because Jagtar faces the death penalty and the Johal family, of whom I have friends including Gurpreet, who is a local councillor in the west of Scotland, must be filled still with trepidation as that happens. But does he agree with me there's also a wider context here, where someone born in this country, a British citizen, a second-generation Indian, has found himself in this situation, incarcerated for nearly a decade, and that does send shivers down the spines of hundreds of thousands and possibly millions of people in that situation living in Britain today that would wish to visit India?
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I agree entirely with my honourable friend's point. He makes a very powerful point in relation to the ongoing position of my constituent Jagtar Singh Johal. And can I also take this opportunity of thanking my honourable friend for not only his intervention this afternoon, but also for his continued support to me and my constituent Jagtar. He again has been unfailing in his commitment on behalf of Glasgow South West to demonstrate the ongoing support across the west of Scotland and the nation to secure Jagtar Singh's safe return home.
Madam Deputy Speaker, in opposition, my party rightly called for his release on the basis that Jagtar was arbitrarily detained, and it's my hope that through effective diplomacy, we'll be able to deliver that outcome. Above all, this case has deeply affected Jagtar's family in Dumbarton, who have spent nearly a decade fighting for justice and searching for answers.
Will the honourable member give way?
Yes, indeed.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honourable member for giving way, and I congratulate him on securing this debate and on his absolutely tireless campaigning for his constituent, which I think is an example to all of us. I myself have written to the former Foreign Secretary and to ministers on several occasions to raise Jagtar Singh Johal's case on behalf of many of my British Sikh constituents in Ealing Southall, who have been hugely concerned for his safety and his legal rights. Does the honourable member agree that it is a testament to many in the British Sikh community in his constituency, in mine, and in many across the country, who have rallied behind Jagtar Singh Johal, and that it is part of the reason that he has now been released on bail from prison?
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for her intervention. I couldn't agree more, and I wish to place on record my thanks to my colleague, and again, the very valid point, my thanks to the British Sikh community across the United Kingdom, the British Sikh Federation, and of course the work of this APPG in this House on British Sikhs. And without that collective support, we wouldn't have secured the position that we've reached today, which is the fact that he's been released on bail, but the fight continues, Madam Deputy Speaker. Jagtar, of course, is from my West Dunbartonshire constituency. His ordeal is a matter of huge concern to many of my constituents, who have urged me to continue pressing Jagtar's case in this place.
And I'm grateful for the continued efforts of campaigners in my constituency and beyond to keep me updated on developments in his case. And while I've never spoken with Jagtar himself, I hope one day to meet him as a free man, shake his hand, and have that long-awaited conversation. Jagtar travelled to India in 2017 shortly after his wedding. What should have been one of the happiest periods of his life turned into nine years of unimaginable suffering. While shopping with his wife in Punjab on his honeymoon, he was abducted from the street by hooded men, who were later identified as police officers.
He was held incommunicado for ten days. During that period, he was subjected to electric shocks, sleep deprivation, stress positions, and threats against his life. It's now known that a forced confession was extracted from Jagtar through torture, and following that, he was sent to prison, where he remained arbitrarily detained for almost nine years. The highly political accusations against Jagtar are not supported by any material evidence. No bank records, no email trail, no CCTV, nothing of this kind.
In fact, the case against him is based on that forced confession obtained under days of torture. These deeply concerning events are not simply claims made by campaigners or family members. They have repeatedly been the subject of international concern and scrutiny. In May 2022, the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention concluded that Jagtar was being detained arbitrarily and called for his release. Earlier this year, in April, ten UN special rapporteurs and independent experts issued an even stronger statement.
They found that there was no rationale for Jagtar's continued detention and stated that eight and a half years of arbitrary detention without a clear path to trial is not justice, it is unlawful suffering. They went on to say that the prolonged uncertainty surrounding his case amounted to a form of psychological torture. These are exceptionally serious findings by the UN.
The same experts raised concerns regarding the apparent duplication of charges, the presumption of innocence, the misuse of counter-terrorism legislation, and the continued reliance on evidence allegedly obtained through torture. They stated that international law is unequivocal: torture includes severe mental suffering caused by prolonged uncertainty while awaiting trial. They also prohibit the use of evidence obtained through torture in proceedings and requires prompt, transparent, and fair trials. Those principles should guide every justice system. They should also guide our response when those principles appear to have been breached in the case of a British citizen, as has been with Mr. Johal.
There have been hundreds of hearings over the course of these proceedings, yet judges recently observed in a written order that the trial is not likely to conclude anytime soon, which is incredibly worrying. There was a significant development in March 2025 when a court in Moga acquitted Jagtar of all charges. Prosecutors have spent seven years on that case, pursuing that prosecution, and ultimately failed to present credible evidence. Yet despite that acquittal, Jagtar remains in prison because he continues to face a series of eight other cases which are essentially duplicated. They all have similar underlying allegations, the same disputed confession, and the same questionable evidence.
This is backed up by UN experts who have raised concerns about the similarity of these charges, as well as issues around double jeopardy, the presumption of innocence, and the use of evidence allegedly obtained through torture. This month, there has finally been progress, Madam Deputy Speaker. Following a bail order granted on the 18th of September, Jagtar was released from Tihar Jail on the 1st of October after almost nine years in custody. This is very welcome news, and I know it's brought enormous relief to his family, friends, and supporters.
Member taking an intervention?
Patricia Ferguson
Yes, of course.
I thank Member for West Dunbartonshire for giving way, and as my constituency neighbor, I'd like to praise his steadfast campaigning on this issue, which literally began before he was elected to this place. But does he share my concern that the fact that it took another court to demand that Jagtar be released on the bail that had already been granted some days before shows how intransigent the Indian authorities are in this case? And that that is something that I think gives us all pause for thought, and hopefully the improving economic relationship this country now has with India can be part of the leverage that will be used to make the Indian government do the right thing at last.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and yes, of course, my honorable friend makes a very important point which I will be touching on towards the conclusion of my speech, and I agree entirely with her comments. But can I also take this opportunity of thanking my honorable friend, the member for Glasgow West, not only for her intervention but her support that she's shown to me over the last two years in our joint fight for justice for my constituent, Jagtar Singh Johal. Madam Deputy Speaker, Jagtar remains subject to strict bail conditions. He remains on trial in eight outstanding cases. He remains under the serious threat of these criminal charges and potentially the death penalty if convicted.
He is unable to return home to Scotland.
While his release represents an important step forward, it does not bring this case to an end. Madam Deputy Speaker, this debate is not intended to undermine the relationship between the United Kingdom and India. I am very aware that India is a hugely important partner to us and a valued friend. Nor do I underestimate the complexities involved in consular cases overseas. I recognise that ministers and officials have intervened on this case over the years and that representations have been made at various levels.
Indeed, a number of previous Foreign Secretaries have raised Jagtar's case with their Indian counterparts. Most recently, the current Foreign Secretary spoke to India's External Affairs Minister Jaishankar last month and stressed that Jagtar's case had been a concern for a long time. I am grateful to the Foreign Secretary for raising this, but the response from Minister Jaishankar was not good enough. As he has done in the past, he insisted that he can't interfere with the courts. But after all these nine years, concern cannot alone be the measure of success.
Raising Jagtar's case at any opportunity is not good enough, and his family saw little evidence of progress coming from these supposed discussions. The measure of success must be whether Jagtar is finally able to return home. In September 2023, a government minister argued publicly that calling for Jagtar's release was not in his best interests. The government therefore chose not to call for his release at that stage. Now the circumstances have changed, the opportunity before us has changed, and the government's approach must change now too.
I was pleased to see the appointment of a UK envoy for complex consular detentions, who is responsible for supporting British nationals detained overseas in complex cases. And I know that he's met with Jagtar's brother Gurpreet, whose commitment throughout this campaign has been extraordinary. Since the very start, he has spoken up for his brother with determination, dignity and resilience. And I want to thank Gurpreet for being Jagtar's biggest supporter and advocate and for relentlessly fighting for his release. I also wish to thank the team at Reprieve.
Speaker 305
They fight for people facing torture, unlawful detention and the death penalty.
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And for their diligent support and assistance to me and to Jagtar over the last two years. However, since the meeting with the envoy, the family have received little information about what concrete action is being taken. I hope the minister can provide greater clarity today. Can we have a timeline for action, given the fact that Alistair Burt was appointed to this role some months ago?
This week, the Scottish Secretary, the Business Secretary and the Environment Secretary are in India for a trade mission. This is a clear illustration of the fact that our government is developing an increasingly strong working relationship with India. Given the strength of this relationship, there is no reason as to why we shouldn't be raising Jagtar's case at every opportunity. Whilst I understand that this week's visit is a trade mission and that Jagtar's situation may be an inconvenient truth, our government need to be doing everything they can at this crucial time to ensure Jagtar's safety. The predominant fear is that his release on bail could be treated as the conclusion of this case rather than the beginning of a critical new phase.
Jagtar is not out of the woods yet. The threat of further proceedings is a reality, and the threat of the death penalty remains. The uncertainty and injustice prevails. This is precisely why our government must act now. The government could have intervened when he was first detained, they did not.
Speaker 308
They could have intervened when the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention ruled that Jagtar was wrongfully imprisoned, they did not. They could and should have intervened when he was acquitted of all charges in a Mogha district trial, but they didn't. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am not here today to point... Yes, of course.
Alexander Carmichael
I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman. This unfortunately is not the first debate that I have attended on behalf of Jagtar Singh Johal, and I commend him for bringing it back to the floor of the House. I was there when the previous minister said that it was not in his interests to intervene and to call for his release.
That was about sending a signal. And in fact, one of the signals that we now want to send is the offering to Jagtar of diplomatic protection. That would be something of enormous significance to Jagtar himself, obviously, but it would be a very potent signal to be sending to the Indian government. And would he join me in saying that that is exactly the sort of thing that we would like to hear from the minister when he responds?
Douglas McAllister
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And my right honorable colleague is 100% correct. That would be a very potent signal, and I'm sure that point has not been lost on the minister this afternoon, who we will hear from, and I thank him for his intervention and for his long-standing and continued support for my constituent, which is greatly appreciated. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not here today to point the finger of blame at anyone specifically. We must work together with the Indian government and utilize our close relationship.
Right now, we have the best chance we're going to get to bring Jagtar Singh Johal back home to his family in Dumbarton. For years, ministers could point to the fact that Jagtar remained imprisoned and that court proceedings were ongoing. Today, the situation is different. Jagtar is no longer behind bars. The international pressure surrounding his case is growing, and the UN has repeatedly called for action.
All of the allegations against Jagtar have been tested in court, and Jagtar has been acquitted. And yet, with the duplicate cases against him remaining, a court has essentially acknowledged that proceedings may continue indefinitely. If there was ever a moment to intensify diplomatic efforts, it is now. This is not the time for routine engagement and simply raising the case with Indian counterparts. It's the time for a coordinated, sustained, and determined effort to bring this case to a conclusion and bring Jagtar home.
The government cannot change what happened in 2017, but it can help to determine what happens next. This may well be the best opportunity we have had in years to secure a just outcome, and I urge ministers to seize it. Jagtar's case is not the only case of British nationals arbitrarily detained abroad. Ryan Cornelius has been imprisoned in the United Arab Emirates since 2008. Like Jagtar, the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention found that his detention was indeed arbitrary.
His original sentence was extended by a further 20 years through the retrospective application of legislation, despite serious concerns regarding due process. Similarly, Jimmy Lai, a 78-year-old British citizen in Hong Kong, has now spent more than 1,800 days in detention and was sentenced earlier this year to a lengthy prison term on national security charges and faces what is essentially now a death sentence. These cases are all different, but they share a common theme. When British citizens face arbitrary detention, unfair legal proceedings, or serious human rights concerns overseas, their own government, our government, may be the only institution capable of advocating effectively on their behalf. Every year, significant numbers of British citizens report torture and mistreatment while detained abroad, and in many cases, diplomats are the only link between those individuals and the outside world.
Jagtar's release on bail is welcome, but it's crucial to remember that this case is not over. For too long, his case has been characterized by delay, uncertainty, and missed opportunities. Now more than ever, there is a genuine opportunity to move things forward. The government should treat this moment with the urgency and seriousness it deserves. I recognize that ministers cannot direct foreign courts, and I recognize the importance of maintaining a strong relationship with India.
Parliament therefore has a duty to ensure that these cases remain visible and that ministers continue to pursue them with determination.
But friendship between nations should never prevent us from standing up for the rights of our citizens. I strongly urge this government to seize this opportunity and make resolving this case the diplomatic priority it should be. Jagtar Singh Johal has lost almost nine years of his life. His family have lost almost nine years with their son, brother, and husband. We cannot give those years back to them.
But we can ensure that nine years does not become ten years or more. So I urge the minister, please use every diplomatic channel available, engage at the highest levels of government, press for a swift conclusion to the remaining proceedings, and work to secure Jagtar's safe return home to my constituency of West Dunbartonshire.
Speaker 309
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank my honorable friend, the member for West Dunbartonshire, for resolutely leading the charge in Parliament to bring the British national Jagtar Singh Johal back home. Earlier this month, after almost nine long years behind bars, Jagtar finally walked out of prison and into the arms of his loved ones. After nearly a decade of anguish and uncertainty, his family could finally experience a moment of relief. It is frankly shameful that our great country has allowed a British national to languish in a foreign prison, reportedly to face torture in what the UN has confirmed is arbitrary detention. More shameful still that despite this long-overdue breakthrough, Jagtar's nightmare ordeal is far from over.
Speaker 310
He may be out of jail, but he has had to surrender his passport. He remains trapped in India, thousands of miles from home, still faced with eight outstanding cases, cases that nine years later still have yet to reach a conclusion, or in some cases even a start. Britain has failed Jagtar, and quite frankly, India has too. India, a country which prides itself on being the world's largest democracy, has dragged its feet for nearly a decade, failing to bring these cases to a conclusion within a reasonable timeframe, trapping a British national on foreign soil for nine long years without conviction. So I ask two questions: first to the minister, and I appreciate other members have raised similar.
What concrete diplomatic steps has the government taken, and what further action will they now take to secure Jagtar's safe return to the United Kingdom? Secondly, to this House, what does it say about Britain if we cannot secure the freedom of one of our own citizens after such a long time? Jagtar's case is a matter of deep national humiliation. His bail must spur urgent action to bring him home, not become another milestone that we merely welcome before turning to the next item on the UK-India agenda or trade deal. Thank you.
Warinder Juss
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to begin by paying tribute to my honourable friend the Member for West Dunbartonshire for his tireless work on behalf of Jagtar Johal and his family. And I know this because I've had regular meetings with my honourable friend about his constituent and I want to thank him for his efforts and for the open and collaborative way he has always engaged with me. In my constituency of Wolverhampton West, I have a Sikh population of some 15%, which is one of the highest in the country, but I've had Sikh and non-Sikh constituents who have contacted me deeply concerned about Jagtar's treatment and the way that his case has been handled, urging the government to do more for the just resolution of his case. I have previously raised Jagtar's case in the House when I mentioned the United Nations Working Group's finding that his detention was arbitrary and his fair trial rights have been violated.
The allegations of torture and the extraordinary delays in the proceedings remain deeply troubling. It appears that the rules of natural justice and the rule of law simply did not apply to Jagtar's case. So I do warmly welcome Jagtar's release on bail. For him and his family who have had so many setbacks, this is an immensely important step. But the conditions of his bail are still unfair.
His passport has been surrendered, his freedom remains severely restricted, and he cannot come home to Scotland. And he continues to face allegations that could result in the death penalty. His release from prison is certainly not the end of our efforts. Next month it will be nine years since Jagtar was arrested on the streets of Punjab in India. But nine years later, there has still not been a single conviction against Jagtar.
These are years that Jagtar and his family can never recover, let alone the suffering that they have endured during this period. So I would urge the government now to use every diplomatic channel available at the highest level to secure a resolution of Jagtar's case without any further delay so that he can safely return back home. And I would be grateful if the Minister could please explain what steps are now being taken to achieve this. Madam Deputy Speaker, how many times have we heard in this House that justice delayed is justice denied? For Jagtar Singh Johal, he has already had his justice delayed for far too long.
Speaker 311
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to my honourable friend Member for West Dunbartonshire for securing this important debate and for his continued attention to the case and his support for Mr Johal and indeed for his whole family. He's advocated relentlessly for Mr Johal since he became the Member of Parliament for West Dunbartonshire in 2024. I'd also like to thank all honourable members who have intervened during today's debate and pay particular tribute to my honourable friends Member for Ilford South and Wolverhampton West who gave further contributions. I'm grateful for all the thoughtful interventions.
But most of all, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to acknowledge Jagtar's family, including his wife and his brother. This case has been a matter of deep concern for successive governments for many years, and at the outset I want to recognise the immense toll that the long-running case has taken on Mr Johal and his family. Nearly nine years in detention without a resolution to his legal proceedings has been an extraordinarily difficult experience. And as the House knows, Mr Johal was released on bail on the 1st of August after almost nine years in pre-trial detention in India. This is a welcome development in the legal process and represents an important step forward in Mr Johal's case after such a prolonged period of detention.
And as the House knows, we have consistently raised our concerns about the length of pre-trial detention and other issues, which I will come to shortly. Since his release, officials at the British High Commission in Delhi have met Mr Johal on two occasions. They will continue to provide him with consular assistance while he remains on bail pending conclusion of his trial. Additionally, FCDO officials and our envoy, who's been mentioned by my honourable friend, for complex consular cases, detentions, Alistair Burt, a former and highly respected member of this House, have maintained regular contact with the family here in the United Kingdom. I should be clear, of course, that Mr Johal's case is not over.
While there have been progress in some elements, and we welcome the progress represented by the earlier acquittal in the state court, eight cases remain against him, remain outstanding before the Indian courts. It is crucial that these proceedings are resolved as quickly as possible within India's independent legal system. I have already made this point, but it bears repeating. The government has consistently raised concerns about Mr Johal's case with the government of India at every opportunity. Engagement has spanned successive governments and ministers and has stressed our legitimate concerns regarding Mr Johal's prolonged pre-trial detention, his very serious allegations of torture and mistreatment, and his right to a fair trial.
Most recently, as been mentioned by my honourable friend, the Foreign Secretary did raise Mr Johal's case with his Indian counterpart on the 24th of September during the United Nations General Assembly in New York. This sustained engagement demonstrates the importance that the government continues to attach to this case and our commitment to seeking a prompt and full resolution to the outstanding cases against him. At every stage, we have emphasized the need for due process and for the legal cases to come to a resolution without delay. As I've emphasized, Mr Johal's release on bail does not mark the end of these prolonged proceedings. The government shares the view of Mr Johal's family and many honourable members that the legal cases should now move forward without continued delays.
India is a sovereign democracy with an independent judiciary. Mr Johal's legal proceedings are a matter for the Indian courts. We have made clear to the government of India our interest in the legal petitions put forward by Mr Johal's defence team and our expectation that they are heard. And we continue to raise our interest and concerns with the government of India at every appropriate opportunity, pressing for a full and fair resolution through the courts, and this must include an investigation into his allegations of torture and mistreatment. And I wanted to come to two points, Madam Deputy Speaker, that have been raised by my honourable friend and members across the House in relation to two important areas that I would like to cover.
One is around the sustained campaign of Mr Johal's case. Can I assure the House, having seen the coordinated effort of ministers and including many Prime Ministers, and I don't say that in jest, we've had a number of Prime Ministers in recent time, Madam Deputy Speaker, that's a matter of fact, but they go all the way back to former Prime Minister Boris Johnson and to most recently former Prime Minister Starmer, and of course most recently by the Foreign Secretary. I would argue that there is a sustained and coordinated piece of work being undertaken by British ministers of successive governments of all colours to secure a way forward for Mr Johal. And then one other point that my honourable friend rightly challenged me on as minister responsible in this area is around the work of the UK-India trade deal and was raised by a number of my honourable friends. Can I assure the House that any support or negotiation in relation to consular is not connected to our work in trade deals.
We do continue to raise his case and we will continue to do so. Let me conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, by reiterating that the government remains fully engaged on Mr Johal's case.
His release on bail after nearly nine years in detention is an important and welcome moment for him and his family. However, significant legal proceedings remain outstanding. We will therefore continue to press, as I've said, the Government of India for a prompt, full and just resolution of Mr. Johal's cases within India's independent legal system, and we will continue to provide consular assistance. After nine painful years, Mr. Johal and his family deserve to see these long-running legal proceedings move forward. The Government will do everything it can to support that outcome.
Speaker 297
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.