House of Commons

4 November 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:21 - 00:28
Lindsay Hoyle
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Order.  We start with questions to the Secretary of State for Wales, Shabana Rashid. 
00:28 - 00:32
Speaker 4
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, question number one. 
00:32 - 00:34
Speaker 2
Minister. 
00:34 - 01:09
Speaker 10
I thank NHS staff and care workers for their tireless work, but I also understand the frustration felt by the people in Wales that waiting lists are going up under the Plaid Cymru government.  Just last week, the Chancellor announced an additional £450 million for the Welsh Government to deliver public services.  This is on top of the largest spending review settlement since devolution.  So, I hope that the Plaid Welsh Government uses this funding wisely to improve NHS services and reduce waiting lists. 
01:09 - 01:10
Shabana Rashid. 
01:10 - 01:39
Speaker 9
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  Welsh Government figures show that as of March 2025, there were more than 30,000 Welsh people waiting for NHS treatment in England, almost three times the number in 2011.  What discussions has the Secretary of State had with the Welsh Government about managing this cross-border demand, reducing waiting times in Wales and ensuring that services in England have the capacity to meet the needs of patients on both sides of the border? 
01:39 - 01:40
Minister. 
01:40 - 02:14
Speaker 10
Well, I thank the Member for her question, and Wales is the home of the NHS and I am proud of the way that Welsh Labour has always been its fiercest defender, even in the face of Tory austerity.  Welsh Labour brought those waiting lists down for 10 months consecutively before the last election.  They're now rising under the Plaid Cymru government, and we now need to see clear action from the Welsh Government to bring these down.  And we regularly have discussions on how we can do that. 
02:14 - 02:16
Lindsay Hoyle
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Jessica Morden. 
02:16 - 02:37
Lab Member of Parliament | Newport East
Member of Parliament | Newport East
Jessica Morden
Mr. Speaker, as the Minister has just said, NHS waiting lists have soared to a 10-month high since Plaid Cymru's election, despite progress being made in them coming down under Welsh Labour.  Would the Minister join me in urging Plaid to make cutting wait waiting lists a priority, especially as we enter these winter months when NHS pressures are at their greatest? 

02:37 - 02:39

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

02:39 - 03:21

Speaker 10

My right honourable friend is absolutely right. Waiting lists are going up under Plaid Cymru after the Welsh Labour government brought them down for 10 months straight. Welsh Labour has always prioritised the NHS: free prescriptions, mental health support via 111, free car parking in hospitals, women's health hubs, specialist mental support in every school. These were Welsh Labour decisions based on Welsh Labour values, and I urge the Plaid Cymru government to honour them, perhaps by using the 450 million in the additional funding that this UK Labour government announced at the budget just last week.

03:21 - 03:23

Speaker 3

Llinos Medi.

03:23 - 03:26

Speaker 7

Question two, please.

03:26 - 03:52

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This was a proudly Labour budget, one that provides people in Wales with breathing space for tomorrow, for today, and hope for tomorrow. We're helping Welsh families with the cost of living, extending 0% VAT on electricity bills, getting rid of gas standing charges, and removing the 4% tariff on heating oil to support 105,000 households in Wales.

03:52 - 03:53

Llinos Medi.

03:53 - 04:20

Llinos Medi

Mr Speaker, the autumn budget will deliver real-terms cuts to Welsh public services because it fails to compensate for higher inflation. Those are not my words, but those of Cardiff University who say Wales now faces difficult choices, including cuts to local authorities like mine on Ynys Môn. Can the Secretary of State explain why this UK Labour government is imposing cuts on Welsh public services?

04:20 - 05:01

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Mr Speaker, I genuinely don't know where Plaid Cymru is getting these numbers from. This budget provides the Welsh government with an additional £450 million for public services, meaning the Welsh government settlement continues to grow in real terms over the SR period. In addition, UK government is providing a £6.5 billion increase in Welsh government spending power as a result of changes to the fiscal framework, additional funding through Barnett, and the largest settlement in the history of devolution. This general generational increase in 2025 was the largest settlement for Wales since devolution began in the late 1990s.

05:01 - 05:04

Lindsay Hoyle

Chair of the Select Committee, Ruth Jones.

05:04 - 05:29

Ruth Jones

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I greatly welcome the Chancellor's announcement of a further £30 million for the delivery of new station at Cardiff Parkway in my neighbouring constituency. Does the min- does the Secretary of State agree with me that this investment stands in stark contrast to the approach of the Plaid minority government at Cardiff Bay, which is threatening to close numerous junctions of the M4, worsening air and noise pollution for residents in my constituency?

05:29 - 05:59

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I absolutely share my right honourable friend's frustration. The Welsh government must recognise that only a relief road will address the needs of the people, the economy and the environment of southeast Wales. What local people do not need is disruption and junction closures. I was pleased to see the Senedd support Welsh Labour's motion to rule out closures and to begin work on appropriate relief road for the M4, and I would urge Plaid Cymru to work with Newport Council and to reconsider their position.

05:59 - 06:04

Lindsay Hoyle

Mims Davies, shadow secretary of state.

06:04 - 06:50

Mims Davies

Thank you, Mr Speaker. A damp squib budget, which largely forgot Wales. Nothing on upgrading the A55 or the M4 bypass. The previous Welsh government was offered the finance by the last Conservative government to unclog the Brynglas Tunnels, yet the Minister's Labour Senedd colleagues, as we've heard, had the hyde last month to call for an M4 relief road, despite being in power for 27 years. Mr Speaker, can the Secretary of State explain why Labour is now making calls on projects it could and should have delivered when in power, or do they prefer to just be the ones shouting from the hard shoulder now?

06:50 - 06:52

Speaker 13

Secretary of State.

06:52 - 07:28

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

I have to say, I'm quite taken aback, Mr Speaker, by the brass neck of the party opposite after 14 years of neglect and incompetence, failing to fund rail, failing to fix so many of the problems that the that were caused by their neglect and incompetence. I as I say, I am very pleased that the Welsh Labour's motion, our Welsh Labour motion in the Senedd was approved, and we call on the Welsh government, Plaid Cymru, to change tack, to reconsider and do the right thing for the people of Wales.

07:28 - 07:29

Mims Davies.

07:29 - 08:11

Mims Davies

Well, Mr Speaker, a screeching U-turn for all of us to see. Matters sadly, as we've heard today, could go from bad to horrendous for M4 drivers. With the separatist, Plaid Cymru Welsh Government now threatening to close those multiple junctions, the Wales Office simply have sat on their hands. Compare that to my Conservative colleagues and I who scrapped the Severn toll bridge tolls. Mr Speaker, where's the action?

Where's the pushback? And after this failure, can the Secretary of State tell the House why drivers and businesses should have any confidence that this Labour government will stand up to them and to Plaid?

08:11 - 08:51

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, in terms of the support, she talked about the budget, and let's just remind ourselves what the budget's doing for drivers, extending the temporary 5p per litre fuel duty cut for a further six months, making permanent the 55p per mile tax-free mileage rate for the first 10,000 business miles. This will save a worker travelling 6,000 business miles at least a hundred and £20 a year in tax from 27/28, and extending the 3.7 pence cut to red diesel duty to the 1st of July 2027. So, I would respectfully suggest to the honourable lady she should perhaps go back, have a look at the budget, and come back when she's got her facts right.

08:51 - 08:54

Lindsay Hoyle

David Chadwick, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

08:54 - 09:25

David Chadwick

Diolch, Mr Speaker. Communities across Wales are desperate to see economic growth, desperate to see new jobs in their communities. And that's why the Welsh Liberal Democrats believe that Wales needs more powers over borrowing, full powers over rail infrastructure, and full powers over the Crown Estate. Can the Secretary of State confirm if he agrees with us, will Wales be getting more powers during this Parliament?

09:25 - 09:26

Secretary of State.

09:26 - 10:00

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank the honourable member and I just want to wish him luck as well in the forthcoming leadership election. I believe he's standing against himself so I'm sure it'll be a positive outcome for him. He mentions rail, I am absolutely delighted we've secured at least 450 45 million pounds to progress rail projects across Wales, including 30 million pounds to progress Cardiff Parkway front-loaded to support delivery of Welsh priorities during the spending review period. And I'm sure he and the Liberal Democrats would join me in welcoming those measures.

10:00 - 10:02

Lindsay Hoyle

Liz Saville Roberts.

10:02 - 10:40

Liz Roberts

Gari ar Lywydd. The Prime Minister promised to end 40 years of Thatcherite ideology, but last week's budget was a whimper, not a reset. A poll since the budget found that 60% of voters believe it merely tinkers round the edges. That's what they're saying. And in Wales, we can see why: real-terms cuts loom for public services, shrinking capital budget, and no meaningful moving movement on rail funding.

So does the Secretary of State understand why so many people in Wales feel the budget falls so far short of the promises talked up by his government?

10:40 - 11:22

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her for that question, but again I'm just not sure that people are clear on the other benches what this budget is delivering. In addition to all of the breathing space measures, which are making a really clear difference to the cost of living, we've got £30 million on Cardiff Parkway railway station, 2.5 million on new funding for M-SParc, 11 million for the Aberavon Bridge, 20 million to support reindustrialisation on AI sectors. And of course this is on in on top of all the work we're doing around nuclear power on Wylfa, revitalising the Welsh steel industry. So I think, again, with all due respect to the honourable lady, I think she should perhaps go back, have another look at the budget, come back when she's got her facts straight.

11:22 - 11:23

Liz Saville Roberts.

11:23 - 12:02

Liz Roberts

From the 14 billion that's been promised, and 300 million for Le Leeds railway station, there are threats of cuts everywhere. The BBC has announced 9 million pounds of cuts at BBC Cymru Wales. This includes 58 job losses. 20 hours of programming, as well as radio shows like Dros Ginio and Ail Farc, will be axed, and Welsh production companies are raising the alarm about the impact of fewer commissions. We've had to fight hard for Welsh language broadcasting.

So, what's he doing, as Wales's supposed man in the Cabinet, to protect jobs and to safeguard our national media?

12:02 - 12:04

Lindsay Hoyle

Secretary of State.

12:04 - 12:36

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I am proud to be a strong voice for Wales in the Cabinet. And, Mr Speaker, I find it frankly shocking that those on the Benches opposite think that Wales shouldn't have a strong voice in the Cabinet. In terms of broadcasting, we absolutely will work closely. Of course, we're ready to work closely with the Welsh Government, and to ensure that our broadcasting industry, which we are very proud of, continues to go from strength to strength. And I look forward to working with her and other colleagues to achieve that objective.

12:36 - 12:37

Jim Shannon.

12:37 - 12:42

Jim Shannon

Question number three, Mr Speaker, please.

12:42 - 12:45

Speaker 22

Secretary of State.

12:45 - 13:08

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Straight back up there, sorry. Excuse me. With your permission, Mr Speaker, I will answer questions three and 11 together. The UK Government is committed to driving economic growth in Wales. We're investing 2.6 billion pounds to bring back nuclear power to Wylfa, 500 million pounds to secure the future of Welsh steel, and 50 million pounds to support defence jobs across Wales.

13:08 - 13:09

Jim Shannon.

13:09 - 13:48

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr Speaker, I thank the Secretary of State very much for his response. He and I both know that, when it comes to driving economic growth, whether it is in Wales or indeed in Northern Ireland, we are always better together, and that's important. Given that both Wales and Northern Ireland face similar challenges with rural economic development and supporting our vital small business sectors, what specific lessons has his Department shared with the Northern Ireland Office and the devolved Executive to ensure that targeted, regional growth strategies work collectively to strengthen this and the entire United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland?

13:48 - 14:31

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank him. And he mentions rural economic development. We are extending the 3.7p cut to red diesel to July 2027, we're suspending tariffs on fertiliser, and we're removing the 4% tariff on heating oil, which will support 105,000 Welsh households, and I'm sure many of his constituents will also benefit. We also had productive talks in the National Economic Council in Glasgow. Of course, it was unfortunate that the Northern Irish Government wasn't represented in those talks, but we will certainly continue to work closely with him and others to ensure strong co- cooperation and collaboration across all of the nations that make up our United Kingdom.

14:31 - 14:33

Lindsay Hoyle

David Chadwick.

14:33 - 15:05

Steve Witherden

Mr Speaker, the Access for All Programme is 20 years old this year, yet much work is to be done on making it easier for rail passengers with mobility constraints. The northbound platform at Ruabon station, in my constituency, for example, still has no step-free access, and is in desperate need of a ramp or, better yet, a lift. What steps is the Department taking to improve accessibility at Welsh railway stations?

15:05 - 15:36

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I enjoyed meeting with my honourable friend just last week, where we discussed Ruabon station. My officials have since raised this project with Network Rail. I'm very pleased to confirm that the UK Government has announced Ruabon as one of the 23 stations across Great Britain selected to progress to the next stage of the Access for All Programme.

I look forward to further engagement with my honourable friend on this vitally important project, which I believe includes the installation of what is known in the trade as a jack-in-the-box lift.

15:36 - 15:37

Carolyn Harris.

15:37 - 15:39

Carolyn Harris

Question four, Mr Speaker.

15:39 - 15:42

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

15:42 - 16:14

Speaker 10

This government is delivering the biggest sustained increase in defence spending since the Cold War, investing £298 billion over the next four years to strengthen our national security and keep us safe. Wales is well placed to benefit from this investment, with 20,000 defence jobs already in Wales. Every pound we invest in defence should be judged by what it does. We want to ensure that all investment brings jobs, skills, and strengthens our national security.

16:14 - 16:15

Carolyn Harris.

16:15 - 16:41

Carolyn Harris

Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's disappointing to see the Plaid Welsh Government decide to delay defence investment decisions in Wales, including on DARC in Pembrokeshire. Welsh Labour will always take the defence of Wales seriously, even if they won't. Can the minister update me on the Welsh Government's commitment to establishing defence technical colleges in Wales so we can get on with training up the next generation of defence experts?

16:41 - 16:42

Minister.

16:42 - 17:23

Speaker 10

Well, my honourable friend is absolutely right, and Labour will always put the defence and security of the Welsh people first. That's why last week we announced that if the Welsh Government continue to drag their feet in committing to a Wales defence technical excellence college, the UK Government stands ready to step in where Plaid won't. With the Scottish Government already making clear their commitment to DTECs in Scotland, I strongly urge the Welsh Plaid Cymru Government to come to the table and work with us so we can protect our security and create the jobs of the future.

17:23 - 17:25

Lindsay Hoyle

Bernard Message.

17:25 - 17:49

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Mr Speaker, the Ajax programme is obviously a huge employer of in Merthyr Tydfil via the General Dynamics Land Systems factory, but with the government unable to get Ajax back on track and with no guarantee of any defence exports going forward, all work at the factory is due to stop after the vehicles have been upgraded to capability drop four. So what are the government doing to ensure the jobs at those factories remain beyond the completion of the work on the Ajax programme?

17:49 - 17:50

Minister.

17:50 - 18:30

Speaker 10

Absolutely, the honourable member makes a very good point, and General Dynamics is very important industry, and I have many conversations with them about their investment and continuation of the programme. While the Ajax programme has encountered challenges, and we know of them, considerable effort has been invested in resolving them and driving this programme forward. This organisation invests hugely in the local community, delivering high-quality jobs, and that is part of our £50 million pound growth defence growth deal that we want to ensure that this continues well into the future.

18:30 - 18:34

Lindsay Hoyle

Charlie Dewhirst, Shadow Minister.

18:34 - 19:12

Charlie Dewhirst

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Now the Welsh defence industry supports 20,000 jobs and is absolutely vital to the national security of the United Kingdom, yet defence firms face growing uncertainty over the UK Government's failure to set out a detailed plan to meet the 3% of GDP target on defence spending alongside Plaid Cymru's proposed defence ethical investment framework in Wales. Both are creating serious concern for businesses looking to invest, expand and protect jobs. Therefore, what discussions has the minister had with defence companies about these concerns, and what is she doing to give the industry the certainty it desperately needs?

19:12 - 19:14

Speaker 26

Minister.

19:14 - 20:08

Speaker 10

Well, I thank the honourable member opposite, but I think he may have a short memory. It is his government that cut the army to its smallest size since Napoleonic times and shortchanged the equipment plan by 17 billion. In stark contrast, this Chancellor announced a £298 billion investment over the next four years into defence.

We are working at pace to deliver the Defence Growth Deal across the country, high-quality jobs and investment across Wales. I am urging the Plaid Cymru government to stop at nothing, work with us and ensure that we are delivering security for the people of Wales and those high-quality jobs.

20:08 - 20:09

Boris Curtis.

20:09 - 20:12

Speaker 44

Question number five, Mr Speaker.

20:12 - 20:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Secretary of State.

20:14 - 20:41

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, whether it is through Wales's role in bolstering UK's defence, steel production or leading the way in industries like compound semiconductors and life sciences, our Union of Nations is hugely strengthened by Wales. You can't put a ceiling on the awesome talent and ambition of the Welsh people, Mr Speaker, and I simply cannot understand why Plaid Cymru is hell-bent on doing so.

20:41 - 20:42

Alice Barras-Curtis.

20:42 - 21:12

Alice Barras-Curtis

Mr Speaker, I was shocked to see the front page of the Western Mail last week. It said, "free milk scheme for pupils could be scrapped." Now I thought we'd gone back in time to the infamous milk snatcher Margaret Thatcher, but no, it was the modern day Plaid Cymru Welsh Government. So does the Secretary of State agree with me that scrapping free school milk would be a backward step and will he commit to work with colleagues in the Cabinet to ensure that from the perspective of the Union it means more opportunities for our children in Wales, not fewer?

21:12 - 21:13

Secretary of State.

21:13 - 21:47

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I have to say that when Plaid won in May, I didn't have Thatcherism 2.0 on my bingo card, Mr Speaker. But first they dragged their feet on ALN funding, then they refused to commit to Flying Start and now they may be targeting free school milk. My honourable friend is right. The Plaid Welsh Government should be supporting children and families just as this UK Labour government has done by scrapping the two-child cap, which will be hugely beneficial for nearly 70,000 Welsh children.

21:47 - 21:49

Speaker 40

Ann Davies.

21:49 - 22:23

Ann Celia Davies

Diolch, Mr Llefarydd. One would hope that any union would be a union of equals with equal partners listening to each other with mutual respect. And may I respectfully ask the Secretary of State to check his facts as he has with us on this side. Can the Secretary of State therefore confirm that the UK government has listened to Welsh Government on the Cynhaliol child payment pilot? Will he ensure that the HMRC will not count this payment as income so that families do not lose out on the other benefits support that they need?

22:23 - 22:49

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

I thank her for that question. We have a shared prior- priority with devolved governments to tackle child poverty so that no child living in poverty in the UK is left behind, particularly through the implementation phase. Child poverty is a significant challenge and reducing it over the next 10 years will require ongoing commitment and collaboration. We are open to exploring the Welsh Government's Cynnal pilot and we will continue to engage with them on the details.

22:49 - 22:51

Lindsay Hoyle

John Cooper.

22:51 - 22:54

John Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Question number six, please.

22:54 - 22:56

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

22:56 - 23:27

Speaker 10

I have regular discussions with the Welsh Government on defence and many other matters. We are fully funding the 15 billion pound defence investment plan, strengthening our armed forces, investing in cutting-edge technology and creating nearly 60,000 additional industry jobs across the UK. Continued uncertainty around the Welsh Government's approach to defence and delays to important projects such as DAG risk deterring that investment and jobs from Wales as well as risking our national security.

23:27 - 23:29

Lindsay Hoyle

John Cooper.

23:29 - 23:49

John Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Plaid, the SNP, Sinn Féin: a separatist cabal trying to break up Britain with little regard for UK defence.

We already in Scotland have a hostile environment for the critical defence industry. What can the Secretary of State do in Wales to prevent the same fate befalling key workers there?

23:49 - 23:50

Minister.

23:50 - 24:24

Speaker 10

Absolutely. This is such a critical industry and topic for our country to work together as a strong United Kingdom. The dither and delay from the Plaid-Welsh government is undermining our Welsh defence sector. It's having a very real impact on jobs, on investment, on opportunities, and our communities deserve better. So I, once again, urge the Plaid-Welsh government to work with us and stop this delay.

24:24 - 24:25

Thomas Symonds.

24:25 - 24:45

Nick Symonds

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The deployment of military personnel to deal with wildfires in Wales was very important this summer. Does the minister though agree with me that having had both the UK and Welsh government summits, and the additional money in the Welsh budget, we need to see a plan on wildfire prevention and resilience ahead of next summer?

24:45 - 24:46

Minister.

24:46 - 25:33

Speaker 10

I thank my honourable member and also pay tribute to his work in working with his community, the commoners, the firefighters in his constituency. And I also pay tribute to all our fire workers and our military for their role in fighting the wildfires this summer. Both the Welsh and UK government held summits last month and set out a route forward, including the UK government equipping RAF helicopters to fight fires in remote areas. This is absolutely essential. Whilst the Welsh Government is looking to bring in international expertise, this is yet another example of the importance and power of cross-border collaboration.

25:33 - 25:36

Speaker 48

Seven, Mr Speaker.

25:33 - 25:33

Luke Evans.

25:36 - 25:37

Minister.

25:37 - 26:04

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Cross-border travel is crucial to unlocking economic growth and employment opportunities. We're investing at least £445 million in Welsh rail, including the Burns stations in south Wales, to improve cross-border connectivity and to help tackle congestion on the M4, a vital economic link between Wales and England. It is, therefore, deeply disappointing that the Welsh government has chosen not to proceed with the M4 relief road.

26:04 - 26:06

Lindsay Hoyle

Dr Luke Evans.

26:06 - 26:34

Luke Morgan Evans

Mr Speaker, one of the biggest straitjackets to economic growth east to west is the most bashed bridge in Britain on A5 that's in my patch, that's the Watling Street bridge. Now, there are plans to lower the road underneath it, but it seems to have stalled. Could I ask him to speak with the transport secretary, to see what he can do with the transport secretary and me to get this unstuck so we can get the road lowered and get Britain moving again?

26:34 - 26:35

Secretary of State.

26:35 - 26:52

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

I thank him. The A5 is a hugely important cross-border artery, so it's, of course, vital to ensure that traffic can flow smoothly. If perhaps he would care to write to me, then I'd be happy to take this up, follow up with officials and with my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Transport.

26:52 - 26:53

The final question.

26:53 - 27:23

Speaker 64

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I was very surprised, I was very surprised to hear the Plaid Cymru transport minister last week calling rail funding of £445 million from the UK government an insult. Would the minister agree with me that squabbling about cross-border transport gets us nowhere and that Welsh government and UK government must work together to get spades in the ground for Magor and Undy walkway station?

27:23 - 27:24

Secretary of State.

27:24 - 28:00

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her for that question. It is, of course, a very substantial contribution that we are making. It's vital to that we invest in rail going forward and she's absolutely right that it's about now making sure that we get those spades in the ground.

We are very much ready to roll up our sleeves and work closely with Welsh government, with Transport for Wales, with Network Rail and others to ensure that we get these projects up and running as rapidly as possible. Point clear.

28:00 - 28:24

Lindsay Hoyle

Before we come to Prime Minister's Questions, may I extend a warm welcome to the president of the National Assembly of Côte d'Ivoire and his delegation who are with us in the gallery today. I now welcome the First Secretary of State's first outing, Louise Haigh.

28:24 - 29:06

Louise Margaret Haigh

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I have been asked to respond on behalf of my right honorable friend, the Prime Minister, who is accompanying His Majesty the King at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Antigua. This weekend, the whole country will fall silent to mark Remembrance Sunday. We pay tribute to the men and women who have served and all those who made the ultimate sacrifice in defense of our values and freedoms. Finally, Mr. Speaker, may I also wish everyone who'll be celebrating a joyful and peaceful Diwali.

This morning, I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in this House, I will have further such meetings later today.

29:06 - 29:07

Matthew Patrick.

29:07 - 29:35

Matthew Patrick

Giving people opportunity is the very mission of our party, but for young people on the Wirral, Brexit means they have been denied many of the opportunities their parents enjoyed, the right to work or study or live across Europe. Now, progress being made on SPS gives me real confidence and hope we can strike a good deal with the European Union in our national interest. So, can the government go further, strike a deal for young people and restore to them the opportunities that Brexit took away?

29:35 - 29:36

First Secretary.

29:36 - 30:14

Louise Margaret Haigh

The honorable gentleman, my honorable friend is absolutely right. The Brexit deal we inherited damaged our economy, weakened our ability to control immigration and took opportunities away from young people. Negotiations are ongoing, but we know that an SPS deal can add billions to our economy, cutting costs for exporters, helping supermarkets offer better prices and supporting British farmers. We're working with the EU to create a balanced youth experience scheme, creating opportunities for young people to live, work and study abroad. Meanwhile, the honorable gentleman has already said they'd rip it all up no matter the benefits.

30:14 - 30:20

Speaker 52

Perhaps the honorable gentleman would like to take this opportunity to set the record straight.

30:20 - 30:28

Lindsay Hoyle

We now come to the deputy leader of the opposition, Alex Burghart.

30:28 - 30:45

Alex Burghart

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and I associate myself with the comments the right honorable lady made about Remembrance Sunday. I very much look forward to marking that in my constituency of Brentwood and Ongar. This year, how much will the government spend on working-age welfare?

30:45 - 30:46

First Secretary.

30:46 - 31:30

Speaker 54

Well, let me start by congratulating the honorable gentleman on his elevation to deputy leader of the Conservative Party. He recently said that it was now his job to tell the leader of the opposition when she's getting things wrong, which must make him the busiest man in Westminster. I'm sure the whole House is right behind him as he takes on such an important job. Mr. Speaker, this government is committed to bringing the benefits bill down and committed to dealing with a mess left behind by the previous Tory government on whose watch welfare rose by 88 billion pounds in a decade.

31:30 - 31:33

Speaker 51

Alex Burghart.

31:33 - 32:14

Alex Burghart

I think it's very telling that the right honorable lady doesn't want to tell us the answer to that question.

The answer to the question is 183 billion pounds. That is the highest figure That's the highest figure ever. It's higher than anything during COVID. It is higher than defence, schools and policing combined.

It is nearly 10,000 pounds for every working household in this country. So will the government commit to bring that bill down in this parliament?

32:14 - 32:15

First Secretary.

32:15 - 32:58

Speaker 54

Mr Speaker, the government has been clear the benefit bill will come down and we're already taking steps to do so. We've rebalanced Universal Credit, we've increased face-to-face assessments, we've introduced a right to try the work for disabled people, we've introduced the youth guarantee for youth unemployed. On his watch, under previous Tory governments, the welfare bill soared by 88 billion pounds, nearly 3 million people written off. The legacy of the last Tory administration, 1 million young people not in employment, education or training. And this government is committed to tackling all of it.

32:58 - 32:59

Alex Burghart.

32:59 - 33:52

Alex Burghart

I think the honourable lady's missed the fact that the bel- bill is higher now than it's ever been before. The government's in a complete mess on this. On Thursday morning, the Chancellor went on the TV and went on the BBC and was asked: "Will there be cuts in welfare before the next election?" He said: "There will be." Cue panic in Downing Street.

The Prime Minister was sent out to clarify things. He said: "The welfare bill needs to come down, but this can't be done by cutting the welfare bill." Then at tea time, the Chancellor conceded defeat and said: "It's not correct to say that we're going to bring the welfare bill down." So will the First Secretary of State be clear, why isn't Labour going to bring the welfare down welfare bill down during this parliament?

33:52 - 34:48

Speaker 54

The honourable gentleman can continue reading out his questions. He should listen to the answers. He should listen to the answers. I have repeatedly said the benefit bill will come down, and then the steps this Labour government are already taking to do so. Mr Speaker, the Milburn report will report shortly, and the Timpson review.

But let me set out what further choices this Labour government are making, because last night, the party opposite walked through lobbies to vote against every change that this budget delivered. Yes, they cheer. They voted against a council tax cut for 20 million households. They voted against VAT off electricity bills. They voted against taking 70,000 small businesses out of business rates.

And they voted against a tax on banks to fund it all. Perhaps he'd like to explain why he did so now.

34:48 - 35:53

Alex Burghart

I think the right honourable lady seems to have missed out the bit where the Resolution Foundation said that this budget would be catastrophic for living standards. I think she left out the bit where the OBR said that it would risk 215,000 jobs through tax rises. So we know that Labour can't bring down welfare in the next three years. It's been briefed, however, that the Prime Minister is preparing a 10-year plan. I'm old enough, Mr Speaker, to remember Keir Starmer's 10-year plan, because it was six months ago.

This is the only political party in history to have two 10-year plans in 10 months. Given that the Labour Party Given that the Labour Party is experimenting with planning, can it commit to reduce this record welfare bill, the highest welfare bill ever, as part of its 10-year plan?

35:53 - 35:54

First Secretary.

35:54 - 36:30

Speaker 54

Mr Speaker, the honourable gentleman can ask me the same question four or five times, and I'm going to keep answering in the same way. We are taking steps already to bring the welfare bill down, and we'll take further. We've committed to legislate.

But every week, Mr Speaker, the opposition party comes and brings the same problems with the same messes that we inherited. On welfare, on defence, on immigration, on the economy, this Labour government are committed to tackling it all. And no matter what he brings, we are taking steps to deliver all of it.

36:30 - 37:28

Alex Burghart

Well, I'm sure the right honourable lady was paying attention at the budget, and paying attention to the figures that were published. Welfare spending is going to go up every single year of this parliament. And yet, I remember the Milburn Review, was a review so important that it was delayed until after the budget. The government isn't going to fix welfare, and we know why. We know why, because the welfare secretary told us.

The welfare secretary said that every meeting he had with Labour MPs was about who can we tax in order to pay benefits. And it's very likely that the right honourable lady was one of those MPs. We all remember that she was the person who led the rebellion against Keir Starmer's very modest welfare reforms. So, if the government can't reduce the welfare bill because of its backbenchers, because of its frontbenchers, can it at least promise that it will not put up taxes to cover these ever increasing costs?

37:28 - 37:29

First Secretary.

37:29 - 38:27

Speaker 54

Mr Speaker, we have been repeatedly clear that we cannot afford to pay for failure and must invest in success. And that is how we will bring the welfare bill down. We will make support more conditional on taking up opportunities, ensuring young people get help they need earlier, tackling the long-term drivers of welfare spending, including high housing costs. And we will do all this in a Labour way.

The honourable gentleman told a gathering of Conservative Party members that they should keep apologising for the many things that they got wrong in government. But I'm not sure his colleagues got the memo. The Leader of the Opposition claimed she wasn't in the cabinet when they made mistakes on migration, but she was there at the peak of the Boris wave. The shadow Home Secretary claimed he wasn't responsible for immigration policy when he was a Home Office minister, and the shadow Chancellor still doesn't want blame for the mini-budget written when she he was in the Treasury.

38:27 - 38:34

Speaker 55

Perhaps he'd like to take this opportunity now to apologise on behalf of himself and his party.

38:34 - 39:22

Alex Burghart

We all know what the Labour way is. The Labour way is more tax, more welfare, and more borrowing! So, there's no commitment to reduce welfare and there's no promise not to put up tax.

They know what needs to be done, but they don't have the bottle to do it. They're too scared to cut spending and they're too weak to do the right thing. They're too busy putting off till tomorrow what needs to be done today, and everyone else is paying the price, the millions of people on welfare and the millions of people picking up the bill.

If Labour doesn't want to do the right thing, why doesn't it just get out of the way?

39:22 - 39:37

Lindsay Hoyle

First Secretary. Order. Mi- Mr Opperman.

We had little eye contact earlier, please. I don't think it looks good trying to shout a woman down.

39:37 - 40:43

Speaker 54

Mr Speaker, I know the honourable gentleman regards himself as the Tories' resident historian. In fact, he once published a paper titled "Profile of a Doomed Elite". I'm sure the House will be as surprised as I was to learn it wasn't a study of the prospects of the current Shadow Cabinet. So, as a student of history, he'll be well aware that few governments have delivered the scale and speed of change that this administration has in our first 100 days: cutting business rates for 70,000 businesses, cutting tax for entrepreneurs, cutting VAT from electricity bills, helping 20 million households with energy bills, scrapping standing charges, capping bus fares, investing in our high streets, extending parental pay, tackling rough sleeping. Mr Speaker, the honourable gentleman doesn't seem impressed.

Perhaps that's because the only government that has had more of an impact in a shorter space of time was the one he served under, Liz Truss.

40:43 - 40:44

Lorraine Beavers.

40:44 - 41:35

Lorraine Beavers

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I hope the whole House will join me in congratulating Fleetwood Town for thrashing Arsenal last week. It was great news for the town and bad news for the Prime Minister as Everton has been drawn to the but sorry, drawn to fight the mighty Cod Army in the quarter finals. In a more serious matter, some of my constituents are living with the threat of contaminated land, fearing for their health and watching their homes lose value. Will the First Secretary of State work with DEFRA and the Environment Agency to ensure that soil testing is completed as soon as possible so that my residents get the answers they so badly need?

41:35 - 41:36

First Secretary.

41:36 - 42:18

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, I'm very happy to congratulate Fleetwood Town with my honourable friend. As a Barnsley fan, we live for these David versus Goliath moments, Mr Speaker. We published the UK's first ever plan to better protect people and our environment from forever chemicals earlier this year. And just this week, the UK Health and Security Agency launched its first study into the levels of forever chemicals in the population. As we continue to build the evidence, we will absolutely consider the case for any appropriate measures, including national standards to manage the risks and protect communities.

The Environment Agency is supporting a thorough investigation into the Thornton Cleveleys site, and I'll make sure the Environment Minister keeps her updated.

42:18 - 42:22

Speaker 58

Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrats Daisy Cooper.

42:22 - 43:19

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I associate myself with the remarks of the First Secretary of State about Remembrance Sunday, where we will join in honouring our service personnel and their sacrifices? And may I join her in wishing a happy Diwali to all those who celebrate? Mr Speaker, American voters have rejected Trump's warmongering and the economic chaos that it has caused, unlike of course the Conservatives and Reform who cheered on Trump's illegal war. But Trump has now renewed his threats of strikes on Iran, strikes that would be devastating for security in the region and devastating for the cost of living here in the UK.

So, will the government stand together with our reliable allies and send a clear message to Trump and Netanyahu there must be no more strikes?

43:19 - 43:20

First Secretary.

43:20 - 43:43

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well the US are one of our most important allies but our, and our priority absolutely is de-escalation. The honourable lady is absolutely right that the war in the Middle East has been catastrophic for the cost of living crisis here at home, and parties opposite, including the Tories and Reform, should consider very carefully their judgment in calling for us to jump so readily into it.

43:43 - 43:46

Speaker 57

Zarah Sultana.

43:46 - 44:40

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm grateful for the unequivocal response on that since she has our backing in calling for de-escalation. Mr Speaker, as well as the economic turmoil, as well as the economic turmoil, the American people have also sent a message that they are sick of Trump's scandals,

from his blatant corruption, to his close friendship with Epstein, and most recently, emerging from the Epstein files, an allegation of rape. Will the First Secretary of State join me in saying that, in this House, we will not tolerate powerful men who abuse their position against women in this Parliament or any other, and will the government commit to assisting any and all inquiries that the new Democratic Congress may launch?

44:40 - 44:41

First Secretary.

44:41 - 44:56

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well the honourable lady raises an incredibly important point about the Epstein files and everything that they revealed. She's absolutely right to highlight the importance always of challenging power and standing on behalf of vulnerable victims.

44:56 - 44:58

Lindsay Hoyle

Oliver Ryan.

44:58 - 45:36

Speaker 88

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Manchester, Leeds, York, Bradford, you can get everywhere direct from Burnley Manchester Road station. You can get to London and you can even get to beautiful, sunny Chorley if you go via Preston. The station is our gateway to the world and it's the world's gateway to us, but in 2026 the station still isn't accessible despite promises from the last Tory government and that said they would do something about the ramp, as it's become known. I know she's visited the station herself with me so will the First Secretary back my long-fought campaign with Burnley Council for a lift bridge connecting the platforms so everyone can use the station accessibly and come to Burnley?

45:36 - 45:36

First Secretary.

45:36 - 45:58

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well I vividly remember visiting this station with my honourable friend. He's been a strong campaigner on this and I know just how important it is for his constituents. We have awarded over 640 million pounds to Lancashire Combined County Authority for their local priorities, which could help deliver schemes like this. I know the rail minister will be very happy to meet with him to discuss the campaign.

45:58 - 46:02

Speaker 66

Chorley's has already started. Gavin Robinson.

46:02 - 47:08

Gavin Robinson

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Political stability in Northern Ireland should never and certainly cannot now be taken for granted. A fundamental principle in our democracy is that ministers who take up office uphold the rule of law, support the police, the courts and our rule of law. And yet the lawless First Minister of Northern Ireland and three of her ministers have shredded their pledge and with it, the responsibility that comes with office. Does the First Secretary of State and our Labour government believe in the rule of law and believe that where one errs, it should not be that all are punished?

That lawmakers cannot be lawbreakers, and therefore there needs to be an amendment to the Northern Ireland Act to ensure that in circumstances such as this, the punishment applies to those who stepped outside all respected norms and their pledge of office?

47:08 - 47:09

First Secretary.

47:09 - 47:50

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, Mr Speaker, the right honourable gentleman will understand that I'm not going to comment on a live police investigation. But the major problem facing Northern Ireland right now is, of course, he will agree, the absence of a budget.

My right honourable friend, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, is looking at how we can ensure there is more political and financial accountability, and he will continue engaging with all Northern Ireland parties about how we move forward. Ultimately, we want calm heads to prevail, power sharing to succeed, and to enhance the resilience of the political institutions in Northern Ireland. We are willing to work with all parties on that, and I know he will play his full part in getting a budget agreed.

47:50 - 47:51

Ned Thomas.

47:51 - 48:38

Frederick Thomas

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Satellite capabilities and AI are essential to our security and economy, yet Britain still relies on allies and a handful of extremely expensive sovereign satellites. But with advancing technologies and growing threats, these are increasingly vulnerable to disruption, no matter who we contract to deliver them. There is another way, Mr. Speaker, a British-owned constellation with hundreds of cheap, commercially built satellites in low-Earth orbit using AI to analyse data in space. This would support our space sector, add resilience to our national security and drive growth.

Combining artificial intelligence with real-time satellite data, Britain could develop its own planetary intelligence. Will the First Secretary meet with me to discuss this capability?

48:38 - 49:06

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, the honourable and my honourable friend is absolutely right. We know this is an industry where the UK can be a world leader, which is why our space strategy set out over 7.8 billion pounds of investment to strengthen our national security and resilience. I can assure him, our decisions will always prioritise economic growth and jobs here in the UK and enhancing our sovereign capabilities, and I'm sure my honourable friend, the space minister, will be very happy to meet him to discuss.

49:06 - 49:07

Chris Coghlan.

49:07 - 49:54

Chris Coghlan

Mr. Speaker, after eight years of refusals by her local authority to support her autism, 13-year-old Evie White took her own life. Six months later, Evie's best friend took her own life, aged 13. Evie is one of 200 cases related to avoidable child suicide and 1,200 cases, 1,200 child testimonies of misconduct on SEND by 134 local authorities. The police are now involved. As local authority misconduct has led to children's deaths, does the government still plan to weaken children's legal protections, especially from tribunal, especially at tribunal in the SEND reforms?

49:54 - 49:56

Lindsay Hoyle

First Secretary.

49:56 - 50:40

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, can I just say, Mr. Speaker, that I'm sure the whole House's thoughts are with the family of Evie and her friend and all who loved her. This is a tragic case and one that absolutely highlights the importance of reforming SEND, something which I know the whole House is behind as we look to tackle the failures in this system that have been an issue for many years. My right honourable friend, the Education Secretary, is leading the work to strengthen that system so families don't have to fight for support. And EHCPs will remain part of the system, parents will continue to be involved in decisions about their children's support and the tribunal will remain a key legal backstop. My right honourable friend is more than happy to meet with the honourable gentleman to discuss this issue and the very sad case he raises.

50:40 - 50:42

Lindsay Hoyle

Dr. Peter Prinsley.

50:42 - 51:24

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I wonder if my right honourable friend has ever had the opportunity to visit the beautiful town of Bury St Edmunds, a jewel in the crown of Suffolk. Now, the Haughley Junction is a piece of crucial railway infrastructure that would, if completed, would enable us to run direct trains from Bury St Edmunds to London, which would of course make it much simpler for my right honourable friend to come and visit us. So, I ask my right honourable friend, what advice she gives me in order that we might get this project back on track?

51:24 - 51:25

First Secretary.

51:26 - 51:58

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, I'm very grateful for that conditional invitation, Mr Speaker. We absolutely recognise the potential benefits that upgrades to Haughley Junction can deliver for passengers and freight alike and that these must be delivered alongside rail upgrades in the Ely area. As my honourable friend knows, both projects were cancelled by the previous government in 2021, but I'm pleased to confirm that both are now being considered for future funding. And I know the Transport Secretary will be happy to meet him to hear his case.

51:58 - 52:00

Lindsay Hoyle

Bradley Thomas.

52:00 - 52:18

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My constituent, Nick, started his business in his spare bedroom. He has grown it into a high-tech manufacturing business that employs 50 people. Surely the Secretary of State does not agree with her colleague who said that employers like Nick are not working people, or does she?

52:18 - 52:19

Chief Secretary.

52:19 - 52:43

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, the honourable gentleman raises an excellent example of the kind of people this Government are behind and trying to help. Working people are the millions of people who put in every day and don't get back what they deserve, people who don't have savings they can dip into to pay their way out of problems, and people who rely on good public services. Those are the people that this Labour Government are delivering through and at the budgets of last week.

52:43 - 52:44

Connor Naismith.

52:44 - 53:28

Connor James Naismith

Hear. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I welcome the Government's ongoing commitment to tackling violence against women and girls and the significant steps the Government has already taken in this regard. But I have become aware of several cases in which constituents seeking to leave abusive relationships through divorce proceedings and custody disputes are unable to access legal aid because of equity in the family home that they share with their abuser. Now, that equity exists on paper, but cannot be accessed in practice.

Will the First Secretary of State work with Cabinet colleagues to look at whether the legal aid system is adequately supporting domestic abuse survivors, so that no victim is denied access to justice because of assets they cannot realistically access?

53:28 - 54:09

Louise Margaret Haigh

Can I congratulate my honourable friend on campaigning on this important area and highlighting some of our most vulnerable constituents? I absolutely agree that victims and survivors of domestic abuse deserve proper, legal and timely support. Recognising that individuals might not be able to access certain assets or funds, we've already updated legislation to improve the availability of legal aid for survivors of domestic abuse, which includes making sure £100,000 of the value of the home will not be considered in the legal aid means test. However, we will always work to ensure victims and survivors have the support they need, and ministers will be happy to hear any further proposals.

53:28 - 53:28

Chief Secretary.

54:09 - 54:10

David Chadwick.

54:10 - 54:39

David Chadwick

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Last Friday, I met a group of farmers from my constituency who told me about their experiences at the hands of a company called Green GEN Cymru. They say that Green GEN Cymru has been sending its workers onto their farms at 4:00 a.m. in the morning wearing dirty wellies and showing no regard for biosecurity. Several members of this House have raised concerns about Green GEN Cymru. Will the Government urgently look at revoking their Ofgem license?

54:39 - 54:39

Chief Secretary.

54:39 - 54:45

Louise Margaret Haigh

I'd be very happy to take that case away and raise it with my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State for Defra.

54:45 - 54:46

Andrew Lewin.

54:46 - 55:12

Alan Andrew Lewin

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Hatfield has a proud history, but our town centre is not the destination it could or should be. We need to unlock both public and private investment in a regeneration programme. Labour is the party of new towns. So, will my right honourable friend build on that legacy and support me and my borough council on an ambitious regeneration programme so we can play our part in delivering good growth in every postcode?

55:12 - 55:13

Chief Secretary.

55:13 - 55:39

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, I thank my honourable friend. As the budget, at the budget, we made clear our commitment to creating good growth in every postcode, driving regeneration in every part of Britain.

And that commitment was backed by £80 million of new funding for the local renewal fund to support projects that create jobs, invest in local economic regeneration, and boost growth. His proposal is a very good fit for that funding, and I'll ensure he meets with the relevant minister to discuss.

55:39 - 55:40

Robbie Moore.

55:40 - 56:11

Bobby Dean

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last night, President Trump took one hell of a beating. And now that the shine is coming off him in America, I'm wondering whether this government will start to take a tougher stance in relation to him, too. Next week, we have the Financial Markets Bill returning to the Commons, and they have the opportunity to insert a clause that will make the US tech giants pay their fair share of compensation to victims of online scams. This is something that the previous Prime Minister had committed to, but this government has yet to deliver on.

Will she make it happen?

56:11 - 56:39

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for raising this important issue. Ofcom has recently introduced a draft advertising code under the Online Safety Act, and when implemented, this will require major tech platforms to take robust action on online scams. Non-compliance could lead to fines of up to 10% of global revenue. We believe it's on big tech platforms to tackle these issues, and where they are failing, we will not shy away from taking firm action.

56:39 - 56:41

Speaker 81

Stephen Doughty.

56:41 - 57:19

Speaker 109

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The poison of racism and religious prejudice is spreading throughout our family of nations. Violent attacks on people because of the colour of their skin, their type of dress, people abused when going to pray. We need robust action on this: education in schools and workplaces, strong policing, and strong enforcement against online hate. Will my right honourable friend the First Secretary of State outline the steps that our government is taking to combat this and confirm that the government will work with the Scottish Government on this?

57:19 - 57:20

First Secretary.

57:20 - 58:01

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, my honourable friend is absolutely right to raise this issue. There is no place for hatred and violence of any kind in our society, whether on our streets or online. Our government action includes investing in stronger protective security for faith communities, using the recommendations of the Bell review to tackle antisemitism in schools and universities, and delivering our social cohesion plan. And for the first time, this government chaired a National Security Council on tackling antisemitism to demonstrate our commitment to rooting out that evil. We will always be happy to work with governments across the UK, including in Scotland, to share best practice, because we all have a role to play in strengthening our society.

58:01 - 58:02

Munira Wilson.

58:02 - 58:38

Munira Wilson

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In September, the First Secretary rightly said that local leaders will have the power and resources they need to invest in the things that matter most to their communities. I agree with her. Yet this Labour government is about to slash over £100 million of funding from Richmond Council over the next four years, that's almost 60% of the council's budget. My vulnerable constituents will suffer the most as a result of those devastating cuts.

Will she agree to meet with me, the leader of the council, and my honourable friend for Richmond Park, so that we can find a sustainable way forward?

58:38 - 58:40

Speaker 76

First Secretary.

58:40 - 59:02

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, Mr. Speaker, cuts over the previous decade severely impacted the most deprived communities, and we inherited an outdated, unfair funding system, which no longer reflected where pressures are greatest. The final settlement available for Richmond Council makes available over £223 million, but I will make sure the relevant minister meets with her to discuss how we take this forward.

59:02 - 59:04

Speaker 80

Joe Powell.

59:04 - 59:40

Edward Joseph Powell

Mr. Speaker, St Mary's Hospital in Paddington has a proud near 200-year history from the discovery of penicillin to becoming one of the country's first major trauma centres. But the estate is now old and crumbling and has the highest maintenance backlog across the entire NHS.

The Conservatives put St Mary's at the back of the queue, delaying funding for construction. So, can the First Secretary reassure my community that innovative financing models will be considered, including the potential of realising new fiscal devolution powers, to get the construction of a new St Mary's underway as soon as possible?

59:40 - 01:00:16

Louise Margaret Haigh

First Secretary. Can I begin, Mr Speaker, by wishing my honourable friend a very happy birthday? I'm sure there's nowhere he'd rather be celebrating. My honourable friend is right to highlight that under the Conservatives, his constituents were let down by unfunded spending commitments that were never deliverable. We've reset the programme, are investing in our NHS, delivering more appointments and lowering wait times, with his local elective waiting list down by almost 27,000.

We are working closely with trusts to accelerate progress wherever possible, and a health minister would be very happy to meet with him to discuss his innovative financing proposals.

01:00:16 - 01:01:10

Helen Maguire

Helen Maguire. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The hospital estate at Epsom and St Helier is failing. The recent CQC report said that this is impacting safety, privacy and dignity of care. My constituents deserve a hospital that they can rely on, now.

At St Helier, the reablement unit is lit- literally had a building broke in two and had to close 13 beds. They found legionellas and pseudomonas in the pipes in the maternity block. And at the St Mary's hospital on the St Helier site, the lifts broke, meaning that staff had to carry children up and down the stairs post-operation. Surely in 2026 staff and patients deserve better. So will the First Secretary of State commit to urgent action, commit to delivering the specialist emergency care hospital to ease pressure on Epsom and hospital, because the time for dither and delay is over?

01:01:10 - 01:01:46

Louise Margaret Haigh

First Secretary. Well, she's absolutely right to raise these critical issues, and I absolutely understand the concerns over these services at St Helier. I know the secondary care minister discussed these issues with MPs earlier this week, and we have allocated £5 million to fund critical repairs at the hospital. We are keen that as many women's health services as possible remain there whilst the essential work is carried out. The trust is committed to take the decision on plans for the maternity and women's unit in December, and I know the minister will be happy to meet with her and discuss next steps and how we address these really important issues.

01:01:46 - 01:02:42

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Today I met with Braylin Hollinsbee, who, along with her mum, today. At 16, she was given just three months to live because of a brain tumour. Braylin travelled to the UK for cutting edge treatment, and she is now 19, with scans showing no evidence of disease. She is here in the gallery with her family today, thanks to our NHS.

The drug DCVax is manufactured here in the UK. It is the first treatment in decades that has been shown to extend survival in recurrent glioblastoma patients, yet it is only available to a tiny number of patients on a compassionate use basis. Will the First Secretary join me in welcoming Braylin, congratulate the NHS for playing a role in helping develop this treatment, and agree that we should help get this into widespread use to save more lives?

01:02:42 - 01:03:00

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, can I congratulate my honourable friend on raising this incredibly important point, and of course, welcome Braylin and her family today. First Secretary. I will ensure the Health Secretary looks at this issue urgently. I know the Prime Minister has taken a personal interest in this, and will want to ensure that action is taken as soon as possible.

01:03:00 - 01:03:10

Luke Morgan Evans

Dr Luke Evans. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Could she confirm it's still Labour government policy that employers are not working people?

01:03:10 - 01:03:23

Speaker 54

First Secretary. I answered this question earlier in the session. He should probably take rather than take the whip's question. Perhaps he could confirm why the Conservatives voted against every measure in the budget that would help his constituents.

01:03:23 - 01:03:54

Irene Campbell

Irene Campbell. Recently the coastal towns of Largs and Saltcoats were badly flooded by Storm Babet, with much damage caused to local businesses as well as damage to constituents' houses and gardens. Does the First Secretary agree with me that to avoid this happening again, there has to be joined-up working with Scottish Government, all relevant authorities and agencies, to ensure our vulnerable coastal towns and communities have coastal defence preparedness plans in place?

01:03:54 - 01:03:55

Speaker 83

First Secretary.

01:03:55 - 01:04:11

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, I know this is an issue my honourable friend has been raising. I met with her yesterday to discuss this very issue. Flooding is devolved to the Scottish government, but we have set up a flood resilience taskforce to make sure that we can work across borders and share best practice and address exactly the issues she raises.

01:04:11 - 01:04:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Liz Jarvis, final question.

01:04:13 - 01:04:48

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Mr Speaker. On Saturday night, five teenagers in my constituency were stabbed while at a party. I'd like to offer my thanks to the emergency services for their prompt response, and also to extend my best wishes to the families, the victims and their friends. But what reassurance can the Minister give my constituents that the government is taking the issue of violent crime seriously and treating it as a public health emergency?

01:04:48 - 01:05:24

Louise Margaret Haigh

Well, the honourable lady is absolutely right to raise this issue and in the way she has. I know the whole House will send their thoughts and best wishes with the victims and their families and all who are will be incredibly worried about them and about the community at this time. We will urge anybody with information to bring that forward to the police so that any perpetrators can be brought to justice. And we remain committed to halving knife crime over the next decade. But I will ensure a Minister meets with her to discuss the particular issues she raises about this crime and how we take these issues going forward.

01:05:24 - 01:05:29

Lindsay Hoyle

Complete Prime Minister's Questions. Points of Order, Gregory Stafford.

01:05:29 - 01:06:04

Gregory James Stafford

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I wish to ask your advice on the potential of the First Secretary of State inadvertently misleading the House. On two occasions in on two occasions during question time, she said that the Conservatives voted against every change of the budget. That isn't true, Mr Speaker. We voted against six specific measures.

She also said quite specifically she also said quite specifically that the Conservatives voted against a council tax cut for 20 million pounds 20 million households. We didn't, we voted against increasing council tax by opposing resolution 86.

01:06:04 - 01:06:20

Lindsay Hoyle

Order. Please, when I stand up, just give me the pleasure of sitting down. Look, we can't continue the debate. I am not responsible for the answers. What you have done is put it and corrected the record by putting down what you believe is the facts.

01:06:20 - 01:07:12

Speaker 111

I don't want to continue a debate at this time. Right, let the front benches change. We now come to presentations of bills, Secretary Miatta Fambulleh.

01:07:12 - 01:07:17

Speaker 97

Energy Independence Bill.

01:07:17 - 01:07:19

Lindsay Hoyle

Second reading what day?

01:07:19 - 01:07:21

Speaker 84

Tuesday 10th November.

01:07:21 - 01:07:30

Lindsay Hoyle

Tuesday the 10th of November. We now come to presentation of bill, Secretary Angela Rayner.

01:07:30 - 01:07:32

Speaker 96

Visitor Levy (England) Bill.

01:07:32 - 01:07:34

Lindsay Hoyle

Second reading what day?

01:07:34 - 01:07:35

Tuesday, 10th of November.

01:07:35 - 01:07:47

Lindsay Hoyle

Tuesday, the 10th of November. Right, we now come to the ten-minute rule bill, Fashion Supply Chain, Liz Twist.

01:07:48 - 01:17:35

Liz Twist

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to provide for a code of practice to be followed by retailers of fashion, clothing, footwear and accessories in their relationships with their suppliers, to set up an adjudicator with the role of enforcing that code of practice and encouraging compliance with it, and for connected purposes. The UK fashion and textile sector contributes 62 billion pounds to our economy and supports 1.3 million jobs, from historic textile mills in Yorkshire and Lancashire, to garment manufacturing in Leicester, London and the West Midlands. Domestic production provides skilled regional employment and industrial capability. The majority of fashion retailers want to trade ethically, and certainly the public encourage them to do that, supporting fair wages and good conditions.

However, the global garment market is heavily buyer-driven. Where a majority of a minority of companies engage in abusive practices, responsible businesses risk being undercut and small suppliers lack bargaining leverage. Without a level playing field, Mr Speaker, bad practice distorts fair competition and stops small businesses operating successfully. Now, Mr Speaker, we saw how completely the garment market can fail during the COVID-19 pandemic. When retail stores closed in 2020, major brands selling in the UK canceled billions of pounds in confirmed orders overnight, withheld payments for garments already stitched, and demanded steep discounts on shipped goods.

That crisis laid bare the fundamental flaw in global garment supply chains. When unexpected costs hit, buyers dump commercial risks onto factory owners and workers with zero accountability. These practices have been documented for decades by organizations, including the International Labour Organization, Human Rights Watch, the Business & Human Rights Resource Centre, and the Vietnam Labour Institute, and recent research from the universities of Aberdeen, Nottingham, and Leicester, the Tata Institute, and Transform Trade shows that unfair buying habits remain routine commercial tactics across the UK, Bangladesh, and India. These unfair practices, including cancelled orders, forced price cuts, refusal to pay for goods in production, and delayed invoices cause job losses, poverty wages, and unsafe working conditions for the workforce, the majority of whom are women. In historic hubs like Leicester, heavy buyer pressure has driven the number of clothing businesses down from 1,500 in 2017 to roughly 95 today.

And behind those figures are real factory owners facing impossible terms. One UK manufacturer produced 1,000 garment samples over a single season costing hundreds of pounds each, only for the buyer to order just 140 styles. Another suffered a sudden cancellation of 80,000 finished garments and 100,000 m of fabric already paid for.

Small UK factories pay up to £4,000 a year for mandatory compliance audits, only for 42% to receive zero orders after passing. Another Overseas suppliers face the exact same tactics. In India, when a factory had an order almost complete, an auditor flagged slightly insufficient lighting in one corner of the workshop, which the buying agent seized on to force down the contract price. Now, elsewhere in the UK retailers have held shipments at destination ports to force steep, retroactive discounts, ignoring daily emails from factory managers asking how to pay their staff. Buyers can drop orders at short notice or force price cuts, making low-paid workers absorb the blow through reduced hours, unpaid overtime, or layoffs.

Women make up 61% of the core garment workforce in the UK and 60% in Bangladesh. Crucially, international suppliers fall outside the jurisdiction of UK labour enforcement bodies, and relationships are governed by unilateral buyer manuals filled with automatic fines. Out of 1,000 factories surveyed in Bangladesh, not one took legal action against a buyer, with 80% fearing blacklisting. Few factory owners, whether in Leicester, India, or Bangladesh, can afford to sue multi-million-pound brands. Mr Speaker, this Labour Government has taken positive steps to raise standards across our economy.

The Government's review into responsible business conduct demonstrates a clear commitment to supply chain integrity. The creation of the fair work agency will strengthen domestic labour enforcement, and the 60-day payment cap in the Commercial Payments Bill is a major step forward for business cash flow. We should celebrate these achievements. But to complete the picture and protect ethical businesses, we must go further where standards fall lower. Enforcing labour laws against factory owners cannot address financial pressures when a retailer forces a supplier to sell below production cost.

Transparency reporting does not stop commercial the commercial abuses like forced discounts or sudden cancellations. Capping payment terms at 60 days helps UK payment schedules, but does not reach international supply chains or protect against cancelled contracts. Advising small suppliers to pursue litigation fails to recognise commercial reality, as no small business can afford to sue the buyer it depends on for survival. We need to regulate buyer behaviour directly through a statutory garment trading adjudicator across the UK market, bringing domestic and foreign retailers selling in the UK into scope. This creates fair competition, enabling small business to compete successfully.

We already have a proven model, Mr Speaker, in the groceries code adjudicator, where code breaches fell from 79% in 2014 to 33% in 2024, while food retailers remain profitable and paid food suppliers up to three months faster than clothing retailers pay garment suppliers. Furthermore, the European Union is proposing similar unfair trading practice regulations for the textile sector.

Ahead of establishing the adjudicator, a mandatory supply chain code of practice is needed to define clear rules of fair dealing. First, the garment trading adjudicator would enforce a mandatory supply chain code of practice including a legally binding principle of fair dealing, giving suppliers certainty over orders, fair payment timelines and protection from sudden contract changes. Second, it would protect suppliers by allowing factory owners, trade unions and third parties to submit evidence through confidential and anonymous reporting channels, supported by a multilingual system, so global suppliers can report in their own languages. Third, it would empower the adjudicator to initiate proactive market investigations based on intelligence without requiring an individual formal public complaint that could expose a single supplier to commercial retaliation.

Fourth, it would have the power to impose financial penalties on abusive retailers who breach the code and require retailers to reimburse suppliers for what they are owed. And finally, the regulator would be funded entirely through a statutory levy on large fashion retailers, placing zero cost on the British taxpayer. This proposal has in the past been raised by the Enviro- Environmental Audit Committee, and has cross-party parliamentary support. By supporting this bill, we can build on this government's impressive work, from the creation of the Fair Work Agency to the new office for responsible business conduct, and complete the regulatory picture. Establishing a garment trading adjudicator will create a level playing field where responsible businesses are protected from unfair competition, smaller suppliers can invest with confidence, and British retail stands tall as a global benchmark for ethical trade.

I urge the House to support this bill, and grant leave for it to be brought in.

01:17:35 - 01:17:52

Lindsay Hoyle

that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.

The ayes have it. Who will prepare to bring in the bill?

01:17:52 - 01:18:31

Liz Twist

Cat Smith, Stella Creasy, David Mundell, Martin Rhodes, Rachael Maskell, Jeff Smith, Maya Ellis, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, Mary Glindon, Vera Hobhouse, Navendu Mishra, and myself.

01:18:31 - 01:18:52

Speaker 125

Nice twist.

01:18:52 - 01:18:55

Speaker 117

Fashion Supply Chain (Code and Adjudicator) Bill.

01:18:55 - 01:18:57

Lindsay Hoyle

Second reading what day?

01:18:57 - 01:19:00

Speaker 115

Uh the 5th of March 2027.

01:19:00 - 01:19:12

Speaker 119

The 5th of March 2027. Well done. Program motion, minister to move.

01:19:12 - 01:19:14

Speaker 113

I beg to move.

01:19:14 - 01:19:32

Lindsay Hoyle

The question is the Sporting Events Bill program motion number two as on the order paper. The question is the Sporting bill, as many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no.

I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

01:19:32 - 01:19:39

Speaker 120

Sporting Events Bill, Lords, as amended in the Public Bill Committee, to be considered.

01:19:39 - 01:19:54

Lindsay Hoyle

We will begin with new clause 1, with which it will be convenient to consider other new clauses, new schedules and amendments as listed on the selection paper. I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson to move clause 1, Anna Sabine.

01:19:54 - 01:22:00

Anna Sabine

Thank you, Mr Speaker. As we've said before, the Liberal Democrats welcome this bill. The Euros, the World Cup, the Olympics, we recognise these events have huge positive implications, like boosting our economy and bringing people together. Making these events easier for the UK to deliver is therefore the right thing to do. During the second reading of this bill, I emphasised my disappointment that the bill didn't include cultural or music events, industries that also bring in billions into the UK's economy and events that encounter many similar problems that sporting events do too.

I've met with and understand the position of ministers on this point, which is that cultural events aren't in the scope of the bill, but I didn't want to let the bill close without emphasising again that there is a missed opportunity here for supporting cultural and music events. There are other areas where this bill could be stronger. First, free-to-air sports. This year, for the first time since the Champions League began in 1992, supporters couldn't watch the final without paying. This is the latest in a long line of events that have gone behind a paywall.

Meanwhile, the BBC's coverage of the Lionesses has inspired a generation of girls to pick up a football, and Channel 4's Paralympics coverage has shown disabled children what is possible. Free-to-air coverage works, and amendment 1 and 2 would ensure that any event covered by this bill or backed by public money should be available to all. As well as this, new clause 2 proposes a bidding framework to bring football home, making sure the government can host the 2042 World Cup. The Liberal Democrats have also long argued that gambling advertising has no place in sport. New clause 4 would ban gambling advertising, marketing, and sponsorship for the events that are covered by this legislation.

Madam Deputy Speak, Mr Speaker, all of these amendments matter to sport and this is why I've continued to push them through the course of this bill. But the amendment I want to call a vote today about is ticket touting. The Labour Party Manifesto says, "Access to music, drama, and sport has become difficult and expensive because of ticket touting. Labour will put fans back at the heart of events by introducing new consumer protections on ticket resales." This was a pledge to act in black and white.

Elsewhere, the government has pledged to bring forward legislation that will ban ticket resales at a face value. The commitment is clear, but here is a bill with the framework to implement all of these promises, and the government has chosen not to act this time. I will give way.

01:22:00 - 01:22:37

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker, I'm really grateful to the honourable lady for giving way. I'm sure she agrees with me that it was really good when this bill was extended in its scope so that it did include more major events, not just one big ticket item. But what it does do now is create a kind of two-tier ticketing system, because these rules restrict the sale of tickets only to these few sporting events, but there are music events and other cultural events which are waiting for a solution that has been promised, but hasn't come. Does she agree with me that this therefore puts into very stark perspective the urgent need for the ticket touting bill to come forward as quickly as possible?

01:22:37 - 01:23:33

Anna Sabine

Very unwise to agree with the honourable member on any issue around this kind of area, but yes, I totally agree with her that this issue of ticket sales really needs clarification. Every year, fans lose £145 million from tickets being sold at eye-watering resale prices. Every delay the government makes to reform ticket sales, more and more money is lost, and more importantly, another eager fan misses out on watching their team play. The government keeps promising further legislation down the line, but the Liberal Democrats are calling for action to be taken now, and this is why we've tabled new clause 1. This clause does what the government has promised and what this bill fails to do: it stops tickets being resold at above face value.

This new clause would mean that no more fans are priced out by an algorithm, no more touts profit at the expense of the people who love sport, but also live music and theatre. The government says it backs reform, today they can prove it, and I hope this House will vote to support new clause 1.

01:23:33 - 01:23:37

Lindsay Hoyle

The question is that new clause 1 be read a second time.

01:23:37 - 01:23:43

Speaker 130

Sorry, prohibition of ticket touting and regulation of resale platforms.

01:23:43 - 01:24:00

Speaker 124

Mr Speaker, I think we're seeing a first in this House, a debate in which the member for Harlow has been called first. So, I

I welcome it. It's because Mr Speaker you're in a good mood because it's Lancashire Day today, isn't it? That's

01:24:00 - 01:24:01

No. Next week.

01:24:01 - 01:27:32

Christopher John Vince

Oh, well I look forward to celebrate that with you next week as a sort of adopted Yorkshireman. This bill and I want to get on the right page. First of all, I want to say it's a pleasure to speak in this debate. As you know, Mr Speaker, I am a keen football supporter and although the fortunes of Harlow Town and Leeds United have been somewhat inconsistent in recent years, I know the member opposite is looking forward to a positive Farke-led revolution. I still feel an intense an immense sense of pride when the country hosts sporting events.

Not only the 2012 Olympics, but believe it or not Mr Speaker, I'm even old enough to remember Euro 96 when football came home only perhaps not in all the ways we may have hoped it would do. And I also want to pay tribute to my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State, the member for Wigan for her commitment and dedication to sport in this country. Whether it's grassroots football teams like the league winning Roydon FC to our Ballon d'Or-winning England captain, Harry Kane. I know that sport and indeed the fantastic rugby league players that I know Mr Speaker you cheer on a regular basis. We sadly don't have any rugby league in Harlow, but maybe between us we can change that.

I feel like I've started a an argument between the Speaker and the Secretary of State, which the Secretary of State is not going to win so I think perhaps we'll move on very quickly. But sport, Mr Speaker, has the opportunity to not only improve people's lives, but also change people's lives as well. I know from standing on the standing at Harlow Town Football Club week in, week out that I have got formed friendships and I'm forever grateful for that opportunity. This bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, will strengthen UK's position as a world-leading host of major sports sporting events by establishing a legal framework making it easier to host international competitions and strength that out advantage when bidding into future tournaments. I welcome some of the suggestions made by the Liberal Democrats in their amendments, but I looking at the bill in its current form, I believe that it already addresses the issues of unauthorized ticket touting.

It's absolutely a menace that we need to get to the bottom of. We want real sports fans to have the opportunity to go to these sporting events. It also looks at something that is a huge issue when we have huge sporting events, which is traffic transport and traffic management, which is a really important point to consider when hosting large events and also the opportunity to provide financial assistance to get these events up and running. Because Madam Deputy Speaker, we know how much in 1996 and 2012 our local communities really benefited from these large tournaments. Not only of course does it benefit businesses, but I think there's something even more even less tangible in this country hosting major sporting events.

It's perhaps a little bit more than just hope. It's about bringing people together through the good times and also sadly the penalty shootouts as well. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill shows this Labour Government is committed to ensuring the UK remains a world leader world-leading destination for major sporting events and ultimately that's what we all want because that gives us home advantage.

01:27:32 - 01:27:34

Speaker 129

Nigel Huddleston.

01:27:33 - 01:32:56

Nigel Huddleston

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Having served as the sports minister overseeing the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games, I know first-hand both the incredible opportunities and also incredible challenges that come with hosting major international sporting events, and it's for that reason that I broadly welcome this bill and the framework that it seeks to establish. The case for hosting major sporting events is very clear: they generate significant economic activity, support jobs, inspire participation in sport and leave lasting legacies in communities right across the country. Sport contributes more than 53 billion pounds annually to the UK economy, and major events play a really important role in supporting growth across sectors such as tourism and hospitality. The Birmingham Commonwealth Games alone generated an additional 1.2 billion pounds in economic value-add, as well, of course, of leaving a legacy for improved and indeed new facilities in and around Birmingham.

Hear.

And as we look ahead to the Euro 2028, as we pursue our ambition to host the 2035 Women's World Cup, and, potentially, a future Olympic Games, it's vital that we have a modern and effective legislative framework in place. Historically, Parliament had to legislate separately for each major event, and this approach is neither efficient nor sustainable. The strength of this bill is that it creates a standing framework through which future events can be delivered more effectively, reducing unnecessary bureaucracy while ensuring the UK remains an attractive, if not the best place in the world, to host major sporting competitions. And for those reasons, I support the broad aims of the bill. And I appreciate that since earlier stages of this bill, Madam Deputy Speaker, the government has accepted some amendments, including incorporating a limited number of recurring annual events.

However, there are a few further amendments and enhancements that I would like the government to consider. And therefore consider supporting some of the amendments proposed by the opposition front bench. The first relates to industrial action. Now, the success of a major sporting event depends not only on athletes and organizers, but on the transport networks and public services that allow spectators, volunteers and competitors to participate. And when that infrastructure is disrupted, local businesses lose trade, visitors face uncertainty and the reputation of the host nation can suffer.

We've seen this before: many will remember the strikes that were planned to coincide with the opening of the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games. This was a deliberate attempt to disrupt a major national event as the country was recovering from the pandemic, with the intent of causing maximum disruption. And furthermore, it meant into meant the government then had to dip into contingencies to the tune of 4 million pounds to provide alternative transport options for sporting fans. Of course, this was taxpayers' money, and therefore any opportunity to limit such damage would be welcome. The second issue concerns the protection of women's sport.

A major sporting event should not only showcase excellence on the field of play, but command the confidence of athletes, spectators and governing bodies alike. For many people, maintaining fairness in women's sporting competition and preserving appropriate single-sex spaces form an important part of that confidence. And the opposition's amendment seeks to incorporate single-sex protections into the sporting events framework, ensuring that where it is applied, major sporting events and associated activities provide single-sex competitive competitions and facilities in accordance with the Equality Act 2010. And the proposals also provide sensible exemptions for self-contained facilities, including those designed for disabled people, recognizing that accessibility, dignity and practicality must sit alongside privacy and fairness.

There are also several proposals and amendments relating to ticketing and ticket touting, in particular the secondary ticket market. And in this area, I think we need to be careful. I think there's cross-party support for the fact that we do need to make sure that we do not have rip-off circumstances in sporting events, and indeed ticketing for many events. However, we also need to make sure that a valid, perfectly legitimate secondary ticket market can thrive, because that can be good for consumers. And also competition can help keep prices low.

And there have been circumstances where a monopoly has been created in sporting events, well-intended, but then has led to the organizers charging considerable amounts, for example, fees. We saw that during the FIFA World Cup, for example, the official resale platform charged a 15% fee to both buyers and sellers. And that demonstrates how easily costs can be passed on to supporters when there is limited competition and no alternative marketplaces available. And therefore, I'd ask the Government to consider what further evidence may be required in order to consider this particularly challenging marketplace. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, again, I want to stress that I support the overall purpose of this bill and the framework it establishes.

However, if we are serious about maximizing the benefits of hosting major sporting events, we should also prepare be prepared to strengthen the legislation where necessary. And the amendments before us do seek to do exactly that, and I hope the Minister would consider them carefully.

01:32:57 - 01:35:14

Adebayo Alaba

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome this bill, because I know from experience just how important it is. Before becoming the Member of Parliament for Southend East and Rochford, I was fortunate enough to be involved in the London 2012 Olympic Games, the European Euro 2020 football championships and the 2022 FIFA World Cup. I've seen firsthand what it takes to make a major sporting event a success and the benefits it can have for the wider community. What these events have taught me is that whilst venues, organization, and promotion are all important, the most crucial factor is support from government and local authorities.

But unfortunately, that support is currently not consistent across the country. While some areas have the relationships, the expertise, and capacity to help sporting events thrive, others start from scratch each and every time. That's why the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee has come has called for a national strategy for major events, and I welcome the Government's commitment to publish one. The committee has also called for responsibility for major events to be moved from DCMS to the Department for Business and Trade, a move that would highlight the role of events in driving investment, tourism, and growth. But the importance of major sporting events is not just their financial contribution, but their ability to create and celebrate community.

We also see this in grassroots events, such as Rochford Hundred's Remembrance Day fixture, which recently brought the community together in an extraordinary way. That event was not a global spectacle, but it showed the true power of sport in building community. I commend the club's president, Ray Stephenson, and its chairman, Steve Maguire, who made that match happen. May I finish by encouraging colleagues to think back on the successful sporting events of the past few decades, and specifically, the ability to make the whole country feel united. And these and in these current times, we all know how important it is to stay united.

This bill strengthens our ability to deliver those moments and ensures the benefits reach every community in the country. Thank you.

01:35:14 - 01:35:16

Speaker 134

A point of order, Nigel Huddleston.

01:35:16 - 01:35:27

Nigel Huddleston

Madam Deputy Speaker, please forgive me, I neglected to refer honourable members to my register of members' interests when I gave my speech some moments ago.

Please forgive me for that omission.

01:35:27 - 01:35:33

Speaker 138

Thank you, that most definitely been put on the record. I now come to Liz Jarvis.

01:35:33 - 01:39:47

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd also like to point members to my Record of Interests. Major sporting events bring significant economic and social benefits from hospitality and tourism to grassroots participation and improved facilities. I am very proud that next summer the Utilita Bowl in Eastleigh will host its first men's Ashes test expected to generate millions a day for the local economy. However, these benefits depend on fans being treated fairly, starting with ticket pricing.

This Bill makes it a criminal offense to tout tickets for an event covered by the framework in the relevant area during a specified period. Fans have waited too long for touting to be tackled and the unlimited fines send the right signal. However, while the Bill criminalizes unauthorized resale even at or below face value, it sets no price limit on authorized resale leaving fans exposed. That is why I welcome new clauses 1 and 3 tabled by my honorable friend the Member for Frome and East Somerset. New clause 1 would stop tickets being resold above their original cost and cap resale platform fees, while new clause 3 would cap transaction fees at 10% and ban surge pricing.

This means the most a fan could ever be charged for a ticket they can no longer use is the price they paid. The Government has committed to capping resale prices on the same basis as new clause 1, but has promised only a draft Bill. These new clauses will protect fans sooner. Too many fans are now priced out of watching the sport they love not just in stadiums, but at home. Amendment 1, also tabled by my honorable friend, would make free-to-air coverage a condition for any event covered by this Bill.

As many of us remember, in 2022 17.4 million people watched the Lionesses win the Euros on BBC One. In the season that followed, the FA estimated there was a 140% increase in girls under-16 playing football, including in my constituency, with 2.3 million more women and girls playing the game than the year before. I won't lean on the old line that girls cannot be what they cannot see and I wouldn't claim that free-to-air coverage is the only reason for this growth, but it is part of the story. As I mentioned, next year's fourth Ashes test will be played in Eastleigh, yet no home Ashes series has been shown live on free-to-air television since 2005. Where public money is given to an event, fans who cannot get a ticket should not then be shut out by the cost of a subscription as well.

This Bill will create restricted advertising zones around events where unauthorized advertising becomes a criminal offense. However, it protects commercial rights and not the content of what is advertised, leaving the door open for gambling companies to remain official sponsors. The Liberal Democrats have long called for stronger protections and new clause 4 would deliver them by prohibiting gambling advertising, marketing, and sponsorship at every event covered by the Bill. The Government's own impact assessment estimated estimates that hundreds of street traders will be affected by trading restrictions and yet the Bill includes no statutory duty to consult them before a restricted trading zone is created. In my constituency, West End has a compact high street close to the Utilita Bowl.

Depending on how a zone is drawn, it could cover much of the village's commercial center. Can the Minister explain what these restrictions would mean in practice for businesses like those in West End? New clause 6 would require consultation with those representing affected businesses, but does not guarantee that the traders themselves or councils are given a say over how a zone is drawn.

I ask the Minister to consider requiring a brief impact assessment for nearby small businesses, with local authorities given a statutory right to comment before a zone is confirmed. If this bill is to work for sport, it must work for local businesses and fans too.

01:39:47 - 01:39:49

Speaker 140

Hear.

01:39:49 - 01:45:37

Paul Stephen Barclay

Mr Steve Barclay. Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Now I rise to speak to amendment eight in terms of industrial action and amendment six regarding single sex protections. And the point really I want to raise Madam Speaker is actually a larger point than this bill specifically, because I think it's a perfect case study really as to what is the purpose of the Chamber. Because we have a bill, as the member for Southend East and Rochford articulated, has I think broad support across the House.

I don't think it's a controversial bill. I think there are colleagues across all parts of the House that love sport, that want our country to attract major sporting events to these shores, that see sport as a force for good in unifying communities, and I very much agreed with the sentiments that he set out in his remarks. And what has been tabled by my colleagues on the front bench are two very modest, very reasonable, very sensible amendments. One of which is simply building on the existing law and saying that if we are going to use taxpayers' money for events in the UK, surely those should comply with UK law. The very essence, I would have thought, of a modest amendment.

We have a consensual piece of legislation and we have an amendment that simply wants to restate what the existing law is and how it applies to an international competition that is held here. And the second is to say that by their nature, these events are unique. They're often once in a generation. Indeed, the reason we have this bill, the very essence for this bill, is because of the unique nature of these events. If they were happening year in, year out, then we would have a very different bill presented to the House.

This is talking about a rugby World Cup. It's talking about a football Euros. It's talking about an Olympics. By their nature, they're very unique events. They don't come around all the time.

So it's quite farcical for the government to maintain a premise that normal industrial relations would be constrained by actually preventing strike action during something that is so out of the ordinary. It is not in the nature of routine industrial actions. And yet that seemed to be the tent of the government's case in the House of Lords. So again, we had effective scrutiny in the House of Lords, sensible amendments brought forward. And the government's argument, from what I could ascertain from it, seemed to really be on two premises.

The first being, "Oh well, this wasn't specifically in our manifesto." But as I say, we're talking about a fairly unique set of circumstances. And second, it would in some ways get in the way of normal industrial relations, it would constrain the trade unions. For the very reason for having this amendment is because if strike action was sought at a specific time of a global sporting event being held in the UK, that is not part of business as usual, that's not normal industrial relations, that's about a trade union trying to exploit that opportunity for unique leverage. And that is not in keeping with the spirit of this bill.

And so, I really just direct ministers to their opening paragraph of their own bill, you know, which talks about legislative provisions to be applied to major sporting events and providing financial assistance in relation to those.

So, we've got a piece of legislation on which there is consensus, where I think there is a lot of support for the Government in attracting sporting events to the UK. We've had sensible suggestions from their lordships, and two very modest amendments put forward by the front bench. And that's why I say actually, I think it's just an interesting case study as to whether this chamber simply becomes somewhere where people come and read out a speech, perhaps someone else has written,

or dare I say even generated by AI, with their heads down and reading it out, and don't take interventions, don't take amendments, and we cease to be a debating chamber. Is that really where debates in this House are going? Well, more than welcome to take an intervention if you would like to intervene on the point.

But is this House going to actually be able to scrutinise legislation, and make modest amendments on issues which simply apply the existing law, that simply ensure that our taxpayers' money is used to host a sporting event that is not hijacked by an entirely separate industrial action? Can the Government actually bring itself to accept even the most modest and consensual amendments? Or is it simply the case that anything tabled will be routinely rejected, the ability of the House to scrutinise legislation has become so defunct that the suggestions from their lordships are disregarded? And we take what is a consensual bill, an area of legislation on which there's broad agreement, and simply refuse the very reasonable amendments that have been put forward.

So, I urge ministers, and I know the default position of all governments, I've been in government, all governments is often just simply to reject opposition amendments. I think what colleagues have tabled here are extremely modest. It reflects the debate their lordships have, and I hope ministers will be able to look constructively on those so that the broad support that there is for deli- this legislation can be maintained moving forward. I

01:45:37 - 01:45:42

Speaker 142

call the Shadow Secretary of State, Rebecca Pow.

01:45:42 - 01:57:22

Rebecca Paul

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it is a pleasure to speak today on behalf of the official opposition, and I refer members to my Register of Interests. As I made clear at second reading, Britain has a world-class sporting heritage and a renowned reputation for hosting major events. From the Olympics and Paralympics, to Wimbledon, the Open and the British Grand Prix, these occasions bring pride to our country, support jobs and inspire future generations. That is why the opposition supports a permanent legislative framework to help Britain host these events and has sought to work constructively with Government on maximising the opportunity. And the result of that can be seen in the bill before us today.

It has benefited considerably from scrutiny, particularly the work of Lord Parkinson, Lord Markham and Baroness Evans in the other place. One of their most significant achievements was extending the framework to major recurring sporting events. As originally drafted, international tournaments visiting Britain could benefit, while established fixtures, such as Wimbledon and the London Marathon, could not. Thanks to Conservative peers working alongside Lord Addington and others, the Lords voted to remove that exclusion. I welcome the Government's subsequent acceptance of the principle, albeit with additional conditions introduced.

Several of our other amendments address practical concerns raised in committee. New clause 8 and amendment 10 would give genuine charitable ticket auctions the protection they deserve. A charity auctioning donated tickets for a good cause should not be treated in the same way as a professional ticket tout, nor should it have to depend on exemptions that ministers might grant later.

We have also proposed safeguards for ordinary supporters who need to resell tickets, stronger parliamentary scrutiny of financial assistance, and an assessment of how government economic policies affect Britain's ability to attract major sporting events. These are important issues, and I hope the government will give them proper consideration. But today, I want to focus on two major improvements we have proposed to this bill. The first concerns industrial action and is set out in amendment 6, alongside amendment 7, new clause 7 and new schedule 1. Taken together, these provisions would establish new protections against industrial action disrupting major sporting events.

As my honourable friend the member for Old Bexley and Sidcup explained in committee, there is little point putting elaborate protections in place for ticketing, advertising, trading and commercial rights if an event can nevertheless be brought to a standstill by industrial action. We saw the risk of disruption around the Birmingham Commonwealth Games in 2022 when rail strikes were announced around the period of the games. More recently, threatened action at Scottish airports raised concerns ahead of the Glasgow Commonwealth Games. And we should remember the enormous economic consequences of transport disruption. Last year's London Underground strikes cost Transport for London an estimated £20 to £25 million in lost fares alone, with the wider economic impact estimated at £230 million.

Major sporting events take years to secure and organise. Spectators travel from across the world, businesses invest in preparation, and our international reputation depends on delivering what we have promised. Yet, all of that can be jeopardised by industrial action at precisely the wrong moment. Our amendments would therefore make restrictions on industrial action by specified transport and local authority workers a mandatory part of the framework during the relevant period. These protections should not be an optional extra applied to some events, but not others.

The government rejected similar proposals in committee, citing workers' rights. But surely we must also consider the rights of spectators, athletes and businesses who have invested their time and money in these events. The minister has yet to explain how the government intends to protect major sporting events from this very real risk, and I hope she will do so today. Moving now to our second substantial proposal concerning fairness, safety and the protection of women's sport. This is advanced through amendment 8, supported by amendment 9 and new schedule 2.

Given its importance, I want to devote the remainder of my contribution to these provisions. Madam Deputy Speaker, at the Paris Olympics in 2024, something shocking happened. It was in a women's boxing match between Angela Carini of Italy and Imane Khelif of Algeria. After taking heavy blows to the face, Angela signalled for the referee to stop the fight. Just 46 seconds after the contest began, Khelif was declared the winner.

Angela fell to her knees in tears, her Olympic dreams shattered. But this wasn't a fair fight. This wasn't a fair competition. Angela was fighting a man, and it was obvious to anyone with eyes. Yet arguably even more shocking than the fight itself was the response.

There was more criticism and ridicule of Angela for not shaking his hand in the ring, for crying, than of a man punching a woman in the face repeatedly. As often happens, the feelings of a man were being prioritised over fairness and safety of a woman. What I observed was cowardice on a huge scale. Even members from this House disgustingly celebrated this televised male violence against a woman that cheated her out of the competition. Sport is played with our bodies.

Men on average are much stronger and faster. Biology matters.

Angela and many other women who have been forced to compete against men have been put at risk of harm. This should never happen in a sporting event anywhere ever again. Opposition amendments would at least help ensure it cannot happen on British soil. There has thankfully been some progress. In March this year, the International Olympic Committee announced that from the Los Angeles Olympics in 2028, eligibility for women's competition will be determined through a one-time non-invasive genetic test via a cheek swab.

This will apply across Olympic sports, with the IOC explicitly recognizing the importance of fairness and safety. Following the controversies of Paris, this is a welcome step towards restoring confidence in women's sport. In this country, we do not accept cheating, we do not accept women being treated as second-class citizens, and we respect the law, which is very clear on this matter. And this is so important because sporting organizations, even after For Women Scotland, are still failing to ensure that the women's category does not include males. They continue to turn a blind eye, or come up with spurious reasons why they can sidestep the law.

Take table tennis and squash here in England. Both governing bodies now recognise the importance of biological sex in determining eligibility for women's competitions, but both operate a two-tier system. Table Tennis England restricts its women's category at nationally ranked competitions to female players, yet allows males to compete in women's categories at local level. England Squash similarly excludes males from its female category in regulated competitions, but permits their participation in recreational competitions. Both organizations accept the need for fairness at higher levels, while sacrificing the integrity of the female category further down.

But surely fairness matters to women at the grassroots just as much as it does to elite athletes. Why should a woman playing in her local league be entitled to any less consideration than a national champion? Do they not realize that cheating a young girl out of her rightful podium place at grassroots level means that she is more likely to give up any dreams to progress further? Consider FIFA, which governs the Women's World Cup. Its gender verification regulations date back to 2011, place responsibility largely on national football associations, and expressly rule out routine testing.

FIFA announced a review of these rules years ago, yet we are still waiting for a clear updated approach. The consequences of these differing standards are already apparent. Zambia's Barbra Banda with- was withdrawn from the 2022 Women's Africa Cup of Nations on gender eligibility grounds, yet subsequently competed at the 2023 Women's World Cup, and was named the BBC's Women's Footballer of the Year in 2024. A once-in-a-lifetime sex screen would ensure that no male is competing in such events. Or take the most recent announcement by the London Marathon.

They are considering allowing male pacemakers into the elite women's race next year. They say it's to help women shatter the world record, but is it? In the words of the famed Olympian Baroness Davies of Devonport: "So do they have cheaters to pace make for men's races? Or just other men, maybe?" Even if the London Marathon's intentions are entirely honorable, they will be changing a single-sex race into a mixed-sex one, opening the door for male competitors to participate and win. It is exactly this type of thing that our amendments would prevent for such major sporting events.

So what would the protections in opposition new schedule 2 actually do? Firstly, it would require the Secretary of State, before applying the sporting events framework, to be satisfied that organizers will ensure competitors in single-sex events compete against those of the same biological sex. It would also require single-sex accommodation, changing and washing facilities and toilets for competitors and officials. These protections would extend to spectators and staff, ensuring access to appropriate single-sex toilets, changing and washing facilities.

Our amendment also seeks to prevent financial assistance being provided to sporting events or associated legacy and social impact programs where the required protections are not observed. The opposition do not believe that any male should be competing in women's sport at all, and we do not support any sporting organization benefiting from this bill or getting taxpayer support if they do not respect the law. The minister may once again tell us that existing legislation is sufficient. We've already heard that argument in committee. We remain unconvinced.

I suspect the female athletes losing podium places to biological men would feel the same. I know there are many sensible members on the Labour benches that entirely agree with us on this. There may even be a couple on the Lib Dem benches. None on the Greens though. So, today, I am asking these members and the government more broadly to be brave and do the right thing.

Back amendment eight and the single-sex protections it would help establish to ensure women's sport at these sporting events is protected, that only females can compete. And if you're still feeling a bit yellow about it, do it for your daughters, do it for your wives and do it for your moms. This is about ensuring that female athletes can compete fairly, that sports women have access to appropriate facilities, and that the sporting organizations benefiting from this framework are held to the highest standards. In closing, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill offers a rare opportunity to strengthen Britain's position as a leading host of major sporting events. We support that ambition.

We welcome the improvements already made during its passage and have put forward a number of reasonable amend- amendments to that end. But we can and must go further. After all, what is the point of putting on a world-class competition if no one can get to it and if the games are rigged from the start? Thank you.

01:57:22 - 01:57:25

Speaker 145

Call the Minister Stephanie Peacock.

01:57:25 - 01:57:50

Stephanie Peacock

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, today's debate has broadly shown the cross-party recognition of the importance of major sporting events and their ability to showcase the very best of our country. The UK is a world leader when it comes to host of major sporting events, and this bill will make sure we continue to attract the world's biggest sporting moments and welcome the social and economic benefits they bring. This I will give way, yes.

01:57:50 - 01:58:22

Jim Shannon

I apologize for not being here at the very beginning of the debate, but I wanted to ask this question very specifically. Running any sporting event, be it a Commonwealth Games, be it a football tournament, whatever it may be, for one city to do on their own is almost impossible because of financial cost, but it may be possible to do that across a number of cities within the United Kingdom. Has government given that commitment to ensuring that if we have a football tournament that Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and England can be part of that showpiece taking place, or for the Commonwealth Games something similar?

01:58:22 - 01:59:02

Stephanie Peacock

Yeah, I'm the honourable gentleman makes an incredibly important point. Indeed, we're working together on Euro 2028, which is the first tournament with which this bill will apply. And of course, this is a framework bill that covers ticketing, transport, advertising, trading and unauthorized association. And as I committed to at second reading, proportionality is now embedded in these powers, making sure everyone can benefit when the world comes to visit us, in particular small and micro-sized businesses. And after valuable discussion in this House and the other place, we are pleased that the bill will also extend to our world-class recurrent events, allowing internationally acclaimed events the opportunity to apply to and benefit from the powers of this bill.

01:59:02 - 01:59:09

Speaker 147

Now, I'm grateful to contributions from across the House, and I will indeed give way to the Chair of the Select Committee.

01:59:09 - 01:59:50

Caroline Dinenage

Grateful to the minister for giving way, and for coming to appear in front of our select committee inquiry into major events earlier in the year. At that session, we asked her what more she could do to demonstrate the government were gripping this, and so the extension to more events other than just these one-offs is really good.

But, as I mentioned earlier, we do risk creating a kind of two-tier ticketing system, because the rules relate to sporting events, but music events and other cultural events are left waiting for a solution that was in the manifesto, but hasn't yet come. Can she give any updates today on when we might be able to expect this ticket-touting bill, that can set out the restrictions on who can operate in the secondary market, and how that can be more legislatively fair?

01:59:50 - 02:01:05

Stephanie Peacock

Minister. I'm grateful to the Select Committee for all their work, and indeed for the honourable member. I really appreciated the work on the major events, and I listened to most of the evidence that her committee took. We're absolutely committed to getting that on the statute book, and I'll come onto it in a moment. I'd like to say I'm grateful to the former sports minister for all his work, and for his contribution.

I believe he raised the question about why transport isn't included for recurrent events. We have had a conversation about this with stakeholders, and we're confident that recurrent events already have robust transport provisions in place, but this issue was raised in detail at committee, and I have written to the relevant transport minister to raise those concerns. I was grateful to the member for Southend East and Harlow for their support and contribution. I think their contributions highlighted that major events contribute to communities across our country. Now, the member for Eastleigh asked about small businesses on drawing the zone that is much tighter, where we work with things like the Euro 2028 and recurrent events, but I am

Give me one second. I have lost my place, but I'd be happy to speak to the honourable member with sorry, I'm going to have to take a moment, sorry. Intervention? Chris Vince. Chris. I'll make it Chris, if you want.

It's Chris Vince. Okay.

02:01:05 - 02:01:14

Christopher John Vince

Would the minister agree with me that it's hugely important that we celebrate all levels of sport, from grassroots football like Roydon FC, to the mighty Harlow Town, and of course to Leeds United?

02:01:15 - 02:01:17

Speaker 150

Minister Peacock. Minister Peacock.

02:01:17 - 02:01:44

Stephanie Peacock

I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman, grateful for the House for being understanding. He makes a really important point. I would now just like to turn to the issue of ticketing. The amendments tabled by the honourable member for Frome and East Somerset deal with ticketing, and as I said to the chair of the Select Committee, we are committed to tackling industrial-scale touting. However, this bill is not the place.

Our upcoming ticket tout fan bill will Yes, I will, yeah.

02:01:44 - 02:02:00

Jim Shannon

Minister, we are very appreciative of all the work that you do as minister for the department, and your enthusiasm and your energy is something that we very much respect, and we understand that you're bringing forward some legislative changes that we wish to see, and that we welcome.

02:02:00 - 02:02:03

Speaker 149

I believe the minister was just about to conclude. Final words?

02:02:03 - 02:02:15

Stephanie Peacock

Yes, so I think he makes a really important point. I think we've had a very good debate on this in particular in committee. I'm grateful for the support of the whole House. We are a world leader in major events, and I commend the bill to the House.

02:02:15 - 02:02:24

Speaker 155

Fantastic job, Minister. Is it the pleasure that New Clause 1 be moved? Is it your pleasure that New Clause 1 be moved?

02:02:24 - 02:02:26

Speaker 148

Yes, I formally move.

02:02:26 - 02:03:15

Speaker 157

The question is that New Clause 1 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". Clear the lobby.

02:03:15 - 02:03:26

Speaker 151

Right. Mr. Gagan Mohindra, Mr. Jim Shannon. Fantastic. The question is as on the Order Paper. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye".

Of the contrary, "No". Tellers for the ayes are Lee Dillon on his crutches and Will Forster, and tellers no, the Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal.

02:14:39 - 02:14:45

Speaker 152

Order.

02:14:45 - 02:14:56

Speaker 156

The Ayes to the right: 62. The Noes to the left: 286.

02:14:56 - 02:15:18

Speaker 155

The Ayes to the right: 62. The Noes to the left: 286. So, the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Amendment six has been selected for separate decision.

I call the opposition spokesperson to move the amendment formally.

02:15:18 - 02:15:19

I beg to move.

02:15:19 - 02:15:24

Speaker 157

Question is that amend- amendment six be made. As many as that opinion say Aye.

02:15:24 - 02:15:25

Of the contrary, no.

02:15:25 - 02:16:01

Speaker 158

The noes have it. Clear the lobby. Colleagues should be seated when I'm on my feet. Mr Alan Mak. Marvelous.

02:16:01 - 02:16:04

Speaker 153

The question is as on the Order Paper. As many that opinion say aye.

02:16:04 - 02:16:05

Of the contrary, no.

02:16:06 - 02:16:09

Speaker 154

Tellers for the ayes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas. Tellers for the noes are Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal.

02:26:52 - 02:26:57

Speaker 152

Order.

02:26:57 - 02:27:07

Speaker 156

The Ayes to the right: 91, the Noes to the left: 298.

02:27:07 - 02:27:33

Speaker 155

The Ayes to the right: 91, the Noes to the left: 298. The Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Amendment. Amendment eight has been selected for separate decision.

I call the opposition spokesperson to move the amendment formally.

02:27:33 - 02:27:35

Speaker 160

I beg to move.

02:27:35 - 02:27:38

Speaker 159

Question is that amendment 8 be made. As many in that opinion say aye.

02:27:39 - 02:27:40

Against, say no.

02:27:41 - 02:28:23

Speaker 161

Clear the lobby. It seems the members that are paying attention to proceedings, marvellous. The question is as on the order paper, as many of that opinion say aye.

02:28:24 - 02:28:25

Of the contrary, no.

02:28:26 - 02:28:26

Tellers for the ayes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas, tellers for the noes are Shaun Davies and Harpreet Uppal.

02:37:59 - 02:38:04

Speaker 163

Order.

02:38:04 - 02:38:13

Speaker 162

The ayes to the right were 93, the noes to the left, 287.

02:38:13 - 02:38:57

Speaker 155

The ayes to the right, 93. The noes to the left, 287. The noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. Before we move on to third reading, I have to make a statement.

Voting in today's deferred divisions will now reopen in the no lobby and continue for 25 minutes. Exciting times. Consider consideration completed, third reading. No. King's consent.

Prince of Wales's consent. Minister to move third reading.

02:38:57 - 02:40:53

Lisa Nandy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that the bill now be read a third time. The UK has a proud record of hosting the world's greatest sporting events, from Glasgow and Birmingham this summer, and who can forget the 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games in London, delivered by the late and great Tessa Jowell, who is still much missed by all of us in this House. And I would like to pay tribute to the honorable member who oversaw an extraordinarily successful Commonwealth Games in Birmingham as well. It really did show what this country is capable of.

In a world where too many things divide us, sport has the remarkable capacity to unite, to bring communities together, and show the best of our country to the world. Perhaps its greatest power is what it can do for the next generation. I was privileged to be at the Red Roses' historic win at the 2025 Women's Rugby World Cup, and see Twickenham packed to the rafters cheering them on. What made me prouder still was seeing what followed: thousands of girls taking their first steps into rugby, signing up to their local clubs and discovering what they were capable for. This is what we should always strive for and we have some extraordinary opportunities ahead of us.

The two Tour de France Grand Departs come to Great Britain next summer, and create the most accessible major sporting event our country has ever hosted. Millions of people will get the chance to get up close to some of the greatest competitors in the world, and I hope to inspire a new generation into cycling. The UEFA European Championship in 2028 will give us a summer of extraordinary football, and its legacy, we are determined, will be about much more than what happens in the stadiums across the whole of the United Kingdom, and that must of course include great benefits to Northern Ireland. Of course.

02:40:53 - 02:41:27

Charlie Dewhirst

The Secretary of State for giving way. It's a slightly technical point, but with mega-events, such as she's just been talking about, there can be issues with unauthorized car parking, whereby this causes major problems for the event organizers, and I've been one myself with traffic management systems and others. Would you agree that it might be appropriate to have exclusion zones around these stadiums and other sporting venues, to ensure that the event organizers work with any land owner who wishes to operate an unauthorized car park and far be it for me to deter such entrepreneurial spirit, but to ensure that they work together so that the event organizers can better organize those traffic management plans?

02:41:27 - 02:41:34

Speaker 155

Before the minister responds, just to let backbenchers know, you and yours not appropriate for the chamber. Minister.

02:41:34 - 02:48:52

Lisa Nandy

I very much took this concern as directed at me, Madam Deputy Speaker, and he's right to raise it, because it can be a significant problem. Transport provisions are already covered as part of the scope of the bill, but we would, of course, always be happy to work with the honorable member and others who share our concerns around making sure these events are successful if there are any particular issues that arise subsequently. The UEFA European Championship in 2028 is going to be an incredible moment for our country. It's going to projected to deliver a sixfold return on public investment, and we're going to use this opportunity to get more people playing football, to strengthen our grassroots clubs, and to open up opportunities right across the country. Members will also know that we have bid for the FIFA 2035 Women's World Cup, and the 2029 World Para Athletics Championships, and this government is committed to seeing the Ryder and Solheim Cups hosted here.

And as my right honorable friend, the Chancellor, announced last week, we have committed £7 million to a detailed feasibility study for a potential bid to host the Olympic and Paralympic Games in the North of England in the 2040s. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is personal for me. I grew up in the North of England, in Manchester. I watched as we unsuccessfully bid for the Olympic Games many years ago. I watched the many people across the country tell us it couldn't be done, that Manchester couldn't host major sporting events, and then only a few years later we went on to host a really successful Commonwealth Games and show the world how it was done.

Every part of this country deserves the chance to contribute to our incredibly rich legacy in major sporting events. We believe the North of England has so much to offer, and we are determined to make sure that the rest of the world gets the chance to see that.

Underpinning all of this is a belief that benefit the benefits of hosting major events should not be confined to the host city or to those fortunate enough to secure a ticket. They should be felt in towns and cities, in our schools and sports clubs, and in communities across all four nations of the UK and inspire a generation of young people to go on and live the richer, larger lives they deserves. This Bill allows us stand ready to host the biggest events in the world, to protect the integrity of those events to ensure that people can enjoy them, and make certain that the benefits reach as far as possible. I am really grateful to Members across this House who have engaged so constructively and thoughtfully with us during the passage of this Bill, to support us on the provisions that we all believe will improve the way that we host major sporting events and to improve the Bill itself. I'd also like to thank our Whip, in particular, the Member for Luton South and South Bedfordshire, for her sterling work on this Bill.

Our Whips are often unsung heroes in this place, and without them, the major benefits that we deliver to the people of this country wouldn't simply not happen. In particular, the improvements that hon. Members have helped us to make have broadened the framework's scope so that some of our world-class recurrent events can also benefit from its provisions in future. We've heard loud and clear the importance of getting the balance right to provide effective protections for major sporting events while ensuring that the framework offers operates fairly and proportionately for businesses and communities, and I'm pleased that these safeguards are now strengthened in the Bill. I do want to address a few of the concerns that we've heard today head-on, in particular, the questions and the points that were made about biological sex and the need to protect sporting events. I'd say to my hon. Friend, the Member opposite, I have heard her points and I know she feels passionately about this issue, but I do want to be clear for the avoidance of any doubt that participation in all events within the scope of this Bill are already based on biological sex.

I don't want Members to misunderstand what we are doing here in this Bill. There were concerns raised by a few hon. Members about the prospect of sporting events being derailed by strike action. I have to say, you know, and I hope Members will take this in the right spirit, that I couldn't disagree more with their proposals. It's notable to me that no Member could point to a single instance where a major sporting event has been derailed by strike action. During the 2012 Olympics, when I was serving as PPS to Tessa Jowell, many Members on the opposite side raised concerns that the 2012 Olympics would be derailed by strike action.

In the event, the only major disruption was when a private company, G4S, failed to deliver on its contract, and the Army had to be drafted in to support. I would just gently say to the other side that if you want to avoid strike action, the best way to do that is to treat the workforce of this country as partners in our national endeavour and to treat them properly. And I want to recognise the concerns that the hon. Member has raised around ticketing that were echoed by the Chair of the Select Committee. I do recognise the intention of bringing the amendment that they brought today, but I just want to be clear, the Government rejected that amendment not because we are anything but committed to bringing in the strongest protection for fans, whether it's at music, sport, or other live events, but because what this would have done, in effect, is to create a two-tier system where sporting events were covered, but music events were not, and dilutes what is a comprehensive package that we are putting forward to the House to clamp down on ticket touts and call time on the rip-off that's been allowed to go on in plain sight for too long, to give music, sports, and other live events back to their fans.

And I have to gently say that in 14 years of Tory government and in five years of coalition, no action was taken on this issue. A Labour government is going to deliver it. I also want to pay particular tribute to our devolved partners. From the outset, we've been clear that this must be legislation for the whole of the United Kingdom. We've worked closely together to ensure that the bill reflects that commitment, and that the opportunities and rewards from hosting these events are shared across all four nations, because when the world comes to our countries, it should be able to see and experience the very best of every part of our United Kingdom, of which we are so immensely proud.

Finally, I want to thank all of the individuals across government who've worked hard to get us to this point. Major sporting events give us moments we remember for a lifetime. But their real value lies in what they leave behind: the communities they strengthen, the opportunities they create, the young people they inspire, and the pride that they help us share with the world. This bill stands us ready to seize those opportunities and make sure that, when those moments come, the benefits belong to us all. I commend this bill to the House.

02:48:52 - 02:48:58

Speaker 166

The question is that the bill be now read a third time. And I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Rebecca Pow.

02:48:58 - 02:53:34

Rebecca Paul

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The opposition will not seek to divide the House on third reading. We support the fundamental purpose of this bill and believe Britain should be the best place in the world to host major sporting events and a permanent legislative framework will help us achieve that ambition. But the great tragedy of this process is that the bill we have before us could have been so much more. Thanks to the work of Conservative peers, alongside others in the other place, the bill was significantly improved before reaching this House.

Yet, despite the efforts of my honourable friend, the member for Old Bexley and Sidcup, in committee, and the arguments we have put forward during its subsequent passage, the government have failed to grasp the opportunity to go further. In this bill, we had an opportunity to establish clear statutory safeguards for female athletes, to protect the integrity of single-sex competition, and to ensure that sporting organisations benefiting from the privileges conferred by this bill respect the rights and safety of women and girls. Isn't that what female athletes deserve? Isn't that what all women deserve? And I have to say I'm actually really shocked at the result of the vote.

So, 93 members in this place voted to protect the women's category, almost all of those Conservatives, and there were no Liberal Democrats voting in favour of our amendment. So, on that point, so I have huge respect for the culture secretary, but we don't believe this is covered. And we know in practice that males are able to participate in these competitions. We know that, as I said in my first speech, the London Marathon are considering including male pacemakers, yet the London Marathon is meant to be covered by this bill. And we also have the numerous issues at FIFA level.

So, with respect, I do not believe that is the case. It is gut-wrenching to know that a rare chance to address these concerns within the framework of this bill was squandered by the front bench opposite, many of whom do still struggle to articulate what a woman even is. It will now fall to a future Conservative government to do what is necessary to protect the fairness and integrity of women's sport. And make no mistake, we will do it.

For now though, we can add sport to Labour's long list of safeguarding failures for women and girls. They've refused to move the dangerous men unlawfully held in women's prisons, dragged their feet on the grooming gang inquiry, stood by as nurses are harassed by the NHS for not wanting to undress in front of males, and refused to stop the Pathways puberty blocker trial, which would cause irreversible harm to hundreds of children. Yet they have the gall to say that reducing violence against women and girls is one of their priorities. I'm afraid actions speak louder than words. Time and time again, they have the chance to do the right thing, but time and time again, they don't.

For them, Madam Deputy Speaker, party will always come before country. Equally disappointing has been the government's refusal to properly address the threat of industrial action disrupting major sporting events. I struggle to see the logic in legislating to protect ticketing arrangements, commercial interests and advertising rights, but stubbornly refusing to take action on the strikes that could bring those same events to a standstill. What good are all these commercial protections if spectators cannot reach the stadium, and event that has taken years to organise is thrown into chaos by union bosses looking for their next bit of leverage? But we all know why they won't support this; they can't upset their union paymasters.

I hope they're all declaring their interests today whilst they do their bidding. With all this said, Madam Deputy Speaker, we will not stand in the way of this bill becoming law. We recognise the benefits it will bring, and the considerable work that has gone into improving it, but the government knows deep down that this was a missed opportunity to deliver something considerably more meaningful. The bill will almost certainly make Britain better equipped to host major sporting events, but sadly it does not make Britain a better place for a female athlete to compete, and that is a terrible shame. Thank you.

02:53:34 - 02:54:20

Speaker 155

If there are no further contributions, the question is that the bill be now read a third time. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". The ayes have it. The ayes have it.

I'll give the Front Benches a moment or two to shuffle over before we get onto the next bit of business. We now come to the motion number four on the Railways Bill carry-over extension. Minister to move, Minister Lightwood.

02:54:20 - 02:55:51

Simon Lightwood

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This bill places passengers back at the heart of our railway. By establishing Great British Railways, it provides a framework to ensure a robust, high-quality offer for passengers, including disabled passengers, to instill confidence in our railways and attract more people to use them. Great British Railways will also ensure that we harness the economic and environmental opportunities of rail freight. Underpinned by two statutory duties related to freight, Great British Railways will be tasked with maximising freight growth in a sustainable way, providing confidence to freight customers and the wider sector that this industry is being prioritised.

Finally, Great British Railways will ensure the needs of communities up and down the country are considered at every turn, with a bespoke partnerships framework requiring Great British Railways to work hand-in-hand with local authorities to make sure local communities receive the services that they need. As honourable members will be aware, this legislation is currently undergoing scrutiny in the other place, and it's important that this work continues and that this bill can reach the statute book. This motion simply ensures that Parliament has sufficient time available to scrutinise it. With that in mind, if honourable members would like to raise any specific concerns, I invite them to do so in writing to my department, where I'm sure my colleague, the rail minister, will be more than happy to respond. I beg to move.

02:55:51 - 02:55:59

Speaker 167

Goodness, I thought we had a rail minister in front of us for a moment. The question is as on the Order Paper. I call the shadow Secretary of State, Richard Holden.

02:55:59 - 03:00:07

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, because the Labour government brought a bill to this House incomplete, late, like a student late with an essay, handing in half-baked work well after the deadline, hoping nobody would notice, with half the answers missing, that's why we're back here. Presumably, the department is taking inspiration from the Education Secretary. They've run out of time, missed the deadline, and now they're back for more, Madam Deputy Speaker. They've had a year, but what on earth have they been doing?

We're here because Labour, once again, has shown whose side they're on, not the side of working people, who they can't even define, but on the side of their union paymasters, on whose coffers they depend. Who are the unions to Labour? An army of sugar daddies they can't do without, picking up the tab for Labour MPs, and when the unions call, Labour can't say no. This lot will ride roughshod over our railways just to fulfill their weird ideological obsessions and, more importantly, those of their union backers. How do we know that?

We look at their bill. Whose interests does it support? Is it for passengers, whose fares are set to rise next year, thanks to the Chancellor sneaking it through on the last page of the budget? Is it for rail freight, who face being squeezed off the tracks, slice by slice, under the weight of more costs and less access to tracks? Is it for the taxpayer, who has to foot the bill for this barefaced indulgence in ideology?

No, it's for their union bosses, pursuing an ideology abandoned by Japan, abandoned by every railway in Europe, but still there in the Labour Party in the UK. Madam Deputy Speaker, there used to be an order to how this worked, uniquely British. The unions rocked up at Number 10, they might pretend that it was beer, sandwiches and pork pies, but there was actually always white wine and smoked salmon, and they left after a genteel chat over some Chablis with giant pay rises. Well, we know Labour couldn't negotiate to save their lives. Forget an actual meeting or even the pretense of a negotiation, it all appears that's all that has to happen these days, just like ordering a takeaway the old school way, is dial-a-rise.

They literally pick up the phone, demand what they want, as if they're ordering a curry for tea. And that's why this bill has been delayed, because their union pals were worried. Worried about saving taxpayers' money. Now, I know that's an alien suggestion to the party opposite who, whenever they get a new Prime Minister, seem contractually obliged to go back to the unions and chuck a whopper of a pay rise so they don't ruffle feathers in their latest leadership election. That's what the Deputy Prime Minister provided of back in those heady days when she was the Transport Secretary, before she had to resign due to forgetting she'd admitted to being convictive of fraud.

And that's what the current Transport Secretary did. That's what this Prime Minister's done as well. Let's be clear. These delays have caused huge issues. Huge issues for taxpayers, already on the hook for God knows how much.

Huge issues for investors in our railways too. This is no way to govern, and this is no way to legislate. And it's no way, Madam Deputy Speaker, to respect this House. But maybe, just maybe, with the thinking they'll get if this with the thinking time they'll get if this motion passes, they'll use it to dwell on how to protect our open-access services, like the Hull Trains direct service from Selby to London, rather than screwing it over with their GBR-or-else mobster-style maneuvering. It is not good enough.

It's not good enough for passengers, who the Secretary of State seems to expect should be out on the streets clapping and banging their pots and pans to support this bill, every time they change a seat from one ironing board to another ironing board at the taxpayer's expense, every time they paint a train red, white and blue, or Burnham yellow in Manchester, every time they put up a clock. On this side, we see a bill that is most certainly not good enough for the taxpayers who have to fork out for all this grandstanding while the service gets more expensive.

That's what this bill promises. Yes, it delivers certainty of a service that will be worse: more trains delayed, more cancellations, more delays, more short-formed trains. We're seeing that already with the services currently being taken under state control. On this side of the House, we will not be voting for that. On this side of the House, we will not vote to carry that forwards.

On this side of the House, rather than the union paymasters, we'll be backing pac- taxpayers and passengers instead. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:00:07 - 03:00:14

Speaker 155

Marvelous. So, we've got the Liberal Democrat spokesperson Olly Glover? Marvelous, Olly Glover, come on.

03:00:14 - 03:01:22

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yes, I am here, very much. Yes, I mean, goodness me, how to follow that? I wonder how many other people have managed to get sugar daddies into Hansard, so congratulations to the Shadow Secretary of State there. Nothing has changed with this Nothing has changed with this legislation as of yet, so our grave concerns remain.

But, of course, we have hope that the deliberations of our noble Lords will lead to some improvements, and we'll look forward to seeing those at a later date. My only question to the minister is why has it taken so long to deliver this bill? It's He's quite right to say that scrute- opportunity for scrutiny is important and that is welcome, but by my analysis, there have been some unexplained gaps: one and a half months between second reading and the start of the bill committee in the Commons, and then a four-month gap between the bill committee concluding and report stage, and also a two-month gap in the Lords between the second reading and the committee stage. I very much hope that the Secretary of State did not procure HS2 or East West Rail to project manage this bill, or perhaps the minister will be considering introducing some form of parliamentary delay repay scheme, maybe he can tell us.

03:01:22 - 03:01:26

Speaker 171

If the minister does wish to respond, Minister Lightwood.

03:01:26 - 03:02:00

Simon Lightwood

Madam Deputy Speaker, what a truly bizarre performance by the Shadow Secretary of State. I hope that it makes more sense with subtitles. And he shouldn't give up his day job, because he'd make an absolutely lousy comedian. What I will say is the Railways Bill once again puts passengers back at the heart of our railway. By establishing Great British Railways, it provides the framework to ensure a robust, high-quality offer for passengers, including disabled passengers, to instill confidence in our railways and attract more people to use them.

I move formally, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:02:00 - 03:02:33

Speaker 172

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division. Clear the lobby.

I'm on my feet, Mr Anselm. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Tellers for the ayes are Sean Davies and Harpreet Uppal, and tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

03:14:28 - 03:14:32

Speaker 152

Order.

03:14:32 - 03:14:35

Speaker 175

The ayes to the right: 279.

03:14:35 - 03:14:42

Speaker 174

The noes to the left: 139.

03:14:42 - 03:15:29

Speaker 155

The ayes to the right: 279. The noes to the left: 139. So the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. Before I move on to the next set of business, I have a statement to make.

Voting in today's deferred division will now reopen in the No Lobby and continue for 2 minutes. 2 minutes. Well, there we see. Secretary of State running out. Marvelous.

Now if we're ready. We now come to motion number five on the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill, carry-over extension.

03:15:29 - 03:15:31

Speaker 177

Minister to move?

03:15:31 - 03:17:10

Speaker 176

Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you very much indeed. The UK is subject to daily and unrelenting cyber-attacks, as cybercriminals and state-linked actors blackmail businesses, steal data and threaten our very way of life. And as our lives become increasingly digital, the threat comes not only from hostile actors, but also from weaknesses and resilience in our systems. We must defend against both and focus our attentions where it matters most. Although all businesses should secure themselves against cyber-attack, using the NCSC's free toolkits, it's right that we do not over-regulate every business.

That is why the bill is targeted at our most essential and critical services: drinking water, health, transport, energy, and the digital services that keep our economy running, services where, if they were disrupted, we would have nowhere else to turn. The bill safeguards these services, and in turn protects individuals and businesses that rely on them. Madam Deputy Speaker, that is the priority of this Government. We will not hesitate to take action where hostile actors seek to do us harm.

This bill delivers a step change in national security and equips the Government with the powers to act decisively on threat in on threat intelligence. And this Government has gone further still, tabling amendments to introduce a new vendor risk management framework, a framework that will assist businesses to review their supply chains, work with Government to mitigate those risks, and if necessary, enable Government to step in and instruct organizations to take action. This week, the bill re-entered the House after completing the third reading in the other place on Monday the 2nd of November. Can I pay tribute to noble Lady, Baroness Lloyd, the minister, as well as members of this House and the other place, for engaging so constructively throughout this passage?

In many instances, their contributions have refined the bill and made it more robust. I know that honorable members will continue this constructive dialogue in their consideration of Lords amendments, and pass a bill that is fit for the cyber threats we face now and into the future. And I beg to move.

03:17:10 - 03:17:19

Speaker 155

The question is as on the order paper, and if I can read the room right, the Liberal Democrats, yes, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Victoria Collins.

03:17:19 - 03:20:00

Victoria Collins

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. We absolutely support this motion, but I feel it's my democratic duty to highlight some things that I'd love the Government to consider as we make that extension. So, if we look locally, nationally and internationally, in July, for example, Hertfordshire County Council raised its cybersecurity risk to the maximum score register of 25 out of 25. That is exactly the kind of risk this bill should manage. And yet, this bill excludes local authorities, despite them holding social care records and some of the most vulnerable people.

Less than a fortnight ago, 32 government services went offline while departments patched critical flaws in widely-used web software. This shows just how vulnerable the heart of our nation's digital infrastructure and security is. On Sunday night, hackers attacked dozens of supermarket refrigerators and freezers in seven European countries up to 50 degrees, spoiling millions of euros of produce. That is the food we all rely on every single day. And the National Cyber Security Centre warned that the UK's cyber resilience is not where it should be.

Our framework must not fall behind our closest neighbours, and we should deepen cooperation with EU agencies and member states. In a digital world, isolation only increases risk. And Madam Deputy Speaker, these examples lay bare the crucial importance of this bill and the devastating cost to businesses, consumers and our national security if we fail to get it right. This bill cannot simply react to yesterday's threats. We must ensure our critical national infrastructure is prepared for the future, which means addressing over-reliance on high foreign technology on high-risk foreign technology, and tackling the rapid rapidly escalating threat of AI cybersecurity attacks, as well as the Internet of Things and how it is really embedded in so much of what we use today.

That's why digital sovereignty underpins everything else. We can no longer ignore the risks of over-reliance on American and Chinese technology, or relying on hostile or unpredictable states for our critical infrastructure. More than half of central government organizations now run most of their systems on the cloud, and it all sits with just two companies, both American.

The government is the UK's largest buyer of technology and it almost never buys British. Since 2023, Palantir has won more than £420 million in public contracts across the NHS, the Met, the financial regulator, a city council and the Ministry of Defence, whose £240 million contract came without competition. It is also an approved supplier on six public sector buying frameworks with a combined value of more than £9.7 billion, a route into Whitehall, the NHS, the police and our local councils.

03:20:00 - 03:20:02

Speaker 180

Will my honourable friend give way?

03:20:02 - 03:20:03

I will give way.

03:20:03 - 03:20:16

Martin Wrigley

Does my honourable friend agree with me that it is a parody that Palantir is not on the strategic suppliers list that is maintained by the Cabinet Office?

03:20:16 - 03:24:38

Victoria Collins

Thank you. I thank my honourable friend for that. I think there is so much that highlights how this is the wrong approach from our government, and how not only do we need to look at our suppliers, but also the importance of backing British technology, which is why we also believe a digital sovereign strategy would change that, backing British innovation, reducing our dependencies and making our critical systems more secure. We need to look at each level of the tech stack and have a strategy that's right for the UK. I put that proposal to this House in June with new clause 13, which received cross-party support.

The government and the Conservatives voted it down. And sovereignty is not about doing this alone. It is about working globally while backing British, becoming and staying world leaders in technology. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is about securing high quality digital infrastructure that embeds us in global supply chains and makes us the most of our incredible talent and skills. That gives us international leverage, not isolation.

The government says sovereignty is covered across Whitehall, and last week's budget put another £60 million in the sovereign AI fund, but a venture fund and a patchwork of departmental reports are not a strategy. The new powers over high-risk vendors that the government react wants that let the government react once a risk supplier is already in our system, on clause 44, but a strategy needs to be proactive. It needs to build British capability so we never have to get to that point. And as even industry is calling for that strategy, I urge the government to bring forward its own amendments on digital sovereignty. Second, backing the review to review the amendment 107, which passed in the Lords.

A crossbench amendment, which Liberal Democrat peers also supported, requires a review within a year of royal assent, and every year after that, of whether this regime is working, which sector it covers, supply chains, the regulators and the AI Security Institute. Given the fast-paced change of cybersecurity, we urge the government to support this and look at expanding scope to cover local government, which holds our electoral rolls, our social records, and retail. A country that cannot feed itself is not resilient. We do welcome the government's commitment in the other place on reviewing whether all CNI sectors should be covered in this legislation and the NIS regulations. And finally, AI.

This week's NCSC review warns that AI-powered malware is highly likely to be used in ransomware attacks on our critical infrastructure by 2028. Yet, there is still no clarity on who oversees AI in our cyberdefences — a single regulator, the AI Security Institute, or the body that's exactly right for it. Our constituents and businesses need that clarity because when there's trust in the regulatory environment, there's investment in it. Madam Deputy Speaker, people need to trust the technology that is both pro-business and pro-society. The government needs a plan for who does what, and it needs to be sooner rather than later.

As we see the Europe call a leaders summit on AI, I will also use this opportunity to reiterate our calls on government to call a global AI summit and look towards an international AI safety agency headquartered in the UK and modelled on the International Atomic Energy Agency, and a global treaty to pause the development of superintelligence.

Finally, none of this works unless it is it can, none of this works unless those who are expected to deliver it can. SMEs make up 99.8% of UK businesses, and are often the most vulnerable link in the cyber supply chains. This week's discount on Cyber Essentials is welcome, and something the Liberal Democrats have called for, but it is time-limited, ends in March, and covers a certificate that must be renewed every year. Even the NCSC calls it a starting point. SMEs need real support from a cybersecurity support service when they are when they are hit, so that they have clear guidance.

At second reading, I compared this Bill to a house with stronger fences and a better alarm, but the back door has been left wide open. The past few days alone have shown us why closing that door matters. Madam Deputy Speaker, I therefore urge the Government to consider our amendments for the communities and councils who rely on critical infrastructure, for the businesses integrated into every supply chain, and for every family who expects the services that they rely on to be there when they need them, so we support this motion.

03:24:38 - 03:24:39

Alex Ballinger.

03:24:39 - 03:27:17

Alexander Robert Ballinger

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's a it's a pleasure to follow the Liberal Democrats on this topic, because they raised a number of important points, particularly the concern I think that people have about Palantir operating in the National Health Service, which is important. But I do support this carry-over motion, and the motion will allow Parliament to complete its work on legislation that is vital to our national security, our civil preparedness and our economic resilience. The motion will allow Parliament, okay, the motion will allow Parliament to complete this work, and having completed its Lords stages earlier this week, the Bill is now within reach of the statute book, and the need for its protections are increasingly urgent. Just yesterday, the chief executive of the National Cyber Security Centre warned us that the cyber threat has increased faster than our defensive capabilities.

And the threats are increasingly obvious. As the Liberal Democrat spokesperson mentioned, this week, we've seen nine countries attacked, with supermarkets turning fridges up to 50 degrees and ruining million pounds of food, on the back of attacks against French supermarkets only three weeks ago. And the National Cyber Security Centre's review describes Russian intelligence exploiting routers to target critical infrastructure, widespread disruption caused by Iranian proxies and the ever-expanding reach of Chinese cyber-espionage. These operations form a fast-evolving hybrid threat to our economy and the infrastructure on which our essential services depend. For those of us in the West Midlands, last year's attack on Jaguar Land Rover brought these threats right to our doorstep.

Production lines were ground to a halt, orders were disrupted and suppliers placed under crushing financial pressure. The attack's cost was estimated at £1.9 billion, and whilst the Government did respond quickly, providing a £1.5 billion loan to help sustain JLR and its supply chain, the best response and the best protection we can give businesses is prevention. JLR's ordeal underscores the need for this Bill and the changes it makes to the 2018 framework, requiring IT service providers, data centres and other critical bodies to meet rigorous cybersecurity standards, strengthening incident reporting and giving Government the power to respond to national security threats. For Halesowen and the West Midlands, these changes would boost the resilience of businesses, keeping them trading, keeping production lines moving and data centres and livelihoods secured. So, I support the motion so that we can complete this legislation promptly and put its protections into practice as soon as possible.

03:27:17 - 03:27:20

Speaker 182

Does the minister wish to respond? Minister Murray.

03:27:28 - 03:28:17

Speaker 176

when we actually have the debate beyond this carry-over motion, so I hope she'll support the carry-over motion so she can read this speech again. And the serious nature that my honorable friend, the member for Halesowen, also mentions JLR and other big, high-profile issues, but I think what it does is allow me to say very briefly, that a big message to all businesses in the country that cybersecurity is also their responsibility. It should be in every boardroom at the top of every agenda to make sure they're not having these incidents. Prevention is better than cure, as my honorable friend said from Halesowen. The National Cyber Security Centre does have all the free tools available. I'd encourage every single business, micro, small, medium, and large to use those tools to make sure they're as secure as they possibly can. Of course, we can't stop all cyber attacks being successful, but we can minimize the risk as much as possible and make sure that's everyone's responsibility. Now, I look forward

03:28:17 - 03:28:20

Speaker 186

Will you take an intervention? I'm happy to give way.

03:28:20 - 03:28:40

David Chadwick

I thank him for giving way. During the evidence collection process, lots of experts from the cybersecurity sector called for board accountability to be reintroduced back into the bill, as it is in the European Union's similar legislation. Can he say Can he give us his thoughts on why that hasn't been included?

03:28:40 - 03:28:41

Minister Murray.

03:28:41 - 03:28:57

Speaker 176

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think the Lib Dem spokesperson mentioned the same European Union regulations. What we need to do is what's in the best interests of businesses in the United Kingdom. The message is pretty clear that all businesses must have this at the top of their agenda. It should be in every boardroom, and we keep encouraging them to do so. And I'm happy to give way to my honorable friend.

03:28:57 - 03:28:59

Speaker 183

Alexis Fernandes.

03:28:59 - 03:29:18

Christopher John Vince

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. You missed out on a very long speech. You're very lucky. I just wonder if the minister could touch on very briefly on what liability there will be for frontier model providers, such as Open AI, who breach infrastructure, who breach their duties. I'm thinking of, for example, the Hugging Face incident in July 2026.

03:29:18 - 03:29:19

Minister Murray.

03:29:19 - 03:29:54

Speaker 176

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend from, we all know it's Harlow, because I'm surprised he didn't he didn't mention it in his con- He didn't mention it in his contribution, so I thought I'd better put that on the record. Otherwise, it'd be it'll be struck out. But, he makes a good point, but actually, you can also see that AI provides a really good solution to this particular problem, because if the PHP incidents that we had in the last few weeks were identified as having holes in that particular system, and then those holes were patched and plugged. So, whilst AI is a big problem in this cybersecurity issue, it's also a big part of the solution, and that's what this bill is here to do. It's to make us better have better cybersecurity and better resilience across all our economy.

03:29:54 - 03:30:20

Speaker 155

Fantastic. The question is as on the order papers, may that period say aye. Aye. Contrarily no. The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. I will allow the front benches a moment or two to shuffle over. Petition, Ben Goldsborough.

03:30:20 - 03:31:05

Ben Goldsborough

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. For many years, residents in Newton Flotman have lived with unsafe junctions on the A140. Five awkward junctions in a 500-yard stretch of the A140 are causing chaos, confusion, and are a serious risk to safety. Over 500 residents who have signed this petition believe road improvements are urgently needed to protect motorists and pedestrians in Newton Flotman. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urge the government to encourage Norfolk County Council to commit to upgrading the junctions on the A140 with Flordon Road, Short Street, Old Street, and Cargate Lane, and to improve safety for road users.

03:31:05 - 03:31:14

Speaker 184

Petition, safety at A140 junctions. Petition, Valerie Vaz.

03:31:14 - 03:32:20

Valerie Vaz

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This petition is presented on behalf of the residents of Walsall and the UK to raise the issue of the proposed secondary school on Reedswood Park, an important community space and former golf course.

The development would result in the irreversible loss of valuable green space and natural habitats, while increasing the existing pressure on the surrounding infrastructure, traffic congestion, limited parking capacity and road safety. If a new secondary school is required, and the data suggests it is not, alternative sites may be available, including the former Sneed school site. There were 2,063 signatories to an online petition, and the petitioners are therefore calling on the government to ensure that in considering proposals for a new secondary school, full weight is given to the environmental, transport and community impacts of development at Read's Wood Park, and to consider whether alternative sites may provide a more appropriate location.

03:32:20 - 03:32:23

Speaker 192

Petition: Read's Wood Park.

03:32:23 - 03:32:26

Speaker 196

Thank you very much.

03:32:26 - 03:32:29

Speaker 194

Petition: Zarah Sultana.

03:32:29 - 03:33:51

Zarah Sultana

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to present a petition on behalf of residents of Coventry South regarding Coventry City Council's contract with Palantir. More than 3,900 people have signed a related online petition. In September 2025, Coventry City Council awarded Palantir a contract worth half a million pounds to provide AI-related services in children's services. This contract was renewed in February 2026 at the cost of 750,000, a 50% increase, bringing the total to 1.25 million.

There are serious concerns about Palantir's involvement in military and immigration operations, including providing surveillance infrastructure to the Israeli government, which is committing genocide in Palestine, as well as the handling of sensitive personal data and the growing privatisation of our public services. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to call on Coventry City Council to terminate its contract with Palantir, to consult residents and trade unions, and to ensure transparency, accountability and democratic public control over the use of data in our public services, and the petitioners remain, etc.

03:33:51 - 03:33:59

Speaker 191

Petition: Coventry City Council contract with Palantir Technologies.

03:33:59 - 03:34:03

Speaker 185

I beg to move that this now House do now adjourn.

03:34:03 - 03:34:14

Speaker 155

The question is that this House do now adjourn, and we have Rachel Blake on impact of new strategic licensing regulations on London. Rachel Blake.

03:34:14 - 03:37:05

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful for the opportunity to raise this matter this afternoon, and I thank the Speaker's Office for granting this debate. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sure I'm not the only member of Parliament to have had a late night. I'm sure I'm not the only member of Parliament to have spent time in Bar Italia as a young person, to enjoy the wonderful culture of central London, whether or not that's at the Royal Albert Hall, at the Theatre Royal Haymarket, at the Soho Theatre. The West End's history and culture is synonymous with our openness, creativity and diversity that define modern London.

But I am the only member of Parliament to represent the communities in the Cities of London and Westminster. Few places have contributed more to our cultural life, and few places demonstrate more clearly the importance of striking the right balance between supporting a thriving nighttime economy and making sure that residential communities can also thrive.

I represent some of the most vibrant, economically critical and culturally significant communities in the country, from the City of London to Pimlico, from Covent Garden to Marylebone and from Fitzrovia to Soho. These are the places that help power London's economy and define our global reputation. And they're also places where people live, where people enjoy their own lives and where people bring up families. They enjoy their homes and the internationally renowned nightlife that exists alongside them. Many of them raise families there.

They sleep there and they expect to have a meaningful say over decisions that affect their neighborhoods and their quality of life. That balance between a thriving city and a livable city is at the heart of any licensing policy, and it's why these regulations matter. Let's just be really clear at the outset of this debate. I support devolution. I support economic growth and I support thriving communities.

And I support the principle that genuinely strategic issues may require a strategic voice. I also recognize that the government's final regulations that they published a few weeks ago are narrower and more objective than many feared they might be. The government has rightly moved away from the broader and more subjective approach originally proposed. Concepts such as economic importance, reputation importance and strategic geography have not been adopted. Instead, the regulations rely on statutory criteria based on venue size, operating hours and licensing classifications.

03:37:05 - 03:37:07

Speaker 187

Will the honorable member give way on that point?

03:37:07 - 03:37:08

I'll give way.

03:37:08 - 03:37:50

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way, and I congratulate her on securing this debate tonight on a very important, this afternoon indeed, on a very important issue. Would she also though welcome the fact that the mayor of London will still need to take into account the four strategic licensing objectives in coming to any decision? And those are protecting public safety, protecting children and young people, looking after, preventing rather, public nuisance and crime. And does she also note that there is a facility for people to then further appeal the mayor of London's decision, if at that point, they don't agree with it?

03:37:50 - 03:37:52

Speaker 189

Rachel Blake.

03:37:52 - 03:38:54

Rachel Blake

I thank my honorable friend for her intervention. I think she makes a really powerful point about the overriding significance of the four licensing objectives. Public safety, preventing crime are critical objectives, and they're ones that mean an awful lot to my constituents. These criteria provide greater certainty for residents, businesses and local authorities alike. However, Parliament should still ask whether the thresholds now adopted reflect the expectations created during the passage of parent legislation.

During the passage of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, ministers repeatedly described these powers as exceptional, carefully constrained, and a measure of last resort. The House of Lords approved the principle before seeing the detailed definition. Parliament has now seen both the regulations and the accompanying guidance. It's therefore reasonable now to ask whether the practical operation of these powers will remain consistent with those assurances.

03:38:54 - 03:38:55

Would she give way on that point?

03:38:55 - 03:38:57

Speaker 188

I will give way on that point.

03:38:57 - 03:39:44

Edward Joseph Powell

I thank my honorable friend for giving way, and also congratulate her on securing this in important debate. And she's making a very good point about how the criteria have been drawn. The Kensington Society in Kensington and Bayswater have estimated that 45 to 50% of venues that currently have a license between would be between D and E, which is what is specified in the secondary legislation.

so they obviously have concerns that volume could generate a whole set of kind of call-ins for things that wouldn't really be considered strategic by the, by any sort of common understanding. So, I wonder whether she's got a similar concern about the volume, particularly for that licensing band in part A of the SI.

03:39:44 - 03:48:46

Rachel Blake

I, I thank my honourable friend and he makes a very good point about the number of premises that will be affected in central London by the statutory instrument as it was laid down. He makes a really important point that such a large proportion will be open to this calling power, and he raises a really important question about whether or not the City Hall is expecting to be able to call in that many, and indeed whether or not they would want to, and whether or not that does fit in with what would, most people would consider a strategic intervention. I think that, and I will come on further to some questions that I would like to ask the Minister about how we might closely define a strategic intervention and monitor what a strategic calling power might look like. We do have to ask whether the practical operation of these powers will remain consistent with the expectations during the course of the bill through Parliament.

So, the concern today is not whether strategic powers should exist. There are many places across London that are of strategic significance to us, our future as a successful world city, and Parliament has already settled that question and I recognize that. The concern today is whether strategic powers will remain genuinely strategic. For communities, such as Soho, where hospitality, culture and late-night activity are an integral part of the area's character, a significant number of applications may potentially fall within the category of strategic importance. And this really matters in Westminster and in the City of London.

The City of Westminster contains around 4,000 licensed premises, with nearly half located in the West End and in St James's ward. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I have some figures that I think are going to be really interesting for everyone here in the House. I know everybody will be really pleased to hear, and interested to hear, that a thousand premises are open until 11:00 p.m.; that 1,692 premises are open until midnight; 478 are open until 1:00 a.m.;

one, sorry Madam Deputy Speaker, I've been, I've slightly, I've used slightly the wrong words, are licensed, are licensed, let me correct myself, 1,000 premises are licensed up to 11:00 p.m.; 1,692 premises up to midnight;

478 premises up to 1:00 a.m.; 131 to 2:00 a.m.; 221 to 3:00 a.m.; 22 premises open to 4:00 a.m.; 19 to 5:00 a.m.; and this is really niche,

24 premises are open until 6:00 a.m., so they're more like the 24-hour premises. And just I think it's really important for everybody to acknowledge the number of premises that are open to the later hours, making sure that we are a truly global world city that is welcoming to people who want to be entertained through the night. But of course, that concentration of licensed activity is unparalleled anywhere else in the country, and therefore it means that even small shifts in licensing policy can have significant consequences not only for residents and local businesses, but for London's wider cultural and night-time economy. That is precisely why Parliament must be confident that powers described as strategic remain genuinely strategic in practice.

Residents therefore have a reasonable question: if large numbers of applications, as my honourable friend for Kensington and Bayswater has drawn attention to, are potentially eligible, where is the line between a strategic exception and a routine intervention? And that leads to perhaps the most important point,

being eligible for a call-in is not the same thing as being called in. The regulations determine which applications may be considered by the Mayor. They do not require the Mayor to intervene. The revised section 182 guidance now provides greater clarity about the operation of the new regime. It establishes a London-wide framework, confirms the Mayor's strategic role, and explains how call-in powers are intended to operate.

But the publication of guidance does not in itself answer the practical questions that matter most to residents and local authorities. How many applications does the Government expect to qualify each year? How many call-ins does the Mayor expect to make? How many venues across London are likely to fall within scope? On what basis will potentially eligible applications be selected for intervention?

What evidence informed the thresholds that have been chosen? Those questions remain important because the impact of the regime will depend not on what may be called in, but what, but on what is called in. The City of London Corporation has also raised concerns about the practical in- implications of the new arrangements and about the scale of applications that could potentially fall within scope. And local authorities across London continue to ask many of the same questions as residents. When will these powers be used?

What criteria will guide the decision to call in? How will strategic considerations be balanced against local evidence? These are reasonable questions, and I believe they deserve answers. Madam Deputy Speaker, one of the strongest concerns I hear from residents is about local democratic control. Throughout the passage of the parent legislation, Ministers rightly spoke about neighborhood voice, community empowerment, and maintaining a strong democratic basis for decision-making.

The revised guidance itself emphasizes the importance of community involvement in licensing decisions and the opportunities for local residents to have their say. Yet many residents still ask the simple question: if a resident speaks at a local licensing hearing, presents evidence on crime, noise, anti-social behavior, dispersal and residential amenity, what democratic links exist between that participation and subsequent determination by City Hall? Residents have every right to expect a meaningful voice in licensing decisions that affect where they live. Licensing decisions often depend on highly local evidence about noise, crime patterns, dispersal routes, and residential amenity.

Anyone who has attended a licensing hearing, as I'm sure many of us have here this afternoon, know that these cases frequently turn on detailed, local knowledge of a particular building, street, or neighborhood. And that local knowledge matters. Westminster's experience demonstrates this clearly. Soho's success depends on getting the balance right between supporting culture, hospitality, and economic activity while also protecting the people for whom Soho is home. So I ask the Minister today: what additional rights will residents have where an application is called in?

How will residents be able to make representations directly in a mayored determination? What weight will be given to evidence heard by local licensing committees? How will borough licensing committees remain primary decision-makers rather than advisory bodies? How will the Government assess whether the new arrangements are strengthening rather than weakening community empowerment? My purpose here is not to argue against strategic objectives, nor to challenge the important role of our night life in London in terms of our economic growth, nor to challenge these powers in principle.

My focus is on safeguards, transparency, accountability, and that's why I will continue to press for five practical measures. First, clear public guidance from the Mayor on the circumstances in which call-in powers will be exercised and what factors will inform those decisions. Second, annual transparency reporting rather than waiting 2 years for the first statutory review.

Third, publication of every call-in decision with full reasons. Fourth, meaningful opportunities for resident participation in every mayoral determination. And finally, publication of annual data, broken down by local authority area, showing how many applications became eligible, how many were called in, and which criteria triggered the intervention. If these powers are genuinely intended to be used sparingly, there should be no objection to that degree of transparency. London's success depends on maintaining the balance between growth and community.

Soho's success depends on maintaining the balance between being a world-famous destination and a place people proudly call home. Residents deserve the confidence that local voices will continue to matter. Parliament deserves confidence that powers described as exceptional will remain exceptional. And we all deserve confidence that implementation will match the assurances that ministers gave when these powers were first proposed. It's my responsibility, as the Member of Parliament for the Cities of London and Westminster, to stand up for centuries-old communities who have lived side by side with a thriving nightlife.

I'm absolutely determined that they will do so into the future, and I look forward to what the minister has to say this afternoon. Hear.

03:48:46 - 03:52:46

Jim McMahon

Minister McMahon. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful to my honorable friend the Member for the Cities of London and Westminster for securing this important debate, and I should also say for the significant effort that she has put in to representing her constituents on this matter over quite a long period of time. I know how much it matters to her and to her constituents, and hopefully I'll address the points that she's made through the course of the speech here, but I know this will not be our final conversation on this, and nor should it be, either. I think these matters of how we balance these competing interests that kind of recognize that London, of course, is a global city and it has that draw, but it's also where people live and where people are part of a community, and I know that's the balance that she herself is trying to strike, too.

The new strategic licensing arrangements came into force yesterday. They give the Mayor a strategic role in licensing across the capital, including a duty to publish a London-wide policy and a power to call in certain applications of potential strategic importance. Before addressing their impact, it's important to explain the problem these reforms are intended to solve. London's hospitality, cultural, and nighttime economy is central to the capital's success and its appeal as a global city, but licensing decisions can have implications extending beyond a single premises or borough, affecting London's wider economy, cultural offer, and international reputation.

Individual boroughs are rightly focused on their local circumstances. These reforms are intended to complement that local expertise with a strategic role for the Mayor where an application may be significant to London as a whole. The aim is not to set local and London-wide interests against each other, but rather for them to complement each other. It's to support a licensing system capable of balancing them fairly, while continuing to protect residents and uphold the licensing objectives. So let me start with residents and the concerns my honorable friend has rightly raised on their behalf.

I want to be clear that these protections are at the heart of the licensing system, and they remain unchanged. The four statutory licensing objectives continue to apply, and those are the prevention of crime and disorder, public safety, the prevention of public nuisance, and the protection of children from harm. Those protections apply equally where the Mayor intervenes. Any application called in will still be determined in accordance with the Licensing Act 2003 and with regard to the importance of promoting those objectives, while residents and other interested parties will retain their existing ability to make representations on individual applications. Residents also have the opportunity to respond to the Mayor's consultation on his new strategic licensing policy, which will set out the wider framework for his strategic licensing role.

Alongside those opportunities to make their voices heard, new arrangements include specific transparency requirements around the Mayor's new strategic role. Advertising requirements will ensure that residents are informed when an application is identified as a potentially strategically important application, and, if the Mayor does intervene, on the decisions that are taken.

There are also clear lines of accountability. Mayoral directions remain subject to the existing rights of appeal, and where a direction is appealed, the mayor is legally responsible for defending it. Overall, residents will retain protections at the heart of the licensing system with transparency and clear accountability built into the mayor's new strategic role. Turning to London's licensing authorities, I do recognise concerns about what the mayor's new role could mean for local decision making as well as additional responsibilities it will place on licensing teams. I should reiterate that local licensing authorities will remain the default decision makers.

They'll continue to receive applications, to consider representations, to hold hearings where necessary, and to determine applications in the first instance. The mayor's new role does not replace those core functions. It provides an additional strategic role for applications that meet the relevant criteria, with calling decisions remaining discretionary. The new

03:52:46 - 03:52:47

Would the minister give way?

03:52:47 - 03:52:49

Speaker 203

Of course.

03:52:49 - 03:53:06

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the minister for giving way, and he makes the point about supporting local authorities in London. Would he also commit to ensuring local authorities are included in the two-year review of this, and would he also look at the potential new burdens funding that might be required for local authorities?

03:53:06 - 03:53:08

Speaker 204

Minister McMahon.

03:53:08 - 03:54:11

Jim McMahon

I'm going to just come on to the new burdens funding shortly, and also I'll mention in a short while the review periods that are built in, and maybe an approach to that in the way that she speaks about. The new arrangements will, however, require some additional information sharing between the GLA. Those requirements are largely based on information authorities already collect or have access to through the normal licensing process. Even so, we recognise that meeting those requirements may come with additional costs. The government will, therefore, conduct a full new burdens assessment to ensure local licensing authorities are appropriately reimbursed for new costs resulting from these powers.

And we recognise that the new system will place demands on the GLA, too. It's been preparing for its new responsibilities in recruit in addition to recruit additional resources to support the operation of the new regime. Our aim is simple, to keep boroughs at the heart of decision making on licensing, while making sure that both they and the GLA are equipped to make sure the new system works effectively.

03:54:11 - 03:54:13

Speaker 205

Will my honourable friend give way?

03:54:14 - 03:54:53

Rachel Blake

Could I ask the minister to comment on the part of the process where the Greater London Authority is making the decision to call in applications, because, as we've discussed in our opening remarks, we know that there's a quite a broad pool of premises which would be eligible, and I believe that my residents have a concern about how that decision to call in will be made and the transparency around that decision, because they'll be concerned that there will be some types of premises or premises operating in particular areas that might be seeking to get that call-in, and we're really seeking some transparency on that.

03:54:53 - 03:54:54

Minister McMahon.

03:54:54 - 03:58:16

Jim McMahon

So I'll talk through the process shortly and I'll also cover just what the criteria means in terms of potential strategic important venues in the way that she talks about. I do need to reiterate, though, that keeping boroughs at the heart of licensing decisions is important to us, but so, too, is ensuring the system supports London's wider growth. And that brings me to businesses and the central purpose behind these reforms, better supporting London's hospitality and the nighttime economy.

A thriving hospitality sector is fundamental to London's success as a global city. We want a licensing system that gives responsible operators greater confidence to invest, to adapt and to grow. Giving businesses that confidence means ensuring new processes do not create unnecessary delay or uncertainty. And that's why the regulations establish clear statutory deadlines and procedures. If I could come on to the point made by the honourable member just a while ago that the call-in power itself is designed to support a more enabling approach to licensing, rather than giving the means for the mayor to block or to further restrict applications.

An application granted as applied for cannot be called in. Where a mayor intervenes, any conditions he imposes cannot, in his opinion, be more restrictive than those imposed by the licensing authority. And he can only direct that an application be rejected where the authority has itself rejected it. And so, in terms of the protections and safeguards, we believe that gets the right strikes the right balance. These safeguards are intended to ensure that the new strategic role supports growth without creating unnecessary delay or uncertainty for businesses, while maintaining important local protections for residents and local community.

On the point around potential strategic important sites to Greater London, we have, as has been said in the debate, built in a requirement for the mayor's call-in power to be reviewed after two years, and then at least every five years thereafter. I'm happy to take away the particular point about the role of local authorities in that review process, and confirm in writing the position on there. But I also think it's important to say, and I mean this has been if I can kind of take a summary of almost one of the bigger concerns is that, because the scope of premises can feel quite wide, there is a concern that this does create a completely double-run system on top of the local licensing authority. And just to kind of set our own expectations as a Government in supporting this proposal and the new licensing regime, it is not our expectation that all of those premises in scope will be called in by the mayor for a strategic decision at all. In fact, it's our expectation that most of them will go on as normal.

And for them to be called in by the mayor, they would have to meet at least one of the criteria set out in law. So, we believe on balance, it gets the right balance in terms of protecting local residents and communities, but also recognising that in many ways London is unique in its nighttime economy, and the way that actually many people come to London of course to work and to shop, but also to experience the nighttime economy in terms of our theatres, our bars, and our restaurants, and our night clubs as well. And so nowhere is the need to get the right the balance right clearer than in the Yeah, I'll take an intervention, yeah.

03:58:16 - 03:58:54

Edward Joseph Powell

I thank the minister for the important clarification he's made about the Government's intention. Would he also accept that the nature of London means that between inner and outer London you do have a big difference between rateable values? And one of the concerns of inner London MPs, like myself and the honourable member who secured this debate, is that almost by definition, we'll ha- we'll end up with more in the potential call-in zone compared to outer London. And so having that clarification for inner London is particularly important.

03:58:54 - 04:00:27

Jim McMahon

I think we will need to see how that works in practice, because, you know, just responding from my perspective, I think that could work both ways. You know, recognising that the imbalance, if you like, in rateable value might be lower in outer London than in inner London, I think that does reflect the economic if you like, benefit that premises in the inner London area brings, which is why the business rate bill ends up being higher.

And so, I think it would be reasonable for the Mayor to say, well because of that, it clearly has a more important role to play than an outer borough premises of the same nature that might look on the outside the same. They actually can provide quite a different role economically in terms of the contribution to the wider, you know, nighttime economy. So, I think that can probably work both ways. And recognizing all the concerns that have been made, I do believe that this gets the right balance. It recognizes London as a global city with that wider consideration, whilst balancing the need to of course make sure that our local licensing authorities are empowered and their status is respected.

And I think that we've set out just how we do that. Indeed, the extraordinary concentration of restaurants and theatres and music venues and nightlife is part of what make these areas so attractive places, not just to visit, but to live as well. And that's why we should not treat the interests of residents of the hospitality sector as inherently opposed. These reforms are intended to balance them fairly, supporting responsible businesses and London's wider growth, while preserving the important role of boroughs and their accountability to local communities.

04:00:27 - 04:00:29

Speaker 206

Will he give way just briefly?

04:00:29 - 04:00:30

Just briefly.

04:00:30 - 04:01:08

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wanted to make sure that the Minister was aware that some of the organizations that are that residents come together to represent their communities really celebrate the nightlife in their neighborhoods and, in fact, have come together to support the re- re-establishment of particular, very celebrated nightlife venues, including G-A-Y in Soho. And I wanted to make sure that it was a matter of public record that they that many residents are very clear about their passion for a lively nightlife as well, making sure that's balanced with the residential character of an area, too.

04:01:08 - 04:01:10

Speaker 207

Minister.

04:01:10 - 04:02:31

Jim McMahon

I, and I think in the way that she has set out, I think she reinforces as to why this is important, because this isn't just about putting residents in one basket and visitors visiting the city from outside in another. Everybody benefits from a place that is thriving, that is active, where people feel welcome and people feel that there is something for everyone, and that's the balance that we're trying to strike here. And I know speaking to all the local MPs in that area who made representations, that is very much the balance that they are trying to strike, too. And so, I absolutely commit that we will continue our communication through this, that I'm keen to understand how this works in practice and to hear from local experiences. And I know that they'll continue to make the case.

Now, the regulations require the Secretary of State to review how these new arrangements are working in practice and to publish a report within 2 years of commencement. Further reviews, as I said earlier on, will then be published at least every 5 years thereafter. And so, it's not the case of introducing these arrangements and simply leaving them in place. Their impact will be kept under review, allowing us to assess how the system is working in practice for London businesses, for licensing authorities, and for residents alike. And that is the balance we're trying to strike.

So, can I thank again my honorable friend for securing this important debate and for her continued work on supporting local residents?

04:02:31 - 04:02:39

Speaker 208

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order. Order.