House of Lords

4 November 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
01:05 - 01:08
Speaker 1
First oral question: the Baroness Wilcox of Newport. 
01:08 - 01:14
Speaker 2
I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper. 
01:14 - 01:44
Speaker 6
My Lords, devolution allows Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland to take different approaches which reflect particular circumstances while continuing to benefit from the pooling of resources, sharing of opportunities and collective strength that comes from being part of the United Kingdom.  The integrity of the United Kingdom is best protected when our four governments work constructively and effectively together on shared challenges.  That is what the Prime Minister is committed to, as he made clear to the heads of the devolved governments in the meeting of the National Economic Council last week. 
01:44 - 02:06
Speaker 4
I thank the Minister for the reply.  And does he agree with me that the true measure of successful devolution is not the accumulation of constitutional difference, but whether it delivers better outcomes for the people of Wales, whilst strengthening their place within the United Kingdom? 
02:06 - 02:56
Speaker 6
My noble friend is absolutely right.  What matters, of course, my Lords, is what works.  The guiding principle for our engagement with the Welsh Government is how to deliver better outcomes on the issues that matter for people in Wales.  That's why we're supporting people in Wales with the cost of living, driving good growth and creating hundreds of jobs, sorry, thousands of jobs in the process.  We were pleased to discuss our ambitions for re-industrialisation and for growth with the Welsh Government at the National Economic Council, and look forward to building on this in the coming months. 

And I agree with my noble friend that this is also about strengthening and championing the contribution Wales makes to the UK's collective security and prosperity, whether it's through Wales's role in bolstering the UK's defence, our steel production, or leading the way in industries like compound semiconductors and life sciences, our union is stronger from having Wales in it. 
02:56 - 03:15
Speaker 5
Why is it a problem when Wales chooses to do things differently, but not when England does?  What assessment has this government made of the impact of the constitutional and policy divergence in England on the integrity of the UK? 
03:15 - 03:54
Speaker 7
I mean, I'd I'd I'd I'd I'd say to the, I'd say to the noble lady that Wales is at risk, if you think about devolution across the whole of the United Kingdom, Wales is at risk of becoming one of the most centralised countries within the United Kingdom. 

I'd say there are opportunities to deepen devolution in Wales and to take a more place-based approach to growth.  And I think that's an ambition the UK and the Welsh Government share.  And we're keen to explore that in a respectful partnership with the Welsh Government.  And this means empowering places right across Wales so they can realize their own growth ambitions. 
03:54 - 03:58
Speaker 3
My Lords,  my Lords, 

03:58 - 04:03

Donald Anderson

move away from Cardiff government and to have

04:03 - 04:06

Speaker 10

It's the turn of the Lib Dems.

04:06 - 04:55

Speaker 16

As the minister has already said, devolution in Wales has given us the ability to do things differently from the rest of the UK if we feel it meets the needs of the people of Wales. And that inevitably means diversion, divergence, sorry. But Wales needs to move on, to travel further on our devolution route journey. We face a number of choices highlighted in the Senedd Commission's report,

the status quo, or Plaid's independence, or the Lib Dem preference for a federal future. What steps does the government intend to take to progress further powers to Wales?

04:55 - 05:50

Speaker 6

Well, I'd say to the noble lady and I think I agree with the sentiment that she expresses. Last week at the National Economic Council, the Prime Minister set out an offer on empowering local regions to deliver good growth and thus develop better public services to prevent, as I said, Wales from becoming maintaining its position as highly centralized. So, this involves all sorts of things like devolving more employment support on the condition that it reaches down into Wales's regions and communities and exploring how we can improve city region deals. Constitutionally, we need to carry on talking respectfully to all our partners in governments across the United Kingdom. And we are looking to have the and the Prime Minister indeed has said he's looking forward to Cardiff hosting the next meeting of the National Economic Council next spring, and I'm sure these discussions will continue.

05:50 - 06:35

Annabel Goldie

Lady Wilcox is absolutely right in advancing the test which she does: the quality of public services delivered, because the experience of Scotland is sad and uninstructive. After 21 years of SNP incumbency, we've had a relentless prosecution of the case for independence, rejected by the Scottish electorate, and we've had a cataclysmic decline of public services while being the highest taxed part of the United Kingdom. Can the noble Lord, the Minister, reassure this House that his government will take steps to ensure that administrations in the devolved parts of this nation are concentrating exclusively on the services they are supposed to be delivering for their electorate?

06:35 - 07:10

Speaker 7

Well, I agree completely with the noble lady. And I want to be absolutely clear: the UK Labour government was elected with a mandate to defend and strengthen our Union, whether that's in relation to Wales or indeed to Scotland. And that's what we are doing now and will continue to do. We will never support independence. In terms of her comments about looking out for the people of the respective nations, whether Wales as originally posed in the question or indeed in Scotland, we're clear they need to focus both nations need and governments need to focus on what's best for the people.

07:10 - 07:35

Speaker 6

We're very pleased that the Welsh Government has decided to follow the UK government's lead in passing on the £100 household energy payment that was announced in last week's budget, but we're also really very clear that when we are giving record funding settlements as we are to Wales, they need to focus on spending it on public services that improves the lives of citizens there, not spend all their time on constitutional questions.

07:35 - 07:42

Speaker 8

Does my noble friend the Minister

07:42 - 08:04

Donald Anderson

One of the abiding problems in Wales is the concentration of power and prosperity in Cardiff and the South East. What can the government do to encourage a greater spread of power and prosperity within Wales, real devolution?

08:04 - 08:54

Speaker 6

I agree with my noble friend, and as I've previously said, that we want to see full regional empowerment and see power not passed down from Westminster to Cardiff Bay, but through there into twitch all parts of Wales. To answer the specifics, we are of course investing in and supporting the Welsh government in investing across the whole of Wales. I'd point, I spoke to the Gwynt y Dôr investment in Ynys Môn for nuclear energy. I'd urge Plaid Cymru to be clear about how it supports the ambitions that we have for nuclear energy to provide both energy security and lots of very good, high-skilled jobs both in Wales and across the UK. We're talking about improving transport links through a new station in Deeside.

There's lots of investment the UK Government is willing to support in Wales, but we also want to see the Welsh Government supporting regional empowerment throughout the whole country of Wales.

08:54 - 09:37

Speaker 17

Crossbench. My Lords, there is the intergovernmental relations are set out in a quarterly report and in the first six months of this year, the Northern Ireland Government had 29 interministerial group meetings, the Scottish Government had 23, and the Welsh Government only had 21. And the when one looks by department, one sees that the Welsh Office only managed to have one in the first six months. The interministerial group structure is one of the key things for making our United Kingdom work properly. And I wonder whether the minister felt satisfied with the number of meetings that I've just described and what plans there were to increase that number for Wales.

09:37 - 10:11

Speaker 6

I thank the noble Lord for that observation. I'm not actually keeping quite a closer tally on as he and on is in the number of meetings, but I would point out that just this weekend we did have this the first meeting of the new National Economic Council, and I think it's really positive, I would say, to see the Prime Minister convene a meeting of the National Economic Council, and made it which he made a very clear offer to the leaders of devolved governments to put politics aside and to work in partnership with the UK Government. That's the spirit in which he wishes to work with the heads of the heads of devolved governments, and I hope that is taken up in the same spirit and I'm sure it will be.

10:11 - 10:46

Speaker 48

My Lords, both the minister and Baroness Wilcox, whom I congratulate for raising this issue, have spoken about outcomes from devolution, but the minister will understand how personally upsetting I find it to see Wales falling behind in so many devolved areas. The latest PISA results were shockingly bad, highlighting the challenges facing Welsh education. Yet, the Welsh Government continues to seek further powers, including the devolution of law and policing. Will the minister rule out further constitutional divergence where it risks undermining the integrity of our United Kingdom? A one-word quick answer will suffice.

10:46 - 11:01

Speaker 6

I can spare more, I think I can spare more than just one word, but I agree. We are looking at We are looking for the Welsh Government, and indeed the Scottish Government, to concentrate on spending public money, on improving people's lives, not on constitutional questions.

11:01 - 11:12

Dafydd Wigley

My Lords, in undertaking his responsibilities on matters which impact on devolved services, from where does the minister get his advice?

11:12 - 11:50

Speaker 6

Well, she's getting Well, my Personally, of course, I'm getting advice from officials in the Wales in the Wales Office, but part of the part of the reason the Prime Minister's convening the National Economic Council is to have frank and open positive conversations with the leaders of devolved government, including of course the Plaid Cymru administration in Cardiff, to ensure that we have a an open dialogue about Wales's challenges, but they need to, I'm sure they will do, come to the come to the table in that spirit of openness and work willingness to work in partnership on what matters to people in Wales. And I'd say that's improving public services.

11:50 - 11:53

Speaker 14

Second oral question, Baroness Lister of Burtersett.

11:53 - 11:57

Speaker 13

I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.

11:57 - 12:24

Speaker 19

My Lords, this government is spending tens of billions of pounds on housing support each year. We're also investing over 40 billion pounds over 10 years in the Social and Affordable Homes programme. We know the causes of homelessness are complex, both personal and structural. My department is working with MHCLG on the national plan to end homelessness. The government's investment in homelessness and rough sleeping services is now over 4 billion pounds over the next three years, building on the actions set out in that strategy.

12:24 - 13:14

Margot Ruth Lister

My Lords, poverty and housing charities and the LGA are very disappointed that the, uh, local housing allowance freeze, a bequest of austerity, was not lifted in the budget, ge- despite the government's very welcome commitment to tackling homelessness and child poverty. The shortfall for low-income private renters has reached an all-time high with consequences for poverty, destitution, homelessness, and the need for temporary accommodation and food banks. Given that the Prime Minister himself told the Commons recently that, I quote, "the freeze does not save money because it just creates an unfunded pressure on council budgets", will the government now consider classifying the LHA as preventative spending with a view to restoring its original annual up-rating from April?

13:14 - 14:00

Speaker 19

My Lords, I think the starting point is that my department spends 38 billion pounds a year on housing, no, on housing support. No other OECD country spends a greater proportion of their GDP on housing help. We're now at a point where around a third of households in the private rented sector get housing support from DWP, that costs over 13 billion pounds a year, and it went up by over three and a half billion in the last decade, and it keeps rising. So in the end, we have to address the root cause of this issue, and the only way to do that is to secure an adequate number of decent affordable homes. That's why the government has recently announced an extra one and a half billion pounds to deliver around 10,000 homes in England, prioritising social rent, especially council homes, and we will keep building up the resources to do that.

14:00 - 14:09

Speaker 11

But there is a discretionary support with housing costs available from local authorities for those receiving housing support who have a shortfall in meeting their housing costs.

14:09 - 14:41

Speaker 35

My Lords, LHA levels have now fallen so far behind market rent levels that fewer than 2% of properties are affordable, leaving hundreds of thousands of families stuck. Stuck on social housing waiting lists with no chance of housing, stuck in temporary accommodation unable to move on, stuck while other families, other homeless families, wait for that space to be freed for them. Can the Minister not see that solving the homelessness crisis requires us first to unstick LHA levels?

14:41 - 15:25

Speaker 19

My Lords, I think the starting point is it needs to be the other way around. The noble Lady mentions 2%, that isn't a figure that the government recognises, I'm sure she will know. But we do recognise the affordability pressures faced by those living in the private rented sector. That's why we've taken a whole series of actions from the Renters' Rights Act in May, powers to challenge excessive rent hikes, as well as giving greater security through the abolition of no-fault section 21 evictions, and also taking practical steps through that act to help rent renters tackling rental discrimination. But my Lords, in the end, the only way to try to drive down rents in the sector is for there to be enough supply of housing, which is why the government has prioritised that.

We're also investing significantly in supporting councils in addressing problems in temporary accommodation and crucially in addressing the root causes of homelessness.

15:25 - 15:28

Speaker 21

That must be the priority.

15:28 - 15:55

Speaker 37

Minister's question. The government wants to move asylum seekers out of hotels into private rented accommodation. The government wants to end rough sleeping, which means providing move-on accommodation to rough sleepers when they leave hostels. Both these groups are by definition on low incomes. So, how can confident is the noble lady that those two worthy ambitions will be met if the local housing allowances don't cover local rents?

15:55 - 16:54

Speaker 19

My Lords, the noble Lord is raising important points, and there are different groups of people who need housing support. But they are all tackling in different ways. I won't go into detail about what's happening with asylum accommodation, but we know what's happening in that space has a lot of work has gone into that. I think the crucial point is that the investment, the significant amounts of extra money, another £432 million in addressing homelessness and rough sleeping, bringing that to over £4 billion over three years, is a is addressing a whole range of questions, trying to get people off the streets, but then giving them support to be able to move on and to operate independently, addressing whatever the underlying questions are, such as mental health issues elsewhere, but also taking actions in different areas. We're working to tackle the inappropriate and illegal use of B&B accommodation for families over a certain area.

We've committed £30 million in support of a three-year emergency accommodation reduction program specifically to support local authorities with the highest pressures. So the government is acting in all the different areas, but I say, in the end, the solution has to be to have more housing.

16:54 - 16:56

Speaker 18

Crossbench. My Lords.

16:56 - 17:17

Martyn Snow

Councils spent £2.8 billion on temporary accommodation last year, while restoring the local housing allowance would cost it's estimated around 2 billion a year by the end of the decade. Did the government weigh the cost of the freeze to councils against its savings to DWP?

17:17 - 18:11

Speaker 19

My Lords, the government weighed across the piece, weighed all of the issues involved in housing. But the In fact, partly as I was saying just now to the noble Lord Young, the truth is we have a housing market, and all of these things are inter are interrelated. So it isn't a matter simply about pressing down here and comparing it with what happens over here. In the longer term, if we don't have enough decent, affordable homes, rents will keep rising. It's a simple law of supply and demand.

So the government has to meet the challenge of addressing crisis in the short term, which is why we've been doing lots on temporary accommodation, addressing crises in the long term, investing over £40 billion over 10 years in the long-term development of further additional housing, and investing in the immediate term with discretionary support to support those so where there is rent shortfall, renters can apply through the through to for help from through the local authorities. And we put the first ever multiyear settlement into local resilience support. So we are doing it across the piece, but, in the end, we have to get the market sorted.

18:11 - 18:42

Richard Stuart Best

Crossbench. My Lords, would the noble Baroness, the Minister, accept that very few landlords are going to let to anyone on housing benefit if they know there's a gap to be filled between the rent that the tenant receives as benefit and the actual rent that has to be paid? No landlord is going to take the risk with such tenants, and this will lead to a drying up, and already is leading to a drying up, of accommodation provided by private landlords for anyone on the lowest incomes.

18:42 - 19:12

Speaker 19

My Lords, there is certainly a relationship, at least we assume there's a relationship, between the amount of money the state will spend supporting housing and how much landlords charge, and that cashes out in various ways, as I've just been trying to describe now. The reality is that a very significant number of people who are in the private rented sector, who receive housing support either in housing benefit or through universal credit, do apply and get help from their councils through discretionary housing payments and the wider Crisis and Resilience Fund. It will carry on being there to support them, and they can use that to help to pay their rents.

19:12 - 19:39

Speaker 62

My Lords, bearing in mind the what the Minister has said about the priorities of the government, I'd like to ask what assessment the Minister has made of the short-term case for restoring local housing allowance to the 30th percentile to make the private rented sector more accessible while the country builds the social homes that we all know are needed for sustainable long-term housing need?

19:40 - 20:29

Speaker 19

My Lords, the government looked carefully, and we'll, and I should say at the start, we will continue to keep the rate of the local housing allowance under review. But just to give the House a sense of the cost that's involved, in April 2024, there was a one-year increase in the local housing allowance. That cost an extra £1.2 billion in 2024-25. Over 5 years, that one rise will cost over £7 billion. So, my Lords, I'm absolutely, I'm extremely sensitive to the points that are being raised.

The government is investing money through a long-term Crisis and Resilience Fund, through local discretionary support to help meet the shortfalls, but in the end I have to come back to the fact that the government's priority is to tackle emergency problems in the short-term, tackle emergency accommodation, tackle temporary accommodation, invest extensively in tackling homelessness and provide extra support while the market is sorted.

20:29 - 20:54

Deborah Stedman-Scott

My Lords, if increasing supply is the sustainable way to make housing more affordable, does the government accept the OBR's forecast that 190,000 fewer additional homes will be delivered over the forecast period, which will mean higher housing costs as a direct result of this government's failed housing policy?

20:54 - 21:49

Speaker 19

Well, my Lords, I'm not sure if I was sitting on the opposite benches I'd be talking too much about failure to build houses over a long period of time, but since we're on the subject, since we're on the subject, my Lords, this government is providing an extra £1.5 billion to provide 10,000 homes in England for social rent now. But also we have a stretching target to build 1.5 million new homes. We know that stretching. Our latest statistics suggest we've built 437,900 net additional homes since the start of the Parliament through to the 20th of September this year. It will take time for the impact of our planning reforms to flow through the permissions data.

And we know this is a difficult environment. The geopolitical context is not easy. We know it will be challenging. But we know it'll take time to turn the tide and deliver more homes. We expect housebuilding to ramp up further in the later years of this Parliament.

But I would urge the whole House to get behind an ambitious target. We need government after government to keep doing this. This government is determined to do it.

21:49 - 22:36

Speaker 45

My Lords, homelessness, my Lords, homelessness and temporary accommodation are not just housing issues, they are public health issues. Housing is an important determinant of health. The report published by our government in December 25 showed that between 2019 and 2024, the last government, 74 children died when temporary accommodation was a contributory factor to their deaths and 58 of those children were under the age of one.

Can I ask my noble friend the minister if the government will consider the public health consequences of homelessness and temporary accommodation and work jointly with the Department of Health and Social Care and the NHS when planning these prevention strategies?

22:36 - 23:22

Speaker 19

My noble friend raises an excellent point, and it isn't just a matter of temporary housing, there are issues about the quality of some housing. And the government is working very hard on this. And we take the issue, particularly, of non-compliant landlords renting out substandard properties very seriously indeed. Local authorities do have various powers to make sure that landlords can be held accountable and robustly enforced against them. And my department is working with MHCLG to increase enforcement activity and to make our data available to make that easier.

But just for one example, we've also acted: Awaab's law came into force in the social rented sector in October last year, that means all social landlords must repair all emergency hazards within 24 hours and fix dangerous damp and mould within fixed timescales. And that will be extended further in phase two. So I'm grateful to her for raising this and I assure her that the government is on it.

23:22 - 23:25

Speaker 23

Oral question, Lord Mann.

23:25 - 23:29

Speaker 22

To ask the question in my name on the Order Paper.

23:29 - 24:01

Speaker 26

The government values the role played by the House of Lords as a revising chamber through the expertise and experience of your Lordships' House members and by holding the government to account, this House improves legislation and delivers better outcomes for the UK public. We will and are taking forward long-overdue reforms to your Lordships' House. These changes will ensure that the second chamber can continue to perform its vital scrutiny role with maximum effectiveness and public confidence going forward.

24:01 - 24:32

Speaker 34

We know what we are, but we know not what we may be. AI will usurp the revising chamber, that much is obvious. Is our future to be merely the hallucinators? The hereditaries flew their perch with barely a murmur, but what of us? Will we waltz into oblivion or quickstep into a brave new world?

24:32 - 25:17

Speaker 26

Well, of all the questions I thought my noble friend would come up with as a supplementary, I wasn't actually anticipating one on AI. I fear that the noble, my noble friend is I'm not I'm not convinced by my noble friend's arguments about AI. Clearly, AI will have a wide range of purposes going forward and will enable us to do our jobs better in so many ways, but I do believe that with a modernised House of Lords, we will continue to have a purpose for many years going forward.

25:17 - 25:20

Speaker 25

Conservative.

25:20 - 25:31

Speaker 39

Failure of the House of Commons to debate many clauses of bills brought before it demonstrates the relevance of this place.

25:31 - 25:50

Speaker 26

My Lords, how the Commons scrutinise legislation is a matter for them, not for us. They have their procedures, we have ours. The two Houses have not and never been a carbon copy of each other, which is probably where one of the strengths lies.

25:50 - 26:27

James Peter Weir

My Lords, I hope by the way I'm not hallucinating at this particular point. But can I ask the minister what examination has the government done in its reforms to the composition of the House of Lords of whether there'll be any level of disproportionate or differential impact on the countries and regions of the United Kingdom in terms of its membership? And if it does come to the conclusion that there is disproportionate impact, what plans does the government have to restore geographical balance to the House?

26:27 - 26:59

Speaker 26

The government is clear that we should have regional and national representation as part of whatever form your Lordships' House takes going forward. We want to reform the appointments process. It's a manifesto commitment to ensure the quality of new appointments and seek to improve the national and regional balance of the second chamber. So, as we work through potential reforms, this will remain a commitment from the government.

26:59 - 27:21

Speaker 32

Would the noble lady the minister agree that an excellent way of reinforcing the relevance and reputation of this House in contemporary and modern Britain would be to finally deliver on the promise made in the Parliament Act of 1911 and make this a democratic chamber?

27:21 - 27:48

Speaker 26

I'm not I'm not I'm not I'm not clear that would necessarily solve all the problems and I think there are a number of arguments against that, as well. At the moment, our focus as a government is on considering the recommendations of the Retirement and Participation Committee.

The overall objective is a smaller chamber that better represents the UK's regions and nations.

27:48 - 28:11

Ilora Finlay

In order for us to fulfill our scrutiny function fully, when will the government increase the number of appointments through the House of Lords Appointments Commission, as these applicants are very carefully scrutinized themselves in order to contribute to any gaps there are in the knowledge in the chamber, in order to look at legislation?

28:11 - 28:34

Speaker 26

The House of Lords Appointments Commission plays a vital role in vetting and nominating crossbenchers to the Lords. We've committed in our manifesto to reform the process of appointments to the House of Lords. We've already strengthened transparency in the appointments system and will continue to work with the House of Lords Appointments Commission as part of our process of reform.

28:34 - 28:54

The Baroness Finn

My Lords, does the noble Baroness the minister agree that much of our legitimacy in the eyes of the public flows from our effectiveness as a scrutinizing chamber? Indeed, many regard this house as the finest scrutinizing chamber in the world. So, does she agree that proposed changes should always be motivated by a desire to improve effective scrutiny?

28:54 - 29:29

Speaker 26

Absolutely. I would wholeheartedly agree with the noble lady. I've got a list of the activity of the House of Lords and, from the 17th of July '24 to the 29th of April this year, apparently, your Lordships spent 2,624 hours spent scrutinizing legislation, which I think speaks for itself as the role of your Lordships' House in scrutinizing legislation.

29:29 - 29:58

Arlene Isobel Foster

I'm privileged to sit on the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee, which is not only relevant to people of Northern Ireland and to the businesses and consumers, but is the only place that carries out that function. So, it is very important that we allow that relevance to become known, not just in Northern Ireland, but across the UK. How can the noble Lord the minister increase the knowledge of what actually happens, not just here in this chamber, but actually in the committees across the house?

29:58 - 30:46

Speaker 26

I think, on one level, this has to be a matter for the House itself. I think that one of the ways we can all make sure that people are clear on what we do as an institution is by sharing that knowledge. And I know a huge number of noble Lords take part in the Learn with the Lords process. I think that promoting what people do across the House is hugely important, and I think I understand that apparently 330 members of your Lordships' House sit on committees. I was surprised by that figure, so if I'm surprised by how much work goes on behind the scenes on committees, I think we've all got a role in promoting the work of our incredible committees going forward.

30:46 - 31:19

Helene Hayman

My Lords, the noble Baroness the minister said, and I think I heard her correctly, that the government's policy was to have a smaller House and to improve the appointments process. In that context, and if they really want to achieve that, is it the government's policy therefore to constrain the unconstrained prerogative of the Prime Minister to appoint as many peers, without the full scrutiny of the Appointments Commission, to this House?

31:19 - 32:04

Speaker 26

We're committed to reform and we've already taken steps to modernize the House of Lords via the Hereditary Peers Act.

It is a longstanding precedent across the political spectrum that governments recommend new peers to the sovereign. Retirements and other departures mean that new peers will be needed to ensure the Lords has appropriate expertise. In the first instance, we are going to be responding to the report by the by the committee of the House that made recommendations, and we're intending to do to report back on that and respond to the committee's report later this year.

32:04 - 32:54

Annabel Goldie

It's contemporary, but coming from Scotland, I'm a proud member of British citizenship, the proud member of the United Kingdom, and I'm privileged to be in this House. And very recently, I've seen at first hand the manifestation of the expertise to which the noble Leader of the Minister has been referring. The 97-year-old noble and gallant, Lord Craig of Radley, delivering a crucial amendment to the Armed Forces Bill, accepted by the government.

My venerable friend, Lord Young of Cookham, in his mid-80s, bringing unrelenting pressure on the government in respect of housing issues and student child trust funds. Does this not suggest to the noble lady that the government should be very careful about interfering with the unique equilibrium which makes this chamber do the excellent job it does?

32:54 - 33:39

Speaker 26

The government's manifesto did commit to a mandatory retirement age, and clearly that was a large part of the consideration of the committee that was made up of your Lordships' House and reported to your Lordships' House earlier this year. I think that while while we have incredible examples of what members of your Lordships' House do over the age of 80, that doesn't necessarily mean that we shouldn't take forward reform. The government will be responding to the committee's proposals in due course as I made clear, and I look forward to future debates with members from across your Lordships' House.

33:39 - 33:42

Speaker 1

A fourth oral question, the Lord Farmer.

33:42 - 33:49

Michael Stahel Farmer

I beg leave to ask this question standing in my name on the order paper.

33:49 - 34:10

Speaker 27

My Lords, recall is an essential public protection tool. Through the Sentencing Act, we have reformed recall, replacing short-term recalls of 14 and 28 days with a fixed-term recall of 56 days to provide time to address risks and resettlement needs to ensure safe release.

34:10 - 35:14

Michael Stahel Farmer

My Lords, MoJ data between April and June this year shows 12,278 releases from custodial sentences and 11,898 recalled prison admissions. Despite radical early-release schemes, we only seem to be breaking even. The noble Lord the Minister has a great track record in offender rehabilitation, but the government needs to end this merry-go-round and make prisons a place of reform. How will they ensure politicians no longer ignore the game-changing role relationships play in rehabilitation?

HMPPS staff and frontline charities are completely seized of its importance, and but need those responsible for policy setting to make the case to a public desperate for change. Is this government going to buck the trend of the last 20 years and explain why it's not being soft on crime to make healthy relationships prominent in penal policy?

35:14 - 36:06

Speaker 27

Well, I hope we do buck the trend of certainly the last 14 years. But but the but can I answer the noble Lord fully? Recall is a public protection measure as he knows, and people are recalled because they've broken license conditions. And the way to for offenders to avoid recall is to comply with their license conditions.

On his wider point about relationships and rehabilitation, I think he knows, as we've worked together on this before, that I have a great deal of sympathy for what he's saying. And if indeed there is a gap between policy and practice, I shall be very happy to champion that, with of course his wise advice and help.

36:06 - 36:20

Speaker 42

My Lords. My Lords. Does the noble Lord the minister agree that special steps are urgently needed to reduce the number of IPP prisoners recalled for breach of licence conditions?

36:20 - 36:51

Speaker 33

Yes, I do agree with that. And I'm very proud that the Government has taken, announced decisive steps to address the IPP problem. It's gone on far too long, and we are going to address it, as the Prime Minister and the Lord Chancellor has announced. I should say, of course, that we shan't we shan't compromise public protection in that. But with regard to recall of IPP prisoners, we must make sure the public are safe.

36:51 - 36:56

Speaker 31

But as far as the IPP sentence is concerned, it must go.

36:56 - 37:36

Jonathan Marks

Recalls are at the highest level ever, with more people now being recalled than are released. More than 70% of recalls follow non-compliance, while only a fifth follow re-offending. Non-compliance is often not deliberate, but results from an inability to meet conditions, often because of housing or debt issues, rather than wilful breaches. Can the noble Lord say how it is decided where recalled prisoners are placed and what support they are offered while back in prison for the 56 days to help break the cycle of repeated recalls?

37:36 - 38:44

Speaker 33

So let me, there's several parts to that question, and let me try and answer them quickly. On the question of recalls which are for, as it were, administrative breaches, we are trying to improve the administrative procedures and use technology to ensure that as far as possible offenders on licence can avoid recall for those reasons. Because the noble Lord is absolutely right: the way to avoid recall is to support people from becoming homeless and all and support all the protecting factors that prevent reoffending or indeed recall. We have, since we started our community accommodation service in HMPPS, helped to house 36,000 people. And the number of homeless prisoners, sorry, the number of homeless ex-offenders has come down, but there is more to do.

And finally, on the 56 days point, the reason we've done that, as the noble Lord knows, is to ensure that something meaningful and purposeful can happen when people are recalled.

38:44 - 39:16

Speaker 52

My Lords, thank you. My Lords, picking up on the last two speakers, there are countless people serving IPP sentences who have been recalled for no further offence and have to wait up to two years to satisfy the parole board that they are indeed safe for release. So picking this up again, does the noble Lord the minister agree that IPPs who have been deemed safe for release should not have to prove yet again as to why they should regain their freedom?

39:16 - 39:44

Speaker 33

Well, I think the noble Lord, my noble friend I should say, knows my views on this. We've worked so together closely together.

He is a tireless campaigner on behalf of IPP prisoners, and I pay tribute to him for that, but we are going to end the sentences, end IPP sentence without compromising public protection and that includes ending the license period.

39:44 - 40:29

David Wolfson

I think we can all agree that unless we have the facts about a government policy none of us can evaluate it properly. The Telegraph reported that in the first week the number of recalls, first week after the early release scheme, the number of recalls went up 10%. In the Ministry of Justice figures was released last week, the relevant quarter the number of recalls went up 27%, but no data is provided as to how much of that 27% is due to the early release scheme. So will the noble Lord, the Minister, commit to providing that disaggregated data so that we can see precisely how many of the recalls are due to the early release scheme?

40:29 - 41:17

Speaker 27

Well, can I politely correct the noble Lord first of all, it is not an early release scheme. Early release schemes were started as an emergency measure under the last government. What we have introduced under the Sentencing Act, which I spent many happy hours here debating, is an earned progression scheme, and that is Well, you may laugh.

I am sorry. Th- this is a big change in sentencing policy, which we have debated at length and it is now the law of the land. On the question of, it is very early days for people released as part of the this model. The data would not be meaningful, but we will publish data in the normal way.

41:17 - 41:29

Speaker 41

Is the noble Lord, the Minister, able to give a breakdown of the types of perpetrators that are being recalled to prison? For example, how many are domestic abuse perpetrators and sexual abuse perpetrators?

41:29 - 41:42

Speaker 27

As I say, we will publish the data in the normal way, but I'm very happy to appoint the noble lady to where that data is available and what breakdown is given.

41:42 - 42:09

Speaker 51

My Lord, many of the prisoners are released have drink and drug and addiction problems. Isn't he concerned, like I am, that we have unfilled beds in residential rehab centres around the country, yet we have prisoners being released who are then quickly going back to drink and drugs, when in fact we should be making a match and filling those beds and getting people proper recovery and stopping the cycle?

42:09 - 42:46

Speaker 33

Yes, I am concerned about that, and I know from being involved with HMPPS for many years that the pathways to drug treatment for people leaving prison are very complicated and very disparate around the country. And we do need to improve access and as my noble friend says, the matching to drug treatment services. It can't be right that we need more offenders to receive that treatment and that treatment is available. It is an absolutely crucial part of reducing reoffending.

42:46 - 43:42

Claire Fox

On why prisoners breach licence conditions, as we've seen prisoners released early armed with tents, because they haven't got houses to go to, isn't that a guarantee that they're going to breach their licensing conditions, just as the Probation Service, who seem to be using recall as a mechanism to cope with the early release system, by getting people off the books? Is it not the case that policy is helping them or is assisting them breaching their licence conditions? And then, just secondly, on the IPP question, will the government look urgently at removing the IPP label from those in the community who've had to jump through high-threshold loops to prove they're safe for release,

so why don't you just get rid of the IPP label so that they won't be recalled egregiously and promiscuously as too many of them are?

43:42 - 44:09

Speaker 27

I should make it absolutely clear to your Lordships' House that we do not issue tents to people leaving prison and the noble lady should not believe everything she reads in the newspapers. On the question of IPPs, I was pleased that the noble lady attended our briefing on that and she knows the progress we're making on that, and I appreciate her support, and I wish all noble Lords a good day off tomorrow.

44:09 - 45:33

Speaker 57

My Lords, that completes oral questions for today. My Lords, I'll give it the House I shall give the House one minute to disperse. My Lords, we now come to an instrument previously debated in Grand Committee, Private Rented Sector Database Regulations 2026,

45:33 - 45:38

Speaker 44

Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

45:38 - 45:42

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

45:42 - 46:00

Speaker 56

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say "content". To the contrary, "not content". The "contents" have it. Questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons yesterday on the situation at Poundland.

46:00 - 47:06

Andrew Sharpe

My Lords, our thoughts are with those 12,000 Poundland workers, and of course all of those in the Poundland supply chain who are facing an anxious Christmas. But, my Lords, only last week, the Chancellor had the perfect opportunity in his budget to reverse £25 billion in national employer national insurance contributions, to cut the most damaging regulations in the Employment Rights Act, to tackle among the highest industrial electricity prices in the developed world, and to reform a business rates regime crushing the high street.

Instead, he chose to make a bad situation worse. According to a new report, since 2024, the cost of employing a worker on minimum wage has increased by £4,462, and an 18 to 20-year-old, the cost has increased by £4,859. That is double the rate of inflation, my Lords. Is it any wonder we have a NEETs crisis?

So, it's sad to say, but Poundland won't be the last. So when will the government get a grip, cut the taxes and regulations that are driving businesses to the wall?

47:06 - 48:15

Sonny Liang

My Lords, firstly, let me thank the noble Lord for coming in to ask this oral question despite having a very heavy cold, and I wish him speedy recovery. My Lords, firstly, let me join with the noble Lords in saying that, firstly, Poundland stores remain open,

but I know how worrying it is with the uncertainty that's happening right now for the 12,000 workers and their family, and perhaps also the wider supply chain. My Lords, Gordon Brown, Gordon Brothers cites inflation and shoplifting, yet Poundland sales have grown and private buyers have come forward. So the owner really needs to explain what is holding up the sale of this company. For the wider high street, the Budget will take around 70,000 more retail, hospitality, and leisure businesses in England out of business rates from April '27, and we are committing £210 million in community assets programme supporting local communities to imagine and revive their struggling high streets.

48:15 - 49:16

Speaker 63

My Lords, in the '70s, Edward Heath, Prime Minister, coined the phrase, "unacceptable face of capitalism". And if the Gordon Brothers do turn their back on the acquisition and they do close Poundland, and they do let these important jobs go, that will be unacceptable. Which is why I am a bit confused by the Minister's response yesterday in the Commons. She seemed to be clear when she said that the Government would not sit by and do nothing. However, that would be clear had she not previously said, but two paragraphs earlier, "We are not interfering with the auction.

There are ongoing commercial negotiations about this private business, and we do not want to impede or influence that process". So could the Minister clear things up? Which of these is the Government not doing?

49:16 - 50:00

Sonny Liang

The Government is definitely not going to intervene currently as far as this ongoing commercial negotiations regarding a private business. And it would not be appropriate for Government to intervene right now. I mean, we really need to wait and see what happens after the negotiations itself. Let's remember that Poundland is currently trading. They have appointed an administrator, and there is a creditor protection for 10 days, which expires next week.

So until such times, we want to see the negotiations carry on. However, the Government, nevertheless, wants all viable options capable of protecting jobs and supporting a sustainable future for Poundland to properly to be properly considered.

50:00 - 50:02

Speaker 58

My Lords,

50:03 - 50:24

Speaker 67

My Lords, it's clear that very many small businesses are being pestered by Poundland to continue to supply them even though their invoices haven't been paid. Can my noble Lord the Minister please give them some advice? How would they respond to that request?

50:24 - 51:11

Sonny Liang

I thank my noble friend for that very important point, actually. For a small supplier, one unpaid invoice can mean a struggling to pay month-end payroll, and suppliers need to know when invoices will be paid, and on what terms they are being asked to send more stock. And I would also advise all suppliers to actually have a look at the terms of supply and see whether they have got a clause in their invoice which states the Romalpa clause itself, which means the title does not pass until the payment is made. So we are pressing Poundland's owner to explain how it will protect suppliers as well as staff,

and the Home & Gift Association opened a register where suppliers can record their exposure.

51:11 - 51:34

Mark Harper

Minister, back to the wider situation raised by my noble friend on the Front Bench, which are the wider trading conditions. In its report ahead of the Budget, the OBR made it clear: unemployment was going to rise in the next year, that the costs from the Employment Rights Act were very significant, and they came on top of the very significant national insurance rises,

51:35 - 51:50

Speaker 73

And those were all factors in pushing up unemployment and they're all under the control of the government. So, what is the government going to do to improve the wider trading conditions for the retail sector?

51:50 - 52:28

Sonny Liang

Well, look, I think I've explained myself earlier, look, at the end of the day, we need to look at in regards to Poundland, I mean, not only is it National Insurance, but other additional employment costs itself. But if noble Lords will look at the history of Poundland, I mean, there was a restructuring a High Court hearing in '25, where the court have actually also said that Poundland was actually in financial distress. So, this has been ongoing for some time. Look, the government has mentioned in the budget, that's taking every step to support businesses, high streets, and small businesses, and we're committed to do so.

52:28 - 52:54

Patience Wheatcroft

My Lords, Poundland is owned by Gordon Brothers, which in turn is owned by Stone Point Capital. These are companies which are effectively private equity organisations and, as is so often the case, they load companies that they purchase with debt that can't be serviced. Wouldn't the noble Lord the minister agree with me that's the essential problem at Poundland?

52:54 - 53:22

Sonny Liang

Well, firstly, let me say that, look, I spend my working life building businesses and I support all forms of capital to help businesses grow and scale. However, I recognize that there have been questions about Poundland. But our immediate priority is to establish the facts and support Poundland's workforce. And if cases this if there are so incidents of what the noble lady have just said and emerges from this case, wider questions, of course, we will consider them carefully.

53:22 - 53:55

Prem Sikka

My Lords, private equity has devoured town centres for years. Can I urge the government to do two things? Firstly, abolish the tax relief on interest payments for corporations, a process that began with Finance Act 2017 by the party opposite, and, secondly, appoint worker-elected directors on the boards of large companies. If the minister finds these suggestions too radical, can he suggest his own?

53:55 - 54:13

Sonny Liang

Well, I always find my noble friend's questions and sometimes very challenging questions quite interesting. Look, as far as his point about carried interest, you know the government's position stays as it is. And as far as directors on board, we can have ongoing conversations, but there's no immediate plans to do so.

54:13 - 54:19

Speaker 68

Will the government rule out specific Poundland subsidy or nationalization as a solution?

54:19 - 54:21

Speaker 69

The answer is no.

54:21 - 54:44

George Foulkes

Lord, but the does the minister share does the minister share my concern that chief executives who get rises often more than their workers get paid in a year and very rich Tories opposite blame a lot of the problems on paying the poorest the minimum wage?

54:44 - 54:59

Sonny Liang

Look, my noble friend obviously has got a point when it comes to the minimum wage, and the government supports the minimum wage. Now, as far as directors' remuneration, it's entirely up to the company to decide how much they pay the directors.

54:59 - 55:10

Speaker 65

My Lords, how can this government credibly claim to champion the high street whilst at the same time increasing employers' National Insurance and business rates?

55:10 - 55:18

Sonny Liang

Well, there's so many ways one can ask that question, and I refer the noble Lord to my previous answer to his noble friend.

55:18 - 55:51

Speaker 70

I take Baroness Wheatcroft's point that typically private equity does put debt into businesses and that sometimes works and sometimes doesn't. I think in this instance, there has been capital put into Poundland,

And I think when the restructuring happened last time, it was going into financial difficulties in any event. But the point remains, does this does the noble Lord, the Minister, think that this business has benefited from more tax and regulation, or would benefit from less tax and regulation?

55:51 - 56:17

Sonny Liang

Well, look, I've tried to address as many as well, I've tried to address the point many times, in different ways, as far as additional employment costs and taxes are. As far as Poundland is concerned, look, there are still ongoing negotiations about a possible sale. So, until such time it happens, the government will work with Poundland and the owners to try and get a sale going.

56:17 - 56:25

Speaker 71

House to be again in committee on the Representation of the People Bill, Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

56:25 - 56:30

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I beg to move that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee on the bill.

56:30 - 56:52

Speaker 56

The question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.

Schedule 1, resume debate on amendment 10.

56:52 - 57:10

Speaker 77

My Lords, before we continue to debate amendment 10, I would just like to remind the House that this is an adjourned debate, and therefore, unless you were present at the start of the group, you are not able to contribute. The clerk at the table has a full list of those who were present.

57:10 - 01:00:59

Charles John Fuller

I was here on Monday evening at the point of adjournment. And not only am I in my place, I'm also next to Lord Reynard, who's in the same place as well, things move on. Now, in every amendment in this bill and in other parts of the work in your Lordships' House, I support my noble friend, Lord Jackson of Peterborough. But regrettably, I cannot support his amendment 124, which requires by law that elections must be started on the count overnight following the polls closing. It's important to explain why.

Running an election is a complicated task for election staff who have to recruit presiding officers, polling inspectors, count staff and handle all matter of other ancillary tasks like fetching and carrying the ballot papers. Now, I know this happens with a general election and it's important we maintain the requirement for overnight counting in those contests, but we have to recognize that local government works over a much larger canvas, geographical canvas. It often encompasses multiple constituencies, there are many more electors in the race. We have multi-member wards, we have funny business when it comes to alternative and supplementary votes for some contests and more people, different and more complicated systems, add complexity and time. Now, local elections are different to the national elections, where simply the person with the most votes wins, and let's not forget that unlike a parliamentary vote, where there is just one election to count, local elections may have many wards, interspersed with town council by-elections, so the number of contests isn't just greater, it's an order of magnitude larger.

And of course, the ability to attract presiding officers and count staff, who have historically come from our high street banks, tellers and other high street financial workers, is harder. We just don't have the tellers to provide us who are used to handling banknotes in the age of tap and pay anymore. So, we've ended up with a diminished pool of talent to operate the election and the facts of life are that oftentimes we rely on the presiding officers who have done a stretch from 7:00 a.m. till 10:00 to turn up again the following day to do the count. Now, you can't have people working for what would be 24 hours nonstop in the most delicate and mentally taxing work, which requires huge concentration not just for validation, but also for the count, as well as the banding, bundling and tallying, if we want to have confidence in our democracy.

And I should also say that local elections have many more types of parties, more candidates, and therefore, a higher propensity for recounts where many contests are decided by just a handful of votes, or even a coin toss. But as I warm to my theme, what this short debate gives us off is the opportunity is to remind the Prime Minister that if he's minded to change the current parliamentary voting system, any ch- changes are likely to prejudice the ability for an overnight counts if greater complexity is introduced. The voters rejected electoral change in a referendum in 2011, but he doesn't seem to be listening. The consequences of change are likely to be that the ability to count overnight is diminished or, at very least, the announcement of the results and the clarity the electorate should deserve will be delayed. I don't believe this has been taken into account in any other forum, and here's my opportunity to mention it.

But to return to the amendment, this is detailed work. It needs a staff who are bright as a button and on the ball to do these local elections, which are more complicated, take more time, and more opportunities to go wrong than parliamentary ke- contests when often there are just two or three main candidates to fl- slug it out. The majorities are weighed in handfuls of thousands, not handfuls of votes. And for this reason, I can't support my noble friend in his endeavour, attractive though it may be. Better to take your time and get it right than rush and live with the consequences.

01:00:59 - 01:01:28

James Stewart Jackson

Before he sits down, will he at least concede that this is a not a prescriptive amendment, it's a it's a probing amendment, and clause 4 of the amendment does allow electoral returning officers to disregard the obligation in emergencies or in specific circumstances, so it's not a draconian amendment forcing every ERO to do the same.

01:01:28 - 01:07:39

Robert Hayward

My Lords, following on from Lord Fuller's comments, can I broadly express support for him in relation to the comments that he's just made? And while I understand Lord Jackson's intervention at the end of his speech, I think the key factor that one has to look at here, which Lord to which Lord Fuller referred in passing, is the sheer number of parties to which we now operate on a regular basis in multi-member wards. I'm looking towards Lord Rennard, and I'm quite happy as fellow pedant if he wishes to correct me. But if one looks back to the 2022 elections, I think there were only three wards in the whole of England which delivered three councillors from three different parties, or independent parties. In 2026, there were actually three wards in Bradford alone that delivered three members from three different wards, let alone the rest of the country.

And I see him nodding, so I feel reassured that I've been pedantic and accurate enough. But that makes my point that the probability for recounts has risen dramatically in current circum- political circumstances. Whether that continues is another matter. But we really should allow the EROs and the local councils the capacity to decide, and decide sensibly, in relation to how they conduct the counts so that there are not errors. What is remarkable at the moment is that there are relatively few errors in local government elections, even where there are many, where there are recounts which have taken place many hours after the count has started, let alone election day has begun, which of course is many hours before that.

But having said that, in relation to disagreement with Lord Jackson on that particular amendment, I think it is important that I pick up on one or two other matters which he uh raised, which with which I would actually agree. He said, and I'm quoting here now, column 1449, that the objective of some of his amendments to rule and contributions was to restore confidence in the electoral process.

That is absolutely key in everything that we do on a daily basis. To be honest, in the complexity of which we now operate in this country, it is staggering that there aren't more errors. And I refer here to the Electoral Commission's report on the elections in May, which identified very few actual genuine errors. Um, but I still think it is important that everything we do in relation to this bill should actually be aimed at ensuring or restoring, depending on which is necessary, the public confidence in the electoral process. And it is both the public confidence and the candidates' confidence that we should give consideration to.

Lord Jackson also made reference to, and Baroness Thornhill is not here, but she gave strong support to amendments in relation to influencing voters through judicial through religious messaging. And I note that Lord Pickles is in his seat and of course he did a very thorough report in relation to a whole range of electoral issues. And this was addressed in the 2022 legislation. But I think it is worthwhile, and I know Lord Walney's in his seat and he's got an amendment, but unfortunately wasn't here previously. These things happen.

But I hope I am going down the path that he would have gone down, and that Baroness Thornhill did go down, saying that there are clearly issues that need to be addressed, need to be kept under consideration, and therefore they have to be reviewed on a regular basis to ensure that we are actually operating sensibly. And my apologies for a slight interruption, but I'm going to have to rest on a crutch for the rest of my contributions. Can I also draw attention to the other comments that Baroness Thornhill made in relation to intimidation and crowds outside polling stations, which does nothing for confidence in the electoral process? I shall be returning to this issue later on in relation to an amendment that I've got on polling issuing accreditation to tellers and the like, and the process of policing outside polling stations. But I would just identify in supporting what Baroness Thornhill referred to, that I don't know how many members of this place are actually aware of the fact that in the most recent parliamentary by-election, Holborn and St Pancras, there were so many crowds outside one polling station, and the presiding officer actually asked for these people to be moved to, and in the end, the agent of the Green Party had to come down and tell the people to move because they were effectively, being realistic, intimidating the voters outside the polling stations.

So this is a matter to which I shall return at a later stage, but I hope I've covered adequately at this stage the points, the different issues that are raised by the amendments that we're considering in this group.

01:07:39 - 01:09:53

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, I wonder if I can beg the

I wonder if I could I'd move the amendments. I wonder if I can beg the indulgence of the House just to conclude my remarks on 129. I did have to curtail them because of time on Monday, and I just wanted to make reference to what the noble my noble friend Lord Hayward has said, which was I was very grateful for the lived experience comments of Baroness Thornhill in Watford in supporting my amendment on undue influence. And I merely wanted to say, my Lords, that following the Pickles report, and I'm delighted that my noble friend is in his place, that steps were taken in the Elections Act of 2022 to strengthen the provision with regard to adding undue spiritual influence. But the review noted that, quote, "unacceptable activity which many people consider electoral fraud, including pressure and intimidation, both in the home and outside polling stations", as my noble friend Lord Hayward has said, "may not be reported by victims".

So this is a valuable provision in law. It's important that it is regularly reviewed by ministers to ensure that it is upheld properly and is up to date with the challenges of the UK's changing demographic and religious landscape, because without regular reviews and monitoring, such provisions risk stagnating or becoming subtly and consistently subverted. The law means nothing if it isn't enforced, and the Pickles review and recent legislative changes reflect the importance of the provision for UK election electoral integrity, and it's vital it is not diminished. And I look forward to hearing the minister's response, and I especially look forward to hearing the contribution of the noble Lord Walney, who I know wasn't present on Monday, and it was commented on from the Liberal Democrat benches, but I'm sure he'll explain that there was a perfectly good reason. And his amendment 136 and my amendment 129 are very similar, of course, and I thank the House for their indulgence.

01:09:53 - 01:10:00

Speaker 77

The Lord Walney wasn't here on the during the debate, so he can't speak.

01:10:00 - 01:10:49

Speaker 86

My Lords, I'd like to add the to the comments of the noble Lords, Lord Fuller and Lord Hayward, some of the practical implications of the of amendment 124. Now, I want to make very clear that like many people here today, I love an overnight count as much as everybody else. And I've been to more than I can remember, including, ironically as it happens, the count at which the minister, the noble Lord Wilson of Sedgefield was elected as a member of Parliament in 2007. And like so like everybody else, I understand that election nights are special and I understand the desire to preserve the excitement that comes with overnight counts as well as, for the broader public, a quick understanding of the implication of local election results for the country as a whole and what it means for the government of the day. But this amendment would not deliver that in practice.

01:10:49 - 01:11:29

Speaker 85

It requires only that verification begins on polling night, not that a single vote is actually so counted or a result declared. What it would do is remove a returning officer's ability to plan a count properly on those nights where, in practice, that judgment matters the most. So let me take a really extreme but real example. On the 6th of May 2021, voters in the village of Waterbeach in Cambridgeshire went to the polls to be handed five different ballot papers. They voted for their county councillor, for a district councillor in a by-election, in a parish council by-election, for the combined authority mayor and for the police and crime commissioner.

01:11:29 - 01:12:33

Speaker 84

Now, the law, as it stands, currently allows the returning officer to have ballot papers cast into either separate ballot boxes or into the same one for elections happening at the same time. And suppose the returning officer had, as they are permitted to do, provided a separate ballot box for each election, if this amendment were implemented, three of those five elections by would by law have to have begun their verification in the two hours between the close of poll and midnight. And as, you know, and the other two would not, but it is not uncommon for voters to put ballot papers into the wrong ballot box. So, in order to carry out the task on this in this complex scenario and to make sure that, for example, a parish council ballot paper sitting in the police and crime commissioner ballot box was found and properly included in the count, in effect, all five ballot boxes would have to have been opened before midnight in order for those counts to be completed in parallel. So, today a returning officer can use one trained team to verify each election in turn,

01:12:33 - 01:13:26

Speaker 85

whereas this amendment would force all five verifications to be to happen in parallel at the same time before midnight. That would mean more staff, more tables, more supervisors for already-pressed local authorities trying to run elections effectively. So, that would simply be impractical. The exemption that the noble Lord referred to does not help either because that covers emergencies and safety risks, it does not cover the ordinary, foreseeable complexity of running multiple elections on the same day using parallel or shared ballot boxes. And whilst this is this that Waterbeach example is an extreme example of what might happen, it is a real one that did actually happen in practice.

Returning officers are already accountable for how they run their counts and ultimately, as one of the previous speakers said, accurate order

01:13:26 - 01:13:46

Charles John Fuller

Would the noble I'd like to make a supportive comment in the sense that the Waterbeach example I used at second reading, because not only were there five different ballot papers, there were two or three different voting methods: first-past-the-post, STV, AMS, for the different mayoral and PCCs, and that adds a further complexity to, I think, the point he's trying to make.

01:13:46 - 01:14:09

Speaker 85

I'm very grateful for that additional point, yes. So, just to wrap up, returning officers are already accountable for how they run their counts and, ultimately, accuracy matters more than speed. So, however much we love a traditional election night, we should not allow that desire to impose unworkable or unnecessarily restrictive practices on already-stretched returning officers.

01:14:09 - 01:17:21

David Frost

Hear. My Lords, I put my name to amendment 124 in the name of Lord Jackson. I just want to explain why and maybe bring one element into this debate that we haven't had so far, which is the voters and how they perceive the electoral process in local elections. And, of course, it is quite a recent development that counts have drifted into the next day. It's really only from the late 2000s in local elections, and we did seem to manage this situation perfectly well before that.

Certainly, elections have got more complicated since then, as many noble Lords have noted, but nevertheless, we did seem to do it, and it's not an inherently implausible suggestion that we might be able to do it again. I do think that in UK elections, there is a sense of drama, and that sense of drama is important, that something significant is changing as a result of this ballot. The drama of democracy is quite important. And that is, of course, more true at general elections, but it's something I think we shouldn't lose in local elections, which also have in many ways just as big an effect on people's lives as general elections. Now, on Monday, the noble Lady Baroness Thornhill said, and I quote, "The main beneficiaries of immediate counts are not the voters, but the campaigners, the candidates and the commentators."

And that struck me as an interesting comment because I'm not sure I entirely agree with it. Speaking as somebody who has seen elections on TV and listened on the radio far more than I've actually participated in them, one of the things that has struck me with our longer counting process is that it allows much more opportunity for political parties and the party leadership and party-aligned commentators to spin the results. Long before we know what the actual results of a whole period of local elections are, we have media comment on them. We have party spokesmen telling us how to interpret these results long before we know what the actual results are. One or two councils take exaggerated significance because they're they come relatively early in the sequence and shape the narrative.

And I think that suits political parties. I'm not making a party-political point in the sense that I think it's true of all parties. It blurs what is important. It allows scope for commentary. It allows scope for spin.

And the actual results of this process take longer to come out. By the time we know the results, the what is more important is the nature of the commentary. So, I do think there's an issue here. I'm happy to give way, please.

01:17:21 - 01:18:04

Robert Hayward

my noble friend sits down, he's not addressed the issue of the extra matters which we give local voters the opportunity on which to vote now. He refers to 2000, but in fact, in the previous Conservative government and before that, we introduced things like environmental neighborhood referenda, mayoral elections, police and crime commissioner elections. I'm not going to delay the House by going on listing them all, but that is one of the reasons why, as was identified, you finish up with people being asked to vote on three, four, or five different occasions on one day.

01:18:04 - 01:19:30

David Frost

The noble lord makes a very good point, of course, and it has been touched on already that the situation is much more complicated than it used to be, but I don't think those practical angles to this can be the only thing that is brought into the debate. We have to remember what we're doing here. We are marking, achieving through democracy, a shift in political power potentially from one set of people to another. And how that is accomplished, how people see it happening, what the media discussion of that is I think just as important. It shouldn't be neglected when we consider how local elections are conducted.

And that balance, I think, is important, and of course different authorities can reach different judgments on that balance, and the noble Lord Jackson's amendment, as he noted, allows for that balance to be reached in certain cases, but we mustn't forget it. These are elections about the shift of power, and administrative convenience and bureaucratic convenience, how it's done, can't be the only determining factor. We have to think about what's happening here, and that's why I think the noble Lord Jackson's amendment deserves discussion and support.

01:19:30 - 01:25:16

Speaker 32

My Lords, I will start with a different amendment in this group, amendment 123 on the issue of poll cards because I think they are probably a topic that is well suited to the sort of scrutiny that we rightly pride ourselves on in this House, in that it is a niche issue and a serious issue, but also not, I will concede, the largest of issues. But I don't think we should be too blasé about the issue, even though it is not the largest of issues, because a very considerable amount of money is spent on the production and distribution of poll cards. In the second half of 2019, for example, £19 million was spent. And so, that's excluding the local and European elections that year, just the general election. So, there are millions of pounds spent each year on poll cards.

And yet, I think it's fair to say if any of us was involved in a recruitment process for a graphic designer, and they were to show us as a pride of the main item in their portfolio a modern poll card, we would quite rapidly be thinking, "How can we bring this interview to an end?" Because clearly it's not very good. Now, in fairness, one should say everyone involved in the process has a really good alibi as to why it's not their fault because there is a complex interaction of legislative requirements, IT systems and their capabilities, time pressures on returning of yet, all of those interact, everyone can say, "It's not my fault." But the reality is, we spend millions and millions of pounds every year on something that we all know when we look at is not very good. And we should also bear in mind that it is the one official communication that all everyone on the electoral register receives about the election, if that is, as it were, the front door, the shop window of democracy to voters.

It is both a poor use of money, but actually slightly embarrassing in terms of how we present democracy to people. So, I hope we will hear some positive noises from the noble Lady the Minister in due course on amendment 123. And I certainly welcome the fact that elsewhere in the bill, some of the proposed proposals in the bill will simplify the legislative framework underpinning poll cards, and will make it easier to improve their design in future. Turning then to the issue that has taken up most of our time on this group this morning, and I, as with others, admire the irony of the timing that we are debating whether or not counts should be overnight on a morning when I think many of us would have rather that we have been able to stay up rather later to watch the elections from the US. And I think there is an important lesson, actually, from those elections in the US, which is that we shouldn't underestimate the importance of speedy election counts in terms of giving confidence in the security of the system.

I mean, thankfully, in Britain, those concerns broadly speaking are a long way in the past. But you know, that the reason we have that the system that where it used to be the norm that just about everything was counted overnight was because of the fear that what will happen with ballot boxes, what will be interfered with them. And I don't think we should be blasé about the risk of those fears in the future. But, as several noble Lords including Lord Hayward and Lord McFall of pointed out, there are significant good practical reasons why overnight counts are not always possible, and indeed in some cases, would be so in- difficult to practically organise that one would even go so far as to say in some occasions, overnight counts are not even desirable. So while I very much sympathise with the thrust of Lord Jackson's amendment, I think a sort of central top-down mandate in the way that it suggests is not the right way to progress on that.

But to speak more positively about a couple of the other amendments in this group including one from Lord Jackson, amendments 12 125 and 128, I think their proposals are very welcome.

I think we saw in our discussions on in the first day of committee, the value of election pilots. In this case, we were of several references were made to the pilots that have been carried out in Wales around automatic voter registration. And I think those pilots do properly inform our decision making. I think it's fair to say the election pilots on other topics that we've had so far have not been hugely successful. There seems to be a relatively small number of ideas which are regularly piloted and never turn out to be particularly effective.

So, I think the spirit of amendments 125 and 128 is very welcome and I hope we may hear in due course from the government also a willingness to be a little bit more imaginative about what is piloted. And if I may just throw in one example of what I mean is if you look at the academic research at turnout in local elections, the evidence is pretty strong that if you have to walk more than 600 m to your polling station, turnout drops quite significantly at local elections. There are different possible ways of piloting having more polling stations so fewer people have to travel long distances to polling stations, which is the sort of slightly more imaginative approach to piloting I hope we can hear in the future. And then, just finally on amendments 129 and 136, I have very little to add to what my colleague, Baroness Thornhill, spoke very eloquently about on this and indeed others have contributed on today, other than simply to add, I think it's fair to say, as we saw for example with the Gorton and Denton by-election, there are significant differences of view about exactly what the scale and nature may be of the problems that these amendments seek to address. But it seems to me that is a good reason to want to face up to that, to want to have a good evidence base and careful consideration rather than simply to ignore the issue completely.

01:25:16 - 01:31:24

Gerard James Jamieson

Thank you, my Lords. First of all, I must declare my interest as a councillor in Central Bedfordshire. My Lords, I'm grateful to my noble friend, Lady Coffey, Lord Jackson, for their amendments and also the amendments from other noble Lords. These do raise important questions about the safeguards and necessary to maintain public confidence in our electoral system, and I would echo the comments of my noble friend, Lord Hayward, that the objective of this should be to increase public confidence in the electoral system. Lady Coffey's amendments 10 and 11 concern the exemptions applying to younger electors in relation to duties of election and electoral registration officers.

These amendments highlight a wider question about consistency in the government's approach to lowering the voting age and the need to ensure accuracy of the register. As my noble friend, Lady O'Neill of Bexley, observed at second reading, the government must explain where we draw the line between the rights and responsibilities of 16 and 17 year olds. If young people are to be entrusted with electing their representatives, it is reasonable to examine how that decision interacts with existing duties and protections in electoral law. As was made clear by the noble Baroness the minister in debates on Monday, EROs are responsible for ensuring the accuracy of the register. Should not the same tools be available to an ERO irrespective of age?

Can the noble Baroness the minister explain the rationale behind retaining these exemptions? Have electoral administrators been consulted about the practical implications? Now as I said at second reading, electoral law is already overly complex and conflicting. We should be seeking opportunities to simplify its administration rather than further increasing inconsistencies. I turn to the amendments tabled by my

Oops. That's gone out, but never mind.

I turn to the amendments tabled by my noble friend Lord Jackson of Peterborough and Lord Frost and the noble Lord Raynard and the noble Baroness Lady Thornhill. Amendment 125 seeks to pilot schemes for more flexible voting including early voting, mobile polling stations and alternative voting locations. Such pilots have already been undertaken locally. Amendment 128 raises the question of piloting electronic voting machines. Our established paper-based system has considerable advantage in being straightforward and transparent.

Electronic systems always raise the issue of cyber security as we have seen with the single patient record in the Health Bill. Can the noble Baroness the Minister tell us what assessment the government have made of the security risks associated with electronic voting machines, and how will the accuracy of an electric count be independently demonstrated and verified? On the topic we have debated a lot this morning, my noble friend Lord Jackson's amendment 124, that counting should begin on the day of the election. Now having stood as a candidate on many occasions, I have great sympathy with this, and I would like to know sooner rather than later. However, as a previous leader of a council, I also have to agree with the comments of my many other noble Lords in this chamber about the difficulties and the complexities of doing a count.

And I would say, as has been raised by a number, that local council elections are frequently much more complex than a national election, with multi-member wards, an increasing diversity of candidates, making the process longer and more complex, the potential for multiple elections on the same day. And at the same time, many councils are finding it increasingly difficult to get sufficient staff, a matter that has been raised elsewhere in this bill. Ultimately, I believe we need to trust the ERO to make the appropriate decision. My noble friend Lord Jackson's amendment 129 and the noble Lord Walney's amendment concern undue influence, religious or spiritual pressure on voters. My Lords, the secrecy of the ballot is fundamental.

Every elector must be able to vote freely, without intimidation, coercion, or improper influence. And I appreciate the comments of many noble Lords on this and so far there seems to be consensus that this is a very important topic and that these amendments are need addressing. At second reading, my noble friend Lord Udny-Lister raised concerns about family voting and the particular vulnerability of younger electors to pressure they might face at home. These concerns deserve careful consideration as the government proposes to extend the franchise. Does the noble Baroness the Minister consider existing law sufficient to protect voters from coercion both in polling stations and where postal voting is used?

And is it not just the law, sorry, and it is not just the law, but the implementation thereof that is important, will there be further guidance given to polling staff? This also relates to amendment 123 in the name of the noble Lord Pack, and the noble Baroness Lady Pinnock on improving poll polling cards, ensuring eligible voters understand the secrecy of their ballot and understand the voting process is crucial. My Lords, we should remember that those responsible for administering elections must make these provisions work in practice. The robustness of our electoral arrangements is fundamental to electoral integrity. I hope the Minister will address the concerns raised in this group and explain how the government intend to preserve the security and transparency of the ballot while avoiding unnecessary complexity.

01:31:24 - 01:39:48

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I'm grateful for this extended debate, or should I say broken debate, in the middle of the group. Can I just make a couple of general points before I go on to responding to individual amendments? First of all, to the noble Lord Hayward, I'm very grateful to him for using his crutch to stand up. If he does wish to remain seated when he makes his contributions, I'm sure the House would be very happy with that. It's on the comments that the noble Lord Pack made about the very interesting situation that we saw unveiling in the United States overnight.

I agree with him: it would have been very nice to have been able to stay up and listen to those results. I didn't, but I was very tempted to do so. And these It does point to some very interesting issues as we discuss this debate, which contains issues that go right to the very heart of our democracy. And some of the comments made early this morning by, for example, James Talarico about attempts at enormous financial influence and other influence in the elections process. We'll come on to some of those later in the discussion of our own bill.

And I It was a pleasure to see the power of the democratic process overcoming something of that. And I think we need to make sure, as we go through our own discussions, that we retain that faith in democracy, and that we continue, as Lord Hayward said, to give the people of this country the confidence that it is the democratic process that takes precedence, even where there are attempts to have financial and other interference. It's very important to all of us in this House. I would also like to—and it was mentioned in the earlier session on this group. Thank you.

Excuse my sniffles. This is the second cold in two weeks, and I think I'm going to have to speak to my friend, the health Minister, to say that you are banned from having a second two colds in two weeks. I wanted to add my tribute to the EROs and the election staff, because we do have a very safe and secure system in this country, and that is down to a lot of work from our returning officers and our election staff, so I'm very grateful to them for all the work they do. Now to address the individual amendments, my Lords. Turning first to the amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Coffey, Amendments 10 10 and 11 and Schedule 1 stand part.

These amendments would remove measures in Schedule 1 that safeguard under-16-year-olds. This would result in electoral registration officers, or EROs, being required to conduct activities such as house-to-house inquiries and making telephone calls to under-16s. And I would say to the noble Lord Fuller that of election administrators are included in Or was it noble Lord Jackson, sorry. Election administrators are included in these discussions. But these age-based measures are important for implementing the franchise change effectively.

In extending the right to vote to 16 and 17-year-olds, it is vital that they are given the same opportunities to be accurately registered as any other voter. The bill provides for people to register to vote from the age of 14 so they are ready to cast their first vote at the age of 16. This arrangement will bring significant benefits, but it must be accompanied with additional measures to protect these young people who are not yet entitled to vote. This is the approach taken throughout the bill, including measures to safeguard young people's data, which are contained in clauses 7 to 13 of the bill. And this does mirror the approach taken in Scotland and Wales.

We should take the safeguarding of those under the age of 16 seriously, and these amendments would remove safeguards that we consider vital. I must emphasize to noble Lords that it is not those of voting age who are being treated differently, but those below voting age, and for those reasons we cannot support these amendments. I thank the noble Lord Pannick, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, for raising the important issue of how electoral information is communicated to voters in amendment 123. We agree that the information provided to electors should be clear and accessible, and I take on board Lord Pannick's comments about polling cards. We have already recognized there is scope to improve election documentation, including poll cards, and we intend to consider how their design and clarity can be enhanced as part of wider research into how people learn about the electoral process.

However, we don't believe a statutory requirement to report to Parliament within 12 months is necessary to take this work forward. Frankly, we just need to get on with it, and I'm very happy to report back to the House when we've concluded our work. In relation to the to amendment 124 from the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough, and the noble Lord Frost, of course, as someone who was elected over many times over the over 27 years, I recognize the importance of election results being declared promptly, and I've much sympathy with what the noble Lord Jamieson, said about this. We all want to hear our results as quickly as possible. Local elections take place, as noble Lords have highlighted very graphically, I don't need to give any further examples, and, as such, require greater operational flexibility than parliamentary elections.

Decisions about when to begin verification and counting are therefore best made by returning officers, taking account of those local circumstances. This amendment would replace that operational judgment with a rigid statutory requirement, subject only to narrow exceptions for emergencies and safety risks. We do not believe that restriction is necessary or proportionate. The noble Lord Fuller, under this amendment, raised some issues around different elections on different systems. I would say to him, I do recognize the fact there was a referendum in 2011 on different voting systems.

The Prime Minister's decided the best way to take this issue forward is to initiate a national commission on electoral reform, which is the right way to start a national conversation on this issue. In terms of amendment 125 from the noble Lord Rennard, and Baroness Thornhill, Section 10 of the Representation of the People Act 2000 already provides powers to pilot changes to when, where and how voting takes place at local government elections, powers the Government has used to pilot flexible voting in the May 2026 polls and which we will use again in the further round of pilots in May 2027. We understand the amendment seeks to go further by enabling flexible voting to be piloted at elections beyond those currently provided for under Section 10, potentially including UK parliamentary elections. We do not believe it would be appropriate to extend the piloting power to parliamentary elections at this stage. Our priority is to continue testing these approaches at local elections and build that evidence base before considering any wider changes.

However, I share their enthusiasm for more modern and flexible voting arrangements as a matter of principle, but I do think it's important that we test these thoroughly and build the evidence base before we go any further. On this theme, I also thank the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough, for his amendment 128. However, the use of electronic voting machines creates the potential for hacking, computer error and interference. Elections are no-fail events. Well, at least they are in terms of process, anyway.

They should be no-fail, they're not always for candidates, we do fail from time to time, I have on occasions myself. But in terms of process, they must be no-fail events, and the integrity of the ballot must come first.

And that's why we have no plans to introduce electronic voting in the UK. As such, it does not make sense to run pilots. My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough, and I will address the noble Lord Walney's amendments, as he's in the chamber today as well. Apologies.

01:39:48 - 01:40:20

Robert Hayward

Minister, for giving way, and particularly I thank her for her very generous comments at the start of her contribution. But can I just ask in relation to Lord Pack and Baroness Thornhill's amendments, something I omitted to have observed, is that when reviews do take place in relation to pilots, that cost should be considered, because obviously if one's taking trials over a period of days, there are all sorts of attendant costs as whether as well as whether the system actually worked.

01:40:20 - 01:42:14

Jane Sharon Taylor

Yes, the noble Lord's quite right, and any assessment of pilots must take cost into account as well. In relation to the amendments from the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough and Lord Walney at 129 and 136, we do, it's been good to have the opportunity to consider this important and sensitive issue. Our electoral law must protect voters from coercion and undue pressure, while ensuring that faith leaders and communities remain free to express their religious and moral views and participate fully in our democratic life. I understand the noble Lord Jackson's wish to ensure that the provisions relating to spiritual injury and undue spiritual pressure continue to strike that very careful balance and remain clear and workable for faith communities, campaigners and voters alike. Examples of what constitutes undue pressure have been provided in the explanatory notes to the Elections Act 2022, and I hope I can offer some reassurance that the Government continuously keeps electoral law under review, including to ensure that it remains effective, proportionate and responsive to evidence about how it operates in practice, but setting out a requirement for a review in statute is unnecessary.

On the noble Lord Walney's Amendment 136, as I'm sure he will be aware, spiritual injury and undue spiritual pressure are already capable of falling within the undue influence offence in Section 114A of the Representation of the People Act 1983. We do not consider a separate polling station offence necessary. Undue influence is already unlawful wherever it occurs, and the focus should remain on the coercive behavior itself, rather than creating a separate offence based on proximity to a polling station.

01:42:14 - 01:42:44

Anne Thérèse Coffey

My Lords, I'd like to thank a number of the peers who spoke in this quite wide-ranging group. Obviously, I'm slightly disappointed in what the minister said to mine. I just hope there is a way that electoral registration officers can follow up on the integrity of the register as soon as somebody does become 16 to check it's valid. But while there's a whole range of things which have been considered, with that, I beg leave to withdraw my Amendment number 10.

01:42:44 - 01:43:27

Speaker 56

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. Amendment 11 not moved. Amendment 12, already debated, moved formally. The question is that Amendment 12 be agreed to.

As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content. The contents have it. The question is that Schedule 1, as amended, be the first schedule to the bill. As many of that opinion will say content.

The contrary, not content. The contents have it. Clause 7, Amendment 13, Lord Hayward.

01:43:27 - 01:52:39

Robert Hayward

My Lords, I hope, first of all, that I can please the government whip by indicating that, although I've tabled a few amendments in relation to one particular aspect of this group, I could have tabled literally dozens of amendments on this subject. And the subject was possibly best described by what one might describe as a half-Irish lyricist who was brought up in inner south London who, when he spoke to this chamber four years ago, said, "I hope that when we get a new prime minister, they will look at the whole issue of electoral law." That half-Irish lyricist from just south of the river was, of course, the noble Lord Kennedy, making an observation in relation to the Ballot Secrecy Bill, and I have given him notice that I intended to quote from his speech on that occasion this morning. But the amendment, the first amendment in this group, clause amendment 13, if one looks at the page of clause seven, the one amendment that I've tabled there in clause and on amendment 13 runs for a whole page. We have to look at a string of pieces of legislation, many of which were introduced by my government and previous governments.

But it has been a clear fact for years that our electoral law is a complete mess and is in desperate need of consolidation into one act. Page after page of this bill is only just referring to one piece of legislation or another piece of legislation, or yet another piece of legislation. I can understand if one was dealing, as Lord Deben referred on Monday, to devolved powers, and therefore devolved legislation. But in far too many cases, that is not the case. We just have what I would best describe as a complete cacophony of electoral law.

And if we think it's a mess, just imagine the sets of circumstances under which the returning officers have to operate, because whereas we can spread out our discussions in relation to electoral law over a number of days, the returning officers are operating particularly when they don't have notice of an election, i.e., a general election. They are working under extreme pressure. And it really is astonishing that actually we have fewer cases, that we have so few cases, where an error is made in one form or another. Just think of what we've just been talking about, whether it or have will be talking about, whether it's postal votes, whether it's entitlement to vote from abroad, whether it's actually registration of votes, whatever it may happen to be. We the poor returning officers are looking at this on an hour-by-hour, day-by-day basis.

And it is truly astonishing that we do not get petitions asking for re- that matters do not go to the elections court challenging the result in one form or another.

And I've paid credit to returning officers again previously, but I will do so again on this occasion. But as I say, there are many amendments that I could have put down which I chose not to. In relation to the other broad category of amendments, this is where I do think we have a serious problem. And I would ask, when the minister comes to reply, for her to clearly identify why on earth we actually need all these amendments that say instead of a registration officer, we have a senior registration officer, or we have to ensure that councils call in every possible officer to administer the elections. I'll come back to that in a minute.

But we are talking here about devolution. This government, one of its great mantras is, "We must devolve powers." The Prime Minister went to Lanarkshire the other week to tell the Scots that they're not devolving powers enough. The minister herself earlier this week started off comments in relation to column 1407, "As we extend the devolution program, this government has made it clear that we think it should be the people with the skin in the game that in the local area who take the key decisions about those areas. It is perfectly right that each of the governments around the UK are free to do what they feel is right."

If we are devolving powers to local councils, how is it that clause after clause tells the local council what role and what status the registration officer should hold within a local council? Birmingham City Council, the chief executive is paid £300,000 a year. Surely he knows better than the minister and officials in Whitehall as to who should be deputed to handle what aspect of elections is their responsibility. It's true throughout the land that we have highly paid chief executive officers, one after another, and yet Whitehall seems to think that they know best as to how an administration an election should be administered. Now, I could understand if there had been a whole series of elections that had gone wrong.

But I refer again to the Electoral Commission's report on the general election. There's not one reference to a general election going wrong. In the local elections, there are one or two very minor exceptions. So, why should it be, and I genuinely believe this is Whitehall dictating utterly unnecessarily to local councils who should handle what? And the amendment that the section of the bill that astonishes me most is the clause where it says that the council should require all its councils officers, whatever they may happen to be, is implicit in the phrasing of the bill, should be called on to administer elections.

Now are we going to insert in an election in an education bill that every member of a council, employee of a council should be called to help with education, or that every employee of a council should be called on to help on environmental matters, or hygiene matters, or whatever it may happen to be? There is no justification. Given that we have not got a failed electoral system, we have an extremely challenging one, but we do not have a failed electoral system, I can see no reason whatsoever why the series of clauses, series of sub-clauses are in the bill which suggest that Whitehall knows best. Can I, my Lord in, my Lords in conclusion, make the observation: I refer to the Prime Minister going to Lanarkshire to deliver his message on devolution.

I would suggest that he goes to Marsham Street and delivers the same message in relation to this bill. And in conclusion, can I beg to move Amendment 13?

01:52:39 - 01:52:46

Speaker 92

Amendment proposed: Clause 7, page 10, line 23, leave out subsection brackets 4.

01:52:46 - 01:54:38

Speaker 95

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Hayward. I sort of woke up this morning thinking, I would love to quote Martin Luther King that I had a dream. The position is that, if we just tiny bit of history, Representation of the People Act 1983 is the core bit of legislation that everything has sprung from. It is 18 years from that in 1983 till the creation of the Electoral Commission. And I think maybe others, were involved in the creation of the Electoral Commission in 2001.

We are now in 2026. It is 43 years since the Representation of the People Act 1983 came into being. There have been repeated amendments, additions, election administration act, the elections bill, etc. I mean we're getting to a point now, to be able to move the election law anywhere, you need a pickup truck. It is completely crackers that we're in this situation.

And what I pray for, yes, my noble friend is showing that, believe me, it's about 10 times that amount, Lord Hayward. But the most important thing that Lord Hayward stepped on is consolidation. And I've discussed this with others, including my noble friend the minister, the possibility of that. And it is a major undertaking. But there's a new kid on the block, and that is AI.

We must get to a situation where we could probably do this, because it is impossible to operate. And I should have declared my interest as a former election lawyer to the Labour Party for many years. And having to deal with this legislation is very difficult, and you can miss things out very easily. So, my plea is to the minister, take it away to the officials, so that my dream can actually come true and we'll have a bit of consolidation within the RPA. Thank you.

01:54:38 - 01:57:16

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, I'd like to support the comments made by my noble friend Lord Hayward and also Lord Shamash, because we've heard in this debate, such as it is, that this bill, as it's been considered so far, that we need a consolidation, and the points made by Lord Shamash are very persuasive. But not only do we not have a consolidation, this bill contains all sorts of contradictory provisions, there's inconsistencies. I can't wait to see what the government amendments are going to be, and I'm sure there'll be several groups of them. Almost impossible duties are being placed on electoral registration staff and returning officers to make quite detailed judgments without the benefit of documentary evidence. A lot of it hasn't been thought through.

But my main point is, as complicated as the situation is today, so much is still to be done through secondary legislation.

For goodness sakes, there is a fundamental conflict of interest asking ministers to change the legislation on the basis upon which they themselves are elected to suit themselves without Parliament scrutinising the detail. I don't deny that secondary legislation has a role in all walks of life and all a lot of the work in which Your Lordship's House considers, but on democracy, which is the foundation of our society, the law should be clear in primary legislation, not so much left for ministers to say, because otherwise it isn't just that the Government has a lack of trust in us, in turn, the voters have a lack of trust in the Parliament who can't be trusted to sort it out and be clear and to make the public, the electors' voices heard. And if there's a lack of trust there, then democracy is in peril. So, I strongly support my noble friend and that of Lord Premach in their claim that, actually, we should bring this together. This bill is, as thick as it is, fails to address the fundamental problem and especially in a world of AI and all and the complexity of the electoral system, which I will not dwell upon again.

01:57:16 - 01:57:22

Speaker 94

I strongly support my noble friend.

01:57:22 - 01:59:26

Speaker 32

My Lords, I think this may be the group on which we have the most widespread agreement from all corners of the House. I very much agree with the broad thrust of the comments from all three of the noble Lords who have spoken so far. And just to give one further illustration, in preparing my sort of ring binder of things that I thought might be useful to have with me during the committee stage, I thought, well, it might be useful to print off a copy of the 1983 Representation of the People Act or the 2000 PPERA Act, the two primary bits of legislation that we will be, hopefully, amending through this legislation. I dutifully downloaded the PDFs for both of them from the legislation.gov.uk. One comes in at 543 pages, the other at 524 pages, which I made about the length of the last copy I saw of War and Peace.

So, I did decide not to print those off. But it does illustrate this problem that was quite rightly touched on earlier about how many staff and volunteers have to grapple with understanding large parts of what is a very complex legal landscape. And I wouldn't want to disappoint the noble Lord Hayward, by not, however, taking the chance to quibble just a little over a couple of his specific amendments in this group, because, actually, the noble Lord's Lord amendment number 16 would remove a cross reference, and actually, I would go the other way, I would say we need more cross references in legislation. But he, I think, is absolutely right with amendment number 17 and the way it I'm sure there is some fine, legal brain in this House who will be able to elucidate why the definition in that is referred to in amendment 17 is not simply a rearranging of the words. It does seem to me that definition adds very little meaning.

But, overall, I think it is welcome that we have seen in one of the more recent government amendments tabled for this bill a tidying up by the proposal to repeal some previously uncommenced legislation, and I hope the debate on this group will encourage the Government to look at further steps of tidying up as we progress through the other groups on this bill.

01:59:26 - 02:03:56

Gerard James Jamieson

My Lords, I am going to be part of the agreement across this House on this one. And I am grateful that my noble friend Lord Hayward for introducing these amendments, and I will agree with all of them, as a point of principle, to be slightly different to Lord Pack.

You know, we need this debate on the complexity of electoral law and administrative bureaucracy, and I'd like to echo the words of the noble Baroness about recognizing and thanking electoral returning officers for their job. It isn't an easy job, as various noble Lords have made clear. Dealing with all the legislation, I think noble Lord Pack added up just over 1100 pages on just two bills. They are long, they complex, they're inconsistent, on occasion they are in conflict,

the electoral returning officers are having to deal with regular new regulation and guidance and changes. It's a surprise that anybody actually wants the job. And then there is not just dealing with this, but the sheer difficulty of running an operation. You may be dealing with 200-plus polling stations. You're having to make sure that you get all your polling booths there, you're having to send out thousands of postal votes and relying on the postal system, which in itself always has a potential for error.

And you have to make decisions on the spot in order to overcome all these various things. I do find then to go into prescribing, as the noble Lord Hayward has said, exactly how someone is supposed to do the job, who is supposed to be doing the job in the council, and as the noble Lord Hayward raised that specific point about requiring all staff to be made available. You know, what happens if all staff are not willing to be made available? What sanction can the chief executive have?

Is it going to be part of their work contract and needing them to be made available potentially for another neighboring authority who needs more people? My Lords, the system works, the EROs get the job done, it's a difficult job. As I said in my previous speech, let's trust them.

And I'll just go through some of these amendments. Beginning with amendment to clause 7 that is in the bill, subsection 4, later reiterated in clause 14, goes on to define absent voter records, overseas elector lists, overseas electors declaration, registration officer, and voter registers. Subsection 5 then clarifies the roles of a deputy electoral registration officer, and a person assisting the electoral registration officer. And my noble friend has already raised concerns over how other Whitehall departments determine this. I can go on through all the various clauses,

and that's before I get on to the clauses in which my noble friend has opposed in an order to prompt this debate. It is clear that our electoral system, local government, and layers of administrative bureaucracy are complex. My Lords, we're fortunate to live in a parliamentary democracy, to work in a system which has evolved relatively organically over time. And so, some legal complexity is perhaps expected. However, we're concerned that some provisions in this bill, rather than seeking to improve the situation, risk increasing the bureaucracy and practical complexity unnecessarily.

I won't go through this all, but it is very clear from across this House that the bill is overly complex, adds complexity, and is not doing what it should do, which is making life simpler, more certain.

I hope the noble Baroness, the minister, will take on board some of the recommendations made by noble Lords of how and where electoral law and administration could be made a little less complex without weakening the system's strength, especially at the local level. In fact, by increasing consistency and simplifying where appropriate, it will strengthen the system. Perhaps the noble Baroness, the minister, can give an indication of what further government amendments your House can expect. Sorry, that Lordships' House can expect.

02:03:56 - 02:10:16

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'm very grateful for that debate. It's been very interesting subject to discuss. And knowing the noble Lord Hayward, I'm sure he will have equally lobbied his own side on these issues before this bill came into the House. This is the first election law I've dealt with, but I'm sure all of the legislation that's gone through in the last in the previous 14 years, he will have been urging his own side to consider these issues. Of course, this bill came forward to serve three very specific purposes.

One was to introduce voting for 16- and 17-year-olds, which is a manifesto commitment from my party, to look at taking the steps towards automatic voter registration, to tackle the issues of under-registration of around 7 to 8 million people. And lastly, some of the steps to tackle overseas political finance. During the course of the bill, some of those issues have been subjects of much public debate. And of course we've had the Rycroft review of political finance, which has added to the bill. And there will be further amendments.

They will be laid, I think, on the 9th of November, so the noble Lord Jamieson's request, he will have sight of amendments then before we get to the second stage of committee on this debate on this bill. In terms of the consolidation of electoral law, it's a very key issue. And I've heard loud and clear, both at second reading and in the engagement meetings that I've held with noble Lords, the importance of doing this. In the process of this bill, it's not possible to tackle the whole consolidation of all the election law. I'm sure it's even more than the number of pages that the noble Lord Pannick, outlined.

However, I do think it's important we take that on board and we look at what the process is going to be for what certainly is a job that needs to be done. I'm going to take that back to the department, and I will, at a later stage of the bill, come back on that if that's all right, because I understand what noble Lords are saying. Can I also say I took the comments of the noble Lord Hayward, about read-only access to registers, which he made during a previous session, very seriously. I've pushed for more information on this. There are some complexities around the localized nature of the register.

In effect, we have 300 separate electoral registers, and I know that's probably the point that the noble Lord was making, and around data protection, but I will do some more work on this, and I'm happy to discuss it with him further in due course. I recognize the broader concerns the noble Lord has around the complexity of electoral law and the administrative burdens which are placed on those responsible for delivering our elections. However, removing important provisions which contain essential legal definitions from the bill, which his amendments do introduce, I don't believe is the right way to address either of those concerns. The legal definitions in particular clarify the scope of the provisions so that it is clear who is captured by the provisions, namely registration officers and those assisting registration officers, and confirming that the measures do not attach to absent voting lists, which only relate to devolved elections. These clauses are not unnecessary additions; they contain substantive measures designed to improve the operation of our electoral system, as well as definitional information to aid the proper interpretation and application of the law.

The noble lord asked me some very specific questions around the measures on electoral registration officers and returning officers. Electoral registration officers and returning officers carry personal, legal responsibility for functions fundamental to the effective operation of our democracy. Discharging those responsibilities requires access to staff, premises, systems and other resources from across the local authority, often within tightly prescribed statutory timetables and during periods of considerable operational pressure. Requiring ultimate responsibility to rest with an appropriately senior officer will help ensure that the office-holder has sufficient organisation-wide authority and accountability to secure the necessary support and provide effective oversight. This is a proportionate safeguard to ensure that returning officers have the authority and access to resources they need to run elections effectively.

It provides a clear minimum standard while, of course, leaving local authorities the flexibility over who they appoint within that framework. Of course, the House will have the opportunity to debate all the measures in the bill as it progresses. The government will continue to make its case for each of them, but I can assure the noble lord, I am listening carefully to all views expressed in the House. I thank the noble lord for his proposed clause stand part on Clause 44, and I want to just explain briefly the importance of this clause to the bill. At present, political parties cannot withdraw their support for a candidate once the nomination papers have been submitted, even where serious issues arise.

Clause 44 enables parties to act where concerns arise during the nomination period. The scope of the provisions is very carefully limited. Support may be withdrawn only up to 48 hours before nominations close, ensuring the candidate still has time to stand independently or for another party, and the party can nominate a replacement. This clause forms part of a suite of new safeguards designed to protect the integrity of elections and prevent and deter personation or false nominations, and removing it would weaken the bill. As I said, I have listened carefully to the debates, particularly around consolidation of election law, and I'm very happy to continue those discussions.

02:10:16 - 02:10:41

Robert Hayward

defer her comments in general and I do want to continue with the conversation, but before she sits down, can I just seek clarification in relation to the last comments that she made about the particular clause? Are they fully are her comments fully supported by both the Electoral Commission and the AEA on behalf of returning officers?

02:10:41 - 02:10:57

Jane Sharon Taylor

My understanding is that the EC and the Association of Electoral Officers was consulted on all is consulted on provisions in the bill. So, but I will go back and check that, and I'll answer him in writing, if that's all right.

02:10:57 - 02:11:34

Robert Hayward

Lord, I've heard some interesting comments from the minister and, as I indicated just now, I intend to, I appreciate the offer that she's made to have further conversations in relation to the specific matters. I think we all knew that, on the question of consolidation, sadly we're going to have to live with Encyclopædia Britannica, whether it's on AI or any other system for the future, but it is grotesquely challenging for everybody that's involved. But on that basis, I beg leave to withdraw.

Thank you.

02:11:34 - 02:12:34

Speaker 97

Is it your pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn?

The amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. Amendment 14, Lord Hayward, not moved. The question is that Clause 7 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not-content".

The Contents have it. In Clause 8, Lord Hayward, amendment 15, not moved. The question is that Clause 8 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not-content".

The Contents have it. The question is that Clauses 9 to 13 inclusive stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not-content". The Contents have it.

In Clause 14, amendments 16 and 17, Lord Hayward, not moved. The question is that Clause 14 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not-content". The Contents have it.

02:12:34 - 02:13:01

Speaker 99

My Lords, I beg to move that the House be resumed. We will then move to lunch break business. We will therefore not return to the bill before one hour, 15 minutes from now. However, to clarify, that will not cut short the debate of 90 minutes for the SI, that's just in the event in case it finishes before and we would resume at the committee business.

02:13:01 - 02:13:19

Speaker 98

The question is that the House be now resumed. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not-content". The Contents have it.

02:13:20 - 02:13:38

Speaker 97

Order. Order. Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions Regulations 2026, Lord Wood of Anfield.

02:13:38 - 02:14:24

Wood

Excuse me. My Lords, I beg to move that the House approve the Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions Regulations 2026. These revoke and reenact with expanded purposes and designations criteria the Global Human Rights Sanctions Regulations 2020. This instrument was laid on the 13th of October under powers in the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act, SAMLA, 2018. The measures in this instrument, subject to the made affirmative parliamentary procedure, entered into force on 15th of October.

02:14:24 - 02:20:54

Speaker 101

My Lords, since coming into office, the Foreign Secretary has been clear that we will be stronger in our values, bolder in our action and relentless in pursuing alliances with our partners across the world. Sanctions are a powerful lever we have to advance with that we have to advance our foreign policy goals in the face of action that breaks the law and is unacceptable. When we impose sanctions, we do so to isolate those responsible, to restrict their ability to act and to change their behaviour. We do it to send a clear message far beyond those we target of the values that the UK will stand up for. And we try to do it, where possible, alongside our partners to maximize the impact of the sanctions we impose.

The Global Human Rights Sanctions regime, now the Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions regime, is particularly vital for this. Since the regime began in 2020, the UK has delivered over 180 designations and, under this Government, we have used the Global Human Rights Sanctions regime to tackle issues such as forced labour in Southeast Asian scam centres, to extremist settlers violently attacking Palestinians in the West Bank, to those responsible for the violent crackdown on protesters in Georgia.

The global human rights sanctions regime is of course not our only tool. We also make extensive use of our range of geographic sanctions regimes. For example, last week, we announced the designation of 15 commanders on both sides of the conflict in Sudan who are suspected of perpetrating or inciting heinous atrocities against civilians, in particular, conflict-related sexual violence. As we mark the anniversary of the horror we saw after the fall of El Fasher, these designations remind the perpetrators of atrocities that the international community is watching them and that actions have consequences. However, that action on Sudan is only possible was only possible because our Sudan sanctions regime permits designations on the grounds of violations of international humanitarian law.

Before we laid this instrument, the government did not have the flexibility to respond in this fashion to similar atrocities taking place in countries that did not happen to have their own geographical sanctions regime. As a result of these revisions, now we do. This instrument also expands our ability to stand up for our values, to tackle injustice and to tackle suffering around the world in other ways. The expanded regime addresses a broader range of human rights abuses and violations by adding the right to security of liberty and person, and also gives the government powers to respond with sanctions where aid has been deliberately prevented from reaching civilian populations. I'll now turn to each measure within this instrument in a bit more detail.

I want to be clear this is a strong enhancement of our existing powers. The global human rights sanctions regime gave us the ability to use sanctions where there were reasonable grounds to suspect serious violations or abuses of the right to life, the right not to be subjected to torture or cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment, the right to be fully free from slavery and not to be held in servitude or required to perform forced or compulsory labour. These amended regulations allow all pre-existing sanctions to remain in force, but give us a powerful lever to respond to a broader range of situations. The expanded sanctions regime now allows designations to be made where there are reasonable grounds to suspect serious violations of international humanitarian law. This strengthens the UK's ability to respond to serious conduct that arises during armed conflict, such as the targeting or mistreatment of civilians, where international humanitarian law provides the most relevant legal framework.

As the Foreign Secretary set out to Parliament on the 8th of September, when he committed to laying this instrument, this legislation gives the UK the powers to target those constructing illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank, such as those participating in E1 settlement expansion. As I have said, the previous version of the regime permitted designations where there were reasonable grounds to suspect serious violations of the right to life, the right not to be subjected to torture or cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment, and the right to be free from slavery, not to be held in servitude or required to perform forced or compulsory labour.

This instrument now adds the right to liberty and security of person to that list of rights. This ensures that the regime can now better address issues such as arbitrary detention and related conduct. The Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law sanctions regime also adds a new ground of obstruction of the delivery or distribution of or access to humanitarian assistance. This addition reflects the serious humanitarian consequences that can result when aid is deliberately prevented from reaching civilian populations, an objective, I'm sure noble Lords will agree, is an important one. The amended regime also adds the power to designate by description.

This allows the UK to designate where a specific name is not available, and in doing so, to capture all members of a specific group or organisation, allowing greater flexibility and reach under the regime. I note that the noble Lord Leigh, has tabled an amendment of regret, and I look forward to hearing from him and responding to his concerns. My Lords, to conclude, this instrument provides the Government with vital new, general powers with which to stand up for British values and respond to serious human rights abuses and serious violations of international humanitarian law around the globe. I beg to move.

02:20:54 - 02:21:02

Speaker 97

The question is that this motion be agreed to. Amendment, Lord Leigh of Hurley.

02:21:02 - 02:28:14

Speaker 70

My Lords, I rise to move the motion of regret standing in my name, and I declare my interests as set out in the register. Sanctions precisely targeted and founded on clear evidence are a legitimate instrument of British foreign policy, and they have my support. But these regulations do not meet that test. They seem to be to many to be there to satisfy local domestic political objectives of the Foreign Secretary and his Government. This is a major change in British foreign policy made without consultation, made without an impact assessment and without a vote in either House.

Parliament is being asked to approve powers already in use. That is not scrutiny; it is ratification. I move this motion because I believe this policy is a mistake. The explanatory note makes no reference to Israel, but the Foreign Secretary statement in the other place, as the noble Lord the Minister has made clear, and it is his concern is about settler violence in the West Bank or Judea and Samaria, and that is driving this legislation through. Let me be quite clear, I condemn such violence by either side.

Those who break the law should be arrested and punished. But I'm disappointed that the Foreign Secretary made no mention whatsoever of the numerous attacks on Jewish people in that area. Violence by terrorists against any civilians must be condemned, and the Government already have the tools to act. 38 people have already been sanctioned for settler violence, and the Government's relentless and unequal focus on measures against Israel have left many Jews in this country fearful. The regulations came with three promises: that they would be targeted, that they would not touch Israel inside the Green Line, and that they would be global.

Not one of them survives a reading of the text. The first promise was about that it would be targeted. But a person can be designated not for committing an abuse, but for providing support for it, obtaining any other benefit from it, or being associated with someone involved. That's not a scalpel; that's a net. And the Government know it.

They have said themselves that these powers widen the net, {quote, unquote}, to, {quote}, "anyone who facilitates, promotes, incites, or funds", {unquote}, the conduct in question, including the banks that finance settlement growth.

So what does associated with mean? A relative, an accountant, a customer? And when the penalty is 7 years in prison, a British business is entitled to know where the line is drawn. It's a fundamental feature of the rule of law that the law, and especially a law with criminal penalties, be clear so that everyone knows what they cannot do and what they can do. The second promise was the green line.

On 8th September, the Foreign Secretary told the other place that the Government would absolutely ensure that it does not hit green lined Israel. Absolutely ensure. So where is it? These regulations contain no safeguard for trade inside the green line and no definition of where that line runs. And what of Jerusalem?

Two weeks ago, I was in East Jerusalem as the UK Chairman of the Jerusalem Foundation for the opening of the Beit Hanina Sports Complex. It's the first ever swimming pool in East Jerusalem. It was paid for in part by the city and in no small part by international Jewish donors, and it will be handed as a gift to the local community to run. It's been so successful that we would like to build a second swimming pool in East Jerusalem to match the many in West Jerusalem. But donors have now told us they're not prepared to consider such a proposal because they may be caught under this legislation.

So, can the Minister assure British charities that their work will not be caught by this instrument, when their trustees face a real possibility of criminal penalties? The Government treat East Jerusalem, including the Western Wall, Judaism's holiest site, as occupied territory. So, I ask the Minister, is the Western Wall within the scope of the regime, yes or no? And could a British citizen who buy buys a flat in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City from a Jewish seller be at risk, when the same purchase from an Arab seller would not be? The Government, and every party to negotiations, has always said that the status of Jerusalem must be settled in negotiations, not in regulations.

And the real cost is trade between Britain and Israel, which is worth some 5.9 billion pounds a year, and at the heart of it sits Israel's banks. Those banks lend across the country because Israeli law forbids them from refusing customers due to where they live. Under these regulations, a mortgage in a settlement could be support, the interest of it a benefit, and on suspicion alone the bank suspicion alone, the bank could be designated. Now, anyone who's worked in the City know how compliance departments work, and they will be faced with undefined tests and a seven-year penalty, criminal sentence. So they won't ask: is it lawful?

They will ask: is it worth the risk? And they will say no. And this is how a boycott of Israel begins, not by a decree, but by deterrence. The Government say they oppose the BDS campaign, yet they've written its sharpest element into British law. So who pays?

I'm afraid we in the UK pay. British banks pay and firms with US operations pay because under US federal law, it treats measures against any territory controlled by Israel as a boycott. So, compliance with these regulations would com- expose them to US penalties. The NHS pays. One in seven generic medicine packs prescribed here comes from an Israeli company, Teva.

British business pays. Firms with American operations now risk anti- a boycott penalties, and Palestinians pay. Some 30,000 depend on jobs with settlement-liked linked employee employers. This smacks of collective punishment. So, I ask the Minister, will the Treasury issue general licences to protect NHS medicine supply?

The third promise was that this regime is global. Now, take Northern Cyprus. Turkey has occupied the northern Cyprus since 74. The UN Security Council has ruled the self-declared republic as legally invalid, and this country is one of Cyprus's three guarantor powers.

So, how many designations have the government made? None. Restrictions on trade? None. One rule for Turkey, one rule for Israel.

Then Xinjiang, it's a settler corporation, who's been sanctioned in full by the US since 2020 and here, goods from the region enter without restriction. And Hamas, and the Iran-backed Houthis, hostage taking, the diversion of aid, the detention of UN staff, yet ministers have given no indication that these powers will be used against them. This is not a global regime. It's a regime with a global title and a single target. My Lords, the cost is not hypothetical.

Within a day of the announcement, Israel ordered the closure of our consulate in Jerusalem, expelled British personnel, and from the centre coordinating—

02:28:14 - 02:28:20

Speaker 103

Can I respectfully remind the noble Lord that the limit for this was six minutes?

02:28:20 - 02:29:21

Speaker 70

I was graciously given a minute by Lord Wood, but thank you. So, I will conclude by saying that there are, there were 1,962 antisemitic incidents in the last six months in the UK. This does nothing to reduce the tensions within the UK, and I'm going to conclude by asking the minister six questions.

Will he confirm that Israel trade within the Green Line will not lead to designation? Will he assure British banks that they will not be penalised for continuing to deal with Israel's banks? Will the government define the terms on which people can be sanctioned, and report annually to Parliament on how this regime is used country by country? And will they assess the impact, particularly on charities, before going further? And lastly, will they refrain from designations while Israel forms a new government at this crucial time?

02:29:21 - 02:32:41

Sarah Ludford

The original question was that the regulations laid before the House on the 12th of October be approved, since when an amendment has been moved by Lord Leigh of Hurley at the end to insert the words set out on the order paper. The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to. My Lords, I speak from the perspective of being a vice president of the Lib Democrat Friends of Israel, not as a spokesman of my group. This is an even more unstable and unpredictable time in Middle East politics than usual. We have the aftermath of elections in both Israel and the US, with lots of speculation, but not so much actual knowledge of what the next few weeks and months will hold.

I hoped for a change government in Israel, my party, the Liberal Democrats, is allied with Yair Lapid's Yesh Atid, but everything is up in the air there as it is in Washington. The possibility of a US-led renewal of hostilities in the Iran War cannot be dismissed, regardless of the domestic Israeli situation, and could influence the coalition talks there. So, I ask the noble Lord, the minister, firstly, what forethought is going into the application of these sanctions and their potential repercussions at this particular time? Let us recall, as the noble Lord Leigh of Hurley, did, all the things that happened within a day of September's announcement, the closure of the British Consulate-General in East Jerusalem and other consequences. Did the government foresee that response by the Israeli government, as of course it should have done?

Does the minister accept that the UK now has less influence over Israeli policy, events in Gaza, and the future of Jerusalem, than it did on the 7th of September, and that its relations with the Palestinian Authority are made harder by a much reduced presence in East Jerusalem? So, looking at the situation now, and the question of the noble Lord Leigh, about designations during coalition talks, will the government undertake not to issue designations while a new Israeli government is being formed?

The Foreign Secretary said in the House on September the 8th that, quote, "Our argument is not with the people of Israel; our argument is with the conduct of its Government." So, should the UK Government not prioritise getting a change in the conduct of a new Israeli Government away from the destructive policies of the Netanyahu Government? What assessment will it make before any designation of the impact not only on those coalition talks, but also on relations with whatever Government emerges? The opposition change parties have said they will, thankfully, crack down on the horrendous settler violence in the West Bank, show more flexibility in moving forward with a post-war plan for Gaza and mend fences with Israel's allies. So, does the Government really think now is a good time to be applying these sanctions, about which there are many questions?

Will the noble Lord the Minister confirm that any designation will be preceded by a formal assessment of its diplomatic consequences, including in the light of emerging US policy? Finally, will the Government confirm that the decision will be taken by Ministers, not officials alone, given the political and diplomatic minefield that is before it?

02:32:41 - 02:36:02

Speaker 102

My Lords, yesterday evening, some of us had the privilege of gathering in the Robing Room with the permission of His Majesty to celebrate the life of our dear friend, Mita, Lord, Baroness Ramsay. We miss her greatly. And I think I can say, after having had the privilege of serving with her when she was long-standing chair in the House of Lords of Labour Friends of Israel, and I had a much briefer stint as chair in the Commons, I think I can say with confidence how dismayed she would be by not only by the these particular sanctions targeting Israel in the way they do, but the turn that this Government has seen since the new Foreign Secretary took his place, and the with the Minister, the noble Lord, supporting him. Now, it was reflected during the tributes how loyal and faithful Mita was to the Labour Party over many years—more faithful, I have to say, than I have been. And so, if this were brought to a vote—I think it's highly unlikely, given she's only I think rebelled certainly only a half a dozen times or less in the whole career in the Lords—it's unlikely she would have voted against the Government.

But I think the noble Lord the Minister will know from his time observing her on the parliamentary committee how she would have made her views known in a courteous but persuasive way. In her absence, let me finish with a number of extra questions. The new aid obstruction ground in these sanctions covers those who facilitate or finance the dispersion of aid. Will the Government use it against Hamas, which grew out of the Muslim Brotherhood, and against those who finance and shelter it, including the IRGC and Hamas figures operating from Turkey? What safeguards will prevent the definitions of "associated with" and "supported" those tests being what will what safeguards will prevent those tests being weaponised against Jewish charities, donors and trustees who wish to conduct lawful giving related to Israel?

And finally, the government said these regulations would not affect freedom of religion. Has the government assessed their impact on Jewish religious observance? And will the minister confirm that worship, religious visits, and support for synagogues and other religious institutions will not be treated as support for settlement activity?

02:36:02 - 02:38:57

Speaker 109

My Lords, I declare my interests as set out in the register. I support my noble friend, Lord Leigh, and wish to focus on one issue, certainty. If these regulations are truly targeted, those affected should be able to understand where the boundary lies. Yet the government have failed to provide that clarity. Faced with serious penalties, many will simply err on the side of caution.

Can the government state clearly, when buying a home or making a charitable donation in East Jerusalem, including the Western Wall, what becomes grounds for designation? What legal test distinguishes a lawful transaction from a sanctionable support? Will the test be published? Trustees, donors, charities should not have to guess whether lawful activity crosses the invisible line. If the government have a clear test, they should publish it.

If they do not, this is precisely the problem. But there are wider consequences. If charities and individuals cannot determine where the line is drawn, why should banks and businesses? Many will simply withdraw from dealings with Israel as the safest course. What assessment did the government make of the impact on UK businesses, particularly those with UK US operations, in light of America's anti-boycott laws?

What assessment was made of any wider implication for the UK-US relationship? What guidance will be issued? If those assessments have been undertaken, they should be published. If guidance has been prepared, it should be issued. The House is not being asked this afternoon whether certainty is desirable.

It's being asked to approve regulations whose boundaries remain undefined in practice, where sanctions carry serious penalties. Uncertainty is not a technical fault. It is a fundamental defect. If those affected cannot know with confidence where the line is drawn, the House should be concerned about what it's being asked to approve. This is, in effect, BDS by the back door, whether it's intended to Whether it was intended or not, this is BDS, and that is why I support the motion of regret.

02:38:57 - 02:39:00

Speaker 104

Hear.

02:39:00 - 02:41:39

Speaker 107

the principle behind the global human rights sanctions when they were first introduced, but like many good things, this instrument, too, carries a risk of mission creep, and I fear it is what we see in the new regulations. I'm concerned about the extension of the regime to the three new grounds, and in particular to violations of international humanitarian law, and I'm also concerned about the new mechanism of designation by description, whereas, until now, we'd only have been able to designate by name alone.

Both questions matter because the threshold is quite low. Reasonable grounds to suspect is not a demanding test, particularly when applied in the fog of war. I don't think there has ever been a war in the history of warfare in which there were not reasonable grounds to suspect that the laws of war were being broken. Reasonable grounds to suspect, if we want to apply this threshold consistently, would require us to consider imposing sanctions in connection with every ongoing armed conflict, including those involving allies. I also wonder if the government has given thought to the relationship between this instrument and the arms embargo regime.

The threshold there is clear risk, which is a higher threshold than reasonable grounds to suspect, particularly when we then also consider the fact that individuals associated with someone may also be sanctionable under the new instrument. Does that mean that we could still potentially sell arms to individuals that we have sanctioned? Or how do the two regimes operate together? I also have some further questions for the minister. Will the government publish examples that show what reasonable grounds to suspect specifically means in evidential terms in the context of an armed conflict? What independent assessment will the government make of evidence from the UN, NGOs, media, or foreign governments, particularly where an allegation is repeated from in report after report, quite often based on the same secondhand source?

But I think, most importantly, how will the government ensure that these new grounds and mechanisms are genuinely applied consistently? If the government imposes sanctions in connection with a settlement in the West Bank, will it set out the legal reasons for not doing the same in other occupied territories, such as Western Sahara and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus?

02:41:39 - 02:43:20

Ros Rosalind Altmann

My Lords, I apologize to the House, and I beg the House's indulgence. For me, this is an a serious issue that places the Jewish people under significant anti-Semitic that the government realizes how serious this is. I beg the House's indulgence that I may make a few remarks. And I thank the House for that.

I will be very brief. Lord Sacks said antisemitism of the age. By the language of its age, which seems now to be human rights. I'm afraid that the West is being played, and this statutory instrument will simply stoke further Jew hatred.

It rewards those who are opposed to a two-state solution. It will not promote or help in any way the people who want the two-state solution, the Palestinians who lose their jobs, who are working alongside Israelis. And I just beg the government to understand the danger of singling out Israel for special punishment when so many of us who are Jewish citizens of this country are trying to warn of the dangers that this entails.

02:43:20 - 02:46:14

Speaker 105

My Lords, the new sanctions purport to be global, but in reality, they apply only to Israel. As my noble friend Lord Leigh of Hurley pointed out, there have been no designations over Northern Cyprus, occupied by Turkey since 1974. The Xinjiang settler corporation in China is unsanctioned, and Ministers have not said that the powers will be used against Hamas for diverting aid in Gaza or the Iran-backed Houthis, who are detaining UN aid workers. My Lords, failure to take any action over Cyprus is particularly heinous. As guarantor under the 1960 Treaty of Guarantee, the UK has a particular responsibility.

The UN Security Council declared the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus legally invalid. The Council of Europe has condemned the colonisation by Turkish settlers, and the European Court of Human Rights has found that Turkey violated the property rights of displaced Greek Cypriots. Indeed, homes continue to be built and sold on their land, including to British buyers, but no sanctions have been imposed. And yet, the Government claims that the sanctions regime is global. If so, why has no action been taken in these other cases?

If the Government's view is that settlement activity in occupied territory constitutes a serious violation of international humanitarian law, presumably that law that view rests on Article 49(6) of the fourth Geneva convention, which applies equally to every alleged occupying power. The Government speaks out loudly against antisemitism, but singling out the one Jewish state for sanctions raises serious doubts as to the sincerity of such a claim. Does the Minister accept that a decision not to apply the regime to comparable conduct elsewhere could be open to judicial review if it rests on a different legal test, and will the Government undertake to publish the criteria it applies? Will the Government also now confirm that action will be taken against those responsible for these other violations? If not, how will the Government show it is not being applied to Israel alone?

02:46:14 - 02:49:00

Speaker 106

My Lords, I draw attention to my register to my entry in the Register of Interests. When announcing these measures, the Foreign Secretary said the Government would absolutely ensure this regime, quote, "does not hit Green Line Israel" and that trade with Israel would continue to be supported. And that trade, my Lords, is worth around six billion pounds, with UK exports worth more than half of it, a trade surplus in Britain's favour of roughly one billion pounds. And over the last five years, more than 400 Israeli companies have established or expanded in the UK, creating 4,000 jobs and bringing in a billion pounds of investment. And this makes a huge contribution to the UK economy.

They're highly skilled and well-paid jobs, and I'm sure the Minister would agree that none of them should be put at risk. But despite the Foreign Secretary's commitment, the Minister will know that business involved businesses involved in the UK-Israel trade, people in Israel, and many, as we've heard from a number of speakers in this debate, people in the Jewish community, want to be reassured about the precise impact of these measures and that they will not affect trade within Israel's pre-1967 lines.

So, can I ask whether the Treasury and the Foreign Office will issue clear guidance so that banks know ordinary trade finance and payments with the Israeli businesses are not to be affected? And what assurance can we give to Palestinian banks which clear shekel payments through Israeli correspondent banks? Given claims by members of Parliament that a recent event recruiting Jewish doctors to work in Israel would have contravened these regulations, will the Minister make clear that lawful healthcare, medical recruitment, and Jewish communal events are not within their scope? And only last night, these regulations were cited when Birmingham City Council's Lib Dem and Green coalition supported I have to say by Labour councillors passed a motion on divestment from Israel, including a review of pension fund investments and council banking relationships. Now this, my Lords, unbelievably, is a city which has had to be rescued from bankruptcy by taxpayers, where rubbish has been piled high in the streets, where it's the youth unemployment capital of Britain, yet the clowns on the council are more concerned, obsessed with, a war 3,000 miles away that they know next to nothing about, and can do even less to solve.

So, will the Minister make clear that this is not government policy? Will he confirm that the government's is opposed to boycotts of The government's opposition to boycotts of Israel applies to Labour councillors, too, and commit to monitoring whether UK banks and businesses are withdrawing from lawful trade with Israel, and to acting to and to act to deal with that if they are?

02:49:00 - 02:52:39

Speaker 110

My Lords, I rise to support my noble friend Lord Leigh, and provide a gentle reminder of why we're here today. Three years ago, on October the 7th, more than 6,000 Palestinian men invaded Israel. They slaughtered over 1,200 men, women, children, and infants. They tortured, beheaded, burned alive, blew up, gang-raped, sodomized their way through the Nova festival and a number of kibbutz. Their second war crime was to take over 250 innocent civilians, including children and infants, hostage into the tunnels of Gaza, where they were tortured, raped, many murdered, and some kept hostage for more than two and a half years.

Some employees of the UN, UNRWA, were complicit, and these actions were supported by the Palestinian Authority, whose members have never condemned the attacks. In fact, it was due to their weakness and cowardice that Hamas and the Palestinian jihadists were able to take control of Gaza in 2006, when the one and only election took place. The Islamic Republic of Iran pulled the strings of its proxies, and the rest is history. So, having witnessed one of the worst crimes in living memory on the citizens of Israel, an ally by the way, who provides us with intelligence, cancer drugs used by the NHS, and much more, what has this government done? Well, let's look, shall we?

This government decided to recognize a Palestinian state despite there being no such thing. There are no borders, no rule of law, or anything, in fact, which can warrant such a decision. This government has also allowed the pro-Palestinian, antisemitic hate protests to take place weekly to this day. The protesters, including Islamist supporters of Hizb ut-Tahrir, take part, and all of them continue to call for the annihilation of Israel and all Jews.

surprising that the British Jewish citizens have and are being bullied, continue to be bullied, attacked and murdered on the streets of the UK, Jewish children and their families living in a ring of steel and antisemitism at a level I never thought I would see in my lifetime. So finally, my Lords, I come to sanctions. Because of a disputed territory, of which we have plenty of our own, this Government places sanctions on our ally with the likes of Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Yemen, Russia, Somalia, Syria and other despotic, barbaric regimes, and yet again gives succour to our enemies by appeasing and rewarding those terrorists who threaten to attack Israel again and again. The truth is, this Government has kowtowed to those who shout loudest and who they hope will keep it in power. Their actions are shameful and a blight on the freedoms we have fought for, and run completely counter to the silent majority of this country.

We know a distraction when we see one, and this regulation, my Lords, has to be one of the worst examples yet. Hear.

02:52:39 - 02:55:46

Speaker 113

includes a more general review of the expansion of these sanctions, so I hope the House will forgive me if I just focus on some questions relating to the Government's current favorite target, Israel. My Lords, since the Clinton parameters, every serious peace proposal has envisaged Israel retaining major settlement blocs while compensating with land swaps. Now, this does not excuse violence, dispossession, or an unlawful expansion, but it recognizes the compromises and complexities on which peace has always depended and the pursuit of it has always required. So, I ask the Minister, is residential construction in those major blocs, in itself, a serious violation of international humanitarian law for the purposes of these regulations? If it is, what assessment have the Government made of the effect on the prospects for a negotiated two-state solution?

Have they assessed how restrictions on civilian economic life in these same blocs might affect the prospects of an agreed territorial compromise? My Lords, has the Minister also considered how these will apply? Banks and insurers, confronted with uncertain tests and grave penalties, may well withdraw from perfectly lawful Israeli trade. Now, the Government says it opposes boycotts. If British institutions withdraw from lawful trade with Israel as a whole, how is that different in effect from a boycott?

What does the Government intend to do to set out to prevent it? And please, we'd be very grateful for the current briefings that officials have made on this have indicated that they are setting terms which Israel cannot even by breaching its own law meet. What assessment has the Government made of the West Bank economy, and what support and arrangements are needed to support Palestinian financial institutions and banks, given the changes? Will the Minister please also give us some view as to what safeguards there are to ensure, if a company delisted, or where it stops a relevant activity, the Government will reassess its designation, so that the regulations are always applied on an up-to-date, factual basis? Why does regulation 8(3)(e) on supplying goods or services contain no requirement of knowledge when regulation 8(3)(d) does?

How promptly will a person designated by description receive usable notice, and how can they obtain clarification of whether designation applies to them? How frequently will the Government reassess the factual basis and continuing appropriateness of each designation, and will it publish aggregate review outcomes? What remedy is available to an innocent third party suffering losses from a mistaken identification, or mistaken ownership and control assessment? How will the Government distinguish a remote or incidental financial benefit from a sufficiently direct benefit under regulation 8(3)(f)?

Under regulation 8(3)(e), can a supplier with no knowledge or reasonable cause to suspect wrongdoing nevertheless be treated as involved, and what proportionality safeguard would apply? What factors merely distinguish an incidental professional, familial or charitable association from an association sufficient for designation under regulation 8(1)(d)?

02:55:46 - 02:55:52

Speaker 108

My Lords, Lord Shinkwin is taking part remotely.

02:55:52 - 02:57:54

Kevin Shinkwin

My Lords, I rise to speak in support of the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord Leigh of Hurley. Yesterday, I spoke to a group of amendments to the health bill, which dealt with the need to address the pernicious threat to the NHS posed by antisemitism and other forms of racism. I spoke then from a patient's perspective, in my case, as someone who owes so much to my childhood Jewish refugee consultant, most of whose family were murdered in the Holocaust, and in whose memory, I will always defend Israel's right to exist in peace and security, and refute the charge of genocide in the tragic situation that is Gaza. Today, I speak again from a patient's perspective, and I have two specific questions for the noble Lord, the minister. Firstly, could he say what contingency arrangements would be put in place to maintain medicines, emergency medical treatments, and aid payments if a major intermediary became designated?

Secondly, could I ask him what assessment the government has made of the effects that would be felt as a result of any settlement-related sanctions or proposed services restrictions on access to healthcare for Israeli and Palestinian patients, including continuity of care and the recruitment of clinicians? I look forward to the noble Lord, the minister's reply.

02:57:54 - 03:01:10

David Frost

My Lords, I rise to support the regret motion in the name of the noble Lord Leigh of Hurley, and in so doing, draw attention to my entry in the Register of Interests. My Lords, I want to raise, briefly, two specific concerns on this proposed legislation. The first is the risk that the sanctions under consideration will not be effectively targeted. Now, the noble Lord Leigh, talked about the chilling effect, I think one could describe it as of the ambiguity of aspects of these sanctions and the definitions. That's a negative, if you like, risk.

But the Foreign Secretary in the Commons, when announcing these sanctions, also set out a positive duty. He said, "We will absolutely ensure it does not hit Green Line Israel." He said, "We will continue to support important and valued trade with Green Line Israel." Now, if that was not just words, they imply a positive duty to act by embassies, by government officials, by departments who support trade between the UK and Israel. And businesses need to know what positive, practical support the government can still give.

Government officials need to know what they can do and can't do under these sanctions. So, I ask the noble Lord the Minister, can he explain what the government will do to deliver on the Foreign Secretary's positive commitment? Will they publish guidance, for example, making clear what trade and investment is supported by HMG and its officials and what isn't?

So, that's my first concern. Second is how the follow-up regulations to these sanctions are to be handled in practice. They're presented as the first stage in a series of measures tightening restrictions over time, and the government's planned measures to prohibit or restrict imports, services, advertising will be very far-reaching. They'll hit a lot of people who probably never imagined they were going to be hit by this, and there's a high risk of getting the detail wrong, or having inadvertent consequential effects. My Lords, this does happen.

Some of us may remember in 2023, the Russia Sanctions Amendment No. 3 Regulations banned legal advisory services. They were made on 27 June that year and came into force three days later. And then an outside stakeholder, it took an outside stakeholder, a law firm, to tell us, the legislators, that these regulations actually made it a crime for UK-based lawyers to advise on how to comply with the sanctions. The firm went on to say this was unnecessary and likely unintended, and Your Lordships' Secondary Legislation Committee went on to confirm this was actually the fact, and it took the government a year to get the legislation right. This happened in a sanction regime that by then was well understood and often used.

So, will the government commit to doing the maximum to avoid a similar situation arising again? Instead of drafting follow-up laws and simply bringing them into force, will they commit to ensuring that measures under this bill will be published in draft, consulted upon, and properly debated in this Parliament first?

03:01:10 - 03:03:20

Speaker 121

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow my noble friend, Lord Frost, who has demonstrated his considerable knowledge and experience in this field. It is a hallmark of bad law that it encourages shadow compliance and overcompliance because British companies and institutions quite rightly wish to obey the law, but also wish not to be test cases. It takes time and money to be a test case, and after all it is not their job to clarify UK law. The government should be responsible for saying exactly where the boundaries lie. And because of that, I'd like to ask the Minister for his assurance about the assessments that the government have made, that their actions are going to be proportionate under this legislation to the government's stated aims, and also that this will be consistent with the government's obligations under international law.

I have got considerable respect for the noble Lord, the Minister, and I understand that he will want to do his best to get this right. But I think we always remember in that this House that statutory instruments we approve, legislation that we approve will be used by ministers in future. And that's why, because I don't necessarily trust people who in future might pick this responsibility up, that's why I'd like to ask the noble Lord the Minister for a further safeguard, and that is that he restore the duty to report to Parliament on sanctions regimes, which was scrapped back in 2022. Because this is a considerable extension of the government's powers sanctioning, and I think it is right that both Houses of Parliament get a report every year about what has happened, who has been sanctioned, and what the results are going to be. So I hope the Minister will be able to reassure me on both those points.

03:03:20 - 03:04:07

Speaker 125

My Lords, the acute human cost of current global conflicts provides the undeniable catalyst for today's debate. The plight of civilians, particularly the catastrophic situation in Gaza, is of profound concern. The Government is entirely right to use these regulations to expand our foreign policy toolkit. By making the intentional obstruction of life-saving humanitarian assistant and serious breaches of international humanitarian law explicit sanctionable offenses, the Government is creating a necessary legal lever to address atrocities worldwide. Crucially, these powers are truly global.

03:04:07 - 03:06:23

Speaker 124

While the immediate focus of many is the Middle East, the updated framework allows the UK to target perpetrators across other devastating theatres of war. It strengthens our hand, as my noble friend the Minister has already outlined. It is to penalise those orchestrating violence or blocking food and medicine in Sudan, for example, where we have recently seen severe human rights violations and the restriction of aid. It gives us explicit legal baseline to act decisively in conflicts across Myanmar, Syria, the Democratic Republic of Congo and the Sahel region. Previously, punishing these acts required slow country-specific geographic regimes.

Today, we establish a unified global standard for accountability. Furthermore, updating our powers to allow designations by descriptions, rather than just by individual name, provides the agility required in fast-moving conflicts. It ensures the UK can act in immediate lockstep with international allies to deter actions that undermine humanitarian law, whether against violent settlers' networks in the West Bank or warlords in East Africa. Procedural questions regarding delegated legislation and legal thresholds are fair matters for this House to scrutinise. However, technical caution must not paralyse urgent humanitarian leverage.

Rather than regretting these regulations, our focus must be on efficient enforcement. So, I ask the Minister to confirm that the Foreign Office has the dedicated intelligence resources to rapidly monitor aid obstruction globally, ensuring that these powers are deployed effectively to protect vulnerable civilians in Gaza, Sudan, and beyond.

03:06:23 - 03:07:51

Speaker 119

My Lords, I declare my interest as general secretary of the Free Speech Union, as a director of the British Friends of Israel, and as the editor-in-chief and majority owner of The Daily Sceptic. Sanctions should target wrongdoing, and not lawful disagreement. No academic or journalist should fear sanctions and losing access to their bank account for challenging the Government's account of a conflict. Yet these regulations risk blurring that distinction through broad, undefined references to promotion, support, and association. The risk is particularly acute if the Government intends to rely on notoriously unreliable UN reporting on Israel.

What happens to the academic who challenges such a report, or the journalist who exposes its flaws? As the publisher of The Daily Sceptic, would I be at risk of designation for publishing such an exposé? Will the noble Lord the Minister confirm that lawful journalism, academic inquiry, and political argument will not, by themselves, justify designation under these regulations?

And will he confirm that the government will not rely on contested UN findings as evidence for designation without first testing them independently?

03:07:51 - 03:10:07

Speaker 126

My Lords, I draw attention to my entry in the register of interests. As Lord Lee told us, this decision represents a significant change in the position adopted by British governments over many years, and is also a serious departure from longstanding Labour Party policy. Like many others, I'm worried about the implications of this and the damage it might do to our relations with a vital ally and many innocent parties. The Foreign Secretary tells us that we cannot outsource our moral responsibilities, and so he's taken the decision to act under our Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law. But surely, unless we're going to see a raft of other measures, that sentiment could have a very hollow ring.

What kind of moral responsibility does it show to act in one instance while turning a blind eye in many others? Like other speakers, I ask my noble friend, if the government is applying a global approach, can we expect soon to see measures directed at those who've seized property and settlements in Northern Cyprus, real measures to curb the IRGC and the Iran-backed Houthis, measures against China and the Xinjiang Settler Organisation and against Hamas for diverting aid in Gaza? If not, how can our government avoid the charge that this decision is about acting against and singling out Israel? And given the uncertainty and the potential risks associated with these measures, can I ask my noble friend, was the Department for Business and Trade fully consulted before they were announced? And can he say with confidence that the regulations and the planned import ban are compatible with the UK-Israel Trade and Partnership Agreement?

03:10:07 - 03:13:33

Speaker 120

I refer the House to my registered interests. Over many years, I've taken more than 150 delegations of parliamentarians to Israel and the region. And I have seen what Britain can achieve when we are trusted and when we are in the room. And I have sadly watched this government give it all away. As Lord Leigh said, within a day of the announcement, our Consul-General in Jerusalem was ordered to leave, British personnel were removed from the centre coordinating the Gaza ceasefire and rebuilding, our training of Palestinian Authority security forces was stopped.

Not one designation had been made and we lost our seat at the table before the ink was dry. And for what? These regulations will not bring peace one day closer. And how would the government even know? How would the government even know?

Beyond counting designations, what measurable outcomes will they use to judge whether these sanctions actually improve humanitarian access? My Lords, the Abraham Accords have shown that peace is built through trade, investment and partnership, and Britain should be part of that. Instead, with tests no one can define and penalties of up to seven years in prison, British banks and businesses cannot know where the government line falls and many will simply walk away from Israel. That damages British trade, it damages Israel, and it damages the relationship between our two countries.

Can I gently remind the noble Lord the Minister that the British Mandate ended almost 80 years ago? Only yesterday the our right honourable Kemi Badenoch said, in relation to our national security and defence, this is not a student union, it is the running of our country. My Lords, these sanctions policy is another example of student politics at its worst. During this debate, and I sort of by my calculation, there have been about 40 or so legitimate questions posed to the Minister. We did not have an opportunity before the SI was laid, so I struggle to understand how such a flawed policy can be rushed through with no parliamentary scrutiny, and done on purely domestic, political considerations with a by-election in Holborn and, frankly, pandering to the mob.

Nor do these measures help the two-state solution. The Government, they say the Government say that they say they support it, but, as the noble Lord Mandelson said, every serious peace proposal since the Clinton Parameters of 2000 has expected the major settlement blocs to remain part of Israel. So, if this policy is to stand, I ask the Minister three simple questions. First, how do these sanctions bring a two-state solution closer? Second, if the green line is now the line on which British sanctions turn, will the Government publish where it runs, and say clearly whether East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights fall within it?

And thirdly, will the planned advertising ban stop British estate agents, newspapers or community organisations from advertising homes in the Jewish neighbourhoods of Jerusalem? My Lords, peace is built through engagement, not sanctions. Britain should be building bridges in the Middle East, not burning them.

03:13:33 - 03:13:41

Speaker 123

My noble friend Lord Mandelson had omitted to declare his interest earlier and would just briefly wish to rise just to do so, and then we will be on to the

03:13:41 - 03:13:47

Speaker 113

My Lords, I apologise, in hacking my speech down I omitted at the very beginning to declare my interests as set out in the register.

03:13:47 - 03:17:18

Jeremy Purvis

My Lords, I should also state, repeatedly in this debate there's been incorrect references. The companion is perfectly clear that references to interest need to be specific. There's been a number of parts of this debate which I hope that the government whips and the opposition whips will reflect on the handling of this debate. I welcome these sanctions, and indeed having scrutinised all sanctions that the UK has passed since 2018, I've called for the updating and the expansion of the human rights sanctions, so I welcome the new elements and the new criteria, and also the fact that descriptions of actions will be put in place to prevent circumvention. There has been, let me refer briefly to the regret motion.

We already have designated individuals within the Israeli government. We have many Israeli actors who have been designated under the human rights regime. I slightly regret the partisan tone in this debate, because I want to quote from the Foreign Secretary. "Today's sanctions place restrictions on those involved in some of the most egregious abuses of human rights. Extremist Israeli settlers are threatening Palestinians, often at gunpoint, and forcing them off land that is rightfully theirs.

This behaviour is illegal and unacceptable." That was David Cameron as Foreign Secretary under the last government in February 2024.

There are many elements of this debate that is not new today. Indeed, I agreed with Lord Cameron, in fact, I questioned him on those in this House, many who's taken part in this debate today didn't. Outposts, in particular, are illegal under Israeli law. I don't understand why we should allow UK bodies to be immune from our law, which facilitates settlements and outposts, which are illegal under Israeli law. We have an obligation in this country to ensure UK entities do not facilitate human rights abuses and egregious breaches of international humanitarian law, as Lord Cameron outlined in 2024.

I welcome the fact that this is a global regime, as the Minister said, and indeed, we can now move more quickly beyond Sudan, Syria, Myanmar and the DRC, where there are country-specific scope, which the Minister had indicated. I'm glad that the Minister mentioned Sudan. I welcome the fact that the commanders are now being sanctioned for the terrible human rights abuses within that conflict. I hope the Minister, he normally says that ministers do not comment on individuals to be sanctioned, but it is worth noting that the UK still has not sanctioned General Burhan and General Hemetti, the two people who are most responsible for the world's worst humanitarian abuses. My final point is with regards to humanitarian relief.

There is scope under these measures to have a Treasury license for exemptions, a humanitarian scope is in place. I hope that the Minister might be able to confirm that it is indeed the Government's intention that there will be a humanitarian assistance license.

03:17:18 - 03:20:59

Martin Callanan

My Lords, when the Government announced these sanctions, both the Government and the official Opposition reasserted our commitment to the two-state solution and Israel's right to defend itself. We all want to see sustainable, long-term peace in the region, and I know there's a broad consensus in the House on that matter. My Lords, also, for the avoidance of doubt, we all condemn settler violence, and I hope that the Israeli authorities will clamp down on many of the abuses that we have seen. But as I said in September, the test by which the Government's sanctions will be judged is whether they bring us closer to a sustainable two-state solution. We on these Benches are far from satisfied that the Government's approach is any closer to achieving that.

We were particularly concerned by the Government's decision to announce these sanctions, which will take months to be implemented, surprisingly close to the Holborn and St Pancras by-election, which incidentally meant creating a further political row during the lead-up to the elections in Israel. This, in my view, my Lords, was a serious misjudgment, leading many of us to suspect that domestic political considerations were at the forefront of the Government's consideration. I share many of the concerns raised by noble Lords across the House today, including, I'm pleased to say, on the Government's own Benches. I hope the noble Lord the Minister will be able to give full answer to the very many serious questions that have been put to him today. And if he needs to write to noble Lords to provide detailed replies, I would be grateful if he would commit to sharing those detailed answers with all peers for the information of the House and lay copies of his replies in the Library.

I hope he will forgive me if I add some of my own questions to his extensive list. On religious freedom, the Government have said that these regulations will not affect freedom of religion. What assessment have they made of the impact on Jewish religious observance, including acts of worship, religious visits, religious goods and related payments, and of compatibility with Article 9, freedom of religion, and Article 14, prohibition of discrimination, in the European Convention of Human Rights, that the Government keep telling us they are so committed to, as given effect by the Human Rights Act 1998? Will they publish objective criteria distinguishing support for worship and religious institutions from financing settlement expansion before charities, donors and banks are expected to apply them?

Will the government report annually to Parliament on designations and decisions not to designate by country, and build an annual review or sunset into the operation of the regulations, so that their efficacy, fairness and proportionality can be assessed every year by all of us? And what assessment has the government made that the regulations will be applied in a manner proportionate to their stated aims and consistent with the UK's obligations under international law? Can the noble Lord, the minister, tell us whether the Treasury, DBT, DHSC and relevant financial regulators were consulted on the wider effects, and will the government publish a summary of their assessments? Finally, on the necessity of these regulations, what specific conduct could not be addressed adequately under the 2020 regime, and what evidence led ministers to conclude that these additional 2026 designation grounds were necessary beyond domestic political considerations? I look forward to the noble Lord, the minister's, response, but should my noble friend, Lord Leigh, put his motion to the vote, then I will certainly support him.

03:20:59 - 03:28:06

Speaker 101

Lots of paper. My Lords, I'd like to thank noble Lords for their contributions to this debate, and I'd like to start by echoing what my noble friend Lord Woodcock said about Mette Ramsay, we all miss her very much. She would have disagreed, I'm sure you're right, with much if not the preponderance of today's SI amendments, but we miss her very much. The expansion of the global human rights sanctions regime, now the global human rights and international humanitarian law regime, shows how the UK is taking bold action to stand up for British values around the world. I'd like to respond to the noble Lord Leigh's motion.

I'm sorry to see opposition. I understand many of the arguments made by noble Lord Leigh and others, on the specific cases of Israel that he focused on and that most Lords noble Lords focused on. But I'm disappointed to see opposition to this as the vehicle by which they express their passionately strongly held views on the question of Israel and the UK's relationship with Israel. Why? Because today is about something slightly different to what majority of noble Lords have been focusing on.

This is about an instrument whose purpose is to strengthen the UK's ability to respond to serious abuses of human rights and violations of international humanitarian law wherever they occur, wherever they occur. And if Lord Leigh's motion was successful, this House would be on record as regarding the expansion of the government's powers to act wherever abuses of human rights or serious violations of international humanitarian law occur across the globe, regretting that, and I don't believe that's the message that this House wants to send. These regulations are not targeting any country. They are expanding the range of abuses upon which the global human rights regime will be based, and upon which the UK government can act. They are global in scope.

They are designed to ensure the UK has the necessary powers to hold individuals and entities accountable for serious misconduct across a range of situations across the world. They provide an important and proportionate addition to our sanctions toolkit, and strengthen our ability to act in defense of fundamental rights and international norms. And I take my noble friend Baroness Gill's point very much to heart, you need to maintain the ability to have strong monitoring of human rights abuses, and international humanitarian law rights abuses, including information from the United Nations and many other sources as well, to go back to noble Lord Young's point.

Now, the noble Lord's motion raises specific many specific questions about and his contribution raises questions about trade with Israel. Let me be clear. As the Foreign Secretary said, we will continue to support important and valued trade with Green Line Israel and its people. These regulations do not affect that trade. Indeed, this set of regulations is not about trade.

I'll come back to this in a minute. This is about behaviour. The noble Lord also asked whether the government will publish clear designation criteria and an evidence-based framework. Well, the designation criteria are set out in the regulations themselves, specifically in regulation 8, page 6, I believe. Any designation must meet the legal tests established in sanctions legislation, and be made in accordance with the Human Rights Act 1998.

Decisions are made by ministers on the basis of evidence and are subject to the safeguards and scrutiny established by Parliament. And just as a passing remark, regulation 8 sets out the designation criteria, it is almost identical to regulation 6, I believe, in the 2020 regulations, almost identical. The idea that there's some massive redefinition of the small print is simply not true. The main changes are in regulation 4 where we have added serious violations of international humanitarian law and wider human rights grounds. Many noble Lords' comments are not about, are not correct in saying that there is a subversive expansion going on here in order to get into particular cases.

It is factually incorrect. Any economic impacts arise, excuse me, I apologise. Questions were also raised regarding impact assessments and reporting to Parliament. A de minimis impact assessment has been completed and concluded that the expected additional impacts on UK businesses will be negligible. And that's because the regulations are enabling legislation only, and are global in scope.

The sanctions regime itself is not targeted at any specific country, conflict, sector, product, market, or group of business businesses. Any economic impacts arise only if ministers decide to designate specific persons under the expanded regime. These designations are separate, case by case, and each designation follows a robust legal process. We designate according only to the specific grounds of the appropriate regime and our reasoning must be properly evidenced with credible sources that can be relied upon in court. We regularly keep sanctions regimes and designations under review.

Noble Lord Evans was right that the duty to report the part annually was scrapped in 2022 by the previous Conservative government. However, this House and the other place do have a range of mechanisms through which sanctions policy and implementation are examined through debates, through questions, through committee scrutiny, through correspondence, through evidence sessions, through extremely friendly text exchanges with friends like my noble Lord Polak on a regular basis. My honourable friend Minister Doughty writes regularly to the chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee setting out the government's sanctions work in detail. Such correspondence is available in the libraries of both Houses, and I am also committed, as I'm sure noble Lords across the House already know, that I am committed to continuing regular engagement with members across the House on sanctions issues and related issues. Let me respond quickly to some of the, I can include some of the individual remarks.

A number of noble Lords raised the question whether this was singling out Israel in some way or focused on Israel.

Not only is this not about Israel, it's about the global human rights regime, it's a statutory instrument amending the global human rights regime. Let me just refer to some of the designations that have been made to Georgia, as I mentioned before, in Sri Lanka, where we sanctioned individuals responsible for serious human rights abuses and violations during the Sri Lankan Civil War, in Cambodia, where we've used it to deliver high-impact sanctions against global conglomerates running sham scam centres as well as their enablers. It is not true, it is simply not true that this is a regime that is targeted on Israel or any one country. It is not true.

03:28:06 - 03:28:39

Speaker 110

Yes. May I just bring to the attention of the noble Lord, the minister, a press release that came out on the 8th of September, a week after Sir Keir Starmer resigned, which read: "The UK to bring forward new powers to respond to moral emergency in Palestine and target illegal settlement activity in the West Bank to protect the viability of a two-state solution." I'll happily give this document to the noble Lord, the minister, when he's completed his response.

03:28:39 - 03:30:31

Speaker 101

Thank you, I'm familiar with that document. I may have even had a hand in helping to write it. There's a confusion, if you don't mind me saying so, at the heart of your question, because the Foreign Secretary, on the 8th of September, announced two things. He announced, in fact, he announced many things, including, which some noble Lords have forgotten, a series of sanctions on financing arms of Hamas and Hezbollah. But he also announced two other things particular: he announced the expansion, excuse me, he announced that there will be a new sanctions regime designed to stop UK economic activity supporting the expansion of illegal settlements, and that will be laid before Parliament within 6 to 9 months.

Many comments of noble Lords and noble Ladies in the last hour have been focused on a bill that has yet to be produced and measures that have yet to be clarified. And I take very seriously the injunctions of many noble Lords, including Lord Mandelson, for clarity to be provided, as much as is consistent with those new rules. But today is about the expansion of the second thing he talked about, the expansion of our existing global human rights regime. That's what we're discussing today. That is not what the quote the noble Lady read out was about.

I don't have time, I'm afraid. I will very happily come back to noble Lords on specific issues. I don't have time to go through everything now, I'm afraid. If this motion were successful, as I said earlier, we would not be taking any action with regard to any one country. We would be saying no to the expansion of the government's right or ability to act, not the right, the ability to act in response to abuse of human rights or serious violations of international humanitarian law.

Is that really the message that we want to send today? A general modification to an established and successfully operating set of regulations to expand abuses that we all debate day to day, people get rightly upset about and ask me oral questions about on a regular basis. Do we really think that is the message we want to send?

03:30:31 - 03:30:53

Nicholas True

My Lords, so just that the importance, I understand that the noble Lord wishes to make progress, and I welcome the fact that more time was given to this through usual channels. Will the noble Lord give an assurance to the House, he says he has no more time now, that he will place in the library a full response to all the questions raised by noble Lords in this debate?

03:30:53 - 03:32:14

Speaker 101

I will happily provide answers to questions I haven't been able to address. I'm happy to put it in the library, as well. My Lords, the UK Indeed. My Lords, the UK has transformed its use of sanctions in recent years and continues to lead internationally in their implementation. This amended global human rights and international humanitarian law regime gives us a stronger and more flexible means of promoting accountability and responsibility and responding to some of the gravest abuses seen around the world.

So, I therefore respectfully urge noble Lords not to support the amendment by Lord Leigh, because Lord Leigh's amendment is an amendment motivated by things which are not the substance of today's amendments. Today's amendments are for the global human rights regime rules. To conclude, I once again wish to thank the House for many insightful contributions, continued cross-party support of our sanctions regimes. We continue to lead internationally on sanctions implementation, and this amended global human rights and international humanitarian law regime will give the UK a powerful tool to respond to human rights abuses and international human law humanitarian law violations across the world. I beg to move.

03:32:14 - 03:33:12

Speaker 70

My Lords, can I, do you foresee me? No. My Lords, can I thank the very many noble Lords who have spoken on this debate? It has, I have listened to some extremely powerful, passionate, and very well-informed comments from actually all sides of the House, and I'm extremely grateful to those noble Lords who have taken the time and trouble so to do. I think there were some 40 questions, maybe 50 questions. I think the noble Lord the Minister has answered about 10.

And this is the purpose of our Chamber, is to look at things in more detail and express reservations, and there are clearly enormous reservations about these statutory instruments. They do not, the protections we've asked for, the concerns we've had raised have not been answered. And it is therefore more than appropriate that the opinion of this House is tested, and I wish so to do that.

03:33:12 - 03:33:57

Speaker 108

My Lords, the question is that the motion in the name of Lord Leigh of Hurley be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say, "Content". To the contrary, "Not-content". The question will be decided by a division. I will advise the House when voting is open.

03:33:57 - 03:34:32

Speaker 139

There may be a small technical delay that we, so, I'm going to sit down, but I strongly advise noble Lords not to leave the Chamber. My Lords, voting is now open. Clear the bar.

03:37:33 - 03:37:36

Speaker 134

Order.

03:37:36 - 03:37:43

Speaker 131

My Lords, the question is that the motion in the name of Lord Leigh of Hurley be agreed to. As many as are of opinion will say content.

03:37:44 - 03:37:45

Of the contrary, not content.

03:37:46 - 03:37:46

The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

03:42:26 - 03:42:30

Speaker 133

My Lords, the- My Lords, the question is that the motion in the name of Lord Leigh of Hurley be agreed to.

03:44:55 - 03:45:31

Speaker 108

My Lords, there have voted contents 94, not contents 90. So, the not content the contents have it, the contents have it. My Lords, I'll take a moment before putting the next motion.

03:45:31 - 03:45:37

Speaker 136

My Lords, my Lords.

03:45:37 - 03:46:34

Speaker 108

The question is that the original motion as amended be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. I will just take a moment for any noble Lords who wish to leave the chamber now to do so quickly so that we can get on to next business.

House to be again in committee on the Representation of the People Bill, Baroness Taylor of Stevenage.

03:46:34 - 03:46:39

Speaker 137

My Lords, I beg to move the House do again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill.

03:46:39 - 03:47:09

Speaker 108

Question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, Representation of the People Bill, clause 15, amendment 18, Lord Fuller.

03:47:09 - 03:50:25

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, I've got two amendments in this short group, 18 and 19, and both are related to the way in which looked-after children are encouraged to register to vote, the information that has been provided them to inform that choice, and then to ensure that party politics can play no part of that decision if there's automatic registration so that one political outcome is not unduly influenced over the other.

Now both my amendments relate to the entirety of the United Kingdom, with 18 referring to Great Britain and 19 the mirroring provision for Northern Ireland. It is the local state in Great Britain, that is the councils and their agents who have responsibility as corporate parents for looked-after children, the relevant young people are referred to by these amendments. And in some cases, that corporate parenting responsibility lasts all the way up to the age of 24. Now my Lords, there are some things that should be apolitical, but it is an inescapable truth that councils are political organizations. Whilst this amendment does not suggest that in any case councils behave politically in every decision they take, given the importance of this bill to the underpinning of democracy in the United Kingdom, these amendments make a belt-and-braces approach to being absolutely explicit that in encouraging young people to come onto the register, that choice cannot, or should not, be tainted or otherwise influenced by party political considerations.

We must remove the temptation for anyone to improperly influence the register by tilting the balance so that only some cohorts are registered, but not others. Now nothing as I say in this group, is meant to imply that councils are seeking to act improperly. We have to recognize that councils now engage with certain external organizations, private care homes, privately-run caring establishments, or even charitable bodies to deliver their caring and corporate parenting responsibilities, which may be within the council's own territory, or it may be in other parts of the country. So both my amendments together would ensure that the duty of neutrality would be extended not just to the local authorities or health boards, but to those in that wider care ecosystem that benefits children that are paid for by local government wherever they are. These organizations, councils or care homes, are in an extraordinarily influential position in the care of relevant young people.

They provide the food, accommodation. They're responsible for health and welfare and all the other issues of day-to-day life. By definition, these children are more socially vulnerable and susceptible to undue influence without the guiding hand of their natural parents. These amendments therefore provide an additional level of certainty and assurance to ensure that these vulnerabilities are not taken of are politically taken advantage of by the council through its policies, more subtly by the political predispositions of individual care workers, wardens or other members of the professional staff on the front line, or as well as by that ecosystem of contractors and charities. It's as simple as that, really.

03:50:25 - 03:50:28

Speaker 138

I beg to move.

03:50:28 - 03:50:35

Speaker 108

Amendment proposed, clause 15, page 21, line 15, at end insert the words printed on the marshalled list.

03:50:35 - 03:58:42

William Wallace

We'll speak to my amendment 18 and also touch on issues raised in the similar amendments by Baroness Lister number 43 and by Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle 44. We are very much concerned that the reduction of the age limit to 16 has to be accompanied by a real effort at proper civic education. I would say, as a Liberal, that there should have been a much greater effort of civic education anyway. The extent to which our young are not taught about British values, about the rights and obligations of British citizenship is profoundly worrying and needs to be overcome.

Others will speak about some of the surveys that have been done about the thinness of civic education in schools. I went around three schools, one in Yorkshire and two in London in the spring, just to see from a very unrepresentative sample what they were doing and was shocked even in the public school which I attended, one of Britain's best public schools, at how little time is spent on this. I was given the lessons plan by the head of PSHE at one school for all the things she had to teach in one hour a week each year, including sexual behaviour, financial education, disease, heaven knows what else, and, of course, political education pissing into that.

All of the teachers I spoke to said, "This is simply not possible to achieve. We need to have more time." And that is part of the message which we want the Minister to give us some answer on, that the current curriculum review recognizes this and that it will be expanded. Teaching citizenship is, for liberals, for people who believe in liberal democracy, a fundamental part of teaching people how to take their part in a democratic society. I'm well aware that there have been many, particularly in the Conservative ranks, who are doubtful about the possibilities of teaching people political education, particularly in state schools.

I remember and I've, as a historian, I've read a number of debates from the early 19th centuries in which Conservative peers doubted that education as such should be provided to the working class because it would give them ideas above their station. And education, of course, is subversive. It teaches people how to question the conventional wisdom. It teaches people how to think for themselves. That's part of what we should be doing.

In the United States we've seen recently, of course, an even more fundamental attack on liberal education in the Trump administration's attack on American universities as being unavoidably left-wing and liberal institutions, because they are concerned about evidence, about doubt, about argument, and about a number of things that the Trump administration appears not to like. I hope that all of us here do not share such a view. There has, as we see in some amendments in this group and later, be been some concern with the possibilities of neutrality. And I declare an interest as someone who spent much of my career teaching politics and international politics in various universities. Yes, of course, we all come with our biases,

but what we try to do is, again, to teach people how to think for themselves. I had when at the London School of Economics a number of Hong Kong and Singapore students, and the hardest job I had with them was to persuade them that they were supposed to disagree with their teacher. And we worked on them. I see the noble Baroness nodding in agreement.

Evidence, examination, debate is what makes someone a worthwhile citizen. Teachers know that. The civics teachers I have spoken to are very clear about their own responsibilities. I had a range of students from all sorts of different opinions.

One of them indeed ended up shortly afterwards as speechwriter to the German Chancellor, so I think it could not be said that I indoctrinated him too much with my opinions. What we have is the possibility of providing training for teachers, and again I hope the Minister will touch on that, to provide the sort of political education which will catch the attention and enthusiasm of teenagers. There are those also, as was affected in other amendments, who doubt the capacity of teenagers to show the level of interest and concern and judgment or understanding. When we get into questions of capacity, we are in a difficult area. I'm not sure that if one doubt one looked at the capacity of some people in their thirties or forties or fifties, we would find levels of interest and concern and understanding sufficient for the critical observer.

I have found, and many other noble Lords who have been to schools have found, active interest among teenagers in the way we are governed, the choices we have to make. And we should be feeding that, and providing the information which is needed for them to engage in the public debate. And that's the last thing I want to talk about, which is information, which again we will come back to, particularly with reference to social media. It does mean that materials need to be provided, and there are a number of projects already underway with NGOs and with the Electoral Commission on that. It does mean that we need to provide on social media some of the information.

And I would here say that the BBC has the potential to be extremely useful in this regard. I discovered during COVID, when I was trying to help my children with the teaching of their children, that BBC Bitesize had some absolutely superb stuff for which to teach people in key stages 2 and 3. And I think that one of the ways in which we should be using the existence and the quality of the BBC is in providing that sort of background information. What we need on this, and I appeal in particular to the Conservative benches here, is a cross-party approach. We do need to engage our younger generation.

We do need to explain to them that democracy matters and that they have a stake in it. And for that to be successful, whether or not we go down to 16 of voting or not, we need a much better and higher quality of civic education than we currently have. I hope the Minister will be able to respond to these probing amendments with some reassurance that the Government is actively taking this on board.

03:58:42 - 04:05:31

Margot Ruth Lister

I will speak to Amendment 43 in my name. It seeks to ensure that extending votes to 16-year-olds, as argued by the noble Lord Wallace of Saltaire, that it is accompanied by the necessary citizenship education to prepare young people to exercise their new rights and responsibilities as citizens. And a number of noble Lords emphasized this in the context of debates about 16 and 17-year-olds in our first day in Committee. The amendment calls for a catch-up program of political and media literacy and citizenship, supported by teacher training, with particular attention to the needs of student groups facing socioeconomic disadvantage, or who most lack electoral confidence, including girls and young women. I applaud the extension of As I said on day one, I applaud the extension of the franchise Oh, sorry, before that I should say that Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, who has added her name in support, asked me to give her apologies that she can't be in her place, and that she can't speak to her own Amendment 44, which would place responsibility for citizenship education on the Electoral Commission, but otherwise is very similar in its tone to my own amendment.

So, I, as I said, I applaud the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, but I'm well aware, from research that I was involved in as an academic some years ago, that some young people lack confidence about voting, not surprisingly. Professor Bryony Hoskins of the University of Roehampton, who has conducted more recent research and to whom I'm grateful for her assistance, tells me that young people approach their first election with unequal access to political learning, unequal confidence and different opportunities to practice making their voices heard. Without action to address these differences, there is a risk that the reform will disproportionately benefit those already equipped to participate. This underlines the importance of good citizenship education. I was a member of the Select Committee on Citizenship and Civic Engagement, the spirit of which lived on in the recent QSD in the name of the noble Lord Norton of Louth.

The committee emphasised that citizenshi- citizenship education has a crucial role to play in helping to build active citizens, and that its importance is all the greater in the context of the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds. More recently, the APPG on Political and Media Literacy, supported by Shout Out UK, to whom I'm also grateful for their help, has pointed to a growing body of research indicating that young people who receive structured political and media education demonstrate higher levels of civic engagement and greater resi- resilience to misinformation, and they're more likely to become first-time voters, which increases the chances of them voting subsequently. With regard to gender, Professor Hoskins' research has shown that, even though girls tend to outperform boys in civic knowledge, they demonstrate lower confidence in their ability to understanding and engage in formal politics. Longitudinal research in England shows that the gender gap in political confidence widens between ages 11 and 16, precisely the years preceding the proposed voting age. When it comes to socioeconomic disadvantage, the IPPAD UK adolescent study found that civic confidence diverges sharply by place, and its report suggested that democratic confidence is shaped not only by age, but also by socioeconomic experience.

Another study by Dr. James Weinberg at the University of Sheffield underlined the current fragmented state of democratic education in England, with stark disparities between private schools and state schools serving affluent communities on the one hand, and state schools in economically deprived communities on the other. Moreover, more affluent parents were more likely to talk to their children about politics and to feel confident doing so. It's perhaps not surprising that other research found that, when they have access to it, disadvantaged students often gain more from citizenship education than do their more privileged peers. G-EPIC, Gender Empowerment through Politics in the Classroom, research undertaken by Professor Hoskins, has developed and evaluated teaching approaches designed to strengthen political confidence, particularly among more disadvantaged girls. Their research should inform the kind of catch-up programme envisaged in this amendment.

Indeed, ACT, the Association for Citizenship Teaching, who've done so much to press the cause of citizenship education, are currently promoting these teaching resources. Now, I welcome the government's appreciation of the importance of citizenship education, especially to newly enfranchised voters, as expressed for example by my noble friend Baroness Smith of Malvern in winding up the recent QSD. I have a number of questions to put to my noble friend the Minister now. One, how will the government ensure that newly enfranchised young people receive appropriate citizenship education before their first opportunity to vote?

Two, how will that provision address the gender and socioeconomic inequalities in political confidence that I've raised? Three, what teacher training and resources will support inclusive delivery? And four, how will implementation be evaluated to establish its success in benefiting young people facing the greatest barriers to political participation? My Lords, in concluding, I want to stress the urgency of this kind of catch-up program envisaged in this amendment. In their briefing on the bill, the Electoral Commission notes we've long recommended improvements of the democratic education in schools and the lowering of the voting age makes this more pressing.

As my noble friend Baroness Smith of Malvern said at the end of the QSD, "This is a pivotal moment for citizenship education." The need to act quickly was emphasized by my noble friend Lord Blunkett, the honorary president of ACT, who regrets he can't be in his place. He warned that if we fail to revise the curriculum so as to inform, educate, and equip young people to take on voting at the ages of 16 and 17, it will be a dereliction of duty. Please, can my noble friend the Minister reassure us that we will fill fulfill our duty to the young people who will exercise their rights and responsibilities as citizens for the first time, hopefully, at the next general election?

04:05:31 - 04:06:42

Speaker 144

My Lords, I wish to very briefly speak in favor to support amendments 23 and 43. Following on from my noble friend, I know that my noble friend Lord Blunkett would say that the new curriculum, in which citizenship is made a compulsory subject for primary schools and a stronger emphasis on the subject should be in secondary schools, and that should be introduced in 2027 rather than 2028. So I would ask my noble friend if it might be possible to change the curriculum and introduce the changes in 2028. I understand that the citizenship GCSE is really rather good, and I would encourage all schools to ensure that the maximum number of students were able to study for that GCSE. But I do know that there's a dearth of citizenship teachers, and I would also ask my noble friend the Minister what we are doing to ensure that there are more teachers qualified to teach citizenship, because, as the noble Lord Saltaire said Lord Wallace of Saltaire said, that is the way to ensure that it's properly taught and taught impartially.

04:06:42 - 04:10:42

Michael Stahel Farmer

I'm rising to speak to my and Lady Meacher's amendment number 24 and also to amendments 280 and 287. My Lords, at second reading, I spoke against plans to lower the voting age to 16 on three grounds: evidence of brain development, the confusion that these plans bring to our policy approach to maturity, and they're playing to the imperative to give evermore stuff to voters, in this case young people.

Young people face far more pressing issues which are far harder to resolve. Progress on these would lead to much more substantive and beneficial change. Today I will focus on the first of these.

I tabled Amendments 24, 280 and 287, partly in response to the noble Baroness the Minister's response. I am grateful that she found time in her closing remarks at second reading to refer to my speech, but what she said concerned me as to how clear I had been. She mentioned scientific evidence I gave against 16 and 17 year-olds being able to vote, saying, and I quote, "We do not give people the vote based on their intellectual or cognitive abilities, and that applies to 16 and 17 year-olds as it does to all our voters." I had not at all been arguing to restrict voting to those with sufficient cognitive and intellectual ability. That would be elitist.

I was not talking about what a 16 year-old understands. My remarks were exclusively about maturity. I mentioned how staff across the Youth Custody Service always refer to 16 and 17 year-olds as children, not because of their cognitive ability, but to remind themselves of their relative immaturity. Neuroscience has quantified and plotted on a graph what brain maturation looks like at 16. I cited the much-respected developmental psychologist, Professor Laurence Steinberg, whose studies have found that across all demographic groups and both sexes, resistance to peer influence increases in a linear fashion between ages 14 and 18, and seems pretty set for the majority at the end of that period.

Hence, typically, by 18, most young people have developed the capacity to stand up for what they believe and withstand peer pressure. I highlighted other studies of the brain's control system, or executive functions, which enable young people to regulate their emotional reactions, perhaps to a shared reel or video short, and make independent judgments. They only stabilize to adult levels in late adolescence, 18 to 20 year-olds. As the researchers of a key study say, "results provide a canon a canonical trajectory of executive function maturation that demarcates the boundaries of adolescence." Lowering the voting age tramples these boundaries, and appears evidentially indefensible.

My and Lady Meyer's Amendment 24 requires that, before 16 and 17 year-olds are given this responsibility, evidence of their decision-making capabilities, maturity and capacity for independent decision-making is compared with that of 18 year-olds, and the assessment published. This major constitutional step should not be taken without serious consideration of the evidence base. Amendments 280 and 287 enable this requirement for the delayed commencement.

04:10:42 - 04:15:33

Speaker 142

My Lords, my Lords, I rise to speak to Amendment 24 tabled by my noble friend Lord Farmer, to which I have added my name. sorry, This amendment asks for something entirely reasonable: proper assessment of the evidence about the decision-making capability of 16 and 17 year-olds compared with those of 18 or over. Surely, before lowering the voting age, Parliament should have that evidence.

This is not about questioning young people's intelligence or enthusiasm. It is about whether, at that age, they have developed the maturity and independence of judgment to understand the long-term consequences of their decisions.

Scientific evidence is there. To give an example, Professor Sally Baxendale, a clinical neuropsychologist at UCL, explains that during adolescence, the brain undergoes extensive rewiring. The connections responsible for rational judgment, impulse control and assessing long-term consequences are still developing. In other words, a 16 year old at 16, the brain is still very much a work in progress. Research also shows that teenagers are particularly sensitive to emotions, immediate rewards and peer pressure.

This is particularly so in today's world of social media influencer, foreign interference and online campaigning. Of course, many 16-year-olds are intelligent and politically engaged, but intelligence is not the same as maturity. Most of them are still at school, living at home and having yet experienced real independence. Voting is not just about expressing an opinion, it's about choosing who governs us, who taxes us and who makes decision affecting our future. We already recognise that young people need protection.

Both the Children's Act and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child generally recognises that those under 18 are children. As noted before, in England, young people cannot marry, buy alcohol or tobacco, serve on a jury, or stand for Parliament until they are 18. And let me remind this House that the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Minimum Age) Act of 2022 passed with cross-party support, including Labour, raised the minimum age of marriage to 18 even with parental consent. Why? To protect children from forced marriages and family cohesion coercion.

If we protect children from family coercion over marriage, should we not equally be concerned about pressure from parents or other adults to entice them to vote in a particular way? Surely, the principle is the same: protecting children from coercion. Only a few months ago, the government announced plans to restrict children's access to social media to give kids their childhood back. But how does involving children in political decisions give them their childhood back? And isn't it not bizarre that the government considers 16-year-olds still in needs of protection from TikTok, yet old enough to choose who will govern the country?

And, my Lords, the bill proposes bringing children into the electoral registration system before they are even old enough to vote. When questioned the other day, the minister told us that, even by the age of 14, children have decided what subjects they want to continue to study as a reason why children at 14 should be involved. But, surely, choosing school subjects is hardly comparable to choosing who would govern our country. Several noble Lords who spoke

04:15:33 - 04:15:51

Speaker 143

My Lords, forgive me. I don't know if the noble Lady was in the Chamber when we discussed these issues, but two days ago. But all of the arguments to which she has quite rightly addressed this afternoon were indeed rehearsed two days ago. They have been discussed and debated very widely.

04:15:51 - 04:17:47

Speaker 142

But I was basically talking on the amendments which requires evidence. And this is why I was talking about that we don't have the evidence. And, in fact, the evidence we have shows us the contrary, that under the age of 18, children are probably not mature enough. So, as noble Lords did point out before, So I was talking about, sorry, but surely choosing which subjects you study at school is not comparable with choosing who should run our country.

And this is where a lot of noble Lords before me questioned whether this is not a question that the Government thinks would encourage young people to vote for their Government. And I cannot But I suspect if the figures were different, and young people voted for the Conservative Government, we would have a very different argument at this stage. Changing the voting age should not be a member of a matter of principle, but sorry, I've been interrupted, I can't go on like this.

Changing the voting age should be a matter of principle, not electoral advantage. I'm particularly concerned about vulnerable children, including children in care, who evidence tells us are more susceptible to pressure or manipulation. So, surely, before extending the franchise to younger and potentially vulnerable people, the Government should establish whether they have the maturity and independence of judgment to exercise the right without undue influence.

04:17:47 - 04:18:03

Richard Balfe

As someone who grew up as a child in care, I can assure the House that I did not fit into the description put forward by the noble Lady.

04:18:03 - 04:19:26

Speaker 142

Sorry. The Government points out that in Scotland, Wales, the Isle of Man, Jersey and Guernsey, children at 16 can vote in certain elections. But my Lords, UK general elections, who takes responsibility for our national defense, security, are quite different to elections in those smaller countries. These are decisions on war and peace. So, if the Government is confident that 16-year-old is appropriate for voting an appropriate voting age, surely it should welcome a proper assessment and explain why it is prepared to disregard scientific concerns about maturity and independent judgment, or is the political advantage the real reason behind this proposal?

So, I therefore ask the Government to look at this amendment and bring forward some evidence. And, frankly, some of us might even question whether we have fully acquired the elements needed to vote at the age of 18.

04:19:26 - 04:22:47

Claire Fox

My Lords. My Lords, I share some of the worries summed up by Amendments 18 and 19 in the name of the noble Lord Fuller, about ensuring that all sides of the arguments are heard by our newly-enfranchised 16-year-olds, especially looked after children.

I've noted as well, Amendments 43 in the name of Baroness Lister and Amendment 44 in the name of Baroness Bennett, that both focus on the role of education and the role it can play in preparing young people for voting. And of course, as a former teacher, I always welcome more knowledge-based education, but I am concerned for a number of reasons which I just wanted to raise now. Firstly, that this puts an undue teacher, burden on teachers, because, as we know, every time there's a social problem in this country, somebody says education will solve it and teachers are tearing their hair out every time they hear it. But secondly, how on earth might we trust that if this is the main source of information that young people are going to get before they vote, that it's suitably impartial? In an earlier group,

there was a very important discussion and concern about undue influence on voters. Sometimes from families, sometimes women being coerced, sometimes religious groups, and so on and so forth. And we all took that very seriously. It was a very important debate.

But here we have to ask whether young voters could be unduly influenced, too. And we have to ask: by what? And so, I'm concerned about how we ensure that if we talk about education and link it to, directly, as these amendments do, to 16-year-olds being prepared to vote, that it's based on impartial information. As my Lords will know or note, my concerns in relation to votes for 16-year-olds is about their dependence on state bodies as people who have not got the majority, because I want to protect the notion of independence of all voters. And it seems to me that we're going to have a group of voters who, by the nature of the way society is organized, are not independent.

And that most expresses itself, funnily enough, in school or in instances of, for example, looked-after children, or dependence on the state or local councils, as the noble Lord Fuller explained. There's a general concern that I've also got that this whole discussion could lead to the politicization of schools that really worries me. The noble Lord Wallace of Saltaire, made the point that education is subversive. Absolutely.

And to be fair, I'm a great fan of being subversive. I kind of try and make a bit of a habit of it. But it's just that I don't necessarily think that linking education as subversive with, and then you must now go out and be a responsible citizen and vote, could get us into some difficulties. In Baroness Lister's amendment, Oh, sorry.

04:22:47 - 04:23:20

Margot Ruth Lister

As she referred to my amendment and you have concerns about it, I would remind that I did make the point about, in my questions, about training and resources because it does have to be adequately resourced. But could I ask the noble lady, does she not agree with the whole concept of citizenship education? Because that does seem to be the tenor of her remarks. I mean, it's I wondered whether the noble lady disagreed with the whole concept of citizenship education, because that does seem to be the tenor of her remarks.

04:23:20 - 04:26:40

Claire Fox

No.

And I'm about to explain my concerns about the amendment of the noble lady Baroness Lister. I actually think that citizenship education can be excellent, but I also think and I think it's it sounds like a sensible, impartial intervention, pragmatic as a catch-up program on political and media literacy, but I have concerns, which is why I'm raising them, not posing, I'm raising them and probing. Citizenship education in recent years has in my experience of going into schools and working in educational settings and so on become somewhat muddled in terms of its agenda and is often a vehicle for social justice campaigning when you actually look at what's going on. If I can use one example, there's a there's a call in the amendment for example for experts, charities and civil society organizations to give advice to the government on the kind of citizenship education. And that sounds as though we're talking about, you know, charities, who what could go wrong with that, or civil society organizations, or NGOs, except that we all know that actually, very often, they're highly politicized, highly partial, and there's all sorts of controversies about it.

And we have one recent example, which was during the Black Lives Matter period in relation to George Floyd, many schools actually invited in NGOs and charities and organizations to help them sort out how they best deal with the response to that Black Lives Matters. And we ended up with quite extensive, and in some instances toxic, examples of the introduction of critical race theory into classrooms, unconscious bias training, children going around accusing others of having white privilege, decolonizing the curriculum off the scale and so on and so forth. Also to know that when we so I'm my query is we have to be careful about the use of or the idea that charities and third parties in relation to educating children for elections are not just a vehicle for political propaganda. And just on that, by the way, the noble Lord Wallace of Saltaire, cited favourably BBC Bitesize as an educational provision. I don't know if he's noted that BBC Bitesize has been withdrawn by and large by the BBC because it's decided that the material was partial, and there was a lot of problematic content in it on everything from gender ideology, it was at odds with equality law, and a lot of the advice it got was from Mermaids and Stonewall, who have also been invited into schools as third-party organizations in relation to that particular issue.

So, I'm all for civics education. In fact, I'm an enthusiast for it, but I just don't think you can say the words and hope you get what you think you're going to get. And I think here— Oh, sorry.

04:26:40 - 04:26:51

William Wallace

Doing my best to follow the logic of the noble baroness' argument, is she saying that civic education is fine, but no social justice should be taught?

04:26:51 - 04:29:10

Claire Fox

I'm suggesting that social justice in a particular reading of it is one-sided and political in a way, so this is what where I was going, that we need to show some caution, because civics education per se is one thing. This is an argument that civics education should be used to prepare young people to vote in elections, which is a different thing. And I'm saying we have to show some caution, and I'm going to come back to this, you'll be delighted to know, in a later group. But anyway, just to finish with one example that I think might illustrate my point, at a debate on education that I was on the panel after the last after the last election in fact, a head teacher on the panel shared with the audience with horror that a citizenship studies mock election in his school had seen some pupils stand as Reform candidates.

Even worse, they won overwhelmingly. He used this as an example of the dangerous radicalisation of youth and the need to tackle extremism, and that the school was now working on ensuring that pupils who exhibited such traits would be introduced to ideas that would counter them. Now, I make no political party political point here, but I do think that it raises the kind of issues that I'm concerned about, which is how dare the head teacher see a political party in this country as the wrong political party? But in the context of votes for 16-year-olds, I mean, I was shocked then, but and I argued back, you can imagine. But I just think that with 16-year-old voting on the horizons, we have to ensure that such political prejudices don't become undue influence over political decision-making by 16-year-olds who are being told that they're being treated as adults to make up their own mind.

But if we depend on schools to shape their minds around the very particular political issues that they'll have to choose around, we're in trouble.

04:29:10 - 04:32:15

Speaker 70

My Lords, it's always a pleasure to once again follow Baroness Fox on the debate on this bill. And I want to pick I want to pick up two amendments that I would like to speak to. First, 24, and can I congratulate Lord Farmer, Baroness Meyer, who do know a huge amount of in this field and are experts in this area, and I'm very grateful to them for their contributions and their amendments today. And the area I want to focus on is peer pressure. And Baroness Royall is right, we did discuss this two days ago.

This is a different slightly different perspective. When I raise peer pressure and last time, I think the noble Lady, the Minister, responded, to the extent she did, about saying that the government doesn't go into cognitive development and doesn't wish to go into cognitive development, which I accept. But this is a different issue. This is about peer pressure. And, again, last time Baroness Royall challenged me on the scientific evidence I claimed, and the my noble friend Baroness O'Neill gave some answer, and it was confirmed by Baroness Meyer independently, by the way, that the expert in this field, Professor Laurence Steinberg of Temple University, has written, both on his own and with others, extensively about the peer pressure and the inability of children to resist peer pressure that gets better for children as they reach to and beyond the age of 18.

But it does raise some very important questions, which is the government, and I say this hopefully in a cooperative spirit, the government really needs to recognise that there is a potential problem of peer pressure for voters of the age of 16 and it needs to take steps to ensure that children are able to make decisions without that peer pressure. Lord Wallace of Saltaire made the very good point after he had gone into the internal machinations of the Conservative Party, which is one of his favourite subjects, but he made the point that it's vital that voters make independent choices, make independent decisions based on their own experiences and their own determination.

And my fear is that there will be gangs, there will be influencers, in certain communities there'll be family pressure, extensive family pressure, for people to make their vote in a certain way. And the response from the front bench before, as well as, you know, there's always peer pressure, is fair, but what we're saying here is that there is evidence that 16 to 18-year-olds are more susceptible to peer pressure than people over the age of 18. So, what steps will the government take to ensure that they are protected?

04:32:15 - 04:32:16

Will the noble Lord give way?

04:32:17 - 04:32:41

Charles John Fuller

My noble friend has just mentioned about the people who are 16 to 18 and can vote. But throughout this bill, we're assuming that people aged 14 or above as attainers are going to prepare to vote. And I just wonder whether the noble Lord would think a little bit about those people, not just who have reached 16, but who are under 16 and even more susceptible to peer pressure.

04:32:41 - 04:36:56

Speaker 70

Well, I couldn't agree more, but I didn't want to go down that route because I would then be accused because the counterargument would be, well, we're only given the votes to 16-year-olds, although who knows in future it may be 14-year-olds. But my noble friend is absolutely spot on. The second amendment I wanted to address is 44A in the absence of Baroness Berridge. I am very worried about this. I have done a lot of canvassing.

I've actually canvassed in every election since 1979, all for the same party, I hasten to add, and not always with much success, but nevertheless, I've been out there regularly in a multitude of constituencies, very many. And I've regularly, particularly in my own constituency, Queens Park and Maida Vale, which was Westminster North, found myself canvassing people who literally spoke no English. And when I knock on the door and try and communicate with them, they immediately pick up the phone and speak to their spouse, or someone I don't know who, and ask for instructions what to say. So, that is one issue. But the particular issue on 44A is about protecting children.

And again, as a canvasser, and I'm sure everybody in this House, all your all noble Lords have done their share of canvassing, when one when a door is answered by a 16-year-old in the past, one has simply said, "Can I speak to your parents?" Now, I'm going to have to engage with 16-year-olds. And this presents some, in my view, presents some challenges. I'm personally not particularly comfortable about the idea of having to knock on the door and engage in conversation with a 16-year-old to try to persuade them to vote for my party. I don't want to be I just don't want to be in that position.

I'm comfortable with an 18-year-old; I'm not comfortable with it doing that with a 16-year-old. And indeed the government recognises that 16-year-olds have to be protected. If I want to interact with 16-year-olds at the various schools where I'm involved, I have to be cleared to do that. I can't just rock off into the classroom without having various checks. But as a canvasser, I can knock on the door and engage with this here and in with a 16-year-old without any checks.

And okay, I'm not worried about me, but I am worried about other people. And let's take this to let's take this not to absurd, but to a logical conclusion. What is to stop predators identifying children now on the electoral roll, identifying them and going to see them supposedly to canvass them, but actually with other purposes in mind? And I'm very worried about this, because I can see that they can justify to the authorities that they are entering into dialogue with a 16-year-old because, they will claim, they're out canvassing, but they have an ulterior motive.

And so, what I want to know from the government is, what protection do they plan to give in those particular circumstances? And of course, it gets a lot worse if we're saying that 14 and 15-year-olds need to be educated, because what then happens to someone who says, perhaps with some credibility, "I want to go and talk to 14 and 15-year-olds because they need to be persuaded to vote for my party, and heaven knows what's going to happen on the doorstep." Regularly, when I go canvassing, I'm invited to go in to discuss the subject over a glass of wine or a cup of tea or whatever, and, of course, I always refuse because that's the guidance. But that doesn't mean that other people will do that. It means you we are giving people the opportunity to enter vulnerable people's homes and children's, if children are on their own, homes to go and have a discussion with them supposedly about political matters, but who knows?

So, I don't have the answer to this problem, but I can see that it is a real problem, and I'd be very grateful if the noble lord, the minister, can address it, either now or later.

04:36:56 - 04:37:58

Speaker 147

My Lords, as a young person, I was so susceptible to subversive influences such as the BBC Television News, the Radio 4 World at One which I listened to every day, and my buying the Guardian daily also, that by the time I was 14, I was the treasurer of my branch of the Liberal Party. And by the time I was 16, I was secretary of the constituency. Now, I don't suggest for a moment that is normal for a teenager, but my point is that people are very different and should be treated differently. Turning to these amendments, the most publicized aspect of this bill is that which we debated on Monday, the principle of extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, and I don't wish to go over those arguments again. But I do wish to say that the good intention of seeking to encourage the engagement of young people in political processes will fail unless we do much more about citizenship education.

04:37:58 - 04:41:30

Speaker 146

If we don't, I accept that there are greater risks to our democracy, especially in the internet age, as most young people rely on information obtained online. Now, the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Political and Media Literacy, of which I'm an active member, it says in its briefing that foundational political and media literacy education is crucial to the health of our democracy. It warns that simply changing the voting age will not, in itself, encourage more civic responsibility or more sustained participation in democratic processes. I mentioned on Monday how Jersey lowered its voting age to 16 in 2008, but it was not such a successful experience because of the lack of civic education to support it. The research compiled by the Academic Advisory Group to our APPG reveals both an overwhelming desire among young people to engage, and a troubling structural deficit in how our current school system prepares them for it.

Young people rely heavily on social media, therefore, they are more vulnerable to digital misinformation unless educated and equipped with critical media literacy tools that should be part of citizenship education. Baroness Lister of Burtersett quoted the excellent research from Dr. James Weinberg.

He studied information from over 3,000 teachers across over half of all secondary schools. He found that at present less than a third of secondary schools currently offer weekly lessons in political or curricular citizenship education, and over 25% provide no democratic education whatsoever. She also drew attention to how state schools serving economically deprived communities provide significantly less political literacy education than private schools or state schools in affluent areas. It seems to me, my lord, my lords, that democratic confidence must not remain the preserve of the privileged,

and the dangers of ignorance amongst the most disadvantaged represents a threat to the principles of that which should underpin a democracy. Teachers want to deliver this vital education, but they are let down by a lack of institutional support. That is why we must embed statutory guarantees into this bill. Amendment 23, which I have signed, places a statutory duty on the Secretary of State to report to Parliament on progress in strengthening civic education in schools and tracking youth registration rates. I also support, of course, Amendment 43 by the noble Baroness, Lady Lister of Burtersett.

My lords, schools are the most trusted institutions for learning about democracy. I hope that the government will accept the principle of these amendments as they are essential to making the aims of the bill in relation to extending the franchise work meaningfully and in a safe way.

04:41:30 - 04:42:47

Speaker 32

My Lords, I think as several noble Lords have illustrated in their speeches and their amendments in this group, it is important that we get the information and educational framework right. And in fact that would be the case even if this bill didn't contain a change in the voting age, but all the more so given the change that it does contain. And I hope we will hear some positive noises from the government in due course on that important topic. And I'll just briefly reflect that as we all know, the decision, whether we agree with it or not, but the decision that this bill legislates for to reduce the voting age to 16 was a manifesto commitment from the party that won a clear majority under our voting system, which I know some noble Lords near me are particularly keen on that voting system, but, you know, the Labour Party won a overwhelming majority with a very clear manifesto commitment. And I'm not sure how good a use of time it is given all the other many important matters of scrutiny that we need to get through at committee stage to be continually relitigating that basic point of principle, which clearly was a manifesto commitment, has been debated extensively already, and there are many other issues that we really need to get time to get stuck into.

And having said that, I will follow my own advice and therefore bring my remarks to a close.

04:42:47 - 04:43:25

Speaker 148

And I'll start where he left off. My Lords, I'm grateful to all noble Lords who's contributed to this debate. The amendments in this group raise many important questions about the responsibilities that accompany the government's proposal to lower the voting age to 16. It is a manifesto commitment. We accepted that, but what we're saying is there are responsibilities that go alongside and things that the government need to actually be aware of and address, because there is no doubt those people out there will be asking it.

04:43:25 - 04:44:34

Speaker 149

So, we should all agree that young people ought to understand how our democracy works, how to register there to vote and how to exercise their democratic rights.

But we must consider whether the government have put sufficient thought into the education and safeguards necessary if the change to the franchise is to go ahead. My noble friend, Lord Fuller's, amendments 18 and 19 would sensibly require political neutral and balanced voter registration to be provided to young people. These amendments seek to prevent local authorities run by any particular party from influencing election material one way or the other. Councils are fundamentally political organisations, we must not forget. My noble friend, Lord Fuller, has accurately identified that looked after children are socially vulnerable, and also at risk of being influenced by the authority that looks after them. And we should be aware of it.

04:44:34 - 04:45:30

Speaker 150

It's a fundamental point. Information provided by public authorities must be impartial, especially when it concerns young people who may be engaging with the electoral system for the very first time. Can the noble baroness the minister explain what safeguards will ensure that registration information provided by local authorities and the relevant bodies in Northern Ireland is politically neutral, and how will compliance be assessed and monitored? I welcome my noble friend Lord Farmer's amendments 24, 280, 287, concerning the decision-making abilities of 16- and 17-year-olds. And I congratulate Baroness Meyer for actually putting the case for consideration of the safeguards around that as well.

04:45:30 - 04:46:06

Speaker 149

These amendments ask the government to assess the evidence before implementing a significant constitutional change. It's not saying that change isn't going to happen; it's consider it beforehand. Can the noble baroness the minister explain what assessment the government have undertaken of the decision-making abilities of 16- and 17-year-olds? And will the minister commit to publishing that evidence before the new voting age comes into effect? These amendments concerning citizenship education and political literacy are also relevant.

04:46:06 - 04:48:21

Speaker 148

The noble lady Lister of Burtersett, amendment 43, both propose a programme of education and citizenship in secondary schools. Lord Wallace of Saltaire also raises that the Secretary of State should report on the progress in the changes to citizenship education. Thus, there's clearly a shared recognition across this Lordships' house that extending the franchise cannot be considered in isolation from the education that young people receive. Everyone in agreement on that one. However, I must respectfully disagree with Lady Bennett's amendments, albeit it was un-moved.

Whilst I welcome the underlying suggestion that children should be educated about their duties to vote, we should not single out groups of children and educate them based on a supposed groupings. Different children must not be educated differently about the vote they share. As we saw in the fruitful debate on ballot secrecy, we must be careful that political education does not become political persuasion.

Can the noble Baroness the Minister tell us what guidance will be provided to schools and teachers to ensure that such education remains balanced, and what additional resources will make be made available to deliver it? My noble friend, Lady Berridge, is unfortunately unable to be in her place today, and although my noble friend, Lord Leigh of Hurley, has made reference to her amendment, actually, I thought she raised a very valid point, and if you bear with me, I think most of us in this Chamber have canvassed and knocked on doors. And when we see a young person, we generally say, can we speak to mum and dad or your carer? We will now have to assess what age that young person had is, and maybe engage a conversation with them. It's something that we really need to consider as a consequence of this proposal.

04:48:21 - 04:49:09

Speaker 150

So, going forward, canvassers will be engaging with younger vote voters, and my noble friend raises the issue about whether there will need to be necessary safeguarding guidance for political campaigners engaging with children. It's something we should think about. It's particularly an important issue. If political parties and campaigners are to engage more directly with younger people younger voters, appropriate safeguards must be in place. Will the noble Baroness the Minister explain what guidance will govern contact between political campaigners and the children, and whether the Government intend to consult safeguarding professionals before the rele- relevant provisions commence?

04:49:09 - 04:49:57

Speaker 149

My Lords, as I said in earlier debates, electoral reform should strengthen public confidence in our democratic system, not introduce uncertainty about the protections on which it depends. The Government has chosen to lower the voting age as a manifesto commitment. It's therefore incumbent upon them to demonstrate that young people will receive impartial information, sufficient education and appropriate safeguarding. They should be properly prepared and protected when exercising that right. I hope the Minister will address these questions in detail and provide reassurance that the practical consequences of this change have been fully and properly considered.

04:49:57 - 04:52:37

Jane Sharon Taylor

Hear. My Lords, before I respond to the amendments, can I just correct a date I gave under the previous group of amendments? I said that the tabling date for amendments for the next set of committee discussions was on the 9th of November. It's on the 17th of November. It's not.

So, my apologies for that, and the amendments for that section will be tabled then. I wanted to just say at the start of this section that the Government of course is committed to ensuring that everyone who's entitled to vote should be able to do so, and supported and encouraged in that. And the provisions that we're making are designed to ensure that vulnerable people who are eligible to vote are enabled, but of course it's quite right that all young people must be prepared for this change to the electoral franchise. The Government's already working with the Electoral Commission, devolved governments, the electoral sector, and civil society organisations, to raise awareness of the franchise change among young people, and to help prepare them to exercise their democratic rights. I'll go into a bit more detail about schools provision in a moment.

But I did want to also I thought it might be helpful to say to noble Lords that we've carried out extensive research, both quantitative and qualitative, to speak to those aged 14 to 17.

A total of 32 focus groups were conducted over two stages, followed by a nationally representative survey of over 3,500 respondents, utilizing both online and offline data collection. The key headlines from that research, which I thought were really interesting, most young people do have a form of valid voter ID, most regard voter ID as necessary, the education system is seen by young people as a good way to learn about these topics, and the majority do feel that their voice would matter more if they had votes at 16.

So, that was the key headlines, but it was a big piece of research. So, the other thing that has slightly surprised me about this is that the debates have taken a direction both on Monday and today that I wasn't really expecting. You know, I think it's a shame that we've had significant doubts cast on teachers' impartiality. We now appear to have doubts being cast on those responsible for looked-after children and the BBC,

and

04:52:37 - 04:53:27

Claire Fox

Only two weeks ago the government intervened about the problems of a lack of partiality amongst teachers in relation to the Israel-Gaza, Palestine commitments, and I congratulated the government at the time for making a stance about the difficulties of that issue. And the clarity was, we have to be very careful from the government. So, I cast no aspersions in general. Well, just as the government noted on a particular issue in relation to the rise of antisemitism and politicization of that war in schools,

the government rightly intervened, and I congratulated you then and now. And I didn't then think that you were casting aspersions on all teachers. You weren't, and neither were the rest of us.

04:53:27 - 04:54:59

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I think these issues have to be tackled when and as they arise. I think to make general points relating to that, it is not helpful. So, that was the point I was actually making. I'd like to start addressing the particular amendments now. I understand and share the noble Lord Fuller's intention that young people should receive impartial information, as expressed in amendments 18 and 19.

I would like to reassure him that clauses 15 and 16 are deliberately narrow in scope. They require local authorities in Great Britain and health and social care trusts in Northern Ireland, where the system is different, to raise awareness of the arrangements for registration that apply to relevant young people and to help those young people register. This is about factual, practical electoral registration information, making sure young people who are or have been in the care system understand how they can register and, where necessary, helping them to do so. I can therefore reassure the noble Lord we fully recognize the importance of political impartiality, but I don't consider that an additional statutory requirement of this kind is needed.

Turning now to amendment 23 from the noble Lord Wallace and Lord Rennard and the noble Baroness Prashar, and can I congratulate the noble Lord Wallace for bringing such sartorial elegance to the chamber this afternoon? It's a panache bringing to our debate at the end of this week's session.

04:54:59 - 04:55:30

William Wallace

I apologize, my other dissent here, the parliament choir is performing this evening, and the dress rehearsal starts at 4:00, so I have said that I will be late. May I also add that there is strong scientific evidence that collective singing in schools improves social cohesion and concentration? I'm not sure the last government accepted that scientific evidence and certainly didn't act on it. If we get talking about scientific evidence in the schools, singing matters as well.

04:55:30 - 04:59:59

Jane Sharon Taylor

I wish the noble Lord very well for his rehearsal, and I look forward to coming to one of the concerts in due course. Noble Lords may recall that a similar amendment to the this was debated during committee stage in the other place, and our position remains that a statutory reporting requirement is not the right way to approach this. The amendment would require the report to cover three areas: raising awareness, civic education, and electoral registration. So, I will address each in turn. First of all, on raising awareness, I agree with noble Lords that young people need to be aware of their new democratic rights.

The government is already working alongside the Electoral Commission, local and devolved governments, the electoral sector, and civil society organisations to make sure our young people are aware of the changes. Raising awareness will be a collective effort, involving organisations with different roles and responsibilities. A report from the government would not provide a complete picture of that work, and it would also not be right for government to report on behalf of other organisations involved in this work, particularly the Electoral Commission, whose independence from government is so vital, and which already publishes its own research and analysis on some of the areas covered by this amendment. Second, on civic education, I have no hesitation in agreeing with noble Lords on the vital importance of preparing young people to exercise their democratic rights. This is an area where we will continue to work with devolved governments and other partners.

The Department for Education leads on education policy in England, while education is devolved in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. All partners will need to work together to support young people's democratic engagement, and I'll cover more on that when I respond to Baroness Lister's amendment. Given these different roles and responsibilities, I don't believe a statutory report from the UK government is the right mechanism for assessing progress in this area. And finally, on electoral registration, substantial information is already publicly available. The Register to Vote performance dashboard provides aggregate data on applications to register to vote, including breakdowns by age.

The Electoral Commission has also conducted studies of electoral registration trends, and the government is separately planning to monitor and evaluate the implementation and impact of votes at 16 measures, which will assess evidence related to the awareness, education, and registration of young people. We do not believe that a further statutory report is necessary. So, I hope I've reassured your Lordships that the government shares the underlying objectives behind this amendment and is already taking forward work to support young people as the franchise is extended to 16 and 17 year olds. My Lords, coming now to Amendments 24, 280, and 287 in the name of the noble Lord, Farmer, and noble Baroness, Neayer, I would point out to noble Lords that these amendments would prevent voting rights from being extended to 16 and 17 year olds until the assessment has been published. The noble Lord raised similar concerns about the maturity and decision-making capabilities of 16 and 17 year olds during the bill's second reading in this house.

And indeed the noble Lord quoted my response to him at the time, which I still hold to, that we don't give people the vote based on intellectual or cognitive abilities, and that principle applies to 16 and 17 year olds as it does to all other voters. I'm sorry to repeat what he's already quoted back at me, but that is the case. Can I just finish this responding, and then I'm happily give way. Our focus on is on delivering this manifesto commitment on which this government was elected, which recognises that 16 and 17 year olds have views which deserve to be represented and that young people should have a say in decisions that affect them.

I simply cannot agree that young people at 16 and 17 do not have the cognitive reasoning to make decisions that impact on their lives. Indeed, as I set out on Monday, we've already asked them to do so. The question is not what else you can or can't do at 16, but is 16 the right age to vote. And the point of this process of engagement is to introduce the concepts of critical thinking. And indeed, young people at these young people of this age now have grown up having to develop their own ability to filter a whole plethora of social media in a way that my generation certainly did not.

04:59:59 - 05:01:10

Michael Stahel Farmer

I thank the noble minister for giving way. I wasn't talking about cognitive ability. That was the whole point that she mentioned in the second reading, and I was trying to say that was not what I was talking about. I was talking about the maturity of young people to withstand peer pressure and, you know, to have the maturity to make a reasoned decision, which we've heard today, you're electing a government, it's a very important responsible decision to make. And so, I mean, it we had the evidence from Professor Laurence Steinberg that, actually, it's at 18 that they are able to make their own judgements, withstand things like TikTok and peer pressure at school and make a reasoned political judgement independently.

And so, it's maturity I'm talking about, not cognitive ability.

05:01:10 - 05:01:57

Jane Sharon Taylor

I've heard what the noble Lord said. I would say requiring such an assessment before these changes can be implemented would introduce a completely unnecessary additional step, in my view, and could delay the delivery of what is a very important manifesto commitment and one which, as I've said, we have done a deal of research with young people. I would also respond to the noble Lord Leigh, who made some points around safeguarding and political canvassing. We have taken steps, as he will know, within the bill to say that attainers, 14- and 15-year-olds, won't be canvassed by the EROs, but I understand the point he's making is around political canvassing. I'm sure that political parties will be developing their own safeguarding response to the provisions in this bill.

05:01:57 - 05:02:53

Speaker 70

Can I intervene on that, first to say that we're not talking about cognitive development, and we're not talking about taking tests of people, we're talking about what steps are the government taking to protect people from peer pressure? And so far, the answer is none, and that is not very satisfactory. And secondly, in respect of what happens on the doorstep, the government can't rely on political parties because my whole point is that there will be individuals who will claim to be canvassers, who will go knock on doors and get entry into doors and in conversation with 16-year-olds under the pretext of being political campaign campaigners, and they will identify such people from the electoral roll. And one cannot expect political parties to know, to vet every single canvassers. It's up to the government, if they're going to introduce 16-year-old eligibility to vote and receive canvassers, to take steps to protect them.

05:02:53 - 05:03:29

Jane Sharon Taylor

There are all sorts of people who knock on our doors. You know, I think I understand what the noble Lord's saying. I will take those points away, but I seriously think the point of the education process is to teach young people to have that critical thinking capacity to make their own decisions about things. And I'm more than confident that our young people at 16 and 17 have the faculties to be able to do that. I would I'm going on now to talk a little bit more about the education process, and I think that's important in this.

05:03:29 - 05:03:35

Speaker 70

When the noble lady the minister says she's more than confident, is she refuting the evidence of Professor Steinberg?

05:03:35 - 05:08:31

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, hopefully I'll have an opportunity to speak to Professor Steinberg at some point, but I think we need to move on with talking about what we are going to do in terms of education. I thank my noble friend Baroness Lister for tabling Amendment 43, and the noble Baroness Bennett, who's not in her place today, for Amendment 44. I recognise the motivations of these amendments, and I share the ambition to ensure that young people are supported to exercise their democratic rights and build lifelong engagement with our democracy. And one of the fundamental points about all this is that we know that engaging young people at a much earlier age does encourage that lifelong engagement with the democratic process. This is a priority for the government.

We're already working to strengthen democratic education and engagement, including in response to the independent curriculum and assessment review. Citizenship is already a statutory national curriculum subject at key stages 3 and 4 in maintained schools, covering parliamentary democracy, electoral systems and how citizens can influence decisions. The government's wider curriculum reforms will strengthen this further, including through clearer teaching of democracy, media literacy and active citizenship. We're considering what transitional support may be needed before those reforms take effect, including practical, non-partisan voter information, adaptable teaching materials and support for teachers on issues such as political impartiality and misinformation. Alongside this, the Electoral Commission is undertaking important work to support young people's democratic education.

It is developing a democratic education framework in partnership with organisations across the education and youth sectors, providing practical resources to help educators and young people to understand and participate in democracy. This is currently being piloted, and a formal launch is planned in March 2027, which I hope answers my noble friend Baroness Royall's question. The Commission also runs a Welcome to Your Vote Week, an annual campaign which provides schools, colleges and youth organisations with opportunities to help people understand elections and build confidence in participating. Further, my department has established the Democratic Engagement Fund to support politically neutral projects that help people understand, engage with and participate in democracy. I recognise my noble friend's concern about young people from disadvantaged backgrounds and politically under-represented groups, including girls and young women, and this fund provides an opportunity to support projects that help break down barriers to democratic participation and ensure that more young people have the opportunity to make their voices heard.

I would just comment on some of the points that have been made about political impartiality in schools: that schools are already subject to clear legal duties on in on political impartiality. They must prohibit the promotion of partisan political views and take reasonably practical steps to ensure that where political issues are brought to pupils' attention, opposing views are presented in a balanced way. And the existing political impartiality in schools guidance makes it clear that these duties apply to public displays, including banners and posters, as well as school communications. We will continue to work with the Electoral Commission, devolved governments and civil society organisations to consider what additional measures can support schools, colleges and youth groups to deliver practical voter and civic education. I hope I've given my noble friend reassurance on these points, and Baroness Bennett on the role of the Electoral Commission.

I entirely recognise the importance of education and engagement in making votes at 16 a success, but I don't believe that further legislation is needed. Finally, turning to Amendment 44, the government recognises the importance of safeguarding young people, and the bill provides strong protections where those are needed, for example, on data protection.

16 and 17-year-olds and those who will turn 16 before polling day should have the same opportunity as any other voter to hear from candidates and political parties and to form an opinion before casting their vote. We completely agree with the importance of appropriate conduct during campaigning. We welcome the Speaker's Conference recommendation to establish a code of conduct for campaigning and have committed to work with the Speaker, the Electoral Commission and political parties to support the development of a code which is fit for purpose, which I hope responds a bit further to the noble Lord Lee's concerns. As part of this work, we have the opportunity to consider the specific issue raised in this amendment regarding safeguarding of young people in campaigning, and we therefore do not consider this amendment is likely to be necessary.

05:08:31 - 05:09:17

Speaker 148

Before the Minister sits down, I'm grateful for that last point. I must admit, as a previous council leader, when that point was raised with me about campaigning, it sent shivers down my spine because we know how important safeguarding is. I do think it might be worth perhaps a conversation at that all-party group so that it's put out through all the different parties so that they are aware of it because I'm sure many of them may not have considered it either, and that it's worth sharing that information. The other point I would like to put across your desk really: you say you've done, or you've got, an awful lot of research and you've had research done. Is it possible to share that with the House?

05:09:17 - 05:09:47

Margot Ruth Lister

To save the my noble friend having to bob up and down, a couple of questions which perhaps you could write to me afterwards about. One was about teacher training and resources that will support the kind of teacher- citizenship education we've been talking about, and the other was evaluation, particularly from the perspective of disadvantaged groups and those who lack political confidence, the greatest barriers to political participation, like girls and young women. Thank you.

05:09:47 - 05:10:34

Jane Sharon Taylor

On the noble Baroness O'Neill's points, I think that she makes a good point about the political parties panel, and I will take that back. On the research, I'm I've got some brief information about the research, but I'll write to her on that if that's okay. On my noble friend Baroness Lister's comments, we are looking at this transitional support about how we make sure we've got adaptable teaching materials and support for teachers on issues like political impartiality and misinformation. I'm happy to update her once that work's gone a bit further.

05:10:34 - 05:11:36

Charles John Fuller

It's been an interesting debate, and of course I support entirely comments on the front bench, that we understand the vote at 16 is a manifesto commitment. But what this last hour and, well, hour and 20 minutes has shown is how much of the consequences of that manifesto commitment are going to mean for the safeguarding of children, the impact on education, people who haven't really had to participate in economic society before. These are unintended consequences, and we're going to have to iron them out, not just for the 16-year-olds, but those attainers from 14. You see, for all the warm words about strengthening democracy and trip- improving transparency, which are littered throughout the impact statement, when it comes to amendments that would give effect to those noble causes, what I think I heard the Minister say was they're prepared to leave it to chance.

We're not going to cast aspersions, but we're going to address these issues

05:11:36 - 05:11:54

Jane Sharon Taylor

If I can give way for a moment, I didn't say we're leaving it to chance. I said we welcome the speaker's conference recommendation to establish codes of conduct on this subject, and we've committed to work with the speaker, the Electoral Commission and political parties to support the development of a code which is fit for purpose.

05:11:54 - 05:12:45

Charles John Fuller

I thank you and I accept those words entirely. But earlier on in the wind, when referring to Baroness Fox of Buckley, the suggestion was made that, well, are we casting aspersions onto teachers and social workers? And we were going to sort of address those as they came along. I just don't think that's right. I think the bill should be explicit about neutrality, particularly for schools and for social and looked after children's environments so there is no risk, because we must remove the temptation for those in positions of authority on some of the most vulnerable people without supportive natural parents to do it.

And if it isn't a problem because there is no prejudice, well, there's no problem in introducing it into the bill. I was very taken up with the other comments about

05:12:45 - 05:12:56

Jane Sharon Taylor

I don't like to do this, but I did make it clear that schools are already subject to clear legal duties on political impartiality, and I gave the details of that.

05:12:56 - 05:13:40

Charles John Fuller

Group six, which we will return to later, thank you very much. I was taken with Baroness's Fox's point about schools, but of course this has really been a debate not so much about schools, but about young people more generally. But I'd like to associate myself with the comments of Lord Wallace about, you know, the practical preparation, and of course this is the watchword of this part of the bill and protecting the minors. Look, this may be something we return to at report, and we need to catch up time, so I'll beg to leave beg leave to withdraw my amendments 18 and 19.

But we really do have to think some of these practical consequences before we get to report, and I hope the minister will meet with myself and others in furtherance of that objective.

05:13:40 - 05:14:54

Speaker 151

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? Amendment 19 not, sorry, we now need Clause 15. So, the question is that Clause 15 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say, "Content". Contrary, "Not content".

The contents have it. In Clause 16, Amendment 19, Lord Fuller not moved. Then we come to Clause 16. The question is that Clause 16 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say, "Content".

Contrary, "Not content". The contents have it. After Clause 16, Amendment 20, Lord Young of Acton not moved. Yeah, but we have to take action, we don't just leave it lying in the air. Of So, it is not moved.

Right, thank you. Amendment 21, Baroness Hoey not moved. Amendment 22, Baroness O'Neill of Bexley not moved. 23, Lord Wallace of Saltaire not moved. Amendment 24, Lord Farmer not moved.

Thank you. Amendment 25, Lord Frost.

05:14:54 - 05:28:56

David Frost

My Lords, I rise to speak to my Amendments 25 to 29, 288, 289 and 299 to 300 on the marshalled list. My Lords, before I move to the explanation of the thinking behind these amendments, let me just give a brief explanation of how they work from a technical point of view. These amendments form two alternative packages rather than a single scheme, and I'll explain why.

Amendments 25 to 26 would end voting and registration rights based solely on Commonwealth citizenship across the UK while preserving British, Irish and retained EU citizens' rights. Amendments 27 to 29 offer a reciprocal alternative. It would be one where Commonwealth citizens retained eligibility, but only where their country gave British citizens a similar, exercisable rights at corresponding elections. Ministers would have to designate those countries obviously through regulations approved by both Houses, publish the assessment and review periodically. The amendments are designed to focus on the Commonwealth issue, which is why they keep the existing non-national elections rights for the EU cohort and for Ireland.

And I'll come to those points, though I do think they merit debate at some point. Both packages also cover parliamentary, devolved and local elections. They cover, Baroness the noble Lady Baroness Bennett would be pleased to hear, though she's not in her place, they cover City of London ward elections and relevant referendums and other acts of democracy. They're drafted to be consistent with the amendments I put forward earlier in our discussions on devolution, though, of course, there's much room for debate about, as it were, how far down the hierarchy of elections these provisions really need to extend. Just to complete the technical introduction, Amendments 288-289 bring would bring the relevant administrative and designation machinery into operations into operation with the first draft regulations required within 12 months.

And then, finally, 299 to 300 would require the substantive nationality rules to start on the same day throughout the UK at least six months after the regulations, but unless there were polls and petitions already underway. My Lords, I put forward these two alternative routes because these are probing amendments, and they're designed to provoke discussion about the nature of the franchise in this country. And I think that's very much worth discussing. The only point I'll make at this stage on the distinction between them is that the reciprocal arrangements require much more process. There's much more complexity.

They require a system under which the government has to review whether reciprocal arrangements exist, whether they've changed, to report on them, and then, of course, to kind of feed that through into the electoral register. Such a system has to exist if a reciprocal arrangement is to work, and it is more complicated and more likely, I guess, to be got wrong, but it is a possibility. Let me move on to the thinking behind them. And once again, my Lords, we come back to a who question. Who gets to vote in the arrangements that we are describing?

And I find that when I'm discussing this issue, most people make an assumption that the franchise in a country is limited to citizens of that country. And I find that people are often extremely surprised when you tell them that's not the case in the United Kingdom, that we do extend the franchise quite considerably. And I find they often literally cannot believe it when they're told about the arrangements to Commonwealth repeating, which seems to me illustrates to me that there is an issue here that needs addressing.

Now, the technical provision is that, quote, "qualifying Commonwealth citizens" are allowed to be on the electoral register. Now, "qualifying", the word "qualifying" really isn't very qualifying at all, for such qualifying Commonwealth citizens do not need to be permanent residents. Any permission to enter or stay in the UK will do, whether it's time-limited, conditional, student, worker, family member, whatever. Indeed, the Electoral Commission spells it out, and I quote, "Any type of permission to enter or stay is acceptable, whether indefinite, time-limited, or conditional", end quote. So, you can have a situation where a student here on a short visa can help elect a government that will have a life long beyond, perhaps, that individual's time in the country.

Indeed, the Electoral Commission's definition of qualifying is so wide that it's not obvious to me it might not capture tourists or casual visitors. After all, we give six-month visas for those things, and it's quite possible to register and vote over that period. Whether it would be possible, through the arrangements, to pick up and distinguish permanent residents from people who are here for a short period isn't entirely obvious to me. However, what this means is that our franchise is, in principle, open to 2.7 billion people around the world, the entire population of the Commonwealth. And any Commonwealth citizen who reaches Britain on any of the bases I've just described is able to vote here.

And that is the extraordinary breadth of the entitlement that exists in our law and, I think, deserves to be discussed. Now, my Lords, my amendments are designed to provide for exactly that discussion. As I've said, they maintain the provision under which Irish citizens will be able to continue to vote. And that's a, I guess, a logical consequence of the Northern Ireland settlement, which recognises the right of its people to identify as British, Irish or both. And it is not really the moment to start opening that particular question, I suspect.

Moreover, it's reciprocal, and British citizens do get to vote and do register and vote in elections in Ireland. As I noted, my amendments also retain the existing rights of EU citizens with settled status to vote in local and some other elections. I think that's that is, in some ways, questionable, probably will need to be debated and dealt with at some point, but not now. I come onto the Commonwealth entitlement. It's quite different, and I do think it's very hard to defend in its current form.

For one thing, it's a complete anomaly internationally. No EU country allows non-citizens to vote in its national elections, with the exception of Ireland, the reciprocal arrangement with us, and Portugal, in the arguably somewhat similar case of Brazilians. No EU country. You have also, you can't vote unless you're a citizen in national elections in Norway, in Switzerland, in Canada, Australia with a small technical exception, and the United States. What we do is very unusual.

The only real exception is New Zealand, which allows all permanent residents to vote, all, not just a subset of them. That at least is logical. What we do in our franchise is extend the right to vote to a group of countries and their citizens, mostly, but not entirely, on the basis that Britain governed them half a century ago. And I suggest this really doesn't make logical sense in the world as we now have it. Now, these arrangements would be easier and a little more defensible, I think, if they were reciprocal.

The problem is the arrangements are not particularly reciprocal at the moment.

Only a small number of Caribbean countries and a couple of relatively small African countries allow British citizens to vote, and even then, they generally have to be pretty permanent residents. Indians can vote in Britain, but no British citizen can vote in India. It's the same for Pakistan, it's the same for Canada, it's the same for Sri Lanka, for Bangladesh, for Nigeria. I could go on with a very extensive list of very important countries with very large populations. I don't blame them, though.

They, those countries, rightly regard choosing their government as the business of their citizens, and I think they're right in that, and I think the arguments why we do not do the same. Really, my Lords, this is a bit of a hangover from the Empire. The voting rates reflect that relationship that existed 50, 60, 70 years ago. They are in law a legacy of the original expansive discussion of who could claim to be a British subject. The

provided that citizens of newly independent Commonwealth countries were still to be regarded as British subjects for the purposes of nationality and voting. Now, that provision has been tightened up a lot since then, and so has the definition of citizenship, but the legacy voting rights remain. They have nothing to do with citizenship of modern nation states as we now understand them. And, of course, we all value the Commonwealth and our friendships with its members, but they are different countries and that has to mean something, I think. My Lords, when I've discussed this issue, I rarely find I've struggled to find a convincing objection of principle to this.

Now, sometimes, of course, there's a sort of half-suppressed admission that citizens of certain countries are felt to be more likely to vote for one or other particular party, but I don't think we can really proceed on that basis. The argument I hear more often is it's always it's always been like that and people don't complain. Now, it's true that we should respect inherited arrangements, but one of those inherited arrangements is the British nation state, and preserving effective democracy in it really ought to be our priority. Now, occasionally, these do get reviewed. The noble Lord Goldsmith, wrote a review of UK citizenship for the then Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, in 2008, and he specifically proposed that government should give consideration to limiting, in principle, the right to vote in Westminster elections to UK citizens.

That was never followed up. His proposal would have preserved would have been reasonable at the time. There were still about a million Commonwealth citizens in Britain at that time. But things have changed a lot since then.

It's quite hard to establish the figures, but there's plausibly between two and three million Commonwealth citizens here now, and the Electoral Commission has suggested in the past that about two-thirds of them register to vote. Now, given the concentration of Commonwealth citizens in certain constituencies, probably it's entirely plausible these numbers are starting to affect outcomes in our elections. But, my Lords, the case for change doesn't rest on this. It rests on the constitutional reality of what it is to be a nation state.

A nation isn't the same thing as the people who happen to be standing on these islands at any given moment. It's a nation is a political community particular commitments to stick by each other. One of those rights is to help choose the government. And non-citizens have not made the same commitments, for one thing they can always leave the country if things get bad.

So, they shouldn't have the same political rights, in my humble opinion, as those who are citizens. If they want them, they should become citizens, and if that's too high a price to pay, it's entirely correct that they don't get the right to choose the government. My Lords, I think it's time to tidy all this up and join the international law, international norm. That's what we need to debate and what my amendments seek to do. Only British and Irish citizens should have the right to vote in national elections.

I think only those citizens should have the right to stand in elections. And if those standing for election are citizens of other countries too, perhaps electors should know that, and we'll come to that in later amendments. electoral arrangements and, most importantly, to bring the rules into line with what most people in this country already think they are. The moment, the time is coming, and I beg to move.

05:28:56 - 05:29:06

Speaker 151

Amendment proposed: after clause 16, insert the following new clause in the words as printed on the marshalled list.

05:29:06 - 05:31:19

Speaker 152

My Lords, I have followed this debate, particularly over the last couple of, this is Lord, this is an area that has exercised me for some years. And can I pay tribute to the House of Lords Library for extracting a lot of information on this to try and bring out where reciprocation exists? And I have to say, the reciprocation arrangements within the Commonwealth are very skinny indeed. And I think the government has opened up Pandora's box with this bill, because at the heart of a lot of part of this bill is the franchise, and the franchise that is attempting to be expanded to 16- and 17-year-olds.

So, I think this is right. If this is surely, this is the right bill to consider a wider franchise which hasn't been considered since 1969, I believe that act that came in 1969. And you have to consider, and we are with a backdrop of CHOGM in progress just at the moment in Antigua, and I'm a huge supporter of the Commonwealth. I'm somewhat saddened in the post-Brexit world that we haven't made a better arrangements with our friends around the Commonwealth to create a new friendship and trading arrangement on preferential terms.

And I hope those sort of issues are being discussed at CHOGM as I speak here today. But the electoral franchise is surely very odd, that we have vast countries with huge populations, let me just sort of pick out India, and Pakistan, and Nigeria, and perhaps Bangladesh, would have populations between them of probably 1 and 1/2 to 1.8 billion, for students and all of those a good areas are to be welcomed.

05:31:19 - 05:32:54

Speaker 154

But surely, to come on a student visa for a short time and then be allowed to vote is a very strange situation. I could consider that to be somewhat fair and reasonable if there was a reciprocation arrangement with those countries.

And as the noble friend, Lord Frost has said, perhaps that is quite complicated to achieve. It would require a department of the Home Office to keep an eye on electoral franchises around those countries of the Commonwealth. So, perhaps the amendments 25 and 26 that are proposed by my noble friend are perhaps cleaner. Perhaps this is the time to make that breakaway, which most other countries have considered to be proper and correct, to say one has to be a British citizen, because British citizenship, as we know, can be obtained.

One of the reasons that some people never do bother obtaining it, even though they've lived here for a very long time, is perhaps the cost and aggravation. But it is achievable, it is doable. One has to pay the fee and do the living in Britain test, and low and behold, one can become a British citizen, with those rights and duties that come with citizenship. So, I think the powerful thing being part of this nation, one cannot just up sticks and return back to the country of where one actually holds citizenship.

05:32:54 - 05:33:35

Craig MacKinlay

Now, the Australian situation is rather odd. Australia thought about this, and I believe it was the Australia Act 1984 within Australia, which made quite a separation between, you know, a new country and what might be called the old country. And it was at that date that Australia decided that one could only vote in Australia if one was an Australian citizen. And I think as my noble friend alluded to, I think if you have lived in Australia prior to 1956, You know, the anomalies round the world are very few and far between.

05:33:35 - 05:34:08

Speaker 154

I think it's time, because the Government has opened up the franchise for discussion, that we do use this bill appropriately to consider the franchise of Commonwealth citizens. It is a throw-back of yesteryear. Much as I perhaps quite like yesteryear, we're not there anymore. We're in the a modern world of 2026, and those old colonial arrangements, which particularly those on benches opposite me would rather like to throw off as rapidly as they can,

05:34:08 - 05:34:34

Craig MacKinlay

to have this subsisting into the future, I think the day is done. It's gone. So, I certainly hope that we could have cross-party support for this measure, and I look forward to the comments from the Minister as to why this is unacceptable. I would have thought such a provision would more likely come from that side of the House than from this side, strangely.

05:34:34 - 05:35:19

Speaker 154

So, I do hope that the Government will listen to this. And I know my noble friend said this was merely a probing amendment, but I think this deserves to be more than that, and I would like to see this beefed up for report stage and we can perhaps vote on such measures. My Lords, I'm pleased to rise to support the amendments of my noble friend Lord Frost, particularly 28 and 29. And I congratulate the previous speaker, my noble friend Lord Mackinlay of Richborough, who asked us to focus on the issue of the value of British citizenship.

05:35:19 - 05:41:34

James Stewart Jackson

I think, as we meet this afternoon and consider the American elections that took place yesterday, we look back and we think about the important issue of the sanctity of the franchise, how important that is. We are very fortunate in this country that we don't, for instance, have gerrymandered electoral districts.

We have a an independent Boundary Commission, and we're also fortunate in this country that most people believe that the franchise is clean, and safeguarded, and the electoral process is one of integrity, and honesty, and transparency, and that's because, broadly speaking, it is. And your Lordships House will know that in the past, in the United States, the Jim Crow laws, the residency, literacy, numeracy laws which were used to ostracise and discriminate against African-Americans and others thankfully is a thing of the past.

But it goes to show how important it is that we protect the sanctity of our electoral process, and it's something my noble friend Lord Hayward rightly mentioned before. The current Commonwealth voting right is outdated, as my noble friend said, it's anomalous, and it is indefensible, and it's time to bring our legislation up to date.

As has been said, the vast majority of Commonwealth nations do not have reciprocal voting arrangements with British citizens. There are around a million Commonwealth citizens living in the UK, and 66% of whom qualifying are qualified and registered to vote as has at March this year. And I think the beauty of these amendments is that they are not harsh and draconian, they do not remove with ministerial fiat or statutory fiat the right to vote for Commonwealth citizens. It's an incremental, it's a permissive, probing amendment, which invites the government to think about the reciprocity between countries.

And in so doing, it recognizes how important the familial and friendship relationships we have has been alluded to by my noble friend with countries. And the other thing is it's colourblind. It doesn't make reference to ethnicity, to religion, to background, to gender. It talks about Commonwealth nations. It talks about New Zealand, Nigeria, Ghana, Australia, Canada, Suriname, I think, British Guyana, and others who are members of our family of the Commonwealth.

My Lords, whilst the number of Commonwealth nations residing in the UK nationals sorry, residing in the UK and the percentage of Commonwealth citizens registered to vote in the UK has been estimated, the government has been unable to produce accurate figures concerning the number of qualifying Commonwealth nationals in the UK. And this is a very significant knowledge gap. If you're fighting a general election or a local election in good faith a general election in good faith, you really need to know who the people are who are going to be able to vote for you. And if you haven't got an estimate nationally, cumulatively, how many of those Commonwealth citizens are able to vote, then you may very well, rather cynically, feel that you're appealing to a noble jury.

You have to be sure of what the electorate is. Voting tied to citizenship is the global norm for a good reason. Elected representatives adopt significant responsibility to act in their elect's best interests. If electoral accountability is to function properly, the electorate must be stakeholders in Britain's long-term future.

Unless this is robustly the case, representatives, be they mayors, MPs, councillors, will not be bound to deliver genuinely prudent decision-making. Allowing those who are not British citizens to contribute to electoral outcomes risks undermining the quality of that representation by detract detracting from candidates' requirements to appeal to people who fundamentally care about their nation's future. And I think this is the thin end of the wedge. If we don't get a handle and focus on that particular philosophical issue, then we could quickly slip into the realms of identity politics, divisive identity politics. And I think that would be, and we've already seen the beginning of that in our country and we've seen it in many parts of the world, and we would wish to avoid that happening.

At its worst, it may encourage political short-termism or the dilution of a representative's accountability away from the interests of British citizens and towards the interests of merely current residents. This is a nuanced, yet important distinction. It is a fact that Britain is experiencing, and has been for some time, a sizable growth in net immigration, including those from Commonwealth nations. The circumstances which make Commonwealth voting eligibility tolerable upon its introduction in 1948 are no longer the circumstances of the United Kingdom today. This distinction is only becoming more acute, and in turn our electoral rules on this issue are becoming more dated and more antiquated.

It is time to make this change in order to preserve the integrity of our electoral system, to show that we value British citizenship, we're not making a value judgment on other countries, we're inviting them to collaborate with us in a reciprocal agreement, and that it may best serve those to whom representatives should truly be accountable, and that is British citizens. And for those reasons, I support these amendments.

05:41:34 - 05:42:04

Anne Thérèse Coffey

My Lords, I also support these amendments, and I'm grateful to my noble friend Lord Frost for making sure that actually the people of Irish citizenship can definitely continue to register. I have heard other people saying why displace the Commonwealth and not the Irish. There's a very different relationship that we have with Ireland and the people of Ireland, and that's why I hope we do actually see these amendments come back at report stage.

05:42:04 - 05:44:14

Speaker 32

I think it's worth starting by paying tribute to the many Commonwealth citizens who, both in peace and in wartime, have made very many significant contributions to our country. But it is also right, as several noble peers have mentioned, that the Commonwealth is the creation of an unusual set of historical circumstances, and one that if we were starting completely from scratch, with maybe a new written constitution for the country, we might take a slightly different approach to some aspects of. But in the spirit of Lord Frost's saying that these are probing amendments, I think there are two points worth highlighting. One is that there are some restrictions that do exist on which Commonwealth citizens are able to register to vote. Now, the combination, I think, of the requirements under the 1983 RPA and the link requirements under the 1971 Immigration Act don't quite provide the fully open door that was perhaps touched on a little in some of the speeches earlier.

But also that this is only one part of a wider question, because one could similarly, I think, reasonably ask why, when it comes to the local government franchise, is somebody who is living in this country for decades, is legally here, who is diligently paying their taxes every year, who has no criminal record, why are they not allowed to vote for their local council?

And I use that as an example of how there are actually many, I think, related issues. And, in a sense, I think it would be wrong to single out Commonwealth citizens as it were, the only one part of that complex, you know, picture, as if they are the only group who we should, in some way, feel maybe concerned about that them having the right to vote. So I think if the government does decide to look further at this issue, I hope it will very much be in the spirit of seeing it as part of a wider, more complex issue, rather than there being a specific problem, which means we should single out Commonwealth citizens above and beyond all of those other aspects of the issue for consideration.

05:44:14 - 05:46:34

Speaker 148

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Frost for tabling these amendments, and giving us the opportunity to have this important discussion on the voting rights of Commonwealth citizens. And to my noble friends Lord Mackinlay of Richborough, Lord Jackson of Peterborough and Baroness Coffey for their thoughtful contributions. It is right that the right to vote in our parliamentary elections to choose our government is restricted to British citizens, although there are some exceptions for those with close historical links to our country. And I've already spoken about our concerns in relation to the consequences of devolved arrangements in Scotland and Wales. The exceptions I mention, and that noble Lords have discussed during the debate, are very long-standing provisions that were implemented to reflect the special status of Irish and Commonwealth citizens in particular.

And I suppose I should declare an interest here, bearing in mind both my parents were Irish. I never, ever remember them voting in Irish elections, but they always voted with pride here. The arrangement we have with the Republic of Ireland precedes the EEC and the EU. It stems from the establishment of the Irish Free State in the 1920s, and the administrative agreement on the Common Travel Area. The two countries have broad reciprocal voting rights.

I do appreciate the concerns that have been raised today on Commonwealth citizens' eligibility to vote, especially the with from what was said earlier, which is clearly difficult for anyone to justify. However, these matters are very complex, and we should be careful about rushing into changes without having wider consideration of broader government policy on citizenship and integration. In fact, no changes to election law should be rushed, and we will be discussing the consequence of doing so through this throughout this bill. I thank noble Lords for raising this debate, and I look forward to the noble Baroness the minister's response.

05:46:34 - 05:48:16

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, of course we always welcome probing amendments, and they do generate interesting discussions in this House. But it may not surprise the noble Lord Frost that the government will not support these amendments. Amendments similar to these were tabled in the other place during earlier bill stages, and the government's views on the topic have been made very clear. The entitlement of resident Commonwealth citizens to vote reflects our very close historical ties with Commonwealth countries. And the noble Lord Peck referred to, recognising the contribution from those countries, from the selfless sacrifice of Commonwealth forces who fought side-by-side with British troops in the world wars, the Windrush generation, who made Britain their home and contributed to our society, community, culture, and public services.

And the ties which bind Commonwealth citizens to the UK are inextricable. And those rights must be respected.

Commonwealth citizens' voting rights are not and have never been based on a quid pro quo. I would say for clarity that a qualifying Commonwealth citizen who is only visiting the country and has no home here would not be eligible to vote. So the Government will not be removing Commonwealth citizens' voting rights. And just briefly on reciprocity, each Commonwealth country determines its own electoral franchise, and reciprocity is not a condition of the UK's very long-standing arrangements. As I've already set out in relation to the noble Lord's Amendments 5, 7 and 31, the Government is also committed to maintaining and defending the devolution settlements.

05:48:16 - 05:48:23

Speaker 156

Does she also think Commonwealth voters at the age of 16 should be voting in the elections as well?

05:48:23 - 05:48:30

Jane Sharon Taylor

The same voting rights will apply across the franchise.

05:48:30 - 05:50:53

David Frost

My Lords, I thank the Minister for her response. As she said, I'm not entirely surprised by it, but and I thank those who've spoken in this short debate. I think it has been worth having, and I don't think the issue will go away. Can I just take a moment to apologise to my noble friend Lord Mackinlay for not mentioning the fact that he was, I think, the only person to raise this at second reading, and I know that he's followed this issue for some time, and as his intervention showed, he knows a lot about the issue. He mentioned Australia, and of course Australia has an extremely restrictive policy generally.

Not only does it restrict voting to citizens, it restrict it restricts candidacies to citizens and it prevents dual nationality entirely as a condition of being a member of the legislature. And Australia may be at one end of the spectrum, we are very definitely at the other end of the spectrum, and the international norm is that only citizens vote, only citizens are candidates, and I find it hard to see how one can defend any other. Of course, citizens of many other countries from the Commonwealth and outside the Commonwealth have made huge contributions to this country, but that's not how we determine voting rights. One last comment perhaps to the noble Lord Phatak: I entirely understand and in some ways sympathise with his comment that why should somebody who's lived here for a long time not get to vote in local elections, and I think that is a point that's worth discussion. National elections, national referendum, national questions are not the same as local questions and issues, and I think that's something that's worth thinking about.

But it should, I guess, if one went down that road, be for logic for everyone or for at least logically defined categories, and not the sort of hangover from the Commonwealth. My Lords, I'll stop there. I thank you for thank noble Lords for a good discussion. We'll reflect on what we do at report stage. I think it probably will be worth having a further discussion and reflection on this, but meanwhile I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

05:50:53 - 05:51:30

Speaker 151

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 26 Lord Frost, not moved. And 27, Lord Frost, not moved. 28, Lord Frost, not moved.

And 29, Lord Frost, not moved. Amendment 30, Lord Frost, not moved. And 31, Lord Frost, not moved. In Amendment 32, Lord Blunkett.

05:51:30 - 05:54:57

Margot Ruth Lister

My Lords, I rise to move Amendment 32 on behalf of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, who regrets that he cannot be in his place. I have to say, I've never really understood why noble Lords are disenfranchised when it comes to general elections, so I look forward to my noble friend the Minister's explanation. That will focus my remarks on Amendment 41 in my name, the purpose of which is to extend the right to vote in general elections to UK residents with settled status or indefinite leave to remain, and on Amendment 42, which would extend the right to vote in local elections to all residents with a form of legal immigration status. The amendments would do no more than bring UK elections into line with those in Wales and Scotland, both of which used the legislation which enfranchised 16- and 17-year-olds to extend the vote to foreign residents. The extension is working well in these countries, I understand, and administrators have not reported problems with the implementation.

There are at present 4.4 million foreign residents who cannot vote in UK general elections and 1.2 million who cannot vote at all in England and Northern Ireland. The case for this is simple. It's undemocratic and unfair that so many residents contribute to this country in various ways, including, but not limited to, taxation, yet have no say in how it is governed and in decisions which affect them. It would simplify the voting system considerably. The current voter eligibility rules are very complex, depending on nationality, date of arrival in the UK, whether their country of origin has a bilateral voting rights agreement with the UK, and which nation of the UK they live in.

Only 66% of eligible EU and Commonwealth citizens are registered to vote. The complexity in understanding who can actually vote means many who are eligible do not register, and the proposed changes would mean clearer rules and better voter participation, including among those migrant residents who do currently have the right to vote. And there is a case on grounds of social cohesion. Democratic participation gives residents a stake in the future of their society and allows them to feel they are equal contributors. This could be particularly important when the franchise is extended to 16- and 17-year-olds, as I'm told that some teachers are expressing concern about how they will discuss in schools the fact that some pupils will get the vote while others will not.

The Migrant Democracy Project, who brought this issue to my attention originally, have rightly said that democracy works best when it is inclusive for all its who it serves. All those who call the UK their home have vested political and social interests in how their communities and country are governed. As I noted at second reading, the now Lord Chancellor, the Right Honourable Alex Norris MP, tabled an amendment to legislation on similar lines back in 2022. We now finally have an opportunity to achieve what he aimed for and catch up with Wales and Scotland. It's surely in line with the principles underlying the Representation of the People Bill.

I hope, therefore, that my noble friend will accept the case which I believe to be strong. I beg to move.

05:54:57 - 05:55:09

Speaker 157

Amendment proposed, after Clause 16, assert insert the words printed as a new clause in the Marshalled List.

05:55:09 - 06:00:49

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

My Lords, Amendment 37 in my name seeks to consider the consequences of the two major changes proposed in the bill on the size of constituency and council ward electorates, which could be significant.

First of all, improvements to voter registration are designed to make the electoral roll more complete. In some areas of the country, the difference between the numbers registered for health services and those on the electoral register are stark. For instance, the Electoral Commission has figures which estimate that only 70% of 18 to 34 year olds are actually registered at all. For those in private rented accommodation, it is as low as 66%. And for those who are in homes at a social rent, it is 80%.

So, the electoral register is skewed against the young and those in rented accommodation. That discrimination obviously has an impact on election results, but also on the size of constituencies, and then the constituent council wards. The other major change proposed in this bill is the addition of 16 and 17 17-year-olds to the register. Now, the House of Commons Library has a very helpful breakdown of people in each age group in every constituency. Adding 16 and 17-year-olds to the register has a disproportionate effect on both constituency electorates and hence ward electorates.

For example, Birmingham Ladywood has 5,070 16 and 17-year-olds. Bradford West will have 4,236. Both constituencies will then have more than 81,000 electors, when the upper limit at the last boundary review was 77,000, easily breaking the 5% tolerance criterion that was applied at that stage. The additions then have impact on ward electorates. In my own Council of Kirklees in West Yorkshire, based on the data, there will be instantly an addition I beg your pardon, additional 10,000 electors in the 16-17-year-old age group.

On average, this will add 450 voters to each ward. However, in the Dewsbury part of the borough, the additional electors will be 600 per ward. So Kirklees wards already have an expected 15,000 electors. Some wards will then have nearly 16,000. And this is before attempts to improve registration have been included.

Unlike parliamentary constituencies, wards across the country are not required to have a roughly equal electorate. In many unitary authorities, the wards the electors per councillor is less than 3,000, whereas in others, such as my own, it is more than 5,000.

This inequality of representation does need to be discussed. Is it fair on citizens that some are more equal than others? Hence my amendment 37, which requires the Secretary of State to lay a report before Parliament within six months to review what effect extending the franchise has on the size of constituency and ward electorates. So, I would like to ask the noble Baroness the minister, not in her place, but to provide the estimated increase in electors for each constituency. That is it is possible to do it, given the figures in the House of Commons Library, and certainly for 16 and 17-year-olds it would be, and whether that inequality is acceptable in a democracy.

And then I'd also like to ask the noble Baroness the minister to consider whether the wide disparity between ward electorates contributes to the equal access to democracy which this country has pledged to provide.

06:00:49 - 06:06:44

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, I'm very taken with the points just made by the noble Baroness Pinnock, about the distorting effects on existing boundaries from extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, but I think she could have gone further because the way in which the automatic registration, which is also part of this group, takes into account the universities will have a further distorting effect on particularly the urban constituencies in another insult to the country mass. This government is always focused on the imbalance in the cities, but in this particular case it puts the rural areas at a disadvantage because they will only have, how can I say, if a student from out of town is registered at home, but the university is automatically registered there, that person has two votes and disproportionately that will affect the concentrated urban situations. Thus, I'm sure the minister, when she returns to her place, will dismiss Baroness Pinnock's point as wholly unnecessary, you know, this is just nothing to be worried about. But I'd like to give a lesson from history because the noble Baroness who is returning to the chamber will know that both she and I participated on some of those COVID calls in the pandemic in 2020 and there was a rush from the city to the countryside. People who lived in London, for example, but other cities are available, chased to North Norfolk in particular, and I see my noble friend on the front bench who late was a Member of Parliament for North Norfolk in a previous life, and but they weren't registered on the NHS, they weren't registered to vote, yet all the consumed all the services in North Norfolk.

And my concern is that if we have all this automatic registration, it does it won't reflect the reality. It isn't just distorting the boundaries, important though that is, and the electoral numbers, the degree of automatic registration could distort the access to services that just doesn't keep up with these registers.

So, I support my the noble Lady, Baroness Pinnock. She's identified more unintended consequences from the double whammy of extending the franchise and automatic registration, which leads me on to my amendment number 45 in this group, which is a probing amendment that seeks to see, well, how in with automatic registration, how will the Electoral Registration Officer know when a person is eligible to be registered or just passing through, or has indefinite leave to remain or is just a tourist? This is a probing amendment that seeks to say that whether or not, whether a British citizen or Commonwealth citizen, if you're not one of those, you have to apply under individual electoral registration and demonstrate your eligibility as you do at the moment. The duty is on these overseas electors to provide absolute proof of entitlement to vote, rather than pressurise the Electoral Registration Officer to make guesses. Because the chances are these people won't have national insurance numbers, they will not be present on many of the UK databases.

How on earth is the ERO to know? How will he know to prevent a duplicate when a wife keeps her maiden name for professional purposes, but has already registered for a married name? And just because there's a Mr. Smith who pays the council tax doesn't mean Mrs. Smith is eligible if she happens to be the foreign-born spouse. And so, I think you can start to see quite a lot of different practical complications here. And there are some cultures, I mentioned Mr. and Mrs. Smith, but there are other cultures where the husband and the wife have different surnames, and that's in their culture.

I'm thinking, particularly, of President Zelensky in Ukraine, whose wife is Mrs. Zelenska. Now, that's just one example. Now, neither of those two are eligible to vote in our elections, but it is an example of the way in which foreign cultures have different mores to ourselves. And each ERO, if there is to be automatic registration, potentially foreign subjects, is going to have to understand all these peculiarities. I think that's an unreasonable burden on the ERO.

So, my amendment is a small one, but it seeks to probe the burdens we place on the Electoral Registration Officer to register people who have no legal or digital footprint in this country, who can't be validated or authenticated. It makes it clear that if you aren't a British, an EU or a Commonwealth citizen and you want to participate, and if you are entitled to participate in our democracy, then you must apply just as you do today. Let these people make their case with the appropriate documentation, so the registration officer can scrutinise rather than make guesses. Because if the register is based on guesswork, then it undermines the integrity of our democracy, and with it, trust in the democratic process and the institutions that flow from it.

06:06:44 - 06:08:17

James Stewart Jackson

My Lords, can I just speak very briefly to make the point, I don't really understand the noble lady Baroness Pinnock's amendment, because she will know that local government boundaries are essentially informed as a result of physical or natural features and community links. I think her amendment would have been more coherent if it had linked the delivery of key public services within an expanded ward, which was the result of a greater registration of 16-17-year-olds. But I fail to see what the point of producing a report saying, "There going to be more people in this ward with regard, vis-a-vis other wards," because if you are talking about, if one is talking about the delivery of public services, that's a fair point to make, but equally you would also you would also, therefore, for instance, in places like Christchurch, Worthing, Hove, talk about the delivery of services for older people, where there's a greater preponderance of older people.

So, unless I'm being particularly obtuse, I can't see what the point is in terms of the obligation that she's seeking the government to meet in producing a report of the number of 16 and 17 year olds, which numerically we all already know.

06:08:17 - 06:11:00

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

My Lords, the whole purpose is that we have a democracy that's based on, first of all, one person, one vote, but then based on having boundaries for of particular electors that are more or less equal in size. Now, whenever there is a constituency boundary review,

there are always parts of the country in the Highlands, or the Isle of Wight, or areas like that where reflecting the geography of the place means that it's better to have something with that's outside the tolerance of the criteria that are set to try and make constituencies of a similar size, because each is going to elect one person to Parliament to make decisions on

behalf of their residents, their citizens. And to have some representing 82, 3000, and some, at the other end of the scale, currently representing

less than 70,000 does lead to inequalities, which is why we have regular boundary reviews. Now, within a council authority area, a local authority area,

the number of wards are determined, and then that leads to the number of electors in each ward. Excuse me. Again, the idea is that, in Kirklees, each ward has 15,000 electors.

In London boroughs, the average is 3,000 per sorry, 5,000 per councillor in Kirklees ward, 3,000 is the norm in London boroughs or less. And that is what I am saying is that if local authorities were required to have wards of a similar size,

there would be a better ability for representation of an equal basis in those areas. That is what I'm saying. That is my argument. If we can do it for constituency boundaries, why are we not doing it for local authority council wards?

06:11:00 - 06:11:28

Speaker 147

I speak to support the principle behind amendment 32 in the name of the noble Lord Blunkett, just as I've previously supported the principle when Lord Naseby introduced a private member's bill in 2020, and when Lord Dobbs introduced an amendment to what became the 2022 Elections Act. The ban on peers voting in general elections belongs, in my view, to bygone times,

06:11:28 - 06:12:28

Speaker 146

when the House was entirely hereditary, had an absolute veto over legislation, and members of this House were often Prime Minister.

But my Lords, we no longer have an absolute veto on legislation. We have no say at all over financial measures, including the budget, and we have no say on who is the Prime Minister, because that is determined solely by MPs. The amendment, however, is far from being our priority, when we are addressing elsewhere in the bill issues of considerable importance, such as the many millions of ordinary people missing from the electoral registers and therefore being unable to vote at all. I would also, my Lords, suggest that I would consider it ironic for members of this House to claim the right to elect members of the House of Commons without equally supporting the right of the people to have a say who sits in this chamber.

06:12:28 - 06:12:32

Speaker 159

Ah, well said.

06:12:32 - 06:16:08

David Frost

My Lords, I rise to speak briefly to amendments 41 and 42 in the name of Baroness Lister. I won't that which arguably ought to have been in the previous group perhaps, because they obviously raise very similar questions. I won't run the equal and opposite arguments to the ones I just ran in the other group for reasons of time, but I did just want to make two points, perhaps. One, the effect of amendments 41 and 42 would be, once again, to extend the franchise beyond citizens in a different kind of way. And once you do that, you lose a firm grounding for what the principle is that you are trying to apply.

In this case, it would extend the franchise to anyone with EU settled status, or anybody with indefinite leave to enter or remain. And that is something that can be changed really quite quickly, as we have seen this week. It's relatively easy to change ILR conditions. And indeed, I guess the effect of these amendments is, if they ever came into force, would be that you could have a situation where two citizens, identical in every respect, except that one was a care worker, and one was not, one would get the right to vote five years earlier than the other under the proposals that were announced this week. And I make I use that example to show how fluid the electorate can become if it isn't soundly grounded on an objective fact, which is citizenship.

The other point I want to make which is relevant here is the point that my noble friend Lord Jackson made in the previous group, which is, he alluded to the fact that residents don't necessarily have the same interests as citizens. They aren't kind of completely substitutable, and that citizenship does mean something. Now in local elections, as I said, maybe that is less so, but in national-level issues, it seems to me it is reasonable to think that residents will have different interests on certain important questions: trade policy and trade links, visas and travel, for example, or even defense policy and which countries we choose to be allied with. Those are questions that citizenship and a commitment to a country affects.

And of course, constitutional issues are the last one. And the sense of legitimacy about a vote on the constitutional future of the country, or an aspect of it, does really depend on whether you're legally committed to that country or merely living here.

And I think if we extend that situation, if we make it even more disconnected from citizenship than it already is, then you risk undermining the legitimacy of some really quite important votes, because people can see that residents from the EU or elsewhere don't necessarily have the same interests and views as citizens. So for those reasons, I come back to the point I made earlier, citizenship is the only safe basis, and any attempt to extend it for any less satisfactory criteria is inevitably going to work out less well.

06:16:08 - 06:18:31

Robert Hayward

My Lords, I rise briefly to comment on one or two aspects of the debate, but would first make the observation that I have a group later on of clause stand part debates, and it was actually my error, which probably caused the officials serious concern when briefing the minister as to why I wanted to stand part on 18, 19 and 20, but haven't actually included 17 within that, but I'll leave that aside. Two other observations, one is in relation to Baroness Pinnock's comments and amendment. I do actually have strong sympathy with her about the issue of the size of local government wards, and the burdens imposed on some councillors in some parts of the country are not imposed on others. There appears to be no logic behind the position that we have from the size of one council or another. I can understand it if one was talking about large geographical areas.

That's a perfectly good reason for saying a councillor has difficulty in terms of serving an area. Baroness Pinnock has referred to Kirklees. There are other metropolitan authorities where the number of voters per councillor are substantially fewer, and she has cited London, were substantially fewer than they are in places like Kirklees and Birmingham. There is no logic to that whatsoever. I won't go on to the question of parliamentary boundaries, because I did actually refer to it during the debate earlier on.

I would merely make two other observations. One is that in clause 17, 12(1)(c) refers to a person who appears to the registrar of being of voting age. I'm not sure that I'm happy with that as a phraseology. Equally, I would comment to Lord Jackson, in passing, he referred to Christchurch. I'm not happy about that reference either, although Lord Rennard, because of his experience in winning the in winning the by-election which crushed my candidacy, would probably get more pleasure out of the reference than I did.

06:18:31 - 06:23:49

Speaker 32

My Lords, I will I was about to say I will pick up where the noble Lord Hayward finished, but I will skip over Christchurch, and instead come to the points that Baroness Pinnock made about her amendment, because I think there is one important knock-on factor which hasn't yet been raised in this debate, and that's because the number because the age profile of the population not only varies significantly across the country, and hence varies between parliamentary constituencies or councils, it varies significantly within many councils. There are, in many councils, areas of, on average, much older population and, on average, much younger population, and therefore it is very plausible that the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds will have a very unequal effect on different council wards around the country as to the electorate in those wards, and hence the knock-on effect both on councillor workload, the ability of voters to get a good service from their councillor, and that fundamental democratic principle of trying to give everybody an equal vote. And therefore, I think there is a knock-on in terms of, for example, the work of the ongoing local government boundary reviews, which needs to be tied into giving 16 and 17-year-olds the vote.

And so I hope we will be able to hear from the noble lady, the Minister, what thought has been given as to how that process will be properly integrated with the potential knock-ons from this bill. Turning to some of the other amendments in this group, I would simply observe that I think Amendment 32 from Lord Blunkett would be an excellent amendment to a bill that was introducing democratic elections to this place and I hope that we have a chance to debate that bill in such in the near future. Turning to Lord Fuller's point with Amendment 45, I would simply observe that there are some data sets in which EU citizens and Commonwealth citizens absolutely are present, which may it may turn out depending on how the automatic voter registration pilots continue to play out, may turn out to be absolutely usable. So I wouldn't quite describe that group of people as being completely unmoored from the data that is available. And to perhaps slightly pre-empt Amendment 50 55 from Baroness O'Neill and Lord Jamieson, because I think there is a useful point here to highlight, I can understand why that amendment seeks to particularly prioritise providing information in writing.

And I think it certainly was the case in the past that saying that you have to be written to was a sort of gold standard form of communication that rightly was often prioritised as, you know, if there is something that's legally important, it has to be in writing. I do think, though, it is reasonable to say that we have moved on quite a long way from that. And I say that for two reasons. One is sadly the decline in the reliability of postal delivery services, whether it's the Royal Mail or sometimes using alternative delivery mechanisms, in that saying that you are sending a letter to somebody doesn't have the same guarantee that it used to, but also, conversely, people receive information in a wide variety of other ways now. And I would just take the example of HMRC.

Every time I log in to the HMRC website, you know, to do my tax return or to check things, HMRC is really keen to encourage me to switch to having, in future, legally required notices about what tax return I might have to make to be sent to me electronically. Many people choose to do that. I happen to find having those notices sent to me the old-fashioned way so I can scribble on them and so on actually more convenient, so I haven't yet opted in, although I'm sure at some point, all of the incessant notifications will wear me down. But I think that illustrates why it is important to have a range of options available for providing information, and as it were, embedding in legislation that it has to be in writing is not necessarily the best course. And I would simply observe that it is a regular feature of secondary legislation at the moment, and something for which I think the government should be given credit, that we regularly see SIs come to this place which require in some way legal notification to be given, and the government to its credit actually puts in quite modern wording that provides some flexibility to use modern forms of communications where they are appropriate.

But then, just finally, on the question of the rights to vote, which have also come up in this group. I think in a way, the split of those amendments between this group and the previous group illustrates the point that I was making earlier that there is an issue that may be worth looking at, but it should be looked at in the round, in the whole, because I think there is a risk that can come through if we are always only singling out particular groups of people as these are the ones that we're worried might get registered when they shouldn't do, or these are the groups of people that we think maybe shouldn't have the vote, that can give the impression of being unduly fearful of or uncomfortable with those groups of people if we're not also at the same time looking at the full, rounded picture, which I think is much the better way to proceed.

06:23:49 - 06:30:09

Speaker 148

My Lords, this has been an interesting debate on a variety of issues and I thank noble Lords for their contributions. The noble Lord Blunkett's amendment 32 would allow sitting Members of this House to vote in general elections. My Lords, our disenfranchisement can be traced back centuries in common law, as well as to a motion passed by the other place in 1699, which stated that "no peer of this kingdom hath any right to give his vote in the election for any member to serve in Parliament". My Lords, as Members of your Lordships' House, we have a voice in Parliament. It is right that we do not also have our voices heard through electric elected representatives in the other place.

Amendment 37 in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Pinnock requires the Government to conduct a review as to whether extending voting rights to 16 and 17 year-olds should affect local council electoral boundaries and the number of councillors. As we've said consistently throughout this through the first day and into today's committee, we must ensure that these changes, and any subsequent changes that can be expected, are well thought through, with all the facts presented before Parliament. This brings me to a broader point, that it's been a long-standing policy under Governments of all political stripes to use the registered electorate as the basis for constituencies rather than population data. But with automatic voter registration, the Government have said it will be introduced in a range of different locations and settings with different characteristics. Can the noble Baroness the Minister say whether this will cut across boundaries?

This could also mean asymmetric electoral rolls, distorting the operation of boundary reviews. Will the review of local government reorganisation, currently ongoing for some areas, take into account the implications of this Bill? Amendment 44 in the name of the noble Lord Bird seeks to extend the franchise to convicted criminals serving a custodial sentence not exceeding 12 months. Whilst I appreciate the work he's done in this area, we must remember that those who are imprisoned have been convicted of serious crimes and therefore lose their civic rights for the duration of their time in prison. In December 2018, the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers upheld the previous Government's ban on convicted prisoners in jail from form from voting.

This judgment extends across the UK and the ECHR consideration is now closed. Turning to amendments 41 and 42 in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Lister of Burtersett, we do not support the proposal to expand the right to vote in general elections and local elections in England to foreign citizens. As I said earlier, citizenship matters and must count for something.

Furthermore, we do have concerns about what similar reforms in Scotland and Wales have meant in relation to foreign interference and political donations. This brings me to amendment 45 in the name of my noble friend Lord Fuller, which would retain individual voter registration for EU and Commonwealth citizens. My Lords, automatic voter registration would risk relying on outdated entries on other databases, which could mean that EU and Commonwealth citizens who are residents, but who are not eligible to vote, could be registered. Such instances would not be minor mishaps, but would undermine the rules of our electoral system. It could also lead to unsolicited poll cards being sent to those households.

Can the noble Baroness the Minister say what assessment has been made of these specific risks? Amendment 277 in my name and my noble friend Lord Jamieson would require the government to publish an independent review of the steps necessary to avoid non-qualifying EU or Commonwealth voters being incorrectly automatically added to the electoral roll. The government may have done their homework already, but if so, we'd like to see it. Individual voter registration was implemented to stop fraudulent electoral registration, ensure a more accurate register with fewer errors, and remove the outdated concept that only a head of household could decide who should be on the electoral roll. That's why we believe individual voter registration should be retained as a whole.

Finally, the remaining amendments in my name and my noble friend Lord Jamieson seek to strengthen the provisions in this bill as currently drafted, probing what checks and processes will be in place to ensure someone is definitely of voting age before registering them. Amendment 55 also probes how individuals will be notified that they are registered. And amendments 56 and 57 probe how electoral registration records are kept and handled once the officer responsible is no longer in post. These are important issues concerning people's data as well as the accurate maintenance of electoral registers. I hope the noble Baroness the Minister can provide some clarity and reassurance on these points, and I look forward to her response.

06:30:09 - 06:33:00

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Blunkett for tabling Amendment 32, moved by my noble friend Baroness Lister, which seeks to allow sitting members of this House to vote in UK Parliamentary elections. I remember the fascinating conversation with my MP, Kevin Bonavia, when he said to me, he was talking about voting and I said, "I'm sorry Kevin, I'm not going to vote for you." And he's and he was a bit horrified, took stepped back, he hadn't realized that I couldn't vote because I'm in here. Of course, if I had been able to vote, I would have voted for him. I recognize the noble Lord has raised this issue before, and that he wishes to address the difference between the voting rights of sitting members of this House and those of other electors.

However, it's important to recognize the particular role that we, as members of this House, have in Parliament. We can participate in debates, scrutinize, and introduce legislation, and ask parliamentary questions. And as such, unlike other voters, we have the opportunity to represent our views directly in Parliament rather than relying on an elected member of the other place to do so. This is the basis for the long-standing restriction on sitting peers, I think the Baroness noble Baroness O'Neill said it goes back to 1699, for on peer sitting peers not voting in UK Parliamentary elections, and the government doesn't believe there is a case for changing these arrangements.

Of course, this doesn't mean that members of this House are excluded from voting altogether. We can vote in local and devolved elections where we do not have the same direct role. I hope that explains the government's position on that amendment. In relation to amendment 37, it appears to require the Secretary of State to report to Parliament within six months on the impact of extending the voting rights to 16 and 17 year olds on the number and boundaries of council electoral areas. The Local Government Boundary Commission for England is already considering how to incorporate newly enfranchised electors into its electoral forecasts and doesn't anticipate that the changes will require a different approach to electoral reviews.

The noble Baroness O'Neill asked me a question about local government reorganization. I would respond to her, most of the proposals that were put forward for LGR didn't involve boundary changes. Those that do will, of course, be subject to review by the Local Government Boundary Commission. I know that the noble Baroness Lady Pinnock has raised these issues before about the variability of ward sizes. I'm happy to continue that conversation with her, but she knows I'm sure that this is really a matter for the Local Government Boundary Commission.

So, we don't see a clear need for a separate review by the Secretary of State. I thank my

06:33:00 - 06:33:41

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

Very quickly. Unfortunately, it's not the role of the Local Government Boundary Commission to make those decisions. And that is the point I'm trying to I hope to make. The determination is made by the council. And if there is no guidance, as there isn't, to councils as to seeking to create wards of a similar size across the country, then the disparity that currently exists, and will get worse, will continue.

06:33:41 - 06:41:07

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'm very happy to carry on that conversation with her. I do feel we're going to come up against in the end here a thing about local determination versus national determination, but we can have that conversation. On the amendments from my noble friend Baroness Lister and Baroness Bennett, let me be clear, the government recognizes the enormous contribution made by people from other countries who choose to make the United Kingdom their home, but the government doesn't believe that lawful residence alone should confer voting rights. Citizenship restrictions rather than resident residence alone are the norm for participation in elections in most democracies. The government has no current plans to extend voting rights to further nationalities or to introduce a residency-based franchise.

There are, of course, different choices within the United Kingdom. Scotland and Wales have chosen to extend their devolved franchises more widely. We respect their right to take that approach within their devolved competence, just as it is right for this Parliament to determine the franchise for elections for which it is responsible. I thank the noble Lord Fuller for his engagement with the bill's provision for improving voter registration via amendment 45. And while I would never wholly dismiss the noble Lord's points made, I do think, he's been very calm today, but I do think he needs to calm down a bit sometimes.

I don't think his points on Monday suggested that democracy was in an imminent danger of collapsing because the EROs and the computers that assist them couldn't recognize an apostrophe. And today, he's worried about the duplicating Mr Smiths. Of course our EROs already deal with all of these issues, and it's under longstanding rules to be registered to vote in a general election, you must be a British, Irish or qualifying Commonwealth citizen.

Qualifying EU citizens are also able to register to vote for certain elections such as local councils, although not for UK Parliamentary elections. The government's got no plans to change this, and I don't think it would be fair to establish an automated voter registration system in which some eligible citizens cannot be directly registered, or their details directly updated. In fact the noble lord referred to President Zelenskyy and his wife having different surnames. I think actually our own Prime Minister and his wife have different surnames.

So the EROs are very used to dealing with these situations. I turn now to amendments 46, 53, 54 and 55 tabled by the noble Baroness Lady O'Neill and Lord Jamieson. The Government agrees that direct registration must operate accurately and with appropriate safeguards, and clause 17 already secures those outcomes. New section 12A requires a person to appear to the registration officer to be both of voting age and entitled to be registered before a person is directly registered.

New section 12B also requires a person to appear to the registration officer to be both of voting age and entitled to be registered before the notice is sent. This requires the officer to assess the available information and reach a view on whether these conditions are met. I think as well as making the point in the amendment the noble Lord Hayward raised the issue about the phrase "appears to the officer". And I would say this is established language in electoral registration law. Section 10ZC of the Representation of the People Act 1983 uses the same formulation for registration following an application,

and this clause preserves that test with respect to direct registration. Schedule 2 to the bill will preserve the that test while distinguishing the existing application-based process from the new process without an application. As now, registration officers will remain under a statutory duty to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that everyone entitled to be registered is registered and no others. Finally new section 12B subsection (3) already expressly requires a notice to be given in writing to a person before they are directly registered. The power concerning how it may be given relates only to the method of delivery,

for example by post, by hand, or electronically. The amendments therefore add no further protection to safeguards already contained within the bill. In relation to amendments 56 and 57, 56 raises an important consideration, and one already envisaged by the bill. If an electoral registration officer leaves their role, their successor in the job would hold the records until the end of the retention period.

This helps ensure that people who have opted out of direct registration during the response period do not receive further notices even if their electoral registration officer changes. I can also clarify that retention of direct registration notice records for five years will ensure that those people who have responded to a notice and subsequently claimed an exemption will then not receive another notice during that time. However they will be liable to be invited to register by an electoral registration officer. If they remain unregistered after five years and still appear to be eligible, then they will be sent another notice. The Government believes this to be an appropriate length of time,

and it is consistent with the period of time the Electoral Commission holds copies of a register, which in turn aligns with the maximum length of a parliament. I hope this provides sufficient reassurance on those points. In relation to amendment 277 regarding direct registration,

I recognise the intention behind the amendment and the importance of maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the electoral register. The Government is equally committed to ensuring that only those who are entitled to be registered are added to the register. However, I don't believe the amendment is necessary. The Government is already undertaking extensive work to identify the most appropriate data sets to support these reforms. This includes assessing the quality and reliability of different sources to ensure they provide sufficient assurance of an individual's entitlement to register.

Any permanent changes to the registration process will be based on robust evidence and user research. Before any wider implementation, we plan to undertake pilots using the powers in Clauses 20 to 25 and, as part of these pilots, we will test the effectiveness and reliability of different datasets and the new approaches to registration. I hope that picks up some of the points made previously by the noble Lord Fuller, as well. Importantly, the Electoral Commission is already required to carry out an independent evaluation of those pilots. The Government will publish the commission's findings, including its assessment of whether the pilots have achieved their stated objectives.

The specific detail of the pilots will be set out in secondary legislation and scrutinised in the usual way. Furthermore, electoral registration officers will continue to apply their knowledge and judgment to assess eligibility before they send someone a notice that they will be registered to vote. So, I hope this provides the reassurance that appropriate safeguards, testing and independent scrutiny are already built into the approach we are taking.

06:41:07 - 06:42:05

Robert Hayward

Could I just ask her to further consider her comments in relation to the point I raised in that she referred, quite rightly, to legislation that is now, in effect, some 40, 50 years old? In those days, the vast majority of people didn't have passports, you didn't have a driving licence with a picture on it and they didn't have virtually any other form of identity, and therefore, appearing to be was a judgement that one made in those days.

We've introduced voter ID and all the associated requirements with that, and there And given that this legislation is intending to be modernising, bringing up to date our election law, could I please ask that the Minister does give that further consideration?

06:42:05 - 06:42:36

Jane Sharon Taylor

I thank the noble Lord for those comments. I'm always happy to give things further consideration. I think it's the point being that in Section 12B, the registration officer has to be certain that the person appears to be of voting age and entitled to be registered before they send the notice. So, the voter ID is another reassurance once they get to the polling station. But I think but I will reflect on his comments.

06:42:36 - 06:43:19

Margot Ruth Lister

My Lords, I thank noble Lords who've contributed to the debate on this rather eclectic group of amendments. On behalf of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, who I sense has got the bit between his teeth on this, so I suspect that I think he probably will not have heard the last of it. I must admit, I was not convinced by the arguments against the amendment. As I think was the noble Lord Rennard, pointed out, we have rather changed six since 1699. We're a very different sort of House than we were then.

But also, it did strike me that the argument used by my noble friend could just as well be used to say that members of the other House shouldn't have the vote. They've got all that influence.

06:43:19 - 06:43:32

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'll ask my noble friend to give way. The point is that, for MPs, they actually stand down from being MPs when the election is called, so they technically they're not MPs when they go to vote.

06:43:32 - 06:44:18

Margot Ruth Lister

Thank you for that correction.

But, anyway, I still I suspect my noble friend will not be convinced and will be back with much stronger arguments than I've got to make at present. I accept that the you know, the arguments have been put in terms of my own amendments. I think it's a shame that we can't follow Scotland and Wales, and it may be that in time, the evidence from there will show that it citizenship is still taken seriously, even if the franchise is extended in that way, but I won't go into that now, and I won't try and cover all the points in what I suspect was an eclectic debate. So, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.

06:44:18 - 06:44:34

Speaker 157

Is it your pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 33, Lord Udny-Lister, not moved. Amendment 34, Lord Fuller.

06:44:34 - 06:53:09

Charles John Fuller

Yes, thank you. I'm calming down. My Lords, this group, which I have most of the amendments, is sort of related to the third group, but it's more detailed this time. Look, I'm trying to put your Lordships' House in the shoes of the 16-year-old casting their first vote on their birthday. Statistically, 1,917 16-year-olds are likely to vote on their birthday and be able to go down to the polling station, and I'm thinking of them.

Look, this cohort won't have voted before. There's a serious need for neutral information about the mechanics of the election and the government, you know, for those for whom the government wants to vote for the first time. Now, my Amendment 34, which I think goes with the rub of the bill, proposes that the Electoral Commission particularly gives a special statutory duty to design media that appeals to the inexperienced cohort about how the elections work, how you prove your identity, not to invalidate the ballot paper by marking it with your initials, a mistake I once made as a youngster, and so forth. Now, times have changed, and I spoke to the noble Baroness Benjamin earlier. And times have changed since we were young, when we were brought up on Play School, Blue Peter, Bagpuss, Crackerjack, and Kate Adie and Alastair Burnet reading the news.

Because nowadays news is consumed in snippets on socials, on phones, on tablets, at home, on the go, and youngsters aren't interested in what the BBC says anymore, still less the noble Baroness Fox. So, it's important that the information that is produced by the Electoral Commission isn't just produced in an age-relevant manner, but it's distributed appropriately too, and that means online. And that brings me to the Children's Wellbeing and Social Act 2026 and the amended Online Safety Act, that give the Secretary of State powers to restrict access to social media to those under 16. And we understand the reasons. But sometimes legislation requires a trade-off to prevent a greater harm, and the act gives powers to segment that ban by age and material, so I'm not proposing something revolutionary that effectively nullifies Parliament's decision, but I want to use the powers in the act to carve out an exception for those people under 16 who are, importantly, registered to vote, allowing them access to election-related materials on social media in advance of an election to include those who will vote on their 16th birthday, but otherwise would have been excluded up to and including the day before.

how can these children be expected to form a view of whom to support at the ballot box, if they can't see, in advance, the full gamut of election material through social channels, including that practical information from the Electoral Commission about how the mechanics of the vote actually work? So, my amendment probing amendment seeks to bring into focus the obvious dichotomy that says on one hand, you know, youngsters are mature enough to play their part in choosing the governance of our nation, but on the other they are so immature they need to be shielded from the messages on which that election depends. This is the consequence of the muddle this Government has created around blurring the boundary between childhood and adulthood.

My amendment says that a social media ban that keeps youngsters away from the candidates, and more particularly from the Electoral Commission's information, would be the greater harm by undermining the democratic foundations of our nation. Technically, Section 214A of the Online Safety Act 2023, added by Section 70 of the Well-being and Schools Act, would be amended. If you're registered to vote, you'd be able to join the social media revolution. The Government says it wants to improve young people's engagement in democracy. I can't think of a stronger recruiting sergeant for democratic involve involvement than by incentivizing youngsters who are preparing to vote by giving them access to the socials.

And that's why in group three on Monday I suggested the age voter registration should be set at 15, not 14, partly because if you did register at 15, it'll be an appropriate age at which those who had registered could access social media. I'm sure we will return to this at report. But there's another second-order consequence of my proposal here, because we currently have no definitive method to authenticate somebody under 16 to prove their age for the purposes of the Online Safety Act. Ofcom is getting in a right muddle by trying to think of four different ways by which youngsters, you know, could prove their age. Well, if they're registered to vote, they'll be on the database, that would be enough.

And so I think there are some other areas in which it would enable ISPs, internet service providers, to fulfill an identity and age check. And at a stroke, it would lift a weight from parents who are subject to intolerable peer pressure from their friends and their children to have a social account when we know that if you're too young, it's just not in their best interests. So this Amendment number 39 would strengthen the hand of parents and the current system of age verification. So, now it moves me onto my Amendments 35 to 37, which cover the schools angle which was covered in group three earlier today. Now, at Sec- Second Reading, I warned that this bill brings party politics into schools.

Now, I'm not talking about the pedagogy of politics, but of political partisanship. This bill puts teachers in a difficult position. It drives wedges between pupils and invites parents to complain their own political prejudices haven't been adequately reinforced. It's our job to set the statutory ground rules for how electoral politics is treated in our schools. I heard the minister earlier, but we need to show teachers, pupils, and parents we will not permit a Wild West that disrupts the classroom, schools, and increases tension.

We need to strengthen their hand to resist providing a conduit for party activists. So, my amendments do not suggest that schools should not discuss the election at all, oh, no. After all, young people will have not have voted before, and teachers will have a role in explaining the process. But that doesn't mean that schools should be a dumping ground for all manner of party leaflets, otherwise schools will become a magnet and uh for these activists, who will conclude they can reach hundreds of voters at once, which is a damn sight easier than knocking on hundreds of doors.

But my amendments isn't just about the party activists. I'm also interested in protecting children from undue influence by teachers' personal political predispositions. So, my amendment 35, which is the duty to be impartial, is intended to strengthen the teachers' ability to insulate themselves from outside influence, and ensure learners age 14 to 18 can make neutral, informed decisions about their vote. My amendment 36 prohibits the display of election materials in educational establishments alongside outside the structured classroom environment, which indeed must be scrupulously impartial. And 38 relates to hustings and seeks to ensure that hustings held in schools are politically balanced, and that all candidates to hustings are given a reasonable notice and the opportunity to attend,

although whether they actually turn up will be up to them. Look, this is an important group. The other place failed to consider the practicality and second-order consequences of extending the franchise to those who are so young, they're still at school. We must stop turning schools into political battlegrounds, sowing division, reinforcing sectarianism, which happens in some areas, campaigning in Urdu, and placing schools so teachers and schools in an invidious position. But just as importantly, my this group will treat those who are mature enough to look to vote in the so who are mature enough to vote to look at the socials, provided they have exercised the privilege that is to be registered to vote in the first place.

06:53:09 - 06:53:11

Speaker 160

I beg to move.

06:53:11 - 06:53:18

Speaker 161

Amendment proposed: after clause 16, insert the new clause printed on the marshalled list.

06:53:18 - 07:01:07

Claire Fox

My Lords, the these amendments, 34, 35, 36, 38, 39, in the name of the noble Lord Fuller, I think do us a favour, in the sense that they do force us to consider second-order consequences of a very big constitutional change. And I think that, regardless of one's views on votes for 16 or 17 year olds, it's a hugely important shift in the franchise, and we should take seriously what that means for society, and for how we operate in terms of politics. And I think, therefore, I found the just even thinking through these issues very important. I wanted to raise something that's not quite reflected in it, but it's kind of come from it, which I've been wondering about, in terms of a kind of nervousness about electoral or party politics coming into the classroom, which is will there be a different atmosphere amongst teachers who are actively engaged in politics, and we'd want them to be, that's what you want citizens to be like, when instead of just educating pupils, they might want to kind of and not even just kind of winning their hearts and minds to ideas, they might want to win their votes. And it's a kind of slightly awkward situation, and I just wondered if the minister had any thoughts on this.

I mean, I've got quite a number of friends who are Labour Party teachers, Labour Party, maybe of the blue variety, but nonetheless Labour Party, and they go out canvassing, but it's a kind of separate activity. But they will actually be teaching people who will be newly enfranchised, and won't it be tempting, and you might think well, they'd know where the boundaries were, but I think this is what we have to consider, and whether we need to make it clear that should never occur.

And whereas one might think, oh, well, you know, Labour Party, can you imagine a situation where you've got teachers who are members of the Green Party of the Zionism is racism variety? If you what I mean going down that route of the Green Party, if they see and start relating to pupils as would-be voters, how uncomfortable that would be for Jewish pupils, the dangers of the sectarianism that have just been mentioned entering into the classroom. So I think it's right that we think about this. I also think that idea about age appropriate election materials is important both actually from a safeguarding point of view. Every teacher always has to think, is this appropriate for this age group?

You don't just teach people who were for example 13 the same as you would somebody who's 17. So, how will that affect? I mean, my concern was slightly different than the one the noble Lord Fuller said, which is, I don't want politics to be dumbed down either. So how do you kind of do it so that you're not then saying, oh, this is specifically designed for you young voters, and then it ends up kind of gutting any kind of depth from it? But these are things I want us to consider.

I also think that it's very important, this point about access to social media, to enable young people who at this stage are registered to vote, they've got the vote, that they can actually make better informed voting decisions. And we have to allow them to be free to research those for themselves. There is a real danger from the group 3 discussion that we see that, in order to make their political decisions, we're going to enable them via education, and that, of course, limits their freedom. Now, I thought that what I would do was just use an example of a government-backed, specially designed educational material that was designed to encourage and teach young people how to make the right choices, which always makes me anxious. But it became quite an infamous example because it was a Home Office funded game, Pathways for Teenagers, an educational interactive game for 11 to 18-year-olds.

And teachers were urged by the government to use it in their classrooms. In terms of making the right choices, players were given control because they were asked to be a person a character called Charlie in brackets (they/them), I kid you not, to negotiate scenarios involving online political content. Charlie was then rated depending on the choices that Charlie made, and the rating was in relation to extremism or radicalisation. And guess what activity scored badly? Discussing or researching migration online was a negative.

Engaging with posts about "the need to take back control of your country" or "the erosion of British values". If Charlie chose those choices, then they were the bad choices, and right at the end, if you make too many bad choices, you end up being sent to Prevent. This has been widely, and even internationally, ridiculed, this project, and the Home Office has, you know, you imagine, it's gone very quiet. It was ridiculed as manipulative propaganda. Ironically, it created a baddie, Amelia, a purple-haired, goth-style cartoon character, a teenage girl in a mini Union Jack from Bridlington, who tried to lure Charlie (they/them) on an anti-small-boats demo.

Now, Amelia has become an international superstar, a meme all over the world. And you know, I'm sure that's not what the government was hoping would happen, but it does show you something about unintended consequences. And the reason I'm using that example is just to simply say, I think teenage voters who are being enfranchised by this government would be should be trusted and would indeed be safer and better off and better informed if they were free to research themselves and make their own choices rather than being treated as though they're in an interactive game that have to come out at the right answer. And I think that one of the things I wanted to stress to the minister, as we go forward with the bill, is the ministers saw that raising these kind of probing amendments was somehow an attempt to undermining a manifesto promise or to destroy the bill, or all sorts of negative things. I genuinely think, as we just talked about the role of the house of this house, that what these amendments and similar are trying to do is to push the government to think through if this bill is fit for purpose and needs to have, on the face of the bill, some clear red lines, some clear guidance on these very important matters.

And if the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds is of such historic importance, as this government maintains, then we should give it a lot of attention and not just box-ticket through.

07:01:07 - 07:04:04

Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor

My Lords, I'd like to say a few words in support of my noble friend Lord Fuller's amendments 35 to 37. They are to require non-partisan teaching, non-party political posters or balanced hustings with all the candidates invited and with proper notice. I think they are very important amendments. It may be argued by the minister that they're already covered in the law under the 1996 Act, sections 406 and 407. And yes, the law does require schools to prohibit the promotion of partisan political views and to take steps to ensure the balanced presentation of views.

And there are also teachers' standards which require teachers not to use the standing or position to influence pupil, pupils who may be vulnerable or not due to age. And, of course, we have the duties under the Human Rights Act, also under the Equality Act, and then the promotion of British values. So all these are there, and before we are we may hear, I don't know what the noble lady the Baroness will respond to these amendments, but why I think they're important is that we're now looking at an entirely new category of people, of 16 and 17. The law, as it stands, was framed for the general teaching of youngsters at school, most of whom who wouldn't be going to the polls during their school years, maybe some at the very end of their school years, but mostly not. And therefore, it is a pretty abstract notion, the idea of what teachers are doing.

But now, we're going to be teaching youngsters, children who will be going to the polls, who are impressionable, and for whom it's not an abstract matter at all. And as other noble Lords have said, there is there really is a danger of, maybe not intentional influence, but non-intentional influence by the kind of material displayed, by the kind of teaching, including, as the noble lady, Baroness Fox, mentioned, how can somebody who is a very committed member of a party, any party, avoid somehow influencing youngsters?

And I think that it is necessary to have some sort of thinking by the government to how do you put in special provisions for people at school who will actually be voting as opposed to the cohorts we have aimed the law at to date, mostly who will not be voting in parliamentary or other elections.

07:04:04 - 07:07:23

Speaker 32

My Lords, I think Lord Fuller touched on what is perhaps the most interesting element of this group, which is something that doesn't directly affect this bill at all, that is the potential knock-on on more widely the Online Safety Act, because if we get to a place where we have 16 and 17-year-olds registered, the existence of that electoral register, as Lord Fuller rightly mentioned in passing, may become a potentially a very important building block in future age verification processes online under the Online Safety Act. So I suspect in some ways the biggest importance of these amendments to the issues these amendments raise is actually not for this bill, but for other areas that exercise us at other times. And I think the general I think there is a general point here which has come out through these amendments and in several earlier groups as well, which is that we will have two fundamentally different processes. Under this bill, we will have the right to vote from 16. Under the Online Safety Act, the key age threshold is 18, and I won't re-litigate the previous debates, particularly in light of my comments earlier, but just observe to myself

the fact that those two ages are different is not a reason to be particularly hostile to that, because we have many variations in all sorts of other areas, as was expressed in previous debates, but we should recognize those two numbers are different, and quite how those two systems will, therefore, properly interact with each other, I think it is fair to say it would be helpful to have more clarity from the government as to what its plan is to ensure that the different age threshold under the Online Safety Act doesn't provide for inadvertent unwanted consequences that damage the extension of franchise to 16-year-olds. In terms of the particular methods that Lord Fuller has chosen in his amendments, I don't quite agree with the details of all of them, but I think there is one important point that is worth drawing out under, which comes up under Lord Fuller's Amendment 35, depending on how one views of what how lawyers might argue over the word outcome. I think it is reasonable for schools to teach children about the values of democracy. And I think if you look at for example, the sorts of decisions made about the national curriculum under previous conservative governments, there is a very clear direction there that we are, as it were, as a nation, not neutral between democracy and dictatorship, and therefore things like an outcome where we want people to participate in the election, I think is something that is reasonable for schools to communicate, and it has to absolutely be done in a way that is fair, and it has to be done in a way that recognizes there are people who may wish to spoil their ballots, although people who may wish to not vote as a matter of principle, but promoting democracy is a reasonable part I think of our education system. So, although there are some details that I would would would would would disagree with, I think the basic point about how is the Online Safety Act world and the world to be created by this bill going to interact is one which would be very helpful to hear more from the government on.

07:07:23 - 07:14:06

Gerard James Jamieson

My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord, sorry, my noble friend Lord Fuller for his amendments which I do think raise some important questions about young people's access to electoral information and the need to ensure political balance in our schools. I know that we've had a number of I think very useful contributions. This has been one of the shorter debates, but I think there's some important points that have been raised. Now, as I recollect our discussions so far in this bill, most if not all noble Lords have been in almost universal agreement about education, civic education, and as the noble Lord Murphy of Torfaen, who is not in his place today, has said he spent 17 years teaching British constitution, and in fact my first exposure to democracy was learning British constitution which I'm pleased I passed. I also think my noble friend Lord Gascoigne made a very important point on the first day.

You know, he best encapsulated the point, votes at 16 cannot be seen as an end in itself, but rather be accompanied by an understanding of what citizenship is and what playing a part in our free, liberal, democratic society means and entails. Therefore, I think it is very important, and we are spending quite a lot of time on it, that we actually consider those two things in parallel. Now, this group again addresses the complete inconsistency in the government's approach to the votes at 16s. As my noble friend Lord Moynihan told us at second reading, if we consider a 16-year-old old enough to choose a government, then accepts that they're old enough to hear all the arguments, and Lord Phat did raise that we have a distinct difference with the online safety and 18 and votes for 16, and we need to somehow reconcile that and recognise that we need to make sure that those who are going to vote have the information they need. Now, my noble friend's amendment 34 would require political, neutral, age-appropriate election information to be published on social media, and that recognises the reality that young people, as has been said several times today, obtain their information online on social media and not through those more traditional channels of newspapers or TV.

And if the government intends to extend the franchise, they must ensure the newly enfranchised voters can access that information necessary to exercise that right. So, will the noble Baroness the minister explain how the government intends to ensure that young people can receive accurate and politically balanced electoral information? Amendment 39 raises a related question of access to information on social media and other related online platforms. There is a clear tension, as I've already discussed, on that matter. Of course, protecting children online is important and we have campaigned for the social media ban for under-16s.

Yet, for 16- and 17-year-olds who are entitled to vote, they do need access to this broad range of political views in a manner that is accessible to them. I turn to my noble friend's amendments 35 and 36 concerning political education and campaign materials in schools. Schools have an important role in preparing young people to understand our democratic institutions. There is a difficult line to tread in teaching pupils about politics and seeking to influence their political choices. And I agree with the noble Lord Phat that I would like to influence people that democracy matters, and that is something that I would say is acceptable, but there are clearly other areas where we do need political neutrality, and the noble Baroness Fox raised what in some ways is quite an alarming issue that was in schools, and we do need to ensure that type of thing does not influence 16- and 17-year-olds.

Political education should expose young people to competing arguments, but most importantly encourage independent critical thinking and allow them to reach their own conclusions. Of course, education does not exist in a bubble, but political education should never become an opportunity for partisan campaigning in or the polarization of a classroom. Whether from peers or from teachers, can the noble Baroness tell us what safeguards will ensure that electoral education remains politically balanced and what guidance will be provided to teachers about the use of party-political materials? And I do think they need guidance. We can't have a situation where every teacher is individually trying to work out what is the right balance.

So the noble Baroness, Fox, mentioned red lines. I'd certainly say guidance and clarity and consistency. Amendment 38 addresses the conduct of election hustings in schools. Such events can provide a valuable opportunity for young people to hear directly from candidates and question them about their policies, but they must be organized fairly. Giving one party privileged access to young voters would undermine the very purpose of political education.

Will the noble Baroness the minister confirm that schools organizing election hustings should provide reasonable notice and a fair opportunity for all candidates to participate, and how will these principles be reflected in government guidance? My Lords, the amendments in this group raise crucial questions about how young people prepare are prepared to participate in our democracy. If the government are determined to extend the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, they must ensure those young people have meaningful access to accurate information, a balanced political education, and the opportunity to hear competing political views. Political neutrality in schools must be protected, but cannot be a barrier to open discussion. And I also agree this point that both the noble Lord, Pack, and my noble friend, Lord Fuller, raised about online age verification and being on the electoral register could be a very helpful mechanism.

I hope the minister will address the practical concerns raised in this group and explain how the government intend to ensure that younger voters can exercise their democratic rights independently and with confidence.

07:14:06 - 07:19:50

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, Amendment 34 tabled by the noble Lord, Fuller, seeks to require extra steps to be taken to publish impartial, age-appropriate election information on social media suitable for young people who may be subject to restrictions on social media access. The Government agrees that extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds must go hand-in-hand with ensuring that young people have access to reliable information and the knowledge they need to participate, not just participate, but participate confidently in elections. We are also clear that the social media ban must not inadvertently cut young people off from valuable information that is essential for their democratic participation. While the Government's proposed social media restrictions will apply to young people under 16, they will still have access to many websites, including news sites, and to political information from a wide range of trusted sources, including schools, colleges, and the Electoral Commission. We have committed to working with regulators, industry, civil society, and subject-matter experts to ensure this information is accessible and easy to find for young people affected by the ban.

And we're also working across government to strengthen democratic education and media literacy, helping young people to develop the knowledge and skills they need to engage confidently with our democracy. And for those reasons, I don't believe an additional statutory duty to publish election information on social media is necessary. In relation to Lord Fuller's Amendments 35, 36, and 38 on political impartiality in schools and educational settings, of course I recognise the importance of ensuring young people receive politically balanced information and can make informed decisions about their vote. However, we don't consider these amendments are necessary. As I mentioned in response to amendments in Group 3, schools are already subject to clear legal duties on political impartiality.

They must prohibit the promotion of partisan political views and take reasonably practical steps to ensure that where political issues are brought to people's attention, opposing views are presented in a balanced way. Existing Department for Education guidance makes it very clear these duties not only apply to classroom teaching, and to pick up Baroness Lawlor's point, they also refer to public displays and school communications. There are also specific safeguards during election periods to prevent schools from being used to promote a particular party or candidate. And in relation to hustings, I would say when I was a parliamentary candidate on one occasion, I was invited to attend a hustings, which was then cancelled because other candidates weren't available to attend. So, I can verify that schools do take this very seriously.

At the same time, schools have an important role in helping young people understand democracy and the electoral process. Schools can harness the interest generated around election periods to raise political awareness through activities such as mock elections. Of course, it's true to say teachers have been educating voters since 1969, when votes for 18 were introduced, and before that for teachers in colleges and universities. And for many years, primary schools have organised mock elections of the kind I was just referring to, and I've participated in those myself. Therefore, the Government considers that the existing framework already provides an appropriate, judgment-based approach, which protects political impartiality without unnecessarily restricting or proscribing, sorry, legitimate educational activities.

Furthermore, I thank the noble Lord Fuller for tabling Amendment 39 and so raising the important question of how we ensure young people who have registered to vote have access to information to inform their voting decision and learn how elections operate. We agree that extending the franchise to 16- and 17-year-olds must go hand in hand with ensuring access to reliable information. And earlier this year, we did announce our intention to ban social media companies from offering their services to under-16s, alongside a package of other measures to improve their safety and well-being online. And I understand Lord Pack's references to the Online Safety Act and making sure that the these two things are working together. So, we must act the Government must act where it sees real evidence of harm, and these changes seek to reset the rules so that children are protected from the platforms and online features that create the most harm.

We are also clear that the social media ban mustn't inadvertently cut young people off from that valuable information that's essential for their democratic participation. The Electoral Commission does already provide a wide range of information, including resources specifically designed for young people. As I've set out earlier, we're working across government to strengthen democratic education and media literacy. And we do take the issues around the citizenship education around democracy, the very issue that Lord Pack was referring to.

It's important that young people understand, for example, that we value democracy, but they need to know the difference between that and dictatorship and some of the even worse methods of government. For these reasons, we don't believe that an additional statutory duty is necessary. So, I hope I've reassured noble Lords that we have put provisions in step for political education.

07:19:50 - 07:21:40

Claire Fox

Sorry. Really quickly, before the noble Lady sits down, I just wanted to query the two things. One is that the social media ban apparently will not prohibit young people from accessing trusted news sources. I mean, it's like trusted by who? Who makes that call?

That partly was my point. I mean, I would have thought that you could trust the Home Office to bring out an interactive game without getting it so badly wrong. So, that might be something to consider. And secondly, I think that the noble Lord Phatk, is absolutely right. We've just got to take look at this.

When the discussions came out about drilling for oil in the North Sea, searches on that were age-gated and anybody over under-16 couldn't get through, couldn't, you had to prove who you were and your age and so on and so forth. Now, that would have been quite a big discussion, I would have thought. So, does the noble Lady at least want to take back to the government the possibility of having a bit more of a layering, you know, thinking that through a bit more rather than just saying it's all going to be all right? I had to say I don't agree with the ban on social media for under-16s, and I had to listen to everybody in this House practically lecture me about how under-16-year-olds can't that you can't let them anywhere near this stuff and everything is going to lead to suicide and mayhem, bedlam, and all the rest of it. We've got to stop them getting access to it.

So, suddenly it's all, "Oh, it's okay if it's news." Well, that's news to me. But I therefore we need a bit more detail.

07:21:40 - 07:22:16

Gerard James Jamieson

Just to save the minister bobbing up too often. I just wanted a bit more clarity. Obviously, I understand that schools are obliged to be politically neutral. It is more, you know, we have tens of thousands of if not millions of teachers, I don't know the number, in this country. Clearly, if we are going to have 16 and 17-year-olds voting and we want politically neutral education on the political landscape for them, it's going to be a lot easier and will have much more consistency if there are clear guidelines that can be reviewed and can be seen by others.

07:22:16 - 07:22:21

Speaker 164

Is that the intention?

07:22:21 - 07:24:00

Jane Sharon Taylor

In response to the noble Lady Baroness Fox, social media is not the only or always the most reliable source of high-quality news content, as we all know only too well. So, I think it's important that young people will continue to have access to a wide range of trusted sources on political information. There will also be a defined list of exemptions, including, for example, educational services. So, she's right to flag up the point that we you know, we're in a new area here, so we do need to continue to think about how we make sure that there's access to information that's needed to make the decisions that these young people will be taking, but also protecting from some of the terrible harms we've seen in terms of online harms. The noble Lord Jamieson referred to the issue of impartiality in schools.

Existing guidance expressly allows schools to use election periods to raise political awareness and all of those issues. I'm not sure if I'm quite addressing his question here, but it will make sure that there is if there are mock elections, hustings, visits from candidates or party representatives, schools have to maintain a political balance in that. And I think that is the existing guidance, and I'm sure that schools already do this, so I'm sure they will continue to do so.

07:24:00 - 07:26:50

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, this debate hasn't quite gone in the direction I anticipated. My noble friend, Lord Pickles, who was the Secretary of State when I was a council leader many years ago, once addressed a meeting of the Conservative Group of Local Government and he said, "If you don't trust the folks, don't go into politics." True words. And politics is about cherishing and promoting the freedom of expression and freedom to explore, which is the bedrock of democracy. And I think the government is getting itself in a muddle here because, on one hand, they can't say, "Well, these youngsters—" and I'm thinking particularly of attainers aged 15 and above, you can't say, "Well, they you know, they're mature enough to vote or to at least prepare to vote on their 16th birthday to make their own decisions," but then in the same breath say, "Well, they're so immature, they need to be protected from socials."

Because where I think this debate has gone in an unexpected manner, is that we've now started to think about, well, what information will they be permitted to see? And I'm concerned about indoctrination. I'm concerned about groupthink. I'm concerned about censorship. And only state-approved media will be permitted for these rising attainers.

Now, and I think we've got to have a process where these attainers can have access to social media, and that in terms will do more for the promotion of registration to vote than any electoral registration officer or automatic registration. You see, the rising attainers need to have access to make up their own minds; otherwise, they could be forced underground, and I think that's really dangerous. Look, let's take the politics out of school. Let's give kids— they are kids— space to make up their own mind, to strengthen the hands of teachers against parents, activist parents and sectarianism, and but, most of all, these attainers need to have make informed choices. And if we do that, with those other safeguards in my other amendment, we'll take schools out of politics and create the best new generation of informed voters, rather than voters who have only seen that media that the incumbent government, in a conflict of interest, says is fit and proper for them to view and nothing else.

I beg leave to withdraw my amendments in this group, but I would like to work with the noble Lord Phat, and others, just to test out these social media provisions between now and report.

07:26:50 - 07:27:07

Speaker 37

Is amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. Amendments 35 to 36, Lord Fuller, not moved. Amendment 37, Baroness Pinnock, not moved. Amendments 38 and 39, Lord Fuller, not moved.

We now come to amendment 40, Lord Hayward.

07:27:07 - 07:37:07

Robert Hayward

My Lords, this amendment is essentially about the operation of the impact assessment and the way it looks at the costs in general. I've chosen one particular example, but I will come back in more detail about one or two other elements of the impact assessment overall.

Before I do so, I would just make a broad observation that I'm interested in the inclusion of these two clauses, 15 and 16, which put an obligation to educate in relation to 16- and 17-year-olds. But when we pass legislation in relation to obligations that are imposed on teachers, or doctors, or large numbers of other groups, there aren't similar clauses in legislation, and I don't know whether this is going to be a new development that each time we pass a bill, we're going to finish up introducing a clause which says all there must be an education of farmers, or there must be an education of seagoers, or whatever it may happen to be. So, I actually call into question whether there is, whether these two clauses should actually be in the bill. The other observation I'd make is in relation to impact assessments in general. They started several decades ago,

and the original intention of the impact assessments, as I understood it, and I have looked back, was to look at the burdens that were imposed on particular groups, and that was all it was intended to do. And I say that as somebody who was for a period the chief executive of the Beer and Pub Association and had to deal with the changes associated with the Licensing Act. The impact assessments nowadays seem to be not only a question of an assessment of costs and burdens, but also, and I say this in particular in relation to this impact assessment, a justification of every decision that's been taken.

It is quite striking. You read paragraphs that explain why the government's taken a decision in relation to whatever it may happen to be. Now, that certainly was never the aim of the impact assessment. Now, I come on to my major concern, and I plead in aid, firstly,

the impact assessment that went with the football Regulation Bill, which only a few weeks ago was identified as having the impact assessment was out by over a hundred percent in 12 months. I've gone through this impact assessment, and I find myself in exactly the same quandary. I do not understand how many of the figures have been arrived at,

and therefore I would ask the minister, firstly, is it the same people who drew up the impact assessment for the Football Regulation Bill who have drawn up this foot this impact assessment, or have they operated to the same broad rules? Now, there are explanations of the principles that they've followed within it, and I have read every single line of the impact assessment. But if they're following the same rules that resulted in another impact assessment being over a hundred percent out in 12 months, I think the Treasury is going to have quite a surprise when it gets to discover what the actual costs of this bill are.

Now, the particular chart, assessment of costs, that I want to refer to in specifically is on page 59, and it relates to the burden, the costs associated with the introduction of 16, votes at 16- and 17-year-olds.

Now we heard from Lord Fuller the other day on Monday about the information that he'd received about the costs for local authorities in terms of the actual registration of new voters. The other side of the costs, and we've heard about it persistently today, is the obligation to educate. Baroness Royall, Baroness Lister, Lord Phat, Lord Rennard, any number of noble Lords have said that there needs to be greater levels oh Lord Wallace, sorry I wouldn't want to exclude him from that list, have said that there need to be much greater levels of education for this group. And there does. Not just to ensure that they're registered, but also because we have to ensure that they are fully aware, as has been identified on any number of occasions, of the issues on which they are being asked, ultimately, to vote.

Now I'm going to quote from one or two parts of the impact assessment and I hope I get this right here in order. But in relation to staffing costs, page 52 paragraph 118 it says, and I quote, "Extra staff may be needed to deal with the additional demand in some local authorities." Now, which local authorities are not going to have the extra demand? And I'm talking here both about registration and education. Then you go on to page 58 paragraph 160: "Wider staffing costs associated with votes at 16 policy have been excluded in line with the treatment of the MHCLG department's staffing costs in this impact assessment."

Then we come on to paragraph 170, where it says it concludes it identifies a particular issue and then it says, "Therefore this cost is not monetised." Now, I don't have the IT capacity to actually go through the whole document to find out how many times it says this cost is not monetised. But I don't have to look very much further than paragraph 170. All I have to go to is paragraph 174, where the phrase is used again: "This cost these contributions are not considered significant in cost terms and have therefore not been monetised." Now, what are these costs in 174 that have been not monetised?

And I quote, "There is an additional resource implication arising from the collaborative development of policy with staff from other governmental departments, principally the DfE," which doesn't come as a surprise given the debates we've had, "contributing meaningfully to its design. There is also a potential impact on education staff." Education staff in every single local authority across the country. And therefore how on earth does one come back to may have implications for some local authorities?

Now, there are many other examples that I could quote, but I then come in conclusion, my Lords, to the paragraph where it which is paragraph 166 in the impact assessment, page 59. The Electoral Commission have been asked to submit their assessment of their costs, and there is no question about it, they have very substantial costs. And in the central scenario, these are given as 39.8 million pounds.

Now, you might think, "Well, the Electoral Commission has got certain work, but all these local authorities, all these government departments, all these registration officers." Now, what figure if the Electoral Commission has got 39.8 sorry, I missed out the .8 39.8 million extra costs, what have all the other government departments and local authorities got? The figure is given as a mere 45 million pounds, in round terms, for sorry, 48 million pounds. So, it's almost the same as it is for the Electoral Commission.

It I was going to use a word that I'd normally hear more on a rugby pitch than I would in the Chamber here, but all I'll say is, my Lords, this impact assessment, in so many ways, is not credible. I beg to move.

07:37:07 - 07:37:14

Speaker 37

Amendment proposed, after clause 16, insert the following new clause as printed on the marshalled list.

07:37:14 - 07:41:53

Charles John Fuller

I haven't spent as much time as my noble friend, Lord Hayward, going line by line through the impact assessment, but I have spent some time with text searches to try and find the paragraphs that relate to the issues that have concerned me most as we've debated the bill thus far, which are for the attainers and the 16 and the 16 to 18-year-olds. And because so much of it says, "non-monetized", I've made my own inquiries. I've made my own inquiries of one of the more senior electoral registration officers in the country, who also happens to be a police area returning officer, a PARO, as well. And we've heard in this the debate hence hitherto how many assumptions are made insofar as, you know, what the powers may be, by extending the franchise and also things from auto-enrolment.

And, my Lords, there is going to be so much more handwork. There are going to be so many more duplicate entries created automatically. There's going to be the need to deduplicate the duplicates that have been created through the best of reasons, but that's just where the legislation is. And there are so many moving parts. And I want to dwell, and I didn't realize that the noble Lord was going to mention the figure of 45 million pounds, but I want to dwell,

I'm sorry, 48 million pounds, but I do want to dwell on the provisions for registering the attainers alone, those people who this bill proposes, aged between 14 and 16, who will come onto the register, but don't have a national insurance card, they don't have a gas bill because their parents do that bit, they don't have a driving license, they may not have a passport,

They effectively don't really exist to the state. I asked my returning officer, "For these kids who don't have a National Insurance number, how are you going to register them on the roll?" And he says, "Well, the only way we can do it is through handwork." Handwork, manually.

And how long might this take? Well, then there's the process. They may need to go, you may need to go and identify them, you've got to write to them, there's a letter come back, you can't automatically validate them, you see. And they've got to send other documentary evidence. There's a lot of backwardsing and forwardsing.

Sometimes it may lead to an attestation in the court because the 'seems to' thing works well. If you're like Members of your Lordships' House, we're in work, we've got a National Insurance number, we pay our taxes, probably got a driving license, we've probably got a passport. All these things are available to us, which aren't to the attesters. And I've worked out, for the 1.4 million people for two hours a pop, and that's being generous because there's a number of different things that need to go backwards and forwards on paper, is going to take 2,000 extra staff in local government offices up and down this country for that provision alone, making the important assumption that they come in sort of evenly rather than all in a rush, which we know sort of happens. If I was just to take as a sum, £45,000 a year for the salary, the on-costs, because National Insurance is so much more expensive nowadays, and the training and the computer licensing and all those other things, for the registration of 14 to 15-year-olds alone, it's a £90 million cost for that element.

That's twice the total impact assessment for all the other things put together. And then we have all the automatic registration, all the assumptions and, you know, how is the Electoral Registration Officer going to be able to make these value judgments if you have people who don't really, aren't really documented? So that's what, so the, there's a big wedge of money there. There's so much still unknown to be determined by secondary legislation. I'll give way.

07:41:53 - 07:42:12

Robert Hayward

I didn't make reference to the question of automatic registration, but since the noble, my noble friend has encouraged me to do so, on page 101, improving registration is given as £5.2 million.

07:42:12 - 07:43:47

Charles John Fuller

I think that you'd characterize that as the down payment. But there we are. Now, look, so much has to be done by secondary legislation. Look, I'm not going to trespass too greatly on a future group, but when it comes to identification and bank cards, there are all sorts of unintended consequences which I repeat, I won't go into now, but there are going to have to be huge changes in systems for bank cards if they are to be fit for purpose. Baroness Pinnock, who isn't in her place earlier, posited that the automatic registration and the duplicates may lead to more frequent boundary reviews.

One thing's absolutely for sure: the way in that which the legislation is today, we're going to need duplicate and parallel IT systems, which will have to be reconciled, and that's going to be expensive. So, and this is just for, and my focus has been on the 1.4 million attainers, but there's a further 1.4 million 16 to 18-year-olds, many of whom won't also have the documentary evidence. So, I know that democracy has a cost.

We live in a free society, that costs money. But what we haven't worked out are the costs in this impact assessment. The figure that the noble Lord has referred to is just a down payment, is a drop in the ocean. My chance are, it's probably four times greater than that, and we should be told.

07:43:47 - 07:46:09

Speaker 32

That's an enthusiastic heckle there. Here. The impact assessment weighing in at 130 pages, I think it's fair to say is very on brand for election law and given our comments earlier about how voluminous election law is. I was struck though in looking through it how little there is about police time and police resources, because we are already in a situation as the noble lady the minister will know well from other questions and debates previously, in a situation where councillors, MPs, members of political parties are often quite frustrated when they raise issues with the police, perhaps about fears of personal safety due to harassment and how often those police resources are not really available to properly follow up on such concerns.

And in the parts of the bill that we'll be coming to on future days rather than this evening to do with political finance, some of the issues we're looking at there to do with, for example, crypto transfers will require quite sophisticated and advanced investigatory techniques. It won't simply be a matter of whether the local police team have got resources to take issues raised with them to do with election law seriously, I'm sure there will actually be quite a lot of pressure on many specialised parts of the police service, the National Crime Agency and so on. And it is striking to me that the impact assessment seems to me to be, I say, just about completely silent in case I have missed something in my reading of it, but I didn't actually spot any reference at all to the potential costs to the police and to associated law enforcement apparatus of the range of offences, for example, that this bill either will create or will toughen up or will put a greater focus on as a result of other parts of the bill. So I hope the noble lady the minister can tell us a little bit about what assessments have been made of what the potential costs are to the law enforcement apparatus and what reassurance we can have is that whatever form this bill takes when it is passed, and then hopefully also commenced by the government, that there will be the necessary resources available to actually enforce it.

07:46:09 - 07:49:46

Speaker 148

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord Hayward, for tabling this amendment and indeed for everything else he's done on this bill, because he has worked many hours. It seeks to address the numerous unqualified costs arising from the provisions of this bill, which has surely not escaped anyone's notice, some of which have been raised in this chamber today, as well as those that were raised on Monday. And I'm really concerned that the government is proposing substantial changes to our electoral system without providing a sufficiently comprehensive account of what those changes will mean. It's particularly concerning given the scale of reforms proposed and the additional responsibilities they'll place upon electoral administrators and local authorities.

Can I ask the noble Baroness the minister how she expects this House or those in the other place to properly assess value for money when one of the principal costs of implementing a major reform has not even been qualified? We're potentially looking as substantial expenditure on new IT infrastructure, data-sharing arrangements, staff training and ongoing administration costs. Can the noble Baroness the minister commit to evaluating the total cost of rolling out automatic voter registration first?

We've yet to receive a number. Moreover, this bill seeks to place a greater burden upon local authorities. Electoral registration officers already operate within a complex legislative framework. This bill will introduce further obligations, potentially requiring new systems and additional verification procedures. Has it failed to escape the government's notice that this will be a great expenditure?

We all know local authorities are already under considerable financial pressure. It's therefore essential that the government explains whether these additional costs will be fully funded by central government or are councils simply meant to absorb them from existing budgets? I welcome a clear answer from the noble baroness the Minister. The government have proceeded with substantial changes to electoral and political finance law without the degree of prior consultation that such measures deserve. Indeed, significant provisions have been introduced or altered during the passage of this bill following the original impact assessment, as my noble friend Lord Hayward has actually identified already.

That makes a comprehensive assessment of the cumulative financial impact all the more important. I therefore ask the Minister two very straightforward questions. Will the government publish a full estimate of the cost of implementing automatic voter registration, including that of the IT infrastructure? Will authorities be fully compensated for the additional burdens imposed by this legislation? My noble friend Lord Hayward's amendment asks the government to be transparent, accountable and to use public money responsibly.

These are not, and should not be, controversial principles. I hope the Minister can provide this House with substantive answers rather than simply referring us back to an impact assessment which leaves significant questions unanswered.

07:49:46 - 07:52:34

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, turning to Lord Hayward's amendments, the provisions he refers to are important to ensure we encourage as many eligible young people as possible to participate in our democracy. I'll come on to the monitoring and evaluation in a moment, but to respond to his points about the impact assessment: this impact assessment, as all impact assessments produced by governments, are produced by departments in line with His Majesty's Treasury investment guidance in the Green Book. So, we follow the rules that are set out in that Green Book. However, a number of detailed questions have been raised about this impact assessment. I think the most helpful thing I can do at this stage of our debate is to write to noble Lords in response to the very particular questions they've asked me about this impact assessment.

In relation to I would just say, in relation to local authority costs, as the noble baroness will know only too well and has probably lobbied on as I have, where there are new burdens on local government, then government has to respond to that by providing funding for those new burdens. In relation to the monitoring and evaluation of the bill, our approach will comply with our published evaluation strategy and that's what we were referring to in relation to in the impact assessment. We will publish evaluation findings in a timely manner, consistent with our policy for the publication of research and Government Social Research guidelines. And that impact evaluation will assess the impacts of the reforms on electors and on local authorities and others responsible for delivering elections; a process evaluation that will seek to examine how the reforms are implemented; and, excuse me, as I referred to earlier this afternoon, an economic evaluation that will assess whether the benefits of the policies actually outweigh their costs.

These are difficult areas to address because anyone that's tried to do it will know that net present social value is quite a difficult concept to evaluate in financial terms, and monetizing it, which is where some of the difficulty occurs. But the appraisal of policies in the impact assessment does rely heavily on qualitative evidence and non-monetized impacts which don't get reflected in that net present social value calculation. But it's important that we continue to look at that economic you know, a clear picture of that economic evaluation, which we will do. So the areas highlighted by the noble Lord will be covered by this work in terms of monitoring, but as I say, I commit to write to members on the specific financial questions they've raised this afternoon.

07:52:34 - 07:52:56

Robert Hayward

Thanking the minister for a very open response, can I just touch on one thing which she referred to earlier on this afternoon, which time didn't allow me to comment on during my opening remarks, and that was the fund which is not referred to in the impact assessment, which she referred to earlier, but on that basis, I seek leave to withdraw my amendment.

07:52:56 - 07:53:40

Speaker 37

Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendments 41 to 43, Baroness Lister, not moved. Amendment 44, Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, not moved. Amendment 44A, Baroness Berridge, not moved.

44B, Lord Bird, not moved. In clause 17, amendment 45, Lord Fuller, not moved. 46, Baroness O'Neill, not moved. 47, Lord Austin of Dudley, not moved. 48, Baroness O'Neill, not moved.

Amendments 49 to 50, Lord Rennard, not moved. Amendment 51, Lord Jackson, not moved.

07:53:40 - 07:53:42

Speaker 166

My Lords, I beg to move the House be resumed.

07:53:42 - 07:53:57

Speaker 167

The question is that the House be now resumed. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. Other contents have it.

07:53:57 - 07:53:59

Speaker 168

My Lords, I beg to move the House do now adjourn.

07:53:59 - 07:53:59

That the House do now adjourn.